id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15796v1 | Rethinking Entity-level Unlearning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T09:40:07 | 2024-06-22T09:40:07 | Weitao Ma, Xiaocheng Feng, Weihong Zhong, Lei Huang, Yangfan Ye, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language model unlearning has gained increasing attention due to its
potential to mitigate security and privacy concerns. Current research
predominantly focuses on Instance-level unlearning, specifically aiming at
forgetting predefined instances of sensitive content. However, a notable gap
still exists in exploring the deletion of complete entity-related information,
which is crucial in many real-world scenarios, such as copyright protection. To
this end, we propose a novel task of Entity-level unlearning, where the
entity-related knowledge within the target model is supposed to be entirely
erased. Given the challenge of practically accessing all entity-related
knowledge within a model, we begin by simulating entity-level unlearning
scenarios through fine-tuning models to introduce pseudo entities. Following
this, we develop baseline methods inspired by trending unlearning techniques
and conduct a detailed comparison of their effectiveness in this task.
Extensive experiments reveal that current unlearning algorithms struggle to
achieve effective entity-level unlearning. Additionally, our analyses further
indicate that entity-related knowledge injected through fine-tuning is more
susceptible than original entities from pre-training during unlearning,
highlighting the necessity for more thorough pseudo-entity injection methods to
make them closer to pre-trained knowledge. | [
-0.4259278178215027,
-0.8997606635093689,
0.47650328278541565,
-0.5415126085281372,
-0.47098657488822937,
0.20760884881019592,
-0.4838908612728119,
-0.5143863558769226,
-0.2598201036453247,
0.6832869648933411,
-0.48276829719543457,
-0.5930421948432922,
-0.3138387203216553,
-0.343965619802475,
-0.6626883149147034,
1.2077412605285645,
0.06584655493497849,
-0.17453546822071075,
-0.2983720898628235,
0.07259758561849594,
-0.4048960208892822,
-0.27006033062934875,
-0.8052560687065125,
-0.3550542891025543,
0.582546055316925,
0.58447265625,
0.2902863919734955,
0.7216576933860779,
-0.03737391158938408,
0.2643309533596039,
-0.40927812457084656,
0.06781449168920517,
-0.8783408999443054,
0.05562780052423477,
-0.471262127161026,
-0.5600515604019165,
-0.28798216581344604,
-0.18255120515823364,
0.738889217376709,
0.9843489527702332,
-0.5617251992225647,
0.2637844979763031,
0.2708529829978943,
0.5134711861610413,
-0.8556973338127136,
0.13632243871688843,
-1.0308542251586914,
-0.030803004279732704,
-0.17775744199752808,
-0.039535075426101685,
-0.46892741322517395,
0.2022237777709961,
0.21978387236595154,
-0.8560729026794434,
0.4841836988925934,
0.11031658947467804,
0.9672595858573914,
0.12856577336788177,
-0.25558340549468994,
-0.14066804945468903,
-0.9956728219985962,
0.8075928092002869,
-0.6501660943031311,
0.5121874213218689,
0.3510093688964844,
-0.21381983160972595,
-0.13650260865688324,
-0.7177253365516663,
-0.5406404733657837,
0.09167568385601044,
0.22208888828754425,
-0.09520837664604187,
-0.41312089562416077,
0.044193610548973083,
0.356038361787796,
0.38407251238822937,
-0.44644564390182495,
0.590630054473877,
-0.324862539768219,
-0.002994304057210684,
0.27554404735565186,
-0.2211548537015915,
0.43152618408203125,
0.03744722902774811,
-0.253047913312912,
0.2275802344083786,
-1.2608850002288818,
-0.10283856093883514,
0.48009762167930603,
0.24433718621730804,
0.3218112885951996,
0.41136056184768677,
-0.14752915501594543,
0.2221304029226303,
0.12700068950653076,
0.050013355910778046,
0.2986626923084259,
0.08844584226608276,
-0.21559932827949524,
0.06468042731285095,
0.5740686655044556,
0.16173705458641052,
0.5579575896263123,
-0.4843865931034088,
-0.3864656388759613,
-0.3952641785144806,
0.38455700874328613,
-0.8007028102874756,
-0.3532887399196625,
0.16184043884277344,
-0.5142994523048401,
-0.13853126764297485,
-0.1949860155582428,
-0.7649313807487488,
-0.28760653734207153,
-0.6202758550643921,
0.4920218884944916,
-0.6334631443023682,
-0.6279877424240112,
-0.007037147413939238,
0.22764407098293304,
-0.028419921174645424,
0.27287545800209045,
-0.8063505291938782,
0.06221817806363106,
0.7670897245407104,
0.5363074541091919,
0.05603489652276039,
-0.46427634358406067,
-0.2907293736934662,
0.3572668135166168,
-0.2262321263551712,
0.5053420066833496,
-0.6021804809570312,
-0.4407110810279846,
0.012939698994159698,
0.06006748229265213,
0.11250223219394684,
-0.7075764536857605,
0.1375066190958023,
-0.851300060749054,
0.12951692938804626,
-0.32430222630500793,
-1.0359129905700684,
-0.1839245855808258,
-0.047475382685661316,
-0.4676288366317749,
0.6489473581314087,
-0.1400013118982315,
-0.7269968390464783,
0.6805914044380188,
-0.32582440972328186,
-0.4488530457019806,
0.07704568654298782,
-0.11183280497789383,
-0.8131575584411621,
0.19309648871421814,
0.035809725522994995,
0.48681262135505676,
-0.2682490646839142,
0.3760761320590973,
-0.4467601478099823,
-0.45139750838279724,
-0.16522827744483948,
-0.3380569517612457,
0.775083601474762,
0.29902663826942444,
-0.435059517621994,
-0.09082076698541641,
-0.8097865581512451,
-0.12116973102092743,
0.3031954765319824,
0.01135643757879734,
-0.8245331645011902,
-0.06639958918094635,
-0.35102683305740356,
0.008442571386694908,
0.22597408294677734,
-0.5919501185417175,
0.15137828886508942,
-0.4652349054813385,
0.5261574983596802,
0.800029993057251,
0.3936714828014374,
0.9400749802589417,
-0.07708628475666046,
0.18671365082263947,
0.4038131833076477,
0.042784228920936584,
-0.33648601174354553,
-0.10801176726818085,
-0.6616894006729126,
-0.28080669045448303,
0.48806455731391907,
0.3792782127857208,
-0.8289386630058289,
0.3443896174430847,
-0.23920613527297974,
-0.562028169631958,
-0.43304720520973206,
0.4267255961894989,
0.7407240867614746,
0.681976318359375,
0.5163441300392151,
-0.17282027006149292,
-0.3015308380126953,
-0.7568425536155701,
-0.3643306493759155,
-0.22315038740634918,
-0.11574915051460266,
-0.02282755821943283,
0.5989173650741577,
-0.10083617269992828,
0.6588327288627625,
-0.5365610718727112,
-0.40643343329429626,
-0.11977985501289368,
0.03266805037856102,
-0.20881180465221405,
0.7584085464477539,
0.34634020924568176,
-0.7466163039207458,
-0.012382855638861656,
-0.1915377676486969,
-0.841765284538269,
0.3699283003807068,
-0.08461400866508484,
0.037737783044576645,
0.16802220046520233,
0.7303549647331238,
-0.7302008867263794,
0.3700060546398163,
-0.029159385710954666,
0.102565236389637,
0.4267510175704956,
-0.4981246888637543,
-0.1397925168275833,
-1.1421775817871094,
0.030174976214766502,
-0.030881013721227646,
0.02103429287672043,
-0.7765664458274841,
0.2538776397705078,
0.25330662727355957,
-0.14002931118011475,
-0.5254333019256592,
0.33604127168655396,
-0.9604893326759338,
0.04102971777319908,
-0.24889513850212097,
-0.0009616079041734338,
-0.11804813146591187,
0.5478008389472961,
-0.0376749150454998,
0.6464482545852661,
0.6519306898117065,
-0.6901009678840637,
-0.0635906234383583,
0.07396586984395981,
-0.5536267161369324,
0.3585307002067566,
-0.4675251543521881,
0.23023158311843872,
-0.5283339619636536,
0.10177969187498093,
-0.5652939677238464,
0.13775195181369781,
-0.030005136504769325,
-0.10006765276193619,
0.6875178217887878,
-0.47437572479248047,
-0.5897634625434875,
-0.04029013216495514,
-0.05619242042303085,
0.6286514401435852,
0.6322284936904907,
-0.5034601092338562,
0.4668201208114624,
0.6477962732315063,
-0.009707686491310596,
-0.7838143706321716,
-0.4226212203502655,
0.028673183172941208,
-0.5294196009635925,
-0.20312067866325378,
0.3959296941757202,
0.18693743646144867,
-0.06518179923295975,
0.2566278576850891,
-0.2768575847148895,
-0.1489744335412979,
0.22584597766399384,
0.3751504421234131,
0.08286506682634354,
-0.1453137844800949,
0.27760761976242065,
0.24773715436458588,
-0.06812490522861481,
0.03177338466048241,
-0.6217081546783447,
0.48775649070739746,
0.0977393239736557,
-0.4939599931240082,
-0.33063745498657227,
0.2733209729194641,
0.3191603422164917,
-0.6124427318572998,
1.066619873046875,
0.45392921566963196,
-0.8863265514373779,
-0.5229097604751587,
-0.4776672124862671,
-0.1788824200630188,
-0.4290190637111664,
0.43608370423316956,
-0.461302787065506,
-0.9258509278297424,
0.6272358298301697,
-0.2385496199131012,
0.44396525621414185,
0.16677632927894592,
0.4693886339664459,
-0.11286052316427231,
0.7016763687133789,
0.8061670064926147,
-0.08543071150779724,
0.6762487292289734,
-0.5488133430480957,
0.5820946097373962,
-0.7513716816902161,
-0.40892258286476135,
-0.4530704915523529,
-0.12669751048088074,
-0.5118744969367981,
-0.030765771865844727,
-0.1758916676044464,
0.5928432941436768,
-0.2958066165447235,
0.5288702845573425,
-0.09551417082548141,
0.8515716195106506,
0.5720049738883972,
0.30922895669937134,
0.43102288246154785,
0.08480820059776306,
0.000233041777391918,
0.14822129905223846,
-0.5018333792686462,
-0.39312970638275146,
1.2621817588806152,
0.24105657637119293,
0.5339646339416504,
0.06350112706422806,
1.0466063022613525,
0.012756920419633389,
0.12858520448207855,
-0.4951408803462982,
0.41620689630508423,
-0.210626482963562,
-0.5773909687995911,
-0.545545756816864,
-0.6464320421218872,
-1.0630440711975098,
-0.0032777939923107624,
-0.20339635014533997,
-0.922670841217041,
0.28221964836120605,
0.5216398239135742,
-0.40721622109413147,
0.8968250751495361,
-0.775029718875885,
0.9804359078407288,
0.29064831137657166,
-0.3303719460964203,
-0.24984852969646454,
-0.4368523359298706,
0.3394409418106079,
-0.5070416331291199,
0.36108240485191345,
-0.005241922102868557,
0.1451280564069748,
0.5551732778549194,
-0.3109372556209564,
0.815809428691864,
-0.37655895948410034,
-0.5380339622497559,
0.18170784413814545,
0.3403402864933014,
0.5035768151283264,
0.22975139319896698,
0.16857226192951202,
0.2699325382709503,
-0.0327937938272953,
-0.47620218992233276,
-0.42435240745544434,
0.8058251738548279,
-0.6528510451316833,
-0.5584715604782104,
0.03904517740011215,
-0.2674119174480438,
-0.26897963881492615,
0.4838269352912903,
0.5325709581375122,
0.3267223834991455,
-0.35628750920295715,
0.01718083582818508,
1.229958176612854,
-0.3653780519962311,
0.43988826870918274,
0.6979765892028809,
-0.05296734720468521,
0.18898914754390717,
1.3059805631637573,
0.2368934154510498,
0.20972871780395508,
0.5535297393798828,
-0.3131973445415497,
-0.28578317165374756,
-0.866782009601593,
-0.40705573558807373,
0.4057384431362152,
-0.5646798014640808,
-0.18532846868038177,
-0.6304973363876343,
-0.006225339602679014,
-0.21948058903217316,
0.1878991574048996,
-0.5877940654754639,
-0.05724092200398445,
-0.5859159827232361,
-0.1528523862361908,
-0.13403084874153137,
0.5633721351623535,
0.07364590466022491,
0.21242442727088928,
-0.7096826434135437,
0.3081638813018799,
0.1881522238254547,
0.5047833323478699,
0.3896538019180298,
-0.7188579440116882,
-0.2950466573238373,
0.2548101544380188,
-0.09773288667201996,
-0.6351578235626221,
0.16613857448101044,
0.20513586699962616,
0.37185752391815186,
0.6547661423683167,
0.1735544204711914,
0.783627450466156,
-0.9250118732452393,
0.5773571133613586,
0.21130859851837158,
-0.9557458162307739,
0.34427759051322937,
-0.30504798889160156,
0.029588883742690086,
0.47688043117523193,
0.3309085965156555,
-0.5036093592643738,
-0.4924803078174591,
-0.904913604259491,
-1.1982142925262451,
0.545411229133606,
-0.023902468383312225,
0.23645339906215668,
0.07663773000240326,
0.7832348346710205,
0.1300874948501587,
0.4421398341655731,
-0.35496801137924194,
-0.38541990518569946,
0.09911889582872391,
-0.08489710092544556,
-0.30148741602897644,
-0.3225198984146118,
0.22887960076332092,
-0.1464245766401291,
0.8139815926551819,
0.3244139850139618,
-0.02492430992424488,
-0.32998570799827576,
-0.6616584062576294,
-0.26026496291160583,
0.4315017759799957,
0.18809902667999268,
0.8937153220176697,
0.02403869852423668,
0.1647503674030304,
0.314772367477417,
-0.3758106827735901,
0.14399470388889313,
-0.15238866209983826,
-0.5640183091163635,
-0.26700359582901,
0.34447482228279114,
0.6592795252799988,
0.4789036512374878,
-0.6711934804916382,
0.41228652000427246,
0.13724537193775177,
-0.07483381778001785,
-0.5070293545722961,
0.1413796842098236,
0.3011232912540436,
0.05193853750824928,
0.2450791746377945,
-0.17208904027938843,
0.10544109344482422,
-0.8043792247772217,
0.4902823269367218,
0.3500121831893921,
-0.36083725094795227,
-0.4291605055332184,
0.682125985622406,
-0.10844819247722626,
-0.041767667979002,
0.7112109661102295,
-0.25237032771110535,
-0.2839714586734772,
0.4601232707500458,
0.47214558720588684,
0.7056521773338318,
-0.315464586019516,
0.07683080434799194,
0.16705678403377533,
0.38044098019599915,
-0.37569618225097656,
-0.14209769666194916,
0.09198950976133347,
-0.7420362830162048,
-0.5477147102355957,
-0.5619415044784546,
-0.08307306468486786,
0.5480065941810608,
-0.8875301480293274,
0.05527086555957794,
-0.494568794965744,
0.21976296603679657,
0.2973155677318573,
-0.1448887139558792,
-0.7486141920089722,
0.20728832483291626,
-0.004165003541857004,
0.6265107989311218,
-0.729141354560852,
0.9296073317527771,
0.7614747881889343,
-0.6145153045654297,
-0.9466509222984314,
0.18117791414260864,
0.13935071229934692,
-0.7133989334106445,
0.27844730019569397,
-0.03734159842133522,
0.15723614394664764,
0.30838361382484436,
-0.36317819356918335,
-0.6380442380905151,
0.8906556367874146,
0.5648569464683533,
-0.905775785446167,
-0.37939465045928955,
0.043809764087200165,
0.5407137870788574,
-0.1287488490343094,
0.02756083570420742,
0.5969573259353638,
-0.07607713341712952,
-0.3143480718135834,
-0.7043067812919617,
0.03309948369860649,
-0.1532902717590332,
-0.026829013600945473,
0.6158779859542847,
-0.37869685888290405,
0.9626495242118835,
-0.27330631017684937,
-0.3501285910606384,
-0.06629745662212372,
0.8353570103645325,
-0.19092640280723572,
0.22670933604240417,
0.8784724473953247,
0.8501496315002441,
0.9418008923530579,
0.04648148640990257,
0.5818670392036438,
-0.15073566138744354,
0.5488812923431396,
1.2794780731201172,
-0.30057492852211,
0.752465009689331,
0.2911045551300049,
0.22244144976139069,
0.23836304247379303,
0.45513102412223816,
0.15703636407852173,
0.4052109122276306,
0.40563029050827026,
-0.3390618860721588,
-0.38637834787368774,
-0.02177206240594387,
-0.20037652552127838,
0.4695225656032562,
0.17572470009326935,
-0.2366340458393097,
-0.2770855128765106,
0.18444202840328217,
0.30141693353652954,
0.05437657982110977,
-0.43545854091644287,
1.101287841796875,
0.2017771452665329,
-0.4495960772037506,
0.4904082417488098,
0.05154017359018326,
0.36749541759490967,
-0.20441213250160217,
-0.008800937794148922,
-0.25583645701408386,
0.3186177611351013,
-0.12139452248811722,
-0.6639246344566345,
0.05113447085022926,
0.28983497619628906,
-0.31315523386001587,
-0.2327803671360016,
0.5575903058052063,
-0.9016534686088562,
0.05449230968952179,
0.39998698234558105,
0.6986755132675171,
0.17842170596122742,
-0.4227530062198639,
-0.6840749382972717,
-0.36379274725914,
0.12446646392345428,
-0.34536391496658325,
0.7361629605293274,
0.7851000428199768,
-0.10986986756324768,
0.6925444006919861,
0.7633515000343323,
0.07172670215368271,
-0.07244562357664108,
0.32075613737106323,
0.8888348937034607,
-0.48492491245269775,
-0.42407500743865967,
-0.8119300603866577,
0.21539300680160522,
0.02101127803325653,
-0.17868486046791077,
0.5686561465263367,
0.631996214389801,
1.3172369003295898,
0.14584161341190338,
0.5047662854194641,
0.25003838539123535,
0.5743545293807983,
-0.6694608330726624,
1.0001466274261475,
-0.8664684891700745,
0.5780481100082397,
-0.5238627195358276,
-1.1079027652740479,
-0.06816736608743668,
0.23583604395389557,
-0.041492074728012085,
0.143363818526268,
0.4720114469528198,
0.7184707522392273,
-0.3623894453048706,
0.14245812594890594,
0.4664936065673828,
0.2705226242542267,
0.27476534247398376,
0.5288036465644836,
0.8488978147506714,
-0.16777747869491577,
0.6302744150161743,
-0.48789846897125244,
-0.10150166600942612,
0.16636665165424347,
-0.664552628993988,
-0.9586378335952759,
-0.7682464718818665,
-0.2606908977031708,
-0.10488123446702957,
0.247799813747406,
0.7725128531455994,
0.3637487292289734,
-0.8864989876747131,
0.13930866122245789,
-0.09437355399131775,
0.0293513685464859,
0.0011396032059565187,
-0.139877051115036,
0.44042515754699707,
-0.22161130607128143,
-0.6942151188850403,
0.2642917037010193,
0.055747486650943756,
0.16235388815402985,
-0.11092109233140945,
0.2793692350387573,
-0.057943228632211685,
-0.23524212837219238,
0.3174373507499695,
0.5596975684165955,
-0.6646575927734375,
-0.30800965428352356,
-0.19532310962677002,
0.12736062705516815,
-0.2532830834388733,
1.0033437013626099,
-0.6322517395019531,
0.03875049576163292,
0.08253076672554016,
0.6980936527252197,
0.5282390713691711,
-0.1009729653596878,
0.38948026299476624,
-1.0173308849334717,
0.15108871459960938,
-0.00007921820360934362,
0.6626703143119812,
0.16610565781593323,
-0.3373706340789795,
0.10936634242534637,
0.15749424695968628,
-0.4182896912097931,
-1.1898471117019653,
0.31959572434425354,
-0.4560413062572479,
-0.6808580160140991,
0.8191644549369812,
-0.4696112275123596,
-0.24804998934268951,
-0.19035325944423676,
0.12337885051965714,
0.7543371319770813,
-0.5123776197433472,
0.7920450568199158,
0.4132956862449646,
0.4325006902217865,
-0.26421281695365906,
-0.3820451498031616,
0.504484236240387,
0.5687789916992188,
-0.6721491813659668,
0.5118921399116516,
0.5314140319824219,
0.6252935528755188,
0.11086106300354004,
0.37106314301490784,
-0.09178876131772995,
0.1182774230837822,
-0.3232424855232239,
0.2578125298023224,
-0.2702094316482544,
-0.7632404565811157,
-0.42975255846977234,
0.23788189888000488,
0.020283766090869904,
0.06977474689483643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15786v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15786v1 | What Matters in Transformers? Not All Attention is Needed | 2024-06-22T08:41:48 | 2024-06-22T08:41:48 | Shwai He, Guoheng Sun, Zheyu Shen, Ang Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Scaling Transformer-based large language models (LLMs) has demonstrated
promising performance across various tasks. However, this scaling also
introduces redundant structures, posing challenges for real-world deployment.
Despite some recognition of redundancy in LLMs, the variability of redundancy
across different structures, such as MLP and Attention layers, is
under-explored. In this work, we investigate the varying redundancy across
different modules within Transformers, including Blocks, MLP, and Attention
layers, using a similarity-based metric. This metric operates on the premise
that redundant structures produce outputs highly similar to their inputs.
Surprisingly, while attention layers are essential for transformers and
distinguish them from other mainstream architectures, we found that a large
proportion of attention layers exhibit excessively high similarity and can be
safely pruned without degrading performance, leading to reduced memory and
computation costs. Additionally, we further propose a method that jointly drops
Attention and MLP layers, achieving improved performance and dropping ratios.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods, e.g.,
Llama-3-70B maintains comparable performance even after pruning half of the
attention layers. Our findings provide valuable insights for future network
architecture design. The code will be released at:
\url{https://github.com/Shwai-He/LLM-Drop}. | [
-0.7850149869918823,
-0.315902978181839,
0.16617760062217712,
0.4746226668357849,
0.15241633355617523,
-0.11772517114877701,
-0.1750681847333908,
-0.5440585017204285,
0.16244350373744965,
0.4898008406162262,
-0.5942906737327576,
-0.05483541265130043,
-0.7077962756156921,
0.16740550100803375,
-0.7048577666282654,
0.9307411313056946,
-0.014167948625981808,
-0.4139658808708191,
-0.4532862901687622,
-0.38610154390335083,
-0.46677252650260925,
-0.10226383060216904,
-0.7714955806732178,
-0.5897543430328369,
0.9280900359153748,
0.4250269830226898,
0.712080717086792,
0.8815388679504395,
1.0041850805282593,
0.41510528326034546,
-0.43272385001182556,
0.11416388303041458,
-0.5893542170524597,
-0.0901164561510086,
-0.2890569567680359,
-0.5848358869552612,
-0.539020299911499,
-0.0923881009221077,
0.7964567542076111,
0.6154668927192688,
-0.1771671324968338,
0.5140846967697144,
0.21516025066375732,
0.9397841691970825,
-0.6391178369522095,
0.16391612589359283,
-0.6753475666046143,
0.2928554117679596,
-0.059791695326566696,
0.0013615647330880165,
-0.24688047170639038,
-0.01724015735089779,
0.09962660074234009,
-0.30090615153312683,
0.34671711921691895,
0.043797995895147324,
0.9205989837646484,
0.7716710567474365,
-0.13994011282920837,
0.37290316820144653,
-0.8473191261291504,
0.814642071723938,
-0.3594709634780884,
0.4437198340892792,
0.20585961639881134,
0.16692286729812622,
0.27515271306037903,
-0.6346180438995361,
-0.3496638536453247,
-0.0002923358406405896,
-0.34612759947776794,
0.22426441311836243,
-0.3735973834991455,
0.03218475729227066,
0.3464186191558838,
0.4605545997619629,
-0.1592824012041092,
0.07056092470884323,
-0.6553430557250977,
-0.09028365463018417,
0.05265768989920616,
0.30184832215309143,
0.15219071507453918,
-0.1619093418121338,
-0.45339787006378174,
-0.03730069845914841,
-0.9452400803565979,
-0.14316236972808838,
0.30560362339019775,
0.08487153053283691,
-0.26485690474510193,
0.42643165588378906,
-0.0421796478331089,
0.3812495172023773,
0.2888488173484802,
-0.027589954435825348,
0.3496688902378082,
-0.028553958982229233,
-0.5163673758506775,
-0.2584991455078125,
0.5727623105049133,
0.4589112401008606,
0.3171614408493042,
-0.3484351336956024,
-0.020964443683624268,
0.014330152422189713,
0.9942310452461243,
-0.5001378059387207,
-0.32308393716812134,
0.27537801861763,
-0.5650113224983215,
-0.17397360503673553,
-0.2620519697666168,
-0.4001094400882721,
-0.09795210510492325,
-0.24644476175308228,
0.17771431803703308,
-0.09128561615943909,
-0.28478625416755676,
-0.006737194489687681,
-0.12842155992984772,
0.3116704821586609,
0.07293163985013962,
-0.9467214941978455,
0.31508728861808777,
0.963658332824707,
0.6776806116104126,
-0.5575550198554993,
-0.49762865900993347,
-0.22511684894561768,
0.1622021645307541,
-0.026962025091052055,
0.5000469088554382,
-0.3790871798992157,
-0.012204536236822605,
-0.19239746034145355,
0.1158413216471672,
-0.21688467264175415,
-1.019593596458435,
0.5650884509086609,
-0.6146562695503235,
-0.1408044546842575,
-0.09950235486030579,
-0.1772618144750595,
-0.2307504564523697,
0.3788711130619049,
-0.913735568523407,
0.947601318359375,
0.2565958797931671,
-1.085195541381836,
0.16662047803401947,
-0.35616037249565125,
-0.7144773006439209,
0.0905265361070633,
-0.08682066202163696,
-0.7266432642936707,
0.3265220820903778,
-0.17542347311973572,
0.49434396624565125,
-0.38908764719963074,
-0.01698574237525463,
-0.11879561096429825,
-0.45988374948501587,
0.005007272120565176,
-0.32541602849960327,
0.3285900950431824,
0.17193558812141418,
-0.4806400239467621,
-0.035532545298337936,
-0.9372214078903198,
-0.01451107393950224,
-0.026712067425251007,
-0.47451961040496826,
-0.01071145199239254,
0.1621604859828949,
0.1972181349992752,
0.24123044312000275,
0.12199722975492477,
-0.5460046529769897,
-0.15823069214820862,
-0.3766443729400635,
0.7579572200775146,
0.6950767040252686,
-0.22181493043899536,
0.5946797132492065,
-0.5346755981445312,
0.4627632796764374,
0.30909714102745056,
0.1884935051202774,
0.06899744272232056,
-0.24943183362483978,
-1.0970814228057861,
-0.2254953682422638,
-0.06548105925321579,
0.39021822810173035,
-0.22211377322673798,
0.3340799808502197,
-0.4884891211986542,
-0.5431554913520813,
-0.7039274573326111,
0.05024798586964607,
0.5053178071975708,
0.5146033763885498,
0.3730049133300781,
-0.33594709634780884,
-0.558660089969635,
-1.5307307243347168,
-0.19105081260204315,
-0.06483582407236099,
-0.1978210210800171,
0.3126393258571625,
0.06738938391208649,
-0.42426368594169617,
0.9171930551528931,
-0.3669956624507904,
-0.5796377062797546,
-0.38771378993988037,
-0.5481833219528198,
0.09307984262704849,
0.3128812313079834,
0.45301443338394165,
-0.6399149298667908,
-0.34386077523231506,
0.28710177540779114,
-0.4048391282558441,
-0.1397610306739807,
-0.08306238055229187,
0.0075844693928956985,
0.014466729946434498,
0.36974555253982544,
-0.9952495098114014,
0.12371576577425003,
0.5585047602653503,
0.23501631617546082,
0.31187155842781067,
0.0033612630795687437,
-0.06713419407606125,
-1.1137882471084595,
0.19375693798065186,
0.012691992335021496,
-0.19187352061271667,
-0.5290058255195618,
0.21881432831287384,
0.24161557853221893,
0.0923936739563942,
-0.6271938681602478,
0.2701647877693176,
-0.3169753849506378,
-0.2707490622997284,
-0.08323308080434799,
0.09952080994844437,
0.02722892537713051,
0.7461246848106384,
-0.2960722744464874,
0.6270105838775635,
0.28941890597343445,
-0.6060119271278381,
0.24903342127799988,
0.18796731531620026,
-0.26218339800834656,
0.443435937166214,
-0.7158235311508179,
-0.02276838757097721,
-0.12136510759592056,
-0.05935359373688698,
-0.9136458039283752,
-0.0531882718205452,
0.1388363093137741,
-0.008243708871304989,
0.3462933599948883,
0.03165894374251366,
-0.44845759868621826,
-0.43803414702415466,
-0.3037022054195404,
0.4478900730609894,
0.4034698009490967,
-0.4144766330718994,
0.5508634448051453,
0.5433419346809387,
-0.026412852108478546,
-0.7807457447052002,
-0.9105860590934753,
-0.0726470798254013,
-0.5955507159233093,
-0.42682966589927673,
0.3982014060020447,
0.08964266628026962,
-0.1165153905749321,
0.13559849560260773,
-0.5143950581550598,
0.0037727702874690294,
0.14781728386878967,
0.6278038024902344,
-0.03891314938664436,
-0.21249349415302277,
0.3515688478946686,
-0.15671733021736145,
-0.21952655911445618,
0.3016888499259949,
-0.1889868974685669,
0.5218183398246765,
-0.09161195904016495,
-0.34614694118499756,
-0.6538564562797546,
0.3048092722892761,
0.7843121886253357,
-0.02843070775270462,
0.6337934732437134,
0.7038050889968872,
-0.02699030376970768,
-0.20713673532009125,
-0.6984624266624451,
-0.07121667265892029,
-0.5645861625671387,
0.8110087513923645,
-0.40175747871398926,
-1.051588773727417,
0.6437922716140747,
0.15796270966529846,
0.3796730041503906,
0.506493330001831,
0.5415270328521729,
-0.25607895851135254,
0.3779727816581726,
0.9001073837280273,
-0.42431026697158813,
0.6350710391998291,
-0.19466382265090942,
0.35478541254997253,
-1.0090068578720093,
-0.13597942888736725,
-0.44273242354393005,
-0.8870692253112793,
-0.6050567030906677,
-0.37408164143562317,
-0.022758303210139275,
-0.24907948076725006,
-0.3804277181625366,
0.6161026358604431,
-0.7156670689582825,
0.7838555574417114,
0.30734917521476746,
-0.11721271276473999,
0.1956273913383484,
0.37098726630210876,
0.3425774872303009,
-0.09209851920604706,
-0.7771545052528381,
-0.3130381107330322,
0.7495812177658081,
0.43840107321739197,
0.6410510540008545,
0.08494468033313751,
0.5514158606529236,
0.19349393248558044,
0.3238227963447571,
-0.6965445280075073,
0.6558539867401123,
-0.16303913295269012,
-0.301313579082489,
-0.27110812067985535,
-0.780578076839447,
-1.0324268341064453,
0.2724517583847046,
0.2044307291507721,
-0.5300298929214478,
-0.09390883147716522,
0.1733778715133667,
-0.18724240362644196,
0.5770794749259949,
-0.7008169889450073,
0.5874885320663452,
0.2876959443092346,
-0.1313183456659317,
-0.5997475385665894,
-0.6213371753692627,
0.09368504583835602,
-0.14655518531799316,
-0.2032361924648285,
-0.1671234667301178,
-0.16678911447525024,
0.46625879406929016,
-0.10775528848171234,
0.9292031526565552,
0.44010570645332336,
-0.3239958882331848,
0.2647166848182678,
0.11052900552749634,
0.4471454620361328,
-0.146050825715065,
0.07381214946508408,
0.4715786278247833,
-0.5030404329299927,
-0.2809511423110962,
-0.5605792999267578,
1.0431578159332275,
-1.0859612226486206,
-0.7080933451652527,
0.23678134381771088,
-0.63164222240448,
-0.025293802842497826,
0.011639569886028767,
0.16787217557430267,
0.29583844542503357,
0.08112981915473938,
0.4347892105579376,
0.5739285945892334,
-0.09244979172945023,
0.6450017094612122,
0.15315638482570648,
0.25422146916389465,
-0.08833666890859604,
0.8423622250556946,
0.17802715301513672,
0.610103964805603,
0.7695768475532532,
-0.17376472055912018,
-0.1255052238702774,
-0.42244240641593933,
-0.007422170136123896,
0.2915687561035156,
-0.7014871835708618,
-0.3311195373535156,
-0.9009795188903809,
-0.5960087180137634,
0.019211919978260994,
-0.060052692890167236,
-0.632808268070221,
-0.5473096966743469,
-0.23007485270500183,
-0.22313782572746277,
0.162359818816185,
0.6925610303878784,
0.223623126745224,
0.37811174988746643,
-0.7670356035232544,
0.3972546458244324,
0.3565780222415924,
0.6522149443626404,
0.45134806632995605,
-0.619123101234436,
-0.4290834069252014,
-0.3668243885040283,
-0.5340256094932556,
-0.25728851556777954,
0.24337635934352875,
0.10109811276197433,
0.4906392991542816,
0.31844136118888855,
-0.19796770811080933,
0.6231124401092529,
-0.61995929479599,
0.4548575282096863,
0.34206071496009827,
-0.6957948803901672,
0.12783576548099518,
-0.2640061378479004,
0.6608432531356812,
0.38120296597480774,
0.1019098088145256,
-0.6405340433120728,
-0.6861066818237305,
-0.8051527738571167,
-1.0428333282470703,
0.8260515332221985,
0.37854230403900146,
0.1989562213420868,
-0.07958667725324631,
0.2589799165725708,
-0.15624535083770752,
0.2981003522872925,
-0.7784244418144226,
-0.5787594318389893,
0.2878715395927429,
-0.17725786566734314,
0.06414639204740524,
-0.27896732091903687,
-0.2128266543149948,
0.01006661169230938,
0.23722179234027863,
0.3690353035926819,
0.27548596262931824,
-0.05416402220726013,
-0.09482964128255844,
-0.10904376953840256,
0.29519206285476685,
0.4654161334037781,
0.4988294541835785,
0.06734580546617508,
0.35147956013679504,
0.4393247663974762,
-0.7170815467834473,
0.13443432748317719,
-0.6816926598548889,
-0.1453924924135208,
-0.19485674798488617,
0.3412032723426819,
0.6889086365699768,
0.4898824691772461,
-0.45126083493232727,
0.15012717247009277,
0.04373014345765114,
-0.14722095429897308,
-0.07230287045240402,
0.22116367518901825,
0.3769189417362213,
0.35451772809028625,
0.16336961090564728,
0.568161129951477,
-0.10699444264173508,
-0.26629412174224854,
0.25485140085220337,
0.2071496844291687,
-0.46485635638237,
-0.35007816553115845,
0.45099905133247375,
0.43140390515327454,
-0.6848184466362,
0.6584423184394836,
0.2603569030761719,
-0.2912355363368988,
1.0050522089004517,
0.39527371525764465,
1.066861629486084,
0.11867544054985046,
0.09592554718255997,
0.1768513172864914,
0.6416581273078918,
-0.16788029670715332,
-0.3610728681087494,
-0.12164784222841263,
-0.6259987950325012,
-0.4866940677165985,
-0.655670166015625,
-0.15983137488365173,
0.309151828289032,
-0.5554394125938416,
0.10626417398452759,
-0.6367191672325134,
-0.32732149958610535,
-0.19886414706707,
-0.20684286952018738,
-0.6886067390441895,
0.0399017259478569,
0.11113229393959045,
0.5418307185173035,
-0.6027879118919373,
0.50533527135849,
0.5833867788314819,
0.07073704153299332,
-0.8761920928955078,
0.08310052752494812,
-0.10845363885164261,
-0.5261924862861633,
0.7819392085075378,
0.3775359094142914,
-0.302085816860199,
-0.11053334921598434,
0.09095610678195953,
-1.0194307565689087,
0.8685333132743835,
0.44494354724884033,
-0.7823022603988647,
0.05251330882310867,
0.2902474105358124,
0.5851753950119019,
-0.29883718490600586,
0.3309289813041687,
0.6102336645126343,
0.28912851214408875,
-0.05658216401934624,
-1.0171583890914917,
-0.11918683350086212,
-0.11747221648693085,
0.029130272567272186,
0.5990296006202698,
-1.1310360431671143,
0.8392042517662048,
-0.33512166142463684,
-0.6205112934112549,
-0.17979362607002258,
0.3183392882347107,
-0.06297864019870758,
-0.0811593309044838,
0.4846042990684509,
0.9114483594894409,
0.30262696743011475,
0.000604507396928966,
0.9017918109893799,
-0.30642879009246826,
0.46890226006507874,
1.1705683469772339,
-0.08036073297262192,
0.8966144919395447,
0.5329987406730652,
-0.33247458934783936,
-0.010726222768425941,
0.3998434245586395,
-0.07798614352941513,
0.3352610766887665,
0.2520267069339752,
0.14921601116657257,
-0.18537890911102295,
0.12342340499162674,
-0.2793251872062683,
0.3788779377937317,
-0.02294328808784485,
-0.35752877593040466,
-0.15826447308063507,
-0.35852062702178955,
-0.18779680132865906,
-0.19173158705234528,
-0.3063679337501526,
0.598792552947998,
0.20118296146392822,
-0.5596347451210022,
0.6288915872573853,
-0.1909579038619995,
0.5588983297348022,
-0.26405781507492065,
0.29486969113349915,
-0.45124372839927673,
0.5349887013435364,
-0.4459262788295746,
-0.752661406993866,
0.6401758193969727,
-0.26058486104011536,
-0.6933935284614563,
-0.4762372672557831,
0.3964054584503174,
-0.35406365990638733,
-0.2315196841955185,
0.527045726776123,
0.24819186329841614,
0.03933524340391159,
-0.030213329941034317,
-0.46293577551841736,
0.3449561297893524,
0.1415223628282547,
-0.3298206925392151,
0.5427419543266296,
0.3271041810512543,
0.10160534828901291,
1.1438369750976562,
0.3096851110458374,
0.15773366391658783,
0.24250468611717224,
0.33406609296798706,
0.8756924867630005,
-0.5060461163520813,
-0.1272827535867691,
-0.8809269666671753,
0.2152436375617981,
-0.09746178984642029,
-0.2979254126548767,
0.6977459192276001,
0.5429597496986389,
0.8009662628173828,
-0.32810214161872864,
0.2736590802669525,
0.20925092697143555,
0.25276216864585876,
-0.030950866639614105,
0.7973811030387878,
-0.6840270757675171,
0.41600510478019714,
-0.2372455596923828,
-1.5364173650741577,
-0.2547277510166168,
0.43717682361602783,
0.19454516470432281,
-0.13767944276332855,
0.6749659180641174,
0.7874819040298462,
-0.3009971082210541,
-0.29461196064949036,
0.47377288341522217,
0.305189847946167,
0.19972454011440277,
0.7580908536911011,
0.7152599692344666,
-0.4717206656932831,
0.8330566883087158,
0.041373785585165024,
0.2400417923927307,
-0.19277310371398926,
-0.4759275019168854,
-0.7294706702232361,
-0.4047415852546692,
-0.4863702654838562,
0.10832767933607101,
-0.16464383900165558,
0.36010998487472534,
0.6445767879486084,
-0.43386340141296387,
-0.13744567334651947,
-0.020376548171043396,
0.3130556046962738,
-0.313958078622818,
-0.2080230712890625,
0.3016243278980255,
-0.3406757414340973,
-0.6930784583091736,
-0.043590791523456573,
0.8225964307785034,
-0.02801154926419258,
-0.3813110291957855,
0.3527379035949707,
0.11424847692251205,
-0.03063208796083927,
0.7011839151382446,
0.11722125113010406,
-0.9236136674880981,
-0.4616469442844391,
-0.19766183197498322,
-0.43772146105766296,
0.2870212495326996,
0.7467552423477173,
-0.6739410161972046,
-0.16645875573158264,
0.7063792943954468,
0.905099093914032,
0.37495896220207214,
0.018160047009587288,
0.362712562084198,
-1.136123776435852,
0.39011767506599426,
0.11246098577976227,
0.3097296357154846,
0.39572691917419434,
-0.295911580324173,
0.5024281144142151,
0.015013975091278553,
-0.5662645101547241,
-0.6889083385467529,
0.5463452339172363,
-1.1132965087890625,
0.10759375989437103,
1.1835756301879883,
-0.06603381782770157,
-0.30437394976615906,
-0.09293483942747116,
-0.04175347089767456,
-0.10899049043655396,
-0.14174921810626984,
1.0595691204071045,
0.7281704545021057,
0.24769507348537445,
-0.6597039699554443,
-0.28898587822914124,
0.39248761534690857,
0.782055675983429,
-0.6276125311851501,
0.474524587392807,
0.12831152975559235,
0.35096338391304016,
0.6452352404594421,
0.2043963372707367,
0.05201715975999832,
0.0027362732216715813,
-0.07122131437063217,
0.07279456406831741,
0.06029336154460907,
-0.5589983463287354,
-0.173687145113945,
0.6116308569908142,
-0.2828712463378906,
-0.23710790276527405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15781v1 | DABL: Detecting Semantic Anomalies in Business Processes Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T08:20:19 | 2024-06-22T08:20:19 | Wei Guan, Jian Cao, Jianqi Gao, Haiyan Zhao, Shiyou Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting anomalies in business processes is crucial for ensuring operational
success. While many existing methods rely on statistical frequency to detect
anomalies, it's important to note that infrequent behavior doesn't necessarily
imply undesirability. To address this challenge, detecting anomalies from a
semantic viewpoint proves to be a more effective approach. However, current
semantic anomaly detection methods treat a trace (i.e., process instance) as
multiple event pairs, disrupting long-distance dependencies. In this paper, we
introduce DABL, a novel approach for detecting semantic anomalies in business
processes using large language models (LLMs). We collect 143,137 real-world
process models from various domains. By generating normal traces through the
playout of these process models and simulating both ordering and exclusion
anomalies, we fine-tune Llama 2 using the resulting log. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that DABL surpasses existing state-of-the-art
semantic anomaly detection methods in terms of both generalization ability and
learning of given processes. Users can directly apply DABL to detect semantic
anomalies in their own datasets without the need for additional training.
Furthermore, DABL offers the capability to interpret the causes of anomalies in
natural language, providing valuable insights into the detected anomalies. | [
-0.17121686041355133,
-1.3304517269134521,
0.771632730960846,
0.04630659893155098,
-0.20366616547107697,
-0.01955600641667843,
0.14505089819431305,
-0.7721195816993713,
0.2159293293952942,
0.8914296627044678,
-0.9360551834106445,
-0.6233415603637695,
-0.7066011428833008,
-0.07113417983055115,
-0.6432837247848511,
0.9339895248413086,
0.06926251947879791,
-0.41027212142944336,
-0.011600487865507603,
-0.08858353644609451,
-0.5014176964759827,
-0.5454691052436829,
-0.6551799178123474,
-0.3410543203353882,
0.28302308917045593,
0.13367000222206116,
0.5111086368560791,
0.5520226955413818,
0.7028083801269531,
0.2605467140674591,
-0.08899688720703125,
0.49504315853118896,
-0.29915663599967957,
0.3944277763366699,
-0.09129200130701065,
-0.3685721755027771,
-0.6828830242156982,
-0.4745166599750519,
0.7069309949874878,
0.7482848763465881,
-0.20639072358608246,
0.06953561305999756,
-0.17788642644882202,
0.7318496704101562,
-0.3635804057121277,
0.4167231321334839,
-0.7137584090232849,
-0.04257612302899361,
-0.5698427557945251,
-0.06266063451766968,
-0.25859978795051575,
0.047703057527542114,
0.014294044114649296,
-0.26490554213523865,
0.3060242235660553,
0.08769864588975906,
0.8238662481307983,
0.37172380089759827,
-0.43821799755096436,
-0.6295719146728516,
-0.7456693649291992,
0.9744167327880859,
-0.9220430254936218,
0.1625838726758957,
0.25853031873703003,
0.21247397363185883,
-0.8661637306213379,
-0.8839331269264221,
-0.9055870175361633,
0.006617099978029728,
-0.13558155298233032,
-0.3126525282859802,
-0.589327871799469,
-0.0044242944568395615,
0.44429680705070496,
-0.02136640064418316,
-0.503296971321106,
0.4329136610031128,
0.15074720978736877,
-0.2823272943496704,
0.5179744362831116,
0.4681164622306824,
0.3875051438808441,
-0.023328065872192383,
-0.42000308632850647,
0.2132633626461029,
-0.47989752888679504,
-0.10773228853940964,
0.5209541916847229,
0.04214109480381012,
-0.08850397169589996,
0.11426148563623428,
-0.31320708990097046,
0.8203350901603699,
-0.14917130768299103,
-0.17794771492481232,
0.04335976019501686,
-0.2177756130695343,
0.05947672203183174,
0.1593763530254364,
0.44639360904693604,
0.023993561044335365,
0.14808472990989685,
-0.19289998710155487,
-0.2243037223815918,
0.32330235838890076,
0.004686426371335983,
-0.6182220578193665,
-0.37036001682281494,
0.3472767174243927,
-0.32075971364974976,
-0.09140584617853165,
-0.1035805270075798,
-0.637653112411499,
-0.5016545653343201,
-0.2233041226863861,
0.15930862724781036,
-0.1815691739320755,
-0.48560792207717896,
0.23784364759922028,
-0.16779612004756927,
0.07575977593660355,
0.2751779854297638,
-0.9325785040855408,
0.2907307744026184,
0.9897623658180237,
0.5726908445358276,
-0.2898198664188385,
-0.3928860127925873,
-0.7702654004096985,
0.5467630624771118,
-0.29257887601852417,
1.0541917085647583,
-0.5675850510597229,
-0.06740009039640427,
-0.17707806825637817,
-0.000246757292188704,
0.25783687829971313,
-0.7169861793518066,
0.433235228061676,
-0.6780970692634583,
-0.2706681489944458,
-0.03251045569777489,
-0.8803921937942505,
-0.29273858666419983,
0.24209067225456238,
-0.5107788443565369,
0.9698503017425537,
-0.0658721923828125,
-0.781509518623352,
0.5489972829818726,
-0.7942290902137756,
-0.2759920358657837,
0.1946791708469391,
-0.16010597348213196,
-0.4922176003456116,
0.25900977849960327,
-0.05473749712109566,
0.45679008960723877,
-0.15587469935417175,
0.43869566917419434,
-0.5830895304679871,
-0.09839048236608505,
0.5650219321250916,
-0.41723042726516724,
0.8247128129005432,
0.04020000249147415,
-0.37108030915260315,
0.0007681033457629383,
-1.135724663734436,
-0.1513916552066803,
0.08849304914474487,
-0.04615498706698418,
-0.5124195218086243,
0.18132077157497406,
-0.15834732353687286,
0.15803061425685883,
0.21981942653656006,
-0.7731307148933411,
0.11024343967437744,
-0.5103329420089722,
0.31633585691452026,
0.6464490294456482,
0.34114453196525574,
0.10891616344451904,
-0.09687816351652145,
0.2918490469455719,
0.4976494610309601,
-0.04424449801445007,
-0.2878965437412262,
-0.7564501166343689,
-0.5808718204498291,
-0.874889612197876,
-0.12251352518796921,
0.40209126472473145,
-0.21064117550849915,
0.7547697424888611,
-0.12345592677593231,
-0.16541913151741028,
-0.40918445587158203,
0.4947841763496399,
-0.11419641226530075,
0.9410215020179749,
0.04942470043897629,
-0.2477421909570694,
-0.6138837933540344,
-0.7775744795799255,
-0.27957937121391296,
-0.1691950261592865,
-0.06990955024957657,
-0.0462571382522583,
0.5038079023361206,
-0.7661716341972351,
1.3462833166122437,
-0.517634928226471,
-0.43476614356040955,
0.010285687632858753,
0.3539048135280609,
0.3847832679748535,
0.249332994222641,
0.4243815839290619,
-0.8018940687179565,
-0.10141978412866592,
-0.11581102013587952,
-1.0091989040374756,
-0.36340364813804626,
-0.10949067026376724,
-0.12856009602546692,
0.748181164264679,
0.3289515972137451,
-0.3903574049472809,
0.6533533930778503,
0.5817194581031799,
-0.6966976523399353,
0.3026595711708069,
-0.6329928636550903,
-0.20826095342636108,
-0.6000536680221558,
-0.15345917642116547,
-0.24251346290111542,
-0.17537464201450348,
-0.8458467721939087,
-0.14217720925807953,
0.15180101990699768,
0.07509154826402664,
-0.1473594605922699,
0.47391846776008606,
-0.3744821846485138,
-0.2362675815820694,
-0.7134271860122681,
-0.16738863289356232,
0.3456079661846161,
0.2976337969303131,
0.055873025208711624,
0.10129164904356003,
0.6635988354682922,
-0.7522850036621094,
0.7188916206359863,
0.19338984787464142,
-0.5005283355712891,
0.5373461842536926,
-0.23091097176074982,
0.15736860036849976,
-0.2948104441165924,
0.3602643311023712,
-1.3757075071334839,
-0.17889384925365448,
0.2383006513118744,
-0.3728310763835907,
0.1535496562719345,
0.027113689109683037,
-0.837945282459259,
-0.2782140374183655,
0.07894580066204071,
0.17438742518424988,
0.3480361998081207,
-0.6917463541030884,
0.5647599101066589,
0.46716079115867615,
0.08196032047271729,
-0.38814690709114075,
-1.024063229560852,
0.2194870412349701,
-0.36492642760276794,
-0.983615517616272,
0.015477911569178104,
0.130075603723526,
-0.1970527172088623,
0.14499077200889587,
-0.40507563948631287,
-0.5548236966133118,
0.6090876460075378,
0.11729886382818222,
0.2792295217514038,
0.02497166581451893,
-0.0029054032638669014,
-0.06909231096506119,
-0.16349652409553528,
0.34427881240844727,
-0.2562178671360016,
0.36489567160606384,
-0.00039414604543708265,
-0.582480788230896,
-0.7222470045089722,
0.4868561625480652,
0.6333736181259155,
-0.05441678687930107,
0.7981852293014526,
0.7357726097106934,
-0.5778564214706421,
-0.3001231849193573,
-0.7846253514289856,
-0.3604198098182678,
-0.4653454124927521,
0.566051185131073,
-0.14216744899749756,
-0.5397266149520874,
0.7944442629814148,
-0.1206297054886818,
-0.0017536571249365807,
0.1070147156715393,
0.5685358643531799,
-0.14346860349178314,
1.170042872428894,
0.8892136216163635,
-0.0026227382477372885,
0.34879201650619507,
-0.0719282254576683,
0.7768133878707886,
-0.5648029446601868,
-0.4404985308647156,
-0.34669050574302673,
-0.12125857919454575,
-0.6653063893318176,
-0.43647634983062744,
0.39178580045700073,
-0.05206160619854927,
0.2858238220214844,
0.13468001782894135,
0.03355386480689049,
0.21823081374168396,
0.39703696966171265,
-0.16160394251346588,
0.6380245685577393,
0.03904179111123085,
0.01911344565451145,
-0.06041347235441208,
-0.4735938608646393,
-0.5495604872703552,
0.7533046007156372,
0.25986337661743164,
0.6865235567092896,
0.3189406394958496,
0.9555339813232422,
0.5970261693000793,
-0.028202682733535767,
-0.805845320224762,
0.4007890522480011,
0.06205189600586891,
-0.7594471573829651,
-0.5401763916015625,
-0.3514317274093628,
-1.1434437036514282,
0.014811222441494465,
-0.08747773617506027,
-0.89935302734375,
0.1836705207824707,
0.3072080612182617,
-0.02316005900502205,
0.3257416784763336,
-0.6631712913513184,
0.7868359088897705,
-0.20182539522647858,
-0.45029133558273315,
-0.3719348609447479,
-0.38689836859703064,
0.2563099265098572,
-0.2406686693429947,
0.6033033728599548,
-0.49192652106285095,
-0.1723083257675171,
0.3719107210636139,
-0.37210360169410706,
0.9709814786911011,
-0.2554152309894562,
-0.4570692181587219,
0.33554404973983765,
0.17552343010902405,
0.9140328168869019,
-0.027885260060429573,
0.021961169317364693,
0.39162179827690125,
-0.07301637530326843,
-0.6065850257873535,
-0.7279319167137146,
0.6750954985618591,
-0.09685134887695312,
-0.5991573333740234,
-0.47463279962539673,
-0.8734368681907654,
-0.15975673496723175,
0.19574590027332306,
-0.13918137550354004,
0.2917664051055908,
0.06538717448711395,
-0.10586310178041458,
0.6179458498954773,
-0.14341676235198975,
0.7393504977226257,
0.883895218372345,
0.19754166901111603,
0.26367518305778503,
0.6533960700035095,
0.09509258717298508,
-0.002885343274101615,
0.14579305052757263,
0.279095858335495,
-0.33769822120666504,
-0.7417423725128174,
-0.4104728698730469,
0.25208035111427307,
-0.5731149315834045,
-0.14396491646766663,
-0.8285284638404846,
0.20015652477741241,
-0.4981291592121124,
0.18732626736164093,
-0.20557141304016113,
-0.23406316339969635,
-0.1807182878255844,
0.19976921379566193,
0.3802002966403961,
0.6669089198112488,
-0.09999250620603561,
-0.007403898052871227,
-1.1037298440933228,
0.38049861788749695,
0.29903295636177063,
0.3123965859413147,
0.2677614092826843,
-0.5916622281074524,
-0.12095115333795547,
0.03146766498684883,
-0.2585110366344452,
-0.9540063142776489,
0.6236281991004944,
0.22827742993831635,
0.8651061654090881,
0.6313830614089966,
0.13550135493278503,
0.6614397764205933,
-0.3885608911514282,
0.47935500741004944,
0.14672312140464783,
-0.8715822696685791,
0.6667165160179138,
-0.4322510063648224,
0.2903420031070709,
-0.10391092300415039,
0.4350143373012543,
-0.5274949073791504,
-0.6334095597267151,
-0.6569400429725647,
-1.066033124923706,
0.8306726217269897,
0.00590799143537879,
-0.027465056627988815,
-0.23361150920391083,
0.2530554234981537,
0.13709434866905212,
0.2878633141517639,
-0.5289294719696045,
-0.3019416630268097,
0.27232465147972107,
-0.13665498793125153,
0.30569151043891907,
-0.5188624858856201,
-0.015041151084005833,
0.10369794815778732,
0.596763551235199,
0.06005890294909477,
-0.06662978231906891,
0.04521477594971657,
-0.28845131397247314,
0.056917641311883926,
0.10371340066194534,
0.3394359052181244,
0.9039929509162903,
-0.09759870916604996,
0.06444353610277176,
0.25700870156288147,
-0.35059651732444763,
-0.010308794677257538,
-0.041281167417764664,
0.03014344535768032,
0.1707763522863388,
0.39859700202941895,
0.738481879234314,
-0.048800647258758545,
-1.0471047163009644,
0.37857744097709656,
0.23870037496089935,
0.04086623713374138,
-0.42387139797210693,
-0.03426986560225487,
0.05508830398321152,
0.42303046584129333,
0.36245790123939514,
-0.30017518997192383,
0.6149069666862488,
-0.9040197134017944,
0.2894695997238159,
0.43040549755096436,
-0.04456998407840729,
-0.23092323541641235,
0.29675737023353577,
0.08706934005022049,
-0.2967623770236969,
0.5524695515632629,
-0.4564545750617981,
-0.34564152359962463,
0.7920125126838684,
0.7157785892486572,
0.707306444644928,
-0.03670363128185272,
-0.08965404331684113,
-0.09199266880750656,
0.25720804929733276,
-0.10306190699338913,
0.049645304679870605,
-0.06399236619472504,
-0.770801842212677,
-0.5185971260070801,
-0.6754560470581055,
-0.5407267808914185,
0.1428060382604599,
-0.6350493431091309,
0.4663160443305969,
-0.2219470590353012,
-0.09225430339574814,
0.15464088320732117,
-0.15402932465076447,
-0.4652705192565918,
-0.24077630043029785,
0.43778181076049805,
0.40667080879211426,
-1.026673674583435,
0.9965930581092834,
0.6901121139526367,
0.03918236121535301,
-0.23058423399925232,
-0.1219310313463211,
0.22963546216487885,
-0.7762506604194641,
0.9825407862663269,
0.09102004766464233,
-0.07076270878314972,
-0.10884366184473038,
0.07146266847848892,
-0.9359179139137268,
0.7610833644866943,
0.38641998171806335,
-0.602461040019989,
0.09879831224679947,
0.18111488223075867,
0.5617942214012146,
-0.2356785237789154,
-0.025957349687814713,
1.0315049886703491,
0.42546290159225464,
-0.0645977184176445,
-0.4645737111568451,
0.1459673047065735,
0.2698471248149872,
-0.06953421980142593,
0.6064006090164185,
-0.418351948261261,
0.48513850569725037,
-0.20401574671268463,
-0.21394528448581696,
-0.1240411326289177,
0.5809093713760376,
0.3282836079597473,
0.6981596946716309,
0.5114434957504272,
0.5163028240203857,
1.1283835172653198,
-0.00577006209641695,
0.676779568195343,
-0.20987315475940704,
0.18899787962436676,
1.0697046518325806,
-0.5575636029243469,
0.5618077516555786,
0.39970287680625916,
0.06664349883794785,
0.8284759521484375,
0.2634018659591675,
-0.02459147572517395,
0.5011996030807495,
0.3863891661167145,
-0.46166688203811646,
-0.3255215883255005,
-0.06013984978199005,
-0.019032252952456474,
0.7662824988365173,
0.7759497761726379,
0.017147842794656754,
-0.5026947259902954,
-0.06508665531873703,
0.11646982282400131,
0.17120470106601715,
-0.11993733048439026,
0.7785123586654663,
-0.04760647192597389,
-0.4254370927810669,
0.5743710994720459,
-0.04326969012618065,
0.7235606908798218,
-0.7383831143379211,
-0.21509477496147156,
-0.25059130787849426,
0.4263067841529846,
-0.21655049920082092,
-0.40753528475761414,
0.7362654805183411,
0.30059149861335754,
-0.32869216799736023,
-0.2524602711200714,
0.7670609951019287,
-0.24095071852207184,
-0.4037929177284241,
0.6331377625465393,
0.27960020303726196,
0.25946828722953796,
-0.03453454002737999,
-0.4274260997772217,
0.14823220670223236,
-0.27364394068717957,
-0.09963420033454895,
0.3740955889225006,
0.9511580467224121,
-0.2702430784702301,
0.6399686336517334,
0.6425804495811462,
0.198355570435524,
0.16716906428337097,
0.03715524822473526,
0.5285383462905884,
-0.6848797798156738,
-0.6400215029716492,
-1.1018208265304565,
0.26534226536750793,
-0.31624704599380493,
0.0381031334400177,
0.6459252834320068,
0.3443356156349182,
0.6914073824882507,
0.05690022185444832,
0.6142431497573853,
0.12880365550518036,
0.5904756188392639,
-0.4900164008140564,
0.4459613859653473,
-0.32404449582099915,
0.6797827482223511,
-0.07579715549945831,
-0.7324091196060181,
-0.2910849153995514,
0.4188248813152313,
-0.11868526041507721,
-0.3817850947380066,
0.7925601005554199,
0.9677135348320007,
0.03449464589357376,
0.007283452432602644,
0.42266684770584106,
0.42342501878738403,
0.4329074025154114,
0.43071964383125305,
0.7423534989356995,
-0.08409906923770905,
0.6459382176399231,
-0.15808959305286407,
-0.45780083537101746,
-0.3588427007198334,
-1.320218801498413,
-0.8959478735923767,
-0.2682945132255554,
-0.5588205456733704,
-0.2145492434501648,
0.10462214797735214,
0.5926740169525146,
0.6032608151435852,
-1.0010921955108643,
-0.3310134708881378,
-0.2397392839193344,
0.20065200328826904,
-0.27905184030532837,
-0.2171318084001541,
0.11187189817428589,
-0.7150698304176331,
-0.8210938572883606,
0.29822254180908203,
0.46393823623657227,
0.19141504168510437,
-0.12799543142318726,
0.3336789906024933,
-0.33310529589653015,
0.03636457398533821,
0.49052727222442627,
0.18659833073616028,
-0.7794415950775146,
-0.25524553656578064,
-0.21027694642543793,
0.25467777252197266,
-0.2583378851413727,
0.6073430180549622,
-0.5196743607521057,
0.46619123220443726,
0.5710706114768982,
0.768958330154419,
0.7035492062568665,
-0.48809814453125,
0.4352617561817169,
-0.690845787525177,
0.518176257610321,
0.17365896701812744,
0.34702926874160767,
0.278126984834671,
-0.44544851779937744,
0.31962308287620544,
0.46002694964408875,
-0.44187527894973755,
-1.0640240907669067,
0.5526639819145203,
-0.9456740021705627,
-0.32473352551460266,
1.0278435945510864,
-0.3540648818016052,
-0.21319423615932465,
-0.43709421157836914,
0.19926717877388,
0.28745803236961365,
-0.28976625204086304,
1.0891529321670532,
0.8670555949211121,
-0.4984264075756073,
0.6860753893852234,
-0.6482106447219849,
0.2742860019207001,
0.43111440539360046,
-0.7267046570777893,
0.2834310829639435,
0.6468936204910278,
0.3518170416355133,
-0.10274530947208405,
0.35560277104377747,
0.009580900892615318,
0.31899282336235046,
-0.050945885479450226,
-0.08505351841449738,
-0.1208030954003334,
-0.18585079908370972,
-0.4641231894493103,
-0.12884104251861572,
0.13286054134368896,
-0.3039741814136505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15765v1 | Unveiling and Harnessing Hidden Attention Sinks: Enhancing Large Language Models without Training through Attention Calibration | 2024-06-22T07:00:43 | 2024-06-22T07:00:43 | Zhongzhi Yu, Zheng Wang, Yonggan Fu, Huihong Shi, Khalid Shaikh, Yingyan Celine Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Attention is a fundamental component behind the remarkable achievements of
large language models (LLMs). However, our current understanding of the
attention mechanism, especially regarding how attention distributions are
established, remains limited. Inspired by recent studies that explore the
presence of attention sink in the initial token, which receives
disproportionately large attention scores despite their lack of semantic
importance, this work delves deeper into this phenomenon. We aim to provide a
more profound understanding of the existence of attention sinks within LLMs and
to uncover ways to enhance the achievable accuracy of LLMs by directly
optimizing the attention distributions, without the need for weight finetuning.
Specifically, this work begins with comprehensive visualizations of the
attention distributions in LLMs during inference across various inputs and
tasks. Based on these visualizations, to the best of our knowledge, we are the
first to discover that (1) attention sinks occur not only at the start of
sequences but also within later tokens of the input, and (2) not all attention
sinks have a positive impact on the achievable accuracy of LLMs. Building upon
our findings, we propose a training-free Attention Calibration Technique (ACT)
that automatically optimizes the attention distributions on the fly during
inference in an input-adaptive manner. Extensive experiments validate that ACT
consistently enhances the accuracy of various LLMs across different
applications. Specifically, ACT achieves an average improvement of up to 7.30%
in accuracy across different datasets when applied to Llama-30B. Our code is
available at https://github.com/GATECH-EIC/ACT. | [
-0.4784598648548126,
-0.494351863861084,
0.8820871710777283,
0.11819958686828613,
-0.29564785957336426,
0.1683790385723114,
-0.2606239318847656,
-0.11398639529943466,
0.2822451591491699,
0.5948262810707092,
-0.6332387924194336,
-0.3377918303012848,
-0.7917414903640747,
-0.05649906396865845,
-0.3135998249053955,
0.747142493724823,
0.12572726607322693,
-0.03188025951385498,
-0.31753358244895935,
-0.11697454750537872,
-0.3560042679309845,
-0.025878483429551125,
-0.7195831537246704,
-0.2498101145029068,
0.6571276783943176,
0.3004436790943146,
0.3312012255191803,
0.7548516392707825,
0.5278067588806152,
0.2425360232591629,
-0.3087479770183563,
0.28155311942100525,
-0.9017908573150635,
-0.006445353385061026,
-0.1397973746061325,
-0.7827150225639343,
-0.24024493992328644,
-0.2540171444416046,
0.772928774356842,
0.8574074506759644,
0.04797174781560898,
0.3970522880554199,
0.3753054738044739,
0.7858863472938538,
-1.045152187347412,
0.4590799808502197,
-0.49600663781166077,
0.10190648585557938,
-0.3544991910457611,
-0.3341684937477112,
-0.5715963840484619,
-0.16788548231124878,
0.06348750740289688,
-0.43093129992485046,
0.2802879810333252,
-0.035356346517801285,
0.3987234830856323,
0.8294917345046997,
-0.462856650352478,
0.00967802107334137,
-0.547358512878418,
0.8350277543067932,
-0.7018759846687317,
0.4578377902507782,
0.09347568452358246,
0.03147390857338905,
-0.09975507855415344,
-0.5109569430351257,
-0.2621961534023285,
0.007622444536536932,
0.09902367740869522,
0.16013775765895844,
-0.07397649437189102,
0.14547327160835266,
0.3507668077945709,
0.338230162858963,
-0.2780615985393524,
0.001223180559463799,
0.04983758181333542,
0.022456718608736992,
0.3249824047088623,
0.16659095883369446,
0.09886900335550308,
0.3962016701698303,
-0.19154173135757446,
-0.1936817765235901,
-0.918910026550293,
0.047328393906354904,
0.12923243641853333,
0.2880100905895233,
-0.31936219334602356,
0.5446534156799316,
-0.06885980069637299,
0.712415874004364,
0.2251976728439331,
0.1477794349193573,
0.09458328783512115,
0.09770707786083221,
-0.31753912568092346,
0.0312669612467289,
0.6021320223808289,
-0.02860134281218052,
0.4524541199207306,
-0.03092399798333645,
-0.13002431392669678,
-0.12235277146100998,
0.31247392296791077,
-0.6667685508728027,
-0.32750093936920166,
0.15180519223213196,
-0.018227173015475273,
-0.4071101248264313,
-0.22821509838104248,
-0.5778089761734009,
-0.699762761592865,
-0.3726065158843994,
0.23625831305980682,
0.0936204269528389,
-0.3146914541721344,
-0.0005362633382901549,
-0.043934792280197144,
0.17939212918281555,
0.3813347816467285,
-0.9305548071861267,
0.03084658458828926,
0.6966115832328796,
0.6755940914154053,
-0.21499969065189362,
-0.10637370496988297,
-0.7386795282363892,
0.4614962637424469,
-0.591962456703186,
0.8709353804588318,
-0.4313405156135559,
-0.0720825344324112,
0.020616091787815094,
-0.12150885164737701,
-0.1232379749417305,
-0.5100018382072449,
0.3797582685947418,
-0.7431807518005371,
-0.38530433177948,
-0.3992116153240204,
-0.5882602334022522,
-0.23618555068969727,
0.1418418288230896,
-0.7934770584106445,
0.8291528820991516,
-0.1320340633392334,
-0.7742902040481567,
0.16299289464950562,
-0.8372666239738464,
-0.41888782382011414,
-0.04935435578227043,
-0.031980015337467194,
-0.1276731640100479,
0.5450583696365356,
0.47046512365341187,
0.44822269678115845,
-0.23179170489311218,
-0.13893266022205353,
-0.4685328006744385,
-0.45938271284103394,
0.36276066303253174,
-0.5712883472442627,
0.7322452664375305,
-0.09110914170742035,
-0.45802971720695496,
0.015068858861923218,
-0.4305582344532013,
-0.04963899403810501,
0.08745785057544708,
-0.38289108872413635,
-0.16961410641670227,
0.07393249124288559,
-0.15487554669380188,
-0.15980035066604614,
0.08416055887937546,
-0.2610546350479126,
0.025671377778053284,
-0.7292370796203613,
0.3800387382507324,
0.8598843216896057,
0.06838515400886536,
0.5236585140228271,
0.10807107388973236,
0.495507150888443,
0.11144363880157471,
-0.0436067208647728,
-0.25027650594711304,
-0.3808978199958801,
-0.8936418294906616,
-0.4231748878955841,
0.3222540616989136,
0.39427247643470764,
-0.45887526869773865,
0.14302031695842743,
-0.47240397334098816,
-0.2393488734960556,
-0.6515539884567261,
0.33195626735687256,
0.2363218367099762,
0.5474605560302734,
0.14719520509243011,
-0.24971672892570496,
-0.22687049210071564,
-0.7146199941635132,
-0.4536513090133667,
0.0968615859746933,
0.05148869380354881,
0.28944629430770874,
0.12443101406097412,
-0.07669057697057724,
0.8352745771408081,
-0.8147004246711731,
-0.31282249093055725,
-0.34488046169281006,
0.11208558827638626,
0.06443248689174652,
0.15633149445056915,
0.42981356382369995,
-0.4881815016269684,
-0.31056371331214905,
-0.08114025741815567,
-0.5556341409683228,
-0.2478451430797577,
0.07368280738592148,
-0.24058310687541962,
0.06280422955751419,
0.642721951007843,
-0.6674746870994568,
0.31842368841171265,
0.6114806532859802,
-0.10696522146463394,
0.2544907331466675,
0.018036428838968277,
-0.08289280533790588,
-0.7332916259765625,
0.24453210830688477,
-0.11037901043891907,
-0.47615817189216614,
-0.6442654728889465,
0.20314976572990417,
0.2972518801689148,
-0.008355104364454746,
-0.4766652286052704,
0.8158367276191711,
-0.6742850542068481,
-0.10917139053344727,
-0.43863368034362793,
0.30509471893310547,
0.013533876277506351,
0.648354709148407,
-0.13560323417186737,
0.6176654696464539,
0.5197633504867554,
-0.560551643371582,
0.2378310263156891,
0.0928012877702713,
-0.4267372190952301,
0.3172466456890106,
-0.4466511011123657,
0.2247437983751297,
-0.3724368214607239,
0.056431978940963745,
-1.4499638080596924,
-0.2987503409385681,
0.20041590929031372,
-0.3318012058734894,
0.7125743627548218,
-0.27766022086143494,
-0.22187291085720062,
-0.2907668948173523,
-0.37892279028892517,
0.4538654386997223,
0.35636037588119507,
-0.506908655166626,
0.5684399604797363,
0.5663067102432251,
-0.18923017382621765,
-0.8520796895027161,
-0.9569957852363586,
0.10994619131088257,
-0.07938239723443985,
-0.2770242691040039,
-0.06976921111345291,
-0.10420320928096771,
-0.11737661808729172,
-0.05689597129821777,
-0.22794456779956818,
0.03469269350171089,
0.1877121776342392,
0.1607542484998703,
0.12517602741718292,
-0.2269929051399231,
0.15862075984477997,
0.08897262811660767,
-0.05346078798174858,
0.1528814136981964,
-0.2096741795539856,
0.5754687786102295,
0.304734468460083,
-0.37579652667045593,
-0.6945443153381348,
0.03674999251961708,
0.8556427955627441,
-0.47570085525512695,
0.5907953977584839,
0.43530717492103577,
-0.2911183536052704,
-0.37062302231788635,
-0.7390689253807068,
-0.3247804641723633,
-0.49927598237991333,
0.3365156352519989,
-0.13642756640911102,
-0.856717050075531,
0.5614654421806335,
-0.0065315887331962585,
0.1894146353006363,
0.2001774162054062,
0.5453736782073975,
-0.06878320872783661,
1.0448006391525269,
0.693666934967041,
-0.1692156046628952,
0.672028124332428,
-0.1669207215309143,
0.35857850313186646,
-1.0857850313186646,
0.061202287673950195,
-0.3430972695350647,
-0.4801064729690552,
-0.3163876533508301,
-0.6724420189857483,
0.23011581599712372,
-0.23851799964904785,
-0.18668745458126068,
-0.1604698747396469,
-0.3094269633293152,
0.7384139895439148,
0.22038260102272034,
0.017223630100488663,
0.06266780197620392,
0.03323297202587128,
0.025735119357705116,
-0.06019904091954231,
-0.5311436057090759,
-0.2011100798845291,
1.2103965282440186,
0.23419849574565887,
0.9341095685958862,
-0.15673880279064178,
0.63112872838974,
0.3099963665008545,
0.6460529565811157,
-0.9945452809333801,
0.5309578776359558,
-0.061192166060209274,
-0.43595823645591736,
-0.43095701932907104,
-0.5530195236206055,
-0.9164779186248779,
0.19116534292697906,
0.3131110966205597,
-0.523294985294342,
0.16836875677108765,
0.4418204128742218,
-0.5902112126350403,
0.13502053916454315,
-0.8884511590003967,
0.9712732434272766,
-0.0736992284655571,
-0.46969565749168396,
-0.2734922170639038,
-0.4368799328804016,
0.3863069713115692,
-0.11239264160394669,
0.23855020105838776,
-0.2850528359413147,
-0.2995210587978363,
0.4900660216808319,
-0.0931447222828865,
1.0027589797973633,
-0.3294842839241028,
-0.3779595196247101,
0.24207642674446106,
0.13658881187438965,
0.696239709854126,
-0.05446677654981613,
0.19097816944122314,
-0.0843779444694519,
-0.4260803163051605,
-0.36860913038253784,
-0.5239691138267517,
0.9464731216430664,
-0.5788834095001221,
-0.5885047912597656,
-0.09649703651666641,
-0.7869314551353455,
-0.48633983731269836,
0.3035719096660614,
-0.2293298840522766,
0.39429351687431335,
0.017837492749094963,
0.13993854820728302,
1.1023552417755127,
-0.05863948538899422,
0.5470813512802124,
0.29779520630836487,
-0.05972718819975853,
-0.31750109791755676,
0.7082210183143616,
0.10922282934188843,
0.26735854148864746,
0.6863729953765869,
0.06301295757293701,
-0.6210694313049316,
-0.4995880126953125,
-0.4339437782764435,
0.4959860146045685,
-0.8664580583572388,
-0.21986304223537445,
-0.6127920746803284,
0.027918612584471703,
-0.4910992681980133,
0.0313202403485775,
-0.5002445578575134,
-0.2712785005569458,
-0.4669420123100281,
-0.13231031596660614,
0.29297351837158203,
0.6228345036506653,
0.10983391106128693,
0.39698049426078796,
-0.5673913955688477,
0.34999749064445496,
0.4094637930393219,
0.32418036460876465,
0.3295767307281494,
-0.5842812061309814,
-0.2473100870847702,
0.15640351176261902,
-0.17068366706371307,
-0.7071412205696106,
0.36403805017471313,
0.23308537900447845,
0.535026490688324,
0.6544125080108643,
-0.1461075395345688,
0.8120140433311462,
-0.4850656986236572,
0.47457313537597656,
-0.002514421008527279,
-0.9725375771522522,
0.45916542410850525,
-0.2907583713531494,
0.6858599185943604,
0.4395357668399811,
0.016880258917808533,
-0.39540866017341614,
-0.5613227486610413,
-0.3665791451931,
-0.8867137432098389,
0.906677782535553,
-0.09754540026187897,
0.36508601903915405,
0.14670398831367493,
0.31828588247299194,
-0.21771018207073212,
0.3059168756008148,
-0.5705809593200684,
-0.2658173143863678,
0.32102707028388977,
-0.47604337334632874,
-0.34916922450065613,
-0.25355008244514465,
-0.14202018082141876,
-0.02120395563542843,
0.6063247919082642,
-0.24068905413150787,
0.1993560642004013,
-0.012525510974228382,
-0.42381832003593445,
-0.24113360047340393,
-0.1376718133687973,
0.6308120489120483,
0.6648931503295898,
0.02643810212612152,
0.3937511742115021,
0.21963343024253845,
-0.6981006860733032,
0.0020974655635654926,
-0.01595260016620159,
-0.15148311853408813,
-0.14852909743785858,
0.27257272601127625,
0.9216501116752625,
0.6116138696670532,
-0.6585155725479126,
0.5025801062583923,
-0.018165605142712593,
0.17285506427288055,
-0.11644673347473145,
0.1523134708404541,
0.5841303467750549,
0.30588167905807495,
0.3792181611061096,
0.06934938579797745,
0.12287034094333649,
-0.23977258801460266,
-0.02554905228316784,
0.5815756320953369,
-0.37390798330307007,
-0.15056058764457703,
0.74500972032547,
0.18739545345306396,
-0.007587518077343702,
0.44935882091522217,
0.02049235627055168,
-0.2126450389623642,
0.5200972557067871,
0.26078060269355774,
0.9642137289047241,
-0.5075066089630127,
0.06985697150230408,
0.19210150837898254,
0.3485877215862274,
-0.07312725484371185,
0.1109975054860115,
-0.24071583151817322,
-0.5913257598876953,
-0.8130744695663452,
-0.6327991485595703,
-0.37035468220710754,
0.229222372174263,
-0.5254360437393188,
0.2974160611629486,
-0.4079475700855255,
-0.05992862582206726,
0.08074557036161423,
-0.1997123658657074,
-0.7252594232559204,
0.10143592208623886,
0.5439952611923218,
0.67140132188797,
-0.756225049495697,
0.43353551626205444,
0.7026514410972595,
0.07991298288106918,
-0.5992043018341064,
0.20038680732250214,
-0.12220045179128647,
-1.1234031915664673,
0.2665557265281677,
0.3210931420326233,
-0.2796787917613983,
0.520490825176239,
-0.609227180480957,
-1.227949857711792,
0.8295837044715881,
0.8846687078475952,
-0.6225700378417969,
0.10514698177576065,
0.3759906589984894,
0.3938743472099304,
-0.06930854171514511,
0.28382787108421326,
0.46076101064682007,
0.35825783014297485,
0.0673862025141716,
-0.4781561493873596,
0.025414567440748215,
0.03917721286416054,
0.028416268527507782,
0.49625784158706665,
-0.6264799237251282,
0.4757581651210785,
-0.44628962874412537,
-0.22893217206001282,
-0.3629508912563324,
0.4604651629924774,
0.18821880221366882,
0.00207264325581491,
0.4000531733036041,
0.7822332978248596,
0.6067094206809998,
-0.18467757105827332,
0.9865056276321411,
-0.234405055642128,
0.375328928232193,
1.041038990020752,
-0.3425622582435608,
0.8246991038322449,
0.796622097492218,
-0.10455755144357681,
0.12958550453186035,
0.5354134440422058,
0.217462420463562,
0.724923849105835,
0.319534569978714,
-0.2793462872505188,
-0.4062584340572357,
-0.05089466646313667,
0.028942545875906944,
0.27822622656822205,
0.410832017660141,
-0.3344094157218933,
-0.2622554302215576,
0.11296669393777847,
-0.12152781337499619,
-0.34161949157714844,
-0.5052332282066345,
0.682636022567749,
0.16295139491558075,
-0.6670272350311279,
0.7069842219352722,
-0.3889351189136505,
0.28909823298454285,
-0.41417157649993896,
0.06976877897977829,
-0.4541252553462982,
0.44066518545150757,
0.017874877899885178,
-0.8469622731208801,
-0.027703527361154556,
0.06645790487527847,
-0.22925062477588654,
-0.31334230303764343,
0.518988311290741,
-0.4134674072265625,
-0.4462907612323761,
0.16321547329425812,
0.5236770510673523,
0.2228470742702484,
-0.4136143624782562,
-0.3384256958961487,
0.2403998076915741,
0.07990318536758423,
-0.6578369736671448,
0.24740269780158997,
0.44689446687698364,
0.12378662079572678,
0.7519970536231995,
0.4975014925003052,
0.08264482766389847,
0.3420073390007019,
0.30027633905410767,
0.6914641261100769,
-0.37013691663742065,
-0.455523282289505,
-0.9848464727401733,
0.6224958300590515,
0.04120983928442001,
-0.11368858069181442,
0.4381777346134186,
0.5012722611427307,
0.6503587961196899,
-0.38496002554893494,
0.6957594156265259,
0.3112216591835022,
0.4466804265975952,
-0.26208940148353577,
0.8296933174133301,
-0.6737773418426514,
0.02322954498231411,
-0.1242813766002655,
-0.9694380164146423,
-0.5405476093292236,
0.4037092328071594,
-0.41174405813217163,
-0.05760164186358452,
0.5630549788475037,
0.814411461353302,
-0.23850305378437042,
-0.33666279911994934,
0.2513417899608612,
0.3291900157928467,
0.2667299509048462,
0.5962671041488647,
0.811135470867157,
-0.1811164915561676,
0.5825884342193604,
-0.1531824767589569,
-0.19276829063892365,
-0.33556151390075684,
-0.7108445167541504,
-0.8556946516036987,
-0.13252604007720947,
-0.4326108694076538,
0.19694532454013824,
0.015386544167995453,
0.4079621434211731,
0.5580719113349915,
-0.753335177898407,
-0.2151716649532318,
-0.3300493657588959,
0.11096934974193573,
-0.16435223817825317,
-0.2035735547542572,
0.42833617329597473,
-0.4928903877735138,
-0.9527764916419983,
0.37594425678253174,
0.4317207634449005,
0.1541035771369934,
-0.25668278336524963,
0.1618218868970871,
-0.014937332831323147,
0.2678253650665283,
0.5626847147941589,
0.14576935768127441,
-0.6624488830566406,
-0.12738215923309326,
-0.011993801221251488,
-0.11548716574907303,
0.0831567719578743,
0.7008354663848877,
-0.7295226454734802,
0.31827056407928467,
0.5556599497795105,
0.841266393661499,
0.6234226226806641,
-0.17385412752628326,
0.3350134491920471,
-0.8668560981750488,
0.15980647504329681,
0.3142179846763611,
0.3515923321247101,
0.4668780565261841,
-0.2956453859806061,
0.49779948592185974,
0.05058973655104637,
-0.48536500334739685,
-1.187844157218933,
0.02312532812356949,
-0.9363373517990112,
0.04282500967383385,
0.951082706451416,
-0.14957265555858612,
-0.41010621190071106,
0.14501233398914337,
-0.28736770153045654,
0.4968450665473938,
-0.2919948995113373,
0.8776236772537231,
0.7700011134147644,
-0.08642458915710449,
-0.3796737790107727,
-0.7074974775314331,
0.5216228365898132,
0.7050602436065674,
-0.8117930889129639,
0.6358764171600342,
0.3880009651184082,
0.4182044565677643,
0.06757579743862152,
0.3326197862625122,
0.04584948718547821,
0.17405343055725098,
-0.2866846024990082,
0.020838811993598938,
0.16576892137527466,
-0.2924669086933136,
-0.45361438393592834,
0.2047579288482666,
0.13550209999084473,
-0.13426369428634644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15754v1 | Multimodal Segmentation for Vocal Tract Modeling | 2024-06-22T06:44:38 | 2024-06-22T06:44:38 | Rishi Jain, Bohan Yu, Peter Wu, Tejas Prabhune, Gopala Anumanchipalli | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Accurate modeling of the vocal tract is necessary to construct articulatory
representations for interpretable speech processing and linguistics. However,
vocal tract modeling is challenging because many internal articulators are
occluded from external motion capture technologies. Real-time magnetic
resonance imaging (RT-MRI) allows measuring precise movements of internal
articulators during speech, but annotated datasets of MRI are limited in size
due to time-consuming and computationally expensive labeling methods. We first
present a deep labeling strategy for the RT-MRI video using a vision-only
segmentation approach. We then introduce a multimodal algorithm using audio to
improve segmentation of vocal articulators. Together, we set a new benchmark
for vocal tract modeling in MRI video segmentation and use this to release
labels for a 75-speaker RT-MRI dataset, increasing the amount of labeled public
RT-MRI data of the vocal tract by over a factor of 9. The code and dataset
labels can be found at \url{rishiraij.github.io/multimodal-mri-avatar/}. | [
-0.5304632782936096,
-0.5806989073753357,
0.32189837098121643,
-0.054486192762851715,
-0.2630608379840851,
0.18631717562675476,
-0.2204016000032425,
-0.42961037158966064,
0.29965296387672424,
0.4338408410549164,
-0.8724198341369629,
-0.3521624803543091,
-0.49211734533309937,
-0.17381466925144196,
-0.05392346531152725,
0.6646163463592529,
0.30936387181282043,
0.49021974205970764,
-0.14055566489696503,
-0.2658381462097168,
-0.38726806640625,
-0.4686143100261688,
-0.4609662890434265,
-0.27279597520828247,
0.6970369815826416,
0.36248722672462463,
0.4736469089984894,
0.71004319190979,
0.7164474725723267,
0.34140607714653015,
-0.16003207862377167,
0.1285838782787323,
0.03479216620326042,
0.4985697865486145,
0.3453877866268158,
-0.3626393675804138,
-0.5270017981529236,
0.06176217272877693,
1.0841103792190552,
0.6975831389427185,
-0.2654779255390167,
0.13525423407554626,
-0.5536176562309265,
0.397045373916626,
-0.37617170810699463,
-0.05433295667171478,
-0.1665494740009308,
0.19252730906009674,
-0.4582224190235138,
-0.5572206974029541,
-0.21182653307914734,
-0.25607144832611084,
0.07025091350078583,
-0.4914732575416565,
0.06076348200440407,
0.04716259241104126,
0.7334865927696228,
0.45496878027915955,
-0.460306316614151,
-0.05645464360713959,
-1.025801658630371,
0.6386241912841797,
-0.5465019941329956,
0.7491562962532043,
0.1167445033788681,
0.47905439138412476,
0.02499280497431755,
-0.7681446671485901,
-0.35593491792678833,
-0.552708625793457,
0.21929682791233063,
-0.1447148472070694,
-0.16064752638339996,
0.21103820204734802,
0.25291112065315247,
0.26285624504089355,
-0.7632139325141907,
0.05094105750322342,
-0.5767103433609009,
-0.0003511654504109174,
0.4275352656841278,
0.326650470495224,
0.5739410519599915,
-0.06009082496166229,
-0.42415139079093933,
-0.3268868923187256,
-0.2746618390083313,
-0.17865517735481262,
0.35087329149246216,
0.2094564139842987,
-0.11293094605207443,
0.7566635012626648,
0.24111317098140717,
0.5998319387435913,
0.030971216037869453,
-0.5028548240661621,
0.5281159281730652,
-0.298075795173645,
-0.3055124282836914,
0.05369289591908455,
0.8688527941703796,
0.054869767278432846,
-0.0110446373000741,
0.18417727947235107,
-0.07762876898050308,
0.06280354410409927,
0.3773975968360901,
-0.6389951109886169,
-0.14973998069763184,
0.3154686987400055,
-0.5510178804397583,
0.1645703762769699,
-0.13148395717144012,
-0.47882503271102905,
-0.4591643512248993,
-0.7607894539833069,
0.4108768105506897,
-0.5709241032600403,
-0.6614199280738831,
-0.083794966340065,
-0.11874644458293915,
0.07904145121574402,
0.03523539751768112,
-0.6730512976646423,
0.2284356653690338,
0.5392101407051086,
0.9372898936271667,
0.19069772958755493,
-0.3810299336910248,
-0.4559311866760254,
0.12234023213386536,
-0.418454110622406,
0.84385746717453,
-0.6419251561164856,
-0.2430131435394287,
-0.45746326446533203,
0.004463377874344587,
-0.6374619007110596,
-0.6072251796722412,
0.3577699363231659,
-0.3373459577560425,
0.1796940267086029,
0.07543577998876572,
-0.5559475421905518,
-0.3864993751049042,
0.08973340690135956,
-0.7586431503295898,
0.4657335579395294,
-0.04350567236542702,
-0.3338102102279663,
0.20539401471614838,
-1.0116277933120728,
-0.43456733226776123,
-0.12904587388038635,
-0.058945320546627045,
-0.5707417726516724,
0.13885889947414398,
0.11519645154476166,
0.3323940634727478,
-0.12420866638422012,
0.275747150182724,
-0.4477478563785553,
-0.1730068027973175,
0.7243276834487915,
-0.5271456241607666,
0.589451014995575,
0.7263153195381165,
-0.11339500546455383,
0.49687081575393677,
-0.8586301803588867,
0.03877129405736923,
-0.07525839656591415,
0.040555160492658615,
-0.08048740774393082,
-0.21821865439414978,
0.2307754009962082,
0.06286031752824783,
-0.07441220432519913,
-0.5859038829803467,
0.1256750375032425,
-0.07284314185380936,
0.3250570297241211,
0.26555079221725464,
-0.006506398785859346,
0.6128190159797668,
-0.35437437891960144,
0.8129793405532837,
0.07191857695579529,
0.42874541878700256,
-0.11736435443162918,
-0.575415849685669,
-0.690611720085144,
-0.7119925618171692,
0.3684883415699005,
0.35479772090911865,
-0.3174026608467102,
0.12267844378948212,
-0.2247767150402069,
-0.5571136474609375,
-0.7853347063064575,
-0.3372341990470886,
0.18633247911930084,
0.216633602976799,
0.272603839635849,
-0.3109215497970581,
-0.6053658127784729,
-0.9032368659973145,
0.03002919629216194,
-0.0017365081002935767,
-0.04796096682548523,
0.2527628242969513,
0.2625240981578827,
-0.11561974883079529,
0.6474977135658264,
-0.5189858078956604,
-0.8028767108917236,
-0.2269449681043625,
0.39281579852104187,
0.010067139752209187,
0.596735417842865,
0.3103642761707306,
-0.6990049481391907,
-0.31804367899894714,
0.1034788265824318,
-0.6974557042121887,
0.12548545002937317,
-0.156162291765213,
0.1351170539855957,
-0.05373745411634445,
0.39795345067977905,
-0.9279940128326416,
0.1746126115322113,
0.4962565302848816,
-0.038509104400873184,
0.07931840419769287,
-0.26933249831199646,
0.5154018998146057,
-0.7661019563674927,
0.2506444454193115,
0.24657213687896729,
0.14068879187107086,
-0.8254592418670654,
-0.017939811572432518,
0.07393085956573486,
-0.5182667970657349,
-0.44722095131874084,
0.11420367658138275,
-0.7254054546356201,
-0.3086232841014862,
-0.19274407625198364,
-0.026616187766194344,
0.14552953839302063,
0.5119115114212036,
0.14411680400371552,
0.5566169023513794,
0.5438583493232727,
-0.3326232433319092,
0.4935367703437805,
0.07611697912216187,
-0.5031155347824097,
0.6525790095329285,
-0.4379161596298218,
0.12950365245342255,
-0.27444785833358765,
0.4380449950695038,
-0.9686092138290405,
-0.2752075493335724,
0.6196578741073608,
-0.6327874064445496,
0.8205534815788269,
-0.4553559422492981,
0.036530863493680954,
-0.02931967005133629,
0.0344138965010643,
0.6110152006149292,
0.24802608788013458,
-0.25283607840538025,
0.8953790664672852,
0.7390081882476807,
-0.1849885731935501,
-0.3512861728668213,
-0.47687995433807373,
0.20052865147590637,
-0.44101208448410034,
-0.7002211809158325,
0.18470486998558044,
0.10109040141105652,
-0.23595158755779266,
-0.06164098531007767,
0.22962811589241028,
-0.2529393136501312,
-0.13065628707408905,
0.40668508410453796,
0.06858410686254501,
-0.30057668685913086,
0.2271244078874588,
-0.03277895972132683,
-0.24113117158412933,
0.04952673614025116,
-0.08398827910423279,
0.3230634927749634,
0.057816192507743835,
-0.6592249870300293,
-1.0122181177139282,
0.6930098533630371,
0.8344648480415344,
-0.5886634588241577,
0.4020724892616272,
1.1569429636001587,
-0.5264379978179932,
0.17948365211486816,
-0.644542396068573,
-0.23982053995132446,
-0.3581644296646118,
0.41053539514541626,
-0.4680972099304199,
-0.489747017621994,
0.2017555683851242,
0.039979416877031326,
-0.36408066749572754,
0.08843635022640228,
0.38955754041671753,
-0.32160425186157227,
1.3551753759384155,
0.11259665340185165,
0.15554377436637878,
0.5583743453025818,
-0.4650896191596985,
0.2458384484052658,
-1.2240574359893799,
-0.6125678420066833,
-0.7005475163459778,
-0.30243179202079773,
-0.31298258900642395,
-0.7376231551170349,
0.387166291475296,
-0.4441804885864258,
0.05100186541676521,
-0.18350210785865784,
-0.6316495537757874,
0.13477355241775513,
0.5794755220413208,
0.047906894236803055,
-0.0654493048787117,
0.2499263733625412,
-0.029807986691594124,
-0.32448020577430725,
-0.4846824109554291,
-0.3050498068332672,
0.7552018761634827,
0.6631770133972168,
0.9962226748466492,
-0.057159174233675,
0.158152237534523,
0.2834417223930359,
0.2633308172225952,
-0.952189028263092,
0.4646035432815552,
-0.14714297652244568,
-0.7137160897254944,
-0.23649798333644867,
-0.23460006713867188,
-0.7467288374900818,
0.4759371876716614,
-0.16854901611804962,
-0.4261038601398468,
0.34583398699760437,
0.1785387098789215,
-0.3807583451271057,
0.33678650856018066,
-0.750309944152832,
0.6142386198043823,
-0.35969650745391846,
0.04097946733236313,
-0.18710707128047943,
-0.7554857730865479,
0.23438891768455505,
0.3253334164619446,
0.3389858603477478,
-0.37957116961479187,
0.08157113194465637,
0.7749091982841492,
-0.3556893765926361,
0.8221701383590698,
-0.5486912131309509,
0.04459666460752487,
0.3670070767402649,
-0.14961744844913483,
0.08318077772855759,
-0.3809022009372711,
0.3856923580169678,
0.2951355576515198,
0.02982565574347973,
0.1388733834028244,
-0.4305056631565094,
0.7788052558898926,
-0.7231312394142151,
-0.28925615549087524,
-0.5199280977249146,
-0.41048571467399597,
-0.2591111958026886,
-0.4089030623435974,
0.05324329435825348,
0.7330650687217712,
0.0007037186878733337,
0.4170392155647278,
0.5348067879676819,
0.03227139636874199,
0.2914912700653076,
0.28614675998687744,
0.14793014526367188,
-0.8213493824005127,
1.144345998764038,
0.2880329489707947,
-0.07087843865156174,
0.49721774458885193,
0.13735394179821014,
-0.7216689586639404,
-0.6553468704223633,
-0.5150545835494995,
0.5651128888130188,
-0.6006557941436768,
-0.10679417103528976,
-0.7356604337692261,
-0.07354972511529922,
-0.454464316368103,
0.5117425322532654,
-0.6419364213943481,
-0.519416332244873,
-0.5640845894813538,
0.20457151532173157,
0.12016920745372772,
0.8086398839950562,
-0.3109420835971832,
0.2640041708946228,
-0.9069767594337463,
0.4163954257965088,
0.29718732833862305,
0.3547890782356262,
0.021193860098719597,
-0.29865479469299316,
-0.37482500076293945,
0.23601166903972626,
-0.21301399171352386,
-0.574113667011261,
0.4874614179134369,
0.4024069607257843,
0.5186551809310913,
0.2653922140598297,
-0.2834583520889282,
1.1582871675491333,
-0.37163275480270386,
0.808619499206543,
0.2807469367980957,
-0.8412082195281982,
0.5185472369194031,
-0.1761861890554428,
0.43333518505096436,
0.19398413598537445,
0.27522823214530945,
-0.7008592486381531,
-0.3466276228427887,
-0.18632416427135468,
-0.746981143951416,
0.7347769141197205,
0.1078927293419838,
-0.20631949603557587,
0.03834488242864609,
0.03163418546319008,
0.05456690117716789,
-0.019923439249396324,
-0.3891645073890686,
-0.2581867277622223,
-0.2607118785381317,
-0.17722082138061523,
-0.2573798596858978,
-0.13437631726264954,
-0.3558574914932251,
-0.2697056531906128,
0.6000392436981201,
-0.18716561794281006,
0.5617809295654297,
0.1513640433549881,
-0.12864071130752563,
-0.3629108965396881,
0.36122381687164307,
1.234397053718567,
0.5198342204093933,
-0.28331258893013,
0.021986903622746468,
-0.2217479944229126,
-0.5473747849464417,
0.4462008774280548,
0.07000651210546494,
0.32342252135276794,
0.23221613466739655,
0.29833364486694336,
1.1452618837356567,
-0.0660933181643486,
-0.44683435559272766,
0.5356364846229553,
-0.4074031412601471,
-0.4381631016731262,
-0.544672966003418,
-0.10231208056211472,
0.13436545431613922,
0.49577972292900085,
0.521522581577301,
0.4172620475292206,
0.18991273641586304,
-0.1545032560825348,
-0.019722972065210342,
0.5779125690460205,
-0.6360313892364502,
-0.3200863003730774,
0.9011505842208862,
0.018230386078357697,
-0.27351921796798706,
0.6262144446372986,
0.5560114979743958,
-0.17463214695453644,
0.6368791460990906,
0.2545675039291382,
1.0734615325927734,
-0.5733429193496704,
0.12776073813438416,
0.22476157546043396,
0.1359594762325287,
0.20547355711460114,
0.10746331512928009,
-0.14458996057510376,
-0.29443952441215515,
-0.5655515193939209,
-0.2894383370876312,
-0.4563919007778168,
0.22522982954978943,
-0.7367989420890808,
-0.0701383650302887,
-0.1626216620206833,
-0.735524594783783,
0.13812851905822754,
-0.29659730195999146,
-0.3780786991119385,
0.6298776865005493,
0.46579623222351074,
0.39546826481819153,
-0.7106872797012329,
0.9393868446350098,
0.7073633670806885,
-0.08761926740407944,
-0.6948168873786926,
-0.23356807231903076,
-0.051388174295425415,
-0.4446350634098053,
0.584486186504364,
0.041932493448257446,
-0.39446401596069336,
-0.3124046325683594,
-0.3094448447227478,
-0.9091613292694092,
0.8353883028030396,
0.2728039026260376,
-0.6252360343933105,
0.14926111698150635,
0.19191773235797882,
0.5933099389076233,
-0.6572925448417664,
0.4658104479312897,
0.20173659920692444,
0.48609310388565063,
0.2674984931945801,
-0.8365959525108337,
-0.35579216480255127,
-0.2849240303039551,
0.13751010596752167,
0.34800243377685547,
-0.4236801862716675,
0.8172386884689331,
-0.3818768858909607,
-0.26947498321533203,
0.13513998687267303,
0.4811437427997589,
0.22661693394184113,
0.418386846780777,
0.7915886044502258,
0.5367487072944641,
0.6299161911010742,
-0.18902352452278137,
0.6894554495811462,
-0.13902805745601654,
0.31020089983940125,
0.9541606903076172,
-0.18441590666770935,
0.756518542766571,
0.5787889361381531,
0.16656552255153656,
0.18467693030834198,
0.6734910607337952,
0.019687704741954803,
0.4347080588340759,
0.1366211175918579,
-0.2972102761268616,
-0.41468772292137146,
-0.4102291166782379,
-0.6783771514892578,
0.7904652953147888,
0.626609742641449,
-0.4059469401836395,
0.32308536767959595,
0.5866550803184509,
-0.14165396988391876,
-0.3318697512149811,
-0.03655124455690384,
0.9628755450248718,
-0.01903836615383625,
-0.6716494560241699,
0.7162469029426575,
-0.39850661158561707,
0.19108451902866364,
-0.6625850200653076,
-0.1706649661064148,
-0.028388740494847298,
0.11869391053915024,
-0.20414221286773682,
-0.5490603446960449,
0.1860918551683426,
-0.3531629145145416,
0.1459553986787796,
-0.2915767729282379,
0.5742880702018738,
-0.6904200911521912,
-0.11490704864263535,
0.2459239512681961,
0.3457348346710205,
0.17879877984523773,
0.09722918272018433,
-0.44815272092819214,
0.4503254294395447,
0.014794417656958103,
-0.3471623957157135,
0.3267606496810913,
0.09521513432264328,
0.13636353611946106,
1.0121911764144897,
0.6437910795211792,
0.2307908833026886,
0.24312658607959747,
0.515373945236206,
0.7871536016464233,
-0.7197546362876892,
-0.36607179045677185,
-0.40005990862846375,
0.727853536605835,
0.0027787243016064167,
-0.062745101749897,
0.4614560008049011,
0.6139225363731384,
0.42232581973075867,
-0.3040674328804016,
0.536943256855011,
0.09626701474189758,
0.8416486978530884,
-0.5226127505302429,
0.7046197056770325,
-0.9375640153884888,
0.028715739026665688,
-0.01091675367206335,
-0.8646274209022522,
-0.5962774753570557,
0.6266291737556458,
0.0647694393992424,
0.1644877940416336,
0.7930212616920471,
0.8900842666625977,
-0.07570631802082062,
0.11521442234516144,
0.43254783749580383,
-0.03826253488659859,
0.24332520365715027,
0.19401058554649353,
1.1940640211105347,
-0.24415789544582367,
0.697327733039856,
-0.5354625582695007,
0.01344170980155468,
-0.3365131616592407,
-0.5650035738945007,
-0.6772801280021667,
-0.7912608981132507,
-0.663598358631134,
-0.09949298202991486,
-0.1780092567205429,
0.9189761877059937,
1.1392676830291748,
-0.437235563993454,
-0.520228385925293,
0.6017331480979919,
0.05412410944700241,
-0.3510807752609253,
-0.19937880337238312,
0.17281599342823029,
-0.14726650714874268,
-0.8940319418907166,
0.7782512903213501,
0.4435202181339264,
0.25068697333335876,
-0.42117437720298767,
-0.023076513782143593,
-0.1645439863204956,
-0.32302212715148926,
0.365872859954834,
0.2197059988975525,
-0.8100902438163757,
-0.15743644535541534,
-0.03249349817633629,
-0.024745222181081772,
0.39699506759643555,
1.110469102859497,
-0.4581794738769531,
0.6578943729400635,
0.45758479833602905,
0.005345824174582958,
0.6701138019561768,
0.03781086206436157,
0.40439286828041077,
-0.5288664698600769,
-0.06998128443956375,
0.48036858439445496,
0.24220791459083557,
0.5183834433555603,
-0.13991695642471313,
0.1790788471698761,
0.0988239198923111,
-0.6283901333808899,
-0.8827897310256958,
-0.01196342334151268,
-1.2381746768951416,
-0.11106331646442413,
0.9584080576896667,
0.026110099628567696,
-0.4170459806919098,
-0.19975896179676056,
-0.4358287751674652,
0.20972570776939392,
-0.4318816363811493,
0.19528737664222717,
0.19191038608551025,
-0.35217171907424927,
-0.700532853603363,
-0.29803702235221863,
0.43606969714164734,
0.11206884682178497,
-0.5839993357658386,
-0.3125770092010498,
0.6266108155250549,
0.4255704879760742,
0.25945207476615906,
0.5633836984634399,
-0.08903519809246063,
0.22648178040981293,
0.07634494453668594,
0.1295858919620514,
-0.266286700963974,
-0.6102508902549744,
-0.5772095322608948,
0.6084014773368835,
0.08092252910137177,
-0.897183358669281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15752v1 | TacoLM: GaTed Attention Equipped Codec Language Model are Efficient Zero-Shot Text to Speech Synthesizers | 2024-06-22T06:39:52 | 2024-06-22T06:39:52 | Yakun Song, Zhuo Chen, Xiaofei Wang, Ziyang Ma, Guanrou Yang, Xie Chen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural codec language model (LM) has demonstrated strong capability in
zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) synthesis. However, the codec LM often suffers
from limitations in inference speed and stability, due to its auto-regressive
nature and implicit alignment between text and audio. In this work, to handle
these challenges, we introduce a new variant of neural codec LM, namely TacoLM.
Specifically, TacoLM introduces a gated attention mechanism to improve the
training and inference efficiency and reduce the model size. Meanwhile, an
additional gated cross-attention layer is included for each decoder layer,
which improves the efficiency and content accuracy of the synthesized speech.
In the evaluation of the Librispeech corpus, the proposed TacoLM achieves a
better word error rate, speaker similarity, and mean opinion score, with 90%
fewer parameters and 5.2 times speed up, compared with VALL-E. Demo and code is
available at https://ereboas.github.io/TacoLM/. | [
-0.5235081315040588,
-0.7610265612602234,
0.32567110657691956,
0.325837105512619,
-0.3869225084781647,
0.24286425113677979,
-0.28716111183166504,
-0.2304103821516037,
0.19203341007232666,
0.5122386813163757,
-0.3257269263267517,
-0.9691212177276611,
-0.40601879358291626,
-0.018672650679945946,
-0.3858415186405182,
1.0356987714767456,
0.010166908614337444,
0.09411543607711792,
0.16487851738929749,
-0.2719053626060486,
-0.42135050892829895,
-0.36538034677505493,
-0.8971112370491028,
-0.2644529938697815,
0.7356212139129639,
-0.006463408004492521,
0.4789508283138275,
0.7768868207931519,
0.12848031520843506,
0.16650152206420898,
-0.42873358726501465,
0.14991362392902374,
-0.2079252302646637,
0.25301316380500793,
-0.19962449371814728,
-0.20628629624843597,
-0.7539792060852051,
-0.25925078988075256,
0.8022825717926025,
0.3508222699165344,
0.0470806360244751,
0.18250006437301636,
0.018104564398527145,
0.4663420021533966,
-0.7898963093757629,
0.09818996489048004,
-0.6442645192146301,
0.3582760989665985,
0.085098035633564,
-0.2313903123140335,
-0.5585781335830688,
-0.2482430636882782,
-0.05104092136025429,
-0.18109270930290222,
0.2314419448375702,
-0.10931161791086197,
0.2792789041996002,
0.500880777835846,
-0.1864320933818817,
0.23669171333312988,
-0.7509713172912598,
0.5353465676307678,
-0.7325873970985413,
0.7811610698699951,
-0.06042557954788208,
0.2247450351715088,
-0.056755222380161285,
-0.9649477601051331,
-0.5499185919761658,
-0.07871152460575104,
0.396485835313797,
0.08025337755680084,
-0.03737794607877731,
0.5968224406242371,
0.2134045660495758,
0.16234245896339417,
-0.5651661157608032,
-0.13873735070228577,
-0.019785262644290924,
-0.39913687109947205,
0.14151526987552643,
0.23197144269943237,
0.3613494634628296,
0.05544038861989975,
-0.5359455347061157,
0.02708594873547554,
-0.6130887866020203,
-0.14666378498077393,
0.09973926097154617,
0.3097708225250244,
-0.13011610507965088,
0.29567334055900574,
-0.16015200316905975,
1.0529568195343018,
0.008907752111554146,
0.034186992794275284,
0.20579680800437927,
-0.36952006816864014,
-0.3773112893104553,
0.49868935346603394,
0.8707037568092346,
0.2996474802494049,
0.10573619604110718,
-0.2035747915506363,
-0.1932286024093628,
-0.030558709055185318,
0.31139692664146423,
-0.9485212564468384,
0.13597168028354645,
0.3875289857387543,
-0.26604488492012024,
-0.3373263478279114,
-0.2149883359670639,
-0.7207793593406677,
0.12770193815231323,
0.09634421020746231,
0.4030032455921173,
-0.3445397615432739,
0.03177666664123535,
0.1384437531232834,
0.17355772852897644,
0.05241694673895836,
0.15249693393707275,
-0.6945348978042603,
0.3745458722114563,
0.501838743686676,
1.2590748071670532,
-0.49771517515182495,
-0.10124360024929047,
-0.9988152980804443,
0.17386461794376373,
-0.6242982745170593,
0.4750390946865082,
-0.3563937246799469,
-0.3024252951145172,
-0.15673762559890747,
-0.10966107994318008,
0.037871815264225006,
-0.22716805338859558,
0.575654923915863,
-0.5891292691230774,
0.12253115326166153,
0.07721737772226334,
-0.3409970700740814,
-0.16438743472099304,
0.09044154733419418,
-0.6198651194572449,
0.8260225653648376,
0.1790096014738083,
-0.8156867027282715,
0.06596280634403229,
-0.7149240374565125,
-0.43251970410346985,
0.002491374034434557,
-0.026812603697180748,
-0.5964414477348328,
-0.031758423894643784,
0.3173023760318756,
0.30490627884864807,
-0.22142545878887177,
0.3330652713775635,
-0.24461475014686584,
-0.5609025359153748,
0.4927794933319092,
-0.4473106563091278,
0.7904340028762817,
0.6675499081611633,
-0.4702281653881073,
0.22495976090431213,
-0.5515480637550354,
0.4581437408924103,
-0.28577515482902527,
-0.31547027826309204,
0.16815799474716187,
-0.3132576644420624,
0.4046664834022522,
0.19514615833759308,
-0.03878430649638176,
-0.5162517428398132,
-0.12411139905452728,
-0.7097794413566589,
0.6587868332862854,
0.4121171534061432,
0.3566892147064209,
0.5959781408309937,
-0.145486518740654,
0.6872698664665222,
0.0053124395199120045,
-0.06883517652750015,
-0.21631097793579102,
-0.24849696457386017,
-0.7885891199111938,
-0.4653889834880829,
0.8028677701950073,
0.2890332341194153,
-0.70216304063797,
0.3440342843532562,
-0.04782971739768982,
-0.21556104719638824,
-0.8454885482788086,
-0.17503972351551056,
0.6441826820373535,
0.49561765789985657,
0.22791831195354462,
-0.5307018756866455,
-0.5497508645057678,
-0.7208888530731201,
-0.3520345687866211,
-0.08403840661048889,
-0.03995718061923981,
0.1983974277973175,
0.03187812864780426,
0.032711539417505264,
0.8432857990264893,
-0.11199268698692322,
-0.2311052531003952,
-0.3329037129878998,
0.02345379628241062,
-0.05806712806224823,
0.3987497091293335,
0.6008617877960205,
-0.3092803657054901,
-0.4513162076473236,
0.10729438811540604,
-0.2612839937210083,
-0.48695889115333557,
-0.0762467086315155,
-0.050998933613300323,
0.42306455969810486,
0.47461602091789246,
-0.6160346865653992,
0.4797060191631317,
0.15960578620433807,
-0.0724201574921608,
0.14825037121772766,
0.033710651099681854,
0.34502729773521423,
-1.1643238067626953,
0.13218854367733002,
-0.19669489562511444,
-0.5299826264381409,
-0.8337610363960266,
0.027613017708063126,
0.17268668115139008,
-0.3439280688762665,
-0.9093930125236511,
0.5421404838562012,
-0.5205581784248352,
-0.3027275502681732,
-0.41136425733566284,
0.17453552782535553,
0.09535089135169983,
0.6914465427398682,
0.13483738899230957,
1.0302892923355103,
0.35794660449028015,
-0.5485352873802185,
0.3573739528656006,
0.03040645830333233,
-0.3436463475227356,
0.13744312524795532,
-0.777775228023529,
0.5238690972328186,
0.032588839530944824,
0.15600965917110443,
-0.8898769617080688,
0.01515998225659132,
0.2356823980808258,
-0.7062956094741821,
0.49454694986343384,
0.060842692852020264,
-0.2602681815624237,
-0.007340710610151291,
-0.3688208758831024,
0.6634909510612488,
0.48522937297821045,
-0.48190566897392273,
0.4955379366874695,
0.2884596884250641,
-0.24235236644744873,
-0.6618703007698059,
-0.9584221839904785,
0.24697814881801605,
-0.0017548055620864034,
-0.2331625521183014,
0.4108114540576935,
0.033061325550079346,
0.06007913872599602,
0.05720603093504906,
-0.06452132016420364,
0.05728822946548462,
-0.14987501502037048,
0.021389443427324295,
-0.008731026202440262,
-0.1780703365802765,
0.3529132306575775,
0.17027609050273895,
-0.16636629402637482,
0.031245475634932518,
-0.7284443378448486,
0.6139095425605774,
-0.02246609516441822,
-0.11624530702829361,
-0.5147982835769653,
0.40164831280708313,
0.5985468626022339,
-0.5289328098297119,
0.5123400092124939,
0.6399596929550171,
-0.36650341749191284,
-0.6471230387687683,
-0.38717108964920044,
-0.14152857661247253,
-0.3867628574371338,
0.7260717153549194,
-0.20093780755996704,
-1.0176342725753784,
0.4155062139034271,
0.2574103772640228,
-0.33862853050231934,
0.05012473464012146,
0.8141297101974487,
0.32497355341911316,
0.86220782995224,
0.2924771308898926,
-0.2379520833492279,
0.62396240234375,
0.01438477449119091,
0.140462264418602,
-0.8956210017204285,
-0.2537052631378174,
-0.5921303033828735,
-0.3002728521823883,
-0.5297801494598389,
-0.5400965809822083,
0.43981263041496277,
-0.31291258335113525,
-0.30270254611968994,
0.2576274573802948,
-0.8857077360153198,
0.3781245946884155,
0.3198971450328827,
0.25217926502227783,
0.21489469707012177,
0.22178177535533905,
-0.30291080474853516,
-0.105490542948246,
-0.8926737904548645,
-0.27202650904655457,
1.0867353677749634,
0.371988981962204,
0.8090012669563293,
-0.16309495270252228,
0.6011503338813782,
0.2711392343044281,
-0.022472338750958443,
-0.8881674408912659,
0.5689480900764465,
0.1051018089056015,
-0.6042066216468811,
-0.013539246283471584,
-0.5038862228393555,
-0.49053698778152466,
-0.044478483498096466,
-0.0409533865749836,
-0.7899714708328247,
-0.020025961101055145,
-0.07725414633750916,
-0.47727736830711365,
0.28939634561538696,
-0.7430610656738281,
0.8506914973258972,
-0.09799528867006302,
-0.8606133460998535,
-0.12082410603761673,
-0.6690129637718201,
0.11402042955160141,
0.07109088450670242,
-0.2794027626514435,
0.1460576206445694,
-0.30122992396354675,
0.6131306886672974,
-0.437335729598999,
0.6311731934547424,
-0.03281917795538902,
0.02208390086889267,
0.6825409531593323,
0.11502543836832047,
0.3600861430168152,
0.1372707039117813,
-0.07537264376878738,
0.05284268409013748,
-0.15941952168941498,
-0.19252176582813263,
-0.7502893805503845,
1.012475848197937,
-0.5556065440177917,
-0.615690290927887,
-0.26612937450408936,
-0.7336762547492981,
-0.20474623143672943,
0.22304168343544006,
0.14426034688949585,
0.45816516876220703,
-0.3377591371536255,
0.25762760639190674,
0.9222004413604736,
-0.3244099020957947,
0.780702531337738,
0.3775612413883209,
-0.3708880841732025,
-0.7906904220581055,
0.6548631191253662,
0.11418446153402328,
0.43860697746276855,
0.6888949275016785,
-0.2494223713874817,
-0.3928506374359131,
-0.6092457175254822,
-0.5160268545150757,
-0.029154615476727486,
-0.38324546813964844,
-0.42492151260375977,
-0.9357038736343384,
-0.5273981094360352,
-0.40773582458496094,
0.12535661458969116,
-0.5760868787765503,
-0.5318368077278137,
-0.2358292192220688,
-0.28587841987609863,
0.5925585031509399,
0.2836631238460541,
0.13871121406555176,
0.32812413573265076,
-0.6639108061790466,
0.3969384729862213,
0.17232626676559448,
0.5210281014442444,
0.0019862770568579435,
-0.6376941204071045,
-0.3540582060813904,
-0.0851140022277832,
-0.20806097984313965,
-0.9686046838760376,
0.5141289830207825,
0.1763366460800171,
0.18580873310565948,
0.13360939919948578,
0.03152143582701683,
0.260303258895874,
-0.34210434556007385,
0.5307866930961609,
0.1869126856327057,
-1.0863451957702637,
0.34561020135879517,
-0.3608038127422333,
0.7491008639335632,
0.25665605068206787,
-0.032476168125867844,
-0.573738694190979,
-0.4358508288860321,
-0.2755075991153717,
-0.4613780975341797,
0.7726230621337891,
0.41640928387641907,
-0.10280585289001465,
-0.14948569238185883,
0.37879419326782227,
-0.06907306611537933,
0.33261334896087646,
-0.6496843099594116,
-0.20360144972801208,
-0.22628121078014374,
-0.5199645161628723,
0.09668032079935074,
-0.3378760814666748,
0.2072220742702484,
-0.09344199299812317,
0.6881992816925049,
0.00696038082242012,
0.529961109161377,
0.4621202349662781,
0.12642614543437958,
-0.06969039887189865,
0.5375756621360779,
0.6354217529296875,
0.07956638187170029,
-0.22930321097373962,
0.41972142457962036,
0.3730786144733429,
-0.43856096267700195,
0.40982726216316223,
0.020261412486433983,
-0.45049214363098145,
0.2674097418785095,
0.05071881040930748,
1.039246678352356,
0.0835285633802414,
-0.3757142722606659,
0.40178489685058594,
-0.09896355122327805,
-0.19802355766296387,
-0.02062360569834709,
0.17754104733467102,
0.37856829166412354,
0.20260946452617645,
-0.03629058972001076,
0.025510815903544426,
0.21344424784183502,
-0.2671974003314972,
0.3286686837673187,
0.4013173282146454,
-0.7082916498184204,
-0.13349394500255585,
1.085006833076477,
0.3194788992404938,
-0.6528371572494507,
0.23214395344257355,
-0.09373260289430618,
-0.4744374752044678,
0.5417224168777466,
0.4936829209327698,
1.2846136093139648,
-0.4721435606479645,
0.1413200944662094,
0.26285484433174133,
0.3550627827644348,
0.24138964712619781,
0.29961681365966797,
-0.3394216299057007,
-0.5351524949073792,
-0.5737560391426086,
-0.5738577842712402,
-0.08926429599523544,
0.19473713636398315,
-0.38084572553634644,
0.2760593593120575,
-0.754896879196167,
-0.47479504346847534,
-0.20945920050144196,
-0.16097702085971832,
-0.3807631731033325,
0.43844667077064514,
-0.10113177448511124,
0.6718193292617798,
-0.39444267749786377,
1.1149262189865112,
0.46774527430534363,
-0.20440104603767395,
-0.7426568865776062,
-0.11906164884567261,
-0.3559311628341675,
-0.47737985849380493,
0.29692795872688293,
-0.015368049032986164,
-0.4664228558540344,
0.17988623678684235,
-0.36708739399909973,
-0.3976415991783142,
0.8152810335159302,
0.5969022512435913,
-0.7457731366157532,
0.1379600614309311,
0.35915008187294006,
0.7351601123809814,
-0.7046358585357666,
0.5228978991508484,
0.4271020293235779,
0.11855439841747284,
-0.1619698405265808,
-0.7179749011993408,
0.06291206181049347,
-0.13450761139392853,
0.45550164580345154,
0.2549940049648285,
-0.8247300982475281,
0.5152212381362915,
-0.3335823714733124,
-0.2291264533996582,
0.02169591188430786,
0.7062122821807861,
-0.03905666247010231,
0.31973937153816223,
0.22820912301540375,
0.5948981046676636,
0.19179119169712067,
-0.10123495012521744,
0.7566289901733398,
-0.4391281008720398,
0.3173985779285431,
1.2642179727554321,
-0.21191751956939697,
0.5724231600761414,
0.6623579859733582,
-0.052456796169281006,
0.09999094903469086,
0.5899099707603455,
0.34575432538986206,
0.6804059147834778,
0.061475612223148346,
-0.7020856142044067,
-0.2429390400648117,
-0.4799189269542694,
-0.47772830724716187,
0.42987924814224243,
0.12086833268404007,
-0.6727970838546753,
-0.03737247362732887,
-0.08263910561800003,
-0.2616789937019348,
0.14720922708511353,
-0.33784887194633484,
0.7917217016220093,
0.23720835149288177,
-0.4709596633911133,
0.8514890074729919,
0.05311490222811699,
0.23016197979450226,
-0.3184608817100525,
-0.07601615786552429,
-0.24355603754520416,
0.08385574072599411,
-0.14407691359519958,
-0.5571995973587036,
0.13961896300315857,
0.17345194518566132,
-0.26291513442993164,
-0.056464359164237976,
0.872998058795929,
-0.7830691337585449,
-0.2570735216140747,
0.42809227108955383,
0.3514108955860138,
0.0833335593342781,
-0.07278668135404587,
-0.4961950182914734,
0.287363201379776,
0.19469651579856873,
-0.2500511407852173,
0.21625873446464539,
0.4485923945903778,
0.03930854797363281,
0.5942586660385132,
0.2731528580188751,
0.23518913984298706,
-0.038670334964990616,
0.3531889319419861,
0.657332718372345,
-0.7378082871437073,
-0.5077150464057922,
-0.8149341344833374,
0.21469195187091827,
0.08465763926506042,
-0.1238907128572464,
0.3933107852935791,
0.5272926092147827,
0.6774740219116211,
-0.3500121235847473,
0.8156667947769165,
0.29362091422080994,
0.49202579259872437,
-0.6011828184127808,
0.9736974239349365,
-0.3364901840686798,
0.1579083651304245,
-0.26514357328414917,
-1.1264054775238037,
-0.2513376474380493,
0.3920719027519226,
0.0359320305287838,
0.3585365414619446,
0.9362176060676575,
1.0399422645568848,
0.16163989901542664,
-0.047879237681627274,
0.6341172456741333,
0.2753729820251465,
0.038611847907304764,
0.9801417589187622,
0.5806077718734741,
-0.6368800401687622,
0.60435551404953,
-0.11236896365880966,
0.09447894245386124,
-0.04842524975538254,
-0.7970938086509705,
-0.9887185096740723,
-0.34764963388442993,
-0.3910909593105316,
-0.33347731828689575,
0.41421836614608765,
0.878746747970581,
0.5636657476425171,
-0.7857609987258911,
-0.03531365841627121,
-0.3581922948360443,
0.26397353410720825,
-0.017398349940776825,
-0.27907100319862366,
0.22934311628341675,
-0.3119737207889557,
-0.9400205612182617,
0.22350984811782837,
0.655447244644165,
0.061460740864276886,
-0.11329872906208038,
-0.06635382771492004,
-0.08047362416982651,
0.011832370422780514,
0.2743111252784729,
0.018684959039092064,
-0.6624279022216797,
-0.3734574019908905,
0.05636398494243622,
-0.28358936309814453,
0.1581181436777115,
0.8137094974517822,
-0.7532641291618347,
0.8712855577468872,
0.6217038035392761,
0.9046142101287842,
0.8941168785095215,
-0.12627123296260834,
0.6999509930610657,
-0.6612541079521179,
0.434489905834198,
0.3091796636581421,
0.24009056389331818,
0.3283027410507202,
-0.24042777717113495,
0.21406012773513794,
-0.004928715527057648,
-0.48434799909591675,
-0.6427724957466125,
0.1293414682149887,
-1.1945546865463257,
0.0052186548709869385,
1.0923157930374146,
-0.06253229826688766,
-0.7680992484092712,
0.06591615825891495,
-0.4108354449272156,
0.7567556500434875,
-0.7051373720169067,
0.6513254642486572,
0.5716128349304199,
0.2918812036514282,
-0.5004097819328308,
-0.3105594217777252,
0.5021991729736328,
0.7503519058227539,
-0.567883312702179,
-0.0012704640394076705,
0.24523647129535675,
0.34829622507095337,
-0.17469927668571472,
0.5692429542541504,
-0.3412400782108307,
0.5947255492210388,
0.010724825784564018,
0.45816928148269653,
-0.3849951922893524,
-0.30317288637161255,
-0.43962228298187256,
0.3391643166542053,
0.09005806595087051,
-0.5108180046081543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15741v1 | Ladder: A Model-Agnostic Framework Boosting LLM-based Machine Translation to the Next Level | 2024-06-22T05:33:35 | 2024-06-22T05:33:35 | Zhaopeng Feng, Ruizhe Chen, Yan Zhang, Zijie Meng, Zuozhu Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | General-purpose Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 have achieved
remarkable advancements in machine translation (MT) by leveraging extensive web
content. On the other hand, translation-specific LLMs are built by pre-training
on domain-specific monolingual corpora and fine-tuning with human-annotated
translation data. Despite the superior performance, these methods either demand
an unprecedented scale of computing and data or substantial human editing and
annotation efforts. In this paper, we develop Ladder, a novel model-agnostic
and cost-effective tool to refine the performance of general LLMs for MT.
Ladder is trained on pseudo-refinement triplets which can be easily obtained
from existing LLMs without additional human cost. During training, we propose a
hierarchical fine-tuning strategy with an easy-to-hard schema, improving
Ladder's refining performance progressively. The trained Ladder can be
seamlessly integrated with any general-purpose LLMs to boost their translation
performance. By utilizing Gemma-2B/7B as the backbone, Ladder-2B can elevate
raw translations to the level of top-tier open-source models (e.g., refining
BigTranslate-13B with +6.91 BLEU and +3.52 COMET for XX-En), and Ladder-7B can
further enhance model performance to be on par with the state-of-the-art GPT-4.
Extensive ablation and analysis corroborate the effectiveness of Ladder in
diverse settings. Our code is available at https://github.com/fzp0424/Ladder | [
0.04287020117044449,
-0.46036309003829956,
0.12201002240180969,
0.25492122769355774,
-0.3458806872367859,
0.40154990553855896,
0.08361602574586868,
-0.3139247000217438,
-0.07768115401268005,
0.3416517972946167,
-0.4122632145881653,
-0.6306545734405518,
-0.6994073987007141,
0.290981262922287,
-0.5808098912239075,
0.9992706179618835,
-0.0020723342895507812,
0.18642154335975647,
0.33638641238212585,
-0.09079018235206604,
-0.33744433522224426,
-0.48609769344329834,
-0.4823633134365082,
-0.36587759852409363,
0.5523591041564941,
0.3713732957839966,
1.0400739908218384,
1.095958948135376,
0.6972993016242981,
0.20600172877311707,
-0.17723789811134338,
0.4505894184112549,
-0.5261549353599548,
-0.13532482087612152,
-0.17832966148853302,
-0.6676299571990967,
-1.0445077419281006,
0.06532358378171921,
0.763826310634613,
0.20071391761302948,
-0.14293329417705536,
0.5897796750068665,
0.10741912573575974,
0.5978831052780151,
-0.3913598656654358,
0.19039811193943024,
-1.1602953672409058,
0.1198936477303505,
-0.38761624693870544,
-0.6631342172622681,
-0.5487757325172424,
-0.19195522367954254,
-0.3485689163208008,
-0.5263059139251709,
0.27958542108535767,
0.29041293263435364,
0.9379789233207703,
0.4916253983974457,
-0.5623814463615417,
-0.05729706957936287,
-0.49061501026153564,
0.5357440114021301,
-0.5719567537307739,
0.5066805481910706,
0.21038784086704254,
0.41015031933784485,
-0.21109649538993835,
-0.8458396196365356,
-0.2026824951171875,
-0.1618409901857376,
0.10385395586490631,
0.08111651241779327,
-0.1486540585756302,
0.038327623158693314,
0.08344462513923645,
0.8757049441337585,
-0.5646777749061584,
0.32622724771499634,
-0.2471555918455124,
0.006583200767636299,
0.19346404075622559,
0.2327854484319687,
0.38560330867767334,
-0.12750695645809174,
-0.510334849357605,
-0.04289235174655914,
-1.216564416885376,
0.06046852469444275,
0.38652700185775757,
0.5034317970275879,
-0.08479714393615723,
0.60524982213974,
0.105808787047863,
0.6139750480651855,
0.23857253789901733,
0.002751267747953534,
0.42655524611473083,
-0.2749498784542084,
-0.2669455111026764,
-0.17537739872932434,
0.6782694458961487,
0.4739237129688263,
0.18287326395511627,
-0.5198954343795776,
-0.2563040852546692,
0.20107243955135345,
0.24935677647590637,
-0.9433408975601196,
-0.2637210488319397,
0.178716778755188,
-0.24040162563323975,
-0.5533252358436584,
-0.43977245688438416,
-0.433414101600647,
-0.29763418436050415,
-0.20753931999206543,
0.3073005974292755,
-0.11454346030950546,
-0.05921465903520584,
0.0647696927189827,
0.20225955545902252,
0.31978893280029297,
0.23002997040748596,
-0.9071530699729919,
0.1463346779346466,
0.6650885343551636,
1.111181616783142,
-0.16260629892349243,
-0.19796797633171082,
-1.0386013984680176,
0.2554571330547333,
-0.6690493226051331,
0.49172061681747437,
-0.4003687798976898,
-0.10829663276672363,
-0.026321442797780037,
-0.09279350936412811,
0.10405731201171875,
-0.48366230726242065,
0.8169152736663818,
-0.7486211657524109,
-0.06986183673143387,
0.08269365131855011,
-0.38514506816864014,
0.004486083984375,
0.40874728560447693,
-0.5164616107940674,
1.0619412660598755,
0.01889878697693348,
-0.7909624576568604,
0.3908989727497101,
-0.39315736293792725,
-0.4543204605579376,
0.15661317110061646,
-0.09747160971164703,
-0.40954306721687317,
-0.07980469614267349,
0.3725855350494385,
0.42309078574180603,
-0.7595340609550476,
0.3691820502281189,
-0.21861405670642853,
-0.4053325057029724,
-0.40149566531181335,
-0.257946252822876,
0.5056377649307251,
0.3014064431190491,
-0.1725134253501892,
0.41883644461631775,
-0.7180002331733704,
0.0226967241615057,
-0.1112498939037323,
-0.5350689888000488,
0.19665099680423737,
0.01181780081242323,
-0.20040801167488098,
0.4144183397293091,
0.27974143624305725,
-0.35322919487953186,
0.4425683617591858,
-0.32912686467170715,
0.6166713833808899,
0.6560636162757874,
-0.33745068311691284,
0.46152517199516296,
-0.25917214155197144,
0.6657883524894714,
-0.07051172107458115,
0.10416534543037415,
-0.127564936876297,
-0.6245856285095215,
-0.6201193332672119,
-0.4046253263950348,
0.43817374110221863,
0.6861131191253662,
-0.6218838095664978,
0.32823559641838074,
-0.6166777014732361,
-0.45747989416122437,
-0.981971800327301,
0.3453218340873718,
0.4434676766395569,
0.6285602450370789,
0.82918781042099,
-0.11826276034116745,
-0.5246508717536926,
-0.9971854090690613,
-0.4151964485645294,
-0.10685432702302933,
-0.21471057832241058,
-0.23608967661857605,
0.2289385348558426,
-0.41576793789863586,
0.6678391098976135,
-0.19200412929058075,
-0.6510581374168396,
-0.22181111574172974,
0.059307463467121124,
0.5063908100128174,
0.36003273725509644,
0.2070355862379074,
-0.7468248009681702,
-0.5607061982154846,
0.4362857937812805,
-0.601338803768158,
-0.2398330569267273,
-0.033859897404909134,
-0.08887644112110138,
-0.15938282012939453,
0.4930587708950043,
-0.44639578461647034,
0.18067969381809235,
0.7559462785720825,
-0.0031511718407273293,
0.42558372020721436,
-0.5360463261604309,
0.1050538569688797,
-1.113970398902893,
0.25134971737861633,
-0.10769927501678467,
-0.5192186832427979,
-0.5588671565055847,
0.43024036288261414,
0.5022375583648682,
0.32919690012931824,
-0.4843188524246216,
0.4012351632118225,
-0.5285033583641052,
-0.044416360557079315,
-0.24167770147323608,
0.24001483619213104,
-0.22568883001804352,
0.46213674545288086,
-0.14173075556755066,
0.7973194718360901,
0.4816785454750061,
-0.27235835790634155,
0.12372726202011108,
0.36412739753723145,
-0.0464690737426281,
0.20887482166290283,
-0.5141766667366028,
0.2135147601366043,
0.17152832448482513,
0.3528388440608978,
-0.7868155241012573,
0.0003702212416101247,
0.27519187331199646,
-0.49161532521247864,
0.2824924886226654,
-0.5514452457427979,
-0.8382253646850586,
-0.34277641773223877,
-0.19164271652698517,
0.19409549236297607,
0.6175822615623474,
-0.6166692972183228,
0.6299875974655151,
0.29303982853889465,
0.052084844559431076,
-0.7349984049797058,
-0.7305377125740051,
0.4679209589958191,
-0.14977924525737762,
-0.750939130783081,
0.5926893353462219,
-0.06672167778015137,
0.20226001739501953,
-0.36308854818344116,
-0.34236016869544983,
-0.034507088363170624,
0.12012176215648651,
0.2772810161113739,
0.356463760137558,
-0.030560720711946487,
-0.08478472381830215,
0.11846868693828583,
-0.3109615743160248,
-0.08830171823501587,
-0.5273787379264832,
0.3128351867198944,
-0.5920669436454773,
-0.19164086878299713,
-0.24639387428760529,
-0.3091750741004944,
0.5701680779457092,
-0.5019885301589966,
0.5100406408309937,
0.5307799577713013,
-0.1343250572681427,
-0.27427950501441956,
-0.35706305503845215,
0.20432479679584503,
-0.46860602498054504,
0.44964373111724854,
-0.589885413646698,
-1.0177029371261597,
0.4662618339061737,
-0.20275121927261353,
0.3349362313747406,
0.39339691400527954,
0.7446879744529724,
0.31846311688423157,
1.129403829574585,
0.3986479938030243,
-0.2812981903553009,
-0.06489204615354538,
-0.22525554895401,
0.1845574826002121,
-0.9239455461502075,
-0.014025234617292881,
-0.5106894373893738,
-0.39498788118362427,
-0.7449867725372314,
-0.770627498626709,
0.15866471827030182,
0.30126166343688965,
-0.18679413199424744,
0.5116559267044067,
-0.43068015575408936,
0.466653972864151,
0.36670905351638794,
-0.17135456204414368,
0.8280017375946045,
-0.14163683354854584,
-0.42907610535621643,
0.21081776916980743,
-0.7374926209449768,
-0.7657167315483093,
1.3000236749649048,
0.53974449634552,
0.4922029674053192,
0.10909947007894516,
0.4284479022026062,
0.2695845663547516,
0.6240791082382202,
-0.5519881844520569,
0.41122713685035706,
-0.13877366483211517,
-0.7399404048919678,
-0.04440256953239441,
-0.6349881887435913,
-0.6592466831207275,
0.5787140130996704,
-0.2046966552734375,
-0.39416638016700745,
-0.21493788063526154,
0.6523245573043823,
0.014754855073988438,
0.6262179017066956,
-0.4658520221710205,
0.7558290362358093,
-0.2761442959308624,
-0.5935941338539124,
-0.2166881263256073,
-0.9730688333511353,
0.2816329300403595,
-0.4130612313747406,
0.46403923630714417,
0.032210059463977814,
-0.037940286099910736,
0.153081476688385,
-0.25151699781417847,
0.5031547546386719,
0.08358398824930191,
-0.29443830251693726,
0.0046847169287502766,
0.31153765320777893,
0.8447871208190918,
-0.04304778203368187,
-0.013751024380326271,
0.2593664824962616,
-0.20358575880527496,
-0.2675221562385559,
-0.39043983817100525,
0.6335878968238831,
-0.7121943831443787,
-0.6774083971977234,
-0.16260361671447754,
-0.6598652601242065,
-0.3115909695625305,
0.3124940097332001,
0.2748347818851471,
0.07179608941078186,
0.1572694629430771,
0.3625623285770416,
0.2753339409828186,
0.034666694700717926,
-0.14713771641254425,
0.39419594407081604,
-0.6478807926177979,
-0.3093107342720032,
0.7088117003440857,
-0.14833126962184906,
0.40071550011634827,
0.7409893870353699,
0.05386689677834511,
-0.4228675365447998,
-0.9717360734939575,
-0.7488803863525391,
0.04910315200686455,
-0.6299803256988525,
-0.3683304190635681,
-0.46846967935562134,
-0.07836601138114929,
-0.10033151507377625,
-0.07744305580854416,
-0.3890022039413452,
-0.525374710559845,
0.012716715224087238,
-0.3448704183101654,
0.08838758617639542,
0.5867229104042053,
-0.05535276606678963,
0.36942240595817566,
-0.87736576795578,
0.4835091233253479,
0.014730134978890419,
0.25514256954193115,
-0.026573151350021362,
-0.8577401041984558,
-0.33917734026908875,
0.15905356407165527,
-0.530225396156311,
-0.5279927849769592,
0.34526705741882324,
0.1060861125588417,
0.2764952778816223,
0.22823098301887512,
-0.21085906028747559,
0.7235273718833923,
-0.9614670872688293,
0.5452770590782166,
0.30585944652557373,
-0.9344291687011719,
0.17457635700702667,
-0.5903810262680054,
0.1361706554889679,
0.3897371292114258,
0.2883707582950592,
-0.385446697473526,
-0.49804770946502686,
-0.2204858809709549,
-1.0395433902740479,
0.5093589425086975,
0.5081250071525574,
-0.18531998991966248,
0.05315466225147247,
0.40018200874328613,
-0.08537160605192184,
0.23039200901985168,
-1.0507526397705078,
-0.11647646874189377,
-0.17906026542186737,
-0.13848641514778137,
-0.15515747666358948,
0.1438509225845337,
0.1003539189696312,
-0.20161274075508118,
0.8444705605506897,
-0.2003536969423294,
-0.4328770041465759,
-0.05176243185997009,
-0.4251124858856201,
-0.39910581707954407,
0.23915928602218628,
0.10591072589159012,
0.547341525554657,
-0.5299064517021179,
0.2286251187324524,
0.31954002380371094,
-0.34818750619888306,
0.2696665823459625,
0.03279419615864754,
-0.07755177468061447,
-0.31741586327552795,
0.28313499689102173,
0.507684051990509,
0.2576727569103241,
-0.2303665280342102,
0.3551710844039917,
0.23521773517131805,
-0.20342370867729187,
0.20967675745487213,
-0.05184927210211754,
0.42068299651145935,
0.260111927986145,
0.3683724105358124,
0.17556793987751007,
0.017796600237488747,
-0.3226344585418701,
0.1413080096244812,
0.40670448541641235,
-0.2666853964328766,
-0.5333275198936462,
1.0759601593017578,
0.306537002325058,
-0.3677228093147278,
0.44440412521362305,
-0.048375315964221954,
-0.3608013093471527,
0.029869722202420235,
0.5008789300918579,
0.8035273551940918,
-0.3188118636608124,
-0.005223425570875406,
0.3574623763561249,
0.62062668800354,
-0.1417762190103531,
-0.20470204949378967,
-0.032284148037433624,
-0.4147188365459442,
-0.5334351658821106,
-0.8573420643806458,
-0.2839546203613281,
0.04083714261651039,
-0.39213666319847107,
0.5146251916885376,
-0.33664587140083313,
-0.20718465745449066,
-0.38881781697273254,
-0.14334258437156677,
-0.5548101663589478,
0.12872183322906494,
-0.0015304246917366982,
1.0817904472351074,
-0.5531254410743713,
1.069350242614746,
0.4865168035030365,
-0.528399646282196,
-0.7537440657615662,
-0.19585111737251282,
0.03915758058428764,
-0.8673297762870789,
0.7678140997886658,
0.10305547714233398,
-0.5598849058151245,
0.3221960663795471,
-0.23511850833892822,
-0.7168675065040588,
1.25700044631958,
0.5085720419883728,
-0.7834359407424927,
-0.6881740689277649,
0.44569480419158936,
0.7481671571731567,
-0.32706573605537415,
0.19221952557563782,
0.3223539888858795,
0.42454537749290466,
0.29884207248687744,
-0.9481379985809326,
-0.015669237822294235,
-0.3568759262561798,
0.1665089875459671,
0.19632522761821747,
-0.4096507728099823,
0.785855770111084,
-0.12867452204227448,
-0.27292653918266296,
0.2627677321434021,
0.4931940734386444,
0.2890062630176544,
-0.21390187740325928,
0.301665723323822,
0.6105873584747314,
0.7748384475708008,
0.09344334900379181,
1.0208044052124023,
-0.6929670572280884,
0.38379529118537903,
1.3110994100570679,
-0.23685665428638458,
0.9412217736244202,
0.4009157419204712,
-0.0365234911441803,
0.3594982922077179,
0.5757301449775696,
-0.06678682565689087,
0.3449159562587738,
0.4368733763694763,
0.22340790927410126,
-0.460275799036026,
0.3514358103275299,
-0.6404459476470947,
0.0694015845656395,
0.11556887626647949,
-0.5278401970863342,
-0.41165733337402344,
-0.6134334206581116,
0.04864369332790375,
-0.0721137523651123,
-0.34518006443977356,
0.21129292249679565,
0.22429004311561584,
-0.46466636657714844,
0.8201696872711182,
0.24740242958068848,
0.4572756290435791,
-0.6671600937843323,
0.026332473382353783,
-0.09845173358917236,
0.46720966696739197,
-0.33834511041641235,
-0.583272397518158,
0.056127894669771194,
0.34596866369247437,
0.040957674384117126,
-0.41599345207214355,
0.3476588726043701,
-0.31993865966796875,
-0.39472270011901855,
0.5070326328277588,
0.4460259675979614,
0.02563912235200405,
-0.1764741986989975,
-0.6176970601081848,
-0.10674749314785004,
0.08998426049947739,
-0.0752326250076294,
0.3228226602077484,
0.4712274372577667,
-0.042425986379384995,
0.8579073548316956,
0.7966817617416382,
0.25321054458618164,
0.08542130887508392,
-0.026106439530849457,
0.6893098950386047,
-0.3868201971054077,
-0.5043026804924011,
-0.8153215050697327,
0.7370277643203735,
0.25503361225128174,
-0.272571861743927,
0.9119448065757751,
0.876264214515686,
0.6941236853599548,
0.10332860052585602,
0.4893030822277069,
0.41762083768844604,
0.4166126549243927,
-0.47742390632629395,
0.6825037598609924,
-0.6236509084701538,
0.5392842292785645,
-0.33762601017951965,
-1.1450369358062744,
-0.6414973139762878,
0.2952509820461273,
-0.3055296540260315,
-0.17818953096866608,
0.5431774258613586,
0.8320868611335754,
-0.15866176784038544,
-0.04727443680167198,
0.25730061531066895,
0.39655250310897827,
0.7069481611251831,
0.5166482925415039,
0.7295268177986145,
-0.39353394508361816,
0.9858191609382629,
0.5250735878944397,
-0.41728833317756653,
-0.14729264378547668,
-1.0247398614883423,
-0.8268613219261169,
-0.30774766206741333,
-0.11211863905191422,
-0.13957370817661285,
0.2216252088546753,
0.9014480113983154,
0.6273695230484009,
-0.39109402894973755,
-0.4023823142051697,
-0.32878321409225464,
-0.21006275713443756,
0.07722146064043045,
-0.05334192514419556,
0.2791992127895355,
-0.5837986469268799,
-0.5147858262062073,
0.5117715001106262,
0.38902539014816284,
-0.22283054888248444,
-0.08806688338518143,
-0.266581654548645,
-0.2586640417575836,
-0.12918071448802948,
0.5967991352081299,
-0.048288166522979736,
-0.7869631052017212,
-0.04159842059016228,
0.025320855900645256,
-0.04933836683630943,
0.5893392562866211,
0.4179289638996124,
-0.6467034816741943,
0.3971635103225708,
0.24066786468029022,
0.759768009185791,
0.6492611169815063,
0.10985058546066284,
0.5861979722976685,
-0.7189177870750427,
-0.14351876080036163,
0.08178061991930008,
0.36179688572883606,
0.47168830037117004,
-0.08915716409683228,
0.721649169921875,
0.06296539306640625,
-0.5979048609733582,
-0.839310884475708,
0.22578838467597961,
-0.6363556385040283,
0.02617679536342621,
1.030373454093933,
-0.11806243658065796,
0.04828234016895294,
0.22405390441417694,
-0.14680346846580505,
0.32465028762817383,
-0.178122416138649,
0.6289589405059814,
0.5615134835243225,
0.17443148791790009,
0.1344178169965744,
-0.4250093698501587,
0.4883590638637543,
0.3668572008609772,
-0.6655733585357666,
0.27214354276657104,
0.5034258365631104,
0.19087764620780945,
0.08584343641996384,
0.36327821016311646,
-0.44811075925827026,
0.10315341502428055,
-0.3512817323207855,
0.0053259022533893585,
-0.3148781657218933,
-0.4846862852573395,
-0.27406036853790283,
0.25792840123176575,
0.31686559319496155,
0.045207876712083817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15736v1 | Evaluating Large Vision-and-Language Models on Children's Mathematical Olympiads | 2024-06-22T05:04:39 | 2024-06-22T05:04:39 | Anoop Cherian, Kuan-Chuan Peng, Suhas Lohit, Joanna Matthiesen, Kevin Smith, Joshua B. Tenenbaum | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent years have seen a significant progress in the general-purpose problem
solving abilities of large vision and language models (LVLMs), such as ChatGPT,
Gemini, etc.; some of these breakthroughs even seem to enable AI models to
outperform human abilities in varied tasks that demand higher-order cognitive
skills. Are the current large AI models indeed capable of generalized problem
solving as humans do? A systematic analysis of AI capabilities for joint vision
and text reasoning, however, is missing in the current scientific literature.
In this paper, we make an effort towards filling this gap, by evaluating
state-of-the-art LVLMs on their mathematical and algorithmic reasoning
abilities using visuo-linguistic problems from children's Olympiads.
Specifically, we consider problems from the Mathematical Kangaroo (MK)
Olympiad, which is a popular international competition targeted at children
from grades 1-12, that tests children's deeper mathematical abilities using
puzzles that are appropriately gauged to their age and skills. Using the
puzzles from MK, we created a dataset, dubbed SMART-840, consisting of 840
problems from years 2020-2024. With our dataset, we analyze LVLMs power on
mathematical reasoning; their responses on our puzzles offer a direct way to
compare against that of children. Our results show that modern LVLMs do
demonstrate increasingly powerful reasoning skills in solving problems for
higher grades, but lack the foundations to correctly answer problems designed
for younger children. Further analysis shows that there is no significant
correlation between the reasoning capabilities of AI models and that of young
children, and their capabilities appear to be based on a different type of
reasoning than the cumulative knowledge that underlies children's mathematics
and logic skills. | [
-0.3507927358150482,
-0.6586299538612366,
0.6784804463386536,
0.16877113282680511,
-0.23475559055805206,
0.148702472448349,
-0.22123688459396362,
-0.593454897403717,
-0.2808285057544708,
0.37693527340888977,
-0.5540422201156616,
-0.1283746063709259,
-0.5666452646255493,
0.22260251641273499,
-0.36456406116485596,
0.3907102942466736,
-0.1469791978597641,
0.05374559387564659,
-0.8604934215545654,
0.05051989108324051,
-0.5063527226448059,
-0.6441718935966492,
-0.4267161190509796,
-0.37459325790405273,
0.4158591330051422,
0.35604649782180786,
0.7364957332611084,
0.4608819782733917,
0.7829853892326355,
0.3521427512168884,
-0.29708999395370483,
0.26575860381126404,
-0.24582409858703613,
0.010120097547769547,
-0.46534791588783264,
-0.5382713675498962,
-0.2383713573217392,
0.015928614884614944,
0.5335363149642944,
0.8911777138710022,
0.11434271186590195,
0.044491659849882126,
0.03896075859665871,
0.9728663563728333,
-0.49037912487983704,
0.444313645362854,
-0.6936362981796265,
0.3332778513431549,
0.01246865838766098,
0.16108611226081848,
-0.3765893280506134,
-0.12240900844335556,
0.26592278480529785,
-0.8450315594673157,
-0.12277663499116898,
0.18970626592636108,
0.6871919631958008,
0.3162183165550232,
-0.2080952376127243,
-0.4113198220729828,
-0.6295934319496155,
1.1750211715698242,
-0.4579515755176544,
0.1724560558795929,
0.5852934718132019,
0.32383641600608826,
-0.1894134283065796,
-0.45537683367729187,
-0.56386798620224,
-0.3718000650405884,
0.11263269931077957,
0.24421462416648865,
-0.3460436165332794,
-0.25683748722076416,
0.505780816078186,
-0.15992818772792816,
-0.7492947578430176,
-0.05440925061702728,
-0.5730582475662231,
-0.16214050352573395,
0.871545672416687,
0.474436491727829,
0.42939141392707825,
-0.1277841478586197,
-0.03831098601222038,
0.04624984785914421,
-0.35624757409095764,
0.36032038927078247,
0.12525196373462677,
0.012114519253373146,
0.013776870444417,
0.9263078570365906,
-0.40250489115715027,
0.8116706609725952,
-0.18529202044010162,
-0.1801939606666565,
0.10936230421066284,
-0.5001611709594727,
-0.06168625131249428,
-0.2284763902425766,
0.7067381739616394,
0.33930525183677673,
0.9699311256408691,
-0.057933393865823746,
-0.2887146472930908,
0.3223252296447754,
-0.05967461317777634,
-0.5968402624130249,
-0.23712466657161713,
-0.024841327220201492,
-0.4697144329547882,
-0.12390149384737015,
-0.069845050573349,
-0.6858817934989929,
-0.4436286687850952,
-0.5843303799629211,
0.6415757536888123,
-0.5038639903068542,
-0.07368088513612747,
0.4263666570186615,
-0.24187031388282776,
0.14605295658111572,
0.3115383982658386,
-0.7011541128158569,
0.1251695305109024,
0.8927266001701355,
0.33919236063957214,
-0.15074758231639862,
-0.3926961421966553,
-0.3276757299900055,
-0.36491844058036804,
-0.4954824447631836,
0.773410975933075,
-0.9813031554222107,
-0.2989439070224762,
-0.06001395732164383,
-0.23515388369560242,
-0.46818357706069946,
-0.8900406360626221,
0.44827479124069214,
-0.3240625858306885,
0.20281748473644257,
-0.21287411451339722,
-0.3007442355155945,
-0.005875311326235533,
0.41097956895828247,
-0.4308205246925354,
0.7887117862701416,
-0.10123104602098465,
-0.6486258506774902,
0.30589744448661804,
-0.3524928689002991,
-0.4974474012851715,
0.007610357366502285,
-0.23030246794223785,
-0.5113581418991089,
0.14988338947296143,
0.6823237538337708,
0.19996675848960876,
-0.485073983669281,
0.5130597949028015,
-0.22348906099796295,
-0.4011421501636505,
0.4256470501422882,
-0.6460264325141907,
0.9142104983329773,
-0.10838887840509415,
-0.28720587491989136,
0.01172227319329977,
-0.7538625001907349,
0.20211492478847504,
0.5074341893196106,
-0.020361527800559998,
-0.21959920227527618,
0.28331905603408813,
-0.5100231766700745,
0.23446357250213623,
0.49184542894363403,
-0.3950565457344055,
0.46412888169288635,
-0.24100488424301147,
0.5891585946083069,
0.496309757232666,
-0.20519480109214783,
0.3252710998058319,
-0.315371572971344,
0.4347144067287445,
-0.07477430999279022,
0.5879107117652893,
-0.10156255215406418,
-1.1559092998504639,
-0.7545716166496277,
-0.12271813303232193,
0.13513945043087006,
0.6935762763023376,
-1.094105839729309,
0.24844276905059814,
-0.34646981954574585,
-0.49579140543937683,
-0.20718912780284882,
-0.05410005897283554,
0.4578760266304016,
0.48482877016067505,
0.14605045318603516,
-0.22263529896736145,
-0.34015223383903503,
-0.9265755414962769,
-0.3322628140449524,
-0.2706493139266968,
-0.008434925228357315,
0.8003196716308594,
0.8507586121559143,
0.028828438371419907,
0.962897539138794,
-0.2520834803581238,
-0.06346996873617172,
-0.08316852152347565,
0.037900570780038834,
0.10733777284622192,
0.31052249670028687,
0.4195413589477539,
-1.0903831720352173,
-0.2933686375617981,
0.12412162125110626,
-1.037874698638916,
-0.17389263212680817,
0.1687740832567215,
0.0175232645124197,
0.11994968354701996,
0.23347264528274536,
-0.6860561966896057,
0.774379551410675,
0.3719344437122345,
-0.628982424736023,
0.8190710544586182,
-0.18750005960464478,
0.031460296362638474,
-0.17063818871974945,
0.047735702246427536,
-0.19644895195960999,
0.10873880237340927,
-0.4561939835548401,
-0.04681502655148506,
0.12519873678684235,
-0.2501739263534546,
-0.37208282947540283,
0.5445349216461182,
-0.30141332745552063,
-0.21133971214294434,
0.013432103209197521,
0.22488757967948914,
0.107742540538311,
0.35397690534591675,
0.06325768679380417,
0.6679768562316895,
0.6135912537574768,
-0.473100870847702,
0.6864545941352844,
-0.1980697065591812,
-0.5850934386253357,
0.6017609238624573,
-0.6700663566589355,
0.21743394434452057,
-0.23893392086029053,
0.05206098034977913,
-0.6678071022033691,
-0.1844387799501419,
0.20464292168617249,
-0.6627556681632996,
-0.04099976271390915,
0.1352851241827011,
-0.46139320731163025,
-0.8281170725822449,
-0.09884914755821228,
0.5843883752822876,
0.5451603531837463,
-0.4427284002304077,
0.8268604278564453,
0.15983714163303375,
-0.2734570801258087,
-0.6574230194091797,
-0.5132951140403748,
0.1845252811908722,
-0.10416647046804428,
-0.8797605633735657,
0.03353571891784668,
-0.2575274109840393,
-0.5973612070083618,
0.44635409116744995,
-0.11726486682891846,
-0.3152654767036438,
0.048455655574798584,
-0.11649706214666367,
0.4093460738658905,
-0.37692227959632874,
-0.0684310793876648,
-0.16681616008281708,
-0.23654185235500336,
0.12351512163877487,
-0.24014557898044586,
0.43589895963668823,
-0.2696794271469116,
-0.44312435388565063,
-0.26202139258384705,
0.11050694435834885,
0.8409076929092407,
-0.7660315036773682,
0.7276753187179565,
0.17168021202087402,
-0.46159645915031433,
-0.05433930084109306,
-0.23574762046337128,
0.028875434771180153,
-0.4102308750152588,
0.5355406999588013,
-0.3568286895751953,
-0.546747624874115,
0.5100337862968445,
0.2747442424297333,
-0.12875430285930634,
0.45184779167175293,
0.5073039531707764,
-0.04352722689509392,
1.3068857192993164,
0.3148728907108307,
-0.0899430364370346,
0.2546064257621765,
-0.33756884932518005,
0.1411174237728119,
-0.7576472163200378,
-0.6556370854377747,
-0.4913037419319153,
-0.350216805934906,
0.0017637229757383466,
-0.4973251223564148,
0.14821241796016693,
0.005708162672817707,
-0.4225039780139923,
0.005338525399565697,
-0.714961588382721,
0.7047737836837769,
0.5474541187286377,
-0.12142875790596008,
0.39868271350860596,
-0.14673352241516113,
-0.20266489684581757,
-0.05597329139709473,
-0.9071861505508423,
-0.26939356327056885,
1.1657626628875732,
-0.051535043865442276,
0.6151054501533508,
-0.1378462165594101,
0.3270169794559479,
0.0221211276948452,
0.34906765818595886,
-0.8160544037818909,
0.8445620536804199,
-0.2361488938331604,
-0.8793479800224304,
-0.47543492913246155,
-0.6378633975982666,
-1.1994976997375488,
0.42349305748939514,
-0.49045705795288086,
-0.8372446894645691,
0.11312119662761688,
-0.15907679498195648,
-0.09988021105527878,
0.3140028715133667,
-0.6327348947525024,
0.6702510118484497,
-0.4421716034412384,
-0.30926513671875,
-0.311577171087265,
-0.4459638297557831,
0.4832059442996979,
-0.24726366996765137,
0.4852529764175415,
-0.08142570406198502,
0.00570807047188282,
0.7138199806213379,
-0.23817147314548492,
0.5780232548713684,
0.032116010785102844,
0.021203992888331413,
0.6527954339981079,
-0.13369911909103394,
0.2244301438331604,
-0.016628149896860123,
-0.022298159077763557,
-0.07940270751714706,
-0.056963033974170685,
-0.48549357056617737,
-0.7813785672187805,
0.46743062138557434,
-0.7841629981994629,
-0.6793980598449707,
-0.5887628197669983,
-0.6615332365036011,
-0.03039255365729332,
0.24364355206489563,
0.04520174488425255,
0.730190098285675,
0.1848752796649933,
0.34067925810813904,
0.5017950534820557,
-0.2980946898460388,
0.3746953308582306,
0.34715747833251953,
-0.47403159737586975,
-0.3979188799858093,
1.1434298753738403,
0.29635849595069885,
0.2189730405807495,
0.15364369750022888,
0.41755521297454834,
-0.11409623175859451,
-0.636988639831543,
-0.47035762667655945,
0.2436918020248413,
-0.6137853860855103,
0.024410920217633247,
-0.15911059081554413,
-0.2957764267921448,
0.05311907082796097,
-0.11691038310527802,
-0.22219957411289215,
-0.5338720679283142,
0.048904743045568466,
0.5819442272186279,
-0.15197856724262238,
0.7934593558311462,
0.10860011726617813,
-0.3781273066997528,
-0.5715667009353638,
0.6383793950080872,
0.7451130151748657,
0.1951628476381302,
0.1878393441438675,
-0.3615076541900635,
-0.1376812756061554,
0.07385444641113281,
-0.15865692496299744,
-0.40771058201789856,
0.11140421032905579,
0.11179466545581818,
0.5194095373153687,
0.25516360998153687,
0.005362953525036573,
0.4609890580177307,
-0.5810895562171936,
0.9610030651092529,
0.09146695584058762,
-0.7622600793838501,
0.2816650867462158,
-0.21484731137752533,
0.23234568536281586,
0.07417499274015427,
-0.15355649590492249,
-0.2889666259288788,
-0.12754057347774506,
-0.5476739406585693,
-0.4571745693683624,
0.5775566101074219,
0.5072737336158752,
-0.1010274663567543,
0.19216713309288025,
0.3513203561306,
-0.10964952409267426,
0.10258815437555313,
-0.3778952658176422,
0.0018385302973911166,
-0.023672468960285187,
-0.43029260635375977,
-0.039406679570674896,
0.19054491817951202,
0.025486882776021957,
-0.5932912230491638,
0.3915383219718933,
0.060206200927495956,
0.17505928874015808,
0.1230187937617302,
0.06339524686336517,
-0.15354062616825104,
0.07294049859046936,
0.5503590703010559,
0.8409198522567749,
0.16622121632099152,
0.0804239884018898,
0.08712839335203171,
-0.691451907157898,
-0.027704952284693718,
0.2712247669696808,
-0.27675238251686096,
-0.46241897344589233,
0.8314204216003418,
0.5187470316886902,
0.03590214252471924,
-1.1374149322509766,
0.4494205415248871,
-0.3350183963775635,
-0.5188513994216919,
-0.13321304321289062,
0.23885643482208252,
0.17364181578159332,
0.5215353965759277,
0.5673516988754272,
0.18827800452709198,
-0.18128183484077454,
-0.680736780166626,
-0.16488654911518097,
0.6365051865577698,
-0.049554795026779175,
-0.2581862509250641,
0.5651585459709167,
0.16937127709388733,
-0.6599370241165161,
0.6825063824653625,
-0.05107272043824196,
-0.8659338355064392,
1.1466670036315918,
0.48870664834976196,
0.5151045918464661,
0.042144130915403366,
0.10175884515047073,
0.17744700610637665,
0.5977097153663635,
-0.046329423785209656,
0.30837854743003845,
0.06318643689155579,
-0.8171108365058899,
-0.6892417669296265,
-0.23504847288131714,
-0.5206180214881897,
0.1701471358537674,
-0.45581427216529846,
-0.09741636365652084,
-0.36499983072280884,
-0.025025000795722008,
0.09311568737030029,
0.15242742002010345,
-0.8557761907577515,
0.531754195690155,
0.517791748046875,
0.5959842205047607,
-0.4836326241493225,
0.4868886172771454,
0.8024149537086487,
-0.08292798697948456,
-0.4742198884487152,
-0.10243703424930573,
-0.23129284381866455,
-0.9822107553482056,
0.8085272312164307,
0.20457321405410767,
-0.13476547598838806,
-0.21388515830039978,
-0.8437148928642273,
-0.9024296402931213,
0.8000254034996033,
0.2262372225522995,
-0.6048890948295593,
-0.06612727046012878,
0.3823171854019165,
0.5540335178375244,
-0.3414710760116577,
-0.06725131720304489,
0.4773963689804077,
0.6212453246116638,
0.037699807435274124,
-1.1267107725143433,
-0.4831647574901581,
-0.43793782591819763,
-0.29328426718711853,
0.09123753011226654,
-0.5621393918991089,
0.9066404104232788,
-0.3898174464702606,
-0.022322464734315872,
0.2879665493965149,
0.535575807094574,
0.5447828769683838,
0.8185299634933472,
0.5116479992866516,
0.5767692923545837,
0.7134858965873718,
-0.1927105188369751,
1.0894088745117188,
-0.1385454535484314,
0.35803690552711487,
0.47092562913894653,
-0.17465262115001678,
0.7559661865234375,
0.2336079180240631,
-0.3023373782634735,
0.19538423418998718,
0.17154477536678314,
0.26891469955444336,
0.41666853427886963,
0.26362931728363037,
-0.03593907877802849,
-0.5828744769096375,
0.05675901472568512,
-0.2998710572719574,
0.3276903033256531,
0.5546208620071411,
0.0038140066899359226,
0.11480457335710526,
0.08646666258573532,
-0.1924029439687729,
0.260668009519577,
-0.7578258514404297,
0.27287209033966064,
0.2857542932033539,
-0.8734841346740723,
0.7441674470901489,
-0.20218878984451294,
0.5045636892318726,
-0.31098031997680664,
0.0018050136277452111,
-0.04245121404528618,
0.4039188623428345,
0.06090975180268288,
-1.236717700958252,
-0.0015700508374720812,
0.2977115213871002,
-0.013517213054001331,
0.2596829831600189,
0.9056889414787292,
-0.20949815213680267,
-0.9071816802024841,
0.11352935433387756,
0.5648128986358643,
0.0943194329738617,
0.025679953396320343,
-0.8864699602127075,
0.14909008145332336,
-0.03551291301846504,
-0.2768276035785675,
0.1995384395122528,
0.7007541060447693,
-0.26083239912986755,
1.040347933769226,
0.5857869982719421,
-0.08070416748523712,
0.1813165694475174,
0.01328384131193161,
0.8689501881599426,
-0.7135273218154907,
-0.12180177122354507,
-0.9148883819580078,
0.45689070224761963,
-0.07907919585704803,
-0.4515986144542694,
0.4812798500061035,
0.4874412715435028,
0.5608794093132019,
-0.024600200355052948,
0.8506900072097778,
0.2357391119003296,
0.24552829563617706,
-0.44601839780807495,
0.4161838889122009,
-0.6602915525436401,
-0.1964571624994278,
-0.236667200922966,
-1.0757761001586914,
-0.6074450016021729,
0.9057998061180115,
-0.7609788775444031,
0.0462743304669857,
0.5540810823440552,
0.2052830159664154,
-0.07643993198871613,
0.1292300969362259,
0.37082043290138245,
0.11438257247209549,
0.4018741548061371,
0.9894667863845825,
1.1812394857406616,
-0.05310691148042679,
0.6104921698570251,
-0.23193567991256714,
-0.37088891863822937,
-0.2810865342617035,
-0.5857473611831665,
-1.2272166013717651,
-0.2901019752025604,
0.014881868846714497,
0.00032207093317992985,
0.3406412601470947,
0.4501524567604065,
0.2467474639415741,
-0.33243051171302795,
0.2537532448768616,
0.011195539496839046,
0.24135814607143402,
-0.16929201781749725,
-0.1066102534532547,
0.49257606267929077,
0.018733689561486244,
-0.7071388959884644,
0.31350862979888916,
0.27966901659965515,
-0.12706710398197174,
-0.23729659616947174,
-0.007703348528593779,
0.30076318979263306,
0.5227177739143372,
0.7419086694717407,
0.2927166819572449,
-0.7233102321624756,
-0.4182974100112915,
0.3010832667350769,
-0.018190590664744377,
-0.06997406482696533,
0.4039180278778076,
-1.0661375522613525,
0.5087991952896118,
0.41590452194213867,
0.3886042535305023,
0.4692578613758087,
-0.03013334982097149,
0.07021231949329376,
0.07194942981004715,
0.31594324111938477,
0.4621241092681885,
0.5310418605804443,
0.30099546909332275,
0.1846054345369339,
0.44471290707588196,
0.48930931091308594,
-0.5856103897094727,
-0.6899667382240295,
0.3054324984550476,
-0.676253080368042,
-0.28340014815330505,
1.0107433795928955,
0.06315299868583679,
-0.4943374991416931,
-0.15642663836479187,
-0.48634153604507446,
-0.09851393103599548,
-0.0997757613658905,
0.7651620507240295,
0.8642511963844299,
-0.17617040872573853,
-0.015716034919023514,
-0.5139532685279846,
0.05103842541575432,
0.5559924244880676,
-0.6820791363716125,
0.0018631929997354746,
0.20142725110054016,
-0.13957801461219788,
0.28963595628738403,
0.2529720366001129,
-0.20185987651348114,
0.4921905994415283,
0.10391387343406677,
-0.34357860684394836,
-0.19228290021419525,
-0.576158881187439,
0.025007909163832664,
0.0953962504863739,
-0.14572516083717346,
0.07090076804161072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15734v1 | RankAdaptor: Hierarchical Dynamic Low-Rank Adaptation for Structural Pruned LLMs | 2024-06-22T04:52:58 | 2024-06-22T04:52:58 | Changhai Zhou, Shijie Han, Shiyang Zhang, Shichao Weng, Zekai Liu, Cheng Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The efficient compression of large language models (LLMs) is becoming
increasingly popular. However, recovering the accuracy of compressed LLMs is
still a major challenge. Structural pruning with standard Low-Rank Adaptation
(LoRA) is a common technique in current LLM compression. In structural pruning,
the model architecture is modified unevenly, resulting in suboptimal
performance in various downstream tasks via standard LoRA with fixed rank. To
address this problem, we introduce RankAdaptor, an efficient fine-tuning method
with hierarchical dynamic rank scheduling for pruned LLMs. An end-to-end
automatic optimization flow is developed that utilizes a lightweight
performance model to determine the different ranks during fine-tuning.
Comprehensive experiments on popular benchmarks show that RankAdaptor
consistently outperforms standard LoRA with structural pruning over different
pruning settings. Without increasing the trainable parameters, RankAdaptor
further reduces the accuracy performance gap between the recovery of the pruned
model and the original model compared to standard LoRA. | [
-0.0009072512621060014,
-0.535478949546814,
0.2148747742176056,
0.08110016584396362,
-0.5542663335800171,
0.4794505834579468,
-0.15834762156009674,
-0.26462435722351074,
0.14462506771087646,
0.22654685378074646,
-0.44213563203811646,
-0.25018003582954407,
-0.7596324682235718,
-0.06094102934002876,
-0.09066124260425568,
1.0644296407699585,
0.003284312319010496,
-0.29195019602775574,
0.10513639450073242,
-0.13692303001880646,
-0.5096156001091003,
-0.2529774606227875,
-0.8029802441596985,
-0.3227005898952484,
0.5465691089630127,
0.5384529829025269,
0.8957981467247009,
0.9522382020950317,
0.6933249235153198,
0.4583667516708374,
-0.2856162190437317,
0.014456331729888916,
-0.8111198544502258,
0.2554590404033661,
-0.08307267725467682,
-0.5064130425453186,
-0.9292448163032532,
-0.40991753339767456,
0.9186980128288269,
0.7419838309288025,
-0.4283609390258789,
0.3633382022380829,
0.2307601273059845,
0.6290484070777893,
-0.536468505859375,
0.0906035527586937,
-0.926366925239563,
-0.003518296405673027,
-0.0982542484998703,
-0.770381510257721,
-0.17506681382656097,
-0.6626114845275879,
-0.3637920320034027,
-0.6113036274909973,
-0.13239216804504395,
0.11080536246299744,
0.7661318778991699,
1.0634373426437378,
-0.3521246314048767,
0.27698442339897156,
-0.6931352019309998,
0.662181556224823,
-0.6405267119407654,
0.18392522633075714,
0.03982831537723541,
0.5843571424484253,
-0.3188489079475403,
-0.49318408966064453,
-0.037600643932819366,
-0.06401175260543823,
0.22686614096164703,
0.132749542593956,
0.13498666882514954,
0.10176333039999008,
0.07417415082454681,
0.6699386835098267,
-0.2699914276599884,
0.5930091738700867,
-0.387600302696228,
0.1275004893541336,
0.28629565238952637,
-0.036682069301605225,
0.20700004696846008,
-0.23183172941207886,
-0.19660532474517822,
-0.11236139386892319,
-0.7162202596664429,
-0.00010320633737137541,
0.4896831214427948,
0.2914682924747467,
-0.03189859911799431,
0.30831706523895264,
-0.05164819955825806,
0.7737430930137634,
0.21965976059436798,
-0.4841163158416748,
0.1228206530213356,
0.06310021877288818,
-0.3165932595729828,
0.25906112790107727,
0.09975592792034149,
0.2947627305984497,
0.24028971791267395,
-0.019124874845147133,
-0.22639873623847961,
0.015258013270795345,
0.27885910868644714,
-1.019054651260376,
-0.5027977824211121,
0.16479717195034027,
-0.42721182107925415,
-0.7527888417243958,
-0.21188010275363922,
-0.5778661966323853,
-0.3993801474571228,
-0.2182168960571289,
0.4731418490409851,
-0.12561602890491486,
-0.06314682215452194,
-0.10344339907169342,
-0.12828224897384644,
0.1927323192358017,
0.6501287221908569,
-0.8298981189727783,
0.44696155190467834,
0.6842778921127319,
0.8747166395187378,
-0.6290944814682007,
-0.134611114859581,
-1.06229829788208,
0.34302255511283875,
-0.3046128451824188,
0.8060815334320068,
-0.3453340530395508,
0.05171744152903557,
-0.3814201056957245,
0.22452977299690247,
-0.35113653540611267,
-0.7581979632377625,
0.623296856880188,
-0.5856249332427979,
-0.1192701905965805,
0.3040429651737213,
-0.13845399022102356,
0.16685481369495392,
0.3018873929977417,
-0.5238670110702515,
1.2502228021621704,
0.3107326924800873,
-0.6253243684768677,
0.4057055711746216,
-0.5079472064971924,
-0.34682831168174744,
0.287871778011322,
-0.1295228749513626,
-0.49987486004829407,
0.2433411329984665,
0.2620871365070343,
0.22536702454090118,
-0.1345997452735901,
0.2169213742017746,
-0.04420444741845131,
-0.6812483072280884,
-0.35674145817756653,
-0.17010509967803955,
0.3795853853225708,
0.04845265671610832,
-0.07369718700647354,
0.4267224073410034,
-0.817767858505249,
-0.07998726516962051,
0.13710874319076538,
-0.8817391395568848,
-0.3222150206565857,
0.4277191460132599,
-0.1878342479467392,
0.16033555567264557,
0.368945837020874,
-0.4575330317020416,
0.5032563805580139,
-0.5587462186813354,
0.5580686926841736,
1.2083171606063843,
0.014553086832165718,
0.28627365827560425,
-0.5557792782783508,
0.5998935699462891,
-0.08477575331926346,
-0.06319081038236618,
0.3844349682331085,
0.03095286712050438,
-0.8923540115356445,
-0.5474467873573303,
0.39791154861450195,
0.46995729207992554,
-0.5797207951545715,
0.6284874677658081,
-0.7376008629798889,
-0.5769139528274536,
-0.47765442728996277,
0.10243639349937439,
0.04364960268139839,
0.20244675874710083,
0.2822953164577484,
-0.2771373689174652,
-0.44479405879974365,
-0.6556563973426819,
-0.4006158411502838,
-0.10566817224025726,
-0.03907930850982666,
0.24277809262275696,
0.29042208194732666,
0.09001924842596054,
0.5492157936096191,
-0.5344604253768921,
-0.5210749506950378,
-0.35779616236686707,
0.17898061871528625,
0.5599273443222046,
0.6750200390815735,
0.42745745182037354,
-0.583539605140686,
-0.37483981251716614,
0.060455404222011566,
-0.5049436092376709,
-0.23737555742263794,
-0.11789730936288834,
0.01820450834929943,
-0.014239382930099964,
0.6074453592300415,
-0.11293643712997437,
-0.03138035535812378,
1.0464534759521484,
-0.08460333943367004,
0.30800169706344604,
-0.39660874009132385,
-0.006943033076822758,
-1.0970969200134277,
-0.1506454199552536,
-0.4512231945991516,
-0.49705982208251953,
-0.20369504392147064,
0.1432206928730011,
-0.181747704744339,
-0.24627970159053802,
-0.31713321805000305,
0.35010913014411926,
-0.6308408379554749,
-0.4034287631511688,
-0.27377042174339294,
0.04764379560947418,
-0.368417888879776,
0.5384195446968079,
-0.1569836288690567,
0.7524732351303101,
0.5454026460647583,
-0.6374119520187378,
0.0830577164888382,
0.2669346034526825,
-0.476214736700058,
0.4163963198661804,
-0.7332091331481934,
-0.02032634988427162,
-0.3089176118373871,
0.18959248065948486,
-1.0019513368606567,
-0.22031442821025848,
0.167183980345726,
-0.030377093702554703,
0.3187679946422577,
-0.8416163921356201,
-0.2657816708087921,
-0.06028377637267113,
-0.455316960811615,
0.4423406422138214,
0.5867950320243835,
-0.7516188025474548,
0.3446752429008484,
0.4599875211715698,
-0.591727077960968,
-0.15593385696411133,
-0.4294252097606659,
-0.015901103615760803,
-0.30761510133743286,
-0.24882513284683228,
0.7147098779678345,
-0.2726705074310303,
-0.0394117571413517,
-0.39352476596832275,
-0.6605647206306458,
0.005841364618390799,
0.49225711822509766,
0.45910385251045227,
0.07995006442070007,
-0.1370183676481247,
-0.17148494720458984,
0.27506932616233826,
-0.213687464594841,
-0.3496395945549011,
0.08255437016487122,
0.48671814799308777,
0.12151545286178589,
-0.383284330368042,
-0.36089763045310974,
-0.2774639427661896,
0.8438234329223633,
0.05937511473894119,
0.6637839674949646,
0.0810999795794487,
-0.19117651879787445,
-0.3152247369289398,
-0.249088317155838,
-0.08769065886735916,
-0.5627360939979553,
0.5024911165237427,
-0.5808264017105103,
-0.7377215027809143,
0.2964344322681427,
-0.5716652274131775,
0.1675807684659958,
0.22416889667510986,
0.4115990102291107,
0.0870329961180687,
0.9908920526504517,
0.6766021251678467,
-0.1724897027015686,
0.7924944758415222,
-0.020925244316458702,
0.11826334148645401,
-0.8181736469268799,
0.1594875603914261,
-0.5230982303619385,
-0.9199756383895874,
-0.8458405137062073,
-0.5370309352874756,
0.4951235353946686,
0.18593452870845795,
-0.2366005778312683,
0.37123069167137146,
-0.7657701373100281,
0.4164261817932129,
0.11667244881391525,
-0.14586159586906433,
0.6147763729095459,
0.023398833349347115,
0.2066054344177246,
-0.1037534773349762,
-0.7433615326881409,
-0.34976688027381897,
0.4182329773902893,
0.4057832658290863,
0.9116896986961365,
0.2586132884025574,
0.6769197583198547,
0.2848019003868103,
0.2575322389602661,
-1.001652479171753,
0.5566526055335999,
-0.2578667104244232,
-0.13669750094413757,
-0.3132549524307251,
-0.48126617074012756,
-0.8530271649360657,
0.6122912168502808,
0.10280272364616394,
-0.7637684345245361,
0.4554211497306824,
0.19028668105602264,
-0.29310351610183716,
0.2965743839740753,
-0.28574538230895996,
0.7119042277336121,
-0.31805160641670227,
-0.05169505253434181,
-0.2030021697282791,
-0.4603995084762573,
0.09047935903072357,
-0.26827573776245117,
0.1001843810081482,
-0.5245869755744934,
-0.10061945766210556,
0.9657242894172668,
-0.5492119193077087,
0.5954325199127197,
-0.2946532666683197,
-0.04841122031211853,
-0.49779948592185974,
0.23804064095020294,
0.879457414150238,
-0.09065558016300201,
-0.4618279039859772,
-0.18929384648799896,
0.21591506898403168,
-0.32509273290634155,
-0.4433169960975647,
0.925622284412384,
-0.9422191977500916,
-0.5008672475814819,
-0.484330415725708,
-0.701542854309082,
-0.11757509410381317,
0.17330703139305115,
-0.05183327570557594,
0.31495121121406555,
-0.10752836614847183,
0.5426182150840759,
0.14131572842597961,
-0.12559325993061066,
0.49155595898628235,
0.42341724038124084,
0.11586922407150269,
-0.19651386141777039,
0.9520245790481567,
0.15776191651821136,
0.09529381990432739,
0.6492629647254944,
0.1616670936346054,
0.3197982907295227,
-1.0157614946365356,
-0.46351516246795654,
-0.006273776758462191,
-0.4955076277256012,
-0.38328245282173157,
-0.31061506271362305,
-0.30631428956985474,
-0.018290504813194275,
-0.3144652545452118,
-0.4922088384628296,
-0.776952862739563,
0.033028364181518555,
0.014336192049086094,
0.2832272946834564,
0.424815833568573,
0.2579418420791626,
0.6079584956169128,
-0.37911808490753174,
0.6538206934928894,
0.17179448902606964,
0.24557267129421234,
-0.24299775063991547,
-0.9786450266838074,
-0.003933990374207497,
-0.2720544934272766,
-0.12404672056436539,
-0.4649960696697235,
0.45507943630218506,
0.6565916538238525,
0.49859991669654846,
0.15184681117534637,
0.31910109519958496,
0.9924448728561401,
-0.5462747812271118,
0.38490718603134155,
-0.34198302030563354,
-0.5418741703033447,
0.5999419689178467,
-0.3606514632701874,
0.4920763373374939,
0.7411739230155945,
0.22442041337490082,
-0.2368321716785431,
-0.47271761298179626,
-0.149782195687294,
-0.9947834610939026,
0.7226319909095764,
0.12198422104120255,
-0.18301169574260712,
0.3369057774543762,
0.2794407904148102,
-0.03355957940220833,
0.14777563512325287,
-0.7754093408584595,
-0.0030817862134426832,
-0.14805766940116882,
-0.30001822113990784,
0.041479043662548065,
-0.20459425449371338,
-0.18266433477401733,
-0.4510585367679596,
0.6177329421043396,
-0.5239364504814148,
0.15706992149353027,
-0.11847642809152603,
-0.5559327006340027,
-0.45328956842422485,
0.3443852365016937,
0.24676646292209625,
0.8600736260414124,
-0.5487016439437866,
0.13006587326526642,
0.3802710175514221,
-0.32559943199157715,
0.13229860365390778,
0.30921876430511475,
-0.1394488513469696,
-0.25691521167755127,
0.158375546336174,
0.799372673034668,
0.7443673014640808,
-0.4371081292629242,
0.26845234632492065,
0.13146404922008514,
-0.02422245591878891,
-0.18209251761436462,
0.2210884839296341,
-0.09335330128669739,
0.07861850410699844,
0.5370612144470215,
0.24489614367485046,
-0.14182281494140625,
-0.4586116671562195,
-0.020733702927827835,
0.2284378558397293,
-0.19549909234046936,
-0.2801847755908966,
0.7651199102401733,
0.23299942910671234,
-0.3340820372104645,
0.19506724178791046,
0.309293657541275,
-0.27603277564048767,
0.4725072681903839,
0.4753560721874237,
0.46373555064201355,
-0.3441714942455292,
-0.0236662570387125,
0.24461430311203003,
0.23249034583568573,
0.06188664585351944,
0.2455785721540451,
-0.1532876342535019,
-0.5553678870201111,
-0.5918254256248474,
-1.133002758026123,
-0.37414199113845825,
-0.10242704302072525,
-0.5359703898429871,
0.24870438873767853,
-0.6217377781867981,
0.24080543220043182,
0.05085160210728645,
0.07299113273620605,
-0.17143139243125916,
0.011289277113974094,
-0.18175773322582245,
1.0361906290054321,
-0.6048701405525208,
1.084202766418457,
0.7433081269264221,
-0.09168815612792969,
-0.6154513955116272,
0.1705733835697174,
0.0796908587217331,
-0.8205937147140503,
0.7322146892547607,
-0.1070503294467926,
-0.277273952960968,
0.6054518818855286,
-0.13676290214061737,
-1.0857164859771729,
1.227272868156433,
0.5973052382469177,
-0.5914441347122192,
-0.29038006067276,
-0.014558112248778343,
0.41087421774864197,
-0.17061595618724823,
0.04999332129955292,
0.3454047739505768,
0.6131885647773743,
0.3299431800842285,
-0.9143982529640198,
0.15932069718837738,
-0.19671134650707245,
0.08472591638565063,
0.3794551193714142,
-0.6864810585975647,
0.5943604707717896,
0.06339547783136368,
0.0017893959302455187,
0.2783764600753784,
0.4731743633747101,
0.5010568499565125,
-0.33203747868537903,
0.843512773513794,
0.3353165090084076,
0.7689680457115173,
-0.04053238779306412,
0.8745207190513611,
-0.5095197558403015,
0.09943774342536926,
1.14822518825531,
-0.344726026058197,
1.0504792928695679,
0.5986854434013367,
0.06554185599088669,
0.6663062572479248,
0.6700724959373474,
-0.0029938044026494026,
0.5595250129699707,
0.2366289347410202,
0.2001762092113495,
-0.31932559609413147,
0.08944257348775864,
-0.3971036374568939,
0.5046905875205994,
0.10527155548334122,
-0.11403252184391022,
-0.3611854910850525,
-0.2742300033569336,
-0.08576160669326782,
-0.26951175928115845,
-0.43059536814689636,
0.7975192070007324,
0.01645229570567608,
-0.7275687456130981,
0.961461067199707,
0.11705702543258667,
0.7390760183334351,
-0.48366469144821167,
0.07052101194858551,
-0.2125268429517746,
0.5799002647399902,
-0.2957497537136078,
-0.20114955306053162,
0.19547240436077118,
-0.2447306215763092,
-0.07332780212163925,
-0.5859309434890747,
0.8562663793563843,
-0.28612378239631653,
-0.4359375834465027,
0.1686158925294876,
0.4619111716747284,
0.2880092263221741,
-0.049539607018232346,
-0.5899784564971924,
0.40294674038887024,
-0.3492751121520996,
-0.4451499283313751,
0.7427006959915161,
0.03526008874177933,
-0.26717689633369446,
0.764555811882019,
0.6442239880561829,
0.4676845073699951,
-0.03321107104420662,
0.17145304381847382,
1.0238358974456787,
-0.5033906698226929,
-0.5102010369300842,
-0.430097758769989,
0.34415918588638306,
-0.015047300606966019,
-0.12302961200475693,
0.5620499849319458,
0.5447273254394531,
0.482445627450943,
0.014289354905486107,
0.30821654200553894,
-0.040361348539590836,
0.5502565503120422,
-0.4109066426753998,
0.8043285608291626,
-0.7935968041419983,
0.39862585067749023,
-0.2222062349319458,
-1.099311351776123,
-0.2713879942893982,
0.7041606903076172,
-0.2872254550457001,
-0.0638570785522461,
0.6546792984008789,
0.6955529451370239,
-0.40893635153770447,
-0.5817989706993103,
0.3672255873680115,
0.5413779616355896,
0.13185817003250122,
0.3632165789604187,
0.6657878756523132,
-0.5726320147514343,
0.6735246777534485,
0.08872029185295105,
-0.29539018869400024,
-0.5303916335105896,
-1.138429880142212,
-0.5194279551506042,
-0.0028610776644200087,
-0.63173907995224,
0.16529680788516998,
0.5199375152587891,
0.6896216869354248,
0.9808960556983948,
-0.758151650428772,
-0.35207223892211914,
-0.15373963117599487,
0.316307932138443,
-0.4444432258605957,
-0.2450464963912964,
0.238057941198349,
-0.12712056934833527,
-0.8534475564956665,
0.9502888321876526,
0.3382657468318939,
-0.32341474294662476,
0.1119011640548706,
-0.1864105612039566,
-0.1276705265045166,
-0.0981212630867958,
0.5181741118431091,
0.25639453530311584,
-0.5147091150283813,
-0.4235493540763855,
-0.5530950427055359,
0.0911269336938858,
0.4194011390209198,
0.6506472229957581,
-0.907453715801239,
-0.10582812875509262,
0.72174471616745,
0.567132294178009,
0.5228148698806763,
0.39534521102905273,
0.5157961249351501,
-1.0874987840652466,
0.3103831112384796,
0.1820199340581894,
0.37713852524757385,
0.2666003406047821,
-0.2431555688381195,
0.5128631591796875,
0.1849752962589264,
-0.7712255716323853,
-1.1985279321670532,
0.231424480676651,
-1.2161853313446045,
-0.29185760021209717,
1.0267211198806763,
0.25809046626091003,
-0.22901007533073425,
-0.00787416286766529,
-0.27547311782836914,
0.1807425618171692,
-0.32824528217315674,
0.663058340549469,
0.13408814370632172,
0.00881063099950552,
-0.4862876236438751,
-0.5802742838859558,
0.5760385394096375,
0.45976611971855164,
-0.9904966950416565,
0.020856695249676704,
0.2391919046640396,
0.34022146463394165,
-0.13135069608688354,
0.514434278011322,
0.01703384332358837,
0.06375951319932938,
-0.4333166480064392,
-0.08587736636400223,
-0.19044563174247742,
-0.2892563045024872,
-0.3354279100894928,
0.43065086007118225,
0.6420305371284485,
-0.19764430820941925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15723v1 | Acoustic Feature Mixup for Balanced Multi-aspect Pronunciation Assessment | 2024-06-22T03:56:29 | 2024-06-22T03:56:29 | Heejin Do, Wonjun Lee, Gary Geunbae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | In automated pronunciation assessment, recent emphasis progressively lies on
evaluating multiple aspects to provide enriched feedback. However, acquiring
multi-aspect-score labeled data for non-native language learners' speech poses
challenges; moreover, it often leads to score-imbalanced distributions. In this
paper, we propose two Acoustic Feature Mixup strategies, linearly and
non-linearly interpolating with the in-batch averaged feature, to address data
scarcity and score-label imbalances. Primarily using goodness-of-pronunciation
as an acoustic feature, we tailor mixup designs to suit pronunciation
assessment. Further, we integrate fine-grained error-rate features by comparing
speech recognition results with the original answer phonemes, giving direct
hints for mispronunciation. Effective mixing of the acoustic features notably
enhances overall scoring performances on the speechocean762 dataset, and
detailed analysis highlights our potential to predict unseen distortions. | [
-0.8290649056434631,
-0.5495513081550598,
-0.0182346198707819,
0.4894760251045227,
-0.39505693316459656,
0.3226953446865082,
-0.18779219686985016,
-0.6533828377723694,
0.7069834470748901,
0.35211533308029175,
-0.16681601107120514,
-0.26842203736305237,
-0.3958231508731842,
-0.12515805661678314,
-0.15440036356449127,
0.7798606157302856,
0.17143428325653076,
0.1805088222026825,
-0.16553246974945068,
-0.667871356010437,
-0.9178041815757751,
-0.6080825924873352,
-0.4519903361797333,
-0.4478110373020172,
0.2999992072582245,
0.5730615258216858,
0.8038777112960815,
0.45344114303588867,
0.20467433333396912,
0.3104955554008484,
-0.20621925592422485,
0.3365902602672577,
-0.14506879448890686,
0.12860488891601562,
0.05550934746861458,
-0.0402931272983551,
-0.799908459186554,
0.31312793493270874,
0.77744060754776,
0.8293629288673401,
-0.20097950100898743,
0.1869303435087204,
0.2712376117706299,
0.015140412375330925,
-0.5589454770088196,
-0.06483016908168793,
-0.6177224516868591,
0.0512622632086277,
-0.21888934075832367,
-0.4065643548965454,
0.05957438424229622,
-0.26973193883895874,
0.1451658308506012,
-0.44655779004096985,
0.10118579119443893,
-0.18151910603046417,
0.48285582661628723,
0.3495858311653137,
0.014664405956864357,
-0.31321388483047485,
-0.5604428648948669,
0.9418981671333313,
-0.8453541994094849,
0.3700542151927948,
0.42180824279785156,
0.29347941279411316,
-0.04670754075050354,
0.038795460015535355,
-0.7816447019577026,
-0.23097582161426544,
0.25236886739730835,
0.20407016575336456,
0.045016560703516006,
0.16910381615161896,
-0.12298882007598877,
0.5920858979225159,
-0.3384983539581299,
0.4945437014102936,
-0.3669893145561218,
-0.530846118927002,
0.6512370705604553,
-0.20997729897499084,
0.13380777835845947,
-0.07836689800024033,
-0.38381654024124146,
-0.6914728283882141,
-0.09194967150688171,
0.31084755063056946,
0.6636447906494141,
0.9718189239501953,
-0.14929743111133575,
0.6646972298622131,
-0.04662097617983818,
0.540726363658905,
0.3543788194656372,
-0.30260857939720154,
0.7505595088005066,
-0.35105961561203003,
-0.2497069090604782,
0.47746583819389343,
0.7927238345146179,
0.35051724314689636,
-0.3203669786453247,
0.03867339342832565,
-0.45621004700660706,
-0.19404485821723938,
0.16515330970287323,
-0.3573286533355713,
-0.18034717440605164,
0.5797106027603149,
-0.1338580846786499,
-0.29474788904190063,
-0.10815640538930893,
-1.0238585472106934,
-0.44608232378959656,
-0.4978404939174652,
0.7676897048950195,
-0.28895920515060425,
-0.20037677884101868,
-0.268429160118103,
-0.22231419384479523,
-0.017927497625350952,
0.2752073407173157,
-0.66351318359375,
0.23053456842899323,
0.47880762815475464,
0.7890000343322754,
0.14781807363033295,
-0.2801209092140198,
-1.0567744970321655,
-0.5871450901031494,
-0.2060462385416031,
0.5790508389472961,
-0.6684873104095459,
-0.5664920210838318,
-0.1742507964372635,
-0.467247873544693,
0.15855535864830017,
-1.073249340057373,
0.5366637110710144,
0.2150115966796875,
0.33515870571136475,
-0.11651309579610825,
-0.6036174297332764,
-0.30892661213874817,
0.16051892936229706,
-0.7316927313804626,
1.377700924873352,
0.31592729687690735,
-0.44821804761886597,
0.5740042924880981,
-0.24822528660297394,
-0.4610402584075928,
0.1456308662891388,
-0.04755869880318642,
-0.5382314920425415,
0.20791922509670258,
0.24241359531879425,
0.11683546751737595,
0.08070574700832367,
-0.034159205853939056,
-0.4714509844779968,
-0.43257415294647217,
0.45224183797836304,
-0.7277968525886536,
0.35797590017318726,
-0.027488291263580322,
-0.2088262438774109,
-0.09289534389972687,
-0.8933656811714172,
0.47027072310447693,
-0.6418822407722473,
-0.6633940935134888,
-0.28407108783721924,
-0.18711254000663757,
0.3301049470901489,
0.17435887455940247,
0.12897764146327972,
-0.2749617397785187,
0.04130074381828308,
-0.2055131196975708,
0.12366843968629837,
0.3430359959602356,
0.11555535346269608,
0.38712695240974426,
-0.5512615442276001,
0.502122163772583,
0.25237616896629333,
0.19545878469944,
0.08559560775756836,
-0.5757328867912292,
-0.7484826445579529,
-0.41166549921035767,
0.5943030118942261,
0.8727762699127197,
-0.5119845867156982,
0.6469873785972595,
0.1316131353378296,
-0.4998707175254822,
-1.1222295761108398,
0.3592018783092499,
0.6748310923576355,
0.3213041424751282,
1.0267783403396606,
-0.6630895733833313,
-0.22985441982746124,
-0.4919550120830536,
-0.34689950942993164,
-0.24070952832698822,
-0.14335942268371582,
0.3069455325603485,
-0.1318967193365097,
0.09661760926246643,
0.5551601052284241,
0.20841839909553528,
-0.4122934937477112,
-0.04451419413089752,
0.3922542333602905,
0.13451999425888062,
0.4959850311279297,
0.48864471912384033,
-0.6129641532897949,
-0.005762958433479071,
0.013026854023337364,
-0.2942679524421692,
-0.23298950493335724,
-0.018185317516326904,
0.31492576003074646,
-0.08792814612388611,
0.14726980030536652,
-0.20930704474449158,
0.15922018885612488,
0.45657941699028015,
-0.0026760066393762827,
0.4335625469684601,
-0.16768981516361237,
0.49713218212127686,
-0.7463352084159851,
-0.45349594950675964,
0.059803809970617294,
-0.07392586767673492,
-0.502705991268158,
-0.21382573246955872,
-0.05675721913576126,
0.02109708823263645,
-0.6450197696685791,
0.42748454213142395,
-0.20506341755390167,
-0.12843218445777893,
-0.290798544883728,
0.22829414904117584,
0.009417449124157429,
0.26399630308151245,
-0.42759180068969727,
0.6662697196006775,
0.3360958695411682,
-0.5147522687911987,
0.2814670205116272,
-0.15846548974514008,
-0.09403766691684723,
0.867883026599884,
-0.31311067938804626,
0.29604387283325195,
0.004887778777629137,
-0.02942499704658985,
-0.9971995949745178,
-0.19028355181217194,
-0.07713915407657623,
-0.5181701183319092,
0.5829965472221375,
-0.25786396861076355,
-0.27189815044403076,
-0.1101856529712677,
-0.46264714002609253,
0.48044127225875854,
0.33649417757987976,
-0.43025609850883484,
0.6058582067489624,
0.4886719882488251,
-0.19750329852104187,
-0.7180693745613098,
-0.4388834536075592,
0.10264372825622559,
-0.7017741203308105,
-0.3788301348686218,
0.3883935213088989,
-0.09133697301149368,
-0.4744013249874115,
-0.15558983385562897,
-0.1465575397014618,
-0.16798825562000275,
-0.09326186031103134,
0.2070186883211136,
0.1846311390399933,
-0.2954375147819519,
-0.00766371376812458,
0.30442965030670166,
0.009172044694423676,
-0.46602538228034973,
-0.45670363306999207,
0.31529635190963745,
0.016552481800317764,
-0.1191800981760025,
-0.41822147369384766,
0.4036126732826233,
0.798636794090271,
-0.03682814538478851,
0.16606195271015167,
0.4695730209350586,
-0.3323320746421814,
-0.06773017346858978,
-0.6703705191612244,
-0.14020414650440216,
-0.41734933853149414,
0.30457234382629395,
-0.29866600036621094,
-0.46797046065330505,
0.598538875579834,
0.08054070174694061,
0.30450639128685,
0.14385256171226501,
0.2993321120738983,
-0.5242741703987122,
0.34190064668655396,
0.17089170217514038,
-0.32460349798202515,
0.26303979754447937,
-0.058335840702056885,
0.28183403611183167,
-0.7844052314758301,
-0.0494951568543911,
-0.4466666877269745,
-0.6443324089050293,
-0.7005555033683777,
-0.7041305899620056,
0.3436477482318878,
0.45562851428985596,
0.4459274709224701,
0.31472665071487427,
-0.2684834897518158,
0.4255015552043915,
0.6737884879112244,
0.20734891295433044,
0.1527930498123169,
0.025935761630535126,
-0.303303062915802,
-0.20043222606182098,
-0.21981064975261688,
-0.025688745081424713,
0.9182957410812378,
0.26086512207984924,
0.36477717757225037,
0.07662521302700043,
0.9623706340789795,
0.5846747756004333,
-0.2464619278907776,
-0.9105144739151001,
0.2290811538696289,
-0.3845144510269165,
-0.025674350559711456,
-0.42236047983169556,
-0.41743066906929016,
-0.32063281536102295,
0.5470505356788635,
-0.4854489862918854,
-0.25867268443107605,
0.40486645698547363,
0.4575377106666565,
-0.31865808367729187,
-0.06797870993614197,
-0.7199773788452148,
0.4988570809364319,
-0.4432179927825928,
-0.06982564181089401,
0.005744547583162785,
-0.24574321508407593,
0.05619014427065849,
-0.24328875541687012,
0.5777497291564941,
0.009651564992964268,
0.4413839280605316,
0.5095854997634888,
-0.6217754483222961,
0.60187166929245,
-0.40071046352386475,
-0.0745527446269989,
0.4097426235675812,
0.003571314038708806,
0.12223313003778458,
-0.11745597422122955,
-0.20351730287075043,
0.4619615972042084,
-0.29196062684059143,
-0.2853038012981415,
-0.6779050827026367,
0.6540618538856506,
-0.8308011293411255,
-0.05988183617591858,
-0.18288284540176392,
-0.36741384863853455,
-0.4757038354873657,
-0.26040950417518616,
0.4578373432159424,
0.6662499904632568,
0.005330375395715237,
-0.10945301502943039,
0.3935771584510803,
-0.11878594011068344,
0.3277071714401245,
0.06038839370012283,
0.08162099123001099,
-0.7492032051086426,
1.3203480243682861,
0.5106189846992493,
0.5932905077934265,
0.2028171718120575,
0.4097445011138916,
-0.468715637922287,
-0.48011237382888794,
-0.4598686695098877,
-0.09800226986408234,
-0.7933164238929749,
0.030894462019205093,
-0.20686359703540802,
-0.15477769076824188,
-0.25557881593704224,
-0.025896314531564713,
-0.6117263436317444,
-0.5931546092033386,
-0.08382172882556915,
-0.18283390998840332,
0.30289173126220703,
0.5560282468795776,
-0.33383044600486755,
0.36498135328292847,
-0.4458599090576172,
0.2173834592103958,
0.3025292754173279,
-0.01451179664582014,
-0.14307166635990143,
-0.7188427448272705,
-0.06919041275978088,
0.15621045231819153,
-0.4732051193714142,
-0.6809381246566772,
0.2827897071838379,
0.4152790606021881,
0.5808221101760864,
0.35086265206336975,
-0.12377243489027023,
1.0018140077590942,
-0.15480126440525055,
0.6414620876312256,
0.15099528431892395,
-1.069140076637268,
0.33513665199279785,
-0.06247000768780708,
0.16988249123096466,
0.7279857993125916,
-0.208906352519989,
-0.443912535905838,
-0.8549603223800659,
-0.6335938572883606,
-1.2601194381713867,
0.31408989429473877,
0.27968621253967285,
-0.014835182577371597,
0.13969172537326813,
0.07560103386640549,
0.2339392453432083,
0.26562607288360596,
-0.3422411382198334,
-0.43833938241004944,
-0.6688387393951416,
-0.22440339624881744,
-0.04249580204486847,
0.05303255841135979,
-0.053423263132572174,
-0.2931821346282959,
0.5102391839027405,
-0.08580692112445831,
-0.01695474050939083,
-0.1625608205795288,
0.03672071546316147,
0.12686553597450256,
0.628557026386261,
0.6277904510498047,
0.3506012260913849,
-0.3045262098312378,
0.2107435166835785,
0.2555410861968994,
-0.835810124874115,
0.10837498307228088,
0.25009456276893616,
-0.007183922920376062,
0.22236835956573486,
0.4591953158378601,
0.8116694092750549,
0.40679749846458435,
-0.34481093287467957,
0.2528437077999115,
0.06410562992095947,
-0.24672099947929382,
-0.07427365332841873,
0.1415342539548874,
-0.1516171246767044,
0.284997820854187,
0.4192928373813629,
0.29136979579925537,
0.2518359422683716,
-0.38054779171943665,
0.21547842025756836,
0.226443350315094,
-0.522053062915802,
-0.0326513946056366,
0.2669386565685272,
0.19591155648231506,
-0.3664056062698364,
0.7063932418823242,
-0.39131486415863037,
-0.3882155120372772,
0.7186129093170166,
0.18740339577198029,
0.7538848519325256,
-0.6311556100845337,
0.09160645306110382,
0.21264716982841492,
0.37418779730796814,
0.11352962255477905,
0.5414069890975952,
-0.21484889090061188,
-0.4904710650444031,
-0.1640888750553131,
-0.5806735157966614,
-0.8108401894569397,
0.3842540383338928,
-0.8199266791343689,
0.4570569097995758,
-0.4387432038784027,
-0.24398767948150635,
0.22557565569877625,
-0.24704168736934662,
-0.7054274678230286,
0.34593671560287476,
0.30158472061157227,
0.23157759010791779,
-0.8285431265830994,
0.5740936398506165,
0.40944531559944153,
-0.4254920780658722,
-0.9065878391265869,
0.17538534104824066,
0.30948007106781006,
-0.502237856388092,
0.20111313462257385,
0.3220200538635254,
-0.09652850031852722,
-0.45218029618263245,
0.14921346306800842,
-0.5130459070205688,
0.5984172821044922,
0.20017258822917938,
-0.6086853742599487,
0.3117595911026001,
0.37045562267303467,
0.3045865297317505,
-0.23137420415878296,
0.4606584906578064,
0.685296893119812,
0.48814359307289124,
0.30834752321243286,
-1.4804071187973022,
-0.4659290313720703,
-0.26687872409820557,
-0.3280186355113983,
0.18796038627624512,
-0.29192671179771423,
1.024989366531372,
-0.12081541866064072,
0.0968342274427414,
-0.27187082171440125,
0.50242018699646,
0.2941787838935852,
0.5881932377815247,
0.7086430788040161,
0.7504041194915771,
1.2033482789993286,
0.019241223111748695,
0.49132654070854187,
-0.018818449229002,
0.2839418053627014,
1.3085821866989136,
-0.10749903321266174,
1.1068739891052246,
0.44098418951034546,
-0.23427115380764008,
0.11830436438322067,
0.6910821199417114,
0.1329444795846939,
0.4692668616771698,
0.16236355900764465,
-0.4491196870803833,
-0.10300496220588684,
-0.06743732839822769,
-0.2613432705402374,
0.963563084602356,
0.5637420415878296,
0.058580514043569565,
-0.20622286200523376,
0.3285060524940491,
-0.08564227819442749,
-0.09061236679553986,
-0.3590295612812042,
0.6704826354980469,
-0.0799223929643631,
-0.4088341295719147,
0.7439469695091248,
-0.19970986247062683,
0.7588542699813843,
-0.14628858864307404,
-0.40936005115509033,
-0.5036634206771851,
-0.06667399406433105,
-0.30112871527671814,
-0.8354079723358154,
-0.046847227960824966,
-0.2775844633579254,
-0.3122512698173523,
0.1682053953409195,
-0.09537378698587418,
-0.7593251466751099,
-0.41627055406570435,
0.5067875981330872,
0.10599690675735474,
0.20072701573371887,
-0.0855945572257042,
-0.5863130688667297,
0.10071633756160736,
-0.21012352406978607,
0.44791126251220703,
0.22469158470630646,
0.42196112871170044,
-0.27053695917129517,
0.18514378368854523,
0.5892686247825623,
0.30887848138809204,
0.3659232258796692,
0.4648606479167938,
0.4423154890537262,
-0.3560939431190491,
-0.6547278165817261,
-0.580498218536377,
0.427951455116272,
0.06276442855596542,
-0.6362143754959106,
0.5439845323562622,
0.3578489422798157,
0.9103397130966187,
0.3053401708602905,
0.845215380191803,
0.328908234834671,
0.614628255367279,
-0.627189576625824,
0.4176940619945526,
-0.509314239025116,
0.27207693457603455,
-0.5660491585731506,
-1.0217454433441162,
0.02403319627046585,
0.4228643774986267,
0.22382687032222748,
0.2619148790836334,
0.31988248229026794,
0.4104432463645935,
-0.24266137182712555,
-0.0013548064744099975,
0.34066277742385864,
0.14136256277561188,
0.2963734567165375,
0.09576991200447083,
0.5757741332054138,
-0.4779137074947357,
0.16334865987300873,
-0.4567917287349701,
-0.4376603662967682,
-0.47041478753089905,
-0.6123066544532776,
-0.5868896842002869,
-0.47191134095191956,
-0.4801807999610901,
-0.4653281569480896,
-0.2717972695827484,
0.888670027256012,
0.645115315914154,
-0.8078818917274475,
-0.3199314773082733,
0.49868884682655334,
0.02354777790606022,
-0.6590218544006348,
-0.2356346845626831,
0.12385661900043488,
-0.29559415578842163,
-0.6049437522888184,
0.9027008414268494,
0.3170735836029053,
0.24058054387569427,
-0.31080272793769836,
0.1034005731344223,
0.25816065073013306,
0.269608736038208,
0.3686467707157135,
0.3692139983177185,
-0.6739173531532288,
-0.2864179015159607,
-0.12014677375555038,
0.36590713262557983,
0.17719006538391113,
0.6677607297897339,
-0.6354062557220459,
0.9931584596633911,
0.29356712102890015,
0.3811478614807129,
0.0042681037448346615,
0.2300967574119568,
0.3151338994503021,
-1.0999284982681274,
0.43535324931144714,
0.2705693244934082,
0.3358207046985626,
0.7011851072311401,
-0.47546014189720154,
0.00513417785987258,
0.10761641710996628,
-0.21029967069625854,
-0.7300408482551575,
-0.36287760734558105,
-1.2783879041671753,
0.10600028187036514,
0.6048204898834229,
0.09443406760692596,
0.23188774287700653,
-0.20367087423801422,
0.13294239342212677,
0.0200079046189785,
-0.575962245464325,
0.8014197945594788,
0.6910583972930908,
-0.2781160771846771,
-0.08939220011234283,
-0.5897049307823181,
0.42977187037467957,
0.27735987305641174,
-0.5996432900428772,
-0.32206016778945923,
0.4367237091064453,
0.2154591828584671,
0.5131313800811768,
0.35716259479522705,
-0.029681110754609108,
0.3590913712978363,
-0.000737128546461463,
0.1151198223233223,
0.09139500558376312,
-0.6243610382080078,
-0.43692734837532043,
-0.06330776959657669,
0.076437808573246,
-0.6781505346298218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15720v1 | Scaling Laws for Fact Memorization of Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T03:32:09 | 2024-06-22T03:32:09 | Xingyu Lu, Xiaonan Li, Qinyuan Cheng, Kai Ding, Xuanjing Huang, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fact knowledge memorization is crucial for Large Language Models (LLM) to
generate factual and reliable responses. However, the behaviors of LLM fact
memorization remain under-explored. In this paper, we analyze the scaling laws
for LLM's fact knowledge and LLMs' behaviors of memorizing different types of
facts. We find that LLMs' fact knowledge capacity has a linear and negative
exponential law relationship with model size and training epochs, respectively.
Estimated by the built scaling law, memorizing the whole Wikidata's facts
requires training an LLM with 1000B non-embed parameters for 100 epochs,
suggesting that using LLMs to memorize all public facts is almost implausible
for a general pre-training setting. Meanwhile, we find that LLMs can generalize
on unseen fact knowledge and its scaling law is similar to general
pre-training. Additionally, we analyze the compatibility and preference of
LLMs' fact memorization. For compatibility, we find LLMs struggle with
memorizing redundant facts in a unified way. Only when correlated facts have
the same direction and structure, the LLM can compatibly memorize them. This
shows the inefficiency of LLM memorization for redundant facts. For preference,
the LLM pays more attention to memorizing more frequent and difficult facts,
and the subsequent facts can overwrite prior facts' memorization, which
significantly hinders low-frequency facts memorization. Our findings reveal the
capacity and characteristics of LLMs' fact knowledge learning, which provide
directions for LLMs' fact knowledge augmentation. | [
-0.23986166715621948,
-0.871053159236908,
0.885097861289978,
-0.06526234745979309,
-0.3137909770011902,
-0.38909944891929626,
-0.33780741691589355,
-0.21361811459064484,
0.19117940962314606,
0.7315147519111633,
-0.30296188592910767,
-0.2537328898906708,
-0.6039042472839355,
-0.22258242964744568,
-0.22458888590335846,
1.312036156654358,
0.09702587127685547,
0.06155354902148247,
-0.6531068682670593,
-0.44154155254364014,
-0.07181739062070847,
-0.7787461280822754,
-0.30417293310165405,
-0.3714388906955719,
0.5859131813049316,
0.5152786374092102,
0.5187063813209534,
0.8849525451660156,
0.4643598198890686,
0.2997146248817444,
-0.2604336440563202,
0.09867025911808014,
-0.8333665132522583,
-0.13086529076099396,
-0.1071673110127449,
-0.7430158853530884,
-0.6595988273620605,
-0.052399661391973495,
0.7629095911979675,
0.7044108510017395,
-0.1694149374961853,
0.3258240520954132,
-0.10095929354429245,
0.7614322304725647,
-0.4664229154586792,
0.3643563687801361,
-0.6540157794952393,
-0.1337653398513794,
-0.010145291686058044,
-0.23231248557567596,
-0.40216419100761414,
-0.43400824069976807,
0.025151317939162254,
-0.7431689500808716,
0.24973393976688385,
0.2881813943386078,
0.6246545314788818,
0.184027761220932,
-0.6909562945365906,
-0.5146341919898987,
-0.6561352014541626,
0.6771815419197083,
-0.5718343257904053,
0.4188857674598694,
0.4409320056438446,
-0.1527097523212433,
0.0049577075988054276,
-0.5390135049819946,
-0.6643818020820618,
-0.4528879225254059,
-0.1998286247253418,
-0.2466110736131668,
-0.07739963382482529,
-0.002166649093851447,
0.7278793454170227,
0.2827368378639221,
-0.20467886328697205,
0.19545157253742218,
-0.34814518690109253,
-0.28145912289619446,
0.39953428506851196,
0.36898672580718994,
0.2672452926635742,
0.036505915224552155,
-0.4398740231990814,
0.02880217880010605,
-0.9787596464157104,
-0.011696943081915379,
-0.0485142283141613,
0.17936544120311737,
-0.11084967106580734,
0.5710105895996094,
0.019072597846388817,
0.2530955970287323,
0.07612530887126923,
-0.8417255282402039,
0.45953309535980225,
-0.3777633011341095,
-0.13239505887031555,
0.06477789580821991,
0.5931521058082581,
0.25759923458099365,
0.23013606667518616,
-0.19898296892642975,
-0.07799116522073746,
-0.710868239402771,
0.17369429767131805,
-0.8555370569229126,
0.17975948750972748,
-0.21215027570724487,
-0.3453527092933655,
0.18941670656204224,
-0.22582609951496124,
-0.4214553236961365,
-0.4320722222328186,
-0.44943365454673767,
0.9634969830513,
-0.3985225260257721,
-0.24132242798805237,
-0.1098850816488266,
0.01260247454047203,
0.2778899073600769,
0.4567726254463196,
-1.0614019632339478,
0.11128652840852737,
0.6544097065925598,
0.7955503463745117,
0.3005957007408142,
-0.41379237174987793,
-0.5486659407615662,
0.18915486335754395,
-0.2985679507255554,
0.3746102750301361,
-0.11467598378658295,
-0.06739656627178192,
-0.10494676232337952,
-0.10075200349092484,
-0.2300543189048767,
-0.3475501239299774,
0.40508177876472473,
-0.8628696799278259,
-0.2070099413394928,
-0.6468772888183594,
-0.9366204142570496,
-0.38267964124679565,
0.38962996006011963,
-0.7575997114181519,
0.485534131526947,
-0.21083112061023712,
-0.936099112033844,
0.41693663597106934,
-0.2108018398284912,
-0.6340779662132263,
-0.13247747719287872,
-0.038625627756118774,
-0.7631223797798157,
0.19713051617145538,
-0.24934011697769165,
0.6015088558197021,
-0.295479953289032,
0.22382275760173798,
-0.569589376449585,
-0.1608727127313614,
0.15023376047611237,
-0.4137200117111206,
0.6516895890235901,
0.04844193533062935,
0.023502424359321594,
-0.08669164776802063,
-0.897950291633606,
-0.3091367185115814,
0.13266287744045258,
-0.8509341478347778,
-0.31782159209251404,
0.11044152081012726,
-0.5034070611000061,
0.07412431389093399,
0.4173583984375,
-0.4719623029232025,
0.20403090119361877,
-0.02333078533411026,
0.28492820262908936,
0.5490156412124634,
0.3296288251876831,
0.4498032033443451,
-0.5250463485717773,
-0.042798060923814774,
0.037572480738162994,
-0.022559670731425285,
-0.005520155653357506,
-0.050642289221286774,
-0.8557268381118774,
-0.25482895970344543,
-0.10080447047948837,
0.34526416659355164,
-0.3557983934879303,
0.19229060411453247,
-0.516849160194397,
-0.48625490069389343,
0.049141377210617065,
0.38727471232414246,
0.25024503469467163,
0.6655248403549194,
0.3444104790687561,
0.013122730888426304,
-0.592013955116272,
-0.749875009059906,
-0.12764297425746918,
-0.33014917373657227,
0.027252916246652603,
0.25359782576560974,
0.6263279318809509,
0.0413333922624588,
0.7911513447761536,
-0.31295084953308105,
-0.3487567603588104,
-0.16188085079193115,
0.1723012775182724,
0.2512671649456024,
0.002879269188269973,
0.4947826862335205,
-0.7709794044494629,
-0.19306421279907227,
-0.054131459444761276,
-0.539563775062561,
0.21135708689689636,
0.03921474888920784,
0.4970705807209015,
0.38098084926605225,
0.8633604645729065,
-0.8426705598831177,
-0.0069406041875481606,
0.17086653411388397,
-0.17858688533306122,
0.4119224548339844,
-0.623085618019104,
-0.08878445625305176,
-0.8491628170013428,
-0.044147051870822906,
-0.13764534890651703,
-0.16699066758155823,
-0.8246997594833374,
-0.05479084700345993,
0.2259712964296341,
0.4133450984954834,
-0.4248746931552887,
0.19134128093719482,
-0.5636366605758667,
-0.10642126947641373,
-0.14186173677444458,
-0.0503670796751976,
-0.297129362821579,
0.6244924068450928,
0.06925233453512192,
0.6997162103652954,
0.27095451951026917,
-0.9779319763183594,
0.38701504468917847,
-0.11605412513017654,
-0.5427870154380798,
0.24189314246177673,
-0.25520050525665283,
-0.06410185247659683,
-0.16239964962005615,
0.17007151246070862,
-0.7787624001502991,
0.04197979345917702,
-0.3812316060066223,
-0.0312839150428772,
0.413547545671463,
-0.17225976288318634,
-0.6961184144020081,
-0.03899821639060974,
-0.2640453577041626,
0.23517517745494843,
0.6070064306259155,
-0.5847668051719666,
0.8385469913482666,
0.3570173978805542,
-0.0578109547495842,
-0.4868308901786804,
-0.4817781448364258,
-0.180316761136055,
-0.481658399105072,
-0.3629510700702667,
-0.1106003001332283,
-0.17057865858078003,
-0.29649215936660767,
-0.09284617006778717,
-0.2656634747982025,
0.03975162282586098,
0.046335190534591675,
0.27150580286979675,
0.20332027971744537,
-0.43483853340148926,
0.3984804153442383,
-0.46413350105285645,
0.2771458029747009,
0.45746439695358276,
-0.19402843713760376,
0.5498402118682861,
-0.24761612713336945,
-0.19712355732917786,
0.05142843723297119,
-0.2382659614086151,
0.8480060696601868,
0.01050324272364378,
1.0193065404891968,
0.5944275259971619,
-0.14751747250556946,
0.10261058062314987,
-0.8060045838356018,
-0.07948270440101624,
-0.3516257405281067,
0.6223934888839722,
-0.28668248653411865,
-0.9122239351272583,
0.5866348147392273,
-0.12488815933465958,
0.09492070227861404,
0.5854232907295227,
0.8336902260780334,
-0.15781377255916595,
0.5327150225639343,
0.5327374339103699,
-0.35891199111938477,
0.2817191183567047,
-0.14033159613609314,
-0.02076573669910431,
-0.6953666806221008,
-0.2978159189224243,
-0.3180277645587921,
-0.0760204866528511,
-0.5606144666671753,
-0.4388934075832367,
0.4806259870529175,
0.042505376040935516,
-0.5508173704147339,
0.08128176629543304,
0.4465256929397583,
0.5924068093299866,
0.47116759419441223,
0.11396759748458862,
0.5298720002174377,
0.0684448704123497,
-0.001794600859284401,
0.09532050043344498,
-0.6300846934318542,
-0.08875147253274918,
1.3469847440719604,
0.4726482927799225,
0.9703901410102844,
0.2459481805562973,
0.6384665966033936,
0.17022278904914856,
0.15463349223136902,
-0.8550552725791931,
0.5536235570907593,
-0.20913778245449066,
-0.6307387351989746,
-0.658284604549408,
-0.8050790429115295,
-0.4704236090183258,
0.19109125435352325,
-0.2828313410282135,
-0.42562657594680786,
-0.05243033170700073,
0.2139756679534912,
-0.22120478749275208,
0.6535491347312927,
-0.7293311357498169,
0.3224862217903137,
-0.1732483208179474,
-0.2430468648672104,
-0.5697330236434937,
-0.5806786417961121,
0.2714759409427643,
-0.2134532779455185,
0.4455724358558655,
0.013608330860733986,
-0.04430268704891205,
0.7667118310928345,
-0.41767191886901855,
1.0516364574432373,
-0.14229059219360352,
-0.2639165222644806,
0.20449616014957428,
-0.0030614701099693775,
0.6982311606407166,
-0.014046486467123032,
0.30438631772994995,
0.08397923409938812,
-0.27830633521080017,
-0.17723487317562103,
-0.5817713737487793,
0.5416488647460938,
-0.9322316646575928,
-0.9005144834518433,
-0.243266299366951,
-0.6590361595153809,
-0.21166041493415833,
0.16010895371437073,
0.25724688172340393,
0.2518312931060791,
-0.27847766876220703,
0.4866269528865814,
1.3161627054214478,
0.22366288304328918,
0.31172725558280945,
1.1223169565200806,
-0.041998427361249924,
-0.19133108854293823,
1.2441316843032837,
0.7633187174797058,
0.49164116382598877,
0.706086277961731,
0.17534705996513367,
-0.25338509678840637,
-0.7218749523162842,
0.03263157233595848,
0.4413144588470459,
-0.6962963342666626,
-0.11916525661945343,
-0.7396502494812012,
-0.5103585124015808,
-0.1927020251750946,
0.18838700652122498,
-0.17860952019691467,
-0.7419784665107727,
-0.16462711989879608,
-0.13408248126506805,
0.5643045902252197,
0.678554356098175,
-0.19017110764980316,
-0.07108078896999359,
-0.47598546743392944,
0.4628959596157074,
0.6183243989944458,
0.30176323652267456,
0.179982528090477,
-0.8754767775535583,
-0.4759230315685272,
-0.2409101128578186,
-0.2152104377746582,
-0.39293867349624634,
-0.11058877408504486,
0.3066260814666748,
0.48453545570373535,
0.6085913777351379,
0.07561342418193817,
0.32900384068489075,
-0.5441800355911255,
0.3347620666027069,
0.26396578550338745,
-0.519673764705658,
-0.003941753879189491,
-0.15814436972141266,
0.04829927533864975,
0.10138416290283203,
0.39872846007347107,
-0.5403100848197937,
-0.4159472584724426,
-0.6181192398071289,
-0.6881272792816162,
0.9000393748283386,
-0.27149882912635803,
0.36472833156585693,
0.17727965116500854,
0.4389917254447937,
0.019072741270065308,
0.08902399986982346,
-0.7267624735832214,
-0.13939440250396729,
-0.2916582524776459,
-0.09341567754745483,
-0.3442595601081848,
-0.6383297443389893,
-0.26481613516807556,
-0.3996222913265228,
0.7300105094909668,
0.10022588074207306,
-0.11120950430631638,
-0.048699751496315,
-0.4113991856575012,
-0.11790095269680023,
0.5396391153335571,
0.8251686096191406,
0.6426348090171814,
-0.3203301727771759,
0.2623688280582428,
0.6921758651733398,
-0.7679992318153381,
0.22699716687202454,
-0.1845342069864273,
-0.27207857370376587,
-0.48541921377182007,
0.697238028049469,
1.0748376846313477,
0.30408409237861633,
-0.3756755590438843,
0.5350466966629028,
0.010002397000789642,
-0.47033143043518066,
-0.331226646900177,
0.34329813718795776,
0.5557470321655273,
0.21286585927009583,
0.35528919100761414,
-0.2164166271686554,
-0.24645118415355682,
-0.7305885553359985,
0.11102204024791718,
0.30803006887435913,
-0.020084362477064133,
-0.3333645761013031,
0.2818436324596405,
-0.011091554537415504,
0.045592714101076126,
0.6442941427230835,
-0.11188432574272156,
-0.46411994099617004,
0.5847442150115967,
0.629538893699646,
0.31697529554367065,
-0.10825016349554062,
-0.03276405856013298,
0.6067105531692505,
0.3779758810997009,
-0.14686889946460724,
-0.11497907340526581,
-0.1116938367486,
-0.7545894980430603,
-0.2928623855113983,
-0.5543047785758972,
-0.32505491375923157,
0.46279358863830566,
-0.502709686756134,
0.20530320703983307,
-0.8761254549026489,
0.025874793529510498,
-0.06819646060466766,
0.3363739848136902,
-0.6957535743713379,
0.23497986793518066,
0.056113116443157196,
0.9410190582275391,
-0.789469301700592,
0.8647819757461548,
0.39709028601646423,
-0.5727404356002808,
-0.8561089634895325,
0.021418865770101547,
0.3405361473560333,
-1.1851894855499268,
0.7209537029266357,
-0.09084277600049973,
-0.006611926015466452,
-0.0841524675488472,
-0.38136184215545654,
-0.9124940633773804,
1.2736072540283203,
0.5504186749458313,
-0.7711585760116577,
-0.10330269485712051,
0.04270787164568901,
0.6826489567756653,
-0.4465552866458893,
0.23451602458953857,
0.5080265998840332,
0.3495018780231476,
0.35458576679229736,
-0.7920141220092773,
0.2063770443201065,
0.15682025253772736,
-0.2688472867012024,
0.32531771063804626,
-1.1023917198181152,
1.0788825750350952,
-0.6804126501083374,
-0.1315237283706665,
-0.32484129071235657,
0.6545823216438293,
0.0744398981332779,
0.30421510338783264,
0.5701541900634766,
0.7648699283599854,
0.7417930364608765,
0.27193325757980347,
0.7552735805511475,
-0.06350412219762802,
0.43288785219192505,
0.9874733090400696,
-0.08746405690908432,
0.7657972574234009,
0.43404054641723633,
-0.2619694471359253,
0.4255200922489166,
0.09826046973466873,
-0.18292807042598724,
0.146694153547287,
0.010515852831304073,
-0.1580106019973755,
-0.2946925163269043,
-0.04452452063560486,
-0.2884296476840973,
0.35602834820747375,
0.330448716878891,
-0.28942206501960754,
-0.2695096433162689,
-0.16884799301624298,
0.4899660646915436,
-0.20794659852981567,
-0.6036801934242249,
1.068420171737671,
0.050040122121572495,
-0.3291233479976654,
0.7396034002304077,
-0.2378145456314087,
0.2419089674949646,
-0.8601849675178528,
0.1805124431848526,
-0.2442808449268341,
0.07269393652677536,
-0.2534298896789551,
-0.8439134359359741,
0.04473515972495079,
-0.026244472712278366,
-0.6407265067100525,
0.029987651854753494,
0.4263547360897064,
-0.47510454058647156,
-0.22885018587112427,
0.26348966360092163,
0.18812835216522217,
0.12557712197303772,
0.13646994531154633,
-0.06987033039331436,
-0.23710426688194275,
0.03616490215063095,
-0.46971774101257324,
0.6428727507591248,
0.6282730102539062,
-0.11920204758644104,
0.8592485785484314,
0.4498230218887329,
0.2658717930316925,
0.2281646728515625,
0.22893215715885162,
0.8304120898246765,
-0.5725962519645691,
-0.3211674094200134,
-0.9505142569541931,
-0.020071428269147873,
0.01621067523956299,
0.06725949794054031,
0.9142702221870422,
0.5516695380210876,
0.6577894687652588,
0.045320410281419754,
0.47227415442466736,
0.04122598096728325,
0.4287049472332001,
-0.8486251831054688,
0.7219505310058594,
-0.4503224194049835,
0.2114294320344925,
0.2866690158843994,
-0.9069849848747253,
0.019946718588471413,
0.057016365230083466,
-0.32784926891326904,
0.004448088817298412,
0.5760790705680847,
0.6305562853813171,
-0.16300331056118011,
0.01883460395038128,
0.4600048065185547,
0.7592554092407227,
0.12246546894311905,
0.6136376857757568,
0.4289511740207672,
-0.03110838122665882,
0.9694269895553589,
0.13506856560707092,
-0.2001364529132843,
-0.48004359006881714,
-0.6380636692047119,
-0.9202572107315063,
-0.6776832342147827,
-0.11732223629951477,
-0.24978455901145935,
-0.2948541045188904,
0.8628230094909668,
0.6147232055664062,
-0.5599657893180847,
-0.2328626662492752,
0.06284669041633606,
0.31464990973472595,
-0.010622605681419373,
-0.13922102749347687,
0.3924639821052551,
-0.5025835633277893,
-0.12407222390174866,
0.04870391637086868,
0.24352329969406128,
0.28931665420532227,
-0.17469725012779236,
-0.2825310528278351,
-0.19359104335308075,
0.27685320377349854,
0.6356207132339478,
0.5736589431762695,
-0.49673280119895935,
-0.24019365012645721,
-0.3585638999938965,
-0.23926109075546265,
0.13381484150886536,
1.0875657796859741,
-0.37517115473747253,
0.29005858302116394,
0.5493813157081604,
0.4274449646472931,
0.7731093168258667,
-0.3001492917537689,
0.21652525663375854,
-0.8614406585693359,
-0.039123740047216415,
-0.20959551632404327,
0.44847944378852844,
0.24911604821681976,
-0.30112260580062866,
0.03798465430736542,
0.35657697916030884,
-0.6289736032485962,
-0.5027593374252319,
0.26084133982658386,
-0.6124928593635559,
-0.20861893892288208,
1.0689436197280884,
-0.21100468933582306,
-0.28426554799079895,
-0.006858729291707277,
0.07625757157802582,
0.14457017183303833,
-0.18889176845550537,
0.7130993604660034,
1.0976574420928955,
-0.013465541414916515,
-0.24030126631259918,
-0.42417892813682556,
0.5063449144363403,
0.3389483094215393,
-0.4342840611934662,
0.48283910751342773,
0.4374675452709198,
0.6988253593444824,
0.3102034032344818,
0.6796134114265442,
0.07230750471353531,
0.16737061738967896,
0.07888682931661606,
-0.13152407109737396,
-0.17290078103542328,
-0.3823758363723755,
-0.25869694352149963,
0.1709887683391571,
0.3538367748260498,
0.24441738426685333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15718v1 | Beyond the Turn-Based Game: Enabling Real-Time Conversations with Duplex Models | 2024-06-22T03:20:10 | 2024-06-22T03:20:10 | Xinrong Zhang, Yingfa Chen, Shengding Hu, Xu Han, Zihang Xu, Yuanwei Xu, Weilin Zhao, Maosong Sun, Zhiyuan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) increasingly permeate daily lives, there is a
growing demand for real-time interactions that mirror human conversations.
Traditional turn-based chat systems driven by LLMs prevent users from verbally
interacting with the system while it is generating responses. To overcome these
limitations, we adapt existing LLMs to \textit{duplex models} so that these
LLMs can listen for users while generating output and dynamically adjust
themselves to provide users with instant feedback. % such as in response to
interruptions. Specifically, we divide the queries and responses of
conversations into several time slices and then adopt a
time-division-multiplexing (TDM) encoding-decoding strategy to
pseudo-simultaneously process these slices. Furthermore, to make LLMs
proficient enough to handle real-time conversations, we build a fine-tuning
dataset consisting of alternating time slices of queries and responses as well
as covering typical feedback types in instantaneous interactions. Our
experiments show that although the queries and responses of conversations are
segmented into incomplete slices for processing, LLMs can preserve their
original performance on standard benchmarks with a few fine-tuning steps on our
dataset. Automatic and human evaluation indicate that duplex models make
user-AI interactions more natural and human-like, and greatly improve user
satisfaction compared to vanilla LLMs. Our duplex model and dataset will be
released. | [
-0.448189377784729,
-1.188663363456726,
0.6662113070487976,
0.6447041034698486,
-0.17879100143909454,
0.646834671497345,
-0.1038672924041748,
-0.7687388062477112,
0.3831632733345032,
0.7934019565582275,
-0.8023664951324463,
-0.2941007614135742,
-0.07442329823970795,
-0.08025187253952026,
-0.48244181275367737,
0.6249319314956665,
0.18498985469341278,
0.18954458832740784,
-0.3349387049674988,
-0.0876481756567955,
-0.4601590037345886,
-0.7733627557754517,
-0.951419472694397,
-0.5494577288627625,
0.4568183422088623,
0.5582400560379028,
0.9154306054115295,
0.5809609889984131,
0.2933001220226288,
0.3476026952266693,
0.1781471073627472,
0.3626686632633209,
-0.6890913844108582,
0.4358716309070587,
-0.0957912728190422,
-0.5969810485839844,
-0.8327270150184631,
0.06857559829950333,
0.49833378195762634,
0.7179940938949585,
-0.2637913227081299,
-0.04648568853735924,
-0.07988015562295914,
0.7738996148109436,
-0.22465641796588898,
-0.03221231698989868,
-0.4178946018218994,
0.42437008023262024,
0.10781693458557129,
-0.3210194706916809,
-0.3821413815021515,
-0.41246920824050903,
0.0394556038081646,
-0.6714368462562561,
0.0023128732573240995,
-0.04443511739373207,
0.5569841265678406,
0.13115710020065308,
-0.20921720564365387,
0.009101670235395432,
-1.3392720222473145,
0.5538787841796875,
-0.7505476474761963,
0.2897876501083374,
0.14678236842155457,
0.346002459526062,
-0.42004889249801636,
-0.42758098244667053,
-0.8734673857688904,
-0.15612022578716278,
0.09685061126947403,
0.09986742585897446,
-0.03786902874708176,
0.2223006933927536,
0.20755267143249512,
0.36583298444747925,
-0.20681828260421753,
0.24624352157115936,
0.08616914600133896,
0.15934842824935913,
1.002647042274475,
0.7888789772987366,
0.3120145797729492,
0.12502728402614594,
-0.2178259789943695,
0.11597006767988205,
-0.5626043081283569,
-0.010919121094048023,
0.3209564685821533,
-0.011628321371972561,
-0.36463943123817444,
0.5536888837814331,
-0.3362782299518585,
0.6347312331199646,
0.3857578933238983,
-0.0460858978331089,
-0.07211121916770935,
-0.5827822089195251,
-0.17756909132003784,
-0.32473331689834595,
0.7691861391067505,
0.42322778701782227,
0.39731064438819885,
-0.16809886693954468,
0.14147400856018066,
-0.1396152228116989,
0.36718395352363586,
-0.602696418762207,
-0.11944335699081421,
0.5739224553108215,
-0.30325180292129517,
-0.4511510133743286,
-0.12762589752674103,
-0.8090833425521851,
-0.2962777316570282,
-0.5207278728485107,
0.2952406704425812,
-0.2045978605747223,
-0.4043347239494324,
0.3670988082885742,
0.25606727600097656,
0.22755543887615204,
0.35532575845718384,
-0.6751187443733215,
0.6314639449119568,
0.8123850226402283,
0.9581370949745178,
-0.37776926159858704,
-0.3543221354484558,
-0.6386273503303528,
0.08179125189781189,
-0.2894313633441925,
0.855358898639679,
-0.6116142272949219,
-0.7046131491661072,
-0.07435823976993561,
-0.008181244134902954,
0.11416714638471603,
-0.5069442987442017,
0.20627687871456146,
-0.6533573269844055,
0.3902774453163147,
-0.16650165617465973,
-0.4074620008468628,
0.19950179755687714,
0.4808248281478882,
-0.3824649453163147,
0.636875331401825,
-0.3307061791419983,
-0.5542423725128174,
0.005695212632417679,
-0.9330801367759705,
-0.823479413986206,
0.1426897644996643,
0.05749451369047165,
-0.37806570529937744,
0.19439874589443207,
0.27228930592536926,
0.1205921545624733,
-0.20244628190994263,
0.007188121322542429,
-0.5941643714904785,
-0.3321525752544403,
0.43537408113479614,
-0.3444138169288635,
0.5039280652999878,
0.14186124503612518,
-0.21430552005767822,
0.3216434717178345,
-0.6087501645088196,
0.3646903336048126,
0.11603148281574249,
-0.5881391763687134,
0.1370125561952591,
0.4998966455459595,
-0.20190121233463287,
0.23453953862190247,
0.026950139552354813,
-0.7903351783752441,
0.3410510718822479,
-0.5093684196472168,
0.4893046021461487,
0.4212576448917389,
-0.0806683599948883,
0.41455140709877014,
-0.5250759720802307,
0.5530368089675903,
0.19514697790145874,
0.4246630370616913,
-0.2129339575767517,
-0.14227992296218872,
-1.0726282596588135,
-0.09878130257129669,
0.2059808224439621,
0.8360545635223389,
-0.8098623752593994,
0.3611144423484802,
-0.5483681559562683,
-0.3985666334629059,
-0.5225690603256226,
-0.12355697900056839,
0.3036184310913086,
0.25240787863731384,
0.058408692479133606,
-0.4516814649105072,
-0.6871374845504761,
-0.6855782866477966,
-0.1769554316997528,
-0.1881243884563446,
-0.18064984679222107,
0.6495253443717957,
0.04462956637144089,
-0.26420271396636963,
1.1334162950515747,
-0.48465511202812195,
-0.10620573908090591,
-0.4736197888851166,
0.2587796151638031,
-0.09990840405225754,
0.2812655568122864,
-0.00004335403355071321,
-0.5518632531166077,
-0.525338351726532,
-0.2674078345298767,
-0.7997729778289795,
-0.22286072373390198,
-0.2374768853187561,
-0.11483820527791977,
0.4959326684474945,
0.4135769009590149,
-0.5529333353042603,
0.35710862278938293,
0.512006938457489,
-0.3374558985233307,
0.44065970182418823,
-0.3394712209701538,
0.3757975697517395,
-1.0422019958496094,
-0.25927314162254333,
-0.39126452803611755,
-0.3430747389793396,
-0.7771552801132202,
-0.3016805648803711,
-0.2952117919921875,
-0.19331242144107819,
-0.4003920555114746,
0.5811867117881775,
-0.5482814311981201,
-0.48222437500953674,
-0.5080573558807373,
0.2482694536447525,
0.1566174030303955,
0.5113314390182495,
0.331892192363739,
0.7987079620361328,
0.1206345334649086,
-0.5522401332855225,
0.5576423406600952,
0.3592773973941803,
-0.38694509863853455,
0.7173797488212585,
-0.9762148857116699,
0.4416428208351135,
0.13191105425357819,
0.5835419297218323,
-0.8297680616378784,
-0.16093771159648895,
0.03839413821697235,
-0.2538796365261078,
-0.10514228790998459,
-0.24329814314842224,
-0.5926482677459717,
-0.4441860020160675,
-0.2767554819583893,
0.2695598900318146,
0.25380751490592957,
-0.4892583191394806,
0.760604739189148,
0.6661297082901001,
-0.3000463843345642,
-0.17445623874664307,
-0.6211187839508057,
0.38427427411079407,
0.1431654691696167,
-1.0034524202346802,
0.2688363790512085,
-0.3117084205150604,
-0.27189362049102783,
-0.37898877263069153,
0.228702574968338,
0.009668022394180298,
0.09195167571306229,
0.4656623303890228,
0.335003137588501,
-0.10278743505477905,
0.004384675063192844,
0.057132188230752945,
-0.08217495679855347,
0.005191129166632891,
-0.287612646818161,
0.8151661157608032,
0.1295655518770218,
-0.6474329829216003,
-0.5000165700912476,
0.6294831037521362,
0.7711395025253296,
-0.05720338225364685,
0.5959270596504211,
0.31217488646507263,
-0.04857834428548813,
-0.039043527096509933,
-0.8070904016494751,
-0.37975701689720154,
-0.4865516126155853,
0.33321264386177063,
-0.4111446738243103,
-1.0969926118850708,
0.5560775995254517,
0.15142831206321716,
0.24905118346214294,
-0.3277999758720398,
0.6398677825927734,
-0.3379307985305786,
1.294646143913269,
0.6033056974411011,
0.19159874320030212,
0.6049124002456665,
0.05666184052824974,
0.24260438978672028,
-0.7593653202056885,
-0.3461587131023407,
-0.1272023767232895,
-0.5651318430900574,
-0.3062443137168884,
-0.48441940546035767,
0.38645103573799133,
-0.15283457934856415,
-0.24295371770858765,
0.0006680480437353253,
-0.20077499747276306,
0.7323167324066162,
0.4373038113117218,
0.11089526116847992,
0.5496581792831421,
-0.01888376474380493,
0.17009586095809937,
-0.1808602213859558,
-0.7113330364227295,
-0.3614749014377594,
0.7735949754714966,
0.4636855125427246,
0.9053012132644653,
0.06393362581729889,
0.3296232223510742,
0.37634652853012085,
0.23701347410678864,
-0.7126981616020203,
0.7216348052024841,
0.04264966398477554,
-0.6553646922111511,
-0.35138505697250366,
-0.5599200129508972,
-0.7158339619636536,
0.27900946140289307,
-0.40792250633239746,
-0.5427455902099609,
-0.09696605801582336,
0.12593664228916168,
-0.7198727130889893,
0.44526422023773193,
-0.6919728517532349,
0.585496187210083,
-0.5858302116394043,
-0.6243046522140503,
-0.3532955050468445,
-0.35824769735336304,
0.3460713028907776,
0.3007291853427887,
0.10722444951534271,
-0.31194886565208435,
0.17806605994701385,
0.6375347971916199,
-0.4554276168346405,
1.0317869186401367,
-0.07690286636352539,
-0.12317957729101181,
0.15130703151226044,
0.5646561980247498,
0.5097370147705078,
0.28776055574417114,
0.2332456260919571,
0.2521743178367615,
0.14310632646083832,
-0.2958432137966156,
-0.5200479030609131,
0.9504770636558533,
-0.8994418382644653,
-0.9778810739517212,
-0.26992979645729065,
-0.7411559224128723,
-0.5026794075965881,
-0.05267833173274994,
-0.12477849423885345,
0.3592575788497925,
-0.36114174127578735,
-0.023006152361631393,
0.5661845803260803,
-0.2832958400249481,
0.3814079165458679,
0.9328202605247498,
-0.5670847296714783,
-0.2754267752170563,
0.6418607234954834,
-0.04957941547036171,
0.3721526563167572,
0.38959065079689026,
-0.056030578911304474,
-0.29370757937431335,
-0.37379273772239685,
-0.28859344124794006,
0.3434024155139923,
-0.1359591782093048,
-0.04132113233208656,
-1.025254726409912,
-0.3215312659740448,
-0.24691273272037506,
-0.05299326404929161,
-0.5781164765357971,
-0.4830624759197235,
-0.23457130789756775,
-0.044649388641119,
0.21646380424499512,
0.9533941745758057,
-0.2489379644393921,
0.4364417493343353,
-1.0296286344528198,
0.3702014982700348,
0.6864174604415894,
0.6750006079673767,
0.07697844505310059,
-0.5328481197357178,
-0.15126046538352966,
0.2717899978160858,
-0.21090762317180634,
-0.4717024862766266,
0.3932766914367676,
-0.02946716919541359,
0.14761313796043396,
0.029833955690264702,
-0.1301567405462265,
0.7425580620765686,
-0.592552900314331,
0.7491716146469116,
0.018441297113895416,
-0.9881595969200134,
0.22175994515419006,
-0.3242129385471344,
0.4842923581600189,
0.2764526605606079,
0.002629905939102173,
-0.9985963106155396,
-0.06622854620218277,
-0.26474234461784363,
-0.5887653827667236,
1.068428635597229,
0.048286423087120056,
0.20311249792575836,
0.09318263083696365,
0.26161989569664,
0.0032529402524232864,
0.13331902027130127,
-0.3666341006755829,
-0.09585970640182495,
-0.24939048290252686,
-0.024826854467391968,
0.1164945438504219,
-0.597037136554718,
-0.1878906935453415,
-0.0811232402920723,
0.22539393603801727,
0.06116655468940735,
0.26429322361946106,
0.11764143407344818,
0.15114101767539978,
-0.3135175108909607,
0.2941001057624817,
0.777953565120697,
0.56525057554245,
-0.0755920261144638,
-0.060532767325639725,
0.2856169641017914,
-0.2870257794857025,
0.13734318315982819,
-0.01560756005346775,
0.0956345871090889,
-0.3110525906085968,
0.15532530844211578,
0.7865380644798279,
0.35484835505485535,
-0.5045819282531738,
0.17294847965240479,
-0.34869202971458435,
-0.07198842614889145,
-0.4839666783809662,
0.2165844440460205,
0.308363139629364,
0.3978285491466522,
0.23355130851268768,
-0.3219068944454193,
-0.20805960893630981,
-0.6035000085830688,
0.1589856743812561,
0.5602231621742249,
-0.3546544015407562,
-0.535554051399231,
0.639147937297821,
0.7661603093147278,
-0.8769739866256714,
0.5190064311027527,
0.22022829949855804,
-0.43394845724105835,
0.33103662729263306,
0.38859322667121887,
0.9024659395217896,
0.031415075063705444,
0.45450878143310547,
0.12504875659942627,
-0.08301243931055069,
-0.07373161613941193,
0.2603137791156769,
-0.12028755247592926,
-0.7807134985923767,
-0.5911058783531189,
-0.5089734792709351,
-0.6648088097572327,
0.19263826310634613,
-0.3655419945716858,
-0.012778548523783684,
-0.6218556761741638,
-0.2780558466911316,
-0.04015999659895897,
0.11766980588436127,
-0.2990071177482605,
-0.14828722178936005,
0.4102356433868408,
0.9226794242858887,
-0.40117067098617554,
0.7928423285484314,
0.3311694264411926,
-0.19929155707359314,
-0.17931053042411804,
-0.17030785977840424,
-0.148148775100708,
-0.7053983807563782,
0.517603874206543,
-0.2807198762893677,
-0.37819936871528625,
-0.04813750088214874,
-0.7133273482322693,
-0.6299955248832703,
0.9104804396629333,
0.1737828105688095,
-0.846469521522522,
-0.21328894793987274,
0.5857661366462708,
0.7007884979248047,
-0.7018398642539978,
0.25513190031051636,
0.5995185971260071,
0.2015165388584137,
0.2936162054538727,
-0.9633154273033142,
-0.259078711271286,
-0.02310781553387642,
0.04154936969280243,
0.17791764438152313,
-0.7707023024559021,
0.5576810836791992,
-0.25443387031555176,
-0.41663259267807007,
-0.05636829882860184,
0.6660720705986023,
0.3102101683616638,
0.24356313049793243,
0.463584303855896,
0.46707773208618164,
0.2472926825284958,
-0.2237045019865036,
1.03218412399292,
-0.2624644339084625,
-0.013577827252447605,
1.483466625213623,
-0.6673165559768677,
0.7457577586174011,
0.4358026087284088,
-0.18868455290794373,
0.3287934362888336,
0.21832329034805298,
0.33815401792526245,
0.15885597467422485,
0.09527585655450821,
-0.27462366223335266,
-0.7152503728866577,
-0.06761045753955841,
-0.12491195648908615,
0.28130096197128296,
0.3800136148929596,
0.19360433518886566,
-0.04160339757800102,
-0.002376376884058118,
0.07525515556335449,
0.19365058839321136,
0.03583922237157822,
0.9800559282302856,
0.018067188560962677,
-0.830356240272522,
0.3353145718574524,
-0.11351315677165985,
0.7878197431564331,
-0.5158908367156982,
-0.0037432138342410326,
-0.715001106262207,
0.3412581980228424,
-0.13668383657932281,
-1.011391520500183,
0.35010194778442383,
-0.04840528219938278,
-0.3798872232437134,
-0.12327314913272858,
0.39574405550956726,
-0.6549990773200989,
-0.4605078101158142,
0.39962655305862427,
0.6810933351516724,
-0.11686205863952637,
0.07520467042922974,
-0.763580858707428,
0.6053532958030701,
0.004765477031469345,
-0.15210352838039398,
0.16404415667057037,
0.25494787096977234,
0.1269870400428772,
0.995835542678833,
0.7673875093460083,
0.04775112494826317,
0.027804428711533546,
0.06603186577558517,
0.7139595746994019,
-0.7565399408340454,
-0.4243965744972229,
-0.6379342079162598,
0.29710185527801514,
-0.2221599519252777,
-0.09144209325313568,
0.6054933071136475,
0.43697091937065125,
0.6378727555274963,
0.05592275783419609,
0.8103458881378174,
0.24706757068634033,
0.8766878247261047,
-0.3720814287662506,
0.7781283855438232,
-0.29776620864868164,
0.4099532961845398,
0.19538213312625885,
-0.5545035600662231,
-0.14467968046665192,
0.19059982895851135,
-0.5003130435943604,
-0.06297121942043304,
0.14415986835956573,
0.5990915894508362,
-0.2034144401550293,
0.13408496975898743,
0.4728577136993408,
0.37380874156951904,
0.7376195192337036,
0.5937062501907349,
1.079471230506897,
-0.18097132444381714,
0.6489573121070862,
-0.052122242748737335,
-0.09362876415252686,
-0.3737335801124573,
-0.6627687811851501,
-1.0460058450698853,
-0.4708858132362366,
-0.26242074370384216,
-0.39502906799316406,
0.19475100934505463,
0.8789389133453369,
0.8009985089302063,
-0.8012670278549194,
-0.5656063556671143,
0.10362856835126877,
0.15392589569091797,
0.14874310791492462,
-0.2450486272573471,
-0.1572485864162445,
-0.27257996797561646,
-0.8319775462150574,
0.5390585660934448,
0.5369346141815186,
0.2700482904911041,
-0.4659228026866913,
-0.10878438502550125,
-0.25289642810821533,
0.5554359555244446,
0.8107580542564392,
0.5737857222557068,
-0.5064758062362671,
-0.31959235668182373,
0.12965518236160278,
-0.20586159825325012,
0.2514817416667938,
0.9682303667068481,
-0.7876217365264893,
0.4502919912338257,
0.41140156984329224,
0.46650686860084534,
0.7450541257858276,
0.17026440799236298,
0.941494882106781,
-0.417045921087265,
0.1764824241399765,
0.12742342054843903,
-0.05140591040253639,
0.47974899411201477,
-0.2114473432302475,
0.43441224098205566,
0.04548737779259682,
-0.562938392162323,
-0.7637525200843811,
0.487748920917511,
-0.7461721301078796,
-0.09535374492406845,
1.0204118490219116,
0.013867114670574665,
-0.26127883791923523,
-0.40641793608665466,
-0.2816586196422577,
0.10625000298023224,
-0.368047297000885,
1.0755730867385864,
0.6191667914390564,
-0.3403610289096832,
-0.152631938457489,
-0.10126833617687225,
0.4748668968677521,
0.40901538729667664,
-1.0206032991409302,
0.4425883889198303,
0.5851885080337524,
0.31478211283683777,
0.13311783969402313,
0.7295826077461243,
-0.27609983086586,
0.0973735973238945,
-0.19989672303199768,
0.010883329436182976,
-0.3369293212890625,
-0.34240052103996277,
-0.1958799660205841,
0.2565440237522125,
-0.09427370876073837,
-0.20828574895858765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15708v1 | Teach Better or Show Smarter? On Instructions and Exemplars in Automatic Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-22T02:07:10 | 2024-06-22T02:07:10 | Xingchen Wan, Ruoxi Sun, Hootan Nakhost, Sercan O. Arik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have demonstrated remarkable capabilities, but their
performance is heavily reliant on effective prompt engineering. Automatic
prompt optimization (APO) methods are designed to automate this and can be
broadly categorized into those targeting instructions (instruction
optimization, IO) vs. those targeting exemplars (exemplar selection, ES).
Despite their shared objective, these have evolved rather independently, with
IO recently receiving more research attention. This paper seeks to bridge this
gap by comprehensively comparing the performance of representative IO and ES
techniques, both isolation and combination, on a diverse set of challenging
tasks. Our findings reveal that intelligently reusing model-generated
input-output pairs obtained from evaluating prompts on the validation set as
exemplars consistently improves performance over IO methods but is currently
under-investigated. We also find that despite the recent focus on IO, how we
select exemplars can outweigh how we optimize instructions, with ES strategies
as simple as random search outperforming state-of-the-art IO methods with seed
instructions without any optimization. Moreover, we observe synergy between ES
and IO, with optimal combinations surpassing individual contributions. We
conclude that studying exemplar selection as a standalone method and its
optimal combination with instruction optimization remains a crucial aspect of
APO and deserves greater consideration in future research, even in the era of
highly capable instruction-following models. | [
-0.3042806088924408,
-0.6783585548400879,
0.5935901999473572,
-0.0044572134502232075,
-0.14310017228126526,
0.04472513124346733,
-0.2769183814525604,
-0.4203917384147644,
-0.09355193376541138,
0.05363377183675766,
-0.6967578530311584,
-0.13106346130371094,
-0.5138351321220398,
0.44255828857421875,
-0.1847413331270218,
0.7660005688667297,
0.01569490134716034,
0.07545772939920425,
-0.6761272549629211,
0.09337640553712845,
-0.6835758686065674,
-0.20525142550468445,
-0.8214714527130127,
-0.14082397520542145,
-0.022462651133537292,
0.6865367889404297,
0.4318040609359741,
0.8966574668884277,
0.5318472385406494,
0.4346972107887268,
0.12758533656597137,
0.2824260890483856,
-0.17028605937957764,
0.35454705357551575,
0.06706780195236206,
-0.304585337638855,
0.06330692023038864,
-0.03384716436266899,
0.41636112332344055,
0.6634872555732727,
0.026764973998069763,
0.14111529290676117,
0.1592453271150589,
0.5448210835456848,
-0.8202194571495056,
0.18224966526031494,
-0.3730738162994385,
0.04014419764280319,
0.1365073174238205,
-0.24097590148448944,
-0.6464179158210754,
-0.5948562026023865,
0.3296855092048645,
-0.9242844581604004,
0.09572898596525192,
0.2840660810470581,
0.5974783897399902,
0.37438079714775085,
-0.2456711232662201,
-0.6327172517776489,
-0.7174090147018433,
1.0853791236877441,
-0.32790783047676086,
0.08104700595140457,
-0.008940126746892929,
0.3717478811740875,
-0.17239606380462646,
-0.6791388988494873,
-0.3115854263305664,
-0.17901289463043213,
0.08508071303367615,
0.40964847803115845,
-0.3552505671977997,
0.1571388989686966,
0.4297953248023987,
0.29937711358070374,
-0.5155596137046814,
0.35918158292770386,
-0.34556734561920166,
-0.2569983899593353,
0.518234133720398,
0.00899109523743391,
0.4652211666107178,
-0.09155184030532837,
-0.43095067143440247,
-0.4786849915981293,
-0.4949014186859131,
0.5097461342811584,
0.40104350447654724,
0.05018584057688713,
0.10421448945999146,
0.39028608798980713,
-0.18766264617443085,
0.6259856224060059,
-0.0759059339761734,
-0.15008047223091125,
0.09362427145242691,
-0.31466400623321533,
0.13143689930438995,
-0.21366555988788605,
0.8447161316871643,
0.3100506067276001,
0.20458011329174042,
-0.04065583273768425,
-0.23114614188671112,
-0.04833238944411278,
-0.08456000685691833,
-0.6891909241676331,
-0.22223377227783203,
0.1540376991033554,
-0.40211889147758484,
-0.0421772301197052,
0.17262057960033417,
-0.7106544971466064,
0.020270908251404762,
-0.4662914276123047,
0.5208075642585754,
-0.2930375039577484,
0.1943511664867401,
-0.20795516669750214,
-0.5146892070770264,
0.11684098839759827,
0.3800440728664398,
-0.7844218015670776,
0.2910971939563751,
0.7495595812797546,
0.6178980469703674,
-0.16238167881965637,
-0.26293548941612244,
-1.0087324380874634,
-0.012421037070453167,
-0.46492519974708557,
0.9287436604499817,
-0.9467339515686035,
-0.656116783618927,
-0.2895593047142029,
-0.23078592121601105,
-0.2448521852493286,
-0.5207845568656921,
0.46055638790130615,
-0.2944486737251282,
0.7054241299629211,
-0.39205726981163025,
-0.7773903012275696,
-0.20979754626750946,
-0.402716726064682,
-0.7397195100784302,
0.8556647300720215,
-0.011311111971735954,
-0.2133520543575287,
0.49858495593070984,
-0.7801568508148193,
-0.448416143655777,
-0.06542092561721802,
-0.24257679283618927,
-0.3410499393939972,
0.3096035420894623,
0.37153494358062744,
0.2592909634113312,
-0.3223389685153961,
0.04759659245610237,
-0.16064170002937317,
-0.5415034294128418,
-0.08642429113388062,
-0.33960047364234924,
0.683707594871521,
0.18882711231708527,
-0.7217862010002136,
0.22280913591384888,
-0.620448887348175,
0.10926718264818192,
0.06442612409591675,
0.037760909646749496,
-0.3952043354511261,
0.24472126364707947,
-0.6652726531028748,
0.056212250143289566,
0.13910309970378876,
-0.4074473977088928,
0.08336544036865234,
-0.3686217665672302,
0.39100179076194763,
0.9057123064994812,
-0.0053765615448355675,
0.5010943412780762,
-0.3263159990310669,
0.6458249688148499,
-0.5156870484352112,
0.5609747767448425,
-0.5843027830123901,
-0.541325032711029,
-0.5838090181350708,
-0.35173824429512024,
-0.031405869871377945,
0.5134275555610657,
-0.7004327178001404,
0.2577880620956421,
0.0060164001770317554,
-0.2600034177303314,
-0.6178558468818665,
-0.039542876183986664,
0.5518706440925598,
0.7597457766532898,
0.43402501940727234,
0.05544152855873108,
-0.3581426739692688,
-0.9817636609077454,
-0.22480341792106628,
-0.16648654639720917,
0.3190871775150299,
0.28201550245285034,
0.21420712769031525,
0.3688145577907562,
0.7410252094268799,
-0.36183440685272217,
0.06061653047800064,
-0.44507578015327454,
0.08990389853715897,
0.07102608680725098,
0.4226057529449463,
0.5077893137931824,
-0.6660058498382568,
-0.7770997285842896,
-0.052341002970933914,
-0.7383872866630554,
-0.28646764159202576,
-0.1526716649532318,
-0.03013446182012558,
0.196507528424263,
0.4641376733779907,
-0.30978256464004517,
0.3302176296710968,
0.2711225748062134,
0.07189249247312546,
0.5531859397888184,
-0.26800793409347534,
0.24128364026546478,
-0.7159017324447632,
0.09831371903419495,
-0.3953118920326233,
-0.069489024579525,
-0.35976147651672363,
0.3310109078884125,
0.025468390434980392,
-0.29566308856010437,
-0.31110280752182007,
0.7058098912239075,
-0.9647068381309509,
-0.08291231095790863,
-0.39396727085113525,
-0.04032845422625542,
0.34190091490745544,
0.43561238050460815,
0.05591327324509621,
1.0586334466934204,
0.7474995255470276,
-0.4529348611831665,
0.29232725501060486,
0.06537595391273499,
-0.20098628103733063,
0.13666145503520966,
-0.9288862347602844,
0.409404993057251,
-0.08467383682727814,
0.019252516329288483,
-0.8957085609436035,
-0.2584676146507263,
0.006105695851147175,
-0.3006383776664734,
0.2807133197784424,
0.20458054542541504,
-0.5395450592041016,
-0.5970189571380615,
-0.741137683391571,
0.054581981152296066,
0.9904861450195312,
-0.5924739837646484,
0.4381050169467926,
0.08338076621294022,
-0.311100035905838,
-0.6329143643379211,
-0.21166306734085083,
-0.31434258818626404,
-0.23897390067577362,
-0.42803800106048584,
0.13719655573368073,
-0.05929698422551155,
-0.2758934199810028,
-0.05998130887746811,
-0.1334170550107956,
0.2880953252315521,
0.357134610414505,
0.08434893190860748,
0.2574736773967743,
-0.14763040840625763,
0.11299128085374832,
0.5026211738586426,
-0.4120620787143707,
0.0006829703925177455,
-0.07427648454904556,
0.336099237203598,
0.009571107104420662,
-0.5762668251991272,
-0.8789201974868774,
0.97211092710495,
0.4182194173336029,
-0.3177143335342407,
0.6229549050331116,
0.19866278767585754,
0.04453999549150467,
-0.3882268965244293,
-0.5058906078338623,
-0.5551704168319702,
-0.4997122883796692,
0.3228267431259155,
-0.32999998331069946,
-0.5226337909698486,
0.3286042809486389,
-0.10914525389671326,
0.4784003794193268,
0.12027882039546967,
-0.1024836003780365,
-0.17799724638462067,
1.502344012260437,
0.683781087398529,
0.2482856661081314,
0.6620727181434631,
-0.1935507357120514,
0.10191076993942261,
-0.8407394886016846,
-0.1828259974718094,
-0.5595805048942566,
-0.3037836253643036,
-0.30058467388153076,
-0.0478224940598011,
0.6188154816627502,
0.11726828664541245,
0.03839835152029991,
0.17600302398204803,
-0.8730906248092651,
0.7297367453575134,
1.0400382280349731,
-0.022021189332008362,
0.26533517241477966,
-0.013701627030968666,
-0.05098329856991768,
-0.04429201781749725,
-0.8776275515556335,
-0.7132853865623474,
1.1139652729034424,
-0.08989313244819641,
0.38086333870887756,
-0.1051628366112709,
0.6870926022529602,
0.05629889667034149,
0.030054474249482155,
-0.6828083992004395,
0.7784932255744934,
-0.3671402633190155,
-0.2326240986585617,
-0.26421207189559937,
-0.43531283736228943,
-1.094261884689331,
0.15129633247852325,
0.10947272926568985,
-0.550119936466217,
0.1813640594482422,
0.41558581590652466,
-0.6785427927970886,
0.10079493373632431,
-1.3564095497131348,
0.9022557139396667,
-0.1495143473148346,
-0.23850169777870178,
-0.05945427715778351,
-0.7303126454353333,
0.002243170514702797,
0.15069618821144104,
0.1683240383863449,
0.11506588757038116,
-0.3028622567653656,
0.5721195936203003,
-0.7207433581352234,
0.45027658343315125,
-0.1536240130662918,
0.18856678903102875,
0.4988410472869873,
-0.18193206191062927,
0.7622811198234558,
-0.2853524684906006,
-0.2625461518764496,
-0.4010623097419739,
-0.14091764390468597,
-0.3746187686920166,
-0.750998854637146,
0.5801265835762024,
-0.8366082906723022,
-0.896407961845398,
-0.02837982028722763,
-0.29511409997940063,
-0.11210377514362335,
0.15133251249790192,
0.680743396282196,
0.948244571685791,
0.16233579814434052,
0.28656116127967834,
0.6517688632011414,
-0.2555726170539856,
0.8403217792510986,
0.19256706535816193,
0.21616223454475403,
-0.26357054710388184,
1.0497664213180542,
0.24410028755664825,
0.602876603603363,
0.5299766659736633,
0.5592350363731384,
-0.12114033848047256,
-0.5382094979286194,
-0.5187821388244629,
0.024328216910362244,
-0.7600771188735962,
-0.1273355633020401,
-0.7644662857055664,
0.24890317022800446,
-0.47020024061203003,
-0.4139617085456848,
-0.25172343850135803,
-0.46019503474235535,
-0.35896071791648865,
-0.021490728482604027,
0.17798453569412231,
0.3664105236530304,
-0.16980691254138947,
0.1334800273180008,
-0.513546347618103,
0.08400394767522812,
0.5498382449150085,
-0.3329720199108124,
0.07915174961090088,
-0.12498151510953903,
0.18800173699855804,
-0.1542057991027832,
-0.19269748032093048,
-1.0824180841445923,
-0.03754590079188347,
0.4056258499622345,
0.7610583901405334,
0.5522331595420837,
0.3976803123950958,
0.5685019493103027,
-0.3312164545059204,
0.6216709017753601,
-0.02851792424917221,
-0.9425314664840698,
1.0084022283554077,
-0.03455608710646629,
0.4979289174079895,
0.6879022121429443,
0.3753308355808258,
-0.031115835532546043,
-0.49549242854118347,
-0.623441219329834,
-1.0894948244094849,
0.8920356631278992,
-0.012197375297546387,
0.11726687103509903,
-0.2253776341676712,
-0.022989509627223015,
0.7446485161781311,
0.31604260206222534,
-0.45524442195892334,
-0.066968634724617,
0.1826750487089157,
-0.2279585301876068,
0.4482741057872772,
0.09939820319414139,
-0.07487981021404266,
0.06916730105876923,
0.7396338582038879,
-0.24572725594043732,
0.4674202799797058,
0.1474154144525528,
-0.16372087597846985,
-0.04723375663161278,
-0.0002697063027881086,
0.5167074203491211,
0.5607366561889648,
0.24546803534030914,
-0.15862959623336792,
0.11017531901597977,
-0.364410400390625,
-0.007041063625365496,
0.1127360463142395,
-0.4406346380710602,
0.09773939102888107,
0.6618580222129822,
0.9918921589851379,
-0.024424558505415916,
-0.8331170678138733,
0.682498574256897,
0.029690925031900406,
0.2297232747077942,
-0.1619788557291031,
0.7166663408279419,
-0.4225163757801056,
0.07987678796052933,
0.5582150816917419,
0.25219419598579407,
0.48656830191612244,
-0.5892041921615601,
-0.06350337713956833,
0.47484588623046875,
-0.08094216883182526,
-0.298462450504303,
0.4171122610569,
0.47681206464767456,
-0.4118589162826538,
0.4959889352321625,
-0.40213799476623535,
-0.36850085854530334,
1.0406973361968994,
0.3712364435195923,
0.9316990375518799,
-0.07719521969556808,
0.25968337059020996,
0.3751833140850067,
0.2770689129829407,
-0.04468235746026039,
0.19328095018863678,
-0.41760826110839844,
-0.20699995756149292,
-0.5628092288970947,
-0.06165282800793648,
-0.5951569080352783,
-0.11288876086473465,
-0.8654443621635437,
0.39724159240722656,
-0.4585250914096832,
0.05813966318964958,
-0.289241224527359,
0.08832374215126038,
-0.5847621560096741,
-0.022314099594950676,
-0.12514586746692657,
0.7654279470443726,
-0.7043954133987427,
0.18553684651851654,
0.9458875060081482,
-0.11120240390300751,
-1.007602572441101,
-0.1207682192325592,
0.04041231423616409,
-0.7794834971427917,
0.3048357367515564,
0.5220606327056885,
-0.07295038551092148,
0.17832370102405548,
-0.42419424653053284,
-0.8030895590782166,
1.0327696800231934,
0.4580835998058319,
-0.5538129806518555,
-0.13890282809734344,
-0.42591592669487,
0.24814729392528534,
-0.24378201365470886,
0.7779536247253418,
0.10851795971393585,
0.2414514124393463,
0.14017616212368011,
-0.7826377749443054,
-0.03711041435599327,
-0.3255094587802887,
0.038349833339452744,
0.34293100237846375,
-1.0177810192108154,
0.5795204043388367,
-0.5246946811676025,
-0.5013791918754578,
0.24407748878002167,
0.6519399881362915,
0.29584404826164246,
0.5041963458061218,
0.42454925179481506,
0.25214847922325134,
0.8614644408226013,
-0.25251737236976624,
1.3690024614334106,
-0.10366178303956985,
-0.13832922279834747,
1.1406360864639282,
-0.29350295662879944,
0.5884418487548828,
0.5441492199897766,
-0.040891293436288834,
0.3983842432498932,
0.6733129620552063,
0.2145017385482788,
0.7580747008323669,
-0.15723714232444763,
-0.13278654217720032,
-0.13300079107284546,
-0.058956973254680634,
-0.41561639308929443,
0.26001718640327454,
0.02536892332136631,
-0.27828022837638855,
-0.15613234043121338,
0.5159662365913391,
0.18224377930164337,
0.16207890212535858,
-0.14369893074035645,
1.194404125213623,
-0.17127232253551483,
-1.137799620628357,
0.0981399267911911,
-0.369383305311203,
0.4422137141227722,
-0.5996054410934448,
-0.0695461556315422,
-0.4014241397380829,
-0.09648304432630539,
0.14343513548374176,
-0.39121758937835693,
0.22115017473697662,
0.005984002258628607,
-0.16949425637722015,
-0.32807841897010803,
0.6166366934776306,
0.06478461623191833,
-0.22591575980186462,
-0.005731134209781885,
0.3600531816482544,
0.15910008549690247,
0.2269011288881302,
-0.5959556102752686,
0.07539833337068558,
-0.00651839654892683,
-0.29121851921081543,
-0.03111770935356617,
0.5582377910614014,
-0.15050514042377472,
0.7388779520988464,
0.7395452857017517,
0.003054442349821329,
0.06556253880262375,
0.0029360433109104633,
0.730056881904602,
-0.3249188959598541,
-0.49749094247817993,
-0.8270167112350464,
0.5663173794746399,
-0.4378851354122162,
-0.647015392780304,
0.6809449195861816,
0.5279415845870972,
0.7731592059135437,
-0.02947269007563591,
0.68560391664505,
0.06327781826257706,
0.43985486030578613,
-0.5820006132125854,
0.1034025251865387,
-0.45968782901763916,
0.31056541204452515,
-0.25984901189804077,
-1.0762594938278198,
0.20156581699848175,
0.5434762835502625,
-0.5120967030525208,
0.27523040771484375,
0.7950767874717712,
0.49212491512298584,
0.16178090870380402,
0.30152565240859985,
0.11443501710891724,
-0.3438290059566498,
0.1864614486694336,
0.6299640536308289,
1.109736680984497,
-0.22387471795082092,
0.5035864114761353,
-0.48572680354118347,
-0.6181867718696594,
-0.244777649641037,
-0.819724440574646,
-0.820685863494873,
-0.4194367527961731,
-0.6136801242828369,
0.440420001745224,
0.28253841400146484,
1.087181806564331,
0.7931615710258484,
-0.6153074502944946,
-0.0029404163360595703,
-0.3762222230434418,
0.24422334134578705,
-0.6271127462387085,
-0.2655543386936188,
0.2827453911304474,
-0.6652108430862427,
-1.127149224281311,
0.5816510915756226,
0.3846420347690582,
0.05559658259153366,
0.046052057296037674,
0.21093067526817322,
0.23349018394947052,
0.0006088614463806152,
0.5132832527160645,
0.3815181851387024,
-0.5026512145996094,
-0.08329585194587708,
0.5094971060752869,
-0.010030492208898067,
-0.17122578620910645,
0.7325852513313293,
-0.7141615152359009,
0.6510330438613892,
0.7422416806221008,
0.7512249946594238,
-0.16064059734344482,
-0.005327281076461077,
0.7258168458938599,
-0.516298770904541,
-0.12714709341526031,
0.4214947819709778,
0.2339484542608261,
0.23917298018932343,
-0.4326772689819336,
0.3732261657714844,
0.13761025667190552,
-0.5266887545585632,
-0.9573814272880554,
0.12859635055065155,
-0.5849423408508301,
-0.4385717213153839,
0.9732502102851868,
-0.1635284125804901,
-0.3039090633392334,
0.09006164222955704,
-0.23986653983592987,
0.044115278869867325,
-0.6558511853218079,
0.6775966286659241,
0.5984082221984863,
-0.6382406949996948,
-0.23500357568264008,
-0.5920049548149109,
0.3995550572872162,
0.9581303000450134,
-1.0008084774017334,
-0.37944045662879944,
0.42434626817703247,
-0.2658175528049469,
0.1958441138267517,
0.28834107518196106,
-0.0035028927959501743,
0.6338890790939331,
-0.12358435988426208,
-0.21838107705116272,
-0.4478764832019806,
-0.544818103313446,
-0.15487003326416016,
0.2344115972518921,
-0.07397954165935516,
-0.5460537672042847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16962v1 | MetaGreen: Meta-Learning Inspired Transformer Selection for Green Semantic Communication | 2024-06-22T00:49:40 | 2024-06-22T00:49:40 | Shubhabrata Mukherjee, Cory Beard, Sejun Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Semantic Communication can transform the way we transmit information,
prioritizing meaningful and effective content over individual symbols or bits.
This evolution promises significant benefits, including reduced latency, lower
bandwidth usage, and higher throughput compared to traditional communication.
However, the development of Semantic Communication faces a crucial challenge:
the need for universal metrics to benchmark the joint effects of semantic
information loss and energy consumption. This research introduces an innovative
solution: the ``Energy-Optimized Semantic Loss'' (EOSL) function, a novel
multi-objective loss function that effectively balances semantic information
loss and energy consumption. Through comprehensive experiments on transformer
models, including energy benchmarking, we demonstrate the remarkable
effectiveness of EOSL-based model selection. We have established that
EOSL-based transformer model selection achieves up to 83\% better
similarity-to-power ratio (SPR) compared to BLEU score-based selection and 67\%
better SPR compared to solely lowest power usage-based selection. Furthermore,
we extend the applicability of EOSL to diverse and varying contexts, inspired
by the principles of Meta-Learning. By cumulatively applying EOSL, we enable
the model selection system to adapt to this change, leveraging historical EOSL
values to guide the learning process. This work lays the foundation for
energy-efficient model selection and the development of green semantic
communication. | [
-0.42395925521850586,
-0.5181676149368286,
0.5128527879714966,
-0.21863983571529388,
-0.3709239661693573,
-0.209344282746315,
-0.1541808396577835,
-0.5859341025352478,
0.2635982930660248,
0.20452161133289337,
-0.86577969789505,
-0.3854944705963135,
-0.5716342329978943,
0.1650073081254959,
-0.0919690653681755,
0.876894474029541,
0.1530330628156662,
-0.05454307422041893,
0.11774426698684692,
-0.29572832584381104,
-0.26801836490631104,
0.21524733304977417,
-0.3952868580818176,
-0.653821587562561,
0.3546692430973053,
0.25888732075691223,
0.6738049387931824,
0.1515655368566513,
0.564969003200531,
0.29351434111595154,
-0.1379416584968567,
0.13697122037410736,
-0.7397608160972595,
-0.11842677742242813,
-0.3948364853858948,
-0.2496110498905182,
-0.18769142031669617,
0.11382273584604263,
0.4194219708442688,
0.5123280882835388,
-0.4347451627254486,
0.37511178851127625,
0.1569068878889084,
0.8323398232460022,
-1.039025068283081,
0.21425150334835052,
-1.0854986906051636,
0.551415205001831,
0.016173230484128,
-0.18500348925590515,
-0.41896507143974304,
-0.05958664044737816,
-0.10785467177629471,
-0.9818530678749084,
-0.034000832587480545,
0.22769814729690552,
0.9139150381088257,
0.48559504747390747,
-0.5173008441925049,
-0.14920637011528015,
-1.0660430192947388,
0.8989617228507996,
-0.31459495425224304,
0.8133081793785095,
-0.021621212363243103,
0.540148913860321,
0.3805873394012451,
-0.7369704842567444,
-0.5661959052085876,
-0.1304045468568802,
-0.11409193277359009,
0.6897047758102417,
-0.31843748688697815,
0.20430919528007507,
-0.01364689227193594,
0.14232203364372253,
-0.36721381545066833,
-0.31323179602622986,
-0.42621278762817383,
-0.3156304657459259,
0.4072573184967041,
0.11202605068683624,
0.0007061614305712283,
-0.2433621734380722,
-0.42865344882011414,
-0.3362877666950226,
-0.4382767081260681,
-0.5025392770767212,
0.34789833426475525,
0.19497571885585785,
0.37902557849884033,
0.27201610803604126,
-0.2777172923088074,
0.6511279940605164,
0.05136773735284805,
-0.12227754294872284,
0.25327786803245544,
-0.3800271451473236,
-0.2165171205997467,
0.12126552313566208,
0.72945237159729,
0.6629804372787476,
-0.07368287444114685,
-0.25565388798713684,
0.07362226396799088,
0.02343914285302162,
0.19895821809768677,
-0.79512619972229,
-0.4587860107421875,
-0.028031418099999428,
-0.686555027961731,
-0.06407028436660767,
0.34869149327278137,
-0.7905824780464172,
0.15545035898685455,
-0.22997482120990753,
0.44255751371383667,
-0.3506639301776886,
-0.5976414680480957,
0.40254005789756775,
-0.5266749858856201,
0.2971094846725464,
0.12906602025032043,
-1.0407006740570068,
0.41582831740379333,
0.6300399899482727,
0.7149822115898132,
0.025310037657618523,
-0.15648244321346283,
-0.13368164002895355,
0.49528568983078003,
-0.1952560395002365,
0.4399228096008301,
-0.6550905108451843,
-0.5724930763244629,
-0.4513762295246124,
0.10223358869552612,
-0.39826712012290955,
-0.15474548935890198,
0.6735314726829529,
-0.5611669421195984,
0.030106741935014725,
-0.05162911117076874,
-0.3220856785774231,
-0.16080179810523987,
-0.02206391468644142,
-0.8576552271842957,
0.9339748620986938,
0.046610116958618164,
-0.7647181153297424,
0.4096056818962097,
-0.8350604176521301,
-0.2715054154396057,
0.10547442734241486,
0.16747400164604187,
-0.5138960480690002,
0.10816305130720139,
-0.5491325259208679,
0.2046712338924408,
-0.27123764157295227,
0.012654317542910576,
-0.23593614995479584,
0.09360945224761963,
-0.3158734440803528,
-0.4226536452770233,
0.22252827882766724,
0.6151526570320129,
-0.48558345437049866,
0.16858424246311188,
-0.8877550363540649,
0.37488219141960144,
0.20892073214054108,
-0.1888558268547058,
-0.5168479681015015,
-0.03972445800900459,
0.2046608030796051,
0.34085458517074585,
-0.1521427184343338,
-1.072501301765442,
-0.6141595244407654,
-0.1890660524368286,
0.5378475785255432,
0.5540370941162109,
-0.5369816422462463,
0.40823453664779663,
-0.20969103276729584,
0.2066590040922165,
-0.4938645660877228,
0.5999869704246521,
0.030311565846204758,
-0.3563561737537384,
-0.5649690628051758,
0.003322306554764509,
-0.0010361999738961458,
0.6502429246902466,
-0.49556535482406616,
0.6963502168655396,
-0.4323728084564209,
-0.8780097365379333,
-0.555923581123352,
-0.005028054118156433,
0.2780817747116089,
0.6642289757728577,
0.6334384679794312,
0.17339009046554565,
-0.11066430807113647,
-0.8381156921386719,
-0.5704452395439148,
0.11624708026647568,
0.032770976424217224,
0.6899464130401611,
0.41127073764801025,
-0.31710711121559143,
0.9474083185195923,
-0.8322911262512207,
-0.16024179756641388,
-0.12702889740467072,
-0.13067328929901123,
-0.021172286942601204,
0.33499711751937866,
0.3064371943473816,
-1.3245209455490112,
-0.53850257396698,
0.19037574529647827,
-0.27644261717796326,
0.006454661022871733,
-0.07415017485618591,
-0.31643280386924744,
-0.1856754720211029,
0.3964628279209137,
-0.7170206308364868,
0.4123564064502716,
0.7470595836639404,
-0.5408625602722168,
0.34684088826179504,
-0.22948883473873138,
0.23254500329494476,
-0.9221195578575134,
0.22579845786094666,
-0.25196272134780884,
-0.273655503988266,
-0.4418802857398987,
-0.18358728289604187,
0.31849679350852966,
-0.38066819310188293,
-0.6736447215080261,
0.34177491068840027,
-0.24538184702396393,
-0.050262995064258575,
-0.1850757598876953,
-0.03688698634505272,
0.2751471996307373,
0.3268539309501648,
0.21006804704666138,
0.21683475375175476,
0.26677510142326355,
-0.7373529076576233,
0.4637298583984375,
0.28687503933906555,
0.15172849595546722,
0.49030062556266785,
-0.6695926189422607,
0.11205116659402847,
-0.07728022336959839,
0.34988969564437866,
-0.746192991733551,
0.13165183365345,
0.41832074522972107,
-0.060131773352622986,
0.09274116903543472,
0.2416701763868332,
-0.2032470703125,
-0.24070239067077637,
-0.24471548199653625,
0.09138775616884232,
0.400142639875412,
-0.6672236919403076,
0.9988999366760254,
0.07668812572956085,
0.32894018292427063,
-0.08590173721313477,
-0.7830345630645752,
0.10998662561178207,
-0.2544945478439331,
-0.7309058308601379,
0.8573253154754639,
-0.1025177463889122,
0.1539541333913803,
0.26187047362327576,
-0.24711152911186218,
0.4400549829006195,
0.3574937582015991,
-0.018302319571375847,
-0.0033849310129880905,
0.05738488957285881,
0.5321491956710815,
-0.057529062032699585,
-0.6238482594490051,
-0.01037695724517107,
-0.8703957200050354,
0.48130863904953003,
-0.3096340596675873,
-0.7768189311027527,
-0.5894731879234314,
0.507623016834259,
0.30468568205833435,
-0.1855449378490448,
0.9454559683799744,
0.59116131067276,
0.010420248843729496,
-0.2389809489250183,
-0.34552207589149475,
-0.34265509247779846,
-0.5209208726882935,
0.5387561917304993,
-0.27246588468551636,
-0.7369504570960999,
-0.016058944165706635,
-0.522958517074585,
0.08107716590166092,
0.9550477266311646,
-0.05775637552142143,
0.13845877349376678,
0.700322687625885,
0.959870457649231,
0.6046985983848572,
0.8706067800521851,
-0.12396269291639328,
0.23794065415859222,
-1.0104180574417114,
-0.4045998752117157,
-0.30962052941322327,
-0.1871456354856491,
-0.8320611715316772,
-0.31086570024490356,
0.5017454624176025,
-0.1448582410812378,
-0.31597745418548584,
0.363020122051239,
-0.7989667057991028,
0.5010702013969421,
0.2984301447868347,
0.190665140748024,
0.15077871084213257,
-0.28444552421569824,
-0.03869760036468506,
0.2483588606119156,
-0.7535346150398254,
-0.4874385595321655,
0.9716018438339233,
0.18634378910064697,
0.8543809056282043,
0.11328049004077911,
0.6809036731719971,
0.023759035393595695,
0.09638344496488571,
-0.7098017930984497,
0.41188275814056396,
-0.18571166694164276,
-0.28150248527526855,
-0.7002539038658142,
-0.6433828473091125,
-0.9034606218338013,
0.48611974716186523,
-0.1941000372171402,
-0.396185040473938,
-0.11429958790540695,
0.19338330626487732,
-0.22776742279529572,
0.5108290314674377,
-0.524448812007904,
0.9421406984329224,
-0.3319183886051178,
-0.24941538274288177,
-0.5029866099357605,
-0.7281747460365295,
-0.002014836994931102,
0.058918774127960205,
0.20576024055480957,
-0.1729682832956314,
-0.14709296822547913,
0.7721465826034546,
-0.5137551426887512,
0.5865217447280884,
-0.032690323889255524,
-0.03277977555990219,
0.20221808552742004,
-0.24791157245635986,
0.6221376657485962,
-0.2664244472980499,
-0.18269500136375427,
0.29090386629104614,
-0.09957952052354813,
-0.2613183557987213,
-0.5764974355697632,
0.43333208560943604,
-0.5180708169937134,
-0.5100958943367004,
-0.09370226413011551,
0.08273299038410187,
-0.03888283297419548,
0.2824844717979431,
0.4820297062397003,
0.15478107333183289,
-0.32465267181396484,
0.2960849702358246,
0.7122365236282349,
-0.129519522190094,
0.6126000285148621,
0.5377320051193237,
0.08334964513778687,
-0.4150699973106384,
1.039506196975708,
0.07781214267015457,
0.9152799844741821,
0.49368640780448914,
0.6916764974594116,
-0.14545102417469025,
-0.16180731356143951,
-0.29078131914138794,
-0.06950026005506516,
-0.9993918538093567,
-0.1620062291622162,
-0.9518460631370544,
-0.13350734114646912,
-0.2085162103176117,
-0.0816005989909172,
-0.6883665323257446,
-0.4093998670578003,
-0.42448240518569946,
-0.37550610303878784,
0.21098895370960236,
0.5926279425621033,
-0.19504216313362122,
0.2179320752620697,
-0.8579241633415222,
0.2819504141807556,
0.571932852268219,
0.3530626893043518,
0.07321223616600037,
-0.040078360587358475,
0.024528590962290764,
-0.07895790785551071,
-0.6429659128189087,
-0.8970741033554077,
0.1998664289712906,
0.7837590575218201,
0.7763751149177551,
0.38239020109176636,
0.1058083325624466,
0.319271057844162,
-0.7311315536499023,
0.53358393907547,
0.7553446888923645,
-0.9726315140724182,
0.808085024356842,
-0.05943324789404869,
0.2441742718219757,
0.43997761607170105,
0.20034775137901306,
-0.8026618361473083,
0.08945315331220627,
-0.9081746935844421,
-0.8780186176300049,
0.5619239807128906,
0.2769801616668701,
0.3476884067058563,
-0.14293338358402252,
0.12322846800088882,
0.1067262589931488,
0.10862531512975693,
-0.5514668226242065,
-0.29847079515457153,
-0.8635349869728088,
-0.177871972322464,
-0.14401599764823914,
0.020086102187633514,
-0.11595407873392105,
-0.1364067643880844,
0.7204465866088867,
-0.577832043170929,
0.24796780943870544,
0.28623202443122864,
-0.0060967374593019485,
-0.13149572908878326,
0.32081717252731323,
0.41002917289733887,
0.49506500363349915,
0.055784087628126144,
0.047579891979694366,
0.5598416924476624,
-0.4570002257823944,
-0.041562844067811966,
-0.08284251391887665,
0.010941850952804089,
0.17687638103961945,
0.15549369156360626,
1.1658622026443481,
0.49727028608322144,
-0.2427515685558319,
0.28908148407936096,
-0.167734757065773,
-0.20335859060287476,
-0.09803915023803711,
0.2835909128189087,
0.14421431720256805,
-0.010293091647326946,
0.3558400273323059,
0.34420669078826904,
0.43060222268104553,
-0.42375847697257996,
0.1501900553703308,
0.7434887886047363,
-0.4556494653224945,
-0.3506704270839691,
0.5804901123046875,
0.6884822845458984,
-0.2614172101020813,
0.3375109136104584,
-0.20621314644813538,
-0.6877455711364746,
0.6102015376091003,
0.5698915719985962,
1.1140660047531128,
-0.1777542382478714,
0.489081472158432,
0.37072280049324036,
0.2805217206478119,
0.09294301271438599,
0.17008408904075623,
-0.42930641770362854,
-0.6507177948951721,
-0.03523920103907585,
-0.8988603353500366,
-0.3330014646053314,
-0.5465973615646362,
-0.7005233764648438,
0.18773503601551056,
-0.2870270609855652,
-0.2995673418045044,
-0.23413591086864471,
0.006856991909444332,
-0.8360417485237122,
0.3204813301563263,
0.36651185154914856,
1.1534925699234009,
-1.0310516357421875,
0.4686157703399658,
0.26298725605010986,
0.358445942401886,
-0.6257014274597168,
-0.034313663840293884,
0.025774382054805756,
-0.45744994282722473,
0.9433733820915222,
0.2938271164894104,
-0.730654776096344,
0.24006877839565277,
-0.19399452209472656,
-1.1768800020217896,
1.6357754468917847,
0.2824368178844452,
-0.8955245018005371,
0.27545881271362305,
0.18224892020225525,
0.20180284976959229,
-0.3510376513004303,
0.7131178975105286,
0.26152345538139343,
0.7026297450065613,
0.7416175007820129,
-1.031471848487854,
0.002858089981600642,
0.03105856478214264,
0.17666423320770264,
0.5667234063148499,
-1.3085497617721558,
0.7287801504135132,
-0.19616906344890594,
-0.5435349345207214,
-0.3368191719055176,
0.6958404779434204,
-0.12723669409751892,
0.33982449769973755,
0.5983216762542725,
0.5416253805160522,
1.108008861541748,
-0.006118972785770893,
1.0108647346496582,
-0.4790201783180237,
0.7169079780578613,
0.6623084545135498,
-0.16979052126407623,
0.6290991902351379,
0.4950670003890991,
-0.08222192525863647,
0.2985009253025055,
0.3987049162387848,
0.12283319234848022,
0.9888132810592651,
0.15964694321155548,
-0.24476803839206696,
-0.5298917293548584,
-0.13450729846954346,
-0.28190258145332336,
0.3220822811126709,
0.3007959723472595,
-0.19161207973957062,
-0.4247448146343231,
0.23726336658000946,
-0.15304289758205414,
-0.29744985699653625,
-0.2470908761024475,
1.0025018453598022,
0.07958175987005234,
-0.3158944845199585,
0.26466208696365356,
-0.02369128353893757,
0.8279179334640503,
-0.8415393233299255,
-0.05885640159249306,
0.34527158737182617,
0.16548793017864227,
-0.326601505279541,
-0.5278567671775818,
0.7062312364578247,
-0.5443727374076843,
-0.0839809998869896,
-0.3698875904083252,
0.8730166554450989,
-0.244138702750206,
-0.4806663691997528,
0.6995224356651306,
0.010979852639138699,
-0.12187620997428894,
0.08508563786745071,
-0.9083001613616943,
0.2783690392971039,
-0.13359950482845306,
-0.29018840193748474,
0.01926477998495102,
0.4294072389602661,
0.3574801981449127,
0.7072568535804749,
0.799525260925293,
-0.008341772481799126,
0.0019351490773260593,
-0.1573234498500824,
0.9127351641654968,
-0.6481097340583801,
-0.6675774455070496,
-0.8306980729103088,
0.35815998911857605,
-0.35049203038215637,
-0.3895761966705322,
0.6550459265708923,
0.34798097610473633,
0.8884480595588684,
0.03146422281861305,
0.8974615335464478,
-0.05289503559470177,
0.17488446831703186,
-0.695379912853241,
0.645939290523529,
-0.3737603724002838,
-0.031227093189954758,
-0.38443225622177124,
-0.9510990381240845,
0.10871242731809616,
0.44569772481918335,
-0.26452410221099854,
0.13728578388690948,
0.789031445980072,
0.6839087605476379,
-0.17325705289840698,
0.4002828598022461,
0.6061944365501404,
-0.2819785475730896,
0.4288296103477478,
0.6946282982826233,
0.7385031580924988,
-0.5624783039093018,
0.5790534615516663,
-0.12121952325105667,
-0.3698122501373291,
-0.2642963230609894,
-1.1807857751846313,
-0.5015084147453308,
-0.5260733962059021,
-0.4620925784111023,
0.041643451899290085,
0.16410782933235168,
0.7621086835861206,
0.9948258399963379,
-0.5914818644523621,
0.3009912073612213,
-0.28941044211387634,
0.2239331305027008,
-0.29975420236587524,
-0.16006779670715332,
0.4282338619232178,
-0.32519444823265076,
-0.44918057322502136,
0.07319757342338562,
0.45310842990875244,
-0.12902258336544037,
0.02626878023147583,
-0.4275065064430237,
-0.057494428008794785,
0.18983770906925201,
0.6129217147827148,
0.12406857311725616,
-0.6410167217254639,
-0.3294091522693634,
-0.13890203833580017,
0.06851467490196228,
-0.07838138192892075,
0.6754108667373657,
-0.6843981146812439,
0.28548043966293335,
0.43031325936317444,
0.44533631205558777,
0.43002769351005554,
-0.29641348123550415,
0.18376342952251434,
-0.1628369241952896,
-0.08418936282396317,
0.15308761596679688,
0.221975177526474,
0.40439555048942566,
-0.4823106527328491,
0.2747194766998291,
0.4123351573944092,
-0.3871614336967468,
-0.13984337449073792,
0.42586520314216614,
-0.5209906697273254,
-0.49818849563598633,
1.3462859392166138,
0.011957556009292603,
-0.6031953692436218,
0.10136687755584717,
-0.11360643804073334,
0.18294130265712738,
-0.1876867562532425,
0.47305867075920105,
0.43282151222229004,
-0.23125018179416656,
-0.1637837290763855,
-0.44307249784469604,
0.5984479784965515,
0.4349331259727478,
-0.7636240124702454,
0.13666319847106934,
0.22794832289218903,
0.46217960119247437,
0.48850834369659424,
0.13139919936656952,
0.13992123305797577,
0.11839251965284348,
-0.008901029825210571,
-0.1521911770105362,
-0.16493439674377441,
-0.46211668848991394,
-0.01861676760017872,
0.07759865373373032,
-0.512529730796814,
-0.3981112241744995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15695v1 | SS-Bench: A Benchmark for Social Story Generation and Evaluation | 2024-06-22T00:14:48 | 2024-06-22T00:14:48 | Yi Feng, Mingyang Song, Jiaqi Wang, Mao Zheng, Liping Jing, Jian Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) often misunderstand social
situations and struggle to participate in daily routines. Psychology experts
write Social Stories under strict constraints of structural clarity,
descriptive orientation, and situational safety to enhance their abilities in
these regimes. However, Social Stories are costly in creation and often limited
in diversity and timeliness. As Large Language Models (LLMs) become
increasingly powerful, there is a growing need for more automated, affordable,
and accessible methods to generate Social Stories in real-time with broad
coverage. Adapting LLMs to meet the unique and strict constraints of Social
Stories is a challenging issue. To this end, we propose \textbf{SS-Bench}, a
\textbf{S}ocial \textbf{S}tory \textbf{Bench}mark for generating and evaluating
Social Stories. Specifically, we develop a constraint-driven strategy named
\textbf{\textsc{StarSow}} to hierarchically prompt LLMs to generate Social
Stories and build a benchmark, which has been validated through experiments to
fine-tune smaller models for generating qualified Social Stories. Additionally,
we introduce \textbf{Quality Assessment Criteria}, employed in human and GPT
evaluations, to verify the effectiveness of the generated stories. We hope this
work benefits the autism community and catalyzes future research focusing on
particular groups. | [
-0.24612347781658173,
-0.4877852201461792,
0.48816773295402527,
0.4086390733718872,
-0.17769038677215576,
0.5790091156959534,
-0.08696427196264267,
-0.5263400673866272,
0.48494642972946167,
0.2527582347393036,
-0.8716967701911926,
-0.4277460277080536,
-0.4945773184299469,
0.1955557018518448,
-0.5234185457229614,
1.0287976264953613,
-0.2556219696998596,
-0.23956938087940216,
-0.0567176528275013,
-0.16296018660068512,
-0.10429538041353226,
-0.1296282857656479,
-0.7020938992500305,
0.08793987333774567,
0.346551775932312,
0.6712664365768433,
0.6563873887062073,
0.8733544945716858,
0.2426961064338684,
0.21154409646987915,
-0.014684905298054218,
0.3826465606689453,
-0.5171328186988831,
0.3092288374900818,
-0.24251124262809753,
-0.04676774889230728,
-0.4812079966068268,
0.013519203290343285,
0.7003734111785889,
0.8707569241523743,
-0.08973203599452972,
0.5710598230361938,
0.2407332956790924,
0.5962848663330078,
-0.4118155539035797,
-0.02048945426940918,
-0.2948738634586334,
0.0959450900554657,
-0.3424784541130066,
0.10265963524580002,
0.14279355108737946,
-0.44816118478775024,
-0.4050954580307007,
-0.4544966220855713,
0.3875594139099121,
0.15145345032215118,
1.0537595748901367,
-0.03224789351224899,
-0.5676199793815613,
-0.04557814449071884,
-0.5664448142051697,
0.43344858288764954,
-0.6020405292510986,
0.29599976539611816,
0.557813286781311,
0.6766542196273804,
-0.07457684725522995,
-0.540236234664917,
-0.5063342452049255,
-0.2880926728248596,
0.27460241317749023,
-0.22395721077919006,
0.14532411098480225,
-0.5033372044563293,
0.2327072024345398,
0.011606954038143158,
-0.510776162147522,
-0.10052706301212311,
-0.4347442388534546,
0.11825138330459595,
0.9926266074180603,
0.5233813524246216,
0.24651150405406952,
-0.5124216675758362,
-0.17969486117362976,
0.08321568369865417,
-0.7302926778793335,
0.11741702258586884,
0.23154214024543762,
0.3702804446220398,
-0.29230546951293945,
0.5464390516281128,
-0.6391904354095459,
0.010195114649832249,
0.27271777391433716,
0.1173272505402565,
0.3911508321762085,
-0.4208889305591583,
0.3927004635334015,
-0.01877928338944912,
0.716950535774231,
0.8566226363182068,
0.21889899671077728,
-0.33212682604789734,
-0.34942224621772766,
0.46927645802497864,
0.3055335283279419,
-0.6635867357254028,
0.45928120613098145,
0.07119545340538025,
-0.45901206135749817,
-0.6247164011001587,
-0.43471845984458923,
-0.7636244297027588,
-0.7270760536193848,
-0.17138627171516418,
-0.016004562377929688,
-0.6220832467079163,
-0.2650719881057739,
-0.1520060896873474,
-0.11083879321813583,
-0.09090889990329742,
-0.059159211814403534,
-0.9010408520698547,
0.6608328223228455,
0.6200695037841797,
0.7285081744194031,
-0.16062361001968384,
-0.5634728670120239,
-0.8219748139381409,
0.546144962310791,
-0.5312585830688477,
0.8806882500648499,
-0.44683223962783813,
-0.26550406217575073,
-0.0743035152554512,
-0.12109530717134476,
0.164907768368721,
-0.29464030265808105,
0.6661741733551025,
-0.07663656026124954,
-0.42620572447776794,
-0.5668054223060608,
-0.45917582511901855,
0.4886482357978821,
0.11344129592180252,
-0.07082875818014145,
0.9086021780967712,
0.4243502616882324,
-0.2637557089328766,
0.5487668514251709,
-0.5483407378196716,
-0.7334407567977905,
0.45614755153656006,
-0.5701330304145813,
-0.1465824693441391,
0.18539053201675415,
0.3996220529079437,
0.2958105504512787,
-0.5079159140586853,
0.556927502155304,
-0.28284478187561035,
-0.3504379689693451,
0.1735345423221588,
-0.10935349017381668,
0.5704596638679504,
0.17171898484230042,
-0.6517521142959595,
0.2587752342224121,
-0.9472807049751282,
0.05543025955557823,
0.3400905132293701,
-0.04809320345520973,
-0.0047189355827867985,
0.24629826843738556,
0.31213244795799255,
-0.032991278916597366,
-0.06169118732213974,
-0.7873515486717224,
-0.4087841510772705,
-0.14277911186218262,
0.6210992932319641,
0.7325251698493958,
0.16199716925621033,
-0.0021906450856477022,
-0.6941652297973633,
0.6210792660713196,
-0.45886513590812683,
0.40742626786231995,
0.145984947681427,
-0.07669459283351898,
-0.31784069538116455,
-0.024191999807953835,
0.23721438646316528,
0.04284915700554848,
-0.8460397124290466,
0.6058275699615479,
-0.3125535249710083,
-0.5985186100006104,
-0.2712104618549347,
0.0856340229511261,
0.5817666053771973,
0.3768370449542999,
0.028374265879392624,
-0.6371137499809265,
-0.21796460449695587,
-0.7050986886024475,
-0.22149260342121124,
0.02367095835506916,
-0.03515143692493439,
0.6695759296417236,
0.17329983413219452,
-0.18866084516048431,
0.7735853791236877,
-0.19018247723579407,
-0.2513207495212555,
-0.3003886640071869,
0.2599288523197174,
-0.08367669582366943,
0.40303289890289307,
0.6934908628463745,
-0.5364500880241394,
-0.7598357200622559,
-0.3404825031757355,
-0.7463032603263855,
-0.5485663414001465,
0.04826187342405319,
-0.027039453387260437,
0.18578492105007172,
0.5540285706520081,
-0.7428867816925049,
0.44992557168006897,
0.39053863286972046,
-0.6838899850845337,
0.8958132863044739,
0.15176182985305786,
0.3798748850822449,
-0.8389090299606323,
-0.1017068400979042,
-0.05005700886249542,
-0.1533854603767395,
-0.1820991188287735,
0.03433815762400627,
0.08400852978229523,
-0.5586771368980408,
-0.3420589864253998,
0.5604977011680603,
-0.5753974914550781,
-0.5014848709106445,
0.10549755394458771,
0.4689674973487854,
-0.14258185029029846,
0.31427040696144104,
-0.2639910578727722,
0.39370810985565186,
0.4739192724227905,
-0.35637032985687256,
0.184275820851326,
0.31060469150543213,
-0.5337854027748108,
0.9609805941581726,
-0.6453850865364075,
-0.021328477188944817,
0.09539277851581573,
0.4677661061286926,
-0.8164461255073547,
-0.31987595558166504,
0.06411650031805038,
-0.4250332713127136,
0.12141343951225281,
0.26284587383270264,
-0.7291596531867981,
-0.6433849334716797,
-0.4513150751590729,
0.15831443667411804,
0.30716046690940857,
-0.469835102558136,
0.2982671558856964,
0.5778908133506775,
-0.5824444890022278,
-0.24455691874027252,
-0.4195359945297241,
0.4195934236049652,
-0.07624954730272293,
-0.7318573594093323,
0.3580120801925659,
-0.2817341983318329,
-0.006642485968768597,
0.44593626260757446,
-0.46575728058815,
0.2880295515060425,
-0.01752595417201519,
0.19457943737506866,
-0.02882496267557144,
-0.5411151647567749,
-0.08236374706029892,
0.48031824827194214,
-0.33379578590393066,
-0.06788507848978043,
0.5208419561386108,
0.48200279474258423,
-0.2921135723590851,
-0.5066199898719788,
-0.0791039988398552,
0.6939829587936401,
0.5865044593811035,
-0.270866334438324,
0.29104843735694885,
0.30820411443710327,
-0.4692663848400116,
-0.6902058124542236,
-0.34877458214759827,
-0.18454135954380035,
-0.5276530385017395,
0.31496089696884155,
-0.31810516119003296,
-0.6439405083656311,
0.4497143626213074,
-0.1073639914393425,
0.00855210330337286,
0.22793617844581604,
0.19238384068012238,
-0.030815888196229935,
0.9724666476249695,
0.24772638082504272,
0.34581243991851807,
0.31748950481414795,
0.1381637156009674,
-0.009530807845294476,
-0.9053589105606079,
0.34090206027030945,
-0.22258402407169342,
-0.5862523913383484,
0.1952521800994873,
-0.29333430528640747,
0.38209086656570435,
0.13478627800941467,
-0.5489230155944824,
0.29753953218460083,
-0.6240890622138977,
0.847171425819397,
0.31537219882011414,
0.016634026542305946,
0.19464701414108276,
-0.21303367614746094,
-0.213104248046875,
-0.1612468808889389,
-0.6225792765617371,
-0.584104061126709,
1.432364821434021,
0.25947603583335876,
0.3616599440574646,
0.2616327404975891,
0.8959581255912781,
0.44354960322380066,
0.6259399652481079,
-0.19303742051124573,
0.8556087613105774,
-0.40416866540908813,
-0.5401343703269958,
-0.557975172996521,
-0.23942770063877106,
-0.8845940828323364,
0.040041081607341766,
-0.4204757511615753,
-1.1575806140899658,
0.3325502574443817,
-0.3075830638408661,
-0.7291802763938904,
-0.1742202788591385,
-0.5320976376533508,
0.8918793797492981,
-0.5772661566734314,
-0.410325825214386,
-0.26332753896713257,
-0.5307003259658813,
0.2688280940055847,
-0.33407020568847656,
0.22353389859199524,
-0.4892137050628662,
0.04268355295062065,
0.6863120794296265,
-0.6991029977798462,
0.9409752488136292,
-0.13366946578025818,
0.47180187702178955,
0.19796179234981537,
0.21788090467453003,
0.539528489112854,
0.05330860987305641,
-0.1489124745130539,
-0.10783667117357254,
0.1782153993844986,
-0.2090320587158203,
-0.20315001904964447,
0.8680724501609802,
-0.7973015904426575,
-0.5000821352005005,
-0.401937872171402,
-0.8001967668533325,
-0.869110107421875,
0.1825801283121109,
-0.16396570205688477,
0.4936050474643707,
-0.4067676067352295,
0.3008284866809845,
0.010331475175917149,
-0.2446940541267395,
0.3562701642513275,
1.0378926992416382,
-0.3338924050331116,
-0.354876846075058,
0.8087686896324158,
0.4274632930755615,
0.1315845549106598,
-0.4643338620662689,
0.14216776192188263,
-0.19596421718597412,
-0.6536024212837219,
-0.5093870162963867,
0.30767443776130676,
-0.5142965316772461,
-0.2849913537502289,
-0.4427596628665924,
-0.638249933719635,
-0.6207968592643738,
-0.7114326357841492,
-0.38637614250183105,
-0.44251197576522827,
0.16293902695178986,
-0.36492493748664856,
0.26549026370048523,
0.5653793215751648,
-0.47355976700782776,
0.15985123813152313,
-0.795718252658844,
0.7526462078094482,
0.0895562618970871,
0.6999472975730896,
0.041181713342666626,
-0.029815159738063812,
-0.16096346080303192,
-0.05768602341413498,
-0.43870943784713745,
-0.7166951894760132,
0.2841886281967163,
0.1856032758951187,
0.7447407245635986,
0.06100979074835777,
0.41238516569137573,
0.505031943321228,
-0.7342477440834045,
0.7614791989326477,
0.28327929973602295,
-0.7886866331100464,
0.5578927993774414,
-0.7565356492996216,
-0.00666541513055563,
0.684075653553009,
0.09265194088220596,
-0.5062446594238281,
-0.6268398761749268,
-1.0019140243530273,
-1.1237149238586426,
0.8789092898368835,
0.32886767387390137,
0.03496566414833069,
-0.24846966564655304,
0.27732327580451965,
0.059525858610868454,
0.24967332184314728,
-0.33618268370628357,
-0.0803474560379982,
-0.16449208557605743,
-0.3603777587413788,
-0.30493640899658203,
-0.39585888385772705,
-0.43000659346580505,
-0.17268982529640198,
0.5072420239448547,
-0.14150895178318024,
-0.10935689508914948,
-0.1372929960489273,
0.21721506118774414,
-0.8574490547180176,
0.1598561406135559,
0.19212034344673157,
0.7240826487541199,
-0.2953973412513733,
-0.10450214892625809,
-0.05781901255249977,
-0.17552827298641205,
0.027405450120568275,
0.5741430521011353,
-0.2960302531719208,
-0.04214511439204216,
0.12280009686946869,
0.6655534505844116,
0.48202571272850037,
-0.7856341600418091,
0.5773687362670898,
-0.20834285020828247,
-0.44079044461250305,
-0.1212950274348259,
0.27099835872650146,
0.33378615975379944,
0.6666687726974487,
0.40763384103775024,
-0.0006956038414500654,
-0.10023953765630722,
-0.5741150379180908,
0.5064266920089722,
0.11130691319704056,
-0.16991190612316132,
-0.10530661791563034,
0.9231956601142883,
0.43208029866218567,
-0.7123157978057861,
0.14947378635406494,
-0.39249107241630554,
-0.1285790205001831,
0.9297269582748413,
0.7696163654327393,
0.9998502731323242,
-0.10715080797672272,
0.7166426777839661,
0.12656939029693604,
0.3326569199562073,
0.13420826196670532,
0.2820330858230591,
-0.145872563123703,
-0.721267580986023,
0.09236222505569458,
-0.8134618997573853,
-0.44068557024002075,
0.21932770311832428,
-0.5884080529212952,
0.18505002558231354,
-0.7299357652664185,
-0.1203770712018013,
0.39826294779777527,
0.08696512132883072,
-0.3640899062156677,
0.15089748799800873,
0.28761783242225647,
0.7937529683113098,
-0.9332544803619385,
0.5543580055236816,
0.45665213465690613,
-0.5110465884208679,
-0.7943046689033508,
0.18019738793373108,
0.36200156807899475,
-0.7247292995452881,
0.4556560218334198,
0.0060576265677809715,
0.00774101447314024,
-0.10469584912061691,
-0.32222697138786316,
-0.9642622470855713,
1.0069104433059692,
0.26516324281692505,
-0.5992984771728516,
0.19447942078113556,
0.34148767590522766,
0.9113647937774658,
-0.819912314414978,
-0.29477283358573914,
0.37781018018722534,
0.35096871852874756,
0.2782618999481201,
-0.8154101371765137,
0.5036205053329468,
-0.6217362880706787,
0.08015526086091995,
-0.2491174340248108,
-0.7818018794059753,
0.6300874948501587,
-0.2493276447057724,
-0.4811074733734131,
0.1869058758020401,
0.37908050417900085,
0.7830787301063538,
0.5358105897903442,
0.584506094455719,
0.08192218095064163,
0.6532562375068665,
0.1691821664571762,
1.0614070892333984,
-0.4804724156856537,
-0.05690538510680199,
1.2284947633743286,
-0.7429189682006836,
0.8615692257881165,
0.08866346627473831,
-0.031733106821775436,
0.27625569701194763,
0.7324037551879883,
0.047150708734989166,
0.5319286584854126,
0.4183753728866577,
0.005761695560067892,
-0.18730038404464722,
-0.20889797806739807,
-0.5541396737098694,
-0.009174654260277748,
0.47177454829216003,
-0.11419249325990677,
-0.3968699276447296,
-0.13514788448810577,
-0.1632799357175827,
0.5092121958732605,
-0.270205557346344,
0.37158799171447754,
0.2354332059621811,
-0.5998656749725342,
0.6191288828849792,
-0.09715550392866135,
0.2757444977760315,
-0.6151397228240967,
0.3012063205242157,
-0.35586127638816833,
0.23038047552108765,
-0.07086814939975739,
-0.7097641229629517,
0.4255371689796448,
0.3250017464160919,
-0.1116589829325676,
-0.32883980870246887,
0.6158097982406616,
-0.34089040756225586,
-0.7260143756866455,
0.15317358076572418,
0.6043962836265564,
0.09767818450927734,
0.22723905742168427,
-0.8272159695625305,
0.25473856925964355,
-0.2722863554954529,
-0.3236759901046753,
0.5752871632575989,
0.7063375115394592,
-0.3542100191116333,
0.6356927156448364,
0.6659558415412903,
0.28134316205978394,
-0.259094774723053,
0.2807919383049011,
0.8221338391304016,
-0.6310295462608337,
-0.8660822510719299,
-0.18410266935825348,
0.4184795320034027,
-0.33779239654541016,
-0.5432320237159729,
0.6932553052902222,
0.5236677527427673,
0.225324809551239,
0.2267918735742569,
0.71318119764328,
-0.1752464771270752,
1.0177083015441895,
0.08840764313936234,
1.2025580406188965,
-0.6709458231925964,
0.3900020718574524,
-0.4008016884326935,
-0.7995895147323608,
-0.03451385349035263,
0.39724844694137573,
-0.19993484020233154,
-0.18273723125457764,
1.0552887916564941,
0.6787269115447998,
-0.03966039419174194,
0.3344329297542572,
0.032144512981176376,
0.2918158769607544,
0.24247534573078156,
0.5220971703529358,
0.8139023780822754,
-0.17391231656074524,
0.5902636647224426,
0.008886568248271942,
-0.5820408463478088,
-0.017695169895887375,
-0.7257605791091919,
-0.8156189322471619,
-0.6235948204994202,
-0.4783145785331726,
-0.5103011727333069,
0.5093322992324829,
0.6536622047424316,
0.5705133080482483,
-0.5568740963935852,
-0.35949090123176575,
-0.05547336861491203,
-0.00035706008202396333,
-0.6578059196472168,
-0.20866940915584564,
0.3621547818183899,
-0.38215866684913635,
-0.2048618644475937,
0.6143657565116882,
0.05542325973510742,
-0.40048184990882874,
-0.11659502983093262,
-0.2732516825199127,
-0.0703440010547638,
0.42852795124053955,
0.35081198811531067,
0.42831161618232727,
-0.3910272717475891,
-0.6812365651130676,
-0.3606572449207306,
-0.34242936968803406,
-0.2527562975883484,
0.3753758668899536,
-0.4323566257953644,
0.0015743860276415944,
0.014059271663427353,
0.7661263942718506,
0.8666425347328186,
-0.013919997029006481,
0.745014488697052,
-0.9208943247795105,
-0.4446302652359009,
0.2863050401210785,
0.2179637849330902,
0.21488671004772186,
-0.3688119053840637,
0.8015376329421997,
0.44313693046569824,
-0.28636184334754944,
-1.164970874786377,
0.13325157761573792,
-0.9960693120956421,
-0.34592294692993164,
1.4839942455291748,
0.08818136900663376,
-0.40218833088874817,
-0.07175182551145554,
-0.21472559869289398,
-0.026227600872516632,
-0.4443841874599457,
1.0551245212554932,
0.6442359089851379,
-0.1634322702884674,
-0.18753790855407715,
-0.22502104938030243,
0.5651116371154785,
0.24570026993751526,
-0.729058027267456,
0.4708932638168335,
0.6668609380722046,
0.3506913483142853,
0.10760664194822311,
0.9878175258636475,
-0.1567717045545578,
0.5272542834281921,
0.5684934854507446,
-0.14250890910625458,
-0.30854347348213196,
-0.13040176033973694,
0.34662169218063354,
0.31495654582977295,
-0.3996570408344269,
-0.048924677073955536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15673v1 | Large Language Models have Intrinsic Self-Correction Ability | 2024-06-21T22:29:40 | 2024-06-21T22:29:40 | Dancheng Liu, Amir Nassereldine, Ziming Yang, Chenhui Xu, Yuting Hu, Jiajie Li, Utkarsh Kumar, Changjae Lee, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have attracted significant attention for their
remarkable abilities in various natural language processing tasks, but they
suffer from hallucinations that will cause performance degradation. One
promising solution to improve the LLMs' performance is to ask LLMs to revise
their answer after generation, a technique known as self-correction. Among the
two types of self-correction, intrinsic self-correction is considered a
promising direction because it does not utilize external knowledge. However,
recent works doubt the validity of LLM's ability to conduct intrinsic
self-correction. In this paper, we present a novel perspective on the intrinsic
self-correction capabilities of LLMs through theoretical analyses and empirical
experiments. In addition, we identify two critical factors for successful
self-correction: zero temperature and fair prompts. Leveraging these factors,
we demonstrate that intrinsic self-correction ability is exhibited across
multiple existing LLMs. Our findings offer insights into the fundamental
theories underlying the self-correction behavior of LLMs and remark on the
importance of unbiased prompts and zero temperature settings in harnessing
their full potential. | [
-0.10396801680326462,
-0.8829089999198914,
0.7479279041290283,
0.06687866151332855,
0.12503837049007416,
0.10416954010725021,
-0.5155109763145447,
-0.3389933407306671,
0.04495493322610855,
0.640284538269043,
-0.6046727895736694,
-0.04725779965519905,
-0.3573087155818939,
0.36786195635795593,
-0.47393307089805603,
1.0017454624176025,
0.03474872186779976,
-0.06352555006742477,
-0.05718337371945381,
-0.1288754940032959,
-0.6008631587028503,
-0.7559898495674133,
-0.5085271000862122,
-0.5751259326934814,
0.6734125018119812,
0.56109619140625,
0.5051003098487854,
0.6082029342651367,
0.2514795958995819,
0.34040629863739014,
0.015703342854976654,
-0.059769339859485626,
-0.555596113204956,
0.4931398332118988,
-0.4526054561138153,
-0.7071978449821472,
-0.4136853516101837,
-0.07431864738464355,
0.8768294453620911,
0.6202321648597717,
-0.2953455448150635,
0.026492996141314507,
0.2270488142967224,
0.8951681852340698,
-0.367658406496048,
-0.09625010937452316,
-0.9942216277122498,
-0.118180051445961,
-0.15640592575073242,
-0.19429272413253784,
-0.4965808093547821,
-0.026404401287436485,
-0.1083349660038948,
-0.11387506872415543,
0.522803544998169,
-0.12278732657432556,
0.49289676547050476,
0.4539545178413391,
-0.3882790207862854,
-0.1591300517320633,
-0.9942563772201538,
0.5890362858772278,
-1.0813595056533813,
0.01657683588564396,
0.1512981653213501,
-0.0716952532529831,
-0.22522279620170593,
-0.2808568775653839,
-0.7733373045921326,
-0.14039494097232819,
0.0195938628166914,
-0.28780147433280945,
-0.13639454543590546,
-0.04666715860366821,
0.3386901915073395,
0.39382490515708923,
-0.14581400156021118,
0.5449680089950562,
-0.21312333643436432,
-0.12086734175682068,
0.3894152045249939,
0.3356878459453583,
0.18703342974185944,
-0.1359269917011261,
-0.03261282667517662,
0.028995806351304054,
-0.7362257242202759,
0.1367669403553009,
0.1958581507205963,
0.4646458029747009,
0.15040552616119385,
0.5698686242103577,
-0.35993221402168274,
0.5485584139823914,
0.3946504592895508,
-0.1676321029663086,
0.06723268330097198,
-0.07476483285427094,
-0.10833197832107544,
0.240783229470253,
0.5010571479797363,
0.30643439292907715,
0.23233234882354736,
-0.3109258711338043,
-0.4950163662433624,
-0.12778733670711517,
0.22512836754322052,
-0.8085582256317139,
-0.10572057217359543,
0.3024284839630127,
-0.09321288764476776,
-0.2068757265806198,
-0.28724169731140137,
-0.3946225643157959,
-0.5162109732627869,
-0.5817835927009583,
0.56838059425354,
-0.18232257664203644,
-0.21853084862232208,
0.22282756865024567,
0.16256870329380035,
-0.0657985731959343,
0.5939918160438538,
-1.0266624689102173,
0.054139867424964905,
0.6437569856643677,
0.7423380017280579,
-0.003234038595110178,
-0.4982253909111023,
-0.22906072437763214,
0.3353627920150757,
-0.46819573640823364,
0.9742236733436584,
-0.5315186381340027,
-0.1474004089832306,
-0.2007177621126175,
-0.0482608787715435,
-0.06739693880081177,
-0.37410515546798706,
0.28726860880851746,
-0.47478610277175903,
0.16125132143497467,
-0.664107084274292,
-0.5062219500541687,
-0.11294524371623993,
0.15707309544086456,
-0.3510090410709381,
0.7710895538330078,
-0.25859972834587097,
-0.6691615581512451,
0.1631903499364853,
-0.47673845291137695,
-0.2608918249607086,
-0.0044318800792098045,
0.15253552794456482,
-0.20084550976753235,
0.4154462516307831,
0.1538441926240921,
0.42985349893569946,
-0.13919788599014282,
0.2945171594619751,
-0.4492512345314026,
-0.07817888259887695,
0.672594428062439,
-0.5599042773246765,
0.40050092339515686,
0.05835624411702156,
-0.5874150991439819,
0.3034632205963135,
-0.5228936076164246,
0.042878955602645874,
0.13327334821224213,
-0.10343369841575623,
-0.21417495608329773,
0.03223725035786629,
-0.6172084808349609,
0.16914989054203033,
0.32932761311531067,
-0.5212998986244202,
0.6504883766174316,
-0.3803180754184723,
0.6318535804748535,
1.205122470855713,
-0.18365003168582916,
0.6070877909660339,
-0.23200161755084991,
0.35746142268180847,
-0.13476064801216125,
0.005590212065726519,
-0.4271845817565918,
-0.193069189786911,
-1.0629082918167114,
-0.024866824969649315,
0.296257883310318,
0.5752986073493958,
-0.566392183303833,
0.2064022570848465,
0.0446418896317482,
-0.4960765540599823,
-0.5854009389877319,
0.45108604431152344,
0.18767552077770233,
0.7701691389083862,
0.2909446954727173,
0.16661101579666138,
-0.24554365873336792,
-0.7727311849594116,
-0.3517395257949829,
-0.09367834776639938,
0.12234880775213242,
0.18418262898921967,
0.3403823673725128,
-0.18602246046066284,
0.9806572198867798,
-0.3147253692150116,
-0.2687450349330902,
-0.14377595484256744,
0.24603568017482758,
0.5207077264785767,
0.39398232102394104,
0.40109315514564514,
-0.13019876182079315,
-0.2816014587879181,
-0.18245477974414825,
-0.8933647871017456,
-0.3162585496902466,
-0.2240711897611618,
0.05684841424226761,
0.5527735948562622,
0.6538786888122559,
-0.5306066274642944,
0.24690347909927368,
0.4728240966796875,
-0.4009028971195221,
0.5866236090660095,
-0.5958905816078186,
0.1745867282152176,
-0.5159134268760681,
-0.15962114930152893,
-0.13738133013248444,
-0.011484792456030846,
-0.7568886280059814,
0.1829482465982437,
0.1545911282300949,
0.24916844069957733,
-0.21481871604919434,
0.8044846057891846,
-0.6595467329025269,
0.11293485760688782,
-0.6987800002098083,
-0.00015323921979870647,
-0.27632883191108704,
0.32608386874198914,
-0.2149467021226883,
0.7618809342384338,
0.7453214526176453,
-0.8414014577865601,
0.38669300079345703,
-0.10537465661764145,
-0.0173545703291893,
0.6419956088066101,
-0.8033598065376282,
0.4395934045314789,
-0.4147022068500519,
0.142691969871521,
-0.9705483317375183,
-0.058290623128414154,
0.10432775318622589,
-0.2776775062084198,
0.4367835521697998,
0.10867630690336227,
-0.7023480534553528,
-0.37734368443489075,
-0.20618796348571777,
0.2788151204586029,
0.36035698652267456,
-0.6647003889083862,
0.5290549993515015,
0.10224409401416779,
-0.4190530478954315,
-0.4739997088909149,
-0.4570279121398926,
0.3714200258255005,
-0.07131193578243256,
-0.5701891183853149,
0.010860242880880833,
-0.3471376597881317,
-0.3275362253189087,
-0.015403425320982933,
0.030458398163318634,
0.40924519300460815,
0.10090423375368118,
0.1930128037929535,
0.2811434864997864,
-0.17158082127571106,
0.386597603559494,
-0.1955493837594986,
-0.12261569499969482,
0.09285048395395279,
-0.2670707404613495,
0.5943609476089478,
-0.35571718215942383,
-0.34107235074043274,
-0.3784439265727997,
-0.002306054113432765,
0.45995014905929565,
-0.08478336781263351,
0.9201708436012268,
0.18710453808307648,
-0.3470996916294098,
-0.17850658297538757,
-1.0755597352981567,
-0.4401807487010956,
-0.5183042883872986,
0.07013587653636932,
-0.3434128165245056,
-1.1494951248168945,
0.7617591619491577,
0.4116046130657196,
-0.03697556257247925,
0.6854683756828308,
0.8710184693336487,
-0.08310460299253464,
1.0880048274993896,
0.49993380904197693,
0.04836932569742203,
0.21340394020080566,
0.1534881740808487,
0.40179261565208435,
-1.003035068511963,
-0.30779460072517395,
-0.7608715295791626,
-0.26162853837013245,
-0.4903862178325653,
-0.2723616659641266,
0.331768274307251,
0.11813492327928543,
-0.3830767571926117,
0.0006792215281166136,
-0.5160768628120422,
0.5414546728134155,
0.5558128952980042,
0.0036644642241299152,
0.38361233472824097,
-0.1620585322380066,
-0.07716197520494461,
-0.22493335604667664,
-0.6329783201217651,
-0.534386396408081,
0.8917407989501953,
0.5680822730064392,
1.1459448337554932,
0.05437923222780228,
0.32860562205314636,
0.21071656048297882,
0.3938613831996918,
-0.5404415130615234,
0.43744957447052,
-0.01671735756099224,
-0.7256731390953064,
-0.700988233089447,
-0.4353170394897461,
-0.7100586891174316,
0.17934934794902802,
-0.1441378891468048,
-0.5621600151062012,
0.023698555305600166,
0.35199812054634094,
-0.35016539692878723,
0.670179545879364,
-0.664408802986145,
0.6386988759040833,
-0.5600317120552063,
-0.5104938745498657,
-0.28922948241233826,
-0.33041566610336304,
0.3360024690628052,
-0.2823004126548767,
0.20405162870883942,
-0.27833861112594604,
0.08727069199085236,
0.4440043270587921,
-0.21557994186878204,
1.1317540407180786,
-0.22052828967571259,
-0.6234208345413208,
0.20288404822349548,
0.4378543794155121,
0.5105751752853394,
0.10955317318439484,
-0.21855497360229492,
0.251016765832901,
-0.02171173132956028,
-0.3771718442440033,
-0.7410664558410645,
0.9046556949615479,
-0.8346337080001831,
-1.157111644744873,
-0.6689556241035461,
-0.4866400957107544,
-0.22591450810432434,
0.21017543971538544,
0.057634055614471436,
0.2706758975982666,
0.1222180426120758,
0.2134280651807785,
0.6967408657073975,
-0.17304837703704834,
0.624181866645813,
1.0380079746246338,
-0.5114588737487793,
-0.06858652085065842,
0.6465311646461487,
0.36442625522613525,
0.3172833323478699,
0.15858609974384308,
0.3609454035758972,
-0.3449639081954956,
-0.5094560980796814,
-0.4224523901939392,
0.5021211504936218,
-0.7272666096687317,
-0.27275794744491577,
-0.845722496509552,
-0.18839654326438904,
-0.674432635307312,
-0.19901156425476074,
-0.4404337406158447,
-0.29281094670295715,
-0.5481153130531311,
-0.1260611116886139,
0.38886263966560364,
0.9684204459190369,
-0.4688326120376587,
0.1901567429304123,
-0.7551851868629456,
0.2725529968738556,
0.6052403450012207,
0.48422297835350037,
0.3710201680660248,
-0.9467833042144775,
0.021636391058564186,
0.30148619413375854,
-0.16923123598098755,
-0.6573303937911987,
0.3304389715194702,
0.13685475289821625,
0.6153550744056702,
0.31159237027168274,
0.0728917047381401,
0.696189820766449,
-0.5955599546432495,
0.6619378328323364,
0.13112768530845642,
-1.2787466049194336,
0.6121571063995361,
-0.3495136797428131,
0.4687790870666504,
0.38025182485580444,
0.017637966200709343,
-0.7950235605239868,
-0.43916749954223633,
-0.5040192604064941,
-0.6520659327507019,
0.6443653702735901,
-0.006011708173900843,
0.49163398146629333,
-0.007496790494769812,
0.7196831107139587,
0.16457121074199677,
0.19525103271007538,
-0.7766812443733215,
-0.1841842234134674,
-0.3651755452156067,
0.31223610043525696,
-0.2693040370941162,
-0.503933310508728,
-0.010638147592544556,
-0.36876407265663147,
0.7797778248786926,
-0.27469775080680847,
0.05971623212099075,
0.3012320399284363,
0.05807541683316231,
-0.523693323135376,
0.6090337038040161,
0.7771189212799072,
0.7382006645202637,
-0.2211727499961853,
0.16951626539230347,
0.44065263867378235,
0.24491725862026215,
0.161319762468338,
-0.4949147701263428,
-0.2709387242794037,
-0.3565685749053955,
0.2826838195323944,
0.7425355911254883,
-0.029713023453950882,
-0.4373437762260437,
0.25925037264823914,
-0.13101352751255035,
0.10675021260976791,
-0.2105761170387268,
0.12969674170017242,
0.01264179963618517,
0.11868119239807129,
0.514299750328064,
0.11451800912618637,
-0.03487652167677879,
-0.9945259094238281,
0.041585665196180344,
0.5265222787857056,
-0.27529868483543396,
-0.5589314103126526,
0.656400203704834,
0.12544500827789307,
-0.2920714020729065,
0.8146098852157593,
-0.29426777362823486,
-0.7204833626747131,
0.29290032386779785,
0.7652578353881836,
0.7498425245285034,
-0.5975725054740906,
0.32047420740127563,
0.3672280013561249,
0.48742708563804626,
-0.22226940095424652,
0.023238033056259155,
0.28036412596702576,
-0.9039915204048157,
-0.5931302905082703,
-0.5604864954948425,
-0.4663742482662201,
0.09337177872657776,
-0.5212986469268799,
0.07771714776754379,
-0.6159844398498535,
-0.010957399383187294,
-0.1910581886768341,
-0.3447885513305664,
-0.5725452899932861,
0.15610960125923157,
0.14722639322280884,
0.6118035912513733,
-0.559841513633728,
0.672292947769165,
0.3452196419239044,
-0.030909040942788124,
-0.816023051738739,
-0.10481797158718109,
-0.039936184883117676,
-1.0247607231140137,
0.6899968981742859,
0.0485885925590992,
-0.20053793489933014,
-0.2320130318403244,
-0.7565032839775085,
-0.9026520848274231,
0.6411727070808411,
0.6029403209686279,
-0.8067222237586975,
-0.1513132005929947,
0.0488775297999382,
0.9058840274810791,
-0.22456838190555573,
0.2612958550453186,
0.4670436382293701,
0.4976516664028168,
0.3052820861339569,
-1.061086893081665,
0.12853676080703735,
-0.10281327366828918,
-0.10432424396276474,
0.20421220362186432,
-0.7453926801681519,
1.0424115657806396,
-0.6353583931922913,
-0.009954691864550114,
-0.0490473136305809,
0.7042505145072937,
0.0037240399979054928,
0.059887032955884933,
0.39255520701408386,
0.588042140007019,
0.6135382652282715,
-0.06581849604845047,
0.9262145757675171,
-0.49949777126312256,
0.4023568630218506,
1.0213807821273804,
-0.6407784223556519,
0.7144165635108948,
0.2807738482952118,
-0.01091036107391119,
0.5155086517333984,
0.3282841742038727,
0.0009766110451892018,
0.2786185145378113,
0.1554497331380844,
-0.11645540595054626,
-0.4714951813220978,
-0.2879141867160797,
-0.44383516907691956,
0.3734593987464905,
0.26787179708480835,
-0.01404175441712141,
-0.10918974131345749,
0.017079731449484825,
0.27162879705429077,
0.08795890212059021,
-0.5295757055282593,
0.7589899897575378,
-0.03751388192176819,
-0.7697038054466248,
0.429701566696167,
0.16542868316173553,
0.7886297106742859,
-0.30074381828308105,
0.07922940701246262,
-0.3012908697128296,
0.2638135552406311,
-0.3135632574558258,
-0.9889734983444214,
0.25103968381881714,
0.022875044494867325,
-0.29844075441360474,
-0.4461113214492798,
0.66959148645401,
-0.1703643798828125,
-0.5112314224243164,
0.28607743978500366,
0.4131781756877899,
-0.18749989569187164,
-0.34858715534210205,
-0.5272727608680725,
-0.04493086785078049,
0.062143225222826004,
-0.21742594242095947,
0.2370547652244568,
0.8246471881866455,
0.3247728645801544,
0.8507682681083679,
0.7219171524047852,
0.34987950325012207,
-0.040841881185770035,
0.06263494491577148,
0.6526492834091187,
-0.8832255005836487,
-0.3674219250679016,
-1.035481333732605,
0.3333582282066345,
0.22219409048557281,
-0.21865034103393555,
0.9249007105827332,
0.21571263670921326,
0.7318044304847717,
-0.07697862386703491,
0.7628502249717712,
0.3018610179424286,
0.8149003386497498,
-0.7029246091842651,
0.41729044914245605,
-0.4067241847515106,
0.5207993388175964,
-0.20889173448085785,
-0.9060612916946411,
-0.043098144233226776,
0.561038613319397,
-0.463903546333313,
0.12040603905916214,
0.696593701839447,
0.8152043223381042,
0.46959206461906433,
-0.09552648663520813,
0.44079679250717163,
0.8043372631072998,
0.48458537459373474,
0.2010410577058792,
0.9541584849357605,
-0.04732378199696541,
0.19047535955905914,
-0.39279577136039734,
-0.26987507939338684,
-0.08636293560266495,
-0.9521365761756897,
-1.0372308492660522,
-0.5764332413673401,
-0.33493828773498535,
-0.5035719275474548,
-0.016614235937595367,
0.942872166633606,
0.3760412633419037,
-0.8947031497955322,
-0.16080057621002197,
0.2097642421722412,
0.0865684300661087,
0.15595988929271698,
-0.21183839440345764,
0.12461459636688232,
-0.5078407526016235,
-0.44196540117263794,
0.24624674022197723,
0.6804704666137695,
0.14890025556087494,
-0.5855934023857117,
0.14233994483947754,
0.14040030539035797,
0.3619118630886078,
0.6029539108276367,
0.3247945010662079,
-0.853453516960144,
-0.4394054114818573,
0.2005523294210434,
-0.20618121325969696,
0.14242468774318695,
0.8492346405982971,
-0.7255628705024719,
0.4006229639053345,
0.36101922392845154,
0.4595242142677307,
0.06257633864879608,
-0.11336072534322739,
0.3880767524242401,
-0.3196779787540436,
-0.268019437789917,
0.13582243025302887,
0.387378454208374,
0.5570386648178101,
-0.591461718082428,
0.2938409447669983,
0.2825784981250763,
-0.9532898664474487,
-0.8999379873275757,
0.13468046486377716,
-0.6864985823631287,
-0.3343268632888794,
1.2754255533218384,
0.19095656275749207,
-0.197114959359169,
0.20185056328773499,
-0.3929157257080078,
-0.02700774371623993,
-0.44845420122146606,
1.2917675971984863,
0.8793157935142517,
-0.277504563331604,
-0.36905622482299805,
-0.2818295657634735,
0.040875256061553955,
0.6590967178344727,
-0.6479759812355042,
0.42283448576927185,
0.36828622221946716,
0.418746680021286,
0.154686838388443,
0.666694164276123,
0.1455107033252716,
-0.06495905667543411,
-0.4044923186302185,
0.20216040313243866,
0.08319848775863647,
-0.35469308495521545,
-0.6900430917739868,
0.03823443874716759,
0.44795528054237366,
0.586367666721344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15668v1 | PI-Whisper: An Adaptive and Incremental ASR Framework for Diverse and Evolving Speaker Characteristics | 2024-06-21T21:58:37 | 2024-06-21T21:58:37 | Amir Nassereldine, Dancheng Liu, Chenhui Xu, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | As edge-based automatic speech recognition (ASR) technologies become
increasingly prevalent for the development of intelligent and personalized
assistants, three important challenges must be addressed for these
resource-constrained ASR models, i.e., adaptivity, incrementality, and
inclusivity. We propose a novel ASR framework, PI-Whisper, in this work and
show how it can improve an ASR's recognition capabilities adaptively by
identifying different speakers' characteristics in real-time, how such an
adaption can be performed incrementally without repetitive retraining, and how
it can improve the equity and fairness for diverse speaker groups. More
impressively, our proposed PI-Whisper framework attains all of these nice
properties while still achieving state-of-the-art accuracy with up to 13.7%
reduction of the word error rate (WER) with linear scalability with respect to
computing resources. | [
-0.4686075448989868,
-0.5669884085655212,
0.028932448476552963,
0.5063048601150513,
0.3214209973812103,
0.4286966919898987,
-0.29017016291618347,
-0.6048673987388611,
0.33432161808013916,
0.08020320534706116,
-0.7182102203369141,
-0.13231556117534637,
-0.6345747709274292,
-0.013435742817819118,
-0.437038391828537,
0.5111664533615112,
0.4674795866012573,
0.08684302866458893,
0.3003165125846863,
-0.3228469491004944,
-0.7042328715324402,
-0.2825680077075958,
-0.757522463798523,
-0.0819593220949173,
0.09514028578996658,
0.7226315140724182,
0.6932855844497681,
0.6011142134666443,
0.24492982029914856,
0.3290300965309143,
-0.2672910988330841,
-0.030290910974144936,
-0.08158375322818756,
0.34059423208236694,
-0.2375565618276596,
-0.07556389272212982,
-0.6987621784210205,
-0.36053788661956787,
0.899071991443634,
0.7369563579559326,
-0.2596481740474701,
-0.15317803621292114,
0.1030970960855484,
0.7380856871604919,
-0.5365930795669556,
-0.08846966177225113,
-0.955199658870697,
0.03104589506983757,
-0.19207675755023956,
-0.2806553542613983,
-0.07225538045167923,
-0.07246524840593338,
0.5142040848731995,
-0.7584049701690674,
0.5328177809715271,
-0.04582777991890907,
0.46311935782432556,
0.19148851931095123,
-0.04799304157495499,
-0.7037919759750366,
-0.9697666764259338,
0.5163272619247437,
-0.47509124875068665,
0.8319355249404907,
0.07097579538822174,
0.5628105998039246,
0.0930156409740448,
-0.5567910671234131,
-0.706832766532898,
-0.22275027632713318,
0.44622039794921875,
-0.012540314346551895,
-0.32906362414360046,
-0.12236662954092026,
-0.11091267317533493,
0.5881255865097046,
-0.29548758268356323,
0.26140883564949036,
-0.35531890392303467,
-0.3568735718727112,
0.6731532216072083,
0.030985800549387932,
0.34858280420303345,
0.5302121639251709,
0.0059557119384408,
-0.19682534039020538,
-0.44356897473335266,
0.3949001729488373,
0.4632921814918518,
0.809360921382904,
-0.2340521663427353,
0.21253472566604614,
-0.5877036452293396,
0.5104860663414001,
0.30314919352531433,
-0.2924564778804779,
0.5194131135940552,
-0.1370495855808258,
0.2836221754550934,
0.6754840016365051,
0.6531707048416138,
0.20467974245548248,
0.26544272899627686,
-0.009083257988095284,
0.0645778626203537,
-0.1337474286556244,
0.10786040127277374,
-0.6211729049682617,
-0.4808651804924011,
0.11349758505821228,
-0.40266942977905273,
-0.03677525371313095,
0.009073934517800808,
-0.8593279719352722,
-0.5570027232170105,
0.04655735194683075,
0.5342710018157959,
-0.5836348533630371,
-0.5984166264533997,
0.12480369210243225,
-0.22636732459068298,
0.24260449409484863,
0.5184871554374695,
-1.0076196193695068,
0.8020833730697632,
0.5829015374183655,
0.9577490091323853,
-0.26505497097969055,
-0.44106820225715637,
-0.8772376775741577,
0.13349489867687225,
-0.04983172193169594,
0.8411362171173096,
-0.9166504740715027,
-0.8205432295799255,
-0.33363574743270874,
-0.2509777247905731,
-0.26219823956489563,
-0.554417073726654,
0.3596348464488983,
0.07044438272714615,
0.18375548720359802,
-0.09695957601070404,
-0.44075697660446167,
-0.00355702405795455,
-0.07822050154209137,
-0.2643604576587677,
0.5242172479629517,
-0.1199035719037056,
-0.5256425142288208,
0.28496453166007996,
-1.1120989322662354,
-0.3204582929611206,
0.23980547487735748,
-0.019429806619882584,
-0.5919827222824097,
0.3182356655597687,
0.4206046462059021,
0.06486527621746063,
0.061464574187994,
-0.1480211466550827,
-0.24020503461360931,
-0.47907403111457825,
0.3250916302204132,
-0.5567719340324402,
0.5036013126373291,
0.24581694602966309,
-0.3968076705932617,
0.42410942912101746,
-0.9755591750144958,
-0.08227644860744476,
-0.1574803739786148,
-0.020307578146457672,
0.1412080079317093,
0.3567926585674286,
0.21154823899269104,
-0.32499170303344727,
-0.012720126658678055,
-0.701833963394165,
-0.10126633197069168,
-0.429508239030838,
0.3939615488052368,
0.6983511447906494,
0.03692542016506195,
0.4649277329444885,
-0.38538652658462524,
0.3916577696800232,
-0.17417484521865845,
0.21653872728347778,
-0.5189526081085205,
-0.58821040391922,
-0.6831842064857483,
-0.7952725291252136,
0.21996767818927765,
0.5873292684555054,
-0.2684766352176666,
0.509166419506073,
-0.38888075947761536,
-0.5491640567779541,
-0.7547795176506042,
0.05661658197641373,
0.47032248973846436,
0.49598899483680725,
0.24721716344356537,
-0.293303519487381,
-0.24846436083316803,
-0.6979249119758606,
-0.5612043738365173,
-0.24248136579990387,
-0.2903362512588501,
0.5547886490821838,
-0.16932806372642517,
-0.26259341835975647,
1.0187894105911255,
-0.14481516182422638,
-0.42688876390457153,
-0.06274955719709396,
-0.04368846118450165,
0.14570190012454987,
0.5799375772476196,
0.43177318572998047,
-1.0717945098876953,
-0.8158906102180481,
0.30833661556243896,
-0.14930714666843414,
-0.4705228805541992,
-0.008604565635323524,
0.6033548712730408,
-0.10918952524662018,
0.3277793228626251,
-0.0267199594527483,
0.33504804968833923,
0.49647286534309387,
-0.5814056992530823,
0.4216141104698181,
-0.09532564133405685,
0.08534470945596695,
-0.6300115585327148,
-0.08150075376033783,
-0.045786745846271515,
-0.11526460200548172,
-0.9504603743553162,
-0.22440657019615173,
-0.18171833455562592,
-0.4348542094230652,
-0.38451945781707764,
0.8084656000137329,
-0.4028644263744354,
-0.2786408066749573,
-0.4111191928386688,
0.15798838436603546,
-0.026843169704079628,
0.2441156506538391,
0.13250871002674103,
0.9887425303459167,
0.8199013471603394,
-0.9453020095825195,
0.398040235042572,
0.38301390409469604,
-0.007925642654299736,
0.9756463766098022,
-0.7024204730987549,
0.1920643150806427,
0.12615393102169037,
0.027155697345733643,
-0.6550162434577942,
-0.21744057536125183,
0.2059621810913086,
-0.7470264434814453,
0.2896765172481537,
-0.2061777263879776,
-0.09857527911663055,
-0.01979140192270279,
-0.3247224688529968,
0.2724704444408417,
0.44509124755859375,
-0.5412212014198303,
1.0528842210769653,
0.5143139958381653,
-0.9516556859016418,
-0.04085458815097809,
-0.18526743352413177,
0.07304781675338745,
-0.16733066737651825,
-0.4680526554584503,
0.6295517683029175,
-0.4447368383407593,
-0.2778523564338684,
-0.2507224678993225,
-0.16358062624931335,
-0.06595586240291595,
0.017116490751504898,
0.3721979260444641,
-0.20637360215187073,
-0.18403753638267517,
0.2184191793203354,
0.12412504106760025,
-0.2003769874572754,
-0.580020010471344,
-0.24873702228069305,
0.4741656184196472,
-0.4684450924396515,
-0.6996244788169861,
-0.9077727198600769,
0.58005291223526,
0.589576780796051,
-0.18929873406887054,
0.10635257512331009,
0.675915002822876,
-0.21830807626247406,
-0.012263325974345207,
-0.8883160948753357,
-0.007766121998429298,
-0.5617589950561523,
0.4686677157878876,
-0.7796803712844849,
-1.1076476573944092,
0.7492544651031494,
0.03677760809659958,
0.033379245549440384,
0.265876829624176,
0.6248918771743774,
-0.14497791230678558,
0.7366234064102173,
0.994920015335083,
-0.09791828691959381,
0.8342680335044861,
0.22311952710151672,
-0.10428090393543243,
-0.9245333075523376,
-0.36454489827156067,
-0.6254788637161255,
-0.23624706268310547,
-0.6778186559677124,
0.014741092920303345,
0.4519122242927551,
-0.09028308093547821,
-0.22466818988323212,
0.039895035326480865,
-0.8514098525047302,
0.1146722137928009,
0.6038050055503845,
-0.0676945298910141,
0.2750381827354431,
-0.020039446651935577,
0.31756168603897095,
-0.16656896471977234,
-0.4268205761909485,
-0.27540862560272217,
0.6999669671058655,
0.7149096131324768,
0.5680304169654846,
0.18460236489772797,
0.2004300206899643,
0.6308746337890625,
0.01523456908762455,
-0.7741163969039917,
0.27731853723526,
-0.16973520815372467,
-0.3379831910133362,
-0.5378398299217224,
-0.328788697719574,
-0.5007802248001099,
0.12417745590209961,
-0.14632302522659302,
-0.9119011759757996,
0.6765196919441223,
0.482483446598053,
-0.4165024757385254,
0.13451312482357025,
-0.6917216181755066,
0.3749297261238098,
-0.2845129668712616,
0.17435671389102936,
-0.1696845144033432,
-0.4143387973308563,
-0.4512529671192169,
-0.08421977609395981,
0.1513541340827942,
-0.5688644647598267,
-0.20867040753364563,
0.7568944692611694,
-0.26406431198120117,
0.6540720462799072,
-0.6464699506759644,
0.2695024013519287,
0.3053092658519745,
0.045925479382276535,
0.37080639600753784,
-0.14820080995559692,
-0.41790109872817993,
0.0680793970823288,
0.023726455867290497,
-0.3509591519832611,
-0.6018877625465393,
0.49180635809898376,
-0.8846774697303772,
-0.3857433497905731,
-0.19701698422431946,
-0.5321512222290039,
-0.5944920182228088,
0.03588941693305969,
0.3950822949409485,
0.6333029866218567,
-0.3118140995502472,
0.3236117959022522,
0.6727043986320496,
-0.2262648046016693,
0.5648661255836487,
0.8345797657966614,
-0.06618765741586685,
-0.6395291090011597,
1.3248679637908936,
0.06463097035884857,
0.23849596083164215,
0.42084357142448425,
0.44849729537963867,
-0.25545650720596313,
-0.9525169134140015,
-0.3063393235206604,
-0.09191927313804626,
-0.3168490529060364,
0.05000706762075424,
-0.9398648738861084,
-0.38509124517440796,
-0.44698598980903625,
-0.33148476481437683,
-0.6615902781486511,
-0.616784930229187,
-0.400222510099411,
0.15856343507766724,
0.7273221611976624,
0.3856627643108368,
-0.020563874393701553,
0.8267486095428467,
-0.5709583163261414,
0.28064262866973877,
0.6323345899581909,
0.6161031126976013,
-0.3109874725341797,
-0.9617156386375427,
0.10907848924398422,
0.014329110272228718,
-0.29437190294265747,
-0.5520234704017639,
0.42283475399017334,
1.14314603805542,
0.7031234502792358,
0.31004899740219116,
0.22976543009281158,
0.7114905714988708,
-0.6694678068161011,
0.6332955956459045,
0.29686397314071655,
-1.2875969409942627,
0.6812668442726135,
-0.24168117344379425,
0.36587226390838623,
0.7419906258583069,
-0.206009179353714,
-0.5679420828819275,
-0.31961625814437866,
-0.5708198547363281,
-0.7867943048477173,
0.5246453881263733,
0.15856362879276276,
0.34913647174835205,
0.6311976909637451,
0.20306888222694397,
0.34191641211509705,
0.18289540708065033,
-0.44324442744255066,
-0.021972933784127235,
-0.7521654963493347,
-0.3479984700679779,
0.15681222081184387,
-0.3577533960342407,
-0.0030524542089551687,
-0.06834182888269424,
0.5639776587486267,
-0.41498616337776184,
0.3819960951805115,
0.3137529194355011,
-0.04193945974111557,
0.22156092524528503,
0.45005929470062256,
0.6993798017501831,
0.5952072739601135,
-0.23403088748455048,
-0.12046214193105698,
0.5372053980827332,
-0.6704102158546448,
0.07475259900093079,
0.2217920869588852,
0.10145661234855652,
0.07935890555381775,
0.4561726748943329,
0.9269127249717712,
0.12563775479793549,
-0.8009853363037109,
0.5953913331031799,
-0.21650773286819458,
0.06039083003997803,
-0.6000409722328186,
0.523708701133728,
-0.13828060030937195,
0.4225265383720398,
0.873416543006897,
0.19583000242710114,
0.4006190896034241,
-0.48814308643341064,
0.3130756616592407,
0.3205789029598236,
-0.9009265303611755,
-0.4332841634750366,
0.34263643622398376,
0.5909851789474487,
-1.0942673683166504,
0.2972319722175598,
-0.22142264246940613,
-0.5084794163703918,
0.1169738918542862,
0.4166608452796936,
1.146177887916565,
-0.6149863600730896,
-0.1597718447446823,
-0.21389485895633698,
-0.05018863454461098,
0.29342514276504517,
0.2376643717288971,
-0.42529410123825073,
-0.8569591045379639,
0.10862843692302704,
-0.582317054271698,
-0.8970159888267517,
-0.37781861424446106,
-0.7141303420066833,
0.12914663553237915,
-0.7325201034545898,
-0.21030275523662567,
0.11090873926877975,
-0.07403557747602463,
-0.2971399426460266,
0.2689438462257385,
0.10109905153512955,
0.979435920715332,
-0.5090916156768799,
0.7039932012557983,
0.4661899209022522,
0.22156037390232086,
-0.3721249997615814,
0.2719281315803528,
0.20091018080711365,
-0.6772250533103943,
0.2449428141117096,
0.04643361270427704,
-0.5706362724304199,
0.030900269746780396,
-0.11549205332994461,
-0.7561603784561157,
1.0628268718719482,
0.45900771021842957,
-0.7361069321632385,
0.13752304017543793,
-0.2277977466583252,
0.4293241798877716,
-0.6966212391853333,
0.11703404039144516,
0.16656170785427094,
0.20868584513664246,
0.4633377492427826,
-1.6642571687698364,
-0.5465590953826904,
-0.7315945029258728,
0.28551623225212097,
-0.38709813356399536,
-0.6382236480712891,
0.5926839113235474,
-0.21852031350135803,
-0.24884288012981415,
-0.0016627857694402337,
0.8202258348464966,
0.5177193284034729,
0.6400454044342041,
0.6766836643218994,
-0.11026822775602341,
0.871849775314331,
-0.028093121945858,
0.6208106279373169,
-0.19625680148601532,
-0.18726864457130432,
1.1430186033248901,
-0.34079933166503906,
0.9358445405960083,
0.011843121610581875,
-0.2031707614660263,
0.35861462354660034,
0.28928259015083313,
0.058682527393102646,
0.6590648889541626,
-0.19833828508853912,
-0.6066402196884155,
0.09634440392255783,
-0.184762105345726,
-0.5426973104476929,
0.7245789170265198,
0.5813947319984436,
0.1081957146525383,
0.3380345106124878,
0.30938518047332764,
-0.13574253022670746,
0.363309383392334,
-0.5403481125831604,
1.011486530303955,
-0.03888260945677757,
-0.025206247344613075,
0.22835072875022888,
-0.1344086080789566,
0.9976047277450562,
-0.6646263599395752,
0.10038551688194275,
0.11327019333839417,
0.4378930628299713,
-0.20073768496513367,
-0.5538281798362732,
0.3894088864326477,
0.06517712771892548,
-0.4940676689147949,
-0.2486972063779831,
0.7186957001686096,
-0.13516508042812347,
-0.6939811706542969,
0.25019124150276184,
0.20061177015304565,
-0.06483501195907593,
-0.23671549558639526,
-0.7057372331619263,
0.7372087836265564,
-0.05965256318449974,
0.17158125340938568,
0.1409379094839096,
0.42704200744628906,
0.1640423983335495,
1.2119858264923096,
0.6688288450241089,
0.408798485994339,
0.24572594463825226,
-0.03269067034125328,
0.8082852959632874,
-0.4717092514038086,
-0.9804755449295044,
-0.6635763645172119,
0.48618078231811523,
-0.3298811912536621,
-0.33507925271987915,
0.5521466732025146,
0.32782161235809326,
0.6432718634605408,
0.2867181599140167,
0.7351071834564209,
0.09091716259717941,
1.1827199459075928,
-0.16461659967899323,
0.8125969171524048,
-0.07779134064912796,
0.44137513637542725,
-0.5174831748008728,
-0.6863585114479065,
-0.20848259329795837,
0.726321280002594,
-0.06073774769902229,
0.14998759329319,
0.020863134413957596,
0.8281568884849548,
-0.04993295297026634,
0.3352811932563782,
0.33375608921051025,
0.1271127611398697,
0.6273291110992432,
0.05409584566950798,
0.7436756491661072,
-0.30810511112213135,
0.4885324239730835,
-0.06685739010572433,
-0.4927584230899811,
-0.31695523858070374,
-0.7282823324203491,
-0.31641191244125366,
-0.6980875730514526,
-0.7246997356414795,
0.0014867243589833379,
0.49158528447151184,
0.9813600182533264,
0.9260079264640808,
-1.1216812133789062,
-0.44528961181640625,
0.01643524505198002,
0.07009787112474442,
-0.3381863832473755,
-0.18924270570278168,
0.22008635103702545,
-0.11872267723083496,
-0.6654529571533203,
0.6639527678489685,
0.6215108633041382,
0.0005846355925314128,
0.05537424981594086,
-0.39049068093299866,
0.3419798016548157,
-0.0037447286304086447,
0.46053439378738403,
0.8007711172103882,
-0.6707213521003723,
-0.5057725310325623,
-0.09573810547590256,
0.3871443569660187,
0.06290550529956818,
0.6167506575584412,
-0.7595760822296143,
0.9311895370483398,
0.06867817789316177,
0.5722229480743408,
0.3356817662715912,
-0.020976247265934944,
0.8232494592666626,
-0.6423620581626892,
0.29618993401527405,
0.3624182939529419,
0.12119890749454498,
0.607387900352478,
-0.19954603910446167,
0.12309148907661438,
0.3185725212097168,
-0.3004463315010071,
-1.0461571216583252,
0.26947495341300964,
-0.9838167428970337,
0.06416667252779007,
0.7284648418426514,
-0.11465789377689362,
0.48900192975997925,
-0.43221452832221985,
-0.2594200372695923,
-0.04689256474375725,
-0.6919625401496887,
0.5254266262054443,
0.05379464104771614,
-0.5715237259864807,
-0.6095597743988037,
-0.053991787135601044,
0.44561588764190674,
-0.11214463412761688,
-0.5146532654762268,
0.03817516192793846,
0.12732410430908203,
0.43413951992988586,
0.42922309041023254,
1.0954235792160034,
-0.0349600650370121,
0.31842488050460815,
0.19336335361003876,
-0.022168319672346115,
-0.4012896716594696,
-0.4690299332141876,
-0.39855146408081055,
0.29286739230155945,
0.33054178953170776,
-0.3727768063545227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15627v1 | Benchmarking Uncertainty Quantification Methods for Large Language Models with LM-Polygraph | 2024-06-21T20:06:31 | 2024-06-21T20:06:31 | Roman Vashurin, Ekaterina Fadeeva, Artem Vazhentsev, Akim Tsvigun, Daniil Vasilev, Rui Xing, Abdelrahman Boda Sadallah, Lyudmila Rvanova, Sergey Petrakov, Alexander Panchenko, Timothy Baldwin, Preslav Nakov, Maxim Panov, Artem Shelmanov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Uncertainty quantification (UQ) is becoming increasingly recognized as a
critical component of applications that rely on machine learning (ML). The
rapid proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has stimulated researchers
to seek efficient and effective approaches to UQ in text generation tasks, as
in addition to their emerging capabilities, these models have introduced new
challenges for building safe applications. As with other ML models, LLMs are
prone to make incorrect predictions, ``hallucinate'' by fabricating claims, or
simply generate low-quality output for a given input. UQ is a key element in
dealing with these challenges. However research to date on UQ methods for LLMs
has been fragmented, with disparate evaluation methods. In this work, we tackle
this issue by introducing a novel benchmark that implements a collection of
state-of-the-art UQ baselines, and provides an environment for controllable and
consistent evaluation of novel techniques by researchers in various text
generation tasks. Our benchmark also supports the assessment of confidence
normalization methods in terms of their ability to provide interpretable
scores. Using our benchmark, we conduct a large-scale empirical investigation
of UQ and normalization techniques across nine tasks and shed light on the most
promising approaches. | [
-0.1766001433134079,
-0.8027716279029846,
0.6182123422622681,
-0.007142359856516123,
-0.20647688210010529,
0.19047093391418457,
-0.26046398282051086,
-0.3321165144443512,
-0.2883634567260742,
0.3381335139274597,
-0.2234046757221222,
-0.6274846792221069,
-0.5667001008987427,
0.11360698938369751,
-0.42960962653160095,
0.6896700263023376,
-0.10092267394065857,
-0.04799310863018036,
-0.41238948702812195,
-0.06289426982402802,
-0.1914028823375702,
-0.6062965989112854,
-0.3307894766330719,
-0.37144750356674194,
0.2889251708984375,
0.14859232306480408,
0.9657078385353088,
0.4615679979324341,
0.519367516040802,
0.24305346608161926,
-0.20368070900440216,
0.26166608929634094,
-0.36148717999458313,
0.3627256751060486,
-0.006285304669290781,
-0.28194659948349,
-0.3379284739494324,
-0.26074638962745667,
0.8970978260040283,
0.9494857788085938,
-0.1443193554878235,
0.4247642755508423,
0.20703983306884766,
0.5533199906349182,
-1.1335235834121704,
0.0680464431643486,
-0.8349646329879761,
0.03772556781768799,
-0.23003970086574554,
0.24210655689239502,
-0.4512939453125,
-0.3784162700176239,
-0.136418879032135,
-0.42219477891921997,
-0.016451766714453697,
-0.011055899783968925,
0.8758721351623535,
0.4313867688179016,
-0.48900583386421204,
-0.0032441571820527315,
-0.8694015741348267,
0.9965807199478149,
-0.8015744686126709,
0.3307206630706787,
0.36328160762786865,
0.4410734176635742,
-0.271280974149704,
-1.0078381299972534,
-0.6000655889511108,
0.010722942650318146,
0.10935775935649872,
0.008551141247153282,
-0.3395712673664093,
0.05695616826415062,
0.1816267967224121,
0.31026962399482727,
-0.4445844292640686,
0.3475821614265442,
0.053454216569662094,
-0.5173686742782593,
0.7061222791671753,
0.26038211584091187,
-0.042656976729631424,
-0.19068200886249542,
-0.16675427556037903,
-0.3894893527030945,
-0.5335788726806641,
0.10413683950901031,
0.3275827467441559,
0.16214613616466522,
0.1989191174507141,
0.6093631982803345,
-0.4986903965473175,
0.783211886882782,
-0.3710903227329254,
-0.2740621566772461,
0.32028713822364807,
-0.25419601798057556,
-0.3796162009239197,
-0.23540736734867096,
1.2616221904754639,
0.39753472805023193,
0.3049570918083191,
0.03110574372112751,
-0.33429279923439026,
0.05694190412759781,
0.14583422243595123,
-0.7397253513336182,
-0.03581925481557846,
0.3413692116737366,
-0.28152742981910706,
-0.41038838028907776,
0.0804874375462532,
-0.8635223507881165,
-0.5644026398658752,
-0.004121196456253529,
0.4412015974521637,
-0.44935256242752075,
-0.11215059459209442,
0.14558686316013336,
0.24573013186454773,
0.03426150977611542,
0.150297611951828,
-0.6164723038673401,
0.24327518045902252,
0.6253415942192078,
0.4616039991378784,
-0.2787114381790161,
-0.1790044903755188,
-0.37855806946754456,
-0.07241964340209961,
-0.5588937997817993,
0.5302571058273315,
-0.2972501218318939,
-0.3760862350463867,
0.11889030784368515,
-0.43938881158828735,
-0.01598377898335457,
-0.5190712809562683,
0.7793933749198914,
-0.20912741124629974,
0.0831788182258606,
0.18835172057151794,
-0.5491324663162231,
-0.08270791172981262,
0.1338346004486084,
-0.5398815870285034,
1.604996919631958,
0.26249316334724426,
-0.7803219556808472,
0.34347590804100037,
-0.030620599165558815,
-0.18042314052581787,
0.16736480593681335,
-0.4655763804912567,
-0.929850697517395,
0.26102975010871887,
0.2568510174751282,
0.6769019365310669,
-0.7316034436225891,
0.39763143658638,
-0.39044901728630066,
-0.37308958172798157,
0.6889426708221436,
-0.6923772692680359,
0.630209743976593,
0.24917592108249664,
-0.4855709373950958,
0.0980210080742836,
-0.8491174578666687,
0.5436895489692688,
0.13117577135562897,
-0.004218368325382471,
-0.2129368931055069,
-0.10413271933794022,
0.12503482401371002,
-0.005966013763099909,
0.19591885805130005,
-0.3479911983013153,
-0.05138928070664406,
-0.02238408848643303,
0.225608229637146,
0.48873370885849,
0.055006079375743866,
0.07565318048000336,
-0.2559950351715088,
0.48896998167037964,
-0.17661093175411224,
0.13860352337360382,
0.07322278618812561,
-0.4635167717933655,
-0.6328118443489075,
-0.2655598819255829,
0.6832403540611267,
0.46541157364845276,
-0.5402529835700989,
0.5940289497375488,
-0.2802663743495941,
-0.7021499276161194,
-0.6485713720321655,
0.06712251156568527,
0.3626585602760315,
0.35605064034461975,
0.23044204711914062,
-0.1730230301618576,
-0.3408161997795105,
-0.6774941682815552,
-0.38857147097587585,
-0.2019970417022705,
-0.34512990713119507,
0.07634475827217102,
0.4543609023094177,
-0.37773650884628296,
0.8737794756889343,
-0.389832466840744,
-0.050867464393377304,
-0.06297662854194641,
0.5252813696861267,
0.12328167259693146,
0.3340894877910614,
0.29771357774734497,
-0.6842421889305115,
-0.5881617665290833,
-0.1768486201763153,
-0.8126753568649292,
-0.053655955940485,
-0.2507891058921814,
-0.02241949550807476,
0.2773676812648773,
0.5356131792068481,
-0.599319338798523,
0.5350671410560608,
0.6959067583084106,
-0.11667587608098984,
0.6657839417457581,
-0.1496410071849823,
0.1650494635105133,
-1.0914723873138428,
0.03688604384660721,
-0.02917586639523506,
-0.36734217405319214,
-0.4622154235839844,
0.04062434658408165,
0.23135986924171448,
0.03481455147266388,
-0.27102893590927124,
0.31767749786376953,
-0.4886438548564911,
-0.19519264996051788,
-0.06319616734981537,
0.13263730704784393,
0.01250982191413641,
-0.0033526853658258915,
-0.18862347304821014,
0.6561620831489563,
0.6711808443069458,
-0.24172738194465637,
0.3050730526447296,
-0.2227718085050583,
-0.5407642126083374,
0.5195882320404053,
-0.7417178153991699,
0.21947653591632843,
0.055348049849271774,
0.12283778190612793,
-0.9770231246948242,
-0.27642756700515747,
0.044547874480485916,
-0.4843605160713196,
0.16693919897079468,
0.14774473011493683,
-0.7818800806999207,
-0.3537372648715973,
-0.21914514899253845,
0.42016685009002686,
0.7056029438972473,
-0.17512166500091553,
0.5313928127288818,
0.3960168957710266,
-0.032048340886831284,
-0.6857174038887024,
-0.5670326948165894,
-0.014800481498241425,
-0.27398842573165894,
-0.39138275384902954,
0.359173446893692,
0.01525097619742155,
-0.4716021716594696,
-0.08823763579130173,
-0.2211965173482895,
-0.27581173181533813,
0.3843366801738739,
0.28988978266716003,
0.13248354196548462,
-0.03488784283399582,
0.047925349324941635,
0.04824564978480339,
-0.08328872174024582,
0.04148747771978378,
-0.1389739066362381,
0.46138960123062134,
-0.1334097981452942,
-0.40095120668411255,
-0.4795970618724823,
0.03687752038240433,
0.46439799666404724,
-0.2223409116268158,
0.680801272392273,
0.8131974935531616,
-0.6145783066749573,
-0.47134023904800415,
-0.37000030279159546,
-0.01728355884552002,
-0.4274864196777344,
0.2974967062473297,
-0.47601649165153503,
-0.8627036213874817,
0.375300794839859,
-0.30527281761169434,
-0.13646052777767181,
0.5792399644851685,
0.688806414604187,
-0.22085493803024292,
0.9075679779052734,
0.5240111947059631,
-0.01644320785999298,
0.09191732108592987,
0.025775419548153877,
0.045371655374765396,
-0.5534785985946655,
-0.01134870108217001,
-0.6860633492469788,
0.05232657119631767,
-0.6170942187309265,
-0.7324941158294678,
0.41660571098327637,
0.44194427132606506,
-0.17382320761680603,
0.07923325896263123,
-0.5097132921218872,
0.40661558508872986,
0.5527324676513672,
-0.15322107076644897,
0.4814814627170563,
0.013125648722052574,
-0.2921174168586731,
-0.14292918145656586,
-0.5399830937385559,
-0.6202508807182312,
1.4483299255371094,
0.39507046341896057,
0.8311368823051453,
0.009581014513969421,
0.8215894103050232,
0.38141146302223206,
0.20479276776313782,
-0.6148912906646729,
0.41426390409469604,
0.05094250664114952,
-0.3055175542831421,
-0.7621524930000305,
-0.7983898520469666,
-1.0766749382019043,
0.34796538949012756,
-0.5759689807891846,
-1.1220877170562744,
-0.07438814640045166,
0.1305677890777588,
-0.43177759647369385,
0.26664912700653076,
-0.3314885199069977,
0.9051068425178528,
-0.09037525206804276,
-0.24085456132888794,
0.15582337975502014,
-0.5421655774116516,
0.2129000872373581,
-0.4042241871356964,
0.2984747588634491,
-0.3107050061225891,
-0.05791951343417168,
0.3684200048446655,
-0.18991583585739136,
0.7650510668754578,
0.13852956891059875,
-0.2982359826564789,
0.42322784662246704,
0.2662369906902313,
0.6435946226119995,
0.13152633607387543,
-0.36287856101989746,
0.32082194089889526,
0.0659538060426712,
-0.3655456602573395,
-0.4763525724411011,
0.33050182461738586,
-0.6709921360015869,
-0.10695478320121765,
-0.508222222328186,
-0.7820180058479309,
-0.408279687166214,
0.2943177819252014,
0.6152411699295044,
0.2169942706823349,
-0.28468722105026245,
0.3221057951450348,
0.6195591688156128,
-0.2595655024051666,
0.3039153218269348,
0.03935884311795235,
-0.18913689255714417,
-0.42324164509773254,
0.7831227779388428,
0.010299303568899632,
0.4035360515117645,
0.37255871295928955,
0.20311327278614044,
-0.3754121661186218,
-0.7948152422904968,
-0.352936714887619,
-0.0717235654592514,
-0.5179359316825867,
-0.35202139616012573,
-0.3431611657142639,
-0.25424617528915405,
-0.6334737539291382,
0.21492956578731537,
-0.5943450331687927,
-0.48181772232055664,
-0.06495683640241623,
0.11006059497594833,
0.12454209476709366,
0.572021484375,
0.10117526352405548,
0.19603386521339417,
-0.672784149646759,
0.3206278085708618,
0.1893029808998108,
0.28088799118995667,
-0.3647594749927521,
-0.47690990567207336,
-0.2757156491279602,
0.11758388578891754,
-0.2755133807659149,
-0.7515338659286499,
0.20352834463119507,
0.1935015469789505,
0.7131938934326172,
0.13111470639705658,
0.4840985834598541,
0.22784055769443512,
-0.2106665074825287,
0.6467208862304688,
0.1254715919494629,
-1.1187130212783813,
0.3230173587799072,
-0.3263731300830841,
0.3141542971134186,
0.6929018497467041,
0.4769377112388611,
-0.49119555950164795,
-0.5152240991592407,
-0.5875717401504517,
-1.0594613552093506,
0.013169866986572742,
0.4994753897190094,
-0.11191704869270325,
0.2737344801425934,
0.2598196268081665,
-0.06794819235801697,
0.40682512521743774,
-0.8440621495246887,
-0.3150057792663574,
0.057825636118650436,
-0.566769003868103,
-0.2214890420436859,
-0.3190593123435974,
-0.09271240234375,
-0.07971809059381485,
0.4637661278247833,
-0.393841952085495,
0.05083884298801422,
0.0346284955739975,
-0.26077091693878174,
-0.08512324094772339,
0.31755954027175903,
0.25518327951431274,
0.6901795268058777,
-0.3378157913684845,
0.20896178483963013,
0.18936845660209656,
-0.35950034856796265,
0.1254502683877945,
0.23259496688842773,
-0.47538259625434875,
0.10104235261678696,
0.3798384666442871,
0.5854930281639099,
-0.01969388872385025,
-0.8261898756027222,
0.49641209840774536,
-0.1535416841506958,
-0.25683969259262085,
-0.3618091642856598,
-0.11851635575294495,
-0.04560987278819084,
0.06203944608569145,
0.43029123544692993,
-0.20143556594848633,
0.14784124493598938,
-0.3048382103443146,
0.3293507993221283,
0.35728415846824646,
-0.46926751732826233,
0.11560188233852386,
0.5352790951728821,
-0.05435339733958244,
-0.15246358513832092,
0.4621192216873169,
-0.30460605025291443,
-0.23764756321907043,
0.4272257387638092,
0.4089498519897461,
0.8591070175170898,
-0.13329797983169556,
0.375113844871521,
0.27640876173973083,
0.47311097383499146,
-0.1250307261943817,
0.3206659257411957,
0.21573595702648163,
-0.857856810092926,
-0.4944170415401459,
-0.7025733590126038,
-0.705041766166687,
0.20376548171043396,
-0.8942534923553467,
-0.10025972872972488,
-0.2116490602493286,
-0.4170803427696228,
-0.08671636879444122,
-0.05071720480918884,
-0.48546335101127625,
0.335747629404068,
0.28575146198272705,
0.5204657912254333,
-0.7268080115318298,
0.8534976243972778,
0.6562366485595703,
-0.0679684579372406,
-0.8313966989517212,
0.3493698239326477,
0.15702106058597565,
-0.4703941345214844,
0.21565166115760803,
0.11190462857484818,
-0.1231023520231247,
-0.05535704270005226,
-0.29373398423194885,
-0.7980829477310181,
1.1421504020690918,
0.483022004365921,
-0.6991162300109863,
0.19606809318065643,
0.6854710578918457,
0.5631008148193359,
-0.17056970298290253,
0.24070341885089874,
0.6378879547119141,
0.32471030950546265,
-0.19571316242218018,
-0.8717042803764343,
0.25493666529655457,
0.10991974174976349,
0.35838860273361206,
0.35956186056137085,
-0.4190973937511444,
0.9209405183792114,
-0.04434701055288315,
-0.20412302017211914,
0.32832470536231995,
0.6863532066345215,
0.419960618019104,
0.2272358238697052,
0.6026120185852051,
0.5153079032897949,
1.0678750276565552,
-0.2579430341720581,
0.9689188599586487,
-0.3286024034023285,
0.6466146111488342,
1.2648992538452148,
-0.2986692488193512,
0.9337473511695862,
0.4558759033679962,
-0.30979689955711365,
0.3748091757297516,
0.7159655690193176,
-0.07782010734081268,
-0.02633487991988659,
0.6535513997077942,
-0.32618260383605957,
-0.34517115354537964,
-0.1956423819065094,
-0.19632503390312195,
0.4424769878387451,
0.3096519410610199,
-0.2708982825279236,
-0.003792489878833294,
-0.26332592964172363,
0.05112912133336067,
0.42110753059387207,
-0.14567066729068756,
0.5982894897460938,
0.017944801598787308,
-0.4734906256198883,
0.79901123046875,
0.0032721443567425013,
0.5821890234947205,
-0.42824631929397583,
0.13524729013442993,
-0.17622534930706024,
0.30020374059677124,
-0.012168224900960922,
-0.7899003028869629,
0.07674071192741394,
0.0323595330119133,
0.11635038256645203,
-0.1337548792362213,
0.6372745633125305,
-0.2872896194458008,
-0.7429746389389038,
0.22739073634147644,
0.6290467381477356,
0.16001032292842865,
-0.3093104064464569,
-0.7844263315200806,
0.2680044174194336,
-0.013436766341328621,
-0.2829878032207489,
0.3292318284511566,
0.7381927371025085,
-0.13142280280590057,
0.6776449680328369,
0.39040789008140564,
0.12168896943330765,
-0.007174970582127571,
0.09665785729885101,
0.45589473843574524,
-0.574497640132904,
-0.004306215327233076,
-0.8348572850227356,
0.6479285359382629,
-0.170052170753479,
-0.6241505742073059,
0.8722326159477234,
0.546074390411377,
0.9027888178825378,
0.20013706386089325,
0.7779083847999573,
0.04383531212806702,
0.44201815128326416,
-0.5603464841842651,
0.6837479472160339,
-0.4951712489128113,
0.17543630301952362,
-0.6243091225624084,
-1.0530740022659302,
-0.5473477244377136,
0.4916096031665802,
0.14733274281024933,
0.038074418902397156,
0.6818957924842834,
0.6798992156982422,
0.28850409388542175,
-0.40752914547920227,
0.5970159769058228,
0.06968245655298233,
0.06034034118056297,
0.38643479347229004,
0.8002125024795532,
-0.5957891345024109,
0.8089756369590759,
-0.599834144115448,
-0.27118822932243347,
-0.06210094317793846,
-1.0265029668807983,
-0.7808356881141663,
-0.5843704342842102,
-0.31810078024864197,
-0.4711883068084717,
0.026409892365336418,
0.6735433340072632,
0.7556397914886475,
-0.6823630332946777,
-0.4470697343349457,
-0.12624064087867737,
0.12736199796199799,
-0.3769727349281311,
-0.20757931470870972,
0.43752843141555786,
-0.27804458141326904,
-0.8060616850852966,
0.13397665321826935,
-0.013355785049498081,
0.23933634161949158,
-0.2764907479286194,
0.053354304283857346,
0.11789289861917496,
0.02951713278889656,
0.38132786750793457,
0.10894322395324707,
-0.5082909464836121,
-0.24441799521446228,
-0.18051622807979584,
-0.3295743465423584,
-0.15720190107822418,
0.6036854982376099,
-0.5291828513145447,
0.38093578815460205,
0.3747948706150055,
0.8559368252754211,
0.5966364145278931,
0.02244511805474758,
0.8314754366874695,
-0.8510196805000305,
0.10854098200798035,
0.36535128951072693,
0.3248598277568817,
0.4136565029621124,
-0.24512070417404175,
0.7150049209594727,
0.1527939736843109,
-0.6659174561500549,
-1.1839426755905151,
0.28270941972732544,
-0.7739610075950623,
-0.36801955103874207,
1.0285810232162476,
-0.2715023458003998,
-0.17804057896137238,
0.0979745090007782,
0.12276492267847061,
0.28204551339149475,
-0.21663914620876312,
0.7823523879051208,
0.5277149081230164,
-0.07794704288244247,
-0.09174912422895432,
-0.47509101033210754,
0.5609795451164246,
0.578620970249176,
-1.0033575296401978,
0.2520248591899872,
0.48742127418518066,
0.047889333218336105,
0.11858319491147995,
0.40460386872291565,
-0.039001647382974625,
0.14090286195278168,
0.19760353863239288,
0.4491496682167053,
0.24304984509944916,
-0.29827284812927246,
-0.23453493416309357,
0.13468700647354126,
0.3058493733406067,
0.054184962064027786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15625v1 | Shortcomings of LLMs for Low-Resource Translation: Retrieval and Understanding are Both the Problem | 2024-06-21T20:02:22 | 2024-06-21T20:02:22 | Sara Court, Micha Elsner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work investigates the in-context learning abilities of pretrained large
language models (LLMs) when instructed to translate text from a low-resource
language into a high-resource language as part of an automated machine
translation pipeline. We conduct a set of experiments translating Southern
Quechua to Spanish and examine the informativity of various types of
information retrieved from a constrained database of digitized pedagogical
materials (dictionaries and grammar lessons) and parallel corpora. Using both
automatic and human evaluation of model output, we conduct ablation studies
that manipulate (1) context type (morpheme translations, grammar descriptions,
and corpus examples), (2) retrieval methods (automated vs. manual), and (3)
model type. Our results suggest that even relatively small LLMs are capable of
utilizing prompt context for zero-shot low-resource translation when provided a
minimally sufficient amount of relevant linguistic information. However, the
variable effects of prompt type, retrieval method, model type, and
language-specific factors highlight the limitations of using even the best LLMs
as translation systems for the majority of the world's 7,000+ languages and
their speakers. | [
-0.278759628534317,
-0.6571134924888611,
0.7751445174217224,
0.09332159161567688,
-0.563569962978363,
0.017989864572882652,
-0.5855321884155273,
-0.1858164221048355,
-0.18112392723560333,
0.5617431402206421,
-0.39464569091796875,
-0.37509554624557495,
-0.683148980140686,
0.5464925765991211,
-0.6649718284606934,
0.9374297857284546,
-0.1165437176823616,
0.05248670652508736,
-0.160612553358078,
-0.13558617234230042,
-0.34098342061042786,
-0.6850100159645081,
-0.4212999939918518,
-0.29111242294311523,
0.6934852600097656,
0.6766656041145325,
0.6929848790168762,
0.8252062797546387,
0.5178217887878418,
0.24630625545978546,
-0.19201260805130005,
-0.04387306049466133,
-0.6491420865058899,
-0.048569127917289734,
-0.21203812956809998,
-0.6852900385856628,
0.09751468896865845,
0.06962579488754272,
0.7705804705619812,
0.9198837876319885,
0.08303733170032501,
0.3639526069164276,
0.1373998522758484,
0.470197468996048,
-0.7129766941070557,
-0.02474500797688961,
-0.8083270788192749,
0.12090415507555008,
-0.4318074882030487,
-0.26709938049316406,
-0.5614563226699829,
-0.2746853232383728,
0.19957002997398376,
-0.40165579319000244,
0.19028520584106445,
0.3070783317089081,
0.7917042374610901,
0.6136825084686279,
-0.6942840218544006,
-0.6349108219146729,
-0.7173054218292236,
0.9668710827827454,
-0.6436663866043091,
0.28485432267189026,
0.6333284974098206,
0.25092586874961853,
0.0467655248939991,
-0.5347808599472046,
-0.5081770420074463,
-0.10279881209135056,
-0.3919388949871063,
-0.16254283487796783,
0.036061666905879974,
0.12532150745391846,
0.431094229221344,
0.45418357849121094,
-0.37632644176483154,
0.4670148193836212,
-0.4797089397907257,
-0.10968828946352005,
0.24664539098739624,
0.24539940059185028,
0.16820228099822998,
-0.5738288164138794,
-0.2358614206314087,
-0.10835595428943634,
-0.8836780786514282,
0.053567010909318924,
0.11684416234493256,
0.5428594946861267,
-0.24127770960330963,
0.6359567642211914,
-0.030124541372060776,
0.7867707014083862,
-0.08188387751579285,
-0.21673370897769928,
0.10103962570428848,
-0.5388330221176147,
-0.5037821531295776,
-0.12416014075279236,
0.8144006133079529,
-0.12818454205989838,
-0.0576351098716259,
-0.30979278683662415,
-0.3761359751224518,
-0.36573973298072815,
-0.03735874965786934,
-0.829461395740509,
0.23691093921661377,
0.03647761419415474,
-0.48281043767929077,
-0.04442697763442993,
-0.3605578541755676,
-0.5125007033348083,
-0.25621190667152405,
-0.22292722761631012,
0.3626400828361511,
-0.3387177288532257,
0.1608240306377411,
-0.15516644716262817,
0.20629628002643585,
0.2254415899515152,
0.30204057693481445,
-0.8797374367713928,
0.00044439357588998973,
0.07370464503765106,
1.0387616157531738,
-0.2486800104379654,
-0.2710849940776825,
-0.5312163233757019,
-0.09734144806861877,
-0.2526165843009949,
0.4795331060886383,
-0.36684200167655945,
-0.5663610696792603,
0.03289457783102989,
0.20505636930465698,
-0.22510923445224762,
-0.6793414950370789,
0.5291667580604553,
-0.7138931155204773,
0.17646993696689606,
-0.49485868215560913,
-0.20105008780956268,
-0.13761314749717712,
0.008645146153867245,
-0.5339610576629639,
0.6140985488891602,
0.21805539727210999,
-0.47823482751846313,
0.08015288412570953,
-0.3056461215019226,
-0.5030759572982788,
-0.020061369985342026,
-0.1936970055103302,
0.14279350638389587,
0.38701316714286804,
-0.1976623237133026,
0.42063048481941223,
-0.5806721448898315,
0.14601583778858185,
0.18458712100982666,
-0.5444169640541077,
0.370147168636322,
-0.6493393778800964,
0.8066164255142212,
0.4630449712276459,
-0.1287592500448227,
-0.15348197519779205,
-0.4822266697883606,
-0.24862094223499298,
0.24936029314994812,
-0.7567163109779358,
-0.34483763575553894,
-0.17240312695503235,
-0.14069817960262299,
0.43596968054771423,
0.4735187888145447,
-0.2850245237350464,
0.19634056091308594,
-0.34768369793891907,
0.492009699344635,
0.4508134424686432,
-0.18806704878807068,
0.8910797238349915,
-0.11287303268909454,
0.6112450361251831,
-0.011835566721856594,
-0.057072144001722336,
-0.3208281397819519,
0.07289266586303711,
-0.8384606242179871,
-0.05247047170996666,
0.20542992651462555,
0.5937672257423401,
-1.0798296928405762,
0.055769212543964386,
-0.1351359635591507,
-0.19265881180763245,
-0.5551467537879944,
0.6370006203651428,
0.5749024748802185,
0.9072211980819702,
0.5288700461387634,
-0.04417484998703003,
-0.3474397659301758,
-0.8562394380569458,
0.09092878550291061,
0.023101922124624252,
-0.2494947910308838,
0.47485271096229553,
0.28026649355888367,
-0.31928005814552307,
0.5756628513336182,
-0.09342091530561447,
-0.3663690388202667,
-0.262136310338974,
-0.03514757379889488,
0.4180445373058319,
0.23825721442699432,
0.5013837814331055,
-0.585119366645813,
-0.4466899335384369,
0.003393234219402075,
-0.7127564549446106,
-0.1981869339942932,
-0.03804631158709526,
0.014601300470530987,
0.15037977695465088,
0.6112644672393799,
-0.5413370728492737,
0.17924603819847107,
0.6116498112678528,
-0.0411355085670948,
0.3743458390235901,
-0.3419741988182068,
0.13187295198440552,
-0.8807600736618042,
0.13298197090625763,
-0.09144196659326553,
-0.03898552060127258,
-0.5389771461486816,
-0.04928788170218468,
0.21518723666667938,
-0.13070978224277496,
-0.8145073652267456,
0.6839243769645691,
-0.5248984694480896,
-0.16076067090034485,
-0.4036914110183716,
0.455613374710083,
-0.07030418515205383,
0.37374475598335266,
0.03465622663497925,
1.0310301780700684,
0.09543413668870926,
-0.9462820887565613,
0.1959943026304245,
0.2865571975708008,
-0.287678599357605,
0.4821014404296875,
-0.459512859582901,
0.16075313091278076,
-0.21515940129756927,
0.05077119916677475,
-0.620655357837677,
-0.45916038751602173,
0.19641080498695374,
-0.2077515870332718,
0.3090738356113434,
-0.2930704653263092,
-0.6108746528625488,
-0.15182287991046906,
0.20638632774353027,
0.5478818416595459,
0.6688851118087769,
-0.5701627135276794,
0.17183566093444824,
0.050916533917188644,
-0.1454920768737793,
-0.6706632971763611,
-0.7696535587310791,
0.019669484347105026,
-0.26826393604278564,
-0.22669661045074463,
0.2027013599872589,
-0.004207172896713018,
-0.4199967682361603,
-0.050438642501831055,
0.01071733608841896,
-0.1538078933954239,
0.3216845989227295,
0.018790461122989655,
0.26277557015419006,
-0.1737751066684723,
0.40286576747894287,
0.10811766982078552,
0.29178252816200256,
-0.09042959660291672,
-0.054196834564208984,
0.6278484463691711,
-0.22752270102500916,
-0.3377346694469452,
-0.208085298538208,
0.14993694424629211,
0.5158559679985046,
-0.1558731645345688,
0.9429665207862854,
0.3333416283130646,
-0.3448007106781006,
-0.09852555394172668,
-0.3767218291759491,
-0.22542701661586761,
-0.4372245967388153,
0.3193723261356354,
-0.24006864428520203,
-0.8292907476425171,
0.5824463963508606,
-0.04952005669474602,
-0.08241672068834305,
0.310450941324234,
0.4883117079734802,
-0.29181578755378723,
0.7300503849983215,
0.5309786796569824,
0.07971612364053726,
0.664925217628479,
-0.3572675883769989,
-0.040207911282777786,
-0.9729482531547546,
-0.1951608657836914,
-0.6982002258300781,
-0.2508561611175537,
-0.3397417366504669,
-0.4599308669567108,
0.33676159381866455,
0.45387646555900574,
-0.3454408347606659,
0.4556518495082855,
-0.08045262098312378,
0.44310829043388367,
0.5434781312942505,
0.1009056493639946,
0.5033080577850342,
0.019453972578048706,
-0.11618129909038544,
-0.10083005577325821,
-0.8130263686180115,
-0.7768872976303101,
1.0360757112503052,
0.07196976244449615,
0.7212547659873962,
0.11525757610797882,
0.5980311036109924,
0.07021663337945938,
0.31054526567459106,
-1.0285577774047852,
0.3149945139884949,
-0.2715633809566498,
-0.4974655508995056,
-0.5127518177032471,
-0.5189546346664429,
-1.003970980644226,
0.43557289242744446,
-0.22560006380081177,
-0.43774962425231934,
0.2484530359506607,
0.153507798910141,
-0.3744167685508728,
0.10976769030094147,
-0.7785444259643555,
0.7745981812477112,
-0.6809900999069214,
-0.4867768883705139,
-0.11382615566253662,
-0.5357744693756104,
0.2896631062030792,
-0.5734143257141113,
0.5129429697990417,
-0.015583821572363377,
-0.22348789870738983,
0.49942973256111145,
-0.3121543228626251,
0.7412179708480835,
-0.07878565043210983,
-0.043802425265312195,
0.3028780221939087,
0.20259836316108704,
0.4610058665275574,
-0.157487690448761,
-0.28163468837738037,
0.09019535034894943,
-0.0023644836619496346,
-0.5647342801094055,
-0.4832325577735901,
0.4705142080783844,
-0.8201532363891602,
-0.7791362404823303,
-0.3062557578086853,
-0.5777655839920044,
-0.1527811586856842,
0.39210280776023865,
0.5486521124839783,
0.09617356210947037,
-0.07150143384933472,
0.4455166757106781,
0.6595615148544312,
-0.3830629885196686,
0.4748397767543793,
0.7459762096405029,
0.010983649641275406,
0.03485819697380066,
0.7497952580451965,
0.21172641217708588,
0.4555807411670685,
0.26980623602867126,
0.03354981914162636,
-0.2832687199115753,
-0.7256393432617188,
-0.4781453609466553,
0.5435076355934143,
-0.7976122498512268,
-0.22616301476955414,
-0.3631300926208496,
-0.1107865497469902,
-0.13317091763019562,
-0.21826912462711334,
-0.324987530708313,
-0.04966220632195473,
-0.8542857766151428,
0.03833967074751854,
-0.0780959352850914,
0.6916381120681763,
0.16264361143112183,
0.7342826724052429,
-0.9444211721420288,
-0.13896901905536652,
0.0756245031952858,
-0.0607747882604599,
0.05246653035283089,
-1.0758508443832397,
-0.710651159286499,
0.047114379703998566,
-0.11521214246749878,
-0.9571080803871155,
0.6002866625785828,
0.16635893285274506,
0.48673734068870544,
0.38319817185401917,
0.23418524861335754,
0.5779337286949158,
-0.4821946918964386,
0.5248820185661316,
0.03943342715501785,
-0.8951261639595032,
0.5569462776184082,
-0.21529501676559448,
0.41389337182044983,
0.6798586249351501,
0.6266292333602905,
-0.6276137232780457,
-0.19222183525562286,
-0.22835923731327057,
-0.7412605881690979,
0.8158905506134033,
-0.05873190984129906,
0.27976301312446594,
-0.21086660027503967,
0.5040705800056458,
0.09292463958263397,
0.4273645281791687,
-0.7101274728775024,
-0.024240797385573387,
-0.07293498516082764,
-0.08867665380239487,
-0.3600030243396759,
-0.20167860388755798,
-0.005742261186242104,
0.11319753527641296,
0.4551355838775635,
-0.1903962343931198,
-0.14407089352607727,
0.18464931845664978,
-0.7125332951545715,
-0.10316474735736847,
0.5235959887504578,
0.5519575476646423,
0.5071617364883423,
-0.25498345494270325,
0.2867133617401123,
0.36717113852500916,
-0.09176073223352432,
0.3444189131259918,
-0.15031808614730835,
-0.35671356320381165,
-0.07362936437129974,
0.4442203640937805,
0.8745126724243164,
0.4480327367782593,
-0.7677780389785767,
0.40068063139915466,
0.010542535223066807,
0.16328664124011993,
-0.2388123869895935,
0.03385709226131439,
0.002897339640185237,
0.22202055156230927,
0.45699357986450195,
-0.036713410168886185,
-0.0964118242263794,
-0.5952289700508118,
-0.3152267336845398,
0.4117375612258911,
-0.26972609758377075,
-0.47296977043151855,
0.6789625883102417,
0.3510117530822754,
-0.2867826819419861,
0.740135133266449,
-0.22736497223377228,
-0.25332820415496826,
0.4014969766139984,
0.4697513282299042,
0.44083282351493835,
-0.0772290751338005,
0.09523386508226395,
0.2938805818557739,
0.42157450318336487,
-0.36602872610092163,
-0.26096418499946594,
-0.2758791446685791,
-0.66889888048172,
-0.5210677981376648,
-0.5863333344459534,
-0.5127930641174316,
0.155386283993721,
-0.6310703158378601,
0.28517305850982666,
-0.3587593138217926,
-0.29815059900283813,
-0.5780275464057922,
-0.08165688067674637,
-1.1020934581756592,
-0.11152085661888123,
-0.019734736531972885,
0.7386960387229919,
-0.8830048441886902,
0.9489431977272034,
0.576038658618927,
-0.7947801947593689,
-0.6492252349853516,
-0.12358281761407852,
-0.11039364337921143,
-0.8269593715667725,
1.0588984489440918,
-0.1370100975036621,
-0.01821364462375641,
0.2157442718744278,
-0.45140475034713745,
-0.9956003427505493,
1.1782747507095337,
0.7618289589881897,
-0.6077322363853455,
-0.4925265610218048,
0.053637437522411346,
0.5726503729820251,
-0.17355035245418549,
0.17981427907943726,
0.5204389691352844,
0.3192983865737915,
-0.006846183445304632,
-1.2181518077850342,
0.001364520052447915,
0.26303035020828247,
-0.021051306277513504,
-0.22849994897842407,
-0.7456039786338806,
1.0855072736740112,
-0.31856340169906616,
-0.6995214819908142,
0.005450506694614887,
0.42956748604774475,
0.029672035947442055,
0.1586325466632843,
0.23233535885810852,
0.12067176401615143,
0.8600488901138306,
-0.03921861574053764,
1.1810311079025269,
-0.23184187710285187,
0.2084369659423828,
1.0223857164382935,
-0.1064104214310646,
0.7656058073043823,
0.7265378832817078,
-0.030459323897957802,
0.16797104477882385,
0.7578489780426025,
0.33928200602531433,
0.5259066820144653,
0.02986947074532509,
-0.3124496340751648,
-0.19804596900939941,
-0.43850433826446533,
-0.2021128386259079,
0.3552963435649872,
0.4559965431690216,
-0.5724499821662903,
-0.03802090883255005,
0.2985132038593292,
0.01581386663019657,
0.20701110363006592,
-0.415615439414978,
0.6203287243843079,
0.4143070578575134,
-0.6477519869804382,
0.92315274477005,
0.016245979815721512,
0.7947216629981995,
-0.2916378676891327,
0.33592790365219116,
-0.46815016865730286,
-0.07836069166660309,
-0.26174673438072205,
-0.44007787108421326,
0.24011723697185516,
0.20452477037906647,
-0.2077750265598297,
-0.29095521569252014,
0.4265785813331604,
-0.45715710520744324,
-0.15277720987796783,
0.34414270520210266,
0.9190887212753296,
0.34898078441619873,
0.13605283200740814,
-0.331246942281723,
0.22625689208507538,
0.0039980048313736916,
-0.181906595826149,
0.5096405744552612,
0.4600861370563507,
0.11641641706228256,
0.7085064053535461,
0.38645046949386597,
0.3846490681171417,
0.11092624813318253,
-0.16564714908599854,
0.5916027426719666,
-0.6306107044219971,
-0.0760887935757637,
-0.8531008958816528,
-0.016590917482972145,
0.3074708878993988,
-0.05345020815730095,
0.7659544348716736,
0.3652113676071167,
1.2021478414535522,
-0.20229147374629974,
0.8114431500434875,
0.1935730129480362,
0.36465758085250854,
-0.6953904628753662,
0.5626769661903381,
-0.5042042136192322,
0.5028741955757141,
0.12196806818246841,
-0.8863120675086975,
-0.057273004204034805,
0.5774053335189819,
-0.5327532887458801,
-0.2466844618320465,
0.8133153915405273,
0.32566359639167786,
0.04955790936946869,
-0.5199028253555298,
0.547823429107666,
0.14145031571388245,
0.174707293510437,
0.5718915462493896,
0.8029308915138245,
-0.23551030457019806,
1.015098214149475,
-0.3386344909667969,
-0.11248302459716797,
-0.47424766421318054,
-0.6834771037101746,
-0.9641214609146118,
-0.5497334599494934,
0.14802399277687073,
-0.27597716450691223,
-0.1555051952600479,
1.0938369035720825,
0.5409196615219116,
-0.5870041847229004,
-0.46607765555381775,
0.2480562925338745,
0.4086862802505493,
0.4256848096847534,
-0.157622829079628,
0.1946868747472763,
-0.5592271685600281,
-1.0067323446273804,
0.6487768888473511,
0.039882298558950424,
0.39102455973625183,
-0.3372763395309448,
-0.2014773041009903,
-0.04613638296723366,
-0.08913688361644745,
0.6926954388618469,
0.6242639422416687,
-0.7316111326217651,
-0.2015983611345291,
0.28814497590065,
-0.48382094502449036,
0.00743311969563365,
0.6914339065551758,
-0.7921585440635681,
0.2983085513114929,
0.471329003572464,
0.7092226147651672,
0.45311543345451355,
-0.003947644494473934,
0.5031341910362244,
-0.7378769516944885,
0.5457084774971008,
0.20983582735061646,
0.43992888927459717,
0.45271193981170654,
-0.3523975908756256,
0.323097825050354,
0.20444375276565552,
-0.4936707019805908,
-0.853623628616333,
0.3545699119567871,
-0.4491783082485199,
-0.19359759986400604,
1.1651173830032349,
-0.11747625470161438,
-0.31729742884635925,
0.024388330057263374,
-0.07504329830408096,
0.45058223605155945,
-0.2843971252441406,
0.6183769702911377,
0.7196599841117859,
-0.012375532649457455,
-0.181550994515419,
-0.7222372889518738,
0.46865925192832947,
0.3433770537376404,
-0.5270692706108093,
-0.06477846205234528,
0.5835778117179871,
0.2122650295495987,
0.038782887160778046,
0.7522383332252502,
0.013600124046206474,
0.03714171051979065,
-0.26377344131469727,
-0.08638857305049896,
-0.013661319389939308,
-0.10182081907987595,
-0.5841027498245239,
-0.12939512729644775,
0.3812624216079712,
0.08558110147714615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00075v1 | Logicbreaks: A Framework for Understanding Subversion of Rule-based Inference | 2024-06-21T19:18:16 | 2024-06-21T19:18:16 | Anton Xue, Avishree Khare, Rajeev Alur, Surbhi Goel, Eric Wong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | We study how to subvert language models from following the rules. We model
rule-following as inference in propositional Horn logic, a mathematical system
in which rules have the form "if $P$ and $Q$, then $R$" for some propositions
$P$, $Q$, and $R$. We prove that although transformers can faithfully abide by
such rules, maliciously crafted prompts can nevertheless mislead even
theoretically constructed models. Empirically, we find that attacks on our
theoretical models mirror popular attacks on large language models. Our work
suggests that studying smaller theoretical models can help understand the
behavior of large language models in rule-based settings like logical reasoning
and jailbreak attacks. | [
-0.20999711751937866,
-0.927321195602417,
0.6600161194801331,
0.14019706845283508,
-0.07582725584506989,
-0.2876734435558319,
0.13775135576725006,
-0.2583591341972351,
0.10040488094091415,
1.1397720575332642,
-1.0148138999938965,
-0.11069783568382263,
-0.5635181069374084,
-0.07216032594442368,
-0.7002077102661133,
1.1759268045425415,
0.19756053388118744,
-0.09575725346803665,
-0.10141569375991821,
0.11877775937318802,
-0.655145525932312,
-0.3411962687969208,
-0.0951235294342041,
-0.6064938306808472,
0.4182228147983551,
0.075865738093853,
1.0052629709243774,
0.594390332698822,
0.3629119098186493,
0.30584511160850525,
-0.20690326392650604,
-0.29846906661987305,
-0.33774352073669434,
0.27949759364128113,
-0.7094782590866089,
-0.8474007844924927,
0.11226783692836761,
0.1721402257680893,
0.08253127336502075,
0.6012141108512878,
-0.217398539185524,
-0.09902728348970413,
-0.5326400399208069,
0.6523441076278687,
-0.43263381719589233,
0.08573271334171295,
-0.806628942489624,
0.15130749344825745,
-0.07609633356332779,
-0.0017569924239069223,
-0.9419965744018555,
-0.5874595642089844,
0.2909310460090637,
-0.49434491991996765,
0.1362219899892807,
0.1211739033460617,
0.7121694684028625,
0.2593892812728882,
-0.35182255506515503,
-0.29502788186073303,
-0.7518819570541382,
0.9124866127967834,
-0.7393991947174072,
0.45899447798728943,
0.4147578179836273,
0.45593300461769104,
-0.39130449295043945,
-0.5969486236572266,
-0.6143616437911987,
-0.14412067830562592,
-0.5169644951820374,
0.008314481936395168,
-0.605046808719635,
0.07318980991840363,
0.7318186163902283,
-0.006713360548019409,
-0.24126951396465302,
-0.2670445442199707,
-0.7227903008460999,
-0.06647156178951263,
0.44869303703308105,
0.052243251353502274,
0.5435531139373779,
-0.32828325033187866,
-0.37625759840011597,
0.03223029524087906,
-1.198883295059204,
-0.17652231454849243,
0.4407990872859955,
0.17008870840072632,
-0.003814553841948509,
0.6882936954498291,
0.09105493128299713,
0.6621273756027222,
0.01992426998913288,
-0.1771976798772812,
-0.08798275887966156,
-0.18178550899028778,
-0.27745693922042847,
0.01821295917034149,
0.4366585314273834,
0.3603152334690094,
0.614456295967102,
-0.30920153856277466,
-0.15867702662944794,
0.35092243552207947,
0.23488157987594604,
-0.6340920925140381,
-0.37228599190711975,
0.1208253726363182,
-0.5160746574401855,
-0.3506746292114258,
0.06240879371762276,
-0.5225397348403931,
-0.7625741362571716,
-0.39656296372413635,
0.38952207565307617,
-0.8281863927841187,
-0.3956754207611084,
0.20995867252349854,
-0.5815443396568298,
0.5292549133300781,
0.22466367483139038,
-0.9424676895141602,
0.6811620593070984,
0.871246874332428,
0.43386995792388916,
0.40216702222824097,
-0.30351102352142334,
-0.5327293872833252,
-0.0423424132168293,
-0.41054147481918335,
0.7503135800361633,
-0.6226645708084106,
-0.5833675861358643,
-0.13163165748119354,
-0.09077998995780945,
-0.11195535212755203,
-0.7256367206573486,
0.7379428744316101,
-0.8783932328224182,
-0.1727135330438614,
-0.1314121037721634,
-0.6878271102905273,
-0.262595534324646,
-0.05759742856025696,
-0.557693362236023,
0.3198302388191223,
-0.18780449032783508,
-0.7079737186431885,
0.36271408200263977,
-0.3407793939113617,
-0.8158094882965088,
-0.3731512427330017,
0.03520876541733742,
-0.14476045966148376,
0.35932502150535583,
0.13095340132713318,
0.008610235527157784,
-0.3063812255859375,
0.16109886765480042,
-0.2999446988105774,
0.03486425429582596,
0.3357401192188263,
-0.35308635234832764,
1.047763466835022,
0.24176296591758728,
-0.406777560710907,
0.3134974539279938,
-0.42140549421310425,
-0.16275420784950256,
0.17319904267787933,
0.3254697620868683,
-0.5955016016960144,
0.7085422873497009,
-0.2865354120731354,
0.33972856402397156,
-0.23388732969760895,
-0.8370376229286194,
0.3879450559616089,
-0.6714363098144531,
0.6187254190444946,
0.7552233934402466,
0.20271790027618408,
0.4548238217830658,
-0.3428432047367096,
0.3670119643211365,
0.03309322148561478,
0.347346693277359,
-0.39956361055374146,
-0.2654676139354706,
-0.561433732509613,
-0.035801731050014496,
0.18496005237102509,
0.7920426726341248,
-0.622383177280426,
0.13148514926433563,
0.1068129763007164,
-0.7357192635536194,
-0.30366960167884827,
-0.08410411328077316,
0.3918391168117523,
0.5455980896949768,
0.6315138339996338,
0.35642820596694946,
-0.7640618085861206,
-1.1643915176391602,
-0.8027577996253967,
-0.20221398770809174,
0.15848195552825928,
-0.16568025946617126,
0.8766458034515381,
-0.09670910239219666,
1.1431559324264526,
-0.49153414368629456,
-0.02086884342133999,
-0.5992010831832886,
-0.09592308104038239,
0.4159700870513916,
0.5998017191886902,
0.579360842704773,
-0.8664184808731079,
-0.10173749923706055,
-0.3936614394187927,
-0.710889458656311,
-0.2935098111629486,
-0.15707695484161377,
0.21766969561576843,
-0.012106535956263542,
0.830315351486206,
-0.6752927303314209,
1.0862317085266113,
0.2089674025774002,
-0.7201105356216431,
0.9981064200401306,
0.30492809414863586,
-0.13942599296569824,
-0.6050049066543579,
-0.6712595224380493,
0.12007323652505875,
-0.15889088809490204,
-0.6730676889419556,
0.10800107568502426,
-0.16051656007766724,
0.17637905478477478,
-0.6425541639328003,
0.41262224316596985,
-0.029779091477394104,
-0.03205820545554161,
-0.28426486253738403,
-0.0023831864818930626,
-0.0493224635720253,
0.06653675436973572,
0.1754181832075119,
0.2979573905467987,
0.6951172947883606,
-0.575685441493988,
0.4599358141422272,
0.2821636497974396,
-0.23261703550815582,
0.6368443369865417,
-1.0252666473388672,
-0.33083754777908325,
-0.03898267075419426,
0.4707273840904236,
-0.664722204208374,
-0.005152278114110231,
0.1408664584159851,
-0.22967854142189026,
-0.2096443623304367,
-0.5050106644630432,
-0.6205261945724487,
-0.1995466947555542,
-0.03217771276831627,
0.36368870735168457,
0.8549850583076477,
-0.7137426137924194,
0.9303849339485168,
0.14682525396347046,
0.21965326368808746,
-0.4230082631111145,
-0.6435413956642151,
-0.17724041640758514,
-0.14633171260356903,
-0.6429092288017273,
0.2565552592277527,
0.13880403339862823,
-1.0958843231201172,
0.003363315248861909,
-0.150786355137825,
0.2430254966020584,
-0.051580581814050674,
0.49099257588386536,
0.20038969814777374,
-0.13845989108085632,
-0.23254501819610596,
0.24662582576274872,
-0.03736605495214462,
0.6182526350021362,
-0.3840482234954834,
0.48500242829322815,
-0.23378512263298035,
-0.5519231557846069,
-0.7673776149749756,
0.23874622583389282,
0.7244258522987366,
-0.42218950390815735,
0.7728980779647827,
-0.3850444257259369,
-0.3359936773777008,
-0.5534839630126953,
-0.33439236879348755,
-0.5743157267570496,
-0.5221866369247437,
-0.015899181365966797,
-0.6925353407859802,
-0.480430006980896,
0.612018346786499,
-0.15732279419898987,
0.1342841535806656,
0.6847190260887146,
0.3562501072883606,
-0.025798218324780464,
0.9775711894035339,
0.6432003974914551,
0.21027854084968567,
0.2903623580932617,
0.13152380287647247,
0.16745057702064514,
-0.38172829151153564,
-0.19654956459999084,
-0.4820111393928528,
0.05816975608468056,
-0.5972394347190857,
-0.09417381137609482,
0.052227891981601715,
0.1965927928686142,
-0.2239830195903778,
0.7471941113471985,
-0.05562633275985718,
1.025019645690918,
0.4815926253795624,
0.13632962107658386,
0.2703080475330353,
-0.4861266314983368,
-0.3426385223865509,
-0.06469675153493881,
-0.6321099400520325,
-0.26848623156547546,
0.7039716839790344,
0.37316006422042847,
1.1697275638580322,
0.38345396518707275,
0.43309321999549866,
0.5192723870277405,
0.24930405616760254,
-0.8389120101928711,
0.6006180644035339,
0.14135916531085968,
-0.938210129737854,
-0.053741712123155594,
-0.3928915858268738,
-0.5791361331939697,
0.3806423246860504,
-0.13076895475387573,
-1.0306980609893799,
0.17151464521884918,
0.11909884214401245,
-0.11994398385286331,
0.6413503885269165,
-0.8550744652748108,
0.9425778985023499,
-0.002672999631613493,
-0.16664859652519226,
-0.4817022383213043,
-0.7406710982322693,
0.8006841540336609,
0.20231710374355316,
0.4589521288871765,
0.11044787615537643,
0.47117260098457336,
0.7091305255889893,
-1.0923428535461426,
1.2518932819366455,
-0.20229597389698029,
-0.1951807588338852,
0.6655811667442322,
0.7853142619132996,
0.5141721963882446,
0.0029062931425869465,
0.03592805564403534,
-0.23230111598968506,
0.6136840581893921,
-0.42255696654319763,
-0.9898319244384766,
0.24509580433368683,
-0.5628554821014404,
-0.7176259756088257,
-0.4854569733142853,
-0.40179261565208435,
-0.17957104742527008,
0.2172321230173111,
0.34418219327926636,
0.6875724196434021,
0.01164206676185131,
0.013730330392718315,
0.8844233751296997,
-0.29226750135421753,
0.19924455881118774,
0.5412725806236267,
-0.6763020753860474,
-0.08076617866754532,
0.6268380284309387,
-0.09335751086473465,
0.505236804485321,
0.1820382922887802,
0.46786418557167053,
-0.392785906791687,
-0.40589749813079834,
-0.2604216933250427,
0.28868553042411804,
-0.9085118770599365,
0.08719991147518158,
-0.18604260683059692,
-0.2351912260055542,
-0.4539399743080139,
-0.13296185433864594,
-0.24345651268959045,
-0.4837043285369873,
0.22357818484306335,
-0.26441988348960876,
0.529988706111908,
1.0193941593170166,
-0.12381069362163544,
0.41945281624794006,
-0.781786322593689,
0.35623985528945923,
0.17626239359378815,
0.22501517832279205,
-0.030931953340768814,
-0.780603289604187,
0.37526965141296387,
-0.2717932164669037,
0.046104833483695984,
-1.3192886114120483,
0.009474710561335087,
-0.12047896534204483,
0.41004088521003723,
0.5349263548851013,
0.32908472418785095,
0.3372359871864319,
-0.9712153673171997,
0.4576103389263153,
0.275907039642334,
-1.317969799041748,
0.938690721988678,
-0.6024433970451355,
0.05204339325428009,
0.3832279145717621,
0.16751596331596375,
-0.8608636856079102,
-0.4738193452358246,
-0.871486246585846,
-0.466170996427536,
0.6108112335205078,
0.08890035003423691,
0.31667089462280273,
-0.09023607522249222,
0.4114055633544922,
0.12577025592327118,
0.031878843903541565,
-0.8396596908569336,
-0.3852030634880066,
-0.41477179527282715,
-0.06116674467921257,
0.29957395792007446,
-0.1429409682750702,
-0.2474411576986313,
-0.4316369593143463,
0.8041502833366394,
0.21898281574249268,
-0.12289604544639587,
0.09401493519544601,
-0.2770415246486664,
0.12611332535743713,
0.3581445515155792,
0.7419095039367676,
0.7730870842933655,
0.15660972893238068,
0.27881136536598206,
-0.019872840493917465,
-0.19960902631282806,
0.08863893151283264,
-0.20752941071987152,
-0.4931565225124359,
-0.2902761399745941,
0.6231699585914612,
0.6098029017448425,
-0.0961742028594017,
-1.0539964437484741,
0.5161390900611877,
0.0852244421839714,
-0.283029705286026,
-0.39504650235176086,
0.26659366488456726,
-0.12644536793231964,
0.3204440772533417,
0.25244826078414917,
0.3710132837295532,
-0.10516925901174545,
-0.9786473512649536,
0.7586203217506409,
0.2682545483112335,
-0.8063721656799316,
-0.5052961707115173,
0.6435704827308655,
-0.14103209972381592,
-0.3750615417957306,
0.5982574224472046,
0.02602655626833439,
-0.9433501958847046,
0.6245433688163757,
0.8796980381011963,
0.4728212058544159,
-0.08159414678812027,
0.35276490449905396,
-0.05281469598412514,
0.8930514454841614,
0.022341765463352203,
0.038551829755306244,
0.13471616804599762,
-0.9892295598983765,
-0.6628604531288147,
-0.5380287170410156,
-0.5787448883056641,
-0.09308306872844696,
-0.6536835432052612,
0.05294850096106529,
-0.8696367740631104,
0.1542464792728424,
0.26432180404663086,
-0.8372776508331299,
-0.0650947317481041,
0.27941402792930603,
-0.20050200819969177,
1.3814094066619873,
-0.8904783129692078,
0.6935918927192688,
0.30753976106643677,
-0.5628439784049988,
-0.7510992288589478,
0.031088730320334435,
0.28292545676231384,
-0.5561742186546326,
0.9717154502868652,
-0.09192364662885666,
-0.35218361020088196,
-0.22614189982414246,
-0.8142208456993103,
-0.5305183529853821,
0.3052615821361542,
0.17961597442626953,
-0.23123157024383545,
0.1229335218667984,
-0.03903093934059143,
0.42971324920654297,
-0.12041627615690231,
0.12968339025974274,
1.1450073719024658,
0.5131427645683289,
0.12712915241718292,
-0.6729572415351868,
0.18189996480941772,
-0.11388737708330154,
-0.5543370842933655,
0.5200033187866211,
-0.4752063751220703,
0.7929694056510925,
-0.5231108069419861,
0.1383192092180252,
0.09873542189598083,
0.847838819026947,
0.24343617260456085,
0.055080167949199677,
0.6694295406341553,
0.583128035068512,
0.30451083183288574,
-0.3658320903778076,
1.0740070343017578,
0.1080404669046402,
0.1193765178322792,
1.2039918899536133,
-0.31802764534950256,
0.7423597574234009,
0.4282684326171875,
-0.15092279016971588,
1.0369377136230469,
0.32832974195480347,
-0.11713789403438568,
0.5782907009124756,
0.4753095507621765,
-0.03669630363583565,
-0.3543640375137329,
0.0377734936773777,
-0.0355229377746582,
0.53372722864151,
0.5975254774093628,
-0.33061835169792175,
-0.3692685663700104,
0.191950723528862,
0.3328458368778229,
0.30846884846687317,
-0.5497123599052429,
0.6967693567276001,
0.08609466999769211,
-0.7509533762931824,
0.28605979681015015,
0.22486792504787445,
0.3276796042919159,
-0.628138542175293,
-0.03950851783156395,
-0.0244001317769289,
0.30872318148612976,
-0.44082149863243103,
-0.7120930552482605,
0.6126123070716858,
0.07387052476406097,
-0.2939959168434143,
-0.189812570810318,
0.7359614968299866,
0.23932212591171265,
-0.45346134901046753,
0.36153045296669006,
0.3077855110168457,
-0.039091743528842926,
0.14174208045005798,
-0.5723733901977539,
-0.10114768147468567,
0.03922418877482414,
-0.32538068294525146,
0.1344211846590042,
0.2530245780944824,
-0.3172089457511902,
0.755203366279602,
0.5448557734489441,
0.011080614291131496,
0.2568940818309784,
0.12825609743595123,
0.7275193333625793,
-0.8169629573822021,
-0.4710516035556793,
-1.2167613506317139,
0.32113417983055115,
-0.007788244169205427,
-0.1079847514629364,
0.8806257843971252,
0.36586353182792664,
0.7912442088127136,
-0.039177875965833664,
0.8423450589179993,
-0.09564149379730225,
0.6034968495368958,
-0.6994062066078186,
0.645648181438446,
-0.2262016236782074,
0.43235665559768677,
-0.35944056510925293,
-0.6530742645263672,
-0.28251516819000244,
0.5395684242248535,
-1.023753046989441,
-0.2389170229434967,
0.7194427847862244,
0.5397442579269409,
0.009111707098782063,
0.4918190836906433,
0.07868370413780212,
0.503564715385437,
0.36225220561027527,
0.05370640754699707,
1.167303204536438,
-0.3346717655658722,
0.5430242419242859,
-0.15943856537342072,
-0.1851002424955368,
0.09325535595417023,
-0.5668741464614868,
-0.9004688858985901,
-0.2369289994239807,
-0.1263599842786789,
-0.6250295639038086,
-0.08870493620634079,
0.664359986782074,
0.5448377132415771,
-0.9374901652336121,
-0.15091173350811005,
-0.4473303556442261,
0.6460753083229065,
-0.36844146251678467,
-0.27792179584503174,
0.2155732661485672,
-0.18562832474708557,
-0.3300953507423401,
0.6300575137138367,
0.12338554114103317,
-0.0657416358590126,
-0.1975250244140625,
0.2695927023887634,
-0.1864652782678604,
0.6510883569717407,
0.667128324508667,
0.5075381398200989,
-0.9515606760978699,
-0.4649732708930969,
-0.06391891092061996,
0.2548074722290039,
-0.19222381711006165,
0.9087141752243042,
-1.0709893703460693,
0.09207259863615036,
0.5308533310890198,
0.45111459493637085,
0.21743564307689667,
0.10140979290008545,
0.5640289187431335,
-0.5629924535751343,
0.23708593845367432,
0.19827786087989807,
0.4798170328140259,
-0.1118088960647583,
0.17313213646411896,
0.30757778882980347,
0.708302915096283,
-0.14933055639266968,
-0.7956042289733887,
1.1493034362792969,
-0.541178286075592,
-0.7330783009529114,
0.8880897760391235,
0.08033023774623871,
-0.46214115619659424,
-0.06239669770002365,
-0.1095869243144989,
-0.24864496290683746,
-0.1288720667362213,
0.33184385299682617,
0.5425171852111816,
-0.3610547184944153,
-0.22269608080387115,
-0.6627439260482788,
0.5521341562271118,
0.39521118998527527,
-0.5269337296485901,
0.35162118077278137,
0.5697295069694519,
0.39692744612693787,
0.25549253821372986,
0.08107326924800873,
-0.2481345385313034,
0.3150078356266022,
0.33737263083457947,
-0.2409479171037674,
0.25644317269325256,
-0.4732830822467804,
0.007721956353634596,
0.19951559603214264,
-0.22699910402297974,
0.44563737511634827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15593v1 | News Deja Vu: Connecting Past and Present with Semantic Search | 2024-06-21T18:50:57 | 2024-06-21T18:50:57 | Brevin Franklin, Emily Silcock, Abhishek Arora, Tom Bryan, Melissa Dell | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Social scientists and the general public often analyze contemporary events by
drawing parallels with the past, a process complicated by the vast, noisy, and
unstructured nature of historical texts. For example, hundreds of millions of
page scans from historical newspapers have been noisily transcribed.
Traditional sparse methods for searching for relevant material in these vast
corpora, e.g., with keywords, can be brittle given complex vocabularies and OCR
noise. This study introduces News Deja Vu, a novel semantic search tool that
leverages transformer large language models and a bi-encoder approach to
identify historical news articles that are most similar to modern news queries.
News Deja Vu first recognizes and masks entities, in order to focus on broader
parallels rather than the specific named entities being discussed. Then, a
contrastively trained, lightweight bi-encoder retrieves historical articles
that are most similar semantically to a modern query, illustrating how
phenomena that might seem unique to the present have varied historical
precedents. Aimed at social scientists, the user-friendly News Deja Vu package
is designed to be accessible for those who lack extensive familiarity with deep
learning. It works with large text datasets, and we show how it can be deployed
to a massive scale corpus of historical, open-source news articles. While human
expertise remains important for drawing deeper insights, News Deja Vu provides
a powerful tool for exploring parallels in how people have perceived past and
present. | [
-0.3184727430343628,
-0.9316219091415405,
0.9235082864761353,
-0.23571109771728516,
-0.4892500340938568,
0.2080841064453125,
-0.037163782864809036,
-0.4218307137489319,
0.611116349697113,
0.5541043281555176,
-0.6183180809020996,
-0.6661437749862671,
-0.6071598529815674,
-0.005326914135366678,
-0.5832259058952332,
0.6487782597541809,
-0.059467166662216187,
-0.02526693604886532,
-0.22701679170131683,
-0.10298404842615128,
-0.4331192076206207,
-0.4136611521244049,
-0.2679729163646698,
-0.28522050380706787,
0.6057846546173096,
0.08947635442018509,
1.118229866027832,
0.35524600744247437,
0.24759727716445923,
0.15921422839164734,
-0.38029131293296814,
0.13863059878349304,
-0.7735097408294678,
0.2937464416027069,
-0.5843255519866943,
-0.4573768377304077,
0.020510639995336533,
0.014320663176476955,
0.476606547832489,
0.7764812111854553,
0.38601523637771606,
0.14026065170764923,
-0.20674091577529907,
0.8350944519042969,
-0.6991291642189026,
0.111217200756073,
-0.8831241726875305,
-0.0301988422870636,
-0.14433258771896362,
-0.47285476326942444,
-0.026481924578547478,
-0.646004855632782,
0.08346915990114212,
-0.6270193457603455,
0.42567503452301025,
-0.3655053675174713,
0.9720174670219421,
0.16101661324501038,
-0.610518217086792,
-0.15426848828792572,
-0.8560094237327576,
0.6701840162277222,
-0.24417178332805634,
0.7511759400367737,
0.24491913616657257,
0.3104456961154938,
-0.46455276012420654,
-0.8326140642166138,
-0.8680947422981262,
-0.09623029828071594,
0.1114950031042099,
-0.005248020403087139,
-0.24172599613666534,
-0.5914427042007446,
0.19607442617416382,
0.41113483905792236,
-0.787296712398529,
0.06459422409534454,
-0.575315535068512,
-0.06530445069074631,
0.13996188342571259,
0.30095595121383667,
0.2789570391178131,
-0.2007187455892563,
-0.4412078857421875,
-0.22680240869522095,
-0.7667555212974548,
0.10752029716968536,
0.4339960813522339,
0.0017088274471461773,
0.26709380745887756,
0.568149983882904,
-0.6443406343460083,
0.8242738246917725,
-0.2554469704627991,
-0.0020276254508644342,
0.3012913167476654,
-0.10562222450971603,
0.22288233041763306,
0.3168044984340668,
0.36483240127563477,
0.5655694007873535,
0.09690996259450912,
-0.29530325531959534,
0.19396844506263733,
0.5618571639060974,
0.4741731584072113,
-0.4821808934211731,
-0.12084375321865082,
-0.161642923951149,
-0.6414803862571716,
-0.24729454517364502,
0.18223683536052704,
-1.1639111042022705,
-0.600380539894104,
-0.6070283055305481,
0.4690573513507843,
-0.11540587991476059,
-0.29225197434425354,
0.44427400827407837,
-0.6240516901016235,
0.3644229769706726,
0.46055272221565247,
-0.47980618476867676,
0.17854218184947968,
0.7894891500473022,
0.5324598550796509,
0.12424557656049728,
-0.2537508010864258,
-0.5421473383903503,
0.15318571031093597,
-0.3003348410129547,
0.5704465508460999,
-0.7848510146141052,
-0.2776867151260376,
0.10648098587989807,
0.17903652787208557,
0.4492582380771637,
-0.1837143748998642,
0.44520658254623413,
-0.7935243844985962,
0.12288807332515717,
-0.20253856480121613,
-0.312272310256958,
-0.2619512677192688,
0.3554474413394928,
-0.9257277846336365,
0.9067621231079102,
0.148751899600029,
-0.8584612607955933,
0.6197124123573303,
-0.009823352098464966,
-0.3686419725418091,
-0.25745832920074463,
-0.4811834394931793,
-0.3038017451763153,
0.19269317388534546,
0.31920742988586426,
0.13869594037532806,
-0.32147663831710815,
0.20458003878593445,
-0.46174168586730957,
-0.5782893300056458,
-0.00023348408285528421,
-0.16862396895885468,
0.7098173499107361,
0.09326671063899994,
-0.4399937391281128,
-0.36010533571243286,
-0.7717750072479248,
-0.6096446514129639,
0.2839275598526001,
-0.08061851561069489,
-0.9700174927711487,
0.04549391195178032,
-0.20073889195919037,
0.09106411784887314,
0.36616697907447815,
-0.6559268236160278,
0.4105411767959595,
-0.34055113792419434,
0.36551734805107117,
0.28134557604789734,
0.10842723399400711,
0.49653616547584534,
-0.1857461780309677,
0.08278969675302505,
0.18459120392799377,
0.23795202374458313,
-0.3390222489833832,
-0.41124844551086426,
-0.3914854824542999,
0.4281217157840729,
0.11110677570104599,
0.3865220546722412,
-0.5042312145233154,
0.3496573865413666,
-0.6299420595169067,
-0.526067316532135,
-0.46909111738204956,
0.049011342227458954,
-0.3100738525390625,
0.354979932308197,
0.3418950140476227,
-0.10492275655269623,
-0.7212231159210205,
-0.8572850227355957,
-0.4415057897567749,
-0.1142905205488205,
-0.15182779729366302,
0.009441678412258625,
0.3117217421531677,
-0.2699364125728607,
1.032740592956543,
-0.7104966640472412,
-0.2596185505390167,
0.19992174208164215,
0.27961865067481995,
0.21917018294334412,
0.059513092041015625,
0.3406739830970764,
-1.4477943181991577,
0.21514971554279327,
0.04883461445569992,
-0.6273759007453918,
0.39681991934776306,
-0.18660478293895721,
-0.08955492824316025,
0.14504842460155487,
0.7954591512680054,
-0.4738553464412689,
0.6580497622489929,
0.32779890298843384,
-0.26444411277770996,
-0.0979619100689888,
-0.12991535663604736,
0.2965344190597534,
-1.0276689529418945,
0.1331842988729477,
-0.31554263830184937,
-0.08317850530147552,
0.013105512596666813,
-0.31570133566856384,
0.24511753022670746,
-0.483419269323349,
-0.587322473526001,
0.5872080326080322,
-0.408121794462204,
0.1829679012298584,
-0.18146590888500214,
0.5079114437103271,
0.20030075311660767,
0.14091283082962036,
0.18952204287052155,
0.05888460949063301,
0.4069784879684448,
-0.49754130840301514,
0.4242228865623474,
0.1318175047636032,
-0.4988791048526764,
0.37982770800590515,
-0.2940223217010498,
0.2042747586965561,
-0.6023362278938293,
0.37477853894233704,
-0.8857787847518921,
0.051689110696315765,
-0.1251407265663147,
-0.5021782517433167,
0.13936151564121246,
0.07288100570440292,
-0.5674430727958679,
-0.4861384630203247,
-0.34344378113746643,
0.33749985694885254,
0.5338533520698547,
-0.482936292886734,
0.5300830006599426,
0.5458755493164062,
-0.0006282959948293865,
-0.6887854933738708,
-0.5205000638961792,
0.3689228296279907,
0.017948288470506668,
-0.608578085899353,
0.47379153966903687,
0.34468740224838257,
-0.27377963066101074,
0.4519544541835785,
-0.5052768588066101,
-0.16589291393756866,
0.07006994634866714,
0.07027659565210342,
0.29074200987815857,
-0.29861414432525635,
0.1554844230413437,
0.17835049331188202,
-0.09423133730888367,
-0.2527664601802826,
-0.279656320810318,
0.5903839468955994,
0.1016513854265213,
-0.1770426630973816,
0.09020672738552094,
0.5675539970397949,
0.8020187020301819,
-0.28495749831199646,
0.7022867798805237,
0.5393268465995789,
-0.5242286920547485,
0.14176836609840393,
-0.935211181640625,
-0.3656994700431824,
-0.3159722685813904,
0.19694198668003082,
-0.1800798624753952,
-1.0081366300582886,
0.3369196057319641,
-0.22725129127502441,
-0.17432962357997894,
0.4942043125629425,
0.42660900950431824,
0.11857878416776657,
0.5681744813919067,
0.39760714769363403,
-0.2963916063308716,
0.4464435577392578,
-0.039157651364803314,
0.24824868142604828,
-0.369210422039032,
-0.42597687244415283,
-0.5398863554000854,
-0.5177373290061951,
-0.5584647059440613,
-0.08484476059675217,
0.2512664198875427,
0.03647281974554062,
-0.09376993775367737,
0.326111763715744,
-0.5627295970916748,
0.4140603244304657,
0.7632243037223816,
0.34274330735206604,
0.5846970081329346,
-0.3009475767612457,
0.4070078134536743,
-0.03822733089327812,
-0.12480444461107254,
-0.2547697126865387,
0.7946404814720154,
0.12331743538379669,
1.256618618965149,
-0.11367541551589966,
0.7918509244918823,
0.23381805419921875,
-0.33840706944465637,
-0.4870779812335968,
0.32657673954963684,
-0.16238203644752502,
-0.44839635491371155,
-0.12927956879138947,
-0.32766956090927124,
-1.5173728466033936,
0.008109019137918949,
-0.3575113117694855,
-0.5640513300895691,
0.5505239963531494,
-0.21912164986133575,
-0.14649513363838196,
0.3194122314453125,
-0.2527061104774475,
0.8951423168182373,
-0.1141602173447609,
-0.06015325337648392,
-0.38719648122787476,
-0.9563065767288208,
0.09672532975673676,
0.11070068180561066,
0.19118383526802063,
-0.2188432812690735,
-0.031874168664216995,
0.40582865476608276,
0.3577241599559784,
0.751535952091217,
0.1537097990512848,
0.2258741557598114,
0.0684218779206276,
0.24111559987068176,
0.5606486797332764,
0.22447431087493896,
0.361080527305603,
0.35568881034851074,
0.0771104171872139,
-0.24139295518398285,
-0.5485666394233704,
1.1057219505310059,
-0.5458633303642273,
-0.6583094596862793,
-0.26906871795654297,
-0.4493595361709595,
0.2169722020626068,
0.21623283624649048,
0.2085181623697281,
0.4255578815937042,
-0.49254080653190613,
0.5645007491111755,
0.7636641263961792,
-0.13430964946746826,
0.25418969988822937,
0.6365965008735657,
-0.24958601593971252,
-0.08194838464260101,
0.6375592350959778,
0.1359667181968689,
-0.3998188376426697,
0.9739508628845215,
0.132602721452713,
-0.1669778972864151,
-0.07810534536838531,
-0.35942238569259644,
0.027846816927194595,
-0.4634777903556824,
-0.3260274827480316,
-0.918647825717926,
-0.025258801877498627,
-0.5589569807052612,
-0.23534978926181793,
-0.36877334117889404,
-0.4825032949447632,
-0.3404061496257782,
-0.035722680389881134,
0.40693914890289307,
0.3861583471298218,
0.17778508365154266,
-0.4364243149757385,
-0.7951365113258362,
0.7355566024780273,
0.3098646402359009,
0.2503853440284729,
-0.3449952304363251,
0.18419931828975677,
-0.16467735171318054,
0.008963069878518581,
-0.4075881540775299,
-1.105430245399475,
0.2727970778942108,
-0.21989943087100983,
0.7379895448684692,
-0.1204058825969696,
0.5020534992218018,
0.22605647146701813,
-0.5608638525009155,
0.9874705672264099,
0.04491028934717178,
-0.5858898758888245,
0.9870147705078125,
-0.34487515687942505,
0.3155478835105896,
0.543036162853241,
0.6081345677375793,
-0.6236542463302612,
-0.5564345717430115,
-0.5526244044303894,
-1.1202068328857422,
0.20751111209392548,
-0.07834923267364502,
0.22456295788288116,
-0.3032582402229309,
0.24049195647239685,
0.44881346821784973,
0.12385538220405579,
-0.330557644367218,
-0.1621137261390686,
-0.4637715518474579,
0.013127142563462257,
0.04333069175481796,
-0.14776870608329773,
-0.021189004182815552,
-0.0969705656170845,
0.29106995463371277,
0.09529267251491547,
0.07517586648464203,
0.5016136169433594,
-0.2573898434638977,
-0.1205204650759697,
0.3762628734111786,
0.27727559208869934,
0.7664754390716553,
-0.1949426531791687,
0.4024163782596588,
0.029121460393071175,
-0.4245503544807434,
-0.0696229413151741,
0.43662428855895996,
-0.04681413248181343,
0.5607777833938599,
-0.08395586907863617,
0.7844882607460022,
0.6506216526031494,
-0.5766976475715637,
0.6736209392547607,
-0.08719658106565475,
-0.028881626203656197,
-0.656831681728363,
-0.17179496586322784,
0.06125283241271973,
0.5495047569274902,
0.8189467787742615,
-0.15967679023742676,
0.31791138648986816,
-0.9167073965072632,
0.24473761022090912,
0.39537113904953003,
-0.2479034960269928,
-0.14850930869579315,
0.8879444599151611,
-0.11028505116701126,
-0.26391980051994324,
0.599642276763916,
0.16801942884922028,
-0.3754907250404358,
0.3717529773712158,
0.33578217029571533,
0.7772374749183655,
0.005338913761079311,
0.11405763030052185,
0.1985478550195694,
0.15864619612693787,
-0.2961314916610718,
0.1471537947654724,
-0.013568167574703693,
-0.4382895231246948,
-0.3840896785259247,
-0.7280339598655701,
-0.38958939909935,
0.3159136176109314,
-0.7836284041404724,
0.7076188325881958,
0.25843918323516846,
-0.14464128017425537,
0.12235879898071289,
0.012187788262963295,
-1.1232836246490479,
0.03881768509745598,
0.33954811096191406,
0.9601541757583618,
-0.8532314300537109,
0.7515967488288879,
0.7051630616188049,
-0.45841604471206665,
0.02627066895365715,
0.1561509221792221,
0.18782202899456024,
-0.5959998965263367,
0.639079749584198,
0.00914173573255539,
0.1454651802778244,
-0.16755275428295135,
-0.2410404533147812,
-0.7738279104232788,
1.0486422777175903,
0.5415246486663818,
-0.5066057443618774,
-0.4223955571651459,
-0.07090582698583603,
0.4238387942314148,
0.04875599965453148,
-0.2991197407245636,
0.4345318078994751,
0.5147812366485596,
0.009557218290865421,
-0.8050621747970581,
0.04541826993227005,
-0.01638982631266117,
-0.0045706951059401035,
0.7301968932151794,
-0.4078022241592407,
0.8478302955627441,
0.07780367881059647,
-0.22327321767807007,
-0.15410685539245605,
0.8305515646934509,
-0.322683185338974,
0.7888522148132324,
0.2958546280860901,
0.5847519040107727,
0.6990431547164917,
-0.11267732083797455,
0.9169000387191772,
-0.12676432728767395,
0.26578423380851746,
0.9274831414222717,
-0.17319461703300476,
0.7031898498535156,
0.4808235764503479,
0.047198615968227386,
0.5779973268508911,
0.30262166261672974,
-0.017431776970624924,
0.6525733470916748,
0.06970080733299255,
-0.24828390777111053,
-0.1803397238254547,
0.13520242273807526,
-0.5460669994354248,
0.3626428544521332,
0.22612959146499634,
-0.4743092656135559,
-0.7998840808868408,
0.2590368092060089,
0.056238315999507904,
0.3514951765537262,
-0.38989874720573425,
0.8825486898422241,
0.09704947471618652,
-0.4135134816169739,
0.1862512230873108,
-0.5961205959320068,
0.4164687991142273,
-0.654417097568512,
-0.22340324521064758,
-0.192049041390419,
0.23127488791942596,
0.13267381489276886,
-0.9554587006568909,
0.575770914554596,
-0.46607404947280884,
-0.4549858272075653,
0.16770465672016144,
0.8676356077194214,
-0.4181198179721832,
-0.26961275935173035,
0.3620148003101349,
0.5234458446502686,
0.07825536280870438,
-0.2970556616783142,
-0.12616650760173798,
0.35312479734420776,
-0.21042731404304504,
-0.24810850620269775,
0.38744235038757324,
0.8180046081542969,
-0.1784304529428482,
0.14186106622219086,
0.4895177185535431,
-0.12411186099052429,
-0.17993062734603882,
-0.0575994998216629,
1.0699244737625122,
-1.067945957183838,
-0.3892859220504761,
-0.8658944368362427,
0.12330853939056396,
-0.10788820683956146,
-0.36041831970214844,
0.5691506862640381,
0.8010991811752319,
1.0941377878189087,
-0.027256648987531662,
0.4256322681903839,
0.203990176320076,
0.6619530916213989,
-0.5643765330314636,
0.5957493185997009,
-0.7475098371505737,
-0.06368309259414673,
-0.18464931845664978,
-0.8120966553688049,
-0.32402491569519043,
0.2803671360015869,
-0.18876215815544128,
-0.500598132610321,
0.5335129499435425,
0.6281920671463013,
-0.06649895757436752,
0.3015298545360565,
0.38112741708755493,
0.07956891506910324,
0.04184255748987198,
0.3894851803779602,
0.9762470126152039,
-0.12326236814260483,
0.8005081415176392,
-0.104945607483387,
-0.08710300177335739,
-0.3801644444465637,
-0.7513655424118042,
-0.7571169137954712,
-0.9967045187950134,
-0.013915474526584148,
-0.31093642115592957,
0.54830402135849,
0.7437537312507629,
0.1184973195195198,
-0.2774936258792877,
0.3409156799316406,
0.10662572085857391,
0.23588678240776062,
-0.21895097196102142,
-0.2694741487503052,
0.5199770927429199,
-0.2555367648601532,
-0.9117537140846252,
0.4463915526866913,
0.2143164575099945,
-0.20969723165035248,
-0.2669220566749573,
0.3765130937099457,
-0.07221004366874695,
-0.15445807576179504,
0.5369024276733398,
0.17903122305870056,
-0.6770597100257874,
-0.45328882336616516,
0.10630989074707031,
-0.17039883136749268,
0.09165458381175995,
1.1744654178619385,
-1.4413278102874756,
0.5697080492973328,
0.8912039399147034,
0.6809461116790771,
0.92699134349823,
-0.30521324276924133,
0.453193724155426,
-0.4929409325122833,
0.3421705663204193,
0.38448566198349,
0.290127694606781,
0.26767826080322266,
-0.6168566346168518,
0.49198392033576965,
0.27780935168266296,
-0.4941740036010742,
-0.606261670589447,
0.09101694077253342,
-1.2746931314468384,
-0.7632054686546326,
1.0496608018875122,
0.40284353494644165,
-0.42936569452285767,
-0.4713498055934906,
-0.32515597343444824,
0.33890193700790405,
-0.4851418733596802,
0.8589577078819275,
0.42409589886665344,
0.10199948400259018,
-0.0332467295229435,
-0.5924360752105713,
0.09362569451332092,
-0.03948017954826355,
-0.13410812616348267,
-0.29902783036231995,
0.5152478814125061,
0.09887173771858215,
0.28701263666152954,
0.3119395971298218,
-0.44664350152015686,
0.2900502681732178,
0.2630321681499481,
-0.17859052121639252,
-0.16447830200195312,
-0.12692709267139435,
-0.03431149199604988,
0.2689903974533081,
-0.48917776346206665,
-0.23708097636699677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15586v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15586v1 | TinyStyler: Efficient Few-Shot Text Style Transfer with Authorship Embeddings | 2024-06-21T18:41:22 | 2024-06-21T18:41:22 | Zachary Horvitz, Ajay Patel, Kanishk Singh, Chris Callison-Burch, Kathleen McKeown, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The goal of text style transfer is to transform the style of texts while
preserving their original meaning, often with only a few examples of the target
style. Existing style transfer methods generally rely on the few-shot
capabilities of large language models or on complex controllable text
generation approaches that are inefficient and underperform on fluency metrics.
We introduce TinyStyler, a lightweight but effective approach, which leverages
a small language model (800M params) and pre-trained authorship embeddings to
perform efficient, few-shot text style transfer. We evaluate on the challenging
task of authorship style transfer and find TinyStyler outperforms strong
approaches such as GPT-4. We also evaluate TinyStyler's ability to perform text
attribute style transfer (formal $\leftrightarrow$ informal) with automatic and
human evaluations and find that the approach outperforms recent controllable
text generation methods. Our model has been made publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/tinystyler/tinystyler . | [
0.06934117525815964,
-0.6549718379974365,
0.7286181449890137,
0.08395778387784958,
-0.3243027925491333,
-0.017247453331947327,
-0.4193861186504364,
-0.46614864468574524,
0.32485389709472656,
0.33340176939964294,
-0.3716282546520233,
-0.14587385952472687,
-0.6230233311653137,
0.246767058968544,
-0.205906942486763,
1.0922174453735352,
-0.06142134219408035,
-0.3032795488834381,
-0.12016396969556808,
-0.04017173871397972,
-0.14073947072029114,
-0.012302604503929615,
-0.7213720679283142,
-0.18143829703330994,
0.682640016078949,
0.9021627902984619,
0.6462175846099854,
0.7284165024757385,
0.7778902053833008,
0.24144364893436432,
0.11488604545593262,
-0.039886895567178726,
-0.6173326969146729,
-0.11664046347141266,
-0.047653645277023315,
-0.16614356637001038,
-0.5864647626876831,
0.01275078859180212,
0.6687654852867126,
0.2802357077598572,
0.11412932723760605,
0.4607645869255066,
0.17807087302207947,
0.5110185146331787,
-0.7597069144248962,
-0.058001015335321426,
-0.4787411093711853,
-0.08126930892467499,
-0.47955310344696045,
-0.09946266561746597,
-0.47578802704811096,
-0.7349752187728882,
-0.10928620398044586,
-0.43354082107543945,
0.05886896327137947,
0.29179880023002625,
0.3391876220703125,
0.06581050902605057,
-0.4002741873264313,
-0.18962979316711426,
-0.6079987287521362,
0.7902871370315552,
-0.5209109783172607,
0.06386664509773254,
0.2450740486383438,
0.4366131126880646,
0.4052405059337616,
-1.0809829235076904,
-0.6975163221359253,
-0.10590358078479767,
-0.41115808486938477,
-0.04494332894682884,
-0.3075176775455475,
-0.07362307608127594,
-0.07770514488220215,
0.007496423553675413,
-0.5131722688674927,
0.0305204838514328,
-0.29730287194252014,
-0.06783232092857361,
0.7300732731819153,
0.20295138657093048,
0.2833126485347748,
-0.290353000164032,
-0.32696735858917236,
-0.22805015742778778,
-0.5735973119735718,
-0.09134140610694885,
0.38433679938316345,
0.42757800221443176,
-0.16600851714611053,
0.24697162210941315,
0.14215919375419617,
0.42427006363868713,
0.22836998105049133,
-0.32884979248046875,
-0.19510123133659363,
-0.7104220986366272,
0.025337720289826393,
0.06526361405849457,
1.0496944189071655,
0.240277960896492,
0.16311953961849213,
-0.2592636048793793,
-0.24857087433338165,
-0.4730582535266876,
0.2376745492219925,
-1.2795231342315674,
-0.7475792765617371,
-0.29773709177970886,
-0.4935336112976074,
-0.690357506275177,
0.06508102267980576,
-0.8084893822669983,
-0.5059305429458618,
-0.03913803771138191,
0.7683171629905701,
-0.3834744691848755,
0.021900834515690804,
-0.29609817266464233,
-0.2765085697174072,
0.2607477903366089,
0.5770731568336487,
-1.044777512550354,
0.26268845796585083,
0.5613595843315125,
1.000593900680542,
-0.21550168097019196,
-0.1594390720129013,
-0.6167569160461426,
0.2094174474477768,
-0.5485829710960388,
0.6761859655380249,
-0.37481290102005005,
-0.13753291964530945,
-0.14372839033603668,
-0.24157166481018066,
-0.1520870327949524,
-0.02193225920200348,
0.1730545312166214,
-0.308977335691452,
-0.06420880556106567,
-0.23291148245334625,
-0.554348349571228,
0.5155190825462341,
-0.06654364615678787,
-0.6614809036254883,
0.8682680130004883,
0.10209714621305466,
-0.5078511238098145,
0.346505731344223,
-0.6954816579818726,
-0.4739847481250763,
0.30038830637931824,
-0.04874345660209656,
-0.4922312796115875,
0.18458697199821472,
-0.07833734899759293,
0.733671247959137,
-0.09844394773244858,
-0.49889445304870605,
-0.38142529129981995,
-0.5661045908927917,
0.22493912279605865,
-0.0031082001514732838,
0.5473437905311584,
0.08799786120653152,
-0.08587145060300827,
-0.04962829127907753,
-0.6042903661727905,
0.05079849809408188,
0.39037835597991943,
-0.0723969116806984,
-0.48268377780914307,
-0.7291510105133057,
0.6063372492790222,
0.019243165850639343,
0.43096819519996643,
-0.5443540215492249,
0.5722026824951172,
-0.09631548076868057,
0.3343372941017151,
0.8629043698310852,
0.07731783390045166,
1.1532690525054932,
-0.5508953928947449,
0.6743221282958984,
-0.6676540374755859,
-0.0635671615600586,
0.023787692189216614,
-0.32292482256889343,
-0.5378513336181641,
-0.5470471978187561,
0.4032576382160187,
0.41262632608413696,
-0.9248712658882141,
0.19979387521743774,
-0.4082597494125366,
-0.7767341136932373,
-0.5360150337219238,
0.562816858291626,
0.43893036246299744,
0.14779606461524963,
0.2021360993385315,
-0.050940703600645065,
-0.11635934561491013,
-0.6631507873535156,
-0.6604935526847839,
-0.14498095214366913,
-0.10836698859930038,
0.07823330163955688,
0.5770385265350342,
0.07890081405639648,
0.9488595128059387,
-0.7201109528541565,
-0.6484758257865906,
-0.6565349102020264,
0.5074970126152039,
-0.2542458176612854,
0.7707169651985168,
1.0237172842025757,
-0.4286341071128845,
-0.7554258108139038,
0.08597921580076218,
-0.30444782972335815,
-0.0986834168434143,
-0.29634493589401245,
-0.08709415048360825,
0.017928317189216614,
0.6214187741279602,
-0.289739727973938,
0.2572565972805023,
0.51698237657547,
-0.338215172290802,
0.37706583738327026,
-0.02619646117091179,
0.20992545783519745,
-1.2228260040283203,
0.1652761548757553,
-0.0015120324678719044,
-0.5423597097396851,
-0.571988582611084,
0.13020551204681396,
0.19266939163208008,
-0.0785549208521843,
-0.5129030346870422,
1.0264474153518677,
-0.5240593552589417,
0.3179839253425598,
-0.2701098322868347,
0.05739317089319229,
0.15503156185150146,
0.33586975932121277,
-0.297482967376709,
0.7572926878929138,
0.1220187097787857,
-0.0023393873125314713,
0.35873109102249146,
0.2566739022731781,
-0.2918074429035187,
0.7834856510162354,
-0.6132388114929199,
0.8316935896873474,
0.04243139177560806,
0.1542896032333374,
-1.3127548694610596,
-0.1989678293466568,
0.3617725074291229,
-0.07267101109027863,
0.7023404240608215,
-0.6652913689613342,
-0.8977648019790649,
-0.07371959090232849,
-0.6491403579711914,
0.4187423586845398,
0.6644546985626221,
-0.4354593753814697,
0.397655725479126,
-0.09433501213788986,
-0.6760106682777405,
0.1565268337726593,
-0.8105588555335999,
0.14486077427864075,
-0.35697776079177856,
-0.5779562592506409,
0.557921826839447,
-0.2537139058113098,
-0.07752278447151184,
-0.010966324247419834,
-0.06818834692239761,
-0.36051592230796814,
0.021679554134607315,
-0.18125872313976288,
0.17684456706047058,
-0.1914636343717575,
0.048355914652347565,
0.35406792163848877,
-0.0441841296851635,
-0.28182870149612427,
-0.04388612136244774,
-0.1134156882762909,
-0.27700933814048767,
-0.006179756484925747,
-0.6319036483764648,
0.25768962502479553,
0.3872700333595276,
0.16378135979175568,
0.8876491785049438,
0.8672729730606079,
-0.15379145741462708,
-0.43460026383399963,
-0.41404232382774353,
-0.5313408970832825,
-0.46094536781311035,
0.026816708967089653,
-0.36222603917121887,
-0.9135441780090332,
0.2624155580997467,
-0.01631154865026474,
-0.0422307625412941,
0.3327009081840515,
0.18352556228637695,
-0.29292577505111694,
0.6605360507965088,
1.0938222408294678,
0.01882040500640869,
0.8985220789909363,
-0.10991048812866211,
-0.0416342169046402,
-0.35714495182037354,
0.21636128425598145,
-0.5349453687667847,
-0.6256800293922424,
-0.7085624933242798,
-0.3230638802051544,
0.42418521642684937,
-0.014513412490487099,
-0.07603908330202103,
0.6923710107803345,
-0.3835180401802063,
0.7782265543937683,
0.39009419083595276,
0.27068132162094116,
0.30865728855133057,
-0.17569845914840698,
0.18633635342121124,
-0.23806288838386536,
-0.6780744194984436,
-0.7104008793830872,
0.9175911545753479,
0.03390613570809364,
1.1038455963134766,
0.4668457806110382,
1.0574620962142944,
0.34707120060920715,
0.2596641182899475,
-0.9527055621147156,
0.4432677626609802,
-0.3997192680835724,
-0.3724348247051239,
-0.34089338779449463,
-0.37820878624916077,
-0.3350173234939575,
0.03327786549925804,
-0.5244965553283691,
-0.8661065101623535,
0.2391701489686966,
0.5166327357292175,
-0.46734780073165894,
0.21938131749629974,
-0.740817129611969,
1.0462408065795898,
0.16360847651958466,
-0.7509088516235352,
0.19983713328838348,
-0.7564504146575928,
0.232773557305336,
-0.3636827766895294,
0.00875923316925764,
0.04919370636343956,
-0.26722803711891174,
1.0291085243225098,
-0.5244618058204651,
0.8821701407432556,
0.13298743963241577,
-0.02203129231929779,
-0.02957896888256073,
0.5011571645736694,
0.806018054485321,
-0.11400680243968964,
-0.09937374293804169,
0.003208108013495803,
0.20965717732906342,
-0.2515157163143158,
-0.7229488492012024,
0.6372716426849365,
-0.5271674394607544,
-0.10213363170623779,
-0.24613751471042633,
-0.24381519854068756,
0.019484544172883034,
0.4472537338733673,
0.4735153317451477,
0.3357255458831787,
-0.392632395029068,
0.4300946295261383,
0.31351804733276367,
0.32173392176628113,
0.5802373886108398,
0.028564125299453735,
0.0517924427986145,
-0.25342294573783875,
0.8354237675666809,
0.1943793147802353,
0.2694231867790222,
0.3612217605113983,
0.6322485208511353,
-0.10621903836727142,
-0.3605459928512573,
-0.7393735647201538,
0.12838442623615265,
-0.615500807762146,
-0.27486056089401245,
-0.5261604189872742,
0.05816711112856865,
-0.5390124917030334,
-0.7947257161140442,
-0.5379390716552734,
-0.7210315465927124,
-0.42989417910575867,
0.2649098336696625,
0.7496464848518372,
0.737392246723175,
-0.013193510472774506,
0.758029043674469,
-0.7415621876716614,
0.36037325859069824,
0.6616520881652832,
0.07629117369651794,
-0.39354610443115234,
-0.772792637348175,
-0.23370212316513062,
-0.47970736026763916,
-0.29077962040901184,
-0.9426555633544922,
0.2875101864337921,
0.5026041865348816,
0.10441640019416809,
0.4267268180847168,
0.2904329001903534,
0.6129193902015686,
-0.616305947303772,
0.616070032119751,
0.1211470514535904,
-0.9551383852958679,
0.42882126569747925,
-0.2921733260154724,
0.2162645161151886,
1.0944585800170898,
0.0578690730035305,
-0.3297289311885834,
-0.2879834771156311,
-0.6479356288909912,
-0.5181618332862854,
0.8073057532310486,
0.3937428295612335,
0.16598732769489288,
0.36590638756752014,
0.2726333737373352,
0.09799528867006302,
0.20398911833763123,
-0.45415303111076355,
-0.015072341077029705,
-0.046396102756261826,
-0.42357832193374634,
-0.08683940023183823,
-0.18939532339572906,
-0.19433821737766266,
-0.18018703162670135,
0.43066278100013733,
-0.524185299873352,
0.4513811469078064,
-0.23162239789962769,
-0.2845402956008911,
-0.07181645929813385,
0.583968460559845,
0.49897679686546326,
0.38350725173950195,
-0.23510117828845978,
0.23831908404827118,
0.14254041016101837,
-0.4161180853843689,
0.12965606153011322,
0.24797780811786652,
-0.2304641306400299,
-0.04914994537830353,
0.5542118549346924,
0.49680501222610474,
0.4986252188682556,
0.13090819120407104,
1.0694392919540405,
-0.011772607453167439,
0.023020341992378235,
-0.022593170404434204,
0.06468294560909271,
-0.16328321397304535,
0.16898050904273987,
0.19530685245990753,
0.3863320052623749,
0.3515230417251587,
-0.43496638536453247,
0.06740302592515945,
0.26059266924858093,
-0.293271541595459,
-0.5370538830757141,
0.7319523692131042,
0.2957882583141327,
-0.05986294522881508,
0.06603344529867172,
-0.3525296747684479,
-0.13884717226028442,
0.404119610786438,
0.6761443614959717,
1.091826319694519,
0.056512437760829926,
0.18730244040489197,
0.046075187623500824,
0.5073481202125549,
-0.16140414774417877,
-0.022258376702666283,
-0.38705846667289734,
-0.4834080636501312,
-0.17908421158790588,
-0.5578190088272095,
-0.6945075988769531,
-0.4409184455871582,
-0.5317542552947998,
0.40107080340385437,
-0.6928028464317322,
-0.029348962008953094,
0.22472795844078064,
-0.02087072841823101,
-0.8937904834747314,
-0.2677372395992279,
-0.05516640469431877,
0.7500699162483215,
-1.2042174339294434,
0.624890148639679,
0.9732135534286499,
-0.4094898998737335,
-0.8570007681846619,
0.2731097638607025,
0.5077528953552246,
-0.541375994682312,
0.44187498092651367,
0.10792502015829086,
-0.4725308120250702,
0.40565869212150574,
-0.8530792593955994,
-0.4866099953651428,
1.1406774520874023,
0.5264660716056824,
-0.42937567830085754,
-0.06727749854326248,
-0.31768396496772766,
0.40247783064842224,
-0.19470468163490295,
0.01712903380393982,
0.5401370525360107,
0.47787049412727356,
0.32480868697166443,
-0.8040531873703003,
0.293822705745697,
-0.09854232519865036,
0.14770765602588654,
0.07813284546136856,
-0.7440608739852905,
0.5952960252761841,
-0.1512218415737152,
-0.15274839103221893,
0.5150701403617859,
0.7037110328674316,
0.04318878799676895,
0.34761926531791687,
0.26622259616851807,
0.17302206158638,
0.5532308220863342,
-0.02158511057496071,
1.0820152759552002,
-0.03933995962142944,
0.3826299011707306,
1.018554925918579,
-0.05656740814447403,
0.9094056487083435,
0.4858069121837616,
-0.05039883404970169,
0.5100309252738953,
0.0025582232046872377,
0.15461543202400208,
0.7232868075370789,
-0.17967069149017334,
-0.20229755342006683,
-0.15344195067882538,
-0.044117946177721024,
-0.18920207023620605,
0.7057027816772461,
-0.21465012431144714,
-0.2732453942298889,
0.13868628442287445,
0.13396774232387543,
0.5369381308555603,
0.0774201825261116,
-0.13832560181617737,
1.0490459203720093,
0.22143198549747467,
-0.04837517440319061,
0.007482659537345171,
0.09402727335691452,
0.8574709296226501,
-0.6225498914718628,
-0.13369013369083405,
-0.2832183241844177,
0.271687775850296,
-0.15253008902072906,
-0.6278652548789978,
0.06624212861061096,
0.08232133090496063,
0.022572804242372513,
-0.9107522964477539,
1.2529793977737427,
-0.48444998264312744,
-0.6927198171615601,
-0.3248792588710785,
0.469990074634552,
0.12790705263614655,
0.027018053457140923,
-0.44189727306365967,
0.014144524931907654,
-0.47223353385925293,
-0.22412145137786865,
0.3598908483982086,
0.6617200374603271,
0.19499266147613525,
0.13510191440582275,
0.4362199008464813,
0.24550160765647888,
-0.19882787764072418,
-0.13832072913646698,
0.6643325686454773,
-0.5271812677383423,
-0.6712855696678162,
-0.9217008352279663,
0.2769852876663208,
-0.027240939438343048,
-0.3410395085811615,
1.0332025289535522,
0.33512890338897705,
0.5008652210235596,
-0.3729296028614044,
0.6123448610305786,
-0.19017034769058228,
0.0848851129412651,
-0.6081390380859375,
1.3226062059402466,
-0.6683120131492615,
-0.12353070080280304,
-1.02364182472229,
-0.7909491658210754,
-0.45067551732063293,
0.6847187876701355,
-0.14219290018081665,
0.28937244415283203,
0.6421715617179871,
0.6361719369888306,
-0.25596511363983154,
-0.14536543190479279,
0.35995617508888245,
-0.14518314599990845,
0.10126938670873642,
0.2843668460845947,
0.5729392170906067,
-0.47695255279541016,
0.7085775136947632,
-0.6075515151023865,
-0.3672500252723694,
-0.550366997718811,
-1.3434540033340454,
-0.6902308464050293,
-0.4108678996562958,
-0.5246082544326782,
0.02035483345389366,
0.005313041619956493,
1.098381519317627,
0.9373677968978882,
-0.5090216398239136,
-0.007130234967917204,
0.1860249787569046,
0.04222339019179344,
-0.34910714626312256,
-0.24811671674251556,
0.3635930120944977,
0.02572563849389553,
-0.7424758076667786,
0.41104042530059814,
0.2167956829071045,
0.1784573346376419,
0.04543238505721092,
0.10618889331817627,
0.2128448486328125,
0.1589089035987854,
0.6655756831169128,
0.23729106783866882,
-0.24587003886699677,
-0.6010547280311584,
-0.22350041568279266,
-0.4949135184288025,
-0.19953562319278717,
0.8256499767303467,
-0.5153480768203735,
0.36742842197418213,
0.7345471382141113,
0.7003259062767029,
0.3375135660171509,
0.17316390573978424,
0.07838527858257294,
-1.3225878477096558,
0.03368718922138214,
0.08506201952695847,
0.19364354014396667,
0.3899762034416199,
-0.369501531124115,
0.38792115449905396,
0.4166176915168762,
-0.5473446249961853,
-0.5756931304931641,
-0.07516016066074371,
-1.1770585775375366,
-0.11632923036813736,
1.160749077796936,
0.10858923196792603,
-0.0931023508310318,
0.4394950568675995,
-0.28378331661224365,
0.12721218168735504,
-0.5742657780647278,
0.2952482998371124,
0.3991183638572693,
-0.1620967835187912,
-0.49951082468032837,
-0.2955554723739624,
0.6592838764190674,
0.040080588310956955,
-0.883077085018158,
-0.05368083715438843,
0.4776144325733185,
0.37433356046676636,
0.13406847417354584,
0.9745574593544006,
0.12531812489032745,
0.3666408658027649,
0.15938271582126617,
0.00865390058606863,
-0.22679322957992554,
-0.5883047580718994,
-0.35669180750846863,
0.1982678920030594,
0.24907521903514862,
-0.23392653465270996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15583v1 | Detecting AI-Generated Text: Factors Influencing Detectability with Current Methods | 2024-06-21T18:31:49 | 2024-06-21T18:31:49 | Kathleen C. Fraser, Hillary Dawkins, Svetlana Kiritchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language models (LLMs) have advanced to a point that even humans have
difficulty discerning whether a text was generated by another human, or by a
computer. However, knowing whether a text was produced by human or artificial
intelligence (AI) is important to determining its trustworthiness, and has
applications in many domains including detecting fraud and academic dishonesty,
as well as combating the spread of misinformation and political propaganda. The
task of AI-generated text (AIGT) detection is therefore both very challenging,
and highly critical. In this survey, we summarize state-of-the art approaches
to AIGT detection, including watermarking, statistical and stylistic analysis,
and machine learning classification. We also provide information about existing
datasets for this task. Synthesizing the research findings, we aim to provide
insight into the salient factors that combine to determine how "detectable"
AIGT text is under different scenarios, and to make practical recommendations
for future work towards this significant technical and societal challenge. | [
-0.3886433243751526,
-1.0849922895431519,
0.6537767052650452,
-0.0338435024023056,
-0.09820963442325592,
0.37173670530319214,
-0.055949170142412186,
-0.8526130318641663,
-0.13257524371147156,
0.4257138669490814,
-0.33237341046333313,
-0.45125246047973633,
-0.9999308586120605,
0.43398401141166687,
-0.9893991947174072,
0.8160533308982849,
-0.16278554499149323,
-0.31708860397338867,
-0.35415729880332947,
-0.07527695596218109,
-0.11913655698299408,
-0.7046897411346436,
-0.7492712140083313,
-0.5482850670814514,
0.04723038151860237,
0.23764999210834503,
0.32314613461494446,
0.8120734095573425,
0.5914744138717651,
0.38627368211746216,
-0.20140229165554047,
0.31720468401908875,
-0.2238054871559143,
0.2375212460756302,
0.1858692169189453,
-0.5356165766716003,
-0.20534738898277283,
0.32780420780181885,
0.5271216630935669,
-0.1221388429403305,
0.3080075979232788,
0.114239901304245,
0.13433150947093964,
0.5130429267883301,
-0.3255551755428314,
0.1577567160129547,
-0.7803971767425537,
0.009704945608973503,
-0.5899031162261963,
-0.31200847029685974,
-0.4977729618549347,
-0.3742525279521942,
0.023769091814756393,
-0.3846662640571594,
0.3151008188724518,
0.34281086921691895,
0.7255735397338867,
0.23366902768611908,
-0.4319080710411072,
-0.7739770412445068,
-0.7617984414100647,
0.7012363076210022,
-0.6573823690414429,
0.23616626858711243,
0.5885435938835144,
-0.07913011312484741,
-0.21103474497795105,
-0.8111090660095215,
-0.9303608536720276,
-0.5098280906677246,
-0.10699113458395004,
0.00815717875957489,
-0.48265427350997925,
-0.18889375030994415,
0.2557976245880127,
0.20743228495121002,
-0.492280513048172,
0.16320918500423431,
0.021297644823789597,
-0.5942701101303101,
0.7715654373168945,
0.046071041375398636,
0.8980780243873596,
-0.17931261658668518,
-0.22549569606781006,
-0.08836913108825684,
-0.6833981275558472,
-0.19712786376476288,
0.8087212443351746,
-0.08340727537870407,
0.010939406231045723,
0.588758647441864,
0.04626292735338211,
0.21069727838039398,
-0.12002640217542648,
-0.037559572607278824,
-0.12985269725322723,
-0.5963726043701172,
0.08448618650436401,
0.05504711717367172,
0.9764174818992615,
-0.0494275838136673,
0.6928240060806274,
0.08694078773260117,
-0.42223483324050903,
0.11818335205316544,
0.1762317717075348,
-0.5750879049301147,
-0.15543700754642487,
-0.09841564297676086,
-0.5937681198120117,
-0.43208038806915283,
0.1985628455877304,
-0.4550635516643524,
-0.8146653175354004,
-0.22127823531627655,
0.16322483122348785,
-0.39918258786201477,
-0.22180157899856567,
-0.3113715946674347,
-0.17765386402606964,
0.2460113912820816,
0.27162352204322815,
-0.5427680611610413,
-0.11506360024213791,
0.6084015965461731,
0.7441176176071167,
-0.36265212297439575,
-0.3078260123729706,
-0.2676905393600464,
-0.04192877933382988,
-0.2883106768131256,
1.0309261083602905,
-0.26056793332099915,
-0.29078409075737,
0.048855215311050415,
-0.2546467185020447,
0.13447391986846924,
-0.5628775954246521,
0.6282258629798889,
-0.48157796263694763,
0.4088384807109833,
-0.1672579050064087,
-0.7813752293586731,
-0.0785456970334053,
0.4591957628726959,
-0.8072583079338074,
0.9477147459983826,
-0.03573276847600937,
-0.9314902424812317,
0.46269556879997253,
-0.6173851490020752,
-0.7140548825263977,
0.253621369600296,
-0.1874242126941681,
-0.8145303130149841,
-0.0887608453631401,
0.08994738757610321,
0.46580877900123596,
-0.3205260932445526,
0.41803139448165894,
0.029597800225019455,
-0.4078761637210846,
0.5698467493057251,
-1.0133739709854126,
0.6656884551048279,
0.15667691826820374,
-0.5980184078216553,
0.13439448177814484,
-0.7391338348388672,
-0.2303498089313507,
0.26132383942604065,
-0.3924897313117981,
-0.2833111584186554,
0.10179069638252258,
0.4016088843345642,
-0.19478750228881836,
0.36537688970565796,
-0.2917454242706299,
-0.0456303246319294,
-0.005526567343622446,
0.6084042191505432,
0.7625496983528137,
0.03863963112235069,
0.18115511536598206,
-0.33919620513916016,
0.587922215461731,
-0.04349305480718613,
-0.021813608705997467,
-0.11614928394556046,
-0.6550536155700684,
-0.6039509773254395,
-0.17315958440303802,
0.3064314126968384,
0.6561039090156555,
-0.8721458911895752,
0.6089053750038147,
0.07604054361581802,
-0.4975873827934265,
-0.3184971213340759,
0.09351637214422226,
0.3918140232563019,
0.2478863000869751,
0.05139383673667908,
0.052702516317367554,
-0.3014827072620392,
-0.8547658920288086,
-0.612170934677124,
-0.6518420577049255,
0.1043146401643753,
0.2543666362762451,
0.7063834071159363,
-0.377668172121048,
0.7323544025421143,
-0.30496078729629517,
-0.2549225389957428,
-0.34104233980178833,
0.6764888167381287,
-0.31310269236564636,
0.36950573325157166,
0.6083669662475586,
-0.7761302590370178,
-0.6166720390319824,
-0.017463037744164467,
-0.9626988768577576,
-0.2985881567001343,
-0.25972360372543335,
0.30288293957710266,
0.29308468103408813,
0.779814600944519,
-0.46975305676460266,
0.7139163017272949,
0.34829777479171753,
-0.4180629253387451,
0.35650354623794556,
-0.24897442758083344,
0.4540621340274811,
-0.9031637907028198,
0.21927066147327423,
0.2083473652601242,
-0.34309911727905273,
-0.63241046667099,
0.05138362571597099,
0.004669772926717997,
0.21143978834152222,
-0.13980598747730255,
0.7852900624275208,
-0.47912371158599854,
0.081436388194561,
-0.5021513104438782,
0.007641779258847237,
-0.17921310663223267,
0.017976757138967514,
-0.24491137266159058,
1.1836426258087158,
0.20294758677482605,
-0.32772964239120483,
0.38010701537132263,
0.2163277119398117,
-0.5816161036491394,
0.5890341401100159,
-0.6026666164398193,
0.25157487392425537,
-0.16389071941375732,
0.22400158643722534,
-1.1109265089035034,
-0.3246297538280487,
0.4846153259277344,
-0.7509536743164062,
0.20589570701122284,
0.15433943271636963,
-0.7600570917129517,
-0.05534234270453453,
-0.17138315737247467,
0.36346885561943054,
0.37720510363578796,
-0.3614758551120758,
0.6071757674217224,
0.39236101508140564,
-0.20868760347366333,
-0.44067174196243286,
-0.6908051371574402,
0.41348472237586975,
-0.2634676992893219,
-0.48735111951828003,
0.2476682811975479,
-0.050441473722457886,
-0.5319535732269287,
-0.02870902791619301,
0.06600461155176163,
-0.14688630402088165,
0.43803462386131287,
0.1699749082326889,
0.024560460820794106,
0.042884912341833115,
-0.10960333049297333,
-0.14788241684436798,
-0.18869486451148987,
0.19900000095367432,
0.0521705187857151,
0.4505380392074585,
0.0517737939953804,
-0.3999636769294739,
-0.846929132938385,
0.43790748715400696,
0.878704309463501,
-0.3161470293998718,
0.5825995206832886,
1.0364972352981567,
-0.497702956199646,
-0.3305990695953369,
-0.3994154930114746,
-0.1730957329273224,
-0.4739014506340027,
0.28154468536376953,
0.2854121923446655,
-0.7190430760383606,
0.3825633227825165,
0.12656956911087036,
-0.18274830281734467,
0.4999997913837433,
0.5006830096244812,
-0.04602065682411194,
1.0353573560714722,
0.6106607913970947,
-0.40127187967300415,
0.6778108477592468,
0.056718673557043076,
0.3917793929576874,
-0.38603535294532776,
-0.24813129007816315,
-0.8532553911209106,
-0.1622781902551651,
-0.8928743600845337,
0.08749459683895111,
0.35268762707710266,
-0.4529739022254944,
-0.1428205370903015,
0.019353751093149185,
-0.4711676836013794,
0.42005300521850586,
0.9954357147216797,
-0.004562571179121733,
0.4833028018474579,
-0.0010839594760909677,
0.27871468663215637,
0.3413622975349426,
-0.13160543143749237,
-0.7313205599784851,
1.0253372192382812,
0.23350892961025238,
0.5067841410636902,
-0.0772242322564125,
0.5883609056472778,
1.019932508468628,
0.3963187336921692,
-0.672635555267334,
0.6254982948303223,
-0.14870265126228333,
-0.6274787187576294,
-0.3154695928096771,
-0.32553479075431824,
-0.8957365155220032,
-0.37919899821281433,
-0.6227900385856628,
-0.6286076903343201,
-0.38695859909057617,
0.06322900205850601,
0.07110516726970673,
0.31047317385673523,
-0.5669460296630859,
0.3872781991958618,
-0.3346562683582306,
-0.10892430692911148,
-0.21546582877635956,
-0.4564320743083954,
0.11856284737586975,
-0.14678990840911865,
0.15638720989227295,
-0.18441668152809143,
0.11295165121555328,
0.7968249320983887,
0.14445467293262482,
0.6898478269577026,
0.08677957952022552,
-0.17597635090351105,
0.5896901488304138,
-0.07531864196062088,
0.7022772431373596,
-0.08753364533185959,
0.09232350438833237,
0.27204155921936035,
-0.3592785894870758,
-0.049719177186489105,
-0.21588824689388275,
0.469032347202301,
-0.7887532114982605,
-0.4635106921195984,
-0.6863149404525757,
-0.5363619923591614,
0.06487303972244263,
0.4045671820640564,
0.7004960775375366,
0.30868637561798096,
-0.3402588665485382,
0.15767359733581543,
0.63507080078125,
-0.35705599188804626,
0.5788468718528748,
0.07802174240350723,
-0.008504640311002731,
-0.26570695638656616,
0.9658454060554504,
0.026469232514500618,
-0.30734941363334656,
0.3131556510925293,
0.15166589617729187,
-0.26063859462738037,
-1.0202699899673462,
-0.45134440064430237,
0.08251146972179413,
-0.575194239616394,
-0.20168322324752808,
-0.30758506059646606,
-0.5701009035110474,
-0.11709015816450119,
-0.027942942455410957,
-0.04936153441667557,
0.04944010451436043,
-0.8267633318901062,
0.0171868484467268,
0.3789060413837433,
1.0237376689910889,
0.23236019909381866,
0.5082612037658691,
-0.6405118703842163,
0.4193976819515228,
0.22685398161411285,
0.35362493991851807,
-0.10343578457832336,
-0.2821976840496063,
-0.06396511942148209,
0.03337860107421875,
-0.19025737047195435,
-0.7217987775802612,
0.3500863015651703,
-0.04121996462345123,
0.5779680013656616,
0.36615729331970215,
0.048629265278577805,
-0.0010904616210609674,
-0.2465948760509491,
0.9174937605857849,
-0.11858196556568146,
-1.0441627502441406,
0.4399868845939636,
-0.42481398582458496,
-0.017013145610690117,
0.38083046674728394,
0.2758874297142029,
-0.3632107377052307,
-0.5001285672187805,
-0.531856119632721,
-0.6879699230194092,
0.2933919429779053,
0.5407959818840027,
0.1885560005903244,
0.1341005563735962,
0.4967089891433716,
0.017349829897284508,
0.23310889303684235,
-0.6979607343673706,
-0.2728482782840729,
0.06385282427072525,
-0.4500064551830292,
-0.006787704769521952,
-0.09621381014585495,
0.11801674962043762,
0.21495798230171204,
0.6538079380989075,
-0.08904621005058289,
0.34714454412460327,
0.03354683145880699,
-0.15513424575328827,
0.07236213237047195,
0.1830569952726364,
0.73313969373703,
0.40825480222702026,
0.059990353882312775,
0.04130730405449867,
-0.25522375106811523,
-0.7734353542327881,
0.2548710107803345,
0.021751772612333298,
-0.5428069829940796,
-0.11584929376840591,
0.8526543378829956,
0.5236862897872925,
-0.609017550945282,
-0.7124024629592896,
0.6409953832626343,
-0.3285994529724121,
-0.2957186996936798,
-0.5704812407493591,
0.24788397550582886,
-0.25296393036842346,
0.31611350178718567,
0.5041286945343018,
0.13650281727313995,
0.11850260943174362,
-0.5691160559654236,
0.17882545292377472,
0.7445366978645325,
-0.20873595774173737,
-0.32584747672080994,
0.7303069829940796,
0.2897493243217468,
-0.5545461177825928,
0.812298059463501,
-0.0805051252245903,
-0.7598791122436523,
0.7531790137290955,
0.5165162682533264,
1.0069900751113892,
0.018223853781819344,
0.19911697506904602,
-0.08081553131341934,
0.5391179919242859,
-0.10779621452093124,
0.15255384147167206,
0.2583796977996826,
-0.9995835423469543,
-0.022853955626487732,
-0.2589772939682007,
-0.5390123128890991,
0.31563684344291687,
-0.45188575983047485,
0.14554230868816376,
-0.4548860490322113,
-0.34527915716171265,
0.05021839588880539,
-0.015963153913617134,
-0.6578906774520874,
0.267650306224823,
0.3895854353904724,
0.6830763816833496,
-1.0782909393310547,
0.5524498820304871,
0.616517186164856,
-0.08532621711492538,
-0.38741934299468994,
0.40083959698677063,
0.43311986327171326,
-0.9637359976768494,
0.15427829325199127,
0.1656595915555954,
-0.2247994989156723,
0.1056990921497345,
-0.9505621194839478,
-0.5028657913208008,
0.9789012670516968,
0.2511139512062073,
-0.2134535163640976,
0.07015885412693024,
0.19305981695652008,
0.6112534403800964,
-0.11081932485103607,
0.22308212518692017,
0.746321439743042,
0.7283651828765869,
-0.2868577539920807,
-0.6811386942863464,
-0.06567800790071487,
-0.23752224445343018,
-0.19269105792045593,
0.2322143018245697,
-0.6283355951309204,
0.6091213226318359,
0.15406236052513123,
-0.24911628663539886,
0.23767659068107605,
0.6662389636039734,
0.26859480142593384,
0.6646957993507385,
0.413299024105072,
0.2807838022708893,
0.8632381558418274,
-0.2643224895000458,
0.799117922782898,
-0.26277685165405273,
0.08837773650884628,
0.4304020404815674,
-0.23530437052249908,
0.6033470630645752,
0.24033372104167938,
0.03858694061636925,
0.4452318847179413,
0.4903038442134857,
-0.32054194808006287,
0.22217968106269836,
0.17929717898368835,
-0.355124831199646,
-0.15731804072856903,
-0.35306042432785034,
-0.15746484696865082,
0.9169800877571106,
0.39005836844444275,
-0.5504602193832397,
0.2688216269016266,
-0.022048013284802437,
0.14031125605106354,
0.27502477169036865,
-0.26872947812080383,
0.9366694092750549,
-0.12695097923278809,
-0.7155306935310364,
0.07782454788684845,
0.15806370973587036,
0.846747636795044,
-0.35674768686294556,
-0.09783803671598434,
-0.307779997587204,
0.07410354912281036,
-0.10833486914634705,
-0.982309103012085,
0.19753830134868622,
0.28219446539878845,
-0.21153582632541656,
-0.30733469128608704,
1.1138547658920288,
-0.22682371735572815,
-0.37219077348709106,
0.10855516791343689,
0.8436452150344849,
0.0024832007475197315,
-0.08667264133691788,
-0.37083378434181213,
0.17486530542373657,
0.09297969192266464,
-0.3445685803890228,
0.24834196269512177,
0.4500467777252197,
-0.05244363099336624,
0.8965238928794861,
0.5778787732124329,
0.039611075073480606,
-0.13618826866149902,
-0.20943427085876465,
0.504334032535553,
-0.6887775659561157,
-0.2824799418449402,
-0.9719891548156738,
0.19250606000423431,
-0.09965550899505615,
-0.2488989531993866,
0.6965708136558533,
0.2965514063835144,
0.7379806637763977,
0.13309550285339355,
1.41337251663208,
0.0342026948928833,
0.2493673712015152,
-0.5457518100738525,
1.224008321762085,
-0.45166873931884766,
0.2787320017814636,
-0.2665749490261078,
-0.7899211049079895,
-0.3471187353134155,
0.46796393394470215,
0.1363440304994583,
0.20476345717906952,
0.5198930501937866,
0.46055588126182556,
0.12317614257335663,
0.17596037685871124,
0.041342440992593765,
-0.061501745134592056,
0.518419623374939,
0.12971870601177216,
1.134606122970581,
-0.2689360976219177,
0.5996236801147461,
0.1292026787996292,
-0.16690059006214142,
-0.15990935266017914,
-1.2006115913391113,
-0.9257296919822693,
-0.7422100901603699,
-0.4581748843193054,
-0.29319778084754944,
-0.05188416689634323,
0.6084997653961182,
0.4109257459640503,
-0.8139796257019043,
0.046213891357183456,
-0.1985844373703003,
0.3458341956138611,
-0.05153392255306244,
-0.16683761775493622,
0.48854440450668335,
0.21499192714691162,
-0.7708690166473389,
0.21258357167243958,
0.06439457833766937,
0.48180192708969116,
-0.29446789622306824,
0.221429705619812,
0.03615764155983925,
0.3521726727485657,
0.46148213744163513,
0.2473168969154358,
-0.7549412250518799,
-0.6745361089706421,
0.02637837827205658,
-0.24103493988513947,
-0.051001764833927155,
0.7767539024353027,
-0.5309998989105225,
0.23958785831928253,
0.6638102531433105,
0.7189301252365112,
0.10139267146587372,
0.14721205830574036,
0.42942577600479126,
-0.8035308122634888,
-0.24940769374370575,
0.14713406562805176,
0.3199913799762726,
0.3850805461406708,
-0.5875400304794312,
0.4504759907722473,
0.39327067136764526,
-0.8918331265449524,
-0.6586588621139526,
0.18552489578723907,
-0.6301260590553284,
-0.20592056214809418,
1.2041828632354736,
-0.11847466975450516,
0.053211066871881485,
-0.2802644968032837,
-0.2397436648607254,
0.3556310832500458,
-0.3294561207294464,
0.8852974772453308,
0.8539451956748962,
-0.1744321584701538,
-0.09683607518672943,
-0.320552259683609,
0.6112991571426392,
-0.048959095031023026,
-1.1638150215148926,
0.08437542617321014,
0.5845709443092346,
0.20811815559864044,
0.10049666464328766,
0.5062961578369141,
0.22668427228927612,
0.12842755019664764,
-0.03704264014959335,
-0.1704513132572174,
-0.18026196956634521,
-0.5049015879631042,
-0.10923761874437332,
0.11949766427278519,
0.14807383716106415,
0.08609917759895325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15576v1 | Contrastive Entity Coreference and Disambiguation for Historical Texts | 2024-06-21T18:22:14 | 2024-06-21T18:22:14 | Abhishek Arora, Emily Silcock, Leander Heldring, Melissa Dell | cs.CL | cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | Massive-scale historical document collections are crucial for social science
research. Despite increasing digitization, these documents typically lack
unique cross-document identifiers for individuals mentioned within the texts,
as well as individual identifiers from external knowledgebases like
Wikipedia/Wikidata. Existing entity disambiguation methods often fall short in
accuracy for historical documents, which are replete with individuals not
remembered in contemporary knowledgebases. This study makes three key
contributions to improve cross-document coreference resolution and
disambiguation in historical texts: a massive-scale training dataset replete
with hard negatives - that sources over 190 million entity pairs from Wikipedia
contexts and disambiguation pages - high-quality evaluation data from
hand-labeled historical newswire articles, and trained models evaluated on this
historical benchmark. We contrastively train bi-encoder models for
coreferencing and disambiguating individuals in historical texts, achieving
accurate, scalable performance that identifies out-of-knowledgebase
individuals. Our approach significantly surpasses other entity disambiguation
models on our historical newswire benchmark. Our models also demonstrate
competitive performance on modern entity disambiguation benchmarks,
particularly certain news disambiguation datasets. | [
-0.6348504424095154,
-0.3987366259098053,
0.5234531164169312,
-0.3738781213760376,
-0.39939117431640625,
0.2891187369823456,
-0.4889066517353058,
-0.5394482612609863,
0.15113751590251923,
0.20559662580490112,
-0.1713915318250656,
-0.4469863772392273,
-0.6471157073974609,
0.32366958260536194,
-0.509327232837677,
0.9433386921882629,
-0.10499007999897003,
0.39827752113342285,
-0.4019203186035156,
-0.46595263481140137,
-0.017292797565460205,
-0.7106075882911682,
-0.26430320739746094,
-0.6174777150154114,
0.4921942353248596,
0.3569522798061371,
0.6733523607254028,
0.669662594795227,
0.3876061737537384,
0.2799568176269531,
-0.23537364602088928,
0.24807953834533691,
-0.5882723331451416,
0.036639779806137085,
-0.8475832343101501,
-0.20886759459972382,
-0.1487060934305191,
-0.002606552094221115,
0.5098131895065308,
0.8120938539505005,
0.3977212607860565,
0.27990299463272095,
0.1458122432231903,
0.6686643958091736,
-0.5855870246887207,
0.18260625004768372,
-0.6833961009979248,
-0.2789399027824402,
-0.5168556571006775,
-0.2667612135410309,
-0.3572656512260437,
-0.27973315119743347,
0.1596764773130417,
-0.7154260277748108,
0.8396315574645996,
0.04102236032485962,
1.0457346439361572,
-0.04199524596333504,
-0.40842071175575256,
-0.2656308710575104,
-0.6801140308380127,
0.5925041437149048,
-0.5005112886428833,
0.4615596830844879,
0.36029380559921265,
-0.06920371204614639,
0.22855955362319946,
-0.5667882561683655,
-0.5476292967796326,
0.024795861914753914,
-0.30902841687202454,
-0.22526653110980988,
-0.06216252222657204,
-0.1631515473127365,
0.4126390218734741,
0.4289019703865051,
-0.4671512842178345,
0.3440714180469513,
-0.5238080024719238,
-0.22294047474861145,
0.3707740008831024,
0.1074366346001625,
-0.04972057044506073,
-0.4130440950393677,
-0.09671582281589508,
-0.049457572400569916,
-0.7612717747688293,
-0.1484679877758026,
0.5346000790596008,
0.35335323214530945,
0.19515131413936615,
0.45728617906570435,
-0.3578399121761322,
0.29440298676490784,
0.6621829867362976,
-0.2896266579627991,
0.509276270866394,
-0.4702865183353424,
0.05243368446826935,
0.1284395009279251,
0.3782643675804138,
0.6007259488105774,
0.2846590280532837,
-0.5781173706054688,
0.28677165508270264,
0.15394409000873566,
0.14313215017318726,
-0.8096897602081299,
-0.28127774596214294,
-0.10832914710044861,
-0.4688889682292938,
0.26522669196128845,
0.028529532253742218,
-0.8111891746520996,
-0.6232211589813232,
-0.5756314992904663,
0.23594360053539276,
-0.5641441941261292,
-0.14230354130268097,
-0.3672057092189789,
-0.5918478965759277,
-0.049240339547395706,
0.32032448053359985,
-0.8410601019859314,
0.08655792474746704,
0.4951344430446625,
0.7293715476989746,
-0.06509223580360413,
-0.4491986036300659,
-0.09587167203426361,
0.3881945312023163,
-0.10298991948366165,
0.6345759034156799,
-0.5394651293754578,
-0.47939568758010864,
-0.1402660310268402,
0.004066274967044592,
0.496783971786499,
-0.5754067897796631,
0.7009309530258179,
-0.35871416330337524,
-0.06720048934221268,
-0.6926620602607727,
-0.6053860783576965,
-0.09673673659563065,
0.21940718591213226,
-0.7513523697853088,
0.8404495716094971,
0.14072628319263458,
-1.089288592338562,
0.5528220534324646,
0.1192876473069191,
-0.5495617389678955,
0.04760759323835373,
-0.47494325041770935,
-0.3223465383052826,
-0.06776978820562363,
0.43186840415000916,
0.44161257147789,
-0.4830666482448578,
0.330856055021286,
-0.5150362253189087,
-0.41636836528778076,
-0.2504813075065613,
-0.00984227005392313,
0.8072459101676941,
-0.13761910796165466,
-0.4169534146785736,
-0.3131936490535736,
-0.652506411075592,
-0.5832666754722595,
0.09579102694988251,
-0.17667639255523682,
-1.0093202590942383,
-0.14694613218307495,
-0.1152857318520546,
-0.10559000819921494,
0.22184689342975616,
-0.5465002059936523,
0.009503934532403946,
-0.06157253310084343,
0.2800644040107727,
0.49619218707084656,
-0.046889424324035645,
0.6768311262130737,
-0.25856509804725647,
-0.19879214465618134,
0.23671160638332367,
0.013044603168964386,
-0.2072415053844452,
-0.09011450409889221,
-0.5799721479415894,
-0.014608794823288918,
0.42596086859703064,
0.28717049956321716,
-0.7087947130203247,
0.41366344690322876,
-0.627775251865387,
-0.7363749742507935,
-0.20976443588733673,
0.09984789043664932,
0.24303124845027924,
0.9305626153945923,
0.7247611880302429,
-0.2666875422000885,
-0.9389007091522217,
-1.0245188474655151,
-0.19013023376464844,
-0.4835525155067444,
-0.18367940187454224,
0.2605176866054535,
0.540194034576416,
-0.135899618268013,
0.8636541366577148,
-0.10566696524620056,
-0.10227750241756439,
0.333074152469635,
0.28454896807670593,
0.06496898829936981,
0.446483850479126,
0.5443646907806396,
-1.1410102844238281,
-0.22501681745052338,
0.07216757535934448,
-0.5914082527160645,
0.18729275465011597,
-0.08969590067863464,
-0.260532021522522,
-0.044955216348171234,
0.4081208407878876,
-0.4812473952770233,
0.31521016359329224,
0.20750084519386292,
-0.11534115672111511,
0.3539915084838867,
0.05730755627155304,
0.6502735018730164,
-1.0957998037338257,
0.26942986249923706,
0.13019399344921112,
-0.10387421399354935,
-0.2719895541667938,
-0.20576848089694977,
0.3928031325340271,
0.054676979780197144,
-0.31744346022605896,
0.4120852053165436,
-0.8858094215393066,
0.11160275340080261,
0.2032768577337265,
0.606695294380188,
-0.00310335261747241,
0.3929878771305084,
0.17159080505371094,
0.35368236899375916,
0.28167176246643066,
-0.5855603814125061,
0.5071904063224792,
0.38354307413101196,
-0.26646459102630615,
1.133989930152893,
-0.17120996117591858,
0.05345042422413826,
-0.3567677438259125,
0.4942294657230377,
-0.6911054849624634,
0.13325746357440948,
-0.037516940385103226,
-0.4616626799106598,
0.4928331673145294,
-0.2530151605606079,
-0.3849199116230011,
-0.30945447087287903,
-0.40674909949302673,
0.396628737449646,
0.25393563508987427,
-0.7285811305046082,
0.6354629397392273,
0.43558257818222046,
-0.14886000752449036,
-0.7804475426673889,
-0.7358832955360413,
0.22781892120838165,
-0.23893383145332336,
-0.4461381435394287,
0.796777606010437,
0.089073546230793,
-0.19848847389221191,
0.33700427412986755,
-0.33872750401496887,
-0.1692856103181839,
-0.11951716244220734,
0.40738344192504883,
0.49476200342178345,
-0.17984725534915924,
0.5504030585289001,
0.17671075463294983,
0.03591734915971756,
-0.2552783489227295,
0.008472778834402561,
0.32923007011413574,
0.0941273495554924,
-0.2505240738391876,
0.14190123975276947,
0.4813717305660248,
0.38372188806533813,
-0.1687784343957901,
0.825959324836731,
0.5893812775611877,
-0.635486900806427,
0.19659578800201416,
-0.9877751469612122,
-0.21046367287635803,
-0.31126856803894043,
0.301584392786026,
-0.21730858087539673,
-0.7885938882827759,
0.4394606649875641,
-0.15074343979358673,
0.3078477680683136,
0.7043403387069702,
0.5450624823570251,
-0.06952471286058426,
0.17372360825538635,
0.010059504769742489,
-0.30092164874076843,
0.49791857600212097,
0.003837866010144353,
0.006438312120735645,
-0.8333818316459656,
-0.11365652084350586,
-0.9312307834625244,
-0.4279000759124756,
-0.4261338412761688,
-0.2999536097049713,
0.04214872792363167,
0.20439285039901733,
-0.41453099250793457,
0.4729805886745453,
-0.2908226549625397,
0.38545483350753784,
0.4466637372970581,
0.3783057630062103,
0.692441463470459,
-0.13736097514629364,
0.13517342507839203,
-0.19182634353637695,
-0.3114226162433624,
-0.5543818473815918,
1.1298807859420776,
0.022617770358920097,
0.8575730323791504,
0.09031535685062408,
0.8235684633255005,
0.46822547912597656,
0.4282877743244171,
-0.4196135997772217,
0.24843081831932068,
-0.3138505816459656,
-0.7939397096633911,
-0.2568987011909485,
-0.4411524832248688,
-0.7675930261611938,
0.01581600308418274,
-0.31797662377357483,
-0.5516005754470825,
0.6164214611053467,
0.2458377629518509,
-0.3569403290748596,
0.3429500460624695,
-0.5654982328414917,
0.7767971158027649,
0.0066730123944580555,
-0.2350618690252304,
-0.21684284508228302,
-0.676807701587677,
0.05581402778625488,
-0.005506628658622503,
0.03368815779685974,
-0.060756586492061615,
-0.04319622740149498,
0.4961201846599579,
0.07643741369247437,
0.8603630065917969,
0.057264164090156555,
0.3103860318660736,
0.1481039673089981,
-0.06267742812633514,
0.6260887980461121,
0.013501686975359917,
-0.1471332311630249,
0.4958207309246063,
-0.03347116336226463,
-0.5287047624588013,
-0.2538820803165436,
0.8839207887649536,
-0.7017069458961487,
-0.6049098968505859,
0.04300522431731224,
-0.25326311588287354,
-0.13712362945079803,
0.023001205176115036,
0.5000567436218262,
0.5778276920318604,
-0.5455607175827026,
0.5546934604644775,
0.7834926843643188,
0.3194772005081177,
0.35998770594596863,
0.4823245406150818,
0.4298182725906372,
-0.17367994785308838,
0.5081966519355774,
0.5496461391448975,
-0.05504431948065758,
0.635189414024353,
-0.20318244397640228,
-0.3554988205432892,
-0.5957788825035095,
-0.7174606323242188,
0.33346569538116455,
-0.9205840826034546,
-0.4492763578891754,
-0.6912532448768616,
0.09517496824264526,
-0.7147192358970642,
-0.384418249130249,
-0.18119266629219055,
-0.3038720190525055,
-0.6586236953735352,
-0.32329514622688293,
0.2240714579820633,
0.18742652237415314,
0.0058057126589119434,
-0.14119847118854523,
-0.700310230255127,
0.3664326071739197,
0.03555712476372719,
0.03744611144065857,
0.045476119965314865,
-0.45609474182128906,
-0.45002618432044983,
-0.19532814621925354,
-0.022936081513762474,
-1.2795969247817993,
-0.14320626854896545,
0.05186200141906738,
0.8723738789558411,
0.2643326222896576,
0.44597679376602173,
0.7823441028594971,
-0.6715862154960632,
0.6792377829551697,
0.18639889359474182,
-0.9041190147399902,
0.3583022952079773,
-0.05436601862311363,
0.11227579414844513,
0.7952564358711243,
0.7129747271537781,
-0.6543205976486206,
-0.19708921015262604,
-0.5572872757911682,
-0.9638474583625793,
0.19270694255828857,
-0.17013712227344513,
-0.02604781650006771,
-0.1570763885974884,
0.5645824670791626,
0.3978313207626343,
0.05008320510387421,
-0.40881526470184326,
-0.2721846401691437,
-0.32111841440200806,
-0.11831116676330566,
-0.2278602421283722,
-0.09888196736574173,
-0.14129941165447235,
-0.03965364024043083,
0.9137825965881348,
-0.0996510237455368,
-0.28092247247695923,
0.4351496398448944,
-0.6042553782463074,
-0.043780531734228134,
0.4598301947116852,
0.08561587333679199,
0.8903079032897949,
-0.00805960688740015,
0.4605685770511627,
0.519471287727356,
-0.36934420466423035,
0.0055756825022399426,
0.45133328437805176,
-0.2528943121433258,
0.43225333094596863,
0.28863582015037537,
0.6496595740318298,
0.3654943108558655,
-0.511911153793335,
0.37454625964164734,
0.1473161280155182,
0.23778674006462097,
-0.3935159742832184,
-0.25605159997940063,
0.20787398517131805,
0.695792555809021,
0.7543272972106934,
-0.16287975013256073,
0.10286922752857208,
-0.4817656874656677,
0.011025710962712765,
0.2552866041660309,
-0.09051626175642014,
-0.09891872107982635,
0.3525678217411041,
0.5405349731445312,
-0.15028239786624908,
0.6156789064407349,
0.13784338533878326,
-0.2600767910480499,
0.26643455028533936,
0.22066715359687805,
0.5480107069015503,
-0.09662036597728729,
0.041612282395362854,
0.7448980212211609,
0.29807049036026,
-0.3372077941894531,
-0.4704044461250305,
-0.2669115662574768,
-0.746947169303894,
-0.12586720287799835,
-0.39536282420158386,
-0.5766185522079468,
-0.009321967139840126,
-0.8492605090141296,
0.3639950752258301,
-0.17605172097682953,
-0.5177302956581116,
0.1398043930530548,
0.1613788604736328,
-1.010656476020813,
0.171115443110466,
0.11523396521806717,
0.8114062547683716,
-0.8703701496124268,
0.7172401547431946,
0.6504205465316772,
-0.5642436146736145,
-0.3044883608818054,
-0.13284792006015778,
0.1602482795715332,
-0.1954004168510437,
0.42844435572624207,
-0.16397246718406677,
0.06861767172813416,
0.057575471699237823,
-0.11524442583322525,
-0.47931304574012756,
1.3557639122009277,
0.5404454469680786,
-1.077492117881775,
-0.6192663908004761,
-0.30939722061157227,
0.4862736463546753,
-0.15421424806118011,
0.26973411440849304,
0.5953164100646973,
0.4590179920196533,
-0.22946570813655853,
-0.8596953749656677,
0.11525638401508331,
-0.07574918866157532,
0.0028291442431509495,
0.4104105234146118,
-0.4394676983356476,
0.741679310798645,
0.0015006582252681255,
-0.5555266737937927,
0.0877213105559349,
0.945676863193512,
-0.03309919312596321,
0.3056158423423767,
0.46015337109565735,
0.5797317624092102,
0.7854810357093811,
-0.29070958495140076,
0.7499226331710815,
-0.10914073139429092,
0.4628846347332001,
1.479232668876648,
-0.12956279516220093,
0.6149255633354187,
0.7422598600387573,
-0.18551304936408997,
0.30468448996543884,
0.8377506136894226,
-0.16166357696056366,
0.11399247497320175,
-0.11363137513399124,
-0.28273239731788635,
-0.2036285549402237,
-0.13736633956432343,
-0.5719924569129944,
-0.19861842691898346,
0.20336949825286865,
-0.6619364619255066,
-0.43637794256210327,
-0.10287486016750336,
0.352501779794693,
0.33599036931991577,
-0.48926931619644165,
0.4620213210582733,
-0.1890113800764084,
-0.43922159075737,
0.13132800161838531,
-0.12425971776247025,
0.7764861583709717,
-0.4747603237628937,
0.14706511795520782,
-0.516151487827301,
0.2233715057373047,
-0.19727300107479095,
-0.6525152325630188,
0.14367496967315674,
0.0015872070798650384,
-0.50005704164505,
0.1474057286977768,
0.5762297511100769,
-0.5308952927589417,
-0.0799679085612297,
0.322997123003006,
0.46965935826301575,
-0.012352373450994492,
-0.005580552853643894,
-0.26443949341773987,
-0.02563891001045704,
-0.18494154512882233,
-0.15573535859584808,
0.3011723458766937,
0.5631511807441711,
-0.11742424219846725,
-0.05652320384979248,
0.452059805393219,
-0.08558645099401474,
-0.09691083431243896,
0.15412546694278717,
0.9522193074226379,
-0.6330693364143372,
-0.25602132081985474,
-0.9916205406188965,
0.19677181541919708,
-0.3004548251628876,
-0.5131134986877441,
0.7931380271911621,
0.6448877453804016,
1.4107227325439453,
0.1007973849773407,
0.5467543005943298,
-0.11421454697847366,
0.7115136981010437,
-0.16007496416568756,
0.36118951439857483,
-0.2915859520435333,
-0.08486922085285187,
-0.32079818844795227,
-0.6661859750747681,
-0.0817963257431984,
0.27441415190696716,
-0.16427356004714966,
-0.12771540880203247,
0.4754694998264313,
0.6086469888687134,
-0.015645382925868034,
-0.07445494085550308,
0.22095897793769836,
0.11781179159879684,
0.11954503506422043,
0.2920837104320526,
0.6264114379882812,
-0.27304112911224365,
0.734898567199707,
-0.3615296185016632,
-0.031106628477573395,
-0.36356478929519653,
-0.8465554118156433,
-1.0733425617218018,
-0.9774107933044434,
-0.3378811180591583,
-0.5289409160614014,
0.42545467615127563,
0.932823896408081,
0.584138035774231,
-0.6825920343399048,
0.10427093505859375,
0.5641123652458191,
0.12293726950883865,
-0.23201897740364075,
-0.15023404359817505,
0.3854871094226837,
0.19356544315814972,
-1.0262560844421387,
0.043233949691057205,
0.19646963477134705,
-0.03972247987985611,
-0.4218747317790985,
-0.11735044419765472,
-0.27429085969924927,
-0.03306826576590538,
0.3596660792827606,
0.2892433702945709,
-0.7312630414962769,
-0.516907811164856,
-0.3724135458469391,
-0.4630219638347626,
0.28012752532958984,
1.2140332460403442,
-0.7955979108810425,
0.31025269627571106,
0.6277362704277039,
0.8868248462677002,
0.7722293734550476,
0.3382093608379364,
-0.017884764820337296,
-0.6955184936523438,
0.1636752486228943,
0.31472232937812805,
0.5052072405815125,
0.7218682169914246,
-0.4998317062854767,
0.5676699876785278,
0.6456041932106018,
-0.3065890073776245,
-0.540543794631958,
-0.018045857548713684,
-0.9405638575553894,
-0.46141186356544495,
0.9072226881980896,
-0.2988593578338623,
-0.15592016279697418,
-0.4217860698699951,
-0.1231178417801857,
0.5269538164138794,
-0.5657083988189697,
0.7351268529891968,
0.8592790365219116,
0.1378316432237625,
-0.2395160049200058,
-0.007750845048576593,
0.02421877160668373,
-0.04597661644220352,
-0.700305700302124,
-0.017907656729221344,
0.8119558095932007,
0.24484021961688995,
0.48443493247032166,
0.4420643746852875,
-0.2018822282552719,
0.24777932465076447,
0.34710606932640076,
0.3032475411891937,
-0.2391180545091629,
-0.049053214490413666,
0.1645982712507248,
0.24019628763198853,
-0.24555905163288116,
0.041749004274606705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15570v1 | DEM: Distribution Edited Model for Training with Mixed Data Distributions | 2024-06-21T18:07:46 | 2024-06-21T18:07:46 | Dhananjay Ram, Aditya Rawal, Momchil Hardalov, Nikolaos Pappas, Sheng Zha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Training with mixed data distributions is a common and important part of
creating multi-task and instruction-following models. The diversity of the data
distributions and cost of joint training makes the optimization procedure
extremely challenging. Data mixing methods partially address this problem,
albeit having a sub-optimal performance across data sources and require
multiple expensive training runs. In this paper, we propose a simple and
efficient alternative for better optimization of the data sources by combining
models individually trained on each data source with the base model using basic
element-wise vector operations. The resulting model, namely Distribution Edited
Model (DEM), is 11x cheaper than standard data mixing and outperforms strong
baselines on a variety of benchmarks, yielding up to 6.2% improvement on MMLU,
11.5% on BBH, 16.1% on DROP, and 9.3% on HELM with models of size 3B to 13B.
Notably, DEM does not require full re-training when modifying a single
data-source, thus making it very flexible and scalable for training with
diverse data sources. | [
-0.7540102601051331,
-0.4865180552005768,
0.22155313193798065,
-0.11153876781463623,
-0.6311967968940735,
0.02429085597395897,
0.000014933956663298886,
-0.2984638810157776,
0.1308513730764389,
0.49602562189102173,
-0.8877531886100769,
-0.5089359283447266,
-0.4698103964328766,
-0.015790332108736038,
-0.40714603662490845,
0.7138563990592957,
-0.057392846792936325,
0.4347958266735077,
-0.03593231737613678,
-0.4117043912410736,
-0.35084810853004456,
-0.41804054379463196,
-0.2825005352497101,
-0.2995346188545227,
0.43969959020614624,
0.26732081174850464,
0.8091034293174744,
1.0196706056594849,
0.6901799440383911,
0.2893883287906647,
-0.15557634830474854,
0.49307945370674133,
-0.726276695728302,
0.14011526107788086,
-0.23747025430202484,
-0.2241269201040268,
-0.4869977533817291,
-0.061845697462558746,
0.5466317534446716,
1.096778154373169,
-0.2996872067451477,
-0.026269856840372086,
-0.0959511399269104,
0.7921246290206909,
-1.2004426717758179,
-0.3142607510089874,
-0.4520307183265686,
0.003273904090747237,
-0.08671190589666367,
-0.10271050781011581,
-0.25020381808280945,
-0.1082707941532135,
-0.02467745915055275,
-0.5661399960517883,
0.41907212138175964,
-0.18669167160987854,
0.3136400878429413,
0.5227283835411072,
-0.485444039106369,
-0.0006352761993184686,
-0.9068686962127686,
0.7400168776512146,
-0.3334900438785553,
0.871539294719696,
0.11349641531705856,
0.36143237352371216,
0.09174807369709015,
-0.6307010054588318,
-0.514670729637146,
0.289408415555954,
0.30049437284469604,
0.38203608989715576,
-0.17251861095428467,
0.26283904910087585,
0.15334145724773407,
0.3873383402824402,
-0.17159909009933472,
-0.01052479725331068,
-0.2376101166009903,
0.05223090574145317,
0.6645542979240417,
0.599577009677887,
0.1604718267917633,
-0.06431847810745239,
-0.40355122089385986,
-0.611789882183075,
-0.512968122959137,
-0.2557029128074646,
0.7753738164901733,
0.45114216208457947,
-0.38603463768959045,
0.7661781311035156,
-0.4712699353694916,
0.8574618697166443,
-0.09552629292011261,
-0.09571800380945206,
0.263644814491272,
-0.5678348541259766,
-0.31567373871803284,
-0.3416851758956909,
0.09587117284536362,
0.549321711063385,
-0.24396149814128876,
0.17117667198181152,
-0.6209337115287781,
0.10580865293741226,
0.2982352375984192,
-0.8439677953720093,
-0.6483169198036194,
0.2583152651786804,
-0.3541233539581299,
-0.36364346742630005,
0.020328113809227943,
-0.808618426322937,
-0.48500674962997437,
-0.7128402590751648,
0.3641324043273926,
-0.3932570517063141,
-0.14535404741764069,
0.41311371326446533,
-0.3216458559036255,
-0.2763095796108246,
0.7900466322898865,
-0.7905216217041016,
0.43195411562919617,
0.5475064516067505,
0.7519667148590088,
-0.1813625544309616,
-0.14002394676208496,
-0.5110300779342651,
0.1524461805820465,
-0.514657199382782,
0.5997107028961182,
-0.6550178527832031,
-0.5854887366294861,
-0.3785962462425232,
-0.583260178565979,
-0.15994301438331604,
-0.5070480108261108,
0.3671911060810089,
-0.3750065565109253,
-0.01960732415318489,
-0.11914964020252228,
-0.6957302093505859,
-0.14814643561840057,
-0.04790036752820015,
-0.8703029751777649,
1.1169824600219727,
0.5865375995635986,
-1.3959124088287354,
0.5705057978630066,
-0.43834131956100464,
-0.09495510160923004,
-0.17220023274421692,
0.1897919476032257,
-0.5304973125457764,
0.033048711717128754,
0.6044070720672607,
0.21777752041816711,
-0.22524094581604004,
-0.040556665509939194,
-0.5937342047691345,
-0.3317263722419739,
-0.2590909004211426,
-0.41369694471359253,
0.7858565449714661,
0.2527945339679718,
0.009975353255867958,
0.09379979223012924,
-1.0765405893325806,
-0.26414385437965393,
-0.07706901431083679,
-0.5216255187988281,
-0.7361535429954529,
-0.1679825633764267,
0.1854507178068161,
-0.02954435907304287,
-0.12070492655038834,
-0.30742910504341125,
0.33001425862312317,
-0.36829933524131775,
-0.294231116771698,
0.8180024027824402,
0.35046863555908203,
0.7325294613838196,
-0.2487916350364685,
0.6247295141220093,
0.38271039724349976,
0.3195982277393341,
0.146686851978302,
-0.18284635245800018,
-0.6238085627555847,
-0.8055124282836914,
0.597004771232605,
0.4312121272087097,
-0.8295360803604126,
0.3838273882865906,
-0.12152734398841858,
-0.77150958776474,
-0.738591194152832,
0.16031765937805176,
-0.1952628791332245,
0.3780283033847809,
0.3794909417629242,
-0.24985234439373016,
-0.6096592545509338,
-0.6388323903083801,
0.1797151118516922,
0.30745136737823486,
0.11321704089641571,
0.19173814356327057,
0.511362612247467,
-0.5442260503768921,
1.085844874382019,
-0.7298195362091064,
0.23901090025901794,
-0.5148636698722839,
-0.011925491504371166,
-0.06055392697453499,
0.3063739240169525,
0.7817500829696655,
-0.5526367425918579,
-0.4533767104148865,
0.01498988177627325,
-0.37858420610427856,
-0.2612970769405365,
-0.06670431792736053,
-0.31525787711143494,
-0.2794109880924225,
-0.06359526515007019,
-0.7475765347480774,
0.5992946028709412,
0.5940515398979187,
0.057507723569869995,
0.478618860244751,
-0.41072961688041687,
-0.009871027432382107,
-1.2043190002441406,
-0.2738614082336426,
-0.08301447331905365,
-0.10603436827659607,
-0.6434218287467957,
0.11263996362686157,
0.36571550369262695,
-0.3196103274822235,
-0.5248928666114807,
0.49380165338516235,
-0.4948255121707916,
-0.12687064707279205,
-0.33957216143608093,
-0.29000774025917053,
-0.11564845591783524,
0.2294197380542755,
-0.20921090245246887,
0.606964647769928,
0.9903128147125244,
-0.6853673458099365,
0.5131354928016663,
0.4911263883113861,
-0.26924192905426025,
0.753957211971283,
-0.5449346303939819,
-0.032528944313526154,
-0.5521681904792786,
0.39872103929519653,
-0.7326053977012634,
-0.2661297023296356,
0.44590315222740173,
0.1703643649816513,
0.19540901482105255,
-0.23994724452495575,
-0.3196600079536438,
-0.046323761343955994,
-0.6047794818878174,
0.3376259207725525,
0.31353315711021423,
-0.9527183175086975,
0.5715661644935608,
0.22221055626869202,
0.09848642349243164,
-0.7634795904159546,
-0.37127262353897095,
-0.3147033154964447,
-0.41048792004585266,
-0.6799045205116272,
0.29270198941230774,
-0.3272453844547272,
-0.4227276146411896,
0.029407117515802383,
-0.37489086389541626,
-0.22604607045650482,
-0.10274990648031235,
-0.06473147124052048,
0.2733610272407532,
0.039491645991802216,
-0.055507514625787735,
0.4163592755794525,
-0.18425698578357697,
-0.39480867981910706,
0.1835104376077652,
0.46117717027664185,
0.8057751655578613,
-0.6094595193862915,
-0.42353910207748413,
0.5450136065483093,
0.3892802298069,
-0.16831670701503754,
0.8359552621841431,
0.3794540762901306,
-0.37361717224121094,
-0.6684067249298096,
-0.03976071625947952,
-0.44008031487464905,
-0.48330244421958923,
0.4136625826358795,
-0.5407106876373291,
-0.07527942210435867,
0.49519822001457214,
-0.2019890993833542,
0.2640853822231293,
0.27501633763313293,
0.40309470891952515,
-0.049563903361558914,
1.0230910778045654,
0.46878910064697266,
0.0162760429084301,
0.6453403234481812,
-0.4583640992641449,
-0.005113502964377403,
-0.5396772027015686,
0.11700327694416046,
-0.4128670394420624,
-0.5093385577201843,
-0.3241254687309265,
-0.5992215871810913,
0.47952696681022644,
-0.013227487914264202,
-0.1353781521320343,
0.1874861717224121,
-0.3507591187953949,
0.3277030289173126,
0.6987037062644958,
0.5255473852157593,
0.1833386868238449,
0.1159573346376419,
0.06567586213350296,
0.09924068301916122,
-0.7833154201507568,
0.14471249282360077,
1.2742277383804321,
0.20694203674793243,
1.1848169565200806,
-0.23992733657360077,
1.0253585577011108,
0.3092789649963379,
-0.01161214243620634,
-0.3640720844268799,
0.39427193999290466,
-0.10709201544523239,
-0.33894243836402893,
-0.01598845236003399,
-0.7441332340240479,
-0.8839926719665527,
0.6898805499076843,
-0.40024688839912415,
-0.16310152411460876,
0.6670462489128113,
-0.03008509799838066,
-0.07534939050674438,
0.5551154017448425,
-0.8403491377830505,
0.6705546379089355,
0.11391237378120422,
0.23343946039676666,
-0.33049213886260986,
-0.5485984086990356,
0.3082260489463806,
-0.35756567120552063,
0.1184956505894661,
-0.08587482571601868,
-0.1519790142774582,
0.6361374258995056,
-0.8639931678771973,
0.5379559397697449,
-0.3195459544658661,
0.16681237518787384,
0.15632526576519012,
-0.17808733880519867,
0.7774848341941833,
0.04823405668139458,
-0.0783989429473877,
0.07769788056612015,
-0.3016304671764374,
-0.31259796023368835,
-0.6694494485855103,
0.23755323886871338,
-1.0474778413772583,
0.004671218805015087,
-0.25199708342552185,
-0.9235703349113464,
-0.07611724734306335,
-0.08777281641960144,
0.4307457506656647,
0.6358465552330017,
0.07868550717830658,
0.16808494925498962,
0.37638071179389954,
-0.014215975999832153,
0.19556966423988342,
0.17623041570186615,
0.18060420453548431,
-0.7993366122245789,
0.5451294779777527,
0.10613811761140823,
0.5412417054176331,
0.19246535003185272,
0.17422641813755035,
-0.2565828263759613,
-0.7478435635566711,
-0.449217826128006,
0.18014584481716156,
-1.0691004991531372,
-0.31194838881492615,
-0.8054649829864502,
-0.07652521878480911,
0.012869377620518208,
-0.3593316972255707,
-0.7604522109031677,
-0.5832523703575134,
-0.4121859669685364,
-0.19677336513996124,
0.4556676149368286,
0.6114671230316162,
-0.45812109112739563,
0.7935558557510376,
-0.5459157824516296,
0.5292741656303406,
0.15590398013591766,
0.30058011412620544,
-0.08455334603786469,
-0.35032927989959717,
-0.38183867931365967,
0.5753095149993896,
-0.290942519903183,
-1.1809055805206299,
0.37484824657440186,
0.00955500639975071,
0.5205549001693726,
0.20730742812156677,
0.21399492025375366,
0.9044707417488098,
-0.3244349956512451,
0.2959578335285187,
0.36066022515296936,
-0.7707371115684509,
0.3325665593147278,
-0.24733243882656097,
-0.00237370771355927,
0.49668800830841064,
0.17872151732444763,
-0.13837313652038574,
-0.36555227637290955,
-0.5819800496101379,
-0.9021278619766235,
0.9988223314285278,
0.32284852862358093,
0.11782805621623993,
0.27741023898124695,
-0.05872741714119911,
0.5607021450996399,
0.08641563355922699,
-0.269905686378479,
-0.7481796741485596,
-0.06784617155790329,
-0.23065581917762756,
0.1575537770986557,
-0.11478670686483383,
-0.3257974088191986,
-0.7867730855941772,
0.6153395175933838,
0.16264311969280243,
0.11440599709749222,
-0.22732456028461456,
0.04636760056018829,
-0.14673863351345062,
-0.031162511557340622,
0.23314480483531952,
0.8284221291542053,
-0.43341195583343506,
0.052598584443330765,
0.23475179076194763,
-0.7061038613319397,
0.23638805747032166,
0.1781160980463028,
-0.3442715108394623,
0.36255189776420593,
-0.0678822472691536,
1.0375396013259888,
0.12663716077804565,
-0.33261677622795105,
0.31082820892333984,
0.1508817821741104,
-0.2880953848361969,
0.3387693166732788,
0.38202130794525146,
0.2612391710281372,
0.40554991364479065,
0.1882615089416504,
0.41136854887008667,
0.178932785987854,
-0.0021824180148541927,
0.3445740044116974,
0.2590791583061218,
0.3198534846305847,
-0.07050896435976028,
0.7099387645721436,
0.11584623903036118,
-0.006495603825896978,
0.8321947455406189,
-0.012105155736207962,
-0.08117476105690002,
0.4133196175098419,
0.29357603192329407,
0.6648666262626648,
-0.36107757687568665,
0.3347931206226349,
0.07633663713932037,
0.18706607818603516,
-0.1121915727853775,
0.44187670946121216,
0.21080270409584045,
-0.7867791652679443,
-0.12307889014482498,
-0.4075133502483368,
-0.845583975315094,
-0.10492240637540817,
-0.5878980159759521,
0.8234096169471741,
-0.25022339820861816,
-0.11682329326868057,
0.14798331260681152,
-0.17653872072696686,
-1.008934736251831,
0.5533162355422974,
-0.08712945133447647,
0.8631455898284912,
-1.0535666942596436,
0.5950524210929871,
0.6211599707603455,
-0.1907503455877304,
-0.5293900370597839,
-0.308615505695343,
-0.1796877682209015,
-0.4862419068813324,
0.04489796236157417,
-0.21033884584903717,
0.31779715418815613,
0.08499381691217422,
-0.32848697900772095,
-0.7177753448486328,
0.7538018226623535,
0.8217344880104065,
-0.43106111884117126,
0.2890132665634155,
0.1851024031639099,
0.2466861754655838,
-0.3423697054386139,
0.3915695548057556,
0.5172688961029053,
0.29367971420288086,
0.31698742508888245,
-0.4216000437736511,
-0.46654826402664185,
-0.02761952206492424,
-0.049769964069128036,
0.4889886975288391,
-0.1353607177734375,
1.0869605541229248,
-0.1427689641714096,
-0.12317226082086563,
-0.45185211300849915,
0.4980889558792114,
0.33447545766830444,
0.5222614407539368,
0.6599838137626648,
0.8222882747650146,
0.7906715273857117,
0.13969185948371887,
1.1070841550827026,
-0.24388359487056732,
0.6454980969429016,
0.866324782371521,
-0.2745542824268341,
0.5777438879013062,
0.24948400259017944,
-0.4468039572238922,
0.02622707188129425,
1.0764795541763306,
0.11150697618722916,
1.018324851989746,
-0.17319892346858978,
-0.48713478446006775,
-0.09952955693006516,
0.19601818919181824,
-0.5047834515571594,
0.2855115532875061,
-0.002160529140383005,
-0.06164339929819107,
-0.8270212411880493,
0.026911189779639244,
-0.29225388169288635,
-0.30173808336257935,
-0.1617630422115326,
0.5714341402053833,
-0.17648084461688995,
0.17819824814796448,
0.6437916159629822,
0.24507777392864227,
0.44950148463249207,
-0.5714568495750427,
0.12234891206026077,
-0.5844078063964844,
-0.024301353842020035,
-0.16809651255607605,
-0.5715153217315674,
0.31380385160446167,
-0.052462104707956314,
-0.14965030550956726,
-0.13644707202911377,
0.5004555583000183,
-0.47905102372169495,
-0.6495586633682251,
-0.0018331577302888036,
0.6129693984985352,
0.08456051349639893,
-0.14173611998558044,
-0.6841809153556824,
0.18263468146324158,
0.0022962314542382956,
-0.4607621431350708,
0.2634800672531128,
0.2926841974258423,
0.14911635220050812,
0.6800723671913147,
0.8038141131401062,
0.29226621985435486,
0.2669098973274231,
0.15061460435390472,
1.1372549533843994,
-0.3664499521255493,
-0.8678946495056152,
-0.7040140628814697,
0.7065374851226807,
-0.23505856096744537,
-0.1985778510570526,
0.30380529165267944,
0.6173197031021118,
0.7713154554367065,
-0.28307589888572693,
0.8795225024223328,
0.1341276317834854,
0.37876638770103455,
-0.29652440547943115,
0.2934958040714264,
-0.6261696815490723,
0.19155253469944,
-0.1937045007944107,
-1.5675305128097534,
-0.06655802577733994,
0.3759494125843048,
-0.06455831974744797,
0.2873108386993408,
0.6485986709594727,
0.5761628150939941,
-0.8081972599029541,
0.09090316295623779,
0.23250870406627655,
-0.35213467478752136,
0.04267483949661255,
0.21343080699443817,
0.5748818516731262,
-0.1976197212934494,
0.12502822279930115,
-1.0243539810180664,
-0.014132965356111526,
-0.22702021896839142,
-0.45871031284332275,
-0.779142439365387,
-0.2648125886917114,
-0.43394479155540466,
0.06863633543252945,
0.01386224664747715,
0.9932764768600464,
0.8242782950401306,
-0.4659595787525177,
0.1172352135181427,
0.031679484993219376,
0.16421443223953247,
-0.44994691014289856,
-0.15310326218605042,
0.544215202331543,
0.03210294991731644,
-1.024080514907837,
0.44114261865615845,
0.21249252557754517,
0.30257612466812134,
-0.03749195486307144,
-0.14464071393013,
0.14015832543373108,
0.41407713294029236,
0.29654982686042786,
-0.40706509351730347,
-0.1818285435438156,
-0.27896207571029663,
-0.1818484663963318,
-0.12984469532966614,
0.10733691602945328,
0.5554386973381042,
-0.376243531703949,
0.8026075959205627,
0.7507438063621521,
0.9744713306427002,
0.6485783457756042,
0.5603926181793213,
0.46662935614585876,
-1.0298311710357666,
0.39561742544174194,
0.06090927496552467,
0.44892051815986633,
0.4155600070953369,
-0.29227113723754883,
0.7513542771339417,
0.4745825529098511,
-0.20055177807807922,
-0.9955666065216064,
0.04642356559634209,
-1.1586366891860962,
-0.10593676567077637,
1.019951343536377,
0.2789962589740753,
0.1367649883031845,
0.10548879951238632,
-0.38341957330703735,
0.4139171540737152,
-0.2347605675458908,
0.6593645215034485,
0.6278047561645508,
-0.039325274527072906,
-0.254933625459671,
-0.4988642930984497,
0.1670338213443756,
0.18962116539478302,
-0.8668733835220337,
0.04467448592185974,
0.7283312678337097,
0.3394831120967865,
-0.6014868021011353,
0.35140079259872437,
0.5146895051002502,
0.1873834878206253,
0.44143301248550415,
0.18889956176280975,
-0.06451423466205597,
-0.485391765832901,
-0.0760229155421257,
0.020336875692009926,
-0.3453807532787323,
-0.5767987966537476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15567v1 | SAIL: Self-Improving Efficient Online Alignment of Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T18:05:35 | 2024-06-21T18:05:35 | Mucong Ding, Souradip Chakraborty, Vibhu Agrawal, Zora Che, Alec Koppel, Mengdi Wang, Amrit Bedi, Furong Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is a key method for
aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. However, current
offline alignment approaches like DPO, IPO, and SLiC rely heavily on fixed
preference datasets, which can lead to sub-optimal performance. On the other
hand, recent literature has focused on designing online RLHF methods but still
lacks a unified conceptual formulation and suffers from distribution shift
issues. To address this, we establish that online LLM alignment is underpinned
by bilevel optimization. By reducing this formulation to an efficient
single-level first-order method (using the reward-policy equivalence), our
approach generates new samples and iteratively refines model alignment by
exploring responses and regulating preference labels. In doing so, we permit
alignment methods to operate in an online and self-improving manner, as well as
generalize prior online RLHF methods as special cases. Compared to
state-of-the-art iterative RLHF methods, our approach significantly improves
alignment performance on open-sourced datasets with minimal computational
overhead. | [
-0.2175891101360321,
-0.24679502844810486,
0.37732669711112976,
0.24965447187423706,
-0.1895514875650406,
0.2310897707939148,
-0.36540767550468445,
-0.29128003120422363,
0.3656218647956848,
0.5233176946640015,
-0.8485329151153564,
-0.29643699526786804,
-0.23447713255882263,
0.017286863178014755,
0.08950155228376389,
1.177987813949585,
0.001984549919143319,
0.09400048106908798,
-0.15353399515151978,
-0.30975541472435,
-0.08894739300012589,
-0.11589857190847397,
-0.6179093718528748,
-0.27317947149276733,
0.7651677131652832,
0.45229995250701904,
0.580967128276825,
0.9190689921379089,
0.6175569295883179,
0.2837638258934021,
0.056908782571554184,
0.4141148626804352,
-0.8180025815963745,
0.3047403395175934,
-0.31309273838996887,
-0.08037944883108139,
-0.49446332454681396,
-0.3098101317882538,
0.5829475522041321,
0.39727407693862915,
-0.7318598628044128,
0.09210389107465744,
-0.024130504578351974,
0.9782084226608276,
-0.7378517985343933,
0.20991265773773193,
-0.3754517734050751,
-0.028057200834155083,
-0.1747889369726181,
-0.14402081072330475,
-0.3631804585456848,
-0.7176498770713806,
0.14051784574985504,
-1.1221596002578735,
-0.11107133328914642,
0.3962295651435852,
0.6814086437225342,
0.46236172318458557,
-0.2639716863632202,
-0.3201098144054413,
-0.5211820006370544,
0.7790049910545349,
-0.9376410245895386,
0.4364301860332489,
0.21087750792503357,
0.4169318377971649,
-0.2995986342430115,
-0.301225483417511,
-0.4667544364929199,
-0.14206939935684204,
-0.0008100543054752052,
0.25017136335372925,
0.27838134765625,
0.2996157109737396,
-0.17869865894317627,
0.24366779625415802,
-0.6333905458450317,
0.4421003758907318,
-0.2998847961425781,
-0.1531556397676468,
0.861461341381073,
0.23447167873382568,
0.01717647910118103,
0.08728272467851639,
-0.2878592610359192,
-0.36646220088005066,
-0.8558331727981567,
0.08066325634717941,
0.5489081740379333,
0.6620789766311646,
-0.15011939406394958,
0.40719109773635864,
-0.11799561232328415,
0.841653048992157,
0.6179585456848145,
-0.437494695186615,
0.15846547484397888,
-0.11165955662727356,
0.17682281136512756,
0.356353759765625,
0.7590577006340027,
0.329360693693161,
0.0021059121936559677,
-0.10029182583093643,
-0.18875326216220856,
-0.38348543643951416,
0.49348151683807373,
-0.4548557698726654,
0.0863896980881691,
0.26563647389411926,
-0.199490025639534,
-0.39642152190208435,
0.05665243789553642,
-0.8797349333763123,
-0.7900437116622925,
-0.2956676483154297,
0.30949726700782776,
0.17564904689788818,
-0.191885843873024,
0.06168895587325096,
0.17975297570228577,
0.37709516286849976,
0.38353875279426575,
-1.1655186414718628,
0.17842869460582733,
0.8659862875938416,
0.6132127642631531,
-0.39877480268478394,
-0.3003907799720764,
-0.6959226727485657,
0.19891507923603058,
-0.4877232611179352,
0.6576712727546692,
-0.18415038287639618,
-0.07908297330141068,
0.19556128978729248,
-0.1648751199245453,
-0.060669660568237305,
-0.4480520486831665,
0.5260236263275146,
-0.7466424703598022,
0.3271082043647766,
-0.35608991980552673,
-0.763002336025238,
0.07082109898328781,
0.29273495078086853,
-0.6588279604911804,
1.2399702072143555,
0.06848090142011642,
-0.855832040309906,
0.25067138671875,
-0.6341735124588013,
-0.43740832805633545,
-0.21906064450740814,
-0.0524139367043972,
-0.7627650499343872,
0.05827997997403145,
0.3498378396034241,
0.12216918915510178,
-0.27215877175331116,
0.39633750915527344,
-0.6067818999290466,
-0.22402453422546387,
0.027695195749402046,
0.22272807359695435,
0.6093515157699585,
0.3166520297527313,
-0.6066537499427795,
0.510144054889679,
-0.7282618880271912,
0.12543724477291107,
0.017440883442759514,
-0.5431733131408691,
-0.26467692852020264,
0.21394814550876617,
-0.15554596483707428,
0.18227876722812653,
0.17103420197963715,
-0.5616840720176697,
0.674142062664032,
-0.8076706528663635,
0.39107561111450195,
1.1126118898391724,
-0.19518595933914185,
0.6706684827804565,
-0.29164546728134155,
0.7020177841186523,
-0.28570112586021423,
0.2305240035057068,
0.21210667490959167,
-0.197134867310524,
-0.7389764189720154,
-0.3441368043422699,
0.27954593300819397,
0.3319816291332245,
-0.4300387501716614,
0.42646872997283936,
-0.4280329644680023,
-0.38065648078918457,
-0.9498507380485535,
0.1518496423959732,
0.47742605209350586,
0.6005094647407532,
0.40449124574661255,
-0.0994517058134079,
-0.5531366467475891,
-0.7457162141799927,
-0.2504422068595886,
-0.24000802636146545,
0.36462387442588806,
0.22561433911323547,
-0.022521955892443657,
-0.14974500238895416,
1.1273924112319946,
-0.4013495147228241,
-0.2653089761734009,
-0.28825777769088745,
0.24383923411369324,
0.15688243508338928,
0.37198886275291443,
0.27050867676734924,
-0.39736586809158325,
-0.6970077157020569,
0.26001501083374023,
-0.49126332998275757,
-0.26579439640045166,
-0.15818336606025696,
-0.18036344647407532,
0.5509670376777649,
0.2737291753292084,
-0.21740572154521942,
0.14450570940971375,
0.6659695506095886,
-0.19057346880435944,
0.24764950573444366,
-0.57657790184021,
0.2016802579164505,
-0.7597934603691101,
-0.15705974400043488,
-0.13975666463375092,
-0.3144972026348114,
-0.41780978441238403,
0.11457190662622452,
0.3043895363807678,
0.15564215183258057,
-0.3996924161911011,
0.8208740949630737,
-0.5580489635467529,
-0.2606198489665985,
-0.2826913893222809,
0.4208979606628418,
-0.24191930890083313,
0.6287121772766113,
0.024458730593323708,
0.5532150864601135,
0.3319496512413025,
-0.4888440668582916,
0.19929052889347076,
0.2556478977203369,
-0.30328285694122314,
0.49918732047080994,
-0.42558303475379944,
0.2905586361885071,
-0.29328814148902893,
0.28648021817207336,
-0.9729745984077454,
-0.09801136702299118,
0.5117978453636169,
-0.046460527926683426,
0.4220200777053833,
0.05746609717607498,
0.08353880047798157,
-0.1834060549736023,
-0.4253460764884949,
0.39614444971084595,
0.28905898332595825,
-0.89682537317276,
0.6193817853927612,
0.45728185772895813,
-0.08671579509973526,
-0.9038470983505249,
-0.27342432737350464,
-0.2380201518535614,
-0.309589147567749,
-0.43824678659439087,
0.40747323632240295,
-0.06460113078355789,
-0.15579630434513092,
-0.28695544600486755,
-0.16257475316524506,
0.15741035342216492,
-0.04602869600057602,
0.001395516679622233,
0.3151032626628876,
-0.010403635911643505,
0.14406174421310425,
0.03948058933019638,
-0.08000164479017258,
-0.38533708453178406,
-0.5230063796043396,
0.29269203543663025,
-0.010336946696043015,
-0.335405170917511,
-0.41749006509780884,
0.10372312366962433,
0.419716477394104,
-0.2601269781589508,
0.6224695444107056,
0.33441704511642456,
0.12835513055324554,
-0.409436970949173,
-0.5867032408714294,
-0.1359243094921112,
-0.5007488131523132,
0.30947497487068176,
-0.1756362020969391,
-1.0082350969314575,
0.25208479166030884,
0.15358984470367432,
0.21802188456058502,
0.29399749636650085,
0.45223599672317505,
-0.38481593132019043,
1.0150072574615479,
0.6855722069740295,
-0.2989364564418793,
0.4000746011734009,
0.20163479447364807,
0.25268352031707764,
-0.6593062877655029,
-0.12171024829149246,
-0.5939819812774658,
-0.3307632505893707,
-0.7656392455101013,
-0.26264262199401855,
0.26177945733070374,
0.1917366087436676,
-0.6019020080566406,
0.40780720114707947,
-0.5502327084541321,
0.3811873495578766,
0.4750310480594635,
0.15552712976932526,
0.2553732991218567,
-0.07017993927001953,
-0.2919875383377075,
-0.22879083454608917,
-0.9811908602714539,
-0.07900502532720566,
1.137758731842041,
0.23182284832000732,
1.1043614149093628,
0.19590739905834198,
0.8755732178688049,
0.3867710828781128,
0.5258249044418335,
-0.6025522351264954,
0.2753448784351349,
0.12508904933929443,
-0.5171588659286499,
-0.5637134313583374,
-0.5803641080856323,
-0.9199876189231873,
0.21710923314094543,
-0.3020685911178589,
-0.5470017194747925,
0.08516384661197662,
0.6963146328926086,
-0.42705217003822327,
0.12620557844638824,
-0.3365923762321472,
0.9154995679855347,
-0.8452308773994446,
-0.5756823420524597,
-0.3117414116859436,
-0.76701819896698,
0.22129839658737183,
-0.03587004914879799,
0.599421501159668,
-0.03437751904129982,
-0.13050460815429688,
0.6210452914237976,
-0.6173477172851562,
0.7633557915687561,
-0.19193218648433685,
-0.3914853632450104,
0.029019394889473915,
0.03181616961956024,
0.939854085445404,
-0.3709343671798706,
-0.00015705896657891572,
-0.19160780310630798,
-0.05409099906682968,
-0.29353615641593933,
-0.7029916048049927,
0.6461185812950134,
-0.9168151021003723,
-0.48011425137519836,
-0.5949633121490479,
-0.34750887751579285,
-0.3316904604434967,
-0.02060631848871708,
-0.0358114056289196,
0.2838555872440338,
0.0020061901304870844,
-0.08359549194574356,
0.5989697575569153,
-0.28988710045814514,
0.36737504601478577,
0.5848411321640015,
-0.5982579588890076,
-0.8634788990020752,
1.0299756526947021,
-0.14750652015209198,
0.39648109674453735,
0.6466806530952454,
0.5202988386154175,
-0.8158941268920898,
-0.4076460599899292,
-0.6244789958000183,
0.5126897692680359,
-0.8058608770370483,
-0.12373299151659012,
-0.22687159478664398,
0.3269239664077759,
-0.6683762073516846,
-0.26160308718681335,
-0.6409528255462646,
-0.5992717146873474,
-0.1282510608434677,
-0.012515717186033726,
0.14811120927333832,
0.8596959114074707,
-0.14183010160923004,
0.2998237907886505,
-0.6744461059570312,
0.07096773386001587,
0.2146591693162918,
0.46078965067863464,
-0.050108570605516434,
-0.679061770439148,
-0.24751323461532593,
-0.07255438715219498,
-0.1922878623008728,
-0.7820370197296143,
0.3192490041255951,
0.31999996304512024,
0.6988374590873718,
0.6191951632499695,
0.2704404890537262,
0.920941174030304,
-0.3729564845561981,
0.3983020484447479,
0.3658248484134674,
-0.8864010572433472,
0.28475549817085266,
-0.46388548612594604,
0.21900147199630737,
0.6987745761871338,
0.5281231999397278,
-0.6469748616218567,
-0.1640802025794983,
-0.34334316849708557,
-0.7747724652290344,
0.7711427807807922,
-0.2145320475101471,
-0.3678770363330841,
0.1988070160150528,
0.44594869017601013,
0.08760341256856918,
0.23853231966495514,
-0.8128393292427063,
-0.34056147933006287,
-0.3256777822971344,
-0.4806191623210907,
-0.1435922384262085,
0.17273907363414764,
-0.03004075400531292,
-0.2791292071342468,
1.1211553812026978,
-0.4976199269294739,
-0.11554111540317535,
0.00021661109349224716,
-0.1537088304758072,
-0.2949936091899872,
0.24746938049793243,
0.793043315410614,
0.6776800751686096,
-0.04295465350151062,
0.025928782299160957,
0.01689763553440571,
0.03346752002835274,
0.3367072641849518,
-0.13264629244804382,
-0.28295937180519104,
-0.5204269289970398,
0.18655183911323547,
0.8139606714248657,
0.6474224925041199,
-0.8051467537879944,
0.4980267882347107,
0.0761260911822319,
-0.07649407535791397,
-0.04417562484741211,
0.05949017405509949,
0.2081018090248108,
0.2629847228527069,
0.08060552179813385,
-0.2762247920036316,
-0.1957964152097702,
-0.3776119649410248,
0.05632179230451584,
0.39304348826408386,
-0.5223292112350464,
-0.0007873939466662705,
0.6320850253105164,
0.1847705841064453,
-0.4907515347003937,
0.6520851850509644,
-0.2506428360939026,
-0.5968350172042847,
0.2414492964744568,
0.5092756748199463,
0.7704159617424011,
-0.11177189648151398,
0.5439690947532654,
0.740719199180603,
0.049619801342487335,
-0.43941375613212585,
0.025408463552594185,
-0.3038588762283325,
-0.7240337133407593,
-0.4062858521938324,
-0.7588000297546387,
-0.6486716866493225,
-0.3840077817440033,
-0.6602329611778259,
0.19433759152889252,
-0.4770132899284363,
0.08116532862186432,
-0.38020452857017517,
-0.22666101157665253,
-0.22217825055122375,
-0.05236700922250748,
-0.03810370713472366,
0.42274704575538635,
-0.50885009765625,
0.8545987606048584,
0.5115059018135071,
-0.34627586603164673,
-0.9501081705093384,
-0.21037115156650543,
0.24094869196414948,
-0.8489217162132263,
0.5910667777061462,
-0.13428255915641785,
-0.21438536047935486,
0.15424971282482147,
-0.39482372999191284,
-1.2230688333511353,
0.9284870624542236,
0.425282746553421,
-0.9767513871192932,
-0.10312782973051071,
0.14286425709724426,
0.4744213819503784,
-0.3817131221294403,
0.3726525604724884,
0.39511656761169434,
0.7432555556297302,
0.1215624138712883,
-0.9595123529434204,
-0.10284213721752167,
0.1625705361366272,
-0.05927656218409538,
0.44879087805747986,
-0.6438475251197815,
0.32073208689689636,
-0.30639350414276123,
-0.14336690306663513,
-0.08757277578115463,
0.6624583005905151,
0.336870014667511,
-0.16392077505588531,
0.4986213445663452,
0.8126698732376099,
0.8099790811538696,
-0.023884981870651245,
0.8606648445129395,
-0.20351657271385193,
0.7166602611541748,
1.595420241355896,
-0.49166709184646606,
0.9093596935272217,
0.5805777907371521,
-0.23177209496498108,
0.4696587920188904,
0.814102053642273,
0.20921967923641205,
0.7849931716918945,
0.5152366757392883,
0.04303659126162529,
-0.3973615765571594,
0.2823881208896637,
-0.20597068965435028,
0.22355449199676514,
-0.25780361890792847,
0.10691386461257935,
-0.4359295964241028,
-0.0988435223698616,
-0.14893697202205658,
0.19257649779319763,
-0.37016791105270386,
1.084236979484558,
-0.24536536633968353,
-1.216829776763916,
0.712187647819519,
0.04218125343322754,
0.7219260334968567,
-0.6763237118721008,
0.1065126433968544,
-0.325668066740036,
0.49499061703681946,
-0.20434917509555817,
-0.33879849314689636,
0.14603137969970703,
-0.2531365156173706,
0.10704934597015381,
-0.44665664434432983,
0.4035998284816742,
-0.6138153672218323,
-0.18667761981487274,
0.4752022624015808,
0.18945913016796112,
-0.045200131833553314,
0.2393585741519928,
-0.8407210111618042,
0.13292811810970306,
0.08875317871570587,
-0.2814529538154602,
0.5021104216575623,
-0.14228954911231995,
-0.06524201482534409,
0.7132388353347778,
0.4497373402118683,
0.19769228994846344,
0.3627331554889679,
0.05770817771553993,
0.5090428590774536,
-0.5942967534065247,
-0.7514553666114807,
-0.5712484121322632,
0.5666028261184692,
-0.044722624123096466,
-0.46486490964889526,
0.5469574332237244,
0.44872790575027466,
1.0272631645202637,
-0.037525590509176254,
0.6703310012817383,
-0.013998044654726982,
0.6323415637016296,
-0.41740262508392334,
0.5432521104812622,
-0.7077009081840515,
0.20876657962799072,
-0.18571487069129944,
-0.8370310664176941,
-0.2395513504743576,
0.7536332607269287,
-0.2783955931663513,
-0.21613015234470367,
0.6554055213928223,
1.0437742471694946,
0.044561851769685745,
0.010352988727390766,
0.14880412817001343,
0.06666792929172516,
0.2610938549041748,
0.2246282398700714,
0.7897919416427612,
-0.12583735585212708,
0.3830012083053589,
-0.3145218789577484,
-0.12100929766893387,
-0.06166570261120796,
-1.245261311531067,
-0.716317355632782,
-0.5177945494651794,
-0.4550436735153198,
-0.3190383017063141,
0.3103463053703308,
1.5013455152511597,
0.7704430818557739,
-0.9316097497940063,
-0.5758842825889587,
-0.2907949686050415,
0.08929719030857086,
-0.45139631628990173,
-0.19288991391658783,
0.34832289814949036,
-0.6201911568641663,
-0.4559191167354584,
0.5605393052101135,
0.4137903153896332,
-0.2320651412010193,
-0.453754723072052,
-0.7325829267501831,
-0.35236597061157227,
0.01545993983745575,
0.17802689969539642,
0.6485608220100403,
-0.8207911252975464,
-0.3864714205265045,
-0.020868854597210884,
-0.19360873103141785,
0.37350764870643616,
0.8853997588157654,
-0.4440029561519623,
0.5868659019470215,
0.540614902973175,
1.096670150756836,
0.7954972982406616,
0.19303254783153534,
0.6391863822937012,
-0.4039812982082367,
-0.26190993189811707,
0.1362822949886322,
0.1965816468000412,
0.27928733825683594,
-0.21253708004951477,
0.3437768220901489,
0.11631209403276443,
-0.722746729850769,
-0.5956947207450867,
0.1496160924434662,
-0.9491150379180908,
-0.1041879951953888,
0.9246294498443604,
-0.16630566120147705,
-0.2681662142276764,
-0.011786394752562046,
-0.2234746813774109,
0.20188313722610474,
-0.4474720358848572,
1.0899444818496704,
0.5515767931938171,
-0.3480868339538574,
-0.25061482191085815,
0.020281264558434486,
0.6290913224220276,
0.5054692625999451,
-1.0677627325057983,
0.26370152831077576,
0.5994460582733154,
0.2693430781364441,
-0.12712067365646362,
0.8141483068466187,
0.08603720366954803,
0.07895688712596893,
-0.5584568977355957,
0.2471056580543518,
0.027376724407076836,
-0.39345642924308777,
-0.5952814221382141,
0.23574475944042206,
0.16997869312763214,
0.23816922307014465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15352v1 | A SMART Mnemonic Sounds like "Glue Tonic": Mixing LLMs with Student Feedback to Make Mnemonic Learning Stick | 2024-06-21T17:59:51 | 2024-06-21T17:59:51 | Nishant Balepur, Matthew Shu, Alexander Hoyle, Alison Robey, Shi Feng, Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Keyword mnemonics are memorable explanations that link new terms to simpler
keywords. Prior works generate mnemonics for students, but they do not guide
models toward mnemonics students prefer and aid learning. We build SMART, a
mnemonic generator trained on feedback from real students learning new terms.
To train SMART, we first fine-tune LLaMA-2 on a curated set of user-written
mnemonics. We then use LLM alignment to enhance SMART: we deploy mnemonics
generated by SMART in a flashcard app to find preferences on mnemonics students
favor. We gather 2684 preferences from 45 students across two types: expressed
(inferred from ratings) and observed (inferred from student learning), yielding
three key findings. First, expressed and observed preferences disagree; what
students think is helpful does not fully capture what is truly helpful. Second,
Bayesian models can synthesize complementary data from multiple preference
types into a single effectiveness signal. SMART is tuned via Direct Preference
Optimization on this signal, which we show resolves ties and missing labels in
the typical method of pairwise comparisons, augmenting data for LLM output
quality gains. Third, mnemonic experts assess SMART as matching GPT-4, at much
lower deployment costs, showing the utility of capturing diverse student
feedback to align LLMs in education. | [
-0.19569681584835052,
-0.6332526803016663,
0.6504044532775879,
-0.15616080164909363,
-0.7454480528831482,
0.32209140062332153,
-0.1947307139635086,
-0.045930832624435425,
0.7002306580543518,
0.1624610275030136,
-0.5909561514854431,
-0.39361751079559326,
-0.2871745824813843,
-0.1445188820362091,
-0.08611330389976501,
1.5636454820632935,
0.3020990490913391,
0.2995460331439972,
-0.35715410113334656,
-0.1341082900762558,
-0.7881190180778503,
-0.1927182972431183,
-0.3965669572353363,
-0.6689859628677368,
0.6962205767631531,
0.9510669708251953,
0.8175551295280457,
0.7591756582260132,
0.4802785813808441,
0.15627723932266235,
-0.02243928052484989,
0.19763031601905823,
-0.3414936661720276,
-0.08129788935184479,
-0.24780908226966858,
-0.696636438369751,
-0.9039021730422974,
0.3161783814430237,
0.08326376229524612,
0.3474161922931671,
-0.12173385918140411,
0.4109446406364441,
0.05999564006924629,
0.7215572595596313,
-0.35122209787368774,
-0.1201176643371582,
-0.7951933741569519,
0.17072249948978424,
-0.2944301664829254,
-0.3735353648662567,
-0.02107222005724907,
-0.5396260023117065,
0.16402733325958252,
-0.562533974647522,
0.08230098336935043,
-0.20714855194091797,
0.7784692645072937,
0.37486326694488525,
-0.27643245458602905,
-0.2737768292427063,
-0.3777002990245819,
0.6479467153549194,
-0.5111545920372009,
0.1539357453584671,
0.27353188395500183,
0.40934526920318604,
-0.17514440417289734,
-0.6248014569282532,
-0.6806946992874146,
0.030666332691907883,
0.3671403229236603,
0.5387406349182129,
0.7043072581291199,
0.07518873363733292,
-0.08200640231370926,
0.2991892099380493,
-0.20918166637420654,
0.03719035163521767,
-0.3611789345741272,
-0.05593612417578697,
0.7466397285461426,
0.21147044003009796,
0.06532327085733414,
-0.18728221952915192,
-0.5690532326698303,
-0.04814525693655014,
-0.6866176724433899,
0.13107766211032867,
0.5535426735877991,
0.08753609657287598,
0.21544520556926727,
0.7571333050727844,
0.22227568924427032,
0.6568363308906555,
0.4089306592941284,
-0.8182228803634644,
0.2667066156864166,
-0.4588721692562103,
0.15567763149738312,
0.4685928225517273,
0.6182242631912231,
0.7099779844284058,
0.5368435978889465,
-0.35170409083366394,
-0.40819287300109863,
0.1499820202589035,
0.2590821385383606,
-0.7784056663513184,
-0.6996138095855713,
0.2896723747253418,
-0.27404987812042236,
-0.32815492153167725,
-0.12893956899642944,
-0.5143043994903564,
-0.41655609011650085,
-0.6866037845611572,
0.7619069218635559,
-0.392017126083374,
0.055672045797109604,
0.21483725309371948,
-0.3951866328716278,
-0.1791694015264511,
0.30284583568573,
-1.3231192827224731,
0.05150318518280983,
0.7663624882698059,
0.6269348859786987,
-0.10301044583320618,
-0.36962631344795227,
-0.3104630708694458,
0.16613411903381348,
-0.23713363707065582,
1.0216896533966064,
-0.5177931189537048,
-0.5126603245735168,
-0.41922998428344727,
-0.31904852390289307,
0.026768729090690613,
-0.723695695400238,
0.20048601925373077,
-0.24027858674526215,
0.31310608983039856,
-0.16260431706905365,
-0.7816845178604126,
-0.06485753506422043,
-0.049821678549051285,
-0.41909486055374146,
0.9280222654342651,
-0.13839508593082428,
-0.49107563495635986,
0.7417128086090088,
-0.41115015745162964,
-0.2593111991882324,
0.27018025517463684,
-0.3157998025417328,
-0.5347353219985962,
0.12943188846111298,
-0.0863475427031517,
0.5494475364685059,
0.12563380599021912,
0.6106351017951965,
-0.4141208529472351,
-0.6860060095787048,
0.5785729289054871,
-0.1759290248155594,
0.3857893645763397,
0.11760667711496353,
-0.2646758258342743,
0.30145516991615295,
-0.6514429450035095,
-0.005978694651275873,
0.005347028374671936,
-0.6089391112327576,
-0.3014288544654846,
0.09032890200614929,
-0.09255201369524002,
0.037896595895290375,
0.5845609307289124,
-0.22086703777313232,
0.5585582256317139,
-0.0635252445936203,
0.5295020341873169,
0.9080182909965515,
-0.077845498919487,
0.5028172135353088,
-0.6225118041038513,
0.20835411548614502,
0.08301674574613571,
0.14489488303661346,
-0.1082872524857521,
-0.548643171787262,
-0.7194129228591919,
-0.4079592227935791,
0.32205843925476074,
0.6014389395713806,
-0.27295050024986267,
0.34197211265563965,
-0.3948775827884674,
-0.3991665840148926,
-0.901667594909668,
0.6925714612007141,
0.15311063826084137,
0.6201070547103882,
0.37515372037887573,
-0.43300288915634155,
-0.3995135724544525,
-0.5780790448188782,
-0.2702341377735138,
-0.05585331842303276,
0.1978767067193985,
0.14764398336410522,
0.35669419169425964,
-0.327921599149704,
1.0575982332229614,
-0.40379101037979126,
-0.2862890660762787,
-0.06331364065408707,
-0.16459228098392487,
0.46962955594062805,
0.34881481528282166,
0.2589423656463623,
-0.5909645557403564,
-0.17298895120620728,
-0.3336239457130432,
-0.36479902267456055,
0.16928231716156006,
-0.3051181435585022,
-0.09345600008964539,
-0.15339554846286774,
0.21680384874343872,
-0.5832833647727966,
0.034742023795843124,
0.052576448768377304,
-0.3617953360080719,
0.5812943577766418,
-0.23084215819835663,
-0.31448572874069214,
-1.2791435718536377,
-0.2258729189634323,
-0.26867401599884033,
0.085242860019207,
-0.2946387529373169,
-0.23656582832336426,
0.3233601748943329,
0.029080362990498543,
-0.31270623207092285,
0.5963079929351807,
-0.23346051573753357,
-0.01181845273822546,
-0.2826777994632721,
0.47461947798728943,
-0.1273251622915268,
0.39097434282302856,
-0.06426941603422165,
0.6757601499557495,
0.24600020051002502,
-0.5729780793190002,
0.37021616101264954,
0.23206304013729095,
-0.19814781844615936,
0.8285375833511353,
-0.5930973291397095,
0.12130355834960938,
-0.08369696140289307,
0.22535063326358795,
-0.9541782736778259,
-0.302722692489624,
0.010582393035292625,
-0.4242941737174988,
0.4310063123703003,
-0.005246252287179232,
-0.4872652292251587,
-0.32337528467178345,
-0.6560776829719543,
0.27443233132362366,
0.5869089365005493,
-0.774254322052002,
0.42693787813186646,
0.2762145400047302,
0.0007726940675638616,
-0.4985430836677551,
-0.5892094373703003,
0.07864663749933243,
-0.5015245676040649,
-0.3471015393733978,
0.3884539008140564,
-0.36415424942970276,
-0.030995290726423264,
0.12036029249429703,
-0.3227888345718384,
0.09326327592134476,
0.4801800847053528,
0.4459843933582306,
0.5490327477455139,
-0.14458996057510376,
0.5256088972091675,
0.054280418902635574,
-0.26818424463272095,
-0.09034844487905502,
-0.4357448220252991,
0.22922909259796143,
-0.20086590945720673,
-0.13504619896411896,
-0.4117394685745239,
-0.12845207750797272,
0.6374381184577942,
-0.12452825158834457,
0.37666240334510803,
0.6730342507362366,
-0.038494572043418884,
-0.2400932013988495,
-0.5076030492782593,
-0.6829636693000793,
-0.47653940320014954,
0.1245882660150528,
-0.3731006681919098,
-0.6539477705955505,
0.2880658507347107,
-0.15814006328582764,
0.4338466227054596,
-0.07022988051176071,
0.33873724937438965,
-0.4120611548423767,
1.020957589149475,
0.5345454216003418,
-0.03134333714842796,
0.6092708706855774,
-0.14376024901866913,
0.4526796042919159,
-0.7723748683929443,
-0.641276478767395,
0.07436966896057129,
-0.7269919514656067,
-0.3903150260448456,
-0.0604453943669796,
0.1686498373746872,
0.49752599000930786,
-0.20730766654014587,
0.11302407085895538,
-0.6250655651092529,
0.4877367913722992,
0.8806300759315491,
0.3380469083786011,
0.09387259930372238,
0.10032093524932861,
-0.2995268404483795,
-0.18193157017230988,
-0.7784022688865662,
-0.6880615949630737,
1.2389845848083496,
0.13951587677001953,
0.7104238271713257,
0.22229541838169098,
1.22615385055542,
-0.11959309875965118,
0.5250054001808167,
-1.2981789112091064,
0.8251639008522034,
-0.17367742955684662,
-0.35236310958862305,
0.03719554841518402,
-0.21258145570755005,
-0.8785949945449829,
0.12723484635353088,
-0.5461714863777161,
-0.48206284642219543,
-0.3838393986225128,
0.42000022530555725,
-0.5603989362716675,
0.19634591042995453,
-0.7333759069442749,
0.5961337089538574,
-0.7005653977394104,
-0.6879041194915771,
-0.2649925649166107,
-0.5936331152915955,
0.4102611541748047,
-0.26715683937072754,
0.03273100405931473,
-0.25854742527008057,
-0.20174506306648254,
0.8789750933647156,
-0.5367498397827148,
0.6822819709777832,
0.1802893429994583,
0.049030985683202744,
0.2670154571533203,
0.012869560159742832,
0.08753449469804764,
0.14785589277744293,
-0.03786759078502655,
-0.16437974572181702,
-0.18694567680358887,
-0.38099995255470276,
-0.6766535043716431,
0.7438045144081116,
-0.6206461787223816,
-0.850967288017273,
-0.16393141448497772,
-0.7449914813041687,
-0.08975614607334137,
0.13272060453891754,
0.15426971018314362,
0.32617247104644775,
0.3413769006729126,
-0.08245214819908142,
0.7780444622039795,
0.36974719166755676,
0.43215587735176086,
0.43008795380592346,
-0.1741367131471634,
-0.6212450265884399,
1.3525829315185547,
0.4637677073478699,
-0.0029527777805924416,
0.13376116752624512,
0.5089847445487976,
-0.43616804480552673,
-0.423215389251709,
-0.5455377697944641,
0.3794371783733368,
-0.6515264511108398,
-0.13392017781734467,
-0.4137544333934784,
0.08932870626449585,
-0.21208593249320984,
-0.5710504055023193,
-0.14679403603076935,
-0.7422334551811218,
-0.6684949994087219,
-0.40845033526420593,
0.5404435396194458,
0.6172376275062561,
-0.15902121365070343,
0.2952928841114044,
-0.6923243403434753,
0.19929440319538116,
0.7550272941589355,
0.2268163114786148,
-0.18862080574035645,
-0.39749300479888916,
-0.1569911539554596,
-0.017314724624156952,
-0.5533075928688049,
-0.8572008609771729,
0.1447748839855194,
0.4458772838115692,
0.46227866411209106,
0.8005098104476929,
-0.18925294280052185,
0.778001606464386,
-0.35629767179489136,
0.8188120722770691,
0.39804330468177795,
-0.738946795463562,
0.807337760925293,
-0.2460804432630539,
0.2125503569841385,
0.7093908786773682,
0.18726001679897308,
-0.02010379172861576,
-0.18908175826072693,
-0.8283452987670898,
-0.9656382203102112,
0.16020530462265015,
-0.5958459377288818,
0.2216968685388565,
-0.12012279778718948,
0.6169865727424622,
0.1529044210910797,
0.4997715353965759,
-0.44309067726135254,
-0.32838526368141174,
-0.4809629023075104,
-0.7915229201316833,
-0.30190783739089966,
-0.1771787703037262,
-0.22175706923007965,
-0.4067964255809784,
0.5098941922187805,
-0.2902488708496094,
0.03167663514614105,
-0.21743662655353546,
0.14397983253002167,
0.19256086647510529,
0.1617361307144165,
0.5958858728408813,
0.47045737504959106,
-0.43619146943092346,
0.5060081481933594,
0.13716934621334076,
-0.8131064772605896,
0.19889980554580688,
-0.17550943791866302,
-0.17718681693077087,
0.054207030683755875,
0.05954424664378166,
0.6123166084289551,
0.46255168318748474,
-0.6986961364746094,
0.4727160334587097,
-0.0024011924397200346,
-0.09560415893793106,
-0.049716636538505554,
0.6676285266876221,
0.35704147815704346,
0.12544213235378265,
0.22585324943065643,
0.20480602979660034,
-0.03951104357838631,
-0.6636898517608643,
0.1682225614786148,
0.6481954455375671,
-0.3776957094669342,
-0.4408641457557678,
0.6823912262916565,
0.28907909989356995,
-0.5259944796562195,
0.5354926586151123,
0.02674596942961216,
-0.6776082515716553,
0.6395941376686096,
0.6397857069969177,
0.6821050643920898,
0.02587910182774067,
0.3181169629096985,
0.28753823041915894,
0.15437860786914825,
-0.22105512022972107,
0.67080157995224,
-0.5741478800773621,
-0.4568457305431366,
0.011744287796318531,
-0.3302708864212036,
-0.6790891885757446,
-0.13516007363796234,
-0.612338662147522,
0.27157455682754517,
-0.6931238174438477,
-0.5336450338363647,
-0.18038682639598846,
0.296032577753067,
-0.5533440113067627,
0.19726425409317017,
-0.17121626436710358,
0.7287898063659668,
-0.6423397660255432,
0.9010725021362305,
1.0099056959152222,
-0.3200342059135437,
-1.015224814414978,
-0.17124250531196594,
0.0031884759664535522,
-0.8158829808235168,
0.5572782754898071,
0.3695327639579773,
0.06630904972553253,
-0.04969019070267677,
-0.49964579939842224,
-0.6808374524116516,
1.3557089567184448,
0.2661409080028534,
-0.6201452016830444,
0.42041072249412537,
-0.033645935356616974,
0.40230894088745117,
-0.18505480885505676,
0.2803192734718323,
0.3974874019622803,
0.36476871371269226,
-0.08712504804134369,
-0.5293505191802979,
-0.08951768279075623,
-0.2180541604757309,
-0.3377608358860016,
0.2442421019077301,
-0.7707211375236511,
0.7244632840156555,
-0.986717700958252,
-0.1933155655860901,
-0.038385793566703796,
0.7018821835517883,
0.5930768847465515,
0.8195443153381348,
0.05432208627462387,
0.7727792263031006,
1.2729560136795044,
-0.12765571475028992,
0.6255799531936646,
-0.5752881765365601,
0.10419731587171555,
1.2880312204360962,
-0.08499110490083694,
0.8572741150856018,
1.0187021493911743,
0.19805099070072174,
0.4656903147697449,
0.9080731868743896,
-0.19567975401878357,
0.6340453028678894,
0.3763599693775177,
-0.28281694650650024,
-0.35317784547805786,
-0.19254730641841888,
-0.32810649275779724,
-0.005818995647132397,
0.4234470725059509,
-0.13524049520492554,
0.26753562688827515,
-0.10907378047704697,
0.11781790107488632,
-0.09732154756784439,
-0.459743469953537,
0.688429594039917,
0.22207388281822205,
-0.9682705998420715,
0.43153172731399536,
-0.28426241874694824,
0.9309858083724976,
-0.506493091583252,
0.08867821842432022,
-0.41519805788993835,
0.4417891800403595,
-0.5374914407730103,
-0.8744301795959473,
-0.33151358366012573,
-0.278083473443985,
-0.19708776473999023,
-0.04958260431885719,
0.48498526215553284,
-0.7071253061294556,
-0.2305266559123993,
-0.10446657985448837,
0.25196781754493713,
0.266281396150589,
0.4957126975059509,
-0.5838225483894348,
-0.491271048784256,
-0.07274161279201508,
-0.032897211611270905,
0.45688092708587646,
0.24400143325328827,
0.14830924570560455,
0.7562821507453918,
0.7861335277557373,
0.16713282465934753,
0.0256736371666193,
-0.1423538625240326,
0.5323341488838196,
-0.5698638558387756,
-0.27089351415634155,
-0.7774685621261597,
0.4757274091243744,
0.08576773852109909,
-0.7472699880599976,
1.0226240158081055,
0.34349697828292847,
0.7842037081718445,
-0.03179023414850235,
0.5320943593978882,
0.7447671294212341,
0.024111805483698845,
-0.646573007106781,
0.5326418280601501,
-0.5671947598457336,
0.365352064371109,
-0.02190259099006653,
-0.9772732853889465,
-0.08281751722097397,
0.7270185351371765,
-0.0025495835579931736,
-0.1292850226163864,
0.48622605204582214,
0.7826679348945618,
-0.09483791142702103,
0.12508265674114227,
0.11306416243314743,
-0.26503804326057434,
0.07417703419923782,
0.5884636640548706,
0.7544707655906677,
-0.2925077974796295,
0.23526445031166077,
-0.3086663484573364,
-0.09164409339427948,
-0.5714213252067566,
-0.826025128364563,
-0.9813258647918701,
-0.303257554769516,
-0.6424595713615417,
-0.3504873216152191,
0.14613792300224304,
1.1053886413574219,
0.5406392216682434,
-0.468772292137146,
-0.2008621096611023,
-0.038387835025787354,
0.5454535484313965,
-0.20448412001132965,
-0.22065280377864838,
0.4334511160850525,
-0.30668798089027405,
-0.3602655529975891,
0.40123704075813293,
0.13611485064029694,
0.6037303805351257,
-0.12475522607564926,
-0.22689910233020782,
0.22757220268249512,
0.4108920395374298,
0.39313820004463196,
0.01586657203733921,
-0.45401719212532043,
-0.11314228177070618,
0.09940419346094131,
-0.26905614137649536,
-0.15151441097259521,
0.6975123882293701,
-0.7506622076034546,
0.5185086131095886,
0.5199620127677917,
0.5865194797515869,
0.12039222568273544,
-0.2454342097043991,
0.13446775078773499,
-0.23777933418750763,
-0.17816662788391113,
-0.03858860582113266,
0.34258145093917847,
0.3455395996570587,
-0.2823183834552765,
0.3905199468135834,
0.38218367099761963,
-0.5720733404159546,
-0.6953869462013245,
-0.08033905178308487,
-0.9859854578971863,
-0.1988377720117569,
0.9941295981407166,
0.0195987019687891,
-0.11735818535089493,
0.050243765115737915,
-0.2909959852695465,
0.07922893762588501,
-0.4655455946922302,
1.0933592319488525,
0.4870792329311371,
-0.1373571902513504,
0.30168789625167847,
-0.375713974237442,
0.4533139169216156,
0.8171112537384033,
-0.4578336477279663,
-0.727603554725647,
0.3062044382095337,
0.4988580644130707,
0.18552091717720032,
0.43588095903396606,
0.19426332414150238,
0.5681235790252686,
-0.17581097781658173,
-0.11383459717035294,
-0.31034693121910095,
-0.5705631971359253,
-0.39021673798561096,
0.0895833745598793,
0.05773971229791641,
-0.3820287585258484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15334v1 | Multimodal Task Vectors Enable Many-Shot Multimodal In-Context Learning | 2024-06-21T17:50:02 | 2024-06-21T17:50:02 | Brandon Huang, Chancharik Mitra, Assaf Arbelle, Leonid Karlinsky, Trevor Darrell, Roei Herzig | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The recent success of interleaved Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) in few-shot
learning suggests that in-context learning (ICL) with many examples can be
promising for learning new tasks. However, this many-shot multimodal ICL
setting has one crucial problem: it is fundamentally limited by the model's
context length set at pretraining. The problem is especially prominent in the
multimodal domain, which processes both text and images, requiring additional
tokens. This motivates the need for a multimodal method to compress many shots
into fewer tokens without finetuning. In this work, we enable LMMs to perform
multimodal, many-shot in-context learning by leveraging Multimodal Task Vectors
(MTV)--compact implicit representations of in-context examples compressed in
the model's attention heads. Specifically, we first demonstrate the existence
of such MTV in LMMs and then leverage these extracted MTV to enable many-shot
in-context learning for various vision-and-language tasks. Our experiments
suggest that MTV can scale in performance with the number of compressed shots
and generalize to similar out-of-domain tasks without additional context length
for inference. | [
-0.5372414588928223,
-0.527809202671051,
0.40952572226524353,
0.23480837047100067,
-0.4509233236312866,
-0.20490719377994537,
-0.39637497067451477,
-0.17569102346897125,
-0.09989378601312637,
-0.03754683583974838,
-0.807704508304596,
-0.2975810170173645,
-0.7178765535354614,
0.0291290320456028,
0.01690707728266716,
0.7643246650695801,
-0.016687961295247078,
0.06841550767421722,
-0.5485427975654602,
-0.2619350552558899,
-0.7752941250801086,
-0.4625912010669708,
-0.3413235545158386,
-0.04634387791156769,
0.6944926977157593,
0.6178634166717529,
0.10964931547641754,
0.18625177443027496,
0.5306960344314575,
0.2501660883426666,
0.27451950311660767,
0.6694841980934143,
-0.6189368367195129,
0.20449794828891754,
0.03305762633681297,
-0.21278434991836548,
-0.15533562004566193,
0.05562594532966614,
0.7615838646888733,
0.39012089371681213,
0.43778273463249207,
0.2861124277114868,
0.3838467001914978,
0.28482168912887573,
-1.0668730735778809,
0.44273456931114197,
-0.4888055622577667,
0.09250273555517197,
-0.21098414063453674,
-0.5044590830802917,
-0.5245917439460754,
0.46783876419067383,
0.045399732887744904,
-0.7592896819114685,
-0.043023731559515,
-0.11926417052745819,
0.6180464625358582,
0.46835198998451233,
-0.760661780834198,
0.00026813228032551706,
-0.5432350039482117,
1.0853158235549927,
-0.28906965255737305,
0.5548324584960938,
0.3830714821815491,
0.427956223487854,
-0.12242011725902557,
-0.6274518370628357,
-0.5247659087181091,
-0.08946691453456879,
-0.001450413721613586,
0.09126701951026917,
-0.05964241549372673,
0.0742468312382698,
0.3594261407852173,
-0.3115846514701843,
-0.48692184686660767,
-0.037605997174978256,
-0.3236336410045624,
-0.0254537221044302,
0.12999625504016876,
0.055389780551195145,
-0.061167217791080475,
-0.3574479818344116,
-0.8161131143569946,
-0.3573925793170929,
-0.765945315361023,
0.3648827373981476,
-0.10252722352743149,
0.3236340284347534,
-0.09684918820858002,
0.4841289222240448,
-0.16392633318901062,
0.8497061729431152,
-0.02562304213643074,
-0.5568643808364868,
0.2716023921966553,
-0.4929993450641632,
-0.2931230068206787,
-0.24782738089561462,
0.5258495211601257,
0.37874576449394226,
0.00138562498614192,
-0.13280576467514038,
-0.0007102458621375263,
0.2133520096540451,
0.274208128452301,
-0.8974096179008484,
0.24538694322109222,
0.08829086273908615,
-0.4210357964038849,
0.282522976398468,
0.028948502615094185,
-0.5172582864761353,
0.08639996498823166,
-0.5179027318954468,
0.8691163659095764,
-0.5120428800582886,
-0.09511896222829819,
-0.055574409663677216,
-0.3239403963088989,
0.09178967773914337,
0.2433892786502838,
-0.4976973831653595,
-0.048703040927648544,
0.48421934247016907,
0.7987964153289795,
-0.20695587992668152,
-0.52211993932724,
-0.8503749966621399,
0.35689979791641235,
-0.21341943740844727,
0.7976751327514648,
-0.8131639361381531,
-0.3028329014778137,
0.009270992130041122,
-0.06030583381652832,
-0.10120466351509094,
-0.3031006157398224,
0.2745152413845062,
-0.2924116849899292,
-0.2673630118370056,
-0.2070041447877884,
-0.4251955449581146,
-0.3328719437122345,
0.4858351945877075,
-0.32877597212791443,
0.7996913194656372,
-0.05892430990934372,
-0.43438199162483215,
0.5858606100082397,
-0.457035094499588,
-0.35728344321250916,
-0.12534809112548828,
-0.3904084861278534,
-0.28289565443992615,
0.2535908818244934,
0.3863750994205475,
1.1717621088027954,
-0.015135015361011028,
-0.04888555780053139,
-0.3766975998878479,
-0.4732051193714142,
0.20241448283195496,
-0.5994037985801697,
0.45492830872535706,
0.09529945254325867,
-0.023604052141308784,
0.3566722273826599,
-0.510031521320343,
-0.04055822268128395,
-0.16235844790935516,
-0.355561763048172,
-0.28923749923706055,
-0.3060181736946106,
0.16374778747558594,
0.7710909247398376,
-0.21317839622497559,
-0.5697635412216187,
0.0730682909488678,
0.03852832317352295,
0.31163838505744934,
0.5895738005638123,
-0.13866044580936432,
0.5484504103660583,
-0.3956865966320038,
0.5297266244888306,
0.48279625177383423,
0.03939342126250267,
-0.6389127373695374,
-0.2517501413822174,
-0.5460654497146606,
-0.8918921947479248,
0.043306462466716766,
0.04011029750108719,
-1.2701656818389893,
-0.1540030688047409,
-0.45566487312316895,
-0.27947908639907837,
-0.06107321009039879,
0.27084362506866455,
0.6625468134880066,
0.49772122502326965,
0.4562409818172455,
-0.4791308045387268,
-0.2884082496166229,
-0.794021487236023,
0.08702309429645538,
0.29021209478378296,
0.11218908429145813,
0.5397428870201111,
0.5590879917144775,
-0.12114302814006805,
0.9986253380775452,
-0.3918382227420807,
-0.8187834024429321,
-0.19848430156707764,
0.2841780483722687,
-0.2155216932296753,
0.6212818026542664,
0.5613147020339966,
-0.8300787210464478,
-0.3132666349411011,
-0.4240364730358124,
-0.681614100933075,
0.37833938002586365,
-0.22635863721370697,
-0.12204370647668839,
-0.16554364562034607,
0.8382164239883423,
-0.7441276907920837,
0.38965070247650146,
0.6023264527320862,
-0.17148813605308533,
0.3039979934692383,
-0.3362239599227905,
0.1605227142572403,
-0.9280810356140137,
-0.32223424315452576,
0.20457139611244202,
-0.5027950406074524,
-0.4680013060569763,
0.04954322427511215,
0.42536023259162903,
-0.16228923201560974,
-1.1253001689910889,
0.5013254880905151,
-0.5455937385559082,
-0.13104316592216492,
-0.3424881398677826,
-0.11712714284658432,
0.2578892409801483,
0.9862320423126221,
-0.07904958724975586,
0.5347575545310974,
0.744480550289154,
-0.9248689413070679,
0.15197592973709106,
0.4694380760192871,
-0.36287400126457214,
0.903839111328125,
-0.1852843016386032,
0.04856104031205177,
-0.727156937122345,
0.7337150573730469,
-1.0058085918426514,
-0.428975373506546,
0.07693447917699814,
-0.3375466465950012,
0.5508856177330017,
-0.18894021213054657,
-0.2956348955631256,
0.023740654811263084,
-0.2816464304924011,
1.056980848312378,
0.1155737116932869,
-0.5728672742843628,
0.7335713505744934,
0.19480592012405396,
0.16641825437545776,
-0.8633782863616943,
-0.7045840620994568,
-0.08713274449110031,
-0.2743780314922333,
-0.3867526352405548,
0.5499711036682129,
-0.18156059086322784,
0.17676942050457,
0.03536910191178322,
0.0006309947348199785,
-0.21441251039505005,
-0.17311064898967743,
0.5013712048530579,
0.10588064789772034,
-0.10350735485553741,
0.5128608345985413,
0.07337962090969086,
-0.09536463022232056,
-0.2593235969543457,
-0.1506245732307434,
0.366317480802536,
0.09280867129564285,
-0.45878931879997253,
-0.27729475498199463,
0.6481006741523743,
0.6918927431106567,
-0.4366859197616577,
0.582541286945343,
0.9069037437438965,
-0.40711307525634766,
-0.22632326185703278,
-0.2651287913322449,
-0.17924197018146515,
-0.3960822522640228,
0.608083188533783,
-0.5697263479232788,
-1.0101337432861328,
-0.0619211308658123,
-0.26682770252227783,
-0.01552831381559372,
0.16939961910247803,
0.5910112857818604,
-0.18153154850006104,
0.7641387581825256,
0.5652256011962891,
0.44276705384254456,
0.6007941365242004,
-0.5102337598800659,
-0.13623231649398804,
-1.106615662574768,
-0.32970649003982544,
0.04458702728152275,
-0.730166494846344,
-0.021197723224759102,
-0.97383713722229,
0.8279334902763367,
-0.11932814121246338,
-0.005024363286793232,
0.1709769070148468,
-0.07918983697891235,
0.6882160902023315,
0.6587835550308228,
0.5904265642166138,
0.04006030037999153,
-0.172368586063385,
-0.08099054545164108,
-0.022995760664343834,
-0.8238554000854492,
0.10866159945726395,
1.170129656791687,
0.11890289932489395,
0.6066593527793884,
0.09637299925088882,
0.47948595881462097,
-0.11155533045530319,
0.09717407822608948,
-0.8744628429412842,
0.5440672636032104,
-0.2791920602321625,
-0.5488606691360474,
-0.11051242798566818,
-0.21275882422924042,
-0.8192545175552368,
0.4578929543495178,
-0.5430801510810852,
-0.1632842719554901,
0.44632530212402344,
0.17242060601711273,
-0.8434005379676819,
-0.08135724067687988,
-0.658022940158844,
0.973848819732666,
-0.04157302528619766,
-0.5271668434143066,
-0.34851008653640747,
-0.7236390709877014,
0.32268020510673523,
0.05825182795524597,
0.12470179796218872,
-0.3901984989643097,
-0.09766408056020737,
0.4194467067718506,
-0.03811332955956459,
1.0763670206069946,
-0.1795186996459961,
0.18945014476776123,
0.15081223845481873,
-0.026393655687570572,
0.2601509392261505,
0.15133430063724518,
0.616317093372345,
0.1740298569202423,
-0.15879566967487335,
-0.36591067910194397,
-0.45342931151390076,
0.7468727231025696,
-0.3548717796802521,
-0.19292013347148895,
-0.4251379370689392,
-1.0002167224884033,
-0.47576484084129333,
0.020018378272652626,
0.45497751235961914,
1.129327654838562,
-0.020636554807424545,
0.4681280553340912,
0.5435947775840759,
-0.23416487872600555,
0.8645227551460266,
0.003985774703323841,
0.05926065519452095,
-0.0479324609041214,
0.8511987328529358,
0.15580247342586517,
0.22830434143543243,
0.5401506423950195,
-0.09543422609567642,
-0.28578275442123413,
-0.31695762276649475,
-0.3104833662509918,
-0.06583526730537415,
-1.009592890739441,
-0.5324093699455261,
-0.6533945798873901,
0.1993066966533661,
-0.2511824071407318,
-0.25039130449295044,
-0.3148736357688904,
-0.2544172704219818,
-0.4837951064109802,
0.05915586277842522,
0.0439644493162632,
0.38302749395370483,
-0.05629283934831619,
0.32683372497558594,
-0.7601004838943481,
0.7410174608230591,
0.6564127802848816,
0.22163964807987213,
0.018066558986902237,
-0.4006185233592987,
-0.27568385004997253,
-0.045019377022981644,
-0.35627278685569763,
-0.45257169008255005,
0.5341306328773499,
0.6908571720123291,
0.20171505212783813,
0.4508296251296997,
-0.06920704245567322,
1.172926902770996,
-0.9050014615058899,
0.5622659921646118,
0.44183677434921265,
-0.6596940755844116,
0.09675819426774979,
-0.16149984300136566,
0.6977197527885437,
0.2859756350517273,
0.570853054523468,
-0.25871753692626953,
-0.05347403511404991,
-0.15520043671131134,
-0.7122505307197571,
0.5846741795539856,
0.006112723611295223,
0.3281100392341614,
-0.1588870733976364,
0.04513116180896759,
0.2186800092458725,
0.17590783536434174,
-0.577261745929718,
-0.08210691064596176,
-0.3419540226459503,
-0.24925722181797028,
-0.42893800139427185,
-0.4447691738605499,
-0.11201582103967667,
-0.35462135076522827,
0.3043646812438965,
-0.41910356283187866,
0.3966369032859802,
0.25089752674102783,
-0.6182631850242615,
0.19428494572639465,
0.23083125054836273,
0.8832435607910156,
0.6786577701568604,
0.02518025040626526,
0.5066269040107727,
0.0853666216135025,
-0.17652414739131927,
0.256207138299942,
-0.07137787342071533,
0.34704530239105225,
-0.07069049030542374,
0.2642227113246918,
0.926252543926239,
0.8614640235900879,
-0.879756510257721,
0.8173004984855652,
-0.14514590799808502,
-0.061263393610715866,
-0.3256241977214813,
-0.3203747272491455,
-0.14397026598453522,
0.6296961307525635,
0.3082524240016937,
0.44781190156936646,
0.032154474407434464,
-0.4421332776546478,
0.40517571568489075,
0.7000949382781982,
-0.5495732426643372,
-0.2743627429008484,
0.6449204683303833,
0.1998128741979599,
0.17770777642726898,
0.38166534900665283,
-0.2679918706417084,
-0.1983329802751541,
0.24902454018592834,
0.5603073835372925,
0.690273106098175,
0.165358766913414,
0.09192503243684769,
0.2217566817998886,
0.015763605013489723,
-0.12369559705257416,
0.05565730109810829,
-0.290742427110672,
-0.6663907766342163,
-0.7783375382423401,
-0.49662405252456665,
-0.060179658234119415,
-0.06036083400249481,
-0.35063648223876953,
0.25090292096138,
-0.27988192439079285,
-0.29834237694740295,
-0.10651024430990219,
-0.6404380798339844,
-0.9698766469955444,
0.13154670596122742,
0.4156549870967865,
0.48972585797309875,
-0.498608261346817,
0.8706298470497131,
0.4000294506549835,
-0.2861887812614441,
-0.47598838806152344,
-0.11406013369560242,
0.08026907593011856,
-0.5078660249710083,
1.2202762365341187,
0.6548813581466675,
-0.19965559244155884,
0.04969640076160431,
-0.28911346197128296,
-0.8393455743789673,
1.086295247077942,
0.5393497943878174,
-0.3495067059993744,
-0.10307858139276505,
0.00006696725904475898,
-0.1010979488492012,
-0.44449374079704285,
0.15705132484436035,
-0.03811678662896156,
0.11446936428546906,
0.10136665403842926,
-0.8427925109863281,
-0.316551148891449,
0.014621752314269543,
0.13024820387363434,
0.07310889661312103,
-0.5631973147392273,
1.1168689727783203,
-0.033948421478271484,
-0.09545113146305084,
-0.44063234329223633,
0.7317115664482117,
-0.000940466474276036,
0.134231299161911,
0.5550369620323181,
0.4613747000694275,
0.2495080530643463,
0.09449312835931778,
1.1465932130813599,
0.06065601855516434,
0.10858514159917831,
1.0801355838775635,
-0.09026458859443665,
0.8763971924781799,
0.633919358253479,
0.47496965527534485,
0.1798417568206787,
0.2379533052444458,
0.4540752172470093,
0.7275658249855042,
-0.2520390748977661,
-0.44871681928634644,
-0.5456437468528748,
-0.3493344187736511,
0.13444983959197998,
0.9151213765144348,
0.33208954334259033,
-0.028681103140115738,
-0.3808750510215759,
0.8121472001075745,
-0.126694455742836,
-0.18370741605758667,
-0.6025792360305786,
0.5276734828948975,
0.2232007086277008,
-0.6189108490943909,
0.4806196391582489,
-0.17173238098621368,
1.0560203790664673,
-0.7360180616378784,
-0.23722946643829346,
0.33795300126075745,
0.37146785855293274,
0.04666866734623909,
-0.38199514150619507,
0.23923251032829285,
-0.26376909017562866,
-0.1197904720902443,
-0.5590536594390869,
0.7984150648117065,
-0.7194669246673584,
-0.32442402839660645,
0.09126100689172745,
0.43905141949653625,
-0.21153727173805237,
-0.4438299238681793,
-0.3418269157409668,
0.12270135432481766,
-0.5263688564300537,
-0.08180568367242813,
0.6728238463401794,
0.2845940589904785,
0.08501061052083969,
0.5849470496177673,
0.5497348308563232,
-0.33733657002449036,
0.30026644468307495,
-0.35045287013053894,
0.8074272274971008,
-0.3241139352321625,
-0.4342948794364929,
-0.9628981351852417,
0.5555202960968018,
0.21010397374629974,
-0.47434020042419434,
0.7938017249107361,
0.3041265904903412,
1.130014181137085,
-0.36661332845687866,
0.47691452503204346,
0.05427040904760361,
0.14125579595565796,
-0.7940931916236877,
0.33361682295799255,
-0.8356374502182007,
-0.3570947051048279,
-0.25716423988342285,
-0.6472356915473938,
-0.4585036039352417,
0.6004112958908081,
0.06016956642270088,
-0.08151296526193619,
0.7932710647583008,
0.568191409111023,
-0.38013383746147156,
-0.5930370688438416,
0.6797350645065308,
-0.21702717244625092,
0.17874231934547424,
0.8949786424636841,
0.650945782661438,
-0.23918843269348145,
0.7274705171585083,
-0.38654351234436035,
-0.06795553117990494,
-0.236991748213768,
-0.9590724110603333,
-1.0330431461334229,
-0.9732218980789185,
-0.22520050406455994,
0.005828833673149347,
-0.25558310747146606,
1.2615641355514526,
1.1270097494125366,
-0.3081403076648712,
-0.10885261744260788,
0.3928104639053345,
-0.29832372069358826,
-0.625877857208252,
-0.09347780793905258,
0.1698383241891861,
-0.5170499086380005,
-0.8932558298110962,
0.7087874412536621,
0.5303823947906494,
-0.08420605957508087,
-0.1999928057193756,
-0.08609878271818161,
-0.520176112651825,
-0.1279824674129486,
1.1802808046340942,
0.11089397966861725,
-0.5100736618041992,
-0.3300359547138214,
-0.15026988089084625,
-0.038151636719703674,
0.16848137974739075,
1.0090296268463135,
-1.053219199180603,
0.5247503519058228,
0.39588528871536255,
0.8089802265167236,
0.6211569905281067,
-0.2742372751235962,
0.360158234834671,
-1.5543279647827148,
0.802679181098938,
0.1789254993200302,
0.5354987978935242,
0.15777526795864105,
-0.019423754885792732,
0.15362940728664398,
0.00419703358784318,
-0.31012290716171265,
-0.7074204683303833,
0.48761048913002014,
-1.1521750688552856,
-0.5497971177101135,
1.2951158285140991,
-0.228582501411438,
-0.20397064089775085,
-0.08212532848119736,
-0.3342142403125763,
0.28701189160346985,
-0.2270515114068985,
0.2570655047893524,
0.5402580499649048,
-0.16231711208820343,
-0.32003915309906006,
-0.6192875504493713,
0.5792849659919739,
0.2842448949813843,
-0.6106863617897034,
-0.17642688751220703,
0.6356136202812195,
-0.03351167216897011,
0.1236610859632492,
0.5138506889343262,
0.1594209522008896,
0.44198545813560486,
-0.18295080959796906,
-0.07758498191833496,
-0.4882271885871887,
-0.734266996383667,
-0.28518351912498474,
0.46615689992904663,
-0.2473718523979187,
-0.4764982759952545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15330v1 | Gradient-Mask Tuning Elevates the Upper Limits of LLM Performance | 2024-06-21T17:42:52 | 2024-06-21T17:42:52 | Haoling Li, Xin Zhang, Xiao Liu, Yeyun Gong, Yifan Wang, Yujiu Yang, Qi Chen, Peng Cheng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized lots of fields of research.
Although it is well-known that fine-tuning is essential for enhancing the
capabilities of LLMs, existing research suggests that there is potential
redundancy in the fine-tuning process and therefore proposes to update only a
subset of parameters. However, these methods fail to leverage the task-specific
information to identify important parameters during training. Based on the
insight that gradients inherently contain information on task-specific data, we
propose Gradient-Mask Tuning (GMT), a method that selectively updates
parameters during training based on their gradient information. Specifically,
we compute the absolute values of the gradients and apply masking to those with
relatively smaller magnitudes. Our empirical results across various tasks
demonstrate that GMT not only outperforms traditional fine-tuning methods but
also elevates the upper limits of LLM performance. Further analysis indicates
that GMT exhibits insensitivity to mask ratio and possesses computational
efficiency comparable to vanilla SFT. | [
-0.6242325305938721,
-0.7252631783485413,
0.1935911625623703,
0.1570168286561966,
-0.32288649678230286,
0.3481297194957733,
-0.5237600207328796,
-0.511236846446991,
0.008932332508265972,
0.4206382930278778,
-0.5954406261444092,
-0.48246583342552185,
-0.7654755711555481,
-0.23444345593452454,
-0.16482596099376678,
1.064072847366333,
0.0470384918153286,
-0.15557701885700226,
0.05791335552930832,
-0.10292031615972519,
-0.34901562333106995,
-0.3380521535873413,
-1.0954457521438599,
-0.27355045080184937,
0.6169859170913696,
0.1847926676273346,
0.37687578797340393,
1.097885251045227,
0.6584398150444031,
0.20553719997406006,
-0.17812812328338623,
0.30176225304603577,
-0.5776660442352295,
0.14054988324642181,
0.03386044502258301,
-0.5753588080406189,
-0.4278029799461365,
0.03242509067058563,
0.9033046364784241,
0.47066861391067505,
-0.1802000105381012,
0.24160580337047577,
0.30589112639427185,
0.8752406239509583,
-0.8444533944129944,
0.13364025950431824,
-0.9466854929924011,
0.2614426016807556,
-0.4916992485523224,
-0.49395835399627686,
-0.0033193309791386127,
-0.01101613137871027,
-0.34918907284736633,
-0.6000867486000061,
0.4731757938861847,
0.03484172374010086,
0.7380300164222717,
0.5951617956161499,
-0.015718592330813408,
0.05169052630662918,
-0.5814001560211182,
0.6652034521102905,
-0.4580192267894745,
0.3316676616668701,
0.5346060991287231,
0.29355138540267944,
-0.012805992737412453,
-0.293740451335907,
-0.1016375944018364,
-0.1962609738111496,
0.019670072942972183,
-0.04263851419091225,
-0.12286435067653656,
0.438387930393219,
0.6304779052734375,
0.4455302953720093,
-0.3638301491737366,
0.2785588502883911,
-0.2562881112098694,
-0.28885751962661743,
0.3403031826019287,
0.15839654207229614,
-0.015810007229447365,
0.3781977891921997,
-0.2634090483188629,
0.12442118674516678,
-0.7362463474273682,
0.05537375807762146,
0.3895690143108368,
0.2809893488883972,
0.27383866906166077,
0.4365028142929077,
-0.555067777633667,
0.8695481419563293,
0.31026318669319153,
0.005244354251772165,
-0.02033107727766037,
-0.026771700009703636,
-0.4371330440044403,
-0.2760201394557953,
0.37271350622177124,
0.27907392382621765,
0.2873438000679016,
-0.3539379835128784,
-0.4906213581562042,
-0.07199975848197937,
0.05389838665723801,
-0.8964917659759521,
-0.08690997213125229,
-0.218891441822052,
-0.01994669996201992,
-0.3481065332889557,
0.019588608294725418,
-0.7186042666435242,
-0.5996535420417786,
-0.4603782296180725,
0.44300082325935364,
0.0718541070818901,
0.01463573519140482,
0.35283422470092773,
0.017105644568800926,
0.08125876635313034,
0.40906983613967896,
-1.069136142730713,
0.1963370442390442,
0.8487852811813354,
0.9861685633659363,
-0.3653472363948822,
-0.11835495382547379,
-0.9479392766952515,
0.0565946102142334,
-0.1835184097290039,
0.5192288756370544,
-0.8104235529899597,
-0.14640818536281586,
-0.09764470905065536,
-0.01929747685790062,
-0.2524212896823883,
-0.8565477132797241,
0.4421476423740387,
-0.6159218549728394,
-0.4229290187358856,
-0.38524505496025085,
-0.2514679729938507,
0.25679811835289,
0.14890030026435852,
-0.5081884264945984,
1.2277647256851196,
0.18308506906032562,
-0.47915250062942505,
0.3590397834777832,
-0.6238160133361816,
-0.43582218885421753,
0.012891708873212337,
-0.007430471014231443,
-0.42854106426239014,
0.3846922218799591,
0.2831031382083893,
0.4287942349910736,
-0.4963562786579132,
0.13788308203220367,
0.0016458476893603802,
-0.5655205845832825,
0.19798997044563293,
-0.32692790031433105,
0.4095635414123535,
0.08221810311079025,
-0.40900686383247375,
0.08386681973934174,
-0.7733443379402161,
-0.041265737265348434,
-0.24549810588359833,
-0.5849199295043945,
-0.03062720037996769,
-0.16908347606658936,
-0.2914990782737732,
0.29439353942871094,
0.17699629068374634,
-0.6485666632652283,
0.06730096787214279,
-0.11714940518140793,
0.5405849814414978,
1.2248038053512573,
-0.2379945069551468,
0.3654092848300934,
-0.7180173993110657,
0.8590489029884338,
-0.10367949306964874,
0.08704385906457901,
-0.003332283813506365,
-0.4420592486858368,
-1.0440335273742676,
-0.583422064781189,
0.4543665945529938,
0.6391066312789917,
-0.3077716529369354,
0.30773767828941345,
-0.07115848362445831,
-0.3756003677845001,
-0.6533339023590088,
0.30950605869293213,
0.44111573696136475,
0.7181772589683533,
0.31592968106269836,
-0.2800999581813812,
-0.47902366518974304,
-0.906229555606842,
-0.5386554002761841,
0.25371265411376953,
-0.2577391266822815,
0.3877539038658142,
0.18447689712047577,
-0.07365650683641434,
0.6642872095108032,
-0.627884030342102,
-0.4022046625614166,
0.1858227252960205,
0.031180761754512787,
0.13658864796161652,
0.5064835548400879,
0.354832261800766,
-0.2904159426689148,
-0.6057259440422058,
0.2160796970129013,
-0.24950182437896729,
-0.5339564681053162,
-0.040935538709163666,
-0.23144058883190155,
0.05595523118972778,
0.8108430504798889,
-0.3751419484615326,
0.3309985399246216,
0.6476157903671265,
-0.052318230271339417,
0.28168797492980957,
-0.12725339829921722,
-0.010951094329357147,
-0.52765291929245,
0.1265067160129547,
0.31836023926734924,
-0.4437883794307709,
-0.4893517792224884,
0.13033033907413483,
0.12312982976436615,
0.04614957794547081,
-0.15156662464141846,
0.7246184349060059,
-0.4363612234592438,
0.23071670532226562,
-0.41772225499153137,
-0.1316043734550476,
-0.16146817803382874,
0.6457405090332031,
-0.25307583808898926,
0.8785874247550964,
0.7610630393028259,
-0.5597907900810242,
0.24154485762119293,
-0.1912626028060913,
-0.4365776479244232,
0.5520686507225037,
-0.4620734751224518,
0.24310283362865448,
-0.1612258106470108,
0.06224505975842476,
-0.8258465528488159,
-0.08786828815937042,
0.16346025466918945,
-0.11072050034999847,
0.46964260935783386,
-0.42107683420181274,
-0.43932783603668213,
-0.07184529304504395,
-0.43123558163642883,
0.46612292528152466,
0.6117193102836609,
-0.5251671075820923,
0.44596484303474426,
0.4631345868110657,
-0.0721052959561348,
-0.7037945985794067,
-0.5901037454605103,
0.018009770661592484,
-0.37358200550079346,
-0.4496266841888428,
0.5542675256729126,
-0.22088655829429626,
0.027184385806322098,
-0.3611820340156555,
-0.41602763533592224,
0.08435001969337463,
0.17609921097755432,
0.1402239203453064,
-0.07626738399267197,
-0.31935223937034607,
0.059513114392757416,
0.03033313900232315,
-0.31457191705703735,
-0.12278759479522705,
-0.474010705947876,
0.4403991997241974,
-0.024912415072321892,
-0.2906445562839508,
-0.2324470579624176,
0.14658620953559875,
0.3783634305000305,
-0.2798255681991577,
0.5816330909729004,
0.8834643363952637,
-0.34836724400520325,
-0.5133466124534607,
-0.8186022043228149,
-0.25063425302505493,
-0.5820614099502563,
0.6138202548027039,
-0.424954354763031,
-1.1596769094467163,
0.8087852001190186,
-0.20526818931102753,
-0.14901258051395416,
0.2234838902950287,
0.3481733798980713,
-0.037783075124025345,
0.9776607155799866,
0.5754690170288086,
-0.2006409466266632,
0.8684338927268982,
0.06374356150627136,
-0.030235471203923225,
-1.2201449871063232,
-0.06971336156129837,
-0.5397515892982483,
-0.6826716661453247,
-0.5933722853660583,
-0.5070126056671143,
0.5139647126197815,
0.22064046561717987,
-0.37497565150260925,
-0.0019502531504258513,
-0.504672110080719,
0.958238959312439,
0.6095548868179321,
0.23983065783977509,
0.2937820851802826,
0.2595657408237457,
0.15987813472747803,
0.07514053583145142,
-0.5520823001861572,
-0.10563933849334717,
0.9478427767753601,
0.31214314699172974,
0.8114217519760132,
-0.10087623447179794,
0.1817684769630432,
0.15838047862052917,
0.23948104679584503,
-0.6066073775291443,
0.6521132588386536,
-0.38218602538108826,
-0.49100539088249207,
-0.37913018465042114,
-0.4180043637752533,
-0.8159034848213196,
0.4272415041923523,
-0.0627918615937233,
-0.6531649827957153,
0.022085221484303474,
0.3136852979660034,
-0.2133057713508606,
0.4150785803794861,
-0.41452643275260925,
0.4736925959587097,
0.1119602620601654,
-0.3510601222515106,
0.05530761182308197,
-0.5157520771026611,
0.003021874465048313,
-0.49919840693473816,
-0.005455616861581802,
-0.35139185190200806,
-0.2626842260360718,
0.7243422269821167,
-0.1705932319164276,
1.0388401746749878,
-0.25554436445236206,
-0.19335132837295532,
-0.19244050979614258,
0.166553795337677,
0.8663337826728821,
0.1566080003976822,
-0.23452621698379517,
0.1913391798734665,
-0.4031500816345215,
-0.5725676417350769,
-0.6293807029724121,
0.9081296324729919,
-0.5203912258148193,
-0.9920489192008972,
-0.23911713063716888,
-0.6219295859336853,
-0.5208135843276978,
0.10433682799339294,
0.18035045266151428,
0.2347317487001419,
0.19494181871414185,
0.2389906495809555,
0.8030174374580383,
-0.04441829025745392,
0.346046507358551,
0.46205830574035645,
0.016042228788137436,
-0.13651461899280548,
0.8927238583564758,
0.15379813313484192,
0.5543453693389893,
0.4595377743244171,
0.22974099218845367,
0.051171738654375076,
-0.9863990545272827,
-0.35782867670059204,
0.30101144313812256,
-0.7076312899589539,
-0.2844012379646301,
-0.3434598445892334,
-0.3624187111854553,
0.1580389440059662,
-0.2507714629173279,
-0.1625983864068985,
-0.4726176857948303,
-0.3321436047554016,
-0.06070772558450699,
0.30600520968437195,
0.3950118124485016,
-0.17279484868049622,
0.447782963514328,
-0.4250175952911377,
0.269189715385437,
0.4345751106739044,
0.7572179436683655,
-0.26706039905548096,
-0.746380627155304,
-0.48019424080848694,
0.12338512390851974,
-0.21528927981853485,
-0.20383304357528687,
0.038275524973869324,
0.3817919194698334,
0.4842285215854645,
0.2018868625164032,
-0.26552292704582214,
0.8097955584526062,
-0.48618313670158386,
0.45791560411453247,
-0.16901665925979614,
-0.9284248352050781,
0.4547768831253052,
-0.6935511231422424,
0.46668827533721924,
0.5578991770744324,
-0.1770143061876297,
-0.5589439868927002,
-0.535431444644928,
-0.132783904671669,
-0.7146051526069641,
0.9180634617805481,
0.05309969559311867,
0.2739771604537964,
0.2699877619743347,
0.539167046546936,
0.028814855962991714,
0.2869468331336975,
-0.5091307163238525,
-0.1901400238275528,
0.18411622941493988,
-0.03827835991978645,
-0.2220384180545807,
-0.11562641710042953,
-0.35379379987716675,
-0.5413145422935486,
0.5939700603485107,
-0.24708512425422668,
0.3009423613548279,
-0.2656642198562622,
-0.10614825040102005,
-0.4890984296798706,
-0.05995059013366699,
1.0029823780059814,
0.7377207279205322,
-0.39650261402130127,
0.08904591202735901,
0.31607934832572937,
-0.6513031125068665,
-0.05186867713928223,
0.05693947523832321,
-0.02653307095170021,
-0.23152178525924683,
0.14616113901138306,
1.0854536294937134,
-0.11748836934566498,
-0.5508997440338135,
0.4687691926956177,
0.16447526216506958,
-0.19169792532920837,
0.18970519304275513,
0.5021191835403442,
-0.1748187243938446,
0.23365674912929535,
0.39549368619918823,
0.4969032108783722,
-0.26462844014167786,
-0.22999770939350128,
0.06609740108251572,
0.6844757199287415,
-0.40864425897598267,
-0.24226953089237213,
0.6755667328834534,
0.11467945575714111,
-0.2025894969701767,
0.315245121717453,
0.023695308715105057,
-0.2674253582954407,
0.809286892414093,
0.5957343578338623,
0.9403776526451111,
-0.3329632580280304,
0.048362668603658676,
0.17973196506500244,
0.5442562103271484,
-0.02581247314810753,
-0.0023789212573319674,
-0.05735502019524574,
-0.5392090678215027,
-0.6523706912994385,
-0.7709819674491882,
-0.09860236197710037,
0.4088438153266907,
-0.4718573987483978,
0.24705420434474945,
-0.6116493940353394,
-0.10178825259208679,
-0.03159387409687042,
-0.23573066294193268,
-0.5932978391647339,
0.24370311200618744,
-0.0313091054558754,
0.8475351333618164,
-0.5757444500923157,
0.8639874458312988,
0.3242942988872528,
0.18849359452724457,
-0.19101616740226746,
0.15057027339935303,
-0.08674588799476624,
-1.1635403633117676,
0.695646345615387,
-0.052133288234472275,
-0.36327171325683594,
0.0750872939825058,
-0.17601391673088074,
-0.888397753238678,
0.9554952383041382,
0.8550111055374146,
-0.7586472630500793,
-0.013596553355455399,
0.3947598338127136,
0.4596824049949646,
-0.28051427006721497,
-0.0700816661119461,
0.5695387721061707,
0.536919891834259,
0.11611571162939072,
-1.0571762323379517,
0.19836436212062836,
-0.16943082213401794,
0.06444624811410904,
0.6109208464622498,
-0.7331106066703796,
0.8071881532669067,
0.010437091812491417,
-0.18276512622833252,
-0.14395317435264587,
0.11023495346307755,
-0.08889603614807129,
-0.05265682190656662,
0.43448394536972046,
0.5858600735664368,
0.9958081841468811,
-0.24736708402633667,
0.9659425616264343,
-0.35567307472229004,
0.28148481249809265,
0.8688284158706665,
0.009473953396081924,
0.41806504130363464,
0.32274752855300903,
-0.06335004419088364,
-0.20606066286563873,
0.6591772437095642,
-0.003657776862382889,
0.5879968404769897,
0.646673321723938,
-0.48043057322502136,
-0.2786965072154999,
-0.07972210645675659,
-0.42322874069213867,
0.2604290843009949,
0.31557267904281616,
-0.42094504833221436,
-0.005346976220607758,
0.13164298236370087,
0.07863420248031616,
-0.2825082540512085,
-0.6730263829231262,
0.634131669998169,
-0.09126168489456177,
-0.6553457975387573,
0.9169812798500061,
0.17801782488822937,
0.8301920890808105,
-0.5063070058822632,
0.23330137133598328,
-0.3170818090438843,
0.097139373421669,
-0.15182854235172272,
-0.5038170218467712,
0.15248271822929382,
-0.14219506084918976,
-0.13117383420467377,
-0.333028107881546,
0.5360707640647888,
-0.3879714906215668,
-0.442886620759964,
0.09395129233598709,
0.21576732397079468,
-0.3992738723754883,
-0.3878723084926605,
-0.5179689526557922,
0.08995071798563004,
0.0009657506016083062,
-0.31325435638427734,
0.6818537712097168,
0.3731039762496948,
0.06592392176389694,
0.667029619216919,
0.6964187026023865,
0.41356855630874634,
0.24956919252872467,
-0.08348092436790466,
1.085147738456726,
-0.582119882106781,
-0.36082202196121216,
-1.0175988674163818,
0.2782934308052063,
0.04125379025936127,
-0.46617192029953003,
0.39837127923965454,
0.615699052810669,
0.965362012386322,
-0.050455283373594284,
0.8189318776130676,
0.4206587076187134,
0.3571770191192627,
-0.9170446395874023,
0.4599735736846924,
-0.48450005054473877,
0.5852711796760559,
-0.05889051780104637,
-1.1340616941452026,
-0.7064930200576782,
0.4952707290649414,
-0.15361356735229492,
0.2947450876235962,
0.5692830681800842,
1.177903413772583,
-0.3983149528503418,
-0.09141526371240616,
0.4624999463558197,
0.14927524328231812,
0.2597258388996124,
0.5299509763717651,
0.7055401802062988,
-0.12660609185695648,
0.2917971611022949,
-0.1282118409872055,
-0.2573956847190857,
-0.2783198952674866,
-0.9807714819908142,
-1.0918998718261719,
-0.6531438231468201,
-0.4488878846168518,
-0.22158221900463104,
0.25385963916778564,
0.5670425891876221,
0.9016249179840088,
-0.6336551904678345,
-0.06132824346423149,
-0.18176749348640442,
-0.20455299317836761,
-0.2064754068851471,
-0.1574837863445282,
0.34541431069374084,
-0.42534172534942627,
-0.6970769166946411,
0.3986321985721588,
0.43765825033187866,
-0.06055891513824463,
-0.08764167875051498,
0.0012215381721034646,
0.1958414614200592,
0.3795318603515625,
0.4579726457595825,
0.29839828610420227,
-0.6472667455673218,
-0.3654591739177704,
-0.11569647490978241,
-0.0711095854640007,
0.3719691038131714,
1.0894094705581665,
-0.5621787905693054,
0.4601287841796875,
0.4006163775920868,
0.8752149343490601,
0.7581637501716614,
-0.11739164590835571,
0.35615208745002747,
-1.1577335596084595,
0.0975320115685463,
0.19367669522762299,
0.1495751589536667,
0.16802352666854858,
-0.41998812556266785,
0.5859602689743042,
0.1033010333776474,
-0.6047911643981934,
-0.9510101079940796,
0.28296777606010437,
-0.9261532425880432,
-0.03843960911035538,
1.2440763711929321,
0.11551747471094131,
0.08951186388731003,
0.004528758581727743,
-0.4018360376358032,
0.02442360855638981,
-0.36191436648368835,
0.8528347611427307,
0.7913721799850464,
-0.15787804126739502,
-0.2100502997636795,
-0.8392486572265625,
0.8943777084350586,
0.46277451515197754,
-0.5943613052368164,
0.2828632593154907,
0.09456367045640945,
0.33916589617729187,
-0.2985876500606537,
0.6357565522193909,
0.14491698145866394,
0.12648144364356995,
-0.4920653700828552,
-0.5116934180259705,
-0.36645615100860596,
-0.20450100302696228,
-0.47574087977409363,
0.22538743913173676,
0.20985372364521027,
-0.26711326837539673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15319v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15319v2 | LongRAG: Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Long-context LLMs | 2024-06-21T17:23:21 | 2024-06-30T15:01:36 | Ziyan Jiang, Xueguang Ma, Wenhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In traditional RAG framework, the basic retrieval units are normally short.
The common retrievers like DPR normally work with 100-word Wikipedia
paragraphs. Such a design forces the retriever to search over a large corpus to
find the `needle' unit. In contrast, the readers only need to extract answers
from the short retrieved units. Such an imbalanced `heavy' retriever and
`light' reader design can lead to sub-optimal performance. In order to
alleviate the imbalance, we propose a new framework LongRAG, consisting of a
`long retriever' and a `long reader'. LongRAG processes the entire Wikipedia
into 4K-token units, which is 30x longer than before. By increasing the unit
size, we significantly reduce the total units from 22M to 700K. This
significantly lowers the burden of retriever, which leads to a remarkable
retrieval score: answer recall@1=71% on NQ (previously 52%) and answer
recall@2=72% (previously 47%) on HotpotQA (full-wiki). Then we feed the top-k
retrieved units ($\approx$ 30K tokens) to an existing long-context LLM to
perform zero-shot answer extraction. Without requiring any training, LongRAG
achieves an EM of 62.7% on NQ, which is the best known result. LongRAG also
achieves 64.3% on HotpotQA (full-wiki), which is on par of the SoTA model. Our
study offers insights into the future roadmap for combining RAG with
long-context LLMs. | [
-0.7879314422607422,
-0.6247000098228455,
0.4418404996395111,
0.20387504994869232,
-0.521695077419281,
0.018381798639893532,
-0.29257717728614807,
-0.6948710680007935,
0.7061245441436768,
0.5227593183517456,
-0.35288381576538086,
-0.22892767190933228,
-0.28766611218452454,
0.45132696628570557,
-0.50625079870224,
1.410175085067749,
-0.09375718981027603,
-0.3344464600086212,
-0.23404306173324585,
-0.28659766912460327,
-0.2501036822795868,
-0.18706199526786804,
-0.5613411664962769,
-0.39123499393463135,
1.1430206298828125,
0.5488161444664001,
0.38208815455436707,
0.5770056843757629,
0.3619251847267151,
0.1859949827194214,
-0.29821017384529114,
0.25391799211502075,
-0.9164444804191589,
0.4092242419719696,
-0.2572172284126282,
-0.2095850110054016,
-0.5494869947433472,
-0.266853004693985,
0.7699191570281982,
0.2884392738342285,
-0.03200787305831909,
0.3734615743160248,
0.26488441228866577,
0.9490485787391663,
-0.9443627595901489,
-0.2548387348651886,
-0.3691820800304413,
-0.0011565348831936717,
-0.6448100805282593,
-0.4621231257915497,
-0.2442629635334015,
0.18789072334766388,
-0.2963240146636963,
-0.9049383401870728,
0.18061363697052002,
0.23106470704078674,
0.5286120176315308,
0.4147908687591553,
-0.4985382854938507,
-0.39890167117118835,
-0.7311954498291016,
0.8509508967399597,
-0.2627522647380829,
0.3597193658351898,
0.27734866738319397,
0.43571943044662476,
-0.2696152329444885,
-0.9426695108413696,
-0.8429946303367615,
0.014740591868758202,
0.051210734993219376,
0.27424702048301697,
-0.08135230839252472,
-0.1327807903289795,
0.49206477403640747,
0.37487560510635376,
-0.5473318696022034,
0.27260294556617737,
-0.7492940425872803,
0.2563358247280121,
0.6548051238059998,
0.19955967366695404,
0.01435113325715065,
-0.5558584928512573,
-0.7276718616485596,
0.14415274560451508,
-1.032595157623291,
-0.0931696966290474,
0.26723793148994446,
0.009974060580134392,
0.18479382991790771,
0.8178677558898926,
-0.49384135007858276,
0.7036338448524475,
0.2500979006290436,
-0.18266047537326813,
0.22751766443252563,
-0.20622548460960388,
-0.1557033658027649,
0.2214318960905075,
0.6615815162658691,
0.4562883973121643,
-0.08442740142345428,
-0.050942324101924896,
-0.23760204017162323,
-0.3593451678752899,
0.3869904577732086,
-1.1268573999404907,
0.1342584192752838,
0.27624309062957764,
-0.30628645420074463,
-0.2750868499279022,
-0.14808636903762817,
-1.0654922723770142,
-0.4240248203277588,
-0.13740263879299164,
0.5008221864700317,
-0.2910340428352356,
-0.10195693373680115,
0.14165113866329193,
-0.4179101884365082,
0.48797035217285156,
0.21799743175506592,
-0.815675675868988,
0.19352810084819794,
0.914396345615387,
0.7022552490234375,
-0.43347230553627014,
-0.4524906277656555,
-0.7555098533630371,
0.42522913217544556,
-0.38101500272750854,
0.983623743057251,
-0.11874422430992126,
-0.38632941246032715,
-0.1325322389602661,
-0.109899140894413,
0.3568435311317444,
-0.5710556507110596,
0.7531388401985168,
-0.8890787363052368,
0.4430663287639618,
-0.38171765208244324,
-0.7262478470802307,
0.2476627081632614,
0.29317766427993774,
-0.7863980531692505,
1.297917127609253,
0.19939523935317993,
-1.0520312786102295,
0.3618662655353546,
-0.7062573432922363,
-0.31970903277397156,
0.19658586382865906,
-0.09777458012104034,
-0.2320854365825653,
0.09873594343662262,
0.140252947807312,
0.26024696230888367,
-0.4654221832752228,
0.12977562844753265,
-0.2798798978328705,
-0.8754727840423584,
0.16605593264102936,
-0.42220479249954224,
0.7061341404914856,
0.36608392000198364,
-0.32939571142196655,
-0.04029140993952751,
-0.5967201590538025,
0.011850051581859589,
-0.04161782190203667,
-0.6963743567466736,
-0.3620447516441345,
-0.14447636902332306,
0.03985002636909485,
0.028333015739917755,
0.353370726108551,
-0.7070586085319519,
0.079165019094944,
-0.4712202548980713,
0.07372403889894485,
0.6424328088760376,
-0.11215240508317947,
0.7089018225669861,
-0.33886587619781494,
0.6372018456459045,
-0.2019956111907959,
0.040799692273139954,
-0.08745517581701279,
-0.08878790587186813,
-0.7921589612960815,
-0.48433494567871094,
0.30565765500068665,
0.25730007886886597,
-0.9352293610572815,
0.39000198245048523,
-0.578937828540802,
-0.3219754993915558,
-0.44982805848121643,
0.4792630970478058,
0.2370840460062027,
0.8248514533042908,
0.6158628463745117,
-0.20069824159145355,
-0.41984403133392334,
-0.6704861521720886,
-0.1171228364109993,
0.09377247840166092,
-0.32738760113716125,
0.3504481315612793,
0.41844648122787476,
-0.14875562489032745,
0.9917598962783813,
-0.6055951118469238,
-0.3234170377254486,
-0.46271300315856934,
-0.201022669672966,
0.7203781604766846,
0.12210895121097565,
0.45776522159576416,
-0.9464284777641296,
-0.7444837093353271,
-0.18480663001537323,
-0.8243120908737183,
-0.17419414222240448,
0.18887445330619812,
-0.37794163823127747,
0.23612061142921448,
0.6281899809837341,
-1.255880355834961,
0.4185396432876587,
0.2025471031665802,
-0.2452184110879898,
0.5871358513832092,
-0.17506389319896698,
-0.034871943295001984,
-1.3064663410186768,
0.3963075876235962,
-0.2807866632938385,
-0.19232133030891418,
-0.4343032240867615,
0.527735710144043,
0.33804476261138916,
-0.2160969227552414,
-0.6051343083381653,
1.0371440649032593,
-0.4368167519569397,
-0.09102241694927216,
-0.5191912651062012,
0.26042547821998596,
0.2794177830219269,
0.2905116081237793,
-0.33241087198257446,
0.9831197261810303,
-0.02574002929031849,
-0.6480708718299866,
0.6404139995574951,
0.0503777340054512,
-0.35648950934410095,
0.814744234085083,
-0.7989091277122498,
0.12254869937896729,
-0.5421497821807861,
0.7761826515197754,
-0.6610330939292908,
-0.47960418462753296,
0.1478419303894043,
-0.4042680263519287,
0.6711735129356384,
-0.043242428451776505,
-0.3596171736717224,
-0.5721678137779236,
-0.7928340435028076,
0.45919159054756165,
0.4536738395690918,
-0.7647437453269958,
0.4002843499183655,
0.29834383726119995,
-0.30120450258255005,
-1.1435645818710327,
-0.3038029670715332,
0.26361775398254395,
-0.4756362736225128,
-0.4999409019947052,
0.7233537435531616,
-0.21773992478847504,
-0.13606196641921997,
-0.050409093499183655,
-0.15286993980407715,
0.022560248151421547,
-0.11528999358415604,
0.11328460276126862,
0.17440207302570343,
-0.21032921969890594,
0.4257805049419403,
0.08304378390312195,
-0.3502868711948395,
-0.22616498172283173,
-0.1411665827035904,
0.6301428079605103,
0.16401605308055878,
-0.1789526641368866,
-0.03373497724533081,
0.5916879773139954,
0.520690381526947,
-0.3521663546562195,
0.6199116706848145,
0.8481175899505615,
-0.17658215761184692,
-0.2537456452846527,
-0.5697431564331055,
-0.06912786513566971,
-0.5114690661430359,
0.3958885371685028,
-0.4038734436035156,
-1.0098100900650024,
0.21550606191158295,
0.12220364063978195,
0.11986730992794037,
0.6028549075126648,
0.49219778180122375,
-0.6009806990623474,
0.5845125317573547,
0.4271302819252014,
-0.38944607973098755,
0.4311751127243042,
-0.2938268482685089,
0.04959588125348091,
-1.125678300857544,
-0.06656286865472794,
-0.5023754835128784,
-0.687986433506012,
-0.5331201553344727,
-0.6258812546730042,
0.6811038255691528,
0.4880109429359436,
-0.30606040358543396,
-0.05391930043697357,
-0.4704454839229584,
0.6801312565803528,
0.5922256708145142,
0.19236676394939423,
0.19368785619735718,
0.1447807401418686,
0.1981116682291031,
0.0616333931684494,
-0.599269449710846,
-0.20871447026729584,
1.30394446849823,
0.1445499211549759,
0.7661667466163635,
0.2319701761007309,
1.228509545326233,
0.2101573944091797,
0.3594754934310913,
-0.9718714952468872,
0.5906846523284912,
-0.13583321869373322,
-0.924020528793335,
-0.5631020665168762,
-0.4043005704879761,
-1.2293213605880737,
0.0965658649802208,
-0.11508458107709885,
-0.09631766378879547,
-0.08148055523633957,
-0.032429154962301254,
-0.28416532278060913,
0.10368552803993225,
-0.16063442826271057,
0.49973562359809875,
-0.22332078218460083,
-0.6969212889671326,
-0.3653806746006012,
-0.51320880651474,
0.3010377585887909,
-0.26503825187683105,
0.06982006132602692,
-0.07509675621986389,
-0.2828131914138794,
0.6612444519996643,
-0.38597774505615234,
0.4553411602973938,
-0.20884139835834503,
-0.08734218776226044,
0.4241979122161865,
-0.29973047971725464,
0.4961111545562744,
0.06226678192615509,
-0.2878848612308502,
-0.22876836359500885,
-0.24490886926651,
-0.5102361440658569,
-0.669079065322876,
0.8292649388313293,
-0.565410315990448,
-0.6820813417434692,
-0.3269346058368683,
-0.34991008043289185,
0.09960762411355972,
0.4982680678367615,
0.4852885603904724,
0.24738149344921112,
-0.18277277052402496,
0.5887252688407898,
0.8001718521118164,
-0.24070458114147186,
0.41131266951560974,
0.34083807468414307,
-0.3944353461265564,
-0.5649938583374023,
0.7407674193382263,
0.13421741127967834,
-0.13817059993743896,
0.4708860218524933,
0.16701816022396088,
-0.3322283923625946,
-0.29330387711524963,
-0.850225031375885,
0.3398292064666748,
-0.5000503063201904,
-0.5705223679542542,
-0.5237254500389099,
-0.25084245204925537,
-0.18067573010921478,
-0.07098388671875,
-0.1389552652835846,
-0.5471116900444031,
-0.5170992016792297,
-0.04865888133645058,
0.4938850402832031,
0.48359623551368713,
-0.03880088031291962,
0.1760091632604599,
-0.7017781138420105,
0.7867412567138672,
0.46087777614593506,
0.3312247097492218,
-0.035697344690561295,
-0.5560461282730103,
-0.28303080797195435,
-0.010136613622307777,
-0.3578498661518097,
-0.8283844590187073,
0.2686719596385956,
0.24046292901039124,
0.34659069776535034,
0.1788337379693985,
0.2852921187877655,
0.9186682105064392,
-0.7520725727081299,
0.6173712015151978,
0.2673398554325104,
-0.34752774238586426,
0.25961834192276,
-0.43639957904815674,
0.2542092502117157,
0.575376570224762,
0.4706052839756012,
-0.4936811923980713,
-0.15288445353507996,
-0.35104823112487793,
-0.9063814878463745,
0.27245622873306274,
-0.19598796963691711,
0.5251542329788208,
-0.2535756230354309,
0.5390316247940063,
0.12334314733743668,
0.01911311410367489,
-0.5119115114212036,
0.047569017857313156,
0.03783593326807022,
-0.303503155708313,
-0.21989750862121582,
-0.7059741020202637,
-0.19489625096321106,
-0.2228991985321045,
0.548446536064148,
-0.11116839945316315,
0.18574048578739166,
0.25864848494529724,
-0.0794840157032013,
-0.10141383856534958,
0.4610093832015991,
0.44052034616470337,
0.7523367404937744,
-0.15130148828029633,
0.12344598770141602,
0.3056890070438385,
-0.43462318181991577,
-0.049917835742235184,
0.22571490705013275,
-0.3124837875366211,
0.1345803588628769,
0.17998288571834564,
0.6110357642173767,
0.2660055160522461,
-0.5324242115020752,
0.5348168015480042,
0.13933786749839783,
0.07009390741586685,
-0.6208963990211487,
0.14060719311237335,
0.18406632542610168,
0.3857574760913849,
0.738074779510498,
-0.4593215584754944,
0.16996891796588898,
-0.3702313005924225,
0.2638879716396332,
0.4503284692764282,
-0.04498474672436714,
-0.05915794149041176,
0.5529437065124512,
0.26627248525619507,
-0.2649769186973572,
0.5874500274658203,
-0.12231609970331192,
-0.2906557321548462,
0.35665231943130493,
0.6988824605941772,
0.47785302996635437,
0.0009079226874746382,
-0.01264214888215065,
0.27526429295539856,
-0.128048837184906,
-0.19247329235076904,
0.24827803671360016,
-0.39451542496681213,
-0.2833186984062195,
-0.47429099678993225,
-1.0798945426940918,
-0.2983642816543579,
0.06549272686243057,
-0.7045170664787292,
0.5068691968917847,
-0.20946668088436127,
-0.1512850522994995,
-0.18373742699623108,
0.3685121536254883,
-0.5887852311134338,
0.10144423693418503,
-0.1437673717737198,
1.1079736948013306,
-0.2156509906053543,
0.8753564357757568,
0.2757905125617981,
-0.2689516842365265,
-0.4490990936756134,
-0.12996704876422882,
-0.29344362020492554,
-0.626234233379364,
0.6226233243942261,
0.2449486404657364,
-0.14738130569458008,
0.01730591617524624,
-0.40657395124435425,
-0.7743844985961914,
1.3140945434570312,
0.20356005430221558,
-0.4924418330192566,
-0.2886289656162262,
-0.04478616267442703,
0.600699782371521,
-0.13554295897483826,
-0.044766977429389954,
0.20637314021587372,
0.2807881832122803,
0.10357648134231567,
-0.9407246708869934,
-0.15810108184814453,
-0.19083334505558014,
-0.3995683193206787,
0.5514755845069885,
-0.5909082889556885,
0.9223324060440063,
-0.0838141143321991,
-0.17227968573570251,
0.3375738859176636,
0.6132703423500061,
0.7208235859870911,
0.739869236946106,
0.2410748451948166,
0.8118914365768433,
0.7103570699691772,
0.4463300406932831,
1.0250678062438965,
-0.273084431886673,
0.21180039644241333,
1.211270809173584,
-0.25861093401908875,
1.3900341987609863,
0.8015029430389404,
-0.08076870441436768,
0.461851567029953,
0.20601150393486023,
0.3093450665473938,
0.3576599657535553,
0.14530320465564728,
-0.6818397045135498,
0.059219151735305786,
-0.1260148137807846,
-0.5603227615356445,
0.6703565120697021,
0.3760364055633545,
-0.4318177402019501,
-0.27233555912971497,
-0.07530263811349869,
0.11993300169706345,
-0.1222587525844574,
-0.3595663607120514,
0.6360248327255249,
0.24743273854255676,
-0.713840126991272,
0.8632126450538635,
0.032256294041872025,
1.046134114265442,
-0.40142685174942017,
0.04718413203954697,
-0.46673813462257385,
0.08879757672548294,
-0.16788999736309052,
-0.8703179955482483,
0.10573025792837143,
0.3689403831958771,
-0.25941258668899536,
-0.27393168210983276,
1.1120551824569702,
-0.3106146454811096,
-0.4619431793689728,
0.19959218800067902,
0.5818890333175659,
0.24727566540241241,
-0.019733121618628502,
-0.33461666107177734,
0.000010599749657558277,
-0.18148910999298096,
-0.37662315368652344,
0.5713762044906616,
0.4785080552101135,
0.0017833132296800613,
0.47006893157958984,
0.6774811148643494,
0.1621454805135727,
-0.05005573108792305,
-0.306631475687027,
1.0871626138687134,
-0.8172511458396912,
-0.33552005887031555,
-0.7279955148696899,
0.3383536636829376,
-0.40852558612823486,
-0.27534499764442444,
0.6429509520530701,
0.7555150389671326,
0.735081136226654,
0.13076482713222504,
0.3590325713157654,
-0.042268164455890656,
0.8652376532554626,
-0.47867563366889954,
0.9531804323196411,
-0.8842936754226685,
0.13747571408748627,
0.028244400396943092,
-1.2634820938110352,
-0.0946292132139206,
0.33044731616973877,
0.018705984577536583,
-0.2026088833808899,
0.3807263672351837,
0.6706075072288513,
-0.3405452072620392,
-0.25002145767211914,
0.16580843925476074,
-0.0820106491446495,
0.28491008281707764,
0.5839592218399048,
0.8337470889091492,
-0.3167771100997925,
0.7574664354324341,
-0.18570870161056519,
-0.14178363978862762,
-0.34378182888031006,
-0.778364360332489,
-0.6941398978233337,
-0.2617209255695343,
0.3954152464866638,
-0.3244091868400574,
0.08248547464609146,
0.602149486541748,
0.2244226187467575,
-0.18569441139698029,
-0.24261413514614105,
0.28733769059181213,
0.15834785997867584,
0.4037403166294098,
-0.22572311758995056,
0.35134315490722656,
-0.3892524540424347,
-0.6110171675682068,
0.5737748146057129,
0.32061508297920227,
-0.21290770173072815,
-0.21188460290431976,
-0.31275811791419983,
0.07552462071180344,
-0.18377253413200378,
0.8782049417495728,
0.5374838709831238,
-0.41191625595092773,
-0.23183602094650269,
0.31874096393585205,
-0.21458491683006287,
0.07365068793296814,
0.6051272749900818,
-1.0874220132827759,
0.2999117076396942,
0.5632301568984985,
0.704554557800293,
0.9934825897216797,
0.002762836404144764,
0.3962783217430115,
-0.7280895709991455,
0.223347470164299,
0.35350126028060913,
0.18343287706375122,
0.25688987970352173,
-0.21676373481750488,
0.5564700365066528,
-0.15094172954559326,
-0.7629703879356384,
-0.964407205581665,
0.28937387466430664,
-0.7607904076576233,
-0.28278154134750366,
1.0830578804016113,
0.08708822727203369,
-0.4124809503555298,
0.13294857740402222,
-0.16144460439682007,
0.3603796064853668,
-0.16825692355632782,
0.9257779121398926,
0.49091988801956177,
-0.20179536938667297,
-0.001930841477587819,
-0.7306385040283203,
0.4801501929759979,
0.4048417806625366,
-0.6758569478988647,
-0.040126409381628036,
0.7671673893928528,
0.41552436351776123,
0.2440774142742157,
0.8563979864120483,
-0.08427130430936813,
0.5189387798309326,
-0.238927960395813,
-0.23807261884212494,
-0.12554048001766205,
-0.445687860250473,
-0.15343907475471497,
0.31918078660964966,
0.022606972604990005,
0.010114097036421299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15313v1 | STARD: A Chinese Statute Retrieval Dataset with Real Queries Issued by Non-professionals | 2024-06-21T17:10:09 | 2024-06-21T17:10:09 | Weihang Su, Yiran Hu, Anzhe Xie, Qingyao Ai, Zibing Que, Ning Zheng, Yun Liu, Weixing Shen, Yiqun Liu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Statute retrieval aims to find relevant statutory articles for specific
queries. This process is the basis of a wide range of legal applications such
as legal advice, automated judicial decisions, legal document drafting, etc.
Existing statute retrieval benchmarks focus on formal and professional queries
from sources like bar exams and legal case documents, thereby neglecting
non-professional queries from the general public, which often lack precise
legal terminology and references. To address this gap, we introduce the STAtute
Retrieval Dataset (STARD), a Chinese dataset comprising 1,543 query cases
collected from real-world legal consultations and 55,348 candidate statutory
articles. Unlike existing statute retrieval datasets, which primarily focus on
professional legal queries, STARD captures the complexity and diversity of real
queries from the general public. Through a comprehensive evaluation of various
retrieval baselines, we reveal that existing retrieval approaches all fall
short of these real queries issued by non-professional users. The best method
only achieves a Recall@100 of 0.907, suggesting the necessity for further
exploration and additional research in this area.
All the codes and datasets are available at:
https://github.com/oneal2000/STARD/tree/main | [
-0.37803712487220764,
-0.5699383616447449,
0.39146631956100464,
0.05154857039451599,
-0.6613645553588867,
-0.30377906560897827,
-0.27022701501846313,
-0.6314499974250793,
0.2597863972187042,
0.8901217579841614,
-0.17993655800819397,
-0.5126389265060425,
-0.2598581612110138,
-0.20011061429977417,
-0.3340275287628174,
0.8055365681648254,
0.3559085428714752,
0.20074373483657837,
0.1053934246301651,
-0.3686448633670807,
-0.4175015687942505,
-0.4734942615032196,
-0.5121017098426819,
0.11723072081804276,
0.6287506222724915,
0.29082155227661133,
0.6264985799789429,
0.692798376083374,
0.5713877081871033,
0.09314043074846268,
0.12337379902601242,
0.2347719520330429,
-0.41519883275032043,
-0.30309128761291504,
-0.2609902322292328,
-0.4621775448322296,
-0.0977923721075058,
0.026397457346320152,
0.3919229507446289,
0.21468034386634827,
-0.04982456564903259,
0.34499210119247437,
-0.19726480543613434,
0.733350932598114,
-0.8557007312774658,
0.32784682512283325,
-0.6069985032081604,
0.16816216707229614,
-0.7768163084983826,
-0.29794955253601074,
-0.2964416444301605,
-0.6777722239494324,
0.2362106293439865,
-0.6638690233230591,
0.5351549983024597,
0.14641894400119781,
1.001520037651062,
0.15849468111991882,
-0.5581763982772827,
-0.23460619151592255,
-0.5998738408088684,
0.2956116199493408,
-0.6052865386009216,
0.4479813277721405,
0.3668789267539978,
0.6410372257232666,
0.003256433177739382,
-0.887783408164978,
-0.5302643179893494,
-0.5239483714103699,
-0.002118357690051198,
0.10483512282371521,
-0.06300957500934601,
0.019775163382291794,
0.29072192311286926,
0.22014713287353516,
-0.7255868315696716,
0.04726610332727432,
-0.39167678356170654,
-0.32474657893180847,
0.8418614864349365,
0.021015388891100883,
0.31302782893180847,
-0.33054855465888977,
-0.3409259617328644,
-0.19923967123031616,
-1.261677861213684,
0.01321423426270485,
0.20211544632911682,
0.3752921521663666,
0.16426591575145721,
0.22472140192985535,
-0.08589743822813034,
0.6225804090499878,
-0.09859585762023926,
0.2795078754425049,
-0.034898433834314346,
-0.40011730790138245,
0.051382821053266525,
0.2388736456632614,
0.7077928185462952,
0.2543562948703766,
0.22486065328121185,
-0.1339622139930725,
-0.5709880590438843,
-0.5152652263641357,
0.39592769742012024,
-0.5353637933731079,
-0.39526787400245667,
0.12175744026899338,
-0.5066595077514648,
0.14145156741142273,
0.5538093447685242,
-0.5845204591751099,
-0.6353597640991211,
-0.45492586493492126,
0.18790341913700104,
-0.3014140725135803,
-0.15740236639976501,
-0.21963751316070557,
-0.14462882280349731,
0.19095063209533691,
0.33811405301094055,
-0.5037420988082886,
0.13240614533424377,
0.9338610768318176,
0.5865938663482666,
0.3345123529434204,
0.16655676066875458,
-0.6242415904998779,
-0.043314408510923386,
-0.8516303896903992,
0.7882875204086304,
-0.5078102350234985,
-0.25285446643829346,
0.17330428957939148,
0.04617174342274666,
0.1600564569234848,
-1.067009687423706,
0.9938045740127563,
-0.8193395733833313,
-0.3108910620212555,
-0.8463706970214844,
-0.3721979260444641,
-0.3163393437862396,
0.13271284103393555,
-0.9586158394813538,
0.4411955773830414,
-0.06579890847206116,
-0.48621121048927307,
0.9167443513870239,
-0.39119774103164673,
-0.25295600295066833,
0.5823847651481628,
-0.8150326609611511,
-0.26671096682548523,
0.03731903061270714,
0.161133274435997,
0.21672576665878296,
-0.6685341596603394,
0.3683595657348633,
-0.21374104917049408,
-0.4595903754234314,
-0.05959634110331535,
-0.23033741116523743,
0.826546311378479,
0.7938363552093506,
-0.04531119763851166,
0.08001461625099182,
-0.21069566905498505,
0.08875829726457596,
0.10513802617788315,
-0.11361395567655563,
-0.5667546391487122,
0.10262807458639145,
0.2534071207046509,
0.23258903622627258,
0.3556407392024994,
-0.5330713391304016,
0.18626737594604492,
-0.13926562666893005,
0.34474703669548035,
0.6099671721458435,
0.42766550183296204,
-0.20578761398792267,
-0.4422534704208374,
0.32499954104423523,
0.2140756994485855,
0.07807344198226929,
0.22979502379894257,
-0.35175177454948425,
-0.5093291997909546,
0.23494645953178406,
0.5540959239006042,
0.6116941571235657,
-0.9163392186164856,
0.38619863986968994,
-0.41456854343414307,
-0.8410592079162598,
-0.6755921244621277,
0.08838693052530289,
0.704125702381134,
0.259929895401001,
0.23791129887104034,
-0.10784032940864563,
-0.35085177421569824,
-0.9542957544326782,
-0.5580717325210571,
-0.38012006878852844,
-0.039951033890247345,
0.6633788347244263,
0.5051815509796143,
0.26712465286254883,
1.014833688735962,
-0.4660927951335907,
-0.8262841105461121,
0.04553373530507088,
0.22575373947620392,
0.44130489230155945,
0.33594459295272827,
0.7034378051757812,
-1.1184096336364746,
-0.4405989646911621,
-0.010846922174096107,
-0.8386748433113098,
0.11885157972574234,
-0.5836439728736877,
-0.07126379013061523,
-0.05294639244675636,
0.18226897716522217,
-0.4898111820220947,
0.1531233936548233,
-0.2508986294269562,
-0.495729923248291,
1.0505748987197876,
-0.35924386978149414,
0.3166971504688263,
-0.5416353940963745,
0.2658021152019501,
0.16594333946704865,
-0.05050079524517059,
-0.39903825521469116,
0.5914808511734009,
0.6664842963218689,
-0.03594628721475601,
-0.5337109565734863,
0.3491886258125305,
-0.6668070554733276,
-0.2186506986618042,
0.10210038721561432,
0.4156661033630371,
-0.4482060968875885,
0.027762405574321747,
0.11333995312452316,
1.1660257577896118,
0.5602909922599792,
-0.9303414821624756,
0.4317924976348877,
0.23641815781593323,
-0.5270693898200989,
0.6143050789833069,
-0.3935791850090027,
-0.22162888944149017,
-0.05607641860842705,
0.07650632411241531,
-0.33584412932395935,
-0.07495754957199097,
0.19068557024002075,
-0.060360878705978394,
0.14877142012119293,
-0.23030760884284973,
-0.8036253452301025,
-0.625119686126709,
-0.21207234263420105,
0.045604366809129715,
0.4678913354873657,
-0.5515218377113342,
-0.19726644456386566,
0.698093593120575,
-0.07747286558151245,
-0.6347469687461853,
-0.532058835029602,
0.4701540768146515,
-0.034613799303770065,
-0.5415170192718506,
0.24633444845676422,
0.27939823269844055,
-0.11911195516586304,
0.3491055965423584,
-0.3833167850971222,
-0.3592327833175659,
-0.234058678150177,
-0.20309126377105713,
-0.031548406928777695,
-0.599153995513916,
0.3445854187011719,
-0.2863316237926483,
0.12080550938844681,
0.25436022877693176,
-0.1697361320257187,
0.3655139207839966,
-0.04264232888817787,
-0.6700312495231628,
-0.46242228150367737,
-0.12037278711795807,
0.15455597639083862,
-0.4710865914821625,
0.1458030641078949,
0.27168163657188416,
-0.6794202923774719,
-0.2561326026916504,
-0.7198261618614197,
-0.2021675407886505,
-0.44994857907295227,
0.25583773851394653,
-0.4507269859313965,
-0.438931405544281,
0.4064188301563263,
0.2929714024066925,
0.37614983320236206,
0.5366917848587036,
0.15451569855213165,
0.359508216381073,
0.38657352328300476,
0.1935531497001648,
-0.3570428192615509,
0.22444774210453033,
-0.15189076960086823,
0.09195508062839508,
-0.5315631031990051,
-0.3086453974246979,
-0.5796723961830139,
-0.1258963644504547,
-0.4885096251964569,
-0.5120563507080078,
0.3505275547504425,
0.14652711153030396,
-0.041456498205661774,
0.8961479663848877,
-0.5405747294425964,
0.426125705242157,
0.5870763063430786,
0.3941827714443207,
0.37034186720848083,
-0.23357385396957397,
-0.05396087095141411,
-0.24109330773353577,
-0.6155879497528076,
-0.5515884160995483,
0.9587656259536743,
-0.15833325684070587,
0.7400597929954529,
0.2150229811668396,
0.8496638536453247,
0.5889714360237122,
0.17890863120555878,
-0.47679847478866577,
0.5921432375907898,
-0.4371538758277893,
-0.8969619870185852,
-0.20534749329090118,
-0.6517550945281982,
-1.2297283411026,
0.34548839926719666,
-0.1950133740901947,
-0.6396655440330505,
0.40674886107444763,
0.01983433961868286,
-0.5848163962364197,
0.403470903635025,
-0.3900682032108307,
0.8380776643753052,
-0.3742188513278961,
-0.42599648237228394,
-0.4441010653972626,
-0.5000512599945068,
0.6563001871109009,
-0.4757276475429535,
0.09011150151491165,
-0.053367771208286285,
-0.045001525431871414,
0.8078094720840454,
-0.57899010181427,
0.4207688570022583,
-0.46503740549087524,
-0.0772632285952568,
0.7364325523376465,
0.12371792644262314,
0.5525194406509399,
0.2974064350128174,
-0.06925573199987411,
-0.2982896566390991,
0.344706654548645,
-0.22611455619335175,
-0.4529415965080261,
0.9271687865257263,
-0.43076714873313904,
-0.7546576857566833,
-0.5742506384849548,
-0.07447759062051773,
0.18219606578350067,
0.4012511968612671,
0.10217289626598358,
0.4854907691478729,
-0.3127400279045105,
0.16650311648845673,
0.652182400226593,
-0.14339889585971832,
0.3835214376449585,
0.7823969721794128,
0.20303334295749664,
-0.012961274944245815,
1.3067415952682495,
0.8226871490478516,
-0.4035954475402832,
0.2373100370168686,
-0.1257788985967636,
-0.7109542489051819,
-0.3637772500514984,
-0.6204289197921753,
0.33522170782089233,
-0.7590076327323914,
-0.08069512248039246,
-0.3725461959838867,
-0.3575786054134369,
-0.445896714925766,
0.23463012278079987,
-0.4318012297153473,
-0.2076149582862854,
-0.3201669752597809,
0.24697540700435638,
0.2500963807106018,
0.6256459355354309,
0.20438691973686218,
-0.43695637583732605,
-1.097028374671936,
0.47384509444236755,
-0.020304523408412933,
0.6757517457008362,
-0.08143872022628784,
-0.3078753650188446,
-0.01462541799992323,
-0.06517873704433441,
-0.28627800941467285,
-0.677222490310669,
0.32309722900390625,
0.3684815466403961,
0.98464035987854,
1.003794550895691,
0.8019763827323914,
0.9320297837257385,
-0.41858091950416565,
0.8021296262741089,
0.03282098099589348,
-0.34924063086509705,
0.36193257570266724,
-0.18382063508033752,
-0.06836777180433273,
0.45010268688201904,
0.48830339312553406,
-0.7538819313049316,
-0.057303011417388916,
-0.586534321308136,
-0.6849074959754944,
0.5965304374694824,
0.1320667266845703,
0.01856435276567936,
-0.0394536629319191,
0.6524108052253723,
-0.1355355679988861,
-0.13075245916843414,
-0.23799122869968414,
-0.19993291795253754,
0.11667956411838531,
0.1692447066307068,
0.08690119534730911,
0.0976569727063179,
-0.20322661101818085,
0.026732001453638077,
0.505506694316864,
0.1236487627029419,
0.5193780660629272,
0.45067304372787476,
-0.22319594025611877,
-0.02214047871530056,
0.2796802222728729,
0.3762935698032379,
0.778303861618042,
-0.17207106947898865,
0.13521550595760345,
-0.004059314727783203,
-0.5841127038002014,
-0.0670468881726265,
0.062369924038648605,
-0.20972229540348053,
0.05637345090508461,
0.24717651307582855,
0.3927020728588104,
0.06060505285859108,
-0.837179958820343,
0.5234528183937073,
0.16664157807826996,
-0.26864466071128845,
-0.8328061103820801,
0.20209337770938873,
-0.1100892722606659,
0.25821080803871155,
0.8001366853713989,
-0.058684367686510086,
0.23140208423137665,
-0.5010597109794617,
1.0326087474822998,
0.3297886848449707,
-0.7350220680236816,
-0.08440994471311569,
1.1752971410751343,
0.10443661361932755,
-0.07370512187480927,
0.7567486763000488,
-0.21046365797519684,
-0.046252526342868805,
0.7555402517318726,
0.2990974485874176,
0.6793618202209473,
0.4608815312385559,
0.1367683708667755,
0.4899410605430603,
0.33913683891296387,
-0.3612806797027588,
0.3990730941295624,
-0.04595522582530975,
-0.25712841749191284,
-0.12045714259147644,
-0.2810806632041931,
-0.27411919832229614,
0.17882344126701355,
-0.6027934551239014,
0.4313370883464813,
-0.6881547570228577,
-0.2686418294906616,
-0.3711146116256714,
0.31202879548072815,
-0.32448041439056396,
0.1760578453540802,
0.02525143511593342,
1.2322041988372803,
-0.36882680654525757,
0.9902490377426147,
0.4503460228443146,
-1.0225567817687988,
-0.42610716819763184,
0.11055080592632294,
0.18689951300621033,
-0.5373635292053223,
0.4445247948169708,
-0.040836501866579056,
0.28536683320999146,
-0.10194553434848785,
-0.34571003913879395,
-0.5246806144714355,
1.150450587272644,
0.10915090143680573,
-0.7237050533294678,
0.24066200852394104,
0.2556706368923187,
0.6714385151863098,
-0.09440264850854874,
0.09811321645975113,
0.5453765392303467,
0.5571784377098083,
0.13533973693847656,
-0.805270254611969,
0.5514398813247681,
-0.34046053886413574,
-0.16165488958358765,
0.06702250987291336,
-0.7250043749809265,
0.8133423328399658,
-0.195007786154747,
-0.4786404073238373,
0.025343243032693863,
0.6505115628242493,
0.4723699390888214,
0.2934492826461792,
0.45357829332351685,
0.39680179953575134,
0.7958890199661255,
-0.38608118891716003,
1.0402523279190063,
-0.6472290754318237,
0.18922024965286255,
0.6525982022285461,
-0.20288044214248657,
0.87436842918396,
0.16242389380931854,
-0.051136329770088196,
-0.11828035861253738,
0.9468675851821899,
-0.4962860643863678,
0.4358004629611969,
0.19668224453926086,
-0.30768927931785583,
-0.4224863052368164,
-0.20711617171764374,
-0.5426447987556458,
-0.1763288676738739,
0.3236706256866455,
-0.16921846568584442,
-0.5177267789840698,
-0.41808000206947327,
-0.1645946055650711,
0.19236484169960022,
-0.2196684628725052,
0.531109631061554,
0.15231113135814667,
-0.7408465147018433,
0.768203854560852,
0.02212700806558132,
0.4671817421913147,
-0.45156487822532654,
-0.228533074259758,
-0.3305799663066864,
0.17877359688282013,
-0.3028688132762909,
-1.0375725030899048,
0.050950489938259125,
-0.06592444330453873,
0.3644142150878906,
0.00945344939827919,
0.5925973653793335,
-0.2318778783082962,
0.0035289530642330647,
0.03271768242120743,
0.19150036573410034,
0.6190727353096008,
-0.5096524357795715,
-0.8942540884017944,
-0.5786385536193848,
-0.1655922830104828,
-0.11438585817813873,
0.3761817216873169,
0.5310173034667969,
-0.7787865996360779,
0.8673211932182312,
0.626228392124176,
0.19128161668777466,
0.0907764732837677,
0.08436670154333115,
0.9826295971870422,
-0.8739017248153687,
-0.5701634287834167,
-0.33619093894958496,
0.05711071938276291,
-0.10495571047067642,
-0.5061360597610474,
0.6404545307159424,
0.950021505355835,
0.7912108302116394,
-0.3783993422985077,
0.7078258991241455,
-0.4382798373699188,
0.345322847366333,
-0.5397565364837646,
1.264297604560852,
-0.5691854953765869,
0.3708237111568451,
-0.163944274187088,
-0.9037404656410217,
-0.4244728684425354,
0.35890328884124756,
-0.13659197092056274,
-0.14755569398403168,
0.35071104764938354,
1.0042171478271484,
-0.22401276230812073,
0.027413763105869293,
0.3633757531642914,
-0.10793561488389969,
0.4256782531738281,
0.4278413951396942,
0.5407544374465942,
-0.40296709537506104,
1.003115177154541,
-0.10738155990839005,
0.0657259002327919,
-0.4874740242958069,
-0.4096170961856842,
-0.4503404498100281,
-0.39631497859954834,
-0.0807095617055893,
-0.03726373612880707,
0.11713317781686783,
1.0576598644256592,
0.6785563826560974,
-1.0445029735565186,
-0.35827842354774475,
-0.13853231072425842,
-0.05505124852061272,
-0.47281232476234436,
-0.22067907452583313,
0.5737845301628113,
-0.7046979069709778,
-0.45684128999710083,
0.3344757854938507,
-0.3154396116733551,
-0.28733277320861816,
-0.010158959776163101,
-0.23137523233890533,
-0.344868004322052,
-0.00693382415920496,
0.16882261633872986,
0.5844874978065491,
-0.8629471063613892,
-0.3343603014945984,
-0.212786465883255,
-0.4586700201034546,
0.10351987928152084,
0.9682387709617615,
-0.49451422691345215,
0.41476696729660034,
0.6800611615180969,
0.6229848265647888,
0.532362163066864,
0.12003160268068314,
0.3941582143306732,
-0.7647345662117004,
-0.005930425599217415,
0.21243156492710114,
0.15678013861179352,
-0.3148771822452545,
-0.4005081057548523,
0.7619709968566895,
0.4967659115791321,
-0.41770535707473755,
-0.40659675002098083,
-0.045489706099033356,
-0.7267036437988281,
-0.4319577217102051,
0.559537410736084,
-0.3982216715812683,
-0.1245436817407608,
-0.4211163818836212,
-0.23739013075828552,
0.18809443712234497,
-0.572930634021759,
0.9315026998519897,
0.47558754682540894,
-0.14144282042980194,
-0.2280094474554062,
-0.977342426776886,
0.5928452014923096,
0.09665896743535995,
-0.5579404830932617,
0.3312314748764038,
0.6828557848930359,
0.3169083893299103,
0.14285816252231598,
0.5765057802200317,
-0.4388478696346283,
0.5545601844787598,
0.2587278187274933,
0.07878296077251434,
-0.09199625998735428,
-0.19420446455478668,
0.11511892080307007,
0.304828017950058,
0.016744500026106834,
0.026975803077220917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15294v1 | NLP-KG: A System for Exploratory Search of Scientific Literature in Natural Language Processing | 2024-06-21T16:38:22 | 2024-06-21T16:38:22 | Tim Schopf, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific literature searches are often exploratory, whereby users are not
yet familiar with a particular field or concept but are interested in learning
more about it. However, existing systems for scientific literature search are
typically tailored to keyword-based lookup searches, limiting the possibilities
for exploration. We propose NLP-KG, a feature-rich system designed to support
the exploration of research literature in unfamiliar natural language
processing (NLP) fields. In addition to a semantic search, NLP-KG allows users
to easily find survey papers that provide a quick introduction to a field of
interest. Further, a Fields of Study hierarchy graph enables users to
familiarize themselves with a field and its related areas. Finally, a chat
interface allows users to ask questions about unfamiliar concepts or specific
articles in NLP and obtain answers grounded in knowledge retrieved from
scientific publications. Our system provides users with comprehensive
exploration possibilities, supporting them in investigating the relationships
between different fields, understanding unfamiliar concepts in NLP, and finding
relevant research literature. Demo, video, and code are available at:
https://github.com/NLP-Knowledge-Graph/NLP-KG-WebApp. | [
-0.49701517820358276,
-0.5428876280784607,
0.4285009503364563,
0.28784245252609253,
-0.21012970805168152,
0.26804375648498535,
-0.04031631350517273,
-0.5453404784202576,
0.557244062423706,
0.39034613966941833,
-0.4232904314994812,
-0.6938202977180481,
-0.6472901701927185,
0.42444413900375366,
-0.4291988015174866,
0.9768273234367371,
0.0978604331612587,
-0.12171053886413574,
-0.3595048487186432,
-0.11644096672534943,
-0.0791921392083168,
-0.11570946127176285,
-0.6228369474411011,
-0.5332402586936951,
0.7087598443031311,
0.08431932330131531,
0.9950925707817078,
0.23283658921718597,
0.7102712988853455,
0.1458924412727356,
-0.5033679604530334,
0.19115494191646576,
-0.4499571621417999,
0.657436728477478,
-0.36324790120124817,
-0.5126236081123352,
-0.1270972341299057,
-0.34101471304893494,
0.5784755349159241,
0.8374696969985962,
-0.003867955645546317,
-0.08585985749959946,
-0.05367062985897064,
0.8639720678329468,
-0.6529972553253174,
0.3981226980686188,
-0.5046266317367554,
0.6057829260826111,
-0.15933389961719513,
-0.6774448752403259,
-0.29307618737220764,
-0.25003156065940857,
0.5455071926116943,
-1.0236966609954834,
0.35478532314300537,
0.25542768836021423,
0.5927113890647888,
0.018159938976168633,
-0.35632240772247314,
-0.702592134475708,
-0.6357335448265076,
0.46201902627944946,
-0.5052435398101807,
0.24612194299697876,
0.557898998260498,
0.47693830728530884,
-0.37867870926856995,
-0.8015626668930054,
-0.555008053779602,
-0.248747780919075,
-0.4809860289096832,
0.1446845978498459,
-0.0170225091278553,
0.08178981393575668,
0.12371845543384552,
0.19733008742332458,
-0.9301016330718994,
-0.156386137008667,
-0.3864629566669464,
-0.04998699948191643,
0.35277608036994934,
-0.060262251645326614,
0.48426708579063416,
-0.5591719746589661,
0.06449006497859955,
-0.22971788048744202,
-0.5512146949768066,
0.20882433652877808,
0.2590824067592621,
0.42314648628234863,
0.3220829665660858,
0.8428861498832703,
-0.5558631420135498,
0.8210017085075378,
-0.5823404788970947,
0.20951420068740845,
0.31176677346229553,
-0.13217198848724365,
-0.10168951749801636,
0.20765087008476257,
0.8608882427215576,
0.21906672418117523,
-0.3747841715812683,
-0.37487927079200745,
0.12237909436225891,
-0.07859256863594055,
0.26083478331565857,
-0.6205667853355408,
-0.4972262680530548,
0.13590121269226074,
-0.3844459056854248,
-0.48724281787872314,
-0.2578839659690857,
-0.9189742803573608,
-0.5191880464553833,
0.010044236667454243,
0.4145078659057617,
-0.5975978970527649,
-0.3207853138446808,
-0.14832459390163422,
-0.527104914188385,
-0.03069511242210865,
0.12881587445735931,
-0.9378142952919006,
0.31329867243766785,
0.4341929852962494,
0.9928447604179382,
-0.24964702129364014,
0.1114499643445015,
-0.2859797775745392,
0.00641911244019866,
-0.1585240513086319,
0.5971924066543579,
-0.9798489212989807,
-0.7035159468650818,
-0.04523223638534546,
-0.15940502285957336,
0.3041742742061615,
-0.4758911728858948,
0.9131042957305908,
-0.9968953132629395,
0.3596533536911011,
-0.3114049434661865,
-0.35861843824386597,
-0.3446701467037201,
0.5900119543075562,
-0.550616443157196,
1.442063331604004,
0.13425549864768982,
-0.9923197031021118,
0.2642548680305481,
-1.1449624300003052,
-0.10452507436275482,
0.2719131410121918,
-0.19923096895217896,
-0.029940418899059296,
-0.1847347915172577,
0.3070683479309082,
0.3379436731338501,
-0.10446449369192123,
0.23474334180355072,
-0.20388543605804443,
-0.24949392676353455,
0.012563087046146393,
0.2402777373790741,
0.7953269481658936,
0.34601524472236633,
0.15084119141101837,
-0.23715078830718994,
-0.9725283980369568,
0.31062018871307373,
0.06083053722977638,
-0.3445059061050415,
-0.9168697595596313,
0.07632098346948624,
0.08436128497123718,
-0.05956652760505676,
0.22499246895313263,
-0.6814864277839661,
0.4335525333881378,
-0.721413254737854,
0.14725546538829803,
0.103639155626297,
-0.15824052691459656,
0.46964138746261597,
0.012474248185753822,
0.6294853687286377,
-0.19943201541900635,
-0.2893899381160736,
-0.4717782139778137,
-0.7649775743484497,
-0.48807334899902344,
0.19750665128231049,
0.4033272862434387,
0.5598339438438416,
-1.1026611328125,
0.20052827894687653,
-0.11484000831842422,
-0.5957610011100769,
-0.573822557926178,
0.01267117541283369,
0.3168560862541199,
0.612385094165802,
0.6288756132125854,
-0.05623947083950043,
-0.5956386923789978,
-0.7971228957176208,
-0.36853551864624023,
-0.16422997415065765,
-0.38601604104042053,
0.5739249587059021,
0.5140819549560547,
-0.28702905774116516,
1.3202290534973145,
-0.884955108165741,
-0.4039371609687805,
0.05607931315898895,
0.6682853698730469,
0.33477652072906494,
0.2526455819606781,
0.22738368809223175,
-1.2755895853042603,
-0.7091612219810486,
0.5355526804924011,
-0.9429662823677063,
-0.3310687243938446,
0.48709535598754883,
-0.09169577807188034,
-0.07377958297729492,
0.5501855611801147,
-0.6128102540969849,
0.06740494817495346,
0.4418315589427948,
-0.16336780786514282,
0.38253122568130493,
-0.3049226999282837,
0.09595023840665817,
-0.9282957911491394,
0.6713935732841492,
-0.24842001497745514,
0.01751735433936119,
-0.5943536758422852,
0.3328806161880493,
0.0657566487789154,
-0.29570192098617554,
-0.09520087391138077,
0.41093572974205017,
-0.24189122021198273,
-0.052040960639715195,
-0.33817631006240845,
0.41953855752944946,
0.1580999791622162,
0.22148177027702332,
0.2319343388080597,
0.41242173314094543,
0.6407642960548401,
-0.6338106989860535,
0.2311192750930786,
0.3429505527019501,
-0.27391618490219116,
0.25889497995376587,
-0.34343573451042175,
-0.004501476418226957,
-0.4295741319656372,
0.24027609825134277,
-0.8415517210960388,
-0.34874939918518066,
0.23411278426647186,
-0.6952930688858032,
0.25425979495048523,
-0.04896017536520958,
-0.5121936202049255,
-0.2947937846183777,
-0.18001683056354523,
0.4609931707382202,
0.2695048153400421,
-0.36015060544013977,
0.5907138586044312,
0.3098260462284088,
-0.813328742980957,
-1.0174351930618286,
-0.2029692530632019,
0.4095156192779541,
0.08079498261213303,
-0.522521436214447,
0.6598992943763733,
0.182146355509758,
0.06629429012537003,
0.4584953784942627,
0.00107995280995965,
-0.19018656015396118,
-0.05638616159558296,
-0.001305890385992825,
0.15348219871520996,
0.011559114791452885,
0.29940658807754517,
0.25143662095069885,
-0.06822124868631363,
0.10683093219995499,
-0.12267199158668518,
0.5897202491760254,
-0.05527569726109505,
-0.07503287494182587,
0.24016788601875305,
0.408679336309433,
0.37379196286201477,
0.10688556730747223,
0.3023405969142914,
0.6693718433380127,
-0.40616273880004883,
-0.07981104403734207,
-0.05933186411857605,
0.021541032940149307,
-0.43074581027030945,
0.4548729956150055,
-0.2222132384777069,
-1.118363618850708,
0.5094059705734253,
-0.15577471256256104,
-0.10198044776916504,
0.6455146074295044,
0.28874921798706055,
-0.3281159996986389,
1.0780938863754272,
0.8158053755760193,
0.2765592038631439,
-0.07976200431585312,
-0.0755484402179718,
0.6223320960998535,
-0.8898499011993408,
-0.5919761061668396,
-0.8312873840332031,
-0.44643986225128174,
-0.6128266453742981,
-0.47108083963394165,
0.7067162394523621,
0.09938174486160278,
0.18158967792987823,
0.2872309386730194,
-0.8744845986366272,
0.6227868795394897,
0.5523164868354797,
-0.33528652787208557,
0.532748818397522,
-0.12905852496623993,
-0.649469792842865,
-0.23034872114658356,
-0.784986674785614,
-0.32791924476623535,
0.9270326495170593,
0.045413680374622345,
0.7090643644332886,
0.07045336812734604,
0.6881412863731384,
0.2168683409690857,
0.477914422750473,
-0.8770737051963806,
0.45537564158439636,
0.10092465579509735,
-0.7931662797927856,
-0.5635651350021362,
-0.5016618371009827,
-1.132257342338562,
0.560768187046051,
-0.39775359630584717,
-0.7337594032287598,
0.03021099604666233,
-0.004847972188144922,
-0.40898171067237854,
0.15798419713974,
-0.44676074385643005,
0.5910927653312683,
-0.055478546768426895,
0.06082235649228096,
-0.007155503612011671,
-0.8190003037452698,
0.4800480902194977,
-0.23554234206676483,
0.2279202938079834,
0.10346826165914536,
0.06481458246707916,
0.6955636143684387,
-0.08050088584423065,
0.5307444334030151,
-0.23855936527252197,
0.11630517989397049,
0.016621654853224754,
0.37870827317237854,
0.4946257770061493,
0.06930024176836014,
0.030981240794062614,
-0.2798144221305847,
0.44616302847862244,
-0.014867451041936874,
-0.8630347847938538,
0.7121869325637817,
-0.5672469139099121,
-0.3285578489303589,
-0.745103120803833,
-0.8310760259628296,
-0.1702522337436676,
0.40326476097106934,
0.20425672829151154,
-0.2676972448825836,
-0.2954064905643463,
0.4279532730579376,
0.7300621867179871,
-0.635294497013092,
0.08672410249710083,
0.7023838758468628,
-0.9432664513587952,
-0.006502015050500631,
0.942756712436676,
0.16827654838562012,
-0.19325865805149078,
0.9169729948043823,
0.40021100640296936,
-0.37581801414489746,
-0.5856125354766846,
-0.2449067384004593,
-0.11884085834026337,
-0.5908000469207764,
-0.28133368492126465,
-1.1661465167999268,
-0.28365597128868103,
-0.3695773482322693,
-0.18074508011341095,
-0.08434503525495529,
-0.6318889856338501,
-0.2183498740196228,
0.034171637147665024,
0.3524487018585205,
0.5250337719917297,
0.09963630139827728,
0.21565115451812744,
-0.7430605292320251,
0.5712193250656128,
0.0449821874499321,
0.46592438220977783,
-0.1600341796875,
-0.2642652690410614,
-0.29426491260528564,
-0.20003020763397217,
-0.442869633436203,
-0.6683958172798157,
0.8884318470954895,
0.2900812029838562,
0.35773369669914246,
0.40437260270118713,
0.16423384845256805,
0.2659437358379364,
-0.44114187359809875,
0.7283875346183777,
0.2650313973426819,
-0.4783969223499298,
0.6909003853797913,
-0.5829592347145081,
0.45156151056289673,
0.7033365964889526,
0.9768276214599609,
-1.0197293758392334,
-0.4956146478652954,
-0.4052039682865143,
-1.1714760065078735,
0.7329116463661194,
0.34666040539741516,
-0.19927753508090973,
0.18496865034103394,
0.12098190188407898,
0.36285680532455444,
0.21741503477096558,
-0.9161732196807861,
-0.2345024198293686,
-0.12162317335605621,
0.08315156400203705,
0.054363176226615906,
-0.08853037655353546,
-0.4364231526851654,
-0.19589297473430634,
0.9022666215896606,
-0.3231138586997986,
0.15008854866027832,
0.5500863790512085,
0.11872078478336334,
-0.2873426079750061,
0.25225281715393066,
0.33642083406448364,
0.3475319445133209,
-0.6779491901397705,
0.2950044274330139,
-0.0022644083946943283,
-0.5477755665779114,
-0.09825900942087173,
0.4711798131465912,
-0.4258396625518799,
0.306339830160141,
-0.08490004390478134,
0.43985283374786377,
0.29252007603645325,
-0.8807302117347717,
0.1437506228685379,
-0.07531766593456268,
-0.26546457409858704,
-0.28320589661598206,
0.05694379284977913,
0.5067950487136841,
0.015434634871780872,
0.6148949861526489,
0.20827555656433105,
0.5760676860809326,
-0.4365752339363098,
-0.05974649637937546,
0.6364761590957642,
-0.21427275240421295,
0.08038628101348877,
0.5560247302055359,
0.0692843496799469,
-0.46847832202911377,
0.2610642611980438,
-0.6496783494949341,
-0.4090830683708191,
0.5666084885597229,
0.4209701120853424,
0.6457961797714233,
0.09842277318239212,
0.57319176197052,
0.22650061547756195,
0.22822685539722443,
0.045665640383958817,
0.12921948730945587,
-0.22966694831848145,
-0.6904292702674866,
-0.4690295159816742,
-0.9158506989479065,
-0.6429122090339661,
0.1765020489692688,
-0.5921082496643066,
0.4272952079772949,
-0.12640608847141266,
-0.053152382373809814,
0.339924156665802,
-0.11425254493951797,
-0.5308635830879211,
0.005293880123645067,
-0.03739286959171295,
0.9971858859062195,
-0.5701712965965271,
0.6736007928848267,
0.7613381147384644,
0.06271036714315414,
-0.16773027181625366,
-0.5347124338150024,
-0.023014288395643234,
-0.671106219291687,
1.1061075925827026,
0.03822490572929382,
-0.08613844960927963,
-0.1420230269432068,
-0.3348655700683594,
-1.146485686302185,
1.1591956615447998,
-0.08213229477405548,
-0.4090111255645752,
-0.17895811796188354,
0.18539787828922272,
0.9097914099693298,
-0.18389242887496948,
0.3411068618297577,
0.3305697739124298,
0.45163652300834656,
0.1609359085559845,
-0.8894772529602051,
-0.2558613717556,
-0.534302294254303,
-0.21835975348949432,
0.5010929107666016,
-0.23040355741977692,
0.36120545864105225,
0.16507169604301453,
-0.09805657714605331,
-0.009809710085391998,
0.41319334506988525,
0.16880826652050018,
0.7907180786132812,
0.25840651988983154,
0.8048282265663147,
0.9138220548629761,
-0.0640067309141159,
0.8738370537757874,
-0.17115502059459686,
0.48769140243530273,
0.8437334299087524,
-0.4476604163646698,
0.8162660598754883,
0.6680368781089783,
-0.3299940228462219,
0.34031838178634644,
0.5411765575408936,
0.04424203559756279,
0.6122336983680725,
0.3035872280597687,
-0.5101739168167114,
0.1842556744813919,
-0.21332857012748718,
-0.5063973069190979,
0.3284534513950348,
0.599234938621521,
-0.5475049614906311,
-0.46914801001548767,
0.05098449066281319,
-0.13638414442539215,
-0.057664815336465836,
-0.11650080978870392,
0.4302460253238678,
0.19722795486450195,
-0.7609923481941223,
0.3101044297218323,
0.17038065195083618,
0.6588231921195984,
-1.1207737922668457,
-0.11901265382766724,
0.16573530435562134,
-0.40768200159072876,
-0.37139779329299927,
-0.7998743057250977,
0.42188650369644165,
-0.05545585975050926,
-0.2904754877090454,
-0.1784849911928177,
0.9643509984016418,
-0.33452412486076355,
-0.5287097096443176,
0.2918533384799957,
0.6279079914093018,
0.3272188901901245,
0.10311918705701828,
-0.6051325798034668,
-0.16238346695899963,
-0.018803592771291733,
-0.5572911500930786,
0.6217548847198486,
0.3827371299266815,
0.12052059173583984,
0.9369630813598633,
0.6728187203407288,
0.1760650873184204,
-0.04851166903972626,
-0.05034308508038521,
0.8545050024986267,
-0.6856321096420288,
-0.5888251662254333,
-0.45875224471092224,
0.05883997306227684,
-0.1610969603061676,
-0.2949097156524658,
0.6149178743362427,
0.6889722943305969,
0.8141112923622131,
-0.04331550374627113,
1.040347933769226,
-0.4023164212703705,
0.7281150817871094,
-0.3826105296611786,
0.8555798530578613,
-0.484146386384964,
0.16690285503864288,
-0.29952266812324524,
-0.9641175866127014,
-0.7475143074989319,
0.6764087677001953,
-0.12404455989599228,
-0.16046825051307678,
0.8715435266494751,
0.8398492932319641,
-0.12661860883235931,
0.3460134267807007,
0.3384123742580414,
0.25546929240226746,
0.37822040915489197,
-0.06633738428354263,
0.5791111588478088,
-0.04379877820611,
0.6577675938606262,
-0.1581059694290161,
-0.15513256192207336,
-0.3187268078327179,
-1.0530883073806763,
-0.5688212513923645,
-0.519012451171875,
-0.08545264601707458,
-0.13028261065483093,
-0.051402922719717026,
0.8274989724159241,
0.2859750986099243,
-0.6456860899925232,
0.02245497889816761,
-0.21383213996887207,
-0.10646952688694,
-0.20172592997550964,
-0.39159560203552246,
0.5275372266769409,
-0.6009264588356018,
-0.6014224886894226,
0.6673671007156372,
0.5235018134117126,
-0.3608093559741974,
-0.4013606607913971,
0.04074249789118767,
-0.42891910672187805,
-0.2548563778400421,
0.6329105496406555,
0.6604591608047485,
-0.41008082032203674,
0.1407231092453003,
0.19830328226089478,
0.13605356216430664,
0.08906292915344238,
1.0903174877166748,
-1.0035161972045898,
1.101279616355896,
0.6800423860549927,
0.8896481990814209,
0.7766720056533813,
-0.40314361453056335,
0.5430245995521545,
-0.8028696775436401,
-0.22092482447624207,
0.8387503027915955,
0.09598717093467712,
0.31569647789001465,
-0.5182209610939026,
0.7079833745956421,
0.2756272852420807,
-0.6840336322784424,
-0.9818282723426819,
0.14376208186149597,
-1.2352856397628784,
-0.4182867407798767,
0.849401593208313,
-0.0051971133798360825,
0.12102121114730835,
-0.3841819763183594,
-0.48451200127601624,
0.05849975347518921,
-0.35326334834098816,
1.0935159921646118,
1.1343762874603271,
-0.5216068625450134,
0.07083135843276978,
-1.0350099802017212,
0.6795158982276917,
0.6373558044433594,
-0.4957093894481659,
-0.200152188539505,
-0.028291793540120125,
-0.21632933616638184,
0.7694879174232483,
0.4953966736793518,
-0.14612793922424316,
0.04951775074005127,
-0.20232510566711426,
0.07110924273729324,
0.020573338493704796,
-0.08756152540445328,
0.0020919416565448046,
0.5916686654090881,
0.004678085446357727,
0.4558021128177643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15284v1 | The Greek podcast corpus: Competitive speech models for low-resourced languages with weakly supervised data | 2024-06-21T16:28:47 | 2024-06-21T16:28:47 | Georgios Paraskevopoulos, Chara Tsoukala, Athanasios Katsamanis, Vassilis Katsouros | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The development of speech technologies for languages with limited digital
representation poses significant challenges, primarily due to the scarcity of
available data. This issue is exacerbated in the era of large, data-intensive
models. Recent research has underscored the potential of leveraging weak
supervision to augment the pool of available data. In this study, we compile an
800-hour corpus of Modern Greek from podcasts and employ Whisper large-v3 to
generate silver transcriptions. This corpus is utilized to fine-tune our
models, aiming to assess the efficacy of this approach in enhancing ASR
performance. Our analysis spans 16 distinct podcast domains, alongside
evaluations on established datasets for Modern Greek. The findings indicate
consistent WER improvements, correlating with increases in both data volume and
model size. Our study confirms that assembling large, weakly supervised corpora
serves as a cost-effective strategy for advancing speech technologies in
under-resourced languages. | [
-0.356303870677948,
-0.3645296096801758,
0.26796311140060425,
-0.17199131846427917,
-0.2536325454711914,
0.04134279862046242,
-0.6170567274093628,
-0.5843268632888794,
0.42235037684440613,
0.23300518095493317,
-0.34006670117378235,
-0.43093737959861755,
-0.686080813407898,
0.16153660416603088,
-0.5406708717346191,
0.8540326356887817,
0.3682384788990021,
0.3690167963504791,
-0.10577524453401566,
0.009659742936491966,
-0.30477017164230347,
-0.3796696662902832,
-0.7637925148010254,
-0.21757714450359344,
0.32894811034202576,
0.7872666716575623,
0.7666679620742798,
0.5920209884643555,
0.38884928822517395,
0.3518791198730469,
-0.5704600214958191,
0.12007226794958115,
-0.5584045648574829,
0.19709378480911255,
-0.1291486918926239,
-0.2312506139278412,
-0.6740310788154602,
-0.108059823513031,
0.6076087355613708,
0.9915104508399963,
-0.14492370188236237,
0.446344792842865,
0.2711746096611023,
0.3422083854675293,
-0.6752083897590637,
0.016559481620788574,
-0.5922280550003052,
-0.10668821632862091,
-0.48334601521492004,
-0.1740184724330902,
-0.1204601302742958,
-0.11478423327207565,
0.3015426993370056,
-0.5855737924575806,
0.5258315205574036,
-0.08823259174823761,
0.34312400221824646,
0.3584004044532776,
-0.27611714601516724,
-0.5662028789520264,
-1.1527475118637085,
0.8215564489364624,
-0.7708779573440552,
0.421665221452713,
0.5752593874931335,
0.034055329859256744,
0.018947696313261986,
-1.072884440422058,
-0.30433306097984314,
-0.1430869996547699,
0.2990061342716217,
0.11476844549179077,
-0.6263160109519958,
-0.14552676677703857,
0.049967262893915176,
0.6733269095420837,
-0.024176442995667458,
0.26004210114479065,
-1.080069661140442,
-0.12814947962760925,
0.6205959916114807,
0.12443070858716965,
0.1778506338596344,
0.0922141894698143,
0.19909892976284027,
-0.0037927685771137476,
-0.4499492943286896,
-0.10854028910398483,
0.6499125957489014,
0.8060901165008545,
-0.20828454196453094,
0.7425928711891174,
-0.3855440318584442,
0.2787984609603882,
0.2326188087463379,
-0.21528805792331696,
0.17075787484645844,
-0.2708815038204193,
0.15834547579288483,
0.71160888671875,
0.8576831817626953,
0.06425897032022476,
0.14029963314533234,
-0.3640565574169159,
-0.0744592472910881,
0.5468618273735046,
0.5094729661941528,
-0.6402894258499146,
-0.3339702785015106,
0.1291150003671646,
-0.3619685769081116,
-0.10998523235321045,
-0.2428065836429596,
-0.551517903804779,
-0.4573059380054474,
-0.2892077565193176,
0.26210132241249084,
-0.4251852333545685,
-0.2371254861354828,
0.2521332800388336,
-0.3639451265335083,
-0.4371578097343445,
0.1113612949848175,
-1.038111925125122,
0.9037436246871948,
0.6241978406906128,
0.9368627667427063,
-0.16754229366779327,
0.11823268234729767,
-0.6359513998031616,
0.10704297572374344,
-0.5174960494041443,
0.6602817177772522,
-0.451163649559021,
-0.5667006373405457,
0.02765672467648983,
-0.25738978385925293,
0.26251378655433655,
-0.6740432977676392,
1.1173300743103027,
-0.10112464427947998,
0.058385010808706284,
-0.18512080609798431,
-0.5483567714691162,
0.18090592324733734,
-0.330936074256897,
-0.6090328097343445,
1.024495005607605,
0.0019934389274567366,
-0.7610628604888916,
0.3267110288143158,
-0.6122708320617676,
-0.5763646960258484,
0.11151359975337982,
-0.032322607934474945,
-0.236615851521492,
0.39124515652656555,
0.23437125980854034,
0.45559707283973694,
-0.32743552327156067,
0.06295621395111084,
-0.3177504539489746,
-0.6146714687347412,
0.229474738240242,
-0.4764021039009094,
0.2982872426509857,
0.46704787015914917,
-0.5685890913009644,
-0.10753078758716583,
-0.774578869342804,
-0.11479391902685165,
-0.13054883480072021,
-0.38562479615211487,
-0.3782922327518463,
0.32273489236831665,
0.17946766316890717,
-0.08880879729986191,
0.07699066400527954,
-0.6518142819404602,
-0.04121832922101021,
-0.537054181098938,
0.5649438500404358,
0.40703412890434265,
-0.2761515974998474,
0.6496080160140991,
-0.3412049412727356,
0.6261083483695984,
-0.16741307079792023,
-0.07041598111391068,
0.33549535274505615,
-0.4260008931159973,
-0.8518601059913635,
-0.5849367380142212,
0.5574519038200378,
0.2156529426574707,
-0.6364941596984863,
-0.02851562388241291,
-0.45910555124282837,
-0.6960053443908691,
-1.1001181602478027,
0.4531061053276062,
0.3636377155780792,
0.32485494017601013,
0.5204809904098511,
-0.58223557472229,
-0.7357624173164368,
-0.7918272614479065,
0.05603395774960518,
-0.05714014917612076,
-0.07030902802944183,
0.4581713080406189,
0.10969308018684387,
-0.21066498756408691,
0.5978021621704102,
-0.051642045378685,
-0.4202176630496979,
-0.5582784414291382,
0.020902009680867195,
0.4265373945236206,
0.4566231966018677,
0.14230063557624817,
-0.5425708293914795,
-0.33370351791381836,
-0.07893291115760803,
-0.5358676314353943,
-0.22936983406543732,
0.37896817922592163,
0.34324586391448975,
-0.08100210875272751,
0.7523714303970337,
-0.5755420327186584,
0.07456447184085846,
0.5953758358955383,
-0.3067496716976166,
0.3337050676345825,
-0.10789971053600311,
-0.012575754895806313,
-0.8322927951812744,
0.11087843775749207,
-0.09616374969482422,
-0.25210028886795044,
-0.6650782227516174,
-0.25497886538505554,
-0.27987849712371826,
-0.2632703483104706,
-0.7237327098846436,
0.4980127811431885,
-0.4156213104724884,
-0.26717180013656616,
-0.2749699354171753,
0.23011308908462524,
-0.4995788633823395,
-0.02562478557229042,
0.11834465712308884,
1.0229076147079468,
0.5351038575172424,
-0.6735048890113831,
0.25725987553596497,
0.3929593861103058,
-0.6026713848114014,
0.26010018587112427,
-0.8352526426315308,
0.16287879645824432,
0.02388428896665573,
0.15123623609542847,
-0.7482783794403076,
-0.3018666207790375,
-0.01563524827361107,
-0.36106061935424805,
0.42459845542907715,
-0.38367772102355957,
-0.5036316514015198,
-0.2830193042755127,
-0.04933992400765419,
0.5082480311393738,
0.4952056109905243,
-0.26232481002807617,
0.3890917897224426,
0.7001420259475708,
-0.7883076667785645,
-0.37587970495224,
-0.41704484820365906,
0.15687212347984314,
-0.5030850768089294,
-0.521748423576355,
0.4058724045753479,
0.07797185331583023,
-0.5430499315261841,
0.11155473440885544,
-0.22108402848243713,
0.13441279530525208,
-0.011201584711670876,
0.4919292628765106,
-0.05710536614060402,
-0.6138433218002319,
0.013958089053630829,
-0.1589411199092865,
-0.1182040274143219,
-0.3096350431442261,
-0.2577003538608551,
0.6683225631713867,
-0.13539430499076843,
-0.139230877161026,
-0.9710787534713745,
0.4110944867134094,
0.5615194439888,
0.15717464685440063,
0.3963199555873871,
0.6061987280845642,
-0.08036237210035324,
-0.14547505974769592,
-0.5799728035926819,
-0.1737801879644394,
-0.5304815769195557,
0.06465813517570496,
-0.3565484285354614,
-0.8313283920288086,
0.42480066418647766,
-0.03195681422948837,
-0.30923983454704285,
0.5213103890419006,
0.6544504165649414,
-0.21851672232151031,
1.0383270978927612,
0.5729471445083618,
-0.3378489017486572,
0.5470483899116516,
-0.32515713572502136,
-0.19743038713932037,
-0.8118460178375244,
0.05032869055867195,
-0.6487799882888794,
-0.42984941601753235,
-0.6216051578521729,
-0.30048856139183044,
0.4566497206687927,
0.023200388997793198,
-0.0693877637386322,
0.2581096291542053,
-0.360239714384079,
0.44082263112068176,
0.9986573457717896,
-0.0922287181019783,
0.37977030873298645,
-0.040060512721538544,
-0.05730259045958519,
-0.09696173667907715,
-1.0335556268692017,
-0.6906409859657288,
1.3026995658874512,
0.38289913535118103,
0.8202314376831055,
0.31232187151908875,
0.5768469572067261,
0.5511016249656677,
-0.12575297057628632,
-0.9008213877677917,
0.2982606589794159,
-0.5090065598487854,
-0.6508092284202576,
-0.27767860889434814,
-0.30565956234931946,
-1.0781327486038208,
0.14351709187030792,
-0.306033194065094,
-0.696313738822937,
0.3484613299369812,
0.2059403359889984,
-0.5975781083106995,
-0.033789943903684616,
-0.8262026906013489,
0.6992310285568237,
0.11597337573766708,
-0.46251755952835083,
-0.20451726019382477,
-0.30666205286979675,
0.15886512398719788,
0.015193132683634758,
0.2967688739299774,
0.058748092502355576,
0.13532990217208862,
0.932696521282196,
-0.5350123643875122,
0.8378629088401794,
-0.008367234840989113,
-0.022204509004950523,
0.3607308268547058,
-0.029514392837882042,
0.4036498963832855,
0.09009906649589539,
-0.19869330525398254,
-0.001980985514819622,
0.09046254307031631,
-0.387958824634552,
0.05790949612855911,
0.6003999710083008,
-0.9090947508811951,
-0.3000015318393707,
-0.3535337448120117,
-0.41858768463134766,
-0.5269899964332581,
0.006665215827524662,
0.49314695596694946,
0.7597112655639648,
-0.3338036835193634,
0.5413455367088318,
0.41074371337890625,
-0.0019615408964455128,
0.3042956590652466,
0.37319257855415344,
0.3996691107749939,
-0.4775194227695465,
0.8229076266288757,
0.14416822791099548,
0.20517270267009735,
-0.40155521035194397,
0.023971248418092728,
-0.24744443595409393,
-0.8892748951911926,
-0.287561297416687,
0.217528834939003,
-0.42087632417678833,
-0.15687739849090576,
-0.5892866849899292,
0.11536142975091934,
-0.5809266567230225,
-0.0686734989285469,
-0.9475821256637573,
-0.7702720165252686,
-0.5917804837226868,
-0.048630695790052414,
0.16977716982364655,
0.6248140931129456,
-0.25832781195640564,
0.7191181182861328,
-0.5750409364700317,
0.5373806357383728,
0.14537207782268524,
0.22647365927696228,
-0.2112300544977188,
-0.6046575903892517,
-0.4148831367492676,
0.07605038583278656,
-0.3669537305831909,
-0.5071905255317688,
0.5312734842300415,
0.46294617652893066,
0.4129183292388916,
0.46086248755455017,
0.3412584364414215,
0.7696817517280579,
-0.7845051884651184,
0.8807085156440735,
0.09460964053869247,
-0.9867784976959229,
0.35257014632225037,
-0.5979900360107422,
0.3083347678184509,
0.6612064242362976,
0.2394445687532425,
-0.3581368625164032,
-0.8493496775627136,
-0.9143272042274475,
-1.071358323097229,
0.888850748538971,
0.29420405626296997,
0.4655112028121948,
-0.009339382871985435,
-0.036268364638090134,
0.0797250047326088,
0.22560326755046844,
-0.18800464272499084,
-0.1570093035697937,
-0.061310090124607086,
-0.23588772118091583,
-0.5453637838363647,
-0.2699395716190338,
-0.19505174458026886,
-0.1559804379940033,
1.022742748260498,
-0.012376108206808567,
0.22745932638645172,
0.1196848526597023,
-0.031294677406549454,
-0.34093931317329407,
0.40887144207954407,
0.5907415151596069,
0.4326085150241852,
-0.3690347671508789,
0.2668704390525818,
0.1638273447751999,
-0.663307785987854,
-0.14583832025527954,
0.21979279816150665,
-0.02597198821604252,
0.2512836158275604,
0.4435882568359375,
0.8829395174980164,
0.45696258544921875,
-0.7773163914680481,
0.4568604528903961,
-0.20850397646427155,
-0.2043626308441162,
-0.5932849049568176,
0.09702306985855103,
0.26012489199638367,
0.6014068722724915,
0.43519845604896545,
0.0473683662712574,
0.3826093375682831,
-0.8402844071388245,
0.11433466523885727,
0.3169317841529846,
-0.5196967124938965,
-0.3360833525657654,
0.9363466501235962,
0.19268563389778137,
-0.11053811758756638,
0.5222019553184509,
-0.01691323332488537,
-0.1888858526945114,
0.25158604979515076,
0.5666120052337646,
0.4220093786716461,
-0.07745764404535294,
0.018863027915358543,
0.08245988935232162,
0.07697237282991409,
-0.3500984013080597,
0.22374004125595093,
-0.22388532757759094,
-0.5626055002212524,
-0.4431779682636261,
-0.7123064398765564,
-0.5042533874511719,
0.22526457905769348,
-0.8490143418312073,
0.34608563780784607,
-0.2209121286869049,
-0.6868779063224792,
0.299980491399765,
0.09005890041589737,
-0.6047883629798889,
0.15102407336235046,
0.35548877716064453,
0.6426190733909607,
-0.7447268962860107,
0.6621132493019104,
0.408231258392334,
-0.1097135990858078,
-0.5865359902381897,
-0.30646735429763794,
0.20374859869480133,
-0.3236366808414459,
0.6322410702705383,
-0.3736676871776581,
-0.38180381059646606,
0.03463800996541977,
-0.45152395963668823,
-0.9362878799438477,
0.7669997215270996,
0.6090152263641357,
-0.5210024118423462,
0.132651224732399,
-0.053777892142534256,
0.7136224508285522,
-0.21790646016597748,
-0.1044773980975151,
0.47267672419548035,
0.007243169471621513,
0.30894291400909424,
-1.3253284692764282,
-0.4138643145561218,
-0.4321282207965851,
-0.3230341970920563,
0.015131901018321514,
-0.3183784782886505,
0.7574865221977234,
-0.0667065754532814,
-0.35582640767097473,
0.37565138936042786,
0.8218684792518616,
-0.08254602551460266,
0.4302807152271271,
0.21972347795963287,
0.47310060262680054,
0.7739838361740112,
0.06300081312656403,
1.1775857210159302,
-0.18639317154884338,
0.04698706418275833,
1.3418740034103394,
-0.1138267070055008,
1.086542010307312,
0.48281699419021606,
-0.04379494860768318,
0.12928175926208496,
0.3966921865940094,
0.14993004500865936,
0.6893270015716553,
0.0007768184295855463,
-0.5122929811477661,
-0.3661584258079529,
-0.5440394282341003,
-0.4920351505279541,
0.8250796794891357,
0.501957356929779,
-0.35517418384552,
0.20875126123428345,
-0.1204386055469513,
0.06316784769296646,
0.11250787228345871,
-0.5370926260948181,
1.0897910594940186,
0.23130697011947632,
-0.3110547959804535,
0.6832213401794434,
-0.0049034408293664455,
0.7163037657737732,
-0.33291810750961304,
0.40216028690338135,
-0.1325121521949768,
0.4235565960407257,
-0.08255981653928757,
-0.07296633720397949,
0.16594308614730835,
0.43417632579803467,
-0.10710763186216354,
-0.1818934679031372,
0.614997148513794,
-0.3573591411113739,
-0.6086116433143616,
0.17102760076522827,
0.6224440932273865,
0.27917325496673584,
0.15479131042957306,
-0.054966267198324203,
0.1556064337491989,
-0.406524658203125,
0.1249038577079773,
0.23126691579818726,
0.4609237015247345,
0.10544081032276154,
0.56068354845047,
0.7332587838172913,
0.7813320755958557,
0.08964626491069794,
-0.021430687978863716,
0.880830705165863,
-0.35990846157073975,
-0.5865314602851868,
-0.5755563378334045,
0.5064601898193359,
-0.029911130666732788,
-0.26389703154563904,
0.7650843262672424,
0.7693454623222351,
0.7736906409263611,
-0.054490890353918076,
0.8011373281478882,
0.12254038453102112,
0.9532815217971802,
-0.5399186015129089,
0.6898014545440674,
-0.5077753663063049,
0.25685369968414307,
-0.6159040331840515,
-0.8628288507461548,
-0.12215311080217361,
0.4971237778663635,
-0.41657742857933044,
-0.3303817808628082,
0.3638807237148285,
0.5639677047729492,
-0.6061115264892578,
0.07729464024305344,
0.13479825854301453,
0.29716169834136963,
-0.07197164744138718,
0.10182642191648483,
0.9927916526794434,
-0.423733651638031,
0.6234328150749207,
-0.13751612603664398,
0.24376550316810608,
-0.18600063025951385,
-0.45436742901802063,
-0.6854801177978516,
-0.5152697563171387,
-0.4194371998310089,
-0.3145636022090912,
0.2726839482784271,
1.0179623365402222,
0.7489385008811951,
-0.9306245446205139,
-0.4287201464176178,
0.24695922434329987,
-0.2801092565059662,
-0.2002229541540146,
-0.10427292436361313,
0.3333146572113037,
-0.36332663893699646,
-0.9904712438583374,
0.968032956123352,
-0.21334293484687805,
0.05473267659544945,
0.28490424156188965,
-0.27016955614089966,
0.23650360107421875,
0.017572997137904167,
0.36904576420783997,
0.44144243001937866,
-0.5447030067443848,
-0.05635966360569,
-0.2927533686161041,
0.022005785256624222,
-0.08826649188995361,
0.7941931486129761,
-0.7049632668495178,
0.34591159224510193,
0.1443142145872116,
0.43578198552131653,
0.8215394616127014,
0.10605195164680481,
0.6853503584861755,
-0.8397183418273926,
0.2973899245262146,
0.4593017101287842,
0.41407471895217896,
0.5597138404846191,
0.11701314151287079,
0.5153183341026306,
0.06576479971408844,
-0.29211318492889404,
-1.0748693943023682,
-0.1516944319009781,
-0.9723829030990601,
-0.12493429332971573,
1.4515568017959595,
0.16413554549217224,
0.22576823830604553,
-0.33798691630363464,
-0.2138618379831314,
0.4494855999946594,
-0.7288143634796143,
0.8669156432151794,
0.5701459646224976,
0.022918295115232468,
0.011586915701627731,
-0.9326756596565247,
0.7998557686805725,
0.2830202579498291,
-0.32511934638023376,
-0.06265891343355179,
0.6606031656265259,
0.11947546899318695,
0.3590415120124817,
0.8303219676017761,
0.02843029983341694,
0.30343204736709595,
0.2068161964416504,
-0.3008604049682617,
0.03481123223900795,
-0.2349587082862854,
-0.30898627638816833,
0.3500393331050873,
0.25169122219085693,
-0.11827456951141357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15279v1 | Cross-Modality Safety Alignment | 2024-06-21T16:14:15 | 2024-06-21T16:14:15 | Siyin Wang, Xingsong Ye, Qinyuan Cheng, Junwen Duan, Shimin Li, Jinlan Fu, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | As Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) becomes increasingly integrated into
various facets of human life, ensuring the safety and ethical alignment of such
systems is paramount. Previous studies primarily focus on single-modality
threats, which may not suffice given the integrated and complex nature of
cross-modality interactions. We introduce a novel safety alignment challenge
called Safe Inputs but Unsafe Output (SIUO) to evaluate cross-modality safety
alignment. Specifically, it considers cases where single modalities are safe
independently but could potentially lead to unsafe or unethical outputs when
combined. To empirically investigate this problem, we developed the SIUO, a
cross-modality benchmark encompassing 9 critical safety domains, such as
self-harm, illegal activities, and privacy violations. Our findings reveal
substantial safety vulnerabilities in both closed- and open-source LVLMs, such
as GPT-4V and LLaVA, underscoring the inadequacy of current models to reliably
interpret and respond to complex, real-world scenarios. | [
0.07458756864070892,
-0.5803427696228027,
0.4756298065185547,
-0.20693084597587585,
0.11461479961872101,
-0.014719225466251373,
0.3429088294506073,
-0.8154955506324768,
-0.4808572828769684,
0.1800239235162735,
-0.7032164335250854,
-0.1999257355928421,
-0.5544372200965881,
-0.08657337725162506,
-0.3296844959259033,
1.1246780157089233,
-0.09324655681848526,
0.10566520690917969,
-0.19030891358852386,
-0.39612913131713867,
-0.8114498853683472,
-0.582165002822876,
-0.42209509015083313,
0.055183764547109604,
0.7052183747291565,
0.051959503442049026,
0.7401838898658752,
0.48238345980644226,
0.6254018545150757,
0.33206474781036377,
0.5399930477142334,
-0.04725159704685211,
-0.44766390323638916,
0.040833089500665665,
-0.34565016627311707,
0.08465465903282166,
-0.7752899527549744,
0.2291126549243927,
0.41853317618370056,
0.41614264249801636,
0.1014706939458847,
0.025563010945916176,
0.22989636659622192,
0.3148271143436432,
-0.7857339978218079,
-0.3690909445285797,
-0.4889110326766968,
0.16375385224819183,
-0.1420285552740097,
-0.31488990783691406,
-0.36919963359832764,
-0.43180567026138306,
0.006508429069072008,
-0.49919164180755615,
-0.45263832807540894,
0.1307670772075653,
0.8150088787078857,
0.7381029725074768,
-0.851952314376831,
-0.11578365415334702,
-0.8456021547317505,
0.8294550180435181,
-0.5090624690055847,
0.5697954893112183,
0.1703387200832367,
0.2934681177139282,
-0.17297370731830597,
-0.35103344917297363,
-0.2002253532409668,
0.03988732025027275,
-0.2629254460334778,
0.07978826761245728,
-0.13380783796310425,
0.178681880235672,
-0.030255602672696114,
-0.1323084831237793,
-0.6373263597488403,
0.19523414969444275,
-0.4537825882434845,
-0.4910563826560974,
0.8937674164772034,
0.3679613173007965,
0.584754467010498,
0.10061077773571014,
-0.7532511353492737,
-0.01670372299849987,
-0.7906222939491272,
0.30826812982559204,
0.7249301671981812,
0.19899071753025055,
-0.15951119363307953,
0.49715670943260193,
0.07391633093357086,
0.4272383153438568,
0.13112954795360565,
-0.4098541736602783,
0.23336640000343323,
-0.9541935324668884,
-0.24835540354251862,
0.20453451573848724,
1.1921459436416626,
0.7196306586265564,
0.1559799313545227,
-0.34727591276168823,
-0.013788318261504173,
-0.018730981275439262,
0.47239968180656433,
-0.4792289435863495,
0.14171850681304932,
0.30151915550231934,
-0.1831827163696289,
-0.7570812106132507,
0.0484357513487339,
-0.49059560894966125,
-0.4515562653541565,
0.0010199655080214143,
0.7665243148803711,
-0.5050446391105652,
-0.09842301905155182,
-0.31281328201293945,
0.32496780157089233,
0.2884821593761444,
0.20288267731666565,
-0.6690242290496826,
0.054232943803071976,
0.8366774320602417,
0.48729372024536133,
-0.3653942942619324,
-0.5646389722824097,
-1.0004870891571045,
0.5021363496780396,
-0.14653700590133667,
0.282589852809906,
-0.37089473009109497,
-0.41620323061943054,
-0.281460165977478,
0.23451340198516846,
-0.36544835567474365,
-0.006566653959453106,
0.5992147326469421,
-0.1704760640859604,
0.444709837436676,
-0.09744247049093246,
-0.17930549383163452,
-0.19486182928085327,
0.11219644546508789,
-0.568630039691925,
0.5558860898017883,
-0.007578602060675621,
-0.8030918836593628,
0.5653591752052307,
-0.3642711341381073,
-0.7540507316589355,
-0.2336864173412323,
-0.7408753633499146,
-0.5723856091499329,
-0.2668609619140625,
-0.2596866190433502,
0.30090612173080444,
-0.07504390925168991,
0.6262572407722473,
-0.45917603373527527,
-0.2878389060497284,
0.41489630937576294,
-0.9173563718795776,
0.8963048458099365,
-0.043245576322078705,
-0.6486820578575134,
0.6631889939308167,
-0.8539043664932251,
0.1765991449356079,
-0.14090797305107117,
-0.32496488094329834,
-0.46533069014549255,
-0.13140025734901428,
-0.022388126701116562,
0.3970113694667816,
0.31089693307876587,
-0.6490404009819031,
-0.20582003891468048,
0.2492523491382599,
0.3613150417804718,
1.1104224920272827,
-0.24846604466438293,
0.5839022994041443,
-0.31467512249946594,
0.3823222815990448,
0.04427086189389229,
0.5830705761909485,
0.3543089032173157,
-0.4420977830886841,
-0.14272527396678925,
-0.23792950809001923,
0.31347793340682983,
0.96891188621521,
-0.48311153054237366,
0.586174488067627,
-0.130545511841774,
-0.2567327618598938,
-0.4542776644229889,
-0.010066858492791653,
0.5473942756652832,
0.7218503355979919,
0.07178470492362976,
-0.21868939697742462,
-0.09784279018640518,
-1.0393216609954834,
-0.2815033495426178,
-0.35552722215652466,
-0.06265775114297867,
0.3880983889102936,
0.21523040533065796,
-0.4007164537906647,
0.5305851101875305,
0.25620797276496887,
-0.25536787509918213,
0.3564442992210388,
0.22737228870391846,
-0.29820331931114197,
0.9314234852790833,
0.609225332736969,
-0.7290940284729004,
0.006133882328867912,
0.4771375358104706,
-0.9539589285850525,
0.04789023473858833,
-0.33218032121658325,
-0.4001355767250061,
0.3116006851196289,
0.5005698204040527,
-0.3093443512916565,
0.7442461252212524,
0.5125256180763245,
-0.559098482131958,
0.21747171878814697,
0.013482598587870598,
0.4978092312812805,
-0.8972404599189758,
0.31771746277809143,
-0.20263777673244476,
-0.3230054974555969,
-0.6558274030685425,
0.10831844061613083,
0.23740434646606445,
-0.030345892533659935,
-0.7838161587715149,
-0.03357410803437233,
-0.2203284502029419,
-0.07650453597307205,
0.14548735320568085,
-0.33227548003196716,
-0.10692688077688217,
0.446842759847641,
-0.33709990978240967,
1.0056500434875488,
0.3880350887775421,
-0.33672672510147095,
0.17939253151416779,
-0.1517886221408844,
-0.007970673963427544,
0.5263314843177795,
-0.7623839974403381,
0.16269107162952423,
0.019536728039383888,
-0.08806885778903961,
-0.5284812450408936,
-0.4340752065181732,
0.5199989080429077,
-0.32242172956466675,
0.3558279275894165,
0.14914025366306305,
0.05172407254576683,
0.21236340701580048,
-0.47062385082244873,
0.9039680361747742,
0.294021338224411,
0.011059197597205639,
0.8599594831466675,
0.5239701271057129,
-0.1578226089477539,
-1.0062901973724365,
-0.7563859224319458,
-0.2451133280992508,
-0.5026540756225586,
-0.7404459714889526,
0.10246984660625458,
-0.24271918833255768,
-0.12871339917182922,
0.12782183289527893,
-0.1313486546278,
0.1686972826719284,
0.5016656517982483,
0.5176505446434021,
0.5381019711494446,
-0.08783771842718124,
-0.29667073488235474,
0.16825082898139954,
-0.16935323178768158,
0.23315636813640594,
0.35149508714675903,
0.046398673206567764,
-0.3968009650707245,
-0.7518119812011719,
-0.5839397311210632,
1.071175217628479,
0.9538402557373047,
0.03137882053852081,
0.3418048918247223,
0.5503110289573669,
-0.5337189435958862,
0.33399316668510437,
-0.11757349967956543,
0.12435559183359146,
-0.511267364025116,
0.29111483693122864,
-0.16706454753875732,
-0.963498055934906,
0.39835208654403687,
0.1823202520608902,
0.34600746631622314,
0.25112587213516235,
0.35376521944999695,
0.03322084620594978,
1.3406988382339478,
0.7426195740699768,
-0.12587985396385193,
0.2684547007083893,
0.3097524046897888,
0.5986346006393433,
-0.48747339844703674,
-0.4072771668434143,
-0.20553313195705414,
-0.3626399040222168,
-0.658482551574707,
-0.25288131833076477,
0.6330997347831726,
-0.17940747737884521,
-0.47214609384536743,
0.3103392720222473,
-0.503993570804596,
0.4079255759716034,
0.6571418046951294,
-0.060793742537498474,
0.4162561297416687,
-0.3753170073032379,
-0.07026652991771698,
0.05133591219782829,
-0.5170820355415344,
-0.4087660312652588,
0.7187967896461487,
0.4594327509403229,
1.1574519872665405,
0.3472342789173126,
0.7667626142501831,
0.3528905212879181,
0.1349974274635315,
-0.624566376209259,
0.5159862637519836,
-0.05017821863293648,
-0.6423022150993347,
-0.5346195101737976,
-0.3966358006000519,
-0.8222694396972656,
0.13142633438110352,
-0.24285754561424255,
-1.0135958194732666,
0.4861339032649994,
0.04669037461280823,
-0.742037832736969,
0.15470898151397705,
-0.6670722365379333,
1.1526905298233032,
-0.9055367112159729,
-0.6003018617630005,
0.08177118748426437,
-1.0067322254180908,
0.6782417297363281,
-0.24835827946662903,
0.4705885350704193,
-0.4169977307319641,
-0.05338399484753609,
0.3245786130428314,
-0.38790953159332275,
0.8114432692527771,
0.30409371852874756,
-0.2797369360923767,
0.07630033046007156,
0.011019570752978325,
0.22758954763412476,
0.09757641702890396,
0.06250349432229996,
0.30732983350753784,
0.14093753695487976,
-0.19189901649951935,
-0.2804132401943207,
0.9865891337394714,
-0.9955006837844849,
-0.6583279371261597,
-0.7894165515899658,
-0.8730958700180054,
-0.3099651038646698,
0.3679315447807312,
0.5523019433021545,
0.2658911645412445,
-0.23275505006313324,
0.1351671814918518,
0.5603988170623779,
0.053103573620319366,
0.5668720602989197,
0.23452021181583405,
0.16053076088428497,
-0.5581169128417969,
1.048134446144104,
0.1565781682729721,
0.5407979488372803,
-0.14276060461997986,
-0.12179142236709595,
0.02071985974907875,
-0.3778107166290283,
-0.8778626322746277,
-0.11612522602081299,
-0.691474199295044,
-0.4418855905532837,
-0.4856444001197815,
-0.48366779088974,
-0.5821756720542908,
-0.34806063771247864,
-0.21607793867588043,
-0.21238838136196136,
-0.2753984332084656,
-0.1298486739397049,
-0.04550231620669365,
0.6319615840911865,
-0.37015148997306824,
-0.3693433701992035,
-1.088390827178955,
0.16875825822353363,
0.5997611284255981,
0.2571069300174713,
-0.3330233693122864,
0.06288383901119232,
0.18215268850326538,
-0.018526794388890266,
-0.262909859418869,
-0.7982030510902405,
-0.07783378660678864,
0.019660359248518944,
0.793728768825531,
0.43625473976135254,
0.37373480200767517,
0.5962527394294739,
-0.7556684017181396,
0.6375527381896973,
0.6245477199554443,
-0.9246651530265808,
0.4568421244621277,
-0.49927523732185364,
-0.04384126886725426,
0.8553537726402283,
0.6180753111839294,
-0.21989397704601288,
-0.25637057423591614,
-0.3706262707710266,
-1.014677882194519,
0.3802974820137024,
0.3397003412246704,
-0.3022131621837616,
0.1676386594772339,
-0.3465043008327484,
0.5289504528045654,
0.10871107876300812,
-0.8840994834899902,
0.13210998475551605,
-0.14282219111919403,
-0.4311355948448181,
0.5403303503990173,
0.185995951294899,
-0.7867738008499146,
-0.18634909391403198,
0.7781264185905457,
-0.2997047007083893,
0.24922825396060944,
0.11375109106302261,
0.02040986903011799,
-0.6191360950469971,
0.39125996828079224,
0.7608452439308167,
0.45594272017478943,
-0.006404782645404339,
0.18462024629116058,
0.06668329983949661,
-0.34978508949279785,
0.4907810688018799,
0.24989821016788483,
-0.4024936854839325,
-0.47841936349868774,
0.34188947081565857,
0.6150317788124084,
0.1727004051208496,
-0.7381632328033447,
0.6822819709777832,
-0.42776671051979065,
-0.14357855916023254,
-0.22626250982284546,
0.3605321943759918,
-0.2984141707420349,
0.30283862352371216,
0.2659977972507477,
0.3740808963775635,
0.3784951865673065,
-0.772666335105896,
0.19521506130695343,
0.6890591979026794,
-0.44544145464897156,
-0.21139828860759735,
1.0346413850784302,
0.44870954751968384,
-0.3452115058898926,
0.08423130214214325,
0.15815629065036774,
-0.15573319792747498,
0.5069023370742798,
0.18009372055530548,
1.144598126411438,
-0.1274137794971466,
0.04660254344344139,
-0.05164123699069023,
0.6116279363632202,
0.38900133967399597,
0.24311581254005432,
0.1364087462425232,
-0.4700482189655304,
-0.3334565758705139,
-0.29981911182403564,
-0.48246872425079346,
0.25629812479019165,
-0.7344584465026855,
0.07015305757522583,
-0.5425763130187988,
-0.17556428909301758,
-0.05088935047388077,
-0.6311806440353394,
-0.44808998703956604,
0.204254150390625,
0.1942068487405777,
0.15303221344947815,
-1.044352650642395,
0.5859735608100891,
0.7357579469680786,
-0.18327051401138306,
-0.8707209825515747,
0.23094159364700317,
0.30073270201683044,
-0.5919333100318909,
0.09495359659194946,
0.3259054720401764,
-0.5712766647338867,
-0.6209055185317993,
-0.487612783908844,
-1.0563600063323975,
1.2918074131011963,
0.449409544467926,
-0.5067492723464966,
-0.34646081924438477,
0.4919288158416748,
0.14624644815921783,
-0.2500704824924469,
-0.23617276549339294,
0.5721217393875122,
0.45617368817329407,
-0.25552067160606384,
-1.2126706838607788,
0.45597943663597107,
-0.43977630138397217,
-0.28514721989631653,
0.21791696548461914,
-0.7657644152641296,
0.7710270285606384,
-0.07220101356506348,
-0.34279870986938477,
0.11920569092035294,
0.6321200728416443,
0.31754961609840393,
0.8562167882919312,
0.6375617384910583,
0.5255322456359863,
0.627334475517273,
-0.09085838496685028,
0.6645112633705139,
-0.3303699195384979,
-0.09840206056833267,
1.1058783531188965,
-0.33754926919937134,
0.38457581400871277,
0.6610903739929199,
0.15861324965953827,
0.20200780034065247,
0.47295713424682617,
0.3868652582168579,
0.7375805974006653,
-0.30160266160964966,
-0.18026940524578094,
-0.4252679646015167,
-0.1698790341615677,
-0.6709904074668884,
0.38654986023902893,
0.1260450929403305,
-0.22318755090236664,
0.041916877031326294,
0.04850216209888458,
-0.008203897625207901,
-0.2575686573982239,
-0.0238430704921484,
0.7049473524093628,
-0.12259989976882935,
-0.6552520990371704,
0.361860454082489,
-0.41927558183670044,
0.6941598653793335,
-0.42672720551490784,
-0.025985952466726303,
0.09155572950839996,
0.12245037406682968,
-0.34356236457824707,
-0.7216756343841553,
0.4209274351596832,
-0.0686260536313057,
0.19582097232341766,
-0.024266965687274933,
0.8892967700958252,
-0.375093013048172,
-0.47558528184890747,
0.37764087319374084,
0.44081270694732666,
-0.2634526193141937,
0.7350147366523743,
-0.5195955038070679,
0.32109737396240234,
-0.1083538681268692,
-0.12170857191085815,
0.6035827398300171,
0.5471482276916504,
-0.3095698058605194,
0.4217689335346222,
0.4276838004589081,
-0.567423939704895,
0.22388336062431335,
-0.21889705955982208,
0.8853294849395752,
-0.6282334923744202,
-0.47379884123802185,
-0.6018134355545044,
0.8766505122184753,
-0.14601267874240875,
-0.5669146180152893,
0.5598228573799133,
0.16960614919662476,
0.906581461429596,
0.17768564820289612,
1.032265305519104,
-0.18388527631759644,
-0.04122764244675636,
-0.43867141008377075,
0.775607705116272,
-0.6896209120750427,
0.13680499792099,
-0.38079559803009033,
-0.3933670222759247,
-0.03176964446902275,
0.3826701045036316,
-0.10055355727672577,
-0.11502354592084885,
0.660085916519165,
0.5049031972885132,
-0.14875437319278717,
0.05570203810930252,
0.5889203548431396,
-0.16532520949840546,
0.26636558771133423,
0.8223869800567627,
0.8575059771537781,
-0.519559919834137,
0.7846792340278625,
-0.40714654326438904,
-0.2774381637573242,
-0.08792219310998917,
-1.1928027868270874,
-0.6552199721336365,
-0.46302273869514465,
-0.5079907178878784,
-0.3854816257953644,
0.27095142006874084,
0.49745991826057434,
0.5716497898101807,
-0.8984624743461609,
0.07603777199983597,
0.012084875255823135,
0.03082490712404251,
-0.18670035898685455,
-0.19980421662330627,
-0.041285738348960876,
0.14263956248760223,
-0.664720892906189,
0.6243603825569153,
0.47423163056373596,
0.17938661575317383,
-0.2703312635421753,
-0.14151398837566376,
-0.20598886907100677,
0.18839707970619202,
0.2839180827140808,
0.3911842107772827,
-0.831184983253479,
-1.01556396484375,
-0.05413295328617096,
-0.40724873542785645,
-0.12006373703479767,
0.6718892455101013,
-0.4055243730545044,
0.05199412629008293,
0.6249839663505554,
0.9531528353691101,
-0.3981613218784332,
0.05536506325006485,
0.8270111083984375,
-0.5726906061172485,
-0.06286861002445221,
0.36271628737449646,
0.5748096108436584,
0.23028621077537537,
-1.0102638006210327,
0.745139479637146,
0.09432583302259445,
-0.9199194312095642,
-0.8438822627067566,
0.4041210114955902,
-1.2493977546691895,
-0.1703890860080719,
0.9445644021034241,
-0.1726233810186386,
-0.4734214246273041,
-0.10430548340082169,
-0.20057110488414764,
0.32492056488990784,
-0.3190918564796448,
0.6407268643379211,
0.3844420909881592,
-0.3350929021835327,
0.09031184762716293,
-0.34716469049453735,
0.3465676009654999,
0.5663280487060547,
-0.8927608132362366,
-0.10666996240615845,
0.7698535919189453,
0.3655836284160614,
0.3781430721282959,
0.3338296413421631,
-0.18538089096546173,
0.7622745037078857,
-0.12255822867155075,
-0.2681603729724884,
-0.03440963849425316,
-0.5304851531982422,
-0.2810418903827667,
0.3551064431667328,
-0.3826335370540619,
-0.45496895909309387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15275v1 | Cognitive Map for Language Models: Optimal Planning via Verbally Representing the World Model | 2024-06-21T16:10:05 | 2024-06-21T16:10:05 | Doyoung Kim, Jongwon Lee, Jinho Park, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models have demonstrated impressive capabilities across various
natural language processing tasks, yet they struggle with planning tasks
requiring multi-step simulations. Inspired by human cognitive processes, this
paper investigates the optimal planning power of language models that can
construct a cognitive map of a given environment. Our experiments demonstrate
that cognitive map significantly enhances the performance of both optimal and
reachable planning generation ability in the Gridworld path planning task. We
observe that our method showcases two key characteristics similar to human
cognition: \textbf{generalization of its planning ability to extrapolated
environments and rapid adaptation with limited training data.} We hope our
findings in the Gridworld task provide insights into modeling human cognitive
processes in language models, potentially leading to the development of more
advanced and robust systems that better resemble human cognition. | [
-0.5579161047935486,
-0.8114813566207886,
0.7215251326560974,
0.2556960880756378,
0.08561892807483673,
-0.14962290227413177,
-0.6817561388015747,
-0.5485410690307617,
-0.07657698541879654,
0.839850127696991,
-0.5861059427261353,
-0.567815899848938,
-0.33739879727363586,
-0.4318811893463135,
-0.15550757944583893,
0.6695884466171265,
0.07061223685741425,
-0.2937890887260437,
-0.31938472390174866,
0.16183139383792877,
-0.44698140025138855,
-0.5056405663490295,
-0.7296430468559265,
-0.7663261890411377,
0.09982535988092422,
0.58717280626297,
1.0625731945037842,
0.5416926741600037,
0.3973466753959656,
0.36994603276252747,
0.15885044634342194,
0.02286272682249546,
-0.5702072978019714,
0.4735444486141205,
-0.15270960330963135,
-0.22117862105369568,
-0.762499213218689,
-0.006209779996424913,
0.41343212127685547,
0.6266207098960876,
-0.31457170844078064,
0.26598477363586426,
-0.05205075070261955,
0.3478252589702606,
-0.4921233355998993,
0.5349388718605042,
-0.8858953714370728,
0.024810532107949257,
0.05902735888957977,
-0.17337146401405334,
-0.3087015748023987,
0.027798686176538467,
0.2284008264541626,
-1.028212308883667,
0.24417471885681152,
0.30774760246276855,
0.5271265506744385,
0.023625720292329788,
-0.32979413866996765,
-0.16754600405693054,
-1.1276599168777466,
0.7917447686195374,
-0.2583707273006439,
0.13672618567943573,
0.6569651961326599,
0.6275209784507751,
-0.39906781911849976,
-0.5983041524887085,
-0.5528318285942078,
-0.2647203803062439,
0.16922137141227722,
0.28998830914497375,
-0.08412576466798782,
0.35564714670181274,
0.533837080001831,
-0.20332583785057068,
-0.5279431939125061,
-0.040666770190000534,
-0.1041284129023552,
-0.19848307967185974,
0.9636681079864502,
0.4517534375190735,
0.5813261866569519,
-0.11675890535116196,
0.004893194884061813,
-0.43678632378578186,
-0.4891822636127472,
0.07349450886249542,
-0.00230712560005486,
0.4010682702064514,
0.09097303450107574,
0.437993586063385,
-0.5242594480514526,
1.0761557817459106,
-0.6830180883407593,
-0.20731927454471588,
-0.23653578758239746,
-0.3979010283946991,
-0.009692634455859661,
-0.13450923562049866,
0.3605412244796753,
0.5145801901817322,
0.6809104681015015,
-0.1953539103269577,
-0.40775972604751587,
0.3479445278644562,
0.47146934270858765,
-0.2998357117176056,
-0.4377286732196808,
-0.00788880791515112,
-0.08157522231340408,
0.10590285062789917,
-0.3901422619819641,
-0.6592931747436523,
-0.11361820250749588,
-0.5645607113838196,
-0.03674570098519325,
-0.4468092620372772,
-0.3854409456253052,
0.277743399143219,
-0.14754441380500793,
-0.0454321950674057,
0.2570204436779022,
-0.9471195936203003,
0.7733895778656006,
0.6104852557182312,
0.5823843479156494,
0.20309939980506897,
-0.27126938104629517,
0.021574312821030617,
0.4462258219718933,
-0.4689355194568634,
1.1131610870361328,
-0.6227908134460449,
-0.7356110215187073,
0.012977476231753826,
-0.4729471802711487,
0.05342266336083412,
-0.39909693598747253,
0.6981680393218994,
-0.2870386242866516,
-0.1485857367515564,
-0.48944735527038574,
-0.3649950325489044,
-0.3512357473373413,
0.15821371972560883,
-0.6684256792068481,
1.0008553266525269,
0.008213709108531475,
-0.107424795627594,
0.4627510905265808,
-1.161941409111023,
-0.316400945186615,
0.15222448110580444,
-0.072832390666008,
0.009395530447363853,
-0.02486276440322399,
0.3266775608062744,
0.39076703786849976,
-0.44114527106285095,
0.17978636920452118,
-0.10893385112285614,
-0.018320463597774506,
0.1172204241156578,
0.13130123913288116,
0.7185186743736267,
0.27953580021858215,
-0.31954190135002136,
0.1695302128791809,
-0.629564642906189,
0.5406184196472168,
0.48674964904785156,
-0.3169942796230316,
-0.5029096007347107,
0.47069835662841797,
0.4110938310623169,
0.5016974806785583,
0.1399850696325302,
-0.44544845819473267,
0.25511685013771057,
-0.15957224369049072,
0.20211327075958252,
0.6014422178268433,
0.004019275773316622,
0.7605499029159546,
-0.4544581174850464,
0.7181673645973206,
-0.4962940514087677,
0.17768807709217072,
0.2249990850687027,
-0.7250650525093079,
-0.6495627164840698,
-0.01516279298812151,
-0.15145613253116608,
0.55226731300354,
-0.5033664107322693,
0.30672746896743774,
-0.659518837928772,
-0.6063607931137085,
-0.010538523085415363,
-0.08608823269605637,
0.3487395644187927,
0.17591385543346405,
0.32944831252098083,
-0.11779090762138367,
-0.6368664503097534,
-0.7096261382102966,
-0.407913476228714,
-0.2459082156419754,
0.03977745771408081,
0.3504912257194519,
0.3502417504787445,
0.10650858283042908,
1.0170092582702637,
-0.7462781071662903,
-0.19628992676734924,
-0.5205104351043701,
-0.05246592313051224,
0.03586927428841591,
0.17480312287807465,
0.4669068157672882,
-0.8679118752479553,
-0.5271738767623901,
0.0035331842955201864,
-0.5434290170669556,
-0.28926146030426025,
-0.40182897448539734,
-0.4823566973209381,
-0.22676333785057068,
0.39626726508140564,
-0.46461743116378784,
0.48224085569381714,
0.5529356002807617,
-0.44397595524787903,
0.4756150543689728,
-0.42991751432418823,
-0.19144827127456665,
-0.7608547210693359,
0.003729891963303089,
-0.11377515643835068,
-0.3124596178531647,
-0.8477643728256226,
0.34126394987106323,
-0.21710902452468872,
-0.2728179693222046,
0.027829669415950775,
0.5450470447540283,
-0.7952861189842224,
-0.3863106369972229,
-0.397322416305542,
0.4230734705924988,
-0.3557944893836975,
0.57538241147995,
0.2738032639026642,
0.4869873523712158,
0.5374913811683655,
-0.671578586101532,
0.27829620242118835,
0.39411357045173645,
-0.48521697521209717,
0.37945857644081116,
-0.3809903562068939,
0.15719513595104218,
-0.06869957596063614,
0.5209694504737854,
-0.7838873863220215,
-0.0262894406914711,
-0.20245791971683502,
-0.1732151061296463,
-0.029486967250704765,
0.3539411425590515,
-0.45376497507095337,
-0.37380653619766235,
0.18719547986984253,
0.24642314016819,
0.7290022373199463,
-0.2039930820465088,
0.6463052034378052,
0.907319962978363,
-0.06480570137500763,
0.2635626196861267,
-0.623599648475647,
0.13864625990390778,
0.15601061284542084,
-0.6829265356063843,
0.5648864507675171,
0.05213015526533127,
-0.4909322261810303,
-0.08978357166051865,
0.23849689960479736,
0.028548384085297585,
0.003271596971899271,
0.6602107286453247,
0.1357925981283188,
0.1426606923341751,
0.06279373914003372,
-0.3511192798614502,
-0.34088537096977234,
0.21222659945487976,
-0.39809930324554443,
0.7434988617897034,
-0.005888954270631075,
-0.1993597149848938,
0.002748133847489953,
0.46648040413856506,
0.43360817432403564,
-0.23791615664958954,
0.4660819172859192,
0.21950529515743256,
-0.6282368898391724,
-0.33474886417388916,
-0.1445767879486084,
0.02336302027106285,
-0.4185502231121063,
0.4923686981201172,
-0.6675036549568176,
-0.30173906683921814,
0.47792166471481323,
-0.4055868685245514,
0.36540302634239197,
0.34393054246902466,
0.37027987837791443,
0.01175940502434969,
1.1495665311813354,
0.6975895762443542,
0.0788276344537735,
0.44123217463493347,
-0.522876501083374,
0.2405642420053482,
-1.0744484663009644,
-0.22177520394325256,
-0.5359331965446472,
-0.5587354302406311,
-0.5823220014572144,
-0.5331579446792603,
0.4700845777988434,
-0.1955060362815857,
-0.12217026948928833,
0.4041484296321869,
-0.6005260348320007,
0.4243451654911041,
0.6127759218215942,
-0.019593210890889168,
0.17107948660850525,
0.17688524723052979,
-0.6117978096008301,
-0.11815765500068665,
-1.0269073247909546,
-0.6140676736831665,
1.087306261062622,
-0.31623944640159607,
0.4680047333240509,
-0.09893695265054703,
0.4887779653072357,
-0.030090807005763054,
0.13547161221504211,
-0.4180798828601837,
1.0827903747558594,
0.14102990925312042,
-0.7207815647125244,
-0.7257463335990906,
-0.12616176903247833,
-1.2923991680145264,
0.3845544755458832,
-0.7566969990730286,
-0.9680947661399841,
-0.13723209500312805,
0.03965333476662636,
-0.09702825546264648,
0.25158485770225525,
-0.6444410085678101,
0.6439741849899292,
-0.08787404000759125,
0.03868226706981659,
-0.7055709958076477,
-0.36213570833206177,
0.05523788556456566,
0.06283353269100189,
0.35143086314201355,
-0.2548241913318634,
-0.16667503118515015,
0.5781370997428894,
-0.07365351170301437,
0.4903699457645416,
-0.32338160276412964,
0.3489093780517578,
0.5091962814331055,
0.230592280626297,
0.6179850697517395,
-0.3200174570083618,
-0.05245939642190933,
0.012283938005566597,
-0.3603228032588959,
-0.6756711006164551,
-0.4721625745296478,
0.7350652813911438,
-0.8546664118766785,
-0.5826648473739624,
-0.28255099058151245,
-0.9427401423454285,
-0.3546912670135498,
0.1371138095855713,
0.15893983840942383,
0.28958967328071594,
-0.7142824530601501,
-0.40925928950309753,
0.17578214406967163,
-0.2679997384548187,
0.6159114241600037,
0.33860504627227783,
-0.7780418395996094,
0.07880795001983643,
0.8209434151649475,
0.40791842341423035,
0.37922486662864685,
0.2877444326877594,
-0.04639038071036339,
-0.25326046347618103,
-0.645589292049408,
0.07422670722007751,
-0.02612958289682865,
-0.6767154335975647,
0.21241113543510437,
-0.6417822241783142,
-0.3350461721420288,
-0.35055580735206604,
-0.3456757068634033,
-0.21579976379871368,
-0.5686992406845093,
0.27164968848228455,
-0.07286068797111511,
0.10297257453203201,
0.9189558029174805,
-0.276506245136261,
0.16977505385875702,
-0.3047255575656891,
0.3570191562175751,
0.47351330518722534,
-0.15281814336776733,
-0.007768912240862846,
0.1706254929304123,
-0.14164456725120544,
0.2682136297225952,
-0.5431684851646423,
-0.7004474997520447,
0.40504926443099976,
0.40846022963523865,
0.6458159685134888,
0.1728380173444748,
0.04891737177968025,
0.8785284161567688,
-0.597778856754303,
0.6545149683952332,
-0.045436255633831024,
-0.771611213684082,
0.7102149724960327,
-0.39849525690078735,
1.006296992301941,
0.19543811678886414,
0.16350868344306946,
-0.7748904228210449,
-0.5744263529777527,
-0.8506964445114136,
-0.9074556827545166,
0.42335060238838196,
0.4384642243385315,
-0.11419342458248138,
-0.007495769299566746,
0.3294050991535187,
-0.2042810320854187,
-0.29047736525535583,
-0.35085049271583557,
0.1297677904367447,
0.05066980794072151,
0.14948269724845886,
-0.45121923089027405,
-0.062342699617147446,
-0.19025838375091553,
-0.3969109058380127,
0.630042552947998,
-0.2339395135641098,
0.6692376136779785,
0.06438414007425308,
-0.10469502955675125,
-0.15831084549427032,
-0.04969121515750885,
0.7337836623191833,
0.8876657485961914,
0.13114650547504425,
0.23144811391830444,
0.3702565133571625,
-0.580194354057312,
0.12964127957820892,
-0.23637515306472778,
-0.1426185816526413,
-0.22996506094932556,
0.5356741547584534,
0.5966680645942688,
0.24616684019565582,
-0.6552584767341614,
0.10350321233272552,
-0.07876978069543839,
-0.06741611659526825,
-0.4346449375152588,
0.44053134322166443,
0.4348698854446411,
0.2070758193731308,
0.1711999475955963,
0.17006142437458038,
0.13209405541419983,
-0.35144034028053284,
-0.05347219482064247,
0.4673181474208832,
-0.103941909968853,
-0.36931508779525757,
0.4667608141899109,
0.0248902328312397,
-0.6296609044075012,
0.9292540550231934,
-0.16856805980205536,
-0.6298987865447998,
0.6708686351776123,
0.8770074844360352,
0.7223222851753235,
-0.22888220846652985,
0.32955819368362427,
0.519015908241272,
0.4190235435962677,
0.03425850719213486,
0.6049878001213074,
-0.06325361132621765,
-0.8843058943748474,
-0.1916338950395584,
-0.44997507333755493,
-0.10161253064870834,
-0.38279634714126587,
-0.5881738662719727,
0.16452519595623016,
-0.42496418952941895,
-0.5578914284706116,
-0.11404760926961899,
0.03041161224246025,
-1.0319106578826904,
0.38310855627059937,
0.22169378399848938,
0.7796544432640076,
-0.6726149916648865,
0.8671649098396301,
0.8074513673782349,
0.1217074766755104,
-0.6243802309036255,
-0.16342757642269135,
-0.07994206994771957,
-0.9772384762763977,
0.5148053765296936,
-0.2630540728569031,
-0.2106209248304367,
0.03990372642874718,
-0.44298607110977173,
-1.0962426662445068,
1.1839663982391357,
0.29381951689720154,
-0.578953742980957,
0.018006660044193268,
0.21783402562141418,
0.6043901443481445,
-0.604192852973938,
0.1321125030517578,
0.43805694580078125,
0.5877376198768616,
-0.2212231606245041,
-0.7398165464401245,
0.30115166306495667,
-0.13558755815029144,
0.5380114316940308,
0.40201202034950256,
-0.4467160403728485,
0.49172917008399963,
-0.35409748554229736,
-0.5049943923950195,
-0.12310223281383514,
0.6503171324729919,
0.16737830638885498,
0.04974198341369629,
0.8419934511184692,
0.5992165803909302,
0.8262595534324646,
-0.02879931405186653,
1.3451523780822754,
-0.5160924792289734,
0.17230601608753204,
1.0821232795715332,
-0.17201440036296844,
0.9812055826187134,
0.3525051772594452,
-0.16539709270000458,
0.5984845161437988,
0.605094313621521,
0.48068955540657043,
0.6880666613578796,
0.37445858120918274,
-0.15889191627502441,
-0.48408380150794983,
-0.2102798968553543,
0.04806610569357872,
0.6593772768974304,
0.6150255799293518,
0.04243945702910423,
-0.27822965383529663,
0.0055926162749528885,
-0.04977533221244812,
0.3744352161884308,
-0.19064603745937347,
0.6638880968093872,
-0.09121991693973541,
-1.013789415359497,
0.4692917764186859,
-0.15484455227851868,
0.007100978866219521,
-0.596574604511261,
-0.016744978725910187,
0.16746245324611664,
-0.04869529977440834,
0.054785821586847305,
-0.6285228729248047,
0.34433192014694214,
-0.28285372257232666,
-0.09509125351905823,
-0.5451762080192566,
0.8076241612434387,
-0.4094896614551544,
-0.31190648674964905,
0.4851815104484558,
0.4406062960624695,
0.09040460735559464,
-0.13967609405517578,
-0.7723394632339478,
-0.23286253213882446,
-0.11875694245100021,
-0.3256072700023651,
0.2520888149738312,
0.22561530768871307,
-0.4277823567390442,
0.8977767825126648,
0.8980101943016052,
0.31533879041671753,
0.22925682365894318,
-0.24101345241069794,
0.5619538426399231,
-0.783814549446106,
-0.7964727878570557,
-0.5447959899902344,
0.25224483013153076,
-0.5166983604431152,
-0.45876452326774597,
0.5298172831535339,
0.48069441318511963,
0.6315235495567322,
0.059727802872657776,
0.889457643032074,
-0.023702098056674004,
-0.028767259791493416,
-0.4647667407989502,
0.5353675484657288,
-0.18426014482975006,
0.0024993433617055416,
-0.033765118569135666,
-1.336557149887085,
-0.29288309812545776,
0.7890749573707581,
-0.6327050924301147,
0.06154919043183327,
0.9132282137870789,
0.8083345890045166,
0.0111455749720335,
0.18888500332832336,
0.5662984848022461,
0.11778543889522552,
0.36340656876564026,
1.10476553440094,
0.6805761456489563,
0.03244830295443535,
0.24462220072746277,
-0.22652576863765717,
-0.426437109708786,
-0.03177613019943237,
-0.637945294380188,
-0.759122908115387,
-0.9520837068557739,
-0.05833851173520088,
-0.13341723382472992,
-0.007745704147964716,
0.8800285458564758,
1.0058331489562988,
-0.36209091544151306,
-0.6452486515045166,
-0.3867124319076538,
0.029344599694013596,
-0.5049721598625183,
-0.15224608778953552,
0.00968805979937315,
-0.3659125864505768,
-0.5944780111312866,
0.3114190697669983,
0.4288922846317291,
0.027298877015709877,
-0.43823325634002686,
-0.31896117329597473,
-0.3958832025527954,
0.259731262922287,
0.4297080636024475,
0.21763703227043152,
-0.639738917350769,
-0.23122966289520264,
-0.09015727788209915,
-0.3190193474292755,
-0.27605244517326355,
1.0567748546600342,
-0.6438020467758179,
0.8574060201644897,
0.4108881950378418,
0.15577803552150726,
1.0282529592514038,
-0.4342362582683563,
0.9448644518852234,
-0.37578460574150085,
0.42543840408325195,
0.23149435222148895,
0.26817187666893005,
0.2619529366493225,
-0.3519749641418457,
0.7396001815795898,
-0.17588090896606445,
-0.8084099292755127,
-0.20482230186462402,
0.43426018953323364,
-1.0337499380111694,
-0.2891177237033844,
1.1721611022949219,
-0.06870101392269135,
-0.4851400554180145,
-0.24580030143260956,
-0.42751002311706543,
0.14350087940692902,
-0.2721896171569824,
0.8389073014259338,
0.829687237739563,
-0.47350209951400757,
0.29926759004592896,
-0.8679090738296509,
0.5613718032836914,
0.259147971868515,
-0.822660505771637,
-0.031477779150009155,
0.34028416872024536,
-0.10686663538217545,
0.2868369221687317,
0.9095237851142883,
0.28619295358657837,
0.11714701354503632,
0.3080112040042877,
0.23123124241828918,
0.2234799563884735,
-0.29726266860961914,
0.16191279888153076,
0.24626940488815308,
0.2038223147392273,
-0.08907508105039597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15267v1 | Evaluating Diversity in Automatic Poetry Generation | 2024-06-21T16:03:21 | 2024-06-21T16:03:21 | Yanran Chen, Hannes Gröner, Sina Zarrieß, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Natural Language Generation (NLG), and more generally generative AI, are
among the currently most impactful research fields. Creative NLG, such as
automatic poetry generation, is a fascinating niche in this area. While most
previous research has focused on forms of the Turing test when evaluating
automatic poetry generation - can humans distinguish between automatic and
human generated poetry - we evaluate the diversity of automatically generated
poetry, by comparing distributions of generated poetry to distributions of
human poetry along structural, lexical, semantic and stylistic dimensions,
assessing different model types (word vs. character-level, general purpose LLMs
vs. poetry-specific models), including the very recent LLaMA3, and types of
fine-tuning (conditioned vs. unconditioned). We find that current automatic
poetry systems are considerably underdiverse along multiple dimensions - they
often do not rhyme sufficiently, are semantically too uniform and even do not
match the length distribution of human poetry. Our experiments reveal, however,
that style-conditioning and character-level modeling clearly increases
diversity across virtually all dimensions we explore. Our identified
limitations may serve as the basis for more genuinely diverse future poetry
generation models. | [
-0.5616077780723572,
-0.5656728148460388,
0.2817211151123047,
0.6349987983703613,
-0.348500519990921,
0.23899969458580017,
-0.3672321140766144,
-0.8750254511833191,
0.08640894293785095,
0.29605644941329956,
-0.57745361328125,
-0.5267345309257507,
-0.6792356967926025,
0.6451412439346313,
-0.6245039701461792,
1.0445497035980225,
0.1113806888461113,
-0.17977043986320496,
-0.18986591696739197,
-0.1853373497724533,
-0.5495052337646484,
-0.1507568359375,
-0.6370781064033508,
-0.38588693737983704,
0.3036283850669861,
0.10706853121519089,
0.6039487719535828,
0.2604805827140808,
0.49180078506469727,
0.3951733708381653,
-0.09481722116470337,
0.15963253378868103,
-0.3470144271850586,
0.3435688018798828,
0.15447014570236206,
-0.39926397800445557,
-0.17734354734420776,
0.27761808037757874,
0.8279234766960144,
0.7435404658317566,
0.043294668197631836,
0.13654451072216034,
-0.09048324078321457,
0.7349610924720764,
-0.4141627550125122,
-0.27888262271881104,
-0.8281960487365723,
0.44481608271598816,
-0.39274200797080994,
-0.01676465943455696,
-0.2272806316614151,
-0.5688214898109436,
0.14640013873577118,
-0.459890216588974,
0.5214807987213135,
0.20592887699604034,
0.5628499388694763,
0.430439829826355,
-0.3867459297180176,
-0.4236111044883728,
-0.8793273568153381,
0.7493630051612854,
-0.5173226594924927,
0.18358753621578217,
0.20842193067073822,
0.318215012550354,
-0.08911687135696411,
-0.6375709772109985,
-0.7021751999855042,
-0.4883814752101898,
0.1973711997270584,
0.33426138758659363,
-0.558128297328949,
-0.07500782608985901,
0.31489261984825134,
0.7658294439315796,
-0.8738524913787842,
0.23104709386825562,
-0.25515562295913696,
0.05912613868713379,
0.9833045601844788,
0.33528074622154236,
0.7249072194099426,
-0.31514596939086914,
-0.13648828864097595,
-0.08026128262281418,
-0.2306366264820099,
0.08667275309562683,
0.9617970585823059,
0.03852441534399986,
-0.10908926278352737,
0.6244527697563171,
-0.13826310634613037,
0.8484228253364563,
-0.1272042691707611,
0.03802386298775673,
0.3376341164112091,
-0.4519904553890228,
-0.17888127267360687,
-0.19642767310142517,
0.9859479069709778,
0.2830328941345215,
0.23131874203681946,
-0.24089489877223969,
-0.2386067509651184,
0.29964664578437805,
0.511177659034729,
-0.3575245141983032,
-0.33500102162361145,
0.04273645579814911,
-0.5068662762641907,
-0.46421048045158386,
-0.007723643444478512,
-0.5598022937774658,
-0.4459933936595917,
-0.08749043941497803,
0.2856435775756836,
-0.45077723264694214,
-0.045968424528837204,
0.12943993508815765,
-0.775719940662384,
0.08033836632966995,
0.06863166391849518,
-0.8452539443969727,
0.060690246522426605,
0.5923206806182861,
0.6327343583106995,
-0.44451871514320374,
-0.5040967464447021,
-0.11934483796358109,
-0.4669581353664398,
-0.38800185918807983,
0.9395791888237,
-0.4972679316997528,
-0.3106212615966797,
-0.29923006892204285,
-0.3837377429008484,
0.018123144283890724,
-0.6978336572647095,
0.6628602743148804,
-0.24199119210243225,
0.24671633541584015,
-0.12476872652769089,
-0.40354880690574646,
0.04847582429647446,
0.08962973952293396,
-0.7831326127052307,
0.8521310687065125,
0.34920716285705566,
-0.7702507972717285,
0.695472002029419,
-0.5613451600074768,
-0.31846511363983154,
0.31048548221588135,
-0.2947414219379425,
-0.4821202754974365,
0.27499881386756897,
0.013553474098443985,
0.22555828094482422,
-0.5378192067146301,
0.05873158574104309,
-0.353493332862854,
-0.3218284249305725,
0.4207906723022461,
-0.5859670042991638,
0.9215392470359802,
0.4900516867637634,
-0.367775022983551,
0.06827913969755173,
-1.0665768384933472,
0.012297051027417183,
0.24064746499061584,
-0.4422791600227356,
-0.08885294198989868,
-0.014317418448626995,
0.1364615559577942,
0.00040218388312496245,
-0.15653735399246216,
-0.6378632187843323,
0.07930564135313034,
-0.5761315822601318,
0.38039812445640564,
0.38205668330192566,
-0.019606418907642365,
0.4085008203983307,
-0.7302164435386658,
0.8346897959709167,
-0.27466821670532227,
0.06605296581983566,
0.16268737614154816,
-0.9023474454879761,
-0.5185081958770752,
-0.2722473442554474,
0.19845257699489594,
0.3728151321411133,
-0.3892064094543457,
0.799148440361023,
-0.012452688068151474,
-0.5976248979568481,
-0.6986795663833618,
0.3187985420227051,
0.05184917151927948,
0.17050951719284058,
0.1341368556022644,
-0.6398653984069824,
-0.5033584833145142,
-0.7307250499725342,
-0.4542446434497833,
-0.2092859447002411,
-0.18036644160747528,
0.24757340550422668,
0.2685245871543884,
-0.41270849108695984,
0.9329844117164612,
-0.13105133175849915,
0.12455521523952484,
-0.5572670698165894,
0.5103742480278015,
-0.07788044959306717,
0.376628577709198,
0.8221513032913208,
-0.39236319065093994,
-0.5028376579284668,
-0.2249889075756073,
-0.5284295082092285,
-0.5038283467292786,
-0.16280809044837952,
-0.09963364899158478,
0.11682529002428055,
-0.03041626699268818,
-0.6297624707221985,
0.5049371123313904,
0.6653380393981934,
-0.28497838973999023,
0.561918318271637,
-0.01962657831609249,
-0.01827048882842064,
-0.5641245245933533,
-0.1689537912607193,
-0.11883047968149185,
0.08815115690231323,
-0.6254942417144775,
0.12317638844251633,
-0.22209444642066956,
-0.22061873972415924,
-0.019199000671505928,
0.3683074414730072,
-0.3183852434158325,
-0.2010396122932434,
-0.5223966240882874,
-0.037545572966337204,
0.1666559875011444,
-0.020934633910655975,
-0.23816242814064026,
0.3986850380897522,
0.5252853035926819,
-0.2750580608844757,
0.5710155963897705,
-0.07445945590734482,
-0.4434875249862671,
0.5113444328308105,
-0.6200475692749023,
0.10643752664327621,
-0.250996857881546,
0.4852544963359833,
-0.9630032181739807,
-0.2658981680870056,
0.03179319202899933,
-0.41380056738853455,
0.07739411294460297,
0.17842745780944824,
-0.5566737651824951,
-0.6133944392204285,
-0.2940747141838074,
0.6906872987747192,
0.8101654052734375,
-0.39879584312438965,
0.46254080533981323,
0.05314071476459503,
0.11467627435922623,
-0.32154688239097595,
-0.6704909205436707,
0.15652309358119965,
-0.4737211763858795,
-0.8262870907783508,
0.1543513536453247,
-0.37619587779045105,
-0.6107380390167236,
-0.07420913875102997,
0.055641110986471176,
0.20141556859016418,
0.4126838445663452,
0.20666548609733582,
-0.20882727205753326,
-0.18813498318195343,
0.1132778525352478,
0.09820663183927536,
0.20536468923091888,
0.055024296045303345,
-0.4756247401237488,
0.6698402762413025,
-0.14550179243087769,
-0.6451218724250793,
-0.22639688849449158,
0.4585774540901184,
0.3108098804950714,
-0.3141472339630127,
0.4588853716850281,
0.9784348607063293,
-0.2660067081451416,
-0.657060444355011,
-0.45274731516838074,
0.29915374517440796,
-0.45976778864860535,
0.10944180935621262,
-0.007040704600512981,
-0.7924136519432068,
0.5280899405479431,
0.38654083013534546,
0.12725259363651276,
0.745058536529541,
0.6407167315483093,
-0.299577534198761,
0.6114290952682495,
0.652208149433136,
0.1944892406463623,
0.2931799590587616,
-0.26432305574417114,
0.15959234535694122,
-0.7023734450340271,
0.05682946369051933,
-0.5782252550125122,
-0.6254538893699646,
-0.8742435574531555,
-0.18255549669265747,
0.2203308641910553,
0.18197917938232422,
-0.13697998225688934,
0.07989996671676636,
-0.709516167640686,
0.4332454800605774,
0.6523562669754028,
-0.26211538910865784,
0.17095313966274261,
-0.1629652976989746,
-0.058328598737716675,
0.16237974166870117,
-0.5044821500778198,
-0.377559095621109,
1.4030174016952515,
0.34303489327430725,
0.5321486592292786,
0.15502597391605377,
1.0525577068328857,
0.38583773374557495,
0.26620301604270935,
-0.7930086255073547,
0.30242374539375305,
-0.6478344202041626,
-0.314008504152298,
-0.41932153701782227,
-0.43686893582344055,
-1.2756242752075195,
0.13692395389080048,
-0.44957610964775085,
-0.5508217811584473,
-0.047973956912755966,
0.011853725649416447,
-0.47274813055992126,
0.3527880907058716,
-0.5609192252159119,
0.5603914856910706,
-0.19521337747573853,
0.3238673508167267,
0.11029614508152008,
-0.40160560607910156,
0.5950738191604614,
-0.25337937474250793,
0.028690192848443985,
-0.2632676362991333,
0.17667481303215027,
0.6591951251029968,
-0.2312508374452591,
0.6922817230224609,
0.23110826313495636,
-0.26968783140182495,
0.4870777130126953,
0.0469178631901741,
0.06559345871210098,
0.040394194424152374,
-0.1700228452682495,
0.08562496304512024,
-0.4408961534500122,
-0.23905105888843536,
-0.6007464528083801,
0.6529770493507385,
-1.117667317390442,
-0.47518306970596313,
-0.2305639237165451,
-0.7918386459350586,
-0.15048187971115112,
-0.05527564138174057,
0.6212629675865173,
0.18096299469470978,
-0.23485678434371948,
0.27074891328811646,
0.33332616090774536,
-0.5146987438201904,
0.4697047770023346,
0.10324442386627197,
-0.14606232941150665,
-0.5569195747375488,
0.7953181266784668,
0.13991202414035797,
0.39438021183013916,
0.062044426798820496,
0.5133985877037048,
-0.26798632740974426,
-0.7730519771575928,
-0.44568586349487305,
-0.03305203840136528,
-0.7894055247306824,
0.12485915422439575,
-0.7141181230545044,
-0.37383100390434265,
-0.4870589077472687,
-0.14939455687999725,
-0.046798110008239746,
-0.5851724743843079,
-0.4561411738395691,
0.056991301476955414,
0.4348423182964325,
1.0532296895980835,
-0.05410335212945938,
0.25538918375968933,
-0.6790436506271362,
0.5127316117286682,
0.6033532023429871,
0.38519424200057983,
-0.01132802851498127,
-0.6333754658699036,
0.2459351122379303,
-0.4360891282558441,
-0.5115671157836914,
-0.9684531092643738,
0.20711317658424377,
0.30820322036743164,
0.6758300065994263,
0.18667440116405487,
-0.09800031781196594,
0.38220179080963135,
-0.5394983291625977,
1.0927687883377075,
0.27385222911834717,
-0.7422046065330505,
0.5085409283638,
-0.4376281499862671,
0.4612569808959961,
0.412265419960022,
0.18455389142036438,
-0.5673097372055054,
-0.8018635511398315,
-0.8375421762466431,
-0.9206880331039429,
0.3395112454891205,
0.5229731798171997,
0.3226148188114166,
-0.1427387148141861,
0.36052894592285156,
0.3991950750350952,
0.1802019327878952,
-0.9738559126853943,
-0.27554741501808167,
-0.5837658643722534,
-0.3714424669742584,
-0.19992458820343018,
0.06529468297958374,
-0.166911780834198,
-0.16776308417320251,
0.1400838941335678,
0.04064265266060829,
0.19670578837394714,
-0.0017455811612308025,
0.09954020380973816,
-0.3745405375957489,
0.33650708198547363,
0.6801144480705261,
0.37943965196609497,
0.07173886150121689,
0.30951008200645447,
0.23056042194366455,
-0.39975211024284363,
0.2583153545856476,
0.027710232883691788,
-0.29922235012054443,
-0.08333303034305573,
0.6083807349205017,
1.1024943590164185,
-0.3534449636936188,
-0.5024337768554688,
0.22365325689315796,
-0.1779794842004776,
-0.29987430572509766,
-0.40601110458374023,
0.6756934523582458,
0.060408562421798706,
0.2740148901939392,
0.1453060805797577,
0.2734135091304779,
0.2098894864320755,
-0.5946680307388306,
0.11640791594982147,
0.6232816576957703,
-0.018750017508864403,
-0.19634690880775452,
0.5947895646095276,
0.10052697360515594,
-0.6858686208724976,
0.48860809206962585,
-0.5330740809440613,
-0.2877436876296997,
0.8482784628868103,
0.7094478011131287,
1.3718713521957397,
0.32198992371559143,
0.1225314810872078,
0.21237294375896454,
0.5502223968505859,
0.04967787116765976,
0.30972450971603394,
-0.17968104779720306,
-0.6985040307044983,
-0.10092132538557053,
-1.0179810523986816,
-0.15000995993614197,
0.1951327919960022,
-0.29070743918418884,
0.014523010700941086,
-0.5035879611968994,
-0.33767449855804443,
0.0012538882438093424,
0.004951033275574446,
-0.7558332085609436,
0.22158388793468475,
0.4916260540485382,
0.6529583930969238,
-0.8769502639770508,
0.4831700921058655,
0.5255056619644165,
-0.24030999839305878,
-0.6313076615333557,
0.33979684114456177,
-0.02002613991498947,
-0.5618830919265747,
0.8658828139305115,
0.10104420781135559,
-0.1390771120786667,
0.022658392786979675,
-0.38420602679252625,
-0.8339581489562988,
1.0208557844161987,
0.09499812126159668,
-0.22503609955310822,
0.25365546345710754,
0.3130522668361664,
0.9950132369995117,
-0.33030688762664795,
0.34579235315322876,
0.5626448392868042,
0.3567710220813751,
-0.03362937271595001,
-0.9519451856613159,
-0.3224136233329773,
-0.5271030068397522,
0.46966710686683655,
0.027620362117886543,
-0.607631504535675,
0.9921292662620544,
0.16399845480918884,
-0.3485933542251587,
0.2633003294467926,
0.6785888671875,
0.5765340328216553,
0.17171365022659302,
0.612157940864563,
0.9408863186836243,
0.7352649569511414,
-0.002205188386142254,
1.1071739196777344,
-0.13251493871212006,
0.02288544364273548,
0.704823911190033,
-0.2981720268726349,
0.4640408456325531,
-0.008756681345403194,
-0.23894533514976501,
0.5030407309532166,
0.49414822459220886,
-0.2558753192424774,
0.14689743518829346,
0.6967759132385254,
-0.3518814742565155,
-0.1579580157995224,
0.07018934190273285,
-0.25810059905052185,
0.6304221153259277,
0.021550437435507774,
-0.33694353699684143,
-0.14220808446407318,
-0.012845379300415516,
-0.6114190220832825,
0.19309480488300323,
-0.12266010046005249,
0.7301516532897949,
0.01826535165309906,
-0.7629181742668152,
0.5618051886558533,
0.15216213464736938,
0.8423452973365784,
-0.36315298080444336,
0.18144585192203522,
-0.20630958676338196,
-0.3923601508140564,
-0.2741187810897827,
-0.9030860662460327,
0.44047707319259644,
0.40121546387672424,
-0.079625204205513,
-0.1720782220363617,
0.718951404094696,
-0.21290317177772522,
-0.5400610566139221,
0.22934719920158386,
0.27984049916267395,
0.171312153339386,
0.23322793841362,
-0.6295826435089111,
0.11702468991279602,
-0.1869240701198578,
-0.09861821681261063,
0.15596041083335876,
0.6270371079444885,
-0.04833836853504181,
0.5814085006713867,
0.6264057755470276,
0.3776523470878601,
0.5052394270896912,
0.464914470911026,
0.40248343348503113,
-0.5585750937461853,
-0.45433396100997925,
-0.7541187405586243,
0.4841850697994232,
0.04866205155849457,
-0.4842723309993744,
0.7160849571228027,
0.1519569754600525,
0.8364555239677429,
-0.014464025385677814,
0.9698512554168701,
0.005545486230403185,
0.15958763659000397,
-0.3835597038269043,
0.7996740341186523,
-0.590301513671875,
0.15166357159614563,
-0.35562664270401,
-0.944268524646759,
-0.3363477885723114,
0.43079790472984314,
-0.2196119725704193,
0.26969683170318604,
0.5696930885314941,
0.29640814661979675,
0.026359958574175835,
0.2192845195531845,
0.25271865725517273,
-0.22372399270534515,
0.3080585300922394,
0.3510095775127411,
1.3483606576919556,
-0.21880775690078735,
0.3315380811691284,
-0.34318169951438904,
-0.2001292109489441,
0.09694217145442963,
-0.932564377784729,
-0.900829017162323,
-0.40071767568588257,
-0.2215583622455597,
-0.001432243618182838,
-0.4081323444843292,
1.0353633165359497,
0.2930494248867035,
-0.5404707193374634,
-0.2786748707294464,
-0.317471981048584,
-0.06607218831777573,
-0.01460625883191824,
-0.18949629366397858,
-0.10087114572525024,
-0.5262961983680725,
-0.5487875938415527,
0.35922038555145264,
0.4070229232311249,
0.2885763347148895,
-0.545020580291748,
-0.05804100260138512,
0.281619131565094,
0.2225649356842041,
0.6054450273513794,
0.04821411520242691,
-0.9363069534301758,
-0.11893436312675476,
-0.0938263013958931,
-0.1665945202112198,
0.05868157744407654,
0.687425434589386,
-0.37588590383529663,
0.4345531165599823,
0.8470656275749207,
0.6484426856040955,
-0.00804863404482603,
0.019720422104001045,
0.37936410307884216,
-0.8613982796669006,
-0.06550256162881851,
0.5392933487892151,
0.3322495222091675,
0.24360015988349915,
-0.2704143822193146,
0.1909996122121811,
0.5443121790885925,
-0.6358667016029358,
-0.6825357675552368,
0.5733171105384827,
-0.900293231010437,
-0.22388949990272522,
1.0938977003097534,
0.08000995963811874,
0.1446845829486847,
-0.10627548396587372,
0.07087202370166779,
0.3402584195137024,
0.022887784987688065,
0.9222115278244019,
0.7324602007865906,
-0.46451741456985474,
-0.10588887333869934,
-0.58228600025177,
0.6387264132499695,
0.4673434793949127,
-0.9364631772041321,
-0.2768104374408722,
0.5387202501296997,
0.15174920856952667,
0.24900442361831665,
0.661788821220398,
0.03456738963723183,
0.38364753127098083,
-0.03315800055861473,
0.24979421496391296,
0.2728174328804016,
-0.40223947167396545,
-0.6041179895401001,
0.2487594187259674,
0.42186403274536133,
0.17990027368068695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15265v1 | Perception of Phonological Assimilation by Neural Speech Recognition Models | 2024-06-21T15:58:22 | 2024-06-21T15:58:22 | Charlotte Pouw, Marianne de Heer Kloots, Afra Alishahi, Willem Zuidema | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human listeners effortlessly compensate for phonological changes during
speech perception, often unconsciously inferring the intended sounds. For
example, listeners infer the underlying /n/ when hearing an utterance such as
"clea[m] pan", where [m] arises from place assimilation to the following labial
[p]. This article explores how the neural speech recognition model Wav2Vec2
perceives assimilated sounds, and identifies the linguistic knowledge that is
implemented by the model to compensate for assimilation during Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR). Using psycholinguistic stimuli, we systematically analyze
how various linguistic context cues influence compensation patterns in the
model's output. Complementing these behavioral experiments, our probing
experiments indicate that the model shifts its interpretation of assimilated
sounds from their acoustic form to their underlying form in its final layers.
Finally, our causal intervention experiments suggest that the model relies on
minimal phonological context cues to accomplish this shift. These findings
represent a step towards better understanding the similarities and differences
in phonological processing between neural ASR models and humans. | [
-0.252385675907135,
-0.30809035897254944,
0.5280781388282776,
0.14812536537647247,
-0.15268169343471527,
-0.45061105489730835,
-0.2558535933494568,
-0.7697079181671143,
-0.10218527168035507,
0.4264300763607025,
-0.5353430509567261,
0.030025208368897438,
-0.5773751735687256,
-0.021322987973690033,
-0.3622003495693207,
0.6127526760101318,
0.37838420271873474,
0.32814010977745056,
-0.06650786846876144,
-0.14864017069339752,
-0.6322953701019287,
-0.4166148006916046,
-0.7574636340141296,
-0.9653820991516113,
0.3420788049697876,
0.14786987006664276,
0.49550488591194153,
0.5551350712776184,
0.15213187038898468,
0.2779586613178253,
-0.21886099874973297,
-0.22575168311595917,
-0.10259641706943512,
-0.11223369836807251,
-0.02327602170407772,
-0.6171460747718811,
-0.11297411471605301,
-0.05931428074836731,
0.7323428392410278,
0.9000223875045776,
-0.39342355728149414,
0.11879296600818634,
0.35278987884521484,
0.6148204207420349,
-0.5108039975166321,
0.025136109441518784,
-0.6705824136734009,
0.1228477954864502,
-0.1717763990163803,
-0.332195907831192,
-0.6820878386497498,
0.008113379590213299,
0.38343679904937744,
-0.6021435260772705,
0.21755065023899078,
-0.27091965079307556,
0.33387237787246704,
0.5185593962669373,
-0.543488621711731,
-0.2978443205356598,
-0.8674231767654419,
0.525392472743988,
-0.6071686744689941,
0.7260631918907166,
0.568213701248169,
0.12844718992710114,
-0.20819637179374695,
-0.4778299331665039,
-0.7489403486251831,
-0.051405396312475204,
-0.35904577374458313,
0.09860015660524368,
-0.2525239586830139,
0.1369132697582245,
0.07968932390213013,
0.12121600657701492,
-0.7173165678977966,
0.21347656846046448,
-0.7308100461959839,
-0.4741766154766083,
0.5602432489395142,
-0.07374680042266846,
0.41043511033058167,
-0.12235362082719803,
-0.1926029473543167,
-0.10956119745969772,
-0.32409796118736267,
0.31267258524894714,
0.42523160576820374,
0.27349066734313965,
-0.3440098762512207,
0.39404168725013733,
0.058708496391773224,
0.9551559090614319,
0.005633585155010223,
0.01714295893907547,
0.25553056597709656,
0.03968893364071846,
-0.2698647081851959,
0.7219889163970947,
0.3877403438091278,
0.2779822051525116,
0.2826898694038391,
-0.1808360517024994,
-0.3378182053565979,
0.4226624369621277,
0.18082067370414734,
-0.3164387345314026,
-0.39573878049850464,
0.09430711716413498,
-0.4641488194465637,
-0.21176211535930634,
0.08595658093690872,
-0.3454603850841522,
-0.7092245221138,
-0.6899875998497009,
0.5988239645957947,
-0.4417980909347534,
-0.3762008249759674,
0.16123878955841064,
-0.369685560464859,
0.42666372656822205,
0.14728114008903503,
-0.9952970147132874,
0.46369627118110657,
0.5586261749267578,
0.772470235824585,
0.007403731346130371,
-0.3470279276371002,
-0.5809181332588196,
-0.03323521092534065,
-0.23015189170837402,
0.9634602665901184,
-0.4775281548500061,
-0.5111799836158752,
-0.15943457186222076,
-0.07221904397010803,
0.030229458585381508,
-0.8100496530532837,
0.21855846047401428,
-0.4581088125705719,
-0.14897212386131287,
-0.4394923448562622,
-0.2669038474559784,
-0.3123665750026703,
-0.3284837305545807,
-0.4720383584499359,
0.5506924986839294,
-0.013573801144957542,
-0.24240358173847198,
0.570830762386322,
-0.6406694650650024,
-0.454537034034729,
-0.05731852352619171,
0.11609276384115219,
0.06144600361585617,
0.42754578590393066,
-0.11678343266248703,
-0.01749023236334324,
0.0682259202003479,
-0.03384879603981972,
0.129507914185524,
-0.30156242847442627,
0.8144675493240356,
-0.3599850535392761,
0.8547992706298828,
0.2688141465187073,
-0.2403826117515564,
0.023791639134287834,
-0.829668402671814,
-0.2162255346775055,
0.08132299780845642,
-0.37804266810417175,
-0.5298426747322083,
0.13896650075912476,
0.10542981326580048,
0.12281861901283264,
0.11754230409860611,
-0.6771729588508606,
-0.12166129052639008,
-0.8773850798606873,
0.7194728255271912,
0.5541526675224304,
0.2985619008541107,
0.8628548979759216,
-0.12904956936836243,
0.09907408058643341,
0.2640637159347534,
-0.08930870145559311,
0.16506391763687134,
-0.5565323829650879,
-0.5901183485984802,
0.3316646218299866,
0.1638776808977127,
0.3711053431034088,
0.0009498896542936563,
0.046536676585674286,
-0.04169326275587082,
-0.22818197309970856,
-0.7250465154647827,
0.017741436138749123,
0.31738781929016113,
0.7031394243240356,
0.47666025161743164,
-0.2691679894924164,
-0.8981418013572693,
-0.8512505888938904,
-0.27157533168792725,
-0.23102214932441711,
-0.3280106484889984,
0.033816490322351456,
0.110654816031456,
-0.17767037451267242,
0.7843452095985413,
-0.31494924426078796,
-0.45047101378440857,
0.1759253889322281,
0.3936932682991028,
-0.1515679508447647,
0.5537972450256348,
0.2905127704143524,
-0.8462454676628113,
-0.2204408198595047,
-0.025042537599802017,
-0.42488422989845276,
-0.3051881194114685,
0.006884511560201645,
0.10653945803642273,
0.1407913863658905,
0.6260936260223389,
-0.22419136762619019,
0.40402305126190186,
0.6591964364051819,
-0.3839971423149109,
0.4193277657032013,
-0.08844311535358429,
-0.1403370052576065,
-0.7298555970191956,
0.11956179141998291,
0.026880737394094467,
-0.11601051688194275,
-0.8240633606910706,
-0.34652671217918396,
-0.0996137261390686,
-0.078740693628788,
-0.29065048694610596,
0.7148923277854919,
-0.5281822085380554,
-0.583346426486969,
-0.49207961559295654,
0.2972976565361023,
0.05636952817440033,
0.42861905694007874,
0.2814375162124634,
0.6835587620735168,
0.3581027388572693,
-0.9220564961433411,
0.0886257216334343,
0.2681210935115814,
-0.17367525398731232,
0.492498517036438,
-0.6693115830421448,
0.2557065188884735,
-0.35392656922340393,
0.3169165253639221,
-1.3032680749893188,
-0.11485293507575989,
0.21479976177215576,
-0.9015315175056458,
0.19195446372032166,
-0.18308961391448975,
0.016843345016241074,
-0.0972520038485527,
0.4093937575817108,
0.6112672686576843,
0.6575961709022522,
-0.48031291365623474,
0.5460024476051331,
0.5407542586326599,
0.03084084950387478,
-0.24858315289020538,
-1.1481540203094482,
-0.17640350759029388,
-0.14679451286792755,
-0.3133387863636017,
0.3639582097530365,
0.051772259175777435,
-0.6346390843391418,
-0.1020723357796669,
-0.15492956340312958,
-0.025415457785129547,
-0.02382047288119793,
0.4289586544036865,
-0.1434827744960785,
-0.4392780661582947,
0.013666220009326935,
0.0006935994024388492,
-0.2341889590024948,
0.3936276435852051,
-0.5441274642944336,
0.6214761734008789,
0.3169892132282257,
-0.1319132149219513,
-0.8576075434684753,
0.12811946868896484,
0.585722804069519,
-0.4180426001548767,
0.623376727104187,
0.6008204817771912,
-0.6310294270515442,
0.17309902608394623,
-0.6356768608093262,
-0.5887388586997986,
-0.412550151348114,
0.12253355979919434,
-0.4275810718536377,
-0.15262620151042938,
0.8177407383918762,
0.3270297348499298,
-0.12942096590995789,
0.3235243260860443,
0.42871958017349243,
-0.13599880039691925,
1.3052330017089844,
0.12396883219480515,
-0.08460070937871933,
0.4821898937225342,
-0.08782204240560532,
0.040317583829164505,
-1.1439162492752075,
-0.3712772727012634,
-0.6473522782325745,
-0.48848026990890503,
-0.4386507272720337,
-0.11348996311426163,
0.27714696526527405,
-0.26235857605934143,
-0.08051320165395737,
0.022926677018404007,
-0.541853129863739,
0.28957289457321167,
0.34708747267723083,
0.39930862188339233,
0.14719733595848083,
0.005909275263547897,
0.199903666973114,
-0.22661368548870087,
-0.2871954143047333,
-0.07572489976882935,
0.7412588596343994,
0.3500819504261017,
0.08052868396043777,
0.3772876262664795,
0.38162901997566223,
0.41056710481643677,
0.09041783958673477,
-0.9428600668907166,
0.3048924505710602,
-0.15189845860004425,
-0.35357847809791565,
-0.2512150704860687,
0.05859066918492317,
-0.9108850359916687,
0.18606087565422058,
-0.17371457815170288,
-1.0987660884857178,
0.7786322236061096,
0.25202539563179016,
-0.5048254132270813,
-0.13721932470798492,
-0.6261887550354004,
0.6718979477882385,
0.12311073392629623,
-0.11459828168153763,
-0.3101814389228821,
-0.7383313179016113,
0.349547415971756,
0.18204908072948456,
0.20928040146827698,
0.26072564721107483,
0.09377934038639069,
0.8079919815063477,
-0.21058881282806396,
0.8820765614509583,
-0.7844386696815491,
-0.07069547474384308,
0.2494717836380005,
0.3496984839439392,
0.49752500653266907,
-0.24506759643554688,
-0.21167457103729248,
0.19722159206867218,
-0.16773159801959991,
-0.26645228266716003,
-0.6775486469268799,
0.4488705098628998,
-1.1092325448989868,
-0.37596288323402405,
-0.2081303894519806,
-0.6446091532707214,
-0.13832515478134155,
-0.05183872580528259,
0.5631411671638489,
0.6044340133666992,
-0.10807060450315475,
0.03594878315925598,
0.6022666096687317,
0.03160972148180008,
0.1937720626592636,
0.6483662724494934,
-0.11295545846223831,
-0.03860681504011154,
0.6411502957344055,
0.18003246188163757,
0.3293554186820984,
0.32917892932891846,
0.42009323835372925,
-0.6144160032272339,
-0.7734313607215881,
-0.2593010663986206,
0.13814052939414978,
-0.7580434083938599,
0.12305556237697601,
-0.6563234329223633,
-0.3370566964149475,
-0.5222376585006714,
-0.17127813398838043,
-0.23681095242500305,
-0.12135115265846252,
-0.3114061951637268,
-0.15259939432144165,
0.22369767725467682,
0.8853806257247925,
-0.35763558745384216,
0.6694523692131042,
-0.4546831548213959,
0.16816608607769012,
0.3534146547317505,
-0.13987843692302704,
0.1733045130968094,
-1.1729931831359863,
0.007458641193807125,
0.5540190935134888,
0.26307618618011475,
-1.047294020652771,
0.46098247170448303,
0.24017825722694397,
0.45225074887275696,
0.3639839291572571,
-0.18861624598503113,
0.9042990803718567,
-0.38748058676719666,
0.783377468585968,
0.05915320664644241,
-0.9406806230545044,
0.641120970249176,
-0.24960391223430634,
0.4140726327896118,
0.4109251797199249,
-0.08683925122022629,
-0.7589340209960938,
-0.2799038290977478,
-0.4400956928730011,
-0.8857474327087402,
0.6847997903823853,
-0.2574200928211212,
0.08011090755462646,
0.3248485028743744,
0.6029890775680542,
0.04383644834160805,
0.034030571579933167,
-0.751743733882904,
-0.11972417682409286,
-0.2978602945804596,
0.12288603186607361,
-0.373555064201355,
-0.3712020516395569,
-0.0494789220392704,
-0.2267540842294693,
0.38322699069976807,
0.0777059867978096,
0.4647938013076782,
0.402569979429245,
-0.4599676728248596,
-0.31629428267478943,
0.038562286645174026,
1.0715727806091309,
0.43077051639556885,
-0.09665326029062271,
0.29413390159606934,
0.16253745555877686,
-0.4211748242378235,
0.15992777049541473,
-0.1904529482126236,
-0.06831242889165878,
-0.07782702893018723,
0.24563783407211304,
0.8679980039596558,
0.29863569140434265,
-0.2376161813735962,
0.21397119760513306,
0.0433979369699955,
-0.2566748559474945,
-0.7148887515068054,
0.20446355640888214,
0.08940029889345169,
0.216566801071167,
0.39514055848121643,
0.5284123420715332,
0.5642077922821045,
-0.6419218182563782,
0.20091749727725983,
0.2092536836862564,
-0.5992351174354553,
-0.5492739081382751,
0.8957250118255615,
-0.07238953560590744,
-0.6010625958442688,
0.8700451850891113,
-0.061330392956733704,
-0.5715233683586121,
0.6608796119689941,
0.8563452363014221,
0.7214884757995605,
-0.8397111296653748,
-0.1034989282488823,
0.5036612153053284,
0.12257716804742813,
0.10984348505735397,
0.038129206746816635,
-0.30198904871940613,
-1.1478774547576904,
-0.16514143347740173,
-0.7286783456802368,
-0.13069921731948853,
0.1863481104373932,
-1.0086804628372192,
0.10533690452575684,
-0.2837110757827759,
0.07393022626638412,
0.41134265065193176,
-0.3891328275203705,
-0.6668381690979004,
0.19158795475959778,
0.5659111738204956,
0.6543362736701965,
-1.2755287885665894,
0.8984797596931458,
0.8262853622436523,
-0.2944369912147522,
-1.0441615581512451,
0.20104163885116577,
0.44608548283576965,
-1.0619909763336182,
0.6074483394622803,
0.05330619215965271,
-0.24553008377552032,
0.4084170162677765,
-0.2713814377784729,
-0.7013328671455383,
0.7782191634178162,
0.15401853621006012,
-0.4799139201641083,
0.23912927508354187,
0.23656108975410461,
0.6750818490982056,
-0.2223881483078003,
-0.06492796540260315,
0.9468894004821777,
0.7900088429450989,
0.02000056579709053,
-0.9387149214744568,
-0.04464302211999893,
-0.18117165565490723,
-0.02363022044301033,
0.053588125854730606,
-0.2820444405078888,
0.789734959602356,
-0.196440190076828,
-0.03754403069615364,
-0.030053025111556053,
0.5802702903747559,
0.24429522454738617,
0.42107129096984863,
0.6261435151100159,
0.06753766536712646,
0.7998198866844177,
0.09894965589046478,
0.9584450721740723,
-0.10327553004026413,
-0.21637018024921417,
0.9435954093933105,
-0.2837452292442322,
0.9059328436851501,
0.8410540223121643,
-0.1684895157814026,
0.4705747663974762,
0.7917170524597168,
0.18979275226593018,
0.701206624507904,
0.1335376352071762,
-0.21471859514713287,
0.18182417750358582,
-0.38585564494132996,
-0.1958937644958496,
1.0552603006362915,
0.6564639210700989,
-0.10764410346746445,
0.30981144309043884,
0.26980552077293396,
-0.21369291841983795,
0.27739739418029785,
-0.6143722534179688,
1.1122560501098633,
0.2270960807800293,
-0.8871196508407593,
0.41745269298553467,
-0.04258378595113754,
0.3819340765476227,
-0.5685902833938599,
0.10120097547769547,
-0.06198425218462944,
0.1587052196264267,
-0.5746101140975952,
-0.5934024453163147,
0.6615556478500366,
-0.5430659055709839,
-0.5464667677879333,
-0.030638420954346657,
0.6482088565826416,
-0.561937689781189,
-0.044290538877248764,
0.40646126866340637,
0.15822502970695496,
0.2820986211299896,
-0.2943185269832611,
-0.366405725479126,
0.03167634457349777,
0.12966105341911316,
-0.10917379707098007,
0.37573686242103577,
0.2069254070520401,
0.020821917802095413,
0.23620523512363434,
0.7347870469093323,
0.4588586091995239,
0.1950739026069641,
0.2461843341588974,
0.2122434377670288,
-0.3543601334095001,
-0.824131190776825,
-0.8717387914657593,
0.7305542230606079,
0.3332774043083191,
0.01898369751870632,
0.25946980714797974,
0.3542153239250183,
0.7080376744270325,
-0.13555936515331268,
0.6566909551620483,
0.20749789476394653,
0.2528485059738159,
-0.7583317160606384,
0.7504501342773438,
-0.6165721416473389,
0.13224294781684875,
-0.013856176286935806,
-0.9848945140838623,
-0.2887612581253052,
0.8194839358329773,
-0.5139287114143372,
-0.08024763315916061,
0.5905222296714783,
0.8277411460876465,
-0.08252838253974915,
0.03711608797311783,
0.39265674352645874,
0.5368877649307251,
-0.14329659938812256,
0.19081689417362213,
0.6052517890930176,
-0.4238497018814087,
0.2601478099822998,
-0.15409724414348602,
0.12821809947490692,
-0.37904155254364014,
-0.3608687222003937,
-0.1656116545200348,
-1.09734308719635,
-0.16770072281360626,
-0.4139193296432495,
0.015681328251957893,
0.8590704202651978,
0.6075676679611206,
-0.9312674403190613,
-0.3884202539920807,
-0.3556942045688629,
-0.1014067754149437,
-0.416340172290802,
-0.2884844243526459,
0.05970907211303711,
-0.09356588125228882,
-0.6711121797561646,
0.6202189326286316,
0.047199975699186325,
0.1519182175397873,
-0.23864944279193878,
-0.18869546055793762,
0.11450423300266266,
-0.11930763721466064,
0.43729767203330994,
0.46438366174697876,
-0.7801414132118225,
-0.4435926079750061,
-0.03769410774111748,
-0.053779859095811844,
0.2987692654132843,
0.9563226699829102,
-0.7023305892944336,
0.5161780118942261,
0.5339078903198242,
0.2271745204925537,
0.3906748294830322,
-0.08973407000303268,
0.8481596112251282,
-0.768622100353241,
0.6721901893615723,
0.1467687040567398,
0.42708128690719604,
0.3595852553844452,
-0.616952657699585,
0.18900372087955475,
0.19480693340301514,
-0.47667619585990906,
-1.1075395345687866,
0.16792753338813782,
-0.8871116042137146,
-0.10540061444044113,
1.1285345554351807,
0.318241685628891,
-0.31891557574272156,
-0.24706850945949554,
-0.2006809264421463,
0.5320549607276917,
-0.3265949785709381,
0.5399253964424133,
0.6700459122657776,
-0.2238251119852066,
-0.3857731819152832,
-0.6676960587501526,
0.5105077028274536,
0.3758960962295532,
-0.02260453812777996,
0.13842815160751343,
0.40259861946105957,
0.36088845133781433,
0.22612552344799042,
0.6887632012367249,
0.03880463168025017,
0.5383867621421814,
0.2623242139816284,
0.37397196888923645,
0.20495665073394775,
-0.2396622747182846,
-0.885543167591095,
-0.15981365740299225,
0.4950486719608307,
-0.2969779074192047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15264v1 | Towards Fine-Grained Citation Evaluation in Generated Text: A Comparative Analysis of Faithfulness Metrics | 2024-06-21T15:57:24 | 2024-06-21T15:57:24 | Weijia Zhang, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Yifei Yuan, Jiahuan Pei, Jia-Hong Huang, Evangelos Kanoulas | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often produce unsupported or unverifiable
information, known as "hallucinations." To mitigate this, retrieval-augmented
LLMs incorporate citations, grounding the content in verifiable sources.
Despite such developments, manually assessing how well a citation supports the
associated statement remains a major challenge. Previous studies use
faithfulness metrics to estimate citation support automatically but are limited
to binary classification, overlooking fine-grained citation support in
practical scenarios. To investigate the effectiveness of faithfulness metrics
in fine-grained scenarios, we propose a comparative evaluation framework that
assesses the metric effectiveness in distinguishinging citations between
three-category support levels: full, partial, and no support. Our framework
employs correlation analysis, classification evaluation, and retrieval
evaluation to measure the alignment between metric scores and human judgments
comprehensively. Our results show no single metric consistently excels across
all evaluations, revealing the complexity of assessing fine-grained support.
Based on the findings, we provide practical recommendations for developing more
effective metrics. | [
-0.36016425490379333,
-0.6080799698829651,
0.9805642366409302,
0.33307480812072754,
-0.2612009644508362,
0.11184188723564148,
-0.23346969485282898,
-0.5573388934135437,
0.2214781492948532,
0.17615234851837158,
-0.036129869520664215,
-0.4180505573749542,
-0.520940899848938,
0.49260032176971436,
-0.4748759865760803,
0.8608224987983704,
0.006621009204536676,
0.43523555994033813,
-0.5089602470397949,
-0.1213296502828598,
-0.4155905246734619,
-0.39679762721061707,
-0.11387250572443008,
-0.5549295544624329,
0.7534173727035522,
0.13970227539539337,
0.8910260200500488,
0.41384708881378174,
1.029038906097412,
0.18161845207214355,
-0.09556378424167633,
0.5131527781486511,
-0.26905497908592224,
0.45923832058906555,
-0.47259026765823364,
-0.17095503211021423,
-0.30004364252090454,
0.08030881732702255,
0.6457026600837708,
0.7762538194656372,
0.1332462579011917,
0.16098567843437195,
0.5268785953521729,
0.611672043800354,
-0.7659688591957092,
-0.038867633789777756,
-0.9918027520179749,
-0.033120643347501755,
-0.3808068633079529,
-0.47126835584640503,
-0.5461516380310059,
-0.7271180748939514,
0.017192726954817772,
-0.43257513642311096,
0.1883147656917572,
0.17616692185401917,
0.992759644985199,
0.11762039363384247,
0.18127863109111786,
-0.37196624279022217,
-0.7424136400222778,
0.9573190808296204,
-0.45883432030677795,
0.44436612725257874,
0.47886940836906433,
0.16680695116519928,
-0.3838216960430145,
-0.7871823906898499,
-0.26359525322914124,
-0.4160195291042328,
-0.16730555891990662,
-0.07468831539154053,
-0.2959713041782379,
-0.1321416199207306,
0.04670647531747818,
0.5689764022827148,
-0.4499761760234833,
-0.17459800839424133,
0.002155158668756485,
-0.3603295385837555,
0.42413029074668884,
0.06750622391700745,
-0.06700337678194046,
-0.41479116678237915,
-0.2623487412929535,
-0.10842553526163101,
-0.2872186005115509,
-0.47678154706954956,
0.25264617800712585,
0.5871976017951965,
0.41351479291915894,
0.7906632423400879,
-0.02993476763367653,
0.3000043034553528,
0.05675060302019119,
-0.009275292977690697,
0.2740711271762848,
-0.44902315735816956,
-0.2582189738750458,
-0.025252168998122215,
0.8555168509483337,
0.23616072535514832,
0.38928505778312683,
-0.871168315410614,
-0.24082061648368835,
-0.04113286733627319,
0.595556914806366,
-0.737372636795044,
0.1278882473707199,
0.19820913672447205,
-0.6644286513328552,
-0.19813281297683716,
0.34464940428733826,
-0.77895188331604,
-0.7099271416664124,
-0.5141923427581787,
0.4317290186882019,
-0.6203054785728455,
0.05140326917171478,
-0.17611995339393616,
-0.11468689143657684,
0.12877248227596283,
0.3329530358314514,
-0.4754425883293152,
0.16402728855609894,
0.8104239106178284,
1.2570154666900635,
-0.43445277214050293,
-0.3985236883163452,
-0.6540353894233704,
0.0789944976568222,
-0.2437547743320465,
1.0768063068389893,
-0.7859551906585693,
-0.36981138586997986,
0.18124383687973022,
-0.02940061129629612,
0.08181142061948776,
-0.8276479244232178,
0.8822566270828247,
-0.501714825630188,
-0.30916377902030945,
-0.40724578499794006,
-0.5405257344245911,
0.2089885026216507,
0.329567015171051,
-0.6342107057571411,
1.1904160976409912,
0.19624117016792297,
-0.887178361415863,
0.4970564544200897,
-0.104069285094738,
-0.20559456944465637,
0.03940999135375023,
-0.19709540903568268,
-0.5342932343482971,
0.5082212090492249,
-0.2383686602115631,
0.39377135038375854,
-0.23566140234470367,
0.46753644943237305,
-0.7721441388130188,
-0.4949129819869995,
0.47910428047180176,
-0.5318912267684937,
0.30611106753349304,
0.416543573141098,
-0.25966885685920715,
0.07452999800443649,
-1.0813642740249634,
0.06851914525032043,
-0.11281279474496841,
-0.19491668045520782,
-0.7662808895111084,
0.11445302516222,
0.2649190127849579,
-0.21339748799800873,
0.2246464639902115,
-0.4697689414024353,
0.21655364334583282,
-0.2875186800956726,
-0.06131564453244209,
0.607328474521637,
-0.052661992609500885,
0.37049099802970886,
-0.32926738262176514,
0.12252388894557953,
-0.13243497908115387,
-0.010669540613889694,
0.17491166293621063,
-0.29888173937797546,
-0.5194337368011475,
-0.02579539641737938,
0.38880234956741333,
0.14786192774772644,
-0.4757695496082306,
0.35378530621528625,
-0.4736119508743286,
-0.5489246845245361,
-0.41598600149154663,
0.24313269555568695,
0.33583810925483704,
0.07338479161262512,
0.5873194336891174,
-0.31297773122787476,
-0.7681467533111572,
-0.8350740671157837,
-0.5965728163719177,
-0.33104196190834045,
-0.13335873186588287,
0.2026645988225937,
0.6567274928092957,
-0.27960509061813354,
0.8299582600593567,
-0.06820041686296463,
-0.40645265579223633,
0.20375098288059235,
0.4062126576900482,
-0.3063388168811798,
0.4228895604610443,
0.49686503410339355,
-0.4850025177001953,
-0.3115258812904358,
0.1880141943693161,
-0.8324006199836731,
-0.1967521458864212,
-0.07474184036254883,
-0.2781674265861511,
0.24868032336235046,
0.28458619117736816,
-0.28843533992767334,
0.3732006847858429,
0.2845531702041626,
-0.4208005368709564,
0.6464751958847046,
-0.011659462004899979,
0.2600536048412323,
-0.7653573155403137,
0.3449876308441162,
0.006266302894800901,
-0.20390012860298157,
-0.23376910388469696,
0.1879720240831375,
-0.02230585180222988,
0.36359885334968567,
0.02655273862183094,
0.43391069769859314,
-0.32160189747810364,
-0.2730185389518738,
-0.24767667055130005,
0.37565773725509644,
0.11457784473896027,
-0.1163158044219017,
-0.13341772556304932,
0.7977778315544128,
0.08444201946258545,
-0.27325889468193054,
0.02935853786766529,
0.11863342672586441,
-0.37155482172966003,
0.8048536777496338,
-0.41184914112091064,
0.06448687613010406,
0.04864751920104027,
-0.019987989217042923,
-0.8848965764045715,
-0.15998466312885284,
-0.025204116478562355,
-0.44491973519325256,
0.18731838464736938,
-0.04142702743411064,
-0.7784091234207153,
-0.05324627086520195,
-0.48726728558540344,
0.2386910766363144,
0.11766494810581207,
-0.40822526812553406,
0.5091429948806763,
0.114206962287426,
0.15725268423557281,
-0.377127468585968,
-0.5791783332824707,
0.21598388254642487,
-0.24010074138641357,
-0.39982104301452637,
0.4731084406375885,
-0.13256847858428955,
-0.7232818007469177,
0.005951493047177792,
-0.3059573769569397,
-0.032811056822538376,
0.09605630487203598,
0.3553794324398041,
0.13482601940631866,
-0.2980552315711975,
0.06658220291137695,
-0.10945121943950653,
0.10759293287992477,
0.034153468906879425,
-0.21273986995220184,
0.6272186636924744,
-0.35951149463653564,
-0.3385802209377289,
-0.347962349653244,
0.26252976059913635,
0.6505857706069946,
0.07602164894342422,
0.7094979882240295,
0.6648579239845276,
-0.3132226765155792,
0.18345923721790314,
-0.8326300978660583,
0.05608943849802017,
-0.37551623582839966,
-0.08887112885713577,
-0.2764278054237366,
-0.5461578369140625,
0.5813695192337036,
0.2676290273666382,
0.006784047000110149,
0.4305759370326996,
0.36813199520111084,
-0.003651529084891081,
0.8972732424736023,
0.155445858836174,
0.11398441344499588,
0.38644036650657654,
0.0583549439907074,
-0.0397050566971302,
-0.8552457690238953,
-0.572685956954956,
-0.8906504511833191,
-0.07894496619701385,
-0.5440015196800232,
-0.4820151627063751,
-0.07148925960063934,
0.4546653926372528,
-0.22288447618484497,
0.20491908490657806,
-0.4134014844894409,
0.2670770287513733,
0.30509650707244873,
-0.0982828363776207,
0.600378692150116,
0.5156848430633545,
-0.13635021448135376,
-0.2420695722103119,
-0.13964907824993134,
-1.1034692525863647,
0.9512043595314026,
0.34195026755332947,
0.6740694642066956,
0.14150561392307281,
0.6647564768791199,
0.4536963105201721,
0.2667836844921112,
-0.8307337760925293,
0.39196890592575073,
-0.12743142247200012,
-0.4359806180000305,
-0.15522538125514984,
-0.4401187002658844,
-0.9170417785644531,
0.27942535281181335,
-0.3240700364112854,
-0.9373133182525635,
0.3583329916000366,
-0.23601362109184265,
-0.3140793740749359,
0.11144717782735825,
-0.3896835446357727,
0.47583067417144775,
0.06422526389360428,
-0.7280234694480896,
-0.04746226966381073,
-0.14860326051712036,
0.06018279492855072,
-0.29971393942832947,
0.11450241506099701,
0.009983506985008717,
0.10674667358398438,
0.7677253484725952,
-0.3256302773952484,
0.46920245885849,
-0.07961875945329666,
-0.22627666592597961,
0.33531755208969116,
0.403877317905426,
0.48222652077674866,
0.24628354609012604,
-0.4812113344669342,
0.22501052916049957,
0.2444862723350525,
-0.2945711612701416,
-0.6804394721984863,
0.9744826555252075,
-0.5814065337181091,
-0.4205317199230194,
-0.5620622634887695,
-0.5262426733970642,
-0.5186690092086792,
0.22297927737236023,
0.1357855647802353,
0.1786365509033203,
-0.32550767064094543,
0.507135272026062,
0.6300141215324402,
0.044712603092193604,
0.4566517472267151,
0.29154807329177856,
-0.33838653564453125,
-0.566283643245697,
0.8859793543815613,
0.1818915754556656,
0.1125430092215538,
0.16969530284404755,
0.2010783851146698,
-0.25735968351364136,
-0.7601005434989929,
-0.3259647488594055,
0.15530931949615479,
-0.5930434465408325,
-0.47307246923446655,
-0.6595665812492371,
-0.2731475234031677,
-0.21559454500675201,
-0.08291544020175934,
-0.40623289346694946,
-0.05963188037276268,
-0.46382665634155273,
0.1061612069606781,
0.1455572098493576,
0.5409157872200012,
0.11763840168714523,
0.052491337060928345,
-0.6977260112762451,
0.09671555459499359,
0.04995577782392502,
0.6541325449943542,
0.21969430148601532,
-0.587678074836731,
-0.13704814016819,
-0.07602867484092712,
-0.4945451319217682,
-0.6804263591766357,
0.0814063772559166,
0.09678106009960175,
0.47846677899360657,
0.46605411171913147,
0.06662436574697495,
1.1726938486099243,
-0.6217065453529358,
0.8961100578308105,
0.1968458741903305,
-0.9512202143669128,
0.4595440924167633,
-0.2107263058423996,
-0.1242959201335907,
1.0485919713974,
0.23345214128494263,
0.15077586472034454,
-0.6741231083869934,
-0.48108041286468506,
-0.6290320158004761,
0.2619275450706482,
0.5968974232673645,
0.09249386191368103,
-0.13170428574085236,
0.39817267656326294,
0.3106713593006134,
-0.013689834624528885,
-0.8684868812561035,
-0.2008572220802307,
-0.13109390437602997,
-0.019278842955827713,
0.10020264983177185,
-0.31367582082748413,
-0.058127693831920624,
-0.19750459492206573,
0.6204015612602234,
-0.11074936389923096,
0.12970960140228271,
0.45735278725624084,
-0.06094362214207649,
-0.16989865899085999,
0.39074233174324036,
0.48479264974594116,
0.7853898406028748,
-0.3923567533493042,
0.45656830072402954,
-0.042101480066776276,
-0.6478950381278992,
0.00504767382517457,
-0.04811062291264534,
-0.1949356645345688,
0.42834213376045227,
0.3991512060165405,
0.38480573892593384,
0.2655673921108246,
-0.4599858224391937,
0.442182332277298,
-0.09694512188434601,
-0.08260809630155563,
-0.29483476281166077,
-0.0952569916844368,
-0.32078057527542114,
0.31311529874801636,
0.4847579300403595,
0.05857140198349953,
0.2963339686393738,
-0.5970820188522339,
0.14019428193569183,
0.7959319353103638,
-0.5947868824005127,
-0.24246783554553986,
0.38474324345588684,
-0.13185468316078186,
-0.28616899251937866,
0.24855512380599976,
-0.3144684135913849,
-0.10798453539609909,
0.13383670151233673,
0.6460176706314087,
0.9272313117980957,
0.09094017744064331,
0.22136390209197998,
0.4019019901752472,
0.15987887978553772,
-0.3231407105922699,
0.10005985200405121,
0.07278364896774292,
-0.4911499321460724,
-0.2104400098323822,
-1.2274045944213867,
-0.16349279880523682,
0.289486825466156,
-0.8584962487220764,
0.15511666238307953,
-0.20200218260288239,
-0.3754786550998688,
0.22701528668403625,
0.19896171987056732,
-0.36928707361221313,
-0.012746833264827728,
0.04690176993608475,
0.8298326730728149,
-0.6450150609016418,
0.7412378787994385,
0.5541458129882812,
-0.7201676368713379,
-0.5650405287742615,
0.4174031913280487,
-0.3063952922821045,
-0.463726669549942,
0.5055710673332214,
0.015019968152046204,
-0.38758036494255066,
-0.3411361277103424,
-0.44578617811203003,
-0.7915865182876587,
0.9181641340255737,
0.4217054843902588,
-0.5901526212692261,
0.004525728058069944,
0.22029365599155426,
0.6357537508010864,
-0.23275238275527954,
0.3471600115299225,
0.6354889273643494,
0.7061324119567871,
0.17466968297958374,
-0.873646080493927,
0.07570257037878036,
-0.04051181674003601,
0.2143053412437439,
-0.03489499166607857,
-0.40124014019966125,
0.37545013427734375,
0.16445225477218628,
-0.37531065940856934,
0.6396859884262085,
0.7247467637062073,
0.42296528816223145,
0.6167107224464417,
0.38691747188568115,
0.28737929463386536,
1.0232632160186768,
-0.2283174991607666,
0.7784215807914734,
-0.23022693395614624,
0.5284576416015625,
1.0816067457199097,
-0.29910820722579956,
1.0969995260238647,
1.0126875638961792,
-0.33041509985923767,
0.7377557754516602,
0.48709893226623535,
-0.30500924587249756,
0.4574865996837616,
0.17944413423538208,
-0.007754846941679716,
-0.43957170844078064,
-0.46401312947273254,
-0.46253976225852966,
0.182474747300148,
-0.009807665832340717,
-0.6147484183311462,
-0.28268691897392273,
0.009443934075534344,
-0.0443306602537632,
0.35749784111976624,
-0.3095953166484833,
0.6636558175086975,
0.23598021268844604,
-0.7344953417778015,
0.6827532052993774,
-0.1971164494752884,
0.45723557472229004,
-0.33677586913108826,
0.0020831732545048,
-0.4232090711593628,
0.1202695444226265,
-0.6940906047821045,
-0.8216902017593384,
0.5694963932037354,
0.4517129361629486,
-0.5143063068389893,
0.18638528883457184,
0.5572426915168762,
0.0834273099899292,
-0.5232186317443848,
0.4961124658584595,
0.34613147377967834,
0.22137564420700073,
-0.08169858902692795,
-0.29488685727119446,
0.2959354519844055,
-0.1800830364227295,
-0.162607803940773,
0.5163794755935669,
0.5786077380180359,
-0.06733643263578415,
0.3563428521156311,
0.53228759765625,
0.2929239571094513,
-0.008600221946835518,
0.47261619567871094,
0.6477073431015015,
-0.5248239040374756,
0.16371123492717743,
-1.1380976438522339,
0.19997096061706543,
-0.2563402056694031,
-0.13271872699260712,
1.2508035898208618,
0.8392289280891418,
0.7009664177894592,
0.15111000835895538,
0.5750616788864136,
0.03488796949386597,
0.18841387331485748,
-0.5085248351097107,
0.5321070551872253,
-0.6694361567497253,
0.6358609199523926,
-0.8428744673728943,
-1.3517347574234009,
-0.5268616676330566,
0.7311326861381531,
-0.229718416929245,
-0.08423658460378647,
0.8055737614631653,
0.7097236514091492,
-0.23292040824890137,
0.11122780293226242,
0.3033912181854248,
0.11734431236982346,
0.12453100085258484,
0.04331119731068611,
1.1417810916900635,
-0.38540518283843994,
0.6165873408317566,
-0.08401695638895035,
0.06960105895996094,
-0.24214516580104828,
-0.9740607142448425,
-0.7952491641044617,
-0.5497706532478333,
-0.29420819878578186,
-0.8678933382034302,
0.07591411471366882,
0.8656279444694519,
0.3971637189388275,
-0.8911637663841248,
-0.0024476516991853714,
-0.2613246440887451,
-0.03795827180147171,
-0.09592749923467636,
-0.2760255038738251,
0.46539223194122314,
-0.8228501677513123,
-0.7581427693367004,
0.14081452786922455,
0.17527887225151062,
-0.011516906321048737,
-0.5511050820350647,
-0.014524589292705059,
0.07323101907968521,
0.2839948832988739,
0.6668106913566589,
-0.1073482409119606,
-0.9285175800323486,
-0.5636095404624939,
0.04136813431978226,
-0.3141765594482422,
0.11891677230596542,
0.8746162056922913,
-0.6909480690956116,
0.41532668471336365,
0.4056225121021271,
0.6403979659080505,
-0.03486812487244606,
0.16647550463676453,
0.20447371900081635,
-0.48956167697906494,
-0.2308667004108429,
0.13557210564613342,
0.3384186923503876,
0.3973652124404907,
-0.1601371467113495,
0.5849141478538513,
0.1898253709077835,
-0.6737908124923706,
-1.2816756963729858,
-0.13870538771152496,
-1.094751000404358,
-0.3379530906677246,
1.4812211990356445,
-0.18608874082565308,
-0.015304978005588055,
-0.25407734513282776,
-0.08396223932504654,
0.15654724836349487,
-0.2409064918756485,
1.0313621759414673,
0.9428906440734863,
-0.11447066813707352,
0.5157085657119751,
-0.243121936917305,
0.3786110579967499,
0.24331720173358917,
-0.496468186378479,
0.3531818687915802,
0.5033548474311829,
0.10613597184419632,
0.7288706302642822,
0.01848939061164856,
-0.2794356942176819,
-0.009543251246213913,
-0.052141860127449036,
-0.3127320408821106,
0.04217549413442612,
-0.40795063972473145,
-0.31645533442497253,
0.3473912477493286,
0.44004717469215393,
0.20122691988945007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15245v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15245v1 | Unsupervised Morphological Tree Tokenizer | 2024-06-21T15:35:49 | 2024-06-21T15:35:49 | Qingyang Zhu, Xiang Hu, Pengyu Ji, Wei Wu, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As a cornerstone in language modeling, tokenization involves segmenting text
inputs into pre-defined atomic units. Conventional statistical tokenizers often
disrupt constituent boundaries within words, thereby corrupting semantic
information. To address this drawback, we introduce morphological structure
guidance to tokenization and propose a deep model to induce character-level
structures of words. Specifically, the deep model jointly encodes internal
structures and representations of words with a mechanism named
$\textit{MorphOverriding}$ to ensure the indecomposability of morphemes. By
training the model with self-supervised objectives, our method is capable of
inducing character-level structures that align with morphological rules without
annotated training data. Based on the induced structures, our algorithm
tokenizes words through vocabulary matching in a top-down manner. Empirical
results indicate that the proposed method effectively retains complete
morphemes and outperforms widely adopted methods such as BPE and WordPiece on
both morphological segmentation tasks and language modeling tasks. The code
will be released later. | [
0.11854701489210129,
-0.7944405674934387,
0.3055814504623413,
0.044805578887462616,
-0.6855652332305908,
0.21095071732997894,
0.14124956727027893,
-0.2728079855442047,
0.2576947808265686,
0.5762091875076294,
-0.34358981251716614,
-0.6423466801643372,
-0.5095211267471313,
-0.05121997743844986,
-0.4328538477420807,
0.8336951732635498,
0.2736872136592865,
0.23577813804149628,
-0.028231721371412277,
0.31425589323043823,
-0.5847204327583313,
-0.7736799716949463,
-0.5394229888916016,
-0.38639453053474426,
0.37121278047561646,
0.023516476154327393,
0.6988885402679443,
1.0474025011062622,
0.19985421001911163,
0.44108298420906067,
-0.5397061705589294,
0.01219613291323185,
-0.06834868341684341,
0.25480175018310547,
-0.20630545914173126,
-0.7138802409172058,
-0.35519495606422424,
-0.3524405062198639,
0.6859595775604248,
0.9036663770675659,
-0.14078472554683685,
-0.2756659686565399,
0.10805407166481018,
0.3791777789592743,
-0.31321120262145996,
0.31989574432373047,
-1.1202807426452637,
0.1353052407503128,
-0.692756712436676,
-0.30283892154693604,
-0.3957933187484741,
0.06586463004350662,
-0.35947486758232117,
-0.1381058692932129,
0.2008001208305359,
-0.1790328025817871,
0.5890523791313171,
0.2779930531978607,
-0.14479845762252808,
-0.1720379739999771,
-0.20575866103172302,
0.2858649790287018,
-0.7475415468215942,
0.38673099875450134,
0.30388036370277405,
-0.08058717101812363,
-0.2726507782936096,
-0.7792173624038696,
-0.2571035325527191,
-0.28239595890045166,
-0.218828022480011,
0.02186182513833046,
-0.09184081852436066,
0.5393789410591125,
0.0007830968825146556,
0.4769541919231415,
-0.41580766439437866,
0.4184960722923279,
-0.40108323097229004,
-0.19366119801998138,
0.177121102809906,
0.08860892802476883,
0.8916857242584229,
-0.6596229076385498,
-0.24240264296531677,
0.0040896679274737835,
-0.6351919174194336,
-0.05180716514587402,
0.24408502876758575,
0.7051641941070557,
0.21520808339118958,
0.9903807044029236,
0.0975368544459343,
0.20966795086860657,
0.3027459979057312,
0.25571784377098083,
0.2346281111240387,
-0.2523263394832611,
-0.3916698694229126,
0.44234028458595276,
0.5460417866706848,
0.13506865501403809,
0.3631099462509155,
-0.3604644536972046,
-0.34270259737968445,
0.24144244194030762,
0.2624112367630005,
-1.00873863697052,
-0.1864868551492691,
0.1928042471408844,
-0.43294909596443176,
-0.38965150713920593,
0.18709932267665863,
-0.721142053604126,
-0.363592267036438,
-0.05618135631084442,
0.24667862057685852,
-0.659607470035553,
-0.25090891122817993,
0.18173015117645264,
-0.30191847681999207,
0.00008168425847543404,
-0.042066819965839386,
-1.152645230293274,
0.23561017215251923,
0.841142475605011,
1.0819734334945679,
-0.23377631604671478,
-0.26972848176956177,
-0.41680580377578735,
0.1881502866744995,
-0.5962474942207336,
0.6047040820121765,
-0.9134437441825867,
-0.5855228304862976,
0.014077466912567616,
0.09345497936010361,
-0.06390027701854706,
-0.3976205289363861,
0.28924569487571716,
-0.2963860332965851,
0.24695764482021332,
0.35541290044784546,
-0.8184543251991272,
0.041149746626615524,
0.021800585091114044,
-0.3499806821346283,
0.8833944201469421,
0.05544983968138695,
-0.7540683150291443,
0.45549896359443665,
-0.798501193523407,
-0.38685542345046997,
0.4147785007953644,
-0.25881636142730713,
-0.21280182898044586,
0.5558847784996033,
0.5415111780166626,
0.47058427333831787,
0.32952213287353516,
0.3734130263328552,
0.034279923886060715,
-0.041549984365701675,
-0.07896576076745987,
-0.47152361273765564,
0.8448212146759033,
-0.006009557284414768,
-0.15525533258914948,
0.5618404150009155,
-0.5253757834434509,
-0.03722623363137245,
0.15367761254310608,
-0.11232063919305801,
-0.6827980875968933,
0.04176343232393265,
-0.04801996052265167,
-0.0017338608158752322,
0.20924708247184753,
-0.7933641672134399,
0.48356953263282776,
-1.048111915588379,
0.6225028038024902,
0.6573308706283569,
0.30608609318733215,
0.5524529218673706,
0.05631755664944649,
0.44305944442749023,
0.3921949565410614,
0.09070008248090744,
-0.5431808829307556,
-0.3526819348335266,
-0.5660989284515381,
-0.34736868739128113,
0.3860602080821991,
0.18847811222076416,
-0.5242083668708801,
0.6392583847045898,
-0.1580946147441864,
-0.4306745231151581,
-0.48499980568885803,
-0.07770679146051407,
0.4281159043312073,
0.25552988052368164,
0.4457840025424957,
-0.48517438769340515,
-0.4865948557853699,
-0.6550372242927551,
-0.10827644169330597,
-0.19130291044712067,
-0.0022927927784621716,
-0.20053261518478394,
0.46333643794059753,
-0.39120250940322876,
0.7753574252128601,
-0.2437436580657959,
-0.437899112701416,
-0.26448795199394226,
0.3411810100078583,
0.0775367021560669,
0.8321869373321533,
0.5158528685569763,
-0.49904540181159973,
-0.21773986518383026,
0.15879720449447632,
-0.16183730959892273,
-0.20161065459251404,
-0.0436478853225708,
0.02793913334608078,
0.0863884687423706,
0.9071828126907349,
-0.6867692470550537,
0.4180491268634796,
0.32499703764915466,
-0.5340718626976013,
0.21766839921474457,
-0.33959516882896423,
-0.11213100701570511,
-1.4013988971710205,
0.01857619546353817,
-0.27857762575149536,
0.011234794743359089,
-0.6589966416358948,
0.3198234736919403,
0.015982624143362045,
-0.3036995232105255,
-0.32615533471107483,
0.6925921440124512,
-0.437334805727005,
-0.14173480868339539,
-0.22082531452178955,
-0.20246218144893646,
-0.07975851744413376,
0.5238864421844482,
0.14126159250736237,
0.7396597266197205,
0.5908287167549133,
-0.3715955317020416,
-0.07045914977788925,
0.2892690598964691,
-0.3028274178504944,
0.39593616127967834,
-0.8105632662773132,
0.05553514137864113,
-0.38683539628982544,
0.08623488247394562,
-1.0111474990844727,
-0.1545405387878418,
0.3240458369255066,
-0.4818328320980072,
0.5157299637794495,
-0.5315525531768799,
-0.5319052338600159,
-0.12813247740268707,
-0.2012467235326767,
0.4945310652256012,
0.3533651530742645,
-0.6587392091751099,
0.46189722418785095,
0.486010879278183,
-0.048996299505233765,
-0.20188704133033752,
-0.7279649972915649,
0.27356159687042236,
-0.27350109815597534,
-0.3148297965526581,
0.8306126594543457,
0.0121505381539464,
-0.06529262661933899,
-0.01926770806312561,
-0.06626888364553452,
-0.3071306049823761,
0.10375572741031647,
0.4259899854660034,
-0.034862179309129715,
-0.27014681696891785,
0.3541947305202484,
0.3890628516674042,
-0.036546025425195694,
0.06423614174127579,
-0.501427173614502,
0.8839832544326782,
0.37660399079322815,
-0.49255314469337463,
-0.7566291689872742,
0.3341977894306183,
0.816677987575531,
-0.6915776133537292,
0.3045189082622528,
0.1633683145046234,
-0.6119309067726135,
-0.07403595000505447,
-0.27060315012931824,
-0.20420706272125244,
-0.5055886507034302,
0.8237621784210205,
-0.7375984787940979,
-0.7388724088668823,
0.318794846534729,
0.04827365651726723,
0.1312975287437439,
0.41881632804870605,
0.45501482486724854,
0.11413629353046417,
1.4054498672485352,
0.5783746242523193,
-0.14950886368751526,
0.6706255078315735,
0.0537913516163826,
-0.12065651267766953,
-0.6938825249671936,
-0.32077324390411377,
-0.6257110238075256,
0.010672162286937237,
-0.5646962523460388,
-0.5529617071151733,
-0.05662223696708679,
0.3225158452987671,
0.007693590596318245,
0.3303782343864441,
-0.7943456172943115,
0.5285279154777527,
0.19885998964309692,
-0.10887852311134338,
0.07457693666219711,
0.26920434832572937,
-0.4768560528755188,
-0.10496275871992111,
-0.655691385269165,
-0.34613236784935,
0.467975914478302,
0.6072760820388794,
0.7184692025184631,
-0.2814282476902008,
0.7795487642288208,
0.20997053384780884,
-0.07068207859992981,
-0.9669549465179443,
0.39194828271865845,
-0.47659263014793396,
-0.4931187331676483,
-0.5477097034454346,
-0.20955872535705566,
-1.2189691066741943,
0.4033769369125366,
0.10865647345781326,
-0.9872660040855408,
0.32406842708587646,
0.07959447056055069,
0.012066605500876904,
0.38006192445755005,
-0.5025277733802795,
0.7854875326156616,
-0.31874367594718933,
0.3313298523426056,
-0.2642582952976227,
-0.2564318776130676,
0.14769643545150757,
-0.1367221176624298,
-0.016521373763680458,
0.09045406430959702,
0.005977119319140911,
0.65375155210495,
-0.6045452952384949,
1.1690222024917603,
-0.2625281810760498,
-0.16973254084587097,
0.10842601209878922,
0.43746548891067505,
0.4958215653896332,
-0.12269528210163116,
0.002839331515133381,
0.28181132674217224,
0.14902010560035706,
-0.3028339743614197,
-0.7256024479866028,
0.3358516991138458,
-0.5204094648361206,
-0.541867196559906,
-0.2167043834924698,
-0.2953971028327942,
-0.14645254611968994,
0.3991326689720154,
0.2852535843849182,
0.5929880142211914,
-0.21743887662887573,
0.2075856477022171,
0.1796036660671234,
0.13190464675426483,
0.4954148828983307,
-0.017933055758476257,
-0.3796200156211853,
-0.48817959427833557,
0.7754005193710327,
0.17003406584262848,
0.14750877022743225,
0.627972424030304,
0.4889202117919922,
-0.4586176574230194,
-0.7320312857627869,
-0.4790904223918915,
0.10337791591882706,
-0.5296946167945862,
-0.18964308500289917,
-0.5422803163528442,
-0.5747776031494141,
-0.2739793360233307,
-0.03441203013062477,
-0.44189685583114624,
-0.3740718364715576,
-0.35621026158332825,
-0.2733577787876129,
0.12915800511837006,
1.0622669458389282,
0.12703049182891846,
0.6088223457336426,
-0.5681771039962769,
0.037896912544965744,
0.24556699395179749,
0.2856052815914154,
0.03430793806910515,
-0.5420501232147217,
0.0759008526802063,
0.06971007585525513,
0.12788499891757965,
-0.7366194128990173,
0.38078030943870544,
0.16373422741889954,
0.43186303973197937,
0.6677210927009583,
-0.3784802258014679,
1.0007596015930176,
-0.745208740234375,
0.6398800611495972,
0.3251529932022095,
-1.1893664598464966,
0.6431877613067627,
-0.14089208841323853,
0.43359917402267456,
0.33976098895072937,
0.028957247734069824,
-0.6989853382110596,
-0.6110326647758484,
-0.3274684548377991,
-0.7614586353302002,
0.4756649136543274,
0.12620143592357635,
0.6162053942680359,
-0.42647725343704224,
0.5140541195869446,
0.15989957749843597,
0.07804419845342636,
-0.5828980803489685,
0.2015179544687271,
-0.4499282240867615,
-0.24453024566173553,
0.09563035517930984,
-0.5920000076293945,
0.3128599524497986,
-0.2575993835926056,
0.3825499713420868,
-0.10195011645555496,
-0.08663221448659897,
0.11259099096059799,
-0.222201406955719,
-0.03205232694745064,
0.24875681102275848,
0.37797772884368896,
0.466113418340683,
0.01990632526576519,
0.39636367559432983,
0.007445504888892174,
-0.42324602603912354,
0.05383211374282837,
-0.06214417144656181,
-0.3898414075374603,
0.06436096131801605,
0.4324926733970642,
0.7243369221687317,
0.42821505665779114,
-0.22490888833999634,
0.31239053606987,
0.1729445457458496,
-0.087159164249897,
0.2627832293510437,
0.1210591122508049,
-0.11347534507513046,
0.10882700979709625,
0.1678035408258438,
-0.28607457876205444,
-0.09330487996339798,
-0.5734208226203918,
0.3698327839374542,
0.7171348929405212,
-0.7021123170852661,
-0.5334762930870056,
0.4899900257587433,
0.20646220445632935,
-0.6001496315002441,
0.5415540933609009,
0.14755354821681976,
-0.5974261164665222,
0.42610713839530945,
0.8840600848197937,
0.9121448397636414,
-0.46129170060157776,
0.2993701100349426,
0.24673180282115936,
0.3144387900829315,
0.11541374027729034,
0.11817903071641922,
-0.15355199575424194,
-0.5885446667671204,
-0.41085535287857056,
-0.8612796664237976,
0.13562718033790588,
0.2233537882566452,
-0.23821622133255005,
0.10534952580928802,
-0.3313324749469757,
-0.04072561487555504,
-0.003720414126291871,
-0.3181099593639374,
-0.13531796634197235,
0.30793970823287964,
0.19081148505210876,
1.0212249755859375,
-0.6232593059539795,
0.8883898854255676,
0.5872513651847839,
-0.5387100577354431,
-0.3921898901462555,
0.17673787474632263,
-0.3338412940502167,
-0.9105609655380249,
0.6015883684158325,
0.3394125699996948,
-0.05944645032286644,
0.2545747458934784,
-0.37744635343551636,
-0.9119998812675476,
0.6146637201309204,
0.1857253909111023,
-0.413443386554718,
-0.44010868668556213,
0.38349246978759766,
0.5651578903198242,
-0.3978806138038635,
0.011738394387066364,
0.15467768907546997,
0.3758540451526642,
0.16795490682125092,
-0.6083213090896606,
0.048106346279382706,
-0.1647718846797943,
0.33579733967781067,
0.3249489367008209,
-0.07806696742773056,
0.6903274059295654,
0.027176639065146446,
-0.7060262560844421,
0.38212963938713074,
0.7386765480041504,
-0.07721888273954391,
-0.4196855425834656,
0.6588466167449951,
0.4374223053455353,
0.7629835605621338,
0.19417035579681396,
0.5757157802581787,
-0.5422191023826599,
-0.007041134871542454,
1.1028552055358887,
0.10837019979953766,
0.5814811587333679,
0.5920901298522949,
0.1347963958978653,
0.4224916994571686,
0.6734994053840637,
-0.23275132477283478,
0.4726299047470093,
0.43483778834342957,
0.2589443027973175,
-0.16243503987789154,
-0.4418901205062866,
-0.30850428342819214,
0.7906060814857483,
0.39528051018714905,
-0.5252107381820679,
-0.4668302536010742,
-0.16140390932559967,
0.028597045689821243,
0.10636147856712341,
-0.6060713529586792,
0.751228392124176,
-0.005489963106811047,
-0.5123723745346069,
0.2955933213233948,
0.16076430678367615,
0.6209118366241455,
-0.7175666093826294,
-0.09506502002477646,
-0.35366517305374146,
-0.06795479357242584,
-0.1331997513771057,
-0.6796051859855652,
0.4095633625984192,
-0.06011918932199478,
0.11694777756929398,
-0.2321491539478302,
0.6230838894844055,
-0.5132132768630981,
-0.6926245093345642,
0.27707260847091675,
0.5545547008514404,
0.18094168603420258,
-0.2363818734884262,
-0.5229230523109436,
-0.15240398049354553,
-0.33816468715667725,
-0.04016084969043732,
0.2513236403465271,
0.6818907856941223,
-0.31324976682662964,
0.4194183647632599,
0.5892437100410461,
0.12332302331924438,
0.1904357522726059,
0.42562171816825867,
0.7597175240516663,
-0.6176193952560425,
-0.696206271648407,
-1.1984992027282715,
0.5822347402572632,
0.0041762241162359715,
-0.3481331765651703,
0.5203328132629395,
0.6150871515274048,
0.6285999417304993,
0.076004758477211,
0.33713001012802124,
0.21051672101020813,
-0.09136546403169632,
-0.6461616158485413,
0.8171943426132202,
-0.5838063955307007,
-0.28016364574432373,
-0.3711951971054077,
-0.7776812314987183,
-0.5840023756027222,
0.38831400871276855,
0.08611351251602173,
-0.06909672170877457,
0.6085069179534912,
0.7916123270988464,
-0.18063803017139435,
-0.34115391969680786,
0.5097182393074036,
0.2413157820701599,
0.24251580238342285,
-0.018590668216347694,
0.7254598736763,
0.10385039448738098,
0.30389800667762756,
-0.21266363561153412,
-0.1096968874335289,
-0.07224038243293762,
-0.6119616627693176,
-1.3408777713775635,
-0.7865108251571655,
-0.22446924448013306,
-0.12609270215034485,
0.20558257400989532,
0.8237765431404114,
0.8819570541381836,
-0.8532311916351318,
-0.07162433862686157,
-0.7799538969993591,
0.11274419724941254,
0.07535990327596664,
-0.21942996978759766,
0.5913307070732117,
-0.7592769265174866,
-0.8291289210319519,
0.6453636884689331,
0.514400064945221,
0.4078049957752228,
-0.5992182493209839,
0.2968713045120239,
0.07536354660987854,
0.1666380763053894,
0.5174590349197388,
-0.019633077085018158,
-0.9415566325187683,
-0.3247266709804535,
-0.10646656900644302,
-0.2178047150373459,
0.38091906905174255,
0.8927296996116638,
-0.5797668099403381,
0.46647635102272034,
0.5283780097961426,
0.6371349692344666,
0.24048814177513123,
0.17459748685359955,
0.47811347246170044,
-0.9137810468673706,
0.07573172450065613,
0.18165339529514313,
0.5660481452941895,
0.20419548451900482,
-0.4944469630718231,
0.3367312252521515,
0.09921573847532272,
-0.023297663778066635,
-0.8820128440856934,
0.3575612008571625,
-0.45101603865623474,
-0.6837104558944702,
0.8808627724647522,
0.16178317368030548,
-0.35924434661865234,
0.025327738374471664,
-0.5507326126098633,
0.4308873116970062,
-0.2557459771633148,
0.7540082335472107,
0.43186789751052856,
0.19499100744724274,
-0.23774762451648712,
0.20752058923244476,
0.46791312098503113,
0.3131358325481415,
-0.8722490072250366,
0.37226301431655884,
0.25566357374191284,
-0.0014095996739342809,
0.26792195439338684,
0.35297468304634094,
-0.36142268776893616,
-0.14077074825763702,
-0.05085133761167526,
0.2513323724269867,
-0.16863180696964264,
-0.37097933888435364,
-0.5496605634689331,
0.3265989124774933,
0.04659213870763779,
-0.409873902797699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15231v1 | Detecting Synthetic Lyrics with Few-Shot Inference | 2024-06-21T15:19:21 | 2024-06-21T15:19:21 | Yanis Labrak, Gabriel Meseguer-Brocal, Elena V. Epure | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In recent years, generated content in music has gained significant
popularity, with large language models being effectively utilized to produce
human-like lyrics in various styles, themes, and linguistic structures. This
technological advancement supports artists in their creative processes but also
raises issues of authorship infringement, consumer satisfaction and content
spamming. To address these challenges, methods for detecting generated lyrics
are necessary. However, existing works have not yet focused on this specific
modality or on creative text in general regarding machine-generated content
detection methods and datasets. In response, we have curated the first dataset
of high-quality synthetic lyrics and conducted a comprehensive quantitative
evaluation of various few-shot content detection approaches, testing their
generalization capabilities and complementing this with a human evaluation. Our
best few-shot detector, based on LLM2Vec, surpasses stylistic and statistical
methods, which are shown competitive in other domains at distinguishing
human-written from machine-generated content. It also shows good generalization
capabilities to new artists and models, and effectively detects post-generation
paraphrasing. This study emphasizes the need for further research on creative
content detection, particularly in terms of generalization and scalability with
larger song catalogs. All datasets, pre-processing scripts, and code are
available publicly on GitHub and Hugging Face under the Apache 2.0 license. | [
-0.5350909233093262,
-0.7121588587760925,
0.5604764223098755,
0.37350791692733765,
-0.23108839988708496,
0.1448647826910019,
-0.3035961389541626,
-0.4220002293586731,
0.2425367385149002,
0.8207523226737976,
-0.9439252614974976,
-0.8330945372581482,
-0.49038583040237427,
0.36814022064208984,
-0.5810675024986267,
0.9826131463050842,
0.2036353051662445,
-0.24500492215156555,
-0.2898765206336975,
-0.008883300237357616,
-0.19118288159370422,
0.042158789932727814,
-0.17238393425941467,
-0.007984498515725136,
0.6974493861198425,
0.4268873929977417,
0.16499575972557068,
0.42427849769592285,
0.36164870858192444,
0.2578783631324768,
0.02023587003350258,
0.5284171104431152,
-0.780436635017395,
0.24733231961727142,
0.08673948794603348,
-0.2835494577884674,
-0.05061957612633705,
0.1894352287054062,
0.6408596634864807,
0.039627447724342346,
0.11126116663217545,
0.40252041816711426,
0.013070937246084213,
0.5137353539466858,
-0.49220991134643555,
-0.09260819107294083,
-0.9773343801498413,
0.12379749864339828,
-0.7064060568809509,
-0.40788760781288147,
-0.43331822752952576,
-0.3366954028606415,
-0.03732677921652794,
-0.6960373520851135,
0.3388240337371826,
0.04708894342184067,
0.6193339228630066,
0.21383263170719147,
-0.10697261989116669,
-0.5409727096557617,
-0.7091341018676758,
0.8803799152374268,
-0.4474872946739197,
-0.05184566602110863,
0.36567869782447815,
0.5680354237556458,
-0.4056110680103302,
-0.9156529307365417,
-0.8872566223144531,
-0.09121721237897873,
0.15169501304626465,
0.20754167437553406,
-0.5888122320175171,
-0.24144621193408966,
0.4385015368461609,
0.29025745391845703,
-0.7513353824615479,
-0.034383807331323624,
-0.18028248846530914,
-0.3774973452091217,
0.6117218732833862,
0.12815463542938232,
0.5201373100280762,
-0.5999442338943481,
-0.45544853806495667,
-0.03172024339437485,
-0.8184593915939331,
-0.09455305337905884,
0.848679780960083,
0.14280837774276733,
-0.15620672702789307,
0.7843751907348633,
-0.22156009078025818,
0.5742541551589966,
-0.18522320687770844,
-0.13730184733867645,
0.17215073108673096,
-0.4790097177028656,
0.0732467845082283,
-0.18984055519104004,
1.2034499645233154,
0.13734792172908783,
0.6361998319625854,
-0.17241200804710388,
-0.38955506682395935,
0.2134704291820526,
0.12864112854003906,
-0.39967280626296997,
-0.4755060374736786,
-0.022365039214491844,
-0.5058078765869141,
-0.2416297197341919,
0.21389341354370117,
-0.5376112461090088,
-0.5943496227264404,
-0.4276050925254822,
0.4324938654899597,
-0.4087536633014679,
-0.2580743432044983,
-0.10156462341547012,
-0.30434557795524597,
0.12434588372707367,
-0.15319381654262543,
-0.515926718711853,
-0.029173817485570908,
0.9082413911819458,
0.9392776489257812,
-0.3957839608192444,
-0.06748238950967789,
-0.45693492889404297,
-0.0037681940011680126,
-0.4933009743690491,
1.4726709127426147,
-0.28063616156578064,
-0.2956441640853882,
-0.05406384542584419,
-0.1509934514760971,
0.23331204056739807,
-0.9393631815910339,
0.7518044114112854,
-0.36315804719924927,
0.1080467626452446,
-0.3335821330547333,
-0.7356734871864319,
0.27305498719215393,
-0.026651425287127495,
-0.8213831782341003,
0.7622179388999939,
0.18613898754119873,
-0.7126302123069763,
0.3813210427761078,
-0.21215730905532837,
-0.30469951033592224,
0.05271496623754501,
-0.2787208557128906,
-0.5977082848548889,
0.27514535188674927,
-0.028775645419955254,
0.2832290232181549,
-0.10603248327970505,
-0.11283022910356522,
-0.4395257532596588,
-0.6499346494674683,
0.6618717312812805,
-0.30422243475914,
0.429342657327652,
0.5151476263999939,
0.026201648637652397,
-0.05691489949822426,
-0.7790798544883728,
0.1466110199689865,
0.15877564251422882,
-0.36095017194747925,
-0.11777404695749283,
-0.14009693264961243,
0.4666006565093994,
0.13488832116127014,
-0.11133597046136856,
-0.5103247165679932,
0.0716133788228035,
-0.3480268716812134,
0.11410973966121674,
0.5104997754096985,
0.38722506165504456,
0.40946900844573975,
-0.49477264285087585,
0.7437682747840881,
-0.21063603460788727,
-0.1947072595357895,
-0.13767918944358826,
-0.6158457398414612,
-0.07016205787658691,
-0.4566667675971985,
0.09625685214996338,
0.39543262124061584,
-0.9342790246009827,
0.4018544554710388,
-0.18037712574005127,
-0.34646961092948914,
-0.4944579303264618,
0.6085251569747925,
0.40087342262268066,
0.2729763090610504,
0.27822160720825195,
-0.020253129303455353,
-0.8495417237281799,
-0.8997313380241394,
-0.6220938563346863,
0.04827811196446419,
-0.4097479581832886,
0.3732903301715851,
0.2877558171749115,
-0.17006225883960724,
1.2004053592681885,
-0.6620112061500549,
-0.5367217659950256,
-0.3668251633644104,
0.45859596133232117,
0.3984628915786743,
0.47163939476013184,
0.7378212213516235,
-0.5776387453079224,
-0.6495554447174072,
-0.31421923637390137,
-0.7181608080863953,
-0.6833715438842773,
-0.23771017789840698,
-0.5414935350418091,
-0.10413321852684021,
-0.0397774763405323,
-0.699985146522522,
0.0024969959631562233,
0.4922407865524292,
0.10485672950744629,
0.4280412197113037,
0.4385596811771393,
0.11828698962926865,
-0.7653876543045044,
-0.06908570230007172,
0.15788166224956512,
-0.18309499323368073,
-0.6278566718101501,
-0.42387115955352783,
-0.1725706160068512,
0.2844575047492981,
-0.5046700239181519,
0.2610265612602234,
-0.11808248609304428,
-0.32946571707725525,
-0.6449174880981445,
0.17352861166000366,
0.03663327172398567,
0.09764403849840164,
0.04028065875172615,
0.6913774609565735,
0.34143170714378357,
-0.06190056726336479,
0.5502941608428955,
0.1734391450881958,
-0.7820004820823669,
0.6451767086982727,
-0.588833749294281,
0.481421560049057,
-0.2661380469799042,
0.5016043186187744,
-1.1311131715774536,
-0.513067901134491,
0.31828731298446655,
-0.7315904498100281,
0.13975654542446136,
-0.41872498393058777,
-0.7406797409057617,
-0.32991674542427063,
-0.2594012916088104,
0.21858082711696625,
0.6467145085334778,
-0.3139457404613495,
0.12652331590652466,
0.35770076513290405,
0.022630836814641953,
-0.11467333137989044,
-0.6398689150810242,
0.26498177647590637,
-0.3443899154663086,
-0.7060314416885376,
0.46798625588417053,
-0.021001702174544334,
-0.20374533534049988,
-0.14152497053146362,
-0.16327440738677979,
-0.1645951122045517,
-0.1671314537525177,
0.1388523280620575,
0.07716212421655655,
-0.298266738653183,
-0.037674836814403534,
0.14221042394638062,
-0.37056228518486023,
0.0006552968407049775,
-0.5075592398643494,
0.44900718331336975,
0.10850534588098526,
-0.039808616042137146,
-0.6499375700950623,
0.2393888533115387,
0.2609384059906006,
-0.056596171110868454,
0.2388947755098343,
1.0142945051193237,
-0.3013146221637726,
-0.48967382311820984,
-0.46008574962615967,
-0.04856795817613602,
-0.45275670289993286,
-0.06897220015525818,
-0.21372108161449432,
-0.5482172966003418,
0.43600350618362427,
0.13021530210971832,
-0.29899367690086365,
0.5514054894447327,
0.5455637574195862,
-0.6373348236083984,
0.9208599925041199,
0.06127011775970459,
0.11486677080392838,
0.4323470890522003,
-0.6946890354156494,
-0.4407298266887665,
-0.6302358508110046,
-0.12968912720680237,
-0.442454069852829,
-0.5188999176025391,
-0.9012276530265808,
-0.30290812253952026,
0.46773603558540344,
-0.18203116953372955,
0.09308122098445892,
0.5295396447181702,
-0.42793354392051697,
0.7531909942626953,
0.5564674735069275,
0.27234143018722534,
0.23774367570877075,
0.1358031928539276,
-0.0010640990221872926,
0.018411383032798767,
-0.2444571703672409,
-0.4878334701061249,
1.158782720565796,
0.1819663792848587,
0.7337129712104797,
0.18587176501750946,
0.9990966320037842,
0.5734978318214417,
0.09135257452726364,
-0.8624922633171082,
0.28596431016921997,
-0.417987197637558,
-0.6950766444206238,
-0.09608369320631027,
-0.40501898527145386,
-0.6556469798088074,
0.014958532527089119,
-0.5135685801506042,
-0.48187369108200073,
-0.24270519614219666,
0.14399810135364532,
-0.37936556339263916,
0.05902908742427826,
-0.4710516035556793,
0.7658464908599854,
-0.04998065531253815,
-0.5078532099723816,
0.04805053770542145,
-0.41051197052001953,
0.5804429650306702,
-0.29398053884506226,
0.09694784134626389,
-0.43377476930618286,
-0.07021228224039078,
0.6353198289871216,
-0.10175026953220367,
0.7367572784423828,
-0.14703397452831268,
-0.2791975140571594,
0.8163621425628662,
0.11677958071231842,
0.6683850884437561,
-0.035156235098838806,
0.11062247306108475,
0.12938068807125092,
0.004689380992203951,
-0.5057528018951416,
-0.6023513078689575,
0.8447985649108887,
-0.4705374240875244,
-0.1568136364221573,
0.04533456638455391,
-0.3154117465019226,
-0.059518963098526,
-0.02173924818634987,
0.9300447702407837,
0.13777366280555725,
0.11574196070432663,
0.39212489128112793,
0.4038478136062622,
-0.27737295627593994,
0.3072431981563568,
0.08559505641460419,
-0.06115642189979553,
-0.7013639807701111,
0.9416003227233887,
-0.07937558740377426,
0.10855952650308609,
0.2263525277376175,
0.4076337218284607,
-0.43963637948036194,
-0.6951488852500916,
-0.523914635181427,
0.20771455764770508,
-0.543437659740448,
-0.17153698205947876,
-0.4993017613887787,
0.1034451499581337,
-0.40197956562042236,
0.10102640092372894,
-0.29871702194213867,
-0.3166886568069458,
-0.43000704050064087,
0.19440904259681702,
0.33777183294296265,
0.7306130528450012,
-0.07406597584486008,
0.3952087163925171,
-0.9205445051193237,
0.8708195686340332,
0.10374753177165985,
0.07894790917634964,
-0.31464943289756775,
-0.5932870507240295,
-0.10920164734125137,
-0.09115111827850342,
-0.3968084454536438,
-0.9037140607833862,
0.32717567682266235,
0.3177730143070221,
0.393941730260849,
0.5505515933036804,
-0.05007708817720413,
0.5135647654533386,
-0.30789318680763245,
0.6623051762580872,
0.10060124844312668,
-0.7174078822135925,
0.5535147190093994,
-0.6898708343505859,
0.09930280596017838,
0.5299859642982483,
0.12565849721431732,
-0.47049665451049805,
-0.21272216737270355,
-0.2795793116092682,
-0.41588276624679565,
0.4345273971557617,
0.5415728688240051,
0.4702114164829254,
-0.13139615952968597,
0.3197822868824005,
0.27785366773605347,
0.2649823725223541,
-0.7145865559577942,
-0.0978611409664154,
-0.12364544719457626,
-0.46399757266044617,
-0.03828568384051323,
-0.08496712148189545,
0.1662982553243637,
0.046317894011735916,
0.29933202266693115,
-0.2436985820531845,
0.19828569889068604,
-0.037225738167762756,
-0.03339281305670738,
-0.44622549414634705,
0.05922571197152138,
0.4996199309825897,
0.2412695586681366,
-0.05388077720999718,
0.17507803440093994,
-0.10053296387195587,
-0.40460875630378723,
0.07009019702672958,
-0.28626546263694763,
-0.45314085483551025,
-0.02874491922557354,
0.8053938746452332,
0.6965089440345764,
0.13032905757427216,
-0.7871469259262085,
0.6039725542068481,
0.23485885560512543,
0.030430492013692856,
-0.5126062631607056,
0.3389463424682617,
-0.08467289060354233,
0.25481608510017395,
0.312651664018631,
0.06546955555677414,
0.3947403132915497,
-0.47920355200767517,
0.6312279105186462,
0.4976266026496887,
-0.28556498885154724,
-0.4523025155067444,
0.4748760759830475,
-0.20705775916576385,
-0.10199275612831116,
0.31263017654418945,
-0.3327926993370056,
-0.39006224274635315,
0.5802157521247864,
0.5252593755722046,
1.131833791732788,
0.2557273507118225,
0.2647658586502075,
0.24478036165237427,
-0.06502366811037064,
0.0752091035246849,
0.3384092152118683,
-0.35623446106910706,
-0.7168824076652527,
-0.49009984731674194,
-0.7571848034858704,
-0.18991011381149292,
0.16574496030807495,
-0.34708914160728455,
0.4274480640888214,
-0.40288493037223816,
-0.21432174742221832,
0.19536817073822021,
-0.15558668971061707,
-0.5611098408699036,
-0.08392857015132904,
0.48836758732795715,
0.5464885830879211,
-1.0236053466796875,
0.5717183947563171,
0.4052141606807709,
-0.5245917439460754,
-0.4170096218585968,
0.2524407207965851,
0.49852225184440613,
-0.5947638750076294,
0.6985087394714355,
0.1703508049249649,
-0.17806701362133026,
0.2056911140680313,
-0.8490341901779175,
-0.5475136041641235,
0.9065024256706238,
-0.010558007284998894,
-0.42179811000823975,
0.1769552379846573,
0.24937626719474792,
0.7122529745101929,
-0.346462607383728,
0.0028345047030597925,
0.7599064111709595,
0.5360051393508911,
0.6560131907463074,
-0.253530353307724,
-0.45623812079429626,
0.029756199568510056,
-0.10660141706466675,
-0.06363797932863235,
-0.12283813953399658,
0.7790613174438477,
0.046764958649873734,
-0.412628173828125,
0.5451676249504089,
0.6908084750175476,
0.6407862305641174,
0.8663533329963684,
0.5288564562797546,
0.5109692811965942,
0.4783271551132202,
-0.1646900773048401,
1.0034960508346558,
0.16534224152565002,
0.3842196464538574,
0.9759853482246399,
-0.19382859766483307,
0.6943789720535278,
0.2976361811161041,
-0.4471120238304138,
0.4638579487800598,
0.6521132588386536,
-0.2979324162006378,
0.6780468821525574,
0.599390983581543,
-0.47671273350715637,
-0.5094318389892578,
-0.29071149230003357,
0.04641352593898773,
0.8048971891403198,
0.11341113597154617,
-0.459770530462265,
0.0983022153377533,
-0.07518304139375687,
-0.2022346705198288,
0.2693626880645752,
0.13392803072929382,
1.0064400434494019,
0.2584415376186371,
-0.6083782315254211,
0.5044804811477661,
-0.1887543648481369,
0.6907100677490234,
-0.20021294057369232,
-0.005205708090215921,
-0.1656554788351059,
-0.1525336652994156,
-0.43062645196914673,
-1.0013715028762817,
0.2122001200914383,
0.41537460684776306,
-0.06416364759206772,
-0.016030412167310715,
0.836824357509613,
-0.46354809403419495,
-0.43579569458961487,
0.05763727426528931,
0.3387317657470703,
0.1286306083202362,
-0.37365424633026123,
-0.3716611862182617,
0.09359820932149887,
-0.15952187776565552,
-0.07530813664197922,
-0.04703884199261665,
0.4472866356372833,
0.17348472774028778,
0.3239501714706421,
0.9488920569419861,
0.377637654542923,
0.21915985643863678,
0.30926021933555603,
0.5438147783279419,
-0.4509902596473694,
-0.28795403242111206,
-0.7646668553352356,
0.3902287483215332,
-0.09425268322229385,
-0.14453968405723572,
0.6620162129402161,
0.8499608635902405,
0.8059259653091431,
-0.504379391670227,
0.9973450899124146,
0.15196657180786133,
0.5664814114570618,
-0.8912748694419861,
0.7330400347709656,
-0.4928191900253296,
0.3577651381492615,
-0.5846507549285889,
-1.0503253936767578,
-0.34267204999923706,
0.2524507939815521,
-0.184880331158638,
-0.03873070701956749,
0.26115772128105164,
0.8665439486503601,
-0.20444902777671814,
-0.1260969340801239,
0.19584372639656067,
0.06772147119045258,
0.21197713911533356,
0.4743849039077759,
1.4714744091033936,
-0.35523849725723267,
0.6927245259284973,
-0.5096712112426758,
0.1011446863412857,
-0.03740331158041954,
-0.9375930428504944,
-0.6813186407089233,
-0.4457690715789795,
-0.2543852627277374,
-0.22385215759277344,
-0.5092214941978455,
0.9637985229492188,
0.5554808974266052,
-0.9964917898178101,
0.08128108084201813,
-0.14137181639671326,
0.2631230652332306,
0.11247282475233078,
-0.18715225160121918,
0.11129511892795563,
-0.049584005028009415,
-0.7201786041259766,
0.6529605388641357,
0.2548304498195648,
0.3082616329193115,
-0.2283666431903839,
-0.30172470211982727,
0.17520751059055328,
0.22449009120464325,
0.5594263672828674,
0.1752306967973709,
-0.9251640439033508,
-0.1626858115196228,
0.3008671700954437,
-0.07524596154689789,
-0.061481181532144547,
0.9203717112541199,
-0.616215705871582,
0.4745004177093506,
1.0491467714309692,
0.3464686870574951,
0.39399978518486023,
0.3496921956539154,
-0.0987454429268837,
-1.0391919612884521,
-0.22149857878684998,
0.12554621696472168,
0.2286287248134613,
0.27457916736602783,
-0.12267076224088669,
0.32052499055862427,
0.6995444297790527,
-0.35502105951309204,
-0.5752867460250854,
0.37866130471229553,
-1.0648949146270752,
0.04671473056077957,
1.2829105854034424,
-0.15129080414772034,
-0.1321997344493866,
0.20809558033943176,
-0.2721773386001587,
0.4134341776371002,
-0.19733835756778717,
0.6689493656158447,
0.3835192322731018,
-0.27664339542388916,
-0.032455924898386,
-0.5944347977638245,
0.5553444623947144,
-0.1849808692932129,
-0.8515118956565857,
-0.1924528330564499,
0.9602108001708984,
0.2758313715457916,
0.05694127455353737,
0.39925679564476013,
-0.10416620224714279,
0.3853594660758972,
-0.06750401854515076,
-0.039925072342157364,
0.0026349248364567757,
-0.5334169864654541,
-0.15630120038986206,
0.18283918499946594,
-0.030024299398064613,
-0.3486228585243225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15227v1 | A LLM-Based Ranking Method for the Evaluation of Automatic Counter-Narrative Generation | 2024-06-21T15:11:33 | 2024-06-21T15:11:33 | Irune Zubiaga, Aitor Soroa, Rodrigo Agerri | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of misinformation and harmful narratives in online
discourse has underscored the critical need for effective Counter Narrative
(CN) generation techniques. However, existing automatic evaluation methods
often lack interpretability and fail to capture the nuanced relationship
between generated CNs and human perception. Aiming to achieve a higher
correlation with human judgments, this paper proposes a novel approach to asses
generated CNs that consists on the use of a Large Language Model (LLM) as a
evaluator. By comparing generated CNs pairwise in a tournament-style format, we
establish a model ranking pipeline that achieves a correlation of $0.88$ with
human preference. As an additional contribution, we leverage LLMs as zero-shot
(ZS) CN generators and conduct a comparative analysis of chat, instruct, and
base models, exploring their respective strengths and limitations. Through
meticulous evaluation, including fine-tuning experiments, we elucidate the
differences in performance and responsiveness to domain-specific data. We
conclude that chat-aligned models in ZS are the best option for carrying out
the task, provided they do not refuse to generate an answer due to security
concerns. | [
-0.42993271350860596,
-0.8232606649398804,
0.4913453459739685,
-0.11534137278795242,
-0.3268568813800812,
0.3329497277736664,
-0.1660155951976776,
-0.503776490688324,
0.3599824905395508,
0.49394604563713074,
-0.44225674867630005,
-0.6550405025482178,
-0.7072955369949341,
0.06140054389834404,
-0.4526049494743347,
1.076086401939392,
0.2374885082244873,
-0.09801256656646729,
-0.13748489320278168,
-0.014481035061180592,
-0.6438733339309692,
-0.6159884929656982,
-0.6139791011810303,
-0.3476842939853668,
0.494293749332428,
0.17373177409172058,
0.7227554321289062,
0.5437716841697693,
0.41643980145454407,
0.2886835038661957,
0.3783298134803772,
0.31806680560112,
-0.9370018243789673,
0.2281799018383026,
-0.2808908522129059,
-0.41508984565734863,
-0.4764654338359833,
0.2828957736492157,
0.14874747395515442,
0.3504701852798462,
-0.02912229672074318,
0.49062246084213257,
-0.004496965557336807,
0.1898520290851593,
-0.7512515783309937,
-0.2176101803779602,
-1.0450513362884521,
-0.11417938768863678,
-0.10998345911502838,
-0.39796528220176697,
-0.6702321767807007,
-0.4027552902698517,
0.2320971041917801,
-0.36393049359321594,
0.22728848457336426,
0.19744132459163666,
0.7067388296127319,
0.04804142937064171,
-0.36612358689308167,
-0.28896191716194153,
-0.7965840697288513,
0.9001392126083374,
-0.8140580654144287,
0.025965170934796333,
0.21429726481437683,
0.4287799298763275,
0.004884243942797184,
-0.4346887171268463,
-0.5889411568641663,
-0.3568154573440552,
0.10129139572381973,
0.3837331533432007,
-0.6516934037208557,
-0.12291687726974487,
-0.06417739391326904,
0.015919072553515434,
-0.8639509081840515,
0.41295406222343445,
-0.09898543357849121,
-0.10138946026563644,
1.117003083229065,
0.5662267804145813,
0.5463017225265503,
-0.23770341277122498,
-0.4688696265220642,
0.04466850310564041,
-1.0317624807357788,
-0.19101983308792114,
0.603565514087677,
0.3535670042037964,
0.013603411614894867,
0.5356171131134033,
-0.2590329945087433,
0.7325279712677002,
0.23503166437149048,
-0.24194121360778809,
-0.1693573147058487,
-0.15950073301792145,
-0.1912759691476822,
0.14442279934883118,
1.1187516450881958,
1.0360902547836304,
0.4312710464000702,
-0.1656942069530487,
-0.0864483192563057,
0.5124277472496033,
0.6938103437423706,
-0.8879023194313049,
-0.0398082472383976,
-0.00657776091247797,
-0.48135873675346375,
-0.755609393119812,
-0.09453242272138596,
-0.860303521156311,
-0.46787258982658386,
-0.1301252841949463,
0.5291995406150818,
-0.18104149401187897,
-0.09673044085502625,
-0.24468037486076355,
-0.00204428075812757,
-0.11145668476819992,
0.17231011390686035,
-0.5685520768165588,
0.2609958350658417,
0.41509902477264404,
0.9461674094200134,
-0.5323126912117004,
0.03365357220172882,
-0.5442981123924255,
0.17118078470230103,
-0.7419595718383789,
0.9276830554008484,
-0.4546281695365906,
-0.4529552757740021,
0.10887309163808823,
-0.4349823296070099,
0.025289934128522873,
-0.5579758882522583,
0.3630008101463318,
-0.477433979511261,
0.23480728268623352,
0.03681085258722305,
-0.6013731956481934,
0.03342963382601738,
0.43761691451072693,
-0.4254715144634247,
0.745798647403717,
-0.09456717222929001,
-0.6837274432182312,
0.21238315105438232,
-0.4338645935058594,
-0.27644842863082886,
0.2631371021270752,
-0.20949265360832214,
-0.2981867790222168,
-0.08340801298618317,
0.2553952634334564,
0.3446139991283417,
-0.5059290528297424,
0.578351616859436,
-0.19445635378360748,
-0.5063059329986572,
0.19731098413467407,
-0.6563207507133484,
0.7530435919761658,
0.2098684310913086,
-0.5219056010246277,
0.21148014068603516,
-0.48251742124557495,
0.03592180088162422,
0.2540438175201416,
0.0058158268220722675,
-0.2069939821958542,
-0.060117289423942566,
-0.3861370086669922,
0.1880655437707901,
0.030820386484265327,
-0.5568843483924866,
0.09642334282398224,
-0.6649581789970398,
0.160897895693779,
0.6223529577255249,
0.2872776389122009,
0.13768790662288666,
-0.6446917653083801,
0.6993301510810852,
-0.14768512547016144,
0.062049392610788345,
-0.2439574897289276,
-0.6375500559806824,
-0.8018389344215393,
0.029641270637512207,
0.11633972823619843,
0.8053388595581055,
-0.9294037818908691,
0.44937199354171753,
-0.3432369530200958,
-0.941032886505127,
-0.5631501078605652,
-0.01177916955202818,
0.7631204128265381,
0.6283954977989197,
0.4642033874988556,
-0.3937556743621826,
-0.5692797899246216,
-0.8348986506462097,
-0.35044798254966736,
-0.4793102741241455,
-0.22712771594524384,
0.3288596272468567,
0.18515367805957794,
0.08828510344028473,
0.9754081964492798,
-0.6281516551971436,
-0.057559940963983536,
-0.48289406299591064,
0.5394075512886047,
-0.04963550716638565,
0.04311079531908035,
0.694762110710144,
-0.20498056709766388,
-0.6565795540809631,
-0.4623245596885681,
-0.8172928690910339,
-0.4251875579357147,
-0.1841830015182495,
-0.10949336737394333,
0.4568810760974884,
0.28757908940315247,
-0.49713441729545593,
0.7974925637245178,
0.3980760872364044,
-0.2791857421398163,
0.6944257616996765,
0.13329344987869263,
0.4587588310241699,
-0.8271967172622681,
0.02805311791598797,
0.005890685133635998,
-0.22274303436279297,
-0.8593189120292664,
0.12736305594444275,
-0.3225281834602356,
-0.06547115743160248,
-0.5942572355270386,
0.5644826889038086,
-0.1803966611623764,
0.05279896780848503,
-0.43634435534477234,
0.6605578064918518,
-0.0016434545395895839,
0.5340932607650757,
0.0523546002805233,
0.5036389827728271,
0.1613321304321289,
-0.47833001613616943,
0.5487436056137085,
0.19104860723018646,
-0.4874171316623688,
0.6808711886405945,
-0.6074215173721313,
0.24740298092365265,
0.06646611541509628,
0.3846215307712555,
-1.1729028224945068,
0.3171360194683075,
0.13780812919139862,
-0.6889069676399231,
0.1417190581560135,
-0.16737478971481323,
-0.4833051264286041,
-0.3437771797180176,
-0.454238623380661,
0.27536845207214355,
0.39939987659454346,
-0.32627809047698975,
0.2025652378797531,
0.5363641977310181,
-0.18178732693195343,
-0.46013298630714417,
-0.5582059621810913,
0.49739524722099304,
-0.36766317486763,
-0.6539967656135559,
0.3926364779472351,
-0.27362096309661865,
-0.5374177694320679,
-0.3841996192932129,
0.15638460218906403,
0.336631715297699,
-0.13475650548934937,
0.28931906819343567,
0.5752217173576355,
-0.27658191323280334,
-0.033819589763879776,
-0.1442052125930786,
-0.27983951568603516,
0.05342130362987518,
-0.0740165263414383,
0.5772775411605835,
0.17811502516269684,
-0.4245162010192871,
-0.2609802782535553,
0.3116285800933838,
0.2408306896686554,
-0.09519068896770477,
0.615774393081665,
0.2902592420578003,
-0.13888444006443024,
-0.18402916193008423,
-0.641241192817688,
-0.12983015179634094,
-0.4025590717792511,
0.205269455909729,
0.0035789564717561007,
-0.4789946377277374,
0.32574668526649475,
0.15145152807235718,
0.19876167178153992,
0.6229987740516663,
0.7443675994873047,
0.09549476951360703,
1.1955925226211548,
0.18602818250656128,
-0.18829737603664398,
0.13681600987911224,
-0.1359977126121521,
0.36633849143981934,
-0.37677234411239624,
0.06439241766929626,
-0.29191866517066956,
-0.29252713918685913,
-0.4745352864265442,
-0.16862626373767853,
0.4115915596485138,
-0.07599816471338272,
-0.3451070487499237,
0.44788166880607605,
-0.47027140855789185,
0.4250260889530182,
0.2831443250179291,
-0.06614575535058975,
0.5578081011772156,
-0.2905762493610382,
-0.25211837887763977,
-0.10789747536182404,
-0.7922337055206299,
-0.8588660359382629,
1.224800705909729,
0.10257729887962341,
0.4122229218482971,
0.30699872970581055,
0.5279347896575928,
0.5260297656059265,
0.5972163677215576,
-0.5959497094154358,
0.6742225885391235,
-0.15724311769008636,
-0.48515960574150085,
-0.4177588224411011,
-0.3210010826587677,
-1.0100964307785034,
0.36467796564102173,
-0.6105595231056213,
-0.9254888296127319,
-0.2953002154827118,
-0.0786638855934143,
-0.7470043301582336,
0.43416544795036316,
-0.6578843593597412,
0.6305893063545227,
-0.3185449242591858,
-0.3494802415370941,
-0.3388781249523163,
-0.5684177279472351,
0.5981279611587524,
-0.01246644463390112,
0.1829935610294342,
-0.06453416496515274,
0.17723362147808075,
0.6583378314971924,
-0.3240258991718292,
1.0321929454803467,
0.012622918002307415,
-0.1334645301103592,
0.6401574015617371,
0.5453547239303589,
0.27028128504753113,
-0.08116205781698227,
-0.21476638317108154,
0.4188518524169922,
-0.21287843585014343,
0.0796440914273262,
-0.5125116109848022,
0.8133244514465332,
-0.7208662033081055,
-0.8429113030433655,
-0.18327583372592926,
-0.4642081558704376,
-0.3137868046760559,
0.13590365648269653,
0.4587897062301636,
0.4984220266342163,
-0.6195762753486633,
-0.02082751877605915,
0.38839370012283325,
-0.6852495074272156,
0.4925447702407837,
0.6783236861228943,
-0.4430989921092987,
-0.269734650850296,
0.9285163879394531,
0.3813503086566925,
0.41885364055633545,
0.3292514979839325,
0.17097041010856628,
-0.10805926471948624,
-0.5606024861335754,
-0.7617825269699097,
-0.07818406075239182,
-0.3878976106643677,
-0.707647979259491,
-0.6446183919906616,
-0.599166214466095,
-0.3354280889034271,
-0.32621243596076965,
-0.2376323640346527,
-0.3225995898246765,
-0.08018156886100769,
-0.33897241950035095,
0.18550477921962738,
0.836442768573761,
0.03960797190666199,
0.47176817059516907,
-0.6222944855690002,
0.569466233253479,
0.319570392370224,
0.22307586669921875,
0.2912467122077942,
-0.7203015685081482,
-0.16397257149219513,
0.11556978523731232,
-0.6932665705680847,
-0.9899659156799316,
0.7980620265007019,
-0.21543556451797485,
0.7184731960296631,
0.5213325619697571,
0.3547121286392212,
0.6824198365211487,
-0.4978576898574829,
0.9181684851646423,
0.30932074785232544,
-0.8173577785491943,
0.5478533506393433,
-0.4574291706085205,
0.33978819847106934,
0.27787742018699646,
0.415373831987381,
-0.4302692711353302,
-0.8360748291015625,
-0.7492021918296814,
-0.8922398090362549,
0.6602074503898621,
0.39489197731018066,
0.22004233300685883,
-0.2910470962524414,
-0.21094155311584473,
0.15540263056755066,
0.11051806807518005,
-0.5620362162590027,
-0.35710883140563965,
-0.26690781116485596,
-0.11034753918647766,
0.01801416091620922,
-0.19934959709644318,
-0.06256487220525742,
0.16378673911094666,
0.6676490306854248,
0.0026892167516052723,
0.030339349061250687,
-0.13550712168216705,
-0.21498732268810272,
-0.4962513744831085,
0.07518415153026581,
0.38434192538261414,
0.7434343099594116,
-0.182356595993042,
0.17366139590740204,
0.3607892096042633,
-0.18066519498825073,
-0.11200990527868271,
-0.27660658955574036,
-0.4805290102958679,
0.04325449466705322,
0.5990808606147766,
0.7131759524345398,
0.2823176681995392,
-0.7430532574653625,
0.7289345264434814,
0.006280708592385054,
-0.1570092886686325,
-0.10542593896389008,
0.18421652913093567,
0.1589984893798828,
0.12433792650699615,
0.3621518015861511,
-0.14280018210411072,
-0.007373131345957518,
-0.6136962175369263,
0.23183652758598328,
0.5413506031036377,
-0.13897337019443512,
-0.15974320471286774,
0.5381300449371338,
0.4179550111293793,
-0.522117555141449,
0.5100254416465759,
-0.1262359619140625,
-0.3997381627559662,
0.5626237392425537,
0.5984324812889099,
0.7601104378700256,
-0.36878278851509094,
0.45947813987731934,
0.6966582536697388,
0.2955709397792816,
0.28889912366867065,
-0.22963181138038635,
0.267264723777771,
-0.7427448034286499,
-0.2875237762928009,
-0.48555678129196167,
-0.3186534643173218,
0.34577807784080505,
-0.3886844515800476,
0.4809620976448059,
-0.3221816420555115,
-0.2875107526779175,
0.06921900808811188,
0.09029274433851242,
-0.5312442779541016,
0.2407274693250656,
0.39688920974731445,
0.5570980310440063,
-0.7366064786911011,
0.5322561860084534,
-0.0743708536028862,
-0.5693141222000122,
-0.41997992992401123,
0.06322848796844482,
0.3182654082775116,
-0.7874176502227783,
0.4390415847301483,
0.10903950035572052,
-0.42658093571662903,
-0.15539075434207916,
-0.5400413870811462,
-0.797800600528717,
1.1015584468841553,
0.44753792881965637,
-0.7112487554550171,
0.12403111159801483,
0.33180588483810425,
0.8743749260902405,
-0.7946867346763611,
0.7877646088600159,
0.2701387107372284,
0.21285420656204224,
0.1823919415473938,
-1.0226404666900635,
0.008729539811611176,
-0.11824742704629898,
-0.05906348302960396,
-0.08075333386659622,
-0.6994975209236145,
0.4538070857524872,
-0.16139139235019684,
-0.4318233132362366,
0.135450541973114,
0.35803404450416565,
0.4993118643760681,
0.45637646317481995,
0.5452428460121155,
0.3475472033023834,
0.3823991119861603,
0.28047269582748413,
0.8688262104988098,
-0.4189739525318146,
0.006343315355479717,
1.3159213066101074,
-0.38405799865722656,
0.921790361404419,
-0.06370408087968826,
-0.03921389579772949,
0.7029269933700562,
0.3086024522781372,
-0.13146214187145233,
0.2840414047241211,
0.4493715167045593,
0.08703348785638809,
-0.4747227132320404,
-0.22671030461788177,
-0.10725077986717224,
0.7994135022163391,
0.14951780438423157,
-0.3978097438812256,
-0.41617467999458313,
-0.346867173910141,
0.04358818754553795,
0.41641855239868164,
-0.23453934490680695,
0.9961758255958557,
0.06450839340686798,
-0.9838266968727112,
0.5976520776748657,
0.14480386674404144,
0.6580449938774109,
-0.4386841654777527,
-0.12053283303976059,
-0.08983208984136581,
-0.25118374824523926,
-0.011176051571965218,
-0.7261992692947388,
0.46497032046318054,
0.5687758922576904,
0.025366710498929024,
-0.20803995430469513,
0.8356049060821533,
-0.30936741828918457,
-0.5658498406410217,
0.4647592306137085,
0.7661457061767578,
0.2471863180398941,
0.009058100171387196,
-0.47708261013031006,
-0.13774003088474274,
-0.10235938429832458,
-0.1346590518951416,
0.470065176486969,
0.11291871964931488,
-0.3953341841697693,
0.5785908699035645,
0.6956334710121155,
-0.03323540836572647,
-0.2800609767436981,
0.2816305160522461,
0.6430742144584656,
-0.619002103805542,
-0.5327187180519104,
-1.0801726579666138,
0.34541863203048706,
-0.14723357558250427,
-0.25711703300476074,
0.7646049857139587,
0.6224451661109924,
0.7223206162452698,
0.2851054072380066,
0.9740591645240784,
0.2409372478723526,
0.7522377967834473,
-0.26150912046432495,
0.9748520851135254,
-0.19806714355945587,
0.43894410133361816,
-0.436259388923645,
-0.7561249136924744,
-0.14135651290416718,
0.2854517102241516,
-0.4635295867919922,
-0.08927756547927856,
0.352939635515213,
0.8170127868652344,
0.2006780058145523,
-0.012837114743888378,
0.6418783068656921,
0.26674237847328186,
0.13840681314468384,
0.5433249473571777,
0.9340015649795532,
-0.30405229330062866,
0.8132481575012207,
0.2604641318321228,
-0.29433003067970276,
-0.21900397539138794,
-0.9380102753639221,
-1.0711954832077026,
-0.2749217450618744,
-0.18657994270324707,
-0.10428225249052048,
0.1252327412366867,
0.8012504577636719,
0.6470403671264648,
-0.7251192927360535,
-0.30406150221824646,
0.3033396303653717,
0.04518933966755867,
0.008955799974501133,
-0.25009870529174805,
0.11374415457248688,
-0.06339974701404572,
-0.6483429670333862,
0.4981941878795624,
0.29875296354293823,
-0.2767940163612366,
-0.555183470249176,
-0.09832311421632767,
-0.38552361726760864,
0.6730290055274963,
0.7700706720352173,
-0.14303897321224213,
-0.896315336227417,
-0.25742459297180176,
-0.04987114295363426,
-0.1806103140115738,
0.02556069940328598,
0.774573802947998,
-1.0777183771133423,
0.5004637837409973,
0.42105868458747864,
0.3553505539894104,
0.3946262300014496,
0.17184239625930786,
0.8408384323120117,
-0.6877659559249878,
-0.3773341178894043,
0.15727415680885315,
0.09232575446367264,
0.36467233300209045,
-0.4327639043331146,
0.5731074810028076,
0.10368400067090988,
-0.3967188596725464,
-0.7156528234481812,
0.26524239778518677,
-0.7011751532554626,
-0.44802314043045044,
1.1844145059585571,
-0.23500482738018036,
0.20358578860759735,
-0.29345619678497314,
-0.20336170494556427,
0.5391010046005249,
-0.42185088992118835,
1.25859797000885,
0.5678175091743469,
-0.2376449853181839,
0.07357612252235413,
-0.4549188017845154,
0.20535483956336975,
0.1812664419412613,
-0.7713029384613037,
0.06462369114160538,
0.48194488883018494,
0.016365885734558105,
0.3388778865337372,
0.5898904800415039,
-0.02151789329946041,
-0.11236883699893951,
0.055179037153720856,
-0.07109896093606949,
-0.08090029656887054,
-0.27282604575157166,
0.04966146871447563,
0.19327503442764282,
-0.25960609316825867,
0.10272595286369324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15214v1 | Unsupervised Extraction of Dialogue Policies from Conversations | 2024-06-21T14:57:25 | 2024-06-21T14:57:25 | Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Traian Rebedea, Christopher Parisien | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue policies play a crucial role in developing task-oriented dialogue
systems, yet their development and maintenance are challenging and typically
require substantial effort from experts in dialogue modeling. While in many
situations, large amounts of conversational data are available for the task at
hand, people lack an effective solution able to extract dialogue policies from
this data. In this paper, we address this gap by first illustrating how Large
Language Models (LLMs) can be instrumental in extracting dialogue policies from
datasets, through the conversion of conversations into a unified intermediate
representation consisting of canonical forms. We then propose a novel method
for generating dialogue policies utilizing a controllable and interpretable
graph-based methodology. By combining canonical forms across conversations into
a flow network, we find that running graph traversal algorithms helps in
extracting dialogue flows. These flows are a better representation of the
underlying interactions than flows extracted by prompting LLMs. Our technique
focuses on giving conversation designers greater control, offering a
productivity tool to improve the process of developing dialogue policies. | [
-0.2944214642047882,
-0.6324493885040283,
0.5919758081436157,
0.1328454166650772,
-0.2375728040933609,
0.5216192603111267,
-0.36815837025642395,
-0.12271295487880707,
0.4054970443248749,
1.3555307388305664,
-0.7481011152267456,
-0.4213886559009552,
-0.5908198356628418,
-0.16074687242507935,
-0.1929304152727127,
1.0562233924865723,
0.006816369015723467,
-0.0383424274623394,
-0.11102928221225739,
0.09648451209068298,
-0.3323034346103668,
-0.26113250851631165,
-0.6282978653907776,
-0.6845886707305908,
0.470066636800766,
0.294585257768631,
0.8585833311080933,
0.1703626960515976,
0.10116070508956909,
0.37724682688713074,
-0.25337088108062744,
0.5803178548812866,
-0.5827397704124451,
0.33185628056526184,
-0.22057165205478668,
-0.1489356905221939,
-0.31553247570991516,
-0.03670055419206619,
0.8175457715988159,
0.8611403703689575,
-0.29058316349983215,
-0.336889386177063,
0.4782674014568329,
0.34093642234802246,
-0.1976209282875061,
0.7699905037879944,
-0.5271715521812439,
-0.08208245038986206,
0.010232917033135891,
-0.43225425481796265,
-0.6443939805030823,
-0.41530871391296387,
0.20004700124263763,
-0.4491041302680969,
-0.31138211488723755,
-0.24689041078090668,
0.7041476368904114,
-0.13557638227939606,
-0.4401668608188629,
-0.4171271026134491,
-1.043139100074768,
0.536190390586853,
-0.7670421600341797,
0.26065999269485474,
0.22319409251213074,
0.17977161705493927,
-0.6758366823196411,
-0.8850589990615845,
-0.4455704092979431,
-0.14707694947719574,
-0.27820003032684326,
0.06419207155704498,
-0.6192508339881897,
0.502823531627655,
0.19332434237003326,
0.045598406344652176,
-0.17046234011650085,
0.2677067518234253,
-0.41015496850013733,
-0.35124677419662476,
0.6097334623336792,
0.3593691289424896,
0.22039473056793213,
-0.4256058931350708,
0.02306460030376911,
-0.041861750185489655,
-0.7794676423072815,
0.14515835046768188,
0.38445624709129333,
0.5141522288322449,
0.009624074213206768,
0.45171526074409485,
-0.42687007784843445,
0.48530489206314087,
-0.07067414373159409,
-0.2949296236038208,
-0.03829033300280571,
-0.24943053722381592,
-0.11009040474891663,
-0.26746612787246704,
1.088971495628357,
0.32315996289253235,
0.4306578040122986,
-0.2806342840194702,
0.00922833476215601,
-0.4678802192211151,
0.10173708200454712,
-0.8786373138427734,
-0.2605811655521393,
0.03210706263780594,
-0.27768024802207947,
-0.4646083116531372,
-0.032914623618125916,
-0.8205363750457764,
-0.3789333701133728,
-0.49983951449394226,
-0.26357361674308777,
0.026013774797320366,
-0.3361014723777771,
-0.1864955872297287,
-0.03877733647823334,
0.01297012809664011,
0.44839003682136536,
-0.7082659602165222,
0.45472633838653564,
0.7457776665687561,
0.7070194482803345,
-0.3186396360397339,
0.31366685032844543,
-0.5252426862716675,
0.18742334842681885,
-0.6396216750144958,
0.5336427688598633,
-0.9280688762664795,
-0.754082441329956,
0.2646801769733429,
0.3161819577217102,
-0.03928138315677643,
-0.456817626953125,
0.1292102336883545,
-0.5413280725479126,
0.15385307371616364,
0.1332433968782425,
-0.34395983815193176,
-0.04986364766955376,
0.014062222093343735,
-0.6621139049530029,
0.6764897704124451,
0.10809573531150818,
-0.3877063989639282,
-0.08327393978834152,
-0.8517814874649048,
-0.2861705422401428,
0.19607296586036682,
-0.5714720487594604,
-0.1929488480091095,
-0.09661567956209183,
0.28599828481674194,
0.5142529606819153,
-0.3664780259132385,
0.807678759098053,
-0.4811607003211975,
0.22025145590305328,
0.40420451760292053,
-0.74184250831604,
1.0063700675964355,
0.2406979650259018,
-0.09782949835062027,
0.22839327156543732,
-0.4952992796897888,
0.18129251897335052,
-0.09844109416007996,
-0.23992787301540375,
-0.05596790462732315,
0.2196795493364334,
-0.30203551054000854,
0.22789309918880463,
0.06105179712176323,
-0.5989348888397217,
0.405391126871109,
-0.3179381191730499,
0.6147109270095825,
1.0246140956878662,
0.3080224394798279,
0.5987282991409302,
0.06697140634059906,
0.6455952525138855,
-0.1676456183195114,
-0.009121191687881947,
-0.1205429881811142,
-0.45522743463516235,
-0.6816956996917725,
-0.42274460196495056,
0.1033228412270546,
0.47972849011421204,
-0.9242554306983948,
0.5028114914894104,
-0.40997371077537537,
-0.2958989143371582,
-0.060723934322595596,
0.37099266052246094,
0.4109422564506531,
0.3245104253292084,
-0.2848716676235199,
-0.39502766728401184,
-0.2782308757305145,
-0.6308950781822205,
0.05344962701201439,
-0.461923211812973,
-0.05909789353609085,
0.5789624452590942,
0.2418377548456192,
-0.13044124841690063,
1.2614201307296753,
-0.9090328216552734,
0.08069781959056854,
-0.623329222202301,
0.25532078742980957,
0.16599825024604797,
0.4013500511646271,
0.04292038083076477,
-0.3824416995048523,
-0.24005134403705597,
0.16880959272384644,
-0.8480725288391113,
-0.35070911049842834,
-0.21519498527050018,
-0.45532485842704773,
0.09936026483774185,
0.7676899433135986,
-0.6228708624839783,
0.5091767311096191,
0.37383514642715454,
-0.021377118304371834,
0.46096211671829224,
-0.10996502637863159,
-0.2724778652191162,
-1.036576509475708,
-0.12719082832336426,
-0.12167242169380188,
-0.6161132454872131,
-0.6403450965881348,
-0.15019570291042328,
-0.38624435663223267,
-0.49756449460983276,
-0.24187885224819183,
0.25062432885169983,
-0.4158658981323242,
-0.13824348151683807,
-0.136310875415802,
-0.050345372408628464,
0.170840322971344,
0.8310030698776245,
0.23384647071361542,
0.5382273197174072,
0.530440092086792,
-0.48219382762908936,
0.5359437465667725,
0.5138439536094666,
-0.20528000593185425,
0.35813212394714355,
-0.6745944619178772,
0.304617702960968,
-0.09024839103221893,
0.7894935011863708,
-0.9060568809509277,
-0.14411823451519012,
0.45828235149383545,
-0.01459136139601469,
0.32999399304389954,
-0.484043151140213,
-0.5063288807868958,
-0.4421459138393402,
0.20650485157966614,
-0.16022661328315735,
0.4192900061607361,
-0.43095657229423523,
0.7433876395225525,
0.9473479986190796,
-0.7423319220542908,
-0.08427141606807709,
-0.10644275695085526,
0.05644333362579346,
-0.1978621482849121,
-0.4609878957271576,
0.03862033039331436,
0.012126668356359005,
-0.19100159406661987,
-0.2638324499130249,
-0.00890673790127039,
-0.20418983697891235,
-0.017580373212695122,
0.4754335284233093,
0.3414247930049896,
0.07644191384315491,
0.03502120450139046,
0.27845054864883423,
-0.20239783823490143,
0.2794424295425415,
-0.4082963168621063,
0.6801679134368896,
0.2028714418411255,
-0.4283091723918915,
-0.833154559135437,
0.6327531337738037,
0.8102232813835144,
-0.1699213832616806,
0.15897123515605927,
0.14673273265361786,
-0.09005418419837952,
-0.14556239545345306,
-0.33442223072052,
-0.23653684556484222,
-0.5273815989494324,
0.29467570781707764,
-0.21531331539154053,
-0.9617878198623657,
0.5117060542106628,
-0.7179728150367737,
0.3347156047821045,
0.061864305287599564,
0.3549140393733978,
-0.09694736450910568,
1.247838020324707,
0.7462318539619446,
-0.19765044748783112,
0.6161296963691711,
-0.2959483563899994,
0.19036996364593506,
-0.6632518768310547,
-0.481535941362381,
-0.46764418482780457,
0.04659435153007507,
-0.6004005074501038,
-0.39493152499198914,
0.4040714502334595,
0.1209995448589325,
-0.030977442860603333,
0.3518746793270111,
-0.28407028317451477,
0.3222638964653015,
0.42489174008369446,
0.10164250433444977,
0.3124789893627167,
0.306628942489624,
-0.07195864617824554,
0.09549965709447861,
-0.5708923935890198,
-0.6110705733299255,
0.9122280478477478,
0.3974429666996002,
0.9452733397483826,
-0.031608231365680695,
0.7176531553268433,
0.20480746030807495,
0.10118549317121506,
-0.7716227173805237,
0.7229068875312805,
-0.08465076982975006,
0.005944950506091118,
-0.5770959258079529,
-0.5836232304573059,
-1.216665506362915,
0.4137156307697296,
-0.04642493650317192,
-1.3128525018692017,
0.19712495803833008,
-0.0075151738710701466,
-0.21923941373825073,
0.25581908226013184,
-0.5401291251182556,
0.6744289398193359,
0.13323894143104553,
0.04962131008505821,
-0.10616282373666763,
-0.4295491874217987,
0.14173097908496857,
0.007921965792775154,
0.11976198852062225,
-0.25383874773979187,
0.6690360903739929,
0.8795455098152161,
-0.9515109062194824,
1.2498871088027954,
-0.18849250674247742,
-0.36640647053718567,
0.6871761083602905,
0.2450684756040573,
0.8558824062347412,
-0.033258456736803055,
0.36730334162712097,
0.2235444039106369,
0.0072015514597296715,
-0.12081269919872284,
-0.815676212310791,
0.5443528294563293,
-0.6055529713630676,
-0.7012246251106262,
0.11726059019565582,
-0.6001647114753723,
-0.3506962060928345,
0.22440586984157562,
-0.10586697608232498,
0.8764103651046753,
-0.41583001613616943,
0.08160742372274399,
0.42707979679107666,
-0.08987576514482498,
0.549403190612793,
0.6487664580345154,
-0.5026965141296387,
-0.15740986168384552,
1.0417249202728271,
0.1676204651594162,
0.49520719051361084,
0.10481876134872437,
0.36785751581192017,
-0.4534805417060852,
-0.21872474253177643,
-0.4095325469970703,
0.07645321637392044,
-0.5742999315261841,
-0.09633695334196091,
-0.6589714884757996,
-0.33749809861183167,
-0.6650357246398926,
0.16903270781040192,
-0.25435611605644226,
-0.5356479287147522,
-0.3114835321903229,
-0.11613616347312927,
0.48611971735954285,
0.8788838386535645,
-0.19420939683914185,
0.5627283453941345,
-0.5365700125694275,
0.09453997015953064,
0.501227080821991,
0.1077926978468895,
-0.15964850783348083,
-0.3013794422149658,
0.2671795189380646,
0.19585342705249786,
-0.6495120525360107,
-0.7907431721687317,
0.5299265384674072,
0.0878765732049942,
0.5153771638870239,
0.6656062602996826,
0.0644112229347229,
0.7343300580978394,
-0.6453968286514282,
0.616745114326477,
0.4191744029521942,
-0.7305118441581726,
0.5360398888587952,
-0.2624540328979492,
0.05482855066657066,
0.3168971836566925,
0.006994771305471659,
-0.6055923700332642,
-0.6554417610168457,
-0.6371508836746216,
-0.7186829447746277,
0.9048511385917664,
0.2845846116542816,
0.4168851375579834,
0.07201170176267624,
-0.15776269137859344,
-0.09868898242712021,
0.22693072259426117,
-0.194954976439476,
-0.08343232423067093,
-0.029649939388036728,
0.040865570306777954,
-0.0653151348233223,
-0.0919707790017128,
-0.3888731002807617,
-0.12917833030223846,
0.35748347640037537,
-0.26920759677886963,
0.25892582535743713,
-0.12045272439718246,
0.07725531607866287,
0.054656632244586945,
0.37078526616096497,
0.38820430636405945,
0.6133395433425903,
0.06325303018093109,
-0.047711849212646484,
-0.17088375985622406,
-0.17757374048233032,
-0.2027987688779831,
0.12926647067070007,
-0.19778019189834595,
0.2521407902240753,
0.11823061853647232,
0.8837680816650391,
0.22780516743659973,
-0.5346184968948364,
0.5630810260772705,
0.11258510500192642,
-0.05125834420323372,
-0.36608603596687317,
-0.05759115144610405,
-0.04734872281551361,
0.41973111033439636,
0.0029442994855344296,
-0.2272915095090866,
0.15886259078979492,
-0.6478675007820129,
0.3461724817752838,
0.6642946600914001,
-0.6224235892295837,
-0.25112098455429077,
0.23195835947990417,
0.5967898368835449,
-0.4172603189945221,
0.6951271891593933,
-0.05234221741557121,
-0.4514384865760803,
0.28664085268974304,
0.5640743970870972,
0.818702757358551,
0.05163386091589928,
0.8568644523620605,
0.02345253713428974,
-0.09448857605457306,
0.21416035294532776,
-0.023145053535699844,
-0.22868573665618896,
-0.8508666157722473,
-0.6096312999725342,
-0.2941194772720337,
-0.601936399936676,
0.26279163360595703,
-0.7290210723876953,
-0.09747160226106644,
-0.39566823840141296,
-0.08367752283811569,
0.1452864557504654,
-0.2685907781124115,
-0.6128715872764587,
-0.3506683111190796,
0.12619246542453766,
0.4184684157371521,
-0.8675506711006165,
0.644307017326355,
-0.026788122951984406,
-0.3245261609554291,
-0.9269736409187317,
-0.32622286677360535,
0.015101819299161434,
-0.9379756450653076,
0.5047140717506409,
-0.19706308841705322,
-0.17519378662109375,
-0.1543540358543396,
-0.8778586387634277,
-0.602867603302002,
0.7104321122169495,
0.3874596953392029,
-0.5961533188819885,
-0.2796279489994049,
0.3006483018398285,
0.3734355568885803,
-0.5642279386520386,
0.25531354546546936,
0.6630433201789856,
0.2798636257648468,
0.4781673848628998,
-0.977429211139679,
0.004742782562971115,
-0.12244927138090134,
0.06551852822303772,
0.3895454704761505,
-0.3483740985393524,
0.3859815001487732,
0.10852226614952087,
-0.323482483625412,
-0.006036701146513224,
0.6372433304786682,
0.08108765631914139,
0.10049819201231003,
0.5661185383796692,
-0.014172671362757683,
0.9521210193634033,
-0.09580793976783752,
0.9660952091217041,
-0.26286280155181885,
0.13105294108390808,
1.1025714874267578,
-0.3167541027069092,
0.613825261592865,
0.3993617296218872,
0.04785146191716194,
0.7573060393333435,
0.38010233640670776,
0.3884482681751251,
0.43488219380378723,
0.3294801115989685,
-0.2752201557159424,
-0.5004224181175232,
-0.41063621640205383,
0.0664457306265831,
0.6485806703567505,
0.6420217156410217,
-0.42316704988479614,
-0.43336227536201477,
0.024554595351219177,
0.4837022125720978,
-0.1320069432258606,
-0.34846606850624084,
1.2091491222381592,
0.15186859667301178,
-0.9591608643531799,
0.46860775351524353,
-0.29718253016471863,
0.022982720285654068,
-0.5570170283317566,
-0.3316164016723633,
-0.038845840841531754,
-0.11387336999177933,
-0.024105163291096687,
-0.9783278107643127,
0.09975114464759827,
0.03639357537031174,
0.16486626863479614,
-0.6454786658287048,
0.7216559052467346,
-0.7434055209159851,
-0.4687662720680237,
0.08243029564619064,
0.49425235390663147,
0.5506907105445862,
0.037725549191236496,
-0.6859204173088074,
0.04903562366962433,
0.3333127498626709,
-0.008371305651962757,
0.06573425233364105,
0.429458886384964,
-0.4265052080154419,
0.6432357430458069,
0.7668696641921997,
0.18349190056324005,
-0.16473667323589325,
0.2553653120994568,
1.2999900579452515,
-0.3443208634853363,
-0.5134270787239075,
-0.5729199647903442,
0.5041881799697876,
-0.5217103958129883,
-0.13105075061321259,
0.2538997530937195,
0.25253263115882874,
0.4795144498348236,
0.36492812633514404,
0.9381363391876221,
0.13339583575725555,
0.3877917528152466,
-0.6212151646614075,
0.5883643627166748,
-0.030490459874272346,
0.1789788007736206,
-0.4175567626953125,
-0.6883144378662109,
0.057843439280986786,
0.5923874378204346,
-0.23606742918491364,
-0.377559632062912,
0.4263921082019806,
0.9831706881523132,
0.05352690815925598,
0.11462956666946411,
0.19828756153583527,
0.11067889630794525,
0.8968358635902405,
0.3193809688091278,
0.7754039168357849,
0.15620841085910797,
0.7118786573410034,
-0.08093003183603287,
-0.28973472118377686,
0.044922392815351486,
-0.6587600708007812,
-0.9052795171737671,
-0.5818808078765869,
-0.40361976623535156,
-0.516988217830658,
-0.11988453567028046,
0.7210698127746582,
0.8156819343566895,
-0.6520344614982605,
-0.3497377336025238,
-0.25078973174095154,
0.42546629905700684,
0.022154856473207474,
-0.22943264245986938,
0.28879448771476746,
-0.31085312366485596,
-0.8796245455741882,
0.5571674704551697,
0.2990471422672272,
-0.02470235899090767,
-0.38705259561538696,
-0.22923557460308075,
0.33427995443344116,
0.25017547607421875,
0.6439067125320435,
0.5636975169181824,
-0.8208163380622864,
-0.4101032018661499,
-0.5115787982940674,
-0.05824052542448044,
0.03642594441771507,
1.1911691427230835,
-0.515997588634491,
0.826140284538269,
0.5014647245407104,
0.4134869873523712,
0.6953656673431396,
-0.04701627790927887,
0.9334278106689453,
-0.6685184240341187,
0.01667145825922489,
0.11327767372131348,
0.35227489471435547,
0.08322763442993164,
-0.10672421753406525,
0.2739580571651459,
0.060582056641578674,
-0.38203322887420654,
-0.8398478031158447,
0.6592093110084534,
-1.0804523229599,
-0.08780837059020996,
1.4437350034713745,
-0.37875646352767944,
-0.06883633881807327,
-0.38472244143486023,
-0.515060544013977,
0.17174752056598663,
-0.7094594240188599,
0.16712172329425812,
0.3884276747703552,
-0.2571207284927368,
-0.11100403219461441,
-0.32741355895996094,
0.4185071587562561,
-0.0839647650718689,
-0.8385906219482422,
0.4470165967941284,
0.5728175044059753,
0.14910666644573212,
0.24401473999023438,
1.134577751159668,
-0.2935197055339813,
-0.41385477781295776,
-0.41022437810897827,
-0.15077868103981018,
0.19216211140155792,
-0.50662761926651,
-0.04975258931517601,
0.05864134058356285,
-0.1884322166442871,
-0.22706669569015503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15211v1 | How Effective is GPT-4 Turbo in Generating School-Level Questions from Textbooks Based on Bloom's Revised Taxonomy? | 2024-06-21T14:52:37 | 2024-06-21T14:52:37 | Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We evaluate the effectiveness of GPT-4 Turbo in generating educational
questions from NCERT textbooks in zero-shot mode. Our study highlights GPT-4
Turbo's ability to generate questions that require higher-order thinking
skills, especially at the "understanding" level according to Bloom's Revised
Taxonomy. While we find a notable consistency between questions generated by
GPT-4 Turbo and those assessed by humans in terms of complexity, there are
occasional differences. Our evaluation also uncovers variations in how humans
and machines evaluate question quality, with a trend inversely related to
Bloom's Revised Taxonomy levels. These findings suggest that while GPT-4 Turbo
is a promising tool for educational question generation, its efficacy varies
across different cognitive levels, indicating a need for further refinement to
fully meet educational standards. | [
-0.5474286079406738,
-0.9842044115066528,
0.6029252409934998,
-0.1806526631116867,
-0.12786339223384857,
0.16412697732448578,
-0.23553910851478577,
-0.34034669399261475,
-0.16632351279258728,
-0.0889386236667633,
-0.444189190864563,
-0.19107773900032043,
-0.19092026352882385,
0.3925517499446869,
-0.5048024654388428,
1.2620223760604858,
0.19695302844047546,
-0.23241020739078522,
-0.390860915184021,
0.46553555130958557,
-0.5006623864173889,
-0.5640618801116943,
-0.7962920665740967,
-0.1828296184539795,
0.6783798933029175,
0.5361877679824829,
0.43783774971961975,
0.11258506029844284,
0.6258503794670105,
0.19774110615253448,
-0.17495234310626984,
-0.3551929295063019,
-0.6846206188201904,
0.42439955472946167,
-0.16839924454689026,
-0.43148934841156006,
-0.3919430077075958,
-0.18287797272205353,
0.9800202250480652,
0.3034477233886719,
-0.21122173964977264,
0.1086786538362503,
0.15760675072669983,
0.3650422692298889,
-0.7623538374900818,
-0.13237012922763824,
-0.8655555248260498,
0.07908132672309875,
-0.22372038662433624,
-0.24117133021354675,
-0.09444564580917358,
-0.2921426296234131,
0.25328120589256287,
-0.7571447491645813,
0.7655547261238098,
-0.5844700336456299,
1.1008306741714478,
0.2743312418460846,
-0.26444992423057556,
-0.2719525098800659,
-0.9461410045623779,
0.48726555705070496,
-0.6673171520233154,
0.3334549367427826,
0.29402655363082886,
0.48201245069503784,
-0.026395834982395172,
-0.8650944232940674,
-0.6973362565040588,
0.07074019312858582,
0.3658877909183502,
0.6912265419960022,
0.08932862430810928,
-0.17897123098373413,
0.521917998790741,
0.6549347043037415,
-0.7601405382156372,
-0.23709701001644135,
-0.692420482635498,
-0.2957722544670105,
0.35865798592567444,
0.25280842185020447,
0.26047736406326294,
-0.33081310987472534,
-0.2639405131340027,
-0.24938690662384033,
-0.6036732792854309,
0.1666136533021927,
0.3587695062160492,
0.28005319833755493,
0.6411469578742981,
0.13423456251621246,
-0.2488202005624771,
0.7409133315086365,
0.011695286259055138,
-0.1016131043434143,
0.09305921196937561,
-0.7904953360557556,
-0.11762652546167374,
-0.13738669455051422,
0.4718379080295563,
0.48305705189704895,
0.09489563852548599,
-0.03082827292382717,
-0.15328054130077362,
-0.09060464799404144,
0.5621607303619385,
-1.0865130424499512,
-0.04366590455174446,
0.07878619432449341,
0.5285111665725708,
-0.2121240496635437,
0.10879741609096527,
-0.9562847018241882,
0.23100991547107697,
-0.03586537763476372,
0.5028789043426514,
-0.6569460034370422,
-0.3306468725204468,
0.16875869035720825,
-0.4102817177772522,
0.6445655226707458,
0.6050965785980225,
-1.1044635772705078,
0.15093640983104706,
0.7301859855651855,
0.8036396503448486,
-0.12254215776920319,
-0.20327524840831757,
-0.012704730033874512,
0.10551558434963226,
-0.33173707127571106,
1.147592306137085,
-0.4923509657382965,
-0.5614922046661377,
-0.19174824655056,
-0.2582325339317322,
-0.2538992166519165,
-0.4519832730293274,
0.3907994329929352,
-0.6547038555145264,
0.35264450311660767,
-0.796367883682251,
-0.6360449194908142,
-0.22405704855918884,
0.858347475528717,
-0.1905684918165207,
1.132988691329956,
0.2547074258327484,
-0.49148619174957275,
0.6330633759498596,
-0.377770334482193,
-0.23617956042289734,
0.7315916419029236,
-0.34772828221321106,
-0.1947483867406845,
-0.31858810782432556,
0.09786560386419296,
0.07737066596746445,
-0.29655879735946655,
0.07045596837997437,
0.23081976175308228,
-0.5255115628242493,
-0.33566775918006897,
-0.5690970420837402,
0.7107727527618408,
0.06869931519031525,
-0.6787445545196533,
-0.3289579153060913,
-0.24069398641586304,
0.527403712272644,
0.1559925675392151,
-0.27668997645378113,
-0.16226190328598022,
-0.2980181574821472,
-0.3790387809276581,
-0.002777585294097662,
0.33286359906196594,
-0.594001054763794,
0.3762156367301941,
-0.3506617546081543,
0.3219227194786072,
0.38937875628471375,
0.6947028636932373,
0.2122645229101181,
-0.33747127652168274,
0.9277359843254089,
-0.28941696882247925,
0.22960220277309418,
-0.09069094061851501,
-1.1396660804748535,
-0.5927223563194275,
0.3337036669254303,
0.07853682339191437,
0.5808961391448975,
-0.677436888217926,
-0.15542083978652954,
0.0379059799015522,
-0.9375356435775757,
0.21572986245155334,
-0.08050008863210678,
0.3794737160205841,
0.9443942308425903,
0.48960238695144653,
-0.40214306116104126,
0.15973226726055145,
-0.42237719893455505,
-0.14890195429325104,
-0.2159501612186432,
0.1008603423833847,
0.5218858122825623,
0.7131121754646301,
0.04143352061510086,
1.0320574045181274,
-0.72735995054245,
0.050021059811115265,
0.0914752259850502,
0.547211229801178,
-0.024561593309044838,
0.3099963963031769,
0.7733350992202759,
-0.7372037172317505,
-0.6006890535354614,
-0.10618606209754944,
-0.32086318731307983,
0.0822291150689125,
-0.26655474305152893,
-0.38013705611228943,
0.0433584526181221,
0.12270888686180115,
-0.5796207189559937,
0.5506343841552734,
-0.18394602835178375,
-0.12146276235580444,
0.6844279766082764,
-0.27924904227256775,
0.40871208906173706,
-0.8261321187019348,
-0.0649198666214943,
-0.19737321138381958,
0.16674551367759705,
-0.7461222410202026,
0.041406143456697464,
0.1741366684436798,
-0.12251783907413483,
-0.389254629611969,
0.3116385042667389,
-0.2732160985469818,
-0.12806127965450287,
-0.09790140390396118,
0.2691703140735626,
0.06355546414852142,
0.2562079131603241,
-0.23798297345638275,
1.2157331705093384,
0.25553983449935913,
-0.7523545026779175,
0.26592499017715454,
0.28212907910346985,
-0.2507804036140442,
0.7352403402328491,
-0.5931529402732849,
0.43553364276885986,
0.019840743392705917,
0.09629657119512558,
-0.8781340718269348,
-0.444976806640625,
0.05945722013711929,
-0.6376753449440002,
0.3396075367927551,
0.03843342885375023,
-0.3970950245857239,
-0.5742644667625427,
-0.34495991468429565,
0.45609596371650696,
0.638331413269043,
-0.1730722039937973,
0.10122638940811157,
-0.17700569331645966,
-0.34966838359832764,
-0.563810408115387,
-0.39503055810928345,
0.137115478515625,
0.12646234035491943,
-0.38691243529319763,
0.38667139410972595,
-0.31734582781791687,
0.014513938687741756,
-0.008433707989752293,
-0.27794381976127625,
-0.4575173258781433,
0.040272630751132965,
-0.2793668806552887,
0.17480050027370453,
-0.38354673981666565,
0.11310983449220657,
0.2623913586139679,
0.26853570342063904,
0.18715472519397736,
-0.11420311033725739,
0.3619130849838257,
-0.27467259764671326,
-0.23184968531131744,
0.004035736434161663,
0.13459911942481995,
0.4259946346282959,
-0.22993740439414978,
0.2212860882282257,
0.42470550537109375,
-0.3242373466491699,
-0.23305818438529968,
-0.2688872814178467,
-0.5950725078582764,
-0.47414344549179077,
0.24628138542175293,
-0.22817999124526978,
-0.928688108921051,
0.23867984116077423,
0.333537757396698,
0.3403020203113556,
0.5933132171630859,
0.6989054679870605,
0.06504904478788376,
0.6941652297973633,
0.29756003618240356,
0.31539562344551086,
0.33243033289909363,
-0.3925648629665375,
0.07627541571855545,
-0.6877282857894897,
-0.35831430554389954,
-0.4423818290233612,
-0.13547708094120026,
-0.31903213262557983,
-0.3209967613220215,
0.3592209219932556,
0.16555483639240265,
-0.5923665761947632,
0.2767353355884552,
-0.9548600912094116,
0.5900054574012756,
0.603367030620575,
-0.12478887289762497,
0.3509472906589508,
-0.022497039288282394,
-0.04881507158279419,
0.07937895506620407,
-0.7111971378326416,
-0.4851202368736267,
1.0620207786560059,
-0.16143620014190674,
0.18279311060905457,
0.3006412088871002,
0.8180673718452454,
-0.229144886136055,
0.6001644730567932,
-0.8443294167518616,
0.5272060036659241,
0.26911547780036926,
-1.4023150205612183,
-0.5454009175300598,
-0.3937525749206543,
-0.8734350204467773,
0.2575177848339081,
-0.10365775972604752,
-0.44101962447166443,
0.017448466271162033,
0.150696262717247,
-0.7775813937187195,
0.2856317162513733,
-0.73261958360672,
0.8434666395187378,
-0.289119154214859,
-0.4524335265159607,
0.2269769012928009,
-0.5559788942337036,
0.4662993550300598,
-0.5811439156532288,
-0.2549777626991272,
-0.03696278855204582,
-0.11058506369590759,
0.717887282371521,
-0.5161336064338684,
0.41899988055229187,
-0.1789770871400833,
-0.31466639041900635,
0.8895288109779358,
0.022308537736535072,
-0.22756162285804749,
0.23575876653194427,
-0.07818388193845749,
0.0138187725096941,
0.23856285214424133,
-0.13389337062835693,
-0.8405057787895203,
0.6368464231491089,
-0.730118453502655,
-1.0556695461273193,
-0.8445976972579956,
-0.610417366027832,
-0.3562757074832916,
0.5575749278068542,
0.4979611933231354,
0.5769678354263306,
0.09937109798192978,
0.022374048829078674,
0.3924751281738281,
-0.1990160048007965,
0.3751407265663147,
0.4145122766494751,
-0.08460929989814758,
-0.43918946385383606,
0.9116437435150146,
0.5059491395950317,
0.6523618102073669,
0.09928932785987854,
0.29231396317481995,
-0.19966693222522736,
-0.3484679162502289,
-0.6714752316474915,
0.19597750902175903,
-0.7359893321990967,
-0.5515373945236206,
-0.40881460905075073,
-0.4616577923297882,
-0.6479823589324951,
-0.31054556369781494,
-0.10177113115787506,
-0.32236775755882263,
-0.41026341915130615,
-0.08605547994375229,
0.5953081250190735,
0.9952809810638428,
0.059449661523103714,
0.1741800159215927,
-0.6522538661956787,
0.0493956059217453,
0.7448797225952148,
0.19520999491214752,
-0.006623803172260523,
-0.6440988779067993,
0.16219960153102875,
0.20312663912773132,
-0.8973547220230103,
-0.891413152217865,
0.13226497173309326,
0.3537483513355255,
0.17827942967414856,
0.38004663586616516,
-0.07425036281347275,
0.8276422619819641,
-0.7352097630500793,
1.2978659868240356,
-0.025729166343808174,
-0.6634951829910278,
0.4336366355419159,
-0.6905359029769897,
0.5723252892494202,
0.65672367811203,
0.6098648309707642,
-0.14140842854976654,
-0.5475680232048035,
-0.863105297088623,
-0.7568565011024475,
0.5410938858985901,
0.508871853351593,
0.3969651162624359,
-0.2661537230014801,
0.9207521080970764,
-0.08362428843975067,
0.18127776682376862,
-0.38297441601753235,
-0.1256299912929535,
-0.766306459903717,
0.1890442669391632,
-0.09056834131479263,
-0.19176827371120453,
0.33068448305130005,
-0.6368650197982788,
0.44305184483528137,
0.06958108395338058,
0.25843656063079834,
0.34772634506225586,
0.41147637367248535,
-0.1441313475370407,
0.621812641620636,
0.9435043334960938,
0.6498655676841736,
-0.5722969770431519,
0.004447924438863993,
0.29359257221221924,
-1.136034607887268,
0.11519002169370651,
-0.21142549812793732,
-0.5837274789810181,
-0.16131356358528137,
0.15847350656986237,
0.18115384876728058,
0.33821362257003784,
-0.30489709973335266,
0.6043175458908081,
-0.15373240411281586,
-0.7802252173423767,
-0.30337151885032654,
0.5303474068641663,
-0.004366212524473667,
-0.2420600801706314,
0.3129168152809143,
-0.06259336322546005,
0.0474638007581234,
-0.5652306079864502,
0.4275719225406647,
0.4416542947292328,
-0.13237354159355164,
-0.4172622263431549,
0.8214966654777527,
0.05654677003622055,
-0.2529144585132599,
0.8361374139785767,
-0.44991815090179443,
-0.815479040145874,
0.696211576461792,
0.8842034935951233,
0.571893036365509,
-0.47712942957878113,
0.4372361898422241,
0.9665375351905823,
0.47623690962791443,
-0.09602305293083191,
0.6844521164894104,
-0.3659839928150177,
-0.7811079025268555,
-0.4243948459625244,
-0.3978171944618225,
-0.9173751473426819,
0.17026245594024658,
-0.7634347081184387,
0.11736630648374557,
-0.7256972193717957,
-0.5056739449501038,
-0.11849191039800644,
-0.17489393055438995,
-0.49058058857917786,
0.3927573263645172,
-0.12792672216892242,
0.724094569683075,
-0.4143778085708618,
0.5148745775222778,
0.8407215476036072,
-0.9351247549057007,
-1.333059549331665,
0.27778565883636475,
-0.13520680367946625,
-0.38356083631515503,
0.7623016834259033,
0.23336035013198853,
-0.2623622715473175,
0.5058627724647522,
-0.4602692723274231,
-1.0971858501434326,
1.368967056274414,
0.23588955402374268,
-0.2790096700191498,
-0.05869678780436516,
0.2038843333721161,
0.6316020488739014,
0.14097250998020172,
0.5452569723129272,
0.48605406284332275,
0.5703610777854919,
0.6524125337600708,
-0.6552659869194031,
-0.25776591897010803,
-0.29624420404434204,
-0.25691384077072144,
0.3226103186607361,
-0.4427550733089447,
1.1539078950881958,
-0.2206900417804718,
-0.4434710443019867,
-0.10081993043422699,
0.422624796628952,
0.10383462905883789,
0.36697137355804443,
0.29680681228637695,
0.6577763557434082,
0.8368527293205261,
-0.27102383971214294,
1.0325720310211182,
-0.20890969038009644,
0.5439479947090149,
0.8142830729484558,
-0.4585078954696655,
0.9095315337181091,
0.07669112831354141,
-0.09593375027179718,
0.6176279187202454,
0.7013453245162964,
-0.11687098443508148,
0.32098883390426636,
0.12974302470684052,
-0.41545847058296204,
-0.17604368925094604,
0.330338716506958,
-0.6472859382629395,
0.2442835569381714,
0.35153520107269287,
0.45994919538497925,
-0.4020546078681946,
-0.20446747541427612,
0.05444420129060745,
-0.2855323851108551,
-0.3147285580635071,
0.7467437982559204,
-0.09188767522573471,
-1.049092173576355,
0.8323153257369995,
-0.34962090849876404,
0.4195477068424225,
-0.4054575264453888,
-0.08632504940032959,
-0.3534126579761505,
-0.03376550227403641,
-0.18443675339221954,
-0.9545081853866577,
0.24736662209033966,
0.35986825823783875,
-0.04114006832242012,
-0.14276458323001862,
0.5556401014328003,
-0.2277902513742447,
-0.4062577188014984,
-0.271328330039978,
0.3604191243648529,
0.4028858542442322,
-0.03826075419783592,
-0.6918007731437683,
-0.4219294488430023,
-0.060484133660793304,
-0.1655505746603012,
0.035198941826820374,
0.29816704988479614,
0.12659063935279846,
0.23701898753643036,
0.6031469106674194,
-0.008178193122148514,
0.2531924247741699,
0.13309705257415771,
0.6415337920188904,
-0.660621702671051,
-0.25933006405830383,
-0.5485289096832275,
0.3017222285270691,
-0.11964312940835953,
-0.6195657849311829,
1.0758254528045654,
0.6779814958572388,
1.0083338022232056,
0.07206684350967407,
0.6583636403083801,
0.04581465944647789,
0.3581313192844391,
-0.06870003044605255,
0.6778957843780518,
-0.708092451095581,
-0.053085509687662125,
-0.6140732169151306,
-1.1726137399673462,
-0.4388686716556549,
0.6573002338409424,
-0.5818321704864502,
0.4135098457336426,
1.1426101922988892,
0.5624791383743286,
0.15466128289699554,
0.47179973125457764,
0.3064766228199005,
-0.08414175361394882,
0.6044712662696838,
0.5075459480285645,
0.7517620921134949,
-0.3775087594985962,
0.5566409230232239,
-0.42554908990859985,
-0.43801823258399963,
0.19974225759506226,
-0.6925686597824097,
-0.8477700352668762,
-0.5492289066314697,
-0.158339723944664,
-0.05531017854809761,
-0.20780839025974274,
0.4012082815170288,
0.13735385239124298,
-0.3615649342536926,
-0.0032090283930301666,
-0.4349525272846222,
-0.1932830959558487,
0.0403888039290905,
-0.28026050329208374,
0.2751903831958771,
-0.7289252877235413,
-0.5648448467254639,
0.25619450211524963,
0.23283885419368744,
0.17920279502868652,
-0.20179502665996552,
0.2781367301940918,
-0.12402725219726562,
0.244151771068573,
0.5710265636444092,
0.38594135642051697,
-0.5184980630874634,
-0.5335291028022766,
0.4699704051017761,
-0.04776569455862045,
0.0020442071836441755,
0.8240102529525757,
-0.6854586601257324,
0.5476487278938293,
0.4185720682144165,
0.6866329312324524,
0.5469101667404175,
0.31688088178634644,
0.38847509026527405,
-0.43994152545928955,
-0.2260001301765442,
0.60303795337677,
0.018764721229672432,
0.3051062226295471,
-0.5577866435050964,
0.3531717360019684,
0.5011295080184937,
-0.8117184042930603,
-0.60505610704422,
0.1601748913526535,
-0.8050490021705627,
-0.11536093801259995,
1.3392536640167236,
0.2709270715713501,
-0.20882464945316315,
-0.10129974037408829,
-0.2406860888004303,
0.07514738291501999,
-0.26857003569602966,
0.5117044448852539,
0.7475319504737854,
-0.318864107131958,
0.0867156907916069,
-0.9490242600440979,
0.6131545305252075,
0.4861776828765869,
-0.9379880428314209,
-0.22174717485904694,
0.40522104501724243,
0.40585270524024963,
0.2278479039669037,
0.7549451589584351,
-0.16218212246894836,
0.5249167680740356,
-0.06510552763938904,
0.022999383509159088,
-0.024006661027669907,
-0.08775576204061508,
0.055753931403160095,
0.26287898421287537,
-0.06061045080423355,
0.33881986141204834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15193v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15193v3 | Reward Steering with Evolutionary Heuristics for Decoding-time Alignment | 2024-06-21T14:35:16 | 2024-06-25T16:55:03 | Chia-Yu Hung, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread applicability and increasing omnipresence of LLMs have
instigated a need to align LLM responses to user and stakeholder preferences.
Many preference optimization approaches have been proposed that fine-tune LLM
parameters to achieve good alignment. However, such parameter tuning is known
to interfere with model performance on many tasks. Moreover, keeping up with
shifting user preferences is tricky in such a situation. Decoding-time
alignment with reward model guidance solves these issues at the cost of
increased inference time. However, most of such methods fail to strike the
right balance between exploration and exploitation of reward -- often due to
the conflated formulation of these two aspects - to give well-aligned
responses. To remedy this we decouple these two aspects and implement them in
an evolutionary fashion: exploration is enforced by decoding from mutated
instructions and exploitation is represented as the periodic replacement of
poorly-rewarded generations with well-rewarded ones. Empirical evidences
indicate that this strategy outperforms many preference optimization and
decode-time alignment approaches on two widely accepted alignment benchmarks
AlpacaEval 2 and MT-Bench. Our implementation will be available at:
https://darwin-alignment.github.io. | [
-0.18871548771858215,
-0.23867417871952057,
0.5606451630592346,
0.4096943140029907,
-0.4437006711959839,
0.42460450530052185,
-0.09124696999788284,
-0.5394083857536316,
0.46886464953422546,
0.26956745982170105,
-0.9948723316192627,
-0.1465156525373459,
-0.6902163624763489,
0.04362271726131439,
0.013799440115690231,
0.9675779938697815,
-0.1875513345003128,
-0.10882323235273361,
-0.09205715358257294,
-0.2958833575248718,
-0.5062850713729858,
-0.4021065831184387,
-0.58500736951828,
-0.6256551742553711,
0.880226194858551,
0.3210604786872864,
0.6829832792282104,
1.1631569862365723,
0.3780297636985779,
0.15751276910305023,
-0.43344151973724365,
0.4486052989959717,
-0.8292869925498962,
0.09782633930444717,
-0.36302629113197327,
-0.3009912073612213,
-0.35979050397872925,
0.0064063784666359425,
0.16514992713928223,
0.45074209570884705,
-0.4902188181877136,
-0.12278943508863449,
0.35498812794685364,
0.5535395741462708,
-0.8918415904045105,
-0.08367149531841278,
-0.5304967761039734,
0.07940889894962311,
-0.41246718168258667,
-1.0268136262893677,
-0.26070842146873474,
-0.49882668256759644,
0.15007345378398895,
-0.9591965675354004,
-0.13823378086090088,
0.05743391811847687,
0.646003007888794,
0.5530737042427063,
-0.40047839283943176,
-0.4708179533481598,
-0.5432925820350647,
1.0278688669204712,
-0.4286925196647644,
0.09418737143278122,
0.18770040571689606,
0.24006786942481995,
-0.3400459289550781,
-0.2158748358488083,
-0.17024490237236023,
0.2821645438671112,
0.07973481714725494,
0.13044586777687073,
-0.005131205078214407,
-0.08483003824949265,
-0.10399359464645386,
0.17739461362361908,
-0.48972249031066895,
0.5375520586967468,
-0.2549963593482971,
-0.21764209866523743,
0.6908039450645447,
0.4001920521259308,
-0.124094158411026,
0.04316062480211258,
-0.8278096318244934,
-0.43087926506996155,
-0.809543251991272,
0.43085384368896484,
0.5663233995437622,
0.2871462404727936,
-0.07012809067964554,
0.7327449917793274,
-0.14330142736434937,
0.5939314365386963,
0.2748388648033142,
0.09526322782039642,
0.18680359423160553,
-0.2946310043334961,
0.06917430460453033,
0.4962247908115387,
0.5741547346115112,
0.7033518552780151,
-0.04042426496744156,
-0.1769295334815979,
-0.28933677077293396,
0.10623090714216232,
0.48846960067749023,
-0.4036640226840973,
0.022447334602475166,
0.2846108675003052,
-0.4799996018409729,
-0.609651505947113,
-0.11018022149801254,
-0.9824599027633667,
-0.5974887013435364,
-0.17358197271823883,
0.28180888295173645,
-0.41864484548568726,
-0.09811684489250183,
0.4934147596359253,
-0.35477590560913086,
0.44239526987075806,
0.3043038547039032,
-1.4986799955368042,
-0.08488033711910248,
1.0611891746520996,
0.7919893264770508,
-0.5111681818962097,
-0.3227290213108063,
-0.8441733717918396,
0.5089126825332642,
-0.13937991857528687,
0.6322431564331055,
-0.5941412448883057,
-0.5720871090888977,
-0.04561725631356239,
-0.13851837813854218,
0.10010990500450134,
-0.31671828031539917,
0.6902356743812561,
-0.7894031405448914,
0.19147183001041412,
-0.54716557264328,
-0.507591187953949,
0.038745440542697906,
0.3269953727722168,
-0.5265350341796875,
0.8552833795547485,
0.20434123277664185,
-0.39679786562919617,
0.5751668810844421,
-0.8057041764259338,
-0.2600160539150238,
-0.005254589486867189,
0.10695873945951462,
-0.3234039545059204,
0.17312148213386536,
0.49529027938842773,
0.1155710518360138,
-0.17077770829200745,
0.1274034082889557,
-0.2157345563173294,
-0.5337315201759338,
0.22424989938735962,
-0.2144620567560196,
0.7374700903892517,
0.32576897740364075,
-0.547598659992218,
0.27400651574134827,
-0.26551729440689087,
0.044600002467632294,
0.25211405754089355,
-0.4977572560310364,
-0.4368944764137268,
0.46210387349128723,
-0.18764598667621613,
-0.12257412821054459,
0.3921419382095337,
-0.3006673753261566,
0.8006266951560974,
-0.4232177436351776,
0.8266575932502747,
1.1430162191390991,
-0.10011662542819977,
0.7470676898956299,
-0.387998104095459,
0.5163995623588562,
-0.0019722713623195887,
0.2642916142940521,
0.021208789199590683,
-0.08379820734262466,
-0.2677096724510193,
-0.01297029945999384,
0.210231751203537,
0.3312534987926483,
-0.32460564374923706,
0.5252559185028076,
-0.479602575302124,
-0.2835240960121155,
-0.7645455002784729,
0.09915196150541306,
0.10750390589237213,
0.34893596172332764,
0.6522934436798096,
-0.2346232682466507,
-0.4348820745944977,
-0.901114284992218,
-0.25587430596351624,
0.05474800989031792,
0.10163291543722153,
0.3478735685348511,
-0.039354849606752396,
-0.3517843782901764,
0.7703574895858765,
-0.3978452682495117,
-0.14065364003181458,
0.005219265352934599,
0.341067910194397,
0.09627588838338852,
0.6723617315292358,
0.47236141562461853,
-0.7385386228561401,
0.0035677540581673384,
0.07475485652685165,
-0.47964146733283997,
-0.09529580920934677,
-0.16229209303855896,
-0.29339292645454407,
0.17700791358947754,
0.13695935904979706,
-0.3186148703098297,
0.06848520785570145,
0.5672075152397156,
-0.2584192752838135,
0.19103318452835083,
0.0589933916926384,
0.3105170726776123,
-0.7031587362289429,
-0.0678667202591896,
-0.22952328622341156,
-0.24244338274002075,
-0.1546933948993683,
0.08763310313224792,
0.30867475271224976,
0.19885745644569397,
-0.2889120280742645,
0.4590303599834442,
-0.47059935331344604,
-0.07900821417570114,
-0.36137402057647705,
-0.013197452761232853,
-0.126658096909523,
0.4888203740119934,
0.046326056122779846,
0.699180543422699,
0.22603829205036163,
-0.5083959102630615,
0.41461730003356934,
0.4396485686302185,
-0.0320592038333416,
0.6327025890350342,
-0.5431196689605713,
0.3157579302787781,
0.14613987505435944,
0.120061494410038,
-0.7210847735404968,
-0.08551416546106339,
0.3973079323768616,
-0.35879141092300415,
0.439611554145813,
-0.25723642110824585,
0.01833164319396019,
-0.1281391680240631,
-0.7749145030975342,
0.7359600067138672,
0.40156424045562744,
-1.0025203227996826,
0.5676640868186951,
-0.01794629730284214,
-0.14848189055919647,
-1.1244561672210693,
-0.5548542141914368,
0.06829474121332169,
-0.5812812447547913,
-0.6069915294647217,
0.7157649993896484,
-0.0059177507646381855,
0.18818780779838562,
0.06693325936794281,
-0.40710315108299255,
0.8124586343765259,
0.27206793427467346,
0.11884679645299911,
0.476248562335968,
-0.11549605429172516,
-0.368151992559433,
0.19534805417060852,
-0.42500758171081543,
-0.02123192511498928,
-0.49291807413101196,
0.8551076650619507,
0.22384504973888397,
-0.4845791161060333,
-0.22678352892398834,
0.2743983268737793,
0.44119733572006226,
-0.37854182720184326,
0.5526468753814697,
0.3159833550453186,
0.018189039081335068,
0.11230338364839554,
-0.5192662477493286,
-0.1894090175628662,
-0.5046210289001465,
0.09804004430770874,
-0.12269970774650574,
-0.8733676671981812,
0.31088125705718994,
-0.19078227877616882,
0.2362697273492813,
0.3200500011444092,
0.4051792025566101,
-0.42842257022857666,
1.2279837131500244,
0.6197481751441956,
-0.2523934245109558,
0.5053390860557556,
-0.21680377423763275,
-0.013840576633810997,
-0.9440960884094238,
-0.5206325650215149,
-0.4747975468635559,
-0.9404683113098145,
-0.5649033784866333,
-0.0016776574775576591,
0.3229679465293884,
0.2130599170923233,
-0.23554208874702454,
0.2580570578575134,
-0.7347924709320068,
0.3559419512748718,
0.624721109867096,
0.008072774857282639,
0.11639794707298279,
0.01051202043890953,
0.06742992252111435,
-0.12817467749118805,
-0.645324170589447,
-0.48797479271888733,
1.0639828443527222,
0.23231524229049683,
1.053961992263794,
0.19240552186965942,
0.971500813961029,
0.36190924048423767,
-0.06370952725410461,
-0.6701335310935974,
0.17416764795780182,
0.10562629252672195,
-0.15994670987129211,
-0.38999295234680176,
-0.30505067110061646,
-1.1034542322158813,
-0.08131980150938034,
-0.21809954941272736,
-0.8073217868804932,
0.5590962171554565,
0.365065336227417,
-0.3768727779388428,
0.078047975897789,
-0.4842309355735779,
0.9106858968734741,
-0.6382005214691162,
-0.5032125115394592,
-0.35290461778640747,
-0.8162441253662109,
0.2604246139526367,
0.2050110399723053,
-0.1423557549715042,
-0.06167946010828018,
-0.2587917447090149,
0.5938473343849182,
-0.2700706720352173,
0.5046464800834656,
-0.2645883858203888,
-0.09734843671321869,
-0.39158040285110474,
0.16861402988433838,
0.8929159045219421,
-0.059305064380168915,
-0.09888353943824768,
-0.12085388600826263,
0.016572168096899986,
-0.6444465517997742,
-0.5194375514984131,
0.8203172087669373,
-0.7716764211654663,
-0.6242018938064575,
-0.5708914995193481,
-0.6457763910293579,
-0.13844898343086243,
-0.1415971964597702,
0.3977978229522705,
0.10237263888120651,
-0.10385904461145401,
0.019748568534851074,
0.718374490737915,
0.09835121780633926,
0.4696594774723053,
0.12302602827548981,
0.008502726443111897,
-0.28190767765045166,
0.8327987790107727,
-0.49229758977890015,
0.3438887894153595,
0.37615108489990234,
0.09289229661226273,
-0.6368919610977173,
-0.5910822749137878,
-0.5992568135261536,
-0.044722847640514374,
-0.36963728070259094,
-0.3199523687362671,
-0.33594515919685364,
0.059499889612197876,
-0.09203685820102692,
-0.7148492932319641,
-0.24994607269763947,
-0.2352418303489685,
-0.44871267676353455,
-0.03306664898991585,
0.33855754137039185,
0.5304355025291443,
-0.13758134841918945,
0.52223801612854,
-0.6285896301269531,
0.09149454534053802,
0.1954364776611328,
0.31982389092445374,
-0.07272472232580185,
-0.30034929513931274,
-0.07870364189147949,
0.23504523932933807,
-0.48895585536956787,
-0.9152266383171082,
0.3299468755722046,
-0.23577886819839478,
0.6045973896980286,
0.44578006863594055,
-0.04771905392408371,
0.7629069089889526,
-0.16233408451080322,
0.6920682787895203,
0.22979699075222015,
-0.9400216937065125,
0.46383392810821533,
-0.16780997812747955,
0.040566351264715195,
0.48727965354919434,
0.3956708014011383,
-0.6547399759292603,
-0.10719393193721771,
-0.2834014296531677,
-0.9405655860900879,
0.9285542368888855,
-0.07509464025497437,
-0.13342857360839844,
0.26351407170295715,
0.3326701819896698,
0.28118133544921875,
0.09692573547363281,
-0.5778342485427856,
-0.041252076625823975,
-0.4751337766647339,
-0.25949427485466003,
-0.35111039876937866,
-0.4354933500289917,
-0.6499664187431335,
0.23985081911087036,
0.6675331592559814,
-0.2101084589958191,
0.17657439410686493,
-0.07800508290529251,
-0.16126033663749695,
-0.4967009425163269,
0.4390263855457306,
0.7607366442680359,
0.633127748966217,
-0.3752329647541046,
0.05283764377236366,
-0.22162313759326935,
-0.01327519677579403,
0.49105149507522583,
0.3724445104598999,
-0.1895008087158203,
-0.6436041593551636,
0.09344110637903214,
0.7091188430786133,
0.30910009145736694,
-0.5188063979148865,
0.320220947265625,
0.09254718571901321,
-0.19501341879367828,
0.13128750026226044,
0.26213908195495605,
0.3429332971572876,
0.558259129524231,
0.5392073392868042,
0.05173289403319359,
0.02047703042626381,
-0.41318583488464355,
-0.3864230215549469,
0.8184985518455505,
-0.14501823484897614,
0.0048294672742486,
0.9292266964912415,
0.17687886953353882,
-0.4035758078098297,
0.6732417345046997,
-0.2580549120903015,
-0.5232917070388794,
0.43805167078971863,
0.4860319197177887,
0.8147004246711731,
-0.1543622463941574,
-0.09784851968288422,
-0.007623361889272928,
0.2553514242172241,
-0.19569158554077148,
0.25451934337615967,
-0.14517387747764587,
-0.6596217155456543,
-0.41468366980552673,
-0.4806124269962311,
-0.33175545930862427,
-0.1371130794286728,
-0.7761671543121338,
0.26038843393325806,
-0.09480755776166916,
0.09665469825267792,
0.04143114015460014,
-0.24039073288440704,
-0.42386239767074585,
-0.3244918882846832,
0.08222827315330505,
0.9244553446769714,
-0.6129410266876221,
0.44719240069389343,
0.5868036150932312,
-0.20075899362564087,
-0.57373046875,
-0.2001039683818817,
0.32538992166519165,
-1.0157921314239502,
0.31518444418907166,
0.05093184858560562,
-0.31757763028144836,
0.03750089183449745,
-0.6708793044090271,
-0.821976363658905,
1.4968323707580566,
0.1831388622522354,
-0.7041640281677246,
-0.04957630857825279,
0.05979585647583008,
0.10109157860279083,
-0.34615644812583923,
-0.06468811631202698,
0.6387991309165955,
0.6455671191215515,
0.12188921123743057,
-0.745073676109314,
-0.05296957120299339,
0.0063822087831795216,
-0.030856430530548096,
0.5743403434753418,
-0.5363806486129761,
0.40977126359939575,
-0.19289934635162354,
-0.20812773704528809,
0.2645244598388672,
0.44768059253692627,
0.536410927772522,
0.36819544434547424,
0.6484525203704834,
0.6443368196487427,
0.6211087107658386,
-0.35129135847091675,
0.8561917543411255,
-0.17734850943088531,
0.30036842823028564,
0.7317522168159485,
-0.2892605662345886,
0.5530016422271729,
0.929324209690094,
-0.07643254846334457,
0.25084125995635986,
1.1529343128204346,
-0.023438915610313416,
0.934019923210144,
0.020731346681714058,
0.025471210479736328,
-0.18946139514446259,
-0.0804506167769432,
-0.48733291029930115,
0.24407115578651428,
0.24549591541290283,
-0.10328531265258789,
-0.21662835776805878,
-0.2381303310394287,
-0.46521663665771484,
-0.030095797032117844,
-0.37476348876953125,
0.8028025031089783,
-0.20990493893623352,
-0.8614417910575867,
0.5818066000938416,
0.12429837137460709,
1.0337759256362915,
-0.7993194460868835,
0.06720346957445145,
-0.2347736358642578,
-0.034486498683691025,
-0.3537691533565521,
-0.8503954410552979,
0.02072850987315178,
-0.16301752626895905,
-0.1411341279745102,
-0.4112989902496338,
0.33619481325149536,
-0.38695064187049866,
0.24100945889949799,
0.37681105732917786,
0.31149086356163025,
-0.26278603076934814,
0.24629603326320648,
-0.519127368927002,
0.22933579981327057,
0.26162511110305786,
-0.2693302035331726,
0.39783379435539246,
0.04025480896234512,
-0.02904784120619297,
0.6285618543624878,
0.6728916168212891,
-0.0013558517675846815,
0.15795882046222687,
-0.23804941773414612,
0.8705164790153503,
-0.7991814613342285,
-0.7053775191307068,
-1.088409423828125,
0.5285950899124146,
0.05663197487592697,
-0.34620121121406555,
0.1496167778968811,
0.7121452689170837,
0.7028131484985352,
0.18449626863002777,
0.4056897759437561,
0.10469384491443634,
0.0858462005853653,
-0.8654049038887024,
0.1506032943725586,
-0.7512915134429932,
0.396344929933548,
-0.009997017681598663,
-1.1463274955749512,
0.18366281688213348,
0.2993771731853485,
-0.12337630987167358,
-0.13346950709819794,
0.3441947400569916,
0.6812576651573181,
-0.40398845076560974,
0.19112738966941833,
-0.33517125248908997,
-0.28957599401474,
0.41598793864250183,
0.9433974027633667,
1.195458173751831,
0.2149105668067932,
0.48790621757507324,
-0.22425617277622223,
-0.320537269115448,
-0.5367626547813416,
-1.267896056175232,
-0.130958691239357,
-0.3888756036758423,
-0.0026973742060363293,
-0.29462930560112,
0.3994009792804718,
1.1895157098770142,
0.6355469822883606,
-0.564616858959198,
-0.2796661853790283,
0.14193859696388245,
0.021053295582532883,
-0.6476660966873169,
-0.20196695625782013,
0.3284480571746826,
-0.3326165974140167,
-0.7146027684211731,
0.6216948628425598,
0.5081719756126404,
0.19962473213672638,
-0.22581297159194946,
-0.5696224570274353,
-0.11170194298028946,
-0.14898595213890076,
0.11223989725112915,
0.5714846253395081,
-0.7861018776893616,
-0.22922451794147491,
0.3257722854614258,
-0.23637725412845612,
0.39006948471069336,
0.9336973428726196,
-0.5827650427818298,
0.3855312168598175,
0.22674177587032318,
1.0237352848052979,
0.8217432498931885,
0.3240775763988495,
0.7569419145584106,
-0.5799655318260193,
-0.06773801147937775,
0.3086691200733185,
0.5035460591316223,
0.2590439021587372,
-0.5993211269378662,
0.6778404116630554,
-0.059997521340847015,
-0.7008921504020691,
-0.7160352468490601,
0.16514240205287933,
-1.4181008338928223,
-0.07740398496389389,
0.9016276001930237,
0.18798960745334625,
-0.09107822924852371,
0.29618966579437256,
-0.23787899315357208,
0.16040028631687164,
-0.5986833572387695,
1.1417266130447388,
0.8003137111663818,
-0.4055068790912628,
0.0025140896905213594,
0.028678715229034424,
0.4442472457885742,
0.8326713442802429,
-0.5280035138130188,
0.09475402534008026,
0.38129615783691406,
0.13421417772769928,
0.21108001470565796,
0.30530843138694763,
-0.09823940694332123,
0.53635573387146,
-0.5507990121841431,
0.0326983705163002,
-0.295411080121994,
0.0012377550592646003,
-0.6387193202972412,
-0.024994516745209694,
0.279612272977829,
-0.43679824471473694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15178v1 | Hybrid Alignment Training for Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T14:23:57 | 2024-06-21T14:23:57 | Chenglong Wang, Hang Zhou, Kaiyan Chang, Bei Li, Yongyu Mu, Tong Xiao, Tongran Liu, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Alignment training is crucial for enabling large language models (LLMs) to
cater to human intentions and preferences. It is typically performed based on
two stages with different objectives: instruction-following alignment and
human-preference alignment. However, aligning LLMs with these objectives in
sequence suffers from an inherent problem: the objectives may conflict, and the
LLMs cannot guarantee to simultaneously align with the instructions and human
preferences well. To response to these, in this work, we propose a Hybrid
Alignment Training (Hbat) approach, based on alternating alignment and modified
elastic weight consolidation methods. The basic idea is to alternate between
different objectives during alignment training, so that better collaboration
can be achieved between the two alignment tasks.We experiment with Hbat on
summarization and dialogue tasks. Experimental results show that the proposed
\textsc{Hbat} can significantly outperform all baselines. Notably, Hbat yields
consistent performance gains over the traditional two-stage alignment training
when using both proximal policy optimization and direct preference
optimization. | [
-0.28705254197120667,
-0.4694186747074127,
0.45144301652908325,
0.1319780796766281,
-0.2793538570404053,
0.5612207055091858,
-0.5256299376487732,
-0.24853549897670746,
0.4381592273712158,
0.30743375420570374,
-0.5843741297721863,
-0.16818279027938843,
-0.3909146785736084,
0.03705078735947609,
-0.12580418586730957,
0.9498487710952759,
-0.5293751358985901,
0.2501702308654785,
-0.2282957285642624,
-0.3601270616054535,
-0.6510187983512878,
-0.3216593861579895,
-0.5666488409042358,
-0.586868941783905,
0.41651007533073425,
0.4152453541755676,
0.752541184425354,
0.7023937702178955,
0.48589345812797546,
0.2672739326953888,
-0.02954952046275139,
0.5134432911872864,
-0.5240668654441833,
-0.05806375667452812,
-0.0878354012966156,
-0.31794244050979614,
-0.5051600337028503,
-0.14834313094615936,
0.9759820103645325,
0.7711871266365051,
-0.4046440124511719,
-0.09754420071840286,
0.3573451638221741,
0.7109981179237366,
-0.6728804111480713,
-0.2951960563659668,
-0.3941739797592163,
0.004167477134615183,
-0.13261678814888,
-0.1500919908285141,
-0.18137866258621216,
-0.13286092877388,
0.044346392154693604,
-0.5251554250717163,
-0.03934969753026962,
0.42047008872032166,
0.8454210758209229,
0.207167387008667,
-0.6120990514755249,
0.10793590545654297,
-0.6072286367416382,
0.8067837953567505,
-0.7999767661094666,
0.3831770718097687,
-0.004659414291381836,
0.11453801393508911,
-0.2598634958267212,
0.026753665879368782,
-0.8172047138214111,
0.12338431179523468,
-0.15084178745746613,
0.21624355018138885,
0.1629468947649002,
0.378015398979187,
-0.07101886719465256,
0.46268749237060547,
-0.6912304759025574,
0.6121644973754883,
-0.12960441410541534,
-0.30235907435417175,
0.6626721620559692,
0.24423877894878387,
0.2789444923400879,
0.007673810701817274,
-0.4750238358974457,
-0.2356189489364624,
-0.6235995292663574,
0.14169280230998993,
0.6112831234931946,
0.39189282059669495,
-0.37581926584243774,
0.6601064205169678,
-0.08023274689912796,
0.7811388373374939,
0.3625161945819855,
-0.20572325587272644,
0.365839421749115,
-0.25615596771240234,
-0.07060102373361588,
0.32523924112319946,
0.8354421854019165,
0.3060106337070465,
-0.10917378216981888,
-0.15573731064796448,
-0.2174600213766098,
-0.049255236983299255,
0.32353827357292175,
-0.48795977234840393,
0.2688039541244507,
0.35754379630088806,
-0.35343697667121887,
-0.25994083285331726,
0.05317677557468414,
-0.4948576092720032,
-0.30516672134399414,
-0.7590168118476868,
0.5071485042572021,
-0.31382063031196594,
-0.27787157893180847,
0.21510842442512512,
0.072252556681633,
0.31021735072135925,
0.3133566081523895,
-1.1709247827529907,
0.525287926197052,
0.9871785044670105,
0.860895574092865,
-0.4895016551017761,
-0.4457142949104309,
-0.6858258843421936,
0.3548484444618225,
-0.21331742405891418,
0.5579313635826111,
-0.41753703355789185,
-0.24419142305850983,
0.08622229844331741,
-0.1322590857744217,
-0.19433020055294037,
-0.297257661819458,
0.35216155648231506,
-0.2356843203306198,
0.46248531341552734,
-0.3073132336139679,
-0.6069400310516357,
-0.05823095887899399,
0.31494155526161194,
-0.3944663405418396,
1.118129014968872,
0.212864488363266,
-0.7578227519989014,
0.2637474536895752,
-0.2674676179885864,
-0.651296079158783,
-0.04799222573637962,
-0.38486772775650024,
-0.6664792895317078,
0.04626072570681572,
0.10465146601200104,
0.205328106880188,
-0.3571009635925293,
0.26640138030052185,
-0.33757686614990234,
-0.6011890172958374,
-0.04641668498516083,
0.0849701389670372,
0.5399360060691833,
-0.16201746463775635,
-0.44166862964630127,
0.3037811815738678,
-0.48805123567581177,
-0.23656399548053741,
0.025323228910565376,
-0.44524818658828735,
-0.465417742729187,
-0.09945666044950485,
-0.14302490651607513,
0.062137067317962646,
0.5169907212257385,
-0.43387508392333984,
0.536339521408081,
-0.5077164173126221,
0.010325799696147442,
0.7869451642036438,
-0.12800896167755127,
0.8068547248840332,
-0.49832117557525635,
0.5845903754234314,
-0.19820040464401245,
-0.1551567018032074,
0.23758971691131592,
-0.08770222216844559,
-0.7217435240745544,
-0.24970225989818573,
0.30748361349105835,
0.4849807024002075,
-0.47692978382110596,
0.9887123703956604,
-0.1799832284450531,
-0.269864946603775,
-0.814304769039154,
0.35786768794059753,
0.4988172948360443,
0.6255438923835754,
0.3979029655456543,
-0.40953540802001953,
-0.8309000134468079,
-0.9718939661979675,
-0.34563297033309937,
-0.21320633590221405,
0.29263341426849365,
0.21418264508247375,
0.2779766917228699,
-0.14194785058498383,
0.8920409083366394,
-0.3113432824611664,
-0.2847364544868469,
-0.471030056476593,
0.39375197887420654,
0.1492098867893219,
0.5919159650802612,
0.36587652564048767,
-0.7394391298294067,
-0.5589301586151123,
0.08927439898252487,
-0.43359944224357605,
-0.11909256875514984,
-0.23030933737754822,
-0.4322425127029419,
0.2814106345176697,
0.20171241462230682,
-0.4168790280818939,
-0.0507824532687664,
0.7931501269340515,
0.19871173799037933,
0.44707944989204407,
-0.30489110946655273,
0.2552553713321686,
-1.4028762578964233,
-0.0758398175239563,
0.12222383916378021,
-0.3080816864967346,
-0.5327194929122925,
-0.3787008225917816,
0.23192933201789856,
0.16328322887420654,
-0.26996251940727234,
0.3648424446582794,
-0.6525233387947083,
-0.2267053723335266,
-0.37938860058784485,
-0.006434966344386339,
-0.025992268696427345,
0.5532140731811523,
0.3142387568950653,
0.7321294546127319,
0.36123764514923096,
-0.3903711140155792,
0.195057213306427,
0.39729806780815125,
-0.31407231092453003,
0.44825103878974915,
-0.43560415506362915,
0.25965380668640137,
-0.28709155321121216,
0.5993797779083252,
-1.077771782875061,
-0.29594630002975464,
0.007344900630414486,
0.00039947617915458977,
0.6528047323226929,
0.0412578321993351,
-0.32969579100608826,
-0.4335097670555115,
-0.45445191860198975,
0.44463470578193665,
0.5730457901954651,
-0.5632017850875854,
0.914471447467804,
0.36607825756073,
-0.06384443491697311,
-0.9407318234443665,
-0.5730871558189392,
-0.13197749853134155,
-0.3287131190299988,
-0.5046012997627258,
0.6309520602226257,
0.3018123507499695,
-0.02113240398466587,
-0.05374994874000549,
-0.27167773246765137,
0.40987130999565125,
-0.09112503379583359,
0.11006615310907364,
0.402808278799057,
-0.08611266314983368,
-0.054169200360774994,
0.21923232078552246,
0.04820458963513374,
-0.5156043767929077,
-0.35031697154045105,
0.8442787528038025,
-0.07914817333221436,
-0.28385260701179504,
-0.6243995428085327,
0.44484052062034607,
0.38410234451293945,
-0.39383170008659363,
1.093121886253357,
0.513863742351532,
-0.28933560848236084,
0.06223496049642563,
-0.8229381442070007,
-0.05341176316142082,
-0.4390752613544464,
0.4187662601470947,
-0.14590732753276825,
-0.8155124187469482,
0.23833946883678436,
-0.08409418165683746,
0.336679071187973,
0.2604241371154785,
0.7206733226776123,
-0.45944052934646606,
1.1733962297439575,
0.693293035030365,
-0.3583627939224243,
0.6665118336677551,
-0.12116950005292892,
0.25426334142684937,
-1.13507878780365,
-0.10899554193019867,
-0.3674928545951843,
-0.6886216402053833,
-0.35697242617607117,
-0.050541892647743225,
0.3983194828033447,
0.18683715164661407,
-0.21079424023628235,
0.7517871260643005,
-0.1766083687543869,
0.40323659777641296,
0.30541035532951355,
0.12809883058071136,
0.10616089403629303,
0.06974684447050095,
-0.1032291054725647,
-0.05185728892683983,
-0.6339096426963806,
-0.434603214263916,
0.783394992351532,
0.3085992634296417,
0.7261770963668823,
0.2208804190158844,
1.1691573858261108,
-0.023968903347849846,
0.16065725684165955,
-0.8049485683441162,
0.42287686467170715,
-0.14273180067539215,
-0.284169465303421,
-0.34116509556770325,
-0.5658680200576782,
-0.7816852927207947,
0.5063083171844482,
-0.45540571212768555,
-0.8073980808258057,
0.06427434831857681,
0.45238634943962097,
-0.47649842500686646,
0.24760116636753082,
-0.6000558733940125,
0.8914141058921814,
-0.5990967750549316,
-0.3982864320278168,
-0.3576996326446533,
-0.8865355253219604,
0.32179826498031616,
-0.04691930487751961,
0.21886974573135376,
-0.03350682929158211,
-0.15839238464832306,
0.7140274047851562,
-0.3978084325790405,
0.7472648024559021,
0.008483675308525562,
-0.02746986225247383,
-0.12298793345689774,
-0.054595112800598145,
0.7169420719146729,
-0.4318844676017761,
0.10779201984405518,
-0.18339739739894867,
-0.3309687376022339,
-0.37803173065185547,
-0.661784291267395,
0.4050079882144928,
-0.9226818084716797,
-0.6928120255470276,
-0.3841395378112793,
-0.8473785519599915,
-0.5305179953575134,
0.2597925662994385,
0.15417809784412384,
0.3488548994064331,
-0.15129144489765167,
0.1289205104112625,
0.49928000569343567,
0.04457085207104683,
0.27669650316238403,
0.5371930599212646,
-0.06771967560052872,
-0.4146922826766968,
0.8068673610687256,
-0.10621249675750732,
0.5659291744232178,
0.6473073959350586,
0.3862117826938629,
-0.32430243492126465,
-0.6329545378684998,
-0.41854730248451233,
0.4375505745410919,
-0.2825488746166229,
-0.050655100494623184,
-0.6886867880821228,
0.03216181695461273,
-0.5838237404823303,
-0.33752280473709106,
-0.472298800945282,
-0.3306780159473419,
-0.195853129029274,
0.1490786224603653,
-0.0778822973370552,
0.2829728424549103,
0.02760155312716961,
0.4230388402938843,
-0.8031376004219055,
0.2904180884361267,
0.061333511024713516,
0.0732419416308403,
-0.147794708609581,
-0.6654006242752075,
-0.31711021065711975,
0.11423101276159286,
-0.3036339581012726,
-0.6559467911720276,
0.17392194271087646,
0.06665867567062378,
0.4757544994354248,
0.39930078387260437,
-0.13853715360164642,
0.9030979871749878,
-0.5436932444572449,
0.49864038825035095,
0.591958224773407,
-0.743912935256958,
0.25471436977386475,
-0.2892354726791382,
0.247572124004364,
0.9608131647109985,
0.5018401741981506,
-0.6760618686676025,
-0.24087360501289368,
-0.33877742290496826,
-0.7942078709602356,
0.8132572770118713,
-0.012358255684375763,
-0.1083783283829689,
0.3750569224357605,
0.22989925742149353,
0.22449800372123718,
0.36081910133361816,
-0.36271360516548157,
0.03634791448712349,
0.3171904385089874,
-0.6978977918624878,
-0.13311325013637543,
-0.046355798840522766,
-0.3520905673503876,
-0.19453327357769012,
0.9559852480888367,
-0.16270925104618073,
-0.12996520102024078,
-0.26085174083709717,
-0.2074662297964096,
-0.3651260733604431,
0.22288714349269867,
0.539169192314148,
0.3714084327220917,
-0.22435133159160614,
-0.08554621785879135,
0.19887150824069977,
-0.14706206321716309,
0.3817915916442871,
0.08746043592691422,
0.08225467801094055,
-0.4604228138923645,
0.369030237197876,
0.988963782787323,
0.24151518940925598,
-0.6249209046363831,
0.6326128244400024,
0.08466489613056183,
-0.35031619668006897,
-0.08497529476881027,
0.08307334035634995,
0.12038625031709671,
0.15700514614582062,
0.07351458072662354,
0.029233204200863838,
-0.02529327943921089,
-0.6400775909423828,
-0.09139353036880493,
0.4894597828388214,
-0.018969055265188217,
-0.016397668048739433,
0.41214025020599365,
0.3094281852245331,
-0.28215306997299194,
0.5375011563301086,
-0.06755263358354568,
-0.785667359828949,
0.28431886434555054,
0.6134149432182312,
0.8051736950874329,
-0.23743408918380737,
0.03042680211365223,
0.1550600826740265,
0.14439085125923157,
-0.5063894987106323,
0.15262237191200256,
-0.15671055018901825,
-0.9708510041236877,
-0.5413374900817871,
-0.5723270773887634,
-0.6516331434249878,
-0.1759113371372223,
-0.8019523024559021,
0.45381760597229004,
-0.17984777688980103,
0.1214616522192955,
-0.1550089567899704,
0.021684909239411354,
-0.39751023054122925,
-0.08154015243053436,
0.2997331917285919,
0.485451877117157,
-1.0134119987487793,
0.6637946367263794,
0.8155828714370728,
-0.28003302216529846,
-0.9453492760658264,
0.08654938638210297,
0.33697831630706787,
-0.8687787055969238,
0.10428375750780106,
0.2584620714187622,
-0.11300408840179443,
-0.12647095322608948,
-0.16498146951198578,
-0.8605466485023499,
1.0544356107711792,
0.3314356207847595,
-1.0850852727890015,
-0.37960702180862427,
0.03381284326314926,
0.430726021528244,
-0.5532159209251404,
-0.09898929297924042,
0.7665519118309021,
0.32114890217781067,
0.20443761348724365,
-1.1031850576400757,
-0.04592715576291084,
0.0667792558670044,
0.11597539484500885,
0.6686046719551086,
-1.0307259559631348,
0.49110206961631775,
-0.025389906018972397,
-0.025838155299425125,
0.05097466707229614,
0.7440354824066162,
0.3228084444999695,
-0.18999537825584412,
0.8875594735145569,
0.7686774730682373,
0.8023003339767456,
-0.07061121612787247,
1.0070730447769165,
-0.15254782140254974,
0.20409591495990753,
1.367467999458313,
-0.7377790808677673,
0.7076694369316101,
0.647437572479248,
-0.08275771886110306,
0.40929391980171204,
0.6961122155189514,
0.06416676938533783,
0.516087532043457,
0.0005482524284161627,
-0.19658780097961426,
-0.25679871439933777,
-0.19169677793979645,
-0.22970035672187805,
0.4486279785633087,
0.019741389900445938,
0.03777478262782097,
-0.029832469299435616,
-0.044109564274549484,
-0.0218419898301363,
0.12600207328796387,
-0.20818352699279785,
0.9332929849624634,
-0.06177777796983719,
-0.9739150404930115,
0.47424858808517456,
-0.023371493443846703,
0.7792750597000122,
-0.6079632639884949,
0.13290484249591827,
0.12442503869533539,
0.283471941947937,
-0.3804265260696411,
-0.6345869898796082,
-0.02397574670612812,
-0.15710563957691193,
0.027215396985411644,
-0.31921082735061646,
0.34024301171302795,
-0.9994353652000427,
-0.13848362863063812,
0.046336498111486435,
0.14988550543785095,
-0.08550398796796799,
0.3466782569885254,
-0.6680232286453247,
0.13532617688179016,
-0.07766943424940109,
-0.24205119907855988,
0.4620313346385956,
-0.0623273141682148,
0.010525917634367943,
0.17530740797519684,
0.3850998282432556,
0.26670894026756287,
-0.23731094598770142,
0.28853359818458557,
0.7259912490844727,
-0.31650638580322266,
-0.6686877012252808,
-0.8152655363082886,
0.5800756216049194,
-0.2711521089076996,
-0.14258430898189545,
0.5019577145576477,
0.6839447021484375,
0.7831072807312012,
0.39008626341819763,
0.8065159916877747,
0.05825146660208702,
0.43178924918174744,
-0.7703210711479187,
0.18868517875671387,
-0.748816728591919,
0.06401701271533966,
-0.1647864431142807,
-1.2441074848175049,
-0.11476989835500717,
0.48809802532196045,
-0.3154127299785614,
0.09285427629947662,
0.7691990733146667,
0.661121129989624,
-0.10632379353046417,
0.016686666756868362,
-0.07942389696836472,
-0.135537251830101,
0.36794203519821167,
0.5781225562095642,
0.7578602433204651,
-0.12184040248394012,
0.24356478452682495,
-0.2898077964782715,
-0.3909568786621094,
-0.34436818957328796,
-0.8690381646156311,
-0.9341176748275757,
-0.4281949996948242,
-0.36790406703948975,
-0.36948907375335693,
0.05841700732707977,
1.5562410354614258,
0.6405642628669739,
-0.7313715815544128,
-0.4599858820438385,
-0.15385857224464417,
-0.2060670107603073,
-0.2826356589794159,
-0.14856772124767303,
0.3426620364189148,
-0.3004801273345947,
-0.7258802652359009,
0.4220050275325775,
0.42407479882240295,
0.3960491418838501,
-0.20497284829616547,
-0.354423850774765,
-0.37361598014831543,
-0.13328014314174652,
0.03695511445403099,
0.47402262687683105,
-0.5888640284538269,
-0.25664398074150085,
-0.17595365643501282,
-0.2662919759750366,
0.14308784902095795,
1.0955854654312134,
-0.40531501173973083,
0.3830435276031494,
0.5212797522544861,
1.0557267665863037,
0.6153022646903992,
0.37319597601890564,
0.9895267486572266,
-0.779926061630249,
0.30667805671691895,
0.2526248097419739,
0.6899019479751587,
0.43063440918922424,
-0.37183815240859985,
0.25333496928215027,
-0.07584193348884583,
-0.4100075960159302,
-0.8328186273574829,
0.10377342998981476,
-1.0749397277832031,
0.017002517357468605,
1.3001230955123901,
0.25727084279060364,
-0.27862802147865295,
0.23175232112407684,
-0.4762117862701416,
0.5091689825057983,
-0.42114171385765076,
0.5885121822357178,
0.7971705794334412,
-0.35724636912345886,
-0.03478926792740822,
0.004004588350653648,
0.2818482220172882,
0.8666083216667175,
-0.7193500995635986,
-0.034852057695388794,
0.38735321164131165,
0.05826777592301369,
0.02079889178276062,
0.5882265567779541,
0.015575033612549305,
0.2612428069114685,
-0.4333038032054901,
0.25737738609313965,
0.033215153962373734,
-0.3406864106655121,
-0.5431037545204163,
-0.17813926935195923,
0.053079962730407715,
-0.19768460094928741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15175v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15175v1 | Enhancing Idiomatic Representation in Multiple Languages via an Adaptive Contrastive Triplet Loss | 2024-06-21T14:21:41 | 2024-06-21T14:21:41 | Wei He, Marco Idiart, Carolina Scarton, Aline Villavicencio | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurately modeling idiomatic or non-compositional language has been a
longstanding challenge in Natural Language Processing (NLP). This is partly
because these expressions do not derive their meanings solely from their
constituent words, but also due to the scarcity of relevant data resources, and
their impact on the performance of downstream tasks such as machine translation
and simplification. In this paper we propose an approach to model idiomaticity
effectively using a triplet loss that incorporates the asymmetric contribution
of components words to an idiomatic meaning for training language models by
using adaptive contrastive learning and resampling miners to build an
idiomatic-aware learning objective. Our proposed method is evaluated on a
SemEval challenge and outperforms previous alternatives significantly in many
metrics. | [
-0.2202451229095459,
-0.1915685534477234,
0.331895112991333,
0.4367864429950714,
-0.6526151299476624,
0.33845093846321106,
-0.2729123532772064,
-0.18393254280090332,
0.1617494523525238,
0.41604241728782654,
-0.4316841959953308,
-0.3500889539718628,
-0.657212495803833,
0.17357872426509857,
-0.11553926765918732,
0.9263573288917542,
-0.5535637140274048,
0.06914918124675751,
-0.04739219322800636,
-0.6543954014778137,
-0.7642248272895813,
-0.39235103130340576,
-0.502589225769043,
-0.5215137600898743,
0.21627794206142426,
0.4182884395122528,
0.41472721099853516,
0.4796919524669647,
0.43684178590774536,
0.11014580726623535,
0.13575118780136108,
0.20417918264865875,
-0.1889611780643463,
0.22264151275157928,
-0.4276297390460968,
-0.44430220127105713,
0.19716893136501312,
0.07999934256076813,
0.882716715335846,
0.9286419153213501,
-0.08665874600410461,
0.00073134625563398,
0.5147888660430908,
0.888460099697113,
-0.6089849472045898,
0.48873499035835266,
-0.8913201689720154,
0.02073068544268608,
0.025664161890745163,
-0.27428925037384033,
-0.10175731033086777,
-0.16600023210048676,
0.01539674773812294,
-0.2497871369123459,
0.06163918599486351,
-0.2351512908935547,
0.6503587961196899,
0.45976144075393677,
-0.21422000229358673,
-0.3790198266506195,
-0.47175681591033936,
0.6180139780044556,
-0.6621115207672119,
0.11560117453336716,
0.1108516976237297,
0.023970728740096092,
0.21482333540916443,
-0.19362741708755493,
-0.5561875104904175,
0.11721482872962952,
0.0016390952514484525,
0.25611355900764465,
-0.04289969429373741,
-0.09509814530611038,
-0.12886810302734375,
0.3382880985736847,
-0.056993402540683746,
0.124955914914608,
-0.3442438542842865,
0.06673720479011536,
0.4799780547618866,
0.30588576197624207,
-0.13749009370803833,
-0.15534552931785583,
-0.457475483417511,
-0.034076984971761703,
-0.535312294960022,
-0.09117016941308975,
0.5053945183753967,
0.737358808517456,
-0.3310804069042206,
0.32321757078170776,
-0.11963560432195663,
0.4515606164932251,
-0.14814327657222748,
0.16631463170051575,
0.43255090713500977,
-0.39962100982666016,
0.1416560858488083,
-0.02823266200721264,
0.5664393305778503,
0.46186402440071106,
-0.21023990213871002,
-0.1138620600104332,
-0.1979784071445465,
0.25459450483322144,
-0.1914675384759903,
-0.7129698395729065,
-0.3517873287200928,
0.08783025294542313,
-0.1649668961763382,
-0.38616517186164856,
0.09194831550121307,
-0.5955135226249695,
-0.5138561725616455,
-0.14548157155513763,
0.5946211218833923,
-0.6536257266998291,
-0.32188981771469116,
0.346692830324173,
-0.346666544675827,
0.20511235296726227,
0.17058691382408142,
-0.8866854310035706,
0.32276061177253723,
0.4570844769477844,
1.0535305738449097,
-0.09009511768817902,
-0.42283108830451965,
-0.4569280445575714,
0.2462104856967926,
-0.2436632215976715,
0.7260326743125916,
-0.6360291838645935,
-0.23821939527988434,
-0.19345664978027344,
-0.16873985528945923,
-0.17224441468715668,
-0.7674326300621033,
0.5023749470710754,
-0.2196875959634781,
0.11630240082740784,
-0.0074328649789094925,
-0.43586254119873047,
-0.6341993808746338,
0.36893635988235474,
-0.503834068775177,
0.8743345141410828,
0.07920663803815842,
-0.8414037227630615,
0.23015546798706055,
-0.8254361748695374,
-0.6056671738624573,
0.08306184411048889,
-0.12129373103380203,
-0.49632272124290466,
0.50119948387146,
0.36888453364372253,
0.5716342926025391,
-0.4439537227153778,
-0.03541463986039162,
-0.33576637506484985,
-0.2666107714176178,
0.021305907517671585,
-0.2866968810558319,
0.7035436034202576,
-0.01931384950876236,
-0.45580682158470154,
-0.1041296198964119,
-0.6743497252464294,
0.07509099692106247,
0.17138037085533142,
-0.546257734298706,
-0.5422127842903137,
0.20603133738040924,
-0.1179581955075264,
0.26618778705596924,
-0.007940351031720638,
-0.33229178190231323,
0.04560348764061928,
-0.5371396541595459,
0.24745941162109375,
0.7914384603500366,
0.06630924344062805,
0.1250937283039093,
-0.3685910403728485,
0.4853813946247101,
0.34758326411247253,
-0.42260101437568665,
-0.30684176087379456,
-0.17073585093021393,
-0.7980634570121765,
-0.3257233798503876,
0.18232735991477966,
0.5584955811500549,
-0.9743098616600037,
0.3241262435913086,
-0.4088912904262543,
-0.2559314966201782,
-0.9187272787094116,
0.3155706226825714,
0.20153869688510895,
0.5767467021942139,
0.4695022404193878,
-0.34137168526649475,
-0.6159833669662476,
-1.0277889966964722,
-0.5446543097496033,
-0.1879090815782547,
-0.10413632541894913,
-0.14960192143917084,
0.48970919847488403,
-0.20530806481838226,
0.3485277593135834,
-0.2544165849685669,
-0.3436073958873749,
-0.10542269051074982,
0.5712598562240601,
0.30465519428253174,
0.48572617769241333,
0.2593088150024414,
-0.5997017621994019,
-0.6136110424995422,
0.16622202098369598,
-0.5665405988693237,
-0.2278783768415451,
-0.12462928891181946,
0.3068274259567261,
0.21299459040164948,
0.5057420134544373,
-0.0634564682841301,
0.3188248574733734,
0.6953433752059937,
-0.08888664841651917,
0.41250884532928467,
-0.030293675139546394,
0.0058874282985925674,
-1.203499674797058,
0.03417670354247093,
-0.3164229393005371,
-0.07992617785930634,
-0.35101988911628723,
0.44702622294425964,
0.1152748167514801,
-0.08057545870542526,
-0.1836671233177185,
0.5055959224700928,
-0.4720444679260254,
-0.029902886599302292,
-0.4999670088291168,
0.16175419092178345,
0.1842416673898697,
0.40459659695625305,
0.060849785804748535,
0.6582531332969666,
0.5996321439743042,
-0.6463401317596436,
0.510067880153656,
-0.1093602254986763,
-0.23058182001113892,
0.881571352481842,
-0.4197511672973633,
-0.019634192809462547,
-0.3495809733867645,
0.03573837876319885,
-0.7209755778312683,
-0.03637733682990074,
0.2864179313182831,
-0.3999888300895691,
0.052881207317113876,
-0.10169317573308945,
-0.6890890598297119,
-0.19510620832443237,
-0.5260339975357056,
0.40433216094970703,
0.22934122383594513,
-0.8362811803817749,
0.5075657963752747,
0.13503706455230713,
-0.04352154582738876,
-0.4230779707431793,
-0.7759912610054016,
0.24548333883285522,
-0.6892558932304382,
-0.5089406967163086,
0.4406529366970062,
0.03635694086551666,
-0.22701449692249298,
0.0842733308672905,
-0.05989331379532814,
0.1240580603480339,
0.4582044780254364,
0.023993732407689095,
-0.05250915512442589,
-0.09206246584653854,
0.7964536547660828,
-0.13583369553089142,
-0.14652453362941742,
0.039204612374305725,
-0.4905705153942108,
0.700514018535614,
-0.6183452010154724,
-0.4172106981277466,
-0.46308091282844543,
0.7603350281715393,
0.4142579734325409,
-0.33948537707328796,
0.7397358417510986,
0.648023784160614,
-0.4488328695297241,
-0.3254973590373993,
-0.3315272033214569,
-0.0667809322476387,
-0.3923921585083008,
0.313935786485672,
-0.39943188428878784,
-0.5551888942718506,
0.8441599011421204,
0.12406399846076965,
0.1034727618098259,
0.6374489665031433,
0.5443724393844604,
-0.2258634716272354,
1.0617543458938599,
0.5975306630134583,
0.15397696197032928,
0.4046965539455414,
-0.054071854799985886,
0.1608601063489914,
-0.9000591039657593,
-0.06001149117946625,
-0.38664090633392334,
-0.1781308948993683,
-0.6280333399772644,
-0.6116630434989929,
0.425042986869812,
0.11691060662269592,
-0.24601134657859802,
0.03433580696582794,
-0.32677337527275085,
0.39936113357543945,
0.7800096869468689,
0.2711595296859741,
0.3549743890762329,
0.25417372584342957,
-0.04424841329455376,
-0.06613895297050476,
-0.600337564945221,
-0.4249071180820465,
0.8179500102996826,
0.2635529339313507,
0.7887796759605408,
0.4026886224746704,
0.8876416683197021,
0.06517217308282852,
0.290033221244812,
-0.942051351070404,
0.17996571958065033,
-0.2638357877731323,
-0.409417986869812,
0.0648161917924881,
-0.3569900691509247,
-0.6131996512413025,
0.41319218277931213,
-0.23481649160385132,
-0.3954232931137085,
0.05899858847260475,
0.20288996398448944,
-0.25960877537727356,
0.5814276337623596,
-0.5026805400848389,
0.62831050157547,
-0.30270475149154663,
-0.32701805233955383,
-0.3465748727321625,
-0.5258726477622986,
0.26550793647766113,
-0.22589915990829468,
0.0557885505259037,
-0.297154039144516,
-0.36343055963516235,
0.5329951643943787,
-0.5231432318687439,
0.680279016494751,
-0.1612919718027115,
0.17023968696594238,
0.21274684369564056,
0.09100418537855148,
0.4660396873950958,
-0.0777244046330452,
-0.3417873978614807,
0.09304766356945038,
0.0015443793963640928,
-0.7640325427055359,
-0.5176395773887634,
0.6029306650161743,
-0.4540315568447113,
-0.6405162215232849,
-0.4945791959762573,
-0.6019972562789917,
-0.3290070593357086,
0.21246643364429474,
0.1581253856420517,
0.021032478660345078,
0.043392714112997055,
0.2926624119281769,
0.3215866982936859,
-0.11734910309314728,
0.40040311217308044,
0.23747140169143677,
0.04487048462033272,
-0.30524739623069763,
0.8126488327980042,
0.030114997178316116,
0.4259253740310669,
0.19397591054439545,
0.4868861138820648,
-0.21995292603969574,
-0.8598390817642212,
-0.3169462978839874,
0.2754054367542267,
-1.073022484779358,
-0.37880179286003113,
-0.5334637761116028,
0.10751361399888992,
-0.27765485644340515,
-0.2927844822406769,
-0.19460397958755493,
-0.32213032245635986,
-0.3734380006790161,
-0.09832742065191269,
0.4547613859176636,
0.37560975551605225,
-0.370066374540329,
0.3378309905529022,
-0.7368046045303345,
0.20520444214344025,
0.4515198767185211,
0.7537685632705688,
-0.30174604058265686,
-0.6459997296333313,
-0.3143266439437866,
0.10921754688024521,
-0.08225621283054352,
-1.0389806032180786,
0.41572055220603943,
0.43845656514167786,
0.5364531874656677,
0.12822292745113373,
0.038552358746528625,
0.8226652145385742,
-0.16847550868988037,
0.39471137523651123,
0.32262054085731506,
-1.047743797302246,
0.4679396450519562,
-0.3720563054084778,
0.5995157361030579,
0.9747681021690369,
0.07397937029600143,
-0.729393720626831,
0.0369185209274292,
-0.6628296971321106,
-0.9491695761680603,
0.5763164758682251,
-0.130056232213974,
0.37492817640304565,
-0.1483093798160553,
0.19454945623874664,
0.19050545990467072,
0.1908939927816391,
-1.1483919620513916,
0.06888726353645325,
-0.3404638469219208,
-0.4592890739440918,
0.17420314252376556,
-0.018186531960964203,
-0.26644274592399597,
0.07666286081075668,
1.0921634435653687,
-0.4649006128311157,
-0.039815425872802734,
-0.13214111328125,
-0.15055321156978607,
0.1952483206987381,
0.21204780042171478,
0.09988235682249069,
0.08076867461204529,
-0.2313919961452484,
0.48213493824005127,
0.27819883823394775,
-0.06980161368846893,
0.08051838725805283,
0.5056477189064026,
-0.0355810821056366,
0.011103946715593338,
0.20655079185962677,
0.7216811776161194,
-0.06468191742897034,
-0.6275756359100342,
0.59283447265625,
0.014214836992323399,
-0.00839928351342678,
-0.1627197265625,
-0.3705165982246399,
0.29558035731315613,
0.21786946058273315,
0.22131609916687012,
0.20785321295261383,
0.0468561016023159,
-0.5296196937561035,
0.08006513863801956,
0.4249526858329773,
-0.7003886699676514,
-0.0915306881070137,
0.37153130769729614,
0.2223469763994217,
-0.008345902897417545,
0.6287644505500793,
-0.35500648617744446,
-0.45517557859420776,
0.36691901087760925,
0.5746095180511475,
1.0700253248214722,
-0.2843233644962311,
0.03471513092517853,
0.3830416798591614,
0.5346155762672424,
-0.10380956530570984,
0.1863967925310135,
0.04036369547247887,
-0.8196237683296204,
-0.11521705985069275,
-0.4995250999927521,
-0.20950399339199066,
-0.05030989646911621,
-0.6207473874092102,
0.533796489238739,
-0.6594974994659424,
0.3902416229248047,
-0.03011172264814377,
-0.08595335483551025,
-0.7361869812011719,
-0.027759123593568802,
0.07028886675834656,
0.5148425102233887,
-1.0518766641616821,
0.6175723671913147,
0.7677013874053955,
-0.6149869561195374,
-0.46748286485671997,
0.03959309309720993,
-0.10358772426843643,
-0.8341559767723083,
0.47109872102737427,
0.38320180773735046,
-0.3653710186481476,
-0.18329916894435883,
-0.39899542927742004,
-0.7737619876861572,
0.7816253304481506,
0.3644006550312042,
-0.05246874317526817,
0.16882014274597168,
-0.03725295141339302,
0.41042792797088623,
-0.6705888509750366,
-0.4108659625053406,
0.5676847100257874,
0.24956688284873962,
-0.020434217527508736,
-0.6159631013870239,
0.05520283058285713,
-0.2844705879688263,
0.03889206424355507,
0.20278039574623108,
-0.32032763957977295,
1.013688564300537,
-0.2331487089395523,
-0.6872266530990601,
-0.10529615730047226,
0.6423488259315491,
0.29126954078674316,
0.10668117552995682,
0.4625672996044159,
0.3855173885822296,
0.6164535880088806,
-0.03613779693841934,
1.006896734237671,
-0.27797865867614746,
0.23269453644752502,
1.443700909614563,
0.0067388941533863544,
0.8128379583358765,
0.7248103022575378,
-0.028636666014790535,
0.43401339650154114,
0.4610320031642914,
0.13570140302181244,
0.5035855770111084,
0.2999170124530792,
-0.620359480381012,
-0.1531573235988617,
-0.1689937263727188,
-0.13390293717384338,
0.6514331102371216,
0.7169273495674133,
-0.54703289270401,
-0.40972021222114563,
0.1373165100812912,
0.24598155915737152,
0.6833029985427856,
-0.3307662904262543,
0.6867104768753052,
-0.1685638427734375,
-0.5851012468338013,
0.7890605330467224,
0.13911619782447815,
0.8240198493003845,
-0.3810265362262726,
-0.2890133857727051,
-0.19220282137393951,
0.2517557442188263,
-0.21478882431983948,
-0.6646541357040405,
0.533714234828949,
-0.27426597476005554,
-0.10630816966295242,
-0.11491214483976364,
0.32289478182792664,
-0.6750370264053345,
-0.7597020864486694,
0.2666988670825958,
0.28744080662727356,
-0.04614110291004181,
-0.1266564279794693,
-0.8067506551742554,
-0.05244087055325508,
0.12330718338489532,
0.3472105860710144,
-0.20448023080825806,
0.2987339198589325,
0.05511204153299332,
0.5479199290275574,
0.13510212302207947,
0.11765409260988235,
-0.03739071264863014,
-0.18646878004074097,
0.8371721506118774,
-0.7139027118682861,
-0.7037433385848999,
-0.7799521088600159,
0.47412699460983276,
-0.09809370338916779,
-0.04057535156607628,
0.599310040473938,
0.3590630292892456,
0.8825893998146057,
0.1237514466047287,
1.1418205499649048,
0.07810035347938538,
0.8590768575668335,
-0.48590704798698425,
0.13691191375255585,
-0.5122754573822021,
0.5914676189422607,
-0.27077507972717285,
-0.8293590545654297,
-0.7471408843994141,
0.6482746005058289,
-0.20544666051864624,
-0.15653009712696075,
0.5437192320823669,
0.5849594473838806,
-0.0933111384510994,
-0.1587507575750351,
0.18860994279384613,
0.18184399604797363,
0.3650760352611542,
0.41811180114746094,
0.6301610469818115,
-0.737152636051178,
0.467180460691452,
-0.4882047474384308,
-0.13566245138645172,
-0.2888537347316742,
-1.0741314888000488,
-0.5845308899879456,
-0.7617446780204773,
-0.3456255793571472,
-0.3563890755176544,
-0.08866741508245468,
1.0151093006134033,
0.2680527865886688,
-0.6881293654441833,
-0.3235691785812378,
-0.09069346636533737,
0.2434951812028885,
-0.5535105466842651,
-0.14210157096385956,
0.5833752155303955,
-0.5084188580513,
-0.6893876194953918,
0.35061734914779663,
0.3985689878463745,
0.16507841646671295,
-0.2197091430425644,
0.15200433135032654,
-0.4551573097705841,
0.1113823875784874,
0.6647077798843384,
0.316263347864151,
-0.6405085921287537,
-0.6979649066925049,
-0.4866011440753937,
0.26495954394340515,
0.2558707892894745,
0.5876805186271667,
-0.7920316457748413,
0.8194769024848938,
0.49983900785446167,
0.8048343062400818,
0.3396528959274292,
-0.10267072170972824,
0.591630756855011,
-0.9493916034698486,
0.18760563433170319,
0.505486249923706,
0.5126362442970276,
0.9619770050048828,
0.060706689953804016,
0.6645989418029785,
0.35509079694747925,
0.045112159103155136,
-0.7562307119369507,
0.6234981417655945,
-0.49038124084472656,
-0.4896305203437805,
0.941935122013092,
-0.12442009896039963,
0.09542442113161087,
-0.14974327385425568,
0.015814850106835365,
0.11006683856248856,
-0.0689178928732872,
0.836228609085083,
0.5252314209938049,
-0.13529330492019653,
-0.3383733928203583,
-0.20770098268985748,
0.3005107343196869,
0.5961759686470032,
-0.7035341858863831,
0.4284576177597046,
0.5071365833282471,
0.2886427938938141,
0.19103874266147614,
0.3232403099536896,
-0.3630509376525879,
0.15138418972492218,
0.054554376751184464,
0.4898059666156769,
0.005434114020317793,
0.019328532740473747,
-0.8547975420951843,
0.13224424421787262,
0.18752793967723846,
-0.2865058183670044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15534v1 | Geneverse: A collection of Open-source Multimodal Large Language Models for Genomic and Proteomic Research | 2024-06-21T14:19:10 | 2024-06-21T14:19:10 | Tianyu Liu, Yijia Xiao, Xiao Luo, Hua Xu, W. Jim Zheng, Hongyu Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, q-bio.QM | The applications of large language models (LLMs) are promising for biomedical
and healthcare research. Despite the availability of open-source LLMs trained
using a wide range of biomedical data, current research on the applications of
LLMs to genomics and proteomics is still limited. To fill this gap, we propose
a collection of finetuned LLMs and multimodal LLMs (MLLMs), known as Geneverse,
for three novel tasks in genomic and proteomic research. The models in
Geneverse are trained and evaluated based on domain-specific datasets, and we
use advanced parameter-efficient finetuning techniques to achieve the model
adaptation for tasks including the generation of descriptions for gene
functions, protein function inference from its structure, and marker gene
selection from spatial transcriptomic data. We demonstrate that adapted LLMs
and MLLMs perform well for these tasks and may outperform closed-source
large-scale models based on our evaluations focusing on both truthfulness and
structural correctness. All of the training strategies and base models we used
are freely accessible. | [
-0.3031858205795288,
-0.7068505883216858,
0.4436059892177582,
-0.027727661654353142,
0.060113586485385895,
0.002206271281465888,
-0.3864160478115082,
-0.16910171508789062,
0.1465669870376587,
0.7452800273895264,
-0.6254815459251404,
-0.4712158441543579,
-0.6069229245185852,
0.4401342272758484,
-0.2790357768535614,
1.03469979763031,
0.0891692042350769,
0.6092487573623657,
-0.4411174952983856,
-0.46686887741088867,
-0.017518192529678345,
-0.3935019373893738,
0.0407293401658535,
-0.20114590227603912,
0.7762609720230103,
0.4424157440662384,
0.767219066619873,
0.5429990887641907,
0.7342174053192139,
0.20241542160511017,
0.07073479145765305,
0.3185505270957947,
-0.6397140026092529,
0.12458257377147675,
-0.5798329710960388,
-0.43595123291015625,
-0.5291823148727417,
0.13553419709205627,
0.5228486657142639,
1.1737267971038818,
0.21784433722496033,
0.26864904165267944,
0.09559529274702072,
0.6609580516815186,
-0.5262621641159058,
0.19952569901943207,
-0.19876322150230408,
0.0876459851861,
-0.21462790668010712,
-0.2183288335800171,
-0.08484045416116714,
-0.4554315507411957,
0.0803668349981308,
-0.6639748811721802,
0.47178131341934204,
-0.10346180945634842,
0.29487791657447815,
0.10511035472154617,
-0.3280622065067291,
-0.2561367154121399,
-0.6559082865715027,
0.661555290222168,
-0.6735141277313232,
0.7027124166488647,
0.24095332622528076,
0.29093414545059204,
-0.4616186022758484,
-0.5003718137741089,
-0.6267004609107971,
-0.3734552562236786,
0.07425248622894287,
0.06988078355789185,
-0.15973404049873352,
0.11674589663743973,
0.06424315273761749,
0.5643094182014465,
-0.8392253518104553,
0.23510302603244781,
-0.22123947739601135,
-0.020057087764143944,
0.44162818789482117,
0.04818635433912277,
0.2064853459596634,
-0.22088295221328735,
-0.17956851422786713,
-0.22696605324745178,
-0.822391927242279,
-0.020020218566060066,
0.19794431328773499,
0.5387489199638367,
-0.026360291987657547,
0.9973648190498352,
-0.17116424441337585,
0.7056030631065369,
-0.24396178126335144,
-0.21149733662605286,
0.3772050440311432,
-0.2565535306930542,
-0.28079402446746826,
-0.29377540946006775,
0.5701435804367065,
0.33650580048561096,
0.05356644466519356,
-0.3619372844696045,
0.0841471403837204,
-0.09807045012712479,
0.00031623878749087453,
-0.7516888380050659,
-0.3420995771884918,
0.6916348934173584,
-0.6080943942070007,
-0.15733514726161957,
-0.23174692690372467,
-0.9458458423614502,
-0.7657582759857178,
-0.650748610496521,
0.49891307950019836,
-0.5990090370178223,
-0.2065761536359787,
0.4400104582309723,
-0.23955872654914856,
-0.06830230355262756,
0.13481204211711884,
-0.6497637033462524,
0.01061858981847763,
0.709935188293457,
0.7917166948318481,
-0.1455647200345993,
-0.1821783185005188,
-0.6745396852493286,
0.1645190715789795,
0.165178120136261,
0.6451025009155273,
-0.6090124249458313,
-0.3469436764717102,
-0.24464067816734314,
0.4630812704563141,
-0.1132444217801094,
-0.5191583633422852,
0.5510472059249878,
-0.2434360533952713,
-0.27814149856567383,
-0.3613201081752777,
-0.6464752554893494,
-0.2482287734746933,
0.17956702411174774,
-0.8026988506317139,
0.31500381231307983,
0.10667267441749573,
-0.6973342895507812,
0.1269116997718811,
-0.5834289789199829,
-0.3584103286266327,
0.382808119058609,
-0.40939706563949585,
-0.3018569350242615,
0.09883950650691986,
0.2242918610572815,
0.9788205027580261,
-0.2991085648536682,
0.5240478515625,
-0.5950484871864319,
-0.010008981451392174,
0.3827359676361084,
-0.11548859626054764,
0.8281906247138977,
0.3583197593688965,
-0.054803114384412766,
0.297343373298645,
-0.8819835782051086,
-0.3789123296737671,
0.14136956632137299,
-0.26333606243133545,
-0.42573419213294983,
0.25914186239242554,
0.10650304704904556,
-0.09374534338712692,
-0.0679296925663948,
-0.7650339603424072,
0.5047681331634521,
-0.32314348220825195,
0.6153931021690369,
0.4550716280937195,
-0.3739214837551117,
0.4946897625923157,
-0.25797343254089355,
0.24264708161354065,
0.0004935030010528862,
0.1878647655248642,
0.15087340772151947,
-0.38290032744407654,
-0.4192383289337158,
-0.5600804686546326,
0.3705251216888428,
0.794367253780365,
-0.894878089427948,
0.38899412751197815,
-0.5805032849311829,
-0.6003296375274658,
-0.4884600341320038,
0.22627341747283936,
0.19662895798683167,
0.38537055253982544,
0.5857700109481812,
-0.27160176634788513,
-0.4681132137775421,
-0.8175153136253357,
0.0712256133556366,
0.3580102026462555,
-0.18052208423614502,
0.3618002235889435,
0.5742660164833069,
-0.5260902643203735,
0.8900163769721985,
-0.42767006158828735,
-0.33741268515586853,
-0.3007379472255707,
-0.13294723629951477,
0.23371516168117523,
0.4110765755176544,
0.5467568039894104,
-0.7095849514007568,
0.10826975852251053,
0.14879629015922546,
-0.8572111129760742,
0.029612330719828606,
0.24469953775405884,
-0.12905491888523102,
-0.4521385133266449,
0.3324977457523346,
-0.6212526559829712,
-0.1959381401538849,
0.9694289565086365,
-0.28243258595466614,
0.5437529683113098,
-0.13475067913532257,
0.13541124761104584,
-1.0816493034362793,
0.32493606209754944,
0.048050832003355026,
-0.417959064245224,
-0.6714285612106323,
0.361279159784317,
0.09217579662799835,
-0.13941846787929535,
-0.44464167952537537,
0.662082314491272,
-0.4493573009967804,
-0.20174190402030945,
-0.18092255294322968,
-0.10646259784698486,
0.05662555247545242,
0.1858527809381485,
-0.056676920503377914,
0.6824463605880737,
0.5358281135559082,
-0.40381959080696106,
0.4133809804916382,
0.5902721881866455,
-0.40592995285987854,
0.2916897237300873,
-0.4647088050842285,
-0.2423713207244873,
-0.4609993100166321,
0.18001098930835724,
-0.6469467878341675,
-0.4750012159347534,
0.2274823933839798,
-0.2701523005962372,
0.18910092115402222,
-0.0163175817579031,
-0.4492628574371338,
-0.4120727777481079,
-0.32346484065055847,
0.0865384116768837,
0.2570297122001648,
-0.4679386615753174,
0.5587280988693237,
0.5464653968811035,
-0.38902878761291504,
-0.3930768668651581,
-0.6602804660797119,
-0.07240136712789536,
0.03913303464651108,
-0.5363481044769287,
0.12285173684358597,
-0.08744926750659943,
-0.15008288621902466,
0.016577083617448807,
0.08479676395654678,
0.18413984775543213,
0.06462570279836655,
0.3142513632774353,
0.1359962671995163,
-0.2920970916748047,
0.06525387614965439,
0.08005429804325104,
0.18835072219371796,
-0.28920626640319824,
-0.3927443325519562,
0.24803881347179413,
0.10390027612447739,
-0.09457094967365265,
0.29970717430114746,
0.6696955561637878,
0.42953598499298096,
-0.4410710036754608,
0.7274643778800964,
0.7634233236312866,
-0.43721601366996765,
-0.1539885252714157,
-0.3746441900730133,
-0.1300591379404068,
-0.38327381014823914,
0.48564571142196655,
-0.11981845647096634,
-1.4385578632354736,
0.32061269879341125,
-0.4303984045982361,
0.16420528292655945,
0.3697102963924408,
0.6510667204856873,
-0.16986572742462158,
0.6405388116836548,
0.7766114473342896,
0.2451801300048828,
-0.05048244446516037,
-0.2709720730781555,
0.0530615970492363,
-0.807174563407898,
-0.12780411541461945,
-0.6174612045288086,
-0.3175520598888397,
-0.28232696652412415,
-0.8148996233940125,
0.47894880175590515,
0.3240576982498169,
-0.1667364537715912,
0.2708391547203064,
-0.3159828186035156,
0.3192340135574341,
0.4296698570251465,
0.27091148495674133,
0.18999618291854858,
0.24088029563426971,
-0.23056644201278687,
0.12900923192501068,
-0.756161630153656,
-0.5745266675949097,
1.082478642463684,
0.4628412127494812,
0.8670527338981628,
0.3089003264904022,
0.24748891592025757,
0.15006770193576813,
0.44322922825813293,
-0.7312591075897217,
0.34139153361320496,
-1.0317447185516357,
-0.4599699378013611,
-0.10133012384176254,
-0.5107057690620422,
-0.993338406085968,
0.05153618007898331,
-0.48946139216423035,
-0.4318760335445404,
0.6087481379508972,
0.08232440799474716,
-0.6704244017601013,
0.26436638832092285,
-0.4552735984325409,
0.9048032760620117,
-0.21601921319961548,
-0.24134626984596252,
0.1538022756576538,
-0.7092459797859192,
0.5318321585655212,
-0.19539588689804077,
0.4916612207889557,
-0.36509382724761963,
0.20147143304347992,
0.5956445336341858,
-0.12323226034641266,
0.9431160688400269,
-0.12801606953144073,
-0.16002853214740753,
-0.09105204045772552,
0.32838767766952515,
0.24380294978618622,
0.17075784504413605,
-0.10749660432338715,
0.4844328463077545,
0.1795477271080017,
-0.18202294409275055,
-0.10256966948509216,
0.8369035124778748,
-0.8193835616111755,
-0.26416102051734924,
-0.0368025004863739,
-0.6316818594932556,
-0.40166279673576355,
0.2622509002685547,
0.18080328404903412,
0.49841776490211487,
-0.12625770270824432,
0.4234338700771332,
0.9477429986000061,
-0.6184026598930359,
0.09181404858827591,
0.4029156565666199,
-0.22648018598556519,
-0.41103270649909973,
0.8503710627555847,
-0.07777427136898041,
0.15707716345787048,
0.6277135014533997,
0.23333172500133514,
-0.17366528511047363,
-0.604934573173523,
-0.40377160906791687,
0.06479337811470032,
-0.6380019783973694,
-0.43479683995246887,
-0.9934401512145996,
-0.006793104112148285,
-0.5165209770202637,
-0.1964830607175827,
-0.3107401728630066,
-0.3006347715854645,
-0.3634164035320282,
0.02032862789928913,
0.6016047596931458,
0.37804940342903137,
-0.22792284190654755,
0.04925864189863205,
-1.220514178276062,
0.7694963812828064,
0.1924671232700348,
0.3890553414821625,
-0.3973555266857147,
-0.09482235461473465,
-0.14232829213142395,
0.10900241136550903,
-0.11557397246360779,
-0.8935911059379578,
0.428862988948822,
0.6110862493515015,
0.6971349716186523,
0.02642868272960186,
-0.3424752950668335,
0.20841853320598602,
-0.8067989945411682,
0.6784744262695312,
0.17661522328853607,
-0.39632168412208557,
0.3761553466320038,
-0.5128329992294312,
0.11273025721311569,
0.5164414644241333,
0.6370132565498352,
-0.33833929896354675,
-0.2158428579568863,
-0.021928438916802406,
-0.7186707258224487,
0.23245948553085327,
0.0379556342959404,
0.011207527481019497,
-0.12582053244113922,
0.3436230719089508,
0.7634152770042419,
0.13458293676376343,
-0.38766294717788696,
-0.12708638608455658,
-0.25788623094558716,
-0.5177757740020752,
-0.4407099187374115,
-0.17116738855838776,
-0.4048132598400116,
-0.2725760042667389,
0.3965222239494324,
-0.6619806885719299,
0.41886866092681885,
0.36282867193222046,
-0.297542542219162,
0.019237881526350975,
0.4035114049911499,
0.5144384503364563,
0.281406432390213,
-0.2706097960472107,
0.22773461043834686,
-0.23717299103736877,
-0.6983439922332764,
0.03569281846284866,
0.5770413279533386,
-0.01754099875688553,
-0.24534419178962708,
0.35725006461143494,
0.7299290895462036,
0.16051402688026428,
-0.904575765132904,
0.5878397822380066,
0.1676226258277893,
-0.38009315729141235,
-0.014380523934960365,
0.021464843302965164,
0.4356890618801117,
0.7114928960800171,
0.2392730861902237,
0.2848919630050659,
0.4409586489200592,
-0.2916053831577301,
0.25725916028022766,
0.3372024893760681,
-0.0736996978521347,
-0.24555806815624237,
0.8869199156761169,
0.2216646820306778,
0.24621212482452393,
0.43431466817855835,
-0.08447789400815964,
-0.05192893370985985,
0.3433777689933777,
0.29362425208091736,
0.7005363702774048,
-0.10434572398662567,
0.23785795271396637,
0.24353991448879242,
0.05545588955283165,
-0.29084038734436035,
0.4863092005252838,
0.3763975203037262,
-0.8056010007858276,
-0.6895095109939575,
-1.178109049797058,
-0.32220783829689026,
0.24464230239391327,
-0.3281579911708832,
0.16792742908000946,
-0.2731735408306122,
-0.19024312496185303,
0.3468170464038849,
-0.35412847995758057,
-0.8497830033302307,
0.05906694382429123,
0.2217104285955429,
0.9820867776870728,
-0.7179788947105408,
0.8779318332672119,
0.6126876473426819,
-0.16150102019309998,
-0.44662532210350037,
-0.44205573201179504,
0.09467621892690659,
-0.6194657683372498,
0.6663442254066467,
0.019744517281651497,
0.11157812178134918,
0.15222403407096863,
-0.77496337890625,
-0.8305065035820007,
1.0163352489471436,
0.5512280464172363,
-1.067867398262024,
-0.13217143714427948,
0.24375644326210022,
0.43821319937705994,
-0.18416565656661987,
-0.20724080502986908,
0.43559256196022034,
0.31393754482269287,
-0.1450529843568802,
-0.823908269405365,
-0.15142951905727386,
-0.13796797394752502,
-0.20396021008491516,
-0.05536714568734169,
-0.452534943819046,
1.0445226430892944,
-0.11050678789615631,
0.10842239111661911,
0.1812877058982849,
0.5031651854515076,
0.3953953683376312,
-0.039276376366615295,
0.12960192561149597,
0.43678900599479675,
0.5787396430969238,
-0.13721340894699097,
1.0736379623413086,
-0.1870749592781067,
0.4446740448474884,
0.8462001085281372,
-0.435468852519989,
0.7193328738212585,
0.2541775405406952,
-0.20282205939292908,
0.019670164212584496,
0.4306187033653259,
-0.23644693195819855,
0.4430689513683319,
0.3860822021961212,
-0.1847287267446518,
-0.2631527781486511,
-0.08423549681901932,
-0.3056100606918335,
0.2633621096611023,
0.6389238834381104,
-0.30553168058395386,
-0.32004231214523315,
0.6183624267578125,
-0.23198767006397247,
0.014623213559389114,
-0.4685380458831787,
0.3445471227169037,
0.23613736033439636,
-0.08435053378343582,
0.3454110026359558,
0.15521594882011414,
0.8030465841293335,
-0.5629836916923523,
-0.11912965029478073,
-0.3547716438770294,
0.1915522962808609,
-0.23096352815628052,
-0.8030471205711365,
0.10782680660486221,
-0.10630505532026291,
-0.23633959889411926,
-0.09862402081489563,
0.7796651124954224,
-0.47771531343460083,
-0.7327525615692139,
0.288614422082901,
0.5923817157745361,
0.05170569196343422,
0.12614229321479797,
-0.6001010537147522,
0.03823553025722504,
-0.15810464322566986,
-0.3119898736476898,
0.21361219882965088,
0.1766863465309143,
-0.12407318502664566,
0.6510496139526367,
0.7814089059829712,
0.28739482164382935,
0.06128116697072983,
0.14435766637325287,
0.8160723447799683,
-0.6678135395050049,
-0.10415206104516983,
-0.6343419551849365,
0.28896117210388184,
0.24631687998771667,
-0.0923033356666565,
0.5456499457359314,
0.4749109447002411,
0.9244063496589661,
-0.5591756701469421,
0.8686826825141907,
-0.07636136561632156,
0.8187801837921143,
-0.5524160265922546,
0.760106086730957,
-0.5861400365829468,
-0.1385628581047058,
-0.15604142844676971,
-0.8459201455116272,
-0.7384888529777527,
0.450758695602417,
-0.08228988200426102,
-0.18553443253040314,
0.45468005537986755,
0.7643759250640869,
-0.26567578315734863,
0.12440783530473709,
0.25110235810279846,
0.29316145181655884,
0.3852221369743347,
0.7012448906898499,
0.4355144500732422,
-0.14981161057949066,
-0.013486874289810658,
-0.037246327847242355,
-0.45315125584602356,
-0.3405962884426117,
-0.9371209740638733,
-0.8050849437713623,
-0.5215730667114258,
-0.19857360422611237,
-0.13578951358795166,
0.20313414931297302,
0.9877692461013794,
0.6116325259208679,
-0.9046744108200073,
-0.004856719169765711,
0.1349116861820221,
-0.5550758838653564,
-0.16233526170253754,
-0.1402391642332077,
0.4041779339313507,
-0.05370756983757019,
-0.5171633362770081,
0.7101725339889526,
0.39160019159317017,
0.04091392084956169,
-0.36931124329566956,
0.05558677017688751,
-0.32937848567962646,
-0.15794098377227783,
0.9208796620368958,
0.46435484290122986,
-0.4771419167518616,
-0.1914159655570984,
0.12270358949899673,
-0.3598349094390869,
-0.17702616751194,
0.8046014904975891,
-0.5648455023765564,
0.26804471015930176,
0.5317438840866089,
0.9437700510025024,
-0.1718958020210266,
-0.203526571393013,
0.5963924527168274,
-0.6563952565193176,
0.09082117676734924,
0.17642758786678314,
0.3364979028701782,
0.5762779116630554,
-0.4620065987110138,
0.501026451587677,
0.2761405110359192,
-0.5134853720664978,
-0.5179567337036133,
0.03271382302045822,
-1.0465189218521118,
-0.6238533854484558,
1.517096757888794,
0.07084619253873825,
-0.25687292218208313,
-0.11449044942855835,
-0.055549249053001404,
0.3409450948238373,
0.24266795814037323,
0.21645037829875946,
0.43390345573425293,
-0.0019314587116241455,
-0.10523653030395508,
-1.024856448173523,
0.527880072593689,
0.23632240295410156,
-0.7200186252593994,
0.21382609009742737,
0.6575541496276855,
0.5068705081939697,
-0.09556280821561813,
0.42868679761886597,
-0.3072497248649597,
0.018104083836078644,
-0.2713337540626526,
0.31423553824424744,
-0.3184625804424286,
-0.36473143100738525,
-0.4162510335445404,
0.27387064695358276,
-0.10267665982246399,
0.2240944355726242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15163v1 | A Syntax-Injected Approach for Faster and More Accurate Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-21T14:08:25 | 2024-06-21T14:08:25 | Muhammad Imran, Olga Kellert, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment Analysis (SA) is a crucial aspect of Natural Language Processing
(NLP), addressing subjective assessments in textual content. Syntactic parsing
is useful in SA because explicit syntactic information can improve accuracy
while providing explainability, but it tends to be a computational bottleneck
in practice due to the slowness of parsing algorithms. This paper addresses
said bottleneck by using a SEquence Labeling Syntactic Parser (SELSP) to inject
syntax into SA. By treating dependency parsing as a sequence labeling problem,
we greatly enhance the speed of syntax-based SA. SELSP is trained and evaluated
on a ternary polarity classification task, demonstrating its faster performance
and better accuracy in polarity prediction tasks compared to conventional
parsers like Stanza and to heuristic approaches that use shallow syntactic
rules for SA like VADER. This increased speed and improved accuracy make SELSP
particularly appealing to SA practitioners in both research and industry. In
addition, we test several sentiment dictionaries on our SELSP to see which one
improves the performance in polarity prediction tasks. Moreover, we compare the
SELSP with Transformer-based models trained on a 5-label classification task.
The results show that dictionaries that capture polarity judgment variation
provide better results than dictionaries that ignore polarity judgment
variation. Moreover, we show that SELSP is considerably faster than
Transformer-based models in polarity prediction tasks. | [
-0.41986700892448425,
-0.517083466053009,
0.4609747529029846,
0.42560702562332153,
-0.4679598808288574,
0.2650904655456543,
-0.23777170479297638,
-0.31429803371429443,
0.39444485306739807,
0.4060952365398407,
-0.30509594082832336,
-0.5460763573646545,
-0.5934368968009949,
0.32486167550086975,
-0.09193312376737595,
0.9740832448005676,
0.4376448392868042,
0.14187359809875488,
-0.11789946258068085,
-0.3775080740451813,
-0.2851991653442383,
-0.6478990316390991,
-0.35572120547294617,
-0.020546624436974525,
0.29752787947654724,
0.10759556293487549,
0.7246300578117371,
0.18470565974712372,
0.5814821124076843,
0.39501655101776123,
-0.6440514326095581,
-0.009419426321983337,
0.10817009210586548,
0.33532872796058655,
-0.3894197344779968,
-0.4845533072948456,
-0.4497251808643341,
-0.1315012276172638,
0.3028630316257477,
0.8153079152107239,
-0.05477528274059296,
0.20262457430362701,
-0.08141136914491653,
1.0146631002426147,
-0.5153343081474304,
0.25904881954193115,
-0.38575130701065063,
0.2906380295753479,
-0.14385554194450378,
0.0032119667157530785,
-0.6451859474182129,
-0.3640425205230713,
0.37462693452835083,
-0.20375889539718628,
0.33990678191185,
-0.02662203647196293,
0.8116851449012756,
0.3514725863933563,
-0.10164574533700943,
-0.0773921012878418,
-0.3748883306980133,
0.6488807201385498,
-1.0793559551239014,
0.35198214650154114,
-0.3463941812515259,
0.17242111265659332,
0.24189139902591705,
-0.5289043188095093,
-0.651623010635376,
0.06913034617900848,
-0.14446288347244263,
0.08464048057794571,
0.011441285721957684,
0.2092520147562027,
0.4848470985889435,
0.2879844605922699,
-0.4480902850627899,
-0.21911576390266418,
0.03432674705982208,
0.033386971801519394,
0.43916723132133484,
0.03745289891958237,
0.26884904503822327,
-0.8580009937286377,
-0.46162861585617065,
-0.006303961854428053,
-0.4089629352092743,
0.19351226091384888,
0.14031440019607544,
0.603540301322937,
-0.04759952425956726,
0.6587266325950623,
-0.24505853652954102,
0.8071534633636475,
0.21593791246414185,
0.12790846824645996,
0.656534731388092,
-0.41482415795326233,
-0.2619054913520813,
-0.05661255493760109,
0.7451484203338623,
0.4283813238143921,
0.1914474368095398,
0.16425487399101257,
-0.12931698560714722,
0.42471253871917725,
0.3216981887817383,
-0.5537222027778625,
0.023722227662801743,
0.28122347593307495,
-0.3041483759880066,
-0.49817797541618347,
0.05621948838233948,
-1.1064172983169556,
-0.6466590166091919,
-0.39884456992149353,
0.09258053451776505,
-0.30855095386505127,
-0.11124388128519058,
0.16354098916053772,
-0.3843068778514862,
0.2873191237449646,
0.21015135943889618,
-0.7026016116142273,
0.016484398394823074,
0.8706276416778564,
0.880811870098114,
-0.01223553717136383,
-0.0532112717628479,
-0.6293910145759583,
-0.23228564858436584,
-0.13493794202804565,
0.921262264251709,
-0.48411431908607483,
-0.06863881647586823,
0.10972298681735992,
-0.060364462435245514,
0.03603396192193031,
-0.5138226747512817,
0.319635272026062,
-0.6174392700195312,
0.15037478506565094,
-0.562354326248169,
-0.4415898323059082,
-0.2291504591703415,
0.1789797991514206,
-0.666054368019104,
0.8661152720451355,
0.23225069046020508,
-0.7219709157943726,
0.5297494530677795,
-0.43679308891296387,
-0.7502953410148621,
0.1592416614294052,
0.030143603682518005,
-0.39206618070602417,
0.12943798303604126,
0.3128794729709625,
0.7093732953071594,
-0.10329917818307877,
0.6306140422821045,
-0.34481531381607056,
-0.06494715809822083,
0.2834724485874176,
0.07159975916147232,
0.8228268027305603,
0.00953275803476572,
-0.5937159657478333,
0.10902275890111923,
-0.5667070150375366,
0.04112333059310913,
-0.25659406185150146,
-0.04025689885020256,
-0.295640230178833,
0.18115408718585968,
-0.20821410417556763,
0.2389451265335083,
0.1409347951412201,
-0.45220720767974854,
0.09840912371873856,
-1.146815299987793,
0.3884658217430115,
0.8468032479286194,
-0.07079774886369705,
0.6837979555130005,
0.24264094233512878,
0.554274320602417,
0.17807798087596893,
0.24375316500663757,
-0.02001669816672802,
-0.594016432762146,
-0.9877704977989197,
0.03303113952279091,
0.14265014231204987,
0.6949684619903564,
-0.961637556552887,
0.7683075070381165,
-0.23628754913806915,
-0.3414054811000824,
-0.381821870803833,
0.20360784232616425,
0.4964258074760437,
0.5052940845489502,
0.5655773282051086,
-0.442561537027359,
-0.6970881223678589,
-0.7780735492706299,
-0.7964879870414734,
-0.4735395908355713,
0.41415178775787354,
0.10165999084711075,
0.08771239966154099,
-0.0009578968747518957,
1.0076507329940796,
-0.7282716631889343,
-0.1586533784866333,
-0.7203212380409241,
0.3507521450519562,
0.5562396049499512,
0.06955640763044357,
0.3799950182437897,
-0.5448537468910217,
-0.8225831389427185,
-0.09549978375434875,
-0.7352600693702698,
-0.3888988792896271,
-0.06852375715970993,
-0.04335976392030716,
0.5347058176994324,
0.2500273883342743,
-0.629122257232666,
0.04895729571580887,
0.13716499507427216,
-0.6020213961601257,
0.27204668521881104,
0.3695448338985443,
-0.11210907995700836,
-0.8515998125076294,
-0.1053459569811821,
0.3249921202659607,
-0.33914247155189514,
-0.726656973361969,
0.03366967290639877,
0.028244880959391594,
-0.14486557245254517,
-0.6761023998260498,
0.10061196237802505,
-0.25764283537864685,
-0.10857647657394409,
0.1921108216047287,
-0.039873622357845306,
0.44469237327575684,
0.44039392471313477,
-0.04752396419644356,
0.8176881074905396,
0.44468680024147034,
-0.16099147498607635,
0.08657221496105194,
0.22872735559940338,
-0.12224005162715912,
0.4003036320209503,
-0.6058374047279358,
0.13305619359016418,
-0.36356401443481445,
0.007235888857394457,
-0.7108464241027832,
0.3071384131908417,
0.29276901483535767,
-0.19053293764591217,
0.3957040309906006,
-0.2216176688671112,
-0.27101102471351624,
-0.16593755781650543,
-0.6037975549697876,
0.12427075207233429,
0.6009213328361511,
-0.6304160356521606,
0.7950001955032349,
0.3410400152206421,
-0.2913123071193695,
-0.8701513409614563,
-0.42132410407066345,
0.04567437618970871,
-0.23402971029281616,
-0.507810115814209,
0.12648075819015503,
0.18913663923740387,
-0.33763957023620605,
-0.2577422261238098,
0.016648896038532257,
0.3266322910785675,
0.04271792247891426,
0.13065126538276672,
0.4227173328399658,
-0.2766772508621216,
0.1411367803812027,
0.0075621879659593105,
-0.42446231842041016,
0.1604735255241394,
0.07724274694919586,
0.6379904747009277,
-0.7170801758766174,
0.043656740337610245,
-0.3811332583427429,
0.2774798572063446,
0.4900427758693695,
-0.24425175786018372,
0.5659157633781433,
0.35642009973526,
0.1871234029531479,
-0.4581347405910492,
-0.6571526527404785,
0.13844864070415497,
-0.4887895882129669,
0.08091133087873459,
-0.07399062812328339,
-0.5213144421577454,
0.12417382001876831,
-0.03516139090061188,
-0.3043905794620514,
0.4911360740661621,
0.34023362398147583,
-0.27716973423957825,
0.9805852174758911,
0.4362074136734009,
-0.34340426325798035,
0.5695312023162842,
-0.3358129858970642,
0.6391446590423584,
-0.5277633666992188,
0.01036001369357109,
-0.43182462453842163,
0.08063589781522751,
-0.3155999183654785,
-0.5874798893928528,
0.3686772286891937,
0.03947998583316803,
-0.008474483154714108,
0.4212689697742462,
-0.7082043290138245,
0.5273968577384949,
0.28368812799453735,
0.01979333534836769,
0.08205979317426682,
-0.13495175540447235,
0.2643139660358429,
-0.2145022600889206,
-0.4590168595314026,
-0.38979750871658325,
0.7797778248786926,
0.2965947389602661,
0.45472654700279236,
0.04454208165407181,
0.6377825736999512,
0.48115837574005127,
0.2710084617137909,
-0.8649474382400513,
0.8463574647903442,
-0.6129540801048279,
-0.058988891541957855,
0.008793204091489315,
-0.07016092538833618,
-0.26519837975502014,
0.3339882493019104,
-0.17218144237995148,
-0.11218982934951782,
0.33862587809562683,
0.22871683537960052,
-0.3444502353668213,
-0.009341215714812279,
-1.0029877424240112,
0.7962871789932251,
-0.13219663500785828,
-0.21630790829658508,
-0.04552093893289566,
-0.9035152196884155,
0.06444789469242096,
0.4129413366317749,
0.13539084792137146,
-0.2862473130226135,
0.08430168032646179,
0.6596843600273132,
-0.40463489294052124,
1.1147550344467163,
-0.6242247819900513,
0.1299571990966797,
0.492876261472702,
-0.10348520427942276,
0.4433228373527527,
0.006696832366287708,
-0.14350582659244537,
0.4503538906574249,
-0.1244225800037384,
-0.06763501465320587,
-0.7959726452827454,
0.3795127868652344,
-0.43527868390083313,
-0.6828300952911377,
-0.7076154947280884,
-0.016743751242756844,
-0.26077109575271606,
-0.06545807421207428,
0.07526329159736633,
0.33569231629371643,
0.11768952012062073,
-0.29119881987571716,
0.5485689640045166,
-0.43313226103782654,
0.5149985551834106,
0.23471935093402863,
-0.03957348316907883,
-0.5695676803588867,
0.9617449641227722,
0.016610225662589073,
0.3588345944881439,
0.38140010833740234,
0.3539828956127167,
-0.3506973683834076,
-0.19040964543819427,
-0.569402277469635,
0.3345341384410858,
-0.8725696802139282,
-0.6118074059486389,
-0.8426792621612549,
-0.08860228210687637,
-0.6741134524345398,
-0.4225103259086609,
-0.34610629081726074,
-0.6444410681724548,
-0.2539454698562622,
-0.09571801126003265,
0.3388625681400299,
0.5672460794448853,
0.2359990030527115,
0.30221790075302124,
-0.6559752225875854,
0.46656835079193115,
0.13470983505249023,
0.28360530734062195,
-0.3303740620613098,
-0.23668518662452698,
-0.04402175545692444,
-0.3967292904853821,
-0.18676601350307465,
-1.1912518739700317,
0.5849025249481201,
0.25318431854248047,
0.07716688513755798,
0.28989142179489136,
-0.03906411677598953,
0.5926868915557861,
-0.440680593252182,
1.0125983953475952,
0.2587299346923828,
-1.445137619972229,
0.8252732157707214,
0.04331895336508751,
0.23204077780246735,
0.7430526614189148,
0.15505588054656982,
-0.38608112931251526,
-0.4894654154777527,
-0.58564293384552,
-1.0536317825317383,
0.5009599924087524,
-0.2083294689655304,
-0.06883449852466583,
-0.34239283204078674,
0.29762738943099976,
0.17559337615966797,
0.3863922357559204,
-0.6618542075157166,
-0.22304898500442505,
-0.36825355887413025,
-0.38702842593193054,
-0.23360508680343628,
-0.5276018977165222,
0.10986229032278061,
-0.48171746730804443,
0.774570107460022,
-0.37548378109931946,
0.14646068215370178,
0.3272166848182678,
-0.30173856019973755,
0.09182484447956085,
0.510338306427002,
0.14566569030284882,
0.23501449823379517,
-0.153451606631279,
0.3813912868499756,
0.26557981967926025,
-0.15108761191368103,
0.035345010459423065,
-0.14191554486751556,
-0.31505078077316284,
0.307331919670105,
0.3183571994304657,
0.6053732633590698,
-0.040605783462524414,
-0.7099642753601074,
0.9370445013046265,
0.17711223661899567,
0.343608021736145,
-0.26036012172698975,
-0.0705898180603981,
0.027164293453097343,
0.3974204957485199,
-0.27981510758399963,
0.3881104290485382,
0.48694202303886414,
-0.2978523075580597,
-0.06249918416142464,
0.47138550877571106,
-0.3087129592895508,
-0.36903777718544006,
0.2705889940261841,
0.24310769140720367,
-0.2833048701286316,
0.34997037053108215,
-0.29506078362464905,
-0.9863981604576111,
0.6757156848907471,
0.31989720463752747,
1.077194094657898,
-0.13115194439888,
0.6125392317771912,
0.4558553397655487,
0.08016879111528397,
0.036624908447265625,
0.6293646097183228,
-0.06920899450778961,
-0.7100649476051331,
-0.5980579257011414,
-0.8826811909675598,
-0.3638187050819397,
-0.5352396368980408,
-0.7071242332458496,
0.4394497871398926,
-0.71119624376297,
-0.30537840723991394,
0.21243996918201447,
-0.413191020488739,
-0.44381675124168396,
0.15967844426631927,
0.12782181799411774,
0.6620008945465088,
-1.1682990789413452,
0.3416268825531006,
0.7336032390594482,
-0.3720613718032837,
-0.5866886973381042,
-0.3239917457103729,
-0.17452220618724823,
-0.4690834879875183,
0.7077142000198364,
0.47303953766822815,
-0.2162010222673416,
-0.2979130446910858,
-0.5039194226264954,
-0.6383005976676941,
0.6088207960128784,
0.1269770860671997,
-0.46557679772377014,
0.3346997797489166,
0.30700454115867615,
0.8391872644424438,
-0.20650482177734375,
0.09176357090473175,
0.6887699365615845,
0.23798595368862152,
-0.34671518206596375,
-0.478407621383667,
0.2702611982822418,
-0.418641060590744,
0.18414688110351562,
0.48507100343704224,
-0.5248652100563049,
0.6648743152618408,
-0.2918488383293152,
-0.16673386096954346,
-0.30673637986183167,
0.7392460703849792,
-0.03945545852184296,
0.3987818658351898,
0.9144877791404724,
0.7245281934738159,
0.37803637981414795,
0.024711187928915024,
0.7623347640037537,
-0.2879517078399658,
0.4845269024372101,
0.964270293712616,
-0.5077654123306274,
0.9243780374526978,
0.8085376620292664,
-0.32623985409736633,
0.8951864242553711,
0.035958319902420044,
-0.06315772980451584,
0.4616425037384033,
-0.08696754276752472,
-0.39921778440475464,
-0.2681269943714142,
-0.26495468616485596,
-0.40501806139945984,
0.23617668449878693,
0.263279527425766,
-0.4636256992816925,
-0.09109530597925186,
0.06988608092069626,
0.02805844135582447,
0.13839396834373474,
0.05509694293141365,
0.9836269021034241,
0.05273621529340744,
-0.7300015687942505,
0.338930606842041,
-0.08141067624092102,
0.6097421646118164,
-0.21365876495838165,
-0.03537634760141373,
-0.11526134610176086,
0.1331482082605362,
-0.3152693510055542,
-0.8761104345321655,
0.5571404695510864,
0.07131104171276093,
-0.12352080643177032,
-0.5517016053199768,
0.8665052056312561,
-0.06572848558425903,
-0.40623968839645386,
0.3274991512298584,
0.4112779200077057,
-0.24958212673664093,
-0.009263021871447563,
-0.5319707989692688,
-0.12557028234004974,
0.04703531786799431,
-0.3776932954788208,
0.10964223742485046,
0.21943873167037964,
0.23572179675102234,
0.4594777226448059,
0.5988390445709229,
0.14023393392562866,
-0.004268636927008629,
0.472991406917572,
1.057586669921875,
-1.0253504514694214,
-0.5626729726791382,
-0.9664186835289001,
0.67086261510849,
-0.25009676814079285,
-0.3388240933418274,
0.5305222272872925,
0.37134894728660583,
0.5080744028091431,
-0.2814187705516815,
0.6363593935966492,
-0.2742807865142822,
0.541111946105957,
-0.4724906086921692,
0.2754339873790741,
-0.31010422110557556,
0.5158340930938721,
-0.3614334464073181,
-0.6893081665039062,
-0.49755585193634033,
0.6713768839836121,
-0.3804596960544586,
-0.27645817399024963,
0.7765654921531677,
0.7891314625740051,
0.2905188202857971,
0.37686634063720703,
-0.0903717502951622,
0.36324575543403625,
0.26538729667663574,
0.24335438013076782,
1.0306836366653442,
-0.27518782019615173,
-0.03896211087703705,
-0.9020324945449829,
-0.11659206449985504,
0.0284188874065876,
-0.8478102087974548,
-0.9567204117774963,
-0.3447313606739044,
-0.43347880244255066,
-0.6932796239852905,
-0.00903571117669344,
0.9204221367835999,
0.30380818247795105,
-0.9231312274932861,
-0.0364469476044178,
-0.16679656505584717,
0.19580543041229248,
-0.17997290194034576,
-0.3708443343639374,
0.18634948134422302,
-0.8659078478813171,
-0.37916332483291626,
0.3674869239330292,
0.6039329171180725,
-0.27250173687934875,
-0.13378971815109253,
0.31014925241470337,
-0.1992185413837433,
-0.10891474783420563,
0.9857550859451294,
0.04343479499220848,
-0.8336398601531982,
-0.3918481767177582,
-0.01940523087978363,
0.11038941144943237,
0.31169968843460083,
0.9076055288314819,
-1.0120378732681274,
0.5182127356529236,
0.8112416863441467,
0.538917601108551,
0.15314313769340515,
0.31490954756736755,
0.40870559215545654,
-0.7663968801498413,
0.061949290335178375,
0.4470003843307495,
0.31297144293785095,
0.431115984916687,
-0.6348513960838318,
0.5062282681465149,
0.47380679845809937,
-0.23152552545070648,
-0.7838975787162781,
0.14142265915870667,
-1.447779893875122,
-0.23197129368782043,
1.212865948677063,
-0.03266853094100952,
-0.3060024380683899,
-0.17474345862865448,
-0.21879008412361145,
0.16639770567417145,
-0.4151220917701721,
0.5521789193153381,
0.32059237360954285,
-0.10284414887428284,
0.10384944081306458,
-0.2092754989862442,
0.44022440910339355,
1.045809268951416,
-0.8474186658859253,
0.13609907031059265,
0.38816577196121216,
0.17123450338840485,
0.34333041310310364,
0.5495405197143555,
-0.013099469244480133,
0.06022988632321358,
-0.25742095708847046,
0.191987082362175,
0.2710835933685303,
-0.4605710804462433,
-0.613529622554779,
0.4115697741508484,
0.10411957651376724,
0.13659457862377167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15130v1 | Assessing Good, Bad and Ugly Arguments Generated by ChatGPT: a New Dataset, its Methodology and Associated Tasks | 2024-06-21T13:27:10 | 2024-06-21T13:27:10 | Victor Hugo Nascimento Rocha, Igor Cataneo Silveira, Paulo Pirozelli, Denis Deratani Mauá, Fabio Gagliardi Cozman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has sparked concerns about
their potential to spread misinformation. As a result, there is a pressing need
for tools to identify ``fake arguments'' generated by such models. To create
these tools, examples of texts generated by LLMs are needed. This paper
introduces a methodology to obtain good, bad and ugly arguments from
argumentative essays produced by ChatGPT, OpenAI's LLM. We then describe a
novel dataset containing a set of diverse arguments, ArGPT. We assess the
effectiveness of our dataset and establish baselines for several
argumentation-related tasks. Finally, we show that the artificially generated
data relates well to human argumentation and thus is useful as a tool to train
and test systems for the defined tasks. | [
-0.4383307993412018,
-1.1362603902816772,
0.24709564447402954,
-0.13452354073524475,
-0.37907931208610535,
-0.18707171082496643,
-0.035527102649211884,
-0.15689654648303986,
-0.09600947797298431,
0.440023273229599,
-0.3560118079185486,
-0.37216779589653015,
-0.47645220160484314,
-0.024570384994149208,
-0.5440947413444519,
1.5097047090530396,
-0.17176802456378937,
0.30547896027565,
-0.2909662425518036,
-0.12746770679950714,
-0.32348400354385376,
-0.3963085412979126,
-0.9589016437530518,
-0.22377857565879822,
0.6793869137763977,
0.4250982701778412,
0.7467858791351318,
0.25356921553611755,
0.4563535451889038,
0.26954448223114014,
0.1917194128036499,
0.29659345746040344,
-0.4897450804710388,
0.02517995424568653,
-0.33915001153945923,
-0.28466227650642395,
-0.08406542986631393,
0.34443801641464233,
0.40816453099250793,
0.2127288579940796,
-0.0470118410885334,
0.3397160470485687,
-0.1657027006149292,
0.21514303982257843,
-0.5045706629753113,
0.08972945809364319,
-0.8009364008903503,
0.14976772665977478,
-0.44764989614486694,
-0.2684386670589447,
-0.2783919870853424,
-0.6138913631439209,
0.09426365792751312,
-0.2626712918281555,
0.01982586272060871,
0.016972122713923454,
1.1480050086975098,
0.05975256487727165,
-0.24593804776668549,
-0.7248782515525818,
-0.7397829294204712,
0.640119194984436,
-0.9651481509208679,
-0.02598929964005947,
0.03708553686738014,
0.3985530734062195,
-0.47133350372314453,
-0.7277444005012512,
-0.7624549269676208,
-0.23831027746200562,
-0.05693129450082779,
0.3816535174846649,
-0.47173625230789185,
-0.09707245230674744,
0.11889605969190598,
0.44301146268844604,
-0.5808696746826172,
0.0972801074385643,
-0.34042197465896606,
-0.25791990756988525,
0.6542954444885254,
-0.014255165122449398,
0.5789356231689453,
-0.34228280186653137,
-0.272360235452652,
-0.14410844445228577,
-0.7877136468887329,
-0.29442694783210754,
1.0017001628875732,
0.17538025975227356,
-0.03607399761676788,
0.7429580688476562,
0.1060950830578804,
0.6942933797836304,
-0.16702407598495483,
0.12712742388248444,
-0.06616269797086716,
-0.11409185081720352,
-0.3481699228286743,
0.0398113913834095,
1.0046885013580322,
0.31307175755500793,
0.5263150930404663,
-0.16568945348262787,
-0.2472321093082428,
0.19543901085853577,
0.30418694019317627,
-0.6497469544410706,
-0.34982195496559143,
0.2075476050376892,
-0.4581016004085541,
-0.5883010625839233,
-0.07626745104789734,
-1.1142776012420654,
-0.591787576675415,
-0.2199312150478363,
0.36677923798561096,
-0.4203484058380127,
-0.09761548042297363,
0.010647748596966267,
-0.1906219720840454,
0.35744330286979675,
0.13799425959587097,
-0.5973694920539856,
0.3368149995803833,
0.6173940896987915,
0.72590172290802,
-0.35159748792648315,
-0.09408095479011536,
-0.5696020722389221,
-0.22041702270507812,
-0.6242781281471252,
1.5223790407180786,
-0.5339986681938171,
-0.08964075893163681,
0.06831763684749603,
-0.1744350790977478,
0.10031522810459137,
-0.7179936170578003,
1.2323447465896606,
-0.3436526954174042,
0.6213326454162598,
-0.054743796586990356,
-0.5625231266021729,
-0.11028827726840973,
0.4493739902973175,
-0.41316109895706177,
1.0495879650115967,
-0.08133217692375183,
-0.7004104852676392,
0.4103471338748932,
-1.0646553039550781,
-0.31876659393310547,
0.18723200261592865,
-0.2495315968990326,
-0.6348995566368103,
-0.001880244235508144,
0.19680871069431305,
0.5981688499450684,
-0.2591998279094696,
0.12274526059627533,
-0.3712868094444275,
-0.07159072160720825,
0.274152010679245,
-0.7307041883468628,
0.6934740543365479,
0.414516806602478,
-0.30180519819259644,
-0.10388127714395523,
-0.6227928996086121,
-0.05593685433268547,
0.25504887104034424,
-0.29969605803489685,
-0.36307039856910706,
0.4208460748195648,
-0.22854308784008026,
0.04682060703635216,
-0.07301854342222214,
-0.6245724558830261,
0.06991982460021973,
-0.6036410331726074,
0.5256836414337158,
0.8550907969474792,
0.3398683965206146,
-0.2542499005794525,
-0.3534643352031708,
0.48835307359695435,
0.2531019449234009,
-0.1000233069062233,
-0.07833539694547653,
-0.6252674460411072,
-0.8042082786560059,
0.08293084800243378,
0.20607729256153107,
0.5453024506568909,
-0.5592091679573059,
-0.02223682962357998,
-0.09241258352994919,
-0.7530348896980286,
-0.37583601474761963,
-0.10955069959163666,
0.2546214163303375,
0.3322697579860687,
0.02728213183581829,
0.013847959227859974,
-0.6138132214546204,
-1.2266716957092285,
-0.5013025403022766,
-0.3200360834598541,
0.027387848123908043,
0.4903602600097656,
0.6266874074935913,
-0.07584585249423981,
0.8073338270187378,
-0.20716841518878937,
0.2021760195493698,
0.06491514295339584,
0.5997419357299805,
0.01863388530910015,
0.24724887311458588,
0.4835933744907379,
-0.5267369747161865,
-0.22311308979988098,
0.12465503066778183,
-0.5422958731651306,
-0.22469530999660492,
-0.3162612318992615,
-0.35026296973228455,
0.11976141482591629,
0.2783762216567993,
-0.6341797113418579,
0.16324414312839508,
0.37784892320632935,
-0.3328680992126465,
0.9074693322181702,
0.13548092544078827,
0.2532983422279358,
-1.1175535917282104,
-0.050636280328035355,
0.2505933344364166,
-0.23388352990150452,
-0.4312196373939514,
0.057999707758426666,
-0.49135565757751465,
-0.31789514422416687,
-0.5432822704315186,
0.8576143980026245,
-0.10117816179990768,
0.4333697259426117,
-0.008387772366404533,
0.1951960325241089,
-0.2485247701406479,
0.328180730342865,
-0.22777767479419708,
0.8666216135025024,
0.20810863375663757,
-0.23200008273124695,
0.5871342420578003,
0.13638529181480408,
-0.4630564749240875,
0.7755906581878662,
-0.563479483127594,
0.20992949604988098,
-0.09267596155405045,
0.08358084410429001,
-1.3493202924728394,
-0.5196844935417175,
0.5297961235046387,
-0.22501768171787262,
-0.191886305809021,
-0.426177442073822,
-0.5348560214042664,
-0.3328035771846771,
-0.15563847124576569,
0.043054331094026566,
0.4605478346347809,
-0.6766954064369202,
0.522539496421814,
0.4161042869091034,
-0.36062249541282654,
-0.5108665823936462,
-0.4169064462184906,
0.4049021005630493,
-0.7367331981658936,
-0.44947874546051025,
0.10573449730873108,
0.06985065340995789,
-0.5909608602523804,
-0.17355699837207794,
0.2321939617395401,
-0.1359485238790512,
-0.19290213286876678,
0.2968731224536896,
0.07799763232469559,
-0.5280274152755737,
0.11200736463069916,
-0.10506194084882736,
0.14087915420532227,
0.33169665932655334,
-0.04882113263010979,
0.3066948354244232,
-0.2179471105337143,
-0.4986356198787689,
0.0035223583690822124,
0.357931524515152,
0.4944642186164856,
0.11250955611467361,
0.28031042218208313,
0.444496750831604,
-0.3440649211406708,
-0.46273189783096313,
-0.5921135544776917,
0.12585552036762238,
-0.43337389826774597,
0.37466347217559814,
-0.045723218470811844,
-0.35802969336509705,
0.4508828818798065,
-0.14245355129241943,
0.659089207649231,
0.3852226138114929,
0.8499660491943359,
0.01051190122961998,
1.0153157711029053,
-0.23428702354431152,
-0.010581127367913723,
0.3040775954723358,
-0.002588863018900156,
0.47374066710472107,
-0.2190573513507843,
0.12610720098018646,
-0.5148435831069946,
-0.1855454295873642,
-0.5045949220657349,
-0.49664506316185,
-0.06535976380109787,
0.05119536444544792,
-0.4757750928401947,
-0.023216404020786285,
-0.5004355907440186,
0.6973214149475098,
0.3294563591480255,
-0.17169189453125,
0.07166517525911331,
0.1973200887441635,
-0.1865319162607193,
0.051605284214019775,
-0.6112658381462097,
-1.2485783100128174,
0.8764333724975586,
0.5195969939231873,
0.561120867729187,
-0.058184150606393814,
0.39111047983169556,
0.6076300144195557,
0.7943950295448303,
-0.99915611743927,
0.5839078426361084,
-0.4092002809047699,
-0.5623664259910583,
0.049623407423496246,
-0.37309256196022034,
-0.9381938576698303,
0.19566704332828522,
-0.07645152509212494,
-0.7573216557502747,
-0.058910541236400604,
0.23365165293216705,
-0.30044692754745483,
0.5491098165512085,
-0.9968194961547852,
0.9912627339363098,
-0.20344369113445282,
-0.3415619432926178,
0.1517397165298462,
0.014928443357348442,
0.6052519679069519,
0.07895410060882568,
-0.007807231042534113,
-0.054452769458293915,
0.2607877552509308,
1.1287338733673096,
-0.24694286286830902,
0.820997953414917,
-0.24028247594833374,
-0.38583698868751526,
0.726885199546814,
0.140536367893219,
0.5193613171577454,
0.00450693117454648,
-0.30407100915908813,
0.08085472881793976,
-0.004156270995736122,
-0.3042547404766083,
-0.6128803491592407,
0.5076526999473572,
-0.7356077432632446,
-0.5653082132339478,
-0.17102520167827606,
-0.2154199331998825,
-0.2999457120895386,
0.10972879081964493,
0.1701212227344513,
0.5066633820533752,
-0.5762521028518677,
-0.03337762877345085,
0.4068221151828766,
-0.48407861590385437,
0.32153260707855225,
0.2524320185184479,
0.029972989112138748,
-0.38213637471199036,
1.2725274562835693,
0.007822633720934391,
0.08015040308237076,
-0.15254175662994385,
0.513198971748352,
-0.24100597202777863,
-0.7209849953651428,
-0.6979177594184875,
-0.049149613827466965,
-0.7918037176132202,
-0.2897205948829651,
-0.34182804822921753,
-0.23224453628063202,
-0.1972026377916336,
0.017566177994012833,
-0.45881155133247375,
-0.266941636800766,
0.06931737810373306,
-0.021899858489632607,
0.268309086561203,
0.9823057651519775,
0.16552680730819702,
0.29483845829963684,
-0.42211395502090454,
0.1040089875459671,
0.31779974699020386,
0.40865880250930786,
-0.06876319646835327,
-0.19843657314777374,
0.0023127179592847824,
0.42432090640068054,
-0.6912786960601807,
-0.7364762425422668,
0.3937794864177704,
0.0012827384052798152,
0.6553769707679749,
0.6347470879554749,
0.0457189604640007,
0.615476131439209,
-0.4292095899581909,
1.1647562980651855,
-0.06017155945301056,
-0.5138614773750305,
0.3233772814273834,
-0.6974343657493591,
-0.20036888122558594,
0.18209561705589294,
0.41895487904548645,
-0.5269381999969482,
-0.4906693994998932,
-0.6509515643119812,
-0.5895988345146179,
0.4845238924026489,
0.21721035242080688,
0.24318832159042358,
-0.4749824106693268,
0.48809748888015747,
0.25628435611724854,
-0.12426991760730743,
-1.0429260730743408,
0.06465335935354233,
-0.28731974959373474,
-0.3491382300853729,
0.14118024706840515,
-0.1176842749118805,
-0.31799474358558655,
0.14185413718223572,
0.7893677353858948,
-0.15331822633743286,
0.468921422958374,
0.00662118149921298,
0.10426463186740875,
-0.023457303643226624,
0.4217339754104614,
0.7236027121543884,
0.3196697533130646,
0.07158072292804718,
0.285623162984848,
0.24746277928352356,
-0.3658493757247925,
0.16396412253379822,
-0.056373875588178635,
0.010698830708861351,
0.02450176328420639,
0.41998374462127686,
0.8063929677009583,
-0.1880398839712143,
-0.7944299578666687,
0.4260203242301941,
-0.0034463524352759123,
-0.36829453706741333,
-0.3623647689819336,
0.16657911241054535,
0.22974887490272522,
0.0017233811086043715,
-0.06263600289821625,
0.20205160975456238,
0.006211466621607542,
-0.605230450630188,
0.1818675994873047,
0.5931769013404846,
-0.4640912115573883,
-0.3169083297252655,
0.2217826247215271,
0.26227936148643494,
-0.5272255539894104,
0.5353293418884277,
-0.1377001255750656,
-0.3452712297439575,
0.3841749429702759,
0.36545976996421814,
0.6641199588775635,
0.053078409284353256,
0.38791900873184204,
0.2508409023284912,
0.06225625053048134,
0.005273640621453524,
0.1597365140914917,
0.2737031877040863,
-0.7950201034545898,
-0.43140411376953125,
-0.5228597521781921,
-0.3539380431175232,
0.7790677547454834,
-0.2519128620624542,
0.48025184869766235,
-0.2895820140838623,
0.1092798113822937,
0.16068078577518463,
-0.02968480996787548,
-0.399876207113266,
0.1555570662021637,
0.11580276489257812,
0.6813884377479553,
-0.9512068033218384,
0.27547982335090637,
0.89697265625,
-0.4066224694252014,
-0.5512118935585022,
0.19185401499271393,
-0.11917076259851456,
-0.8672816157341003,
0.6368653178215027,
-0.22485989332199097,
-0.18252937495708466,
-0.37842342257499695,
-0.7698991298675537,
-0.38420718908309937,
0.20681296288967133,
0.5125987529754639,
-0.25873303413391113,
0.059976574033498764,
0.4403541088104248,
0.6179063320159912,
-0.21707770228385925,
0.5196895003318787,
0.4151217043399811,
0.6133032441139221,
-0.012492450885474682,
-0.4656289219856262,
-0.012660423293709755,
-0.43293464183807373,
-0.3968108296394348,
0.061384543776512146,
-0.47793546319007874,
0.7762612700462341,
-0.014516779221594334,
-0.4303126633167267,
0.0909813717007637,
0.34557458758354187,
0.09089892357587814,
0.11474771052598953,
0.4587306082248688,
0.5312321186065674,
0.5699160099029541,
-0.06308312714099884,
1.041106104850769,
0.11450152844190598,
0.18451674282550812,
1.1293058395385742,
-0.15541444718837738,
0.967058539390564,
0.4108481705188751,
-0.07716017961502075,
0.5063754916191101,
0.9799243211746216,
-0.281098872423172,
0.15639705955982208,
0.7249501943588257,
-0.17608724534511566,
-0.3085678219795227,
0.10627168416976929,
-0.021358972415328026,
0.5466579794883728,
0.3235713839530945,
-0.17658032476902008,
-0.6966661214828491,
-0.0710505023598671,
0.1618596762418747,
-0.04189738258719444,
-0.04773015156388283,
0.9298622012138367,
-0.11979473382234573,
-0.9811993837356567,
0.48635029792785645,
0.07246024906635284,
0.7368446588516235,
-0.3296591639518738,
-0.4581019878387451,
-0.2546527683734894,
0.061510659754276276,
-0.14062321186065674,
-0.9077281951904297,
0.3032282888889313,
0.3366607129573822,
0.18449050188064575,
-0.008660922758281231,
0.7733933925628662,
-0.14086927473545074,
-0.5854329466819763,
-0.22221465408802032,
0.551094651222229,
0.5968272686004639,
0.23416653275489807,
-0.8938682675361633,
-0.3571821451187134,
-0.011517159640789032,
-0.4908113181591034,
0.19755546748638153,
0.6238805055618286,
-0.2428540289402008,
0.5785659551620483,
0.6564983129501343,
0.4372692406177521,
0.01481539849191904,
-0.05940093472599983,
0.6364486217498779,
-0.3788858950138092,
-0.03895413875579834,
-1.1648995876312256,
0.35402703285217285,
-0.21881814301013947,
-0.5775895118713379,
0.7320177555084229,
0.6819888353347778,
0.5644398927688599,
0.024096278473734856,
0.9072482585906982,
0.02449822425842285,
0.8144029974937439,
-0.4181266725063324,
0.815613329410553,
-0.3173329532146454,
0.19194579124450684,
-0.5119868516921997,
-0.7365232706069946,
-0.2205178439617157,
0.8101293444633484,
-0.49668556451797485,
0.059687644243240356,
0.418559193611145,
1.0015337467193604,
-0.4571758806705475,
0.28622445464134216,
0.19582314789295197,
0.29308584332466125,
0.6285961866378784,
0.3130035400390625,
1.316051959991455,
-0.43997761607170105,
0.7321959137916565,
0.0957111045718193,
-0.03335459902882576,
-0.005276089999824762,
-1.2562164068222046,
-0.9400268793106079,
-0.4759587347507477,
-0.5583879351615906,
-0.44051605463027954,
0.3282721936702728,
0.8606361150741577,
0.654238760471344,
-0.9586592316627502,
-0.2210225611925125,
-0.2472601681947708,
0.03600054234266281,
0.014553267508745193,
-0.2798897325992584,
0.42230597138404846,
-0.38978055119514465,
-0.6395573616027832,
0.2460637390613556,
-0.05574804171919823,
0.060541003942489624,
-0.3771756887435913,
-0.03362565487623215,
-0.1155531033873558,
0.6379756927490234,
0.6329417824745178,
0.26095542311668396,
-0.6597987413406372,
-0.6296474933624268,
-0.571661651134491,
0.18241918087005615,
0.20690135657787323,
0.8818795680999756,
-0.5609147548675537,
0.2458682358264923,
0.3007397949695587,
0.46160057187080383,
-0.0992409735918045,
0.04118793457746506,
0.7546899914741516,
-0.5917416214942932,
-0.10978368669748306,
0.24900226294994354,
0.4023612439632416,
0.3421798050403595,
-0.14905628561973572,
0.38959598541259766,
-0.017612650990486145,
-0.5525556206703186,
-1.0922629833221436,
-0.0855097696185112,
-0.7731093764305115,
-0.2976592481136322,
1.3473197221755981,
-0.44444388151168823,
-0.14903247356414795,
-0.22876082360744476,
-0.5047504305839539,
0.09854903072118759,
-0.40764319896698,
1.1202161312103271,
1.1513617038726807,
-0.23923930525779724,
0.08803389966487885,
-0.6914017796516418,
0.6263018250465393,
0.32497045397758484,
-1.2019696235656738,
0.4682650864124298,
0.5148131251335144,
0.32516101002693176,
0.21794471144676208,
0.2583562433719635,
-0.41913965344429016,
0.11025052517652512,
0.17370754480361938,
-0.16901297867298126,
0.10242266207933426,
0.10757952183485031,
0.09631795436143875,
0.2788199484348297,
0.019696909934282303,
-0.10552677512168884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15111v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15111v2 | Investigating the impact of 2D gesture representation on co-speech gesture generation | 2024-06-21T12:59:20 | 2024-06-24T08:19:00 | Teo Guichoux, Laure Soulier, Nicolas Obin, Catherine Pelachaud | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Co-speech gestures play a crucial role in the interactions between humans and
embodied conversational agents (ECA). Recent deep learning methods enable the
generation of realistic, natural co-speech gestures synchronized with speech,
but such approaches require large amounts of training data. "In-the-wild"
datasets, which compile videos from sources such as YouTube through human pose
detection models, offer a solution by providing 2D skeleton sequences that are
paired with speech. Concurrently, innovative lifting models have emerged,
capable of transforming these 2D pose sequences into their 3D counterparts,
leading to large and diverse datasets of 3D gestures. However, the derived 3D
pose estimation is essentially a pseudo-ground truth, with the actual ground
truth being the 2D motion data. This distinction raises questions about the
impact of gesture representation dimensionality on the quality of generated
motions, a topic that, to our knowledge, remains largely unexplored. In this
work, we evaluate the impact of the dimensionality of the training data, 2D or
3D joint coordinates, on the performance of a multimodal speech-to-gesture deep
generative model. We use a lifting model to convert 2D-generated sequences of
body pose to 3D. Then, we compare the sequence of gestures generated directly
in 3D to the gestures generated in 2D and lifted to 3D as post-processing. | [
-0.301509290933609,
-0.36510366201400757,
0.21737982332706451,
-0.1887182593345642,
-0.2805253565311432,
0.00658775120973587,
0.31434980034828186,
-0.8483168482780457,
0.46987754106521606,
0.09510435163974762,
-0.41711169481277466,
-0.5288847088813782,
-0.7564401030540466,
-0.09253181517124176,
-0.36310362815856934,
0.7770363092422485,
0.3047352135181427,
0.022210419178009033,
-0.3128623962402344,
-0.12612205743789673,
-0.2582343816757202,
-0.7899609208106995,
-0.3482453227043152,
-0.28256529569625854,
0.2959340810775757,
0.3479786515235901,
0.86161869764328,
0.20093874633312225,
0.22922690212726593,
0.26652660965919495,
0.061478130519390106,
0.1637512445449829,
-0.5351343154907227,
-0.0043967654928565025,
0.3492119610309601,
-0.30260831117630005,
-0.5536261796951294,
0.4160614013671875,
0.5835265517234802,
0.9556456208229065,
-0.04145948216319084,
-0.025990869849920273,
0.014863974414765835,
0.5030581951141357,
-0.33786454796791077,
0.11065104603767395,
-0.2645203173160553,
0.12341222912073135,
-0.22329428791999817,
0.01132224965840578,
0.04949986934661865,
-0.2439485788345337,
0.27279430627822876,
-0.3935479521751404,
0.5543269515037537,
-0.24487698078155518,
0.5863690376281738,
0.2756083905696869,
-0.4755026400089264,
-0.3444265127182007,
-0.6831985116004944,
0.245697483420372,
-0.32227644324302673,
0.693672776222229,
0.43620574474334717,
0.33266133069992065,
0.004522992763668299,
-0.6026561260223389,
-0.7869477272033691,
-0.22897042334079742,
0.012345629744231701,
0.11628945171833038,
0.060944341123104095,
0.014886679127812386,
0.49832817912101746,
0.21264272928237915,
-0.7594364285469055,
0.310361385345459,
-0.4338221848011017,
-0.16535939276218414,
1.0137168169021606,
0.07040585577487946,
0.3931296169757843,
-0.3102462589740753,
-0.47868427634239197,
-0.801554262638092,
-0.7462345957756042,
0.45550060272216797,
0.5910657644271851,
0.3521692454814911,
-0.7357632517814636,
0.5971401333808899,
-0.07533419132232666,
0.5924304127693176,
0.32649341225624084,
0.13522258400917053,
0.38953498005867004,
-0.2541360855102539,
-0.15998077392578125,
0.04338179901242256,
0.8332135081291199,
0.47877174615859985,
-0.006640686187893152,
-0.12553751468658447,
0.3386770784854889,
0.000011886630090884864,
0.05508669838309288,
-0.7277041077613831,
-0.5074301958084106,
0.28265050053596497,
-0.23090755939483643,
0.08409770578145981,
0.2695639729499817,
-0.722663402557373,
-0.7277515530586243,
-0.40479424595832825,
-0.05470086261630058,
-0.1523745059967041,
-0.6534108519554138,
0.11478284746408463,
-0.28342708945274353,
0.47756338119506836,
0.31635603308677673,
-0.9132724404335022,
-0.005771176423877478,
0.6086381673812866,
0.6625785827636719,
0.052224818617105484,
-0.015700742602348328,
-0.5611769556999207,
0.19966872036457062,
-0.5021706819534302,
0.3701377213001251,
-0.4188254475593567,
-0.5302374362945557,
-0.13507795333862305,
-0.4491153955459595,
-0.17159272730350494,
-0.6436967849731445,
0.4342957139015198,
-0.170802503824234,
0.38204896450042725,
-0.23743945360183716,
-0.48755863308906555,
-0.10168872028589249,
0.07033678889274597,
-0.696970522403717,
0.6624521017074585,
-0.19929327070713043,
-0.482722669839859,
0.606265127658844,
-0.29325249791145325,
-0.5031057596206665,
0.052734747529029846,
-0.6851837635040283,
-0.6639341711997986,
0.37256261706352234,
0.2599494755268097,
0.7234910130500793,
-0.10283143818378448,
-0.11944808810949326,
-0.4528210461139679,
-0.19931568205356598,
0.12148825824260712,
-0.2895640730857849,
0.5994312763214111,
-0.10323856770992279,
-0.23111668229103088,
-0.28247103095054626,
-0.8982149362564087,
0.00611644983291626,
0.06570348143577576,
-0.15492479503154755,
-0.2649601995944977,
0.004394089337438345,
-0.38811245560646057,
0.5565021634101868,
-0.06087145209312439,
-0.5044405460357666,
0.006080645136535168,
-0.5663402080535889,
0.007666176185011864,
0.11059536039829254,
-0.19432558119297028,
0.6055784821510315,
0.09098667651414871,
0.4052254855632782,
0.0546790175139904,
-0.20955057442188263,
-0.044002700597047806,
-0.5232114791870117,
-0.17940568923950195,
-0.4579352140426636,
-0.28671520948410034,
0.045309219509363174,
-0.7515655755996704,
0.3637598752975464,
-0.7105662822723389,
-0.4369855523109436,
-0.3403587341308594,
-0.2013423591852188,
0.42995166778564453,
0.057970281690359116,
0.19806484878063202,
-0.28798961639404297,
-0.45307520031929016,
-0.7752462029457092,
-0.18347616493701935,
-0.41485923528671265,
-0.3322257995605469,
0.08344825357198715,
0.2501470446586609,
0.3293728828430176,
0.8556527495384216,
-0.199121356010437,
-0.24013037979602814,
-0.18405881524085999,
0.48900195956230164,
-0.1782655417919159,
0.5779392719268799,
0.8445311188697815,
-0.9172853827476501,
-0.20020802319049835,
-0.15166234970092773,
-0.7935776114463806,
0.18596261739730835,
-0.1251508742570877,
0.21308633685112,
0.19275185465812683,
0.5277701616287231,
-1.0001811981201172,
0.5202851891517639,
1.0244693756103516,
-0.3149108290672302,
0.2830199897289276,
-0.16425783932209015,
0.15101753175258636,
-1.240261197090149,
0.027427637949585915,
-0.20603667199611664,
0.02253243513405323,
-0.7628076672554016,
-0.13515998423099518,
-0.22933347523212433,
-0.4465109705924988,
-0.5224648118019104,
0.2676231861114502,
-0.7349929809570312,
-0.5550845861434937,
-0.16521456837654114,
0.38182687759399414,
0.09181339293718338,
0.4864034652709961,
0.4277859628200531,
0.46561765670776367,
0.3990406095981598,
-0.703431248664856,
0.04999500885605812,
0.40088409185409546,
-0.16474606096744537,
0.7560293674468994,
-0.6010003089904785,
0.5698965191841125,
0.09024330973625183,
0.389102965593338,
-1.1555216312408447,
-0.3857768177986145,
0.13734972476959229,
-1.0430063009262085,
0.52090984582901,
-0.08795933425426483,
-0.42885109782218933,
-0.5219728946685791,
-0.26923131942749023,
0.2952037751674652,
0.23062177002429962,
-0.8382115364074707,
0.5993373990058899,
0.4250020980834961,
0.16382871568202972,
-0.5071508884429932,
-0.7469332218170166,
0.1806069314479828,
-0.14859429001808167,
-0.8006063103675842,
0.26655101776123047,
0.20032425224781036,
0.059341784566640854,
-0.4072592258453369,
-0.24671925604343414,
0.33879172801971436,
-0.08876661956310272,
0.475265234708786,
-0.024631386622786522,
0.237607941031456,
-0.16113300621509552,
0.04143187403678894,
0.01611463911831379,
0.3694756031036377,
0.12866351008415222,
0.6843018531799316,
0.253481388092041,
-0.5832063555717468,
-0.9419031143188477,
0.28717491030693054,
0.7289488911628723,
-0.08500225841999054,
0.6527254581451416,
0.7497450709342957,
-0.32263660430908203,
0.18485815823078156,
0.016555054113268852,
-0.20514361560344696,
-0.42105457186698914,
0.6443631052970886,
-0.5555333495140076,
-0.665580689907074,
0.318424791097641,
-0.032838113605976105,
0.03928418457508087,
0.12425648421049118,
0.6045292019844055,
-0.523868203163147,
1.1833746433258057,
0.24368928372859955,
0.06045340746641159,
0.4285992681980133,
-0.6078382730484009,
0.3560847043991089,
-0.7778263092041016,
-0.5983622670173645,
-0.6813160181045532,
-0.7794060707092285,
-0.5908447504043579,
-0.8634525537490845,
0.5363431572914124,
0.0976569801568985,
-0.021602369844913483,
0.4524643123149872,
0.03809455409646034,
-0.033792443573474884,
0.4062025249004364,
0.06462904810905457,
-0.12789712846279144,
0.38995665311813354,
-0.039686355739831924,
0.15628042817115784,
-0.49364811182022095,
-0.31748253107070923,
0.8348670601844788,
0.24080321192741394,
0.3616940677165985,
0.2958281934261322,
0.7474727034568787,
0.19185210764408112,
-0.20181944966316223,
-0.547511100769043,
0.6468901038169861,
-0.3020285367965698,
-0.3914395272731781,
-0.32639482617378235,
-0.44503575563430786,
-1.1149606704711914,
0.42352840304374695,
-0.3718012273311615,
-0.4253308176994324,
0.5004756450653076,
0.3429452180862427,
-0.43392711877822876,
0.1964133083820343,
-0.6600353717803955,
0.6691932082176208,
-0.18067073822021484,
-0.38407933712005615,
-0.46002036333084106,
-0.8208121657371521,
0.19107785820960999,
0.31776127219200134,
-0.025468645617365837,
-0.20764490962028503,
0.24225881695747375,
0.5437968969345093,
-0.3956214189529419,
1.2018541097640991,
-0.684333324432373,
-0.5912894010543823,
0.22283968329429626,
0.14089606702327728,
0.5250030159950256,
-0.045776113867759705,
0.09563605487346649,
0.6700368523597717,
-0.20439979434013367,
-0.26985830068588257,
-0.6495511531829834,
0.4387936294078827,
-0.9456417560577393,
-0.43529462814331055,
-0.15291912853717804,
-0.5672942996025085,
-0.5323774218559265,
-0.39799222350120544,
0.27061185240745544,
0.5318381786346436,
-0.4787273705005646,
0.32209742069244385,
0.20761756598949432,
-0.3528582751750946,
0.39286649227142334,
0.326391339302063,
-0.047852933406829834,
-0.3450867533683777,
0.6893181800842285,
-0.07471039891242981,
0.5685601830482483,
0.44588741660118103,
0.049884505569934845,
-0.6910643577575684,
-0.4585506021976471,
-0.5453134775161743,
0.08914019912481308,
-0.2512472867965698,
0.003168193157762289,
-0.4648474454879761,
-0.005358055233955383,
-0.7993780970573425,
-0.008394382894039154,
-0.3174675703048706,
-0.6881452798843384,
-0.3150826096534729,
-0.5175496339797974,
-0.01459462009370327,
0.39734262228012085,
-0.5192571878433228,
0.2860131859779358,
-0.8010103106498718,
0.6980084776878357,
0.5043398141860962,
-0.07301945239305496,
-0.14570248126983643,
-0.5105198621749878,
-0.18854287266731262,
0.5116676092147827,
-0.15464457869529724,
-0.4086377024650574,
0.32426729798316956,
0.4545944333076477,
0.391460657119751,
0.4050014913082123,
-0.007644952740520239,
0.8361228108406067,
-0.27672281861305237,
1.140933871269226,
0.8016986846923828,
-0.4462483823299408,
0.39328017830848694,
-0.27722954750061035,
0.30964601039886475,
0.03066130168735981,
0.41385939717292786,
-0.4128575921058655,
-0.23986968398094177,
-0.47133809328079224,
-0.6727608442306519,
0.8030009865760803,
0.39908745884895325,
0.6078965663909912,
-0.055631160736083984,
0.281448632478714,
0.1621064394712448,
-0.03876188024878502,
-0.20826147496700287,
-0.14075100421905518,
-0.29898983240127563,
-0.14049029350280762,
-0.1684371381998062,
-0.1515791416168213,
-0.06231531500816345,
-0.25090745091438293,
0.0059264302253723145,
-0.11915615200996399,
0.3877179026603699,
-0.11415999382734299,
-0.023757630959153175,
-0.31145334243774414,
-0.19229894876480103,
0.6123749017715454,
-0.05836350843310356,
0.19560113549232483,
0.13848352432250977,
-0.16351239383220673,
-0.5813401937484741,
-0.08218367397785187,
0.11896509677171707,
0.18764522671699524,
-0.11167129129171371,
0.4143257141113281,
1.15480375289917,
0.09597138315439224,
-0.4292265474796295,
0.5520091652870178,
0.05471579730510712,
-0.28721246123313904,
-0.21514825522899628,
-0.028660519048571587,
0.061952002346515656,
0.40673983097076416,
0.30195483565330505,
0.36642277240753174,
0.09514688700437546,
-0.4642561674118042,
0.08145126700401306,
0.5407483577728271,
-0.09897587448358536,
-0.96220862865448,
0.7269495129585266,
0.38518422842025757,
-0.14639566838741302,
0.8659569621086121,
0.08851099014282227,
-0.18654929101467133,
0.5297748446464539,
0.24568326771259308,
0.9310817718505859,
-0.3985896408557892,
0.3711678981781006,
0.7254552841186523,
-0.1729038655757904,
0.3272210359573364,
0.09185901284217834,
-0.4592945873737335,
-0.8979347348213196,
-0.12306839972734451,
-0.4432457685470581,
-0.21257808804512024,
-0.15922708809375763,
-0.6916490793228149,
0.2099841833114624,
0.011308123357594013,
-0.14728260040283203,
-0.23223762214183807,
-0.11369667947292328,
-0.7717365026473999,
0.35974550247192383,
0.8572165369987488,
0.2605128586292267,
-0.8410994410514832,
0.8559675812721252,
0.5446124076843262,
-0.42597994208335876,
-0.7263200879096985,
0.3179531991481781,
0.17569373548030853,
-0.8803269863128662,
0.7344362735748291,
0.23711371421813965,
-0.5271198153495789,
-0.16793739795684814,
-0.4641922116279602,
-0.8633608222007751,
1.0304116010665894,
0.6836487650871277,
-0.600683867931366,
-0.25495970249176025,
1.0225235223770142,
0.7720128893852234,
0.08178532868623734,
-0.1339704543352127,
0.36630725860595703,
0.1008986234664917,
0.5486240983009338,
-1.0201009511947632,
-0.3836624026298523,
-0.015591982752084732,
0.04530111327767372,
-0.17868414521217346,
-0.518794059753418,
0.5903081297874451,
-0.4371543526649475,
-0.3997035622596741,
0.1558741182088852,
0.9208343029022217,
0.5665464997291565,
0.24400073289871216,
0.5469675064086914,
0.6354601383209229,
0.8426085710525513,
0.010900896973907948,
1.229579210281372,
-0.25755733251571655,
-0.05001823604106903,
1.1554203033447266,
-0.47959139943122864,
0.9379331469535828,
0.2525993883609772,
-0.1397865265607834,
0.3555218279361725,
0.4007597267627716,
0.4615360200405121,
0.5283337831497192,
0.20026452839374542,
-0.08543150871992111,
-0.18124254047870636,
0.15592403709888458,
-0.23161259293556213,
0.934916079044342,
0.5275833010673523,
-0.09108085185289383,
-0.1920211911201477,
0.30251505970954895,
-0.12892362475395203,
0.2430332452058792,
-0.21526558697223663,
0.8308298587799072,
0.08624836802482605,
-0.517609715461731,
0.5979405641555786,
-0.5111793279647827,
0.4248965084552765,
-0.3703438639640808,
-0.060267504304647446,
-0.38001081347465515,
0.14572519063949585,
-0.16214437782764435,
-0.7850835919380188,
0.504100501537323,
0.029217448085546494,
-0.005179704632610083,
-0.45948144793510437,
0.30547958612442017,
-0.4806596636772156,
-0.13990554213523865,
0.4112399220466614,
0.45605024695396423,
0.5089654326438904,
-0.11794395744800568,
-0.5654247999191284,
0.11554521322250366,
-0.21635623276233673,
-0.21383516490459442,
0.4293689727783203,
0.379455029964447,
-0.05436903238296509,
0.2775701582431793,
0.47657978534698486,
-0.1808808445930481,
0.3838545083999634,
0.41585248708724976,
0.6148026585578918,
-0.2214270681142807,
-0.29156336188316345,
-0.3835631012916565,
0.4620637595653534,
-0.14434213936328888,
-0.10603269934654236,
0.693367063999176,
0.6034904718399048,
1.028586983680725,
-0.03969268500804901,
0.561445951461792,
-0.41250115633010864,
0.4631325304508209,
-0.5417739152908325,
0.6431258320808411,
-0.5162044763565063,
-0.011434070765972137,
-0.1416502594947815,
-0.5229991674423218,
-0.28616073727607727,
0.5751259326934814,
-0.3411750793457031,
0.33393603563308716,
0.25737816095352173,
0.7380486726760864,
0.12161026149988174,
-0.013766661286354065,
0.7898020148277283,
0.1568855494260788,
0.49632322788238525,
0.40218016505241394,
0.7038873434066772,
-0.4724723994731903,
0.2978869676589966,
-0.17814891040325165,
0.23175881803035736,
-0.15078699588775635,
-0.5032706260681152,
-0.869969367980957,
-0.8565444946289062,
-0.6421050429344177,
-0.08877252042293549,
-0.35988304018974304,
0.9348689317703247,
0.9954343438148499,
-0.6381857395172119,
-0.2547089457511902,
0.1371956467628479,
-0.5342791080474854,
-0.45019182562828064,
-0.09892310947179794,
0.6181274652481079,
0.06076083332300186,
-1.1768674850463867,
0.6602529287338257,
0.013643244281411171,
0.20004281401634216,
-0.011315185576677322,
-0.397442489862442,
-0.019550874829292297,
-0.31562018394470215,
0.8168567419052124,
0.3726445734500885,
-0.5042548775672913,
-0.4896831810474396,
-0.14953398704528809,
-0.03170686960220337,
-0.05243575572967529,
0.9384322166442871,
-0.7780306935310364,
0.5502241253852844,
0.47522321343421936,
0.31065407395362854,
0.5698816180229187,
0.12279468774795532,
0.7582050561904907,
-1.3412097692489624,
0.31968748569488525,
0.062326282262802124,
0.11904430389404297,
0.5486578941345215,
-0.1541958600282669,
0.3188525140285492,
0.3284092843532562,
-0.0456547886133194,
-0.5659365653991699,
0.22508330643177032,
-1.0716921091079712,
0.02075527235865593,
0.9047077298164368,
-0.06107410043478012,
0.07702043652534485,
-0.0863647609949112,
-0.23417851328849792,
0.356597900390625,
-0.10249170660972595,
0.8482761979103088,
0.11419294774532318,
-0.5219826698303223,
-0.3347221910953522,
-0.08573601394891739,
0.6023034453392029,
0.044243715703487396,
-0.582023561000824,
0.21914522349834442,
0.9374929070472717,
-0.03236042335629463,
0.20871396362781525,
0.5403168201446533,
-0.2835950255393982,
0.21471460163593292,
0.008184248581528664,
0.39133867621421814,
-0.13157813251018524,
-0.2174413800239563,
-0.3473224341869354,
0.49463987350463867,
-0.3728514015674591,
-0.5269360542297363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15109v1 | Brain-Like Language Processing via a Shallow Untrained Multihead Attention Network | 2024-06-21T12:54:03 | 2024-06-21T12:54:03 | Badr AlKhamissi, Greta Tuckute, Antoine Bosselut, Martin Schrimpf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been shown to be effective models of the
human language system, with some models predicting most explainable variance of
brain activity in current datasets. Even in untrained models, the
representations induced by architectural priors can exhibit reasonable
alignment to brain data. In this work, we investigate the key architectural
components driving the surprising alignment of untrained models. To estimate
LLM-to-brain similarity, we first select language-selective units within an
LLM, similar to how neuroscientists identify the language network in the human
brain. We then benchmark the brain alignment of these LLM units across five
different brain recording datasets. By isolating critical components of the
Transformer architecture, we identify tokenization strategy and multihead
attention as the two major components driving brain alignment. A simple form of
recurrence further improves alignment. We further demonstrate this quantitative
brain alignment of our model by reproducing landmark studies in the language
neuroscience field, showing that localized model units -- just like language
voxels measured empirically in the human brain -- discriminate more reliably
between lexical than syntactic differences, and exhibit similar response
profiles under the same experimental conditions. Finally, we demonstrate the
utility of our model's representations for language modeling, achieving
improved sample and parameter efficiency over comparable architectures. Our
model's estimates of surprisal sets a new state-of-the-art in the behavioral
alignment to human reading times. Taken together, we propose a highly brain-
and behaviorally-aligned model that conceptualizes the human language system as
an untrained shallow feature encoder, with structural priors, combined with a
trained decoder to achieve efficient and performant language processing. | [
-0.21886855363845825,
-0.5417766571044922,
0.4865679442882538,
0.11156933009624481,
-0.10036008805036545,
0.0441933199763298,
-0.4040586054325104,
-0.386665403842926,
0.20879362523555756,
0.44665607810020447,
-0.450746089220047,
-0.3813430368900299,
-0.29969891905784607,
-0.06993258744478226,
-0.25117725133895874,
0.7794901132583618,
0.2555084228515625,
0.12334225326776505,
-0.0933343917131424,
-0.34773311018943787,
-0.5995212197303772,
-0.37632641196250916,
-0.5343819856643677,
-0.7306509017944336,
0.5558122992515564,
0.006187692750245333,
0.7979505062103271,
0.9451472163200378,
0.5693143010139465,
0.28495165705680847,
-0.15660125017166138,
-0.11673291027545929,
-0.2243138700723648,
-0.08850035816431046,
-0.18878313899040222,
-0.5097666382789612,
-0.5355506539344788,
-0.4003151059150696,
0.6788955926895142,
1.1620287895202637,
-0.24144083261489868,
0.04795515537261963,
0.31188809871673584,
0.7123315930366516,
-0.6263283491134644,
-0.10862782597541809,
-0.5660163760185242,
-0.18448473513126373,
-0.5059301853179932,
-0.01814529299736023,
-0.3881668746471405,
-0.1298498511314392,
0.13472291827201843,
-0.19615456461906433,
0.20455363392829895,
0.06085546687245369,
0.6610578298568726,
0.44364774227142334,
-0.30234605073928833,
0.059268005192279816,
-0.4833092987537384,
0.6021239161491394,
-0.7243525981903076,
0.8542227745056152,
0.012462595477700233,
0.10960552096366882,
-0.13006079196929932,
-0.49853602051734924,
-0.6041810512542725,
0.0264726635068655,
-0.31676408648490906,
0.02993910014629364,
-0.264279305934906,
0.1947983205318451,
0.01803547330200672,
0.05873057246208191,
-0.9784721732139587,
0.4004429876804352,
-0.21114327013492584,
-0.16653159260749817,
0.1934741735458374,
0.11771232634782791,
0.2970430552959442,
-0.13722877204418182,
-0.22399841248989105,
0.01937473565340042,
-0.7576029896736145,
0.08404169231653214,
0.20928548276424408,
0.4394591450691223,
-0.0162252988666296,
0.6309944987297058,
-0.024953503161668777,
0.8392432928085327,
0.10484147816896439,
0.09937917441129684,
0.38543522357940674,
-0.017294282093644142,
-0.22508546710014343,
0.19558723270893097,
0.8701353073120117,
0.24080120027065277,
0.5585681796073914,
-0.4348102807998657,
-0.20362837612628937,
0.30386069416999817,
0.5986046195030212,
-0.5183537602424622,
-0.22253356873989105,
0.1712632179260254,
-0.5106669664382935,
-0.0031695549841970205,
-0.32800644636154175,
-0.46677276492118835,
-0.36492183804512024,
-0.46162864565849304,
0.06832927465438843,
-0.44805899262428284,
-0.1295362114906311,
0.3758047819137573,
0.21731963753700256,
0.359281063079834,
-0.17008112370967865,
-1.1154415607452393,
0.42293235659599304,
0.6612357497215271,
0.8081622123718262,
-0.4393022656440735,
-0.5052061676979065,
-0.08301485329866409,
0.25135231018066406,
-0.47841212153434753,
0.9879941344261169,
-0.5212908387184143,
0.16909217834472656,
-0.0797632485628128,
-0.12920813262462616,
-0.05254989489912987,
-0.4360868036746979,
0.3068924844264984,
-0.8115864992141724,
-0.045818500220775604,
-0.15164725482463837,
-0.35346487164497375,
-0.0036053822841495275,
0.16568134725093842,
-0.5465628504753113,
0.8597212433815002,
-0.15890730917453766,
-0.9165886640548706,
0.11450181901454926,
-0.5859745144844055,
-0.43304428458213806,
0.003725246759131551,
-0.26205921173095703,
-0.19514453411102295,
0.33871185779571533,
0.23643814027309418,
0.4495779871940613,
-0.2557062804698944,
0.1911589354276657,
-0.2730923891067505,
-0.5714547038078308,
0.4041198492050171,
-0.48622462153434753,
0.7958470582962036,
0.03651599586009979,
-0.2693190574645996,
0.16705793142318726,
-0.6273624300956726,
-0.01097150705754757,
0.019614655524492264,
-0.30514782667160034,
-0.5117652416229248,
-0.029774025082588196,
-0.041153375059366226,
0.12362653762102127,
0.3972262144088745,
-0.5685290694236755,
0.29630428552627563,
-0.6464765071868896,
0.580743670463562,
0.5589054226875305,
-0.347712904214859,
0.6192401051521301,
-0.0006419303244911134,
0.15827731788158417,
0.1142454445362091,
-0.15045730769634247,
-0.17421536147594452,
-0.06007927656173706,
-0.5979077219963074,
-0.3439657390117645,
0.32000452280044556,
0.35294267535209656,
-0.17054589092731476,
0.3482653796672821,
-0.7732263803482056,
-0.1751367747783661,
-0.8373668193817139,
-0.09179145842790604,
0.5688904523849487,
0.5617754459381104,
0.4213421940803528,
-0.37690454721450806,
-0.34845155477523804,
-1.2394015789031982,
-0.28154700994491577,
0.004844483453780413,
-0.20158544182777405,
0.07875556498765945,
0.042874667793512344,
-0.4279952645301819,
0.8709386587142944,
-0.6130742430686951,
-0.35931268334388733,
-0.12888644635677338,
0.06887063384056091,
0.3571944832801819,
0.31740865111351013,
0.34086087346076965,
-0.3017168939113617,
-0.25579962134361267,
0.25271981954574585,
-0.5809624791145325,
-0.1622972935438156,
0.035086605697870255,
-0.20211301743984222,
0.14954587817192078,
0.5969357490539551,
-0.8014006614685059,
0.12751689553260803,
0.3303775489330292,
-0.09009918570518494,
0.08603227883577347,
-0.1916491538286209,
0.03471754491329193,
-0.9767001271247864,
0.34157422184944153,
-0.1689537763595581,
-0.05122210085391998,
-0.6121063828468323,
0.038807764649391174,
0.3377024233341217,
0.08511101454496384,
-0.2845214605331421,
0.4691866636276245,
-0.688668966293335,
-0.40050140023231506,
-0.4241907000541687,
0.23485755920410156,
-0.10879988968372345,
0.9459289312362671,
0.22876155376434326,
0.5862889885902405,
0.5817147493362427,
-0.4527648091316223,
0.07920604199171066,
0.2948940396308899,
-0.31159746646881104,
0.5497121214866638,
-0.8572708368301392,
0.381681352853775,
-0.39645400643348694,
0.06086232140660286,
-1.2510310411453247,
-0.019763655960559845,
-0.10222043097019196,
-0.34433889389038086,
0.4767422080039978,
0.12083827704191208,
-0.1970386654138565,
-0.1781691014766693,
-0.06620925664901733,
0.7942336797714233,
0.4299098253250122,
-0.3083006739616394,
0.7135875821113586,
0.4566400945186615,
-0.1203082874417305,
-0.8264985084533691,
-1.0012553930282593,
0.01744387485086918,
-0.0863427147269249,
-0.4472763240337372,
0.6395806074142456,
0.16490720212459564,
-0.11551056802272797,
0.0923275351524353,
-0.13792751729488373,
-0.12676511704921722,
-0.20499470829963684,
0.16576190292835236,
0.23910562694072723,
-0.5217448472976685,
0.04614177346229553,
-0.16500233113765717,
-0.0755644291639328,
-0.009119433350861073,
-0.33916163444519043,
0.6625780463218689,
0.018147120252251625,
-0.35453447699546814,
-0.5419341921806335,
0.2575535774230957,
0.7207689881324768,
-0.3569062352180481,
0.5656612515449524,
0.27133262157440186,
-0.49308234453201294,
0.06698097288608551,
-0.5943257808685303,
-0.2597694396972656,
-0.42925480008125305,
0.6111027002334595,
-0.43177759647369385,
-0.8906866908073425,
0.5149932503700256,
0.11801094561815262,
0.1464778333902359,
0.14509159326553345,
0.6272801756858826,
-0.14397519826889038,
0.9755940437316895,
0.6402460932731628,
-0.249806210398674,
0.4251340329647064,
0.11476830393075943,
0.22756347060203552,
-1.2216774225234985,
-0.2805126905441284,
-0.4275287389755249,
-0.5908469557762146,
-0.3056521713733673,
-0.1855725347995758,
-0.06408408284187317,
0.020106447860598564,
-0.34075912833213806,
0.5504966378211975,
-0.6448415517807007,
0.6652475595474243,
0.22065143287181854,
-0.09595758467912674,
0.13570739328861237,
-0.14508257806301117,
-0.3959881663322449,
-0.20954416692256927,
-0.4674323499202728,
-0.4507926404476166,
1.0328562259674072,
0.26245731115341187,
0.7934021353721619,
0.010172161273658276,
0.35994717478752136,
0.05877922475337982,
0.36698827147483826,
-0.7120262384414673,
0.35133036971092224,
-0.15639686584472656,
-0.4272492825984955,
-0.3666718900203705,
-0.1218167096376419,
-1.0362132787704468,
0.4228106737136841,
0.10103431344032288,
-0.9660395383834839,
0.23659440875053406,
0.11392522603273392,
-0.634736955165863,
-0.007726328447461128,
-0.674679160118103,
1.1051980257034302,
-0.2492886632680893,
-0.09793677926063538,
-0.16973862051963806,
-0.7485223412513733,
0.3478128910064697,
-0.1305604726076126,
0.02597362920641899,
0.1839078962802887,
-0.10447581857442856,
0.40919801592826843,
0.1134062334895134,
0.9011489748954773,
0.13516870141029358,
-0.16038814187049866,
-0.02193368226289749,
0.07458249479532242,
0.2862352430820465,
-0.19549505412578583,
0.14219270646572113,
0.49909263849258423,
-0.26210013031959534,
-0.27048876881599426,
-0.671981930732727,
0.7928491234779358,
-0.9851160049438477,
-0.4513893127441406,
-0.27316319942474365,
-0.6830300092697144,
-0.2757400572299957,
0.4139474630355835,
0.22440241277217865,
0.48828116059303284,
-0.2731173634529114,
0.24708378314971924,
0.7565595507621765,
0.06943847984075546,
0.5424961447715759,
0.5502086877822876,
-0.16265247762203217,
-0.3217849135398865,
0.5941716432571411,
-0.0063236248679459095,
0.00659613311290741,
0.9788088202476501,
-0.14057107269763947,
-0.591337263584137,
-0.6311809420585632,
-0.2422228306531906,
0.3170393109321594,
-0.4689888656139374,
-0.18696914613246918,
-0.8478825092315674,
-0.18005946278572083,
-0.5597912073135376,
-0.07336355745792389,
-0.6696712970733643,
-0.0806022360920906,
-0.029675694182515144,
-0.010974153876304626,
-0.2406887412071228,
0.6544858813285828,
0.21493320167064667,
0.5906506180763245,
-0.5079244375228882,
0.3653826415538788,
0.23584409058094025,
0.482332319021225,
0.193560391664505,
-0.5904228687286377,
-0.28865349292755127,
0.1666851043701172,
-0.18357788026332855,
-0.7586043477058411,
0.2664678692817688,
0.1139122024178505,
0.47844773530960083,
0.4666396379470825,
-0.3834565579891205,
0.8584784269332886,
-1.0100140571594238,
0.43486499786376953,
0.15241269767284393,
-0.8861163258552551,
0.10294093191623688,
-0.198811337351799,
0.6099807620048523,
0.5483388900756836,
0.14202213287353516,
-0.6751509308815002,
-0.30512696504592896,
-0.15463633835315704,
-0.6109950542449951,
0.6901514530181885,
0.12693215906620026,
0.051435042172670364,
-0.16308049857616425,
0.4654613733291626,
-0.08088367432355881,
0.10572102665901184,
-0.6842795610427856,
-0.1392032653093338,
-0.15007701516151428,
-0.3149188160896301,
-0.09762020409107208,
-0.06805817037820816,
0.09677049517631531,
-0.029175492003560066,
0.3181750476360321,
-0.21898725628852844,
0.3785010278224945,
0.04606786370277405,
-0.27589088678359985,
-0.013922709040343761,
0.1942579597234726,
0.75882887840271,
0.5120855569839478,
-0.05250144004821777,
0.40041178464889526,
0.1696031093597412,
-0.3724440634250641,
0.05080351233482361,
-0.19939710199832916,
0.0648820623755455,
-0.16691318154335022,
0.5192438960075378,
0.7308244109153748,
0.5897928476333618,
-0.4366298317909241,
0.5453214049339294,
-0.15326058864593506,
0.2970398962497711,
-0.07379421591758728,
-0.11697704344987869,
0.567741870880127,
0.3769419491291046,
0.2622559666633606,
0.3249846398830414,
0.07627764344215393,
-0.264005571603775,
0.12663069367408752,
0.7064588665962219,
-0.3978646397590637,
-0.6479587554931641,
0.6819890141487122,
0.0054932148195803165,
-0.5516579747200012,
0.7527232766151428,
0.24697040021419525,
-0.2889516055583954,
0.23231609165668488,
0.5993553996086121,
0.9475328922271729,
-0.28005585074424744,
-0.1514475792646408,
0.09795767068862915,
0.33294689655303955,
-0.1339476853609085,
0.01860213093459606,
-0.1403467059135437,
-1.1043226718902588,
-0.673572838306427,
-0.8805049657821655,
0.12331745773553848,
0.24901048839092255,
-0.6858073472976685,
0.18881842494010925,
-0.23894251883029938,
-0.268142968416214,
0.14740049839019775,
-0.30379217863082886,
-0.6898720860481262,
0.2001267522573471,
0.2684064209461212,
0.609625518321991,
-0.7909530401229858,
0.9462372660636902,
0.7959086298942566,
-0.09764813631772995,
-0.7115170359611511,
0.2543390095233917,
-0.21931497752666473,
-0.8958358764648438,
0.5361066460609436,
0.2757994830608368,
-0.29242047667503357,
0.15275239944458008,
-0.1806664764881134,
-0.9713672995567322,
0.8891522288322449,
0.835231602191925,
-0.8349534273147583,
-0.35448822379112244,
0.2569907009601593,
0.7717708349227905,
-0.3679189085960388,
0.34905165433883667,
0.6456746459007263,
0.05425214394927025,
-0.11231923848390579,
-0.6683017015457153,
0.09346822649240494,
-0.13973988592624664,
0.2841224670410156,
0.5764084458351135,
-0.6464810371398926,
0.6178561449050903,
-0.11918160319328308,
-0.24454329907894135,
-0.22034324705600739,
0.8697549700737,
0.2589075565338135,
-0.27305537462234497,
0.20048284530639648,
0.8260706663131714,
0.6134591698646545,
0.09017831087112427,
0.7770848870277405,
-0.4329778850078583,
0.05162086710333824,
1.0739163160324097,
-0.3033352494239807,
0.8965190052986145,
0.6755361557006836,
-0.09191395342350006,
0.5628836750984192,
0.4646769165992737,
0.32108014822006226,
0.734927773475647,
0.06581465154886246,
0.20385012030601501,
-0.27800452709198,
-0.06467241793870926,
-0.191167414188385,
0.5505797863006592,
-0.01774965040385723,
-0.21087424457073212,
-0.2263752669095993,
-0.170514315366745,
-0.3039287328720093,
0.043264999985694885,
-0.15286007523536682,
0.7607025504112244,
0.20895737409591675,
-0.7500472664833069,
0.481847882270813,
-0.03506720811128616,
0.8153133392333984,
-0.5673342347145081,
0.25120434165000916,
-0.27590471506118774,
0.30851981043815613,
-0.13892604410648346,
-0.7001986503601074,
0.4819653332233429,
-0.10029695928096771,
-0.460949569940567,
-0.23234523832798004,
0.36434313654899597,
-0.5509855151176453,
-0.10118813067674637,
0.38933756947517395,
0.34862786531448364,
0.18522267043590546,
-0.14687122404575348,
-0.5416709184646606,
0.12454390525817871,
-0.22319403290748596,
-0.42421287298202515,
0.4663654863834381,
0.5039727687835693,
-0.19188205897808075,
0.5116137266159058,
0.4915837049484253,
0.20862597227096558,
0.10890638828277588,
0.3710838854312897,
0.6240338087081909,
-0.7727457880973816,
-0.5549492239952087,
-1.184485912322998,
0.41420015692710876,
0.18933828175067902,
-0.44201403856277466,
0.3882986903190613,
0.49256566166877747,
0.7700879573822021,
0.024147238582372665,
0.24171356856822968,
0.29552891850471497,
0.14164693653583527,
-0.33866336941719055,
0.7053353786468506,
-0.3874780535697937,
0.13735607266426086,
-0.10357441753149033,
-1.2553932666778564,
-0.3644825518131256,
0.5048959255218506,
-0.1518498808145523,
-0.13187986612319946,
0.8637667894363403,
0.8405352234840393,
-0.20905610918998718,
-0.08089061826467514,
0.4329192042350769,
0.23171712458133698,
0.0441272035241127,
0.7190847396850586,
0.5693342089653015,
-0.21823960542678833,
0.4615412950515747,
0.036664314568042755,
-0.10478872060775757,
0.15839383006095886,
-0.6643818616867065,
-0.9753652811050415,
-0.47701728343963623,
-0.2286360114812851,
0.05771581456065178,
0.051251307129859924,
0.7289170622825623,
0.545925498008728,
-0.7842370271682739,
-0.27036091685295105,
-0.2512347996234894,
-0.13716408610343933,
-0.28309765458106995,
-0.20779332518577576,
0.5599298477172852,
-0.33701804280281067,
-0.6239972114562988,
0.33476686477661133,
0.5647025108337402,
-0.13755975663661957,
-0.325793981552124,
0.14804604649543762,
-0.13663901388645172,
0.07467582076787949,
0.2922838032245636,
0.1234053447842598,
-0.8473911285400391,
-0.3102725148200989,
0.29503828287124634,
-0.6568530797958374,
0.20765337347984314,
0.8030931353569031,
-0.8260931968688965,
0.12973475456237793,
0.4315757155418396,
1.0327318906784058,
0.21992039680480957,
-0.05242957919836044,
0.5187368392944336,
-0.8652499318122864,
0.07474527508020401,
0.2938753664493561,
0.47041594982147217,
0.6005367040634155,
-0.4724513590335846,
0.2408253401517868,
-0.10664790868759155,
-0.5786457061767578,
-0.7696695923805237,
0.22009247541427612,
-0.8086204528808594,
-0.2441665679216385,
0.8407447934150696,
0.09394846856594086,
-0.6647725105285645,
-0.012890532612800598,
-0.09947357326745987,
0.38163575530052185,
-0.23393380641937256,
0.9738650321960449,
0.7685157656669617,
-0.3347470164299011,
-0.09480904787778854,
-0.11029326915740967,
0.25146299600601196,
0.5536336898803711,
-0.46529754996299744,
0.28047096729278564,
0.3279578387737274,
0.3710727095603943,
0.41672688722610474,
0.6315081119537354,
-0.11309074610471725,
0.08258052170276642,
-0.22714927792549133,
0.3435504734516144,
0.14399880170822144,
-0.4410480558872223,
-0.6096925735473633,
0.2323974221944809,
-0.20101815462112427,
-0.20789341628551483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15085v1 | A Unified Framework for Input Feature Attribution Analysis | 2024-06-21T12:01:03 | 2024-06-21T12:01:03 | Jingyi Sun, Pepa Atanasova, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Explaining the decision-making process of machine learning models is crucial
for ensuring their reliability and fairness. One popular explanation form
highlights key input features, such as i) tokens (e.g., Shapley Values and
Integrated Gradients), ii) interactions between tokens (e.g., Bivariate Shapley
and Attention-based methods), or iii) interactions between spans of the input
(e.g., Louvain Span Interactions). However, these explanation types have only
been studied in isolation, making it difficult to judge their respective
applicability. To bridge this gap, we propose a unified framework that
facilitates a direct comparison between highlight and interactive explanations
comprised of four diagnostic properties. Through extensive analysis across
these three types of input feature explanations--each utilizing three different
explanation techniques--across two datasets and two models, we reveal that each
explanation type excels in terms of different diagnostic properties. In our
experiments, highlight explanations are the most faithful to a model's
prediction, and interactive explanations provide better utility for learning to
simulate a model's predictions. These insights further highlight the need for
future research to develop combined methods that enhance all diagnostic
properties. | [
-0.42587655782699585,
-0.6382103562355042,
0.8205219507217407,
0.28440728783607483,
-0.12535743415355682,
-0.23450404405593872,
-0.13784636557102203,
-0.39200493693351746,
0.0067422278225421906,
0.4253828525543213,
-0.5311118960380554,
-0.25346502661705017,
-0.5159079432487488,
-0.20801736414432526,
-0.5597978234291077,
1.1539438962936401,
-0.4306124448776245,
0.08830491453409195,
-0.6010148525238037,
-0.2514248788356781,
-0.4506123960018158,
-0.4153013229370117,
-0.6240946650505066,
-0.39255425333976746,
0.9307988286018372,
0.3502579927444458,
0.7864121198654175,
0.7784940600395203,
0.5986871719360352,
0.3224668800830841,
-0.08109603822231293,
-0.08982691913843155,
-0.14577020704746246,
0.07569699734449387,
-0.2481880933046341,
-0.3558289706707001,
-0.38596171140670776,
0.18993444740772247,
0.4726356267929077,
1.143646001815796,
0.2647925615310669,
0.15549376606941223,
0.4002688527107239,
0.20205332338809967,
-0.9767454266548157,
0.20594429969787598,
-0.36370861530303955,
0.08739661425352097,
-0.05686761438846588,
-0.2347373515367508,
-0.267076313495636,
-0.29114672541618347,
0.13262702524662018,
-0.5430671572685242,
0.6453802585601807,
-0.32929399609565735,
1.0457789897918701,
0.32093483209609985,
-0.4326249063014984,
-0.08425278961658478,
-0.8776516318321228,
0.7766575813293457,
-0.2882305383682251,
0.10225518047809601,
0.2522173821926117,
0.5172012448310852,
0.22729194164276123,
-0.7177624702453613,
-0.3263935148715973,
0.008841101080179214,
-0.538833498954773,
0.11109240353107452,
-0.37488025426864624,
0.28210315108299255,
0.05964161828160286,
0.2771151065826416,
-0.25566035509109497,
0.34559300541877747,
-0.42094361782073975,
-0.49997228384017944,
0.6972041130065918,
0.13100029528141022,
-0.0626593828201294,
-0.03198954835534096,
-0.42699286341667175,
-0.015485516749322414,
-0.4216267466545105,
0.5757189393043518,
-0.016655435785651207,
0.3066820800304413,
-0.23403887450695038,
0.35934969782829285,
0.06677841395139694,
0.5934944152832031,
0.1900816261768341,
-0.005499657243490219,
0.10388456284999847,
-0.5307074189186096,
-0.21188652515411377,
0.036168187856674194,
0.8639229536056519,
0.24961984157562256,
0.03509535640478134,
-0.25584959983825684,
-0.07680483162403107,
-0.02362697944045067,
0.20501014590263367,
-0.7047386169433594,
-0.30725356936454773,
0.36390843987464905,
-0.7139549255371094,
-0.8776441812515259,
0.2189769595861435,
-0.8365126848220825,
-0.6461722254753113,
-0.34679773449897766,
0.4737939238548279,
-0.1538681983947754,
-0.3109530806541443,
-0.23855791985988617,
-0.22900545597076416,
0.0999545082449913,
0.38115647435188293,
-0.9478315114974976,
0.25340867042541504,
0.5443063378334045,
0.6878673434257507,
-0.5594165325164795,
-0.3944426476955414,
-0.6733253598213196,
-0.03498643636703491,
-0.0675073117017746,
0.81059330701828,
-0.663952648639679,
-0.15001212060451508,
-0.07951286435127258,
-0.17215073108673096,
-0.2768336832523346,
-0.5306086540222168,
0.45369452238082886,
-0.20684252679347992,
0.32698485255241394,
-0.42955225706100464,
-0.29741305112838745,
-0.604909360408783,
-0.17327456176280975,
-0.8376675844192505,
0.9241797924041748,
0.35780957341194153,
-0.7951791882514954,
1.022173523902893,
-1.1708486080169678,
-0.3613201975822449,
-0.09848735481500626,
-0.2804130017757416,
-0.7613955140113831,
0.24100378155708313,
0.47613295912742615,
0.7485742568969727,
-0.10089683532714844,
0.678902804851532,
-0.8732711672782898,
-0.47743934392929077,
0.6900790929794312,
-0.6330186724662781,
1.0267949104309082,
0.21446576714515686,
-0.4936303496360779,
0.5406148433685303,
-0.9067314267158508,
-0.07437410205602646,
0.2855815291404724,
-0.05554414913058281,
0.36145466566085815,
-0.058473408222198486,
-0.026673264801502228,
-0.10408152639865875,
0.08628498017787933,
-0.31376272439956665,
-0.3541783392429352,
0.10137373208999634,
0.4779011607170105,
0.6179909706115723,
-0.06241104006767273,
0.48594555258750916,
-0.2673526704311371,
0.8895294070243835,
0.41656363010406494,
0.2838495075702667,
-0.5247716307640076,
-0.33503270149230957,
-0.5359078049659729,
-0.8051988482475281,
0.4106900990009308,
0.41277822852134705,
-0.05290887504816055,
0.3474467694759369,
0.1151513159275055,
-0.006996132433414459,
-0.6091018915176392,
-0.010713901370763779,
0.526839554309845,
0.6050373911857605,
0.3599890470504761,
-0.18486887216567993,
-0.6491104364395142,
-1.0019501447677612,
-0.24280263483524323,
-0.1584051251411438,
-0.3843371868133545,
0.3272606432437897,
0.3120132088661194,
0.088971808552742,
1.175264835357666,
-0.06886978447437286,
0.13690969347953796,
-0.3797464370727539,
0.2126321643590927,
-0.03453449904918671,
0.28255951404571533,
0.7399833798408508,
-0.8062868118286133,
-0.16003702580928802,
0.08416937291622162,
-0.8759812116622925,
-0.18237589299678802,
-0.10183968394994736,
0.15697497129440308,
-0.1451515406370163,
0.4394722878932953,
-0.11255542933940887,
0.9427828788757324,
0.3092438578605652,
-0.35064974427223206,
0.6120492815971375,
-0.06672453135251999,
0.3141838610172272,
-0.5362020134925842,
0.1441003978252411,
0.013950591906905174,
-0.13855412602424622,
-0.3867393136024475,
0.1475246101617813,
0.039517149329185486,
-0.3238236904144287,
-0.17715471982955933,
0.5608425140380859,
-0.08286165446043015,
-0.33003708720207214,
0.09711805731058121,
0.03317524492740631,
0.559906542301178,
0.4935001730918884,
-0.29910463094711304,
0.6497282385826111,
0.6517882347106934,
-0.6767646074295044,
0.5133011937141418,
-0.08548141270875931,
0.10045874118804932,
0.3024250268936157,
-0.9653681516647339,
-0.3584804832935333,
-0.021532904356718063,
0.039261046797037125,
-1.4020732641220093,
-0.39761146903038025,
0.1886327862739563,
-0.7052019238471985,
0.1471889168024063,
-0.26715895533561707,
-0.3975561261177063,
-0.276150643825531,
-0.28318366408348083,
0.45758119225502014,
0.48629894852638245,
-0.7584253549575806,
0.8709712028503418,
-0.03271632269024849,
-0.13908842206001282,
-0.39949631690979004,
-0.48732441663742065,
-0.366184800863266,
-0.8776130676269531,
-0.8179348707199097,
0.38752201199531555,
0.2536369264125824,
-0.3785579204559326,
-0.08551252633333206,
0.09380815178155899,
-0.3169838786125183,
0.8424901962280273,
0.4044452905654907,
0.45503854751586914,
-0.46540385484695435,
0.06625469028949738,
-0.011913647875189781,
-0.28898724913597107,
0.28884199261665344,
0.23266281187534332,
0.02723827213048935,
-0.06945548951625824,
-0.6102035641670227,
-0.5638854503631592,
0.37343698740005493,
0.467503160238266,
-0.46387696266174316,
0.5228059887886047,
0.8741450905799866,
-0.15799036622047424,
-0.04666540399193764,
-0.34749242663383484,
-0.4328249990940094,
-0.4303523898124695,
0.4023347496986389,
-0.39959394931793213,
-0.6003203988075256,
1.021397590637207,
0.11460467427968979,
0.0650123879313469,
0.6385961174964905,
0.54340660572052,
-0.43176186084747314,
1.4647599458694458,
0.9251455068588257,
0.1676764190196991,
0.4511413872241974,
0.18866220116615295,
0.32437580823898315,
-0.5454083681106567,
-0.35927310585975647,
-0.5956758856773376,
-0.3990035355091095,
-0.30273178219795227,
-0.10565021634101868,
0.37107014656066895,
0.42572543025016785,
-0.08830755949020386,
-0.1579439640045166,
-0.5321195721626282,
0.3102510869503021,
0.4135207533836365,
0.11810491234064102,
0.09024947881698608,
0.11876238137483597,
-0.26108869910240173,
-0.11234323680400848,
-0.7478356957435608,
-0.34743624925613403,
1.255052089691162,
0.5778381824493408,
0.45645758509635925,
-0.10253863036632538,
0.6445363759994507,
0.19150792062282562,
0.22726751863956451,
-0.8123762607574463,
0.08810459077358246,
-0.22541587054729462,
-0.4715522527694702,
-0.36431580781936646,
-0.2773122191429138,
-1.140204906463623,
0.4242975115776062,
-0.24339915812015533,
-0.9874895811080933,
0.10108660161495209,
0.6023328900337219,
-0.682054340839386,
0.24488885700702667,
-0.8480216860771179,
1.2364940643310547,
-0.3913091719150543,
-0.3013187050819397,
0.11401080340147018,
-0.4360612630844116,
0.5333946347236633,
0.14888988435268402,
0.21549157798290253,
0.168112114071846,
0.19991832971572876,
0.8139214515686035,
-0.2795402705669403,
0.9217947125434875,
-0.2627713978290558,
0.09551181644201279,
0.05939710512757301,
0.1215900182723999,
0.05266966670751572,
-0.05941587686538696,
-0.05363726243376732,
-0.06772920489311218,
-0.13971488177776337,
-0.3487243354320526,
-0.9818525910377502,
0.21458664536476135,
-0.6073840260505676,
-0.24084247648715973,
0.07861656695604324,
-0.3818415701389313,
-0.2307729870080948,
-0.015107011422514915,
0.36969971656799316,
0.620965838432312,
-0.12787744402885437,
0.10938999056816101,
0.9924616813659668,
0.0471520870923996,
0.189540296792984,
0.23065443336963654,
-0.5367617607116699,
-0.03316580504179001,
1.0426573753356934,
-0.3106570541858673,
0.07505413144826889,
-0.06330571323633194,
0.5393930673599243,
-0.021802669391036034,
-0.7291244864463806,
-0.45619598031044006,
-0.06372445821762085,
-0.7811851501464844,
-0.018709110096096992,
-0.6875258088111877,
-0.08136483281850815,
-0.224264994263649,
-0.5313778519630432,
-0.14994144439697266,
-0.41080087423324585,
-0.6113798022270203,
-0.1871073842048645,
0.6228947043418884,
0.6864216923713684,
-0.21072453260421753,
0.3412718176841736,
-0.49983522295951843,
0.35751214623451233,
0.39757657051086426,
0.339441180229187,
0.14792412519454956,
-0.7811247110366821,
-0.17891916632652283,
0.010751992464065552,
-0.39446377754211426,
-0.8278780579566956,
-0.10525672137737274,
0.19328534603118896,
0.8772493004798889,
0.8640671968460083,
-0.40954458713531494,
0.5869593024253845,
0.02970767766237259,
0.798399031162262,
0.26369214057922363,
-0.8977587223052979,
0.6942763924598694,
-0.1379036009311676,
-0.03982691094279289,
0.6079195737838745,
0.266343891620636,
-0.18750903010368347,
-0.3311401307582855,
-0.9059357643127441,
-0.699722945690155,
0.7758516073226929,
0.08751863241195679,
-0.47966232895851135,
0.46061941981315613,
0.3825357258319855,
0.4124276041984558,
-0.04836975038051605,
-0.45486950874328613,
-0.1835191249847412,
-0.36330166459083557,
-0.43424344062805176,
0.057490356266498566,
-0.10454081743955612,
-0.48504194617271423,
-0.3628349304199219,
0.29728052020072937,
-0.2918437123298645,
0.4446488916873932,
-0.25327274203300476,
-0.2044023871421814,
0.026840362697839737,
0.029586222022771835,
0.5521427989006042,
0.9985823631286621,
-0.1526414453983307,
0.15928097069263458,
-0.06520826369524002,
-0.11944613605737686,
-0.21948453783988953,
0.40028926730155945,
0.011203168891370296,
0.19506877660751343,
0.8453660011291504,
1.0038652420043945,
0.36307621002197266,
-0.178776353597641,
0.8103817105293274,
-0.006385980173945427,
-0.4441954791545868,
0.03693157434463501,
0.2982324957847595,
-0.013964721001684666,
0.353656530380249,
0.18868222832679749,
0.08925589919090271,
0.5196357369422913,
-0.4330238401889801,
0.23670092225074768,
0.44910866022109985,
-0.9094634652137756,
-0.38357192277908325,
0.7486937046051025,
0.30423903465270996,
0.11561654508113861,
0.4930899739265442,
-0.0814128965139389,
-0.7528840899467468,
1.045375943183899,
0.11453191190958023,
1.0227537155151367,
0.17754146456718445,
0.47578150033950806,
0.1580066829919815,
-0.16947710514068604,
0.37760624289512634,
0.10912063717842102,
-0.30068305134773254,
-0.8316830992698669,
-0.47518572211265564,
-0.4159233570098877,
-0.43231940269470215,
0.20140689611434937,
-1.1530858278274536,
0.1479661911725998,
-0.47202154994010925,
0.14443856477737427,
0.7664229869842529,
-0.3101290464401245,
-0.9642198085784912,
0.20781801640987396,
0.25420668721199036,
0.3619479835033417,
-1.1532129049301147,
0.33710283041000366,
0.5810978412628174,
-0.6993924379348755,
-0.8678318858146667,
-0.2157498449087143,
0.2868659496307373,
-1.2742639780044556,
0.7069596648216248,
0.1830664575099945,
0.011519649997353554,
-0.6471806168556213,
-0.8167831301689148,
-0.8046205639839172,
0.9186328649520874,
0.4736650586128235,
0.07515382021665573,
0.1405830979347229,
-0.08891519904136658,
0.3314773738384247,
-0.6449640393257141,
0.5175101161003113,
0.9239603877067566,
0.6457611322402954,
0.16459104418754578,
-1.1340407133102417,
0.0788644328713417,
0.08672434836626053,
-0.05957169458270073,
0.04211735725402832,
-0.09744897484779358,
0.8805215954780579,
-0.481270432472229,
-0.10625050961971283,
-0.23098859190940857,
0.6023235321044922,
0.44730913639068604,
0.4759025573730469,
0.4168477952480316,
0.18636979162693024,
0.7886338233947754,
-0.27626833319664,
0.9994379281997681,
0.13065814971923828,
0.3612654507160187,
0.8897780776023865,
0.024649817496538162,
0.32776835560798645,
0.39315640926361084,
-0.5908459424972534,
0.6020681262016296,
0.9126730561256409,
-0.1439002901315689,
0.38427090644836426,
0.16850420832633972,
0.10637269169092178,
-0.22982148826122284,
0.025839615613222122,
-0.14381814002990723,
0.7063495516777039,
0.4025024175643921,
-0.7759947776794434,
-0.3465922772884369,
0.31016698479652405,
0.16124606132507324,
-0.04869397357106209,
-0.4496670663356781,
0.9869794249534607,
-0.4065009355545044,
-0.4218045771121979,
0.5354238152503967,
-0.09002139419317245,
0.482525110244751,
-0.5208688974380493,
-0.1953301876783371,
-0.22906984388828278,
0.16702060401439667,
-0.45673975348472595,
-0.9335299730300903,
0.17356322705745697,
-0.09235186874866486,
-0.6609640121459961,
-0.19338233768939972,
0.5608078241348267,
-0.23971369862556458,
-0.4995172321796417,
0.1386808604001999,
0.2292850762605667,
0.3476800322532654,
-0.26103684306144714,
-0.89326012134552,
0.22789546847343445,
0.14389978349208832,
-0.0419120192527771,
0.29891201853752136,
0.782592236995697,
-0.35703521966934204,
0.5913842916488647,
0.29292285442352295,
-0.09525154531002045,
-0.03356018289923668,
0.01621711626648903,
0.798199474811554,
-0.543843150138855,
-0.4461938738822937,
-0.7166012525558472,
0.997739851474762,
-0.13817113637924194,
-0.3736172616481781,
0.3340582251548767,
0.14694975316524506,
0.4897686243057251,
0.2761429250240326,
1.034316062927246,
0.1403782069683075,
0.5099563002586365,
-0.5363187193870544,
0.48207607865333557,
-0.5690212845802307,
0.16205856204032898,
-0.00022447342053055763,
-0.7693758606910706,
-0.277156263589859,
0.6114709973335266,
0.11697187274694443,
0.44020986557006836,
0.8540711402893066,
0.33530884981155396,
-0.4166332185268402,
0.11577779799699783,
0.2845607399940491,
-0.01175190694630146,
0.2803247570991516,
0.14621053636074066,
0.523981511592865,
-0.06940840929746628,
0.5954538583755493,
-0.34757000207901,
-0.5673384070396423,
-0.6222253441810608,
-1.0428409576416016,
-0.792913556098938,
-0.4316321909427643,
-0.42616498470306396,
-0.3723638355731964,
-0.27538514137268066,
0.24890287220478058,
0.8301926851272583,
-1.1354329586029053,
0.04983929544687271,
0.21481327712535858,
0.2782602906227112,
-0.5535499453544617,
-0.28399986028671265,
0.480974406003952,
-0.39962121844291687,
-0.16791783273220062,
0.09234538674354553,
0.16168095171451569,
-0.11374808847904205,
-0.586921215057373,
0.21226882934570312,
0.4652422070503235,
-0.1630047708749771,
0.4773121178150177,
0.3373623192310333,
-0.9943941831588745,
-0.26714131236076355,
-0.2516274154186249,
0.13870005309581757,
0.2680374085903168,
1.2551772594451904,
-0.8553034067153931,
0.5264517664909363,
0.18196061253547668,
0.6364632844924927,
0.392203152179718,
-0.1778016835451126,
0.8261238932609558,
-0.5808007717132568,
0.021428417414426804,
0.2185671627521515,
0.4487607777118683,
0.3058564364910126,
-0.6375777721405029,
0.2863934338092804,
0.006577665917575359,
-0.3843061923980713,
-0.7452603578567505,
0.2853773236274719,
-0.8754322528839111,
-0.22662046551704407,
0.8891603946685791,
-0.3904033303260803,
-0.09873773157596588,
-0.3008453845977783,
0.05982081592082977,
0.1387711763381958,
-0.41905638575553894,
0.6927793622016907,
0.6510984301567078,
-0.5045552849769592,
-0.3318665325641632,
-0.39132067561149597,
0.6441610455513,
0.504984438419342,
-0.627930760383606,
0.263001024723053,
0.3680180311203003,
0.23474805057048798,
0.0637989491224289,
0.20166951417922974,
-0.27715200185775757,
0.7277957201004028,
-0.10696674883365631,
0.10433661937713623,
-0.3809177875518799,
-0.4405856728553772,
-0.7476054430007935,
0.15738317370414734,
0.10995543748140335,
-0.3462372124195099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15066v1 | Cross-lingual paraphrase identification | 2024-06-21T11:37:24 | 2024-06-21T11:37:24 | Inessa Fedorova, Aleksei Musatow | cs.CL | cs.CL | The paraphrase identification task involves measuring semantic similarity
between two short sentences. It is a tricky task, and multilingual paraphrase
identification is even more challenging. In this work, we train a bi-encoder
model in a contrastive manner to detect hard paraphrases across multiple
languages. This approach allows us to use model-produced embeddings for various
tasks, such as semantic search. We evaluate our model on downstream tasks and
also assess embedding space quality. Our performance is comparable to
state-of-the-art cross-encoders, with only a minimal relative drop of 7-10% on
the chosen dataset, while keeping decent quality of embeddings. | [
-0.20652875304222107,
-0.6721401810646057,
0.48657312989234924,
0.34392598271369934,
-0.46450328826904297,
-0.10219402611255646,
-0.004127781372517347,
-0.30909281969070435,
0.055346399545669556,
0.4713413119316101,
-0.28461214900016785,
-0.515598475933075,
-0.7255491018295288,
0.298775851726532,
-0.4659530222415924,
0.7983226776123047,
-0.263980895280838,
0.36576980352401733,
-0.30580636858940125,
-0.21961933374404907,
-0.33071398735046387,
-0.44833868741989136,
-0.35382628440856934,
-0.28757208585739136,
0.4935610294342041,
0.22414395213127136,
0.830039918422699,
0.5339407920837402,
0.39690640568733215,
0.281142920255661,
-0.24219666421413422,
0.09443425387144089,
-0.37935924530029297,
-0.01194763369858265,
-0.45629680156707764,
-0.2765502333641052,
0.024859366938471794,
-0.3108331561088562,
0.6538224220275879,
0.9141510128974915,
-0.03780775144696236,
-0.031216053292155266,
0.4907037913799286,
0.2580357491970062,
-0.6385349631309509,
0.2454725205898285,
-0.5688267350196838,
0.05285284295678139,
-0.2756592631340027,
-0.16494786739349365,
-0.2894589900970459,
-0.3129507601261139,
0.07812701910734177,
-0.5585768818855286,
0.5455124974250793,
0.25441721081733704,
1.0732027292251587,
-0.13901035487651825,
-0.5022538304328918,
-0.5518380403518677,
-0.4405404329299927,
0.7429059147834778,
-0.7665961384773254,
0.8558363318443298,
0.40888339281082153,
0.16569457948207855,
0.34459245204925537,
-0.719338595867157,
-0.573903501033783,
0.019321180880069733,
-0.25742071866989136,
-0.10574433207511902,
0.01708754524588585,
-0.2815532684326172,
-0.05524400249123573,
0.33418402075767517,
-0.7707036733627319,
-0.10929552465677261,
-0.5319700837135315,
-0.3913715183734894,
0.14878150820732117,
0.276851087808609,
0.4933634400367737,
-0.31180357933044434,
-0.37577661871910095,
-0.017918407917022705,
-0.6931172013282776,
-0.016586828976869583,
0.41437846422195435,
0.3128710985183716,
-0.12469235807657242,
0.6746271848678589,
-0.36853283643722534,
0.5349040627479553,
0.03968002647161484,
0.002986229956150055,
0.5088655352592468,
-0.5388898849487305,
-0.049130797386169434,
-0.010739920660853386,
0.6749797463417053,
0.40144407749176025,
0.22025896608829498,
-0.5204166173934937,
-0.397945761680603,
-0.21447685360908508,
0.08514338731765747,
-0.6925075650215149,
-0.2248622328042984,
-0.22671224176883698,
-0.5774653553962708,
0.18908478319644928,
0.04510711506009102,
-0.8236327171325684,
-0.2977788746356964,
-0.2961978316307068,
0.5271605849266052,
-0.7555776834487915,
-0.043316829949617386,
0.02128799818456173,
-0.3989812433719635,
0.5559064745903015,
-0.06851588934659958,
-0.8045222163200378,
0.31450608372688293,
0.6779213547706604,
0.9358421564102173,
-0.09049023687839508,
-0.7146796584129333,
-0.5413057804107666,
0.35452669858932495,
-0.4058877229690552,
0.6407017111778259,
-0.7681489586830139,
-0.2492157518863678,
0.08053649961948395,
0.3143637478351593,
-0.24070273339748383,
-0.681689441204071,
0.5377956032752991,
-0.7161900401115417,
0.09085313230752945,
-0.4272163510322571,
-0.5687370300292969,
-0.21593262255191803,
0.3726380467414856,
-0.7386747002601624,
0.8829531073570251,
0.2771759629249573,
-1.0205788612365723,
0.31922537088394165,
-0.11719182133674622,
-0.5228466987609863,
0.07951755821704865,
-0.033115338534116745,
-0.2960258424282074,
0.1278967708349228,
0.4320324957370758,
0.5414125323295593,
-0.5620638132095337,
0.0644141435623169,
-0.4702163636684418,
-0.4392895996570587,
0.18055088818073273,
-0.33331239223480225,
0.7584202289581299,
0.21883389353752136,
-0.14338046312332153,
-0.26951491832733154,
-0.6423191428184509,
-0.1227034330368042,
0.15612231194972992,
-0.4030889868736267,
-0.8843246698379517,
-0.24761678278446198,
0.34714624285697937,
0.39263924956321716,
0.40398186445236206,
-0.8982899785041809,
-0.4057459831237793,
-0.47505149245262146,
0.3368552029132843,
0.35926443338394165,
0.1571352332830429,
0.31085556745529175,
-0.2688465118408203,
0.4567895531654358,
0.286993145942688,
0.024734172970056534,
0.1848454475402832,
-0.4235573410987854,
-0.6111974716186523,
-0.16107451915740967,
0.5979533791542053,
0.72544926404953,
-0.9725958108901978,
0.3690386712551117,
-0.594285786151886,
-0.5126917362213135,
-0.765601634979248,
0.7253236174583435,
0.7307811975479126,
0.332893431186676,
0.6062616109848022,
-0.19199924170970917,
-0.14728161692619324,
-1.1434402465820312,
-0.436955988407135,
0.3231044113636017,
-0.2916978597640991,
0.13373978435993195,
0.6719195246696472,
-0.2818332314491272,
0.5405592918395996,
-0.24030330777168274,
-0.05051043629646301,
-0.4542383551597595,
0.10777825862169266,
-0.1013629361987114,
0.5606252551078796,
0.5850205421447754,
-1.0870304107666016,
-0.7786756157875061,
0.09539171308279037,
-0.8955586552619934,
-0.14577263593673706,
0.06454154849052429,
-0.27535566687583923,
-0.15125912427902222,
0.699968159198761,
-0.5832556486129761,
0.2811272442340851,
0.43159452080726624,
-0.45531439781188965,
-0.025512464344501495,
-0.36453577876091003,
0.3467797338962555,
-1.0839165449142456,
0.030692923814058304,
-0.050783902406692505,
0.04640389233827591,
-0.4265458881855011,
0.23412056267261505,
0.43701425194740295,
-0.3432713747024536,
-0.7357733845710754,
0.335967481136322,
-0.6158280372619629,
-0.02614426799118519,
-0.012490453198552132,
0.2332001030445099,
0.22319446504116058,
0.6229673027992249,
0.2647588551044464,
0.5675944685935974,
0.5085940957069397,
-0.5700371265411377,
0.29080259799957275,
0.42181745171546936,
-0.6417680978775024,
0.760810136795044,
-0.8707543611526489,
0.15839415788650513,
-0.2220526784658432,
0.025599893182516098,
-1.1356068849563599,
-0.10868129879236221,
0.10528185218572617,
-0.2501968741416931,
0.19538362324237823,
-0.18380531668663025,
-0.6870630979537964,
-0.08285822719335556,
-0.18931424617767334,
0.5489374399185181,
0.3336893916130066,
-0.624944806098938,
0.5931369066238403,
0.11730092018842697,
-0.5434479713439941,
-0.35460516810417175,
-0.8444133996963501,
-0.004502252209931612,
-0.2624448239803314,
-0.4310200810432434,
0.5073819160461426,
0.25553280115127563,
0.1513628363609314,
0.041144758462905884,
0.12857940793037415,
-0.2770773768424988,
-0.17405134439468384,
0.09072404354810715,
0.009053356014192104,
-0.14231979846954346,
-0.10117700695991516,
0.38572919368743896,
0.018695874139666557,
-0.022063039243221283,
0.03650616481900215,
0.5809303522109985,
0.08007646352052689,
-0.6133237481117249,
-0.2619825303554535,
0.8814250230789185,
0.6588531136512756,
-0.39947792887687683,
0.7095649242401123,
0.8120306730270386,
-0.48407676815986633,
0.14791901409626007,
-0.4334070384502411,
0.1317642778158188,
-0.48364102840423584,
0.5096250176429749,
-0.7918065190315247,
-0.39373478293418884,
0.5637483596801758,
0.0038974278140813112,
-0.20898468792438507,
0.2788435220718384,
0.4745091199874878,
-0.05594060197472572,
1.0886812210083008,
0.4618285894393921,
0.06596527248620987,
0.1826932430267334,
-0.2078186571598053,
0.261756032705307,
-0.8545442819595337,
-0.5962038040161133,
-0.5767608284950256,
-0.2402980625629425,
-0.5360973477363586,
-0.5832887887954712,
0.2342008650302887,
0.15540868043899536,
-0.24679026007652283,
0.5700656771659851,
-0.22343125939369202,
0.3848322033882141,
0.7929595708847046,
0.38337016105651855,
-0.06252396106719971,
-0.1666528880596161,
-0.26889097690582275,
-0.16580742597579956,
-0.6690845489501953,
-0.47249773144721985,
0.935624361038208,
0.09829976409673691,
0.7931277751922607,
0.26756179332733154,
0.8495312333106995,
0.08782397210597992,
-0.12854625284671783,
-0.39803263545036316,
0.5262646675109863,
-0.2345387190580368,
-0.6408145427703857,
-0.1996171474456787,
-0.2833288908004761,
-1.0307996273040771,
0.24142813682556152,
-0.04322870075702667,
-0.4408142566680908,
0.27433761954307556,
-0.1206088736653328,
-0.15957091748714447,
0.20924068987369537,
-0.6196262240409851,
1.252846360206604,
-0.10551462322473526,
-0.2928122282028198,
-0.20923976600170135,
-0.6827148199081421,
-0.024951046332716942,
-0.15227766335010529,
0.15522707998752594,
0.10120783001184464,
-0.2158806174993515,
0.933036744594574,
-0.1552845686674118,
0.7242669463157654,
-0.25766628980636597,
0.14589904248714447,
0.24000780284404755,
0.3743397295475006,
0.3857209086418152,
-0.11037030816078186,
-0.1273450404405594,
0.24305406212806702,
0.2706412076950073,
-0.7322108745574951,
-0.5916960835456848,
0.7792022824287415,
-0.6277433037757874,
-0.4072403013706207,
-0.028827594593167305,
-0.5093747973442078,
-0.3363623023033142,
0.09921716898679733,
0.5455694198608398,
0.5151551961898804,
-0.20518478751182556,
0.6383136510848999,
0.492956280708313,
-0.415319561958313,
0.39368653297424316,
0.30583786964416504,
0.2674161195755005,
-0.3872767686843872,
1.0556837320327759,
-0.08737578988075256,
0.26624152064323425,
0.7891139984130859,
0.20899789035320282,
-0.3907909691333771,
-0.5026569962501526,
-0.4889739751815796,
0.3103475868701935,
-0.9560415744781494,
-0.14598698914051056,
-0.7232580184936523,
-0.03249669075012207,
-0.5856526494026184,
-0.31940895318984985,
-0.3465432822704315,
-0.09141922742128372,
-0.06328331679105759,
-0.009336845017969608,
0.06569505482912064,
0.6083008050918579,
0.10942336171865463,
0.07938589155673981,
-0.9430297017097473,
0.39371857047080994,
0.3608302175998688,
0.07185831665992737,
-0.13911406695842743,
-0.7592606544494629,
-0.38036906719207764,
0.0534033440053463,
-0.24717357754707336,
-0.9488708972930908,
0.6598603129386902,
0.3597167730331421,
0.8171616792678833,
0.22220703959465027,
0.034048061817884445,
0.595871090888977,
-0.6002564430236816,
0.8250487446784973,
0.13922157883644104,
-1.0811930894851685,
0.42739689350128174,
-0.0013820198364555836,
0.36872655153274536,
0.6046946048736572,
0.9624695181846619,
-0.35567229986190796,
-0.5177947878837585,
-0.3368849754333496,
-0.8571486473083496,
0.355638712644577,
0.059185877442359924,
0.36175382137298584,
-0.14025752246379852,
0.09641300141811371,
0.4027625620365143,
0.0541611984372139,
-0.7757576107978821,
0.0490088015794754,
-0.3755057156085968,
-0.4301851689815521,
-0.29363277554512024,
-0.19184726476669312,
-0.04105189070105553,
-0.2531721889972687,
0.3608609437942505,
-0.016301969066262245,
0.29448652267456055,
0.12107156962156296,
-0.6101539134979248,
0.3264130651950836,
0.3852497637271881,
0.1153271421790123,
0.5671023726463318,
-0.06010020151734352,
0.38884493708610535,
0.5268738865852356,
-0.3021555244922638,
0.037749454379081726,
0.20397336781024933,
-0.08166197687387466,
0.411194771528244,
0.6721721291542053,
0.7638534307479858,
0.6103708744049072,
-0.6958340406417847,
0.7098105549812317,
0.2986884117126465,
-0.15450704097747803,
0.14252252876758575,
-0.3842495083808899,
0.1725994348526001,
0.4102349877357483,
0.07214802503585815,
-0.3025084137916565,
0.5320324897766113,
-0.5987960696220398,
0.0859726294875145,
0.2569422423839569,
-0.3501063585281372,
-0.4121583104133606,
0.5522424578666687,
0.19086132943630219,
-0.44750937819480896,
0.8535820245742798,
-0.07312476634979248,
-0.8459534645080566,
0.4113626778125763,
0.6453190445899963,
0.8560977578163147,
-0.14223581552505493,
-0.05627378076314926,
0.20348940789699554,
0.20212893187999725,
0.1056213229894638,
0.27770107984542847,
-0.31341901421546936,
-0.7283689379692078,
-0.030169639736413956,
-0.6662906408309937,
-0.44420015811920166,
-0.06535351276397705,
-1.0082225799560547,
0.25719085335731506,
-0.025636764243245125,
0.24124138057231903,
0.07432103157043457,
-0.3171473443508148,
-1.0649540424346924,
0.2224854826927185,
0.24760417640209198,
0.6439989805221558,
-1.1779567003250122,
0.9512758851051331,
0.631233811378479,
-0.4271310269832611,
-0.6038519740104675,
-0.0007518142811022699,
-0.34017127752304077,
-0.7754215598106384,
0.9350766539573669,
0.19737187027931213,
-0.06702927500009537,
-0.25027546286582947,
0.0057396963238716125,
-0.7326326370239258,
1.1353164911270142,
0.36696550250053406,
-0.42911192774772644,
-0.34662383794784546,
0.243259996175766,
0.563370943069458,
-0.22426775097846985,
0.11578205227851868,
0.4134824573993683,
0.25917497277259827,
-0.166507288813591,
-0.9692770838737488,
0.16135159134864807,
-0.310866117477417,
0.2430810183286667,
-0.0064110709354281425,
-0.32632139325141907,
0.9908097386360168,
0.10302326083183289,
-0.02405049093067646,
-0.034202881157398224,
0.5684145092964172,
0.14266616106033325,
0.42229005694389343,
0.627765417098999,
0.42513206601142883,
0.3846210837364197,
0.19608822464942932,
0.9826036095619202,
-0.6163451075553894,
0.3094312846660614,
1.0514544248580933,
-0.4402371048927307,
1.0999442338943481,
0.746094286441803,
0.05296237766742706,
0.6219591498374939,
0.5198123455047607,
0.06457176804542542,
1.1058008670806885,
-0.03585140407085419,
-0.05322334170341492,
-0.46947774291038513,
0.15706226229667664,
-0.2412176877260208,
0.3927266299724579,
0.38085129857063293,
-0.5532884001731873,
-0.3597993850708008,
0.36899852752685547,
-0.35663071274757385,
0.1949310153722763,
-0.14406298100948334,
0.7291845083236694,
0.03861367329955101,
-0.6983815431594849,
0.5790903568267822,
0.08823499828577042,
0.7276212573051453,
-0.5841360092163086,
-0.0373091921210289,
-0.2562166750431061,
0.36127814650535583,
0.09469428658485413,
-0.7986264824867249,
0.5925606489181519,
-0.06329718977212906,
-0.007639821153134108,
-0.20627085864543915,
0.4613669812679291,
-0.7652905583381653,
-0.48509901762008667,
0.7512006163597107,
0.6452533006668091,
0.2543199062347412,
-0.03315214440226555,
-0.7646549940109253,
-0.054439593106508255,
-0.14599110186100006,
-0.23102480173110962,
0.36678755283355713,
0.8140158653259277,
-0.04610184580087662,
0.5457020401954651,
0.31149664521217346,
-0.10616761445999146,
0.19818177819252014,
0.11935116350650787,
0.5775126814842224,
-0.7348765730857849,
-0.6480356454849243,
-0.8306131362915039,
0.033410169184207916,
-0.123940110206604,
-0.4259791374206543,
0.9314013719558716,
0.8210042715072632,
1.072160243988037,
-0.4710562229156494,
0.5303313732147217,
-0.012163695879280567,
0.6844696998596191,
-0.58692866563797,
0.5270587801933289,
-0.6790996193885803,
0.014473164454102516,
-0.3407648801803589,
-0.8485504984855652,
0.012307041324675083,
0.6005558967590332,
-0.25709038972854614,
-0.13470907509326935,
0.8538123369216919,
1.1399072408676147,
-0.6498830318450928,
-0.12508627772331238,
0.4987170398235321,
-0.3170287013053894,
-0.023735007271170616,
0.8536620736122131,
0.8040915727615356,
-0.6686794757843018,
1.0444952249526978,
-0.5034511685371399,
0.23388640582561493,
-0.15240436792373657,
-0.5590449571609497,
-1.0135624408721924,
-0.7866470813751221,
-0.48460280895233154,
-0.29161933064460754,
0.0815124660730362,
0.6255208253860474,
0.6403425931930542,
-0.92566978931427,
-0.0848485603928566,
-0.020967505872249603,
-0.013861297629773617,
-0.4660823345184326,
-0.20063263177871704,
0.415622353553772,
-0.18422269821166992,
-0.9929183721542358,
0.3599393367767334,
0.012163043953478336,
-0.08731573820114136,
-0.009931554086506367,
-0.22222450375556946,
-0.4770091474056244,
0.2202354520559311,
0.42217370867729187,
-0.0327758751809597,
-0.7260503172874451,
-0.5131657719612122,
0.0026165724266320467,
-0.39097824692726135,
-0.10650251060724258,
0.7921723127365112,
-0.2822502851486206,
0.28309404850006104,
0.7666723132133484,
0.8735849857330322,
0.6902173757553101,
-0.14556996524333954,
0.5950806140899658,
-0.7563620209693909,
0.1034526452422142,
0.21782580018043518,
0.6615967750549316,
0.7197653651237488,
-0.04960700124502182,
0.3701133131980896,
0.27498283982276917,
-0.34414148330688477,
-0.8291874527931213,
-0.1357250064611435,
-0.8862218260765076,
-0.37063199281692505,
1.3706272840499878,
-0.6648520827293396,
-0.20197345316410065,
-0.4093211591243744,
-0.11078726500272751,
0.34376949071884155,
0.09338165819644928,
0.393414169549942,
0.805526077747345,
0.27803659439086914,
-0.012808216735720634,
-0.22387567162513733,
0.05449208244681358,
0.45441100001335144,
-0.38131484389305115,
-0.07269760221242905,
0.15228557586669922,
0.6979663372039795,
0.2556917369365692,
0.10923796147108078,
-0.2389647364616394,
0.3471682071685791,
0.3924967050552368,
0.008184927515685558,
0.02756398729979992,
-0.2554509937763214,
-0.3385080397129059,
0.49489903450012207,
-0.1125408485531807,
-0.5427051782608032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15053v1 | PARIKSHA : A Large-Scale Investigation of Human-LLM Evaluator Agreement on Multilingual and Multi-Cultural Data | 2024-06-21T11:00:38 | 2024-06-21T11:00:38 | Ishaan Watts, Varun Gumma, Aditya Yadavalli, Vivek Seshadri, Manohar Swaminathan, Sunayana Sitaram | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluation of multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) is challenging due to
a variety of factors -- the lack of benchmarks with sufficient linguistic
diversity, contamination of popular benchmarks into LLM pre-training data and
the lack of local, cultural nuances in translated benchmarks. In this work, we
study human and LLM-based evaluation in a multilingual, multi-cultural setting.
We evaluate 30 models across 10 Indic languages by conducting 90K human
evaluations and 30K LLM-based evaluations and find that models such as GPT-4o
and Llama-3 70B consistently perform best for most Indic languages. We build
leaderboards for two evaluation settings - pairwise comparison and direct
assessment and analyse the agreement between humans and LLMs. We find that
humans and LLMs agree fairly well in the pairwise setting but the agreement
drops for direct assessment evaluation especially for languages such as Bengali
and Odia. We also check for various biases in human and LLM-based evaluation
and find evidence of self-bias in the GPT-based evaluator. Our work presents a
significant step towards scaling up multilingual evaluation of LLMs. | [
-0.4798424243927002,
-0.5805474519729614,
0.36738941073417664,
0.6057079434394836,
-0.3786070644855499,
0.34918129444122314,
-0.6216070652008057,
-0.47091585397720337,
-0.011289214715361595,
0.4887568950653076,
-0.05488411337137222,
-0.44546639919281006,
-0.7155647277832031,
0.5291460752487183,
-0.13180038332939148,
0.6256460547447205,
-0.2861117720603943,
0.5484326481819153,
-0.22211915254592896,
-0.49552345275878906,
-0.6539063453674316,
-0.5277582406997681,
-0.3425344228744507,
-0.6263613700866699,
0.20395155251026154,
0.4047825038433075,
0.5150983333587646,
0.21539297699928284,
0.5789645314216614,
0.3171522915363312,
-0.35474687814712524,
0.17863395810127258,
-0.2803242802619934,
-0.018015097826719284,
-0.25258129835128784,
-0.305589497089386,
-0.41645511984825134,
0.1469385176897049,
0.7733601927757263,
0.8011530041694641,
-0.4838530719280243,
0.5316177010536194,
0.14109373092651367,
0.6805406808853149,
-0.5959417819976807,
0.12209749221801758,
-0.32064807415008545,
0.1669938564300537,
-0.298661470413208,
0.21855556964874268,
-0.2901487350463867,
-0.4109959900379181,
-0.17448444664478302,
-0.20632806420326233,
-0.30105140805244446,
0.021433252841234207,
0.5141125321388245,
0.05111240595579147,
-0.7292690873146057,
-0.04717027395963669,
-0.5197678804397583,
0.945367157459259,
-0.740676760673523,
0.43398311734199524,
0.6562206149101257,
0.3501587212085724,
-0.09746772050857544,
-0.2478068619966507,
-0.5728353261947632,
-0.4625065326690674,
0.11857641488313675,
0.19684329628944397,
0.148017019033432,
-0.27729669213294983,
0.17925943434238434,
0.5457097291946411,
-0.4434088170528412,
0.27780091762542725,
-0.26995816826820374,
-0.18189720809459686,
0.6536357402801514,
0.43390822410583496,
0.34641680121421814,
-0.42630138993263245,
-0.34394359588623047,
0.13103128969669342,
-0.8587484359741211,
0.264396071434021,
0.5400941371917725,
0.125052809715271,
-0.4022670090198517,
0.5495438575744629,
-0.6404178738594055,
0.8349257707595825,
0.009198692627251148,
-0.3548119366168976,
0.24607235193252563,
-0.5384265780448914,
0.006460467353463173,
-0.08869921416044235,
0.9741926789283752,
0.4398152530193329,
0.3002098798751831,
-0.17309367656707764,
-0.06290679425001144,
0.04999269172549248,
-0.07164076715707779,
-0.8744547963142395,
0.1731998473405838,
0.004660424310714006,
-0.6823470592498779,
-0.1551254242658615,
-0.23811286687850952,
-0.8229848146438599,
-0.7690014839172363,
-0.5945852994918823,
0.18136650323867798,
-0.19984576106071472,
-0.5334801077842712,
0.06871756166219711,
0.3084564507007599,
0.6733385324478149,
0.33603182435035706,
-0.5472891330718994,
0.2250097393989563,
0.6510043740272522,
0.5447392463684082,
-0.06534792482852936,
-0.8225837349891663,
-0.25630712509155273,
-0.06405521929264069,
-0.5848609805107117,
0.7934421896934509,
-0.6414293050765991,
-0.3125060200691223,
-0.05445215851068497,
-0.3285105228424072,
0.06320814043283463,
-0.7298144102096558,
0.8816534876823425,
-0.2789093852043152,
0.09560802578926086,
-0.48863735795021057,
-0.4294692277908325,
-0.2045057713985443,
0.4336152672767639,
-0.42388778924942017,
0.8451208472251892,
-0.13882149755954742,
-0.6760607361793518,
0.49867597222328186,
-0.3922288417816162,
-0.43764933943748474,
0.3072343170642853,
-0.4494630694389343,
-0.18397577106952667,
0.13869468867778778,
0.3635016977787018,
0.5538315773010254,
-0.9839291572570801,
0.6687367558479309,
-0.39520063996315,
-0.5727576613426208,
0.41210731863975525,
-0.49050071835517883,
0.9213483929634094,
0.28295737504959106,
-0.1634034812450409,
0.1521809697151184,
-0.9534001350402832,
-0.11806346476078033,
0.15177856385707855,
-0.5246872305870056,
-0.294551819562912,
-0.02599518373608589,
0.003798783291131258,
0.3155812919139862,
0.2533908784389496,
-0.7624012231826782,
0.060604628175497055,
-0.13011085987091064,
0.4506136178970337,
0.7839032411575317,
-0.20806969702243805,
0.08479923754930496,
-0.1866793930530548,
0.7156254649162292,
-0.11108928918838501,
0.26124367117881775,
-0.011048357002437115,
-0.4726256728172302,
-0.6104314923286438,
-0.22401292622089386,
0.17937035858631134,
0.3272228538990021,
-0.520056426525116,
0.19104698300361633,
-0.35898661613464355,
-0.5880358815193176,
-0.7509423494338989,
0.5324339866638184,
0.45482197403907776,
0.35855600237846375,
-0.033331308513879776,
-0.3359746038913727,
-0.2270452231168747,
-1.079368233680725,
-0.5866644978523254,
-0.060927003622055054,
0.16113318502902985,
0.02049223519861698,
0.33645084500312805,
-0.2130158394575119,
0.8087007403373718,
0.08779680728912354,
-0.18456760048866272,
-0.4665316045284271,
0.21969163417816162,
0.4727155566215515,
0.18665960431098938,
0.4058524966239929,
-0.6631377339363098,
-0.838027834892273,
0.3190036714076996,
-0.7540208697319031,
-0.17515389621257782,
0.30912089347839355,
0.04110298305749893,
0.18135659396648407,
0.08185362815856934,
-0.4736787676811218,
0.32428014278411865,
0.6502223014831543,
-0.4291132390499115,
0.7582060098648071,
-0.21098482608795166,
0.4494432508945465,
-1.0852586030960083,
-0.015674492344260216,
-0.06137431412935257,
-0.15678012371063232,
-0.4023098051548004,
0.20258745551109314,
0.3050529360771179,
-0.2016591727733612,
-0.3961871862411499,
0.7175953984260559,
-0.3956570625305176,
-0.03455008938908577,
-0.150795117020607,
-0.08100035041570663,
-0.15658089518547058,
0.3794519901275635,
-0.03724752739071846,
0.9512320160865784,
0.4777858853340149,
-0.25069594383239746,
0.4353955090045929,
0.521063506603241,
-0.8608226180076599,
0.8655656576156616,
-0.4995863437652588,
0.28035208582878113,
0.0051764571107923985,
0.21298791468143463,
-0.9403446912765503,
-0.44173723459243774,
0.15303851664066315,
-0.24664542078971863,
0.193115696310997,
-0.0340995267033577,
-0.5315814018249512,
-0.06007344648241997,
-0.5265849232673645,
0.687047004699707,
0.485826313495636,
-0.6215448379516602,
0.7192988395690918,
0.3345267176628113,
-0.3118177056312561,
-0.6444387435913086,
-0.4285441040992737,
0.4325047433376312,
-0.6116831302642822,
-0.733119785785675,
-0.24067652225494385,
-0.10991007834672928,
-0.5978899598121643,
-0.43354156613349915,
-0.16652703285217285,
-0.21523815393447876,
0.10540283471345901,
0.2561359107494354,
0.09775534272193909,
-0.035097524523735046,
-0.3587583899497986,
-0.18802987039089203,
-0.040652547031641006,
0.1756526380777359,
0.3541018068790436,
0.596204400062561,
-0.4465274512767792,
-0.5532878637313843,
-0.6342874765396118,
0.23819668591022491,
0.5766074061393738,
-0.45963865518569946,
0.6715806722640991,
0.794840395450592,
-0.14345337450504303,
0.12162774801254272,
-0.9705009460449219,
0.32896122336387634,
-0.38414236903190613,
0.3620181381702423,
-0.7400185465812683,
-0.7401891350746155,
0.7397754788398743,
-0.23487001657485962,
-0.3826085925102234,
0.522161602973938,
0.8854436278343201,
0.11363108456134796,
0.8031721711158752,
0.36888885498046875,
-0.2009260505437851,
0.09976229816675186,
0.05335111543536186,
0.20192553102970123,
-1.1052286624908447,
-0.20386403799057007,
-0.4818243086338043,
-0.19247163832187653,
-0.6522414684295654,
-0.27906152606010437,
0.4574199914932251,
0.2570722997188568,
-0.32086077332496643,
0.06059357151389122,
0.057230472564697266,
0.6329593062400818,
0.11415857076644897,
0.02358049340546131,
0.4384821653366089,
0.0037085413932800293,
-0.2016974240541458,
-0.18393513560295105,
-0.44935041666030884,
-0.5752128958702087,
1.3267923593521118,
0.37759140133857727,
0.7791372537612915,
0.35261985659599304,
0.6632235050201416,
0.2573404312133789,
0.5357434749603271,
-0.5138339400291443,
0.4259600341320038,
-0.28972315788269043,
-0.42645859718322754,
-0.2569124102592468,
-0.44683367013931274,
-0.6179150342941284,
0.6545366644859314,
0.16895252466201782,
-0.5824046730995178,
0.02760344371199608,
-0.35106873512268066,
-0.15339362621307373,
0.07767687737941742,
-0.6228421926498413,
0.8297073245048523,
-0.4255244731903076,
-0.45729804039001465,
-0.48912665247917175,
-0.5223156213760376,
0.7296591401100159,
-0.3565245270729065,
0.487259179353714,
-0.42687052488327026,
0.1945757269859314,
0.8810213804244995,
-0.09199195355176926,
0.8680729866027832,
-0.07739310711622238,
-0.2870529592037201,
0.06355255842208862,
0.12564125657081604,
0.29873451590538025,
0.14720651507377625,
-0.23462152481079102,
0.6260838508605957,
-0.00034783867886289954,
-0.5996750593185425,
-0.3488468527793884,
0.6223157048225403,
-1.0474432706832886,
-0.5859322547912598,
-0.5793752670288086,
-0.5013161897659302,
-0.49769604206085205,
-0.003370841033756733,
-0.04268898069858551,
0.289063036441803,
-0.1950705349445343,
0.37673279643058777,
0.12161722034215927,
-0.5648822784423828,
0.20202939212322235,
0.799833357334137,
-0.4159047603607178,
-0.6262071132659912,
0.8759832978248596,
-0.05416080355644226,
0.18922507762908936,
0.2570262551307678,
0.5794028639793396,
-0.24436204135417938,
-0.6752455234527588,
-0.6046366691589355,
0.19730018079280853,
-0.8806461691856384,
-0.06406769901514053,
-0.13506190478801727,
-0.013797743245959282,
-0.3494727909564972,
0.3088954985141754,
-0.370290607213974,
-0.18181397020816803,
0.36163413524627686,
0.038082193583250046,
0.05975697189569473,
1.0279110670089722,
0.0943569540977478,
0.26331692934036255,
-0.7977299094200134,
0.3210119307041168,
0.18492425978183746,
0.4353210926055908,
-0.02266412414610386,
-0.6346451640129089,
-0.2564133405685425,
-0.09549368917942047,
-0.16215726733207703,
-0.5873000025749207,
0.1800842583179474,
0.093802809715271,
0.6073956489562988,
0.3173338770866394,
-0.1546664834022522,
0.9237183332443237,
-0.38734495639801025,
0.7232074737548828,
0.250656396150589,
-1.0891954898834229,
0.053418029099702835,
-0.4161428213119507,
0.2090701162815094,
0.6147863864898682,
0.13637101650238037,
-0.7879723906517029,
-0.12515035271644592,
-0.03350292518734932,
-0.7067478895187378,
0.7619792819023132,
0.011579811573028564,
0.14178259670734406,
0.2583082616329193,
0.4260523319244385,
0.41750025749206543,
0.26874709129333496,
-0.809704601764679,
0.002332040574401617,
0.0874323695898056,
-0.08669068664312363,
-0.18361516296863556,
-0.5205194354057312,
-0.0788034200668335,
-0.41630762815475464,
0.29693546891212463,
-0.04531846195459366,
-0.2062104195356369,
-0.10014025121927261,
-0.360205739736557,
-0.11602473258972168,
0.5353333950042725,
0.5123741030693054,
1.1612287759780884,
-0.13405700027942657,
-0.048827238380908966,
0.35971856117248535,
-0.40993836522102356,
0.4378981590270996,
-0.060307685285806656,
0.09819027781486511,
-0.48036131262779236,
0.7412495017051697,
0.8434617519378662,
0.18528883159160614,
-0.7234418988227844,
0.5149869918823242,
-0.35811057686805725,
0.21068882942199707,
-0.3941939175128937,
-0.3716507852077484,
0.16176970303058624,
0.14399288594722748,
0.15418387949466705,
-0.2898799777030945,
0.021705273538827896,
-0.36543214321136475,
-0.12646663188934326,
0.27256226539611816,
-0.004005069378763437,
-0.43028682470321655,
0.341914564371109,
0.34805744886398315,
-0.16483138501644135,
0.7466908693313599,
-0.2557763159275055,
-0.6060571074485779,
0.46531417965888977,
0.34156686067581177,
0.9027456641197205,
-0.5991626977920532,
0.2611916661262512,
0.2220238596200943,
0.3558467626571655,
-0.005727856419980526,
0.40155741572380066,
-0.21527621150016785,
-0.7600807547569275,
-0.8342027068138123,
-1.1588637828826904,
-0.5891046524047852,
0.14206993579864502,
-0.761867105960846,
0.25137317180633545,
-0.10238630324602127,
0.09460736066102982,
-0.17456050217151642,
0.2712053656578064,
-0.8684447407722473,
-0.19780965149402618,
0.10738927125930786,
0.7475090026855469,
-0.9715966582298279,
0.909028172492981,
0.9113953709602356,
-0.3835272789001465,
-0.789372444152832,
0.07880214601755142,
-0.2923877239227295,
-1.0629788637161255,
1.0552361011505127,
0.20635947585105896,
0.04635103419423103,
-0.3280584216117859,
-0.08118818700313568,
-0.7155918478965759,
0.9678072929382324,
0.5623911619186401,
-0.6129472255706787,
0.3527734875679016,
0.64703369140625,
0.6421502828598022,
-0.13024982810020447,
0.44945570826530457,
0.7362496852874756,
0.7880696058273315,
-0.2509627938270569,
-1.3567019701004028,
-0.09210394322872162,
-0.22295644879341125,
0.08137356489896774,
0.22120220959186554,
-0.9372086524963379,
1.05225670337677,
0.18804828822612762,
0.14232634007930756,
0.21677081286907196,
0.3345586657524109,
0.3250375986099243,
0.18415598571300507,
0.35383570194244385,
0.6964278221130371,
0.32978615164756775,
0.15185385942459106,
1.3557026386260986,
-0.4539168179035187,
0.38113728165626526,
1.018031358718872,
-0.8076679706573486,
0.9059790968894958,
0.49685540795326233,
-0.7920690774917603,
0.13415315747261047,
0.6858235597610474,
0.22468984127044678,
0.13300803303718567,
0.26767125725746155,
-0.1412760466337204,
-0.4211376905441284,
-0.3774164617061615,
-0.17050909996032715,
0.8259492516517639,
0.07321333885192871,
0.22691819071769714,
-0.3483828008174896,
0.04539390280842781,
-0.01174820028245449,
0.10887434333562851,
-0.21628262102603912,
0.6840854287147522,
0.17097769677639008,
-0.6739137172698975,
0.6986685991287231,
0.25933992862701416,
0.6009129285812378,
-0.5213024020195007,
0.0376916229724884,
-0.4958801865577698,
0.28447985649108887,
-0.150738924741745,
-0.6499672532081604,
0.1884530633687973,
0.17798179388046265,
0.09332344681024551,
-0.16136129200458527,
0.5259948372840881,
-0.4004173278808594,
-0.5749141573905945,
0.5433739423751831,
0.6784444451332092,
0.22560179233551025,
-0.19307483732700348,
-0.4930080473423004,
0.33049723505973816,
0.06349194794893265,
-0.3775213658809662,
0.6794798970222473,
0.20206426084041595,
-0.3687102496623993,
0.5611898899078369,
0.5495707988739014,
0.24721409380435944,
0.08918299525976181,
0.31022408604621887,
0.46719011664390564,
-0.7851471304893494,
-0.2485159933567047,
-0.9544863104820251,
0.19695188105106354,
0.13197390735149384,
-0.4173257350921631,
0.9756974577903748,
0.5059028267860413,
0.8899531960487366,
0.04351167008280754,
0.6279233694076538,
0.054073937237262726,
0.4444156587123871,
-0.4840729534626007,
0.846795916557312,
-0.39615514874458313,
0.19489417970180511,
0.02094903588294983,
-1.13394296169281,
0.1075759008526802,
0.5286301970481873,
-0.38824179768562317,
0.001175748067907989,
0.6219010353088379,
0.27183613181114197,
0.040760062634944916,
0.11164650321006775,
0.423908531665802,
0.31393828988075256,
0.3627593517303467,
0.4084971249103546,
1.4351520538330078,
-0.07823551446199417,
0.06937433779239655,
-0.5056101083755493,
-0.3108457624912262,
0.2546687424182892,
-0.9104707837104797,
-0.9937344789505005,
-0.39117029309272766,
-0.12042943388223648,
0.09740763902664185,
-0.2457265853881836,
1.0600477457046509,
0.41927847266197205,
-0.8054059743881226,
-0.9757830500602722,
0.3679071366786957,
-0.004936182405799627,
-0.07910110056400299,
-0.1749609261751175,
0.47030144929885864,
-0.20755445957183838,
-0.7645260691642761,
0.5258017778396606,
0.3161722421646118,
-0.4706791043281555,
-0.5765196681022644,
-0.39606577157974243,
-0.10982944071292877,
-0.22228726744651794,
0.6157703399658203,
-0.23315460979938507,
-1.1075712442398071,
-0.02586076781153679,
-0.40303292870521545,
0.15203583240509033,
0.05474522337317467,
0.752377986907959,
-0.5619748830795288,
0.48037129640579224,
0.4792180359363556,
0.825167715549469,
0.18966177105903625,
-0.041492681950330734,
0.5462109446525574,
-0.4551689624786377,
0.24105411767959595,
-0.04048946872353554,
0.5183167457580566,
0.4822171628475189,
0.0054703932255506516,
0.5934424996376038,
0.049528174102306366,
-0.5929039120674133,
-1.0277819633483887,
0.05529247596859932,
-0.7595333456993103,
-0.12298721075057983,
1.1629854440689087,
-0.3095097243785858,
-0.07294315099716187,
0.0306619331240654,
-0.22890739142894745,
0.050077345222234726,
-0.1914709210395813,
0.9433034062385559,
1.2467139959335327,
-0.2425837218761444,
0.12206368148326874,
-0.7050132751464844,
0.21534428000450134,
0.5783868432044983,
-0.7529039978981018,
0.1372552067041397,
0.31133773922920227,
0.5360850095748901,
0.16814520955085754,
0.470651239156723,
-0.10163793712854385,
0.10989581048488617,
-0.33638253808021545,
0.12040694802999496,
-0.012667222879827023,
-0.15868961811065674,
-0.8607823848724365,
0.006231131963431835,
0.41210684180259705,
0.19183340668678284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15050v1 | Tri-VQA: Triangular Reasoning Medical Visual Question Answering for Multi-Attribute Analysis | 2024-06-21T10:50:55 | 2024-06-21T10:50:55 | Lin Fan, Xun Gong, Cenyang Zheng, Yafei Ou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7; I.2.10; J.3 | The intersection of medical Visual Question Answering (Med-VQA) is a
challenging research topic with advantages including patient engagement and
clinical expert involvement for second opinions. However, existing Med-VQA
methods based on joint embedding fail to explain whether their provided results
are based on correct reasoning or coincidental answers, which undermines the
credibility of VQA answers. In this paper, we investigate the construction of a
more cohesive and stable Med-VQA structure. Motivated by causal effect, we
propose a novel Triangular Reasoning VQA (Tri-VQA) framework, which constructs
reverse causal questions from the perspective of "Why this answer?" to
elucidate the source of the answer and stimulate more reasonable forward
reasoning processes. We evaluate our method on the Endoscopic Ultrasound (EUS)
multi-attribute annotated dataset from five centers, and test it on medical VQA
datasets. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our approach over
existing methods. Our codes and pre-trained models are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Tri_VQA. | [
-0.6953495740890503,
-0.8608083724975586,
0.7910029888153076,
-0.06805408746004105,
-0.36239930987358093,
0.08810292929410934,
0.31313014030456543,
-0.4979405105113983,
0.3135908842086792,
0.4867406487464905,
-0.5183653831481934,
-0.3901420831680298,
-0.3949078321456909,
0.2507466971874237,
-0.2898474335670471,
0.6537531614303589,
-0.1595684438943863,
0.5453814268112183,
-0.40508323907852173,
-0.5028964281082153,
-0.5218266844749451,
-0.20060615241527557,
-0.5983477830886841,
0.018811896443367004,
0.731037974357605,
0.4964700937271118,
1.030315637588501,
0.5684207677841187,
0.43779969215393066,
0.27076455950737,
0.1690552681684494,
0.17360679805278778,
-0.3032171130180359,
-0.01903788559138775,
-0.2449032962322235,
-0.38488391041755676,
-0.1900956928730011,
-0.04343439266085625,
0.36754363775253296,
0.6870859265327454,
-0.09124843776226044,
0.4133746325969696,
-0.22811086475849152,
0.5142663717269897,
-0.6489126682281494,
-0.36753353476524353,
-0.14089013636112213,
-0.041903190314769745,
0.026558605954051018,
-0.43429097533226013,
-0.1502199023962021,
-0.5137879848480225,
0.3863672614097595,
-0.6328074336051941,
-0.0677063912153244,
0.15550389885902405,
0.9133914709091187,
0.6094163656234741,
-0.8550705313682556,
0.037306901067495346,
-0.681101381778717,
0.56426602602005,
-0.22442509233951569,
0.46161749958992004,
0.060925234109163284,
0.7355651259422302,
0.12018763273954391,
-0.8015848994255066,
-0.7157741189002991,
0.07957758754491806,
0.044315557926893234,
0.4040497839450836,
-0.24286669492721558,
-0.08436024934053421,
-0.11646513640880585,
0.25367289781570435,
-0.6007256507873535,
-0.14393378794193268,
-0.30690938234329224,
0.06823310256004333,
0.456783264875412,
0.3312619626522064,
0.5844812989234924,
0.046060673892498016,
-0.701958417892456,
0.0402735136449337,
-0.987513542175293,
0.16433311998844147,
-0.19587434828281403,
-0.20457468926906586,
-0.03859155997633934,
0.7937899827957153,
-0.2649373710155487,
0.5783780217170715,
0.2944813072681427,
0.09299485385417938,
0.14310172200202942,
-0.324785053730011,
-0.2673279047012329,
0.09710769355297089,
0.4443944990634918,
0.6392272710800171,
0.20311108231544495,
0.07597494125366211,
0.3905245065689087,
-0.13483399152755737,
0.3718138635158539,
-0.4943108558654785,
0.17051342129707336,
0.6830976009368896,
-0.6397958397865295,
-0.275640606880188,
0.009873727336525917,
-0.20820648968219757,
-0.21450936794281006,
-0.45859673619270325,
0.8429245352745056,
-0.20356479287147522,
-0.25919002294540405,
0.3536458909511566,
-0.06204909458756447,
0.2959117591381073,
0.526833713054657,
-0.02772870473563671,
0.15389423072338104,
0.5003540515899658,
0.48727741837501526,
0.2482430785894394,
-0.2112140655517578,
-0.47201552987098694,
0.3397432565689087,
-0.3881169557571411,
0.9652806520462036,
-0.38936322927474976,
-0.035688869655132294,
-0.14080145955085754,
0.23463712632656097,
0.0515386201441288,
-0.4400157034397125,
0.43066900968551636,
-0.36162108182907104,
0.637436032295227,
-0.8827857375144958,
-0.12022661417722702,
-0.5864267945289612,
0.3680214285850525,
-0.6833142042160034,
0.6973284482955933,
-0.03253265097737312,
-0.75371915102005,
0.5521692633628845,
-0.18977446854114532,
-0.10426840931177139,
-0.2049224078655243,
-0.7210236191749573,
-0.7633128762245178,
0.09897936135530472,
0.6725778579711914,
0.5261627435684204,
-0.7938777804374695,
0.6649174094200134,
-0.6686866879463196,
-0.22411790490150452,
0.4549460709095001,
-0.32996413111686707,
0.8148714900016785,
-0.10855910181999207,
-0.33407458662986755,
0.11650548875331879,
-0.7873008251190186,
-0.06932727992534637,
0.08301745355129242,
0.23411825299263,
-0.5166841149330139,
-0.2752002775669098,
-0.4303281009197235,
0.6240741610527039,
-0.20387674868106842,
-0.796835720539093,
0.11267557740211487,
0.11146169155836105,
-0.16474777460098267,
0.4246007204055786,
0.40833520889282227,
0.03118404746055603,
-0.7155029773712158,
0.387307345867157,
0.31739211082458496,
0.5269389748573303,
0.49860143661499023,
-0.8425183892250061,
-0.4984738528728485,
-0.369369238615036,
-0.10357271879911423,
0.374006450176239,
-1.2398717403411865,
-0.4609779119491577,
-0.014529525302350521,
-0.4613959789276123,
-0.8864155411720276,
-0.36629024147987366,
0.7139526009559631,
1.1111406087875366,
0.6237002015113831,
-0.1922382414340973,
-0.4854327142238617,
-1.188281774520874,
-0.3608410656452179,
-0.27785488963127136,
0.14994800090789795,
0.35330256819725037,
0.49898630380630493,
0.19528837502002716,
0.5727059245109558,
-0.5406860709190369,
-0.13507838547229767,
0.014576098881661892,
0.3357219696044922,
0.26711735129356384,
0.23048298060894012,
0.6919430494308472,
-0.9272878766059875,
-0.16612470149993896,
-0.3144422471523285,
-0.8527961373329163,
-0.2127152979373932,
-0.5234054923057556,
-0.2551538944244385,
-0.09458709508180618,
0.38910603523254395,
-0.3771302402019501,
0.6993386149406433,
0.162247434258461,
-0.5610342025756836,
0.661651611328125,
0.037683386355638504,
0.4878140985965729,
-1.118436574935913,
0.03716814145445824,
0.14478634297847748,
-0.07968899607658386,
-0.5621562600135803,
-0.15297989547252655,
-0.14364658296108246,
0.21674683690071106,
-0.3952403962612152,
0.36512917280197144,
-0.38049566745758057,
-0.06636868417263031,
0.18864955008029938,
-0.17833450436592102,
-0.08242861926555634,
0.5124009847640991,
0.22787858545780182,
0.5755332708358765,
0.48419052362442017,
-0.5326247215270996,
0.20360758900642395,
0.40038469433784485,
0.06003579869866371,
1.3103288412094116,
-0.9745513200759888,
-0.1990031599998474,
-0.41756492853164673,
-0.03886572644114494,
-1.3417612314224243,
-0.10142643004655838,
0.21583901345729828,
-0.6318874955177307,
0.13196243345737457,
-0.0821140930056572,
-0.005188509356230497,
-0.4547371566295624,
-0.38880181312561035,
0.633545994758606,
-0.11213448643684387,
-0.849784791469574,
0.6900901794433594,
0.3938959240913391,
-0.12200747430324554,
-0.8951034545898438,
-0.5947149991989136,
0.08848284184932709,
-0.3073742091655731,
-0.8168491125106812,
0.14289668202400208,
0.1397569477558136,
-0.229983389377594,
0.262889564037323,
-0.18390291929244995,
-0.30626752972602844,
-0.05965561419725418,
0.20385894179344177,
0.15525208413600922,
-0.38393962383270264,
0.3480370044708252,
0.21213848888874054,
-0.26209813356399536,
0.15456117689609528,
-0.22538496553897858,
0.07760162651538849,
-0.3318983018398285,
-0.5959259867668152,
-0.5907796621322632,
0.7010512351989746,
0.7457157969474792,
-0.28533291816711426,
0.7817954421043396,
0.7100384831428528,
-0.5136042237281799,
0.12643350660800934,
-0.5815467834472656,
0.1004774197936058,
-0.3682911992073059,
0.21590766310691833,
-0.3595890700817108,
-0.8274908661842346,
0.607233464717865,
0.05101051926612854,
-0.07292445749044418,
0.465480238199234,
0.9141150116920471,
-0.5734788179397583,
1.050110101699829,
0.11946035921573639,
0.4748397171497345,
-0.11382454633712769,
-0.21004462242126465,
0.03961846977472305,
-0.8204114437103271,
-0.6949324011802673,
-0.4096444547176361,
-0.24283574521541595,
-0.30067917704582214,
-0.30514654517173767,
0.9489679336547852,
-0.139280766248703,
-0.6095861792564392,
-0.15440864861011505,
-0.4347477853298187,
0.06414049863815308,
0.6066131591796875,
0.5076078176498413,
0.3675890564918518,
-0.39708784222602844,
-0.2634538412094116,
0.13210900127887726,
-0.5915805697441101,
-0.11207782477140427,
0.935308039188385,
0.2014787644147873,
0.6678448915481567,
0.4821237027645111,
0.6279923915863037,
-0.3428591191768646,
0.18116511404514313,
-0.3363601267337799,
0.3812967538833618,
0.18998993933200836,
-0.7137044072151184,
-0.45995908975601196,
-0.15203770995140076,
-0.7959693670272827,
0.5141673684120178,
-0.4492199122905731,
-0.5263166427612305,
0.5938611030578613,
0.2233123481273651,
-0.6046960353851318,
0.24988840520381927,
-0.4614205062389374,
0.6439865827560425,
-0.479928195476532,
-0.838096559047699,
0.09159809350967407,
-0.8057305812835693,
0.5064053535461426,
0.19753775000572205,
0.11707454174757004,
0.24827931821346283,
-0.20091946423053741,
0.5072145462036133,
-0.865240752696991,
0.7220796942710876,
-0.1551637500524521,
-0.044830985367298126,
0.368122398853302,
-0.03588162362575531,
0.1186920553445816,
0.5527294874191284,
0.5536683797836304,
0.010765989311039448,
0.2576034963130951,
-0.33960485458374023,
-0.8958206176757812,
0.36102283000946045,
-0.556159496307373,
-0.7241230607032776,
-0.4051593840122223,
-0.2509138882160187,
-0.36438316106796265,
0.031159106642007828,
0.11276073008775711,
0.5879667401313782,
0.13729868829250336,
0.3836420476436615,
0.5966540575027466,
-0.354188472032547,
0.23953010141849518,
0.3313864767551422,
-0.1371861845254898,
-0.6577584147453308,
0.4730514585971832,
0.14427617192268372,
0.15705692768096924,
0.4007548391819,
0.3860444724559784,
-0.3635549247264862,
-0.43562203645706177,
-0.5832412242889404,
0.3429485261440277,
-0.37416526675224304,
-0.2869700789451599,
-0.5464605093002319,
0.014661976136267185,
0.002400822238996625,
-0.1685130000114441,
-0.4839363992214203,
-0.568828284740448,
0.023418014869093895,
0.055146224796772,
0.35032761096954346,
0.521200954914093,
-0.32189786434173584,
0.08181201666593552,
-0.617332398891449,
0.8653324842453003,
0.6680459976196289,
0.4641948342323303,
-0.04271997883915901,
0.033045444637537,
-0.09478531777858734,
0.020179584622383118,
-0.22962604463100433,
-1.1511452198028564,
-0.1225697249174118,
-0.05296819657087326,
0.6095917224884033,
0.29724302887916565,
0.029121456667780876,
1.0316380262374878,
-0.081107959151268,
0.6423953771591187,
0.3912583589553833,
-0.6600244641304016,
0.209755077958107,
-0.2751534581184387,
0.2133234739303589,
0.47985345125198364,
0.664215087890625,
-0.3404074013233185,
-0.3001334071159363,
-0.42482084035873413,
-0.5792639851570129,
-0.013121403753757477,
0.16959717869758606,
-0.7238794565200806,
0.06049272418022156,
0.3981381058692932,
0.09629686176776886,
0.12451090663671494,
-0.46151280403137207,
-0.25233688950538635,
-0.16778089106082916,
-0.1638546884059906,
0.40979933738708496,
-0.21060900390148163,
-0.36050400137901306,
-0.5443509221076965,
0.5422817468643188,
-0.19130589067935944,
0.28701409697532654,
0.6462213397026062,
-0.03656325489282608,
-0.10826732218265533,
0.16799283027648926,
0.42203253507614136,
0.4902895390987396,
-0.029811080545186996,
0.2520028352737427,
0.1714855581521988,
-0.5153601169586182,
0.04903583228588104,
-0.18947751820087433,
-0.036806635558605194,
-0.129949688911438,
0.5050775408744812,
0.2780502438545227,
0.21220622956752777,
-0.028307562693953514,
0.7148208618164062,
-0.48790037631988525,
-0.3514164686203003,
-0.1948704570531845,
-0.40968766808509827,
0.332850843667984,
0.6030219197273254,
0.3829849362373352,
-0.08098343014717102,
0.4070499837398529,
-0.45998865365982056,
0.4113369584083557,
0.388068288564682,
-0.44115886092185974,
-0.09233147650957108,
0.7983750700950623,
-0.009453696198761463,
0.35883957147598267,
0.4063120186328888,
0.34164780378341675,
-0.4513804018497467,
0.5329320430755615,
0.32931920886039734,
0.7237285375595093,
-0.42416825890541077,
0.5837058424949646,
0.410224050283432,
0.4345451593399048,
0.13035079836845398,
1.3046319484710693,
0.13204404711723328,
-0.4195750951766968,
-0.5623746514320374,
0.1699327826499939,
-0.357045978307724,
-0.2534589171409607,
-0.8620023727416992,
0.24272021651268005,
-0.2651884853839874,
-0.2342168390750885,
-0.15990689396858215,
-0.2427508533000946,
-0.7143601179122925,
0.6870026588439941,
-0.0014903697883710265,
0.5822078585624695,
-0.771896243095398,
0.3002670109272003,
0.6534484624862671,
-0.8289070725440979,
-0.8394172191619873,
-0.19114211201667786,
0.27758994698524475,
-0.9151778817176819,
0.29051727056503296,
-0.2658139169216156,
-0.38774970173835754,
-0.3714740574359894,
-0.9273995161056519,
-1.0766704082489014,
1.097212314605713,
0.25705021619796753,
-0.25785091519355774,
0.04517621174454689,
0.4224255383014679,
0.6239162087440491,
-0.2977132201194763,
0.39146798849105835,
0.10348714143037796,
0.2673741579055786,
0.3807773292064667,
-0.9164033532142639,
0.45375266671180725,
-0.17713959515094757,
-0.139230415225029,
0.027202989906072617,
-0.5278797745704651,
0.8351872563362122,
-0.7909294962882996,
-0.06860918551683426,
0.12112029641866684,
0.43353477120399475,
0.47592708468437195,
0.6493774652481079,
0.30524876713752747,
0.8281034231185913,
0.6817274689674377,
-0.23755337297916412,
1.1208555698394775,
-0.06223704293370247,
0.24088436365127563,
1.2384843826293945,
0.25449639558792114,
0.6058624386787415,
0.9306194186210632,
0.10784879326820374,
0.5578992366790771,
0.5981125831604004,
0.22329668700695038,
0.5357877016067505,
0.08988109230995178,
0.09120042622089386,
-0.5944299697875977,
-0.2937512993812561,
-0.7783496379852295,
0.736613392829895,
0.13155706226825714,
-0.07597949355840683,
-0.2136944830417633,
-0.0947631224989891,
-0.06432268023490906,
-0.19753265380859375,
-0.2519299387931824,
0.6207390427589417,
0.17393620312213898,
-0.3568447530269623,
0.611197829246521,
-0.5736745595932007,
-0.13808593153953552,
-0.040063243359327316,
-0.3804381191730499,
-0.08989318460226059,
-0.06291385740041733,
-0.27930018305778503,
-1.0743777751922607,
0.22780227661132812,
-0.3158576190471649,
0.22634907066822052,
0.14304238557815552,
0.31581127643585205,
-0.381363183259964,
-0.4359360337257385,
-0.11130128800868988,
0.980631411075592,
-0.23376168310642242,
0.1455853283405304,
-0.5763870477676392,
-0.2839563488960266,
-0.367540568113327,
-0.10033627599477768,
-0.09780798107385635,
0.683833658695221,
-0.4031628668308258,
0.7432857751846313,
0.4988124370574951,
-0.08334672451019287,
-0.1414657086133957,
0.09212169796228409,
0.9196878671646118,
-0.6266913414001465,
-0.56501305103302,
-0.43651941418647766,
0.9042263627052307,
-0.178101047873497,
-0.5767390131950378,
0.6164390444755554,
0.2905329465866089,
0.8437339067459106,
0.059632837772369385,
0.44337135553359985,
0.3132418096065521,
0.46611759066581726,
-0.6183149218559265,
0.6587596535682678,
-1.04719078540802,
0.2749565541744232,
-0.6458505392074585,
-0.470122367143631,
-0.6485417485237122,
0.37207600474357605,
-0.2249494194984436,
0.02957211621105671,
0.7914274334907532,
0.49638432264328003,
0.0761648491024971,
0.3693016767501831,
0.2013617306947708,
0.45707786083221436,
0.22636978328227997,
0.8719320893287659,
1.1769349575042725,
-0.3884791433811188,
0.30218297243118286,
-0.33456504344940186,
-0.38406679034233093,
-0.06966844946146011,
-0.7591286301612854,
-0.869591236114502,
-0.8627943992614746,
-0.506848931312561,
-0.4645930230617523,
0.12176045775413513,
0.5445940494537354,
0.4442909061908722,
-0.558300256729126,
0.24834325909614563,
0.17468300461769104,
0.3780824840068817,
-0.48270276188850403,
-0.05796941742300987,
0.7525917291641235,
0.3471739888191223,
-0.047146379947662354,
-0.18165920674800873,
0.41646018624305725,
-0.08506128191947937,
-0.036778487265110016,
0.06840808689594269,
-0.3709763288497925,
-0.13114367425441742,
0.37777137756347656,
0.4831099212169647,
-0.5653799772262573,
-0.5890417098999023,
0.020610637962818146,
0.1311015784740448,
0.14526018500328064,
0.6908078789710999,
-0.9251853823661804,
0.6052760481834412,
0.3491608798503876,
0.7633336186408997,
0.3309374451637268,
0.036143627017736435,
0.7106136083602905,
-0.2587934732437134,
-0.47885143756866455,
0.08532070368528366,
0.45903462171554565,
0.009572703391313553,
-0.45506551861763,
0.40863505005836487,
0.21683189272880554,
-0.2657581567764282,
-0.6930418014526367,
0.3036429286003113,
-1.1565886735916138,
-0.3882083594799042,
0.879060685634613,
0.17275182902812958,
-0.37586599588394165,
-0.46388524770736694,
-0.4079280495643616,
0.41502928733825684,
0.038468897342681885,
0.8507205247879028,
0.22373823821544647,
-0.5550934076309204,
-0.4125875234603882,
-0.13712678849697113,
0.34214285016059875,
0.49674996733665466,
-0.8742785453796387,
-0.6051385402679443,
0.4433484375476837,
0.3274275064468384,
0.07929336279630661,
0.3961787521839142,
-0.48016101121902466,
0.9363800883293152,
-0.06746897846460342,
-0.2524736821651459,
-0.49942195415496826,
-0.6986013054847717,
-0.28139808773994446,
0.3558638393878937,
-0.35564038157463074,
-0.5257612466812134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15045v1 | Harnessing Knowledge Retrieval with Large Language Models for Clinical Report Error Correction | 2024-06-21T10:48:21 | 2024-06-21T10:48:21 | Jinge Wu, Zhaolong Wu, Abul Hasan, Yunsoo Kim, Jason P. Y. Cheung, Teng Zhang, Honghan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study proposes an approach for error correction in clinical radiology
reports, leveraging large language models (LLMs) and retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) techniques. The proposed framework employs internal and
external retrieval mechanisms to extract relevant medical entities and
relations from the report and external knowledge sources. A three-stage
inference process is introduced, decomposing the task into error detection,
localization, and correction subtasks, which enhances the explainability and
performance of the system. The effectiveness of the approach is evaluated using
a benchmark dataset created by corrupting real-world radiology reports with
realistic errors, guided by domain experts. Experimental results demonstrate
the benefits of the proposed methods, with the combination of internal and
external retrieval significantly improving the accuracy of error detection,
localization, and correction across various state-of-the-art LLMs. The findings
contribute to the development of more robust and reliable error correction
systems for clinical documentation. | [
0.40910014510154724,
-0.5411654710769653,
0.9664627313613892,
-0.0012610947014763951,
-0.0047300891019403934,
0.11037229001522064,
-0.2914271950721741,
-0.6055326461791992,
0.06557133048772812,
0.60672527551651,
0.00777974259108305,
-0.43214482069015503,
-0.8072054982185364,
0.14504842460155487,
-0.16825097799301147,
0.6595718264579773,
-0.3310736417770386,
0.6882607936859131,
-0.17803806066513062,
-0.2032727748155594,
-0.7328368425369263,
-0.22236759960651398,
-0.7009528279304504,
-0.2764475345611572,
0.6358489394187927,
0.5695331692695618,
0.6907957792282104,
0.5531033277511597,
0.8541660308837891,
0.24729779362678528,
0.15101459622383118,
0.7766899466514587,
-0.3297237455844879,
0.1088462620973587,
-0.23495931923389435,
-0.5056166648864746,
-0.5982446670532227,
-0.5157667398452759,
0.4952048361301422,
0.5578927993774414,
-0.36731839179992676,
-0.3031480312347412,
-0.3034379780292511,
0.7571648359298706,
-0.7473366260528564,
0.21496213972568512,
-0.3606584966182709,
-0.17170992493629456,
-0.1738346517086029,
-0.7112731337547302,
-0.8495853543281555,
-0.45869773626327515,
-0.08684303611516953,
-0.5548439621925354,
0.39669767022132874,
0.0718289464712143,
0.6098596453666687,
0.001731422496959567,
-0.33759036660194397,
-0.6969999074935913,
-0.8488408327102661,
0.6221100091934204,
-0.8910854458808899,
0.3051980435848236,
0.6457575559616089,
0.43591946363449097,
-0.1660182625055313,
-1.0478503704071045,
-0.22931671142578125,
-0.07179152965545654,
-0.4285811185836792,
0.2703576385974884,
-0.06917774677276611,
0.16503411531448364,
0.3044022023677826,
0.19721753895282745,
-0.3127025067806244,
-0.028615286573767662,
-0.4598985016345978,
-0.18969810009002686,
0.5887102484703064,
0.2784357964992523,
0.48762255907058716,
-0.15017615258693695,
0.00442097382619977,
-0.30372196435928345,
-0.9407645463943481,
-0.6680924296379089,
-0.3035660684108734,
0.41753509640693665,
-0.01368002686649561,
0.514635443687439,
-0.19381624460220337,
0.5643368363380432,
-0.0646163821220398,
-0.7388843297958374,
0.2697588801383972,
-0.12276623398065567,
-0.2715170085430145,
0.23939858376979828,
0.3814772367477417,
0.3977109491825104,
-0.23378238081932068,
-0.24042321741580963,
-0.36393359303474426,
-0.16959694027900696,
0.40257057547569275,
-0.36417466402053833,
0.039084434509277344,
0.2477155178785324,
-0.5513483285903931,
-0.20533844828605652,
-0.013367509469389915,
-0.6195802092552185,
-0.8404791355133057,
-0.292561411857605,
0.6677462458610535,
-0.6282467842102051,
0.016262581571936607,
0.3001781105995178,
0.08115480840206146,
-0.08279246836900711,
0.7345700263977051,
-0.48412713408470154,
0.18059855699539185,
0.36613309383392334,
0.6450965404510498,
0.3332498073577881,
0.058424804359674454,
-0.8227567076683044,
0.5332664251327515,
-0.4213375449180603,
0.9729412794113159,
-0.4040614664554596,
-0.4792317748069763,
0.23036015033721924,
-0.08395811915397644,
-0.10714803636074066,
-0.6868587136268616,
0.4886535704135895,
-0.7944064736366272,
0.13324512541294098,
-0.24589097499847412,
-0.5602880120277405,
-0.11074892431497574,
-0.014408675953745842,
-0.5955486297607422,
0.5555405616760254,
0.26523107290267944,
-0.828222930431366,
0.21046896278858185,
-0.3861221969127655,
-0.34998270869255066,
0.1571764498949051,
-0.18060734868049622,
-0.35041260719299316,
0.09212391823530197,
0.35555940866470337,
0.30446815490722656,
-0.5325814485549927,
0.22197267413139343,
0.16358482837677002,
-0.18373219668865204,
-0.02716892585158348,
0.09231270849704742,
0.5229028463363647,
0.2804758846759796,
-0.037847597151994705,
0.010798447765409946,
-0.716235876083374,
-0.06177487224340439,
0.16405163705348969,
-0.38775360584259033,
-0.47421994805336,
0.09498157352209091,
-0.37005725502967834,
-0.04862958937883377,
-0.021750012412667274,
-0.571191132068634,
0.11402322351932526,
-0.12680508196353912,
0.014845633879303932,
0.3158501088619232,
0.20081551373004913,
0.288738876581192,
-0.7108228206634521,
0.611723780632019,
0.18056248128414154,
0.060648005455732346,
-0.35658565163612366,
-0.16458243131637573,
-0.6715940237045288,
-0.16026313602924347,
0.3790871500968933,
0.568605363368988,
-0.9477027058601379,
-0.19190746545791626,
-0.3562595248222351,
-0.48412907123565674,
-0.5545814037322998,
-0.09874784201383591,
0.569909393787384,
0.9918487071990967,
0.4570660889148712,
0.0016741221770644188,
-0.7347123026847839,
-0.4813583791255951,
-0.08383961021900177,
-0.1280851662158966,
-0.026736482977867126,
0.31349828839302063,
0.2732924818992615,
-0.3894723057746887,
0.4615120589733124,
-0.6478845477104187,
-0.6876672506332397,
-0.16915848851203918,
0.18624071776866913,
0.14604240655899048,
0.20862556993961334,
0.13721291720867157,
-0.48509764671325684,
-0.34923169016838074,
0.25505340099334717,
-0.8579787015914917,
-0.1905011236667633,
-0.034319985657930374,
0.15981140732765198,
0.6542525291442871,
0.8212294578552246,
-0.3594242036342621,
0.481831818819046,
0.31106457114219666,
0.017791232094168663,
0.528106153011322,
-0.8147396445274353,
0.5078021883964539,
-0.8247969746589661,
0.03560325503349304,
-0.13172921538352966,
-0.19151553511619568,
-0.43794843554496765,
0.08272518962621689,
0.4930168092250824,
0.30963122844696045,
-0.2149735391139984,
0.30055734515190125,
-0.7462227940559387,
-0.0714225247502327,
-0.18086577951908112,
0.10571958124637604,
0.2074294239282608,
-0.16545267403125763,
0.008921757340431213,
0.42962396144866943,
0.21016573905944824,
-0.36914747953414917,
0.35786134004592896,
0.3274170756340027,
-0.2766481637954712,
0.5731086730957031,
-0.3195788860321045,
0.24895921349525452,
-0.5549447536468506,
0.41660594940185547,
-0.8948426246643066,
-0.6244960427284241,
-0.11977720260620117,
-0.414801687002182,
0.7189226150512695,
-0.31356051564216614,
-0.7833234071731567,
-0.3115003705024719,
-0.003972374368458986,
0.207428976893425,
0.3257341682910919,
-0.41390928626060486,
0.6523290872573853,
0.4036342203617096,
-0.26085352897644043,
-0.6556162238121033,
-0.6233790516853333,
0.05660206079483032,
0.23790723085403442,
-0.7705660462379456,
0.30886006355285645,
0.20658043026924133,
-0.3896426260471344,
-0.09928517043590546,
0.12786653637886047,
-0.04285280779004097,
-0.36947888135910034,
0.05383029952645302,
0.37762385606765747,
-0.4048279821872711,
0.40783098340034485,
-0.25478029251098633,
0.07284599542617798,
-0.13586807250976562,
0.14191775023937225,
0.3127938210964203,
0.01947849616408348,
-0.5498951077461243,
-0.2456163913011551,
0.05890870466828346,
0.4962921440601349,
-0.06314346194267273,
0.6726438999176025,
0.19713088870048523,
-0.5793099999427795,
-0.12982268631458282,
-1.0348459482192993,
-0.1799253672361374,
-0.35941892862319946,
0.37382954359054565,
-0.06673786044120789,
-0.45854121446609497,
0.5733675360679626,
0.07555709779262543,
-0.14075516164302826,
0.3410605192184448,
0.4435836374759674,
-0.2601481080055237,
0.8907855749130249,
0.34853413701057434,
0.3284856677055359,
-0.17934845387935638,
-0.039118584245443344,
0.24023285508155823,
-0.9124743938446045,
-0.4880200922489166,
-0.6946150660514832,
0.10398659855127335,
-0.2770293951034546,
-0.827323853969574,
0.7413612008094788,
-0.0582297258079052,
0.02122616209089756,
-0.22311997413635254,
-0.19280146062374115,
0.3455832600593567,
0.28021082282066345,
0.4477893114089966,
0.7435526251792908,
0.11454059928655624,
-0.0074534728191792965,
-0.2951180636882782,
-0.8890259265899658,
-0.3129213750362396,
1.0166040658950806,
0.36027792096138,
1.0875275135040283,
0.19545595347881317,
0.47750717401504517,
0.11063442379236221,
0.6739853024482727,
-0.6494534611701965,
0.12805670499801636,
-0.3892182409763336,
-0.3113766610622406,
-0.18006767332553864,
-0.2897616922855377,
-0.7387324571609497,
0.1774037629365921,
-0.24539107084274292,
-0.2743974030017853,
-0.021932894363999367,
0.12128443270921707,
-0.4155389666557312,
0.4118523597717285,
-0.681353747844696,
0.398844838142395,
-0.058356527239084244,
-0.28690680861473083,
-0.37975338101387024,
-0.6453585624694824,
0.46079766750335693,
-0.17238931357860565,
0.6916770339012146,
0.2528946101665497,
-0.1130809411406517,
0.5665237903594971,
-0.6126900911331177,
0.8246031403541565,
-0.14205902814865112,
-0.2961697280406952,
0.17174752056598663,
0.3044215440750122,
0.7514782547950745,
-0.06632581353187561,
-0.17737191915512085,
-0.17098766565322876,
0.02622474543750286,
-0.037324804812669754,
-0.593273937702179,
0.5548271536827087,
-0.6605180501937866,
-0.3017177879810333,
-0.4339701235294342,
-0.846717357635498,
-0.5799775123596191,
0.28530675172805786,
0.2224796563386917,
0.9149686694145203,
0.13127052783966064,
0.007364911027252674,
0.5781517028808594,
-0.5236696004867554,
-0.07535870373249054,
1.080245852470398,
-0.1559942066669464,
-0.45822620391845703,
0.7065886855125427,
0.26085132360458374,
0.21011866629123688,
0.5479927659034729,
0.24614685773849487,
-0.20685389637947083,
-0.9085721373558044,
-0.24103471636772156,
0.7597817182540894,
-1.0718345642089844,
-0.5590123534202576,
-0.652587890625,
-0.2323920577764511,
-0.6373462677001953,
-0.18420670926570892,
-0.3870333135128021,
0.018925350159406662,
-0.14235033094882965,
0.22169287502765656,
0.4885581135749817,
1.0793951749801636,
-0.20728865265846252,
0.3906189203262329,
-1.1565011739730835,
0.23061035573482513,
-0.2545747458934784,
0.4846811890602112,
0.05861527472734451,
-0.8357892036437988,
-0.5022725462913513,
-0.050052713602781296,
-0.1553209125995636,
-0.6864923238754272,
0.6029190421104431,
-0.06798429042100906,
0.35784733295440674,
0.03485926240682602,
0.03691934421658516,
0.9019879102706909,
-0.44892555475234985,
0.2954917252063751,
0.19332535564899445,
-0.5405115485191345,
0.7286176681518555,
-0.6459391713142395,
0.2105335146188736,
0.2926827073097229,
0.16526076197624207,
-0.763242781162262,
-0.5442485809326172,
-0.6178964972496033,
-0.9047151207923889,
0.8459930419921875,
-0.3270881772041321,
-0.34920817613601685,
-0.19320990145206451,
0.4056461751461029,
-0.21646825969219208,
-0.3067997395992279,
-0.17690986394882202,
-0.0139973359182477,
0.4822399914264679,
-0.21704968810081482,
-0.016994263976812363,
-0.5845106244087219,
-0.42894935607910156,
-0.016064202412962914,
0.9701685309410095,
-0.37079057097435,
0.15603631734848022,
0.7038542032241821,
-0.3798045516014099,
-0.7187252044677734,
0.07854249328374863,
0.7783310413360596,
1.4145824909210205,
-0.327019065618515,
0.158267542719841,
0.19412274658679962,
-0.5003799796104431,
-0.1224919855594635,
-0.30836936831474304,
0.17058336734771729,
0.12954506278038025,
0.5786763429641724,
0.29562148451805115,
0.2849395275115967,
-0.7793839573860168,
0.576953113079071,
-0.21501976251602173,
-0.09382364898920059,
-0.48381301760673523,
-0.3322642147541046,
0.21041594445705414,
0.13188380002975464,
0.5696064233779907,
0.06349996477365494,
-0.044440850615501404,
-0.23174737393856049,
0.37195292115211487,
0.20917250216007233,
-0.2792735993862152,
0.08205613493919373,
0.548584520816803,
-0.08214656263589859,
0.16798518598079681,
0.5105358362197876,
0.2786557674407959,
0.0637182742357254,
0.6129204630851746,
0.8081238269805908,
0.3404388725757599,
-0.2620423138141632,
0.30736255645751953,
0.5995546579360962,
0.1599833220243454,
-0.5311490297317505,
0.0879800096154213,
0.8069347143173218,
-0.7130934000015259,
-0.9921764135360718,
-0.2538657486438751,
-0.5653979182243347,
0.3265174925327301,
-0.6139339804649353,
0.49441298842430115,
-0.4342602491378784,
0.2309354692697525,
-0.04574979841709137,
-0.4048597514629364,
-0.14067652821540833,
0.39631035923957825,
0.17639808356761932,
0.8957801461219788,
-0.3359793424606323,
0.7655766010284424,
0.7374803423881531,
-0.3503665030002594,
-1.1014823913574219,
-0.21852761507034302,
0.07677935063838959,
-1.030542016029358,
0.9840513467788696,
-0.27158528566360474,
-0.09198072552680969,
-0.4347173273563385,
-0.31707534193992615,
-0.9763305187225342,
1.0814887285232544,
0.21994765102863312,
-0.596155047416687,
-0.10323277860879898,
0.028250236064195633,
0.6699499487876892,
-0.2738151550292969,
0.4761148691177368,
0.5252395868301392,
0.22508114576339722,
0.3349420726299286,
-1.139525055885315,
0.2985336184501648,
0.288703590631485,
-0.051261886954307556,
0.18637189269065857,
-0.3192827105522156,
0.46005576848983765,
-0.47750046849250793,
-0.026641428470611572,
-0.03514368459582329,
0.5946595072746277,
0.25654518604278564,
0.1053953617811203,
0.22837570309638977,
0.5226895213127136,
0.8348437547683716,
0.09068779647350311,
1.346584677696228,
-0.11023915559053421,
0.2607521712779999,
1.086287498474121,
-0.341959685087204,
0.660232424736023,
0.43124642968177795,
-0.12205550819635391,
0.469546914100647,
0.12434517592191696,
0.30365344882011414,
0.3548058867454529,
-0.14883320033550262,
-0.24040654301643372,
0.014772563241422176,
-0.06054981052875519,
-0.26568111777305603,
0.3472256064414978,
0.5776640176773071,
-0.6110332608222961,
-0.39545318484306335,
-0.10441965609788895,
0.24310076236724854,
0.004696926102042198,
-0.4160785973072052,
0.7571566700935364,
0.06599552929401398,
-0.8730511665344238,
0.7768234610557556,
0.13741499185562134,
0.32214730978012085,
-0.6404412388801575,
-0.2762776017189026,
-0.30723920464515686,
0.6548324227333069,
-0.5237840414047241,
-0.5147562026977539,
0.5132182240486145,
-0.13692939281463623,
-0.16494405269622803,
-0.08816233277320862,
0.946945071220398,
-0.3413774371147156,
-0.3170016407966614,
0.11642467230558395,
0.13725849986076355,
-0.1891328990459442,
0.2079416960477829,
-0.25343990325927734,
0.31875550746917725,
0.14090843498706818,
0.16177742183208466,
0.31884801387786865,
0.22913400828838348,
-0.10335036367177963,
0.5824646949768066,
0.3067958354949951,
0.5297899842262268,
-0.19107654690742493,
0.31122490763664246,
0.6193177103996277,
-0.36877620220184326,
-0.28976500034332275,
-0.42306214570999146,
0.5383502244949341,
0.06067840754985809,
0.039362143725156784,
0.5138661861419678,
0.3010769188404083,
0.5822917819023132,
-0.2242894023656845,
0.8524678945541382,
-0.042181871831417084,
1.0893114805221558,
-0.7735301852226257,
0.5051901340484619,
-0.39397719502449036,
0.5842279195785522,
-0.24265553057193756,
-0.4454494118690491,
-0.7295823097229004,
0.4139350950717926,
-0.42964521050453186,
-0.10979841649532318,
0.9912188053131104,
1.0944002866744995,
0.13661128282546997,
-0.030482282862067223,
0.32870832085609436,
0.7860140800476074,
0.30588871240615845,
0.29903724789619446,
0.6012201309204102,
-0.6030245423316956,
0.4958878755569458,
-0.33810704946517944,
-0.2636133134365082,
-0.42343756556510925,
-0.6142849922180176,
-0.2569766640663147,
-0.3502066135406494,
-0.48385903239250183,
-0.9483962655067444,
0.2531566023826599,
0.7426217198371887,
0.48985883593559265,
-0.7099539637565613,
-0.0058570001274347305,
0.20634782314300537,
0.03295992314815521,
0.09904229640960693,
-0.2028539925813675,
0.6285674571990967,
-0.7514576315879822,
-0.3986245095729828,
0.4374081790447235,
0.23402036726474762,
-0.22918276488780975,
0.06976373493671417,
-0.0699775218963623,
-0.032252661883831024,
-0.22321724891662598,
0.6831740140914917,
0.19365175068378448,
-0.46541279554367065,
-0.3816379904747009,
-0.044171348214149475,
-0.47447359561920166,
0.2602294385433197,
0.9549866914749146,
-0.5651041865348816,
0.7378692030906677,
0.5052387714385986,
0.5952149033546448,
0.4453504681587219,
-0.20944452285766602,
0.583366870880127,
-0.7011493444442749,
-0.10389887541532516,
0.2785038650035858,
0.4216560125350952,
0.5812286138534546,
-0.4778966009616852,
0.5751480460166931,
0.2752986550331116,
-0.678358793258667,
-0.8378580212593079,
-0.16986317932605743,
-0.7976301908493042,
-0.30677634477615356,
1.2659988403320312,
-0.0847826600074768,
-0.24701867997646332,
-0.28298419713974,
-0.33770129084587097,
0.18859237432479858,
-0.041746724396944046,
0.8546772003173828,
0.4976733922958374,
-0.3479980528354645,
-0.12709768116474152,
-0.7676586508750916,
0.631362795829773,
0.2818014621734619,
-0.6858858466148376,
0.03808831796050072,
0.8133264183998108,
0.5239704847335815,
0.21080830693244934,
0.9217935800552368,
-0.7380110621452332,
0.6794475317001343,
-0.18731646239757538,
0.13254545629024506,
0.20763465762138367,
-0.06634945422410965,
-0.32186660170555115,
-0.011902420781552792,
0.31142011284828186,
0.25788119435310364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15038v1 | Online detection and infographic explanation of spam reviews with data drift adaptation | 2024-06-21T10:35:46 | 2024-06-21T10:35:46 | Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Silvia García-Méndez, Fátima Leal, Benedita Malheiro, J. C. Burguillo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Spam reviews are a pervasive problem on online platforms due to its
significant impact on reputation. However, research into spam detection in data
streams is scarce. Another concern lies in their need for transparency.
Consequently, this paper addresses those problems by proposing an online
solution for identifying and explaining spam reviews, incorporating data drift
adaptation. It integrates (i) incremental profiling, (ii) data drift detection
& adaptation, and (iii) identification of spam reviews employing Machine
Learning. The explainable mechanism displays a visual and textual prediction
explanation in a dashboard. The best results obtained reached up to 87 % spam
F-measure. | [
-0.8425766825675964,
-0.7982460856437683,
0.4162274897098541,
0.4195218086242676,
-0.4797861874103546,
0.2552100419998169,
0.14288730919361115,
-0.3612408936023712,
0.3455798029899597,
0.685496985912323,
-1.004309058189392,
-0.545754075050354,
-0.5368192195892334,
-0.022215045988559723,
-0.5536623001098633,
1.6360191106796265,
-0.10985378175973892,
0.017398834228515625,
0.003156318562105298,
-0.1391066610813141,
-0.42326802015304565,
-0.17194494605064392,
-0.5388923287391663,
-0.09831540286540985,
0.412523478269577,
0.39981943368911743,
0.6631752252578735,
0.4827622175216675,
0.5275037288665771,
0.24283960461616516,
0.13884635269641876,
0.1566450297832489,
-0.815715491771698,
0.09707272052764893,
-0.17408858239650726,
-0.5895335674285889,
-0.290880024433136,
-0.05883324518799782,
0.6486135721206665,
0.2504441738128662,
-0.023414522409439087,
0.22429445385932922,
-0.0058754812926054,
0.9679681658744812,
-0.6074535846710205,
-0.09698004275560379,
-0.6258782148361206,
0.19508762657642365,
-0.02359534241259098,
-0.564677894115448,
-0.40091246366500854,
-0.5490415692329407,
0.021222127601504326,
-0.8384190201759338,
0.4096050262451172,
-0.02143627218902111,
0.6742603182792664,
0.2687157988548279,
-0.10965144634246826,
-0.6053980588912964,
-1.0548278093338013,
0.34954729676246643,
-0.2513726055622101,
0.12822219729423523,
-0.046148836612701416,
0.6397706866264343,
-0.1299179494380951,
-0.4920320212841034,
-0.5127447247505188,
0.08157134056091309,
0.17463453114032745,
0.3722900152206421,
-0.3328591585159302,
-0.3531808853149414,
0.16656017303466797,
0.5279348492622375,
-0.6720566153526306,
0.016086190938949585,
-0.17446209490299225,
-0.20053547620773315,
0.5187888145446777,
0.3576287627220154,
-0.09910482168197632,
0.2602418065071106,
-0.8157399296760559,
0.03393521532416344,
-0.46186792850494385,
0.03944528102874756,
0.670010507106781,
-0.18056190013885498,
-0.2293855845928192,
0.12511783838272095,
-0.21317580342292786,
0.5963304042816162,
0.5841609835624695,
0.088270403444767,
0.32019150257110596,
-0.3145497739315033,
0.006436165887862444,
0.16502143442630768,
0.5886803865432739,
0.5718317031860352,
0.00572021771222353,
0.15813851356506348,
-0.2848031520843506,
0.0874474048614502,
0.44664257764816284,
-0.740243136882782,
-0.3610363006591797,
0.2939857840538025,
-0.7538855671882629,
-0.6634981036186218,
0.4029179513454437,
-1.1414085626602173,
-0.9535332918167114,
-0.004432679619640112,
0.5659902691841125,
-0.09605211764574051,
-0.7860147953033447,
0.19661332666873932,
-0.509739100933075,
-0.12442265450954437,
0.5549916625022888,
-0.35333266854286194,
0.3463309109210968,
0.6855946183204651,
0.8958655595779419,
-0.3984734117984772,
-0.17764034867286682,
-0.2616409361362457,
-0.026666786521673203,
-0.3251784145832062,
1.3731566667556763,
-0.3935910165309906,
-0.17109693586826324,
0.006312314886599779,
0.24509581923484802,
0.08329463005065918,
-0.5373430848121643,
0.34558039903640747,
-0.623271107673645,
0.4287410378456116,
0.17796024680137634,
-0.6578867435455322,
-0.46425411105155945,
0.3353060483932495,
-0.8894711136817932,
0.8134191632270813,
0.3774788975715637,
-0.9859848022460938,
0.5322425365447998,
-0.9765129089355469,
-0.11906715482473373,
0.19531245529651642,
0.8154661655426025,
-0.7306825518608093,
0.3884815573692322,
0.2593834400177002,
0.2581635117530823,
0.28526851534843445,
-0.2268821895122528,
-0.7096356749534607,
-0.28225016593933105,
0.8968430757522583,
-0.2167334407567978,
0.8109577894210815,
0.5222547650337219,
-0.4013274312019348,
0.22690491378307343,
-0.5539683103561401,
-0.12898564338684082,
0.035688161849975586,
-0.1897638887166977,
-0.059405405074357986,
-0.1704874038696289,
0.001409823657013476,
0.11627096682786942,
-0.12854018807411194,
-0.07496555149555206,
0.013956679031252861,
-0.17961393296718597,
0.22650793194770813,
0.8325372934341431,
0.6673800945281982,
0.43113455176353455,
-0.5044754147529602,
0.7536950707435608,
0.34307336807250977,
0.2981743812561035,
-0.357018381357193,
-0.4424515664577484,
-0.7935794591903687,
-0.10185270011425018,
0.35172781348228455,
0.30415695905685425,
-0.6066513061523438,
0.3411768078804016,
-0.33810386061668396,
-0.3458086848258972,
-0.6473581194877625,
0.25178229808807373,
0.09724316000938416,
0.28551796078681946,
0.045567434281110764,
-0.5628744959831238,
-0.2341315597295761,
-0.41402414441108704,
-0.7318493127822876,
0.14444997906684875,
-0.12101851403713226,
-0.08093545585870743,
0.421807199716568,
-0.26219719648361206,
0.7537288069725037,
-0.26375722885131836,
-0.3175555169582367,
-0.13942082226276398,
0.22914695739746094,
0.22086676955223083,
0.00833216030150652,
0.4926151633262634,
-0.8772523403167725,
-0.6144803762435913,
-0.2766262888908386,
-0.3952946662902832,
-0.18189482390880585,
-0.34202656149864197,
-0.2472228705883026,
0.012900175526738167,
0.06862784177064896,
-0.24714967608451843,
0.2824150025844574,
0.43778759241104126,
-0.3120044469833374,
0.4354536831378937,
0.09011370688676834,
0.3038874566555023,
-0.8720690608024597,
-0.3320450782775879,
0.42257899045944214,
-0.5387458205223083,
-0.7700469493865967,
-0.24411237239837646,
-0.011031526140868664,
-0.19809311628341675,
-0.1663358211517334,
0.3113356828689575,
-0.3461417257785797,
-0.06750591099262238,
-0.4981893002986908,
0.32199639081954956,
0.096560537815094,
0.2396744191646576,
0.17486673593521118,
0.24742670357227325,
0.5152591466903687,
-0.9154332876205444,
0.5170508027076721,
-0.09240858256816864,
-0.5007510185241699,
0.8881369829177856,
-0.03889435529708862,
0.2416718453168869,
-0.20513597130775452,
0.5885425209999084,
-1.289900302886963,
-0.34764713048934937,
0.77182936668396,
-0.9036580920219421,
0.07058209180831909,
-0.33611008524894714,
-0.3322415351867676,
-0.1869836449623108,
-0.7063049077987671,
-0.17044463753700256,
0.25383883714675903,
-0.7408960461616516,
0.31295910477638245,
0.7071172595024109,
0.012101524509489536,
-0.24816803634166718,
-0.2949236035346985,
-0.06494604796171188,
-0.5848771929740906,
-0.4768773019313812,
0.21281029284000397,
-0.12280160188674927,
-0.38349273800849915,
0.11355745792388916,
0.016123227775096893,
-0.061481669545173645,
0.15093077719211578,
0.17085203528404236,
0.11119994521141052,
-0.3002242147922516,
0.20831722021102905,
-0.2807067334651947,
-0.29063063859939575,
0.223815456032753,
-0.21352984011173248,
0.31450775265693665,
0.023111898452043533,
-0.0329417809844017,
-0.6737833023071289,
0.06697312742471695,
0.5902771353721619,
0.3967343270778656,
0.5837385654449463,
0.8897700905799866,
-0.2869197130203247,
-0.6944582462310791,
-0.5182492733001709,
-0.3983664810657501,
-0.4843596816062927,
0.32577332854270935,
-0.09083791077136993,
-0.33114442229270935,
0.4880457818508148,
-0.25393229722976685,
-0.16783997416496277,
0.5099865794181824,
0.7909265160560608,
-0.33915942907333374,
1.2676726579666138,
0.6472619771957397,
-0.07853328436613083,
0.7399446368217468,
0.026717372238636017,
0.11115902662277222,
-0.46891748905181885,
-0.3288973867893219,
-0.3406161367893219,
-0.43903738260269165,
-0.5738300681114197,
-0.18726462125778198,
0.20600439608097076,
0.13144971430301666,
0.05414240434765816,
-0.012261931784451008,
-0.8428822755813599,
0.4053969383239746,
0.15987443923950195,
0.3359958231449127,
0.3713340759277344,
0.40157175064086914,
0.4297258257865906,
0.05050744116306305,
-0.6187930107116699,
-0.23796537518501282,
1.095681071281433,
0.6300077438354492,
0.8216615319252014,
-0.12397870421409607,
0.10511355847120285,
0.8166359066963196,
0.8187699913978577,
-0.5798997282981873,
0.12370960414409637,
0.33422723412513733,
-0.7547716498374939,
0.047613512724637985,
-0.18997177481651306,
-0.7627406716346741,
0.07132688164710999,
-0.4989844560623169,
-0.18034447729587555,
-0.055535510182380676,
0.2262030690908432,
0.019434792920947075,
0.24605856835842133,
-0.6155776977539062,
0.642399251461029,
-0.35751810669898987,
-0.22547654807567596,
-0.4606093466281891,
-0.4395678639411926,
0.47049465775489807,
-0.04804525896906853,
0.718102216720581,
-0.08965442329645157,
-0.12965086102485657,
0.8431248068809509,
-0.33132755756378174,
0.7225907444953918,
-0.48921605944633484,
0.06031067296862602,
0.39631521701812744,
0.11500681936740875,
0.5816509127616882,
0.13083522021770477,
0.25957292318344116,
0.07098280638456345,
-0.3383484184741974,
-0.2737904191017151,
-0.5709211230278015,
0.7831956744194031,
-0.5269253849983215,
-0.22088086605072021,
-0.26517993211746216,
-0.3645270764827728,
-0.17045286297798157,
-0.0978626012802124,
0.26584240794181824,
-0.144394189119339,
-0.07451402395963669,
0.0023741722106933594,
0.8571035265922546,
0.07976178824901581,
0.12751507759094238,
0.8286962509155273,
-0.5590609312057495,
-0.5812981128692627,
1.0539897680282593,
-0.14970742166042328,
0.05474483594298363,
0.1382811963558197,
0.30286291241645813,
-0.5894580483436584,
-0.6476014852523804,
-0.7828439474105835,
0.07813973724842072,
-0.8427451252937317,
-0.0781281515955925,
-0.47692742943763733,
0.021967124193906784,
-0.0752851665019989,
0.04144710674881935,
-0.023103687912225723,
-0.5581353306770325,
-0.4165082275867462,
-0.06026672199368477,
0.7430673837661743,
1.2122629880905151,
0.029981406405568123,
0.41446560621261597,
-0.5030815601348877,
0.42171037197113037,
-0.0032328495290130377,
0.5009095668792725,
-0.10978090763092041,
-0.7989303469657898,
-0.46919533610343933,
0.02747827209532261,
-0.59242182970047,
-1.2089967727661133,
0.2291056364774704,
0.11006487905979156,
0.4712589979171753,
0.8156769871711731,
-0.12736652791500092,
0.5372056365013123,
0.19946056604385376,
0.5660389065742493,
0.20993860065937042,
-0.675676167011261,
0.5028985142707825,
-0.20047907531261444,
0.06773406267166138,
0.21226808428764343,
0.8040556907653809,
-0.43662044405937195,
-0.4403381943702698,
-0.4997485280036926,
-0.3713642954826355,
0.5614327788352966,
-0.16417467594146729,
0.0512833409011364,
0.5695312023162842,
0.33270663022994995,
0.6855898499488831,
0.23874393105506897,
-0.9074609875679016,
-0.08924651145935059,
-0.5424370169639587,
0.06230933591723442,
-0.09841035306453705,
-0.06187259778380394,
-0.09881628304719925,
-0.04687117785215378,
0.753631055355072,
-0.0018552759429439902,
0.4044954776763916,
-0.19039730727672577,
-0.46165210008621216,
-0.3987969160079956,
0.0702374204993248,
0.3751751184463501,
0.7973337173461914,
0.057829953730106354,
0.026739519089460373,
0.001567651517689228,
-0.5405429601669312,
-0.07133470475673676,
-0.2269834280014038,
-0.28317952156066895,
0.431320458650589,
0.1727786809206009,
0.7579785585403442,
-0.02007589116692543,
-0.1908789426088333,
0.5541754961013794,
-0.03433295339345932,
-0.22157493233680725,
-0.29202011227607727,
0.10682772845029831,
0.06297870725393295,
0.046827252954244614,
0.4639515280723572,
0.233184814453125,
0.26384130120277405,
-0.509528636932373,
0.2029803991317749,
0.42463383078575134,
-0.708225429058075,
-0.4480989873409271,
0.3846711814403534,
0.19797435402870178,
-0.39037632942199707,
0.129905104637146,
0.006089706905186176,
-0.6505914926528931,
0.466836154460907,
0.4311457574367523,
0.9044458270072937,
-0.23909643292427063,
0.5268955230712891,
0.29738762974739075,
0.08719108253717422,
-0.04798530414700508,
0.16156430542469025,
-0.11264707148075104,
-0.5629431009292603,
-0.01846306584775448,
-0.3894810676574707,
-0.6614224910736084,
0.37696373462677,
-0.6773949265480042,
0.5510830879211426,
-0.6131948232650757,
-0.24775031208992004,
0.488669216632843,
-0.2899071276187897,
-0.531512439250946,
0.08200911432504654,
0.19663652777671814,
0.8094894289970398,
-1.0065381526947021,
0.32983505725860596,
0.3220534324645996,
-0.18343298137187958,
0.030269967392086983,
0.16640959680080414,
0.2504015862941742,
-0.6996576189994812,
0.19773808121681213,
0.2976534366607666,
-0.41258782148361206,
-0.07751677185297012,
-0.7286496758460999,
-0.2325526624917984,
0.5806909203529358,
0.16968396306037903,
-0.44043031334877014,
0.6082310080528259,
-0.11417203396558762,
0.7172674536705017,
-0.7219881415367126,
0.351247638463974,
0.3740087151527405,
0.5475491285324097,
-0.25280046463012695,
-0.4096432626247406,
-0.03475673869252205,
-0.14772096276283264,
-0.22728976607322693,
0.0721910148859024,
-0.3762795329093933,
0.5345578193664551,
-0.03430920094251633,
-0.3893736004829407,
-0.2612718343734741,
0.261141836643219,
-0.05250589922070503,
0.7417336106300354,
0.5919888019561768,
0.4804067313671112,
0.6104773283004761,
-0.17176775634288788,
0.9114399552345276,
-0.221318319439888,
0.5286569595336914,
0.7452071905136108,
-0.06512974947690964,
0.6646050214767456,
0.33515870571136475,
-0.21655941009521484,
1.1579742431640625,
1.1346696615219116,
-0.2513595521450043,
0.7857063412666321,
0.389225572347641,
-0.49047422409057617,
-0.037399325519800186,
-0.022841598838567734,
-0.5078205466270447,
-0.10199402272701263,
0.7036705613136292,
-0.6282949447631836,
-0.14382262527942657,
0.18449407815933228,
-0.08847923576831818,
-0.1356976330280304,
-0.9132494330406189,
1.1834067106246948,
-0.2828335762023926,
-0.7358106374740601,
0.6638745069503784,
-0.17638786137104034,
0.6147838234901428,
-0.31597450375556946,
-0.07814536988735199,
-0.016548987478017807,
0.5602152943611145,
-0.6084160208702087,
-1.0903836488723755,
0.1666080206632614,
0.06536724418401718,
-0.19383639097213745,
-0.27299508452415466,
0.990048885345459,
-0.1244095116853714,
-0.5183259844779968,
0.18348275125026703,
0.4984540045261383,
0.4341331124305725,
-0.11586666107177734,
-1.0085800886154175,
0.1438249796628952,
-0.08913125097751617,
-0.3209664821624756,
0.36724334955215454,
0.4406415522098541,
-0.04064120724797249,
0.7741228342056274,
0.6980974078178406,
-0.11690915375947952,
0.19267775118350983,
-0.003708902280777693,
0.9092890620231628,
-0.3831046521663666,
-0.848594069480896,
-0.8322873115539551,
0.5938553214073181,
-0.4263850450515747,
-0.14725840091705322,
0.816371500492096,
0.7740563154220581,
0.8267087936401367,
-0.4823964238166809,
1.0911481380462646,
0.3411855101585388,
0.8682329058647156,
-0.4113999009132385,
0.62330162525177,
-0.33314329385757446,
0.2796700596809387,
-0.05013444274663925,
-1.0593805313110352,
-0.1705773025751114,
0.5916348695755005,
-0.2136528044939041,
-0.08805356919765472,
0.7846574187278748,
0.6646792888641357,
-0.26021090149879456,
0.2028426229953766,
-0.174103245139122,
0.2826536297798157,
-0.21073317527770996,
0.2513027787208557,
0.9748942255973816,
-0.22020487487316132,
0.8108722567558289,
-0.30181223154067993,
-0.21356604993343353,
-0.7779606580734253,
-0.9160992503166199,
-1.0368503332138062,
-0.3074708878993988,
-0.6261515021324158,
-1.0122944116592407,
-0.03015393763780594,
0.20481476187705994,
0.6778968572616577,
-1.1272300481796265,
-0.04855562373995781,
-0.04074281081557274,
0.4011973738670349,
-0.4882556200027466,
-0.3196139335632324,
-0.049745526164770126,
-0.13388685882091522,
-0.37879571318626404,
0.13588671386241913,
0.34545785188674927,
-0.0735403448343277,
-0.639420211315155,
-0.2506047189235687,
0.22930769622325897,
0.06112638860940933,
0.09110303968191147,
0.29371631145477295,
-0.535578191280365,
-0.10297368466854095,
-0.31130799651145935,
0.17844320833683014,
0.4481144845485687,
1.0140217542648315,
-0.5900467038154602,
0.7939808964729309,
0.5231380462646484,
0.34478577971458435,
1.031808853149414,
0.20006120204925537,
0.3411082327365875,
-0.37351730465888977,
-0.15124019980430603,
0.21877853572368622,
-0.027161244302988052,
0.3518450856208801,
-0.484830379486084,
0.22404281795024872,
0.2985430657863617,
-0.40881019830703735,
-0.8756407499313354,
0.17204856872558594,
-0.6850374341011047,
-0.18572898209095,
0.926649272441864,
-0.2079843431711197,
-0.12244487553834915,
-0.6415396332740784,
-0.15872010588645935,
-0.1212824210524559,
-0.49510955810546875,
1.2171870470046997,
0.8501294255256653,
-0.3869501054286957,
-0.2069970667362213,
-0.466082900762558,
0.6610629558563232,
-0.17667679488658905,
-1.0904731750488281,
-0.13612990081310272,
0.3342306315898895,
0.875156581401825,
0.07831243425607681,
0.5415751934051514,
-0.054574135690927505,
0.6302397847175598,
-0.03555174171924591,
-0.36360058188438416,
-0.038754213601350784,
-0.23375366628170013,
-0.7908017635345459,
0.38598233461380005,
-0.13864417374134064,
-0.3210713267326355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15032v1 | GiusBERTo: A Legal Language Model for Personal Data De-identification in Italian Court of Auditors Decisions | 2024-06-21T10:25:26 | 2024-06-21T10:25:26 | Giulio Salierno, Rosamaria Bertè, Luca Attias, Carla Morrone, Dario Pettazzoni, Daniela Battisti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Natural Language Processing have demonstrated the
effectiveness of pretrained language models like BERT for a variety of
downstream tasks. We present GiusBERTo, the first BERT-based model specialized
for anonymizing personal data in Italian legal documents. GiusBERTo is trained
on a large dataset of Court of Auditors decisions to recognize entities to
anonymize, including names, dates, locations, while retaining contextual
relevance. We evaluate GiusBERTo on a held-out test set and achieve 97%
token-level accuracy. GiusBERTo provides the Italian legal community with an
accurate and tailored BERT model for de-identification, balancing privacy and
data protection. | [
-0.2438599169254303,
-0.8137440085411072,
0.5138775706291199,
-0.0677829384803772,
-0.35536113381385803,
-0.05363034829497337,
-0.3378726840019226,
-0.7577615976333618,
0.24116146564483643,
0.3757859766483307,
-0.44300299882888794,
-0.6021469235420227,
-0.6081550121307373,
-0.051890186965465546,
-0.9104434847831726,
1.0227935314178467,
0.3922426104545593,
0.49837526679039,
0.3169623911380768,
-0.26293623447418213,
0.03517552837729454,
-0.7241706848144531,
-0.6351598501205444,
0.34297865629196167,
0.6688656806945801,
0.15988852083683014,
0.6897845268249512,
0.5848557949066162,
0.31932151317596436,
0.3283344805240631,
-0.2567489445209503,
-0.22667741775512695,
-0.3375178575515747,
-0.039242345839738846,
-0.3705731928348541,
-0.3993476629257202,
-0.3041720688343048,
-0.1077069342136383,
0.43553486466407776,
0.3447069227695465,
-0.37874042987823486,
0.26915600895881653,
-0.049464669078588486,
0.6968976855278015,
-0.6848853826522827,
0.029356518760323524,
-0.6800729036331177,
-0.06467263400554657,
-0.3910805284976959,
0.011358543299138546,
-0.4010925889015198,
-0.8300651907920837,
0.19640685617923737,
-0.5765644311904907,
0.6353740096092224,
-0.14699381589889526,
1.1921451091766357,
0.2794766426086426,
-0.17467421293258667,
-0.8887391686439514,
-0.9062772393226624,
0.42587289214134216,
-0.633198082447052,
0.21976231038570404,
0.3825402855873108,
0.5291679501533508,
-0.058670319616794586,
-0.7704657912254333,
-0.5791173577308655,
-0.41380199790000916,
-0.09531974792480469,
-0.11948049068450928,
-0.12595240771770477,
0.1243928000330925,
0.23603340983390808,
0.16630779206752777,
-0.5084966421127319,
0.17399226129055023,
-0.5504066944122314,
-0.27864888310432434,
0.7275318503379822,
-0.1855110377073288,
0.35405412316322327,
0.3639414310455322,
-0.344946026802063,
0.17865709960460663,
-0.6477255821228027,
-0.2004023790359497,
1.0561058521270752,
0.3213169276714325,
0.1581285446882248,
0.23930589854717255,
-0.1971755176782608,
0.49436643719673157,
0.036679498851299286,
0.05915835499763489,
0.1875607967376709,
0.19281381368637085,
-0.27698448300361633,
0.2793121039867401,
0.6044048070907593,
-0.1064673587679863,
0.613997220993042,
-0.29563984274864197,
-0.2602232098579407,
-0.18215250968933105,
0.2423463761806488,
-0.7305833101272583,
-0.25404274463653564,
0.10883915424346924,
-0.2609277069568634,
-0.22038017213344574,
0.20416554808616638,
-0.6946481466293335,
-0.6361885070800781,
-0.39527109265327454,
0.27374082803726196,
-0.32210811972618103,
0.16874216496944427,
0.07032538950443268,
0.07977769523859024,
0.07301682978868484,
0.6263640522956848,
-1.2220796346664429,
0.40338537096977234,
0.5587760210037231,
0.45974406599998474,
0.3818413019180298,
0.04392979294061661,
-0.5921899676322937,
0.3752304017543793,
-0.20211905241012573,
0.5187898278236389,
-0.6953690648078918,
-0.35244911909103394,
0.2556951642036438,
0.0619659423828125,
0.07987955212593079,
-0.5002701282501221,
0.608119785785675,
-0.5137911438941956,
0.376871794462204,
-0.19863489270210266,
-0.6136751770973206,
-0.3103850781917572,
-0.047333911061286926,
-0.6813143491744995,
0.6714562773704529,
0.03464684262871742,
-0.7809484004974365,
0.7100018262863159,
-0.7361481189727783,
-0.5862637758255005,
0.5382527709007263,
-0.46839866042137146,
-0.39620843529701233,
0.16029563546180725,
-0.1641167253255844,
0.2723904252052307,
-0.2954227030277252,
0.7592971920967102,
-0.44211718440055847,
-0.2601543664932251,
-0.1025279313325882,
-0.4042346477508545,
1.1712836027145386,
0.5537168383598328,
-0.4732169508934021,
-0.005820859223604202,
-0.8884689211845398,
-0.1637471467256546,
-0.005937730893492699,
-0.42998504638671875,
-0.46286576986312866,
0.4601583480834961,
-0.01636938750743866,
-0.19827735424041748,
0.45547109842300415,
-0.5641981363296509,
0.30557575821876526,
-0.286904513835907,
0.8325706720352173,
0.6394714117050171,
-0.3052283525466919,
0.3717835545539856,
-0.18584857881069183,
0.4579084813594818,
-0.20124869048595428,
0.28638800978660583,
0.13855426013469696,
-0.5426146984100342,
-0.44433924555778503,
-0.8517154455184937,
0.940066933631897,
0.7366616129875183,
-0.15867313742637634,
0.5963037610054016,
-0.40717118978500366,
-0.587576687335968,
-0.5257370471954346,
-0.007406945340335369,
0.12652914226055145,
0.43497398495674133,
0.1513214260339737,
-0.15345482528209686,
-0.2620202898979187,
-1.2363371849060059,
-0.20597343146800995,
-0.30973896384239197,
-0.26594632863998413,
0.5313231945037842,
0.6689404249191284,
-0.3792879283428192,
0.9130516052246094,
-0.10997960716485977,
-0.5873172879219055,
-0.07051095366477966,
0.5471949577331543,
0.26142022013664246,
0.5685386657714844,
0.9895618557929993,
-0.8843551874160767,
-0.4090905487537384,
-0.046738576143980026,
-0.48298850655555725,
-0.06529444456100464,
-0.06214982271194458,
-0.18111109733581543,
0.09626217931509018,
-0.08540159463882446,
-0.42988619208335876,
0.8163340091705322,
0.2128124088048935,
-0.24824264645576477,
0.32172930240631104,
-0.801788866519928,
0.09287552535533905,
-0.6246189475059509,
0.2568940818309784,
-0.17175155878067017,
-0.3540721535682678,
-0.7470661997795105,
0.06313183158636093,
0.26500043272972107,
-0.05379241332411766,
-0.49075624346733093,
0.5919040441513062,
-0.5722509026527405,
-0.1160779744386673,
0.23209114372730255,
-0.09133629500865936,
-0.2919326722621918,
0.42866310477256775,
0.03020702861249447,
0.9028230309486389,
0.651639997959137,
-0.7202654480934143,
0.15142858028411865,
0.41164010763168335,
-0.708423376083374,
0.5915917158126831,
-0.5087088346481323,
0.27512097358703613,
-0.21106331050395966,
-0.3322529196739197,
-1.0438579320907593,
-0.29571661353111267,
0.2874269485473633,
-0.43720945715904236,
0.3253883719444275,
-0.3452080488204956,
-0.7377474308013916,
-0.2734266221523285,
-0.029490668326616287,
0.19865292310714722,
0.3479638695716858,
-0.60481196641922,
0.8467177152633667,
0.6231251955032349,
-0.5605560541152954,
-0.36344021558761597,
-0.7420804500579834,
0.23985041677951813,
-0.5442548990249634,
-0.4414809048175812,
0.34624341130256653,
-0.20622049272060394,
-0.10223212093114853,
-0.16430936753749847,
0.3543836176395416,
-1.0499051809310913,
0.6057358384132385,
0.07783982157707214,
0.2337484359741211,
0.12832464277744293,
0.4314330816268921,
0.1583986133337021,
0.1914055347442627,
0.07768614590167999,
0.03093923069536686,
0.3909056782722473,
0.2088388353586197,
-0.0676766186952591,
-0.6072497367858887,
0.413597971200943,
0.48961105942726135,
-0.1609070748090744,
0.5944539904594421,
0.05234596133232117,
-0.5458860993385315,
0.0590796023607254,
-0.5318195223808289,
0.14618681371212006,
-0.4708097577095032,
0.06320890784263611,
-0.29626068472862244,
-0.47729453444480896,
0.6776244640350342,
0.1372126191854477,
0.028019314631819725,
0.2382381558418274,
0.5726845264434814,
-0.10722117125988007,
0.8580667972564697,
0.6723207831382751,
-0.6985548734664917,
0.690740168094635,
0.10191630572080612,
0.37734851241111755,
-0.1985277533531189,
-0.008693399839103222,
-1.0384379625320435,
-0.37604257464408875,
-0.6033691167831421,
0.13810093700885773,
0.07339321076869965,
-0.06576061993837357,
-0.19740943610668182,
0.4040374159812927,
-0.5816225409507751,
0.44051817059516907,
0.9311363101005554,
0.2736544907093048,
0.2515154480934143,
-0.19088247418403625,
-0.09656805545091629,
0.09652601927518845,
-0.19398421049118042,
-0.9235707521438599,
0.9486307501792908,
-0.01001234445720911,
0.9196137189865112,
0.23625320196151733,
0.8247630000114441,
0.7520710229873657,
0.5027141571044922,
-0.3768575191497803,
0.48341646790504456,
-0.05957777425646782,
-1.2255017757415771,
-0.43256285786628723,
-0.385297954082489,
-0.9455211162567139,
0.0664403960108757,
-0.2115623652935028,
-1.194534182548523,
0.36698102951049805,
0.25873756408691406,
-0.5961009860038757,
0.04332222044467926,
-0.7283101081848145,
0.768403172492981,
-0.5681328177452087,
-0.5800325274467468,
-0.32910582423210144,
-0.595327615737915,
0.09073633700609207,
-0.10033363848924637,
0.43137720227241516,
-0.2516639828681946,
0.07250098884105682,
0.6072083115577698,
-0.47187402844429016,
0.5601406097412109,
-0.5343860983848572,
-0.13297206163406372,
0.22060441970825195,
0.028394684195518494,
0.6599052548408508,
0.3036690354347229,
-0.1378660351037979,
0.13992786407470703,
0.2645503878593445,
-0.16322959959506989,
-0.33153557777404785,
0.547246515750885,
-0.3596602976322174,
-0.6329424381256104,
-0.4075215756893158,
-0.1481846570968628,
0.08230927586555481,
0.3781273365020752,
0.28757357597351074,
0.2751099765300751,
-0.42450857162475586,
0.18938468396663666,
0.45342138409614563,
-0.17270313203334808,
0.443762868642807,
0.9287397265434265,
0.29348427057266235,
-0.38934406638145447,
0.6741907000541687,
0.2881559729576111,
-0.38687682151794434,
0.12379665672779083,
-0.01649455539882183,
-0.40731891989707947,
-0.5802047252655029,
-0.4822101294994354,
0.1796501725912094,
-0.4666425585746765,
-0.025597229599952698,
-0.32815736532211304,
0.028534775599837303,
-0.24386447668075562,
-0.047308795154094696,
-0.1444973200559616,
-0.4866601228713989,
-0.43955346941947937,
-0.1693204790353775,
-0.189938485622406,
0.7208439707756042,
-0.040788717567920685,
0.02704310230910778,
-0.6228100061416626,
0.2187548279762268,
0.3074091970920563,
0.2908608913421631,
-0.5465698838233948,
-0.3843182325363159,
0.005158673506230116,
0.19483207166194916,
0.10379362106323242,
-1.0610312223434448,
0.5159949064254761,
0.3202051818370819,
0.6609676480293274,
0.6903578042984009,
0.10128398984670639,
0.7146430611610413,
-0.6742188930511475,
0.4537568986415863,
-0.08071531355381012,
-1.1738914251327515,
0.645190417766571,
-0.17361992597579956,
-0.3078939616680145,
0.9210925102233887,
0.40854471921920776,
-0.0478423647582531,
-0.6149036288261414,
-0.6509507298469543,
-0.8372939229011536,
0.5446680784225464,
0.22868560254573822,
0.36593708395957947,
0.02771313302218914,
0.5194445252418518,
0.19515912234783173,
0.6484453678131104,
-0.6016393899917603,
0.21559202671051025,
0.41944900155067444,
-0.38349467515945435,
0.19275760650634766,
-0.4087372422218323,
-0.2387646585702896,
-0.4732096493244171,
0.6381411552429199,
0.015430863946676254,
0.40658244490623474,
0.29955580830574036,
-0.4706399440765381,
0.2323993742465973,
0.26543959975242615,
0.8846598863601685,
0.7408140301704407,
-0.03731926530599594,
-0.2609536349773407,
0.074703149497509,
-0.31082776188850403,
0.02848454751074314,
0.25813743472099304,
-0.40517520904541016,
0.4207710325717926,
0.18752482533454895,
0.42787688970565796,
0.21422886848449707,
-0.7797183394432068,
0.628856360912323,
-0.33431071043014526,
-0.38458889722824097,
-0.7723923921585083,
0.3048923909664154,
-0.29836323857307434,
0.21232278645038605,
0.41148823499679565,
-0.1827254295349121,
0.6515321135520935,
-0.5259910225868225,
0.1472863256931305,
0.5239230394363403,
-0.11159802973270416,
-0.4275102913379669,
1.3180514574050903,
0.40320026874542236,
-0.2786482274532318,
0.5083573460578918,
-0.08569687604904175,
-0.427493155002594,
0.6240828633308411,
-0.27294230461120605,
1.0527976751327515,
-0.363045871257782,
0.10180499404668808,
0.4409281015396118,
0.17045553028583527,
-0.1650114506483078,
0.25139832496643066,
-0.605084240436554,
-0.5771352052688599,
0.34286510944366455,
-0.27773019671440125,
-0.49139225482940674,
-0.04343322664499283,
-1.0641196966171265,
0.38225820660591125,
-0.7844454050064087,
-0.26420679688453674,
0.13812494277954102,
-0.014095358550548553,
-0.6496177911758423,
0.24750640988349915,
0.32891950011253357,
0.935569703578949,
-0.6772719025611877,
1.4397519826889038,
0.3213981091976166,
-0.24075396358966827,
-0.3318764865398407,
-0.23104354739189148,
-0.02754857949912548,
-0.687383770942688,
0.7687492370605469,
0.2033492773771286,
-0.05552494153380394,
0.034821413457393646,
-0.774349570274353,
-0.5000672340393066,
1.091232180595398,
0.7764080166816711,
-1.038184642791748,
-0.21297037601470947,
0.07181716710329056,
0.7404252886772156,
-0.34785905480384827,
0.14636112749576569,
0.6465967297554016,
0.649368941783905,
0.030993210151791573,
-0.6744765043258667,
-0.35322093963623047,
-0.23072941601276398,
-0.11340432614088058,
0.007490796968340874,
-0.4203788638114929,
0.7945268750190735,
-0.2824648916721344,
-0.6355403065681458,
0.5130009651184082,
0.3828521966934204,
-0.5116739869117737,
0.07311493158340454,
0.4809495806694031,
0.5387271046638489,
1.572442650794983,
-0.3983937203884125,
0.9196879267692566,
-0.798233151435852,
0.637631356716156,
1.3669488430023193,
-0.6259955167770386,
0.577120840549469,
0.15537326037883759,
0.01978629268705845,
0.6145360469818115,
0.3930032551288605,
-0.11065148562192917,
0.927967369556427,
0.3515677750110626,
-0.4737194776535034,
0.03763239085674286,
0.09311068803071976,
-0.2323884516954422,
0.14529277384281158,
0.17494288086891174,
-0.6548179388046265,
-0.05315275490283966,
-0.16996847093105316,
0.1962767094373703,
0.11596135050058365,
0.014200837351381779,
0.8750224709510803,
-0.641284167766571,
-0.3663562536239624,
0.17762795090675354,
-0.10546859353780746,
0.08904317766427994,
-0.6135666370391846,
0.06081835925579071,
-0.3714767396450043,
0.2949974834918976,
0.11348310858011246,
-0.5098472237586975,
0.14307385683059692,
0.3665255308151245,
-0.04766112565994263,
-0.3850380778312683,
0.3431355953216553,
-0.5343214273452759,
-0.40637168288230896,
0.4362301528453827,
-0.09964928776025772,
0.216402068734169,
0.01952427811920643,
-0.6811537146568298,
-0.3566264808177948,
-0.17429028451442719,
-0.3551480770111084,
0.11923373490571976,
0.48753413558006287,
0.030376208946108818,
0.8177565932273865,
0.34557250142097473,
0.12323709577322006,
0.23678255081176758,
0.19396060705184937,
0.8804125785827637,
-0.7573153376579285,
-0.8504300713539124,
-0.8060788512229919,
0.4115469455718994,
-0.3194807767868042,
-0.40450724959373474,
0.31479230523109436,
0.8149876594543457,
0.6654365658760071,
-0.12067706882953644,
0.8705260753631592,
-0.24837176501750946,
0.6262385845184326,
-0.49372997879981995,
0.8743740916252136,
-0.3830862045288086,
0.16450224816799164,
0.10924134403467178,
-0.6789956092834473,
-0.21737147867679596,
0.7645450234413147,
-0.3348221182823181,
-0.2375226765871048,
0.25030308961868286,
0.9041882157325745,
0.3519863486289978,
-0.046229876577854156,
0.4225667417049408,
0.23788826167583466,
0.3182458281517029,
0.6202113628387451,
0.6194581985473633,
-0.07297112792730331,
0.3199654221534729,
-0.04674065113067627,
-0.08621832728385925,
-0.2635122835636139,
-0.6233412623405457,
-0.9598660469055176,
-0.4357055425643921,
-0.24872790277004242,
0.2218383401632309,
0.3996632993221283,
0.4755743741989136,
0.7363693118095398,
-1.0898252725601196,
-0.021863006055355072,
-0.16096371412277222,
-0.10774565488100052,
0.06880063563585281,
-0.15599650144577026,
-0.04476075619459152,
-0.26647159457206726,
-1.1173393726348877,
0.07634859532117844,
0.3339075446128845,
0.18916374444961548,
-0.0007796812569722533,
-0.058953799307346344,
-0.29633212089538574,
0.1874779760837555,
-0.10183568298816681,
0.487032949924469,
-0.6078993082046509,
-0.5893489718437195,
-0.6832205653190613,
-0.44889792799949646,
0.1901543289422989,
0.6354983448982239,
-0.416682630777359,
0.6484010219573975,
0.4446917772293091,
0.4677946865558624,
0.4068845808506012,
0.35597988963127136,
0.5554154515266418,
-0.34527456760406494,
0.5473271012306213,
0.319871187210083,
0.7169108390808105,
-0.08829846233129501,
-0.5456864237785339,
0.821109414100647,
0.10677210241556168,
-0.3740778863430023,
-0.6070358753204346,
-0.13089556992053986,
-0.6606621146202087,
-0.0798133984208107,
0.5958302021026611,
-0.5456064343452454,
-0.3853526711463928,
0.04452408477663994,
-0.3420122265815735,
-0.07238893955945969,
-0.295247882604599,
1.081099033355713,
0.9056900143623352,
0.5044592618942261,
0.2250743806362152,
-0.7399625182151794,
0.3684879243373871,
0.1593073010444641,
-0.8694521188735962,
-0.06220385804772377,
0.6287793517112732,
0.2654511034488678,
0.05048845335841179,
0.6656416058540344,
-0.1638074666261673,
0.2904873490333557,
-0.4697040617465973,
0.11466305702924728,
0.1593458652496338,
-0.6821104288101196,
-0.30914968252182007,
0.09347853064537048,
-0.06596512347459793,
-0.357402503490448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15019v1 | MedOdyssey: A Medical Domain Benchmark for Long Context Evaluation Up to 200K Tokens | 2024-06-21T09:46:57 | 2024-06-21T09:46:57 | Yongqi Fan, Hongli Sun, Kui Xue, Xiaofan Zhang, Shaoting Zhang, Tong Ruan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous advanced Large Language Models (LLMs) now support context lengths up
to 128K, and some extend to 200K. Some benchmarks in the generic domain have
also followed up on evaluating long-context capabilities. In the medical
domain, tasks are distinctive due to the unique contexts and need for domain
expertise, necessitating further evaluation. However, despite the frequent
presence of long texts in medical scenarios, evaluation benchmarks of
long-context capabilities for LLMs in this field are still rare. In this paper,
we propose MedOdyssey, the first medical long-context benchmark with seven
length levels ranging from 4K to 200K tokens. MedOdyssey consists of two
primary components: the medical-context "needles in a haystack" task and a
series of tasks specific to medical applications, together comprising 10
datasets. The first component includes challenges such as counter-intuitive
reasoning and novel (unknown) facts injection to mitigate knowledge leakage and
data contamination of LLMs. The second component confronts the challenge of
requiring professional medical expertise. Especially, we design the ``Maximum
Identical Context'' principle to improve fairness by guaranteeing that
different LLMs observe as many identical contexts as possible. Our experiment
evaluates advanced proprietary and open-source LLMs tailored for processing
long contexts and presents detailed performance analyses. This highlights that
LLMs still face challenges and need for further research in this area. Our code
and data are released in the repository:
\url{https://github.com/JOHNNY-fans/MedOdyssey.} | [
-0.1331276148557663,
-0.492941677570343,
0.96868896484375,
0.1438351273536682,
-0.41564372181892395,
-0.11326683312654495,
-0.42888420820236206,
-0.675825834274292,
0.29132136702537537,
0.4449702203273773,
-0.6972953677177429,
-0.580594539642334,
-0.5289391875267029,
0.3033875823020935,
-0.09927568584680557,
1.0996161699295044,
-0.2567448318004608,
0.15553492307662964,
-0.4052012860774994,
-0.5323179364204407,
-0.586150050163269,
-0.4481395483016968,
-0.4050423204898834,
-0.06645866483449936,
0.7242030501365662,
0.05255277082324028,
0.23203738033771515,
0.6613487005233765,
0.6295788884162903,
0.22274388372898102,
-0.14357076585292816,
0.3524188697338104,
-0.5610754489898682,
0.45547565817832947,
-0.330099493265152,
-0.1472652703523636,
-0.7590435147285461,
0.07915817201137543,
0.5440260171890259,
0.8335543870925903,
-0.10711749643087387,
0.2689935266971588,
0.07542896270751953,
0.7897838950157166,
-0.6478461623191833,
-0.11970486491918564,
-0.31531351804733276,
-0.07172486931085587,
-0.5031928420066833,
-0.3292357325553894,
-0.17914390563964844,
-0.1236783117055893,
0.10876211524009705,
-0.5196501016616821,
-0.16774815320968628,
0.04848437011241913,
0.40581580996513367,
0.23416706919670105,
-0.7073237895965576,
-0.2949482202529907,
-0.08562862873077393,
0.9151089787483215,
-0.6323121190071106,
0.34927618503570557,
0.4800735414028168,
0.4849385917186737,
-0.43526551127433777,
-0.9246253967285156,
-0.2563598155975342,
-0.2421313375234604,
0.23388315737247467,
-0.04464375972747803,
0.038855038583278656,
0.12172265350818634,
0.17443519830703735,
0.09580575674772263,
-0.5590474009513855,
0.16621056199073792,
-0.4056977927684784,
-0.04021894931793213,
0.5883602499961853,
0.6309618949890137,
-0.006369106937199831,
-0.1595238596200943,
-0.49656468629837036,
0.30681902170181274,
-0.6364639401435852,
-0.010338391177356243,
-0.20669546723365784,
-0.10309847444295883,
-0.2726789116859436,
0.6126871109008789,
-0.3696161210536957,
0.703772783279419,
-0.27414557337760925,
-0.4209328591823578,
0.5199655890464783,
-0.22987297177314758,
-0.28017401695251465,
-0.12121331691741943,
0.5526882410049438,
0.6306249499320984,
-0.12298528105020523,
-0.24203133583068848,
-0.22513850033283234,
0.12097956240177155,
0.2971387505531311,
-0.8309443593025208,
0.18704120814800262,
0.4974685609340668,
-0.6567274928092957,
-0.13709181547164917,
-0.49811506271362305,
-0.5696028470993042,
-0.6945692896842957,
-0.31895899772644043,
0.25251609086990356,
-0.5287987589836121,
-0.01774805784225464,
0.42881736159324646,
0.07190488278865814,
-0.2154814451932907,
0.3243071138858795,
-0.5206757187843323,
0.376404732465744,
1.2414100170135498,
0.954590916633606,
-0.6739036440849304,
-0.47874191403388977,
-0.3916454315185547,
0.14378872513771057,
-0.3913889527320862,
0.7734904289245605,
-0.27095651626586914,
-0.14097993075847626,
-0.0738753080368042,
0.22815492749214172,
0.03489789739251137,
-0.6258803606033325,
0.5720341205596924,
-0.05682813376188278,
0.08010527491569519,
-0.05142652988433838,
-0.9673823118209839,
0.23728080093860626,
0.2609272599220276,
-0.3280075490474701,
0.7924093008041382,
0.19306500256061554,
-0.7079180479049683,
0.7686538696289062,
-0.7077326774597168,
-0.4554878771305084,
0.40313348174095154,
-0.5658211708068848,
-0.15327765047550201,
0.2168901413679123,
-0.19814801216125488,
0.5233411192893982,
-0.5352767705917358,
0.5292971134185791,
-0.4444543123245239,
-0.38949087262153625,
0.4113177955150604,
-0.47638705372810364,
0.716004490852356,
0.23670418560504913,
-0.24901007115840912,
0.15897071361541748,
-0.7902692556381226,
0.13192883133888245,
-0.08485221117734909,
-0.4402907192707062,
-0.5061580538749695,
-0.05074840784072876,
0.2029290348291397,
0.23006485402584076,
0.29820263385772705,
-0.8468525409698486,
0.23502196371555328,
-0.27396613359451294,
0.5018782019615173,
0.722209095954895,
-0.19358666241168976,
-0.15919484198093414,
-0.5406521558761597,
0.5486046671867371,
-0.21398717164993286,
0.11996825039386749,
-0.05177134647965431,
-0.391757607460022,
-0.013191401027143002,
-1.014647364616394,
0.01800953596830368,
0.11737805604934692,
-0.38648200035095215,
0.6219041347503662,
-0.5062644481658936,
-0.2299976348876953,
-0.6005771160125732,
-0.049939125776290894,
0.38939616084098816,
0.605916440486908,
0.3362317383289337,
-0.3083590865135193,
-0.46075505018234253,
-1.0001026391983032,
-0.5073949694633484,
0.20418190956115723,
-0.3684305250644684,
0.656717836856842,
0.5314028263092041,
-0.6979617476463318,
0.9674160480499268,
-0.4347580373287201,
-0.4127522110939026,
0.08261192589998245,
-0.21097862720489502,
0.6622695922851562,
0.39004889130592346,
0.41463229060173035,
-0.39085179567337036,
-0.24117369949817657,
-0.029322510585188866,
-0.7714678049087524,
-0.2747921943664551,
0.17210735380649567,
-0.04572112485766411,
0.24803826212882996,
0.47750619053840637,
-0.7656977772712708,
0.3287186622619629,
0.8559380173683167,
-0.7458677887916565,
0.6577625274658203,
-0.3634512424468994,
0.2171645611524582,
-1.1751593351364136,
0.478897362947464,
-0.2882136106491089,
-0.4964745044708252,
-0.40183526277542114,
-0.05113290250301361,
0.39264070987701416,
0.06218213960528374,
-0.3871143162250519,
0.9425841569900513,
-0.20347003638744354,
0.12186260521411896,
-0.23659557104110718,
0.00011922944395337254,
-0.18275724351406097,
0.26876571774482727,
-0.2029821127653122,
0.6127575635910034,
0.44644081592559814,
-0.2846619486808777,
0.5282831788063049,
-0.09404955059289932,
-0.8027610778808594,
0.9151056408882141,
-0.48866134881973267,
-0.10646330565214157,
0.06960447132587433,
0.48676595091819763,
-0.887175440788269,
-0.30521559715270996,
-0.24978508055210114,
-0.25670039653778076,
0.09242481738328934,
-0.1387099325656891,
-0.39232107996940613,
-0.422859787940979,
-0.3823595345020294,
0.8076611161231995,
0.5092692375183105,
-0.49939361214637756,
0.1798897534608841,
0.5318466424942017,
-0.1857171654701233,
-0.6241558194160461,
-0.48191526532173157,
0.37500327825546265,
-0.4294566512107849,
-0.5241518616676331,
0.2463092803955078,
-0.22573219239711761,
-0.0252524446696043,
-0.2092345654964447,
-0.3652578294277191,
-0.012181202881038189,
-0.033075928688049316,
0.4606828987598419,
0.1354483962059021,
-0.03953883796930313,
0.3375326991081238,
0.06821037828922272,
-0.3219436705112457,
0.22102178633213043,
-0.19112175703048706,
0.4234580993652344,
0.11353082954883575,
-0.3603341579437256,
-0.3993711769580841,
0.3337309956550598,
0.7860166430473328,
0.2340649515390396,
0.5639896988868713,
0.10641463100910187,
-0.4628596603870392,
-0.19972161948680878,
-0.6557990908622742,
0.01804262213408947,
-0.4660216271877289,
0.8988205194473267,
-0.37666791677474976,
-0.8561372756958008,
0.31074440479278564,
-0.35073408484458923,
0.1548154056072235,
0.2127092480659485,
0.6353215575218201,
-0.057912614196538925,
0.9279050230979919,
0.2976069748401642,
-0.21061435341835022,
-0.04273022711277008,
0.1463412344455719,
-0.07069748640060425,
-0.9106870889663696,
-0.2640098035335541,
-0.13357038795948029,
-0.1901373267173767,
-0.39920827746391296,
-0.5801243185997009,
0.677901029586792,
-0.17309291660785675,
-0.14372242987155914,
-0.0737418681383133,
-0.21861059963703156,
0.39847201108932495,
0.1284305453300476,
0.29608839750289917,
0.19175858795642853,
-0.11826609075069427,
-0.2752783000469208,
-0.0496431402862072,
-0.42215496301651,
-0.35863226652145386,
1.3007187843322754,
0.695892333984375,
0.7584421634674072,
-0.05653068423271179,
0.6901722550392151,
0.15565717220306396,
0.415506511926651,
-0.851622998714447,
0.5130617022514343,
-0.23184426128864288,
-0.6077834367752075,
-0.34039750695228577,
-0.3780560791492462,
-1.1531099081039429,
0.1087561845779419,
-0.038315050303936005,
-0.5345484614372253,
-0.10316627472639084,
0.013248310424387455,
-0.17977473139762878,
0.10689504444599152,
-0.221501424908638,
0.8337039947509766,
-0.16297850012779236,
-0.4870246946811676,
-0.3656857907772064,
-0.6111379265785217,
0.017824409529566765,
-0.2942056953907013,
0.2896234691143036,
-0.4327809512615204,
-0.4629349410533905,
0.8858315944671631,
-0.4998283386230469,
0.5862905979156494,
-0.10085643827915192,
-0.11449802666902542,
-0.346962571144104,
0.04737532138824463,
0.21042795479297638,
0.12321238964796066,
0.04625328630208969,
0.2818390727043152,
0.4835241138935089,
-0.5365658402442932,
-0.11833586543798447,
0.7958953976631165,
-0.23859834671020508,
-0.2553870975971222,
-0.3628850281238556,
-0.7074584364891052,
-0.5470491647720337,
0.4977392554283142,
0.16785074770450592,
0.6593860387802124,
-0.1752791851758957,
0.5512903928756714,
0.4003830552101135,
-0.18280155956745148,
0.11142060160636902,
0.5002270936965942,
-0.1463475525379181,
-0.23424366116523743,
0.5053622722625732,
-0.24208050966262817,
0.08625250309705734,
-0.07300852239131927,
0.2521275579929352,
-0.18437731266021729,
-0.7449355125427246,
-0.22790567576885223,
0.29167070984840393,
-0.5616269707679749,
-0.41226962208747864,
-0.5660386681556702,
0.07448048144578934,
-0.1970762461423874,
-0.09230039268732071,
-0.5265642404556274,
-0.0815809965133667,
0.1922215223312378,
0.19672417640686035,
0.3496049642562866,
0.6465620398521423,
0.04171846807003021,
-0.2460021823644638,
-0.5567592978477478,
0.4042888283729553,
0.14383579790592194,
1.0357557535171509,
-0.1640024036169052,
-0.38173696398735046,
-0.3783452808856964,
-0.09978942573070526,
0.04939105361700058,
-0.4932625889778137,
0.2832692563533783,
-0.04410581663250923,
0.4379916489124298,
0.5192119479179382,
-0.18169023096561432,
0.8258613348007202,
-0.9827218651771545,
0.5195958614349365,
0.2999984323978424,
-0.6167762875556946,
0.08928458392620087,
-0.3943098485469818,
0.2571984529495239,
0.7220908403396606,
0.17329873144626617,
-0.8659502267837524,
-0.28083130717277527,
-0.21213296055793762,
-0.776075005531311,
0.3455260396003723,
-0.0720253586769104,
-0.06883750855922699,
-0.27059924602508545,
0.4463407099246979,
0.47075754404067993,
0.24431274831295013,
-0.22170786559581757,
-0.08900735527276993,
0.40809306502342224,
-0.6358106136322021,
-0.28825733065605164,
-0.274170845746994,
-0.44698724150657654,
-0.3488643765449524,
0.1430656462907791,
-0.1812823861837387,
0.0018494733376428485,
0.2895657420158386,
-0.028123511001467705,
-0.07243435829877853,
0.1541217714548111,
0.7048618197441101,
1.256909966468811,
-0.282050222158432,
0.06395746767520905,
0.2727058231830597,
-0.8228665590286255,
-0.043455496430397034,
-0.010355903767049313,
0.4872440993785858,
-0.03434734418988228,
0.7407856583595276,
0.429320365190506,
0.30659887194633484,
-1.2741453647613525,
0.8388278484344482,
-0.06652767211198807,
-0.2534184455871582,
-0.26501354575157166,
-0.21125368773937225,
0.14824455976486206,
0.37706807255744934,
0.4453001916408539,
-0.2916768193244934,
0.2579144239425659,
-0.5191987752914429,
0.33144691586494446,
0.47867849469184875,
-0.25431910157203674,
-0.08169867098331451,
0.5378888249397278,
0.05876666679978371,
-0.08494091033935547,
0.24565955996513367,
0.23320861160755157,
-0.033481646329164505,
0.5586927533149719,
0.5298931002616882,
0.5794453620910645,
-0.09738240391016006,
-0.39139324426651,
-0.02747338078916073,
-0.16610506176948547,
-0.07123956829309464,
0.33711984753608704,
0.09494300931692123,
-0.14961890876293182,
-0.3334167003631592,
-0.5261295437812805,
-0.24080179631710052,
0.3146746754646301,
-0.6735481023788452,
0.2184280902147293,
-0.21346694231033325,
-0.2745858132839203,
0.05051703378558159,
0.16251996159553528,
-0.6928532719612122,
0.22097055613994598,
-0.13643288612365723,
1.063436508178711,
-0.500351071357727,
0.9697204828262329,
0.5366933345794678,
0.42836901545524597,
-0.08208565413951874,
-0.2793175280094147,
0.07849124073982239,
-1.095341444015503,
0.6447409391403198,
0.4860593378543854,
0.027610480785369873,
-0.5884518027305603,
-0.5597205758094788,
-0.4949228763580322,
1.1857795715332031,
0.06605497747659683,
-0.7528003454208374,
-0.07236862927675247,
0.15569983422756195,
0.7029769420623779,
-0.4847351610660553,
-0.09476426243782043,
0.6160398721694946,
0.07135235518217087,
-0.3705365061759949,
-1.2104675769805908,
0.258438378572464,
-0.2224799543619156,
-0.19358696043491364,
0.16955243051052094,
-0.31458115577697754,
0.8476563096046448,
-0.04580402374267578,
-0.011002168990671635,
0.5117472410202026,
0.10352274030447006,
0.6780837178230286,
0.7047104835510254,
0.4425801932811737,
0.43507125973701477,
0.7038684487342834,
0.26972299814224243,
0.9515621066093445,
-0.5763412117958069,
0.4323236644268036,
1.049402117729187,
-0.44067078828811646,
0.7780452966690063,
0.8501473069190979,
-0.23103421926498413,
0.17020975053310394,
0.3919804096221924,
0.3487726151943207,
0.5522634387016296,
0.42294466495513916,
-0.3627016246318817,
-0.0023927076254040003,
-0.02031349018216133,
-0.5129870772361755,
0.1622711718082428,
0.4157296121120453,
-0.32098305225372314,
0.006717965472489595,
0.1928926706314087,
0.022260230034589767,
-0.07803480327129364,
-0.24701830744743347,
0.7206493616104126,
0.15707062184810638,
-0.49765801429748535,
0.6679912805557251,
-0.09815569967031479,
0.8426450490951538,
-0.7113250494003296,
-0.013642234727740288,
-0.333562433719635,
0.42550602555274963,
-0.038423240184783936,
-0.7798945307731628,
-0.18623872101306915,
-0.029492631554603577,
0.07272789627313614,
0.004366553388535976,
0.358474463224411,
-0.2953072488307953,
-0.14323776960372925,
0.33187127113342285,
0.19354194402694702,
0.3528631627559662,
0.1664484292268753,
-0.43621164560317993,
0.05405411496758461,
-0.41901203989982605,
-0.3045092523097992,
0.49883782863616943,
0.6413359642028809,
0.0033036028034985065,
0.7973069548606873,
0.433235228061676,
0.5834907293319702,
-0.14598514139652252,
-0.22076299786567688,
0.8912617564201355,
-0.9024604558944702,
-0.7516098618507385,
-0.8674554228782654,
0.17478887736797333,
-0.18600548803806305,
-0.7018559575080872,
0.5419619083404541,
0.7379807233810425,
0.4999164938926697,
0.11016321927309036,
0.482959121465683,
0.1780739724636078,
0.955216646194458,
-0.5008856058120728,
0.7934073209762573,
-0.7924015522003174,
0.10075631737709045,
-0.154921293258667,
-0.5067777633666992,
-0.1574123203754425,
0.32831764221191406,
-0.05013471469283104,
-0.013109356164932251,
0.9350018501281738,
0.3259557783603668,
-0.2013445496559143,
-0.2830406129360199,
0.40768197178840637,
0.2869488596916199,
0.3131363093852997,
0.9706358909606934,
0.6088536381721497,
-0.00653421226888895,
0.060100242495536804,
-0.08043860644102097,
-0.6119383573532104,
-0.354006826877594,
-0.9362643361091614,
-1.0644830465316772,
-0.5224077105522156,
0.1895938366651535,
-0.43174439668655396,
0.3076106011867523,
1.0415682792663574,
0.7277153134346008,
-0.5646457672119141,
-0.3580329716205597,
0.22974880039691925,
-0.3029261827468872,
-0.18335796892642975,
-0.1334538459777832,
0.6400238275527954,
-0.2642320990562439,
-0.34836241602897644,
0.5209251046180725,
0.4743741750717163,
-0.3667373061180115,
-0.0831998661160469,
-0.14029009640216827,
0.06650857627391815,
-0.08067356050014496,
0.7307584285736084,
0.18923960626125336,
-0.6180675029754639,
-0.2586624026298523,
-0.22704650461673737,
-0.3783070743083954,
0.025222836062312126,
0.9628548622131348,
-0.7532393336296082,
0.5255776047706604,
0.2666252553462982,
0.7213711142539978,
0.2735763490200043,
-0.18979902565479279,
0.34108319878578186,
-0.540140688419342,
0.2805434465408325,
0.5031496286392212,
0.4342884123325348,
-0.15343771874904633,
-0.17991268634796143,
0.5497641563415527,
0.12569473683834076,
-0.6690860390663147,
-1.2342342138290405,
-0.03406038135290146,
-0.8261462450027466,
-0.6665178537368774,
1.0752631425857544,
-0.09147804975509644,
-0.186101034283638,
-0.2672859728336334,
-0.20736753940582275,
0.06585529446601868,
-0.12211517989635468,
0.9424651265144348,
0.4049776792526245,
-0.2175300568342209,
0.4629986882209778,
-0.9691638350486755,
0.7837826013565063,
0.703056275844574,
-0.9038947224617004,
0.25928160548210144,
0.5260300636291504,
0.649491012096405,
-0.3298358917236328,
0.9504203200340271,
-0.2554088234901428,
0.4850771725177765,
-0.32109665870666504,
-0.25116944313049316,
-0.062026120722293854,
-0.29592910408973694,
-0.5188748836517334,
-0.06622403115034103,
-0.1667683720588684,
-0.12861749529838562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15015v1 | GraLMatch: Matching Groups of Entities with Graphs and Language Models | 2024-06-21T09:44:16 | 2024-06-21T09:44:16 | Fernando De Meer Pardo, Claude Lehmann, Dennis Gehrig, Andrea Nagy, Stefano Nicoli, Branka Hadji Misheva, Martin Braschler, Kurt Stockinger | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we present an end-to-end multi-source Entity Matching problem,
which we call entity group matching, where the goal is to assign to the same
group, records originating from multiple data sources but representing the same
real-world entity. We focus on the effects of transitively matched records,
i.e. the records connected by paths in the graph G = (V,E) whose nodes and
edges represent the records and whether they are a match or not. We present a
real-world instance of this problem, where the challenge is to match records of
companies and financial securities originating from different data providers.
We also introduce two new multi-source benchmark datasets that present similar
matching challenges as real-world records. A distinctive characteristic of
these records is that they are regularly updated following real-world events,
but updates are not applied uniformly across data sources. This phenomenon
makes the matching of certain groups of records only possible through the use
of transitive information.
In our experiments, we illustrate how considering transitively matched
records is challenging since a limited amount of false positive pairwise match
predictions can throw off the group assignment of large quantities of records.
Thus, we propose GraLMatch, a method that can partially detect and remove false
positive pairwise predictions through graph-based properties. Finally, we
showcase how fine-tuning a Transformer-based model (DistilBERT) on a reduced
number of labeled samples yields a better final entity group matching than
training on more samples and/or incorporating fine-tuning optimizations,
illustrating how precision becomes the deciding factor in the entity group
matching of large volumes of records. | [
-0.22795262932777405,
-0.7216992974281311,
0.4957810938358307,
-0.012172539718449116,
-0.07817786931991577,
0.4608210623264313,
-0.0020968839526176453,
-0.5903373956680298,
0.18170815706253052,
0.6346294283866882,
-0.48376891016960144,
-0.42605647444725037,
-0.6197006106376648,
-0.2334529012441635,
-0.4619658291339874,
1.0576691627502441,
-0.1413753777742386,
-0.11162712424993515,
-0.05014299228787422,
-0.5164114236831665,
-0.6518623232841492,
-0.47646427154541016,
-0.6414893269538879,
-0.4535239338874817,
0.27585235238075256,
0.1589389592409134,
0.9645940661430359,
0.9299508929252625,
0.7568877339363098,
0.27731481194496155,
0.1529597043991089,
0.028316115960478783,
-0.7278499603271484,
0.2070411890745163,
-0.30624350905418396,
-0.384117066860199,
-0.20111362636089325,
0.1309056282043457,
0.7404385805130005,
0.7654047012329102,
-0.4314862787723541,
0.33510610461235046,
-0.3334360122680664,
0.6031794548034668,
-0.34206250309944153,
0.2553684115409851,
-0.8850216269493103,
-0.042960360646247864,
-0.33764156699180603,
-0.3432702422142029,
-0.4156847596168518,
-0.49516239762306213,
-0.10235505551099777,
-0.6746702194213867,
0.8349044919013977,
0.48230478167533875,
1.1725478172302246,
0.3437987267971039,
-0.44004926085472107,
-0.537198007106781,
-0.727175772190094,
0.2444775253534317,
-0.2868725657463074,
0.4621763229370117,
0.24192392826080322,
0.627633810043335,
-0.41970038414001465,
-0.586309015750885,
-0.3565293848514557,
0.017077144235372543,
-0.3079971969127655,
0.11488628387451172,
-0.28999724984169006,
-0.0030379665549844503,
0.32724130153656006,
0.398497998714447,
-0.8171412944793701,
-0.15978023409843445,
-0.21761950850486755,
-0.2202422320842743,
0.4116438627243042,
0.06619808077812195,
0.43515124917030334,
0.4197937846183777,
-0.31207436323165894,
-0.40063855051994324,
-0.7003641724586487,
-0.49772995710372925,
0.6706687808036804,
0.7402631044387817,
0.27434372901916504,
0.4785735309123993,
-0.0009235517936758697,
0.795853853225708,
-0.12807491421699524,
-0.07052390277385712,
0.2309897094964981,
-0.5767441391944885,
-0.09892307966947556,
0.3195614516735077,
0.5631281137466431,
0.6374351382255554,
0.3427416980266571,
-0.5699371695518494,
-0.03766263648867607,
0.5940165519714355,
-0.2851532995700836,
-0.6697879433631897,
-0.3694898188114166,
-0.2745596170425415,
-0.44648781418800354,
0.19390997290611267,
0.004523826763033867,
-0.8278120756149292,
-0.34640514850616455,
-0.4892333149909973,
0.2634337246417999,
-0.049001969397068024,
-0.1851687878370285,
0.2730688154697418,
-0.3110731840133667,
0.13574004173278809,
0.13427861034870148,
-0.7087372541427612,
0.44736382365226746,
0.7526887059211731,
1.0884279012680054,
0.16082289814949036,
-0.27654051780700684,
-0.9203326106071472,
0.37052568793296814,
-0.13839828968048096,
0.8688386082649231,
-0.7588538527488708,
-0.45144450664520264,
-0.12178122997283936,
-0.0001278500712942332,
-0.19591480493545532,
-0.6767773628234863,
0.374807745218277,
-0.47550511360168457,
0.23113176226615906,
-0.39384904503822327,
-0.579815149307251,
0.2121550738811493,
0.0613546296954155,
-0.8253029584884644,
0.8326859474182129,
0.2970394194126129,
-0.5139375329017639,
0.5495873093605042,
-0.3752943277359009,
-0.4009196162223816,
0.14760646224021912,
-0.3443528413772583,
-0.35902899503707886,
-0.12174699455499649,
-0.06998477876186371,
0.17808149755001068,
-0.5515970587730408,
0.29350292682647705,
-0.5030720829963684,
-0.3243977427482605,
-0.3134886920452118,
0.08834586292505264,
0.41412603855133057,
0.15410378575325012,
0.023308955132961273,
-0.05335880443453789,
-0.6980813145637512,
-0.0627421960234642,
0.37104880809783936,
-0.1168038621544838,
-0.674809992313385,
0.1734657883644104,
0.0698334127664566,
0.33913111686706543,
-0.08820270746946335,
-0.32633379101753235,
0.46882933378219604,
0.2352903038263321,
0.5011821985244751,
0.7983198761940002,
-0.09982891380786896,
0.4097765386104584,
-0.3968699872493744,
0.4964006841182709,
-0.14622345566749573,
0.010955672711133957,
-0.12510418891906738,
-0.36071914434432983,
-0.11705988645553589,
-0.19845040142536163,
0.3966435194015503,
0.42581626772880554,
-0.5029678344726562,
0.04917042702436447,
-0.5469830632209778,
-0.5717509388923645,
-0.5274999141693115,
-0.1397233009338379,
0.3160493075847626,
0.626089334487915,
0.4111609160900116,
-0.30565059185028076,
-0.3894225060939789,
-0.9523299336433411,
-0.6103013753890991,
-0.36717742681503296,
0.11676239967346191,
0.4828277826309204,
0.12731023132801056,
-0.16864071786403656,
0.723818838596344,
-0.7676905989646912,
-0.598976731300354,
0.327135294675827,
-0.09149476885795593,
0.40840110182762146,
0.2568291425704956,
0.756619930267334,
-0.6911195516586304,
-0.6398841142654419,
0.1614687144756317,
-0.6864551305770874,
-0.18676964938640594,
-0.2490551620721817,
-0.36657047271728516,
-0.18861764669418335,
0.6406888961791992,
-0.4224761724472046,
-0.0025506748352199793,
0.7000713348388672,
-0.7501363158226013,
0.11424523591995239,
-0.20064212381839752,
0.29441648721694946,
-0.9753636121749878,
-0.06097685918211937,
0.23432649672031403,
-0.39039167761802673,
-0.5777812004089355,
0.3523632884025574,
-0.0829966813325882,
-0.1326039731502533,
-0.14585112035274506,
0.587652325630188,
-0.6214070916175842,
-0.24544335901737213,
-0.13225889205932617,
0.43983393907546997,
-0.06283719092607498,
0.2817564904689789,
-0.3173602521419525,
0.8626350164413452,
0.5847024917602539,
-0.3291251063346863,
0.48017624020576477,
0.59904944896698,
-0.17141275107860565,
0.8927978873252869,
-0.48225077986717224,
0.2710292637348175,
-0.33937907218933105,
0.3921682834625244,
-0.8522569537162781,
0.04967517405748367,
0.2753017842769623,
-0.18083055317401886,
0.13165339827537537,
-0.46077659726142883,
-0.6269066333770752,
-0.09299053251743317,
0.15680384635925293,
0.4566608667373657,
0.27764180302619934,
-0.6514660120010376,
0.8895043134689331,
0.3462124764919281,
0.029888221994042397,
-0.45878422260284424,
-0.6479049921035767,
0.15921375155448914,
-0.3934924304485321,
-0.6573978662490845,
0.5209651589393616,
-0.1712341159582138,
-0.2232976257801056,
0.4411574602127075,
-0.327891081571579,
0.03222854062914848,
0.11561950296163559,
0.1625061184167862,
0.36769402027130127,
-0.09057094156742096,
0.15302737057209015,
-0.2540062367916107,
-0.23213209211826324,
-0.17109151184558868,
-0.40207067131996155,
0.5532951354980469,
-0.16513881087303162,
-0.6445053815841675,
0.14554724097251892,
0.33014610409736633,
0.442518949508667,
-0.1537821888923645,
0.7256526350975037,
0.3164195716381073,
-0.573183000087738,
0.10273529589176178,
-0.53114253282547,
0.09816572815179825,
-0.47139790654182434,
0.4116837680339813,
-0.5829436779022217,
-0.6930184960365295,
0.9545717239379883,
-0.1600111424922943,
-0.12903925776481628,
0.429078608751297,
0.4537539482116699,
0.3941623866558075,
0.7000800371170044,
0.3474961817264557,
-0.5547980666160583,
0.4187694191932678,
-0.009298148564994335,
0.44254472851753235,
-0.5261129140853882,
-0.1376921385526657,
-0.8651907444000244,
-0.34538567066192627,
-0.8620877265930176,
-0.03872344270348549,
0.045695967972278595,
0.13883553445339203,
-0.08829940855503082,
0.7639071941375732,
-0.690833568572998,
0.8173221349716187,
0.6062061786651611,
-0.16986963152885437,
0.5399186611175537,
-0.19822104275226593,
0.029728682711720467,
0.1804666370153427,
-0.44190841913223267,
-0.18719349801540375,
1.055424690246582,
-0.015124291181564331,
0.9262909889221191,
0.33245542645454407,
0.4364900588989258,
0.42666831612586975,
0.37328094244003296,
-0.4782961905002594,
0.41608497500419617,
-0.06999865174293518,
-0.5918417572975159,
-0.16688263416290283,
-0.8747700452804565,
-0.9671773314476013,
0.2967659533023834,
-0.1545150727033615,
-0.5688241124153137,
0.2624346911907196,
0.15970344841480255,
0.08834786713123322,
0.2906649708747864,
-0.8385340571403503,
0.946894109249115,
-0.07635260373353958,
-0.21740326285362244,
0.17066822946071625,
-0.5348003506660461,
0.2225521206855774,
-0.24088549613952637,
0.23827597498893738,
-0.43061235547065735,
0.4654912054538727,
0.4801595211029053,
-0.20931048691272736,
0.019069893285632133,
-0.23974649608135223,
-0.06775584816932678,
0.1205693781375885,
0.24439789354801178,
0.8892335295677185,
0.14867077767848969,
-0.02262423001229763,
0.2985577881336212,
0.1646120846271515,
-0.42583534121513367,
-0.5307962894439697,
0.7825482487678528,
-0.632549524307251,
-0.5238140225410461,
-0.42833176255226135,
-0.46133846044540405,
-0.01808762550354004,
0.3614053428173065,
0.14141440391540527,
0.2477685660123825,
-0.25358060002326965,
-0.07242805510759354,
0.17769134044647217,
0.3373377025127411,
0.2953336834907532,
0.6157792806625366,
-0.31042611598968506,
-0.1821921020746231,
1.049214243888855,
0.004157565999776125,
0.2894037663936615,
0.17607973515987396,
-0.07560337334871292,
-0.5910598039627075,
-0.4310416281223297,
-0.3993414640426636,
0.5022117495536804,
-0.8379658460617065,
-0.14398035407066345,
-0.42442700266838074,
0.19646820425987244,
-0.1715201735496521,
0.11860955506563187,
-0.18657416105270386,
-0.05735592544078827,
-0.09958910197019577,
0.005203697830438614,
0.056370336562395096,
0.442584753036499,
0.0892556756734848,
0.21103709936141968,
-0.8478084802627563,
0.344768226146698,
0.3320337235927582,
0.7420639991760254,
-0.3499923348426819,
-0.32909783720970154,
-0.15536141395568848,
-0.08340856432914734,
-0.0020322168711572886,
-0.8604162931442261,
0.005094454158097506,
0.37873879075050354,
0.6079636216163635,
0.12238453328609467,
-0.058302149176597595,
0.95755535364151,
-0.7679147720336914,
0.18366575241088867,
0.10739678889513016,
-0.9399487972259521,
0.34411725401878357,
-0.3804146647453308,
-0.30940836668014526,
0.7286750674247742,
0.1631607860326767,
-1.0968338251113892,
-0.34643644094467163,
-0.6703333258628845,
-0.6984543800354004,
0.6218339204788208,
0.42176660895347595,
-0.19614794850349426,
-0.07589811831712723,
0.5426734089851379,
-0.2553979754447937,
0.3279333710670471,
-0.41347548365592957,
-0.42432889342308044,
-0.206845223903656,
-0.23905916512012482,
-0.28821438550949097,
0.3803234398365021,
-0.2587338984012604,
0.2839182913303375,
0.6458914875984192,
-0.2939474582672119,
0.20442843437194824,
0.004141911864280701,
-0.03123156912624836,
-0.32188618183135986,
-0.06876421719789505,
0.5921869277954102,
0.7410128712654114,
-0.24317140877246857,
0.08483961969614029,
-0.16273346543312073,
-0.2833287715911865,
0.34207937121391296,
0.440736323595047,
-0.024251608178019524,
0.2516272962093353,
0.2978539764881134,
0.883165717124939,
-0.3901994228363037,
-0.6738575100898743,
0.46308374404907227,
-0.21472929418087006,
-0.21961717307567596,
-0.19035561382770538,
0.0006183465011417866,
0.0635211393237114,
0.3742278218269348,
0.5168214440345764,
0.16135364770889282,
0.039802148938179016,
-0.6772285103797913,
0.26373225450515747,
0.728923499584198,
-0.40316808223724365,
-0.44718137383461,
1.081438422203064,
-0.1660151332616806,
-0.6080614924430847,
0.6540184617042542,
-0.3751453757286072,
-0.3764643669128418,
0.6724352240562439,
0.5726546049118042,
0.5579506754875183,
-0.3473304212093353,
0.04654742032289505,
0.12980309128761292,
0.3780720829963684,
-0.5056226253509521,
-0.15245620906352997,
0.5307449102401733,
-0.9734234809875488,
-0.41717392206192017,
-0.1054898127913475,
-0.42185521125793457,
0.12087724357843399,
-0.7311686277389526,
0.27799686789512634,
-0.2776055634021759,
-0.1909351795911789,
0.0976671427488327,
-0.3416272699832916,
-0.8503451347351074,
-0.08183040469884872,
-0.06818590313196182,
0.5049464702606201,
-1.3389602899551392,
0.5191001296043396,
0.5782950520515442,
-0.3493884205818176,
-0.6562644243240356,
-0.12682420015335083,
0.004641453269869089,
-0.8788169026374817,
0.2998327314853668,
-0.11808427423238754,
0.2693035900592804,
0.1292523443698883,
-0.17998653650283813,
-0.896934986114502,
1.0089114904403687,
0.7227489352226257,
-0.6949154138565063,
-0.24471566081047058,
0.10679929703474045,
0.4760743975639343,
0.009706464596092701,
0.33365097641944885,
0.7413818836212158,
0.4931733012199402,
0.10533357411623001,
-0.7596220374107361,
0.23784923553466797,
-0.2745116949081421,
-0.21383431553840637,
0.8674168586730957,
-0.961829662322998,
0.9139256477355957,
0.35986289381980896,
-0.6038594245910645,
-0.409895658493042,
0.34401553869247437,
0.2917277216911316,
0.24947606027126312,
0.7095291018486023,
0.786331057548523,
1.0692212581634521,
-0.40900665521621704,
0.8812854886054993,
-0.4739128649234772,
0.9501411318778992,
1.3379690647125244,
-0.8091321587562561,
0.14404994249343872,
0.3413114845752716,
-0.3758302330970764,
0.24658924341201782,
0.5894801020622253,
-0.369613915681839,
0.5898268222808838,
0.4405231773853302,
-0.03996192291378975,
-0.24678149819374084,
-0.32893839478492737,
-0.6087425947189331,
0.0924208015203476,
0.06567834317684174,
-0.12530021369457245,
-0.48887941241264343,
-0.3324527442455292,
-0.21316543221473694,
0.24531523883342743,
-0.015358571894466877,
0.5310023427009583,
-0.22300148010253906,
-0.3901863992214203,
0.18613141775131226,
-0.0375213660299778,
0.22579476237297058,
-0.3738611340522766,
-0.1354246288537979,
-0.3645237982273102,
0.0026299809105694294,
-0.03286626562476158,
-0.49438053369522095,
0.20129811763763428,
-0.5679083466529846,
-0.2943496108055115,
-0.10722089558839798,
0.6385887861251831,
-0.5621412396430969,
-0.3025868535041809,
0.6379739046096802,
0.4948766827583313,
-0.03288108855485916,
-0.3265877664089203,
-0.597009003162384,
-0.35098037123680115,
-0.18991971015930176,
-0.019457785412669182,
0.3579767644405365,
0.5200452208518982,
-0.19636541604995728,
0.6949554085731506,
0.9026661515235901,
0.121273472905159,
0.03509870916604996,
0.2809271812438965,
0.8337072730064392,
-0.6411923766136169,
-0.5246466398239136,
-0.9418549537658691,
-0.1586180478334427,
-0.050432492047548294,
-0.07950890064239502,
0.42338258028030396,
0.9170371294021606,
1.0083403587341309,
0.12179715186357498,
0.7675150036811829,
0.16542337834835052,
0.4434874653816223,
-0.44753316044807434,
0.3575003743171692,
-0.2923313081264496,
0.18557070195674896,
-0.5507006645202637,
-1.3267782926559448,
-0.26534828543663025,
0.33683791756629944,
0.1965944617986679,
-0.10702170431613922,
0.8039678335189819,
0.8498546481132507,
-0.3426097631454468,
0.007135055959224701,
0.06590794026851654,
-0.029620014131069183,
0.6220118999481201,
0.7533031702041626,
0.702104389667511,
-0.6942481398582458,
0.6772902011871338,
0.337524950504303,
-0.06860990077257156,
-0.13907277584075928,
-0.8481428623199463,
-0.7733609676361084,
-0.5520781874656677,
-0.4745079278945923,
-0.495828241109848,
0.12665985524654388,
0.6352688074111938,
0.2317267805337906,
-0.5922955870628357,
-0.03167073428630829,
-0.2162390649318695,
0.16627924144268036,
-0.28952452540397644,
-0.21373558044433594,
0.5029560923576355,
0.09901626408100128,
-0.7148864269256592,
0.35810622572898865,
0.1218305379152298,
0.30734676122665405,
0.13904514908790588,
0.06119420379400253,
-0.17352943122386932,
-0.20058713853359222,
0.11708734929561615,
0.2260415405035019,
-0.40516847372055054,
-0.6284992694854736,
0.15850386023521423,
-0.0656910166144371,
0.18836720287799835,
0.97004634141922,
-0.4653455317020416,
0.35501840710639954,
0.33126556873321533,
0.7537029385566711,
0.6464260816574097,
0.36195141077041626,
0.251443088054657,
-0.6977328658103943,
0.1671110987663269,
-0.13009445369243622,
0.5815817713737488,
0.19119319319725037,
-0.37130019068717957,
0.9656166434288025,
0.5856347680091858,
-0.7146705389022827,
-0.9598409533500671,
0.18782676756381989,
-0.8297803401947021,
-0.007668695878237486,
0.9852931499481201,
-0.07901327311992645,
0.17411890625953674,
-0.11333218961954117,
0.0318562351167202,
0.3775464594364166,
-0.3278445303440094,
0.513545036315918,
0.8470585346221924,
0.24725928902626038,
0.08941271901130676,
-0.47565364837646484,
0.16332541406154633,
0.1998787224292755,
-0.673199474811554,
0.11309654265642166,
0.4527486264705658,
0.21569305658340454,
0.2694622278213501,
0.8017433285713196,
0.20347049832344055,
-0.1159735694527626,
-0.1059800311923027,
0.05873187631368637,
-0.14219437539577484,
-0.21333163976669312,
-0.0551067553460598,
0.1705775409936905,
-0.1684771329164505,
-0.27456727623939514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15000v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15000v1 | Unveiling the Impact of Multi-Modal Interactions on User Engagement: A Comprehensive Evaluation in AI-driven Conversations | 2024-06-21T09:26:55 | 2024-06-21T09:26:55 | Lichao Zhang, Jia Yu, Shuai Zhang, Long Li, Yangyang Zhong, Guanbao Liang, Yuming Yan, Qing Ma, Fangsheng Weng, Fayu Pan, Jing Li, Renjun Xu, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced user-bot
interactions, enabling more complex and coherent dialogues. However, the
prevalent text-only modality might not fully exploit the potential for
effective user engagement. This paper explores the impact of multi-modal
interactions, which incorporate images and audio alongside text, on user
engagement in chatbot conversations. We conduct a comprehensive analysis using
a diverse set of chatbots and real-user interaction data, employing metrics
such as retention rate and conversation length to evaluate user engagement. Our
findings reveal a significant enhancement in user engagement with multi-modal
interactions compared to text-only dialogues. Notably, the incorporation of a
third modality significantly amplifies engagement beyond the benefits observed
with just two modalities. These results suggest that multi-modal interactions
optimize cognitive processing and facilitate richer information comprehension.
This study underscores the importance of multi-modality in chatbot design,
offering valuable insights for creating more engaging and immersive AI
communication experiences and informing the broader AI community about the
benefits of multi-modal interactions in enhancing user engagement. | [
-0.4251137375831604,
-0.987129271030426,
0.630460262298584,
-0.015484679490327835,
-0.19748055934906006,
0.1897643506526947,
-0.36596083641052246,
-0.7653254270553589,
0.11182449012994766,
0.09347237646579742,
-0.4925145208835602,
-0.059345971792936325,
-0.3801989257335663,
-0.056072015315294266,
-0.1383838951587677,
0.5520974397659302,
0.31634387373924255,
0.037414707243442535,
-0.5491616129875183,
-0.010496309958398342,
-0.8781510591506958,
-0.6767776012420654,
-0.5303807854652405,
-0.23793604969978333,
0.8550563454627991,
0.13790270686149597,
1.1101516485214233,
0.13621626794338226,
0.6212922930717468,
0.4353734254837036,
-0.004393611568957567,
0.40951651334762573,
-0.42519721388816833,
0.4462020993232727,
0.38727593421936035,
-0.36723655462265015,
-0.22316865622997284,
0.10331408679485321,
0.38275933265686035,
0.17050616443157196,
0.12723475694656372,
-0.22648920118808746,
0.05380372703075409,
0.3003915846347809,
-0.4559982717037201,
0.39327919483184814,
-0.3749319911003113,
-0.10752080380916595,
-0.22399361431598663,
-0.5051544308662415,
-0.47367963194847107,
0.18098445236682892,
0.06875991821289062,
-0.5304476022720337,
-0.5342119932174683,
-0.17128510773181915,
0.6715052723884583,
0.459014892578125,
-0.8659787774085999,
-0.4765762686729431,
-0.9970768690109253,
0.6687785983085632,
-0.5342724919319153,
0.5906020402908325,
0.36622506380081177,
0.06746836006641388,
-0.10481204092502594,
-0.214784175157547,
-0.9931023120880127,
-0.41569095849990845,
-0.16833868622779846,
0.23403438925743103,
-0.28455251455307007,
0.3878055810928345,
0.16089493036270142,
0.1384062021970749,
-0.14765506982803345,
0.13648058474063873,
-0.30143365263938904,
-0.20549404621124268,
0.5511388182640076,
0.361488938331604,
0.5922945141792297,
-0.3558448851108551,
-0.27558350563049316,
-0.32630231976509094,
-0.17312277853488922,
0.39962688088417053,
0.4835505783557892,
0.16048790514469147,
-0.47125592827796936,
0.7829635143280029,
0.39873066544532776,
0.5887397527694702,
-0.22671034932136536,
-0.4287954866886139,
0.24851630628108978,
-0.9774709343910217,
-0.0038936941418796778,
-0.42415422201156616,
1.0910755395889282,
0.45228350162506104,
0.21112582087516785,
0.09573622047901154,
0.032617226243019104,
0.05646901577711105,
0.31666621565818787,
-0.7238646745681763,
-0.01177871786057949,
0.45177432894706726,
-0.5942205786705017,
-0.217206209897995,
0.19573193788528442,
-0.5783236026763916,
-0.4522840082645416,
-0.34377872943878174,
0.3558611273765564,
-0.608915388584137,
-0.43674418330192566,
-0.06680148094892502,
-0.2644749581813812,
0.12723807990550995,
0.785713255405426,
-0.6728430986404419,
-0.09231360256671906,
0.5603192448616028,
0.7491853833198547,
0.06532556563615799,
-0.27542561292648315,
-0.3208191990852356,
0.20425014197826385,
-0.29225268959999084,
0.6143249273300171,
-0.9676674008369446,
-0.5061357021331787,
0.017498696222901344,
-0.36363551020622253,
-0.3039778769016266,
-0.031843699514865875,
0.4091969430446625,
-0.4893191158771515,
0.5418586730957031,
-0.08679188787937164,
-0.26719558238983154,
-0.4187791347503662,
0.24960210919380188,
-0.6636500358581543,
0.7905179262161255,
-0.21974295377731323,
-0.36224058270454407,
0.261508971452713,
-1.156776785850525,
-0.6521103978157043,
0.029636843129992485,
-0.4268902838230133,
-0.0757533386349678,
0.16435506939888,
0.08118782937526703,
0.24100132286548615,
-0.3672734200954437,
0.1348753124475479,
-0.038412872701883316,
-0.2086830735206604,
0.7158470153808594,
-0.8985980153083801,
0.20720429718494415,
-0.0536474771797657,
-0.258163183927536,
0.37194791436195374,
-0.29419586062431335,
-0.11049008369445801,
-0.0712309330701828,
-0.5293139815330505,
-0.11532140523195267,
0.23744818568229675,
0.4490528702735901,
0.46871471405029297,
0.16561438143253326,
-0.5648630857467651,
-0.011393669992685318,
-0.12001413851976395,
0.38851407170295715,
0.7697258591651917,
-0.07491273432970047,
0.3328286111354828,
-0.3459623456001282,
0.6672910451889038,
0.2601540684700012,
0.23044490814208984,
-0.8670973777770996,
-0.5746213793754578,
-0.43542274832725525,
-0.7129642963409424,
0.1474447101354599,
0.3891252875328064,
-0.5988345742225647,
0.3382459282875061,
-0.1668744683265686,
-0.3112865090370178,
-0.5324313640594482,
0.21422012150287628,
0.2924977242946625,
0.2055947333574295,
0.04434303939342499,
-0.35234615206718445,
-0.049508996307849884,
-0.6745932698249817,
0.05029171332716942,
-0.4629935920238495,
-0.05964739993214607,
0.9926130771636963,
0.11817087978124619,
-0.5992552638053894,
1.0148478746414185,
0.07915464788675308,
-0.3296458423137665,
-0.3738321363925934,
0.29077258706092834,
-0.21221569180488586,
0.33577001094818115,
0.4374493956565857,
-0.9254171252250671,
-0.5088359713554382,
0.15235412120819092,
-0.6314900517463684,
0.27549150586128235,
-0.7993341088294983,
0.04724304378032684,
0.33833572268486023,
0.23810650408267975,
-0.8818415403366089,
0.6317754983901978,
0.6112725734710693,
-0.2714374363422394,
0.08433516323566437,
0.0056124781258404255,
0.6944389343261719,
-0.7327073216438293,
0.007774506229907274,
0.08115138113498688,
-0.11703258752822876,
-0.6841714382171631,
-0.3764890432357788,
-0.01819959655404091,
-0.2864307463169098,
-0.5779626369476318,
0.4776560366153717,
-0.5130309462547302,
0.014852702617645264,
-0.25340601801872253,
0.18829874694347382,
0.08347763866186142,
0.4746841788291931,
-0.054876476526260376,
1.1243603229522705,
0.39668941497802734,
-0.23402903974056244,
0.15747599303722382,
0.5035141110420227,
-0.1241062730550766,
0.45984816551208496,
-0.8092588782310486,
0.2639724612236023,
-0.04054814949631691,
0.3773866593837738,
-1.5267748832702637,
-0.3012254238128662,
0.26215416193008423,
-0.48637303709983826,
0.1676112860441208,
0.161462664604187,
-0.8646491169929504,
-0.05965445563197136,
-0.6199359893798828,
0.44202953577041626,
0.049520283937454224,
-0.17959482967853546,
1.0688823461532593,
0.414936363697052,
-0.12053685635328293,
-0.20779618620872498,
-0.5758966207504272,
0.55326908826828,
-0.15302003920078278,
-1.104719877243042,
-0.024571040645241737,
-0.4666806757450104,
-0.16524671018123627,
-0.39168861508369446,
0.1429339349269867,
0.06613362580537796,
0.2289021760225296,
0.42289847135543823,
0.5690668225288391,
-0.0018929599318653345,
0.3420603573322296,
-0.20225051045417786,
-0.046380747109651566,
-0.14990855753421783,
0.6646077632904053,
0.972705066204071,
-0.19962219893932343,
-0.6731873750686646,
-1.4449900388717651,
0.5170329213142395,
0.9597101807594299,
-0.25697553157806396,
0.8150913715362549,
0.8484068512916565,
0.042655494064092636,
0.9584144949913025,
-0.6864749789237976,
-0.6045665144920349,
-0.523699164390564,
0.37038934230804443,
-0.35418280959129333,
-0.8722931146621704,
0.34560486674308777,
-0.0316351093351841,
0.251503586769104,
0.05634661018848419,
0.6244186758995056,
-0.5467944741249084,
1.472609043121338,
0.5177962183952332,
-0.044640202075242996,
0.9632435441017151,
0.25431475043296814,
0.4436775743961334,
-0.9035553336143494,
-0.6033636331558228,
-0.18828967213630676,
-0.551459550857544,
-0.33864936232566833,
-0.4668556749820709,
0.5566728711128235,
-0.10761602967977524,
0.11274895071983337,
0.10049433261156082,
-0.11642393469810486,
0.13149362802505493,
0.46050789952278137,
0.19216212630271912,
0.3317968249320984,
-0.16101206839084625,
0.4993644952774048,
-0.32830187678337097,
-0.44707465171813965,
-0.40663695335388184,
0.8526359796524048,
0.3832227885723114,
0.9606809020042419,
0.4739474654197693,
0.2978281080722809,
0.5143495202064514,
0.01050657406449318,
-1.0474188327789307,
0.42939314246177673,
0.6499395966529846,
-0.5509893894195557,
-0.3525623679161072,
-0.2771111726760864,
-1.2994446754455566,
0.3001023232936859,
-0.5978809595108032,
-0.758062481880188,
-0.0869736596941948,
-0.08325081318616867,
-0.11810468137264252,
-0.07132355868816376,
-0.7208667993545532,
0.7623792290687561,
-0.6606957912445068,
-0.18801724910736084,
-0.6303041577339172,
-0.6578143835067749,
0.21161986887454987,
-0.009654002264142036,
0.4132671356201172,
-0.059511180967092514,
-0.21555344760417938,
0.47710537910461426,
-0.09664037823677063,
1.0820577144622803,
0.19046863913536072,
-0.16820049285888672,
0.17778797447681427,
0.11874640733003616,
0.3142407536506653,
0.15841330587863922,
0.3281004726886749,
0.2855669856071472,
-0.15798138082027435,
-0.1891864538192749,
-0.5054782629013062,
0.4951081871986389,
-0.9725913405418396,
-0.6624422669410706,
-0.3280191719532013,
-0.9715807437896729,
-0.1076100617647171,
0.137163445353508,
-0.4308459460735321,
0.5796121954917908,
-0.16754354536533356,
0.4220907390117645,
0.40969032049179077,
-0.10801668465137482,
0.7574325799942017,
0.09919751435518265,
-0.03194407746195793,
-0.3797087073326111,
0.6987595558166504,
-0.3475772738456726,
0.40250879526138306,
0.22123460471630096,
0.23128780722618103,
-0.26507413387298584,
-0.08623486012220383,
-0.6076012253761292,
0.2762055993080139,
-0.41236093640327454,
-0.08499351888895035,
-0.944527268409729,
0.1256524622440338,
-0.3364729583263397,
-0.17489799857139587,
-0.2770560681819916,
-0.25393229722976685,
-0.5637768507003784,
0.3270120620727539,
0.25622043013572693,
0.6682431101799011,
-0.07033270597457886,
0.5714460015296936,
-1.0293139219284058,
0.19627486169338226,
0.3224736750125885,
-0.024819020181894302,
0.11543560028076172,
-0.07330227643251419,
-0.12889918684959412,
0.12884236872196198,
-0.4645485281944275,
-1.0702000856399536,
-0.01144587341696024,
0.3904140293598175,
0.739391565322876,
0.6446244120597839,
-0.31667202711105347,
0.6038058400154114,
-0.1273162066936493,
0.9813934564590454,
0.6078736186027527,
-0.8922516703605652,
0.43085765838623047,
-0.5567933320999146,
0.4968350827693939,
0.38181623816490173,
0.13379666209220886,
-0.9694847464561462,
-0.12134478986263275,
-0.3394550085067749,
-0.7827152609825134,
0.7646591663360596,
0.1370445191860199,
0.6941172480583191,
-0.0008374699973501265,
-0.09380365908145905,
-0.0863129124045372,
0.3713453710079193,
-0.7987701296806335,
-0.3408447802066803,
-0.016680289059877396,
-0.05443375185132027,
0.14349666237831116,
-0.265421599149704,
-0.39271271228790283,
-0.01697407476603985,
0.10313227772712708,
-0.08689107745885849,
0.3414074778556824,
-0.2610809803009033,
-0.07426205277442932,
-0.03500699996948242,
0.18183469772338867,
0.841733455657959,
0.4855107367038727,
0.18880721926689148,
-0.0888717770576477,
-0.4020388424396515,
-0.2856391668319702,
-0.24480728805065155,
-0.029116854071617126,
0.36695581674575806,
-0.14226597547531128,
0.27117621898651123,
0.6289912462234497,
0.23290877044200897,
-0.9526873230934143,
0.601537823677063,
-0.40694659948349,
0.2401912808418274,
0.011927587911486626,
-0.014487039297819138,
0.25126752257347107,
0.48379868268966675,
0.3997255861759186,
0.45638179779052734,
0.02276473492383957,
-0.8906689286231995,
0.01709495484828949,
0.805547833442688,
-0.49912357330322266,
-0.295749306678772,
0.5090293884277344,
0.5650687217712402,
-0.6859264373779297,
0.5500237941741943,
0.46879395842552185,
-0.4974614977836609,
0.2278500199317932,
0.37161311507225037,
0.4697045385837555,
-0.014104879461228848,
0.19414862990379333,
0.003716421313583851,
0.21227140724658966,
0.5407577753067017,
0.1469913274049759,
-0.5845317840576172,
-0.6630794405937195,
-0.3702041804790497,
0.18681523203849792,
-0.5866422057151794,
-0.06682100147008896,
-0.2752574682235718,
0.20105041563510895,
-0.17299781739711761,
-0.48146989941596985,
0.05652487650513649,
-0.27328214049339294,
-0.8346576690673828,
-0.2762414813041687,
0.3309164047241211,
0.24621251225471497,
-0.551176905632019,
0.3126680254936218,
0.688747227191925,
-0.6770182847976685,
-0.21301287412643433,
0.1050114631652832,
0.373449444770813,
-0.5871513485908508,
0.3933679163455963,
0.37776732444763184,
-0.3941703736782074,
-0.4187709093093872,
-0.3748134970664978,
-0.6437774896621704,
0.9078656435012817,
0.17958754301071167,
-0.20958425104618073,
0.3554421663284302,
0.3996933102607727,
0.5655853748321533,
-0.17757397890090942,
0.8901100754737854,
0.1894923448562622,
0.5821790099143982,
0.11136691272258759,
-1.0826841592788696,
-0.21571098268032074,
-0.35864391922950745,
-0.0377032570540905,
0.18340948224067688,
-0.9420415759086609,
0.4231317639350891,
-0.06480704247951508,
-0.5590049624443054,
-0.12177690863609314,
0.8040159940719604,
0.0935266837477684,
0.3003634214401245,
0.6753876209259033,
-0.005446555092930794,
0.5794526934623718,
0.07391685247421265,
1.0584644079208374,
-0.4168664515018463,
-0.10730759799480438,
0.6970966458320618,
-0.058246318250894547,
0.7990284562110901,
0.7796797752380371,
0.05214180052280426,
0.3885127902030945,
0.48242470622062683,
0.30718299746513367,
0.1884712278842926,
-0.22923143208026886,
-0.4611997902393341,
-0.5515038371086121,
-0.4523833394050598,
-0.3140936493873596,
0.8186174631118774,
0.37660834193229675,
-0.008190618827939034,
0.05871036648750305,
0.26535627245903015,
0.32778140902519226,
0.04156748205423355,
0.26154062151908875,
0.934094250202179,
-0.3227716386318207,
-0.4691345691680908,
0.18034735321998596,
-0.30654484033584595,
0.9080249667167664,
-0.3724304437637329,
-0.10818815231323242,
0.08136902749538422,
-0.19798453152179718,
-0.18231818079948425,
-0.9190586805343628,
-0.1651933789253235,
-0.19978919625282288,
-0.1519060730934143,
-0.2424425184726715,
0.6918059587478638,
-0.37088850140571594,
-0.2348611056804657,
0.23227764666080475,
0.9960712790489197,
0.16044999659061432,
-0.048814449459314346,
-0.7324608564376831,
0.6554327607154846,
-0.037715036422014236,
-0.4853167235851288,
0.2946012318134308,
0.17343583703041077,
0.18615810573101044,
0.6484516859054565,
0.9745035767555237,
-0.7103689908981323,
-0.1313840001821518,
0.1827288269996643,
0.9828029274940491,
-0.4340071380138397,
-0.16410094499588013,
-0.8773134350776672,
0.7806214690208435,
-0.057997558265924454,
-0.3139115571975708,
0.6192314028739929,
0.578116238117218,
0.4593215882778168,
0.23546487092971802,
0.8377609848976135,
-0.24003857374191284,
-0.08576605468988419,
-0.14118145406246185,
0.41858044266700745,
-0.6993033289909363,
0.24502034485340118,
-0.30129966139793396,
-0.5632773041725159,
-0.09794164448976517,
0.543897807598114,
-0.07215701043605804,
0.2184559851884842,
0.3954167664051056,
0.5267064571380615,
-0.06775090098381042,
0.17361289262771606,
0.6537162065505981,
-0.1868487447500229,
0.7437509298324585,
0.1976030468940735,
1.3378338813781738,
-0.22404904663562775,
0.7060455679893494,
-0.13084259629249573,
-0.3218424916267395,
-0.2662462294101715,
-0.6020641326904297,
-1.1230475902557373,
-0.8207222819328308,
-0.07390286773443222,
-0.09899714589118958,
-0.20460133254528046,
0.9377279877662659,
0.6745445728302002,
-0.2134026736021042,
-0.25610610842704773,
0.4409116804599762,
-0.07656535506248474,
0.161047101020813,
-0.26213639974594116,
0.0026651951484382153,
-0.5086076855659485,
-1.149257779121399,
0.6844274997711182,
0.6030063033103943,
0.0823630839586258,
-0.3752772808074951,
-0.1463104486465454,
-0.41021788120269775,
0.3369821608066559,
0.863493800163269,
0.20523439347743988,
-0.8153890371322632,
-0.4722827076911926,
0.20691929757595062,
-0.3617394268512726,
0.5089103579521179,
0.9169591069221497,
-0.6560583710670471,
0.6004599332809448,
0.5605539083480835,
0.6714553236961365,
0.4723367989063263,
0.1258811503648758,
0.7341190576553345,
-0.31907549500465393,
0.2012648582458496,
0.11826945096254349,
0.08680571615695953,
0.25423890352249146,
-0.4474903643131256,
0.23918311297893524,
0.06580021232366562,
-0.5861636996269226,
-0.683866560459137,
0.25637826323509216,
-1.2772969007492065,
-0.1276576668024063,
1.177091121673584,
0.1627039909362793,
0.255929559469223,
-0.19262485206127167,
-0.6795018911361694,
0.0778178870677948,
-0.8603979349136353,
0.745991051197052,
0.7333139181137085,
-0.6265596747398376,
-0.40314725041389465,
-0.5686420798301697,
0.17867553234100342,
0.6984706521034241,
-0.930155336856842,
-0.07371512055397034,
0.9404155015945435,
-0.3784579634666443,
0.38953498005867004,
0.5376036167144775,
-0.023493709042668343,
0.26109766960144043,
-0.19004759192466736,
-0.030225083231925964,
-0.14111995697021484,
-0.41654202342033386,
-0.16898730397224426,
0.020334940403699875,
-0.14388494193553925,
-0.1810368150472641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14993v1 | Disability Representations: Finding Biases in Automatic Image Generation | 2024-06-21T09:12:31 | 2024-06-21T09:12:31 | Yannis Tevissen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in image generation technology have enabled widespread
access to AI-generated imagery, prominently used in advertising, entertainment,
and progressively in every form of visual content. However, these technologies
often perpetuate societal biases. This study investigates the representation
biases in popular image generation models towards people with disabilities
(PWD). Through a comprehensive experiment involving several popular
text-to-image models, we analyzed the depiction of disability. The results
indicate a significant bias, with most generated images portraying disabled
individuals as old, sad, and predominantly using manual wheelchairs. These
findings highlight the urgent need for more inclusive AI development, ensuring
diverse and accurate representation of PWD in generated images. This research
underscores the importance of addressing and mitigating biases in AI models to
foster equitable and realistic representations. | [
-0.704774796962738,
-0.18514585494995117,
0.45051687955856323,
0.19349561631679535,
-0.21862755715847015,
-0.278829425573349,
0.31578871607780457,
-0.7218244671821594,
0.4237687289714813,
0.31945544481277466,
-0.4736781120300293,
-0.09243383258581161,
-0.9235866069793701,
0.33875468373298645,
-0.15056496858596802,
0.5594135522842407,
-0.09689886122941971,
0.30371859669685364,
-0.24087876081466675,
-0.4346874952316284,
-0.908034086227417,
-0.39627447724342346,
-0.4314844310283661,
-0.3179326057434082,
0.19523443281650543,
0.006355705671012402,
1.188279151916504,
0.5403057932853699,
0.20624341070652008,
0.2614120543003082,
0.28073906898498535,
0.039020512253046036,
-0.1623355895280838,
0.2613926827907562,
-0.04785916581749916,
-0.17967957258224487,
-0.24599196016788483,
0.18863485753536224,
0.4941492974758148,
0.7062520980834961,
0.4342247247695923,
-0.0032863772939890623,
-0.04384581744670868,
0.6524905562400818,
-0.7130188941955566,
-0.006213699001818895,
-0.4002886116504669,
0.5857957601547241,
-0.3931041955947876,
0.22083836793899536,
-0.3547552525997162,
-0.37600433826446533,
-0.16595733165740967,
-0.6640243530273438,
0.4422121047973633,
0.03051633946597576,
0.7842821478843689,
0.4349725544452667,
-0.7063354849815369,
-0.5917011499404907,
-0.67880779504776,
0.5580077767372131,
-0.27383166551589966,
0.42914268374443054,
0.4050874710083008,
0.3962511718273163,
-0.0488351434469223,
-0.3275657296180725,
-0.6118283271789551,
-0.4433717429637909,
-0.050585247576236725,
-0.20788294076919556,
-0.1111714094877243,
-0.0024677955079823732,
0.39614489674568176,
0.03406624495983124,
-0.2902938723564148,
0.5028658509254456,
-0.38721761107444763,
-0.3176009953022003,
0.9450388550758362,
0.07354820519685745,
0.7528501749038696,
-0.41585320234298706,
-0.07605887204408646,
-0.039713092148303986,
-0.7050451040267944,
-0.3442852199077606,
0.46610546112060547,
-0.2927846312522888,
0.010391440242528915,
1.0838303565979004,
0.07041861861944199,
0.6394676566123962,
0.25610825419425964,
0.3362090289592743,
0.36274224519729614,
0.010219705291092396,
-0.02740011364221573,
0.11828463524580002,
0.402193546295166,
0.8727371096611023,
0.3586418926715851,
-0.13164927065372467,
-0.4215751588344574,
0.053754497319459915,
0.22215919196605682,
-0.373341828584671,
0.0012345761060714722,
-0.11687345802783966,
-0.7338535785675049,
-0.06813043355941772,
0.16483992338180542,
-0.975508451461792,
-1.3403918743133545,
-0.1351694017648697,
0.2156049609184265,
-0.19074197113513947,
-0.3161805272102356,
-0.16221970319747925,
-0.6081166863441467,
0.260043203830719,
0.3901859521865845,
-0.7004835605621338,
-0.19097217917442322,
-0.015621897764503956,
0.5566393136978149,
-0.0008406422566622496,
0.10882949829101562,
-0.419185608625412,
0.3220868408679962,
-0.4700762629508972,
0.8173185586929321,
-0.29552677273750305,
-0.5193267464637756,
-0.07484257221221924,
0.17176735401153564,
0.4691985845565796,
-0.5630595684051514,
0.38744306564331055,
-0.38796427845954895,
0.18248146772384644,
-0.3560754954814911,
-0.010866117663681507,
0.17579227685928345,
-0.15348969399929047,
-1.2446739673614502,
0.4044381082057953,
0.3392406702041626,
-0.8292999267578125,
1.0870331525802612,
-0.7029754519462585,
-0.37694108486175537,
-0.07081348448991776,
-0.6882086396217346,
-0.7454267740249634,
0.4520997703075409,
0.4234998822212219,
0.1747254729270935,
-0.23089376091957092,
0.14876475930213928,
-0.4166421592235565,
-0.2957812249660492,
0.08959195762872696,
-0.6108213067054749,
0.8384028077125549,
0.2986290752887726,
-0.7397043108940125,
-0.04177397862076759,
-0.28720131516456604,
-0.5930482745170593,
0.42246007919311523,
-0.1254400610923767,
-0.435555636882782,
0.09506335109472275,
0.11842742562294006,
0.3295460045337677,
0.03926064074039459,
-0.6171833276748657,
-0.07690808176994324,
-0.13721142709255219,
0.2339843213558197,
1.001129388809204,
-0.12391383200883865,
0.645890474319458,
-0.4278760254383087,
0.5525197386741638,
0.3134446442127228,
0.25480467081069946,
-0.10685520619153976,
-0.804172158241272,
-0.41924849152565,
-0.09399836510419846,
0.14256061613559723,
0.12061682343482971,
-0.8375303149223328,
0.22550882399082184,
-0.08545616269111633,
0.0008419596124440432,
-0.66164630651474,
-0.045671239495277405,
0.11531870067119598,
0.27500078082084656,
0.155851811170578,
-0.6730446815490723,
-0.2790743112564087,
-1.3062608242034912,
-0.43322718143463135,
-0.1819341778755188,
-0.5087146162986755,
0.43497636914253235,
0.3621867001056671,
-0.34349676966667175,
0.9039058089256287,
-0.13490594923496246,
-0.45197561383247375,
0.15032319724559784,
0.31430456042289734,
-0.3843728005886078,
0.6709989905357361,
0.9000623226165771,
-1.1128510236740112,
-0.07912769913673401,
-0.3614538013935089,
-0.8690537810325623,
-0.13942451775074005,
-0.3774779438972473,
0.18073762953281403,
0.5792527794837952,
0.09662029892206192,
-0.659430205821991,
0.9347676634788513,
0.0817728340625763,
-0.623539388179779,
0.550853431224823,
-0.2720385789871216,
0.3710253834724426,
-0.557612955570221,
0.014238917268812656,
0.5215680599212646,
-0.1742185354232788,
0.11642730981111526,
-0.04040246084332466,
-0.06408525258302689,
-0.46782875061035156,
-0.19725842773914337,
0.43008384108543396,
-0.9827210903167725,
-0.42012646794319153,
-0.04217807948589325,
0.08500044047832489,
0.11939415335655212,
-0.3681783676147461,
0.059695933014154434,
0.6715667247772217,
0.7948465943336487,
-0.3206463158130646,
0.34859469532966614,
0.15811234712600708,
-0.11887684464454651,
0.7764950394630432,
-0.7309446334838867,
0.22399187088012695,
-0.7533615231513977,
0.38204774260520935,
-0.8512014150619507,
-0.6317927241325378,
0.46145686507225037,
-0.35705897212028503,
0.3769725561141968,
0.3468359708786011,
-0.4510079622268677,
-0.7719910144805908,
-0.430253803730011,
0.6129351854324341,
0.7669389843940735,
-0.3732960522174835,
0.5840903520584106,
0.926959216594696,
0.25190672278404236,
-0.4347846806049347,
-1.0193294286727905,
0.27138376235961914,
-0.4859949052333832,
-0.7860128879547119,
0.538748562335968,
0.3413136899471283,
-0.4988592267036438,
0.16156749427318573,
-0.01218224223703146,
-0.11456027626991272,
-0.2033894956111908,
0.28488844633102417,
0.09641546756029129,
-0.1393868774175644,
0.09585709124803543,
0.11771338433027267,
0.043677933514118195,
0.11803266406059265,
0.2072465419769287,
0.2669912576675415,
0.4293241798877716,
-0.8271138668060303,
-0.6691617369651794,
0.8888521194458008,
0.8167558312416077,
-0.05158930644392967,
0.5669585466384888,
0.24668435752391815,
-0.5413895845413208,
-0.06683679670095444,
-0.49561700224876404,
-0.11694768071174622,
-0.4878807067871094,
0.38322752714157104,
-0.0011259905295446515,
-0.3075796961784363,
0.5159852504730225,
-0.04493154585361481,
0.1090683862566948,
0.42905938625335693,
0.40867745876312256,
-0.0711633488535881,
1.8216679096221924,
0.5322620868682861,
0.0314236544072628,
0.523551344871521,
0.06583167612552643,
0.05665116012096405,
-0.6546030640602112,
-0.4874623119831085,
-0.5309919714927673,
-0.512107253074646,
-0.6628888845443726,
-0.3897137939929962,
0.3614911735057831,
-0.0703897774219513,
-0.3415498733520508,
-0.11643247306346893,
-1.0906922817230225,
0.2644749879837036,
0.5432124733924866,
0.5017093420028687,
-0.023638315498828888,
-0.007632262539118528,
0.11108741909265518,
-0.23149427771568298,
-0.36107349395751953,
-0.6426367163658142,
1.1368279457092285,
0.4628722071647644,
0.9110893607139587,
-0.07028177380561829,
0.5718624591827393,
0.9038957953453064,
0.6987655162811279,
-0.5466671586036682,
0.3360050320625305,
-0.23190546035766602,
-0.7482330799102783,
-0.08196652680635452,
-0.10174434632062912,
-1.0228832960128784,
-0.33549365401268005,
-0.1832250952720642,
-0.5252524018287659,
0.7826707363128662,
0.4542343318462372,
0.02427011914551258,
0.24431635439395905,
-0.8864660859107971,
0.5109312534332275,
-0.2777538001537323,
-0.23428936302661896,
-0.4546279013156891,
-0.6569333672523499,
0.4727228283882141,
-0.04473239555954933,
0.12174122780561447,
0.0972452387213707,
0.06776198744773865,
0.7327276468276978,
-0.3475351333618164,
0.8445243835449219,
-0.6370580792427063,
0.07536371052265167,
0.26587849855422974,
-0.13659723103046417,
0.3175204396247864,
-0.05564073473215103,
-0.34164974093437195,
-0.05990886315703392,
-0.518530011177063,
-0.6770637035369873,
-0.295258104801178,
0.5083934664726257,
-0.8777520656585693,
-0.9833387732505798,
-0.4276766777038574,
-0.45785143971443176,
-0.11852865666151047,
-0.03519802913069725,
0.1821001172065735,
0.2758406698703766,
-0.15676113963127136,
-0.19793257117271423,
0.4828835427761078,
-0.7810890078544617,
0.1672290563583374,
-0.19581875205039978,
-0.05807057395577431,
-0.12069212645292282,
0.5433794260025024,
0.49288317561149597,
0.0759262815117836,
-0.44884833693504333,
-0.25803232192993164,
-0.3061356246471405,
-0.4990360140800476,
-0.6830590963363647,
0.346892386674881,
-0.8713096380233765,
-0.03273216634988785,
-0.263618528842926,
0.07003366202116013,
-0.5595263242721558,
-0.24129819869995117,
0.04070354625582695,
-0.5457547307014465,
-0.5774676203727722,
-0.11693806946277618,
0.12331431359052658,
1.1320587396621704,
-0.15325003862380981,
0.18906597793102264,
-0.14064641296863556,
0.7028875946998596,
0.49628764390945435,
0.34681767225265503,
0.00953029002994299,
0.02832583710551262,
0.08855178207159042,
0.1113203763961792,
-0.8415563106536865,
-1.2316861152648926,
0.006588586140424013,
0.10461651533842087,
0.9287014603614807,
0.3293119966983795,
0.2363341897726059,
0.3825356364250183,
-0.35461950302124023,
1.148757815361023,
0.6561449766159058,
-0.7066892385482788,
0.696885347366333,
0.02471519075334072,
0.19728988409042358,
0.19097858667373657,
0.44998928904533386,
-0.3634755611419678,
-0.4728085696697235,
-0.5275413393974304,
-0.683100700378418,
0.4481927156448364,
-0.08406353741884232,
0.4904917776584625,
-0.11216182261705399,
0.16151787340641022,
0.31968027353286743,
-0.12737193703651428,
-0.9299900531768799,
-0.1998222917318344,
-0.761273205280304,
-0.21318215131759644,
0.6134302616119385,
-0.05485816299915314,
0.0342692993581295,
-0.15566213428974152,
0.30036643147468567,
-0.0520622581243515,
0.769146740436554,
0.4200909733772278,
-0.21921224892139435,
-0.29053375124931335,
-0.3124622106552124,
0.2639826238155365,
0.5776633024215698,
0.34817084670066833,
0.2028336077928543,
-0.22001424431800842,
-0.23178885877132416,
0.1992967128753662,
0.08790121227502823,
-0.35856717824935913,
0.4490688145160675,
0.05405167490243912,
0.9223830699920654,
-0.5329142212867737,
-0.7148938775062561,
0.5526406168937683,
-0.049987588077783585,
-0.050761427730321884,
-0.3247811496257782,
0.09729171544313431,
-0.12369115650653839,
0.06373286247253418,
0.6672556400299072,
0.5118620991706848,
0.1545223444700241,
-0.533569872379303,
0.30462825298309326,
0.7632928490638733,
-0.4271845519542694,
-0.3143622875213623,
1.2704341411590576,
0.4554765522480011,
-0.6511293649673462,
0.7573196887969971,
-0.17350947856903076,
-0.11272747069597244,
0.9113507866859436,
0.495310515165329,
0.8828046917915344,
-0.13031506538391113,
0.5551148056983948,
0.05019937828183174,
0.3798217475414276,
-0.04519902542233467,
-0.034123893827199936,
-0.002126753330230713,
-0.5164250731468201,
0.06660842150449753,
-0.24243417382240295,
0.11578712612390518,
-0.07706627249717712,
-0.2726902663707733,
0.5443298816680908,
-0.16977174580097198,
-0.6568689346313477,
0.11726201325654984,
-0.5414890646934509,
-0.8887748122215271,
0.3354422152042389,
0.4841323792934418,
0.7719714641571045,
-1.064496636390686,
0.5275689363479614,
0.8082046508789062,
-0.8436243534088135,
-0.42548733949661255,
0.5135154128074646,
-0.07734821736812592,
-0.8076425194740295,
0.8093529343605042,
0.2376248687505722,
0.11293797194957733,
-0.1928609311580658,
-0.6377618908882141,
-0.3710756003856659,
1.0156843662261963,
0.7423732876777649,
-0.1688225120306015,
-0.47997334599494934,
0.39602985978126526,
0.221576988697052,
-0.5383034944534302,
0.25986796617507935,
0.18799805641174316,
0.6249557733535767,
-0.26887744665145874,
-0.8648626804351807,
0.2652604579925537,
-0.22951005399227142,
0.5124599933624268,
-0.09906626492738724,
-0.4342246949672699,
0.611341118812561,
-0.22003863751888275,
-0.31107980012893677,
-0.052442267537117004,
0.5564798712730408,
0.6487800478935242,
0.6266760230064392,
0.7229592800140381,
0.13984447717666626,
0.6384753584861755,
0.10508513450622559,
1.1426544189453125,
0.11678575724363327,
-0.08905261009931564,
0.2732410430908203,
-0.2885894477367401,
-0.2339339405298233,
0.603324830532074,
0.18278351426124573,
0.31234896183013916,
0.5980087518692017,
-0.03621463477611542,
0.6500426530838013,
0.2703162133693695,
-0.3678785264492035,
0.06967361271381378,
-0.32382118701934814,
-0.4552990794181824,
0.027479887008666992,
0.3366248309612274,
-1.0405679941177368,
-0.3419298231601715,
0.4832165539264679,
-0.24513664841651917,
0.3213618993759155,
-0.3432104289531708,
0.45667707920074463,
-0.01516546681523323,
-0.5369863510131836,
0.45534467697143555,
-0.032569434493780136,
0.8650096654891968,
-0.1340167075395584,
-0.27328550815582275,
-0.10797291249036789,
-0.2335241436958313,
-0.13703110814094543,
-0.8742387890815735,
0.5543790459632874,
0.018687084317207336,
-0.10338661819696426,
-0.3480968773365021,
1.0793970823287964,
0.19231773912906647,
-0.5737617015838623,
0.14741919934749603,
0.2847554087638855,
0.17912769317626953,
0.29259347915649414,
-0.7048041820526123,
0.10628936439752579,
0.04525020346045494,
-0.21254906058311462,
0.25473546981811523,
0.5868006348609924,
-0.6057825684547424,
0.48175784945487976,
-0.15023955702781677,
0.19519805908203125,
0.22981558740139008,
-0.04578038677573204,
0.7927913069725037,
-0.3735041320323944,
-0.28951144218444824,
-0.49400871992111206,
0.6723737120628357,
-0.48454904556274414,
-0.4214610159397125,
0.5842136740684509,
0.2904566824436188,
0.3802410364151001,
-0.2951706349849701,
1.0208896398544312,
-0.4470507800579071,
-0.23381510376930237,
-0.18896421790122986,
0.9951250553131104,
-0.547221839427948,
-0.07158798724412918,
-0.30864766240119934,
-0.5477375388145447,
-0.2967424690723419,
0.7000919580459595,
-0.5165164470672607,
0.4265784025192261,
0.1393222063779831,
0.7831941246986389,
-0.16733531653881073,
0.026152266189455986,
0.004908664617687464,
-0.13737386465072632,
0.40102627873420715,
0.2378251552581787,
0.8642284274101257,
-0.17083650827407837,
0.040888190269470215,
0.05619572103023529,
-0.6107567548751831,
-0.11367524415254593,
-0.8459665179252625,
-0.44945964217185974,
-0.5708608031272888,
-0.5291135907173157,
-0.39985617995262146,
0.20222164690494537,
0.733808159828186,
0.7538048028945923,
-0.5504356026649475,
0.04950716346502304,
-0.279357373714447,
0.33464905619621277,
-0.022806264460086823,
-0.23126588761806488,
0.22202123701572418,
-0.0026742098852992058,
-0.695888876914978,
-0.3860737681388855,
-0.09570522606372833,
0.1211821585893631,
-0.8490589261054993,
-0.2519850730895996,
0.328745573759079,
-0.046072110533714294,
0.33144572377204895,
0.11273965239524841,
-0.5473890900611877,
-0.42957621812820435,
-0.28908759355545044,
-0.08031013607978821,
0.37885627150535583,
0.7661647796630859,
-1.1402007341384888,
0.39201709628105164,
0.5688146948814392,
0.3709382712841034,
0.23030433058738708,
0.026017529889941216,
0.8911854028701782,
-0.6141782402992249,
0.25803250074386597,
0.505012035369873,
0.2828061878681183,
0.635090172290802,
-0.6229710578918457,
0.07801184058189392,
0.453692227602005,
-0.5651232004165649,
-1.0391662120819092,
0.38919928669929504,
-0.3508373498916626,
-0.5457513928413391,
0.7149785757064819,
0.1318255066871643,
-0.27782851457595825,
-0.34227296710014343,
-0.4648793041706085,
0.48423701524734497,
-0.3192152976989746,
1.2994784116744995,
0.3537624478340149,
-0.29311078786849976,
-0.16452869772911072,
-0.6625099778175354,
0.45882371068000793,
0.24383145570755005,
-0.5686343312263489,
0.02930905856192112,
1.0281227827072144,
0.16973960399627686,
0.25401780009269714,
0.6830183267593384,
-0.29704034328460693,
0.3586231470108032,
-0.08057612180709839,
0.021082984283566475,
0.14542005956172943,
0.05269921198487282,
-0.1508702039718628,
0.25514400005340576,
0.1972932368516922,
-0.18161793053150177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14991v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14991v1 | SpreadsheetBench: Towards Challenging Real World Spreadsheet Manipulation | 2024-06-21T09:06:45 | 2024-06-21T09:06:45 | Zeyao Ma, Bohan Zhang, Jing Zhang, Jifan Yu, Xiaokang Zhang, Xiaohan Zhang, Sijia Luo, Xi Wang, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We introduce SpreadsheetBench, a challenging spreadsheet manipulation
benchmark exclusively derived from real-world scenarios, designed to immerse
current large language models (LLMs) in the actual workflow of spreadsheet
users. Unlike existing benchmarks that rely on synthesized queries and
simplified spreadsheet files, SpreadsheetBench is built from 912 real questions
gathered from online Excel forums, which reflect the intricate needs of users.
The associated spreadsheets from the forums contain a variety of tabular data
such as multiple tables, non-standard relational tables, and abundant
non-textual elements. Furthermore, we propose a more reliable evaluation metric
akin to online judge platforms, where multiple spreadsheet files are created as
test cases for each instruction, ensuring the evaluation of robust solutions
capable of handling spreadsheets with varying values. Our comprehensive
evaluation of various LLMs under both single-round and multi-round inference
settings reveals a substantial gap between the state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
and human performance, highlighting the benchmark's difficulty. | [
-0.16081692278385162,
-1.162064790725708,
0.42400825023651123,
0.25871390104293823,
0.20600062608718872,
0.4156999886035919,
-0.4663216769695282,
-0.7006081938743591,
-0.1764807254076004,
0.6226524114608765,
-0.8485611081123352,
-0.5861504077911377,
-0.3820858299732208,
0.11377400159835815,
-0.6346582770347595,
0.786156177520752,
-0.36076873540878296,
0.13557717204093933,
-0.41326984763145447,
-0.08330751955509186,
-0.3375777006149292,
-0.3755188584327698,
0.025189658626914024,
-0.08132853358983994,
0.31045472621917725,
0.7923817038536072,
0.48573586344718933,
0.2797110080718994,
0.5966599583625793,
0.2403131127357483,
0.04145141690969467,
-0.06855030357837677,
-0.6231563091278076,
0.495358407497406,
-0.05203261971473694,
-0.5931177735328674,
-0.42609959840774536,
0.20732541382312775,
0.34105223417282104,
0.7176678776741028,
-0.5909592509269714,
0.3041466772556305,
-0.21387504041194916,
0.7606777548789978,
-0.7213274240493774,
0.049238547682762146,
-0.4968494176864624,
0.2640930414199829,
-0.4674605131149292,
0.47046804428100586,
-0.3395671546459198,
-0.788439154624939,
-0.11233292520046234,
-0.7205235362052917,
0.06412345170974731,
0.1007242351770401,
0.7613502740859985,
0.1307467222213745,
-0.3398577570915222,
-0.2752528786659241,
-0.7010317444801331,
0.4451920986175537,
-0.5856066346168518,
0.5715351700782776,
0.3611842691898346,
0.9937208890914917,
-0.34384629130363464,
-0.8906568288803101,
-0.671710193157196,
-0.5510901212692261,
0.19695408642292023,
0.1436132788658142,
-0.1760585606098175,
-0.23992614448070526,
0.5833430886268616,
0.09670388698577881,
-0.5421383380889893,
0.16189029812812805,
-0.4961152970790863,
-0.1409912258386612,
0.38126882910728455,
0.34929999709129333,
0.2990170419216156,
0.10133601725101471,
-0.28160467743873596,
-0.2970547080039978,
-0.8474351167678833,
0.12099115550518036,
0.5169224143028259,
0.16355353593826294,
-0.04462654888629913,
0.508305013179779,
-0.2113879770040512,
0.6403497457504272,
-0.14540287852287292,
0.14287203550338745,
-0.05249250680208206,
-0.204883873462677,
-0.1745767593383789,
-0.0667402371764183,
0.5617039203643799,
0.31762608885765076,
0.14361810684204102,
-0.4597789943218231,
0.0346919484436512,
0.07677116990089417,
0.5015846490859985,
-0.8067017197608948,
-0.019414357841014862,
0.10165762156248093,
0.07085400819778442,
-0.3522487282752991,
0.1678227037191391,
-0.9469352960586548,
-0.4027000069618225,
-0.3706248104572296,
0.17816415429115295,
-0.40104421973228455,
0.05636043846607208,
-0.4001084566116333,
0.2737583518028259,
0.130192831158638,
0.4821167588233948,
-0.5971718430519104,
0.726820170879364,
0.8920048475265503,
0.5006445646286011,
-0.1310952752828598,
-0.517699658870697,
-0.953737199306488,
-0.011241935193538666,
-0.35630911588668823,
1.1405171155929565,
-0.7333248853683472,
-0.51560378074646,
-0.1452358365058899,
-0.14962588250637054,
0.03455578535795212,
-0.735393762588501,
0.7061250805854797,
-0.6644716262817383,
0.03444048762321472,
-0.6215292811393738,
-0.7160276770591736,
0.09161379188299179,
0.4942235052585602,
-0.932828426361084,
1.1383451223373413,
0.4466470181941986,
-0.3628235459327698,
0.521565854549408,
-0.8436613082885742,
-0.15162862837314606,
0.07712387293577194,
-0.20251189172267914,
-0.390863299369812,
-0.2701564431190491,
-0.2091304361820221,
0.13774926960468292,
-0.5143935084342957,
0.05721183493733406,
-0.5157282948493958,
-0.30005964636802673,
0.2318066954612732,
-0.10209290683269501,
0.36100098490715027,
0.2289956659078598,
-0.2205575555562973,
0.26285257935523987,
-0.6464020609855652,
0.1325228363275528,
-0.15264716744422913,
-0.2979481816291809,
0.1304028183221817,
-0.24586306512355804,
0.4526049494743347,
0.45041555166244507,
-0.028544854372739792,
-0.717059314250946,
0.410245418548584,
-0.1307922899723053,
0.2589678466320038,
0.6233503818511963,
-0.38112926483154297,
0.2607365548610687,
-0.10267002880573273,
0.8446730375289917,
-0.18148991465568542,
-0.02521349862217903,
0.3836938738822937,
-0.06926706433296204,
-0.037130724638700485,
-0.06409250944852829,
0.7260205745697021,
0.6814092397689819,
-0.36971142888069153,
0.04215467348694801,
-0.4204097092151642,
-0.7624509930610657,
-0.3042691946029663,
0.544657826423645,
0.5952892899513245,
0.6736655235290527,
0.16003285348415375,
-0.12526997923851013,
-0.29324331879615784,
-0.9424461126327515,
-0.7356311082839966,
0.307547390460968,
-0.05820822715759277,
0.17673394083976746,
0.4419762194156647,
-0.12308376282453537,
1.0017138719558716,
-0.4584188759326935,
-0.18877902626991272,
-0.3837755024433136,
0.4539310336112976,
0.009899981319904327,
0.1415514200925827,
0.4973786771297455,
-0.7503857016563416,
-0.932812511920929,
-0.04093065485358238,
-0.603270947933197,
-0.3158598244190216,
-0.05953212082386017,
-0.19655172526836395,
0.43535128235816956,
0.6525508165359497,
-0.53324294090271,
0.7303203344345093,
0.324257493019104,
-0.26926395297050476,
0.9124918580055237,
-0.14562885463237762,
0.1335621327161789,
-0.6977217197418213,
0.12645544111728668,
0.007743871305137873,
-0.44310644268989563,
-0.5423124432563782,
0.3234212100505829,
0.7194042205810547,
-0.10080194473266602,
-0.5666881799697876,
0.44890278577804565,
-0.43103209137916565,
-0.29896852374076843,
0.059402141720056534,
0.23853954672813416,
-0.15945476293563843,
0.22085116803646088,
-0.45133310556411743,
1.0459365844726562,
0.16201330721378326,
-0.14780670404434204,
0.6586182713508606,
0.4279795289039612,
-0.6588395237922668,
0.9443576335906982,
-0.3089153468608856,
0.1928056925535202,
0.2606237232685089,
0.6068681478500366,
-0.7167021036148071,
-0.38585129380226135,
-0.15289221704006195,
-0.010642037726938725,
0.419592022895813,
0.006645343266427517,
-0.6412842869758606,
-0.48095664381980896,
-0.399919331073761,
0.05572224035859108,
0.4066777229309082,
-0.4917224645614624,
0.4977380037307739,
0.23653088510036469,
-0.17158876359462738,
-0.5648902654647827,
-0.600737988948822,
0.5859993100166321,
-0.09160146862268448,
-0.6828357577323914,
0.505652129650116,
-0.16041572391986847,
-0.49910467863082886,
0.03972267359495163,
-0.4180479943752289,
-0.05108208209276199,
0.09022236615419388,
0.39111629128456116,
-0.008603144437074661,
0.05676352232694626,
-0.17486067116260529,
-0.0394948273897171,
-0.13497759401798248,
-0.0299362950026989,
0.2041795700788498,
0.3855891525745392,
-0.26070037484169006,
-0.580950915813446,
-0.14721278846263885,
0.42460885643959045,
0.542742133140564,
-0.04238484799861908,
0.5278655886650085,
0.3893691897392273,
-0.46610844135284424,
-0.27899765968322754,
-0.7299396991729736,
0.11042831093072891,
-0.4543723165988922,
0.4264153242111206,
-0.715413510799408,
-0.544625997543335,
0.7369368076324463,
-0.2652605175971985,
0.2097022533416748,
0.20686538517475128,
0.7631238102912903,
-0.03617345169186592,
0.4747714400291443,
0.3677588403224945,
0.1328711211681366,
0.2900247871875763,
-0.1175110936164856,
0.12584108114242554,
-0.6334494948387146,
-0.16612641513347626,
-0.6013495922088623,
-0.4166920781135559,
-0.3254784643650055,
-0.44497716426849365,
0.444982647895813,
-0.018659908324480057,
-0.005372331477701664,
0.6461701989173889,
-0.07137613743543625,
0.7507825493812561,
0.5057573914527893,
0.15678256750106812,
0.0836181789636612,
-0.2687700092792511,
-0.38713380694389343,
-0.08380018174648285,
-0.3392862379550934,
-0.6343672871589661,
1.1736925840377808,
-0.15092355012893677,
0.8091059327125549,
0.22695273160934448,
0.6288483738899231,
0.3291879892349243,
0.768715500831604,
-0.4638359546661377,
0.5619034171104431,
-0.027638331055641174,
-0.6135826110839844,
-0.3326013386249542,
-0.5644562840461731,
-1.0168280601501465,
0.12820108234882355,
-0.10067383944988251,
-1.0255836248397827,
-0.3720395565032959,
0.06240544468164444,
-0.39549094438552856,
0.43626758456230164,
-0.9167833924293518,
1.288116455078125,
-0.28417208790779114,
-1.0595953464508057,
-0.19075672328472137,
-0.6778363585472107,
0.3033132255077362,
-0.15231813490390778,
0.638627290725708,
-0.13366162776947021,
0.17471644282341003,
0.5168334245681763,
-0.7595125436782837,
0.5678676962852478,
-0.22102698683738708,
-0.2095012068748474,
0.14810287952423096,
0.6955239772796631,
0.5029177665710449,
-0.17303210496902466,
-0.3606545329093933,
-0.11295311897993088,
0.40787363052368164,
-0.5464559197425842,
-0.5671060085296631,
1.0661720037460327,
-0.5386548042297363,
-0.44730937480926514,
-0.2731715142726898,
-0.6493186354637146,
-0.618527889251709,
0.18481950461864471,
-0.14400674402713776,
0.48403218388557434,
-0.6574788689613342,
0.12839427590370178,
-0.08549442887306213,
0.05083908885717392,
0.20668110251426697,
0.4562786817550659,
-0.15056771039962769,
-0.1446443796157837,
0.6373094916343689,
0.2864851653575897,
0.21633657813072205,
0.34896016120910645,
0.21364183723926544,
-0.535048246383667,
-0.4007122814655304,
-0.7378138899803162,
-0.24439704418182373,
-0.8359026312828064,
-0.21663717925548553,
-0.46817347407341003,
0.28856778144836426,
-0.36038774251937866,
-0.09140045940876007,
-0.2351401001214981,
-0.6588860154151917,
0.017128044739365578,
-0.3377205729484558,
0.37639951705932617,
0.7381315231323242,
-0.12332978844642639,
0.002384660765528679,
-0.988405704498291,
0.5400094985961914,
0.5291169881820679,
0.7349479794502258,
-0.23197048902511597,
-0.335345983505249,
-0.18422260880470276,
-0.10821182280778885,
-0.6148069500923157,
-1.0901027917861938,
0.37729886174201965,
0.06763365119695663,
0.5855937600135803,
0.03391260653734207,
-0.06283539533615112,
0.845547616481781,
-0.5105457305908203,
0.5097607970237732,
-0.1589980125427246,
-0.8876056671142578,
0.1577470451593399,
-0.348007470369339,
0.05957901105284691,
0.9708098769187927,
0.1322515457868576,
-0.6675699353218079,
-0.3607407808303833,
-0.5164211392402649,
-0.8952270746231079,
0.9920993447303772,
0.3510074317455292,
-0.16053719818592072,
0.5068552494049072,
0.48892879486083984,
0.47565221786499023,
0.151163250207901,
-0.4990789294242859,
0.13747423887252808,
-0.058366063982248306,
-0.31294509768486023,
0.2446180135011673,
0.07715907692909241,
-0.0791168063879013,
-0.15545488893985748,
0.4153209328651428,
0.03332054615020752,
-0.2206958532333374,
-0.04869350045919418,
-0.5504692792892456,
-0.3922998309135437,
0.4348032474517822,
0.6253487467765808,
0.9666641354560852,
-0.5768634080886841,
0.06158800423145294,
0.41369426250457764,
-0.4858926832675934,
0.018873903900384903,
0.23417650163173676,
0.1819337010383606,
-0.4076765775680542,
0.18668289482593536,
0.418724000453949,
0.6616196632385254,
-0.9203752279281616,
0.28202375769615173,
-0.3555772304534912,
-0.27979013323783875,
-0.256746768951416,
0.16371183097362518,
0.31197449564933777,
-0.14668186008930206,
0.2939979135990143,
-0.03946499153971672,
-0.05522270128130913,
-0.7006329298019409,
0.2791247069835663,
0.32550475001335144,
-0.3703894019126892,
-0.2576984763145447,
0.7410677075386047,
0.06350304186344147,
-0.6836758255958557,
0.3745664656162262,
-0.31947895884513855,
-0.53440260887146,
0.7380867600440979,
0.33470073342323303,
0.5673848390579224,
-0.004161648452281952,
-0.03676433861255646,
0.16992361843585968,
0.045554012060165405,
-0.08651042729616165,
0.29215237498283386,
-0.15471191704273224,
-0.32477355003356934,
-0.2535933554172516,
-0.4418133795261383,
-1.216206431388855,
-0.1486789733171463,
-0.7243242263793945,
0.22726984322071075,
-0.4094240367412567,
0.008906145580112934,
0.3170894980430603,
0.10639341175556183,
-0.8129738569259644,
-0.040358904749155045,
-0.013046042062342167,
1.211320161819458,
-0.5345842838287354,
0.7407945394515991,
0.816062331199646,
-0.17576488852500916,
-0.5187671780586243,
-0.11431804299354553,
0.21332472562789917,
-0.5527734756469727,
0.5467701554298401,
0.1927541196346283,
0.018898693844676018,
-0.3979932963848114,
-0.6211132407188416,
-0.46417906880378723,
0.9056205153465271,
0.49844303727149963,
-0.7389604449272156,
0.11235422641038895,
0.4204269051551819,
0.5572940111160278,
0.1399421989917755,
0.5913771390914917,
1.0502463579177856,
0.8015363812446594,
-0.07239469885826111,
-1.0279496908187866,
0.16854551434516907,
-0.48188990354537964,
-0.40046295523643494,
0.31491148471832275,
-0.6627871990203857,
0.6782791614532471,
0.06389795988798141,
0.027274420484900475,
-0.08134397864341736,
0.27493345737457275,
0.30221596360206604,
0.3085169494152069,
0.5484634041786194,
0.679022490978241,
0.6687017679214478,
-0.20801272988319397,
1.1877427101135254,
-0.3193713128566742,
0.3187444508075714,
1.1896508932113647,
-0.9069534540176392,
0.8077506422996521,
0.4663532078266144,
-0.6244674324989319,
0.6920391321182251,
0.3983341157436371,
0.10548625141382217,
0.10719957202672958,
0.5639060139656067,
-0.0838877409696579,
-0.43969786167144775,
0.36872225999832153,
-0.2274261862039566,
0.28719615936279297,
0.38525331020355225,
0.5424681901931763,
-0.7006863951683044,
-0.3282935619354248,
0.014650503173470497,
0.6167388558387756,
0.2042384296655655,
0.5625975728034973,
-0.05425792559981346,
-0.5872446894645691,
0.42571255564689636,
0.1383068710565567,
0.3256370425224304,
-0.6611308455467224,
0.09025005251169205,
-0.20726561546325684,
0.16856122016906738,
-0.1652941256761551,
-0.7154304385185242,
0.3265026807785034,
0.3296167850494385,
0.1885586827993393,
-0.4040270149707794,
0.5443114638328552,
-0.09994054585695267,
-0.7146133780479431,
0.19850046932697296,
0.48638656735420227,
0.029208175837993622,
-0.2684735059738159,
-0.8211691379547119,
-0.02423083409667015,
-0.27175551652908325,
-0.5854972004890442,
0.5963153839111328,
0.5043555498123169,
-0.269292414188385,
0.689389705657959,
0.7925155162811279,
-0.11184022575616837,
0.04682699590921402,
0.23498979210853577,
0.9562649726867676,
-0.9303501844406128,
-0.5887271761894226,
-0.7527208924293518,
0.1710691601037979,
-0.19803842902183533,
-0.09011464565992355,
0.6379061341285706,
0.8666625618934631,
0.5881367325782776,
-0.05980917811393738,
0.6545343995094299,
-0.014361990615725517,
0.8037673830986023,
-0.42652931809425354,
0.8497666120529175,
-0.4506548047065735,
0.17040471732616425,
-0.42701274156570435,
-0.7202234268188477,
-0.38996991515159607,
0.3665539026260376,
-0.5855299830436707,
-0.0547054298222065,
0.5752607583999634,
0.7238712906837463,
-0.2947731912136078,
0.34323635697364807,
0.3798689544200897,
0.42074885964393616,
0.5060940980911255,
0.48382824659347534,
0.9118030071258545,
-0.24030940234661102,
0.8109476566314697,
-0.3417683243751526,
-0.1387658715248108,
-0.32570698857307434,
-0.9986842274665833,
-0.640922486782074,
-0.16623178124427795,
-0.13951930403709412,
-0.21087636053562164,
-0.14486944675445557,
1.1746407747268677,
0.6818440556526184,
-0.9842484593391418,
-0.38711175322532654,
-0.23252201080322266,
0.18497449159622192,
-0.24977430701255798,
-0.22154287993907928,
0.2831076681613922,
-0.2014998346567154,
-0.6024418473243713,
0.4280048906803131,
0.2179815024137497,
-0.07180957496166229,
-0.16031904518604279,
0.23433856666088104,
-0.06652595102787018,
-0.06427285820245743,
0.407199889421463,
0.48114117980003357,
-0.49308714270591736,
0.0440811887383461,
0.11711514741182327,
-0.24184174835681915,
0.28074923157691956,
0.7415255308151245,
-0.7129916548728943,
0.39307287335395813,
0.2588472068309784,
0.5571700930595398,
1.0179115533828735,
0.2945670783519745,
0.42431527376174927,
-0.6594719886779785,
0.09148121625185013,
0.15363074839115143,
0.23052778840065002,
0.27087461948394775,
-0.27342283725738525,
0.5054075717926025,
-0.04885927215218544,
-0.3171842098236084,
-1.1049362421035767,
0.10148150473833084,
-1.1011344194412231,
-0.24878910183906555,
0.9146093726158142,
-0.18937444686889648,
-0.5608126521110535,
-0.13563159108161926,
-0.33041462302207947,
0.09813051670789719,
-0.45482274889945984,
1.105743408203125,
0.7207794189453125,
-0.14444150030612946,
0.15433456003665924,
-0.7866479754447937,
0.327350378036499,
0.5122856497764587,
-1.318004846572876,
0.4668692350387573,
0.5116640329360962,
0.46709877252578735,
-0.03315769135951996,
0.3123980760574341,
-0.11556430906057358,
0.46988171339035034,
-0.059145841747522354,
0.12323173135519028,
-0.2251429259777069,
0.027591750025749207,
0.11226555705070496,
0.32481881976127625,
-0.1349722295999527,
0.3977016806602478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14986v2 | Do Large Language Models Exhibit Cognitive Dissonance? Studying the Difference Between Revealed Beliefs and Stated Answers | 2024-06-21T08:56:35 | 2024-07-02T14:02:04 | Manuel Mondal, Ljiljana Dolamic, Gérôme Bovet, Philippe Cudré-Mauroux, Julien Audiffren | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Prompting and Multiple Choices Questions (MCQ) have become the preferred
approach to assess the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), due to
their ease of manipulation and evaluation. Such experimental appraisals have
pointed toward the LLMs' apparent ability to perform causal reasoning or to
grasp uncertainty. In this paper, we investigate whether these abilities are
measurable outside of tailored prompting and MCQ by reformulating these issues
as direct text completion - the foundation of LLMs. To achieve this goal, we
define scenarios with multiple possible outcomes and we compare the prediction
made by the LLM through prompting (their Stated Answer) to the probability
distributions they compute over these outcomes during next token prediction
(their Revealed Belief). Our findings suggest that the Revealed Belief of LLMs
significantly differs from their Stated Answer and hint at multiple biases and
misrepresentations that their beliefs may yield in many scenarios and outcomes.
As text completion is at the core of LLMs, these results suggest that common
evaluation methods may only provide a partial picture and that more research is
needed to assess the extent and nature of their capabilities. | [
-0.4635777473449707,
-0.795438826084137,
1.265097737312317,
0.21231448650360107,
-0.19074420630931854,
0.14727994799613953,
-0.34992584586143494,
-0.12602807581424713,
-0.2114657461643219,
0.31787484884262085,
-0.6687538623809814,
-0.24178831279277802,
-0.9436666965484619,
0.46140533685684204,
-0.3497946858406067,
0.6133284568786621,
-0.11379978805780411,
-0.05034149810671806,
-0.48509421944618225,
0.13630430400371552,
-0.8022997379302979,
-0.31628212332725525,
-0.5013118982315063,
-0.6862814426422119,
0.6798162460327148,
0.31739121675491333,
0.7924676537513733,
0.11334939301013947,
0.20490823686122894,
0.3347543478012085,
-0.18952201306819916,
0.05636593699455261,
-0.23474250733852386,
0.06670954823493958,
-0.3701465427875519,
-0.5291114449501038,
0.017153941094875336,
0.2562336027622223,
0.7778964638710022,
0.8311984539031982,
-0.11121568083763123,
-0.07448793947696686,
0.42156362533569336,
0.573335587978363,
-0.4732222855091095,
-0.01285883691161871,
-0.8725429773330688,
-0.08149386942386627,
0.06949449330568314,
0.01191754825413227,
-0.7375249266624451,
-0.11259927600622177,
0.3619212508201599,
-0.3117942214012146,
-0.05271352082490921,
0.02409612573683262,
0.5902826189994812,
0.42328694462776184,
-1.0198185443878174,
-0.8446881771087646,
-0.6960589289665222,
0.8513849973678589,
-0.7930628657341003,
0.15494880080223083,
0.4698895514011383,
0.26577645540237427,
-0.2841278910636902,
-0.24040503799915314,
-0.9644351601600647,
-0.346926748752594,
-0.23795796930789948,
0.14898274838924408,
-0.1829189658164978,
0.14528289437294006,
0.5478944182395935,
0.4597979784011841,
-0.5119921565055847,
0.2585783898830414,
-0.20180250704288483,
-0.1991923302412033,
0.4240663945674896,
0.21030394732952118,
0.10928183794021606,
-0.32340115308761597,
-0.3128815293312073,
-0.09814810007810593,
-0.6644774079322815,
0.07472296804189682,
0.3235509693622589,
0.130496546626091,
-0.12086249142885208,
0.749295175075531,
-0.005622273776680231,
0.8521634936332703,
0.09780450910329819,
-0.33590802550315857,
0.09782181680202484,
-0.14713045954704285,
-0.4617951512336731,
0.10697905719280243,
0.7934479713439941,
0.0167408287525177,
0.3104213774204254,
0.22089064121246338,
-0.12924109399318695,
0.23425541818141937,
0.17533767223358154,
-0.32500559091567993,
0.059970010071992874,
0.5435236692428589,
-0.3035300076007843,
-0.020100828260183334,
-0.036894384771585464,
-0.3716335892677307,
-0.6689088940620422,
-0.452347993850708,
0.24064181745052338,
-0.5131718516349792,
-0.5642532706260681,
0.4490610361099243,
-0.2850673794746399,
0.23338721692562103,
0.5477015972137451,
-0.7849809527397156,
-0.07803521305322647,
0.6621055603027344,
0.6311146020889282,
-0.1862453669309616,
-0.3793353736400604,
-0.11279195547103882,
-0.024684026837348938,
-0.46888190507888794,
0.61774080991745,
-0.5693625807762146,
-0.5007138848304749,
0.13788071274757385,
-0.19128267467021942,
-0.13193660974502563,
-0.36444994807243347,
0.5704279541969299,
-0.5524870157241821,
0.23257283866405487,
-0.7117939591407776,
-0.5713073015213013,
-0.37901216745376587,
0.5479891896247864,
-0.7012383341789246,
0.7550671696662903,
-0.21947965025901794,
-0.8620908260345459,
0.5562500953674316,
0.018670743331313133,
-0.34377995133399963,
-0.16575226187705994,
-0.644059956073761,
-0.06287942081689835,
0.18014396727085114,
0.014693142846226692,
0.6587323546409607,
-0.5368834733963013,
0.8477287292480469,
-0.41955137252807617,
-0.2831086218357086,
0.7423920631408691,
-0.9649462699890137,
0.6341979503631592,
0.1003849133849144,
-0.37647566199302673,
-0.1669444888830185,
-0.6717529892921448,
-0.1325855255126953,
-0.04811360687017441,
-0.5089451670646667,
-0.5043067336082458,
0.1494608223438263,
-0.5108537673950195,
0.4129359722137451,
0.2681615650653839,
-0.329640656709671,
0.4160211384296417,
-0.19938616454601288,
0.32050803303718567,
0.9267617464065552,
-0.01726214960217476,
0.45050686597824097,
-0.43125033378601074,
0.3544204533100128,
0.3166036307811737,
-0.11002683639526367,
-0.15763789415359497,
-0.652687668800354,
-0.6266430020332336,
-0.3131333887577057,
-0.13095837831497192,
0.29007411003112793,
-0.6785669326782227,
0.3662974536418915,
-0.10302206873893738,
-0.3830128014087677,
-0.15705397725105286,
0.06687995046377182,
0.4244057536125183,
0.5346730947494507,
0.22071458399295807,
0.42748257517814636,
-0.40490543842315674,
-0.9362278580665588,
-0.3102358281612396,
-0.40386396646499634,
-0.013599214144051075,
0.25697144865989685,
0.614042341709137,
-0.25919845700263977,
0.8871933817863464,
-0.4165792167186737,
0.12652334570884705,
-0.22898541390895844,
0.13377101719379425,
0.5857436656951904,
0.07970701158046722,
0.3618103861808777,
-0.918419361114502,
-0.2801755666732788,
-0.18078108131885529,
-1.012508511543274,
0.13551798462867737,
-0.3500326871871948,
0.22810351848602295,
0.07904157787561417,
0.28661128878593445,
-0.7898974418640137,
0.38310229778289795,
0.6914346218109131,
-0.32922983169555664,
0.7994711399078369,
-0.1616632044315338,
0.4502316117286682,
-0.9214990139007568,
-0.24461479485034943,
-0.12935392558574677,
-0.023113522678613663,
-0.41029542684555054,
-0.4418627619743347,
0.0656949132680893,
0.36719053983688354,
-0.19692100584506989,
0.49625006318092346,
-0.6600379943847656,
-0.04036277160048485,
-0.21473349630832672,
0.48517659306526184,
0.0741627961397171,
0.12726427614688873,
0.10054197907447815,
0.5884372591972351,
0.6345101594924927,
-0.9999771118164062,
0.13409270346164703,
0.17851926386356354,
-0.5424309372901917,
0.35677826404571533,
-0.6881778836250305,
-0.1494092345237732,
-0.41153809428215027,
0.21850275993347168,
-1.3736720085144043,
-0.4547179043292999,
-0.04607241973280907,
-0.2204325795173645,
0.07180199027061462,
0.05969530716538429,
-0.44062548875808716,
-0.5975821018218994,
0.07189855724573135,
0.25749707221984863,
0.591949999332428,
-0.4311269223690033,
0.5015202760696411,
0.03637561947107315,
-0.12537309527397156,
-0.8139634728431702,
-0.9447859525680542,
-0.03501184657216072,
-0.25322839617729187,
-0.3075644075870514,
0.14096537232398987,
-0.15273378789424896,
-0.7461448311805725,
-0.24559515714645386,
0.06403227895498276,
0.19755195081233978,
0.03506680950522423,
0.3749019205570221,
0.391083300113678,
-0.011000299826264381,
0.4896054267883301,
0.40797659754753113,
0.22412969172000885,
0.10857293009757996,
-0.08383753895759583,
0.5055486559867859,
0.08802218735218048,
-0.8278132081031799,
-0.18144020438194275,
0.11707668006420135,
0.6322408318519592,
0.04633694514632225,
0.7095317244529724,
0.09078501164913177,
-0.5063855051994324,
-0.04111790657043457,
-0.8323628902435303,
-0.16993333399295807,
-0.46941810846328735,
0.1562170684337616,
-0.525060772895813,
-1.1905521154403687,
0.591901957988739,
-0.05981564149260521,
0.05129719898104668,
0.6057470440864563,
0.698535680770874,
-0.008261780254542828,
1.0729396343231201,
0.1385704129934311,
0.28263357281684875,
0.2804069519042969,
-0.010637340135872364,
-0.09751424938440323,
-0.8149866461753845,
-0.26965194940567017,
-0.4724542498588562,
-0.15349677205085754,
-0.4489421546459198,
-0.4225085377693176,
0.2499387413263321,
0.2838922142982483,
-0.384540855884552,
-0.03347012773156166,
-0.45128417015075684,
0.3500696122646332,
0.14572885632514954,
-0.0221563633531332,
0.46511900424957275,
-0.18231837451457977,
-0.5060199499130249,
-0.1317262351512909,
-0.5838250517845154,
-0.9297292232513428,
1.021498680114746,
0.31159353256225586,
0.5890036225318909,
0.2421865612268448,
0.5226714015007019,
0.2777835726737976,
0.3179766833782196,
-0.7451123595237732,
0.43311041593551636,
0.3197591304779053,
-0.852089524269104,
-0.30353376269340515,
-0.3907443583011627,
-0.8698925375938416,
0.30289626121520996,
-0.2579447627067566,
-0.791363537311554,
0.19929087162017822,
0.06795553863048553,
-0.24603931605815887,
0.09643660485744476,
-0.502731204032898,
0.569070041179657,
-0.1364540159702301,
-0.017777999863028526,
-0.32020190358161926,
-0.23667463660240173,
0.7456475496292114,
-0.12955333292484283,
0.430934876203537,
-0.10979562997817993,
0.11058485507965088,
0.5527722239494324,
-0.13232256472110748,
1.0757461786270142,
-0.13036809861660004,
-0.6221818923950195,
0.6183328032493591,
0.14274902641773224,
0.42881250381469727,
0.2647387683391571,
-0.401337593793869,
-0.0608331598341465,
-0.03667709603905678,
-0.26385578513145447,
-0.7299945950508118,
0.7846772074699402,
-0.6283305287361145,
-0.9690917134284973,
-0.5857015252113342,
-0.33542320132255554,
-0.24717126786708832,
0.2579217553138733,
0.2575802803039551,
0.576108992099762,
-0.3413989543914795,
-0.017555933445692062,
0.7512868642807007,
-0.39803290367126465,
0.4232020676136017,
0.42778250575065613,
-0.3211940824985504,
-0.2482711225748062,
0.25461938977241516,
0.11203377693891525,
0.4813443720340729,
0.24404454231262207,
0.23266728222370148,
-0.5990120768547058,
-0.6708177328109741,
-0.2685219943523407,
0.26768529415130615,
-0.9361925721168518,
-0.021318966522812843,
-0.5587016344070435,
0.1372961699962616,
-0.35818231105804443,
-0.2247120589017868,
-0.1233787089586258,
-0.038114141672849655,
-0.25339847803115845,
-0.3944171667098999,
0.2845270037651062,
1.200662612915039,
0.21285149455070496,
0.27917012572288513,
-0.7782628536224365,
0.031667161732912064,
0.32061460614204407,
-0.02409449964761734,
0.2679973840713501,
-0.5085252523422241,
-0.034701187163591385,
0.42774444818496704,
-0.2643658518791199,
-1.0664187669754028,
0.019403252750635147,
-0.22237643599510193,
0.666822075843811,
0.5192942023277283,
0.19741694629192352,
0.6156187653541565,
-0.5630537271499634,
0.9185265898704529,
0.3637319803237915,
-0.9536411762237549,
0.5412353873252869,
-0.33228105306625366,
0.44002339243888855,
0.5118492245674133,
0.6159164309501648,
-0.4624404311180115,
-0.6254907846450806,
-0.5357361435890198,
-0.2968468964099884,
0.3606492578983307,
-0.0003312210610602051,
0.12709759175777435,
-0.4876088500022888,
0.42154303193092346,
0.3370739817619324,
0.2972998321056366,
-0.7543672919273376,
-0.14359290897846222,
0.12968884408473969,
-0.1810958832502365,
-0.25419560074806213,
-0.33823129534721375,
-0.14229470491409302,
-0.05409180000424385,
0.4415771961212158,
-0.18945574760437012,
0.08569813519716263,
0.4812856614589691,
-0.07408684492111206,
0.2560807168483734,
0.5632669925689697,
0.6170746088027954,
0.7858273983001709,
0.1280350536108017,
0.3829064965248108,
0.19811628758907318,
-0.25321608781814575,
0.31684204936027527,
-0.351979523897171,
-0.036732014268636703,
-0.04885225370526314,
0.5935526490211487,
0.7027771472930908,
0.1647672951221466,
-0.7633562088012695,
0.5405328869819641,
-0.006491172127425671,
-0.2937062978744507,
-0.45127037167549133,
-0.04148292914032936,
0.15866847336292267,
0.30032965540885925,
0.5563992261886597,
0.2138390988111496,
0.15653309226036072,
-0.7458838224411011,
0.07106724381446838,
0.43673714995384216,
-0.4594586491584778,
-0.20757390558719635,
0.4930952489376068,
-0.17706087231636047,
0.06777948141098022,
0.685910701751709,
-0.30295971035957336,
-0.4678504467010498,
0.5396880507469177,
0.4918936491012573,
0.5790435075759888,
-0.05475078523159027,
0.3632141053676605,
0.4295274615287781,
0.47731584310531616,
-0.39513522386550903,
0.21620211005210876,
0.1553221344947815,
-1.0400019884109497,
-0.6614397764205933,
-0.5336037874221802,
-0.17076987028121948,
0.06063290685415268,
-0.5797712206840515,
0.3756650388240814,
-0.41128358244895935,
-0.3329220116138458,
-0.10419483482837677,
-0.2204052358865738,
-0.6550911068916321,
0.39344850182533264,
0.14676517248153687,
0.8525723814964294,
-0.7864829897880554,
0.7025996446609497,
0.463989794254303,
-0.5572363138198853,
-0.9266045093536377,
0.1688261777162552,
0.17648054659366608,
-0.6925824880599976,
0.6103039979934692,
0.2853805720806122,
-0.12670113146305084,
-0.2498488873243332,
-0.32847023010253906,
-0.6971370577812195,
1.2118953466415405,
0.3822895288467407,
-0.7850028276443481,
-0.24144764244556427,
0.18645095825195312,
0.4056541323661804,
-0.42584651708602905,
0.43799230456352234,
0.43299466371536255,
0.6669854521751404,
0.26488012075424194,
-0.9618467092514038,
0.33909010887145996,
0.23381096124649048,
-0.14638137817382812,
-0.0470593124628067,
-0.3949103057384491,
1.077211618423462,
-0.40245482325553894,
-0.3627362847328186,
-0.21651077270507812,
0.3917655348777771,
0.46459701657295227,
0.3060990273952484,
0.5629005432128906,
0.21703247725963593,
1.0749272108078003,
-0.13230140507221222,
1.1895467042922974,
0.13091525435447693,
0.26691946387290955,
0.9936919808387756,
-0.4322178363800049,
0.8266062140464783,
0.6014432311058044,
-0.30699068307876587,
0.721042275428772,
0.7153782248497009,
0.3628772497177124,
0.35031700134277344,
0.1852896809577942,
-0.19106581807136536,
-0.4987452030181885,
0.11166372150182724,
-0.21626757085323334,
0.43005067110061646,
0.6226709485054016,
-0.3940771222114563,
-0.002652345923706889,
0.13635821640491486,
0.002248017117381096,
0.28135889768600464,
-0.2656537592411041,
0.7954631447792053,
0.35521823167800903,
-1.1077591180801392,
0.7841677069664001,
-0.16018326580524445,
0.6947689652442932,
-0.4656810164451599,
0.11316273361444473,
0.19709007441997528,
0.05264328792691231,
-0.20739991962909698,
-1.2130231857299805,
0.40190985798835754,
-0.19548821449279785,
-0.33847132325172424,
-0.2851587235927582,
0.7031895518302917,
-0.4095189571380615,
-0.26150646805763245,
0.3610478341579437,
0.6761115193367004,
0.04058048874139786,
-0.2510177493095398,
-0.6481246948242188,
0.10858408361673355,
0.16532868146896362,
-0.3352067172527313,
0.1358374059200287,
0.7131581902503967,
0.07488492876291275,
0.6500167846679688,
0.4372570216655731,
-0.0608532577753067,
-0.07395371794700623,
0.10401653498411179,
0.8216569423675537,
-0.5670503377914429,
-0.1334104984998703,
-1.336075782775879,
0.561408281326294,
-0.1355935037136078,
-0.2610286474227905,
0.8141369819641113,
0.2850644886493683,
0.6474382281303406,
-0.0841178372502327,
1.112282633781433,
-0.013127215206623077,
0.3863508701324463,
-0.7559217214584351,
0.5137361884117126,
-0.45347490906715393,
0.36468228697776794,
-0.40125709772109985,
-0.7450107336044312,
0.047909945249557495,
0.5557717084884644,
-0.755649745464325,
0.14476928114891052,
0.8241289258003235,
0.37098073959350586,
0.119920514523983,
0.11970747262239456,
0.5337026119232178,
0.3488008975982666,
0.25513312220573425,
0.5472742915153503,
1.241335391998291,
-0.23203779757022858,
0.3589094281196594,
0.4161682426929474,
-0.497039258480072,
0.06590180844068527,
-0.9565856456756592,
-1.162443995475769,
-0.8319849371910095,
-0.1895732879638672,
-0.31979644298553467,
-0.3778647482395172,
0.6234850883483887,
0.012781291268765926,
-0.5362555980682373,
0.006104736123234034,
-0.2565612494945526,
0.47661444544792175,
0.04691062495112419,
-0.21530765295028687,
-0.024250371381640434,
-0.23339660465717316,
-0.7671472430229187,
0.22903700172901154,
0.28320610523223877,
0.21495816111564636,
-0.44754913449287415,
-0.22647711634635925,
-0.3027680218219757,
0.3287717401981354,
0.6174779534339905,
-0.15111279487609863,
-1.0114713907241821,
-0.4849042594432831,
0.05511407554149628,
-0.2541687786579132,
-0.22059045732021332,
0.752953052520752,
-0.6850765943527222,
0.29648059606552124,
0.4081414043903351,
0.3529697358608246,
0.21055735647678375,
-0.25893548130989075,
0.7387183904647827,
-0.5023303627967834,
0.14986127614974976,
0.12107250839471817,
0.5770823359489441,
0.2950480282306671,
-0.29289934039115906,
0.03630923479795456,
-0.023549944162368774,
-0.44859033823013306,
-0.70539391040802,
0.7548283338546753,
-0.7186640501022339,
-0.4291885197162628,
1.3657267093658447,
-0.14046311378479004,
-0.07257150858640671,
-0.20308758318424225,
-0.3244234323501587,
0.18800568580627441,
-0.17450925707817078,
0.5764361023902893,
1.3920063972473145,
0.08845759183168411,
0.07226486504077911,
-0.5480991005897522,
0.5088025331497192,
0.38952118158340454,
-0.3984864056110382,
0.3067668676376343,
0.7018982768058777,
0.15910747647285461,
0.2973746955394745,
0.9036189913749695,
-0.07865805178880692,
-0.08430817723274231,
0.07980026304721832,
-0.3441798985004425,
0.3240594267845154,
-0.07756305485963821,
-0.2755480706691742,
-0.1478143036365509,
0.4007340967655182,
0.36537232995033264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00072v2 | Pistis-RAG: A Scalable Cascading Framework Towards Content-Centric Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-21T08:52:11 | 2024-07-03T06:54:16 | Yu Bai, Yukai Miao, Li Chen, Dan Li, Yanyu Ren, Hongtao Xie, Ce Yang, Xuhui Cai | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In Greek mythology, Pistis symbolized good faith, trust, and reliability.
Drawing inspiration from these principles, Pistis-RAG is a scalable multi-stage
framework designed to address the challenges of large-scale retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) systems. This framework consists of distinct stages: matching,
pre-ranking, ranking, reasoning, and aggregating. Each stage contributes to
narrowing the search space, prioritizing semantically relevant documents,
aligning with the large language model's (LLM) preferences, supporting complex
chain-of-thought (CoT) methods, and combining information from multiple
sources.
Our ranking stage introduces a significant innovation by recognizing that
semantic relevance alone may not lead to improved generation quality, due to
the sensitivity of the few-shot prompt order, as noted in previous research.
This critical aspect is often overlooked in current RAG frameworks.
We argue that the alignment issue between LLMs and external knowledge ranking
methods is tied to the model-centric paradigm dominant in RAG systems. We
propose a content-centric approach, emphasizing seamless integration between
LLMs and external information sources to optimize content transformation for
specific tasks.
Our novel ranking stage is designed specifically for RAG systems,
incorporating principles of information retrieval while considering the unique
business scenarios reflected in LLM preferences and user feedback. We simulated
feedback signals on the MMLU benchmark, resulting in a 9.3% performance
improvement. Our model and code will be open-sourced on GitHub. Additionally,
experiments on real-world, large-scale data validate the scalability of our
framework. | [
-0.7592119574546814,
-0.39807575941085815,
0.6024115681648254,
0.06216707080602646,
-0.2907768785953522,
0.2510455250740051,
-0.31357136368751526,
-0.18861128389835358,
0.4923233389854431,
0.32975897192955017,
-0.38319796323776245,
-0.2508617341518402,
-0.780884325504303,
-0.04355032369494438,
-0.47911128401756287,
1.212294340133667,
0.3395377993583679,
-0.1032252311706543,
-0.041018661111593246,
-0.09447168558835983,
-0.3248497247695923,
-0.27241644263267517,
-0.8816689252853394,
-0.19007310271263123,
0.877973735332489,
0.6193141937255859,
0.7454004287719727,
0.4199519157409668,
0.5593429803848267,
0.19520695507526398,
-0.3657401502132416,
0.42912301421165466,
-0.745081901550293,
0.7444273233413696,
-0.795104444026947,
-0.23106658458709717,
-0.6478694081306458,
0.03300187364220619,
0.34980350732803345,
0.40204742550849915,
-0.16965867578983307,
0.5542870759963989,
0.032312389463186264,
0.884289026260376,
-1.0257978439331055,
-0.0669412910938263,
-0.6961939930915833,
-0.13673409819602966,
-0.6634098887443542,
-0.49125030636787415,
-0.4637547731399536,
-0.17087404429912567,
-0.03775651752948761,
-0.6940001845359802,
0.3005438446998596,
0.22811712324619293,
0.7019267082214355,
-0.014849300496280193,
-0.29004618525505066,
-0.5312461256980896,
-0.5633620619773865,
0.6429464221000671,
-0.36959242820739746,
0.2321515530347824,
0.3510732054710388,
0.4645846486091614,
-0.2299419492483139,
-0.9386427998542786,
-0.6302840113639832,
0.07521877437829971,
-0.05518650636076927,
0.3015831410884857,
0.05468694120645523,
-0.45139071345329285,
0.14804215729236603,
0.5354935526847839,
-0.5319648385047913,
-0.0834750309586525,
-0.4520866870880127,
0.3493301272392273,
0.4963478446006775,
0.06958301365375519,
0.07554606348276138,
-0.3021964132785797,
-0.17724372446537018,
-0.1468878984451294,
-0.6237211227416992,
0.014844294637441635,
0.2915785610675812,
0.6264370083808899,
0.1141340583562851,
0.9691870808601379,
-0.20046155154705048,
0.5064825415611267,
0.700039267539978,
-0.31534141302108765,
0.12733782827854156,
-0.06004520505666733,
0.04854302853345871,
0.28061965107917786,
0.5240836143493652,
0.17207098007202148,
-0.15852560102939606,
-0.12520095705986023,
-0.20776459574699402,
0.05138861760497093,
0.8485357761383057,
-0.7009928226470947,
0.121653713285923,
0.18786826729774475,
-0.2864327132701874,
-0.5493780970573425,
0.4287632703781128,
-0.9504256248474121,
-0.7652550935745239,
-0.22656728327274323,
0.46791642904281616,
-0.39787739515304565,
-0.39695385098457336,
-0.1831589639186859,
0.07428397983312607,
0.14112365245819092,
0.3757496774196625,
-0.8447502851486206,
0.22042672336101532,
1.3116909265518188,
0.890508770942688,
-0.5494018793106079,
-0.10546831786632538,
-0.8841556906700134,
0.3671276271343231,
-0.7549620866775513,
0.8892600536346436,
-0.5332008004188538,
-0.3467886745929718,
-0.2676767110824585,
0.010970545932650566,
0.0896238163113594,
-0.3041287958621979,
0.9573314785957336,
-0.7670511603355408,
0.28034213185310364,
-0.3378060758113861,
-0.5518747568130493,
-0.06691768020391464,
0.1566528081893921,
-0.6930326819419861,
0.9399363398551941,
0.0673505961894989,
-1.2052792310714722,
0.46592292189598083,
-0.478450745344162,
-0.3985685110092163,
0.25173234939575195,
-0.12043213844299316,
-0.5775358080863953,
0.5142579674720764,
-0.07028191536664963,
0.3716682195663452,
-0.5788699388504028,
0.21290026605129242,
-0.3129023015499115,
-0.35545575618743896,
0.0496382936835289,
-0.05655939504504204,
0.3761206567287445,
0.5521799325942993,
-0.4817778170108795,
-0.03241090103983879,
-0.4622083604335785,
0.09324479848146439,
0.025869466364383698,
-0.14884397387504578,
-0.4799667000770569,
0.042780086398124695,
-0.12074857950210571,
0.14275281131267548,
0.19449332356452942,
-0.38320472836494446,
0.2570508122444153,
-0.18340441584587097,
-0.20942355692386627,
0.5315996408462524,
-0.0305738914757967,
0.8693407773971558,
-0.5541418790817261,
0.5321326851844788,
-0.06186409667134285,
0.14076201617717743,
-0.30133548378944397,
-0.44724041223526,
-0.6718294620513916,
-0.29728150367736816,
0.12675926089286804,
0.08760610967874527,
-0.5795206427574158,
0.24868619441986084,
-0.42448890209198,
-0.7945255637168884,
-0.2757693827152252,
-0.10048012435436249,
0.17080986499786377,
0.7092083692550659,
0.2838096022605896,
-0.3811676800251007,
-0.31625378131866455,
-0.5534988641738892,
-0.17388510704040527,
-0.03640956059098244,
0.19346334040164948,
0.05732886120676994,
0.08263993263244629,
-0.10806455463171005,
0.7361977100372314,
-0.26947683095932007,
-0.44718337059020996,
-0.37881946563720703,
0.16094261407852173,
0.685085117816925,
0.36476436257362366,
0.2696075737476349,
-1.2346457242965698,
-0.7014425992965698,
0.29590874910354614,
-0.3855825364589691,
-0.25776779651641846,
0.11376840621232986,
-0.3581916391849518,
0.30962926149368286,
0.2509656846523285,
-0.6405816078186035,
0.47022536396980286,
0.6237342953681946,
-0.45866885781288147,
0.677339494228363,
-0.25111958384513855,
0.45184481143951416,
-1.2611984014511108,
0.38026416301727295,
-0.24509479105472565,
-0.1199188232421875,
-0.5857405662536621,
0.31101229786872864,
0.21797211468219757,
-0.24796441197395325,
-0.24866920709609985,
0.4822477102279663,
-0.3419553339481354,
-0.5182492733001709,
-0.534403920173645,
0.22463542222976685,
0.38450759649276733,
0.13413424789905548,
-0.13612191379070282,
1.1998950242996216,
0.2696393132209778,
-0.7749014496803284,
0.18698465824127197,
0.13681019842624664,
0.01784995198249817,
1.2165721654891968,
-0.3809472620487213,
-0.12791331112384796,
-0.23898732662200928,
0.2464834749698639,
-0.5683630704879761,
-0.18551741540431976,
0.10032320767641068,
-0.5231538414955139,
0.5583797097206116,
-0.30707821249961853,
-0.6371294260025024,
-0.11479721963405609,
-0.25120803713798523,
0.5207217335700989,
0.27011027932167053,
-0.5152530670166016,
0.7199863791465759,
0.5271387696266174,
-0.4585192799568176,
-0.5159820318222046,
-0.19211161136627197,
0.004703377839177847,
-0.34763526916503906,
-0.5694171786308289,
0.5560732483863831,
-0.0652860701084137,
-0.19060780107975006,
-0.04784539341926575,
-0.3617890775203705,
0.007139436900615692,
-0.14489421248435974,
0.30652546882629395,
0.23759740591049194,
-0.12054993957281113,
0.1996697038412094,
0.16013425588607788,
-0.4604751765727997,
-0.6076645255088806,
-0.6034123301506042,
0.7227571606636047,
-0.14868567883968353,
-0.4600306749343872,
0.008031423203647137,
0.29354867339134216,
0.9501408934593201,
-0.568872332572937,
0.7764416933059692,
0.6879169940948486,
-0.05921677127480507,
-0.0670066624879837,
-0.7561313509941101,
0.2211223840713501,
-0.4292677640914917,
0.015337923541665077,
-0.4973427951335907,
-0.7738486528396606,
0.25974833965301514,
-0.15017352998256683,
0.19147057831287384,
0.7377474308013916,
0.7198699712753296,
-0.2645743191242218,
0.7619121074676514,
0.594737708568573,
0.07861494272947311,
0.19343626499176025,
-0.1728188395500183,
0.2340657114982605,
-1.1222034692764282,
-0.2276879996061325,
-0.5648458003997803,
-0.2731629014015198,
-0.6445590257644653,
-0.6091165542602539,
0.6777849793434143,
0.17727011442184448,
-0.44537830352783203,
0.2534777522087097,
-0.5986304879188538,
0.28958073258399963,
0.31236764788627625,
-0.1972217559814453,
0.5241254568099976,
0.07024244219064713,
-0.24207475781440735,
-0.22853884100914001,
-0.723827600479126,
-0.39673173427581787,
1.098777174949646,
0.05499054118990898,
0.73859041929245,
0.30530062317848206,
0.7322594523429871,
0.42055487632751465,
0.27884915471076965,
-0.6508185267448425,
0.18402163684368134,
-0.4744296669960022,
-0.7361736297607422,
-0.3205384314060211,
-0.37072062492370605,
-1.1316524744033813,
0.48474302887916565,
-0.37723785638809204,
-0.39011576771736145,
0.21313604712486267,
-0.2509738504886627,
-0.3253932297229767,
0.45894497632980347,
-0.31494423747062683,
0.38807570934295654,
-0.27992159128189087,
-0.7258917093276978,
-0.4200928509235382,
-0.21576489508152008,
0.3856484591960907,
-0.45458611845970154,
0.5549646615982056,
-0.050649531185626984,
-0.23150217533111572,
0.408500075340271,
-0.34735968708992004,
0.08386319130659103,
0.14460405707359314,
-0.09530752152204514,
0.043174635618925095,
0.3807438611984253,
0.3388177752494812,
0.1261773556470871,
-0.3059946596622467,
-0.38212457299232483,
0.09349165856838226,
-0.2806301712989807,
-0.6780192255973816,
0.8891725540161133,
-0.3791961967945099,
-0.39256688952445984,
-0.7165008187294006,
-0.42009884119033813,
-0.10384846478700638,
0.46287500858306885,
0.4094730019569397,
0.3759193420410156,
0.13465146720409393,
0.2535436749458313,
1.0399038791656494,
-0.257266640663147,
0.17981302738189697,
0.4271109700202942,
-0.613152027130127,
-0.5694774389266968,
0.9820137619972229,
0.09044188261032104,
0.12982302904129028,
0.21089015901088715,
0.15908892452716827,
-0.08697011321783066,
-0.11295192688703537,
-0.22458429634571075,
0.3683699369430542,
-0.4415707290172577,
-0.3699045777320862,
-0.47578752040863037,
-0.1940840631723404,
-0.4072303771972656,
-0.2409474402666092,
-0.8402020931243896,
-0.5048069357872009,
-0.14360903203487396,
0.2549375593662262,
0.08362912386655807,
0.8386239409446716,
0.04213767871260643,
0.18863874673843384,
-0.5984370112419128,
0.6254372596740723,
0.07113077491521835,
0.7338607311248779,
-0.01516639906913042,
-0.5571163296699524,
-0.3749246895313263,
-0.28818073868751526,
-0.320826917886734,
-0.7465036511421204,
0.4259984493255615,
0.024669921025633812,
0.6341187357902527,
0.3769066333770752,
0.19957464933395386,
0.6190692186355591,
-0.5676261186599731,
0.522744357585907,
0.17834466695785522,
-0.6777687072753906,
0.5326570868492126,
-0.369263619184494,
0.20840677618980408,
0.7849108576774597,
0.3781485855579376,
-0.590778648853302,
-0.248264342546463,
-0.7528102993965149,
-0.9286433458328247,
0.6244451403617859,
0.2228580266237259,
-0.1933404505252838,
0.024344559758901596,
0.3772539794445038,
0.25002291798591614,
0.3364158272743225,
-0.26494264602661133,
-0.1841646283864975,
0.032449062913656235,
-0.006686405744403601,
-0.1509571522474289,
-0.4024209678173065,
-0.10083921998739243,
0.04290717467665672,
0.9780264496803284,
-0.0853082612156868,
0.025260789319872856,
0.19183403253555298,
-0.12692803144454956,
-0.1883293241262436,
0.21344637870788574,
0.5898498296737671,
0.8629005551338196,
0.07791247963905334,
0.2140444815158844,
-0.17275480926036835,
-0.5834456086158752,
0.16005666553974152,
-0.08618984371423721,
-0.27406200766563416,
0.14459511637687683,
-0.04516652226448059,
0.32748958468437195,
0.4136168658733368,
-0.23896104097366333,
0.5166598558425903,
-0.13613824546337128,
0.28426527976989746,
-0.5447134971618652,
-0.10206914693117142,
0.019652072340250015,
0.5286141633987427,
0.7667572498321533,
-0.048200011253356934,
0.11134843528270721,
-0.3762202262878418,
0.39672744274139404,
0.3258945643901825,
0.019597098231315613,
-0.039400964975357056,
0.5124388337135315,
-0.2201138287782669,
-0.22857601940631866,
-0.006774274632334709,
-0.27609509229660034,
-0.4235425889492035,
0.1556692123413086,
0.17770786583423615,
0.7115411162376404,
-0.19175583124160767,
0.36358699202537537,
0.4152158498764038,
0.06896751374006271,
-0.3845519721508026,
-0.00799841433763504,
-0.11544400453567505,
-0.2502773702144623,
-0.36511191725730896,
-0.9770074486732483,
-0.4740050733089447,
-0.3114102780818939,
-0.7806469798088074,
0.42633330821990967,
-0.4572269916534424,
-0.5330371856689453,
-0.2539334297180176,
0.2702735662460327,
-0.43001338839530945,
0.1415860652923584,
0.09403710812330246,
0.8839144110679626,
-0.3076016306877136,
0.7031741142272949,
0.5994009971618652,
-0.5192701816558838,
-0.7682867646217346,
0.16083653271198273,
-0.04416227340698242,
-0.26246750354766846,
0.7310925722122192,
-0.0788540467619896,
-0.15083271265029907,
-0.06307581812143326,
-0.16647906601428986,
-1.2750084400177002,
1.3957329988479614,
0.23118802905082703,
-0.29778406023979187,
-0.15015079081058502,
-0.09536662697792053,
0.4211634397506714,
-0.5033084750175476,
0.21685045957565308,
0.28091931343078613,
0.3206467032432556,
0.49491816759109497,
-0.9620485901832581,
-0.2366834133863449,
-0.17468179762363434,
0.1473221778869629,
0.14244170486927032,
-0.5699462294578552,
0.975324273109436,
0.14800532162189484,
-0.18419724702835083,
0.14600440859794617,
0.6835252046585083,
0.7912104725837708,
0.5156413912773132,
0.3501521348953247,
0.8027738332748413,
0.6512762308120728,
0.04987666755914688,
1.028428554534912,
-0.5782382488250732,
0.4253384470939636,
1.273194432258606,
-0.10767795890569687,
0.9356042146682739,
0.5396414399147034,
0.006760850083082914,
0.5275416374206543,
0.23908111453056335,
0.32632848620414734,
0.49055853486061096,
-0.12380465120077133,
-0.24853314459323883,
-0.0012344083515927196,
-0.16947393119335175,
-0.51024329662323,
0.3675573468208313,
0.4348006546497345,
-0.26974424719810486,
-0.353391170501709,
-0.19383588433265686,
0.11208149045705795,
0.1320641189813614,
-0.4375278055667877,
0.7101200819015503,
0.029011504724621773,
-0.895628809928894,
0.28746241331100464,
0.04278102144598961,
0.6640380024909973,
-0.6720825433731079,
0.2149025797843933,
-0.4362134039402008,
0.07248719036579132,
-0.421654611825943,
-0.7473495602607727,
0.4244004487991333,
0.18754953145980835,
-0.28589579463005066,
-0.24550828337669373,
0.8036646842956543,
-0.1882881075143814,
-0.54119873046875,
0.12839935719966888,
0.46195536851882935,
-0.11896674335002899,
-0.11222345381975174,
-0.44684898853302,
0.4341142177581787,
-0.5466524362564087,
-0.29587703943252563,
0.5422925353050232,
0.8667330145835876,
0.005038516595959663,
0.5545654296875,
0.7192530632019043,
0.4099217653274536,
0.09578061103820801,
-0.09507322311401367,
0.903701901435852,
-0.18827614188194275,
-0.7299494743347168,
-0.32246264815330505,
0.5489403009414673,
-0.2523046135902405,
0.1603318750858307,
0.7455214262008667,
0.685377299785614,
0.6622363924980164,
0.3012808859348297,
0.47075220942497253,
-0.19360771775245667,
0.911814272403717,
-0.12856976687908173,
1.0269298553466797,
-0.721344530582428,
0.35683581233024597,
-0.588660717010498,
-1.1714146137237549,
-0.03930335119366646,
0.5098456144332886,
-0.1746404618024826,
-0.0913352221250534,
0.6049515604972839,
0.542267918586731,
-0.32260486483573914,
-0.1249382346868515,
0.41291624307632446,
-0.08316758275032043,
0.321027934551239,
0.09411506354808807,
0.408877432346344,
-0.22853969037532806,
0.4103367328643799,
-0.19003300368785858,
-0.2795587182044983,
-0.09690922498703003,
-0.7123789191246033,
-0.39681532979011536,
-0.878606379032135,
0.09067422151565552,
-0.38938891887664795,
0.16650693118572235,
0.7558616995811462,
0.498182088136673,
-0.5974568724632263,
-0.33185169100761414,
-0.016366124153137207,
-0.032906047999858856,
0.043121088296175,
-0.22366750240325928,
0.22211164236068726,
-0.7917062044143677,
-0.6002727746963501,
0.22971749305725098,
0.5314019918441772,
-0.3742320239543915,
-0.3856247067451477,
-0.2879583537578583,
-0.2692832052707672,
-0.07682696729898453,
0.6843209266662598,
0.246903657913208,
-0.5414178967475891,
0.10385294258594513,
0.03983661159873009,
-0.3243964910507202,
-0.14296439290046692,
0.9049415588378906,
-0.7612595558166504,
0.541770875453949,
0.6019670367240906,
0.830191433429718,
0.7645727396011353,
0.13660527765750885,
0.5074256062507629,
-0.32639598846435547,
0.09611482173204422,
0.3071000277996063,
0.1834004670381546,
0.25900518894195557,
-0.3755902349948883,
0.5795047879219055,
0.13770927488803864,
-0.5265783667564392,
-0.6664905548095703,
0.35365229845046997,
-0.9005148410797119,
-0.23918388783931732,
0.975357174873352,
-0.1517857313156128,
-0.03205132856965065,
0.13658548891544342,
-0.1470901519060135,
0.3230690658092499,
-0.24456724524497986,
0.8283553123474121,
0.3738268315792084,
-0.09993761777877808,
-0.2693396508693695,
-0.533073365688324,
0.45957663655281067,
0.38674497604370117,
-0.5929611325263977,
-0.09585849940776825,
0.4874996840953827,
0.03300056606531143,
0.5746332406997681,
0.5813176035881042,
-0.45506343245506287,
0.3747834265232086,
-0.35636794567108154,
-0.236733078956604,
-0.040322016924619675,
-0.5299004912376404,
-0.24460972845554352,
0.5890263319015503,
0.1319323480129242,
0.345043808221817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14979v1 | Retrieve-Plan-Generation: An Iterative Planning and Answering Framework for Knowledge-Intensive LLM Generation | 2024-06-21T08:45:52 | 2024-06-21T08:45:52 | Yuanjie Lyu, Zihan Niu, Zheyong Xie, Chao Zhang, Tong Xu, Yang Wang, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the significant progress of large language models (LLMs) in various
tasks, they often produce factual errors due to their limited internal
knowledge. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), which enhances LLMs with
external knowledge sources, offers a promising solution. However, these methods
can be misled by irrelevant paragraphs in retrieved documents. Due to the
inherent uncertainty in LLM generation, inputting the entire document may
introduce off-topic information, causing the model to deviate from the central
topic and affecting the relevance of the generated content. To address these
issues, we propose the Retrieve-Plan-Generation (RPG) framework. RPG generates
plan tokens to guide subsequent generation in the plan stage. In the answer
stage, the model selects relevant fine-grained paragraphs based on the plan and
uses them for further answer generation. This plan-answer process is repeated
iteratively until completion, enhancing generation relevance by focusing on
specific topics. To implement this framework efficiently, we utilize a simple
but effective multi-task prompt-tuning method, enabling the existing LLMs to
handle both planning and answering. We comprehensively compare RPG with
baselines across 5 knowledge-intensive generation tasks, demonstrating the
effectiveness of our approach. | [
-0.26604634523391724,
-0.6422590017318726,
0.7858158946037292,
0.39663800597190857,
-0.05220859870314598,
0.07815152406692505,
-0.14397822320461273,
-0.07128152996301651,
0.10790498554706573,
0.8419538140296936,
-0.9415870904922485,
-0.3538565933704376,
-0.3540746867656708,
-0.046877097338438034,
-0.19345462322235107,
0.7259160876274109,
-0.2181777060031891,
-0.15456679463386536,
-0.2870984375476837,
0.25097063183784485,
-0.5983102917671204,
-0.10780160874128342,
-0.831241250038147,
-0.31041640043258667,
0.4278297424316406,
0.7791892886161804,
0.12581203877925873,
0.9110816717147827,
0.3444253206253052,
0.22509610652923584,
-0.08336971700191498,
0.5766709446907043,
-0.7958963513374329,
0.4385344088077545,
-0.32404330372810364,
-0.3945925235748291,
-0.35543039441108704,
-0.3675678074359894,
0.4351606070995331,
0.568229079246521,
-0.19894489645957947,
0.3831002116203308,
0.03331727162003517,
0.5805546045303345,
-0.7109707593917847,
0.28483039140701294,
-1.073134422302246,
-0.019905418157577515,
-0.2783544361591339,
-0.7268195748329163,
-0.4818708896636963,
-0.1496790498495102,
-0.00988598633557558,
-0.7934147119522095,
0.2883784770965576,
0.21937903761863708,
0.6097402572631836,
0.19591106474399567,
-0.1363396942615509,
-0.5919919610023499,
-0.6803765296936035,
0.7341963648796082,
-0.5480876564979553,
-0.13100522756576538,
0.5400425791740417,
0.25261908769607544,
-0.4208017885684967,
-0.6833077669143677,
-0.5466527342796326,
0.03827430307865143,
0.08029371500015259,
0.2563609182834625,
0.07228592038154602,
0.13461150228977203,
0.43954765796661377,
0.250152051448822,
-0.5703662037849426,
-0.11584722995758057,
-0.23686417937278748,
-0.09638754278421402,
0.5828781723976135,
0.3647543787956238,
0.20125430822372437,
-0.4719897508621216,
-0.3646317720413208,
0.13692285120487213,
-1.1683214902877808,
-0.028595030307769775,
0.39989057183265686,
0.39691734313964844,
0.2512753903865814,
1.0430413484573364,
-0.48144587874412537,
0.6957278847694397,
0.23058699071407318,
-0.5183871388435364,
-0.03778672218322754,
-0.5703656673431396,
0.07171815633773804,
-0.07187923789024353,
0.41710153222084045,
0.28500258922576904,
-0.028370965272188187,
-0.13893015682697296,
-0.2980738580226898,
-0.20350834727287292,
0.3868621587753296,
-0.7390104532241821,
0.0003834645904134959,
0.3042387068271637,
-0.24965710937976837,
-0.25989827513694763,
-0.3906841576099396,
-0.840050995349884,
-0.4817160964012146,
-0.09601041674613953,
0.33792874217033386,
-0.4432826340198517,
-0.23408806324005127,
-0.10344281792640686,
-0.3432329595088959,
0.2519792914390564,
0.26073339581489563,
-0.8059757351875305,
-0.1766670048236847,
0.7361950278282166,
0.4296218454837799,
-0.1884406954050064,
-0.18254981935024261,
-0.7617917656898499,
0.6573271155357361,
-0.4350588023662567,
1.1475707292556763,
-0.4437129497528076,
-0.671798050403595,
0.19682767987251282,
-0.3320792317390442,
0.024734532460570335,
-0.6692525744438171,
0.8225290775299072,
-0.5132550597190857,
0.36506548523902893,
-0.650130033493042,
-0.6321086287498474,
0.10692460834980011,
0.6259887218475342,
-0.46710243821144104,
0.9803750514984131,
0.2029888927936554,
-0.7484416961669922,
0.4729052782058716,
-0.5879639983177185,
-0.22980500757694244,
0.2556089162826538,
-0.42404279112815857,
-0.13595247268676758,
-0.01232637744396925,
0.23648077249526978,
0.4002441167831421,
-0.6932772397994995,
0.47260037064552307,
-0.11065801233053207,
-0.07849843055009842,
-0.06130445748567581,
-0.35607385635375977,
0.3269222676753998,
0.3055594265460968,
-0.2665376663208008,
0.16101762652397156,
-0.9323928952217102,
0.311694860458374,
0.19921128451824188,
-0.7640727162361145,
0.08651001006364822,
0.2614273726940155,
-0.4050203263759613,
0.44168123602867126,
0.3431730270385742,
-0.48236197233200073,
0.274370402097702,
-0.4171784520149231,
-0.048152483999729156,
0.6238328814506531,
0.34019917249679565,
0.6769915223121643,
-0.7447987198829651,
0.6208061575889587,
-0.08912768959999084,
-0.2658829391002655,
-0.6627620458602905,
-0.29834699630737305,
-0.7931391000747681,
-0.03636699169874191,
-0.23535823822021484,
0.5532345771789551,
-1.2249265909194946,
0.08914458751678467,
-0.2898308038711548,
-0.4592643678188324,
-0.32375451922416687,
0.18491749465465546,
0.484650582075119,
0.930269181728363,
0.3602258861064911,
0.36081209778785706,
-0.5215052962303162,
-0.527961015701294,
-0.40885627269744873,
-0.2575271725654602,
-0.0873541459441185,
0.6071543097496033,
0.052968088537454605,
0.004362700507044792,
0.9427189230918884,
-0.6567209959030151,
-0.1766497939825058,
-0.6033877730369568,
0.2973172962665558,
0.1624782234430313,
0.19820274412631989,
0.18883799016475677,
-0.7253792881965637,
-0.5825649499893188,
-0.1151413843035698,
-0.5799655914306641,
-0.3310522437095642,
-0.28893768787384033,
-0.24645967781543732,
0.0869332104921341,
0.350607693195343,
-0.7283852100372314,
0.2619934678077698,
0.09117250144481659,
-0.34438270330429077,
0.5622663497924805,
-0.20015932619571686,
0.020982814952731133,
-1.3589719533920288,
0.33483782410621643,
-0.4424484670162201,
0.012124424800276756,
-0.5509079694747925,
0.1532096266746521,
0.08679159730672836,
-0.20768363773822784,
-0.2096952199935913,
0.8756982088088989,
-0.586401104927063,
-0.0802542120218277,
-0.48554787039756775,
0.3449709713459015,
0.21833428740501404,
0.40611734986305237,
-0.059943217784166336,
0.9903626441955566,
0.25983452796936035,
-0.7252989411354065,
0.1547907441854477,
0.3257710039615631,
-0.09067484736442566,
0.5710562467575073,
-0.2528209686279297,
0.013940280303359032,
-0.3384277820587158,
0.03662506490945816,
-0.7804155349731445,
-0.4851810336112976,
0.1770588755607605,
-0.32628679275512695,
0.4155682921409607,
-0.08358309417963028,
-0.33596765995025635,
-0.32156482338905334,
-0.2495487481355667,
-0.1030922457575798,
0.30372992157936096,
-0.5431125164031982,
0.9107333421707153,
0.5076642036437988,
-0.567805290222168,
-0.7376151084899902,
-0.09987188130617142,
-0.08392602950334549,
-0.204008549451828,
-0.7967031598091125,
0.4083431363105774,
-0.11682238429784775,
-0.3010551929473877,
0.006766282021999359,
-0.22433732450008392,
0.014492660760879517,
-0.11365579068660736,
0.05499741807579994,
0.10809221118688583,
-0.13366913795471191,
0.15805937349796295,
0.23857265710830688,
-0.15381114184856415,
0.14004404842853546,
-0.33201444149017334,
0.7401439547538757,
0.6075901389122009,
-0.28625601530075073,
0.33501821756362915,
0.5985255837440491,
0.2747742235660553,
-0.37957799434661865,
0.34948182106018066,
0.40537554025650024,
-0.27484068274497986,
-0.46687549352645874,
-0.6312388777732849,
0.047353100031614304,
-0.4885292649269104,
0.3914097845554352,
-0.5538952946662903,
-0.6342089176177979,
0.4296855926513672,
-0.5753112435340881,
0.5387305021286011,
0.5143080949783325,
0.45835942029953003,
-0.08910379558801651,
0.890852689743042,
0.7063062787055969,
0.3285067677497864,
0.25075313448905945,
-0.17715562880039215,
-0.06433399766683578,
-0.7970775365829468,
-0.40073978900909424,
-0.7098602652549744,
-0.01755412481725216,
-0.1932835429906845,
-0.7066558003425598,
0.1939316987991333,
0.3392665684223175,
-0.026302414014935493,
0.08721235394477844,
-0.22206559777259827,
0.3393729627132416,
0.30319085717201233,
-0.2089141458272934,
0.4041576385498047,
-0.05309056118130684,
-0.3226996958255768,
0.024818379431962967,
-0.8800396919250488,
-0.6412004828453064,
1.185793161392212,
-0.09318210929632187,
0.63145512342453,
-0.05966515094041824,
0.7415264844894409,
-0.16511082649230957,
0.2315293848514557,
-0.5266389846801758,
0.6894041299819946,
-0.02174021489918232,
-0.6643521189689636,
-0.3379659354686737,
-0.5872112512588501,
-0.8214263916015625,
0.1356602907180786,
-0.3251722753047943,
-0.6859076023101807,
0.0722329318523407,
0.22378520667552948,
-0.39287272095680237,
0.2668492794036865,
-0.44461148977279663,
0.6440064311027527,
-0.21308091282844543,
-0.4144150912761688,
-0.25054997205734253,
-0.3765031397342682,
0.30338147282600403,
-0.32509297132492065,
0.0480482317507267,
-0.24153722822666168,
-0.055926449596881866,
0.440357506275177,
-0.2354389876127243,
0.3956892788410187,
-0.3183428943157196,
-0.2238762080669403,
0.5672650933265686,
0.08541589975357056,
0.904608428478241,
0.2227642834186554,
-0.3103638291358948,
-0.6007157564163208,
-0.2871188819408417,
-0.27335214614868164,
-0.455636590719223,
0.6933782696723938,
-0.43716326355934143,
-0.7571209669113159,
-0.042159587144851685,
-0.9309703707695007,
-0.4118562638759613,
0.48345014452934265,
0.5529299974441528,
0.4332609176635742,
-0.2754530906677246,
-0.08078877627849579,
0.9010362029075623,
-0.5272384285926819,
0.48381906747817993,
0.5859993100166321,
-0.4365142285823822,
-0.229488343000412,
1.0071262121200562,
0.13484644889831543,
0.3143450915813446,
0.5431736707687378,
0.04130833223462105,
-0.3901987671852112,
-0.6713591814041138,
-0.5649827122688293,
0.034695617854595184,
-0.6562284231185913,
-0.296867311000824,
-0.9771571755409241,
-0.18395526707172394,
-0.3014291524887085,
-0.20317986607551575,
-0.330923855304718,
-0.4963127374649048,
-0.37032759189605713,
-0.08242157846689224,
0.1387370079755783,
0.6887108683586121,
-0.08883002400398254,
0.2884554862976074,
-0.7454244494438171,
0.6222183704376221,
0.10262066125869751,
0.06252401322126389,
-0.2786135673522949,
-0.35335221886634827,
0.05988824740052223,
0.07211934030056,
-0.4886879324913025,
-0.8038887977600098,
0.39627039432525635,
0.15174074470996857,
0.6763373017311096,
0.23076526820659637,
0.18641437590122223,
0.803635835647583,
-0.5680755972862244,
0.480896919965744,
-0.1255227029323578,
-0.4500501751899719,
0.6583495140075684,
-0.6195067167282104,
0.5055763125419617,
0.667982280254364,
0.24557386338710785,
-0.3550012707710266,
-0.2891623377799988,
-0.5960053205490112,
-1.2562867403030396,
0.7620258331298828,
-0.021794350817799568,
-0.00738369207829237,
-0.11728048324584961,
0.5547584891319275,
0.16692331433296204,
0.4919857680797577,
-0.436575323343277,
-0.16517622768878937,
0.09040506929159164,
-0.06337718665599823,
0.2659277021884918,
-0.5111969113349915,
-0.26070377230644226,
0.36324501037597656,
0.741308331489563,
-0.3483249247074127,
0.3848673701286316,
-0.02881820686161518,
0.046369973570108414,
-0.43855345249176025,
0.3974228501319885,
0.47063329815864563,
1.0251203775405884,
0.0322243757545948,
-0.031651344150304794,
0.20618075132369995,
-0.3875718414783478,
-0.03161883354187012,
0.3297460079193115,
-0.5231885313987732,
-0.019768303260207176,
0.12732850015163422,
0.6505763530731201,
0.11078429222106934,
-0.822083055973053,
0.3668866455554962,
-0.06122394651174545,
-0.183578222990036,
-0.45332443714141846,
0.1868627518415451,
0.287776917219162,
0.2974652051925659,
0.5739097595214844,
0.019737357273697853,
-0.005692624021321535,
-0.420934796333313,
0.3117976486682892,
0.4462268352508545,
-0.09815410524606705,
0.11725201457738876,
0.5187288522720337,
0.2273477166891098,
-0.264837384223938,
0.3979339599609375,
-0.5442619323730469,
-0.2598471939563751,
0.5212856531143188,
0.8021296858787537,
0.7157748937606812,
0.05959346145391464,
0.3842747211456299,
0.5270084142684937,
0.10715897381305695,
-0.13413524627685547,
0.9047169089317322,
0.02494051493704319,
-0.5690373778343201,
-0.8272610306739807,
-0.6764997243881226,
-0.21180512011051178,
0.07089190185070038,
-0.561098575592041,
0.2586148679256439,
-0.23732656240463257,
0.048729851841926575,
-0.5062873363494873,
0.07726769894361496,
-0.47871530055999756,
0.07821161299943924,
-0.08548429608345032,
1.022632360458374,
-0.22315169870853424,
0.6484374403953552,
0.5663099884986877,
-0.26912757754325867,
-1.1721081733703613,
0.3172239363193512,
-0.04064688831567764,
-0.8446582555770874,
0.44661077857017517,
0.01362481340765953,
-0.006266244687139988,
0.2643944025039673,
-0.27226051688194275,
-1.1454081535339355,
1.4126538038253784,
0.2977098524570465,
-0.5695250034332275,
-0.4328879415988922,
0.12494006752967834,
0.22848448157310486,
-0.38491731882095337,
0.02295973338186741,
0.3534214198589325,
0.46663475036621094,
0.530850887298584,
-0.6287567615509033,
-0.0022642193362116814,
-0.044849786907434464,
-0.11905191838741302,
0.2954678237438202,
-0.4008612334728241,
0.7388570308685303,
-0.3548316955566406,
-0.49449923634529114,
0.2719603180885315,
0.4586271345615387,
0.7331758141517639,
0.29496490955352783,
0.22197633981704712,
0.5456418991088867,
0.873428463935852,
-0.11289205402135849,
0.9311677813529968,
-0.5262154936790466,
-0.03828565776348114,
1.297426700592041,
-0.437017023563385,
0.7621037364006042,
0.4312276840209961,
0.2843727767467499,
-0.009409096091985703,
0.3189539611339569,
0.3506419062614441,
0.6994355916976929,
0.1539866179227829,
-0.39485856890678406,
-0.13238860666751862,
-0.328235924243927,
-0.3426608741283417,
0.37513208389282227,
0.5156193375587463,
-0.27506861090660095,
-0.5633819103240967,
-0.08723250031471252,
0.2502512037754059,
0.11401597410440445,
-0.4764697253704071,
0.9815890789031982,
-0.04875177517533302,
-1.2001270055770874,
0.12082050740718842,
0.07054615020751953,
0.3595298230648041,
-0.7786248326301575,
-0.1298510581254959,
-0.28096315264701843,
0.08458558470010757,
0.016628898680210114,
-0.7979877591133118,
0.3336523771286011,
0.25874871015548706,
-0.33163225650787354,
-0.546933114528656,
1.0947455167770386,
-0.5909428000450134,
-0.32635587453842163,
0.1280275136232376,
0.8532639145851135,
-0.2582959830760956,
-0.10483968257904053,
-0.5980667471885681,
-0.07613103836774826,
0.12948071956634521,
-0.3324582278728485,
0.27251869440078735,
0.8279169201850891,
0.09644153714179993,
0.7461689114570618,
0.5883350372314453,
0.18163764476776123,
0.2006865292787552,
-0.2879040837287903,
1.1377079486846924,
-0.49145805835723877,
-0.3995216190814972,
-0.5340610146522522,
0.6303228139877319,
-0.2486734539270401,
-0.35029706358909607,
0.6512578129768372,
0.5977304577827454,
0.7312713861465454,
0.17538242042064667,
0.8177830576896667,
-0.22289244830608368,
0.8393731713294983,
-0.524121105670929,
0.5645394325256348,
-0.4485369622707367,
0.5317748188972473,
-0.26094868779182434,
-1.007242202758789,
0.06580085307359695,
0.3038907051086426,
-0.30767494440078735,
-0.19041545689105988,
0.5961772203445435,
0.8006234765052795,
0.32934361696243286,
-0.10710534453392029,
0.28955236077308655,
-0.052240192890167236,
0.442472904920578,
0.47171923518180847,
0.9259422421455383,
0.02538147009909153,
0.9115141034126282,
-0.16097916662693024,
-0.1340804547071457,
0.13314177095890045,
-0.8915801644325256,
-0.6844417452812195,
-0.46465227007865906,
0.15063215792179108,
-0.18761958181858063,
0.09314810484647751,
0.8248478770256042,
0.33300870656967163,
-0.3269733190536499,
-0.17281481623649597,
-0.2996378242969513,
0.024260520935058594,
0.18002043664455414,
-0.2016696184873581,
0.09926192462444305,
-0.7404235601425171,
-0.4037410020828247,
0.6504725217819214,
0.4523761570453644,
-0.26583290100097656,
-0.2338370829820633,
-0.0896521657705307,
-0.23063354194164276,
0.14048050343990326,
0.4783312678337097,
0.4039077162742615,
-0.41143566370010376,
0.02619211934506893,
0.3683306574821472,
-0.20846286416053772,
0.0033741926308721304,
1.00717294216156,
-0.6544246673583984,
0.5601414442062378,
0.5782642364501953,
0.9214708209037781,
0.6595271229743958,
0.09549526125192642,
0.8717583417892456,
-0.9932959675788879,
-0.0701482817530632,
0.4082973003387451,
0.27724331617355347,
0.18263757228851318,
-0.5161232352256775,
0.46046963334083557,
-0.0738043412566185,
-0.6147738099098206,
-0.5816366672515869,
0.5472272634506226,
-0.5859131813049316,
-0.33241432905197144,
1.3240214586257935,
-0.17032526433467865,
-0.005029267631471157,
-0.2783627510070801,
-0.5598646998405457,
0.1661451905965805,
-0.23739495873451233,
0.7327229380607605,
0.499394953250885,
-0.1895928829908371,
-0.18131040036678314,
-0.6298110485076904,
0.7348810434341431,
0.2908722758293152,
-1.1004937887191772,
0.2940398156642914,
0.6433042287826538,
0.027516791597008705,
0.3432582914829254,
1.1541098356246948,
-0.17284096777439117,
0.1747097223997116,
0.1015656441450119,
-0.06582494080066681,
0.004170650150626898,
-0.4002563953399658,
0.22688229382038116,
0.42644307017326355,
0.3397396206855774,
0.2257479727268219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14972v1 | A Tale of Trust and Accuracy: Base vs. Instruct LLMs in RAG Systems | 2024-06-21T08:31:02 | 2024-06-21T08:31:02 | Florin Cuconasu, Giovanni Trappolini, Nicola Tonellotto, Fabrizio Silvestri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) represents a significant advancement in
artificial intelligence combining a retrieval phase with a generative phase,
with the latter typically being powered by large language models (LLMs). The
current common practices in RAG involve using "instructed" LLMs, which are
fine-tuned with supervised training to enhance their ability to follow
instructions and are aligned with human preferences using state-of-the-art
techniques. Contrary to popular belief, our study demonstrates that base models
outperform their instructed counterparts in RAG tasks by 20% on average under
our experimental settings. This finding challenges the prevailing assumptions
about the superiority of instructed LLMs in RAG applications. Further
investigations reveal a more nuanced situation, questioning fundamental aspects
of RAG and suggesting the need for broader discussions on the topic; or, as
Fromm would have it, "Seldom is a glance at the statistics enough to understand
the meaning of the figures". | [
-0.2274751514196396,
-0.5039061903953552,
0.7646624445915222,
-0.08740474283695221,
-0.16155731678009033,
0.6466357111930847,
-0.027689285576343536,
-0.5773253440856934,
0.02024092897772789,
0.7114586234092712,
-0.17026959359645844,
-0.24359063804149628,
-0.9566813707351685,
0.02232161909341812,
-0.47463199496269226,
1.095856785774231,
0.014603671617805958,
0.21603354811668396,
-0.4902861416339874,
-0.15961900353431702,
-0.44220688939094543,
-0.5897261500358582,
-0.7356290221214294,
-0.933250904083252,
0.1865793764591217,
0.43850767612457275,
0.9363800883293152,
0.7924452424049377,
0.6165422797203064,
0.2400059849023819,
-0.10171948373317719,
0.48255008459091187,
-0.6839048862457275,
0.37233883142471313,
-0.2883218228816986,
-0.8768911361694336,
-0.49993863701820374,
0.24729444086551666,
0.4093520939350128,
0.8574740290641785,
-0.05091537535190582,
0.32740524411201477,
0.09796109795570374,
1.1923365592956543,
-0.8385621905326843,
-0.10254477709531784,
-0.9539836049079895,
-0.19749724864959717,
-0.003288240870460868,
-0.4802713990211487,
-0.8374529480934143,
-0.43541598320007324,
0.17447805404663086,
-0.5614521503448486,
0.36236196756362915,
0.3736784756183624,
0.8630304336547852,
0.37658265233039856,
-0.4888177514076233,
-0.6466119885444641,
-0.8697845935821533,
0.9104689359664917,
-0.14243891835212708,
0.42661571502685547,
0.479478120803833,
0.26076245307922363,
-0.43003442883491516,
-0.8646593689918518,
-0.3856850266456604,
-0.6137163043022156,
-0.15030613541603088,
0.09692151099443436,
-0.10878318548202515,
-0.09963103383779526,
0.4243750274181366,
0.4294734597206116,
-0.4121299386024475,
0.03503495082259178,
-0.10588686168193817,
0.07489598542451859,
0.43675696849823,
0.15647822618484497,
0.13364076614379883,
-0.1565631926059723,
-0.6577655076980591,
-0.26081493496894836,
-1.0444974899291992,
-0.017091087996959686,
0.185062974691391,
0.06595531105995178,
-0.05002567172050476,
0.7798067927360535,
-0.056446753442287445,
0.7904248833656311,
0.6962177157402039,
-0.33046215772628784,
0.11879303306341171,
0.11660593748092651,
-0.29825928807258606,
0.10991699993610382,
0.4524417817592621,
0.39316025376319885,
0.5729062557220459,
-0.28195324540138245,
-0.3915823698043823,
0.15481728315353394,
0.5958840847015381,
-0.4656701385974884,
0.013362645171582699,
-0.15782365202903748,
-0.5143850445747375,
-0.49457329511642456,
0.2596415877342224,
-0.5084545612335205,
-0.666566014289856,
-0.5214576125144958,
0.6004263758659363,
-0.3786648213863373,
-0.18667025864124298,
-0.29555177688598633,
-0.14451420307159424,
0.3863782584667206,
0.26168856024742126,
-0.7609847784042358,
0.4337013065814972,
1.1072115898132324,
0.5535142421722412,
-0.42793577909469604,
-0.07221017777919769,
-0.5136414170265198,
0.19176949560642242,
-0.813279390335083,
0.667693555355072,
-0.5745070576667786,
-0.8042541742324829,
-0.19840511679649353,
-0.19938422739505768,
-0.012457438744604588,
-0.6848245859146118,
0.4415850341320038,
-0.8482939004898071,
0.08182068914175034,
-0.18467861413955688,
-0.6919808387756348,
-0.10311566293239594,
0.21185924112796783,
-0.4887210726737976,
1.0910025835037231,
0.27775102853775024,
-0.7860283851623535,
0.4997197687625885,
-0.37193211913108826,
-0.3144194781780243,
-0.019635608419775963,
-0.2778805196285248,
-0.1747744381427765,
0.19889672100543976,
0.06671501696109772,
0.41966894268989563,
-0.36363092064857483,
0.1511608064174652,
-0.044706087559461594,
-0.5123677253723145,
0.45708033442497253,
-0.5225626230239868,
0.6792795062065125,
0.2489585280418396,
-0.4799340069293976,
-0.21841184794902802,
-0.6346433758735657,
0.0425826758146286,
0.028230946511030197,
-0.1948845237493515,
-0.6432045102119446,
-0.2286933809518814,
-0.5148979425430298,
-0.3013315200805664,
0.47416988015174866,
-0.3034307062625885,
0.040461163967847824,
-0.5973824858665466,
-0.24967706203460693,
0.7400988340377808,
0.03958333656191826,
1.0477962493896484,
-0.6772328615188599,
0.574524998664856,
-0.4425191283226013,
0.08904213458299637,
-0.17207321524620056,
-0.46370929479599,
-0.8264255523681641,
0.07984104752540588,
0.4693240523338318,
0.6141949892044067,
-0.7665815949440002,
0.06553079932928085,
-0.3924138844013214,
-0.5730447769165039,
-0.4594147503376007,
0.02624700963497162,
0.9119729399681091,
0.721558153629303,
0.2715526521205902,
-0.28536567091941833,
-0.5414205193519592,
-0.8460243344306946,
-0.3060457706451416,
-0.28308814764022827,
-0.016861289739608765,
0.4275101125240326,
0.25795087218284607,
-0.1925748586654663,
0.8888610601425171,
-0.19626270234584808,
0.02737344056367874,
-0.17079588770866394,
0.2804568111896515,
0.12871257960796356,
0.48607417941093445,
0.5589781403541565,
-0.9407906532287598,
-0.9209812879562378,
0.246229350566864,
-0.8048142790794373,
0.051083218306303024,
0.056972455233335495,
-0.21655718982219696,
0.5446610450744629,
0.4494841992855072,
-0.5148704648017883,
0.5639768838882446,
0.6865689158439636,
-0.15662412345409393,
0.5800744295120239,
-0.2962847352027893,
0.33938783407211304,
-1.2576481103897095,
-0.04841180145740509,
-0.2842247784137726,
-0.42818984389305115,
-0.533014178276062,
0.14347778260707855,
0.11828648298978806,
0.2997363805770874,
0.03767779469490051,
0.5741419792175293,
-0.7577382922172546,
-0.3832322359085083,
-0.5607329607009888,
-0.11285754293203354,
0.12379626929759979,
0.13851182162761688,
-0.10996095091104507,
1.2129029035568237,
0.41120171546936035,
-0.6316537261009216,
0.2312866598367691,
0.23275208473205566,
-0.16598446667194366,
0.7301757335662842,
-0.4982830584049225,
0.5239914059638977,
0.0159071683883667,
0.0487058162689209,
-0.7637628316879272,
-0.364552766084671,
0.1362561583518982,
-0.8748104572296143,
0.8490824103355408,
-0.4205372631549835,
-0.3300183415412903,
0.017438750714063644,
-0.06541220098733902,
0.04552163928747177,
0.98723965883255,
-0.7234847545623779,
0.8728721141815186,
0.6015505194664001,
-0.008939024060964584,
-1.1829720735549927,
-0.525759220123291,
0.1031852588057518,
-0.11959201097488403,
-0.5027398467063904,
0.2723585367202759,
0.14610011875629425,
-0.7917820811271667,
0.04048984870314598,
-0.3943629562854767,
-0.15802517533302307,
0.04358967766165733,
0.6112805604934692,
0.43493974208831787,
-0.23972831666469574,
0.02676567994058132,
-0.08950233459472656,
-0.15394683182239532,
0.21869082748889923,
0.03391395881772041,
0.5346737504005432,
-0.13502083718776703,
-0.5487508773803711,
-0.14601124823093414,
0.17621837556362152,
0.5336171984672546,
-0.10813073068857193,
0.6416162848472595,
0.19702163338661194,
-0.09608308225870132,
-0.41651609539985657,
-0.7238046526908875,
-0.09597568958997726,
-0.5298148989677429,
-0.0027800684329122305,
-0.42176878452301025,
-0.7899034023284912,
0.23354412615299225,
-0.2271791696548462,
0.0033902020659297705,
0.3773626983165741,
0.36827853322029114,
-0.48850393295288086,
1.0349780321121216,
0.7700385451316833,
0.08855313062667847,
0.324018657207489,
-0.24315713346004486,
-0.2162504643201828,
-0.8903824090957642,
-0.24403195083141327,
-0.5901930332183838,
-0.14677368104457855,
-0.751390814781189,
-0.4533141851425171,
0.5500167608261108,
0.16293445229530334,
-0.32507774233818054,
0.03051873669028282,
-0.6788080334663391,
0.5319704413414001,
0.6720285415649414,
0.23526200652122498,
0.45130300521850586,
0.10953900218009949,
0.02062389999628067,
0.0026084682904183865,
-0.7209124565124512,
-0.8298275470733643,
1.4868395328521729,
0.2752246856689453,
1.059547781944275,
-0.1100659966468811,
0.8386929035186768,
0.4651051163673401,
0.6344081163406372,
-0.8381656408309937,
0.5024262070655823,
-0.3578552007675171,
-0.583359956741333,
-0.13184808194637299,
-0.2986887991428375,
-1.1222299337387085,
-0.09700554609298706,
-0.372496098279953,
-0.26675331592559814,
0.1834910660982132,
0.35735058784484863,
-0.12031462043523788,
0.28480398654937744,
-0.6771432161331177,
0.3085395097732544,
-0.3698641359806061,
-0.11866588145494461,
-0.31799623370170593,
-0.8030819296836853,
0.36920464038848877,
-0.06000673770904541,
0.16093049943447113,
0.1791616678237915,
-0.0877700224518776,
0.665501058101654,
-0.2426377683877945,
0.6704637408256531,
-0.1338415890932083,
0.19839568436145782,
0.37141695618629456,
0.39775097370147705,
0.769069492816925,
-0.24571074545383453,
0.00005089653132017702,
-0.2562319040298462,
-0.2293660044670105,
-0.05701642856001854,
-0.7767260074615479,
0.6589641571044922,
-0.7172784209251404,
-0.7748164534568787,
-0.58460932970047,
-0.5139012336730957,
-0.5611951947212219,
0.07418257743120193,
0.30223196744918823,
0.5231589078903198,
-0.22681975364685059,
0.3982045352458954,
1.2606438398361206,
0.00020445157133508474,
0.005445199552923441,
0.31025636196136475,
-0.2932557463645935,
-0.2980537414550781,
0.7469612956047058,
-0.10601670295000076,
0.6145200729370117,
0.37120190262794495,
0.09939111769199371,
-0.18064278364181519,
-0.6304109692573547,
-0.5152978897094727,
0.25725680589675903,
-0.8791221976280212,
-0.2510874569416046,
-0.5457321405410767,
-0.2499651163816452,
-0.24069999158382416,
-0.3379928469657898,
-0.5128203630447388,
-0.4153937101364136,
-0.28669601678848267,
-0.1558331996202469,
0.553134560585022,
1.2619068622589111,
0.028317812830209732,
0.32156282663345337,
-0.8561743497848511,
0.5228303670883179,
0.37648969888687134,
0.16075578331947327,
-0.19127660989761353,
-0.8107602000236511,
-0.2021174281835556,
0.0991402342915535,
-0.07893166691064835,
-0.8924856781959534,
0.1741475611925125,
-0.13661649823188782,
0.8537245988845825,
0.16886356472969055,
0.11096210032701492,
0.6054685115814209,
-0.6063866019248962,
0.6421052813529968,
0.06584103405475616,
-0.7498297691345215,
0.2631082236766815,
-0.16501948237419128,
-0.07423724234104156,
0.5183895230293274,
0.5418605804443359,
-0.0926036462187767,
-0.38300958275794983,
-0.8549593687057495,
-0.5678278207778931,
0.4894297122955322,
-0.12931472063064575,
0.20805098116397858,
0.2058005928993225,
0.49207422137260437,
0.24145948886871338,
0.14925727248191833,
-0.27893227338790894,
-0.5045402646064758,
0.04496359825134277,
-0.15905825793743134,
0.12951049208641052,
-0.5801130533218384,
-0.23899288475513458,
0.17712658643722534,
0.6182674169540405,
0.01790119707584381,
0.26405224204063416,
0.2057880312204361,
-0.15664683282375336,
-0.41030022501945496,
0.18909449875354767,
0.4056583344936371,
1.0120258331298828,
-0.07391341030597687,
0.09605968743562698,
0.2628304362297058,
-0.7261220216751099,
0.16363394260406494,
-0.16405947506427765,
-0.36536461114883423,
0.19794900715351105,
0.3676527738571167,
0.7620771527290344,
0.21095861494541168,
-0.3418915569782257,
0.36331161856651306,
0.1950264722108841,
-0.10659107565879822,
-0.5868797898292542,
0.18003037571907043,
-0.05178835242986679,
0.28373983502388,
0.667768120765686,
0.44137483835220337,
0.1916062980890274,
-0.4548552632331848,
0.31107112765312195,
0.6069532632827759,
-0.2481551319360733,
0.02981642819941044,
0.4991963505744934,
0.05798099935054779,
-0.5047719478607178,
0.2977568209171295,
-0.09711496531963348,
-0.5543549060821533,
0.5345914363861084,
0.410483181476593,
0.8262838125228882,
-0.18329563736915588,
0.21929241716861725,
0.16832378506660461,
0.42882364988327026,
-0.3337680399417877,
0.05599164590239525,
0.1315031796693802,
-0.9475929737091064,
-0.5648617744445801,
-0.6240267157554626,
-1.024864912033081,
-0.12540718913078308,
-0.9190379977226257,
-0.09993535280227661,
-0.46879884600639343,
-0.2930963337421417,
-0.27308037877082825,
0.018921462818980217,
-0.5739433169364929,
0.3458467721939087,
0.06596267223358154,
0.9454486966133118,
-0.4281095564365387,
0.7812727093696594,
0.747348964214325,
-0.11322655528783798,
-1.1706678867340088,
0.09483343362808228,
-0.2265891134738922,
-0.9258871674537659,
0.9552752375602722,
-0.1248718723654747,
-0.5191688537597656,
0.00970508623868227,
-0.7709091305732727,
-0.8982639908790588,
1.087363362312317,
0.36478152871131897,
-0.24438737332820892,
-0.10982505977153778,
-0.12622985243797302,
0.5305649042129517,
-0.61138516664505,
-0.019522853195667267,
0.41361841559410095,
0.39112794399261475,
0.2267894595861435,
-1.2406485080718994,
-0.2653330862522125,
0.1355840414762497,
0.037043847143650055,
0.07874169200658798,
-0.3107224404811859,
0.8761731386184692,
-0.26391735672950745,
-0.24955534934997559,
0.1295751929283142,
0.6540462970733643,
0.5981043577194214,
0.6126481294631958,
0.6106788516044617,
0.3595184087753296,
0.663801908493042,
-0.04009001702070236,
1.418923258781433,
-0.1812453418970108,
-0.05308043956756592,
1.3077001571655273,
-0.2600843608379364,
0.8205632567405701,
0.5068674683570862,
-0.1309223622083664,
0.7023271918296814,
0.2964904010295868,
0.23107115924358368,
0.35113537311553955,
-0.2965293228626251,
-0.14507023990154266,
-0.16384929418563843,
-0.1052808091044426,
-0.34171780943870544,
0.5020950436592102,
0.550575315952301,
-0.6370176672935486,
0.0834340825676918,
-0.1525244116783142,
0.06745106726884842,
0.5846189260482788,
-0.596119225025177,
0.9498708248138428,
0.25856712460517883,
-0.80336594581604,
0.555069625377655,
-0.35211896896362305,
0.6758674383163452,
-0.5302563905715942,
-0.3048771023750305,
-0.07691403478384018,
0.08969007432460785,
-0.15157881379127502,
-0.8826916217803955,
0.3021320402622223,
0.19634325802326202,
-0.33851224184036255,
-0.395351767539978,
1.1163007020950317,
-0.0687132477760315,
-0.203129380941391,
0.22256197035312653,
0.8851666450500488,
0.15028029680252075,
0.1494324654340744,
-0.618289053440094,
-0.00898384302854538,
-0.013334540650248528,
-0.3979050815105438,
0.30535995960235596,
0.6052559018135071,
-0.2237514853477478,
0.8128703236579895,
0.7007149457931519,
0.16882158815860748,
0.2308967411518097,
-0.1704639047384262,
0.7850382924079895,
-0.31823620200157166,
-0.1618928760290146,
-0.5851913690567017,
0.44915512204170227,
-0.19932310283184052,
0.02238551340997219,
0.9392606019973755,
0.38458511233329773,
1.0101649761199951,
-0.1320294588804245,
0.8435752987861633,
0.058470219373703,
1.2093722820281982,
-0.6171325445175171,
0.8528516292572021,
-0.3614940047264099,
0.09495468437671661,
0.097535140812397,
-0.8668538331985474,
-0.005917300935834646,
0.6017271280288696,
-0.35072287917137146,
0.18747034668922424,
0.5559443235397339,
0.7932872772216797,
0.0061924150213599205,
-0.1763630360364914,
0.44709718227386475,
0.12454842031002045,
-0.12689043581485748,
0.042884211987257004,
1.040054440498352,
-0.13051344454288483,
0.45272767543792725,
-0.41591688990592957,
-0.30313971638679504,
-0.14683765172958374,
-0.715173602104187,
-0.9877597689628601,
-0.33432736992836,
0.15095758438110352,
-0.5195167064666748,
0.2830680012702942,
1.1166294813156128,
0.5280588865280151,
-0.8623976111412048,
-0.3480987846851349,
0.031385794281959534,
0.1080351173877716,
-0.010658642277121544,
-0.1822996437549591,
0.23274734616279602,
-0.44225233793258667,
-0.8531799912452698,
0.6279898285865784,
-0.007859444245696068,
0.08922191709280014,
-0.2664220631122589,
-0.35006609559059143,
-0.0557851567864418,
-0.0011494617210701108,
0.4538610577583313,
0.12157964706420898,
-0.7196900844573975,
-0.24554356932640076,
0.3825659155845642,
-0.5309889316558838,
0.030467629432678223,
0.759907603263855,
-0.9337036609649658,
0.4346192181110382,
0.4838338792324066,
0.8030471205711365,
0.38260242342948914,
0.4277248978614807,
0.7691537141799927,
-0.6538336873054504,
-0.10431843996047974,
0.44010642170906067,
0.20053105056285858,
0.5041472911834717,
-0.6256450414657593,
0.7695925831794739,
0.1330353319644928,
-0.8960864543914795,
-1.0013720989227295,
0.3283703327178955,
-1.0081192255020142,
-0.11161967366933823,
1.1626616716384888,
-0.09967247396707535,
-0.2850642204284668,
-0.2125880867242813,
-0.2781974673271179,
0.30365610122680664,
-0.34048035740852356,
0.6670007109642029,
0.4357474446296692,
-0.2424088418483734,
-0.07912734150886536,
-0.6138622164726257,
0.7370790243148804,
0.47899723052978516,
-0.3264924883842468,
-0.12854880094528198,
0.5236659049987793,
0.31907224655151367,
0.41649726033210754,
0.5510693788528442,
-0.035407137125730515,
0.3608931601047516,
0.07450290024280548,
0.0049064876511693,
-0.2853957414627075,
-0.39014706015586853,
-0.23826275765895844,
0.17118948698043823,
0.44316890835762024,
-0.0953189879655838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14971v1 | Domain Adaptation of Llama3-70B-Instruct through Continual Pre-Training and Model Merging: A Comprehensive Evaluation | 2024-06-21T08:29:31 | 2024-06-21T08:29:31 | Shamane Siriwardhana, Mark McQuade, Thomas Gauthier, Lucas Atkins, Fernando Fernandes Neto, Luke Meyers, Anneketh Vij, Tyler Odenthal, Charles Goddard, Mary MacCarthy, Jacob Solawetz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We conducted extensive experiments on domain adaptation of the
Meta-Llama-3-70B-Instruct model on SEC data, exploring its performance on both
general and domain-specific benchmarks. Our focus included continual
pre-training (CPT) and model merging, aiming to enhance the model's
domain-specific capabilities while mitigating catastrophic forgetting. Through
this study, we evaluated the impact of integrating financial regulatory data
into a robust language model and examined the effectiveness of our model
merging techniques in preserving and improving the model's instructive
abilities. The model is accessible at hugging face:
https://huggingface.co/arcee-ai/Llama-3-SEC-Base, arcee-ai/Llama-3-SEC-Base.
This is an intermediate checkpoint of our final model, which has seen 20B
tokens so far. The full model is still in the process of training. This is a
preprint technical report with thorough evaluations to understand the entire
process. | [
-0.21065378189086914,
-0.71645188331604,
0.33021873235702515,
0.35736334323883057,
-0.4786490201950073,
0.29515668749809265,
0.0028691368643194437,
-0.8275250196456909,
-0.06994763761758804,
0.7342968583106995,
-0.32135891914367676,
-0.36095795035362244,
-0.6105725765228271,
-0.02698870562016964,
-0.5479864478111267,
1.2574694156646729,
-0.34337443113327026,
0.13179908692836761,
-0.12822116911411285,
0.22772973775863647,
-0.5647491812705994,
-0.8420006632804871,
-0.6735446453094482,
-0.16816961765289307,
-0.09159621596336365,
0.2582455277442932,
0.2516016662120819,
0.36191636323928833,
0.8032251596450806,
0.2328345626592636,
-0.08327361196279526,
-0.12200713902711868,
-0.5551128387451172,
-0.30706414580345154,
-0.23443211615085602,
-0.3746911585330963,
-1.0692719221115112,
0.1217273399233818,
0.7113986015319824,
0.6596096754074097,
-0.4994387924671173,
0.26701536774635315,
0.37312591075897217,
0.49729663133621216,
-0.5185443162918091,
0.23611553013324738,
-0.7010582685470581,
-0.2703137993812561,
-0.25491124391555786,
-0.08893094956874847,
-0.5720978379249573,
-0.43658608198165894,
0.5569390058517456,
-0.45265334844589233,
0.13361552357673645,
0.1163477972149849,
0.8951839208602905,
0.14306902885437012,
-0.6042607426643372,
-0.2032395452260971,
-0.5885613560676575,
0.4350131154060364,
-0.7295914888381958,
0.28771984577178955,
0.47758880257606506,
0.1574963629245758,
-0.03854402154684067,
-0.9809343814849854,
-0.337186336517334,
-0.299936443567276,
0.28292062878608704,
0.07191549986600876,
-0.4830402433872223,
0.03355390578508377,
-0.12444879859685898,
0.20311394333839417,
-0.18828661739826202,
0.15686403214931488,
-0.5880016088485718,
-0.3865297734737396,
0.44987624883651733,
0.0024339703377336264,
-0.022583745419979095,
0.20464783906936646,
-0.6538386344909668,
-0.23297686874866486,
-0.9448800086975098,
-0.11368607729673386,
0.3674968481063843,
0.1849522441625595,
-0.32758086919784546,
0.3748748302459717,
-0.08158979564905167,
0.5563839673995972,
0.22318494319915771,
-0.0812806710600853,
0.41118186712265015,
-0.4579876661300659,
-0.3928142189979553,
0.06499495357275009,
0.4603540897369385,
0.3184100389480591,
0.247169628739357,
0.0360378660261631,
-0.44386452436447144,
-0.07546494156122208,
0.4362960159778595,
-0.6291508674621582,
-0.16349847614765167,
-0.017610488459467888,
-0.5696017146110535,
-0.15413056313991547,
0.1383151412010193,
-0.5045400857925415,
-0.16571751236915588,
-0.4990861415863037,
0.6122256517410278,
-0.4569799304008484,
-0.31327831745147705,
0.43116867542266846,
0.05139391869306564,
0.43270593881607056,
0.44802120327949524,
-0.7260552048683167,
0.6075142025947571,
0.7929085493087769,
0.7544234395027161,
-0.25948572158813477,
-0.39560559391975403,
-0.3635602593421936,
0.336003839969635,
-0.10069965571165085,
0.9553132653236389,
-0.40751633048057556,
-0.5536965727806091,
-0.11690418422222137,
-0.041154664009809494,
-0.3994700312614441,
-0.7739003300666809,
0.27443376183509827,
-0.7881070375442505,
-0.00953326839953661,
-0.10447477549314499,
-0.4309329390525818,
-0.34386682510375977,
0.2079780101776123,
-0.6870455741882324,
0.6995917558670044,
0.4203500747680664,
-0.5368358492851257,
0.2696950435638428,
-0.7728448510169983,
-0.2666488587856293,
0.03140421584248543,
0.4520927667617798,
-0.43060728907585144,
-0.0004399549216032028,
0.10068714618682861,
0.4396279454231262,
-0.4218102991580963,
0.21576738357543945,
-0.5265752673149109,
-0.5365790724754333,
0.27764472365379333,
-0.34505629539489746,
0.46920520067214966,
-0.1050071120262146,
-0.3129851520061493,
0.15482959151268005,
-0.6080407500267029,
-0.4946706295013428,
0.10229279100894928,
-0.027437785640358925,
-0.14735294878482819,
-0.31812748312950134,
0.01797226443886757,
-0.14583633840084076,
0.398000031709671,
-0.10462014377117157,
0.3939458429813385,
-0.09008201211690903,
0.34777191281318665,
0.9464742541313171,
0.23398971557617188,
0.4686560332775116,
-0.3720581829547882,
0.6234686970710754,
0.13549591600894928,
0.5124524235725403,
0.05742980167269707,
-0.26468855142593384,
-0.8072246313095093,
-0.13366173207759857,
0.5337675213813782,
0.6442506909370422,
-0.43272075057029724,
0.2652874290943146,
-0.13399627804756165,
-0.47933995723724365,
-0.1006557047367096,
0.054626915603876114,
0.24519823491573334,
0.3851906359195709,
0.3829428553581238,
-0.8397715091705322,
-0.4228934049606323,
-0.8288494944572449,
0.2349371463060379,
-0.29205381870269775,
0.12466826289892197,
0.029016930609941483,
0.869379460811615,
-0.46513640880584717,
0.5094290375709534,
-0.33092817664146423,
-0.285960853099823,
-0.1503249853849411,
0.08772691339254379,
0.23740197718143463,
0.5535615682601929,
0.8280617594718933,
-0.5393977165222168,
-0.3027704656124115,
0.10912862420082092,
-0.4563167691230774,
0.06271428614854813,
-0.2417660355567932,
-0.28660354018211365,
0.011682756245136261,
0.3780433237552643,
-0.3270741105079651,
0.468661904335022,
0.5184779167175293,
-0.20996522903442383,
0.5985796451568604,
0.01456151157617569,
0.24613642692565918,
-0.9507405161857605,
0.10902518033981323,
-0.29713067412376404,
-0.1730666309595108,
-0.7032158374786377,
-0.21842341125011444,
0.17402614653110504,
0.0019222913542762399,
-0.4991757571697235,
0.5005418062210083,
-0.4370152950286865,
-0.15708403289318085,
-0.3903253376483917,
0.08342178165912628,
-0.19953568279743195,
0.3675783574581146,
0.033589284867048264,
0.9103406071662903,
0.710537314414978,
-0.7456518411636353,
0.15337112545967102,
0.3475506901741028,
-0.3128034770488739,
0.5486056208610535,
-0.48267656564712524,
0.25220054388046265,
0.29565098881721497,
0.4949827194213867,
-0.5390562415122986,
-0.302123486995697,
0.4547916054725647,
0.07139366120100021,
0.41443130373954773,
-0.0658106580376625,
-0.2256024032831192,
-0.24324344098567963,
-0.17044338583946228,
0.5208253860473633,
0.29184311628341675,
-0.5071025490760803,
0.8868440985679626,
0.3986324369907379,
-0.35094189643859863,
-0.6156021952629089,
-0.47488582134246826,
0.21883219480514526,
-0.4306008517742157,
-0.3305259644985199,
0.6722027063369751,
-0.115269735455513,
-0.07603129744529724,
0.1434503197669983,
-0.13151854276657104,
-0.24770395457744598,
0.3052220046520233,
0.2302578091621399,
0.756942629814148,
-0.27446725964546204,
-0.32139965891838074,
0.021541163325309753,
0.02567807398736477,
0.17410340905189514,
-0.2532840669155121,
0.5926554203033447,
-0.39642950892448425,
-0.5656965970993042,
-0.7839874625205994,
-0.03650372102856636,
0.45696571469306946,
-0.23259051144123077,
0.6784288883209229,
0.1616773158311844,
-0.312211811542511,
-0.09077707678079605,
-0.6381562948226929,
-0.020110227167606354,
-0.464550644159317,
0.2873002588748932,
-0.3211227357387543,
-1.1096229553222656,
0.627898097038269,
-0.2444642037153244,
-0.15190757811069489,
0.5999695062637329,
0.570990264415741,
0.13364861905574799,
0.3153012692928314,
1.032395839691162,
-0.1531301736831665,
0.6597375869750977,
-0.2890717387199402,
0.03995173051953316,
-0.8413594961166382,
-0.466644287109375,
-0.31329473853111267,
0.03481961414217949,
-0.2922276556491852,
-0.3657148778438568,
0.21347171068191528,
0.21939536929130554,
-0.37889909744262695,
0.563214898109436,
-0.044315434992313385,
0.5017843246459961,
0.17428259551525116,
0.34869492053985596,
0.10317125916481018,
-0.17768920958042145,
0.31274667382240295,
0.4244539737701416,
-0.446865975856781,
-0.5053492784500122,
1.3529117107391357,
0.5795464515686035,
0.7352016568183899,
0.1151658445596695,
0.7134441137313843,
0.40657100081443787,
0.883772075176239,
-0.4181057810783386,
0.38916921615600586,
-0.04919786751270294,
-0.3975103199481964,
0.1873137503862381,
-0.3560178577899933,
-0.511052131652832,
-0.11146502941846848,
-0.060924921184778214,
-0.721466600894928,
0.3476897180080414,
0.20082932710647583,
-0.4907439649105072,
0.07185547798871994,
-0.6815403699874878,
0.6554587483406067,
-0.422701358795166,
-0.049334991723299026,
-0.3600620925426483,
-0.3926357626914978,
0.8497554659843445,
-0.8442038297653198,
-0.010836022906005383,
-0.10407085716724396,
-0.0796164721250534,
0.871559202671051,
-0.11724992841482162,
1.1534355878829956,
-0.0858660489320755,
-0.24271681904792786,
0.48271802067756653,
-0.03715348616242409,
0.386167049407959,
-0.03715704381465912,
0.05453425645828247,
0.5520186424255371,
0.057954899966716766,
-0.3565812408924103,
-0.38185232877731323,
0.3071364760398865,
-0.7555913329124451,
-0.6940727233886719,
-0.35982638597488403,
-0.3554733395576477,
-0.4430202841758728,
0.016715219244360924,
-0.07719891518354416,
0.2916431128978729,
-0.428593248128891,
0.3292596936225891,
0.3799126148223877,
0.021416837349534035,
0.36846739053726196,
0.459527850151062,
-0.21244089305400848,
-0.7299048900604248,
0.559863269329071,
-0.22055621445178986,
0.4040444791316986,
0.1857682317495346,
0.036996807903051376,
-0.339949369430542,
-0.6572450995445251,
-0.0582033134996891,
0.3550891578197479,
-0.7974844574928284,
-0.5703879594802856,
-0.2720252275466919,
-0.33234861493110657,
-0.3444993793964386,
-0.15507423877716064,
-0.2877294421195984,
-0.2542460262775421,
-0.4567769467830658,
-0.15323343873023987,
0.39708787202835083,
1.1153842210769653,
-0.21880675852298737,
0.8934229016304016,
-1.0008631944656372,
0.010511234402656555,
0.08474085479974747,
0.45611584186553955,
0.08382845669984818,
-0.8468242287635803,
-0.4973284900188446,
-0.09199007600545883,
-0.3269714117050171,
-0.8260604739189148,
0.03142036870121956,
0.35534536838531494,
0.6588393449783325,
0.4400452673435211,
-0.22899964451789856,
0.7864769697189331,
-0.26910173892974854,
0.7181236147880554,
0.24081940948963165,
-1.3600794076919556,
0.2960384786128998,
-0.12280591577291489,
-0.02531379461288452,
0.6401460766792297,
0.3338530957698822,
-0.18903228640556335,
-0.18508030474185944,
-0.48352521657943726,
-0.7675153613090515,
0.6008379459381104,
0.006414595991373062,
0.31598758697509766,
0.11870895326137543,
0.6915945410728455,
0.17231568694114685,
0.17977669835090637,
-0.7470088601112366,
0.16038350760936737,
-0.16569089889526367,
0.007454702164977789,
0.3116443157196045,
-0.41357749700546265,
-0.3122859299182892,
-0.06657864898443222,
0.6677228808403015,
-0.07365892082452774,
0.20479297637939453,
-0.2733825743198395,
-0.1335539072751999,
0.2781650722026825,
-0.10273168236017227,
0.7100898623466492,
0.8203326463699341,
-0.24438349902629852,
-0.21711164712905884,
0.5276315808296204,
-0.8407163023948669,
0.08623897284269333,
0.19245445728302002,
0.2794230580329895,
-0.541709840297699,
0.7910242676734924,
0.7176176309585571,
0.44778549671173096,
-0.5046484470367432,
0.6068143844604492,
-0.21588651835918427,
-0.40617305040359497,
-0.12300236523151398,
0.0779607817530632,
-0.1293638050556183,
0.43565279245376587,
0.43319252133369446,
0.13103872537612915,
0.039962735027074814,
-0.4753047823905945,
0.40487608313560486,
0.33003130555152893,
-0.109160415828228,
-0.48672839999198914,
0.7079312801361084,
0.4052395820617676,
0.24765269458293915,
0.715072512626648,
0.21307975053787231,
-0.7622220516204834,
0.5769956707954407,
0.744172215461731,
1.158976435661316,
-0.20472636818885803,
-0.09629251807928085,
0.12727218866348267,
0.1741095930337906,
-0.32858431339263916,
0.1715967357158661,
-0.30060601234436035,
-0.6388915181159973,
-0.49083876609802246,
-0.5705777406692505,
-0.7283270955085754,
-0.14572854340076447,
-0.8969197869300842,
0.311811625957489,
-0.6222866177558899,
-0.41293665766716003,
-0.29923853278160095,
-0.12903475761413574,
-0.7879584431648254,
0.24246954917907715,
0.18332742154598236,
1.0192129611968994,
-0.8806085586547852,
0.8152003288269043,
0.36155736446380615,
-0.3334692120552063,
-0.7245038747787476,
0.22313395142555237,
-0.0536932572722435,
-0.8952536582946777,
0.6520830988883972,
0.16086873412132263,
-0.34587395191192627,
-0.07309999316930771,
-0.7211354374885559,
-1.0088918209075928,
1.2534897327423096,
0.38771364092826843,
-0.6616127490997314,
0.1561618149280548,
-0.04848100244998932,
0.32926997542381287,
-0.5747901797294617,
-0.016566202044487,
0.8057733178138733,
0.3008328974246979,
0.17273487150669098,
-1.1772030591964722,
-0.18938805162906647,
-0.12698663771152496,
-0.30722635984420776,
0.008810197003185749,
-0.6809388399124146,
0.6071664690971375,
-0.1463382989168167,
-0.21569731831550598,
0.03622669354081154,
0.9340808391571045,
0.23107251524925232,
0.2939523160457611,
0.6856151819229126,
0.3042251169681549,
0.8585145473480225,
-0.06656587868928909,
0.8959510326385498,
-0.49311119318008423,
0.36993178725242615,
1.1213639974594116,
-0.6434107422828674,
1.0492488145828247,
0.26368576288223267,
-0.18550153076648712,
0.49655961990356445,
0.8591393828392029,
-0.07112796604633331,
0.546248197555542,
-0.04700765758752823,
-0.25306206941604614,
-0.013206638395786285,
-0.34706100821495056,
-0.633710503578186,
0.6356903910636902,
0.15918514132499695,
-0.10076640546321869,
0.1506340652704239,
-0.07616198807954788,
0.05953548103570938,
-0.36184942722320557,
-0.1855493187904358,
0.7894319295883179,
0.1808386594057083,
-0.37590405344963074,
0.2774478793144226,
-0.20282861590385437,
0.5132395029067993,
-0.8311030268669128,
0.07683819532394409,
-0.4001883268356323,
0.13819538056850433,
0.08320555090904236,
-0.5736362338066101,
0.27921661734580994,
0.15258869528770447,
0.00462313462048769,
-0.38184791803359985,
0.4046618640422821,
-0.14728865027427673,
-0.3160730004310608,
0.2998184859752655,
0.3190400004386902,
0.0666419118642807,
0.12389025092124939,
-0.5615554451942444,
0.2872176468372345,
-0.02469707652926445,
-0.27115821838378906,
0.389037162065506,
0.2974565923213959,
-0.22772926092147827,
0.5364333391189575,
0.7891277074813843,
0.017773795872926712,
-0.23771198093891144,
0.33576393127441406,
1.1080782413482666,
-0.6405880451202393,
-0.3016015291213989,
-0.7153006792068481,
0.3856147825717926,
0.1382928341627121,
-0.41610386967658997,
0.4243309199810028,
0.5454459190368652,
0.9289723038673401,
-0.14350077509880066,
0.5709941387176514,
0.11630982160568237,
-0.06857079267501831,
-0.7806879878044128,
0.6095761656761169,
-0.45302724838256836,
0.35143721103668213,
-0.2595694661140442,
-1.1880189180374146,
-0.3291458189487457,
0.1712641566991806,
-0.22666004300117493,
0.09293625503778458,
0.6828444600105286,
0.6361814737319946,
-0.07854264974594116,
-0.058652114123106,
0.05389385297894478,
0.0241057351231575,
0.3123270869255066,
0.40457215905189514,
0.8820663094520569,
-0.3714170455932617,
0.447409987449646,
-0.262834757566452,
-0.2862262725830078,
-0.1780748963356018,
-1.108637809753418,
-0.7377864718437195,
-0.46650731563568115,
-0.33262377977371216,
-0.3116035759449005,
-0.2149360030889511,
0.8010742664337158,
0.5368586182594299,
-0.7943507432937622,
-0.3452349603176117,
0.40109312534332275,
-0.270317405462265,
-0.20370496809482574,
-0.09526879340410233,
0.5500884056091309,
-0.0268630962818861,
-0.5738287568092346,
0.5128763318061829,
0.5394432544708252,
0.4389920234680176,
-0.08922894299030304,
-0.029430335387587547,
0.0968388244509697,
0.15458500385284424,
0.49162784218788147,
0.056929752230644226,
-0.4989522695541382,
-0.3261815309524536,
0.0650545209646225,
-0.0381583645939827,
-0.18746015429496765,
0.8766489028930664,
-0.37556394934654236,
0.19996277987957,
0.15752673149108887,
0.8412569761276245,
0.4531834125518799,
0.4134579300880432,
0.7677862048149109,
-0.12407985329627991,
0.03574856370687485,
0.030158093199133873,
0.39721453189849854,
0.22566372156143188,
-0.25506362318992615,
0.6703783273696899,
0.23772726953029633,
-0.6593687534332275,
-0.9493438601493835,
-0.06855576485395432,
-1.1853320598602295,
-0.08350317925214767,
0.9440094828605652,
-0.05798362195491791,
-0.3578394949436188,
0.11186544597148895,
-0.1677371710538864,
0.17966924607753754,
-0.1991736739873886,
0.6624117493629456,
0.7374635338783264,
-0.2820650339126587,
-0.05751199647784233,
-0.45954403281211853,
0.400209903717041,
0.18951895833015442,
-0.9598318338394165,
0.12578681111335754,
0.33094358444213867,
0.3899320960044861,
-0.17383049428462982,
0.6895562410354614,
0.019888686016201973,
0.5255701541900635,
0.04370599240064621,
0.09476283192634583,
-0.006767616607248783,
-0.5012940168380737,
-0.4713374376296997,
-0.09531959891319275,
0.17579776048660278,
-0.0769965872168541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14956v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14956v1 | Unlocking the Global Synergies in Low-Rank Adapters | 2024-06-21T08:10:03 | 2024-06-21T08:10:03 | Zixi Zhang, Cheng Zhang, Xitong Gao, Robert D. Mullins, George A. Constantinides, Yiren Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Low-rank Adaption (LoRA) has been the de-facto parameter-efficient
fine-tuning technique for large language models. We present HeteroLoRA, a
light-weight search algorithm that leverages zero-cost proxies to allocate the
limited LoRA trainable parameters across the model for better fine-tuned
performance. In addition to the allocation for the standard LoRA-adapted
models, we also demonstrate the efficacy of HeteroLoRA by performing the
allocation in a more challenging search space that includes LoRA modules and
LoRA-adapted shortcut connections. Experiments show that HeteroLoRA enables
improvements in model performance given the same parameter budge. For example,
on MRPC, we see an improvement of 1.6% in accuracy with similar training
parameter budget. We will open-source our algorithm once the paper is accepted. | [
-0.2916661500930786,
-0.527917742729187,
0.589651346206665,
0.05934689939022064,
-0.2630869746208191,
-0.3185521960258484,
-0.2726215124130249,
-0.583750307559967,
0.4172481298446655,
0.20660831034183502,
-0.5216746926307678,
-0.26466503739356995,
-0.32669147849082947,
-0.13077135384082794,
0.2088620960712433,
0.7635843753814697,
0.21322442591190338,
-0.10813374817371368,
0.3756497800350189,
-0.6874556541442871,
-0.604145348072052,
-0.047474589198827744,
-0.31979283690452576,
-0.3726925849914551,
1.3092612028121948,
0.8793909549713135,
1.0477334260940552,
0.6996150016784668,
0.22188512980937958,
0.20379270613193512,
-0.370919793844223,
0.2128618359565735,
-0.7519431710243225,
0.00695411954075098,
-0.5848787426948547,
-0.6873226165771484,
-0.6374607682228088,
0.2239212542772293,
0.8038796782493591,
0.8170228004455566,
-0.24793945252895355,
0.4527067244052887,
-0.272445410490036,
0.6332866549491882,
-1.0269901752471924,
-0.2084338515996933,
-1.2854408025741577,
-0.08460990339517593,
-0.41715875267982483,
-0.38391798734664917,
-0.10237610340118408,
-0.2807576656341553,
0.006437236443161964,
-0.7859361171722412,
-0.03342953696846962,
0.06622488796710968,
0.8499597907066345,
0.38216960430145264,
-0.0007588390144519508,
-0.057154446840286255,
-0.7636017203330994,
0.7996593117713928,
-0.8238039612770081,
0.5289633274078369,
-0.017781931906938553,
0.47284379601478577,
-0.16011646389961243,
-0.5602649450302124,
-0.5511751770973206,
0.22643326222896576,
0.16064061224460602,
-0.07745537906885147,
-0.21482400596141815,
-0.029736747965216637,
0.02504635788500309,
0.4220178723335266,
-0.20171654224395752,
0.5580157041549683,
-0.5640860795974731,
0.16934050619602203,
0.31538125872612,
-0.04128110408782959,
0.25767433643341064,
0.11670416593551636,
0.038987066596746445,
-0.06990561634302139,
-0.8094308972358704,
-0.16735787689685822,
0.5498251914978027,
0.9846673607826233,
-0.14209237694740295,
0.46303966641426086,
-0.29260411858558655,
0.8896251916885376,
-0.1187310591340065,
-0.06651544570922852,
0.045544806867837906,
-0.12940451502799988,
-0.22237913310527802,
0.19430039823055267,
0.20963121950626373,
-0.09900486469268799,
-0.006971638649702072,
-0.14084431529045105,
-0.019557438790798187,
0.10199318081140518,
0.03957177698612213,
-0.8885293006896973,
-0.2166547179222107,
-0.08874757587909698,
-0.4564428925514221,
-0.11770102381706238,
-0.09462311118841171,
-0.9255788326263428,
-0.27771449089050293,
-0.1280318796634674,
0.5068129301071167,
0.005289447493851185,
0.11362090706825256,
0.11515858769416809,
-0.06594127416610718,
0.23456694185733795,
0.4470347762107849,
-1.0780185461044312,
0.22901302576065063,
0.6003025770187378,
1.0048664808273315,
-0.019250858575105667,
-0.4781522750854492,
-1.1529436111450195,
0.1072976216673851,
-0.22546294331550598,
0.9306619763374329,
-0.6721751093864441,
-0.045226890593767166,
-0.10664444416761398,
0.11798730492591858,
-0.43399837613105774,
-0.5356404781341553,
0.58611661195755,
-0.6484120488166809,
0.3412623703479767,
-0.24761609733104706,
-0.1598432958126068,
0.10062013566493988,
-0.09883473813533783,
-0.86460280418396,
0.6571475863456726,
0.43672361969947815,
-0.6935060620307922,
0.1828763484954834,
-0.8308643102645874,
-0.2603473663330078,
-0.06841860711574554,
0.05435994639992714,
-0.41263383626937866,
0.34482449293136597,
0.1767185926437378,
0.004158704541623592,
-0.49943143129348755,
-0.27493470907211304,
-0.5907977819442749,
-0.7880695462226868,
-0.2861350476741791,
-0.2469612956047058,
0.7304798364639282,
0.3365626633167267,
-0.0015148536767810583,
0.28622815012931824,
-0.7797747254371643,
0.20177461206912994,
0.13506118953227997,
-0.6598742008209229,
-0.5460445284843445,
-0.057047177106142044,
0.0813765823841095,
0.24700534343719482,
0.2301524579524994,
-0.28036102652549744,
0.47472384572029114,
-0.8025857210159302,
0.4031067192554474,
0.860964834690094,
-0.14533282816410065,
0.5488483309745789,
-0.035366304218769073,
0.41662701964378357,
-0.2349477857351303,
0.33211448788642883,
0.3181608021259308,
-0.5694131255149841,
-0.745098888874054,
-0.20170488953590393,
0.2893836200237274,
0.17614704370498657,
-0.6521321535110474,
0.27431970834732056,
-0.2264547049999237,
-0.7802647948265076,
-0.8470960855484009,
0.46911898255348206,
0.24226386845111847,
0.26014211773872375,
0.40178030729293823,
-0.0750068798661232,
-0.26401618123054504,
-0.884375810623169,
-0.5684681534767151,
-0.062281522899866104,
0.22585007548332214,
0.23265713453292847,
0.19787096977233887,
-0.5165590047836304,
0.7170366644859314,
-0.6136485934257507,
-0.5663455128669739,
-0.22835089266300201,
-0.19103823602199554,
0.6967536807060242,
0.41812509298324585,
0.9354881048202515,
-0.6546199917793274,
-0.6063238978385925,
0.23826871812343597,
-0.344596266746521,
-0.16036000847816467,
0.40087780356407166,
-0.21273337304592133,
0.12341839075088501,
0.4714963138103485,
-0.17778202891349792,
0.23621727526187897,
1.0311607122421265,
-0.625408947467804,
0.06986841559410095,
-0.5028841495513916,
-0.3662853240966797,
-0.9427469372749329,
0.3749937117099762,
-0.20990154147148132,
-0.1549210250377655,
-0.5451270341873169,
0.24007922410964966,
-0.08470959216356277,
-0.1562892496585846,
-0.5467600226402283,
0.8375018835067749,
-0.5476335883140564,
-0.31305229663848877,
-0.3414326310157776,
0.5092647671699524,
-0.19331127405166626,
0.5688132047653198,
-0.43539223074913025,
0.9115720987319946,
0.27331191301345825,
-0.45512354373931885,
0.09560027718544006,
0.1726401001214981,
-0.2934322953224182,
0.5017523169517517,
-0.46955105662345886,
0.14175309240818024,
0.07459200173616409,
0.06536844372749329,
-0.6051686406135559,
-0.08709514886140823,
0.08348549902439117,
0.26300978660583496,
-0.2567654252052307,
-0.38172176480293274,
-0.41408801078796387,
-0.05450084060430527,
-0.37969547510147095,
0.5721054673194885,
0.4538869559764862,
-0.9561911821365356,
0.4794822633266449,
0.2773497700691223,
-0.10640744119882584,
-0.23486723005771637,
-0.2929803729057312,
-0.24865250289440155,
-0.1816231608390808,
-0.21023692190647125,
0.4274100363254547,
-0.3114096522331238,
-0.051658745855093,
-0.15019142627716064,
-0.1652117371559143,
0.13307160139083862,
0.4457145035266876,
0.13379095494747162,
0.17756310105323792,
-0.5051820278167725,
-0.15021510422229767,
0.0011300321202725172,
-0.1424373984336853,
-0.5437027812004089,
-0.40285560488700867,
0.6847952604293823,
-0.30012810230255127,
-0.49868103861808777,
-0.3891299068927765,
-0.043322060257196426,
0.6500625014305115,
-0.09797529131174088,
0.9127371907234192,
0.5528648495674133,
-0.19233828783035278,
-0.5424646139144897,
-0.30744463205337524,
-0.09393619000911713,
-0.540630578994751,
0.2913214862346649,
-0.3274534046649933,
-0.6742405295372009,
0.671212375164032,
-0.12040353566408157,
-0.07393623143434525,
0.47373196482658386,
0.44003909826278687,
0.3914056122303009,
0.8460696339607239,
0.9423668384552002,
-0.39998218417167664,
0.8574867248535156,
-0.015100015327334404,
0.38704654574394226,
-0.8445470929145813,
0.22223320603370667,
-0.8350878357887268,
-0.6305327415466309,
-0.90604168176651,
-0.6011488437652588,
0.6072044968605042,
0.27621331810951233,
-0.10059069842100143,
0.33671674132347107,
-0.46314993500709534,
0.8241133689880371,
0.5944849848747253,
0.0030240104533731937,
0.5167548656463623,
0.04205518215894699,
-0.000787709781434387,
0.07835061848163605,
-1.092678427696228,
-0.08534674346446991,
0.8408187031745911,
0.3269873261451721,
0.811095654964447,
0.43321338295936584,
0.5838128328323364,
-0.00012505495396908373,
0.3131183087825775,
-0.6270638704299927,
0.35989949107170105,
-0.5334762930870056,
-0.4643794596195221,
-0.4970943331718445,
-0.442155659198761,
-0.8629072308540344,
0.5678532719612122,
-0.19789019227027893,
-1.026411771774292,
0.6148608922958374,
0.2706710696220398,
-0.4181487560272217,
0.5071026682853699,
-0.5409682393074036,
0.8397161960601807,
-0.10949966311454773,
-0.4983258545398712,
-0.4038500487804413,
-0.4357253313064575,
0.1795068234205246,
-0.15940336883068085,
0.09045515209436417,
-0.2618076503276825,
0.12321767210960388,
0.6322762370109558,
-0.27296435832977295,
0.5035891532897949,
-0.3688282370567322,
-0.5675972700119019,
-0.2053052932024002,
-0.008750327862799168,
0.6231566667556763,
0.10556218028068542,
-0.5968557000160217,
-0.1141292154788971,
0.05626806616783142,
-0.7333651185035706,
-0.6006407737731934,
1.0776981115341187,
-0.8949901461601257,
-0.3827660381793976,
-0.18870984017848969,
-0.7406331896781921,
-0.44911277294158936,
0.38252735137939453,
0.13370342552661896,
0.11430481821298599,
-0.29483550786972046,
0.12237748503684998,
0.4941260814666748,
-0.34169813990592957,
0.25880008935928345,
0.6925886869430542,
-0.2436472773551941,
-0.2708326280117035,
1.1216129064559937,
0.04186684265732765,
0.5061278343200684,
0.1694716364145279,
0.4611165225505829,
0.2117280662059784,
-0.46102631092071533,
-0.41552290320396423,
0.3725319802761078,
-0.8463634252548218,
-0.22634194791316986,
-0.2255159467458725,
-0.12503676116466522,
-0.1976897269487381,
-0.2519476115703583,
-0.6746706962585449,
-0.5076367259025574,
-0.2768341898918152,
0.39938563108444214,
0.21856153011322021,
0.5519792437553406,
-0.06651180237531662,
0.5650106072425842,
-0.2613910436630249,
0.6494885087013245,
0.5827457308769226,
0.7014825344085693,
-0.0007823270279914141,
-0.6502076387405396,
-0.5452484488487244,
0.029088670387864113,
0.002212373074144125,
-0.5612102150917053,
0.1860782653093338,
0.5725772380828857,
0.567975640296936,
0.35947927832603455,
0.017950208857655525,
0.9548661112785339,
-0.4184272289276123,
0.40282201766967773,
-0.03327934816479683,
-0.7920755743980408,
0.4884638786315918,
-0.38741475343704224,
0.544076681137085,
0.7711362242698669,
-0.14449208974838257,
-0.40053272247314453,
-0.15560594201087952,
-0.40661197900772095,
-0.8122410178184509,
1.0318350791931152,
0.05232547968626022,
0.03733567148447037,
0.535868227481842,
0.45986998081207275,
-0.08889305591583252,
-0.04430210962891579,
-0.6251842379570007,
-0.29154065251350403,
0.014126215130090714,
-0.051499634981155396,
-0.20814667642116547,
-0.03974831476807594,
-0.2942158579826355,
-0.5020684003829956,
0.8910403251647949,
-0.7367055416107178,
0.11008816957473755,
-0.05714493244886398,
0.01990867406129837,
-0.6038891673088074,
0.39696556329727173,
0.47790417075157166,
0.632490873336792,
-0.49651509523391724,
0.16788844764232635,
0.4058511257171631,
-0.2169930338859558,
-0.052629269659519196,
0.3237266540527344,
-0.20465998351573944,
-0.011198177933692932,
0.3299814760684967,
0.8725413084030151,
0.5130931735038757,
-0.5931130647659302,
0.24696744978427887,
-0.12417923659086227,
-0.0322728231549263,
0.3149667978286743,
0.5470688343048096,
0.12131348997354507,
0.3527929186820984,
0.11148771643638611,
-0.007569448556751013,
-0.16742251813411713,
-0.9739019870758057,
-0.1256459504365921,
0.49137094616889954,
-0.38571566343307495,
-0.5152512192726135,
0.57912278175354,
0.08919772505760193,
-0.253226637840271,
0.22951389849185944,
0.05518422648310661,
-0.42321228981018066,
0.27064037322998047,
0.7279817461967468,
0.7014214396476746,
-0.21820473670959473,
0.15181544423103333,
-0.027084628120064735,
0.13157126307487488,
-0.10032810270786285,
0.423735648393631,
0.12439457327127457,
-0.6977620720863342,
0.18251249194145203,
-0.7625149488449097,
-0.41495710611343384,
-0.023668427020311356,
-0.4972277581691742,
0.35488781332969666,
-0.5852298140525818,
0.26070788502693176,
0.2561652362346649,
0.18728339672088623,
-0.6910297274589539,
-0.254031777381897,
0.05878463014960289,
1.0526477098464966,
-0.8943114876747131,
1.2557485103607178,
0.6210058331489563,
-0.3370504379272461,
-0.8609065413475037,
0.22601039707660675,
-0.22322748601436615,
-0.872136652469635,
0.5044468641281128,
-0.15691357851028442,
-0.4404536187648773,
0.08605154603719711,
-0.47492673993110657,
-1.026442050933838,
1.159307599067688,
0.9080631136894226,
-0.5314706563949585,
-0.2823290228843689,
0.08143208920955658,
0.6057257056236267,
-0.34883537888526917,
-0.025414764881134033,
0.6186157464981079,
0.6550533175468445,
-0.10494376718997955,
-1.069347858428955,
-0.020827224478125572,
-0.1952616572380066,
0.10515034198760986,
-0.003320678835734725,
-0.9353069067001343,
1.2722043991088867,
-0.12313944846391678,
-0.16892309486865997,
0.36493000388145447,
0.4866325259208679,
0.38058310747146606,
0.3174421489238739,
0.6129160523414612,
0.39577043056488037,
0.7984076738357544,
0.2633124887943268,
0.6918109059333801,
-0.2832624614238739,
0.35330408811569214,
1.2122844457626343,
-0.6632687449455261,
0.9977715611457825,
0.7856449484825134,
-0.028078235685825348,
0.7639645338058472,
0.20397937297821045,
0.12211744487285614,
0.6970310211181641,
0.16451968252658844,
0.09924931079149246,
-0.20522093772888184,
-0.3057236969470978,
-0.31401920318603516,
0.3784826099872589,
0.12606239318847656,
-0.11410682648420334,
-0.4789366126060486,
-0.11245741695165634,
-0.08174247294664383,
0.2542445659637451,
-0.34673672914505005,
0.7507715225219727,
0.08091598749160767,
-0.7468384504318237,
0.981609046459198,
0.22324654459953308,
0.6684836149215698,
-0.5571901202201843,
0.006612441036850214,
-0.38042789697647095,
0.5976599454879761,
-0.22104907035827637,
-0.09911633282899857,
-0.040556564927101135,
-0.18079382181167603,
-0.22602030634880066,
0.16160407662391663,
0.6876760125160217,
-0.3784545361995697,
-0.48206326365470886,
0.7231853008270264,
0.7160970568656921,
-0.2664649486541748,
-0.12252672016620636,
-0.5602350234985352,
0.2147347629070282,
-0.1453714370727539,
-0.09025900810956955,
0.5332412123680115,
0.4658983051776886,
-0.12019895017147064,
0.6141060590744019,
0.6491684317588806,
0.458072304725647,
0.031087271869182587,
0.11090834438800812,
1.2441457509994507,
-0.6295055150985718,
-0.7705021500587463,
-0.4350273609161377,
-0.07915998250246048,
0.25087374448776245,
-0.24633517861366272,
0.601304292678833,
0.4851643741130829,
0.643269419670105,
0.08125165849924088,
0.4304605722427368,
0.1396932601928711,
0.47532549500465393,
-0.6910499930381775,
0.7348291277885437,
-0.9471558928489685,
0.4691844582557678,
-0.4248753786087036,
-1.1978403329849243,
-0.21130064129829407,
0.4617474377155304,
-0.28210413455963135,
-0.34547650814056396,
0.4236666262149811,
0.8809294700622559,
-0.7463542222976685,
-0.17476752400398254,
0.27571484446525574,
0.12875932455062866,
0.36754110455513,
0.5846564769744873,
0.41739821434020996,
-0.671074390411377,
0.19848468899726868,
0.029425784945487976,
0.12506864964962006,
-0.6637319326400757,
-0.7508543133735657,
-0.7846709489822388,
-0.2812747359275818,
0.02979557029902935,
-0.1088653951883316,
0.42025497555732727,
0.987848699092865,
0.9859923720359802,
-0.7258842587471008,
-0.25269752740859985,
0.042358625680208206,
0.4425373077392578,
-0.2621563971042633,
-0.14521494507789612,
0.297206848859787,
-0.23877812922000885,
-0.7133386731147766,
0.7914351224899292,
0.07570333033800125,
-0.17874009907245636,
-0.3353419303894043,
-0.4212987720966339,
-0.547584593296051,
0.29976886510849,
0.3287166655063629,
0.5877389907836914,
-0.6427134871482849,
-0.32815152406692505,
-0.409180611371994,
0.0055258325301110744,
0.03601274639368057,
0.6936675906181335,
-0.8382241129875183,
0.18733717501163483,
0.42454543709754944,
0.3769480884075165,
0.22677704691886902,
-0.02041402831673622,
0.6275810599327087,
-0.7798922657966614,
0.6943503022193909,
0.016563843935728073,
0.33312278985977173,
0.09244491904973984,
-0.16018147766590118,
0.5905666351318359,
0.1106342151761055,
-0.3851396143436432,
-1.1287840604782104,
0.15829409658908844,
-1.0514719486236572,
-0.5111787915229797,
0.9509531855583191,
0.19986793398857117,
-0.35326042771339417,
0.23225492238998413,
-0.09674285352230072,
0.18250997364521027,
-0.31931188702583313,
0.7032567858695984,
0.004969391040503979,
0.14121855795383453,
-0.016714025288820267,
-0.49553462862968445,
0.6050970554351807,
0.6379240155220032,
-1.030596375465393,
0.1185530424118042,
0.29624587297439575,
0.2182019203901291,
0.3031773567199707,
0.43400701880455017,
0.16501034796237946,
0.2150261104106903,
-0.3666418492794037,
-0.37572944164276123,
0.1633872240781784,
-0.5208572149276733,
-0.5044369697570801,
0.25974929332733154,
0.5237029790878296,
0.16184358298778534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14955v1 | ICLEval: Evaluating In-Context Learning Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T08:06:10 | 2024-06-21T08:06:10 | Wentong Chen, Yankai Lin, ZhenHao Zhou, HongYun Huang, Yantao Jia, Zhao Cao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-Context Learning (ICL) is a critical capability of Large Language Models
(LLMs) as it empowers them to comprehend and reason across interconnected
inputs. Evaluating the ICL ability of LLMs can enhance their utilization and
deepen our understanding of how this ability is acquired at the training stage.
However, existing evaluation frameworks primarily focus on language abilities
and knowledge, often overlooking the assessment of ICL ability. In this work,
we introduce the ICLEval benchmark to evaluate the ICL abilities of LLMs, which
encompasses two key sub-abilities: exact copying and rule learning. Through the
ICLEval benchmark, we demonstrate that ICL ability is universally present in
different LLMs, and model size is not the sole determinant of ICL efficacy.
Surprisingly, we observe that ICL abilities, particularly copying, develop
early in the pretraining process and stabilize afterward. Our source codes and
benchmark are released at https://github.com/yiye3/ICLEval. | [
-0.2173190712928772,
-0.43774640560150146,
0.4722417891025543,
0.4154432415962219,
-0.3443759083747864,
0.3295475244522095,
-0.2280905395746231,
-0.44113636016845703,
-0.6853620409965515,
0.13361574709415436,
-0.17891272902488708,
-0.6004830002784729,
-0.6026607155799866,
-0.041127242147922516,
-0.7136697173118591,
1.1487531661987305,
-0.13537892699241638,
0.28011009097099304,
-0.647566556930542,
-0.08011382818222046,
-0.2746802270412445,
-0.429617702960968,
-0.7061458826065063,
-0.33217284083366394,
0.17126627266407013,
0.424320787191391,
0.08899512887001038,
0.6941828727722168,
0.4605993628501892,
0.15839742124080658,
-0.13263900578022003,
-0.07834258675575256,
-0.7767586708068848,
-0.021451281383633614,
-0.17754244804382324,
-0.32142043113708496,
-0.2850893437862396,
-0.02329283393919468,
1.2837945222854614,
0.6074353456497192,
-0.07038576900959015,
0.4903528392314911,
0.3492160737514496,
0.5560325384140015,
-0.6741921901702881,
0.32016560435295105,
-0.9307831525802612,
0.08375871181488037,
0.009559188969433308,
-0.07334045320749283,
-0.4148287773132324,
-0.3792550265789032,
0.30241674184799194,
-0.5241006016731262,
-0.16806605458259583,
0.18515561521053314,
0.48975229263305664,
0.15614506602287292,
-0.44003620743751526,
-0.5929065942764282,
-0.36143729090690613,
0.7322493195533752,
-0.8412576913833618,
0.3656902313232422,
0.34016093611717224,
0.2215082049369812,
0.13628962635993958,
-0.8912291526794434,
-0.43143758177757263,
-0.7088785171508789,
-0.21903620660305023,
-0.15879082679748535,
-0.06586441397666931,
-0.07128200680017471,
0.5093502402305603,
0.32821688055992126,
-0.3554955720901489,
0.23046979308128357,
-0.2971269488334656,
0.07714007049798965,
0.3249756991863251,
0.06104470044374466,
0.5601856112480164,
0.026289254426956177,
-0.5031841993331909,
-0.09142657369375229,
-0.8409491777420044,
0.3189263343811035,
0.009158684872090816,
0.16964691877365112,
-0.3168247938156128,
0.29472970962524414,
-0.20217984914779663,
0.4254768490791321,
0.2295738011598587,
-0.3153703808784485,
0.49105119705200195,
-0.3078247308731079,
-0.13071255385875702,
0.18787646293640137,
0.5269956588745117,
-0.056027259677648544,
0.15754194557666779,
-0.3067176043987274,
-0.4382714033126831,
-0.5917153358459473,
0.1844884753227234,
-0.8715016841888428,
0.0613858662545681,
-0.17120522260665894,
-0.5490679740905762,
-0.1354147046804428,
0.12231111526489258,
-0.5112250447273254,
-0.2915625274181366,
-0.430530846118927,
0.6176085472106934,
-0.5185607075691223,
-0.10193131864070892,
-0.11566095799207687,
0.1485092043876648,
0.4509747326374054,
0.2256244719028473,
-0.5984824299812317,
0.48566803336143494,
0.9521048069000244,
0.8629468083381653,
-0.42912179231643677,
-0.6468220949172974,
-0.7452054619789124,
0.11943269520998001,
-0.32405775785446167,
0.540174663066864,
-0.46239423751831055,
-0.21602845191955566,
0.003974548075348139,
-0.26792827248573303,
-0.24784672260284424,
-0.7317527532577515,
0.45810195803642273,
-0.7042909264564514,
-0.27546119689941406,
-0.21403847634792328,
-0.6757000684738159,
-0.006322728935629129,
0.18881423771381378,
-0.4245576858520508,
0.9171748161315918,
0.1834511160850525,
-0.6066453456878662,
0.7500628232955933,
-0.4497731328010559,
-0.6407238245010376,
0.26055940985679626,
-0.06479541212320328,
-0.37460801005363464,
0.05828617885708809,
0.01648186519742012,
0.4562617540359497,
-0.4148857891559601,
0.16959017515182495,
-0.2987552881240845,
-0.5542212128639221,
0.1261042356491089,
-0.20365643501281738,
0.6807118654251099,
0.11626887321472168,
-0.6772221922874451,
0.10165025293827057,
-0.7836470603942871,
0.22053733468055725,
-0.14564166963100433,
-0.39634495973587036,
-0.304971843957901,
-0.07392627745866776,
-0.09549734741449356,
0.5681149363517761,
0.3636645972728729,
-0.38144922256469727,
0.15117987990379333,
0.03400026261806488,
0.22900612652301788,
0.6689461469650269,
-0.02936750091612339,
0.464502215385437,
-0.30408918857574463,
0.572458028793335,
0.0029856874607503414,
0.14639265835285187,
0.18498539924621582,
0.17860759794712067,
-0.6689227223396301,
-0.4337924122810364,
0.22772909700870514,
0.45401501655578613,
-0.6470199227333069,
0.30754560232162476,
-0.24344497919082642,
-0.7070257663726807,
-0.4308033883571625,
0.5272061228752136,
0.9677611589431763,
0.31372085213661194,
0.43974703550338745,
-0.19507639110088348,
-0.37020909786224365,
-0.8441483974456787,
-0.3037567138671875,
-0.20573928952217102,
0.13050788640975952,
0.2866186797618866,
0.5344271063804626,
0.07082624733448029,
0.593968391418457,
0.03717798739671707,
-0.4069012999534607,
-0.4918386936187744,
0.1561514437198639,
-0.05478551983833313,
0.6336191296577454,
0.7157041430473328,
-0.5020807385444641,
-0.973227322101593,
0.1769152134656906,
-0.966291069984436,
-0.4261782467365265,
-0.01865515112876892,
-0.09424746781587601,
0.08439578115940094,
1.0855293273925781,
-0.36370909214019775,
0.35819384455680847,
0.3840909004211426,
-0.28020352125167847,
0.4315950870513916,
-0.3821968138217926,
0.11412736028432846,
-0.701664924621582,
0.22785644233226776,
-0.10044777393341064,
-0.12491028010845184,
-0.5640215873718262,
0.24311070144176483,
0.418453574180603,
0.10857120156288147,
-0.5961235165596008,
0.629096269607544,
-0.6095438003540039,
-0.37746667861938477,
-0.0548236183822155,
0.0313095822930336,
-0.41305404901504517,
0.42522042989730835,
-0.2402799427509308,
0.7860116362571716,
0.6702292561531067,
-0.5346658229827881,
-0.1679731160402298,
-0.08141953498125076,
-1.0152620077133179,
0.6905871629714966,
-0.6432194709777832,
0.14114759862422943,
-0.08840757608413696,
0.184586763381958,
-0.8495157957077026,
0.11650808155536652,
0.026409301906824112,
0.025902658700942993,
0.4094606041908264,
-0.19014565646648407,
-0.6510140895843506,
-0.01422012597322464,
-0.06421385705471039,
0.6984458565711975,
0.5271075963973999,
-0.7071595191955566,
0.48022112250328064,
0.292758971452713,
-0.025517696514725685,
-0.6296215057373047,
-0.32350340485572815,
-0.15199142694473267,
-0.19641384482383728,
-0.053385645151138306,
0.2966511845588684,
-0.40498051047325134,
-0.3370163142681122,
-0.035209424793720245,
-0.09124889224767685,
-0.05045019090175629,
0.15472611784934998,
0.28761085867881775,
0.053897008299827576,
-0.21949610114097595,
-0.09680934995412827,
0.11704546213150024,
0.13495475053787231,
0.08865201473236084,
-0.2698178291320801,
0.4941839277744293,
-0.40538913011550903,
-0.5640483498573303,
-0.5846659541130066,
-0.0620429553091526,
0.9974392056465149,
-0.2864011526107788,
0.8174054026603699,
0.3363354802131653,
-0.2269914299249649,
-0.5340260863304138,
-0.500559389591217,
0.15996257960796356,
-0.38186538219451904,
0.6687767505645752,
-0.5454928874969482,
-0.7011638283729553,
0.42022672295570374,
0.15976227819919586,
-0.01346066128462553,
0.2619188725948334,
0.35781198740005493,
0.23554149270057678,
1.1731176376342773,
0.5167258977890015,
-0.203273743391037,
0.6181132197380066,
-0.28299108147621155,
0.12819364666938782,
-1.1215964555740356,
-0.6320086121559143,
-0.46229034662246704,
-0.18781881034374237,
-0.14674700796604156,
-0.2544989585876465,
0.34998759627342224,
0.4482297897338867,
-0.46787551045417786,
0.1919509917497635,
0.06322621554136276,
0.6937451362609863,
0.4170528054237366,
0.1064923107624054,
0.5183389782905579,
0.0035179024562239647,
-0.29704707860946655,
0.13268551230430603,
-0.6929925680160522,
-0.41881120204925537,
0.9801832437515259,
0.2757183909416199,
0.614057183265686,
-0.08836864680051804,
0.5016376376152039,
0.3814638555049896,
0.5769019722938538,
-0.7434239983558655,
0.7205326557159424,
-0.18102897703647614,
-0.2257782220840454,
-0.25491800904273987,
-0.5459818243980408,
-0.5136945843696594,
0.4140188694000244,
-0.19404573738574982,
-0.6240397691726685,
-0.007432085461914539,
0.012021791189908981,
-0.06638327240943909,
0.6251141428947449,
-0.4947696924209595,
0.7699348330497742,
-0.459623247385025,
-0.3020847737789154,
-0.466547429561615,
-0.41186898946762085,
0.2107958048582077,
-0.3623201251029968,
0.12180984020233154,
-0.08099964261054993,
-0.20061582326889038,
0.5756485462188721,
-0.07015616446733475,
0.6243305206298828,
-0.2521747946739197,
-0.034877028316259384,
0.017380602657794952,
0.3234885036945343,
0.17616750299930573,
0.07639829814434052,
-0.14131022989749908,
0.23777873814105988,
0.23446090519428253,
-0.38681694865226746,
-0.5582642555236816,
0.8366923332214355,
-0.9727847576141357,
-0.43224605917930603,
-0.30147695541381836,
-0.39267125725746155,
-0.2708818018436432,
0.3420380651950836,
0.1805364489555359,
0.659728467464447,
-0.29144731163978577,
0.6495223641395569,
0.5843178629875183,
-0.03293044492602348,
0.41556516289711,
0.8043323159217834,
-0.28615081310272217,
-0.1916855424642563,
0.8995361328125,
0.21817906200885773,
0.5683824419975281,
0.42245858907699585,
0.08416535705327988,
-0.07784943282604218,
-0.9898170828819275,
-0.2566085755825043,
0.06784967333078384,
-0.959931492805481,
-0.14259183406829834,
-0.6970483660697937,
-0.49337515234947205,
-0.019409766420722008,
-0.1853555589914322,
-0.23385970294475555,
-0.00037492241244763136,
-0.2628524899482727,
0.0220087468624115,
-0.20519979298114777,
1.1225725412368774,
-0.10671130567789078,
-0.04882517084479332,
-0.519166886806488,
0.1429711878299713,
0.4769076108932495,
0.5122897028923035,
0.7128857970237732,
-0.759480357170105,
-0.4199458956718445,
-0.07415714859962463,
-0.03963635489344597,
-0.11711040884256363,
0.1269841194152832,
0.25301167368888855,
0.97950279712677,
0.30838900804519653,
-0.08052236586809158,
0.6029068231582642,
-0.34331294894218445,
0.5369167327880859,
-0.03282119333744049,
-1.285203218460083,
0.1396167129278183,
-0.08866693824529648,
0.507622241973877,
0.9138814806938171,
0.6368094682693481,
-0.47098466753959656,
-0.3209837079048157,
-0.40640559792518616,
-0.7098830938339233,
0.8345158696174622,
-0.06209131330251694,
-0.05766605585813522,
0.06183391064405441,
0.43157193064689636,
0.16473890841007233,
0.21402835845947266,
-0.844994306564331,
0.011815189383924007,
-0.00009387390309711918,
-0.16357864439487457,
-0.004237059503793716,
-0.3060876429080963,
0.14257746934890747,
-0.4626871943473816,
0.6499192118644714,
-0.1274537444114685,
-0.15513482689857483,
0.016685156151652336,
-0.705977737903595,
-0.10888919234275818,
0.11813182383775711,
0.41439512372016907,
1.2400628328323364,
-0.3314794898033142,
0.004594559781253338,
0.4975006878376007,
-0.4090753197669983,
0.08044921606779099,
-0.0540771447122097,
-0.16436439752578735,
-0.5988844633102417,
0.7809610366821289,
0.7816034555435181,
0.6363047957420349,
-0.931681752204895,
0.729259729385376,
-0.28188613057136536,
-0.1756245344877243,
-0.2386171668767929,
0.07098906487226486,
-0.25378984212875366,
0.3335079252719879,
0.5856624245643616,
-0.13727809488773346,
-0.09655167162418365,
-0.6981958150863647,
0.2941496670246124,
0.5274495482444763,
-0.7343375086784363,
-0.37171828746795654,
0.3375784456729889,
-0.18888846039772034,
-0.3225858807563782,
0.7644042372703552,
-0.1774328052997589,
-0.547038733959198,
0.5994561314582825,
0.8168177008628845,
0.8009205460548401,
0.053432807326316833,
0.04589283466339111,
0.38275372982025146,
0.14958521723747253,
0.06078965589404106,
-0.1530148684978485,
-0.2844759523868561,
-0.5767242908477783,
-0.1959095299243927,
-0.6131923198699951,
-0.244608536362648,
0.2475459724664688,
-0.7902808785438538,
0.19415593147277832,
-0.8704817891120911,
0.46651649475097656,
-0.30868855118751526,
0.06147545948624611,
-0.7946919798851013,
0.04993735998868942,
0.11521697044372559,
0.9957177042961121,
-0.5886828899383545,
0.949736475944519,
0.5789071917533875,
-0.42574241757392883,
-0.7311673760414124,
0.29406261444091797,
-0.06037016957998276,
-0.8543282151222229,
1.1370240449905396,
0.10392125695943832,
-0.17419634759426117,
0.13877986371517181,
-0.5654597282409668,
-0.8758360147476196,
1.3048577308654785,
0.3540503680706024,
-0.4161170721054077,
-0.07270167022943497,
-0.02417536824941635,
0.7165864109992981,
-0.8862287998199463,
0.43325939774513245,
0.6867585182189941,
0.1510610580444336,
0.09850103408098221,
-1.096030592918396,
0.06195959448814392,
-0.29341843724250793,
-0.12990246713161469,
-0.04858831316232681,
-0.6325021982192993,
0.8437042236328125,
-0.1278497278690338,
-0.21606673300266266,
0.29191160202026367,
0.42779332399368286,
0.2644932270050049,
-0.0030753365717828274,
0.7798062562942505,
0.5826392769813538,
0.5559349656105042,
0.22226423025131226,
1.19016432762146,
-0.4798992872238159,
0.20660416781902313,
1.1082372665405273,
-0.4295106530189514,
1.126150369644165,
0.20259983837604523,
0.15227296948432922,
0.6128299832344055,
0.293509840965271,
0.31031957268714905,
0.673178493976593,
0.3164164423942566,
-0.26741859316825867,
-0.20099855959415436,
-0.10545597970485687,
-0.43473348021507263,
0.42725199460983276,
0.18634361028671265,
-0.34549957513809204,
-0.16361145675182343,
0.09604135900735855,
0.092301145195961,
-0.012681766413152218,
-0.5820894837379456,
1.0297009944915771,
0.059238508343696594,
-0.7130544781684875,
0.6534374952316284,
-0.4350367486476898,
0.4747566282749176,
-0.7568854689598083,
-0.15707097947597504,
-0.13486798107624054,
0.27648207545280457,
0.032403383404016495,
-0.8128249645233154,
-0.169632226228714,
-0.12565521895885468,
-0.18696533143520355,
-0.3064270615577698,
0.40813568234443665,
-0.5047696828842163,
-0.24708928167819977,
0.6587140560150146,
0.37268465757369995,
-0.08741827309131622,
0.2715011239051819,
-0.7500893473625183,
-0.1041472926735878,
-0.040392763912677765,
0.0006289624143391848,
0.705100953578949,
0.4253273606300354,
-0.026222266256809235,
0.8243395686149597,
0.5982670783996582,
0.3361092209815979,
0.009397466666996479,
0.13949750363826752,
0.7452567219734192,
-0.37746894359588623,
-0.2903252840042114,
-0.8274962306022644,
0.2576572895050049,
-0.03492261469364166,
-0.5129587054252625,
0.8707058429718018,
0.6003366112709045,
1.2747236490249634,
-0.12397635728120804,
0.8044140338897705,
-0.16250069439411163,
0.28908640146255493,
-0.6303712725639343,
0.7952859401702881,
-0.6268590688705444,
0.3309510350227356,
-0.4785391092300415,
-1.1457841396331787,
-0.19388240575790405,
0.4721088707447052,
-0.5898047089576721,
-0.008805660530924797,
0.9127338528633118,
0.5509121417999268,
-0.3167065382003784,
-0.1780421882867813,
0.45177698135375977,
0.2583143413066864,
0.3311382532119751,
0.5455116629600525,
1.152097225189209,
-0.12495406717061996,
0.4420868754386902,
-0.30275654792785645,
-0.47697317600250244,
-0.10424819588661194,
-1.0534580945968628,
-1.127022624015808,
-0.7106464505195618,
-0.0979543924331665,
-0.1946781724691391,
0.02718132548034191,
1.306596040725708,
0.9054145812988281,
-0.7465399503707886,
-0.6516867876052856,
-0.02787807397544384,
0.11071723699569702,
-0.2308422327041626,
-0.17403097450733185,
0.5018056631088257,
-0.57878178358078,
-0.5203593373298645,
0.4017162621021271,
0.29710617661476135,
-0.03793962299823761,
-0.23528870940208435,
-0.2048768550157547,
-0.3497558534145355,
-0.15878982841968536,
0.7803055644035339,
0.34057900309562683,
-0.4306478202342987,
-0.13655342161655426,
-0.43610483407974243,
-0.24814282357692719,
-0.1298433393239975,
1.0407449007034302,
-0.6469278335571289,
0.4077301323413849,
0.5139816403388977,
0.6610960960388184,
0.44072225689888,
-0.07918199151754379,
0.5269441604614258,
-0.3215237855911255,
0.1437578797340393,
0.12438252568244934,
0.47137531638145447,
0.29885074496269226,
-0.04018503800034523,
0.2641957402229309,
-0.01623832993209362,
-0.6222532391548157,
-0.8290629982948303,
-0.13450610637664795,
-0.5987791419029236,
-0.19171489775180817,
1.0857696533203125,
-0.40541312098503113,
0.0772457867860794,
-0.005708290264010429,
-0.17973743379116058,
0.06729746609926224,
-0.2388262003660202,
0.748321533203125,
0.580365002155304,
0.1889362633228302,
-0.05849713832139969,
-0.5603380799293518,
0.722690999507904,
0.3824737071990967,
-0.785624086856842,
-0.07392352819442749,
0.1652459353208542,
0.4466550946235657,
-0.23423777520656586,
0.3517444431781769,
-0.24229760468006134,
0.3218669891357422,
-0.30822333693504333,
-0.17506271600723267,
-0.03785107657313347,
-0.5573251247406006,
-0.4885571599006653,
0.23057685792446136,
0.45716139674186707,
0.3864918649196625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14952v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14952v2 | ESC-Eval: Evaluating Emotion Support Conversations in Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T08:03:33 | 2024-06-24T12:24:52 | Haiquan Zhao, Lingyu Li, Shisong Chen, Shuqi Kong, Jiaan Wang, Kexin Huang, Tianle Gu, Yixu Wang, Dandan Liang, Zhixu Li, Yan Teng, Yanghua Xiao, Yingchun Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion Support Conversation (ESC) is a crucial application, which aims to
reduce human stress, offer emotional guidance, and ultimately enhance human
mental and physical well-being. With the advancement of Large Language Models
(LLMs), many researchers have employed LLMs as the ESC models. However, the
evaluation of these LLM-based ESCs remains uncertain. Inspired by the awesome
development of role-playing agents, we propose an ESC Evaluation framework
(ESC-Eval), which uses a role-playing agent to interact with ESC models,
followed by a manual evaluation of the interactive dialogues. In detail, we
first re-organize 2,801 role-playing cards from seven existing datasets to
define the roles of the role-playing agent. Second, we train a specific
role-playing model called ESC-Role which behaves more like a confused person
than GPT-4. Third, through ESC-Role and organized role cards, we systematically
conduct experiments using 14 LLMs as the ESC models, including general
AI-assistant LLMs (ChatGPT) and ESC-oriented LLMs (ExTES-Llama). We conduct
comprehensive human annotations on interactive multi-turn dialogues of
different ESC models. The results show that ESC-oriented LLMs exhibit superior
ESC abilities compared to general AI-assistant LLMs, but there is still a gap
behind human performance. Moreover, to automate the scoring process for future
ESC models, we developed ESC-RANK, which trained on the annotated data,
achieving a scoring performance surpassing 35 points of GPT-4. Our data and
code are available at https://github.com/haidequanbu/ESC-Eval. | [
-0.4879601001739502,
-0.8587349057197571,
0.7508329749107361,
0.12741348147392273,
-0.09506087005138397,
0.18565434217453003,
-0.3572896122932434,
-0.5141676068305969,
0.2604905068874359,
0.3947344422340393,
-0.6018316149711609,
-0.7901231646537781,
-0.5441223978996277,
0.2834693193435669,
-0.4707546532154083,
0.9975269436836243,
0.017858728766441345,
0.120355524122715,
-0.5595921874046326,
-0.06422874331474304,
-0.06774338334798813,
-0.6071605682373047,
-0.8767508864402771,
-0.18215328454971313,
0.2655797600746155,
0.44439905881881714,
0.37318122386932373,
0.0727464109659195,
0.3699839413166046,
0.4975418746471405,
-0.20745114982128143,
0.2753317952156067,
-0.3714829683303833,
0.44057774543762207,
0.22890225052833557,
-0.38138097524642944,
-0.7067601084709167,
-0.27936312556266785,
0.43733540177345276,
0.10117293149232864,
-0.4329252541065216,
0.008725949563086033,
0.10298173129558563,
0.459012895822525,
-0.44116756319999695,
0.37877562642097473,
-0.44199517369270325,
-0.048603761941194534,
0.18577983975410461,
-0.11570132523775101,
-0.6257621645927429,
-0.1595790833234787,
0.023778267204761505,
-0.3491361141204834,
-0.2285911738872528,
0.11204976588487625,
0.6208527088165283,
0.31845822930336,
-0.34947165846824646,
-0.45223766565322876,
-0.5909691452980042,
0.5026282668113708,
-0.6912265419960022,
0.12731516361236572,
0.3480031490325928,
0.33873602747917175,
0.08258344233036041,
-0.2960972189903259,
-0.499372273683548,
-0.543194591999054,
0.12348475307226181,
0.4607025980949402,
-0.16694863140583038,
0.46857529878616333,
0.48627403378486633,
0.09135451167821884,
-0.36995312571525574,
0.17293861508369446,
-0.11309456825256348,
0.1292644739151001,
0.7964162826538086,
0.41162189841270447,
0.1986822783946991,
-0.008079048246145248,
-0.25362837314605713,
-0.06858203560113907,
-0.42366743087768555,
0.09563948959112167,
0.5713574290275574,
0.10014297068119049,
-0.17201754450798035,
0.5404787063598633,
-0.20726539194583893,
0.3327139914035797,
-0.022162891924381256,
0.24179358780384064,
0.17711007595062256,
0.16695193946361542,
-0.09833019971847534,
-0.07806091755628586,
0.6810548305511475,
0.6016649007797241,
0.3648734986782074,
0.10114172846078873,
-0.23558104038238525,
0.07785294204950333,
0.40266722440719604,
-0.7990121841430664,
0.24437211453914642,
0.29182833433151245,
-0.33073529601097107,
-0.36212512850761414,
-0.04613596200942993,
-0.984711766242981,
-0.6186165809631348,
-0.31337958574295044,
0.2740979790687561,
-0.12592187523841858,
-0.16121983528137207,
-0.18917840719223022,
0.248787522315979,
0.28322267532348633,
0.5170882344245911,
-0.7100592255592346,
0.7571987509727478,
0.6564048528671265,
0.7599512934684753,
-0.2419479340314865,
-0.3290577530860901,
-0.6324470043182373,
-0.5148704051971436,
-0.09243378043174744,
0.9388766884803772,
-0.7867146730422974,
-0.5964570045471191,
0.23195023834705353,
0.021029304713010788,
-0.02632489614188671,
-0.3320949375629425,
0.7801710963249207,
-0.25013482570648193,
-0.15194915235042572,
-0.19768287241458893,
-0.5908599495887756,
0.10615543276071548,
0.372422456741333,
-0.6395893692970276,
0.9839091897010803,
-0.19504231214523315,
-0.42234766483306885,
-0.04767148941755295,
-0.9384793043136597,
-0.32075536251068115,
0.00367321097292006,
-0.24218875169754028,
-0.4572561979293823,
0.06705435365438461,
0.23267191648483276,
0.4939696788787842,
-0.5192350149154663,
0.06969749927520752,
-0.46781009435653687,
-0.5410420298576355,
0.42281535267829895,
-0.39883333444595337,
0.22119849920272827,
0.06724999099969864,
-0.38693422079086304,
0.1750613898038864,
-0.5554322600364685,
-0.011692112311720848,
-0.16278564929962158,
-0.03248123824596405,
-0.030351337045431137,
0.3244357109069824,
0.16690415143966675,
0.5084347128868103,
-0.04734213650226593,
-0.5298824906349182,
0.1624154895544052,
-0.19922856986522675,
0.24475102126598358,
0.7278121709823608,
-0.012447156012058258,
0.20134758949279785,
0.0005886228173039854,
0.8985337615013123,
-0.3561287224292755,
0.25678378343582153,
-0.2729589641094208,
-0.5292171239852905,
-0.8309608697891235,
-0.09388668835163116,
-0.035153333097696304,
0.5020102858543396,
-0.662212610244751,
0.6049206256866455,
-0.007204176392406225,
-0.49135810136795044,
-0.6668943762779236,
-0.25574737787246704,
0.4388488829135895,
0.22755248844623566,
0.4182160198688507,
-0.18432529270648956,
-0.3058038055896759,
-0.8972926139831543,
-0.16704997420310974,
-0.39436814188957214,
-0.04729895666241646,
0.6210147142410278,
0.42258208990097046,
-0.14801575243473053,
0.6217745542526245,
-0.31590330600738525,
-0.07561936974525452,
-0.4340214729309082,
0.41489002108573914,
-0.30814895033836365,
0.15620094537734985,
0.30503419041633606,
-0.4301702380180359,
-0.4765413701534271,
-0.028366154059767723,
-0.40921124815940857,
-0.5640600323677063,
-0.13526353240013123,
-0.031657624989748,
0.45381271839141846,
0.3561244308948517,
-0.47912636399269104,
0.602060079574585,
0.8652660250663757,
-0.48794299364089966,
0.394284188747406,
-0.19125697016716003,
0.6389667987823486,
-0.8556602597236633,
0.11273795366287231,
0.08370141685009003,
-0.12484018504619598,
-0.5836700201034546,
-0.3948853313922882,
-0.08768388628959656,
-0.1452302783727646,
-0.33833038806915283,
0.5415948629379272,
-0.31210556626319885,
-0.3126944601535797,
-0.17334333062171936,
0.4300169348716736,
-0.07608874142169952,
0.569980800151825,
0.2634787857532501,
0.4960031509399414,
0.5876992344856262,
-0.14174361526966095,
0.3440280854701996,
0.08504806458950043,
-0.26594042778015137,
0.9620155692100525,
-0.5569239854812622,
0.4747568368911743,
-0.09704581648111343,
0.31181877851486206,
-1.0397534370422363,
0.0031963034998625517,
-0.1735977977514267,
-0.21719864010810852,
0.20384275913238525,
-0.13316062092781067,
-0.31579986214637756,
-0.35651203989982605,
-0.299398809671402,
0.16391338407993317,
0.5470711588859558,
-0.445637583732605,
0.9416090250015259,
0.3667120635509491,
-0.2815648913383484,
-0.44074875116348267,
-0.5151545405387878,
0.13137394189834595,
-0.26444658637046814,
-0.6807993054389954,
0.1778194010257721,
-0.45893630385398865,
-0.23639290034770966,
-0.05005491524934769,
0.000682980113197118,
0.1254204958677292,
0.17891740798950195,
0.59852534532547,
0.2619725167751312,
0.06505854427814484,
0.21334896981716156,
0.12074950337409973,
-0.12247440963983536,
0.09293831139802933,
0.34641900658607483,
0.4528164565563202,
-0.6153286695480347,
-0.831737220287323,
-0.46632394194602966,
0.5908254981040955,
0.8094184994697571,
-0.20798982679843903,
0.6266652345657349,
0.2903163731098175,
-0.3568613529205322,
-0.1751786470413208,
-0.755715548992157,
-0.14237728714942932,
-0.4059637486934662,
0.6831538677215576,
-0.26944491267204285,
-0.7959194779396057,
0.7642854452133179,
-0.11177447438240051,
0.027243182063102722,
0.3182845413684845,
0.6981272101402283,
-0.059465453028678894,
1.4305853843688965,
0.31232011318206787,
0.07805173844099045,
0.42933616042137146,
-0.06780833005905151,
0.2479899376630783,
-0.8796003460884094,
-0.3389424681663513,
-0.4777854382991791,
-0.30331653356552124,
-0.3729305863380432,
-0.25851839780807495,
0.2761284410953522,
-0.18415826559066772,
-0.12070822715759277,
0.12393862754106522,
-0.20684565603733063,
0.4974845051765442,
-0.20204196870326996,
-0.012799300253391266,
0.11647820472717285,
-0.2706201374530792,
0.1655324101448059,
0.009374774061143398,
-0.27500590682029724,
-0.6764714121818542,
0.8318523168563843,
0.6520549654960632,
0.7288407683372498,
-0.04636383056640625,
0.7254710793495178,
0.4323325753211975,
0.6639752388000488,
-0.9773619174957275,
0.6268826127052307,
0.014701828360557556,
-0.2669353783130646,
-0.3451252579689026,
-0.34236106276512146,
-0.6082765460014343,
0.3194720447063446,
-0.3057521879673004,
-1.0216939449310303,
-0.22814734280109406,
0.04899585247039795,
-0.44876956939697266,
0.08252965658903122,
-0.8915511965751648,
0.944442093372345,
-0.6598713397979736,
-0.31185033917427063,
-0.27826356887817383,
-0.43361896276474,
0.05990162491798401,
0.0137683916836977,
0.19650407135486603,
-0.12669096887111664,
0.04486454278230667,
0.6768732070922852,
-0.38069385290145874,
0.6543945074081421,
-0.2859581410884857,
0.03881649672985077,
0.3864726722240448,
-0.0005934765213169158,
0.67485511302948,
-0.026523973792791367,
-0.30465376377105713,
0.02624964527785778,
-0.07881736010313034,
-0.022742386907339096,
-0.8824793100357056,
0.6825760006904602,
-0.7836673259735107,
-0.4850979447364807,
-0.30632227659225464,
-0.04916385933756828,
-0.39691105484962463,
-0.34004220366477966,
-0.1830654740333557,
0.34105193614959717,
-0.5338451862335205,
0.2451290339231491,
0.23609092831611633,
-0.3336709141731262,
0.1942889392375946,
0.6479448676109314,
-0.12136609107255936,
-0.23881033062934875,
0.5301040410995483,
-0.08407677710056305,
0.37334826588630676,
0.20880472660064697,
0.07808232307434082,
-0.3485468327999115,
-0.2584761381149292,
-0.29732754826545715,
0.07946062088012695,
-0.7018197178840637,
-0.28292116522789,
-0.7832965850830078,
-0.22904673218727112,
-0.1511448174715042,
-0.25185084342956543,
-0.5630114078521729,
-0.017571786418557167,
-0.08401881903409958,
-0.4340512454509735,
0.4439254701137543,
0.8639621138572693,
0.1766834259033203,
0.22389739751815796,
-0.5771422386169434,
-0.11618882417678833,
0.3518555164337158,
0.39291587471961975,
-0.05096779391169548,
-0.4382271468639374,
-0.18041378259658813,
-0.09268584847450256,
-0.14026285707950592,
-1.0733466148376465,
0.3727787733078003,
0.12444596737623215,
0.6353925466537476,
0.38155028223991394,
-0.024129897356033325,
0.6517149806022644,
-0.44802767038345337,
0.9701579809188843,
0.12682823836803436,
-1.2541217803955078,
0.3575468361377716,
-0.08952604234218597,
0.006639375351369381,
0.6501824855804443,
0.06832945346832275,
-0.8384649157524109,
-0.32999128103256226,
-0.8395050168037415,
-1.0780754089355469,
1.0422017574310303,
0.32305777072906494,
-0.05874418467283249,
-0.07448416948318481,
0.0664210394024849,
-0.29296258091926575,
0.15920136868953705,
-0.48809516429901123,
-0.16488513350486755,
0.07071449607610703,
-0.4192865490913391,
0.05968877300620079,
-0.41139593720436096,
-0.06834758818149567,
0.1707984060049057,
0.6318063735961914,
-0.18254569172859192,
0.4563570022583008,
0.05450965836644173,
0.07199905067682266,
-0.2555200755596161,
0.47870442271232605,
0.6974859833717346,
0.036262597888708115,
-0.06889579445123672,
0.09436032921075821,
0.7069054841995239,
-0.14562536776065826,
-0.0932360291481018,
0.14536522328853607,
0.4388381242752075,
-0.37356969714164734,
0.26501214504241943,
1.0259307622909546,
0.37480324506759644,
-0.9516921043395996,
0.7005499601364136,
-0.3072480857372284,
0.024943633005023003,
-0.2560969591140747,
0.007851753383874893,
0.22406987845897675,
0.49421370029449463,
0.033017586916685104,
-0.15575499832630157,
0.24440006911754608,
-0.49012771248817444,
0.17733025550842285,
0.2432728409767151,
-0.3760087788105011,
-0.35080602765083313,
0.27161940932273865,
0.593532919883728,
-0.6446905732154846,
0.4956633746623993,
-0.30122581124305725,
-0.851834237575531,
0.9154441952705383,
0.3335789442062378,
1.1061874628067017,
-0.5785054564476013,
0.37377625703811646,
0.3041079342365265,
0.15835696458816528,
-0.23395580053329468,
0.17531359195709229,
-0.17417976260185242,
-0.47142189741134644,
-0.3640846610069275,
-0.4235554039478302,
-0.6772579550743103,
0.010764877311885357,
-0.6465356349945068,
0.35849806666374207,
-0.015981288626790047,
-0.1540427803993225,
-0.4754081070423126,
0.09275207668542862,
-0.8085364103317261,
-0.03586028143763542,
0.5724040865898132,
0.720352828502655,
-1.1261093616485596,
0.6107025742530823,
0.5813409686088562,
-0.18464542925357819,
-0.8301743268966675,
-0.13153231143951416,
0.1825559288263321,
-0.5621622800827026,
0.43743398785591125,
0.2875381410121918,
-0.40454667806625366,
-0.1696902960538864,
-0.3466096520423889,
-0.5407624244689941,
1.2810910940170288,
0.20812618732452393,
-0.6249274611473083,
0.19846536219120026,
0.026654986664652824,
1.0928345918655396,
-0.796994686126709,
1.1664589643478394,
0.5831249952316284,
0.5202354192733765,
0.19709400832653046,
-0.8584922552108765,
-0.15298350155353546,
-0.5840831995010376,
-0.1199006512761116,
-0.10125776380300522,
-0.7206005454063416,
0.47498610615730286,
-0.01261103991419077,
-0.1646520346403122,
0.24195368587970734,
0.30787181854248047,
0.4149225354194641,
0.38792410492897034,
0.7467264533042908,
0.3753414452075958,
0.6863718032836914,
-0.2216993272304535,
1.0719271898269653,
-0.30369246006011963,
0.6078147292137146,
0.9466282725334167,
-0.7234843373298645,
0.9069957733154297,
0.25527310371398926,
-0.07452728599309921,
0.4545949697494507,
0.400544673204422,
0.08732214570045471,
0.09618177264928818,
0.486055463552475,
-0.18919290602207184,
-0.4224172532558441,
-0.08421343564987183,
-0.053836431354284286,
0.4790656268596649,
0.6162710785865784,
-0.2858988642692566,
-0.00428874883800745,
-0.08929891139268875,
-0.03197444975376129,
0.016475750133395195,
-0.1287006139755249,
0.6922761797904968,
0.046035539358854294,
-0.687412440776825,
0.08257634937763214,
-0.10902279615402222,
0.41363829374313354,
-0.6554792523384094,
-0.2813611328601837,
-0.24738331139087677,
-0.09651712328195572,
-0.24285170435905457,
-0.85190749168396,
0.0755830779671669,
0.5949802398681641,
0.4011644423007965,
-0.19210605323314667,
0.5511439442634583,
-0.6187341213226318,
-0.3269573152065277,
0.6589107513427734,
0.4140964448451996,
0.43989241123199463,
-0.05111103504896164,
-0.8095041513442993,
0.4181990921497345,
-0.19873780012130737,
-0.651517391204834,
0.24350911378860474,
0.4411916136741638,
0.06338787823915482,
0.54558926820755,
0.2595703899860382,
-0.028098685666918755,
-0.3977605700492859,
0.4944314658641815,
0.7309001684188843,
-0.5024428367614746,
-0.4981826841831207,
-0.7822335362434387,
0.8637498021125793,
-0.38163188099861145,
-0.26056551933288574,
0.3399418592453003,
0.2851811349391937,
0.31680312752723694,
0.2022952288389206,
0.708986222743988,
0.011132662184536457,
0.1682637333869934,
-0.45507654547691345,
0.5915594696998596,
-0.5240535736083984,
0.4163815677165985,
-0.5689764618873596,
-0.8079853057861328,
-0.1282566338777542,
0.7722352743148804,
-0.4614095687866211,
0.37740880250930786,
0.6960315704345703,
0.8374325633049011,
0.35602396726608276,
0.25077345967292786,
0.6010841727256775,
0.23622144758701324,
0.5232887864112854,
0.6668230891227722,
1.2847464084625244,
-0.22463347017765045,
0.4367299973964691,
0.008722750470042229,
-0.34101495146751404,
-0.40042033791542053,
-0.8521648049354553,
-0.8783841729164124,
-0.6604511737823486,
-0.3160329759120941,
-0.3095623552799225,
0.07397720217704773,
1.3407869338989258,
0.5060117840766907,
-0.5777758955955505,
-0.24219702184200287,
0.02622097358107567,
-0.00435707438737154,
-0.1585623323917389,
-0.20579268038272858,
0.3115632236003876,
-0.11808644980192184,
-0.9812124371528625,
0.3914281725883484,
0.41950249671936035,
-0.20558606088161469,
-0.3309679627418518,
-0.3666893541812897,
0.09662208706140518,
0.26700538396835327,
0.6732979416847229,
0.1440936177968979,
-0.7085913419723511,
-0.4234395921230316,
0.22306333482265472,
-0.07391849160194397,
-0.020855724811553955,
0.8393179774284363,
-0.43046948313713074,
0.48846665024757385,
0.24702362716197968,
0.7269126772880554,
0.49400609731674194,
0.1808895319700241,
0.3800874352455139,
-0.4631060063838959,
-0.2350112944841385,
0.2984205484390259,
0.4510962665081024,
0.28247207403182983,
-0.48963335156440735,
0.39477941393852234,
-0.23119349777698517,
-0.7548369765281677,
-0.7523596286773682,
0.1813517063856125,
-1.1898612976074219,
0.14991119503974915,
1.5129112005233765,
-0.3096999228000641,
-0.1184438094496727,
0.09845059365034103,
-0.6166476011276245,
0.18940439820289612,
-0.8329863548278809,
0.8301072716712952,
0.8745408058166504,
-0.5059095621109009,
-0.2025402933359146,
-0.3968594968318939,
0.4330817759037018,
0.41785335540771484,
-1.244889736175537,
0.20259879529476166,
0.411601185798645,
-0.17960020899772644,
0.11357148736715317,
0.6520594358444214,
-0.06024634838104248,
-0.019788386300206184,
-0.20180177688598633,
0.358249306678772,
0.01784011349081993,
-0.3771607577800751,
-0.6440816521644592,
0.057435084134340286,
0.13673223555088043,
0.1722603291273117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14938v1 | Towards Retrieval Augmented Generation over Large Video Libraries | 2024-06-21T07:52:01 | 2024-06-21T07:52:01 | Yannis Tevissen, Khalil Guetari, Frédéric Petitpont | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Video content creators need efficient tools to repurpose content, a task that
often requires complex manual or automated searches. Crafting a new video from
large video libraries remains a challenge. In this paper we introduce the task
of Video Library Question Answering (VLQA) through an interoperable
architecture that applies Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) to video
libraries. We propose a system that uses large language models (LLMs) to
generate search queries, retrieving relevant video moments indexed by speech
and visual metadata. An answer generation module then integrates user queries
with this metadata to produce responses with specific video timestamps. This
approach shows promise in multimedia content retrieval, and AI-assisted video
content creation. | [
-0.648252546787262,
-0.7939049601554871,
0.4610510468482971,
-0.023256689310073853,
-0.10813070088624954,
0.3194473087787628,
0.17945343255996704,
-0.2115233987569809,
0.3183612823486328,
0.8606542348861694,
-0.6406527757644653,
0.0006630223360843956,
-0.30390146374702454,
-0.11921697109937668,
-0.8420899510383606,
0.6950123310089111,
-0.02529524452984333,
-0.04014896973967552,
-0.34231898188591003,
-0.36189764738082886,
-0.37013116478919983,
-0.5452209115028381,
-0.4035642147064209,
-0.06897309422492981,
0.22212933003902435,
0.2586650848388672,
0.6577349305152893,
0.6084179282188416,
0.501926839351654,
0.41398489475250244,
-0.07525129616260529,
0.8145297169685364,
-0.2336398959159851,
0.29387977719306946,
-0.45220381021499634,
-0.12046120315790176,
-0.11391385644674301,
-0.5146380066871643,
0.7057974934577942,
0.1575886458158493,
0.1511198729276657,
0.7962964773178101,
-0.29243263602256775,
0.5391969680786133,
-0.8003289103507996,
-0.5441866517066956,
-0.8789804577827454,
0.10681982338428497,
-0.060433611273765564,
-0.8653154969215393,
-0.14938916265964508,
-0.17616060376167297,
-0.019446851685643196,
-0.3936065435409546,
0.3411073088645935,
0.039070017635822296,
0.7815359830856323,
0.6292009353637695,
-0.15997610986232758,
-0.3959938585758209,
-0.905708909034729,
0.47461244463920593,
-0.4086827039718628,
0.34564000368118286,
0.5761807560920715,
0.6062625050544739,
0.08295418322086334,
-0.9555987119674683,
-0.826921284198761,
0.023219987750053406,
0.2844337224960327,
-0.11857544630765915,
-0.07719603180885315,
-0.13473986089229584,
0.35399556159973145,
0.5216249227523804,
-0.7039628028869629,
-0.12338122725486755,
-0.223770409822464,
-0.04813147336244583,
0.5891141891479492,
0.30251744389533997,
0.4637065827846527,
-0.6317885518074036,
-0.15439169108867645,
0.08256497234106064,
-0.5260919332504272,
-0.0383460596203804,
0.5166565775871277,
-0.0573989562690258,
0.4460354149341583,
1.1449228525161743,
-0.17025943100452423,
0.6450481414794922,
0.19293619692325592,
-0.21961641311645508,
0.07761448621749878,
-0.4676588475704193,
-0.3353390693664551,
0.13436350226402283,
0.21613043546676636,
0.3179576098918915,
-0.12999199330806732,
0.11592059582471848,
-0.1839827299118042,
-0.4569462239742279,
0.4878617823123932,
-0.774604320526123,
-0.06378936022520065,
0.2833864092826843,
-0.20659713447093964,
0.1908351629972458,
0.10250933468341827,
-0.4045381546020508,
-0.37645384669303894,
-0.3543470501899719,
0.9044138789176941,
-0.16940443217754364,
-0.0826268419623375,
-0.17958864569664001,
-0.23164625465869904,
0.620254635810852,
0.27570945024490356,
-0.7166258692741394,
0.2183142602443695,
0.4777567982673645,
0.43480271100997925,
0.09396957606077194,
0.09124044328927994,
-1.2982745170593262,
0.5214517712593079,
-0.26602622866630554,
0.5762919783592224,
-0.26205700635910034,
-0.17586301267147064,
0.5429525971412659,
0.08404628932476044,
0.6414664387702942,
-0.7589336037635803,
0.2241644412279129,
-1.2735257148742676,
0.1038464605808258,
-0.22404168546199799,
-0.42206722497940063,
-0.036067113280296326,
0.5793938040733337,
-0.7648529410362244,
1.1656873226165771,
-0.024968666955828667,
-0.7766962647438049,
0.1903783231973648,
-0.1978767216205597,
-0.0022811393719166517,
0.38579434156417847,
-0.2720407247543335,
-0.37422940135002136,
-0.15356604754924774,
0.4681837260723114,
0.18533536791801453,
-0.4687862694263458,
0.5014098286628723,
0.048100829124450684,
-0.21815545856952667,
0.30929481983184814,
-0.5292379260063171,
0.21486319601535797,
0.5046683549880981,
-0.033015791326761246,
-0.10303819924592972,
-0.7201870083808899,
0.2911084294319153,
-0.21596413850784302,
-0.5350618958473206,
-0.1639488935470581,
0.054785896092653275,
0.13463817536830902,
0.08491609990596771,
0.3557599186897278,
-0.378671258687973,
0.20693306624889374,
-0.11946887522935867,
0.07071301341056824,
0.6100037097930908,
0.24059703946113586,
0.3792625069618225,
-0.12035936117172241,
0.558720588684082,
-0.1144031435251236,
0.036226414144039154,
-0.23407939076423645,
-0.07044674456119537,
-0.5487962961196899,
0.060116130858659744,
-0.07414934039115906,
0.5731849670410156,
-1.522274136543274,
-0.07528845965862274,
-0.0292288176715374,
-0.32207298278808594,
-0.5674875974655151,
0.5123363137245178,
0.4853694438934326,
0.48133161664009094,
0.5387367010116577,
-0.20084436237812042,
-0.7827960252761841,
-0.7309865355491638,
0.1705106496810913,
-0.2828093469142914,
-0.2391987293958664,
0.7823144197463989,
0.17704953253269196,
-0.15805034339427948,
0.7311980128288269,
-0.47108960151672363,
-0.04370560124516487,
-0.14378602802753448,
0.17752183973789215,
0.2018044888973236,
0.03734629973769188,
0.3549192249774933,
-1.4065805673599243,
-0.3301197290420532,
0.06064281240105629,
-0.8440757989883423,
-0.19860441982746124,
0.04856255650520325,
0.058532170951366425,
0.25018706917762756,
0.8467388153076172,
-0.3440152108669281,
0.2727369964122772,
0.41768190264701843,
-0.006423944607377052,
0.5659636855125427,
-0.2816113829612732,
0.4827370047569275,
-1.1373777389526367,
0.07302217185497284,
-0.5314932465553284,
-0.11673446744680405,
-0.3363988399505615,
0.10567766427993774,
-0.5213508009910583,
-0.2227071076631546,
-0.8166347146034241,
0.7821381688117981,
-0.15527793765068054,
-0.7757449746131897,
-0.20767547190189362,
0.33443722128868103,
-0.09552531689405441,
0.23714514076709747,
0.15186533331871033,
0.947912335395813,
0.3360387086868286,
-0.7570701837539673,
0.6212361454963684,
0.47939324378967285,
-0.3766220808029175,
0.6068549156188965,
-0.6084843277931213,
-0.04280976206064224,
-0.4740225076675415,
-0.2620278298854828,
-0.973054051399231,
-0.6630474925041199,
-0.17714740335941315,
-0.6213585734367371,
0.060196831822395325,
-0.3880210518836975,
-0.43675023317337036,
-0.3537158966064453,
-0.13123783469200134,
0.7173916101455688,
0.30351191759109497,
-0.8722822666168213,
0.5875574350357056,
0.5555179119110107,
-0.28416186571121216,
-0.9677746295928955,
-0.37284722924232483,
0.17679104208946228,
-0.22842639684677124,
-0.8675892949104309,
0.3926554024219513,
-0.4037681221961975,
-0.36258095502853394,
0.3424873948097229,
0.04360370337963104,
-0.41555720567703247,
-0.28297853469848633,
0.006302800960838795,
0.1657153218984604,
-0.30200842022895813,
0.32014358043670654,
-0.11838383972644806,
0.3916880786418915,
-0.32751768827438354,
-0.17949599027633667,
0.6282466053962708,
0.19443555176258087,
-0.23924580216407776,
0.1356709897518158,
0.7769857048988342,
0.34934890270233154,
-0.5905251502990723,
0.3187565505504608,
0.9905617237091064,
-0.22077099978923798,
-0.12657776474952698,
-0.8367208242416382,
0.1638883650302887,
-0.5821586847305298,
0.5943424105644226,
-0.3235071003437042,
-1.0898748636245728,
0.44783350825309753,
0.14693182706832886,
0.015923740342259407,
0.07501615583896637,
0.9830577969551086,
-0.29293063282966614,
0.9502905607223511,
0.45499905943870544,
0.4912192225456238,
0.7456672787666321,
-0.35105767846107483,
-0.2894848585128784,
-0.5820519924163818,
-0.14409585297107697,
-0.2652732729911804,
-0.13944938778877258,
-0.5660384297370911,
-0.6722916960716248,
0.7090618014335632,
0.07459737360477448,
-0.5423213243484497,
0.19478729367256165,
-0.4101548492908478,
0.6249551773071289,
0.7072300910949707,
0.0053459228947758675,
0.31821200251579285,
0.1034850925207138,
0.4254486858844757,
-0.007120064459741116,
-0.6127794981002808,
-0.3293413817882538,
0.6798628568649292,
0.005448490846902132,
0.6050713062286377,
0.6301165223121643,
0.6544468402862549,
0.5486538410186768,
-0.027254650369286537,
-0.6058752536773682,
0.6927993893623352,
-0.41918161511421204,
-0.6358553767204285,
-0.35963037610054016,
-0.14967750012874603,
-0.7340412139892578,
-0.26118963956832886,
-0.3635503053665161,
-0.4572643041610718,
-0.2054460644721985,
0.11571485549211502,
-0.24482838809490204,
0.3805372416973114,
-0.1520317792892456,
0.5245036482810974,
-0.27668243646621704,
-0.6936184167861938,
-0.07191736996173859,
-0.7072887420654297,
0.444977343082428,
0.020976005122065544,
0.1467313915491104,
0.3893182575702667,
0.06433311849832535,
0.4483805000782013,
-0.625847578048706,
0.10380958020687103,
-0.10651564598083496,
0.16070516407489777,
1.1373273134231567,
0.23404619097709656,
0.23638074100017548,
0.24645939469337463,
0.10367312282323837,
-0.6496946811676025,
0.056344278156757355,
-0.10052929073572159,
-0.6892644762992859,
0.5407912135124207,
-0.7457380890846252,
-0.7407594323158264,
0.08585073053836823,
-0.5928723812103271,
-0.09612925350666046,
0.09219714999198914,
0.0058190166018903255,
0.5788648128509521,
0.1314118206501007,
0.2893728017807007,
0.9554529786109924,
-0.6800305247306824,
0.4576033651828766,
0.414460688829422,
-0.4784421920776367,
-0.5808743834495544,
1.0027261972427368,
0.051281701773405075,
0.2527049779891968,
0.578923761844635,
-0.26317912340164185,
-0.3209540843963623,
-0.3670617938041687,
-0.6683169603347778,
0.15683375298976898,
-0.7426948547363281,
-0.35539212822914124,
-0.4561102092266083,
-0.5628144145011902,
-0.2621355950832367,
-0.07476308196783066,
-0.2868401110172272,
-0.14079523086547852,
-0.20282679796218872,
-0.33788207173347473,
0.47251442074775696,
0.5055698752403259,
-0.2637578845024109,
0.2249973863363266,
-1.1593354940414429,
0.7608727216720581,
0.8995330333709717,
0.2551285922527313,
-0.16781213879585266,
-0.7495929002761841,
-0.44696539640426636,
-0.36841195821762085,
-0.394090861082077,
-0.5679224133491516,
0.4991735517978668,
0.2585836350917816,
0.468316912651062,
-0.13928262889385223,
-0.2269180417060852,
0.8010072112083435,
-0.7537200450897217,
1.0553498268127441,
0.0032413192093372345,
-0.6006104946136475,
0.5257585644721985,
-0.29229816794395447,
0.22387149930000305,
0.31549423933029175,
0.5455636978149414,
-0.3711922764778137,
-0.041050489991903305,
-0.38876986503601074,
-1.0536115169525146,
0.20252996683120728,
-0.019491538405418396,
0.3503528833389282,
-0.1433434933423996,
0.3264230191707611,
-0.1447637528181076,
0.1582796424627304,
-0.3955150842666626,
-0.04722299799323082,
-0.21760079264640808,
0.1976379007101059,
0.2265816181898117,
-0.2623607814311981,
-0.08585868030786514,
0.08259465545415878,
0.6685429215431213,
-0.2715226709842682,
0.01107592973858118,
0.4792877435684204,
-0.07810092717409134,
-0.45721226930618286,
0.16549059748649597,
0.16024284064769745,
0.35224512219429016,
-0.3601704239845276,
0.04867454618215561,
-0.06760591268539429,
-0.2936747074127197,
0.3243733048439026,
-0.052027683705091476,
-0.26036226749420166,
0.10262449830770493,
0.22362694144248962,
0.56767737865448,
-0.2182195633649826,
-1.326043963432312,
0.39421162009239197,
0.009574174880981445,
-0.21341276168823242,
-0.8094073534011841,
-0.03847189247608185,
-0.18274228274822235,
0.6836148500442505,
0.7304586172103882,
-0.5402176380157471,
0.31290826201438904,
-0.8347247242927551,
0.7934412360191345,
0.5806890726089478,
-0.24602535367012024,
0.048976831138134,
0.9348056316375732,
-0.19748429954051971,
-0.6579568386077881,
0.6954788565635681,
-0.07772362977266312,
-0.21721282601356506,
0.3943940997123718,
0.23508651554584503,
0.7423869371414185,
-0.03855548053979874,
0.5859572887420654,
0.4739072322845459,
-0.13568468391895294,
0.007405146956443787,
0.5187602639198303,
-0.19151580333709717,
-0.5285146236419678,
-0.9243156909942627,
-0.8463190197944641,
-0.45912620425224304,
0.06640588492155075,
-0.6246333718299866,
0.34195756912231445,
-0.24858751893043518,
-0.0736476480960846,
-0.11827225238084793,
-0.15682904422283173,
-0.6176677346229553,
0.3887120485305786,
0.4981633424758911,
0.7180832624435425,
-0.5106587409973145,
0.6906132102012634,
0.6636262536048889,
-0.7595298290252686,
-1.005789875984192,
-0.4715422987937927,
-0.46168458461761475,
-0.6408947706222534,
1.150234341621399,
-0.3739946484565735,
0.01641613245010376,
-0.08062097430229187,
-0.8445993661880493,
-0.9558790326118469,
1.1878001689910889,
0.2228815108537674,
-0.03081643208861351,
-0.36304008960723877,
0.28310564160346985,
0.7968628406524658,
-0.13022032380104065,
0.16381099820137024,
0.2393779456615448,
0.03024212084710598,
0.7349661588668823,
-0.8129958510398865,
-0.49966976046562195,
-0.3150750696659088,
-0.15319064259529114,
0.20946785807609558,
-0.23389917612075806,
0.8719760775566101,
-0.06572525203227997,
0.05970446392893791,
0.4331674873828888,
0.8425671458244324,
0.39819708466529846,
0.5342978835105896,
0.2567833364009857,
0.5099092721939087,
0.31613871455192566,
0.4415847063064575,
0.9464404582977295,
0.042764801532030106,
-0.05164264142513275,
1.32708740234375,
0.10493198037147522,
0.9112532734870911,
0.8057538866996765,
-0.033976323902606964,
0.25517386198043823,
0.33254900574684143,
0.17072895169258118,
0.5043067932128906,
0.12142256647348404,
-0.5386962890625,
-0.554480791091919,
-0.6725448966026306,
-0.13211986422538757,
0.5052375197410583,
0.3115507662296295,
-0.3457777500152588,
-0.1644751876592636,
-0.008808759972453117,
-0.5439256429672241,
0.4647003412246704,
-0.7879002690315247,
0.9189584851264954,
-0.20460084080696106,
-0.8045554161071777,
0.43126991391181946,
-0.3168313801288605,
0.17840391397476196,
-0.47080013155937195,
-0.4153251051902771,
-0.2322091907262802,
-0.13165993988513947,
-0.322098970413208,
-1.0808748006820679,
0.38243967294692993,
0.36051708459854126,
-0.285758376121521,
0.04608694463968277,
0.5431366562843323,
-0.7166990041732788,
-0.3147929012775421,
-0.06921015679836273,
0.6577961444854736,
0.2327807992696762,
0.18964579701423645,
-0.38917645812034607,
0.08863486349582672,
-0.063470259308815,
-0.23041068017482758,
0.4693084955215454,
0.480684757232666,
-0.24792812764644623,
0.6727281212806702,
0.4734562039375305,
-0.09383779019117355,
0.3083569407463074,
-0.09875490516424179,
0.9111730456352234,
-0.4015199840068817,
-0.13342468440532684,
-0.39608559012413025,
0.6673481464385986,
0.11074068397283554,
0.1577521413564682,
0.5650118589401245,
0.3797190487384796,
0.8741391897201538,
-0.15047883987426758,
0.6994666457176208,
-0.36513566970825195,
0.5148857831954956,
-0.6468706727027893,
-0.04279882460832596,
-0.950554609298706,
0.4188527762889862,
-0.4956798255443573,
-1.19760262966156,
-0.16283024847507477,
-0.07923804968595505,
-0.06532704085111618,
-0.4579205811023712,
-0.09964248538017273,
0.9290717244148254,
-0.05194100737571716,
-0.5217398405075073,
0.40416738390922546,
0.13067704439163208,
0.6604854464530945,
0.2599862813949585,
0.8519514203071594,
-0.5163378119468689,
1.0065175294876099,
0.020681163296103477,
0.24297937750816345,
-0.1823190450668335,
-0.8429775238037109,
-0.5814806222915649,
-0.6915479898452759,
-0.027088413015007973,
-0.3556150197982788,
0.041813746094703674,
0.9496042728424072,
0.18686527013778687,
-0.39655598998069763,
-0.176702082157135,
0.406063050031662,
-0.07030056416988373,
0.18069161474704742,
-0.2868961989879608,
0.4548407196998596,
0.06281579285860062,
-0.7512627243995667,
0.2401645928621292,
0.24958494305610657,
-0.16680265963077545,
-0.6740384101867676,
-0.054879672825336456,
-0.4602225720882416,
0.29645833373069763,
0.7238743901252747,
0.7193723917007446,
-0.5524734258651733,
-0.6361373066902161,
0.3355451822280884,
0.0890706405043602,
-0.10246103256940842,
0.6817969679832458,
-0.8772863149642944,
0.6836455464363098,
0.7668349742889404,
1.242096185684204,
0.8876937031745911,
0.42803287506103516,
0.253338485956192,
-0.9917937517166138,
0.08532565087080002,
0.29563868045806885,
0.14135020971298218,
0.5757237672805786,
-0.1790434718132019,
0.5395326018333435,
-0.13642439246177673,
-0.8501676917076111,
-0.8755050301551819,
0.5958907604217529,
-1.0479782819747925,
-0.1351487934589386,
0.9553170204162598,
0.1303822100162506,
-0.14599505066871643,
0.124759241938591,
-0.527592658996582,
0.20288187265396118,
0.1717182844877243,
0.5686648488044739,
0.32187750935554504,
-0.13479752838611603,
-0.3598059415817261,
-0.5956172347068787,
0.33167025446891785,
0.27794623374938965,
-0.4283981919288635,
-0.11659498512744904,
0.6635310053825378,
-0.010312101803719997,
0.26179951429367065,
0.6743960380554199,
-0.07827630639076233,
0.5837344527244568,
-0.14861419796943665,
-0.020685948431491852,
-0.12301784008741379,
-0.3845878541469574,
0.13429315388202667,
0.32377514243125916,
0.14154589176177979,
0.12031703442335129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15527v1 | Data Efficient Evaluation of Large Language Models and Text-to-Image Models via Adaptive Sampling | 2024-06-21T07:38:55 | 2024-06-21T07:38:55 | Cong Xu, Gayathri Saranathan, Mahammad Parwez Alam, Arpit Shah, James Lim, Soon Yee Wong, Foltin Martin, Suparna Bhattacharya | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Evaluating LLMs and text-to-image models is a computationally intensive task
often overlooked. Efficient evaluation is crucial for understanding the diverse
capabilities of these models and enabling comparisons across a growing number
of new models and benchmarks. To address this, we introduce SubLIME, a
data-efficient evaluation framework that employs adaptive sampling techniques,
such as clustering and quality-based methods, to create representative subsets
of benchmarks. Our approach ensures statistically aligned model rankings
compared to full datasets, evidenced by high Pearson correlation coefficients.
Empirical analysis across six NLP benchmarks reveals that: (1) quality-based
sampling consistently achieves strong correlations (0.85 to 0.95) with full
datasets at a 10\% sampling rate such as Quality SE and Quality CPD (2)
clustering methods excel in specific benchmarks such as MMLU (3) no single
method universally outperforms others across all metrics. Extending this
framework, we leverage the HEIM leaderboard to cover 25 text-to-image models on
17 different benchmarks. SubLIME dynamically selects the optimal technique for
each benchmark, significantly reducing evaluation costs while preserving
ranking integrity and score distribution. Notably, a minimal sampling rate of
1% proves effective for benchmarks like MMLU. Additionally, we demonstrate that
employing difficulty-based sampling to target more challenging benchmark
segments enhances model differentiation with broader score distributions. We
also combine semantic search, tool use, and GPT-4 review to identify redundancy
across benchmarks within specific LLM categories, such as coding benchmarks.
This allows us to further reduce the number of samples needed to maintain
targeted rank preservation. Overall, SubLIME offers a versatile and
cost-effective solution for the robust evaluation of LLMs and text-to-image
models. | [
-0.04407358542084694,
-0.7018558979034424,
0.6271312832832336,
0.41475704312324524,
-0.19679953157901764,
0.38882434368133545,
-0.5810776352882385,
-0.016346238553524017,
-0.12190234661102295,
0.33463507890701294,
-0.24397896230220795,
-0.9306525588035583,
-0.5274295210838318,
0.09675348550081253,
-0.7123826742172241,
0.590246319770813,
0.10756714642047882,
0.029941802844405174,
-0.40786212682724,
-0.33342257142066956,
-0.6489472985267639,
-0.25153976678848267,
-0.7183237075805664,
0.08199010044336319,
0.4282929599285126,
0.20578725636005402,
0.7280513644218445,
0.5421217083930969,
0.7007035613059998,
0.3583779036998749,
-0.1336471140384674,
0.3176642954349518,
-0.7191612720489502,
0.06341427564620972,
-0.23771017789840698,
-0.3390737771987915,
-0.32276153564453125,
-0.017968857660889626,
0.7979104518890381,
0.4822196662425995,
-0.22572961449623108,
0.07167574763298035,
0.1604331135749817,
0.7985633015632629,
-0.8380340337753296,
-0.13870839774608612,
-0.8325026035308838,
-0.09542855620384216,
-0.06324438750743866,
-0.26676666736602783,
-0.611679196357727,
-0.4259476661682129,
-0.16642917692661285,
-0.8370736241340637,
0.1482655555009842,
0.04648963734507561,
0.811582088470459,
0.30595362186431885,
-0.19744381308555603,
-0.12058985233306885,
-0.4549505412578583,
1.0836116075515747,
-0.575235903263092,
0.49324747920036316,
0.35472768545150757,
0.4836742877960205,
-0.06246044859290123,
-0.7552646994590759,
-0.26118454337120056,
-0.26492002606391907,
0.15322355926036835,
0.4627724587917328,
-0.35876601934432983,
-0.30953556299209595,
0.10808286815881729,
0.4649200141429901,
-0.490714430809021,
0.3187185823917389,
-0.1037660539150238,
-0.12560488283634186,
0.563391387462616,
0.12306579202413559,
0.37397506833076477,
-0.48059314489364624,
-0.31448742747306824,
-0.2507811188697815,
-0.5825174450874329,
-0.04111481085419655,
0.22427986562252045,
0.25697341561317444,
-0.023063013330101967,
0.38061803579330444,
-0.013770774006843567,
0.7340903282165527,
-0.19629229605197906,
-0.01713421195745468,
0.215226411819458,
-0.3947603404521942,
-0.08000431954860687,
-0.4634186923503876,
0.9400447607040405,
0.7478317618370056,
-0.14195601642131805,
-0.3341376483440399,
-0.3639114201068878,
0.06733494251966476,
0.5476847887039185,
-0.6653554439544678,
-0.3142799437046051,
0.23030170798301697,
-0.40642985701560974,
-0.24792097508907318,
-0.300677627325058,
-0.9373238682746887,
-0.37944310903549194,
-0.21308933198451996,
0.5091740489006042,
-0.5411442518234253,
-0.06935229152441025,
0.08343830704689026,
-0.26053550839424133,
-0.15751704573631287,
0.6804412007331848,
-0.516444206237793,
0.3673887848854065,
0.6634780168533325,
1.0636777877807617,
-0.6282162070274353,
-0.24323779344558716,
-0.5022187232971191,
-0.08370743691921234,
-0.8584772348403931,
1.0877931118011475,
-0.5976794958114624,
-0.29178234934806824,
0.023743312805891037,
-0.1849367618560791,
-0.03143608197569847,
-0.8037029504776001,
0.7787301540374756,
-0.6140958070755005,
-0.0937289372086525,
-0.3145492672920227,
-0.5883986353874207,
-0.09028511494398117,
0.39670899510383606,
-0.8441235423088074,
1.4630446434020996,
0.45624369382858276,
-0.6110601425170898,
0.51631760597229,
-0.5849347114562988,
-0.04322175309062004,
0.12553031742572784,
-0.08932016789913177,
-0.5088350772857666,
0.3158663213253021,
0.6508033275604248,
0.5423952341079712,
-0.5446105599403381,
0.36212921142578125,
-0.33897364139556885,
-0.5134063363075256,
0.2624024748802185,
-0.43769198656082153,
0.47315284609794617,
0.19944150745868683,
-0.0027001616545021534,
0.4096083641052246,
-0.7783964276313782,
0.03301975131034851,
0.20589272677898407,
-0.4794749617576599,
-0.5505521297454834,
0.1301790326833725,
0.5181424021720886,
-0.06455051898956299,
-0.09315971285104752,
-0.280274897813797,
0.27949458360671997,
-0.29746970534324646,
0.45261818170547485,
0.8404138088226318,
-0.005296557210385799,
0.4925573766231537,
-0.3845144510269165,
0.5904204249382019,
-0.07574158161878586,
0.19156047701835632,
-0.33860722184181213,
-0.13192932307720184,
-0.7341210246086121,
-0.6586943864822388,
0.4786922335624695,
0.4140271544456482,
-1.0455149412155151,
0.5036836266517639,
-0.5021188855171204,
-0.7823700308799744,
-0.857820451259613,
0.2501671612262726,
0.33093684911727905,
0.2894056439399719,
0.5230126976966858,
-0.4298485815525055,
-0.04880126193165779,
-1.0412613153457642,
-0.447299987077713,
0.1321163922548294,
-0.17147673666477203,
0.3821755051612854,
0.18446581065654755,
0.003387096570804715,
0.9062939286231995,
-0.3973844051361084,
-0.19809594750404358,
-0.1854342371225357,
0.03595366328954697,
0.3196336328983307,
0.5687715411186218,
0.7709590196609497,
-0.6327998638153076,
-0.6056509613990784,
-0.20789209008216858,
-0.6441567540168762,
-0.21447426080703735,
-0.3948923349380493,
-0.4458875358104706,
0.06452865153551102,
0.40673404932022095,
-0.22693218290805817,
0.18554024398326874,
0.39227965474128723,
-0.02781449258327484,
0.348131388425827,
-0.09565921872854233,
0.5124232769012451,
-1.1830908060073853,
0.07466886192560196,
0.32571685314178467,
-0.37774795293807983,
-0.31816378235816956,
0.29227960109710693,
0.44837626814842224,
0.04014003649353981,
-0.3638807237148285,
0.5791212320327759,
-0.5415799617767334,
-0.25678879022598267,
-0.18844157457351685,
0.12533794343471527,
0.23339512944221497,
0.3665103316307068,
-0.06760022044181824,
0.9121605753898621,
0.7242875099182129,
-0.24983175098896027,
0.21980760991573334,
0.1642407476902008,
-0.7998961806297302,
0.7383161783218384,
-0.5351566672325134,
0.21461249887943268,
0.0016041949857026339,
0.044094156473875046,
-1.0542356967926025,
0.08399396389722824,
-0.08831296861171722,
-0.22650840878486633,
0.2437339872121811,
-0.25004756450653076,
-0.9607976675033569,
-0.21702586114406586,
-0.6817816495895386,
0.31895092129707336,
0.6141407489776611,
-0.6496022343635559,
0.5158261060714722,
0.3401484489440918,
-0.21294283866882324,
-0.43296825885772705,
-0.3280261158943176,
0.3511585295200348,
-0.319349467754364,
-0.19821426272392273,
0.34529900550842285,
-0.14164623618125916,
-0.004636853002011776,
0.06149394437670708,
-0.0203925222158432,
-0.07404140383005142,
0.2860449254512787,
0.09698949009180069,
0.270336776971817,
-0.006771836429834366,
0.09284687787294388,
0.27446773648262024,
-0.08214311301708221,
-0.3067934811115265,
-0.12057073414325714,
0.5672156810760498,
0.12037741392850876,
-0.4543472230434418,
-0.39481037855148315,
0.29220396280288696,
0.45193007588386536,
-0.054198820143938065,
0.3069571852684021,
0.5357930660247803,
-0.3196065127849579,
-0.4044606387615204,
-0.6312777400016785,
0.10084713250398636,
-0.49876850843429565,
0.587177038192749,
-0.3028373420238495,
-0.5742201805114746,
0.45439866185188293,
-0.17104481160640717,
0.3053082227706909,
0.44834479689598083,
0.7260882258415222,
0.07119158655405045,
0.8933612704277039,
0.5868180394172668,
-0.1555168181657791,
0.5209273099899292,
-0.310271680355072,
-0.10434610396623611,
-0.9355574250221252,
0.06840948760509491,
-0.4720548987388611,
-0.3205474019050598,
-0.22618907690048218,
-0.7624427080154419,
0.6547526121139526,
0.3141601085662842,
0.04917158931493759,
0.29643920063972473,
-0.7367085814476013,
0.6168957352638245,
0.5571582317352295,
0.24223102629184723,
0.41063210368156433,
0.240764319896698,
-0.061207085847854614,
-0.13868467509746552,
-0.7946577668190002,
-0.4774757921695709,
1.3798468112945557,
0.2774490714073181,
0.8078249096870422,
0.14119833707809448,
0.4423435926437378,
0.45122283697128296,
0.7085374593734741,
-0.9268395900726318,
0.5363926887512207,
-0.2726655602455139,
-0.24584457278251648,
-0.06908957660198212,
-0.36343303322792053,
-0.8235177993774414,
0.25662288069725037,
-0.3560485541820526,
-0.5225023627281189,
0.11838497221469879,
0.06964075565338135,
-0.3650161325931549,
0.1071341335773468,
-0.6239674687385559,
0.6962966322898865,
-0.012965825386345387,
-0.7466024160385132,
-0.2360813468694687,
-0.20182494819164276,
0.3384663164615631,
-0.4919109344482422,
0.2596786320209503,
-0.23903009295463562,
-0.27451321482658386,
0.8380762338638306,
-0.16483469307422638,
0.5450506806373596,
-0.0038623311556875706,
-0.03096145950257778,
0.10617831349372864,
0.16086576879024506,
0.1460265964269638,
0.07385121285915375,
-0.45688602328300476,
0.28043434023857117,
0.046557292342185974,
-0.44762006402015686,
-0.7486209273338318,
0.8815155625343323,
-0.6898918747901917,
-0.30666583776474,
-0.15742293000221252,
-0.6384755373001099,
-0.2750917077064514,
0.043022844940423965,
0.20768818259239197,
0.4631674289703369,
-0.0015510738594457507,
0.1749480664730072,
0.05453472584486008,
-0.6533272862434387,
0.4815081059932709,
0.5472930073738098,
-0.2824018895626068,
-0.7760594487190247,
0.8538321256637573,
0.17201650142669678,
0.2045065015554428,
0.23787285387516022,
0.13328154385089874,
-0.40736037492752075,
-0.8205934166908264,
-0.7716839909553528,
0.06330283731222153,
-0.9479705691337585,
-0.47613486647605896,
-0.7005460262298584,
0.051744889467954636,
-0.25755003094673157,
-0.3840693533420563,
-0.5876583456993103,
-0.2332809418439865,
-0.1717856228351593,
0.17931336164474487,
0.4881337285041809,
0.4545137584209442,
0.22629959881305695,
0.3369031846523285,
-0.7677858471870422,
0.2345811128616333,
-0.1146644577383995,
0.5400897860527039,
0.2302292436361313,
-0.5611618757247925,
-0.28314584493637085,
-0.408683180809021,
-0.4965561330318451,
-0.9384071230888367,
0.5513120889663696,
0.3385555148124695,
0.6037269830703735,
0.09092820435762405,
0.10190016031265259,
0.8255129456520081,
-0.6714994311332703,
0.9075306057929993,
0.12533757090568542,
-0.9718416929244995,
0.5453716516494751,
-0.3574325144290924,
0.19303055107593536,
0.8073228001594543,
0.3799406588077545,
-0.42812347412109375,
-0.5268563032150269,
-0.47653988003730774,
-1.1911956071853638,
0.5056955814361572,
0.21175965666770935,
0.18404190242290497,
0.044695351272821426,
0.4867129623889923,
0.11456955224275589,
0.15133701264858246,
-0.753234326839447,
0.017988866195082664,
-0.06918293237686157,
-0.44033628702163696,
-0.2541975975036621,
-0.17067649960517883,
-0.1727253645658493,
-0.3202149271965027,
0.6052612066268921,
-0.3647845983505249,
0.23883475363254547,
0.09578705579042435,
-0.3179590404033661,
0.06399013847112656,
0.20253118872642517,
0.17774687707424164,
0.5903995037078857,
-0.05610105022788048,
-0.05425727739930153,
0.06154034286737442,
-0.28214672207832336,
-0.0003715847269631922,
-0.05876293405890465,
-0.18351545929908752,
0.026096608489751816,
0.43504440784454346,
0.7701545357704163,
0.36447200179100037,
-0.8957639336585999,
0.6970653533935547,
-0.038098130375146866,
0.014208444394171238,
-0.010872756130993366,
-0.008772083558142185,
0.04961223900318146,
0.1550673097372055,
0.28107425570487976,
0.011778824031352997,
0.4144563376903534,
-0.313320130109787,
0.13807564973831177,
0.472322940826416,
-0.2544650435447693,
-0.17042987048625946,
0.5502001643180847,
-0.09889960289001465,
-0.1485888957977295,
0.4988236427307129,
0.0036278220359236,
-0.3541821241378784,
0.576309323310852,
0.498730331659317,
0.8490689396858215,
0.11193457245826721,
0.05346851050853729,
0.5010510087013245,
0.28682348132133484,
-0.15723571181297302,
0.11163445562124252,
-0.07156384736299515,
-0.5474028587341309,
-0.4228501319885254,
-0.8084400296211243,
-0.5478197932243347,
-0.012760085985064507,
-0.6578244566917419,
0.4446474611759186,
-0.4013645648956299,
-0.15935857594013214,
0.024100033566355705,
-0.22827447950839996,
-0.4628233313560486,
0.007105597760528326,
-0.2918808162212372,
1.165231704711914,
-0.9417084455490112,
0.6277434825897217,
0.5123241543769836,
-0.2532860040664673,
-0.7664322257041931,
-0.14034754037857056,
-0.04872284084558487,
-0.7524933218955994,
0.3807167708873749,
0.11930975317955017,
0.33607032895088196,
0.16443414986133575,
-0.5131266117095947,
-0.7853159308433533,
1.034388542175293,
0.3977683186531067,
-0.6258652806282043,
0.2982158362865448,
-0.2306380420923233,
0.5679768323898315,
-0.03662687912583351,
0.49336498975753784,
0.5969313979148865,
0.34929385781288147,
0.07620541751384735,
-0.7767444849014282,
-0.029699040576815605,
-0.5382525324821472,
0.3057401478290558,
0.11357425898313522,
-0.4065801501274109,
0.6636963486671448,
0.23443850874900818,
-0.282537579536438,
0.2780798077583313,
0.3366507589817047,
0.3658289909362793,
0.2902417778968811,
0.531059205532074,
0.6511372923851013,
0.5273162126541138,
-0.1388159692287445,
1.1415616273880005,
-0.47682127356529236,
0.5293131470680237,
0.845556914806366,
-0.26351091265678406,
1.1980599164962769,
0.37688934803009033,
-0.28571587800979614,
0.20697800815105438,
0.922183632850647,
-0.3629852533340454,
0.600809633731842,
0.2881111800670624,
-0.05885087326169014,
-0.20080718398094177,
0.007189875468611717,
-0.1177595779299736,
0.27707940340042114,
0.21224580705165863,
-0.1983218789100647,
-0.4918447732925415,
0.15865077078342438,
-0.16004633903503418,
0.3699956238269806,
-0.3370562791824341,
0.9803184866905212,
-0.15965014696121216,
-0.6329530477523804,
0.9368623495101929,
0.11621381342411041,
0.8812699913978577,
-0.3510816991329193,
0.018443448469042778,
-0.19475410878658295,
-0.014166499488055706,
-0.12612015008926392,
-0.6140127778053284,
0.23765859007835388,
0.21998092532157898,
-0.09813684225082397,
-0.2559138536453247,
0.6552870869636536,
-0.30926597118377686,
-0.801496684551239,
0.1288309395313263,
0.4518864154815674,
0.166383758187294,
-0.1838112473487854,
-0.8763709664344788,
0.4313579797744751,
-0.35224905610084534,
-0.2681930661201477,
0.2843834161758423,
0.045976247638463974,
-0.22937586903572083,
0.5985551476478577,
0.8657146692276001,
0.18259446322917938,
-0.021400606259703636,
0.20205077528953552,
0.9597105383872986,
-0.5513972043991089,
-0.4544723927974701,
-0.8938013911247253,
0.5140047669410706,
-0.2176012545824051,
-0.0740794762969017,
0.7709983587265015,
0.8951444029808044,
0.43262940645217896,
-0.07819167524576187,
0.710839569568634,
0.33570346236228943,
0.5864002704620361,
-0.7774507999420166,
0.9322091341018677,
-0.907680094242096,
0.4594476521015167,
-0.600691020488739,
-1.0816760063171387,
-0.48855382204055786,
0.48489946126937866,
-0.3278394639492035,
-0.04902051389217377,
0.5576765537261963,
0.9632251262664795,
-0.1400647759437561,
-0.2971686124801636,
0.38892224431037903,
0.116555355489254,
0.46382829546928406,
0.5199587941169739,
0.9589341282844543,
-0.5077056884765625,
0.06564391404390335,
-0.15899163484573364,
-0.34774014353752136,
-0.11795483529567719,
-1.1591899394989014,
-0.5474300980567932,
-0.5443052649497986,
-0.482149600982666,
-0.25056537985801697,
-0.08129362016916275,
0.932283878326416,
0.8076964616775513,
-0.5445424318313599,
-0.12475944310426712,
0.13737818598747253,
0.01547357439994812,
-0.37185078859329224,
-0.23769520223140717,
0.7909637093544006,
-0.4943041503429413,
-1.1460269689559937,
0.5201026201248169,
0.6095182299613953,
-0.2462211549282074,
-0.1824232041835785,
0.2600121796131134,
0.10569553822278976,
0.1528683602809906,
0.7432358264923096,
-0.19553129374980927,
-0.6875053644180298,
0.015995122492313385,
-0.04655592516064644,
-0.13593275845050812,
0.2800292670726776,
0.5819535851478577,
-0.8276484608650208,
0.44675692915916443,
0.32301732897758484,
1.0168386697769165,
0.18322783708572388,
0.035345979034900665,
0.252267986536026,
-0.686288058757782,
0.08971856534481049,
0.16508734226226807,
0.30497509241104126,
0.5906533002853394,
-0.23383942246437073,
0.5406213998794556,
0.2793591022491455,
-0.4034307301044464,
-1.1758437156677246,
-0.06766147166490555,
-1.445014476776123,
-0.41050758957862854,
1.216008186340332,
-0.15008999407291412,
-0.18947696685791016,
0.20495083928108215,
-0.288281112909317,
-0.06659288704395294,
-0.3446076214313507,
0.8092750310897827,
0.656059980392456,
0.17614920437335968,
-0.3455977439880371,
-0.7649425268173218,
0.31584250926971436,
0.49080297350883484,
-1.022618055343628,
0.04338931664824486,
0.6718173027038574,
0.39480429887771606,
0.037360820919275284,
0.7427375912666321,
-0.28585031628608704,
0.2267109602689743,
-0.2666516602039337,
-0.008299191482365131,
0.004602312576025724,
-0.2636694014072418,
-0.4871523082256317,
0.29509568214416504,
0.2359255701303482,
0.01793382503092289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14928v1 | Autonomous Agents for Collaborative Task under Information Asymmetry | 2024-06-21T07:37:19 | 2024-06-21T07:37:19 | Wei Liu, Chenxi Wang, Yifei Wang, Zihao Xie, Rennai Qiu, Yufan Dang, Zhuoyun Du, Weize Chen, Cheng Yang, Chen Qian | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MA, cs.SI | Large Language Model Multi-Agent Systems (LLM-MAS) have achieved great
progress in solving complex tasks. It performs communication among agents
within the system to collaboratively solve tasks, under the premise of shared
information. However, when agents' communication is leveraged to enhance human
cooperation, a new challenge arises due to information asymmetry, since each
agent can only access the information of its human user. Previous MAS struggle
to complete tasks under this condition. To address this, we propose a new MAS
paradigm termed iAgents, which denotes Informative Multi-Agent Systems. In
iAgents, the human social network is mirrored in the agent network, where
agents proactively exchange human information necessary for task resolution,
thereby overcoming information asymmetry. iAgents employs a novel agent
reasoning mechanism, InfoNav, to navigate agents' communication towards
effective information exchange. Together with InfoNav, iAgents organizes human
information in a mixed memory to provide agents with accurate and comprehensive
information for exchange. Additionally, we introduce InformativeBench, the
first benchmark tailored for evaluating LLM agents' task-solving ability under
information asymmetry. Experimental results show that iAgents can collaborate
within a social network of 140 individuals and 588 relationships, autonomously
communicate over 30 turns, and retrieve information from nearly 70,000 messages
to complete tasks within 3 minutes. | [
-0.4961181879043579,
-0.4323236048221588,
0.5713719129562378,
0.4276954233646393,
-0.12260574102401733,
0.2398783266544342,
-0.5318354368209839,
-0.6358495950698853,
0.6824874877929688,
0.3676011264324188,
-0.8608219623565674,
-0.3032364845275879,
-0.6291682720184326,
0.01603974960744381,
-0.37969860434532166,
0.6612926125526428,
-0.010210971347987652,
0.09161246567964554,
-0.4107967019081116,
-0.35544779896736145,
-0.20785222947597504,
-0.35062095522880554,
-0.8114386200904846,
-0.6139019131660461,
0.41633057594299316,
0.6698313355445862,
0.7634077668190002,
0.7968389987945557,
0.6317920088768005,
0.4478945732116699,
0.39503616094589233,
0.404656320810318,
-0.19184865057468414,
0.607099711894989,
-0.49544575810432434,
-0.47474581003189087,
-0.2018084079027176,
-0.200762540102005,
0.4245419502258301,
0.7844632863998413,
-0.00297528225928545,
0.11930010467767715,
0.3974277973175049,
0.7070727944374084,
-0.7297074198722839,
0.48537278175354004,
-0.46024325489997864,
-0.3160175085067749,
-0.19654875993728638,
-0.319205105304718,
-0.27324625849723816,
-0.030745211988687515,
-0.138900026679039,
-0.8840271830558777,
-0.08515268564224243,
-0.010795061476528645,
0.54704350233078,
0.5526848435401917,
-0.30833563208580017,
-0.4837975800037384,
-0.8551315665245056,
0.534635603427887,
-0.3223806321620941,
0.17819151282310486,
0.5368120074272156,
0.16055072844028473,
-0.4430483281612396,
-0.22403456270694733,
-0.48695316910743713,
-0.26078417897224426,
0.15734198689460754,
0.15696072578430176,
-0.42980653047561646,
0.025597533211112022,
-0.0475977286696434,
-0.2362130731344223,
-0.38775375485420227,
0.08774854242801666,
-0.044969841837882996,
0.03218517452478409,
0.7426667213439941,
0.2773798108100891,
-0.005511772353202105,
0.13575142621994019,
-0.7778642773628235,
-0.12907126545906067,
-0.17659543454647064,
0.2418433129787445,
0.24314238131046295,
0.3696972131729126,
-0.12403250485658646,
0.7178658843040466,
-0.44607365131378174,
0.35837820172309875,
0.17177243530750275,
0.18550582230091095,
0.25264447927474976,
-0.642932116985321,
0.08782833814620972,
-0.07425513863563538,
0.8074250221252441,
0.2598113715648651,
-0.00603461405262351,
-0.1798861175775528,
-0.3138866126537323,
0.0634785145521164,
0.2584797143936157,
-0.3688341975212097,
-0.1420041173696518,
0.25589719414711,
-0.48331302404403687,
-0.07196526229381561,
0.2972210943698883,
-0.3392446041107178,
-0.8474567532539368,
-0.4972524642944336,
0.6229119300842285,
-0.3864661753177643,
-0.40969935059547424,
-0.08644403517246246,
-0.13348588347434998,
-0.14266188442707062,
0.7093107104301453,
-0.262074738740921,
0.6918863654136658,
0.46107879281044006,
0.695915699005127,
-0.3143448233604431,
-0.7058757543563843,
-0.56576007604599,
0.16172203421592712,
-0.17402639985084534,
0.7592458128929138,
-0.26546210050582886,
-0.09178478270769119,
-0.3626899719238281,
-0.11028231680393219,
0.010033697821199894,
-0.3932962715625763,
0.093094103038311,
-0.38388684391975403,
-0.22689339518547058,
-0.38548949360847473,
-0.42127346992492676,
-0.15595482289791107,
0.4198853671550751,
-0.6216038465499878,
0.4581807255744934,
-0.3812905550003052,
-0.6177411675453186,
0.031041257083415985,
-0.7095007300376892,
-0.15448155999183655,
0.14173485338687897,
-0.48246246576309204,
-0.040716446936130524,
-0.3314564824104309,
-0.15392223000526428,
0.46908918023109436,
-0.7801775932312012,
0.3774135410785675,
-0.3659769892692566,
-0.3380676507949829,
0.2802819609642029,
-0.21110834181308746,
0.7880154848098755,
0.2738461196422577,
-0.6739777326583862,
0.30749791860580444,
-0.4699060916900635,
-0.02456367015838623,
0.17067162692546844,
-0.35317543148994446,
-0.2642231285572052,
0.06040414050221443,
-0.1828431934118271,
0.003444080939516425,
0.8197813630104065,
-0.49723637104034424,
0.25390034914016724,
0.15642622113227844,
-0.18846864998340607,
0.8780020475387573,
-0.15240992605686188,
0.6185511946678162,
-0.684883713722229,
0.26764431595802307,
0.04787890985608101,
0.23143871128559113,
0.14498481154441833,
-0.3998316824436188,
-0.8649474382400513,
-0.2739280164241791,
-0.22132417559623718,
0.44042539596557617,
-1.1589112281799316,
0.5954208970069885,
-0.16031135618686676,
-0.5371385812759399,
-0.3340509533882141,
0.10609852522611618,
0.4712434709072113,
0.033172354102134705,
0.31563442945480347,
-0.4186471700668335,
-0.36014366149902344,
-0.851725697517395,
-0.2971770763397217,
-0.3349239230155945,
0.009883161634206772,
0.29319101572036743,
0.16259564459323883,
-0.46587738394737244,
0.743948757648468,
-0.0807502269744873,
-0.6115026473999023,
-0.17586657404899597,
0.3812316954135895,
0.2010260671377182,
0.498256653547287,
0.04043450579047203,
-0.7805929780006409,
-0.3303990364074707,
-0.015767863020300865,
-0.835071861743927,
-0.11453165113925934,
0.06681519001722336,
0.05185738578438759,
0.14726467430591583,
0.7303668856620789,
-0.7569683790206909,
0.43704211711883545,
0.35683709383010864,
-0.5333733558654785,
0.4667012095451355,
-0.45493006706237793,
0.2916722893714905,
-0.8214753270149231,
0.19037365913391113,
-0.1758624017238617,
-0.3057209551334381,
-0.47002243995666504,
0.06510823965072632,
-0.23877665400505066,
0.19536349177360535,
-0.0021403899881988764,
0.600791335105896,
-0.9193009734153748,
-0.1804586946964264,
-0.6217201352119446,
0.267918199300766,
-0.1605909913778305,
0.6132089495658875,
-0.198316290974617,
0.3003389835357666,
0.4555230140686035,
-0.5913822054862976,
0.7071785926818848,
0.09817467629909515,
0.023938683792948723,
0.7856447100639343,
-0.1783868670463562,
0.1656985580921173,
-0.4339652359485626,
0.4483984708786011,
-0.7831922769546509,
-0.30619314312934875,
0.3648245334625244,
-0.6913306713104248,
-0.10297694802284241,
0.1872512251138687,
-0.7491239309310913,
-0.00014396687038242817,
-0.20866993069648743,
0.39918163418769836,
-0.14686162769794464,
-0.4738735854625702,
0.8842400312423706,
0.3155486583709717,
-0.13364481925964355,
-0.8583254814147949,
-0.3806585967540741,
0.08871868997812271,
0.09373301267623901,
-0.7413177490234375,
0.08715210109949112,
-0.20116828382015228,
-0.6138011813163757,
0.5374412536621094,
-0.006821587216109037,
-0.2496652603149414,
0.07602090388536453,
0.5022307634353638,
0.16013233363628387,
0.060033779591321945,
0.42253923416137695,
-0.30511045455932617,
-0.26706355810165405,
-0.22236722707748413,
-0.2620222270488739,
0.7206464409828186,
-0.37983691692352295,
-0.6816778182983398,
-0.36082929372787476,
0.6507073044776917,
0.5775110721588135,
-0.17224404215812683,
0.8270081281661987,
0.36298611760139465,
-0.4348655343055725,
-0.12378552556037903,
-0.7976965308189392,
-0.30287113785743713,
-0.4617559313774109,
0.17135752737522125,
-0.4637235701084137,
-0.5492910742759705,
0.6150990128517151,
-0.08091914653778076,
0.1308990865945816,
0.16906405985355377,
0.4115510582923889,
-0.14781562983989716,
0.7786709070205688,
0.6910434365272522,
-0.13108286261558533,
0.39078614115715027,
-0.07269516587257385,
-0.12669704854488373,
-0.3092513680458069,
-0.4214649200439453,
-0.4743306636810303,
-0.5181121230125427,
-0.21168535947799683,
-0.5766354203224182,
0.5467076301574707,
-0.09670586884021759,
-0.5511889457702637,
0.46207478642463684,
-0.43824243545532227,
0.3479040265083313,
0.8654671907424927,
0.056329887360334396,
0.6400734186172485,
-0.25335127115249634,
0.09451880306005478,
0.3874422311782837,
-0.5745785236358643,
-0.16808821260929108,
0.8637099266052246,
0.07971059530973434,
0.991615355014801,
0.3144182562828064,
0.7330266237258911,
0.4214906394481659,
-0.02137928456068039,
-0.6821267008781433,
0.8314915895462036,
-0.02365410514175892,
-0.3364109992980957,
-0.4074954688549042,
-0.45401835441589355,
-1.4012393951416016,
0.23145252466201782,
-0.34964650869369507,
-1.0002104043960571,
0.3774130344390869,
-0.038041938096284866,
-0.0010285427561029792,
0.24303922057151794,
-0.516202449798584,
0.376177042722702,
-0.1438896358013153,
-0.37870675325393677,
-0.4781447649002075,
-1.0409666299819946,
-0.1420319527387619,
0.13209807872772217,
0.3967468738555908,
-0.21807904541492462,
-0.2941190004348755,
0.5393398404121399,
-0.3303031623363495,
0.6850593686103821,
-0.1507539451122284,
0.3284895122051239,
0.14282774925231934,
0.26176124811172485,
0.8402920365333557,
-0.2872273325920105,
-0.18718256056308746,
-0.017882445827126503,
-0.2913086712360382,
-0.40275052189826965,
-0.628875195980072,
0.667052686214447,
-0.8337118029594421,
-0.6355239152908325,
-0.36315733194351196,
-0.7740010619163513,
-0.17288650572299957,
0.2795217037200928,
0.44386518001556396,
0.3035902976989746,
0.12494153529405594,
0.34996044635772705,
0.21160347759723663,
0.4574739634990692,
0.328865647315979,
0.7161549925804138,
-0.011801470071077347,
-0.04534841701388359,
0.8118645548820496,
0.15725897252559662,
0.31958821415901184,
0.1436343938112259,
-0.05975106731057167,
-0.11049041897058487,
-0.3344435691833496,
-0.2601742446422577,
0.3080032765865326,
-0.8333320617675781,
-0.2469651848077774,
-0.7689107656478882,
-0.2316441833972931,
-0.040524207055568695,
-0.20850300788879395,
-0.7178688645362854,
-0.10456979274749756,
-0.3035264313220978,
0.44968917965888977,
0.014210146851837635,
0.9690626859664917,
-0.22855377197265625,
-0.00710713816806674,
-0.7077625393867493,
0.2788833975791931,
-0.05449379235506058,
0.18747669458389282,
0.14748117327690125,
-0.007162533700466156,
-0.34122225642204285,
0.15382440388202667,
-0.06417953968048096,
-0.8081468939781189,
-0.05406537279486656,
-0.29552292823791504,
0.8076240420341492,
0.44966188073158264,
0.37384799122810364,
0.4153444170951843,
-0.01106664352118969,
0.3366917669773102,
0.35191774368286133,
-0.8758556842803955,
0.15388008952140808,
-0.34945836663246155,
0.2670670747756958,
0.7335062623023987,
0.23526780307292938,
-0.32457828521728516,
-0.6733081340789795,
-0.7373588681221008,
-0.9927139282226562,
0.7915655970573425,
0.4419913589954376,
-0.4719860851764679,
0.3199065625667572,
-0.10405538231134415,
-0.013686810620129108,
0.40866604447364807,
-0.7240950465202332,
-0.31474757194519043,
0.29722651839256287,
-0.3845844268798828,
-0.025914635509252548,
0.34284624457359314,
-0.2542625069618225,
0.1373921036720276,
0.7356818914413452,
-0.17358329892158508,
0.4311780035495758,
0.25086262822151184,
0.13363312184810638,
-0.35324007272720337,
0.19203393161296844,
0.1867954581975937,
0.29369229078292847,
0.026263557374477386,
0.5567308664321899,
-0.25625529885292053,
-0.23702509701251984,
0.5815285444259644,
0.4024706184864044,
0.20419245958328247,
-0.21038810908794403,
0.22648672759532928,
0.43235036730766296,
-0.3267640173435211,
-0.6832150220870972,
0.8788279891014099,
-0.2474486082792282,
-0.07893151789903641,
-0.6316179633140564,
0.31036898493766785,
0.1908716857433319,
0.975376307964325,
0.48994117975234985,
0.6991295218467712,
0.1690398007631302,
-0.6064658761024475,
0.1416010707616806,
0.6866827011108398,
-0.44650453329086304,
-0.04164209961891174,
0.4452732801437378,
0.2330278903245926,
-0.48420435190200806,
0.25580185651779175,
-0.459647536277771,
-0.10380829125642776,
0.7830787897109985,
0.25297868251800537,
0.682564377784729,
-0.37569230794906616,
0.10429449379444122,
-0.06027824059128761,
0.3703652024269104,
-0.4194439947605133,
0.2049461305141449,
-0.3593086004257202,
-0.9488057494163513,
-0.08803150057792664,
0.03958742320537567,
-0.5472455024719238,
-0.04776401445269585,
-0.502894937992096,
0.2186947762966156,
-0.43515777587890625,
-0.1796640008687973,
-0.12315966933965683,
-0.03268715366721153,
-0.6951208710670471,
0.053507328033447266,
-0.08074676245450974,
0.38400229811668396,
-0.47349774837493896,
0.7464714646339417,
0.8758445978164673,
-0.1949501931667328,
-0.8770787119865417,
0.2712819576263428,
0.2569194436073303,
-0.6392474174499512,
0.6287363171577454,
0.24244901537895203,
-0.8055685758590698,
-0.05379806458950043,
-0.5978937149047852,
-1.1424437761306763,
1.2327734231948853,
0.404363751411438,
-0.29614126682281494,
-0.026057785376906395,
-0.10901517421007156,
0.32637953758239746,
-0.5206892490386963,
0.12915007770061493,
0.14018335938453674,
0.5634335875511169,
0.25309085845947266,
-1.0540480613708496,
0.2437632530927658,
-0.8525035381317139,
-0.51040118932724,
0.06514342874288559,
-0.8402467370033264,
1.0974980592727661,
-0.1701374053955078,
-0.25757989287376404,
0.2362719476222992,
0.40310797095298767,
0.27547940611839294,
0.4355178773403168,
0.8966515064239502,
0.08840461820363998,
0.8487580418586731,
0.24176500737667084,
0.773491621017456,
-0.16402769088745117,
0.05910327658057213,
1.3915189504623413,
-0.24796701967716217,
0.5049291849136353,
0.34077101945877075,
0.21610544621944427,
0.2722289264202118,
0.022667841985821724,
0.25593775510787964,
0.1768869310617447,
0.04530560225248337,
-0.5049435496330261,
-0.38165026903152466,
-0.5311396718025208,
-0.0438004732131958,
0.7115548253059387,
0.2587602436542511,
-0.02671145461499691,
-0.21687403321266174,
0.1588725447654724,
-0.03350017964839935,
0.23089927434921265,
-0.251377671957016,
0.8922576308250427,
-0.12576225399971008,
-0.9040168523788452,
0.32886990904808044,
0.11896385252475739,
0.571007251739502,
-0.5703787207603455,
0.05185845494270325,
0.30890753865242004,
0.4126085937023163,
-0.21825264394283295,
-0.7746057510375977,
0.020877130329608917,
-0.30237871408462524,
-0.12062624841928482,
-0.044921305030584335,
0.999229907989502,
-0.568055272102356,
0.036678608506917953,
0.7909839749336243,
0.7561530470848083,
0.0806037187576294,
-0.20463918149471283,
-0.5792674422264099,
0.03399255499243736,
-0.12149223685264587,
-0.07957715541124344,
0.18012486398220062,
0.29578733444213867,
-0.103693887591362,
1.1357169151306152,
0.482114315032959,
0.1338576227426529,
-0.27780425548553467,
-0.2821997106075287,
0.9573744535446167,
-0.4755702614784241,
-0.7083353400230408,
-0.6998311281204224,
0.389579176902771,
-0.27904069423675537,
0.19315750896930695,
0.7892315983772278,
0.3510630130767822,
0.6957816481590271,
0.3272791802883148,
0.7990034222602844,
0.017312629148364067,
0.6064518690109253,
-0.1614716351032257,
0.5482358932495117,
-0.6583415865898132,
0.4435933828353882,
-0.11482967436313629,
-0.8949431777000427,
0.055482104420661926,
0.4386589229106903,
0.025853067636489868,
-0.055385008454322815,
0.5582022666931152,
0.4840961694717407,
-0.025767775252461433,
0.23322047293186188,
0.049002811312675476,
0.2454024851322174,
0.24923275411128998,
0.48900383710861206,
0.9932505488395691,
-0.0021398526150733232,
0.5332550406455994,
-0.2043391466140747,
-0.49273544549942017,
-0.3332011103630066,
-0.3893637955188751,
-0.6837755441665649,
-0.9000635147094727,
0.05299101024866104,
-0.39302724599838257,
0.10306629538536072,
1.7002642154693604,
0.5482414364814758,
-0.2697916328907013,
-0.6628398299217224,
-0.22322311997413635,
0.0786520466208458,
-0.22305358946323395,
-0.22340406477451324,
-0.02380317635834217,
-0.13581247627735138,
-0.4650122821331024,
0.5293076038360596,
0.49482622742652893,
-0.09230493009090424,
-0.26734745502471924,
-0.09160870313644409,
-0.27155548334121704,
0.34807851910591125,
0.06554891169071198,
0.19143971800804138,
-0.4351649582386017,
-0.20786833763122559,
-0.06613687425851822,
-0.40508395433425903,
0.17928487062454224,
0.8357701897621155,
-0.4156418740749359,
0.7355784773826599,
0.22952529788017273,
0.6860764026641846,
0.43533962965011597,
0.24000956118106842,
0.44378387928009033,
-0.6491284370422363,
0.4678950905799866,
0.38005056977272034,
0.2579295337200165,
0.250540554523468,
-0.5788347721099854,
0.49587616324424744,
0.14081436395645142,
-0.5142695307731628,
-0.2813751995563507,
0.35584959387779236,
-0.9761276245117188,
-0.41757214069366455,
1.1398957967758179,
-0.27568575739860535,
-0.22048737108707428,
-0.533420205116272,
-0.17575350403785706,
0.3942444622516632,
-0.7319747805595398,
0.5588966012001038,
0.5138548612594604,
-0.4377228617668152,
0.0725165605545044,
-0.14194145798683167,
0.24083910882472992,
0.416923463344574,
-0.977799654006958,
-0.10747549682855606,
0.3588528633117676,
-0.10889415442943573,
0.5047227144241333,
1.2467387914657593,
0.350125789642334,
0.26120972633361816,
0.1801576167345047,
0.22441628575325012,
-0.24893824756145477,
-0.6878061890602112,
0.1019432321190834,
0.10900242626667023,
0.17567774653434753,
-0.3511548638343811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14917v1 | LLM2FEA: Discover Novel Designs with Generative Evolutionary Multitasking | 2024-06-21T07:20:51 | 2024-06-21T07:20:51 | Melvin Wong, Jiao Liu, Thiago Rios, Stefan Menzel, Yew Soon Ong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.NE | The rapid research and development of generative artificial intelligence has
enabled the generation of high-quality images, text, and 3D models from text
prompts. This advancement impels an inquiry into whether these models can be
leveraged to create digital artifacts for both creative and engineering
applications. Drawing on innovative designs from other domains may be one
answer to this question, much like the historical practice of ``bionics", where
humans have sought inspiration from nature's exemplary designs. This raises the
intriguing possibility of using generative models to simultaneously tackle
design tasks across multiple domains, facilitating cross-domain learning and
resulting in a series of innovative design solutions. In this paper, we propose
LLM2FEA as the first attempt to discover novel designs in generative models by
transferring knowledge across multiple domains. By utilizing a multi-factorial
evolutionary algorithm (MFEA) to drive a large language model, LLM2FEA
integrates knowledge from various fields to generate prompts that guide the
generative model in discovering novel and practical objects. Experimental
results in the context of 3D aerodynamic design verify the discovery
capabilities of the proposed LLM2FEA. The designs generated by LLM2FEA not only
satisfy practicality requirements to a certain degree but also feature novel
and aesthetically pleasing shapes, demonstrating the potential applications of
LLM2FEA in discovery tasks. | [
-0.5716220140457153,
-0.7836911678314209,
0.7882030606269836,
0.5107758641242981,
-0.13167046010494232,
0.36343276500701904,
0.4772125780582428,
-0.7054319381713867,
0.37193214893341064,
0.05818728730082512,
-0.9599506855010986,
-0.2263438105583191,
-0.4829246699810028,
0.08726438879966736,
-0.27315083146095276,
0.3448735773563385,
-0.2635151147842407,
-0.20470397174358368,
-0.38144949078559875,
0.11415711790323257,
-0.46456632018089294,
-0.4196343421936035,
-0.4546700119972229,
-0.49104079604148865,
0.6333400011062622,
0.3342495858669281,
0.2944034934043884,
0.19648326933383942,
0.3098270893096924,
0.2635990381240845,
-0.15006881952285767,
0.751825749874115,
-0.36270156502723694,
-0.04428242892026901,
-0.1625906527042389,
-0.3727168142795563,
-0.16170044243335724,
-0.13880884647369385,
0.30151814222335815,
0.4270104169845581,
0.08128741383552551,
-0.025469886139035225,
0.15659308433532715,
0.7750118374824524,
-0.3191230595111847,
0.36793962121009827,
-0.42372167110443115,
0.2746042311191559,
-0.3621869385242462,
-0.5617002248764038,
-0.2671028673648834,
-0.0714380070567131,
-0.14876726269721985,
-1.025955080986023,
0.20668278634548187,
0.04972538352012634,
0.5150467157363892,
0.1114044189453125,
-0.38835635781288147,
-0.48799243569374084,
-0.8646644949913025,
0.6794564723968506,
-0.37488019466400146,
0.6586652994155884,
-0.19444449245929718,
0.1758628785610199,
-0.4834021329879761,
-0.6741116642951965,
-0.6823899745941162,
0.024105196818709373,
0.1263848841190338,
0.11620776355266571,
-0.09579282253980637,
-0.2454342246055603,
-0.11093224585056305,
0.10585767775774002,
-0.7648494243621826,
0.27854275703430176,
-0.3625257611274719,
-0.1884312629699707,
0.6645558476448059,
0.10367097705602646,
0.5441153645515442,
0.12930716574192047,
-0.7774823904037476,
0.17984147369861603,
-0.8904435634613037,
-0.00914874766021967,
0.3351788818836212,
0.10732144117355347,
-0.17025336623191833,
0.7265673279762268,
-0.4003978967666626,
0.23458901047706604,
-0.27884766459465027,
-0.189999520778656,
0.578172504901886,
-0.35218098759651184,
0.18135012686252594,
-0.3156069815158844,
0.5980880856513977,
0.28065115213394165,
0.1021069884300232,
-0.2987631559371948,
-0.28366246819496155,
-0.006501561962068081,
0.4041960835456848,
-0.7781968116760254,
-0.1567400097846985,
0.2511790990829468,
-0.7031781673431396,
-0.55355304479599,
-0.015526637434959412,
-0.9778304696083069,
-0.5143957734107971,
-0.4174036681652069,
0.3850596249103546,
-0.020477328449487686,
-0.7163746953010559,
0.2063860297203064,
-0.4830798804759979,
0.10337090492248535,
0.26386433839797974,
-1.092282772064209,
-0.3790512979030609,
0.7881608009338379,
0.8866434097290039,
-0.22326916456222534,
-0.43833234906196594,
0.052945882081985474,
0.062025755643844604,
-0.44812774658203125,
1.293243646621704,
-0.3964482545852661,
-0.7505387663841248,
0.03857545554637909,
-0.1230001449584961,
0.20611006021499634,
-0.5883996486663818,
0.35831916332244873,
-0.7579221129417419,
-0.12859709560871124,
-0.20750677585601807,
-0.13402396440505981,
-0.5072386264801025,
-0.08371271193027496,
-0.8371409177780151,
0.7046177983283997,
0.09224805980920792,
-0.5456838607788086,
0.30282384157180786,
-0.8766155242919922,
-0.7106367945671082,
0.13810592889785767,
-0.5722904205322266,
-0.6721301078796387,
0.44044798612594604,
-0.0145948501303792,
0.15159769356250763,
-0.3946448564529419,
0.10516022145748138,
-0.5321380496025085,
-0.0567791573703289,
0.020047597587108612,
-0.23441685736179352,
0.8132661581039429,
0.2698586583137512,
-0.3663352131843567,
0.059339992702007294,
-0.5814232230186462,
0.12543334066867828,
0.5363289713859558,
-0.4141840934753418,
-0.2309718132019043,
0.0186395775526762,
0.24994665384292603,
0.39253607392311096,
0.18404445052146912,
-0.4550226926803589,
0.21092592179775238,
-0.3360566198825836,
0.4455995559692383,
0.7850505113601685,
0.18600042164325714,
0.3271823227405548,
-0.8326184749603271,
0.4313209354877472,
-0.20096002519130707,
0.014603309333324432,
0.03401295095682144,
-0.9421812295913696,
-0.5962924957275391,
0.029503008350729942,
-0.2484188675880432,
0.4584718346595764,
-0.987145185470581,
0.04833848029375076,
0.019872410222887993,
-0.5509974360466003,
0.018757056444883347,
0.3615714907646179,
0.07281841337680817,
-0.07026410102844238,
0.1403704285621643,
-0.06570745259523392,
-0.570438802242279,
-0.90959233045578,
0.017239324748516083,
-0.0033749400172382593,
-0.2672281563282013,
0.35884371399879456,
0.5902557969093323,
-0.47226542234420776,
0.6615604162216187,
-0.5501991510391235,
-0.2708588242530823,
-0.085340715944767,
0.5330802798271179,
-0.10567037016153336,
0.5144405364990234,
0.9718140959739685,
-0.8101701140403748,
-0.07184857130050659,
0.1410086452960968,
-1.1636297702789307,
0.0994717925786972,
-0.3127584159374237,
-0.5362722277641296,
-0.11789271980524063,
0.15205013751983643,
-0.9277362823486328,
-0.032480716705322266,
0.3881876766681671,
-0.1520645171403885,
0.49606800079345703,
0.18590164184570312,
-0.04584991931915283,
-1.1676557064056396,
0.01710795797407627,
-0.07423048466444016,
0.561463475227356,
-0.6061771512031555,
0.326949805021286,
-0.18968503177165985,
-0.12734989821910858,
-0.7293515205383301,
0.7285955548286438,
-0.6480726003646851,
0.052072253078222275,
-0.5481550097465515,
-0.08492379635572433,
0.2701430022716522,
0.5165137052536011,
0.08562170714139938,
0.9906963109970093,
0.37881797552108765,
-0.6744746565818787,
0.23114287853240967,
0.5034549832344055,
-0.3201155364513397,
0.3603835105895996,
-0.48279625177383423,
0.5803847908973694,
-0.38925960659980774,
-0.07553700357675552,
-0.8052303194999695,
-0.08400657773017883,
-0.006415901239961386,
-0.4832708239555359,
0.04889211803674698,
0.2730533480644226,
-0.36595839262008667,
-0.5643452405929565,
-0.37408944964408875,
0.5517475605010986,
0.08879438042640686,
-0.9607897400856018,
0.9546368718147278,
0.5549690127372742,
-0.45555344223976135,
-0.11284425854682922,
-0.4815036356449127,
-0.007314053364098072,
-0.08232148736715317,
-1.0401307344436646,
0.911310076713562,
-0.3823954164981842,
-0.2245437353849411,
-0.15828558802604675,
-0.24657411873340607,
0.09093267470598221,
0.37213146686553955,
0.2483319789171219,
0.26916518807411194,
-0.4341945946216583,
-0.06608125567436218,
0.29237881302833557,
-0.05229572579264641,
0.23987051844596863,
-0.37515968084335327,
0.5332274436950684,
0.05079164728522301,
-0.18475697934627533,
-0.5234165787696838,
0.760129451751709,
0.6956436634063721,
-0.19514647126197815,
0.332800030708313,
0.47013717889785767,
-0.7084522247314453,
-0.6525663733482361,
-0.3444111943244934,
-0.27614539861679077,
-0.5770721435546875,
0.3332344889640808,
-0.9277912378311157,
-0.7210832834243774,
0.2988596260547638,
-0.572862982749939,
0.36807942390441895,
0.5147811770439148,
0.7375935912132263,
-0.2744993269443512,
0.9079077839851379,
1.090185523033142,
0.30802223086357117,
0.5040708184242249,
-0.5862670540809631,
0.11770326644182205,
-0.8984305262565613,
-0.7166252136230469,
-0.5340887308120728,
-0.25587478280067444,
-0.3556756377220154,
-0.3724101781845093,
0.46039608120918274,
-0.09391094744205475,
-0.06369294226169586,
0.20038068294525146,
-0.43404799699783325,
0.4546046853065491,
0.7336161136627197,
0.146867036819458,
0.28904110193252563,
0.2570108473300934,
-0.4564145803451538,
0.4464000463485718,
-0.6380942463874817,
-0.46739280223846436,
1.1083869934082031,
0.21412666141986847,
0.730426013469696,
0.32753297686576843,
0.677727222442627,
0.3878697454929352,
0.2714875340461731,
-0.9276988506317139,
0.18882179260253906,
-0.12163110077381134,
-0.593384861946106,
-0.14503897726535797,
-0.2143724411725998,
-0.9072376489639282,
0.29029619693756104,
-0.3717813491821289,
-0.3373631238937378,
0.33692243695259094,
-0.05020784214138985,
-0.5625585317611694,
0.225961372256279,
-0.4996457099914551,
0.6007474064826965,
-0.5829079747200012,
-0.3572496473789215,
-0.27768614888191223,
-0.21748599410057068,
0.7122812271118164,
-0.2741428315639496,
0.3210098445415497,
-0.11775323748588562,
0.17486876249313354,
0.6946839690208435,
0.09604338556528091,
0.7404845952987671,
-0.03647845238447189,
-0.4485326409339905,
0.5389266014099121,
0.1635296642780304,
0.5285099744796753,
0.15003745257854462,
-0.07201720774173737,
0.13827133178710938,
-0.38643720746040344,
-0.16432851552963257,
-0.6144694089889526,
0.7936233282089233,
-0.8774340748786926,
-0.6204659938812256,
-0.2348814159631729,
-0.18623225390911102,
-0.31376194953918457,
0.3582015931606293,
0.12089841812849045,
0.24987384676933289,
-0.4179176688194275,
0.0929352268576622,
0.44990596175193787,
-0.046961888670921326,
0.4206992983818054,
0.5672292709350586,
0.006112697999924421,
-0.39402952790260315,
1.2258753776550293,
-0.14778631925582886,
-0.1059633269906044,
0.622390866279602,
0.06364940106868744,
-0.4685538411140442,
-0.841253399848938,
-0.7926478981971741,
0.07989111542701721,
-0.6330848336219788,
-0.18474021553993225,
-0.47315672039985657,
-0.4230310916900635,
-0.08727244287729263,
-0.3023551404476166,
-0.19284838438034058,
-0.40891149640083313,
-0.6327658295631409,
-0.24135378003120422,
0.10792432725429535,
1.2428845167160034,
0.10259924829006195,
0.03060365468263626,
-0.5788071155548096,
0.5629154443740845,
0.593456506729126,
0.2690480947494507,
0.18832440674304962,
-0.08843912184238434,
0.12051548063755035,
0.021964875981211662,
-0.6545772552490234,
-0.5461329817771912,
0.14858393371105194,
0.08659986406564713,
1.0079480409622192,
0.38166543841362,
-0.23430003225803375,
-0.004885885864496231,
-0.5759075284004211,
0.6060072779655457,
0.24806401133537292,
-0.4411958158016205,
0.38750261068344116,
-0.27972346544265747,
0.03916223347187042,
0.040482547134160995,
0.423841655254364,
-0.2507605254650116,
0.08734995126724243,
-0.33082079887390137,
-0.622337281703949,
0.20234373211860657,
0.21394489705562592,
0.22490400075912476,
0.2996087968349457,
0.26286470890045166,
0.4464293122291565,
0.05145014449954033,
-0.34657636284828186,
-0.15409709513187408,
-0.3744710385799408,
-0.16316454112529755,
0.17550250887870789,
-0.2821482717990875,
-0.2813842296600342,
0.10494420677423477,
0.6896202564239502,
-0.4157698452472687,
0.6745748519897461,
-0.10155583918094635,
0.13941408693790436,
-0.013398632407188416,
-0.031215697526931763,
1.154451608657837,
0.5714874863624573,
0.33359071612358093,
0.37623330950737,
-0.04287731647491455,
-0.3336639106273651,
0.3796160817146301,
0.0985291376709938,
-0.352014422416687,
-0.09157891571521759,
0.21958503127098083,
0.7036015391349792,
-0.09541270136833191,
-0.3465474247932434,
0.16184480488300323,
0.16124244034290314,
-0.5215532779693604,
-0.4051186442375183,
-0.0026781330816447735,
0.3759932518005371,
0.5299077033996582,
0.38382211327552795,
0.33938518166542053,
0.3229718804359436,
-0.5455633997917175,
0.49923017621040344,
0.723267674446106,
0.39939969778060913,
-0.43645766377449036,
1.1769487857818604,
0.6873433589935303,
-0.42367279529571533,
0.3607240319252014,
-0.2759798765182495,
-0.3047693967819214,
0.839935839176178,
0.6369559168815613,
1.06289541721344,
0.10635008662939072,
0.3371659517288208,
0.17202912271022797,
0.16944393515586853,
0.039985936135053635,
0.5051915049552917,
0.02330203540623188,
-0.9720078706741333,
-0.016309326514601707,
-0.7392370104789734,
-0.3461303114891052,
0.17053087055683136,
0.09404600411653519,
0.27233853936195374,
-0.4985141456127167,
-0.2025287002325058,
0.44608065485954285,
-0.19317862391471863,
-0.5989656448364258,
0.04851086065173149,
0.3564545214176178,
0.6865136027336121,
-0.6605443358421326,
0.5582631826400757,
0.47723451256752014,
-0.6252822875976562,
-0.27421391010284424,
-0.06773160398006439,
0.6096739768981934,
-1.1816316843032837,
0.7102150917053223,
0.2785624563694,
-0.6111380457878113,
0.11420390009880066,
-0.10123106837272644,
-0.9768753051757812,
1.2638952732086182,
-0.047503191977739334,
-0.43295207619667053,
-0.36792343854904175,
0.3251053988933563,
0.09191478788852692,
-0.4148029685020447,
-0.04635104537010193,
0.11376634240150452,
0.37329769134521484,
0.41893622279167175,
-0.5762795209884644,
0.08554966747760773,
-0.7723404169082642,
0.20629209280014038,
-0.08506888896226883,
-0.9833434820175171,
0.7708577513694763,
-0.727473258972168,
-0.5669107437133789,
0.4128618836402893,
0.8704537153244019,
0.5176505446434021,
0.34060975909233093,
0.2536328434944153,
0.31825751066207886,
0.7184323668479919,
0.08438219130039215,
0.6671715974807739,
-0.20261670649051666,
0.263935923576355,
0.5648260712623596,
-0.2944122850894928,
0.6345482468605042,
0.4226740598678589,
-0.19201654195785522,
0.5288115739822388,
0.6105014085769653,
-0.11915985494852066,
0.6723074913024902,
0.27679747343063354,
-0.6172207593917847,
0.035977803170681,
-0.062318820506334305,
-0.37195366621017456,
0.29240134358406067,
0.3060128688812256,
-0.185001939535141,
-0.04265814647078514,
0.27373218536376953,
-0.14304021000862122,
-0.2156766951084137,
-0.01835262030363083,
0.7786365747451782,
0.23696671426296234,
-0.41158294677734375,
0.6343359351158142,
0.18196198344230652,
0.8366380333900452,
-0.2922886312007904,
-0.41600874066352844,
-0.29983076453208923,
0.09616327285766602,
-0.19582302868366241,
-0.8420184254646301,
0.3347359597682953,
-0.3826771676540375,
-0.2923705279827118,
-0.2891639769077301,
0.5066467523574829,
-0.016275018453598022,
-0.6371148228645325,
0.31111767888069153,
0.7214146256446838,
-0.14336198568344116,
-0.09384751319885254,
-0.3632194697856903,
0.1991387903690338,
-0.12369534373283386,
-0.025129152461886406,
0.08744779974222183,
0.3495938181877136,
0.06047999858856201,
0.8784103393554688,
0.8370471596717834,
-0.358616441488266,
0.05614687129855156,
0.07233288884162903,
0.8941631317138672,
-0.5627078413963318,
-0.3429928123950958,
-0.49615880846977234,
0.45330268144607544,
0.1815478503704071,
-0.2636980712413788,
0.38558927178382874,
0.8217829465866089,
0.9100845456123352,
-0.5447067618370056,
1.2261863946914673,
0.010611404664814472,
0.10108324885368347,
-0.994549036026001,
0.6422036290168762,
-0.6980495452880859,
0.0596885085105896,
0.14692431688308716,
-0.6575581431388855,
-0.278557151556015,
0.5690497756004333,
0.38708996772766113,
0.16717831790447235,
0.7295141220092773,
0.9254639744758606,
-0.032362546771764755,
0.3972015678882599,
0.10005521774291992,
-0.08579954504966736,
0.6827255487442017,
0.7229013442993164,
0.953738272190094,
-0.1343001425266266,
0.3483933210372925,
-0.4286203682422638,
-0.4775775372982025,
-0.29323217272758484,
-0.6415360569953918,
-0.9296706914901733,
-0.7304922938346863,
-0.039376161992549896,
-0.03162216767668724,
-0.09848883748054504,
0.6580871343612671,
0.7382519841194153,
-0.8150500059127808,
-0.00946564506739378,
-0.46723368763923645,
0.1800784319639206,
-0.3914516866207123,
-0.2366381585597992,
0.09645624458789825,
-0.2707202136516571,
-0.6589497327804565,
0.9512636661529541,
0.13614356517791748,
0.5438296794891357,
-0.5835320353507996,
0.09593093395233154,
0.12240219116210938,
0.11142049729824066,
1.1240007877349854,
0.37596938014030457,
-0.7233187556266785,
-0.2059757560491562,
0.27775895595550537,
0.1849564164876938,
0.09416425973176956,
1.0210375785827637,
-0.5397239923477173,
0.12246114760637283,
0.6405155658721924,
0.8080441951751709,
0.45787525177001953,
-0.14657126367092133,
0.5684996247291565,
-0.3853228986263275,
-0.020784636959433556,
-0.11418606340885162,
0.39879506826400757,
0.08756111562252045,
-0.48814570903778076,
0.43977534770965576,
0.5829451680183411,
-0.2801840007305145,
-0.3670296370983124,
0.49374833703041077,
-0.8766138553619385,
-0.38298681378364563,
1.1640249490737915,
0.3362043797969818,
0.04776983708143234,
-0.0580395869910717,
-0.41745758056640625,
-0.15504445135593414,
-0.08968545496463776,
1.1718244552612305,
0.5038832426071167,
-0.5579226613044739,
-0.006862323731184006,
-0.623660683631897,
0.549109697341919,
0.06209507957100868,
-1.1249713897705078,
-0.04047735407948494,
0.16799703240394592,
0.4470524191856384,
0.46194949746131897,
0.4398241937160492,
0.013881497085094452,
0.33950355648994446,
0.2901425361633301,
0.037693336606025696,
-0.3080304265022278,
-0.8955338597297668,
0.22460563480854034,
0.5076701045036316,
0.2664937973022461,
-0.3055792450904846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14909v1 | MoA: Mixture of Sparse Attention for Automatic Large Language Model Compression | 2024-06-21T06:58:37 | 2024-06-21T06:58:37 | Tianyu Fu, Haofeng Huang, Xuefei Ning, Genghan Zhang, Boju Chen, Tianqi Wu, Hongyi Wang, Zixiao Huang, Shiyao Li, Shengen Yan, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Sparse attention can effectively mitigate the significant memory and
throughput demands of Large Language Models (LLMs) in long contexts. Existing
methods typically employ a uniform sparse attention mask, applying the same
sparse pattern across different attention heads and input lengths. However,
this uniform approach fails to capture the diverse attention patterns inherent
in LLMs, ignoring their distinct accuracy-latency trade-offs. To address this
challenge, we propose the Mixture of Attention (MoA), which automatically
tailors distinct sparse attention configurations to different heads and layers.
MoA constructs and navigates a search space of various attention patterns and
their scaling rules relative to input sequence lengths. It profiles the model,
evaluates potential configurations, and pinpoints the optimal sparse attention
compression plan. MoA adapts to varying input sizes, revealing that some
attention heads expand their focus to accommodate longer sequences, while other
heads consistently concentrate on fixed-length local contexts. Experiments show
that MoA increases the effective context length by $3.9\times$ with the same
average attention span, boosting retrieval accuracy by $1.5-7.1\times$ over the
uniform-attention baseline across Vicuna-7B, Vicuna-13B, and Llama3-8B models.
Moreover, MoA narrows the capability gaps between sparse and dense models,
reducing the maximum relative performance drop from $9\%-36\%$ to within $5\%$
across two long-context understanding benchmarks. MoA achieves a
$1.2-1.4\times$ GPU memory reduction and boosts decode throughput by $5.5-6.7
\times$ for 7B and 13B dense models on a single GPU, with minimal impact on
performance. | [
-0.5832494497299194,
-0.9452797174453735,
0.725029468536377,
0.5573066473007202,
-0.4353841245174408,
-0.05434885993599892,
-0.42838892340660095,
-0.39458900690078735,
0.5656951069831848,
0.5684673190116882,
-0.5813427567481995,
-0.15191154181957245,
-0.6972931027412415,
0.023944057524204254,
-0.3273176848888397,
0.5083463191986084,
0.18557588756084442,
-0.31600630283355713,
-0.2736290991306305,
-0.15138262510299683,
-0.8939998149871826,
-0.4398215413093567,
-0.5743725895881653,
-0.043832529336214066,
0.5956509709358215,
0.06321059912443161,
0.5458760261535645,
0.8434350490570068,
0.43698886036872864,
0.34632056951522827,
-0.3037690818309784,
0.34355437755584717,
-0.7949113249778748,
0.07533545047044754,
-0.15554659068584442,
-0.14920513331890106,
-0.38419920206069946,
-0.19471536576747894,
0.8655434846878052,
0.6658965945243835,
-0.2121896743774414,
0.24327540397644043,
0.2583276033401489,
0.6802023649215698,
-0.9636602401733398,
-0.08185219764709473,
-0.7281877398490906,
-0.1288810521364212,
-0.1271030455827713,
-0.37286368012428284,
-0.28009963035583496,
0.24221232533454895,
-0.006579885724931955,
-0.46938222646713257,
0.22743961215019226,
0.049141936004161835,
0.7073278427124023,
0.7335054278373718,
-0.2611740231513977,
0.25938889384269714,
-0.5996782183647156,
1.0511773824691772,
-0.5463966727256775,
0.3274821937084198,
0.34720268845558167,
0.10295890271663666,
-0.13867945969104767,
-0.35417652130126953,
-0.5198528170585632,
0.12382921576499939,
0.05060776323080063,
0.13832838833332062,
-0.13019303977489471,
0.1894516944885254,
0.34716466069221497,
0.5724892020225525,
-0.6925790309906006,
-0.05258819833397865,
-0.2654723823070526,
-0.05846542865037918,
0.39911484718322754,
0.17372757196426392,
0.3147410750389099,
0.10007034242153168,
-0.2820773124694824,
-0.119282566010952,
-0.6876488924026489,
-0.2256360650062561,
0.15240919589996338,
0.22353816032409668,
-0.15054306387901306,
0.48694297671318054,
-0.2754536271095276,
1.1477516889572144,
0.22526109218597412,
-0.40708091855049133,
0.02593970112502575,
-0.2952643930912018,
-0.6142119765281677,
-0.18023395538330078,
0.7464521527290344,
0.06223523989319801,
-0.03071960061788559,
-0.21963706612586975,
-0.32036903500556946,
0.05511966347694397,
0.2928284704685211,
-0.8139676451683044,
-0.0595480315387249,
0.3739430606365204,
-0.40227368474006653,
0.08224696666002274,
-0.13742516934871674,
-1.0291101932525635,
-0.22416344285011292,
-0.583442211151123,
0.43906664848327637,
-0.24066594243049622,
0.09075320512056351,
0.315935343503952,
0.1084456518292427,
-0.12507306039333344,
0.2659521996974945,
-1.0478191375732422,
0.3183034658432007,
0.5277012586593628,
0.9926354885101318,
-0.45011237263679504,
-0.1281571090221405,
-0.9247395992279053,
0.3154336214065552,
0.06353700160980225,
0.7978353500366211,
-0.8211216330528259,
-0.20593155920505524,
-0.14150957763195038,
-0.136912539601326,
-0.31794124841690063,
-0.6669966578483582,
0.291672945022583,
-0.5035524368286133,
0.005516325123608112,
0.013017057441174984,
-0.31418347358703613,
-0.1786119043827057,
0.23678533732891083,
-0.7344415783882141,
1.0140855312347412,
0.2683258354663849,
-0.5071388483047485,
0.10751646757125854,
-0.32083770632743835,
-0.5876160860061646,
0.15220974385738373,
-0.22280938923358917,
-0.13349409401416779,
0.20975404977798462,
0.4368378221988678,
0.5253890752792358,
-0.5400362610816956,
0.2738623023033142,
-0.38917991518974304,
-0.5910641551017761,
0.10039518028497696,
-0.3398030996322632,
0.6123486757278442,
0.1718447208404541,
-0.351515531539917,
0.31221723556518555,
-0.8658509254455566,
-0.12551124393939972,
0.13373085856437683,
-0.423252135515213,
-0.39825019240379333,
-0.10744506865739822,
0.24574390053749084,
0.28181490302085876,
0.4089411795139313,
-0.24511078000068665,
0.16725803911685944,
-0.3491373360157013,
0.5350783467292786,
0.6753368973731995,
0.03024933487176895,
0.4617733359336853,
-0.2088918834924698,
0.5910034775733948,
-0.12179267406463623,
0.012775992043316364,
-0.22649313509464264,
-0.3253772556781769,
-0.8422874212265015,
-0.7012828588485718,
0.2747069001197815,
0.4118955433368683,
-0.5165714621543884,
0.8580714464187622,
-0.4199795126914978,
-0.04649091511964798,
-0.5353012681007385,
0.5042861700057983,
0.3541658818721771,
0.27462130784988403,
0.3432864546775818,
-0.5172150135040283,
-0.5384308099746704,
-0.8426777124404907,
0.1642635613679886,
0.19739675521850586,
-0.24534955620765686,
0.5747680068016052,
0.12059502303600311,
-0.32290250062942505,
0.8148182034492493,
-0.6179390549659729,
-0.44350701570510864,
-0.25745323300361633,
0.00989905372262001,
0.07971818000078201,
0.3681459426879883,
0.5450024604797363,
-0.7179359197616577,
-0.4392329752445221,
-0.04874688386917114,
-0.25118860602378845,
-0.14587867259979248,
-0.23547673225402832,
-0.2740675210952759,
-0.05664554983377457,
0.223114013671875,
-0.616761326789856,
0.1725330501794815,
0.7926819324493408,
-0.02550356835126877,
0.13975957036018372,
-0.07264234125614166,
0.011143490672111511,
-1.1974526643753052,
0.2091965675354004,
0.23936739563941956,
-0.19990181922912598,
-0.3326628804206848,
0.31253495812416077,
0.09403108060359955,
-0.17420633137226105,
-0.31288838386535645,
0.744978129863739,
-0.5976744294166565,
-0.1304890215396881,
-0.4394373893737793,
0.0973137617111206,
-0.009599726647138596,
0.9304889440536499,
0.14658620953559875,
1.039432168006897,
0.5002668499946594,
-0.7221775054931641,
0.3134261965751648,
-0.0465613417327404,
-0.31066539883613586,
0.2431136816740036,
-0.7236922979354858,
0.3683328926563263,
0.0022532774601131678,
0.2430754452943802,
-1.116754412651062,
-0.44593778252601624,
0.16982467472553253,
-0.15331748127937317,
0.4421856701374054,
-0.12547917664051056,
-0.5831177234649658,
-0.15851470828056335,
-0.2600548565387726,
0.7464994788169861,
0.5566959381103516,
-0.45003750920295715,
0.8433750867843628,
0.5831042528152466,
-0.2416231632232666,
-0.5714220404624939,
-0.641144871711731,
0.1109207347035408,
-0.20048482716083527,
-0.7397292852401733,
0.4384876489639282,
-0.2941199243068695,
-0.2007964849472046,
-0.17160271108150482,
-0.07681799679994583,
-0.3051735758781433,
0.04343223199248314,
0.19584256410598755,
0.23596836626529694,
-0.3031952679157257,
-0.15792472660541534,
-0.0055600921623408794,
0.09960588812828064,
-0.22220805287361145,
-0.26863908767700195,
0.9682104587554932,
0.2935813367366791,
-0.0506325364112854,
-0.30329984426498413,
0.638299822807312,
0.6731582283973694,
-0.31975823640823364,
0.7131386995315552,
0.5045071244239807,
-0.45295479893684387,
-0.1515396237373352,
-0.7853521108627319,
-0.12312966585159302,
-0.45885732769966125,
0.3524211645126343,
-0.23650746047496796,
-1.0037821531295776,
0.6225191950798035,
0.3200971186161041,
-0.1029977947473526,
0.31241077184677124,
0.6905897855758667,
0.3133755326271057,
0.9635705947875977,
0.7607081532478333,
-0.567992627620697,
0.6991384625434875,
-0.012928355485200882,
0.14755669236183167,
-0.9705407619476318,
0.048716116696596146,
-0.4212903082370758,
-0.4443734288215637,
-0.07542011141777039,
-0.643997311592102,
0.2633107900619507,
-0.18279041349887848,
0.144792377948761,
0.19684380292892456,
-0.5942699313163757,
0.7682888507843018,
0.3708919584751129,
0.22378772497177124,
-0.030418120324611664,
0.22113224864006042,
0.4330873489379883,
0.09522753953933716,
-0.7565986514091492,
-0.019562510773539543,
0.8243551850318909,
0.2322133183479309,
0.8351771831512451,
0.0056480830535292625,
0.47082605957984924,
0.051130183041095734,
0.08404357731342316,
-0.9085143208503723,
0.6015240550041199,
-0.14075329899787903,
-0.285738080739975,
-0.3035539984703064,
-0.5621693134307861,
-0.9266288876533508,
0.3381026089191437,
0.09661552309989929,
-0.7691395878791809,
0.3156450688838959,
0.06337722390890121,
-0.7619361281394958,
-0.005826470907777548,
-0.670344352722168,
0.7259423732757568,
0.15669439733028412,
-0.40008744597435,
-0.3924381732940674,
-0.540611207485199,
0.6394485831260681,
-0.17922848463058472,
-0.04479503259062767,
0.0346052423119545,
-0.0923134982585907,
0.6074300408363342,
-0.08244416862726212,
0.8451684713363647,
0.319455087184906,
-0.20229694247245789,
0.2237699329853058,
-0.05407286807894707,
0.600780725479126,
0.0030366673599928617,
0.45378634333610535,
0.032593075186014175,
-0.29714834690093994,
-0.5037850141525269,
-0.5662572383880615,
0.8934724926948547,
-0.6855886578559875,
-0.6012628674507141,
-0.2557973861694336,
-0.9384791851043701,
-0.3068145215511322,
0.07610075175762177,
0.10316716134548187,
0.47583872079849243,
0.14995625615119934,
0.38500773906707764,
1.198271632194519,
-0.045519568026065826,
0.2941630184650421,
0.27248185873031616,
0.14267940819263458,
-0.44220149517059326,
1.0450119972229004,
-0.006561781745404005,
0.23033593595027924,
0.5339688658714294,
-0.05435623228549957,
-0.06617296487092972,
-0.6439813375473022,
-0.4336811304092407,
0.34437066316604614,
-0.5386977791786194,
-0.2757813632488251,
-0.9327121376991272,
-0.24556592106819153,
-0.6351748108863831,
0.04704494774341583,
-0.25074779987335205,
-0.12280865013599396,
-0.4372223913669586,
0.4736625850200653,
-0.014292948879301548,
0.285521000623703,
0.4320501983165741,
0.4220288097858429,
-0.8768749833106995,
0.5839172005653381,
0.4946608245372772,
0.21107086539268494,
0.12341032922267914,
-0.767488420009613,
-0.22031567990779877,
-0.19825251400470734,
-0.07384978234767914,
-0.5979495644569397,
0.7317044734954834,
0.11124438792467117,
0.4094220697879791,
0.5491231083869934,
-0.24219854176044464,
1.0721933841705322,
-0.36734724044799805,
0.6676220297813416,
0.14407896995544434,
-0.7391039729118347,
0.4282412528991699,
-0.35214605927467346,
0.5928475856781006,
0.40706026554107666,
0.07698007673025131,
-0.33471959829330444,
-0.38248807191848755,
-0.41410917043685913,
-0.9312455058097839,
0.8556668758392334,
0.15861189365386963,
0.07813436537981033,
-0.003828737186267972,
0.2548627257347107,
-0.06507527083158493,
0.05075618252158165,
-0.6075853705406189,
-0.13585254549980164,
0.3034703731536865,
-0.39192408323287964,
-0.12531107664108276,
-0.6504664421081543,
-0.3967364430427551,
-0.022273069247603416,
0.6306825280189514,
-0.2867654263973236,
0.31178221106529236,
-0.012717640027403831,
-0.33291634917259216,
-0.1784406453371048,
0.07784856855869293,
0.769474446773529,
0.6015912294387817,
-0.32828453183174133,
0.06509041041135788,
-0.005092136561870575,
-0.7413145899772644,
-0.03760070726275444,
0.21425168216228485,
-0.13394887745380402,
-0.14464807510375977,
0.21136003732681274,
0.7265896201133728,
0.2950051426887512,
-0.9694065451622009,
0.3212950527667999,
-0.12758314609527588,
0.013236142694950104,
0.11535656452178955,
0.2675217390060425,
-0.06238385662436485,
0.04200110584497452,
0.3190569281578064,
0.03043610043823719,
0.33866432309150696,
-0.45141756534576416,
-0.09645747393369675,
0.4016273319721222,
-0.06069878116250038,
-0.1460902839899063,
0.42093968391418457,
0.21434694528579712,
0.00965090375393629,
0.31478559970855713,
0.10526124387979507,
-0.22940611839294434,
0.7774561047554016,
0.5294404029846191,
0.9932776689529419,
-0.17442113161087036,
-0.3419898450374603,
0.282783180475235,
0.23891232907772064,
-0.2920506000518799,
-0.021270062774419785,
-0.3243972957134247,
-0.5146999955177307,
-0.774653971195221,
-0.7115224599838257,
-0.1663004606962204,
0.5424376130104065,
-0.5597667098045349,
0.1341162770986557,
-0.5958432555198669,
0.1361626535654068,
-0.03662766516208649,
-0.030971823260188103,
-0.38965606689453125,
0.3548738956451416,
0.27649936079978943,
0.677458643913269,
-0.6824649572372437,
1.005440592765808,
0.5631439089775085,
-0.25785210728645325,
-0.5200412273406982,
0.18923938274383545,
-0.13219331204891205,
-0.6980060338973999,
0.3885435163974762,
0.28534314036369324,
-0.1901288628578186,
-0.11186663806438446,
-0.5377184748649597,
-1.2064915895462036,
0.8211703896522522,
0.5525058507919312,
-0.8075186014175415,
0.13838452100753784,
-0.24465836584568024,
0.2832358777523041,
-0.33324021100997925,
0.017379317432641983,
0.5118329524993896,
0.1326311081647873,
0.2837243378162384,
-0.7872990965843201,
0.07565613836050034,
-0.2619730830192566,
0.1011262983083725,
0.2612781524658203,
-1.014551043510437,
0.7981951832771301,
0.10032741725444794,
-0.39275577664375305,
0.14600978791713715,
0.8277959823608398,
0.3170085549354553,
0.010431269183754921,
0.5754057168960571,
0.6441843509674072,
0.5815936326980591,
0.0886390209197998,
1.104234218597412,
-0.43748465180397034,
0.1757258027791977,
1.05231773853302,
-0.2727026343345642,
0.7511960864067078,
0.6133354902267456,
-0.1621750295162201,
0.08015485852956772,
0.7714058756828308,
0.2561957538127899,
0.6737282276153564,
-0.017440425232052803,
-0.28765493631362915,
-0.4763084053993225,
-0.09827495366334915,
-0.32297345995903015,
-0.0011479004751890898,
0.4091651141643524,
-0.2388399839401245,
0.10543069243431091,
-0.05682433769106865,
-0.37930184602737427,
-0.019109642133116722,
-0.4035916328430176,
0.6391981244087219,
-0.004649993497878313,
-0.873481810092926,
0.6938084363937378,
0.09982709586620331,
0.8419386148452759,
-0.6784660816192627,
0.0369388684630394,
-0.43427738547325134,
0.17226403951644897,
0.013552145101130009,
-0.5272125601768494,
0.06661897897720337,
-0.11660975962877274,
-0.5241115689277649,
-0.07428095489740372,
0.7153919339179993,
-0.6896352767944336,
-0.2587294578552246,
0.17645075917243958,
-0.010471108369529247,
-0.0337570458650589,
-0.4925292432308197,
-0.5914667844772339,
0.4650532901287079,
0.06916158646345139,
-0.2799582779407501,
0.79654860496521,
0.4246516823768616,
0.03443806245923042,
0.7527839541435242,
0.6208788156509399,
-0.0072729275561869144,
0.2495042085647583,
0.05707210302352905,
1.0670260190963745,
-0.5285940170288086,
-0.6837350130081177,
-0.7656733989715576,
0.13237887620925903,
-0.1163170114159584,
-0.23317235708236694,
0.49733877182006836,
0.4851878881454468,
0.5148654580116272,
-0.11818764358758926,
0.5752057433128357,
0.11454587429761887,
0.19876955449581146,
-0.8022214770317078,
0.33464154601097107,
-0.77200847864151,
0.12663599848747253,
-0.05979832261800766,
-1.2651855945587158,
-0.36942940950393677,
0.6064764261245728,
-0.03480838984251022,
0.08975709229707718,
0.6631824970245361,
0.6485847234725952,
-0.43984904885292053,
-0.43091946840286255,
0.4518353044986725,
0.08163800835609436,
0.06439439207315445,
0.9794776439666748,
0.4775052070617676,
-0.16343079507350922,
0.5174955129623413,
-0.19006961584091187,
-0.21060743927955627,
-0.4045235216617584,
-0.5843366980552673,
-0.9903765320777893,
-0.4166574776172638,
-0.30239221453666687,
-0.2707345485687256,
-0.11355085670948029,
0.90475994348526,
0.9409476518630981,
-0.7538482546806335,
-0.09299765527248383,
0.08956312388181686,
-0.10078799724578857,
-0.2258378118276596,
-0.26713553071022034,
0.39024803042411804,
-0.456849604845047,
-1.0656850337982178,
0.5595271587371826,
0.7029231190681458,
0.0023689856752753258,
-0.5090571641921997,
0.003554930677637458,
-0.16091881692409515,
0.22485767304897308,
0.6524026393890381,
0.33534500002861023,
-0.8897353410720825,
-0.057670410722494125,
-0.13519883155822754,
-0.35328465700149536,
0.06431766599416733,
0.8583902716636658,
-0.7690255045890808,
0.4068511426448822,
0.6071488261222839,
1.0573545694351196,
0.4563737213611603,
0.028700262308120728,
0.5397109389305115,
-0.9427757263183594,
0.67033851146698,
0.34532684087753296,
0.5834189653396606,
0.19979211688041687,
-0.6969031691551208,
0.4962030053138733,
0.35542163252830505,
-0.49224522709846497,
-0.8951576948165894,
-0.008799728937447071,
-1.6389057636260986,
-0.2735050320625305,
1.5842196941375732,
0.031901389360427856,
-0.6307845115661621,
0.051687516272068024,
-0.4363883435726166,
-0.08010268956422806,
-0.6069382429122925,
0.9495997428894043,
0.8747215867042542,
0.14799408614635468,
-0.31550872325897217,
-0.4480931758880615,
0.21871601045131683,
0.7247464656829834,
-0.7148897647857666,
0.2182905375957489,
0.650371789932251,
0.078705333173275,
0.20720143616199493,
0.4884698987007141,
0.16546405851840973,
0.39314505457878113,
-0.13692998886108398,
-0.04412971809506416,
0.12917731702327728,
-0.48101097345352173,
-0.45414137840270996,
0.36051541566848755,
-0.39581120014190674,
-0.1658223271369934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14898v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14898v2 | Safely Learning with Private Data: A Federated Learning Framework for Large Language Model | 2024-06-21T06:43:15 | 2024-06-26T04:28:38 | JiaYing Zheng, HaiNan Zhang, LingXiang Wang, WangJie Qiu, HongWei Zheng, ZhiMing Zheng | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Private data, being larger and quality-higher than public data, can greatly
improve large language models (LLM). However, due to privacy concerns, this
data is often dispersed in multiple silos, making its secure utilization for
LLM training a challenge. Federated learning (FL) is an ideal solution for
training models with distributed private data, but traditional frameworks like
FedAvg are unsuitable for LLM due to their high computational demands on
clients. An alternative, split learning, offloads most training parameters to
the server while training embedding and output layers locally, making it more
suitable for LLM. Nonetheless, it faces significant challenges in security and
efficiency. Firstly, the gradients of embeddings are prone to attacks, leading
to potential reverse engineering of private data. Furthermore, the server's
limitation of handle only one client's training request at a time hinders
parallel training, severely impacting training efficiency. In this paper, we
propose a Federated Learning framework for LLM, named FL-GLM, which prevents
data leakage caused by both server-side and peer-client attacks while improving
training efficiency. Specifically, we first place the input block and output
block on local client to prevent embedding gradient attacks from server.
Secondly, we employ key-encryption during client-server communication to
prevent reverse engineering attacks from peer-clients. Lastly, we employ
optimization methods like client-batching or server-hierarchical, adopting
different acceleration methods based on the actual computational capabilities
of the server. Experimental results on NLU and generation tasks demonstrate
that FL-GLM achieves comparable metrics to centralized chatGLM model,
validating the effectiveness of our federated learning framework. | [
-0.17011715471744537,
-0.7549246549606323,
0.2013109028339386,
0.317230224609375,
-0.05906663089990616,
0.3371029794216156,
-0.29336968064308167,
-0.3403323292732239,
-0.2534387409687042,
0.4877077639102936,
-0.40773439407348633,
-0.6454769372940063,
-0.4627700746059418,
-0.07265662401914597,
-0.3527255356311798,
1.0401475429534912,
0.09533768892288208,
0.28047269582748413,
-0.32405975461006165,
-0.30798572301864624,
0.0501997247338295,
-0.6630441546440125,
-0.5952906608581543,
-0.24273139238357544,
0.3042822778224945,
0.385127454996109,
0.640065610408783,
0.6726946234703064,
0.6054200530052185,
0.3614342212677002,
0.33745139837265015,
-0.03117114119231701,
-0.8927462697029114,
0.3648626208305359,
-0.1844821274280548,
-0.6318817138671875,
-0.4554130733013153,
-0.08766090869903564,
0.7743546962738037,
0.46568357944488525,
-0.39037826657295227,
0.09660482406616211,
-0.1831888109445572,
0.8676902651786804,
-0.6077430248260498,
0.5028827786445618,
-0.5224418640136719,
0.3367172181606293,
-0.2671836316585541,
0.1628827601671219,
-0.4834135174751282,
-0.37024301290512085,
0.1361561268568039,
-0.25295090675354004,
0.30001500248908997,
0.17232240736484528,
0.6428198218345642,
-0.06968642771244049,
-0.060736965388059616,
0.15199199318885803,
-0.632827877998352,
0.7601891160011292,
-0.5009417533874512,
0.6442723274230957,
0.49016496539115906,
0.5342469215393066,
-0.20797549188137054,
-0.604185163974762,
-0.19069379568099976,
0.13216723501682281,
-0.08654802292585373,
-0.18929193913936615,
-0.1241796538233757,
0.05116554722189903,
0.025983542203903198,
0.6212641000747681,
-0.6269716024398804,
0.45850375294685364,
-0.1142309382557869,
-0.25195252895355225,
0.8642756342887878,
0.007017913274466991,
0.23505651950836182,
0.41605421900749207,
-0.621941864490509,
-0.1949494481086731,
-0.8418363332748413,
-0.020682599395513535,
0.6380022764205933,
0.520399272441864,
-0.1769733726978302,
0.12163065373897552,
-0.2537895739078522,
0.3757275938987732,
0.10007664561271667,
-0.5806204676628113,
0.409635066986084,
-0.016155190765857697,
-0.5006942749023438,
-0.11434272676706314,
0.9112090468406677,
-0.07842805236577988,
0.021540656685829163,
-0.4935722351074219,
-0.43158334493637085,
-0.31343281269073486,
0.007853972725570202,
-0.9392692446708679,
-0.018351944163441658,
0.39834997057914734,
-0.24588777124881744,
-0.6945030689239502,
0.06556420773267746,
-0.897505521774292,
-0.35437527298927307,
0.005610493011772633,
0.14114844799041748,
-0.18542051315307617,
-0.4646430015563965,
-0.10345440357923508,
0.41088128089904785,
0.031061287969350815,
0.23513738811016083,
-1.1170494556427002,
0.6440750956535339,
1.060134768486023,
0.8805081248283386,
-0.16393868625164032,
-0.3152828514575958,
-0.9902040362358093,
0.022262996062636375,
0.07646331936120987,
0.10978925973176956,
-0.25779810547828674,
-0.2549579441547394,
0.38437554240226746,
0.15869943797588348,
-0.12855328619480133,
-0.1458776742219925,
-0.06647402048110962,
-0.7502673268318176,
0.5000874996185303,
0.04216410219669342,
-0.7495799660682678,
-0.21524648368358612,
0.1934499591588974,
-0.584420919418335,
0.22238485515117645,
0.035230666399002075,
-0.9775249361991882,
-0.008969524875283241,
-0.43029457330703735,
-0.4828647971153259,
0.19894129037857056,
-0.4851779043674469,
-0.9842841029167175,
-0.012148523703217506,
0.2527416944503784,
0.7582389116287231,
-0.1735348254442215,
0.515855610370636,
-0.5209740996360779,
-0.3223377466201782,
0.18055227398872375,
-0.3486086130142212,
0.8893270492553711,
0.15376609563827515,
-0.5595786571502686,
0.14382213354110718,
-0.6857163906097412,
-0.017050573602318764,
0.29554641246795654,
-0.4124264419078827,
-0.14173178374767303,
-0.0833386480808258,
-0.1067463830113411,
-0.015422871336340904,
0.13724982738494873,
-0.7025004029273987,
-0.07658253610134125,
-0.6377084851264954,
0.33615535497665405,
0.8692110776901245,
-0.05987532064318657,
0.756827712059021,
-0.3483709394931793,
0.5877060890197754,
-0.05169343203306198,
0.3669506013393402,
0.034341976046562195,
-0.301501989364624,
-0.3272598683834076,
-0.5227530002593994,
0.19889391958713531,
0.3869599401950836,
-0.5661534667015076,
0.22172433137893677,
-0.24735283851623535,
-0.4485276937484741,
-0.451750785112381,
0.35921281576156616,
0.5638328194618225,
0.38611361384391785,
0.0852387323975563,
-0.12280429154634476,
-0.12516139447689056,
-0.4942079782485962,
0.0567937009036541,
0.05445374175906181,
0.04883124679327011,
0.37474048137664795,
0.4250088632106781,
-0.2689729928970337,
0.7801896929740906,
-0.32393717765808105,
-0.5747029781341553,
-0.08337537199258804,
-0.13799625635147095,
-0.1267702579498291,
0.6992313861846924,
0.4997463524341583,
-0.8419992923736572,
-0.6030440926551819,
0.23770074546337128,
-0.6957436800003052,
0.20168627798557281,
0.07331153005361557,
-0.08802835643291473,
0.4634455442428589,
0.016666961833834648,
-0.3376519978046417,
0.18989773094654083,
0.7542822360992432,
-0.11521782726049423,
0.33695268630981445,
-0.283549964427948,
-0.2511674761772156,
-0.8559861183166504,
-0.017896568402647972,
-0.3476279675960541,
-0.5693112015724182,
-0.6286522150039673,
0.4973028004169464,
0.011218230240046978,
-0.46515601873397827,
-0.4393773674964905,
0.3356836140155792,
-0.47495242953300476,
-0.17538386583328247,
-0.24453167617321014,
-0.007094081025570631,
-0.15964877605438232,
0.5914243459701538,
-0.03639224171638489,
0.710114598274231,
0.8641714453697205,
0.03202790021896362,
0.5448164343833923,
0.19003039598464966,
-0.1670932173728943,
0.29192692041397095,
-0.3597392439842224,
0.43420469760894775,
0.0055892616510391235,
0.21472352743148804,
-0.5194181799888611,
-0.37733471393585205,
0.24625062942504883,
-0.15953122079372406,
0.4973856508731842,
0.016689568758010864,
-0.5470176935195923,
0.020100101828575134,
-0.302417129278183,
0.01557440310716629,
0.41446730494499207,
-0.8278468251228333,
0.38387036323547363,
0.44181331992149353,
0.09092950075864792,
-1.0430418252944946,
-0.7909243106842041,
-0.3574323356151581,
-0.16923220455646515,
-0.763680100440979,
-0.05120136961340904,
0.09169723093509674,
-0.2257222980260849,
-0.14985641837120056,
-0.13145077228546143,
-0.2657676935195923,
0.4182431995868683,
0.5794743895530701,
0.07351286709308624,
-0.24542562663555145,
0.0891905352473259,
0.044548675417900085,
-0.025629421696066856,
0.13394758105278015,
-0.3994227349758148,
0.5391852855682373,
-0.4852810204029083,
-0.3808359205722809,
-0.3973069190979004,
0.5150338411331177,
0.5223945379257202,
-0.3919726014137268,
1.3110384941101074,
0.6884986758232117,
-0.3308631181716919,
-0.5306378602981567,
-0.46717044711112976,
-0.2668657898902893,
-0.5296846628189087,
0.047593869268894196,
-0.011622723191976547,
-1.2574349641799927,
0.4626973569393158,
-0.037980057299137115,
0.32755276560783386,
-0.23086388409137726,
0.5144535899162292,
0.059415847063064575,
0.8054043054580688,
0.9001470804214478,
-0.33755725622177124,
0.5811022520065308,
-0.2107941210269928,
0.11839044094085693,
-0.15035514533519745,
-0.17710000276565552,
-0.20386090874671936,
-0.1315029412508011,
-0.6272352337837219,
-0.24162691831588745,
-0.012797768227756023,
-0.0314660482108593,
-0.262037068605423,
-0.15591885149478912,
-0.23686367273330688,
0.572915256023407,
0.3069082796573639,
0.1659906506538391,
0.3056449294090271,
0.37889519333839417,
-0.2152469903230667,
0.2728448510169983,
-0.5151669979095459,
0.04258181154727936,
1.1322296857833862,
0.7047696113586426,
0.8128694891929626,
0.19246485829353333,
1.1953587532043457,
0.08932244032621384,
0.381212055683136,
-0.354214072227478,
0.43488743901252747,
-0.06674142181873322,
-0.6118341684341431,
-0.3432033360004425,
-0.7974169850349426,
-0.6800132989883423,
0.49662449955940247,
-0.25569072365760803,
-0.7914445400238037,
0.14720121026039124,
-0.06720371544361115,
-0.11074541509151459,
0.4575900137424469,
-0.60983806848526,
0.6514686942100525,
-0.22180406749248505,
-0.6018581986427307,
-0.1155921146273613,
-0.7879384160041809,
0.47269558906555176,
-0.3779697120189667,
0.3747459948062897,
0.02771010249853134,
0.2571467161178589,
0.6347947716712952,
-0.769879162311554,
0.902896523475647,
-0.5501400232315063,
0.03355691581964493,
-0.08134090900421143,
-0.02897447533905506,
0.7354615330696106,
0.33500799536705017,
0.06364648044109344,
0.32790452241897583,
-0.36154040694236755,
-0.4779182970523834,
-0.5618653297424316,
0.944812536239624,
-0.9714635610580444,
-0.7914949059486389,
-0.46651414036750793,
-0.44985759258270264,
-0.2997685372829437,
0.25353771448135376,
-0.03536730259656906,
0.317546546459198,
0.048543624579906464,
0.504730224609375,
0.6472603678703308,
-0.16241079568862915,
0.31481054425239563,
0.7375606894493103,
-0.5871009826660156,
-0.558451771736145,
1.0145615339279175,
-0.05509839579463005,
0.5355583429336548,
0.3960806727409363,
0.35211876034736633,
-0.2647935748100281,
-0.6689157485961914,
-0.08536866307258606,
0.4240955114364624,
-0.60715651512146,
-0.38751423358917236,
-0.4690001606941223,
-0.2899329662322998,
-0.40773776173591614,
-0.19048228859901428,
-0.5242552757263184,
-0.1693788468837738,
-0.24155010282993317,
-0.37084847688674927,
0.43772628903388977,
0.21999789774417877,
-0.30956754088401794,
0.34797048568725586,
-0.6709466576576233,
-0.18788105249404907,
0.2509172856807709,
0.5880228877067566,
0.0999043881893158,
0.10619068145751953,
-0.1870644986629486,
0.10633779317140579,
0.09060303121805191,
-0.49576616287231445,
0.4375685453414917,
0.2950862646102905,
0.395232230424881,
0.6478667259216309,
0.161974236369133,
0.380946546792984,
-0.48368385434150696,
0.4076410233974457,
0.21279020607471466,
-0.7983601689338684,
0.2977534234523773,
-0.3452107310295105,
0.0317041352391243,
0.6453641653060913,
0.5049283504486084,
-0.18368475139141083,
-0.6372648477554321,
-0.6987402439117432,
-0.5949262976646423,
0.7233237624168396,
0.2153964638710022,
-0.09279592335224152,
0.470417320728302,
0.14787422120571136,
0.4013862609863281,
0.3934233784675598,
-0.7441326379776001,
-0.35424578189849854,
-0.16119569540023804,
-0.059973862022161484,
0.05489487946033478,
0.1391824185848236,
-0.43109020590782166,
-0.045040883123874664,
0.5530993938446045,
-0.09132387489080429,
0.16585330665111542,
-0.18772871792316437,
-0.07342660427093506,
-0.2890340983867645,
0.24302534759044647,
0.35802894830703735,
0.5274149775505066,
-0.1828426718711853,
0.07560524344444275,
-0.04635755717754364,
-0.5591139197349548,
0.2576987147331238,
0.317916601896286,
-0.22271345555782318,
-0.1137712150812149,
0.23471780121326447,
0.7291548252105713,
0.2648930549621582,
-0.4750083386898041,
0.8585565090179443,
-0.29584717750549316,
-0.28851187229156494,
-0.17127522826194763,
0.19149428606033325,
0.04452282562851906,
0.3402736485004425,
0.15817733108997345,
-0.030015965923666954,
-0.3537416458129883,
-0.24406024813652039,
0.2630704939365387,
0.41040584444999695,
-0.0772014930844307,
-0.25387880206108093,
0.5347098112106323,
0.2971516251564026,
-0.296866774559021,
0.6128953099250793,
-0.05080109089612961,
-0.4821476340293884,
0.16543792188167572,
0.5981367230415344,
0.7939197421073914,
-0.4701175391674042,
0.4453986585140228,
-0.21424739062786102,
0.09137795120477676,
-0.2067415714263916,
0.12875449657440186,
-0.48983070254325867,
-0.6348900198936462,
-0.13526596128940582,
-0.7360346913337708,
-0.4197216331958771,
0.2170228511095047,
-0.6542925834655762,
-0.21937693655490875,
-0.9482235908508301,
0.1290079802274704,
-0.41779807209968567,
0.29788264632225037,
-0.7164261341094971,
-0.03315427899360657,
0.2446211576461792,
0.7124998569488525,
-0.8369469046592712,
1.1608662605285645,
0.24479356408119202,
-0.2613498568534851,
-0.8094154596328735,
-0.2784835696220398,
0.07223669439554214,
-0.7652233242988586,
0.5833634734153748,
0.21745310723781586,
0.07816599309444427,
-0.19881075620651245,
-0.4451654553413391,
-0.7113498449325562,
1.1941837072372437,
0.4273312985897064,
-0.8949981927871704,
-0.09269348531961441,
0.5135956406593323,
0.595511257648468,
-0.3585822582244873,
-0.3049730956554413,
0.18518707156181335,
0.1380908042192459,
-0.14563345909118652,
-0.6935345530509949,
0.10940182209014893,
0.1828763335943222,
-0.19211743772029877,
0.049181416630744934,
-0.7590360045433044,
0.773278534412384,
-0.027938412502408028,
-0.47729694843292236,
-0.4128311276435852,
0.7790198922157288,
0.11522360146045685,
0.2619893252849579,
0.480164498090744,
0.2876598536968231,
1.133134126663208,
0.07493950426578522,
0.785720705986023,
-0.08289680629968643,
0.7531302571296692,
1.2065500020980835,
-0.43199533224105835,
0.8320993185043335,
0.37751060724258423,
-0.04246963560581207,
0.18834003806114197,
0.12529611587524414,
-0.027399396523833275,
0.8277198076248169,
0.1351538449525833,
-0.44265007972717285,
0.033097490668296814,
0.26341313123703003,
-0.4806484580039978,
0.48519402742385864,
0.262024462223053,
-0.5159631371498108,
-0.4739234447479248,
0.40412193536758423,
0.21952874958515167,
0.049264535307884216,
-0.14209502935409546,
0.7292245626449585,
0.1930382400751114,
-0.01274869218468666,
0.44740039110183716,
0.012667818926274776,
0.6126553416252136,
-0.6057418584823608,
0.35016486048698425,
-0.3831854462623596,
0.4817398488521576,
-0.43732643127441406,
-0.30809691548347473,
0.24014775454998016,
0.12202796339988708,
0.04735388606786728,
-0.4590405821800232,
0.7934744358062744,
-0.5684390068054199,
-0.22048474848270416,
0.385570764541626,
0.48633086681365967,
-0.0348040908575058,
0.2101697027683258,
-0.7079182863235474,
0.21859054267406464,
-0.047691743820905685,
-0.2890029549598694,
0.8958979845046997,
0.2184106558561325,
0.2139260172843933,
0.697979211807251,
0.6386435627937317,
0.17561422288417816,
0.03506172448396683,
0.03511122241616249,
0.7893828749656677,
0.02794216014444828,
-0.7915514707565308,
-0.7880404591560364,
0.1524275541305542,
-0.1931503266096115,
0.2083931267261505,
0.7803909778594971,
0.38854098320007324,
1.0045515298843384,
-0.005883329082280397,
0.569001317024231,
0.272778183221817,
0.3583533763885498,
-0.31452304124832153,
1.3167777061462402,
-0.2699873745441437,
0.19060945510864258,
-0.07285913079977036,
-0.6153407096862793,
-0.4620879292488098,
0.5456092953681946,
-0.39185571670532227,
-0.41357484459877014,
0.4635779559612274,
0.7850946187973022,
-0.04353638365864754,
0.5196655988693237,
0.4163690507411957,
0.1457000970840454,
0.6821655035018921,
0.5512917041778564,
0.41009169816970825,
-0.28597697615623474,
0.23529687523841858,
-0.744588315486908,
-0.16233204305171967,
-0.12697073817253113,
-0.6453515887260437,
-1.1304199695587158,
-0.4617302715778351,
-0.43030601739883423,
-0.08416691422462463,
0.2811112701892853,
0.8680819272994995,
0.7037846446037292,
-0.8933709859848022,
-0.1330346316099167,
-0.3278539478778839,
0.26846301555633545,
-0.19521604478359222,
-0.2388511598110199,
0.3793645203113556,
-0.24291643500328064,
-0.48852306604385376,
0.5416091680526733,
0.12822888791561127,
0.02669251337647438,
-0.6897599697113037,
-0.029998837038874626,
-0.16863425076007843,
-0.45149198174476624,
0.19566765427589417,
0.35822129249572754,
-0.47604718804359436,
-0.40691885352134705,
-0.4132328927516937,
-0.2608969509601593,
-0.04319893196225166,
0.5344911217689514,
-0.5898383855819702,
0.43143725395202637,
0.49775633215904236,
1.1669421195983887,
0.42131319642066956,
0.026998674497008324,
0.6355111002922058,
-1.1215022802352905,
0.32733938097953796,
0.17463116347789764,
0.3560331165790558,
0.4265134334564209,
-0.6788053512573242,
0.30359652638435364,
0.29094168543815613,
-0.7523233890533447,
-1.0721395015716553,
-0.069545216858387,
-0.6215686798095703,
-0.06924200803041458,
0.8838568329811096,
-0.876328706741333,
-0.5680325031280518,
0.13057556748390198,
0.31310534477233887,
0.09572657942771912,
-0.43868815898895264,
0.6136770248413086,
0.4761265814304352,
0.13884900510311127,
-0.14716458320617676,
-0.24616824090480804,
0.6276091933250427,
0.09145418554544449,
-0.7498845458030701,
0.2416212409734726,
0.4369421899318695,
0.39182451367378235,
0.021359393373131752,
0.42858555912971497,
-0.18169455230236053,
0.12231491506099701,
-0.050830163061618805,
-0.43683701753616333,
-0.5050712823867798,
-0.5088387727737427,
-0.677946925163269,
0.699981689453125,
-0.2875082492828369,
-0.48218563199043274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14894v1 | Talking the Talk Does Not Entail Walking the Walk: On the Limits of Large Language Models in Lexical Entailment Recognition | 2024-06-21T06:30:16 | 2024-06-21T06:30:16 | Candida M. Greco, Lucio La Cava, Andrea Tagarelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.IR, physics.soc-ph | Verbs form the backbone of language, providing the structure and meaning to
sentences. Yet, their intricate semantic nuances pose a longstanding challenge.
Understanding verb relations through the concept of lexical entailment is
crucial for comprehending sentence meanings and grasping verb dynamics. This
work investigates the capabilities of eight Large Language Models in
recognizing lexical entailment relations among verbs through differently
devised prompting strategies and zero-/few-shot settings over verb pairs from
two lexical databases, namely WordNet and HyperLex. Our findings unveil that
the models can tackle the lexical entailment recognition task with moderately
good performance, although at varying degree of effectiveness and under
different conditions. Also, utilizing few-shot prompting can enhance the
models' performance. However, perfectly solving the task arises as an unmet
challenge for all examined LLMs, which raises an emergence for further research
developments on this topic. | [
-0.39195501804351807,
-0.8474944829940796,
1.0670262575149536,
-0.1455872654914856,
-0.29844167828559875,
-0.3096677362918854,
-0.2881975471973419,
-0.5265318155288696,
0.2349376678466797,
0.5178893208503723,
-0.6266447901725769,
-0.42262178659439087,
-0.8447768092155457,
0.20024600625038147,
-0.5325630903244019,
0.5014636516571045,
0.0811229944229126,
-0.045677900314331055,
-0.2633482813835144,
-0.1621847301721573,
-0.5853018164634705,
-0.2323589324951172,
-0.468509316444397,
-0.5316861867904663,
0.21834658086299896,
0.31823238730430603,
1.0737130641937256,
0.5847133994102478,
0.3138786852359772,
0.2610074579715729,
-0.44323232769966125,
0.38686248660087585,
-0.44923681020736694,
0.24888554215431213,
-0.10893411189317703,
-0.46167105436325073,
-0.19233068823814392,
-0.14061841368675232,
0.37107136845588684,
0.9269616603851318,
0.09558655321598053,
0.08880681544542313,
0.022397298365831375,
0.5322302579879761,
-0.6397679448127747,
0.18335270881652832,
-0.6666475534439087,
-0.19200395047664642,
-0.15676771104335785,
-0.05412055552005768,
-0.3244623839855194,
0.06634540110826492,
0.2472926527261734,
-0.29813864827156067,
0.2678815424442291,
0.1261918693780899,
1.090935468673706,
-0.11221397668123245,
-0.4423637092113495,
-0.4909675419330597,
-0.6308472156524658,
0.29331156611442566,
-0.728233277797699,
0.517158567905426,
0.7622576951980591,
0.2937711477279663,
-0.2720597982406616,
-0.30971094965934753,
-0.6688246130943298,
-0.5457333922386169,
-0.06425424665212631,
-0.1126890704035759,
-0.2454267144203186,
0.25354334712028503,
0.2835327088832855,
0.218727245926857,
-0.5056759119033813,
0.1221109926700592,
-0.20884497463703156,
-0.016474341973662376,
0.20407341420650482,
0.5500582456588745,
0.188704252243042,
-0.3307253122329712,
-0.29142090678215027,
0.019408581778407097,
-0.7838542461395264,
0.10126344859600067,
-0.02050021104514599,
0.4276731312274933,
-0.31492918729782104,
0.8285426497459412,
-0.043101388961076736,
0.9754393100738525,
-0.0017132380744442344,
0.12774835526943207,
-0.2284570336341858,
-0.43314310908317566,
-0.41611605882644653,
-0.01035773940384388,
0.5577046871185303,
0.15902996063232422,
0.5591496825218201,
-0.24616169929504395,
-0.12820540368556976,
-0.10853669047355652,
-0.024759870022535324,
-0.46697741746902466,
0.10373879224061966,
0.28876134753227234,
-0.24651439487934113,
0.29144230484962463,
0.09190448373556137,
-0.5578538179397583,
-0.7441876530647278,
-0.4155597686767578,
0.6894153356552124,
-0.5281528830528259,
-0.3749430477619171,
0.6127803325653076,
-0.19324049353599548,
0.7291367650032043,
0.5275195837020874,
-0.8936334848403931,
0.6086570620536804,
0.9226969480514526,
1.1161009073257446,
0.153615802526474,
-0.3021557033061981,
-0.4299834966659546,
0.2335321009159088,
-0.5659278631210327,
0.40106141567230225,
-0.7591972947120667,
-0.485941082239151,
0.141218364238739,
0.04949018731713295,
-0.22082501649856567,
-0.5483513474464417,
0.12099719047546387,
-0.3429727256298065,
-0.3932762145996094,
-0.2433619350194931,
-0.8210917115211487,
-0.327757328748703,
0.4577077627182007,
-0.4191329777240753,
0.4458271265029907,
-0.4032354950904846,
-0.2968790829181671,
-0.01598932594060898,
-0.18729501962661743,
-0.23474574089050293,
0.012504439800977707,
-0.2902086675167084,
0.12719987332820892,
0.4633060097694397,
0.05798208713531494,
0.6164248585700989,
-0.40708011388778687,
0.1680009663105011,
-0.09275127947330475,
-0.11604221165180206,
0.2078448385000229,
-0.2037825882434845,
0.4927798807621002,
-0.125001460313797,
-0.07992500811815262,
0.13154712319374084,
-0.5694514513015747,
-0.26091623306274414,
0.24689258635044098,
0.061220746487379074,
-0.28824374079704285,
-0.012188147753477097,
-0.3883706331253052,
0.030803803354501724,
0.008371149189770222,
-0.47410884499549866,
-0.061484161764383316,
-0.608401894569397,
0.2564961612224579,
0.4919244647026062,
-0.07440412789583206,
0.44672203063964844,
-0.29692620038986206,
0.4240129590034485,
0.03466423973441124,
-0.15950539708137512,
-0.4178043603897095,
-0.46630430221557617,
-1.119156837463379,
-0.1451672464609146,
-0.048523347824811935,
0.18078798055648804,
-0.43617865443229675,
0.09952598065137863,
-0.3952449560165405,
-0.5839219689369202,
-0.27684617042541504,
0.0699508935213089,
0.4257671535015106,
0.29395562410354614,
0.2376452535390854,
0.16196171939373016,
-0.2078401893377304,
-0.7141189575195312,
-0.16929468512535095,
-0.30084484815597534,
0.13648752868175507,
0.3464469909667969,
0.5869981050491333,
0.21203145384788513,
0.7608490586280823,
-0.42845436930656433,
-0.27901285886764526,
-0.4934155344963074,
0.004707860294729471,
0.18973439931869507,
0.0552140474319458,
0.3290659785270691,
-0.4027988314628601,
-0.24678298830986023,
0.01968732662498951,
-0.6335856914520264,
0.1432974487543106,
-0.09080807864665985,
-0.11125911772251129,
-0.03328050300478935,
0.8793986439704895,
-0.8862671256065369,
0.5596750974655151,
0.3186323344707489,
-0.5836182832717896,
0.2375953197479248,
-0.25597578287124634,
-0.19894644618034363,
-0.6365892887115479,
-0.4140130877494812,
-0.03081817366182804,
-0.3671169877052307,
-0.7685772180557251,
0.2074282020330429,
0.12776948511600494,
-0.3170216679573059,
-0.5720933675765991,
0.6480261087417603,
-0.8556721806526184,
0.05330974608659744,
-0.4590098559856415,
0.2605386972427368,
-0.0350445881485939,
0.23423610627651215,
0.24194487929344177,
0.201465904712677,
0.9504721760749817,
-1.0878243446350098,
0.26984891295433044,
0.2981952428817749,
-0.1626480519771576,
0.1917141079902649,
-0.6938598155975342,
0.2935646176338196,
-0.4666501581668854,
0.020899366587400436,
-1.0949584245681763,
-0.2281022071838379,
0.1060626208782196,
-0.5633363127708435,
0.2848048508167267,
-0.12826836109161377,
-0.6036331653594971,
0.06857383996248245,
-0.19114916026592255,
0.19208170473575592,
0.5416987538337708,
-0.4639667272567749,
0.7653172016143799,
0.182218998670578,
0.37343156337738037,
-0.037843771278858185,
-0.48173224925994873,
0.11847330629825592,
-0.06289468705654144,
-0.6200842261314392,
0.045217081904411316,
0.5105414986610413,
-0.4601348638534546,
-0.12471167743206024,
-0.12365379929542542,
0.10514017194509506,
-0.18008628487586975,
0.47224166989326477,
0.2629305422306061,
-0.1771155446767807,
0.6198397278785706,
-0.5792801976203918,
0.06643404811620712,
-0.09475794434547424,
0.0931519940495491,
0.7312686443328857,
-0.030500562861561775,
-0.5370287299156189,
-0.3233009874820709,
0.24483934044837952,
0.6723908185958862,
-0.21749280393123627,
0.8996588587760925,
0.1974179893732071,
-0.6075600981712341,
0.009957769885659218,
-0.47918936610221863,
-0.32445448637008667,
-0.42650508880615234,
0.25372248888015747,
-0.5982487797737122,
-0.8084818720817566,
0.32893607020378113,
0.20007023215293884,
-0.0412515327334404,
0.03664664551615715,
0.5549465417861938,
0.19845250248908997,
0.6496464014053345,
0.5740880966186523,
0.05919498950242996,
0.04459712654352188,
0.09298674762248993,
0.3070719540119171,
-0.696613073348999,
-0.26318037509918213,
-0.5788668990135193,
-0.20872506499290466,
-0.5607250928878784,
-0.34275946021080017,
0.4132995903491974,
-0.031049609184265137,
-0.21255484223365784,
0.5943042635917664,
0.042537275701761246,
0.43747419118881226,
0.03478865697979927,
0.06763909012079239,
0.3332378566265106,
-0.22627004981040955,
0.09626266360282898,
0.05776363983750343,
-0.4062038064002991,
-0.655873715877533,
0.6028144955635071,
0.2637491822242737,
0.9144933223724365,
0.5127968788146973,
0.6750127077102661,
-0.24425658583641052,
-0.597380518913269,
-1.350939393043518,
1.0386545658111572,
0.04054509848356247,
-0.4685624837875366,
-0.2967120110988617,
-0.12779644131660461,
-1.2828571796417236,
0.42597609758377075,
-0.3604399561882019,
-0.9914063811302185,
0.21013154089450836,
-0.030652131885290146,
-0.36784064769744873,
0.2823881506919861,
-0.6102566123008728,
0.5100394487380981,
0.12665227055549622,
-0.4091170132160187,
-0.26114264130592346,
-0.40752455592155457,
0.0487348698079586,
0.31423503160476685,
0.1492716372013092,
-0.5846617221832275,
-0.239507257938385,
0.4439938962459564,
-0.377616822719574,
0.8641819357872009,
0.08669746667146683,
-0.05656695365905762,
0.5433419942855835,
0.6715985536575317,
0.4536956548690796,
-0.3429253399372101,
0.23645789921283722,
-0.06080394983291626,
0.08910315483808517,
-0.24593932926654816,
-0.5524109601974487,
0.5130175352096558,
-0.2956298291683197,
-0.9033670425415039,
-0.4610707461833954,
-0.41122370958328247,
-0.49390679597854614,
-0.04314367100596428,
0.12694190442562103,
0.5831292867660522,
-0.08385483920574188,
0.03142702579498291,
0.42349761724472046,
-0.06556897610425949,
0.6680312752723694,
0.665522038936615,
-0.2794169783592224,
0.3342084288597107,
0.7050620317459106,
0.1191987618803978,
0.5130009055137634,
0.19868901371955872,
0.16871637105941772,
-0.36069154739379883,
-0.46377378702163696,
-0.24182960391044617,
0.5713478326797485,
-0.7295722961425781,
0.00011629210348473862,
-0.6100785732269287,
-0.14027701318264008,
-0.4646003544330597,
0.004248857032507658,
-0.18013761937618256,
-0.2460130900144577,
-0.21154378354549408,
-0.15924061834812164,
0.541413426399231,
0.8789042234420776,
0.21194182336330414,
0.1411590874195099,
-0.9692176580429077,
0.2854496240615845,
0.1848134994506836,
-0.0732927992939949,
0.46494022011756897,
-0.7716538310050964,
0.028020650148391724,
-0.1978577822446823,
-0.17300564050674438,
-1.1346278190612793,
0.3815193176269531,
0.4390840530395508,
0.33941566944122314,
0.3852469027042389,
-0.04915092885494232,
0.8261553645133972,
-0.757752001285553,
0.8162631988525391,
0.28249257802963257,
-0.9817244410514832,
0.5248364210128784,
-0.26030203700065613,
0.43924838304519653,
0.10094264894723892,
0.6155039668083191,
-0.5858968496322632,
-0.41184502840042114,
-0.48848026990890503,
-0.7980115413665771,
0.508659303188324,
0.27974236011505127,
0.6242632269859314,
-0.2828376889228821,
0.22437278926372528,
-0.12655751407146454,
-0.11639400571584702,
-0.4186541736125946,
0.06788742542266846,
0.22791680693626404,
-0.1073874980211258,
-0.06514919549226761,
-0.13591226935386658,
-0.027010418474674225,
-0.09029144793748856,
0.40287768840789795,
0.09704124182462692,
0.1652834117412567,
0.29059138894081116,
-0.27628403902053833,
0.13399623334407806,
0.3998522162437439,
0.29648134112358093,
0.6125115156173706,
-0.010009088553488255,
0.5169866681098938,
0.08277427405118942,
-0.39571353793144226,
0.10577155649662018,
-0.38839346170425415,
0.0499534085392952,
0.22167633473873138,
0.6424217820167542,
0.8165879845619202,
0.0783916637301445,
-0.7693719267845154,
0.5366253852844238,
0.2613307237625122,
-0.07963787764310837,
-0.28368741273880005,
0.0948573648929596,
0.2897033989429474,
0.19206278026103973,
-0.06751037389039993,
-0.4805962145328522,
0.016628911718726158,
-0.9100228548049927,
-0.1941123604774475,
0.6335029006004333,
-0.5632144212722778,
-0.26197126507759094,
0.35669904947280884,
-0.19345085322856903,
-0.28273823857307434,
0.5633189678192139,
-0.14945034682750702,
-0.16754508018493652,
0.7842255234718323,
0.6109842658042908,
0.7548409700393677,
0.2044162154197693,
0.10981915891170502,
0.5422846078872681,
0.13569916784763336,
-0.23180457949638367,
0.06134483590722084,
-0.04422783851623535,
-1.0499377250671387,
-0.1816435158252716,
-0.4531194865703583,
-0.4806433916091919,
0.07389255613088608,
-0.5928271412849426,
0.5316935181617737,
-0.4585636854171753,
-0.1296270787715912,
0.3900556266307831,
-0.5948052406311035,
-0.5731166005134583,
-0.16619251668453217,
0.4220814108848572,
0.8472866415977478,
-0.6226176619529724,
0.4720366299152374,
0.675093948841095,
-0.47915250062942505,
-0.8465782403945923,
0.1529482752084732,
0.4018227159976959,
-0.859809935092926,
0.5366669297218323,
0.2406895011663437,
-0.4207212030887604,
0.027689915150403976,
-0.5953099131584167,
-0.5055175423622131,
0.6919645071029663,
0.3525948226451874,
-0.3604244887828827,
-0.07137345522642136,
0.02917502261698246,
0.32344987988471985,
-0.18606169521808624,
0.28772905468940735,
0.618374764919281,
0.33983471989631653,
0.46509960293769836,
-1.1400548219680786,
0.18287977576255798,
0.19451011717319489,
-0.012518320232629776,
0.33368346095085144,
-0.46933847665786743,
0.6960785984992981,
-0.3612968325614929,
-0.4351096451282501,
0.1701631397008896,
0.5870224237442017,
0.1357899308204651,
0.18161219358444214,
0.3181929886341095,
0.36434584856033325,
0.4395233392715454,
-0.08619076758623123,
0.9553889632225037,
0.034280646592378616,
0.1534508913755417,
0.9436060190200806,
-0.451861172914505,
0.9347957968711853,
0.44289442896842957,
-0.23811684548854828,
0.008345567621290684,
0.4150194823741913,
0.1873694509267807,
0.14865075051784515,
0.26815617084503174,
-0.47694605588912964,
-0.5752098560333252,
-0.25714629888534546,
-0.022439122200012207,
0.8499469757080078,
0.558468759059906,
-0.0905798003077507,
-0.6477639675140381,
-0.04885226488113403,
0.2851290702819824,
0.25400063395500183,
-0.7387093901634216,
0.9442096948623657,
0.35554832220077515,
-0.6948716044425964,
0.8051093220710754,
-0.12279912084341049,
0.6334439516067505,
-0.6824267506599426,
-0.048917803913354874,
0.043556325137615204,
0.001996822189539671,
-0.18165256083011627,
-0.7992812395095825,
0.4115234613418579,
0.004396074917167425,
0.2434413731098175,
0.13285785913467407,
0.8540986776351929,
-0.3403760492801666,
-0.19337734580039978,
0.5046887993812561,
0.9327471256256104,
0.4860234558582306,
0.011954238638281822,
-0.09606729447841644,
-0.05157428979873657,
-0.32263386249542236,
0.07850886136293411,
0.3967934250831604,
0.5873644351959229,
0.043888628482818604,
0.6784839630126953,
0.2814783751964569,
0.1612379401922226,
0.13739138841629028,
0.1425859034061432,
0.4044710397720337,
-0.7730786204338074,
-0.19003508985042572,
-1.3179062604904175,
0.05697309970855713,
0.27130258083343506,
-0.20207008719444275,
0.7516043186187744,
0.20257584750652313,
0.5708300471305847,
-0.20448876917362213,
0.061152394860982895,
0.08237521350383759,
0.2810450792312622,
-0.8046779632568359,
0.2797635495662689,
-0.39700472354888916,
0.04355702921748161,
0.14633694291114807,
-0.5676651000976562,
-0.2068786472082138,
0.5700547099113464,
-0.3013591170310974,
-0.10452593117952347,
0.7248290777206421,
1.0587676763534546,
-0.13749931752681732,
0.07142441719770432,
0.8613653182983398,
0.18874502182006836,
0.1278926283121109,
0.6808774471282959,
0.8425194621086121,
-0.03400355204939842,
0.36018311977386475,
0.33989647030830383,
0.13195295631885529,
0.005177601240575314,
-0.6942412257194519,
-0.983985185623169,
-0.639258086681366,
-0.2541365921497345,
-0.49081963300704956,
0.0661999061703682,
1.275809407234192,
0.5639747977256775,
-0.5570682287216187,
-0.556915283203125,
-0.29644420742988586,
-0.08367317169904709,
0.02120397239923477,
-0.11780167371034622,
0.3203009366989136,
-0.47250574827194214,
-0.8365502953529358,
0.33646807074546814,
0.40501415729522705,
0.33186259865760803,
-0.16160286962985992,
-0.10967763513326645,
-0.4864048957824707,
0.40656882524490356,
0.6566887497901917,
0.3379112482070923,
-0.7423776388168335,
-0.19312231242656708,
0.020125875249505043,
0.03185742720961571,
0.0374910794198513,
0.8093029856681824,
-0.6166000962257385,
0.4998778700828552,
0.6037204265594482,
0.7296876311302185,
0.5105796456336975,
-0.31916671991348267,
0.28725144267082214,
-0.5481301546096802,
0.327675998210907,
0.14102275669574738,
0.5800142884254456,
0.2788486182689667,
-0.08143584430217743,
0.48031726479530334,
0.010842760093510151,
-0.2232353389263153,
-0.5405037999153137,
0.6628748774528503,
-0.8995407819747925,
-0.3046935796737671,
1.5026798248291016,
-0.07672207802534103,
-0.27743759751319885,
-0.3497907221317291,
-0.18826596438884735,
0.05265788733959198,
-0.10301630944013596,
0.07815427333116531,
1.032508373260498,
-0.49947255849838257,
-0.33623096346855164,
-0.9716883301734924,
0.32176119089126587,
0.4889536201953888,
-0.2537495195865631,
0.15818403661251068,
0.5315499901771545,
0.05751190334558487,
0.04432634264230728,
0.6354131698608398,
-0.21292655169963837,
0.011426112614572048,
-0.12495747953653336,
-0.41159456968307495,
-0.14023786783218384,
-0.15694913268089294,
-0.5095086097717285,
-0.10054151713848114,
0.3365313708782196,
-0.4671230912208557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14891v1 | Generate-then-Ground in Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Multi-hop Question Answering | 2024-06-21T06:26:38 | 2024-06-21T06:26:38 | Zhengliang Shi, Shuo Zhang, Weiwei Sun, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Zhaochun Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Multi-Hop Question Answering (MHQA) tasks present a significant challenge for
large language models (LLMs) due to the intensive knowledge required. Current
solutions, like Retrieval-Augmented Generation, typically retrieve potential
documents from an external corpus to read an answer. However, the performance
of this retrieve-then-read paradigm is constrained by the retriever and the
inevitable noise in the retrieved documents. To mitigate these challenges, we
introduce a novel generate-then-ground (GenGround) framework, synergizing the
parametric knowledge of LLMs and external documents to solve a multi-hop
question. GenGround empowers LLMs to alternate two phases until the final
answer is derived: (1) formulate a simpler, single-hop question and directly
generate the answer; (2) ground the question-answer pair in retrieved
documents, amending any wrong predictions in the answer. We also propose an
instructional grounding distillation method to generalize our method into
smaller models. Extensive experiments conducted on four datasets illustrate the
superiority of our method. | [
-0.37752601504325867,
-0.944635272026062,
0.7499591112136841,
-0.024575956165790558,
-0.2135225087404251,
0.3994787931442261,
-0.014304445125162601,
-0.17740733921527863,
0.13781392574310303,
0.39064568281173706,
-0.8383656144142151,
-0.1317736953496933,
-0.6012245416641235,
0.08787976950407028,
-0.33849233388900757,
0.8579016923904419,
0.09879671037197113,
-0.14432010054588318,
-0.34196534752845764,
0.0451568178832531,
-0.608206033706665,
-0.5266063213348389,
-0.5239435434341431,
-0.46087539196014404,
0.2817723751068115,
0.6954694986343384,
0.5769609212875366,
0.32555004954338074,
0.2663820683956146,
0.31459397077560425,
-0.16828632354736328,
0.40909343957901,
-0.431997150182724,
0.4767571687698364,
0.05509117618203163,
-0.28316742181777954,
-0.09501753747463226,
-0.005624363664537668,
0.6451096534729004,
0.8895745277404785,
0.006273957435041666,
0.29742738604545593,
0.1287979930639267,
0.7359872460365295,
-0.5412761569023132,
-0.20096425712108612,
-0.9878618717193604,
-0.2685212790966034,
-0.1858091503381729,
-0.6333993673324585,
-0.33940646052360535,
-0.13625378906726837,
-0.16582091152668,
-0.5945897698402405,
0.14364412426948547,
0.19691769778728485,
0.6465566158294678,
0.19313006103038788,
-0.4365251064300537,
-0.24662666022777557,
-0.5971095561981201,
0.4987660050392151,
-0.44746842980384827,
0.42921537160873413,
0.27495843172073364,
0.3674389123916626,
-0.23827213048934937,
-0.6713388562202454,
-0.5651736259460449,
-0.2875124216079712,
0.14496994018554688,
0.14662957191467285,
0.2381848245859146,
-0.09671236574649811,
0.41190940141677856,
0.2932654023170471,
-0.4360705018043518,
-0.4119182825088501,
-0.345252126455307,
-0.14567741751670837,
0.24697889387607574,
0.04765757918357849,
0.10804009437561035,
-0.31169605255126953,
-0.12325218319892883,
-0.006433165166527033,
-0.8500534296035767,
0.19870686531066895,
0.22833684086799622,
0.4167127013206482,
0.40115994215011597,
0.8674706220626831,
-0.45700767636299133,
0.6436686515808105,
0.5681893229484558,
-0.3342437148094177,
0.30922186374664307,
-0.27818313241004944,
-0.14835159480571747,
-0.02509460039436817,
0.42487093806266785,
0.035645317286252975,
-0.13499195873737335,
-0.20192721486091614,
-0.082818403840065,
-0.41680628061294556,
0.09195885807275772,
-0.8577233552932739,
-0.12552504241466522,
0.3759711682796478,
-0.3162759840488434,
-0.31290847063064575,
-0.1344267725944519,
-0.8465383052825928,
-0.3468117117881775,
-0.33057981729507446,
0.6268148422241211,
-0.5179262757301331,
-0.34936249256134033,
-0.17206892371177673,
-0.3769831955432892,
0.1909617930650711,
0.18196702003479004,
-0.6817083358764648,
0.05917489901185036,
0.5913364291191101,
0.7908761501312256,
0.4838647246360779,
-0.5125426650047302,
-1.0792958736419678,
0.2746052145957947,
-0.3053833842277527,
0.527768075466156,
-0.407613068819046,
-0.28190720081329346,
-0.034834686666727066,
-0.17814569175243378,
0.17322522401809692,
-0.44315847754478455,
0.31028327345848083,
-0.9393805265426636,
0.2614380717277527,
-0.62767094373703,
-0.34962740540504456,
0.16109739243984222,
0.508259654045105,
-0.36615118384361267,
1.238891839981079,
0.20229120552539825,
-1.1491204500198364,
0.15878015756607056,
-0.1208186075091362,
-0.32628950476646423,
0.0004036610771436244,
-0.2548958361148834,
-0.18319933116436005,
0.15325795114040375,
0.26272720098495483,
0.12924635410308838,
-0.44436559081077576,
0.5525161027908325,
-0.04630540311336517,
-0.155809685587883,
-0.10199635475873947,
-0.24613523483276367,
0.8384420275688171,
0.13349278271198273,
-0.4070490300655365,
-0.024314850568771362,
-0.9659106135368347,
0.22502806782722473,
0.2771643400192261,
-0.5739600658416748,
-0.4435831606388092,
0.00748519878834486,
-0.41353440284729004,
0.5059399604797363,
0.2308897227048874,
-0.5628080368041992,
0.013641398400068283,
-0.05703425779938698,
0.2806254029273987,
0.577841579914093,
0.22089140117168427,
0.44235867261886597,
-0.5545309782028198,
0.43264755606651306,
-0.07088349759578705,
-0.2944243252277374,
-0.48321717977523804,
-0.5702706575393677,
-0.7050162553787231,
0.044452130794525146,
0.11753420531749725,
0.42067480087280273,
-1.1143794059753418,
0.3426935374736786,
-0.2888485789299011,
-0.468761146068573,
-0.5610118508338928,
0.20273762941360474,
0.4029618501663208,
0.8528820872306824,
0.565955400466919,
0.5869817137718201,
-0.609961748123169,
-0.48095959424972534,
-0.17263124883174896,
-0.26145002245903015,
-0.011323027312755585,
0.22708572447299957,
0.3541537821292877,
-0.1106235459446907,
0.8672155737876892,
-0.41085758805274963,
-0.007552588824182749,
-0.2519627809524536,
0.3753596246242523,
0.14463841915130615,
0.3784269690513611,
0.2321903258562088,
-0.8676744699478149,
-0.2998381555080414,
-0.3373243808746338,
-0.8174750804901123,
-0.4022907018661499,
-0.08846694976091385,
-0.4480348229408264,
-0.3425370454788208,
0.7342473864555359,
-0.8060670495033264,
-0.24599814414978027,
0.5453319549560547,
-0.10911212116479874,
0.6878687143325806,
-0.21191935241222382,
0.3806340992450714,
-1.332336187362671,
0.04393119737505913,
-0.4823816418647766,
-0.04580157995223999,
-0.5188427567481995,
0.34626591205596924,
0.075694240629673,
-0.27469348907470703,
-0.246955007314682,
0.28139522671699524,
-0.7076277732849121,
0.05258960649371147,
-0.38910913467407227,
0.17918993532657623,
0.35562488436698914,
0.24095240235328674,
0.02233341708779335,
1.0652750730514526,
0.3794402480125427,
-0.6251417994499207,
0.10900606960058212,
0.5147228837013245,
0.04636775329709053,
0.16324597597122192,
-0.5295901894569397,
0.39766767621040344,
-0.5277026295661926,
0.38394883275032043,
-1.0112807750701904,
-0.340311735868454,
-0.15171939134597778,
-0.5090753436088562,
0.2399689108133316,
-0.34376734495162964,
-0.3738071620464325,
-0.4958871006965637,
-0.37730661034584045,
0.5392308831214905,
0.5926607847213745,
-0.6888149976730347,
0.6417930722236633,
0.2816845178604126,
-0.24481511116027832,
-0.5822716355323792,
-0.4470210075378418,
-0.011547905392944813,
-0.2560035288333893,
-0.7933477163314819,
0.4195385277271271,
-0.2222537249326706,
-0.3441430628299713,
-0.20104017853736877,
-0.09594237804412842,
0.07541011273860931,
0.02492225170135498,
0.07383446395397186,
-0.10740000009536743,
-0.17797303199768066,
0.20294111967086792,
0.3943813443183899,
-0.06845441460609436,
0.1937066614627838,
-0.5796892642974854,
0.6394182443618774,
0.06433917582035065,
-0.3839428424835205,
0.1499851644039154,
0.7354898452758789,
0.6800064444541931,
-0.4210747182369232,
0.6730892658233643,
0.2371133267879486,
-0.48930639028549194,
-0.11167999356985092,
-0.546562910079956,
-0.2102988362312317,
-0.5052797198295593,
0.15102717280387878,
-0.8560093641281128,
-0.8182488083839417,
0.34331852197647095,
-0.37494462728500366,
0.11318696290254593,
0.44817355275154114,
0.6669455170631409,
-0.25259363651275635,
0.811386227607727,
0.41827070713043213,
0.25835826992988586,
0.32620033621788025,
-0.20577046275138855,
0.05669594556093216,
-0.8969130516052246,
-0.5170912146568298,
-0.6120893359184265,
0.025243697687983513,
-0.2968098819255829,
-0.46038711071014404,
0.601798951625824,
0.5532268285751343,
-0.2523099184036255,
0.12220681458711624,
-0.17262819409370422,
0.3495638966560364,
0.8936123251914978,
0.23584513366222382,
0.35689985752105713,
0.04076327756047249,
-0.3533201217651367,
-0.05762534216046333,
-0.727942943572998,
-0.3041813373565674,
1.1511484384536743,
0.031031373888254166,
0.5329396724700928,
0.13031841814517975,
1.1255675554275513,
-0.007394078653305769,
0.06962668895721436,
-0.4190540611743927,
0.4144251048564911,
0.1707962453365326,
-0.589000940322876,
-0.33024007081985474,
-0.48396390676498413,
-0.6615859866142273,
0.5782483220100403,
-0.3320632874965668,
-0.34826552867889404,
-0.19060039520263672,
0.12160254269838333,
-0.47384247183799744,
0.2676655054092407,
-0.44247201085090637,
0.46055805683135986,
-0.2695702314376831,
-0.5707876682281494,
0.1339820772409439,
-0.8747649192810059,
0.6415790915489197,
-0.3119487762451172,
0.4428245425224304,
-0.03151337057352066,
0.3042990565299988,
0.6435845494270325,
-0.557705819606781,
0.24487240612506866,
-0.4505782127380371,
-0.15676453709602356,
0.7084653377532959,
0.23172630369663239,
0.6704738736152649,
0.17649735510349274,
-0.20963448286056519,
-0.2853110432624817,
-0.1460133045911789,
-0.2971024215221405,
-0.5016546249389648,
0.5507903099060059,
-0.6720824837684631,
-0.9288398027420044,
-0.2491927295923233,
-0.5872465372085571,
-0.4968004822731018,
0.4311853051185608,
0.522079586982727,
0.48812928795814514,
-0.05852629616856575,
0.1859927922487259,
0.6472365260124207,
-0.08514678478240967,
0.2384306788444519,
0.31596964597702026,
-0.28182733058929443,
-0.5524994134902954,
0.6428429484367371,
0.023514870554208755,
0.2986268401145935,
0.4941292703151703,
0.3501184284687042,
-0.5646780729293823,
-0.5464171767234802,
-0.6023258566856384,
-0.034802600741386414,
-0.785789430141449,
-0.3546956181526184,
-1.0365158319473267,
-0.35178670287132263,
-0.36114978790283203,
-0.023861803114414215,
-0.11445245146751404,
-0.3634811341762543,
-0.0682557076215744,
-0.08913107961416245,
0.2672947943210602,
0.1865793615579605,
-0.22233620285987854,
0.4556417465209961,
-1.1778184175491333,
0.8070189952850342,
0.5308786034584045,
-0.13094991445541382,
-0.22645874321460724,
-0.8212703466415405,
-0.021508637815713882,
0.3955652415752411,
-0.3484509289264679,
-1.1226983070373535,
0.11236947029829025,
0.3551223576068878,
0.3799714744091034,
-0.00219712289981544,
0.10922036319971085,
0.8456791043281555,
-1.0191237926483154,
0.6687297821044922,
0.14988143742084503,
-0.8537728190422058,
0.7939220070838928,
-0.45775169134140015,
0.1896817982196808,
0.9128655791282654,
0.26351457834243774,
-0.23282763361930847,
-0.5219704508781433,
-0.6012535095214844,
-0.9539241790771484,
0.44033533334732056,
0.40861111879348755,
0.21082021296024323,
-0.10853615403175354,
0.3837016224861145,
0.16404989361763,
0.43697842955589294,
-0.5617213845252991,
-0.21882395446300507,
-0.09856785088777542,
0.1306024193763733,
-0.03795929253101349,
-0.4402463734149933,
-0.1309138983488083,
-0.16469073295593262,
0.6879355907440186,
-0.1393137276172638,
0.07587509602308273,
0.07810583710670471,
-0.2983056604862213,
-0.3227893114089966,
0.4191001355648041,
0.19505392014980316,
0.664417564868927,
-0.46583181619644165,
0.4321509003639221,
-0.14490914344787598,
-0.15313592553138733,
0.6454976797103882,
0.1876666247844696,
-0.355446457862854,
0.1292150914669037,
0.29161879420280457,
0.3063923716545105,
-0.10710862278938293,
-0.5192971229553223,
0.47484880685806274,
0.15243349969387054,
-0.4096870720386505,
-0.1469230204820633,
-0.10327503830194473,
0.11033696681261063,
0.4306260645389557,
0.7836312651634216,
0.06711622327566147,
0.17683853209018707,
-0.44640761613845825,
0.5706942677497864,
0.3981768786907196,
0.2626115381717682,
-0.025527970865368843,
0.9627174735069275,
0.22348374128341675,
-0.23565207421779633,
0.7130518555641174,
-0.3383004069328308,
-0.5744996070861816,
0.5231944918632507,
0.7961831092834473,
0.7981514930725098,
-0.004838563036173582,
0.25617626309394836,
0.5082497596740723,
0.32184720039367676,
-0.06166874244809151,
0.5189747214317322,
-0.06060429662466049,
-0.7399961352348328,
-0.4890410900115967,
-0.6692790389060974,
-0.2590450048446655,
0.34897294640541077,
-0.6698792576789856,
0.1292029470205307,
-0.28905147314071655,
-0.05387221649289131,
-0.10184880346059799,
-0.07453849166631699,
-0.4422403872013092,
0.3579231798648834,
0.22370991110801697,
0.8406133651733398,
-0.9023017287254333,
0.6996955275535583,
0.6812178492546082,
-0.5010718703269958,
-0.8326631188392639,
0.47902074456214905,
-0.17716558277606964,
-0.5881142616271973,
0.5760077834129333,
0.26549291610717773,
-0.2988159656524658,
0.39044585824012756,
-0.37146899104118347,
-0.9906700849533081,
1.1905502080917358,
0.36230945587158203,
-0.49633851647377014,
-0.20691736042499542,
-0.06004835665225983,
0.3278766870498657,
-0.15794019401073456,
0.30193400382995605,
0.49016645550727844,
0.25212380290031433,
0.32794415950775146,
-0.4630233645439148,
0.056719109416007996,
-0.3206399381160736,
-0.14417694509029388,
0.09312837570905685,
-0.6871433258056641,
1.0286333560943604,
-0.40986260771751404,
-0.1278359293937683,
0.0016430153045803308,
0.7351098656654358,
0.9932548403739929,
0.23620299994945526,
0.5948851108551025,
0.5548784136772156,
0.9028059840202332,
0.07077612727880478,
0.7046570181846619,
-0.5035354495048523,
0.15870164334774017,
1.386748194694519,
-0.2695567011833191,
0.8519245386123657,
0.7609464526176453,
-0.07749145478010178,
0.3717617094516754,
0.7421788573265076,
0.5314687490463257,
0.8226280212402344,
0.25535568594932556,
-0.2846027612686157,
-0.4307725131511688,
-0.0206267349421978,
-0.7553237080574036,
0.4450188875198364,
-0.010758116841316223,
-0.022028416395187378,
-0.5990925431251526,
0.03855649754405022,
-0.2269076704978943,
0.08867363631725311,
-0.2280111312866211,
0.6755735278129578,
-0.0050202626734972,
-0.8383384346961975,
0.7736015319824219,
0.20204292237758636,
0.2878279983997345,
-0.5305347442626953,
-0.25418001413345337,
-0.30581438541412354,
-0.15237395465373993,
0.07968568801879883,
-0.5554889440536499,
0.2613757252693176,
0.09960293024778366,
-0.47248944640159607,
-0.34410884976387024,
0.6149147748947144,
-0.6522725820541382,
-0.5422214865684509,
0.359794020652771,
1.04127836227417,
-0.07666478306055069,
-0.38406437635421753,
-0.59819096326828,
-0.25230371952056885,
-0.12341425567865372,
-0.22056683897972107,
0.2865840196609497,
0.8184265494346619,
0.061794064939022064,
0.5989829897880554,
0.8696855902671814,
-0.13898664712905884,
0.5876901745796204,
0.05493374541401863,
1.227080225944519,
-0.3464798927307129,
-0.599266529083252,
-0.6986258029937744,
0.7007520794868469,
0.1479739397764206,
-0.04520808532834053,
0.6723517775535583,
0.5606091022491455,
0.5478085875511169,
0.022633761167526245,
0.9978904724121094,
-0.5099957585334778,
0.6133096814155579,
-0.8460752367973328,
0.2632119357585907,
-0.6948726177215576,
0.21620774269104004,
-0.21478649973869324,
-0.9726099371910095,
0.128139466047287,
0.20449064671993256,
0.0483257919549942,
0.04199740290641785,
0.8685067892074585,
0.5374571681022644,
-0.05119345337152481,
-0.2616519629955292,
0.31997817754745483,
-0.07252144068479538,
0.2671414911746979,
0.6032581925392151,
1.1610546112060547,
-0.6464924812316895,
0.6002445220947266,
-0.3952408730983734,
-0.2857254445552826,
0.05415552854537964,
-0.7479076981544495,
-0.7973554730415344,
-0.44865676760673523,
-0.043205857276916504,
-0.7361724376678467,
0.0028970891144126654,
0.8654816746711731,
0.5165562629699707,
-0.7108845710754395,
0.13650250434875488,
-0.34869876503944397,
-0.009403052739799023,
-0.04230291768908501,
-0.17624743282794952,
0.3107644021511078,
-0.6890462636947632,
-0.5403373837471008,
0.7049956321716309,
-0.019410014152526855,
-0.08492553979158401,
0.05506692826747894,
-0.07852129638195038,
-0.4486047029495239,
-0.13728810846805573,
0.5462061762809753,
0.03742586076259613,
-0.5464650392532349,
-0.10253400355577469,
0.12612071633338928,
0.008226594887673855,
0.1471884548664093,
1.0640206336975098,
-0.7023770213127136,
0.485197514295578,
0.5180611610412598,
1.0897393226623535,
0.32759934663772583,
0.5340178608894348,
0.3855980336666107,
-1.1014409065246582,
0.34775999188423157,
0.1488136351108551,
0.3641611933708191,
0.20226316154003143,
-0.49335023760795593,
0.10133597254753113,
0.3246755003929138,
-0.39906004071235657,
-0.5315393209457397,
0.19370786845684052,
-0.5236806869506836,
-0.21140317618846893,
1.3599339723587036,
0.0007576584466733038,
0.15069976449012756,
-0.12746231257915497,
-0.2782626748085022,
0.313145250082016,
-0.08277637511491776,
0.5593319535255432,
0.6043212413787842,
0.19154079258441925,
-0.24752835929393768,
-0.4938793480396271,
0.43871527910232544,
0.35415008664131165,
-0.9213768839836121,
0.11624807119369507,
0.7740933895111084,
0.33134925365448,
0.20405682921409607,
1.0404515266418457,
0.09333391487598419,
0.0015303847612813115,
0.32271289825439453,
-0.1993042379617691,
-0.3099431097507477,
-0.7476864457130432,
-0.1647348403930664,
0.4315056800842285,
0.2030050903558731,
-0.41774192452430725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14890v1 | InterBiasing: Boost Unseen Word Recognition through Biasing Intermediate Predictions | 2024-06-21T06:25:10 | 2024-06-21T06:25:10 | Yu Nakagome, Michael Hentschel | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Despite recent advances in end-to-end speech recognition methods, their
output is biased to the training data's vocabulary, resulting in inaccurate
recognition of unknown terms or proper nouns. To improve the recognition
accuracy for a given set of such terms, we propose an adaptation parameter-free
approach based on Self-conditioned CTC. Our method improves the recognition
accuracy of misrecognized target keywords by substituting their intermediate
CTC predictions with corrected labels, which are then passed on to the
subsequent layers. First, we create pairs of correct labels and recognition
error instances for a keyword list using Text-to-Speech and a recognition
model. We use these pairs to replace intermediate prediction errors by the
labels. Conditioning the subsequent layers of the encoder on the labels, it is
possible to acoustically evaluate the target keywords. Experiments conducted in
Japanese demonstrated that our method successfully improved the F1 score for
unknown words. | [
-0.4523715078830719,
-0.4486986994743347,
0.3935500681400299,
0.3292168080806732,
-0.5503060817718506,
0.2168426513671875,
-0.43680253624916077,
-0.3234522044658661,
0.2929297983646393,
0.3150542676448822,
-0.6195095181465149,
-0.4017382562160492,
-0.7451591491699219,
0.14174236357212067,
-0.38677355647087097,
1.0657247304916382,
0.30154380202293396,
0.3334197998046875,
-0.07059162110090256,
-0.42709168791770935,
-0.2962685525417328,
-0.44916200637817383,
-0.7643185257911682,
-0.3471280038356781,
0.15227019786834717,
0.500221848487854,
0.6421940922737122,
0.6497067213058472,
0.13752643764019012,
0.2930264174938202,
0.09105458110570908,
0.13433606922626495,
-0.420297771692276,
0.025035271421074867,
-0.15555432438850403,
-0.47265884280204773,
-0.08764326572418213,
0.3493110239505768,
0.5443844199180603,
0.5485535860061646,
0.34881341457366943,
-0.1297101378440857,
0.4563841223716736,
0.7211655974388123,
-0.7706096768379211,
0.3483113646507263,
-0.903420090675354,
0.13856706023216248,
-0.015079371631145477,
-0.7342049479484558,
-0.4907626509666443,
-0.04204835370182991,
0.11945072561502457,
-0.787336528301239,
0.3058412969112396,
-0.19249925017356873,
0.5848891139030457,
0.5751967430114746,
0.09875718504190445,
-0.438503235578537,
-0.5998867154121399,
0.49697616696357727,
-0.7836657762527466,
0.5452736616134644,
0.7760290503501892,
0.016088338568806648,
-0.1417468935251236,
-0.540278971195221,
-0.565500795841217,
-0.40510186553001404,
0.032565999776124954,
0.6936379671096802,
-0.10653415322303772,
0.39706987142562866,
0.1494169533252716,
0.03252333030104637,
-0.0469493493437767,
0.180387482047081,
-0.3973446786403656,
-0.37847772240638733,
0.409679114818573,
-0.3837388753890991,
0.09108258783817291,
0.16287611424922943,
-0.329904705286026,
-0.3061462938785553,
-0.581969141960144,
-0.05184391885995865,
0.5438786745071411,
0.6611021161079407,
-0.1865638941526413,
0.41016605496406555,
-0.3700162172317505,
0.6426538825035095,
0.6614953875541687,
-0.014618842862546444,
0.4200264811515808,
-0.16673727333545685,
-0.044884975999593735,
0.5073572397232056,
0.5044071078300476,
0.4383009374141693,
0.20581817626953125,
-0.39575621485710144,
-0.10216466337442398,
0.1721617728471756,
0.04584367573261261,
-0.4404458999633789,
-0.43584564328193665,
0.1762361079454422,
-0.14683929085731506,
-0.2410244345664978,
0.06621558219194412,
-0.6787354350090027,
-0.25789308547973633,
-0.22183936834335327,
0.7651860117912292,
-0.23440758883953094,
0.13646438717842102,
-0.2104300856590271,
-0.21451786160469055,
0.0658864974975586,
0.18840090930461884,
-0.5918283462524414,
0.22396205365657806,
0.10050521045923233,
0.8398141264915466,
0.15910044312477112,
-0.14073525369167328,
-0.6107532382011414,
0.053329866379499435,
-0.5137386918067932,
0.9119174480438232,
-0.6244094371795654,
-0.5404041409492493,
-0.10536520183086395,
-0.076693095266819,
0.1517486423254013,
-0.4873712956905365,
0.7229182124137878,
-0.284648597240448,
0.4204532504081726,
-0.0744970440864563,
-0.5307847261428833,
-0.03740527108311653,
-0.019897472113370895,
-0.6162907481193542,
1.0061529874801636,
-0.02266024611890316,
-1.018653392791748,
0.3819112479686737,
-0.41262128949165344,
-0.12340885400772095,
-0.04479646310210228,
-0.13944119215011597,
-0.32059961557388306,
0.23153439164161682,
0.6951829791069031,
0.4104514718055725,
0.010517106391489506,
-0.03292941302061081,
-0.7110313177108765,
-0.31089648604393005,
0.24645154178142548,
-0.5669560432434082,
0.5512514114379883,
0.1900201141834259,
-0.24588167667388916,
0.013661121018230915,
-0.754156768321991,
0.3515605926513672,
-0.3445013165473938,
-0.46267446875572205,
-0.5801112651824951,
0.13799749314785004,
-0.20855766534805298,
0.2806064188480377,
0.09543328732252121,
-0.5207455158233643,
0.01979759708046913,
-0.5254568457603455,
0.29098430275917053,
0.8963962197303772,
-0.050093043595552444,
0.5689388513565063,
-0.07619614899158478,
0.31541696190834045,
0.303837388753891,
-0.02040485292673111,
0.029346974566578865,
-0.2865632176399231,
-1.15255606174469,
0.05999317765235901,
0.6388722658157349,
0.427978515625,
-1.1781518459320068,
0.592995285987854,
-0.22916583716869354,
-0.4634866714477539,
-0.7352548241615295,
-0.14611726999282837,
0.5869538187980652,
0.6008830666542053,
0.4825972616672516,
-0.1625550240278244,
-0.6891677379608154,
-0.8178727626800537,
-0.7382059693336487,
-0.26393795013427734,
0.06499121338129044,
0.06758655607700348,
0.05246727168560028,
-0.04359552264213562,
0.6938210129737854,
-0.3309956192970276,
-0.6761296391487122,
0.13975191116333008,
0.2663877010345459,
0.22294270992279053,
0.6797966361045837,
0.35374966263771057,
-0.4264684021472931,
-0.5028249621391296,
-0.1772266924381256,
-0.20109716057777405,
-0.2354488968849182,
-0.029759962111711502,
0.06609097868204117,
-0.07203971594572067,
1.0168355703353882,
0.11288078129291534,
0.37254056334495544,
0.7175411581993103,
-0.16175778210163116,
0.11725141853094101,
-0.40264683961868286,
-0.08896096795797348,
-1.019511103630066,
-0.4289664924144745,
0.1167730987071991,
-0.193142369389534,
-0.6744675636291504,
-0.3102491796016693,
0.1470804214477539,
0.2399662435054779,
-0.3083380162715912,
0.6723804473876953,
-0.7206581234931946,
0.06473822891712189,
-0.5637484192848206,
0.1843341439962387,
-0.27943769097328186,
0.5346667766571045,
0.22939981520175934,
0.9569136500358582,
0.6382521390914917,
-0.728131115436554,
-0.11555995047092438,
-0.10257013887166977,
-0.38772138953208923,
0.41969603300094604,
-0.29448843002319336,
0.5725184082984924,
-0.4152420461177826,
0.13110539317131042,
-0.9936203360557556,
-0.12021083384752274,
0.17236332595348358,
-0.9052417874336243,
0.4365423917770386,
0.061055075377225876,
-0.24092330038547516,
-0.3580498695373535,
-0.1647430956363678,
0.4726186990737915,
0.20504046976566315,
-0.8294430375099182,
0.48407983779907227,
0.4350264072418213,
0.127130389213562,
-0.7440344095230103,
-0.7284018397331238,
-0.14219246804714203,
-0.06467171758413315,
0.2871916890144348,
0.38606205582618713,
-0.2228996753692627,
0.09709621965885162,
-0.05126915127038956,
-0.3535084128379822,
-0.2602205276489258,
-0.12801796197891235,
0.2897731065750122,
-0.004566967021673918,
0.19995011389255524,
0.40846455097198486,
0.40740686655044556,
-0.0569937564432621,
-0.13399557769298553,
-0.6548277735710144,
0.2741813361644745,
-0.03040759637951851,
0.010574797168374062,
-0.20379570126533508,
0.06724251061677933,
0.33517611026763916,
0.20588943362236023,
0.15019036829471588,
0.591505229473114,
-0.715458333492279,
-0.2079610526561737,
-0.6067619323730469,
-0.31358101963996887,
-0.48534002900123596,
0.523127555847168,
-0.4465327560901642,
-0.5501788854598999,
0.3012690246105194,
0.09780464321374893,
-0.23589347302913666,
0.4930124878883362,
0.41356608271598816,
-0.1784140169620514,
0.9393030405044556,
0.6596183776855469,
-0.3453662097454071,
0.4196254312992096,
-0.015432829037308693,
0.2195291519165039,
-0.9379261136054993,
-0.11291100829839706,
-0.649554431438446,
-0.27359795570373535,
-0.7045904994010925,
-0.5605049133300781,
0.6276441216468811,
0.1424807757139206,
0.14176248013973236,
0.2740299105644226,
-0.5272462964057922,
0.49508556723594666,
0.737386167049408,
0.5961339473724365,
0.23286135494709015,
0.040077608078718185,
-0.4467989504337311,
-0.04858122393488884,
-0.6872965693473816,
0.025299277156591415,
1.2030277252197266,
0.13138927519321442,
0.6736509203910828,
-0.5012145042419434,
0.6313872933387756,
0.5646171569824219,
0.3595772385597229,
-0.7838428020477295,
0.3400726616382599,
-0.32596224546432495,
-0.7749260067939758,
-0.3103082478046417,
-0.16197779774665833,
-0.5645937323570251,
0.225252166390419,
-0.3709750175476074,
-0.5803589224815369,
0.4633486568927765,
0.3368986248970032,
-0.44561612606048584,
0.12892116606235504,
-0.5493146777153015,
0.08103685826063156,
-0.30472037196159363,
-0.3419553339481354,
-0.21566300094127655,
-0.6606071591377258,
0.1876567304134369,
-0.2561500370502472,
0.27489587664604187,
-0.2156139761209488,
-0.08667124807834625,
1.124313235282898,
-0.3100939989089966,
0.7816291451454163,
-0.3606085181236267,
0.24875091016292572,
0.30380979180336,
-0.14867520332336426,
0.38970062136650085,
-0.04497351869940758,
-0.08543611317873001,
0.1368885189294815,
-0.16811802983283997,
-0.33711400628089905,
-0.6125636100769043,
0.7346088886260986,
-0.891927182674408,
-0.6390438675880432,
-0.5080022811889648,
-0.5249791145324707,
-0.8602626919746399,
0.21732935309410095,
0.7245968580245972,
0.28593772649765015,
-0.21338173747062683,
0.18844299018383026,
0.30247458815574646,
0.038042519241571426,
0.6074719429016113,
0.42302289605140686,
0.17694918811321259,
-0.9406480193138123,
0.42194080352783203,
0.3060753047466278,
0.2517718970775604,
0.5685532093048096,
0.37671276926994324,
-0.6388336420059204,
-0.586715042591095,
-0.10086263716220856,
0.02486492320895195,
-0.7860704064369202,
-0.40026816725730896,
-0.6569172143936157,
-0.2980956733226776,
-0.4064454138278961,
-0.12223909795284271,
-0.42415761947631836,
-0.4758313298225403,
-0.6910486817359924,
-0.4035297632217407,
0.3172244429588318,
0.36328551173210144,
-0.4550437331199646,
0.7679222226142883,
-0.5039531588554382,
0.22227126359939575,
0.21162976324558258,
0.2281172275543213,
-0.2921516001224518,
-1.0257974863052368,
-0.30087655782699585,
0.1410408914089203,
0.012919480912387371,
-0.8651126623153687,
0.554137110710144,
0.5202701091766357,
0.5046502947807312,
0.6704549193382263,
0.2785705029964447,
1.0005242824554443,
-0.20624111592769623,
0.261721134185791,
0.46737751364707947,
-1.2029223442077637,
0.5509657859802246,
-0.048775967210531235,
0.42398741841316223,
0.8868245482444763,
0.34993401169776917,
-0.17991025745868683,
-0.4449836313724518,
-0.6885243654251099,
-0.5610467195510864,
0.6230047941207886,
0.03245752677321434,
0.159479022026062,
0.24533407390117645,
0.3600980341434479,
0.13629618287086487,
0.11659149825572968,
-0.9313126802444458,
-0.06567208468914032,
-0.40732836723327637,
-0.15396800637245178,
-0.3034585118293762,
-0.3040072023868561,
0.07091307640075684,
-0.46635687351226807,
0.9762967228889465,
-0.5193033814430237,
0.24053449928760529,
0.5359784364700317,
-0.017133785411715508,
-0.007188110612332821,
0.28045880794525146,
0.3606138825416565,
0.15787865221500397,
-0.26122546195983887,
0.25954461097717285,
0.43912988901138306,
-0.5289084315299988,
0.21474525332450867,
0.037674520164728165,
-0.18248333036899567,
0.11123189330101013,
0.36595186591148376,
0.8846893906593323,
0.2168927788734436,
-0.2543807327747345,
0.5395529866218567,
0.047519341111183167,
-0.16155150532722473,
-0.34711137413978577,
-0.019004030153155327,
-0.1890355348587036,
0.08278302848339081,
0.2663222849369049,
0.3063254654407501,
0.1146400198340416,
-0.49684569239616394,
0.2032422125339508,
0.5115557909011841,
-1.0530935525894165,
-0.35274407267570496,
0.6929963231086731,
0.13751927018165588,
-0.05372626706957817,
0.5050798654556274,
0.10323117673397064,
-0.560496985912323,
0.3593485951423645,
0.7158634066581726,
1.1994245052337646,
-0.5974292159080505,
-0.0799042358994484,
0.6675940155982971,
0.4714001417160034,
0.0017224207986146212,
0.30887120962142944,
-0.4368228018283844,
-1.0164227485656738,
0.011867071501910686,
-0.4189910590648651,
-0.29298141598701477,
0.20490163564682007,
-0.7539453506469727,
0.4098787307739258,
-0.6603620648384094,
-0.425770103931427,
-0.23138093948364258,
-0.07105359435081482,
-0.7707558870315552,
0.5875551700592041,
0.03664587065577507,
0.8573428988456726,
-0.8352828025817871,
1.1333256959915161,
0.467641144990921,
-0.26828911900520325,
-0.8716020584106445,
0.29505452513694763,
-0.265620619058609,
-1.0796749591827393,
0.4611472189426422,
0.10969167947769165,
-0.3114224374294281,
-0.024653034284710884,
-0.6516809463500977,
-1.0984737873077393,
0.7261940240859985,
0.19861829280853271,
-0.7891154289245605,
-0.1838691234588623,
-0.09184892475605011,
0.5689683556556702,
-0.41198161244392395,
0.5243346095085144,
0.46615105867385864,
0.5103809237480164,
-0.18712426722049713,
-0.9070060849189758,
-0.10308796167373657,
-0.17215561866760254,
-0.08363647758960724,
-0.3068855106830597,
-0.6005445122718811,
0.6650601625442505,
-0.48434197902679443,
-0.2817019820213318,
0.060242775827646255,
0.9103654623031616,
0.0730077400803566,
0.3016313910484314,
0.7372444272041321,
0.44298508763313293,
0.6077336072921753,
-0.1561005860567093,
0.490695595741272,
-0.48365506529808044,
0.20369833707809448,
1.466853380203247,
0.003469870425760746,
0.8186753988265991,
0.6244567036628723,
-0.28913262486457825,
0.3381880819797516,
0.6242676377296448,
0.1636802852153778,
1.0428967475891113,
0.05897650122642517,
-0.23270022869110107,
-0.1315690577030182,
-0.05651095509529114,
-0.4023508131504059,
0.7852006554603577,
0.6921577453613281,
-0.5172968506813049,
-0.2716463506221771,
0.2013470083475113,
0.09659583121538162,
0.06685678660869598,
-0.6477723121643066,
0.9239663481712341,
0.1802130490541458,
-0.7964405417442322,
0.6812761425971985,
-0.22789055109024048,
0.6941409111022949,
-0.4668911099433899,
0.21392323076725006,
-0.07310034334659576,
0.2805640995502472,
-0.248337060213089,
-0.5075562000274658,
0.0037214495241642,
-0.4081684648990631,
-0.10470622777938843,
0.1625247597694397,
0.8303624987602234,
-0.6468460559844971,
-0.5907309055328369,
0.6247575283050537,
0.3829777240753174,
0.11378507316112518,
-0.29750895500183105,
-0.6392015218734741,
-0.13552534580230713,
0.13688527047634125,
0.28932568430900574,
0.15557925403118134,
0.21437641978263855,
0.27028030157089233,
0.5389446020126343,
0.5925058722496033,
0.3421255350112915,
0.26855921745300293,
0.044624339789152145,
0.7967017889022827,
-0.5445287227630615,
-0.8268129229545593,
-0.617306113243103,
-0.030635511502623558,
0.02520749159157276,
-0.39043718576431274,
0.6020783185958862,
0.4389224946498871,
1.1321940422058105,
-0.3754764497280121,
0.9316412210464478,
0.5012431740760803,
0.707386314868927,
-0.6979883909225464,
0.6696017384529114,
-0.518297016620636,
0.09236408025026321,
-0.3897532820701599,
-0.7737933397293091,
-0.3024657666683197,
0.2814878523349762,
-0.07191532105207443,
0.05678107589483261,
0.6725476980209351,
0.8455751538276672,
0.0727921724319458,
-0.005119953770190477,
0.5543913841247559,
0.3847135007381439,
-0.11207116395235062,
0.3564251959323883,
0.6969297528266907,
-0.5827440619468689,
0.3507131040096283,
-0.592139482498169,
-0.3783172369003296,
-0.035690225660800934,
-0.7840998768806458,
-0.8372477293014526,
-0.8462568521499634,
-0.3159424364566803,
-0.6420658826828003,
0.3594115078449249,
0.9463619589805603,
0.8485152125358582,
-0.972393810749054,
-0.09683485329151154,
-0.2524974048137665,
-0.06297487765550613,
-0.2764438986778259,
-0.20050907135009766,
0.3894057273864746,
-0.34140846133232117,
-0.9266805052757263,
0.5722932815551758,
0.3458060026168823,
0.14414267241954803,
-0.10936976224184036,
0.06418832391500473,
-0.0004576017672661692,
0.20435068011283875,
0.5107224583625793,
0.2667085528373718,
-0.7803201079368591,
-0.4242648184299469,
-0.48907414078712463,
0.2931652069091797,
0.4280518889427185,
0.7651098966598511,
-1.2384601831436157,
0.835536539554596,
0.48728084564208984,
0.5329676270484924,
0.26670190691947937,
0.08676287531852722,
0.4310329258441925,
-0.5616323947906494,
0.3676113784313202,
0.33153197169303894,
0.5096550583839417,
0.3836062550544739,
-0.4398297667503357,
0.47218143939971924,
0.22636020183563232,
-0.23014600574970245,
-0.6897821426391602,
0.08982738852500916,
-1.0046018362045288,
-0.24441708624362946,
0.9202869534492493,
0.006062305998057127,
-0.1897565871477127,
-0.04475894942879677,
-0.08217284828424454,
0.5941739678382874,
-0.4633250832557678,
0.9183530211448669,
0.6074327230453491,
0.016817806288599968,
-0.05058316886425018,
-0.010394628159701824,
0.6105303168296814,
0.5162784457206726,
-0.6670670509338379,
-0.09065864980220795,
0.22226861119270325,
0.37686869502067566,
0.05363807827234268,
0.808695375919342,
-0.22106023132801056,
0.07644864171743393,
0.01852327026426792,
-0.06629665940999985,
0.21041274070739746,
-0.3890611231327057,
-0.40532833337783813,
-0.12569980323314667,
0.18324722349643707,
-0.705536961555481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14887v1 | InternLM-Law: An Open Source Chinese Legal Large Language Model | 2024-06-21T06:19:03 | 2024-06-21T06:19:03 | Zhiwei Fei, Songyang Zhang, Xiaoyu Shen, Dawei Zhu, Xiao Wang, Maosong Cao, Fengzhe Zhou, Yining Li, Wenwei Zhang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen, Jidong Ge | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have showcased impressive capabilities,
they struggle with addressing legal queries due to the intricate complexities
and specialized expertise required in the legal field. In this paper, we
introduce InternLM-Law, a specialized LLM tailored for addressing diverse legal
queries related to Chinese laws, spanning from responding to standard legal
questions (e.g., legal exercises in textbooks) to analyzing complex real-world
legal situations. We meticulously construct a dataset in the Chinese legal
domain, encompassing over 1 million queries, and implement a data filtering and
processing pipeline to ensure its diversity and quality. Our training approach
involves a novel two-stage process: initially fine-tuning LLMs on both
legal-specific and general-purpose content to equip the models with broad
knowledge, followed by exclusive fine-tuning on high-quality legal data to
enhance structured output generation. InternLM-Law achieves the highest average
performance on LawBench, outperforming state-of-the-art models, including
GPT-4, on 13 out of 20 subtasks. We make InternLM-Law and our dataset publicly
available to facilitate future research in applying LLMs within the legal
domain. | [
-0.08764087408781052,
-0.5878869295120239,
0.23834919929504395,
0.3017338216304779,
-0.5512209534645081,
-0.19706954061985016,
-0.47744256258010864,
-0.44614624977111816,
-0.30129146575927734,
0.7263495326042175,
-0.17359018325805664,
-0.7450986504554749,
-0.22112424671649933,
-0.22890092432498932,
-0.6434299349784851,
1.0165820121765137,
0.09984490275382996,
0.5975770950317383,
0.10608261823654175,
-0.31175652146339417,
-0.20694848895072937,
-0.5163716077804565,
-0.7761379480361938,
-0.1839667707681656,
0.40567007660865784,
0.22414609789848328,
0.5271322727203369,
0.49458104372024536,
0.5057071447372437,
0.09003666788339615,
-0.25103992223739624,
-0.035548582673072815,
-0.7087422013282776,
-0.1302330493927002,
-0.12802208960056305,
-0.6285189390182495,
-0.4062363803386688,
-0.22029942274093628,
0.4869743585586548,
0.20280636847019196,
-0.5098303556442261,
0.11478497833013535,
-0.019840069115161896,
0.5777707695960999,
-0.44062840938568115,
0.00820802990347147,
-0.9732343554496765,
0.21508629620075226,
-0.4328387677669525,
0.03767184540629387,
-0.29243943095207214,
-0.3897888958454132,
-0.20914697647094727,
-0.5234149098396301,
0.14449045062065125,
0.3794426918029785,
0.7964760661125183,
0.15163324773311615,
-0.4309682846069336,
-0.26168814301490784,
-0.3831673264503479,
0.3482150137424469,
-1.1544857025146484,
0.12536892294883728,
0.17466643452644348,
0.5543718338012695,
-0.20221956074237823,
-0.9311149716377258,
-0.5774651765823364,
-0.7107071876525879,
-0.026163142174482346,
0.1053302064538002,
0.16575632989406586,
0.22038249671459198,
0.22839729487895966,
0.38498005270957947,
-0.7785651683807373,
0.515799880027771,
-0.46428680419921875,
0.07594536989927292,
0.9250760078430176,
0.4046578109264374,
0.6400630474090576,
0.28125205636024475,
-0.00018528284272179008,
0.42686501145362854,
-1.1797338724136353,
0.28215253353118896,
0.5285979509353638,
0.35631129145622253,
-0.10718811303377151,
0.6409038305282593,
-0.15267153084278107,
0.6396402716636658,
-0.26381155848503113,
0.147404745221138,
0.007732188329100609,
-0.20322340726852417,
-0.06501650810241699,
0.11310617625713348,
0.8779381513595581,
0.11814689636230469,
0.3407799005508423,
-0.027228636667132378,
-0.6100965142250061,
-0.7546643018722534,
0.15079878270626068,
-0.7137062549591064,
-0.045306384563446045,
0.3557155728340149,
-0.580245852470398,
-0.20855413377285004,
0.25578489899635315,
-0.34315523505210876,
-0.6493455767631531,
-0.6318995952606201,
0.08680567145347595,
-0.21788866817951202,
-0.1453634798526764,
0.11585249751806259,
0.12555144727230072,
0.4395650625228882,
0.40046030282974243,
-0.6679080128669739,
0.18233908712863922,
0.8874408006668091,
0.6858835220336914,
-0.061581090092659,
-0.07883719354867935,
-0.86042320728302,
0.3607842028141022,
-0.5327584147453308,
0.35690462589263916,
-0.5112442970275879,
-0.044570211321115494,
0.34512221813201904,
-0.019719401374459267,
0.26230931282043457,
-0.6309453248977661,
0.650303065776825,
-0.8016394972801208,
-0.3439459204673767,
-0.036978498101234436,
-0.47272735834121704,
0.035890672355890274,
0.648289680480957,
-0.5477550029754639,
0.7154330611228943,
-0.01722538098692894,
-0.7034647464752197,
0.438726544380188,
-0.839418351650238,
-0.5547280311584473,
0.5105121731758118,
-0.4327766001224518,
-0.3137601315975189,
-0.06885349750518799,
0.051486171782016754,
0.3230271339416504,
-0.6262494325637817,
0.4891955554485321,
-0.23352943360805511,
-0.36384013295173645,
-0.005390973761677742,
-0.05035969987511635,
1.0546716451644897,
0.4482767581939697,
0.002410780405625701,
0.4590090215206146,
-0.7561368942260742,
-0.29046544432640076,
0.18277205526828766,
-0.5900853276252747,
-0.38520610332489014,
0.057538654655218124,
0.05061078444123268,
0.32421839237213135,
0.4068286418914795,
-0.767111599445343,
0.3161786198616028,
-0.5023748278617859,
0.6370980739593506,
0.5713018774986267,
-0.1832059621810913,
-0.012377218343317509,
-0.18768155574798584,
0.32370564341545105,
0.18151602149009705,
0.1383010894060135,
-0.026256587356328964,
-0.4461165964603424,
-0.6100374460220337,
-0.056951623409986496,
0.23023709654808044,
0.48527994751930237,
-0.3889322876930237,
-0.039087798446416855,
-0.2940826416015625,
-0.616887092590332,
-0.6410073637962341,
0.23115655779838562,
0.05365610495209694,
0.21901835501194,
0.2503845989704132,
0.29096364974975586,
-0.39609861373901367,
-0.8763298988342285,
-0.49274295568466187,
-0.17520545423030853,
-0.12528300285339355,
0.4374898672103882,
0.5445228219032288,
0.0059373266994953156,
0.7645069360733032,
-0.34014251828193665,
-0.45592451095581055,
-0.4576861560344696,
0.17378512024879456,
0.6172189712524414,
0.31319060921669006,
0.6380864381790161,
-0.854026734828949,
-0.9745787382125854,
0.6888134479522705,
-0.6657952666282654,
-0.1745413839817047,
-0.15320679545402527,
-0.13602426648139954,
-0.09626004844903946,
0.7831120491027832,
-0.6084480285644531,
0.2259983867406845,
-0.11240681260824203,
-0.34908047318458557,
0.7662655711174011,
-0.4292834997177124,
-0.13421353697776794,
-0.7060574293136597,
-0.028257763013243675,
0.009500719606876373,
-0.28474971652030945,
-0.6714399456977844,
0.5101833343505859,
0.26250359416007996,
-0.04123236611485481,
-0.7630447745323181,
0.566630482673645,
-0.44077807664871216,
-0.06776196509599686,
-0.35886824131011963,
-0.011537620797753334,
-0.31493332982063293,
0.25437667965888977,
-0.2253427356481552,
0.8134375810623169,
0.6716037392616272,
-0.654678225517273,
0.713333785533905,
0.10150791704654694,
-0.4710638225078583,
0.39279526472091675,
-0.6818761825561523,
-0.030597910284996033,
-0.23850584030151367,
-0.08928324282169342,
-0.46901077032089233,
-0.29032400250434875,
0.23356673121452332,
0.032516978681087494,
0.3404513895511627,
-0.33116212487220764,
-0.9129222631454468,
-0.4413667321205139,
-0.09019654244184494,
0.22116075456142426,
0.5657848119735718,
-0.6093945503234863,
0.657437264919281,
0.44378891587257385,
-0.18228842318058014,
-0.6855449080467224,
-0.5518943667411804,
0.23507338762283325,
-0.2250986397266388,
-0.5943988561630249,
0.2746543288230896,
0.14399771392345428,
-0.41451525688171387,
0.166733980178833,
0.3730936646461487,
-0.42130643129348755,
-0.04032104089856148,
-0.051545288413763046,
0.0010104782413691282,
-0.45974960923194885,
0.1520819067955017,
0.06384368240833282,
0.42822471261024475,
0.2811965346336365,
-0.17655719816684723,
0.6180811524391174,
0.043946683406829834,
-0.6402847766876221,
-0.1341685801744461,
0.06965214759111404,
0.5269577503204346,
-0.4069514870643616,
0.4548444151878357,
0.33120444416999817,
-0.31885242462158203,
-0.48382043838500977,
-0.4242609143257141,
0.23650497198104858,
-0.4556926190853119,
0.5986582040786743,
-0.3830721974372864,
-0.7259061932563782,
0.4993423819541931,
0.21959081292152405,
0.7997803688049316,
0.3510787785053253,
0.955790102481842,
-0.03415578603744507,
0.7362251877784729,
0.45812925696372986,
-0.3288486897945404,
0.3838110566139221,
0.12617972493171692,
0.17439579963684082,
-0.5264036059379578,
-0.34615692496299744,
-0.4717446267604828,
-0.10474959015846252,
-0.2884277403354645,
-0.39875516295433044,
0.36780813336372375,
-0.15303508937358856,
-0.5967348217964172,
0.2815592586994171,
-0.1332261562347412,
0.5428706407546997,
0.6164746880531311,
0.16196689009666443,
0.49264034628868103,
-0.2615102231502533,
-0.1385309100151062,
0.24489954113960266,
-0.661442220211029,
-0.36860594153404236,
1.125303864479065,
0.25600695610046387,
0.9645969867706299,
0.07073968648910522,
0.3592470586299896,
0.26558995246887207,
0.3419574499130249,
-0.7143670320510864,
0.5741994380950928,
-0.5519881248474121,
-0.6528723239898682,
-0.44567903876304626,
-0.3888588845729828,
-0.8789256811141968,
0.5855085253715515,
0.049120236188173294,
-0.43506908416748047,
-0.2482644021511078,
-0.07832645624876022,
-0.35209062695503235,
0.5699434280395508,
0.04075539857149124,
0.6212674379348755,
-0.5375908613204956,
-0.4502149522304535,
-0.4931481182575226,
-0.640034556388855,
0.6679429411888123,
-0.3334749937057495,
0.2548012435436249,
-0.38921135663986206,
0.027526866644620895,
0.4094816744327545,
-0.6193086504936218,
0.6534898281097412,
-0.14076843857765198,
-0.20742639899253845,
0.516021728515625,
-0.09791997075080872,
0.6582810282707214,
0.2013215720653534,
-0.13509885966777802,
0.11751866340637207,
-0.04203049838542938,
-0.09554614126682281,
-0.3444393277168274,
0.585870623588562,
-0.6442133784294128,
-0.8790881037712097,
-0.2670847773551941,
-0.7205925583839417,
0.11536089330911636,
0.34052494168281555,
0.10491728037595749,
0.037657782435417175,
-0.33937254548072815,
0.30829954147338867,
0.4316214323043823,
-0.39161303639411926,
0.31383711099624634,
1.087053656578064,
-0.2800486087799072,
0.027917945757508278,
0.9676200747489929,
0.279058039188385,
-0.2713273763656616,
0.290661484003067,
0.22001133859157562,
-0.3004762530326843,
-0.892761766910553,
-0.3283963203430176,
0.3087416887283325,
-0.8794602155685425,
-0.006688855588436127,
-0.6740272641181946,
-0.6666801571846008,
-0.39556291699409485,
0.16340970993041992,
-0.3365621566772461,
0.0747903510928154,
-0.2877119183540344,
0.18710769712924957,
0.18857641518115997,
0.5683472752571106,
0.1502123475074768,
0.01443131361156702,
-0.9248757362365723,
0.5002841353416443,
0.2295321524143219,
0.42418861389160156,
-0.2918604016304016,
-0.8355116844177246,
-0.26284080743789673,
-0.10255508869886398,
-0.14164435863494873,
-0.4137798845767975,
0.360671728849411,
0.29713088274002075,
0.8073912262916565,
0.6052342653274536,
0.2379741370677948,
0.5254272818565369,
-0.8811147809028625,
0.7514484524726868,
0.08355540037155151,
-0.5669692754745483,
0.4447747766971588,
-0.4253929853439331,
-0.0424177460372448,
0.4368082880973816,
0.0560029074549675,
-0.5284425020217896,
-0.6475257277488708,
0.018005313351750374,
-0.9199912548065186,
0.8718809485435486,
0.17170916497707367,
0.61933833360672,
0.4042741656303406,
0.5181682705879211,
0.12554144859313965,
0.23145562410354614,
-0.9642389416694641,
0.0859517827630043,
-0.06605517864227295,
-0.24189165234565735,
0.44591644406318665,
-0.13346219062805176,
-0.19946503639221191,
-0.47287890315055847,
0.743286669254303,
0.03749289736151695,
-0.33598124980926514,
-0.2201877236366272,
-0.23307493329048157,
0.05266191437840462,
0.2554006576538086,
0.5122380256652832,
0.7914931774139404,
-0.008464065380394459,
-0.2555525004863739,
0.23012693226337433,
-0.39871758222579956,
0.07653796672821045,
0.041109610348939896,
-0.4026786684989929,
0.1323366016149521,
0.14211134612560272,
0.7568958401679993,
-0.21106529235839844,
-1.1152029037475586,
0.7008295655250549,
-0.011065241880714893,
-0.3176959753036499,
-0.6940845847129822,
0.2803865075111389,
0.04084724187850952,
0.25899985432624817,
0.37752607464790344,
-0.5619980096817017,
0.2142532765865326,
-0.3636658191680908,
0.1963758021593094,
0.3767373263835907,
-0.33039921522140503,
-0.05258651077747345,
1.0553165674209595,
0.22073687613010406,
-0.045185547322034836,
0.5990073680877686,
0.05838131159543991,
-0.2153976410627365,
0.8126160502433777,
0.3266034424304962,
0.6086668968200684,
0.04412899166345596,
-0.06332094967365265,
0.6279640197753906,
0.36803770065307617,
-0.40644004940986633,
0.32392802834510803,
0.2686363160610199,
-0.4281442165374756,
-0.27282410860061646,
-0.4106031358242035,
-0.3943626284599304,
0.42965248227119446,
-0.513853907585144,
0.7402865886688232,
-0.583972692489624,
0.22973650693893433,
-0.46483731269836426,
-0.38737809658050537,
-0.4875648319721222,
0.010228280909359455,
0.17451344430446625,
1.1650718450546265,
-0.2260308712720871,
0.9806146621704102,
0.7140991687774658,
-0.5359063744544983,
-0.4094723165035248,
0.11600787937641144,
-0.0833202674984932,
-0.9412559866905212,
0.8920923471450806,
0.138885498046875,
0.3090710937976837,
-0.015065270476043224,
-0.8210062980651855,
-0.4686894416809082,
1.037893295288086,
0.5459763407707214,
-1.064666986465454,
-0.0625322237610817,
0.5097323656082153,
0.66524738073349,
-0.46171537041664124,
0.05539527162909508,
0.6813879013061523,
0.3445488512516022,
0.08735141903162003,
-0.6847060918807983,
-0.06842455267906189,
-0.3188784122467041,
-0.03382013365626335,
-0.12205120921134949,
-0.7397668361663818,
1.17870032787323,
-0.16737104952335358,
-0.07031531631946564,
-0.06938551366329193,
0.6900334358215332,
0.4862208962440491,
0.22227297723293304,
0.38652610778808594,
0.41958874464035034,
0.6951476335525513,
-0.07495954632759094,
0.9608981609344482,
-0.834562361240387,
0.18664444983005524,
1.296242117881775,
-0.4927363395690918,
0.6882664561271667,
0.1296370029449463,
-0.015330174006521702,
0.18239830434322357,
0.6528558731079102,
-0.5092502236366272,
0.2932925522327423,
0.6613035202026367,
-0.1942225843667984,
-0.20608487725257874,
-0.16905905306339264,
-0.3167273700237274,
0.17151442170143127,
0.21382445096969604,
-0.2757816016674042,
-0.31617942452430725,
-0.04271453246474266,
-0.17951010167598724,
-0.046886980533599854,
-0.562066376209259,
0.7876234650611877,
0.16755881905555725,
-0.39561694860458374,
0.1959298998117447,
0.26627564430236816,
0.538485586643219,
-0.7000766396522522,
0.000130000218632631,
-0.44914063811302185,
-0.052033208310604095,
-0.1667463332414627,
-1.013413906097412,
0.0009176803287118673,
0.31982558965682983,
0.2951381206512451,
0.1749839335680008,
0.5473992228507996,
-0.5583237409591675,
-0.389309823513031,
0.27652397751808167,
0.19339364767074585,
0.36860108375549316,
-0.28033706545829773,
-0.7691494226455688,
-0.3221531808376312,
-0.3398405909538269,
-0.3320411741733551,
0.2841107249259949,
0.7665818333625793,
-0.19077225029468536,
0.8866465091705322,
0.6659761071205139,
0.4403170049190521,
0.32592716813087463,
0.3853386640548706,
1.1001454591751099,
-0.6473553776741028,
-0.7181352376937866,
-0.9671650528907776,
0.5571944713592529,
-0.30876970291137695,
-0.25823771953582764,
0.41157424449920654,
0.7367312908172607,
0.7967486381530762,
-0.053623300045728683,
1.0490918159484863,
-0.07169653475284576,
0.287244588136673,
-0.6092445850372314,
0.9822911620140076,
-0.7990846037864685,
0.4978656768798828,
0.4038262367248535,
-0.8914051651954651,
-0.36635181307792664,
0.18861903250217438,
-0.058974191546440125,
-0.326581746339798,
0.17065760493278503,
0.7712641358375549,
-0.23451584577560425,
-0.30473119020462036,
0.657107949256897,
0.34366950392723083,
0.636383056640625,
0.5050463080406189,
0.907348096370697,
-0.02066704072058201,
0.9090789556503296,
0.2117479145526886,
0.19755296409130096,
-0.44202059507369995,
-0.4142935574054718,
-1.1479153633117676,
-0.0030821014661341906,
-0.015711937099695206,
-0.007826512679457664,
-0.10098996013402939,
1.1956735849380493,
0.43278488516807556,
-1.0473191738128662,
-0.49426957964897156,
-0.2643796503543854,
-0.16859951615333557,
0.08793830871582031,
-0.17633429169654846,
0.2704005241394043,
-0.768650472164154,
-0.8442063331604004,
0.3241828680038452,
0.2487899363040924,
0.020823340862989426,
-0.28815957903862,
-0.24188923835754395,
-0.08291471004486084,
0.07519849389791489,
0.547945499420166,
0.22994691133499146,
-0.9142706990242004,
0.24433355033397675,
-0.4100695252418518,
-0.5372892022132874,
0.3851704001426697,
1.2226152420043945,
0.017601557075977325,
0.4543147683143616,
0.6011703610420227,
0.7659173011779785,
0.4461434781551361,
-0.11003037542104721,
0.6491121053695679,
-0.6082691550254822,
0.30052614212036133,
0.48267245292663574,
0.7270334362983704,
-0.05881553515791893,
-0.4904864430427551,
0.711543083190918,
-0.13281504809856415,
-0.3952609896659851,
-0.8139570951461792,
0.13526393473148346,
-0.5446227788925171,
-0.6713551878929138,
1.3106012344360352,
-0.49476659297943115,
-0.058768756687641144,
-0.403913676738739,
-0.43521052598953247,
0.2597815692424774,
-0.46842634677886963,
0.6836166977882385,
0.7475831508636475,
0.04631465673446655,
-0.3123283386230469,
-0.8920258283615112,
0.23758451640605927,
0.0784117579460144,
-0.8554426431655884,
0.1583544909954071,
0.4133012294769287,
0.3839227855205536,
-0.3855947256088257,
0.6259270310401917,
-0.39169010519981384,
0.2215510606765747,
-0.1562681794166565,
0.07277107238769531,
-0.334024578332901,
-0.06524862349033356,
-0.16050155460834503,
0.3750379681587219,
0.18185973167419434,
0.1527477353811264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14884v1 | FlowBench: Revisiting and Benchmarking Workflow-Guided Planning for LLM-based Agents | 2024-06-21T06:13:00 | 2024-06-21T06:13:00 | Ruixuan Xiao, Wentao Ma, Ke Wang, Yuchuan Wu, Junbo Zhao, Haobo Wang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLM-based agents have emerged as promising tools, which are crafted to
fulfill complex tasks by iterative planning and action. However, these agents
are susceptible to undesired planning hallucinations when lacking specific
knowledge for expertise-intensive tasks. To address this, preliminary attempts
are made to enhance planning reliability by incorporating external
workflow-related knowledge. Despite the promise, such infused knowledge is
mostly disorganized and diverse in formats, lacking rigorous formalization and
comprehensive comparisons. Motivated by this, we formalize different formats of
workflow knowledge and present FlowBench, the first benchmark for
workflow-guided planning. FlowBench covers 51 different scenarios from 6
domains, with knowledge presented in diverse formats. To assess different LLMs
on FlowBench, we design a multi-tiered evaluation framework. We evaluate the
efficacy of workflow knowledge across multiple formats, and the results
indicate that current LLM agents need considerable improvements for
satisfactory planning. We hope that our challenging benchmark can pave the way
for future agent planning research. | [
-0.36611825227737427,
-0.2917477786540985,
0.5896482467651367,
0.11489059776067734,
-0.01885778084397316,
0.22989840805530548,
0.09634017199277878,
-0.3052944540977478,
0.338084876537323,
0.6127392053604126,
-0.8729588389396667,
-0.4039192795753479,
-0.467678964138031,
-0.07696458697319031,
-0.26602447032928467,
0.5969734191894531,
-0.42510902881622314,
0.1842765063047409,
-0.2627727687358856,
-0.24421799182891846,
-0.5040859580039978,
-0.15668247640132904,
-0.5495204925537109,
-0.8168116807937622,
0.5841599106788635,
0.29488876461982727,
0.8267127275466919,
0.28166598081588745,
0.4500919282436371,
0.321749210357666,
-0.07827237248420715,
0.2828787863254547,
-0.5338408350944519,
0.4089651107788086,
-0.39125433564186096,
-0.0727587416768074,
-0.6891995668411255,
-0.12806296348571777,
0.24027447402477264,
0.849342405796051,
-0.54163658618927,
0.03214162215590477,
-0.1423686444759369,
0.8019663691520691,
-0.8692476153373718,
0.2134556919336319,
-0.5032784938812256,
0.3973054587841034,
0.06515713781118393,
-0.16044001281261444,
-0.2410123348236084,
-0.15607449412345886,
-0.13021059334278107,
-0.43464648723602295,
-0.002066647866740823,
-0.024734707549214363,
0.2946781814098358,
0.7056878805160522,
-0.2417747676372528,
-0.07064472138881683,
-0.9909696578979492,
0.15389008820056915,
-0.5865887403488159,
0.35797950625419617,
0.11094152927398682,
0.9123969078063965,
-0.6097217202186584,
-1.0744414329528809,
-0.29311731457710266,
-0.08840890228748322,
0.09959519654512405,
0.16500256955623627,
-0.19003917276859283,
0.09116509556770325,
0.44223397970199585,
0.17646606266498566,
-0.8232448697090149,
0.07647589594125748,
-0.19721995294094086,
-0.37732571363449097,
0.6609231233596802,
0.3537108600139618,
-0.18191036581993103,
0.4225268065929413,
-0.5129790902137756,
-0.33048081398010254,
-0.4753439128398895,
0.10828539729118347,
0.20944271981716156,
0.023030128329992294,
0.15051214396953583,
0.6101272702217102,
-0.7130778431892395,
0.6033538579940796,
-0.04558354243636131,
-0.11818268150091171,
0.27936333417892456,
-0.1327926218509674,
-0.31100788712501526,
-0.19084283709526062,
0.3455193042755127,
0.30682992935180664,
0.25259315967559814,
-0.5434620380401611,
-0.3621200919151306,
-0.376445472240448,
0.5009597539901733,
-0.9166483283042908,
0.020846813917160034,
0.2821541726589203,
-0.22481822967529297,
-0.06791406869888306,
-0.056890349835157394,
-0.5363249182701111,
-0.9763283729553223,
-0.30092543363571167,
0.26042062044143677,
-0.4451802968978882,
-0.2519996464252472,
-0.08998505026102066,
-0.35898837447166443,
0.4047354459762573,
0.6015380620956421,
-0.21857471764087677,
0.20971572399139404,
1.0054445266723633,
0.565100371837616,
-0.1425005942583084,
-0.7857321500778198,
-0.6944534778594971,
0.11490406095981598,
-0.4070291817188263,
1.1046370267868042,
-0.49002572894096375,
-0.3909205198287964,
0.013060635887086391,
-0.008136635646224022,
0.11364946514368057,
-0.7297354936599731,
0.5229684710502625,
-0.34615638852119446,
-0.294497549533844,
-0.37456414103507996,
-0.5891608595848083,
-0.3118191659450531,
0.48323825001716614,
-0.7441278696060181,
0.7295655012130737,
0.3709772527217865,
-0.31608378887176514,
0.6444485187530518,
-0.4418450891971588,
-0.25738316774368286,
0.10617009550333023,
-0.25333553552627563,
-0.06469514220952988,
-0.14391684532165527,
-0.2873654067516327,
0.44202297925949097,
-0.30552616715431213,
0.23994247615337372,
-0.48033326864242554,
-0.33368319272994995,
0.16671903431415558,
-0.23482370376586914,
0.4642690122127533,
0.12403250485658646,
-0.36563462018966675,
0.5537212491035461,
-0.7514981031417847,
0.37275710701942444,
-0.15225666761398315,
0.0664018765091896,
0.34266161918640137,
-0.04989008232951164,
-0.31925463676452637,
0.46277177333831787,
-0.03298824280500412,
-0.23036591708660126,
0.1354360282421112,
-0.14438427984714508,
0.10783872753381729,
0.780082643032074,
0.04609435051679611,
0.36564433574676514,
-0.7999207377433777,
0.6687442660331726,
-0.16626201570034027,
0.1828276515007019,
0.1991920918226242,
-0.26787668466567993,
-0.35795858502388,
-0.056955765932798386,
-0.2378288358449936,
0.3418988585472107,
-0.8067296743392944,
0.09770682454109192,
-0.24308639764785767,
-0.9889982342720032,
0.06644771993160248,
0.1946975588798523,
0.1289324164390564,
0.669974148273468,
0.26171714067459106,
-0.449561208486557,
-0.24634474515914917,
-0.6087611317634583,
-0.22782650589942932,
-0.21617791056632996,
0.1535763144493103,
0.10218226164579391,
0.5483406186103821,
-0.32704058289527893,
0.49505841732025146,
-0.2117144763469696,
-0.23320871591567993,
-0.46554720401763916,
0.028487473726272583,
-0.06675483286380768,
0.10050607472658157,
0.3064281642436981,
-0.46294277906417847,
-0.3879697024822235,
-0.2814011573791504,
-0.4794277846813202,
0.01032187882810831,
0.0011629436630755663,
-0.6027234792709351,
0.13795071840286255,
0.4775407612323761,
-0.6817073225975037,
0.684658408164978,
0.36154019832611084,
-0.5973145365715027,
0.5934167504310608,
-0.09006789326667786,
-0.22454510629177094,
-0.7003428339958191,
0.18043683469295502,
-0.4545607566833496,
-0.2021566778421402,
-0.5761362910270691,
-0.030437812209129333,
-0.03574329987168312,
-0.03990060091018677,
-0.4490194320678711,
0.798988938331604,
-0.43243011832237244,
-0.34936264157295227,
-0.4396858811378479,
-0.0634651631116867,
0.15189187228679657,
0.5930739641189575,
0.2754579484462738,
0.6505645513534546,
0.4364761412143707,
-0.3283258378505707,
0.5033988952636719,
0.05764918401837349,
-0.026775654405355453,
0.7609500885009766,
-0.4095710515975952,
0.26606640219688416,
-0.006364039145410061,
0.49952200055122375,
-0.49461668729782104,
-0.05759481340646744,
0.3312077224254608,
-0.05339410901069641,
0.28838443756103516,
-0.22229178249835968,
-0.5193111896514893,
-0.15781965851783752,
-0.4374545216560364,
0.028191914781928062,
0.4531300961971283,
-0.3774963915348053,
1.0911965370178223,
0.15203134715557098,
0.11561226099729538,
-0.6668632626533508,
-0.404601126909256,
-0.0653739795088768,
-0.09178423136472702,
-0.7791396975517273,
0.29200637340545654,
-0.13187919557094574,
-0.3980962634086609,
-0.0862879827618599,
-0.5773853063583374,
-0.18299593031406403,
0.05842917785048485,
0.5459661483764648,
-0.3535841405391693,
-0.01871332898736,
-0.23995168507099152,
-0.32667845487594604,
-0.1811942309141159,
0.2009386420249939,
-0.22484001517295837,
0.5950056910514832,
0.019808266311883926,
-0.7734301686286926,
0.006435060407966375,
0.18862348794937134,
0.5873854160308838,
-0.18895283341407776,
0.5161653161048889,
0.5501249432563782,
-0.469035804271698,
-0.5666975378990173,
-0.4813266396522522,
-0.09965546429157257,
-0.4651111364364624,
0.04900297522544861,
-0.3399190306663513,
-0.2243848443031311,
0.5833964943885803,
-0.5175415873527527,
0.29644155502319336,
0.22908653318881989,
0.5305517315864563,
-0.07302527129650116,
0.2867823839187622,
0.598361611366272,
0.33549290895462036,
0.21166735887527466,
-0.38723450899124146,
-0.24438461661338806,
-0.5450578927993774,
-0.413552850484848,
-0.2897166907787323,
-0.45105862617492676,
-0.32010215520858765,
-0.7579030394554138,
0.20491918921470642,
-0.1311841607093811,
-0.13603806495666504,
0.21599742770195007,
-0.04817075654864311,
0.2598189413547516,
0.27326738834381104,
-0.21450895071029663,
0.33309406042099,
-0.3503754734992981,
-0.2300349473953247,
0.45498135685920715,
-0.5475468039512634,
-0.7095208168029785,
1.1990643739700317,
0.1004505306482315,
0.7203937768936157,
-0.0035254228860139847,
0.7120309472084045,
0.30026108026504517,
0.38114362955093384,
-0.5854024887084961,
0.5870550870895386,
0.39194774627685547,
-0.47384148836135864,
-0.5434911847114563,
-0.1589926928281784,
-1.007777214050293,
0.4536460340023041,
0.05469027906656265,
-0.6805444955825806,
0.187825009226799,
0.08329471200704575,
-0.08847882598638535,
0.3932856321334839,
-0.5147433280944824,
0.8879902958869934,
-0.3757515549659729,
-0.6254977583885193,
-0.050960756838321686,
-0.49284693598747253,
-0.060339827090501785,
0.013104701414704323,
-0.013576311059296131,
-0.4556722939014435,
-0.11072696000337601,
0.3060378134250641,
-0.9511372447013855,
0.5219968557357788,
-0.45354560017585754,
-0.21018056571483612,
0.3195314109325409,
0.15765421092510223,
0.9073001146316528,
-0.0660763829946518,
-0.3655841648578644,
0.16122367978096008,
0.057733263820409775,
-0.2895953357219696,
-0.6052901744842529,
0.38850581645965576,
-0.41029664874076843,
-0.400770902633667,
-0.40138909220695496,
-0.4959445297718048,
-0.7335770130157471,
0.3271927833557129,
0.11732202768325806,
0.1879035085439682,
-0.49273577332496643,
-0.08453096449375153,
0.20133228600025177,
0.217143714427948,
0.5949879884719849,
0.7607224583625793,
-0.13616858422756195,
-0.13637980818748474,
0.5355793237686157,
0.1398584097623825,
0.14692607522010803,
0.32987210154533386,
0.0026697812136262655,
-0.1345960944890976,
-0.8530563116073608,
-0.4003531038761139,
-0.1917453557252884,
-0.8551927208900452,
-0.2483319640159607,
-0.25858569145202637,
-0.2776891887187958,
-0.09418289363384247,
-0.1240786612033844,
-0.6953554749488831,
-0.20840543508529663,
0.23060786724090576,
-0.1008048877120018,
0.07039672881364822,
0.7407820820808411,
-0.16583941876888275,
0.013743356801569462,
-0.369454950094223,
0.07352886348962784,
0.13003334403038025,
0.6211414337158203,
-0.10539040714502335,
-0.004924051929265261,
-0.14613306522369385,
-0.13718253374099731,
-0.4829773008823395,
-0.7804673910140991,
0.24424801766872406,
-0.1417493224143982,
1.0836760997772217,
0.41695865988731384,
0.1718197613954544,
0.5525324940681458,
-0.37272948026657104,
0.31846562027931213,
-0.37104710936546326,
-0.3986523449420929,
0.4203973710536957,
-0.061310503631830215,
0.2067098468542099,
0.8626611828804016,
0.17918013036251068,
-0.26134923100471497,
-0.29940828680992126,
-0.7922157049179077,
-0.7758408188819885,
0.5625564455986023,
0.46299952268600464,
-0.3921840488910675,
0.7041746377944946,
0.27234023809432983,
0.5551157593727112,
0.33805498480796814,
-0.2064126878976822,
-0.2584936320781708,
-0.2657299339771271,
0.06327854096889496,
-0.24786046147346497,
0.035881638526916504,
-0.4336143732070923,
0.05851944535970688,
0.42293477058410645,
-0.21852976083755493,
0.19576331973075867,
0.047188855707645416,
-0.23860183358192444,
-0.05332338437438011,
0.15732049942016602,
0.6806269288063049,
1.2069936990737915,
-0.19330161809921265,
0.06161227449774742,
0.26820966601371765,
-0.5049178600311279,
0.13354504108428955,
0.4935931861400604,
0.03766690194606781,
-0.017774462699890137,
0.6010868549346924,
0.5796462893486023,
-0.12034300714731216,
-0.8762773275375366,
0.22773084044456482,
-0.2739519476890564,
-0.3090114891529083,
-0.5757547616958618,
0.37859243154525757,
0.06708326190710068,
0.7113479971885681,
0.14707018435001373,
0.10619687288999557,
0.33616578578948975,
-0.43736714124679565,
0.09779093414545059,
0.3838127553462982,
-0.37136775255203247,
-0.04035622999072075,
0.16366301476955414,
0.16604407131671906,
-0.41561445593833923,
0.05082812160253525,
-0.5564392805099487,
-0.12219429016113281,
0.6317338943481445,
-0.03828930854797363,
1.0057684183120728,
0.2474350929260254,
0.13487420976161957,
0.03800702095031738,
0.3468358516693115,
-0.03068879060447216,
0.752732515335083,
-0.21301384270191193,
-0.44601044058799744,
-0.16799025237560272,
-0.23460623621940613,
-0.8352662920951843,
0.007361120544373989,
-0.37935152649879456,
0.17436975240707397,
-0.5227104425430298,
-0.12599065899848938,
-0.25243037939071655,
0.19751176238059998,
-0.9565484523773193,
-0.15637941658496857,
0.08938208967447281,
1.2416099309921265,
-0.29186299443244934,
0.5554675459861755,
1.1462435722351074,
-0.2166067361831665,
-0.8684207201004028,
0.3515866994857788,
0.3190391957759857,
-0.9206976294517517,
0.17885375022888184,
0.03157621622085571,
-0.49377596378326416,
-0.2720918357372284,
-0.20914021134376526,
-0.933342456817627,
1.6144992113113403,
0.2786840498447418,
-0.42396244406700134,
0.21029068529605865,
0.28706684708595276,
0.5976428389549255,
-0.3380843698978424,
0.3957248330116272,
0.35533422231674194,
0.5712595582008362,
0.7228764891624451,
-0.9339553117752075,
0.20528392493724823,
-0.21125167608261108,
-0.09963054209947586,
0.033656373620033264,
-0.7603468894958496,
0.5500209927558899,
-0.2740820050239563,
-0.16398108005523682,
-0.15666870772838593,
0.4032280445098877,
0.33545610308647156,
0.7395802736282349,
0.44341379404067993,
0.4795026481151581,
1.0487648248672485,
0.004790578968822956,
0.6126662492752075,
-0.476576030254364,
-0.18047526478767395,
1.368698239326477,
-0.7433026432991028,
0.6729084253311157,
0.395722359418869,
-0.05063462629914284,
0.7304742336273193,
0.5669990181922913,
0.1554689258337021,
0.4925306737422943,
0.27042752504348755,
0.1144295483827591,
-0.10184679180383682,
-0.001432469580322504,
-0.30984076857566833,
0.4900554120540619,
-0.07667721807956696,
0.049796439707279205,
-0.4902086853981018,
-0.2292221188545227,
0.07448511570692062,
-0.22470226883888245,
-0.2693769037723541,
0.9354906678199768,
-0.06279385834932327,
-0.866965115070343,
0.301261842250824,
-0.22589853405952454,
0.17776717245578766,
-0.5767987370491028,
0.045560527592897415,
-0.6295650005340576,
0.2661113142967224,
-0.14950785040855408,
-0.8655832409858704,
0.40371260046958923,
-0.050407059490680695,
0.08074645698070526,
-0.4932638108730316,
0.8786007761955261,
0.17668768763542175,
-0.07760309427976608,
0.37770479917526245,
1.0220392942428589,
0.16843144595623016,
-0.4047611355781555,
-0.6055278182029724,
-0.11259645968675613,
-0.4384143650531769,
-0.3218088150024414,
0.21835380792617798,
0.8626090884208679,
-0.06705249100923538,
0.971695065498352,
0.32637539505958557,
0.03562336415052414,
0.009984138421714306,
0.19947144389152527,
0.9505086541175842,
-0.7787888050079346,
-0.2618442475795746,
-0.6925304532051086,
0.5834325551986694,
-0.2819056510925293,
-0.2060849964618683,
0.29727107286453247,
0.5879471302032471,
0.8225299715995789,
0.1515795737504959,
0.4727342128753662,
0.008031378500163555,
0.12637288868427277,
-0.4846743941307068,
0.5716651678085327,
-0.5635309219360352,
0.31163838505744934,
-0.10051976144313812,
-0.8537869453430176,
0.3506770133972168,
0.28181254863739014,
-0.03286822885274887,
0.22923001646995544,
0.7609313130378723,
0.6227315068244934,
0.2725326716899872,
-0.02519812621176243,
0.23877401649951935,
-0.2305193841457367,
0.3040451407432556,
0.6710289120674133,
1.0517525672912598,
0.1738898605108261,
0.6777676343917847,
-0.5958259105682373,
-0.16858704388141632,
-0.19526968896389008,
-0.9877825379371643,
-0.9620556235313416,
-0.5357503294944763,
-0.21292738616466522,
-0.04805406555533409,
-0.04738315939903259,
0.800429105758667,
0.8411186337471008,
-0.3254605829715729,
-0.303343802690506,
-0.16749195754528046,
0.5074206590652466,
-0.521611213684082,
-0.09865481406450272,
-0.15201297402381897,
-0.16363327205181122,
-0.1791735291481018,
0.45546606183052063,
0.354104608297348,
0.33095061779022217,
-0.588258683681488,
-0.3881182074546814,
0.3659422993659973,
-0.03023565001785755,
0.3927772045135498,
0.4103828966617584,
-0.4762442111968994,
0.18764628469944,
-0.006588733289390802,
-0.1356075257062912,
0.03372063487768173,
0.8662192225456238,
-0.7166669964790344,
0.1223754957318306,
0.48492881655693054,
0.3218081295490265,
0.5502781867980957,
-0.0611158050596714,
0.6594142913818359,
-0.45203712582588196,
0.12551358342170715,
0.5459082126617432,
0.5236240029335022,
0.04201521724462509,
-0.25656116008758545,
1.0968236923217773,
-0.04249448701739311,
-0.3912123143672943,
-0.685947060585022,
0.1435546725988388,
-1.061933159828186,
-0.27421048283576965,
1.2618091106414795,
-0.13323494791984558,
0.1499110907316208,
-0.03354187682271004,
-0.181897833943367,
0.09222733974456787,
-0.3758377134799957,
0.5764557123184204,
0.7102168202400208,
-0.7432541847229004,
0.014692740514874458,
-0.44166913628578186,
0.6181740760803223,
0.03531171381473541,
-1.120640516281128,
0.13654166460037231,
0.5612326264381409,
0.19852304458618164,
-0.05308612436056137,
0.902864933013916,
0.3001805543899536,
0.190560981631279,
0.27723872661590576,
0.0374881774187088,
-0.3925069272518158,
-0.4876222610473633,
0.033451300114393234,
0.2734561264514923,
0.4765003025531769,
0.15761038661003113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14883v1 | OATH-Frames: Characterizing Online Attitudes Towards Homelessness with LLM Assistants | 2024-06-21T06:09:47 | 2024-06-21T06:09:47 | Jaspreet Ranjit, Brihi Joshi, Rebecca Dorn, Laura Petry, Olga Koumoundouros, Jayne Bottarini, Peichen Liu, Eric Rice, Swabha Swayamdipta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Warning: Contents of this paper may be upsetting.
Public attitudes towards key societal issues, expressed on online media, are
of immense value in policy and reform efforts, yet challenging to understand at
scale. We study one such social issue: homelessness in the U.S., by leveraging
the remarkable capabilities of large language models to assist social work
experts in analyzing millions of posts from Twitter. We introduce a framing
typology: Online Attitudes Towards Homelessness (OATH) Frames: nine
hierarchical frames capturing critiques, responses and perceptions. We release
annotations with varying degrees of assistance from language models, with
immense benefits in scaling: 6.5x speedup in annotation time while only
incurring a 3 point F1 reduction in performance with respect to the domain
experts. Our experiments demonstrate the value of modeling OATH-Frames over
existing sentiment and toxicity classifiers. Our large-scale analysis with
predicted OATH-Frames on 2.4M posts on homelessness reveal key trends in
attitudes across states, time periods and vulnerable populations, enabling new
insights on the issue. Our work provides a general framework to understand
nuanced public attitudes at scale, on issues beyond homelessness. | [
-0.20141105353832245,
-0.5827611684799194,
0.6715898513793945,
0.38548439741134644,
0.04315993934869766,
-0.043332986533641815,
0.029494890943169594,
-0.37892821431159973,
0.631222128868103,
0.03573831915855408,
-0.19634957611560822,
-0.15527774393558502,
-1.0132076740264893,
0.2911745309829712,
-0.3271542191505432,
0.9161158204078674,
0.030417263507843018,
0.2683517634868622,
-0.3361695408821106,
-0.3408561944961548,
-0.12403109669685364,
-0.07462350279092789,
-0.3921075761318207,
-0.1469377726316452,
0.4215935468673706,
0.18538698554039001,
1.3302980661392212,
0.5588454008102417,
0.6690519452095032,
0.28774791955947876,
-0.13691052794456482,
-0.4306614100933075,
-0.8059312105178833,
-0.1630699634552002,
-0.17656375467777252,
-0.4797341227531433,
-0.8188655376434326,
0.017316291108727455,
0.22348126769065857,
0.5294954776763916,
-0.17469441890716553,
0.8116266131401062,
-0.226558655500412,
0.6844035387039185,
-0.6116244792938232,
0.30144229531288147,
-0.5867871046066284,
0.04600526764988899,
-0.24660028517246246,
0.07453704625368118,
-0.13222987949848175,
-0.5528128743171692,
-0.0938110426068306,
-0.7592650651931763,
0.25784626603126526,
0.15930144488811493,
0.6040180325508118,
0.2146836817264557,
-0.4713490605354309,
-0.4281853437423706,
-0.3973466157913208,
0.33995532989501953,
-0.6899243593215942,
0.3720279335975647,
0.8851989507675171,
0.017985844984650612,
0.2503455579280853,
-0.6086151599884033,
-0.6500471830368042,
-0.0720536857843399,
0.06492885202169418,
-0.28525903820991516,
-0.3510398268699646,
0.18741288781166077,
0.1411394327878952,
0.38309258222579956,
-0.5539194345474243,
-0.2921847701072693,
-0.5044737458229065,
-0.08615496754646301,
0.6340517401695251,
0.237625390291214,
0.42830193042755127,
-0.5528071522712708,
-0.4112343192100525,
0.14444255828857422,
-0.43444809317588806,
0.24739792943000793,
0.41556498408317566,
0.011697238311171532,
-0.2939051687717438,
0.8488878607749939,
0.10121118277311325,
0.1602809578180313,
0.40998759865760803,
0.10941845178604126,
0.31725597381591797,
0.12907661497592926,
-0.0009747212752699852,
-0.18660734593868256,
0.2967281937599182,
0.9512947201728821,
0.29710015654563904,
-0.03279779106378555,
-0.29486513137817383,
0.26386523246765137,
0.7486217021942139,
-0.5724013447761536,
0.11758340895175934,
0.43524396419525146,
-0.6706430315971375,
-0.35692137479782104,
0.041795339435338974,
-0.6930669546127319,
-0.9951696395874023,
-0.18019971251487732,
0.34081900119781494,
0.12093812227249146,
-0.4633488953113556,
-0.027331341058015823,
-0.3100266754627228,
0.48219984769821167,
0.3989599347114563,
-0.678572952747345,
0.1722189337015152,
0.8767676949501038,
1.0742350816726685,
-0.13467666506767273,
0.028021715581417084,
-0.3609412908554077,
-0.13343243300914764,
-0.4870418906211853,
0.4703260064125061,
-0.7542750239372253,
-0.00675508938729763,
0.285314679145813,
-0.045501627027988434,
0.1726323515176773,
-0.33400577306747437,
0.043957993388175964,
-0.5947655439376831,
-0.1925126612186432,
-0.16851231455802917,
-0.48612454533576965,
0.507131040096283,
0.6857526898384094,
-0.6817743182182312,
1.1086078882217407,
0.3006073534488678,
-0.8370987176895142,
0.10839882493019104,
-0.9759350419044495,
0.13050074875354767,
-0.0976480171084404,
0.2883846163749695,
-0.22470521926879883,
0.5828922390937805,
0.18682987987995148,
0.5751013159751892,
-0.01867547258734703,
0.5078276991844177,
-0.7898955345153809,
-0.038556523621082306,
0.3457910418510437,
-0.2577127516269684,
0.7569156289100647,
0.47446495294570923,
-0.3294844925403595,
0.19874776899814606,
-0.49710315465927124,
-0.38621798157691956,
-0.014337277039885521,
-0.1461900770664215,
-0.4569827914237976,
0.005440420471131802,
0.08797819912433624,
-0.14145247638225555,
0.392753541469574,
-0.8620096445083618,
-0.13773156702518463,
-0.3388535678386688,
0.5963298082351685,
0.880050003528595,
-0.28177592158317566,
0.44801652431488037,
-0.48490646481513977,
0.5589473247528076,
-0.4188670516014099,
0.4300694167613983,
0.14565281569957733,
-0.6933733820915222,
-0.3993831276893616,
0.08225400000810623,
-0.5468730926513672,
0.28229770064353943,
-0.424048513174057,
-0.04060181975364685,
-0.43449246883392334,
-0.15008610486984253,
-0.6911671757698059,
-0.058729492127895355,
0.49634668231010437,
-0.02012328803539276,
0.35621243715286255,
0.07722346484661102,
-0.11952850222587585,
-0.7512764930725098,
-0.785271406173706,
-0.5424845218658447,
-0.05907376855611801,
0.19078727066516876,
0.5615196228027344,
-0.035653360188007355,
1.091199517250061,
-0.5584973692893982,
-0.22333210706710815,
-0.014442544430494308,
0.3698176443576813,
-0.3757610321044922,
-0.028190473094582558,
0.3399266302585602,
-1.0117820501327515,
-0.4962669610977173,
-0.37415310740470886,
-0.7608071565628052,
-0.18482984602451324,
0.15571919083595276,
0.3783140480518341,
-0.012617114931344986,
0.4601011872291565,
-0.47976210713386536,
0.2618713080883026,
0.5327433347702026,
-0.6422038078308105,
0.2330801635980606,
0.08912598341703415,
0.2365999072790146,
-1.060550570487976,
-0.28722524642944336,
0.2684497535228729,
-0.12913557887077332,
-0.8001692295074463,
0.3534497022628784,
-0.17580091953277588,
-0.4997422397136688,
-0.8018949031829834,
0.6234833598136902,
-0.4316243827342987,
-0.11112664639949799,
0.12100818753242493,
0.15440909564495087,
0.08515393733978271,
0.24670401215553284,
0.017394043505191803,
0.556238055229187,
0.23254388570785522,
0.1292300671339035,
0.42926689982414246,
0.5204641819000244,
-0.16955453157424927,
0.817936360836029,
-0.37244459986686707,
0.34389227628707886,
-0.6372298002243042,
0.3790353536605835,
-1.3706085681915283,
-0.47181448340415955,
0.052774153649806976,
-0.5774781703948975,
-0.06172742694616318,
0.14703144133090973,
-0.059880323708057404,
-0.32425442337989807,
-0.9045442342758179,
0.5357829928398132,
-0.16956806182861328,
-0.09594225883483887,
0.5356959700584412,
0.7324245572090149,
-0.2507613003253937,
-0.3926027715206146,
-0.5086707472801208,
0.26749417185783386,
-0.49055570363998413,
-0.5463061928749084,
0.14677950739860535,
0.2667903006076813,
-0.9538960456848145,
0.12080018222332001,
-0.02756945788860321,
-0.5258208513259888,
-0.04067473113536835,
0.4641643166542053,
0.04645413160324097,
-0.1845211535692215,
0.20441493391990662,
-0.3036298453807831,
-0.11305716633796692,
0.26080676913261414,
0.16188783943653107,
0.18819591403007507,
-0.7031339406967163,
-0.3060232102870941,
-0.2976280450820923,
0.4854407012462616,
0.9338958859443665,
0.2509176731109619,
0.8599792718887329,
0.543972373008728,
-0.48133230209350586,
0.292976438999176,
-0.7866830825805664,
0.13759571313858032,
-0.40733930468559265,
0.0995158851146698,
-0.052352480590343475,
-0.8651522397994995,
0.391216903924942,
0.14860856533050537,
0.19305238127708435,
0.0525997057557106,
0.33823156356811523,
-0.44854217767715454,
0.5950307846069336,
0.5935383439064026,
-0.19538597762584686,
0.21005511283874512,
-0.09361957013607025,
0.1702246218919754,
-0.8325313329696655,
-0.10596819221973419,
-0.42784956097602844,
-0.30335235595703125,
-0.365314781665802,
-0.6751725077629089,
0.5540291666984558,
-0.08375217765569687,
-0.13910311460494995,
0.4474571943283081,
-0.2495219111442566,
0.2631668448448181,
-0.3890790343284607,
0.26750269532203674,
0.3364473879337311,
-0.4093976318836212,
0.37807324528694153,
0.0073972586542367935,
-0.19795110821723938,
-0.7587615847587585,
1.1004730463027954,
0.6731224656105042,
0.6239280700683594,
0.2866511046886444,
0.4205271899700165,
1.0118608474731445,
0.9536316394805908,
-0.9067249894142151,
0.319663405418396,
0.3408235013484955,
-1.0012457370758057,
-0.7768213152885437,
-0.014032760635018349,
-0.7227820158004761,
0.3756279945373535,
-0.3247557282447815,
-0.6322671175003052,
0.1640079915523529,
0.37563058733940125,
-0.321350634098053,
0.6149488687515259,
-0.5821849703788757,
0.6109707355499268,
-0.0660075917840004,
-0.17366498708724976,
-0.53863126039505,
-0.7662638425827026,
0.24260449409484863,
0.002052569529041648,
0.8876255750656128,
-0.602565348148346,
-0.2006625533103943,
0.3359946310520172,
-0.5440152883529663,
1.0858323574066162,
-0.2848856747150421,
-0.14893370866775513,
0.11129479855298996,
-0.06154358759522438,
0.8254450559616089,
-0.08529101312160492,
-0.4874917268753052,
0.18791623413562775,
0.25235453248023987,
-0.37545010447502136,
-0.25759443640708923,
0.2796027660369873,
-0.7773101329803467,
-0.5547673106193542,
-0.12785838544368744,
-0.48319968581199646,
-0.38804593682289124,
-0.27977028489112854,
0.07686999440193176,
0.7280563712120056,
-0.4995768070220947,
0.27772435545921326,
0.5690162181854248,
-0.19399450719356537,
0.28779852390289307,
0.03984406590461731,
-0.2300725132226944,
-0.39458736777305603,
0.7072699666023254,
0.12795989215373993,
0.42529061436653137,
0.5264235734939575,
0.7303469181060791,
-0.4416520893573761,
-0.3261909782886505,
-0.4728611409664154,
-0.02118641883134842,
-0.6830583810806274,
-0.17059959471225739,
-0.5006670355796814,
0.29114827513694763,
-0.7203738689422607,
-0.6508691310882568,
-0.3812340795993805,
-0.45658034086227417,
-0.037000205367803574,
-0.259904146194458,
0.5456753373146057,
1.10845148563385,
-0.030536411330103874,
0.25790053606033325,
-0.6790305972099304,
0.8385570645332336,
0.253407746553421,
0.6416406035423279,
-0.019118983298540115,
-0.4720810353755951,
0.031392984092235565,
-0.05280639976263046,
-0.017242584377527237,
-0.9990135431289673,
0.12187912315130234,
0.34846025705337524,
0.2580217123031616,
0.8185779452323914,
0.6899515390396118,
0.8762328624725342,
-0.2010941058397293,
1.0271345376968384,
0.1857410967350006,
-0.7008956074714661,
0.12354110926389694,
-0.670979917049408,
-0.13474027812480927,
0.5878469347953796,
0.7545928955078125,
-0.5780416131019592,
-0.7455974221229553,
-0.6021672487258911,
-0.7897672057151794,
0.6053787469863892,
0.2526495158672333,
0.6909288167953491,
-0.2633201777935028,
0.19145067036151886,
-0.006045143119990826,
0.4549832344055176,
-0.9185882806777954,
-0.4530259966850281,
-0.5978241562843323,
-0.1576291024684906,
0.3180846869945526,
-0.583166778087616,
-0.015101428143680096,
-0.2845411002635956,
0.3109956681728363,
0.025098402053117752,
0.1282794177532196,
-0.011180111207067966,
-0.24307112395763397,
-0.3864152729511261,
0.4939459562301636,
0.40427789092063904,
1.0704067945480347,
-0.19239352643489838,
0.24493585526943207,
0.3620370626449585,
-0.5076957941055298,
0.43304574489593506,
-0.5574142932891846,
-0.09239586442708969,
-0.09177061915397644,
0.4519491195678711,
0.5998325943946838,
0.5160833597183228,
-0.1493009775876999,
0.9662479758262634,
0.2739846110343933,
-0.10970399528741837,
-0.5830947756767273,
-0.33900994062423706,
0.3704776167869568,
0.11805751919746399,
0.3526482582092285,
-0.06703292578458786,
0.03390605375170708,
-0.7700726985931396,
0.0026325273793190718,
0.584540605545044,
-0.5604504942893982,
-0.5158458948135376,
0.6576071381568909,
0.4748426377773285,
-0.6931284070014954,
0.34236031770706177,
-0.24277134239673615,
-0.13825954496860504,
0.37465330958366394,
0.4980345070362091,
0.9775854349136353,
-0.016296660527586937,
0.6589010953903198,
0.13485832512378693,
0.14392712712287903,
-0.31475919485092163,
-0.10090520977973938,
-0.2905955910682678,
-0.9323544502258301,
0.1876920908689499,
-1.0162509679794312,
-0.31949660181999207,
0.2031378149986267,
-0.9805110692977905,
-0.2026354968547821,
-0.5190695524215698,
-0.5098603963851929,
-0.08646105974912643,
-0.4275473952293396,
-0.43606865406036377,
-0.07084114849567413,
0.19437579810619354,
0.9147346019744873,
-1.2369294166564941,
0.3878031075000763,
0.9034512639045715,
-0.09685705602169037,
-0.6027874946594238,
0.466490775346756,
0.7000594735145569,
-0.925667405128479,
0.16552087664604187,
0.2058827131986618,
-0.4003874957561493,
0.007048359140753746,
-0.4768836796283722,
-0.94286048412323,
0.865927517414093,
0.49727916717529297,
-0.11315840482711792,
-0.40342339873313904,
0.4422813057899475,
0.5607455372810364,
-0.4819676876068115,
0.12223675847053528,
0.5342150330543518,
0.8243714570999146,
0.0072668008506298065,
-0.9539283514022827,
-0.033883947879076004,
-0.406404972076416,
0.14768071472644806,
0.17244598269462585,
-0.5265906453132629,
0.49582621455192566,
-0.31915855407714844,
-0.30999431014060974,
-0.08295217901468277,
0.3960924446582794,
-0.2086178958415985,
0.5299778580665588,
0.6130422353744507,
0.5095376968383789,
0.527737557888031,
0.1274137645959854,
0.8298875093460083,
-0.20208312571048737,
0.2577058970928192,
0.7741167545318604,
-0.22663326561450958,
0.9065742492675781,
0.34418272972106934,
-0.3956758975982666,
0.3868684768676758,
0.21348489820957184,
0.21203933656215668,
0.05509541928768158,
0.3604806065559387,
-0.22913794219493866,
-0.24939380586147308,
-0.3369194269180298,
-0.0849752128124237,
0.4466521739959717,
0.3495151698589325,
-0.037150993943214417,
-0.6634092926979065,
0.4856673777103424,
0.10184285789728165,
0.4583631157875061,
-0.6759705543518066,
0.7034411430358887,
0.22041089832782745,
-0.4503878653049469,
0.1585908830165863,
-0.05671793967485428,
0.4999238848686218,
-0.35363486409187317,
-0.023338673636317253,
-0.018962860107421875,
-0.21212399005889893,
-0.3889845907688141,
-0.9544267058372498,
0.8915917873382568,
0.33057156205177307,
-0.14299532771110535,
-0.7838937044143677,
0.5998061895370483,
0.0441356785595417,
-0.3710366487503052,
0.2950689196586609,
0.33722230792045593,
0.5619814991950989,
-0.23558162152767181,
-0.6857640147209167,
0.11242829263210297,
-0.3765690326690674,
-0.4172687530517578,
0.5097291469573975,
0.3047637939453125,
-0.31514596939086914,
0.766732931137085,
0.4306742250919342,
0.2737155556678772,
0.1622467190027237,
-0.2080857902765274,
0.5783069133758545,
-0.48311367630958557,
-0.27704086899757385,
-0.6745909452438354,
0.5077800750732422,
0.08219406008720398,
-0.6546638607978821,
0.5334607362747192,
0.295457661151886,
0.7436544299125671,
-0.015451733022928238,
0.32939812541007996,
-0.44648414850234985,
0.3094799816608429,
-0.20132118463516235,
0.6379390954971313,
-0.3831882178783417,
0.10132114589214325,
-0.28890538215637207,
-0.5647380352020264,
-0.03593364357948303,
0.6468031406402588,
-0.38188835978507996,
-0.5694793462753296,
0.3394950032234192,
1.024119257926941,
0.3536890745162964,
-0.07713926583528519,
0.3459216356277466,
0.1319679319858551,
0.126742884516716,
-0.061724741011857986,
0.7808097004890442,
-0.08610092848539352,
0.43281593918800354,
0.14365053176879883,
0.05609406530857086,
-0.1884327381849289,
-0.8481930494308472,
-0.6828081011772156,
-0.750186026096344,
-0.20136505365371704,
-0.4415011405944824,
-0.044553376734256744,
1.3503552675247192,
0.4325292706489563,
-0.7958362102508545,
-0.09149888157844543,
0.05727510526776314,
0.2710424065589905,
-0.1614173799753189,
-0.32335570454597473,
0.2589024603366852,
-0.23761215806007385,
-0.32932886481285095,
0.05615182965993881,
0.3502757251262665,
-0.5579097270965576,
-0.6603224277496338,
-0.05823716148734093,
-0.10266444832086563,
0.33076679706573486,
0.7250820398330688,
0.2612210214138031,
-1.028139591217041,
-0.5676496624946594,
-0.15444394946098328,
-0.24060234427452087,
0.35240674018859863,
0.6593565940856934,
-0.2650356590747833,
0.45820221304893494,
0.5842819809913635,
0.3526064455509186,
0.3283972144126892,
0.6073096990585327,
0.3918166160583496,
-0.5941154360771179,
-0.2886006534099579,
0.2221405804157257,
0.21366995573043823,
0.44944149255752563,
-0.625676155090332,
0.27536705136299133,
0.18188223242759705,
-0.2310430258512497,
-0.8273259997367859,
0.13294050097465515,
-0.4677550792694092,
-0.24492965638637543,
1.0929582118988037,
-0.3175640106201172,
-0.103601835668087,
-0.6550760269165039,
0.33006128668785095,
0.01492566242814064,
-0.548765242099762,
1.2573790550231934,
0.6375870704650879,
-0.1460600048303604,
-0.12079837918281555,
-0.6592076420783997,
0.5782431364059448,
-0.16663245856761932,
-0.6542289853096008,
0.39034736156463623,
0.6055247783660889,
0.3898579776287079,
0.4827658534049988,
1.1623764038085938,
-0.06585134565830231,
0.0423746332526207,
0.07473321259021759,
-0.3461765944957733,
-0.30086612701416016,
-0.4947727918624878,
-0.2624516785144806,
0.553526759147644,
0.014480900019407272,
0.010839883238077164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14882v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14882v1 | 70B-parameter large language models in Japanese medical question-answering | 2024-06-21T06:04:10 | 2024-06-21T06:04:10 | Issey Sukeda, Risa Kishikawa, Satoshi Kodera | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the rise of large language models (LLMs), the domain adaptation has
been one of the hot topics in various domains. Many medical LLMs trained with
English medical dataset have made public recently. However, Japanese LLMs in
medical domain still lack its research. Here we utilize multiple 70B-parameter
LLMs for the first time and show that instruction tuning using Japanese medical
question-answering dataset significantly improves the ability of Japanese LLMs
to solve Japanese medical license exams, surpassing 50\% in accuracy. In
particular, the Japanese-centric models exhibit a more significant leap in
improvement through instruction tuning compared to their English-centric
counterparts. This underscores the importance of continual pretraining and the
adjustment of the tokenizer in our local language. We also examine two slightly
different prompt formats, resulting in non-negligible performance improvement. | [
-0.3242918848991394,
-0.9532626271247864,
0.7706364393234253,
-0.1558903008699417,
-0.3346259295940399,
-0.11241483688354492,
-0.4226919114589691,
-0.23223434388637543,
0.010947220958769321,
0.6722558736801147,
-0.5904121398925781,
-0.7145258784294128,
-0.5888055562973022,
0.2666178047657013,
0.3153197765350342,
0.8162094950675964,
-0.19754204154014587,
0.6581302285194397,
-0.3434830605983734,
-0.054375745356082916,
-0.7167825102806091,
-0.4670320153236389,
-1.0695830583572388,
-0.22751131653785706,
0.5440101027488708,
0.3332688808441162,
0.5275276899337769,
0.6504337191581726,
0.6088266968727112,
0.28088709712028503,
-0.07719919085502625,
0.1652919054031372,
-0.11501671373844147,
0.21943357586860657,
-0.05548560991883278,
-1.0452935695648193,
-0.6862599849700928,
-0.27927786111831665,
0.8058244585990906,
0.8988661170005798,
-0.04240941256284714,
-0.07752184569835663,
-0.3683313727378845,
0.7807610034942627,
-0.4246920347213745,
0.24064864218235016,
-0.5037673711776733,
-0.21986554563045502,
-0.25948366522789,
-0.3782399594783783,
-0.6082229614257812,
-0.35127758979797363,
-0.0465807281434536,
-0.6874605417251587,
0.24966394901275635,
-0.007912210188806057,
0.7763250470161438,
0.36453360319137573,
-0.34103938937187195,
-0.1980598121881485,
-0.28490957617759705,
0.5396542549133301,
-0.9191069602966309,
0.32949694991111755,
0.3712834417819977,
0.17735353112220764,
-0.23979079723358154,
-0.6339336037635803,
-0.1034286767244339,
-0.24591588973999023,
0.3239721953868866,
0.15647611021995544,
0.2898730933666229,
0.22517041862010956,
0.4906160533428192,
0.20439675450325012,
-0.5885258316993713,
0.5399224162101746,
-0.44403693079948425,
-0.20692582428455353,
0.586658775806427,
0.5188624858856201,
0.39484620094299316,
-0.09708897024393082,
0.06251456588506699,
-0.07587513327598572,
-0.8547401428222656,
-0.029826244339346886,
0.05276873707771301,
0.2623179256916046,
-0.044942401349544525,
0.2830184996128082,
-0.2281356155872345,
1.0767289400100708,
0.09216859936714172,
-0.4774625599384308,
0.19121244549751282,
-0.15276572108268738,
-0.010612772777676582,
0.10530032962560654,
0.5616948008537292,
0.43514636158943176,
0.4572911262512207,
-0.09659477323293686,
0.0642208456993103,
-0.13975590467453003,
0.3086280822753906,
-0.8322328329086304,
-0.022041069343686104,
0.20264355838298798,
-0.40328124165534973,
0.1138993501663208,
-0.030561406165361404,
-0.5471245646476746,
-0.34301620721817017,
-0.4612332284450531,
0.49418962001800537,
-0.3647817075252533,
-0.09197398275136948,
0.46974772214889526,
-0.035602159798145294,
0.43332546949386597,
0.44573870301246643,
-0.6304144263267517,
0.052328452467918396,
0.6940491795539856,
0.6826531887054443,
-0.2744229733943939,
-0.13476577401161194,
-0.2442212849855423,
0.08762689679861069,
-0.6287400722503662,
0.6184934377670288,
-0.7061384320259094,
-0.6485893726348877,
-0.1658993810415268,
0.48163145780563354,
-0.27536770701408386,
-0.7757530212402344,
0.10379768162965775,
-0.6470621824264526,
0.4054702818393707,
-0.3816891610622406,
-0.6313011050224304,
-0.12404174357652664,
0.21172596514225006,
-0.35687878727912903,
0.6684854626655579,
0.11089261621236801,
-0.3384189009666443,
0.1449965238571167,
-0.6836631298065186,
-0.5336103439331055,
0.12466395646333694,
0.14925642311573029,
-0.38787218928337097,
0.2506784200668335,
0.41473549604415894,
0.5653058290481567,
-0.3227808177471161,
0.33404451608657837,
-0.2276122272014618,
-0.5161835551261902,
0.4068309962749481,
-0.5804550647735596,
0.7124959230422974,
-0.12661467492580414,
-0.04794824868440628,
-0.09084440022706985,
-0.6265603303909302,
0.19007861614227295,
0.19269275665283203,
-0.30632996559143066,
-0.4117657244205475,
-0.3903856575489044,
-0.4946191906929016,
-0.08679278939962387,
0.32938241958618164,
-0.4141859710216522,
0.35935378074645996,
-0.6042909026145935,
0.19237346947193146,
0.5746566653251648,
0.38196608424186707,
0.24226538836956024,
-0.3487883508205414,
0.9963285326957703,
0.14145824313163757,
0.26890403032302856,
-0.45564496517181396,
-0.6973869800567627,
-0.7353385090827942,
-0.08721429109573364,
0.517256498336792,
0.4885188639163971,
-0.7765358686447144,
0.1785520762205124,
-0.16999225318431854,
-0.5925997495651245,
-0.7138296365737915,
-0.16035842895507812,
0.4761910140514374,
0.6924543976783752,
0.27284863591194153,
-0.429625004529953,
-0.18009255826473236,
-0.5808106660842896,
-0.07548690587282181,
-0.1118675023317337,
0.07310428470373154,
0.48075050115585327,
0.2788468301296234,
-0.013289867900311947,
0.2741517126560211,
-0.6894621849060059,
0.004756571725010872,
-0.18462274968624115,
-0.22663481533527374,
0.4780479371547699,
0.27395206689834595,
0.41054901480674744,
-0.6420737504959106,
-0.6669734120368958,
-0.031567685306072235,
-0.5519087910652161,
-0.21060888469219208,
0.08320295065641403,
-0.21847307682037354,
0.33562585711479187,
0.5097154974937439,
-0.2714393734931946,
0.07867427915334702,
0.331421434879303,
-0.14267900586128235,
0.4611850380897522,
-0.49949872493743896,
0.47652825713157654,
-1.4259072542190552,
-0.11717907339334488,
-0.018170129507780075,
-0.31304341554641724,
-0.6178886294364929,
0.1904660016298294,
0.3078914284706116,
-0.16837471723556519,
-0.5982398986816406,
0.6824376583099365,
-0.6281459927558899,
0.06211680546402931,
-0.5026894807815552,
0.10608430951833725,
0.07888882607221603,
0.2827373743057251,
0.1531381905078888,
0.9607068300247192,
0.797368586063385,
-0.7919853925704956,
0.3454395532608032,
0.11514859646558762,
-0.2538544535636902,
0.6151134967803955,
-0.6907524466514587,
0.3156905472278595,
-0.47064995765686035,
0.1913135051727295,
-0.7778106927871704,
-0.4204822778701782,
0.16803953051567078,
-0.29948416352272034,
0.7478871941566467,
-0.27612966299057007,
-0.19938704371452332,
-0.3895183801651001,
-0.004944374784827232,
0.06097586825489998,
0.6833221316337585,
-0.3047500252723694,
0.38880953192710876,
0.2687807083129883,
-0.44921600818634033,
-0.50519859790802,
-0.41654708981513977,
-0.15959881246089935,
-0.11023359000682831,
-0.21023254096508026,
0.17532581090927124,
-0.20833058655261993,
0.03190694376826286,
-0.0649121031165123,
-0.16441862285137177,
-0.13798899948596954,
0.2883510887622833,
0.23747725784778595,
0.6225109696388245,
-0.6615710854530334,
0.13942348957061768,
0.4003054201602936,
-0.23929426074028015,
0.3538636565208435,
-0.05454728379845619,
0.7161787152290344,
0.14644549787044525,
-0.31535103917121887,
-0.6249820590019226,
0.21136099100112915,
0.43677541613578796,
-0.1550329178571701,
0.7703326940536499,
0.19621725380420685,
-0.16681160032749176,
-0.01462866272777319,
-0.5329771637916565,
-0.1751932054758072,
-0.4723488688468933,
0.9037237167358398,
-0.5808915495872498,
-0.8949434757232666,
0.256657212972641,
-0.1175021231174469,
-0.053319983184337616,
0.3874635696411133,
0.7685103416442871,
-0.08640506118535995,
1.1075128316879272,
0.25505495071411133,
0.0043085115030407906,
0.2684991955757141,
0.1288471668958664,
-0.20819582045078278,
-0.8874916434288025,
-0.2519899308681488,
-0.6373194456100464,
-0.15357369184494019,
-0.5582743287086487,
-0.43509119749069214,
0.7220975160598755,
-0.24416746199131012,
-0.1878044456243515,
-0.16834230720996857,
-0.34338632225990295,
0.7786676287651062,
0.2275114506483078,
0.5166136622428894,
0.09635923057794571,
-0.18121632933616638,
0.14649391174316406,
-0.13475576043128967,
-0.7966716289520264,
-0.3044930100440979,
1.4558022022247314,
0.34293317794799805,
0.8357812762260437,
-0.13513213396072388,
0.5909097194671631,
-0.23608160018920898,
0.5554648637771606,
-0.7391297817230225,
0.5506797432899475,
-0.6807428598403931,
-0.8741233944892883,
-0.24026893079280853,
-0.47932547330856323,
-0.88875412940979,
0.049937061965465546,
0.11080578714609146,
-0.35237863659858704,
-0.19644467532634735,
0.06408502906560898,
-0.1404169499874115,
0.06221892312169075,
-0.6280406713485718,
0.7230117917060852,
-0.39236631989479065,
-0.14627717435359955,
-0.016223885118961334,
-0.6260703206062317,
0.1611584722995758,
-0.19451431930065155,
0.061892326921224594,
-0.24561423063278198,
-0.36423346400260925,
0.8821864724159241,
-0.02286655642092228,
0.8009859323501587,
-0.5277420282363892,
-0.05525429919362068,
-0.05232103168964386,
-0.2623853385448456,
0.2500135898590088,
0.25933998823165894,
-0.19981664419174194,
0.0769975483417511,
0.13547354936599731,
-0.5369150638580322,
-0.699989914894104,
0.651051938533783,
-0.8370648622512817,
-1.0513930320739746,
-0.14455218613147736,
-0.7254863381385803,
-0.6990620493888855,
0.20131365954875946,
0.321743905544281,
0.6324870586395264,
0.017053047195076942,
0.2510138750076294,
1.1006205081939697,
-0.4323442280292511,
0.18985730409622192,
0.7788521647453308,
-0.20027706027030945,
-0.32879868149757385,
0.5747969746589661,
0.19054464995861053,
0.5597776174545288,
0.43369773030281067,
0.2753540575504303,
-0.40720823407173157,
-0.5720085501670837,
-0.7852780222892761,
0.6841467618942261,
-0.7880069017410278,
-0.13937892019748688,
-0.6272578239440918,
-0.3120574653148651,
-0.33624157309532166,
-0.12734360992908478,
-0.24790053069591522,
-0.0859031081199646,
-0.35683542490005493,
0.1482236683368683,
0.40247711539268494,
0.5146341323852539,
0.559197187423706,
0.4333891272544861,
-0.8487989902496338,
0.3037809729576111,
-0.005256850738078356,
0.3323747217655182,
-0.1769629567861557,
-1.0194848775863647,
-0.24364757537841797,
0.15850290656089783,
0.005555273965001106,
-0.9988505244255066,
0.15749837458133698,
0.1743941605091095,
0.6213461756706238,
0.22107446193695068,
-0.11936987936496735,
0.8662118911743164,
-0.5047647953033447,
0.8266494870185852,
0.05449577048420906,
-0.694353461265564,
0.5545576810836792,
-0.06933798640966415,
0.6223520636558533,
0.6112977862358093,
0.9087973833084106,
-0.4715060591697693,
-0.3179744482040405,
-0.37083685398101807,
-0.5504817366600037,
0.6416022181510925,
-0.7210959792137146,
0.539563775062561,
0.12304305285215378,
1.0017564296722412,
0.3971104323863983,
0.04811463505029678,
-0.3721529543399811,
-0.45000845193862915,
0.12708383798599243,
-0.4966469407081604,
-0.269505113363266,
-0.19468972086906433,
0.1545177400112152,
-0.42896711826324463,
0.8825997710227966,
-0.3270859122276306,
0.24688969552516937,
0.03644982725381851,
0.038717467337846756,
0.007901646196842194,
0.41374364495277405,
0.454285204410553,
0.918332040309906,
0.021454211324453354,
-0.13147468864917755,
0.4541933834552765,
-0.6238335371017456,
0.36581501364707947,
-0.04915967211127281,
-0.26666978001594543,
0.18626318871974945,
0.31883499026298523,
1.0151220560073853,
0.13071322441101074,
-0.5878007411956787,
0.35658934712409973,
-0.04637441039085388,
-0.279929518699646,
0.01645698770880699,
0.5715132355690002,
0.19652938842773438,
-0.06087626516819,
0.08153627067804337,
-0.41539686918258667,
-0.10737638175487518,
-0.4519841969013214,
0.023002512753009796,
0.36196592450141907,
-0.4823538661003113,
-0.1319366693496704,
0.7447402477264404,
-0.05709705501794815,
-0.30577072501182556,
0.48755770921707153,
0.2102210968732834,
-0.4985150992870331,
0.8012533187866211,
0.9145628213882446,
0.40253323316574097,
-0.4093795418739319,
0.2355763018131256,
0.46185725927352905,
0.04621069133281708,
-0.24510179460048676,
0.593377411365509,
0.21380779147148132,
-0.5737990140914917,
-0.6119023561477661,
-0.538758397102356,
-0.7444282174110413,
0.15205830335617065,
-0.9496179223060608,
0.24672789871692657,
-0.5369718074798584,
-0.29478150606155396,
0.03683880716562271,
0.1372537612915039,
-0.4582665264606476,
0.5943930745124817,
-0.06724128127098083,
0.8077576756477356,
-0.751450777053833,
0.9441498517990112,
1.1671372652053833,
-0.20226195454597473,
-0.9106258153915405,
-0.002060457831248641,
-0.4112069606781006,
-1.0929213762283325,
0.35091203451156616,
0.05794361233711243,
0.35957759618759155,
0.2371346354484558,
-0.49937036633491516,
-0.7731986045837402,
0.8409485220909119,
0.34199902415275574,
-0.8487488031387329,
-0.028067225590348244,
0.20990429818630219,
0.5954546928405762,
-0.32214197516441345,
0.21059371531009674,
0.3877728283405304,
0.33487027883529663,
-0.1348874568939209,
-0.716397225856781,
0.0026765097863972187,
-0.07066386193037033,
0.0382591187953949,
0.34319189190864563,
-0.7029821872711182,
0.5715395212173462,
-0.2761809527873993,
0.19255299866199493,
0.015600073151290417,
0.378897488117218,
0.3864220380783081,
0.4328499436378479,
0.3453291356563568,
0.2345965951681137,
0.7917269468307495,
-0.25719571113586426,
1.0748560428619385,
-0.39030665159225464,
-0.05824550241231918,
0.9068931341171265,
-0.37489083409309387,
0.7558060884475708,
0.3575192391872406,
-0.3608502149581909,
0.43987441062927246,
0.637576162815094,
0.06872310489416122,
0.2641717195510864,
0.048713911324739456,
-0.052279092371463776,
-0.48779726028442383,
-0.0861622542142868,
-0.6192487478256226,
0.2775018811225891,
0.32629823684692383,
-0.34741348028182983,
0.24573010206222534,
0.30944496393203735,
0.28739163279533386,
-0.030469104647636414,
-0.5546225309371948,
0.8680764436721802,
0.21214357018470764,
-0.7855060696601868,
0.5971217751502991,
0.003965157084167004,
0.5133402943611145,
-0.7965700030326843,
0.30858728289604187,
-0.46024376153945923,
0.0333903469145298,
0.03110538423061371,
-0.6556686162948608,
0.04643762856721878,
0.11826861649751663,
-0.3446003794670105,
0.036486342549324036,
0.5278381109237671,
-0.26382240653038025,
-0.5639404058456421,
-0.1919076144695282,
0.4159614145755768,
0.31689637899398804,
0.11434107273817062,
-0.656743586063385,
-0.12541694939136505,
-0.02339927665889263,
-0.31707867980003357,
0.4478597044944763,
0.4684072434902191,
-0.10646916925907135,
0.5883913636207581,
0.6271247267723083,
0.5783550143241882,
0.2533912658691406,
0.37559255957603455,
0.6309937834739685,
-0.709220290184021,
-0.4372786581516266,
-0.7243930101394653,
0.2975023090839386,
0.07798226922750473,
-0.47875240445137024,
0.621136486530304,
0.33101004362106323,
0.8094668388366699,
-0.29160892963409424,
0.5962868928909302,
0.21562860906124115,
0.5306127071380615,
-0.9174977540969849,
0.6653484106063843,
-0.8963288068771362,
0.13352522253990173,
0.15990374982357025,
-0.7339532971382141,
-0.3712397515773773,
0.2192758470773697,
-0.4398404061794281,
0.37484681606292725,
0.7693911790847778,
0.9946497082710266,
0.201261505484581,
-0.11994145065546036,
0.48980244994163513,
0.23888254165649414,
0.04640015587210655,
0.7224091291427612,
0.7061426043510437,
-0.4575347602367401,
0.08099821954965591,
-0.2748175859451294,
-0.05082205682992935,
-0.033503659069538116,
-0.4916514754295349,
-0.9176853895187378,
-0.27005860209465027,
-0.563092827796936,
-0.36514410376548767,
0.30483001470565796,
0.8487218618392944,
0.5796017646789551,
-0.841931939125061,
0.0015383990248665214,
0.3559718728065491,
-0.08644095808267593,
-0.045515988022089005,
-0.17340849339962006,
0.35662057995796204,
-0.46979445219039917,
-0.8294219970703125,
0.36304235458374023,
0.2840369641780853,
-0.037549570202827454,
-0.1662604957818985,
-0.08260690420866013,
0.20216558873653412,
0.14735431969165802,
0.15845590829849243,
-0.10036112368106842,
-0.5914638638496399,
-0.05282696336507797,
0.38349196314811707,
-0.24252784252166748,
0.38356733322143555,
0.6617818474769592,
-0.40510082244873047,
0.5365681052207947,
0.30359965562820435,
0.8110178709030151,
0.3822878897190094,
0.02969643659889698,
0.45988187193870544,
-0.47053027153015137,
0.04348064959049225,
0.10566902160644531,
0.22293183207511902,
0.3699256479740143,
-0.37288698554039,
0.28775715827941895,
0.28116104006767273,
-0.616787850856781,
-0.7584736943244934,
-0.0013579375809058547,
-0.9174984097480774,
-0.5301092863082886,
1.2197225093841553,
-0.17051051557064056,
-0.4762863218784332,
-0.12290915101766586,
-0.38990795612335205,
0.33834511041641235,
0.047382522374391556,
0.6297850608825684,
0.709929883480072,
-0.03012474998831749,
-0.2721453607082367,
-0.5847305655479431,
0.19297316670417786,
0.748488187789917,
-1.1300647258758545,
-0.24155329167842865,
0.3915867507457733,
0.6602039933204651,
-0.3464992940425873,
0.6487125754356384,
-0.3222578763961792,
0.6077557802200317,
-0.3058371841907501,
-0.17015017569065094,
-0.2661890983581543,
-0.2968815863132477,
-0.569401204586029,
0.26772719621658325,
0.4554610848426819,
-0.17037974298000336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14877v1 | Sports Intelligence: Assessing the Sports Understanding Capabilities of Language Models through Question Answering from Text to Video | 2024-06-21T05:57:50 | 2024-06-21T05:57:50 | Zhengbang Yang, Haotian Xia, Jingxi Li, Zezhi Chen, Zhuangdi Zhu, Weining Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding sports is crucial for the advancement of Natural Language
Processing (NLP) due to its intricate and dynamic nature. Reasoning over
complex sports scenarios has posed significant challenges to current NLP
technologies which require advanced cognitive capabilities. Toward addressing
the limitations of existing benchmarks on sports understanding in the NLP
field, we extensively evaluated mainstream large language models for various
sports tasks. Our evaluation spans from simple queries on basic rules and
historical facts to complex, context-specific reasoning, leveraging strategies
from zero-shot to few-shot learning, and chain-of-thought techniques. In
addition to unimodal analysis, we further assessed the sports reasoning
capabilities of mainstream video language models to bridge the gap in
multimodal sports understanding benchmarking. Our findings highlighted the
critical challenges of sports understanding for NLP. We proposed a new
benchmark based on a comprehensive overview of existing sports datasets and
provided extensive error analysis which we hope can help identify future
research priorities in this field. | [
-0.24519416689872742,
-0.8727415800094604,
0.5589594841003418,
0.04253867268562317,
-0.11361534893512726,
0.16308623552322388,
-0.3587573766708374,
-0.636730968952179,
-0.26666542887687683,
0.12666860222816467,
-0.9116160869598389,
-0.4761209487915039,
-0.7109372615814209,
-0.021016597747802734,
-0.28516489267349243,
0.8604739904403687,
-0.22252818942070007,
0.1971440613269806,
-0.5491364598274231,
-0.679405152797699,
-0.7780675888061523,
-0.6012119054794312,
-0.6688384413719177,
-0.3125273883342743,
-0.19119931757450104,
0.1938680112361908,
0.5465286374092102,
0.2748515009880066,
0.9025322794914246,
0.37985190749168396,
-0.2043178677558899,
0.24483421444892883,
-0.5310667753219604,
0.505438506603241,
-0.39777934551239014,
-0.23566772043704987,
-0.46016618609428406,
-0.0838775634765625,
0.6417064666748047,
0.9636178016662598,
0.08788109570741653,
0.590458869934082,
-0.2347293645143509,
0.6793375611305237,
-0.64729905128479,
0.17996786534786224,
-0.660162091255188,
0.17222172021865845,
-0.022703202441334724,
-0.3586413562297821,
-0.1066804975271225,
0.21076847612857819,
0.22468146681785583,
-0.5975251197814941,
0.29097986221313477,
-0.052099429070949554,
0.608461320400238,
0.32460781931877136,
-0.2873598337173462,
-0.15675459802150726,
-0.9381943345069885,
0.6277689933776855,
-0.6357014179229736,
0.6834760904312134,
0.5961781740188599,
0.5686835646629333,
0.12019065022468567,
-0.3500906825065613,
-0.334615021944046,
0.05645570531487465,
0.2329387366771698,
0.2422810047864914,
-0.186746284365654,
-0.06709480285644531,
0.38679230213165283,
0.056367941200733185,
-0.7334855794906616,
-0.16392457485198975,
-0.27107030153274536,
0.41309434175491333,
0.9484469294548035,
0.34575968980789185,
0.37945517897605896,
-0.008482715114951134,
-0.020809238776564598,
0.17332439124584198,
-0.07338577508926392,
0.5669537782669067,
0.11476590484380722,
0.1439422219991684,
0.07878705859184265,
0.5738963484764099,
-0.741064727306366,
0.6509409546852112,
-0.29121285676956177,
-0.1484045684337616,
0.16741640865802765,
-0.43494606018066406,
-0.442568838596344,
-0.058658063411712646,
0.4973888397216797,
0.6348885297775269,
0.18356624245643616,
-0.6221609711647034,
0.07177401334047318,
-0.14225487411022186,
0.08773543685674667,
-0.48756569623947144,
0.1516341120004654,
0.3616429567337036,
-0.5442709922790527,
0.14789457619190216,
0.04017756134271622,
-0.6645022630691528,
-0.409051775932312,
-0.29424500465393066,
0.4682077467441559,
-0.547602117061615,
-0.20041631162166595,
0.5359157919883728,
-0.5421323776245117,
0.4661652743816376,
0.18938693404197693,
-1.0071372985839844,
0.2482621669769287,
0.6988555192947388,
0.4492383897304535,
0.19004780054092407,
-0.247678741812706,
-0.4091828465461731,
0.17622141540050507,
-0.0931318923830986,
1.1182677745819092,
-0.5774994492530823,
0.10891211777925491,
0.17594702541828156,
-0.3755306899547577,
-0.10510820150375366,
-0.3115367293357849,
0.6238263249397278,
-0.4350035488605499,
-0.21177610754966736,
-0.11082833260297775,
-0.6613937020301819,
-0.6092109680175781,
0.5638262033462524,
-0.3850260078907013,
1.0970215797424316,
-0.07518801838159561,
-0.4628430902957916,
0.6126286387443542,
-0.7425630688667297,
-0.5043780207633972,
0.1875630021095276,
0.004867998883128166,
-0.16189730167388916,
0.25743862986564636,
0.48481401801109314,
0.303374707698822,
-0.6036052107810974,
0.4152750074863434,
-0.6344369649887085,
-0.19484691321849823,
0.40378743410110474,
-0.4529135823249817,
0.4888426661491394,
-0.07090315967798233,
-0.18281793594360352,
-0.14223650097846985,
-0.7068865895271301,
0.18766847252845764,
-0.04444943368434906,
-0.01881624385714531,
-0.2136240303516388,
0.46347615122795105,
-0.2330518215894699,
0.2948800325393677,
-0.020232990384101868,
-0.28680697083473206,
0.07386481761932373,
-0.2345869243144989,
0.4513556957244873,
0.3345586955547333,
-0.07806955277919769,
0.4474768340587616,
0.015239909291267395,
0.5070375204086304,
-0.4401766061782837,
0.3877503573894501,
-0.10573168843984604,
-0.5011208653450012,
-0.2950528860092163,
0.03181504085659981,
-0.025286806747317314,
0.5799427032470703,
-0.5639106035232544,
0.08791261911392212,
-0.5263148546218872,
-0.5304238200187683,
-0.49596038460731506,
0.3167964518070221,
0.29314666986465454,
0.5583176612854004,
0.4556731879711151,
0.03636745736002922,
-0.589261531829834,
-0.6207160949707031,
-0.6260787844657898,
-0.216298446059227,
0.17492975294589996,
0.4860024154186249,
0.6445163488388062,
0.2662535607814789,
0.6565783619880676,
-0.37660935521125793,
-0.21734119951725006,
-0.4934674799442291,
0.38050737977027893,
0.2102307379245758,
0.18019838631153107,
0.7389411926269531,
-0.9560864567756653,
-0.3856895864009857,
-0.07161194831132889,
-1.2270302772521973,
0.013679992407560349,
-0.09014183282852173,
-0.08108308911323547,
-0.33805051445961,
0.5168200135231018,
-0.727660596370697,
0.7024309635162354,
0.489386647939682,
-0.709586501121521,
0.30740997195243835,
-0.08858524262905121,
0.6603580713272095,
-0.20877407491207123,
0.22754164040088654,
0.1816425919532776,
-0.0613534115254879,
-0.8140235543251038,
0.06080338731408119,
-0.4838675260543823,
-0.021777089685201645,
-0.3953004777431488,
0.34552720189094543,
-0.4606008231639862,
-0.33792057633399963,
-0.28573495149612427,
0.21368108689785004,
0.07636376470327377,
0.26538190245628357,
0.3349733352661133,
0.4897730350494385,
0.6274508833885193,
-0.6611820459365845,
0.6090941429138184,
0.4132012128829956,
-0.5842224955558777,
0.6060752868652344,
-0.568991482257843,
-0.06601572781801224,
-0.5290097594261169,
0.011400238610804081,
-1.083763599395752,
-0.3162583112716675,
0.036961138248443604,
-0.6596643328666687,
0.14643876254558563,
-0.14328427612781525,
-0.21368905901908875,
-0.5053714513778687,
-0.112761490046978,
0.6570199131965637,
0.16917529702186584,
-0.11736488342285156,
0.7820786833763123,
0.6883888244628906,
0.05161140486598015,
-0.5877587795257568,
-0.3904847204685211,
0.05561333894729614,
-0.21018852293491364,
-0.5878252387046814,
0.02331557869911194,
-0.26744696497917175,
-0.5053250193595886,
0.10482136160135269,
-0.4867130517959595,
-0.6928539872169495,
0.33750781416893005,
0.0432642325758934,
0.1464969515800476,
-0.6259976029396057,
0.23738491535186768,
-0.19620613753795624,
0.19636650383472443,
0.1720474660396576,
-0.005891628563404083,
0.3253355324268341,
-0.13159291446208954,
-0.17322197556495667,
-0.5372728705406189,
0.5331001281738281,
0.3369390666484833,
-0.29794397950172424,
0.7512544989585876,
0.4360729157924652,
-0.3722973167896271,
-0.16628479957580566,
-0.5004013776779175,
0.07704232633113861,
-0.36519700288772583,
0.7126193642616272,
-0.4895745813846588,
-0.7128267884254456,
0.43201786279678345,
0.11396266520023346,
0.021264346316456795,
0.5738165974617004,
0.502825915813446,
-0.558978796005249,
1.3369169235229492,
0.17641687393188477,
0.15057598054409027,
0.04924387484788895,
-0.179276704788208,
0.09662685543298721,
-0.575404167175293,
-0.48991239070892334,
-0.6357964873313904,
-0.5745677947998047,
-0.02603949047625065,
-0.2570233643054962,
0.007901599630713463,
0.19812890887260437,
-0.31538429856300354,
0.45452234148979187,
-0.2211350053548813,
0.8578349351882935,
0.31519490480422974,
0.1476612687110901,
0.2744194269180298,
-0.48199859261512756,
0.4336906373500824,
-0.21093907952308655,
-0.7922260165214539,
-0.12688599526882172,
0.8063873648643494,
0.2552022635936737,
0.4816244840621948,
0.5140243172645569,
0.049911752343177795,
0.28966885805130005,
0.23671802878379822,
-0.9201927781105042,
0.3922310173511505,
-0.3196849524974823,
-1.173245906829834,
-0.43850278854370117,
-0.25210314989089966,
-0.5799410939216614,
0.08895248919725418,
-0.7386424541473389,
-0.6558032631874084,
-0.13814695179462433,
-0.04562192037701607,
-0.6047464609146118,
0.45855143666267395,
-0.4813852906227112,
0.8318255543708801,
-0.3045300543308258,
-0.38204529881477356,
-0.0031403889879584312,
-0.4021528661251068,
0.5436614751815796,
0.20933936536312103,
0.4329706132411957,
-0.4750654399394989,
0.03928901255130768,
0.7417483925819397,
-0.0875994861125946,
0.49088558554649353,
0.12322794646024704,
0.314677357673645,
0.3893274962902069,
0.06028914079070091,
-0.35000184178352356,
0.15522216260433197,
-0.1625213325023651,
0.041539087891578674,
0.2372874617576599,
-0.5074419379234314,
-0.9121728539466858,
0.3668808341026306,
-0.5774716734886169,
-0.6792007684707642,
-0.31865158677101135,
-0.6490837335586548,
-0.7146830558776855,
0.004856640473008156,
0.00789151806384325,
0.48219260573387146,
-0.14366361498832703,
0.7039915919303894,
0.4913235902786255,
0.03980168700218201,
0.5673827528953552,
0.5193524956703186,
0.1198817566037178,
-0.18572549521923065,
0.4675310254096985,
-0.02620675414800644,
-0.2177545428276062,
0.5292088389396667,
-0.009928036481142044,
-0.6534751653671265,
-0.978168249130249,
-0.2199261635541916,
0.1785779446363449,
-0.8799359798431396,
-0.3583770990371704,
-0.19450916349887848,
-0.04348791390657425,
-0.5774794816970825,
0.17263835668563843,
-0.3647584617137909,
-0.3583223521709442,
-0.026636110618710518,
-0.2983793616294861,
0.1609388142824173,
0.8033965229988098,
0.12101221084594727,
0.2511751055717468,
-1.069833517074585,
0.5087937712669373,
0.16723519563674927,
0.6700423955917358,
-0.07478263974189758,
-0.8471699357032776,
-0.1357397586107254,
-0.04194571077823639,
-0.06363792717456818,
-0.9644257426261902,
0.13164407014846802,
0.3392038345336914,
1.0306416749954224,
0.42295342683792114,
-0.1498895138502121,
0.7362873554229736,
-0.6910383701324463,
0.9510182738304138,
0.2668347954750061,
-0.9311073422431946,
0.6342757940292358,
-0.44951412081718445,
0.19713738560676575,
0.9614272713661194,
0.5279929637908936,
-0.47496888041496277,
-0.0050722332671284676,
-0.6170331835746765,
-0.501306414604187,
0.7049849629402161,
0.12140224874019623,
0.1168316900730133,
-0.06873438507318497,
0.5803744792938232,
0.013744702562689781,
0.1567261666059494,
-0.524867594242096,
-0.06566615402698517,
-0.20316007733345032,
-0.05343443527817726,
-0.2315034717321396,
-0.0049267918802797794,
0.008364071138203144,
-0.5761529803276062,
0.6701388955116272,
-0.08125784248113632,
-0.12251696735620499,
0.19735552370548248,
-0.3086753487586975,
-0.03243476152420044,
0.04088573902845383,
0.688896119594574,
0.8582493662834167,
-0.38356542587280273,
-0.09587901085615158,
0.5270259380340576,
-0.20863750576972961,
-0.052098944783210754,
-0.16539204120635986,
-0.06761455535888672,
0.021264221519231796,
0.7658403515815735,
0.8795192837715149,
0.5295151472091675,
-0.9935119152069092,
0.5544781684875488,
-0.03868069499731064,
-0.6710838079452515,
0.04389219358563423,
-0.02157716080546379,
0.04702615365386009,
0.37985745072364807,
0.33372145891189575,
0.30795809626579285,
0.3820698857307434,
-0.8997789621353149,
0.320673406124115,
0.6479790806770325,
-0.7069412469863892,
-0.4296559691429138,
0.9936226010322571,
0.18319016695022583,
-0.2643895745277405,
0.4986313283443451,
0.03636744245886803,
-0.6181103587150574,
0.49067553877830505,
0.30523815751075745,
0.6151189208030701,
0.046150337904691696,
0.33136317133903503,
0.6135891675949097,
0.20705686509609222,
-0.11997806280851364,
0.06333725899457932,
-0.12662635743618011,
-0.8572757840156555,
-0.7223030924797058,
-0.4248633086681366,
-0.3181201219558716,
0.1924591064453125,
-0.6314852237701416,
0.019643457606434822,
-0.3777660131454468,
-0.4281352460384369,
0.4133775532245636,
-0.11731866747140884,
-0.9361916780471802,
0.4545483887195587,
0.6577519178390503,
1.0899090766906738,
-0.9432308077812195,
0.5796485543251038,
0.7988576292991638,
-0.8481268882751465,
-0.5323991775512695,
-0.31274476647377014,
-0.019745739176869392,
-0.7467867732048035,
1.1622174978256226,
0.025349030271172523,
-0.11031541973352432,
-0.28749698400497437,
-0.5958017110824585,
-0.37577885389328003,
0.9000874161720276,
0.10693672299385071,
0.11123038083314896,
-0.28317734599113464,
0.321803480386734,
0.6032745838165283,
-0.301460325717926,
0.6089476943016052,
0.9493404030799866,
0.41537806391716003,
0.24242538213729858,
-0.736332893371582,
-0.3307397663593292,
-0.2789020836353302,
-0.29140567779541016,
-0.07234679907560349,
-0.5695313215255737,
0.43775495886802673,
-0.1033940538764,
0.1055457666516304,
-0.025701262056827545,
0.8588636517524719,
-0.0015876853140071034,
0.5314960479736328,
0.34331315755844116,
0.5294581651687622,
0.5404765605926514,
-0.06444693356752396,
0.9922312498092651,
0.14007344841957092,
0.460858017206192,
1.023041009902954,
-0.3663739562034607,
0.9259844422340393,
0.35852622985839844,
-0.303985595703125,
0.1284460723400116,
0.19333532452583313,
0.008356931619346142,
0.17435403168201447,
0.05234251543879509,
-0.1938791573047638,
-0.8049818277359009,
-0.07075992226600647,
-0.07860514521598816,
1.1358767747879028,
0.15985096991062164,
-0.06859589368104935,
-0.4973624348640442,
0.052268706262111664,
-0.15561294555664062,
0.5612083077430725,
-0.5131886005401611,
0.857132077217102,
-0.303194522857666,
-0.8953560590744019,
0.11115056276321411,
-0.18329989910125732,
0.49459096789360046,
-0.6483398079872131,
-0.055778976529836655,
-0.1021944209933281,
0.19692425429821014,
0.02501559816300869,
-1.1066300868988037,
0.5609458684921265,
0.2411690503358841,
-0.21311429142951965,
-0.21437492966651917,
0.6516591310501099,
-0.329252153635025,
-0.2649533450603485,
0.23997586965560913,
0.5241085290908813,
0.19502441585063934,
-0.15493108332157135,
-1.0683584213256836,
0.04025107994675636,
-0.20890364050865173,
-0.20420897006988525,
0.2643914520740509,
0.6166041493415833,
0.238848477602005,
0.6830897927284241,
0.5290864706039429,
0.06813513487577438,
0.07870893180370331,
0.10931961983442307,
0.4171963632106781,
-0.5798951387405396,
-0.1475042998790741,
-0.9866490960121155,
0.3839110732078552,
-0.32654044032096863,
-0.5776204466819763,
0.7596481442451477,
0.7375823855400085,
0.47473758459091187,
-0.303669273853302,
0.5281997323036194,
0.0803954005241394,
0.4648130238056183,
-0.6008589863777161,
0.770582377910614,
-0.5495520234107971,
-0.018699124455451965,
-0.02594001218676567,
-0.49801385402679443,
-0.6831094622612,
0.5108739733695984,
-0.4293557107448578,
-0.24656836688518524,
0.6007715463638306,
0.05124540254473686,
-0.03768512234091759,
0.43339675664901733,
0.4181244671344757,
-0.009234042838215828,
0.1895422339439392,
0.5923795104026794,
0.7794865965843201,
-0.7010806202888489,
0.8657137751579285,
-0.17805394530296326,
-0.23624537885189056,
-0.12107530236244202,
-0.9062004089355469,
-1.2133934497833252,
-0.6213274598121643,
-0.3324108123779297,
-0.25306597352027893,
0.06143878400325775,
0.8033864498138428,
0.6425440907478333,
-0.933868408203125,
-0.25716152787208557,
0.21223267912864685,
-0.08163557946681976,
-0.5442361831665039,
-0.18954318761825562,
0.3664884567260742,
-0.5436849594116211,
-0.7071204781532288,
0.3732885420322418,
0.3943735659122467,
-0.29400303959846497,
0.258573442697525,
-0.0046174549497663975,
-0.7989537715911865,
0.2655962109565735,
0.9181557893753052,
0.7329097986221313,
-0.5739718079566956,
-0.42326924204826355,
0.4021545648574829,
0.21705007553100586,
0.012707219459116459,
0.9011672735214233,
-0.6083189249038696,
0.41637954115867615,
0.8650116324424744,
0.9418157935142517,
0.43630680441856384,
0.12660656869411469,
0.364597350358963,
-0.46904096007347107,
0.14773039519786835,
0.34914901852607727,
0.2687516212463379,
0.14142659306526184,
0.019062114879488945,
0.6286464929580688,
0.5685973763465881,
-0.27560529112815857,
-0.7529855370521545,
-0.11112506687641144,
-0.9784916043281555,
-0.6298508048057556,
1.0439726114273071,
0.1096002608537674,
-0.39482250809669495,
-0.33825284242630005,
-0.05677933245897293,
0.19191314280033112,
0.08993008732795715,
0.5764084458351135,
1.1145426034927368,
-0.35628727078437805,
-0.16052012145519257,
-0.971673846244812,
0.6763581037521362,
0.31742238998413086,
-0.7136090993881226,
0.1498204618692398,
0.2213989645242691,
0.009195601567626,
-0.19059622287750244,
0.708032488822937,
0.11224957555532455,
0.4345909059047699,
0.04064306616783142,
-0.2628048360347748,
-0.06555643677711487,
-0.33366096019744873,
0.07887597382068634,
0.2775210440158844,
-0.3209145665168762,
-0.06700501590967178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15524v1 | Rethinking Pruning Large Language Models: Benefits and Pitfalls of Reconstruction Error Minimization | 2024-06-21T05:13:34 | 2024-06-21T05:13:34 | Sungbin Shin, Wonpyo Park, Jaeho Lee, Namhoon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work suggests fundamentally rethinking the current practice of pruning
large language models (LLMs). The way it is done is by divide and conquer:
split the model into submodels, sequentially prune them, and reconstruct
predictions of the dense counterparts on small calibration data one at a time;
the final model is obtained simply by putting the resulting sparse submodels
together. While this approach enables pruning under memory constraints, it
generates high reconstruction errors. In this work, we first present an array
of reconstruction techniques that can significantly reduce this error by more
than $90\%$. Unwittingly, however, we discover that minimizing reconstruction
error is not always ideal and can overfit the given calibration data, resulting
in rather increased language perplexity and poor performance at downstream
tasks. We find out that a strategy of self-generating calibration data can
mitigate this trade-off between reconstruction and generalization, suggesting
new directions in the presence of both benefits and pitfalls of reconstruction
for pruning LLMs. | [
-0.2900705635547638,
-0.639049232006073,
0.5001764893531799,
0.028737660497426987,
-0.1607569307088852,
0.12696444988250732,
-0.31770792603492737,
-0.10928371548652649,
0.24326375126838684,
0.7519920468330383,
-0.5065330862998962,
-0.17888393998146057,
-0.4891156256198883,
-0.06860846281051636,
-0.3676677942276001,
0.7697648406028748,
0.1060875952243805,
-0.14299947023391724,
-0.2218630462884903,
-0.005516980309039354,
-0.4557187557220459,
-0.6587374806404114,
-0.5931845903396606,
-0.27096307277679443,
0.47109490633010864,
0.5558826923370361,
0.597172200679779,
0.8322024941444397,
0.22188617289066315,
0.25109630823135376,
-0.0008418288198299706,
0.276982843875885,
-0.8404832482337952,
0.17272493243217468,
0.24333065748214722,
-0.550159752368927,
-0.14640961587429047,
-0.19457224011421204,
0.8829775452613831,
0.9366792440414429,
-0.2922467291355133,
0.008314586244523525,
0.0821857750415802,
0.9402772784233093,
-0.6566551923751831,
-0.1230761855840683,
-0.5192855000495911,
-0.046817343682050705,
-0.18504181504249573,
-0.16218604147434235,
-0.42067474126815796,
-0.24409936368465424,
0.00169579335488379,
-0.5433673858642578,
0.47522807121276855,
0.057357124984264374,
0.5455688238143921,
0.37939003109931946,
-0.44743379950523376,
0.028564969077706337,
-1.1706360578536987,
1.1016260385513306,
-0.7548860907554626,
0.17701639235019684,
0.42539530992507935,
0.38404569029808044,
-0.17712543904781342,
-0.48527997732162476,
-0.152991384267807,
0.0440027192234993,
-0.0077032907865941525,
-0.11401265859603882,
-0.24378959834575653,
0.0475800447165966,
0.36359333992004395,
0.5252823233604431,
-0.4606062173843384,
0.14398819208145142,
-0.5456714034080505,
-0.5807300209999084,
0.6858506202697754,
0.14752541482448578,
0.06643006950616837,
0.11169936507940292,
-0.29697856307029724,
-0.18998415768146515,
-1.2552062273025513,
-0.2145221084356308,
0.5297492742538452,
0.21607980132102966,
0.4960484802722931,
0.47204867005348206,
-0.03992275148630142,
0.761142909526825,
-0.14870750904083252,
-0.302386999130249,
-0.015644004568457603,
-0.4762217700481415,
-0.26942628622055054,
-0.11696603149175644,
0.5116705894470215,
0.2167164534330368,
0.4282713830471039,
-0.05653202906250954,
-0.2218993753194809,
-0.06664960831403732,
0.26948803663253784,
-0.7036030292510986,
-0.3395654857158661,
0.1650024801492691,
-0.40687328577041626,
-0.1898568719625473,
-0.24446427822113037,
-0.687878429889679,
-0.30422747135162354,
-0.39612188935279846,
0.14796829223632812,
-0.37734469771385193,
-0.2961491644382477,
0.2511022984981537,
0.35622841119766235,
0.11811557412147522,
0.6643978357315063,
-0.7132455706596375,
0.29267653822898865,
0.7637912034988403,
0.54078209400177,
0.07560113817453384,
-0.19939523935317993,
-0.2921067476272583,
0.10581859201192856,
-0.4351753890514374,
0.6228541731834412,
-0.17486676573753357,
-0.5766834616661072,
-0.08450788259506226,
-0.21392770111560822,
-0.0923975333571434,
-0.7797901034355164,
0.3708277940750122,
-0.2995656728744507,
0.004128989763557911,
-0.4333833158016205,
-0.5513455271720886,
-0.2740400433540344,
0.38768088817596436,
-0.8413568735122681,
0.6023356914520264,
-0.022746585309505463,
-0.6990135908126831,
-0.003486254019662738,
0.20169925689697266,
-0.516468346118927,
-0.29177162051200867,
-0.18050938844680786,
-0.3425069749355316,
0.6113311052322388,
0.16833709180355072,
0.14385885000228882,
-0.5902202725410461,
0.2765815854072571,
-0.13141869008541107,
-0.296813040971756,
0.03698170185089111,
-0.48564642667770386,
0.582017719745636,
0.3899437189102173,
0.06004394218325615,
-0.0022065278608351946,
-0.6736125946044922,
0.04211010783910751,
0.2105807214975357,
-0.5083407163619995,
-0.33155229687690735,
0.28990039229393005,
-0.24973857402801514,
-0.17550690472126007,
0.1673278957605362,
-0.6161790490150452,
0.31522518396377563,
-0.42420488595962524,
0.4719371795654297,
0.7244394421577454,
-0.1527903527021408,
0.4940060079097748,
-0.6263903379440308,
0.7205610871315002,
-0.08051247894763947,
0.00650565093383193,
-0.33341431617736816,
-0.06000368669629097,
-0.9661495089530945,
-0.2548128068447113,
0.4852502942085266,
0.48255372047424316,
-0.6768767833709717,
0.14075133204460144,
-0.4123067259788513,
-0.42536646127700806,
-0.5308492183685303,
0.22291897237300873,
0.43033772706985474,
0.3410559594631195,
0.18202558159828186,
-0.341495543718338,
-0.789751410484314,
-1.0978184938430786,
-0.21017058193683624,
-0.1646445095539093,
0.025862636044621468,
0.18798784911632538,
0.20905818045139313,
-0.15661416947841644,
0.9762412905693054,
-0.47861790657043457,
-0.3132457137107849,
-0.355484277009964,
-0.10776255279779434,
-0.07102692872285843,
0.7568076848983765,
0.35206976532936096,
-0.6981975436210632,
-0.28170114755630493,
-0.13415604829788208,
-0.24182550609111786,
-0.0003401497669983655,
-0.17547151446342468,
0.23855425417423248,
0.15371572971343994,
0.5504229068756104,
-0.5326160192489624,
0.40054720640182495,
0.5894683003425598,
0.19912086427211761,
0.770438551902771,
-0.25383979082107544,
-0.1028919368982315,
-0.9340214729309082,
-0.13020828366279602,
-0.1309817135334015,
-0.3709615468978882,
-0.6555730104446411,
-0.12969215214252472,
-0.1894235908985138,
0.1910889744758606,
-0.15931899845600128,
0.2933310866355896,
-0.6737753748893738,
-0.12149344384670258,
-0.5187546014785767,
-0.06780107319355011,
-0.09164686501026154,
0.317592591047287,
-0.024631448090076447,
0.516721785068512,
0.38271522521972656,
-0.34175267815589905,
0.44256696105003357,
-0.0220464039593935,
-0.43919020891189575,
0.13277150690555573,
-0.4791644811630249,
0.14317044615745544,
-0.3347613513469696,
0.43223264813423157,
-1.1991957426071167,
-0.08783459663391113,
0.015037725679576397,
-0.43243712186813354,
0.5961139798164368,
-0.2819073498249054,
-0.38285037875175476,
-0.06339849531650543,
-0.32782480120658875,
0.8363955020904541,
0.6204314827919006,
-0.4457783102989197,
0.5689005255699158,
0.5265478491783142,
-0.13615071773529053,
-0.593143880367279,
-0.7842252850532532,
0.03203890845179558,
-0.3280244469642639,
-0.6275206208229065,
0.2690366804599762,
0.02362918294966221,
-0.31365102529525757,
-0.18784740567207336,
-0.2912110686302185,
0.16065865755081177,
0.06379129737615585,
0.004715337883681059,
-0.007699355948716402,
-0.07208109647035599,
0.06251490861177444,
-0.1300538033246994,
-0.19083014130592346,
-0.006159226875752211,
-0.17321175336837769,
0.593406081199646,
-0.008253605104982853,
-0.5766162872314453,
-0.08186077326536179,
0.30211183428764343,
0.45334941148757935,
-0.15435542166233063,
0.41685235500335693,
0.14089636504650116,
-0.47808563709259033,
-0.23001153767108917,
-0.9803006649017334,
-0.1354067176580429,
-0.42202866077423096,
0.40893858671188354,
-0.23868827521800995,
-0.8802215456962585,
0.46317580342292786,
-0.2567465901374817,
0.3013676404953003,
0.3533286154270172,
0.46045389771461487,
-0.049154311418533325,
0.8968743681907654,
0.7917838096618652,
-0.23668862879276276,
0.4361935555934906,
-0.34016215801239014,
0.2671876549720764,
-0.879093587398529,
0.039420388638973236,
-0.6749157905578613,
-0.2702634930610657,
-0.5242342948913574,
-0.5848312377929688,
-0.07183340936899185,
-0.07318814098834991,
-0.030658872798085213,
0.23373578488826752,
-0.22084327042102814,
0.442863404750824,
0.6113566756248474,
-0.08985581994056702,
0.2839205861091614,
0.296435683965683,
0.12659254670143127,
-0.30123329162597656,
-1.0320149660110474,
-0.5534003973007202,
1.1536259651184082,
0.4182092249393463,
1.002811074256897,
0.02332065813243389,
0.9534792900085449,
-0.2384244054555893,
0.4153672754764557,
-0.9252322912216187,
0.5239288806915283,
-0.1621856391429901,
-0.5325902104377747,
-0.3875262141227722,
-0.8281577825546265,
-0.9158225059509277,
0.5284661054611206,
0.0570385679602623,
-0.6341952085494995,
0.2728005647659302,
0.5097082853317261,
-0.5034428238868713,
0.4668545424938202,
-0.7592599987983704,
0.6349084377288818,
-0.1632159948348999,
-0.26000291109085083,
-0.32860061526298523,
-0.524640679359436,
0.5561220645904541,
-0.31218430399894714,
0.5322717428207397,
0.003430837532505393,
0.07562529295682907,
0.7266810536384583,
-0.43111279606819153,
0.9830677509307861,
-0.12123730778694153,
-0.17283453047275543,
0.3095148205757141,
0.582692563533783,
0.544029176235199,
-0.2796047329902649,
0.13112975656986237,
-0.2664576470851898,
0.3408229649066925,
-0.3699478209018707,
-0.42054638266563416,
0.771809458732605,
-0.49484971165657043,
-0.8675286769866943,
-0.28330227732658386,
-0.6664044260978699,
-0.39041584730148315,
0.08943425118923187,
0.1688215434551239,
0.44026556611061096,
-0.37565889954566956,
0.4148128926753998,
0.5787100195884705,
-0.32145583629608154,
0.19096602499485016,
0.30613264441490173,
-0.2469600886106491,
-0.5165824890136719,
1.0786406993865967,
0.3149883449077606,
0.48762863874435425,
0.17622116208076477,
0.15995725989341736,
-0.04432608187198639,
-0.8179222941398621,
-0.050393976271152496,
0.505264163017273,
-0.5953323841094971,
-0.17459449172019958,
-0.08637524396181107,
-0.079424649477005,
-0.4912395775318146,
0.15705053508281708,
-0.6575077176094055,
-0.502753496170044,
-0.28974440693855286,
-0.049444396048784256,
-0.26215672492980957,
0.542000949382782,
-0.25304853916168213,
0.36560410261154175,
-0.8419269919395447,
-0.05213744938373566,
0.06277265399694443,
-0.08101644366979599,
0.0976179912686348,
-0.4835483133792877,
-0.31272628903388977,
0.25354140996932983,
-0.1341499537229538,
-0.6852630376815796,
0.6808679699897766,
0.09568292647600174,
0.4040629267692566,
0.11208303272724152,
0.09631451219320297,
0.8380934596061707,
-0.5625354051589966,
0.4580744206905365,
0.22880752384662628,
-0.4869947135448456,
0.2013147920370102,
-0.0889301598072052,
0.39156219363212585,
0.5436881184577942,
0.10999708622694016,
-0.669411301612854,
-0.26495081186294556,
-0.6919416785240173,
-1.0471068620681763,
0.4115135967731476,
0.04509975388646126,
0.05380522832274437,
0.15570054948329926,
0.4705289304256439,
0.021891552954912186,
0.15451088547706604,
-0.5684722661972046,
-0.08417785912752151,
0.08151103556156158,
-0.21900081634521484,
-0.44132325053215027,
-0.7197430729866028,
-0.4520361125469208,
-0.07051128149032593,
0.7078731060028076,
-0.17374727129936218,
0.15342390537261963,
0.1524123251438141,
-0.36584803462028503,
-0.2260362207889557,
0.1704815775156021,
0.5968089699745178,
0.6959030628204346,
0.03852901607751846,
0.3032948970794678,
-0.02454308420419693,
-0.29421645402908325,
0.06283877789974213,
-0.04395294934511185,
-0.20217415690422058,
-0.16886666417121887,
0.4350983798503876,
0.6688019037246704,
0.10873185843229294,
-0.646419107913971,
0.3422822654247284,
-0.08392103761434555,
-0.17803369462490082,
-0.3515958786010742,
-0.24222593009471893,
0.14445286989212036,
0.13905885815620422,
0.5240478515625,
0.04160037264227867,
-0.23672878742218018,
-0.32205262780189514,
0.03486932814121246,
0.5921533703804016,
0.11679044365882874,
-0.3650248050689697,
0.2685372531414032,
0.05171598494052887,
-0.2215377688407898,
0.711139976978302,
0.2683922052383423,
-0.5472679138183594,
0.6526837944984436,
0.5527278780937195,
0.6912420392036438,
-0.2763635516166687,
-0.005175704136490822,
0.4930441379547119,
0.6271739602088928,
-0.27368658781051636,
-0.14208748936653137,
-0.07784103602170944,
-0.9301961660385132,
-0.8495510816574097,
-0.49583837389945984,
-0.38441717624664307,
0.16295664012432098,
-0.4977254569530487,
-0.10815925151109695,
-0.46236857771873474,
0.02410755679011345,
-0.271416574716568,
0.014421802945435047,
-0.3207728862762451,
0.2566700577735901,
0.0481286458671093,
0.7888339161872864,
-0.7823194265365601,
0.9967989921569824,
0.3514816164970398,
-0.05043693259358406,
-0.9148989319801331,
-0.09022538363933563,
-0.014574994333088398,
-0.7954026460647583,
0.4130656123161316,
0.08337530493736267,
-0.09478933364152908,
0.15670372545719147,
-0.4486066699028015,
-1.0114949941635132,
0.8988277912139893,
0.7211859822273254,
-0.8587207794189453,
-0.212208554148674,
0.053324922919273376,
0.3757603168487549,
-0.20525017380714417,
-0.16318877041339874,
0.7417014241218567,
0.3959634006023407,
0.3528309762477875,
-1.01157546043396,
0.09681453555822372,
0.14884807169437408,
0.12174732983112335,
0.31598562002182007,
-0.412158727645874,
0.7876020073890686,
-0.23061233758926392,
-0.5334469079971313,
0.14993569254875183,
0.4081609845161438,
0.21275585889816284,
-0.0876561850309372,
0.7580716013908386,
0.7257193326950073,
0.4842372238636017,
-0.27463218569755554,
0.9780778288841248,
-0.07014255970716476,
0.5042755603790283,
1.0654919147491455,
-0.16847167909145355,
0.521781861782074,
0.8538941740989685,
-0.3063238263130188,
-0.039329998195171356,
0.7588687539100647,
0.18532904982566833,
0.33262330293655396,
0.33734071254730225,
-0.16999287903308868,
-0.4491875469684601,
0.1182253360748291,
-0.2747214734554291,
0.3008965253829956,
0.2913123667240143,
-0.09675012528896332,
-0.4385528564453125,
-0.06899204105138779,
-0.014786540530622005,
-0.04647577926516533,
-0.15199832618236542,
0.6248742938041687,
0.15860606729984283,
-0.8376448750495911,
0.5568386912345886,
0.004983912687748671,
0.5277734398841858,
-0.41633322834968567,
0.055636871606111526,
-0.388401597738266,
0.3787209689617157,
-0.182622030377388,
-0.34694498777389526,
0.6562401652336121,
-0.40071365237236023,
-0.004745704121887684,
-0.5032845139503479,
0.8616757392883301,
-0.620993971824646,
-0.3781384825706482,
0.07369844615459442,
0.6203042268753052,
0.1515151858329773,
-0.16434748470783234,
-0.3996793031692505,
0.30516162514686584,
0.4512922465801239,
-0.475507915019989,
0.5066028833389282,
0.06868026405572891,
0.025809254497289658,
0.8531078100204468,
0.663234293460846,
0.3761311173439026,
0.11534563452005386,
-0.17412051558494568,
0.7885721325874329,
-0.6197661757469177,
-0.2142936736345291,
-0.7562238574028015,
0.42834365367889404,
0.2978138029575348,
0.07931647449731827,
0.6736223101615906,
0.5767001509666443,
1.02064049243927,
0.0420437715947628,
0.6695353984832764,
0.0836327001452446,
0.7707728147506714,
-0.39841488003730774,
0.3897523283958435,
-0.6243219971656799,
0.45216628909111023,
0.031551893800497055,
-0.7799449563026428,
-0.48612698912620544,
0.708533763885498,
-0.42538318037986755,
0.06574639678001404,
0.43425312638282776,
0.9730591773986816,
0.1468949168920517,
-0.26931434869766235,
0.5078045725822449,
0.2512224018573761,
0.43954506516456604,
0.6038475632667542,
0.8280196189880371,
-0.317071795463562,
0.6426078677177429,
-0.5174214839935303,
-0.22466278076171875,
-0.2165289670228958,
-0.7494376301765442,
-0.2431696355342865,
-0.5489128828048706,
-0.3024102747440338,
-0.3842580020427704,
-0.23975473642349243,
0.6174560189247131,
0.5665663480758667,
-0.6648687124252319,
-0.5565266609191895,
-0.06687542051076889,
0.23000067472457886,
-0.004396284930408001,
-0.12202456593513489,
0.1766948699951172,
-0.10238108038902283,
-0.7799022197723389,
0.5451626181602478,
-0.004362447187304497,
0.14870217442512512,
-0.5311205983161926,
-0.1621374785900116,
-0.08400549739599228,
0.03984471410512924,
0.42760252952575684,
0.734215497970581,
-0.6429443955421448,
-0.2451159507036209,
-0.2087436467409134,
-0.013295908458530903,
-0.011148052290081978,
1.0564601421356201,
-0.8882246613502502,
0.5884196162223816,
0.4460773468017578,
0.8532390594482422,
0.7192927002906799,
-0.01172245480120182,
0.895261287689209,
-0.6466066241264343,
0.1397418975830078,
0.34195569157600403,
0.5559796690940857,
0.5612192749977112,
0.0022996619809418917,
0.512585461139679,
0.27152323722839355,
-0.5716432332992554,
-1.2221497297286987,
0.6132858395576477,
-0.7303966879844666,
-0.38942673802375793,
1.1279104948043823,
-0.14339114725589752,
-0.33243146538734436,
0.19647923111915588,
-0.4380234479904175,
0.19594110548496246,
0.14963649213314056,
0.6144866943359375,
0.7919400930404663,
0.0031877001747488976,
-0.21895729005336761,
-0.4595378339290619,
0.3941185474395752,
0.6713740229606628,
-0.4704568386077881,
0.3219555616378784,
0.9446430206298828,
0.6232733726501465,
0.18212856352329254,
0.6291370987892151,
-0.024300221353769302,
0.19348418712615967,
-0.15998363494873047,
-0.011641466058790684,
-0.13740572333335876,
-0.30862903594970703,
-0.5052803754806519,
0.14822641015052795,
0.2582649886608124,
-0.12430349737405777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14868v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14868v2 | Direct Multi-Turn Preference Optimization for Language Agents | 2024-06-21T05:13:20 | 2024-06-25T08:44:24 | Wentao Shi, Mengqi Yuan, Junkang Wu, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) for agent tasks is critical in
developing language agents. Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) is a promising
technique for this adaptation with the alleviation of compounding errors,
offering a means to directly optimize Reinforcement Learning (RL) objectives.
However, applying DPO to multi-turn tasks presents challenges due to the
inability to cancel the partition function. Overcoming this obstacle involves
making the partition function independent of the current state and addressing
length disparities between preferred and dis-preferred trajectories. In this
light, we replace the policy constraint with the state-action occupancy measure
constraint in the RL objective and add length normalization to the
Bradley-Terry model, yielding a novel loss function named DMPO for multi-turn
agent tasks with theoretical explanations. Extensive experiments on three
multi-turn agent task datasets confirm the effectiveness and superiority of the
DMPO loss. | [
-0.2617802917957306,
-0.22385288774967194,
0.9621322751045227,
0.40666893124580383,
-0.07499680668115616,
0.12348076701164246,
-0.5188306570053101,
0.1314680278301239,
-0.01037830300629139,
0.6480266451835632,
-0.8491195440292358,
-0.2726574242115021,
-0.5114133954048157,
0.08086599409580231,
0.24026350677013397,
0.9627547264099121,
-0.40273475646972656,
-0.19567519426345825,
-0.11340949684381485,
-0.09212209284305573,
-0.3185972273349762,
-0.18282125890254974,
-0.7334200143814087,
-0.5374041199684143,
0.7993565201759338,
0.5698789358139038,
0.9262287616729736,
0.5022525191307068,
0.22412514686584473,
0.2880115211009979,
0.1086818128824234,
0.6328437924385071,
-0.6177737712860107,
0.08020174503326416,
0.017006993293762207,
-0.4313620626926422,
-0.4246807098388672,
0.0059172543697059155,
0.7534658312797546,
0.5598658919334412,
-0.36115360260009766,
-0.40347564220428467,
-0.21426235139369965,
0.9531757235527039,
-0.8321653604507446,
0.28722286224365234,
-0.4841136932373047,
0.22938090562820435,
0.40302905440330505,
-0.37317726016044617,
-0.6418180465698242,
-0.48650288581848145,
0.20066465437412262,
-0.8319485783576965,
-0.10109883546829224,
-0.15438872575759888,
0.4029776155948639,
0.5286605358123779,
-0.6555576324462891,
-0.22864218056201935,
-1.1597532033920288,
0.9447952508926392,
-0.5607296228408813,
0.3937051594257355,
0.11416446417570114,
0.13209885358810425,
-0.3550693094730377,
0.13088610768318176,
-0.809661328792572,
-0.5424082279205322,
-0.039587996900081635,
0.05992975831031799,
0.04688599333167076,
0.38053998351097107,
0.0159309022128582,
0.0206400528550148,
-0.3948589265346527,
0.26998305320739746,
0.0014339714543893933,
-0.13827575743198395,
0.7715001702308655,
0.32873567938804626,
0.044892262667417526,
0.2613775134086609,
-0.43994808197021484,
-0.48608914017677307,
-0.5236084461212158,
0.3445274829864502,
0.6452499032020569,
0.3274022042751312,
0.01934392936527729,
0.20921744406223297,
-0.29471200704574585,
0.6060001254081726,
0.12114502489566803,
-0.5545280575752258,
0.22206492722034454,
0.019712276756763458,
0.024379359558224678,
-0.15351657569408417,
0.4998953938484192,
0.3809971511363983,
0.171382337808609,
-0.1938195824623108,
-0.2200847715139389,
-0.19388428330421448,
0.14776182174682617,
-0.6040611863136292,
0.13068746030330658,
0.2097267210483551,
-0.006917845923453569,
-0.22984318435192108,
-0.11633575707674026,
-0.4309823513031006,
-0.3963664472103119,
-0.3765691816806793,
0.18555296957492828,
-0.3418623208999634,
-0.22712557017803192,
0.4552878439426422,
-0.03113052435219288,
0.18012894690036774,
0.2746904790401459,
-0.7838286757469177,
0.2999259829521179,
0.4935181736946106,
0.5465583205223083,
-0.5173782110214233,
-0.5863161683082581,
-0.4811459481716156,
0.2580842971801758,
-0.4166300296783447,
0.44772854447364807,
-0.6022798418998718,
-0.6514941453933716,
0.0451253317296505,
-0.014967716298997402,
-0.2880849838256836,
-0.44103720784187317,
0.4237821102142334,
-0.44079160690307617,
-0.11228331923484802,
-0.17320522665977478,
-0.08828435838222504,
-0.22070102393627167,
0.300619900226593,
-0.38989531993865967,
0.7385054230690002,
0.03269847109913826,
-0.08495985716581345,
0.3592800199985504,
-0.6216099262237549,
-0.44857919216156006,
-0.4047543704509735,
0.03155770152807236,
-0.6293727159500122,
0.29754289984703064,
0.06718184798955917,
0.18189090490341187,
-0.012247803620994091,
0.24237173795700073,
-0.4008231461048126,
-0.08582913875579834,
0.40647685527801514,
-0.24151980876922607,
0.4546360671520233,
0.039238378405570984,
-0.02071959897875786,
0.3521462082862854,
-0.6776267886161804,
-0.06549999862909317,
0.25913795828819275,
-0.7079994082450867,
-0.3891093134880066,
0.5131946206092834,
-0.42511487007141113,
0.08626812696456909,
0.2061045616865158,
-0.5520126223564148,
0.6433969140052795,
-0.4081955850124359,
0.2187052071094513,
0.8878820538520813,
-0.10427284240722656,
0.807148277759552,
-0.2127973586320877,
0.6288899183273315,
0.0042910207994282246,
0.6781929731369019,
0.36387431621551514,
-0.008655400946736336,
-0.7374554872512817,
-0.5440956354141235,
-0.25788384675979614,
0.4267764389514923,
-0.7692370414733887,
0.27824848890304565,
-0.14814214408397675,
-0.32195818424224854,
-0.27069324254989624,
-0.04583294689655304,
0.29825544357299805,
0.2044801414012909,
0.21681705117225647,
0.01622959040105343,
-0.138432115316391,
-1.0498446226119995,
0.10367831587791443,
-0.16748128831386566,
0.27819886803627014,
0.34026649594306946,
0.16420744359493256,
-0.4244597256183624,
0.8482246398925781,
-0.9746119976043701,
-0.18012331426143646,
-0.4260334372520447,
-0.24242058396339417,
0.15670421719551086,
0.20035313069820404,
0.5705751180648804,
-0.6986145377159119,
-0.6873699426651001,
-0.1534496247768402,
-0.07906004041433334,
-0.06895706057548523,
-0.1984052062034607,
-0.10431728512048721,
0.23954562842845917,
0.024076156318187714,
-0.5513736009597778,
0.34095287322998047,
0.6662086248397827,
-0.13501036167144775,
0.5016084909439087,
-0.5627578496932983,
0.15300370752811432,
-0.4509262442588806,
-0.4094639718532562,
-0.234689399600029,
-0.05301831662654877,
-0.7496305704116821,
-0.0952521488070488,
0.07717574387788773,
-0.21829691529273987,
-0.46877503395080566,
0.5422275066375732,
-0.4096705913543701,
-0.08384108543395996,
-0.5051499009132385,
0.11609652638435364,
0.22871406376361847,
0.8435826301574707,
0.19091206789016724,
0.6309973001480103,
0.4110261797904968,
-0.9945741891860962,
0.15839160978794098,
0.28456607460975647,
0.39212095737457275,
0.23020847141742706,
-0.2566494941711426,
0.33121243119239807,
-0.29720303416252136,
0.18177956342697144,
-0.8526706695556641,
0.2123846560716629,
0.3027922809123993,
-0.24986691772937775,
0.39210382103919983,
0.10815637558698654,
-0.08811075240373611,
-0.18474990129470825,
-0.6956053376197815,
0.4729166030883789,
0.1897592395544052,
-0.37938445806503296,
0.48511645197868347,
0.19960631430149078,
0.21506738662719727,
-0.6428729295730591,
-0.25448617339134216,
-0.3252928555011749,
-0.14433448016643524,
-0.36524608731269836,
0.5495111346244812,
-0.18878662586212158,
-0.1435071974992752,
-0.2272747904062271,
-0.18270038068294525,
0.0316399447619915,
-0.010078507475554943,
0.07101117074489594,
0.1781582236289978,
0.26866814494132996,
0.24030837416648865,
0.15682822465896606,
-0.1693122535943985,
-0.14440110325813293,
0.0038272817619144917,
0.6776238679885864,
0.18218354880809784,
-0.33903196454048157,
-0.19946548342704773,
0.43144282698631287,
0.5257638096809387,
-0.2751009464263916,
0.5616582036018372,
0.2799989879131317,
0.25133413076400757,
-0.659868597984314,
-0.29037681221961975,
-0.23727920651435852,
-0.44553011655807495,
0.6658650636672974,
-0.47810879349708557,
-0.5787647366523743,
0.29683026671409607,
0.06287296861410141,
-0.04643958806991577,
0.2891809940338135,
0.44551947712898254,
0.3531462848186493,
1.0949300527572632,
0.827969491481781,
-0.19306577742099762,
0.5183347463607788,
-0.1722109168767929,
0.40934595465660095,
-0.7601262927055359,
-0.17601746320724487,
-0.535804271697998,
-0.3256319463253021,
-0.7245749235153198,
-0.513745903968811,
0.5392199158668518,
-0.2867194414138794,
-0.18681839108467102,
0.22000283002853394,
-0.6127350926399231,
0.22907207906246185,
0.6665717959403992,
0.28030386567115784,
0.2764652371406555,
-0.26020169258117676,
0.11957108229398727,
0.03633391484618187,
-0.6731541156768799,
-0.19181041419506073,
1.0092830657958984,
0.17092245817184448,
0.8112884163856506,
0.1664358228445053,
1.0307618379592896,
0.26370537281036377,
-0.04478127509355545,
-1.1506383419036865,
0.626437246799469,
0.05239531770348549,
-0.39503416419029236,
-0.7941179871559143,
-0.34609922766685486,
-1.0214793682098389,
0.22605659067630768,
-0.06766854226589203,
-0.4110583961009979,
0.25105610489845276,
0.2652013301849365,
-0.29097139835357666,
0.1695340871810913,
-0.47357308864593506,
0.6441622376441956,
-0.4394017457962036,
-0.16724884510040283,
-0.44687578082084656,
-0.21782203018665314,
0.17701245844364166,
0.21502690017223358,
0.13265208899974823,
-0.5110260844230652,
-0.41050776839256287,
0.4868920147418976,
-0.41203412413597107,
0.48429441452026367,
-0.40581005811691284,
-0.09925492852926254,
0.31081128120422363,
0.19339850544929504,
0.7046921253204346,
0.009234345518052578,
-0.07546158134937286,
-0.26837092638015747,
-0.021556509658694267,
-0.2666403651237488,
-0.6350486874580383,
0.6167358756065369,
-1.0532541275024414,
-0.6722859144210815,
-0.45395132899284363,
-0.670674741268158,
-0.5192293524742126,
-0.07486400753259659,
-0.22303231060504913,
0.20358110964298248,
-0.1751021444797516,
-0.24625656008720398,
0.47355711460113525,
-0.43577420711517334,
0.7477376461029053,
0.9358950257301331,
-0.09780661016702652,
-0.29372933506965637,
0.9459123015403748,
-0.2275140881538391,
0.4858260154724121,
0.5558911561965942,
0.6415915489196777,
-0.33863458037376404,
-0.7346420884132385,
-0.3391670882701874,
0.3983587324619293,
-0.3936103880405426,
0.03322877734899521,
-0.21216310560703278,
0.09009893238544464,
-0.3039923906326294,
-0.251288503408432,
-0.5205457210540771,
-0.2063918113708496,
-0.10952446609735489,
-0.0252241063863039,
0.1707146316766739,
0.4432901442050934,
-0.110284723341465,
0.150197371840477,
-0.579685389995575,
0.17678247392177582,
0.33162131905555725,
0.26605167984962463,
-0.1321626901626587,
-0.4860369563102722,
-0.17965006828308105,
-0.10469590127468109,
-0.5337704420089722,
-0.9743858575820923,
0.3202897906303406,
0.2973107695579529,
0.6754732131958008,
0.4562608003616333,
0.42636775970458984,
0.35637006163597107,
-0.6004206538200378,
0.22816386818885803,
0.3000294864177704,
-0.6204742789268494,
0.4539201557636261,
-0.3285817503929138,
0.3851751685142517,
0.4740200638771057,
0.5164735913276672,
-0.5647672414779663,
-0.010721134021878242,
-0.16007204353809357,
-0.7142754197120667,
0.8226651549339294,
-0.005811210256069899,
0.16678425669670105,
-0.023052694275975227,
0.3283993601799011,
0.21803191304206848,
0.2826409339904785,
-0.8405598402023315,
-0.392013818025589,
0.13588349521160126,
0.04057321324944496,
-0.2708057463169098,
-0.4370057284832001,
-0.18717272579669952,
-0.002486721146851778,
0.8899718523025513,
-0.3345552980899811,
0.2640106976032257,
0.24925240874290466,
-0.0036850739270448685,
0.030809123069047928,
0.4359127879142761,
1.0065447092056274,
0.6609888076782227,
-0.2424364537000656,
-0.16772671043872833,
0.05229722708463669,
-0.3046773672103882,
0.588878333568573,
0.04083520546555519,
-0.26679643988609314,
-0.259968638420105,
0.11291617900133133,
0.8941943049430847,
-0.03124685026705265,
-0.5654585361480713,
0.3682798445224762,
0.2435947060585022,
-0.2530067563056946,
-0.2575881779193878,
0.06566300243139267,
-0.24926067888736725,
0.23246793448925018,
0.3695070147514343,
-0.13573643565177917,
0.29033687710762024,
-0.6394448280334473,
-0.10632085800170898,
0.42624539136886597,
-0.5821419358253479,
-0.25587713718414307,
0.02466745860874653,
0.397815078496933,
-0.4004950225353241,
0.17228485643863678,
-0.40269196033477783,
-0.6070681214332581,
0.6191946864128113,
0.21768790483474731,
1.099416732788086,
-0.3315061032772064,
0.631341814994812,
0.21115262806415558,
0.33142051100730896,
-0.10322890430688858,
-0.029947549104690552,
-0.00014216206909622997,
-1.076038122177124,
-0.47538110613822937,
-0.4957355856895447,
-0.5437323451042175,
-0.10653632879257202,
-0.5018572807312012,
0.19326262176036835,
-0.47216469049453735,
-0.17525790631771088,
-0.28428876399993896,
-0.05485919117927551,
-0.5937068462371826,
0.09913825243711472,
0.28435686230659485,
0.2424885481595993,
-0.6785237789154053,
0.7703285217285156,
0.49858909845352173,
-0.17975088953971863,
-0.7137344479560852,
-0.046847738325595856,
-0.04259900003671646,
-1.0191619396209717,
0.5602686405181885,
-0.2681746482849121,
-0.37264108657836914,
-0.2524898052215576,
-0.05153364688158035,
-0.7955448627471924,
0.7582343816757202,
0.43867531418800354,
-0.7008041143417358,
-0.14473344385623932,
0.43661898374557495,
0.31152021884918213,
-0.47706499695777893,
0.20238439738750458,
0.6107247471809387,
0.6147375702857971,
-0.006038487423211336,
-0.9577342867851257,
0.10510221868753433,
0.6933555603027344,
0.15290945768356323,
0.5872050523757935,
-1.0422600507736206,
0.7015236616134644,
-0.42799174785614014,
0.23994098603725433,
-0.3712438642978668,
0.2356409728527069,
0.1853870153427124,
0.4003237187862396,
0.8905624151229858,
0.39821162819862366,
0.29663994908332825,
-0.07954143732786179,
0.9303664565086365,
-0.033276937901973724,
0.44895628094673157,
0.9597654342651367,
-0.5584762096405029,
0.6399634480476379,
0.6882621645927429,
-0.508632242679596,
0.25669145584106445,
0.4697432518005371,
0.45730605721473694,
0.8781912922859192,
0.5405436754226685,
-0.3414756655693054,
-0.33885568380355835,
0.03328825905919075,
0.08201781660318375,
0.6855232119560242,
-0.0755581334233284,
-0.0037285711150616407,
-0.09566491097211838,
0.16518567502498627,
0.21588917076587677,
0.4524194002151489,
-0.3491687476634979,
0.8297963738441467,
-0.211500346660614,
-0.9370459914207458,
0.4656924903392792,
0.0025985511019825935,
0.3978416919708252,
-0.694708526134491,
0.1261972188949585,
-0.3537706136703491,
0.5387449860572815,
-0.010873718187212944,
-0.3496306836605072,
0.269787460565567,
-0.6168641448020935,
-0.27992483973503113,
-0.268037348985672,
0.37667492032051086,
-0.4857669174671173,
-0.36216840147972107,
0.6062420606613159,
0.2561383545398712,
-0.24916619062423706,
-0.1976127028465271,
-0.7631626725196838,
0.2026677280664444,
0.25798383355140686,
-0.3898726999759674,
0.36952438950538635,
0.27859243750572205,
0.17297615110874176,
0.8851795196533203,
0.21666200459003448,
0.21125270426273346,
-0.1135064885020256,
-0.06593795120716095,
0.8490636944770813,
-0.5361866354942322,
-0.3801923096179962,
-0.7864033579826355,
0.3732280731201172,
0.053813423961400986,
-0.2345684915781021,
0.5278967618942261,
0.4865573048591614,
0.8096839785575867,
-0.34892046451568604,
0.7072907090187073,
0.07785486429929733,
0.36515146493911743,
-0.5236874222755432,
0.19613194465637207,
-0.7304515838623047,
0.03656354546546936,
-0.06571458280086517,
-1.1525096893310547,
0.21014072000980377,
0.20210756361484528,
-0.5279299020767212,
-0.023814981803297997,
0.8155606985092163,
0.8894806504249573,
0.22088055312633514,
-0.6946691274642944,
0.6496336460113525,
-0.1763944923877716,
0.39735716581344604,
0.8564738035202026,
0.6932145953178406,
-0.06933988630771637,
0.7545005679130554,
-0.3856658935546875,
-0.34103262424468994,
-0.3286171555519104,
-0.7625424265861511,
-0.8277835845947266,
-0.6081542372703552,
-0.5451266765594482,
-0.046502817422151566,
0.13998501002788544,
0.9604378938674927,
0.7102721333503723,
-0.6238865852355957,
-0.44507038593292236,
0.23560002446174622,
0.3808295428752899,
-0.32107168436050415,
-0.19971343874931335,
0.14298027753829956,
-0.43846595287323,
-1.0101243257522583,
0.5548163652420044,
0.5383184552192688,
-0.11968003213405609,
-0.32275184988975525,
-0.6403233408927917,
-0.27898481488227844,
0.18578439950942993,
0.6286675333976746,
0.3833068311214447,
-0.8097505569458008,
-0.5178534388542175,
-0.002003674628213048,
0.02250254899263382,
0.07927006483078003,
1.0758287906646729,
-0.24656353890895844,
0.5248202681541443,
0.3153288960456848,
0.6403546333312988,
0.7314289808273315,
-0.2070010006427765,
0.71345055103302,
-0.6250444054603577,
0.4399014413356781,
0.319193571805954,
0.03676147386431694,
0.08757025748491287,
-0.34619343280792236,
0.39237236976623535,
0.08373476564884186,
-0.601744532585144,
-0.6888734698295593,
0.463736891746521,
-1.0934008359909058,
-0.19823691248893738,
1.3121042251586914,
-0.044704776257276535,
-0.13922768831253052,
0.32242709398269653,
-0.38201215863227844,
0.11680377274751663,
-0.786790668964386,
0.672482430934906,
0.432511568069458,
-0.4297560751438141,
-0.13664589822292328,
-0.22819605469703674,
0.7702193260192871,
0.39731061458587646,
-0.5376924872398376,
-0.07072945684194565,
0.5034545660018921,
0.10562806576490402,
0.06261828541755676,
0.7320179343223572,
0.46081531047821045,
0.002167216269299388,
-0.23171792924404144,
0.43446794152259827,
-0.29259437322616577,
-0.4887865483760834,
-0.13373535871505737,
-0.08365374803543091,
0.556681752204895,
-0.6087186336517334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14867v1 | DistiLRR: Transferring Code Repair for Low-Resource Programming Languages | 2024-06-21T05:05:39 | 2024-06-21T05:05:39 | Kyle Wong, Alfonso Amayuelas, Liangming Pan, William Yang Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance on code
generation tasks. A recent application of LLMs for code generation is iterative
code repair, where a model fixes an incorrect program by rationalizing about
errors and generating a new program. However, code repair is primarily studied
on high-resource languages like Python, and the framework's efficacy is
under-explored on low-resource languages. To apply code repair for low-resource
languages, we propose Distilling Low-Resource Repairs (DistiLRR), an approach
that transfers the reasoning and code generation ability from a teacher model
to a student model. Our results show that DistiLRR consistently outperforms
baselines on low-resource languages, but has similar performance on
high-resource languages. To investigate this behavior, we perform a further
analysis and find that the correlation between rationale quality and code
correctness is weaker than previously perceived. We hypothesize this weakness
is magnified in low-resource settings where base models lack deep knowledge of
a programming language, leading to wavering benefits of code repair between
high-resource and low-resource languages. | [
-0.04265621304512024,
-0.4990505874156952,
0.37388578057289124,
0.12176525592803955,
-0.01122735533863306,
0.4328175485134125,
-0.42784836888313293,
-0.1812731921672821,
-0.1830940991640091,
0.45667558908462524,
-0.26230576634407043,
0.12105898559093475,
-0.5365853309631348,
0.15426500141620636,
-0.32079601287841797,
1.1498318910598755,
-0.055560674518346786,
-0.009044846519827843,
-0.4046063721179962,
-0.01549501158297062,
-0.5677170157432556,
-0.5528896450996399,
-0.7429750561714172,
-0.3950682580471039,
0.3605387806892395,
0.7328612804412842,
0.4917067289352417,
0.6612381935119629,
0.5722350478172302,
0.44568949937820435,
-0.12232393026351929,
-0.1323964148759842,
-0.8679958581924438,
-0.036886051297187805,
-0.5185790061950684,
-0.644507110118866,
-0.37863877415657043,
-0.3010571002960205,
0.21977409720420837,
0.7540571093559265,
-0.18695543706417084,
0.2568686008453369,
0.3738989531993866,
1.145686388015747,
-0.7437282204627991,
0.07540661841630936,
-0.7402617335319519,
-0.2121012657880783,
0.010680139996111393,
-0.1397206336259842,
-0.4926474690437317,
-0.4459892213344574,
-0.12016269564628601,
-0.3050823211669922,
0.3554133176803589,
-0.06850848346948624,
0.4065113663673401,
0.7113712430000305,
-0.24239878356456757,
-0.286844938993454,
-0.960025429725647,
1.021592140197754,
-0.9034395217895508,
-0.21833692491054535,
0.2721618413925171,
0.24039575457572937,
-0.15433436632156372,
-0.7548355460166931,
-0.6280286312103271,
-0.16372892260551453,
-0.14270463585853577,
-0.25321128964424133,
-0.30032116174697876,
-0.019589168950915337,
0.7461070418357849,
0.7367150783538818,
-0.21685053408145905,
-0.10911809653043747,
-0.7281075716018677,
-0.1649286150932312,
0.5606927275657654,
0.18140046298503876,
0.37151288986206055,
-0.042901165783405304,
-0.31631800532341003,
-0.005726270843297243,
-0.6592607498168945,
0.05744783580303192,
0.14427852630615234,
0.1352238953113556,
0.08626510202884674,
0.47227907180786133,
0.03441735357046127,
0.8355252146720886,
-0.02167445980012417,
-0.6628186106681824,
-0.14343968033790588,
-0.46680381894111633,
-0.22464463114738464,
0.2338559776544571,
0.4540085792541504,
0.3098260760307312,
0.2759568393230438,
0.04162881523370743,
-0.3730207681655884,
0.18350602686405182,
0.0855468362569809,
-0.9771528840065002,
-0.6042138934135437,
-0.023964283987879753,
-0.5441768765449524,
-0.36109820008277893,
-0.2404755800962448,
-0.4726034998893738,
-0.4991491138935089,
-0.4906138479709625,
0.0627623051404953,
-0.47086814045906067,
-0.6478132605552673,
0.2036152482032776,
-0.24031759798526764,
-0.18485049903392792,
0.15267741680145264,
-0.7500457167625427,
-0.014452764764428139,
0.4634188413619995,
0.692510187625885,
0.16968287527561188,
-0.39905592799186707,
-0.393176406621933,
-0.015562036074697971,
-0.26989907026290894,
0.6133519411087036,
-0.39306017756462097,
-0.373899906873703,
-0.22063054144382477,
-0.044148869812488556,
-0.08349663019180298,
-0.7741352915763855,
0.32692041993141174,
-0.28105562925338745,
-0.13609646260738373,
-0.5729595422744751,
-0.4477187693119049,
0.12019060552120209,
0.020461175590753555,
-0.6874778866767883,
0.9170921444892883,
0.5608748197555542,
-0.8281530737876892,
0.18480460345745087,
-0.3399813175201416,
-0.4033617377281189,
-0.11766118556261063,
0.21449624001979828,
-0.37787291407585144,
0.32668259739875793,
-0.07801484316587448,
0.12936758995056152,
-0.3904440402984619,
0.29852521419525146,
-0.2832872271537781,
-0.5413958430290222,
0.4867880940437317,
-0.6023120284080505,
0.8771334886550903,
0.506950855255127,
-0.15783238410949707,
-0.23667016625404358,
-0.859093427658081,
0.12378441542387009,
0.050443366169929504,
-0.6567554473876953,
-0.49703359603881836,
0.04666449502110481,
-0.09584062546491623,
0.31604528427124023,
0.39034825563430786,
-0.42029497027397156,
0.584317684173584,
-0.32689180970191956,
0.8426675200462341,
0.6536003351211548,
-0.1685526818037033,
0.7933445572853088,
-0.37074655294418335,
0.5824412703514099,
0.07933037728071213,
-0.12655305862426758,
-0.201937735080719,
0.02242611162364483,
-1.0476884841918945,
-0.396621972322464,
0.09399867802858353,
0.3849056363105774,
-1.135151743888855,
-0.24602149426937103,
-0.1572311818599701,
-0.27207261323928833,
-0.5910560488700867,
0.45528027415275574,
0.7312665581703186,
0.740065336227417,
0.43743959069252014,
0.030538028106093407,
-0.7750750184059143,
-0.6948498487472534,
-0.21413740515708923,
-0.5701541304588318,
0.21149316430091858,
-0.04048074781894684,
0.26470479369163513,
-0.27799510955810547,
0.8007335662841797,
-0.6735161542892456,
-0.02388916164636612,
-0.5964919924736023,
-0.20080479979515076,
0.2617720365524292,
0.5128296613693237,
0.7042223215103149,
-0.3990994989871979,
-0.6181434988975525,
-0.23166979849338531,
-0.3737682104110718,
-0.2612806558609009,
0.009199230000376701,
-0.09997550398111343,
0.6166898012161255,
0.5418565273284912,
-0.1676880419254303,
0.19948965311050415,
0.6849252581596375,
-0.29784873127937317,
0.43917250633239746,
-0.45734527707099915,
0.31154096126556396,
-1.2132997512817383,
0.17608734965324402,
-0.1822323203086853,
-0.08891809731721878,
-0.462497740983963,
-0.028365403413772583,
-0.06969605386257172,
-0.19757255911827087,
-0.22063244879245758,
0.2909335196018219,
-0.5380064845085144,
-0.028337668627500534,
-0.7047476172447205,
-0.31653642654418945,
0.17551559209823608,
0.19662360846996307,
-0.12564413249492645,
0.9652405977249146,
0.4663678705692291,
-0.4378264546394348,
0.4272387623786926,
-0.1739499717950821,
-0.1913001984357834,
0.5960559248924255,
-0.7524542808532715,
0.22032727301120758,
0.05973419174551964,
-0.09654469043016434,
-0.9196230173110962,
-0.2122562974691391,
-0.1400095671415329,
-0.151884526014328,
0.3443841338157654,
-0.6790629625320435,
-0.3127502202987671,
-0.44851088523864746,
0.04218704625964165,
0.532635509967804,
0.6702483892440796,
-0.7875199317932129,
0.28222787380218506,
0.11197199672460556,
-0.30206987261772156,
-0.6929458379745483,
-0.5968435406684875,
-0.036415841430425644,
-0.1822005808353424,
-0.6956409811973572,
0.17002500593662262,
-0.10117355734109879,
-0.6330611109733582,
0.08501752465963364,
-0.22601628303527832,
-0.5062829256057739,
0.32943034172058105,
0.06693588197231293,
0.41833195090293884,
-0.34083425998687744,
-0.0047869556583464146,
-0.03505407273769379,
-0.25279852747917175,
0.009591338224709034,
-0.20697379112243652,
0.43132591247558594,
-0.3465143144130707,
-0.4660663306713104,
0.10497086495161057,
0.032207075506448746,
0.6929237842559814,
-0.3559550642967224,
0.6131030917167664,
0.1270928829908371,
-0.13811346888542175,
-0.4423616826534271,
-0.5348731279373169,
-0.1471562534570694,
-0.5035393238067627,
0.4063471853733063,
-0.2623061537742615,
-0.6832787394523621,
0.2535015940666199,
-0.23288412392139435,
-0.07402745634317398,
0.27874380350112915,
0.480689138174057,
-0.10742247849702835,
0.800656795501709,
1.0025948286056519,
-0.5561596155166626,
0.3821242153644562,
-0.33253440260887146,
0.44615694880485535,
-0.3012737035751343,
-0.0770990327000618,
-0.7702751159667969,
-0.3549790680408478,
-0.3005078434944153,
-0.28770074248313904,
-0.07242324948310852,
0.7701842784881592,
-0.2833956182003021,
0.5691580176353455,
-0.7902421951293945,
0.9604166746139526,
0.6235749125480652,
-0.09026244282722473,
0.6573007106781006,
0.1034802496433258,
0.2840162217617035,
0.019584408029913902,
-0.8661647439002991,
-0.7107238173484802,
0.6203656196594238,
0.13176225125789642,
0.9861567616462708,
0.18112309277057648,
0.9549373984336853,
0.05398927628993988,
0.3167288899421692,
-0.6773608326911926,
0.3463645279407501,
-0.30625829100608826,
-0.33413460850715637,
-0.27635252475738525,
-0.6205168962478638,
-0.5481730699539185,
0.004775118548423052,
0.1562117338180542,
-0.24682876467704773,
0.07325025647878647,
0.5346922278404236,
-0.2820427119731903,
0.5064454078674316,
-0.9041783213615417,
0.8274938464164734,
-0.24448804557323456,
-0.45262545347213745,
-0.41191235184669495,
-0.2363385558128357,
0.45796918869018555,
-0.16689355671405792,
0.21187175810337067,
0.03086167760193348,
0.4412238597869873,
0.2885029911994934,
-0.8901791572570801,
0.6927493214607239,
-0.35072076320648193,
-0.3465178310871124,
0.42531508207321167,
0.47818076610565186,
0.30041253566741943,
0.21869339048862457,
-0.23016373813152313,
0.01962311938405037,
0.22627632319927216,
-0.45086073875427246,
-0.5308538675308228,
0.8174452781677246,
-0.582084596157074,
-0.5845978856086731,
-0.42130208015441895,
-0.5701145529747009,
0.16106882691383362,
0.07873164862394333,
0.2505805194377899,
0.2815457880496979,
0.15355584025382996,
-0.009956552647054195,
0.7240340709686279,
-0.24865727126598358,
0.728207528591156,
0.6241815090179443,
-0.0013632344780489802,
-0.1297827810049057,
1.1081783771514893,
-0.03424230217933655,
0.42177829146385193,
-0.06218589097261429,
0.0639256089925766,
0.14341486990451813,
-0.35288023948669434,
-0.5962380766868591,
-0.055316243320703506,
-0.5546415448188782,
-0.4303441643714905,
-0.11538370698690414,
-0.16012167930603027,
0.05110354349017143,
-0.5693070888519287,
-0.5770642161369324,
-0.5969513654708862,
-0.25055447220802307,
0.08119455724954605,
0.526170551776886,
0.514470100402832,
-0.06756096333265305,
0.02388700656592846,
-0.9474495053291321,
0.21640266478061676,
0.08091965317726135,
0.2616093158721924,
0.04349197819828987,
-0.6195751428604126,
-0.4592304229736328,
0.296002060174942,
-0.2752726376056671,
-0.4598340690135956,
0.2713034451007843,
0.24185335636138916,
0.4044502079486847,
0.18265998363494873,
0.4227617383003235,
0.8699026107788086,
-0.5164728760719299,
0.663169801235199,
0.44223883748054504,
-1.0052322149276733,
0.7382012605667114,
0.15200473368167877,
0.13268022239208221,
0.6954377889633179,
-0.027999933809041977,
-0.38879236578941345,
-0.4857960641384125,
-0.3422216475009918,
-0.6596617698669434,
0.7679515480995178,
-0.05542221665382385,
0.08231902867555618,
-0.10146812349557877,
0.4301505982875824,
-0.025662468746304512,
-0.08143300563097,
-0.6266099810600281,
-0.09832507371902466,
-0.5724305510520935,
-0.19634808599948883,
-0.11291361600160599,
-0.35345229506492615,
-0.05182303860783577,
-0.15362229943275452,
0.6130183339118958,
-0.24888648092746735,
-0.03117445856332779,
0.06129653379321098,
-0.41622138023376465,
-0.15914809703826904,
0.5565561056137085,
0.398831844329834,
0.7194364070892334,
0.03319472819566727,
0.3040284216403961,
0.11009355634450912,
-0.3109064996242523,
0.5571755766868591,
0.0008561533759348094,
0.036761924624443054,
-0.21477074921131134,
0.5350950956344604,
0.4749802052974701,
0.010297931730747223,
-0.6884445548057556,
0.5966057181358337,
0.07962504774332047,
0.11768724769353867,
-0.15655140578746796,
0.37300905585289,
0.1996307671070099,
0.3770110011100769,
0.14325572550296783,
0.3745504915714264,
0.03888354450464249,
-0.6008039116859436,
0.014630007557570934,
0.09242149442434311,
-0.1712149828672409,
-0.3873841464519501,
0.5781336426734924,
0.26880303025245667,
-0.05260174348950386,
1.0091220140457153,
-0.02962290495634079,
-0.4484288990497589,
0.8391707539558411,
0.6781934499740601,
0.6621536612510681,
-0.0994604155421257,
0.09919257462024689,
0.6288866996765137,
0.16622638702392578,
-0.5286253690719604,
0.3080836236476898,
0.14023713767528534,
-0.5428685545921326,
-0.799376368522644,
-0.6150887608528137,
-0.17750060558319092,
-0.1187671571969986,
-0.666657030582428,
0.09127230942249298,
-0.4270632863044739,
-0.14715704321861267,
-0.2792673110961914,
-0.10915786772966385,
-0.3935786187648773,
-0.15324315428733826,
-0.05860214680433273,
0.8168200254440308,
-0.7705271244049072,
1.0803130865097046,
0.6608534455299377,
-0.829627275466919,
-1.0418174266815186,
-0.05636649206280708,
-0.15274643898010254,
-0.44009095430374146,
1.1673005819320679,
-0.11559341847896576,
-0.17326919734477997,
-0.04608540236949921,
-0.5627987384796143,
-0.770073413848877,
1.0482878684997559,
0.990375280380249,
-0.9012835025787354,
-0.007233460433781147,
0.27510926127433777,
0.6643555164337158,
0.05536465346813202,
0.09001549333333969,
0.47226500511169434,
0.06187878176569939,
0.03955767676234245,
-1.1453638076782227,
0.10337589681148529,
-0.1636125147342682,
0.4142390787601471,
0.11930607259273529,
-0.6422877311706543,
0.9756069779396057,
-0.7267643809318542,
-0.14749383926391602,
0.25776705145835876,
0.338443398475647,
0.4602201282978058,
0.15014009177684784,
0.433491051197052,
0.6482722759246826,
0.7885521054267883,
-0.1828181892633438,
1.0049837827682495,
-0.7041479349136353,
0.4291667640209198,
1.032080054283142,
-0.4179226756095886,
0.593658983707428,
0.6772078275680542,
-0.2719191610813141,
0.6054183840751648,
0.10622997581958771,
0.07529667019844055,
0.6211237907409668,
0.48692044615745544,
-0.3287680745124817,
-0.21942132711410522,
0.029058028012514114,
-0.3797520697116852,
0.1858949512243271,
-0.14794765412807465,
-0.2796460688114166,
-0.1714952290058136,
0.04951784387230873,
-0.017571546137332916,
0.27860763669013977,
-0.44812342524528503,
0.7743330001831055,
0.257906436920166,
-0.6972016096115112,
1.0244139432907104,
0.097171850502491,
0.5486757159233093,
-0.1613648384809494,
-0.2742457389831543,
-0.6880658864974976,
0.8165596127510071,
-0.4472968280315399,
-0.5694490075111389,
0.6422688364982605,
0.28696271777153015,
-0.8409433364868164,
-0.2902679741382599,
1.0280853509902954,
-0.3808008134365082,
-0.4762568771839142,
0.263918399810791,
0.3871685564517975,
-0.07665810734033585,
0.11945609748363495,
-0.4659096300601959,
0.060723163187503815,
0.23515285551548004,
-0.03739918768405914,
0.5121073126792908,
0.7245627045631409,
0.11375671625137329,
0.7025975584983826,
0.6141719222068787,
0.13979904353618622,
-0.03319115936756134,
0.10393065959215164,
1.0889960527420044,
-0.4236447811126709,
0.030477305874228477,
-1.1233333349227905,
0.6244692802429199,
-0.06224367395043373,
-0.009119435213506222,
0.6845028400421143,
0.6890062689781189,
1.1718815565109253,
-0.28208449482917786,
0.9546115398406982,
-0.15379217267036438,
0.39527803659439087,
-0.5239973068237305,
0.7451539039611816,
-0.31615135073661804,
0.7177431583404541,
-0.40690726041793823,
-1.063458800315857,
0.2054426223039627,
0.8326238989830017,
-0.07338415086269379,
-0.31998127698898315,
0.6027952432632446,
0.9229491353034973,
-0.11270461976528168,
-0.397100567817688,
0.2461082488298416,
0.2492949366569519,
0.30349093675613403,
0.7310865521430969,
1.1119967699050903,
-0.1578933447599411,
0.8339399695396423,
-0.471586138010025,
-0.4281828701496124,
0.012515807524323463,
-0.887225866317749,
-0.8708899617195129,
-0.3558536469936371,
-0.48298123478889465,
-0.7297165393829346,
-0.12830281257629395,
0.8985083103179932,
0.3373621702194214,
-0.6080801486968994,
-0.2992447018623352,
-0.2563140392303467,
0.0818617045879364,
-0.3165562152862549,
-0.21735535562038422,
0.09455934911966324,
-0.7059147357940674,
-0.6895067095756531,
0.3186497390270233,
0.0033800462260842323,
-0.17375701665878296,
-0.2742575705051422,
-0.36632633209228516,
0.45712175965309143,
-0.15101921558380127,
0.6550783514976501,
0.4292590320110321,
-0.4599466323852539,
-0.05204106867313385,
0.15704230964183807,
-0.4450373947620392,
-0.13976702094078064,
1.1647814512252808,
-0.6890192627906799,
0.2137799710035324,
0.5788422226905823,
0.6174055337905884,
0.19163267314434052,
-0.2223101109266281,
0.5773338675498962,
-0.7479056715965271,
0.16675570607185364,
0.0678698867559433,
0.7845021486282349,
0.3462041914463043,
-0.30256685614585876,
0.5445626378059387,
0.3092784881591797,
-0.6653340458869934,
-0.9857537746429443,
0.3129265606403351,
-0.5577790141105652,
-0.580023467540741,
1.2626266479492188,
-0.370868444442749,
0.06802120804786682,
-0.03041193261742592,
-0.5677777528762817,
0.2364504337310791,
-0.16511374711990356,
0.9831299185752869,
0.6103447675704956,
0.23818722367286682,
-0.13071656227111816,
-0.10985037684440613,
0.49819302558898926,
0.24733711779117584,
-0.5342311859130859,
0.395309180021286,
0.8589749932289124,
0.7032500505447388,
0.1460353583097458,
0.8517360091209412,
-0.15787214040756226,
0.09092371165752411,
0.07454774528741837,
0.28915950655937195,
-0.32990598678588867,
-0.18107223510742188,
-0.1970198154449463,
-0.05482296645641327,
0.6014578938484192,
0.3139151930809021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14862v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14862v3 | LatentExplainer: Explaining Latent Representations in Deep Generative Models with Multi-modal Foundation Models | 2024-06-21T04:39:03 | 2024-06-28T13:19:37 | Mengdan Zhu, Raasikh Kanjiani, Jiahui Lu, Andrew Choi, Qirui Ye, Liang Zhao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Deep generative models like VAEs and diffusion models have advanced various
generation tasks by leveraging latent variables to learn data distributions and
generate high-quality samples. Despite the field of explainable AI making
strides in interpreting machine learning models, understanding latent variables
in generative models remains challenging. This paper introduces
LatentExplainer, a framework for automatically generating semantically
meaningful explanations of latent variables in deep generative models.
LatentExplainer tackles three main challenges: inferring the meaning of latent
variables, aligning explanations with inductive biases, and handling varying
degrees of explainability. By perturbing latent variables and interpreting
changes in generated data, the framework provides a systematic approach to
understanding and controlling the data generation process, enhancing the
transparency and interpretability of deep generative models. We evaluate our
proposed method on several real-world and synthetic datasets, and the results
demonstrate superior performance in generating high-quality explanations of
latent variables. | [
-0.19881290197372437,
-0.746979296207428,
0.6472776532173157,
0.3340621292591095,
-0.20313255488872528,
0.08483181893825531,
0.008667178452014923,
0.11135416477918625,
-0.24908015131950378,
0.22671698033809662,
-0.7826247811317444,
-0.3512740135192871,
-0.34874463081359863,
-0.24369671940803528,
-0.20001743733882904,
0.9030351638793945,
-0.2547846734523773,
0.04365970566868782,
-0.1917853206396103,
0.23900245130062103,
-0.5112554430961609,
-0.2510874271392822,
-0.30563822388648987,
-0.6227879524230957,
0.6578815579414368,
0.020239897072315216,
0.836726188659668,
0.2068728506565094,
0.17387379705905914,
0.2561771869659424,
-0.028700590133666992,
-0.002667974680662155,
-0.701795756816864,
0.43746328353881836,
-0.07124200463294983,
-0.5488592982292175,
-0.3769439160823822,
-0.20682258903980255,
0.4191410541534424,
1.0990796089172363,
0.019680919125676155,
-0.30569860339164734,
0.002988819032907486,
0.2065335512161255,
-0.6166256666183472,
0.20261532068252563,
-0.437844842672348,
0.5182584524154663,
-0.14568588137626648,
-0.2569679915904999,
-0.2559676468372345,
-0.4481774866580963,
0.007016788702458143,
-0.6697701215744019,
0.7498270869255066,
-0.48863810300827026,
0.44842728972435,
0.47584882378578186,
-0.2958257794380188,
0.13945524394512177,
-1.1517163515090942,
0.5864381790161133,
-0.33632147312164307,
0.29474833607673645,
0.07926573604345322,
0.6435256600379944,
-0.22157292068004608,
-0.889724612236023,
-0.810407817363739,
0.12127909064292908,
-0.13218548893928528,
0.28026384115219116,
-0.24130943417549133,
0.025416076183319092,
0.03304298222064972,
0.7353897094726562,
-0.8066751956939697,
0.11902279406785965,
0.013944858685135841,
-0.20867635309696198,
0.37629759311676025,
0.3586462140083313,
0.0816684141755104,
-0.324209064245224,
-0.18411734700202942,
-0.09987980127334595,
-0.6363373398780823,
-0.0783737376332283,
0.33172088861465454,
0.16283018887043,
-0.1922599822282791,
0.5546820759773254,
0.22741055488586426,
0.6124088168144226,
0.22960543632507324,
0.1934460699558258,
0.18614453077316284,
-0.24564144015312195,
-0.2400636523962021,
-0.11039992421865463,
0.5249770879745483,
0.06481245905160904,
-0.4534066915512085,
-0.4757908880710602,
-0.40117254853248596,
0.222885861992836,
0.2878781855106354,
-0.8525006175041199,
-0.3787553310394287,
0.27158018946647644,
-0.7842299938201904,
-0.4711911678314209,
0.06479672342538834,
-0.9678319096565247,
-0.34023913741111755,
-0.5226501822471619,
0.5094839334487915,
-0.26547273993492126,
-0.5826533436775208,
-0.14125889539718628,
-0.15707091987133026,
0.2716660499572754,
0.6069616079330444,
-0.6913659572601318,
0.06333521753549576,
0.5379801392555237,
0.7224995493888855,
-0.1934947967529297,
0.01348879560828209,
-0.5480144023895264,
0.15033352375030518,
-0.5088695883750916,
0.562279224395752,
-0.6040735840797424,
-0.3866722285747528,
-0.21148982644081116,
0.018020298331975937,
-0.17928241193294525,
-0.3906044363975525,
-0.09569091349840164,
-0.7261832356452942,
0.3183976113796234,
-0.11202970892190933,
-0.6406983137130737,
-0.13451378047466278,
-0.21549861133098602,
-0.7324279546737671,
0.7254664897918701,
0.3481198847293854,
-0.5906037092208862,
0.38053303956985474,
-0.9090446829795837,
-0.08139626681804657,
0.2902028262615204,
-0.4447573721408844,
-0.35166260600090027,
0.5686742663383484,
0.15851454436779022,
0.6442694067955017,
-0.3382219970226288,
0.6816572546958923,
-0.013782432302832603,
-0.018031444400548935,
0.3160189986228943,
-0.930325984954834,
0.6901943683624268,
0.47080716490745544,
-0.39113351702690125,
0.2669447064399719,
-0.7097766995429993,
-0.17509116232395172,
0.06592534482479095,
0.23203642666339874,
-0.02299375832080841,
-0.0732659101486206,
0.22188326716423035,
0.13681116700172424,
0.0059476313181221485,
-0.002501675160601735,
-0.10235101729631424,
-0.2849956154823303,
0.26659226417541504,
0.7618646025657654,
0.2005523145198822,
0.43502697348594666,
-0.12496554106473923,
0.8628324270248413,
0.2128777652978897,
0.041364122182130814,
-0.3308326005935669,
-0.19345439970493317,
-0.41078633069992065,
-0.29513317346572876,
0.11565733700990677,
0.163958340883255,
-0.9222255349159241,
0.45574721693992615,
-0.13214311003684998,
-0.4873649775981903,
-0.22474928200244904,
-0.019025100395083427,
0.3126719295978546,
0.5544764995574951,
0.3752683699131012,
-0.14837822318077087,
-0.1418239325284958,
-0.5468666553497314,
0.08470882475376129,
0.01843421719968319,
-0.2517876923084259,
0.3224645256996155,
0.5641984343528748,
-0.49346867203712463,
1.05434250831604,
-0.5123274922370911,
0.20179279148578644,
-0.015605751425027847,
0.8099401593208313,
-0.013042689301073551,
0.5408669114112854,
0.653459370136261,
-1.149500846862793,
-0.0035122279077768326,
-0.23183679580688477,
-0.9592547416687012,
-0.2151414155960083,
-0.4056450128555298,
-0.21520452201366425,
-0.29387417435646057,
0.5579183101654053,
-0.3993726968765259,
0.509378969669342,
0.33972495794296265,
-0.5166273713111877,
0.6051859259605408,
-0.18988189101219177,
-0.19320400059223175,
-1.0403497219085693,
0.12464305013418198,
-0.35688623785972595,
-0.22185863554477692,
-0.356061190366745,
0.05365367606282234,
-0.4084315299987793,
-0.3375132083892822,
-0.28211790323257446,
0.32088369131088257,
-0.32507458329200745,
-0.012307015247642994,
-0.08196938782930374,
-0.3603062033653259,
0.2929456830024719,
0.05720116198062897,
-0.022367695346474648,
0.8610390424728394,
0.666854739189148,
-0.8111299276351929,
0.6986173987388611,
0.24768319725990295,
0.03729821369051933,
0.40644001960754395,
-0.8018725514411926,
0.026982272043824196,
-0.46294718980789185,
0.37089115381240845,
-0.9854431748390198,
-0.4852920174598694,
0.1858789622783661,
-0.34947866201400757,
0.2490415871143341,
-0.3671817481517792,
-0.34848228096961975,
-0.2694239914417267,
-0.015292983502149582,
0.584089994430542,
0.228645458817482,
-0.9299071431159973,
0.9298675656318665,
-0.1404116451740265,
-0.1385330706834793,
-0.17742997407913208,
-0.55906081199646,
0.017571665346622467,
-0.35456040501594543,
-0.5731499195098877,
0.9272627830505371,
-0.3365437686443329,
-0.43844735622406006,
0.2535669505596161,
-0.1910802572965622,
-0.2398710995912552,
0.20380918681621552,
0.39715200662612915,
-0.005167782306671143,
-0.5804669260978699,
0.4265678822994232,
0.29178059101104736,
-0.5435200333595276,
0.3239193558692932,
-0.5494635701179504,
0.44944220781326294,
0.13481773436069489,
-0.36009588837623596,
-0.33129623532295227,
0.4324564039707184,
0.5687317252159119,
-0.136560320854187,
0.7594240307807922,
0.9354556202888489,
-0.35995402932167053,
-0.1925051063299179,
-0.15425986051559448,
-0.1898016482591629,
-0.39801058173179626,
0.07192748785018921,
-0.7459902763366699,
-0.6440582871437073,
0.5923494100570679,
-0.36845454573631287,
-0.2768591046333313,
0.6800704598426819,
0.8361955285072327,
0.22772221267223358,
1.0742093324661255,
0.6984537243843079,
0.36332061886787415,
0.44579070806503296,
-0.43462324142456055,
0.24224404990673065,
-0.3962496817111969,
-0.4784143269062042,
-0.22909866273403168,
0.23091095685958862,
-0.6100808382034302,
-0.8836722373962402,
0.32281291484832764,
0.15331022441387177,
-0.062043409794569016,
-0.22881968319416046,
-0.4056883752346039,
0.41936591267585754,
0.10817573219537735,
-0.10915648937225342,
-0.0642641931772232,
0.12566973268985748,
-0.06140343099832535,
-0.15247851610183716,
-0.5311475992202759,
-0.690613329410553,
0.7085409760475159,
0.26380711793899536,
1.164320707321167,
0.4901968240737915,
0.43688803911209106,
0.43137630820274353,
-0.10705678164958954,
-0.6810039281845093,
-0.11507125198841095,
-0.25508448481559753,
-0.2217496633529663,
-0.026700491085648537,
-0.5322530269622803,
-0.8757882118225098,
0.309123158454895,
-0.23635880649089813,
-0.5923340320587158,
0.6481011509895325,
0.365951269865036,
-0.6052429676055908,
0.057257093489170074,
-0.6228026151657104,
1.0711153745651245,
-0.3901976943016052,
-0.72584468126297,
-0.1781589686870575,
-0.5854833126068115,
0.2661266624927521,
-0.16386957466602325,
-0.12400510907173157,
0.10278856754302979,
0.14461705088615417,
0.4757622182369232,
-0.7596247792243958,
0.9336053133010864,
-0.5742053389549255,
-0.3435375392436981,
0.10645491629838943,
0.2154385894536972,
0.1882222443819046,
0.5395815372467041,
-0.36091145873069763,
-0.025751445442438126,
-0.30062055587768555,
-0.4514290690422058,
-0.747548520565033,
0.6448422074317932,
-0.8477011919021606,
-0.2788681983947754,
-0.1501452475786209,
-0.3885095417499542,
0.06363479793071747,
0.022417381405830383,
0.5972504019737244,
0.4767617881298065,
-0.47941717505455017,
0.09561615437269211,
0.9512461423873901,
-0.4740498960018158,
0.2885660231113434,
0.11654917150735855,
0.01191706769168377,
-0.07330913841724396,
0.972748339176178,
-0.15134185552597046,
-0.1059824600815773,
0.5735886693000793,
0.25977787375450134,
-0.37605488300323486,
-0.2849831283092499,
-0.47820860147476196,
-0.19152109324932098,
-0.5822498798370361,
-0.024255206808447838,
-0.7959269285202026,
-0.2116234302520752,
-0.1530631184577942,
-0.3106931149959564,
-0.266985684633255,
-0.38657328486442566,
-0.6967295408248901,
-0.04592257738113403,
0.39132189750671387,
0.8238198757171631,
-0.3063843250274658,
0.6906432509422302,
-0.3512510359287262,
0.8378060460090637,
0.6989644169807434,
0.24134445190429688,
0.05116456374526024,
-0.34979248046875,
0.13910748064517975,
-0.05454963445663452,
-0.14132030308246613,
-0.9390055537223816,
0.3329797685146332,
0.14168179035186768,
0.6581044793128967,
0.7017342448234558,
-0.04219338670372963,
0.5828690528869629,
-0.20189061760902405,
1.0330302715301514,
0.26209792494773865,
-1.1162011623382568,
0.8497669696807861,
-0.3075113892555237,
0.05593102052807808,
0.11717202514410019,
0.32328853011131287,
0.015096824616193771,
-0.04117558151483536,
-0.6324907541275024,
-1.1769561767578125,
0.4670405685901642,
0.5703507661819458,
0.33693090081214905,
0.24461469054222107,
0.6299490928649902,
0.7509911060333252,
0.1670796275138855,
-0.6054853200912476,
-0.24386942386627197,
-0.8322777152061462,
-0.23534169793128967,
-0.24104419350624084,
-0.4634200930595398,
-0.14673839509487152,
0.005482633598148823,
0.3558981418609619,
-0.2973833680152893,
0.6227549314498901,
-0.035086337476968765,
-0.5358165502548218,
-0.18447528779506683,
0.19667640328407288,
0.5143889784812927,
0.9530028700828552,
-0.03557642921805382,
0.40736624598503113,
-0.274719774723053,
-0.1719512939453125,
0.1352684199810028,
0.6439864039421082,
-0.029932862147688866,
0.2005952149629593,
0.6295267343521118,
1.0511747598648071,
-0.34219226241111755,
-0.12693598866462708,
0.6433237791061401,
-0.4995936155319214,
0.03855922818183899,
-0.6492003202438354,
0.3027532696723938,
-0.2706798315048218,
0.2708835303783417,
0.47931304574012756,
0.104945108294487,
0.13939951360225677,
-0.08344686776399612,
0.04235532507300377,
0.11203712970018387,
-0.42888426780700684,
-0.7403222322463989,
1.0162347555160522,
0.0958733782172203,
0.09210880100727081,
0.39147913455963135,
-0.20402225852012634,
-0.42566925287246704,
0.6925981640815735,
0.4356975257396698,
0.842181384563446,
-0.3348192274570465,
0.3989061415195465,
-0.02051393687725067,
-0.034206368029117584,
0.32246559858322144,
0.3157535791397095,
-0.3759717047214508,
-0.6455478072166443,
-0.5720828771591187,
-0.5252251029014587,
-0.11505832523107529,
0.5727629661560059,
-0.7555252909660339,
-0.15315905213356018,
-0.16366955637931824,
0.01256288681179285,
0.6477158665657043,
-0.40724578499794006,
-0.8760034441947937,
0.3580778241157532,
0.07710831612348557,
0.4506596028804779,
-1.279085636138916,
0.2664357125759125,
0.6598133444786072,
-0.715644359588623,
-0.5927959084510803,
0.5152973532676697,
0.10337763279676437,
-0.5058276653289795,
0.8554182648658752,
-0.004026217386126518,
-0.24545665085315704,
-0.07409325242042542,
-0.588370144367218,
-0.49080121517181396,
0.9481989741325378,
0.5915918946266174,
-0.3559856712818146,
0.20313048362731934,
-0.08227194845676422,
0.6532836556434631,
-0.41152018308639526,
0.40360575914382935,
0.1952812671661377,
0.5231947898864746,
0.16549089550971985,
-0.23922961950302124,
-0.04064284265041351,
-0.41673460602760315,
0.4410858750343323,
-0.26481863856315613,
-0.10611729323863983,
0.9606189727783203,
-0.28643926978111267,
0.09756656736135483,
-0.0379759818315506,
0.752139687538147,
-0.09353915601968765,
0.4253041744232178,
0.5609766840934753,
0.19779418408870697,
0.9143831133842468,
-0.22043605148792267,
0.9704122543334961,
-0.09504745900630951,
0.10013606399297714,
0.956673264503479,
-0.06642235070466995,
0.018545769155025482,
0.4245462417602539,
-0.02687639556825161,
0.6695454120635986,
0.8686066269874573,
-0.11126630753278732,
0.5159589648246765,
0.37435707449913025,
-0.5819705128669739,
-0.3905879259109497,
-0.26181337237358093,
-0.5879765748977661,
0.6462556719779968,
0.5993237495422363,
-0.5317845344543457,
-0.23108020424842834,
0.37191107869148254,
-0.2141726315021515,
-0.025693347677588463,
-0.005506822839379311,
0.7733332514762878,
-0.09274018555879593,
-0.4284873604774475,
0.42688024044036865,
-0.0468822680413723,
0.1623709350824356,
-0.32599252462387085,
-0.43232443928718567,
-0.26809754967689514,
0.3180065453052521,
-0.3577013611793518,
-0.4861396551132202,
0.48567888140678406,
0.053003180772066116,
-0.7571392059326172,
-0.4436586797237396,
0.5497645139694214,
-0.3280878961086273,
-0.5291939973831177,
0.35600805282592773,
0.8133114576339722,
0.18135187029838562,
-0.04208328574895859,
-0.6862769722938538,
0.017405273392796516,
-0.288377046585083,
-0.20150220394134521,
-0.2003985196352005,
0.943524181842804,
-0.15842784941196442,
0.29959774017333984,
0.5151610970497131,
-0.09531162679195404,
-0.08887594193220139,
0.5891852974891663,
0.9983475208282471,
-0.650221586227417,
-0.5631035566329956,
-0.6024245619773865,
0.41106969118118286,
0.21012242138385773,
0.011043883860111237,
0.35852888226509094,
0.5972145795822144,
0.3559349477291107,
-0.20829428732395172,
0.9304216504096985,
-0.20132508873939514,
0.1919049620628357,
-0.7065688967704773,
0.6210184693336487,
-0.6860039234161377,
0.3841429650783539,
-0.10603012889623642,
-0.8477391004562378,
-0.2533970773220062,
0.9018380641937256,
-0.23352877795696259,
0.3282625675201416,
0.4585243761539459,
0.8384591341018677,
-0.4078141152858734,
-0.06720419973134995,
0.15143586695194244,
0.5793102979660034,
0.4564688205718994,
0.26774346828460693,
1.1191704273223877,
-0.1256783902645111,
0.2595175802707672,
-0.1554143726825714,
-0.21815277636051178,
-0.20930558443069458,
-0.9339659810066223,
-0.662371814250946,
-0.5526679158210754,
-0.5225546956062317,
-0.29455310106277466,
0.055068936198949814,
0.618155837059021,
0.8815735578536987,
-0.7985053062438965,
0.21308837831020355,
-0.6618053913116455,
0.32216891646385193,
-0.22002367675304413,
-0.3863438367843628,
0.5370016098022461,
-0.3825206160545349,
-0.5432764291763306,
0.5845111012458801,
0.06724696606397629,
0.3022083640098572,
-0.444437175989151,
-0.1022624745965004,
0.42263564467430115,
-0.2818312644958496,
0.7280080914497375,
-0.0012015942484140396,
-0.790239155292511,
0.19421295821666718,
-0.28684112429618835,
0.08852202445268631,
-0.12825997173786163,
1.1436561346054077,
-0.9763873815536499,
0.7616972923278809,
0.5258973836898804,
0.43279415369033813,
0.6496455073356628,
-0.1422668993473053,
0.9806680083274841,
-0.8749960064888,
0.10951704531908035,
0.3066355884075165,
0.051916368305683136,
0.5049482583999634,
-0.637715756893158,
0.32873448729515076,
0.29395782947540283,
-0.12540900707244873,
-0.6234583854675293,
0.250193327665329,
-0.6978729367256165,
-0.5102117657661438,
0.7851319313049316,
-0.18762844800949097,
-0.04069290682673454,
-0.4312822222709656,
0.16191168129444122,
0.5850765109062195,
-0.24747908115386963,
0.644249677658081,
0.040825579315423965,
-0.24946825206279755,
-0.24684438109397888,
-0.39071351289749146,
0.5140867829322815,
0.3014982342720032,
-0.816166877746582,
0.23891691863536835,
0.7372546792030334,
0.13602493703365326,
0.06581083685159683,
0.4211103320121765,
-0.11222401261329651,
0.2596927285194397,
0.028657415881752968,
-0.062484607100486755,
0.08489803224802017,
-0.4137285351753235,
-0.557328462600708,
0.22680196166038513,
-0.055060144513845444,
-0.04182827100157738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14859v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14859v1 | From LLMs to MLLMs: Exploring the Landscape of Multimodal Jailbreaking | 2024-06-21T04:33:48 | 2024-06-21T04:33:48 | Siyuan Wang, Zhuohan Long, Zhihao Fan, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) has exposed vulnerabilities to various adversarial
attacks. This paper provides a comprehensive overview of jailbreaking research
targeting both LLMs and MLLMs, highlighting recent advancements in evaluation
benchmarks, attack techniques and defense strategies. Compared to the more
advanced state of unimodal jailbreaking, multimodal domain remains
underexplored. We summarize the limitations and potential research directions
of multimodal jailbreaking, aiming to inspire future research and further
enhance the robustness and security of MLLMs. | [
-0.39138391613960266,
-1.1034207344055176,
0.5488118529319763,
0.1760520040988922,
0.17711466550827026,
0.7152983546257019,
-0.20763200521469116,
-0.45664697885513306,
0.044195521622896194,
0.7275463938713074,
-0.6384663581848145,
-0.22853173315525055,
-0.7917207479476929,
-0.09743525087833405,
-0.3440658748149872,
1.0203640460968018,
-0.00852159969508648,
0.34650200605392456,
-0.23066873848438263,
-0.38362744450569153,
-0.564548909664154,
-1.075979232788086,
-0.23270626366138458,
0.049737848341464996,
0.722616970539093,
-0.09568243473768234,
0.7047427296638489,
0.15658387541770935,
0.6931580305099487,
0.3883703351020813,
-0.19043780863285065,
0.24597731232643127,
-0.36329081654548645,
0.45925289392471313,
0.06942648440599442,
-0.5314053893089294,
-0.2461080104112625,
-0.06991568207740784,
0.44400981068611145,
0.3327246308326721,
0.07914315909147263,
-0.12492685765028,
-0.1683882176876068,
0.9045637249946594,
-0.9522257447242737,
-0.32110148668289185,
-0.6634602546691895,
0.043169356882572174,
-0.5268111824989319,
0.044991634786129,
-0.5268279910087585,
-0.07135705649852753,
-0.13628381490707397,
-0.0786447823047638,
-0.28346723318099976,
0.15307465195655823,
0.2778874933719635,
-0.028270229697227478,
-0.8002678155899048,
-0.47983551025390625,
-0.6012184023857117,
0.9980415105819702,
-0.5263183116912842,
0.4430186450481415,
0.2030632495880127,
0.4199266731739044,
-0.4748297333717346,
-0.7720402479171753,
-0.22075000405311584,
-0.7080516815185547,
0.08417969197034836,
-0.4821937382221222,
-0.3312169313430786,
0.023401550948619843,
0.09883502870798111,
0.13394536077976227,
-0.53907310962677,
0.19867417216300964,
-0.3793262541294098,
-0.14501112699508667,
0.5326599478721619,
0.3124339282512665,
0.7753266096115112,
-0.027099961414933205,
-0.6267256140708923,
0.09886578470468521,
-1.023500680923462,
-0.07188936322927475,
0.41597113013267517,
0.2411128580570221,
-0.05524425208568573,
0.7291757464408875,
0.374136745929718,
0.6691168546676636,
-0.4120841324329376,
-0.39544230699539185,
0.20156610012054443,
-0.43854618072509766,
-0.18568478524684906,
-0.36341744661331177,
0.8567053079605103,
0.5286831259727478,
0.1508939117193222,
-0.46369773149490356,
-0.1511848121881485,
-0.2014853060245514,
0.2989158630371094,
-0.5398664474487305,
0.08804901689291,
0.3280770480632782,
-0.6168327927589417,
-0.48572590947151184,
0.013253707438707352,
-0.976124107837677,
-1.0946115255355835,
0.14803284406661987,
0.17873217165470123,
-0.42866751551628113,
-0.3488081395626068,
-0.21361277997493744,
-0.2850814163684845,
0.09145128726959229,
0.20156756043434143,
-1.0381972789764404,
0.20026633143424988,
0.6272574663162231,
1.041297435760498,
-0.21453697979450226,
-0.4698815941810608,
-0.23958690464496613,
0.11670143902301788,
-0.04001364856958389,
0.4888274669647217,
-0.4195273518562317,
-0.5322209000587463,
0.02887427806854248,
-0.009067211300134659,
-0.2474212348461151,
-0.48645836114883423,
0.2247157096862793,
-0.7649229168891907,
-0.2876898944377899,
0.0971759706735611,
-0.34530845284461975,
-0.17605125904083252,
0.749356210231781,
-0.9340050220489502,
0.460306316614151,
-0.08144573867321014,
-0.7616289854049683,
0.04682294279336929,
-0.785174548625946,
-0.3517228662967682,
-0.4615266025066376,
0.15503229200839996,
-0.5056661367416382,
0.12507624924182892,
0.25621297955513,
0.32841429114341736,
-0.1447436362504959,
0.4039227366447449,
-0.6676814556121826,
0.006348215043544769,
0.7313863039016724,
-0.6482242941856384,
0.9803258180618286,
0.6286745071411133,
-0.17202730476856232,
0.38696175813674927,
-0.5854091048240662,
-0.18238697946071625,
0.46494439244270325,
-0.27286821603775024,
-0.31215372681617737,
0.23535822331905365,
0.39353147149086,
0.2751609683036804,
0.3677305579185486,
-0.5516119599342346,
0.4744488596916199,
-0.07093492150306702,
0.9685035943984985,
0.7229548692703247,
-0.16340678930282593,
0.4280663728713989,
-0.024722695350646973,
0.3855147361755371,
0.01041280198842287,
0.4906390309333801,
-0.48713061213493347,
-0.09397674351930618,
-0.37841132283210754,
-0.21006011962890625,
0.20455268025398254,
0.7021609544754028,
-0.6444488763809204,
-0.34148916602134705,
0.27800101041793823,
-0.5437672138214111,
-0.4127112627029419,
0.5005655884742737,
0.46323418617248535,
-0.3376615047454834,
0.3735800087451935,
-0.061457857489585876,
-0.8243727087974548,
-0.9400141835212708,
-0.5243127942085266,
0.035221509635448456,
0.29987359046936035,
0.0939570963382721,
0.5477438569068909,
-0.5049484968185425,
0.5483183264732361,
-0.26729851961135864,
-0.3751811981201172,
-0.5995662212371826,
-0.247061088681221,
-0.1585151106119156,
0.483155757188797,
0.8565593957901001,
-0.9273272752761841,
-0.3088802397251129,
-0.28621479868888855,
-0.9974468946456909,
0.4473111629486084,
-0.03736383467912674,
0.3842714726924896,
0.09058046340942383,
0.7722909450531006,
-0.7434696555137634,
0.32955601811408997,
0.7102540731430054,
-0.4992069900035858,
0.85207599401474,
-0.06690721213817596,
0.1468118280172348,
-0.8387529850006104,
-0.3812747299671173,
-0.10587042570114136,
-0.28445836901664734,
-0.9672882556915283,
0.5954209566116333,
0.02231605350971222,
-0.10252729058265686,
-0.6771690249443054,
0.37575429677963257,
-0.8506794571876526,
-0.2174401432275772,
-0.2853526175022125,
0.14180973172187805,
-0.0898851677775383,
0.13299258053302765,
-0.5277625918388367,
0.7079662680625916,
0.7139872908592224,
-0.07179104536771774,
0.8856226205825806,
-0.04231803119182587,
-0.47980737686157227,
-0.04064911603927612,
-0.4161565899848938,
0.13690444827079773,
-0.01391518209129572,
0.22066527605056763,
-0.8355489373207092,
0.08938582986593246,
0.1226319968700409,
-0.28449180722236633,
0.4277832508087158,
-0.2824481427669525,
-0.6924236416816711,
-0.31447911262512207,
-0.8262301683425903,
0.32647570967674255,
0.14325332641601562,
-0.5129355788230896,
0.5465769171714783,
0.6166646480560303,
-0.16363182663917542,
-0.7990713715553284,
-0.5354538559913635,
0.7274929881095886,
-0.4908545911312103,
-0.8003755211830139,
0.06807932257652283,
-0.09860866516828537,
-0.8737186789512634,
-0.3486664593219757,
0.22501996159553528,
-0.10396979749202728,
0.4479711055755615,
0.32289424538612366,
0.47329750657081604,
-0.20544546842575073,
-0.2930861711502075,
-0.3991655111312866,
0.09944058209657669,
0.1414666324853897,
0.09541736543178558,
0.7282416820526123,
-0.3434802293777466,
-0.4883788824081421,
-0.049494657665491104,
0.360311359167099,
0.9304056763648987,
-0.35838744044303894,
1.077591896057129,
0.45440828800201416,
0.03419714793562889,
0.09159065037965775,
-0.6204881072044373,
0.06715700030326843,
-0.47626131772994995,
0.5343427062034607,
-0.38551533222198486,
-1.211990475654602,
0.3639005720615387,
-0.3096168339252472,
0.07494239509105682,
-0.033212341368198395,
0.7691964507102966,
-0.08747528493404388,
1.0526002645492554,
0.8619414567947388,
-0.29104378819465637,
0.6512511372566223,
-0.037575386464595795,
0.21554598212242126,
-0.9381184577941895,
-0.48514536023139954,
-0.23472735285758972,
-0.14793376624584198,
-0.6271504163742065,
-0.36073386669158936,
0.13853959739208221,
0.20914854109287262,
0.00744697917252779,
0.2600025236606598,
-0.020778033882379532,
0.530727744102478,
0.301618754863739,
-0.06834971904754639,
0.2667100131511688,
-0.27205225825309753,
-0.14939403533935547,
0.08663064986467361,
-0.3412747085094452,
-0.45614394545555115,
1.5948971509933472,
0.6063243746757507,
0.8967304825782776,
0.511949896812439,
0.2729996144771576,
0.6013759970664978,
0.42138901352882385,
-0.5157525539398193,
0.41601094603538513,
-0.23837168514728546,
-0.9251270890235901,
-0.19243784248828888,
-0.06114931032061577,
-0.8100097179412842,
0.6945368647575378,
-0.1898292899131775,
-1.0486847162246704,
-0.1339007169008255,
-0.03620787337422371,
-0.18691006302833557,
0.7775717377662659,
-0.755298376083374,
0.9154704809188843,
-0.7108405828475952,
-0.33446693420410156,
-0.14653334021568298,
-0.9479357004165649,
0.8532710075378418,
-0.014416875317692757,
0.7162233591079712,
-0.2637329697608948,
0.24296098947525024,
0.4500638246536255,
-0.5424978137016296,
0.9183528423309326,
-0.2862880825996399,
-0.22714562714099884,
0.16072770953178406,
0.10937929153442383,
0.37644529342651367,
0.15742084383964539,
0.22220659255981445,
-0.02089441567659378,
-0.05054405331611633,
-0.3225223124027252,
-0.5969052910804749,
0.9059160947799683,
-0.6283776164054871,
-0.7343373894691467,
-0.2802543342113495,
-0.7038413286209106,
-0.3780144155025482,
-0.006401878781616688,
-0.05821169540286064,
0.42197203636169434,
-0.38356292247772217,
0.03349301218986511,
0.8148097395896912,
-0.25480809807777405,
0.7908255457878113,
0.33499202132225037,
-0.7051548957824707,
-0.5725874304771423,
0.971791684627533,
-0.26766830682754517,
0.25717705488204956,
0.291885107755661,
-0.1917576938867569,
-0.26321128010749817,
-0.9318485856056213,
-0.6154468059539795,
-0.001228027860634029,
-0.6709367632865906,
-0.12623292207717896,
-0.5301685333251953,
-0.305640310049057,
-0.6084805130958557,
-0.2590400278568268,
-0.471068799495697,
-0.3416599929332733,
0.07060973346233368,
-0.10567070543766022,
0.2698698043823242,
0.8932022452354431,
-0.09956411272287369,
0.2671787142753601,
-0.9916984438896179,
0.5038934946060181,
0.2613070607185364,
0.026647334918379784,
0.101133793592453,
-0.18672524392604828,
-0.20684939622879028,
-0.17619936168193817,
-0.4242803156375885,
-0.9280086159706116,
0.3284458816051483,
-0.05427418649196625,
0.550442636013031,
0.5381752252578735,
-0.3570108115673065,
0.5797730684280396,
-0.8959913849830627,
0.8617826700210571,
0.5708736181259155,
-0.7019432187080383,
0.6137115955352783,
-0.10655277222394943,
-0.18895751237869263,
0.3631868362426758,
0.04858997464179993,
-0.5457350015640259,
-0.42267683148384094,
-0.13861405849456787,
-0.9291248917579651,
0.32238948345184326,
0.16451895236968994,
0.3694715201854706,
0.257848858833313,
-0.06527449190616608,
0.13641755282878876,
0.27238354086875916,
-1.0580565929412842,
-0.5909356474876404,
-0.23277068138122559,
0.12864366173744202,
-0.329983651638031,
-0.46611806750297546,
-0.3176780939102173,
-0.20274730026721954,
0.2579633295536041,
0.3004038631916046,
-0.04305564612150192,
-0.26845085620880127,
-0.6717552542686462,
0.3415476083755493,
0.7217375040054321,
0.9969822764396667,
0.5669642686843872,
-0.2108820527791977,
0.2479582577943802,
0.01887580007314682,
-0.5842407941818237,
0.5259712338447571,
-0.0036046893801540136,
-0.13168516755104065,
-0.19702990353107452,
0.6100460886955261,
1.0577058792114258,
0.10356859117746353,
-1.1681276559829712,
0.6776744723320007,
-0.03841773048043251,
-0.0366370864212513,
-0.479857861995697,
0.008640611544251442,
-0.05556585267186165,
0.5333137512207031,
0.28406256437301636,
0.19114156067371368,
-0.09885743260383606,
-0.8275825381278992,
0.19048506021499634,
0.7384060621261597,
-0.3422611951828003,
-0.22696803510189056,
0.7429835796356201,
0.02797645330429077,
-0.1132129356265068,
0.4990348517894745,
0.30029621720314026,
-0.5056771039962769,
0.6063793897628784,
0.7411013245582581,
0.7977052927017212,
-0.1689431369304657,
-0.0724097341299057,
-0.2064995914697647,
0.7206323146820068,
0.15871642529964447,
-0.06592706590890884,
0.023179545998573303,
-0.6784336566925049,
-0.26284119486808777,
-0.5544986724853516,
-0.20433467626571655,
0.2048596739768982,
-0.6029980182647705,
-0.010760304518043995,
-0.6656601428985596,
-0.30334562063217163,
0.045083269476890564,
-0.3555716872215271,
-0.08915304392576218,
-0.059378329664468765,
0.4607023000717163,
0.9131568670272827,
-0.40605634450912476,
0.9359722137451172,
0.7430243492126465,
-0.23767289519309998,
-0.06262851506471634,
-0.25971582531929016,
0.6949517130851746,
-0.8114964962005615,
0.9487748742103577,
0.2637037932872772,
-0.07775744795799255,
-0.24193787574768066,
-0.6302737593650818,
-0.8148831129074097,
0.9484540224075317,
0.18726381659507751,
-0.6126412153244019,
-0.12063092738389969,
0.18192607164382935,
0.16506344079971313,
-0.3881836235523224,
0.000195889690076001,
0.884725034236908,
0.5692259669303894,
-0.2746035158634186,
-0.6900625228881836,
-0.17792610824108124,
-0.32058602571487427,
-0.019714150577783585,
0.38248369097709656,
-0.6818468570709229,
0.9093361496925354,
-0.6782044172286987,
0.13862456381320953,
0.2998741865158081,
0.3886251151561737,
0.48823612928390503,
0.4423113167285919,
0.3249882161617279,
0.7231579422950745,
0.25432702898979187,
-0.072200708091259,
0.9803669452667236,
-0.07757216691970825,
0.2655324935913086,
1.0018173456192017,
-0.36038467288017273,
0.6770622134208679,
0.7842841744422913,
-0.36861053109169006,
0.46006157994270325,
0.3246545195579529,
-0.4156208038330078,
0.667182445526123,
0.48409220576286316,
-0.5063232779502869,
0.055700819939374924,
0.21403633058071136,
-0.3404402434825897,
0.4321712851524353,
0.5912421941757202,
-0.4384818971157074,
-0.31894904375076294,
0.7655344009399414,
0.4046303629875183,
-0.15201793611049652,
-0.48363515734672546,
0.8468068242073059,
0.11362520605325699,
-0.18092606961727142,
0.36146771907806396,
0.5143070816993713,
0.8840164542198181,
-0.8275179862976074,
0.2993924617767334,
-0.05753651633858681,
0.14815501868724823,
-0.10852156579494476,
-0.6722779273986816,
0.10978378355503082,
0.45959049463272095,
-0.1536831557750702,
-0.32325589656829834,
1.0232499837875366,
-0.06030787527561188,
-0.11015094071626663,
0.7555382251739502,
0.5576198697090149,
-0.17480066418647766,
-0.0683969259262085,
-0.7668461203575134,
0.4777181148529053,
0.0174393393099308,
-0.48637714982032776,
0.8641025424003601,
0.006140183657407761,
0.08645159006118774,
1.1770015954971313,
0.7748579382896423,
-0.12680113315582275,
0.5583862066268921,
0.12974917888641357,
1.1671382188796997,
-0.9681602120399475,
-0.009267101064324379,
-1.5779732465744019,
0.5412570238113403,
-0.07975893467664719,
-0.07758095860481262,
1.163558840751648,
0.5414484143257141,
0.5224197506904602,
-0.04663636162877083,
0.894146203994751,
-0.20388519763946533,
0.07940243184566498,
-0.8080289959907532,
0.901874303817749,
-0.42042112350463867,
0.4497525691986084,
-0.37646910548210144,
-0.5657780170440674,
-0.28718024492263794,
0.08074415475130081,
-0.14504389464855194,
-0.19323840737342834,
0.6583579182624817,
0.5950129628181458,
0.24814949929714203,
-0.21361586451530457,
0.4778922498226166,
0.24686536192893982,
0.431282639503479,
0.5271927714347839,
1.369255542755127,
-0.20715224742889404,
0.5359110236167908,
-0.15220242738723755,
-0.06763796508312225,
-0.22979554533958435,
-0.5911977887153625,
-1.2159419059753418,
-0.3793747127056122,
0.1531115472316742,
-0.36786308884620667,
0.19767555594444275,
0.6750473380088806,
0.5197427868843079,
-0.8085050582885742,
-0.3318701982498169,
0.30073946714401245,
0.3772660195827484,
0.013945667073130608,
-0.22917386889457703,
0.02691621147096157,
-0.35373425483703613,
-0.3908628225326538,
0.8799431324005127,
0.6665728092193604,
0.1413527876138687,
-0.6667222380638123,
-0.026896249502897263,
-0.4018286168575287,
-0.02349626086652279,
1.0379635095596313,
0.3170835077762604,
-0.86538165807724,
0.20913876593112946,
-0.2640165090560913,
-0.14807747304439545,
0.03125162050127983,
1.2152878046035767,
-0.5422004461288452,
0.28498077392578125,
-0.04031136631965637,
0.6398438215255737,
0.21377912163734436,
-0.18109561502933502,
0.40275704860687256,
-0.6874013543128967,
0.36352112889289856,
0.03322627395391464,
0.5515490770339966,
0.2678457796573639,
-0.08369765430688858,
0.2165495902299881,
0.388268381357193,
-0.3400772213935852,
-1.1169781684875488,
0.5262067317962646,
-0.7622860074043274,
-0.916100025177002,
0.8528024554252625,
-0.2419845014810562,
-0.2366907000541687,
-0.3659290373325348,
-0.1399683803319931,
-0.2253694236278534,
0.009327691048383713,
0.5336827039718628,
0.8421834111213684,
-0.07077470421791077,
-0.4472772479057312,
-0.8838709592819214,
0.3545306622982025,
0.06184215843677521,
-0.8598182201385498,
0.2420627623796463,
0.4265192449092865,
0.31498846411705017,
0.2325972020626068,
0.39375588297843933,
-0.422786682844162,
0.0713689848780632,
0.008561018854379654,
-0.16480319201946259,
-0.38296180963516235,
-0.5336400270462036,
-0.32122117280960083,
0.6012826561927795,
0.13540895283222198,
0.13560858368873596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14848v1 | Leveraging Passage Embeddings for Efficient Listwise Reranking with Large Language Models | 2024-06-21T03:33:51 | 2024-06-21T03:33:51 | Qi Liu, Bo Wang, Nan Wang, Jiaxin Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Recent studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of using large language
language models (LLMs) in passage ranking. The listwise approaches, such as
RankGPT, have become new state-of-the-art in this task. However, the efficiency
of RankGPT models is limited by the maximum context length and relatively high
latency of LLM inference. To address these issues, in this paper, we propose
PE-Rank, leveraging the single passage embedding as a good context compression
for efficient listwise passage reranking. By treating each passage as a special
token, we can directly input passage embeddings into LLMs, thereby reducing
input length. Additionally, we introduce an inference method that dynamically
constrains the decoding space to these special tokens, accelerating the
decoding process. For adapting the model to reranking, we employ listwise
learning to rank loss for training. Evaluation results on multiple benchmarks
demonstrate that PE-Rank significantly improves efficiency in both prefilling
and decoding, while maintaining competitive ranking effectiveness. {The Code is
available at \url{https://github.com/liuqi6777/pe_rank}.} | [
-0.06201624125242233,
-0.5265401005744934,
0.7161984443664551,
0.28283774852752686,
-0.5339556932449341,
0.21739907562732697,
-0.2514663338661194,
0.10251083970069885,
0.31349611282348633,
0.401864230632782,
-0.062311358749866486,
-0.6501507759094238,
-0.8608748912811279,
0.14923164248466492,
-0.2802048921585083,
0.8796912431716919,
0.24434418976306915,
-0.16662783920764923,
-0.05810379981994629,
0.030227603390812874,
-0.19278503954410553,
-0.7090700268745422,
-0.7372808456420898,
-0.05374844744801521,
0.6649149060249329,
0.39475542306900024,
0.5472661256790161,
0.7051600217819214,
0.26285794377326965,
0.2503759264945984,
-0.16379544138908386,
0.0768749937415123,
-0.6049906015396118,
0.4006083309650421,
-0.06575121730566025,
-0.1409546285867691,
-0.6081406474113464,
0.14397293329238892,
1.1994562149047852,
0.8632361888885498,
-0.2794138193130493,
-0.11472633481025696,
0.2541297674179077,
0.25782039761543274,
-0.46786224842071533,
0.08865530788898468,
-0.6903210282325745,
-0.05821021646261215,
-0.3246149718761444,
-0.43780580163002014,
-0.8411921262741089,
-0.429817259311676,
0.12449803203344345,
-0.5745631456375122,
-0.28688010573387146,
0.23688051104545593,
0.5413417816162109,
0.41008731722831726,
-0.5167738795280457,
0.25388702750205994,
-0.10774385184049606,
0.7030642628669739,
-0.634302020072937,
0.8387341499328613,
0.32383105158805847,
0.027224401012063026,
0.06342904269695282,
-0.8880190849304199,
-0.09670483320951462,
-0.08816953003406525,
0.25704991817474365,
0.025175822898745537,
0.23347197473049164,
-0.0513148307800293,
-0.12629762291908264,
0.2306201010942459,
-0.4621964693069458,
0.17110338807106018,
0.05255437642335892,
-0.016701221466064453,
0.6274004578590393,
-0.26534274220466614,
0.20425282418727875,
0.14951133728027344,
-0.4007703363895416,
-0.35044392943382263,
-0.9908801317214966,
0.0741972103714943,
0.3768911361694336,
0.2978161573410034,
0.25091761350631714,
0.23328611254692078,
-0.001817715703509748,
0.6538910865783691,
0.07611801475286484,
0.0038509047590196133,
0.36766964197158813,
-0.06850945204496384,
-0.03310701996088028,
0.21603168547153473,
0.442141056060791,
0.27754026651382446,
0.10834439098834991,
-0.5148851275444031,
-0.21010512113571167,
-0.5081648230552673,
0.1877841055393219,
-0.9874395728111267,
-0.45587730407714844,
0.009959611110389233,
-0.48808905482292175,
-0.31861916184425354,
0.21438100934028625,
-0.5682463049888611,
-0.16044774651527405,
0.31831908226013184,
0.5505018830299377,
-0.1732207089662552,
-0.29832637310028076,
0.09234634786844254,
-0.2023894190788269,
0.2562878727912903,
0.4045356810092926,
-0.8237162828445435,
0.16093598306179047,
0.6887765526771545,
0.8617416620254517,
-0.2822805345058441,
-0.6025980114936829,
-1.1228519678115845,
0.15601609647274017,
-0.3503418266773224,
0.9455952048301697,
-0.991182804107666,
-0.4087047874927521,
-0.11044485121965408,
-0.039980363100767136,
-0.4823652505874634,
-0.4273499548435211,
0.6924571990966797,
-0.5652811527252197,
-0.11717125028371811,
0.008948145434260368,
-0.820769727230072,
0.20194801688194275,
0.18764027953147888,
-0.5232846736907959,
0.8750147819519043,
-0.20319534838199615,
-0.5601635575294495,
0.33389943838119507,
-0.3534359931945801,
-0.5340794920921326,
0.04630628973245621,
-0.10150010138750076,
-0.4179140627384186,
0.09549267590045929,
0.5694215297698975,
0.4887399971485138,
0.2140125036239624,
0.036803022027015686,
-0.23123718798160553,
-0.6541438698768616,
0.03624434769153595,
-0.4434402883052826,
0.2984142005443573,
0.1459062695503235,
-0.1286439597606659,
-0.14755992591381073,
-0.16282689571380615,
0.22418390214443207,
0.10618792474269867,
-0.7816919684410095,
-0.5272908210754395,
0.21773774921894073,
-0.11472537368535995,
-0.17314085364341736,
0.19178766012191772,
-0.49273937940597534,
0.6549968123435974,
-0.6071943044662476,
0.3898129463195801,
0.9177882671356201,
0.16653870046138763,
0.6226952075958252,
-0.06250141561031342,
0.44717472791671753,
-0.33634787797927856,
0.07147572189569473,
-0.03347300365567207,
-0.7387421131134033,
-0.38500455021858215,
-0.15635861456394196,
0.7201568484306335,
0.5762752890586853,
-0.5943698287010193,
0.5519982576370239,
-0.6501283645629883,
-0.2622777819633484,
-0.3802452087402344,
-0.017734980210661888,
0.2663372755050659,
-0.07329781353473663,
0.3062833845615387,
-0.10094292461872101,
-0.11938533931970596,
-0.5864598751068115,
-0.5524933934211731,
-0.17908875644207,
-0.023462580516934395,
0.24600622057914734,
0.1783251315355301,
0.05209633335471153,
0.495138555765152,
-0.5306951999664307,
-0.11849480867385864,
-0.530259370803833,
-0.24357087910175323,
0.3903391659259796,
0.5255523920059204,
0.07881209999322891,
-0.8980196714401245,
-0.46517452597618103,
-0.3746412396430969,
-0.30071958899497986,
-0.30365481972694397,
0.03131450340151787,
-0.2608044445514679,
-0.1609678715467453,
0.6615215539932251,
0.10156305879354477,
0.3693097233772278,
0.6924236416816711,
-0.6162892580032349,
0.05003485083580017,
-0.3244992792606354,
0.27332478761672974,
-0.9437413811683655,
-0.028475400060415268,
-0.3523765504360199,
-0.6145832538604736,
-0.34060749411582947,
0.14292019605636597,
0.061159469187259674,
-0.27913904190063477,
-0.49361085891723633,
0.4688594341278076,
-0.40655413269996643,
0.022376755252480507,
-0.026707235723733902,
0.3063748776912689,
-0.060225196182727814,
0.5175665616989136,
0.28928136825561523,
0.696643590927124,
0.32695817947387695,
-0.4972107708454132,
-0.26063498854637146,
0.28757432103157043,
-0.2838355600833893,
0.16606314480304718,
-0.48580464720726013,
0.18758803606033325,
0.2447967529296875,
0.5129895210266113,
-0.8084559440612793,
0.4449574947357178,
0.04404795542359352,
-0.22820378839969635,
0.48488596081733704,
-0.5736829042434692,
-0.44909995794296265,
0.1442665457725525,
-0.5702193379402161,
0.6513239741325378,
0.39440205693244934,
-0.7052518129348755,
0.04242797568440437,
0.572982132434845,
-0.40993815660476685,
-0.5821107029914856,
-0.4449567496776581,
0.19607119262218475,
-0.1834186166524887,
-0.4283274710178375,
0.957453727722168,
-0.16161100566387177,
0.15788213908672333,
-0.19705252349376678,
-0.31063616275787354,
0.24848271906375885,
0.14533233642578125,
0.0803835317492485,
-0.15982289612293243,
0.061643585562705994,
0.23214741051197052,
0.33999723196029663,
-0.36551564931869507,
-0.3077128827571869,
-0.48180055618286133,
0.6008003354072571,
-0.12215499579906464,
-0.30097559094429016,
-0.15986290574073792,
0.5495782494544983,
0.5717119574546814,
-0.34404581785202026,
0.9002327919006348,
0.2154911756515503,
-0.21814888715744019,
-0.34233006834983826,
-0.3546459376811981,
-0.20079855620861053,
-0.4439878463745117,
0.21171246469020844,
-0.5453005433082581,
-0.8329181671142578,
0.30494144558906555,
-0.4091726839542389,
0.11184737086296082,
0.1371380090713501,
0.23514977097511292,
0.21470680832862854,
1.0466196537017822,
0.577514111995697,
-0.17917625606060028,
0.7542168498039246,
-0.37175849080085754,
0.5065434575080872,
-0.9541890621185303,
-0.151890367269516,
-0.2767447531223297,
-0.42235156893730164,
-0.6713411211967468,
-0.5917171239852905,
0.6186668276786804,
0.3605700433254242,
-0.3427797853946686,
-0.04047437384724617,
-0.5073651671409607,
0.7473376989364624,
0.43729010224342346,
0.29735276103019714,
0.41977858543395996,
0.21175827085971832,
-0.45014914870262146,
0.06618554890155792,
-0.9640136957168579,
-0.4466579556465149,
1.2639415264129639,
0.36695343255996704,
0.8818051815032959,
0.3873477578163147,
1.168710708618164,
0.36912763118743896,
0.23074914515018463,
-0.6067558526992798,
0.4960799813270569,
-0.40904051065444946,
-0.08567506819963455,
-0.5784668922424316,
-0.3726118206977844,
-1.0328972339630127,
0.5600967407226562,
0.06394630670547485,
-0.8343302607536316,
0.22892999649047852,
-0.04268549382686615,
-0.2938295304775238,
0.37426066398620605,
-0.5239985585212708,
1.0796080827713013,
-0.07493524253368378,
-0.4781147241592407,
-0.14549124240875244,
-0.34109196066856384,
-0.08148758113384247,
0.14550021290779114,
-0.05057197064161301,
0.117047518491745,
-0.37707725167274475,
1.0340760946273804,
-0.6229144930839539,
0.4962470829486847,
-0.30717092752456665,
-0.1343151479959488,
-0.17350107431411743,
-0.020299043506383896,
0.8383905291557312,
0.45860740542411804,
-0.34075140953063965,
0.057963673025369644,
-0.012318151071667671,
-0.4762149751186371,
-0.5037376880645752,
0.9829769134521484,
-0.5918865203857422,
-0.6426976919174194,
-0.46338996291160583,
-0.09145621955394745,
-0.16396887600421906,
0.12960273027420044,
0.45881351828575134,
0.5886268615722656,
0.01369774341583252,
0.4286613166332245,
0.772122859954834,
-0.419781893491745,
0.4400159418582916,
0.1964949518442154,
-0.25255557894706726,
-0.3897131383419037,
0.9692306518554688,
0.23494236171245575,
0.07897912710905075,
0.8208502531051636,
0.3093681335449219,
-0.7497235536575317,
-0.8811930418014526,
-0.36446413397789,
0.1737283617258072,
-0.7661739587783813,
-0.02037019096314907,
-0.622832715511322,
-0.207315593957901,
-0.5713492035865784,
-0.29564961791038513,
-0.47493425011634827,
-0.4382171332836151,
0.3298889398574829,
-0.148114413022995,
0.06869786977767944,
0.46864864230155945,
0.020471062511205673,
0.0530862994492054,
-0.6227556467056274,
0.023973051458597183,
0.27174142003059387,
0.47480037808418274,
0.0606776662170887,
-0.6069923639297485,
-0.2905184030532837,
-0.454186350107193,
-0.1900736391544342,
-1.0608389377593994,
0.3978114724159241,
0.30380451679229736,
1.0794545412063599,
0.28216007351875305,
0.21478259563446045,
0.6005105376243591,
-0.6740928292274475,
0.722399890422821,
-0.26614901423454285,
-0.8908646106719971,
0.5547187328338623,
-0.12564261257648468,
0.14891114830970764,
0.6658859848976135,
0.03676512837409973,
-0.5562904477119446,
-0.43844953179359436,
-0.500143826007843,
-1.193794846534729,
0.45869821310043335,
0.23736070096492767,
-0.05852356180548668,
-0.1420169174671173,
0.23603923618793488,
0.11890488117933273,
0.07857964932918549,
-0.8602309823036194,
-0.2768908739089966,
-0.22938475012779236,
-0.06480439007282257,
-0.34389546513557434,
-0.10285885632038116,
0.23355810344219208,
-0.3629181981086731,
0.6565256118774414,
0.00023114927171263844,
0.49500101804733276,
0.3998199701309204,
-0.4749755263328552,
0.34258660674095154,
0.39901334047317505,
0.3132437467575073,
0.6244064569473267,
-0.2841430902481079,
0.3485797643661499,
0.2836889624595642,
-0.3777960538864136,
0.2796646058559418,
0.16082318127155304,
0.012944678775966167,
-0.13038790225982666,
0.36003822088241577,
0.40986043214797974,
0.6320870518684387,
-0.4538962244987488,
0.7118163704872131,
-0.09252969175577164,
0.10984408855438232,
-0.15967650711536407,
-0.09552418440580368,
0.007559036836028099,
0.3051731586456299,
0.4756285846233368,
-0.3135084807872772,
0.17142651975154877,
-0.3565092384815216,
0.30433717370033264,
0.10306838899850845,
0.07129338383674622,
0.13427309691905975,
0.6864570379257202,
0.6294530630111694,
-0.4480467438697815,
0.7088143229484558,
-0.28492459654808044,
-0.7362918257713318,
0.2729315459728241,
0.5695888996124268,
0.632781445980072,
-0.42325377464294434,
0.1815124750137329,
0.15337558090686798,
0.2704329788684845,
-0.10354883223772049,
0.0621502622961998,
-0.40760165452957153,
-0.5591686367988586,
-0.4551986753940582,
-0.6766132712364197,
-0.4229852557182312,
0.012497150339186192,
-0.3104921579360962,
-0.059003304690122604,
-0.28000134229660034,
0.04731878638267517,
-0.441385418176651,
0.11069861799478531,
-0.6452922821044922,
-0.19250746071338654,
0.28471773862838745,
0.975666880607605,
-0.6175416707992554,
1.0696995258331299,
0.6486933827400208,
-0.21934154629707336,
-0.7765575051307678,
0.5114942789077759,
-0.3889745771884918,
-0.6076001524925232,
0.762476921081543,
0.3723784387111664,
-0.16718211770057678,
0.4937899112701416,
0.05385218933224678,
-0.8869091272354126,
1.1121270656585693,
0.265835165977478,
-0.5802104473114014,
-0.12256815284490585,
-0.22589369118213654,
0.007328044157475233,
-0.4900626540184021,
0.2579747140407562,
0.3219396770000458,
0.5483726859092712,
-0.37280896306037903,
-0.8408052921295166,
0.13216546177864075,
-0.35186630487442017,
-0.07151376456022263,
0.35805657505989075,
-0.5114343166351318,
0.6878706216812134,
-0.0936853215098381,
-0.18253953754901886,
0.1510719507932663,
0.16729280352592468,
0.4428322911262512,
0.40645715594291687,
0.8116362690925598,
0.7100644707679749,
0.768486738204956,
0.03186529129743576,
1.143436312675476,
-0.27151399850845337,
0.3299562633037567,
0.8236831426620483,
-0.13891924917697906,
1.3757672309875488,
0.4227311313152313,
-0.07653933018445969,
0.6883784532546997,
0.7648270726203918,
0.3023633062839508,
0.9014111757278442,
0.19618530571460724,
-0.2483382523059845,
-0.7790973782539368,
0.17073602974414825,
-0.6326822638511658,
0.3828674554824829,
0.2755231261253357,
-0.6579189896583557,
-0.11365392804145813,
-0.06440194696187973,
-0.0723787173628807,
-0.09381372481584549,
-0.30147939920425415,
0.5477548241615295,
0.15650507807731628,
-0.7403014898300171,
0.6470029354095459,
0.09027457982301712,
0.7566640377044678,
-0.440273642539978,
-0.13675151765346527,
-0.40300583839416504,
0.10561883449554443,
0.054575365036726,
-0.677371621131897,
-0.2295800894498825,
-0.0946197360754013,
-0.014545205049216747,
-0.873820424079895,
0.4594707190990448,
-0.49371394515037537,
-0.37321946024894714,
0.2915607988834381,
0.7642671465873718,
0.5540011525154114,
-0.36640721559524536,
-0.5771456360816956,
0.09016525745391846,
-0.13596630096435547,
-0.5445654988288879,
0.506170928478241,
0.14359818398952484,
-0.0731053501367569,
0.6785191297531128,
0.5578680634498596,
0.16296544671058655,
-0.08088187128305435,
0.33958083391189575,
0.6715262532234192,
-0.6063106060028076,
-1.098152756690979,
-0.8690154552459717,
0.18278874456882477,
-0.2661229372024536,
-0.1493413895368576,
0.5912332534790039,
0.6412652730941772,
0.7698320150375366,
0.1947096884250641,
0.4615142047405243,
0.3235780894756317,
0.26382869482040405,
-0.5849224925041199,
0.8622004985809326,
-0.6777234673500061,
0.6048208475112915,
-0.33816754817962646,
-1.1222834587097168,
-0.34532201290130615,
0.7985563278198242,
-0.49100765585899353,
-0.0016891208942979574,
0.7564178705215454,
0.6934502720832825,
-0.13404469192028046,
-0.4242270290851593,
0.5337089896202087,
-0.013109021820127964,
0.36639663577079773,
0.8803825974464417,
0.7765783071517944,
-0.34704867005348206,
0.8028024435043335,
-0.05353885516524315,
-0.19909842312335968,
-0.48171529173851013,
-0.9569395184516907,
-0.6454101204872131,
-0.4708057940006256,
-0.4044208526611328,
-0.018519753590226173,
0.35373422503471375,
0.8337936401367188,
0.9021846652030945,
-0.323755145072937,
0.06758832931518555,
0.0686163455247879,
0.45424067974090576,
-0.5256850719451904,
-0.19474956393241882,
0.6720682978630066,
-0.12409467250108719,
-0.9757084846496582,
0.9135822057723999,
0.28510382771492004,
-0.348597913980484,
0.03108709678053856,
-0.47385257482528687,
-0.3154996931552887,
-0.13051430881023407,
0.7115863561630249,
-0.09462642669677734,
-0.6858436465263367,
-0.39423808455467224,
-0.10142120718955994,
0.24435344338417053,
-0.17325013875961304,
1.0312844514846802,
-1.0619900226593018,
0.11649216711521149,
0.6861063838005066,
0.7564970254898071,
0.3629516661167145,
0.1301308423280716,
0.5906686186790466,
-0.8476067185401917,
-0.21956105530261993,
0.2767544984817505,
0.5824346542358398,
0.21849407255649567,
-0.3120010197162628,
0.549289345741272,
0.26102426648139954,
-0.7440075874328613,
-0.9815084338188171,
-0.034182287752628326,
-0.9585353136062622,
-0.4615216851234436,
1.0373166799545288,
-0.3886962831020355,
0.05818914249539375,
0.030329279601573944,
0.035764820873737335,
0.2366352081298828,
-0.7322589159011841,
0.42893072962760925,
0.46331918239593506,
-0.09198547154664993,
-0.4784676432609558,
-0.27912652492523193,
0.26866084337234497,
0.506982684135437,
-0.6189160943031311,
0.0060210926458239555,
-0.013268770650029182,
0.4127620458602905,
-0.18850423395633698,
0.680976927280426,
-0.061446063220500946,
0.13631495833396912,
0.023392202332615852,
-0.42268407344818115,
-0.2507898807525635,
-0.40027740597724915,
-0.30463090538978577,
0.47640112042427063,
0.33855175971984863,
-0.5214971899986267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14835v1 | ToVo: Toxicity Taxonomy via Voting | 2024-06-21T02:35:30 | 2024-06-21T02:35:30 | Tinh Son Luong, Thanh-Thien Le, Thang Viet Doan, Linh Ngo Van, Thien Huu Nguyen, Diep Thi-Ngoc Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Existing toxic detection models face significant limitations, such as lack of
transparency, customization, and reproducibility. These challenges stem from
the closed-source nature of their training data and the paucity of explanations
for their evaluation mechanism. To address these issues, we propose a dataset
creation mechanism that integrates voting and chain-of-thought processes,
producing a high-quality open-source dataset for toxic content detection. Our
methodology ensures diverse classification metrics for each sample and includes
both classification scores and explanatory reasoning for the classifications.
We utilize the dataset created through our proposed mechanism to train our
model, which is then compared against existing widely-used detectors. Our
approach not only enhances transparency and customizability but also
facilitates better fine-tuning for specific use cases. This work contributes a
robust framework for developing toxic content detection models, emphasizing
openness and adaptability, thus paving the way for more effective and
user-specific content moderation solutions. | [
-0.07626400887966156,
-0.14119096100330353,
0.700292706489563,
-0.11054116487503052,
-0.48556092381477356,
-0.40388017892837524,
0.002006129827350378,
-0.03321991488337517,
0.030738288536667824,
0.8181286454200745,
-0.500499963760376,
-1.2267869710922241,
-0.4899691343307495,
-0.0818408951163292,
-0.3153608441352844,
1.2392911911010742,
0.14358733594417572,
-0.3063007593154907,
-0.287773460149765,
-0.38442516326904297,
-0.4440426528453827,
-0.25014445185661316,
-0.5207783579826355,
-0.25348275899887085,
1.0741829872131348,
0.6701571941375732,
0.5436914563179016,
0.6327550411224365,
0.08236873894929886,
0.30566951632499695,
-0.041844483464956284,
0.12016384303569794,
-0.6611273288726807,
0.29826071858406067,
-0.7638556361198425,
-0.6991183757781982,
-0.18277791142463684,
0.07583741098642349,
0.15041515231132507,
0.12093295156955719,
-0.32924696803092957,
0.24163305759429932,
-0.2000660002231598,
0.6505451202392578,
-0.9884578585624695,
0.024446135386824608,
-0.7720999717712402,
0.23585893213748932,
-0.3187411427497864,
-0.3715534806251526,
-0.6861976981163025,
-0.35022154450416565,
-0.19273239374160767,
-0.5201613903045654,
-0.24112342298030853,
-0.1790582835674286,
0.4578375816345215,
0.3249844014644623,
-0.6846281886100769,
-0.5131871700286865,
-0.5269482731819153,
0.5815282464027405,
-0.8247867226600647,
0.23112663626670837,
0.15737655758857727,
0.4181225895881653,
0.04122370108962059,
-0.9353161454200745,
-0.3674352467060089,
-0.12385596334934235,
0.34625110030174255,
0.3856012225151062,
-0.08450614660978317,
-0.13126619160175323,
-0.07533133774995804,
0.33103564381599426,
-0.3708684742450714,
0.16251647472381592,
-0.04870462790131569,
-0.39323699474334717,
0.5500692129135132,
0.4428239166736603,
0.13110272586345673,
-0.4405089318752289,
-0.31379789113998413,
0.14255766570568085,
-0.5260935425758362,
-0.0839075893163681,
0.6047681570053101,
0.5337126851081848,
0.16390526294708252,
0.6923589110374451,
-0.3174522817134857,
0.3417747914791107,
-0.2791600525379181,
0.3151097297668457,
0.22452430427074432,
-0.3624633252620697,
-0.09559129178524017,
-0.05505208298563957,
0.9766375422477722,
0.4495440721511841,
-0.3660484254360199,
-0.04466303437948227,
-0.23266075551509857,
0.1270975023508072,
0.567001461982727,
-0.9408963322639465,
-0.45958179235458374,
0.4241277873516083,
-0.6632700562477112,
-1.0612260103225708,
0.003803572617471218,
-0.6227987408638,
-0.6480449438095093,
-0.08884067833423615,
0.831638514995575,
-0.07969172298908234,
-0.5250058770179749,
0.3027477562427521,
-0.2506643235683441,
-0.3636767864227295,
0.3623253107070923,
-0.44233477115631104,
0.14999249577522278,
0.6110808849334717,
0.9469558000564575,
-0.3564068377017975,
0.2884102463722229,
-0.7252155542373657,
0.14091214537620544,
-0.42678865790367126,
0.9795917272567749,
-0.5951856970787048,
-0.16940274834632874,
0.1030806228518486,
0.031588971614837646,
0.5566004514694214,
-0.7194424271583557,
0.5818913578987122,
-0.5901921391487122,
0.38400939106941223,
-0.514255940914154,
-0.3961630165576935,
-0.36612486839294434,
0.4931826591491699,
-0.6849740743637085,
0.7701780200004578,
0.1911483258008957,
-1.083875298500061,
0.7188425064086914,
-0.7130115032196045,
-0.1177423745393753,
0.3139702379703522,
0.23360368609428406,
-0.7091529369354248,
-0.06445614248514175,
-0.08788631856441498,
0.45528826117515564,
-0.0481221079826355,
0.3247389793395996,
-0.5470813512802124,
-0.273607075214386,
0.031274158507585526,
-0.18598869442939758,
0.9772676825523376,
0.40605428814888,
0.018742958083748817,
0.7166897058486938,
-0.5164704918861389,
-0.14457321166992188,
0.0323372446000576,
-0.47230762243270874,
-0.6040163040161133,
0.48462432622909546,
0.05918188765645027,
0.3234251141548157,
-0.16953468322753906,
-0.5302282571792603,
-0.17485839128494263,
-0.11722362041473389,
0.5428191423416138,
0.8724660277366638,
0.3904103636741638,
0.137070894241333,
-0.5578881502151489,
0.2293347418308258,
0.447006493806839,
0.7341290712356567,
0.021549122408032417,
-0.5355976223945618,
-0.532183825969696,
-0.03664429113268852,
0.17808054387569427,
0.3328019678592682,
-0.8687637448310852,
0.7749970555305481,
-0.259199857711792,
-0.8936607837677002,
-0.007656262721866369,
-0.1516285240650177,
0.13819704949855804,
0.6777623295783997,
0.2325151562690735,
-0.7585189342498779,
-0.040773048996925354,
-0.4554204046726227,
0.2246275097131729,
-0.30403921008110046,
-0.1942373514175415,
0.577484667301178,
0.7747455835342407,
-0.2033560425043106,
0.6484760642051697,
-0.544033408164978,
-0.6099974513053894,
0.2586553990840912,
-0.03595499321818352,
0.286113440990448,
0.24062475562095642,
0.46502986550331116,
-0.5975584983825684,
-0.2924594581127167,
-0.018722599372267723,
-0.809368371963501,
-0.27851006388664246,
0.3810724914073944,
-0.4480445683002472,
-0.28872066736221313,
0.5426860451698303,
0.36969494819641113,
0.32541146874427795,
0.4363597631454468,
-0.18849340081214905,
0.6543295979499817,
0.09766756743192673,
0.3159959614276886,
-1.1238999366760254,
0.03861338272690773,
-0.02160218544304371,
-0.2805469036102295,
-0.7044569849967957,
0.14915190637111664,
0.005239310674369335,
-0.27739933133125305,
-1.11707603931427,
0.313287615776062,
0.17578750848770142,
0.19507376849651337,
-0.10525314509868622,
-0.22166071832180023,
0.09142323583364487,
0.40049073100090027,
0.3051147162914276,
0.6208203434944153,
0.5712535977363586,
-0.6733185648918152,
0.5364229679107666,
0.3502121567726135,
-0.3944035768508911,
0.5405184626579285,
-0.5940438508987427,
0.03981944918632507,
-0.19014348089694977,
0.30092793703079224,
-0.913211464881897,
-0.2381228804588318,
0.799975574016571,
-0.25268369913101196,
-0.047001369297504425,
-0.4945492744445801,
-0.8146255612373352,
-0.27954649925231934,
-0.5092935562133789,
0.3604505956172943,
0.15234801173210144,
-0.5505387187004089,
0.21270941197872162,
0.5627216696739197,
0.053541768342256546,
-0.26485440135002136,
-0.5279785394668579,
-0.07176576554775238,
-0.3786073327064514,
-0.5978206992149353,
0.05027743801474571,
-0.16870279610157013,
0.08356060832738876,
0.008080590516328812,
-0.03421984240412712,
-0.15520501136779785,
-0.14173761010169983,
0.1583908051252365,
0.07064241170883179,
-0.12335164099931717,
0.6866095662117004,
0.3965418040752411,
-0.07981014251708984,
0.24065791070461273,
-0.22694222629070282,
0.27624964714050293,
0.1350112408399582,
-0.3766305446624756,
-0.13932397961616516,
0.3631725013256073,
0.8087140321731567,
-0.367351233959198,
0.37547093629837036,
0.2930827736854553,
-0.2468518614768982,
-0.41964244842529297,
0.039581846445798874,
-0.05838315561413765,
-0.5922906994819641,
0.145880788564682,
0.10316954553127289,
-0.6167724132537842,
0.6423344016075134,
-0.310396671295166,
0.16175910830497742,
0.27169302105903625,
0.9639372825622559,
0.16282495856285095,
0.9101629257202148,
-0.05311310291290283,
0.16426992416381836,
0.593597412109375,
-0.1535993367433548,
-0.32258340716362,
-0.6711224317550659,
-0.4421629309654236,
-0.41874101758003235,
0.01584697887301445,
-0.6220101714134216,
-0.570007860660553,
0.7280089855194092,
-0.7242527008056641,
-0.7665975689888,
0.04379881173372269,
-0.9950959086418152,
0.3623981773853302,
0.3761250376701355,
0.938692569732666,
0.47659948468208313,
-0.22464093565940857,
-0.16191571950912476,
0.17995312809944153,
-0.767995297908783,
-0.38996249437332153,
1.2514679431915283,
0.4468255937099457,
0.6951665878295898,
0.2907971441745758,
0.8006263375282288,
0.5098211169242859,
0.6575245261192322,
-1.009740948677063,
0.5567324161529541,
-0.4643491208553314,
-0.9146146774291992,
-0.26659512519836426,
-0.25967326760292053,
-0.5730196237564087,
0.04294276982545853,
-0.24346819519996643,
-0.25866201519966125,
0.313186913728714,
-0.28570160269737244,
-0.13292261958122253,
0.5202648639678955,
-0.656177282333374,
0.8061489462852478,
0.10450814664363861,
-0.7537976503372192,
-0.042406268417835236,
-0.4831765592098236,
0.5669704675674438,
-0.16379068791866302,
0.18722380697727203,
-0.1838768869638443,
-0.34893324971199036,
0.7552865743637085,
-0.8273671269416809,
0.9702548384666443,
-0.22944322228431702,
-0.29111266136169434,
0.6870425343513489,
0.16625215113162994,
0.2979227900505066,
0.48536255955696106,
-0.34024351835250854,
0.2928323745727539,
-0.327593594789505,
-0.17906267940998077,
-0.21445739269256592,
0.4372313320636749,
-0.4908248484134674,
-0.31033191084861755,
-0.5403691530227661,
-0.47615566849708557,
0.007685287389904261,
0.4440506398677826,
0.4928102195262909,
0.26794999837875366,
0.13029825687408447,
0.05802740529179573,
0.805056095123291,
-0.5798344612121582,
-0.04222305119037628,
0.5612825751304626,
-0.2814033031463623,
-0.37493032217025757,
1.0360945463180542,
-0.05425554886460304,
0.37429895997047424,
0.24475593864917755,
0.6234928369522095,
-0.24439775943756104,
-0.7375443577766418,
-0.014090324752032757,
0.1024317592382431,
-0.9637964367866516,
-0.4150552749633789,
-0.3585205674171448,
-0.29563459753990173,
-0.14727216958999634,
0.257846862077713,
-0.4366992712020874,
0.3834300637245178,
-0.6659250259399414,
0.023541122674942017,
0.5358093976974487,
0.8138790726661682,
-0.27300992608070374,
0.08295734971761703,
-0.773607075214386,
0.16350141167640686,
0.5800670981407166,
0.8983807563781738,
0.003092402359470725,
-0.3429667055606842,
0.13213235139846802,
0.09141472727060318,
-0.48139965534210205,
-1.1875786781311035,
0.34367233514785767,
-0.06766100227832794,
0.28494611382484436,
0.6236944198608398,
0.5885217785835266,
0.17893938720226288,
-0.22697655856609344,
0.7985475659370422,
0.1166563481092453,
-0.9476712346076965,
0.9113117456436157,
-0.7294414639472961,
-0.12068697810173035,
0.7281003594398499,
0.6028220653533936,
-0.5225846171379089,
-0.5647201538085938,
-0.040343377739191055,
-0.5733543038368225,
0.5365740656852722,
0.2677927315235138,
0.23601312935352325,
-0.15448984503746033,
0.1041577085852623,
0.5454279780387878,
0.1950492560863495,
-0.6701726317405701,
-0.0602881982922554,
-0.4851321280002594,
0.10305095463991165,
0.3223992586135864,
-0.19822178781032562,
-0.2695236802101135,
-0.36594927310943604,
0.41016265749931335,
-0.045300696045160294,
0.3172854483127594,
-0.059202663600444794,
0.08012841641902924,
-0.3481747508049011,
0.23450013995170593,
0.12276344746351242,
0.3484703004360199,
-0.3232877850532532,
-0.049043215811252594,
-0.16194890439510345,
-0.4598033130168915,
0.10113418102264404,
-0.4518652558326721,
-0.2778412103652954,
-0.15800848603248596,
0.1578265130519867,
0.6082717776298523,
-0.06072763726115227,
-0.45098963379859924,
0.693271279335022,
-0.17702895402908325,
-0.5231318473815918,
-0.05156313255429268,
0.31498241424560547,
-0.054962363094091415,
0.17291292548179626,
-0.013859721831977367,
0.0691654160618782,
0.6144917011260986,
-0.7585909366607666,
0.601516842842102,
0.07700356096029282,
-0.7888558506965637,
0.013818012550473213,
0.6857975125312805,
0.2645896077156067,
0.08461640775203705,
0.7742122411727905,
-0.17301210761070251,
-0.48330914974212646,
0.2933610677719116,
0.06251823902130127,
0.6391589045524597,
-0.2889615595340729,
0.7540402412414551,
0.4749036729335785,
-0.05305728316307068,
0.08031009137630463,
0.4634464681148529,
-0.0036690004635602236,
-0.9078369736671448,
-0.161393940448761,
-0.4650241434574127,
-0.5478485822677612,
0.32210421562194824,
-0.7785590291023254,
0.5565244555473328,
-0.4235308766365051,
-0.2440647929906845,
0.2741560935974121,
-0.1460086703300476,
-0.113723024725914,
0.27568888664245605,
-0.04993347451090813,
0.9479086399078369,
-1.5368553400039673,
0.39376989006996155,
0.4091908037662506,
-0.7047440409660339,
-0.6134799718856812,
-0.1609557420015335,
-0.022024888545274734,
-0.5275278091430664,
0.09569256752729416,
0.16883070766925812,
0.4600597620010376,
-0.05697457864880562,
-0.8387769460678101,
-0.3251591920852661,
1.038317322731018,
0.07246620953083038,
-0.2600146234035492,
0.03028268739581108,
-0.05908782407641411,
0.6126212477684021,
-0.1464105099439621,
0.1251574009656906,
0.10911789536476135,
0.5011852979660034,
0.5826303362846375,
-0.36350783705711365,
0.25940394401550293,
-0.4217934012413025,
-0.12684857845306396,
0.028561517596244812,
-0.49335065484046936,
0.7381724119186401,
-0.12749724090099335,
-0.28582239151000977,
-0.2229613959789276,
0.3124966323375702,
0.21361444890499115,
0.671419084072113,
0.7083937525749207,
0.542500913143158,
0.5668174624443054,
0.03829968720674515,
0.6926969289779663,
0.33198827505111694,
0.2858348488807678,
1.0794997215270996,
-0.3619192838668823,
0.7106412053108215,
0.12732072174549103,
-0.09749360382556915,
0.7721924781799316,
1.0059667825698853,
-0.3302459120750427,
0.9275296330451965,
0.30611467361450195,
-0.6014767289161682,
-0.48054781556129456,
-0.6088223457336426,
-0.18202276527881622,
0.30128851532936096,
0.515377938747406,
-0.43199190497398376,
-0.5003983378410339,
0.2589576542377472,
-0.33178117871284485,
0.05816612392663956,
-0.6621487140655518,
0.8863897323608398,
-0.10783467441797256,
-0.5864060521125793,
0.21771031618118286,
-0.4090907871723175,
0.622714638710022,
-0.3981720209121704,
-0.009971312247216702,
0.13231240212917328,
-0.07586071640253067,
-0.43086183071136475,
-1.425919771194458,
0.6514039039611816,
-0.1186089962720871,
0.15170073509216309,
-0.05534474179148674,
0.876045286655426,
-0.2640429437160492,
-0.09787722676992416,
0.1796715259552002,
0.3361850082874298,
0.16282513737678528,
-0.3533041477203369,
-0.6278801560401917,
0.0736832544207573,
-0.19807279109954834,
-0.056772008538246155,
0.19630426168441772,
0.501556396484375,
-0.3022543489933014,
0.6166463494300842,
0.8170483708381653,
0.2247338593006134,
-0.11266456544399261,
0.18344087898731232,
1.266179084777832,
-0.030922992154955864,
-0.572219729423523,
-0.31584295630455017,
0.7714483141899109,
0.0646374374628067,
-0.1009851023554802,
0.11223546415567398,
0.5838897824287415,
0.8125284910202026,
-0.13656222820281982,
0.8847017288208008,
0.013263510540127754,
0.17382118105888367,
-0.17919065058231354,
1.157771348953247,
-0.6397441625595093,
0.10516856610774994,
-0.08672602474689484,
-0.6240578293800354,
-0.3305044174194336,
0.20354697108268738,
-0.1433882713317871,
-0.059482693672180176,
0.5704097151756287,
0.9109505414962769,
-0.07494553178548813,
-0.17464929819107056,
0.29258400201797485,
0.24083270132541656,
0.4838271737098694,
0.71132892370224,
0.6819533705711365,
-0.4294470250606537,
0.6812479496002197,
-0.32614827156066895,
-0.33372166752815247,
-0.16784904897212982,
-1.097557783126831,
-0.9757471680641174,
-0.873893141746521,
-0.42951950430870056,
-0.6096460223197937,
0.024238470941781998,
0.37801316380500793,
0.7094268202781677,
-0.8622153401374817,
0.17758217453956604,
-0.24076883494853973,
0.3568098545074463,
-0.000876647187396884,
-0.18637636303901672,
-0.03298075869679451,
-0.07059403508901596,
-0.36243534088134766,
-0.10721296817064285,
0.261083722114563,
-0.24813085794448853,
-0.11751105636358261,
-0.0862666592001915,
-0.07496796548366547,
0.1761331707239151,
0.7324060797691345,
0.15803685784339905,
-0.36964505910873413,
-0.45289433002471924,
-0.19805529713630676,
-0.058630675077438354,
0.09684150665998459,
0.5031050443649292,
-0.4958283603191376,
0.9835629463195801,
0.9290907979011536,
-0.08397618681192398,
0.4959563612937927,
-0.12307792901992798,
0.2916724681854248,
-0.780598521232605,
-0.14392517507076263,
0.48064443469047546,
-0.09625814855098724,
0.1775694340467453,
-0.505106508731842,
0.5359658002853394,
0.14145450294017792,
-0.4762022793292999,
-0.8263236284255981,
0.34613728523254395,
-1.1780375242233276,
-0.39438536763191223,
1.248852014541626,
-0.15356619656085968,
-0.249940425157547,
-0.3549288511276245,
-0.09943534433841705,
0.5574292540550232,
-0.5158035755157471,
0.8088667988777161,
0.4053991734981537,
0.1379590928554535,
0.033276163041591644,
-0.2812773287296295,
0.18595901131629944,
-0.5574692487716675,
-1.154273509979248,
0.16025258600711823,
0.47755658626556396,
0.762117326259613,
0.0248725526034832,
0.5888894200325012,
-0.5332450270652771,
0.382403701543808,
-0.10199058055877686,
-0.1232438012957573,
-0.32119321823120117,
-0.23249506950378418,
-0.12215924263000488,
0.26041096448898315,
-0.17619889974594116,
-0.34928759932518005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14833v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14833v2 | Efficient Continual Pre-training by Mitigating the Stability Gap | 2024-06-21T02:28:37 | 2024-06-27T08:11:01 | Yiduo Guo, Jie Fu, Huishuai Zhang, Dongyan Zhao, Yikang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Continual pre-training has increasingly become the predominant approach for
adapting Large Language Models (LLMs) to new domains. This process involves
updating the pre-trained LLM with a corpus from a new domain, resulting in a
shift in the training distribution. To study the behavior of LLMs during this
shift, we measured the model's performance throughout the continual
pre-training process. we observed a temporary performance drop at the
beginning, followed by a recovery phase, a phenomenon known as the "stability
gap," previously noted in vision models classifying new classes. To address
this issue and enhance LLM performance within a fixed compute budget, we
propose three effective strategies: (1) Continually pre-training the LLM on a
subset with a proper size for multiple epochs, resulting in faster performance
recovery than pre-training the LLM on a large corpus in a single epoch; (2)
Pre-training the LLM only on high-quality sub-corpus, which rapidly boosts
domain performance; and (3) Using a data mixture similar to the pre-training
data to reduce distribution gap. We conduct various experiments on Llama-family
models to validate the effectiveness of our strategies in both medical
continual pre-training and instruction tuning. For example, our strategies
improve the average medical task performance of the OpenLlama-3B model from
36.2% to 40.7% with only 40% of the original training budget and enhance the
average general task performance without causing forgetting. Furthermore, we
apply our strategies to the Llama-3-8B model. The resulting model,
Llama-3-Physician, achieves the best medical performance among current
open-source models, and performs comparably to or even better than GPT-4 on
several medical benchmarks. We release our models at
\url{https://huggingface.co/YiDuo1999/Llama-3-Physician-8B-Instruct}. | [
-0.3078754246234894,
-0.6359673738479614,
0.5658910274505615,
0.06576304137706757,
-0.41209539771080017,
0.07969025522470474,
-0.38480478525161743,
-0.41165030002593994,
0.050234999507665634,
0.5205615758895874,
-0.43752825260162354,
-0.44901758432388306,
-0.804790198802948,
0.06209780275821686,
-0.17205633223056793,
0.7583019733428955,
-0.11829220503568649,
0.18389177322387695,
-0.17138013243675232,
-0.030934026464819908,
-0.6235439777374268,
-0.5523126125335693,
-0.6727372407913208,
-0.3889065384864807,
0.4332817494869232,
0.3854905962944031,
0.6305543184280396,
0.7277058362960815,
0.6231632232666016,
0.22006353735923767,
0.06816436350345612,
0.0067289466969668865,
-0.7336230874061584,
0.2235632985830307,
0.16983772814273834,
-0.48057258129119873,
-0.5614049434661865,
-0.0344751700758934,
0.9452778697013855,
0.8435934782028198,
-0.5144713521003723,
-0.06885457783937454,
0.26346877217292786,
0.6323124766349792,
-0.6485625505447388,
-0.17341862618923187,
-0.6860314607620239,
-0.01537181343883276,
-0.5802156925201416,
-0.24223430454730988,
-0.4087168574333191,
-0.41437867283821106,
0.16857439279556274,
-0.745131254196167,
0.09609051793813705,
-0.11469119042158127,
1.0731782913208008,
0.5916504263877869,
0.09618906676769257,
0.11814720183610916,
-0.6807997822761536,
0.5415684580802917,
-0.6241757273674011,
0.6092115640640259,
0.45178964734077454,
0.08763560652732849,
-0.38603100180625916,
-0.7631798982620239,
-0.42281144857406616,
-0.3715744614601135,
0.35453927516937256,
0.19844429194927216,
-0.08212213963270187,
0.035884883254766464,
0.08678236603736877,
0.275398850440979,
-0.4557609260082245,
0.38245025277137756,
-0.3007887601852417,
-0.061818744987249374,
0.2676088213920593,
0.10673057287931442,
0.1338750123977661,
0.5464087128639221,
-0.3373999297618866,
-0.014307224191725254,
-1.162947177886963,
-0.13497230410575867,
0.04200734943151474,
-0.17534735798835754,
-0.05746690183877945,
0.3024001717567444,
0.10305028408765793,
0.7300928831100464,
0.2349185198545456,
-0.4024171829223633,
0.30454590916633606,
-0.23417340219020844,
-0.126450315117836,
-0.06784256547689438,
0.3600723445415497,
0.23480242490768433,
0.39633995294570923,
-0.04430776089429855,
-0.2649325132369995,
0.4068252146244049,
0.5604212880134583,
-0.6879345774650574,
-0.34470680356025696,
-0.1783517450094223,
-0.42630863189697266,
-0.10194607079029083,
-0.4576281011104584,
-0.573021650314331,
-0.1355493664741516,
-0.4075220823287964,
0.45516887307167053,
-0.42639967799186707,
-0.19885118305683136,
0.2749563455581665,
0.49831435084342957,
0.07073727250099182,
0.3792783319950104,
-1.0835282802581787,
0.6014328598976135,
0.42846864461898804,
0.9358106255531311,
-0.3653370440006256,
-0.35719263553619385,
-0.5364936590194702,
0.180389404296875,
-0.6067591309547424,
0.8711656928062439,
-0.4766809046268463,
-0.35491350293159485,
-0.10080250352621078,
-0.10789874941110611,
-0.35744354128837585,
-0.8614145517349243,
0.03204786032438278,
-0.5623310804367065,
-0.01442878320813179,
0.08472657948732376,
-0.5200501084327698,
0.23080581426620483,
0.25844141840934753,
-0.48802706599235535,
0.8929200768470764,
0.18076635897159576,
-0.4786044657230377,
0.46663856506347656,
-0.7289756536483765,
-0.24738359451293945,
0.04436135292053223,
-0.03299526497721672,
-0.6193984150886536,
0.01868566684424877,
0.2113463282585144,
0.30040234327316284,
-0.24010048806667328,
0.11931120604276657,
-0.36112654209136963,
-0.4954349100589752,
-0.001940577058121562,
-0.12234196066856384,
0.46069765090942383,
0.07591438293457031,
-0.270355224609375,
0.054132647812366486,
-0.5789300799369812,
-0.17946982383728027,
0.18087460100650787,
-0.43356308341026306,
-0.2897759675979614,
0.11556375026702881,
-0.42650625109672546,
-0.0403548888862133,
0.05184463411569595,
-0.27400457859039307,
0.34259480237960815,
-0.5812268853187561,
0.17974209785461426,
0.8265069127082825,
0.06567449122667313,
0.3092731833457947,
-0.3128562569618225,
0.7597858905792236,
0.05136322230100632,
0.4258890748023987,
-0.10288490355014801,
-0.30207547545433044,
-1.0468099117279053,
-0.2358255237340927,
0.44212573766708374,
0.4989621043205261,
-0.7209437489509583,
0.2735375761985779,
-0.34525027871131897,
-0.35113367438316345,
-0.4215879440307617,
0.354474812746048,
0.33966943621635437,
0.6978852152824402,
0.38024404644966125,
-0.7276884317398071,
-0.37685081362724304,
-0.559120237827301,
0.06895734369754791,
-0.16753777861595154,
0.1777423769235611,
-0.17150282859802246,
0.41693007946014404,
-0.42218780517578125,
0.6416832208633423,
-0.5022627115249634,
-0.17262712121009827,
-0.1551332324743271,
-0.12455201894044876,
0.24937227368354797,
0.6187913417816162,
0.6645308136940002,
-0.5934053659439087,
-0.35349589586257935,
-0.12346287071704865,
-0.5799219608306885,
-0.10858306288719177,
0.004741567652672529,
-0.33060339093208313,
0.3811560273170471,
0.4037382900714874,
-0.4778814911842346,
0.4741213023662567,
0.7026237845420837,
-0.061993829905986786,
0.5708400011062622,
-0.2366127222776413,
-0.21871940791606903,
-0.8634935617446899,
0.09672512114048004,
-0.18880413472652435,
-0.25370320677757263,
-0.6926270127296448,
-0.08874603360891342,
-0.050161655992269516,
0.08362790197134018,
-0.3503537178039551,
0.4057455062866211,
-0.5531320571899414,
0.14515537023544312,
-0.2970854938030243,
0.07508040219545364,
-0.30515292286872864,
0.3014901876449585,
0.054800648242235184,
0.8286631107330322,
0.7077030539512634,
-0.9333429932594299,
-0.03124525025486946,
0.2582584619522095,
-0.3681732416152954,
0.47735264897346497,
-0.6292058229446411,
0.24055014550685883,
-0.011663228273391724,
0.28215378522872925,
-0.5148356556892395,
-0.2407636046409607,
0.4149985611438751,
-0.24616068601608276,
0.5854560136795044,
-0.07399885356426239,
-0.31256088614463806,
-0.322194904088974,
-0.10523246228694916,
0.4004151523113251,
0.6600742340087891,
-0.5044355988502502,
0.47575557231903076,
0.5263305902481079,
-0.3264486491680145,
-0.6498768329620361,
-0.45755261182785034,
0.06100015342235565,
-0.25538018345832825,
-0.6137452125549316,
0.5393316149711609,
-0.2480056881904602,
0.017503658309578896,
0.04198629409074783,
-0.29384639859199524,
-0.05858887732028961,
0.2578994929790497,
0.2079928070306778,
0.5277438759803772,
-0.2771855592727661,
0.16852310299873352,
-0.12985900044441223,
-0.36224982142448425,
-0.14050470292568207,
-0.5151923894882202,
0.7279860973358154,
-0.05582282319664955,
-0.21973299980163574,
-0.32298627495765686,
0.011196219362318516,
0.3266142010688782,
-0.186708003282547,
0.8145764470100403,
0.3624691963195801,
-0.4360426366329193,
0.032516755163669586,
-0.8538491129875183,
-0.23693181574344635,
-0.4296278953552246,
0.2985287308692932,
-0.199082151055336,
-0.9994601011276245,
0.2962961494922638,
-0.3159598708152771,
0.06573938578367233,
0.2910038232803345,
0.7242518067359924,
-0.03801977261900902,
0.6300658583641052,
0.9415540099143982,
-0.04685141146183014,
0.48908600211143494,
-0.21415668725967407,
0.04792831093072891,
-0.7718732357025146,
-0.27229195833206177,
-0.2634508013725281,
-0.01734945923089981,
-0.14925701916217804,
-0.3967253565788269,
0.577265202999115,
0.30718496441841125,
-0.26415055990219116,
0.08992855995893478,
-0.3079686164855957,
0.4260130524635315,
0.25149545073509216,
0.10850607603788376,
0.05234888941049576,
0.10973525047302246,
-0.13628020882606506,
0.08988414704799652,
-0.89725661277771,
-0.39650484919548035,
1.193130373954773,
0.4722226858139038,
0.7755317687988281,
-0.009381786920130253,
0.814879834651947,
-0.09329778701066971,
0.6196323037147522,
-0.4059186279773712,
0.4196375012397766,
-0.24393990635871887,
-0.23339234292507172,
-0.1706201434135437,
-0.4501315653324127,
-1.2804477214813232,
0.16132904589176178,
-0.33461305499076843,
-0.6287930011749268,
0.09585746377706528,
0.6140540242195129,
-0.48086875677108765,
0.12239832431077957,
-0.5236817002296448,
0.8546785116195679,
-0.3761356472969055,
-0.48407793045043945,
-0.37955382466316223,
-0.8107227087020874,
0.3544780910015106,
-0.5595748424530029,
0.09584943950176239,
-0.2578597664833069,
-0.23546916246414185,
0.6391714811325073,
-0.4500228464603424,
0.7034689784049988,
-0.30126896500587463,
0.009790699928998947,
0.12217175215482712,
-0.1725625842809677,
0.3239123225212097,
-0.06977936625480652,
0.11327724903821945,
0.3918950855731964,
-0.15674756467342377,
-0.49233478307724,
-0.42513611912727356,
0.49803364276885986,
-0.9107105731964111,
-0.6853224039077759,
-0.37921759486198425,
-0.3192993700504303,
-0.479330837726593,
0.26437607407569885,
0.3721671402454376,
0.2885667085647583,
-0.1663515269756317,
0.16908158361911774,
0.7604223489761353,
-0.12306105345487595,
0.3375871777534485,
0.4170816242694855,
-0.15928807854652405,
-0.44665637612342834,
0.46495646238327026,
0.20875075459480286,
0.513330340385437,
0.14627258479595184,
0.21457690000534058,
-0.3502781093120575,
-0.9442318677902222,
-0.29731428623199463,
0.4238095283508301,
-0.5526818633079529,
-0.24920694530010223,
-0.4614088833332062,
-0.23867549002170563,
-0.4144494831562042,
-0.10741710662841797,
-0.32216665148735046,
-0.11330419033765793,
-0.22249199450016022,
0.1456325352191925,
0.21746128797531128,
0.548762857913971,
-0.05324499309062958,
0.669257402420044,
-0.7433458566665649,
0.30591389536857605,
0.09360505640506744,
0.49085214734077454,
-0.16420572996139526,
-0.5872722864151001,
-0.34889936447143555,
-0.2122073918581009,
-0.42560768127441406,
-0.6841741800308228,
0.2996216416358948,
0.3529374301433563,
0.7384545803070068,
0.3483128845691681,
-0.2521185874938965,
0.9771645665168762,
-0.7096582055091858,
0.7592071890830994,
0.48648568987846375,
-0.8311958312988281,
0.5083919167518616,
-0.2548008859157562,
0.32036134600639343,
0.5416421890258789,
0.34040993452072144,
-0.20168639719486237,
-0.26019972562789917,
-0.32912614941596985,
-0.8808614015579224,
0.5322752594947815,
0.13477317988872528,
0.025571992620825768,
0.06746477633714676,
0.5705044865608215,
0.06242082640528679,
0.17307248711585999,
-0.6997541785240173,
0.0039163208566606045,
-0.20919466018676758,
-0.13362866640090942,
-0.1117861196398735,
-0.17837673425674438,
-0.11100611090660095,
-0.3126784563064575,
0.6635598540306091,
-0.06743889302015305,
0.12749013304710388,
0.034080229699611664,
-0.24653121829032898,
-0.028752872720360756,
-0.08289229869842529,
0.7169814705848694,
1.0369763374328613,
-0.08601907640695572,
0.04357085004448891,
0.38486799597740173,
-0.9455047249794006,
0.34621375799179077,
0.028176715597510338,
0.024042844772338867,
-0.1500760018825531,
0.3447186052799225,
0.7432210445404053,
0.3536630868911743,
-0.5792572498321533,
0.45622512698173523,
0.03321456536650658,
-0.22341100871562958,
-0.4876777231693268,
0.16599471867084503,
0.030213605612516403,
0.0701170489192009,
0.14667551219463348,
0.30086207389831543,
-0.37236082553863525,
-0.27307769656181335,
0.24563303589820862,
0.03762747719883919,
0.11305414885282516,
-0.2375793755054474,
0.6826050281524658,
0.18344157934188843,
-0.011432794854044914,
0.689562201499939,
0.1635887324810028,
-0.41327735781669617,
0.37581318616867065,
0.8186941742897034,
0.6138328313827515,
-0.6042981743812561,
-0.0732663944363594,
0.23805838823318481,
0.2750203013420105,
-0.577594518661499,
0.08552029728889465,
0.1585768610239029,
-0.7417891025543213,
-0.6622225046157837,
-0.6151700615882874,
-0.19969631731510162,
0.06420231610536575,
-0.566408634185791,
0.24823135137557983,
-0.6161795258522034,
-0.3916270136833191,
-0.38245806097984314,
-0.12555363774299622,
-0.7162387371063232,
0.22067634761333466,
0.11004211008548737,
0.8015034198760986,
-0.5096652507781982,
1.1160558462142944,
0.4665483236312866,
-0.23239469528198242,
-0.7825890183448792,
0.07020659744739532,
-0.07650666683912277,
-0.9633283019065857,
0.4638043940067291,
0.08528152853250504,
-0.3803318440914154,
-0.06280963122844696,
-0.5853610634803772,
-1.1976186037063599,
1.0040391683578491,
0.7358402013778687,
-0.9898154735565186,
0.02300924062728882,
-0.1309177577495575,
0.5085597038269043,
-0.4485911726951599,
-0.22523283958435059,
0.711794912815094,
0.2945346236228943,
-0.03324032574892044,
-0.8645082712173462,
-0.11019069701433182,
-0.2847943603992462,
0.11187859624624252,
0.44203996658325195,
-0.47641947865486145,
0.6964454650878906,
-0.31994903087615967,
-0.15867938101291656,
0.27753356099128723,
0.4636078178882599,
0.5558916926383972,
0.2854984998703003,
0.8273198008537292,
0.7912102341651917,
0.899694561958313,
-0.10916201770305634,
1.0975654125213623,
-0.5496438145637512,
0.0903407409787178,
0.8343363404273987,
-0.39176177978515625,
0.991482675075531,
0.43455594778060913,
-0.07337688654661179,
0.46989360451698303,
0.7651153206825256,
-0.1370806246995926,
0.5429436564445496,
0.30561363697052,
-0.2152678221464157,
-0.3935302495956421,
0.09506397694349289,
-0.6955153942108154,
0.28504475951194763,
0.4172525405883789,
-0.09072573482990265,
0.11503798514604568,
0.045870449393987656,
0.2736554443836212,
-0.04326348006725311,
-0.4344242513179779,
0.5346590280532837,
0.24210824072360992,
-0.7053994536399841,
0.9607560038566589,
-0.348849356174469,
0.5584808588027954,
-0.9537758231163025,
0.12388816475868225,
-0.21962545812129974,
0.324278324842453,
-0.1377415508031845,
-0.1883774846792221,
0.1711878776550293,
0.05680891126394272,
-0.04000089690089226,
-0.10928476601839066,
0.5404484868049622,
-0.31200408935546875,
-0.39811331033706665,
0.33081185817718506,
0.23340195417404175,
0.21558962762355804,
0.2535972595214844,
-0.5251182317733765,
0.3805055618286133,
-0.28705862164497375,
-0.13502629101276398,
0.40860021114349365,
0.11382234841585159,
-0.0767633393406868,
0.6788642406463623,
0.7361918091773987,
0.4283914566040039,
0.2475518137216568,
0.20644904673099518,
1.0774180889129639,
-0.38142627477645874,
-0.48928648233413696,
-0.7624269127845764,
0.2608802020549774,
0.07059674710035324,
-0.42739251255989075,
0.5326856970787048,
0.32986897230148315,
0.8621515035629272,
0.017400069162249565,
0.45757004618644714,
0.39240410923957825,
0.32437577843666077,
-0.8747488260269165,
0.6062610745429993,
-0.694290816783905,
0.4143871068954468,
-0.2843170166015625,
-1.0599360466003418,
-0.5893915295600891,
0.7024484872817993,
-0.2803160548210144,
0.1561031937599182,
0.777661919593811,
0.6914290189743042,
0.1039336621761322,
-0.22971615195274353,
0.27123206853866577,
0.29653462767601013,
0.22652746737003326,
0.6817334294319153,
0.9829915761947632,
0.014965740963816643,
0.48172348737716675,
-0.07314680516719818,
-0.3610062897205353,
-0.13796335458755493,
-0.8311983942985535,
-0.6326519250869751,
-0.15810392796993256,
-0.33901435136795044,
-0.36217907071113586,
0.489773690700531,
0.8153420686721802,
0.9913718700408936,
-0.5161628127098083,
-0.23017844557762146,
-0.017045460641384125,
-0.38952091336250305,
-0.24548731744289398,
-0.03954986855387688,
0.3827199935913086,
-0.5327758193016052,
-0.304045170545578,
0.4968932569026947,
0.45406782627105713,
0.129954993724823,
-0.17904223501682281,
-0.23145200312137604,
-0.020657140761613846,
-0.08998402208089828,
0.44956719875335693,
0.30426642298698425,
-0.6940230131149292,
-0.2880399823188782,
0.027124615386128426,
0.13547956943511963,
0.26649612188339233,
0.800686776638031,
-0.7384195327758789,
0.33616989850997925,
-0.12260738760232925,
0.9859845042228699,
0.6782561540603638,
0.013481566682457924,
0.5867958068847656,
-0.38027921319007874,
0.1747765839099884,
0.3326055705547333,
0.3278631567955017,
0.3055594563484192,
-0.2681531310081482,
0.6512473225593567,
0.34534919261932373,
-0.8599672913551331,
-0.7936367392539978,
0.15846483409404755,
-0.9417065382003784,
-0.2682968080043793,
0.8650782108306885,
-0.23523077368736267,
-0.10696931183338165,
-0.19993522763252258,
0.09816213697195053,
0.22194598615169525,
-0.11008390784263611,
0.8690674901008606,
0.5721074342727661,
-0.2871868908405304,
-0.19718991219997406,
-0.5991578698158264,
0.3867110013961792,
0.7067553400993347,
-0.8513273000717163,
-0.2080925554037094,
0.46515390276908875,
0.5856112241744995,
0.03452589362859726,
1.0342341661453247,
-0.2737249732017517,
0.3875935971736908,
-0.02867564558982849,
-0.07492978125810623,
0.07492368668317795,
-0.6440664529800415,
-0.4047240614891052,
0.09696049988269806,
0.2663446068763733,
-0.3356156051158905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14829v1 | Is this a bad table? A Closer Look at the Evaluation of Table Generation from Text | 2024-06-21T02:18:03 | 2024-06-21T02:18:03 | Pritika Ramu, Aparna Garimella, Sambaran Bandyopadhyay | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding whether a generated table is of good quality is important to be
able to use it in creating or editing documents using automatic methods. In
this work, we underline that existing measures for table quality evaluation
fail to capture the overall semantics of the tables, and sometimes unfairly
penalize good tables and reward bad ones. We propose TabEval, a novel table
evaluation strategy that captures table semantics by first breaking down a
table into a list of natural language atomic statements and then compares them
with ground truth statements using entailment-based measures. To validate our
approach, we curate a dataset comprising of text descriptions for 1,250 diverse
Wikipedia tables, covering a range of topics and structures, in contrast to the
limited scope of existing datasets. We compare TabEval with existing metrics
using unsupervised and supervised text-to-table generation methods,
demonstrating its stronger correlation with human judgments of table quality
across four datasets. | [
-0.31462594866752625,
-1.0187366008758545,
0.3624246120452881,
-0.23359158635139465,
-0.4743891656398773,
-0.06074553728103638,
0.009446741081774235,
-0.2587067186832428,
0.1266557276248932,
0.543645441532135,
-0.13991309702396393,
-0.7939654588699341,
-0.2604790925979614,
0.17309613525867462,
-0.8994717001914978,
1.5875359773635864,
-0.12449607998132706,
-0.1901412159204483,
-0.5979301929473877,
0.11729102581739426,
-0.44635501503944397,
0.11831075698137283,
-0.034309614449739456,
-0.20343439280986786,
0.33646485209465027,
0.7905338406562805,
1.0254887342453003,
0.9387287497520447,
0.768462061882019,
0.2120540738105774,
0.32516711950302124,
0.3168257474899292,
-0.5998940467834473,
0.07328329235315323,
-0.216766357421875,
-0.24772875010967255,
-0.44724327325820923,
0.09471790492534637,
0.5061506032943726,
0.49092957377433777,
-0.35978856682777405,
0.48986348509788513,
0.16965240240097046,
0.8949931263923645,
-0.4620773494243622,
0.23428981006145477,
-0.9828161001205444,
0.22729142010211945,
-0.6567720174789429,
-0.2116038054227829,
-0.6955509781837463,
-0.7891650795936584,
0.010929794050753117,
-0.4857402443885803,
0.40903112292289734,
0.43127337098121643,
1.1388928890228271,
0.18841718137264252,
-0.2526116371154785,
-0.5483589768409729,
-0.5926267504692078,
0.15346163511276245,
-0.7776302695274353,
0.5110744833946228,
0.3207172155380249,
0.5330533981323242,
-0.5234236717224121,
-1.0143404006958008,
-1.1174225807189941,
-0.832951009273529,
-0.15394039452075958,
-0.0036262127105146646,
-0.08399648219347,
-0.19353361427783966,
0.11856953054666519,
0.389254093170166,
-0.7646450400352478,
-0.19519320130348206,
-0.3622121214866638,
-0.21024291217327118,
0.36146533489227295,
0.27244916558265686,
0.6671038866043091,
-0.5083218812942505,
-0.34721431136131287,
-0.1516818106174469,
-0.8720390796661377,
-0.07376060634851456,
0.44729506969451904,
0.30877238512039185,
0.1762465536594391,
0.8669132590293884,
-0.1785510927438736,
0.8637149930000305,
-0.08619343489408493,
-0.015147852711379528,
0.008006311021745205,
-0.38215744495391846,
-0.07637656480073929,
0.2100343406200409,
0.7674084901809692,
0.7645394802093506,
0.06456238031387329,
-0.8185067772865295,
-0.027864351868629456,
0.49778205156326294,
0.7069941759109497,
-0.40567559003829956,
-0.3400925099849701,
0.11128446459770203,
-0.23056574165821075,
-0.43580833077430725,
0.39108964800834656,
-0.9205132126808167,
-0.37965691089630127,
-0.2804209589958191,
0.5553909540176392,
-0.27761316299438477,
0.22420023381710052,
-0.46622779965400696,
-0.3300136625766754,
0.05519036576151848,
0.111477792263031,
-0.6271199584007263,
0.5190181136131287,
0.5745275020599365,
0.5729149580001831,
-0.5455026626586914,
-0.2907945513725281,
-0.5187198519706726,
0.34623733162879944,
-0.8215908408164978,
1.1324081420898438,
-0.09127513319253922,
-0.35277217626571655,
-0.043318040668964386,
-0.26853427290916443,
0.46477842330932617,
-0.6769176721572876,
0.8419985771179199,
-0.36060458421707153,
0.017741482704877853,
-0.47196823358535767,
-0.4182906746864319,
0.17103491723537445,
0.36166587471961975,
-0.9475218653678894,
0.8429297804832458,
0.19467632472515106,
-0.7970237135887146,
1.2384657859802246,
-0.5924422144889832,
-0.7122669816017151,
0.10115405917167664,
-0.18398720026016235,
-0.5878232717514038,
-0.03765846788883209,
0.056302156299352646,
0.16976512968540192,
-0.4518306255340576,
0.5508190393447876,
-0.1432243138551712,
-0.1346951723098755,
0.5136786699295044,
-0.25902119278907776,
0.06123991683125496,
0.251107782125473,
-0.47120359539985657,
0.0624208003282547,
-0.7325775623321533,
0.3114164471626282,
-0.20546965301036835,
-0.5136809945106506,
0.031921979039907455,
0.3911919593811035,
0.08672037720680237,
0.23667514324188232,
-0.11273687332868576,
-0.6123840808868408,
-0.19484083354473114,
-0.5814141035079956,
0.3179527819156647,
0.2955605983734131,
0.3313078284263611,
0.3423413932323456,
-0.4082181751728058,
-0.2289019674062729,
-0.131787970662117,
0.04399431496858597,
0.4731452167034149,
-0.0676683560013771,
-0.9361960887908936,
0.2685873210430145,
0.4288669228553772,
0.3257056176662445,
-0.8974681496620178,
0.42908063530921936,
-0.4926304221153259,
-0.8691360950469971,
-0.2400556057691574,
0.027882346883416176,
0.47517839074134827,
0.822239339351654,
0.6584004163742065,
-0.1982773244380951,
-0.23376134037971497,
-1.2127537727355957,
-0.6240781545639038,
-0.28415176272392273,
0.014871806837618351,
0.13055133819580078,
0.6071028113365173,
0.04429999366402626,
1.0103963613510132,
-0.2602798640727997,
-0.3209545910358429,
-0.43366536498069763,
0.30567851662635803,
0.020262448117136955,
0.5273146629333496,
0.09453455358743668,
-0.41154807806015015,
-0.6635505557060242,
0.20080359280109406,
-0.7332046627998352,
0.05819291993975639,
-0.03994709625840187,
-0.599302351474762,
0.32399019598960876,
0.2443339079618454,
-0.716257631778717,
0.5123650431632996,
-0.14220154285430908,
-0.3644186854362488,
0.4350912272930145,
-0.0814182460308075,
0.5001885294914246,
-0.7469066977500916,
0.22815774381160736,
-0.21048308908939362,
0.0663536936044693,
-0.47403228282928467,
0.11377162486314774,
0.05959504470229149,
-0.3681994080543518,
-0.3979639708995819,
0.34048551321029663,
-0.43822750449180603,
-0.10662737488746643,
-0.04373287782073021,
0.39004793763160706,
0.15930870175361633,
0.11939973384141922,
-0.31681421399116516,
0.6707834005355835,
-0.10377927124500275,
-0.5853776931762695,
0.37866121530532837,
0.6417401432991028,
-0.5672672390937805,
0.7568871378898621,
-0.38785088062286377,
-0.01589849777519703,
-0.07954324781894684,
0.27726486325263977,
-0.9507587552070618,
-0.4328463077545166,
0.2678946256637573,
-0.6215612888336182,
0.6100568771362305,
0.45532792806625366,
-0.4481102228164673,
-0.6118375062942505,
-0.5007414817810059,
-0.4318844676017761,
0.148512601852417,
-0.5239337086677551,
0.2456829696893692,
0.6912084817886353,
0.2368505597114563,
-0.6842225790023804,
-0.918055534362793,
0.5533093810081482,
-0.2549571394920349,
-0.642511785030365,
0.619434118270874,
0.39084863662719727,
-0.44778043031692505,
0.24743592739105225,
-0.6013152599334717,
-0.07844361662864685,
-0.06343381851911545,
0.10988215357065201,
-0.012073211371898651,
0.008450076915323734,
0.21206824481487274,
0.1712673008441925,
-0.06541639566421509,
0.22255660593509674,
-0.04248882085084915,
0.3777320384979248,
-0.28448349237442017,
-0.040058813989162445,
-0.5053592324256897,
0.0033503365702927113,
0.28420886397361755,
-0.07498551905155182,
0.5530716776847839,
0.3742330074310303,
-0.40328940749168396,
-0.49832797050476074,
-0.5932008028030396,
-0.08204919844865799,
-0.40388455986976624,
0.32417240738868713,
-0.03445354849100113,
-0.08154968172311783,
0.46404150128364563,
0.35802769660949707,
0.35526445508003235,
0.9215772151947021,
0.31742462515830994,
-0.3303207457065582,
0.4598366618156433,
0.04491574317216873,
0.277929425239563,
-0.1359677016735077,
-0.1828826665878296,
0.17264549434185028,
-0.3229176104068756,
-0.4204721748828888,
-0.9895709753036499,
-0.23176459968090057,
-0.8120409846305847,
-0.38346707820892334,
0.19036778807640076,
-0.20866195857524872,
-0.2744635045528412,
0.5569996237754822,
-0.5186507105827332,
0.720085084438324,
0.48992156982421875,
0.3237845301628113,
0.42087414860725403,
0.1735617220401764,
0.05024776980280876,
-0.1077456921339035,
-0.40450993180274963,
-1.0370471477508545,
0.8734917044639587,
0.0023351390846073627,
0.8770128488540649,
0.0394977442920208,
0.741119384765625,
0.8482276797294617,
0.7451379895210266,
-0.35022300481796265,
0.5472104549407959,
-0.31079670786857605,
-0.7941116690635681,
-0.7804548740386963,
-0.7155494093894958,
-0.8554031848907471,
-0.03513199836015701,
-0.37795692682266235,
-0.5702677965164185,
-0.2843088209629059,
0.4110221862792969,
0.0361555777490139,
0.12453664839267731,
-0.6401808261871338,
1.2656978368759155,
-0.19421307742595673,
-0.6070893406867981,
-0.032188162207603455,
-0.51553875207901,
0.5178238749504089,
0.02376336045563221,
0.12500189244747162,
-0.13339975476264954,
0.12427409738302231,
0.9650852084159851,
-0.7528716325759888,
0.2074590027332306,
-0.18434582650661469,
0.14587582647800446,
0.8417551517486572,
0.5477184653282166,
0.2745456397533417,
0.19972850382328033,
-0.07725252956151962,
-0.053233664482831955,
-0.08319230377674103,
-0.05279846861958504,
-0.6476707458496094,
0.8517665266990662,
-0.6071767807006836,
-0.28440096974372864,
-0.11538566648960114,
-0.17811749875545502,
-0.4050537645816803,
0.04182023927569389,
0.5976659059524536,
0.5884531736373901,
-0.39969995617866516,
0.20263007283210754,
0.12757320702075958,
-0.3531365990638733,
0.19659143686294556,
0.17605671286582947,
0.17716167867183685,
-0.4557221531867981,
1.3673715591430664,
0.4328084886074066,
0.03599761798977852,
0.6420042514801025,
0.20710693299770355,
-0.5203150510787964,
-0.55293208360672,
-0.7235901355743408,
-0.24611787497997284,
-0.7030291557312012,
-0.55806964635849,
-0.3362284004688263,
-0.05178835615515709,
-0.046579960733652115,
-0.13353198766708374,
-0.11369296163320541,
-0.6119725108146667,
-0.04291004687547684,
-0.4302869737148285,
0.06520119309425354,
0.5378676652908325,
0.08195998519659042,
0.31014081835746765,
-0.7827939987182617,
0.4725760817527771,
0.3012254238128662,
0.4321173131465912,
0.06835773587226868,
-0.2572137713432312,
0.015572904609143734,
-0.1696777045726776,
-0.6067543625831604,
-1.2975263595581055,
0.41708409786224365,
0.41489559412002563,
0.9227612614631653,
0.054565902799367905,
0.2230842113494873,
0.39037495851516724,
-0.7642949819564819,
0.7243048548698425,
0.1583307534456253,
-1.0908770561218262,
0.7072409987449646,
-0.17832410335540771,
0.04554274305701256,
1.152917742729187,
0.2086079865694046,
-0.26557332277297974,
-0.7940326929092407,
-0.5670838952064514,
-0.9542389512062073,
0.36731818318367004,
0.20053449273109436,
0.16923733055591583,
-0.4638845920562744,
0.2653464078903198,
0.4839771091938019,
0.38296058773994446,
-1.2340506315231323,
0.03125810623168945,
-0.38576871156692505,
-0.29708394408226013,
0.27899596095085144,
-0.16801339387893677,
0.06570760160684586,
0.019230827689170837,
0.6303478479385376,
0.20434099435806274,
0.23808418214321136,
0.025156941264867783,
-0.5183075070381165,
-0.2998046576976776,
0.5114354491233826,
0.2235163152217865,
0.8035386800765991,
-0.16527116298675537,
0.3351370394229889,
0.24431584775447845,
-0.47585806250572205,
-0.05403319001197815,
-0.06947238743305206,
-0.23076359927654266,
0.2606373429298401,
0.3023133873939514,
0.5919461846351624,
0.058053817600011826,
-0.3495504856109619,
0.3108433485031128,
0.07728186994791031,
-0.15116074681282043,
0.2643280029296875,
0.17123118042945862,
-0.11848428845405579,
-0.3653576374053955,
0.22163353860378265,
-0.5150755643844604,
0.661860466003418,
-0.6443385481834412,
0.7466487288475037,
0.4532451331615448,
-0.34625956416130066,
0.115237757563591,
0.5456517338752747,
0.3819897770881653,
-0.39032065868377686,
0.7968661189079285,
-0.1760481595993042,
-0.27876412868499756,
0.4922349452972412,
0.35467061400413513,
0.39632678031921387,
-0.07311394065618515,
0.5668304562568665,
0.5658369064331055,
0.7051279544830322,
0.3362051546573639,
0.22208087146282196,
-0.1491725742816925,
-0.3534679710865021,
-0.12637248635292053,
-0.7570591568946838,
-0.43974804878234863,
0.056956999003887177,
-0.40428662300109863,
0.19491414725780487,
-0.09971719980239868,
-0.2698460817337036,
0.17183226346969604,
-0.0862429216504097,
-0.495530903339386,
0.15364263951778412,
-0.3144758343696594,
0.7769769430160522,
-0.710109293460846,
0.1823481321334839,
0.09559911489486694,
-0.5557973384857178,
-0.7564221620559692,
0.15100744366645813,
-0.33851850032806396,
-0.38073593378067017,
0.4833938777446747,
0.1379735767841339,
0.3243497908115387,
-0.2529102861881256,
-0.37285351753234863,
-0.5603578090667725,
0.5625917315483093,
0.19277231395244598,
-0.28489750623703003,
-0.1578211486339569,
0.6530605554580688,
0.6023879647254944,
0.4385553300380707,
0.025554915890097618,
0.7896515727043152,
0.8060146570205688,
-0.2871434688568115,
-0.7734219431877136,
0.1065324917435646,
-0.09691506624221802,
-0.3246440589427948,
0.7119238972663879,
0.10727950185537338,
0.4780052602291107,
-0.19887757301330566,
-0.6072930097579956,
-0.21776799857616425,
0.7605694532394409,
-0.1467977911233902,
0.39625683426856995,
0.2797113358974457,
0.7403748035430908,
0.58979731798172,
-0.45447179675102234,
0.8982729911804199,
-0.07130321115255356,
0.22506634891033173,
1.1692066192626953,
-0.3322180211544037,
0.9169577360153198,
0.40669071674346924,
-0.237277552485466,
0.357849657535553,
0.5095725059509277,
-0.3016835153102875,
0.6192713975906372,
0.6904736161231995,
0.2004622519016266,
0.19432717561721802,
-0.0061233751475811005,
-0.3360961973667145,
0.47908204793930054,
0.4328460693359375,
-0.3423248827457428,
-0.912224531173706,
-0.10542317479848862,
-0.18889448046684265,
0.41828665137290955,
-0.19068114459514618,
0.9556387662887573,
-0.23050452768802643,
-0.7850508689880371,
0.3406696021556854,
0.01359150093048811,
0.017840448766946793,
-0.0752023234963417,
-0.24943120777606964,
-0.2703249156475067,
-0.24824364483356476,
-0.4310464560985565,
-1.1086095571517944,
0.4997729957103729,
0.24908839166164398,
0.0723855197429657,
0.16906799376010895,
0.6268826127052307,
-0.31964313983917236,
-0.20318803191184998,
-0.35794225335121155,
0.7081568837165833,
0.18250788748264313,
0.2997449040412903,
-0.2089429497718811,
-0.26704901456832886,
-0.20066478848457336,
-0.07955366373062134,
0.04747071862220764,
0.38225099444389343,
-0.17262068390846252,
0.23457472026348114,
0.7307304739952087,
-0.1219572052359581,
-0.11081704497337341,
-0.08677470684051514,
0.6527764201164246,
-0.4968331754207611,
-0.598829448223114,
-0.9856051206588745,
0.5283344984054565,
-0.20690123736858368,
-0.5857323408126831,
0.6326628923416138,
0.8107473850250244,
0.5975058078765869,
-0.13736139237880707,
0.27221986651420593,
-0.1189793199300766,
0.4924550950527191,
-0.5314533114433289,
1.133474588394165,
-0.2694486975669861,
-0.14975614845752716,
-0.5995108485221863,
-1.2111730575561523,
-0.33055442571640015,
0.770033061504364,
-0.24801361560821533,
-0.32936617732048035,
0.7946282625198364,
0.6096132397651672,
0.24788343906402588,
0.015191097743809223,
0.1217496246099472,
0.19905339181423187,
0.29584211111068726,
0.14289867877960205,
1.1724483966827393,
-0.14177021384239197,
0.7277578711509705,
0.007431629113852978,
-0.055468056350946426,
-0.08350716531276703,
-0.9168161153793335,
-0.4442225992679596,
-0.6710960268974304,
-0.06247210502624512,
-0.6812460422515869,
0.20393657684326172,
0.5692133903503418,
0.16133229434490204,
-0.5775461196899414,
-0.20495061576366425,
-0.4782891869544983,
0.1709478795528412,
0.16141186654567719,
-0.3005029857158661,
0.636174201965332,
-0.4951559007167816,
-0.14327454566955566,
0.09551346302032471,
0.08822476118803024,
-0.18445658683776855,
-0.06846021115779877,
0.15867477655410767,
0.14836731553077698,
0.03967076539993286,
0.40715861320495605,
0.08902282267808914,
-0.631995677947998,
-0.2280433624982834,
-0.21245886385440826,
-0.3696558177471161,
0.08472426235675812,
0.4041234254837036,
-0.630574643611908,
0.30142855644226074,
0.5500414967536926,
0.5786407589912415,
0.5953983664512634,
-0.0044398121535778046,
0.3405015468597412,
-0.49420276284217834,
-0.453838050365448,
0.40029701590538025,
0.13219137489795685,
0.4050655961036682,
-0.23482121527194977,
0.49808669090270996,
-0.23798421025276184,
-0.5468322038650513,
-1.131706714630127,
-0.2188963145017624,
-0.872187077999115,
-0.13919104635715485,
0.8226710557937622,
0.3117988407611847,
-0.5646061301231384,
0.030385367572307587,
-0.2556866407394409,
0.5046623349189758,
-0.3799648880958557,
1.3272948265075684,
0.6841665506362915,
-0.11158830672502518,
0.6038044095039368,
-0.5651077032089233,
0.891776978969574,
-0.22722573578357697,
-1.5183242559432983,
0.2733113169670105,
0.7885866761207581,
0.06042075902223587,
0.3348371088504791,
0.2692003548145294,
-0.3133867084980011,
0.6104286909103394,
0.20574277639389038,
0.09400811046361923,
0.007945571094751358,
-0.5313307642936707,
0.5264455676078796,
0.29387223720550537,
0.15563932061195374,
0.040064871311187744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14828v1 | Word Matters: What Influences Domain Adaptation in Summarization? | 2024-06-21T02:15:49 | 2024-06-21T02:15:49 | Yinghao Li, Siyu Miao, Heyan Huang, Yang Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Domain adaptation aims to enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to generalize
domain datasets unseen effectively during the training phase. However, factors
such as the size of the model parameters and the scale of training data are
general influencers and do not reflect the nuances of domain adaptation
performance. This paper investigates the fine-grained factors affecting domain
adaptation performance, analyzing the specific impact of `words' in training
data on summarization tasks. We propose quantifying dataset learning difficulty
as the learning difficulty of generative summarization, which is determined by
two indicators: word-based compression rate and abstraction level. Our
experiments conclude that, when considering dataset learning difficulty, the
cross-domain overlap and the performance gain in summarization tasks exhibit an
approximate linear relationship, which is not directly related to the number of
words. Based on this finding, predicting a model's performance on unknown
domain datasets is possible without undergoing training. | [
-0.43829071521759033,
-0.6260759234428406,
0.39461299777030945,
0.24281270802021027,
-0.34014758467674255,
0.1327449381351471,
-0.3334881365299225,
-0.4720718562602997,
-0.1568281352519989,
0.1360863894224167,
-0.4061957895755768,
-0.1491156369447708,
-1.3166402578353882,
0.26993945240974426,
-0.10333742946386337,
1.2517861127853394,
-0.16765858232975006,
-0.09272047132253647,
-0.5425152778625488,
-0.18378131091594696,
-0.5027960538864136,
-0.6330504417419434,
-0.41167664527893066,
-0.5943980813026428,
0.2470119297504425,
0.19740791618824005,
0.6957340836524963,
0.40289729833602905,
0.5911794900894165,
0.30549466609954834,
-0.07686606794595718,
0.29037806391716003,
-0.6958823204040527,
0.11532560735940933,
-0.29478520154953003,
-0.7476111054420471,
-0.5467303395271301,
-0.18404288589954376,
0.3149152994155884,
1.031371831893921,
0.0795917958021164,
-0.08839616179466248,
0.5632149577140808,
0.9540492296218872,
-0.5277966856956482,
0.5821796655654907,
-0.6487119197845459,
-0.13339164853096008,
-0.09827926754951477,
-0.5535065531730652,
-0.06821595877408981,
-0.12056887149810791,
0.2524137496948242,
-0.9016801714897156,
0.6563456654548645,
0.09490243345499039,
0.6662202477455139,
0.19540119171142578,
-0.31098365783691406,
-0.3880944848060608,
-0.7978116273880005,
0.8257659077644348,
-0.5237045884132385,
0.13492923974990845,
0.514853298664093,
-0.02428600564599037,
-0.1849844753742218,
-0.3764732778072357,
-0.38034266233444214,
0.33208373188972473,
-0.06295882910490036,
0.0010875711450353265,
-0.2459687441587448,
0.18336065113544464,
0.16413725912570953,
0.48875692486763,
-0.22741542756557465,
-0.046933189034461975,
-0.6870527267456055,
0.09560993313789368,
0.7006474137306213,
0.417025089263916,
0.40113046765327454,
0.06693128496408463,
0.015907995402812958,
-0.09070735424757004,
-0.6629467010498047,
0.17231370508670807,
0.11073603481054306,
0.5466094613075256,
-0.4287590980529785,
0.5186550617218018,
-0.18503108620643616,
0.6871879696846008,
0.0564492829144001,
-0.09884130954742432,
0.0919928103685379,
-0.20288383960723877,
-0.23015156388282776,
-0.05866183340549469,
0.2575848400592804,
0.38014689087867737,
0.5984888672828674,
-0.3078397810459137,
-0.2689928114414215,
-0.24513444304466248,
0.3314466178417206,
-0.9134266376495361,
-0.41548216342926025,
0.08208376169204712,
-0.3274155855178833,
0.1594344973564148,
0.1940820813179016,
-0.3497234582901001,
-0.5638841390609741,
-0.527282178401947,
0.7338137626647949,
-0.4814684987068176,
0.07627244293689728,
0.11845088005065918,
-0.43833109736442566,
0.2165224701166153,
0.6964403390884399,
-1.003221035003662,
0.5876893997192383,
0.6747829914093018,
0.8717390894889832,
-0.6314297914505005,
-0.44346553087234497,
-0.29161813855171204,
-0.02366282232105732,
-0.3650188446044922,
0.7351040840148926,
-0.4640772342681885,
-0.5497839450836182,
-0.03000689297914505,
0.16584663093090057,
-0.6013922095298767,
-0.5855157375335693,
0.12378065288066864,
-0.6308024525642395,
0.07779841125011444,
-0.3003743290901184,
-0.8839382529258728,
-0.36597126722335815,
-0.33096784353256226,
-0.5678613185882568,
0.4261032044887543,
0.5069637894630432,
-0.8484762907028198,
0.517554521560669,
-0.5537330508232117,
-0.7642577290534973,
0.16240467131137848,
0.03459980711340904,
-0.24656374752521515,
0.7099397778511047,
0.08971871435642242,
0.7667931318283081,
-0.1423577070236206,
-0.04759630933403969,
-0.13221879303455353,
-0.34229668974876404,
0.4186066687107086,
-0.06341627240180969,
0.21784381568431854,
-0.22423076629638672,
0.09524925798177719,
-0.17766714096069336,
-0.7364501953125,
-0.0947495698928833,
0.17173351347446442,
-0.4860813617706299,
-0.6513311862945557,
0.2467324435710907,
-0.3267684876918793,
-0.12323164194822311,
-0.16789650917053223,
0.0884753167629242,
0.25033044815063477,
-0.2767544388771057,
-0.036234334111213684,
0.7191715836524963,
0.49611884355545044,
0.43142616748809814,
-0.4981718063354492,
0.8168542385101318,
0.10561402887105942,
-0.3686971366405487,
-0.006459078285843134,
-0.47405365109443665,
-0.7814661860466003,
0.04500054568052292,
0.7303391695022583,
0.3754672110080719,
-0.9182407259941101,
-0.025683993473649025,
-0.6477855443954468,
-0.255057156085968,
-0.3939187526702881,
0.45060214400291443,
0.28779101371765137,
0.09060850739479065,
0.3001757562160492,
-0.44805189967155457,
-0.2624307870864868,
-0.5767897963523865,
-0.308573454618454,
0.09083889424800873,
-0.20691195130348206,
0.39920979738235474,
0.6169067025184631,
0.1108514815568924,
0.747613787651062,
-0.8001971244812012,
-0.506933331489563,
-0.6286041736602783,
0.25642189383506775,
0.08910996466875076,
0.22655902802944183,
0.6220211982727051,
-0.6210408806800842,
-0.5044059753417969,
-0.12164745479822159,
-0.6096066236495972,
-0.3041805326938629,
-0.052830688655376434,
0.3508715331554413,
0.1344846785068512,
0.4304535686969757,
-0.30593088269233704,
0.4397105276584625,
0.8060134053230286,
-0.25641319155693054,
0.3420898914337158,
-0.6187142133712769,
0.1281599998474121,
-0.853467583656311,
-0.2344621866941452,
0.12196037173271179,
0.0015021400758996606,
-0.8223580718040466,
-0.09027384221553802,
-0.013412402011454105,
0.05463720113039017,
-0.4503256380558014,
0.33803313970565796,
-0.5819090604782104,
-0.10889420658349991,
-0.4359618127346039,
0.24979740381240845,
0.2956380248069763,
0.5586353540420532,
0.008290489204227924,
1.225998878479004,
0.5133605599403381,
-1.2753490209579468,
-0.13005506992340088,
0.27655014395713806,
-0.4866052567958832,
0.453238308429718,
-0.7002694010734558,
0.025647738948464394,
-0.12116973102092743,
-0.12405220419168472,
-0.8362330198287964,
-0.2831856310367584,
-0.18307310342788696,
-0.2784421145915985,
0.5391154885292053,
0.02857137843966484,
-0.11998212337493896,
0.09518098831176758,
-0.2686980366706848,
0.31291264295578003,
0.11536385118961334,
-0.1750890463590622,
0.4008563756942749,
0.4072956442832947,
-0.4701136350631714,
-0.0895681157708168,
-0.6816707253456116,
-0.036068327724933624,
-0.14157113432884216,
-0.34498897194862366,
0.4934879541397095,
-0.1957513988018036,
-0.2687387466430664,
-0.1691419929265976,
-0.16841337084770203,
-0.11705213040113449,
0.3000888228416443,
0.4601798355579376,
0.05999356135725975,
-0.147196426987648,
0.25817039608955383,
0.17464502155780792,
0.24047188460826874,
0.1876232624053955,
0.09946197271347046,
0.16065183281898499,
0.10092777758836746,
0.09932059049606323,
-0.034089382737874985,
-0.0068131061270833015,
0.4962265193462372,
0.1469995528459549,
0.8948871493339539,
0.0915558859705925,
-0.004504199139773846,
-0.7456839084625244,
0.18852274119853973,
0.1278826892375946,
-0.4195774495601654,
0.6027259826660156,
-0.6020256280899048,
-0.6284700036048889,
0.48675644397735596,
-0.1864011138677597,
-0.3099564015865326,
0.5897401571273804,
0.3725081980228424,
-0.016480300575494766,
0.6280528903007507,
0.9268509745597839,
-0.16801388561725616,
0.26644986867904663,
-0.32416877150535583,
0.02755272202193737,
-1.1053156852722168,
-0.016990337520837784,
-0.3406846821308136,
-0.3465462327003479,
-0.5244508981704712,
-0.5666442513465881,
0.21415238082408905,
0.22612659633159637,
0.22382672131061554,
0.25711148977279663,
0.0030390629544854164,
0.30346551537513733,
-0.05908418446779251,
0.04052654281258583,
0.3325873613357544,
0.15961407124996185,
0.3299706280231476,
-0.07873515039682388,
-0.7986230254173279,
0.04821912199258804,
1.168514609336853,
0.11879684776067734,
0.9143657088279724,
0.4552716910839081,
0.1359429955482483,
0.758286714553833,
-0.026578882709145546,
-0.9851712584495544,
0.31668567657470703,
-0.4011238217353821,
-0.0775972530245781,
-0.22337494790554047,
-0.35587742924690247,
-1.2369446754455566,
0.29490649700164795,
-0.2449660748243332,
-0.44608497619628906,
0.3588733673095703,
-0.2858690619468689,
-0.2696148753166199,
0.030378935858607292,
-0.6331924796104431,
0.2182348668575287,
0.06958229094743729,
0.043157342821359634,
-0.1454046368598938,
-0.23548491299152374,
0.11471002548933029,
-0.5632399916648865,
0.38335108757019043,
-0.1681489795446396,
-0.19004517793655396,
1.0724848508834839,
-0.30874788761138916,
0.9601760506629944,
-0.10703489184379578,
-0.026913411915302277,
0.11269590258598328,
0.15689638257026672,
0.361300528049469,
-0.40232527256011963,
0.16725343465805054,
0.3652200996875763,
-0.23042111098766327,
-0.30892035365104675,
-0.6613972783088684,
0.3773249089717865,
-0.9456711411476135,
-0.8189562559127808,
-0.1329377442598343,
-0.6885920166969299,
-0.6369214653968811,
-0.09032087028026581,
0.3730931282043457,
0.5616878867149353,
-0.2953205704689026,
0.3877844214439392,
0.7478644847869873,
-0.10533858090639114,
0.47608548402786255,
0.538922905921936,
-0.15325555205345154,
-0.16101105511188507,
1.1058136224746704,
0.3782278597354889,
0.5405576825141907,
0.39917898178100586,
0.14174337685108185,
0.1498965173959732,
-0.9497228860855103,
-0.3942473828792572,
0.037536706775426865,
-0.6951267123222351,
-0.2867007851600647,
-0.470170795917511,
-0.37858521938323975,
-0.17214244604110718,
-0.08424273878335953,
0.00511079141870141,
-0.6772463917732239,
-0.6533881425857544,
-0.12819264829158783,
0.5810091495513916,
0.885277509689331,
0.24543972313404083,
0.5405912399291992,
-0.6704958081245422,
0.4702606499195099,
0.37979161739349365,
0.2995780110359192,
-0.027138864621520042,
-1.2201486825942993,
-0.5938007235527039,
-0.34138891100883484,
-0.08554019033908844,
-0.5202632546424866,
0.27708742022514343,
0.9692941308021545,
0.2663673758506775,
0.349671334028244,
0.05576706677675247,
0.630770206451416,
-0.3698866367340088,
0.8040211200714111,
-0.10243730992078781,
-0.9559678435325623,
0.35014650225639343,
-0.04233866557478905,
0.39759930968284607,
0.37882813811302185,
0.42999082803726196,
-0.25964590907096863,
-0.3551781475543976,
-0.3995473384857178,
-0.7067356705665588,
0.8464310765266418,
0.3168680965900421,
0.37082359194755554,
0.4193660616874695,
0.4465506374835968,
0.26735037565231323,
0.2160235196352005,
-0.21523962914943695,
-0.2888062596321106,
0.14840702712535858,
0.2517794072628021,
-0.30241888761520386,
-0.3298775851726532,
0.06896284967660904,
-0.3503343462944031,
0.5722938776016235,
-0.2203950583934784,
0.15186120569705963,
0.056949492543935776,
-0.41692107915878296,
-0.13115550577640533,
0.2291804850101471,
0.6996639966964722,
0.8075576424598694,
-0.1121370866894722,
-0.06652515381574631,
0.2988854944705963,
-0.6497133374214172,
-0.01057347934693098,
-0.01934036798775196,
-0.016912762075662613,
0.12659256160259247,
0.9187678694725037,
1.0774399042129517,
0.28143545985221863,
-0.22831398248672485,
0.6832281351089478,
-0.1843794733285904,
-0.4880390167236328,
0.28683173656463623,
0.5694941878318787,
-0.26038533449172974,
-0.036230746656656265,
0.5212465524673462,
-0.016148535534739494,
0.017768174409866333,
-0.39115220308303833,
-0.0006010590004734695,
0.11999119818210602,
-0.30884191393852234,
-0.5933615565299988,
0.47885939478874207,
0.15918287634849548,
-0.19503900408744812,
0.1353294998407364,
-0.10012724250555038,
-0.5560849905014038,
0.556663453578949,
0.5113605260848999,
0.7797702550888062,
-0.422507643699646,
-0.0459548756480217,
-0.048752978444099426,
0.07520072907209396,
-0.0719459056854248,
-0.007985561154782772,
0.03394831717014313,
-0.7641277313232422,
-0.39997246861457825,
-0.5433844923973083,
-0.4637814164161682,
0.018309641629457474,
-0.7558638453483582,
-0.11367618292570114,
-0.325595885515213,
-0.11323230713605881,
0.15083342790603638,
0.13646799325942993,
-0.8476624488830566,
0.6183034181594849,
-0.004443575628101826,
0.9839349389076233,
-0.993436336517334,
0.677932620048523,
0.3943181335926056,
-0.09978271275758743,
-0.5292102098464966,
0.15417949855327606,
-0.1979677379131317,
-0.6842668056488037,
0.526301383972168,
-0.21394400298595428,
-0.2054254710674286,
-0.08939334005117416,
-0.3131903409957886,
-0.6960830092430115,
0.9488533735275269,
0.154027059674263,
-0.2832881212234497,
0.09938028454780579,
0.2818340063095093,
0.7062710523605347,
-0.598639190196991,
-0.26007598638534546,
0.65201735496521,
0.20181134343147278,
-0.21385665237903595,
-0.8074296712875366,
-0.033502738922834396,
-0.18330617249011993,
0.21123678982257843,
0.1432027518749237,
-0.5036503076553345,
0.730725884437561,
-0.41926202178001404,
-0.3736521303653717,
-0.28004181385040283,
0.6172677278518677,
-0.3060854971408844,
0.2739643454551697,
0.2440950721502304,
0.07998368889093399,
0.7205705046653748,
-0.07717334479093552,
1.3643133640289307,
-0.3202401101589203,
0.3426190912723541,
1.1320170164108276,
-0.11928541213274002,
0.7560496926307678,
0.4021746516227722,
-0.5762632489204407,
0.5352165102958679,
0.3496793210506439,
-0.12472950667142868,
0.6434401869773865,
0.34888365864753723,
-0.1421394646167755,
0.06010017171502113,
0.00784723274409771,
-0.4523981809616089,
0.6266740560531616,
0.6393075585365295,
-0.5056393146514893,
-0.0603102408349514,
0.04705321416258812,
-0.13184432685375214,
-0.04082610085606575,
-0.5497641563415527,
1.0395581722259521,
0.2109866440296173,
-0.4506362974643707,
0.6930527091026306,
0.16979248821735382,
0.401351660490036,
-0.7718767523765564,
0.08844909071922302,
-0.30000925064086914,
0.010382452048361301,
-0.243560329079628,
-0.7162790298461914,
0.3216429352760315,
-0.19750823080539703,
-0.48129260540008545,
0.1497235745191574,
0.8124383687973022,
-0.18091712892055511,
-0.4310702979564667,
0.37973618507385254,
0.8595989346504211,
0.2399962991476059,
-0.24229681491851807,
-0.4273982346057892,
0.11861878633499146,
-0.03791831061244011,
-0.5087016820907593,
0.7900705337524414,
0.7096436023712158,
0.05158486217260361,
0.5308362245559692,
0.33516407012939453,
0.4436201751232147,
-0.2594171166419983,
0.06442347913980484,
0.8744979500770569,
-0.5676536560058594,
-0.1714620292186737,
-0.7394932508468628,
0.13897034525871277,
0.24953418970108032,
-0.234313502907753,
0.7160943150520325,
0.35281825065612793,
0.64606112241745,
-0.29552891850471497,
0.9777190685272217,
0.17634280025959015,
0.29153159260749817,
-0.6661900877952576,
0.7690187692642212,
-0.5649318099021912,
0.26473379135131836,
-0.09434285014867783,
-0.8677414059638977,
-0.1809937059879303,
0.026876060292124748,
-0.4422258138656616,
0.24179862439632416,
0.720500648021698,
0.5075371265411377,
0.008188796229660511,
-0.04854443296790123,
0.6166149377822876,
0.21403443813323975,
-0.08696388453245163,
0.48243656754493713,
0.3158701956272125,
-0.46770137548446655,
0.3285089135169983,
-0.06386249512434006,
-0.13265474140644073,
-0.32072171568870544,
-0.8721250891685486,
-0.8767330050468445,
-0.6162745952606201,
-0.5483778119087219,
-0.2888595163822174,
0.1143699511885643,
0.5058267712593079,
0.4393330216407776,
-1.0227978229522705,
-0.050742361694574356,
0.05199962109327316,
0.18100211024284363,
-0.25038841366767883,
-0.2488764524459839,
0.724677324295044,
-0.3483944535255432,
-0.7793781161308289,
0.2447350025177002,
0.1997431367635727,
0.2220725119113922,
0.12727852165699005,
-0.012309147976338863,
0.42440956830978394,
0.3821624219417572,
0.7958129048347473,
0.12094509601593018,
-0.4001735746860504,
-0.1131182312965393,
-0.4586103558540344,
-0.05008786916732788,
0.25487595796585083,
0.9318187832832336,
-0.5603528022766113,
0.5141583681106567,
0.17541074752807617,
0.6970177888870239,
0.15043430030345917,
0.3059607446193695,
0.6675022840499878,
-0.8407215476036072,
-0.2677018642425537,
-0.4589504301548004,
0.16387341916561127,
0.4342641830444336,
-0.4841110408306122,
0.4319104254245758,
0.3269963562488556,
-0.4815453290939331,
-0.2553320527076721,
-0.14583511650562286,
-0.6835876107215881,
-0.5386713147163391,
1.3159914016723633,
-0.24393314123153687,
-0.23725131154060364,
-0.3556863069534302,
-0.008882066234946251,
0.01107945665717125,
-0.15163879096508026,
0.8889736533164978,
0.8502269387245178,
-0.38114461302757263,
0.05409734696149826,
-0.6195535659790039,
0.8227822780609131,
0.22307030856609344,
-0.5855699181556702,
0.47471514344215393,
0.15015554428100586,
0.4348069429397583,
-0.0983118861913681,
0.3576909899711609,
0.27363353967666626,
0.0067858570255339146,
0.01136406883597374,
-0.19188940525054932,
-0.030042525380849838,
-0.30400532484054565,
-0.756370484828949,
0.281520813703537,
0.26530081033706665,
-0.022245096042752266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14825v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14825v3 | TemPrompt: Multi-Task Prompt Learning for Temporal Relation Extraction in RAG-based Crowdsourcing Systems | 2024-06-21T01:52:37 | 2024-06-30T08:54:37 | Jing Yang, Yu Zhao, Yang Linyao, Xiao Wang, Long Chen, Fei-Yue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal relation extraction (TRE) aims to grasp the evolution of events or
actions, and thus shape the workflow of associated tasks, so it holds promise
in helping understand task requests initiated by requesters in crowdsourcing
systems. However, existing methods still struggle with limited and unevenly
distributed annotated data. Therefore, inspired by the abundant global
knowledge stored within pre-trained language models (PLMs), we propose a
multi-task prompt learning framework for TRE (TemPrompt), incorporating prompt
tuning and contrastive learning to tackle these issues. To elicit more
effective prompts for PLMs, we introduce a task-oriented prompt construction
approach that thoroughly takes the myriad factors of TRE into consideration for
automatic prompt generation. In addition, we present temporal event reasoning
as a supplement to bolster the model's focus on events and temporal cues. The
experimental results demonstrate that TemPrompt outperforms all compared
baselines across the majority of metrics under both standard and few-shot
settings. A case study is provided to validate its effectiveness in
crowdsourcing scenarios. | [
-0.3227313756942749,
-0.45447829365730286,
0.5908844470977783,
0.26337188482284546,
-0.5615876913070679,
0.18222296237945557,
-0.30845171213150024,
-0.3967092037200928,
-0.02220241352915764,
0.09609459340572357,
-0.8690378665924072,
-0.4756978154182434,
-0.472030371427536,
0.3040677607059479,
0.08039159327745438,
1.0172865390777588,
0.11889462918043137,
-0.173076331615448,
-0.036731865257024765,
-0.2087354063987732,
-0.3676040768623352,
-0.4434647262096405,
-0.885517954826355,
-0.16075068712234497,
0.9928749203681946,
0.7921282052993774,
0.16409438848495483,
0.602715015411377,
0.21589605510234833,
0.29756128787994385,
0.1431143879890442,
0.537348747253418,
-0.10715661197900772,
0.5947201251983643,
-0.3646518290042877,
-0.19814874231815338,
-0.07842038571834564,
0.163589745759964,
0.47274574637413025,
0.43024930357933044,
0.00908658467233181,
0.5550390481948853,
0.1288449913263321,
0.24851366877555847,
-0.8091554641723633,
0.5093937516212463,
-0.6124594807624817,
0.017090696841478348,
-0.5203556418418884,
-0.42680713534355164,
-0.3007024824619293,
-0.15461991727352142,
0.15648064017295837,
-0.7728070020675659,
0.5983358025550842,
0.23098768293857574,
0.7848367691040039,
0.3506169319152832,
-0.3731478750705719,
-0.10070250928401947,
-0.36375758051872253,
0.9028590321540833,
-0.31500905752182007,
0.20826391875743866,
0.6456925868988037,
0.46145421266555786,
0.1292145848274231,
-0.8618127107620239,
-0.5709820985794067,
-0.25799882411956787,
-0.02990809828042984,
0.11551088839769363,
0.20814701914787292,
-0.2987562119960785,
0.3743145167827606,
-0.07275329530239105,
-0.5643948912620544,
0.08759470283985138,
-0.21119338274002075,
-0.06669411063194275,
0.04263395443558693,
0.3056061267852783,
0.1413092166185379,
-0.7186535596847534,
-0.4929269254207611,
-0.07231972366571426,
-0.32053714990615845,
0.13753122091293335,
0.18943078815937042,
0.7484433054924011,
-0.26293835043907166,
0.44002777338027954,
0.05178513377904892,
0.7420495748519897,
0.2063852846622467,
0.08528753370046616,
0.005934374872595072,
-0.2870089113712311,
0.11903400719165802,
-0.22053688764572144,
0.7432431578636169,
0.17939308285713196,
0.2651780843734741,
-0.3709031641483307,
0.05277840420603752,
-0.14375685155391693,
0.0027058280538767576,
-0.6964403986930847,
-0.075564906001091,
0.1674417108297348,
-0.34120556712150574,
-0.09404468536376953,
0.14624963700771332,
-0.9427019953727722,
-0.5831264853477478,
-0.6109094619750977,
-0.04072846099734306,
-0.5738412737846375,
-0.38411325216293335,
-0.3934428095817566,
-0.3068688213825226,
0.1601136177778244,
0.29598575830459595,
-0.4517459571361542,
-0.08213196694850922,
0.796146810054779,
0.9756464958190918,
-0.3773365616798401,
-0.6573442220687866,
-1.1253224611282349,
0.2707687020301819,
0.08750560879707336,
0.9900384545326233,
-0.7169772982597351,
-0.4233168959617615,
-0.22756212949752808,
0.06434599310159683,
-0.17048275470733643,
-0.35329440236091614,
0.28897568583488464,
-0.6191826462745667,
0.698893666267395,
-0.33089715242385864,
-0.2502830922603607,
0.23632295429706573,
0.2707579433917999,
-0.6652542352676392,
0.8780743479728699,
0.20091526210308075,
-0.8044317364692688,
0.45580223202705383,
-0.8040207624435425,
-0.3997729420661926,
0.2119477540254593,
0.022158075124025345,
-0.34055060148239136,
0.04046805575489998,
0.4325614273548126,
0.5441181063652039,
-0.33448031544685364,
0.5197311639785767,
-0.34832763671875,
0.04826059564948082,
0.2156100869178772,
-0.12235719710588455,
0.8607588410377502,
0.5620493292808533,
-0.18671414256095886,
0.2335202544927597,
-0.5200402140617371,
-0.2641091048717499,
0.11604417115449905,
-0.07012898474931717,
-0.20592254400253296,
-0.17541874945163727,
0.2529987096786499,
0.39532527327537537,
0.05694669112563133,
-0.45837289094924927,
0.058433741331100464,
-0.15033994615077972,
0.41785120964050293,
0.7020368576049805,
0.2496979683637619,
0.40331149101257324,
-0.37470170855522156,
0.6696110963821411,
-0.02444952167570591,
0.14208495616912842,
-0.5543764233589172,
-0.1768752932548523,
-0.09414927661418915,
-0.25732553005218506,
0.2777404487133026,
0.5596700310707092,
-1.256077766418457,
0.12842388451099396,
-0.1546229124069214,
-0.34972965717315674,
-0.08635801821947098,
-0.12499938905239105,
0.49183428287506104,
1.1028409004211426,
0.31767457723617554,
0.12967346608638763,
-0.5313288569450378,
-0.49234578013420105,
-0.47508689761161804,
-0.31623056530952454,
-0.1936589777469635,
0.2649531364440918,
0.2163914293050766,
0.2622194290161133,
1.1046457290649414,
-0.4072225093841553,
-0.26613783836364746,
-0.21463729441165924,
0.6513046026229858,
0.1890370100736618,
0.5000399351119995,
0.6551358103752136,
-0.8440070152282715,
-0.41339486837387085,
-0.32655927538871765,
-0.42512422800064087,
-0.40509867668151855,
-0.007102010305970907,
0.0011996590765193105,
0.20764729380607605,
0.3579026758670807,
-0.5506809949874878,
0.1848779320716858,
0.2385973483324051,
-0.5617822408676147,
0.5989948511123657,
0.03673888370394707,
0.4716014862060547,
-1.3653786182403564,
0.2356307953596115,
0.29838690161705017,
-0.42869827151298523,
-0.44455015659332275,
-0.11957968771457672,
0.10613476485013962,
-0.4974304437637329,
-0.5836470127105713,
0.9929772615432739,
-0.6032302975654602,
-0.07972435653209686,
-0.2952253818511963,
0.21500220894813538,
0.09487168490886688,
0.7010345458984375,
0.14607876539230347,
0.7313552498817444,
0.2870413362979889,
-0.7192047238349915,
0.45644932985305786,
0.21596281230449677,
-0.16268040239810944,
0.861689031124115,
-0.38855794072151184,
0.3493339717388153,
-0.11542145162820816,
0.07792765647172928,
-0.8638988733291626,
-0.3019118905067444,
0.41074517369270325,
-0.8407844305038452,
0.4341377913951874,
-0.5121761560440063,
-0.748975396156311,
-0.30434542894363403,
-0.1465379297733307,
0.4603944420814514,
0.3387860059738159,
-0.5959734320640564,
0.6228157877922058,
0.410381942987442,
-0.6007615327835083,
-0.648867666721344,
-0.44366830587387085,
0.0037160837091505527,
-0.3652593195438385,
-0.1336519420146942,
0.2610451877117157,
0.1194361001253128,
-0.2966300845146179,
-0.020588291808962822,
-0.2884970009326935,
-0.45360368490219116,
-0.011256027966737747,
0.3234305679798126,
0.2721916437149048,
0.09735319763422012,
0.4675770401954651,
-0.21206799149513245,
-0.29841870069503784,
-0.11148915439844131,
-0.21803587675094604,
0.6244562864303589,
0.11145132780075073,
-0.3775343596935272,
-0.6178738474845886,
0.34074556827545166,
0.5220604538917542,
-0.44776907563209534,
0.4880426228046417,
0.7708490490913391,
-0.4936029016971588,
0.02174614742398262,
-0.7300241589546204,
-0.3480992317199707,
-0.4343925714492798,
0.15852700173854828,
-0.3050345182418823,
-0.7057628035545349,
0.5817425847053528,
-0.21488603949546814,
0.19119800627231598,
0.5566266179084778,
0.27294304966926575,
-0.25811222195625305,
0.5366349816322327,
0.4224037528038025,
-0.02759060077369213,
1.014563798904419,
0.080283023416996,
-0.6975919604301453,
-0.5408076047897339,
-0.48702624440193176,
-0.865292489528656,
-0.2315322309732437,
-0.0885758027434349,
-0.34779050946235657,
0.3319121301174164,
-0.16272075474262238,
-0.4774976074695587,
0.19881577789783478,
-0.3106020987033844,
0.4477224051952362,
0.696448802947998,
0.32836899161338806,
0.11407884210348129,
0.0403662845492363,
0.2367122620344162,
-0.22794291377067566,
-0.6574987173080444,
-0.260369211435318,
0.5892927050590515,
-0.18509002029895782,
0.05071157589554787,
-0.19234789907932281,
0.6298086047172546,
0.29205891489982605,
0.25873997807502747,
-0.4771876037120819,
0.44195467233657837,
-0.02402900531888008,
-0.5106911063194275,
-0.5499492883682251,
-0.6197227239608765,
-1.1380425691604614,
-0.11836107075214386,
-0.0940885916352272,
-0.5884599685668945,
0.27677449584007263,
0.1791698932647705,
-0.4133492112159729,
0.36753126978874207,
-0.703616738319397,
0.8378803133964539,
-0.15335771441459656,
-0.49377915263175964,
-0.17200975120067596,
-1.0015809535980225,
0.0035390404518693686,
0.007563180755823851,
0.32604873180389404,
-0.45228469371795654,
-0.34922268986701965,
0.7518790364265442,
-0.2874175012111664,
0.9547166228294373,
-0.5546192526817322,
0.35650238394737244,
0.21016032993793488,
0.19987577199935913,
0.554611325263977,
0.2539082169532776,
-0.24044682085514069,
-0.06221117079257965,
-0.04586396366357803,
-0.4622373878955841,
-0.37372562289237976,
0.488646924495697,
-0.4338274598121643,
-0.450609028339386,
-0.2518388330936432,
-0.7661551237106323,
-0.4247167110443115,
0.0719255656003952,
0.285741925239563,
0.76836097240448,
0.005335730034857988,
-0.08426978439092636,
0.3619033992290497,
-0.31543025374412537,
0.8972532153129578,
0.6282510161399841,
0.1731957346200943,
-0.5787404179573059,
0.8017064332962036,
-0.20721721649169922,
-0.06109728291630745,
0.4723895788192749,
0.28624099493026733,
-0.4215451776981354,
-0.051229093223810196,
-0.2736015319824219,
0.21887272596359253,
-0.4614095091819763,
-0.4299294650554657,
-0.5941560864448547,
0.36583632230758667,
-0.5873777270317078,
-0.000954252784140408,
-0.05094301328063011,
-0.625603973865509,
-0.5391378998756409,
0.061545420438051224,
0.630439043045044,
0.25281211733818054,
-0.2760380208492279,
0.28786197304725647,
-1.099568486213684,
0.7621685266494751,
0.3788115978240967,
0.19178663194179535,
-0.20828239619731903,
-0.4838922619819641,
0.0228077694773674,
-0.2975163757801056,
-0.04390167072415352,
-1.1431001424789429,
0.37603023648262024,
0.221745565533638,
0.6239400506019592,
0.36061108112335205,
0.2794363796710968,
0.6846348643302917,
-0.5408957004547119,
0.8044404983520508,
0.3176131248474121,
-0.8721923232078552,
0.8143819570541382,
-0.44415295124053955,
0.5833576917648315,
0.6217377185821533,
0.34102028608322144,
-0.6188326478004456,
-0.33614832162857056,
-0.8741825222969055,
-0.6882092952728271,
1.1137659549713135,
-0.05756012350320816,
-0.09890326857566833,
-0.13766632974147797,
0.46561282873153687,
0.4226296842098236,
0.3292587399482727,
-0.4607214629650116,
-0.22358955442905426,
-0.2290356308221817,
-0.19371473789215088,
-0.19611907005310059,
-0.40702590346336365,
0.07207871973514557,
-0.002999271033331752,
0.24367430806159973,
0.028894944116473198,
0.026697849854826927,
0.08870680630207062,
-0.2568463087081909,
-0.18499596416950226,
0.43919292092323303,
0.42033934593200684,
0.978813648223877,
-0.0318123959004879,
0.3485312759876251,
0.19221220910549164,
-0.300769180059433,
-0.14901362359523773,
0.6572741270065308,
0.2844274938106537,
0.12032172828912735,
0.46625277400016785,
0.4669622778892517,
0.22825832664966583,
-0.519106924533844,
0.40184956789016724,
0.05674443021416664,
0.1533850133419037,
0.10429877787828445,
-0.32185694575309753,
-0.2119452953338623,
0.5899531245231628,
0.6373539566993713,
-0.11449406296014786,
-0.06887689977884293,
-0.35317403078079224,
0.2635529637336731,
0.1834188848733902,
-0.2390289157629013,
-0.37448444962501526,
0.6927322745323181,
0.3372468054294586,
-0.48928195238113403,
0.6231571435928345,
-0.3411649763584137,
-0.4909544587135315,
0.8038559556007385,
0.1987043172121048,
0.9365183115005493,
-0.48595622181892395,
0.34893521666526794,
0.41136544942855835,
0.1349940448999405,
0.06449110060930252,
0.42476314306259155,
-0.5627409219741821,
-0.24485455453395844,
-0.6419904232025146,
-0.3429828882217407,
-0.5980117917060852,
-0.0749170258641243,
-0.6929975748062134,
0.22355976700782776,
-0.21573641896247864,
-0.37267693877220154,
-0.21036095917224884,
0.0974179357290268,
-0.8312037587165833,
-0.09582709521055222,
0.08706504106521606,
0.6013085246086121,
-0.7560838460922241,
0.6253887414932251,
0.9222632050514221,
-0.4807998239994049,
-0.5885631442070007,
0.05799730122089386,
-0.05561436340212822,
-0.6682599782943726,
0.8470004796981812,
0.1382058560848236,
0.13203857839107513,
0.0531066432595253,
-0.5900164842605591,
-0.5489869713783264,
0.9389458894729614,
0.6683580279350281,
-0.45090001821517944,
-0.16162216663360596,
-0.09064839780330658,
0.2860323488712311,
-0.1221734881401062,
-0.00824936106801033,
0.0028997575864195824,
0.5266032218933105,
0.15615473687648773,
-0.9599283337593079,
0.07655347883701324,
-0.12691240012645721,
-0.22457805275917053,
0.13583989441394806,
-0.4140293598175049,
0.7433017492294312,
-0.26938968896865845,
-0.6321455240249634,
-0.05576770380139351,
0.7006954550743103,
0.745801568031311,
0.87200528383255,
0.66201251745224,
0.08455970883369446,
0.7624882459640503,
-0.17413035035133362,
0.970000147819519,
-0.37700194120407104,
0.06996942311525345,
1.4605298042297363,
-0.18542544543743134,
0.3252514898777008,
0.5835192203521729,
0.057896360754966736,
0.3513387441635132,
0.8667283654212952,
0.10446058958768845,
0.6025581359863281,
-0.0730915367603302,
-0.10628824681043625,
-0.4794656038284302,
-0.5293444991111755,
-0.2817118763923645,
-0.031206322833895683,
0.34340140223503113,
-0.1137135773897171,
-0.49102655053138733,
0.3366606831550598,
-0.04554097726941109,
0.06827285885810852,
-0.48460012674331665,
0.6792736649513245,
0.15195946395397186,
-0.7639275193214417,
-0.05552007257938385,
-0.31435632705688477,
0.4864319860935211,
-0.4779515564441681,
-0.11116403341293335,
-0.14147847890853882,
-0.23332588374614716,
0.008747964166104794,
-0.6683035492897034,
0.19716575741767883,
0.2757181227207184,
-0.31004780530929565,
-0.4700116813182831,
0.6940218806266785,
-0.3818696439266205,
-0.12027265131473541,
-0.12917408347129822,
1.0005097389221191,
0.02610621601343155,
-0.2400512993335724,
-0.7090217471122742,
-0.28964969515800476,
-0.45638594031333923,
-0.4296303987503052,
0.08882731944322586,
0.9443328976631165,
0.04557523876428604,
0.5086585879325867,
0.5275078415870667,
0.14620746672153473,
-0.23511768877506256,
0.2999638617038727,
0.7460917830467224,
-0.6461216807365417,
-0.5643284320831299,
-0.9305888414382935,
0.5114954113960266,
-0.2843035161495209,
-0.3343595564365387,
0.5650613307952881,
0.42146003246307373,
0.4177265167236328,
-0.04468437656760216,
0.49099037051200867,
0.02475552074611187,
0.8618528842926025,
-0.40000754594802856,
0.24610896408557892,
-0.3741081953048706,
0.07851307839155197,
-0.161434605717659,
-0.686795711517334,
-0.3584511876106262,
-0.1287647783756256,
-0.31962189078330994,
-0.04058011993765831,
0.7274495363235474,
0.4158135950565338,
-0.03125865012407303,
-0.10622136294841766,
0.01938760094344616,
-0.36578822135925293,
0.12213264405727386,
0.5497065782546997,
1.201384425163269,
0.3099658787250519,
0.8227956295013428,
-0.2913425862789154,
-0.1999770700931549,
0.12024339288473129,
-1.1825324296951294,
-1.0154222249984741,
-0.9774219393730164,
-0.37645235657691956,
-0.04860331490635872,
0.2134968787431717,
1.235506296157837,
0.6386619210243225,
-0.6561988592147827,
-0.04547807201743126,
0.1988874077796936,
0.2085191011428833,
-0.23214441537857056,
-0.24652664363384247,
0.5673025250434875,
-0.7257853150367737,
-0.812150239944458,
0.3443591296672821,
0.11828635632991791,
0.03525558486580849,
0.29761722683906555,
0.287104994058609,
-0.07585998624563217,
-0.43973812460899353,
0.44357091188430786,
0.5088051557540894,
-0.537315845489502,
-0.06363075226545334,
-0.00920928455889225,
-0.08936397731304169,
-0.12910524010658264,
1.1843520402908325,
-0.9731442928314209,
0.2878285348415375,
0.5698456764221191,
0.4964713752269745,
0.594632625579834,
0.12254805117845535,
0.5463265180587769,
-1.2709476947784424,
0.34066468477249146,
0.4227680563926697,
0.3648216128349304,
0.247949481010437,
-0.3218730092048645,
0.5556524395942688,
0.3621771037578583,
-0.47960150241851807,
-0.8691831231117249,
0.3555608093738556,
-0.9993268847465515,
-0.561713695526123,
1.3246053457260132,
-0.02002589963376522,
-0.012448238208889961,
-0.40154483914375305,
-0.1809653639793396,
0.8184711337089539,
-0.5353055596351624,
0.89727783203125,
0.32225316762924194,
-0.10282275825738907,
-0.4693143367767334,
-0.3066725432872772,
0.5661506056785583,
0.01571502909064293,
-0.8359082341194153,
0.26941347122192383,
0.7237861156463623,
0.21465624868869781,
0.16150256991386414,
0.5295276045799255,
-0.026475848630070686,
0.4938099682331085,
-0.3859807848930359,
0.012968730181455612,
-0.8535465002059937,
-0.3081327974796295,
-0.24746008217334747,
0.5689941048622131,
-0.19532223045825958,
-0.40240246057510376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15518v1 | Steering Without Side Effects: Improving Post-Deployment Control of Language Models | 2024-06-21T01:37:39 | 2024-06-21T01:37:39 | Asa Cooper Stickland, Alexander Lyzhov, Jacob Pfau, Salsabila Mahdi, Samuel R. Bowman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) have been shown to behave unexpectedly post-deployment.
For example, new jailbreaks continually arise, allowing model misuse, despite
extensive red-teaming and adversarial training from developers. Given most
model queries are unproblematic and frequent retraining results in unstable
user experience, methods for mitigation of worst-case behavior should be
targeted. One such method is classifying inputs as potentially problematic,
then selectively applying steering vectors on these problematic inputs, i.e.
adding particular vectors to model hidden states. However, steering vectors can
also negatively affect model performance, which will be an issue on cases where
the classifier was incorrect. We present KL-then-steer (KTS), a technique that
decreases the side effects of steering while retaining its benefits, by first
training a model to minimize Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between a steered
and unsteered model on benign inputs, then steering the model that has
undergone this training. Our best method prevents 44% of jailbreak attacks
compared to the original Llama-2-chat-7B model while maintaining helpfulness
(as measured by MT-Bench) on benign requests almost on par with the original
LM. To demonstrate the generality and transferability of our method beyond
jailbreaks, we show that our KTS model can be steered to reduce bias towards
user-suggested answers on TruthfulQA. Code is available:
https://github.com/AsaCooperStickland/kl-then-steer. | [
-0.5308642387390137,
-0.5779099464416504,
0.3876718580722809,
0.19340188801288605,
-0.3327137231826782,
0.25116708874702454,
-0.30857527256011963,
-0.19647979736328125,
0.14475734531879425,
0.7470179796218872,
-0.40880998969078064,
-0.44654831290245056,
-0.6678093075752258,
-0.4752393662929535,
-0.5765706896781921,
1.5123555660247803,
0.17805999517440796,
-0.1111607626080513,
-0.14352543652057648,
-0.2736465632915497,
-0.5488101243972778,
-0.4587143659591675,
-0.5289466977119446,
-0.38624563813209534,
0.6309515833854675,
0.39604777097702026,
1.1097773313522339,
0.3827669620513916,
0.3600875735282898,
0.19151754677295685,
-0.3412865996360779,
-0.20038658380508423,
-0.4633493721485138,
0.17944367229938507,
-0.24274247884750366,
-0.5383594036102295,
-0.3115452527999878,
-0.06001366674900055,
0.23245809972286224,
0.5829971432685852,
-0.401137113571167,
-0.24209211766719818,
0.021681105718016624,
0.7277734279632568,
-0.8390719294548035,
-0.13473623991012573,
-0.4199135899543762,
-0.218768909573555,
-0.2100079357624054,
-0.05314956605434418,
-0.6326242685317993,
-0.4401606023311615,
0.2345784604549408,
-0.5943171381950378,
-0.10339200496673584,
-0.11974979937076569,
0.6610427498817444,
0.3206266462802887,
-0.5668337345123291,
-0.35934117436408997,
-0.7666878700256348,
0.8316035270690918,
-0.677682638168335,
0.7596850991249084,
0.5927343964576721,
0.348241925239563,
-0.3844444155693054,
-0.3335905075073242,
-0.3387395441532135,
-0.686055600643158,
0.04011758789420128,
-0.028374165296554565,
-0.29661914706230164,
0.03905545920133591,
-0.07974211871623993,
-0.22537998855113983,
-0.5260217785835266,
0.5094689130783081,
-0.43320146203041077,
-0.5062580704689026,
0.5559327602386475,
-0.09151434153318405,
0.18792295455932617,
0.07683783024549484,
-0.11496856808662415,
-0.2281958907842636,
-1.1856783628463745,
0.15087664127349854,
0.3864423632621765,
0.26396170258522034,
-0.2501240074634552,
0.7424235939979553,
-0.3283163011074066,
0.4068286418914795,
0.35117053985595703,
0.01553323119878769,
0.2998335659503937,
-0.12833940982818604,
0.04769151657819748,
-0.09505124390125275,
0.5557376146316528,
0.6100836992263794,
0.287712961435318,
-0.13937029242515564,
-0.2485649734735489,
0.23481865227222443,
0.3852052390575409,
-0.543839156627655,
-0.44748014211654663,
0.29173991084098816,
-0.3806096315383911,
-0.6078025698661804,
-0.33925753831863403,
-0.48236963152885437,
-0.7680348753929138,
-0.024515047669410706,
0.1992315798997879,
-0.4851766526699066,
-0.48036500811576843,
-0.0493498221039772,
0.05625314638018608,
0.2803788185119629,
0.16418884694576263,
-0.8275783061981201,
0.23270151019096375,
0.7309954762458801,
0.5791555047035217,
-0.17530420422554016,
0.014266733080148697,
-0.7756083011627197,
0.023981014266610146,
-0.5092552304267883,
0.634158194065094,
-0.29485955834388733,
-0.652972936630249,
0.06677592545747757,
-0.19800402224063873,
0.16636383533477783,
-0.5913729071617126,
0.5565323829650879,
-0.7803886532783508,
0.23174002766609192,
-0.10020765662193298,
-0.5844194889068604,
-0.07899518311023712,
0.20319180190563202,
-0.38636302947998047,
0.7539543509483337,
-0.1476713865995407,
-0.6528300642967224,
0.2759265601634979,
-0.4863531291484833,
-0.6497283577919006,
-0.1897640973329544,
-0.1767638772726059,
-0.5783287286758423,
0.1602616310119629,
0.20675650238990784,
0.3316381871700287,
0.10202595591545105,
0.4857783913612366,
-0.30449575185775757,
-0.09645619243383408,
0.08547888696193695,
0.0759335607290268,
0.7917091846466064,
0.2800952196121216,
-0.3001238703727722,
0.3338128924369812,
-0.5477409958839417,
0.09188975393772125,
-0.010233576409518719,
-0.37382248044013977,
-0.7275609970092773,
0.2573389708995819,
-0.1831682175397873,
0.2806953489780426,
-0.035721343010663986,
-0.509796142578125,
0.14770552515983582,
-0.5459591150283813,
0.12746916711330414,
0.7252256870269775,
-0.16499942541122437,
0.9129815101623535,
-0.20292797684669495,
0.6891359686851501,
0.11977506428956985,
0.3330972492694855,
0.0893276259303093,
-0.573708176612854,
-0.8536399602890015,
0.2174631506204605,
0.08467677980661392,
0.6418529748916626,
-1.1403238773345947,
0.29874956607818604,
-0.08454875648021698,
-0.7462628483772278,
-0.373506635427475,
0.18019108474254608,
0.6984978318214417,
0.4463876187801361,
0.28658172488212585,
-0.21506761014461517,
-0.392350435256958,
-0.8448950052261353,
-0.3274005353450775,
-0.5300676226615906,
0.0025919084437191486,
0.13866417109966278,
0.15695495903491974,
-0.22480812668800354,
0.8407596349716187,
-0.3741894066333771,
0.05460819602012634,
-0.3931628465652466,
0.08201292902231216,
-0.054819099605083466,
0.6107873916625977,
0.5759791731834412,
-0.777035653591156,
-0.3288951516151428,
0.04912477731704712,
-0.39345818758010864,
-0.5433092713356018,
-0.007955975830554962,
-0.18042829632759094,
0.4260457158088684,
0.5208963751792908,
-0.789194643497467,
0.3777526915073395,
0.5048009753227234,
-0.46932703256607056,
0.5781247615814209,
-0.19156137108802795,
-0.21199095249176025,
-0.625144362449646,
-0.12107348442077637,
-0.1253761500120163,
-0.20537236332893372,
-0.748595654964447,
0.20027993619441986,
0.4117280840873718,
0.13736532628536224,
-0.526931643486023,
0.42261719703674316,
-0.09375353157520294,
0.18555815517902374,
-0.4065556824207306,
0.0659184530377388,
-0.0646343007683754,
0.3015480637550354,
0.04732172563672066,
0.5709443688392639,
0.5511683225631714,
-0.6913341879844666,
0.12908510863780975,
0.18055902421474457,
-0.0648333728313446,
0.6604466438293457,
-0.6111193299293518,
0.13470646739006042,
-0.3780592679977417,
0.04432054981589317,
-0.8254387378692627,
0.2559349238872528,
0.413841187953949,
-0.46753939986228943,
0.3067191243171692,
-0.20320948958396912,
0.11589889973402023,
-0.21339555084705353,
-0.514545202255249,
-0.0008586634648963809,
0.6638333201408386,
-0.4649753272533417,
0.33594605326652527,
0.41521719098091125,
-0.3099788725376129,
-0.41071951389312744,
-0.49648797512054443,
-0.09387627243995667,
-0.35135409235954285,
-0.26731157302856445,
0.3054211139678955,
-0.25570806860923767,
-0.19602513313293457,
-0.06441428512334824,
-0.0861256867647171,
-0.19163459539413452,
0.2983340322971344,
0.14600734412670135,
0.2760024666786194,
-0.018966397270560265,
0.09821633994579315,
0.40889567136764526,
-0.4305957853794098,
0.01962631195783615,
-0.23701389133930206,
0.37290534377098083,
0.01833173632621765,
-0.22177660465240479,
-0.25636932253837585,
0.35108208656311035,
0.590316116809845,
-0.3829048275947571,
0.7292084693908691,
0.426553338766098,
0.05510465428233147,
-0.038340598344802856,
-0.5684331059455872,
-0.26031333208084106,
-0.4898853302001953,
0.5290711522102356,
-0.10399623215198517,
-0.9518317580223083,
0.26378965377807617,
0.08152909576892853,
0.21904318034648895,
0.056162185966968536,
0.5059835910797119,
-0.4142799377441406,
1.1208000183105469,
1.0416321754455566,
-0.3811982274055481,
0.7078869342803955,
-0.042713653296232224,
0.3699339032173157,
-0.4643140435218811,
-0.24399451911449432,
-0.39806798100471497,
-0.007962779141962528,
-0.7263785004615784,
-0.09255214780569077,
0.3256065845489502,
0.2807428538799286,
-0.16251926124095917,
0.36699357628822327,
-0.24341128766536713,
0.3085952699184418,
0.57188481092453,
0.031204747036099434,
0.16579338908195496,
-0.2737538516521454,
-0.1493891179561615,
-0.005559108220040798,
-0.6957415342330933,
-0.16361847519874573,
1.123155951499939,
0.33912646770477295,
0.875758945941925,
0.2307729721069336,
0.7956193685531616,
0.25859835743904114,
0.5768523216247559,
-0.676678478717804,
0.5547979474067688,
-0.06476106494665146,
-0.4207354784011841,
-0.06074119359254837,
-0.42972370982170105,
-0.766643226146698,
0.2495473027229309,
-0.1638287603855133,
-0.7261534333229065,
0.05315078794956207,
0.4726490080356598,
-0.5167127847671509,
0.01678675413131714,
-0.8420842885971069,
0.7954127192497253,
-0.4002379775047302,
-0.277664452791214,
-0.32254210114479065,
-0.7526354789733887,
0.3169940114021301,
-0.13935153186321259,
0.35884541273117065,
-0.05422988533973694,
-0.01491641253232956,
0.6324915885925293,
-0.6413741111755371,
0.7558020353317261,
-0.517379105091095,
-0.19208529591560364,
0.19597740471363068,
0.42340224981307983,
0.7480512261390686,
-0.314322292804718,
0.20895430445671082,
-0.10130591690540314,
0.003069110680371523,
-0.15997548401355743,
-0.7391069531440735,
0.7028274536132812,
-0.6183199882507324,
-0.6974520683288574,
-0.022156165912747383,
-0.5089051723480225,
-0.12376084923744202,
0.2459671050310135,
0.20573927462100983,
0.11031389981508255,
0.10496265441179276,
0.16144880652427673,
0.40533673763275146,
-0.3662799000740051,
0.46227627992630005,
0.7677152156829834,
-0.7554845809936523,
-0.19158115983009338,
0.7806241512298584,
0.12163197249174118,
0.5224654674530029,
0.03128163143992424,
0.4143913984298706,
-0.4991514980792999,
-0.8624184131622314,
-0.4295061230659485,
0.0017391963629052043,
-0.45738500356674194,
-0.2718575894832611,
-0.32173070311546326,
-0.13657146692276,
-0.2560046315193176,
-0.0982365682721138,
-0.770954966545105,
-0.4827646315097809,
0.04698562249541283,
-0.26554256677627563,
0.5128381252288818,
0.608815610408783,
-0.0045371041633188725,
0.8111169934272766,
-0.5959128737449646,
0.07678374648094177,
-0.16571389138698578,
0.4730739891529083,
-0.2582987844944,
-0.5059393048286438,
-0.28460782766342163,
0.1431269645690918,
-0.49230146408081055,
-0.8038726449012756,
0.39780911803245544,
0.1651766002178192,
0.5624068975448608,
0.3666246831417084,
0.2335042506456375,
0.40120822191238403,
-0.42126554250717163,
0.4718010425567627,
0.15978524088859558,
-0.8048051595687866,
0.6584575176239014,
-0.3502717614173889,
0.376533180475235,
0.40098369121551514,
0.45917263627052307,
-0.5930385589599609,
-0.8488729000091553,
-0.4210149943828583,
-0.7461239695549011,
0.4435584247112274,
0.33460474014282227,
0.1429109424352646,
0.034535810351371765,
0.28414440155029297,
-0.05122074857354164,
0.29512056708335876,
-0.6807532906532288,
-0.3061705529689789,
-0.20375631749629974,
-0.051299165934324265,
-0.039066068828105927,
-0.4403647184371948,
0.26467782258987427,
-0.1651415377855301,
0.8086117506027222,
0.14973235130310059,
-0.23040200769901276,
-0.22179394960403442,
-0.29764243960380554,
0.1047327071428299,
0.3370400667190552,
0.619075357913971,
0.3344303071498871,
-0.0777529701590538,
0.3166539967060089,
-0.01536460593342781,
-0.39699751138687134,
0.36001816391944885,
0.022352561354637146,
-0.5917404294013977,
-0.1614772528409958,
0.08244714885950089,
0.5528212189674377,
0.1862216740846634,
-0.6194592714309692,
0.5985782742500305,
0.10444385558366776,
0.16357716917991638,
-0.010633681900799274,
0.12238749861717224,
0.13350647687911987,
0.3086225390434265,
-0.0857381671667099,
0.22707101702690125,
0.019647318869829178,
-0.0782947689294815,
0.23131130635738373,
0.37369588017463684,
-0.3903059661388397,
-0.41301625967025757,
0.6330639719963074,
0.30369022488594055,
-0.45354363322257996,
0.5702739953994751,
-0.3126092255115509,
-0.5051647424697876,
0.3633441627025604,
0.5542797446250916,
0.7004961371421814,
-0.6458991169929504,
0.42558321356773376,
-0.059067219495773315,
0.4125191867351532,
-0.03205092251300812,
0.2838080823421478,
-0.08569172769784927,
-1.0332462787628174,
-0.3460836410522461,
-0.21375271677970886,
-0.23744288086891174,
-0.05796686187386513,
-0.8589267730712891,
0.10618479549884796,
-0.5753211379051208,
-0.38331449031829834,
-0.20551325380802155,
-0.4344586431980133,
-0.38806694746017456,
0.04717368260025978,
0.08360335230827332,
0.851893961429596,
-0.9608052968978882,
1.0441511869430542,
0.593556821346283,
-0.23878759145736694,
-0.478074312210083,
-0.3277699053287506,
0.17876510322093964,
-0.627579391002655,
0.38288819789886475,
0.00019301222346257418,
-0.21628841757774353,
-0.15114781260490417,
-0.46866339445114136,
-0.8535321354866028,
0.5566992163658142,
0.3663681745529175,
-0.7567345499992371,
0.2979729473590851,
0.05552709102630615,
0.4250262379646301,
0.058607492595911026,
0.10244888812303543,
0.7640997767448425,
0.11824295669794083,
-0.1054355800151825,
-1.059836506843567,
-0.08976487815380096,
-0.2316581904888153,
0.04387681186199188,
0.33674952387809753,
-0.24359308183193207,
0.500149667263031,
-0.511642575263977,
-0.038057003170251846,
0.14872704446315765,
0.4299669563770294,
0.4432484805583954,
0.11866792291402817,
0.7508223652839661,
0.3685317635536194,
0.7379505634307861,
0.07682148367166519,
1.1332314014434814,
-0.249863401055336,
0.2566405236721039,
1.2266452312469482,
-0.30128714442253113,
0.9893175959587097,
0.905167281627655,
-0.05038617551326752,
0.3606688380241394,
0.36406782269477844,
0.5104990005493164,
1.1463385820388794,
0.32759013772010803,
-0.1666480004787445,
-0.14708612859249115,
-0.28030842542648315,
-0.4465728998184204,
0.42530375719070435,
0.16722393035888672,
-0.0717044398188591,
-0.36456558108329773,
0.44187772274017334,
0.44665101170539856,
0.167196124792099,
-0.2649506628513336,
0.6400437951087952,
0.1446274071931839,
-0.6210876703262329,
0.631269097328186,
0.233785480260849,
0.8274438381195068,
-0.6235501766204834,
0.19357194006443024,
-0.4634057581424713,
0.28881680965423584,
-0.12264908105134964,
-0.8233121633529663,
0.5769252777099609,
0.032124489545822144,
-0.18071608245372772,
-0.21310728788375854,
0.7239764332771301,
-0.43546047806739807,
-0.39899495244026184,
0.5276051759719849,
0.5445910096168518,
0.07820814847946167,
-0.04159674420952797,
-0.5256557464599609,
0.23533163964748383,
0.07031969726085663,
-0.3188592791557312,
0.22379948198795319,
-0.12718860805034637,
-0.4848771393299103,
1.0675803422927856,
0.5413638949394226,
0.005151547957211733,
0.18706302344799042,
0.24676059186458588,
1.0897459983825684,
-0.5062737464904785,
-0.7154276371002197,
-0.8668254613876343,
0.6219862699508667,
0.21483543515205383,
-0.21668867766857147,
0.7010595798492432,
0.37057915329933167,
0.9068936705589294,
0.08231443166732788,
0.721981406211853,
-0.07080752402544022,
0.4119177460670471,
-0.43568840622901917,
0.9915944337844849,
-0.2696506381034851,
0.48887431621551514,
-0.2381594330072403,
-0.45842814445495605,
-0.5211437940597534,
0.6912897825241089,
-0.6540956497192383,
0.014273349195718765,
0.32477036118507385,
0.9602675437927246,
0.042149949818849564,
-0.033308807760477066,
0.3120726943016052,
0.3427130877971649,
0.5120828747749329,
0.536993682384491,
1.1856670379638672,
-0.11021870374679565,
0.6112393140792847,
-0.5992143750190735,
-0.16184943914413452,
-0.0817825123667717,
-0.9180711507797241,
-0.737529456615448,
-0.18137341737747192,
-0.3381121754646301,
-0.3356558382511139,
0.3396914005279541,
0.736872136592865,
0.8411791920661926,
-0.9532160758972168,
-0.3099847435951233,
-0.149431973695755,
0.3556145131587982,
0.0338858999311924,
-0.15335631370544434,
0.1479535549879074,
-0.20493660867214203,
-0.1051994264125824,
0.5713910460472107,
0.004563815426081419,
0.022236835211515427,
-0.15630531311035156,
-0.414926141500473,
-0.028074095025658607,
-0.3254236578941345,
0.6273880004882812,
0.30646535754203796,
-0.6508497595787048,
-0.5401449203491211,
-0.06226780265569687,
0.005906614940613508,
0.04539337009191513,
0.6075319051742554,
-0.8378069400787354,
0.44912704825401306,
0.10956283658742905,
0.6415033340454102,
0.3587934374809265,
-0.20759116113185883,
0.8163647055625916,
-0.7721952199935913,
0.4603496193885803,
0.15102927386760712,
0.15860849618911743,
0.2928771376609802,
-0.3188419044017792,
0.07310688495635986,
-0.0887109786272049,
-0.2335035353899002,
-0.714651882648468,
0.31512686610221863,
-0.49183595180511475,
-0.11935287714004517,
0.908316969871521,
-0.16471588611602783,
0.012766784057021141,
-0.20115748047828674,
-0.34290727972984314,
0.12205008417367935,
-0.4278509318828583,
0.724481463432312,
0.43103814125061035,
-0.0539882555603981,
-0.3093012273311615,
-0.5446740388870239,
0.48932138085365295,
0.8353058695793152,
-0.5804845690727234,
0.07794760912656784,
0.41282007098197937,
0.4392508268356323,
-0.10205141454935074,
0.6265291571617126,
-0.014187023043632507,
0.2800002694129944,
-0.3498428761959076,
0.10585469007492065,
-0.05868403986096382,
-0.5402862429618835,
-0.5507653951644897,
-0.13332755863666534,
0.366138756275177,
-0.3864902853965759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14805v1 | How Well Do LLMs Represent Values Across Cultures? Empirical Analysis of LLM Responses Based on Hofstede Cultural Dimensions | 2024-06-21T00:58:01 | 2024-06-21T00:58:01 | Julia Kharchenko, Tanya Roosta, Aman Chadha, Chirag Shah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) attempt to imitate human behavior by responding
to humans in a way that pleases them, including by adhering to their values.
However, humans come from diverse cultures with different values. It is
critical to understand whether LLMs showcase different values to the user based
on the stereotypical values of a user's known country. We prompt different LLMs
with a series of advice requests based on 5 Hofstede Cultural Dimensions -- a
quantifiable way of representing the values of a country. Throughout each
prompt, we incorporate personas representing 36 different countries and,
separately, languages predominantly tied to each country to analyze the
consistency in the LLMs' cultural understanding. Through our analysis of the
responses, we found that LLMs can differentiate between one side of a value and
another, as well as understand that countries have differing values, but will
not always uphold the values when giving advice, and fail to understand the
need to answer differently based on different cultural values. Rooted in these
findings, we present recommendations for training value-aligned and culturally
sensitive LLMs. More importantly, the methodology and the framework developed
here can help further understand and mitigate culture and language alignment
issues with LLMs. | [
-0.24084073305130005,
-0.5290921330451965,
0.4794010818004608,
0.5466896891593933,
-0.34075963497161865,
0.3532068729400635,
-0.21695172786712646,
-0.6952508687973022,
0.4267139732837677,
0.4213167726993561,
-0.49872222542762756,
-0.46532028913497925,
-0.6373125910758972,
0.10474971681833267,
0.07063500583171844,
0.8613324761390686,
-0.049665436148643494,
0.41946396231651306,
-0.444355845451355,
-0.5841434597969055,
-0.23936066031455994,
-0.7908924221992493,
-0.33748748898506165,
-0.33479776978492737,
0.5427300333976746,
0.6043253540992737,
0.581626296043396,
0.38961261510849,
0.670741081237793,
0.1100764274597168,
-0.3447154462337494,
0.062393657863140106,
-0.608416736125946,
0.14367356896400452,
-0.04971791431307793,
-0.07284152507781982,
-0.5931599736213684,
0.2550850212574005,
0.3208768367767334,
0.8249059915542603,
0.04634924978017807,
0.5345268249511719,
0.12173980474472046,
0.6627318263053894,
-0.41800156235694885,
0.10354156792163849,
-0.17708145081996918,
0.25437840819358826,
-0.041179608553647995,
-0.03668316826224327,
-0.16960342228412628,
-0.6178046464920044,
0.30217209458351135,
-0.36991095542907715,
-0.288027286529541,
-0.12052895128726959,
0.7073270082473755,
-0.05201948434114456,
-0.8620085716247559,
-0.4634703993797302,
-0.8566831946372986,
0.7152133584022522,
-0.42640671133995056,
0.23080818355083466,
0.3199739456176758,
0.16486752033233643,
-0.19188320636749268,
-0.12574470043182373,
-0.1631566733121872,
-0.14089356362819672,
-0.0010383727494627237,
0.18555855751037598,
0.1358007937669754,
-0.33284032344818115,
0.39203086495399475,
0.4096681773662567,
-0.46462905406951904,
0.3204392194747925,
-0.21657277643680573,
-0.3244149684906006,
0.816533625125885,
0.2306903898715973,
0.25154149532318115,
0.15416491031646729,
-0.49877315759658813,
-0.14534395933151245,
-1.0000852346420288,
0.6703866124153137,
0.5222555994987488,
0.18137069046497345,
-0.18064133822917938,
0.4671293795108795,
-0.2341652810573578,
0.33448565006256104,
0.14023523032665253,
-0.655975878238678,
0.07097470015287399,
-0.0446913056075573,
0.14361852407455444,
0.0355241559445858,
0.5637758374214172,
0.8164902925491333,
0.8371927738189697,
-0.10875346511602402,
-0.20707851648330688,
-0.23661139607429504,
0.031513914465904236,
-1.0040411949157715,
0.27837762236595154,
0.03645365312695503,
-0.7712557315826416,
-0.24892936646938324,
-0.0008239082526415586,
-0.6368611454963684,
-0.6063810586929321,
-0.21072223782539368,
0.10805211216211319,
-0.11611896753311157,
-0.372977077960968,
-0.07833053171634674,
-0.06955388188362122,
0.7124784588813782,
0.07966582477092743,
-1.1104190349578857,
0.3402937650680542,
0.3689524829387665,
0.6887840628623962,
-0.38766664266586304,
-0.15778475999832153,
-0.3129883110523224,
-0.09522654116153717,
-0.27798178791999817,
0.7375743985176086,
-0.6071200966835022,
-0.7446918487548828,
0.1625499278306961,
-0.07556498795747757,
0.4217962622642517,
-0.5856125354766846,
0.2756536900997162,
-0.683232843875885,
0.10758932679891586,
-1.0731287002563477,
-0.37307116389274597,
0.015025479719042778,
0.4751212000846863,
-0.5228585600852966,
0.8883953094482422,
0.2021709680557251,
-0.5891156196594238,
0.4821712374687195,
-0.4313952922821045,
-0.5342809557914734,
0.16883081197738647,
-0.2093890756368637,
-0.10579115152359009,
0.15946237742900848,
0.13470527529716492,
0.49640563130378723,
-0.3668597638607025,
0.04082633927464485,
-0.4749930202960968,
-0.4790881276130676,
0.4571900963783264,
-0.5578484535217285,
0.8728115558624268,
0.31154367327690125,
-0.12151230126619339,
0.13463155925273895,
-0.6251798272132874,
0.01656200736761093,
0.28158941864967346,
-0.5145371556282043,
-0.2999463677406311,
-0.05555278807878494,
0.02523362636566162,
0.4753175973892212,
0.409526526927948,
-0.46393728256225586,
0.24733982980251312,
-0.17419305443763733,
0.4336026906967163,
0.7108790874481201,
-0.028352197259664536,
0.49292099475860596,
-0.4171529710292816,
0.7267963886260986,
0.21268507838249207,
0.05840316787362099,
0.06580733507871628,
-0.3178023099899292,
-0.30318012833595276,
-0.0939815416932106,
-0.1636923998594284,
0.6271534562110901,
-0.19171178340911865,
0.053574029356241226,
-0.34453725814819336,
-0.4579598605632782,
-0.46823418140411377,
0.2333301454782486,
0.12252295017242432,
0.3042772710323334,
0.08957024663686752,
-0.3486540913581848,
-0.32020822167396545,
-1.0599690675735474,
-0.37721237540245056,
-0.48966073989868164,
-0.13526998460292816,
0.07713281363248825,
0.5849716067314148,
-0.045056458562612534,
1.0345168113708496,
-0.23633547127246857,
-0.004580345004796982,
-0.06341032683849335,
-0.046554889529943466,
-0.03718371316790581,
-0.00022924863151274621,
0.5118441581726074,
-0.6131959557533264,
-0.6959621906280518,
0.036210253834724426,
-0.6975502967834473,
-0.2917342782020569,
0.1644301861524582,
-0.08556300401687622,
0.3883918821811676,
0.24755632877349854,
-0.020464139059185982,
0.2039712816476822,
0.7027471661567688,
-0.24119813740253448,
0.41906365752220154,
-0.20073074102401733,
0.275455504655838,
-1.1099765300750732,
-0.0016987253911793232,
0.07629939168691635,
-0.05680755153298378,
-0.45583316683769226,
-0.334951788187027,
0.10108979046344757,
0.0643046647310257,
-0.4225294888019562,
0.7601318359375,
-0.36367031931877136,
-0.26226624846458435,
-0.2700771689414978,
0.027052361518144608,
-0.010157625190913677,
0.24664773046970367,
0.35123246908187866,
0.897585391998291,
0.28494107723236084,
-0.40274330973625183,
0.5581796169281006,
0.28545400500297546,
-0.45240160822868347,
1.3793354034423828,
-0.6058991551399231,
0.176197350025177,
-0.13302679359912872,
0.2333502322435379,
-0.830598771572113,
-0.1763741374015808,
0.16113561391830444,
-0.23949722945690155,
-0.1643170267343521,
-0.20861053466796875,
-0.3424285650253296,
-0.18356288969516754,
-0.18779170513153076,
0.3329187333583832,
0.6293305158615112,
-0.5310808420181274,
0.5937137007713318,
0.601765513420105,
-0.14320923388004303,
-0.6520184278488159,
-0.47604990005493164,
0.0820356234908104,
-0.7443313598632812,
-0.6980193853378296,
0.15014095604419708,
-0.3811904191970825,
-0.7222067713737488,
-0.20691044628620148,
-0.23788413405418396,
-0.024671774357557297,
0.26669785380363464,
0.28445056080818176,
0.013768017292022705,
-0.23092462122440338,
0.046676743775606155,
-0.2659357786178589,
0.021289387717843056,
0.463967889547348,
-0.2883484363555908,
0.3647409975528717,
-0.5422574877738953,
-0.4814409613609314,
-0.06524253636598587,
0.43187224864959717,
0.8035503029823303,
-0.25112077593803406,
0.9289833307266235,
0.6563538908958435,
-0.3111588656902313,
0.18531276285648346,
-0.5593770146369934,
-0.10309769213199615,
-0.42909833788871765,
0.05908285453915596,
-0.4698886573314667,
-0.9468566179275513,
0.9476272463798523,
0.039250366389751434,
0.07845842838287354,
0.29602956771850586,
0.778434157371521,
-0.6845293045043945,
0.9854477047920227,
0.7206335663795471,
-0.19760571420192719,
0.21349333226680756,
-0.022843021899461746,
0.2187833935022354,
-0.6007444858551025,
-0.4924999475479126,
-0.31137537956237793,
-0.5361781716346741,
-0.8945263624191284,
0.01287434995174408,
0.3930293917655945,
-0.03729061782360077,
-0.37149903178215027,
-0.21989811956882477,
-0.06324437260627747,
0.6088895201683044,
0.35488361120224,
-0.21414241194725037,
0.2060704529285431,
0.15404072403907776,
-0.06743025779724121,
-0.11087305098772049,
-0.5990442633628845,
-0.9498894810676575,
0.6802112460136414,
0.5579794049263,
1.1151399612426758,
0.224552720785141,
0.5319474339485168,
0.05768689885735512,
0.4417107403278351,
-1.0852638483047485,
0.4423583447933197,
-0.010143665596842766,
-0.42851728200912476,
-0.27680158615112305,
-0.2825120985507965,
-0.7070313692092896,
0.33443787693977356,
-0.1965307742357254,
-0.703574001789093,
0.018386391922831535,
0.07937444001436234,
-0.22592170536518097,
0.23103688657283783,
-0.37822216749191284,
0.7347834706306458,
-0.5774784088134766,
-0.24907077848911285,
0.16163544356822968,
-0.7776559591293335,
0.2780335545539856,
-0.06592904776334763,
0.34959927201271057,
-0.46268919110298157,
0.21035559475421906,
0.7719582915306091,
0.04473745822906494,
1.0973315238952637,
-0.05693451687693596,
-0.6246212720870972,
0.16891726851463318,
0.142950177192688,
0.1531480848789215,
0.12767282128334045,
-0.1162445992231369,
0.2946082353591919,
0.4629395306110382,
-0.6420279145240784,
-0.313377320766449,
0.8159841895103455,
-1.0239354372024536,
-0.7196230888366699,
-0.4528743028640747,
-0.854671835899353,
-0.27050232887268066,
-0.08895064145326614,
0.18209022283554077,
0.18873880803585052,
-0.6606037020683289,
0.17410579323768616,
0.7685157060623169,
-0.15877051651477814,
0.27387484908103943,
0.6014862656593323,
-0.10045715421438217,
-0.2863120436668396,
0.5434964895248413,
0.2576567530632019,
0.4501766264438629,
0.25271937251091003,
0.31754401326179504,
-0.47152313590049744,
-0.1105370745062828,
-0.3304821848869324,
0.2230874001979828,
-1.0932142734527588,
0.13246400654315948,
-0.20814861357212067,
-0.037299513816833496,
-0.5363174080848694,
-0.2790817618370056,
-0.012062333524227142,
-0.03795507922768593,
-0.11731120198965073,
-0.0783790647983551,
0.5379008054733276,
0.8272740244865417,
0.0035216454416513443,
0.4149879515171051,
-1.0612396001815796,
-0.05865071713924408,
0.36724862456321716,
0.4074406027793884,
-0.2621195316314697,
-0.6167570948600769,
-0.30086714029312134,
0.3492269814014435,
-0.08148498088121414,
-1.0033708810806274,
0.2982772886753082,
-0.0970083549618721,
0.8318887948989868,
0.6339715719223022,
0.16548900306224823,
0.756240963935852,
-0.326884388923645,
0.8559724688529968,
-0.2065013200044632,
-0.9132943749427795,
0.31693020462989807,
-0.04865243658423424,
0.4485321640968323,
0.3910101056098938,
0.6591993570327759,
-1.1849370002746582,
-0.28393054008483887,
-0.443920761346817,
-0.5471169352531433,
0.4113629162311554,
-0.19544997811317444,
0.5796071887016296,
-0.08143287152051926,
0.39963722229003906,
0.0757560208439827,
0.1385769098997116,
-0.9477025866508484,
-0.12655840814113617,
-0.14568497240543365,
-0.2560284733772278,
0.12437447160482407,
-0.5438160300254822,
-0.474104106426239,
0.04403914883732796,
0.3825257420539856,
-0.2776963412761688,
0.09429851919412613,
-0.09765119105577469,
-0.3826526403427124,
-0.4936990737915039,
0.38571763038635254,
0.8314201235771179,
0.9766596555709839,
-0.23577778041362762,
0.2993099093437195,
0.5171239972114563,
-0.38627737760543823,
0.37497374415397644,
-0.5603229403495789,
0.25901952385902405,
-0.4815886318683624,
0.5080271363258362,
0.5669707655906677,
-0.29693442583084106,
-0.6274429559707642,
0.42291340231895447,
-0.17022454738616943,
-0.04857772961258888,
-0.37090006470680237,
-0.07706867903470993,
0.28891751170158386,
0.22569608688354492,
0.09744369238615036,
-0.38416019082069397,
-0.3495534062385559,
-0.6547194123268127,
-0.2974190413951874,
0.7298933267593384,
-0.49020916223526,
-0.4163627326488495,
0.43186211585998535,
0.4868447482585907,
-0.47601625323295593,
0.6867722868919373,
0.0882909968495369,
-0.5379617810249329,
0.6345880031585693,
0.5393478274345398,
0.5571197867393494,
-0.23905369639396667,
0.28948432207107544,
0.012014283798635006,
0.3729141354560852,
0.021612411364912987,
0.3672245144844055,
0.12569208443164825,
-1.1233890056610107,
-0.3457127511501312,
-0.7210020422935486,
-0.5570456981658936,
0.09386393427848816,
-0.8924787044525146,
0.025542329996824265,
-0.31483814120292664,
0.030795233324170113,
-0.42660486698150635,
0.1606220006942749,
-0.8178266882896423,
0.23026378452777863,
0.2697106897830963,
0.8417260646820068,
-1.3727508783340454,
0.8369944095611572,
0.9088306427001953,
-0.37163251638412476,
-0.5036554932594299,
0.2258315086364746,
0.2510252296924591,
-0.9824656844139099,
1.0126928091049194,
0.22866156697273254,
-0.5241865515708923,
-0.2920478582382202,
-0.2932751178741455,
-0.7545278072357178,
0.9941999912261963,
0.17213121056556702,
-0.17273519933223724,
0.3645436763763428,
0.5363377928733826,
0.7116053700447083,
-0.7533174753189087,
0.270830899477005,
0.7719665765762329,
0.39011144638061523,
0.2621247470378876,
-0.892629086971283,
-0.16101780533790588,
-0.10825858265161514,
0.24151106178760529,
-0.21665829420089722,
-0.5653390288352966,
0.36652520298957825,
-0.27956733107566833,
-0.03222603723406792,
-0.15354713797569275,
0.6251170635223389,
0.36249738931655884,
0.2474813163280487,
0.5131256580352783,
0.10925618559122086,
0.9251117706298828,
0.04715867340564728,
0.7989944219589233,
-0.4718485474586487,
0.13935372233390808,
0.6882771253585815,
-0.7074616551399231,
0.7522964477539062,
0.5973292589187622,
-0.07965805381536484,
0.38742536306381226,
1.0058220624923706,
-0.00742580508813262,
0.32960912585258484,
0.11043566465377808,
-0.1480982005596161,
-0.2557137608528137,
-0.28380024433135986,
-0.24184070527553558,
0.6272985339164734,
0.3354347050189972,
-0.21397826075553894,
-0.08366011828184128,
0.1194075271487236,
-0.014832615852355957,
0.06199345737695694,
-0.18607071042060852,
0.8352369666099548,
0.14432984590530396,
-0.4700959622859955,
0.4823782742023468,
-0.05489146336913109,
0.5614359378814697,
-0.5177143216133118,
0.16146963834762573,
-0.6441726088523865,
-0.143230140209198,
-0.2166522890329361,
-1.070042610168457,
0.387745201587677,
0.22529275715351105,
-0.3193824291229248,
-0.7944930791854858,
0.3991347849369049,
-0.47549718618392944,
-0.3301771879196167,
0.21785710752010345,
0.6766003370285034,
0.35398751497268677,
0.23876072466373444,
-0.31954193115234375,
0.057025302201509476,
-0.1608513742685318,
-0.13142073154449463,
0.4881824851036072,
0.4557307958602905,
-0.40493541955947876,
0.6949015855789185,
0.46441203355789185,
0.0697014182806015,
-0.2793636918067932,
0.07195258140563965,
0.3166291117668152,
-0.6336314678192139,
-0.30759501457214355,
-1.0606013536453247,
0.5267171859741211,
-0.0681808590888977,
-0.4087451994419098,
0.7690213322639465,
0.28757455945014954,
0.9790210127830505,
-0.08108416944742203,
0.46402326226234436,
0.319419264793396,
0.09969117492437363,
-0.5110083222389221,
0.5957558155059814,
-0.46044376492500305,
0.5246586799621582,
0.2099490463733673,
-1.1149009466171265,
-0.07629716396331787,
0.8706197142601013,
-0.5341084599494934,
0.13418230414390564,
0.5180951356887817,
0.6072763204574585,
0.20618517696857452,
-0.06502576917409897,
0.4529048502445221,
0.07043570280075073,
0.49080488085746765,
0.16531291604042053,
1.1898387670516968,
0.19792120158672333,
0.4274180829524994,
-0.18974852561950684,
-0.03469148278236389,
-0.2165466696023941,
-1.0383937358856201,
-0.7850039601325989,
-0.44413959980010986,
-0.33621492981910706,
-0.3550131022930145,
-0.28946787118911743,
1.341984748840332,
0.6139777302742004,
-0.7609933018684387,
-0.6630521416664124,
0.7232326865196228,
0.09508264064788818,
-0.2568223476409912,
-0.17487771809101105,
0.13923326134681702,
-0.03209993615746498,
-0.711533784866333,
0.15477827191352844,
0.40574708580970764,
0.27269792556762695,
-0.5042513608932495,
-0.1213316023349762,
0.2598574757575989,
0.23773793876171112,
0.8466114401817322,
0.05511663109064102,
-0.899918794631958,
-0.6758463978767395,
0.38852566480636597,
-0.4904312789440155,
0.25602880120277405,
0.8627892732620239,
-0.46755126118659973,
0.19058768451213837,
0.42819052934646606,
0.4601430594921112,
0.16474953293800354,
-0.2007811963558197,
0.5630370378494263,
-0.8027191162109375,
0.06222071498632431,
0.1740989089012146,
0.40132424235343933,
0.47072312235832214,
-0.4745090901851654,
0.26780325174331665,
0.08916325867176056,
-0.6618104577064514,
-0.44792377948760986,
0.493384450674057,
-0.9352999329566956,
-0.1743222326040268,
1.3551578521728516,
-0.2781514525413513,
-0.032305579632520676,
-0.02699648030102253,
-0.15087589621543884,
-0.04660246893763542,
-0.07512270659208298,
0.9430815577507019,
1.1103321313858032,
-0.12594659626483917,
-0.1195640116930008,
-0.47776010632514954,
0.33011919260025024,
0.23074908554553986,
-0.8479382991790771,
-0.04961816966533661,
0.45984116196632385,
0.6965147852897644,
-0.05207119137048721,
0.6087201833724976,
0.06642047315835953,
0.012209134176373482,
-0.6368396282196045,
-0.005684554111212492,
0.26869431138038635,
-0.10313670337200165,
-0.5789598822593689,
0.026065347716212273,
0.4681846499443054,
0.05023888498544693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14785v1 | Understanding Finetuning for Factual Knowledge Extraction | 2024-06-20T23:27:06 | 2024-06-20T23:27:06 | Gaurav Ghosal, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Aditi Raghunathan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we study the impact of QA fine-tuning data on downstream
factuality. We show that fine-tuning on lesser-known facts that are poorly
stored during pretraining yields significantly worse factuality than
fine-tuning on well-known facts, even when all facts are seen during
pretraining. We prove this phenomenon theoretically, showing that training on
lesser-known facts can lead the model to ignore subject entity names and
instead output a generic plausible response even when the relevant factual
knowledge is encoded in the model. On three question answering benchmarks
(PopQA, Entity Questions, and MMLU) and two language models (Llama-2-7B and
Mistral-7B), we find that (i) finetuning on a completely factual but
lesser-known subset of the data deteriorates downstream factuality (5-10%) and
(ii) finetuning on a subset of better-known examples matches or outperforms
finetuning on the entire dataset. Ultimately, our results shed light on the
interaction between pretrained knowledge and finetuning data and demonstrate
the importance of taking into account how facts are stored in the pretrained
model when fine-tuning for knowledge-intensive tasks. | [
-0.6569652557373047,
-0.8682034015655518,
0.8667613863945007,
-0.45504456758499146,
-0.38119831681251526,
-0.3634670376777649,
-0.3529512286186218,
-0.5869573950767517,
-0.3327290117740631,
0.4917750954627991,
-0.6359162330627441,
-0.26054835319519043,
-0.6256267428398132,
-0.047221891582012177,
-0.3762566149234772,
1.4602622985839844,
0.23790788650512695,
0.11440716683864594,
-0.3282359838485718,
-0.2314276099205017,
-0.7219747304916382,
-0.3984472155570984,
-0.5420730113983154,
-0.2230934351682663,
0.5784314274787903,
0.7801466584205627,
0.5870695114135742,
0.7536004781723022,
0.29847654700279236,
0.23454833030700684,
-0.009748028591275215,
0.24421009421348572,
-1.0420600175857544,
-0.13090987503528595,
-0.32777780294418335,
-0.9999337792396545,
-0.029177533462643623,
0.30245786905288696,
0.4406192898750305,
0.739160418510437,
-0.01171785593032837,
0.7172238826751709,
0.11614511162042618,
0.6471377611160278,
-0.7323875427246094,
0.2545223534107208,
-0.8652602434158325,
-0.2589711546897888,
-0.2871747612953186,
-0.2583392560482025,
-0.10585865378379822,
-0.6137975454330444,
0.35011032223701477,
-0.7262858152389526,
0.5654760003089905,
0.10983835160732269,
1.4984962940216064,
0.7324674725532532,
-0.30997830629348755,
-0.18182595074176788,
-0.7639586925506592,
0.6543772220611572,
-0.6331316828727722,
0.4243324398994446,
0.47034457325935364,
0.3202306032180786,
0.20870114862918854,
-0.6352204084396362,
-0.8337425589561462,
0.062065087258815765,
-0.2930488884449005,
0.04946023225784302,
0.027465512976050377,
0.1358981877565384,
0.5800694823265076,
0.621353805065155,
-0.029724393039941788,
0.08069310337305069,
-0.7084541320800781,
-0.26269271969795227,
0.44990214705467224,
-0.002467160811647773,
0.06711964309215546,
-0.18657717108726501,
-0.2947313189506531,
0.05015808343887329,
-0.9132787585258484,
0.37851831316947937,
0.11636462807655334,
0.3598822057247162,
0.09615454077720642,
0.5332944393157959,
-0.6383047699928284,
0.5027719140052795,
0.4297328591346741,
-0.12846094369888306,
0.04884028434753418,
-0.4601685106754303,
-0.3886277973651886,
0.07190018892288208,
0.41705799102783203,
0.40891146659851074,
0.4027833640575409,
-0.40437307953834534,
-0.06664993613958359,
-0.19732582569122314,
0.09189826995134354,
-0.9229326248168945,
-0.39798617362976074,
0.15182587504386902,
-0.22373057901859283,
-0.02501766011118889,
0.0742945522069931,
-0.39618852734565735,
-0.4122698903083801,
-0.9047666192054749,
0.7257075309753418,
-0.5222678184509277,
-0.026786863803863525,
-0.0003217503835912794,
-0.228440061211586,
0.4911562502384186,
0.29567667841911316,
-0.6733044981956482,
0.0846657082438469,
0.8344669342041016,
0.4083402156829834,
0.23398329317569733,
-0.1520017385482788,
-0.985770046710968,
-0.010238510556519032,
-0.2847726047039032,
0.8651750087738037,
-0.25723984837532043,
0.26591572165489197,
-0.27016109228134155,
0.17467100918293,
-0.061938971281051636,
-0.7252028584480286,
0.7965898513793945,
-0.8611859679222107,
0.08712194114923477,
-0.6911789178848267,
-0.8160609602928162,
-0.4403417110443115,
0.16178831458091736,
-0.6648807525634766,
0.474221408367157,
-0.16418439149856567,
-0.7897610664367676,
0.9382390379905701,
-0.06445515155792236,
-0.3415379822254181,
-0.1754201203584671,
-0.18616923689842224,
-0.38100942969322205,
0.19395406544208527,
0.028061136603355408,
0.6306493282318115,
-0.3990436792373657,
0.341707706451416,
-0.34667813777923584,
-0.3214412033557892,
0.23888984322547913,
-0.4255174696445465,
0.4744340181350708,
0.22317670285701752,
-0.33694884181022644,
-0.37521302700042725,
-0.9410902857780457,
0.03823211044073105,
-0.2593638002872467,
-0.5692450404167175,
-0.426114022731781,
-0.03221414238214493,
-0.4404965341091156,
0.387173593044281,
0.05091262608766556,
-0.7893751859664917,
-0.10380570590496063,
-0.46613791584968567,
0.028559518977999687,
0.5512800216674805,
0.25142529606819153,
0.32314643263816833,
-0.5494279265403748,
0.09617339819669724,
0.2542673945426941,
-0.10449125617742538,
0.30425864458084106,
-0.10010316222906113,
-0.960639476776123,
-0.09121856093406677,
0.678141176700592,
0.48137167096138,
-0.6550273895263672,
-0.07171472907066345,
-0.4131760597229004,
-0.5136812925338745,
-0.8351778984069824,
0.2591988444328308,
0.5364290475845337,
0.9068500399589539,
0.5112505555152893,
0.08157219737768173,
-0.5369889736175537,
-1.020291805267334,
-0.6676778197288513,
0.15798187255859375,
-0.06625571101903915,
-0.0010470112320035696,
0.1687915027141571,
0.09281067550182343,
1.0562703609466553,
-0.6749067306518555,
-0.3834587335586548,
0.0306436475366354,
0.2202543020248413,
0.08502787351608276,
0.6520861387252808,
0.43497419357299805,
-0.6734955310821533,
-0.1370074599981308,
-0.09842459857463837,
-0.5423394441604614,
0.20669850707054138,
-0.29844194650650024,
-0.22145673632621765,
0.07194932550191879,
0.43342068791389465,
-0.9353755116462708,
0.28940916061401367,
0.18250516057014465,
-0.19179430603981018,
0.6687808036804199,
0.13745416700839996,
0.15491801500320435,
-0.7237775325775146,
-0.04379050061106682,
-0.05512942001223564,
-0.2654854357242584,
-0.5536597371101379,
0.07089756429195404,
-0.13168154656887054,
0.1553836464881897,
-0.27759549021720886,
0.153110533952713,
-0.2908215820789337,
0.13222265243530273,
0.07376816123723984,
0.21477332711219788,
0.26401692628860474,
0.4385754466056824,
-0.0644385889172554,
0.8642733097076416,
0.2631874084472656,
-1.0715000629425049,
0.03736580163240433,
0.33671119809150696,
-0.5906456112861633,
0.2584443986415863,
-0.5358728766441345,
-0.01942054182291031,
-0.2580679953098297,
-0.3220057487487793,
-0.7450177669525146,
-0.1910720020532608,
0.01610765978693962,
-0.4113762080669403,
0.3526501953601837,
-0.4304705858230591,
-0.37614285945892334,
0.020798752084374428,
-0.059462759643793106,
0.2208585888147354,
0.377792626619339,
-0.5729061365127563,
0.3202851414680481,
0.3492588698863983,
-0.21308857202529907,
-0.3605360984802246,
-0.617872953414917,
-0.4923621714115143,
-0.39306771755218506,
-0.42896658182144165,
0.06254047155380249,
0.16575738787651062,
-0.11172620207071304,
-0.11128214001655579,
-0.566226065158844,
-0.34548571705818176,
0.22754058241844177,
0.06828809529542923,
0.05220748111605644,
-0.601842999458313,
0.45044848322868347,
0.16980943083763123,
-0.024572309106588364,
0.47318312525749207,
-0.13039006292819977,
0.18048880994319916,
-0.17084798216819763,
-0.09672803431749344,
-0.5708855390548706,
-0.10197213292121887,
0.3098139762878418,
-0.30316606163978577,
1.0487006902694702,
0.7460897564888,
-0.3571380078792572,
0.109425850212574,
-0.7405843734741211,
-0.3856586813926697,
-0.4402581453323364,
0.21756257116794586,
-0.4535695016384125,
-0.7388695478439331,
0.47322240471839905,
-0.24190740287303925,
0.1882343292236328,
0.7410077452659607,
0.16247640550136566,
-0.5035940408706665,
0.8391582369804382,
0.6802788972854614,
0.3324524164199829,
0.3385356664657593,
-0.4057749807834625,
0.16687723994255066,
-0.568700909614563,
-0.1519143283367157,
-0.53258216381073,
-0.18631258606910706,
-0.8009307384490967,
-0.023613912984728813,
0.11411961913108826,
0.5065317153930664,
-0.368979275226593,
-0.002007588744163513,
-0.07639891654253006,
0.5966939926147461,
0.6943801641464233,
0.35355091094970703,
0.45594820380210876,
-0.08252452313899994,
0.1909642219543457,
0.020558802410960197,
-0.8879944086074829,
-0.5762455463409424,
1.186733365058899,
0.2109992504119873,
0.5816161632537842,
0.0651511698961258,
0.5069875717163086,
-0.08911065012216568,
0.22241869568824768,
-0.7439086437225342,
0.06174825131893158,
-0.2294096201658249,
-0.8340644836425781,
-0.4427568018436432,
-0.5222817063331604,
-0.6103477478027344,
-0.06805271655321121,
-0.5162281394004822,
-0.3480418920516968,
0.5037786960601807,
0.5175418257713318,
-1.038811206817627,
0.1945829689502716,
-1.1670278310775757,
0.8544955253601074,
0.05646796524524689,
-0.328775554895401,
-0.28462380170822144,
-0.6630173325538635,
0.646316409111023,
-0.06055590510368347,
0.32667362689971924,
-0.10705859959125519,
0.5611505508422852,
0.9190093874931335,
-0.45556557178497314,
0.8059682250022888,
-0.311000257730484,
-0.07593084871768951,
0.3315848410129547,
-0.03873935714364052,
0.32446303963661194,
0.44002774357795715,
0.034861862659454346,
-0.07116273045539856,
0.6078466176986694,
-0.5151231288909912,
-0.6262131929397583,
0.4541465938091278,
-0.9530928730964661,
-0.7831622958183289,
-0.07679294794797897,
-0.3221072554588318,
-0.5174294114112854,
0.21617145836353302,
0.4667600095272064,
0.7826873660087585,
0.04547853022813797,
0.25535568594932556,
1.0291725397109985,
0.11232195794582367,
-0.054198600351810455,
0.5231112241744995,
0.3215300738811493,
0.0793188065290451,
1.1917824745178223,
0.5034271478652954,
0.419911652803421,
0.27333158254623413,
0.1003594920039177,
-0.2719264030456543,
-0.5715360641479492,
-0.2476785033941269,
0.23161794245243073,
-0.9068828225135803,
-0.46002665162086487,
-0.5221084356307983,
-0.19805417954921722,
-0.24476531147956848,
0.4282310903072357,
-0.37827083468437195,
-0.60249263048172,
-0.4313901960849762,
-0.31481480598449707,
0.4100562334060669,
0.5867415070533752,
-0.02881959080696106,
0.3209916353225708,
-0.9610220193862915,
0.5911181569099426,
0.7318210601806641,
0.4907664656639099,
-0.09490980952978134,
-0.6080132126808167,
-0.6100365519523621,
0.4589885473251343,
-0.15735985338687897,
-0.5356255173683167,
-0.24966765940189362,
0.46275290846824646,
0.4437231719493866,
0.6552287936210632,
0.3593348264694214,
0.9181761145591736,
-0.32806795835494995,
0.5553872585296631,
-0.17175644636154175,
-0.6436111927032471,
0.4068218767642975,
-0.11768469214439392,
0.1757376790046692,
1.134369134902954,
0.448605477809906,
-0.2559632360935211,
-0.43172866106033325,
-0.6906097531318665,
-0.48855283856391907,
0.7301920056343079,
-0.08720946311950684,
-0.004892183002084494,
0.022579319775104523,
0.6896941661834717,
0.5638761520385742,
0.373102605342865,
-0.4537440538406372,
-0.2935427725315094,
-0.24142925441265106,
-0.13196422159671783,
-0.11957450211048126,
-0.36868003010749817,
-0.3208887577056885,
-0.48105064034461975,
0.6846306920051575,
-0.09714837372303009,
0.09151552617549896,
0.20860078930854797,
-0.6021493673324585,
0.02922249026596546,
0.3696613311767578,
0.43536892533302307,
0.6864390969276428,
-0.2532036304473877,
0.13252024352550507,
0.2859947979450226,
-0.4568096697330475,
-0.28678834438323975,
0.30030471086502075,
-0.38952067494392395,
-0.17701315879821777,
0.4093523323535919,
0.8722094893455505,
0.21748557686805725,
-0.4739765524864197,
0.30025845766067505,
-0.10100799053907394,
-0.08382078260183334,
-0.026908723637461662,
0.40448951721191406,
-0.1522342562675476,
0.2567432224750519,
0.36573299765586853,
0.47765281796455383,
0.3459875285625458,
-0.46793878078460693,
0.22033298015594482,
0.22662560641765594,
-0.3811298906803131,
-0.41155391931533813,
0.5226134061813354,
0.15255141258239746,
0.5136276483535767,
0.6061885952949524,
-0.20485062897205353,
-0.4101945459842682,
0.5048160552978516,
0.11235745251178741,
0.35003918409347534,
0.2668132185935974,
0.11791907995939255,
0.4607669711112976,
0.2871543765068054,
0.1548222452402115,
0.1732218712568283,
-0.16979406774044037,
-0.6698103547096252,
-0.6587476134300232,
-0.7256021499633789,
0.031880270689725876,
0.22789201140403748,
-0.8287367820739746,
0.27725255489349365,
-0.4595310389995575,
-0.15505947172641754,
0.1419631689786911,
0.28822892904281616,
-1.259859323501587,
0.6946513652801514,
0.14307546615600586,
0.7313283681869507,
-0.7820296287536621,
0.5012167096138,
0.6237475275993347,
-0.7838127613067627,
-1.3172297477722168,
0.2414790838956833,
-0.1508031189441681,
-0.6282393932342529,
0.7019248604774475,
0.07244724780321121,
-0.025626270100474358,
0.3916831910610199,
-0.592302143573761,
-1.0490891933441162,
1.112540364265442,
0.5893899202346802,
-0.5273275971412659,
-0.06534706801176071,
0.1507149487733841,
0.391244500875473,
0.007809762842953205,
-0.008017093874514103,
1.012578010559082,
0.3389786183834076,
-0.10096290707588196,
-0.8189366459846497,
0.23632293939590454,
0.12995778024196625,
-0.4765893220901489,
-0.11983810365200043,
-0.7134970426559448,
0.8457023501396179,
-0.3639863431453705,
-0.7183172702789307,
-0.13488836586475372,
0.6985979676246643,
-0.005434961058199406,
0.2816013991832733,
0.3986664414405823,
0.5975529551506042,
1.133013367652893,
-0.311892032623291,
0.985500693321228,
-0.1272783726453781,
0.2879367172718048,
1.2443214654922485,
0.3269113004207611,
0.6419844031333923,
0.49014946818351746,
-0.020773475989699364,
0.4003424644470215,
0.7923955321311951,
0.27529266476631165,
0.7881907820701599,
-0.09416810423135757,
0.11052975058555603,
-0.490521639585495,
-0.04071899130940437,
-0.4533192217350006,
0.42224666476249695,
0.18138620257377625,
0.11067451536655426,
-0.27651262283325195,
-0.00782255083322525,
0.11272946745157242,
-0.019973943009972572,
-0.5713164210319519,
1.0145480632781982,
0.0836494043469429,
-0.7662461996078491,
0.9741947054862976,
-0.21615256369113922,
0.38714799284935,
-0.12939345836639404,
0.09873871505260468,
-0.3298310935497284,
0.002863045549020171,
-0.4102098047733307,
-0.7817065715789795,
0.3860708773136139,
-0.07935724407434464,
-0.5715087652206421,
0.13718892633914948,
0.5994584560394287,
-0.4994322955608368,
-0.022130707278847694,
-0.3094787299633026,
0.6767528057098389,
-0.07020827382802963,
-0.2327793687582016,
-0.30350103974342346,
-0.32522422075271606,
0.013804863207042217,
-0.08663395792245865,
0.20959100127220154,
0.9559451341629028,
0.1324317455291748,
0.621810793876648,
0.7253168225288391,
-0.09908338636159897,
0.3010673522949219,
0.018464388325810432,
1.0557090044021606,
-0.47097423672676086,
-0.46503427624702454,
-0.6187480688095093,
0.5071268677711487,
-0.09577687084674835,
-0.41184234619140625,
0.6037521958351135,
0.47931575775146484,
0.9338264465332031,
-0.15329954028129578,
0.5799383521080017,
0.09689617156982422,
0.6967806816101074,
-1.0618722438812256,
0.9410821199417114,
-0.395738422870636,
0.30260318517684937,
0.04130356386303902,
-0.6337318420410156,
0.17284245789051056,
0.07591363787651062,
-0.6293646097183228,
-0.17910926043987274,
0.6565516591072083,
0.45220082998275757,
-0.2701161205768585,
0.1555963009595871,
0.14780114591121674,
0.5413453578948975,
0.018727868795394897,
0.1891895830631256,
0.7372450232505798,
-0.5486244559288025,
0.6758273243904114,
-0.44011449813842773,
0.029874034225940704,
-0.043850529938936234,
-0.4963560998439789,
-0.8660398125648499,
-0.5907359719276428,
-0.3469087481498718,
-0.12158596515655518,
0.0029411723371595144,
0.5359731912612915,
0.7320177555084229,
-1.0398610830307007,
0.4073852598667145,
-0.09348481148481369,
0.34453803300857544,
-0.1761854887008667,
-0.2550998032093048,
0.26217585802078247,
-0.6059175729751587,
-0.21012459695339203,
-0.05154762789607048,
-0.46582868695259094,
0.03783126547932625,
0.23436285555362701,
0.124592624604702,
-0.3311358094215393,
0.013573861680924892,
0.5854935646057129,
0.44748392701148987,
-0.5956316590309143,
-0.7122702598571777,
-0.09571665525436401,
0.027902334928512573,
0.02401239238679409,
0.4965304732322693,
-1.1058826446533203,
0.09594070911407471,
0.21964357793331146,
0.8616501092910767,
0.4222354590892792,
0.38600966334342957,
0.6320626735687256,
-0.8872185945510864,
-0.025761811062693596,
-0.08395926654338837,
0.08451935648918152,
0.34906309843063354,
-0.5146252512931824,
0.16555193066596985,
0.1899733990430832,
-0.48895055055618286,
-0.7605188488960266,
0.13928398489952087,
-0.5800099968910217,
-0.03537778556346893,
0.8198080062866211,
-0.09634077548980713,
-0.20977632701396942,
-0.2600787580013275,
-0.14769834280014038,
0.6469867825508118,
-0.19196723401546478,
0.9859676957130432,
0.818061888217926,
0.027338910847902298,
-0.11820140480995178,
-0.7786548137664795,
1.1203787326812744,
0.5260313153266907,
-0.6913065910339355,
0.23173531889915466,
0.5965332984924316,
0.6995130181312561,
0.14966730773448944,
0.20385760068893433,
0.31571123003959656,
0.5541217923164368,
-0.266999214887619,
-0.17662392556667328,
-0.058802198618650436,
-0.15958115458488464,
-0.1977277249097824,
0.0036381641402840614,
0.291029155254364,
-0.2256026715040207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14783v1 | Evaluating RAG-Fusion with RAGElo: an Automated Elo-based Framework | 2024-06-20T23:20:34 | 2024-06-20T23:20:34 | Zackary Rackauckas, Arthur Câmara, Jakub Zavrel | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Challenges in the automated evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG) Question-Answering (QA) systems include hallucination problems in
domain-specific knowledge and the lack of gold standard benchmarks for company
internal tasks. This results in difficulties in evaluating RAG variations, like
RAG-Fusion (RAGF), in the context of a product QA task at Infineon
Technologies. To solve these problems, we propose a comprehensive evaluation
framework, which leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate large
datasets of synthetic queries based on real user queries and in-domain
documents, uses LLM-as-a-judge to rate retrieved documents and answers,
evaluates the quality of answers, and ranks different variants of
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) agents with RAGElo's automated Elo-based
competition. LLM-as-a-judge rating of a random sample of synthetic queries
shows a moderate, positive correlation with domain expert scoring in relevance,
accuracy, completeness, and precision. While RAGF outperformed RAG in Elo
score, a significance analysis against expert annotations also shows that RAGF
significantly outperforms RAG in completeness, but underperforms in precision.
In addition, Infineon's RAGF assistant demonstrated slightly higher performance
in document relevance based on MRR@5 scores. We find that RAGElo positively
aligns with the preferences of human annotators, though due caution is still
required. Finally, RAGF's approach leads to more complete answers based on
expert annotations and better answers overall based on RAGElo's evaluation
criteria. | [
-0.5586574673652649,
-0.4158605635166168,
0.5159525871276855,
0.11887713521718979,
0.08961503207683563,
0.51934814453125,
-0.11380945891141891,
-0.7184798717498779,
0.18974734842777252,
0.45463865995407104,
-0.3247147798538208,
-0.535331666469574,
-0.42030927538871765,
0.4810195565223694,
-0.5591690540313721,
1.2551350593566895,
-0.06172828748822212,
-0.08441728353500366,
-0.7393068671226501,
-0.12672767043113708,
-0.16090796887874603,
-0.35790374875068665,
-0.6185849905014038,
-0.4742469787597656,
0.2161257565021515,
0.3535062074661255,
0.6859310865402222,
0.11263233423233032,
0.7229985594749451,
0.3162120282649994,
-0.30387425422668457,
0.5205681920051575,
-0.5259467959403992,
0.4473573863506317,
-0.25585466623306274,
-0.32279831171035767,
-0.5543421506881714,
-0.18684041500091553,
0.42024627327919006,
0.3395044207572937,
-0.23198728263378143,
0.3419148921966553,
-0.1522766649723053,
0.831425130367279,
-0.7178052067756653,
-0.371648907661438,
-0.8255998492240906,
0.0028813937678933144,
0.14553424715995789,
-0.04433637857437134,
-0.42852911353111267,
-0.5694618225097656,
0.20505394041538239,
-0.5957679152488708,
0.1119651272892952,
0.4100319743156433,
1.1918226480484009,
0.403130441904068,
-0.24423295259475708,
-0.6664839386940002,
-0.8645733594894409,
0.7366617321968079,
-0.6276474595069885,
0.24034562706947327,
0.3363313376903534,
0.4632801413536072,
-0.4359581172466278,
-0.42198511958122253,
-0.7096158266067505,
-0.46234244108200073,
-0.04803723096847534,
0.43978336453437805,
0.024576200172305107,
0.10009682923555374,
0.12707889080047607,
0.5215981602668762,
-0.8532302379608154,
-0.04533061385154724,
-0.19457757472991943,
-0.029489420354366302,
0.9407901167869568,
0.2985272705554962,
0.11144023388624191,
-0.24837596714496613,
-0.4287630021572113,
-0.20208880305290222,
-0.2622835338115692,
-0.18998843431472778,
0.40130484104156494,
0.016427647322416306,
0.4563866853713989,
0.578295886516571,
-0.17881253361701965,
0.8560159802436829,
0.3096284866333008,
-0.28182533383369446,
0.229587122797966,
-0.1100219264626503,
-0.2922029197216034,
-0.2629045248031616,
0.8331443071365356,
0.2420424371957779,
-0.005290237721055746,
-0.577330470085144,
-0.6636338233947754,
-0.20043312013149261,
0.5528789758682251,
-0.4725510776042938,
0.18706849217414856,
0.6636940836906433,
-0.2021888941526413,
-0.35754209756851196,
0.23542211949825287,
-0.951676607131958,
-0.6532696485519409,
-0.1613616794347763,
0.9412156939506531,
-0.17765961587429047,
-0.15425753593444824,
0.04504392668604851,
-0.25075775384902954,
0.35079580545425415,
0.27890560030937195,
-0.3541119396686554,
0.5789601802825928,
0.6726292371749878,
0.5789288878440857,
-0.6315571665763855,
-0.17216700315475464,
-0.4700486361980438,
-0.055316321551799774,
-0.28277483582496643,
1.2949470281600952,
-0.44919657707214355,
-0.6085989475250244,
0.03387201577425003,
-0.34339556097984314,
-0.23928852379322052,
-1.1786202192306519,
0.7780190706253052,
-0.9586675763130188,
0.33987563848495483,
-0.0013874064898118377,
-0.7858855724334717,
-0.10751707851886749,
0.5928773880004883,
-0.5493601560592651,
1.187741994857788,
0.3564068675041199,
-0.5493147969245911,
0.20643717050552368,
-0.6039050817489624,
-0.2204524278640747,
0.15880577266216278,
0.057823553681373596,
-0.3175373673439026,
-0.09616988152265549,
-0.048480886965990067,
0.10019469261169434,
-0.6314085125923157,
-0.009961800649762154,
-0.08950000256299973,
-0.39044225215911865,
0.4802277386188507,
0.17300941050052643,
0.4405079185962677,
0.3299027979373932,
-0.29313474893569946,
0.15540140867233276,
-0.8393125534057617,
0.24160617589950562,
-0.021626999601721764,
-0.23674529790878296,
-0.19761605560779572,
-0.20298798382282257,
-0.011572293937206268,
0.346921443939209,
0.37417343258857727,
-0.4607013761997223,
-0.0697251707315445,
-0.6844583749771118,
-0.4972916841506958,
0.5914838910102844,
0.18645763397216797,
0.36043065786361694,
-0.5559315085411072,
0.7899734377861023,
-0.2519836723804474,
0.33819863200187683,
0.21138162910938263,
-0.4312714636325836,
-0.9586518406867981,
-0.0721585750579834,
0.3976670503616333,
0.7354757189750671,
-0.7602370381355286,
0.4905962347984314,
-0.06039901450276375,
-0.6484817862510681,
-0.6098693609237671,
0.1596013903617859,
0.6719844341278076,
0.6407779455184937,
0.19477105140686035,
-0.2726060152053833,
-0.4317755401134491,
-0.9043708443641663,
-0.3013029098510742,
-0.14613014459609985,
-0.13405916094779968,
0.5763040781021118,
0.42831408977508545,
-0.3543587625026703,
0.8500000238418579,
-0.3100379407405853,
-0.3836611807346344,
-0.1770211011171341,
0.27241551876068115,
0.38402867317199707,
0.04303761571645737,
0.15945717692375183,
-0.8756402730941772,
-0.6272739768028259,
0.4235115051269531,
-0.6640875339508057,
-0.2672479450702667,
0.0729578286409378,
-0.23319414258003235,
0.4436498284339905,
0.10911238938570023,
-0.45722630620002747,
0.13449516892433167,
0.5070297718048096,
-0.2986895740032196,
0.7098318934440613,
-0.050511449575424194,
0.6036704778671265,
-0.9792721271514893,
0.33613207936286926,
-0.1541997790336609,
-0.16075003147125244,
-0.5650601387023926,
0.18839481472969055,
-0.20391036570072174,
-0.1942785531282425,
-0.386034220457077,
0.8259530663490295,
-0.09471938014030457,
-0.4063545763492584,
-0.3655247390270233,
0.5022491216659546,
0.2952679395675659,
0.37460845708847046,
-0.44049450755119324,
0.8840103149414062,
0.06575687229633331,
-0.6042947769165039,
0.2668352425098419,
0.1890973150730133,
-0.18678580224514008,
0.5766626000404358,
-0.7364472150802612,
0.44411179423332214,
0.004710458684712648,
-0.10703519731760025,
-0.9102331399917603,
-0.36846426129341125,
-0.040414899587631226,
-0.4434869885444641,
0.2840211093425751,
-0.0488024540245533,
-0.6997441649436951,
-0.5015485286712646,
-0.2471420168876648,
0.1235479936003685,
0.4811604619026184,
-0.42549991607666016,
0.7879997491836548,
0.6636269092559814,
0.10388745367527008,
-0.5695037245750427,
0.02773350290954113,
-0.04192135110497475,
-0.25976893305778503,
-0.7042050361633301,
0.4802488088607788,
-0.1565079689025879,
-0.5279143452644348,
-0.011171350255608559,
-0.18825502693653107,
-0.21361087262630463,
-0.06348026543855667,
0.21853169798851013,
0.3308980166912079,
0.22574982047080994,
0.19305235147476196,
0.016305962577462196,
0.03680058568716049,
-0.00615914911031723,
-0.08500883728265762,
0.4519137144088745,
-0.21803922951221466,
-0.1930837482213974,
-0.06599835306406021,
0.21263960003852844,
0.6406672596931458,
-0.26065486669540405,
0.49891558289527893,
0.35941237211227417,
-0.3370387852191925,
-0.32626497745513916,
-0.7365638017654419,
0.09144262224435806,
-0.456205815076828,
0.09358251839876175,
-0.28772076964378357,
-0.7511085867881775,
0.7369639873504639,
-0.17158356308937073,
0.1790197640657425,
0.8229123950004578,
0.6444974541664124,
-0.24195989966392517,
1.0446306467056274,
0.5150752067565918,
0.31764283776283264,
0.09878075122833252,
-0.2563861310482025,
-0.05303063616156578,
-0.7893226742744446,
-0.5018616318702698,
-0.6692516207695007,
-0.285077303647995,
-0.43223148584365845,
-0.24382729828357697,
0.7052383422851562,
-0.041019681841135025,
-0.10304554551839828,
0.2544044554233551,
-0.7498971223831177,
0.5178955793380737,
0.21655254065990448,
-0.06841390579938889,
0.42183947563171387,
-0.2044266164302826,
0.03409824147820473,
0.25670352578163147,
-0.6998047232627869,
-0.5834600329399109,
1.0906020402908325,
0.1007322371006012,
0.694536030292511,
-0.05431889370083809,
0.8675427436828613,
0.630605161190033,
0.45405837893486023,
-0.9204385876655579,
0.5134569406509399,
-0.24832573533058167,
-0.5343415141105652,
-0.15869031846523285,
-0.29244503378868103,
-0.8717412352561951,
0.19667863845825195,
-0.28142860531806946,
-0.5124804377555847,
0.19296731054782867,
-0.01902475580573082,
-0.5160645842552185,
-0.0999082699418068,
-0.7446231245994568,
0.7092876434326172,
-0.13509991765022278,
-0.17112457752227783,
-0.1852535754442215,
-0.35328930616378784,
0.3736709952354431,
-0.2608977258205414,
0.0709315836429596,
-0.07198420912027359,
-0.07200969755649567,
0.9502032399177551,
-0.23987038433551788,
0.17486339807510376,
0.0795973464846611,
-0.16422349214553833,
0.552671492099762,
0.22637103497982025,
0.539053201675415,
-0.09574388712644577,
-0.4838625192642212,
-0.17580217123031616,
0.08370058238506317,
-0.03191491588950157,
-0.9200091361999512,
0.7467976808547974,
-0.6662930846214294,
-0.5536646842956543,
-0.4133012294769287,
-0.4843716621398926,
-0.5353376865386963,
-0.007188142742961645,
0.19628942012786865,
0.21642369031906128,
-0.11610736697912216,
-0.20406346023082733,
0.8184967637062073,
-0.1538321077823639,
0.08046761155128479,
0.5086463093757629,
-0.45750823616981506,
-0.5692823529243469,
1.0156676769256592,
-0.04492254927754402,
0.22833168506622314,
0.24385268986225128,
0.11109001189470291,
-0.370431125164032,
-0.30221015214920044,
-0.4789693057537079,
0.24478496611118317,
-0.6396639943122864,
-0.4964636564254761,
-0.7503532767295837,
-0.30894219875335693,
-0.1255079209804535,
-0.08155576884746552,
-0.3261067867279053,
-0.31140077114105225,
-0.11149229109287262,
0.3209705948829651,
0.31954675912857056,
0.9170088768005371,
0.3536938428878784,
-0.04074087366461754,
-0.7414650917053223,
0.3818703293800354,
0.40637102723121643,
0.26993781328201294,
-0.09346923977136612,
-0.8519631028175354,
-0.4804740250110626,
-0.25580617785453796,
-0.4014699161052704,
-0.9362669587135315,
0.32450515031814575,
0.09961599111557007,
0.5111270546913147,
-0.0008334838785231113,
0.056397054344415665,
0.6626759767532349,
-0.26255467534065247,
0.6397154331207275,
-0.18709494173526764,
-0.7873091697692871,
0.5932715535163879,
-0.29276809096336365,
0.17607514560222626,
0.7277933359146118,
0.4888565242290497,
-0.24409115314483643,
-0.6823687553405762,
-0.7939043045043945,
-0.9366632699966431,
0.45205551385879517,
0.1914578676223755,
-0.21053378283977509,
0.05278965085744858,
0.3863721489906311,
0.1550414264202118,
0.20046064257621765,
-0.2411947101354599,
-0.097354955971241,
0.18858444690704346,
-0.12529703974723816,
0.4680633246898651,
-0.22239051759243011,
-0.3049319386482239,
0.09786083549261093,
0.8226817846298218,
-0.060771822929382324,
0.21513450145721436,
0.37878313660621643,
-0.22915737330913544,
-0.21523639559745789,
0.1801747977733612,
0.5401022434234619,
0.7330537438392639,
-0.29173702001571655,
-0.33328837156295776,
0.3699493110179901,
-0.28250351548194885,
0.11772938817739487,
0.13877379894256592,
-0.16566596925258636,
0.12797203660011292,
0.046540506184101105,
0.354827344417572,
-0.018260538578033447,
-1.1274082660675049,
0.32375869154930115,
-0.03012446127831936,
-0.10092061758041382,
-0.34714770317077637,
0.2590563893318176,
-0.4440264105796814,
0.3341224491596222,
0.7209728360176086,
-0.03939571976661682,
0.6232803463935852,
-0.22585296630859375,
0.3573225140571594,
0.4238196015357971,
-0.28343111276626587,
-0.16499948501586914,
0.4029237627983093,
0.12321560084819794,
-0.41660934686660767,
0.22544996440410614,
-0.5754336714744568,
-0.5842376351356506,
0.8010215163230896,
0.5370185375213623,
1.1142470836639404,
-0.147993803024292,
0.33155402541160583,
0.38271069526672363,
0.09551828354597092,
-0.024539925158023834,
0.35574913024902344,
0.1064898893237114,
-0.5360475778579712,
-0.4797203242778778,
-1.037442922592163,
-0.882081151008606,
-0.04690559580922127,
-0.6180319786071777,
0.17463961243629456,
-0.3574317395687103,
-0.254761278629303,
-0.25984635949134827,
0.22482748329639435,
-0.5615047216415405,
0.41640034317970276,
-0.030091408640146255,
0.7293108701705933,
-0.4241219162940979,
0.39346516132354736,
0.9768244028091431,
-0.29274165630340576,
-0.5669770836830139,
0.11548848450183868,
-0.24415434896945953,
-0.35886895656585693,
0.6844819784164429,
-0.0525357760488987,
-0.3381834030151367,
-0.06724848598241806,
-0.2569529116153717,
-0.920734703540802,
1.0810233354568481,
0.1796676516532898,
-0.2693430483341217,
0.23843024671077728,
-0.1443575918674469,
0.8842399716377258,
-0.3617624044418335,
0.45131716132164,
0.5566487312316895,
0.35199952125549316,
0.23412249982357025,
-1.1150156259536743,
-0.3520151972770691,
-0.28830599784851074,
-0.0023620203137397766,
0.18705974519252777,
-0.6389391422271729,
0.4699569344520569,
0.008797324262559414,
-0.41388195753097534,
0.02885596640408039,
0.6993706822395325,
0.3742189407348633,
0.48945537209510803,
0.5673520565032959,
0.6633205413818359,
0.7291474342346191,
0.09156928956508636,
1.1760846376419067,
-0.3383500576019287,
0.3852525055408478,
1.0748913288116455,
-0.48882272839546204,
0.9039261937141418,
0.2932179570198059,
-0.2611749768257141,
0.6365957260131836,
0.3994269073009491,
0.16527333855628967,
0.2181936502456665,
0.27147403359413147,
-0.429923951625824,
-0.03406407684087753,
-0.4452345669269562,
-0.0037284267600625753,
0.4631672203540802,
0.23863700032234192,
-0.04419193044304848,
-0.21524691581726074,
-0.008681327104568481,
-0.18302123248577118,
0.39204496145248413,
-0.3025524318218231,
1.0427501201629639,
-0.17364758253097534,
-0.8114089369773865,
0.6912931799888611,
-0.20633818209171295,
0.5359643697738647,
-0.4860406816005707,
0.08333422988653183,
-0.49728867411613464,
0.01519106701016426,
-0.37745362520217896,
-0.8451299071311951,
0.5415900945663452,
0.2533304691314697,
-0.19125796854496002,
0.013566436246037483,
0.787021279335022,
-0.32557639479637146,
-0.36818361282348633,
0.27638718485832214,
0.5188433527946472,
0.2893390953540802,
-0.05908258259296417,
-0.7617558836936951,
0.0733228251338005,
-0.29973292350769043,
-0.311955988407135,
0.3732568919658661,
0.2656008005142212,
-0.05323481559753418,
0.7144954800605774,
0.45186352729797363,
-0.17068390548229218,
-0.04642791673541069,
0.27065539360046387,
0.9708749055862427,
-0.41494160890579224,
0.06600462645292282,
-0.38781294226646423,
0.478353351354599,
-0.14141403138637543,
-0.39884284138679504,
0.7948995232582092,
0.6258394718170166,
0.7647925019264221,
-0.010418839752674103,
0.41137322783470154,
-0.16773918271064758,
0.6184844374656677,
-0.228439599275589,
0.826848030090332,
-0.87540203332901,
0.08610104024410248,
-0.319049596786499,
-1.028716802597046,
-0.26670682430267334,
0.3141177296638489,
-0.1728467494249344,
0.004707368090748787,
0.4904402494430542,
0.9611598253250122,
0.3598637282848358,
-0.27536991238594055,
0.5161679983139038,
0.1843860149383545,
0.13676859438419342,
0.3979342579841614,
0.8874428868293762,
-0.7665427923202515,
0.7582619190216064,
-0.17174045741558075,
-0.1929018348455429,
-0.16534151136875153,
-0.5484846830368042,
-0.7203953266143799,
-0.6534652709960938,
-0.148411825299263,
-0.5892906785011292,
0.16380806267261505,
0.9794409275054932,
0.310600221157074,
-0.8904816508293152,
-0.5035697221755981,
0.2793647348880768,
0.33771049976348877,
-0.1377551555633545,
-0.30085766315460205,
0.2529464066028595,
-0.7321866154670715,
-0.9251860976219177,
0.4694790244102478,
0.5081351399421692,
-0.16487333178520203,
-0.3638758659362793,
-0.09334150701761246,
-0.13900020718574524,
0.22608666121959686,
0.7342539429664612,
0.3376108407974243,
-0.6203574538230896,
-0.04693320021033287,
0.4774949252605438,
-0.19773545861244202,
-0.09724118560552597,
0.4493817985057831,
-0.9990081191062927,
0.6206538677215576,
0.5700600743293762,
0.8238487839698792,
0.2233048975467682,
0.2514549791812897,
0.46418464183807373,
-0.3629811704158783,
-0.17127984762191772,
0.6811224818229675,
-0.11584556102752686,
0.2489534318447113,
-0.450157105922699,
0.5584702491760254,
-0.03341834619641304,
-0.928152322769165,
-0.9169992208480835,
0.0024324823170900345,
-0.9021109342575073,
0.054259512573480606,
1.3295961618423462,
0.07131944596767426,
-0.3798695206642151,
-0.127399742603302,
-0.253642201423645,
0.03048219531774521,
-0.3273070454597473,
1.181937336921692,
0.52995765209198,
-0.39462536573410034,
0.16710394620895386,
-0.3859553635120392,
0.7181780338287354,
0.4894329607486725,
-1.0526740550994873,
-0.3234821856021881,
0.26907607913017273,
-0.2161819338798523,
0.4726429283618927,
0.47177502512931824,
-0.24804484844207764,
0.45311298966407776,
-0.19164729118347168,
0.25873637199401855,
0.07318522036075592,
-0.35101908445358276,
-0.35013195872306824,
0.20596545934677124,
0.1973845362663269,
0.11959227919578552
] |
Subsets and Splits