id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16536v1 | C-LLM: Learn to Check Chinese Spelling Errors Character by Character | 2024-06-24T11:16:31 | 2024-06-24T11:16:31 | Kunting Li, Yong Hu, Liang He, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chinese Spell Checking (CSC) aims to detect and correct spelling errors in
sentences. Despite Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit robust capabilities and
are widely applied in various tasks, their performance on CSC is often
unsatisfactory. We find that LLMs fail to meet the Chinese character-level
constraints of the CSC task, namely equal length and phonetic similarity,
leading to a performance bottleneck. Further analysis reveal that this issue
stems from the granularity of tokenization, as current mixed character-word
tokenization struggles to satisfy these character-level constraints. To address
this issue, we propose C-LLM, a Large Language Model-based Chinese Spell
Checking method that learns to check errors Character by Character.
Character-level tokenization enables the model to learn character-level
alignment, effectively mitigating issues related to character-level
constraints. Furthermore, CSC is simplified to replication-dominated and
substitution-supplemented tasks. Experiments on two CSC benchmarks demonstrate
that C-LLM achieves an average improvement of 10% over existing methods.
Specifically, it shows a 2.1% improvement in general scenarios and a
significant 12% improvement in vertical domain scenarios, establishing
state-of-the-art performance. The source code can be accessed at
https://github.com/ktlKTL/C-LLM. | [
0.4049616754055023,
-0.6074680685997009,
0.5466833114624023,
0.299638956785202,
-0.1401844322681427,
0.3841865360736847,
-0.2044905573129654,
-0.5043367147445679,
0.14426688849925995,
0.49185463786125183,
-0.5534553527832031,
-0.9115968346595764,
-0.5388372540473938,
0.3130773901939392,
-0.30600374937057495,
0.3982439637184143,
-0.22386634349822998,
0.4619743525981903,
-0.06848219782114029,
0.2154073864221573,
-0.39095109701156616,
-0.8391214609146118,
-1.0377811193466187,
-0.14039507508277893,
0.821819543838501,
0.6378014087677002,
0.5610343217849731,
0.9288927912712097,
0.4192793071269989,
0.2660274803638458,
-0.30550819635391235,
0.81740403175354,
-0.5116071105003357,
-0.10920219123363495,
0.19747117161750793,
-0.6502882838249207,
-0.5836924314498901,
-0.11313845962285995,
0.8662581443786621,
0.7176783084869385,
-0.16588936746120453,
-0.2344408929347992,
0.1341571807861328,
0.5917869210243225,
-0.6214618682861328,
0.06620451807975769,
-0.8666467070579529,
0.03975089639425278,
-0.40921059250831604,
-0.10723687708377838,
-0.4651450514793396,
-0.3706846237182617,
-0.3151118755340576,
-0.7053992748260498,
0.3635275363922119,
0.4982442557811737,
0.8867096304893494,
0.19470538198947906,
-0.348821759223938,
-0.4109697639942169,
-0.39384153485298157,
0.6636769771575928,
-0.8755194544792175,
0.3912683427333832,
0.3671330213546753,
0.026233192533254623,
-0.3981906473636627,
-0.46142488718032837,
-0.795084536075592,
-0.3374952971935272,
0.06440266966819763,
0.14437507092952728,
0.3203512132167816,
0.6529240012168884,
0.45507603883743286,
0.58481365442276,
-0.6790215969085693,
0.47567570209503174,
-0.23798248171806335,
-0.4230116605758667,
0.37132275104522705,
0.2634388506412506,
0.9576102495193481,
-0.1121189072728157,
-0.22321954369544983,
0.024991031736135483,
-0.9723957777023315,
0.2606847286224365,
0.4310464560985565,
0.5203715562820435,
0.06351678818464279,
0.6485450267791748,
-0.0971980094909668,
0.3835239112377167,
0.2703506648540497,
-0.2943931519985199,
-0.11785061657428741,
-0.19708216190338135,
-0.3239538073539734,
0.24016276001930237,
0.4161558747291565,
0.08791385591030121,
0.0479266382753849,
-0.11345155537128448,
-0.31052640080451965,
-0.06139769032597542,
-0.01733708195388317,
-0.6911026835441589,
-0.29084935784339905,
0.29678767919540405,
-0.3323535621166229,
-0.1164255291223526,
0.13221052289009094,
-0.16976091265678406,
-0.6913133859634399,
-0.2522425651550293,
0.20662729442119598,
-0.4986145794391632,
0.1934240311384201,
0.0986081212759018,
-0.011724203824996948,
0.28226450085639954,
0.29412925243377686,
-1.0630735158920288,
0.022366071119904518,
0.9310808777809143,
0.9142372608184814,
-0.5020856857299805,
-0.5966023206710815,
-0.7706915736198425,
0.028189143165946007,
-0.580672562122345,
0.6903489828109741,
-0.09703082591295242,
-0.4698273241519928,
0.18332907557487488,
0.2245265543460846,
-0.3258267641067505,
-0.8737303018569946,
0.6534451246261597,
-0.31195640563964844,
-0.24767552316188812,
-0.6932049989700317,
-0.6859260201454163,
-0.03175090253353119,
0.43198880553245544,
-0.5597754716873169,
1.050800085067749,
-0.05944438278675079,
-0.5717194676399231,
0.4794960021972656,
-0.1407749503850937,
-0.5752498507499695,
0.34739649295806885,
0.19747944176197052,
-0.3730292320251465,
0.03479477018117905,
0.28947100043296814,
0.3427923917770386,
0.0002391615998931229,
-0.01875322125852108,
-0.38816124200820923,
-0.7488648295402527,
0.154654398560524,
-0.3231455981731415,
0.744918167591095,
0.003376397304236889,
-0.06965218484401703,
0.24586042761802673,
-0.9010738134384155,
0.023320434615015984,
-0.03844258189201355,
-0.6923852562904358,
-0.3269345760345459,
0.16379094123840332,
-0.07205008715391159,
0.07171804457902908,
0.4932631254196167,
-0.45880424976348877,
0.33229967951774597,
-0.6706685423851013,
0.2967754602432251,
0.6744481921195984,
-0.2524654269218445,
0.34162065386772156,
-0.3525375723838806,
0.417097270488739,
0.21418271958827972,
0.17823860049247742,
-0.24644802510738373,
0.0012949859956279397,
-1.150411605834961,
-0.5153345465660095,
0.2770591378211975,
0.884002685546875,
-1.0017259120941162,
0.4613384008407593,
0.014239142648875713,
-0.3062187135219574,
-0.3418619930744171,
0.3525070548057556,
0.4701303541660309,
0.2147095501422882,
0.31612923741340637,
-0.31305575370788574,
-0.5157272219657898,
-0.42626112699508667,
-0.5340158939361572,
-0.427449107170105,
0.1018911823630333,
-0.005484488792717457,
0.16775092482566833,
-0.2796367406845093,
0.4249430298805237,
-0.3468364179134369,
-0.367747038602829,
-0.35643041133880615,
-0.10668981820344925,
0.14440909028053284,
0.25001490116119385,
0.050659067928791046,
-0.40365782380104065,
-0.47987255454063416,
0.16293485462665558,
-0.4540697932243347,
-0.40933576226234436,
-0.26058605313301086,
0.07545627653598785,
0.4835538864135742,
0.5363450050354004,
-0.29424092173576355,
0.45104265213012695,
0.5447528958320618,
-0.37712976336479187,
0.9029024839401245,
-0.5316696763038635,
0.3706187307834625,
-0.8971747756004333,
-0.11767644435167313,
-0.029061853885650635,
-0.2872946262359619,
-0.7214635610580444,
0.30963513255119324,
0.4761328399181366,
0.10456761717796326,
-0.6537910103797913,
0.43031418323516846,
-0.6544653177261353,
0.08062933385372162,
-0.38344866037368774,
0.3017579913139343,
-0.12545526027679443,
0.5875617861747742,
-0.12339314073324203,
0.7386431694030762,
0.3168259561061859,
-0.6339693665504456,
0.3770730197429657,
-0.07834810763597488,
-0.23253510892391205,
0.7329714298248291,
-0.45614123344421387,
0.018614713102579117,
0.20022161304950714,
0.12743712961673737,
-0.9281830191612244,
-0.2633763253688812,
0.30044636130332947,
-0.4255451261997223,
0.5105137825012207,
0.00971693079918623,
-0.8902993202209473,
-0.5923801064491272,
-0.18541185557842255,
0.3892185688018799,
0.1056806743144989,
-1.0466980934143066,
0.6551908254623413,
-0.012344785034656525,
0.2758973240852356,
-0.7022894024848938,
-0.6122414469718933,
0.26340630650520325,
0.09746519476175308,
-0.7726674675941467,
0.296039342880249,
-0.3258332908153534,
0.11150365322828293,
-0.43095412850379944,
-0.23535124957561493,
-0.2671254277229309,
0.19854332506656647,
0.3207778334617615,
0.4681603014469147,
0.0009862103033810854,
-0.12572728097438812,
0.15544775128364563,
0.3258730173110962,
-0.11491835862398148,
-0.3490482270717621,
0.3078101575374603,
0.23913241922855377,
-0.6680925488471985,
-0.5380163192749023,
-0.011995669454336166,
0.4590916037559509,
-0.004876492545008659,
0.6154135465621948,
0.28065910935401917,
-0.6519107818603516,
-0.5823755264282227,
-0.7179355621337891,
0.09136241674423218,
-0.5167443156242371,
0.6323719620704651,
-0.21521860361099243,
-0.9411076307296753,
0.6821409463882446,
0.022892551496624947,
0.007282102946192026,
0.1883697807788849,
0.3219810724258423,
-0.15755783021450043,
0.9536694884300232,
0.5353745222091675,
-0.11111913621425629,
0.31310877203941345,
0.12357167154550552,
0.44298699498176575,
-0.5532020926475525,
-0.09542539715766907,
-0.4523991048336029,
-0.09196165204048157,
-0.47964540123939514,
-0.6255910396575928,
0.16876688599586487,
0.4263004958629608,
-0.17521224915981293,
0.42321014404296875,
-0.3180602192878723,
0.573398768901825,
0.4409036636352539,
0.246219664812088,
0.37839433550834656,
-0.10728257149457932,
-0.5171269774436951,
-0.16904893517494202,
-0.5075711607933044,
-0.3317016661167145,
0.5446823239326477,
0.2726627290248871,
0.5340099334716797,
-0.13416945934295654,
0.6051750183105469,
0.07078242301940918,
0.07953734695911407,
-0.9966538548469543,
0.6520332098007202,
-0.6328340768814087,
-0.2887292504310608,
-0.2726903259754181,
-0.442819207906723,
-0.4925633668899536,
0.23958812654018402,
-0.26642653346061707,
-0.510299026966095,
0.03841743245720863,
0.4727027714252472,
-0.18816924095153809,
0.7717106342315674,
-0.4071151614189148,
0.6717473268508911,
-0.4781433045864105,
-0.04313186928629875,
-0.1635577380657196,
-0.28332340717315674,
0.6035141944885254,
-0.26872777938842773,
0.04608535021543503,
0.08936085551977158,
0.14645586907863617,
0.2650734782218933,
-0.8519579172134399,
0.9197397232055664,
0.13044869899749756,
-0.4041469693183899,
0.282596230506897,
0.12233477830886841,
0.6752215027809143,
-0.33375057578086853,
0.03566678613424301,
0.48919248580932617,
0.2294158935546875,
-0.3777409493923187,
-0.449592262506485,
0.6912719011306763,
-0.7538409233093262,
-0.5453872680664062,
-0.5507379174232483,
-0.4269948899745941,
-0.013593582436442375,
0.24318739771842957,
0.21738731861114502,
0.12215319275856018,
-0.4302850067615509,
-0.18431925773620605,
0.7108319401741028,
-0.6632923483848572,
0.3158198893070221,
0.5264415740966797,
-0.1474827378988266,
-0.4620179533958435,
0.9782407283782959,
0.25070247054100037,
0.34776368737220764,
0.6520044803619385,
0.013122663833200932,
0.007649682927876711,
-0.7268356084823608,
-0.36158445477485657,
0.3073199689388275,
-0.7904677987098694,
0.017386527732014656,
-0.3978365659713745,
-0.44187498092651367,
-0.44841164350509644,
-0.11426039785146713,
-0.18025720119476318,
-0.050041962414979935,
-0.5590302348136902,
0.11552770435810089,
-0.20342569053173065,
0.525206446647644,
-0.00821984838694334,
0.5654988884925842,
-0.6546645164489746,
0.26307398080825806,
0.2230924516916275,
0.2799729108810425,
0.06383582949638367,
-0.6504654288291931,
-0.45944416522979736,
0.08372685313224792,
-0.5491485595703125,
-0.60761559009552,
0.5243008136749268,
0.0002318849292350933,
0.3415221869945526,
0.43008264899253845,
-0.21115238964557648,
0.9565099477767944,
-0.6113669276237488,
1.0996606349945068,
0.2674751877784729,
-1.273303747177124,
0.09361116588115692,
-0.14361239969730377,
0.25240060687065125,
0.2704472243785858,
-0.057912733405828476,
-1.334641456604004,
-0.4591706693172455,
-0.013988321647047997,
-0.7536642551422119,
0.6417930126190186,
-0.19230586290359497,
-0.22609971463680267,
-0.21316394209861755,
0.7313761711120605,
-0.2471895068883896,
-0.18335305154323578,
-0.7579589486122131,
-0.3409286439418793,
0.08780434727668762,
-0.34512224793434143,
0.09672299027442932,
-0.6235807538032532,
0.5752753615379333,
-0.002775603672489524,
1.053327202796936,
-0.30152302980422974,
-0.29017969965934753,
0.2854739725589752,
-0.4528948664665222,
-0.2198152393102646,
0.17915575206279755,
0.7378019690513611,
0.41479629278182983,
0.26520010828971863,
0.09595301002264023,
0.7573519349098206,
-0.6898619532585144,
-0.16932883858680725,
-0.16612489521503448,
-0.14013749361038208,
-0.14943134784698486,
0.5041043758392334,
0.5271573066711426,
0.40261027216911316,
-0.6462401151657104,
0.5375929474830627,
-0.0003308567975182086,
-0.40993213653564453,
-0.2440401166677475,
0.02471156045794487,
0.1636335402727127,
0.14508116245269775,
0.36678770184516907,
-0.3136497437953949,
-0.0551971010863781,
-0.35385891795158386,
-0.10145165771245956,
0.5282775163650513,
-0.376112163066864,
-0.15634925663471222,
0.6129055619239807,
0.02738693356513977,
-0.21646010875701904,
0.7139161229133606,
-0.18618394434452057,
-0.9767568707466125,
0.7972702383995056,
0.3986324071884155,
0.8234394192695618,
-0.37485310435295105,
-0.015852106735110283,
0.5265086889266968,
0.5080848336219788,
-0.5694916844367981,
0.15577749907970428,
0.2336343228816986,
-0.6187868714332581,
-0.4329809844493866,
-0.5012903213500977,
-0.5927460789680481,
-0.145381361246109,
-0.17052370309829712,
0.7829530239105225,
-0.7159801721572876,
0.1949283331632614,
-0.46048063039779663,
0.26321831345558167,
-0.5058335661888123,
0.22886145114898682,
0.3618246614933014,
0.8038685321807861,
-0.5245440006256104,
0.8921512961387634,
0.2754085958003998,
-0.2567160725593567,
-1.2657980918884277,
0.05809139832854271,
0.19857646524906158,
-1.1207636594772339,
0.7670881152153015,
0.24602608382701874,
-0.06728953868150711,
-0.2858535647392273,
-0.6326589584350586,
-0.7657896876335144,
1.2210298776626587,
0.17361634969711304,
-1.1187610626220703,
-0.34545549750328064,
0.4089576303958893,
0.5800809264183044,
-0.2107626050710678,
0.1939876824617386,
0.3743581771850586,
0.3963068425655365,
0.26822173595428467,
-1.0206084251403809,
-0.049247972667217255,
0.2801736295223236,
0.25423887372016907,
-0.08994915336370468,
-0.7555610537528992,
0.7090457677841187,
-0.2880139648914337,
-0.5757800936698914,
0.4213991165161133,
0.8812673091888428,
0.39368438720703125,
0.37195324897766113,
0.6198341250419617,
0.5252760648727417,
1.25139319896698,
-0.1371140480041504,
0.6106049418449402,
-0.4149942994117737,
0.2303512990474701,
1.0184743404388428,
-0.4550774395465851,
0.808795690536499,
0.2534978687763214,
-0.02650800719857216,
0.4434714615345001,
0.9068173170089722,
-0.17443664371967316,
-0.04816703870892525,
0.6635200381278992,
-0.28233593702316284,
-0.473974347114563,
0.08792863041162491,
0.17660461366176605,
0.22434081137180328,
0.29008689522743225,
-0.2551504373550415,
0.18030673265457153,
-0.21798092126846313,
-0.001336362212896347,
0.3441343307495117,
-0.7093833088874817,
0.5067216753959656,
0.292664498090744,
-0.49239078164100647,
0.4867474138736725,
0.27391085028648376,
1.116161823272705,
-0.41855546832084656,
0.0011842153035104275,
-0.33344799280166626,
0.22705820202827454,
-0.31336796283721924,
-0.16184788942337036,
0.013842559419572353,
-0.07512397319078445,
-0.3932079076766968,
0.09046176820993423,
0.6707566976547241,
-0.8754204511642456,
-0.5537239909172058,
0.29023829102516174,
0.12122389674186707,
0.22032727301120758,
-0.05331024155020714,
-0.6391059756278992,
0.0706433579325676,
-0.11930780857801437,
0.426162451505661,
0.09441474080085754,
0.36818569898605347,
-0.16552534699440002,
0.7103157043457031,
0.6353477835655212,
0.5105211734771729,
0.12999404966831207,
0.1746092289686203,
0.277447372674942,
-0.6195388436317444,
-0.39072534441947937,
-0.89841228723526,
0.09023860841989517,
0.19364634156227112,
-0.058363161981105804,
0.7568696141242981,
0.542987048625946,
0.9628486037254333,
0.06426538527011871,
0.5521804094314575,
0.4943731129169464,
0.5231538414955139,
-0.5260594487190247,
0.8721458911895752,
-0.6244356632232666,
0.38324427604675293,
-0.16480527818202972,
-0.7414512038230896,
-0.6211726069450378,
0.16446511447429657,
-0.11713027954101562,
-0.14649872481822968,
0.996767520904541,
1.151606559753418,
0.30009812116622925,
-0.19601471722126007,
0.8291796445846558,
0.13334013521671295,
0.3015226125717163,
0.8131518959999084,
0.833412766456604,
-0.4677678048610687,
0.55080646276474,
0.027110321447253227,
-0.09142038226127625,
-0.20354223251342773,
-0.8537454605102539,
-1.2560497522354126,
-0.41791707277297974,
-0.41698867082595825,
-0.557486355304718,
0.26039010286331177,
1.137654185295105,
0.5249592661857605,
-0.7327706813812256,
-0.14844495058059692,
0.10303215682506561,
0.5098292827606201,
-0.4391331076622009,
-0.1604827642440796,
0.4190847873687744,
-0.5210428833961487,
-0.9391494393348694,
0.340385764837265,
0.3584405481815338,
-0.04821363091468811,
-0.19686183333396912,
-0.14725494384765625,
0.03002861514687538,
0.28817319869995117,
0.389656126499176,
0.3627512753009796,
-1.0365750789642334,
-0.4821053743362427,
0.23077194392681122,
-0.5886608958244324,
0.03755692392587662,
1.0168265104293823,
-0.12490289658308029,
0.4511566162109375,
0.45908260345458984,
0.660411536693573,
0.008224059827625751,
-0.19624876976013184,
0.3444300889968872,
-0.7356724143028259,
-0.4118790328502655,
-0.30463653802871704,
0.6581092476844788,
0.5317214727401733,
-0.7631525993347168,
0.004323026165366173,
0.4147145748138428,
-0.7346328496932983,
-0.6223234534263611,
0.00991256907582283,
-1.08413827419281,
-0.19520895183086395,
1.2608078718185425,
-0.2783498764038086,
-0.4620817005634308,
0.0358300544321537,
-0.4494990110397339,
0.5431956648826599,
-0.09345952421426773,
0.7304509282112122,
0.9479451775550842,
0.5390497446060181,
-0.08489854633808136,
-0.08832651376724243,
0.5147221684455872,
0.42949607968330383,
-0.5785726308822632,
0.2800520360469818,
0.5121232271194458,
0.5821514129638672,
-0.18573223054409027,
0.4337432086467743,
0.013805790804326534,
0.4569110572338104,
-0.355951189994812,
0.5449859499931335,
0.060338132083415985,
-0.08821873366832733,
-0.4453502893447876,
0.005298892967402935,
0.237473264336586,
0.01939362846314907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16535v1 | Token-based Decision Criteria Are Suboptimal in In-context Learning | 2024-06-24T11:16:26 | 2024-06-24T11:16:26 | Hakaze Cho, Yoshihiro Sakai, Mariko Kato, Kenshiro Tanaka, Akira Ishii, Naoya Inoue | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In-Context Learning (ICL) typically utilizes classification criteria from
probabilities of manually selected label tokens. However, we argue that such
token-based classification criteria lead to suboptimal decision boundaries,
despite delicate calibrations through translation and constrained rotation. To
address this problem, we propose Hidden Calibration, which renounces token
probabilities and uses the nearest centroid classifier on the LM's last hidden
states. In detail, we use the nearest centroid classification on the hidden
states, assigning the category of the nearest centroid previously observed from
a few-shot calibration set to the test sample as the predicted label. Our
experiments on 3 models and 10 classification datasets indicate that Hidden
Calibration consistently outperforms current token-based calibrations by about
20%. Our further analysis demonstrates that Hidden Calibration finds better
classification criteria with less inter-categories overlap, and LMs provide
linearly separable intra-category clusters with the help of demonstrations,
which supports Hidden Calibration and gives new insights into the conventional
ICL. | [
-0.45887938141822815,
-0.13837893307209015,
0.42736613750457764,
-0.4095616936683655,
-0.36410465836524963,
0.31536445021629333,
-0.23647883534431458,
-0.2783195674419403,
-0.017699316143989563,
0.336769700050354,
-0.5518693923950195,
-0.7305810451507568,
-0.27699729800224304,
-0.15681590139865875,
0.02759629487991333,
1.1216250658035278,
0.06891747564077377,
0.2105042189359665,
-0.5579649806022644,
-0.5004550814628601,
-0.6359817981719971,
-0.8584192395210266,
-0.18356142938137054,
-0.6474928855895996,
0.5222018957138062,
0.8340176343917847,
0.4871184229850769,
0.24170809984207153,
0.17311377823352814,
0.095767542719841,
-0.4249252378940582,
0.2230990082025528,
-0.38750630617141724,
-0.5605762600898743,
-0.3863923251628876,
-0.9812196493148804,
-0.12541252374649048,
0.3600083291530609,
0.37059664726257324,
0.8321660757064819,
0.16741633415222168,
0.38139259815216064,
0.2683333158493042,
0.7656211853027344,
-0.8577333688735962,
0.2582172155380249,
-0.7026613354682922,
0.48855236172676086,
-0.11851835995912552,
-0.12921825051307678,
-0.7276290059089661,
-0.37795260548591614,
0.11714427173137665,
-0.42565056681632996,
0.1082536056637764,
0.08717907965183258,
0.480683833360672,
0.46743932366371155,
-0.5655891299247742,
-0.1741524189710617,
-0.3934817910194397,
0.8139934539794922,
-0.27010297775268555,
0.42277637124061584,
0.7893068194389343,
0.614152193069458,
-0.054302554577589035,
-0.568092942237854,
-0.3083568215370178,
-0.10259297490119934,
-0.11943145096302032,
0.06349456310272217,
0.1843995302915573,
0.12356490641832352,
0.3433636724948883,
0.1745113879442215,
-0.0268799290060997,
0.32702791690826416,
-0.31325438618659973,
-0.4689958691596985,
0.08018730580806732,
-0.051462579518556595,
-0.20008346438407898,
0.022032788023352623,
-0.6547448039054871,
-0.22208835184574127,
-1.1655644178390503,
0.40320831537246704,
0.22942093014717102,
0.5410543084144592,
-0.15059028565883636,
0.41962942481040955,
0.09703445434570312,
0.49486294388771057,
0.3944266140460968,
-0.28042590618133545,
0.3658542335033417,
-0.2597105801105499,
-0.24945543706417084,
0.34902074933052063,
0.17794956266880035,
0.29952123761177063,
-0.23939064145088196,
-0.15255551040172577,
-0.3283160924911499,
-0.15941892564296722,
-0.153118297457695,
-0.6140277981758118,
0.029096294194459915,
-0.07320922613143921,
-0.35170266032218933,
-0.4299459159374237,
0.0826430469751358,
-0.24909467995166779,
-0.3030552268028259,
-0.44782450795173645,
0.6058317422866821,
-0.19934529066085815,
0.25676271319389343,
-0.472797691822052,
-0.08837143331766129,
0.2419324517250061,
0.29374372959136963,
-0.6292051672935486,
0.13196024298667908,
0.590079128742218,
0.7930219769477844,
-0.2698943316936493,
-0.020391665399074554,
-0.6228305697441101,
-0.21176627278327942,
-0.7818368077278137,
0.3363667130470276,
-0.5185784101486206,
-0.3993118703365326,
-0.23192544281482697,
-0.12450175732374191,
0.017750950530171394,
-0.7475317120552063,
0.4003342092037201,
-0.5873000025749207,
0.047719523310661316,
-0.6809187531471252,
-0.49656936526298523,
-0.46083584427833557,
0.2884088456630707,
-0.3893696069717407,
1.031477928161621,
0.14075618982315063,
-0.6965561509132385,
1.0748220682144165,
-0.33687999844551086,
-0.014218542724847794,
0.37281444668769836,
-0.4928952157497406,
-0.31820163130760193,
0.07432898879051208,
0.18783263862133026,
0.23299884796142578,
-0.0013206019066274166,
0.45756468176841736,
-0.40940117835998535,
-0.8032528162002563,
0.3060707747936249,
-0.8134189248085022,
0.6690150499343872,
0.04318062216043472,
-0.6158061623573303,
0.0781654343008995,
-0.5866057872772217,
0.13185201585292816,
-0.8543810844421387,
-0.5216999053955078,
-0.26083672046661377,
-0.06945258378982544,
-0.16673415899276733,
0.29750216007232666,
0.11572270095348358,
-0.7141464948654175,
-0.13746853172779083,
-0.4865894615650177,
0.2082831710577011,
0.8367077708244324,
-0.21526813507080078,
0.7674996852874756,
-0.41061243414878845,
0.24075476825237274,
0.3617033362388611,
0.27147790789604187,
0.021910730749368668,
-0.4067933261394501,
-0.7368925213813782,
-0.27506640553474426,
0.48812952637672424,
0.36617666482925415,
-0.9250714778900146,
0.6304081082344055,
-0.011623825877904892,
-0.6933417320251465,
-0.09517297148704529,
-0.10141593962907791,
0.5985942482948303,
1.0529131889343262,
0.42423948645591736,
-0.22478170692920685,
-0.10137051343917847,
-0.6666649580001831,
-0.2672232687473297,
-0.16873577237129211,
0.10760626196861267,
0.6254506707191467,
0.4493820071220398,
-0.30426129698753357,
1.2225804328918457,
-0.016064569354057312,
-0.7648471593856812,
-0.05007350817322731,
-0.02270122617483139,
0.355045884847641,
0.504249095916748,
0.49999356269836426,
-0.8395150899887085,
-0.4343103766441345,
0.12882119417190552,
-0.49130967259407043,
0.03692753240466118,
0.03644799068570137,
0.041135530918836594,
0.3670719861984253,
0.740761399269104,
-0.21862947940826416,
1.1681326627731323,
-0.03845832124352455,
-0.20237119495868683,
0.4123331606388092,
-0.3489818274974823,
-0.2596176564693451,
-0.34739452600479126,
-0.09199313074350357,
-0.28597262501716614,
-0.32244816422462463,
-0.08591364324092865,
0.09556417167186737,
0.6309041976928711,
0.054588016122579575,
-0.8409258723258972,
0.6505373120307922,
-0.29575076699256897,
-0.18917544186115265,
-0.22653914988040924,
0.01251009851694107,
-0.08367384970188141,
0.6405988931655884,
-0.0869087502360344,
0.737007737159729,
0.6840791702270508,
-0.7418968081474304,
-0.12463536113500595,
-0.06788738071918488,
-0.5495311617851257,
0.5453460216522217,
0.04483288154006004,
0.029856692999601364,
-0.28662607073783875,
0.7599954605102539,
-0.798435389995575,
0.09027168154716492,
0.15335850417613983,
-0.16295471787452698,
0.36414822936058044,
-0.31657591462135315,
-0.35648730397224426,
-0.29123637080192566,
-0.4085291028022766,
0.9317476749420166,
0.2823866307735443,
-0.954545259475708,
0.4666975438594818,
0.4697577655315399,
0.7143511176109314,
-0.7655313014984131,
-0.8863996863365173,
-0.27619004249572754,
-0.24250705540180206,
0.3434262275695801,
0.45139673352241516,
-0.2656477093696594,
0.10908062011003494,
-0.10112833231687546,
-0.34350523352622986,
0.2631504237651825,
-0.064021535217762,
0.7079948782920837,
0.1338493973016739,
-0.15058715641498566,
0.3844965100288391,
0.2294524610042572,
-0.20161084830760956,
-0.1551828235387802,
-0.36847826838493347,
0.37449732422828674,
-0.43521586060523987,
-0.7091021537780762,
-0.5274776816368103,
0.005526668392121792,
0.7490243315696716,
-0.10016245394945145,
0.49442803859710693,
0.5988043546676636,
-0.6157670021057129,
-0.24132512509822845,
-0.3115091919898987,
-0.19267992675304413,
-0.5158872008323669,
0.24442973732948303,
-0.3858841359615326,
-0.5461689829826355,
0.6600414514541626,
-0.04854709282517433,
0.0744142010807991,
0.34712889790534973,
0.3973591923713684,
0.11393669247627258,
1.1317249536514282,
0.7064475417137146,
0.0714343786239624,
0.5279238224029541,
-0.36727896332740784,
0.21640361845493317,
-1.1070411205291748,
-0.6821916103363037,
-0.26118946075439453,
-0.562169075012207,
-0.6709046363830566,
-0.5269365310668945,
0.7899768948554993,
0.25296974182128906,
-0.4132923185825348,
0.1407080441713333,
-0.5167413949966431,
0.8541128635406494,
0.808102011680603,
0.7371439337730408,
-0.17596188187599182,
-0.11303762346506119,
-1.1149020195007324,
-0.17192231118679047,
-0.85780930519104,
-0.2608032524585724,
1.1059117317199707,
0.19364012777805328,
0.4758957326412201,
-0.07687113434076309,
0.8178556561470032,
0.2831275463104248,
0.8107926249504089,
-0.9026691913604736,
0.5270275473594666,
-0.06969219446182251,
-0.6153179407119751,
-0.25746017694473267,
-0.3629770874977112,
-0.49370336532592773,
0.3873771131038666,
-0.08317544311285019,
-0.8996155858039856,
0.5864378213882446,
0.030763080343604088,
-0.5173227190971375,
0.5469212532043457,
-0.7099497318267822,
0.6437704563140869,
-0.35447052121162415,
-0.24057093262672424,
-0.06346647441387177,
-0.5993114709854126,
0.07181151956319809,
-0.3410722017288208,
0.49912917613983154,
-0.14542368054389954,
-0.004918561317026615,
0.6355805993080139,
-0.8079801797866821,
1.1768778562545776,
-0.4463815987110138,
0.44345173239707947,
0.4950779378414154,
0.11341501772403717,
0.29755693674087524,
0.20090804994106293,
-0.1520165354013443,
0.09770683944225311,
0.28786686062812805,
-0.2959838807582855,
-0.39570701122283936,
0.6686597466468811,
-0.6533671617507935,
-0.5628204941749573,
-0.5857087969779968,
-0.24525226652622223,
-0.3911450207233429,
0.27734261751174927,
0.4969319701194763,
0.6670292615890503,
0.2538842558860779,
0.4221563935279846,
0.40249380469322205,
-0.3729773461818695,
0.7356786727905273,
0.2285011112689972,
-0.14910802245140076,
-0.5087202787399292,
1.002087950706482,
0.34753450751304626,
0.08113525062799454,
0.5385217070579529,
0.572536826133728,
-0.46411943435668945,
-0.21721869707107544,
-0.4977981150150299,
0.0140462014824152,
-1.2732386589050293,
-0.7372214794158936,
0.07090064883232117,
-0.24122963845729828,
0.0097081633284688,
-0.3362713158130646,
-0.2639077603816986,
-0.3033611476421356,
-0.7281493544578552,
-0.5274794101715088,
-0.08252130448818207,
0.5783601999282837,
-0.20341600477695465,
0.161732479929924,
-0.5493761897087097,
-0.30695655941963196,
0.15409016609191895,
0.48325350880622864,
0.09908175468444824,
-0.5821231603622437,
-0.33137214183807373,
0.2503896951675415,
-0.18155480921268463,
-0.5840429663658142,
0.16040319204330444,
0.4552459418773651,
0.6060920357704163,
0.6080725193023682,
0.46738559007644653,
1.0042579174041748,
-0.3567843735218048,
0.6185166835784912,
0.30829301476478577,
-0.9681248664855957,
0.3378101885318756,
0.21919234097003937,
0.4761638045310974,
0.914681077003479,
0.20901493728160858,
-0.3392341136932373,
-0.09653240442276001,
-0.46265822649002075,
-0.788652241230011,
0.9665353298187256,
-0.236288920044899,
0.1790432631969452,
-0.0377114862203598,
0.5704981088638306,
0.39705678820610046,
0.09763183444738388,
-0.8170018196105957,
-0.3325379490852356,
-0.046889930963516235,
-0.23474030196666718,
-0.09323059022426605,
-0.003497959580272436,
-0.10181781649589539,
-0.6337893009185791,
0.3510284125804901,
-0.5110814571380615,
-0.06014310568571091,
0.3141680955886841,
-0.2170381397008896,
-0.1542738676071167,
-0.23847220838069916,
0.3898794651031494,
0.6795383095741272,
-0.20168623328208923,
0.3577032685279846,
0.6275306940078735,
-0.4023575484752655,
-0.08295165747404099,
-0.42410072684288025,
-0.46003255248069763,
-0.1713535487651825,
0.18170514702796936,
0.7138967514038086,
0.7074792981147766,
-0.6624540686607361,
0.9773423075675964,
-0.15009558200836182,
0.010303134098649025,
-0.33433598279953003,
0.14243493974208832,
-0.5045675039291382,
0.17945560812950134,
0.6643288135528564,
0.6119109392166138,
-0.13099807500839233,
-0.5403570532798767,
0.4835124909877777,
0.6041417121887207,
-1.092816948890686,
-0.23385900259017944,
0.6958219408988953,
-0.04778687655925751,
-0.2818819284439087,
0.3561975359916687,
-0.18139131367206573,
-0.7042141556739807,
0.6088939905166626,
0.5110777020454407,
0.7192223072052002,
0.3177509307861328,
0.4221344292163849,
0.3510284721851349,
0.19297544658184052,
0.08477141708135605,
-0.022553516551852226,
-0.7291570901870728,
-0.5105777978897095,
0.0856202095746994,
-0.6191437244415283,
-0.6571230292320251,
-0.11444515734910965,
-0.7619930505752563,
0.46164029836654663,
-0.682338535785675,
-0.30069172382354736,
-0.2854441702365875,
-0.0021109371446073055,
-0.8437976241111755,
0.3637535870075226,
0.1822187304496765,
1.023687720298767,
-0.6511839628219604,
0.8418428897857666,
0.40833720564842224,
-0.0021608900278806686,
-0.7292805314064026,
-0.19759896397590637,
-0.04764696955680847,
-0.6424511075019836,
0.7404814958572388,
0.627934992313385,
-0.2490260899066925,
-0.25378838181495667,
-0.5680728554725647,
-1.020236611366272,
1.1637324094772339,
0.346717894077301,
-0.29269832372665405,
0.04159616678953171,
0.24851834774017334,
0.5022323727607727,
-0.3873235583305359,
0.5266403555870056,
0.3027665317058563,
0.17723776400089264,
0.33221128582954407,
-0.9114579558372498,
-0.08878893405199051,
0.23539115488529205,
-0.2514101564884186,
-0.07204591482877731,
-0.7337606549263,
0.8055425882339478,
-0.33017632365226746,
-0.37682849168777466,
-0.3197048604488373,
0.3951179087162018,
0.2784564793109894,
0.5993017554283142,
0.4758359491825104,
0.348222553730011,
0.8740869760513306,
-0.17448872327804565,
0.7227333784103394,
-0.06005965545773506,
0.44516482949256897,
0.8974459767341614,
-0.07024309039115906,
0.9441297054290771,
0.5797767639160156,
0.07662642747163773,
0.5942507982254028,
1.1952145099639893,
0.5027915239334106,
0.7729820609092712,
0.07720628380775452,
-0.18674810230731964,
-0.3891369700431824,
-0.034093692898750305,
-0.10376408696174622,
0.577447772026062,
0.7279834747314453,
-0.0688524916768074,
-0.32645049691200256,
0.3067852854728699,
-0.2435183823108673,
-0.21742510795593262,
-0.7238534092903137,
0.5086230039596558,
0.15115314722061157,
-0.7794694304466248,
0.5837058424949646,
-0.029884779825806618,
0.5986363291740417,
-0.0795736163854599,
0.028913332149386406,
-0.41201284527778625,
0.448946475982666,
-0.4155173599720001,
-0.4900549650192261,
0.03443107008934021,
-0.4025822877883911,
0.122743621468544,
-0.19230777025222778,
0.43141356110572815,
-0.32519999146461487,
-0.386942058801651,
0.11600601673126221,
0.15621627867221832,
0.1308407336473465,
-0.03134411200881004,
-0.4204496443271637,
-0.4037102460861206,
-0.13101881742477417,
0.09206120669841766,
0.5867317318916321,
0.3916969895362854,
-0.48178038001060486,
0.6422904133796692,
0.6040650606155396,
-0.12453002482652664,
0.22218626737594604,
-0.0013512801378965378,
0.8048185706138611,
-0.4584227502346039,
-0.7925078272819519,
-0.5895166397094727,
0.006678684148937464,
0.29636523127555847,
-0.4886515736579895,
0.3839496970176697,
0.6362801790237427,
1.247776985168457,
0.22456952929496765,
0.22199638187885284,
0.42214086651802063,
0.3110116124153137,
-0.5274484157562256,
0.8524737358093262,
-0.6263392567634583,
0.4977520704269409,
0.0232990849763155,
-0.5334991216659546,
-0.7051088213920593,
0.5294720530509949,
-0.410448282957077,
-0.03412061557173729,
0.6054918169975281,
0.6590242385864258,
-0.10298626124858856,
-0.1971595287322998,
0.6623194813728333,
-0.3177812397480011,
0.11163013428449631,
0.5073962807655334,
0.7044216394424438,
-0.43201470375061035,
0.34810954332351685,
-0.445315420627594,
-0.5242764949798584,
-0.423143595457077,
-0.7405496835708618,
-1.0850480794906616,
-0.6799504160881042,
-0.20367346704006195,
-0.035000987350940704,
-0.46788474917411804,
0.9905987977981567,
0.9236696362495422,
-0.9585224390029907,
0.05435102432966232,
-0.21925577521324158,
0.5514025092124939,
-0.26942652463912964,
-0.2312525063753128,
0.49826401472091675,
-0.29257696866989136,
-0.5945727825164795,
0.41994863748550415,
0.4603188931941986,
0.10717958211898804,
-0.08898793905973434,
-0.13223707675933838,
0.17750363051891327,
-0.02612905763089657,
0.6021866798400879,
0.27095818519592285,
-0.8903453350067139,
-0.5966996550559998,
-0.15118567645549774,
-0.10279549658298492,
0.18295085430145264,
0.8190314173698425,
-1.354074239730835,
0.6967342495918274,
0.1763594150543213,
0.4607737958431244,
0.7356905341148376,
-0.15912143886089325,
-0.020600909367203712,
-1.0624704360961914,
0.3945813775062561,
0.45922279357910156,
0.3146125078201294,
0.14081686735153198,
-0.29218146204948425,
0.12112189084291458,
0.2359793484210968,
-0.301425039768219,
-1.1239718198776245,
0.16706380248069763,
-0.41468438506126404,
-0.17954221367835999,
0.8574930429458618,
-0.1302529275417328,
-0.4457436800003052,
-0.124962218105793,
-0.17688654363155365,
0.22692221403121948,
-0.02864169143140316,
0.7326394319534302,
0.47248658537864685,
-0.3006884753704071,
0.05830080434679985,
-0.18976163864135742,
0.7464892268180847,
0.42945390939712524,
-0.19512943923473358,
-0.1862545907497406,
0.2540437877178192,
0.19409024715423584,
0.1290988177061081,
0.2678234875202179,
-0.27959567308425903,
0.3737712502479553,
-0.13493254780769348,
-0.3844614326953888,
0.047675877809524536,
-0.6310842037200928,
-0.310823917388916,
0.2242799997329712,
0.0008195416303351521,
-0.3647162616252899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16529v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16529v1 | Towards Better Graph-based Cross-document Relation Extraction via Non-bridge Entity Enhancement and Prediction Debiasing | 2024-06-24T11:08:28 | 2024-06-24T11:08:28 | Hao Yue, Shaopeng Lai, Chengyi Yang, Liang Zhang, Junfeng Yao, Jinsong Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-document Relation Extraction aims to predict the relation between
target entities located in different documents. In this regard, the dominant
models commonly retain useful information for relation prediction via bridge
entities, which allows the model to elaborately capture the intrinsic
interdependence between target entities. However, these studies ignore the
non-bridge entities, each of which co-occurs with only one target entity and
offers the semantic association between target entities for relation
prediction. Besides, the commonly-used dataset--CodRED contains substantial NA
instances, leading to the prediction bias during inference. To address these
issues, in this paper, we propose a novel graph-based cross-document RE model
with non-bridge entity enhancement and prediction debiasing. Specifically, we
use a unified entity graph to integrate numerous non-bridge entities with
target entities and bridge entities, modeling various associations between
them, and then use a graph recurrent network to encode this graph. Finally, we
introduce a novel debiasing strategy to calibrate the original prediction
distribution. Experimental results on the closed and open settings show that
our model significantly outperforms all baselines, including the GPT-3.5-turbo
and InstructUIE, achieving state-of-the-art performance. Particularly, our
model obtains 66.23% and 55.87% AUC points in the official
leaderboard\footnote{\url{https://codalab.lisn.upsaclay.fr/competitions/3770#results}}
under the two settings, respectively, ranking the first place in all
submissions since December 2023. Our code is available at
https://github.com/DeepLearnXMU/CoRE-NEPD. | [
-0.5871431827545166,
-0.7200074791908264,
0.424639493227005,
-0.2238531857728958,
-0.32136112451553345,
0.10799983888864517,
-0.005813262425363064,
-0.7010893225669861,
0.40825986862182617,
0.5511007905006409,
-0.428802490234375,
-0.715695321559906,
-0.8994487524032593,
0.08832632005214691,
-0.3445527255535126,
1.0043151378631592,
-0.09628085047006607,
-0.0014737581368535757,
-0.2282506376504898,
-0.1123250424861908,
-0.41104936599731445,
-0.3251103162765503,
-0.5002998113632202,
-0.675030529499054,
0.2968578636646271,
0.22799943387508392,
0.5508797764778137,
0.2601574659347534,
0.2089337259531021,
0.12277473509311676,
0.07757111638784409,
0.12085341662168503,
-0.5051494240760803,
-0.009474101476371288,
-0.3376758098602295,
-0.09368635714054108,
-0.7895882725715637,
0.14764700829982758,
0.46244949102401733,
0.7521860003471375,
0.15095724165439606,
-0.08191423863172531,
0.16398108005523682,
0.5794833898544312,
-0.4875674545764923,
0.6617286205291748,
-0.8378645777702332,
-0.10586380958557129,
-0.06140200421214104,
0.0010447577806189656,
-0.5364009141921997,
0.028908774256706238,
0.1287401020526886,
-0.7660263776779175,
0.4640139043331146,
-0.013254205696284771,
1.2326321601867676,
0.10016663372516632,
-0.44331520795822144,
0.12196352332830429,
-0.3734888434410095,
0.5731244683265686,
-0.6132933497428894,
0.7708474397659302,
0.35091617703437805,
0.08393219113349915,
-0.21330887079238892,
-0.8427806496620178,
-0.21564583480358124,
-0.10778521746397018,
-0.06721988320350647,
0.30388233065605164,
-0.49557602405548096,
0.031761910766363144,
0.17507480084896088,
0.4056869447231293,
-0.42582398653030396,
0.08689301460981369,
-0.10912799090147018,
-0.103899747133255,
0.4460414946079254,
-0.08813901245594025,
0.23234042525291443,
-0.2667449116706848,
-0.5095851421356201,
0.12454743683338165,
-0.5400527715682983,
-0.1847933977842331,
0.25000616908073425,
0.38701140880584717,
-0.13222438097000122,
0.27826613187789917,
-0.12377242743968964,
0.5044003129005432,
0.46932530403137207,
0.11649898439645767,
0.5767292380332947,
-0.20125064253807068,
-0.2774953246116638,
0.08122056722640991,
0.7925623655319214,
0.4544753134250641,
0.45095789432525635,
-0.5320519804954529,
-0.1639430671930313,
0.22238154709339142,
0.10350944846868515,
-0.7956187129020691,
-0.4333139955997467,
-0.14017485082149506,
-0.4629676342010498,
-0.26138246059417725,
0.020389236509799957,
-1.1085710525512695,
-0.13704697787761688,
-0.2326943576335907,
-0.24382182955741882,
-0.5114592909812927,
-0.44639137387275696,
-0.2418871819972992,
-0.12259072065353394,
-0.21296343207359314,
0.33614087104797363,
-0.8040001392364502,
0.4581719636917114,
0.5063304901123047,
0.8850460648536682,
-0.15200278162956238,
-0.23205235600471497,
-0.6438196897506714,
0.30718061327934265,
-0.07480747997760773,
0.8119475245475769,
-0.786974310874939,
-0.6155349016189575,
-0.35269302129745483,
0.09727517515420914,
-0.2373409867286682,
-0.23296034336090088,
0.551572322845459,
-0.7243832349777222,
-0.01966179721057415,
0.0017135117668658495,
-0.6299042701721191,
-0.14924350380897522,
0.40732720494270325,
-1.2308924198150635,
1.0573900938034058,
0.37341704964637756,
-1.0163979530334473,
0.32916808128356934,
-0.38585174083709717,
-0.4344993233680725,
-0.2962964177131653,
-0.11219050735235214,
-0.6394203305244446,
-0.2608056664466858,
0.8662793636322021,
0.10037658363580704,
-0.6651002764701843,
0.2935713827610016,
-0.8841490149497986,
-0.14498069882392883,
-0.3135679066181183,
-0.30431458353996277,
0.6664999127388,
0.010062377899885178,
-0.3279840052127838,
0.005516601726412773,
-0.632443904876709,
-0.004552213940769434,
0.05352688208222389,
-0.08306214213371277,
-0.4018671214580536,
-0.6140349507331848,
-0.08436165750026703,
0.3940598666667938,
-0.024294978007674217,
-0.8261642456054688,
0.21230477094650269,
-0.5685833692550659,
0.29844143986701965,
0.6138767600059509,
0.49874910712242126,
0.7936097979545593,
-0.07028382271528244,
0.8062665462493896,
-0.013057597912847996,
0.046139251440763474,
0.1479257047176361,
-0.5322892665863037,
-0.06604825705289841,
-0.09595519304275513,
0.8014203310012817,
0.378212571144104,
-0.7736456394195557,
0.20173507928848267,
-0.5573965311050415,
-0.6220867037773132,
-0.25080370903015137,
0.3826172649860382,
0.41498902440071106,
0.9815007448196411,
0.6139987111091614,
-0.5192235708236694,
-0.6715278625488281,
-0.6318053007125854,
-0.1432826966047287,
-0.07292070239782333,
0.23771654069423676,
0.34025508165359497,
0.4149992763996124,
-0.27744561433792114,
0.9045921564102173,
-0.6281432509422302,
-0.6201627850532532,
-0.3992346227169037,
0.28377270698547363,
0.24796387553215027,
0.3086493909358978,
0.6811646819114685,
-0.7528462409973145,
-0.5866953134536743,
-0.14649127423763275,
-0.7273233532905579,
-0.08882448077201843,
0.03093518130481243,
-0.27359724044799805,
0.28982865810394287,
0.40055304765701294,
-0.7632388472557068,
0.6637962460517883,
0.4699937105178833,
0.05655423551797867,
0.10769616812467575,
-0.007435361854732037,
-0.22760331630706787,
-1.0438610315322876,
0.028892740607261658,
0.2830776870250702,
-0.10981748253107071,
-0.2227686643600464,
-0.321076899766922,
0.010617226362228394,
-0.23978252708911896,
-0.00572583032771945,
0.6984863877296448,
-0.8633357286453247,
-0.2832559645175934,
-0.17117182910442352,
0.5122226476669312,
0.4166407585144043,
0.4745309054851532,
0.2517326772212982,
0.2277526706457138,
0.505843460559845,
-0.13985739648342133,
0.1946467012166977,
0.5192548036575317,
-0.17514066398143768,
0.33713018894195557,
-0.5201891660690308,
0.19307616353034973,
-0.10062558948993683,
0.7263807654380798,
-0.8026167750358582,
0.40644416213035583,
0.3216913044452667,
-0.6658529043197632,
0.7034200429916382,
-0.6023264527320862,
-0.34278178215026855,
-0.212201789021492,
-0.15599000453948975,
0.2549715042114258,
0.10861209034919739,
-0.43453657627105713,
0.9092645049095154,
0.603302538394928,
0.013686411082744598,
-0.8260007500648499,
-0.6285833716392517,
0.21984794735908508,
0.19438083469867706,
-0.6857338547706604,
0.5716442465782166,
0.3639944791793823,
0.030617352575063705,
0.4586035907268524,
-0.3535824418067932,
-0.09032656997442245,
0.011122964322566986,
0.5609435439109802,
0.6175342798233032,
-0.07084865868091583,
0.18963421881198883,
0.0758814588189125,
-0.670943021774292,
-0.07439985126256943,
-0.4243481159210205,
0.39946964383125305,
0.09194406867027283,
-0.22445033490657806,
-0.04683353006839752,
0.30813103914260864,
0.39807096123695374,
-0.46288254857063293,
0.3545163571834564,
0.4979496896266937,
-0.5027477741241455,
-0.1706225574016571,
-0.2558808922767639,
-0.1748587191104889,
-0.302461177110672,
0.2715350389480591,
-0.5404474139213562,
-0.4102780818939209,
0.4254751205444336,
-0.11585282534360886,
0.06920138001441956,
0.5274587273597717,
0.19848264753818512,
0.27191779017448425,
0.6338676810264587,
0.48133111000061035,
-0.5492104887962341,
0.4921923279762268,
-0.7011298537254333,
0.20972315967082977,
-1.0830049514770508,
-0.19948410987854004,
-0.23913192749023438,
-0.2906886339187622,
-0.5235730409622192,
-0.2841015160083771,
0.054395001381635666,
0.23001010715961456,
0.0997578501701355,
0.5668536424636841,
-0.3489754796028137,
0.10617564618587494,
0.3924100399017334,
0.040030092000961304,
0.4365154504776001,
0.06274997442960739,
-0.3485225737094879,
-0.010770079679787159,
-0.5958271622657776,
-0.16009238362312317,
1.3873319625854492,
0.21383266150951385,
0.8971021175384521,
-0.198998361825943,
1.1063957214355469,
0.2725549340248108,
0.673106849193573,
-0.5307453870773315,
0.3249032199382782,
-0.19922246038913727,
-0.6147909760475159,
-0.45417532324790955,
-0.5499025583267212,
-1.1703648567199707,
0.1338299810886383,
-0.22971904277801514,
-0.6996006965637207,
0.5371876955032349,
-0.03518936038017273,
-0.03988651558756828,
0.591881275177002,
-0.4196460545063019,
0.9670170545578003,
-0.15157675743103027,
-0.4124733507633209,
0.08622544258832932,
-0.631031334400177,
0.150875523686409,
-0.07625696808099747,
0.17755238711833954,
-0.2594415843486786,
0.1043570265173912,
0.40549805760383606,
-0.37795618176460266,
0.7674028873443604,
-0.2847164273262024,
-0.031210212036967278,
0.47162163257598877,
0.05778367817401886,
0.7335246205329895,
0.16967211663722992,
-0.42578059434890747,
0.5585881471633911,
-0.35629281401634216,
-0.13675127923488617,
-0.7655504941940308,
0.9737847447395325,
-0.6414740085601807,
-0.3857748210430145,
-0.2612547278404236,
-0.6022616624832153,
-0.4133386015892029,
0.537631094455719,
0.27692699432373047,
0.5768062472343445,
-0.3427647650241852,
-0.08538780361413956,
0.22718684375286102,
0.173198401927948,
0.41242146492004395,
0.3286825120449066,
-0.1873721033334732,
-0.7509457468986511,
0.728407621383667,
0.34328722953796387,
0.20806831121444702,
0.5594179034233093,
-0.15675629675388336,
-0.6555750370025635,
-0.5128931403160095,
-0.48778843879699707,
0.23264187574386597,
-0.856960117816925,
-0.44694197177886963,
-0.9569551348686218,
-0.06105569377541542,
-0.9662759304046631,
0.0805562287569046,
-0.22051428258419037,
-0.4056261479854584,
-0.3178461492061615,
-0.6203308701515198,
0.15229368209838867,
0.4221312999725342,
-0.19160044193267822,
-0.12141864001750946,
-0.8772062659263611,
0.4498474895954132,
-0.0984102115035057,
0.32228711247444153,
0.15777823328971863,
-0.36317652463912964,
0.021224457770586014,
-0.056568440049886703,
-0.2884922921657562,
-1.0311839580535889,
0.3625616729259491,
0.006386131979525089,
0.7199006676673889,
0.21693657338619232,
0.3610933721065521,
0.5891100764274597,
-0.049260687083005905,
0.1225094348192215,
0.17050789296627045,
-0.8028026223182678,
0.37925758957862854,
-0.16405440866947174,
-0.13508246839046478,
0.7676222920417786,
0.3237684965133667,
-0.18955756723880768,
-0.29073554277420044,
-1.015633225440979,
-0.9300243854522705,
0.6441980004310608,
0.23866231739521027,
-0.18405979871749878,
-0.06559132784605026,
0.23715202510356903,
-0.06395111232995987,
0.11724962294101715,
-0.6870790123939514,
-0.1748158484697342,
-0.39953771233558655,
-0.12040915340185165,
-0.04295454919338226,
-0.04215260595083237,
0.32096344232559204,
-0.1341068297624588,
0.9712089896202087,
-0.15773572027683258,
-0.029736509546637535,
0.35155004262924194,
-0.19820478558540344,
-0.2691706418991089,
0.11780911684036255,
-0.15790188312530518,
0.5924469828605652,
-0.4745730757713318,
-0.02825016714632511,
0.21813523769378662,
-0.3064309358596802,
-0.08135177195072174,
0.6388982534408569,
-0.41158556938171387,
0.40397346019744873,
0.5039050579071045,
0.6675015091896057,
0.4727875292301178,
-0.11374714225530624,
0.4539566934108734,
0.10214187949895859,
-0.13440807163715363,
-0.27751481533050537,
-0.3900032341480255,
0.2046714723110199,
0.1284032016992569,
-0.043653085827827454,
-0.053398869931697845,
0.049238916486501694,
-0.47446271777153015,
0.5827943682670593,
0.5028624534606934,
-0.6182355284690857,
-0.11616969853639603,
0.7798110246658325,
0.3637549877166748,
0.11532285809516907,
0.7495712041854858,
-0.2895980775356293,
-0.47142815589904785,
0.7049392461776733,
0.5772777795791626,
0.9803124070167542,
-0.005448456853628159,
0.20642675459384918,
0.6275848150253296,
0.25898346304893494,
0.2024076133966446,
0.020038487389683723,
-0.02053227089345455,
-0.7539311647415161,
-0.18115545809268951,
-0.4823491871356964,
-0.23673386871814728,
0.0012165119405835867,
-0.7186383008956909,
0.4065967798233032,
-0.4395967721939087,
-0.4432847797870636,
0.1715390831232071,
0.2558685839176178,
-0.5288476347923279,
0.3143466114997864,
0.08057133853435516,
1.0511542558670044,
-0.7664994597434998,
1.232338547706604,
0.5281534194946289,
-0.8872482180595398,
-0.8360050320625305,
-0.0057337358593940735,
-0.16384242475032806,
-0.594401478767395,
0.7025725245475769,
0.11232372373342514,
-0.11342565715312958,
0.10788668692111969,
0.06338640302419662,
-0.7980355620384216,
1.2631524801254272,
0.5385943055152893,
-0.7167388796806335,
-0.486114501953125,
-0.06948861479759216,
0.3333841860294342,
-0.6700261235237122,
0.3519459664821625,
0.335745245218277,
0.5538068413734436,
0.1981898993253708,
-0.6515218615531921,
0.43159326910972595,
-0.3805638253688812,
-0.03185069561004639,
0.560244083404541,
-0.423068642616272,
0.8868014812469482,
-0.2916034162044525,
-0.4437413215637207,
-0.1435392051935196,
0.5522729754447937,
0.038133423775434494,
0.5987675189971924,
0.6565894484519958,
0.9665622115135193,
0.7305200099945068,
0.11817509680986404,
1.1668341159820557,
-0.5129029154777527,
0.5511354804039001,
1.8358412981033325,
-0.5531989932060242,
0.4562751352787018,
0.3264290392398834,
0.11809568852186203,
0.8156867027282715,
0.5983421206474304,
-0.3596478998661041,
0.584147036075592,
-0.14300239086151123,
0.19804343581199646,
-0.41014501452445984,
-0.16146878898143768,
-0.5654745697975159,
0.19145071506500244,
-0.019521508365869522,
-0.7973309755325317,
-0.6213350892066956,
-0.36627650260925293,
0.052524104714393616,
-0.005740336142480373,
-0.1667851209640503,
0.6555806398391724,
0.3067150413990021,
-0.5919778347015381,
0.3517836332321167,
-0.13136307895183563,
0.2023438960313797,
-0.4302181899547577,
-0.15716253221035004,
-0.1354513019323349,
0.1878833919763565,
-0.24671758711338043,
-0.6791545152664185,
0.1608358919620514,
-0.2188144326210022,
-0.38890156149864197,
-0.016973840072751045,
1.090827465057373,
-0.3204505443572998,
-0.47384077310562134,
1.042288064956665,
0.6063641309738159,
-0.12806133925914764,
-0.25335997343063354,
-0.8785080909729004,
-0.26929938793182373,
0.004058468155562878,
-0.1877157986164093,
0.3217756450176239,
0.4423619210720062,
-0.28475937247276306,
0.3056125044822693,
0.8833826184272766,
0.07223748415708542,
-0.3380625545978546,
0.3496016561985016,
0.9638718366622925,
-0.4438992142677307,
-0.4546625316143036,
-0.8224940896034241,
0.09594035148620605,
-0.35496124625205994,
-0.25776904821395874,
0.7039004564285278,
0.7119898796081543,
0.7972918748855591,
0.24038439989089966,
0.8064667582511902,
0.16383428871631622,
0.3656410872936249,
-0.24845696985721588,
0.47617292404174805,
-0.31445038318634033,
0.13057568669319153,
-0.719805896282196,
-0.9812860488891602,
-0.043625641614198685,
0.1114078238606453,
-0.6912234425544739,
0.1000308096408844,
0.621862530708313,
0.7003054022789001,
-0.13692063093185425,
0.134357288479805,
0.14169561862945557,
-0.016726702451705933,
0.3305574655532837,
0.8730374574661255,
0.38008299469947815,
-0.5145335793495178,
0.9155097007751465,
-0.35084179043769836,
-0.07176096737384796,
-0.016944171860814095,
-0.8766250014305115,
-0.9758356809616089,
-0.2675090730190277,
-0.36250385642051697,
-0.49841251969337463,
-0.1396407037973404,
0.5511673092842102,
0.5786512494087219,
-0.5562689304351807,
0.2838039696216583,
-0.20556899905204773,
0.40931448340415955,
-0.142982617020607,
-0.24879001080989838,
0.4866664707660675,
-0.020860178396105766,
-0.7029076218605042,
0.26467013359069824,
0.22743602097034454,
0.0656042993068695,
0.08600202947854996,
-0.16014111042022705,
-0.48461419343948364,
-0.20497363805770874,
0.25028741359710693,
0.26703688502311707,
-0.3971012234687805,
-0.1017654687166214,
-0.18212556838989258,
-0.050722066313028336,
0.3015572726726532,
0.750633180141449,
-0.8175217509269714,
0.4609726369380951,
0.47775405645370483,
0.701040506362915,
0.9986331462860107,
0.1418479084968567,
0.5277417898178101,
-0.6296442151069641,
-0.004317883402109146,
0.17599079012870789,
0.7074878811836243,
0.35161662101745605,
-0.5464747548103333,
0.9973521828651428,
0.4719260632991791,
-0.10496848076581955,
-0.6388683319091797,
0.278217613697052,
-0.8878768086433411,
-0.27252140641212463,
0.871350109577179,
-0.5541403293609619,
-0.2537544071674347,
-0.2817094624042511,
0.029967907816171646,
0.6001344323158264,
-0.7751078009605408,
0.5815619826316833,
0.4244014024734497,
-0.2233823537826538,
-0.1601557731628418,
-0.3002181947231293,
0.04543817415833473,
0.18338441848754883,
-0.793586254119873,
0.2207067459821701,
0.49984806776046753,
0.5082331895828247,
0.2206372767686844,
0.7873038053512573,
-0.3460331857204437,
0.1908060908317566,
0.18572993576526642,
0.08304756134748459,
-0.533605694770813,
-0.21394111216068268,
-0.018515726551413536,
0.27858617901802063,
-0.2228398621082306,
-0.22893556952476501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16528v1 | Evaluating the Ability of Large Language Models to Reason about Cardinal Directions | 2024-06-24T11:07:01 | 2024-06-24T11:07:01 | Anthony G Cohn, Robert E Blackwell | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate the abilities of a representative set of Large language Models
(LLMs) to reason about cardinal directions (CDs). To do so, we create two
datasets: the first, co-created with ChatGPT, focuses largely on recall of
world knowledge about CDs; the second is generated from a set of templates,
comprehensively testing an LLM's ability to determine the correct CD given a
particular scenario. The templates allow for a number of degrees of variation
such as means of locomotion of the agent involved, and whether set in the first
, second or third person. Even with a temperature setting of zero, Our
experiments show that although LLMs are able to perform well in the simpler
dataset, in the second more complex dataset no LLM is able to reliably
determine the correct CD, even with a temperature setting of zero. | [
-0.18608896434307098,
-0.659246027469635,
0.8814709782600403,
0.560559868812561,
-0.29152795672416687,
-0.31447795033454895,
-0.709284782409668,
-0.12403809279203415,
-0.1120300218462944,
0.6005876064300537,
-0.5295236706733704,
-0.777167558670044,
-0.43392083048820496,
0.13748280704021454,
-0.6058475375175476,
0.8781077861785889,
0.0720113217830658,
0.02293788455426693,
-0.36487606167793274,
-0.038026269525289536,
-0.4088418483734131,
-0.5681946873664856,
-0.7269609570503235,
-0.43629077076911926,
0.7281103730201721,
0.7373831272125244,
0.9547334313392639,
0.550151526927948,
0.7419726252555847,
0.2530365288257599,
-0.006598871201276779,
0.19212009012699127,
-0.7109677791595459,
0.49951061606407166,
-0.4502521753311157,
-0.3649198114871979,
-0.2949165999889374,
0.10458922386169434,
0.6895418167114258,
0.6988773941993713,
-0.2748161852359772,
-0.16395904123783112,
-0.16679693758487701,
0.7675402164459229,
-0.20147784054279327,
0.23513539135456085,
-0.8186271786689758,
-0.27201607823371887,
0.016114961355924606,
-0.4667167663574219,
-0.5258846879005432,
-0.427929550409317,
0.35859373211860657,
-0.489538311958313,
0.3425256907939911,
0.13807299733161926,
0.6810010075569153,
0.16600099205970764,
-0.7825369834899902,
-0.6090919971466064,
-1.0872160196304321,
0.8661403656005859,
-0.6695811152458191,
0.567938506603241,
0.599360466003418,
0.2878296375274658,
-0.4269438087940216,
-0.5779794454574585,
-0.6456524729728699,
-0.30988022685050964,
0.2002531886100769,
0.17692284286022186,
-0.03049374558031559,
-0.16074630618095398,
0.460048109292984,
0.3251814544200897,
-0.8118367791175842,
0.20583724975585938,
-0.47069206833839417,
0.2971569001674652,
0.7837162017822266,
0.3109695017337799,
0.2604147493839264,
0.11620178818702698,
-0.21841108798980713,
-0.41282281279563904,
-0.9679672122001648,
-0.01176141481846571,
0.2987864315509796,
0.32910528779029846,
-0.16758741438388824,
0.5821558237075806,
-0.11102870106697083,
1.012816071510315,
-0.073496975004673,
-0.29064759612083435,
-0.13431210815906525,
-0.1548435240983963,
-0.32728657126426697,
-0.11959854513406754,
0.693692684173584,
0.5896418690681458,
0.43585261702537537,
-0.3079074025154114,
-0.3383345305919647,
-0.22259898483753204,
0.18236158788204193,
-0.5458293557167053,
-0.45003542304039,
0.22288239002227783,
-0.2851375341415405,
-0.08335355669260025,
0.023744063451886177,
-0.44174742698669434,
-0.8037729859352112,
-0.7953948378562927,
-0.15740610659122467,
-0.553932249546051,
-0.3419646918773651,
0.28185775876045227,
-0.19289791584014893,
0.6961424350738525,
0.48034295439720154,
-0.9739689230918884,
0.17334462702274323,
1.0790963172912598,
0.658501923084259,
-0.0032458293717354536,
-0.5453014969825745,
-0.257647842168808,
0.0938224121928215,
-0.6059111952781677,
1.132344126701355,
-0.8184240460395813,
-0.5002687573432922,
0.010796457529067993,
0.0011912211775779724,
-0.230521559715271,
-0.4718210697174072,
0.6967936158180237,
-0.5556399822235107,
0.04061691090464592,
-0.8417954444885254,
-0.5454463362693787,
-0.36697888374328613,
0.5669841170310974,
-0.7016475200653076,
0.7515767216682434,
-0.2805464267730713,
-0.5432859063148499,
0.47499287128448486,
-0.2481880635023117,
-0.47723960876464844,
-0.2727515399456024,
-0.3949613869190216,
-0.22002382576465607,
0.19857533276081085,
0.15913699567317963,
0.5039107203483582,
-0.7123250961303711,
0.20657600462436676,
-0.39935389161109924,
-0.10099595040082932,
0.4248124063014984,
-0.5810530781745911,
0.9057748317718506,
0.02596740610897541,
-0.04649946093559265,
0.1000790074467659,
-0.9105449318885803,
-0.06764235347509384,
0.30962321162223816,
-0.5125917196273804,
-0.4142052233219147,
0.5505079030990601,
-0.24870552122592926,
0.2759428918361664,
0.13086964190006256,
-0.25194236636161804,
0.5599102973937988,
-0.16629725694656372,
0.2823038101196289,
0.7828220725059509,
0.051348332315683365,
0.44904473423957825,
-0.440570205450058,
0.507030725479126,
-0.0035448784474283457,
-0.14767122268676758,
0.10070914030075073,
-0.5905922651290894,
-1.0753473043441772,
0.0479644350707531,
-0.02771143615245819,
0.5416625738143921,
-0.6909215450286865,
0.1987653374671936,
-0.3799944818019867,
-0.7754808068275452,
-0.11408752202987671,
0.1620197296142578,
0.12648949027061462,
0.19292080402374268,
0.03835846111178398,
0.04077460244297981,
-0.4961360692977905,
-0.5624261498451233,
0.027782393619418144,
-0.4605632722377777,
-0.035528093576431274,
0.4759083688259125,
0.5366594195365906,
0.13303256034851074,
0.8192396759986877,
-0.26298049092292786,
0.2412005513906479,
-0.37924227118492126,
-0.07916772365570068,
0.559187114238739,
0.3812756836414337,
0.4568757712841034,
-0.8552920818328857,
-0.33484312891960144,
0.14898395538330078,
-1.0420113801956177,
-0.07800458371639252,
-0.29342567920684814,
-0.09922183305025101,
0.06206890940666199,
0.6203693747520447,
-0.649000883102417,
0.40647780895233154,
0.5379404425621033,
-0.5474921464920044,
0.6412059664726257,
-0.538662314414978,
-0.07399395108222961,
-0.5440382361412048,
0.015742342919111252,
-0.06446074694395065,
0.07363525778055191,
-0.8731052279472351,
0.01810222677886486,
-0.05910015106201172,
0.10979869216680527,
-0.336713045835495,
0.45121681690216064,
-0.5289019346237183,
-0.10512899607419968,
-0.09208127856254578,
0.23187483847141266,
0.06040208414196968,
0.3351156711578369,
0.4051367938518524,
0.2783258557319641,
0.7398974895477295,
-0.7745010256767273,
0.7133903503417969,
-0.10498637706041336,
-0.5124724507331848,
0.7407257556915283,
-0.7575752139091492,
0.3397395610809326,
-0.2558857798576355,
0.22690212726593018,
-1.0759586095809937,
-0.22210973501205444,
0.13469521701335907,
-0.09110909700393677,
0.09207264333963394,
-0.015662146732211113,
-0.7962667942047119,
-0.3684382736682892,
0.2953883111476898,
0.46075186133384705,
0.2946915626525879,
-0.6535372734069824,
0.3566009998321533,
0.09228209406137466,
0.0431261844933033,
-0.24060720205307007,
-0.3406829535961151,
0.11484810709953308,
-0.4651183784008026,
-0.600587785243988,
-0.025590533390641212,
-0.33073970675468445,
-0.7617170810699463,
-0.4725874364376068,
0.14374080300331116,
0.006618859712034464,
0.11942777782678604,
0.3634019196033478,
0.0801452025771141,
-0.3400629460811615,
0.36035069823265076,
-0.4950908124446869,
-0.029991114512085915,
0.27695783972740173,
-0.33086928725242615,
0.6069508194923401,
-0.3866950571537018,
-0.6535675525665283,
0.0039833420887589455,
0.21745021641254425,
0.6765630841255188,
-0.2002699375152588,
0.9622097015380859,
0.3069472014904022,
-0.2943952977657318,
-0.17202673852443695,
-0.6161841750144958,
0.1090790331363678,
-0.4283464848995209,
0.05698950216174126,
-0.4361022710800171,
-0.34968945384025574,
0.7507346272468567,
0.5139824748039246,
0.2270253449678421,
0.2731417417526245,
0.8848496079444885,
0.055402059108018875,
0.7962067127227783,
0.4348450005054474,
0.0528726726770401,
-0.007304932922124863,
-0.2062446027994156,
0.38494595885276794,
-0.6504685282707214,
-0.44393500685691833,
-0.742139995098114,
-0.10869444161653519,
-0.9179069399833679,
-0.47251495718955994,
0.20981299877166748,
0.06063549220561981,
-0.3570106029510498,
0.11353262513875961,
-0.2892678678035736,
0.8042333722114563,
0.5100297331809998,
0.09076285362243652,
0.34010323882102966,
-0.2052588313817978,
-0.26694604754447937,
0.19611255824565887,
-0.7488295435905457,
-0.7213634848594666,
1.0195990800857544,
0.4265410900115967,
0.8634349703788757,
0.39465126395225525,
0.4921964704990387,
-0.25444546341896057,
0.41125354170799255,
-0.892544686794281,
0.6588126420974731,
-0.2500092685222626,
-0.6131293773651123,
-0.5339095592498779,
-0.08989262580871582,
-0.9191448092460632,
0.42905858159065247,
0.019370468333363533,
-0.5282226800918579,
0.2958037555217743,
-0.06220284104347229,
-0.22087430953979492,
0.31234437227249146,
-0.4487905502319336,
0.7339933514595032,
-0.3530130386352539,
-0.2805473208427429,
0.09306911379098892,
-0.46392568945884705,
0.34667038917541504,
0.0929889976978302,
0.12250831723213196,
-0.21466249227523804,
0.25307297706604004,
0.764308512210846,
-0.2926328480243683,
0.9482777118682861,
0.08052530884742737,
-0.6546489000320435,
0.47452521324157715,
0.1442946195602417,
0.3708105981349945,
0.06211986020207405,
-0.5410012602806091,
0.132185697555542,
0.00617401534691453,
-0.36176833510398865,
-0.6338883638381958,
0.7751732468605042,
-0.6960373520851135,
-0.8981215953826904,
-0.4550282657146454,
-0.6984280943870544,
-0.10015807300806046,
0.16264775395393372,
0.33949699997901917,
0.37664076685905457,
-0.39992913603782654,
0.33797717094421387,
0.5092241168022156,
-0.3432285487651825,
0.2490484118461609,
0.9450228214263916,
-0.3930080831050873,
0.04799574986100197,
0.9699493050575256,
0.046435367316007614,
0.2871370017528534,
0.3438337743282318,
0.38585159182548523,
-0.2353798896074295,
-0.43484315276145935,
-0.2379990965127945,
0.31908631324768066,
-0.9976410269737244,
0.0894784927368164,
0.011113348416984081,
-0.2852519452571869,
-0.35679852962493896,
-0.12103941291570663,
-0.26192203164100647,
-0.21740402281284332,
-0.31515949964523315,
-0.0571642704308033,
0.15546701848506927,
1.0854920148849487,
-0.11140257865190506,
0.2490137368440628,
-0.48201784491539,
-0.06924072653055191,
0.3193329870700836,
-0.02947845309972763,
0.019568799063563347,
-0.4714981019496918,
-0.02243770845234394,
0.14871284365653992,
-0.4131678342819214,
-0.8676333427429199,
0.4487864673137665,
0.07883873581886292,
0.46747851371765137,
0.7335434556007385,
0.11954786628484726,
0.7316842079162598,
-0.5107059478759766,
0.8512470126152039,
0.056955236941576004,
-0.7377060055732727,
0.4322033226490021,
-0.517708420753479,
0.37965869903564453,
0.06087207421660423,
0.29094669222831726,
-0.6716506481170654,
-0.6037050485610962,
-0.6617388725280762,
-0.5608707666397095,
0.38488495349884033,
0.3919660747051239,
-0.16546355187892914,
-0.20454896986484528,
0.39022931456565857,
0.03741704300045967,
-0.16918648779392242,
-0.6427704095840454,
-0.10996565967798233,
-0.11751070618629456,
0.14560991525650024,
-0.5154406428337097,
-0.23158270120620728,
-0.16640827059745789,
-0.11763927340507507,
0.4438225328922272,
0.06538227200508118,
0.26015958189964294,
0.15999726951122284,
0.27990666031837463,
-0.21293871104717255,
0.32169267535209656,
1.0380170345306396,
1.2786628007888794,
-0.30953702330589294,
0.48797932267189026,
0.11628807336091995,
-0.07879652082920074,
-0.0057157897390425205,
-0.1790495663881302,
0.011544648557901382,
-0.04425114393234253,
0.8497065901756287,
0.7573099732398987,
-0.10882338136434555,
-0.4413479268550873,
0.3179037570953369,
-0.3778141736984253,
-0.17844992876052856,
-0.5365665555000305,
0.1459648162126541,
0.2364998459815979,
0.30732080340385437,
-0.022424200549721718,
-0.21688176691532135,
-0.22913897037506104,
-0.560432493686676,
-0.10778305679559708,
0.512938916683197,
-0.2721675932407379,
-0.4957810938358307,
0.23344361782073975,
-0.0656093880534172,
-0.3421895205974579,
1.1064661741256714,
-0.14383567869663239,
-0.6519684195518494,
1.128827691078186,
0.7244942784309387,
0.5982476472854614,
-0.3928673565387726,
0.12153550237417221,
0.3543929159641266,
0.5959914326667786,
-0.0253966823220253,
0.2838009297847748,
-0.0001967819407582283,
-1.0434759855270386,
-0.1349412351846695,
-0.4818898141384125,
-0.42516398429870605,
0.2347596436738968,
-0.7560977935791016,
0.2169540375471115,
-0.4571312963962555,
0.05399613454937935,
-0.08142351359128952,
-0.19032786786556244,
-1.1093589067459106,
0.3735574185848236,
0.12988059222698212,
1.0630143880844116,
-0.9149748682975769,
0.9830377697944641,
0.6628634333610535,
-0.24727171659469604,
-0.8658000826835632,
0.053411874920129776,
-0.04840153828263283,
-1.0154863595962524,
0.9818392395973206,
0.05746394023299217,
-0.07442273944616318,
-0.40879106521606445,
-0.6624355912208557,
-0.7837950587272644,
1.05980384349823,
0.1601613610982895,
-0.7460098266601562,
-0.03231937438249588,
0.3487318754196167,
0.8600635528564453,
-0.3468420207500458,
0.33399447798728943,
0.8830508589744568,
0.6535323262214661,
0.45970556139945984,
-0.9691941142082214,
-0.038877423852682114,
-0.021674668416380882,
-0.08753281086683273,
-0.12943516671657562,
-0.651706874370575,
0.933035671710968,
-0.5200205445289612,
-0.1571214348077774,
0.03883148357272148,
0.7379148602485657,
0.45552048087120056,
0.32572969794273376,
0.5755361318588257,
0.5136948227882385,
0.8648502230644226,
-0.11204236000776291,
1.219063639640808,
-0.3875741958618164,
0.3722550868988037,
1.0203299522399902,
-0.4132004678249359,
0.843696117401123,
0.5562277436256409,
-0.06024481728672981,
0.39900290966033936,
0.6568173766136169,
0.09402474015951157,
0.5110364556312561,
0.43109551072120667,
-0.22551333904266357,
-0.6154019236564636,
0.06546914577484131,
-0.3287055194377899,
0.6095945835113525,
0.6488284468650818,
-0.35282620787620544,
-0.17083758115768433,
-0.3764498233795166,
0.07205482572317123,
-0.13730233907699585,
-0.20599931478500366,
0.5910290479660034,
0.32434433698654175,
-1.1120558977127075,
0.7429514527320862,
0.04880034923553467,
-0.34972575306892395,
-0.306639164686203,
-0.018628044053912163,
-0.3734373152256012,
0.3478871285915375,
-0.21282877027988434,
-1.014564871788025,
0.2736949920654297,
-0.028455153107643127,
-0.17897777259349823,
-0.21017102897167206,
0.48783230781555176,
-0.47518277168273926,
-0.7476918697357178,
0.12126412242650986,
0.45163682103157043,
0.4249054491519928,
0.20925001800060272,
-0.4951758086681366,
0.21314994990825653,
0.047246772795915604,
-0.35794779658317566,
-0.034176476299762726,
0.9477477073669434,
0.08523893356323242,
0.9195458889007568,
0.6861836314201355,
0.2841223180294037,
-0.10035470873117447,
0.1725514531135559,
0.7590184211730957,
-0.908393383026123,
-0.4166693687438965,
-1.0910216569900513,
0.19807864725589752,
0.09637916833162308,
-0.2971346080303192,
0.883428156375885,
0.3564583361148834,
0.5853884816169739,
-0.0014377920888364315,
0.637387216091156,
0.03300129249691963,
0.283639520406723,
-0.9299564361572266,
0.30676212906837463,
-0.33289068937301636,
0.7297596335411072,
-0.061306390911340714,
-0.9954416155815125,
-0.43612805008888245,
0.9341526627540588,
-0.8168252110481262,
0.07025208324193954,
0.8620678782463074,
0.9017348885536194,
-0.016553567722439766,
0.20710448920726776,
0.47061705589294434,
0.4076444208621979,
0.7653069496154785,
0.8522692322731018,
1.214542269706726,
-0.12241945415735245,
0.25335726141929626,
-0.2671073377132416,
-0.23490066826343536,
-0.013726986944675446,
-1.2342222929000854,
-1.2301682233810425,
-0.682577908039093,
-0.22412514686584473,
-0.4945182800292969,
-0.015751434490084648,
0.8424811959266663,
0.5534462332725525,
-0.7038981914520264,
-0.5770390629768372,
-0.1197698712348938,
0.39602622389793396,
-0.08222806453704834,
-0.15795965492725372,
0.5308725833892822,
-0.24893538653850555,
-0.44200268387794495,
0.40202292799949646,
0.18339288234710693,
-0.20214895904064178,
-0.5464304685592651,
-0.3756488859653473,
0.021309703588485718,
0.17386698722839355,
0.6176100373268127,
0.2395140677690506,
-0.8680717349052429,
-0.37143340706825256,
-0.11771976947784424,
-0.22773241996765137,
0.0023941027466207743,
1.018139123916626,
-0.2651590406894684,
0.43682214617729187,
0.5853306651115417,
0.11421994119882584,
0.11688622832298279,
-0.0641949251294136,
0.7055565714836121,
-0.506967306137085,
-0.030593449249863625,
0.04625316336750984,
0.5727399587631226,
0.40698564052581787,
-0.12126898765563965,
0.4054965674877167,
0.10186769813299179,
-1.0238128900527954,
-0.45051097869873047,
0.2636268436908722,
-1.1586960554122925,
-0.08699115365743637,
1.7275333404541016,
-0.3309912383556366,
-0.24743150174617767,
-0.041070036590099335,
-0.17059339582920074,
-0.024336205795407295,
-0.2955641448497772,
0.8073959350585938,
1.022241234779358,
-0.19876225292682648,
-0.022160323336720467,
-0.49517691135406494,
0.38524243235588074,
0.2323695421218872,
-0.5245621800422668,
0.259679913520813,
0.4885241985321045,
0.38582947850227356,
0.040925536304712296,
0.6132634282112122,
0.22686578333377838,
0.035803064703941345,
-0.2935822308063507,
-0.2658524811267853,
0.28185078501701355,
-0.5098749399185181,
-0.2507798969745636,
-0.010268053039908409,
0.33068498969078064,
0.22128577530384064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16527v1 | SyROCCo: Enhancing Systematic Reviews using Machine Learning | 2024-06-24T11:04:43 | 2024-06-24T11:04:43 | Zheng Fang, Miguel Arana-Catania, Felix-Anselm van Lier, Juliana Outes Velarde, Harry Bregazzi, Mara Airoldi, Eleanor Carter, Rob Procter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.DL, cs.LG | The sheer number of research outputs published every year makes systematic
reviewing increasingly time- and resource-intensive. This paper explores the
use of machine learning techniques to help navigate the systematic review
process. ML has previously been used to reliably 'screen' articles for review -
that is, identify relevant articles based on reviewers' inclusion criteria. The
application of ML techniques to subsequent stages of a review, however, such as
data extraction and evidence mapping, is in its infancy. We therefore set out
to develop a series of tools that would assist in the profiling and analysis of
1,952 publications on the theme of 'outcomes-based contracting'. Tools were
developed for the following tasks: assign publications into 'policy area'
categories; identify and extract key information for evidence mapping, such as
organisations, laws, and geographical information; connect the evidence base to
an existing dataset on the same topic; and identify subgroups of articles that
may share thematic content. An interactive tool using these techniques and a
public dataset with their outputs have been released. Our results demonstrate
the utility of ML techniques to enhance evidence accessibility and analysis
within the systematic review processes. These efforts show promise in
potentially yielding substantial efficiencies for future systematic reviewing
and for broadening their analytical scope. Our work suggests that there may be
implications for the ease with which policymakers and practitioners can access
evidence. While ML techniques seem poised to play a significant role in
bridging the gap between research and policy by offering innovative ways of
gathering, accessing, and analysing data from systematic reviews, we also
highlight their current limitations and the need to exercise caution in their
application, particularly given the potential for errors and biases. | [
-0.553867757320404,
-0.30052900314331055,
0.4666953384876251,
0.133732870221138,
-0.32098889350891113,
-0.1057729721069336,
0.07231762260198593,
-0.29420092701911926,
0.11685962975025177,
0.6574382185935974,
-0.6375041604042053,
-0.6925716996192932,
-0.7425786852836609,
0.349886953830719,
-0.5426292419433594,
1.1735363006591797,
-0.19126616418361664,
0.3321681320667267,
0.018725233152508736,
-0.23120342195034027,
-0.1896105706691742,
-0.43291911482810974,
-0.24413351714611053,
-0.3067886233329773,
0.8971109390258789,
0.4381203353404999,
0.4416143298149109,
0.269976943731308,
1.0067352056503296,
0.22084665298461914,
-0.06866434216499329,
0.4924904704093933,
-0.2803676724433899,
0.1266770213842392,
-0.17888043820858002,
-0.46721649169921875,
-0.10506317019462585,
0.17009669542312622,
0.5454933643341064,
0.8511127829551697,
-0.39385727047920227,
0.31001049280166626,
0.38307008147239685,
1.0648318529129028,
-0.8175405859947205,
0.25415027141571045,
-0.5471315979957581,
0.22944115102291107,
0.02689073048532009,
-0.2864127457141876,
-0.33690306544303894,
-0.6000252366065979,
0.2875891923904419,
-0.6783302426338196,
0.10779809951782227,
0.12485461682081223,
0.8515269756317139,
0.3864648938179016,
-0.253480464220047,
-0.8322402834892273,
-0.6352658271789551,
0.7125075459480286,
-0.7942388653755188,
-0.038300253450870514,
0.1493360549211502,
0.2943322956562042,
-0.31587672233581543,
-0.7319260239601135,
-0.19009871780872345,
-0.4049123525619507,
-0.42721956968307495,
0.15353411436080933,
0.058895181864500046,
0.0721188336610794,
0.43122348189353943,
-0.01714310795068741,
-0.4158993661403656,
0.01615232042968273,
-0.7067710757255554,
-0.07250497490167618,
0.8480453491210938,
0.1527710109949112,
-0.09681324660778046,
-0.24542485177516937,
0.032219789922237396,
-0.11723592877388,
-0.7570847868919373,
0.15941812098026276,
0.34778520464897156,
0.28624606132507324,
0.28181037306785583,
0.6930240392684937,
-0.22977334260940552,
0.6182982921600342,
-0.33812424540519714,
0.038355305790901184,
0.28204435110092163,
-0.27569034695625305,
-0.3029784858226776,
0.08288907259702682,
0.8093976378440857,
0.13531169295310974,
-0.20812112092971802,
0.39627230167388916,
-0.22027568519115448,
-0.16520985960960388,
0.5026373267173767,
-0.6721621155738831,
-0.3121873438358307,
0.39774444699287415,
-0.7674051523208618,
-0.40329304337501526,
0.6107379198074341,
-0.443289577960968,
-0.46102097630500793,
-0.4612884223461151,
0.2713013291358948,
-0.05264333263039589,
-0.1604791134595871,
0.07873266190290451,
-0.5987857580184937,
-0.013315108604729176,
0.3976192772388458,
-0.3049990236759186,
0.311911016702652,
0.8415811657905579,
0.7187433242797852,
-0.15927553176879883,
-0.01296528335660696,
-0.10749880969524384,
-0.04544133320450783,
-0.6655384302139282,
0.7949743866920471,
-0.3996678292751312,
-0.5262323021888733,
0.1990671008825302,
0.2697155773639679,
0.011477543972432613,
-0.5921663641929626,
0.4532511830329895,
-0.23762555420398712,
0.32077592611312866,
-0.07549583166837692,
-0.23851269483566284,
-0.30455347895622253,
0.28226104378700256,
-0.8244131207466125,
0.7820773720741272,
0.14961375296115875,
-0.7773379683494568,
0.8286854028701782,
-0.6585279107093811,
-0.43753746151924133,
-0.2427241951227188,
-0.26390382647514343,
-0.9474655389785767,
0.27111342549324036,
0.23831677436828613,
0.33277758955955505,
-0.2915147542953491,
0.18915651738643646,
-0.5556049942970276,
-0.34222933650016785,
0.4253132939338684,
-0.031882986426353455,
1.0149109363555908,
0.4701114594936371,
-0.43784523010253906,
0.3788532316684723,
-0.4016682803630829,
-0.13911455869674683,
-0.4207727313041687,
-0.12054476141929626,
-0.18355916440486908,
0.1832127720117569,
-0.05955164507031441,
0.18176260590553284,
-0.24198263883590698,
-0.17948825657367706,
0.12458039075136185,
-0.11572683602571487,
0.35864707827568054,
0.5635889768600464,
0.26512813568115234,
0.38660556077957153,
-0.40972110629081726,
0.5697277188301086,
-0.013321914710104465,
0.45860493183135986,
-0.16821785271167755,
-0.5225033164024353,
-0.7502699494361877,
-0.2377622276544571,
0.8863797783851624,
0.24144722521305084,
-0.6180557012557983,
0.6638944745063782,
-0.042332492768764496,
-0.5114929676055908,
-1.0082472562789917,
0.1297013908624649,
0.04695484787225723,
0.39872291684150696,
-0.01380117516964674,
-0.6845155954360962,
-0.5820862054824829,
-0.7484651207923889,
-0.1865532249212265,
-0.34675371646881104,
-0.04859859123826027,
0.45322373509407043,
0.5434677600860596,
-0.3225865364074707,
0.9102685451507568,
-0.3343009650707245,
-0.5317488312721252,
-0.12577185034751892,
0.3629889190196991,
0.5487079620361328,
0.23580436408519745,
-0.1165667325258255,
-0.8404096961021423,
-0.2403421401977539,
0.24311107397079468,
-1.0687439441680908,
-0.10995612293481827,
-0.3041350841522217,
0.019043797627091408,
0.07093296945095062,
0.4062687158584595,
-0.3122200667858124,
0.3262445628643036,
0.08121809363365173,
0.0475655198097229,
0.46553608775138855,
-0.20718501508235931,
0.2660117745399475,
-0.41297104954719543,
0.4860287606716156,
0.17643292248249054,
0.06521829962730408,
-0.3124457597732544,
-0.00474235974252224,
0.1257728636264801,
-0.04196837544441223,
-0.41037628054618835,
0.030721111223101616,
-0.6723803877830505,
-0.06558282673358917,
-0.0959245041012764,
-0.032517071813344955,
0.04931626096367836,
0.0772693082690239,
0.12440311908721924,
0.4680730998516083,
0.26479217410087585,
-0.6125728487968445,
0.09827372431755066,
0.07724335044622421,
-0.4881763160228729,
0.247547909617424,
-0.36794453859329224,
-0.19899927079677582,
-0.22957247495651245,
0.40660762786865234,
-0.6059437394142151,
-0.05053411424160004,
0.7313302755355835,
-0.3407374322414398,
0.23840990662574768,
-0.35663172602653503,
-0.02664702944457531,
-0.5498244166374207,
-0.4964069128036499,
-0.19619494676589966,
0.3455222249031067,
-0.11759144812822342,
0.4557156264781952,
0.7395191788673401,
-0.5595001578330994,
-0.762030839920044,
-0.3881312310695648,
0.14788681268692017,
-0.37656956911087036,
-0.010896309278905392,
-0.0420292392373085,
0.43336886167526245,
-0.33321186900138855,
0.18084284663200378,
-0.06537216156721115,
-0.1326858401298523,
0.1817501187324524,
0.3674028515815735,
0.25787055492401123,
-0.029320882633328438,
0.00279219844378531,
0.3069642186164856,
-0.2546674907207489,
0.4306199252605438,
-0.31190726161003113,
0.03875952586531639,
0.2568405270576477,
-0.5094223618507385,
-0.46630027890205383,
0.29635509848594666,
0.34451448917388916,
-0.21666592359542847,
0.14740823209285736,
0.5999302268028259,
-0.060923635959625244,
-0.43349406123161316,
-0.36520814895629883,
-0.10913953930139542,
-0.361544668674469,
0.26196447014808655,
-0.13825269043445587,
-0.6636555194854736,
0.07536935806274414,
-0.4133200943470001,
0.2957198917865753,
0.4703805148601532,
0.6803260445594788,
-0.519603967666626,
0.8257677555084229,
0.6124516129493713,
-0.2548319399356842,
0.48677027225494385,
-0.4958416819572449,
0.2870144844055176,
-0.6575666069984436,
-0.5066080093383789,
-0.7475261688232422,
-0.30443620681762695,
-0.8126428723335266,
-0.39581814408302307,
0.48473110795021057,
-0.07548900693655014,
0.20539292693138123,
0.14915214478969574,
-0.7955455780029297,
-0.014365640468895435,
0.6480993628501892,
0.3681868612766266,
0.41972342133522034,
0.09455636143684387,
-0.007736929226666689,
0.11291579902172089,
-1.0193325281143188,
-0.559814989566803,
1.572987675666809,
0.356765478849411,
0.851792573928833,
-0.5335977077484131,
0.9031776189804077,
0.6447891592979431,
0.8728910684585571,
-0.8038846850395203,
0.3559948205947876,
0.2690703272819519,
-0.5698911547660828,
-0.45590275526046753,
-0.48696622252464294,
-1.0650609731674194,
0.2743314504623413,
-0.47273972630500793,
0.04398103058338165,
0.517780065536499,
0.03966362401843071,
-0.3380849063396454,
0.025521624833345413,
-0.46718910336494446,
0.44082510471343994,
-0.24718227982521057,
-0.16053777933120728,
-0.4442998170852661,
-0.5217118859291077,
0.28536540269851685,
-0.07227399945259094,
0.32074499130249023,
-0.09042737632989883,
0.011823923327028751,
0.7300718426704407,
-0.4845135509967804,
0.5541834235191345,
-0.17164014279842377,
-0.09132120013237,
0.5264397263526917,
-0.18221144378185272,
0.30889856815338135,
0.2496822476387024,
0.05312779173254967,
0.351332426071167,
0.2022460401058197,
-0.21491385996341705,
-0.6402586698532104,
0.4520795941352844,
-0.539581835269928,
-0.4693524241447449,
-0.7514147162437439,
-0.3954811096191406,
-0.05314427241683006,
0.196027934551239,
-0.1069529801607132,
0.15761364996433258,
-0.05431291088461876,
-0.05462592467665672,
0.49896618723869324,
0.005851561203598976,
0.1402798742055893,
0.37169453501701355,
-0.11185192316770554,
-0.5599284768104553,
0.8989402651786804,
0.32936492562294006,
-0.3839505910873413,
0.13728024065494537,
0.07151481509208679,
-0.29269886016845703,
-0.8860142230987549,
-0.13137288391590118,
0.06265018880367279,
-0.25349828600883484,
-0.28259050846099854,
-0.49356043338775635,
-0.09807157516479492,
-0.33290860056877136,
0.2871892750263214,
0.21638046205043793,
-0.550707995891571,
0.12068483233451843,
0.02038186974823475,
-0.07807561755180359,
0.9399871230125427,
-0.1404678076505661,
0.09387436509132385,
-0.36022233963012695,
0.3742404282093048,
-0.06195172294974327,
0.13380733132362366,
-0.1952192187309265,
0.07998215407133102,
-0.4278796315193176,
-0.08971624821424484,
-0.3460879325866699,
-0.7152836322784424,
0.4496988356113434,
-0.0813242718577385,
0.6752294898033142,
0.8188728094100952,
0.05702394247055054,
0.5274713635444641,
-0.4091033935546875,
0.43192240595817566,
0.20358805358409882,
-0.36192676424980164,
0.6477899551391602,
-0.16418343782424927,
-0.1261652559041977,
0.6635719537734985,
0.7329904437065125,
-0.34698763489723206,
-0.4300147294998169,
-0.5287425518035889,
-0.7656700015068054,
0.5813602805137634,
0.24934200942516327,
-0.4496277868747711,
0.3020678758621216,
0.15259332954883575,
0.2643739879131317,
0.4414726197719574,
-0.14532551169395447,
0.05493132770061493,
0.2588237524032593,
-0.1984492838382721,
-0.11078224331140518,
-0.0701843723654747,
-0.6546478867530823,
-0.17768611013889313,
0.9303612112998962,
-0.23691792786121368,
0.12195424735546112,
0.5991961359977722,
-0.31872063875198364,
0.10401219874620438,
0.2493259310722351,
0.2069459855556488,
0.8717526793479919,
-0.2024267613887787,
-0.17373529076576233,
-0.08838970214128494,
-0.3793761432170868,
0.05972006544470787,
0.3814085125923157,
-0.5522881746292114,
0.43590691685676575,
0.5277288556098938,
0.17863284051418304,
0.00015358491509687155,
-0.7334704995155334,
0.16826759278774261,
-0.0020586117170751095,
-0.5145525336265564,
-0.23293517529964447,
0.046081915497779846,
-0.3776077926158905,
0.2057502418756485,
0.3255801498889923,
0.09150037914514542,
0.6780094504356384,
-0.4284398853778839,
0.524186909198761,
0.43020880222320557,
-0.7889865636825562,
0.3243357539176941,
0.10748867690563202,
0.2331627905368805,
-0.2749848961830139,
0.6152634620666504,
0.18550969660282135,
-0.10096970200538635,
0.732503354549408,
-0.07146444916725159,
0.6999606490135193,
0.12585672736167908,
0.45164844393730164,
0.3083639442920685,
0.4278082549571991,
-0.030780209228396416,
0.10383165627717972,
-0.30757880210876465,
-0.18353360891342163,
-0.41559532284736633,
-0.21547779440879822,
-0.74538254737854,
-0.33321407437324524,
-0.926015317440033,
0.16347798705101013,
-0.4352443516254425,
-0.4780976474285126,
-0.2886333167552948,
0.30498310923576355,
-0.5750257968902588,
-0.0464019812643528,
-0.03770488128066063,
0.9868077635765076,
-0.9202116131782532,
0.5029558539390564,
0.44228121638298035,
-0.38299083709716797,
-0.457510381937027,
-0.28371861577033997,
0.31818535923957825,
-0.504180908203125,
0.1813078075647354,
0.23084913194179535,
-0.12607692182064056,
-0.46917784214019775,
-0.43736210465431213,
-0.3185771107673645,
1.1984301805496216,
-0.08109109103679657,
-0.7844041585922241,
-0.09159865230321884,
0.050872620195150375,
0.48798874020576477,
-0.4337591826915741,
0.5632964968681335,
0.7446063756942749,
0.49184608459472656,
-0.39611056447029114,
-0.5958250761032104,
-0.1102924793958664,
-0.2013521045446396,
-0.19586262106895447,
0.10669965296983719,
-0.26663002371788025,
0.12831485271453857,
-0.1762552261352539,
-0.07195106148719788,
0.01368245854973793,
0.7183811068534851,
0.5270315408706665,
0.6629390716552734,
0.4524296820163727,
0.34473979473114014,
0.9462474584579468,
-0.13531574606895447,
0.8459292054176331,
-0.2647565007209778,
0.4072117507457733,
0.7574294805526733,
-0.4162386953830719,
0.7963638305664062,
0.8089030981063843,
-0.42419737577438354,
0.6301625370979309,
0.8660520911216736,
-0.30548638105392456,
0.5135048031806946,
0.4579521417617798,
-0.03890582174062729,
0.07234518229961395,
-0.39043256640434265,
-0.3061874806880951,
-0.14058010280132294,
0.49534034729003906,
-0.5867556929588318,
-0.023763591423630714,
-0.11368662863969803,
-0.3030413091182709,
0.04209299385547638,
-0.4593561887741089,
1.0318793058395386,
0.2918633222579956,
-0.7815237045288086,
-0.012847786769270897,
-0.1154821440577507,
0.3797694146633148,
-0.7421701550483704,
-0.46623000502586365,
-0.123294897377491,
0.1172754317522049,
-0.5466139912605286,
-0.8165247440338135,
0.3105126917362213,
-0.25015726685523987,
0.010790242813527584,
-0.49740922451019287,
0.6911137104034424,
-0.1295958012342453,
-0.8655722141265869,
0.1247185543179512,
0.6861392259597778,
0.061929356306791306,
0.22371350228786469,
-1.0458972454071045,
0.18043231964111328,
-0.1423049122095108,
-0.09427785128355026,
0.15721584856510162,
0.5696532726287842,
-0.1931775063276291,
0.6904798746109009,
0.7283687591552734,
0.694679856300354,
-0.21879296004772186,
0.18647409975528717,
0.8699213266372681,
-0.5607609748840332,
-0.4541284441947937,
-0.6728789210319519,
0.47965413331985474,
-0.4256994128227234,
-0.2755819261074066,
0.714776337146759,
0.6912144422531128,
0.8245874047279358,
0.00822050217539072,
0.9820783734321594,
-0.06313133984804153,
0.5464016199111938,
-0.49978139996528625,
0.8317777514457703,
-0.18156231939792633,
0.26203635334968567,
-0.18357428908348083,
-0.6936326622962952,
-0.5513982176780701,
0.6775937676429749,
-0.31813886761665344,
-0.31719744205474854,
0.6681284308433533,
0.9455961585044861,
0.2163148820400238,
-0.108030766248703,
-0.14216427505016327,
-0.0037777682300657034,
0.3397143483161926,
0.1397208720445633,
0.928619921207428,
-0.39494311809539795,
0.5228748321533203,
-0.1763518899679184,
-0.34992656111717224,
-0.19743295013904572,
-0.5824947357177734,
-0.818423867225647,
-0.41030436754226685,
-0.2604430615901947,
-0.5809422135353088,
0.6268357634544373,
0.6802699565887451,
0.8745622038841248,
-1.000630497932434,
-0.6171119809150696,
-0.08326361328363419,
0.5116104483604431,
-0.5395349264144897,
-0.13904614746570587,
0.4802805185317993,
-0.6324228048324585,
-0.18848614394664764,
-0.09893812984228134,
0.2964377701282501,
-0.6020131707191467,
-0.46594908833503723,
-0.2235395908355713,
-0.020754307508468628,
-0.3454866111278534,
0.31870415806770325,
0.2138311266899109,
-0.5424387454986572,
0.5060443878173828,
-0.25551214814186096,
0.03582204878330231,
0.12245336174964905,
1.3997910022735596,
-0.8093967437744141,
0.40608903765678406,
0.48430681228637695,
0.5909910798072815,
0.5339251756668091,
-0.0281342975795269,
0.7021713852882385,
0.06018618121743202,
-0.12610949575901031,
0.3960750699043274,
0.3974952697753906,
-0.020761163905262947,
-0.07052217423915863,
0.7110002040863037,
-0.010803978890180588,
-0.4156605899333954,
-0.802659273147583,
-0.15054279565811157,
-0.7131268978118896,
-0.36142998933792114,
0.8584715127944946,
-0.1126464381814003,
-0.37294456362724304,
-0.33716881275177,
-0.4231567680835724,
0.010326222516596317,
-0.37135469913482666,
1.12640380859375,
0.5907171368598938,
-0.3510553538799286,
0.03636540472507477,
-0.5898943543434143,
0.5835605263710022,
0.3123363256454468,
-1.0184340476989746,
-0.15440349280834198,
0.355723112821579,
0.052614327520132065,
-0.04349944740533829,
0.58230060338974,
-0.39453068375587463,
0.3753327429294586,
-0.2191222608089447,
-0.017931198701262474,
0.09070412069559097,
-0.5702470541000366,
-0.9105858206748962,
0.25459563732147217,
0.11870458722114563,
0.11379370838403702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16524v1 | The Privileged Students: On the Value of Initialization in Multilingual Knowledge Distillation | 2024-06-24T10:59:26 | 2024-06-24T10:59:26 | Haryo Akbarianto Wibowo, Thamar Solorio, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | Knowledge distillation (KD) has proven to be a successful strategy to improve
the performance of a smaller model in many NLP tasks. However, most of the work
in KD only explores monolingual scenarios. In this paper, we investigate the
value of KD in multilingual settings. We find the significance of KD and model
initialization by analyzing how well the student model acquires multilingual
knowledge from the teacher model. Our proposed method emphasizes copying the
teacher model's weights directly to the student model to enhance
initialization. Our finding shows that model initialization using copy-weight
from the fine-tuned teacher contributes the most compared to the distillation
process itself across various multilingual settings. Furthermore, we
demonstrate that efficient weight initialization preserves multilingual
capabilities even in low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.16669383645057678,
-0.21700350940227509,
0.3161325752735138,
0.19046266376972198,
-0.39661017060279846,
0.4304872453212738,
-0.33882778882980347,
-0.2913074493408203,
-0.12323451042175293,
0.1384275108575821,
0.16030950844287872,
-0.1324366331100464,
-0.8803574442863464,
0.045632921159267426,
-0.17458131909370422,
1.4067732095718384,
0.0577157698571682,
0.3109827935695648,
-0.39356091618537903,
-0.14343328773975372,
-0.3585087060928345,
-0.8437290787696838,
-0.5982704162597656,
-0.48547399044036865,
0.5358448624610901,
0.8247312307357788,
0.5720189213752747,
0.42629626393318176,
0.0348992720246315,
0.29264435172080994,
-0.21803703904151917,
-0.09946082532405853,
-0.5712577104568481,
0.26646533608436584,
0.1404486447572708,
-0.6632697582244873,
0.020803559571504593,
0.1737833023071289,
0.6104130148887634,
1.2001076936721802,
-0.324605256319046,
0.21094714105129242,
0.4406990110874176,
0.9457319974899292,
-0.6508663296699524,
0.22795020043849945,
-0.5297972559928894,
0.1177452951669693,
-0.07457511126995087,
0.07736247777938843,
-0.4474502205848694,
-0.2566044330596924,
0.4371028542518616,
-0.6170591115951538,
0.18632465600967407,
-0.42251265048980713,
0.717416524887085,
0.12645304203033447,
-0.8031346797943115,
-0.29182931780815125,
-0.8267441987991333,
0.8335719108581543,
-0.43156659603118896,
0.5399911999702454,
0.4004702568054199,
0.28045618534088135,
0.13077621161937714,
-0.6691426038742065,
-0.5832608938217163,
0.03964151069521904,
-0.13899081945419312,
-0.014318191446363926,
0.1226087361574173,
-0.10226696729660034,
0.29678091406822205,
0.4168558716773987,
0.04346625134348869,
0.03383142128586769,
-0.9510822892189026,
0.1298530101776123,
0.37154561281204224,
-0.3077559769153595,
0.3194250166416168,
-0.24510619044303894,
-0.43277838826179504,
-0.26303336024284363,
-0.13117645680904388,
0.26929008960723877,
0.6877830028533936,
0.617552638053894,
-0.22312358021736145,
0.5037595629692078,
-0.21983426809310913,
0.49730342626571655,
-0.01019714493304491,
-0.6338241100311279,
0.12496063113212585,
-0.3383166193962097,
0.036360710859298706,
0.4633268415927887,
0.2052927315235138,
0.26944786310195923,
0.712304413318634,
-0.26070883870124817,
0.09730415046215057,
-0.05530247464776039,
0.12226531654596329,
-0.8792451024055481,
-0.3824922740459442,
-0.04638035595417023,
-0.5327848196029663,
-0.3352053463459015,
-0.1479060798883438,
-0.6019233465194702,
-0.34866172075271606,
-0.6655447483062744,
0.14833223819732666,
-0.4822145104408264,
-0.49440422654151917,
0.2573661506175995,
-0.4524400532245636,
-0.020215891301631927,
0.05235971137881279,
-1.3514693975448608,
0.37228983640670776,
0.4836948812007904,
0.6813896298408508,
-0.21413131058216095,
-0.39470580220222473,
-0.009120103903114796,
0.12823456525802612,
-0.0853869616985321,
0.17652882635593414,
-0.22191540896892548,
-0.5984789133071899,
-0.2522345185279846,
-0.09591255336999893,
0.08041578531265259,
-0.418080598115921,
0.5927978754043579,
-0.5721985101699829,
0.0644843578338623,
-0.5948672294616699,
-0.5655430555343628,
-0.03619927540421486,
-0.07233292609453201,
-0.47663992643356323,
1.07478666305542,
0.08134297281503677,
-0.772879958152771,
0.9816550016403198,
-0.47837013006210327,
-0.5211356282234192,
0.21719081699848175,
0.10706359893083572,
0.014348951168358326,
0.20447011291980743,
0.27062085270881653,
0.5159249305725098,
0.17349375784397125,
0.2588289678096771,
-0.015751739963889122,
0.2148534655570984,
-0.16701720654964447,
-0.4246537685394287,
1.1411935091018677,
0.2795754373073578,
0.10969842225313187,
-0.6228797435760498,
-0.7979326248168945,
0.07669597864151001,
0.17813177406787872,
-0.4891705811023712,
-1.1378628015518188,
-0.2985139787197113,
0.021418699994683266,
0.09097269177436829,
0.2435608059167862,
-0.4614342451095581,
0.3584555983543396,
-0.07800190895795822,
0.12982219457626343,
0.8939988613128662,
0.14429306983947754,
0.7159223556518555,
-0.1007654219865799,
0.6920191049575806,
0.20200076699256897,
0.07881759107112885,
-0.2661888301372528,
-0.4276711344718933,
-0.7506736516952515,
-0.25644156336784363,
0.5487678647041321,
0.2747578024864197,
-0.9236554503440857,
-0.39132291078567505,
-0.10350748896598816,
-0.5541145205497742,
-0.6769883036613464,
0.600592851638794,
0.3904394805431366,
0.5602002739906311,
0.33476653695106506,
0.1332898885011673,
-0.39779070019721985,
-1.0826921463012695,
-0.20420779287815094,
-0.1299971491098404,
0.1775791496038437,
0.22578994929790497,
0.3074442148208618,
0.4485267400741577,
0.9299272894859314,
-0.7585031986236572,
-0.29574573040008545,
-0.3330099582672119,
-0.046404168009757996,
0.2513895630836487,
0.754142165184021,
0.9562158584594727,
-0.9326773285865784,
-1.033371090888977,
0.139426589012146,
-0.8216384053230286,
-0.12603451311588287,
-0.029969077557325363,
-0.4617704451084137,
0.0339764729142189,
0.3566546142101288,
-0.29061630368232727,
-0.026182547211647034,
0.5957522392272949,
-0.32779332995414734,
0.38152197003364563,
-0.5333465933799744,
0.30105623602867126,
-1.402814269065857,
-0.08625955879688263,
-0.14688996970653534,
-0.08153722435235977,
-0.796386182308197,
0.14968076348304749,
0.0985151007771492,
-0.15872584283351898,
-0.4742740988731384,
0.4920910596847534,
-0.6725168228149414,
0.1838814616203308,
-0.25168871879577637,
0.06035846099257469,
0.2381577491760254,
0.25837597250938416,
0.06616069376468658,
0.44068872928619385,
0.4307829439640045,
-0.7206889986991882,
0.23779945075511932,
-0.06229158863425255,
-0.6123385429382324,
0.759954035282135,
-0.6950710415840149,
0.004099397920072079,
-0.33063679933547974,
-0.26160991191864014,
-0.7916104793548584,
0.004802060313522816,
-0.2777369022369385,
-0.31555187702178955,
0.5253273844718933,
-0.47121942043304443,
-0.5614813566207886,
-0.29425472021102905,
0.15860459208488464,
0.7518808841705322,
0.45714470744132996,
-0.743005096912384,
0.2942948043346405,
0.4364599883556366,
-0.2901942729949951,
-0.7507249116897583,
-0.5350861549377441,
-0.09713690727949142,
-0.26009202003479004,
-0.436428964138031,
0.053377702832221985,
-0.064151830971241,
-0.2731000781059265,
-0.06726933270692825,
-0.023357562720775604,
-0.24319444596767426,
0.366158664226532,
0.06644845008850098,
0.2694607377052307,
0.025287071242928505,
0.304383784532547,
0.5259461402893066,
-0.10099277645349503,
-0.16890014708042145,
-0.43921342492103577,
0.4919833242893219,
0.027571024373173714,
-0.21297933161258698,
-0.3217528760433197,
0.3092864751815796,
0.6393983960151672,
-0.0855330228805542,
1.0597031116485596,
0.26989123225212097,
-0.4972981810569763,
-0.2972542643547058,
-0.5133981704711914,
-0.38545259833335876,
-0.48027458786964417,
0.3789690136909485,
-0.5968712568283081,
-0.5096900463104248,
0.5954166650772095,
0.07846764475107193,
-0.12759344279766083,
0.17566676437854767,
0.29444020986557007,
0.07008462399244308,
0.6506015658378601,
1.052073359489441,
-0.15068140625953674,
0.28889068961143494,
-0.35836514830589294,
0.21454018354415894,
-0.6009421348571777,
-0.5551906228065491,
-0.6397982239723206,
-0.6370000839233398,
-0.2874823808670044,
-0.14258579909801483,
0.5815751552581787,
0.6961334347724915,
0.21142517030239105,
0.208507239818573,
-0.45180344581604004,
0.9141114950180054,
0.7295710444450378,
-0.04232127219438553,
0.6138490438461304,
-0.06389448046684265,
-0.4616885781288147,
-0.4564998149871826,
-0.9173986315727234,
-0.5132390260696411,
1.4686936140060425,
0.0859958678483963,
0.5616979598999023,
0.2906290292739868,
0.8514331579208374,
0.0713808611035347,
0.20278383791446686,
-0.6693249940872192,
0.1785217821598053,
-0.21754838526248932,
-0.5016520023345947,
-0.2878720462322235,
-0.26905807852745056,
-0.7935216426849365,
0.6784771084785461,
-0.18365095555782318,
-0.5317487120628357,
0.32872819900512695,
0.05717204511165619,
-0.5000176429748535,
0.32020655274391174,
-1.1405843496322632,
0.8911564946174622,
-0.23630467057228088,
-0.10413835942745209,
-0.14722083508968353,
-0.4023841917514801,
0.6983943581581116,
-0.23065686225891113,
0.3279571235179901,
0.020549071952700615,
0.16378003358840942,
0.8919509053230286,
-0.3057340085506439,
0.7702386379241943,
-0.6446566581726074,
-0.39431652426719666,
-0.029557477682828903,
-0.1098293736577034,
0.0055932290852069855,
0.34888559579849243,
-0.04750194400548935,
-0.06520845741033554,
0.3093996047973633,
-0.48720207810401917,
-0.5454778671264648,
0.7032979130744934,
-0.8789823055267334,
-0.6111613512039185,
-0.269893616437912,
-0.49444910883903503,
0.09282536059617996,
0.4249277710914612,
-0.06342358887195587,
0.19815181195735931,
0.02120218798518181,
0.3607092499732971,
0.5041406750679016,
-0.10265239328145981,
0.5494459867477417,
0.7019667029380798,
-0.4832192361354828,
-0.14596661925315857,
0.569253146648407,
0.5060039162635803,
0.7561041712760925,
-0.030861342325806618,
0.3254597783088684,
-0.07216273993253708,
-0.1292445957660675,
-0.652860701084137,
-0.1424068808555603,
-0.9781779050827026,
-0.16138561069965363,
-0.9386839866638184,
0.011570516973733902,
-0.49311602115631104,
-0.41049373149871826,
-0.7635185718536377,
-0.6279629468917847,
-0.28878286480903625,
-0.3069901764392853,
0.2559313476085663,
0.2375091314315796,
-0.13527928292751312,
0.278948575258255,
-0.7119422554969788,
0.5026553273200989,
0.4838428497314453,
0.09033772349357605,
0.2934158444404602,
-0.47882434725761414,
-0.5282140374183655,
0.1542900651693344,
-0.24261076748371124,
-0.6444411277770996,
0.17836447060108185,
0.5047892928123474,
0.745792031288147,
0.7723585367202759,
0.4570375978946686,
0.5283816456794739,
-0.4153638184070587,
0.8233915567398071,
0.053366538137197495,
-0.9076410531997681,
0.507778525352478,
0.1617010235786438,
0.47390270233154297,
0.7543298602104187,
0.8698696494102478,
-0.8109010457992554,
-0.4044274687767029,
-0.5029526352882385,
-0.8701327443122864,
0.7118421196937561,
-0.15305335819721222,
0.540336549282074,
0.08247330784797668,
0.47660815715789795,
0.4511021077632904,
0.3217577636241913,
-0.8634471297264099,
-0.5380190014839172,
-0.06885615736246109,
0.18283580243587494,
-0.1787954419851303,
-0.4074012339115143,
-0.14236345887184143,
-0.5678026080131531,
0.6179433465003967,
-0.043313756585121155,
-0.547537624835968,
-0.011177266016602516,
-0.20241716504096985,
0.16529396176338196,
0.22116738557815552,
0.3394482433795929,
0.6171541810035706,
0.028518008068203926,
0.3541448712348938,
0.14414654672145844,
-0.5885934829711914,
0.4596710503101349,
-0.1597534418106079,
-0.2939422130584717,
-0.10827969759702682,
0.20363248884677887,
0.7720332741737366,
0.43956440687179565,
-0.3668290376663208,
0.4713124930858612,
0.0573834627866745,
-0.13685661554336548,
0.013155972585082054,
-0.018291518092155457,
0.07483982294797897,
0.23550021648406982,
0.5395104289054871,
-0.022264709696173668,
-0.008938632905483246,
-0.5140321850776672,
0.1043156310915947,
0.29685351252555847,
0.09915881603956223,
-0.2867746949195862,
0.722346305847168,
0.014212420210242271,
0.18233118951320648,
0.7613588571548462,
-0.2251884639263153,
-0.7649152874946594,
0.5079347491264343,
0.602307915687561,
0.5774207711219788,
-0.37595582008361816,
0.3866909444332123,
0.5602095127105713,
0.27990463376045227,
-0.09535615146160126,
0.13514412939548492,
-0.29317614436149597,
-1.0615699291229248,
-0.1986730396747589,
-0.9071827530860901,
-0.08090395480394363,
-0.3799777626991272,
-0.936926543712616,
0.44402509927749634,
-0.17478349804878235,
-0.2164938598871231,
0.2443474680185318,
-0.06565013527870178,
-0.5528003573417664,
-0.12616115808486938,
0.025140969082713127,
0.4283079504966736,
-1.0166581869125366,
1.0061314105987549,
0.4981990158557892,
-0.15989692509174347,
-0.8821962475776672,
-0.3971700966358185,
-0.2052711844444275,
-0.5579707026481628,
1.2636020183563232,
-0.16787460446357727,
0.257986843585968,
0.1551799327135086,
-0.09113010764122009,
-0.6991355419158936,
1.1217814683914185,
0.4556708037853241,
-0.22607479989528656,
0.07721787691116333,
0.1786041408777237,
0.4867497682571411,
-0.20487435162067413,
-0.01614101231098175,
0.4270058572292328,
0.4845012426376343,
0.1605767011642456,
-1.0743991136550903,
-0.3104771077632904,
-0.17277075350284576,
0.19582578539848328,
0.0010232975473627448,
-0.37239453196525574,
1.1587743759155273,
-0.5888649821281433,
-0.3545343279838562,
-0.4157549738883972,
0.5557817220687866,
-0.1713128536939621,
0.039164382964372635,
0.48628851771354675,
0.6634489297866821,
0.9655092358589172,
0.07739735394716263,
0.9790537357330322,
-0.658249020576477,
0.20726218819618225,
1.18628990650177,
-0.11192508786916733,
0.6014364957809448,
0.9504387378692627,
-0.29772332310676575,
0.23253613710403442,
0.2593351900577545,
0.02130289375782013,
0.6692068576812744,
0.2757450342178345,
-0.4414513111114502,
0.03251120448112488,
-0.28582441806793213,
-0.5861301422119141,
0.5847991704940796,
-0.19133950769901276,
-0.305756151676178,
-0.3738425374031067,
0.7077662348747253,
0.26775071024894714,
0.34971243143081665,
-0.32489505410194397,
0.8182777762413025,
0.12326236814260483,
-0.6546468734741211,
0.5991472005844116,
0.15752650797367096,
0.6575689911842346,
-0.5363735556602478,
0.12388941645622253,
-0.21281872689723969,
0.2512124478816986,
-0.09087081253528595,
-0.3712707459926605,
0.20303399860858917,
0.00029859435744583607,
-0.6187950372695923,
-0.6685400009155273,
0.520603597164154,
-0.8543476462364197,
-0.6977317333221436,
0.2753698527812958,
0.6208239793777466,
0.030803730711340904,
0.11785911023616791,
-0.13777105510234833,
-0.28216904401779175,
-0.04754282534122467,
-0.05061100050806999,
0.48680752515792847,
0.5998089909553528,
0.14256985485553741,
0.5394216775894165,
0.7600554823875427,
0.23092035949230194,
0.30544474720954895,
0.17759932577610016,
0.8253140449523926,
0.01870385743677616,
-0.5254397392272949,
-1.083001971244812,
0.5610078573226929,
0.09740598499774933,
-0.30193638801574707,
1.106764554977417,
0.7063730359077454,
1.2232234477996826,
-0.3616970479488373,
0.6170344352722168,
-0.1372007131576538,
0.1837763488292694,
-0.45109087228775024,
1.1673578023910522,
-0.5112583637237549,
0.007907790131866932,
-0.5220303535461426,
-0.922431230545044,
0.0557115338742733,
0.4659166634082794,
0.014647153206169605,
-0.03480001538991928,
0.6175996661186218,
0.21029184758663177,
-0.047886062413454056,
-0.051497627049684525,
0.423923134803772,
-0.0729566290974617,
0.2166474610567093,
0.23441848158836365,
0.5858741998672485,
-0.36385074257850647,
0.18256914615631104,
-0.7992709279060364,
-0.3083576261997223,
0.27028995752334595,
-0.9887414574623108,
-0.7924390435218811,
-0.8386685252189636,
-0.3080613613128662,
-0.28364595770835876,
-0.22669611871242523,
0.8766779899597168,
0.7275151610374451,
-0.5342182517051697,
-0.34419694542884827,
0.3156667947769165,
0.3087782561779022,
-0.2794736325740814,
-0.24791109561920166,
0.14891064167022705,
-0.688073992729187,
-1.083457589149475,
0.14106982946395874,
-0.18075032532215118,
0.35607874393463135,
-0.2690785825252533,
-0.15468630194664001,
-0.41270342469215393,
-0.19594699144363403,
0.6293426752090454,
0.08509084582328796,
-0.2427811324596405,
-0.0032437406480312347,
-0.2277284860610962,
0.018046647310256958,
-0.2832101583480835,
0.8391940593719482,
-0.6634644865989685,
0.7818416953086853,
0.1406203955411911,
0.5534094572067261,
0.4913524389266968,
-0.13872583210468292,
0.642829954624176,
-1.179418921470642,
0.6091870665550232,
-0.0038451291620731354,
0.2776014506816864,
0.2710927128791809,
-0.32330048084259033,
0.3051758110523224,
0.38965609669685364,
-0.34590432047843933,
-1.1276887655258179,
-0.16823208332061768,
-0.6126918196678162,
-0.2163233906030655,
0.9313200116157532,
-0.4112503230571747,
0.36792629957199097,
0.07433944940567017,
-0.3108902871608734,
0.37711092829704285,
-0.26880642771720886,
0.8205447793006897,
1.1627691984176636,
0.41478532552719116,
-0.11827585101127625,
-0.7482561469078064,
0.7148066759109497,
0.3433681130409241,
-0.4672357439994812,
0.11905326694250107,
0.18897561728954315,
0.22368434071540833,
0.19491299986839294,
0.5767844319343567,
-0.05577555671334267,
-0.1892620325088501,
0.11840125918388367,
0.20833291113376617,
-0.28468260169029236,
-0.5035133361816406,
0.023955581709742546,
0.3520297110080719,
0.11274880915880203,
-0.2027631253004074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16521v1 | Carrot and Stick: Inducing Self-Motivation with Positive & Negative Feedback | 2024-06-24T10:55:31 | 2024-06-24T10:55:31 | Jimin Sohn, Jeihee Cho, Junyong Lee, Songmu Heo, Ji-Eun Han, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Positive thinking is thought to be an important component of self-motivation
in various practical fields such as education and the workplace. Previous work,
including sentiment transfer and positive reframing, has focused on the
positive side of language. However, self-motivation that drives people to reach
their goals has not yet been studied from a computational perspective.
Moreover, negative feedback has not yet been explored, even though positive and
negative feedback are both necessary to grow self-motivation. To facilitate
self-motivation, we propose CArrot and STICk (CASTIC) dataset, consisting of
12,590 sentences with 5 different strategies for enhancing self-motivation. Our
data and code are publicly available at here. | [
-0.22568850219249725,
-0.6254963278770447,
0.4112914502620697,
0.544315755367279,
-0.14710159599781036,
0.16774526238441467,
-0.04949871450662613,
-0.29752084612846375,
0.5217563509941101,
0.13941074907779694,
-0.7312162518501282,
-0.31495505571365356,
-0.386534720659256,
0.24526219069957733,
-0.26061978936195374,
1.1271791458129883,
0.12435834109783173,
0.3194839656352997,
-0.24300642311573029,
-0.07036259025335312,
-1.335879921913147,
-0.7055538892745972,
-0.2169782519340515,
-0.25877344608306885,
0.6748160123825073,
0.9942863583564758,
0.23171520233154297,
0.4560360610485077,
0.261056512594223,
0.15337274968624115,
0.47026142477989197,
-0.3819969892501831,
-0.7301285862922668,
0.3154759109020233,
-0.6712329983711243,
-0.6644240021705627,
0.08923669159412384,
0.5022640228271484,
0.09895584732294083,
0.24129922688007355,
0.034187328070402145,
0.4892929494380951,
0.14046745002269745,
0.801799476146698,
-0.5676048994064331,
0.12103264033794403,
-0.33014172315597534,
0.2196970283985138,
-0.15277734398841858,
-0.26350393891334534,
-0.1563960462808609,
-0.8627587556838989,
-0.19991576671600342,
-0.5085858702659607,
0.13222619891166687,
-0.19439828395843506,
0.6325550079345703,
0.10720138996839523,
-0.5552382469177246,
-0.6654152870178223,
-0.5691761374473572,
0.865898609161377,
-0.30194544792175293,
0.17675389349460602,
0.33218899369239807,
0.1337970644235611,
-0.031284671276807785,
-0.080476775765419,
-0.4174480438232422,
-0.1428440809249878,
0.22487516701221466,
0.4090367257595062,
0.21088901162147522,
-0.42229169607162476,
0.038690775632858276,
0.08147745579481125,
-0.23438461124897003,
-0.028028437867760658,
-0.6384497880935669,
0.02357666939496994,
0.42555272579193115,
0.11426140367984772,
0.07404515892267227,
-0.34618377685546875,
-0.4562051594257355,
-0.15118929743766785,
-0.9598949551582336,
0.3662935197353363,
0.23285996913909912,
0.4001960754394531,
0.15800660848617554,
0.8903720378875732,
-0.06938071548938751,
0.43532663583755493,
0.2953174114227295,
-0.17538736760616302,
0.2713535726070404,
-0.6785700917243958,
0.3083060383796692,
0.2139044553041458,
0.4047161638736725,
0.7303312420845032,
0.19185277819633484,
-0.20832519233226776,
-0.18770109117031097,
0.8411192297935486,
0.2698782980442047,
-0.9750534892082214,
-0.19974476099014282,
0.3813232481479645,
-0.41178467869758606,
-0.4224100708961487,
0.20941145718097687,
-0.8162996172904968,
-0.5712531805038452,
-0.5020396113395691,
0.49712908267974854,
-0.6505033373832703,
-0.24362491071224213,
0.12813986837863922,
-0.5698015093803406,
0.5079548954963684,
0.4058256149291992,
-0.9390063881874084,
0.16682183742523193,
1.1323034763336182,
0.6725717782974243,
-0.21125401556491852,
-0.40551039576530457,
-0.6990345120429993,
0.1601804792881012,
-0.6736288666725159,
0.9290849566459656,
-0.5347598195075989,
-0.17728635668754578,
0.2497478574514389,
-0.02862481027841568,
-0.01953081414103508,
-0.6010237336158752,
0.6564253568649292,
0.06527836620807648,
0.6368044018745422,
-0.7663130760192871,
-0.7514355182647705,
-0.3028642535209656,
0.47891727089881897,
-0.1673252433538437,
0.7930473685264587,
0.3021821975708008,
-0.3049931228160858,
0.7225508689880371,
-0.7862372398376465,
-0.8057470917701721,
0.07756073772907257,
-0.45373842120170593,
-0.05324086546897888,
0.22821415960788727,
0.024855831637978554,
0.6019748449325562,
-0.43414461612701416,
0.2713516652584076,
-0.3735668361186981,
-0.17225806415081024,
0.4334454834461212,
0.11481945216655731,
0.7831628918647766,
0.1484089344739914,
-0.6874823570251465,
0.172127366065979,
-0.29590824246406555,
-0.12616059184074402,
0.06918859481811523,
-0.1460118144750595,
-0.20409239828586578,
-0.08263905346393585,
-0.2957558333873749,
0.6421135067939758,
0.36042577028274536,
-0.7235996127128601,
0.5467284917831421,
-0.16487641632556915,
0.44029492139816284,
0.8677442669868469,
0.26795169711112976,
0.0583202950656414,
-0.3614785075187683,
0.9218159914016724,
0.15216119587421417,
0.0915817990899086,
-0.041726671159267426,
-0.6116554737091064,
-0.42431414127349854,
0.018466079607605934,
0.21450236439704895,
0.6425723433494568,
-0.8229027390480042,
0.1749967634677887,
0.030634526163339615,
-0.32501018047332764,
-0.744881808757782,
0.4097864627838135,
0.2611270844936371,
0.8155877590179443,
0.21586322784423828,
-0.30210787057876587,
-0.3343978822231293,
-0.45807990431785583,
-0.25113052129745483,
0.11613618582487106,
-0.017352795228362083,
0.1781948357820511,
0.43724215030670166,
0.04632220417261124,
0.8517035245895386,
-0.6133971214294434,
-0.6815230250358582,
-0.12860310077667236,
0.20893079042434692,
0.4791138172149658,
0.4666808247566223,
0.6408596038818359,
-0.6246598362922668,
-0.8154664039611816,
-0.36928626894950867,
-0.5510371327400208,
0.0995023176074028,
-0.41728004813194275,
-0.05636635050177574,
-0.27437299489974976,
0.39051395654678345,
-0.501481294631958,
0.43374553322792053,
0.23694901168346405,
-0.9414903521537781,
0.6691250205039978,
0.21939487755298615,
0.47552451491355896,
-0.6652138829231262,
-0.24505794048309326,
0.20343565940856934,
-0.36381882429122925,
-0.42941364645957947,
-0.20993392169475555,
0.03664803504943848,
-0.12377790361642838,
-0.8518433570861816,
0.1900966614484787,
-0.2318103164434433,
0.20245400071144104,
-0.22818821668624878,
0.20504793524742126,
0.04169909283518791,
0.5691718459129333,
-0.14042437076568604,
1.1214381456375122,
0.9337708353996277,
-0.7494871020317078,
0.2180459052324295,
0.25475412607192993,
-0.12845855951309204,
0.9422927498817444,
-0.6985871195793152,
-0.07491666823625565,
-0.19847500324249268,
-0.12897412478923798,
-1.114537000656128,
-0.12123080343008041,
0.5096222162246704,
-0.38372349739074707,
0.05525706335902214,
0.18427149951457977,
-0.1861269474029541,
-0.5347639918327332,
-0.8708364367485046,
0.22560226917266846,
0.5354149341583252,
-0.6343437433242798,
0.00603601336479187,
0.5173285007476807,
0.07712024450302124,
-0.08920406550168991,
-0.4931970536708832,
0.021863320842385292,
-0.6069973111152649,
-0.13585595786571503,
0.32970452308654785,
-0.2629118859767914,
0.12120206654071808,
-0.04603101685643196,
0.1570615917444229,
0.43076545000076294,
-0.17632639408111572,
0.25668251514434814,
0.08378593623638153,
-0.06339297443628311,
0.3105226457118988,
-0.13710327446460724,
-0.20164230465888977,
0.3065227270126343,
-0.2656657099723816,
0.5846585631370544,
-0.33034148812294006,
-0.12454380840063095,
-0.5608225464820862,
0.43970754742622375,
0.42447832226753235,
-0.0021499693393707275,
0.551840603351593,
0.5986166596412659,
-0.062227763235569,
0.20205500721931458,
-0.35096290707588196,
-0.41220593452453613,
-0.515121579170227,
0.048874419182538986,
-0.3324454724788666,
-0.9585608243942261,
0.1894351691007614,
-0.4605904221534729,
-0.26629024744033813,
0.525733232498169,
0.8062425255775452,
-0.33277806639671326,
1.0100692510604858,
0.45777758955955505,
0.012599718756973743,
0.5280608534812927,
-0.017655178904533386,
-0.021499192342162132,
-0.7746500372886658,
-0.048868320882320404,
-0.3853907287120819,
-0.4980837106704712,
-0.351824551820755,
-0.24742405116558075,
0.0010119372745975852,
0.25768545269966125,
-0.10146810859441757,
0.45254215598106384,
-1.206269383430481,
0.4427994191646576,
0.7725167274475098,
-0.17958278954029083,
-0.2160482406616211,
-0.6625795960426331,
-0.11619846522808075,
-0.3394792973995209,
-0.6463601589202881,
-0.3080296516418457,
0.9104565978050232,
0.2973523736000061,
0.6960685849189758,
0.19887495040893555,
0.9475870728492737,
0.4678012430667877,
0.6631137728691101,
-0.8855109810829163,
0.5947499871253967,
0.042609281837940216,
-0.8116719126701355,
-0.3136744499206543,
-0.25473394989967346,
-1.279728889465332,
-0.10056374967098236,
-0.06265595555305481,
-0.7379952073097229,
0.44259101152420044,
0.2759099304676056,
-0.2672324478626251,
-0.31216326355934143,
-1.155370831489563,
1.1817831993103027,
-0.6137319207191467,
-0.42069968581199646,
-0.323661744594574,
-0.5824037790298462,
0.2912609577178955,
0.08530515432357788,
0.2015942633152008,
-0.4704211950302124,
0.08375424146652222,
1.04168701171875,
-0.2509556710720062,
0.9037908315658569,
-0.6005693674087524,
0.0244185421615839,
0.7409965395927429,
0.18682610988616943,
0.32576271891593933,
0.15622052550315857,
0.09276904910802841,
-0.32283714413642883,
0.28569960594177246,
-0.302533894777298,
-0.7960801124572754,
0.6567735075950623,
-0.6798544526100159,
-0.6953429579734802,
-0.545855700969696,
-0.01850229501724243,
-0.1352645307779312,
0.3090726137161255,
0.12913763523101807,
-0.11194103956222534,
-0.12823984026908875,
0.16451919078826904,
0.23122566938400269,
0.1755191832780838,
0.33080366253852844,
0.20442892611026764,
-0.8366493582725525,
-0.6721771359443665,
1.3826340436935425,
0.1847304105758667,
0.08396457880735397,
0.18206787109375,
0.5449559688568115,
-0.30376771092414856,
0.018042495474219322,
-0.12512965500354767,
0.24430246651172638,
-0.49168160557746887,
-0.6746092438697815,
0.04998158663511276,
0.37406450510025024,
-0.6688445210456848,
-0.2269010841846466,
-0.5080978274345398,
-1.0550298690795898,
-0.6920163035392761,
-0.1537903994321823,
0.3447759449481964,
1.204755425453186,
-0.464029461145401,
-0.09396766871213913,
-0.383247971534729,
0.38452810049057007,
0.5321263670921326,
0.33089178800582886,
0.05919275060296059,
0.1634674370288849,
-0.33347249031066895,
0.03936776518821716,
-0.7157306671142578,
-1.2757482528686523,
0.39388614892959595,
0.06944595277309418,
0.11156997829675674,
0.49345332384109497,
0.0072494251653552055,
0.5531520843505859,
-0.4056975841522217,
0.8734636902809143,
0.6831272840499878,
-1.0015605688095093,
0.7987343072891235,
-0.22298167645931244,
0.3836613595485687,
0.7785398364067078,
0.5870285034179688,
-0.590032160282135,
-0.127470001578331,
-0.29645004868507385,
-0.6147838830947876,
0.4020949900150299,
-0.12132659554481506,
-0.06369652599096298,
-0.31719931960105896,
0.5456884503364563,
0.5831297636032104,
0.4700445234775543,
-0.9642552733421326,
-0.2042207419872284,
-1.0163830518722534,
0.04739786311984062,
0.005931648891419172,
-0.10545022785663605,
-0.357473760843277,
-0.9024645090103149,
0.6931772828102112,
-0.1890038102865219,
0.6907598972320557,
0.2352340817451477,
0.2177022099494934,
-0.29248878359794617,
0.2437763661146164,
0.6558603048324585,
0.5153544545173645,
-0.21046976745128632,
0.07964501529932022,
-0.14969885349273682,
-0.3914879858493805,
0.49750643968582153,
-0.3038366734981537,
0.07403246313333511,
-0.24920038878917694,
-0.2219373732805252,
0.49754467606544495,
0.03716997429728508,
-0.30240726470947266,
0.7727551460266113,
-0.1709631085395813,
-0.36024796962738037,
-0.21902646124362946,
0.33574381470680237,
0.24675677716732025,
-0.0034915851429104805,
0.4132906198501587,
-0.044899068772792816,
0.05702169984579086,
-0.8074392676353455,
0.24730715155601501,
0.537821352481842,
-0.635663628578186,
-0.48027846217155457,
0.6622694730758667,
0.20606930553913116,
-0.8056384921073914,
0.5710601210594177,
-0.5565633773803711,
-0.780072033405304,
0.1409071683883667,
0.9366765022277832,
0.8943834900856018,
-0.19109652936458588,
0.7255955934524536,
0.3118794858455658,
0.010203259065747261,
0.3058117926120758,
0.5241581797599792,
-0.17918187379837036,
-0.5290758609771729,
-0.5715125203132629,
-0.15653638541698456,
-0.5804572105407715,
-0.1777421236038208,
-0.713051438331604,
0.4433746337890625,
-0.24809570610523224,
-0.35755833983421326,
-0.09805090725421906,
-0.10071813315153122,
-0.8232800960540771,
0.23781119287014008,
-0.2532438635826111,
0.6961512565612793,
-0.7380702495574951,
0.6983239650726318,
0.6272523999214172,
-0.6226184964179993,
-0.6750030517578125,
-0.12935380637645721,
-0.37978705763816833,
-0.7743325233459473,
0.6426250338554382,
0.43610382080078125,
-0.054686736315488815,
-0.1846524477005005,
-0.6046741008758545,
-0.896683931350708,
0.9165732860565186,
0.3162434697151184,
-0.17885775864124298,
0.16313232481479645,
0.4174444377422333,
0.5181894898414612,
-0.5386006236076355,
-0.12553472816944122,
0.12516167759895325,
0.5291220545768738,
0.12955722212791443,
-0.4193553328514099,
0.22216738760471344,
-0.10310065746307373,
-0.4251566529273987,
0.1074514165520668,
-0.8485026955604553,
0.7786865830421448,
-0.0935400202870369,
-0.2317359894514084,
-0.4724479615688324,
0.8882761597633362,
0.07886380702257156,
0.09414241462945938,
0.4778141677379608,
0.3956555426120758,
0.7060397267341614,
0.09496519714593887,
0.8355997204780579,
-0.7003729939460754,
0.2976613938808441,
0.9144082069396973,
-0.3654208183288574,
0.8526023030281067,
0.8933199048042297,
-0.17975351214408875,
0.8550963401794434,
0.5668773055076599,
-0.08750929683446884,
0.833781361579895,
0.1363907754421234,
0.06078256294131279,
-0.22319592535495758,
-0.0726746991276741,
-0.40661898255348206,
0.34464654326438904,
0.5390039086341858,
0.016917087137699127,
0.05690591409802437,
0.49503758549690247,
-0.09422427415847778,
-0.02505810372531414,
-0.23220820724964142,
0.5480486154556274,
0.06433794647455215,
-1.0284309387207031,
0.48463350534439087,
-0.36833205819129944,
0.6694709062576294,
-0.23856738209724426,
-0.30795818567276,
0.17304767668247223,
0.2438880056142807,
-0.15371352434158325,
-0.9777865409851074,
0.27024927735328674,
-0.357483446598053,
-0.009791570715606213,
-0.7639190554618835,
0.9419404864311218,
-0.20806504786014557,
-0.2867695689201355,
0.014015582390129566,
0.5891702771186829,
0.026696914806962013,
0.19205044209957123,
-0.7307978868484497,
-0.14504587650299072,
0.1483146697282791,
-0.16827960312366486,
0.35664430260658264,
0.6889662146568298,
0.48625874519348145,
0.4651270806789398,
0.5604488849639893,
-0.04224661365151405,
-0.016125714406371117,
-0.1713247001171112,
0.9219104647636414,
-1.0457763671875,
-0.6326488852500916,
-0.7791525721549988,
0.5528159141540527,
-0.0752103328704834,
-0.6369753479957581,
1.3233376741409302,
0.7121905088424683,
0.5242756009101868,
-0.4069947302341461,
0.4777754247188568,
-0.2483968436717987,
0.874636173248291,
-0.16633331775665283,
0.4391031861305237,
-0.36870840191841125,
-0.07007632404565811,
-0.39049386978149414,
-0.9108192324638367,
-0.2547362744808197,
0.7533098459243774,
-0.5744005441665649,
-0.1104012131690979,
0.7413296699523926,
0.3392569422721863,
0.29836711287498474,
0.10383957624435425,
0.0640435442328453,
-0.020799903199076653,
0.5330828428268433,
0.3586456775665283,
1.0193121433258057,
-0.02189994417130947,
0.4194333255290985,
-0.32380640506744385,
-0.49520087242126465,
-0.15618400275707245,
-1.085126519203186,
-0.8961865305900574,
-0.6219032406806946,
-0.6985173225402832,
-0.6105279922485352,
0.02632022835314274,
0.9170261025428772,
0.6239234805107117,
-0.8519791960716248,
-0.5446513295173645,
-0.5449569821357727,
0.522542417049408,
-0.3747434616088867,
-0.3326953053474426,
0.2406226396560669,
-0.5685877799987793,
-0.24589799344539642,
0.26386043429374695,
0.3458844721317291,
0.030985111370682716,
-0.5876771807670593,
-0.1050373986363411,
-0.5975510478019714,
0.16178502142429352,
0.5564728379249573,
0.5646790862083435,
-0.16474047303199768,
-0.629088282585144,
0.12904705107212067,
0.08459729701280594,
0.533627986907959,
0.9630553722381592,
-1.1530258655548096,
0.2859019935131073,
0.3167129456996918,
0.24577133357524872,
0.49632424116134644,
0.11045239865779877,
0.6062990427017212,
-0.4127170741558075,
-0.20064063370227814,
0.595633327960968,
0.11125117540359497,
0.33394625782966614,
-0.4727615416049957,
0.610057532787323,
0.2852426767349243,
-0.96115642786026,
-0.657427966594696,
0.22456972301006317,
-0.5829407572746277,
-0.296726793050766,
0.9586163759231567,
0.10971251130104065,
-0.5272992849349976,
-0.001641669892705977,
-0.638278603553772,
0.10934483259916306,
-0.48686084151268005,
1.1101603507995605,
0.8054465055465698,
-0.8961162567138672,
0.1476791352033615,
-0.058053843677043915,
0.6348034739494324,
0.8109955191612244,
-0.8833144307136536,
-0.039723366498947144,
0.38633993268013,
0.04022620990872383,
0.46625804901123047,
0.6675648093223572,
0.3178434371948242,
0.3447970747947693,
0.033213093876838684,
-0.16435328125953674,
0.31316494941711426,
-0.4278899133205414,
-0.017183596268296242,
0.44002071022987366,
0.18328619003295898,
-0.4101903438568115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16508v1 | Large Vocabulary Size Improves Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T10:27:07 | 2024-06-24T10:27:07 | Sho Takase, Ryokan Ri, Shun Kiyono, Takuya Kato | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper empirically investigates the relationship between subword
vocabulary size and the performance of large language models (LLMs) to provide
insights on how to define the vocabulary size. Experimental results show that
larger vocabulary sizes lead to better performance in LLMs. Moreover, we
consider a continual training scenario where a pre-trained language model is
trained on a different target language. We introduce a simple method to use a
new vocabulary instead of the pre-defined one. We show that using the new
vocabulary outperforms the model with the vocabulary used in pre-training. | [
-0.5317494869232178,
-0.6927599906921387,
0.489122599363327,
0.15471455454826355,
-0.5630890130996704,
0.207940474152565,
-0.6657734513282776,
-0.6949590444564819,
0.297579824924469,
0.4438106417655945,
-0.07389603555202484,
-0.08632826060056686,
-0.896551251411438,
0.15639017522335052,
-0.5747605562210083,
0.6523204445838928,
0.029340315610170364,
0.32902804017066956,
-0.42583146691322327,
-0.012509791180491447,
-0.4340556859970093,
-0.7474600076675415,
-0.9788806438446045,
-0.6804965734481812,
0.7864561676979065,
0.1313202679157257,
0.7901660799980164,
0.7793832421302795,
0.8269376754760742,
0.39666905999183655,
-0.21067464351654053,
-0.049228254705667496,
-0.7451754212379456,
0.044119544327259064,
-0.05843088775873184,
-0.5061694979667664,
-0.3928433656692505,
-0.03205334022641182,
0.8781841397285461,
0.8889539837837219,
-0.21750842034816742,
0.13397316634655,
0.07580693811178207,
0.45389726758003235,
-0.5670732259750366,
-0.07503592222929001,
-0.6752160787582397,
-0.1707577109336853,
-0.2992149889469147,
-0.28729715943336487,
-0.27530723810195923,
0.05334657058119774,
0.2547406256198883,
-0.5538034439086914,
0.01784246414899826,
0.1476384997367859,
0.8734248876571655,
0.14312423765659332,
-0.21174491941928864,
-0.19814173877239227,
-0.7161238193511963,
0.9175403714179993,
-0.8932826519012451,
0.7131731510162354,
0.19053053855895996,
0.0825066864490509,
-0.24309688806533813,
-0.7483306527137756,
-0.660973310470581,
-0.6686538457870483,
-0.04572819545865059,
-0.25763726234436035,
0.059845034033060074,
0.23379634320735931,
0.3536399006843567,
0.44528135657310486,
-0.37835875153541565,
0.5232313871383667,
-0.37185996770858765,
-0.005191143602132797,
0.7085832357406616,
0.16949890553951263,
0.10170047730207443,
0.3470180332660675,
-0.05702189728617668,
-0.0061952583491802216,
-0.9982651472091675,
-0.35274219512939453,
0.24222277104854584,
0.2274327576160431,
0.08284128457307816,
0.6159703135490417,
0.015486019663512707,
0.7438290119171143,
-0.1705903708934784,
-0.5132511854171753,
0.25431764125823975,
-0.3562159538269043,
-0.2915368974208832,
-0.05206245556473732,
0.46756991744041443,
0.22384126484394073,
0.7117551565170288,
-0.22506257891654968,
-0.10735122114419937,
-0.10325850546360016,
0.08103462308645248,
-0.845887303352356,
0.03051908314228058,
-0.10845731943845749,
-0.4323211908340454,
0.13568048179149628,
-0.12304320186376572,
-0.40496909618377686,
-0.28971877694129944,
-0.6028683185577393,
0.506382942199707,
-0.25967469811439514,
-0.35397830605506897,
0.3383016884326935,
-0.21284951269626617,
0.3576584458351135,
0.3288290798664093,
-0.739949643611908,
0.4989657998085022,
0.7342833876609802,
0.955901026725769,
-0.2825346291065216,
-0.46253567934036255,
-0.45115387439727783,
0.052589051425457,
-0.8258095979690552,
0.44927066564559937,
-0.4946274757385254,
-0.515993058681488,
0.11730428785085678,
-0.1498125046491623,
-0.013175994157791138,
-0.9375778436660767,
-0.09290076792240143,
-0.7045765519142151,
0.007257725577801466,
-0.11369743198156357,
-0.8204197883605957,
0.2089405208826065,
0.2129134088754654,
-0.6433002948760986,
0.9537956118583679,
0.07706501334905624,
-0.49244433641433716,
0.5642733573913574,
-0.5754489898681641,
-0.5407530665397644,
0.12750664353370667,
0.0359676294028759,
-0.2458096444606781,
0.4927644431591034,
-0.17374244332313538,
0.608585774898529,
-0.3202950060367584,
0.0745459794998169,
-0.21884368360042572,
-0.347033828496933,
0.4256449341773987,
-0.039461273699998856,
0.15309152007102966,
0.1337948888540268,
0.17195011675357819,
0.17625081539154053,
-0.4263208210468292,
0.013992857187986374,
0.1642143875360489,
-0.6098685264587402,
-0.5230490565299988,
-0.03323900327086449,
-0.09800653904676437,
0.2329237461090088,
0.6036040186882019,
-0.595615804195404,
-0.03352445736527443,
-0.647552490234375,
0.2845028042793274,
0.38254037499427795,
-0.08364487439393997,
0.4708901345729828,
-0.2888408303260803,
0.5691492557525635,
-0.19918955862522125,
-0.0201129000633955,
0.03235062211751938,
-0.1105751022696495,
-0.9477683305740356,
-0.247988760471344,
0.8466790318489075,
0.27758803963661194,
-0.5108199715614319,
0.29661667346954346,
-0.6174066662788391,
-0.46401092410087585,
-0.23816829919815063,
0.6548569798469543,
0.3498324751853943,
0.045386556535959244,
0.18356157839298248,
-0.5527587532997131,
-0.8515905141830444,
-0.818504810333252,
-0.1439974457025528,
0.007755175698548555,
-0.07262297719717026,
0.28207769989967346,
0.7227439284324646,
-0.07903487980365753,
0.678383469581604,
-0.4214499294757843,
-0.2022351622581482,
-0.8609746098518372,
-0.1397634595632553,
0.01660609431564808,
0.36798083782196045,
0.5371618270874023,
-0.5324258804321289,
-0.5345718860626221,
0.004622320644557476,
-0.4989382326602936,
0.12142681330442429,
0.016869721934199333,
-0.009525364264845848,
0.2484796941280365,
0.8505086898803711,
-0.6441240310668945,
0.35894984006881714,
0.6626959443092346,
0.002424023812636733,
0.5841686129570007,
-0.46967607736587524,
-0.38822126388549805,
-1.061163067817688,
-0.26477086544036865,
0.058502450585365295,
-0.1603367030620575,
-0.3201746642589569,
0.11573198437690735,
-0.07826002687215805,
0.2161247730255127,
-0.5792914628982544,
0.8509625792503357,
-0.7459719181060791,
-0.422555536031723,
-0.4980561137199402,
0.2424665093421936,
-0.22959226369857788,
-0.059813957661390305,
0.23138131201267242,
0.9138142466545105,
0.5522724986076355,
-0.7733978033065796,
0.5523092150688171,
-0.12472761422395706,
-0.7277546525001526,
0.017735378816723824,
-0.8905644416809082,
-0.2552184462547302,
-0.09911536425352097,
0.24249733984470367,
-0.964331328868866,
-0.24017122387886047,
-0.7005269527435303,
-0.4474615156650543,
0.6078777313232422,
0.13932563364505768,
-0.6357574462890625,
-0.49112653732299805,
-0.12834686040878296,
0.17511171102523804,
0.5911665558815002,
-0.4478166699409485,
0.5277111530303955,
0.32365015149116516,
-0.16714169085025787,
-0.40792116522789,
-0.7894014120101929,
0.2801499366760254,
-0.44775447249412537,
-0.4422741234302521,
0.2731105387210846,
-0.10152919590473175,
-0.5889713168144226,
-0.25373706221580505,
0.0905502662062645,
0.024356363341212273,
0.2496047466993332,
-0.0030215545557439327,
0.2721751630306244,
-0.41646307706832886,
0.7283580303192139,
-0.41947153210639954,
0.056328967213630676,
0.17601870000362396,
-0.05978701263666153,
1.131576418876648,
-0.04109359532594681,
0.028102807700634003,
-0.22411997616291046,
0.34823474287986755,
0.39036452770233154,
-0.31053397059440613,
1.2645230293273926,
0.2626492381095886,
-0.10146971046924591,
-0.1722879856824875,
-0.5866225957870483,
-0.26568403840065,
-0.4835139811038971,
0.7525522112846375,
-0.4531940817832947,
-0.9851519465446472,
0.4910258650779724,
-0.19910135865211487,
0.026778629049658775,
0.3830319046974182,
0.6307238340377808,
-0.00852915644645691,
0.8520209789276123,
0.9751378297805786,
-0.24092911183834076,
0.7431547045707703,
-0.20835602283477783,
0.12609262764453888,
-0.9700497984886169,
-0.07905197888612747,
-0.37076881527900696,
-0.35826295614242554,
-0.3981088399887085,
-0.47540047764778137,
0.12436734139919281,
0.2513491213321686,
-0.3329750597476959,
0.18346242606639862,
-0.017835885286331177,
0.4764806628227234,
0.48597919940948486,
-0.17449386417865753,
0.18062472343444824,
0.10045057535171509,
-0.008046796545386314,
0.06264621019363403,
-0.7437072992324829,
-0.4511469900608063,
1.1574331521987915,
0.6328758001327515,
0.8605285882949829,
0.35015469789505005,
0.6533027291297913,
-0.09777705371379852,
0.45007869601249695,
-1.1774189472198486,
0.6736282110214233,
-0.18590699136257172,
-0.6383712291717529,
-0.6277481317520142,
-0.4422179162502289,
-1.3195548057556152,
0.21500347554683685,
-0.35601896047592163,
-0.49280181527137756,
-0.3431607782840729,
0.0236483346670866,
-0.18524815142154694,
0.19155561923980713,
-0.5966412425041199,
0.5346702933311462,
-0.4846090078353882,
-0.18633918464183807,
-0.44568493962287903,
-0.27308034896850586,
-0.058489471673965454,
-0.3227648437023163,
0.09849333763122559,
0.16862817108631134,
-0.45839250087738037,
0.9838525056838989,
-0.5294745564460754,
0.6771129369735718,
0.2677929103374481,
-0.16438902914524078,
0.1278710514307022,
-0.06813722848892212,
0.3361596465110779,
-0.08539532124996185,
0.013739439658820629,
0.29389363527297974,
-0.20804306864738464,
-0.458141952753067,
-0.48447123169898987,
0.7874851822853088,
-0.8327778577804565,
-0.6866269111633301,
-0.20651215314865112,
-0.6765379905700684,
-0.45776984095573425,
0.1855429857969284,
0.43351876735687256,
0.3398423194885254,
-0.13049741089344025,
0.7193755507469177,
0.8864040374755859,
-0.30248260498046875,
0.6510701179504395,
0.6157037019729614,
-0.493318110704422,
0.07908459007740021,
0.3212153911590576,
0.511975109577179,
0.5779675841331482,
0.547042191028595,
0.33774328231811523,
-0.44586220383644104,
-0.8555617928504944,
0.004769989755004644,
0.4678971767425537,
-0.5239341259002686,
0.03722545504570007,
-0.5287483930587769,
-0.32396185398101807,
-0.6709892749786377,
-0.006804635748267174,
-0.44258588552474976,
-0.13415412604808807,
-0.003014459041878581,
-0.18891923129558563,
0.6080577969551086,
0.6959625482559204,
-0.024438362568616867,
0.7638748288154602,
-0.5880364179611206,
-0.17519576847553253,
0.40116560459136963,
0.38799917697906494,
0.18547892570495605,
-0.9161537289619446,
-0.4341653287410736,
-0.20090025663375854,
0.1978718638420105,
-0.4548158645629883,
0.5849260687828064,
0.30442550778388977,
0.7760758399963379,
0.20822261273860931,
-0.405504435300827,
0.6896941661834717,
-0.6268426775932312,
0.8043237924575806,
0.3532707691192627,
-0.8060968518257141,
0.240706205368042,
-0.307546466588974,
0.47255563735961914,
0.1759704351425171,
0.5205198526382446,
-0.35245993733406067,
-0.01132460031658411,
-0.675101101398468,
-0.8921911120414734,
0.06012672930955887,
-0.1652074158191681,
0.5298244953155518,
-0.16109946370124817,
0.4975411593914032,
-0.1628233939409256,
0.3407849967479706,
-0.5483217835426331,
-0.11776182055473328,
0.3159680664539337,
-0.10753558576107025,
-0.8484296798706055,
-0.526020884513855,
-0.0022725702729076147,
-0.2913038730621338,
0.6873704195022583,
-0.01842532679438591,
0.19939939677715302,
-0.3069351315498352,
-0.09356356412172318,
-0.10979416221380234,
0.21998417377471924,
0.564582347869873,
0.9858622550964355,
0.07783801853656769,
0.19714072346687317,
0.6800776124000549,
-0.5710126757621765,
-0.2191554754972458,
-0.2660510540008545,
0.44541099667549133,
0.1132373958826065,
0.8574439287185669,
0.5863237380981445,
0.0972307026386261,
-0.949238121509552,
0.447618305683136,
0.026143286377191544,
-0.31956747174263,
-0.6040770411491394,
0.11378223448991776,
0.4776031970977783,
0.020719660446047783,
0.1360090970993042,
-0.49128028750419617,
-0.3038448393344879,
-0.7142553329467773,
0.11723954975605011,
0.53072589635849,
-0.14982420206069946,
0.19905659556388855,
-0.015994248911738396,
-0.04778977856040001,
-0.34227392077445984,
0.5249063372612,
0.22726893424987793,
-0.5042209029197693,
0.7763729095458984,
0.6955987811088562,
0.24642325937747955,
-0.35443729162216187,
-0.10421918332576752,
0.258052259683609,
0.31589028239250183,
-0.4328131377696991,
0.16626955568790436,
0.19627711176872253,
-0.933940589427948,
-0.8695239424705505,
-0.8255752921104431,
-0.2644403874874115,
0.6892683506011963,
-0.5428687334060669,
-0.06334801018238068,
-0.6486034989356995,
-0.11289191991090775,
0.06385539472103119,
0.3945884108543396,
-0.6260886788368225,
0.5516806244850159,
0.007646008860319853,
1.058215618133545,
-0.46503111720085144,
1.1354049444198608,
0.7577682137489319,
-0.2103102058172226,
-1.2029247283935547,
-0.30550524592399597,
-0.3057423233985901,
-0.8480176329612732,
1.0968708992004395,
-0.05796283110976219,
-0.11692337691783905,
-0.19063979387283325,
-0.539603054523468,
-1.355034351348877,
0.7510214447975159,
0.0001595256762811914,
-0.8947757482528687,
0.21142593026161194,
0.2026595175266266,
0.8298631906509399,
-0.6250941753387451,
-0.14731848239898682,
0.582791805267334,
0.11975590884685516,
0.18369141221046448,
-1.1903711557388306,
-0.28204312920570374,
0.07544027268886566,
0.2255493551492691,
0.47951096296310425,
-0.4494127929210663,
1.0777591466903687,
-0.10144598037004471,
0.22868730127811432,
0.39547625184059143,
0.867328941822052,
0.027422018349170685,
-0.08045569807291031,
0.5653048157691956,
0.5714626908302307,
0.5878974199295044,
0.062405675649642944,
1.2523856163024902,
-0.26691651344299316,
0.31594759225845337,
1.3441102504730225,
-0.3797862231731415,
1.3034021854400635,
0.5855111479759216,
-0.1008196473121643,
0.33220964670181274,
0.6253330707550049,
0.17269419133663177,
0.18578824400901794,
0.650732159614563,
-0.19770312309265137,
-0.5938014984130859,
-0.04962361976504326,
-0.5099121332168579,
0.6031510829925537,
0.581398069858551,
-0.5638939142227173,
-0.04590505734086037,
0.20787367224693298,
0.050754498690366745,
0.1012282744050026,
-0.7482137680053711,
0.7474544644355774,
0.3085096478462219,
-0.5152180790901184,
0.6595209240913391,
0.06542745977640152,
0.8305783867835999,
-0.7441153526306152,
0.39904701709747314,
-0.1680910438299179,
0.4825698733329773,
0.02854534052312374,
-0.7853361964225769,
0.3640446662902832,
-0.1007954478263855,
-0.012936877086758614,
0.08432761579751968,
0.7313293814659119,
-0.44978323578834534,
-0.3345765769481659,
0.43223413825035095,
0.6000281572341919,
0.2826560437679291,
0.058981262147426605,
-0.5475099682807922,
0.13779577612876892,
-0.4967212975025177,
-0.22408610582351685,
0.7309620976448059,
0.47445783019065857,
-0.07918375730514526,
0.7769757509231567,
0.6158970594406128,
0.527396023273468,
0.23180733621120453,
0.08803832530975342,
0.6773407459259033,
-0.5516220331192017,
-0.3435977101325989,
-0.8827739357948303,
-0.16593997180461884,
-0.3064972460269928,
-0.407722532749176,
1.0352518558502197,
0.5606690645217896,
1.093823790550232,
-0.12360059469938278,
0.6325034499168396,
0.2000482678413391,
0.8417116403579712,
-0.5670313835144043,
0.3621121942996979,
-0.7400375008583069,
0.32264387607574463,
-0.05491209775209427,
-0.933465301990509,
-0.25049614906311035,
0.8296987414360046,
-0.7550324201583862,
0.24792248010635376,
0.5615642666816711,
0.7982633113861084,
0.18522697687149048,
-0.4940764904022217,
0.7381277680397034,
0.3781507909297943,
0.08096050471067429,
0.3750292658805847,
1.0048105716705322,
-0.00481924694031477,
0.28162363171577454,
0.015278935432434082,
0.04893560707569122,
-0.23305901885032654,
-0.8683774471282959,
-1.2381540536880493,
-0.28860628604888916,
-0.12260697036981583,
-0.3863462209701538,
-0.0635318011045456,
0.8197880387306213,
0.828744113445282,
-0.4037836492061615,
-0.5363243222236633,
-0.058625031262636185,
-0.17214910686016083,
0.004442727658897638,
-0.16669803857803345,
0.09344072639942169,
-0.3104788064956665,
-0.6081966161727905,
0.1687673032283783,
0.05001692473888397,
0.26972079277038574,
-0.5326560735702515,
-0.19118134677410126,
-0.3416126072406769,
0.5465671420097351,
0.9085152745246887,
0.09376475214958191,
-0.5197901725769043,
-0.2871707081794739,
-0.18063107132911682,
-0.045450590550899506,
-0.1781531423330307,
0.7588186264038086,
-0.6000666618347168,
-0.036372143775224686,
0.4174925684928894,
0.6634843945503235,
0.5389247536659241,
-0.342462956905365,
0.6018728017807007,
-0.8581831455230713,
0.2729979157447815,
-0.05444825440645218,
0.5067927241325378,
0.411578893661499,
-0.31311631202697754,
0.4657314121723175,
-0.0019326013280078769,
-0.36487048864364624,
-0.5985018610954285,
0.2529965341091156,
-0.8441809415817261,
-0.6726490259170532,
1.570924162864685,
-0.07156390696763992,
-0.2049446403980255,
-0.07890981435775757,
-0.05009356886148453,
0.13569293916225433,
-0.17111694812774658,
0.5813520550727844,
0.9329876899719238,
0.0506848469376564,
-0.28630295395851135,
-0.5868403911590576,
0.4998502731323242,
0.40067359805107117,
-0.6110261678695679,
-0.09131158143281937,
0.19496330618858337,
0.5450025796890259,
0.23025736212730408,
0.46504127979278564,
-0.017559003084897995,
0.07256873697042465,
-0.02973843924701214,
-0.13817715644836426,
0.014264576137065887,
-0.38510218262672424,
-0.24158266186714172,
0.1617283970117569,
0.41255617141723633,
0.06988909095525742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16495v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16495v2 | OTCE: Hybrid SSM and Attention with Cross Domain Mixture of Experts to construct Observer-Thinker-Conceiver-Expresser | 2024-06-24T10:05:23 | 2024-06-25T02:20:14 | Jingze Shi, Ting Xie, Bingheng Wu, Chunjun Zheng, Kai Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent research has shown that combining Mamba with Transformer architecture,
which has selective state space and quadratic self-attention mechanism,
outperforms using Mamba or Transformer architecture alone in language modeling
tasks. The quadratic self-attention mechanism effectively alleviates the
shortcomings of selective state space in handling long-term dependencies of any
element in the sequence. We propose a position information injection method
that connects the selective state space model with the quadratic attention, and
integrates these two architectures with hybrid experts with cross-sharing
domains, so that we can enjoy the advantages of both. We design a new
architecture with a more biomimetic idea: Observer-Thinker-Conceiver-Expresser
(OTCE), which can compete with well-known medium-scale open-source language
models on a small scale in language modeling tasks. | [
-0.5949522852897644,
-0.5424196720123291,
0.6656928658485413,
-0.08156377077102661,
-0.05454012751579285,
0.41631343960762024,
-0.11028358340263367,
-0.7279776930809021,
0.507328450679779,
0.2717137038707733,
-0.44455471634864807,
-0.21146617829799652,
-0.5729110836982727,
-0.03668377548456192,
-0.20894770324230194,
0.42610958218574524,
-0.10778774321079254,
-0.08524337410926819,
0.016626158729195595,
-0.23753376305103302,
-0.3375478982925415,
-0.4192570745944977,
-0.5028706192970276,
0.006072360556572676,
0.24733604490756989,
0.23741984367370605,
0.6217430830001831,
0.3877144753932953,
0.014563205651938915,
0.4066776633262634,
-0.06129547953605652,
0.24170494079589844,
-0.25663185119628906,
-0.15863586962223053,
-0.6180669069290161,
-0.6618423461914062,
-0.6713290214538574,
0.014941644854843616,
0.6641184687614441,
0.7029330730438232,
-0.08489136397838593,
0.2416965216398239,
0.060088127851486206,
0.3451290428638458,
-0.8029770255088806,
0.012177751399576664,
-0.4919469356536865,
0.12442422658205032,
-0.12619636952877045,
-0.09307707846164703,
-0.5280160307884216,
-0.1983279287815094,
0.13878236711025238,
-0.46627235412597656,
0.029053155332803726,
0.33955827355384827,
0.3108639121055603,
0.3111981451511383,
-0.3768904209136963,
0.3030245304107666,
-0.9287367463111877,
1.013433814048767,
-0.6220660209655762,
0.6550948023796082,
0.049589015543460846,
0.250837504863739,
-0.10841725021600723,
-0.3068866431713104,
-0.9172829985618591,
0.026392310857772827,
0.027915356680750847,
0.354573518037796,
-0.16107942163944244,
-0.010274356231093407,
-0.12471900135278702,
0.32008272409439087,
-0.4033155143260956,
-0.1025727391242981,
-0.38374051451683044,
0.013569504953920841,
0.5073239803314209,
0.2652575671672821,
0.4225012958049774,
0.10369349271059036,
-0.5418534874916077,
0.36460718512535095,
-0.5261880159378052,
-0.21998916566371918,
0.11794988811016083,
-0.052189864218235016,
-0.07406093180179596,
0.5563662648200989,
-0.11798232793807983,
0.670367956161499,
0.5255069136619568,
0.12742702662944794,
0.2529474198818207,
-0.41530054807662964,
-0.275359570980072,
-0.03813694417476654,
0.8810731768608093,
-0.004621507134288549,
-0.029931092634797096,
-0.33644095063209534,
0.0696212649345398,
0.2769257426261902,
0.46065521240234375,
-0.33912330865859985,
0.12319974601268768,
0.41728273034095764,
-0.6018761396408081,
-0.34482598304748535,
-0.05135617032647133,
-0.8709491491317749,
0.05545363202691078,
-0.22833362221717834,
0.4741617441177368,
-0.4980296194553375,
-0.5599411129951477,
0.2527693808078766,
0.21370969712734222,
0.16791974008083344,
-0.07523444294929504,
-1.0646976232528687,
0.6060511469841003,
0.6011942625045776,
0.6784602403640747,
-0.543138325214386,
-0.2971583604812622,
-0.33160898089408875,
0.4417565166950226,
-0.1375114768743515,
0.88816237449646,
-0.6446124315261841,
-0.3760600686073303,
-0.2018233835697174,
-0.21418671309947968,
-0.3731674551963806,
-0.3104988634586334,
0.1942467838525772,
-0.5479027032852173,
0.5553160905838013,
0.15158037841320038,
-0.5762690901756287,
-0.12747105956077576,
-0.09189659357070923,
-0.4235021471977234,
1.219118595123291,
0.3091777265071869,
-0.6056862473487854,
0.15464147925376892,
-0.9336414933204651,
-0.4710524380207062,
0.43370214104652405,
-0.358219712972641,
-0.11585003137588501,
0.07708217948675156,
0.039175815880298615,
0.2554766535758972,
-0.2194923460483551,
0.058071669191122055,
-0.33680206537246704,
-0.1127481460571289,
0.18006058037281036,
0.18596844375133514,
0.6135976314544678,
0.15521720051765442,
-0.46774205565452576,
0.14930114150047302,
-0.8442975878715515,
0.12925051152706146,
0.11346210539340973,
-0.15092778205871582,
-0.6294828057289124,
0.11352681368589401,
-0.008519593626260757,
0.48950961232185364,
0.2661866247653961,
-0.8888459205627441,
0.13266527652740479,
-0.6903316378593445,
0.5701833367347717,
0.31948503851890564,
0.08986010402441025,
0.9135470390319824,
0.04518371447920799,
0.6237685084342957,
0.2268162965774536,
0.3960625231266022,
0.1436484158039093,
-0.3623054623603821,
-0.7400950789451599,
-0.30666494369506836,
0.2019578367471695,
0.5252184867858887,
-0.7735674977302551,
0.7152709364891052,
-0.06668049097061157,
-0.3025076687335968,
-0.988170862197876,
0.07741254568099976,
0.4520767331123352,
0.3607543408870697,
0.3557451367378235,
-0.10044914484024048,
-0.3653159737586975,
-1.1532891988754272,
-0.1141907349228859,
0.08269085735082626,
0.03609384596347809,
0.053089745342731476,
0.2742217779159546,
-0.02114795707166195,
0.9657325148582458,
-0.4403362572193146,
-0.24692115187644958,
-0.6296805739402771,
-0.12322746217250824,
0.07708541303873062,
0.36598244309425354,
0.727476179599762,
-0.6132722496986389,
-0.4875745177268982,
0.016198912635445595,
-0.48037809133529663,
0.03536350280046463,
0.09282563626766205,
-0.31880104541778564,
0.17473849654197693,
0.3592994511127472,
-0.814998984336853,
0.25055772066116333,
0.5557613372802734,
-0.1416035294532776,
0.27043911814689636,
0.061457060277462006,
0.07138486206531525,
-1.4921289682388306,
0.17529253661632538,
0.07909543812274933,
-0.22667193412780762,
-0.7909014225006104,
0.32353562116622925,
0.29612600803375244,
-0.03395029157400131,
-0.7656828761100769,
0.6802582740783691,
-0.6829721331596375,
0.033377744257450104,
-0.5507129430770874,
0.353944331407547,
-0.10181431472301483,
0.7963075041770935,
0.1847514510154724,
0.6907642483711243,
0.5580093264579773,
-0.47332483530044556,
0.09822093695402145,
0.35165318846702576,
-0.307742178440094,
0.640636146068573,
-0.5692539811134338,
0.30069106817245483,
0.1261231005191803,
0.09138056635856628,
-0.8860582709312439,
0.08517882227897644,
0.43282219767570496,
-0.458232581615448,
0.3436013162136078,
0.10513017326593399,
-0.35480615496635437,
-0.5340076684951782,
-0.31232988834381104,
0.5571373105049133,
0.3856155574321747,
-0.3476078510284424,
1.1181762218475342,
0.5515884757041931,
-0.2853861153125763,
-0.379867821931839,
-0.6893221735954285,
-0.031136125326156616,
0.02708008512854576,
-0.6845040917396545,
0.36604824662208557,
-0.015986941754817963,
-0.06099497154355049,
0.17589911818504333,
-0.27255573868751526,
0.2798827290534973,
0.008265617303550243,
0.0695413276553154,
0.5822932124137878,
-0.4975263178348541,
0.002038541017100215,
0.30957475304603577,
-0.3614007532596588,
0.06600712984800339,
-0.6516479253768921,
0.4583911597728729,
0.017667992040514946,
-0.36971867084503174,
-0.5510258674621582,
0.8654339909553528,
0.6100513339042664,
-0.6859611868858337,
0.8770055770874023,
0.15430504083633423,
-0.3920619487762451,
-0.34033626317977905,
-0.7167481184005737,
-0.14450466632843018,
-0.4838930666446686,
0.3723888397216797,
-0.3944076597690582,
-0.8548339605331421,
0.34383144974708557,
-0.10047802329063416,
0.03348847106099129,
0.2875538766384125,
0.6670692563056946,
-0.1911899596452713,
1.230998158454895,
0.8142788410186768,
-0.3829752504825592,
0.5898464322090149,
-0.0836864486336708,
0.453672856092453,
-1.0540045499801636,
-0.1547713279724121,
-0.4167344570159912,
-0.4731954038143158,
-0.25108256936073303,
-0.2967672646045685,
0.41582754254341125,
-0.36474624276161194,
-0.025787778198719025,
0.45855745673179626,
-0.4325576424598694,
0.33672845363616943,
0.5601953864097595,
0.16915179789066315,
0.046089231967926025,
-0.3607940971851349,
-0.27801239490509033,
0.023350190371274948,
-0.7786049246788025,
-0.4504931569099426,
0.8120003342628479,
0.24052365124225616,
0.7443187236785889,
0.04350076615810394,
0.46194592118263245,
-0.077252097427845,
0.07362529635429382,
-0.7031130790710449,
0.6999722719192505,
-0.0009468162897974253,
-0.6365306377410889,
-0.07155214250087738,
-0.07713575661182404,
-0.608639121055603,
0.4611530601978302,
-0.14718061685562134,
-1.058181881904602,
0.7190389633178711,
0.3168278634548187,
-0.6461862325668335,
0.3882558047771454,
-0.7261763215065002,
0.7768438458442688,
-0.15809045732021332,
-0.35319021344184875,
-0.48690739274024963,
-0.8993769884109497,
0.309370756149292,
-0.17782558500766754,
0.1757282167673111,
0.19616329669952393,
-0.27659499645233154,
0.3849412202835083,
-0.42261171340942383,
0.9385026693344116,
-0.06520851701498032,
0.019369522109627724,
0.2713201642036438,
0.14408300817012787,
0.4742346405982971,
-0.23877723515033722,
-0.004958388861268759,
0.11691547185182571,
-0.2963313162326813,
-0.45496758818626404,
-0.5754859447479248,
0.5451234579086304,
-0.8652067184448242,
-0.7309575080871582,
-0.20891304314136505,
-0.35837438702583313,
-0.5797967910766602,
0.31652510166168213,
0.2187521755695343,
0.24032069742679596,
-0.16969452798366547,
0.013992068357765675,
0.7245768904685974,
0.09574518352746964,
0.35929274559020996,
0.753699779510498,
0.008987721987068653,
-0.4524676501750946,
0.6655153632164001,
-0.28385940194129944,
0.614281415939331,
0.7225496768951416,
0.01783117465674877,
0.049283288419246674,
-0.41697853803634644,
-0.3624584674835205,
0.39460358023643494,
-0.32708558440208435,
-0.13896095752716064,
-1.0865026712417603,
-0.3182632625102997,
-0.2891249656677246,
-0.1515149474143982,
-0.6174924969673157,
-0.4680749177932739,
0.021358570083975792,
-0.15770843625068665,
-0.04772390052676201,
0.5347071886062622,
0.19660405814647675,
0.4222566485404968,
-0.7292249202728271,
0.42736080288887024,
0.15992368757724762,
0.30431845784187317,
0.13323616981506348,
-0.34184160828590393,
-0.4418450891971588,
-0.0304676815867424,
-0.2215990126132965,
-0.9814503788948059,
0.2838975787162781,
0.020653048530220985,
0.942957878112793,
0.4253314137458801,
-0.23016630113124847,
0.21145540475845337,
-0.48220351338386536,
0.6883782148361206,
0.21350917220115662,
-1.1197940111160278,
0.5329965949058533,
-0.07261677831411362,
0.4615984559059143,
0.37532156705856323,
0.2578030526638031,
-0.48329827189445496,
-0.9672136306762695,
-0.3808135986328125,
-0.6152268648147583,
1.0311001539230347,
0.09494990855455399,
-0.1353372186422348,
-0.021226661279797554,
0.1387799084186554,
0.33720093965530396,
0.16543114185333252,
-0.4986999034881592,
-0.21123188734054565,
-0.14103713631629944,
-0.5610336065292358,
0.16724137961864471,
-0.18616648018360138,
0.07276260852813721,
-0.07235021889209747,
0.7601443529129028,
-0.1831580102443695,
0.4530983865261078,
0.09906289726495743,
-0.19277852773666382,
-0.4053206741809845,
0.31125181913375854,
0.5256277918815613,
0.34202805161476135,
0.12504728138446808,
0.18303970992565155,
0.2917287051677704,
-0.3325834572315216,
0.07693324238061905,
-0.04723229259252548,
-0.3616291582584381,
-0.22557681798934937,
0.07304012030363083,
0.7401988506317139,
0.6418928503990173,
-0.18908090889453888,
0.32811930775642395,
0.29049625992774963,
-0.15008868277072906,
0.020066482946276665,
0.24295468628406525,
0.42475467920303345,
0.3906140923500061,
0.30613425374031067,
0.451063334941864,
0.3145977854728699,
-0.44228917360305786,
-0.20036575198173523,
0.27031663060188293,
-0.16435205936431885,
-0.6281031966209412,
1.0418614149093628,
0.36197033524513245,
-0.3004804849624634,
0.060646384954452515,
0.22548019886016846,
-0.6158279180526733,
0.49229535460472107,
0.4983550012111664,
0.9564082026481628,
-0.8294951319694519,
0.06472082436084747,
0.07016501575708389,
0.17982687056064606,
0.17291581630706787,
0.6068952083587646,
-0.30729514360427856,
-0.7538847923278809,
-0.46275201439857483,
-0.2713654935359955,
-0.2728371024131775,
-0.12403015047311783,
-0.5966452360153198,
0.2742577791213989,
-0.20074014365673065,
-0.2831953167915344,
0.39809611439704895,
-0.3021831214427948,
-0.5998016595840454,
0.11903323978185654,
0.3114406168460846,
0.9914036393165588,
-0.7671614289283752,
1.0481451749801636,
0.9239006638526917,
-0.399310827255249,
-0.5542032718658447,
-0.11270270496606827,
-0.07988870143890381,
-0.7280633449554443,
0.43233010172843933,
-0.33040255308151245,
-0.5755122303962708,
-0.016545027494430542,
-0.3610295355319977,
-0.9832944869995117,
0.8097161650657654,
0.05832521617412567,
-0.7105765342712402,
-0.10086832195520401,
0.16500918567180634,
0.6458449959754944,
-0.44086942076683044,
0.18260326981544495,
0.3020121157169342,
0.2931966781616211,
-0.15739934146404266,
-0.7568203210830688,
0.07494015246629715,
-0.41235923767089844,
0.044005125761032104,
0.5625628232955933,
-1.143862009048462,
0.415573388338089,
-0.12483236938714981,
-0.30367663502693176,
0.050533730536699295,
0.9218533039093018,
-0.0206708163022995,
-0.0430234894156456,
0.6650780439376831,
0.2588925063610077,
0.1763247698545456,
0.3187280595302582,
0.8824788331985474,
-0.5661733150482178,
0.16819030046463013,
1.1622360944747925,
-0.5611042380332947,
0.9714478254318237,
0.6293884515762329,
-0.3179374039173126,
0.38629457354545593,
0.29255926609039307,
0.1768379658460617,
0.7673133611679077,
-0.4202738106250763,
-0.3317278027534485,
-0.3751086890697479,
0.21375717222690582,
-0.3141338527202606,
0.23033523559570312,
0.48246872425079346,
-0.28757551312446594,
0.09262236207723618,
0.23813843727111816,
-0.2709261476993561,
0.05739957094192505,
-0.0752822756767273,
0.7937907576560974,
0.3906935453414917,
-0.6600385308265686,
0.050773534923791885,
0.04778548330068588,
0.5934610366821289,
-0.6071813702583313,
0.22337113320827484,
-0.26437535881996155,
0.2971622049808502,
-0.07372794300317764,
-0.7499619126319885,
0.2096025049686432,
-0.35298922657966614,
-0.31887757778167725,
-0.15000684559345245,
0.8082648515701294,
-0.6781399846076965,
-0.3350833058357239,
0.6054918766021729,
0.5192558169364929,
-0.18600493669509888,
0.12839949131011963,
-0.46559280157089233,
-0.14438307285308838,
-0.1796233355998993,
-0.22135387361049652,
0.1879313439130783,
0.24221420288085938,
-0.11652126163244247,
0.5993191003799438,
0.2851945161819458,
0.0788092315196991,
0.296210378408432,
0.02206246368587017,
0.8122081160545349,
-0.6300145983695984,
-0.8543207049369812,
-0.6993963122367859,
0.30016881227493286,
-0.12877334654331207,
-0.0870867520570755,
0.6070650219917297,
0.5918064713478088,
0.6128363013267517,
-0.28212079405784607,
1.0463745594024658,
0.01717686839401722,
0.7649715542793274,
-0.1443789154291153,
0.6407021284103394,
-0.4848092496395111,
-0.20636090636253357,
-0.12320262938737869,
-0.9549964666366577,
0.05867772176861763,
0.23861995339393616,
-0.3652869462966919,
0.15665407478809357,
0.9151948094367981,
0.48294538259506226,
-0.4196118414402008,
0.2993824779987335,
0.3575410544872284,
0.4098806083202362,
-0.06143861636519432,
0.8626078367233276,
0.8166947960853577,
-0.25336021184921265,
0.42086777091026306,
-0.189362034201622,
-0.3705187141895294,
-0.462358295917511,
-0.4336278438568115,
-0.8701265454292297,
-0.5031999945640564,
-0.4383834898471832,
0.1380760818719864,
0.03385213762521744,
1.0428279638290405,
0.8484699726104736,
-1.044108510017395,
0.05572305619716644,
0.26185715198516846,
-0.22811472415924072,
-0.38151979446411133,
-0.20995445549488068,
0.2815295457839966,
-0.08314546197652817,
-0.9036039710044861,
0.5714412331581116,
0.7904976010322571,
-0.11995209753513336,
-0.573661744594574,
0.1759965419769287,
-0.20181433856487274,
0.3047432005405426,
0.6173654794692993,
0.3348613679409027,
-0.8813261389732361,
-0.2717534601688385,
0.3239326477050781,
-0.36478573083877563,
0.1660396307706833,
0.739249050617218,
-0.7213432192802429,
0.45084598660469055,
0.4688461422920227,
0.6569656729698181,
0.4351092278957367,
-0.12904755771160126,
0.9154460430145264,
-0.43000897765159607,
0.1262119859457016,
0.15012124180793762,
0.608616292476654,
-0.05538303405046463,
-0.5195870399475098,
0.3205682337284088,
0.08854388445615768,
-0.3031655550003052,
-0.3177514970302582,
0.08970949798822403,
-1.2779436111450195,
-0.13757175207138062,
0.8959705233573914,
0.05152249336242676,
-0.5714409947395325,
-0.23783104121685028,
-0.40372177958488464,
0.14047545194625854,
-0.47777292132377625,
0.7854402661323547,
0.578041672706604,
0.024470418691635132,
-0.27077868580818176,
-0.448979914188385,
-0.10715001076459885,
0.6345378756523132,
-0.9275161027908325,
-0.31753262877464294,
0.09978470206260681,
0.46496886014938354,
0.3105926215648651,
0.34867188334465027,
-0.20226360857486725,
0.3938254117965698,
-0.06773065775632858,
0.5813668370246887,
-0.007814401760697365,
-0.08314591646194458,
0.04730753228068352,
0.13687701523303986,
-0.327865332365036,
-0.6817671656608582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16490v1 | eagerlearners at SemEval2024 Task 5: The Legal Argument Reasoning Task in Civil Procedure | 2024-06-24T09:57:44 | 2024-06-24T09:57:44 | Hoorieh Sabzevari, Mohammadmostafa Rostamkhani, Sauleh Eetemadi | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study investigates the performance of the zero-shot method in
classifying data using three large language models, alongside two models with
large input token sizes and the two pre-trained models on legal data. Our main
dataset comes from the domain of U.S. civil procedure. It includes summaries of
legal cases, specific questions, potential answers, and detailed explanations
for why each solution is relevant, all sourced from a book aimed at law
students. By comparing different methods, we aimed to understand how
effectively they handle the complexities found in legal datasets. Our findings
show how well the zero-shot method of large language models can understand
complicated data. We achieved our highest F1 score of 64% in these experiments. | [
0.04702840745449066,
-0.7603877186775208,
0.9268305897712708,
0.03714347630739212,
-0.43030789494514465,
-0.3985079228878021,
-0.04724973812699318,
-0.27648746967315674,
-0.3094841241836548,
0.3647351861000061,
-0.12550565600395203,
-0.73638916015625,
-0.5890858173370361,
-0.042018383741378784,
-0.591501772403717,
0.8803961277008057,
-0.022134752944111824,
0.5123564600944519,
-0.30735108256340027,
-0.28823021054267883,
-0.43679970502853394,
-0.42775484919548035,
-0.4615626037120819,
-0.09997927397489548,
0.6000431776046753,
0.6303882598876953,
0.2816859483718872,
0.8920426964759827,
0.4934605360031128,
0.2568758428096771,
-0.011543584987521172,
-0.5745894312858582,
-0.43142077326774597,
0.6255479454994202,
-0.41427791118621826,
-0.8291850090026855,
-0.09079153835773468,
0.12842848896980286,
0.21182571351528168,
0.6104418635368347,
-0.2842097878456116,
0.25752657651901245,
-0.3581129312515259,
0.25892460346221924,
-0.8904186487197876,
0.13258478045463562,
-0.6606027483940125,
0.32764095067977905,
-0.5388533473014832,
-0.21606764197349548,
-0.5711641907691956,
-0.13368597626686096,
0.03306170925498009,
-0.40307459235191345,
0.39271777868270874,
-0.11043309420347214,
0.8169572949409485,
0.31738895177841187,
-0.5778735280036926,
-0.22448891401290894,
-0.7072544693946838,
0.7635579705238342,
-0.8524934649467468,
0.20613715052604675,
0.16856540739536285,
0.41077256202697754,
0.011374063789844513,
-0.782943844795227,
-0.6155158281326294,
0.01777084544301033,
0.3800257444381714,
0.3498964309692383,
-0.10272622853517532,
0.14043642580509186,
0.6101217865943909,
0.08884288370609283,
-0.8764260411262512,
0.37659549713134766,
-0.7438058853149414,
-0.1531750112771988,
0.9560046195983887,
0.24606561660766602,
-0.026467107236385345,
-0.14933954179286957,
0.11452251672744751,
0.10399805009365082,
-0.6759849786758423,
-0.03443966060876846,
0.38706475496292114,
0.4119493365287781,
0.08803194016218185,
0.6886414289474487,
-0.4613420069217682,
0.8170854449272156,
-0.0844971314072609,
0.16841915249824524,
0.22824536263942719,
0.14119641482830048,
-0.5081606507301331,
0.2006150186061859,
0.5991235971450806,
-0.010894556529819965,
0.27437716722488403,
-0.03704480081796646,
-0.0773467868566513,
0.005415989551693201,
0.12747366726398468,
-0.7930998802185059,
0.1262792944908142,
0.5680474638938904,
-0.5678248405456543,
-0.23638947308063507,
0.015084119513630867,
-0.7235459089279175,
-0.6206293702125549,
-0.49723923206329346,
0.48196882009506226,
-0.15654347836971283,
0.12010181695222855,
0.42347434163093567,
0.0063439649529755116,
0.5182604193687439,
0.7743579745292664,
-0.4112149775028229,
0.16789747774600983,
0.7510066032409668,
0.43530866503715515,
-0.01840907149016857,
-0.09012484550476074,
-0.9891742467880249,
0.10511691123247147,
-0.3925430178642273,
1.0838863849639893,
-0.7386950850486755,
0.0232830923050642,
0.10654956847429276,
0.1415187120437622,
-0.1515331119298935,
-0.5490351319313049,
1.1645774841308594,
-0.5517504811286926,
0.3526979386806488,
-0.22087238729000092,
-0.8638591170310974,
-0.42970243096351624,
0.26667770743370056,
-0.3424513339996338,
0.4829060137271881,
-0.057751093059778214,
-0.4639986753463745,
0.6913963556289673,
-0.8293523192405701,
-0.6646053791046143,
0.4883561432361603,
-0.5036473274230957,
-0.39844298362731934,
0.1983364075422287,
0.002376137999817729,
1.0057764053344727,
-0.28682756423950195,
0.24566255509853363,
-0.5445699095726013,
-0.39696013927459717,
-0.07738030701875687,
-0.1463809311389923,
0.9708998799324036,
0.5674375295639038,
-0.6499872803688049,
0.03357105702161789,
-0.5183043479919434,
-0.1693233996629715,
0.5367825627326965,
-0.23034103214740753,
-0.15647517144680023,
0.05066874995827675,
-0.3915146291255951,
0.4622538983821869,
0.014750374481081963,
-0.7173342704772949,
0.09645116329193115,
-0.3011074662208557,
0.2352779656648636,
0.6020417213439941,
0.12918230891227722,
0.1598576307296753,
0.11507278680801392,
0.8308671116828918,
0.30952689051628113,
-0.02600264921784401,
-0.2736578583717346,
-0.46477749943733215,
-0.9915494918823242,
0.3051796555519104,
0.5649669170379639,
0.7152701616287231,
-0.4976615011692047,
-0.16901734471321106,
-0.062310948967933655,
-0.4564240276813507,
-0.42220181226730347,
-0.17403282225131989,
0.029854044318199158,
0.3507760763168335,
0.33555859327316284,
0.10579060763120651,
-0.388244092464447,
-0.9055917263031006,
-0.27164098620414734,
-0.24091772735118866,
0.1899379938840866,
0.4358237385749817,
0.6935125589370728,
0.13676221668720245,
0.5607249736785889,
-0.4851342737674713,
-0.13576799631118774,
-0.1586473286151886,
0.547458291053772,
0.42843884229660034,
0.3863168954849243,
0.590891420841217,
-0.5603592991828918,
-0.48320966958999634,
0.10764221847057343,
-1.0778447389602661,
-0.17254890501499176,
-0.27561306953430176,
-0.06544876098632812,
0.24194686114788055,
0.6105061173439026,
-0.4511934518814087,
0.5871444940567017,
-0.18488112092018127,
-0.5980382561683655,
0.4147835373878479,
0.1717228889465332,
0.2431815266609192,
-0.8354637622833252,
-0.1678682267665863,
0.21790096163749695,
-0.24573911726474762,
-0.7734494209289551,
0.2969757616519928,
-0.05825056880712509,
-0.2928169071674347,
-0.8427241444587708,
0.3290621042251587,
-0.49880918860435486,
0.040907539427280426,
-0.1311323493719101,
-0.054610587656497955,
-0.17226411402225494,
0.25810137391090393,
0.06623226404190063,
0.3698413372039795,
0.7783409357070923,
-0.3397025465965271,
0.5408459901809692,
-0.11006942391395569,
-0.13782328367233276,
0.7770490050315857,
-0.6365981101989746,
0.24132883548736572,
-0.5214709639549255,
-0.1046561747789383,
-0.8915995955467224,
-0.4790431261062622,
0.08623825758695602,
-0.4097648561000824,
0.4070184528827667,
-0.4503062069416046,
-0.4877396523952484,
-0.3928879201412201,
-0.07112986594438553,
0.2752554416656494,
0.2566721439361572,
-0.06564775109291077,
0.5418424010276794,
0.40252524614334106,
-0.3743923008441925,
-0.6231127381324768,
-0.5656730532646179,
0.026096602901816368,
-0.630622148513794,
-0.40148258209228516,
0.0520734041929245,
0.1642611026763916,
-0.35368862748146057,
0.09069516509771347,
0.17260198295116425,
-0.2849496304988861,
-0.03469081595540047,
0.2970728576183319,
0.12389420717954636,
-0.39802640676498413,
0.23887322843074799,
0.04465959593653679,
0.10870686918497086,
0.3447173833847046,
0.1833665519952774,
0.49515292048454285,
-0.002572838682681322,
-0.6125571131706238,
-0.47117093205451965,
0.5626677870750427,
0.7082385420799255,
-0.08633538335561752,
0.580547034740448,
0.14666135609149933,
-0.4867038130760193,
-0.16664080321788788,
-0.745717465877533,
0.11238117516040802,
-0.36865565180778503,
0.2869328558444977,
-0.4842180609703064,
-0.9712976813316345,
0.5373397469520569,
0.13396641612052917,
0.4848203659057617,
0.640766441822052,
0.7171192169189453,
-0.06297466903924942,
1.0822551250457764,
0.11706067621707916,
-0.07473307847976685,
0.062435004860162735,
-0.12167173624038696,
0.32775434851646423,
-0.3198901414871216,
-0.31802716851234436,
-0.9165633320808411,
-0.1510225385427475,
-0.1952037513256073,
-0.6172183752059937,
0.03447660431265831,
0.13957107067108154,
-0.4905970096588135,
0.23426468670368195,
-0.425603449344635,
0.47758883237838745,
0.36346903443336487,
-0.2748841345310211,
0.022292301058769226,
-0.014607064425945282,
-0.14580433070659637,
0.02834482677280903,
-0.6836517453193665,
-0.39887112379074097,
1.2705506086349487,
0.5143471956253052,
0.628700315952301,
0.2196698635816574,
0.8827545046806335,
0.1465528905391693,
0.16867172718048096,
-1.1505740880966187,
0.7134069204330444,
-0.2366381287574768,
-0.7031187415122986,
-0.41119474172592163,
-0.326883465051651,
-1.3199177980422974,
0.35290631651878357,
-0.1409577578306198,
-0.6202520132064819,
0.34045013785362244,
-0.20913735032081604,
-0.7736515998840332,
-0.16792528331279755,
-0.6135033369064331,
0.9277017712593079,
-0.1561332643032074,
-0.7573373913764954,
-0.12183612585067749,
-0.5403499603271484,
0.4172481298446655,
-0.003161471104249358,
0.19128316640853882,
-0.30315643548965454,
0.2136746346950531,
0.9894202947616577,
-0.4003245234489441,
0.31050941348075867,
-0.5791523456573486,
-0.00890152994543314,
0.5706666707992554,
0.06849692761898041,
0.39110448956489563,
-0.010989117436110973,
-0.26450034976005554,
-0.1309346854686737,
0.19893397390842438,
-0.3889552056789398,
-0.7243043184280396,
0.4954913854598999,
-0.5231806635856628,
-0.8030954003334045,
-0.6671422719955444,
-0.4665180444717407,
-0.08659274131059647,
0.16264797747135162,
0.07451195269823074,
0.28166672587394714,
0.1606973558664322,
0.5833053588867188,
0.4657122492790222,
-0.0774226188659668,
0.39395469427108765,
0.9987747073173523,
0.22573399543762207,
0.14849311113357544,
0.8609234094619751,
0.6170623898506165,
-0.256244421005249,
-0.020345773547887802,
0.06668650358915329,
-0.5010321140289307,
-0.8397498726844788,
-0.45627880096435547,
0.2931249737739563,
-0.8905226588249207,
-0.2998075783252716,
-0.857158362865448,
-0.366501122713089,
-0.6672414541244507,
-0.03807853162288666,
-0.16061344742774963,
-0.462671160697937,
-0.3253493010997772,
-0.08532872796058655,
-0.05225910246372223,
0.6060377955436707,
0.20116326212882996,
-0.16076421737670898,
-0.7748770117759705,
-0.06740754842758179,
0.34987708926200867,
0.11112206429243088,
-0.2514626383781433,
-0.8723792433738708,
-0.003585133934393525,
-0.3726562261581421,
-0.24786251783370972,
-1.1622051000595093,
0.08390279114246368,
-0.07289404422044754,
0.9641017317771912,
0.8009835481643677,
0.150839701294899,
0.6868583559989929,
-0.4912508726119995,
0.783528745174408,
-0.19489741325378418,
-0.8236411809921265,
0.9757159352302551,
-0.539260745048523,
0.18001876771450043,
0.7851549983024597,
0.5788933634757996,
-0.16528145968914032,
-0.22509953379631042,
-0.6811450719833374,
-0.7141544818878174,
0.7163029313087463,
0.28800368309020996,
0.07673252373933792,
0.05808252468705177,
0.5341261625289917,
-0.13252928853034973,
0.004178269300609827,
-0.8136671781539917,
0.17674340307712555,
0.1502426117658615,
-0.34281986951828003,
0.33165621757507324,
-0.21754316985607147,
-0.12929530441761017,
-0.4084416925907135,
0.514646589756012,
-0.22506451606750488,
0.19868779182434082,
-0.010749117471277714,
-0.07549744099378586,
-0.08294514566659927,
0.5947173833847046,
0.8119497895240784,
0.7017309069633484,
0.06923910230398178,
0.13540974259376526,
0.2584271728992462,
-0.27643662691116333,
0.41562581062316895,
0.351279616355896,
0.012911206111311913,
-0.07813969254493713,
0.5721569061279297,
0.6935580372810364,
-0.22668413817882538,
-0.7541850209236145,
0.8229607343673706,
-0.2306475043296814,
-0.6491187810897827,
-0.344279021024704,
0.13465918600559235,
-0.0944732204079628,
0.37702518701553345,
0.2858150601387024,
-0.2839817404747009,
0.553396463394165,
-0.6362608075141907,
0.18268601596355438,
0.14479544758796692,
-0.4942450225353241,
-0.1489090621471405,
0.7308368682861328,
0.0853278860449791,
0.07602529972791672,
0.5055990219116211,
-0.3038599193096161,
-0.2866356372833252,
0.733335554599762,
0.453864187002182,
0.6735849976539612,
-0.41060054302215576,
0.27302879095077515,
0.4648713171482086,
-0.07569688558578491,
-0.13383184373378754,
0.5531859993934631,
-0.05350462347269058,
-0.7168682217597961,
-0.627392053604126,
-0.5970063805580139,
-0.13899852335453033,
0.4676157236099243,
-0.7709700465202332,
0.3592405915260315,
-0.2636152505874634,
0.10645268112421036,
0.246486634016037,
-0.07981376349925995,
-0.7005324363708496,
0.317208856344223,
0.11681339889764786,
0.8220849633216858,
-1.1530325412750244,
0.49063074588775635,
0.9534575343132019,
-0.32590407133102417,
-0.9032532572746277,
-0.027032537385821342,
0.351972758769989,
-0.5418021082878113,
0.8065712451934814,
0.17008377611637115,
0.13516460359096527,
-0.12316516786813736,
-0.7897121906280518,
-0.5514377355575562,
0.9191282987594604,
0.4810294210910797,
-0.6749622225761414,
0.24523627758026123,
0.06060653179883957,
0.42767947912216187,
-0.272215873003006,
0.08029597997665405,
0.5740991234779358,
0.2574822008609772,
0.5210521817207336,
-0.4383411109447479,
-0.09535529464483261,
-0.49860885739326477,
-0.34802550077438354,
-0.05517919734120369,
-0.3867778480052948,
0.8550421595573425,
-0.21246476471424103,
-0.26339536905288696,
-0.31114912033081055,
0.7016178965568542,
0.5519298315048218,
0.4930482804775238,
0.6536825895309448,
0.8995888233184814,
0.5742647051811218,
-0.2652270793914795,
0.8017148375511169,
-0.07383304089307785,
0.4983289837837219,
1.1977077722549438,
-0.9342124462127686,
0.8983676433563232,
0.30928927659988403,
-0.14211507141590118,
0.4430217146873474,
0.8641760349273682,
-0.2029896080493927,
0.3054107427597046,
0.35440772771835327,
-0.36136701703071594,
-0.5353073477745056,
-0.28411969542503357,
-0.23996402323246002,
0.8980051279067993,
0.34274476766586304,
-0.32763585448265076,
-0.3573281764984131,
-0.09150254726409912,
0.111029714345932,
-0.11662984639406204,
-0.3527851700782776,
0.8116985559463501,
-0.09403160959482193,
-0.8366129398345947,
0.03826484829187393,
0.1356307715177536,
0.05980958789587021,
-0.06939162313938141,
-0.3295034170150757,
-0.1384369134902954,
0.20520338416099548,
-0.2919226586818695,
-1.113734245300293,
0.2647993266582489,
0.31343981623649597,
0.13548687100410461,
0.05425594002008438,
0.835811197757721,
-0.1432744711637497,
-0.48825860023498535,
0.04997246712446213,
0.5504287481307983,
0.6034829616546631,
-0.004113817121833563,
-0.8142964243888855,
-0.06371486932039261,
-0.18522909283638,
-0.2919905185699463,
0.08841243386268616,
0.7987816333770752,
-0.32587382197380066,
0.3502196669578552,
0.4265260100364685,
0.09544161707162857,
0.04713881015777588,
0.5113706588745117,
0.8154875040054321,
-0.6086546182632446,
-0.4050672650337219,
-0.8444687724113464,
0.7436016798019409,
-0.4151468575000763,
-0.22711744904518127,
0.6731360554695129,
0.869307816028595,
0.626862108707428,
0.045072369277477264,
0.5659016966819763,
-0.09256498515605927,
0.7408811450004578,
-0.4989837110042572,
0.4236432611942291,
-0.490444540977478,
-0.015873689204454422,
-0.3617069721221924,
-0.8242606520652771,
-0.5773875713348389,
0.9356618523597717,
-0.5009599328041077,
0.1760525107383728,
0.639225959777832,
0.61468505859375,
-0.11768727004528046,
0.06770570576190948,
0.518019437789917,
0.08630526810884476,
0.3209301233291626,
0.6647503972053528,
0.9298083186149597,
-0.3499131202697754,
0.347113698720932,
0.011026715859770775,
-0.12485157698392868,
-0.25982481241226196,
-0.6324605345726013,
-0.8268221020698547,
-0.30571484565734863,
-0.43680325150489807,
-0.2813831865787506,
0.052025239914655685,
0.7310578227043152,
0.9063706994056702,
-1.062957525253296,
-0.1729673594236374,
-0.1673271656036377,
-0.33770042657852173,
0.2730129063129425,
-0.3484939932823181,
0.18143147230148315,
-0.48950594663619995,
-0.6570682525634766,
0.4183335602283478,
0.441687673330307,
0.0021188624668866396,
-0.09458086639642715,
0.02666006051003933,
-0.4254668653011322,
0.2225479781627655,
0.7056207656860352,
0.24545326828956604,
-0.6590558886528015,
-0.3181738555431366,
-0.10123070329427719,
0.028152553364634514,
-0.08029672503471375,
0.9139682650566101,
-0.4380711615085602,
0.6183685064315796,
0.7337541580200195,
0.7743716239929199,
0.6722237467765808,
0.19061124324798584,
0.5685809850692749,
-0.3937177360057831,
0.27411189675331116,
0.59307861328125,
0.6642209887504578,
-0.026900796219706535,
-0.3986962139606476,
0.8824601173400879,
0.2209949940443039,
-0.7826852202415466,
-0.8862757086753845,
-0.05280274897813797,
-0.8555895686149597,
-0.4346873164176941,
0.9901196360588074,
-0.5650677680969238,
-0.16386863589286804,
-0.43302422761917114,
0.07428789883852005,
0.1487049162387848,
-0.23723088204860687,
0.6175196766853333,
0.8707684874534607,
-0.31465989351272583,
-0.6417914032936096,
-1.0409806966781616,
0.0626123696565628,
0.5468723773956299,
-1.115247130393982,
-0.2961966395378113,
0.7377002835273743,
0.30520665645599365,
0.2195671945810318,
0.600144624710083,
-0.33135053515434265,
0.46679574251174927,
-0.22253556549549103,
-0.17956778407096863,
0.06137493997812271,
-0.46863868832588196,
-0.6451660394668579,
0.6144483089447021,
-0.05456960201263428,
-0.07930004596710205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16489v1 | Deepfake tweets automatic detection | 2024-06-24T09:55:31 | 2024-06-24T09:55:31 | Adam Frej, Adrian Kaminski, Piotr Marciniak, Szymon Szmajdzinski, Soveatin Kuntur, Anna Wroblewska | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study addresses the critical challenge of detecting DeepFake tweets by
leveraging advanced natural language processing (NLP) techniques to distinguish
between genuine and AI-generated texts. Given the increasing prevalence of
misinformation, our research utilizes the TweepFake dataset to train and
evaluate various machine learning models. The objective is to identify
effective strategies for recognizing DeepFake content, thereby enhancing the
integrity of digital communications. By developing reliable methods for
detecting AI-generated misinformation, this work contributes to a more
trustworthy online information environment. | [
-0.4262025058269501,
-0.9249044060707092,
0.34926241636276245,
0.27316659688949585,
-0.12866415083408356,
0.5979170203208923,
0.21831226348876953,
-0.8396894931793213,
0.06890372186899185,
0.5427359938621521,
-0.8623420000076294,
-0.3434500992298126,
-0.760883629322052,
0.25409916043281555,
-0.658001184463501,
0.6533998847007751,
-0.005050930194556713,
-0.3378118574619293,
0.5104267597198486,
0.17844723165035248,
-0.3345969319343567,
-0.004941049963235855,
-1.0474650859832764,
-0.5001370906829834,
0.03272082656621933,
0.5101150274276733,
0.8692913055419922,
0.255706250667572,
0.5645870566368103,
0.24741274118423462,
0.21948038041591644,
0.34387239813804626,
-0.3335084617137909,
0.15594488382339478,
-0.04685024917125702,
0.034586649388074875,
-0.09145155549049377,
0.2976028025150299,
0.5737789273262024,
0.09909484535455704,
0.0635346844792366,
-0.004303332418203354,
-0.1535658985376358,
0.5829537510871887,
-0.5552054643630981,
-0.20308350026607513,
-0.7851772904396057,
0.4306331276893616,
-0.21772825717926025,
-0.3145219683647156,
-0.32770615816116333,
-0.5141075253486633,
-0.05219091475009918,
-0.3046457767486572,
0.37500545382499695,
-0.09672395884990692,
1.0105218887329102,
0.39898446202278137,
-0.311789870262146,
-0.5155295729637146,
-0.574176013469696,
0.5539682507514954,
-1.0194783210754395,
0.3585538864135742,
0.6333276033401489,
0.3506583273410797,
-0.19552193582057953,
-0.5178368091583252,
-0.6710895895957947,
-0.19868625700473785,
-0.10952255874872208,
-0.12843945622444153,
-0.25414153933525085,
0.021916260942816734,
0.14939026534557343,
0.5282567739486694,
-0.6523053050041199,
0.2671623229980469,
0.1342466026544571,
-0.46759143471717834,
0.8273004293441772,
-0.11384665220975876,
0.6245137453079224,
-0.15021002292633057,
-0.15526799857616425,
0.1411457657814026,
-0.3111666440963745,
-0.33089035749435425,
0.40468016266822815,
-0.07505114376544952,
-0.1505429595708847,
0.5152454972267151,
-0.24575653672218323,
0.38080665469169617,
0.35250604152679443,
0.062123384326696396,
0.2529985308647156,
-0.15660709142684937,
-0.5755232572555542,
0.035717349499464035,
0.8917776346206665,
0.253585547208786,
0.862655758857727,
-0.3372902572154999,
-0.49397096037864685,
-0.1628848910331726,
0.10840839147567749,
-0.7254387736320496,
-0.21155455708503723,
0.2674371898174286,
-0.5206306576728821,
-0.7176210880279541,
0.22490842640399933,
-0.529297947883606,
-0.7370055317878723,
-0.3121802508831024,
0.273537278175354,
-0.5557937026023865,
-0.6201339960098267,
0.004898271057754755,
-0.33645394444465637,
0.12608736753463745,
0.47976136207580566,
-0.6078950762748718,
0.029056571424007416,
0.7822856903076172,
0.7910136580467224,
-0.10353673249483109,
-0.13889198005199432,
-0.5453934669494629,
0.2043481320142746,
-0.7206073999404907,
0.9665557146072388,
-0.5359617471694946,
-0.1291651576757431,
0.2325708568096161,
0.04717960208654404,
0.03072603978216648,
-0.5209891200065613,
0.473876416683197,
-0.6405446529388428,
0.10365074127912521,
-0.28377023339271545,
-0.9203568696975708,
-0.11949793249368668,
0.2475624680519104,
-0.8861175179481506,
0.8790935277938843,
0.00645079743117094,
-0.8121350407600403,
0.778242290019989,
-0.9151514768600464,
-0.8142818808555603,
0.30728015303611755,
-0.012878265231847763,
-0.35894864797592163,
0.19511571526527405,
0.3407571017742157,
0.8449941873550415,
0.05520198121666908,
0.2555420994758606,
-0.20386731624603271,
-0.30747973918914795,
0.31778618693351746,
-0.730777382850647,
1.0019725561141968,
0.3026348352432251,
-0.7576279640197754,
-0.10946138948202133,
-0.3806043565273285,
-0.11681307852268219,
0.2445976585149765,
-0.2524062395095825,
-0.08768327534198761,
-0.29043564200401306,
0.2156948745250702,
0.060380060225725174,
0.001034651999361813,
-0.5379566550254822,
0.183084636926651,
-0.4770973324775696,
0.26620036363601685,
0.6291175484657288,
0.29574599862098694,
0.3297753930091858,
-0.09736938029527664,
0.2517291009426117,
-0.0031756144016981125,
0.2011324167251587,
0.049846094101667404,
-0.5026217699050903,
-0.5682117938995361,
0.19471342861652374,
0.11240085959434509,
0.6789580583572388,
-0.9176070690155029,
0.5243762731552124,
0.20785023272037506,
-0.2664436995983124,
-0.6902109384536743,
0.2553172707557678,
0.008653651922941208,
0.36025291681289673,
0.3389255404472351,
0.08144830912351608,
-0.4401877224445343,
-0.9464386701583862,
-0.46032509207725525,
0.026347793638706207,
0.1382327377796173,
-0.12440917640924454,
0.6570054292678833,
-0.5512896180152893,
0.6678900718688965,
-0.1780262142419815,
-0.3173695504665375,
0.07120109349489212,
0.7829747200012207,
-0.20174267888069153,
0.4698513448238373,
0.8847602009773254,
-1.0111018419265747,
-0.9224013686180115,
-0.2657458484172821,
-0.8328888416290283,
-0.15506263077259064,
-0.3454740643501282,
0.06101125106215477,
0.4767066240310669,
0.6769497990608215,
-0.7019224762916565,
0.6948227882385254,
0.4142801761627197,
-0.6061702966690063,
0.26121845841407776,
0.37852609157562256,
0.7904961109161377,
-0.8902223110198975,
-0.024079034104943275,
-0.07293493300676346,
-0.36700066924095154,
-0.7043336033821106,
-0.1354486346244812,
-0.14128823578357697,
0.21438564360141754,
-0.2828761041164398,
0.6001060605049133,
-0.21334023773670197,
0.04918711259961128,
-0.5423292517662048,
-0.3019227385520935,
-0.12585404515266418,
-0.09276412427425385,
-0.015568366274237633,
0.7605912089347839,
0.26377853751182556,
-0.27209264039993286,
0.3326924443244934,
0.043114449828863144,
-0.3188667893409729,
0.28213703632354736,
-0.408614844083786,
0.2923453748226166,
0.11392387747764587,
0.19910287857055664,
-1.249583125114441,
-0.6289401650428772,
0.6740072965621948,
-1.054189920425415,
0.43428027629852295,
-0.1211053803563118,
-1.0722600221633911,
-0.24099025130271912,
-0.20623894035816193,
0.017491362988948822,
0.26009401679039,
-0.42810919880867004,
0.45502063632011414,
0.4095018804073334,
0.19290654361248016,
-0.6770046353340149,
-0.9060889482498169,
0.4853939116001129,
0.17624014616012573,
-0.6027729511260986,
0.2265850454568863,
0.08357331901788712,
-0.23087522387504578,
0.13000637292861938,
-0.11373430490493774,
-0.4280970096588135,
0.5259287357330322,
0.14199736714363098,
-0.17108456790447235,
-0.242667555809021,
0.13882343471050262,
0.30082789063453674,
-0.19755156338214874,
0.06092603877186775,
0.05446534603834152,
0.7605116963386536,
-0.17200711369514465,
-0.2050042599439621,
-1.054799199104309,
0.6023390889167786,
0.5206922292709351,
-0.10212424397468567,
0.8665227293968201,
1.4254320859909058,
-0.8240575194358826,
-0.3113369345664978,
-0.856440007686615,
-0.36727064847946167,
-0.5257774591445923,
-0.16458508372306824,
0.05053092911839485,
-0.9091570973396301,
0.13794928789138794,
0.10008762776851654,
0.1908128559589386,
0.8630384206771851,
0.36004000902175903,
-0.3327620029449463,
0.9451745748519897,
0.6408531069755554,
-0.37953293323516846,
0.3151499629020691,
-0.21631260216236115,
0.18035021424293518,
0.0278212558478117,
-0.06338340044021606,
-0.41744568943977356,
-0.1863480657339096,
-0.4697951078414917,
-0.1253725290298462,
-0.5050990581512451,
-0.06216435134410858,
-0.4073143005371094,
0.2098923623561859,
-0.6692715287208557,
0.5349651575088501,
0.5401406288146973,
-0.053858984261751175,
0.1784188598394394,
0.15667761862277985,
0.07514924556016922,
-0.07821302115917206,
-0.20996558666229248,
-0.5225647687911987,
0.8348446488380432,
0.5579531788825989,
0.45528870820999146,
0.14062848687171936,
0.7612332105636597,
1.1802639961242676,
0.49556803703308105,
-0.60221266746521,
0.3012765049934387,
-0.22560328245162964,
-0.8858107924461365,
-0.3104681372642517,
-0.17038792371749878,
-0.7090964317321777,
-0.6104037165641785,
-0.5086801648139954,
-0.5488244295120239,
-0.14612238109111786,
0.10668604075908661,
-0.1249639019370079,
0.4759206473827362,
-0.5672414302825928,
0.6338040232658386,
-0.2203301638364792,
0.07028023153543472,
-0.40876302123069763,
-0.362923800945282,
0.2874284088611603,
-0.06201570853590965,
0.11642857640981674,
-0.39028438925743103,
-0.04394698888063431,
0.7621081471443176,
0.20869874954223633,
0.906513512134552,
-0.2974449098110199,
-0.0934041291475296,
0.3568735420703888,
0.6211177706718445,
0.32552534341812134,
0.3107167184352875,
0.11665910482406616,
0.39678117632865906,
-0.5307742357254028,
-0.43236052989959717,
0.0125686414539814,
0.617538571357727,
-0.6565912365913391,
-0.2922879457473755,
-0.26846256852149963,
-0.3717339336872101,
-0.17271266877651215,
0.5130344033241272,
0.5127292275428772,
-0.19638532400131226,
-0.20327173173427582,
0.2948494553565979,
0.5652937889099121,
-0.2091301530599594,
0.8474734425544739,
0.46508756279945374,
0.012694540433585644,
-0.3500441908836365,
0.6377983689308167,
-0.03085288591682911,
-0.07581404596567154,
0.4977823495864868,
0.08522199094295502,
-0.10162201523780823,
-0.5949869751930237,
-0.4246159493923187,
0.05682875216007233,
-0.6367316246032715,
-0.28699249029159546,
-0.6693577766418457,
-0.5964665412902832,
-0.7124561071395874,
-0.32010790705680847,
-0.43197694420814514,
-0.1919579952955246,
-0.5525505542755127,
-0.2834683954715729,
0.493472695350647,
0.9692469239234924,
-0.3967130184173584,
0.5031927227973938,
-0.8124417066574097,
0.7656530141830444,
0.21251215040683746,
0.40111619234085083,
0.02764277718961239,
-0.3908189535140991,
-0.13074852526187897,
0.0973190888762474,
-0.2545473277568817,
-0.9388917088508606,
0.35133835673332214,
0.2662668824195862,
0.5370681881904602,
0.5851218104362488,
0.00046753307105973363,
0.29633012413978577,
-0.19164860248565674,
0.7568405866622925,
0.16264691948890686,
-0.9826992750167847,
0.8843434453010559,
-0.4109497666358948,
0.15373307466506958,
0.637248694896698,
0.6245529651641846,
-0.41104909777641296,
-0.35202616453170776,
-0.8594017028808594,
-0.5820217728614807,
0.3760433793067932,
0.5216824412345886,
0.10171138495206833,
0.053040314465761185,
0.4102102518081665,
0.26766064763069153,
0.40475693345069885,
-0.6792237162590027,
-0.04668238386511803,
-0.18108411133289337,
-0.2909453809261322,
0.04370824247598648,
-0.22636531293392181,
-0.027503851801156998,
-0.10638295114040375,
0.449454128742218,
0.020411953330039978,
0.4468000829219818,
0.03772040084004402,
-0.26123151183128357,
-0.46574667096138,
-0.19604961574077606,
0.6270111799240112,
0.3532373607158661,
-0.2120034247636795,
-0.09257373958826065,
-0.21061395108699799,
-0.6089116930961609,
-0.02694198675453663,
0.048619817942380905,
-0.20006762444972992,
0.3273482918739319,
0.8510779142379761,
0.4492279887199402,
-0.33347344398498535,
-0.35700055956840515,
0.5805988311767578,
-0.04740758240222931,
-0.24608568847179413,
-0.6558100581169128,
0.27622637152671814,
0.05712096765637398,
0.2505474090576172,
0.9070101380348206,
0.4173858165740967,
0.44392356276512146,
-0.4822543263435364,
0.671629786491394,
0.33658942580223083,
-0.4391566216945648,
-0.1846611648797989,
0.3947179913520813,
0.34843820333480835,
-0.6230238080024719,
0.7338407039642334,
-0.1053607240319252,
-0.6439624428749084,
0.7313817143440247,
0.0032773478887975216,
1.2698558568954468,
-0.4687489867210388,
0.4878557324409485,
0.07272369414567947,
0.6857578158378601,
-0.038810085505247116,
0.12398317456245422,
-0.0022372929379343987,
-0.9987928867340088,
-0.4752768278121948,
-0.4121556580066681,
-0.2432764768600464,
0.7333034873008728,
-0.13855060935020447,
0.24963703751564026,
-0.8203326463699341,
-0.2642594873905182,
0.39011284708976746,
0.1507428139448166,
-0.8014446496963501,
0.5389206409454346,
0.5755143761634827,
0.9710171818733215,
-1.196589469909668,
0.6514869332313538,
0.3547557592391968,
-0.4498497247695923,
-0.6039619445800781,
0.6727966666221619,
0.3199264109134674,
-0.873775064945221,
0.6749491691589355,
0.4603487551212311,
-0.1806062012910843,
-0.009714674204587936,
-1.0750999450683594,
-0.6365426182746887,
0.6560664772987366,
0.24584166705608368,
-0.16909287869930267,
0.03102327138185501,
0.24409712851047516,
0.36959925293922424,
-0.4554571211338043,
-0.04473141208291054,
0.6098827719688416,
0.7023215889930725,
-0.06095545366406441,
-0.9019415378570557,
0.0444999635219574,
-0.24089501798152924,
-0.6641925573348999,
0.13585354387760162,
-0.31378838419914246,
0.6381192207336426,
0.027874121442437172,
-0.26857098937034607,
-0.3443778455257416,
0.49723637104034424,
-0.04012202098965645,
0.6641052961349487,
0.5875484347343445,
0.424738347530365,
0.494634211063385,
-0.05072205141186714,
0.6879224181175232,
0.07203954458236694,
0.30202868580818176,
0.9496696591377258,
0.06667802482843399,
0.5837334394454956,
0.33739131689071655,
0.20928749442100525,
0.36727628111839294,
0.7907799482345581,
-0.4066099226474762,
0.3516656160354614,
-0.4698943495750427,
-0.020586201921105385,
-0.4027853310108185,
-0.1091773733496666,
-0.23861919343471527,
0.35526975989341736,
0.6471042037010193,
-0.46934670209884644,
-0.1565939486026764,
-0.004361454397439957,
0.24879880249500275,
0.046051640063524246,
-0.14637070894241333,
0.8995959162712097,
0.053240422159433365,
-0.4600003957748413,
0.5531359314918518,
-0.0390748530626297,
0.7558580040931702,
-0.09994996339082718,
-0.2224205732345581,
-0.012106223963201046,
0.15857255458831787,
-0.6069003939628601,
-1.1971465349197388,
0.6148044466972351,
-0.057519324123859406,
-0.00818241760134697,
-0.14146529138088226,
1.2501428127288818,
-0.045216746628284454,
-0.35869351029396057,
0.4472874402999878,
0.3480289578437805,
-0.1707361787557602,
-0.3965804874897003,
-1.2494933605194092,
0.009995035827159882,
0.19587507843971252,
-0.3720793128013611,
-0.17891618609428406,
0.4187130331993103,
0.37012627720832825,
0.8316704034805298,
0.6749223470687866,
-0.14784976840019226,
-0.07406412065029144,
0.09198174625635147,
0.6107826232910156,
-0.6066240072250366,
-0.36132609844207764,
-0.9155623912811279,
0.5208779573440552,
-0.6919482350349426,
-0.24731029570102692,
0.6310276985168457,
0.38351479172706604,
0.7955355048179626,
-0.24177125096321106,
1.0050545930862427,
-0.09581170976161957,
0.7364478707313538,
-0.4405709505081177,
1.0159014463424683,
-0.6399980187416077,
0.11961653083562851,
-0.41228947043418884,
-0.5745766162872314,
-0.32192593812942505,
0.797971785068512,
-0.143833726644516,
0.13545376062393188,
0.5599586367607117,
0.43325912952423096,
-0.1678999364376068,
0.19891700148582458,
0.17589089274406433,
0.2032800316810608,
0.39373043179512024,
0.2835502624511719,
0.6590427756309509,
-0.6621977686882019,
0.1887994259595871,
-0.32250282168388367,
0.06629520654678345,
-0.7220721244812012,
-0.9240853190422058,
-1.2278531789779663,
-0.5517216920852661,
-0.540411651134491,
-0.3646969497203827,
-0.09800179302692413,
0.8024531602859497,
0.6829196214675903,
-1.1600555181503296,
0.19088123738765717,
-0.3315292298793793,
0.16797418892383575,
0.11243383586406708,
-0.37581169605255127,
0.2782725393772125,
-0.32506778836250305,
-0.3949134945869446,
0.3230117857456207,
0.22689330577850342,
0.4242496192455292,
-0.23859082162380219,
0.007257228717207909,
-0.6104176044464111,
0.3317098915576935,
0.4742751717567444,
0.09799078851938248,
-0.6175390481948853,
-0.40798184275627136,
-0.03881189972162247,
-0.276391863822937,
-0.23268839716911316,
0.7432023882865906,
-0.502592146396637,
0.020304014906287193,
0.5253586173057556,
0.7825934886932373,
0.3485596477985382,
-0.1858564019203186,
0.5345063209533691,
-0.5182562470436096,
0.07516579329967499,
0.6842579245567322,
-0.08706071972846985,
0.4623139500617981,
-0.7805243730545044,
0.6089028120040894,
0.3522292971611023,
-0.454522967338562,
-0.7864017486572266,
0.21537244319915771,
-0.7547651529312134,
-0.6037173271179199,
1.0169661045074463,
0.162615567445755,
0.17112331092357635,
-0.5739088654518127,
-0.0939735695719719,
0.3509150445461273,
-0.6543624997138977,
0.8530243635177612,
0.6861703991889954,
-0.03811962157487869,
-0.3249819576740265,
-0.8084020018577576,
1.0224424600601196,
-0.093968465924263,
-0.6144331097602844,
-0.22275762259960175,
0.2786402106285095,
0.37360450625419617,
0.04274749383330345,
0.5449736714363098,
0.19373677670955658,
0.5459613800048828,
-0.06267008185386658,
-0.1204669326543808,
-0.11008580029010773,
-0.3307746350765228,
0.1096998006105423,
0.2804412543773651,
-0.35424935817718506,
-0.006325934082269669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16478v1 | EMMI -- Empathic Multimodal Motivational Interviews Dataset: Analyses and Annotations | 2024-06-24T09:32:28 | 2024-06-24T09:32:28 | Lucie Galland, Catherine Pelachaud, Florian Pecune | cs.CL | cs.CL | The study of multimodal interaction in therapy can yield a comprehensive
understanding of therapist and patient behavior that can be used to develop a
multimodal virtual agent supporting therapy. This investigation aims to uncover
how therapists skillfully blend therapy's task goal (employing classical steps
of Motivational Interviewing) with the social goal (building a trusting
relationship and expressing empathy). Furthermore, we seek to categorize
patients into various ``types'' requiring tailored therapeutic approaches. To
this intent, we present multimodal annotations of a corpus consisting of
simulated motivational interviewing conversations, wherein actors portray the
roles of patients and therapists. We introduce EMMI, composed of two publicly
available MI corpora, AnnoMI and the Motivational Interviewing Dataset, for
which we add multimodal annotations. We analyze these annotations to
characterize functional behavior for developing a virtual agent performing
motivational interviews emphasizing social and empathic behaviors. Our analysis
found three clusters of patients expressing significant differences in behavior
and adaptation of the therapist's behavior to those types. This shows the
importance of a therapist being able to adapt their behavior depending on the
current situation within the dialog and the type of user. | [
-0.3897399306297302,
-0.9136162996292114,
0.8062000274658203,
0.2541401982307434,
0.10282520204782486,
0.1804467886686325,
-0.11490742117166519,
-0.2615431547164917,
0.7598221898078918,
0.23855485022068024,
-0.6381561756134033,
-0.32584667205810547,
-0.5697928071022034,
0.37073010206222534,
0.230927973985672,
0.8633877038955688,
-0.13288602232933044,
0.44756072759628296,
-0.47806423902511597,
-0.2773112654685974,
-0.5799044370651245,
-0.7387085556983948,
-0.5721830129623413,
-0.17806604504585266,
0.7179496884346008,
0.47182175517082214,
0.2939698100090027,
0.2957068383693695,
0.3937493860721588,
0.37341463565826416,
0.41082364320755005,
0.07103120535612106,
-0.3238278031349182,
0.5476094484329224,
0.040352415293455124,
-0.33973920345306396,
-0.34366413950920105,
0.20100495219230652,
0.24577902257442474,
0.24665524065494537,
-0.06889678537845612,
0.30078771710395813,
-0.15970182418823242,
-0.054982561618089676,
-0.5600467920303345,
0.03360738977789879,
-0.09081891924142838,
0.24914948642253876,
0.2172844111919403,
-0.676524817943573,
-0.3635815382003784,
-0.13407555222511292,
-0.1248522624373436,
-0.5238426327705383,
0.057845164090394974,
0.05709310248494148,
0.4225853979587555,
0.23923727869987488,
-1.0423334836959839,
-0.24057146906852722,
-0.7179468274116516,
0.7258092164993286,
0.019457446411252022,
0.2374093383550644,
0.7450528144836426,
0.4067015051841736,
0.13947966694831848,
-0.33597373962402344,
-0.13568057119846344,
-0.4805956482887268,
-0.2850745618343353,
0.07997586578130722,
0.04990234598517418,
0.3019828796386719,
0.5177037715911865,
0.09291908144950867,
-0.3123823404312134,
-0.21271543204784393,
-0.34208613634109497,
-0.3072870075702667,
0.4802555441856384,
0.4756949543952942,
0.31852012872695923,
-0.015286359004676342,
-0.46564483642578125,
0.1332230567932129,
-0.2990218997001648,
0.18930071592330933,
0.02242317795753479,
-0.06028250232338905,
-0.3510134220123291,
0.7375568747520447,
0.011817633174359798,
0.6592475771903992,
-0.07393791526556015,
-0.5994291305541992,
0.20229922235012054,
-0.23747701942920685,
-0.007958605885505676,
0.33979520201683044,
0.28921252489089966,
0.921308696269989,
0.17142799496650696,
-0.06329374015331268,
0.08484894782304764,
0.1374567300081253,
0.6320487260818481,
-0.9176491498947144,
0.1446949988603592,
0.5009138584136963,
-0.7180178165435791,
-0.4354003667831421,
-0.23768340051174164,
-0.7591052651405334,
-0.3701815605163574,
-0.6394549608230591,
0.4219066798686981,
-0.5037767291069031,
-0.40400925278663635,
-0.2795504033565521,
-0.570115327835083,
0.12925346195697784,
0.3710325360298157,
-0.7839223146438599,
0.30395591259002686,
0.5046165585517883,
0.9183902740478516,
0.36163949966430664,
-0.332622766494751,
-0.6998288035392761,
0.3864285349845886,
0.12391959130764008,
0.559782862663269,
-0.97132807970047,
-0.2890319228172302,
0.19021493196487427,
0.12966571748256683,
-0.43574076890945435,
-0.009769123047590256,
0.4415934681892395,
0.07833895832300186,
-0.0029188047628849745,
-0.3926776647567749,
-0.20858833193778992,
-0.32785552740097046,
1.183060884475708,
-0.34235700964927673,
0.35204023122787476,
0.45170295238494873,
-0.4297729432582855,
0.16760869324207306,
-1.0031076669692993,
-0.2478053867816925,
-0.28417691588401794,
-0.2380066215991974,
0.3516496419906616,
0.3686046898365021,
-0.1561562418937683,
0.40067362785339355,
-0.37415552139282227,
0.03730608895421028,
-0.3712143301963806,
-0.11662716418504715,
0.6936394572257996,
-0.08391471207141876,
0.670677125453949,
0.3018694519996643,
0.16485770046710968,
0.10892251878976822,
-0.8320239186286926,
-0.16276368498802185,
0.047924984246492386,
-0.041441988199949265,
-0.578289270401001,
-0.35263702273368835,
0.2661181092262268,
0.441771537065506,
0.04026464745402336,
-0.9930198788642883,
0.05627408251166344,
0.21317780017852783,
0.3872658312320709,
0.5513412356376648,
0.16995514929294586,
-0.05329867824912071,
-0.6871735453605652,
0.9722920060157776,
0.03704097121953964,
0.5846523642539978,
-0.3379583954811096,
-0.29964807629585266,
-0.4175553619861603,
-0.6756018996238708,
-0.11371521651744843,
0.3779628276824951,
-0.644116997718811,
-0.1498234122991562,
-0.014251306653022766,
-0.5504043698310852,
-0.6941028833389282,
-0.05196218565106392,
0.41087061166763306,
0.4585915207862854,
0.20270507037639618,
-0.3429458439350128,
-0.5618793368339539,
-0.8381201028823853,
-0.18191266059875488,
0.018488964065909386,
0.14748282730579376,
0.4507112503051758,
0.47894325852394104,
-0.4013020396232605,
0.7769536375999451,
-0.2065281867980957,
-0.5889705419540405,
-0.2176743596792221,
0.1623532623052597,
-0.12149795144796371,
0.600439190864563,
0.7878583073616028,
-1.0696845054626465,
-0.581355631351471,
-0.027422577142715454,
-0.806556224822998,
-0.013621480204164982,
-0.2810814082622528,
0.04100640490651131,
-0.13062147796154022,
0.3527570366859436,
-0.550381600856781,
0.35029926896095276,
0.5871067047119141,
-0.7643945217132568,
0.08232493698596954,
-0.17610909044742584,
0.7471536993980408,
-1.091188907623291,
-0.019499698653817177,
0.16374626755714417,
-0.08454690873622894,
-0.8879517316818237,
-0.28702500462532043,
-0.36695751547813416,
0.01203716266900301,
-0.47239357233047485,
0.40696969628334045,
-0.23795416951179504,
0.2147776037454605,
0.024263175204396248,
-0.053618159145116806,
0.011823953129351139,
0.5991066694259644,
0.09460197389125824,
0.036517657339572906,
0.6816517114639282,
-0.578463077545166,
0.5248952507972717,
0.44087839126586914,
0.3307764530181885,
1.0575544834136963,
-0.4674178957939148,
0.2362474948167801,
-0.22821193933486938,
-0.1525227278470993,
-0.9255208969116211,
-0.415203332901001,
0.6182832717895508,
-0.5455320477485657,
0.19128450751304626,
-0.22433382272720337,
-0.40686652064323425,
0.22958530485630035,
-0.46389317512512207,
0.6568856835365295,
0.13307037949562073,
-0.1886538565158844,
1.0866373777389526,
0.1993163526058197,
-0.2369527518749237,
-0.10252659767866135,
-0.5922428965568542,
-0.03661898523569107,
-0.5514702200889587,
-0.6027892827987671,
0.3279445767402649,
-0.32727664709091187,
-0.5478659868240356,
-0.17207807302474976,
0.4471718966960907,
-0.11735551804304123,
0.12659676373004913,
0.491203635931015,
0.2263232320547104,
0.029629847034811974,
-0.058775436133146286,
0.261307030916214,
-0.27369409799575806,
0.31245484948158264,
0.6207730174064636,
0.4589084982872009,
-0.002208482939749956,
-0.5131441354751587,
-0.3545013964176178,
0.6542671918869019,
0.6691188812255859,
-0.07295969128608704,
1.0521525144577026,
0.932702898979187,
-0.25170356035232544,
0.44764193892478943,
-0.6668828129768372,
-0.34481626749038696,
-0.33388209342956543,
-0.12169952690601349,
-0.7548784613609314,
-1.0706335306167603,
0.5610743165016174,
-0.03078540600836277,
-0.08617207407951355,
-0.07291186600923538,
0.7957341074943542,
0.21289727091789246,
1.2600499391555786,
0.314179390668869,
0.3951815366744995,
0.5430178046226501,
0.25447824597358704,
0.08719421178102493,
-0.934329628944397,
-0.46720004081726074,
-0.2976352274417877,
-0.3721587657928467,
-0.6472182869911194,
-0.1523473560810089,
0.49296021461486816,
-0.3767548203468323,
-0.33750277757644653,
0.03438473865389824,
-0.510246992111206,
-0.25722479820251465,
0.5893491506576538,
0.32059329748153687,
0.1555047184228897,
-0.05812288075685501,
0.1465599685907364,
-0.2724948525428772,
-0.29062050580978394,
-0.3987506330013275,
1.1803675889968872,
0.5385919809341431,
0.443521112203598,
0.5192664861679077,
0.7361968159675598,
0.37387511134147644,
0.7217859029769897,
-0.8846102952957153,
0.4301441013813019,
0.7354819178581238,
-0.7911530137062073,
0.024230413138866425,
-0.11742112040519714,
-0.953525185585022,
0.533412754535675,
-0.3009305000305176,
-0.8723506927490234,
0.267316073179245,
0.22188371419906616,
-0.3217782974243164,
-0.32011091709136963,
-0.827949583530426,
1.0371240377426147,
-0.496707558631897,
-0.24431388080120087,
-0.40402644872665405,
-0.7828156352043152,
0.1937546283006668,
-0.12605467438697815,
0.16255435347557068,
-0.22874964773654938,
-0.12278921902179718,
0.4332307279109955,
-0.18504948914051056,
0.8620912432670593,
-0.4798385500907898,
0.48980891704559326,
0.16217920184135437,
0.37035781145095825,
0.004973214585334063,
0.10346605628728867,
0.08491569012403488,
0.02223983220756054,
0.6333889961242676,
-0.2612755596637726,
-0.709316611289978,
0.4243178963661194,
-0.5057525038719177,
-0.6398352384567261,
-0.6176325678825378,
-0.47288230061531067,
-0.38165733218193054,
-0.09002379328012466,
-0.11011675000190735,
0.5205849409103394,
-0.5775429606437683,
0.4237358868122101,
0.18978890776634216,
-0.13599884510040283,
-0.052828796207904816,
0.7013435363769531,
-0.1306982934474945,
-0.5508189797401428,
0.7521926164627075,
-0.12780196964740753,
0.24781376123428345,
0.3751767575740814,
0.29936516284942627,
-0.060440920293331146,
-0.10177460312843323,
0.024741046130657196,
0.3777919411659241,
-0.5504006147384644,
-0.03151871636509895,
-0.6680935025215149,
0.17696405947208405,
-0.7479619979858398,
-0.21224400401115417,
0.012430147267878056,
-0.2274404913187027,
0.02960674650967121,
-0.23377038538455963,
0.7269020080566406,
0.5113241672515869,
-0.2411481887102127,
0.11981149017810822,
-1.037128210067749,
0.13843612372875214,
-0.013028926216065884,
-0.10578437894582748,
-0.26653853058815,
-0.16992610692977905,
-0.2748531401157379,
0.17710566520690918,
-0.45328065752983093,
-0.9435611367225647,
0.578962504863739,
0.13489165902137756,
0.5319973826408386,
0.6270744204521179,
0.009306333027780056,
0.4370885193347931,
-0.06612125784158707,
0.5769042372703552,
0.2938538193702698,
-0.692126452922821,
0.6960170865058899,
-0.417960524559021,
-0.4707506597042084,
0.5524519681930542,
0.7352898120880127,
-0.6325084567070007,
0.01668981835246086,
-0.510709822177887,
-0.24290435016155243,
0.8022773265838623,
0.17417524755001068,
0.10846694558858871,
-0.10402349382638931,
0.10402463376522064,
0.07706096768379211,
0.43325144052505493,
-0.6967732310295105,
-0.12843766808509827,
-0.1924310028553009,
-0.5279817581176758,
-0.136691153049469,
-0.48738646507263184,
-1.0778299570083618,
-0.3304134011268616,
0.11901780217885971,
-0.19728194177150726,
0.6264322996139526,
0.3479597866535187,
-0.04060571640729904,
-0.11579427868127823,
0.11584674566984177,
0.6697620153427124,
0.40217065811157227,
-0.40422213077545166,
0.07726407796144485,
-0.0484699122607708,
-0.187494158744812,
0.16336975991725922,
0.14004205167293549,
0.4739161729812622,
0.06417623907327652,
0.27093639969825745,
0.6861568689346313,
0.08188917487859726,
-0.9314228296279907,
0.63688725233078,
-0.24103423953056335,
-0.2631479501724243,
-0.6647789478302002,
0.02966698445379734,
-0.3261331617832184,
0.5563591122627258,
-0.17000366747379303,
-0.18444973230361938,
0.3617003560066223,
-0.7613520622253418,
-0.08878452330827713,
0.26382356882095337,
-0.4825901389122009,
-0.5072143077850342,
0.3626200556755066,
0.16554254293441772,
-0.6914279460906982,
0.6491169929504395,
0.14840084314346313,
-0.3419243097305298,
0.44974324107170105,
0.6049668192863464,
0.8384352922439575,
-0.46213871240615845,
0.4723018705844879,
0.08660967648029327,
0.10528595000505447,
0.21033509075641632,
0.3942875266075134,
-0.3878262937068939,
-0.9180634021759033,
0.10593219846487045,
-0.32905271649360657,
-0.5651059150695801,
-0.4434832036495209,
-0.9579967856407166,
0.027885597199201584,
-0.21899671852588654,
-0.3534035384654999,
-0.10573500394821167,
-0.5061579942703247,
-0.7845069766044617,
0.1392446756362915,
-0.06761932373046875,
0.43417808413505554,
-0.9413747191429138,
0.549457311630249,
1.0846041440963745,
-0.7643129825592041,
-0.5109487175941467,
-0.4764663577079773,
0.31459754705429077,
-0.9334855675697327,
0.7758776545524597,
0.35451647639274597,
0.16531942784786224,
-0.1685488373041153,
-0.28234434127807617,
-0.7239850163459778,
1.2993656396865845,
0.44052454829216003,
0.1618519425392151,
0.00938914529979229,
0.2424313873052597,
0.7588720321655273,
-0.9662691950798035,
0.5477827787399292,
0.48233553767204285,
0.7014773488044739,
0.09491955488920212,
-0.8264029622077942,
0.17661717534065247,
-0.6164947748184204,
-0.19005675613880157,
0.030628111213445663,
-0.8112115859985352,
0.7181107401847839,
-0.10166943818330765,
0.30684396624565125,
0.03241648152470589,
-0.08307776600122452,
0.36684340238571167,
0.7528095245361328,
0.683082103729248,
0.20328202843666077,
0.2964105010032654,
0.03279992192983627,
1.0731664896011353,
-0.6675952076911926,
0.04264888912439346,
0.5882094502449036,
-0.24008749425411224,
0.41029658913612366,
0.8482425808906555,
0.32054075598716736,
0.359262079000473,
0.6557267308235168,
-0.18042634427547455,
0.2883867621421814,
-0.20888714492321014,
-0.3611273169517517,
-0.3521740138530731,
-0.8634212613105774,
-0.1429481953382492,
0.6971575021743774,
0.5191560983657837,
-0.786794126033783,
0.1487666219472885,
0.4960603415966034,
-0.10913559794425964,
-0.26133430004119873,
-0.18638218939304352,
0.5077541470527649,
0.30241331458091736,
-0.8056204915046692,
0.05660729110240936,
-0.1097659096121788,
0.09047868847846985,
-0.47131186723709106,
-0.33633968234062195,
0.23477613925933838,
0.08535349369049072,
-0.3720221221446991,
-0.3237341344356537,
0.16316445171833038,
-0.16491004824638367,
0.07216309010982513,
-0.7779581546783447,
0.6319358944892883,
-0.46044307947158813,
-0.2331497222185135,
0.3987998366355896,
0.6128537058830261,
0.4701851010322571,
-0.075289286673069,
-0.6414212584495544,
0.21126601099967957,
-0.042361997067928314,
-0.5085525512695312,
0.6807836294174194,
0.5079568028450012,
0.18933475017547607,
0.6502779126167297,
0.5833540558815002,
-0.09614688158035278,
-0.2737915813922882,
0.26536521315574646,
0.8191454410552979,
-0.8347192406654358,
-0.2276846170425415,
-0.7262260317802429,
0.646699070930481,
-0.061686597764492035,
-0.5186396241188049,
0.8572942614555359,
0.26431989669799805,
0.47256794571876526,
-0.12964116036891937,
0.4638863801956177,
-0.3169310688972473,
0.6343597173690796,
-0.5048399567604065,
0.10030721127986908,
-0.8227887749671936,
-0.32944613695144653,
-0.2528942823410034,
-0.8037250638008118,
-0.025776466354727745,
0.6817649006843567,
-0.16707931458950043,
0.2721307873725891,
0.6918106079101562,
0.9201743006706238,
0.274835467338562,
0.07322445511817932,
0.5295212864875793,
0.05715478956699371,
0.30042269825935364,
0.4197128117084503,
1.1458073854446411,
-0.04606957733631134,
0.1676921248435974,
-0.35975250601768494,
-0.3059022128582001,
-0.42636990547180176,
-0.5906670093536377,
-1.054126501083374,
-0.6446163058280945,
-0.3009938597679138,
-0.5163202881813049,
-0.29190748929977417,
1.5251128673553467,
0.31346309185028076,
-0.337845116853714,
-0.15548700094223022,
0.37604016065597534,
-0.21964767575263977,
-0.2894344925880432,
-0.23065833747386932,
-0.043885089457035065,
-0.11400188505649567,
-0.8204947710037231,
0.3329817056655884,
0.4399729371070862,
-0.10393519699573517,
-0.2849541902542114,
-0.20041389763355255,
-0.08322873711585999,
-0.03194684535264969,
0.7307021617889404,
0.1904623657464981,
-0.42878392338752747,
-0.4770587682723999,
0.11783025413751602,
0.10057301819324493,
0.1299331784248352,
1.191265344619751,
-0.2682149112224579,
0.7011368274688721,
0.11543924361467361,
0.4609682857990265,
0.3761243522167206,
0.25548702478408813,
0.5921358466148376,
-0.1896468997001648,
0.1151299849152565,
0.4317916929721832,
0.4136795103549957,
0.02241704612970352,
-0.4393408000469208,
0.565869152545929,
0.276811808347702,
-0.5174553990364075,
-1.0167611837387085,
0.09270476549863815,
-1.2427557706832886,
0.04841156303882599,
1.38676118850708,
-0.3192261755466461,
-0.16883479058742523,
-0.4368697702884674,
-0.6967095732688904,
0.09318440407514572,
-0.46362513303756714,
0.6861835718154907,
0.6962593793869019,
-0.7279247641563416,
-0.2719637453556061,
-0.29764270782470703,
0.4359518587589264,
0.310185045003891,
-0.4668900966644287,
-0.5868197083473206,
0.6906469464302063,
0.23948800563812256,
0.3026915192604065,
0.787331223487854,
0.1961817890405655,
0.16293850541114807,
0.16162805259227753,
0.17999300360679626,
-0.38142988085746765,
-0.23596987128257751,
-0.11516277492046356,
0.44916146993637085,
0.21375548839569092,
-0.3323328495025635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16477v1 | DaLPSR: Leverage Degradation-Aligned Language Prompt for Real-World Image Super-Resolution | 2024-06-24T09:30:36 | 2024-06-24T09:30:36 | Aiwen Jiang, Zhi Wei, Long Peng, Feiqiang Liu, Wenbo Li, Mingwen Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Image super-resolution pursuits reconstructing high-fidelity high-resolution
counterpart for low-resolution image. In recent years, diffusion-based models
have garnered significant attention due to their capabilities with rich prior
knowledge. The success of diffusion models based on general text prompts has
validated the effectiveness of textual control in the field of text2image.
However, given the severe degradation commonly presented in low-resolution
images, coupled with the randomness characteristics of diffusion models,
current models struggle to adequately discern semantic and degradation
information within severely degraded images. This often leads to obstacles such
as semantic loss, visual artifacts, and visual hallucinations, which pose
substantial challenges for practical use. To address these challenges, this
paper proposes to leverage degradation-aligned language prompt for accurate,
fine-grained, and high-fidelity image restoration. Complementary priors
including semantic content descriptions and degradation prompts are explored.
Specifically, on one hand, image-restoration prompt alignment decoder is
proposed to automatically discern the degradation degree of LR images, thereby
generating beneficial degradation priors for image restoration. On the other
hand, much richly tailored descriptions from pretrained multimodal large
language model elicit high-level semantic priors closely aligned with human
perception, ensuring fidelity control for image restoration. Comprehensive
comparisons with state-of-the-art methods have been done on several popular
synthetic and real-world benchmark datasets. The quantitative and qualitative
analysis have demonstrated that the proposed method achieves a new
state-of-the-art perceptual quality level, especially in real-world cases based
on reference-free metrics. | [
-0.45097705721855164,
-1.0145277976989746,
0.7420928478240967,
-0.1544906049966812,
-0.26409974694252014,
-0.08838656544685364,
-0.04632767662405968,
-0.30968940258026123,
-0.06041973456740379,
0.424403578042984,
-0.4693071246147156,
-0.24022817611694336,
-0.5717120170593262,
0.1831538826227188,
-0.42060938477516174,
0.8261637091636658,
0.10671830177307129,
0.25266149640083313,
-0.25644540786743164,
-0.02067485637962818,
-0.7540900707244873,
-0.05080394446849823,
-0.7904536724090576,
-0.0614711195230484,
0.29376646876335144,
0.14616890251636505,
1.0835410356521606,
0.6891295909881592,
0.7621546387672424,
0.19707098603248596,
-0.30805647373199463,
0.26484277844429016,
-0.44993478059768677,
0.19838981330394745,
-0.1955566555261612,
0.0316624790430069,
-0.31849434971809387,
-0.11285259574651718,
0.6306937336921692,
0.36484506726264954,
-0.20235675573349,
-0.05049075186252594,
0.23033356666564941,
0.6992009878158569,
-0.8119365572929382,
-0.15683718025684357,
-0.47483694553375244,
0.028740089386701584,
0.24193620681762695,
-0.2657787501811981,
-0.38909924030303955,
-0.33413955569267273,
-0.21139326691627502,
-0.9320011138916016,
0.20841985940933228,
-0.18270735442638397,
1.3271538019180298,
0.5427021384239197,
-0.06221297010779381,
0.035732101649045944,
-0.7551096081733704,
0.8290929198265076,
-0.49372240900993347,
0.3332289755344391,
0.42809441685676575,
0.5390120148658752,
-0.30446887016296387,
-0.7205700278282166,
-0.746097207069397,
-0.0733518972992897,
-0.14232869446277618,
0.26231470704078674,
-0.1528085321187973,
-0.14381355047225952,
-0.024314425885677338,
0.6061596274375916,
-0.3990805447101593,
0.08525773882865906,
-0.09242593497037888,
-0.5311746001243591,
0.13673581182956696,
0.1654781550168991,
0.40134599804878235,
-0.0932060033082962,
-0.5848370790481567,
-0.272832989692688,
-0.6376334428787231,
-0.5239983201026917,
0.11256653815507889,
0.01865570619702339,
0.06986896693706512,
0.06630348414182663,
-0.08427709341049194,
0.7545032501220703,
0.14876452088356018,
-0.36920297145843506,
0.09867680817842484,
-0.5912907123565674,
-0.16339994966983795,
-0.2630847096443176,
0.5642344355583191,
0.8126657009124756,
-0.08611543476581573,
-0.010569506324827671,
-0.2850389778614044,
0.37280699610710144,
0.2160184532403946,
-0.7050578594207764,
-0.0013633329654112458,
-0.08972988277673721,
-0.6652592420578003,
0.0755978599190712,
-0.3634347915649414,
-0.8883281350135803,
-0.5600215196609497,
-0.42591458559036255,
0.5733740925788879,
-0.6104179620742798,
-0.25645825266838074,
0.14922194182872772,
-0.23932264745235443,
0.2366592288017273,
0.7323360443115234,
-0.46718132495880127,
-0.11661388725042343,
0.32664284110069275,
0.9149313569068909,
0.012322688475251198,
0.043090902268886566,
-0.5855615139007568,
0.09491146355867386,
-0.32229191064834595,
1.0261868238449097,
-0.734313428401947,
-0.5308088660240173,
-0.0296048354357481,
0.07342398911714554,
0.4508790969848633,
-0.8506998419761658,
1.1824626922607422,
-0.6917433142662048,
0.28794071078300476,
-0.18007849156856537,
-0.18597368896007538,
-0.020473182201385498,
0.3258606493473053,
-0.4722139239311218,
0.9890216588973999,
0.10288607329130173,
-0.6680999398231506,
0.38407230377197266,
-0.18735875189304352,
0.0828649029135704,
0.24043187499046326,
0.06172202527523041,
-0.40119174122810364,
0.058401044458150864,
0.3408149480819702,
0.4343317151069641,
-0.2887311577796936,
0.2368459701538086,
-0.21977834403514862,
-0.2568109333515167,
-0.1488664746284485,
-0.6926809549331665,
0.17761799693107605,
0.4002695381641388,
0.17126765847206116,
0.0119467256590724,
-0.8002815246582031,
-0.23398971557617188,
0.09211880713701248,
0.08645608276128769,
-0.5988998413085938,
0.026374686509370804,
-0.013321880251169205,
0.36705735325813293,
0.24180850386619568,
-0.6041979789733887,
0.005693234968930483,
-0.2172849327325821,
0.2298303097486496,
0.6380009055137634,
0.2618252635002136,
0.5517147183418274,
-0.3872465193271637,
0.40927648544311523,
-0.024453483521938324,
0.28213250637054443,
-0.7062963247299194,
-0.2288735806941986,
-0.4690883755683899,
-0.5992953777313232,
0.20122267305850983,
0.7084720730781555,
-0.7905119061470032,
0.30855992436408997,
-0.4121922552585602,
-0.31939610838890076,
-0.5909444689750671,
-0.2875394821166992,
0.520786464214325,
0.9672791957855225,
0.8364715576171875,
-0.4369492828845978,
-0.39826342463493347,
-0.9609544277191162,
-0.003365960903465748,
0.16178973019123077,
-0.15985922515392303,
0.2408406138420105,
0.08074786514043808,
-0.3969607353210449,
0.784729540348053,
-0.5122158527374268,
-0.6617618799209595,
0.03513684123754501,
-0.039466824382543564,
0.18580055236816406,
0.541144073009491,
0.2315308004617691,
-0.8458833694458008,
-0.3503521680831909,
-0.22764697670936584,
-0.595255434513092,
-0.12334718555212021,
-0.3295068144798279,
-0.29719388484954834,
0.35315096378326416,
0.6382130980491638,
-0.5316213369369507,
0.4698433578014374,
0.6694793105125427,
-0.24445480108261108,
1.0785341262817383,
-0.5788577198982239,
0.5671634078025818,
-0.9363796710968018,
-0.048436008393764496,
0.3197644352912903,
-0.1861201375722885,
-0.3636694848537445,
0.24774475395679474,
0.025276971980929375,
-0.017747584730386734,
-0.3112748861312866,
0.6063647866249084,
-0.4457966685295105,
0.02248106151819229,
-0.17123161256313324,
0.16759344935417175,
0.3119957149028778,
-0.09057212620973587,
0.19047003984451294,
0.8581313490867615,
0.6499210000038147,
-0.5431356430053711,
0.1557532399892807,
0.33768919110298157,
-0.2250649333000183,
1.1587162017822266,
-0.7936899065971375,
0.000771254999563098,
-0.39366045594215393,
0.3520983159542084,
-1.1984866857528687,
-0.392102986574173,
0.18462467193603516,
-0.23233485221862793,
0.5095919966697693,
-0.11579613387584686,
-0.5507009029388428,
0.000850776385050267,
-0.22582577168941498,
0.41352856159210205,
0.6349942684173584,
-0.5179844498634338,
0.29926228523254395,
0.12624716758728027,
-0.3261842429637909,
-0.34696727991104126,
-0.6791186928749084,
0.25493887066841125,
-0.10598821938037872,
-0.5233064889907837,
0.6646566390991211,
-0.03317973390221596,
-0.05835234001278877,
-0.02351026050746441,
-0.047308072447776794,
0.1949176788330078,
-0.3060312271118164,
0.12504802644252777,
0.5139716863632202,
-0.09426562488079071,
0.16213275492191315,
0.09285080432891846,
-0.3811987042427063,
-0.28513142466545105,
-0.06634862720966339,
0.5510315299034119,
0.14153283834457397,
-0.1419006735086441,
-0.8064041137695312,
0.39077797532081604,
0.6529093384742737,
-0.1746777445077896,
0.6057195067405701,
0.5752178430557251,
-0.24227164685726166,
0.3275132179260254,
-0.6158119440078735,
-0.03713502362370491,
-0.48882076144218445,
0.36475563049316406,
-0.26679328083992004,
-0.49435004591941833,
0.5354570150375366,
-0.3068358600139618,
-0.14506171643733978,
0.37504827976226807,
0.3283517360687256,
-0.3657781779766083,
1.0118597745895386,
0.3555697500705719,
0.2892875373363495,
0.5105594396591187,
-0.4263538122177124,
0.12255442887544632,
-0.8062646985054016,
-0.26817771792411804,
-0.3903366029262543,
-0.09417462348937988,
0.06805720180273056,
-0.4698626399040222,
0.420315146446228,
0.4012947082519531,
-0.3066898286342621,
0.2083480805158615,
-0.762938916683197,
0.619520902633667,
0.2608845829963684,
0.437273234128952,
0.33985745906829834,
0.3560723066329956,
-0.050673291087150574,
-0.23045310378074646,
-0.2541479468345642,
-0.8669657111167908,
0.2711634635925293,
0.3527265191078186,
0.9293067455291748,
-0.16489768028259277,
0.5904156565666199,
0.7415117621421814,
-0.11053064465522766,
-0.7821962833404541,
0.6902172565460205,
-0.22375458478927612,
-0.17041750252246857,
-0.2334001511335373,
-0.30504292249679565,
-0.8913648724555969,
-0.0477496013045311,
-0.20435819029808044,
-0.36743319034576416,
0.4576277434825897,
0.40958431363105774,
-0.40819141268730164,
0.17762291431427002,
-0.7134294509887695,
0.9324682354927063,
0.34879618883132935,
-0.450471967458725,
-0.3914332687854767,
-0.7943351864814758,
0.09624438732862473,
0.07441134005784988,
0.4122155010700226,
0.03651243820786476,
-0.28090834617614746,
0.32258862257003784,
-0.37668097019195557,
0.5298448204994202,
-0.3531765639781952,
-0.46913567185401917,
0.01096633542329073,
0.42713433504104614,
0.6925670504570007,
-0.22551502287387848,
-0.09009858220815659,
-0.04510505497455597,
0.1741914600133896,
-0.38955628871917725,
-0.7390993237495422,
0.6976255178451538,
-0.5322360992431641,
-0.4142139256000519,
-0.050911784172058105,
-0.33045274019241333,
-0.06664169579744339,
0.05662110075354576,
0.3354525566101074,
0.7002430558204651,
-0.05024902522563934,
-0.27279067039489746,
0.6339464783668518,
-0.48671847581863403,
0.5232212543487549,
0.14641714096069336,
-0.18756896257400513,
-0.5864200592041016,
1.1624022722244263,
0.013792211189866066,
0.500876784324646,
0.22009234130382538,
-0.03699641674757004,
-0.5138067007064819,
-0.5912343263626099,
-0.5659623742103577,
0.26889854669570923,
-0.7670255303382874,
-0.7403222918510437,
-0.43355533480644226,
0.16887709498405457,
-0.14853140711784363,
-0.4038231670856476,
-0.19841855764389038,
-0.3149939775466919,
-0.5407472252845764,
0.06880290061235428,
0.19737759232521057,
0.30421826243400574,
-0.029245929792523384,
0.3944026827812195,
-1.0113778114318848,
0.5534124970436096,
0.016891760751605034,
0.3149065375328064,
-0.1848883181810379,
-0.9077771902084351,
-0.11174878478050232,
0.13206003606319427,
-0.2954730987548828,
-0.756066083908081,
0.6520847678184509,
0.4002630114555359,
0.4915768802165985,
0.20804663002490997,
0.1895112544298172,
0.8005074858665466,
-0.30483779311180115,
1.144270896911621,
0.3415588140487671,
-0.6120624542236328,
0.7949262857437134,
-0.25420430302619934,
0.23823045194149017,
0.40578892827033997,
0.5191905498504639,
-0.5223914980888367,
-0.4690132141113281,
-0.6303570866584778,
-0.8678600788116455,
0.4411008954048157,
-0.37008944153785706,
0.339281290769577,
-0.18961367011070251,
0.5612783432006836,
0.19469217956066132,
-0.40106773376464844,
-0.285765677690506,
-0.09418728947639465,
-0.3363848626613617,
-0.16209669411182404,
0.10749243944883347,
-0.5237574577331543,
0.062302812933921814,
0.04621702805161476,
0.8868761658668518,
-0.015513652935624123,
0.18421556055545807,
0.47021329402923584,
-0.3790634274482727,
-0.06026529148221016,
0.421395480632782,
0.3335166275501251,
0.26609933376312256,
-0.006011290941387415,
0.19496698677539825,
-0.08394508808851242,
-0.5155015587806702,
0.4844565689563751,
-0.1387811005115509,
-0.4536581039428711,
-0.27147385478019714,
0.2689130902290344,
0.4490712881088257,
-0.164472758769989,
-0.5776470303535461,
0.5632612109184265,
-0.010800930671393871,
0.03789471089839935,
0.006819324102252722,
-0.026691168546676636,
-0.45680883526802063,
0.12462706863880157,
0.7056240439414978,
0.5113086104393005,
0.4307206869125366,
-0.42676830291748047,
0.3224915862083435,
0.34380170702934265,
-0.6121494174003601,
-0.23513425886631012,
0.41083332896232605,
0.1540514975786209,
-0.11534985899925232,
0.5400660037994385,
-0.5328925251960754,
-0.2025986760854721,
0.25424447655677795,
0.665920615196228,
0.516728937625885,
-0.15412506461143494,
0.38993558287620544,
0.5933164954185486,
-0.0853487029671669,
-0.2835925817489624,
0.17784078419208527,
-0.03720911964774132,
-0.7784122228622437,
-0.6647881865501404,
-0.8284027576446533,
0.04154663905501366,
0.07645855098962784,
-0.6643739938735962,
0.10334671288728714,
-0.44266846776008606,
-0.37949323654174805,
-0.1955082267522812,
-0.37629568576812744,
-0.038767389953136444,
0.255341112613678,
0.141184002161026,
0.9147546887397766,
-0.7219648361206055,
0.5683335065841675,
0.7353724837303162,
-0.5710200071334839,
-0.4957772195339203,
0.26784729957580566,
-0.18599705398082733,
-0.6094232201576233,
0.7633527517318726,
0.07576905936002731,
-0.17573681473731995,
0.3649608790874481,
-0.532881498336792,
-0.5590051412582397,
0.9334031939506531,
0.6519424915313721,
-0.3476704955101013,
0.05583861097693443,
-0.39786797761917114,
0.5762430429458618,
0.054899975657463074,
0.23096586763858795,
0.5940050482749939,
0.44002410769462585,
0.36866968870162964,
-0.8985830545425415,
0.39007464051246643,
-0.08871403336524963,
0.32908567786216736,
0.44024792313575745,
-0.4410134255886078,
0.19708356261253357,
-0.4297286868095398,
-0.7231443524360657,
0.46539440751075745,
0.6419369578361511,
0.17141176760196686,
0.06017255783081055,
0.6445297598838806,
0.9592373371124268,
0.2618284523487091,
-0.06000879779458046,
0.9398499131202698,
-0.05339786782860756,
0.3318690061569214,
0.838836669921875,
-0.05989088863134384,
0.7986183762550354,
0.5783073306083679,
-0.24262212216854095,
0.6528487205505371,
0.577763020992279,
0.039826735854148865,
0.9217864871025085,
-0.12627743184566498,
-0.46900245547294617,
-0.32678693532943726,
-0.7116779088973999,
-0.4170560836791992,
0.02206392213702202,
0.5225690603256226,
-0.42905834317207336,
-0.46217748522758484,
0.2887961268424988,
-0.23284558951854706,
0.35392963886260986,
-0.4159567654132843,
0.7367314696311951,
-0.2710266411304474,
-0.6251509189605713,
0.8767493963241577,
-0.2298964112997055,
0.8714377880096436,
-0.42002952098846436,
-0.4474499821662903,
-0.46273621916770935,
0.22526320815086365,
-0.2915745675563812,
-0.8766930103302002,
0.6922183632850647,
-0.39548853039741516,
-0.365103542804718,
-0.3854723870754242,
0.8309316039085388,
-0.3309984505176544,
-0.209755077958107,
0.2116365283727646,
0.046284839510917664,
0.22978301346302032,
-0.1422855257987976,
-0.6426328420639038,
0.3297373950481415,
-0.23670096695423126,
0.03633780777454376,
0.3244986832141876,
0.37476322054862976,
0.12882350385189056,
0.5837644338607788,
0.4972603917121887,
0.10978203266859055,
-0.05907563865184784,
0.18319544196128845,
0.7893425226211548,
-0.3083549737930298,
-0.07886003702878952,
-0.6370454430580139,
0.47100865840911865,
0.0028461271431297064,
0.09872689098119736,
0.3981953561306,
0.4359610378742218,
0.5848103165626526,
-0.15781427919864655,
0.4368724524974823,
-0.026574021205306053,
0.4671339690685272,
-0.6950666308403015,
0.4214916229248047,
-0.6995785236358643,
0.3273099660873413,
-0.5385345816612244,
-0.6407511234283447,
-0.6206371784210205,
0.5527899265289307,
-0.27812278270721436,
-0.17456120252609253,
0.3042161166667938,
1.428541660308838,
-0.13354907929897308,
-0.4196881353855133,
0.5157966017723083,
0.13157027959823608,
0.07464785128831863,
0.06996633112430573,
1.1291611194610596,
-0.4630405604839325,
0.7993436455726624,
0.04737101495265961,
-0.4833691716194153,
-0.027338353917002678,
-0.8941106200218201,
-0.05806783586740494,
-0.756819486618042,
-0.6652863621711731,
-0.4317705035209656,
0.09606222808361053,
0.5507791042327881,
0.764338493347168,
-0.549558699131012,
0.5794079899787903,
-0.27181172370910645,
-0.1720111221075058,
-0.2643822133541107,
-0.3437626361846924,
0.4655664563179016,
-0.5569024682044983,
-0.5057745575904846,
0.15828070044517517,
0.6034882664680481,
0.3977460563182831,
-0.37594568729400635,
-0.23095010221004486,
-0.028445877134799957,
-0.186488538980484,
0.6409431099891663,
0.22555993497371674,
-0.888562798500061,
-0.3311358392238617,
0.04022538661956787,
-0.1869199424982071,
0.05372914299368858,
0.4393991529941559,
-1.0723484754562378,
0.3636821508407593,
0.6674535870552063,
0.3345317244529724,
0.15685124695301056,
0.16564524173736572,
0.3668363392353058,
-0.6597561240196228,
0.14740240573883057,
0.11893293261528015,
0.43872949481010437,
0.5774247646331787,
-0.46738430857658386,
0.34114503860473633,
0.3992575407028198,
-0.599865734577179,
-0.7055677175521851,
0.25901272892951965,
-1.0193809270858765,
-0.3353903591632843,
1.0688034296035767,
-0.3914712071418762,
0.03154144063591957,
-0.23385213315486908,
-0.911702573299408,
0.1750330626964569,
-0.5107230544090271,
0.6131487488746643,
0.4678231477737427,
0.036573950201272964,
-0.6648592948913574,
-0.11664798110723495,
0.3335943818092346,
0.3650129437446594,
-0.5076104998588562,
0.24482126533985138,
1.0236057043075562,
-0.062132880091667175,
0.6095738410949707,
0.499301552772522,
-0.5751277804374695,
0.29440832138061523,
-0.010976726189255714,
0.05111142620444298,
0.08565971255302429,
-0.3019261956214905,
-0.3620588183403015,
0.12321119755506516,
0.045776668936014175,
-0.12593822181224823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16469v1 | Evaluating Visual and Cultural Interpretation: The K-Viscuit Benchmark with Human-VLM Collaboration | 2024-06-24T09:18:15 | 2024-06-24T09:18:15 | Yujin Baek, ChaeHun Park, Jaeseok Kim, Yu-Jung Heo, Du-Seong Chang, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | To create culturally inclusive vision-language models (VLMs), the foremost
requirement is developing a test benchmark that can diagnose the models'
ability to respond to questions reflecting cultural elements. This paper
addresses the necessity for such benchmarks, noting that existing research has
relied on human annotators' manual efforts, which impedes diversity and
efficiency. We propose a semi-automated pipeline for constructing cultural VLM
benchmarks to enhance diversity and efficiency. This pipeline leverages
human-VLM collaboration, where VLMs generate questions based on guidelines,
human-annotated examples, and image-wise relevant knowledge, which are then
reviewed by native speakers for quality and cultural relevance. The
effectiveness of our adaptable pipeline is demonstrated through a specific
application: creating a dataset tailored to Korean culture, dubbed K-Viscuit.
The resulting benchmark features two types of questions: Type 1 questions
measure visual recognition abilities, while Type 2 assess fine-grained visual
reasoning skills. This ensures a thorough diagnosis of VLM models across
various aspects. Our evaluation using K-Viscuit revealed that open-source
models notably lag behind proprietary models in understanding Korean culture,
highlighting areas for improvement. We provided diverse analyses of VLM
performance across different cultural aspects. Besides, we explored the
potential of incorporating external knowledge retrieval to enhance the
generation process, suggesting future directions for improving cultural
interpretation ability of VLMs. Our dataset and code will be made publicly
available. | [
-0.488305926322937,
0.032125942409038544,
0.4185654819011688,
0.184224471449852,
-0.3238171339035034,
0.1973465383052826,
-0.5015372037887573,
-0.9324943423271179,
-0.058428630232810974,
0.6488113403320312,
-0.4649006724357605,
-0.67118239402771,
-0.2790799140930176,
0.1309906393289566,
-0.07917819917201996,
0.4126354157924652,
-0.20133045315742493,
0.3931529223918915,
-0.340644896030426,
-0.5728945136070251,
-0.6101240515708923,
-0.19625788927078247,
0.011882108636200428,
-0.1231718510389328,
0.02306130900979042,
0.3586183786392212,
0.5857817530632019,
0.7021297216415405,
0.5815389156341553,
0.26840850710868835,
-0.07153656333684921,
0.2286756932735443,
-0.5171375274658203,
0.18854868412017822,
-0.1404716670513153,
-0.5156769752502441,
-0.040311284363269806,
0.00010754488903330639,
0.29787006974220276,
0.8100082874298096,
0.11515350639820099,
0.8953649997711182,
-0.0983736515045166,
0.4996238946914673,
-0.7290476560592651,
0.3659512996673584,
-0.5903134942054749,
0.3224746286869049,
-0.15808723866939545,
0.02493710070848465,
-0.2265995889902115,
-0.5535836815834045,
0.2426234632730484,
-0.4787532389163971,
0.04178399220108986,
0.07465281337499619,
0.839131236076355,
0.3798249363899231,
-0.4510594606399536,
-0.09123098105192184,
-0.6761189103126526,
0.8020126819610596,
-0.45192834734916687,
0.6910367608070374,
0.3535958230495453,
0.8464108109474182,
0.1318662315607071,
-0.9635308980941772,
-0.37010714411735535,
-0.3502458333969116,
-0.031072301790118217,
0.41100451350212097,
0.032670263200998306,
-0.42604732513427734,
0.2113347053527832,
0.3678753674030304,
-0.6008071899414062,
-0.12038559466600418,
-0.6549203395843506,
-0.6002986431121826,
0.685709536075592,
0.6253862977027893,
0.3879448175430298,
-0.43117430806159973,
-0.3692586421966553,
-0.19269618391990662,
-0.3421526849269867,
0.40710580348968506,
0.11155124008655548,
0.1308871954679489,
-0.027298109605908394,
0.5948145389556885,
-0.7346160411834717,
0.7401973605155945,
-0.48657670617103577,
-0.014007736928761005,
0.3742423355579376,
-0.6872887015342712,
-0.17182545363903046,
-0.20382076501846313,
0.5113927721977234,
1.0638140439987183,
0.6393872499465942,
-0.11887755244970322,
0.07277733087539673,
0.38429832458496094,
0.27729129791259766,
-0.6924641728401184,
-0.4100317656993866,
-0.05758338049054146,
-0.86761474609375,
-0.27513957023620605,
0.018354663625359535,
-0.9338666796684265,
-0.6058458089828491,
-0.5604863166809082,
0.16207687556743622,
-0.17815929651260376,
-0.42489349842071533,
-0.00504657719284296,
-0.5023508667945862,
0.36532920598983765,
0.3176704943180084,
-0.5085832476615906,
0.05278398469090462,
0.3301035165786743,
0.45718470215797424,
-0.0820271298289299,
-0.3176959455013275,
-0.4138672649860382,
-0.12700611352920532,
-0.3622741103172302,
0.5671905875205994,
-0.4935409426689148,
-0.2977307140827179,
0.04570018872618675,
0.20535682141780853,
0.2758820354938507,
-0.8126834630966187,
0.585079550743103,
-0.3618853986263275,
0.06227456033229828,
-0.7224804162979126,
-0.11537648737430573,
-0.22552084922790527,
0.22157606482505798,
-0.4353846311569214,
0.878366231918335,
0.41424599289894104,
-0.49490684270858765,
0.9491655230522156,
-0.20452441275119781,
-0.08227314800024033,
0.6721006035804749,
-0.5693994760513306,
0.045406587421894073,
0.170252725481987,
0.3052060604095459,
0.19461271166801453,
-0.4267938733100891,
0.004641251638531685,
-0.4677516520023346,
-0.3890540897846222,
-0.10857681930065155,
-0.16598805785179138,
0.9878731966018677,
0.26947465538978577,
-0.4020310044288635,
0.18212708830833435,
-1.0294870138168335,
0.4465738534927368,
0.2517409026622772,
-0.20820415019989014,
-0.48987695574760437,
-0.21554772555828094,
0.22610847651958466,
0.43512120842933655,
0.2829275131225586,
-0.2757309675216675,
-0.005434872582554817,
0.056585878133773804,
0.07349754124879837,
0.6880183219909668,
-0.2788189649581909,
0.18200089037418365,
0.12926813960075378,
0.6039283275604248,
-0.05567454174160957,
0.5555463433265686,
-0.00012469592911656946,
-0.5912662744522095,
-0.6301673650741577,
-0.3181992173194885,
0.10014951229095459,
0.4610958695411682,
-1.0008766651153564,
-0.08389009535312653,
-0.2119305580854416,
-0.7473272681236267,
-0.9919034838676453,
0.31850314140319824,
0.41330355405807495,
0.7547944784164429,
0.24625355005264282,
-0.7380293011665344,
-0.6394490599632263,
-0.8783206343650818,
-0.303367555141449,
-0.4243093430995941,
-0.3325689435005188,
0.5208879709243774,
0.2394084930419922,
-0.023911627009510994,
0.8225498199462891,
-0.35491153597831726,
-0.07156914472579956,
0.02846585586667061,
0.2000158578157425,
0.10988809913396835,
-0.08510449528694153,
0.5260046124458313,
-0.9454054236412048,
-0.7074825167655945,
0.2763154208660126,
-1.2035856246948242,
-0.41056114435195923,
0.4705459475517273,
-0.25160878896713257,
0.05303187295794487,
0.43381384015083313,
0.01492663286626339,
0.6242589950561523,
0.4414328932762146,
-0.6258191466331482,
0.7220422029495239,
-0.042000703513622284,
0.3487774729728699,
-0.528644859790802,
0.048060182482004166,
-0.047799792140722275,
-0.09850634634494781,
-0.4856836795806885,
0.20173044502735138,
0.3762495815753937,
-0.14503361284732819,
-0.5622203350067139,
0.5609328150749207,
-0.5022490620613098,
-0.3332139253616333,
0.028149833902716637,
0.06920631974935532,
-0.01615631952881813,
0.38436973094940186,
0.33415284752845764,
0.45938220620155334,
0.5259014964103699,
-0.3727431893348694,
0.45103564858436584,
0.15422162413597107,
-0.6991914510726929,
0.9327232241630554,
-0.43644124269485474,
-0.020828308537602425,
-0.23390446603298187,
-0.2510795593261719,
-0.8916277289390564,
-0.1442594826221466,
0.29358959197998047,
-0.16818317770957947,
-0.27329781651496887,
-0.35382336378097534,
-0.21844549477100372,
-0.5725314617156982,
-0.34412047266960144,
0.34539178013801575,
0.8327328562736511,
-0.5920243859291077,
0.6274505853652954,
0.17718768119812012,
0.14499858021736145,
-0.4525330364704132,
-0.45790597796440125,
0.05095153674483299,
-0.2668771743774414,
-1.011736512184143,
-0.02617538347840309,
-0.12488892674446106,
-0.3973710238933563,
0.14715337753295898,
-0.15947136282920837,
0.16083958745002747,
-0.0010215949732810259,
0.11657144129276276,
0.3815229535102844,
-0.5257276892662048,
-0.27835702896118164,
-0.554881751537323,
0.03655703365802765,
0.0033109006471931934,
-0.3898918032646179,
0.4316185712814331,
-0.367738276720047,
-0.41652366518974304,
-0.11120438575744629,
0.21742123365402222,
0.8071573972702026,
-0.7028725743293762,
0.3889630436897278,
1.1476713418960571,
-0.09244436770677567,
-0.03924601152539253,
-0.5505445599555969,
0.0943235233426094,
-0.42291519045829773,
0.3355344533920288,
-0.3715786635875702,
-0.5487987399101257,
0.7262066006660461,
-0.11358806490898132,
-0.12212026864290237,
0.11262333393096924,
0.8020496368408203,
-0.11007468402385712,
0.9843461513519287,
0.6378678679466248,
0.1758628636598587,
0.36656782031059265,
-0.07256633788347244,
-0.10399841517210007,
-0.7821547985076904,
-0.3347017467021942,
-0.31775468587875366,
-0.2520054578781128,
-0.672983705997467,
-0.5299569368362427,
0.4858447313308716,
-0.011869857087731361,
0.041664447635412216,
0.26447322964668274,
-0.4603478014469147,
0.3292987644672394,
0.662056028842926,
-0.15761905908584595,
0.35060250759124756,
-0.1865852177143097,
-0.3031601011753082,
-0.2578434944152832,
-0.430867463350296,
-0.6102549433708191,
1.1387792825698853,
0.25320562720298767,
0.6594616770744324,
0.10018600523471832,
0.33954837918281555,
0.20411334931850433,
0.245585098862648,
-0.5483856201171875,
0.6507015228271484,
-0.12283492088317871,
-0.5061066150665283,
-0.1851814091205597,
-0.2586853504180908,
-0.4975617825984955,
0.4782255291938782,
-0.03700230270624161,
-1.0211656093597412,
0.3413982093334198,
0.07787630707025528,
-0.06581316143274307,
-0.10890889167785645,
-0.9744351506233215,
1.1916308403015137,
-0.29729047417640686,
-0.3439476788043976,
0.19840766489505768,
-0.7175502181053162,
0.5108224749565125,
0.06242533028125763,
0.08109134435653687,
-0.2681683301925659,
0.14628173410892487,
0.33562782406806946,
-0.15737509727478027,
0.6615878343582153,
-0.3590605556964874,
0.2243540734052658,
0.1819203794002533,
0.044753290712833405,
0.1855715811252594,
-0.027572661638259888,
-0.052116960287094116,
0.38690993189811707,
0.23589810729026794,
-0.3922865092754364,
-0.5478204488754272,
0.21175824105739594,
-0.6222882866859436,
-0.3154242932796478,
0.09796950221061707,
-0.5929074287414551,
-0.42095619440078735,
0.10729433596134186,
0.1349111944437027,
0.4505689740180969,
0.09392046928405762,
0.24939090013504028,
0.1858804076910019,
-0.2954957187175751,
0.05655881389975548,
0.710270345211029,
-0.5501188635826111,
-0.22907456755638123,
0.9075093269348145,
0.12557169795036316,
0.4610818922519684,
-0.17905940115451813,
0.2630489468574524,
-0.27123841643333435,
-0.6440848112106323,
-0.7315321564674377,
-0.12071143835783005,
-1.1540156602859497,
0.21815724670886993,
-0.4270879626274109,
-0.08646931499242783,
-0.34726250171661377,
0.10265782475471497,
-0.22324799001216888,
0.008811709471046925,
0.14846459031105042,
0.18402709066867828,
0.12837935984134674,
0.5303680896759033,
0.00471880380064249,
-0.2793968915939331,
-0.5807415246963501,
0.4930482804775238,
0.3625935912132263,
0.523690938949585,
0.05372856184840202,
-0.3688012957572937,
-0.23021580278873444,
-0.2702690660953522,
0.07209912687540054,
-0.5817990303039551,
0.1500522345304489,
-0.20699986815452576,
0.8016091585159302,
0.23063920438289642,
0.17621928453445435,
0.9059239625930786,
-0.41703981161117554,
0.808413028717041,
-0.058815207332372665,
-0.6680673956871033,
0.4365765452384949,
-0.0546925812959671,
0.5552012920379639,
0.7858831882476807,
0.33346912264823914,
-0.7625281810760498,
-0.6800644397735596,
-0.1464139223098755,
-0.8285223245620728,
0.5134438872337341,
0.13082799315452576,
-0.1657296121120453,
0.17438827455043793,
-0.24124063551425934,
0.1704457700252533,
0.1590999960899353,
-0.4412262439727783,
-0.07287980616092682,
-0.4025347828865051,
-0.26850587129592896,
0.055624641478061676,
-0.04966490715742111,
-0.0734405517578125,
-0.4899497330188751,
0.2127632200717926,
-0.2425210028886795,
-0.17564040422439575,
0.17706871032714844,
-0.39667198061943054,
-0.16014651954174042,
-0.14338332414627075,
0.48808997869491577,
1.0257444381713867,
-0.3632204234600067,
-0.024651212617754936,
0.18052822351455688,
-0.5907309055328369,
-0.16148126125335693,
-0.030088823288679123,
-0.22090870141983032,
0.007563948631286621,
0.47915390133857727,
0.804322361946106,
-0.1851413995027542,
-1.0026366710662842,
0.30318060517311096,
-0.5300787687301636,
0.025743762031197548,
-0.34556180238723755,
0.004979412537068129,
0.10507718473672867,
0.6097105741500854,
0.2316417247056961,
-0.009197999723255634,
0.11455625295639038,
-0.6962345838546753,
0.21441322565078735,
0.3664391338825226,
-0.5969957709312439,
-0.13563796877861023,
0.7927443385124207,
0.19198989868164062,
-0.29277563095092773,
0.6796145439147949,
-0.2886117994785309,
-0.6439194679260254,
0.6040401458740234,
0.056731339544057846,
0.5670756697654724,
0.05523976311087608,
0.33796748518943787,
0.23077552020549774,
0.4927685558795929,
0.23262260854244232,
0.6149621605873108,
-0.19267824292182922,
-0.6531862020492554,
-0.25538089871406555,
-0.6610130667686462,
-0.32320135831832886,
-0.018145788460969925,
-0.8721053004264832,
0.575228214263916,
-0.14935725927352905,
0.06704181432723999,
0.015568636357784271,
-0.15273992717266083,
-1.0879260301589966,
0.2386770099401474,
0.5926206111907959,
0.9707263708114624,
-0.9983875751495361,
0.550283670425415,
0.8336620926856995,
-0.5455940365791321,
-0.743244469165802,
0.05417893826961517,
0.18217210471630096,
-1.0747568607330322,
0.8931946754455566,
0.003831060603260994,
0.1143026202917099,
-0.3482656478881836,
-0.2721855938434601,
-0.692635715007782,
1.276774287223816,
0.2331579178571701,
-0.35951149463653564,
0.35591116547584534,
0.2464413046836853,
0.8658438324928284,
-0.2379317730665207,
0.3811269998550415,
0.622310996055603,
0.5310569405555725,
0.1797957420349121,
-1.1375651359558105,
-0.0344318188726902,
-0.4078387916088104,
0.09914025664329529,
0.13065758347511292,
-0.5363832712173462,
0.6338313817977905,
0.031689904630184174,
-0.05676984041929245,
0.0038171829655766487,
0.5717776417732239,
0.2244148701429367,
0.6137803196907043,
0.6589186787605286,
0.1611490696668625,
0.7776879072189331,
0.0491749569773674,
1.0243792533874512,
-0.285013884305954,
0.13542740046977997,
1.0148104429244995,
-0.4360729157924652,
0.5991731286048889,
0.5325593948364258,
-0.18236324191093445,
0.16283491253852844,
0.4880679249763489,
-0.3277561068534851,
0.599898636341095,
0.42592349648475647,
-0.028529375791549683,
-0.3582916259765625,
-0.577759861946106,
-0.33665892481803894,
0.9314760565757751,
-0.05945175513625145,
-0.4330453872680664,
-0.22320343554019928,
0.051712580025196075,
-0.38781172037124634,
0.1801113784313202,
-0.396889328956604,
0.5117447972297668,
-0.17642909288406372,
-0.6373685002326965,
0.6141185760498047,
-0.39406338334083557,
0.5020930171012878,
-0.513617217540741,
0.006657720543444157,
-0.25467821955680847,
0.02530641295015812,
0.002234657993540168,
-0.8083425760269165,
0.10131635516881943,
0.09702168405056,
-0.08675006777048111,
-0.11190567910671234,
0.8887348175048828,
-0.3776054382324219,
-0.678709089756012,
0.4384082853794098,
0.6211736798286438,
0.26729878783226013,
0.18139049410820007,
-0.4239360988140106,
0.32120993733406067,
0.11216428875923157,
-0.03482941910624504,
0.19143541157245636,
0.42637667059898376,
-0.505413293838501,
0.5565275549888611,
0.3982296586036682,
0.1699153333902359,
0.2517894208431244,
0.45980724692344666,
0.5618246793746948,
-0.552608847618103,
-0.29403555393218994,
-0.7360517978668213,
0.7934337258338928,
-0.40169334411621094,
-0.35568222403526306,
0.6963433623313904,
0.2009657919406891,
1.3341528177261353,
-0.34763067960739136,
0.789017379283905,
-0.2107967734336853,
0.14766031503677368,
-0.3190188407897949,
0.7757526636123657,
-0.7369782328605652,
-0.078476183116436,
-0.4255572557449341,
-0.7107725739479065,
0.06403262913227081,
0.2560814619064331,
-0.28904464840888977,
-0.05549776181578636,
0.44424641132354736,
0.6385102868080139,
-0.15524141490459442,
0.1961660534143448,
0.6195751428604126,
0.0351325124502182,
0.2710493206977844,
0.4174053966999054,
1.2778922319412231,
-0.12294644862413406,
0.7216634154319763,
-0.6652643084526062,
-0.18498751521110535,
-0.15992821753025055,
-1.0015712976455688,
-0.9044419527053833,
-0.7021199464797974,
-0.25105297565460205,
-0.06492122262716293,
-0.19246608018875122,
0.8559101223945618,
0.7542160749435425,
-0.5602420568466187,
-0.28978198766708374,
0.5015354752540588,
-0.12635795772075653,
-0.37274834513664246,
-0.22323589026927948,
0.1306236833333969,
-0.057476647198200226,
-0.6046457886695862,
0.10087637603282928,
0.49406760931015015,
-0.2212991863489151,
-0.5231068730354309,
-0.02969460003077984,
0.37938937544822693,
-0.28031912446022034,
0.7751634120941162,
0.15768727660179138,
-0.8393797874450684,
-0.44933021068573,
0.1997654139995575,
0.12641623616218567,
-0.19776298105716705,
0.5325021743774414,
-0.664654016494751,
0.9436597228050232,
0.46567466855049133,
0.648733377456665,
0.3167920708656311,
-0.11869072169065475,
0.6702648401260376,
-0.395679235458374,
0.1407952755689621,
0.35305118560791016,
0.3830498456954956,
0.35540318489074707,
-0.0923600047826767,
0.7859251499176025,
0.3762194812297821,
-0.26212581992149353,
-0.9998019933700562,
0.27327480912208557,
-0.8857916593551636,
-0.020761962980031967,
0.9581300020217896,
-0.17688247561454773,
-0.3878554105758667,
-0.322454035282135,
-0.33829256892204285,
0.020465409383177757,
0.1998126357793808,
0.7161792516708374,
0.911780059337616,
0.03390778228640556,
-0.06981029361486435,
-1.040144443511963,
0.2836861312389374,
0.3401281237602234,
-0.6373022198677063,
0.1097821593284607,
0.4375300705432892,
0.31559574604034424,
0.09148141741752625,
0.5335543155670166,
-0.20554114878177643,
0.5353940725326538,
-0.018616918474435806,
0.20860126614570618,
-0.05829250440001488,
-0.22057704627513885,
-0.11677438020706177,
0.04224580153822899,
0.16756770014762878,
-0.2813710570335388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16464v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16464v2 | InterCLIP-MEP: Interactive CLIP and Memory-Enhanced Predictor for Multi-modal Sarcasm Detection | 2024-06-24T09:13:42 | 2024-06-26T05:40:16 | Junjie Chen, Subin Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | The prevalence of sarcasm in social media, conveyed through text-image
combinations, presents significant challenges for sentiment analysis and
intention mining. Current multi-modal sarcasm detection methods have been
proven to struggle with biases from spurious cues, leading to a superficial
understanding of the complex interactions between text and image. To address
these issues, we propose InterCLIP-MEP, a robust framework for multi-modal
sarcasm detection. InterCLIP-MEP introduces a refined variant of CLIP,
Interactive CLIP (InterCLIP), as the backbone, enhancing sample representations
by embedding cross-modality information in each encoder. Furthermore, a novel
training strategy is designed to adapt InterCLIP for a Memory-Enhanced
Predictor (MEP). MEP uses dynamic dual-channel memory to store valuable
historical knowledge of test samples and then leverages this memory as a
non-parametric classifier to derive the final prediction. By using InterCLIP to
encode text-image interactions more effectively and incorporating MEP,
InterCLIP-MEP offers a more robust recognition of multi-modal sarcasm.
Experiments demonstrate that InterCLIP-MEP achieves state-of-the-art
performance on the MMSD2.0 benchmark. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/CoderChen01/InterCLIP-MEP. | [
-0.5954901576042175,
-0.44194623827934265,
0.2460932731628418,
0.6320973038673401,
-0.3963930904865265,
0.3568001091480255,
-0.14929014444351196,
-0.24408681690692902,
0.637069046497345,
-0.1798354983329773,
-0.8065298199653625,
-0.1861896812915802,
-0.5863319635391235,
-0.06267829984426498,
0.003266680520027876,
0.8893473148345947,
0.21093006432056427,
0.3458060622215271,
-0.13811558485031128,
-0.031247423961758614,
-0.5603760480880737,
-0.6268012523651123,
-0.3776426315307617,
0.0996418297290802,
0.17435643076896667,
0.43127262592315674,
0.5823328495025635,
-0.1274978369474411,
0.5446822643280029,
0.18405888974666595,
0.26538583636283875,
0.3747568130493164,
-0.09165127575397491,
0.12081112712621689,
-0.07561258971691132,
-0.3217608630657196,
-0.322147399187088,
-0.011621407233178616,
0.2636493742465973,
-0.3036985397338867,
0.31587356328964233,
0.1995205134153366,
-0.17421270906925201,
0.14654342830181122,
-0.9179599285125732,
0.20074377954006195,
-0.641815721988678,
0.04173624515533447,
-0.23427431285381317,
-0.9496920704841614,
-0.44156795740127563,
-0.10340099781751633,
-0.14898808300495148,
-0.149946391582489,
-0.1479583978652954,
-0.08025597035884857,
0.4599841237068176,
0.362160325050354,
-0.3012382686138153,
-0.25976067781448364,
-0.5399876832962036,
0.6307662129402161,
-0.7313672304153442,
0.06648017466068268,
0.09903764724731445,
0.5668505430221558,
0.03871719166636467,
-0.46973171830177307,
-0.5682334303855896,
-0.1466316431760788,
0.1546359807252884,
0.34460192918777466,
-0.007909391075372696,
0.17457881569862366,
0.35899972915649414,
-0.04872763156890869,
-0.3818848729133606,
-0.20782151818275452,
-0.20679627358913422,
-0.2778277099132538,
0.1226920336484909,
0.021082846447825432,
0.5240973830223083,
-0.36007270216941833,
-0.7890126705169678,
-0.08163811266422272,
-0.16070467233657837,
0.35388991236686707,
0.4304448962211609,
-0.07500375807285309,
0.02303503081202507,
0.471987247467041,
0.006951102986931801,
0.07231947034597397,
-0.050472959876060486,
-0.4873192608356476,
0.19286353886127472,
-0.27848148345947266,
0.16427063941955566,
-0.07634953409433365,
0.6232101917266846,
0.6199811697006226,
0.29037708044052124,
0.2402440309524536,
-0.02101052738726139,
0.289831280708313,
-0.0891953855752945,
-0.8676679730415344,
-0.3898470997810364,
-0.003415627870708704,
-0.3778078258037567,
-0.15189878642559052,
0.47432395815849304,
-0.8778603076934814,
0.1815256029367447,
-0.11253362894058228,
0.25759732723236084,
-0.7246690988540649,
-0.19966450333595276,
0.051302239298820496,
-0.7454517483711243,
-0.04836297780275345,
0.3832075297832489,
-0.6975544095039368,
0.25590595602989197,
0.6168777942657471,
0.9482463598251343,
0.05198260769248009,
-0.5327438712120056,
-0.5458199381828308,
0.35504207015037537,
0.4326075315475464,
0.8322573304176331,
-0.7570485472679138,
-0.05792040750384331,
-0.12742571532726288,
-0.25638052821159363,
-0.17534875869750977,
-0.3176044225692749,
0.7546018958091736,
-0.27858591079711914,
0.06469924747943878,
-0.3364107608795166,
-0.20311467349529266,
-0.2515650689601898,
0.4470873177051544,
-0.7426938414573669,
1.0966230630874634,
0.23513546586036682,
-1.0905033349990845,
0.2854771912097931,
-0.5767516493797302,
-0.263042151927948,
-0.02424883469939232,
-0.40213754773139954,
-0.17619332671165466,
0.0897984430193901,
0.4123522639274597,
0.5075482726097107,
-0.4250221252441406,
0.3694681227207184,
-0.8926278352737427,
-0.5565266013145447,
0.6464117765426636,
-0.9060443043708801,
0.5944526791572571,
-0.02100960537791252,
-0.29487982392311096,
-0.1305323839187622,
-0.263223797082901,
0.28741246461868286,
-0.18832345306873322,
-0.2638550400733948,
-0.38523170351982117,
-0.35617518424987793,
0.17920035123825073,
0.8475103974342346,
0.140433669090271,
-0.4533848464488983,
0.06767996400594711,
0.23250168561935425,
0.5144498348236084,
0.7871981859207153,
-0.11262719333171844,
0.18617704510688782,
-0.30365532636642456,
0.7962928414344788,
0.15919175744056702,
0.5347820520401001,
-0.5141685605049133,
-0.3574768602848053,
-0.34197500348091125,
-0.8506497740745544,
0.2173372209072113,
0.7559056282043457,
-0.9071022272109985,
0.32854336500167847,
-0.4435419738292694,
-0.09566662460565567,
-0.2954482436180115,
-0.23751725256443024,
0.5163391828536987,
0.4067821800708771,
0.5545153021812439,
-0.3681888282299042,
-0.3387618362903595,
-0.8554683327674866,
-0.4347652494907379,
-0.08343132585287094,
0.11141107976436615,
0.3888252079486847,
0.3739892542362213,
-0.08783275634050369,
0.734246015548706,
-0.47673580050468445,
-0.35322853922843933,
-0.09755778312683105,
0.39375054836273193,
-0.174056276679039,
0.38087183237075806,
0.9420897960662842,
-0.733662486076355,
-0.6876024603843689,
-0.4536816477775574,
-0.4294913113117218,
-0.2341168373823166,
-0.2733306884765625,
0.0073168338276445866,
-0.08108023554086685,
0.5870383381843567,
-0.6872017979621887,
0.44884952902793884,
0.4034488797187805,
-0.2380780279636383,
0.8359745740890503,
0.05746185779571533,
0.6735309958457947,
-0.7337999939918518,
-0.060889728367328644,
-0.14331801235675812,
-0.3527386784553528,
-0.259743869304657,
-0.2688131332397461,
0.0993252694606781,
-0.03153156861662865,
-0.5622152090072632,
0.48280274868011475,
-0.391380250453949,
-0.1026504784822464,
-0.14595380425453186,
-0.12504875659942627,
0.12681521475315094,
0.5584147572517395,
-0.40549448132514954,
0.8148750066757202,
0.29147806763648987,
-0.18037256598472595,
0.1797304004430771,
-0.00802088063210249,
0.01990598253905773,
0.8371056914329529,
-0.15708832442760468,
-0.0647488534450531,
0.04808848351240158,
0.534072756767273,
-1.123009443283081,
-0.4620378613471985,
0.36220163106918335,
-0.730443000793457,
0.4448849558830261,
-0.18040335178375244,
-0.6414851546287537,
-0.5964318513870239,
-1.0719295740127563,
0.8155434131622314,
0.1344785988330841,
-0.6864064931869507,
0.709601640701294,
0.3035750985145569,
-0.185566246509552,
-0.9576795697212219,
-0.7507733702659607,
0.04353624954819679,
-0.2699951231479645,
-0.7129732370376587,
0.4462032914161682,
-0.34161195158958435,
0.2555035352706909,
-0.07188735157251358,
-0.03199657052755356,
-0.41334372758865356,
-0.0992526039481163,
0.33856436610221863,
0.30743834376335144,
0.01684516668319702,
0.2849164307117462,
0.5423774719238281,
-0.2547595202922821,
-0.021415600553154945,
0.19283698499202728,
0.8098238706588745,
-0.21075406670570374,
-0.6566938161849976,
-0.7129945158958435,
0.42323780059814453,
0.7775176763534546,
0.0575682669878006,
0.06618040055036545,
0.8741269707679749,
-0.23789054155349731,
-0.33912360668182373,
-0.6320235133171082,
-0.39262256026268005,
-0.49026188254356384,
0.2647629380226135,
-0.45390740036964417,
-0.5911374688148499,
0.33721300959587097,
-0.6097481846809387,
-0.37425634264945984,
-0.10993018746376038,
0.2751238942146301,
-0.10640770941972733,
1.1787190437316895,
0.3354809284210205,
-0.19596050679683685,
0.7075893878936768,
0.08389028906822205,
0.30512535572052,
-0.8407301306724548,
-0.1611071676015854,
0.12439767271280289,
-0.690180778503418,
0.05916660651564598,
-0.9366251826286316,
0.46974092721939087,
0.18406008183956146,
-0.0037053164560347795,
0.009997154586017132,
-0.36062681674957275,
0.705775797367096,
0.6130274534225464,
0.30038774013519287,
0.28799474239349365,
-0.14859400689601898,
0.119161456823349,
-0.5285274386405945,
-0.3845410645008087,
-0.3183586299419403,
0.7853999733924866,
0.31042635440826416,
0.7382219433784485,
0.000386544648790732,
0.284661203622818,
0.548245906829834,
0.09658737480640411,
-0.7552825212478638,
0.7177342772483826,
-0.29765400290489197,
-0.354846328496933,
0.3674773573875427,
-0.04975021630525589,
0.04059027507901192,
0.13691489398479462,
-0.3033370077610016,
-0.3437819182872772,
-0.06769219785928726,
0.4670153558254242,
-0.1830519139766693,
0.26468563079833984,
-0.5917964577674866,
0.5925925374031067,
-0.7160484790802002,
-0.08134928345680237,
-0.4439300298690796,
-1.0357768535614014,
0.5694636106491089,
0.35236024856567383,
0.028501076623797417,
-0.4536634087562561,
-0.10042034834623337,
0.21858401596546173,
-0.18831031024456024,
0.89797043800354,
-0.30659252405166626,
0.745029866695404,
0.4230461120605469,
0.1536082923412323,
0.1158003881573677,
0.2647266983985901,
-0.028753597289323807,
0.08449241518974304,
0.09052297472953796,
-0.103640116751194,
-0.6046508550643921,
0.767449140548706,
-0.4233172535896301,
-0.014538750983774662,
-0.4061352014541626,
-0.6563522815704346,
-0.029219795018434525,
-0.023699386045336723,
0.26790764927864075,
0.5961220264434814,
-0.24929973483085632,
-0.0029996943194419146,
0.33067193627357483,
0.017006291076540947,
0.5711480379104614,
0.0018062529852613807,
-0.0038919541984796524,
-0.8351737856864929,
0.9019665122032166,
0.01369681116193533,
0.26072466373443604,
0.4104142189025879,
0.11834153532981873,
-0.15749648213386536,
-0.018556443974375725,
-0.3892238438129425,
0.19046208262443542,
-1.0965909957885742,
-0.5114250779151917,
-0.6470080018043518,
-0.054255954921245575,
-0.22027334570884705,
-0.47501176595687866,
-0.2619691789150238,
-0.9398097395896912,
-0.5763159394264221,
0.024233099073171616,
0.22750939428806305,
-0.024470455944538116,
-0.14676432311534882,
0.505914568901062,
-0.5675785541534424,
0.15489426255226135,
0.036280419677495956,
0.1151999905705452,
-0.15391220152378082,
-0.2608870565891266,
0.23381924629211426,
-0.08563336730003357,
-0.4061237871646881,
-0.9374250769615173,
0.41168397665023804,
0.39558055996894836,
0.20963014662265778,
0.6450338363647461,
0.1695859283208847,
0.7910669445991516,
-0.11538844555616379,
0.46133625507354736,
0.5219559669494629,
-1.1545499563217163,
0.40291133522987366,
-0.32131320238113403,
0.1484348475933075,
0.8513818979263306,
0.353885293006897,
-0.2547338902950287,
-0.27147674560546875,
-0.5249536037445068,
-0.57258141040802,
0.6185929179191589,
-0.41340863704681396,
0.14390118420124054,
-0.14432667195796967,
0.4518381953239441,
0.19782263040542603,
0.5330415964126587,
-1.0165228843688965,
0.0482294037938118,
-0.27155041694641113,
-0.45498499274253845,
0.5192235708236694,
-0.4550281763076782,
-0.16000516712665558,
-0.40794867277145386,
0.3977150619029999,
-0.6332069635391235,
0.36914780735969543,
-0.018122214823961258,
-0.328512966632843,
0.16367395222187042,
0.21432805061340332,
0.39056697487831116,
0.224136084318161,
-0.19213362038135529,
0.52219557762146,
-0.02042335644364357,
-0.4221388101577759,
-0.07723918557167053,
-0.06310255080461502,
-0.15910841524600983,
0.06492730230093002,
0.05027236416935921,
0.5559241771697998,
0.5404966473579407,
-1.0329291820526123,
1.2327288389205933,
-0.03617798164486885,
-0.016707461327314377,
-0.4015744626522064,
-0.16644810140132904,
-0.2399722784757614,
0.4542752504348755,
0.07483883947134018,
0.6024118661880493,
0.5718636512756348,
-0.6078783273696899,
0.29580485820770264,
0.7768388986587524,
-0.5259494185447693,
-0.8733620643615723,
0.4139995872974396,
0.09663274884223938,
0.03531867638230324,
0.20341932773590088,
-0.28010091185569763,
-1.1331020593643188,
0.5831505656242371,
0.7568145394325256,
0.8529422283172607,
-0.3250831663608551,
0.5329273343086243,
0.22047582268714905,
0.3653254210948944,
-0.032418664544820786,
0.7285853028297424,
-0.15593016147613525,
-0.26483866572380066,
0.0115615613758564,
-0.13064725697040558,
-0.34952160716056824,
-0.26351839303970337,
-0.4516957700252533,
0.9497146606445312,
-0.9246028661727905,
-0.37237393856048584,
-0.2431308627128601,
-0.6167432069778442,
-0.5248309373855591,
0.035063736140728,
0.22224780917167664,
0.8597657084465027,
-0.9630735516548157,
0.5712815523147583,
0.42360371351242065,
-0.4286568760871887,
-0.3298918902873993,
0.34060341119766235,
0.1821582317352295,
-0.7129097580909729,
0.4245036244392395,
0.8546549081802368,
-0.5128560066223145,
-0.3069501519203186,
-0.6210293769836426,
-0.6107457876205444,
1.2088110446929932,
0.6439143419265747,
0.0650356113910675,
0.01683695800602436,
-0.05227286368608475,
0.2849763035774231,
-0.4697451889514923,
0.7778118848800659,
0.3242935240268707,
0.424982488155365,
0.24948248267173767,
-0.7028434872627258,
0.22516696155071259,
-0.2590945363044739,
-0.2385399043560028,
0.29070714116096497,
-1.008494257926941,
1.1904523372650146,
-0.36790192127227783,
-0.2917672097682953,
-0.15802372992038727,
0.32222095131874084,
0.07575096935033798,
0.6522024869918823,
0.43184390664100647,
0.5520856976509094,
0.4752550423145294,
0.0003764567372854799,
0.5982360243797302,
-0.451301634311676,
0.10416442155838013,
1.2349072694778442,
-0.05397897586226463,
1.026341199874878,
0.6545640230178833,
0.2529403567314148,
0.6849381923675537,
0.38123518228530884,
-0.03701033443212509,
0.6788247227668762,
-0.19863134622573853,
-0.4406973123550415,
-0.09829109162092209,
-0.2696714401245117,
-0.21596647799015045,
0.4260963797569275,
0.4895804226398468,
-0.3443963825702667,
-0.11317874491214752,
0.15848228335380554,
0.25339871644973755,
-0.27985018491744995,
-0.0989697128534317,
0.4057312607765198,
-0.10430734604597092,
-0.5812367796897888,
0.14121916890144348,
-0.16060948371887207,
1.086181402206421,
-0.5446336269378662,
-0.03325499966740608,
0.4706762135028839,
0.32898613810539246,
-0.28869038820266724,
-0.7391420602798462,
0.18404120206832886,
-0.48314017057418823,
-0.1195143386721611,
0.01400360930711031,
1.1832630634307861,
-0.43271711468696594,
-0.07655387371778488,
0.7337344288825989,
0.3004724085330963,
-0.0655059665441513,
-0.25624120235443115,
-1.0031076669692993,
0.1347653716802597,
-0.1193368062376976,
0.011337106116116047,
0.3136661946773529,
0.4656185805797577,
-0.0893930122256279,
0.6498308777809143,
0.589148759841919,
-0.38131436705589294,
0.29808667302131653,
0.17858119308948517,
1.256367802619934,
-0.46423304080963135,
-0.5921987295150757,
-1.0167936086654663,
0.5821251273155212,
-0.2760075032711029,
-0.4755469560623169,
0.520647406578064,
0.4235662519931793,
0.46158891916275024,
-0.2999550700187683,
0.8850736021995544,
-0.14166006445884705,
0.4605900049209595,
-0.2588275969028473,
-0.04350466653704643,
-0.41717568039894104,
0.15814493596553802,
-0.440987229347229,
-0.61490797996521,
-0.3610573410987854,
0.42658907175064087,
-0.1382589042186737,
-0.04371219500899315,
0.795473575592041,
0.5386605262756348,
-0.5554860234260559,
0.14397349953651428,
0.0005900422693230212,
-0.23042461276054382,
0.4295477867126465,
0.5441545844078064,
1.013777256011963,
-0.33717551827430725,
0.6347583532333374,
-0.3938155174255371,
-0.7068552374839783,
-0.6584493517875671,
-0.9289901256561279,
-1.0821471214294434,
-0.39005088806152344,
-0.06579817831516266,
-0.19196487963199615,
-0.35819393396377563,
1.1591486930847168,
0.4603850245475769,
-0.38453352451324463,
0.10801976919174194,
0.21430987119674683,
-0.1373908519744873,
-0.03811365365982056,
-0.26258954405784607,
-0.018959075212478638,
-0.12495145201683044,
-0.5503617525100708,
0.24161630868911743,
0.9757808446884155,
0.032117873430252075,
-0.1749555468559265,
0.1368991732597351,
-0.3054048418998718,
0.3025713860988617,
0.6648910045623779,
0.28292253613471985,
-0.6313285231590271,
-0.2640220522880554,
0.0800972655415535,
0.0840040072798729,
0.15964064002037048,
1.080194115638733,
-0.5897389054298401,
0.6381112337112427,
0.6544389724731445,
0.49026715755462646,
0.3667840361595154,
0.3124332129955292,
0.27651286125183105,
-0.8351453542709351,
0.5261877179145813,
0.5030689239501953,
0.4149935841560364,
0.4285528063774109,
-0.4198820888996124,
0.4001096189022064,
0.39348897337913513,
-0.4562670588493347,
-0.8895261883735657,
0.3441656231880188,
-1.238330364227295,
-0.3203968405723572,
0.9187048673629761,
-0.061727214604616165,
-0.04919824004173279,
-0.12885195016860962,
-0.5257564783096313,
-0.054738570004701614,
-0.706760823726654,
0.7191113829612732,
0.46197429299354553,
-0.3509463667869568,
-0.08620969951152802,
-0.4580859839916229,
0.42036139965057373,
0.44939959049224854,
-0.8481968641281128,
-0.09236887842416763,
0.6045086979866028,
0.11826251447200775,
0.24036814272403717,
1.0871303081512451,
-0.1548590213060379,
0.5130934119224548,
-0.15080086886882782,
-0.05991530045866966,
0.05662725493311882,
-0.8019372224807739,
-0.04015856236219406,
0.11508427560329437,
-0.19815890491008759,
-0.1480366289615631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16450v1 | Building on Efficient Foundations: Effectively Training LLMs with Structured Feedforward Layers | 2024-06-24T08:43:21 | 2024-06-24T08:43:21 | Xiuying Wei, Skander Moalla, Razvan Pascanu, Caglar Gulcehre | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art results in large language models (LLMs) often rely on scale,
which becomes computationally expensive. This has sparked a research agenda to
reduce these models' parameter count and computational costs without
significantly impacting their performance. Our study focuses on
transformer-based LLMs, specifically targeting the computationally intensive
feedforward networks (FFN), which are less studied than attention blocks. We
consider three candidate linear layer approximations in the FFN by combining
efficient low-rank and block-diagonal matrices. In contrast to many previous
works that examined these approximations, our study i) explores these
structures from the training-from-scratch perspective, ii) scales up to 1.3B
parameters, and iii) is conducted within recent Transformer-based LLMs rather
than convolutional architectures. We first demonstrate they can lead to actual
computational gains in various scenarios, including online decoding when using
a pre-merge technique. Additionally, we propose a novel training regime, called
\textit{self-guided training}, aimed at improving the poor training dynamics
that these approximations exhibit when used from initialization. Experiments on
the large RefinedWeb dataset show that our methods are both efficient and
effective for training and inference. Interestingly, these structured FFNs
exhibit steeper scaling curves than the original models. Further applying
self-guided training to the structured matrices with 32\% FFN parameters and
2.5$\times$ speed-up enables only a 0.4 perplexity increase under the same
training FLOPs. Finally, we develop the wide and structured networks surpassing
the current medium-sized and large-sized Transformer in perplexity and
throughput performance. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/CLAIRE-Labo/StructuredFFN/tree/main}. | [
-0.2658582329750061,
-0.43085625767707825,
0.2959176301956177,
0.6475369334220886,
0.035395365208387375,
0.062101028859615326,
-0.3171465992927551,
-0.29191067814826965,
0.17471690475940704,
0.4811018407344818,
-0.6607466340065002,
-0.04914079234004021,
-0.5088340640068054,
0.10456061363220215,
-0.5992635488510132,
0.6879345178604126,
0.09661491215229034,
0.14508424699306488,
0.048031073063611984,
0.03500841557979584,
0.13493496179580688,
-0.24181292951107025,
-0.6503064632415771,
-0.6478939652442932,
0.7949300408363342,
0.1987638920545578,
0.580614447593689,
1.0634762048721313,
0.6109725832939148,
0.39919227361679077,
-0.24240951240062714,
0.08443153649568558,
-0.7753497362136841,
0.05128191038966179,
0.0029681134037673473,
-0.3096108138561249,
-0.2903575897216797,
0.020829087123274803,
0.8124750256538391,
1.0858169794082642,
-0.1986425220966339,
0.06388010084629059,
0.224903866648674,
0.677539050579071,
-0.5268096327781677,
0.1224982962012291,
-0.5662038326263428,
0.5388413071632385,
-0.006487777456641197,
-0.050457149744033813,
-0.5714300870895386,
-0.11158721148967743,
0.03889719396829605,
-0.6355558633804321,
0.1826789528131485,
-0.0859459787607193,
0.48706120252609253,
0.3225981593132019,
-0.24580340087413788,
-0.05066809058189392,
-0.8690928816795349,
0.701738715171814,
-0.6839597225189209,
0.6593388319015503,
0.010178986936807632,
0.2503710389137268,
-0.27170559763908386,
-1.1290966272354126,
-0.22275309264659882,
-0.08556508272886276,
-0.18778547644615173,
0.21183128654956818,
-0.346019983291626,
0.25231924653053284,
0.44487690925598145,
0.488777756690979,
-0.368866503238678,
0.22632941603660583,
-0.35147643089294434,
0.0023131431080400944,
0.5299932956695557,
0.04145830124616623,
-0.2832053005695343,
-0.1377187967300415,
-0.5079324841499329,
-0.21060597896575928,
-0.6103845834732056,
0.13835416734218597,
0.3824462592601776,
0.3471117317676544,
0.017037203535437584,
0.24153003096580505,
-0.09356638044118881,
0.5693244338035583,
0.44452330470085144,
-0.21071618795394897,
0.15932995080947876,
-0.14177541434764862,
-0.3845931887626648,
-0.13151083886623383,
0.813720703125,
0.04501543939113617,
0.39643236994743347,
-0.5537774562835693,
-0.2725241780281067,
-0.2381391078233719,
0.5299561023712158,
-1.0369443893432617,
-0.33572182059288025,
0.05169105529785156,
-0.46386659145355225,
-0.4753652513027191,
-0.2453482300043106,
-0.48726165294647217,
-0.30488309264183044,
-0.42552781105041504,
0.40727490186691284,
-0.3023720681667328,
-0.1245276927947998,
-0.041909731924533844,
0.22053952515125275,
0.6060294508934021,
0.4085032641887665,
-0.9591262936592102,
0.5574449300765991,
0.6761083006858826,
0.7501972317695618,
-0.1381850242614746,
-0.2412448525428772,
-0.4022143483161926,
-0.104647696018219,
-0.4679975211620331,
0.6453717947006226,
-0.36957022547721863,
-0.22839298844337463,
-0.15311315655708313,
-0.034037794917821884,
-0.17079326510429382,
-0.5662251114845276,
0.4893891513347626,
-0.640860915184021,
-0.09155654907226562,
0.06717909127473831,
-0.3485950827598572,
0.014466924592852592,
0.24754996597766876,
-0.7095621228218079,
1.0132441520690918,
0.119954913854599,
-0.6675013899803162,
-0.2096358686685562,
-0.21094375848770142,
-0.7614141702651978,
-0.13637959957122803,
-0.019467506557703018,
-0.3627336621284485,
0.2160334438085556,
0.1724269986152649,
0.7861239910125732,
-0.31481221318244934,
0.2767162322998047,
-0.15724177658557892,
-0.5018436312675476,
0.10481496900320053,
-0.5549243688583374,
0.5031560063362122,
0.2384709119796753,
-0.36595141887664795,
0.09364563226699829,
-0.9716250896453857,
0.10354022681713104,
0.14921316504478455,
-0.4429725706577301,
-0.04920945316553116,
-0.0021167087834328413,
-0.06625780463218689,
0.24612857401371002,
-0.15089379251003265,
-0.39063894748687744,
0.20329232513904572,
-0.6794012188911438,
0.773785412311554,
0.7392112016677856,
-0.27395761013031006,
0.643401026725769,
-0.10180530697107315,
0.5019246935844421,
-0.13014066219329834,
0.14946165680885315,
-0.363511860370636,
-0.09883704781532288,
-0.8215745687484741,
-0.25417560338974,
0.23763374984264374,
0.38736021518707275,
-0.630672812461853,
0.30867087841033936,
-0.5182574987411499,
-0.5635656714439392,
-0.33839425444602966,
0.19569450616836548,
0.4369991421699524,
0.6360098123550415,
0.46083828806877136,
0.058290764689445496,
-0.4643537998199463,
-1.007156491279602,
-0.12691791355609894,
0.1637643426656723,
-0.18647152185440063,
0.2599480152130127,
0.24867326021194458,
-0.07494060695171356,
0.9007784128189087,
-0.399346262216568,
-0.1696239858865738,
-0.13375958800315857,
-0.25367772579193115,
0.4945524334907532,
0.5630651712417603,
0.21272563934326172,
-0.6530773639678955,
-0.41050487756729126,
-0.055092815309762955,
-0.5907990336418152,
-0.07280167192220688,
-0.12758584320545197,
0.12204302847385406,
-0.25141292810440063,
0.6664749979972839,
-0.4731937646865845,
-0.0013933980371803045,
0.5341469645500183,
0.07597687840461731,
0.13780847191810608,
-0.1829402595758438,
-0.3593409061431885,
-0.9921655058860779,
-0.09833866357803345,
0.18261004984378815,
-0.4441557228565216,
-0.9319607615470886,
-0.05216417461633682,
0.21901533007621765,
-0.08872678875923157,
-0.501613199710846,
0.2609504759311676,
-0.5738968849182129,
-0.009285680949687958,
-0.12805181741714478,
-0.012920670211315155,
0.026839710772037506,
0.9738863110542297,
-0.1417880654335022,
0.6885083913803101,
0.3869248330593109,
-0.25399231910705566,
0.24477051198482513,
0.003934083040803671,
-0.1243264451622963,
0.4913856089115143,
-0.639809787273407,
0.11030074954032898,
-0.28443583846092224,
0.36405372619628906,
-0.9195564985275269,
0.0737907737493515,
0.17782871425151825,
-0.09293931722640991,
0.5728310942649841,
-0.1124323308467865,
-0.1591535210609436,
-0.45784851908683777,
-0.5473619699478149,
0.27368617057800293,
0.45932918787002563,
-0.7898564338684082,
1.0114336013793945,
0.054792046546936035,
0.27822527289390564,
-0.7189756631851196,
-0.9838325381278992,
0.034051381051540375,
-0.11927762627601624,
-0.6759456396102905,
0.47427380084991455,
0.00687424186617136,
0.010600383393466473,
-0.1094018742442131,
-0.2624989449977875,
0.22604583203792572,
0.12070305645465851,
0.2750170826911926,
-0.22533723711967468,
-0.5518130660057068,
-0.09062574058771133,
0.012517120689153671,
-0.06833088397979736,
0.2570388913154602,
-0.6626092791557312,
0.46403244137763977,
-0.3482867181301117,
-0.00491786003112793,
-0.16820895671844482,
0.21997669339179993,
0.4252045452594757,
-0.17881590127944946,
0.711433470249176,
0.43918120861053467,
-0.30225563049316406,
-0.5677053928375244,
-0.6356467008590698,
-0.12357276678085327,
-0.5959409475326538,
0.3909624218940735,
-0.4292946755886078,
-0.9620113372802734,
0.6687760949134827,
-0.25645530223846436,
0.005645802244544029,
0.500766396522522,
0.3208332061767578,
-0.2534487843513489,
0.6692447066307068,
0.3877395689487457,
-0.029171772301197052,
0.3385244309902191,
-0.6188610792160034,
0.2284712940454483,
-1.0352879762649536,
-0.310888409614563,
-0.2594641447067261,
-0.5595278739929199,
-0.6613614559173584,
-0.621239185333252,
0.2294507771730423,
0.2108590006828308,
-0.35422828793525696,
0.425123929977417,
-0.4843641221523285,
0.44017645716667175,
0.2662431597709656,
0.2407243549823761,
0.22120122611522675,
0.1487952619791031,
-0.12246645987033844,
0.10510843247175217,
-1.0216854810714722,
-0.08770810067653656,
0.97725510597229,
0.6670520901679993,
1.0303305387496948,
-0.1968313455581665,
0.41192078590393066,
0.20100000500679016,
0.4697257876396179,
-0.8769370913505554,
0.4231990575790405,
-0.24956943094730377,
-0.15894199907779694,
-0.40919944643974304,
-0.6873648166656494,
-0.8516334295272827,
0.5481989979743958,
-0.16620199382305145,
-0.3965594470500946,
0.3739294409751892,
0.196613609790802,
-0.18923182785511017,
0.4072190225124359,
-0.608500599861145,
0.5590927004814148,
-0.2082066386938095,
-0.5063202381134033,
-0.03641900420188904,
-0.8058789968490601,
0.18434815108776093,
-0.1562456637620926,
0.08088243752717972,
0.17227275669574738,
0.06750893592834473,
0.7016539573669434,
-0.6013607978820801,
0.8817411661148071,
-0.11922578513622284,
-0.2798076272010803,
0.09598636627197266,
-0.05275501310825348,
0.6650323271751404,
0.04424135386943817,
-0.12450258433818817,
0.287519633769989,
-0.41714563965797424,
-0.2889726758003235,
-0.803670346736908,
0.7116941809654236,
-0.88018399477005,
-0.5711846351623535,
-0.1398605853319168,
-0.5350436568260193,
-0.2994321584701538,
0.22539138793945312,
0.06503631919622421,
0.7963364124298096,
0.04826916381716728,
0.5606873035430908,
0.8995617628097534,
0.14185306429862976,
0.5099878907203674,
0.16042236983776093,
-0.06616352498531342,
-0.5329973101615906,
0.6506047248840332,
0.2844327986240387,
0.3065609037876129,
0.7586814761161804,
0.3901522159576416,
-0.15364409983158112,
-0.6816885471343994,
-0.43033263087272644,
0.24113398790359497,
-0.864126443862915,
-0.4804155230522156,
-0.7260997295379639,
-0.7113481760025024,
-0.2155589610338211,
-0.224092498421669,
-0.6016373634338379,
-0.4392375946044922,
-0.13140146434307098,
-0.11029302328824997,
0.21977512538433075,
0.6791287064552307,
0.13210174441337585,
0.7236492037773132,
-0.3445971608161926,
0.05113110691308975,
0.4024308919906616,
0.6057562828063965,
0.5151575207710266,
-0.6467448472976685,
-0.4008844792842865,
-0.23962721228599548,
-0.1912219375371933,
-0.4884307086467743,
0.05804713815450668,
0.34573447704315186,
0.5638160109519958,
0.5440302491188049,
-0.14176452159881592,
0.5920710563659668,
-0.8981934189796448,
0.35153743624687195,
0.1460789442062378,
-0.7722915410995483,
0.1668890416622162,
-0.3747844398021698,
0.3360045552253723,
0.45595183968544006,
0.40349575877189636,
-0.3308544456958771,
-0.18765109777450562,
-0.3288155496120453,
-0.7261283993721008,
0.885185182094574,
0.4133671522140503,
0.351686030626297,
0.30322256684303284,
0.6961925029754639,
-0.18017607927322388,
0.08477579057216644,
-0.8031394481658936,
-0.5266029238700867,
-0.4797365963459015,
-0.29546093940734863,
0.02282806485891342,
-0.22388486564159393,
0.07712927460670471,
-0.3811783492565155,
0.4721057116985321,
-0.34094467759132385,
0.30601850152015686,
0.2235194444656372,
-0.1361784189939499,
-0.041996099054813385,
-0.005756822414696217,
0.5196933150291443,
0.5906369686126709,
-0.05555558577179909,
0.42516234517097473,
0.38464435935020447,
-0.6890149116516113,
0.29418647289276123,
0.2710196375846863,
-0.07321019470691681,
-0.40929409861564636,
0.7568808197975159,
0.99724942445755,
0.6751594543457031,
-0.24280239641666412,
0.5130164623260498,
-0.07840043306350708,
-0.45439064502716064,
-0.29963022470474243,
0.12066242843866348,
0.3099716305732727,
0.5862882137298584,
0.48358389735221863,
0.13316088914871216,
0.025756459683179855,
-0.08119972050189972,
0.05925341695547104,
0.37078943848609924,
-0.29040297865867615,
-0.3663058578968048,
0.5675002932548523,
0.23935925960540771,
-0.428364634513855,
0.5972135663032532,
0.2148951292037964,
-0.5279748439788818,
0.44428199529647827,
0.7086541652679443,
0.7992475032806396,
-0.2748647928237915,
0.020929180085659027,
0.13465772569179535,
0.4788828194141388,
-0.23120494186878204,
-0.24614883959293365,
-0.4095696210861206,
-0.7657691836357117,
-0.5740399956703186,
-0.8886349201202393,
-0.31331318616867065,
0.12088394910097122,
-0.34936535358428955,
0.058025117963552475,
-0.7803708910942078,
0.03490544483065605,
0.026967143639922142,
0.08744124323129654,
-0.4857827126979828,
0.2905159890651703,
0.2099408507347107,
1.0800247192382812,
-0.5181069374084473,
0.8967486023902893,
0.3637094795703888,
0.07651374489068985,
-1.1588053703308105,
-0.1761394441127777,
-0.40065476298332214,
-0.7457200884819031,
0.510189414024353,
0.3066245913505554,
-0.390346497297287,
0.2353232055902481,
-0.34625694155693054,
-1.055875301361084,
1.1764262914657593,
0.43166351318359375,
-0.698842465877533,
-0.28946030139923096,
0.34083953499794006,
0.5766884088516235,
-0.2882828712463379,
0.4411700367927551,
0.4809878468513489,
0.36841079592704773,
0.47547394037246704,
-0.5475248098373413,
0.06495056301355362,
-0.3150447607040405,
0.38003823161125183,
0.2644874155521393,
-0.7276298403739929,
0.7508807182312012,
0.10056491941213608,
-0.031816232949495316,
-0.2429227977991104,
0.8420236110687256,
-0.19135020673274994,
-0.148978590965271,
0.7154737710952759,
0.4900406301021576,
0.5025060176849365,
-0.05457308888435364,
0.9496722221374512,
-0.39363613724708557,
0.43694019317626953,
0.8085882663726807,
-0.1872309446334839,
0.5588256120681763,
0.412011057138443,
-0.27491453289985657,
0.3510763645172119,
0.34969601035118103,
-0.18575233221054077,
0.4766831696033478,
0.4799095392227173,
0.1868981570005417,
-0.26980674266815186,
0.20490247011184692,
-0.17512813210487366,
0.3843946158885956,
0.17609046399593353,
-0.4237828552722931,
-0.2987743616104126,
0.13430601358413696,
0.05468737706542015,
0.08896195143461227,
-0.46402204036712646,
0.5123401880264282,
0.3420143127441406,
-0.41889458894729614,
0.713834822177887,
0.13341011106967926,
0.8362086415290833,
-0.8222362995147705,
0.28788426518440247,
-0.49127036333084106,
0.3880917727947235,
-0.34637710452079773,
-0.5600711703300476,
0.29184603691101074,
-0.1267453134059906,
-0.2204347401857376,
-0.5988685488700867,
0.801405668258667,
-0.502361536026001,
-0.7604316473007202,
0.49305081367492676,
0.21600796282291412,
-0.18240641057491302,
-0.06343887001276016,
-0.4011700451374054,
0.087781623005867,
-0.21081721782684326,
-0.6402953267097473,
0.14917276799678802,
0.29206594824790955,
-0.029810480773448944,
0.6302189826965332,
0.4814997613430023,
0.10907936096191406,
0.1353348046541214,
0.10736094415187836,
1.1536062955856323,
-0.5157772302627563,
-0.3788224756717682,
-0.790732204914093,
0.19066353142261505,
0.07103231549263,
-0.014331545680761337,
0.6305744647979736,
0.5713343024253845,
0.8305322527885437,
0.0520937442779541,
0.17861774563789368,
0.33002564311027527,
0.16683122515678406,
-0.5620561838150024,
0.7338961958885193,
-0.5731019377708435,
0.2566272020339966,
-0.1650468111038208,
-1.0958555936813354,
-0.3228076100349426,
0.6236904263496399,
-0.21763503551483154,
0.18187738955020905,
0.4391946792602539,
0.6842393279075623,
-0.33390799164772034,
0.2108221799135208,
0.2649545669555664,
0.3690541982650757,
0.3560168147087097,
0.5562682747840881,
0.7355296611785889,
-0.5783547163009644,
0.5700801610946655,
-0.6050883531570435,
-0.17203731834888458,
-0.015963317826390266,
-0.8620347380638123,
-1.1253225803375244,
-0.28804442286491394,
-0.07600191980600357,
-0.2531426250934601,
0.02179339900612831,
0.8916276693344116,
0.8740954399108887,
-0.6941953897476196,
-0.32660043239593506,
-0.09679722040891647,
0.057916175574064255,
-0.16384534537792206,
-0.14277692139148712,
0.4211476147174835,
-0.22692102193832397,
-0.45238253474235535,
0.5240410566329956,
0.25078150629997253,
-0.20209237933158875,
-0.60978102684021,
-0.02585226111114025,
-0.19249911606311798,
0.24168457090854645,
0.8862362504005432,
-0.014065098948776722,
-0.5360816121101379,
-0.17852163314819336,
0.356903612613678,
-0.19817493855953217,
0.27958109974861145,
0.8908027410507202,
-0.9787143468856812,
0.1060243621468544,
0.3360567092895508,
0.9650612473487854,
0.9041537642478943,
-0.004080773796886206,
0.4241868853569031,
-0.7686222791671753,
0.08209042251110077,
0.20119109749794006,
0.14744852483272552,
0.45865538716316223,
-0.43392935395240784,
0.5180960893630981,
0.2449205219745636,
-0.32034769654273987,
-0.7392280101776123,
0.01248761173337698,
-0.8801400065422058,
-0.108221635222435,
0.9546447992324829,
-0.07254723459482193,
-0.4709042012691498,
0.4188765287399292,
0.23407836258411407,
0.009365272708237171,
-0.13749805092811584,
0.3531777262687683,
0.3485698997974396,
-0.10722055286169052,
-0.286312460899353,
-0.25213661789894104,
0.42276278138160706,
0.41307735443115234,
-0.5903538465499878,
0.018308721482753754,
0.07972607761621475,
0.2033841460943222,
0.18201561272144318,
0.33616960048675537,
0.13580191135406494,
-0.14867836236953735,
-0.16935905814170837,
-0.15443556010723114,
-0.4065203070640564,
-0.5433533787727356,
-0.6327841281890869,
0.3236302137374878,
-0.349843293428421,
0.18751443922519684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16441v1 | UniCoder: Scaling Code Large Language Model via Universal Code | 2024-06-24T08:32:48 | 2024-06-24T08:32:48 | Tao Sun, Linzheng Chai, Jian Yang, Yuwei Yin, Hongcheng Guo, Jiaheng Liu, Bing Wang, Liqun Yang, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intermediate reasoning or acting steps have successfully improved large
language models (LLMs) for handling various downstream natural language
processing (NLP) tasks. When applying LLMs for code generation, recent works
mainly focus on directing the models to articulate intermediate
natural-language reasoning steps, as in chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting, and
then output code with the natural language or other structured intermediate
steps. However, such output is not suitable for code translation or generation
tasks since the standard CoT has different logical structures and forms of
expression with the code. In this work, we introduce the universal code
(UniCode) as the intermediate representation. It is a description of algorithm
steps using a mix of conventions of programming languages, such as assignment
operator, conditional operator, and loop. Hence, we collect an instruction
dataset UniCoder-Instruct to train our model UniCoder on multi-task learning
objectives. UniCoder-Instruct comprises natural-language questions, code
solutions, and the corresponding universal code. The alignment between the
intermediate universal code representation and the final code solution
significantly improves the quality of the generated code. The experimental
results demonstrate that UniCoder with the universal code significantly
outperforms the previous prompting methods by a large margin, showcasing the
effectiveness of the structural clues in pseudo-code. | [
-0.3330916464328766,
-0.6289068460464478,
0.2793228030204773,
0.2678128182888031,
-0.0861494243144989,
-0.11292588710784912,
-0.5402365326881409,
-0.34026390314102173,
-0.06937188655138016,
0.6213048100471497,
-0.39055174589157104,
-0.2763024866580963,
-0.44191911816596985,
0.4130622446537018,
-0.20866228640079498,
0.9759840369224548,
-0.044872626662254333,
0.09075618535280228,
0.006058439612388611,
-0.21717707812786102,
-0.6217147707939148,
-0.8017104864120483,
-0.7022824287414551,
-0.2061225026845932,
0.41375529766082764,
0.6576635241508484,
0.6337621212005615,
0.6452906131744385,
0.6632006168365479,
0.348161518573761,
0.19765762984752655,
0.026558276265859604,
-0.4057402014732361,
0.03881913423538208,
-0.1824067234992981,
-0.582431435585022,
-0.34858590364456177,
-0.37317824363708496,
0.7099817991256714,
0.5136259198188782,
-0.08992357552051544,
0.3892160654067993,
-0.02323308028280735,
0.700156569480896,
-0.2612766623497009,
0.17250151932239532,
-0.638298511505127,
-0.327982634305954,
-0.15545107424259186,
-0.06037812680006027,
-0.7750808000564575,
-0.02492699772119522,
-0.5723807215690613,
-0.2046974152326584,
-0.11378201842308044,
0.04737858846783638,
0.6911386847496033,
0.17960399389266968,
-0.5641856789588928,
-0.48534542322158813,
-0.8137147426605225,
0.7333044409751892,
-0.49544522166252136,
0.3971673846244812,
-0.09798640012741089,
0.24435560405254364,
-0.11981253325939178,
-0.7960443496704102,
-0.5866144299507141,
-0.4100780487060547,
0.053534939885139465,
-0.2610361874103546,
-0.18958696722984314,
0.13079504668712616,
0.40267935395240784,
0.15916292369365692,
-0.5055640935897827,
0.12225887924432755,
-0.39484602212905884,
-0.24943232536315918,
0.5513288378715515,
0.15057657659053802,
0.6431771516799927,
-0.11014282703399658,
-0.22620800137519836,
-0.09481129050254822,
-0.8323194980621338,
0.09104794263839722,
0.12244512140750885,
0.646720826625824,
-0.1274728626012802,
0.6449705362319946,
-0.18517255783081055,
0.8762511610984802,
0.16332508623600006,
0.13540631532669067,
-0.00811535120010376,
-0.3353646695613861,
-0.0703497976064682,
0.10768947750329971,
0.6789344549179077,
0.3071930706501007,
0.3280556797981262,
0.09822127223014832,
-0.26765820384025574,
0.14646582305431366,
0.506942093372345,
-1.0366655588150024,
0.03183372691273689,
0.11274563521146774,
-0.43359583616256714,
0.20097769796848297,
-0.07286711782217026,
-0.302208811044693,
0.03679453581571579,
-0.7469946146011353,
0.24560941755771637,
-0.4916699528694153,
-0.15055981278419495,
-0.10369210690259933,
0.443862646818161,
0.3893134891986847,
0.20720484852790833,
-0.7611168026924133,
0.2843933403491974,
0.5310057401657104,
0.7156725525856018,
0.20286825299263,
-0.10592640191316605,
-0.7685429453849792,
-0.09793601185083389,
-0.49723196029663086,
0.6159827709197998,
-0.7659143805503845,
-0.2248734086751938,
-0.1086767166852951,
-0.23707200586795807,
-0.09933634102344513,
-0.3232569098472595,
0.4644550383090973,
-0.47447237372398376,
-0.17735114693641663,
-0.2643005847930908,
-0.5775322914123535,
-0.06373331695795059,
0.15478335320949554,
-0.59879070520401,
0.8883967399597168,
0.2655256390571594,
-0.7273563742637634,
0.18332011997699738,
-0.8814545273780823,
-0.3778272271156311,
0.25612059235572815,
-0.4487241208553314,
-0.04890909418463707,
0.22520065307617188,
0.3217640221118927,
0.5014001131057739,
-0.3133277893066406,
0.22248318791389465,
-0.025527246296405792,
-0.3596147298812866,
0.15816985070705414,
-0.2950887680053711,
0.6391299366950989,
0.38394686579704285,
-0.2138872891664505,
0.28544265031814575,
-0.5774182081222534,
0.1333521604537964,
0.057934824377298355,
-0.444789856672287,
-0.28035926818847656,
-0.238369882106781,
0.19630113244056702,
0.34536775946617126,
0.2154809683561325,
-0.45764607191085815,
0.5137824416160583,
-0.1445230394601822,
0.2576572299003601,
0.5573667287826538,
0.026755385100841522,
0.6184044480323792,
-0.04580434411764145,
0.4920116662979126,
-0.1001742035150528,
0.11076104640960693,
-0.2646813988685608,
-0.42984911799430847,
-0.8077629208564758,
-0.06852015852928162,
0.30811119079589844,
0.40619930624961853,
-0.780730664730072,
0.33200252056121826,
-0.3880939483642578,
-0.2545582950115204,
-0.4109709560871124,
0.3799649477005005,
0.553716778755188,
0.40180325508117676,
0.3494895398616791,
-0.15744943916797638,
-0.7382326722145081,
-0.5557206273078918,
-0.1924106329679489,
-0.24169570207595825,
-0.1584874540567398,
-0.12392940372228622,
0.4592776894569397,
-0.5646307468414307,
0.8335946202278137,
-0.1621028035879135,
-0.32711052894592285,
-0.6711089611053467,
0.12573137879371643,
0.39601293206214905,
0.4983407258987427,
0.1913892924785614,
-0.8723158240318298,
-0.5201662182807922,
0.034408096224069595,
-0.5554077625274658,
0.09341032058000565,
-0.3696606457233429,
-0.21558798849582672,
0.27578839659690857,
0.8014765977859497,
-0.22609367966651917,
0.14404959976673126,
0.43486183881759644,
-0.23114296793937683,
0.6602285504341125,
-0.5511387586593628,
0.1191432997584343,
-1.2169721126556396,
0.0634675994515419,
0.1595911830663681,
-0.11538637429475784,
-0.6837572455406189,
0.6309689283370972,
0.41975682973861694,
-0.11647490411996841,
-0.2595645785331726,
0.3780864477157593,
-0.7035689949989319,
0.08632313460111618,
-0.2555135488510132,
-0.3265363872051239,
-0.28579285740852356,
0.4875710606575012,
0.2376013547182083,
0.8843724131584167,
0.5904894471168518,
-0.6530926823616028,
0.2743527591228485,
-0.028875842690467834,
-0.16702264547348022,
0.6719411611557007,
-0.5647726655006409,
0.29739347100257874,
-0.06789737194776535,
0.42416051030158997,
-0.8420171737670898,
-0.28090792894363403,
-0.3391560912132263,
-0.49590545892715454,
0.5053650140762329,
-0.3025314509868622,
-0.7147461771965027,
-0.6016547083854675,
0.12134657800197601,
0.3446771204471588,
0.6425542831420898,
-0.5646377801895142,
0.547656774520874,
0.17152224481105804,
-0.20963992178440094,
-0.3396194875240326,
-0.49692538380622864,
0.32509270310401917,
-0.1112833097577095,
-0.4867049753665924,
-0.0018225940875709057,
-0.12250469624996185,
-0.2246825248003006,
-0.25366008281707764,
-0.1625107228755951,
-0.05332118645310402,
-0.21950340270996094,
0.21404138207435608,
0.32010528445243835,
-0.49646419286727905,
0.011843172833323479,
0.04904637858271599,
-0.234047070145607,
0.11947663128376007,
-0.331520140171051,
0.5500532984733582,
-0.4726587235927582,
-0.24970073997974396,
-0.23561741411685944,
0.3389301896095276,
0.40677565336227417,
-0.3155823349952698,
0.5678807497024536,
0.6170157194137573,
-0.2896910011768341,
-0.2511821687221527,
-0.4116697609424591,
0.010587278753519058,
-0.4852803349494934,
0.47856462001800537,
-0.6541185975074768,
-0.7336104512214661,
0.4582834541797638,
-0.24736288189888,
0.23909050226211548,
0.3926658630371094,
0.6106765866279602,
0.1298990696668625,
1.2306010723114014,
0.8378883600234985,
-0.2697102427482605,
0.23686370253562927,
-0.4111677408218384,
0.23481835424900055,
-1.03128981590271,
-0.10820426046848297,
-0.832272469997406,
-0.1475851684808731,
-0.3412132263183594,
-0.6736459136009216,
0.2485351860523224,
0.40815311670303345,
-0.4758422374725342,
0.6232373714447021,
-0.6547898054122925,
0.7082518935203552,
0.4912661612033844,
-0.021374914795160294,
0.12426242977380753,
0.05809511989355087,
-0.32118695974349976,
0.14257165789604187,
-0.6284155249595642,
-0.5606864094734192,
1.160286545753479,
0.10251861065626144,
0.9257041811943054,
0.08272368460893631,
0.956052303314209,
0.282514363527298,
0.44906026124954224,
-0.5283275842666626,
0.5455516576766968,
-0.20871293544769287,
-0.4052559435367584,
-0.3018418848514557,
-0.6758610010147095,
-0.7767989635467529,
0.13569997251033783,
0.1978265941143036,
-0.9268618226051331,
-0.07535003870725632,
0.08453787863254547,
-0.179531529545784,
0.30460262298583984,
-0.7759914398193359,
0.8004719018936157,
-0.15723399817943573,
-0.09847578406333923,
-0.0689561516046524,
-0.7454239726066589,
0.2508416473865509,
-0.07097046822309494,
0.46991342306137085,
0.26289501786231995,
-0.0195364598184824,
0.6337404847145081,
-0.6059235334396362,
0.708930492401123,
-0.08797625452280045,
-0.237559974193573,
0.42536571621894836,
0.36166897416114807,
0.630426824092865,
-0.0038004529196769,
-0.1603681594133377,
0.07009474188089371,
-0.3032492697238922,
-0.34281784296035767,
-0.41675812005996704,
0.7630777955055237,
-0.7235599160194397,
-0.4050962030887604,
-0.18612439930438995,
-0.7561609745025635,
-0.1747034192085266,
0.2338612675666809,
0.38373157382011414,
0.7907773852348328,
0.0356256403028965,
0.24425008893013,
0.45809420943260193,
0.04220103472471237,
0.48735305666923523,
0.33864083886146545,
-0.23252779245376587,
-0.16164429485797882,
0.9191838502883911,
-0.04158458486199379,
0.32311221957206726,
0.6831466555595398,
0.029929984360933304,
-0.5283589363098145,
-0.36862534284591675,
-0.6971591711044312,
0.07327041029930115,
-0.8156123161315918,
-0.3761841654777527,
-0.4471045434474945,
-0.17450736463069916,
-0.4386058449745178,
-0.3877010941505432,
-0.25834164023399353,
-0.09088253974914551,
-0.12479449808597565,
0.08227914571762085,
0.27416151762008667,
0.7036271095275879,
-0.08876730501651764,
0.19991526007652283,
-0.9399665594100952,
0.5038636326789856,
0.09097878634929657,
0.2036883533000946,
-0.04741658642888069,
-0.6572042107582092,
-0.4169217646121979,
0.28161463141441345,
-0.09653975814580917,
-0.5640414953231812,
0.2459615170955658,
0.2906009256839752,
0.4195915162563324,
0.4696636199951172,
0.18152481317520142,
0.9359731674194336,
-0.698498010635376,
0.617107093334198,
0.5482289791107178,
-0.9442914128303528,
0.43982043862342834,
-0.14041359722614288,
0.6058927178382874,
0.4754866063594818,
0.3788565695285797,
-0.613922119140625,
-0.626706600189209,
-0.372650146484375,
-0.7174810171127319,
0.7169774770736694,
0.2451530545949936,
0.3922065794467926,
-0.13715089857578278,
0.21072973310947418,
-0.05623263865709305,
-0.2655782699584961,
-0.7987926602363586,
-0.13620145618915558,
-0.0648590475320816,
-0.379940390586853,
-0.06337521225214005,
-0.07411623001098633,
0.20379602909088135,
-0.15729780495166779,
0.41146937012672424,
-0.4031148850917816,
0.39819854497909546,
0.07607787102460861,
-0.5201708078384399,
-0.10942178964614868,
0.4459812641143799,
0.36009302735328674,
0.6069351434707642,
-0.07039374858140945,
0.17889675498008728,
-0.13728287816047668,
-0.5316614508628845,
0.2813442647457123,
-0.08975514769554138,
-0.015191813930869102,
-0.18525159358978271,
0.4871118366718292,
0.6349634528160095,
0.10456153750419617,
-0.6362708806991577,
0.3708969056606293,
-0.154727965593338,
-0.059885174036026,
0.041932426393032074,
0.2480802983045578,
0.06304597854614258,
0.08429481089115143,
0.42481720447540283,
0.18341723084449768,
0.16530561447143555,
-0.5813817381858826,
0.3500385582447052,
0.13074547052383423,
-0.5425460338592529,
-0.32925981283187866,
0.7530641555786133,
0.3324851393699646,
-0.26564085483551025,
0.9869664311408997,
-0.3421611189842224,
-0.38630715012550354,
0.7277843356132507,
0.8755260705947876,
0.717290997505188,
-0.3150177299976349,
0.22182607650756836,
0.47088387608528137,
0.46589481830596924,
0.007055416237562895,
0.37364253401756287,
-0.20545582473278046,
-0.5951159596443176,
-0.7661117315292358,
-0.7884390354156494,
-0.15348383784294128,
-0.1763787567615509,
-0.8289850950241089,
0.10670434683561325,
-0.26416444778442383,
0.011397254653275013,
-0.1853845864534378,
-0.029011227190494537,
-0.6713060140609741,
0.19951367378234863,
0.4357917606830597,
0.9916305541992188,
-0.7087700366973877,
1.015546202659607,
0.8317887187004089,
-0.6640151739120483,
-1.2122410535812378,
0.05242881178855896,
-0.12817151844501495,
-0.7713140249252319,
0.7701622247695923,
0.4542410671710968,
0.12256823480129242,
0.07125688344240189,
-0.4990255832672119,
-0.860866904258728,
0.570659875869751,
0.3506884276866913,
-0.8302996754646301,
-0.17264340817928314,
0.2944720983505249,
0.486425518989563,
-0.5241612792015076,
0.4769197106361389,
0.40758800506591797,
0.24378293752670288,
0.3436338007450104,
-0.8474382162094116,
0.3388301730155945,
-0.30129826068878174,
0.40449702739715576,
0.37604621052742004,
-0.2890405058860779,
0.73615962266922,
-0.7091806530952454,
-0.07192123681306839,
0.12876877188682556,
0.8755318522453308,
0.29791417717933655,
-0.1281905472278595,
0.46192824840545654,
0.3017727732658386,
0.5535658597946167,
0.037998247891664505,
1.2251406908035278,
-0.34102070331573486,
0.22326791286468506,
1.1823773384094238,
-0.4565774202346802,
0.9880484938621521,
0.3977615237236023,
-0.3258596658706665,
0.7628916501998901,
0.4932231903076172,
0.24822522699832916,
0.041753169149160385,
0.4280725419521332,
0.02201688103377819,
-0.2632278501987457,
0.09174584597349167,
-0.32937267422676086,
0.31410136818885803,
0.5059294700622559,
-0.002669513924047351,
-0.369575560092926,
0.2545245587825775,
0.12162087857723236,
0.08649107813835144,
-0.6863216757774353,
0.8304794430732727,
0.08983252942562103,
-0.6478681564331055,
0.8538711667060852,
0.12181670218706131,
0.5726398229598999,
-0.6603387594223022,
-0.1751098334789276,
-0.436557799577713,
0.31632277369499207,
-0.06734968721866608,
-0.5945748090744019,
0.2604310214519501,
0.32440847158432007,
-0.0682729035615921,
-0.2650306820869446,
0.49218007922172546,
-0.3962124288082123,
-0.8353599309921265,
0.1369122564792633,
-0.12171723693609238,
0.24832944571971893,
-0.313859760761261,
-0.8134287595748901,
0.09101063013076782,
0.08223607391119003,
-0.12558576464653015,
0.3682972490787506,
0.6467879414558411,
-0.303149551153183,
0.6456871628761292,
0.6665229797363281,
0.003363908501341939,
0.31313657760620117,
0.34985053539276123,
0.742140531539917,
-0.652557909488678,
-0.584604799747467,
-0.6344547867774963,
0.5239705443382263,
0.03715948387980461,
-0.025249166414141655,
0.7497145533561707,
0.6800996661186218,
0.765495777130127,
-0.003330303356051445,
0.5228778123855591,
-0.33588364720344543,
0.04821036010980606,
-0.5534924864768982,
0.5066966414451599,
-0.41021332144737244,
0.14598305523395538,
-0.24476516246795654,
-1.0303235054016113,
-0.4659140110015869,
0.3309886157512665,
0.011911330744624138,
0.0838780328631401,
0.7633794546127319,
0.7635352611541748,
-0.09289905428886414,
-0.18303464353084564,
0.3321172595024109,
0.3622221052646637,
0.3396390974521637,
0.6100552678108215,
0.5510912537574768,
-0.3588971197605133,
0.7659245729446411,
-0.006439643446356058,
-0.30429553985595703,
-0.2804577052593231,
-0.6034888625144958,
-0.745635986328125,
-0.6408280730247498,
-0.3348655104637146,
-0.42920106649398804,
-0.2324235588312149,
1.0076711177825928,
0.721562385559082,
-0.7405292987823486,
-0.5436069369316101,
-0.47310566902160645,
0.0006593056605197489,
-0.428092896938324,
-0.19467855989933014,
0.357330322265625,
-0.8671759963035583,
-0.6107130646705627,
0.19924382865428925,
0.22261637449264526,
-0.2442828267812729,
-0.07247073948383331,
-0.38832607865333557,
-0.15853439271450043,
0.26791897416114807,
0.6282289624214172,
0.3146298825740814,
-0.6973499059677124,
-0.1238718181848526,
0.08071309328079224,
-0.18193218111991882,
0.01032146904617548,
0.9772050380706787,
-0.470787912607193,
0.5231277346611023,
0.3027992248535156,
0.43116337060928345,
0.16810044646263123,
-0.05455271154642105,
0.6251170635223389,
-0.8375517129898071,
0.010944182053208351,
0.06627105921506882,
0.4786476492881775,
0.1903088539838791,
-0.343924880027771,
0.3172317445278168,
-0.2683412432670593,
-0.544359028339386,
-0.7160578966140747,
0.18112342059612274,
-0.8644058108329773,
-0.3355270326137543,
1.3391709327697754,
-0.03336176648736,
-0.44554468989372253,
-0.0031251327600330114,
-0.3632337749004364,
0.16378234326839447,
-0.5058201551437378,
0.38745325803756714,
0.2724725008010864,
-0.15692348778247833,
-0.0024491201620548964,
-0.08107294887304306,
0.16386505961418152,
-0.02661369927227497,
-0.8111954927444458,
0.1759198158979416,
0.5386163592338562,
0.16133403778076172,
0.2521035671234131,
0.791077196598053,
-0.20016248524188995,
0.23908939957618713,
0.23283623158931732,
0.47617894411087036,
0.09051468968391418,
-0.5371279716491699,
-0.3712035119533539,
0.018581261858344078,
0.1312364637851715,
-0.10514934360980988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16416v1 | Multilingual Knowledge Editing with Language-Agnostic Factual Neurons | 2024-06-24T08:06:56 | 2024-06-24T08:06:56 | Xue zhang, Yunlong Liang, Fandong Meng, Songming Zhang, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual knowledge editing (MKE) aims to simultaneously revise factual
knowledge across multilingual languages within large language models (LLMs).
However, most existing MKE methods just adapt existing monolingual editing
methods to multilingual scenarios, overlooking the deep semantic connections of
the same factual knowledge between different languages, thereby limiting edit
performance. To address this issue, we first investigate how LLMs represent
multilingual factual knowledge and discover that the same factual knowledge in
different languages generally activates a shared set of neurons, which we call
language-agnostic factual neurons. These neurons represent the semantic
connections between multilingual knowledge and are mainly located in certain
layers. Inspired by this finding, we propose a new MKE method by locating and
modifying Language-Agnostic Factual Neurons (LAFN) to simultaneously edit
multilingual knowledge. Specifically, we first generate a set of paraphrases
for each multilingual knowledge to be edited to precisely locate the
corresponding language-agnostic factual neurons. Then we optimize the update
values for modifying these located neurons to achieve simultaneous modification
of the same factual knowledge in multiple languages. Experimental results on
Bi-ZsRE and MzsRE benchmarks demonstrate that our method outperforms existing
MKE methods and achieves remarkable edit performance, indicating the importance
of considering the semantic connections among multilingual knowledge. | [
-0.2892817556858063,
-0.689223051071167,
0.6693357229232788,
0.24396149814128876,
-0.13257259130477905,
0.24776127934455872,
-0.4497101902961731,
-0.43088820576667786,
0.46630287170410156,
0.29199519753456116,
-0.48812755942344666,
-0.5480475425720215,
-0.41697224974632263,
0.1729031652212143,
0.10296881198883057,
0.7703712582588196,
0.043166279792785645,
0.05627582222223282,
-0.24994009733200073,
-0.6912882924079895,
-0.27991819381713867,
-0.49568700790405273,
-0.5789023041725159,
-0.24963071942329407,
0.9106534719467163,
0.30800366401672363,
0.9150736927986145,
0.540951669216156,
0.09074921160936356,
0.34314391016960144,
-0.45916783809661865,
0.40924322605133057,
-0.20943355560302734,
-0.08963014930486679,
-0.5945589542388916,
-0.3799687623977661,
-0.5258762240409851,
-0.27700209617614746,
0.7764060497283936,
0.5649017095565796,
-0.049021970480680466,
0.17177215218544006,
-0.04349249601364136,
0.5157756209373474,
-0.6598368287086487,
0.16182994842529297,
-0.8256306052207947,
0.04421589523553848,
-0.004280221648514271,
-0.20718468725681305,
-0.5431656837463379,
-0.3656812310218811,
-0.11047235131263733,
-0.681513786315918,
0.3788532614707947,
-0.24108920991420746,
0.5161877870559692,
0.11969657242298126,
-0.39436474442481995,
-0.06417567282915115,
-0.543451726436615,
0.41825371980667114,
-0.645905077457428,
0.60511714220047,
0.1370212286710739,
-0.015984781086444855,
0.09433025121688843,
-0.4650380313396454,
-0.8218613862991333,
-0.27021801471710205,
-0.2358155995607376,
0.04494258016347885,
-0.07338586449623108,
0.1357843577861786,
0.3399205207824707,
-0.032260119915008545,
-0.2977345287799835,
-0.08372405916452408,
-0.11770521104335785,
-0.48545822501182556,
0.33976006507873535,
-0.18081526458263397,
0.462125688791275,
-0.18942894041538239,
-0.28113698959350586,
0.0915549173951149,
-0.587811291217804,
-0.1270284205675125,
0.27974411845207214,
0.10195193439722061,
0.26753905415534973,
0.7366757392883301,
-0.2514635920524597,
0.7391331791877747,
-0.16207611560821533,
-0.3481036126613617,
0.183249369263649,
-0.6814086437225342,
-0.1032392680644989,
0.37491342425346375,
0.7200857996940613,
0.287087619304657,
0.09097728133201599,
-0.41687706112861633,
-0.009659826755523682,
-0.03947777673602104,
0.12368351221084595,
-0.4853266179561615,
-0.12792067229747772,
-0.12455390393733978,
-0.16254019737243652,
-0.1557774394750595,
-0.40627771615982056,
-0.7421890497207642,
-0.3902900218963623,
-0.3989071846008301,
0.47579488158226013,
-0.6800711154937744,
-0.0918622612953186,
0.31527242064476013,
-0.10313020646572113,
-0.20419633388519287,
0.34513258934020996,
-0.8868045210838318,
-0.0379510223865509,
0.4116368293762207,
0.7373172640800476,
0.24585336446762085,
-0.9641222357749939,
-0.3322238326072693,
0.5725526809692383,
-0.3619029223918915,
0.827626645565033,
-0.48288288712501526,
-0.1428767442703247,
-0.1445544958114624,
-0.10544061660766602,
-0.18940089643001556,
-0.3593830168247223,
0.4815385937690735,
-1.011675238609314,
-0.20807689428329468,
-0.7884013652801514,
-0.4519289433956146,
-0.3334030210971832,
0.3418196439743042,
-0.5600053071975708,
0.7808640003204346,
-0.2520659565925598,
-0.7955503463745117,
0.4147834777832031,
-0.7802326679229736,
-0.5656313300132751,
-0.3987542688846588,
0.16870667040348053,
-0.14930468797683716,
0.06155455857515335,
0.35902199149131775,
0.24056029319763184,
0.12404779344797134,
0.45419368147850037,
-0.217083141207695,
0.057046711444854736,
0.2358182668685913,
-0.593643844127655,
0.7966131567955017,
-0.12934891879558563,
-0.1826218068599701,
0.3287658989429474,
-0.7934097051620483,
-0.20169824361801147,
-0.14842922985553741,
-0.3208106458187103,
-0.4215216040611267,
0.0610550157725811,
-0.32574328780174255,
0.44858595728874207,
0.4232710301876068,
-0.7198670506477356,
0.31906893849372864,
-0.1368408054113388,
0.21766410768032074,
0.896040141582489,
0.12444918602705002,
0.37230968475341797,
-0.1896834373474121,
0.22656114399433136,
0.3252485692501068,
0.2565126121044159,
-0.09906917065382004,
-0.4118029475212097,
-0.7674100995063782,
-0.1737341284751892,
0.43579185009002686,
0.804454505443573,
-1.0587644577026367,
0.089500293135643,
-0.3496614098548889,
-0.3121122121810913,
-0.7277294993400574,
0.49134862422943115,
0.2269180715084076,
0.5393639802932739,
0.7159612774848938,
0.24549852311611176,
-0.32393136620521545,
-1.1668204069137573,
-0.6085243821144104,
-0.2114245444536209,
0.40105658769607544,
-0.01631242223083973,
0.34780457615852356,
-0.22916188836097717,
0.8800472617149353,
-0.4385313093662262,
-0.07609159499406815,
0.10102584958076477,
0.05230780690908432,
0.023747311905026436,
0.3839683532714844,
0.7026433944702148,
-0.7556849122047424,
-0.5723474025726318,
0.42443737387657166,
-0.9152063131332397,
-0.005984093528240919,
-0.44402629137039185,
-0.2819715142250061,
0.2097143828868866,
0.4436332583427429,
-0.8990631699562073,
0.33215925097465515,
0.28246599435806274,
-0.23990987241268158,
0.7294915318489075,
-0.5569931268692017,
0.5021557211875916,
-1.0958690643310547,
-0.0640130564570427,
-0.1825183629989624,
-0.12313395738601685,
-0.6126168966293335,
0.1956157684326172,
0.5636609792709351,
-0.004283261019736528,
-0.42612606287002563,
0.4795338213443756,
-0.5579954981803894,
0.04636915773153305,
-0.06962964683771133,
0.17113304138183594,
0.09570326656103134,
0.682590663433075,
-0.09573036432266235,
0.856446385383606,
0.6115761995315552,
-0.4604285657405853,
0.43862447142601013,
0.4564702808856964,
-0.5589727759361267,
0.32462868094444275,
-0.3219486474990845,
0.06435106694698334,
-0.2035311460494995,
-0.000722744211088866,
-0.6050351858139038,
-0.008134108036756516,
0.233377143740654,
-0.2798888087272644,
0.31919553875923157,
-0.12793569266796112,
-0.8480222225189209,
0.031039860099554062,
-0.17464661598205566,
0.6141951084136963,
-0.10770831257104874,
-0.7545139193534851,
0.7886771559715271,
0.14659419655799866,
-0.4021354615688324,
-0.9895992875099182,
-0.6560032963752747,
0.5102120041847229,
0.10403785854578018,
-0.8656609654426575,
0.2903071641921997,
-0.20501506328582764,
-0.24684837460517883,
0.18160398304462433,
-0.050809964537620544,
-0.031178288161754608,
-0.16209770739078522,
-0.4107877314090729,
0.2864760160446167,
-0.31424614787101746,
0.2027931660413742,
0.5714771151542664,
-0.11935141682624817,
-0.06054544448852539,
-0.2929517924785614,
0.2556881010532379,
0.02340914122760296,
-0.5974361300468445,
-0.34622952342033386,
0.3387920558452606,
0.7917197942733765,
-0.6028792262077332,
0.9527940154075623,
0.490998774766922,
-0.41806283593177795,
0.09293957054615021,
-0.9058510661125183,
0.03372989222407341,
-0.4299173653125763,
0.5184807777404785,
-0.6058604121208191,
-0.8535321354866028,
0.797461986541748,
-0.07705360651016235,
0.05070579797029495,
0.3396245837211609,
0.27085769176483154,
0.2789199650287628,
0.7330628037452698,
0.44675421714782715,
-0.1521521657705307,
0.08871275186538696,
0.0791671872138977,
0.26253628730773926,
-0.7351813912391663,
-0.2507685124874115,
-0.3595229685306549,
-0.2067512720823288,
-0.31297722458839417,
-0.6842401623725891,
0.5218183994293213,
0.23873069882392883,
0.17778488993644714,
0.21556906402111053,
0.02594757080078125,
0.8238292932510376,
0.43114975094795227,
0.2618095278739929,
0.4048909842967987,
-0.05876705050468445,
-0.5940122008323669,
-0.029453234747052193,
-1.0345313549041748,
-0.22848770022392273,
0.8083566427230835,
-0.02408440038561821,
0.21704387664794922,
0.2578730583190918,
0.3403434753417969,
0.20325343310832977,
0.25082144141197205,
-0.650134801864624,
0.6537327170372009,
-0.15819263458251953,
-0.6236440539360046,
-0.17933277785778046,
-0.4597295820713043,
-0.28526219725608826,
0.44947510957717896,
-0.3655710220336914,
-0.5140457153320312,
0.3680272698402405,
0.20793090760707855,
-0.3263687193393707,
0.9263859391212463,
-0.7782919406890869,
0.9824080467224121,
-0.10110539942979813,
-0.5048350691795349,
-0.7090399265289307,
-0.6278412938117981,
0.19110341370105743,
-0.27446848154067993,
0.4348982274532318,
0.06857940554618835,
-0.003318130737170577,
0.3428075313568115,
-0.26996180415153503,
0.7345578074455261,
-0.18689031898975372,
-0.16156192123889923,
0.159947469830513,
0.3030158579349518,
0.5324031710624695,
0.5296622514724731,
-0.40269234776496887,
0.3266585171222687,
-0.173345148563385,
-0.5839020013809204,
-0.7434548139572144,
0.8338955044746399,
-0.5764284729957581,
-0.6398289799690247,
-0.3402835428714752,
-0.7291699051856995,
-0.41975608468055725,
0.32289984822273254,
0.08844511955976486,
0.5949106812477112,
-0.41035351157188416,
-0.0833994448184967,
0.7479177117347717,
-0.49281546473503113,
0.38030385971069336,
0.6044153571128845,
-0.20267987251281738,
-0.5877290964126587,
0.8785279393196106,
0.23797990381717682,
0.38553929328918457,
0.5824114680290222,
0.1078454852104187,
-0.3038921654224396,
-0.5448648929595947,
-0.6939519643783569,
0.3636671304702759,
-1.047122836112976,
-0.029426217079162598,
-0.9105924367904663,
-0.0353209562599659,
-0.35373738408088684,
-0.3281181752681732,
-0.3807397484779358,
-0.42539021372795105,
0.09700718522071838,
-0.19296850264072418,
0.39027589559555054,
0.42472079396247864,
-0.6013643741607666,
0.23812144994735718,
-0.9238601922988892,
0.7642219066619873,
0.5251505970954895,
0.48602503538131714,
-0.0019379875157028437,
-0.230378195643425,
-0.43044450879096985,
0.40358778834342957,
0.05318981036543846,
-0.8208641409873962,
-0.1259615570306778,
0.3474024534225464,
0.563467264175415,
0.01717880181968212,
-0.2125006765127182,
0.8313087821006775,
-0.879474937915802,
0.5405791401863098,
0.28471049666404724,
-1.0711957216262817,
0.3653181195259094,
-0.2822921574115753,
0.4582245349884033,
0.6800987124443054,
0.30394458770751953,
-0.8170587420463562,
-0.3233006000518799,
-0.3436571955680847,
-0.4600415825843811,
0.8663942813873291,
0.04332843795418739,
0.12055206298828125,
-0.16506950557231903,
0.5659617185592651,
0.17630213499069214,
0.32318317890167236,
-0.7388200759887695,
-0.4644218981266022,
-0.22982604801654816,
0.09010423719882965,
-0.21902994811534882,
-0.5252030491828918,
-0.21649441123008728,
-0.6072260141372681,
0.927950382232666,
-0.16448578238487244,
0.11276587098836899,
0.32465633749961853,
-0.29594674706459045,
-0.09665049612522125,
0.41187357902526855,
0.8489646911621094,
1.0069490671157837,
-0.11478091031312943,
0.17068570852279663,
0.5710672736167908,
-0.37684911489486694,
0.17148932814598083,
-0.027465879917144775,
-0.365036278963089,
0.2929304838180542,
0.31655678153038025,
1.0454535484313965,
0.3823562562465668,
-0.22283320128917694,
0.20477405190467834,
-0.06744258850812912,
-0.29212820529937744,
-0.010388607159256935,
-0.1009194552898407,
0.3507910668849945,
0.2616516947746277,
0.023458683863282204,
0.9816312789916992,
-0.1188160628080368,
-0.434183269739151,
0.23757261037826538,
0.2812621295452118,
-0.028988245874643326,
-0.3820381164550781,
0.6262470483779907,
-0.21671023964881897,
-0.17457154393196106,
0.309453547000885,
-0.1827351599931717,
-0.5803244113922119,
0.28333860635757446,
0.4252671003341675,
0.7453489303588867,
-0.47028443217277527,
0.38968712091445923,
0.44358447194099426,
0.6280544996261597,
0.011181669309735298,
0.0007082621450535953,
0.028477678075432777,
-1.09781813621521,
-0.8956810832023621,
-0.5247830748558044,
-0.12124640494585037,
-0.12822364270687103,
-0.4923264980316162,
0.34079402685165405,
-0.31738004088401794,
0.06396656483411789,
0.22618889808654785,
-0.49804261326789856,
-0.39254865050315857,
0.13822832703590393,
-0.06770443916320801,
0.9509626626968384,
-0.6148808598518372,
1.0960906744003296,
0.8256812691688538,
-0.03810159116983414,
-0.5586501359939575,
-0.011425845324993134,
-0.1685824990272522,
-0.71628737449646,
0.2897283136844635,
-0.2200540453195572,
-0.37723299860954285,
0.050118133425712585,
-0.20023542642593384,
-0.6879726648330688,
0.8684284687042236,
0.770643413066864,
-0.3664284646511078,
0.024148013442754745,
0.30248287320137024,
0.43530556559562683,
0.18573692440986633,
0.009188930504024029,
0.2721654772758484,
0.6876521110534668,
0.0017638239078223705,
-0.7699998021125793,
-0.22343599796295166,
-0.2183634638786316,
-0.18047218024730682,
0.3202522397041321,
-0.7797324657440186,
0.502615749835968,
-0.21178601682186127,
0.11592844128608704,
-0.27795499563217163,
0.6913414597511292,
0.007231414783746004,
0.13932539522647858,
0.4816807508468628,
0.7856391668319702,
0.8017006516456604,
0.2062225341796875,
0.7607967257499695,
-0.576743483543396,
0.314402312040329,
1.263013243675232,
-0.38240551948547363,
0.6251978278160095,
0.4103465974330902,
0.1112743392586708,
0.3234543800354004,
0.2242937833070755,
0.21844634413719177,
0.4342331290245056,
-0.4386739432811737,
-0.8386132717132568,
-0.37794578075408936,
0.07866771519184113,
-0.30634576082229614,
0.4058220684528351,
0.17194408178329468,
-0.05604178458452225,
-0.35591644048690796,
0.1732783019542694,
0.36449024081230164,
0.08214899897575378,
-0.348913311958313,
0.6735814213752747,
-0.15986457467079163,
-0.6769765019416809,
0.5664064288139343,
0.3371121287345886,
0.3947307765483856,
-0.8888356685638428,
0.07858633995056152,
-0.09107150882482529,
0.0397423692047596,
-0.130111426115036,
-0.7966803312301636,
0.5461777448654175,
0.03674895316362381,
-0.4340185821056366,
-0.2726709842681885,
0.8806489109992981,
-0.5653523206710815,
-0.6877145767211914,
0.7637940049171448,
0.4940313994884491,
-0.4560683071613312,
-0.13881830871105194,
-0.7786010503768921,
-0.13817285001277924,
0.3150692582130432,
-0.1902783215045929,
0.44515493512153625,
0.7983765602111816,
0.2849136292934418,
0.5710709691047668,
0.8110103011131287,
0.12372452765703201,
0.2528479993343353,
-0.03302028030157089,
0.8480319976806641,
-0.6960098147392273,
-0.45904356241226196,
-1.074639081954956,
0.5181362628936768,
-0.07092086225748062,
-0.20034003257751465,
0.7596035003662109,
0.6821796894073486,
0.8919371366500854,
-0.26879286766052246,
0.8578500151634216,
-0.015026739798486233,
0.24320131540298462,
-0.7844153642654419,
1.0018216371536255,
-0.6088934540748596,
0.010980453342199326,
-0.2778284549713135,
-0.9999595284461975,
-0.42327243089675903,
0.40593650937080383,
-0.21539020538330078,
-0.3508967459201813,
0.9292556643486023,
1.0580129623413086,
-0.3262755274772644,
0.26557719707489014,
0.4256274104118347,
0.6346647143363953,
0.014877215959131718,
0.2750120759010315,
0.6190038323402405,
-0.2727150321006775,
0.35276806354522705,
-0.68822181224823,
-0.04458943009376526,
0.3090261220932007,
-0.8147186040878296,
-0.7160234451293945,
-0.4544543921947479,
-0.4289938509464264,
-0.186767578125,
0.17665179073810577,
0.8598185777664185,
0.2804398238658905,
-0.7687294483184814,
-0.20633277297019958,
0.1477825790643692,
0.29969123005867004,
-0.3469843864440918,
-0.11864445358514786,
0.3933528661727905,
-0.3848395049571991,
-0.4908071756362915,
0.8985018730163574,
0.5547149777412415,
-0.32730990648269653,
0.16305667161941528,
0.04284266009926796,
-0.8585865497589111,
-0.04515864700078964,
0.8088430762290955,
0.20883809030056,
-0.5450108647346497,
-0.4408848285675049,
-0.0428452305495739,
0.07975152134895325,
0.2662320137023926,
0.7829210162162781,
-0.5099294185638428,
0.7588396072387695,
0.4077375531196594,
0.7830877304077148,
0.20970074832439423,
-0.2750947177410126,
0.2968789041042328,
-0.7865674495697021,
0.2892661988735199,
-0.034993983805179596,
0.6205732822418213,
0.24909023940563202,
-0.21082709729671478,
0.09427405893802643,
0.5942116975784302,
-0.5524235367774963,
-0.5334800481796265,
0.1302492916584015,
-1.0714772939682007,
-0.33707395195961,
1.0772124528884888,
-0.2414696216583252,
-0.2317872792482376,
-0.13494925200939178,
-0.36534610390663147,
0.5549780130386353,
0.046209532767534256,
0.6776440739631653,
0.9110776782035828,
0.20414304733276367,
0.05702216178178787,
-0.6657778024673462,
0.28261271119117737,
0.6093690395355225,
-0.5557761788368225,
0.1933239996433258,
0.7096193432807922,
0.2693241536617279,
0.3156696856021881,
0.4641008973121643,
-0.006359327584505081,
0.45376503467559814,
-0.09532000124454498,
0.37134960293769836,
-0.14337030053138733,
-0.5750220417976379,
-0.23692525923252106,
0.22117064893245697,
0.08469261974096298,
0.2016637623310089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16408v1 | A Symmetry Property of Christoffel Words | 2024-06-24T08:05:21 | 2024-06-24T08:05:21 | Yan Lanciault, Christophe Reutenauer | math.CO | math.CO, cs.CL | Motivated by the theory of trapezoidal words, whose sequences of cardinality
of factors by length are symmetric, we introduce a bivariate variant of this
symmetry. We show that this symmetry characterizes Christoffel words, and
establish other related results. | [
-0.22817926108837128,
-0.10326732695102692,
0.451158732175827,
0.43039998412132263,
-0.5478319525718689,
0.2910458445549011,
-0.2625837028026581,
-0.03091978281736374,
0.5393850207328796,
0.6062272787094116,
-0.590419352054596,
-0.6020559668540955,
-0.7579712271690369,
0.2050333321094513,
-0.49543991684913635,
0.9757779836654663,
-0.4173688590526581,
0.6408897638320923,
0.2884349822998047,
-0.6585984230041504,
-0.36146292090415955,
-0.24597370624542236,
0.08201807737350464,
-0.2764614224433899,
0.7736577391624451,
0.32662704586982727,
1.345626711845398,
0.804499626159668,
0.4386232793331146,
0.3155243992805481,
0.4678376317024231,
0.011351080611348152,
-0.5101229548454285,
0.5121232271194458,
-0.1372900754213333,
-0.8729142546653748,
0.03320695459842682,
-0.008374477736651897,
0.4224448502063751,
1.1833417415618896,
-0.3847999572753906,
0.10374436527490616,
0.24116654694080353,
0.716462254524231,
-0.06635111570358276,
0.059277161955833435,
-0.6088598370552063,
-0.33541908860206604,
-0.49614784121513367,
-0.18201249837875366,
0.14870372414588928,
-0.33273664116859436,
-0.21928264200687408,
-0.7365419864654541,
0.687279462814331,
0.3592310845851898,
0.9105879068374634,
-0.09259727597236633,
-0.015294232405722141,
-0.5825636386871338,
-0.6377975940704346,
1.080332636833191,
-0.41187962889671326,
0.8583509922027588,
0.49870428442955017,
0.03474672511219978,
-0.27855509519577026,
-0.469827264547348,
-0.629970908164978,
-0.21597784757614136,
-0.3303939700126648,
0.32444971799850464,
-0.13930021226406097,
-0.02268870733678341,
0.5343450903892517,
0.23361042141914368,
-1.1986323595046997,
-0.5735255479812622,
-0.39529919624328613,
0.3533099889755249,
1.0942553281784058,
0.2876497805118561,
0.637906014919281,
0.07670923322439194,
-0.34690171480178833,
-0.09756679832935333,
-0.7238225936889648,
0.08128538727760315,
0.5931723117828369,
0.32150518894195557,
-0.044616758823394775,
0.8659813404083252,
0.2895265519618988,
0.6825854182243347,
-0.13738732039928436,
-0.1981036514043808,
0.12496206909418106,
-0.2980368435382843,
0.06082605570554733,
0.136204332113266,
0.3217664957046509,
-0.02981354109942913,
0.4234711527824402,
-0.6023719906806946,
-0.18772894144058228,
0.5020368695259094,
0.14850351214408875,
-0.6522546410560608,
-0.2168494015932083,
-0.16847527027130127,
-0.7427507638931274,
0.071542888879776,
1.151780366897583,
-0.7160630226135254,
0.04189673438668251,
-0.25765180587768555,
0.04944482445716858,
-0.32940348982810974,
0.09814711660146713,
0.5920522212982178,
-0.5891339778900146,
-0.1308950036764145,
-0.16037005186080933,
-1.0615551471710205,
0.6482133269309998,
1.177175760269165,
0.8259465098381042,
-0.11011606454849243,
-0.37669119238853455,
-0.3494240939617157,
0.23362550139427185,
-0.9001784324645996,
0.44839221239089966,
-1.0704350471496582,
-1.053968906402588,
0.2519291639328003,
0.4293726980686188,
0.21999423205852509,
-0.3590817451477051,
0.4771144688129425,
-0.3970685601234436,
0.05568224936723709,
-0.7862335443496704,
-0.5592865347862244,
-0.23432384431362152,
-0.10200200229883194,
-0.24542151391506195,
0.31781670451164246,
0.4086771309375763,
-0.5422844290733337,
0.6693724393844604,
-0.010779431089758873,
-0.5730311274528503,
0.3992294371128082,
-0.7422925233840942,
-0.3679368793964386,
0.7683647274971008,
-0.49364617466926575,
-0.11339756846427917,
-0.4612889289855957,
-0.07626136392354965,
-0.5605025291442871,
-0.3712567687034607,
0.2517327070236206,
0.22674331068992615,
1.035256266593933,
0.29251715540885925,
-0.38068974018096924,
-0.169850692152977,
-0.6895098686218262,
-0.052705008536577225,
0.058569371700286865,
-0.03951165825128555,
-0.8591349720954895,
0.47928592562675476,
-0.011833852156996727,
-0.09414088726043701,
-0.11692280322313309,
-1.0203536748886108,
0.5779324173927307,
-0.30830466747283936,
-0.2068043351173401,
0.599388599395752,
0.06675388664007187,
0.2458604872226715,
-0.6979005932807922,
0.953065812587738,
0.2500731348991394,
-0.010111537761986256,
0.20409221947193146,
-0.6567221283912659,
-0.42770224809646606,
-0.6439749598503113,
-0.03604571521282196,
0.36456099152565,
-0.5345799326896667,
0.42285314202308655,
-0.22740520536899567,
-0.31714099645614624,
-0.18830858170986176,
0.7178956270217896,
0.39219942688941956,
-0.2134864330291748,
0.15870024263858795,
-0.4094100594520569,
-0.30102136731147766,
-1.079927921295166,
-0.6100279092788696,
-0.10421399772167206,
-0.17605865001678467,
0.009774545207619667,
0.27493128180503845,
0.007495177909731865,
0.793406069278717,
-1.0847781896591187,
-0.2822958827018738,
-0.03675593063235283,
0.563488781452179,
0.6267659068107605,
0.18326158821582794,
1.3358745574951172,
-0.6763215661048889,
-0.574834942817688,
-0.18682913482189178,
-0.28222599625587463,
-0.0835934653878212,
-0.19984151422977448,
-0.29536721110343933,
-0.21920955181121826,
0.2609117031097412,
-0.6291753649711609,
0.816045880317688,
0.3843889832496643,
-0.776538074016571,
0.3585815727710724,
-0.13846081495285034,
-0.2373560667037964,
-1.2039119005203247,
-0.3088158667087555,
-0.19871462881565094,
-0.022616034373641014,
-0.7072622179985046,
-0.25499147176742554,
-0.08677279204130173,
0.12888705730438232,
0.07495300471782684,
0.043338511139154434,
-0.7392830848693848,
-0.13218340277671814,
-0.40094804763793945,
0.008900068700313568,
0.032784439623355865,
0.11178844422101974,
0.19122350215911865,
0.5270565748214722,
0.803512692451477,
-0.4233096241950989,
0.43190997838974,
0.8034224510192871,
-0.2099601775407791,
0.9492631554603577,
-0.5942186713218689,
-0.7577884197235107,
-0.5127860307693481,
-0.18363817036151886,
-1.0676804780960083,
0.2544383406639099,
-0.0859946683049202,
-0.21564628183841705,
0.31763309240341187,
0.2692777216434479,
-0.42346349358558655,
-0.6634261012077332,
-0.6202973127365112,
0.42760756611824036,
0.2822652757167816,
-0.5948625206947327,
-0.206767275929451,
-0.13984671235084534,
-0.10555288195610046,
-0.6791951060295105,
-0.7700495719909668,
-0.20872555673122406,
-0.1795235425233841,
-0.3735373914241791,
0.5242359638214111,
-0.31759828329086304,
-0.4848859906196594,
-0.09106611460447311,
0.20440331101417542,
0.28878629207611084,
-0.24126270413398743,
0.2658334970474243,
0.4509246349334717,
-0.1582021713256836,
0.380188524723053,
0.1272381693124771,
0.3003438711166382,
0.0871235653758049,
-0.5569460391998291,
0.5067790746688843,
0.11514541506767273,
-0.23825106024742126,
0.10734499990940094,
0.9415956735610962,
0.6199898719787598,
-0.014237646013498306,
0.5842199325561523,
0.17343130707740784,
-0.730708122253418,
-0.3154620826244354,
-0.06866873055696487,
-0.3259570002555847,
-0.4633544683456421,
0.2938656210899353,
-0.13604891300201416,
-0.5843492746353149,
0.585023045539856,
0.44577664136886597,
-0.014758694916963577,
0.23589414358139038,
0.28636467456817627,
-0.13921864330768585,
1.456963300704956,
0.6155214905738831,
0.12339907139539719,
0.22548966109752655,
-0.24095971882343292,
0.7579339742660522,
-0.7263707518577576,
-0.21012286841869354,
-0.7060522437095642,
-0.3700900375843048,
-1.2079856395721436,
0.0473521463572979,
0.11395923793315887,
0.5466550588607788,
-0.5249921083450317,
0.5416877269744873,
-0.13491806387901306,
0.05383165180683136,
0.26630160212516785,
-0.2255631685256958,
-0.017505357041954994,
0.08234165608882904,
-0.14675624668598175,
-0.4672980010509491,
-0.3977440893650055,
-0.4634109437465668,
0.44280359148979187,
0.023437203839421272,
1.1731457710266113,
0.6194555759429932,
0.7113392949104309,
0.1509387195110321,
0.6123940348625183,
-0.556816816329956,
0.41758066415786743,
-0.5503457188606262,
-0.8002799153327942,
0.0011736173182725906,
-0.057629190385341644,
-1.2896778583526611,
-0.2651897668838501,
-0.22535626590251923,
-1.0268170833587646,
0.9744300246238708,
-0.11525167524814606,
0.06688125431537628,
0.3731071352958679,
0.24861247837543488,
0.6354383230209351,
-0.5386868119239807,
-0.15004996955394745,
-0.059599369764328,
-0.48646506667137146,
0.28577080368995667,
0.14466853439807892,
-0.16106347739696503,
-0.07462149858474731,
-0.11563562601804733,
0.5425838232040405,
-0.955403208732605,
0.34481024742126465,
0.2511207163333893,
0.09256812185049057,
0.2039419561624527,
0.45836538076400757,
0.4083564579486847,
0.30555638670921326,
0.1669287085533142,
0.2479465752840042,
0.3751954138278961,
-0.5902600884437561,
-0.7379869222640991,
0.8830151557922363,
-0.5468603372573853,
-0.40254896879196167,
-0.696715772151947,
-0.3804895877838135,
-0.4168344736099243,
0.17262838780879974,
0.6173706650733948,
0.5914648771286011,
-0.2209644764661789,
0.29913294315338135,
0.22593466937541962,
-0.10718728601932526,
0.8647884130477905,
0.24383139610290527,
-0.9944114685058594,
-0.43205660581588745,
0.6424757838249207,
0.40924376249313354,
-0.008829918690025806,
0.37256401777267456,
0.2596089839935303,
-0.23076175153255463,
-0.013280465267598629,
-0.4168626070022583,
0.5817409753799438,
0.16771121323108673,
-0.2963988184928894,
-0.1413998305797577,
-0.11485324054956436,
-0.32801106572151184,
-0.6556980013847351,
-0.22501255571842194,
-0.519290566444397,
-0.21547316014766693,
-0.22084470093250275,
0.27883583307266235,
1.204032301902771,
-0.25620418787002563,
0.4284818172454834,
-0.7222387790679932,
0.4499453604221344,
0.4919775426387787,
0.4574633240699768,
-0.4113917946815491,
-0.4416446387767792,
0.02762853540480137,
0.02254597470164299,
-0.3342018723487854,
-1.493414044380188,
0.413669228553772,
0.326943039894104,
0.573877215385437,
1.1607494354248047,
-0.019217094406485558,
0.43843531608581543,
-0.2965514063835144,
0.756751537322998,
0.9284461140632629,
-0.8375383019447327,
-0.023132801055908203,
-0.6409109830856323,
0.15318603813648224,
0.3052728772163391,
0.6210209131240845,
-0.6864306330680847,
-0.2538031041622162,
-0.6940047144889832,
-0.3496512472629547,
0.13359378278255463,
0.5089802145957947,
0.3063806891441345,
-0.54537433385849,
0.3400397002696991,
0.4569094181060791,
0.7409369349479675,
-0.08893630653619766,
-0.8619218468666077,
-0.876591682434082,
-0.477509081363678,
-0.26458531618118286,
-0.5492899417877197,
-0.36748164892196655,
-0.17264220118522644,
0.5974221229553223,
0.02398592419922352,
0.3563384413719177,
0.13586319983005524,
0.10849640518426895,
-0.119891457259655,
0.37689730525016785,
1.158806324005127,
1.3520405292510986,
-0.029876362532377243,
0.33770087361335754,
-0.1624932736158371,
-0.8365598320960999,
0.14887894690036774,
0.34070664644241333,
-0.40523600578308105,
0.3973395526409149,
0.40243372321128845,
0.514285147190094,
-0.13835777342319489,
-0.21791484951972961,
0.5787954926490784,
0.038338616490364075,
-0.320369690656662,
-0.26481208205223083,
-0.13655196130275726,
-0.10548212379217148,
0.10460463166236877,
0.11642207205295563,
-0.10099724680185318,
0.15020611882209778,
-0.9487667679786682,
0.37708941102027893,
0.7757059931755066,
-0.7539588809013367,
-0.6535982489585876,
0.4740966260433197,
-0.49440985918045044,
-0.6219449043273926,
0.5217475891113281,
-0.34061893820762634,
-0.8106827735900879,
0.2681380808353424,
0.7688233256340027,
0.7823842167854309,
-0.6409677267074585,
0.6225968599319458,
0.47678157687187195,
0.16700810194015503,
0.021174779161810875,
1.0734827518463135,
0.06224538013339043,
-0.7385848760604858,
0.5416235327720642,
-0.9756129384040833,
0.4049895107746124,
-0.20206277072429657,
-0.8767786622047424,
0.10832224786281586,
-0.5803754329681396,
-0.2577674388885498,
-0.207426518201828,
-0.35533803701400757,
-0.5006835460662842,
0.12958680093288422,
0.07972985506057739,
0.7660320401191711,
-0.6884332895278931,
0.6203486919403076,
0.7050254344940186,
-0.3095582127571106,
-0.9008780717849731,
0.01389379519969225,
-0.19492048025131226,
-0.6377037763595581,
0.8131749033927917,
-0.034026701003313065,
-0.43547141551971436,
-0.5823612809181213,
-0.7113713026046753,
-0.7732807993888855,
0.8910946249961853,
0.1967441737651825,
-0.794521152973175,
0.21008217334747314,
0.7807160019874573,
0.7809675931930542,
-0.6632306575775146,
-0.37340018153190613,
0.20232519507408142,
0.7277188897132874,
-0.12858253717422485,
-0.10367681086063385,
-0.06656554341316223,
0.005799452308565378,
0.5665938258171082,
0.4019307494163513,
-0.7846418619155884,
0.4854114353656769,
-0.1916612982749939,
-0.2610548138618469,
0.2197665423154831,
0.9183260202407837,
-0.04018012061715126,
0.1390409618616104,
0.391482949256897,
0.7524608969688416,
0.5322262048721313,
-0.13221541047096252,
0.8917652368545532,
-1.0111573934555054,
0.594939649105072,
0.5988787412643433,
-0.19388750195503235,
0.5110393762588501,
0.5167868733406067,
-0.31612837314605713,
0.6859824657440186,
0.23661449551582336,
-0.0833437368273735,
0.48707762360572815,
0.6784762740135193,
-0.5635045766830444,
-0.5224934220314026,
-0.025498639792203903,
-0.14499147236347198,
0.8617469072341919,
0.20825639367103577,
-0.5098342299461365,
-0.15779870748519897,
-0.371609628200531,
0.33773180842399597,
0.5848575234413147,
-0.2780773937702179,
0.32786521315574646,
0.6274464130401611,
-0.8116056323051453,
0.17337103188037872,
-0.0036955163814127445,
0.14421966671943665,
-0.7013033032417297,
-0.25051793456077576,
-0.04900842159986496,
0.39470672607421875,
-0.14348053932189941,
-0.7881960272789001,
0.4826023280620575,
-0.5241209864616394,
-0.19502195715904236,
-0.09145618975162506,
0.34759223461151123,
-0.7311205267906189,
-1.1397860050201416,
0.4392850697040558,
0.15326790511608124,
-0.37537968158721924,
0.4637949764728546,
-0.6148461103439331,
-0.42322099208831787,
-0.238133504986763,
-0.16108039021492004,
-0.4096549153327942,
-0.026984283700585365,
0.020788101479411125,
0.12148478627204895,
0.3659798502922058,
0.2548236548900604,
0.3686480224132538,
-0.1206309124827385,
0.5527108907699585,
-0.7892234921455383,
-0.6578758358955383,
-0.8319889903068542,
0.08318550884723663,
-0.13139189779758453,
-0.4569949507713318,
0.42194294929504395,
0.6945823431015015,
0.6861464977264404,
-0.29820016026496887,
0.6387256979942322,
0.039889685809612274,
0.6073184013366699,
-0.07519087940454483,
0.9590361714363098,
-0.622116208076477,
-0.16958963871002197,
-0.2604503929615021,
-1.4373310804367065,
-0.3880803883075714,
0.6684761643409729,
-0.1802329421043396,
0.20846468210220337,
1.056911587715149,
0.7406824231147766,
-0.2534218430519104,
0.34892043471336365,
0.5983530879020691,
0.22132916748523712,
0.03825036808848381,
0.006261398084461689,
0.5649604201316833,
-0.31584230065345764,
0.0617520697414875,
-0.04223644360899925,
-0.2195989340543747,
0.07434027642011642,
-0.5126631855964661,
-0.8121011853218079,
-1.1763616800308228,
-0.17782321572303772,
-0.27771803736686707,
0.3461919128894806,
0.49635937809944153,
0.620368480682373,
-0.7837033867835999,
-0.4241560697555542,
-0.42793089151382446,
0.11367551237344742,
-0.3081425130367279,
-0.12339095771312714,
0.32717016339302063,
0.13122420012950897,
-0.164387509226799,
-0.21333515644073486,
0.6672605276107788,
0.127197265625,
-0.15817591547966003,
-0.19847992062568665,
-0.07026059180498123,
0.6094450354576111,
0.26299890875816345,
0.34259462356567383,
-0.44807228446006775,
-0.6136603355407715,
-0.028136327862739563,
-0.16171610355377197,
0.1690673679113388,
1.3448481559753418,
0.04414781555533409,
0.22212101519107819,
0.9107733964920044,
-0.07211259007453918,
0.17136403918266296,
0.4533798098564148,
0.4315328896045685,
-0.40531235933303833,
-0.0063469805754721165,
0.0031251150649040937,
0.8134778738021851,
0.09195248037576675,
-0.35329028964042664,
0.02617492340505123,
0.5343679785728455,
-0.24552644789218903,
-0.34773778915405273,
1.0084459781646729,
-1.1115864515304565,
-0.004891164600849152,
0.8093207478523254,
-0.2824222445487976,
-0.03443194925785065,
0.014438978396356106,
0.04145807772874832,
0.09459799528121948,
0.07505302131175995,
0.6660946011543274,
0.7168207168579102,
-0.08227720856666565,
-0.11676331609487534,
-0.1586712896823883,
0.3689275085926056,
0.5646278858184814,
-0.44022977352142334,
0.035015005618333817,
0.06863925606012344,
0.3379051089286804,
0.513065755367279,
-0.17232784628868103,
-0.3008228838443756,
0.161824032664299,
-0.12123574316501617,
0.01482966635376215,
0.3025890290737152,
-0.4580932855606079,
0.12718059122562408,
0.043657515197992325,
0.22098374366760254,
-0.34355685114860535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16382v1 | UNO Arena for Evaluating Sequential Decision-Making Capability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-24T07:47:34 | 2024-06-24T07:47:34 | Zhanyue Qin, Haochuan Wang, Deyuan Liu, Ziyang Song, Cunhang Fan, Zhao Lv, Jinlin Wu, Zhen Lei, Zhiying Tu, Dianhui Chu, Xiaoyan Yu, Dianbo Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sequential decision-making refers to algorithms that take into account the
dynamics of the environment, where early decisions affect subsequent decisions.
With large language models (LLMs) demonstrating powerful capabilities between
tasks, we can't help but ask: Can Current LLMs Effectively Make Sequential
Decisions? In order to answer this question, we propose the UNO Arena based on
the card game UNO to evaluate the sequential decision-making capability of LLMs
and explain in detail why we choose UNO. In UNO Arena, We evaluate the
sequential decision-making capability of LLMs dynamically with novel metrics
based Monte Carlo methods. We set up random players, DQN-based reinforcement
learning players, and LLM players (e.g. GPT-4, Gemini-pro) for comparison
testing. Furthermore, in order to improve the sequential decision-making
capability of LLMs, we propose the TUTRI player, which can involves having LLMs
reflect their own actions wtih the summary of game history and the game
strategy. Numerous experiments demonstrate that the TUTRI player achieves a
notable breakthrough in the performance of sequential decision-making compared
to the vanilla LLM player. | [
-0.3749651610851288,
-0.8622556924819946,
0.6892254948616028,
0.5151486396789551,
-0.221086323261261,
0.29236841201782227,
-0.3182428777217865,
-0.30200961232185364,
-0.07388719171285629,
0.31516745686531067,
-0.30188313126564026,
-0.19609135389328003,
-0.2939957082271576,
0.4081982672214508,
-0.08612930029630661,
0.843683123588562,
-0.061442092061042786,
0.14147882163524628,
-0.2787015736103058,
-0.18922333419322968,
-0.7525414824485779,
-0.3214700520038605,
-1.1929315328598022,
-0.6593481302261353,
0.49860209226608276,
0.48223215341567993,
0.6585016846656799,
0.42938241362571716,
0.47302010655403137,
0.5667053461074829,
0.000019751185391214676,
-0.0022101025097072124,
-0.5660915970802307,
0.060939595103263855,
-0.46896153688430786,
-0.7273288369178772,
-0.4738703668117523,
-0.006415145006030798,
1.0931779146194458,
0.33193233609199524,
-0.1972467005252838,
0.10982493311166763,
-0.03782234713435173,
0.6004572510719299,
-0.11937164515256882,
0.19292578101158142,
-0.5027838945388794,
0.30917516350746155,
-0.09270554780960083,
-0.3442835807800293,
-0.4259679615497589,
-0.1544048935174942,
0.09563539922237396,
-0.7114003300666809,
-0.21453073620796204,
0.24878807365894318,
0.16207152605056763,
0.2937685549259186,
-0.1648155301809311,
-0.02026331052184105,
-1.1042042970657349,
0.5931198596954346,
-0.5470083951950073,
0.34140846133232117,
0.0019246761221438646,
0.28378933668136597,
-0.3743414282798767,
-0.7525477409362793,
-0.6160619854927063,
-0.48263078927993774,
0.13698391616344452,
0.3333504796028137,
-0.08686315268278122,
0.05134463682770729,
0.6869309544563293,
0.10887462645769119,
-0.5227944850921631,
0.5935004353523254,
-0.3174763321876526,
0.22081445157527924,
0.8847959041595459,
0.27564936876296997,
-0.01846231333911419,
0.11106850951910019,
-0.37467268109321594,
-0.13058345019817352,
-0.4329349100589752,
0.16513656079769135,
0.24601450562477112,
-0.1621059626340866,
0.05309812352061272,
0.5315267443656921,
-0.20722779631614685,
0.5656396746635437,
0.05880611762404442,
-0.3530460596084595,
0.0588768795132637,
0.17962034046649933,
-0.33911675214767456,
0.019906889647245407,
1.0248093605041504,
0.31255966424942017,
0.2084130048751831,
-0.266299843788147,
-0.26470088958740234,
0.274304062128067,
0.13582991063594818,
-0.5378636121749878,
0.004926005844026804,
0.24361377954483032,
-0.4331130087375641,
-0.29028797149658203,
0.08489181101322174,
-0.8481904864311218,
-0.49130627512931824,
-0.12911126017570496,
0.5525249242782593,
-0.3466663062572479,
-0.09192723780870438,
-0.20119082927703857,
-0.0644567459821701,
0.16200560331344604,
0.3547527492046356,
-0.5224938988685608,
0.4859431982040405,
0.6539746522903442,
0.7123202085494995,
-0.4460335671901703,
-0.48504093289375305,
-0.8710389733314514,
-0.1774098128080368,
-0.4836859703063965,
0.9323766827583313,
-0.6298618316650391,
-0.7519574165344238,
-0.18326641619205475,
-0.2404962033033371,
0.16525839269161224,
-0.5628195405006409,
0.5225343704223633,
-0.42414161562919617,
-0.12827421724796295,
-0.09501183778047562,
-0.4815194606781006,
-0.13257278501987457,
0.19596627354621887,
-0.7282423973083496,
0.9220553636550903,
-0.17468681931495667,
-0.3891869783401489,
0.5755430459976196,
-0.6735432147979736,
-0.4723259210586548,
0.6061964631080627,
-0.4301968812942505,
-0.38559576869010925,
0.43360331654548645,
-0.22956639528274536,
0.2610548734664917,
-0.29929858446121216,
0.238599956035614,
-0.325944185256958,
-0.4522789716720581,
0.6324276328086853,
-0.32912689447402954,
0.3191407322883606,
0.24360769987106323,
-0.36544179916381836,
0.29382941126823425,
-0.7253046035766602,
0.0978718176484108,
0.014820857904851437,
-0.39798107743263245,
-0.2582322359085083,
0.5838634967803955,
-0.5544940829277039,
0.21954476833343506,
-0.018594803288578987,
-0.01833353377878666,
0.53741455078125,
-0.051795247942209244,
0.1591431349515915,
0.7578351497650146,
-0.06190862879157066,
0.7125410437583923,
-0.5357315540313721,
0.5032668113708496,
-0.22627776861190796,
0.2760552167892456,
0.01437638234347105,
-0.6799999475479126,
-0.6345360279083252,
-0.04716276004910469,
0.5899125337600708,
0.7681863903999329,
-1.102885365486145,
0.36902472376823425,
-0.17314015328884125,
-0.3826572000980377,
-0.3021603226661682,
-0.05775412172079086,
0.2657347321510315,
0.11788865923881531,
-0.07228054851293564,
-0.7066105604171753,
-0.5586560368537903,
-0.47361910343170166,
-0.062047626823186874,
-0.4633867144584656,
0.17185428738594055,
0.37798747420310974,
0.8543015718460083,
-0.19674454629421234,
0.6834965944290161,
-0.1481286883354187,
-0.3484690189361572,
-0.3487313687801361,
0.44082319736480713,
0.20357416570186615,
0.3629601001739502,
0.38886556029319763,
-0.7557942271232605,
-0.31871557235717773,
0.3118667006492615,
-0.8359784483909607,
-0.09128125011920929,
-0.44204455614089966,
-0.025280077010393143,
0.22949300706386566,
0.4840865731239319,
-0.3705862760543823,
0.7343276739120483,
0.39032983779907227,
-0.32515037059783936,
0.4704608619213104,
-0.7759072780609131,
0.2991805970668793,
-0.48533084988594055,
0.17961694300174713,
-0.2606678605079651,
-0.11199299991130829,
-0.5651006698608398,
0.10231687873601913,
-0.16860920190811157,
0.2993400990962982,
-0.3247837424278259,
0.7614596486091614,
-0.3705638349056244,
-0.5140631794929504,
-0.2499089539051056,
0.21647211909294128,
-0.3889618217945099,
0.4758654832839966,
0.3752458095550537,
0.461509108543396,
0.5505386590957642,
-0.9760295152664185,
0.4589751064777374,
-0.005220151040703058,
-0.8147231936454773,
0.5245606899261475,
-0.589371383190155,
0.15863560140132904,
-0.13283143937587738,
0.22492417693138123,
-0.9119574427604675,
0.1248905211687088,
0.15499666333198547,
-0.41804608702659607,
0.13505280017852783,
-0.04977233335375786,
-0.6873890161514282,
-0.6305142641067505,
-0.04498080536723137,
0.3435462415218353,
0.616717517375946,
-0.22588421404361725,
0.71197909116745,
0.4251110851764679,
-0.1649390012025833,
-0.569327712059021,
-0.4333748519420624,
-0.09163720160722733,
-0.3179998993873596,
-0.32516372203826904,
0.19318661093711853,
-0.5894777178764343,
-0.6541321277618408,
-0.09461934119462967,
0.08841711282730103,
0.17403572797775269,
0.35791856050491333,
0.32491186261177063,
0.19130976498126984,
0.057719290256500244,
-0.08812116086483002,
-0.18062357604503632,
-0.13986438512802124,
-0.01896028034389019,
-0.3931227922439575,
0.4736999273300171,
-0.15790365636348724,
0.049921903759241104,
-0.17783668637275696,
0.11668137460947037,
0.518356442451477,
-0.3863750994205475,
0.8459764122962952,
0.2324279397726059,
-0.18138863146305084,
-0.2620227634906769,
-0.6101593971252441,
0.13532958924770355,
-0.395415335893631,
0.3400639295578003,
-0.32610946893692017,
-0.7485525608062744,
0.972885251045227,
-0.3915491998195648,
0.25713497400283813,
0.32966071367263794,
0.749632716178894,
-0.10100091993808746,
1.0147522687911987,
0.2549867033958435,
0.08495649695396423,
0.3801296055316925,
-0.3772766888141632,
-0.1498454213142395,
-0.711699366569519,
-0.5249011516571045,
-0.4711681604385376,
-0.6467705965042114,
-0.7433767914772034,
-0.562676727771759,
0.47529885172843933,
0.04577590152621269,
-0.25571367144584656,
-0.2017793357372284,
-0.14503134787082672,
0.5916460752487183,
0.4582274854183197,
-0.057112157344818115,
0.47537529468536377,
-0.19922961294651031,
-0.45051777362823486,
0.11965879797935486,
-0.8450257182121277,
-0.2342577874660492,
0.6832804083824158,
0.2239348143339157,
0.7148868441581726,
0.07090231031179428,
0.780551016330719,
0.28444385528564453,
0.7353417277336121,
-0.6848087906837463,
0.7566609978675842,
0.0841166079044342,
-0.46573588252067566,
-0.5584885478019714,
-0.727134644985199,
-1.1712626218795776,
0.45757734775543213,
-0.766132652759552,
-0.7413157820701599,
0.046418558806180954,
-0.20171037316322327,
-0.6506712436676025,
0.5122729539871216,
-0.3687331974506378,
0.7207518219947815,
-0.6544762849807739,
-0.5862833857536316,
-0.183800607919693,
-0.27023911476135254,
0.3835825026035309,
-0.21540610492229462,
0.5049231648445129,
0.19556953012943268,
-0.21210187673568726,
0.8588159680366516,
-0.22482788562774658,
0.30917760729789734,
-0.016176819801330566,
0.11911177635192871,
0.4836658239364624,
0.2661040127277374,
0.3252105116844177,
0.3618896007537842,
-0.09331043809652328,
0.19076858460903168,
-0.2792968153953552,
0.26983290910720825,
-0.6433203220367432,
0.8140008449554443,
-0.8945669531822205,
-0.5668070316314697,
-0.807375967502594,
-0.36056989431381226,
-0.05927620083093643,
0.3921193778514862,
0.4196471869945526,
0.24153898656368256,
-0.7307544946670532,
0.20812755823135376,
0.4456382989883423,
-0.5157326459884644,
0.5287667512893677,
0.8606724143028259,
-0.5527650713920593,
-0.5192432999610901,
0.5546343326568604,
0.26106131076812744,
-0.13565954566001892,
0.5270344018936157,
0.4284100830554962,
-0.4193848669528961,
-0.7227391600608826,
-0.02267414517700672,
0.1338324248790741,
-0.18964967131614685,
-0.2947670519351959,
-0.13445600867271423,
-0.030401835218071938,
-0.10684559494256973,
-0.016599377617239952,
-0.10373540967702866,
-0.14179955422878265,
0.19016045331954956,
-0.10763759911060333,
-0.10048808157444,
1.0041800737380981,
-0.5162827372550964,
0.5164703130722046,
-0.5787230134010315,
0.41744399070739746,
0.5386701822280884,
0.5647311210632324,
0.017346510663628578,
-0.36600738763809204,
0.09941422194242477,
-0.20356005430221558,
-0.1940539926290512,
-0.9338248372077942,
0.39232194423675537,
-0.11168760806322098,
0.7688840627670288,
0.4718789756298065,
-0.09711824357509613,
0.6462619304656982,
-0.8164423108100891,
0.40721359848976135,
0.18415801227092743,
-0.5854595303535461,
0.3070943355560303,
-0.19452904164791107,
0.43176642060279846,
0.48573237657546997,
0.1537369340658188,
-0.5256900191307068,
-0.29223984479904175,
-0.8388691544532776,
-0.4109032154083252,
1.035968542098999,
0.3874130845069885,
-0.42894235253334045,
-0.10550666600465775,
0.3499002754688263,
0.09857330471277237,
0.10918376594781876,
-0.7313743233680725,
-0.4821348190307617,
0.4141952395439148,
0.46605485677719116,
-0.3744117319583893,
-0.23961851000785828,
0.1767219454050064,
-0.27177220582962036,
0.5159813165664673,
0.26823943853378296,
0.3106768727302551,
0.08230138570070267,
0.061285920441150665,
-0.311405211687088,
0.24090486764907837,
0.4389415979385376,
0.638046145439148,
0.005521114449948072,
-0.3066766560077667,
0.5665603280067444,
-0.11514293402433395,
0.0446055606007576,
0.22576622664928436,
-0.2534426748752594,
-0.11301465332508087,
0.1564050167798996,
0.8259248733520508,
0.6114523410797119,
-0.6162183284759521,
0.0870971828699112,
-0.5017760992050171,
-0.35010096430778503,
-0.5606401562690735,
0.1953829824924469,
-0.2735494375228882,
0.6242945194244385,
0.35819119215011597,
0.16620956361293793,
0.08146411180496216,
-0.9887692928314209,
0.25190356373786926,
0.33782345056533813,
0.03704262524843216,
-0.02853836491703987,
0.7003985047340393,
0.2877369821071625,
-0.6514402031898499,
0.8800426721572876,
-0.36998897790908813,
-0.4979228675365448,
0.6068068742752075,
0.37797972559928894,
0.5489503145217896,
-0.681326687335968,
0.4232925772666931,
0.4594206213951111,
0.22804689407348633,
-0.5542951822280884,
0.29132145643234253,
-0.08710925281047821,
-0.7008056044578552,
-0.6892998814582825,
-0.39408639073371887,
-0.33528125286102295,
0.3024856746196747,
-0.5372892022132874,
0.09731003642082214,
-0.778720498085022,
-0.4951866567134857,
-0.1812138855457306,
0.45445165038108826,
-0.8755884170532227,
0.08352947980165482,
0.39061492681503296,
0.9146528840065002,
-0.4169811010360718,
0.6946482062339783,
0.6874532699584961,
-0.07057461142539978,
-0.5007609724998474,
-0.5524402856826782,
-0.13973553478717804,
-0.6453532576560974,
0.6134002804756165,
-0.06274761259555817,
0.22514969110488892,
-0.052252449095249176,
-0.6586683988571167,
-0.532123327255249,
1.1301041841506958,
0.09458805620670319,
-0.8400081992149353,
0.047670841217041016,
-0.060431208461523056,
0.5822573900222778,
-0.27538764476776123,
0.5032607316970825,
0.6289680004119873,
0.6348989605903625,
0.3857322633266449,
-1.0316786766052246,
-0.4987450838088989,
-0.10851763933897018,
-0.08036286383867264,
0.3459116518497467,
-0.6007506251335144,
0.6645127534866333,
-0.6598975658416748,
-0.37095826864242554,
0.5466283559799194,
1.056220531463623,
0.6341531276702881,
0.377121239900589,
0.7034445405006409,
0.787362813949585,
0.9219074845314026,
-0.30256181955337524,
1.1357481479644775,
0.06252675503492355,
0.11069431155920029,
1.026013731956482,
-0.4036503732204437,
1.0098971128463745,
-0.11092260479927063,
-0.08642332255840302,
0.6754632592201233,
0.3180702030658722,
-0.05346318706870079,
0.40272629261016846,
0.3715364336967468,
-0.11612943559885025,
-0.36152902245521545,
0.20348358154296875,
-0.19656316936016083,
0.7171701788902283,
0.4667360186576843,
-0.043458204716444016,
0.11627364903688431,
-0.09149911999702454,
0.0391838364303112,
-0.06550838053226471,
-0.7343734502792358,
0.8970742225646973,
0.07329714298248291,
-1.1216590404510498,
-0.15314771234989166,
0.046685218811035156,
0.39375966787338257,
-0.7423837780952454,
-0.2050277441740036,
-0.32438644766807556,
0.43306058645248413,
-0.055114082992076874,
-0.9592729806900024,
-0.2587874233722687,
0.11323023587465286,
0.26163557171821594,
-0.1169818565249443,
0.36405467987060547,
-0.41235408186912537,
-0.5193024277687073,
0.1838981807231903,
0.48918816447257996,
0.25975897908210754,
0.13274547457695007,
-0.8264511227607727,
0.4430186450481415,
-0.3606063723564148,
0.11113322526216507,
0.285226434469223,
0.7525486946105957,
-0.14336392283439636,
0.6289973855018616,
0.5477985739707947,
0.18604815006256104,
-0.32012301683425903,
0.07667872309684753,
0.2966507077217102,
-0.5238738656044006,
-0.8450907468795776,
-0.8689278364181519,
0.45775675773620605,
-0.15777337551116943,
-0.23875997960567474,
0.547034740447998,
0.622595489025116,
0.8340664505958557,
0.06402759999036789,
0.7513134479522705,
-0.184940367937088,
-0.018534425646066666,
-0.47461998462677,
0.4592486023902893,
-0.4271926283836365,
0.19877786934375763,
-0.25874531269073486,
-1.0917664766311646,
-0.30065521597862244,
1.0591866970062256,
-0.36587560176849365,
0.039634689688682556,
0.6846579909324646,
0.19527272880077362,
0.41845446825027466,
-0.04691309481859207,
0.5718098878860474,
0.604367196559906,
0.08026871830224991,
0.8340147137641907,
1.1157691478729248,
-0.23667384684085846,
0.3576042056083679,
-0.0807911679148674,
-0.716365396976471,
-0.09904429316520691,
-1.0122144222259521,
-1.0676639080047607,
-0.6160605549812317,
-0.29557543992996216,
-0.17187143862247467,
-0.08237289637327194,
0.7647950649261475,
0.28488287329673767,
-0.41094568371772766,
-0.5443105101585388,
0.3266366720199585,
0.3497069180011749,
-0.5317305326461792,
-0.16058243811130524,
0.030095616355538368,
0.002081530401483178,
-0.6479897499084473,
0.3727930784225464,
0.3146400451660156,
-0.18409407138824463,
-0.06155598908662796,
-0.3754391074180603,
-0.06658952683210373,
-0.033592358231544495,
0.7462054491043091,
0.6136022806167603,
-0.45008906722068787,
-0.11019384860992432,
-0.12315260618925095,
0.2669927477836609,
-0.0410635806620121,
1.0499827861785889,
-1.1032160520553589,
0.5079202055931091,
0.5411650538444519,
0.2468542903661728,
0.3268243372440338,
-0.1769900768995285,
0.6519308686256409,
-0.13324061036109924,
0.11456224322319031,
0.2529096305370331,
0.6467989087104797,
-0.03233421593904495,
0.07229376584291458,
0.5940248966217041,
0.11685594916343689,
-0.7487110495567322,
-0.48302218317985535,
-0.10217488557100296,
-0.9913991093635559,
-0.23823513090610504,
1.3510633707046509,
0.07737580686807632,
-0.26084133982658386,
0.03731534257531166,
-0.2754439115524292,
0.15318846702575684,
-0.39449822902679443,
0.7540181279182434,
0.5563284158706665,
-0.06775340437889099,
-0.09689788520336151,
-0.4888366460800171,
0.5403781533241272,
-0.04163751378655434,
-0.718126118183136,
-0.24910502135753632,
0.5936155319213867,
-0.016702111810445786,
0.16872303187847137,
0.8549084067344666,
-0.26285266876220703,
0.40656578540802,
-0.0984511598944664,
-0.2817094027996063,
0.022991199046373367,
-0.6295412182807922,
-0.20014138519763947,
-0.06364697962999344,
0.04507850110530853,
0.14109903573989868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16377v1 | On the Transformations across Reward Model, Parameter Update, and In-Context Prompt | 2024-06-24T07:42:32 | 2024-06-24T07:42:32 | Deng Cai, Huayang Li, Tingchen Fu, Siheng Li, Weiwen Xu, Shuaiyi Li, Bowen Cao, Zhisong Zhang, Xinting Huang, Leyang Cui, Yan Wang, Lemao Liu, Taro Watanabe, Shuming Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the general capabilities of pre-trained large language models (LLMs),
they still need further adaptation to better serve practical applications. In
this paper, we demonstrate the interchangeability of three popular and distinct
adaptation tools: parameter updating, reward modeling, and in-context
prompting. This interchangeability establishes a triangular framework with six
transformation directions, each of which facilitates a variety of applications.
Our work offers a holistic view that unifies numerous existing studies and
suggests potential research directions. We envision our work as a useful
roadmap for future research on LLMs. | [
-0.24154123663902283,
-0.3282192647457123,
0.9752235412597656,
0.4184325933456421,
-0.11247005313634872,
-0.0877850204706192,
-0.5559282898902893,
-0.2598332464694977,
-0.18502816557884216,
0.42631715536117554,
-0.5619572997093201,
-0.2658592760562897,
-0.7943933010101318,
0.35773172974586487,
-0.4967300295829773,
0.7629106640815735,
-0.3709739148616791,
0.3186543583869934,
-0.1442088931798935,
-0.14010925590991974,
-0.6316767930984497,
-0.5376790761947632,
-0.880078136920929,
-0.3807887136936188,
0.8602923154830933,
0.433005154132843,
0.5320603251457214,
0.3042885661125183,
0.41655591130256653,
0.38251224160194397,
0.09415149688720703,
-0.2603079676628113,
-0.42911863327026367,
0.2021193504333496,
-0.5298302173614502,
-0.5411866903305054,
-0.20399226248264313,
0.016499966382980347,
0.7325205206871033,
0.8476325273513794,
-0.011427233926951885,
0.00010826175275724381,
0.44431957602500916,
0.49491629004478455,
-0.6884409189224243,
-0.006372659932821989,
-0.5038352608680725,
-0.2691490650177002,
0.07153096050024033,
-0.3938397467136383,
-0.44829168915748596,
-0.5885627865791321,
0.18031297624111176,
-0.4982836842536926,
-0.4196335971355438,
-0.24197933077812195,
0.43599933385849,
0.2704409956932068,
-0.5999056100845337,
-0.49701181054115295,
-0.7292898893356323,
0.9484066367149353,
-0.7604840993881226,
0.38430944085121155,
0.01664844900369644,
0.7303224802017212,
-0.5207411050796509,
-0.8343632221221924,
-0.3854643404483795,
-0.1665317267179489,
-0.005330743733793497,
-0.2000526487827301,
-0.20285281538963318,
-0.02922939881682396,
0.07290993630886078,
0.1688752919435501,
-0.06733845919370651,
0.39372751116752625,
-0.07594424486160278,
0.24391409754753113,
0.5657408833503723,
0.27710577845573425,
0.4356864094734192,
0.09456904232501984,
-0.34848737716674805,
-0.4873870015144348,
-1.054160237312317,
0.3882732391357422,
-0.013005503453314304,
0.47223785519599915,
-0.32075008749961853,
0.26497626304626465,
-0.08783206343650818,
1.0524104833602905,
0.20476768910884857,
-0.2715827524662018,
-0.002628996968269348,
-0.17471548914909363,
-0.4144025146961212,
0.08976737409830093,
0.6358101963996887,
0.3812534213066101,
0.17385655641555786,
-0.070734903216362,
-0.3332968056201935,
-0.4591103196144104,
0.09649500995874405,
-0.6029068231582642,
0.15705391764640808,
0.09045795351266861,
-0.4378497302532196,
-0.10205194354057312,
-0.004927425179630518,
-0.5564282536506653,
-0.8072986006736755,
-0.6424767374992371,
0.5383986234664917,
-0.22220948338508606,
-0.3325337767601013,
0.5594964027404785,
-0.12818852066993713,
0.5249824523925781,
0.7478505969047546,
-1.0520195960998535,
0.1014336571097374,
0.7871192693710327,
0.7610388994216919,
-0.5145390033721924,
-0.5019918084144592,
-0.5527888536453247,
0.25770294666290283,
-0.336820513010025,
0.7545750737190247,
-0.7698031663894653,
-0.4267161190509796,
0.3882862627506256,
0.2803129255771637,
-0.2744123935699463,
-0.47176697850227356,
0.34906890988349915,
-0.5282132625579834,
0.5219252109527588,
-0.7451573610305786,
-0.25361305475234985,
-0.27301016449928284,
0.5033302307128906,
-0.6524565815925598,
1.0421340465545654,
0.5319786667823792,
-0.5398872494697571,
0.3117624521255493,
-0.9629557728767395,
-0.19728133082389832,
-0.1699669361114502,
-0.0014030135935172439,
0.23565667867660522,
0.3047142028808594,
0.12553028762340546,
0.555690586566925,
-0.6853978633880615,
0.35873889923095703,
-0.3719625771045685,
-0.5390270352363586,
0.5886627435684204,
-0.27662503719329834,
0.9462282657623291,
0.027653636410832405,
-0.20227505266666412,
0.7045224905014038,
-0.7082878351211548,
-0.28509774804115295,
-0.13420861959457397,
-0.5579724907875061,
-0.3897077143192291,
-0.05216682329773903,
-0.1052301824092865,
0.45721501111984253,
0.25058144330978394,
-0.2321460098028183,
0.46456432342529297,
-0.2540692389011383,
0.589547872543335,
0.880037248134613,
-0.10351205617189407,
0.7520456910133362,
-0.22676849365234375,
0.665839433670044,
0.2742053270339966,
0.16566349565982819,
-0.1807936131954193,
-0.09048948436975479,
-0.8016722202301025,
-0.18933075666427612,
0.2969503700733185,
0.47358670830726624,
-0.8680807948112488,
0.20635056495666504,
-0.41370418667793274,
-0.3492940366268158,
-0.2668960392475128,
-0.11295071989297867,
-0.07047589868307114,
0.2624012231826782,
0.46342748403549194,
0.1102566123008728,
-0.6088471412658691,
-0.534537672996521,
-0.6281207799911499,
-0.2203408181667328,
-0.25417301058769226,
-0.10014678537845612,
0.2715802490711212,
-0.2761635184288025,
0.7777366042137146,
-0.00022985971008893102,
0.05015547573566437,
-0.49326640367507935,
-0.042271938174963,
0.620721161365509,
0.47433194518089294,
0.8056839108467102,
-0.5642808675765991,
-0.671734631061554,
0.22384968400001526,
-0.4986884295940399,
-0.1960446834564209,
-0.4727365970611572,
0.06494563072919846,
-0.33519166707992554,
0.8912081122398376,
-0.24820737540721893,
0.31187257170677185,
0.6776560544967651,
-0.25580689311027527,
0.32807329297065735,
-0.06893915683031082,
0.4466763734817505,
-1.2580106258392334,
-0.24302949011325836,
-0.12789267301559448,
-0.29983100295066833,
-0.852153480052948,
-0.10799676179885864,
0.12038586288690567,
0.1289108544588089,
-0.6295322179794312,
1.096378207206726,
-0.6264373064041138,
-0.1713988184928894,
-0.38131946325302124,
-0.13930387794971466,
-0.2610655128955841,
0.28037649393081665,
-0.03795960545539856,
0.7821688055992126,
0.8479726314544678,
-1.0229476690292358,
0.5543578863143921,
0.21226608753204346,
-0.18443401157855988,
0.8431785702705383,
-0.621307373046875,
0.06799696385860443,
0.008211364969611168,
0.2723681330680847,
-0.9663408398628235,
-0.3315236270427704,
0.6451302766799927,
-0.15048140287399292,
0.2191329002380371,
-0.12760019302368164,
-0.5025126934051514,
-0.0006946074427105486,
-0.4738186001777649,
0.30868956446647644,
0.4567759037017822,
-1.0135760307312012,
0.902174711227417,
-0.07314030826091766,
-0.5594821572303772,
-0.25438281893730164,
-0.42392808198928833,
0.3175297677516937,
-0.6228260397911072,
-0.17045357823371887,
0.526085376739502,
-0.1687718778848648,
-0.41342049837112427,
-0.1557961106300354,
0.14046846330165863,
0.18941789865493774,
0.10737673938274384,
0.13590697944164276,
0.20002269744873047,
-0.27411144971847534,
0.14725568890571594,
0.16183900833129883,
-0.08143243938684464,
0.16916678845882416,
-0.22675946354866028,
0.45962655544281006,
0.07530814409255981,
-0.3968123495578766,
-0.21834035217761993,
0.23070453107357025,
0.5386130809783936,
-0.005341110285371542,
0.747438371181488,
0.4420700967311859,
-0.24429640173912048,
0.06637295335531235,
-0.47036969661712646,
-0.14450770616531372,
-0.5776403546333313,
0.3281285762786865,
-0.5895462036132812,
-1.0301254987716675,
0.41699108481407166,
-0.46185103058815,
0.0312969908118248,
0.10837085545063019,
0.747138261795044,
0.1386341154575348,
1.0925097465515137,
0.8141959309577942,
0.11332440376281738,
0.9208174347877502,
0.3958752751350403,
0.12110454589128494,
-1.0115423202514648,
-0.16694170236587524,
-0.5880180597305298,
-0.40782031416893005,
-0.394225537776947,
-0.14645633101463318,
0.4402778446674347,
0.20738975703716278,
-0.4114357829093933,
0.36053940653800964,
-0.14344336092472076,
0.36730676889419556,
0.2858985662460327,
-0.23368710279464722,
0.0005504762521013618,
0.028215577825903893,
0.04572198912501335,
-0.01727674901485443,
-0.6274608373641968,
-0.49998652935028076,
1.0448704957962036,
0.31813761591911316,
0.7465784549713135,
0.373931884765625,
0.5866614580154419,
0.02184317074716091,
0.7217637300491333,
-0.6653961539268494,
0.6081050038337708,
-0.04091956466436386,
-0.34219181537628174,
-0.40133407711982727,
-0.029272940009832382,
-1.096178650856018,
0.33896487951278687,
-0.3247784674167633,
-0.8920537233352661,
0.4750829041004181,
-0.06802544742822647,
-0.24848803877830505,
0.3162713348865509,
-0.6544433236122131,
0.9019615650177002,
-0.31807950139045715,
-0.1514022946357727,
0.02752080000936985,
-0.41061437129974365,
0.10498666018247604,
-0.2142559438943863,
0.017636379227042198,
-0.12903492152690887,
-0.146929070353508,
0.5727928280830383,
-0.12674710154533386,
0.8282923102378845,
-0.2499946653842926,
-0.31736916303634644,
-0.0925256684422493,
0.06867290288209915,
0.5136284232139587,
-0.06112678721547127,
-0.27713966369628906,
-0.04723590239882469,
0.28357309103012085,
-0.3166084885597229,
-0.979559063911438,
0.6421141624450684,
-0.6044961810112,
-0.8858134150505066,
-0.4951878488063812,
-0.8289182186126709,
-0.6303649544715881,
0.20468783378601074,
-0.09764474630355835,
0.2084728330373764,
-0.2113945186138153,
0.22970640659332275,
0.40803125500679016,
-0.350023478269577,
0.6255221962928772,
0.47756657004356384,
-0.35473376512527466,
-0.04951309412717819,
0.4401974678039551,
-0.45948073267936707,
0.278083860874176,
0.437855064868927,
0.26915958523750305,
-0.6080548167228699,
-0.6479734778404236,
-0.37595176696777344,
0.3317071199417114,
-1.0365551710128784,
-0.07527279108762741,
-0.3450286090373993,
0.09347816556692123,
-0.6207091212272644,
-0.5546750426292419,
0.014521944336593151,
-0.15197648108005524,
-0.626594603061676,
0.09096210449934006,
0.4764435291290283,
0.9356317520141602,
-0.17909856140613556,
0.7589088678359985,
-0.7869781255722046,
-0.015505783259868622,
0.4884410798549652,
0.28267714381217957,
-0.16105061769485474,
-0.8198402523994446,
-0.16806842386722565,
0.09550541639328003,
-0.04900024086236954,
-1.2652491331100464,
0.26428574323654175,
0.07220136374235153,
0.7413114905357361,
0.14700427651405334,
-0.18667684495449066,
0.659871518611908,
-0.4032492935657501,
0.879936933517456,
0.4866640567779541,
-1.1205683946609497,
0.09087633341550827,
-0.2974662482738495,
0.3679766356945038,
0.5762043595314026,
0.651565432548523,
-0.862225353717804,
0.2874893546104431,
-0.19041328132152557,
-0.41778290271759033,
0.6547956466674805,
-0.4987260699272156,
0.2762312591075897,
0.24715323746204376,
0.43362510204315186,
0.3497110903263092,
0.0914890319108963,
-0.6608880162239075,
0.29723629355430603,
-0.2920290231704712,
-0.4342566132545471,
-0.2858695685863495,
-0.1546037644147873,
-0.24673788249492645,
-0.3886371850967407,
0.5049811601638794,
-0.2833935022354126,
0.25946158170700073,
-0.25142019987106323,
-0.2918967306613922,
0.21034766733646393,
0.6951864361763,
0.5098910927772522,
0.9535037279129028,
0.05066113919019699,
0.21702800691127777,
0.32747188210487366,
0.060531917959451675,
0.4693599045276642,
-0.09177739918231964,
0.10463285446166992,
-0.19497203826904297,
0.35431772470474243,
1.000575304031372,
0.7957258224487305,
-0.3932456970214844,
0.48270273208618164,
-0.028531596064567566,
-0.11947450786828995,
-0.08216966688632965,
0.2653326988220215,
0.23092414438724518,
0.37640994787216187,
0.22004316747188568,
-0.2580721378326416,
0.017450833693146706,
-0.7672264575958252,
-0.24403725564479828,
0.214901402592659,
-0.5673487782478333,
-0.43987974524497986,
0.4745851159095764,
0.11564841866493225,
-0.3915872871875763,
0.2207532823085785,
-0.11778223514556885,
-0.24169933795928955,
-0.023312672972679138,
0.7211236357688904,
0.8853746652603149,
-0.5329700708389282,
0.368355929851532,
0.23696410655975342,
-0.0659908652305603,
-0.43717503547668457,
0.19019557535648346,
0.03765321895480156,
-0.7670304179191589,
-0.4216921031475067,
-0.4222933351993561,
-0.3505116403102875,
0.1254378706216812,
-0.7387963533401489,
0.4949856996536255,
-0.30539795756340027,
-0.009210823103785515,
0.004023910500109196,
-0.6503235101699829,
-0.7590287923812866,
0.06841322779655457,
-0.09295282512903214,
0.942852258682251,
-0.7992607355117798,
0.9804759621620178,
1.1606621742248535,
-0.18596144020557404,
-0.6912357211112976,
-0.07841727137565613,
0.06565874814987183,
-0.8790899515151978,
0.6908165812492371,
-0.17113949358463287,
-0.22101467847824097,
0.2315826117992401,
-0.744330108165741,
-0.9038035273551941,
1.0741550922393799,
0.464343398809433,
-0.3154199421405792,
-0.14214199781417847,
0.34695595502853394,
0.48266154527664185,
-0.7900431752204895,
0.28637754917144775,
0.782146692276001,
0.6171872019767761,
0.09464409947395325,
-0.8968175053596497,
0.18549130856990814,
-0.0012000350980088115,
0.34621578454971313,
-0.0002243402268504724,
-0.01535103190690279,
0.9396387338638306,
0.07980372756719589,
-0.300387978553772,
0.1018298789858818,
0.5045650601387024,
0.4503924548625946,
-0.0737789198756218,
0.6733860373497009,
-0.20725293457508087,
0.36690059304237366,
-0.15826068818569183,
0.8528203964233398,
-0.12745100259780884,
0.05566641688346863,
0.9525520205497742,
-0.5165705680847168,
0.9518920183181763,
0.7834627628326416,
-0.24430598318576813,
0.7934809327125549,
0.8082535266876221,
0.3798772990703583,
0.4907172620296478,
0.10447456687688828,
-0.16290494799613953,
-0.2690269649028778,
0.00238064699806273,
-0.49784815311431885,
0.20238593220710754,
0.5685504674911499,
-0.08970072120428085,
-0.4284573495388031,
0.14993497729301453,
0.0551384873688221,
-0.004475155379623175,
-0.504832923412323,
0.6359976530075073,
0.15124139189720154,
-0.7875327467918396,
0.7487353682518005,
0.2148067057132721,
0.7847803235054016,
-0.7767799496650696,
-0.10883841663599014,
-0.00620498601347208,
0.11164892464876175,
-0.03686615079641342,
-0.8481174111366272,
0.02874019183218479,
-0.1787422150373459,
0.06777725368738174,
-0.664465606212616,
0.8072452545166016,
-0.42814189195632935,
-0.2473817765712738,
0.3699339032173157,
0.5240796208381653,
0.0001681370777077973,
-0.16933567821979523,
-1.0813251733779907,
0.4011022448539734,
-0.03696862980723381,
-0.11077416688203812,
0.5981426239013672,
0.5673316717147827,
-0.15691831707954407,
0.5933575630187988,
0.7397905588150024,
0.17015326023101807,
0.19139085710048676,
0.12587516009807587,
0.9025143384933472,
-0.8900091648101807,
-0.6270619034767151,
-0.7745568156242371,
0.530933678150177,
0.03243270888924599,
-0.3422495126724243,
0.8199903964996338,
-0.09326551854610443,
0.7302542328834534,
-0.24542468786239624,
0.6969807744026184,
0.23932284116744995,
0.5043862462043762,
-0.7772981524467468,
0.27465391159057617,
-0.6602246761322021,
0.26505547761917114,
-0.2207014411687851,
-1.1787340641021729,
-0.2514144778251648,
0.4754430055618286,
-0.5468156337738037,
0.27745339274406433,
0.8755602240562439,
0.5384749174118042,
-0.07743948698043823,
-0.013950799591839314,
0.2974697947502136,
0.16698308289051056,
0.39280903339385986,
0.6607673764228821,
1.1324667930603027,
-0.15944884717464447,
0.08216746896505356,
0.2766057550907135,
-0.23860661685466766,
-0.40580663084983826,
-1.1769678592681885,
-0.8812237977981567,
-0.8403631448745728,
-0.22404086589813232,
-0.2322091907262802,
0.09991242736577988,
0.9478577375411987,
0.6052653789520264,
-0.7835362553596497,
-0.5654272437095642,
0.12255124002695084,
-0.04212568700313568,
-0.3255372941493988,
-0.1077466607093811,
0.2094247043132782,
-0.28709664940834045,
-0.6661695837974548,
0.5833737254142761,
0.5181272029876709,
0.23157502710819244,
-0.45860323309898376,
-0.3072342872619629,
-0.1329551637172699,
0.15771041810512543,
0.7032586932182312,
0.5406181216239929,
-0.7792688608169556,
-0.5315151214599609,
0.06330575793981552,
-0.054046157747507095,
0.13446301221847534,
1.1482913494110107,
-0.7396395206451416,
0.15084055066108704,
0.632917046546936,
0.8038466572761536,
0.2695751190185547,
-0.18496038019657135,
0.783478319644928,
-0.478618860244751,
0.2587931156158447,
-0.18631033599376678,
0.31974852085113525,
0.6045934557914734,
-0.1236528679728508,
0.37984800338745117,
-0.23458491265773773,
-0.3892679214477539,
-1.0135225057601929,
0.5115882754325867,
-0.9565871357917786,
-0.34150105714797974,
1.4717979431152344,
-0.035800039768218994,
-0.28886428475379944,
-0.13066793978214264,
-0.23778022825717926,
0.07704183459281921,
0.11433617770671844,
0.5341819524765015,
0.8693973422050476,
-0.13260243833065033,
-0.43833836913108826,
-0.282362699508667,
0.6084920763969421,
0.4163028299808502,
-1.056442141532898,
-0.0573979914188385,
0.2534353733062744,
0.4790756106376648,
-0.16767846047878265,
0.7175705432891846,
-0.19461415708065033,
0.2341582030057907,
-0.4371791481971741,
0.08781652897596359,
0.09863407164812088,
-0.23422202467918396,
-0.9290763735771179,
-0.2526964545249939,
0.4132603704929352,
0.03943505883216858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16374v1 | KEHRL: Learning Knowledge-Enhanced Language Representations with Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning | 2024-06-24T07:32:35 | 2024-06-24T07:32:35 | Dongyang Li, Taolin Zhang, Longtao Huang, Chengyu Wang, Xiaofeng He, Hui Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-enhanced pre-trained language models (KEPLMs) leverage relation
triples from knowledge graphs (KGs) and integrate these external data sources
into language models via self-supervised learning. Previous works treat
knowledge enhancement as two independent operations, i.e., knowledge injection
and knowledge integration. In this paper, we propose to learn
Knowledge-Enhanced language representations with Hierarchical Reinforcement
Learning (KEHRL), which jointly addresses the problems of detecting positions
for knowledge injection and integrating external knowledge into the model in
order to avoid injecting inaccurate or irrelevant knowledge. Specifically, a
high-level reinforcement learning (RL) agent utilizes both internal and prior
knowledge to iteratively detect essential positions in texts for knowledge
injection, which filters out less meaningful entities to avoid diverting the
knowledge learning direction. Once the entity positions are selected, a
relevant triple filtration module is triggered to perform low-level RL to
dynamically refine the triples associated with polysemic entities through
binary-valued actions. Experiments validate KEHRL's effectiveness in probing
factual knowledge and enhancing the model's performance on various natural
language understanding tasks. | [
-0.18245163559913635,
-0.9643034338951111,
0.6749803423881531,
0.06654305756092072,
-0.012982625514268875,
0.43947601318359375,
-0.21962055563926697,
-0.5103003978729248,
-0.20053480565547943,
0.5418525338172913,
-0.12596923112869263,
-0.629210889339447,
-0.6581118702888489,
-0.17928792536258698,
0.19466552138328552,
0.9928064346313477,
-0.02240932360291481,
-0.019939487800002098,
-0.2516895532608032,
-0.03258316218852997,
-0.22756917774677277,
-0.5254544615745544,
-0.7302480340003967,
-0.7070586085319519,
0.5824323296546936,
0.43400102853775024,
0.7016116380691528,
0.5153048634529114,
0.22613202035427094,
0.3477979600429535,
-0.04153921827673912,
0.3107505738735199,
-0.3031957149505615,
0.2297152280807495,
-0.3219272792339325,
-0.2776973843574524,
-0.22475481033325195,
-0.23629574477672577,
0.9289095997810364,
0.6076164245605469,
-0.27981773018836975,
-0.14254270493984222,
0.2794848680496216,
0.6213269233703613,
-0.8921196460723877,
0.5813784599304199,
-0.49366241693496704,
0.22953151166439056,
0.0022402394097298384,
-0.09871126711368561,
-0.39094722270965576,
-0.3783414363861084,
0.22798402607440948,
-0.588127851486206,
-0.5791690945625305,
0.18025149405002594,
0.6044055223464966,
0.33735910058021545,
-0.6500245928764343,
-0.2852671444416046,
-0.7120966911315918,
0.708874523639679,
-0.6815986037254333,
0.6298485994338989,
0.4586600959300995,
0.3650347590446472,
-0.21579453349113464,
-0.48800650238990784,
-0.6138859987258911,
-0.4884020686149597,
-0.46465396881103516,
0.12395931780338287,
0.013369085267186165,
0.4424784779548645,
0.10336889326572418,
0.3022157549858093,
-0.15179887413978577,
0.1297605186700821,
-0.15290823578834534,
-0.19218063354492188,
0.23593680560588837,
-0.06933976709842682,
0.29502278566360474,
-0.38361799716949463,
-0.44091200828552246,
-0.30473241209983826,
-0.45904773473739624,
0.23745714128017426,
0.28180304169654846,
0.4341157376766205,
0.042014967650175095,
0.2360924333333969,
-0.0980205237865448,
0.5415461659431458,
0.23238106071949005,
-0.21898742020130157,
0.2569590210914612,
-0.10973872244358063,
-0.36333921551704407,
0.1830887794494629,
0.8022540807723999,
-0.46660980582237244,
0.013478540815412998,
-0.05580998584628105,
-0.26185402274131775,
-0.4803781807422638,
0.24230754375457764,
-0.4837600886821747,
-0.2412271499633789,
0.07910433411598206,
-0.20083555579185486,
-0.5416828393936157,
-0.03498144820332527,
-0.5598137378692627,
-0.35303908586502075,
-0.10446087270975113,
0.7697625160217285,
-0.618023693561554,
-0.4191971719264984,
0.1493648737668991,
-0.017913764342665672,
0.013662523590028286,
0.06395261734724045,
-0.8708614110946655,
0.49444830417633057,
0.3488387167453766,
0.289974570274353,
-0.12380914390087128,
-0.3539513647556305,
-0.6518548727035522,
0.6542980670928955,
-0.38806647062301636,
0.6273349523544312,
-0.6735879182815552,
-0.1788150519132614,
0.21793106198310852,
-0.22282275557518005,
-0.019724776968359947,
-0.6238040924072266,
0.1820496767759323,
-1.0445847511291504,
0.37001660466194153,
-0.1417447030544281,
-0.5945210456848145,
-0.39871853590011597,
0.33319270610809326,
-0.4896394610404968,
1.1811662912368774,
0.10846968740224838,
-0.7026172876358032,
0.32395651936531067,
-0.7069926857948303,
-0.44696882367134094,
0.18727454543113708,
-0.27183786034584045,
-0.32306796312332153,
-0.408252090215683,
0.4203547537326813,
0.46835386753082275,
0.3254247009754181,
0.20667284727096558,
-0.22781184315681458,
-0.00847858376801014,
-0.3609732389450073,
0.05695164203643799,
0.37303972244262695,
-0.19301943480968475,
-0.15980271995067596,
0.3375447988510132,
-0.4681711792945862,
0.024628642946481705,
0.012277209199965,
-0.6182714104652405,
-0.5031810402870178,
-0.13014192879199982,
-0.5693237781524658,
0.38544172048568726,
0.39149412512779236,
-0.30338913202285767,
0.07227177172899246,
-0.5375667810440063,
-0.17864862084388733,
0.7343789339065552,
0.41883307695388794,
0.638164758682251,
-0.12924884259700775,
0.4992385506629944,
0.4764903485774994,
0.022081095725297928,
0.1303815394639969,
-0.19256392121315002,
-0.8084527850151062,
0.0067582023330032825,
0.2142428457736969,
0.4921530783176422,
-1.1974289417266846,
0.5159443616867065,
-0.12522727251052856,
-0.2069801539182663,
-0.274985671043396,
0.2769610583782196,
0.4502952992916107,
0.6240654587745667,
0.6013662815093994,
0.10101425647735596,
-0.4427678883075714,
-0.9196828007698059,
-0.14197611808776855,
-0.4444899559020996,
0.26076844334602356,
0.3499864339828491,
0.6280201077461243,
-0.25674954056739807,
0.7084912657737732,
-0.22689594328403473,
-0.3772667944431305,
-0.4300573468208313,
0.35922759771347046,
0.024787168949842453,
0.41650596261024475,
0.0816257894039154,
-0.4919484257698059,
-0.5819940567016602,
0.3875139653682709,
-0.6450822353363037,
0.10236872732639313,
0.046551838517189026,
-0.1965796798467636,
0.16595840454101562,
0.6102485656738281,
-0.3223884403705597,
0.024931015446782112,
0.47948166728019714,
-0.18279694020748138,
0.6313648223876953,
-0.6281232833862305,
0.19021271169185638,
-0.8455901741981506,
-0.0031462975312024355,
-0.08135825395584106,
-0.5548302531242371,
-0.5865649580955505,
0.10116010159254074,
0.31137219071388245,
0.11592229455709457,
-0.2462693601846695,
0.5521777272224426,
-0.2569360136985779,
-0.2102205604314804,
-0.3076156675815582,
0.20329728722572327,
-0.1491279900074005,
0.909481942653656,
0.4319753050804138,
0.5667240619659424,
0.3995027542114258,
-0.7939729690551758,
0.18628358840942383,
0.09261858463287354,
-0.33025798201560974,
0.17945638298988342,
-0.27212631702423096,
0.031209511682391167,
-0.1843581348657608,
0.26659321784973145,
-0.5616206526756287,
-0.1649927794933319,
0.5123290419578552,
-0.28268808126449585,
0.22477364540100098,
-0.1135120540857315,
-0.5305394530296326,
-0.2338031530380249,
-0.04555540531873703,
0.3229483366012573,
0.5765502452850342,
-0.6540260910987854,
0.6484673023223877,
0.43506982922554016,
-0.058999862521886826,
-0.8356546759605408,
-0.34014517068862915,
-0.3454774022102356,
-0.013595202937722206,
-0.1927577406167984,
0.478203684091568,
0.33585378527641296,
-0.0796697586774826,
0.429878294467926,
-0.10970117151737213,
-0.21536885201931,
-0.15521539747714996,
-0.12709124386310577,
0.09692231565713882,
-0.13729815185070038,
0.5097712278366089,
0.2763017416000366,
-0.13888457417488098,
0.07954628765583038,
-0.5369116067886353,
0.43773362040519714,
-0.10371985286474228,
-0.39602717757225037,
-0.6088780760765076,
0.17975451052188873,
0.47498759627342224,
-0.08039674907922745,
0.7848984599113464,
0.6048111915588379,
-0.44379737973213196,
-0.1454717069864273,
-0.44666650891304016,
-0.1826450675725937,
-0.48389557003974915,
0.5260114073753357,
-0.4148971736431122,
-0.9746453166007996,
0.26079636812210083,
-0.0450594425201416,
-0.05962565541267395,
0.5375520586967468,
0.41106727719306946,
-0.3168758749961853,
1.2465643882751465,
0.6402748227119446,
-0.1983232945203781,
0.4768221378326416,
-0.08450192213058472,
0.2380276620388031,
-0.7461324334144592,
-0.4779658317565918,
-0.15127067267894745,
-0.024033812806010246,
-0.46071115136146545,
-0.43083468079566956,
0.5509406924247742,
0.366956889629364,
-0.5217624306678772,
0.13316552340984344,
0.08110347390174866,
0.5199840664863586,
0.5880081057548523,
0.305388480424881,
0.37343722581863403,
-0.011666622012853622,
-0.6812008619308472,
0.09249338507652283,
-0.808699369430542,
-0.14192552864551544,
0.5085914731025696,
0.5653742551803589,
0.5256670117378235,
0.06740602850914001,
0.7578641772270203,
0.31493493914604187,
-0.02436167560517788,
-0.6967292428016663,
0.4377768635749817,
0.12129326909780502,
-0.156508669257164,
-0.39995282888412476,
-0.5327657461166382,
-0.7118278741836548,
0.2936769723892212,
-0.2653043568134308,
-0.520310640335083,
0.16540850698947906,
0.3004598617553711,
-0.5791944861412048,
0.5008338689804077,
-0.46041473746299744,
0.7503203749656677,
-0.2466837465763092,
-0.32697200775146484,
-0.7834622859954834,
-0.4238593876361847,
0.3411136865615845,
0.052231565117836,
0.31256189942359924,
0.21359576284885406,
-0.15326917171478271,
0.5539694428443909,
-0.2173454761505127,
0.6994655728340149,
-0.38206011056900024,
-0.328336626291275,
-0.1035713329911232,
0.2354537844657898,
0.8229343295097351,
0.007499254774302244,
0.1533617079257965,
-0.2410745918750763,
-0.07492700219154358,
-0.4592982530593872,
-0.8998522758483887,
0.43434834480285645,
-0.7420698404312134,
-0.7141405344009399,
-0.3798127770423889,
-0.6448090076446533,
-0.6161518692970276,
0.19692184031009674,
-0.3763800859451294,
0.3085479438304901,
0.1257975846529007,
0.15947620570659637,
0.6227738857269287,
-0.48929518461227417,
0.11967985332012177,
0.4201123118400574,
-0.47982239723205566,
-0.5027689933776855,
0.7975813746452332,
-0.28865528106689453,
0.5400791764259338,
0.7254594564437866,
0.4111902117729187,
-0.5245973467826843,
-0.4544389545917511,
-0.15142422914505005,
0.15807859599590302,
-0.6641372442245483,
0.01694330759346485,
-0.8434843420982361,
-0.4308423697948456,
-0.4800178110599518,
0.10863785445690155,
-0.16712193191051483,
-0.20742326974868774,
0.21570149064064026,
-0.13792993128299713,
0.12978267669677734,
0.9260179996490479,
-0.48536089062690735,
0.22235701978206635,
-0.715912401676178,
0.4563685357570648,
0.7525832653045654,
0.34422531723976135,
0.2397885024547577,
-0.3904990553855896,
-0.5513248443603516,
-0.04817194119095802,
-0.1208619773387909,
-0.8043901324272156,
0.3197020888328552,
0.06555578112602234,
0.7143182158470154,
0.44226911664009094,
-0.20625856518745422,
0.7551469206809998,
-0.36847466230392456,
0.529626190662384,
0.14609505236148834,
-0.821273922920227,
0.6419976353645325,
-0.39260250329971313,
0.4886954128742218,
0.39351725578308105,
0.6482720971107483,
-0.7115853428840637,
-0.6180426478385925,
-0.6092602014541626,
-0.5870216488838196,
0.8644343018531799,
0.08620522171258926,
-0.1284206509590149,
-0.0625147670507431,
0.2179194688796997,
-0.024655601009726524,
0.220313161611557,
-0.9037263989448547,
-0.2027713805437088,
0.12878546118736267,
-0.15791721642017365,
0.34338343143463135,
-0.42718571424484253,
0.27160704135894775,
-0.3781695067882538,
1.139510989189148,
0.08822761476039886,
0.07315711677074432,
-0.014348356984555721,
-0.36395207047462463,
-0.06768833100795746,
0.2799391448497772,
0.0015849120682105422,
0.3017181158065796,
-0.23491106927394867,
0.3089835047721863,
0.4081680476665497,
-0.2010294497013092,
-0.032976921647787094,
-0.12109391391277313,
0.22442315518856049,
-0.40565264225006104,
0.4387441575527191,
0.694048285484314,
0.6719133257865906,
-0.5563326478004456,
0.32300183176994324,
0.2487318068742752,
0.05573343485593796,
-0.06762655824422836,
0.033237867057323456,
0.0239238440990448,
0.343514621257782,
0.18283048272132874,
-0.054054874926805496,
0.03496571630239487,
-0.6998158097267151,
0.5340339541435242,
0.25922977924346924,
-0.6850519180297852,
-0.020665520802140236,
0.01445578970015049,
0.23462887108325958,
-0.0591583251953125,
0.5218648314476013,
-0.48314404487609863,
-0.9504636526107788,
0.18422983586788177,
0.5585638880729675,
0.4623965919017792,
-0.49704840779304504,
0.40770700573921204,
0.6403555870056152,
0.0834745243191719,
0.1591443419456482,
0.14370271563529968,
-0.5766628384590149,
-1.0084832906723022,
-0.5963190793991089,
-0.5025004744529724,
-0.3536260724067688,
0.15692193806171417,
-0.536082923412323,
0.056955087929964066,
-0.3949822187423706,
0.3555468022823334,
-0.29409679770469666,
0.15441378951072693,
-0.4751501977443695,
-0.144924595952034,
0.1361055225133896,
0.6576631665229797,
-0.6802087426185608,
1.1677550077438354,
0.5629445910453796,
-0.48273882269859314,
-0.7595453262329102,
0.18787120282649994,
-0.26442378759384155,
-0.893023669719696,
1.0529916286468506,
-0.194321408867836,
-0.29169508814811707,
0.28904953598976135,
-0.11547843366861343,
-0.8213351964950562,
0.7705482244491577,
0.15228009223937988,
-0.2139306515455246,
-0.245845228433609,
0.24016214907169342,
0.3537464141845703,
-0.23961704969406128,
0.33788391947746277,
0.5937427878379822,
0.5322803854942322,
-0.036342594772577286,
-0.81918865442276,
-0.08766825497150421,
-0.06301122903823853,
-0.11453603208065033,
0.3644222021102905,
-0.2635868787765503,
0.34674859046936035,
-0.11141697317361832,
-0.33661121129989624,
-0.3208814859390259,
0.7328521013259888,
0.37695547938346863,
-0.32466357946395874,
0.8300864100456238,
0.6172235012054443,
0.8346981406211853,
0.21719524264335632,
0.9501468539237976,
-0.22124716639518738,
0.1868276596069336,
1.2392574548721313,
-0.07920019328594208,
0.845062255859375,
0.32711243629455566,
-0.011682591401040554,
1.1851563453674316,
0.46220335364341736,
0.4027628004550934,
0.7530556917190552,
-0.14182448387145996,
-0.4617302417755127,
-0.6405637860298157,
-0.3247986435890198,
-0.16756662726402283,
0.27293825149536133,
0.634529709815979,
-0.16974978148937225,
-0.5383709073066711,
0.1272832453250885,
-0.20818057656288147,
0.13259726762771606,
-0.19756194949150085,
1.0741411447525024,
0.03442812338471413,
-0.5221897959709167,
0.16698847711086273,
-0.05795995518565178,
0.501471757888794,
-0.6990998983383179,
-0.26889774203300476,
0.08083594590425491,
0.04778047651052475,
-0.04584546759724617,
-0.8979082703590393,
0.18471688032150269,
-0.4187563359737396,
-0.08494758605957031,
-0.4037882685661316,
0.9818413257598877,
-0.8149707317352295,
-0.08953241258859634,
0.6165459752082825,
0.6323015689849854,
-0.17159517109394073,
-0.045688580721616745,
-0.8207162618637085,
-0.4294084906578064,
-0.13991983234882355,
-0.06721461564302444,
0.15453003346920013,
0.43978288769721985,
0.220563605427742,
0.7153205275535583,
0.4902871549129486,
0.2879403233528137,
-0.21167047321796417,
0.2542591094970703,
0.5038798451423645,
-0.563426673412323,
-0.7240700721740723,
-0.6980520486831665,
0.45748573541641235,
-0.37765568494796753,
0.24163830280303955,
0.5730368494987488,
0.3168855309486389,
0.8226696848869324,
0.04674720764160156,
0.7144192457199097,
0.015139707364141941,
0.33224809169769287,
-0.6357189416885376,
0.5813060998916626,
-0.3180218040943146,
0.05309634655714035,
-0.03231767192482948,
-0.5568305850028992,
-0.15956062078475952,
0.5590196251869202,
-0.5775137543678284,
0.08240669220685959,
0.98069828748703,
0.659290611743927,
-0.05694243311882019,
-0.15739893913269043,
0.559205174446106,
0.3857424557209015,
0.1832798719406128,
0.7448495626449585,
1.1617438793182373,
-0.22677189111709595,
0.5874989628791809,
-0.62385094165802,
-0.1253804862499237,
0.02264837548136711,
-0.636834442615509,
-0.8258235454559326,
-0.7918091416358948,
-0.22674845159053802,
-0.015048324130475521,
0.242656409740448,
1.0450550317764282,
0.9498068690299988,
-0.7505955100059509,
-0.17860804498195648,
-0.27636322379112244,
0.5946389436721802,
-0.3539595603942871,
-0.22934196889400482,
0.5001561045646667,
-0.901430070400238,
-0.5997772812843323,
0.6160728335380554,
0.41324684023857117,
-0.1086888536810875,
-0.4232260584831238,
-0.178770512342453,
-0.22846686840057373,
-0.22670698165893555,
0.6445921659469604,
0.18684706091880798,
-0.638745903968811,
-0.5525538921356201,
-0.3206581473350525,
-0.08020710945129395,
0.09449970722198486,
0.7407262325286865,
-1.150598168373108,
0.42688292264938354,
0.6001342535018921,
0.7819623947143555,
0.3275207281112671,
-0.21099969744682312,
0.768073320388794,
-1.0154284238815308,
-0.05723040550947189,
0.2987566292285919,
0.29301372170448303,
0.03277669474482536,
-0.45851802825927734,
0.03893394395709038,
-0.05743030458688736,
-0.430393785238266,
-0.42343035340309143,
0.31872355937957764,
-0.49559006094932556,
-0.26832252740859985,
1.1733784675598145,
0.05315517634153366,
0.017902767285704613,
-0.32384151220321655,
0.010129307396709919,
0.35326504707336426,
-0.44066959619522095,
0.7682701349258423,
0.6432594656944275,
-0.08673230558633804,
-0.2826371490955353,
-0.6270620822906494,
0.8360378742218018,
0.3735465407371521,
-0.9443632364273071,
-0.07889285683631897,
0.33286964893341064,
-0.019232885912060738,
0.05122790485620499,
0.452599436044693,
-0.2680397629737854,
0.2992115318775177,
-0.3828795850276947,
0.11056172102689743,
-0.013681751675903797,
-0.4657129645347595,
-0.29613521695137024,
0.277018278837204,
0.14709638059139252,
-0.053717516362667084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16372v1 | UniPSDA: Unsupervised Pseudo Semantic Data Augmentation for Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Natural Language Understanding | 2024-06-24T07:27:01 | 2024-06-24T07:27:01 | Dongyang Li, Taolin Zhang, Jiali Deng, Longtao Huang, Chengyu Wang, Xiaofeng He, Hui Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual representation learning transfers knowledge from resource-rich
data to resource-scarce ones to improve the semantic understanding abilities of
different languages. However, previous works rely on shallow unsupervised data
generated by token surface matching, regardless of the global context-aware
semantics of the surrounding text tokens. In this paper, we propose an
Unsupervised Pseudo Semantic Data Augmentation (UniPSDA) mechanism for
cross-lingual natural language understanding to enrich the training data
without human interventions. Specifically, to retrieve the tokens with similar
meanings for the semantic data augmentation across different languages, we
propose a sequential clustering process in 3 stages: within a single language,
across multiple languages of a language family, and across languages from
multiple language families. Meanwhile, considering the multi-lingual knowledge
infusion with context-aware semantics while alleviating computation burden, we
directly replace the key constituents of the sentences with the above-learned
multi-lingual family knowledge, viewed as pseudo-semantic. The infusion process
is further optimized via three de-biasing techniques without introducing any
neural parameters. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our model
consistently improves the performance on general zero-shot cross-lingual
natural language understanding tasks, including sequence classification,
information extraction, and question answering. | [
-0.2870752811431885,
-0.533056378364563,
0.46874696016311646,
0.05003277584910393,
-0.843076765537262,
0.19558586180210114,
-0.10669195652008057,
-0.3886805474758148,
0.413357138633728,
0.49574053287506104,
-0.5946725010871887,
-0.48456597328186035,
-0.28914833068847656,
0.06903646886348724,
-0.08915093541145325,
0.8253085017204285,
-0.01097691711038351,
0.39087167382240295,
-0.05199603736400604,
-0.06605654954910278,
-0.4230479598045349,
-0.19338905811309814,
-0.18187770247459412,
-0.3722815215587616,
0.10936208069324493,
0.6787781119346619,
0.4336914122104645,
0.41373294591903687,
0.020082980394363403,
0.25676172971725464,
0.03714636713266373,
0.18482305109500885,
-0.4785832166671753,
-0.3989013135433197,
-0.47175133228302,
-0.564265787601471,
-0.12365081161260605,
-0.23767085373401642,
0.8321820497512817,
1.2271767854690552,
0.14519697427749634,
-0.006528705824166536,
-0.07269011437892914,
0.47397321462631226,
-0.5238841772079468,
0.08338352292776108,
-0.8399230241775513,
0.15206925570964813,
-0.27868640422821045,
-0.23299767076969147,
-0.15387356281280518,
0.22743140161037445,
0.372135728597641,
-0.9249139428138733,
0.20238853991031647,
0.037585027515888214,
0.5880512595176697,
0.16377943754196167,
-0.3130508065223694,
-0.00597778707742691,
-0.2663354277610779,
0.7940409779548645,
-0.5389586091041565,
0.47565174102783203,
0.15622209012508392,
0.07304587960243225,
-0.30617839097976685,
-0.5334876179695129,
-0.8704897165298462,
0.26882755756378174,
-0.30258291959762573,
0.07976806163787842,
-0.21657948195934296,
0.1162402555346489,
-0.15508022904396057,
0.3229883313179016,
-0.8435837626457214,
0.25332412123680115,
-0.22316499054431915,
-0.32188138365745544,
0.19932179152965546,
-0.0948980450630188,
0.7224037051200867,
-0.4011859595775604,
-0.6843366026878357,
-0.05691775307059288,
-0.7315422892570496,
0.035429827868938446,
0.14184243977069855,
0.4675547480583191,
-0.23616555333137512,
0.632140576839447,
-0.39494314789772034,
0.8156070709228516,
0.14082853496074677,
-0.030578037723898888,
0.5659039616584778,
-0.7339959740638733,
-0.2728499174118042,
0.47086113691329956,
0.5748676061630249,
0.29476049542427063,
0.2929604947566986,
-0.6447557806968689,
0.20223766565322876,
0.25002843141555786,
0.1088012307882309,
-0.703670084476471,
-0.01301339827477932,
-0.02791726030409336,
-0.37134838104248047,
-0.058930013328790665,
0.19714613258838654,
-0.8206044435501099,
0.00982162170112133,
-0.34990790486335754,
0.3294351398944855,
-0.3891044557094574,
-0.43081095814704895,
0.31229910254478455,
-0.21397078037261963,
0.3227624297142029,
-0.1600521057844162,
-0.7478978633880615,
0.0039221118204295635,
0.505554735660553,
0.5966698527336121,
-0.23183859884738922,
-0.5506254434585571,
-0.4870160222053528,
0.5021904706954956,
-0.6031727194786072,
0.8910605311393738,
-0.7021940350532532,
-0.4094599187374115,
-0.2395503669977188,
0.2254296839237213,
-0.14659909904003143,
-0.36025795340538025,
0.27092602849006653,
-0.48192098736763,
0.46682703495025635,
-0.12161799520254135,
-0.5674113035202026,
-0.4059150218963623,
0.019332215189933777,
-0.2372715026140213,
0.9478442072868347,
0.12341290712356567,
-0.7881236672401428,
0.6755805611610413,
-0.7924893498420715,
-0.48818886280059814,
0.12581348419189453,
-0.1326827108860016,
-0.07018880546092987,
0.1667371392250061,
0.4341042637825012,
0.38144269585609436,
-0.22590355575084686,
0.28122037649154663,
-0.3137389123439789,
-0.4878332018852234,
-0.08494944125413895,
-0.22636786103248596,
0.7451736927032471,
-0.11124888062477112,
-0.39650073647499084,
0.1799144297838211,
-0.8221781849861145,
0.10252689570188522,
0.06929370760917664,
0.2906549572944641,
-0.6699585914611816,
-0.6422543525695801,
-0.06676406413316727,
0.38109442591667175,
0.2429538071155548,
-0.9881985187530518,
0.02566208690404892,
-0.7570463418960571,
0.1890161782503128,
0.4833855628967285,
0.07576672732830048,
0.9401284456253052,
0.18586772680282593,
0.1794564127922058,
0.4179772734642029,
0.005714916158467531,
-0.2560499906539917,
-0.4073728621006012,
-0.4591026306152344,
-0.47353386878967285,
0.3450295031070709,
0.506249189376831,
-1.182462453842163,
0.6392157673835754,
-0.48967549204826355,
-0.28130704164505005,
-0.6383413076400757,
0.46583542227745056,
0.5077745318412781,
0.799511730670929,
0.5947244167327881,
-0.40734076499938965,
-0.6348248720169067,
-0.7994388341903687,
-0.10518140345811844,
-0.06898848712444305,
-0.28156644105911255,
-0.12957783043384552,
0.1725025475025177,
-0.5276654362678528,
1.1485517024993896,
-0.3418886065483093,
-0.6146990060806274,
-0.5228534936904907,
0.5858400464057922,
-0.0030806008726358414,
0.26969194412231445,
0.5470926761627197,
-0.6634445190429688,
-0.5379460453987122,
0.1258208006620407,
-0.5594543218612671,
-0.2770691215991974,
-0.22054776549339294,
-0.36892610788345337,
0.31807124614715576,
0.29525941610336304,
-0.4953400194644928,
0.5637054443359375,
0.2277703732252121,
-0.4141787886619568,
0.003370676189661026,
-0.43119314312934875,
-0.003394253319129348,
-0.9511166214942932,
-0.023464400321245193,
-0.18225039541721344,
-0.08036381006240845,
-0.7697938680648804,
-0.27968907356262207,
0.1558019369840622,
-0.01346738450229168,
-0.6166887879371643,
0.6612229943275452,
-0.635601818561554,
-0.336388498544693,
-0.45754286646842957,
0.38190266489982605,
-0.03271931782364845,
0.622769832611084,
0.6669990420341492,
0.5781431794166565,
0.977338969707489,
-0.441039115190506,
0.10356511175632477,
0.23021550476551056,
-0.3057510256767273,
0.6579173803329468,
-0.4750261604785919,
0.01537916250526905,
-0.3418523371219635,
0.3001399636268616,
-0.9320072531700134,
0.19369156658649445,
0.27311909198760986,
-0.4897017776966095,
0.17267705500125885,
-0.18481723964214325,
-0.43786972761154175,
-0.010355752892792225,
-0.3376350998878479,
0.5150425434112549,
0.3223860263824463,
-0.8809333443641663,
0.6829923987388611,
0.45462197065353394,
0.16684424877166748,
-0.5117539763450623,
-0.8299891352653503,
0.20659583806991577,
-0.115965336561203,
-0.6786743998527527,
0.712735116481781,
0.26174694299697876,
-0.025086287409067154,
0.3154611885547638,
-0.06307167559862137,
-0.04890253767371178,
-0.35081639885902405,
-0.08435124158859253,
0.41713133454322815,
-0.053762804716825485,
0.04704327508807182,
0.29054534435272217,
-0.5657726526260376,
-0.29029083251953125,
-0.5880433917045593,
0.33055222034454346,
0.18309931457042694,
-0.33759644627571106,
-0.4426904618740082,
0.42805302143096924,
0.286925733089447,
-0.1134110689163208,
0.6937578916549683,
0.8081546425819397,
-0.3079293668270111,
-0.2618534564971924,
-0.221963033080101,
-0.2914336323738098,
-0.37683308124542236,
0.1596127152442932,
-0.3793419301509857,
-0.8779592514038086,
0.45380666851997375,
-0.04847565293312073,
-0.0612306222319603,
0.348591685295105,
0.382198303937912,
0.038798026740550995,
0.7844868302345276,
0.6749357581138611,
-0.1914905607700348,
0.24042567610740662,
-0.19340361654758453,
0.588870108127594,
-0.5938270092010498,
-0.22733552753925323,
-0.1972235143184662,
-0.1330072283744812,
-0.49155035614967346,
-0.7713209390640259,
0.2097547948360443,
-0.051893286406993866,
0.20795680582523346,
0.24911543726921082,
-0.29189804196357727,
0.47625526785850525,
0.3391990661621094,
-0.2596265971660614,
0.2994356155395508,
0.06644399464130402,
-0.39226800203323364,
-0.15740469098091125,
-0.8527063131332397,
0.00816857535392046,
0.9532975554466248,
0.01015398371964693,
0.6116259098052979,
-0.12316671758890152,
0.5219464898109436,
0.07411953806877136,
-0.08301074057817459,
-0.43038150668144226,
0.48134201765060425,
-0.29872649908065796,
-0.2367512583732605,
-0.4284663200378418,
-0.5892102718353271,
-0.8346648216247559,
0.6049495935440063,
-0.14152967929840088,
-0.6406965255737305,
0.4175513684749603,
-0.1782507598400116,
-0.045910872519016266,
0.37578803300857544,
-0.7847999930381775,
0.9977194666862488,
-0.3869895935058594,
-0.18531487882137299,
-0.23359069228172302,
-0.8987581729888916,
0.23113879561424255,
-0.19376705586910248,
0.18793247640132904,
0.20179130136966705,
-0.1089560016989708,
0.791471540927887,
-0.5633144378662109,
0.994386613368988,
-0.46507781744003296,
0.06403648108243942,
0.3181479275226593,
-0.16409407556056976,
0.3381378650665283,
-0.033662233501672745,
0.36330264806747437,
0.3776718080043793,
0.0931876003742218,
-0.540178120136261,
-0.7975947260856628,
0.6925521492958069,
-0.4928368926048279,
-0.12619683146476746,
-0.41389164328575134,
-0.4493241012096405,
-0.47647398710250854,
0.2514326274394989,
0.18084107339382172,
0.2904922366142273,
-0.06818559020757675,
0.0031856244895607233,
0.5939493179321289,
-0.09650104492902756,
0.3775206506252289,
0.8690022230148315,
-0.015800900757312775,
-0.15091657638549805,
1.2082322835922241,
0.04463862255215645,
0.07447759062051773,
0.5460343360900879,
0.11676625162363052,
-0.8355402946472168,
-0.47802087664604187,
-0.8471213579177856,
0.4572265148162842,
-0.533515453338623,
-0.03071986697614193,
-0.6105726361274719,
0.3132071793079376,
-0.4857192635536194,
-0.1973014622926712,
-0.31670764088630676,
-0.43573707342147827,
-0.3546915054321289,
-0.34683263301849365,
0.2871730625629425,
0.3847180902957916,
-0.338816374540329,
0.45586055517196655,
-0.7865175008773804,
0.7487359642982483,
0.12855176627635956,
0.3941843807697296,
-0.07346033304929733,
-0.6258088946342468,
-0.0041295550763607025,
0.21497842669487,
0.35971346497535706,
-0.6536737084388733,
0.32081928849220276,
0.11896110326051712,
0.7349566221237183,
0.561237633228302,
0.08035530894994736,
1.1435688734054565,
-0.41762006282806396,
0.6742245554924011,
0.41279521584510803,
-1.1116403341293335,
0.23242110013961792,
0.09480496495962143,
0.32183051109313965,
0.6067233681678772,
0.2999948561191559,
-0.5224035382270813,
-0.13219794631004333,
-0.519727349281311,
-0.7614402174949646,
0.928250789642334,
-0.1008329764008522,
0.10733385384082794,
0.10047659277915955,
0.1356937140226364,
0.2705082297325134,
-0.036222852766513824,
-0.5005577206611633,
-0.15094612538814545,
-0.522495448589325,
-0.21761009097099304,
0.02351333200931549,
-0.11160782724618912,
0.20574605464935303,
-0.4416843354701996,
0.6525783538818359,
-0.3972507417201996,
-0.05218949541449547,
0.1101367250084877,
-0.4696001410484314,
-0.13145750761032104,
0.1719146966934204,
0.2313920557498932,
0.7416624426841736,
0.012976733967661858,
0.18008366227149963,
0.18082374334335327,
-0.32115375995635986,
-0.06834498792886734,
0.10722605884075165,
-0.10296174138784409,
0.1723177433013916,
0.2825121581554413,
0.7649621367454529,
0.6661797165870667,
-0.7513132095336914,
0.5167134404182434,
-0.15450811386108398,
-0.08764980733394623,
0.065663643181324,
-0.35009706020355225,
-0.03799835219979286,
-0.18436133861541748,
0.3620961308479309,
-0.39356714487075806,
0.10289968550205231,
-0.6117258071899414,
0.5092365741729736,
0.646554708480835,
-0.24127717316150665,
-0.30926328897476196,
0.1878444403409958,
0.044131115078926086,
0.2881849706172943,
0.4152827262878418,
-0.3682972490787506,
-0.5619500875473022,
0.06795301288366318,
0.675638735294342,
0.6011924743652344,
-0.16048647463321686,
0.6201757192611694,
0.10052764415740967,
0.10697014629840851,
0.15097999572753906,
0.266456663608551,
-0.3363647758960724,
-0.7921878695487976,
-0.6036543250083923,
-0.5254200100898743,
-0.23996230959892273,
-0.10079599171876907,
-0.36874938011169434,
0.1319674402475357,
-0.11516161262989044,
0.40646791458129883,
-0.16291312873363495,
-0.0694134309887886,
-0.4585550129413605,
0.32143834233283997,
-0.07374744862318039,
0.7788336277008057,
-1.0059795379638672,
0.9419385194778442,
0.6838703155517578,
-0.38968944549560547,
-0.6053228378295898,
0.05427196994423866,
-0.21832901239395142,
-0.9764442443847656,
0.5573444962501526,
-0.05727165937423706,
-0.28954017162323,
-0.13541492819786072,
-0.02817366272211075,
-0.7254825234413147,
0.7195574641227722,
0.3018322288990021,
-0.1658657044172287,
0.0937504768371582,
0.779392659664154,
0.7458572387695312,
-0.3730941414833069,
0.29770269989967346,
0.500438392162323,
0.5296681523323059,
0.4775201380252838,
-0.7078158259391785,
-0.043209437280893326,
-0.21472801268100739,
0.021252842620015144,
0.24081720411777496,
-0.023004671558737755,
0.3624069094657898,
-0.04611910879611969,
-0.2666817903518677,
-0.30811813473701477,
0.8349958062171936,
-0.05251823365688324,
0.2315756380558014,
0.6505535840988159,
0.7549806237220764,
0.6132051348686218,
0.06520523875951767,
0.698257565498352,
-0.24999314546585083,
-0.03985846787691116,
0.9288895130157471,
-0.32732143998146057,
0.46155643463134766,
0.8090999722480774,
0.09000880271196365,
0.4421080946922302,
0.6255958676338196,
0.38222214579582214,
0.8453310132026672,
-0.01214572973549366,
-0.05695926770567894,
-0.3342059254646301,
-0.41861045360565186,
-0.25788959860801697,
0.7540326118469238,
0.2601339519023895,
0.011586017906665802,
-0.69594407081604,
0.14385727047920227,
-0.12780366837978363,
0.05347021296620369,
-0.3264177143573761,
0.9718782305717468,
-0.019498905166983604,
-0.5163930058479309,
0.6459746956825256,
0.12389694154262543,
0.8892518877983093,
-0.6927410364151001,
-0.12028869241476059,
-0.19489699602127075,
-0.10775772482156754,
-0.25493869185447693,
-0.8757569193840027,
0.5300187468528748,
0.17017284035682678,
-0.016676578670740128,
-0.30391472578048706,
0.7416069507598877,
-0.7521690130233765,
-0.5470430254936218,
0.7288116216659546,
0.5786538124084473,
0.2357187569141388,
0.037836600095033646,
-0.7087187767028809,
-0.1835254281759262,
0.00622366089373827,
0.24290554225444794,
0.6313415765762329,
0.611803412437439,
-0.2939879298210144,
0.2749665677547455,
0.8552355766296387,
0.06623128056526184,
0.11621475219726562,
0.37859082221984863,
0.8245369791984558,
-0.3496902287006378,
-0.9383692741394043,
-0.49376216530799866,
0.35698065161705017,
-0.06607036292552948,
-0.1651746779680252,
0.6543076634407043,
0.43130388855934143,
1.179255485534668,
0.11186779290437698,
0.6000248193740845,
0.12475036084651947,
0.6274209022521973,
-0.5622431635856628,
0.571098268032074,
-0.6241483688354492,
-0.01890392228960991,
-0.24298404157161713,
-0.774889349937439,
-0.38415008783340454,
0.5182495713233948,
-0.4357975721359253,
-0.3053198456764221,
0.4893021881580353,
0.7898095846176147,
-0.3419257700443268,
0.13116680085659027,
0.39369702339172363,
-0.05073446407914162,
-0.03284414857625961,
0.4716804027557373,
0.3601178824901581,
-0.00005164712274563499,
0.41393551230430603,
-0.5396009683609009,
-0.4218926727771759,
0.11139114201068878,
-0.7556160092353821,
-0.9679590463638306,
-0.616235613822937,
-0.0135006383061409,
0.3837426006793976,
-0.06013847142457962,
0.641418993473053,
0.5716288685798645,
-0.8210541009902954,
-0.051143672317266464,
-0.2573317587375641,
0.254210889339447,
-0.060728855431079865,
-0.24182181060314178,
0.5829542279243469,
-0.4511936902999878,
-0.6372650265693665,
0.8020721673965454,
0.4215855300426483,
-0.16403092443943024,
-0.2792294919490814,
-0.044954512268304825,
-0.294470876455307,
-0.06586787849664688,
0.4101780354976654,
0.41167721152305603,
-0.5789634585380554,
-0.20283548533916473,
-0.0006685289554297924,
0.2759340703487396,
0.061859726905822754,
0.8561356663703918,
-1.0592217445373535,
0.6842238306999207,
0.6816985607147217,
0.9609763026237488,
0.41800448298454285,
0.038014400750398636,
0.48925119638442993,
-0.7572705149650574,
0.49774500727653503,
-0.1381056010723114,
0.5228326916694641,
0.4715246260166168,
-0.41459912061691284,
0.2912142872810364,
0.46812704205513,
0.1344018131494522,
-0.8025773167610168,
0.0053225127048790455,
-0.8572266697883606,
-0.5323656797409058,
0.8034831285476685,
-0.1150255873799324,
-0.34212765097618103,
-0.5500963926315308,
-0.13352197408676147,
0.39309799671173096,
-0.2931448221206665,
0.6087641716003418,
0.25192832946777344,
-0.24487832188606262,
-0.09719939529895782,
0.11402406543493271,
0.38361382484436035,
0.7631193399429321,
-0.8735880255699158,
0.11609407514333725,
0.2996414601802826,
0.23094181716442108,
0.14521153271198273,
0.5355293154716492,
-0.29889100790023804,
0.28956952691078186,
-0.383774071931839,
-0.06741584837436676,
-0.03491560369729996,
-0.48018136620521545,
-0.24750873446464539,
-0.06646114587783813,
-0.5469874739646912,
-0.4674491286277771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16356v1 | Evaluation of Instruction-Following Ability for Large Language Models on Story-Ending Generation | 2024-06-24T06:53:36 | 2024-06-24T06:53:36 | Rem Hida, Junki Ohmura, Toshiyuki Sekiya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable
performance across various benchmark tasks. While providing instructions to
LLMs for guiding their generations is user-friendly, assessing their
instruction-following capabilities is still unclarified due to a lack of
evaluation metrics. In this paper, we focus on evaluating the
instruction-following ability of LLMs in the context of story-ending
generation, which requires diverse and context-specific instructions. We
propose an automatic evaluation pipeline that utilizes a machine reading
comprehension (MRC) model to determine whether the generated story-ending
reflects instruction. Our findings demonstrate that our proposed metric aligns
with human evaluation. Furthermore, our experiments confirm that recent
open-source LLMs can achieve instruction-following performance close to
GPT-3.5, as assessed through automatic evaluation. | [
-0.3300471007823944,
-0.46762600541114807,
0.645643949508667,
0.1592729240655899,
-0.290761798620224,
0.3967038691043854,
-0.42865073680877686,
-0.21879790723323822,
-0.2980014383792877,
0.5561635494232178,
-0.9628007411956787,
-0.6893979907035828,
-0.6226198673248291,
0.21627183258533478,
-0.3406654894351959,
1.0325011014938354,
-0.2717186212539673,
-0.1225196048617363,
-0.4305334687232971,
0.12834565341472626,
-0.6735779643058777,
-0.16333620250225067,
-0.40067556500434875,
-0.3206908702850342,
0.5672320127487183,
0.46569305658340454,
0.6666776537895203,
1.1688110828399658,
0.25057166814804077,
0.2077247053384781,
-0.011989418417215347,
0.4876748025417328,
-0.46257007122039795,
0.16411052644252777,
0.0643153041601181,
-0.21053209900856018,
-0.30706512928009033,
0.11032940447330475,
0.9479260444641113,
0.7554502487182617,
-0.004551845137029886,
0.4640424847602844,
0.4640100598335266,
0.7722523212432861,
-0.5198734402656555,
0.11916378885507584,
-0.3172648251056671,
0.2335231900215149,
0.29598140716552734,
-0.5513938069343567,
-0.8938077092170715,
-0.6079965829849243,
0.24928361177444458,
-0.22079108655452728,
0.12809152901172638,
0.14683859050273895,
0.5491895079612732,
0.2850443124771118,
-0.33970603346824646,
-0.6617118716239929,
-0.4845014810562134,
0.6349917650222778,
-0.6416406035423279,
0.5551774501800537,
0.44496700167655945,
0.28528931736946106,
-0.13468483090400696,
-0.5231900215148926,
-0.2686219811439514,
-0.5900646448135376,
-0.0074031469412148,
0.18771332502365112,
-0.01842425763607025,
-0.057083241641521454,
0.18840600550174713,
0.22491025924682617,
-0.6254956722259521,
0.29385897517204285,
-0.39173248410224915,
0.14572879672050476,
0.43361416459083557,
0.5275734066963196,
0.32330402731895447,
-0.3407420814037323,
-0.37600570917129517,
-0.026120586320757866,
-0.667464554309845,
0.09004858881235123,
0.6793342232704163,
0.12257460504770279,
-0.2022397369146347,
0.6125669479370117,
-0.12573547661304474,
0.8291710019111633,
-0.12228881567716599,
0.16678597033023834,
0.20175522565841675,
-0.5380056500434875,
-0.04926489666104317,
-0.032003942877054214,
0.648974597454071,
0.5209031105041504,
0.336514413356781,
-0.34972527623176575,
-0.4494166076183319,
-0.3554980456829071,
0.2843259572982788,
-0.9104331731796265,
-0.09848710894584656,
-0.07180053740739822,
-0.5238072872161865,
-0.25960248708724976,
-0.08954073488712311,
-0.7458938956260681,
-0.29391980171203613,
-0.36213263869285583,
0.27104300260543823,
-0.5521027445793152,
0.26171234250068665,
-0.13735191524028778,
-0.13684098422527313,
0.5343252420425415,
0.16604489088058472,
-1.0611299276351929,
0.06744050979614258,
0.9400755763053894,
0.9837415814399719,
-0.2759230434894562,
-0.48953524231910706,
-0.8396618962287903,
0.02237381599843502,
-0.47925740480422974,
0.8064859509468079,
-0.8156120181083679,
-0.4248446822166443,
-0.096506267786026,
0.08296141773462296,
-0.27308979630470276,
-0.3458618223667145,
0.6048200130462646,
-0.45904281735420227,
0.4564574658870697,
0.01615726202726364,
-0.9029129147529602,
-0.16390304267406464,
0.08276938647031784,
-0.3122628927230835,
0.6271023750305176,
0.1719473898410797,
-0.44993507862091064,
0.3201999068260193,
-0.5284537672996521,
-0.571833074092865,
0.0747736319899559,
0.07460172474384308,
-0.21637699007987976,
0.30564820766448975,
0.2943400740623474,
0.31365713477134705,
-0.40015482902526855,
-0.025517191737890244,
-0.2190852165222168,
-0.7957068681716919,
0.0035775385331362486,
-0.875533401966095,
0.8354473114013672,
0.06321221590042114,
-0.3083481788635254,
0.1564442664384842,
-0.750117301940918,
0.2956060767173767,
-0.14703580737113953,
-0.5002627968788147,
-0.07329884171485901,
0.13388988375663757,
-0.5098411440849304,
-0.053810231387615204,
0.2766610383987427,
-0.2697301506996155,
0.253359317779541,
-0.09473056346178055,
0.3109094798564911,
0.8556751012802124,
0.11446244269609451,
0.2634112536907196,
-0.25650733709335327,
0.9972435235977173,
-0.6406286954879761,
0.028088988736271858,
-1.0010422468185425,
-0.5548589825630188,
-0.8227103352546692,
-0.15962132811546326,
0.22116556763648987,
0.5833421349525452,
-0.44737276434898376,
0.5647997856140137,
-0.20372343063354492,
-0.5263440012931824,
-0.6012309789657593,
0.22189576923847198,
0.5792195796966553,
0.5282403230667114,
0.28758037090301514,
-0.327862411737442,
-0.5294532179832458,
-0.676109254360199,
-0.3166375458240509,
-0.17154668271541595,
-0.3501054644584656,
0.36815115809440613,
0.31538593769073486,
-0.29345566034317017,
0.6841523051261902,
-0.45172119140625,
0.23403102159500122,
-0.2794320583343506,
0.3375197947025299,
0.19325777888298035,
0.20774242281913757,
0.003820638405159116,
-0.10057248175144196,
-0.45985379815101624,
0.0679498016834259,
-0.7972418665885925,
-0.5152990818023682,
-0.2685590386390686,
-0.04337504506111145,
0.2414208948612213,
0.3362450897693634,
-0.2937529385089874,
0.2806503474712372,
0.6312156319618225,
-0.5032527446746826,
0.9174124598503113,
-0.34546297788619995,
0.39009279012680054,
-0.7471853494644165,
-0.07269831001758575,
-0.05812752991914749,
-0.1220642551779747,
-0.35000789165496826,
0.1063564196228981,
0.19841541349887848,
0.03385736793279648,
-0.19929897785186768,
0.5024390816688538,
-0.6893605589866638,
-0.6628695130348206,
-0.21783514320850372,
0.3568357229232788,
0.18514980375766754,
0.34154585003852844,
0.0795736238360405,
0.9793148040771484,
0.34125351905822754,
-0.37932711839675903,
0.33667832612991333,
0.020292310044169426,
-0.5413213968276978,
0.41876986622810364,
-0.48851680755615234,
0.3337891399860382,
-0.05043167993426323,
0.2387368381023407,
-0.7708561420440674,
-0.0065983617678284645,
0.16130273044109344,
-0.5006237030029297,
0.219489187002182,
-0.4131826162338257,
-0.7182934284210205,
-0.5348702669143677,
-0.2788059413433075,
-0.1830645501613617,
0.7941685914993286,
-0.5723032355308533,
0.5606561303138733,
-0.3526379466056824,
-0.2491026222705841,
-0.4246353209018707,
-0.5882102251052856,
0.27704742550849915,
-0.14227858185768127,
-0.7039764523506165,
-0.09479313343763351,
-0.30711570382118225,
0.06107107549905777,
-0.07880377769470215,
0.028577670454978943,
-0.03873195871710777,
-0.10235268622636795,
0.07999920845031738,
0.4661524295806885,
-0.39105942845344543,
-0.07175672799348831,
0.20044873654842377,
-0.04827437177300453,
0.2424621433019638,
-0.24105437099933624,
0.4581219255924225,
-0.2324777990579605,
-0.37932711839675903,
-0.4635551869869232,
0.15628014504909515,
0.42368385195732117,
-0.4025340974330902,
0.6731658577919006,
0.5874620079994202,
-0.08538232743740082,
-0.30792975425720215,
-0.2691059410572052,
-0.08319023251533508,
-0.49429258704185486,
0.4865569770336151,
-0.18098780512809753,
-0.6204921007156372,
0.48712509870529175,
0.145950049161911,
0.35122764110565186,
0.24075539410114288,
0.6605652570724487,
-0.3214603662490845,
1.1670879125595093,
0.48976096510887146,
0.41337841749191284,
0.40522634983062744,
-0.018134690821170807,
-0.01592370867729187,
-1.0471984148025513,
-0.1810988336801529,
-0.2793615460395813,
-0.1608688235282898,
-0.4016329050064087,
-0.4027382433414459,
0.1506044715642929,
0.19556598365306854,
-0.12085499614477158,
0.48069947957992554,
-0.38608264923095703,
0.7220416069030762,
0.46139103174209595,
-0.19521979987621307,
0.6710072755813599,
-0.1857644021511078,
-0.3479621112346649,
0.27770471572875977,
-0.6945815682411194,
-0.9082335829734802,
0.9792331457138062,
0.6108207702636719,
0.6697760224342346,
-0.12145223468542099,
0.7385057806968689,
0.4145056903362274,
0.7002459168434143,
-0.6661139726638794,
0.6089065670967102,
-0.24688927829265594,
-0.2518778443336487,
-0.2361263632774353,
-0.6580933928489685,
-0.7199981808662415,
0.372972309589386,
0.07938160002231598,
-0.818436324596405,
-0.3353103995323181,
0.031783655285835266,
-0.3460523188114166,
0.16847392916679382,
-0.9607678055763245,
1.004104495048523,
-0.4362412393093109,
-0.2004791647195816,
-0.2657364010810852,
-0.4933159053325653,
0.4705672264099121,
-0.19344593584537506,
0.00464203953742981,
0.008173934184014797,
-0.19625742733478546,
0.6359317898750305,
-0.2729201018810272,
0.652839183807373,
0.008155221119523048,
-0.13836725056171417,
0.5415108799934387,
0.06627047806978226,
0.3029979467391968,
-0.32555949687957764,
-0.09970198571681976,
-0.15993346273899078,
-0.11999233812093735,
-0.08695073425769806,
-0.7487151622772217,
0.8017693758010864,
-0.5420495867729187,
-0.6835417151451111,
-0.10018277168273926,
-0.6859827637672424,
-0.2857239246368408,
0.17355835437774658,
0.20409716665744781,
0.4995817542076111,
-0.2171003669500351,
0.10287029296159744,
0.5354984402656555,
-0.36834096908569336,
0.572662353515625,
0.6692396998405457,
-0.2568453848361969,
-0.35922229290008545,
0.8936786651611328,
0.08940032124519348,
0.31347277760505676,
0.1568886637687683,
0.3081696033477783,
-0.5374034643173218,
-0.6613053679466248,
-1.2832599878311157,
0.17051847279071808,
-0.7992642521858215,
-0.08022944629192352,
-0.450796514749527,
-0.23644854128360748,
0.13464821875095367,
-0.3321685492992401,
-0.1422334760427475,
-0.05615249648690224,
-0.5106823444366455,
-0.1483059972524643,
-0.03463418781757355,
0.8485277891159058,
0.2950972616672516,
0.22514432668685913,
-1.2049776315689087,
-0.0568401999771595,
0.12487176805734634,
0.5780160427093506,
0.2514910399913788,
-1.0007113218307495,
-0.3414359390735626,
-0.10252683609724045,
-0.46695688366889954,
-0.813085675239563,
0.10257215797901154,
0.13513901829719543,
0.46216487884521484,
0.30624210834503174,
-0.12987391650676727,
0.6018410325050354,
-0.7976426482200623,
0.5120282173156738,
0.12007606774568558,
-0.8581026792526245,
0.3675095736980438,
-0.34064653515815735,
0.6824182868003845,
0.33164963126182556,
0.19532641768455505,
-0.6014785766601562,
-0.4475278854370117,
-0.20861871540546417,
-0.6081676483154297,
0.6446618437767029,
0.10935241729021072,
0.2497328668832779,
-0.06300000101327896,
0.35637250542640686,
0.1976282298564911,
0.13080137968063354,
-0.36444419622421265,
-0.034703779965639114,
-0.03431987389922142,
-0.2626972794532776,
0.02376929670572281,
-0.09473507106304169,
0.20793527364730835,
0.06105819717049599,
0.3951917886734009,
-0.01226103026419878,
-0.008596740663051605,
-0.23043182492256165,
-0.1991213709115982,
-0.35490480065345764,
0.25026440620422363,
0.5426987409591675,
0.8849323987960815,
-0.17111295461654663,
-0.08699671179056168,
0.22137553989887238,
-0.21759650111198425,
0.1000412181019783,
0.2983529567718506,
-0.3487204313278198,
-0.18517781794071198,
0.7192180156707764,
0.9854454398155212,
0.1519775688648224,
-1.0437965393066406,
0.36412760615348816,
-0.13976624608039856,
-0.04404696449637413,
-0.2962503433227539,
0.3233143389225006,
0.2748761773109436,
0.28857237100601196,
0.5271533727645874,
-0.13852576911449432,
0.09147025644779205,
-0.5176590085029602,
0.5144369006156921,
0.29918575286865234,
-0.4103969931602478,
-0.23264113068580627,
0.4123395085334778,
0.21587762236595154,
-0.5736314654350281,
0.8356543183326721,
-0.2927778959274292,
-0.46672266721725464,
0.6771304607391357,
0.508236289024353,
1.1242482662200928,
-0.29044684767723083,
0.1368703544139862,
0.24845287203788757,
0.5440555810928345,
0.11700088530778885,
-0.0450175479054451,
-0.0772828683257103,
-0.16099263727664948,
-0.7851080298423767,
-0.6392886638641357,
-0.47591274976730347,
-0.1806662380695343,
-0.6897926926612854,
0.41755759716033936,
-0.3658698797225952,
0.19394075870513916,
-0.2953875958919525,
-0.07269473373889923,
-0.6689696907997131,
0.13187429308891296,
0.33196327090263367,
1.0357728004455566,
-0.5304349660873413,
0.6143752932548523,
0.367901474237442,
-0.24292947351932526,
-0.4613454341888428,
0.28277885913848877,
-0.038450952619314194,
-0.763512134552002,
0.4470023810863495,
0.5368674397468567,
-0.4035753905773163,
0.02430647984147072,
-0.1413053572177887,
-0.4747803509235382,
1.1807478666305542,
0.2331843376159668,
-0.8276569843292236,
-0.16066502034664154,
-0.08913198113441467,
0.7450829148292542,
-0.7644203305244446,
0.6005423665046692,
0.7166997790336609,
0.41393086314201355,
0.1448521912097931,
-0.6968689560890198,
-0.1747896820306778,
-0.039896540343761444,
-0.11336664110422134,
0.09701661765575409,
-0.4584157466888428,
0.24234816431999207,
-0.6377596259117126,
-0.3294069170951843,
0.37506353855133057,
0.7394365668296814,
0.19772055745124817,
0.42794251441955566,
0.4997583031654358,
0.4998960494995117,
0.6015533804893494,
0.22482691705226898,
1.2762348651885986,
-0.3998730778694153,
0.23493079841136932,
1.3083280324935913,
0.01746760867536068,
1.003339171409607,
0.028276847675442696,
-0.03978990018367767,
0.6466960906982422,
0.7767361402511597,
-0.1401863396167755,
0.47530296444892883,
0.37356218695640564,
-0.13499419391155243,
-0.029528290033340454,
0.041669610887765884,
-0.06705989688634872,
0.3935990333557129,
0.14679303765296936,
-0.8277386426925659,
-0.12144435942173004,
-0.17458806931972504,
-0.05665936693549156,
0.026116179302334785,
-0.3709885776042938,
0.6800392270088196,
-0.016886426135897636,
-0.9435274600982666,
0.8402482867240906,
-0.004698552191257477,
0.3080707788467407,
-0.4699842929840088,
-0.16812549531459808,
-0.29540035128593445,
-0.16507643461227417,
-0.050424445420503616,
-1.116081714630127,
0.2393379658460617,
0.4857267439365387,
-0.19432108104228973,
-0.16819778084754944,
0.25767844915390015,
-0.4731435179710388,
-0.5223411321640015,
0.2754151523113251,
0.5304110646247864,
0.14102484285831451,
0.3928109407424927,
-0.517637312412262,
0.34530773758888245,
0.20277991890907288,
-0.5465195775032043,
0.26459163427352905,
0.31764212250709534,
0.08870761096477509,
0.9332623481750488,
0.50313401222229,
-0.19269534945487976,
0.1455005556344986,
0.30825093388557434,
0.6641004085540771,
-0.5801559090614319,
-0.3197731077671051,
-0.9118167757987976,
0.43682560324668884,
0.2334212362766266,
-0.4079907238483429,
0.7402445077896118,
0.5509143471717834,
0.7244716882705688,
0.14815334975719452,
0.7497062087059021,
0.3209238350391388,
0.4074658751487732,
-0.5164020657539368,
0.5665993690490723,
-0.2423088550567627,
0.5696598291397095,
-0.07642707973718643,
-1.2897981405258179,
0.023448536172509193,
0.38347387313842773,
-0.35169902443885803,
0.25413984060287476,
0.7322672009468079,
0.42233607172966003,
-0.05137872323393822,
0.2837722599506378,
0.21713735163211823,
0.13188596069812775,
0.07709763944149017,
0.5232170820236206,
1.0009983777999878,
-0.0175861194729805,
0.7232325673103333,
0.0765821561217308,
-0.5573670268058777,
-0.038618139922618866,
-1.0385609865188599,
-1.0080093145370483,
-0.32837116718292236,
-0.2252049297094345,
-0.1538800448179245,
0.3788314759731293,
0.8610357642173767,
0.4245782494544983,
-0.41854292154312134,
-0.19689194858074188,
-0.03944672644138336,
0.03531312942504883,
-0.2595050036907196,
-0.20165981352329254,
0.35802900791168213,
-0.40100008249282837,
-0.8704360127449036,
0.6957189440727234,
0.34395503997802734,
-0.19643312692642212,
-0.7671372294425964,
-0.34927046298980713,
0.21443916857242584,
0.1931665688753128,
0.6756147146224976,
0.04475663602352142,
-0.7310390472412109,
-0.3912504315376282,
0.09510689228773117,
-0.0562908835709095,
-0.049676842987537384,
0.6965080499649048,
-0.7534880638122559,
0.6167476177215576,
0.3929870128631592,
0.8589252829551697,
0.32028499245643616,
0.2056325525045395,
0.797454833984375,
-0.6050602197647095,
-0.6117075681686401,
0.3255777657032013,
0.303801953792572,
0.49893179535865784,
-0.187261700630188,
0.5091428756713867,
-0.08253409713506699,
-0.6351341009140015,
-0.7424208521842957,
0.16574086248874664,
-0.37479615211486816,
-0.03234034404158592,
1.1001347303390503,
-0.4467667043209076,
-0.045906297862529755,
0.15538790822029114,
0.014787783846259117,
0.16107837855815887,
-0.4002610445022583,
0.6077242493629456,
0.8889108896255493,
-0.19011440873146057,
-0.8372382521629333,
-0.9252537488937378,
-0.027215637266635895,
0.2716752290725708,
-0.7667191028594971,
0.5113115906715393,
0.6301762461662292,
0.25190556049346924,
-0.2260776311159134,
0.2809068560600281,
0.035952139645814896,
0.3199877440929413,
-0.09169740974903107,
-0.1872943490743637,
-0.291983425617218,
-0.35845547914505005,
-0.4314986765384674,
-0.10200198739767075,
0.014055849052965641,
-0.07899094372987747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16342v1 | ADVSCORE: A Metric for the Evaluation and Creation of Adversarial Benchmarks | 2024-06-24T06:27:47 | 2024-06-24T06:27:47 | Yoo Yeon Sung, Eve Fleisig, Ishani Mondal, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adversarial benchmarks validate model abilities by providing samples that
fool models but not humans. However, despite the proliferation of datasets that
claim to be adversarial, there does not exist an established metric to evaluate
how adversarial these datasets are. To address this lacuna, we introduce
ADVSCORE, a metric which quantifies how adversarial and discriminative an
adversarial dataset is and exposes the features that make data adversarial. We
then use ADVSCORE to underpin a dataset creation pipeline that incentivizes
writing a high-quality adversarial dataset. As a proof of concept, we use
ADVSCORE to collect an adversarial question answering (QA) dataset, ADVQA, from
our pipeline. The high-quality questions in ADVQA surpasses three adversarial
benchmarks across domains at fooling several models but not humans. We validate
our result based on difficulty estimates from 9,347 human responses on four
datasets and predictions from three models. Moreover, ADVSCORE uncovers which
adversarial tactics used by human writers fool models (e.g., GPT-4) but not
humans. Through ADVSCORE and its analyses, we offer guidance on revealing
language model vulnerabilities and producing reliable adversarial examples. | [
-0.3643151819705963,
-0.8114119172096252,
0.2796440124511719,
-0.4189641773700714,
0.23517769575119019,
0.2562463581562042,
0.026820514351129532,
0.1369447410106659,
-0.3345237076282501,
0.47458186745643616,
-0.413966566324234,
-0.5311852693557739,
-0.5204644799232483,
-0.4190404713153839,
-0.6628234386444092,
1.2830833196640015,
0.04736078158020973,
0.029383793473243713,
-0.5324318408966064,
-0.2421071082353592,
-0.09893228858709335,
-0.7560611367225647,
-0.4139293134212494,
-0.05772531032562256,
0.21170583367347717,
0.01895531825721264,
0.8954346776008606,
0.6371688842773438,
0.5545242428779602,
0.2732895016670227,
-0.09478075057268143,
0.4519004821777344,
-0.4884539246559143,
0.08486386388540268,
-0.11347823590040207,
-0.7510350346565247,
-0.4841739535331726,
0.48088571429252625,
0.3103163242340088,
0.2655429244041443,
-0.1543777585029602,
0.385189414024353,
-0.1687135249376297,
0.6329084634780884,
-0.7699685096740723,
-0.19029369950294495,
-0.7444701790809631,
0.05749150365591049,
-0.3911714553833008,
0.06213100254535675,
-0.14667220413684845,
-0.5060493350028992,
-0.12072829157114029,
-0.5172560811042786,
0.5930612087249756,
-0.061632782220840454,
0.7831989526748657,
0.34965720772743225,
-0.2871999144554138,
-0.239257350564003,
-0.6192600727081299,
0.6474364399909973,
-0.47439008951187134,
-0.08662506937980652,
0.1698308140039444,
0.6867759823799133,
-0.16600622236728668,
-0.5030491352081299,
-0.43388327956199646,
-0.3681977391242981,
0.3146601617336273,
0.053747110068798065,
-0.5928685069084167,
-0.2970265746116638,
0.3528691828250885,
0.32014188170433044,
-0.797301173210144,
-0.17416100203990936,
-0.33664676547050476,
-0.2778937518596649,
0.8059704303741455,
0.3669106364250183,
0.37806829810142517,
-0.004528356250375509,
-0.5693899989128113,
-0.42692482471466064,
-0.8095998167991638,
0.3082411587238312,
0.9360080361366272,
0.06574754416942596,
0.3432657718658447,
0.3605254292488098,
0.13201740384101868,
0.44939181208610535,
-0.26186394691467285,
0.1728365570306778,
0.1239587813615799,
-0.25618189573287964,
-0.06742990016937256,
-0.1747017353773117,
0.8635411858558655,
0.26281845569610596,
0.24273720383644104,
-0.4133232533931732,
-0.3208288252353668,
0.7276018261909485,
0.9466402530670166,
-0.4717656970024109,
-0.5407615900039673,
0.27723395824432373,
-0.055185865610837936,
-0.7308778762817383,
0.0647912472486496,
-0.43067020177841187,
-0.8605895638465881,
0.16725657880306244,
0.47019752860069275,
-0.4916991591453552,
-0.1724318116903305,
-0.10908249765634537,
-0.5117368698120117,
-0.18184460699558258,
0.13875292241573334,
-0.20283906161785126,
0.6913856863975525,
0.8476845026016235,
0.46900486946105957,
-0.10685481131076813,
-0.5102701783180237,
-0.5854551196098328,
-0.39906930923461914,
-0.6449725031852722,
0.6923202872276306,
-0.18307889997959137,
-0.376169890165329,
-0.22218386828899384,
-0.18781904876232147,
0.05178745836019516,
-0.678756058216095,
0.7908439040184021,
-0.6127849221229553,
0.07104219496250153,
-0.3389951288700104,
-0.4622475206851959,
-0.325991690158844,
0.6225206255912781,
-0.6202696561813354,
1.0164738893508911,
0.20662206411361694,
-0.7464675903320312,
0.15084519982337952,
-0.38111424446105957,
-0.319938987493515,
0.016898151487112045,
-0.13735608756542206,
-0.4410020112991333,
0.04476075991988182,
0.35231491923332214,
0.2137903869152069,
-0.5265622735023499,
0.13055531680583954,
-0.5158858895301819,
-0.23221878707408905,
0.5512908101081848,
-0.5738425254821777,
0.8612741231918335,
0.28787773847579956,
-0.15497781336307526,
0.0008285220828838646,
-0.5445730090141296,
0.14100483059883118,
0.38847824931144714,
-0.005745097063481808,
-0.26985952258110046,
0.08864853531122208,
-0.30831462144851685,
0.14467018842697144,
0.11969691514968872,
-0.6051146984100342,
0.04815276339650154,
-0.2489567995071411,
0.4725000560283661,
0.7550212144851685,
0.021343151107430458,
0.07785159349441528,
-0.5637779235839844,
0.7990533709526062,
0.18165726959705353,
0.4106431305408478,
0.19657912850379944,
-0.27526581287384033,
-0.5346792936325073,
-0.06622220575809479,
0.2848966717720032,
0.6664534211158752,
-0.8561540842056274,
0.1486274003982544,
-0.18745562434196472,
-0.9988522529602051,
-0.8658531904220581,
0.41721975803375244,
0.8941994309425354,
0.5983373522758484,
0.3443455100059509,
-0.44787928462028503,
-0.40928107500076294,
-0.9431899189949036,
-0.30737048387527466,
-0.4966849386692047,
0.025994377210736275,
0.46893197298049927,
0.5614378452301025,
0.2548559904098511,
0.6130008101463318,
-0.5088329911231995,
-0.1399717777967453,
0.04274687170982361,
0.12492594867944717,
-0.13634026050567627,
0.15185141563415527,
0.5916655659675598,
-0.762864351272583,
-0.008879347704350948,
-0.4162599742412567,
-0.7677315473556519,
0.2826683223247528,
0.26828524470329285,
-0.12485340982675552,
-0.4609122574329376,
0.17235106229782104,
-0.3127451241016388,
0.01949874870479107,
0.46815377473831177,
-0.29369279742240906,
0.72597336769104,
-0.16712135076522827,
0.44864997267723083,
-0.8484768867492676,
0.10421808063983917,
0.06067504361271858,
-0.14582297205924988,
-0.6050525903701782,
0.34903448820114136,
0.15393497049808502,
-0.32052111625671387,
-0.7774064540863037,
0.22407588362693787,
-0.09981837868690491,
-0.08219511061906815,
0.125461608171463,
0.31741607189178467,
0.42032352089881897,
0.2224193662405014,
-0.48467832803726196,
1.0140646696090698,
0.6015256643295288,
-0.5831484794616699,
0.9496078491210938,
0.22268715500831604,
-0.476468026638031,
0.7654300928115845,
-0.8770014643669128,
0.23926497995853424,
0.027667058631777763,
0.1715061068534851,
-0.8690162897109985,
0.2070520967245102,
-0.04770712926983833,
-0.8275241255760193,
0.026840344071388245,
-0.20654450356960297,
-0.4542471170425415,
-0.5615597367286682,
-0.49981507658958435,
0.14810298383235931,
0.48947855830192566,
-0.4469612240791321,
0.11524102091789246,
0.6065024733543396,
0.30545955896377563,
-0.6619759202003479,
-0.710152804851532,
0.1076216772198677,
-0.2543797492980957,
-0.7227829098701477,
0.3062743842601776,
-0.13691213726997375,
-0.34227895736694336,
0.17232699692249298,
0.22093825042247772,
-0.018175238743424416,
0.547812283039093,
0.36004123091697693,
0.23117919266223907,
-0.4424324333667755,
-0.05986437946557999,
-0.6902419924736023,
0.0016574234468862414,
0.3712117075920105,
-0.0945490300655365,
0.11560522019863129,
-0.49254313111305237,
-0.6116992831230164,
-0.2064519077539444,
0.15127919614315033,
0.7761200666427612,
-0.4236844480037689,
0.3817664682865143,
0.582382321357727,
-0.4073924124240875,
-0.5011990070343018,
-0.3800402879714966,
0.13242076337337494,
-0.409079372882843,
0.42343607544898987,
-0.4634036123752594,
-0.23098720610141754,
0.5838059186935425,
0.32836073637008667,
-0.016108976677060127,
0.615371823310852,
0.41380855441093445,
0.2082158476114273,
1.3307218551635742,
-0.024328408762812614,
-0.1614108681678772,
-0.10048035532236099,
-0.5418812036514282,
-0.1697692573070526,
-1.0392920970916748,
-0.21216024458408356,
-0.3472295105457306,
-0.32091495394706726,
-0.23011374473571777,
-0.490225613117218,
0.2805132269859314,
-0.04453488439321518,
-0.36373212933540344,
0.5782565474510193,
-0.5310734510421753,
0.24760432541370392,
0.6372599005699158,
0.18548645079135895,
-0.20334844291210175,
-0.36602485179901123,
0.05297590047121048,
-0.09019100666046143,
-0.5627133250236511,
-0.49943041801452637,
1.1492737531661987,
0.43310117721557617,
0.7277792096138,
0.2568906247615814,
0.2890118360519409,
0.697467029094696,
0.11196129024028778,
-0.5686233043670654,
0.5066070556640625,
-0.5350455045700073,
-0.8346810340881348,
0.18136261403560638,
-0.48617666959762573,
-0.5210720896720886,
-0.019772689789533615,
-0.026099050417542458,
-0.27206796407699585,
0.06706676632165909,
0.13238969445228577,
-0.5751356482505798,
0.4209558069705963,
-0.6454328894615173,
0.9545585513114929,
-0.39238670468330383,
-0.2013411819934845,
0.07717661559581757,
-0.23317357897758484,
0.3807145953178406,
0.3348586857318878,
0.18504178524017334,
-0.20201405882835388,
-0.000109568951302208,
0.8260175585746765,
-0.37169235944747925,
0.7174542546272278,
-0.3257659673690796,
0.056622106581926346,
0.5848448872566223,
0.4606090784072876,
0.5446182489395142,
-0.03190264478325844,
-0.24877403676509857,
-0.23970158398151398,
-0.14853346347808838,
-0.44196659326553345,
-0.6358409523963928,
0.9582082629203796,
-1.0075175762176514,
-0.5470075011253357,
-0.37233754992485046,
-0.3719274401664734,
-0.3958395719528198,
-0.17571024596691132,
0.264293909072876,
0.6464259028434753,
-0.7526068687438965,
0.12120039016008377,
0.7891661524772644,
0.10972023755311966,
0.010037532076239586,
0.6511304974555969,
0.40893301367759705,
-0.4109083116054535,
1.2590606212615967,
0.09906221926212311,
0.2188798189163208,
0.09274144470691681,
0.10202876478433609,
-0.38544490933418274,
-0.6863174438476562,
-0.8169115781784058,
-0.2572600245475769,
-0.771183967590332,
-0.39982712268829346,
-0.43568694591522217,
-0.4225579798221588,
-0.3864552676677704,
-0.07667811214923859,
-0.7936137318611145,
-0.3309386968612671,
-0.19714759290218353,
0.03812139108777046,
0.32717201113700867,
0.8027349710464478,
0.15328246355056763,
-0.19194330275058746,
-0.5651000142097473,
0.29553714394569397,
0.6309486627578735,
-0.10169614851474762,
-0.08571664243936539,
-0.7670201063156128,
-0.007221308071166277,
0.23604707419872284,
-0.38991284370422363,
-0.7240632772445679,
0.30021122097969055,
0.1915345937013626,
0.7269901633262634,
0.29007500410079956,
0.26162779331207275,
0.46439164876937866,
-0.3458154499530792,
1.1192712783813477,
-0.0001353608095087111,
-0.8612675666809082,
0.6921651363372803,
-0.17411784827709198,
-0.08458075672388077,
0.5943279266357422,
0.24080726504325867,
-0.3165995478630066,
-0.471158891916275,
-0.996312141418457,
-0.5392727851867676,
0.4679777920246124,
0.203955739736557,
-0.1085030809044838,
0.07501573860645294,
0.09262806177139282,
-0.03007940575480461,
0.25387582182884216,
-0.13024403154850006,
-0.43829506635665894,
-0.3712695837020874,
-0.0709756389260292,
-0.2871173620223999,
0.03882017359137535,
-0.6504429578781128,
0.3246634006500244,
0.5953252911567688,
-0.026121804490685463,
-0.17994366586208344,
0.06157148256897926,
-0.16703256964683533,
0.17753718793392181,
0.24755334854125977,
0.23978206515312195,
0.5008208751678467,
-0.13774828612804413,
0.4151580035686493,
0.1810295283794403,
-0.3908684551715851,
0.3007553517818451,
0.2555975019931793,
-0.12877525389194489,
-0.39550167322158813,
0.44710788130760193,
0.7327944040298462,
-0.24011418223381042,
-0.7118367552757263,
0.9318851828575134,
-0.4149680435657501,
-0.23682676255702972,
-0.17617186903953552,
0.3766522705554962,
-0.16299466788768768,
0.25888654589653015,
0.13482819497585297,
0.39977994561195374,
0.28311821818351746,
-0.43694210052490234,
0.3321857154369354,
0.5403708815574646,
-0.871056318283081,
-0.3848734200000763,
0.7439596652984619,
0.2256850004196167,
-0.24728074669837952,
0.4657348096370697,
-0.3379339873790741,
-0.8506776094436646,
0.8697176575660706,
0.14953696727752686,
0.9011963605880737,
-0.15175779163837433,
0.4459143280982971,
0.21527820825576782,
0.4421216547489166,
0.05437489598989487,
-0.01671961322426796,
0.2137150913476944,
-0.5930379033088684,
0.23574377596378326,
-0.5162808299064636,
-0.4146050810813904,
0.16438765823841095,
-0.8931849598884583,
-0.013265854679048061,
-0.5248993039131165,
-0.12371569126844406,
0.3232899606227875,
0.20682260394096375,
-0.6631240248680115,
0.5820857286453247,
0.11976209282875061,
0.7703080773353577,
-0.9819890856742859,
0.4795704185962677,
0.8322884440422058,
-0.39033475518226624,
-0.27701616287231445,
-0.2442339062690735,
0.39848223328590393,
-0.953883171081543,
0.37819698452949524,
-0.23597609996795654,
-0.20181338489055634,
-0.3060501515865326,
-0.29102060198783875,
-0.4232925474643707,
0.9369978904724121,
0.21586757898330688,
0.11068108677864075,
0.11812502890825272,
-0.2387075275182724,
0.6453191041946411,
-0.3423379063606262,
0.20590414106845856,
0.5074023604393005,
0.09607284516096115,
-0.19272449612617493,
-0.3581606447696686,
0.2010720819234848,
-0.7128968238830566,
0.0559864342212677,
0.07777662575244904,
-0.6284539103507996,
0.9168681502342224,
-0.3392849862575531,
-0.3008421063423157,
-0.1510092169046402,
0.38508814573287964,
-0.10391772538423538,
-0.1197093203663826,
0.6669778227806091,
0.7931764125823975,
0.7533359527587891,
-0.09049393236637115,
1.260499358177185,
-0.0706673189997673,
0.0867280662059784,
0.9214330315589905,
-0.04856104776263237,
0.7525941133499146,
-0.0447593629360199,
-0.40938547253608704,
0.18666893243789673,
0.49882712960243225,
-0.2944902181625366,
0.4665364921092987,
0.45492348074913025,
-0.15577483177185059,
-0.3232033848762512,
-0.26734188199043274,
-0.5310764908790588,
0.5296409726142883,
0.3224814534187317,
-0.17793381214141846,
-0.1467352658510208,
-0.1488916575908661,
0.10272105783224106,
0.5273105502128601,
-0.09798932820558548,
0.7169445753097534,
-0.2804741859436035,
-0.6435244083404541,
0.7506138682365417,
0.006307126488536596,
0.3771076798439026,
-0.6525784134864807,
0.2529153525829315,
0.02260771580040455,
0.6257297396659851,
0.01085133571177721,
-0.9717089533805847,
0.24061307311058044,
0.15072001516819,
-0.25303831696510315,
0.051173340529203415,
0.3292548954486847,
-0.1904665231704712,
-0.36110827326774597,
0.1542913168668747,
0.38435667753219604,
-0.0042072925716638565,
-0.26470980048179626,
-1.0357061624526978,
-0.1511540412902832,
-0.0844600573182106,
-0.341290682554245,
0.30384737253189087,
0.25880691409111023,
0.34035933017730713,
0.7305846214294434,
0.6956148743629456,
0.4349857568740845,
-0.3918326497077942,
0.03278880566358566,
1.0297703742980957,
-0.37952104210853577,
-0.37757644057273865,
-0.7808082699775696,
0.32113027572631836,
-0.23300080001354218,
-0.7126423716545105,
0.9399266839027405,
0.585054874420166,
0.6462914943695068,
0.32876062393188477,
1.0363496541976929,
0.035903122276067734,
0.7010764479637146,
-0.10770435631275177,
0.8728119134902954,
-0.6523157358169556,
0.3053932189941406,
0.06430167704820633,
-0.37549206614494324,
0.14378230273723602,
0.014367889612913132,
-0.3086302578449249,
-0.25120434165000916,
0.4828032851219177,
0.9026282429695129,
-0.003958842251449823,
-0.11160105466842651,
0.3736531734466553,
0.2649129033088684,
0.5232585072517395,
0.8198122382164001,
0.8456031084060669,
-0.8662489652633667,
1.028382658958435,
-0.3684319853782654,
-0.2733876705169678,
0.06391790509223938,
-0.6026975512504578,
-0.9491546750068665,
-0.416782945394516,
-0.4325433671474457,
-0.822952389717102,
0.4848104417324066,
0.14926576614379883,
0.7040484547615051,
-0.9251853227615356,
0.04806152731180191,
0.09281381219625473,
0.142759308218956,
-0.4492209851741791,
-0.19769030809402466,
0.3862496614456177,
-0.1201396957039833,
-0.5334728360176086,
0.6140128374099731,
-0.04666929319500923,
-0.09294600039720535,
-0.8483618497848511,
0.112472765147686,
0.11181985586881638,
0.2656743824481964,
0.06375595927238464,
0.3381396234035492,
-0.5396760702133179,
-0.05876968428492546,
-0.040044158697128296,
-0.5279904007911682,
-0.3001707196235657,
0.6101207137107849,
-0.7006288766860962,
0.6929181814193726,
0.5450019836425781,
0.703325092792511,
0.042140647768974304,
0.22467535734176636,
0.7965874075889587,
-0.8815990090370178,
-0.040247272700071335,
0.4846889078617096,
0.16756610572338104,
0.647993803024292,
-0.38768506050109863,
0.31313204765319824,
0.23177050054073334,
-0.5155095458030701,
-0.961566686630249,
0.2943562865257263,
-0.3056842088699341,
-0.3093043863773346,
0.9112081527709961,
-0.5935482382774353,
-0.48240095376968384,
-0.06512852013111115,
0.05725812911987305,
0.00666832085698843,
-0.20307207107543945,
0.7677224278450012,
0.6830468773841858,
0.239071324467659,
0.4280291199684143,
-0.6069411039352417,
0.8774233460426331,
0.08574069291353226,
-0.7498928308486938,
0.32954636216163635,
0.19251294434070587,
0.0992976576089859,
0.24243558943271637,
0.2126021534204483,
-0.24224336445331573,
0.5068439841270447,
0.6817039251327515,
-0.11862538754940033,
-0.5819872617721558,
-0.28531399369239807,
0.03637102246284485,
0.35955750942230225,
-0.0518752746284008,
-0.43095558881759644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16341v1 | EHRCon: Dataset for Checking Consistency between Unstructured Notes and Structured Tables in Electronic Health Records | 2024-06-24T06:26:50 | 2024-06-24T06:26:50 | Yeonsu Kwon, Jiho Kim, Gyubok Lee, Seongsu Bae, Daeun Kyung, Wonchul Cha, Tom Pollard, Alistair Johnson, Edward Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are integral for storing comprehensive
patient medical records, combining structured data (e.g., medications) with
detailed clinical notes (e.g., physician notes). These elements are essential
for straightforward data retrieval and provide deep, contextual insights into
patient care. However, they often suffer from discrepancies due to unintuitive
EHR system designs and human errors, posing serious risks to patient safety. To
address this, we developed EHRCon, a new dataset and task specifically designed
to ensure data consistency between structured tables and unstructured notes in
EHRs. EHRCon was crafted in collaboration with healthcare professionals using
the MIMIC-III EHR dataset, and includes manual annotations of 3,943 entities
across 105 clinical notes checked against database entries for consistency.
EHRCon has two versions, one using the original MIMIC-III schema, and another
using the OMOP CDM schema, in order to increase its applicability and
generalizability. Furthermore, leveraging the capabilities of large language
models, we introduce CheckEHR, a novel framework for verifying the consistency
between clinical notes and database tables. CheckEHR utilizes an eight-stage
process and shows promising results in both few-shot and zero-shot settings.
The code is available at https://github.com/dustn1259/EHRCon. | [
0.2752126455307007,
-0.8907455801963806,
0.7646400928497314,
0.07997377216815948,
-0.2781180739402771,
-0.0733940601348877,
-0.10383423417806625,
-0.5252310037612915,
0.36399704217910767,
0.7672123908996582,
-0.07370464503765106,
-0.8976604342460632,
-0.37676021456718445,
0.25458672642707825,
-0.30093055963516235,
1.429037094116211,
-0.4868292212486267,
0.016395818442106247,
-0.12566787004470825,
-0.386223167181015,
-0.24984046816825867,
-0.4735018312931061,
-0.409175306558609,
-0.6102012991905212,
0.6062998175621033,
0.39249187707901,
0.4428653419017792,
1.2544596195220947,
1.0146516561508179,
0.2715998589992523,
0.0006069390801712871,
0.3648515045642853,
-0.12376401573419571,
0.2738613486289978,
0.1945454478263855,
-0.2273058146238327,
-1.127573847770691,
-0.7867724895477295,
0.5753947496414185,
0.3740081191062927,
-0.8450784683227539,
0.0395987406373024,
0.275900274515152,
0.5244646072387695,
-0.42352232336997986,
0.20194604992866516,
-0.32676437497138977,
0.06566264480352402,
-0.5849547386169434,
-0.42596977949142456,
-0.14313073456287384,
-0.6017060279846191,
-0.029961735010147095,
-0.545516848564148,
0.19213950634002686,
0.22443394362926483,
1.0979105234146118,
0.009831550531089306,
-0.48965930938720703,
-0.1895098090171814,
-0.805751621723175,
0.4429562985897064,
-0.6364196538925171,
0.47605326771736145,
0.3889033794403076,
0.2972739338874817,
-0.4019957184791565,
-0.9430378079414368,
-0.6214125156402588,
-0.0522109754383564,
-0.18670161068439484,
0.20610889792442322,
0.014669863507151604,
0.39661604166030884,
0.27980518341064453,
0.5264363288879395,
-0.7273472547531128,
-0.029331421479582787,
-0.1593373417854309,
-0.12436990439891815,
0.2418837696313858,
0.4600260555744171,
0.23100361227989197,
-0.4187256097793579,
-0.3740557134151459,
-0.32098880410194397,
-0.6379422545433044,
-0.19553177058696747,
0.07095199078321457,
0.27291354537010193,
-0.23119385540485382,
0.6670059561729431,
-0.16830134391784668,
0.7774563431739807,
0.06705666333436966,
-0.2591179609298706,
0.24362711608409882,
-0.4060085415840149,
-0.29537004232406616,
0.571760356426239,
0.6979808211326599,
0.4464346766471863,
-0.22796177864074707,
0.0026722289621829987,
-0.41576650738716125,
0.15274620056152344,
0.20170123875141144,
-0.44476479291915894,
-0.6125316023826599,
0.6714308261871338,
-0.5335979461669922,
-0.28023576736450195,
0.3448033034801483,
-0.8644688129425049,
-0.32588621973991394,
-0.33727744221687317,
0.3846108317375183,
-0.1916274130344391,
0.27397415041923523,
0.24310019612312317,
0.032674696296453476,
-0.03477112948894501,
0.23763425648212433,
-0.5846524238586426,
0.8031647205352783,
1.0119459629058838,
0.7651851773262024,
-0.11151565611362457,
-0.2574828267097473,
-0.7577877044677734,
0.30952513217926025,
-0.27043914794921875,
1.1187976598739624,
-0.07395710796117783,
-0.11705007404088974,
0.1200934424996376,
0.20283102989196777,
0.004001890309154987,
-0.5910994410514832,
0.9360308647155762,
-0.21681906282901764,
0.06874903291463852,
-0.18364772200584412,
-0.7208256721496582,
0.15257219970226288,
0.6365946531295776,
-0.8300976157188416,
1.0007401704788208,
0.23289306461811066,
-0.6585975885391235,
0.498039573431015,
-0.3222188353538513,
-0.691474974155426,
-0.012419710867106915,
-0.3568071722984314,
-1.1940217018127441,
-0.37430042028427124,
-0.09671291708946228,
0.0022134629543870687,
-0.21609114110469818,
0.07172518968582153,
-0.31619104743003845,
-0.18028734624385834,
0.11486871540546417,
0.3932456076145172,
0.6321199536323547,
0.12531909346580505,
-0.17666596174240112,
0.274896502494812,
-0.8380495309829712,
0.3942298889160156,
-0.10571164637804031,
-0.746077835559845,
-0.35328736901283264,
-0.005800414830446243,
0.6230696439743042,
0.3750370740890503,
0.047512199729681015,
-0.6830025315284729,
-0.12808431684970856,
0.09985476732254028,
0.4549160301685333,
0.4280640780925751,
0.35265958309173584,
-0.06538427621126175,
-1.035342812538147,
0.20524747669696808,
0.2253064215183258,
0.24382230639457703,
-0.46982601284980774,
-0.20697662234306335,
-0.631667971611023,
-0.21354831755161285,
0.5633977055549622,
0.5909757018089294,
0.10325520485639572,
1.0266530513763428,
-0.3501422703266144,
-0.020207466557621956,
-0.45920997858047485,
0.06783366948366165,
0.5062674880027771,
0.7330031991004944,
0.4662237763404846,
-0.4285735487937927,
-1.0758662223815918,
-0.6947610378265381,
-0.11916453391313553,
-0.149353489279747,
-0.29950881004333496,
0.21709434688091278,
0.46644237637519836,
-0.33607596158981323,
0.5355513095855713,
-0.1858324259519577,
-0.8708289265632629,
-0.22985298931598663,
0.049650534987449646,
0.12142512947320938,
0.6384276747703552,
-0.18255841732025146,
-0.39798644185066223,
-0.6100203990936279,
0.41432374715805054,
-0.701769232749939,
0.015943177044391632,
-0.1592961698770523,
-0.25668469071388245,
-0.0266922265291214,
0.40501946210861206,
-0.4718722999095917,
0.33969399333000183,
0.3337722718715668,
-0.011019585654139519,
-0.05219725891947746,
-0.8820083141326904,
0.47365641593933105,
-1.0559440851211548,
0.41768360137939453,
-0.04168311879038811,
-0.5589175224304199,
-0.6856905221939087,
-0.3045327961444855,
0.3651806712150574,
0.14829498529434204,
0.012038525193929672,
0.10882362723350525,
-0.4856712222099304,
0.3008088767528534,
0.14714184403419495,
0.18120621144771576,
0.45100143551826477,
0.11048789322376251,
-0.07717552781105042,
-0.20858165621757507,
0.266750305891037,
-0.3883036971092224,
0.36860525608062744,
0.6926364898681641,
-0.33612072467803955,
1.133409023284912,
-1.1116575002670288,
0.454868882894516,
-0.08507566154003143,
0.39656180143356323,
-0.46642807126045227,
-0.540228009223938,
0.16820621490478516,
0.04187214747071266,
0.31890156865119934,
-0.14035846292972565,
-0.5846307873725891,
-0.3917901813983917,
-0.2083238661289215,
0.007227212190628052,
0.36952778697013855,
-0.2366381734609604,
0.717555820941925,
0.5203453898429871,
-0.009593263268470764,
-0.3177160918712616,
-0.6574733257293701,
0.06318794190883636,
0.051808882504701614,
-0.5110472440719604,
0.6068417429924011,
0.13953939080238342,
-0.3913724422454834,
0.1109134703874588,
-0.2957908511161804,
-0.3499106764793396,
-0.4173915386199951,
0.3818032145500183,
0.45549800992012024,
-0.2763601243495941,
-0.16107264161109924,
-0.04428531602025032,
0.022228004410862923,
-0.17501352727413177,
-0.4311859905719757,
0.09691818803548813,
-0.035830650478601456,
-0.6254727244377136,
-0.5364263653755188,
0.38928550481796265,
0.5937978625297546,
-0.1247418224811554,
0.4265984892845154,
-0.045501165091991425,
-0.7730472683906555,
-0.09532227367162704,
-0.6412562131881714,
-0.1649722009897232,
-0.3368415832519531,
0.3092345595359802,
-0.04249418154358864,
-0.43796902894973755,
0.9960394501686096,
0.22891239821910858,
0.1134568452835083,
0.15572528541088104,
0.3082723617553711,
-0.28800395131111145,
0.8568478226661682,
0.35935524106025696,
0.29470959305763245,
0.08710352331399918,
0.23209263384342194,
0.15735174715518951,
-0.9293020963668823,
-0.8290125727653503,
-0.7065639495849609,
-0.12261863052845001,
-0.5862469673156738,
-0.08523771166801453,
0.6204296946525574,
-0.36124902963638306,
-0.2869666516780853,
0.2952078580856323,
-0.264057457447052,
0.5426631569862366,
0.07596936076879501,
0.6524927020072937,
0.5688169598579407,
-0.09814635664224625,
-0.13328640162944794,
0.20458801090717316,
-0.3312598764896393,
-0.5246118307113647,
1.025229573249817,
0.14699527621269226,
0.9455109238624573,
-0.048474185168743134,
0.7420095801353455,
0.3635130524635315,
0.10557501018047333,
-0.4746592044830322,
0.06009029224514961,
-0.12479699403047562,
-0.7299215793609619,
-0.29748743772506714,
-0.5161964893341064,
-1.1176766157150269,
-0.1569410264492035,
-0.27184829115867615,
-0.2550240755081177,
0.18910107016563416,
0.639554500579834,
-0.5979251265525818,
0.4003910720348358,
0.021008381620049477,
0.938510000705719,
-0.14173941314220428,
-0.34213709831237793,
0.1654493361711502,
-0.9237675070762634,
-0.06209138408303261,
-0.13048268854618073,
-0.08260723203420639,
0.18952469527721405,
0.19577057659626007,
0.5879193544387817,
-0.8710752129554749,
0.2434203177690506,
0.39925235509872437,
0.02501814067363739,
0.2421952486038208,
0.2895392179489136,
0.8324632048606873,
-0.23802529275417328,
0.032551079988479614,
0.2830411195755005,
0.1514359563589096,
-0.320197194814682,
-0.40426260232925415,
0.5479936003684998,
-0.29672035574913025,
0.12570025026798248,
-0.4576666057109833,
-0.35737520456314087,
0.05881335586309433,
0.5167297720909119,
0.19367976486682892,
0.7618714570999146,
-0.3950325548648834,
0.2582848370075226,
0.73749178647995,
0.24397173523902893,
-0.17584119737148285,
0.6189801692962646,
0.1522645652294159,
-0.42282941937446594,
0.4466272294521332,
0.02200128510594368,
0.04459222033619881,
0.6728255748748779,
0.17398473620414734,
-0.3577195107936859,
-0.3128042221069336,
-0.4419991075992584,
0.05422673746943474,
-0.6175597310066223,
-0.2372898906469345,
-0.7003523111343384,
-0.05078607052564621,
-0.07757887244224548,
0.044266894459724426,
-0.2812097668647766,
-0.15452280640602112,
0.18617206811904907,
-0.10687694698572159,
0.39378485083580017,
0.9678758382797241,
-0.08178651332855225,
0.1126922145485878,
-1.0278198719024658,
0.24574808776378632,
0.08690156042575836,
0.6981384754180908,
-0.2648140788078308,
-0.48721879720687866,
-0.21593014895915985,
-0.07592690736055374,
-0.2891746461391449,
-0.8060254454612732,
-0.030090179294347763,
0.2910822033882141,
0.5116112232208252,
0.576600968837738,
0.011938098818063736,
0.5276508927345276,
-0.8745791912078857,
0.19170665740966797,
0.031458478420972824,
-0.8087076544761658,
0.5844793915748596,
-0.7010007500648499,
-0.045796409249305725,
0.8476197123527527,
-0.05460286885499954,
-0.9562992453575134,
-0.2277977019548416,
-0.6064708232879639,
-0.7198066115379333,
0.4784654676914215,
0.037190262228250504,
-0.5214577317237854,
-0.011072767898440361,
0.3111947774887085,
-0.16974548995494843,
0.13883358240127563,
-0.2999364137649536,
-0.34423545002937317,
-0.2078409194946289,
-0.5762665271759033,
0.161036878824234,
-0.045945458114147186,
-0.5690205693244934,
0.17068855464458466,
0.141588494181633,
0.19197873771190643,
0.0798419862985611,
0.5273036360740662,
0.018866950646042824,
-0.6205960512161255,
0.47366246581077576,
0.5685564279556274,
0.6651106476783752,
-0.5809530019760132,
0.5602059364318848,
0.05572865530848503,
-0.8003814220428467,
0.08866643160581589,
0.09494831413030624,
-0.16777588427066803,
0.06117105856537819,
0.17331059277057648,
0.4721018671989441,
0.4454164206981659,
-0.5634568929672241,
0.33938413858413696,
0.013352516107261181,
-0.11454039067029953,
-0.3360294997692108,
-0.1529366672039032,
-0.31857743859291077,
-0.2482951581478119,
-0.21728666126728058,
0.09276209026575089,
0.16818352043628693,
-0.456607460975647,
0.7252071499824524,
-0.14042235910892487,
-0.6206607222557068,
-0.35329392552375793,
0.7898001074790955,
-0.30122390389442444,
-0.3874399662017822,
0.6964016556739807,
0.05791323632001877,
-0.32912856340408325,
0.6618508100509644,
0.5214641094207764,
0.6327183246612549,
-0.42857223749160767,
0.008288886398077011,
0.38705578446388245,
0.34458157420158386,
-0.6197378635406494,
0.7218864560127258,
0.24476757645606995,
-0.3770648241043091,
-0.05381730943918228,
-0.07452615350484848,
-0.7038454413414001,
0.05060821771621704,
-1.053863286972046,
0.43521547317504883,
-0.503158450126648,
-0.2528018653392792,
-0.08599484711885452,
-0.3808553218841553,
-0.48748427629470825,
0.0031839986331760883,
-0.28032559156417847,
0.40927186608314514,
-0.752953290939331,
0.6414260864257812,
0.7824546098709106,
-0.303305447101593,
-0.903359591960907,
-0.15461915731430054,
0.5069493055343628,
-0.22532546520233154,
0.19254359602928162,
-0.30208903551101685,
0.1736978143453598,
-0.3551836907863617,
-0.02137664519250393,
-0.3680229187011719,
0.8774518370628357,
-0.019405169412493706,
-0.851538896560669,
0.21900242567062378,
0.3457714021205902,
0.6938097476959229,
-0.1451357752084732,
0.07711010426282883,
0.5400258302688599,
0.5513676404953003,
-0.1523352861404419,
-1.047524333000183,
0.17898371815681458,
-0.1997421830892563,
-0.2833065688610077,
0.538959801197052,
-0.27006956934928894,
1.0082496404647827,
-0.2758152484893799,
-0.0004110442823730409,
0.00863872841000557,
0.3248237073421478,
0.4502224624156952,
0.5752335786819458,
0.30234619975090027,
0.6906023621559143,
1.1408246755599976,
-0.2578699290752411,
1.0327438116073608,
-0.22987177968025208,
0.30965980887413025,
1.3838375806808472,
-0.9300601482391357,
0.8237258791923523,
0.29715099930763245,
-0.16131499409675598,
0.8586463928222656,
0.39784514904022217,
-0.2917402684688568,
0.29831889271736145,
0.14567379653453827,
-0.2444334477186203,
-0.13970160484313965,
-0.09012208878993988,
-0.2628934383392334,
0.26955386996269226,
0.07602479308843613,
-0.2857801020145416,
-0.20893308520317078,
-0.42169174551963806,
0.19014301896095276,
0.1981278359889984,
0.08305460214614868,
0.7485379576683044,
0.023197634145617485,
-0.46404707431793213,
0.07527989149093628,
-0.040272459387779236,
0.03116558864712715,
-0.6473627090454102,
-0.3455066680908203,
-0.06643682718276978,
0.6460947394371033,
-0.45519667863845825,
-0.5862255096435547,
0.13968443870544434,
-0.09688927978277206,
-0.2101326286792755,
0.10096876323223114,
0.5840610861778259,
-0.7029945254325867,
-0.17299415171146393,
0.06862612068653107,
0.3061801493167877,
0.025112219154834747,
0.2560543119907379,
-0.5162997245788574,
0.09937629103660583,
-0.34765297174453735,
0.2972885072231293,
0.16006696224212646,
0.7258000373840332,
-0.03506403788924217,
0.27603480219841003,
0.5520147681236267,
0.39639145135879517,
-0.2240283042192459,
0.388860821723938,
0.5396921038627625,
-0.3258027136325836,
-0.7178645133972168,
-0.6906066536903381,
0.49741506576538086,
-0.1958492249250412,
-0.47681593894958496,
0.7601245045661926,
0.9267685413360596,
0.5673455595970154,
0.045973386615514755,
0.4000220000743866,
0.08209546655416489,
0.9068475961685181,
-0.38277530670166016,
0.8480282425880432,
-0.20366978645324707,
0.17586269974708557,
-0.39849600195884705,
-0.737623929977417,
-0.614160418510437,
0.7043153643608093,
0.11490098387002945,
0.07452340424060822,
1.0321182012557983,
0.8157448768615723,
-0.13015539944171906,
-0.05580092966556549,
0.05455349385738373,
0.17185327410697937,
0.1987803876399994,
0.5312305688858032,
0.6080018281936646,
-0.7043693661689758,
0.5365539789199829,
-0.35956910252571106,
-0.08649605512619019,
-0.2127663791179657,
-0.9883913397789001,
-0.68570476770401,
-0.31418415904045105,
-0.5727320909500122,
-0.8591273427009583,
0.22209379076957703,
1.002590537071228,
0.7159149050712585,
-1.1798750162124634,
-0.26370522379875183,
-0.09409979730844498,
0.09243247658014297,
-0.4547731876373291,
-0.10664036124944687,
0.7484807968139648,
0.18605585396289825,
-0.1430291384458542,
-0.02146855928003788,
0.5414025783538818,
0.1059480756521225,
0.2445010542869568,
-0.02681710198521614,
0.18531572818756104,
-0.039242684841156006,
0.09050531685352325,
0.5528436303138733,
-0.3127332329750061,
-0.05389128252863884,
0.3481810986995697,
-0.5566631555557251,
0.4638265371322632,
1.1337593793869019,
-0.11630137264728546,
0.5063560605049133,
0.5551579594612122,
0.21309296786785126,
0.22420337796211243,
0.0787617638707161,
0.11587177217006683,
-0.5005706548690796,
-0.32612308859825134,
0.2881372272968292,
0.6601582765579224,
0.49897751212120056,
-0.48117542266845703,
0.13880841434001923,
-0.2617318034172058,
-0.8886393308639526,
-0.9296165108680725,
-0.11713144928216934,
-1.2013579607009888,
0.49668529629707336,
0.8232946395874023,
-0.1601397544145584,
-0.2620965242385864,
-0.778588056564331,
-0.03503572568297386,
0.28458333015441895,
-0.2317255735397339,
1.098097562789917,
0.2422371208667755,
-0.18206427991390228,
0.12324821203947067,
-0.5103039145469666,
0.6171675324440002,
0.18400683999061584,
-1.1875357627868652,
0.10589946061372757,
0.449956476688385,
0.3218783438205719,
0.05708732828497887,
0.650073230266571,
-0.6214697957038879,
0.4072239398956299,
-0.07449762523174286,
0.35113078355789185,
-0.04139036685228348,
-0.33214834332466125,
-0.4666751027107239,
-0.18746963143348694,
-0.31086209416389465,
-0.19605280458927155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16332v1 | DemoRank: Selecting Effective Demonstrations for Large Language Models in Ranking Task | 2024-06-24T06:10:13 | 2024-06-24T06:10:13 | Wenhan Liu, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recently, there has been increasing interest in applying large language
models (LLMs) as zero-shot passage rankers. However, few studies have explored
how to select appropriate in-context demonstrations for the passage ranking
task, which is the focus of this paper. Previous studies mainly apply a
demonstration retriever to retrieve demonstrations and use top-$k$
demonstrations for in-context learning (ICL). Although effective, this approach
overlooks the dependencies between demonstrations, leading to inferior
performance of few-shot ICL in the passage ranking task. In this paper, we
formulate the demonstration selection as a \textit{retrieve-then-rerank}
process and introduce the DemoRank framework. In this framework, we first use
LLM feedback to train a demonstration retriever and construct a novel
dependency-aware training samples to train a demonstration reranker to improve
few-shot ICL. The construction of such training samples not only considers
demonstration dependencies but also performs in an efficient way. Extensive
experiments demonstrate DemoRank's effectiveness in in-domain scenarios and
strong generalization to out-of-domain scenarios. Our codes are available
at~\url{https://github.com/8421BCD/DemoRank}. | [
-0.19538702070713043,
-0.5248979926109314,
0.601109504699707,
0.27253714203834534,
-0.2463047206401825,
-0.010461398400366306,
-0.18950960040092468,
-0.12282826751470566,
0.053054798394441605,
0.24156256020069122,
-0.2035917341709137,
-0.7644818425178528,
-0.7260624766349792,
-0.028651375323534012,
-0.488552987575531,
1.0838332176208496,
0.19771024584770203,
0.05457198619842529,
-0.5844348073005676,
-0.09168346226215363,
0.025131147354841232,
-0.5477041602134705,
-0.4355308413505554,
-0.5642698407173157,
0.4825625717639923,
0.6961863040924072,
0.31955084204673767,
0.3476296663284302,
0.2668737471103668,
0.28149765729904175,
-0.21326662600040436,
-0.2324647605419159,
-0.8355087041854858,
0.3450374901294708,
-0.15123485028743744,
-0.6196292638778687,
-0.07299263030290604,
0.12419500201940536,
0.9223278164863586,
0.7434186339378357,
0.01500425674021244,
0.07740912586450577,
0.1218690499663353,
0.34856241941452026,
-0.8475366830825806,
0.23674830794334412,
-0.7023845911026001,
-0.1388842761516571,
-0.2950589954853058,
-0.04574764892458916,
-0.9146292209625244,
-0.43951112031936646,
0.05494530871510506,
-0.45466798543930054,
0.13540911674499512,
-0.031873103231191635,
0.6401693224906921,
-0.0052347066812217236,
-0.6305091381072998,
0.2029341161251068,
-0.44223758578300476,
1.0240378379821777,
-0.7035045027732849,
0.395617812871933,
0.30629459023475647,
0.561055064201355,
-0.16665971279144287,
-0.9492639303207397,
-0.23637305200099945,
-0.6499614119529724,
0.1100827157497406,
0.16279858350753784,
-0.02959253080189228,
-0.004344926215708256,
0.26804372668266296,
0.3070391118526459,
-0.36641988158226013,
0.32271113991737366,
-0.07216616719961166,
-0.20976674556732178,
0.40181252360343933,
-0.00346315186470747,
0.03651166334748268,
0.03402814641594887,
-0.3408817648887634,
-0.30814895033836365,
-1.1324036121368408,
0.17981071770191193,
0.23542669415473938,
0.36958828568458557,
0.0966220572590828,
0.560635507106781,
-0.6416527628898621,
0.7452487349510193,
0.2626815736293793,
-0.1865469068288803,
0.38983389735221863,
-0.08733362704515457,
-0.1447274535894394,
-0.17212994396686554,
0.48253628611564636,
0.12899839878082275,
0.018091442063450813,
-0.3136908710002899,
-0.2727591395378113,
-0.17951606214046478,
0.11998437345027924,
-1.2207670211791992,
-0.4093365967273712,
-0.028169965371489525,
-0.5164041519165039,
-0.4243444502353668,
0.11352187395095825,
-0.5793800950050354,
-0.18577145040035248,
-0.0813446044921875,
0.9010636806488037,
-0.2611512541770935,
-0.27630290389060974,
-0.15049797296524048,
-0.18587759137153625,
0.15351150929927826,
0.4160633683204651,
-0.7636472582817078,
0.29002463817596436,
0.755340039730072,
0.8540997505187988,
-0.41476669907569885,
-0.5724242329597473,
-0.9596743583679199,
0.1295328438282013,
-0.3685879409313202,
0.8248841762542725,
-0.5112079977989197,
-0.4355566203594208,
0.20894701778888702,
-0.09928853064775467,
-0.2769681215286255,
-0.9342798590660095,
0.329929918050766,
-0.6095351576805115,
0.07795514166355133,
-0.0451115220785141,
-0.9781862497329712,
-0.09632053971290588,
0.2903705835342407,
-0.49109652638435364,
0.8011854290962219,
0.04858393222093582,
-0.4636760652065277,
0.3323904871940613,
-0.5031102895736694,
-0.4880395233631134,
0.08431262522935867,
-0.3072018027305603,
-0.4267244040966034,
-0.042029157280921936,
0.11339665204286575,
0.5676158666610718,
0.2566649913787842,
-0.07605528086423874,
-0.48082661628723145,
-0.7412948608398438,
0.16963835060596466,
-0.33477649092674255,
0.6037405133247375,
-0.11392787843942642,
-0.6054311394691467,
0.1596338301897049,
-0.5640193819999695,
0.10649716854095459,
-0.016272783279418945,
-0.42520201206207275,
-0.3581409752368927,
0.025963766500353813,
-0.07519610971212387,
0.13388098776340485,
0.031698014587163925,
-0.6241531372070312,
0.4322477877140045,
-0.5170180201530457,
0.07889699935913086,
0.7854835987091064,
0.3392370343208313,
0.6104106903076172,
-0.2835947573184967,
0.6523131728172302,
-0.06355996429920197,
0.2285647988319397,
-0.05522453784942627,
-0.3310167193412781,
-0.7129135131835938,
-0.3284470736980438,
0.4565981924533844,
0.16072894632816315,
-0.7795654535293579,
0.07161044329404831,
-0.4504249095916748,
-0.5478996634483337,
-0.27604809403419495,
0.21273256838321686,
0.48932313919067383,
0.3223872184753418,
0.1203945204615593,
0.09315621107816696,
-0.11597955226898193,
-0.9091223478317261,
0.03899115324020386,
-0.42308029532432556,
-0.018156997859477997,
0.05190933123230934,
0.506896436214447,
0.20214448869228363,
0.8527501225471497,
-0.5877109169960022,
-0.5159205794334412,
-0.6721975803375244,
0.07244749367237091,
0.2935219407081604,
0.1825551688671112,
0.6314966082572937,
-0.8244951963424683,
-0.4613681137561798,
-0.3806729018688202,
-0.521844744682312,
-0.07675935328006744,
0.1041770651936531,
-0.2380763292312622,
-0.016980886459350586,
0.7259781956672668,
-0.22617317736148834,
0.2944304645061493,
0.6228189468383789,
-0.049727097153663635,
0.5113058090209961,
0.021683791652321815,
0.18780376017093658,
-0.8832933306694031,
-0.15856540203094482,
-0.0029312006663531065,
-0.48715582489967346,
-0.3963371217250824,
0.3110277056694031,
0.0648341104388237,
-0.08112125098705292,
-0.7698901295661926,
0.4151122570037842,
-0.333070307970047,
0.08143600821495056,
-0.3497277498245239,
0.10800270736217499,
-0.23490282893180847,
0.5620226263999939,
0.11958548426628113,
0.873170793056488,
0.5748216509819031,
-0.6579018831253052,
-0.1772802770137787,
0.16142933070659637,
-0.5238441824913025,
0.48379167914390564,
-0.5777813792228699,
-0.06756420433521271,
0.28426340222358704,
0.36507144570350647,
-1.2087534666061401,
0.001175610814243555,
-0.028869876638054848,
-0.2868022918701172,
0.28961339592933655,
-0.6058444380760193,
-0.573212206363678,
0.15720947086811066,
-0.4765399098396301,
0.28801843523979187,
0.5209618806838989,
-0.7416766881942749,
0.17742931842803955,
0.35353216528892517,
-0.17392598092556,
-0.5260833501815796,
-0.251276433467865,
-0.09848664700984955,
-0.034570470452308655,
-0.287381649017334,
0.5279432535171509,
-0.19490349292755127,
-0.12576639652252197,
-0.35841208696365356,
0.012262653559446335,
0.20902110636234283,
0.10006401687860489,
0.5801122188568115,
-0.006005850154906511,
-0.0924336239695549,
0.1750936657190323,
0.041519466787576675,
-0.213511660695076,
-0.007312724366784096,
0.03031633235514164,
0.46711310744285583,
-0.0737658143043518,
-0.8756862282752991,
-0.372660368680954,
0.3437909483909607,
0.653775691986084,
-0.0005783929373137653,
0.5358638167381287,
0.12415307760238647,
-0.09858478605747223,
-0.4870191514492035,
-0.40272364020347595,
-0.342502236366272,
-0.4632609188556671,
0.5399718880653381,
-0.34485867619514465,
-0.9154936075210571,
0.12822206318378448,
-0.4866068959236145,
0.29847487807273865,
0.14093875885009766,
0.557502806186676,
-0.08098562061786652,
1.1748089790344238,
0.7379799485206604,
-0.41547685861587524,
0.8483893275260925,
-0.6326934695243835,
0.0055254315957427025,
-0.816667914390564,
-0.07168307155370712,
-0.4385831952095032,
-0.42979100346565247,
-0.40970662236213684,
-0.26511120796203613,
0.6376991271972656,
0.2211223989725113,
-0.14958766102790833,
0.11784962564706802,
-0.004137534648180008,
0.510875403881073,
0.7108303308486938,
0.16053186357021332,
0.3999272584915161,
0.10365930199623108,
-0.47181954979896545,
-0.20627361536026,
-0.532561719417572,
-0.4714164435863495,
0.9758796095848083,
0.08755557984113693,
0.8259159326553345,
0.3577943444252014,
1.0989073514938354,
0.4000687897205353,
0.5566176176071167,
-0.916022777557373,
0.8333736062049866,
-0.26849982142448425,
-0.39445844292640686,
-0.45820796489715576,
-0.24898993968963623,
-1.0541572570800781,
0.6049119234085083,
0.031294967979192734,
-0.826079785823822,
0.07380559295415878,
0.18226857483386993,
-0.0874592512845993,
0.1286851167678833,
-0.5259760618209839,
0.878424346446991,
0.09615882486104965,
-0.266616553068161,
-0.3174663484096527,
-0.5014708042144775,
0.18218305706977844,
0.3015059232711792,
-0.1445240080356598,
0.2936248779296875,
0.1592995673418045,
0.6425092816352844,
-0.40165504813194275,
0.917346715927124,
-0.4227333068847656,
-0.13044236600399017,
-0.062374819070100784,
0.19388236105442047,
0.6109429597854614,
0.00869913212954998,
-0.3197067081928253,
-0.14921139180660248,
-0.3026781380176544,
-0.16680949926376343,
-0.8550524711608887,
0.7893831133842468,
-0.6440854072570801,
-0.6858882308006287,
-0.14301683008670807,
-0.07985001057386398,
-0.3745591342449188,
0.09403018653392792,
0.4725413918495178,
0.6552221775054932,
-0.21794851124286652,
0.6038786768913269,
0.7254279255867004,
-0.012743296101689339,
0.48441070318222046,
0.5869835615158081,
-0.4764135777950287,
-0.3558599054813385,
1.1731950044631958,
0.263060063123703,
0.6192766427993774,
0.6599844098091125,
0.03346271440386772,
-0.5159944891929626,
-0.8317328095436096,
-0.3957822918891907,
0.16880306601524353,
-0.8951573371887207,
-0.16193461418151855,
-0.5681627988815308,
-0.4013849198818207,
-0.39296862483024597,
-0.003470267867669463,
-0.3284813165664673,
-0.5294914245605469,
-0.05079909414052963,
-0.2880426347255707,
0.06180658936500549,
0.581241250038147,
0.026916230097413063,
0.24518725275993347,
-0.23411399126052856,
0.3056063950061798,
0.4623907506465912,
0.2571873664855957,
0.2573421597480774,
-0.6610550880432129,
-0.33501484990119934,
-0.21563176810741425,
-0.5404142737388611,
-0.7600537538528442,
0.11383254081010818,
0.20639008283615112,
1.0546208620071411,
0.5937255620956421,
0.24028335511684418,
0.518744945526123,
-0.44735386967658997,
0.9002068638801575,
0.001168483286164701,
-0.7282045483589172,
0.6590330004692078,
-0.1375911831855774,
0.1472458839416504,
0.7246812582015991,
0.20756110548973083,
-0.3146801292896271,
-0.9045290946960449,
-0.5758748650550842,
-1.0332237482070923,
0.6081979870796204,
0.24556715786457062,
0.0029815237503498793,
0.02053612843155861,
0.02388979308307171,
0.1380288302898407,
0.1724269688129425,
-0.845454216003418,
-0.525050699710846,
0.07098111510276794,
-0.03524124622344971,
-0.2184944897890091,
-0.2759115695953369,
-0.0692405253648758,
-0.20300118625164032,
0.9140186905860901,
-0.11133523285388947,
0.04969371110200882,
-0.10297508537769318,
-0.5470709204673767,
0.11841307580471039,
0.4005368649959564,
0.5058390498161316,
0.6827499866485596,
-0.2902525067329407,
0.1462080180644989,
0.051703374832868576,
-0.3618638217449188,
0.5887404680252075,
0.052306655794382095,
-0.5730952620506287,
0.23777556419372559,
0.4199909567832947,
0.5271053910255432,
0.5687330365180969,
-0.5364239811897278,
1.0715360641479492,
0.18478526175022125,
-0.12624527513980865,
-0.3249143660068512,
0.17060889303684235,
0.031204557046294212,
0.3911275267601013,
0.49070554971694946,
-0.3401156961917877,
0.3917846381664276,
-0.36092233657836914,
0.49771833419799805,
0.4962140619754791,
-0.40571877360343933,
-0.03605186566710472,
0.5112572312355042,
0.2563788592815399,
-0.33936744928359985,
0.5999534726142883,
-0.3712015450000763,
-0.4814470708370209,
0.5249947905540466,
0.7297134399414062,
0.7054176330566406,
0.08420878648757935,
0.6172561049461365,
0.18094883859157562,
-0.09770317375659943,
-0.2807847857475281,
0.01694154553115368,
-0.186219722032547,
-0.5036506056785583,
-0.5378898978233337,
-0.28164422512054443,
-0.7753655314445496,
0.17256313562393188,
-0.8359626531600952,
0.350466251373291,
-0.1423254907131195,
-0.1272117793560028,
-0.10362017899751663,
0.10268272459506989,
-0.3605913519859314,
-0.041136693209409714,
0.14871418476104736,
0.9131426215171814,
-0.9295875430107117,
0.8498356342315674,
0.7918459177017212,
-0.4421398639678955,
-0.5857436656951904,
0.4123140871524811,
-0.0095941461622715,
-0.5401360392570496,
0.932003378868103,
0.2214527726173401,
-0.2701667845249176,
0.27790945768356323,
-0.6742234826087952,
-0.682279646396637,
1.0496585369110107,
0.5964298248291016,
-0.3082898259162903,
0.3999086618423462,
-0.1908033788204193,
0.4724249541759491,
-0.3729592263698578,
0.5832720994949341,
-0.08741298317909241,
0.14412397146224976,
0.0677100419998169,
-0.6432331800460815,
-0.0875837430357933,
-0.12618008255958557,
0.00747070973739028,
0.1675710678100586,
-0.892023503780365,
0.5323876738548279,
-0.36642467975616455,
-0.0708831176161766,
0.3715575039386749,
0.7290775179862976,
0.8202307224273682,
0.4164404273033142,
0.8718019723892212,
0.47613704204559326,
0.3331228494644165,
0.08050230145454407,
1.100706934928894,
0.1802011877298355,
0.3132845163345337,
1.3191773891448975,
-0.43770256638526917,
1.454330563545227,
0.5508447885513306,
-0.22848819196224213,
0.8877565860748291,
0.5814979672431946,
0.11453922837972641,
1.0004791021347046,
0.3904212713241577,
-0.32683736085891724,
-0.6366552114486694,
-0.20927181839942932,
-0.3374781310558319,
0.4248965084552765,
-0.10300824791193008,
-0.4528372883796692,
-0.5667949318885803,
0.09881041944026947,
-0.22161203622817993,
0.03224242478609085,
-0.05038240924477577,
0.8679031729698181,
0.10618352144956589,
-0.5488172769546509,
0.4518599808216095,
-0.15297222137451172,
0.5947118401527405,
-0.6536591649055481,
-0.5025959610939026,
-0.35479533672332764,
0.2853836417198181,
0.09355317056179047,
-0.6698237657546997,
-0.483699232339859,
-0.11299522966146469,
-0.3787573575973511,
-0.4251280725002289,
0.3042196035385132,
-0.31870073080062866,
-0.48892009258270264,
0.35800033807754517,
0.5525435209274292,
0.3708021342754364,
-0.22469021379947662,
-0.30933520197868347,
-0.20495855808258057,
-0.04826071113348007,
-0.3738448917865753,
0.9057216644287109,
0.2954356372356415,
-0.21822792291641235,
0.8202861547470093,
0.5992297530174255,
0.12236513942480087,
-0.15933112800121307,
0.7250362634658813,
0.9055718779563904,
-0.44184404611587524,
-0.5640108585357666,
-0.9204714894294739,
0.2669002115726471,
-0.2716433107852936,
-0.16803108155727386,
0.7404662370681763,
0.8067482709884644,
0.9249007105827332,
-0.09215822070837021,
0.7259718775749207,
0.1848296821117401,
0.6906854510307312,
-0.4984564483165741,
0.7402330636978149,
-0.6228322386741638,
0.24253225326538086,
-0.2986554503440857,
-0.814619243144989,
-0.2055346816778183,
0.5444642901420593,
-0.18436899781227112,
-0.012661358341574669,
0.5871189832687378,
0.9299314022064209,
-0.153274804353714,
-0.4037734568119049,
0.6157872676849365,
0.16208888590335846,
0.45323070883750916,
0.6757223010063171,
1.1751317977905273,
-0.25467565655708313,
0.9184085130691528,
-0.4216093420982361,
-0.14890015125274658,
-0.45897385478019714,
-0.9620859026908875,
-0.7846241593360901,
-0.4670984447002411,
-0.5625223517417908,
-0.17788566648960114,
-0.060150422155857086,
0.8689899444580078,
0.9547984004020691,
-0.7797124981880188,
-0.3824955224990845,
0.2849687337875366,
0.41402268409729004,
-0.5819458365440369,
-0.29242730140686035,
0.36998340487480164,
-0.3755301833152771,
-0.9237655997276306,
0.5688638091087341,
0.20566752552986145,
-0.05564124882221222,
-0.20398831367492676,
-0.11099592596292496,
-0.12599626183509827,
-0.5000788569450378,
0.7402871251106262,
0.0669821947813034,
-0.7639935612678528,
-0.2230701595544815,
-0.04171689227223396,
-0.05555706471204758,
-0.00184984493535012,
0.835737407207489,
-0.9874843955039978,
0.24297693371772766,
0.46744289994239807,
0.5452082753181458,
0.5633987188339233,
0.15494604408740997,
0.5101024508476257,
-0.8583307862281799,
-0.1913069635629654,
0.1572861224412918,
0.3801012337207794,
0.23326344788074493,
-0.10230890661478043,
0.4727230966091156,
0.22343139350414276,
-0.5571704506874084,
-0.8358772397041321,
0.1704743653535843,
-1.0239206552505493,
-0.1569119542837143,
1.4982777833938599,
-0.3931337594985962,
0.15326571464538574,
-0.024753388017416,
-0.1870381087064743,
0.03550722450017929,
-0.5618147850036621,
0.9251940250396729,
0.5296069383621216,
-0.14823713898658752,
-0.24227075278759003,
-0.42972537875175476,
0.16247807443141937,
0.36292406916618347,
-0.6864890456199646,
-0.05394291505217552,
0.40269899368286133,
0.5946701765060425,
-0.036452338099479675,
0.6612191796302795,
-0.11330568790435791,
0.10918339341878891,
-0.35057610273361206,
-0.22765907645225525,
-0.08146141469478607,
-0.26654279232025146,
-0.4098820984363556,
0.5215124487876892,
0.47417306900024414,
-0.5569453239440918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16330v1 | Pruning via Merging: Compressing LLMs via Manifold Alignment Based Layer Merging | 2024-06-24T05:57:55 | 2024-06-24T05:57:55 | Deyuan Liu, Zhanyue Qin, Hairu Wang, Zhao Yang, Zecheng Wang, Fangying Rong, Qingbin Liu, Yanchao Hao, Xi Chen, Cunhang Fan, Zhao Lv, Zhiying Tu, Dianhui Chu, Bo Li, Dianbo Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) excel in many domains, their complexity
and scale challenge deployment in resource-limited environments. Current
compression techniques, such as parameter pruning, often fail to effectively
utilize the knowledge from pruned parameters. To address these challenges, we
propose Manifold-Based Knowledge Alignment and Layer Merging Compression (MKA),
a novel approach that uses manifold learning and the Normalized Pairwise
Information Bottleneck (NPIB) measure to merge similar layers, reducing model
size while preserving essential performance. We evaluate MKA on multiple
benchmark datasets and various LLMs. Our findings show that MKA not only
preserves model performance but also achieves substantial compression ratios,
outperforming traditional pruning methods. Moreover, when coupled with
quantization, MKA delivers even greater compression. Specifically, on the MMLU
dataset using the Llama3-8B model, MKA achieves a compression ratio of 43.75%
with a minimal performance decrease of only 2.82\%. The proposed MKA method
offers a resource-efficient and performance-preserving model compression
technique for LLMs. | [
-0.4355297386646271,
-0.45981669425964355,
0.46510809659957886,
-0.08363386988639832,
-0.5420277714729309,
0.168671652674675,
-0.19099563360214233,
-0.13890981674194336,
0.08530107885599136,
0.5039882659912109,
-0.47132569551467896,
-0.47442251443862915,
-0.504710853099823,
-0.3121652603149414,
-0.14720378816127777,
0.593798041343689,
0.03793765604496002,
0.005097212735563517,
-0.544589638710022,
-0.1493232697248459,
-0.6630621552467346,
-0.5359750986099243,
-0.5587910413742065,
-0.006626099348068237,
0.5903336405754089,
0.32399746775627136,
0.454522967338562,
0.8381018042564392,
0.5716662406921387,
0.3269776403903961,
-0.16744497418403625,
0.7567530274391174,
-0.5432903170585632,
0.12329483777284622,
0.1500587910413742,
-0.4132363498210907,
-0.48974382877349854,
0.09655679762363434,
0.9250970482826233,
0.7654257416725159,
-0.3959251046180725,
0.3876848816871643,
0.12213117629289627,
0.8436230421066284,
-0.6262974143028259,
0.09725066274404526,
-0.5211887955665588,
-0.07440932840108871,
0.052583929151296616,
-0.3343440592288971,
-0.22505295276641846,
-0.49887850880622864,
-0.2449798583984375,
-0.35448157787323,
-0.12501375377178192,
0.1967470794916153,
0.8792747855186462,
0.6042153835296631,
-0.5678545236587524,
0.27163487672805786,
-0.7698068022727966,
1.0482091903686523,
-0.8780004978179932,
0.5350304245948792,
0.06790555268526077,
0.38172683119773865,
-0.05673465505242348,
-0.2092503309249878,
-0.5951362252235413,
0.20946167409420013,
0.07912290841341019,
-0.093116894364357,
-0.16319814324378967,
-0.10668099671602249,
0.07683874666690826,
0.2922115623950958,
-0.5658519864082336,
0.29139137268066406,
-0.7246999144554138,
-0.3048352003097534,
0.3567497432231903,
-0.04887155070900917,
0.25630491971969604,
-0.17530015110969543,
-0.5394251346588135,
-0.35630401968955994,
-1.0794421434402466,
-0.09123537689447403,
0.6429055333137512,
0.27185186743736267,
0.13323909044265747,
0.6213326454162598,
0.06295383721590042,
1.124433159828186,
-0.3860945403575897,
-0.5567119717597961,
-0.021260416135191917,
-0.09445920586585999,
-0.571902871131897,
-0.11593101918697357,
0.703541100025177,
0.6096916198730469,
-0.06838024407625198,
-0.3651895523071289,
-0.015564396046102047,
0.16064661741256714,
0.21868985891342163,
-0.7487429976463318,
-0.11778471618890762,
0.2859225571155548,
-0.4404592514038086,
-0.365261971950531,
0.008649438619613647,
-0.7330548763275146,
-0.2847823202610016,
-0.7649928331375122,
0.17160667479038239,
-0.4077008068561554,
-0.2854252755641937,
0.04507662355899811,
0.10732501745223999,
0.25283756852149963,
0.2774468958377838,
-0.47270292043685913,
0.21278074383735657,
1.0089093446731567,
0.88109290599823,
-0.09238259494304657,
-0.14630092680454254,
-0.5199209451675415,
0.4054674506187439,
-0.16878552734851837,
0.612907886505127,
-0.27465954422950745,
-0.1732035130262375,
-0.28747132420539856,
-0.2290845811367035,
0.05828406289219856,
-0.7774764895439148,
0.5913010239601135,
-0.5317877531051636,
0.1175636500120163,
-0.17171575129032135,
-0.6540201306343079,
-0.3823670744895935,
0.35565808415412903,
-0.6580274105072021,
0.7006470561027527,
0.2542186677455902,
-0.6486385464668274,
0.2893584072589874,
0.00484594888985157,
-0.13367745280265808,
-0.14916132390499115,
-0.17373019456863403,
-0.6187449097633362,
0.19650079309940338,
0.4490969181060791,
0.6295325756072998,
-0.6736648082733154,
0.41788992285728455,
-0.31822699308395386,
-0.16333872079849243,
0.04036002233624458,
-0.11617335677146912,
0.7405611276626587,
0.3902439475059509,
0.2562924921512604,
0.06334205716848373,
-0.6146183013916016,
0.07647456228733063,
-0.048913586884737015,
-0.45849016308784485,
-0.2236434817314148,
-0.2987278401851654,
-0.3264577388763428,
0.3275662660598755,
0.36000728607177734,
-0.33791103959083557,
0.6177336573600769,
-0.11332614719867706,
0.48069480061531067,
0.7311245203018188,
-0.07308349013328552,
0.6090460419654846,
-0.659596860408783,
0.5033807158470154,
0.23069971799850464,
0.08168431371450424,
0.41804271936416626,
-0.4028291404247284,
-0.8009316921234131,
-0.43450868129730225,
0.6572027802467346,
0.5355018377304077,
-0.6162001490592957,
0.5640774965286255,
-0.7436231374740601,
-0.6725038886070251,
-0.8126030564308167,
0.3227386176586151,
0.3051633834838867,
0.6700562834739685,
0.33184200525283813,
-0.44290608167648315,
-0.5729206800460815,
-0.9505911469459534,
-0.08109219372272491,
-0.25140243768692017,
-0.15081796050071716,
0.5485553741455078,
-0.18926306068897247,
0.07400123029947281,
0.794282853603363,
-0.3337675929069519,
-0.3595517873764038,
-0.20765817165374756,
0.2698970437049866,
0.21784107387065887,
0.9064784049987793,
0.35430917143821716,
-0.6426538228988647,
-0.23399664461612701,
0.15554089844226837,
-0.6132138967514038,
-0.1460888534784317,
0.1385984867811203,
-0.1581975817680359,
0.01159332599490881,
0.4196620285511017,
-0.7558661103248596,
0.1426444947719574,
0.8923335075378418,
0.07803606986999512,
0.34554314613342285,
-0.04969201982021332,
0.24164623022079468,
-1.3219883441925049,
-0.14894650876522064,
-0.10812230408191681,
-0.36659830808639526,
-0.5201379060745239,
0.17929892241954803,
0.17711569368839264,
-0.3002189099788666,
-0.5161004662513733,
0.33734390139579773,
-0.8077448606491089,
-0.2350204735994339,
-0.14378836750984192,
-0.03706721216440201,
-0.103509321808815,
0.5855827927589417,
-0.23624932765960693,
0.6405645608901978,
0.44548824429512024,
-0.744820773601532,
0.2890346646308899,
0.04081688076257706,
-0.3516504168510437,
0.38877010345458984,
-0.16210035979747772,
0.34232571721076965,
-0.13162951171398163,
0.32740142941474915,
-0.49372759461402893,
-0.01789611205458641,
0.12983322143554688,
-0.13749650120735168,
0.6360960602760315,
-0.5255385041236877,
-0.6601276993751526,
-0.05265798792243004,
-0.33473294973373413,
0.7742943167686462,
0.7906329035758972,
-0.47659388184547424,
0.7432271838188171,
0.44313350319862366,
-0.10697172582149506,
-0.5405728816986084,
-0.6127026081085205,
0.15110571682453156,
-0.6304372549057007,
-0.7006887793540955,
0.5141167044639587,
-0.13383713364601135,
0.11831352859735489,
0.07137235254049301,
-0.22070544958114624,
-0.03920568898320198,
-0.04795711487531662,
0.10332097858190536,
0.46020832657814026,
-0.15138712525367737,
-0.07902632653713226,
0.21549953520298004,
0.10361994057893753,
-0.3571954071521759,
-0.6216971278190613,
0.6534693837165833,
0.19283752143383026,
-0.3687764108181,
-0.6408596634864807,
0.15343348681926727,
0.5964471697807312,
-0.04844820871949196,
0.9676656126976013,
0.6373290419578552,
-0.25736990571022034,
-0.04688617214560509,
-0.9002475738525391,
-0.12452936917543411,
-0.3814861476421356,
-0.008081112988293171,
-0.19583436846733093,
-1.1538645029067993,
0.38027986884117126,
-0.6099447011947632,
-0.09640132635831833,
0.10943116992712021,
0.21871696412563324,
0.012808498926460743,
0.8151653409004211,
0.7291732430458069,
-0.47965916991233826,
0.22640150785446167,
-0.33840587735176086,
0.5108219385147095,
-1.2009526491165161,
-0.0755617693066597,
-0.4853114187717438,
-0.7566164135932922,
-0.5869702696800232,
-0.81048184633255,
0.25712719559669495,
0.4901482164859772,
-0.035664308816194534,
0.455606073141098,
-0.5989519953727722,
0.6209694743156433,
0.497293084859848,
0.008066213689744473,
0.2050052136182785,
0.14776556193828583,
0.14367076754570007,
0.06254221498966217,
-1.005484938621521,
-0.41421186923980713,
1.155060052871704,
0.23970811069011688,
0.37132716178894043,
0.5374271273612976,
0.7958382368087769,
-0.35305383801460266,
0.189224511384964,
-0.7202464938163757,
0.6747520565986633,
-0.08155438303947449,
-0.08056055754423141,
-0.2476733773946762,
-0.9762952923774719,
-0.7440307140350342,
0.07912550866603851,
-0.08064877241849899,
-0.767020046710968,
0.3295648992061615,
0.05787575989961624,
-0.2586996257305145,
0.6150651574134827,
-0.6568425297737122,
0.41499462723731995,
0.07972215116024017,
-0.1756085306406021,
-0.06974855810403824,
-0.4947033226490021,
0.6983304619789124,
-0.08254831284284592,
0.27417290210723877,
-0.18943466246128082,
-0.15394583344459534,
0.7166720628738403,
-0.5254170298576355,
0.6023935079574585,
-0.21437034010887146,
0.013766903430223465,
-0.041378337889909744,
0.33311617374420166,
0.46792393922805786,
-0.23124222457408905,
0.2188490480184555,
0.15168431401252747,
-0.05471377447247505,
-0.5006937980651855,
-1.0826646089553833,
0.8274148106575012,
-0.7577293515205383,
-0.5563199520111084,
0.08622339367866516,
-0.9309181571006775,
-0.4515899121761322,
-0.02070235274732113,
-0.1812613606452942,
0.46246251463890076,
0.27857959270477295,
0.24517783522605896,
0.48049676418304443,
-0.11202826350927353,
0.09019967913627625,
0.42480960488319397,
-0.15164533257484436,
-0.6084858179092407,
1.2517166137695312,
0.20445729792118073,
0.13237729668617249,
0.44535011053085327,
0.20373865962028503,
-0.0008415284100919962,
-0.939526379108429,
-0.2508975565433502,
0.47926050424575806,
-0.5024621486663818,
-0.8682252764701843,
-0.3747693598270416,
-0.3661407232284546,
-0.6837170720100403,
0.008935253135859966,
-0.15061426162719727,
-0.6280412077903748,
-0.10792256891727448,
0.042719196528196335,
0.010874807834625244,
0.7130767703056335,
-0.09680081158876419,
0.39661380648612976,
-1.0931532382965088,
-0.009699570015072823,
0.351582795381546,
0.09323415905237198,
0.011852405034005642,
-0.3480217754840851,
-0.1435617357492447,
-0.28644707798957825,
-0.19013500213623047,
-0.6269696354866028,
0.7471736669540405,
0.0891818031668663,
0.2753761112689972,
0.33784162998199463,
-0.03804667666554451,
0.7745532393455505,
-0.333204060792923,
0.6841932535171509,
0.2189485728740692,
-0.6245359182357788,
0.26926103234291077,
-0.08204757422208786,
0.21677878499031067,
0.3287738263607025,
0.4869685769081116,
-0.26560351252555847,
-0.30034691095352173,
-0.6187224984169006,
-0.7741400003433228,
0.4604032635688782,
0.17613866925239563,
-0.29956305027008057,
0.3930318057537079,
0.40528666973114014,
-0.07712353020906448,
0.3871913552284241,
-0.4625394940376282,
-0.0778462365269661,
0.27871230244636536,
-0.46408724784851074,
-0.15696540474891663,
-0.43161705136299133,
-0.6105403304100037,
-0.3303506374359131,
0.7292853593826294,
-0.08633080124855042,
0.25462812185287476,
-0.03640301898121834,
-0.27822983264923096,
0.1195184513926506,
0.1385568231344223,
0.619827151298523,
0.5544739961624146,
-0.3340834677219391,
0.2252214103937149,
-0.03121282160282135,
-0.17794813215732574,
0.27047377824783325,
-0.005054510664194822,
-0.03143424168229103,
-0.4568794071674347,
0.27346882224082947,
0.7894415259361267,
0.16443277895450592,
-0.3413957357406616,
0.3844979405403137,
-0.23107238113880157,
-0.2563101649284363,
0.4331226944923401,
-0.12367543578147888,
0.17612631618976593,
0.29007425904273987,
0.014039315283298492,
0.11947618424892426,
-0.09543363749980927,
-0.24299150705337524,
-0.02301420271396637,
0.5407887101173401,
-0.08164964616298676,
-0.14253714680671692,
0.290309876203537,
0.02195192687213421,
-0.06525824964046478,
0.6216113567352295,
-0.15567468106746674,
-0.528450071811676,
0.3378163278102875,
0.3365754783153534,
0.6804307103157043,
-0.18631212413311005,
-0.09524169564247131,
0.36408182978630066,
0.4104507267475128,
0.06156838312745094,
-0.01824747584760189,
-0.38923391699790955,
-0.8077777624130249,
-0.7816323041915894,
-0.8017414212226868,
-0.3486001789569855,
0.15439975261688232,
-0.5495123863220215,
0.25851261615753174,
-0.6269542574882507,
0.029842058196663857,
-0.3895289897918701,
0.20453228056430817,
-0.5998108983039856,
0.11572834849357605,
0.015208126977086067,
0.8744528889656067,
-0.7487571239471436,
0.9661720395088196,
0.512374758720398,
-0.3038833737373352,
-1.3135228157043457,
-0.19015491008758545,
0.23735648393630981,
-0.5432266592979431,
0.6610235571861267,
0.030428586527705193,
0.10784745216369629,
0.14293882250785828,
-0.3583226799964905,
-0.9857696890830994,
1.4541300535202026,
0.8127445578575134,
-0.5741950869560242,
-0.02811388671398163,
0.16995102167129517,
0.07924356311559677,
-0.43211495876312256,
-0.2803266942501068,
0.5839216709136963,
0.4561310410499573,
0.39398884773254395,
-0.8653274178504944,
0.08775991201400757,
-0.18027086555957794,
0.0027053956873714924,
0.44648781418800354,
-0.6345688700675964,
0.6337586641311646,
0.3777051270008087,
-0.3982369303703308,
0.015893401578068733,
0.8032733798027039,
0.3222792148590088,
-0.007047830615192652,
0.699910581111908,
1.149962306022644,
0.9723780155181885,
-0.040577322244644165,
0.8931117057800293,
-0.49061739444732666,
0.33761927485466003,
0.9186862707138062,
-0.1055823266506195,
0.8206685185432434,
0.7085549831390381,
-0.21750128269195557,
0.434675395488739,
0.5994988083839417,
0.3499520719051361,
0.33699238300323486,
0.14300045371055603,
-0.1431303173303604,
-0.18833650648593903,
-0.2804359793663025,
-0.2823270857334137,
0.2963121235370636,
0.06345994025468826,
0.03340176120400429,
0.03099033609032631,
-0.25209373235702515,
0.006145726423710585,
-0.2088572233915329,
-0.1492898315191269,
0.8689478635787964,
0.034832313656806946,
-0.6875434517860413,
0.6269822716712952,
-0.1407734602689743,
0.6317239999771118,
-0.3649291694164276,
0.13136622309684753,
-0.17736853659152985,
-0.22305713593959808,
-0.1185954362154007,
-0.2900521755218506,
0.37806692719459534,
-0.3479357361793518,
-0.12763191759586334,
-0.3744124174118042,
0.7833899259567261,
-0.7003874778747559,
-0.533467173576355,
0.10481619834899902,
0.5442861914634705,
0.25116196274757385,
0.09809223562479019,
-0.46730056405067444,
0.3595462739467621,
0.0542023628950119,
0.1981770545244217,
0.6783671975135803,
0.35657280683517456,
0.21084913611412048,
0.6932936310768127,
0.8472669720649719,
0.6809517741203308,
0.1405092179775238,
0.048110075294971466,
1.1093635559082031,
-0.41990020871162415,
-0.2625851333141327,
-0.47577962279319763,
0.4128875434398651,
-0.22307124733924866,
0.23333530128002167,
0.4434444010257721,
0.4976919889450073,
0.7649379968643188,
0.1570463925600052,
0.3540807068347931,
0.21753039956092834,
0.5280019044876099,
-0.8428534269332886,
0.7001160979270935,
-0.6007229685783386,
0.5421566367149353,
0.02130717784166336,
-1.2788666486740112,
-0.3820784091949463,
0.23213034868240356,
-0.09867003560066223,
-0.12257631123065948,
0.5786264538764954,
0.9366448521614075,
-0.4020131826400757,
-0.43923220038414,
0.4967859387397766,
0.03487861901521683,
0.4398251473903656,
0.5527743697166443,
0.5463060140609741,
-0.32559260725975037,
0.40622907876968384,
-0.5134963393211365,
-0.27045631408691406,
0.0067144595086574554,
-1.171227216720581,
-0.6613573431968689,
-0.7712696194648743,
-0.4530566930770874,
-0.1762002557516098,
-0.19817610085010529,
0.6291313767433167,
0.9521576166152954,
-0.5877530574798584,
-0.3156314790248871,
-0.17198197543621063,
0.18129296600818634,
-0.1978912204504013,
-0.2341172844171524,
0.42888912558555603,
-0.17865322530269623,
-0.8482615351676941,
0.6202983260154724,
0.36776062846183777,
0.1704840511083603,
-0.5570898652076721,
-0.06699904054403305,
-0.22928760945796967,
0.08309010416269302,
0.2129197120666504,
0.16463345289230347,
-0.6777474880218506,
-0.07917705923318863,
-0.5351942181587219,
0.19232389330863953,
-0.16201907396316528,
1.0089704990386963,
-1.0194740295410156,
0.1828918159008026,
0.6501376032829285,
0.9900999665260315,
0.33523598313331604,
0.17596502602100372,
0.930948793888092,
-1.038805365562439,
0.3606569468975067,
0.1944272220134735,
0.43044087290763855,
0.6363626718521118,
-0.308180034160614,
0.47381559014320374,
0.14865002036094666,
-0.7207315564155579,
-1.195258617401123,
0.2394135743379593,
-1.1870150566101074,
-0.16067509353160858,
1.00118887424469,
-0.13345463573932648,
-0.5938931703567505,
0.4084796905517578,
-0.10921568423509598,
0.5065608620643616,
-0.1627013087272644,
0.579439640045166,
0.6727845072746277,
0.11540625244379044,
-0.42969581484794617,
-0.3118410110473633,
0.56864333152771,
0.5485306978225708,
-0.6968950629234314,
-0.035464808344841,
0.369040310382843,
-0.036160439252853394,
0.13207761943340302,
0.03545568138360977,
0.018537528812885284,
0.001300764619372785,
-0.38971513509750366,
-0.029691221192479134,
-0.4026867151260376,
-0.4458360970020294,
-0.5204856395721436,
0.33791667222976685,
0.03572823107242584,
-0.03766874969005585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16320v1 | What Do VLMs NOTICE? A Mechanistic Interpretability Pipeline for Noise-free Text-Image Corruption and Evaluation | 2024-06-24T05:13:19 | 2024-06-24T05:13:19 | Michal Golovanevsky, William Rudman, Vedant Palit, Ritambhara Singh, Carsten Eickhoff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have gained community-spanning prominence due
to their ability to integrate visual and textual inputs to perform complex
tasks. Despite their success, the internal decision-making processes of these
models remain opaque, posing challenges in high-stakes applications. To address
this, we introduce NOTICE, the first Noise-free Text-Image Corruption and
Evaluation pipeline for mechanistic interpretability in VLMs. NOTICE
incorporates a Semantic Minimal Pairs (SMP) framework for image corruption and
Symmetric Token Replacement (STR) for text. This approach enables semantically
meaningful causal mediation analysis for both modalities, providing a robust
method for analyzing multimodal integration within models like BLIP. Our
experiments on the SVO-Probes, MIT-States, and Facial Expression Recognition
datasets reveal crucial insights into VLM decision-making, identifying the
significant role of middle-layer cross-attention heads. Further, we uncover a
set of ``universal cross-attention heads'' that consistently contribute across
tasks and modalities, each performing distinct functions such as implicit image
segmentation, object inhibition, and outlier inhibition. This work paves the
way for more transparent and interpretable multimodal systems. | [
-0.0363379642367363,
-0.5439431667327881,
0.7569573521614075,
0.5829448699951172,
-0.5360783338546753,
-0.37931397557258606,
0.15434731543064117,
-0.70367032289505,
0.13463465869426727,
0.7409650087356567,
-0.8433690071105957,
-0.22169803082942963,
-0.7795146107673645,
-0.08962234109640121,
-0.6801541447639465,
1.051619291305542,
0.06868213415145874,
-0.032748397439718246,
-0.4558544456958771,
-0.06884883344173431,
-0.5148640871047974,
-0.24127745628356934,
-0.4026317596435547,
0.010204235091805458,
0.7129289507865906,
-0.10682515799999237,
0.7268710136413574,
0.7335289120674133,
0.7750164270401001,
0.2354648858308792,
-0.06346326321363449,
0.015071381814777851,
-0.4597429931163788,
-0.034289680421352386,
-0.5159173607826233,
-0.4054877758026123,
-0.29487818479537964,
-0.12196425348520279,
0.4988107681274414,
0.4087439179420471,
0.18306855857372284,
0.39345064759254456,
0.18260978162288666,
0.6978161334991455,
-0.8619558215141296,
0.41704025864601135,
-0.9249732494354248,
0.21813397109508514,
-0.4717770218849182,
-0.3025795519351959,
-0.5630318522453308,
0.3275260627269745,
0.06869372725486755,
-0.32254958152770996,
0.04516499117016792,
0.11171171814203262,
0.9484551548957825,
0.6200506091117859,
-0.34185999631881714,
-0.10683140903711319,
-0.622939944267273,
1.0533007383346558,
-0.435942143201828,
0.6368166208267212,
0.09376361966133118,
0.4297827184200287,
-0.14678063988685608,
-0.8713230490684509,
-0.5029577016830444,
0.04097413271665573,
-0.2870441675186157,
0.37223994731903076,
-0.7457810044288635,
0.0528540313243866,
0.14372646808624268,
0.14566326141357422,
-0.5277513861656189,
0.010129339061677456,
-0.5441681146621704,
-0.4735753536224365,
0.24896059930324554,
0.16305606067180634,
0.20172837376594543,
-0.3428390324115753,
-0.606959879398346,
0.22181947529315948,
-0.6028276681900024,
0.0512961708009243,
0.012968149967491627,
0.24316300451755524,
-0.3150979280471802,
0.784717857837677,
-0.23061035573482513,
0.8435431718826294,
-0.36338698863983154,
0.28156644105911255,
0.04029912129044533,
-0.623863935470581,
-0.7807019948959351,
-0.18474623560905457,
0.7996217012405396,
0.5737237334251404,
0.023663315922021866,
-0.06912776082754135,
-0.21065054833889008,
0.3459398150444031,
0.41922351717948914,
-0.44736969470977783,
-0.09311098605394363,
0.28632214665412903,
-0.679114043712616,
-0.6305609345436096,
-0.03179272264242172,
-0.7654910087585449,
-0.5569332242012024,
-0.5352885723114014,
0.6049132943153381,
-0.024097492918372154,
-0.2139902114868164,
0.049048300832509995,
-0.48245900869369507,
0.14255383610725403,
0.6444615125656128,
-0.5013431906700134,
-0.1084149181842804,
0.6449161767959595,
0.7702379822731018,
-0.09597484767436981,
-0.317333847284317,
-0.7920327186584473,
0.13270799815654755,
-0.2097882181406021,
0.699097216129303,
-0.47642529010772705,
-0.07376927137374878,
0.006168964318931103,
0.1426679939031601,
-0.13169614970684052,
-0.3697895407676697,
0.7638974189758301,
-0.2719345688819885,
-0.025131618604063988,
-0.16106927394866943,
0.012609422206878662,
-0.1100989431142807,
0.18384382128715515,
-0.5872200131416321,
0.8189964294433594,
0.13748398423194885,
-0.7926724553108215,
0.6544210910797119,
-0.4338158667087555,
-0.15808843076229095,
-0.013667991384863853,
-0.2873591482639313,
-0.4341420829296112,
0.3812095522880554,
0.10226448625326157,
0.4568755328655243,
-0.24156297743320465,
-0.07112744450569153,
-0.3775255084037781,
-0.31411969661712646,
0.25546520948410034,
-0.6199718117713928,
0.8628124594688416,
0.09308100491762161,
-0.46379345655441284,
0.5430828332901001,
-0.7382960319519043,
-0.01366011705249548,
-0.0950719565153122,
0.07494179159402847,
-0.5066789388656616,
0.04779362305998802,
0.31543952226638794,
0.7662627696990967,
0.3260928988456726,
-0.3101719915866852,
-0.1255381852388382,
0.04818776622414589,
0.35008132457733154,
1.0747216939926147,
-0.1629692167043686,
0.1773516833782196,
0.023864280432462692,
0.1927718073129654,
0.5978845953941345,
0.9755733609199524,
-0.31117063760757446,
-0.7088010311126709,
-0.8576421141624451,
-0.4741123616695404,
-0.16833063960075378,
0.4362012445926666,
-0.8701537847518921,
0.05357188731431961,
-0.2711695730686188,
-0.3830529451370239,
-0.8441675305366516,
0.3359105587005615,
0.774481475353241,
0.5167509913444519,
0.38386639952659607,
-0.2737196683883667,
-0.6922754049301147,
-0.9882718920707703,
-0.5306707620620728,
-0.149065300822258,
0.12869544327259064,
0.2634669542312622,
0.35994860529899597,
-0.6349209547042847,
0.7284584641456604,
-0.17958346009254456,
-0.5234136581420898,
0.04877842590212822,
0.18640044331550598,
0.030144691467285156,
0.15335813164710999,
0.3803824186325073,
-0.8646038770675659,
-0.1758771687746048,
-0.051172152161598206,
-0.8978151679039001,
-0.2493479698896408,
-0.19250856339931488,
-0.19599224627017975,
0.2984032928943634,
0.7235713005065918,
-0.35461553931236267,
0.80548495054245,
0.66485595703125,
-0.6345783472061157,
0.819457471370697,
-0.10290180891752243,
-0.15873174369335175,
-0.2091381996870041,
-0.11534581333398819,
0.01565319485962391,
-0.45791763067245483,
-0.49317482113838196,
0.05397593230009079,
0.0968291163444519,
0.1980874091386795,
-0.7549511790275574,
0.6990733742713928,
-0.3467407524585724,
-0.4175379276275635,
0.1460489183664322,
0.060789190232753754,
0.027947314083576202,
0.5238092541694641,
-0.23890382051467896,
0.4698784351348877,
0.7536126375198364,
-0.685473620891571,
-0.08449157327413559,
0.04639454931020737,
-0.19995954632759094,
0.7669282555580139,
-0.5649285912513733,
-0.07033754885196686,
-0.41631996631622314,
-0.4301225543022156,
-1.0683925151824951,
0.018488358706235886,
0.5286818742752075,
-0.27290818095207214,
0.031070921570062637,
-0.11259274929761887,
-0.28339508175849915,
-0.43276751041412354,
-0.4033048450946808,
0.18619495630264282,
0.2350742071866989,
-0.4580335319042206,
0.3851761817932129,
0.24637414515018463,
0.23226727545261383,
-0.6693503260612488,
-0.74652498960495,
0.11328893154859543,
0.11504616588354111,
-0.5575032234191895,
-0.21672335267066956,
-0.028860123828053474,
-0.33490949869155884,
0.21287719905376434,
-0.2857058644294739,
-0.09182706475257874,
0.040124911814928055,
0.5635932683944702,
0.3662753105163574,
-0.06652847677469254,
-0.1628112643957138,
0.008556634187698364,
-0.19763299822807312,
-0.04744827002286911,
-0.1683586984872818,
0.34668073058128357,
-0.17365172505378723,
-0.5660473704338074,
-0.4600053131580353,
0.10495689511299133,
1.0239226818084717,
-0.3074556887149811,
0.4483773112297058,
0.7979956865310669,
-0.23337264358997345,
0.020665770396590233,
-0.24724912643432617,
-0.07979980856180191,
-0.44522613286972046,
0.2351335734128952,
-0.18268251419067383,
-0.719433605670929,
0.30072200298309326,
0.15509139001369476,
-0.07788892835378647,
0.4341820180416107,
0.5732833743095398,
-0.19789156317710876,
1.1724199056625366,
0.7179168462753296,
0.1329859495162964,
0.7587814927101135,
0.13408918678760529,
0.14790241420269012,
-0.7974463701248169,
-0.29006320238113403,
-0.25323721766471863,
-0.12328653037548065,
-0.46947959065437317,
-0.7502642273902893,
0.585613489151001,
-0.13686145842075348,
0.10738369077444077,
0.025812285020947456,
-0.5465205907821655,
0.2510685920715332,
0.4556752145290375,
0.1317000836133957,
0.3532978296279907,
0.05866162106394768,
-0.0593167245388031,
-0.5132620334625244,
-0.38560399413108826,
-0.24304728209972382,
0.9189266562461853,
0.17755265533924103,
0.6221954822540283,
-0.03480319678783417,
0.3048618733882904,
0.49934548139572144,
0.2544732689857483,
-0.6322131156921387,
0.3461707830429077,
-0.32219162583351135,
-0.36832523345947266,
-0.298211008310318,
-0.16217564046382904,
-0.8969703912734985,
0.526743471622467,
-0.3076463043689728,
-0.8513248562812805,
0.24471881985664368,
0.3118395507335663,
0.10676009207963943,
0.03089023567736149,
-0.5072805881500244,
1.1465511322021484,
-0.14692777395248413,
-0.6216731667518616,
-0.30661994218826294,
-0.6590489745140076,
0.723064124584198,
0.13242799043655396,
0.5705252289772034,
-0.06410593539476395,
0.01539872121065855,
0.35048148036003113,
-0.22383904457092285,
0.8683983087539673,
-0.14438308775424957,
0.04816620796918869,
0.0008464103448204696,
0.032510485500097275,
0.5080654621124268,
-0.34635889530181885,
0.19565296173095703,
0.43298324942588806,
0.06272869557142258,
-0.373299777507782,
-0.5207091569900513,
0.45361873507499695,
-0.3983648121356964,
-0.30959001183509827,
-0.2766490876674652,
-0.27919065952301025,
0.1157260462641716,
0.3828771710395813,
0.22014249861240387,
0.49551865458488464,
0.09031768888235092,
0.09301837533712387,
0.484807550907135,
-0.14192385971546173,
0.3573414981365204,
0.4724996089935303,
-0.707367479801178,
-0.08193721622228622,
1.116949200630188,
-0.02395465411245823,
0.2841726243495941,
0.2894729971885681,
0.0905182808637619,
-0.2151077538728714,
-0.3139208257198334,
-0.6212060451507568,
0.14441139996051788,
-0.7407492399215698,
-0.0077269719913601875,
-0.6612285375595093,
-0.13217127323150635,
-0.16575004160404205,
-0.014538371004164219,
-0.3843521177768707,
-0.24259915947914124,
-0.11593027412891388,
0.2199029177427292,
0.058570075780153275,
0.6108396053314209,
-0.013497953303158283,
0.32632002234458923,
-0.7308955788612366,
0.4289190471172333,
0.3030809462070465,
0.39993807673454285,
-0.06449232995510101,
-0.1793503314256668,
-0.29418066143989563,
-0.10270009189844131,
-0.19879287481307983,
-0.7033878564834595,
0.24400931596755981,
0.06677258014678955,
0.5306240320205688,
0.6063939929008484,
-0.3075227439403534,
0.7998005747795105,
-0.4377053380012512,
0.7197579741477966,
0.40815469622612,
-1.128455400466919,
0.5990281701087952,
-0.28890570998191833,
0.02752334624528885,
0.13447214663028717,
-0.19878365099430084,
-0.7300431728363037,
-0.8313591480255127,
-0.6495115756988525,
-0.918307900428772,
0.5258641839027405,
0.26052820682525635,
-0.09407718479633331,
0.08907493203878403,
-0.06787676364183426,
-0.0901678279042244,
0.5486087203025818,
-0.7166831493377686,
-0.2668001353740692,
-0.16521453857421875,
-0.06755919009447098,
0.2148180603981018,
-0.4473764896392822,
-0.2706993818283081,
-0.156440868973732,
0.23910272121429443,
-0.023197133094072342,
0.3521425426006317,
0.37932276725769043,
-0.5282268524169922,
-0.22610905766487122,
0.2977360486984253,
0.816157877445221,
0.6996539235115051,
-0.16847765445709229,
0.3251492977142334,
-0.47215354442596436,
-0.4994574785232544,
-0.3804764151573181,
-0.2785000205039978,
-0.3575369119644165,
0.36684173345565796,
0.44940629601478577,
0.9718372821807861,
0.5580992698669434,
-0.758450984954834,
0.8679302334785461,
-0.17651458084583282,
0.12319095432758331,
-0.22586612403392792,
-0.05967022478580475,
-0.39126157760620117,
0.3418951630592346,
0.192148819565773,
0.38700205087661743,
0.46816349029541016,
-0.6672322154045105,
0.3613397181034088,
0.5798365473747253,
-1.0913726091384888,
-0.45339033007621765,
0.9090869426727295,
-0.16573865711688995,
0.13020522892475128,
0.31796035170555115,
-0.1424514800310135,
-0.4860526919364929,
0.5110301375389099,
0.2462080866098404,
0.8185054659843445,
-0.0652470588684082,
0.4174214005470276,
-0.08179759979248047,
0.8763817548751831,
0.14893260598182678,
0.5047460794448853,
0.14823082089424133,
-0.544543445110321,
-0.39216676354408264,
-0.6626747250556946,
-0.32473134994506836,
0.050834279507398605,
-0.6673356294631958,
0.47548869252204895,
-0.6404075622558594,
0.02952488325536251,
0.20476406812667847,
-0.6468840837478638,
-0.8998632431030273,
0.38342687487602234,
0.06863008439540863,
0.6689398288726807,
-1.0720491409301758,
0.5220761299133301,
0.5618900060653687,
-0.45546039938926697,
-0.41906559467315674,
-0.2694544494152069,
0.3148031532764435,
-1.0509414672851562,
0.6906678080558777,
0.1983012855052948,
-0.0592169389128685,
-0.27111753821372986,
-0.6230019927024841,
-0.5139705538749695,
0.8373909592628479,
0.3726123869419098,
-0.5170677900314331,
0.18591023981571198,
0.0591605044901371,
0.5650461912155151,
-0.018336905166506767,
0.2631203234195709,
0.4762190580368042,
0.6889228224754333,
0.11842532455921173,
-1.0113757848739624,
0.14102010428905487,
-0.04423489421606064,
-0.14141851663589478,
0.22647686302661896,
-0.6040929555892944,
1.0455946922302246,
-0.15493188798427582,
-0.1364290416240692,
-0.40217775106430054,
0.42294061183929443,
0.10421287268400192,
0.7340543270111084,
0.4828166961669922,
0.4477194845676422,
0.8019768595695496,
-0.08193349093198776,
1.1460907459259033,
-0.03467881679534912,
0.1665833741426468,
0.9331988096237183,
-0.03683606907725334,
0.6899424195289612,
1.0621803998947144,
-0.09360921382904053,
0.3969075083732605,
0.12619182467460632,
-0.03729139268398285,
0.665556788444519,
-0.055676575750112534,
-0.04761017486453056,
-0.26840612292289734,
-0.37782642245292664,
-0.02664463222026825,
0.5297152400016785,
0.3806365132331848,
-0.4916399121284485,
-0.3470326066017151,
0.004713853355497122,
-0.02499629557132721,
-0.18938615918159485,
-0.7025683522224426,
0.6233022212982178,
0.17159217596054077,
-0.23565833270549774,
0.2660738527774811,
-0.36024442315101624,
0.6711503863334656,
-0.3533155620098114,
-0.12506990134716034,
0.1634385585784912,
0.30613669753074646,
-0.4133935570716858,
-0.7530776262283325,
0.704948902130127,
-0.22600974142551422,
-0.5247136354446411,
-0.29505354166030884,
0.7588488459587097,
-0.4295245110988617,
-0.5467043519020081,
0.47724542021751404,
0.5186208486557007,
0.27669423818588257,
-0.35606807470321655,
-0.7519432306289673,
0.39655452966690063,
-0.009453495033085346,
0.013772566802799702,
0.3090306520462036,
0.5046893954277039,
-0.5116277933120728,
0.6945520043373108,
0.8597373962402344,
0.18811772763729095,
0.4348829686641693,
0.13675792515277863,
0.6757495999336243,
-0.53300940990448,
-0.36227014660835266,
-0.9763591289520264,
0.9990989565849304,
-0.18735584616661072,
-0.14780333638191223,
0.7611405849456787,
0.40490129590034485,
0.5043468475341797,
-0.29456067085266113,
0.8071707487106323,
0.12720239162445068,
0.1576520949602127,
-0.6330789923667908,
0.701775848865509,
-0.8371162414550781,
0.042885612696409225,
-0.545513391494751,
-0.5405299663543701,
-0.25971680879592896,
0.41699856519699097,
-0.03630751371383667,
-0.5657126307487488,
0.6525508761405945,
0.6457799673080444,
-0.07340191304683685,
-0.1999640166759491,
0.6379796862602234,
0.4163690507411957,
0.4238852858543396,
0.28057464957237244,
0.6937412619590759,
-0.5055036544799805,
0.7406620383262634,
-0.0650046169757843,
-0.14730115234851837,
-0.4154385030269623,
-1.1879627704620361,
-0.6623055338859558,
-0.5970489382743835,
-0.27532005310058594,
-0.2729005813598633,
-0.06276965886354446,
0.4095996618270874,
0.4177744388580322,
-0.45912405848503113,
0.13715626299381256,
-0.09253475069999695,
0.5411749482154846,
-0.5390414595603943,
-0.27635133266448975,
0.24708348512649536,
-0.425513356924057,
-0.5759716629981995,
0.06235481798648834,
0.9605675935745239,
-0.0224642064422369,
-0.2224111258983612,
0.21468928456306458,
0.1692206710577011,
0.03846336901187897,
0.8196412324905396,
0.1312890648841858,
-0.8585317730903625,
-0.3974629044532776,
-0.03350803628563881,
-0.29821452498435974,
-0.07923527806997299,
0.6773866415023804,
-0.4952836334705353,
0.8399704694747925,
0.3592357635498047,
0.2663387954235077,
0.5253196358680725,
-0.5445554256439209,
0.4945478141307831,
-0.8931719660758972,
0.64683997631073,
-0.08629808574914932,
0.5251455903053284,
0.3340272605419159,
-0.3456311821937561,
0.5457109808921814,
0.42131826281547546,
-0.2246314436197281,
-1.0950393676757812,
0.2604621648788452,
-1.2272976636886597,
-0.05189983546733856,
0.8604596853256226,
0.007639897055923939,
-0.5318099856376648,
-0.2203967422246933,
-0.28994452953338623,
0.11827979981899261,
-0.09304707497358322,
0.6844296455383301,
0.6448445320129395,
0.053083386272192,
-0.4500107169151306,
-0.9019840359687805,
0.6422220468521118,
0.3821994364261627,
-0.567372739315033,
0.2626560628414154,
0.5566843748092651,
0.018489355221390724,
0.29419857263565063,
0.6514060497283936,
-0.3586999177932739,
0.4413825273513794,
-0.1577640026807785,
0.02407369762659073,
-0.10079949349164963,
-0.4583410322666168,
-0.41021043062210083,
-0.2734834849834442,
-0.15841048955917358,
-0.24990485608577728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16319v1 | Modelled Multivariate Overlap: A method for measuring vowel merger | 2024-06-24T04:56:26 | 2024-06-24T04:56:26 | Irene Smith, Morgan Sonderegger, The Spade Consortium | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel method for quantifying vowel overlap. There is
a tension in previous work between using multivariate measures, such as those
derived from empirical distributions, and the ability to control for unbalanced
data and extraneous factors, as is possible when using fitted model parameters.
The method presented here resolves this tension by jointly modelling all
acoustic dimensions of interest and by simulating distributions from the model
to compute a measure of vowel overlap. An additional benefit of this method is
that computation of uncertainty becomes straightforward. We evaluate this
method on corpus speech data targeting the PIN-PEN merger in four dialects of
English and find that using modelled distributions to calculate Bhattacharyya
affinity substantially improves results compared to empirical distributions,
while the difference between multivariate and univariate modelling is subtle. | [
-0.5763388872146606,
-0.664814829826355,
0.5652652978897095,
0.4238679111003876,
0.14227750897407532,
0.2857617139816284,
-0.12953351438045502,
-0.8071261644363403,
0.4685949683189392,
0.08084281533956528,
-0.3117387294769287,
-0.3894597291946411,
-0.7045077681541443,
-0.21572807431221008,
-0.3310217559337616,
0.04859747365117073,
-0.11308642476797104,
0.15964697301387787,
0.05134618282318115,
-0.13544106483459473,
-0.4781356155872345,
-0.4908433258533478,
0.03489523380994797,
-0.1714126616716385,
0.5915454626083374,
0.3602629601955414,
0.4818493127822876,
0.48579922318458557,
0.654601514339447,
0.3361172080039978,
-0.256165474653244,
0.3018992245197296,
-0.1258184164762497,
0.15512552857398987,
0.2237301468849182,
-0.5463681817054749,
-0.40056827664375305,
0.3655138909816742,
0.6797928214073181,
1.2251092195510864,
-0.2363050878047943,
-0.23025400936603546,
0.23597703874111176,
0.12201983481645584,
-0.7401412725448608,
-0.10529904067516327,
-0.42685553431510925,
0.09403712302446365,
-0.3509499728679657,
-0.3648655116558075,
-0.12445899099111557,
-0.3681672215461731,
0.20907063782215118,
-0.49004292488098145,
0.02702472172677517,
-0.008911150507628918,
0.7846968770027161,
-0.21613706648349762,
-0.5097575187683105,
-0.06475682556629181,
-0.9888324737548828,
1.2581713199615479,
-0.5746973752975464,
0.603889524936676,
0.08570357412099838,
0.23960214853286743,
-0.18514910340309143,
-0.3262097239494324,
-0.6274787783622742,
-0.03739966079592705,
0.07085759192705154,
-0.06336791813373566,
-0.3212486505508423,
0.24612756073474884,
-0.2207460105419159,
0.43008217215538025,
-0.39055371284484863,
0.1606355607509613,
-0.8616507649421692,
-0.0902785211801529,
0.5318261981010437,
0.14625734090805054,
0.5511392951011658,
0.12185338139533997,
-0.7976542115211487,
-0.06735783815383911,
-0.552291750907898,
0.27002209424972534,
1.1729985475540161,
0.6565822958946228,
-0.05577348172664642,
0.8384669423103333,
0.07369332015514374,
0.5635955333709717,
0.046914588660001755,
-0.08000609278678894,
0.3714003264904022,
-0.20215032994747162,
0.08664862811565399,
0.44808247685432434,
0.6313436031341553,
0.18318933248519897,
0.029521508142352104,
0.2726258635520935,
0.21156030893325806,
0.12285416573286057,
0.1690952181816101,
-0.15767700970172882,
-0.005158602725714445,
0.5074033737182617,
-0.4287794828414917,
-0.13973280787467957,
0.037979576736688614,
-0.735698401927948,
0.17252029478549957,
-0.5920339822769165,
0.6402599215507507,
-0.4775761663913727,
-0.7269870638847351,
0.37035006284713745,
-0.533089816570282,
0.12082219868898392,
-0.07400232553482056,
-1.0178649425506592,
0.5081653594970703,
0.7973544597625732,
0.6308318972587585,
-0.2882630228996277,
-0.7147649526596069,
-0.13353823125362396,
0.20131070911884308,
-0.5398290157318115,
0.7450520992279053,
-0.8016788363456726,
-0.46400973200798035,
0.1956350952386856,
-0.3740782141685486,
-0.2221868485212326,
-0.3417004346847534,
0.2920316755771637,
-0.10364098846912384,
0.12283968180418015,
0.12674440443515778,
-0.9739879369735718,
-0.5125911235809326,
-0.16058510541915894,
-0.623587965965271,
1.0142850875854492,
0.16719813644886017,
-0.5172574520111084,
0.5863202810287476,
-0.32259026169776917,
-0.27432534098625183,
-0.14975272119045258,
-0.17110633850097656,
-0.30462026596069336,
0.16559171676635742,
0.04418931528925896,
0.2516093850135803,
-0.20507821440696716,
0.11103310436010361,
-0.7694683074951172,
-0.38545215129852295,
0.23496060073375702,
-0.5334107279777527,
0.8037710189819336,
0.02270607464015484,
0.04039151594042778,
-0.01809038035571575,
-0.6084991097450256,
0.1777683049440384,
-0.7802708745002747,
0.222373828291893,
-0.8089665770530701,
-0.4932924807071686,
0.4383193552494049,
-0.0409931056201458,
0.3771018087863922,
-0.33944380283355713,
0.23671306669712067,
-0.14457955956459045,
0.06718721240758896,
0.19880548119544983,
0.2195654660463333,
0.2237817645072937,
-0.4830194413661957,
0.6542683839797974,
0.3181360960006714,
0.3230014443397522,
0.3418794274330139,
-0.728959321975708,
-0.2635499835014343,
-0.7540034651756287,
0.6555874347686768,
0.27934765815734863,
0.1516706347465515,
0.7003651261329651,
0.15798459947109222,
-0.7491298913955688,
-0.8380508422851562,
-0.1731024533510208,
0.16486437618732452,
-0.12687665224075317,
0.2530820369720459,
-0.4504639804363251,
-0.7075892090797424,
-0.8702515959739685,
-0.21076832711696625,
-0.5417160987854004,
-0.010135325603187084,
0.1175098717212677,
0.014166979119181633,
0.006425031926482916,
0.9129375219345093,
-0.5334115028381348,
-0.1756441295146942,
0.04193445295095444,
0.8405100107192993,
0.22502762079238892,
0.6131852865219116,
0.5727337002754211,
-0.6204542517662048,
-0.413825124502182,
0.18990300595760345,
-0.6964738965034485,
-0.19877541065216064,
0.05479593575000763,
-0.04559944570064545,
-0.13921765983104706,
0.406139075756073,
-0.6631112098693848,
0.46344149112701416,
0.7345156669616699,
-0.018143007531762123,
0.939368486404419,
-0.28482675552368164,
0.711551308631897,
-0.8009709715843201,
-0.17003783583641052,
0.005952419713139534,
0.27317360043525696,
-0.9577609896659851,
-0.07636803388595581,
-0.027237948030233383,
0.18470843136310577,
-0.8943755030632019,
0.4302842319011688,
-0.5824019312858582,
-0.12075411528348923,
0.035668566823005676,
0.010562214069068432,
-0.03449265658855438,
0.1975504457950592,
-0.14203672111034393,
0.5972193479537964,
0.6640807390213013,
-0.4393678605556488,
0.08250834792852402,
0.4515196681022644,
-0.18657448887825012,
0.895169734954834,
-0.5036938786506653,
-0.4511354863643646,
0.2735174298286438,
-0.28432783484458923,
-1.3940532207489014,
0.04677865654230118,
-0.25993794202804565,
-0.635852575302124,
0.2833891212940216,
-0.19668133556842804,
0.17743057012557983,
-0.3025904595851898,
-0.5791221261024475,
0.8944557905197144,
0.22770464420318604,
-0.6202194094657898,
0.8604340553283691,
0.5253919363021851,
-0.44425398111343384,
-0.6669333577156067,
-0.5122366547584534,
-0.09880197793245316,
-0.8882454633712769,
-0.8218096494674683,
0.3524038791656494,
0.046395715326070786,
-0.38260865211486816,
0.16541409492492676,
0.08501899242401123,
-0.5410197377204895,
-0.5279122591018677,
0.22606207430362701,
0.24688643217086792,
-0.4183409512042999,
-0.12824666500091553,
0.4305015206336975,
0.14346745610237122,
-0.20907896757125854,
-0.12860539555549622,
0.4290052652359009,
0.4101201593875885,
-0.566842257976532,
-0.7395015954971313,
0.7014995813369751,
0.6060848236083984,
-0.15085043013095856,
0.4113111197948456,
0.4722241163253784,
-0.38897189497947693,
0.04770452529191971,
-0.7454738616943359,
-0.0187386367470026,
-0.4100663661956787,
-0.02870318852365017,
-0.5482016801834106,
-0.5448057651519775,
0.7841836214065552,
0.00027651581331156194,
-0.2793775498867035,
0.3753706216812134,
0.36758747696876526,
-0.2234647572040558,
0.9222601652145386,
0.7099285125732422,
-0.0613909475505352,
0.15623170137405396,
-0.03812936693429947,
0.36563384532928467,
-0.9303170442581177,
-0.1556343138217926,
-0.5037989616394043,
-0.32028427720069885,
-0.6860722899436951,
-0.4894741475582123,
0.326384574174881,
0.3998333811759949,
0.09366612136363983,
0.2950016260147095,
-0.034130990505218506,
0.1612665057182312,
0.5178315043449402,
-0.25172796845436096,
0.28957730531692505,
0.12799428403377533,
-0.23201029002666473,
-0.3804694712162018,
-0.5381292104721069,
-0.1707877367734909,
1.1217849254608154,
0.39213335514068604,
0.840811550617218,
0.20237116515636444,
0.6162166595458984,
0.30201131105422974,
-0.21546749770641327,
-0.5085223913192749,
0.0745692029595375,
-0.19256821274757385,
-0.4296809732913971,
-0.5777757167816162,
-0.3651125133037567,
-1.2524683475494385,
0.4476626515388489,
-0.24604278802871704,
-0.9986263513565063,
0.7554491758346558,
-0.10028888285160065,
-0.35779476165771484,
0.3567175269126892,
-0.8270306587219238,
0.3470695912837982,
-0.03684511408209801,
-0.22140663862228394,
-0.19107751548290253,
-0.19966575503349304,
0.7747058868408203,
-0.2378052920103073,
0.1934186816215515,
-0.2601574659347534,
0.09226422011852264,
0.7498123645782471,
-0.42309099435806274,
0.7045273184776306,
0.14185693860054016,
-0.10729945451021194,
0.4090001881122589,
-0.0100629273802042,
-0.05195929855108261,
-0.4598515033721924,
0.010653994046151638,
0.5920038223266602,
0.3591240346431732,
-0.4572293162345886,
-0.5372809767723083,
0.5707736015319824,
-0.8219659328460693,
-0.25148409605026245,
-0.34217381477355957,
-0.7791761159896851,
-0.40655192732810974,
-0.06558350473642349,
0.13039198517799377,
0.523970365524292,
-0.43152713775634766,
0.06424995511770248,
-0.026354534551501274,
-0.07544900476932526,
0.24161504209041595,
0.3994508683681488,
-0.21586085855960846,
-0.33681508898735046,
0.5166640281677246,
0.36629176139831543,
0.3438136577606201,
0.33482834696769714,
0.3423014283180237,
-0.7390082478523254,
-0.30357104539871216,
-0.08589857816696167,
0.15161098539829254,
-0.17886239290237427,
0.055272176861763,
-0.5684839487075806,
-0.4349578619003296,
-0.38924047350883484,
-0.04504065215587616,
-0.39707428216934204,
-0.48058757185935974,
0.215482696890831,
-0.06961151957511902,
0.5635863542556763,
1.0439338684082031,
-0.6553297638893127,
0.6705406904220581,
-0.7077820897102356,
0.07488574832677841,
0.3135037422180176,
0.4073295593261719,
0.048381172120571136,
-0.30163121223449707,
0.10488155484199524,
-0.027396801859140396,
-0.13864362239837646,
-1.1833866834640503,
0.5992600321769714,
0.033227209001779556,
0.7794946432113647,
0.6144335269927979,
-0.09767689555883408,
0.6420772671699524,
-0.3150795102119446,
0.6113096475601196,
0.48028984665870667,
-1.0649610757827759,
-0.010238360613584518,
-0.6558976173400879,
-0.24878154695034027,
0.30240657925605774,
0.6147695183753967,
-0.45204290747642517,
-0.8288699984550476,
-0.7027848362922668,
-1.1218552589416504,
0.027676260098814964,
0.38898441195487976,
-0.29051539301872253,
0.2050321400165558,
-0.048670362681150436,
0.34272143244743347,
0.2359004020690918,
0.17231321334838867,
-0.3377235233783722,
0.7610974311828613,
-0.3320082724094391,
-0.24504972994327545,
-0.2708248496055603,
-0.06569650024175644,
-0.5168604254722595,
0.4766603112220764,
0.29622143507003784,
0.16675685346126556,
-0.2939417064189911,
-0.010792653076350689,
-0.15475191175937653,
0.08052518218755722,
0.5410158634185791,
0.7979300618171692,
-0.4927780032157898,
0.36836379766464233,
0.09786327183246613,
-0.6307549476623535,
0.5512686967849731,
0.1621137261390686,
0.3212505877017975,
0.26337018609046936,
0.4828955829143524,
0.5123128890991211,
0.33863118290901184,
-0.10551795363426208,
0.4292205274105072,
-0.11852922290563583,
-0.5953603982925415,
-0.07023365795612335,
-0.20594903826713562,
0.17083777487277985,
0.227444127202034,
0.2066548615694046,
-0.06664830446243286,
0.333325058221817,
-0.5168682932853699,
0.7212626338005066,
0.34231236577033997,
-0.48963987827301025,
-0.0022139307111501694,
0.36283090710639954,
0.04170873016119003,
-0.10971903800964355,
0.38159510493278503,
-0.08471444249153137,
-0.5420277118682861,
0.727144718170166,
0.25273028016090393,
0.5515550971031189,
-0.816287100315094,
0.013842982240021229,
0.06587021052837372,
0.22761252522468567,
-0.10850681364536285,
0.5749393105506897,
0.4980836510658264,
-0.6364480257034302,
-0.4814405143260956,
-0.33088475465774536,
-0.6521445512771606,
0.23885942995548248,
-1.0037809610366821,
0.6021298766136169,
0.28158703446388245,
-0.18792025744915009,
0.45066431164741516,
0.076074980199337,
-0.5391077399253845,
-0.08870625495910645,
-0.19839918613433838,
0.7477193474769592,
-1.445679783821106,
0.39270079135894775,
0.19359749555587769,
-0.3535870909690857,
-1.0040923357009888,
0.1392788141965866,
0.17612634599208832,
-0.6789963841438293,
0.26087886095046997,
0.11227278411388397,
-0.30990684032440186,
-0.37655726075172424,
0.2169313281774521,
-0.779849648475647,
0.516555666923523,
0.055907946079969406,
-0.5340215563774109,
0.4530442953109741,
0.38856348395347595,
0.4488399922847748,
-0.2820158898830414,
0.5503292083740234,
0.8394133448600769,
0.7031726837158203,
-0.00482664629817009,
-0.950775682926178,
-0.4799717366695404,
-0.06288909912109375,
-0.13198378682136536,
0.514136552810669,
-0.2191486954689026,
0.9354006052017212,
0.01924189366400242,
0.034784719347953796,
0.126414954662323,
0.7160879373550415,
0.39528918266296387,
0.14733731746673584,
0.788308322429657,
0.41057467460632324,
1.0306729078292847,
-0.006933275144547224,
0.44314220547676086,
-0.6935860514640808,
0.4922645092010498,
0.7946001291275024,
-0.39602231979370117,
1.1451876163482666,
0.6701838374137878,
-0.6765643358230591,
0.10691516101360321,
0.6406552791595459,
0.03038853220641613,
-0.009444160386919975,
0.3169311583042145,
-0.4226895868778229,
-0.034853387624025345,
-0.2809446454048157,
-0.567912220954895,
0.9281772971153259,
0.4403008818626404,
0.19587358832359314,
-0.014796358533203602,
0.011169102974236012,
-0.4037426710128784,
0.2829205393791199,
-0.0009853990050032735,
0.3573242127895355,
-0.07606343179941177,
-0.3280319571495056,
0.5111275315284729,
-0.21940447390079498,
0.7996090054512024,
-0.5764983296394348,
-0.03758930042386055,
0.00705702742561698,
0.1058952584862709,
-0.0382191427052021,
-1.0381197929382324,
0.2993946373462677,
-0.4103149175643921,
-0.10758861899375916,
0.21481113135814667,
0.34846165776252747,
-1.2904924154281616,
-0.7951914072036743,
0.7681389451026917,
0.5948270559310913,
0.44193851947784424,
0.2130468487739563,
-0.08481816202402115,
0.33681514859199524,
-0.41301050782203674,
0.18066811561584473,
0.0848366990685463,
0.40895137190818787,
0.02195434644818306,
0.1682780683040619,
0.4760739505290985,
0.5788782238960266,
0.38270264863967896,
0.21889807283878326,
0.09084416180849075,
-0.5060601830482483,
-0.8215548992156982,
-0.5612202882766724,
0.29842954874038696,
-0.005509649869054556,
-0.3577568531036377,
0.5717901587486267,
0.8914968371391296,
0.5849148631095886,
0.026292843744158745,
0.7951407432556152,
0.3360751271247864,
0.7606656551361084,
-0.5424340963363647,
0.6936460137367249,
-0.7051799893379211,
-0.013062596321105957,
-0.3992783725261688,
-0.9216631054878235,
-0.177141472697258,
0.43123480677604675,
-0.08433490246534348,
0.2614091634750366,
0.8032174110412598,
0.7853497266769409,
-0.5374586582183838,
0.14438819885253906,
0.6357789039611816,
0.057608675211668015,
-0.0020107796881347895,
0.304234117269516,
1.182112216949463,
-0.31297245621681213,
0.048109833151102066,
-0.16182993352413177,
-0.3223498463630676,
-0.34815382957458496,
-0.7445117235183716,
-0.40272417664527893,
-0.8941724300384521,
-0.15319150686264038,
-0.061291392892599106,
0.11305368691682816,
0.8575048446655273,
1.0028996467590332,
-0.5756060481071472,
-0.8309398293495178,
0.4013989567756653,
0.1526535153388977,
-0.7008708715438843,
-0.1443926841020584,
0.3506263494491577,
-0.28354519605636597,
-0.8893068432807922,
0.4333915412425995,
0.24997353553771973,
0.14866966009140015,
-0.5291074514389038,
0.12409652024507523,
-0.5219062566757202,
0.433241069316864,
0.3625245988368988,
0.23401299118995667,
-0.6095142364501953,
-0.252950519323349,
-0.28460487723350525,
0.03427915647625923,
0.2203722596168518,
0.8133365511894226,
-0.024029560387134552,
0.3699614703655243,
0.6597679853439331,
0.28933578729629517,
0.34369534254074097,
0.022544145584106445,
1.09880530834198,
-0.8935705423355103,
0.42283299565315247,
-0.3857242166996002,
0.2829815149307251,
0.2778500020503998,
-0.43479564785957336,
0.13387155532836914,
-0.15294542908668518,
-0.2152480185031891,
-0.8097532391548157,
0.08590706437826157,
-1.1954227685928345,
-0.18826676905155182,
0.9020898938179016,
0.20653897523880005,
-0.011081184260547161,
-0.34754014015197754,
0.02564903348684311,
0.2568764090538025,
-0.38289958238601685,
0.811282753944397,
0.8616306185722351,
-0.26915067434310913,
0.0842684954404831,
-0.5459936261177063,
0.3324824869632721,
0.362211674451828,
-0.6205064058303833,
-0.03694223240017891,
0.07166177034378052,
0.09120980650186539,
0.25695011019706726,
0.1214337944984436,
-0.15021942555904388,
0.10310730338096619,
0.3343642055988312,
0.5399590134620667,
0.40026476979255676,
-0.72758948802948,
-0.5339726805686951,
0.14754173159599304,
0.13367371261119843,
-0.5340240597724915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16316v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16316v1 | Does Cross-Cultural Alignment Change the Commonsense Morality of Language Models? | 2024-06-24T04:50:12 | 2024-06-24T04:50:12 | Yuu Jinnai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Alignment of the language model with human preferences is a common approach
to making a language model useful to end users. However, most alignment work is
done in English, and human preference datasets are dominated by English,
reflecting only the preferences of English-speaking annotators. Nevertheless,
it is common practice to use the English preference data, either directly or by
translating it into the target language, when aligning a multilingual language
model. The question is whether such an alignment strategy marginalizes the
preference of non-English speaking users. To this end, we investigate the
effect of aligning Japanese language models with (mostly) English resources. In
particular, we focus on evaluating whether the commonsense morality of the
resulting fine-tuned models is aligned with Japanese culture using the
JCommonsenseMorality (JCM) and ETHICS datasets. The experimental results show
that the fine-tuned model outperforms the SFT model. However, it does not
demonstrate the same level of improvement as a model fine-tuned using the JCM,
suggesting that while some aspects of commonsense morality are transferable,
others may not be. | [
-0.24093429744243622,
-0.35085374116897583,
0.4285290837287903,
-0.16665413975715637,
-0.39135101437568665,
-0.31979119777679443,
-0.3799917697906494,
-0.6595632433891296,
0.07405973225831985,
0.7618662118911743,
-0.363817423582077,
-0.18795563280582428,
-0.4894377887248993,
0.25397831201553345,
0.29599884152412415,
1.1297929286956787,
-0.015531945042312145,
0.2127852737903595,
-0.45130160450935364,
-0.7910143136978149,
-0.5339205265045166,
-0.45329543948173523,
-0.585290789604187,
-0.43047770857810974,
0.4904167950153351,
0.3864762485027313,
1.4540058374404907,
0.886920154094696,
0.4527587890625,
0.30591920018196106,
0.11126267164945602,
-0.09704969823360443,
-0.46707943081855774,
-0.20387643575668335,
-0.8401169180870056,
-0.5092129707336426,
-0.2710052728652954,
0.28565266728401184,
0.16165125370025635,
0.7109986543655396,
-0.0013655639486387372,
0.16658566892147064,
0.12364190816879272,
0.6295813322067261,
-0.7035617828369141,
-0.1857396364212036,
-0.46102187037467957,
-0.01721915602684021,
-0.20457451045513153,
-0.35615357756614685,
-0.37725046277046204,
-0.2800767719745636,
0.28589674830436707,
-0.8050583600997925,
-0.085394948720932,
0.3264801800251007,
0.8720598220825195,
0.20726288855075836,
-0.6414483785629272,
-0.21943116188049316,
-0.4138335883617401,
1.3575390577316284,
-0.7909626960754395,
0.428444504737854,
0.4738158583641052,
0.02318793162703514,
0.1435018628835678,
-0.016658294945955276,
-0.5451470613479614,
-0.11140220612287521,
-0.44987961649894714,
0.2138555645942688,
-0.12165971845388412,
-0.04093627631664276,
0.23554588854312897,
0.055993374437093735,
-0.5396138429641724,
0.48983171582221985,
-0.38741618394851685,
-0.14433668553829193,
0.8895686268806458,
0.22159677743911743,
0.7696853876113892,
-0.622763454914093,
-0.48413974046707153,
-0.12005683779716492,
-0.5918375253677368,
0.24445326626300812,
0.7357481122016907,
0.6341274380683899,
-0.30654701590538025,
0.5461246967315674,
0.045986074954271317,
0.6219365000724792,
-0.02594509907066822,
-0.34805476665496826,
0.10780233889818192,
-0.3771938681602478,
0.0024871074128896,
0.26289382576942444,
0.8884533047676086,
1.1133981943130493,
0.7134161591529846,
0.16003823280334473,
-0.027579057961702347,
0.042955975979566574,
0.3018830418586731,
-0.4868251383304596,
-0.027857564389705658,
0.08393340557813644,
-0.6332322359085083,
-0.38746580481529236,
-0.18218760192394257,
-0.33999669551849365,
-0.354667067527771,
-0.5725873708724976,
0.31360965967178345,
-0.361037015914917,
-0.45674607157707214,
0.2762216329574585,
-0.11953825503587723,
0.2515668272972107,
0.072808176279068,
-1.001542568206787,
0.023009654134511948,
0.8888939619064331,
0.6635892391204834,
-0.1695445477962494,
-0.3082086145877838,
-0.18780168890953064,
0.1862875074148178,
-0.4657832682132721,
0.34999462962150574,
-0.9890012741088867,
-0.4402746558189392,
-0.2266378551721573,
0.2507336437702179,
0.07418110966682434,
-0.19027340412139893,
0.738149881362915,
-0.17012518644332886,
0.40730586647987366,
-0.6439105272293091,
-0.3852692246437073,
-0.08092515915632248,
0.0622793585062027,
-0.6785787343978882,
0.3225569427013397,
-0.23895810544490814,
-0.8733285665512085,
0.6204479336738586,
-0.5979275107383728,
-0.4868995249271393,
-0.0711798444390297,
-0.11240369081497192,
-0.3288652300834656,
0.00805735494941473,
0.2373281866312027,
0.47001785039901733,
-0.24401606619358063,
0.5512048006057739,
-0.7515820264816284,
-0.44571778178215027,
0.41394323110580444,
-0.7334781885147095,
1.2042351961135864,
0.3279207944869995,
-0.05555072799324989,
-0.4395577609539032,
-0.4461469054222107,
-0.2986283600330353,
0.1937159299850464,
0.12536990642547607,
-1.2076600790023804,
0.016112741082906723,
0.18798384070396423,
0.3404339551925659,
0.38670432567596436,
-0.6066684722900391,
-0.0057092211209237576,
-0.19768881797790527,
0.24613431096076965,
0.9281768798828125,
-0.2413371354341507,
0.7129123210906982,
-0.589722752571106,
0.5724949836730957,
-0.07160221040248871,
0.3936787545681,
0.34197694063186646,
-0.45239758491516113,
-0.38104748725891113,
-0.04715524986386299,
0.009805314242839813,
0.49603456258773804,
-0.27729421854019165,
0.28849074244499207,
-0.32511648535728455,
-0.4103734493255615,
-0.8685293197631836,
-0.10140398144721985,
0.6372086405754089,
0.5217660665512085,
0.23927651345729828,
-0.4709886312484741,
-0.2626063823699951,
-1.2969576120376587,
-0.7709891200065613,
-0.2267676293849945,
0.3759995698928833,
0.7018774151802063,
0.066807821393013,
0.1935538947582245,
0.6950624585151672,
-0.110141821205616,
0.028154658153653145,
-0.003182358341291547,
-0.00268624909222126,
0.1515607088804245,
0.7224988341331482,
0.6786274313926697,
-1.0321813821792603,
-0.6886467337608337,
0.4881720542907715,
-0.5810272097587585,
-0.2884986400604248,
-0.0028683256823569536,
-0.27865472435951233,
0.33578649163246155,
0.08371876925230026,
-0.0726945623755455,
0.10737856477499008,
0.8410396575927734,
-0.2448418140411377,
0.25952649116516113,
0.04600077122449875,
0.6432923078536987,
-1.5243526697158813,
0.27685025334358215,
0.0574079304933548,
-0.1384987235069275,
-0.5169459581375122,
0.05913080647587776,
0.2044292539358139,
-0.017719682306051254,
-0.6332350373268127,
0.7014105319976807,
-0.15312939882278442,
-0.2571924030780792,
-0.23540695011615753,
0.09337560087442398,
0.2361440360546112,
0.1866399049758911,
0.5288036465644836,
0.9492290616035461,
0.3362257480621338,
-0.3609631061553955,
-0.026197126135230064,
0.3006468415260315,
-0.08888337016105652,
1.0254050493240356,
-0.3549044728279114,
0.04060385003685951,
-0.17972849309444427,
-0.04088257998228073,
-0.7935170531272888,
-0.10349979251623154,
0.07462324947118759,
-0.3886736333370209,
0.10798964649438858,
-0.576261043548584,
-0.12645380198955536,
0.05131824314594269,
-0.22113065421581268,
0.4520360827445984,
0.3764920234680176,
-0.5249465107917786,
0.3689526915550232,
0.43649131059646606,
-0.3224898874759674,
-1.1359626054763794,
-0.9040604829788208,
-0.3116670846939087,
-0.5062975883483887,
-0.5248395800590515,
0.15563680231571198,
0.1083299070596695,
-0.39673152565956116,
0.1170046478509903,
0.11817251145839691,
0.17411844432353973,
0.1636580228805542,
0.07287302613258362,
0.5865965485572815,
-0.20143093168735504,
-0.1407684087753296,
0.31320828199386597,
-0.20824319124221802,
-0.09904573857784271,
-0.14694586396217346,
0.31719663739204407,
-0.14823570847511292,
-0.3362182378768921,
-0.5022691488265991,
0.3998509645462036,
0.553415834903717,
-0.37923750281333923,
0.690908670425415,
0.36131882667541504,
-0.11203077435493469,
0.4558732807636261,
-0.510904848575592,
-0.05591126158833504,
-0.47577711939811707,
0.29133158922195435,
-0.25626492500305176,
-1.0127623081207275,
0.4052567481994629,
0.33910077810287476,
0.3335627615451813,
0.5064188241958618,
0.1552196890115738,
-0.332893431186676,
1.2119815349578857,
0.6663447022438049,
-0.2226698100566864,
0.28928887844085693,
0.3383813500404358,
0.40399453043937683,
-0.8644298911094666,
0.26370951533317566,
-0.6151342391967773,
-0.5341719388961792,
-1.2975062131881714,
0.040144339203834534,
0.22759690880775452,
-0.06052885204553604,
-0.27027180790901184,
0.540916919708252,
-0.30405980348587036,
0.9417953491210938,
0.16822797060012817,
-0.21568025648593903,
0.48353317379951477,
-0.08194515109062195,
-0.0025533863808959723,
-0.4736001789569855,
-0.632962703704834,
-0.7139657139778137,
1.0594679117202759,
0.0922442078590393,
0.6564729809761047,
0.38627853989601135,
0.7497966289520264,
-0.025585418567061424,
0.2294061779975891,
-0.5314016342163086,
0.2503793239593506,
-0.8710084557533264,
-0.7849289774894714,
-0.24028266966342926,
-0.47377657890319824,
-0.9022439122200012,
0.16900216042995453,
-0.07881210744380951,
-0.7462438344955444,
0.48445501923561096,
0.21435576677322388,
-0.27807289361953735,
0.44941505789756775,
-0.8249003887176514,
1.0017576217651367,
-0.37623563408851624,
-0.5846133828163147,
-0.4204433858394623,
-0.6130890846252441,
0.44957783818244934,
-0.07257995754480362,
0.3366362750530243,
-0.296100378036499,
-0.017510568723082542,
0.8052083849906921,
-0.08854391425848007,
0.8705227971076965,
-0.046236950904130936,
-0.13803230226039886,
-0.21641387045383453,
0.04882106930017471,
0.4321001470088959,
0.06109389662742615,
-0.2773112952709198,
0.34590944647789,
0.23574747145175934,
-0.5741100907325745,
-0.46658870577812195,
0.9423112273216248,
-0.9782689809799194,
-0.8676949739456177,
-0.32758158445358276,
-0.7756147384643555,
-0.33522549271583557,
0.22380264103412628,
0.16554445028305054,
0.2973680794239044,
-0.07556527853012085,
0.15921655297279358,
0.42981818318367004,
-0.41632160544395447,
0.22898127138614655,
0.7899698615074158,
-0.07304494082927704,
-0.2374306470155716,
0.818194568157196,
0.1798032522201538,
0.7585618495941162,
0.2159319967031479,
0.5130609273910522,
-0.41988590359687805,
0.15787287056446075,
-0.6829611659049988,
0.27542272210121155,
-0.6273148059844971,
-0.02415730431675911,
-0.5038113594055176,
0.12491881102323532,
-0.32219618558883667,
-0.8195287585258484,
-0.6158402562141418,
-0.3864539861679077,
0.010132984258234501,
0.07386352866888046,
0.4900989234447479,
0.35216817259788513,
-0.05626394599676132,
-0.1794334203004837,
-0.8096796274185181,
0.00015736909699626267,
0.011420968919992447,
0.47526389360427856,
-0.3425769507884979,
-0.6659400463104248,
0.008007058873772621,
0.1695527732372284,
0.08553122729063034,
-0.43782341480255127,
0.09759782254695892,
-0.3671211004257202,
0.37890687584877014,
0.5091719031333923,
0.12196426093578339,
0.9939594864845276,
-0.29307907819747925,
0.6358311176300049,
0.2845916450023651,
-0.7816081643104553,
0.20617951452732086,
-0.40402013063430786,
0.2136835753917694,
0.8630558848381042,
0.7329462766647339,
-0.8333445191383362,
-0.6097201108932495,
-0.7060731649398804,
-0.35683801770210266,
0.8602848649024963,
-0.15942758321762085,
0.5992209911346436,
0.06525713205337524,
0.031829848885536194,
0.5481153726577759,
-0.015748152509331703,
-0.7827024459838867,
-0.027827298268675804,
-0.13813629746437073,
-0.19204258918762207,
-0.03291293978691101,
0.15342558920383453,
-0.14355617761611938,
-0.04845595732331276,
0.7017650604248047,
-0.07929546386003494,
-0.1999286562204361,
-0.15508727729320526,
0.05056031048297882,
-0.37487176060676575,
0.5852207541465759,
0.3040435016155243,
0.6650252342224121,
-0.030162349343299866,
-0.18650184571743011,
0.0876728743314743,
-0.3601333796977997,
0.1641688048839569,
0.0032839865889400244,
-0.37369394302368164,
-0.3199065625667572,
0.03717971220612526,
0.7234068512916565,
0.3358895480632782,
-0.4049476683139801,
0.6350489854812622,
-0.03701635077595711,
0.046034373342990875,
0.11800510436296463,
0.1710980236530304,
0.06596271693706512,
0.0965910330414772,
-0.33532246947288513,
0.20456337928771973,
0.11062513291835785,
-0.6365521550178528,
-0.004659770987927914,
0.7729364633560181,
-0.20998987555503845,
-0.061187367886304855,
0.5202211141586304,
0.24623741209506989,
-0.05842733010649681,
0.4917200803756714,
0.07493997365236282,
-0.3771616220474243,
0.36387306451797485,
0.7371199131011963,
0.6819360256195068,
-0.38410040736198425,
0.13804207742214203,
0.4229741394519806,
0.45432499051094055,
0.04164012894034386,
0.0158243328332901,
0.0009348237654194236,
-1.1699373722076416,
-0.5091484785079956,
-0.6085792183876038,
-0.509708821773529,
-0.0900871753692627,
-1.0124784708023071,
0.3719036281108856,
-0.2615952789783478,
-0.06193696707487106,
-0.16339491307735443,
0.054968927055597305,
-0.4335078299045563,
0.2555207312107086,
0.014113925397396088,
0.3058377504348755,
-1.304276943206787,
0.8178547620773315,
0.7267259359359741,
-0.4594809412956238,
-0.8772631883621216,
0.12495391070842743,
0.039200957864522934,
-0.8588597774505615,
0.08072062581777573,
0.14282479882240295,
-0.16586260497570038,
-0.16349226236343384,
-0.4305676519870758,
-1.0152925252914429,
0.9658289551734924,
0.3267379701137543,
-0.6329770684242249,
0.33264702558517456,
0.3246210217475891,
0.42379334568977356,
-0.22423586249351501,
0.08098863065242767,
0.3878937065601349,
0.5083418488502502,
-0.2763758599758148,
-1.1230945587158203,
-0.04636562988162041,
-0.17668025195598602,
0.10835675150156021,
0.5857828855514526,
-0.9055759906768799,
0.38052934408187866,
-0.22725078463554382,
-0.2041686773300171,
-0.1367664784193039,
0.38851577043533325,
0.40858396887779236,
0.22869956493377686,
0.6567941904067993,
0.6245914101600647,
0.729891836643219,
0.17080684006214142,
1.0362221002578735,
-0.3245328366756439,
0.1817479133605957,
0.9181925654411316,
-0.5421121120452881,
0.764273464679718,
0.7618063688278198,
-0.06314609944820404,
0.2963964641094208,
0.24385647475719452,
0.10904859751462936,
0.37316977977752686,
-0.5314080715179443,
0.29164984822273254,
-0.29799023270606995,
-0.577662467956543,
-0.24921265244483948,
0.57108473777771,
0.040453989058732986,
-0.32210806012153625,
0.09542611241340637,
-0.02080061286687851,
0.5169417262077332,
0.311446875333786,
-0.3621685206890106,
0.6889504194259644,
0.061867933720350266,
-0.9951063394546509,
0.34768760204315186,
0.06777592748403549,
0.7847204804420471,
-0.46722930669784546,
0.4104751944541931,
-0.23806211352348328,
-0.17253820598125458,
-0.24146996438503265,
-1.081737995147705,
0.5098299980163574,
0.21594591438770294,
-0.09815724939107895,
-0.26310455799102783,
0.6244524717330933,
-0.5102590322494507,
-0.36203259229660034,
0.2329261153936386,
0.19470304250717163,
0.05850275233387947,
0.6008769869804382,
-0.8143782615661621,
-0.1374218761920929,
0.11595562845468521,
-0.024408550933003426,
0.5245554447174072,
0.214225172996521,
-0.4343084394931793,
0.30765098333358765,
0.9584487676620483,
-0.007933885790407658,
-0.34079885482788086,
0.12731489539146423,
0.3647206425666809,
-0.5364779829978943,
-0.48790812492370605,
-0.7794848084449768,
0.5444027781486511,
-0.16916407644748688,
-0.44894710183143616,
0.6899673938751221,
0.4932270348072052,
1.309951901435852,
0.12450127303600311,
0.7268422245979309,
-0.06285213679075241,
0.12923510372638702,
-0.7202046513557434,
0.906875729560852,
-0.9513487219810486,
0.004928083624690771,
-0.40873032808303833,
-0.7776668667793274,
-0.11729447543621063,
0.5758686661720276,
-0.6668199896812439,
0.16646833717823029,
0.5924010872840881,
0.941646158695221,
-0.3842718303203583,
0.3980793356895447,
0.5514472126960754,
-0.1192818284034729,
-0.12254729121923447,
0.48580679297447205,
0.7078171968460083,
-0.12662214040756226,
0.15448561310768127,
-0.6348081231117249,
-0.09667045623064041,
0.06368421763181686,
-0.9525482058525085,
-0.6556036472320557,
-0.5768846869468689,
-0.2543381452560425,
-0.055500295013189316,
0.10496559739112854,
1.1195402145385742,
0.27569788694381714,
-0.7218152284622192,
-0.2416001558303833,
0.1794186383485794,
-0.13175825774669647,
-0.26709577441215515,
-0.2489614635705948,
0.15841050446033478,
-0.2022789716720581,
-0.955967903137207,
0.007313945330679417,
0.44229376316070557,
-0.13212883472442627,
-0.183817058801651,
-0.31485140323638916,
-0.123848557472229,
0.21769940853118896,
0.31969186663627625,
0.10880646109580994,
-0.900178849697113,
-0.4321226179599762,
0.07711660861968994,
-0.4017032980918884,
0.11962714791297913,
0.762588381767273,
-0.2188814878463745,
0.5887512564659119,
0.34947648644447327,
0.48109161853790283,
-0.14893895387649536,
0.17713667452335358,
0.8194950819015503,
-0.4848349094390869,
0.19934624433517456,
0.09942319989204407,
0.6667282581329346,
0.5719610452651978,
-0.6115715503692627,
0.27412477135658264,
0.05581870675086975,
-0.5470366477966309,
-0.5354182720184326,
0.2347688376903534,
-0.7543286085128784,
-0.24638082087039948,
1.173125982284546,
0.10700073838233948,
-0.27895551919937134,
-0.05200737342238426,
-0.12018316239118576,
0.2727935314178467,
-0.3183557093143463,
0.5621898770332336,
0.8651942610740662,
0.18439823389053345,
-0.09563658386468887,
-0.4797864258289337,
0.3874361515045166,
0.9268643856048584,
-0.4082905650138855,
0.4356940686702728,
0.4107145369052887,
0.466586709022522,
0.1861506998538971,
0.4058809280395508,
-0.3976242244243622,
0.5749788880348206,
-0.5508213043212891,
-0.04850808158516884,
0.09866295009851456,
0.07853110879659653,
-0.3729188144207001,
-0.3321060240268707,
0.16112539172172546,
0.17629659175872803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16315v1 | Song Data Cleansing for End-to-End Neural Singer Diarization Using Neural Analysis and Synthesis Framework | 2024-06-24T04:48:29 | 2024-06-24T04:48:29 | Hokuto Munakata, Ryo Terashima, Yusuke Fujita | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We propose a data cleansing method that utilizes a neural analysis and
synthesis (NANSY++) framework to train an end-to-end neural diarization model
(EEND) for singer diarization. Our proposed model converts song data with
choral singing which is commonly contained in popular music and unsuitable for
generating a simulated dataset to the solo singing data. This cleansing is
based on NANSY++, which is a framework trained to reconstruct an input
non-overlapped audio signal. We exploit the pre-trained NANSY++ to convert
choral singing into clean, non-overlapped audio. This cleansing process
mitigates the mislabeling of choral singing to solo singing and helps the
effective training of EEND models even when the majority of available song data
contains choral singing sections. We experimentally evaluated the EEND model
trained with a dataset using our proposed method using annotated popular duet
songs. As a result, our proposed method improved 14.8 points in diarization
error rate. | [
-0.6566882729530334,
-0.5923987627029419,
-0.05417642742395401,
0.5049503445625305,
-0.17970266938209534,
0.14928710460662842,
-0.29343774914741516,
-0.7148721814155579,
0.7178385257720947,
0.5785831809043884,
-0.8184179067611694,
-0.5078823566436768,
-0.31410476565361023,
0.16165708005428314,
-0.8270209431648254,
1.0670310258865356,
0.3810817003250122,
0.2960505187511444,
-0.08464501053094864,
0.2603566348552704,
-0.37937891483306885,
-0.441322386264801,
-1.0636409521102905,
-0.060818348079919815,
0.5481275320053101,
0.51702481508255,
0.16374589502811432,
0.3291386663913727,
0.17877767980098724,
0.375316858291626,
-0.5122092366218567,
0.19109417498111725,
-0.7498290538787842,
0.38285958766937256,
0.4350825846195221,
-0.5173287391662598,
-0.8428811430931091,
0.3268320560455322,
0.452407568693161,
1.0862383842468262,
-0.3118588626384735,
0.3693171441555023,
0.01724584586918354,
0.6177775859832764,
-0.34564822912216187,
-0.31434446573257446,
-0.7557709813117981,
0.28236740827560425,
-0.1502520591020584,
-0.2424476146697998,
-0.054090194404125214,
-0.51918625831604,
0.07670995593070984,
-0.8879970908164978,
0.6720249056816101,
-0.35460054874420166,
0.6043404340744019,
0.23897841572761536,
-0.25700631737709045,
-0.028099043294787407,
-0.8929483890533447,
0.6964982748031616,
-0.5415101051330566,
0.4080894887447357,
0.642647385597229,
0.3239074945449829,
-0.0068496232852339745,
-0.44378697872161865,
-0.34891724586486816,
-0.09185339510440826,
0.29177093505859375,
0.4768918454647064,
0.20072348415851593,
0.061186276376247406,
0.18688417971134186,
0.40548059344291687,
-0.5467919707298279,
-0.1609923094511032,
-0.7815065383911133,
-0.1939956396818161,
0.7896808981895447,
-0.0849558487534523,
0.4529322385787964,
-0.08423525094985962,
-0.8255345225334167,
0.3160201907157898,
-0.7433854341506958,
0.01690530776977539,
0.5012959241867065,
0.3140026926994324,
0.12778890132904053,
0.296539306640625,
-0.24092154204845428,
0.649390697479248,
0.26276695728302,
0.18590876460075378,
0.5093498826026917,
-0.2828980088233948,
-0.32166385650634766,
0.6187356114387512,
0.2389800250530243,
0.39951369166374207,
0.2862703502178192,
-0.37087953090667725,
-0.5624045729637146,
0.21579942107200623,
0.013231152668595314,
-0.6579268574714661,
-0.4268389940261841,
0.26606303453445435,
-0.5590704083442688,
-0.2519100308418274,
-0.12881740927696228,
-0.6714116930961609,
-0.4192940294742584,
-1.0360878705978394,
0.41143038868904114,
-0.40664908289909363,
-0.5238179564476013,
0.39374905824661255,
-0.1673712581396103,
-0.3170129656791687,
0.3145466148853302,
-0.8081053495407104,
0.4544963538646698,
0.888918399810791,
0.7927643656730652,
0.17609499394893646,
-0.3019956052303314,
-0.46375882625579834,
0.11034902185201645,
-0.5470339059829712,
0.5718179941177368,
0.013624262996017933,
-0.21934545040130615,
-0.39335983991622925,
-0.2763354778289795,
-0.43831974267959595,
-0.9295135736465454,
0.2814771831035614,
-0.4360436499118805,
0.27797263860702515,
-0.2810536026954651,
-0.8326316475868225,
-0.4536967873573303,
0.12867790460586548,
-1.0777606964111328,
0.45789459347724915,
0.12461663037538528,
-0.36782461404800415,
0.5481793284416199,
-0.5780985355377197,
-0.28823649883270264,
-0.0918469950556755,
0.17223922908306122,
-0.4634719789028168,
0.337719202041626,
0.15654563903808594,
0.2624005377292633,
-0.10182467103004456,
0.3183550536632538,
-0.3323487937450409,
-0.7666457891464233,
0.05158615484833717,
-0.6172180771827698,
0.9819794297218323,
0.24413685500621796,
-0.19761225581169128,
0.1489807367324829,
-1.248612880706787,
0.16892340779304504,
-0.102247454226017,
-0.3621457815170288,
-0.28586703538894653,
-0.20185169577598572,
0.2966618537902832,
0.25311407446861267,
0.28822061419487,
-0.6787861585617065,
0.0989425852894783,
-0.47266265749931335,
0.20317746698856354,
0.555077314376831,
0.09416887909173965,
0.25341829657554626,
-0.5959565043449402,
0.5578307509422302,
-0.08903170377016068,
0.04119399935007095,
0.17305615544319153,
-0.5916982293128967,
-0.5264511108398438,
-0.4207574725151062,
0.35464996099472046,
0.4162950813770294,
-0.23173780739307404,
0.5724560618400574,
-0.17034278810024261,
-0.26185494661331177,
-0.8272517323493958,
0.13348594307899475,
0.37430882453918457,
0.6125883460044861,
0.609408974647522,
-0.42797908186912537,
-0.918524980545044,
-0.716023325920105,
0.0011675546411424875,
-0.024629367515444756,
-0.12885397672653198,
-0.16855286061763763,
0.12491796910762787,
0.23261870443820953,
0.6977802515029907,
-0.07127022743225098,
-0.6606642603874207,
-0.1400240659713745,
0.13556629419326782,
0.46138250827789307,
0.7055773735046387,
0.4533334970474243,
-0.9161147475242615,
-0.4716174602508545,
-0.2868656814098358,
-0.4403951168060303,
-0.29151880741119385,
-0.29857689142227173,
-0.14009439945220947,
-0.2601860463619232,
0.450465589761734,
-0.5207899808883667,
0.5023128986358643,
0.40943849086761475,
-0.4021926820278168,
0.6315951943397522,
0.26290184259414673,
0.4307413697242737,
-0.7879617214202881,
0.1619739979505539,
-0.2520714998245239,
-0.1374111920595169,
-1.070284366607666,
-0.26676422357559204,
-0.09365785866975784,
0.06118233874440193,
-0.3345578908920288,
-0.20741359889507294,
-0.5204384326934814,
-0.08428359776735306,
-0.36769551038742065,
-0.125751331448555,
0.1225777119398117,
0.3867078721523285,
0.3151683509349823,
0.4824887216091156,
0.5778089761734009,
-0.4325453042984009,
0.337078332901001,
0.45835575461387634,
-0.48185497522354126,
0.6071745157241821,
-0.5692768692970276,
0.07865529507398605,
-0.052800051867961884,
-0.008853578008711338,
-1.1416447162628174,
0.020689642056822777,
0.12148570269346237,
-0.5824941396713257,
0.4532923400402069,
-0.18868905305862427,
-0.262137770652771,
-0.02149168588221073,
-0.0700841099023819,
0.5230259299278259,
0.22072917222976685,
-0.7629674673080444,
0.052460722625255585,
0.10446782410144806,
-0.11643897742033005,
-0.28452029824256897,
-0.5599520802497864,
0.09078094363212585,
-0.5940518379211426,
-0.6895614266395569,
0.5020156502723694,
-0.031671226024627686,
-0.05718038231134415,
-0.179881751537323,
-0.3519548773765564,
-0.2547801733016968,
0.21231462061405182,
0.19403836131095886,
0.14878644049167633,
-0.24381569027900696,
0.09270171821117401,
-0.057576023042201996,
-0.4713425040245056,
0.08703731745481491,
-0.24655914306640625,
0.6861063241958618,
0.24557796120643616,
-0.3802538216114044,
-0.6918448209762573,
0.5326216220855713,
0.37023255228996277,
-0.2676563560962677,
0.5008935928344727,
0.6017584204673767,
-0.40109783411026,
-0.324358195066452,
-0.3358493447303772,
-0.09831617027521133,
-0.4875940680503845,
0.3915235102176666,
-0.16228845715522766,
-0.41306835412979126,
0.6142974495887756,
-0.10881006717681885,
0.01002541184425354,
0.05871695280075073,
0.0799739733338356,
-0.47164103388786316,
1.0634088516235352,
0.23393499851226807,
-0.19481594860553741,
0.41605469584465027,
-0.610240638256073,
-0.23780176043510437,
-0.9859129190444946,
-0.26455411314964294,
-0.42719632387161255,
-0.989896297454834,
0.037141457200050354,
-0.03419933095574379,
0.3852459490299225,
0.5589618682861328,
-0.3497256636619568,
0.4216945469379425,
-0.7502120137214661,
0.4542890191078186,
0.6464288234710693,
0.27727606892585754,
0.15071287751197815,
0.038563068956136703,
0.07499876618385315,
0.07408025860786438,
-0.20717065036296844,
0.07378298044204712,
1.1758676767349243,
0.08831000328063965,
0.42211541533470154,
0.08782929927110672,
1.0945909023284912,
-0.14271314442157745,
0.18745304644107819,
-0.6774107813835144,
0.5083937644958496,
-0.1635151207447052,
-0.7764216065406799,
-0.3392637073993683,
-0.609880268573761,
-0.6444683074951172,
0.21966417133808136,
-0.015172561630606651,
-0.716947078704834,
0.4483489692211151,
0.05144599452614784,
-0.2880740165710449,
0.5471813082695007,
-0.5726563930511475,
0.4177391827106476,
-0.30629444122314453,
0.18579351902008057,
0.0591575913131237,
-0.5585603713989258,
0.525745153427124,
-0.340383917093277,
0.03758906200528145,
-0.13580921292304993,
-0.0654936283826828,
0.946151077747345,
-0.46647587418556213,
0.8056954145431519,
-0.4838646948337555,
-0.17911194264888763,
0.1634194254875183,
0.10605563223361969,
0.1296091377735138,
-0.036597397178411484,
-0.11547605693340302,
0.41921335458755493,
-0.13347558677196503,
-0.2613157629966736,
-0.4936352074146271,
0.5174933671951294,
-0.6759994029998779,
-0.33727625012397766,
0.1716252714395523,
-0.552494466304779,
-0.3115047812461853,
-0.13374578952789307,
0.638978898525238,
0.4407956898212433,
0.15534169971942902,
0.34172508120536804,
0.4511954188346863,
0.018560124561190605,
0.47356048226356506,
0.35928845405578613,
-0.2541697323322296,
-0.94701087474823,
0.8333185911178589,
0.18774306774139404,
0.42213037610054016,
0.1783130168914795,
-0.1699894368648529,
-0.28196224570274353,
-0.7599610686302185,
-0.1193285807967186,
0.07102826237678528,
-0.48077037930488586,
0.009284048341214657,
-0.2487635463476181,
-0.1906820386648178,
-0.2140355259180069,
0.1934870183467865,
-0.5804621577262878,
-0.7553750872612,
-0.30750277638435364,
-0.08148839324712753,
0.42142000794410706,
0.4400879740715027,
-0.3528965711593628,
0.48781365156173706,
-0.7326003909111023,
0.6218799948692322,
-0.1743364930152893,
0.6009424924850464,
0.16793370246887207,
-0.4435252249240875,
-0.3753657937049866,
0.039587706327438354,
-0.09759384393692017,
-1.2373803853988647,
0.44588249921798706,
0.4432241916656494,
0.32983124256134033,
0.6393458247184753,
-0.16003015637397766,
1.108883261680603,
-0.467620849609375,
0.6249252557754517,
0.3905608654022217,
-0.9027649760246277,
0.3828701972961426,
-0.38928207755088806,
-0.10445807129144669,
0.8695804476737976,
0.23927311599254608,
-0.8032597303390503,
-0.25909170508384705,
-0.4117676615715027,
-1.0718189477920532,
0.5743886232376099,
0.3597217798233032,
-0.20942527055740356,
0.14491991698741913,
0.25627270340919495,
0.13170376420021057,
0.4303715229034424,
-0.31006956100463867,
-0.325014591217041,
-0.2769777476787567,
-0.14292019605636597,
-0.29581934213638306,
0.2676766812801361,
-0.10780913382768631,
-0.6034438610076904,
0.9218034148216248,
0.2729280889034271,
0.35043036937713623,
0.24121171236038208,
0.07368628680706024,
-0.3607862889766693,
-0.13165122270584106,
0.05445415899157524,
0.3591827154159546,
-0.21824151277542114,
-0.23587048053741455,
-0.22349320352077484,
-0.6498285531997681,
0.3335416615009308,
0.12363956868648529,
-0.4598730206489563,
0.011860387399792671,
0.36090391874313354,
0.5148771405220032,
0.2224442958831787,
-0.3709542751312256,
0.3869996666908264,
-0.11673164367675781,
-0.41478273272514343,
-0.5881425738334656,
0.15930336713790894,
0.5445630550384521,
-0.0011049844324588776,
0.24738922715187073,
0.4222416579723358,
0.3496171832084656,
-0.06290249526500702,
0.7475442290306091,
0.14985160529613495,
-0.566634476184845,
-0.27490177750587463,
0.9773005247116089,
-0.16118110716342926,
-0.2519380748271942,
0.7423556447029114,
-0.011987457051873207,
-0.45147404074668884,
1.0776740312576294,
0.557724118232727,
1.1111133098602295,
-0.5507271885871887,
0.08957100659608841,
0.3384898602962494,
-0.1002521887421608,
0.22966814041137695,
0.7098128795623779,
-0.28288567066192627,
-0.4504048824310303,
-0.5382188558578491,
-0.7053976655006409,
0.16988182067871094,
0.6394439935684204,
-1.0146275758743286,
0.22992199659347534,
-0.2859012186527252,
-0.0824093446135521,
0.3187929391860962,
-0.03697353973984718,
-0.3989706337451935,
0.5622806549072266,
0.3302002549171448,
0.7059858441352844,
-0.8913154006004333,
0.45777657628059387,
0.4090360701084137,
-0.5760328769683838,
-0.9285023212432861,
0.04115314409136772,
0.3007688522338867,
-0.26362237334251404,
0.582918107509613,
0.398342490196228,
0.17132532596588135,
0.009732208214700222,
-0.6050460934638977,
-0.9340146780014038,
0.7360848188400269,
0.06305288523435593,
-0.8362746238708496,
0.10940113663673401,
0.2560475170612335,
0.508537769317627,
-0.29300159215927124,
0.20454013347625732,
0.48238489031791687,
0.5214154720306396,
0.14149832725524902,
-0.8281559944152832,
-0.2529850900173187,
-0.7779524326324463,
-0.364833265542984,
0.17009776830673218,
-0.3691394627094269,
1.1951587200164795,
0.08879805356264114,
-0.13956110179424286,
0.6495782136917114,
0.4844582676887512,
0.32690170407295227,
0.6327378153800964,
0.9462260007858276,
0.678645133972168,
0.8912307024002075,
-0.13893449306488037,
0.4975578188896179,
-0.3641538619995117,
0.32587963342666626,
1.20487380027771,
-0.39493227005004883,
0.6733940839767456,
0.4464256763458252,
-0.045623138546943665,
0.12713877856731415,
0.775703489780426,
-0.18495965003967285,
0.6386504769325256,
0.43202486634254456,
-0.5417337417602539,
-0.3098627030849457,
0.23186418414115906,
-0.37803125381469727,
0.6716814041137695,
0.22998572885990143,
-0.43610671162605286,
-0.3714810907840729,
0.11288803815841675,
-0.31938865780830383,
0.1604035347700119,
-0.32370173931121826,
0.9505231976509094,
-0.06388643383979797,
-0.50572270154953,
0.954839289188385,
-0.39190196990966797,
0.502958357334137,
-0.3399506211280823,
-0.09582801163196564,
-0.09358128905296326,
0.061700087040662766,
-0.5241391062736511,
-0.2841445505619049,
0.36000093817710876,
-0.08732827752828598,
-0.25264784693717957,
-0.044423412531614304,
0.4716510474681854,
-0.8838064074516296,
-0.2575015425682068,
0.601432740688324,
0.4513433277606964,
0.3134381175041199,
-0.3432571589946747,
-0.6266043186187744,
-0.5560017824172974,
0.1907951384782791,
-0.2680373191833496,
0.1810755729675293,
0.20773208141326904,
0.16652992367744446,
0.4039590358734131,
0.9554941654205322,
0.7070214152336121,
0.2425307184457779,
0.6435367465019226,
0.5795528888702393,
-0.6821016073226929,
-0.7691136598587036,
-0.3469570577144623,
0.5724283456802368,
-0.09594345837831497,
-0.13588020205497742,
0.5612034797668457,
1.0368648767471313,
0.8187140226364136,
-0.12503767013549805,
0.7636680006980896,
0.2304883450269699,
0.9464148879051208,
-0.48918405175209045,
1.257819414138794,
-0.7236366868019104,
0.5216221809387207,
-0.3202025890350342,
-0.9541687369346619,
-0.19060072302818298,
0.3212277591228485,
-0.05315835028886795,
0.2616632580757141,
0.2933063805103302,
0.7800597548484802,
-0.42647868394851685,
0.7674926519393921,
0.3600447177886963,
-0.01450297050178051,
0.17107312381267548,
0.7735722661018372,
1.1691087484359741,
-0.31916558742523193,
0.2850953936576843,
-0.6301705241203308,
-0.11721935868263245,
0.17836232483386993,
-0.5218148231506348,
-0.5447908639907837,
-0.4729554057121277,
-0.4541224539279938,
-0.18336182832717896,
-0.11961773782968521,
0.916123628616333,
0.8047794699668884,
-1.0016933679580688,
-0.23008878529071808,
-0.32499241828918457,
-0.1274116188287735,
-0.7978900074958801,
-0.22828766703605652,
0.6148818731307983,
-0.31368592381477356,
-0.7939696311950684,
0.8851749897003174,
-0.17668674886226654,
-0.09119290858507156,
-0.056838709861040115,
-0.10281391441822052,
-0.09048127382993698,
0.0025735136587172747,
0.07388163357973099,
-0.010175884701311588,
-0.41941025853157043,
-0.09614672511816025,
-0.08168066293001175,
0.24305394291877747,
0.3358202278614044,
0.6921078562736511,
-0.6280524730682373,
0.517521321773529,
0.5482578277587891,
0.20374146103858948,
0.2871355712413788,
0.3611259162425995,
0.23807393014431,
-1.0006293058395386,
-0.24658721685409546,
0.37776750326156616,
0.38953155279159546,
0.21807990968227386,
-0.49219366908073425,
0.4054401218891144,
0.24837012588977814,
-0.39608168601989746,
-0.6600036025047302,
0.006828777492046356,
-0.9442159533500671,
-0.1667233556509018,
0.8555586338043213,
-0.13809382915496826,
-0.16648094356060028,
-0.2533339560031891,
-0.2478760927915573,
0.5741668343544006,
-0.03980052098631859,
0.8005653023719788,
0.3113551437854767,
-0.18553607165813446,
0.3047393262386322,
-0.6457565426826477,
0.7151486277580261,
0.37879252433776855,
-0.5358924269676208,
0.021775202825665474,
0.6280272603034973,
0.5227348804473877,
0.21733731031417847,
0.5089362859725952,
-0.3123980462551117,
0.7542775273323059,
-0.005338618066161871,
0.2407711148262024,
-0.4331097900867462,
-0.7637506723403931,
-0.560231626033783,
0.4060235023498535,
-0.6533303260803223,
-0.6088559031486511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16308v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16308v1 | Anomaly Detection of Tabular Data Using LLMs | 2024-06-24T04:17:03 | 2024-06-24T04:17:03 | Aodong Li, Yunhan Zhao, Chen Qiu, Marius Kloft, Padhraic Smyth, Maja Rudolph, Stephan Mandt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown their potential in long-context
understanding and mathematical reasoning. In this paper, we study the problem
of using LLMs to detect tabular anomalies and show that pre-trained LLMs are
zero-shot batch-level anomaly detectors. That is, without extra
distribution-specific model fitting, they can discover hidden outliers in a
batch of data, demonstrating their ability to identify low-density data
regions. For LLMs that are not well aligned with anomaly detection and
frequently output factual errors, we apply simple yet effective data-generating
processes to simulate synthetic batch-level anomaly detection datasets and
propose an end-to-end fine-tuning strategy to bring out the potential of LLMs
in detecting real anomalies. Experiments on a large anomaly detection benchmark
(ODDS) showcase i) GPT-4 has on-par performance with the state-of-the-art
transductive learning-based anomaly detection methods and ii) the efficacy of
our synthetic dataset and fine-tuning strategy in aligning LLMs to this task. | [
-0.2224978357553482,
-1.1738131046295166,
0.8184398412704468,
-0.1745256930589676,
-0.20231226086616516,
0.034961000084877014,
-0.24751950800418854,
-0.11909931153059006,
0.03267121687531471,
0.6341068148612976,
-0.7713935971260071,
-0.9104194045066833,
-0.4469830095767975,
0.057637836784124374,
-0.6689968705177307,
0.8920605182647705,
-0.2471562922000885,
-0.18966838717460632,
-0.18515868484973907,
0.17182426154613495,
-0.4898635745048523,
-0.5051714181900024,
-0.4494802951812744,
-0.10987719893455505,
0.23733662068843842,
0.648274302482605,
0.26765868067741394,
0.9352296590805054,
0.5549502968788147,
0.25488802790641785,
0.3045342266559601,
0.5733590722084045,
-0.477168470621109,
0.16513365507125854,
0.014795636758208275,
-0.6165193319320679,
-0.6014977097511292,
-0.325401246547699,
0.8469278216362,
0.4224666357040405,
-0.15036672353744507,
0.10121937096118927,
-0.10614387691020966,
0.5476768016815186,
-0.18270939588546753,
0.1540011167526245,
-0.9241523742675781,
0.3952025771141052,
-0.8046114444732666,
-0.4439209997653961,
-0.3204980194568634,
-0.38636884093284607,
-0.45146840810775757,
-0.40149402618408203,
0.5959369540214539,
0.23378023505210876,
0.7360238432884216,
0.2750159502029419,
-0.3255513310432434,
-0.23483887314796448,
-0.7331535816192627,
0.8594337701797485,
-0.7906607985496521,
0.36175262928009033,
0.15139882266521454,
0.2732233703136444,
-0.8329206705093384,
-0.6383101940155029,
-0.8194043636322021,
-0.1682203859090805,
0.1074242889881134,
-0.03660663217306137,
-0.25181111693382263,
-0.09420131146907806,
0.34633708000183105,
0.23826627433300018,
-1.0217055082321167,
0.578569769859314,
0.03920304402709007,
-0.19045881927013397,
0.41060692071914673,
0.43572255969047546,
0.2300155758857727,
0.197672039270401,
-0.2058013379573822,
0.1226930171251297,
-0.7934483885765076,
-0.06455015391111374,
0.453247994184494,
0.4590079188346863,
-0.29256531596183777,
0.4258618950843811,
-0.10194370150566101,
0.7171472311019897,
-0.10843930393457413,
-0.05567237362265587,
0.10400120913982391,
-0.3226173520088196,
-0.28805306553840637,
0.06519249081611633,
0.6676528453826904,
-0.07384883612394333,
0.4897613823413849,
-0.021344829350709915,
-0.34277093410491943,
0.1446210741996765,
0.0033138960134238005,
-0.48258012533187866,
-0.2286917269229889,
0.10935227572917938,
-0.1488269865512848,
-0.3535723388195038,
-0.127207949757576,
-0.60496985912323,
-0.42447513341903687,
-0.36260417103767395,
0.479865700006485,
-0.11591386795043945,
-0.12549279630184174,
0.007689688820391893,
0.1340877115726471,
-0.09560475498437881,
0.3859248459339142,
-0.8329742550849915,
0.33701929450035095,
0.6840513944625854,
0.6425361633300781,
-0.4951612651348114,
-0.36487483978271484,
-0.847734808921814,
0.1149335652589798,
-0.7284204363822937,
1.1184134483337402,
-0.4732856750488281,
-0.2839421331882477,
0.044336721301078796,
0.26873156428337097,
0.119207002222538,
-0.7907261252403259,
0.6230168342590332,
-0.2062021791934967,
-0.12169672548770905,
-0.36648744344711304,
-0.5830404162406921,
0.1773357391357422,
0.6066595911979675,
-0.3887704610824585,
0.9918450713157654,
0.2882114052772522,
-0.4159441590309143,
0.5986060500144958,
-0.637915849685669,
-0.2809528112411499,
0.21838387846946716,
-0.4196213483810425,
-0.8396413922309875,
0.1678198277950287,
0.30650627613067627,
0.4381902515888214,
-0.3200662434101105,
0.22138363122940063,
-0.29871901869773865,
-0.3930044174194336,
0.44267046451568604,
-0.6417645812034607,
0.07393811643123627,
0.006261672358959913,
-0.09891650080680847,
0.15243366360664368,
-0.5309142470359802,
0.000024574712369940244,
0.07491827011108398,
-0.31020301580429077,
0.14359894394874573,
-0.13475973904132843,
-0.32426685094833374,
0.005875918548554182,
0.07133155316114426,
-0.4636874794960022,
0.3290210962295532,
-0.0014307590899989009,
0.062371037900447845,
0.5898074507713318,
0.20806613564491272,
0.2869639992713928,
-0.21679939329624176,
0.5222305655479431,
0.7818717360496521,
-0.038868021219968796,
-0.2046293169260025,
-0.30005592107772827,
-0.42991161346435547,
-0.3697759807109833,
0.29454293847084045,
0.5938442349433899,
-0.6371275782585144,
0.5542259216308594,
-0.23788824677467346,
-0.1431194394826889,
-0.11105809360742569,
0.5663059949874878,
0.10928510874509811,
0.8762855529785156,
0.2459930181503296,
0.04179691895842552,
-0.4121752977371216,
-0.8791481256484985,
-0.7572513818740845,
0.3492852449417114,
-0.03177991136908531,
0.03804950788617134,
0.41050010919570923,
-0.4177406132221222,
0.9585456252098083,
-0.4971838891506195,
-0.541155993938446,
-0.43696358799934387,
0.11521140486001968,
0.4897945523262024,
0.49296092987060547,
0.4246393144130707,
-0.4806918799877167,
-0.5246602892875671,
0.1451461762189865,
-0.9528828263282776,
-0.2478262335062027,
-0.1110924705862999,
0.17707999050617218,
0.39164626598358154,
0.5337077975273132,
-0.40906962752342224,
0.5497485399246216,
0.297841340303421,
-0.17102807760238647,
0.30035197734832764,
-0.411255419254303,
0.011635352857410908,
-0.9173972606658936,
-0.5112383365631104,
0.36187681555747986,
-0.31096890568733215,
-1.0726803541183472,
-0.4716978669166565,
0.39506250619888306,
-0.055277351289987564,
-0.21634218096733093,
0.3485032320022583,
-0.5412006974220276,
-0.18767528235912323,
-0.31688809394836426,
0.0485931858420372,
0.00041501171654090285,
0.3784249424934387,
-0.115642249584198,
0.6516463756561279,
0.538787305355072,
-0.5034804940223694,
0.4718429446220398,
-0.11414840072393417,
-0.34103602170944214,
0.5581643581390381,
-0.08798804879188538,
-0.02249731682240963,
-0.388921856880188,
0.23531503975391388,
-0.977384626865387,
-0.3520253300666809,
0.21425551176071167,
-0.32477086782455444,
0.48940616846084595,
-0.24992844462394714,
-0.492658406496048,
-0.49762898683547974,
-0.41104158759117126,
0.37735843658447266,
0.27358072996139526,
-0.6360395550727844,
0.38444018363952637,
0.3239106237888336,
0.038847364485263824,
-0.6126719117164612,
-0.7894339561462402,
-0.007971525192260742,
-0.49057090282440186,
-0.47377845644950867,
0.09524489939212799,
0.32023102045059204,
-0.016032246872782707,
-0.05270731449127197,
-0.401398628950119,
-0.10660351067781448,
0.0498107448220253,
-0.025522790849208832,
0.1263706535100937,
-0.33276692032814026,
0.08760235458612442,
0.10278359800577164,
0.11501390486955643,
0.00481286970898509,
-0.4408000409603119,
0.6823991537094116,
-0.3034749925136566,
-0.5214083194732666,
-0.5739843845367432,
0.02162337861955166,
0.31708502769470215,
0.21885529160499573,
0.4395010769367218,
0.6329602599143982,
-0.679836094379425,
-0.49988657236099243,
-0.6269649267196655,
-0.18784736096858978,
-0.5008150339126587,
0.6297313570976257,
-0.24356943368911743,
-0.4509018063545227,
0.7439623475074768,
-0.21545282006263733,
-0.13743749260902405,
0.1621539443731308,
0.4770665764808655,
-0.15729081630706787,
0.6306872963905334,
0.3978733420372009,
-0.08635739982128143,
0.3385337293148041,
-0.34176546335220337,
0.5061815977096558,
-0.7717679738998413,
-0.21603332459926605,
-0.39591020345687866,
-0.3763475716114044,
-0.769718587398529,
-0.41745850443840027,
0.7386816143989563,
-0.10594629496335983,
-0.10041815042495728,
0.1053648591041565,
-0.11033765226602554,
0.5827776789665222,
0.3391818404197693,
0.09373775124549866,
0.29232215881347656,
0.16849872469902039,
0.22992567718029022,
-0.11839821189641953,
-0.44334715604782104,
-0.2323211282491684,
1.106176495552063,
0.25997859239578247,
0.9207910895347595,
0.042588405311107635,
0.7540532946586609,
0.6027436256408691,
0.19805683195590973,
-0.5427618622779846,
0.41175130009651184,
-0.2012789398431778,
-0.2678895890712738,
-0.6829589605331421,
-0.682031512260437,
-0.9842995405197144,
0.016925469040870667,
-0.2597154378890991,
-0.7954676151275635,
0.21802282333374023,
0.42011216282844543,
-0.20431166887283325,
0.43641397356987,
-0.7935160398483276,
0.9800612926483154,
-0.41034719347953796,
-0.4294068515300751,
0.2313101589679718,
-0.10273973643779755,
0.5942068696022034,
-0.3369934856891632,
0.3095235526561737,
-0.1960712969303131,
0.11071426421403885,
0.30911481380462646,
-0.2756519913673401,
0.5800397992134094,
-0.3557327389717102,
-0.2845257818698883,
0.2153477519750595,
0.25119444727897644,
0.8032692670822144,
0.27547284960746765,
0.06737411767244339,
0.10438062250614166,
-0.22386032342910767,
-0.3243127763271332,
-0.5754474401473999,
0.8943620324134827,
-0.3846225440502167,
-0.782980740070343,
-0.3809283673763275,
-0.8974218964576721,
-0.2805994749069214,
0.08680485934019089,
0.28464475274086,
0.6331343054771423,
0.07857991009950638,
0.20086351037025452,
0.6759241819381714,
-0.1724381446838379,
0.5427494645118713,
0.5378114581108093,
-0.023315152153372765,
0.09578923881053925,
1.0249642133712769,
0.34607693552970886,
-0.10291343182325363,
0.3860240578651428,
0.30063578486442566,
-0.4394455552101135,
-0.7433567643165588,
-0.7351911067962646,
0.06291443854570389,
-0.38716989755630493,
-0.44051593542099,
-0.3818734288215637,
-0.3134298324584961,
-0.3355807363986969,
0.18065451085567474,
-0.24376405775547028,
-0.1914360672235489,
-0.2681804895401001,
0.13123460114002228,
0.3733600676059723,
0.6149324774742126,
-0.022133443504571915,
0.390389621257782,
-0.8372673988342285,
0.33518391847610474,
0.16155914962291718,
0.21228529512882233,
-0.13940328359603882,
-0.7484049201011658,
-0.24509219825267792,
0.008965199813246727,
-0.4791688323020935,
-0.702064037322998,
0.709931492805481,
0.13812653720378876,
0.5142635703086853,
0.5619499683380127,
-0.06113439425826073,
0.6297231912612915,
-0.3647383451461792,
0.4735036790370941,
-0.1609516143798828,
-0.7186824679374695,
0.3732767105102539,
-0.6592055559158325,
0.22319617867469788,
0.14350007474422455,
0.14892587065696716,
-0.19901305437088013,
-0.21514472365379333,
-0.33996060490608215,
-0.5007032752037048,
0.7968400716781616,
0.012417495250701904,
-0.13642331957817078,
0.171800896525383,
0.5121209621429443,
0.010765988379716873,
0.46615561842918396,
-0.913401186466217,
-0.12047256529331207,
0.06731868535280228,
-0.3960917294025421,
-0.013689694926142693,
-0.06423234939575195,
-0.07332699000835419,
-0.16706594824790955,
0.3883267343044281,
-0.1192627027630806,
0.07844891399145126,
-0.014142557047307491,
-0.20774853229522705,
-0.2884095013141632,
0.31222280859947205,
0.9424960613250732,
0.6144448518753052,
-0.22636936604976654,
0.1933317333459854,
0.5599893927574158,
-0.6117487549781799,
0.17481085658073425,
-0.07382983714342117,
0.1645043045282364,
-0.036477699875831604,
0.25643473863601685,
0.6439914107322693,
-0.11106482893228531,
-0.4938635230064392,
0.4055580198764801,
-0.030383281409740448,
-0.258132666349411,
-0.5594813227653503,
0.1322307288646698,
-0.06129472330212593,
0.14833876490592957,
0.47757312655448914,
-0.276824414730072,
0.08417312055826187,
-0.9003905653953552,
0.11305166780948639,
0.8950696587562561,
0.05448721721768379,
-0.21893948316574097,
0.33367353677749634,
-0.23825670778751373,
-0.4557059109210968,
0.3401905596256256,
-0.32490628957748413,
-0.5633002519607544,
0.8588144183158875,
0.711643397808075,
0.46144866943359375,
-0.20270439982414246,
-0.06554458290338516,
-0.28281471133232117,
0.5834898352622986,
-0.10552477091550827,
0.3964554965496063,
-0.025983605533838272,
-0.9701364040374756,
-0.13450390100479126,
-0.368740439414978,
-0.39046692848205566,
0.7113553285598755,
-0.3453010320663452,
0.5253528952598572,
-0.2557540237903595,
0.045552946627140045,
-0.156309574842453,
-0.006154975853860378,
-0.6363765597343445,
0.028071625158190727,
0.10204620659351349,
0.654076099395752,
-1.0074328184127808,
0.8374336361885071,
0.3260252773761749,
0.19050848484039307,
-0.6469820737838745,
0.16862072050571442,
0.03438153490424156,
-0.7515451312065125,
0.4898814857006073,
-0.002968946471810341,
0.2289002388715744,
-0.052511971443891525,
-0.21630585193634033,
-0.8211011290550232,
0.9001138210296631,
0.4410130977630615,
-0.8856242895126343,
0.0681334063410759,
0.6039890646934509,
0.4560527503490448,
-0.2575349509716034,
0.06925810128450394,
1.0818266868591309,
0.517516553401947,
-0.21762984991073608,
-0.5201123952865601,
-0.01059158705174923,
0.16653792560100555,
-0.2201242744922638,
0.7131513357162476,
-0.25290030241012573,
0.9054370522499084,
-0.03871205076575279,
0.0536302849650383,
-0.3175535202026367,
0.4166712164878845,
0.3615516424179077,
0.7229111790657043,
0.3066897988319397,
0.7195188403129578,
0.9415889382362366,
-0.33278873562812805,
0.6804365515708923,
-0.16282084584236145,
0.13263648748397827,
0.8986119627952576,
-0.5863113403320312,
0.37440821528434753,
0.08082520216703415,
0.08774507790803909,
0.3433438539505005,
0.5785099267959595,
-0.1686088740825653,
0.40368062257766724,
0.4535693824291229,
-0.32426774501800537,
-0.22923824191093445,
0.22380372881889343,
-0.42564988136291504,
0.3255250155925751,
0.8702558279037476,
-0.016954824328422546,
-0.4947175085544586,
-0.12741497159004211,
-0.01464258786290884,
0.0018692006124183536,
-0.5174742937088013,
0.5644887685775757,
0.026416266337037086,
-0.36424368619918823,
0.6283893585205078,
-0.08398094773292542,
0.4601951539516449,
-0.25975534319877625,
-0.0727066770195961,
-0.5138815641403198,
0.3118061125278473,
-0.40819051861763,
-0.6557738780975342,
0.016938067972660065,
0.2267632931470871,
-0.028698205947875977,
0.05912288650870323,
0.672484278678894,
-0.5031653046607971,
-0.5057178139686584,
-0.17335419356822968,
0.6196379661560059,
0.2625778913497925,
0.08714709430932999,
-0.15417784452438354,
0.01051357202231884,
-0.12414567172527313,
-0.09397342801094055,
0.4829142987728119,
0.9162393808364868,
-0.5202061533927917,
0.5223727822303772,
0.7140858769416809,
0.3479393720626831,
0.06747621297836304,
0.27482518553733826,
0.7726138830184937,
-0.6439154148101807,
-0.3826359510421753,
-1.2170450687408447,
0.05630271136760712,
-0.21668894588947296,
-0.10145534574985504,
0.6626111268997192,
0.7916358709335327,
0.6082227826118469,
-0.2749567925930023,
0.6956049203872681,
0.564233660697937,
0.5608448386192322,
-0.7900303602218628,
0.529312789440155,
-0.3614608645439148,
0.6520656943321228,
-0.08266232907772064,
-0.8989105820655823,
-0.38196974992752075,
0.244526669383049,
-0.2733679711818695,
0.03782176226377487,
0.674530029296875,
0.9965000748634338,
-0.28509747982025146,
-0.07505521923303604,
0.5259146690368652,
0.4378903806209564,
0.40196409821510315,
0.4133390486240387,
0.9611200094223022,
-0.21902072429656982,
0.3580567538738251,
0.12635909020900726,
-0.2110268622636795,
-0.1817767322063446,
-1.0247411727905273,
-1.041296362876892,
-0.22613205015659332,
0.036094240844249725,
-0.03345262631773949,
0.16175881028175354,
0.8901461362838745,
0.48165640234947205,
-1.0091010332107544,
-0.3132416307926178,
-0.4800746440887451,
0.2472224086523056,
0.07144802808761597,
-0.2643148899078369,
0.2946837544441223,
-0.44387075304985046,
-0.6378504633903503,
0.7255151867866516,
0.3035511076450348,
0.3524550795555115,
-0.13988351821899414,
0.30614393949508667,
0.17020873725414276,
0.05194155499339104,
0.2601809501647949,
0.33807894587516785,
-0.4691430330276489,
-0.23381821811199188,
0.034125398844480515,
0.2713451683521271,
0.1692809760570526,
0.8321935534477234,
-0.6468442678451538,
0.03814571350812912,
0.297184556722641,
0.5612950921058655,
0.6933925747871399,
0.21635596454143524,
0.49485334753990173,
-0.9692518711090088,
0.30649396777153015,
0.12491516768932343,
0.516607403755188,
0.15663468837738037,
-0.6344863176345825,
0.23096852004528046,
0.18669961392879486,
-0.750769317150116,
-1.4603174924850464,
0.16867893934249878,
-0.6553165912628174,
0.02817203849554062,
0.8484300971031189,
-0.0042886375449597836,
-0.10663826763629913,
-0.1420886069536209,
0.28034156560897827,
0.2120213359594345,
-0.4133351445198059,
0.9324752688407898,
0.4853171110153198,
-0.6005216240882874,
0.051647018641233444,
-0.630795419216156,
0.7229414582252502,
0.1454988420009613,
-1.1979622840881348,
0.12219571322202682,
0.16526909172534943,
0.33104196190834045,
-0.09728651493787766,
0.19538384675979614,
0.06316859275102615,
0.3071276843547821,
-0.3001311421394348,
-0.24704688787460327,
-0.17647282779216766,
-0.5745174288749695,
-0.4885709583759308,
-0.1428845226764679,
-0.007168747950345278,
-0.2153371423482895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16306v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16306v1 | Cascade Reward Sampling for Efficient Decoding-Time Alignment | 2024-06-24T04:08:35 | 2024-06-24T04:08:35 | Bolian Li, Yifan Wang, Ananth Grama, Ruqi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences is critical for
their deployment. Recently, decoding-time alignment has emerged as an effective
plug-and-play technique that requires no fine-tuning of model parameters.
However, generating text that achieves both high reward and high likelihood
remains a significant challenge. Existing methods often fail to generate
high-reward text or incur substantial computational costs. In this paper, we
propose Cascade Reward Sampling (CARDS) to address both issues, guaranteeing
the generation of high-reward and high-likelihood text with significantly low
costs. Based on our analysis of reward models (RMs) on incomplete text and our
observation that high-reward prefixes induce high-reward complete text, we use
rejection sampling to iteratively generate small semantic segments to form such
prefixes. The segment length is dynamically determined by the predictive
uncertainty of LLMs. This strategy guarantees desirable prefixes for subsequent
generations and significantly reduces wasteful token re-generations and the
number of reward model scoring. Our experiments demonstrate substantial gains
in both generation efficiency and alignment ratings compared to the baselines,
achieving five times faster text generation and 99\% win-ties in GPT-4/Claude-3
helpfulness evaluation. | [
-0.14791032671928406,
-0.18113303184509277,
0.44552332162857056,
0.3887682557106018,
-0.38003429770469666,
0.12837082147598267,
-0.2958081364631653,
-0.2746100127696991,
0.35815197229385376,
0.22725622355937958,
-0.756026029586792,
-0.41034337878227234,
-0.5534312129020691,
0.02076462097465992,
-0.1859520524740219,
1.2266134023666382,
0.05635374039411545,
-0.26655828952789307,
-0.10925258696079254,
0.15908099710941315,
-0.6161225438117981,
-0.4070586562156677,
-0.7926814556121826,
-0.33693331480026245,
0.8544007539749146,
0.35364559292793274,
0.623364269733429,
0.9915332198143005,
0.4011591970920563,
0.15111234784126282,
-0.12614791095256805,
0.18404129147529602,
-0.5432168245315552,
0.1837567836046219,
-0.16934499144554138,
-0.14681687951087952,
-0.6924060583114624,
0.10061128437519073,
0.5493945479393005,
0.40578168630599976,
-0.3675503134727478,
0.18821625411510468,
0.222978413105011,
0.5572943091392517,
-0.9414828419685364,
-0.07503857463598251,
-0.9027411341667175,
0.015459943562746048,
-0.5930988192558289,
-0.7054879665374756,
-0.4752793312072754,
-0.42714348435401917,
-0.07816251367330551,
-0.7654829621315002,
0.14933638274669647,
0.11594079434871674,
1.0066789388656616,
0.24993163347244263,
-0.2862522304058075,
-0.46400901675224304,
-0.5186581015586853,
1.0460941791534424,
-0.6380086541175842,
0.015978330746293068,
0.3306833803653717,
0.20214027166366577,
-0.2327156960964203,
-0.34498700499534607,
-0.6796164512634277,
0.10331441462039948,
0.06366004049777985,
0.20764879882335663,
-0.06645219027996063,
-0.11298000067472458,
0.13360090553760529,
0.4333782196044922,
-0.41869044303894043,
0.3109019994735718,
0.22288157045841217,
-0.19879621267318726,
0.5910166501998901,
0.4276532828807831,
0.18307332694530487,
-0.5205751061439514,
-0.4715050458908081,
-0.41113603115081787,
-0.6909167766571045,
0.23021411895751953,
0.6010465025901794,
0.48098981380462646,
-0.09637655317783356,
0.6816254258155823,
-0.11385495960712433,
0.713618814945221,
0.2752925157546997,
-0.40978753566741943,
0.17984503507614136,
-0.5861883759498596,
-0.07555850595235825,
0.19088183343410492,
0.74945068359375,
0.34128648042678833,
0.06126986816525459,
-0.17526720464229584,
-0.2869931757450104,
0.005075159948319197,
0.21913345158100128,
-0.6781070232391357,
0.1775149554014206,
0.3481636941432953,
-0.49168214201927185,
-0.5494652390480042,
-0.2209111750125885,
-0.630719006061554,
-0.21836930513381958,
-0.3414801359176636,
0.14055198431015015,
-0.3935438394546509,
0.0753679946064949,
0.1680164635181427,
-0.3715420067310333,
0.36431723833084106,
0.27283361554145813,
-1.1613984107971191,
-0.04023106023669243,
0.7419964075088501,
0.732458770275116,
-0.47936034202575684,
-0.41256240010261536,
-1.1003085374832153,
0.5294016599655151,
-0.2127753347158432,
0.7473922371864319,
-0.5264430046081543,
-0.3590669631958008,
0.09271451830863953,
-0.2663722038269043,
0.21175165474414825,
-0.4277968406677246,
0.859197199344635,
-0.6059916019439697,
0.04203057661652565,
-0.41372454166412354,
-0.4635542631149292,
0.673551619052887,
0.40882983803749084,
-0.682172954082489,
1.0479992628097534,
0.161817267537117,
-0.9317670464515686,
0.6299002170562744,
-0.206471785902977,
-0.5284184813499451,
0.255209356546402,
-0.15115149319171906,
-0.45187124609947205,
0.12719306349754333,
0.573639452457428,
0.3538188338279724,
-0.4046931564807892,
0.40980052947998047,
-0.021581169217824936,
-0.45923081040382385,
0.23992635309696198,
-0.5960924625396729,
0.4816567897796631,
0.2900005578994751,
-0.4643644690513611,
0.0603802353143692,
-0.5395142436027527,
0.05673868581652641,
-0.09489741176366806,
-0.7445579171180725,
-0.3247184753417969,
0.22223587334156036,
0.037713006138801575,
0.1504635065793991,
0.1944749802350998,
-0.6190927028656006,
0.49952685832977295,
-0.2936669588088989,
0.06001714989542961,
0.9505587220191956,
-0.07875239104032516,
0.5455960035324097,
-0.4492524564266205,
0.4951622784137726,
0.1660718470811844,
-0.00299095269292593,
-0.19393600523471832,
-0.19772563874721527,
-0.5334928035736084,
-0.5281393527984619,
0.619648814201355,
0.36805203557014465,
-0.8108446598052979,
0.785139262676239,
-0.7786065340042114,
-0.2566792964935303,
-0.687892735004425,
-0.06753439456224442,
0.17500710487365723,
0.31428974866867065,
0.42813876271247864,
-0.1262395679950714,
-0.27984070777893066,
-0.7897382378578186,
-0.3502093553543091,
0.06369534134864807,
-0.24870507419109344,
0.18320909142494202,
0.10721904039382935,
0.10151413083076477,
1.0254640579223633,
-0.5300880670547485,
-0.41108599305152893,
-0.1608959436416626,
0.2874228060245514,
0.1490316390991211,
0.5255211591720581,
0.2376776933670044,
-0.487543523311615,
-0.30694785714149475,
-0.23441381752490997,
-0.22972553968429565,
0.055346809327602386,
-0.3571730852127075,
-0.4460699260234833,
0.20623520016670227,
0.08965562283992767,
-0.5749843120574951,
0.3539436161518097,
0.5435789227485657,
-0.28716710209846497,
0.2428101748228073,
-0.10188919305801392,
0.2140004187822342,
-1.1535102128982544,
0.2549486458301544,
-0.2159186154603958,
-0.08000626415014267,
-0.29838988184928894,
-0.39736124873161316,
0.11631157249212265,
0.10243360698223114,
-0.20561712980270386,
0.668286144733429,
-0.44627636671066284,
0.15755218267440796,
-0.43006062507629395,
0.11123958975076675,
-0.07590054720640182,
0.4586487114429474,
0.2558600604534149,
0.47502341866493225,
0.06130964681506157,
-0.6201190948486328,
0.07417488098144531,
0.25086262822151184,
-0.41171661019325256,
0.8225539326667786,
-0.39609163999557495,
-0.03913033381104469,
-0.20999914407730103,
0.5990985035896301,
-0.7218872904777527,
-0.4047611951828003,
0.13942301273345947,
-0.5369424819946289,
0.3252953290939331,
0.0010239832336083055,
-0.31508010625839233,
-0.19511805474758148,
-0.41201716661453247,
0.8621062636375427,
0.6580899357795715,
-0.8062655925750732,
0.3436131775379181,
0.37677112221717834,
-0.24657198786735535,
-1.1196227073669434,
-0.6279991269111633,
-0.012276176363229752,
-0.17289257049560547,
-0.3456423878669739,
0.7768104076385498,
0.1217656284570694,
0.3240366578102112,
0.06239129602909088,
0.03943252936005592,
0.6213662624359131,
-0.08278898894786835,
0.11858967691659927,
0.3320915400981903,
0.0993061438202858,
0.07508452981710434,
0.17137748003005981,
-0.33924999833106995,
-0.3633427321910858,
-0.5770499110221863,
0.6170973181724548,
0.46750977635383606,
-0.4055672883987427,
-0.37305521965026855,
0.4638354182243347,
0.3288221061229706,
-0.3202931880950928,
0.6286194920539856,
0.6177155375480652,
-0.33575570583343506,
-0.30611178278923035,
-0.4922559857368469,
0.001892311149276793,
-0.419952929019928,
0.23102937638759613,
-0.29214513301849365,
-0.8055499792098999,
0.15251277387142181,
0.2715393602848053,
0.26938769221305847,
0.4256415367126465,
0.7022250294685364,
0.02272266149520874,
1.089341402053833,
0.24867373704910278,
-0.3659915328025818,
0.4176844656467438,
0.15691225230693817,
0.19574159383773804,
-0.7360808253288269,
-0.30325278639793396,
-0.6506970524787903,
-0.5504894852638245,
-0.4734843969345093,
-0.4200945198535919,
0.15653707087039948,
0.09680891036987305,
-0.14452975988388062,
0.02445354498922825,
-0.5964810848236084,
0.4120696187019348,
0.7400100827217102,
-0.1370067596435547,
0.2918004095554352,
0.4398399293422699,
0.015069412998855114,
-0.09482264518737793,
-0.6615880727767944,
-0.3999498188495636,
0.8657056093215942,
0.1652083545923233,
0.9473915100097656,
0.06709973514080048,
0.8914055228233337,
0.1875779777765274,
0.3149619400501251,
-0.7601372599601746,
0.22198854386806488,
-0.12030269205570221,
-0.26164838671684265,
-0.3552475571632385,
-0.6172472834587097,
-1.1251766681671143,
-0.013847524300217628,
-0.33256927132606506,
-0.6659566164016724,
0.1393686830997467,
0.4045451283454895,
-0.4539906680583954,
0.32208892703056335,
-0.09910748898983002,
0.7645809054374695,
-0.08740128576755524,
-0.34766197204589844,
0.05047912523150444,
-0.5289946794509888,
0.3622162938117981,
-0.003580197924748063,
0.08848313987255096,
-0.2351352721452713,
-0.04292231798171997,
0.6709364652633667,
-0.45501774549484253,
0.57396000623703,
-0.10587167739868164,
-0.3283868432044983,
0.21504171192646027,
0.0892656072974205,
0.7842828035354614,
0.023136574774980545,
-0.1083853468298912,
-0.1931496262550354,
-0.15359579026699066,
-0.6661837697029114,
-0.3574588894844055,
0.8389708399772644,
-0.5462300181388855,
-0.3327508568763733,
-0.5498230457305908,
-0.8329757452011108,
-0.12245921045541763,
0.08391651511192322,
0.6427433490753174,
0.45265552401542664,
-0.04308400675654411,
-0.14284493029117584,
0.32567939162254333,
-0.27065879106521606,
0.6128890514373779,
0.031396180391311646,
0.09049361199140549,
-0.636169970035553,
1.1037801504135132,
-0.24449381232261658,
0.3075302839279175,
0.6054725646972656,
0.05099807307124138,
-0.44360774755477905,
-0.34065768122673035,
-0.5263609290122986,
0.2148522138595581,
-0.34199845790863037,
-0.5096896290779114,
-0.43632951378822327,
-0.10387309640645981,
-0.42732521891593933,
-0.3835010528564453,
-0.37483882904052734,
-0.3606644868850708,
-0.10608691722154617,
0.08607204258441925,
0.05578557401895523,
0.48573851585388184,
-0.11065667122602463,
0.39495930075645447,
-0.966964602470398,
0.14629095792770386,
0.14007116854190826,
0.31115350127220154,
0.23470132052898407,
-0.3255164623260498,
-0.17430612444877625,
0.04112539812922478,
-0.3743324279785156,
-0.5241603851318359,
0.4080411195755005,
-0.1637711226940155,
0.3536383807659149,
0.13932575285434723,
0.17228096723556519,
0.7781497836112976,
-0.513312041759491,
0.9725545048713684,
0.3959435224533081,
-1.0550270080566406,
0.24793487787246704,
-0.3536377549171448,
0.5016219615936279,
0.6130866408348083,
0.20068293809890747,
-0.7933163642883301,
-0.32869186997413635,
-0.6084718704223633,
-0.9233208894729614,
0.9522294998168945,
0.40801870822906494,
0.07394253462553024,
-0.35288572311401367,
0.3619021475315094,
0.058067552745342255,
0.15060164034366608,
-0.6716896295547485,
-0.06901732087135315,
-0.005723875947296619,
-0.6968113780021667,
-0.17667321860790253,
-0.35159745812416077,
-0.14844787120819092,
0.14565128087997437,
0.689701497554779,
-0.19252754747867584,
0.2663777470588684,
-0.022082623094320297,
0.07388000935316086,
-0.23716218769550323,
0.38747701048851013,
0.6179513931274414,
0.21087080240249634,
-0.16204208135604858,
0.27556341886520386,
-0.07785329967737198,
-0.3910043239593506,
0.38848942518234253,
-0.04047125205397606,
-0.2362052947282791,
-0.11396806687116623,
0.3688738942146301,
0.8538761734962463,
0.07536087930202484,
-0.5341237187385559,
0.7495075464248657,
-0.1599380522966385,
-0.08670621365308762,
-0.08135362714529037,
-0.221622034907341,
0.24289193749427795,
-0.045369431376457214,
0.2665080428123474,
-0.06511027365922928,
-0.22967536747455597,
-0.33093634247779846,
0.036945149302482605,
0.7119969725608826,
-0.2699563801288605,
-0.07185062021017075,
0.5663606524467468,
0.16807323694229126,
-0.2957207262516022,
0.9494840502738953,
-0.26089784502983093,
-0.2408837527036667,
0.32822200655937195,
0.6356372833251953,
0.7171933054924011,
-0.08640781790018082,
0.20955593883991241,
0.49586743116378784,
0.06734438240528107,
-0.24105527997016907,
0.07323608547449112,
-0.2187962830066681,
-0.6189981698989868,
-0.5631698369979858,
-1.0233352184295654,
-0.08891342580318451,
0.08606672286987305,
-0.7010248303413391,
0.41268953680992126,
0.10113687813282013,
-0.2138272374868393,
-0.21476924419403076,
-0.34238100051879883,
-0.5286972522735596,
0.03491230681538582,
0.24267356097698212,
0.9562839865684509,
-0.6933637261390686,
0.7228440642356873,
0.22388602793216705,
-0.2541852593421936,
-1.075903058052063,
0.18879128992557526,
-0.04589177668094635,
-0.5422484874725342,
0.6957204341888428,
0.06137838587164879,
-0.16501367092132568,
0.1334703266620636,
-0.42443355917930603,
-0.8901253938674927,
1.1171362400054932,
0.2028772085905075,
-0.44566577672958374,
-0.4408409893512726,
0.2912217974662781,
0.14664031565189362,
-0.4025780260562897,
0.2946416139602661,
0.5961583256721497,
0.3626042306423187,
0.4555373191833496,
-0.6999416351318359,
0.22119256854057312,
-0.0982356071472168,
0.1948554962873459,
0.43624451756477356,
-0.36986732482910156,
0.6852369904518127,
0.060491640120744705,
-0.4717029929161072,
0.3257136642932892,
0.6912649869918823,
0.676910936832428,
0.09705010056495667,
0.6266644597053528,
0.6295346021652222,
0.8951370716094971,
-0.159258171916008,
1.2201343774795532,
-0.21831250190734863,
0.28324511647224426,
1.0774414539337158,
-0.20684859156608582,
0.9587132334709167,
0.7186100482940674,
0.16050267219543457,
0.44822239875793457,
0.762745201587677,
0.2502592206001282,
0.5701170563697815,
0.4127686321735382,
-0.24472089111804962,
-0.45269060134887695,
-0.23343543708324432,
-0.28890734910964966,
0.19095812737941742,
0.14071567356586456,
-0.12904393672943115,
-0.2938973307609558,
-0.09352704137563705,
-0.020741963759064674,
-0.1937524974346161,
-0.24076984822750092,
0.5840024352073669,
-0.08212630450725555,
-1.2790786027908325,
0.5850262641906738,
0.09610940515995026,
0.8723757863044739,
-0.6848785281181335,
0.08358469605445862,
-0.2629665732383728,
0.30363526940345764,
-0.21498043835163116,
-0.6890980005264282,
-0.05183061957359314,
0.06074358895421028,
-0.26787641644477844,
-0.2437012493610382,
0.2958839237689972,
-0.7103621959686279,
-0.2770448327064514,
-0.058066580444574356,
0.1568649411201477,
-0.03204198181629181,
0.061075203120708466,
-0.34237053990364075,
0.18808205425739288,
-0.07716179639101028,
-0.25394293665885925,
0.39973723888397217,
0.2165694534778595,
-0.07609213888645172,
0.23000842332839966,
0.5414136052131653,
0.28565385937690735,
0.046110183000564575,
0.04968511685729027,
0.6207000613212585,
-0.7045538425445557,
-0.5862523913383484,
-1.000685214996338,
0.6659514307975769,
-0.24729712307453156,
-0.35599619150161743,
0.5180270671844482,
0.7442830801010132,
0.78555828332901,
-0.02538474090397358,
0.7371941804885864,
-0.07749583572149277,
0.353427529335022,
-0.7472280263900757,
0.3506532311439514,
-0.7696804404258728,
0.34273943305015564,
-0.38864198327064514,
-0.9690943360328674,
-0.18067289888858795,
0.16552837193012238,
-0.11779267340898514,
-0.22989344596862793,
0.6313486099243164,
0.6841378808021545,
-0.15829609334468842,
-0.0005623903125524521,
-0.0623997338116169,
-0.49051007628440857,
0.5545236468315125,
1.0059430599212646,
1.068019151687622,
-0.2293662428855896,
0.61952805519104,
-0.022678202018141747,
-0.3536265790462494,
-0.11032750457525253,
-1.1480447053909302,
-0.5246041417121887,
-0.5650281310081482,
-0.10102923959493637,
-0.5991655588150024,
-0.2867223024368286,
1.0251638889312744,
0.6433837413787842,
-0.5017114877700806,
-0.2710541784763336,
0.09548670053482056,
0.0400935597717762,
-0.2998308539390564,
-0.196797713637352,
0.6151494979858398,
-0.710755467414856,
-0.968532919883728,
0.15471160411834717,
0.2480345219373703,
0.061816129833459854,
0.07728460431098938,
-0.2961812913417816,
-0.0673522800207138,
0.053785908967256546,
0.38012465834617615,
0.1861446052789688,
-0.6749400496482849,
-0.25632724165916443,
0.11572088301181793,
-0.4940046966075897,
0.09303382784128189,
1.1784459352493286,
-0.6944111585617065,
0.06106534227728844,
0.5592491030693054,
0.9784116148948669,
0.5639138221740723,
0.4026983082294464,
0.6524034142494202,
-0.8990982174873352,
-0.04983031004667282,
0.21749135851860046,
0.12781943380832672,
0.28604671359062195,
-0.4587858021259308,
0.156772181391716,
0.09600149840116501,
-0.583362340927124,
-0.8661291599273682,
0.3326355516910553,
-1.1809238195419312,
-0.0939541906118393,
1.1748979091644287,
0.1324700266122818,
-0.421256422996521,
0.3061562776565552,
-0.22342298924922943,
0.36035728454589844,
-0.3689176142215729,
0.6545597314834595,
0.6783173680305481,
-0.06092927232384682,
0.42776575684547424,
0.011884112842381,
0.7907401323318481,
0.7102869153022766,
-0.7809907793998718,
0.2773682177066803,
0.39555492997169495,
0.10491550713777542,
0.2040499895811081,
0.8606716990470886,
-0.17954371869564056,
0.19783271849155426,
-0.0915585309267044,
0.26753225922584534,
0.14789819717407227,
-0.1547309160232544,
-0.32187581062316895,
0.2758384943008423,
0.22128546237945557,
-0.15408770740032196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17808v1 | Training-Free Exponential Extension of Sliding Window Context with Cascading KV Cache | 2024-06-24T03:59:17 | 2024-06-24T03:59:17 | Jeffrey Willette, Heejun Lee, Youngwan Lee, Myeongjae Jeon, Sung Ju Hwang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The context window within a transformer provides a form of active memory for
the current task, which can be useful for few-shot learning and conditional
generation, both which depend heavily on previous context tokens. However, as
the context length grows, the computational cost increases quadratically.
Recent works have shown that saving a few initial tokens along with a
fixed-sized sliding window leads to stable streaming generation with linear
complexity in transformer-based Large Language Models (LLMs). However, they
make suboptimal use of the fixed window by naively evicting all tokens
unconditionally from the key-value (KV) cache once they reach the end of the
window, resulting in tokens being forgotten and no longer able to affect
subsequent predictions. To overcome this limitation, we propose a novel
mechanism for storing longer sliding window contexts with the same total cache
size by keeping separate cascading sub-cache buffers whereby each subsequent
buffer conditionally accepts a fraction of the relatively more important tokens
evicted from the previous buffer. Our method results in a dynamic KV cache that
can store tokens from the more distant past than a fixed, static sliding window
approach. Our experiments show improvements of 5.6% on long context generation
(LongBench), 1.2% in streaming perplexity (PG19), and 0.6% in language
understanding (MMLU STEM) using LLMs given the same fixed cache size.
Additionally, we provide an efficient implementation that improves the KV cache
latency from 1.33ms per caching operation to 0.54ms, a 59% speedup over
previous work. | [
-0.22324667870998383,
-0.5185567140579224,
0.3619552552700043,
0.34765443205833435,
-0.4618285298347473,
-0.007211518939584494,
-0.5230642557144165,
-0.33891305327415466,
0.3359224200248718,
0.24336333572864532,
-0.6142353415489197,
-0.2886430323123932,
-0.36899709701538086,
-0.39027678966522217,
-0.3755939304828644,
0.9606515765190125,
-0.28736376762390137,
-0.1584109663963318,
-0.15903747081756592,
-0.23259039223194122,
-0.4658313989639282,
-0.12472385913133621,
-0.6233924627304077,
-0.17099885642528534,
0.5528128147125244,
0.14013054966926575,
0.3637451231479645,
0.46576032042503357,
0.09372438490390778,
0.16296584904193878,
0.03372295945882797,
-0.019854137673974037,
-0.5508133172988892,
0.34178775548934937,
0.1567082405090332,
-0.730306088924408,
-0.5644940733909607,
-0.35974714159965515,
0.7068811058998108,
0.12952390313148499,
-0.18498042225837708,
0.022076087072491646,
-0.14198316633701324,
0.5130300521850586,
-0.9905823469161987,
0.3324940800666809,
-0.8481329083442688,
0.28144195675849915,
-0.20033390820026398,
-0.3233805298805237,
-0.751129150390625,
0.07813998311758041,
0.16154737770557404,
-0.5101494193077087,
0.20602378249168396,
-0.5311005711555481,
0.8212035894393921,
0.47085040807724,
-0.5378986597061157,
0.08191793411970139,
-0.6865050196647644,
0.6516494154930115,
-0.5947540402412415,
0.4071422815322876,
0.005340600851923227,
0.5238077640533447,
-0.1321461945772171,
-0.9383602738380432,
-0.4459705054759979,
-0.004327654372900724,
0.08274107426404953,
0.3003879189491272,
-0.18278954923152924,
0.06078973412513733,
0.17839640378952026,
0.10353246331214905,
-0.3268851935863495,
0.21102552115917206,
-0.28121161460876465,
-0.39129018783569336,
0.2052585929632187,
0.34087279438972473,
0.00015060833538882434,
0.09623164683580399,
-0.5121248364448547,
-0.12094645947217941,
-1.0867050886154175,
0.2788703739643097,
0.05950307101011276,
0.27191880345344543,
-0.13355322182178497,
0.07161222398281097,
-0.10729612410068512,
0.205592542886734,
0.16700246930122375,
-0.13823570311069489,
0.24775779247283936,
-0.15102316439151764,
-0.12233947962522507,
0.04227466136217117,
0.36270129680633545,
0.32080355286598206,
-0.02580784447491169,
-0.1599973440170288,
-0.0716979056596756,
0.03496629372239113,
0.30673837661743164,
-1.0211936235427856,
-0.16703391075134277,
-0.05200077220797539,
-0.17396734654903412,
-0.17936305701732635,
-0.11582311242818832,
-0.6110233068466187,
0.17763389647006989,
0.0010295568499714136,
0.3742993175983429,
-0.1480463296175003,
0.013376244343817234,
-0.13755914568901062,
-0.03132173418998718,
0.32631948590278625,
0.4038107693195343,
-0.9259964227676392,
0.31461405754089355,
0.5236502289772034,
0.8612464070320129,
-0.485085129737854,
-0.1412733942270279,
-0.9557510614395142,
0.21515324711799622,
-0.22980952262878418,
0.20595088601112366,
-0.5848931074142456,
-0.45553305745124817,
0.16589754819869995,
0.2817235589027405,
0.08135437220335007,
-0.13963733613491058,
0.129693865776062,
-0.9161851406097412,
0.1954493522644043,
-0.19423510134220123,
-0.37380990386009216,
0.053805891424417496,
-0.06522295624017715,
-0.6287587881088257,
1.2251096963882446,
0.04714927822351456,
-0.6169580221176147,
0.6135500073432922,
-0.5367961525917053,
-0.35918518900871277,
0.10754162073135376,
-0.13637703657150269,
-0.48923397064208984,
0.2573261857032776,
0.27059420943260193,
0.22329729795455933,
-0.007818437181413174,
0.459932804107666,
-0.001436530495993793,
-0.39986756443977356,
-0.04723353311419487,
-0.8532081842422485,
0.3542988896369934,
-0.07854016870260239,
-0.6599817276000977,
-0.00370466778986156,
-0.6912195086479187,
-0.1006777435541153,
-0.2911130487918854,
-0.6894022822380066,
-0.3719770610332489,
-0.027318431064486504,
-0.1324000060558319,
0.353474885225296,
0.493728905916214,
-0.6252450346946716,
0.37770211696624756,
-0.2766997814178467,
0.36530834436416626,
0.941600501537323,
-0.10441599041223526,
0.5921209454536438,
0.20798736810684204,
0.4962750971317291,
0.4090394675731659,
0.18520385026931763,
-0.6797434687614441,
-0.31725794076919556,
-1.211443543434143,
-0.1709621399641037,
0.3670275807380676,
0.20604683458805084,
-0.9155948162078857,
0.22913917899131775,
-0.7320858240127563,
-0.22509296238422394,
-0.24703291058540344,
-0.05340044945478439,
0.40512338280677795,
0.4520569145679474,
0.3721710741519928,
-0.5505349040031433,
-0.48919010162353516,
-0.833044707775116,
0.1906961053609848,
0.03558040410280228,
0.053015947341918945,
0.4154728055000305,
0.5378603339195251,
-0.15125586092472076,
1.230316400527954,
-0.5085169076919556,
0.043631892651319504,
0.14056147634983063,
0.22704681754112244,
0.0963396355509758,
0.5102049708366394,
0.5235430002212524,
-0.7441384196281433,
-0.6976791024208069,
-0.18335120379924774,
-0.4304022192955017,
-0.17814163863658905,
-0.3275764584541321,
-0.12338629364967346,
0.5353939533233643,
0.4752660393714905,
-0.8914765119552612,
0.7244972586631775,
0.5735812187194824,
-0.0452226921916008,
0.472491592168808,
-0.3333703279495239,
-0.2713998854160309,
-0.9734542369842529,
-0.0989079624414444,
-0.342135488986969,
-0.37589403986930847,
-0.43380841612815857,
-0.03078192099928856,
0.4670284688472748,
0.12882283329963684,
-0.7879766821861267,
0.6578734517097473,
-0.49587759375572205,
0.04749307781457901,
-0.6125590205192566,
0.0840950459241867,
-0.24172565340995789,
0.6497659683227539,
0.04757576063275337,
0.8554235696792603,
0.6339457631111145,
-0.5188343524932861,
-0.031184885650873184,
-0.20993351936340332,
-0.08786734938621521,
0.05774928629398346,
-0.2656567692756653,
0.17057976126670837,
-0.3228105306625366,
1.0447837114334106,
-0.7813118100166321,
0.1971575766801834,
-0.3366840183734894,
-0.2640353739261627,
0.5414499044418335,
-0.31086665391921997,
-0.17246340215206146,
-0.3358243703842163,
-0.44366681575775146,
0.4339534342288971,
0.6794924736022949,
-0.8169562816619873,
0.7111944556236267,
0.16706067323684692,
0.08191752433776855,
-1.0421011447906494,
-0.6556283235549927,
0.18283043801784515,
-0.230884850025177,
-0.5449360609054565,
0.5318475961685181,
-0.002705154474824667,
0.24076706171035767,
0.010246118530631065,
-0.6396601796150208,
0.12370003759860992,
-0.23002444207668304,
0.316283643245697,
0.2753419578075409,
-0.52366703748703,
0.23915494978427887,
0.46137964725494385,
-0.40770864486694336,
-0.21818743646144867,
-0.7202410697937012,
0.6242038607597351,
-0.19440855085849762,
-0.1133122369647026,
-0.0502249039709568,
0.12137540429830551,
0.8648719787597656,
0.09608431160449982,
0.9900817275047302,
0.7848535776138306,
-0.32808718085289,
-0.2801642417907715,
-0.5385774374008179,
-0.21881617605686188,
-0.5597068667411804,
0.20366640388965607,
-0.41209790110588074,
-1.2017970085144043,
0.8280379772186279,
0.08671119809150696,
0.32321229577064514,
0.40929657220840454,
0.8114878535270691,
0.34206125140190125,
0.8042027354240417,
0.6403961777687073,
-0.20977316796779633,
0.6439131498336792,
-0.33018362522125244,
0.2112903743982315,
-0.8781195282936096,
-0.11014637351036072,
0.06458532065153122,
-0.41206371784210205,
-0.5924021601676941,
-0.7475085258483887,
0.37878066301345825,
-0.10504230856895447,
-0.06941113620996475,
0.4873800277709961,
-0.10080540180206299,
0.5428588390350342,
0.2851063013076782,
-0.0120517797768116,
0.09875355660915375,
-0.16143861413002014,
-0.6060863137245178,
-0.041710685938596725,
-0.6289902925491333,
-0.23692482709884644,
0.9979035258293152,
0.31289562582969666,
0.7637393474578857,
0.027283605188131332,
0.5735369324684143,
0.1390756517648697,
0.35757091641426086,
-0.5619344115257263,
0.6461630463600159,
-0.00028134550666436553,
-0.6102195978164673,
-0.2789463698863983,
-0.2766714096069336,
-0.9060889482498169,
0.5246772766113281,
0.13150998950004578,
-1.0710618495941162,
0.10362500697374344,
0.2775529623031616,
-0.21635004878044128,
0.45829877257347107,
-0.4814528226852417,
0.3373163938522339,
-0.04921232908964157,
-0.8044784069061279,
-0.2649863064289093,
-0.941423773765564,
0.16416510939598083,
-0.17100019752979279,
-0.2132161557674408,
0.17503440380096436,
-0.19527854025363922,
0.6289430856704712,
-0.5986395478248596,
0.8843522667884827,
-0.49384620785713196,
-0.13765807449817657,
0.2831563353538513,
0.020312579348683357,
0.9018399715423584,
0.1744827777147293,
0.2362954318523407,
-0.1135750487446785,
-0.295044869184494,
-0.4741291105747223,
-0.8502447605133057,
1.0148824453353882,
-0.5032514929771423,
-0.7001470923423767,
-0.15015269815921783,
-0.5351986289024353,
-0.171904057264328,
0.09311499446630478,
0.1932864636182785,
0.46266934275627136,
0.07047846913337708,
0.6231687664985657,
0.6294533014297485,
-0.05416896194219589,
0.9122099876403809,
0.7465609312057495,
0.008874940685927868,
-0.08755041658878326,
0.6645999550819397,
0.15300488471984863,
0.2078770399093628,
0.69655841588974,
0.21164341270923615,
-0.2368464171886444,
-0.4040563106536865,
-0.4252566993236542,
-0.05439655855298042,
-0.8759814500808716,
-0.1222158819437027,
-0.7223412990570068,
-0.24111942946910858,
-0.07434894144535065,
-0.3862649202346802,
-0.645330011844635,
-0.7108190655708313,
-0.13397608697414398,
-0.3903428018093109,
0.43279537558555603,
-0.020936287939548492,
-0.03205163776874542,
0.4146747589111328,
-0.8055822849273682,
-0.23802843689918518,
0.4045867621898651,
0.3274911642074585,
0.5942550897598267,
-0.31991028785705566,
-0.4893832802772522,
0.0012418052647262812,
-0.4085816442966461,
-0.41178444027900696,
0.5492336750030518,
0.07519535720348358,
0.4650021493434906,
0.5626691579818726,
-0.06276349723339081,
0.9844211339950562,
-0.7952475547790527,
1.194535255432129,
0.4711489975452423,
-0.8794854879379272,
0.2212185263633728,
-0.417761892080307,
0.5331141352653503,
0.6100350618362427,
0.19036775827407837,
-0.3837742507457733,
-0.34647858142852783,
-0.6027511954307556,
-1.3550782203674316,
0.5196073055267334,
0.37520045042037964,
0.3899194300174713,
-0.13964785635471344,
0.287969172000885,
0.3520043194293976,
0.10016606748104095,
-0.7305697798728943,
-0.17282699048519135,
-0.16990016400814056,
0.09268268197774887,
-0.03330221399664879,
0.0015092032263055444,
0.07351100444793701,
-0.4159184992313385,
0.6337008476257324,
-0.19782096147537231,
0.4698464572429657,
-0.0733780711889267,
-0.2270025610923767,
-0.15541373193264008,
0.22450308501720428,
0.6749856472015381,
0.6798585057258606,
-0.0627710148692131,
0.3541393280029297,
0.6527629494667053,
-0.7351043820381165,
0.15203529596328735,
-0.4297138452529907,
-0.11872899532318115,
0.052535783499479294,
-0.09430934488773346,
1.101467251777649,
0.5732991099357605,
-0.6081385612487793,
0.512010931968689,
-0.13587693870067596,
-0.047307368367910385,
-0.42902281880378723,
0.1004365086555481,
0.2355574071407318,
0.10948111116886139,
0.6875239610671997,
-0.1925317347049713,
-0.25004294514656067,
-0.4649963676929474,
0.4362051784992218,
0.30301105976104736,
-0.5301176905632019,
-0.48273593187332153,
0.734601616859436,
0.2665306627750397,
-0.1941206157207489,
0.6288453936576843,
0.20279575884342194,
-0.5847648978233337,
0.4293993413448334,
0.7880175709724426,
1.073372721672058,
-0.026589781045913696,
-0.10894104093313217,
0.062826007604599,
0.06444159895181656,
0.04351240023970604,
-0.10117868334054947,
-0.6253513097763062,
-0.4685485064983368,
-0.4789951741695404,
-0.7915955185890198,
-0.20229819416999817,
0.1652567982673645,
-0.6251481175422668,
0.32124054431915283,
-0.04290948435664177,
-0.19747528433799744,
-0.3106401264667511,
-0.08325149863958359,
-0.5825918912887573,
0.08568894863128662,
0.10972060263156891,
1.2007596492767334,
-0.7994210124015808,
1.2730443477630615,
0.126211479306221,
-0.13589920103549957,
-0.42669057846069336,
0.02865840308368206,
-0.06816945225000381,
-0.5934158563613892,
0.559789776802063,
0.2505281865596771,
-0.2659958004951477,
-0.240652397274971,
-0.34007394313812256,
-0.9052020907402039,
1.4548101425170898,
0.13351528346538544,
-0.709105372428894,
-0.3325338661670685,
-0.14692004024982452,
0.7077871561050415,
-0.5890545845031738,
0.18664585053920746,
0.43452513217926025,
0.37809106707572937,
0.273438423871994,
-0.9066408276557922,
0.2052888721227646,
-0.4431529939174652,
0.12466221302747726,
0.6757665276527405,
-0.8399860262870789,
0.7088401913642883,
0.044310636818408966,
-0.10081609338521957,
0.026741016656160355,
0.669282853603363,
0.08190714567899704,
0.272631973028183,
0.464263379573822,
0.6951777935028076,
0.43314287066459656,
-0.0638967975974083,
0.8200687170028687,
-0.4518566131591797,
0.45242956280708313,
1.0364508628845215,
-0.061566129326820374,
0.9132109880447388,
0.7575832605361938,
0.02834712527692318,
0.763769268989563,
0.3634289503097534,
0.3189126253128052,
0.8676427602767944,
0.07557888329029083,
-0.5489002466201782,
-0.18953652679920197,
0.3512963056564331,
-0.26255014538764954,
0.20927965641021729,
0.45372048020362854,
-0.3627362549304962,
-0.38474810123443604,
0.13844098150730133,
0.27493226528167725,
-0.6272411942481995,
-0.1408160924911499,
0.451986163854599,
0.22043581306934357,
-0.9279994368553162,
0.49021127820014954,
0.05637459456920624,
0.8285675644874573,
-0.76313316822052,
0.3353731036186218,
-0.10984006524085999,
0.15129095315933228,
-0.09706789255142212,
-0.315170019865036,
0.2408665418624878,
0.05963671952486038,
-0.131926491856575,
-0.27097979187965393,
0.5641947388648987,
-0.42612332105636597,
-0.10678140074014664,
0.15697041153907776,
0.23209017515182495,
-0.00023984091239981353,
0.5659803748130798,
-0.15935540199279785,
-0.04338269308209419,
-0.18003952503204346,
-0.4743692874908447,
0.7877715229988098,
0.15809470415115356,
-0.3577604591846466,
0.5493802428245544,
0.6492785811424255,
-0.11886771023273468,
0.6105058789253235,
0.10096100717782974,
1.1245771646499634,
-0.4577535092830658,
-0.8349485397338867,
-0.8238698244094849,
0.662808358669281,
0.08102038502693176,
-0.29745885729789734,
0.8350008130073547,
0.616768479347229,
0.5415245890617371,
-0.06777168065309525,
0.5819869041442871,
0.04176442697644234,
-0.3833601176738739,
-0.6234492063522339,
0.48992466926574707,
-0.48909512162208557,
0.28018930554389954,
-0.14874625205993652,
-0.7983068823814392,
-0.14065197110176086,
0.4072261154651642,
-0.31731802225112915,
-0.13555924594402313,
0.7790924906730652,
0.6592633724212646,
-0.23624226450920105,
0.039199620485305786,
0.2583315074443817,
0.1353413462638855,
0.6139456033706665,
0.8187505006790161,
0.4986262619495392,
-0.34891998767852783,
0.5722871422767639,
0.07862091809511185,
-0.17418363690376282,
-0.3167603313922882,
-1.1213500499725342,
-0.6139183044433594,
-0.7393161654472351,
-0.220272958278656,
-0.1434081345796585,
0.13206759095191956,
0.6494666337966919,
0.835187554359436,
-0.4630213677883148,
0.02060278132557869,
-0.2866663932800293,
-0.20118874311447144,
-0.08635371923446655,
-0.3073090612888336,
0.3966432809829712,
-0.2089281976222992,
-0.5692079663276672,
0.5389595627784729,
0.6207271814346313,
0.08481770008802414,
-0.5583863854408264,
-0.2768351435661316,
0.15496815741062164,
0.41029122471809387,
0.7969978451728821,
0.2537803053855896,
-0.7056581377983093,
-0.49183887243270874,
0.10731911659240723,
0.18100300431251526,
0.31863921880722046,
0.9679948091506958,
-1.2236888408660889,
0.6306823492050171,
0.5594132542610168,
0.49474605917930603,
1.4471276998519897,
-0.3075321912765503,
0.5546862483024597,
-1.1136807203292847,
0.324663907289505,
0.111249640583992,
0.5133278369903564,
-0.022706780582666397,
-0.28203731775283813,
0.09835021942853928,
-0.05784422904253006,
-0.3008316159248352,
-0.8574115633964539,
0.17372269928455353,
-1.1532751321792603,
-0.12118515372276306,
0.8890302181243896,
-0.33258742094039917,
-0.32326486706733704,
0.06466416269540787,
0.15383730828762054,
0.26197075843811035,
-0.6213529706001282,
0.86590576171875,
0.6829443573951721,
-0.06706264615058899,
-0.10844700038433075,
-0.3952876031398773,
0.3080158531665802,
0.14714239537715912,
-0.3051739037036896,
0.06831472367048264,
0.23272936046123505,
0.3474978804588318,
0.25681665539741516,
0.7513218522071838,
-0.26487672328948975,
0.5081515908241272,
0.06990190595388412,
-0.35439878702163696,
0.012118647806346416,
-0.6550619602203369,
-0.3077033758163452,
0.3246898353099823,
-0.5459193587303162,
-0.10076701641082764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16299v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16299v1 | Compensate Quantization Errors: Make Weights Hierarchical to Compensate Each Other | 2024-06-24T03:52:52 | 2024-06-24T03:52:52 | Yifei Gao, Jie Ou, Lei Wang, Yuting Xiao, Zhiyuan Xiang, Ruiting Dai, Jun Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, F.2.3 | Emergent Large Language Models (LLMs) use their extraordinary performance and
powerful deduction capacity to discern from traditional language models.
However, the expenses of computational resources and storage for these LLMs are
stunning, quantization then arises as a trending conversation. To address
accuracy decay caused by quantization, two streams of works in post-training
quantization methods stand out. One uses other weights to compensate existing
quantization error, while the other transfers the quantization difficulty to
other parts in the model. Combining both merits, we introduce Learnable
Singular value Increment (LSI) as an advanced solution. LSI uses Singular Value
Decomposition to extract singular values of the weights and make them learnable
to help weights compensate each other conditioned on activation. Incorporating
LSI with existing techniques, we achieve state-of-the-art performance in
diverse quantization settings, no matter in weight-only, weight-activation or
extremely low bit scenarios. By unleashing the potential of LSI, efficient
finetuning on quantized model is no longer a prohibitive problem. | [
0.31928765773773193,
-0.4660956859588623,
0.4621100127696991,
0.21780845522880554,
-0.16722823679447174,
0.33473965525627136,
-0.2339896857738495,
-0.22237129509449005,
0.03216170519590378,
0.25814542174339294,
-0.42545098066329956,
-0.17217107117176056,
-0.5533285737037659,
-0.09333688765764236,
-0.11051399260759354,
0.9913185238838196,
0.07567187398672104,
0.2252163141965866,
-0.3217163383960724,
-0.3125070631504059,
-0.22249364852905273,
-0.5726615786552429,
-1.1464574337005615,
-0.24927480518817902,
0.6842321753501892,
0.294586718082428,
0.5412655472755432,
0.43653368949890137,
0.4520792067050934,
0.3026621341705322,
-0.18707828223705292,
0.049035463482141495,
-0.6117351651191711,
0.18319539725780487,
0.1792498528957367,
-0.6764742136001587,
-0.9828122854232788,
-0.4158509075641632,
1.15032958984375,
0.8583724498748779,
-0.1813182532787323,
0.039483942091464996,
0.10240928828716278,
0.8502492904663086,
-0.6665620803833008,
0.24522066116333008,
-0.6490235328674316,
-0.05324593931436539,
-0.3189451992511749,
-0.27189821004867554,
-0.5127508044242859,
-0.4857470691204071,
-0.20559343695640564,
-0.49561750888824463,
-0.03260055556893349,
-0.4884493947029114,
0.657570481300354,
0.6538570523262024,
-0.06733917444944382,
0.1661616563796997,
-0.8481055498123169,
1.0966956615447998,
-0.9448339343070984,
0.358085572719574,
0.05197826400399208,
0.059411223977804184,
-0.024577727541327477,
-0.6472852826118469,
-0.1588745266199112,
0.07161426544189453,
0.1433129459619522,
-0.08657784014940262,
-0.3106961250305176,
0.18066106736660004,
0.32134008407592773,
0.6634249091148376,
-0.24253006279468536,
0.5435137748718262,
-0.4002743065357208,
-0.05861319229006767,
0.5203821063041687,
0.04353431984782219,
0.15442785620689392,
0.25142404437065125,
-0.023412616923451424,
-0.2490510493516922,
-0.9870154857635498,
0.34183138608932495,
0.3752223551273346,
0.4985121190547943,
0.06538328528404236,
0.3351031243801117,
-0.216537207365036,
0.6350258588790894,
0.1369638741016388,
-0.4017508924007416,
0.31967368721961975,
-0.1839602142572403,
-0.4603390395641327,
0.15109722316265106,
0.1772266924381256,
-0.076355941593647,
0.10588102042675018,
-0.10588639229536057,
-0.4688986837863922,
-0.21781708300113678,
0.23771324753761292,
-0.932636559009552,
-0.31090211868286133,
0.4048956632614136,
-0.1193983256816864,
-0.16285324096679688,
-0.22270995378494263,
-0.17696426808834076,
-0.36319705843925476,
-0.3691500425338745,
0.7248340845108032,
-0.22320851683616638,
-0.3006739020347595,
0.13759462535381317,
0.033229343593120575,
-0.11245603859424591,
0.3157646059989929,
-1.0502811670303345,
0.2733333110809326,
0.49511346220970154,
0.7638987302780151,
0.07385554909706116,
0.008831487037241459,
-0.6414202451705933,
0.006766995415091515,
-0.4472183883190155,
0.6028985381126404,
-0.033508263528347015,
0.044069863855838776,
-0.0586000420153141,
-0.27628275752067566,
0.2159510850906372,
-0.5834288001060486,
0.3808914124965668,
-0.612157940864563,
-0.22046618163585663,
-0.09188532829284668,
-0.4865438640117645,
0.04928874969482422,
0.08518513292074203,
-0.7130493521690369,
0.9446801543235779,
0.21363486349582672,
-0.7045364379882812,
0.5503529906272888,
-0.5005431175231934,
-0.17840667068958282,
0.3736112713813782,
0.07366177439689636,
-0.901865541934967,
0.3024269640445709,
0.13718988001346588,
0.5548920631408691,
0.12118953466415405,
0.26645627617836,
-0.3159380257129669,
-0.5478360652923584,
0.04767308384180069,
-0.5005569458007812,
0.7245683670043945,
-0.08839723467826843,
-0.29740965366363525,
0.398042768239975,
-0.9444357752799988,
0.2801970839500427,
0.21563765406608582,
-0.5486770272254944,
-0.6911952495574951,
0.1987602859735489,
-0.4565039277076721,
-0.21711869537830353,
0.3248315453529358,
-0.3588739335536957,
0.19909419119358063,
-0.7194492816925049,
0.5493268370628357,
1.0210621356964111,
-0.1158994659781456,
0.4727674126625061,
0.00604670587927103,
0.2753857970237732,
0.24862034618854523,
0.1162385568022728,
-0.23299071192741394,
0.009708382189273834,
-0.9766626954078674,
-0.41861218214035034,
0.510678768157959,
0.2749388515949249,
-0.8333497643470764,
0.2174919843673706,
-0.5382860898971558,
-0.4129800796508789,
-0.6360830068588257,
0.04140179604291916,
0.27527791261672974,
-0.03312676399946213,
0.30523985624313354,
-0.04275510460138321,
-0.636576235294342,
-0.7585238814353943,
-0.16477139294147491,
0.09661697596311569,
-0.2930637001991272,
-0.14720448851585388,
0.1839248239994049,
-0.04768401011824608,
0.7006617784500122,
-0.23971407115459442,
-0.2785784900188446,
0.05736498162150383,
0.21900969743728638,
0.1860981434583664,
0.6788789629936218,
0.1345958411693573,
-0.5969911813735962,
-0.12887313961982727,
-0.03259611129760742,
-0.5476586222648621,
-0.09406659007072449,
-0.19337353110313416,
0.15520378947257996,
0.32283419370651245,
0.7539401650428772,
-0.0216471366584301,
0.16782517731189728,
0.6821029782295227,
-0.10035073757171631,
0.4750118553638458,
-0.29387667775154114,
0.02954697422683239,
-0.8505969047546387,
-0.041674721986055374,
-0.1168450266122818,
-0.43814510107040405,
-0.4240375757217407,
0.19564631581306458,
0.28386810421943665,
0.1176488921046257,
-0.48637425899505615,
0.35067787766456604,
-0.4738166630268097,
-0.35997843742370605,
-0.1084444671869278,
-0.0039239912293851376,
-0.1532338410615921,
0.6026241779327393,
-0.14205579459667206,
0.9213874936103821,
0.48445940017700195,
-0.7426154017448425,
0.32492944598197937,
-0.35015130043029785,
-0.24391591548919678,
0.6853416562080383,
-0.8126593828201294,
-0.12800681591033936,
-0.28777259588241577,
0.18354763090610504,
-0.8905234336853027,
-0.06906671822071075,
0.07744862884283066,
-0.3947705924510956,
0.3517264425754547,
-0.2900344729423523,
-0.4430602788925171,
-0.35027042031288147,
-0.5204290747642517,
0.7658438682556152,
0.3074988126754761,
-0.5539609789848328,
0.2805616855621338,
0.36683765053749084,
-0.4937126040458679,
-0.5791081190109253,
-0.5261690616607666,
0.041485194116830826,
-0.06515912711620331,
-0.1329750120639801,
0.19823002815246582,
-0.3992327153682709,
-0.30758655071258545,
-0.09452486783266068,
-0.026128562167286873,
-0.09250108897686005,
0.14165616035461426,
0.19972877204418182,
0.063135527074337,
-0.35875120759010315,
0.5365551114082336,
0.4138302803039551,
-0.3344199061393738,
-0.19415678083896637,
-0.7187480330467224,
0.40703871846199036,
-0.3516104817390442,
-0.27613839507102966,
-0.3009399175643921,
0.1969148814678192,
0.6783091425895691,
-0.045980118215084076,
0.7556238174438477,
0.44993269443511963,
-0.763196587562561,
-0.07246885448694229,
-0.4996581971645355,
0.04362144321203232,
-0.4696643054485321,
0.45148590207099915,
-0.44912341237068176,
-1.1091972589492798,
0.20288914442062378,
-0.004092767834663391,
0.4917934834957123,
0.5183199644088745,
0.6013762354850769,
0.06408808380365372,
1.2310779094696045,
0.808975338935852,
0.15164530277252197,
0.5369613170623779,
-0.2831205725669861,
0.29672783613204956,
-0.6640309691429138,
-0.15300726890563965,
-0.5018138885498047,
-0.3757295310497284,
-0.4245101511478424,
-0.34407952427864075,
0.63584303855896,
0.15423892438411713,
-0.37628522515296936,
0.1710885614156723,
-0.4511047899723053,
0.5263247489929199,
0.572955310344696,
0.24550387263298035,
0.3685425817966461,
0.21405799686908722,
0.09699784964323044,
-0.3437901735305786,
-0.7522580027580261,
-0.13893067836761475,
0.8229354023933411,
0.5346341133117676,
0.8213278651237488,
0.09135779738426208,
0.619530200958252,
0.2847915589809418,
0.33382025361061096,
-1.0692137479782104,
0.3556074798107147,
-0.3622532784938812,
0.059566106647253036,
-0.651496410369873,
-0.6963456273078918,
-0.9237260222434998,
0.19936732947826385,
-0.015042891725897789,
-0.45363304018974304,
0.1254729926586151,
0.22367122769355774,
-0.9205463528633118,
0.5966876745223999,
-0.5703771114349365,
0.5787048935890198,
-0.03216645121574402,
-0.30541858077049255,
-0.24638940393924713,
-0.31512749195098877,
0.45512592792510986,
-0.0393756665289402,
0.24844081699848175,
0.1438678652048111,
-0.1573249101638794,
0.8798070549964905,
-0.3853514790534973,
0.986344039440155,
-0.03580256551504135,
-0.6538068056106567,
-0.07576675713062286,
0.038153063505887985,
0.5462054014205933,
-0.1248655691742897,
-0.059972405433654785,
0.06902012974023819,
0.001884548575617373,
-0.7770274877548218,
-0.5508657693862915,
0.7839675545692444,
-0.6453583240509033,
-0.3198416233062744,
-0.262611985206604,
-0.49418142437934875,
-0.11815522611141205,
0.15384437143802643,
0.14082451164722443,
0.5418292880058289,
0.061378538608551025,
0.27101218700408936,
1.037175178527832,
0.03650848940014839,
0.6079497933387756,
0.3706669211387634,
0.10338584333658218,
-0.77911376953125,
1.0077787637710571,
0.2309667468070984,
0.540700376033783,
0.4101369082927704,
0.09653168171644211,
-0.14814935624599457,
-0.652066171169281,
-0.5231619477272034,
0.19454841315746307,
-0.5171520113945007,
-0.6808205246925354,
-0.619423508644104,
-0.43676093220710754,
-0.3268589675426483,
-0.25063127279281616,
-0.6789781451225281,
-0.5935758352279663,
-0.32410162687301636,
-0.22656312584877014,
0.28180888295173645,
0.5821419358253479,
-0.27011263370513916,
0.4188706874847412,
-0.9492357969284058,
0.07924849539995193,
0.6299772262573242,
0.48034238815307617,
0.08635354042053223,
-0.7471064925193787,
-0.6551916003227234,
0.3640214502811432,
-0.12346157431602478,
-0.3065774738788605,
0.23049072921276093,
0.25610968470573425,
0.18469399213790894,
0.40679049491882324,
-0.10431905090808868,
1.0241279602050781,
-0.3760628402233124,
0.7455654144287109,
0.25062817335128784,
-1.1659373044967651,
0.4803105890750885,
-0.08998141437768936,
0.3565681576728821,
0.3691096007823944,
0.2770440876483917,
-0.498942106962204,
-0.4942236542701721,
-0.6532530784606934,
-1.1224753856658936,
0.5509389638900757,
-0.04284222424030304,
0.2674599885940552,
0.34625908732414246,
0.5349321961402893,
0.009665769524872303,
0.2004631757736206,
-1.2064626216888428,
-0.09645674377679825,
0.1698829084634781,
-0.10829722881317139,
-0.06235208734869957,
-0.5625666379928589,
0.13448834419250488,
-0.25059807300567627,
0.877166748046875,
-0.3148577809333801,
0.10449503362178802,
-0.03520112484693527,
-0.2006935477256775,
-0.624249279499054,
0.2620096504688263,
0.5586075186729431,
0.7365681529045105,
0.0010147449793294072,
0.33411070704460144,
0.26724565029144287,
-0.17809025943279266,
0.22631585597991943,
-0.08713594824075699,
-0.35798001289367676,
-0.2331925630569458,
0.11476916819810867,
0.9379392266273499,
0.7461317777633667,
-0.680937647819519,
0.41234928369522095,
0.01817118562757969,
-0.07000158727169037,
-0.49379950761795044,
-0.10481355339288712,
-0.1374472975730896,
0.3195900619029999,
0.5379747152328491,
0.15529729425907135,
-0.010324748232960701,
-0.35279399156570435,
0.2631721794605255,
0.5276232957839966,
-0.4313504099845886,
-0.3082287013530731,
0.6510986089706421,
0.0943390354514122,
-0.18708543479442596,
0.37466397881507874,
-0.3379046618938446,
-0.49613410234451294,
0.28129369020462036,
0.4186082184314728,
0.6945285797119141,
-0.47257471084594727,
0.24618346989154816,
0.5978143811225891,
0.281468003988266,
-0.1404516100883484,
0.007530881557613611,
-0.10947734862565994,
-0.640739381313324,
-0.8406332731246948,
-0.7170568108558655,
-0.31400468945503235,
0.2154366821050644,
-0.5916352868080139,
0.14600415527820587,
-0.5354552865028381,
0.14749984443187714,
-0.06324941664934158,
0.05474557355046272,
-0.27091288566589355,
0.3189890384674072,
0.2117662876844406,
0.3503815233707428,
-0.8288795948028564,
0.6280803680419922,
0.5083491206169128,
-0.38360467553138733,
-0.6905239224433899,
-0.13168871402740479,
-0.3340347707271576,
-0.8250986933708191,
0.6385539174079895,
-0.142128586769104,
-0.030212344601750374,
0.47676515579223633,
-0.5306687355041504,
-0.9400390982627869,
1.0447803735733032,
0.39188647270202637,
-0.5818766355514526,
-0.024966692551970482,
-0.10710134357213974,
0.43501025438308716,
0.19486545026302338,
0.2032509744167328,
0.6043215394020081,
0.31965216994285583,
0.16255031526088715,
-0.7419108152389526,
-0.1203363686800003,
-0.039431411772966385,
0.06564129143953323,
0.4565831422805786,
-0.448879599571228,
0.9960924386978149,
-0.33894243836402893,
-0.3437945246696472,
0.2490862011909485,
0.8435879349708557,
0.22967922687530518,
0.09343715012073517,
0.5715424418449402,
0.7422887086868286,
0.8788297176361084,
0.029469257220625877,
0.7360738515853882,
0.1989087611436844,
0.2856844961643219,
0.9633845686912537,
0.053430985659360886,
1.0279874801635742,
0.5233792066574097,
-0.5932986736297607,
0.5592873096466064,
0.7285155653953552,
0.29192090034484863,
0.2648642957210541,
0.4068423807621002,
-0.5941916704177856,
-0.32270246744155884,
0.013533076271414757,
-0.2478189766407013,
0.132060706615448,
0.3889363408088684,
0.048411618918180466,
-0.2192753404378891,
0.1459956020116806,
0.1656271368265152,
-0.031003747135400772,
-0.7852874994277954,
0.7894460558891296,
0.013337096199393272,
-0.4677366316318512,
0.9052014350891113,
0.13137099146842957,
0.884409487247467,
-0.6507011651992798,
-0.04393405094742775,
-0.21292592585086823,
0.4760395586490631,
-0.1591646522283554,
-0.37531763315200806,
0.3993266224861145,
-0.2031024843454361,
-0.30232110619544983,
-0.4660967290401459,
0.38751980662345886,
-0.6600496768951416,
-0.7805312275886536,
-0.051274240016937256,
0.2602141201496124,
0.0037650044541805983,
-0.2643800377845764,
-0.4057629704475403,
0.17482715845108032,
-0.0009442482842132449,
0.05203259363770485,
0.43614462018013,
0.38564854860305786,
-0.07387825101613998,
0.6433895230293274,
0.6561465859413147,
0.3762573301792145,
0.11417774111032486,
0.2652464807033539,
0.7976105809211731,
-0.4499358832836151,
-0.4390335977077484,
-0.7600707411766052,
0.7178341746330261,
0.07160204648971558,
-0.022618664428591728,
0.4300948679447174,
0.2685953676700592,
0.8574245572090149,
-0.07636868953704834,
0.5090068578720093,
0.24547547101974487,
0.5379924178123474,
-0.7337052822113037,
0.5870739221572876,
-0.8183780312538147,
0.3804020881652832,
-0.1847587525844574,
-0.7191274166107178,
-0.8054823875427246,
0.41328883171081543,
-0.0028755643870681524,
-0.07401762157678604,
0.5139570832252502,
0.6511744856834412,
0.1694689244031906,
-0.5450745820999146,
0.6404882669448853,
0.4978264570236206,
0.18780829012393951,
0.6956573724746704,
0.6006637215614319,
-0.7361981868743896,
0.4486352503299713,
-0.10629259049892426,
-0.487551212310791,
-0.2625138461589813,
-0.92180997133255,
-0.3565725088119507,
-0.6707436442375183,
-0.599223792552948,
-0.225120410323143,
0.09433163702487946,
0.7314922213554382,
0.7003774046897888,
-0.9484573006629944,
-0.14148882031440735,
-0.17269563674926758,
0.39712241291999817,
-0.55476975440979,
-0.24146680533885956,
0.3387173116207123,
-0.6821737885475159,
-0.998868465423584,
0.28369224071502686,
0.5072321891784668,
0.2133675366640091,
-0.43716347217559814,
-0.07062121480703354,
0.15976330637931824,
0.12040203809738159,
0.9748591184616089,
0.377956360578537,
-0.5943947434425354,
-0.27341169118881226,
-0.25712281465530396,
-0.16860777139663696,
0.18775500357151031,
1.1370887756347656,
-0.9571799039840698,
0.2654041349887848,
0.2344646155834198,
0.7382441759109497,
0.21260817348957062,
-0.1646622270345688,
0.3869619071483612,
-0.9926548600196838,
0.27202320098876953,
0.29226264357566833,
0.3237502872943878,
0.4560266137123108,
-0.47957900166511536,
0.29241234064102173,
0.3845168650150299,
-0.5087208151817322,
-1.010820746421814,
0.04373423755168915,
-0.8381994962692261,
-0.11706031858921051,
0.8219466209411621,
-0.22484612464904785,
-0.14016200602054596,
0.07928944379091263,
-0.1274426430463791,
0.2822342813014984,
-0.13630418479442596,
0.7011809349060059,
0.4394354820251465,
0.3749091923236847,
-0.36903855204582214,
-0.2192700207233429,
0.5672456622123718,
0.7172380089759827,
-0.7895939946174622,
0.10687488317489624,
0.4991954565048218,
0.1333148032426834,
0.0029832003638148308,
0.7170060276985168,
-0.27892187237739563,
0.25355538725852966,
-0.04635145515203476,
0.3179234564304352,
0.17299287021160126,
-0.38291263580322266,
-0.6337553262710571,
0.017155008390545845,
0.37273159623146057,
-0.24285204708576202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16294v1 | LangSuitE: Planning, Controlling and Interacting with Large Language Models in Embodied Text Environments | 2024-06-24T03:36:29 | 2024-06-24T03:36:29 | Zixia Jia, Mengmeng Wang, Baichen Tong, Song-Chun Zhu, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown inspiring
achievements in constructing autonomous agents that rely on language
descriptions as inputs. However, it remains unclear how well LLMs can function
as few-shot or zero-shot embodied agents in dynamic interactive environments.
To address this gap, we introduce LangSuitE, a versatile and simulation-free
testbed featuring 6 representative embodied tasks in textual embodied worlds.
Compared with previous LLM-based testbeds, LangSuitE (i) offers adaptability to
diverse environments without multiple simulation engines, (ii) evaluates
agents' capacity to develop ``internalized world knowledge'' with embodied
observations, and (iii) allows easy customization of communication and action
strategies. To address the embodiment challenge, we devise a novel
chain-of-thought (CoT) schema, EmMem, which summarizes embodied states w.r.t.
history information. Comprehensive benchmark results illustrate challenges and
insights of embodied planning. LangSuitE represents a significant step toward
building embodied generalists in the context of language models. | [
-0.4155195355415344,
-0.8037641644477844,
0.7767884135246277,
0.2258400171995163,
-0.08869388699531555,
0.011163435876369476,
-0.1786707192659378,
-0.4350147545337677,
0.4008341133594513,
0.670810878276825,
-0.6462398767471313,
-0.6179250478744507,
-0.39023077487945557,
-0.08214107155799866,
-0.4516632854938507,
0.5584086179733276,
-0.4949730336666107,
-0.5249295234680176,
-0.07210167497396469,
-0.30133920907974243,
-0.39254871010780334,
-0.43224263191223145,
-0.4858214855194092,
-0.2831985354423523,
0.4683402180671692,
0.24710741639137268,
0.75754714012146,
0.15411920845508575,
-0.141231968998909,
0.2774204611778259,
0.2345583289861679,
0.1886221319437027,
-0.2906583845615387,
0.5477682948112488,
-0.28569716215133667,
-0.5600597262382507,
-0.48954272270202637,
-0.23153170943260193,
0.6282021403312683,
0.43910783529281616,
-0.15159232914447784,
0.045949142426252365,
-0.015264284797012806,
0.12159363925457001,
-0.9504305720329285,
0.3631282448768616,
-0.31859534978866577,
0.30880922079086304,
0.3837606608867645,
0.11991367489099503,
-0.519428551197052,
0.27376842498779297,
-0.06569566577672958,
-0.6493521332740784,
-0.07739698886871338,
0.14698123931884766,
0.24683184921741486,
0.14400972425937653,
-0.4433368146419525,
-0.30189037322998047,
-0.9073368310928345,
0.6101070046424866,
-0.5838685631752014,
0.42685359716415405,
0.3265651762485504,
0.299689382314682,
-0.20022378861904144,
-0.6757622957229614,
-0.629618227481842,
-0.08408378809690475,
-0.12038648873567581,
0.18656383454799652,
-0.09552841633558273,
0.20770272612571716,
0.2611910402774811,
-0.03933240845799446,
-0.5723930597305298,
0.293006956577301,
0.22743576765060425,
-0.05414198338985443,
0.6071781516075134,
0.2971906363964081,
0.8512877225875854,
0.08761046081781387,
-0.14150045812129974,
-0.3262099325656891,
-0.7538381814956665,
-0.3090578615665436,
-0.11176245659589767,
0.30081239342689514,
-0.2167258858680725,
0.8226390480995178,
-0.007429727353155613,
0.529377281665802,
-0.5547115802764893,
0.17173346877098083,
-0.48522239923477173,
0.1275966465473175,
-0.49052903056144714,
0.23929019272327423,
0.581462025642395,
0.13032837212085724,
0.047087185084819794,
-0.32674887776374817,
-0.3565931022167206,
0.005768299102783203,
0.2961519658565521,
-0.740193247795105,
0.14420494437217712,
0.39016038179397583,
-0.031062066555023193,
-0.20359262824058533,
-0.1373533010482788,
-0.8113170266151428,
-0.5363209247589111,
-0.18516384065151215,
0.47623956203460693,
-0.31825846433639526,
-0.2807515859603882,
0.3471064865589142,
-0.10982883721590042,
0.6421293616294861,
0.46481218934059143,
-1.0489506721496582,
0.8412565588951111,
0.5728797912597656,
0.8272085189819336,
0.09890297800302505,
-0.4380355775356293,
-0.29346799850463867,
0.6194430589675903,
-0.4875870645046234,
0.5411979556083679,
-0.4463053345680237,
-0.6342853903770447,
0.2010188102722168,
0.04664967209100723,
-0.09895635396242142,
-0.0028915032744407654,
0.08259473741054535,
-0.3357027769088745,
0.2129490226507187,
-0.1270093321800232,
-0.7371396422386169,
-0.11604484915733337,
0.3157830238342285,
-0.6709263324737549,
0.745191752910614,
-0.04154456406831741,
-0.43648678064346313,
0.33166420459747314,
-0.6287246346473694,
-0.34299466013908386,
0.12274128943681717,
-0.4665374159812927,
0.03255946934223175,
0.1108430027961731,
0.191110759973526,
0.4892730116844177,
-0.11691617965698242,
-0.02287379465997219,
-0.1660996377468109,
-0.6111055612564087,
0.1051873117685318,
-0.060421738773584366,
0.46193361282348633,
-0.026330986991524696,
-0.7227295637130737,
0.08237925171852112,
-0.3699602484703064,
0.06763306260108948,
0.28781193494796753,
0.0866265818476677,
-0.41225260496139526,
0.3190264403820038,
0.17034174501895905,
-0.017607754096388817,
0.013837938196957111,
-0.41366079449653625,
0.5960979461669922,
-0.5250757336616516,
0.2626515328884125,
0.5953991413116455,
-0.12064260989427567,
0.7542843222618103,
-0.510678231716156,
0.7745448350906372,
-0.720099687576294,
0.011598520912230015,
-0.23560123145580292,
-0.2803241014480591,
-0.8140274882316589,
-0.28490781784057617,
-0.2288137823343277,
0.39694133400917053,
-0.6231850385665894,
0.1489706039428711,
-0.13111849129199982,
-0.4318883419036865,
-0.09413330256938934,
-0.13702255487442017,
0.31182318925857544,
-0.4573521316051483,
0.30209606885910034,
0.043404094874858856,
-0.3488275408744812,
-0.6199795007705688,
-0.23661571741104126,
-0.26549679040908813,
-0.12607978284358978,
0.3102599084377289,
0.6456122994422913,
-0.299677312374115,
0.7052506804466248,
-0.3960421681404114,
-0.1868971884250641,
-0.5684407353401184,
0.12478061765432358,
-0.15458989143371582,
0.3338156044483185,
0.6298036575317383,
-0.5169491767883301,
-0.12009080499410629,
0.131207674741745,
-0.8686827421188354,
0.026553403586149216,
-0.3186686933040619,
-0.27632996439933777,
0.09122995287179947,
0.5076097249984741,
-0.5982206463813782,
0.36912214756011963,
0.6960486173629761,
-0.37023764848709106,
0.4658750891685486,
-0.46433132886886597,
0.17739108204841614,
-1.0391556024551392,
0.14878404140472412,
-0.3590003550052643,
-0.2214175909757614,
-0.41937732696533203,
0.6915292143821716,
0.09012771397829056,
-0.2852602005004883,
-0.46459436416625977,
1.2230052947998047,
-0.7131879329681396,
-0.2848668098449707,
-0.40056470036506653,
0.3635667860507965,
-0.06742436438798904,
0.47411608695983887,
0.21220079064369202,
0.5589084029197693,
0.4717350900173187,
-0.6626986861228943,
0.27093639969825745,
0.39553314447402954,
-0.32876068353652954,
0.2081659734249115,
-0.5862888097763062,
0.3038814961910248,
-0.10156378149986267,
0.4428560137748718,
-0.7389354705810547,
-0.5101398825645447,
-0.03425530344247818,
0.06548440456390381,
0.3251761794090271,
-0.07291225343942642,
-0.7531461715698242,
-0.20978491008281708,
-0.15121367573738098,
0.5948619246482849,
0.6105815172195435,
-0.36733219027519226,
0.9833617210388184,
0.4758427143096924,
-0.08585943281650543,
-0.297743022441864,
-0.8778383731842041,
0.20442596077919006,
-0.061883345246315,
-0.19330637156963348,
0.28516513109207153,
-0.01664075441658497,
-0.38862282037734985,
-0.12828445434570312,
-0.12353724241256714,
-0.10244915634393692,
0.06295280903577805,
0.39939990639686584,
0.05428255721926689,
-0.1105591282248497,
0.2737673223018646,
0.3973471224308014,
0.2203342765569687,
0.0066709318198263645,
-0.22913134098052979,
0.5717763900756836,
-0.059276070445775986,
-0.6581116914749146,
-0.01890353485941887,
0.3446143865585327,
0.7256618142127991,
-0.08583378791809082,
0.529527485370636,
-0.08452313393354416,
-0.6656787395477295,
-0.6234133243560791,
-0.39606550335884094,
-0.08966859430074692,
-0.4439462721347809,
0.27556872367858887,
-0.28627827763557434,
-0.930489182472229,
0.589641809463501,
-0.07687277346849442,
0.29169410467147827,
-0.012815323658287525,
0.24341584742069244,
0.06107620522379875,
0.782385528087616,
0.6159510016441345,
0.1445513814687729,
0.1705874800682068,
-0.17255350947380066,
-0.011843773536384106,
-0.8407590985298157,
-0.1966419816017151,
-0.22418735921382904,
-0.4804871082305908,
-0.53611820936203,
-0.7429591417312622,
0.30578741431236267,
-0.23055846989154816,
-0.5393755435943604,
0.5047207474708557,
-0.19753187894821167,
0.5359314680099487,
0.11936923861503601,
0.05941728502511978,
0.12123273313045502,
-0.30672967433929443,
-0.3356340527534485,
0.04331627115607262,
-0.6925836205482483,
-0.8130785226821899,
0.7687810063362122,
0.08155075460672379,
0.9616223573684692,
0.32180020213127136,
0.674683690071106,
0.023680543527007103,
0.22506901621818542,
-0.7335808277130127,
0.8726956248283386,
0.04843682050704956,
-0.6963331699371338,
-0.3445705473423004,
0.09036862105131149,
-0.9993323683738708,
0.5361716151237488,
-0.3696066737174988,
-1.031962513923645,
-0.020114872604608536,
0.037635236978530884,
-0.1407119333744049,
0.6205220222473145,
-0.3083905875682831,
0.6953372359275818,
-0.3511575758457184,
-0.5595289468765259,
-0.3408789038658142,
-0.3858885169029236,
0.319275438785553,
0.016739608719944954,
0.32462772727012634,
-0.19220291078090668,
-0.4454066753387451,
0.4049975574016571,
-0.08574636280536652,
1.0948281288146973,
0.0196799635887146,
-0.3656676113605499,
0.2651621997356415,
0.7263145446777344,
0.48896849155426025,
-0.06280431151390076,
0.04610375687479973,
-0.44113197922706604,
0.060008369386196136,
-0.5271320343017578,
-0.6387044191360474,
0.8159257769584656,
-0.43753600120544434,
-0.4022369086742401,
-0.4727272093296051,
-0.4161789119243622,
-0.49191585183143616,
0.23203130066394806,
-0.13773079216480255,
0.6446762681007385,
-1.0406941175460815,
-0.03925533592700958,
0.6260778307914734,
-0.829731285572052,
0.4992237091064453,
0.5908528566360474,
-0.8139199614524841,
-0.1356620341539383,
0.49274227023124695,
-0.10580457746982574,
0.34689900279045105,
0.6736031770706177,
-0.08475060015916824,
-0.3601880669593811,
0.09463446587324142,
-0.3974168300628662,
0.2552643418312073,
-0.6902679204940796,
0.15327176451683044,
-0.5742921233177185,
-0.17666831612586975,
-0.046420224010944366,
-0.6503419876098633,
-0.42518487572669983,
-0.15959306061267853,
0.10295489430427551,
-0.24166624248027802,
-0.02102089859545231,
1.0893208980560303,
0.3091539144515991,
0.2824552655220032,
-0.6112205982208252,
0.09670711308717728,
0.4231490194797516,
0.3799580931663513,
0.003943222109228373,
0.02216443419456482,
-0.05799156427383423,
0.19341732561588287,
-0.05419609323143959,
-0.8866855502128601,
0.35357919335365295,
0.1466377228498459,
0.6809744834899902,
0.008261104114353657,
0.1736915111541748,
0.3431318402290344,
-0.4447977840900421,
0.8137899041175842,
0.030577024444937706,
-0.9200736880302429,
0.6761404275894165,
-0.3826121687889099,
0.6520777940750122,
0.13721910119056702,
0.2457405924797058,
-0.7539229393005371,
-0.8745787143707275,
-0.7086948156356812,
-0.74090975522995,
0.3236693739891052,
0.29264792799949646,
0.37172770500183105,
-0.0231622327119112,
0.31342390179634094,
0.12212183326482773,
0.160737082362175,
-0.5786357522010803,
0.12958602607250214,
0.08935729414224625,
0.014602869749069214,
-0.24761782586574554,
-0.21782514452934265,
-0.07810816168785095,
-0.06993352621793747,
0.41691356897354126,
-0.36662688851356506,
0.3767571449279785,
0.2713736593723297,
-0.4578067362308502,
0.1802830547094345,
0.41837021708488464,
0.5785080194473267,
0.4296610951423645,
0.0050285751931369305,
0.4560689926147461,
0.42324137687683105,
-0.11952634900808334,
0.3982700705528259,
-0.20364084839820862,
0.04142463579773903,
-0.17232605814933777,
0.6555379629135132,
0.8100337386131287,
0.8932363986968994,
-0.9017146825790405,
0.41442427039146423,
-0.1298033595085144,
-0.20862919092178345,
-0.3624371588230133,
0.291736900806427,
0.14341440796852112,
0.24989844858646393,
-0.09101000428199768,
-0.30166327953338623,
-0.012661298736929893,
-0.7315827012062073,
0.1112389788031578,
0.2669055461883545,
-0.5139140486717224,
-0.34553465247154236,
0.914412260055542,
0.05613439157605171,
-0.055039968341588974,
0.4441601634025574,
-0.045008204877376556,
-0.2655525803565979,
0.6572941541671753,
0.5770086050033569,
1.0751725435256958,
-0.2962542176246643,
0.3060387670993805,
0.3964691460132599,
0.4823989272117615,
-0.17499622702598572,
0.2388840615749359,
-0.03361126035451889,
-0.8766010999679565,
-0.4791491627693176,
-0.6082130074501038,
-0.5429242253303528,
-0.1066816970705986,
-0.3985685110092163,
0.36565083265304565,
-0.4941335618495941,
0.15571968257427216,
-0.36977607011795044,
-0.26367929577827454,
-0.7372639179229736,
0.054755114018917084,
0.31926652789115906,
1.0082577466964722,
-0.7998995184898376,
0.6091703176498413,
0.8349709510803223,
-0.41197583079338074,
-0.6715044975280762,
0.1015547588467598,
0.08035748451948166,
-0.7693829536437988,
0.119821697473526,
0.13579531013965607,
-0.4921128451824188,
0.1507449746131897,
-0.5507761240005493,
-0.4452807605266571,
1.2617278099060059,
0.5793440341949463,
-0.4064956307411194,
-0.14304684102535248,
0.00030733051244169474,
0.49666911363601685,
-0.2822656035423279,
0.35788494348526,
0.3380873203277588,
0.42590805888175964,
-0.0292071346193552,
-0.9675052165985107,
0.2814520299434662,
-0.034318290650844574,
-0.030570760369300842,
0.3422892093658447,
-0.6535124778747559,
0.281759649515152,
-0.2343095988035202,
-0.34134045243263245,
0.3666192889213562,
0.34312912821769714,
0.2792348265647888,
0.09010377526283264,
0.4606817960739136,
0.3820534348487854,
0.5888193249702454,
0.04152926057577133,
1.304741621017456,
-0.03148183971643448,
0.1750405728816986,
1.1107712984085083,
-0.591519832611084,
0.9182183742523193,
0.13137394189834595,
-0.11395589262247086,
0.5322969555854797,
0.2819885015487671,
0.47726181149482727,
0.2932716906070709,
0.3633333146572113,
-0.7185209393501282,
-0.3204987049102783,
0.0908421128988266,
-0.11912943422794342,
0.6264022588729858,
0.46632763743400574,
-0.009360716678202152,
-0.3187224566936493,
0.2670813500881195,
0.057071082293987274,
0.15248897671699524,
-0.14072977006435394,
0.9044321775436401,
0.18135185539722443,
-0.639371395111084,
0.16403362154960632,
-0.24902455508708954,
0.2870699167251587,
-0.8287861347198486,
-0.06573863327503204,
-0.27995339035987854,
0.06543447077274323,
0.20777197182178497,
-0.8421828150749207,
0.147202730178833,
-0.1926300972700119,
0.32397329807281494,
-0.589590311050415,
0.8359134793281555,
-0.4413411617279053,
-0.26593345403671265,
0.4946329891681671,
0.6741155385971069,
0.23913677036762238,
-0.125873401761055,
-0.24440601468086243,
0.17474454641342163,
-0.3477979898452759,
-0.22479107975959778,
0.42370036244392395,
0.4734070599079132,
-0.13247674703598022,
0.7444230318069458,
0.10340405255556107,
-0.057444535195827484,
-0.07706472277641296,
-0.06230927258729935,
0.6809986233711243,
-0.8441463112831116,
-0.5297859907150269,
-0.6536080837249756,
0.21777498722076416,
-0.023754756897687912,
-0.04667256399989128,
0.39032313227653503,
0.6018975973129272,
0.6612305045127869,
-0.07846808433532715,
0.8038241863250732,
-0.23036204278469086,
-0.15278619527816772,
-0.6330171823501587,
0.8117021918296814,
-0.6231275200843811,
0.011503118090331554,
-0.34773337841033936,
-0.9146369099617004,
-0.41319039463996887,
0.7627617716789246,
0.016139233484864235,
-0.009366891346871853,
0.7465906143188477,
0.5920964479446411,
-0.2557617425918579,
0.13405655324459076,
0.5631216168403625,
0.10248072445392609,
0.498632550239563,
0.6286075115203857,
0.8697671890258789,
-0.28343039751052856,
0.016097966581583023,
0.013618912547826767,
-0.19268454611301422,
-0.05157811939716339,
-0.9517408013343811,
-0.7328968644142151,
-0.614697277545929,
-0.20833691954612732,
0.06750695407390594,
0.1429888904094696,
1.0829381942749023,
0.6724156141281128,
-0.5464888215065002,
-0.636186420917511,
-0.2729107439517975,
-0.06941720098257065,
-0.25139787793159485,
-0.13838118314743042,
0.08957623690366745,
-0.33768510818481445,
-0.8512004613876343,
0.6775883436203003,
0.38624823093414307,
0.4518401026725769,
-0.3785823881626129,
-0.23033232986927032,
-0.1386636644601822,
0.2979539632797241,
0.8971036672592163,
0.43387570977211,
-0.6720128655433655,
-0.4571705758571625,
0.026575623080134392,
-0.2972179055213928,
-0.5788062214851379,
1.045247197151184,
-0.7003458142280579,
0.7367861270904541,
0.15293842554092407,
0.5688182711601257,
0.912834107875824,
-0.48339536786079407,
1.0866265296936035,
-0.783417820930481,
0.5207879543304443,
0.37840625643730164,
0.5184640884399414,
-0.06481523811817169,
-0.00997887272387743,
0.5598567128181458,
-0.19219328463077545,
-0.4701501727104187,
-0.5201277136802673,
0.2670363187789917,
-0.9583964347839355,
-0.6204044818878174,
1.3186806440353394,
0.05782606080174446,
-0.2688131034374237,
0.10340418666601181,
-0.5741532444953918,
0.14729826152324677,
0.17329052090644836,
0.4235363006591797,
0.860139787197113,
-0.11747768521308899,
-0.2578263580799103,
-0.9118340611457825,
0.30067387223243713,
0.29934531450271606,
-0.9251635670661926,
0.15379644930362701,
0.6942788362503052,
0.08960099518299103,
-0.2592308223247528,
0.9362080097198486,
0.22103986144065857,
0.041775356978178024,
0.0622701533138752,
0.41021913290023804,
0.1797739714384079,
-0.22469620406627655,
0.14540418982505798,
-0.002042566891759634,
0.22770534455776215,
0.024510612711310387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16293v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16293v1 | Combining Supervised Learning and Reinforcement Learning for Multi-Label Classification Tasks with Partial Labels | 2024-06-24T03:36:19 | 2024-06-24T03:36:19 | Zixia Jia, Junpeng Li, Shichuan Zhang, Anji Liu, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional supervised learning heavily relies on human-annotated datasets,
especially in data-hungry neural approaches. However, various tasks, especially
multi-label tasks like document-level relation extraction, pose challenges in
fully manual annotation due to the specific domain knowledge and large class
sets. Therefore, we address the multi-label positive-unlabelled learning
(MLPUL) problem, where only a subset of positive classes is annotated. We
propose Mixture Learner for Partially Annotated Classification (MLPAC), an
RL-based framework combining the exploration ability of reinforcement learning
and the exploitation ability of supervised learning. Experimental results
across various tasks, including document-level relation extraction, multi-label
image classification, and binary PU learning, demonstrate the generalization
and effectiveness of our framework. | [
-0.5976777672767639,
-0.7406010031700134,
0.2927677631378174,
0.3657633364200592,
-0.03427422419190407,
0.3395284414291382,
-0.15033338963985443,
-0.48109689354896545,
0.11102650314569473,
0.6011672616004944,
-0.6304266452789307,
-0.4374978542327881,
-0.8115853071212769,
0.032033298164606094,
-0.0003024451725650579,
1.4883308410644531,
-0.12540750205516815,
-0.2302083820104599,
-0.4456976056098938,
-0.31271809339523315,
-0.5586495399475098,
-0.8543064594268799,
-0.5023418664932251,
-0.8495768904685974,
1.0150573253631592,
0.2928876578807831,
0.14988601207733154,
0.12982414662837982,
-0.03451022133231163,
0.2918020784854889,
0.10578503459692001,
0.5791256427764893,
-0.28845593333244324,
0.24111372232437134,
-0.22127726674079895,
-0.45339179039001465,
-0.07341648638248444,
0.36384153366088867,
0.3803521990776062,
0.6007603406906128,
-0.04815184697508812,
-0.06671208143234253,
0.13403721153736115,
0.3973606526851654,
-0.9410791397094727,
0.45530179142951965,
-0.12242146581411362,
0.5046338438987732,
0.16822271049022675,
-0.2582114338874817,
-0.6347752213478088,
-0.013338060118258,
0.16779178380966187,
-1.126939058303833,
-0.11583702266216278,
0.13348937034606934,
0.9127827882766724,
0.44307741522789,
-0.6455286145210266,
-0.2781960368156433,
-0.6312692165374756,
0.9916027188301086,
-0.20816318690776825,
0.42413634061813354,
0.6175506114959717,
0.2482864260673523,
-0.22929884493350983,
-0.6599157452583313,
-0.42663490772247314,
-0.3177812099456787,
-0.3242289423942566,
0.4619571268558502,
0.3102000057697296,
0.16237960755825043,
0.2883172929286957,
0.36257559061050415,
-0.07485879957675934,
0.20190857350826263,
-0.18745625019073486,
-0.4214284121990204,
0.4867230951786041,
-0.10617348551750183,
0.1261366903781891,
0.1711093783378601,
-0.8846766948699951,
-0.37444445490837097,
-0.23431982100009918,
0.2865799069404602,
0.18164992332458496,
0.28485244512557983,
-0.05377716198563576,
0.5272694230079651,
-0.023877082392573357,
0.8891744017601013,
0.09328518807888031,
-0.5266388654708862,
0.6363926529884338,
-0.11033334583044052,
-0.3259789049625397,
0.0917525663971901,
0.8336886167526245,
-0.22359105944633484,
-0.15524645149707794,
-0.3181931674480438,
-0.4116270840167999,
0.1217789500951767,
0.1970290094614029,
-0.5454457998275757,
-0.49804043769836426,
0.24071787297725677,
-0.11516685783863068,
-0.3692045211791992,
0.18386290967464447,
-0.6875250339508057,
-0.710285484790802,
-0.5822693109512329,
0.6047161221504211,
-0.28068897128105164,
-0.22504708170890808,
0.02614087611436844,
-0.40006721019744873,
0.04867856577038765,
0.4094955325126648,
-0.47860005497932434,
0.2158179134130478,
0.6336655020713806,
0.4385784864425659,
-0.31933146715164185,
-0.5561336278915405,
-0.9803760051727295,
0.18185609579086304,
-0.17527136206626892,
0.631009042263031,
-0.6095486879348755,
-0.5310028791427612,
0.01969446986913681,
0.028582625091075897,
-0.19773924350738525,
-0.48806989192962646,
0.6238857507705688,
-0.4976832866668701,
0.5016885995864868,
0.08468778431415558,
-0.65376877784729,
-0.3761979043483734,
0.5780134797096252,
-0.6776706576347351,
1.1888737678527832,
0.2864081859588623,
-0.7808001637458801,
0.6019213199615479,
-0.5039445161819458,
-0.7317673563957214,
-0.09615125507116318,
-0.2834913432598114,
-0.8727250099182129,
-0.33163586258888245,
0.19113653898239136,
0.5707784295082092,
0.11466240137815475,
0.5574445128440857,
-0.4584785997867584,
-0.2469833940267563,
0.6282564997673035,
-0.18751661479473114,
0.6543902158737183,
0.13717128336429596,
-0.2959747910499573,
0.5239278674125671,
-0.9450364112854004,
-0.38203805685043335,
-0.12832899391651154,
-0.7187007665634155,
-0.49991142749786377,
-0.1611787974834442,
-0.16105279326438904,
0.7853460311889648,
0.23167435824871063,
-0.5763826370239258,
0.270922988653183,
0.04043455421924591,
-0.19099284708499908,
0.6777399778366089,
0.4282113313674927,
0.4800688922405243,
-0.22158408164978027,
0.43433645367622375,
0.4229046702384949,
0.17600218951702118,
-0.060246456414461136,
-0.4870341718196869,
-1.0808261632919312,
-0.6540940403938293,
0.5736444592475891,
0.6382274627685547,
-1.2662138938903809,
0.7273520827293396,
0.37660178542137146,
-0.23153692483901978,
-0.442096471786499,
0.29121384024620056,
0.68916916847229,
0.68459552526474,
0.6451595425605774,
-0.2510770857334137,
-0.34524840116500854,
-0.807101845741272,
0.4175090491771698,
0.11514797806739807,
0.05206179618835449,
0.3892524242401123,
0.35347169637680054,
-0.34535080194473267,
0.7892079949378967,
-0.5093774795532227,
-0.6387593746185303,
-0.08392935991287231,
0.5892779231071472,
0.06853170692920685,
0.3228145241737366,
0.06078862398862839,
-1.079732060432434,
-0.3040621280670166,
0.06698225438594818,
-0.8888571858406067,
0.06174303591251373,
-0.4608599841594696,
-0.19987709820270538,
-0.011552490293979645,
0.2241135835647583,
-0.2235797643661499,
0.3349391222000122,
0.17641793191432953,
-0.015007310546934605,
0.3558233380317688,
-0.5751097202301025,
-0.11809923499822617,
-0.6527566909790039,
-0.21243974566459656,
0.7278572916984558,
-0.2660459578037262,
-0.6383373141288757,
-0.09317125380039215,
0.23645009100437164,
-0.1766708791255951,
-0.5133726596832275,
0.35444048047065735,
-0.3387562930583954,
-0.08856000751256943,
-0.49890679121017456,
-0.1735275834798813,
0.13379229605197906,
1.0192328691482544,
0.5196804404258728,
0.42224037647247314,
0.6413211226463318,
-0.8822737336158752,
0.18968597054481506,
0.1132524162530899,
0.08339081704616547,
0.359942227602005,
-0.13938018679618835,
-0.11444485187530518,
-0.21937169134616852,
0.7051337957382202,
-0.807392418384552,
-0.06999272108078003,
0.6549185514450073,
-0.12315665930509567,
0.6264020204544067,
0.07763084769248962,
-0.5775701403617859,
-0.19306014478206635,
-0.35860389471054077,
-0.002162875607609749,
0.19304871559143066,
-0.6593019962310791,
0.7076132893562317,
0.47020983695983887,
0.2611531913280487,
-0.7580412030220032,
-0.34519585967063904,
-0.37048429250717163,
-0.3427676558494568,
0.00901802908629179,
0.30324074625968933,
0.22887787222862244,
0.2981932759284973,
0.11411183327436447,
-0.19210581481456757,
-0.19280385971069336,
0.13770796358585358,
0.5624279379844666,
0.43705740571022034,
0.2864796221256256,
0.12346512079238892,
0.07975210249423981,
-0.335824191570282,
-0.18499833345413208,
-0.12780383229255676,
0.19368183612823486,
0.12137173116207123,
-0.16388875246047974,
-0.34064674377441406,
0.20181769132614136,
0.034264519810676575,
-0.45816701650619507,
0.8229140639305115,
0.9861283302307129,
-0.21739690005779266,
-0.31801852583885193,
-0.27416661381721497,
-0.04746977612376213,
-0.40817588567733765,
0.19804464280605316,
-0.5268188118934631,
-0.9034338593482971,
0.1773492842912674,
-0.43463966250419617,
0.17248784005641937,
0.3692377507686615,
0.49281179904937744,
-0.22665449976921082,
0.6270328760147095,
0.7189723253250122,
-0.10509837418794632,
0.5306902527809143,
-0.3017258048057556,
-0.04107268899679184,
-0.7802905440330505,
-0.8044655323028564,
-0.21195049583911896,
-0.3286883234977722,
-0.5489687919616699,
-0.37183877825737,
0.3262687027454376,
0.09620045870542526,
-0.31138211488723755,
0.1948581486940384,
-0.6353353261947632,
0.27522361278533936,
0.8938488364219666,
0.4757850468158722,
0.1829562485218048,
-0.05546637624502182,
-0.06582751125097275,
0.2028152048587799,
-0.6854141354560852,
0.1495455503463745,
0.9599519968032837,
0.32692843675613403,
0.4897315204143524,
-0.18417124450206757,
1.1149009466171265,
0.40381234884262085,
0.5737791657447815,
-0.6480159163475037,
0.243190199136734,
-0.0390724278986454,
-0.6023573875427246,
-0.22030048072338104,
-0.5285857915878296,
-0.9936220645904541,
0.8244301080703735,
-0.6984995007514954,
-0.585612952709198,
0.4921458065509796,
0.08970023691654205,
-0.11693039536476135,
0.12117710709571838,
-0.722878634929657,
0.9253144860267639,
-0.5083364844322205,
-0.4168229103088379,
0.11048341542482376,
-0.8267097473144531,
0.5977551341056824,
-0.2858321964740753,
0.40764787793159485,
0.0036593470722436905,
-0.25101718306541443,
0.7901997566223145,
-0.2133478969335556,
1.0623549222946167,
-0.5044198036193848,
0.07713241875171661,
0.33624571561813354,
-0.2624416649341583,
0.3864051103591919,
-0.1250351518392563,
0.35582685470581055,
-0.15485598146915436,
-0.2739163339138031,
-0.5408412218093872,
-0.6149877309799194,
0.38213834166526794,
-0.9864357709884644,
-0.004956982564181089,
-0.8667688369750977,
-0.5055022835731506,
-0.6432458162307739,
-0.05857660993933678,
-0.05096885561943054,
0.1504073441028595,
0.3970269560813904,
-0.20046834647655487,
0.870947003364563,
-0.5222801566123962,
0.10166908800601959,
0.32051336765289307,
-0.3531053364276886,
-0.5569758415222168,
1.6448408365249634,
-0.24266158044338226,
-0.013151848688721657,
0.6338175535202026,
0.18821756541728973,
-0.4281325042247772,
-0.23844777047634125,
-0.12438613176345825,
0.18545854091644287,
-0.5097582340240479,
-0.2007867842912674,
-0.5181666016578674,
-0.13263149559497833,
0.06169332191348076,
0.10983919352293015,
-0.04660779610276222,
-0.25676026940345764,
-0.5163517594337463,
-0.12843570113182068,
-0.024596353992819786,
0.4967907667160034,
-0.1472492665052414,
0.31615307927131653,
-0.5462789535522461,
0.6510637402534485,
0.4141174256801605,
-0.002131934277713299,
0.0030680950731039047,
-0.2955832779407501,
-0.15288449823856354,
-0.16149255633354187,
-0.52312833070755,
-0.9701104164123535,
0.2848849296569824,
0.13557814061641693,
0.7735841274261475,
0.36694765090942383,
0.16812153160572052,
0.46595001220703125,
-0.10627473890781403,
0.35010597109794617,
0.7012816667556763,
-0.3288945257663727,
0.4026685357093811,
0.023261209949851036,
-0.19332708418369293,
0.5985291004180908,
0.8268764615058899,
-0.30786675214767456,
-0.40406128764152527,
-0.7037146687507629,
-1.0938893556594849,
0.6902897357940674,
0.06679338216781616,
-0.4504989683628082,
0.15433873236179352,
-0.08106311410665512,
0.42571309208869934,
0.3669950067996979,
-1.0005133152008057,
-0.5531101822853088,
-0.32996276021003723,
-0.1143745705485344,
-0.24025005102157593,
0.02160245180130005,
-0.19894103705883026,
-0.210928812623024,
1.0826290845870972,
0.07885350286960602,
0.07905586808919907,
0.07627944648265839,
-0.26240745186805725,
0.4776897430419922,
0.49490201473236084,
0.36107388138771057,
0.18396826088428497,
-0.37586843967437744,
0.126888245344162,
-0.22178702056407928,
0.06143190711736679,
0.5077632665634155,
0.5391976833343506,
-0.10487820953130722,
-0.36709535121917725,
0.2736346125602722,
0.888803243637085,
0.49281471967697144,
-0.6118133664131165,
0.4773154854774475,
0.012750810012221336,
-0.48137205839157104,
-0.08714812248945236,
0.09655065089464188,
-0.01859988085925579,
0.21598947048187256,
0.3366207778453827,
-0.0701218843460083,
0.20190118253231049,
-0.4705452620983124,
0.5459604859352112,
0.06140262261033058,
-0.7143830060958862,
0.17506887018680573,
0.38746917247772217,
0.24113047122955322,
0.009432128630578518,
0.5494189858436584,
-0.6192039847373962,
-0.5783481001853943,
0.38585227727890015,
0.579382598400116,
0.355449914932251,
0.2473992556333542,
0.5987930297851562,
0.22410111129283905,
0.009324788115918636,
0.020747298374772072,
-0.18611180782318115,
-0.4693714380264282,
-0.670432448387146,
-0.7172856330871582,
-0.5525643229484558,
-0.6176616549491882,
0.16604392230510712,
-0.710869312286377,
-0.10725375264883041,
-0.5413309335708618,
0.018530389294028282,
0.2555396854877472,
0.06600414961576462,
-0.5138506293296814,
0.34313055872917175,
0.3067414462566376,
0.5114424228668213,
-1.0264523029327393,
1.0723040103912354,
0.8934149742126465,
-0.7252431511878967,
-0.7373300790786743,
-0.42045268416404724,
-0.12395747005939484,
-0.4128578007221222,
0.7475547790527344,
0.37154263257980347,
0.2386048436164856,
-0.4616580307483673,
-0.13900628685951233,
-0.11553962528705597,
0.8251501321792603,
-0.09222603589296341,
-0.48196932673454285,
0.287973552942276,
-0.08809769153594971,
0.3449804186820984,
-0.1819702684879303,
0.05874726548790932,
0.3249150812625885,
0.5183535218238831,
0.1843641996383667,
-0.5293675065040588,
-0.28559887409210205,
-0.032882653176784515,
-0.3917580842971802,
0.43285682797431946,
-0.593734085559845,
0.5584459900856018,
0.21690550446510315,
0.1668960303068161,
-0.33853620290756226,
0.9087967276573181,
0.642692506313324,
0.737636148929596,
0.6853481531143188,
0.6387990713119507,
0.9438855648040771,
-0.06017008051276207,
1.0209400653839111,
0.17033207416534424,
0.4519386887550354,
1.3111763000488281,
-0.3137303292751312,
0.5340492129325867,
0.3880268335342407,
-0.3445497751235962,
0.3296051323413849,
1.0461658239364624,
0.10928375273942947,
0.7847070097923279,
0.2689882218837738,
-0.6187393069267273,
-0.5218890309333801,
-0.24760884046554565,
-0.12823325395584106,
0.033947765827178955,
0.5424109697341919,
-0.09177466481924057,
-0.3140105903148651,
0.34359997510910034,
-0.17487162351608276,
-0.022883886471390724,
-0.39239412546157837,
0.9374560117721558,
0.0714113786816597,
-0.5690948963165283,
0.1664806455373764,
0.05392419174313545,
1.1219695806503296,
-0.5416125655174255,
-0.24123015999794006,
0.006527747958898544,
-0.01909930258989334,
-0.38843828439712524,
-0.8224138021469116,
-0.2674805819988251,
-0.37771353125572205,
0.0035548750311136246,
-0.13786093890666962,
1.0301783084869385,
-0.5914241671562195,
-0.4799405634403229,
0.33264148235321045,
0.4281875789165497,
-0.032303813844919205,
0.07258258014917374,
-0.9219177961349487,
-0.24709472060203552,
0.1557762324810028,
-0.060377947986125946,
0.8950323462486267,
0.4750109612941742,
0.08522471785545349,
0.6303762793540955,
0.6742210984230042,
-0.12295687198638916,
0.29336485266685486,
-0.07971019297838211,
0.9645949006080627,
-0.4478308856487274,
-0.4538600444793701,
-0.429279088973999,
0.5540833473205566,
-0.27295857667922974,
-0.15287922322750092,
0.4698021709918976,
0.73496013879776,
0.78547602891922,
-0.011776342988014221,
0.8516038060188293,
0.04868285730481148,
0.3555908203125,
-0.45460817217826843,
0.07243922352790833,
-0.5501479506492615,
-0.1076708510518074,
-0.16431698203086853,
-0.9014461040496826,
-0.45258674025535583,
0.6677543520927429,
-0.31746426224708557,
-0.19088473916053772,
0.5154421925544739,
0.2713707685470581,
-0.27469849586486816,
-0.11226368695497513,
0.3313051462173462,
-0.39832040667533875,
0.2921273410320282,
0.7881364226341248,
1.0932667255401611,
-0.006830185651779175,
0.41767728328704834,
-0.8400028347969055,
-0.4256575405597687,
0.05853395164012909,
-0.7477169036865234,
-0.9434438347816467,
-0.6567854285240173,
-0.580437958240509,
-0.2660471796989441,
-0.03509300947189331,
0.70865398645401,
0.7182562947273254,
-0.5084329843521118,
0.06759929656982422,
0.15948086977005005,
0.18568268418312073,
-0.31832244992256165,
-0.282640665769577,
0.4637581706047058,
-0.48875969648361206,
-0.4580162763595581,
0.42015939950942993,
0.2435651272535324,
-0.014013474807143211,
-0.1874849498271942,
-0.353040486574173,
-0.5296629667282104,
-0.4226961135864258,
0.631594181060791,
0.7386598587036133,
-0.4217161238193512,
0.10401741415262222,
-0.6554939150810242,
0.01909162476658821,
0.15064530074596405,
0.8647002577781677,
-0.9635311365127563,
0.4460577368736267,
0.05271964892745018,
1.0989538431167603,
1.0692479610443115,
0.14425088465213776,
-0.016050178557634354,
-1.1668798923492432,
0.406145304441452,
0.1722669005393982,
0.4538974165916443,
0.24426192045211792,
-0.2399260401725769,
0.44908854365348816,
0.12183219194412231,
-0.49199017882347107,
-0.5139487385749817,
0.18141025304794312,
-1.3215832710266113,
-0.5211935639381409,
1.029358983039856,
-0.4099985659122467,
-0.20659099519252777,
-0.18478089570999146,
-0.2778582274913788,
0.42608246207237244,
-0.6180486083030701,
0.4997400939464569,
0.48189297318458557,
-0.7358924746513367,
-0.2009655088186264,
-0.5095469355583191,
0.050924547016620636,
0.12815718352794647,
-1.0102458000183105,
-0.45778781175613403,
0.7439424991607666,
0.0932810977101326,
0.36877644062042236,
0.6329590678215027,
0.23665452003479004,
0.07004255801439285,
-0.14831732213497162,
0.1570853441953659,
-0.5451915264129639,
-0.5814915299415588,
-0.032281674444675446,
0.48528748750686646,
0.14863115549087524,
-0.6252011656761169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16288v1 | PlagBench: Exploring the Duality of Large Language Models in Plagiarism Generation and Detection | 2024-06-24T03:29:53 | 2024-06-24T03:29:53 | Jooyoung Lee, Toshini Agrawal, Adaku Uchendu, Thai Le, Jinghui Chen, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent literature has highlighted potential risks to academic integrity
associated with large language models (LLMs), as they can memorize parts of
training instances and reproduce them in the generated texts without proper
attribution. In addition, given their capabilities in generating high-quality
texts, plagiarists can exploit LLMs to generate realistic paraphrases or
summaries indistinguishable from original work. In response to possible
malicious use of LLMs in plagiarism, we introduce PlagBench, a comprehensive
dataset consisting of 46.5K synthetic plagiarism cases generated using three
instruction-tuned LLMs across three writing domains. The quality of PlagBench
is ensured through fine-grained automatic evaluation for each type of
plagiarism, complemented by human annotation. We then leverage our proposed
dataset to evaluate the plagiarism detection performance of five modern LLMs
and three specialized plagiarism checkers. Our findings reveal that GPT-3.5
tends to generates paraphrases and summaries of higher quality compared to
Llama2 and GPT-4. Despite LLMs' weak performance in summary plagiarism
identification, they can surpass current commercial plagiarism detectors.
Overall, our results highlight the potential of LLMs to serve as robust
plagiarism detection tools. | [
-0.17868012189865112,
-0.8424538969993591,
0.6789439916610718,
-0.008894332684576511,
-0.5207302570343018,
0.23950865864753723,
-0.09179401397705078,
-0.23548409342765808,
-0.1024404913187027,
0.7703067660331726,
-0.23777544498443604,
-0.5145673155784607,
-0.5500671863555908,
0.14567475020885468,
-0.7711322903633118,
1.2394393682479858,
-0.20165124535560608,
0.04505547508597374,
-0.49830126762390137,
-0.19100259244441986,
-0.11525429040193558,
-0.7107328176498413,
-0.4329081177711487,
-0.4073883891105652,
0.5814562439918518,
0.1462634801864624,
0.5194346904754639,
0.5173991322517395,
0.6097372174263,
0.2823476791381836,
-0.1006106585264206,
0.06049394607543945,
-0.6943972706794739,
0.11049316823482513,
-0.3237704336643219,
-0.4091171622276306,
-0.47772908210754395,
0.044246021658182144,
0.9524848461151123,
0.43033716082572937,
-0.02900124154984951,
0.22524672746658325,
0.21851202845573425,
0.43988388776779175,
-0.5147806406021118,
0.0404852032661438,
-0.6969727873802185,
-0.1806822121143341,
-0.5465273857116699,
-0.07268138229846954,
-0.49350136518478394,
-0.33519116044044495,
-0.18148092925548553,
-0.19058215618133545,
0.4477477967739105,
-0.052107494324445724,
0.6599884033203125,
0.0704045221209526,
-0.44498443603515625,
-0.6106049418449402,
-0.3022659122943878,
0.7817420959472656,
-0.7366179823875427,
-0.09977830946445465,
0.04210139438509941,
0.21600058674812317,
-0.23986083269119263,
-0.8794872760772705,
-0.6242627501487732,
-0.19767563045024872,
-0.14260177314281464,
0.14918653666973114,
0.06716319173574448,
-0.03245324268937111,
0.21446660161018372,
0.6647910475730896,
-0.7243560552597046,
0.2891216576099396,
-0.16567790508270264,
-0.4163857400417328,
0.71531081199646,
0.10279425233602524,
0.3710799515247345,
0.025142792612314224,
-0.343087375164032,
-0.12300806492567062,
-0.8058803081512451,
-0.2648005187511444,
0.8432322144508362,
0.06643541902303696,
0.13815435767173767,
0.38530516624450684,
0.24578869342803955,
0.42195284366607666,
-0.41580748558044434,
-0.16148920357227325,
0.19427670538425446,
-0.3705730140209198,
-0.01943148672580719,
0.006598120555281639,
0.7928471565246582,
0.23677411675453186,
0.19423237442970276,
-0.2268763780593872,
-0.2427983582019806,
0.1854596585035324,
0.023701993748545647,
-0.7119868993759155,
-0.4437938928604126,
0.05799771100282669,
-0.37128105759620667,
-0.3933021128177643,
0.27559417486190796,
-0.9164575338363647,
-0.606921374797821,
-0.4980730712413788,
0.352723628282547,
-0.3840857446193695,
-0.3849903345108032,
-0.011770762503147125,
-0.06773558259010315,
0.2173280268907547,
0.20830734074115753,
-0.49347758293151855,
0.17076687514781952,
0.8934873342514038,
0.8774927854537964,
-0.47060099244117737,
-0.6159238815307617,
-0.49015501141548157,
0.29482558369636536,
-0.2377774864435196,
0.9315075874328613,
-0.2900472581386566,
-0.3916838765144348,
0.008668215945363045,
-0.03102266788482666,
0.130098357796669,
-0.6637719869613647,
0.6628788709640503,
-0.412794291973114,
0.20631428062915802,
-0.2814272940158844,
-0.6488550901412964,
-0.18433313071727753,
-0.06121046468615532,
-0.8310391306877136,
0.9279730916023254,
-0.08565427362918854,
-0.8369859457015991,
0.33526185154914856,
-0.3611050546169281,
-0.5653381943702698,
0.1507144272327423,
-0.014620435424149036,
-0.7195909023284912,
0.18830297887325287,
-0.14039821922779083,
0.48127755522727966,
-0.34860482811927795,
0.4370788633823395,
-0.3324744999408722,
-0.401572048664093,
0.3575288951396942,
-0.3110574781894684,
0.7719239592552185,
-0.02564840018749237,
-0.16872303187847137,
0.2913198173046112,
-0.6520272493362427,
-0.33445149660110474,
0.4049754738807678,
-0.523285984992981,
-0.4357295334339142,
-0.07275645434856415,
0.025189826264977455,
0.3100120723247528,
0.44097989797592163,
-0.5007647275924683,
-0.20098865032196045,
-0.15339557826519012,
0.41697046160697937,
0.8033310174942017,
-0.0017420618096366525,
0.21201980113983154,
-0.5087376832962036,
0.5131411552429199,
-0.1496003419160843,
-0.180312380194664,
-0.10273899883031845,
-0.13588111102581024,
-0.707177996635437,
-0.502147912979126,
0.30644670128822327,
0.39768141508102417,
-0.5641658902168274,
0.33572062849998474,
-0.3469484746456146,
-0.4047555923461914,
-0.4403199255466461,
0.45997384190559387,
0.6008639335632324,
0.3110514283180237,
0.3344556391239166,
-0.17170076072216034,
-0.37812966108322144,
-1.0001590251922607,
-0.7263177633285522,
0.02160939760506153,
-0.1529872864484787,
-0.11243126541376114,
0.9274286031723022,
0.15135183930397034,
0.8323681354522705,
-0.15371137857437134,
-0.2968219816684723,
-0.3636341989040375,
0.3446601629257202,
-0.044156577438116074,
0.2963184416294098,
0.6479493975639343,
-0.8142294883728027,
-0.5643568634986877,
-0.2741730511188507,
-0.9656113982200623,
-0.3905067443847656,
-0.22460009157657623,
-0.17686975002288818,
0.26308873295783997,
0.487741082906723,
-0.44613999128341675,
0.05802340433001518,
0.40921059250831604,
-0.27569133043289185,
0.650357723236084,
-0.11899423599243164,
-0.2300880402326584,
-0.9908851981163025,
0.48340868949890137,
-0.2842979431152344,
-0.31551969051361084,
-0.41986963152885437,
0.35494911670684814,
0.18836112320423126,
-0.01410020049661398,
-0.3093407452106476,
0.3984771966934204,
-0.5126809477806091,
-0.20056769251823425,
-0.4615744650363922,
0.21353890001773834,
0.010451470501720905,
0.22297999262809753,
-0.18762841820716858,
0.8151733875274658,
0.24966704845428467,
-0.08898288011550903,
0.4386012554168701,
0.21359172463417053,
-0.3751346170902252,
0.6787678003311157,
-0.5149368643760681,
0.3014070689678192,
-0.27565324306488037,
0.5257760882377625,
-0.8620979189872742,
-0.4205072224140167,
-0.0557921938598156,
-0.050933629274368286,
0.23473669588565826,
-0.11275546252727509,
-0.9980087280273438,
-0.1981031596660614,
-0.7137631773948669,
0.01906360685825348,
0.5098993182182312,
-0.5880460143089294,
0.4948442280292511,
0.29742029309272766,
-0.4372732639312744,
-0.3954974412918091,
-0.6098727583885193,
0.32243332266807556,
-0.2890176773071289,
-0.5395421385765076,
0.08565601706504822,
-0.02571728266775608,
-0.24665029346942902,
-0.2088065892457962,
-0.11685771495103836,
0.07527686655521393,
0.2370474487543106,
0.18941786885261536,
0.2200428992509842,
0.03812558948993683,
-0.013271896168589592,
0.09433291107416153,
-0.010147702880203724,
0.07254263013601303,
-0.06247873231768608,
0.6376274228096008,
-0.1628907471895218,
-0.32506927847862244,
-0.283474862575531,
0.518394947052002,
0.7143133878707886,
-0.31366440653800964,
0.7903399467468262,
0.5448280572891235,
-0.10551445186138153,
-0.3653446435928345,
-0.6109529137611389,
-0.24689233303070068,
-0.4315396845340729,
0.19758066534996033,
-0.3509697914123535,
-0.6987539529800415,
0.44073987007141113,
0.0018615785520523787,
0.27074819803237915,
0.3032311499118805,
0.705058217048645,
0.2101767510175705,
0.6968511343002319,
0.3028123378753662,
0.055783383548259735,
0.3800279200077057,
-0.1195867583155632,
0.338944673538208,
-0.4894077777862549,
-0.056079644709825516,
-0.1959606111049652,
-0.25864219665527344,
-0.3928123712539673,
-0.2943592965602875,
0.2142425775527954,
0.1438574641942978,
-0.0740579292178154,
0.12849892675876617,
-0.2560829222202301,
0.6080195903778076,
0.741898775100708,
-0.14703971147537231,
0.461883544921875,
0.10247648507356644,
-0.07099244743585587,
0.1139017641544342,
-0.3135848343372345,
-0.9477446675300598,
1.1626449823379517,
0.1538892388343811,
0.3797917068004608,
0.13663150370121002,
0.8133172392845154,
0.1046152263879776,
0.4185265898704529,
-0.3882612884044647,
0.8463068604469299,
-0.37105998396873474,
-0.7198391556739807,
0.09579391777515411,
-0.40067747235298157,
-0.7589529752731323,
0.5187239050865173,
-0.014011053368449211,
-0.35361120104789734,
-0.2740679979324341,
0.11839127540588379,
-0.1274765580892563,
0.407421350479126,
-0.6800282001495361,
0.8642451763153076,
-0.24330683052539825,
-0.8505927920341492,
-0.16943207383155823,
-0.5872092843055725,
0.5107829570770264,
-0.5431603193283081,
0.23368418216705322,
-0.28921183943748474,
-0.048797428607940674,
0.7023923397064209,
-0.23478952050209045,
0.754530131816864,
-0.12608063220977783,
-0.1983572542667389,
0.36406537890434265,
0.3948986828327179,
0.5481675863265991,
0.10668481141328812,
-0.06980296224355698,
0.34282058477401733,
-0.011223790235817432,
-0.46031108498573303,
-0.052754804491996765,
0.9333403706550598,
-0.418978750705719,
-0.6062880754470825,
-0.45550617575645447,
-0.7462077140808105,
0.059411775320768356,
0.4949413537979126,
0.24010419845581055,
0.15562061965465546,
-0.07302429527044296,
0.38972553610801697,
0.3061664402484894,
-0.17971056699752808,
0.36017081141471863,
0.5800724029541016,
-0.026588376611471176,
-0.14550697803497314,
1.0535262823104858,
0.016317499801516533,
0.2262248694896698,
0.18635553121566772,
0.14457206428050995,
-0.2148580104112625,
-0.9121479392051697,
-0.2472190409898758,
0.5692561864852905,
-0.8200520873069763,
-0.19199520349502563,
-0.4694770872592926,
-0.028244752436876297,
-0.3092615008354187,
-0.2529037296772003,
-0.09327849000692368,
-0.11727415770292282,
-0.32831767201423645,
-0.052252501249313354,
0.2106161117553711,
0.6002354621887207,
0.042591437697410583,
0.2520964741706848,
-0.5829373598098755,
0.2613402009010315,
0.226282000541687,
0.23150496184825897,
-0.25731077790260315,
-0.4640175700187683,
0.12620238959789276,
-0.1179674044251442,
-0.27671536803245544,
-0.6419879794120789,
0.4265685975551605,
0.05945141240954399,
0.44596511125564575,
0.05982557684183121,
-0.14741140604019165,
0.2306046187877655,
-0.3707277476787567,
0.81878262758255,
-0.06789791584014893,
-0.9324761629104614,
0.1928078979253769,
-0.5708459615707397,
0.07225888967514038,
0.6110388040542603,
0.26343855261802673,
-0.07205633074045181,
-0.6577737927436829,
-0.44425809383392334,
-0.9982487559318542,
0.6997738480567932,
0.12034466117620468,
0.10914835333824158,
0.33405598998069763,
0.34256017208099365,
0.4297538101673126,
0.5031088590621948,
-0.8936783671379089,
0.09407772868871689,
-0.11025507748126984,
-0.5737032294273376,
-0.22409868240356445,
-0.562756359577179,
-0.17454977333545685,
0.22279970347881317,
0.5681038498878479,
-0.0893542692065239,
-0.09679720550775528,
-0.1782272309064865,
-0.46372950077056885,
0.16366110742092133,
0.23916979134082794,
0.46708813309669495,
0.6878616809844971,
-0.06157587841153145,
0.23631447553634644,
0.115618996322155,
-0.3712562322616577,
0.0022010065149515867,
0.01224147342145443,
-0.04322916641831398,
0.06333448737859726,
0.5958630442619324,
0.5511571168899536,
0.04236890375614166,
-0.8774879574775696,
0.5933031439781189,
0.20421497523784637,
-0.144872784614563,
-0.6115304231643677,
0.06655415892601013,
0.15826168656349182,
-0.0012312029721215367,
0.11266550421714783,
-0.3051762580871582,
0.06946125626564026,
-0.5543343424797058,
0.024626294150948524,
0.42920663952827454,
0.3931589722633362,
-0.5025578737258911,
0.6791155934333801,
0.06254297494888306,
-0.09712796658277512,
0.323494017124176,
-0.11492675542831421,
-0.5082263946533203,
0.2956007719039917,
0.44708412885665894,
0.6334673166275024,
-0.17768147587776184,
-0.03627772629261017,
-0.023285256698727608,
0.09424450248479843,
-0.42060816287994385,
0.17659425735473633,
0.05576876550912857,
-0.4878852367401123,
-0.32280096411705017,
-0.8758948445320129,
-0.32699593901634216,
0.4572155475616455,
-0.5600972175598145,
0.34712404012680054,
-0.5175597071647644,
0.09478294104337692,
0.23508457839488983,
-0.22614021599292755,
-0.2976008355617523,
-0.33011379837989807,
0.345185250043869,
0.3173346221446991,
-0.9238451719284058,
0.8030709624290466,
0.8132227659225464,
-0.3855172097682953,
-0.27147334814071655,
0.07951678335666656,
0.22315627336502075,
-0.6762048006057739,
0.47111642360687256,
0.2713046073913574,
-0.23685334622859955,
0.1795879602432251,
-0.4511891305446625,
-0.44536158442497253,
1.1343756914138794,
0.7071523070335388,
-0.5273852944374084,
-0.2308608889579773,
0.2989295721054077,
0.6649054288864136,
0.10049953311681747,
-0.14360812306404114,
0.9953761696815491,
0.3075767457485199,
-0.11733003705739975,
-0.7945711016654968,
0.08100227266550064,
-0.08428642898797989,
-0.09712451696395874,
0.4063608646392822,
-0.7280051708221436,
1.1081726551055908,
0.28137311339378357,
-0.25066936016082764,
0.2190324068069458,
0.08446526527404785,
0.34063711762428284,
0.07893970608711243,
0.09629710018634796,
0.5673454403877258,
0.563473105430603,
-0.048706043511629105,
1.0972700119018555,
-0.17738932371139526,
0.27619194984436035,
1.1024854183197021,
-0.5233275890350342,
0.7300411462783813,
0.5476521253585815,
-0.16264383494853973,
0.5697230100631714,
0.26485657691955566,
-0.3588937819004059,
0.2809315621852875,
0.2825946807861328,
-0.4890034794807434,
-0.23693089187145233,
0.06845644861459732,
-0.04806070774793625,
0.39933446049690247,
0.3579021394252777,
-0.5916711091995239,
-0.4427061975002289,
-0.005307886749505997,
0.2349175214767456,
0.2777836322784424,
-0.1893387883901596,
0.7697659134864807,
0.12635841965675354,
-0.6632164120674133,
0.6044108867645264,
0.043199826031923294,
0.6601777076721191,
-0.4634813964366913,
0.128061443567276,
-0.26683157682418823,
0.6383879780769348,
-0.18922752141952515,
-0.8266888856887817,
0.09675382822751999,
0.19061918556690216,
0.053910303860902786,
-0.37784838676452637,
0.7573491334915161,
-0.4575757384300232,
-0.3662027418613434,
0.32966503500938416,
0.4709955155849457,
0.28310465812683105,
-0.1582549810409546,
-0.6063035726547241,
0.12257681041955948,
-0.052286937832832336,
-0.30369916558265686,
0.6097204089164734,
0.22410356998443604,
-0.021816542372107506,
0.3658106029033661,
0.8349229693412781,
0.05907130241394043,
0.08607035130262375,
-0.02389185130596161,
0.6131535172462463,
-0.28468015789985657,
-0.47727540135383606,
-1.1063743829727173,
0.23937056958675385,
-0.3919348418712616,
-0.06294482946395874,
1.0554916858673096,
0.7227882742881775,
0.9178004860877991,
-0.10984691977500916,
1.009755253791809,
0.30151450634002686,
0.7315605282783508,
-0.49325013160705566,
0.6871195435523987,
-0.35605117678642273,
0.2493222951889038,
-0.07187377661466599,
-0.8105329275131226,
-0.439136803150177,
0.5283449292182922,
-0.5607380270957947,
-0.11301931738853455,
0.7216569185256958,
0.7452285885810852,
-0.1397709846496582,
0.08243744820356369,
0.15546274185180664,
0.16440331935882568,
0.5213144421577454,
0.5420122742652893,
0.8560554385185242,
-0.1180160641670227,
0.7109884023666382,
-0.11272081732749939,
-0.07411546260118484,
-0.4258272349834442,
-0.7944602966308594,
-1.1677887439727783,
-0.23901455104351044,
-0.3482958972454071,
-0.3036852478981018,
-0.0411800779402256,
0.40264883637428284,
0.0352330319583416,
-0.9949132800102234,
-0.2179242968559265,
-0.4377500116825104,
-0.14116041362285614,
0.1918487250804901,
-0.2567513883113861,
0.41736242175102234,
-0.20567826926708221,
-0.7595637440681458,
0.3297644555568695,
0.12275545299053192,
0.23448826372623444,
-0.41650474071502686,
0.33474645018577576,
-0.09044130146503448,
0.07777950912714005,
0.5178012847900391,
0.004351858515292406,
-0.6458497047424316,
-0.04788307100534439,
-0.5152602195739746,
-0.19758962094783783,
-0.13574478030204773,
1.0521776676177979,
-0.49903494119644165,
0.1640879213809967,
0.6079109311103821,
0.4367247521877289,
0.46965160965919495,
0.021660441532731056,
0.4421546459197998,
-0.6870503425598145,
0.31315121054649353,
0.41159889101982117,
0.5073961019515991,
0.6197282671928406,
0.038224440068006516,
0.26795342564582825,
0.408720463514328,
-0.6393212080001831,
-1.2360353469848633,
0.06637444347143173,
-0.4722343683242798,
-0.6167949438095093,
1.356337308883667,
-0.456785649061203,
-0.11141461133956909,
-0.17056095600128174,
-0.29468289017677307,
0.24225395917892456,
-0.26924002170562744,
0.6903833150863647,
0.8459660410881042,
0.16691561043262482,
0.222992941737175,
-0.8082356452941895,
0.3923915922641754,
0.4710569977760315,
-0.7722074389457703,
0.3619805872440338,
0.6499422192573547,
0.6284219026565552,
0.06657625734806061,
0.09119806438684464,
-0.2675972878932953,
0.21036188304424286,
0.06832937151193619,
0.13932108879089355,
-0.34900379180908203,
-0.044114746153354645,
-0.4885742664337158,
0.49571681022644043,
0.0817217081785202,
0.13071759045124054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16275v1 | Investigating the Influence of Prompt-Specific Shortcuts in AI Generated Text Detection | 2024-06-24T02:50:09 | 2024-06-24T02:50:09 | Choonghyun Park, Hyuhng Joon Kim, Junyeob Kim, Youna Kim, Taeuk Kim, Hyunsoo Cho, Hwiyeol Jo, Sang-goo Lee, Kang Min Yoo | cs.CL | cs.CL | AI Generated Text (AIGT) detectors are developed with texts from humans and
LLMs of common tasks. Despite the diversity of plausible prompt choices, these
datasets are generally constructed with a limited number of prompts. The lack
of prompt variation can introduce prompt-specific shortcut features that exist
in data collected with the chosen prompt, but do not generalize to others. In
this paper, we analyze the impact of such shortcuts in AIGT detection. We
propose Feedback-based Adversarial Instruction List Optimization (FAILOpt), an
attack that searches for instructions deceptive to AIGT detectors exploiting
prompt-specific shortcuts. FAILOpt effectively drops the detection performance
of the target detector, comparable to other attacks based on adversarial
in-context examples. We also utilize our method to enhance the robustness of
the detector by mitigating the shortcuts. Based on the findings, we further
train the classifier with the dataset augmented by FAILOpt prompt. The
augmented classifier exhibits improvements across generation models, tasks, and
attacks. Our code will be available at https://github.com/zxcvvxcz/FAILOpt. | [
-0.4292580187320709,
-0.8029419183731079,
0.48049139976501465,
-0.41343972086906433,
-0.23232468962669373,
0.03766593337059021,
-0.17787952721118927,
0.03799846023321152,
-0.11685363203287125,
0.30124619603157043,
-0.7873586416244507,
-0.5457088947296143,
-0.7631122469902039,
0.30474618077278137,
-0.22937670350074768,
1.2438174486160278,
0.06431753188371658,
-0.2819657623767853,
0.009375665336847305,
0.020890522748231888,
-0.6091366410255432,
-0.3751952052116394,
-0.8746477365493774,
0.10547153651714325,
0.3196934461593628,
0.4801432192325592,
0.8126672506332397,
0.6257572770118713,
0.4771156311035156,
0.2655780017375946,
-0.10023831576108932,
0.3638836741447449,
-0.296644389629364,
0.021907301619648933,
0.18304342031478882,
-0.4146975874900818,
-0.08426307141780853,
-0.05538111925125122,
0.45229703187942505,
0.041455816477537155,
0.23398032784461975,
-0.07150328159332275,
0.23116295039653778,
0.27269235253334045,
-0.6584227085113525,
-0.08028506487607956,
-0.5665388107299805,
-0.05733458325266838,
-0.2968558967113495,
-0.4056161046028137,
-0.4619113802909851,
-0.449237197637558,
0.07432211190462112,
-0.3315832316875458,
0.41293102502822876,
0.0005307254614308476,
0.6200829148292542,
0.6935955286026001,
-0.190079003572464,
-0.706339418888092,
-0.33738091588020325,
0.6185867786407471,
-0.6001854538917542,
-0.030637240037322044,
0.2144923061132431,
0.21675637364387512,
-0.37213772535324097,
-0.4350329041481018,
-0.33490607142448425,
-0.5909977555274963,
-0.23241783678531647,
0.016900353133678436,
-0.4167386293411255,
0.48815181851387024,
0.4154912531375885,
-0.06005144491791725,
-0.6207907199859619,
-0.04470616951584816,
-0.16276194155216217,
-0.2885834574699402,
0.34540292620658875,
0.14330443739891052,
0.7171170115470886,
-0.37357568740844727,
-0.2912497818470001,
-0.10099691152572632,
-0.7623755931854248,
0.07453671097755432,
0.5623061656951904,
0.28518301248550415,
0.24827958643436432,
0.29821062088012695,
0.032285310328006744,
0.6974324584007263,
0.025111377239227295,
0.010795557871460915,
0.01863286830484867,
-0.3391019403934479,
0.09754334390163422,
0.028228139504790306,
1.0178066492080688,
0.11322548240423203,
0.10117986053228378,
-0.03870958089828491,
-0.21281392872333527,
-0.012535376474261284,
0.2271556556224823,
-0.7245818972587585,
-0.30777204036712646,
-0.09551338851451874,
-0.3890603184700012,
-0.5162491202354431,
0.1516980677843094,
-0.39476823806762695,
-0.2770957946777344,
-0.007626102771610022,
0.2973308265209198,
-0.5816935300827026,
0.37170174717903137,
-0.35962724685668945,
-0.40705668926239014,
-0.09136177599430084,
0.281374990940094,
-0.4749290347099304,
-0.18245956301689148,
0.634391725063324,
0.7637251019477844,
-0.1712275594472885,
-0.38225311040878296,
-1.042991042137146,
-0.09130492061376572,
-0.12307535111904144,
0.6762604117393494,
-0.5675045847892761,
-0.632098913192749,
-0.21158884465694427,
-0.1473894566297531,
-0.19642102718353271,
-0.5223941206932068,
0.7855333089828491,
-0.3920377790927887,
0.4353455603122711,
-0.3657293915748596,
-0.3990488648414612,
-0.1426805853843689,
0.4968899190425873,
-0.6243522763252258,
0.7882142663002014,
-0.21200816333293915,
-0.8556823134422302,
0.35750633478164673,
-0.8859026432037354,
-0.67221599817276,
0.12970279157161713,
-0.2892107367515564,
-0.6539214253425598,
-0.10312007367610931,
0.6161273717880249,
0.12862186133861542,
-0.08272518962621689,
0.08820877224206924,
-0.17971773445606232,
-0.7451358437538147,
0.09128465503454208,
-1.0203702449798584,
0.6485992670059204,
0.09532511979341507,
-0.879389226436615,
0.1726365089416504,
-0.5903911590576172,
0.17183749377727509,
0.007122550625354052,
-0.3786781132221222,
-0.27942681312561035,
0.007142188493162394,
-0.1026357039809227,
-0.1971033364534378,
0.14083091914653778,
-0.19571493566036224,
0.448890745639801,
-0.2625932991504669,
0.1878693848848343,
0.9009764790534973,
0.26969707012176514,
0.012503594160079956,
-0.13317807018756866,
0.9937409162521362,
-0.2727375328540802,
0.21678930521011353,
-0.2824143171310425,
-0.3866083025932312,
-0.44667407870292664,
-0.37071895599365234,
0.20423993468284607,
0.7941945195198059,
-1.2251479625701904,
0.40507760643959045,
0.0406249575316906,
-0.2882276773452759,
-0.3658694922924042,
0.14238175749778748,
0.7761414647102356,
0.47793859243392944,
0.2456573247909546,
0.004974587354809046,
-0.2344444841146469,
-0.7967427968978882,
-0.5724673271179199,
-0.45388442277908325,
-0.17235825955867767,
0.4610925316810608,
0.3806948661804199,
-0.18865425884723663,
0.7483855485916138,
-0.6242445111274719,
-0.31632792949676514,
-0.35369232296943665,
0.17962147295475006,
0.0403117761015892,
0.15588024258613586,
0.8110741972923279,
-0.6664689779281616,
-0.505348265171051,
-0.39568042755126953,
-0.580201268196106,
-0.1393383890390396,
-0.2886914908885956,
0.05009344965219498,
-0.10325851291418076,
0.4852389395236969,
-0.6029739379882812,
0.7583516836166382,
-0.008252947591245174,
-0.357225239276886,
0.5607006549835205,
-0.10781805962324142,
0.40795668959617615,
-0.8406189680099487,
0.008665855042636395,
-0.2290562242269516,
-0.23150129616260529,
-0.45432764291763306,
0.15370619297027588,
-0.05507257953286171,
-0.29980406165122986,
-0.6125140190124512,
0.35716578364372253,
-0.3938966691493988,
0.142266184091568,
-0.5813512802124023,
-0.036882635205984116,
-0.009763508103787899,
0.4740028381347656,
-0.23832876980304718,
1.3636356592178345,
0.23011557757854462,
-0.5110324025154114,
0.31495583057403564,
0.3453757166862488,
0.07987318187952042,
0.3550552725791931,
-0.6709080338478088,
0.4654448330402374,
-0.11598413437604904,
0.27992385625839233,
-0.929673433303833,
-0.17300328612327576,
0.7354838252067566,
-0.7211207747459412,
0.2758973240852356,
-0.19515493512153625,
-0.39998310804367065,
-0.3566891849040985,
-0.7543685436248779,
0.20823653042316437,
0.3237551748752594,
-1.0151044130325317,
0.24745962023735046,
-0.19508758187294006,
0.08253438025712967,
-0.7450608611106873,
-0.47310197353363037,
0.0790124461054802,
-0.34628745913505554,
-0.5788586735725403,
0.0915403962135315,
-0.21739798784255981,
0.021917615085840225,
0.09290384501218796,
0.1817389279603958,
0.37205103039741516,
0.3389193117618561,
0.17125524580478668,
0.2016543447971344,
-0.13443656265735626,
0.02863636612892151,
-0.0013174291234463453,
-0.053518109023571014,
0.1654587835073471,
-0.12567204236984253,
0.34829288721084595,
-0.2590826451778412,
-0.5081819295883179,
-0.6697556972503662,
0.5110034942626953,
0.5653777122497559,
-0.06121840700507164,
0.5042212605476379,
0.6766537427902222,
-0.12330468744039536,
-0.379231333732605,
-0.015948370099067688,
-0.3534714877605438,
-0.5893777012825012,
0.4948907792568207,
-0.18287982046604156,
-0.553915798664093,
0.2019338607788086,
0.15912164747714996,
-0.11093021929264069,
0.1930420696735382,
0.2548213303089142,
-0.035564642399549484,
1.0054957866668701,
0.28674763441085815,
-0.3437744975090027,
0.6533268094062805,
-0.33660683035850525,
0.1918988823890686,
-0.7357818484306335,
0.13246400654315948,
-0.46868252754211426,
-0.3192586600780487,
-0.5141767859458923,
-0.13427281379699707,
0.6525352597236633,
-0.0724220797419548,
-0.0546514168381691,
0.20777329802513123,
-0.9302806258201599,
0.6953651905059814,
1.0438505411148071,
0.4169379770755768,
-0.11197791248559952,
-0.1612124890089035,
0.2128053456544876,
0.03337939456105232,
-0.8154003620147705,
-0.3996666371822357,
1.1552402973175049,
0.014964786358177662,
0.7362109422683716,
-0.17716443538665771,
0.9514601230621338,
0.7192394733428955,
-0.031992439180612564,
-0.645190417766571,
0.6760815978050232,
-0.32821276783943176,
-0.207497701048851,
-0.11204381287097931,
-0.37216633558273315,
-0.8623576164245605,
-0.16182464361190796,
0.3127383291721344,
-0.4873316287994385,
-0.020687038078904152,
0.566952109336853,
-0.39624759554862976,
0.3469047546386719,
-0.9457062482833862,
0.9414956569671631,
-0.47035518288612366,
-0.055197108536958694,
0.08519664406776428,
-0.4233359098434448,
0.1808951497077942,
0.42975813150405884,
-0.14536556601524353,
0.1714666187763214,
0.11398014426231384,
0.6605461239814758,
-0.6565935015678406,
0.8547636866569519,
-0.4370104968547821,
0.25896382331848145,
0.7033270597457886,
-0.02868039906024933,
1.1266286373138428,
0.17777903378009796,
0.202545166015625,
-0.10472550988197327,
-0.6116393208503723,
-0.18131661415100098,
-0.5547616481781006,
0.6170251965522766,
-0.6071158051490784,
-0.885898232460022,
-0.43808209896087646,
-0.3327794671058655,
-0.029410313814878464,
0.07627939432859421,
0.9031267166137695,
0.5785104036331177,
-0.044433750212192535,
-0.11190647631883621,
0.5374471545219421,
-0.24351303279399872,
0.628525972366333,
-0.08598049730062485,
0.33808261156082153,
-0.4791003167629242,
1.1297860145568848,
-0.11661496758460999,
0.2640857696533203,
0.15347695350646973,
0.12106815725564957,
-0.2921784818172455,
-0.689260721206665,
-0.6169303059577942,
-0.19983476400375366,
-0.9313802719116211,
-0.4211673438549042,
-0.357088565826416,
-0.19673283398151398,
-0.2972055971622467,
-0.21620774269104004,
-0.05080052465200424,
-0.1638815701007843,
-0.8592842817306519,
-0.05530514568090439,
0.41220390796661377,
0.40810850262641907,
-0.025271333754062653,
0.6048816442489624,
-0.7876323461532593,
0.32482874393463135,
0.2862705886363983,
-0.08855396509170532,
-0.054307229816913605,
-0.32341820001602173,
-0.01829509437084198,
-0.060555942356586456,
-0.43723008036613464,
-0.9561792016029358,
0.19644324481487274,
0.22369414567947388,
0.48894020915031433,
0.441863089799881,
0.3604193925857544,
0.15743552148342133,
-0.38509735465049744,
0.8927801847457886,
-0.02190975286066532,
-0.8720123171806335,
0.8986057639122009,
-0.4207156300544739,
0.5584742426872253,
0.729421854019165,
0.05311989039182663,
-0.2547244429588318,
-0.4819253087043762,
-0.4733463227748871,
-0.7347845435142517,
0.8131566643714905,
0.3407193720340729,
0.013649052940309048,
-0.17258472740650177,
0.21155399084091187,
0.05686650052666664,
0.3111827075481415,
-0.39461439847946167,
-0.5109853148460388,
-0.039777711033821106,
-0.33785778284072876,
0.3886542320251465,
-0.25178101658821106,
-0.08674975484609604,
0.29490354657173157,
0.7369982600212097,
-0.21479946374893188,
0.40395882725715637,
0.02139122039079666,
-0.04951109364628792,
0.22874386608600616,
0.4533230662345886,
0.7099478840827942,
0.15855689346790314,
-0.09035947918891907,
-0.11448018997907639,
-0.04378203675150871,
-0.7352951765060425,
0.2069140076637268,
0.3252843916416168,
-0.8374249339103699,
0.39330440759658813,
0.550912082195282,
1.0981603860855103,
-0.22143688797950745,
-0.6211856603622437,
0.47099539637565613,
-0.22270268201828003,
0.2193230837583542,
-0.17333459854125977,
0.4362371563911438,
-0.6386498808860779,
0.25702789425849915,
0.5215168595314026,
0.5618889331817627,
0.619222104549408,
-0.3000660240650177,
0.3506835401058197,
0.7696995735168457,
-0.3939896821975708,
-0.1637670397758484,
0.8171690106391907,
0.278748095035553,
-0.5828297734260559,
0.6281105875968933,
-0.44563138484954834,
-1.1789684295654297,
0.887225866317749,
0.12848453223705292,
1.2224280834197998,
-0.010069984011352062,
0.3032657206058502,
0.09634815156459808,
0.5831988453865051,
0.28109613060951233,
0.04158161208033562,
-0.2098323553800583,
-0.2887219488620758,
0.07140164077281952,
0.0028583863750100136,
-0.5275892019271851,
0.22026507556438446,
-0.4862048923969269,
0.5480364561080933,
-0.4275543987751007,
-0.21172133088111877,
-0.26928263902664185,
-0.17591312527656555,
-0.7194766998291016,
0.22410179674625397,
0.05551311746239662,
0.40507224202156067,
-0.38266879320144653,
0.4255019426345825,
0.5091028809547424,
-0.16893351078033447,
-0.7091310024261475,
0.7151448130607605,
0.30289962887763977,
-0.8987746238708496,
0.34453779458999634,
0.39450034499168396,
-0.18316523730754852,
-0.21620754897594452,
-0.3933734893798828,
-0.639782726764679,
0.6805382966995239,
0.40804818272590637,
-0.4176608622074127,
-0.28402599692344666,
0.10124139487743378,
0.26690807938575745,
-0.05439414456486702,
0.3960992097854614,
0.7062802910804749,
0.4177573621273041,
-0.06340612471103668,
-0.7833967804908752,
0.21088293194770813,
-0.15118558704853058,
-0.23871393501758575,
0.3711329996585846,
-0.644205629825592,
0.4932107627391815,
-0.47798800468444824,
-0.14219588041305542,
-0.0026687239296734333,
0.4001938998699188,
0.38905012607574463,
0.6356246471405029,
0.47918614745140076,
0.35299670696258545,
0.5445387959480286,
-0.05755094438791275,
1.0958168506622314,
-0.14113470911979675,
0.16805493831634521,
1.117272973060608,
0.37379685044288635,
0.3324306011199951,
0.3007366359233856,
0.03334633633494377,
0.11771710216999054,
0.678936243057251,
-0.16400964558124542,
0.8760326504707336,
0.03686665743589401,
-0.35589224100112915,
0.03895476460456848,
-0.1279018372297287,
-0.5835669040679932,
0.2524932622909546,
0.28330931067466736,
-0.492413729429245,
-0.23383331298828125,
0.5156493186950684,
0.29103344678878784,
-0.1045471802353859,
-0.27720513939857483,
0.6956057548522949,
-0.23829999566078186,
-0.7734992504119873,
0.760848343372345,
-0.17528541386127472,
0.9031556248664856,
-0.4541231095790863,
-0.037282805889844894,
-0.13738612830638885,
0.16015709936618805,
0.016099141910672188,
-0.5701212882995605,
0.027211224660277367,
0.1732412725687027,
-0.06784415245056152,
0.0370774045586586,
0.8495600819587708,
-0.3322710692882538,
-0.3603050410747528,
0.023963823914527893,
-0.1455022096633911,
0.03852490335702896,
-0.16081054508686066,
-0.672156035900116,
0.1682605743408203,
0.5793041586875916,
-0.41649162769317627,
0.03790762647986412,
0.3507170081138611,
0.07591983675956726,
0.516332745552063,
0.5257237553596497,
-0.01712537743151188,
0.04911956936120987,
-0.24544763565063477,
0.9518945217132568,
-0.47653019428253174,
-0.6809864640235901,
-0.9928716421127319,
0.27004435658454895,
-0.09188975393772125,
-0.374161034822464,
0.5744187831878662,
0.44421663880348206,
0.7711054682731628,
-0.24892793595790863,
1.3048138618469238,
-0.021280907094478607,
0.43370163440704346,
-0.6336214542388916,
0.6954025626182556,
-0.4949263036251068,
0.721836268901825,
-0.17256204783916473,
-0.6387917995452881,
-0.041505660861730576,
0.11232725530862808,
-0.5111465454101562,
0.16519661247730255,
0.5167183876037598,
0.551517903804779,
0.05532960593700409,
-0.21744641661643982,
0.14429542422294617,
-0.2869466543197632,
0.7399091720581055,
0.6280136108398438,
0.7757565379142761,
-0.5405963659286499,
1.027111291885376,
-0.19420748949050903,
-0.0797358825802803,
-0.3259340822696686,
-0.6127422451972961,
-1.1649233102798462,
-0.0876878872513771,
-0.542563796043396,
-0.36613672971725464,
0.34478679299354553,
0.775891125202179,
0.302725225687027,
-0.6486740708351135,
0.4776667058467865,
-0.20613299310207367,
0.3599691092967987,
0.09335347265005112,
-0.30619490146636963,
0.8523829579353333,
-0.3338139057159424,
-0.7240943312644958,
0.6350415945053101,
0.20010168850421906,
0.1813720464706421,
0.1133492961525917,
-0.11397501826286316,
0.188922718167305,
0.0869661271572113,
0.053355295211076736,
0.5059776306152344,
-0.7570652961730957,
-0.5677528381347656,
0.0022852502297610044,
0.09235932677984238,
-0.0013022616039961576,
0.8098542094230652,
-0.7532640695571899,
0.4576939344406128,
0.4886370897293091,
0.7159656882286072,
-0.05609774962067604,
0.2743598222732544,
0.43727079033851624,
-1.1165218353271484,
0.33491167426109314,
0.41148868203163147,
0.17343303561210632,
0.36713603138923645,
-0.9694554805755615,
0.2986680269241333,
0.30829909443855286,
-0.5423660278320312,
-0.9293486475944519,
0.23909704387187958,
-0.46652889251708984,
-0.2738112211227417,
1.0194075107574463,
-0.2179243564605713,
-0.3512071669101715,
0.19967785477638245,
-0.5877862572669983,
0.002033874159678817,
-0.7144848704338074,
0.7589448690414429,
0.5258256793022156,
-0.2864680290222168,
-0.17798607051372528,
-0.1585104912519455,
0.8759632706642151,
0.4155028462409973,
-0.9439829587936401,
-0.061924535781145096,
0.5028713345527649,
0.055602286010980606,
0.12161977589130402,
0.527799129486084,
0.390157550573349,
0.7839192152023315,
-0.1057363897562027,
-0.37155088782310486,
-0.3036843240261078,
-0.4822372496128082,
-0.10894348472356796,
0.25404754281044006,
-0.004796647932380438,
-0.949147641658783
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16264v1 | One Thousand and One Pairs: A "novel" challenge for long-context language models | 2024-06-24T02:03:57 | 2024-06-24T02:03:57 | Marzena Karpinska, Katherine Thai, Kyle Lo, Tanya Goyal, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Synthetic long-context LLM benchmarks (e.g., "needle-in-the-haystack") test
only surface-level retrieval capabilities, but how well can long-context LLMs
retrieve, synthesize, and reason over information across book-length inputs? We
address this question by creating NoCha, a dataset of 1,001 minimally different
pairs of true and false claims about 67 recently-published English fictional
books, written by human readers of those books. In contrast to existing
long-context benchmarks, our annotators confirm that the largest share of pairs
in NoCha require global reasoning over the entire book to verify. Our
experiments show that while human readers easily perform this task, it is
enormously challenging for all ten long-context LLMs that we evaluate: no
open-weight model performs above random chance (despite their strong
performance on synthetic benchmarks), while GPT-4o achieves the highest
accuracy at 55.8%. Further analysis reveals that (1) on average, models perform
much better on pairs that require only sentence-level retrieval vs. global
reasoning; (2) model-generated explanations for their decisions are often
inaccurate even for correctly-labeled claims; and (3) models perform
substantially worse on speculative fiction books that contain extensive
world-building. The methodology proposed in NoCha allows for the evolution of
the benchmark dataset and the easy analysis of future models. | [
-0.3120426833629608,
-0.7178189158439636,
0.8299030661582947,
0.10312027484178543,
-0.11349117010831833,
-0.03942982852458954,
-0.11401889473199844,
-0.7463963031768799,
-0.1574804037809372,
0.6975377798080444,
-0.5509293675422668,
-0.37912988662719727,
-0.2978723645210266,
0.4488464891910553,
-0.5140107870101929,
0.8062740564346313,
-0.13793699443340302,
-0.18197418749332428,
-0.6756468415260315,
-0.4601660966873169,
-0.1705019474029541,
-0.590826690196991,
-0.12745991349220276,
-0.17281517386436462,
0.7498924136161804,
0.1590949296951294,
0.7067264914512634,
0.4260402023792267,
0.2849753797054291,
0.2830761969089508,
-0.08052583783864975,
0.3727627396583557,
-0.4450213611125946,
0.1799507439136505,
-0.07760421186685562,
-0.4817642867565155,
-0.41781654953956604,
0.0744296982884407,
0.820806622505188,
0.8225234746932983,
0.32582932710647583,
0.051124829798936844,
-0.054571982473134995,
0.7206846475601196,
-0.3717813789844513,
-0.2376226782798767,
-0.5231383442878723,
-0.23849941790103912,
-0.415181040763855,
-0.13778816163539886,
-0.6148850321769714,
-0.21334099769592285,
0.1982300877571106,
-0.7427683472633362,
0.34090957045555115,
0.3600519597530365,
0.6635328531265259,
-0.03247998282313347,
-0.804677426815033,
-0.2882855236530304,
-0.6751326322555542,
0.9022769331932068,
-0.5958699584007263,
0.3887731730937958,
0.393156498670578,
0.22344878315925598,
-0.329013854265213,
-0.3951146900653839,
-0.7984119057655334,
-0.56612229347229,
-0.056988418102264404,
-0.2305402308702469,
0.031857993453741074,
-0.13408787548542023,
0.368922621011734,
0.16264380514621735,
-0.6329858303070068,
-0.035148896276950836,
-0.24482928216457367,
-0.008549642749130726,
0.6743824481964111,
0.12635453045368195,
0.3184662163257599,
-0.3537663221359253,
-0.7761237025260925,
0.00650652265176177,
-0.8992065191268921,
0.09003977477550507,
0.3561876714229584,
0.24148555099964142,
-0.11662109196186066,
0.4280322194099426,
-0.19571730494499207,
0.5751837491989136,
-0.38518503308296204,
-0.06292605400085449,
0.06008579209446907,
-0.5139227509498596,
-0.10091641545295715,
-0.06735672801733017,
0.7986831665039062,
0.2390754371881485,
0.22147288918495178,
-0.5707464814186096,
-0.2197222113609314,
0.10276459157466888,
0.030724793672561646,
-0.6487212181091309,
0.3566610515117645,
0.26427048444747925,
0.002261699875816703,
-0.20640429854393005,
-0.065728560090065,
-0.6713514924049377,
-0.503020167350769,
-0.32872438430786133,
0.5417246222496033,
-0.3653777539730072,
-0.055437181144952774,
0.2722507119178772,
-0.14321663975715637,
0.32939037680625916,
0.32918331027030945,
-0.6532054543495178,
0.5117691159248352,
0.7744714021682739,
0.8439675569534302,
-0.27362632751464844,
-0.3749012053012848,
-0.22880710661411285,
0.14472909271717072,
-0.5839158892631531,
0.9113225936889648,
-0.4812944829463959,
-0.43432313203811646,
-0.19688861072063446,
-0.014629226177930832,
0.0891556367278099,
-0.34228166937828064,
0.5813197493553162,
-0.42409974336624146,
0.23640288412570953,
-0.7776188254356384,
-0.7072492241859436,
0.14437468349933624,
0.3709445297718048,
-0.634480893611908,
1.052844762802124,
0.06198035180568695,
-0.6100814938545227,
0.0978102833032608,
-0.39734187722206116,
-0.2904040813446045,
0.24139080941677094,
-0.4790554940700531,
0.11918594688177109,
0.11156915873289108,
0.08774028718471527,
0.1644149124622345,
-0.8180737495422363,
0.3672112226486206,
-0.3648136258125305,
-0.45159631967544556,
0.22223778069019318,
-0.5775235295295715,
0.805096447467804,
0.028925877064466476,
-0.3215481638908386,
-0.19156582653522491,
-0.7583995461463928,
0.0027637635357677937,
0.4322604537010193,
-0.13319729268550873,
-0.4934336841106415,
-0.04576685652136803,
0.019922956824302673,
-0.07375068217515945,
0.2753029465675354,
-0.96164470911026,
0.5054135918617249,
-0.2087334543466568,
0.4387491047382355,
0.6904752850532532,
-0.2087324559688568,
0.49279844760894775,
-0.5858917236328125,
0.5117857456207275,
-0.2307712286710739,
-0.059130389243364334,
-0.4773233234882355,
-0.44481131434440613,
-0.6763619780540466,
0.01570715941488743,
0.3131544589996338,
0.3361131548881531,
-0.6028367280960083,
0.2855343520641327,
-0.40838348865509033,
-0.5447813272476196,
-0.37195494771003723,
0.1353498101234436,
0.46778208017349243,
0.6018176674842834,
0.3672063648700714,
-0.0030199564062058926,
-0.18143630027770996,
-0.9181315302848816,
-0.48559120297431946,
0.04001173749566078,
-0.08724154531955719,
0.5254712700843811,
0.48407676815986633,
-0.167233407497406,
1.1121044158935547,
-0.20655199885368347,
0.030274812132120132,
-0.050754155963659286,
-0.04431537538766861,
0.12226928770542145,
0.32584476470947266,
0.5944404602050781,
-0.7960200905799866,
-0.49217718839645386,
0.13184672594070435,
-0.9936336874961853,
0.10702043771743774,
-0.17697466909885406,
-0.17648489773273468,
0.3654729127883911,
0.41615912318229675,
-0.7579726576805115,
0.2459588646888733,
0.4124424159526825,
-0.315572589635849,
0.640481173992157,
-0.22292590141296387,
0.041187942028045654,
-0.8467209935188293,
0.13192705810070038,
0.0958055779337883,
-0.23495326936244965,
-0.5383596420288086,
0.24320697784423828,
0.33786991238594055,
-0.08177678287029266,
-0.2694461941719055,
1.1306031942367554,
-0.3900124430656433,
0.23421967029571533,
-0.05230710282921791,
0.35092347860336304,
0.17226842045783997,
0.3653033673763275,
-0.20484450459480286,
0.7852187156677246,
0.31958329677581787,
-0.47807106375694275,
0.33162790536880493,
0.11315940320491791,
-0.6403353810310364,
0.3822847306728363,
-0.7035988569259644,
0.4311804175376892,
-0.24231015145778656,
0.6322059631347656,
-1.2238177061080933,
-0.2199433445930481,
-0.14018100500106812,
-0.2879890501499176,
-0.0067703998647630215,
0.0919811874628067,
-0.6725959777832031,
-0.20207752287387848,
-0.12384107708930969,
0.7206658720970154,
0.3470854163169861,
-0.8005540370941162,
0.42830902338027954,
0.13815882802009583,
-0.20751889050006866,
-0.5082594752311707,
-0.5337334275245667,
0.1775139570236206,
-0.07173185795545578,
-0.7028360366821289,
0.5502681732177734,
-0.24225924909114838,
-0.28337669372558594,
-0.09337396174669266,
-0.5675033926963806,
0.13530537486076355,
-0.060753848403692245,
0.24277393519878387,
0.25804775953292847,
-0.16459639370441437,
0.30836600065231323,
-0.158296138048172,
-0.20418906211853027,
0.10482318699359894,
-0.09355571866035461,
0.35457977652549744,
-0.3096409738063812,
-0.3198775351047516,
-0.16983729600906372,
0.48310843110084534,
0.5348837375640869,
-0.16130927205085754,
0.46245521306991577,
0.06914156675338745,
-0.4161759316921234,
-0.4510546028614044,
-0.7907275557518005,
0.06508857756853104,
-0.5175619125366211,
0.22673656046390533,
-0.6545029878616333,
-0.814030110836029,
0.3853786289691925,
0.0817023441195488,
0.03385037183761597,
0.449125200510025,
0.21235531568527222,
-0.06958051770925522,
0.7558093667030334,
0.36449164152145386,
-0.1633126437664032,
0.06838855892419815,
-0.06796713173389435,
0.22252067923545837,
-0.5267650485038757,
-0.325518935918808,
-0.547492265701294,
-0.2639777958393097,
-0.5966793298721313,
-0.5394859313964844,
0.3727056682109833,
0.16032803058624268,
-0.15964260697364807,
0.4471505880355835,
-0.3319096267223358,
1.0475361347198486,
0.7019357681274414,
-0.014207074418663979,
0.53492271900177,
0.0864076241850853,
-0.28042206168174744,
0.10888855159282684,
-0.39022448658943176,
-0.6674631834030151,
1.1638256311416626,
0.20004311203956604,
0.49401161074638367,
0.35320696234703064,
0.6689872741699219,
0.1821061372756958,
0.1507730782032013,
-0.6358916163444519,
0.6630841493606567,
-0.09247639775276184,
-0.8361793160438538,
-0.2919989228248596,
-0.45166173577308655,
-0.9324845671653748,
0.25348982214927673,
0.06451719254255295,
-0.5815861821174622,
0.050915610045194626,
-0.24571101367473602,
-0.4183143079280853,
0.2592616081237793,
-0.47397446632385254,
0.8512064814567566,
-0.510838508605957,
-0.49428650736808777,
-0.10042062401771545,
-0.6807671785354614,
0.2851491868495941,
-0.11035579442977905,
0.2505660653114319,
-0.3458852171897888,
-0.2271498590707779,
0.5704313516616821,
-0.25182756781578064,
0.6530188322067261,
0.08008269220590591,
-0.32202839851379395,
0.46794137358665466,
0.3572447597980499,
0.4883645474910736,
0.06405450403690338,
-0.33782196044921875,
0.25147101283073425,
0.4744420647621155,
-0.7230125069618225,
-0.5377514958381653,
0.8427900671958923,
-0.7253199219703674,
-0.6630606055259705,
-0.6454699039459229,
-0.6279982328414917,
-0.46353042125701904,
0.3271557688713074,
0.13075952231884003,
0.5878193974494934,
-0.38339537382125854,
0.4532376229763031,
0.3081757426261902,
-0.2169000208377838,
0.3264714777469635,
0.501672625541687,
-0.1974344700574875,
-0.23884499073028564,
0.8723666667938232,
0.13772667944431305,
0.37342363595962524,
0.4831984043121338,
0.27210161089897156,
-0.41687074303627014,
-0.31279972195625305,
-0.465209037065506,
0.3555119037628174,
-0.6100236773490906,
0.0910373255610466,
-0.47230005264282227,
-0.06681513786315918,
-0.27774783968925476,
-0.04953265190124512,
-0.19827526807785034,
-0.3620181083679199,
0.029639549553394318,
0.04009430110454559,
0.1688762605190277,
0.9129733443260193,
0.3752097487449646,
-0.046625811606645584,
-0.7500990629196167,
0.4750819206237793,
0.19732587039470673,
0.329720139503479,
0.03693001717329025,
-0.46749281883239746,
0.035934872925281525,
-0.032212741672992706,
-0.28030580282211304,
-0.8155582547187805,
0.18284031748771667,
-0.1344289779663086,
0.34201672673225403,
0.20526890456676483,
0.3462667763233185,
0.6595488786697388,
-0.6439810395240784,
0.720690906047821,
0.00007669283513678238,
-0.7865081429481506,
0.1869388222694397,
-0.6476033329963684,
0.2565368413925171,
0.4892670214176178,
0.6903355121612549,
-0.6768240332603455,
-0.040338654071092606,
-0.606577455997467,
-0.5710523724555969,
0.5613676309585571,
0.106987364590168,
0.34803327918052673,
-0.27115336060523987,
0.5162813663482666,
0.33210551738739014,
0.09543375670909882,
-0.7264657616615295,
-0.21561039984226227,
0.3210201859474182,
-0.09585433453321457,
-0.24022875726222992,
-0.3277996778488159,
-0.13582175970077515,
-0.20073938369750977,
0.3262380361557007,
-0.20933979749679565,
0.018303338438272476,
0.3488592803478241,
-0.00896372552961111,
-0.06097981333732605,
0.2956974506378174,
0.6052230000495911,
0.7065385580062866,
-0.2878706455230713,
0.08710825443267822,
-0.0243851188570261,
0.008764997124671936,
0.20423507690429688,
-0.021781181916594505,
-0.23305648565292358,
0.046575773507356644,
0.5002461671829224,
0.6498611569404602,
0.3529403507709503,
-0.8280578851699829,
0.5080833435058594,
-0.00250968337059021,
-0.28006821870803833,
-0.3782007098197937,
-0.018017688766121864,
0.20825375616550446,
0.2788098156452179,
0.4516395628452301,
-0.10945650190114975,
-0.1690031886100769,
-0.6276646852493286,
0.1678641140460968,
0.534248948097229,
0.059356287121772766,
-0.40828290581703186,
0.5723428726196289,
0.34568601846694946,
-0.4203459918498993,
0.5846563577651978,
-0.4801749587059021,
-0.24250778555870056,
0.7347726821899414,
0.6176808476448059,
0.5465279817581177,
0.2378176599740982,
0.10139527916908264,
0.39122650027275085,
0.10766075551509857,
-0.26230764389038086,
-0.04251385107636452,
-0.20396944880485535,
-0.7381677627563477,
-0.153494730591774,
-0.6105261445045471,
-0.6219099164009094,
0.265337198972702,
-0.4895528256893158,
0.303344190120697,
-0.534874439239502,
0.07855485379695892,
0.18814319372177124,
0.17912288010120392,
-0.6341903805732727,
-0.14663833379745483,
0.1647421270608902,
0.9087488055229187,
-0.5674343705177307,
0.9522005915641785,
0.20994701981544495,
-0.3615305423736572,
-0.35254284739494324,
-0.05299162119626999,
0.12186490744352341,
-0.7264017462730408,
0.5315853357315063,
0.437561571598053,
0.017749376595020294,
0.041532907634973526,
-0.5045390725135803,
-0.8703600764274597,
0.9355169534683228,
0.5406450629234314,
-0.8474798202514648,
-0.42140334844589233,
0.21470195055007935,
0.5120111107826233,
-0.3506411910057068,
0.10161320865154266,
0.5053701400756836,
0.420947402715683,
0.04618632048368454,
-1.0323421955108643,
0.08982623368501663,
-0.17682263255119324,
-0.2372230440378189,
0.32060107588768005,
-0.8294453024864197,
0.9525706768035889,
-0.34010985493659973,
-0.305748850107193,
0.6224230527877808,
0.4595735967159271,
0.411094605922699,
0.4975244104862213,
0.4376508891582489,
0.49154913425445557,
0.8272523283958435,
0.08029898256063461,
1.4083517789840698,
-0.24082596600055695,
0.34946107864379883,
1.2430967092514038,
-0.4156205952167511,
1.0436606407165527,
0.4556780457496643,
-0.44259199500083923,
0.43354368209838867,
0.48142051696777344,
0.03340916335582733,
0.12879833579063416,
0.2184431552886963,
-0.5192705988883972,
-0.46055856347084045,
-0.1619192659854889,
-0.4630483090877533,
0.19660831987857819,
0.054620448499917984,
0.023570235818624496,
-0.27890530228614807,
-0.240232914686203,
-0.08884338289499283,
0.2334953397512436,
0.06689458340406418,
0.36615419387817383,
0.26796644926071167,
-0.8667125105857849,
0.7858542203903198,
0.04303250461816788,
0.6650773882865906,
-0.5420740246772766,
0.14494892954826355,
-0.3488304913043976,
0.2218010276556015,
0.03408364579081535,
-0.37210142612457275,
-0.11496023088693619,
0.10942970216274261,
-0.23374034464359283,
-0.2587299942970276,
0.347521036863327,
-0.43665802478790283,
-0.6825933456420898,
0.37708359956741333,
0.5548849105834961,
0.1686350256204605,
-0.25452008843421936,
-0.4294985830783844,
0.061817266047000885,
-0.08930721133947372,
-0.36876577138900757,
0.5362421870231628,
0.4473506212234497,
-0.20370854437351227,
0.6582067012786865,
0.70212322473526,
-0.005592150613665581,
0.004295315593481064,
0.017059754580259323,
0.513401985168457,
-1.1061164140701294,
-0.265703022480011,
-0.9054242372512817,
0.18703216314315796,
0.06070361286401749,
-0.3548024892807007,
0.8674787878990173,
0.5106224417686462,
0.895271897315979,
0.1772894561290741,
0.8063669204711914,
0.21367083489894867,
0.4852137863636017,
-0.34160012006759644,
0.543063759803772,
-0.8509395122528076,
0.18540343642234802,
0.05819402635097504,
-0.8469555974006653,
-0.15678603947162628,
0.3614380955696106,
-0.2116175889968872,
0.0552607998251915,
0.9021756052970886,
0.692052960395813,
0.046954624354839325,
0.2868734300136566,
0.3177095353603363,
0.19851849973201752,
0.40761950612068176,
0.6726489067077637,
0.697012722492218,
-0.70963454246521,
0.48358041048049927,
-0.12259072810411453,
-0.013895221054553986,
-0.03302932530641556,
-1.0234577655792236,
-0.8505299091339111,
-0.4559342861175537,
-0.13162709772586823,
-0.33295366168022156,
-0.08655846118927002,
0.8223374485969543,
0.5300103425979614,
-0.6489609479904175,
-0.291037917137146,
-0.14735181629657745,
0.012555139139294624,
0.1988818496465683,
-0.15997645258903503,
0.25250688195228577,
-0.40508797764778137,
-0.9257364273071289,
0.7695839405059814,
0.08275030553340912,
0.027403000742197037,
-0.35099297761917114,
-0.2060515284538269,
-0.10351672768592834,
0.25825828313827515,
0.6078360080718994,
0.37479081749916077,
-1.0908595323562622,
-0.32767996191978455,
0.12105831503868103,
-0.2683041989803314,
-0.0512198768556118,
0.7707254886627197,
-0.9161941409111023,
0.5261403918266296,
0.48483383655548096,
0.9016125798225403,
0.4656513035297394,
0.06285955756902695,
0.534163773059845,
-0.6927245855331421,
0.13394120335578918,
0.22105124592781067,
0.2686905562877655,
0.2016904056072235,
-0.05319182574748993,
0.6078402400016785,
0.3917078971862793,
-0.5864599943161011,
-1.2400962114334106,
0.17254458367824554,
-1.1392613649368286,
-0.34078317880630493,
1.2888381481170654,
0.12813235819339752,
-0.31621819734573364,
0.15572109818458557,
-0.03890597075223923,
-0.1928604394197464,
-0.19713862240314484,
0.6296176314353943,
1.0458399057388306,
-0.07477296143770218,
0.1521604210138321,
-0.8094812035560608,
0.36110174655914307,
0.7064505219459534,
-0.6671931147575378,
0.22043564915657043,
0.44627946615219116,
0.37273988127708435,
0.27292245626449585,
0.6159588098526001,
-0.07109098881483078,
0.12870629131793976,
0.09671887010335922,
-0.18014444410800934,
-0.22120465338230133,
-0.5511676073074341,
-0.19479329884052277,
0.18834137916564941,
0.007499106228351593,
0.11110281199216843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16254v1 | Confidence Regulation Neurons in Language Models | 2024-06-24T01:31:03 | 2024-06-24T01:31:03 | Alessandro Stolfo, Ben Wu, Wes Gurnee, Yonatan Belinkov, Xingyi Song, Mrinmaya Sachan, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite their widespread use, the mechanisms by which large language models
(LLMs) represent and regulate uncertainty in next-token predictions remain
largely unexplored. This study investigates two critical components believed to
influence this uncertainty: the recently discovered entropy neurons and a new
set of components that we term token frequency neurons. Entropy neurons are
characterized by an unusually high weight norm and influence the final layer
normalization (LayerNorm) scale to effectively scale down the logits. Our work
shows that entropy neurons operate by writing onto an unembedding null space,
allowing them to impact the residual stream norm with minimal direct effect on
the logits themselves. We observe the presence of entropy neurons across a
range of models, up to 7 billion parameters. On the other hand, token frequency
neurons, which we discover and describe here for the first time, boost or
suppress each token's logit proportionally to its log frequency, thereby
shifting the output distribution towards or away from the unigram distribution.
Finally, we present a detailed case study where entropy neurons actively manage
confidence in the setting of induction, i.e. detecting and continuing repeated
subsequences. | [
-0.09382936358451843,
-0.4127805233001709,
0.2895621359348297,
0.23777572810649872,
0.01054927334189415,
-0.12542183697223663,
-0.30940210819244385,
-0.4510619044303894,
0.17877347767353058,
0.2356642782688141,
-0.20731014013290405,
-0.3543263375759125,
-0.630372166633606,
-0.039044056087732315,
-0.4709532558917999,
0.8448356986045837,
0.2850356101989746,
0.06281515210866928,
-0.11709348112344742,
0.32229378819465637,
-0.2319861650466919,
-0.6952476501464844,
-0.8364353775978088,
-0.8697414994239807,
0.8153103590011597,
0.15399476885795593,
0.6134671568870544,
0.40245330333709717,
0.3057229518890381,
0.34832775592803955,
-0.4259880483150482,
-0.21222861111164093,
-0.33477669954299927,
0.193658247590065,
0.1643470823764801,
-0.8945712447166443,
-0.39468780159950256,
-0.0368061438202858,
0.7983018755912781,
0.5632692575454712,
-0.285072922706604,
-0.009000614285469055,
0.19290345907211304,
0.20614752173423767,
-0.6139507293701172,
0.2619544565677643,
-0.9818018078804016,
-0.15338283777236938,
-0.03610025718808174,
-0.47310492396354675,
-0.5802820324897766,
-0.02832047827541828,
-0.17001093924045563,
-0.35357600450515747,
0.07821333408355713,
0.1503547877073288,
0.8104866743087769,
0.3043971061706543,
-0.1714852899312973,
0.1072683036327362,
-0.7041601538658142,
0.4867992103099823,
-0.8036899566650391,
0.16463768482208252,
0.7273606657981873,
-0.4653560519218445,
-0.33450040221214294,
-0.905009388923645,
-0.47422847151756287,
-0.05693984404206276,
-0.09573771059513092,
-0.18797491490840912,
-0.1339755654335022,
0.38176849484443665,
0.13562068343162537,
0.09881013631820679,
-0.09475318342447281,
0.3544592559337616,
-0.40729349851608276,
-0.5207343101501465,
0.2780410647392273,
0.1574169546365738,
0.13138604164123535,
-0.08048523217439651,
-0.12124861776828766,
0.012257358990609646,
-0.5854697823524475,
0.17623476684093475,
0.30404698848724365,
0.107917420566082,
0.13808678090572357,
0.5428743362426758,
0.10056552290916443,
0.5966148972511292,
-0.11187522113323212,
-0.008322205394506454,
0.15720750391483307,
-0.05435687676072121,
-0.4084339141845703,
0.3140929341316223,
0.7762053608894348,
0.4107309877872467,
0.3919079005718231,
0.049042005091905594,
-0.48820796608924866,
-0.022572940215468407,
0.3545190989971161,
-0.54323810338974,
-0.19790145754814148,
0.17225778102874756,
-0.3689093589782715,
-0.5368776917457581,
0.005783218424767256,
-0.3055846393108368,
-0.44896194338798523,
-0.13699807226657867,
0.48572084307670593,
-0.293070912361145,
-0.3250258266925812,
0.23968413472175598,
-0.2748138904571533,
0.22671835124492645,
0.251037061214447,
-1.2567918300628662,
0.6114727854728699,
0.877679169178009,
0.9305328130722046,
-0.19027751684188843,
-0.4100138247013092,
-0.09854713082313538,
-0.0016817302675917745,
-0.7574177384376526,
0.3035472333431244,
-0.5172608494758606,
-0.06198585405945778,
0.0019118207274004817,
0.09472434967756271,
-0.16169026494026184,
-0.281909704208374,
0.3019714951515198,
-0.6940521001815796,
-0.03359661251306534,
-0.04611804708838463,
-0.5392060279846191,
-0.027542676776647568,
-0.12524902820587158,
-0.6116456389427185,
0.9313594698905945,
0.011765078641474247,
-0.9541436433792114,
0.39873576164245605,
-0.1292785257101059,
-0.38388651609420776,
-0.06200648471713066,
-0.12857772409915924,
-0.07220998406410217,
0.5585780739784241,
-0.27325010299682617,
0.5261787176132202,
-0.16209615767002106,
-0.05902545154094696,
-0.28076431155204773,
-0.5516705513000488,
0.5840882062911987,
-0.6789630055427551,
0.7073864340782166,
0.07806427776813507,
-0.26120081543922424,
0.2564603388309479,
-0.6576838493347168,
0.1866580843925476,
-0.363546222448349,
-0.3265124559402466,
-0.5088284015655518,
-0.08760853856801987,
0.023464733734726906,
0.20852510631084442,
-0.006315628066658974,
-0.4875335395336151,
-0.07378237694501877,
-0.16429255902767181,
0.8564876914024353,
1.0494922399520874,
0.20638282597064972,
0.4157761037349701,
-0.3537268042564392,
0.3162805438041687,
0.06323850154876709,
0.08599863201379776,
-0.08449456840753555,
-0.6508361101150513,
-0.6961476802825928,
-0.1313244104385376,
0.4508066177368164,
0.3919823467731476,
-0.19064004719257355,
0.5148556232452393,
-0.2941495478153229,
-0.39367231726646423,
-0.5063080191612244,
0.14751514792442322,
0.051375698298215866,
0.3255443871021271,
0.08157118409872055,
-0.4848410189151764,
-0.25414326786994934,
-0.638778030872345,
-0.02814129926264286,
-0.43187257647514343,
-0.1530613899230957,
0.061555635184049606,
0.28590700030326843,
0.18138004839420319,
0.7569288611412048,
-0.013924770057201385,
-0.03351832181215286,
0.06258463859558105,
0.22719117999076843,
0.2770911753177643,
0.9105467796325684,
0.11858228594064713,
-0.6999198198318481,
-0.10970775038003922,
0.028603749349713326,
-0.3601517975330353,
0.049294427037239075,
-0.482451468706131,
0.055861104279756546,
0.31739291548728943,
0.8842583894729614,
-1.0022603273391724,
0.5753173828125,
0.6820912957191467,
-0.31555646657943726,
0.387081116437912,
-0.2213258594274521,
-0.11068927496671677,
-0.818584144115448,
0.03245344012975693,
-0.3255101442337036,
-0.12078219652175903,
-0.692050039768219,
-0.2846720218658447,
0.2159186601638794,
0.4828670024871826,
-0.22902709245681763,
0.18990057706832886,
-0.320405513048172,
-0.050661999732255936,
-0.19977319240570068,
-0.19761456549167633,
-0.047487523406744,
0.4628707468509674,
-0.06145894527435303,
0.7307385206222534,
0.728952169418335,
-0.6998839378356934,
0.24274006485939026,
-0.029194774106144905,
-0.7178915739059448,
-0.21125763654708862,
-0.8766977787017822,
-0.061100851744413376,
-0.02471071295440197,
0.2249663770198822,
-1.1935834884643555,
-0.34433403611183167,
-0.0314212441444397,
-0.7258412837982178,
0.6989870667457581,
-0.012053421698510647,
-0.4804586172103882,
-0.19886420667171478,
-0.19923648238182068,
0.15972770750522614,
0.6561444997787476,
-0.18253718316555023,
0.5651643872261047,
0.27462971210479736,
-0.13011081516742706,
-0.7814769744873047,
-1.3286069631576538,
0.10844001919031143,
0.01993122510612011,
-0.25218215584754944,
0.2995942533016205,
0.039616428315639496,
-0.5098472237586975,
-0.03251662477850914,
-0.3061128556728363,
0.05037147179245949,
0.35593217611312866,
0.5641735792160034,
0.12558028101921082,
-0.11806131154298782,
0.45450910925865173,
0.10259409248828888,
0.1315278559923172,
0.24682585895061493,
-0.5409689545631409,
0.8318727612495422,
-0.1062801256775856,
-0.29038235545158386,
-0.751768946647644,
-0.01774301379919052,
0.7756279706954956,
-0.04404454678297043,
1.0220049619674683,
0.5564170479774475,
-0.3858170211315155,
-0.1607399880886078,
-0.5137153267860413,
-0.36545225977897644,
-0.5188779234886169,
0.4110100269317627,
-0.40202760696411133,
-1.185178518295288,
0.743233859539032,
0.16057205200195312,
-0.178145170211792,
0.5013886094093323,
0.8260522484779358,
0.03348599374294281,
0.760448157787323,
0.6337587237358093,
-0.08453511446714401,
0.547263503074646,
0.0697348490357399,
0.12223871052265167,
-0.8882948160171509,
-0.2996355891227722,
-0.5961576104164124,
-0.30919432640075684,
-0.6968913078308105,
-0.42984646558761597,
0.02136177197098732,
0.29386064410209656,
-0.1975899189710617,
-0.05118364095687866,
-0.29354941844940186,
0.5325707793235779,
0.7169783711433411,
0.0326637402176857,
-0.03202776983380318,
0.04642582684755325,
-0.30776211619377136,
0.22900331020355225,
-0.8695943355560303,
-0.25750061869621277,
1.0760629177093506,
0.6383832693099976,
1.059085726737976,
-0.27924105525016785,
0.5732260942459106,
0.28358393907546997,
0.11140641570091248,
-0.704045295715332,
0.32638847827911377,
0.0790758728981018,
-0.7838011980056763,
-0.5505310297012329,
-0.40898755192756653,
-0.66093510389328,
-0.08970454335212708,
-0.10805190354585648,
-0.9270139336585999,
0.5740593671798706,
0.18705326318740845,
-0.5787416100502014,
0.5578127503395081,
-0.7687421441078186,
0.30861908197402954,
0.11323290318250656,
-0.4647194743156433,
-0.22270943224430084,
-0.8560993075370789,
0.2533847689628601,
-0.056168314069509506,
-0.00824887678027153,
-0.08700957894325256,
-0.3608284294605255,
0.5674563646316528,
-0.16646252572536469,
1.2607041597366333,
0.12135111540555954,
-0.31770753860473633,
0.5536296367645264,
0.36898720264434814,
0.4153115153312683,
0.13506115972995758,
-0.27503275871276855,
0.3940359950065613,
0.06040896475315094,
-0.3057142198085785,
-0.30123674869537354,
0.6845391988754272,
-0.7691459655761719,
-0.6164183616638184,
-0.33302730321884155,
-0.6917210221290588,
-0.06254508346319199,
0.18802860379219055,
0.5259059071540833,
0.21353080868721008,
0.07316288352012634,
0.7019540667533875,
0.7058787941932678,
-0.03907599672675133,
0.6314283013343811,
-0.15494096279144287,
-0.1025453731417656,
-0.1919761300086975,
0.5418654084205627,
0.17228400707244873,
0.6308826804161072,
0.35503312945365906,
0.03853389248251915,
-0.08650675415992737,
-0.606998860836029,
0.18872864544391632,
-0.14351585507392883,
-0.7575355768203735,
-0.3436611592769623,
-0.5435589551925659,
-0.5200584530830383,
-0.6623996496200562,
0.14782458543777466,
-0.2458379715681076,
-0.7909939885139465,
-0.26666152477264404,
-0.45402035117149353,
0.4151773452758789,
0.9129130244255066,
-0.47125041484832764,
0.4146465063095093,
-0.4664347171783447,
-0.15343353152275085,
0.45374637842178345,
0.7895318269729614,
0.13175849616527557,
-0.763340413570404,
-0.22886624932289124,
-0.1702299863100052,
0.29867103695869446,
-0.546104907989502,
0.2117738425731659,
0.3564208745956421,
0.4325322210788727,
0.4561045169830322,
-0.2105567753314972,
0.37247028946876526,
-0.4816162586212158,
0.8541398644447327,
0.3489568829536438,
-1.2483991384506226,
-0.04454110562801361,
-0.12606695294380188,
0.1827625185251236,
0.16425423324108124,
0.18885529041290283,
-0.7093788981437683,
-0.5515653491020203,
-0.6134470105171204,
-0.7626076340675354,
0.7544000744819641,
0.2440386861562729,
0.6550918221473694,
-0.13084270060062408,
0.6567366123199463,
-0.08573685586452484,
0.3316079378128052,
-0.6090676188468933,
-0.1331479698419571,
-0.3009622097015381,
-0.08945360779762268,
-0.27163165807724,
-0.7406569123268127,
-0.25510555505752563,
-0.3698510229587555,
0.39221516251564026,
-0.04608651250600815,
0.27704060077667236,
0.38218483328819275,
0.4046441316604614,
-0.35872238874435425,
0.20750924944877625,
0.8881900310516357,
0.4757503867149353,
-0.1787162721157074,
0.5004134774208069,
0.1348470002412796,
-0.6364491581916809,
0.05785991623997688,
-0.5710001587867737,
-0.3583977520465851,
0.07389911264181137,
0.6048628091812134,
0.9640732407569885,
0.06579937785863876,
-0.23245127499103546,
0.35227343440055847,
-0.1889306604862213,
-0.36347371339797974,
-0.41498202085494995,
0.39192670583724976,
0.14211009442806244,
0.05096353963017464,
0.24723704159259796,
0.652625322341919,
-0.2237442433834076,
-0.43730446696281433,
0.45889803767204285,
0.3692914545536041,
-0.611793577671051,
-0.45181307196617126,
0.5616664290428162,
-0.1685960739850998,
-0.31214597821235657,
0.5521675944328308,
0.2036392241716385,
-0.5179978609085083,
0.6842014193534851,
0.7360161542892456,
0.8323472142219543,
-0.375639945268631,
0.025664523243904114,
0.27405497431755066,
0.7951129078865051,
-0.36830487847328186,
0.2569888234138489,
0.20920859277248383,
-1.0448166131973267,
-0.5577660799026489,
-0.7174068689346313,
0.10533303022384644,
0.1685444861650467,
-0.7476298809051514,
-0.09453421831130981,
-0.9102522134780884,
-0.5573158860206604,
-0.16102734208106995,
-0.39028435945510864,
-0.35995978116989136,
0.21629491448402405,
0.35737133026123047,
1.2244540452957153,
-0.7632543444633484,
1.150006651878357,
0.22179344296455383,
-0.14925459027290344,
-0.8993417024612427,
0.06454625725746155,
-0.14721348881721497,
-0.9037512540817261,
0.7071449160575867,
-0.005062676966190338,
-0.25657719373703003,
0.2065691500902176,
-1.1173120737075806,
-0.906408965587616,
0.863160252571106,
0.16079598665237427,
-0.39534491300582886,
-0.09754842519760132,
-0.15228208899497986,
0.748266339302063,
-0.5019217729568481,
0.021229101344943047,
0.5693569183349609,
0.3965442180633545,
0.2073127031326294,
-0.7556079626083374,
0.06761287897825241,
-0.27144181728363037,
0.14645209908485413,
0.09588117897510529,
-0.5426973104476929,
1.265971302986145,
-0.22349658608436584,
0.04255073890089989,
0.13658547401428223,
0.6226550340652466,
-0.17787598073482513,
-0.1578017771244049,
0.45382338762283325,
0.37847769260406494,
0.8331118822097778,
-0.02709594927728176,
1.1122299432754517,
-0.6589140892028809,
0.13824677467346191,
1.2902191877365112,
-0.211958646774292,
1.0224167108535767,
1.0601924657821655,
0.09174591302871704,
0.6045241951942444,
0.6594592928886414,
-0.06271877139806747,
0.25892212986946106,
0.5979079008102417,
-0.23263145983219147,
-0.4838148355484009,
-0.3744562566280365,
-0.0814673900604248,
0.4561428427696228,
0.6904581785202026,
-0.5121335387229919,
0.4468720555305481,
-0.3030274212360382,
0.06604734063148499,
-0.23260498046875,
-0.5770667195320129,
0.6779727339744568,
0.24377502501010895,
-0.6694139242172241,
0.6447734832763672,
-0.06000998243689537,
0.5292412638664246,
-0.7936326861381531,
0.15928596258163452,
-0.16271014511585236,
0.0900668054819107,
-0.30188700556755066,
-0.705385684967041,
0.024260975420475006,
-0.3383947014808655,
0.008020525798201561,
-0.13245248794555664,
0.7531935572624207,
-0.4109343886375427,
-0.2575916051864624,
0.5274100303649902,
0.14486077427864075,
-0.09366445988416672,
0.000016950596545939334,
-0.2769530415534973,
0.1544995903968811,
-0.13188698887825012,
-0.5997201800346375,
0.21512115001678467,
0.7900454998016357,
0.009081106632947922,
0.7041416168212891,
0.5409306287765503,
0.5070761442184448,
0.5389072895050049,
0.018297046422958374,
0.7512884736061096,
-0.48986566066741943,
-0.17147713899612427,
-0.8198526501655579,
0.26537805795669556,
0.006968834437429905,
-0.3950865566730499,
0.5491234660148621,
0.13060235977172852,
0.836074948310852,
0.02877657301723957,
0.6052070260047913,
-0.14921978116035461,
-0.05265316739678383,
-0.674653947353363,
0.967399001121521,
-0.5082598924636841,
0.29710665345191956,
0.028786353766918182,
-0.5977464318275452,
-0.6419522166252136,
0.3952181041240692,
0.11470592021942139,
0.05414252728223801,
0.8699883818626404,
0.9401953816413879,
0.3595457077026367,
-0.1358260214328766,
0.5884414315223694,
0.5261191725730896,
0.022992271929979324,
0.20051981508731842,
0.6140890717506409,
-0.28323623538017273,
0.4689072072505951,
-0.385017067193985,
-0.051552914083004,
0.03857342153787613,
-0.7075617909431458,
-0.8466742038726807,
-0.6609597206115723,
-0.05263517051935196,
-0.5737667083740234,
-0.204842209815979,
0.9209330081939697,
0.791810154914856,
-1.12447190284729,
-0.4037781357765198,
-0.4206762909889221,
0.19128242135047913,
-0.19969922304153442,
-0.18098798394203186,
0.2086222916841507,
-0.7912497520446777,
-0.4146020710468292,
0.05327685922384262,
0.4018539488315582,
0.23470452427864075,
-0.23142680525779724,
-0.0760560929775238,
-0.21073612570762634,
0.31058812141418457,
0.3285834789276123,
0.07230732589960098,
-0.6290953755378723,
-0.36155378818511963,
-0.001554735004901886,
-0.5148959159851074,
-0.01707112044095993,
1.0153398513793945,
-0.3140166401863098,
0.1877964437007904,
0.7562365531921387,
0.5636041760444641,
0.20549651980400085,
-0.2880975306034088,
0.775935173034668,
-0.923378050327301,
0.2957278788089752,
0.22803807258605957,
0.38719552755355835,
0.08915064483880997,
-0.44252583384513855,
0.362510621547699,
0.30553823709487915,
-0.4900587499141693,
-0.8578696846961975,
0.11212129890918732,
-0.6761986613273621,
-0.3329247832298279,
1.1824110746383667,
-0.12224763631820679,
-0.49787503480911255,
-0.03263212367892265,
0.06519613415002823,
0.14858774840831757,
-0.3521115183830261,
0.8639085292816162,
1.1686025857925415,
0.02619900368154049,
-0.35548651218414307,
-0.4398122727870941,
0.9162677526473999,
0.6987341046333313,
-0.19819539785385132,
0.3243374228477478,
0.2231346070766449,
0.09624374657869339,
0.33784055709838867,
0.5537989735603333,
-0.13586609065532684,
0.11044108122587204,
0.28915804624557495,
0.31249913573265076,
0.21756260097026825,
-0.665177583694458,
-0.7295372486114502,
0.2643887996673584,
0.3488711416721344,
0.07623155415058136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16253v2 | LLMs Assist NLP Researchers: Critique Paper (Meta-)Reviewing | 2024-06-24T01:30:22 | 2024-06-25T18:04:38 | Jiangshu Du, Yibo Wang, Wenting Zhao, Zhongfen Deng, Shuaiqi Liu, Renze Lou, Henry Peng Zou, Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Nan Zhang, Mukund Srinath, Haoran Ranran Zhang, Vipul Gupta, Yinghui Li, Tao Li, Fei Wang, Qin Liu, Tianlin Liu, Pengzhi Gao, Congying Xia, Chen Xing, Jiayang Cheng, Zhaowei Wang, Ying Su, Raj Sanjay Shah, Ruohao Guo, Jing Gu, Haoran Li, Kangda Wei, Zihao Wang, Lu Cheng, Surangika Ranathunga, Meng Fang, Jie Fu, Fei Liu, Ruihong Huang, Eduardo Blanco, Yixin Cao, Rui Zhang, Philip S. Yu, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work is motivated by two key trends. On one hand, large language models
(LLMs) have shown remarkable versatility in various generative tasks such as
writing, drawing, and question answering, significantly reducing the time
required for many routine tasks. On the other hand, researchers, whose work is
not only time-consuming but also highly expertise-demanding, face increasing
challenges as they have to spend more time reading, writing, and reviewing
papers. This raises the question: how can LLMs potentially assist researchers
in alleviating their heavy workload?
This study focuses on the topic of LLMs assist NLP Researchers, particularly
examining the effectiveness of LLM in assisting paper (meta-)reviewing and its
recognizability. To address this, we constructed the ReviewCritique dataset,
which includes two types of information: (i) NLP papers (initial submissions
rather than camera-ready) with both human-written and LLM-generated reviews,
and (ii) each review comes with "deficiency" labels and corresponding
explanations for individual segments, annotated by experts. Using
ReviewCritique, this study explores two threads of research questions: (i)
"LLMs as Reviewers", how do reviews generated by LLMs compare with those
written by humans in terms of quality and distinguishability? (ii) "LLMs as
Metareviewers", how effectively can LLMs identify potential issues, such as
Deficient or unprofessional review segments, within individual paper reviews?
To our knowledge, this is the first work to provide such a comprehensive
analysis. | [
-0.45383965969085693,
-0.45558229088783264,
0.6671292781829834,
0.3120364546775818,
-0.30125802755355835,
0.19071675837039948,
-0.21946312487125397,
-0.7169146537780762,
0.4739281237125397,
0.577747642993927,
-0.48965758085250854,
-0.4586256444454193,
-0.5505555272102356,
0.705510139465332,
-0.4328835904598236,
1.299178957939148,
-0.18477396667003632,
0.20873011648654938,
-0.38322368264198303,
0.008631978183984756,
-0.21801237761974335,
-0.4399837255477905,
-0.655280590057373,
-0.5825755596160889,
0.8695279955863953,
0.1994175910949707,
0.47635453939437866,
0.10731200873851776,
0.6500148773193359,
0.25404536724090576,
-0.2991345226764679,
0.4573361873626709,
-0.38405412435531616,
0.190536767244339,
-0.31649258732795715,
-0.3704843521118164,
-0.6228125095367432,
0.09211627393960953,
0.5358028411865234,
0.6741085052490234,
-0.028204675763845444,
0.3460133373737335,
0.7575090527534485,
0.9289676547050476,
-0.4672451317310333,
0.029653750360012054,
-0.5767676830291748,
0.25502073764801025,
-0.21820028126239777,
-0.3731849789619446,
-0.2693573832511902,
-0.42014989256858826,
0.1417204886674881,
-0.3993806838989258,
0.37876972556114197,
-0.13662780821323395,
0.49195435643196106,
0.4286574423313141,
-0.36865267157554626,
-0.298738032579422,
-0.8905148506164551,
0.6121416091918945,
-0.646294116973877,
0.1754821240901947,
0.4102766513824463,
0.025855276733636856,
-0.08057975023984909,
-0.5462289452552795,
-0.5767172574996948,
-0.1737310141324997,
-0.34991419315338135,
0.25098052620887756,
-0.055260781198740005,
-0.0035177820827811956,
0.25995221734046936,
0.5330458283424377,
-0.31644031405448914,
-0.05074745789170265,
-0.25644880533218384,
-0.23469139635562897,
0.5477821826934814,
0.29043710231781006,
0.028122514486312866,
-0.42121195793151855,
-0.13515885174274445,
0.20632965862751007,
-0.6135990619659424,
-0.09441930055618286,
0.2758043110370636,
0.04897703230381012,
0.3886922597885132,
0.5737063884735107,
-0.09234756231307983,
0.6306524872779846,
-0.10879849642515182,
-0.15507568418979645,
0.33202439546585083,
-0.3951162099838257,
-0.37232324481010437,
-0.5017170310020447,
0.7967048287391663,
0.5556362271308899,
0.19908693432807922,
-0.16127203404903412,
-0.3044501841068268,
-0.3070727288722992,
0.390296071767807,
-0.5105445384979248,
-0.06599181145429611,
0.27468040585517883,
-0.7191226482391357,
-0.34055033326148987,
0.07464073598384857,
-0.9759809374809265,
-0.6134515404701233,
-0.47030118107795715,
0.22502774000167847,
0.05648433417081833,
-0.24781794846057892,
0.15310902893543243,
-0.047373637557029724,
0.031399376690387726,
0.5770903825759888,
-0.6095749735832214,
0.2362787127494812,
0.6048063635826111,
0.7596220374107361,
-0.3857598602771759,
-0.21532170474529266,
-0.3305553197860718,
-0.08253221958875656,
-0.08316373080015182,
0.9142038822174072,
-0.27750203013420105,
-0.5508358478546143,
0.015986686572432518,
0.09109480679035187,
-0.08546797931194305,
-0.6622314453125,
0.7936677932739258,
-0.4481396973133087,
0.19779443740844727,
-0.4231507182121277,
-0.291970819234848,
-0.2413448989391327,
0.6375793218612671,
-0.7282737493515015,
0.9642642736434937,
-0.0402107872068882,
-1.100144386291504,
0.17039716243743896,
-0.331438809633255,
-0.21666757762432098,
0.09196251630783081,
-0.1608586460351944,
-0.3847552239894867,
0.29707804322242737,
0.2647508382797241,
0.338299036026001,
-0.4717576503753662,
0.07696297019720078,
-0.14338770508766174,
-0.21250967681407928,
0.47078579664230347,
-0.26383087038993835,
0.5467395186424255,
0.0550474151968956,
-0.17216825485229492,
0.04694895073771477,
-0.5328428745269775,
-0.024597039446234703,
-0.009727864526212215,
-0.6698899269104004,
-0.13552609086036682,
0.16830292344093323,
0.1528974175453186,
-0.08299335837364197,
-0.09579581022262573,
-0.5117149949073792,
0.1497533619403839,
-0.16390439867973328,
0.4208621680736542,
0.5131108164787292,
0.17532721161842346,
0.21339823305606842,
-0.40851131081581116,
0.7893418073654175,
-0.3415580093860626,
0.10305041074752808,
-0.18225322663784027,
-0.3238235116004944,
-0.9089747667312622,
-0.047831203788518906,
0.6742518544197083,
0.6300342082977295,
-0.7688154578208923,
0.2658262252807617,
0.012116113677620888,
-0.3357866704463959,
-0.6520967483520508,
0.4652433395385742,
0.5182628631591797,
0.5840451717376709,
0.3813308775424957,
-0.33493778109550476,
-0.7212527394294739,
-0.9054768085479736,
-0.47165536880493164,
-0.11192015558481216,
-0.2712154686450958,
0.4421560764312744,
0.6165603399276733,
-0.40331870317459106,
0.7210285663604736,
-0.27454236149787903,
-0.4335954487323761,
-0.34845536947250366,
0.07999927550554276,
0.08570138365030289,
0.07837551087141037,
0.27717313170433044,
-0.3547045588493347,
-0.4666828513145447,
-0.40320074558258057,
-0.6495023965835571,
-0.6771805882453918,
-0.05791076272726059,
0.22591516375541687,
0.2529991567134857,
0.5650153160095215,
-0.5418276190757751,
0.31524109840393066,
0.5638765692710876,
-0.09568221122026443,
0.7471001148223877,
-0.008639799430966377,
0.010096902959048748,
-0.6634736061096191,
0.26398882269859314,
0.05202728137373924,
-0.3344731628894806,
-0.4489608705043793,
-0.14613203704357147,
-0.2335299253463745,
0.08367029577493668,
-0.13913936913013458,
0.408884733915329,
-0.48305556178092957,
-0.07780882716178894,
-0.5090352892875671,
0.3965161442756653,
0.22612079977989197,
0.21213991940021515,
0.1198357418179512,
0.43663328886032104,
0.275753378868103,
-0.4244982600212097,
0.007735138759016991,
0.17912717163562775,
-0.40092408657073975,
0.48647376894950867,
-0.7930412888526917,
0.21104057133197784,
-0.22941936552524567,
0.48844704031944275,
-1.1638238430023193,
-0.01909792050719261,
0.30216217041015625,
-0.4827573001384735,
0.11592786759138107,
-0.19243036210536957,
-0.7912420034408569,
-0.2256431132555008,
-0.4357473850250244,
0.27425846457481384,
0.14148832857608795,
-0.35951462388038635,
0.7256144881248474,
0.400421679019928,
-0.39598795771598816,
-0.670519232749939,
-0.6561119556427002,
0.3626185655593872,
0.12263735383749008,
-0.3251529037952423,
0.4078246057033539,
-0.03337728604674339,
-0.4400668740272522,
-0.01208261214196682,
-0.03215011581778526,
0.12789468467235565,
-0.07339072972536087,
0.17892144620418549,
0.15951263904571533,
0.1860518902540207,
0.2206186205148697,
-0.30776169896125793,
-0.24659276008605957,
0.19020085036754608,
0.08399897068738937,
0.3374931514263153,
-0.10386446863412857,
-0.30899572372436523,
-0.23285067081451416,
0.299954354763031,
0.41939350962638855,
-0.22940178215503693,
0.2797771990299225,
0.7074857950210571,
0.0351717546582222,
-0.26914381980895996,
-0.8790953755378723,
-0.22194428741931915,
-0.33695951104164124,
0.1750781536102295,
0.08788637071847916,
-0.9491881132125854,
0.3615230619907379,
0.11064706742763519,
0.21504929661750793,
0.4770190417766571,
0.5900476574897766,
-0.4609534740447998,
0.606619656085968,
0.5877687931060791,
-0.111264169216156,
0.3682582676410675,
-0.1640700101852417,
0.05586130544543266,
-1.1968066692352295,
-0.4079621732234955,
-0.6168099641799927,
-0.4581661522388458,
-0.4409515857696533,
-0.5077853202819824,
0.4311072826385498,
-0.02964826487004757,
0.2464546412229538,
-0.038582250475883484,
-0.6155929565429688,
0.5679260492324829,
0.43186765909194946,
0.14902254939079285,
0.46816447377204895,
0.0048132785595953465,
-0.05129396915435791,
-0.2264079749584198,
-0.6687799096107483,
-0.831344723701477,
1.159757375717163,
0.4965960681438446,
0.7956057190895081,
-0.23026491701602936,
0.5353988409042358,
0.260407954454422,
0.4624243378639221,
-0.8273786902427673,
0.7713411450386047,
-0.141714945435524,
-0.46340107917785645,
-0.11326652765274048,
-0.33700767159461975,
-0.7808417677879333,
0.5228762030601501,
-0.5035895705223083,
-0.3207227885723114,
0.11124040186405182,
0.24084387719631195,
-0.1845986694097519,
0.39807960391044617,
-0.2511259913444519,
0.3725751042366028,
-0.3090379536151886,
-0.5224661827087402,
-0.21200188994407654,
-0.5229029059410095,
0.4431689977645874,
-0.17100639641284943,
0.1630338430404663,
-0.05817725136876106,
-0.08366599678993225,
0.8600592017173767,
-0.3301202654838562,
1.0978424549102783,
-0.09595613181591034,
-0.14834070205688477,
0.43103107810020447,
0.17083534598350525,
0.23609322309494019,
0.19327394664287567,
0.032317668199539185,
0.19492551684379578,
-0.10105671733617783,
0.06848721206188202,
-0.39969226717948914,
0.42171603441238403,
-0.45430728793144226,
-0.7625224590301514,
-0.5173057913780212,
-0.4056971073150635,
-0.28458982706069946,
0.1621958315372467,
0.09887752681970596,
0.19926221668720245,
-0.012869307771325111,
0.2649663984775543,
0.6510764360427856,
-0.21197859942913055,
0.43636488914489746,
0.7451594471931458,
-0.492485910654068,
-0.5971451997756958,
0.3083319664001465,
0.052857186645269394,
-0.016456104815006256,
0.35807210206985474,
0.25349998474121094,
-0.22955183684825897,
-0.6644449234008789,
-0.20140798389911652,
0.4093116819858551,
-0.6170622706413269,
-0.3114384710788727,
-0.8410685658454895,
-0.20270457863807678,
-0.008887621574103832,
0.23727278411388397,
-0.10777635127305984,
-0.5750553607940674,
-0.30633190274238586,
-0.18744324147701263,
0.10325842350721359,
0.7115395069122314,
-0.0645599439740181,
0.13291724026203156,
-0.8186289072036743,
0.3476361334323883,
0.4036727845668793,
0.19008654356002808,
0.3151014745235443,
-0.5753365159034729,
-0.11007102578878403,
-0.23735791444778442,
-0.4852844774723053,
-0.8147380352020264,
0.16071303188800812,
-0.002157944720238447,
0.6336398124694824,
0.23416917026042938,
-0.18573786318302155,
0.4403056800365448,
-0.535261869430542,
0.7726697325706482,
-0.08348220586776733,
-0.7969321608543396,
0.33929121494293213,
-0.262093186378479,
0.2484026551246643,
0.7516129612922668,
0.36772337555885315,
-0.5050239562988281,
-0.44281163811683655,
-0.2400529682636261,
-0.8185852766036987,
0.3421592116355896,
0.28182071447372437,
-0.01626436784863472,
0.04151288792490959,
0.6474828720092773,
0.056852374225854874,
0.43222394585609436,
-1.0167227983474731,
-0.03695717453956604,
-0.078066885471344,
0.2640060484409332,
-0.13319608569145203,
-0.8114537596702576,
-0.44862863421440125,
-0.049215901643037796,
0.4964047968387604,
-0.006582801695913076,
0.17058733105659485,
0.581648051738739,
-0.13898830115795135,
-0.1437004804611206,
0.44510555267333984,
0.7154000401496887,
0.8557642102241516,
-0.2157084345817566,
0.2863958775997162,
0.25552624464035034,
-0.38019561767578125,
-0.10897553712129593,
-0.12417693436145782,
-0.36254438757896423,
0.25761109590530396,
0.6881168484687805,
0.3887190520763397,
-0.055453188717365265,
-0.5467930436134338,
0.31819769740104675,
-0.08986737579107285,
-0.44854432344436646,
-0.2254253625869751,
-0.1258295178413391,
0.14498506486415863,
0.2813059687614441,
0.47675591707229614,
-0.05560901761054993,
0.21833308041095734,
-0.4618839919567108,
-0.014603099785745144,
0.7131381630897522,
-0.15623527765274048,
-0.33132749795913696,
0.4605480432510376,
0.664236307144165,
-0.4376263916492462,
0.5098004937171936,
-0.003602675162255764,
-0.6293258666992188,
0.48425015807151794,
0.297127366065979,
1.136623740196228,
-0.07224074751138687,
0.12895506620407104,
0.2681055963039398,
0.6193376183509827,
-0.040365930646657944,
0.2731693387031555,
-0.05155331268906593,
-0.5696200132369995,
-0.5982915759086609,
-0.6756716370582581,
-0.7351586222648621,
0.2912265360355377,
-0.7430081367492676,
0.06618130952119827,
-0.38386258482933044,
-0.5388954877853394,
-0.11524175852537155,
-0.0016600243980064988,
-0.40208640694618225,
0.1237315759062767,
0.03785570338368416,
0.8862595558166504,
-0.7347967028617859,
0.4837050437927246,
0.6042643189430237,
-0.29886677861213684,
-0.3224250376224518,
0.17079775035381317,
0.13424664735794067,
-0.5444387197494507,
0.6437534093856812,
0.14641627669334412,
-0.48239684104919434,
-0.3685504198074341,
-0.3808717727661133,
-0.5262058973312378,
1.05199134349823,
0.08311091363430023,
-0.7191748023033142,
0.06877380609512329,
0.1539124846458435,
1.042880654335022,
-0.3206899166107178,
0.28993383049964905,
0.3276735246181488,
0.6065473556518555,
-0.07011161744594574,
-0.9510661363601685,
-0.05835924670100212,
-0.1799330860376358,
-0.06628692895174026,
0.03190100938081741,
-0.7252910137176514,
0.5985082387924194,
-0.1604798138141632,
-0.1147952675819397,
-0.17484238743782043,
0.3579710125923157,
0.28028810024261475,
0.3073135316371918,
0.6996523141860962,
0.5167147517204285,
0.6012222170829773,
0.08807460218667984,
0.8799967765808105,
-0.40054163336753845,
0.28800150752067566,
1.2289106845855713,
-0.4119735360145569,
0.8551579117774963,
0.7113523483276367,
-0.25524190068244934,
0.45089074969291687,
0.49398863315582275,
-0.31177645921707153,
0.22392748296260834,
0.29527977108955383,
-0.20268608629703522,
-0.1993032544851303,
-0.1396043300628662,
-0.194183349609375,
0.15501892566680908,
0.19784381985664368,
-0.6228026151657104,
-0.1299077868461609,
-0.21266236901283264,
-0.011879590339958668,
0.04402490705251694,
-0.40915918350219727,
0.8065870404243469,
0.3163086473941803,
-0.7745749354362488,
0.3004896640777588,
0.060019101947546005,
0.5719687938690186,
-0.47406813502311707,
0.05256335437297821,
-0.33186426758766174,
0.09732835739850998,
-0.6893295049667358,
-1.043649673461914,
0.6216437220573425,
0.25804704427719116,
-0.4165259301662445,
-0.5391188859939575,
0.7526785731315613,
-0.2997661530971527,
-0.5791840553283691,
0.36695852875709534,
0.7887285947799683,
0.14578549563884735,
0.008463965728878975,
-0.765796422958374,
0.19995664060115814,
0.02319987863302231,
-0.3367307186126709,
0.22755488753318787,
0.13543389737606049,
0.16027463972568512,
0.7703738808631897,
0.4064987599849701,
0.2736953794956207,
-0.33967721462249756,
0.2040119171142578,
0.7354511618614197,
-0.6665225028991699,
-0.04633201286196709,
-1.0131710767745972,
0.42332324385643005,
0.052937719970941544,
-0.09956472367048264,
0.9196935296058655,
0.5566200017929077,
0.6234511137008667,
-0.2121635377407074,
0.8155192732810974,
0.08257408440113068,
0.9572057127952576,
-0.5893858671188354,
0.528692364692688,
-0.46183380484580994,
0.46484437584877014,
-0.33661454916000366,
-1.1059812307357788,
-0.5349614024162292,
0.5019779205322266,
-0.2512185573577881,
0.11982551217079163,
0.8814353346824646,
0.7703505754470825,
0.2531279921531677,
-0.2680691182613373,
-0.0777435451745987,
0.0360550582408905,
0.33019310235977173,
0.4157143235206604,
0.9978829622268677,
-0.10344774276018143,
0.7640536427497864,
0.031769417226314545,
-0.00985614862293005,
-0.35085660219192505,
-1.1906698942184448,
-1.2597981691360474,
-0.2769855260848999,
-0.2643260061740875,
-0.49172696471214294,
-0.13047119975090027,
0.6059257388114929,
0.3334943354129791,
-0.5490359663963318,
-0.2809527516365051,
0.09503694623708725,
0.20259533822536469,
0.05392051488161087,
-0.17447523772716522,
0.3475680649280548,
-0.2824728488922119,
-0.7079517841339111,
0.17795397341251373,
0.3124717175960541,
-0.07494206726551056,
-0.6323853731155396,
0.22554033994674683,
0.12626628577709198,
0.05511590093374252,
0.5905222296714783,
0.13247978687286377,
-0.7787123918533325,
0.024302411824464798,
-0.09482214599847794,
-0.05969587340950966,
0.06768933683633804,
1.1420215368270874,
-0.5421379804611206,
0.4544737935066223,
0.6841370463371277,
0.5898284912109375,
0.46571773290634155,
0.1554221361875534,
0.40295782685279846,
-0.5243760347366333,
-0.265708863735199,
0.40763720870018005,
0.414688378572464,
0.3776051998138428,
-0.10002235323190689,
0.7953524589538574,
0.1508934497833252,
-0.9091743230819702,
-0.8135603666305542,
0.21194419264793396,
-0.9722350835800171,
0.02058791182935238,
1.2472788095474243,
-0.10078643262386322,
0.07756179571151733,
-0.08216441422700882,
-0.3636298179626465,
-0.1730857938528061,
-0.11655020713806152,
1.012690782546997,
0.9230154752731323,
-0.3599877655506134,
-0.36883097887039185,
-0.6578509211540222,
0.6506175994873047,
0.5117854475975037,
-0.8600956797599792,
0.13410584628582,
0.29076942801475525,
0.4931304156780243,
0.2686048448085785,
0.8147584795951843,
-0.26314374804496765,
0.11547811329364777,
-0.4293234348297119,
0.038752175867557526,
-0.19411493837833405,
-0.23360663652420044,
-0.5603371858596802,
0.13122247159481049,
0.20151013135910034,
0.17522110044956207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16985v1 | Unveiling LLM Mechanisms Through Neural ODEs and Control Theory | 2024-06-23T22:56:34 | 2024-06-23T22:56:34 | Yukun Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This study presents a novel approach that leverages Neural Ordinary
Differential Equations (Neural ODEs) to unravel the intricate relationships
between inputs and outputs in Large Language Models (LLMs), and employs robust
control to fine-tune outputs to meet predefined standards. Central to our
methodology is the transformation of LLM inputs and outputs into a
lower-dimensional latent space, facilitating a detailed examination of the
information processing pathways within LLMs. Neural ODEs play a pivotal role in
this investigation by providing a dynamic model that captures the continuous
evolution of data within the LLMs. Additionally, robust control mechanisms are
applied to strategically adjust the model's outputs, ensuring they not only
maintain high quality and reliability but also adhere to specific performance
criteria. This fusion of Neural ODEs and robust control represents a
significant advancement in LLM interpretability, offering a comprehensive
framework that elucidates the previously opaque mechanisms of these complex
models. Our empirical results validate the effectiveness of this integrated
approach, making a substantial contribution to the field of explainable AI by
merging advanced machine learning techniques with the critical need for
transparency and control in AI outputs. | [
-0.195155069231987,
-0.8730139136314392,
0.6112252473831177,
0.05679783970117569,
-0.0866619423031807,
0.06941141188144684,
-0.40962299704551697,
-0.28636109828948975,
-0.06555935740470886,
0.22481222450733185,
-0.5676304697990417,
-0.338518887758255,
-0.8180468082427979,
-0.10278499871492386,
-0.4481862485408783,
0.9248285889625549,
-0.3279528021812439,
0.1438491940498352,
-0.25253844261169434,
0.026705339550971985,
-0.14325480163097382,
-0.32216355204582214,
-0.6595911979675293,
-0.6909429430961609,
0.6756181716918945,
-0.003250525100156665,
0.8168314099311829,
0.8271111845970154,
0.3318733274936676,
0.309078186750412,
-0.31097739934921265,
0.028878754004836082,
-0.48015525937080383,
0.23569442331790924,
-0.03981658071279526,
-0.7446817755699158,
-0.5045590996742249,
-0.018682176247239113,
0.8123917579650879,
0.8525897264480591,
-0.16382449865341187,
-0.00729011045768857,
0.6015275716781616,
0.4074685275554657,
-0.4006974697113037,
0.5143535733222961,
-0.6382098197937012,
-0.05395170673727989,
-0.13551703095436096,
-0.45737797021865845,
-0.22941505908966064,
-0.36989453434944153,
-0.1443054974079132,
-0.39114612340927124,
-0.24872934818267822,
-0.3090975880622864,
0.6591278314590454,
0.5158806443214417,
-0.2612626254558563,
-0.3011862635612488,
-0.8961137533187866,
0.7469429969787598,
-0.7569133043289185,
0.3157300651073456,
0.12366145104169846,
0.1351165622472763,
-0.3663445711135864,
-0.7361271977424622,
-0.42171815037727356,
-0.26436540484428406,
-0.07453867048025131,
0.07758117467164993,
-0.3421292006969452,
0.10008268058300018,
0.07503578066825867,
0.01789543218910694,
-0.3537448048591614,
0.5910291075706482,
-0.362561970949173,
-0.3170046806335449,
0.43248316645622253,
0.38331538438796997,
0.5229204893112183,
0.25870540738105774,
-0.2129097282886505,
0.16316847503185272,
-0.824198842048645,
0.3232325315475464,
0.39851114153862,
0.43361714482307434,
-0.3732885718345642,
0.4972802698612213,
0.04342128336429596,
0.5723831653594971,
-0.19076193869113922,
-0.07839564979076385,
-0.2802971303462982,
-0.23995767533779144,
-0.06217062845826149,
-0.0775265172123909,
0.8366129398345947,
0.13179390132427216,
0.20077764987945557,
-0.3009144961833954,
-0.4420601725578308,
0.12161321192979813,
0.15101726353168488,
-0.4159711003303528,
0.11321403086185455,
0.3636593818664551,
-0.5218877196311951,
-0.6059725284576416,
-0.3599119782447815,
-0.8943349123001099,
-0.47912949323654175,
-0.6813145279884338,
0.5149579644203186,
-0.277975469827652,
-0.254295289516449,
-0.14433132112026215,
0.24999234080314636,
0.5467079877853394,
0.41320693492889404,
-0.8848976492881775,
0.47376951575279236,
0.6155827641487122,
0.8927794098854065,
-0.4554559588432312,
-0.43367981910705566,
-0.6244053840637207,
0.1561422497034073,
-0.5143201947212219,
0.40055224299430847,
-0.5054115056991577,
0.15282446146011353,
0.23498950898647308,
-0.28750908374786377,
-0.06201707944273949,
-0.46704405546188354,
0.292377769947052,
-0.8719354867935181,
-0.14732952415943146,
0.25919345021247864,
-0.23550693690776825,
-0.10218209773302078,
0.16015446186065674,
-0.7258267402648926,
0.6215381026268005,
-0.1497102826833725,
-0.5736085772514343,
-0.0730310007929802,
-0.9095390439033508,
-0.2703554034233093,
-0.2533140778541565,
-0.4079658091068268,
-0.18050584197044373,
0.27528974413871765,
0.03319676220417023,
0.5100687146186829,
-0.3933151960372925,
0.521404504776001,
-0.33484789729118347,
-0.25984668731689453,
0.35536062717437744,
-0.8516267538070679,
0.8487878441810608,
0.16107746958732605,
-0.44336310029029846,
0.3339214026927948,
-0.8148675560951233,
-0.07400849461555481,
0.1985279619693756,
-0.46631351113319397,
-0.10805514454841614,
0.14327123761177063,
-0.2648453116416931,
0.06039230525493622,
0.5251135230064392,
-0.09813369065523148,
0.1686651110649109,
-0.4651242792606354,
0.7135136127471924,
0.8463948369026184,
-0.2077784687280655,
0.7315086722373962,
-0.06957505643367767,
0.516024649143219,
0.09665563702583313,
0.02224964275956154,
-0.2622181177139282,
-0.24979804456233978,
-0.5883400440216064,
0.044972874224185944,
0.2927301526069641,
0.39160972833633423,
-0.5011414289474487,
0.3345092535018921,
-0.20060381293296814,
-0.14778992533683777,
-0.5140239596366882,
0.2199464738368988,
0.18401753902435303,
0.5479444861412048,
0.1798301637172699,
-0.010633885860443115,
-0.14479050040245056,
-0.8930214643478394,
-0.14919109642505646,
-0.08507789671421051,
-0.13990426063537598,
0.11219451576471329,
0.27806952595710754,
-0.12004800140857697,
0.6795548796653748,
-0.11455092579126358,
0.04109099879860878,
-0.22542503476142883,
0.34830695390701294,
0.43121838569641113,
0.5844975113868713,
0.4187712073326111,
-0.6910540461540222,
-0.04475932940840721,
0.1718759983778,
-0.7911069989204407,
-0.3029721677303314,
-0.20249374210834503,
0.0015385508304461837,
0.05680657923221588,
0.799164891242981,
-0.5023259520530701,
0.6832249164581299,
0.5650107860565186,
-0.19559945166110992,
0.5286933183670044,
-0.2972431778907776,
-0.008329846896231174,
-0.9134144186973572,
-0.07408013939857483,
-0.23301346600055695,
-0.040353525429964066,
-0.5445676445960999,
0.19833515584468842,
0.1136503666639328,
-0.013092078268527985,
-0.3982087969779968,
0.16993267834186554,
-0.632760763168335,
-0.1763673722743988,
-0.43625566363334656,
0.19167423248291016,
-0.08450304716825485,
0.6235581040382385,
-0.31693294644355774,
0.6564180850982666,
0.8423967361450195,
-0.6774488687515259,
0.5266547799110413,
0.0671418234705925,
-0.1334196925163269,
0.07171705365180969,
-0.7289842963218689,
0.004319470841437578,
-0.3747555911540985,
-0.08052772283554077,
-1.2125113010406494,
-0.1431627720594406,
0.13295875489711761,
-0.6587040424346924,
0.6332497000694275,
-0.13953064382076263,
-0.4382511377334595,
0.2298949956893921,
-0.042699892073869705,
0.28329068422317505,
0.5166069269180298,
-0.4289892911911011,
1.0016742944717407,
0.23325486481189728,
-0.423021525144577,
-0.42783284187316895,
-0.8345608711242676,
0.14893729984760284,
-0.3734983801841736,
-0.41092580556869507,
0.31083691120147705,
-0.0696549192070961,
-0.5957019329071045,
-0.025854403153061867,
-0.028632454574108124,
-0.20752881467342377,
0.36240023374557495,
0.20689034461975098,
0.21965579688549042,
-0.5372084379196167,
-0.02689661830663681,
0.48776334524154663,
-0.16755208373069763,
0.476117342710495,
-0.40405234694480896,
0.7109331488609314,
0.016788620501756668,
-0.3317188024520874,
-0.8842408657073975,
0.3356052041053772,
1.089390516281128,
-0.2684224843978882,
0.8495283126831055,
0.4179503619670868,
-0.42172297835350037,
-0.32977184653282166,
0.00826301146298647,
-0.38236209750175476,
-0.4756038784980774,
0.4299876093864441,
-0.3452058732509613,
-0.7485678791999817,
0.8800265789031982,
-0.325601190328598,
-0.040632463991642,
0.31017982959747314,
0.7053895592689514,
-0.026909323409199715,
1.1470671892166138,
0.9081215262413025,
-0.23291926085948944,
0.26980456709861755,
-0.09811297059059143,
0.20173203945159912,
-0.7057832479476929,
-0.3222217261791229,
-0.626271665096283,
-0.5656232833862305,
-0.42712166905403137,
-0.18156421184539795,
0.26174184679985046,
0.4026432931423187,
-0.20120057463645935,
0.046353377401828766,
-0.07917316257953644,
0.3619658052921295,
0.3819395899772644,
-0.026936348527669907,
0.17555297911167145,
-0.12751226127147675,
-0.4580865204334259,
-0.08349344879388809,
-0.719855010509491,
-0.666490375995636,
0.9258232116699219,
0.6143860816955566,
0.9820447564125061,
0.28037330508232117,
0.36949920654296875,
0.17385995388031006,
0.1937704086303711,
-0.8825006484985352,
0.3842407166957855,
0.07302828878164291,
-0.07243924587965012,
-0.30437058210372925,
-0.3199860751628876,
-0.8611851930618286,
-0.022024042904376984,
-0.1920139491558075,
-1.1478912830352783,
-0.019811859354376793,
0.2554060220718384,
-0.39143723249435425,
0.4794235825538635,
-0.7152856588363647,
0.5354016423225403,
-0.4797193109989166,
-0.8088660836219788,
-0.08576524257659912,
-0.6123585104942322,
0.31985992193222046,
-0.22613076865673065,
0.16057926416397095,
0.16697943210601807,
-0.3192819654941559,
0.5574561953544617,
-0.08085425943136215,
1.151453971862793,
0.07687006890773773,
-0.48261508345603943,
-0.02030411921441555,
0.3431718051433563,
0.6497334837913513,
0.06110677868127823,
-0.058976344764232635,
0.36098596453666687,
-0.21172413229942322,
-0.2784157991409302,
-0.8617830276489258,
0.8754875063896179,
-0.8479915261268616,
-0.48471391201019287,
-0.03164101392030716,
-0.8880552649497986,
-0.13717299699783325,
0.25918275117874146,
0.15053404867649078,
0.4914979040622711,
0.1665649712085724,
0.20176218450069427,
0.7207038998603821,
-0.2672073543071747,
0.6391676068305969,
0.39748936891555786,
-0.20111490786075592,
-0.2648746967315674,
0.5843055844306946,
0.006195781286805868,
0.27721649408340454,
0.545513391494751,
0.25697746872901917,
-0.4299592077732086,
-1.0084404945373535,
-0.2487422376871109,
0.07011454552412033,
-0.6020512580871582,
-0.029513465240597725,
-0.29410240054130554,
-0.2577432692050934,
-0.516583263874054,
0.02828366495668888,
-0.32577216625213623,
-0.15621590614318848,
-0.5674301981925964,
-0.0018333325861021876,
0.06644578278064728,
1.082910180091858,
-0.11870346963405609,
0.327730655670166,
-0.6651695370674133,
0.28808483481407166,
0.17854002118110657,
0.5809183716773987,
0.10492231696844101,
-0.5889430046081543,
-0.0899704098701477,
0.12168560177087784,
-0.27435603737831116,
-1.0387470722198486,
0.4535840153694153,
0.04978768527507782,
0.8036326766014099,
0.6689152121543884,
-0.0803544744849205,
0.451681911945343,
-0.5505308508872986,
0.7442090511322021,
0.17397528886795044,
-0.9815990328788757,
0.6076744794845581,
-0.4513189196586609,
0.07214869558811188,
0.017481112852692604,
0.5090212821960449,
0.029565341770648956,
-0.27280402183532715,
-0.30786001682281494,
-0.9778730869293213,
0.7352641224861145,
0.26923829317092896,
0.054799847304821014,
0.6502422094345093,
0.6158198118209839,
0.040765900164842606,
0.07924418151378632,
-0.7275278568267822,
-0.2624785006046295,
0.24828875064849854,
-0.36866042017936707,
-0.062157321721315384,
-0.21693120896816254,
-0.3171986937522888,
-0.01628934219479561,
0.323081910610199,
-0.18699871003627777,
0.21465298533439636,
-0.01882675476372242,
0.06075624004006386,
-0.17816577851772308,
0.172091543674469,
0.792768657207489,
0.7585108876228333,
0.07569251209497452,
0.3940791189670563,
-0.09198155254125595,
-0.31073641777038574,
-0.023153500631451607,
0.07061724364757538,
-0.25464165210723877,
-0.27718299627304077,
0.4353140592575073,
0.8119316697120667,
-0.0888335332274437,
-0.49311918020248413,
0.24007382988929749,
-0.06621881574392319,
-0.22656556963920593,
-0.21452808380126953,
0.15144607424736023,
0.055888112634420395,
0.5158491134643555,
0.17760969698429108,
0.3054885268211365,
-0.026203151792287827,
-0.3910706341266632,
0.2561950385570526,
0.41285988688468933,
-0.6587117910385132,
-0.6007746458053589,
1.0256407260894775,
-0.08826804906129837,
-0.39754584431648254,
0.41972026228904724,
0.3022085428237915,
-0.36399486660957336,
0.7569328546524048,
0.6207462549209595,
0.7492867708206177,
-0.09545716643333435,
-0.02989986166357994,
0.08072185516357422,
0.5660547018051147,
0.1836819350719452,
0.123432956635952,
-0.10398605465888977,
-0.8656854033470154,
-0.7964349985122681,
-0.7066459655761719,
-0.24675489962100983,
0.7256600260734558,
-0.770768404006958,
0.05882738530635834,
-0.4611033499240875,
0.19017291069030762,
0.21524637937545776,
-0.45771363377571106,
-0.32377997040748596,
-0.024709150195121765,
0.24078227579593658,
0.886132538318634,
-0.9249538779258728,
0.7238093614578247,
0.6866981387138367,
-0.4916516840457916,
-0.9507678747177124,
0.2671746015548706,
0.18238180875778198,
-0.8980500102043152,
0.7269725203514099,
-0.16145804524421692,
-0.2921205461025238,
0.00992912519723177,
-1.0112669467926025,
-0.9478928446769714,
0.8443049192428589,
0.6878055334091187,
-0.3166244328022003,
0.1853894293308258,
0.20834355056285858,
0.4673735797405243,
-0.43875306844711304,
0.10865478962659836,
0.7858278751373291,
0.5215598940849304,
-0.1080191433429718,
-0.7491351366043091,
-0.10316429287195206,
-0.4894980788230896,
-0.15693704783916473,
0.11474987119436264,
-0.36354586482048035,
0.7185708284378052,
-0.21631743013858795,
-0.04396294429898262,
0.08282355964183807,
0.7630513310432434,
0.12427021563053131,
0.2608318328857422,
0.18170234560966492,
0.2596588432788849,
0.5257557034492493,
-0.23207296431064606,
0.7791566252708435,
-0.4036259949207306,
0.020024623721837997,
0.9841903448104858,
-0.19897371530532837,
0.7384427785873413,
0.7454673051834106,
-0.19308744370937347,
0.2518545091152191,
0.4150943458080292,
0.3400762379169464,
0.35278767347335815,
0.4617106020450592,
-0.17711247503757477,
-0.05521893873810768,
-0.18288837373256683,
0.07261171191930771,
0.6621673107147217,
0.541513979434967,
-0.43516403436660767,
-0.22013795375823975,
-0.05737888440489769,
0.004041172564029694,
0.3436923623085022,
-0.4879208505153656,
0.8590874075889587,
-0.0929131880402565,
-0.546857476234436,
0.6329230666160583,
-0.08849514275789261,
0.5830563306808472,
-0.7768257260322571,
-0.19543081521987915,
-0.25848686695098877,
0.14592550694942474,
-0.06211473047733307,
-0.7470693588256836,
0.4524247944355011,
0.07635388523340225,
-0.1463117152452469,
-0.35955938696861267,
0.7128748893737793,
-0.5324060320854187,
-0.13308903574943542,
0.45650121569633484,
0.47683289647102356,
0.21744313836097717,
0.19569134712219238,
-0.5261121988296509,
0.2916392683982849,
0.07023794203996658,
-0.08177181333303452,
0.31304100155830383,
0.5736492872238159,
-0.0118686119094491,
0.6033040285110474,
0.6095512509346008,
0.5391773581504822,
0.20335476100444794,
-0.04761220142245293,
1.0180962085723877,
-0.5418283343315125,
-0.39608171582221985,
-0.8952004909515381,
0.5085382461547852,
0.19132955372333527,
-0.10232754796743393,
0.27854642271995544,
0.3095061182975769,
0.53883957862854,
0.07634297013282776,
0.8746300935745239,
0.15220001339912415,
0.22956982254981995,
-0.8204898238182068,
1.157095193862915,
-0.6818577647209167,
0.4666154980659485,
0.048387639224529266,
-0.6900776624679565,
-0.45746350288391113,
0.25809726119041443,
-0.1499258130788803,
-0.07139476388692856,
0.49498945474624634,
0.8419497013092041,
-0.09074286371469498,
-0.2825486958026886,
0.5672974586486816,
0.7425312399864197,
0.3573961853981018,
0.5093833804130554,
1.0497071743011475,
-0.2205607295036316,
0.592889666557312,
-0.07231838256120682,
-0.5146864652633667,
0.1449309140443802,
-1.073288083076477,
-0.5917830467224121,
-0.48604917526245117,
-0.27048590779304504,
-0.26245003938674927,
-0.14211173355579376,
0.7247083783149719,
0.4807775914669037,
-0.9883249402046204,
-0.24696363508701324,
-0.4165287911891937,
0.22902517020702362,
-0.1976129710674286,
-0.23487909138202667,
0.36287397146224976,
-0.5399277210235596,
-0.9728553295135498,
0.5494505167007446,
0.5360078811645508,
0.1919206827878952,
-0.4987710118293762,
-0.13262614607810974,
0.1354246437549591,
0.152579665184021,
0.44080889225006104,
0.22205758094787598,
-0.7318850159645081,
0.1647949516773224,
-0.04546079412102699,
0.01809888333082199,
-0.04580477252602577,
0.8583857417106628,
-0.5279785394668579,
0.2549194097518921,
0.6678586602210999,
0.9320141077041626,
-0.010735404677689075,
-0.3555903136730194,
0.875083327293396,
-0.4824369549751282,
0.03877131640911102,
0.281002938747406,
0.5064319968223572,
0.09752184897661209,
-0.3489397466182709,
0.15789297223091125,
-0.034731198102235794,
-0.38248544931411743,
-0.7674954533576965,
0.3538200855255127,
-0.9952158331871033,
-0.32461026310920715,
0.9543963670730591,
-0.15813343226909637,
-0.5090829133987427,
-0.11691045016050339,
0.02047685533761978,
0.4603614807128906,
-0.28222453594207764,
0.9304283261299133,
0.49804165959358215,
-0.299368292093277,
-0.3200509548187256,
-0.4884703457355499,
0.43746620416641235,
0.28993725776672363,
-0.7438924908638,
0.18909986317157745,
0.47995397448539734,
0.06709139794111252,
0.2418556958436966,
0.1298660784959793,
-0.42542558908462524,
-0.04411204904317856,
-0.1911337822675705,
-0.08219242095947266,
-0.12874433398246765,
-0.5272027850151062,
-0.9200010895729065,
0.4531395733356476,
-0.041930925101041794,
-0.1915450394153595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16235v1 | Preference Tuning For Toxicity Mitigation Generalizes Across Languages | 2024-06-23T22:53:47 | 2024-06-23T22:53:47 | Xiaochen Li, Zheng-Xin Yong, Stephen H. Bach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Detoxifying multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) has become crucial due
to their increasing global use. In this work, we explore zero-shot
cross-lingual generalization of preference tuning in detoxifying LLMs. Unlike
previous studies that show limited cross-lingual generalization for other
safety tasks, we demonstrate that Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) training
with only English data can significantly reduce toxicity in multilingual
open-ended generations. For example, the probability of mGPT-1.3B generating
toxic continuations drops from 46.8% to 3.9% across 17 different languages
after training. Our results also extend to other multilingual LLMs, such as
BLOOM, Llama3, and Aya-23. Using mechanistic interpretability tools like causal
intervention and activation analysis, we identified the dual multilinguality
property of MLP layers in LLMs, which explains the cross-lingual generalization
of DPO. Finally, we show that bilingual sentence retrieval can predict the
cross-lingual transferability of DPO preference tuning. | [
-0.06346805393695831,
-0.3964950740337372,
0.5345580577850342,
0.29307180643081665,
-0.1790049821138382,
-0.08231769502162933,
-0.3479355573654175,
-0.32442373037338257,
-0.01396474801003933,
0.5950514078140259,
-0.5028049349784851,
-0.5949735641479492,
-0.4811840355396271,
0.29470744729042053,
0.4996655583381653,
1.1823786497116089,
-0.02364138513803482,
0.3081951439380646,
0.23935507237911224,
-0.09774220734834671,
-0.457903653383255,
-0.46259573101997375,
-0.8927263021469116,
-0.5796031355857849,
1.1309226751327515,
0.6291749477386475,
0.5696597695350647,
0.44652241468429565,
0.1860567182302475,
0.1318076103925705,
-0.09279723465442657,
0.026974089443683624,
-0.7180593013763428,
0.08576720207929611,
-0.4063448905944824,
-0.637117326259613,
-0.17846782505512238,
0.032073382288217545,
0.3457924425601959,
0.5643232464790344,
-0.010749098844826221,
-0.31953224539756775,
-0.08681266754865646,
0.7990518808364868,
-0.8264549970626831,
-0.10996358096599579,
-1.0600574016571045,
0.43983179330825806,
0.13421152532100677,
-0.6145475506782532,
-0.6953636407852173,
-0.16326846182346344,
-0.09382124245166779,
-0.6188534498214722,
-0.2765677571296692,
-0.11858297884464264,
0.7124097943305969,
0.3114059865474701,
-0.9366188049316406,
0.03089877963066101,
-0.5561537742614746,
1.1824760437011719,
-0.5903534293174744,
0.36197397112846375,
0.3027426302433014,
-0.035221293568611145,
0.012124355882406235,
0.09185437858104706,
0.02834436111152172,
-0.24968907237052917,
-0.1703927218914032,
0.20144163072109222,
-0.006120726931840181,
0.31548479199409485,
0.06010044738650322,
0.09648824483156204,
-0.5756350755691528,
0.42984697222709656,
-0.12863588333129883,
-0.43756598234176636,
0.6278791427612305,
0.10357163101434708,
0.59562748670578,
-0.06130804494023323,
-0.5564888119697571,
0.18860359489917755,
-1.0865360498428345,
-0.1133643165230751,
0.5691637396812439,
0.4299437701702118,
-0.12363826483488083,
0.25162428617477417,
-0.1558801382780075,
0.42800095677375793,
-0.162189781665802,
-0.12296053767204285,
0.3445999324321747,
-0.3504621684551239,
-0.20094844698905945,
0.21782712638378143,
0.7412707805633545,
0.7102519869804382,
0.5182938575744629,
-0.409538596868515,
0.316935271024704,
-0.25362423062324524,
0.17886672914028168,
-1.0107028484344482,
-0.031217388808727264,
0.28218886256217957,
-0.15438657999038696,
-0.4837370812892914,
-0.5839226245880127,
-0.7243989109992981,
-0.0388677641749382,
-0.24613900482654572,
0.2408047467470169,
-0.34700852632522583,
-0.5612533688545227,
0.6107848286628723,
-0.1146044060587883,
0.10244015604257584,
-0.19653618335723877,
-1.2002350091934204,
-0.20378327369689941,
0.35910937190055847,
0.7780405282974243,
-0.3432263135910034,
-0.3381994962692261,
-0.6954590678215027,
0.5321414470672607,
-0.4192850887775421,
0.5200279355049133,
-0.6493409276008606,
-0.503960907459259,
0.01896383799612522,
0.0687934085726738,
-0.23244205117225647,
-0.5882594585418701,
0.7942035794258118,
-0.49316370487213135,
0.22461721301078796,
-0.42452380061149597,
0.07284436374902725,
-0.06272388994693756,
0.2907651960849762,
-0.4031051695346832,
0.6068781018257141,
-0.29423049092292786,
-0.806997537612915,
0.720558762550354,
-0.49308136105537415,
-0.6089918613433838,
-0.3064250349998474,
0.1606299877166748,
-0.3542378842830658,
0.0038913574535399675,
0.034746550023555756,
0.217477485537529,
0.06435529887676239,
0.21059107780456543,
-0.6256587505340576,
-0.35987624526023865,
-0.3085050880908966,
-0.37128695845603943,
0.8918015956878662,
0.35200443863868713,
-0.21885007619857788,
0.4249180555343628,
-0.5194803476333618,
0.15725724399089813,
-0.04092072695493698,
-0.5578653812408447,
-0.8471072316169739,
-0.11244979500770569,
0.008601338602602482,
0.5190318822860718,
0.0206377524882555,
-0.6850372552871704,
-0.13839972019195557,
-0.4172660708427429,
0.310606986284256,
0.7453752160072327,
0.24147439002990723,
0.37395668029785156,
-0.2837817072868347,
0.3610946238040924,
0.26940932869911194,
0.3167327046394348,
0.10421019047498703,
-0.19217026233673096,
-0.7568321824073792,
-0.3465937077999115,
-0.2747436761856079,
0.7734009027481079,
-0.7921481728553772,
0.5375694632530212,
-0.2035066932439804,
-0.19209814071655273,
-0.12729856371879578,
0.18128326535224915,
0.7174649238586426,
0.5329194068908691,
0.4671822786331177,
0.059655021876096725,
-0.4247382879257202,
-1.2169954776763916,
-0.4054371416568756,
-0.18897078931331635,
-0.027179552242159843,
0.44907212257385254,
0.11869236081838608,
-0.18751491606235504,
0.529141366481781,
-0.5470553636550903,
-0.1940397024154663,
-0.11051442474126816,
-0.18061301112174988,
0.28342849016189575,
0.17940859496593475,
0.7813435196876526,
-0.6160977482795715,
-0.9519382119178772,
0.40223973989486694,
-0.5152943134307861,
-0.47929996252059937,
-0.1466744989156723,
-0.5874590277671814,
0.24389620125293732,
0.23773613572120667,
-0.2051886022090912,
-0.09916369616985321,
0.5104200839996338,
-0.08046362549066544,
0.38282960653305054,
-0.31163719296455383,
0.1617140918970108,
-0.8740636110305786,
0.21800178289413452,
-0.01181167270988226,
0.033093225210905075,
-0.9184525609016418,
0.19614608585834503,
0.2697265148162842,
0.013355985283851624,
-0.9495922327041626,
0.7547934651374817,
-0.48260071873664856,
0.43333491683006287,
-0.20157352089881897,
-0.16754364967346191,
0.1361519992351532,
0.5463890433311462,
0.44046130776405334,
0.5416154861450195,
0.680283784866333,
-0.6791171431541443,
-0.07712828367948532,
0.06579239666461945,
0.28130748867988586,
0.6294289827346802,
-0.5347335338592529,
-0.05458453297615051,
-0.17956405878067017,
0.022939594462513924,
-0.7206486463546753,
0.1343366652727127,
0.21982501447200775,
0.08499554544687271,
0.4675106108188629,
-0.2815166711807251,
-0.1201714351773262,
-0.09082216024398804,
-0.6107861995697021,
0.3276936709880829,
0.2107992321252823,
-0.5739160776138306,
0.05042403191328049,
0.22964408993721008,
-0.06782618910074234,
-0.9439030289649963,
-0.6679079532623291,
-0.034432005137205124,
-0.6559173464775085,
-0.3847910165786743,
0.05234074592590332,
-0.4402490258216858,
-0.24285472929477692,
-0.49398183822631836,
-0.18355697393417358,
0.19260145723819733,
0.11331461369991302,
-0.1331426352262497,
0.22896836698055267,
0.2671918272972107,
0.30982136726379395,
0.44110366702079773,
-0.40061670541763306,
-0.03431592881679535,
0.030343035236001015,
0.4988262355327606,
0.1618804931640625,
-0.13678820431232452,
0.13762211799621582,
0.5758252143859863,
0.4957835078239441,
-0.2022436261177063,
0.607928454875946,
0.5114206075668335,
0.16627897322177887,
-0.2569922208786011,
-0.2623940706253052,
-0.10662679374217987,
-0.4780222773551941,
0.372881144285202,
-0.5788558721542358,
-0.8589017391204834,
0.4700080156326294,
0.08265219628810883,
0.12677784264087677,
0.24553222954273224,
0.7947015762329102,
0.5172470808029175,
0.8985275626182556,
0.5033718943595886,
-0.4933116137981415,
0.48745787143707275,
0.04931445047259331,
0.13295100629329681,
-0.7579691410064697,
0.032352376729249954,
-0.29727211594581604,
-0.3040800094604492,
-0.5973169207572937,
-0.20042048394680023,
0.7599843144416809,
-0.2009449452161789,
-0.7112614512443542,
-0.03736297786235809,
-0.45058873295783997,
0.8408588171005249,
0.33413583040237427,
0.22089235484600067,
0.5469489097595215,
0.3752939701080322,
-0.6079732179641724,
-0.22404547035694122,
-0.49050697684288025,
-0.1581699252128601,
1.2488828897476196,
0.44996166229248047,
0.7415440082550049,
0.059954773634672165,
0.8146427869796753,
-0.24045731127262115,
0.2925034463405609,
-0.691339373588562,
0.2567145526409149,
-0.4786904454231262,
-0.8972426652908325,
-0.18441808223724365,
-0.6686037182807922,
-0.9630106687545776,
0.5243304967880249,
0.06429427117109299,
-0.5763465762138367,
0.07185113430023193,
-0.07816315442323685,
-0.1428181678056717,
0.42168933153152466,
-0.7752683758735657,
0.8178449273109436,
-0.49314072728157043,
-0.6463837027549744,
-0.34821823239326477,
-0.6690911650657654,
0.5055311918258667,
-0.2624090015888214,
0.2819272577762604,
-0.40514707565307617,
-0.23876340687274933,
0.10823279619216919,
0.17520613968372345,
0.7216185331344604,
-0.09324965626001358,
-0.49976906180381775,
-0.3120741844177246,
0.04782973602414131,
0.1457163691520691,
0.22008900344371796,
-0.5472519397735596,
0.4852518141269684,
-0.08501531183719635,
-0.40243327617645264,
-0.17826654016971588,
1.1213847398757935,
-0.8655000925064087,
-0.6383209824562073,
-0.18948929011821747,
-0.6232142448425293,
-0.5162742137908936,
0.4431511461734772,
0.39840495586395264,
-0.14782105386257172,
-0.17346881330013275,
-0.11453840136528015,
0.7302345037460327,
-0.7084227800369263,
0.40222495794296265,
0.9679199457168579,
-0.23301349580287933,
-0.3790442645549774,
0.8137786984443665,
-0.18345461785793304,
0.7314251065254211,
0.7068449854850769,
0.3905699849128723,
-0.2500930428504944,
-0.4558901786804199,
-0.5433251261711121,
0.5120025277137756,
-0.5983636975288391,
-0.10319900512695312,
-0.6290263533592224,
-0.14271292090415955,
-0.17866772413253784,
-0.11980440467596054,
-0.08409298956394196,
-0.14955291152000427,
-0.33831536769866943,
-0.420127272605896,
0.3003329038619995,
0.2835037112236023,
-0.4794091284275055,
-0.09824363887310028,
-0.7729333639144897,
0.28307560086250305,
0.22975386679172516,
0.6774183511734009,
-0.28737130761146545,
-0.39950212836265564,
-0.1706092357635498,
0.2796751856803894,
-0.2848989963531494,
-0.8267845511436462,
0.4913369119167328,
0.46844151616096497,
0.8360549211502075,
0.5477094054222107,
0.17745761573314667,
0.39741167426109314,
-0.6346713900566101,
0.45947709679603577,
0.270395964384079,
-0.6309174299240112,
0.5714454650878906,
-0.6914564371109009,
0.1658131331205368,
0.671572744846344,
0.9064094424247742,
-0.875424325466156,
-0.3336149752140045,
0.02595624327659607,
-0.9015206694602966,
0.6279642581939697,
-0.118582583963871,
0.4711916148662567,
-0.1997397392988205,
0.25121039152145386,
0.30870842933654785,
0.08254498988389969,
-0.8576989769935608,
-0.3640841543674469,
0.10189605504274368,
0.0763542503118515,
-0.23099128901958466,
-0.4212460517883301,
-0.47599685192108154,
-0.12139589339494705,
0.839819073677063,
-0.1294713318347931,
-0.33412110805511475,
-0.07687410712242126,
0.01572995074093342,
-0.48442915081977844,
0.6509440541267395,
0.4754253923892975,
0.20704203844070435,
-0.4046989977359772,
0.15647374093532562,
0.17025126516819,
-0.32820016145706177,
0.4803699553012848,
-0.28981801867485046,
-0.3729141652584076,
-0.25873205065727234,
0.09292687475681305,
0.862015962600708,
0.37241628766059875,
-0.5074349045753479,
0.030779188498854637,
0.13621504604816437,
-0.21005485951900482,
0.22030779719352722,
0.1960722953081131,
-0.023517517372965813,
-0.20979438722133636,
0.13585013151168823,
-0.2919437289237976,
0.2534582018852234,
-0.6446124911308289,
0.19539889693260193,
0.7181812524795532,
-0.2891228497028351,
-0.1002713218331337,
0.6068993806838989,
0.45866498351097107,
0.3198573887348175,
0.22031088173389435,
0.12417978793382645,
-0.343734472990036,
0.33986184000968933,
0.555012047290802,
0.988566517829895,
-0.32197582721710205,
0.372663676738739,
0.6330203413963318,
0.3785306215286255,
0.34375062584877014,
0.09193357080221176,
0.1887238621711731,
-0.999383807182312,
-0.3772229552268982,
-0.662029504776001,
-0.2639845907688141,
0.16061805188655853,
-0.6159162521362305,
0.18841689825057983,
-0.2948073446750641,
0.13319966197013855,
-0.08997304737567902,
0.013667035847902298,
-0.25541239976882935,
0.08603731542825699,
0.2593638300895691,
0.6319156289100647,
-1.210992693901062,
0.7421444654464722,
0.6252601146697998,
-0.35460588335990906,
-0.5356776714324951,
0.008637585677206516,
0.11125212162733078,
-0.9066780209541321,
0.7468780279159546,
0.11583057790994644,
-0.12140428274869919,
-0.07183663547039032,
-0.04303944483399391,
-0.6838811635971069,
0.717494547367096,
0.7322938442230225,
-0.5640522241592407,
0.02093384973704815,
0.4299089014530182,
0.6255708932876587,
0.005077518988400698,
0.49359050393104553,
0.6191691756248474,
0.6592440605163574,
0.19332705438137054,
-1.2106642723083496,
-0.029009833931922913,
-0.17009945213794708,
0.02455068565905094,
0.17135654389858246,
-0.8887463212013245,
0.509655773639679,
-0.31167706847190857,
-0.1334080696105957,
-0.45843106508255005,
-0.24358300864696503,
0.18399396538734436,
0.030363917350769043,
0.5618875026702881,
0.7312725186347961,
0.30170655250549316,
0.26931384205818176,
0.8335889577865601,
-0.4950249493122101,
0.19350048899650574,
0.9273372292518616,
-0.4800325334072113,
0.7159006595611572,
0.6594457030296326,
-0.13543790578842163,
0.39075422286987305,
0.6772649884223938,
0.4359981119632721,
0.8505133986473083,
0.13464666903018951,
-0.39580321311950684,
-0.48378124833106995,
-0.36435770988464355,
-0.40759336948394775,
0.25953948497772217,
0.09765727072954178,
-0.46058619022369385,
-0.48633530735969543,
0.12023288011550903,
0.46706417202949524,
-0.13003431260585785,
-0.3594997227191925,
0.7167008519172668,
0.04077603667974472,
-0.7535296678543091,
0.9737091660499573,
-0.19334286451339722,
0.9106088876724243,
-0.7652827501296997,
0.2503477931022644,
-0.48230013251304626,
0.27157798409461975,
-0.35689228773117065,
-0.7623395919799805,
0.4522469937801361,
-0.3348696529865265,
-0.24806274473667145,
-0.49936577677726746,
0.6116963624954224,
-0.8266142010688782,
-0.38511189818382263,
0.8941841125488281,
0.37733757495880127,
0.013206006027758121,
-0.12238281965255737,
-0.5717059373855591,
-0.1513826698064804,
0.30114856362342834,
-0.24541541934013367,
0.6917172074317932,
0.2941444218158722,
-0.016623562201857567,
0.7206721305847168,
0.6653581261634827,
0.3896059989929199,
-0.0018602026393637061,
0.3459682762622833,
0.8391128182411194,
-0.29053404927253723,
-0.2818036377429962,
-0.9575001001358032,
0.51423579454422,
0.09593129903078079,
-0.10304674506187439,
0.7831374406814575,
0.6743208169937134,
0.9698407649993896,
-0.2924705147743225,
0.8718979358673096,
0.4040170907974243,
0.30696871876716614,
-0.6491522789001465,
0.8450633883476257,
-0.8591481447219849,
0.14231812953948975,
-0.07375150173902512,
-0.8358132839202881,
-0.5099359154701233,
0.2712041139602661,
-0.5605284571647644,
0.042300254106521606,
0.7074289321899414,
0.9703162908554077,
-0.029639389365911484,
-0.4659092426300049,
0.6661742329597473,
0.14777690172195435,
0.38269031047821045,
1.0688366889953613,
0.37722471356391907,
0.03434591367840767,
0.5839710831642151,
-0.3940899670124054,
-0.2701346278190613,
-0.10980843752622604,
-1.0777862071990967,
-0.8827718496322632,
-0.20406363904476166,
-0.1634702980518341,
0.0020940322428941727,
0.013318262062966824,
0.6469771265983582,
0.6292365789413452,
-0.8139123320579529,
-0.12502706050872803,
0.07130146771669388,
0.3582945466041565,
0.01415981911122799,
-0.20830506086349487,
-0.05970541760325432,
-0.6692113876342773,
-0.8082928657531738,
0.37246689200401306,
0.6169542074203491,
-0.255247563123703,
-0.19447004795074463,
-0.15800437331199646,
-0.266635924577713,
0.13870006799697876,
0.6997718811035156,
0.2292257398366928,
-0.605760395526886,
-0.6105027198791504,
-0.01395575050264597,
-0.17741793394088745,
0.1614932119846344,
0.7003656029701233,
-0.18456551432609558,
0.6371592283248901,
0.5288090109825134,
0.08032906800508499,
0.32151713967323303,
-0.3317205309867859,
0.7150225639343262,
-0.9067612886428833,
0.36852729320526123,
0.04824734106659889,
0.34934449195861816,
0.2121681571006775,
-0.5929397344589233,
0.6767775416374207,
0.048957452178001404,
-0.49360617995262146,
-0.5994460582733154,
0.5045165419578552,
-0.8002002835273743,
-0.30412402749061584,
1.7533843517303467,
-0.2996216416358948,
0.11234021931886673,
-0.2333553582429886,
-0.4287596344947815,
0.1214217096567154,
-0.324855238199234,
0.69191974401474,
0.6345232129096985,
-0.026601068675518036,
-0.262313574552536,
-0.347409725189209,
0.5516510009765625,
0.6226107478141785,
-0.9293827414512634,
0.23012574017047882,
0.5340063571929932,
0.7634106278419495,
0.05359254032373428,
0.6164655685424805,
-0.10277921706438065,
0.10678185522556305,
-0.3468714952468872,
0.11558542400598526,
-0.004927436355501413,
-0.283191055059433,
-0.4465728998184204,
-0.14209330081939697,
0.11141883581876755,
0.007194414734840393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16229v1 | Multi-Objective Linguistic Control of Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T21:56:48 | 2024-06-23T21:56:48 | Dang Nguyen, Jiuhai Chen, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs), despite their breakthroughs on many challenging
benchmark tasks, lean to generate verbose responses and lack the
controllability of output complexity, which is usually preferred by human users
in practice. In this paper, we study how to precisely control multiple
linguistic complexities of LLM output by finetuning using off-the-shelf data.
To this end, we propose multi-control tuning (MCTune), which includes multiple
linguistic complexity values of ground-truth responses as controls in the input
for instruction tuning. We finetune LLaMA2-7B on Alpaca-GPT4 and WizardLM
datasets. Evaluations on widely used benchmarks demonstrate that our method
does not only improve LLMs' multi-complexity controllability substantially but
also retains or even enhances the quality of the responses as a side benefit. | [
-0.7457178235054016,
-1.0325044393539429,
0.31490185856819153,
0.10816745460033417,
-0.07706966251134872,
-0.009747846983373165,
-0.757293701171875,
-0.15828751027584076,
-0.12201632559299469,
0.6745582222938538,
-0.596285343170166,
-0.4756334722042084,
-0.8411389589309692,
0.12517476081848145,
-0.02118777483701706,
1.0677353143692017,
-0.08662006258964539,
-0.10130579024553299,
0.3052959740161896,
-0.16691510379314423,
-0.5023106336593628,
-0.5252346396446228,
-0.5911775231361389,
-0.4557780921459198,
0.8102458715438843,
0.9538713693618774,
0.9397026300430298,
0.7074959874153137,
0.4958842098712921,
0.3171977400779724,
0.07805167883634567,
0.6099189519882202,
-0.6513992547988892,
-0.05023615062236786,
-0.2519100308418274,
-0.5392754673957825,
-0.4672148823738098,
-0.01877107098698616,
0.6754732728004456,
0.43415459990501404,
-0.4495379328727722,
0.17926061153411865,
0.275216668844223,
0.4639331102371216,
-0.519375205039978,
0.21068450808525085,
-0.8019974827766418,
-0.274167001247406,
-0.19653412699699402,
-0.26785263419151306,
-0.3733915090560913,
-0.4022733271121979,
-0.5493928790092468,
-0.5589779615402222,
0.016872646287083626,
0.16420744359493256,
0.8280594944953918,
0.6048903465270996,
-0.40279701352119446,
-0.6665264964103699,
-0.5993871688842773,
1.028425693511963,
-0.9208502769470215,
0.4959910809993744,
0.4847884774208069,
0.21508556604385376,
-0.26238131523132324,
-0.1598002016544342,
-0.4335603713989258,
-0.39866000413894653,
-0.15527541935443878,
-0.00461736461147666,
0.22795052826404572,
0.14828650653362274,
0.22969308495521545,
0.08646292239427567,
-0.27903589606285095,
0.49153104424476624,
-0.3904854953289032,
-0.2991611659526825,
0.49584126472473145,
0.079478919506073,
0.07212476432323456,
-0.022362535819411278,
-0.05413471907377243,
0.10991082340478897,
-0.6292914748191833,
-0.043335653841495514,
0.3364615738391876,
0.4214994013309479,
0.02313193865120411,
1.074713945388794,
-0.5589897632598877,
0.7452462315559387,
0.21211861073970795,
-0.4475438892841339,
0.039749808609485626,
-0.15581507980823517,
-0.3013497292995453,
0.08207076787948608,
0.7671672105789185,
0.3570907711982727,
0.48316076397895813,
-0.26869311928749084,
-0.19138649106025696,
0.11580709367990494,
0.03228701278567314,
-0.6239518523216248,
-0.026937974616885185,
0.34585845470428467,
-0.027981974184513092,
-0.023985516279935837,
-0.2192084938287735,
-0.6408693194389343,
-0.19038155674934387,
-1.0158075094223022,
0.3807887136936188,
-0.4419063627719879,
-0.1973101943731308,
0.09238102287054062,
0.25681647658348083,
0.2150612324476242,
0.10375741869211197,
-0.9347776174545288,
0.47625985741615295,
0.6009268760681152,
0.7483658790588379,
-0.27047744393348694,
-0.5364660620689392,
-0.9649982452392578,
0.3739562928676605,
-0.28909197449684143,
0.2961778938770294,
-0.589975118637085,
0.07605531811714172,
-0.24344322085380554,
-0.09125138074159622,
-0.07007303833961487,
-0.49454358220100403,
0.49130016565322876,
-0.38764479756355286,
-0.2103721797466278,
-0.19395017623901367,
-0.4084530472755432,
-0.027553848922252655,
0.18756864964962006,
-0.5463507175445557,
0.8827106952667236,
-0.31386029720306396,
-0.443977952003479,
0.19512517750263214,
-0.3938687741756439,
-0.37790191173553467,
-0.4511283040046692,
-0.1527682989835739,
-0.29828038811683655,
0.5044113993644714,
0.2594582140445709,
0.7344503998756409,
-0.2593459486961365,
0.7107805609703064,
-0.2964642345905304,
-0.2437785118818283,
0.18980611860752106,
-0.6456759572029114,
0.21902236342430115,
0.235175222158432,
-0.5374564528465271,
0.21927951276302338,
-1.0169720649719238,
0.3287690281867981,
-0.2624616026878357,
-0.6217139363288879,
-0.17331118881702423,
-0.04742911085486412,
-0.06344135850667953,
0.4473532736301422,
0.03737277910113335,
-0.3805829584598541,
0.16552843153476715,
-0.028660248965024948,
0.5351138710975647,
0.6364495754241943,
-0.4384763240814209,
0.3077904284000397,
-0.38781434297561646,
0.3669230341911316,
-0.1280805766582489,
-0.022237814962863922,
0.18493099510669708,
-0.26752451062202454,
-1.0364834070205688,
-0.28319504857063293,
0.13051480054855347,
0.5537622570991516,
-0.7363491654396057,
0.3711263835430145,
-0.18067799508571625,
-0.4672563970088959,
-0.5277212262153625,
0.49422675371170044,
0.5584253072738647,
0.3662375509738922,
0.49554458260536194,
-0.02004300244152546,
-0.071946881711483,
-0.9954833984375,
-0.2655755579471588,
0.4264185428619385,
-0.07473189383745193,
0.4880116581916809,
0.10177604109048843,
-0.07055902481079102,
0.532777726650238,
-0.3540045917034149,
-0.3888286054134369,
-0.09940499812364578,
0.3509312570095062,
0.2638035714626312,
0.5392202138900757,
0.14420388638973236,
-0.7288143634796143,
-0.1256372481584549,
0.2227654755115509,
-0.38840118050575256,
-0.4901309013366699,
-0.07199055701494217,
-0.2631847560405731,
0.18728719651699066,
0.5870166420936584,
-0.6085725426673889,
-0.022702187299728394,
0.8118540048599243,
0.06548873335123062,
0.6219732761383057,
-0.2817387282848358,
0.2932880222797394,
-0.7461853623390198,
-0.09564654529094696,
-0.15087302029132843,
-0.2082531601190567,
-0.516541063785553,
0.24364814162254333,
0.22855713963508606,
0.26403263211250305,
-0.5050796866416931,
0.18546487390995026,
-0.46598145365715027,
0.12784765660762787,
-0.148026704788208,
0.16069813072681427,
-0.11871008574962616,
0.8467816114425659,
-0.04621564596891403,
0.6743424534797668,
0.3788835108280182,
-1.0051337480545044,
0.46478599309921265,
0.09102766215801239,
-0.21087396144866943,
0.5982403755187988,
-0.6582226157188416,
-0.02012765035033226,
-0.33476901054382324,
-0.06278001517057419,
-0.9196876287460327,
-0.4876440465450287,
0.22298938035964966,
-0.23025114834308624,
0.5373111367225647,
0.13481904566287994,
-0.39368823170661926,
-0.07061566412448883,
-0.10710977017879486,
-0.01089849229902029,
0.0029160184785723686,
-0.34060174226760864,
0.7189751267433167,
0.11322548240423203,
-0.4350898861885071,
-0.5209360718727112,
-1.0052855014801025,
-0.00478714145720005,
-0.29100048542022705,
-0.04292584955692291,
0.12208621203899384,
-0.3253648579120636,
-0.14993201196193695,
-0.33605360984802246,
-0.13211585581302643,
-0.0017815250903367996,
-0.08289407938718796,
0.2385350614786148,
-0.08584389835596085,
-0.1932859718799591,
0.41594821214675903,
0.495340496301651,
-0.14915603399276733,
-0.12484553456306458,
-0.1443529576063156,
0.6253527402877808,
-0.041438233107328415,
-0.4521983563899994,
-0.4487035274505615,
0.38197848200798035,
0.6548774838447571,
-0.41888493299484253,
0.5307853817939758,
0.6450933218002319,
-0.07699279487133026,
-0.1748419553041458,
-0.8022144436836243,
-0.11517567187547684,
-0.4554905593395233,
0.6245133280754089,
-0.7109291553497314,
-0.9842787981033325,
0.36603647470474243,
-0.23429591953754425,
0.16948874294757843,
0.4671976566314697,
0.9126855731010437,
0.09798029065132141,
0.9768811464309692,
0.37268194556236267,
0.061511583626270294,
0.16477616131305695,
-0.10849158465862274,
-0.15788999199867249,
-0.8424931764602661,
-0.29560282826423645,
-0.7424898743629456,
-0.5990633368492126,
-0.6841442584991455,
-0.152975931763649,
0.12593305110931396,
0.48017340898513794,
-0.5207873582839966,
0.17180794477462769,
-0.4037235379219055,
0.7012684941291809,
0.6689218878746033,
0.26994413137435913,
0.53367680311203,
-0.06161744147539139,
-0.2625874876976013,
-0.011870971880853176,
-0.8712801337242126,
-0.4767640233039856,
0.9775059819221497,
0.16639280319213867,
1.2644517421722412,
0.37350356578826904,
0.513097882270813,
-0.08426117151975632,
0.25528183579444885,
-0.8082087635993958,
0.21910443902015686,
-0.3963465690612793,
-0.4736981987953186,
-0.5263611078262329,
-0.6966133713722229,
-0.4859519898891449,
0.3792508542537689,
-0.04127902910113335,
-0.7945098280906677,
-0.011410650797188282,
0.4990171790122986,
-0.24159562587738037,
0.1341041475534439,
-0.9055476188659668,
0.5440322160720825,
-0.5350862145423889,
-0.4697427451610565,
-0.13370631635189056,
-0.621228814125061,
0.536785900592804,
-0.2929639220237732,
0.5795182585716248,
-0.43973031640052795,
-0.16157926619052887,
0.3777395486831665,
-0.15118390321731567,
0.8278292417526245,
0.18850868940353394,
-0.3844730854034424,
-0.102105051279068,
0.19419939815998077,
0.5790964365005493,
0.39677396416664124,
-0.08417712897062302,
0.15629199147224426,
-0.17417076230049133,
-0.3354668617248535,
-0.2515921890735626,
1.299813985824585,
-0.8739069700241089,
-0.5785172581672668,
-0.06410704553127289,
-0.7200404405593872,
-0.45253750681877136,
0.4744362533092499,
0.39355218410491943,
0.6967114210128784,
0.17762959003448486,
0.3140100836753845,
0.6185738444328308,
-0.23632928729057312,
0.5039316415786743,
0.4148358106613159,
-0.17664769291877747,
-0.5199329853057861,
0.7484602928161621,
0.3335886597633362,
0.7673954367637634,
0.43152129650115967,
0.24256736040115356,
-0.4729435443878174,
-0.40131518244743347,
-0.5828996300697327,
0.10123870521783829,
-0.6660979390144348,
-0.3801391124725342,
-0.45845678448677063,
0.09481332451105118,
-0.230958953499794,
0.1379992663860321,
-0.4401007890701294,
-0.31718817353248596,
-0.34160012006759644,
0.05400215834379196,
0.298460453748703,
0.8354321122169495,
-0.047048479318618774,
0.6743284463882446,
-0.7346718907356262,
0.7965688705444336,
0.3063119947910309,
0.8158075213432312,
-0.19791997969150543,
-0.38120323419570923,
-0.13168026506900787,
0.3768943250179291,
-0.2831358313560486,
-0.7414774894714355,
0.12683647871017456,
0.7632816433906555,
0.5438961386680603,
0.12689603865146637,
-0.041516128927469254,
0.6343207359313965,
-0.667329728603363,
0.3252863883972168,
0.18695063889026642,
-1.1040695905685425,
0.2963212728500366,
-0.21337178349494934,
0.6562684774398804,
0.3739745020866394,
0.3709264397621155,
-0.2992793321609497,
-0.6213818192481995,
-0.11363440752029419,
-0.5281049013137817,
0.8576307892799377,
0.1814807504415512,
0.15358388423919678,
0.2769063711166382,
0.461037814617157,
0.1699255257844925,
0.3350791037082672,
-0.5092824697494507,
-0.1983833760023117,
-0.2096276581287384,
-0.2730625867843628,
-0.4683564305305481,
-0.23899725079536438,
-0.29289454221725464,
-0.11678663641214371,
0.5935551524162292,
-0.3435509502887726,
-0.2985507547855377,
-0.07718553394079208,
-0.2612170875072479,
-0.05528225004673004,
0.618350088596344,
0.824033796787262,
0.7787909507751465,
0.08793241530656815,
0.45522773265838623,
0.24334324896335602,
-0.2961273193359375,
0.28097298741340637,
-0.051388319581747055,
0.10622309893369675,
-0.20777106285095215,
0.12344161421060562,
0.8672154545783997,
0.2168550044298172,
-0.40347108244895935,
-0.10927322506904602,
0.1120627224445343,
-0.28210896253585815,
0.2476676106452942,
0.36144888401031494,
0.15535752475261688,
0.18002764880657196,
0.0648704320192337,
0.20678271353244781,
-0.0018611857667565346,
-0.1716507375240326,
0.14807188510894775,
0.28345826268196106,
-0.16730238497257233,
-0.0069834208115935326,
0.782819390296936,
-0.0997835025191307,
0.03906087204813957,
0.4158863127231598,
-0.01911989413201809,
-0.36824119091033936,
0.607823371887207,
0.5539687871932983,
0.29806700348854065,
-0.19612504541873932,
0.08630766719579697,
0.25139129161834717,
0.640429675579071,
-0.11954325437545776,
0.313935786485672,
0.20288148522377014,
-0.6742704510688782,
-0.9056703448295593,
-0.7813942432403564,
-0.29795315861701965,
0.3492283523082733,
-0.7029498219490051,
0.37044551968574524,
-0.47462502121925354,
-0.21826817095279694,
0.17190128564834595,
-0.1638236790895462,
-0.6606676578521729,
0.36075738072395325,
-0.09289774298667908,
0.5962741374969482,
-0.6231123805046082,
0.8730115294456482,
0.24530227482318878,
-0.2660992741584778,
-1.002811312675476,
-0.3820919990539551,
0.17627958953380585,
-0.6367653608322144,
0.4258575737476349,
0.14658619463443756,
-0.42682644724845886,
0.3342140316963196,
-0.6706245541572571,
-0.977756142616272,
0.7284841537475586,
0.5255780220031738,
-1.0739338397979736,
0.27106982469558716,
0.23502668738365173,
0.12248999625444412,
-0.11904533952474594,
0.11242391914129257,
1.0696146488189697,
0.7605791687965393,
0.18646055459976196,
-1.2396214008331299,
-0.20545834302902222,
0.0686844140291214,
-0.05628880858421326,
0.39911776781082153,
-0.7196568250656128,
0.7812340259552002,
-0.25571155548095703,
0.08453711122274399,
-0.0764465257525444,
0.372829794883728,
0.2996423542499542,
-0.11263054609298706,
0.22697213292121887,
0.5711272358894348,
0.7412735223770142,
-0.31466254591941833,
0.8610659837722778,
-0.22056925296783447,
0.45708802342414856,
1.5055564641952515,
0.013229282572865486,
0.7870638966560364,
0.5094575881958008,
-0.009759501554071903,
-0.10865198075771332,
0.559759259223938,
0.16235221922397614,
0.36518827080726624,
0.5058215260505676,
0.30617326498031616,
-0.2872103154659271,
-0.0939185619354248,
-0.3398953080177307,
0.5084712505340576,
0.5535436272621155,
-0.013617247343063354,
0.052276454865932465,
0.2449430227279663,
0.2601388096809387,
0.041673172265291214,
-0.5912806987762451,
0.7515081167221069,
0.009988528676331043,
-0.7218598127365112,
1.0492103099822998,
0.1256493479013443,
0.9104708433151245,
-0.7647772431373596,
0.11862543970346451,
-0.26998239755630493,
0.28583818674087524,
-0.2924966514110565,
-0.6014988422393799,
0.3111112415790558,
-0.10868413746356964,
-0.1803557127714157,
0.05690620467066765,
0.32834702730178833,
-0.8994140625,
-0.6513586640357971,
0.10008372366428375,
0.3638221025466919,
0.030456284061074257,
-0.10477102547883987,
-0.4108218848705292,
0.36034879088401794,
-0.14524328708648682,
-0.31564322113990784,
-0.07505225390195847,
0.49804556369781494,
-0.14548586308956146,
0.7287636995315552,
0.541949450969696,
0.39513301849365234,
0.6344437003135681,
0.0829816684126854,
0.766874372959137,
-0.4055796265602112,
-0.16379615664482117,
-0.8423069715499878,
0.10909959673881531,
0.06197085231542587,
-0.5486190319061279,
0.5814846158027649,
0.3933700621128082,
0.9513925909996033,
-0.11616966873407364,
0.6304383277893066,
-0.04200218990445137,
0.3338073790073395,
-0.9382590651512146,
0.6297457814216614,
-0.6658722162246704,
0.10964355617761612,
-0.07280491292476654,
-1.0305206775665283,
-0.49747389554977417,
0.08190781623125076,
0.03788652643561363,
0.09664387255907059,
0.5739094018936157,
0.9836589694023132,
-0.36881929636001587,
-0.33409762382507324,
0.4503345787525177,
0.38163551688194275,
0.3265784680843353,
0.5699489116668701,
0.5657142400741577,
0.009423789568245411,
0.5597857236862183,
-0.27051880955696106,
-0.43936583399772644,
-0.01848188415169716,
-0.9429080486297607,
-0.7493109703063965,
-0.1302124708890915,
-0.09470879286527634,
-0.017313137650489807,
0.01845991052687168,
0.8898946046829224,
0.7346504330635071,
-1.2508745193481445,
-0.4136490523815155,
-0.09152711927890778,
0.06889082491397858,
-0.2934489846229553,
-0.1309446096420288,
0.3575037121772766,
-0.710601806640625,
-0.9500706791877747,
0.1788194328546524,
0.15098585188388824,
-0.06875193119049072,
-0.2879384458065033,
-0.33246007561683655,
-0.19281809031963348,
0.08631736040115356,
0.602642834186554,
-0.013316674157977104,
-1.2461806535720825,
-0.17948856949806213,
-0.0027705016545951366,
-0.20936809480190277,
-0.09274100512266159,
0.8051937818527222,
-0.20540739595890045,
0.41842931509017944,
0.17908558249473572,
0.5233927369117737,
0.3106265366077423,
-0.018982337787747383,
0.5553554892539978,
-0.9272177219390869,
0.1063741073012352,
-0.17552952468395233,
0.22761675715446472,
0.1892186403274536,
-0.23164966702461243,
0.24223634600639343,
-0.273963987827301,
-0.5924294590950012,
-0.2175026535987854,
0.24758380651474,
-0.8092291355133057,
-0.28777915239334106,
1.3533810377120972,
0.09683539718389511,
0.12919916212558746,
-0.03222566097974777,
-0.6187393069267273,
0.39296481013298035,
-0.4107624590396881,
0.5070408582687378,
0.9577121138572693,
-0.06303251534700394,
-0.35163289308547974,
-0.8390752077102661,
0.4958778917789459,
0.35535839200019836,
-0.8603970408439636,
0.18507826328277588,
0.7558120489120483,
0.14658959209918976,
-0.0027367109432816505,
0.1808093637228012,
0.14411185681819916,
-0.01899690181016922,
-0.5321618914604187,
0.04775375500321388,
-0.24343246221542358,
-0.6888697743415833,
-0.2843644320964813,
0.20021846890449524,
0.21416275203227997,
0.0009254029137082398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16223v1 | Continuous Output Personality Detection Models via Mixed Strategy Training | 2024-06-23T21:32:15 | 2024-06-23T21:32:15 | Rong Wang, Kun Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The traditional personality models only yield binary results. This paper
presents a novel approach for training personality detection models that
produce continuous output values, using mixed strategies. By leveraging the
PANDORA dataset, which includes extensive personality labeling of Reddit
comments, we developed models that predict the Big Five personality traits with
high accuracy. Our approach involves fine-tuning a RoBERTa-base model with
various strategies such as Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) integration, and
hyperparameter tuning. The results demonstrate that our models significantly
outperform traditional binary classification methods, offering precise
continuous outputs for personality traits, thus enhancing applications in AI,
psychology, human resources, marketing and health care fields. | [
-0.6068509817123413,
-0.5976868867874146,
0.8622219562530518,
0.3013263940811157,
-0.2164827138185501,
0.09807896614074707,
-0.5303183794021606,
-0.23465175926685333,
0.25257882475852966,
0.6912182569503784,
-1.0491223335266113,
-0.4882168471813202,
-0.7847855091094971,
-0.08582358062267303,
-0.29181748628616333,
1.2798196077346802,
0.47207504510879517,
0.2219618707895279,
0.03795197978615761,
-0.2630171477794647,
-0.8555423021316528,
-0.7640756368637085,
-0.8005514144897461,
-0.535154402256012,
1.0662009716033936,
0.4965483844280243,
0.4653598368167877,
0.243068665266037,
0.2171594798564911,
0.22385366261005402,
0.1608053594827652,
0.2675374746322632,
-0.6334677934646606,
0.14256012439727783,
-0.1525268256664276,
-0.3158867061138153,
-0.3685079514980316,
0.26825013756752014,
0.663206160068512,
0.4244577884674072,
0.07094712555408478,
0.369525671005249,
-0.13409709930419922,
0.44102251529693604,
-0.6562589406967163,
-0.08185333013534546,
-0.4983721375465393,
0.23194357752799988,
-0.42440396547317505,
-0.2772587239742279,
-0.7252098321914673,
-0.4615253806114197,
-0.19278621673583984,
-0.12619423866271973,
-0.1371128261089325,
0.001327470992691815,
0.6755801439285278,
0.23331426084041595,
-0.4817202687263489,
-0.2237139195203781,
-1.3050557374954224,
1.2306629419326782,
-0.6462851166725159,
0.07961536198854446,
0.18462017178535461,
0.5411136150360107,
-0.038123298436403275,
-0.451322466135025,
-0.739787757396698,
0.036032892763614655,
-0.04494325816631317,
0.3001490533351898,
0.10639417916536331,
-0.21777179837226868,
0.18069136142730713,
0.1481231451034546,
-0.2622343599796295,
0.11063960939645767,
-0.07767539471387863,
0.2255268543958664,
0.7639091610908508,
0.23133988678455353,
0.028935983777046204,
0.3255581557750702,
0.08527794480323792,
-0.2370571345090866,
-0.08955128490924835,
-0.028447775170207024,
0.4736327528953552,
0.0025093634612858295,
-0.10794951766729355,
0.4498589038848877,
-0.10557436943054199,
0.6547635197639465,
0.6242746710777283,
-0.529615044593811,
-0.06273511052131653,
-0.1103661060333252,
0.022128745913505554,
-0.1924925595521927,
0.4505350589752197,
0.17047052085399628,
0.36884281039237976,
-0.2652019262313843,
-0.001788420951925218,
0.4239872395992279,
0.528375506401062,
-0.6960280537605286,
-0.45530834794044495,
0.670019805431366,
-0.6019423604011536,
-0.6061181426048279,
-0.15267376601696014,
-0.6534896492958069,
-0.3787826597690582,
-0.3249908983707428,
0.3391144573688507,
-0.5233398675918579,
-0.3849973678588867,
0.07917017489671707,
-0.4866347312927246,
-0.030481450259685516,
0.31038904190063477,
-1.0609389543533325,
0.12246252596378326,
0.6001812219619751,
0.6424733400344849,
-0.40777498483657837,
-0.08576454222202301,
-0.798373818397522,
0.0641724020242691,
-0.33689773082733154,
0.7087502479553223,
-0.6933794021606445,
-0.13854405283927917,
-0.12391010671854019,
-0.37272995710372925,
0.07901457697153091,
-0.5223431587219238,
0.6347056031227112,
-0.5156117677688599,
0.05781581252813339,
-0.11834337562322617,
-0.5976024866104126,
-0.1560126096010208,
0.21232254803180695,
-0.2786831557750702,
0.7096044421195984,
0.2137610912322998,
-0.8059127330780029,
0.7636540532112122,
-0.8099242448806763,
-0.0787733718752861,
0.1321343630552292,
0.0441996306180954,
-0.7553503513336182,
0.044521842151880264,
0.04831809550523758,
0.8447623252868652,
0.34989529848098755,
0.08692298829555511,
-0.7457683086395264,
-0.41183027625083923,
0.8847154378890991,
-0.04166104272007942,
0.65167236328125,
-0.012508632615208626,
-0.3708550035953522,
0.5553858280181885,
-1.0432007312774658,
0.3470149338245392,
-0.029740532860159874,
-0.5696594715118408,
-0.2888406813144684,
0.21643322706222534,
0.16660040616989136,
0.33068254590034485,
0.21780912578105927,
-0.9211376905441284,
0.04580029845237732,
0.33452481031417847,
0.23276005685329437,
0.7231130599975586,
0.001983662135899067,
0.17128373682498932,
-0.42490923404693604,
0.23796798288822174,
0.26070478558540344,
0.21262827515602112,
0.37118297815322876,
-0.5654657483100891,
-0.7299506664276123,
-0.7451916337013245,
0.39029574394226074,
0.3841506242752075,
-0.15030494332313538,
1.0465394258499146,
-0.17331191897392273,
-0.8032998442649841,
-0.3340212106704712,
-0.039626676589250565,
0.2999183237552643,
0.19880948960781097,
0.16092276573181152,
-0.7441255450248718,
-0.6467406153678894,
-0.6210883259773254,
-0.3150010406970978,
0.30658745765686035,
-0.23454681038856506,
0.29082876443862915,
0.5969728827476501,
-0.4979274272918701,
0.7729922533035278,
-0.3391260802745819,
0.06106920167803764,
-0.4634816646575928,
0.5208598971366882,
0.4603516757488251,
0.4062126576900482,
0.5071852207183838,
-0.7948248386383057,
-0.6953887343406677,
-0.007893199101090431,
-0.7333565950393677,
0.15826624631881714,
-0.08696135133504868,
-0.1640632003545761,
-0.23009076714515686,
-0.13931378722190857,
-0.2045792043209076,
0.2490202635526657,
0.567570149898529,
-0.4431542456150055,
0.7643455266952515,
0.21593211591243744,
-0.10818508267402649,
-0.7436009049415588,
-0.12205054610967636,
0.348307341337204,
-0.39771851897239685,
-0.617943286895752,
-0.10292991995811462,
0.06743601709604263,
-0.1841462105512619,
0.07455562055110931,
0.3024941682815552,
0.007631462067365646,
-0.27396729588508606,
-0.36086660623550415,
-0.4982854425907135,
-0.430164098739624,
0.7012576460838318,
0.39201968908309937,
0.5039041638374329,
0.22127975523471832,
-0.6078574061393738,
0.5145606398582458,
0.14065352082252502,
-0.14231494069099426,
1.2152544260025024,
-0.5055772066116333,
0.45330652594566345,
-0.21927335858345032,
0.5681295990943909,
-0.9979040026664734,
-0.5882962942123413,
0.046084653586149216,
-0.5560204386711121,
0.19345489144325256,
-0.3278280794620514,
-0.4821107089519501,
-0.28282690048217773,
-0.2145300805568695,
-0.20007212460041046,
0.694800853729248,
-0.48195335268974304,
0.5207508206367493,
0.0689699724316597,
-0.039990879595279694,
-0.1665332019329071,
-0.5660603046417236,
-0.1449829488992691,
-0.6200886964797974,
-0.660836398601532,
0.37171462178230286,
-0.2603851556777954,
0.06813777983188629,
-0.26332390308380127,
0.36357855796813965,
-0.056694094091653824,
-0.027756262570619583,
0.2911853790283203,
0.029699990525841713,
-0.07421650737524033,
-0.1980406790971756,
-0.19532491266727448,
-0.1297246366739273,
-0.11046659201383591,
-0.37117552757263184,
0.782914936542511,
0.0159175843000412,
-0.17405171692371368,
-0.49017584323883057,
0.6005530953407288,
0.7632392644882202,
-0.1956743746995926,
1.000443458557129,
1.2416448593139648,
0.05305269733071327,
-0.39829933643341064,
-0.4185258746147156,
-0.4806366562843323,
-0.4460999071598053,
0.24677929282188416,
-0.2420380562543869,
-0.7201913595199585,
0.45114636421203613,
-0.23272109031677246,
0.2539735436439514,
-0.04613111540675163,
0.8939271569252014,
-0.4083135426044464,
1.4648239612579346,
0.7366937398910522,
0.29344993829727173,
0.6473882794380188,
-0.03407490253448486,
0.36551618576049805,
-0.9517508745193481,
0.09271378815174103,
-0.19126509130001068,
-0.7352351546287537,
-0.7312136888504028,
0.04082086682319641,
0.7763680815696716,
-0.42637336254119873,
-0.6892523765563965,
0.10545794665813446,
-0.6719189286231995,
0.163799449801445,
1.037322998046875,
0.477660208940506,
0.14395739138126373,
-0.23808810114860535,
-0.005416298285126686,
-0.3216433823108673,
-0.30517125129699707,
-0.41112345457077026,
1.618149757385254,
0.5475524067878723,
0.7281401753425598,
0.31294703483581543,
0.8766111731529236,
0.5104786157608032,
0.5789219737052917,
-0.6543199419975281,
0.25345221161842346,
-0.16423866152763367,
-0.606877863407135,
-0.3734051585197449,
-0.300139844417572,
-0.4541434943675995,
0.02990644797682762,
-0.5553041100502014,
-0.79802006483078,
0.18398571014404297,
0.11838079988956451,
-0.5399661660194397,
0.16972985863685608,
-0.7537195086479187,
0.7819179892539978,
-0.3382180631160736,
-0.5167499780654907,
-0.1826329529285431,
-0.42996522784233093,
0.684231162071228,
-0.06738169491291046,
-0.2544582188129425,
0.05795343220233917,
0.39972665905952454,
0.623910665512085,
-0.017400996759533882,
0.9306174516677856,
-0.17018719017505646,
0.3129440248012543,
-0.3989604413509369,
-0.13130468130111694,
0.5369910001754761,
0.09100556373596191,
0.12393312901258469,
0.13182780146598816,
0.07462235540151596,
-0.705650806427002,
-0.4666723906993866,
0.6561062932014465,
-1.0867091417312622,
0.06528624892234802,
-0.5214613080024719,
-0.6574686765670776,
-0.6469919085502625,
0.01363667193800211,
0.27192819118499756,
0.009141257032752037,
-0.018018998205661774,
0.36742666363716125,
0.9172280430793762,
-0.1514255404472351,
0.20242178440093994,
0.44466570019721985,
-0.0838564857840538,
-0.4225322902202606,
0.8232641816139221,
-0.06671778112649918,
0.14022661745548248,
-0.050554633140563965,
0.18332885205745697,
-0.25169575214385986,
-0.5275818705558777,
-0.2499638944864273,
0.3211667835712433,
-0.41145727038383484,
0.3183031976222992,
-0.517913818359375,
-0.25825291872024536,
-0.18221595883369446,
-0.12773218750953674,
-0.46583548188209534,
0.06622584909200668,
0.07920366525650024,
0.2996242642402649,
0.20893597602844238,
0.8299627900123596,
0.15315696597099304,
0.5261449217796326,
-0.4702051281929016,
0.2773917615413666,
0.6807366013526917,
0.3784192204475403,
0.05797318369150162,
-0.29461488127708435,
-0.309303879737854,
0.027086738497018814,
-0.9401537775993347,
-0.9986509680747986,
0.5080990791320801,
0.030963629484176636,
0.14971640706062317,
0.5893951654434204,
-0.2595994472503662,
0.3850683569908142,
-0.10467814654111862,
0.5832719802856445,
0.36329951882362366,
-0.5304227471351624,
0.5170235633850098,
-0.6470839977264404,
0.18437232077121735,
0.237175852060318,
0.6064133048057556,
-0.728303849697113,
-0.17800280451774597,
-0.6772096157073975,
-0.22816681861877441,
0.41033056378364563,
0.3245995342731476,
-0.06472660601139069,
0.08918822556734085,
0.2394084334373474,
0.08517811447381973,
0.39757847785949707,
-0.9272779226303101,
0.014165421016514301,
-0.2458559274673462,
-0.4449140727519989,
0.04369473457336426,
-0.09385532140731812,
-0.31813690066337585,
-0.43779709935188293,
0.7203792333602905,
-0.28435763716697693,
0.5266038775444031,
-0.0869278758764267,
0.35466301441192627,
-0.13709166646003723,
0.2619560658931732,
0.5296880006790161,
0.6784628629684448,
-0.7057734727859497,
-0.2777445912361145,
-0.22153887152671814,
-0.20064464211463928,
0.1126430407166481,
-0.3447456359863281,
-0.26872196793556213,
0.009535934776067734,
0.06774275004863739,
0.7638055086135864,
0.12010160833597183,
-0.44091951847076416,
0.2440629005432129,
-0.2197088748216629,
-0.10182832926511765,
-0.8975412249565125,
0.49058112502098083,
0.4234330356121063,
0.23066946864128113,
0.2824731469154358,
0.19139155745506287,
-0.12449318170547485,
-1.0459779500961304,
0.0819709300994873,
0.4637838900089264,
-0.3236212432384491,
-0.33225229382514954,
0.6380014419555664,
0.18326665461063385,
-0.1706552356481552,
0.5094267129898071,
-0.19284527003765106,
-0.30841198563575745,
0.46263036131858826,
0.4308256208896637,
0.7684444189071655,
0.050419311970472336,
0.2917141616344452,
0.39507171511650085,
-0.33025115728378296,
0.023030497133731842,
0.4044971466064453,
-0.11742641776800156,
-1.0366190671920776,
-0.42237934470176697,
-0.8983778953552246,
-0.8483516573905945,
0.5247357487678528,
-0.6873548626899719,
0.2892017662525177,
-1.0158981084823608,
-0.3681263029575348,
0.6174046993255615,
0.15282940864562988,
-0.6153838634490967,
0.3184356689453125,
0.2815850079059601,
0.09797605127096176,
-0.9466392993927002,
0.8151297569274902,
0.7145170569419861,
-0.4917273223400116,
-0.48239970207214355,
-0.05184962972998619,
0.10062647610902786,
-0.4793281853199005,
0.7110233306884766,
0.014802836813032627,
0.27342110872268677,
0.14514319598674774,
-0.8452236652374268,
-0.5988581776618958,
0.7574328780174255,
-0.1058644950389862,
-0.516023576259613,
0.1636393517255783,
-0.21507412195205688,
0.5337090492248535,
-0.7922433614730835,
0.3526184558868408,
0.7387614250183105,
0.6935355067253113,
0.05356935039162636,
-0.6036556363105774,
-0.35852932929992676,
-0.13663651049137115,
0.19678765535354614,
0.037434276193380356,
-0.6998171806335449,
0.9910796284675598,
0.23102103173732758,
0.0858834832906723,
0.05145122483372688,
0.6649284958839417,
0.6827011108398438,
0.3257126808166504,
0.5380721092224121,
0.8096933960914612,
0.6493845582008362,
-0.1041497141122818,
0.955937922000885,
-0.14707398414611816,
0.16612045466899872,
1.0108885765075684,
-0.3071911633014679,
0.9153997302055359,
0.28338587284088135,
-0.2834490239620209,
0.9842804670333862,
0.8108115196228027,
-0.16004647314548492,
0.6753443479537964,
0.15482279658317566,
-0.4116522967815399,
-0.41385704278945923,
0.08645755052566528,
0.06177262216806412,
0.43238481879234314,
0.5183165073394775,
-0.37980005145072937,
0.2722163498401642,
0.12541843950748444,
0.16924527287483215,
0.14649304747581482,
-0.10648064315319061,
0.7229407429695129,
-0.33752918243408203,
-0.9489047527313232,
0.6405200362205505,
0.2189507782459259,
1.3101015090942383,
-0.738111674785614,
-0.17780475318431854,
-0.19581268727779388,
0.5495560169219971,
-0.382610946893692,
-0.7500118017196655,
0.36767733097076416,
0.020842943340539932,
-0.37488996982574463,
-0.2189532220363617,
0.6015672087669373,
-0.2592941224575043,
-0.4606117010116577,
0.12995900213718414,
0.13432179391384125,
-0.017432473599910736,
-0.33630433678627014,
-0.4919414222240448,
-0.11626509577035904,
-0.13640213012695312,
0.17405831813812256,
0.605351448059082,
0.2549131512641907,
0.059780362993478775,
0.5515291094779968,
0.9772685170173645,
0.39494284987449646,
0.21497611701488495,
-0.088894322514534,
0.5865291357040405,
-0.7920963764190674,
-0.7707117199897766,
-0.488641619682312,
0.6454657912254333,
-0.5310983061790466,
-0.5210164785385132,
0.6346592307090759,
0.1465694159269333,
0.8169687390327454,
-0.297056645154953,
0.9553627967834473,
0.023065747693181038,
0.9905222654342651,
-0.17782866954803467,
0.4758363366127014,
-0.2670291066169739,
-0.14756062626838684,
-0.15534187853336334,
-0.9072432518005371,
0.19045311212539673,
0.47214508056640625,
-0.367835134267807,
0.2780948877334595,
0.5940013527870178,
0.4789005219936371,
-0.5112227201461792,
-0.1726144701242447,
0.36240479350090027,
0.32264888286590576,
0.22096994519233704,
0.6074331998825073,
0.5105442404747009,
-0.03493301570415497,
0.13747426867485046,
-0.534221887588501,
-0.5608707666397095,
-0.517293393611908,
-0.611103355884552,
-1.1467907428741455,
-0.43066534399986267,
-0.23840324580669403,
-0.45113980770111084,
0.1504199504852295,
0.32261696457862854,
1.255995512008667,
-0.8534031510353088,
-0.1525779515504837,
-0.08506976813077927,
-0.07743627578020096,
-0.7318850755691528,
-0.345216304063797,
-0.1621633768081665,
-0.15291209518909454,
-0.6725355386734009,
0.08613830804824829,
0.3151794672012329,
-0.36211204528808594,
-0.8999101519584656,
-0.08144248276948929,
-0.24322079122066498,
0.28416183590888977,
0.5289556980133057,
0.2449854165315628,
-0.667834997177124,
-0.6316401958465576,
-0.20664943754673004,
0.11364801228046417,
0.016097256913781166,
0.4652872383594513,
-0.3767113983631134,
0.1387779861688614,
0.27954089641571045,
0.3955761194229126,
0.9937688708305359,
0.18418988585472107,
0.6703599691390991,
-0.9564520120620728,
0.010356126353144646,
0.4859026074409485,
0.11786935478448868,
0.4440847337245941,
-0.5852212309837341,
0.4778309762477875,
0.3348511755466461,
-0.7240740656852722,
-0.4695386290550232,
0.549180805683136,
-1.1570874452590942,
-0.12642697989940643,
0.8931700587272644,
-0.17750222980976105,
-0.40885284543037415,
-0.24028511345386505,
-0.09813693165779114,
0.048563551157712936,
-0.3588002324104309,
1.0018411874771118,
0.8796436786651611,
-0.4953047037124634,
-0.3900858163833618,
-0.5526949763298035,
0.2564070522785187,
0.460795521736145,
-0.6300216913223267,
-0.40834131836891174,
0.4619443714618683,
0.573675811290741,
0.3086521029472351,
0.48777294158935547,
-0.10357064008712769,
0.5147647261619568,
-0.03540443256497383,
0.25055837631225586,
0.28276175260543823,
-0.1980455070734024,
0.046103719621896744,
0.28712397813796997,
-0.026617543771862984,
-0.26108577847480774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16203v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16203v3 | LLMs' Classification Performance is Overclaimed | 2024-06-23T19:49:10 | 2024-07-03T13:18:50 | Hanzi Xu, Renze Lou, Jiangshu Du, Vahid Mahzoon, Elmira Talebianaraki, Zhuoan Zhou, Elizabeth Garrison, Slobodan Vucetic, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | In many classification tasks designed for AI or human to solve, gold labels
are typically included within the label space by default, often posed as "which
of the following is correct?" This standard setup has traditionally highlighted
the strong performance of advanced AI, particularly top-performing Large
Language Models (LLMs), in routine classification tasks. However, when the gold
label is intentionally excluded from the label space, it becomes evident that
LLMs still attempt to select from the available label candidates, even when
none are correct. This raises a pivotal question: Do LLMs truly demonstrate
their intelligence in understanding the essence of classification tasks?
In this study, we evaluate both closed-source and open-source LLMs across
representative classification tasks, arguing that the perceived performance of
LLMs is overstated due to their inability to exhibit the expected comprehension
of the task. This paper makes a threefold contribution: i) To our knowledge,
this is the first work to identify the limitations of LLMs in classification
tasks when gold labels are absent. We define this task as Classify-w/o-Gold and
propose it as a new testbed for LLMs. ii) We introduce a benchmark, Know-No,
comprising two existing classification tasks and one new task, to evaluate
Classify-w/o-Gold. iii) This work defines and advocates for a new evaluation
metric, OmniAccuracy, which assesses LLMs' performance in classification tasks
both when gold labels are present and absent. | [
-0.38864415884017944,
-0.5332320928573608,
0.5961955189704895,
-0.04092850536108017,
0.06727133691310883,
0.18862450122833252,
-0.41893133521080017,
-0.6982913613319397,
-0.005784665700048208,
0.5358777046203613,
-0.4882482588291168,
-0.6319286823272705,
-0.8124540448188782,
0.305212140083313,
-0.17732948064804077,
1.1739510297775269,
-0.10253643989562988,
-0.3201267719268799,
-0.6157221794128418,
-0.36043640971183777,
-0.18664106726646423,
-0.7275110483169556,
-0.1211882159113884,
-0.590418815612793,
0.5977249145507812,
0.26548904180526733,
0.7164629101753235,
0.6780757904052734,
0.47730138897895813,
0.2910977900028229,
-0.25789177417755127,
0.4496331214904785,
-0.38657140731811523,
-0.22923076152801514,
-0.20848962664604187,
-0.7799970507621765,
-0.48462802171707153,
0.38952404260635376,
0.6244898438453674,
0.7441605925559998,
0.20556893944740295,
0.38137125968933105,
0.21615596115589142,
0.7666164636611938,
-0.9887537360191345,
0.45129790902137756,
-0.5342488288879395,
0.24751321971416473,
-0.30053168535232544,
-0.2926062047481537,
-0.41983354091644287,
-0.1738591492176056,
-0.03624552860856056,
-0.49410244822502136,
0.012628238648176193,
0.11535444855690002,
0.7056770920753479,
0.667719841003418,
-0.17959579825401306,
-0.4389696717262268,
-0.8981114029884338,
0.8125514984130859,
-0.3928292691707611,
0.24569742381572723,
0.41847914457321167,
0.331752210855484,
0.0346485935151577,
-0.6527838110923767,
-0.46431413292884827,
-0.4237975478172302,
-0.10783654451370239,
0.21239769458770752,
-0.30478668212890625,
-0.013513130135834217,
0.37521740794181824,
0.616395115852356,
-0.4874899089336395,
0.43250900506973267,
-0.4765484631061554,
-0.08606182038784027,
0.5067940950393677,
0.07277459651231766,
0.05552089959383011,
0.09983410686254501,
-0.3134678304195404,
0.04807087779045105,
-0.4944603741168976,
-0.06197050213813782,
0.2633307874202728,
0.3403323292732239,
0.20325978100299835,
1.0074039697647095,
-0.10392723977565765,
0.7095518112182617,
-0.2602115273475647,
-0.3279864490032196,
0.540295422077179,
0.03778335452079773,
-0.40279415249824524,
0.15608297288417816,
0.6715532541275024,
-0.0037263233680278063,
0.3775729537010193,
-0.3707916736602783,
-0.23597007989883423,
0.4476945400238037,
0.09788734465837479,
-0.4072286784648895,
-0.21640226244926453,
0.11878014355897903,
-0.2939201891422272,
-0.0657443106174469,
0.11318045109510422,
-0.23631715774536133,
-0.5033954977989197,
-0.15210741758346558,
0.6253156661987305,
0.019516287371516228,
-0.04567817226052284,
0.12112152576446533,
-0.20605580508708954,
-0.012397057376801968,
0.20971496403217316,
-0.5771452188491821,
0.37852010130882263,
0.8125727772712708,
0.7315894961357117,
-0.36412519216537476,
-0.3935403525829315,
-0.5852411985397339,
-0.07782282680273056,
-0.3595336973667145,
0.7433453798294067,
-0.4391571879386902,
-0.06872855126857758,
-0.08681615442037582,
-0.043411143124103546,
-0.3003263473510742,
-0.808449387550354,
0.6657689809799194,
-0.5745428800582886,
0.01856387034058571,
-0.2508288621902466,
-0.7321018576622009,
-0.2240685075521469,
0.43332481384277344,
-0.7268891334533691,
0.7396939396858215,
0.22387756407260895,
-0.6458863615989685,
0.40760260820388794,
-0.656672477722168,
-0.1942741721868515,
0.29916253685951233,
-0.210782989859581,
-0.2348618507385254,
-0.0382787249982357,
-0.025704748928546906,
0.4031778872013092,
-0.11031635105609894,
-0.10139071196317673,
-0.36657243967056274,
-0.7548837065696716,
0.6314195394515991,
-0.5753424167633057,
0.717271625995636,
0.07343931496143341,
-0.40535181760787964,
-0.23474659025669098,
-0.7159390449523926,
0.1471172571182251,
-0.0019721738062798977,
-0.6612588167190552,
-0.2928889989852905,
-0.006700923200696707,
-0.45712947845458984,
0.14935483038425446,
0.3075469434261322,
-0.5190547108650208,
0.19014061987400055,
-0.40431106090545654,
0.35184600949287415,
0.6512848734855652,
-0.4231792092323303,
0.3546445369720459,
-0.46431586146354675,
0.4495554268360138,
-0.3603163957595825,
0.09626123309135437,
0.09761720150709152,
-0.5801611542701721,
-1.070317268371582,
-0.32273611426353455,
0.5772516131401062,
0.8907386064529419,
-0.4223179519176483,
0.6241994500160217,
-0.37337756156921387,
-0.5241382718086243,
-0.719262957572937,
0.5234773755073547,
0.43108606338500977,
0.17451928555965424,
0.36102622747421265,
-0.3374411165714264,
-0.29448360204696655,
-0.830185055732727,
-0.3884037733078003,
-0.29379042983055115,
-0.05545719712972641,
0.4057759642601013,
0.6161732077598572,
-0.3532624840736389,
0.7539326548576355,
-0.3517840802669525,
-0.5635936260223389,
-0.17746290564537048,
0.2011793702840805,
0.1140168234705925,
0.1979488581418991,
0.5137736797332764,
-0.5602285265922546,
0.035560011863708496,
-0.02207019552588463,
-0.9492616057395935,
-0.19501405954360962,
0.2664518356323242,
0.08308622986078262,
0.559445858001709,
0.44254180788993835,
-0.5794842839241028,
0.5419025421142578,
0.6444681882858276,
-0.20203843712806702,
0.5266494750976562,
-0.29724186658859253,
0.01934446580708027,
-0.17575475573539734,
0.1724911481142044,
0.05123945325613022,
0.0703924223780632,
-0.37389400601387024,
-0.0626249834895134,
0.16140198707580566,
0.15362012386322021,
-0.42737463116645813,
0.5735081434249878,
-0.35183656215667725,
-0.41394367814064026,
-0.22640879452228546,
0.356058806180954,
0.06061631813645363,
0.5803201198577881,
-0.1002180203795433,
0.5065712332725525,
0.4320811629295349,
-0.737692654132843,
0.26775768399238586,
0.13469426333904266,
-0.5428261756896973,
0.40702006220817566,
-0.3630093038082123,
-0.0354563444852829,
-0.20357617735862732,
0.15914367139339447,
-1.161916732788086,
-0.178450345993042,
0.47518596053123474,
-0.5590024590492249,
0.18685954809188843,
-0.0867214947938919,
-0.8308064937591553,
-0.534795343875885,
-0.04365621507167816,
0.31080204248428345,
0.7883060574531555,
-0.4890808165073395,
0.4362506568431854,
0.20022085309028625,
0.11275015771389008,
-0.5318560004234314,
-1.0061802864074707,
-0.05906795710325241,
-0.2404862940311432,
-0.24851545691490173,
0.17249098420143127,
-0.1158115565776825,
-0.4672529101371765,
0.07140485942363739,
-0.13219350576400757,
0.022795628756284714,
0.3416517376899719,
0.4444708526134491,
0.15244784951210022,
-0.1760082095861435,
0.28550848364830017,
-0.2689720392227173,
-0.0833776593208313,
0.20603910088539124,
-0.08140116930007935,
0.18010196089744568,
-0.3311724066734314,
-0.8423293232917786,
-0.4231632649898529,
-0.1889495551586151,
0.7041763663291931,
-0.40089309215545654,
0.8003564476966858,
0.6349865198135376,
-0.18355093896389008,
-0.1617206633090973,
-0.6086011528968811,
0.2721930742263794,
-0.44711846113204956,
0.28269731998443604,
-0.060827743262052536,
-0.8531895875930786,
0.319587767124176,
-0.03337866812944412,
0.37757301330566406,
0.6263136267662048,
0.20012639462947845,
-0.17223171889781952,
1.082985281944275,
0.46533316373825073,
-0.07189993560314178,
0.1496320366859436,
-0.32892370223999023,
0.11905542016029358,
-0.8747375011444092,
-0.4363527297973633,
-0.7549567818641663,
-0.3490905165672302,
-0.5503053069114685,
-0.3479667007923126,
0.4245041608810425,
0.14310744404792786,
-0.307503342628479,
-0.07995083183050156,
-0.4573981463909149,
0.4991232454776764,
0.5136192440986633,
0.18872720003128052,
0.4535243809223175,
0.09746871888637543,
0.24751316010951996,
-0.040278151631355286,
-0.7199453711509705,
-0.7693442106246948,
1.0054841041564941,
0.39113038778305054,
0.6037003993988037,
-0.04406116157770157,
0.552257239818573,
0.5602428913116455,
0.6389193534851074,
-0.8971551656723022,
0.49469447135925293,
-0.34928858280181885,
-0.5108911991119385,
-0.10742247849702835,
-0.5042604207992554,
-1.1391350030899048,
0.3181473910808563,
-0.17823904752731323,
-0.736914336681366,
-0.20627187192440033,
0.022401882335543633,
-0.45277658104896545,
0.4481183886528015,
-0.5901093482971191,
0.8095841407775879,
-0.6649119257926941,
0.02181423455476761,
0.1516464352607727,
-0.3671463429927826,
0.44195789098739624,
-0.1215115413069725,
0.47311440110206604,
-0.2117970734834671,
-0.30766236782073975,
1.0394195318222046,
-0.13157300651073456,
0.8514405488967896,
-0.00459035811945796,
-0.111546091735363,
0.37894415855407715,
-0.024953661486506462,
0.18430857360363007,
-0.4287150800228119,
-0.14034804701805115,
0.15110567212104797,
-0.3938762843608856,
-0.35802558064460754,
-0.7144232988357544,
0.5917338728904724,
-0.738924503326416,
-0.4690556824207306,
-0.3917902112007141,
-0.35656875371932983,
-0.22670109570026398,
-0.03539350628852844,
0.14746814966201782,
0.29512521624565125,
0.1415969729423523,
0.1052040085196495,
0.7886317372322083,
-0.31301236152648926,
0.05750444903969765,
0.43770506978034973,
-0.0014633777318522334,
-0.2986568212509155,
1.1191134452819824,
0.4460175633430481,
0.2798226475715637,
0.23054665327072144,
0.072898268699646,
-0.2937401533126831,
-0.5531867742538452,
-0.4819478690624237,
0.4549306631088257,
-1.0247095823287964,
0.028609082102775574,
-0.7130728363990784,
-0.4141956865787506,
-0.14034515619277954,
-0.0027324019465595484,
-0.18195417523384094,
-0.3570328950881958,
-0.5014580488204956,
-0.06305886059999466,
0.16719932854175568,
0.9669378995895386,
0.12465156614780426,
-0.01637071929872036,
-0.7838616967201233,
0.12204114347696304,
0.4829842746257782,
0.38621172308921814,
-0.02437838539481163,
-0.6703602075576782,
-0.15120509266853333,
0.007833155803382397,
-0.36771488189697266,
-0.490827739238739,
0.026282690465450287,
0.18013504147529602,
1.124105453491211,
0.3896455764770508,
0.2638969421386719,
0.6364963054656982,
-0.22795860469341278,
0.9010295271873474,
-0.1394081711769104,
-0.6598101854324341,
0.41440922021865845,
0.09769754111766815,
0.3219466209411621,
0.5285654664039612,
0.5017402172088623,
-0.0059838988818228245,
-0.6077606081962585,
-0.7367898225784302,
-0.7912446856498718,
0.7882141470909119,
0.4590742886066437,
-0.17870447039604187,
-0.0329371839761734,
0.2795039415359497,
0.15303337574005127,
0.45348167419433594,
-0.8876084089279175,
-0.4911045730113983,
0.22006669640541077,
0.03774076700210571,
-0.4806123971939087,
-0.11280597746372223,
-0.013844193890690804,
-0.10859539359807968,
0.5384353399276733,
0.027643363922834396,
0.3085114061832428,
0.05618998408317566,
-0.22255142033100128,
-0.0873938500881195,
0.2756200134754181,
0.5375050902366638,
0.8023605346679688,
-0.11861853301525116,
0.23535077273845673,
0.2806837558746338,
-0.07687592506408691,
-0.179338738322258,
-0.016339002177119255,
0.04441399127244949,
-0.0021933182142674923,
0.6724998354911804,
0.7640974521636963,
0.11116065084934235,
-0.996528685092926,
0.4864092171192169,
0.0919160470366478,
-0.3460984528064728,
-0.3415716588497162,
0.49232858419418335,
-0.17720171809196472,
0.4509589970111847,
0.3721613585948944,
0.34785839915275574,
0.11802200227975845,
-0.7653102874755859,
-0.14080007374286652,
0.4973795413970947,
-0.5139607191085815,
-0.06039651483297348,
0.45328065752983093,
-0.104507677257061,
-0.4179735779762268,
0.566350519657135,
-0.2869586944580078,
-0.7938057780265808,
0.7123271822929382,
0.18840590119361877,
0.6774758100509644,
0.11509638279676437,
0.022941231727600098,
0.11802253872156143,
0.5752824544906616,
-0.18373635411262512,
0.10869356244802475,
-0.2432388812303543,
-0.4767909348011017,
-0.4911457598209381,
-0.6271812915802002,
-0.3879146873950958,
0.33286604285240173,
-0.6862607002258301,
-0.07248242199420929,
-0.31940868496894836,
-0.1981557458639145,
-0.045752011239528656,
-0.02693820931017399,
-0.6117740869522095,
0.20562498271465302,
0.5326431393623352,
0.9896203875541687,
-0.9681680798530579,
0.34362682700157166,
0.7640316486358643,
0.021006138995289803,
-0.4173228442668915,
-0.1689269244670868,
-0.16873209178447723,
-0.6999061107635498,
0.6916940212249756,
0.4832436740398407,
-0.13826172053813934,
-0.3107760548591614,
-0.5422181487083435,
-0.7878564596176147,
0.898719847202301,
0.3122245967388153,
-0.07576516270637512,
0.1049867644906044,
0.11612293124198914,
0.7062923312187195,
-0.133285790681839,
0.11383233219385147,
0.6574345827102661,
0.6848183274269104,
0.09698653966188431,
-1.1885018348693848,
-0.3351707458496094,
-0.274745374917984,
-0.2856777012348175,
0.1265069544315338,
-0.573657751083374,
0.8190425038337708,
-0.16224339604377747,
-0.23430220782756805,
0.2734904885292053,
0.5111772418022156,
0.4503171741962433,
0.5067026019096375,
0.4562528133392334,
0.5758099555969238,
0.8167577385902405,
-0.30718764662742615,
1.0632222890853882,
0.12783630192279816,
0.2381398230791092,
0.7915360331535339,
-0.3678767681121826,
0.8588442802429199,
0.14492031931877136,
-0.3134117126464844,
0.33791473507881165,
0.5700772404670715,
-0.07425227016210556,
0.4602545499801636,
0.3568412661552429,
-0.11196663975715637,
-0.4572289288043976,
-0.09833003580570221,
-0.3350953757762909,
0.496829628944397,
0.6268090009689331,
-0.4599528908729553,
-0.1892816126346588,
0.157584086060524,
-0.17609162628650665,
0.0597272589802742,
-0.6559503674507141,
0.7673819065093994,
-0.0924551784992218,
-0.9663639068603516,
0.8022041916847229,
0.027907313778996468,
0.7042587399482727,
-0.4849385917186737,
-0.049470603466033936,
0.03174581006169319,
0.39167994260787964,
-0.36885422468185425,
-0.948063850402832,
0.13704317808151245,
0.014785042963922024,
-0.06089065596461296,
-0.02555345557630062,
0.5717579126358032,
-0.23122386634349823,
-0.43697863817214966,
0.3259299099445343,
0.5404660105705261,
0.5988166332244873,
-0.0208990927785635,
-0.5926199555397034,
0.1307283192873001,
-0.20373867452144623,
-0.17895002663135529,
0.4497542381286621,
0.5241466760635376,
-0.03184070065617561,
0.9345592260360718,
0.3735125660896301,
0.1754920482635498,
0.06100941076874733,
-0.10198623687028885,
0.7156473994255066,
-0.3446005880832672,
-0.2576565444469452,
-0.9860246181488037,
0.1152619794011116,
0.1327933818101883,
-0.15710483491420746,
0.8291640877723694,
0.5119509100914001,
0.9856013059616089,
0.02754453755915165,
0.8743894696235657,
0.09871049225330353,
0.4092106819152832,
-0.4445253610610962,
0.4975350499153137,
-0.8200087547302246,
0.30306559801101685,
-0.3869136869907379,
-0.8231444358825684,
-0.3180099427700043,
0.5995674133300781,
-0.39692041277885437,
0.2275991141796112,
0.5461307764053345,
0.46671029925346375,
0.0736350566148758,
0.03280714526772499,
0.41753700375556946,
0.007354025729000568,
-0.11944582313299179,
0.7744138836860657,
1.1708507537841797,
-0.3415409326553345,
0.8498902320861816,
-0.19177581369876862,
-0.2969464063644409,
-0.32671576738357544,
-0.6955136060714722,
-1.2491092681884766,
-0.35518795251846313,
-0.42938345670700073,
-0.2823610305786133,
0.027950404211878777,
0.697939932346344,
0.3927977383136749,
-0.5494299530982971,
-0.04797852784395218,
0.2068723887205124,
0.11192712187767029,
-0.36868414282798767,
-0.1986774206161499,
0.25437071919441223,
-0.22102580964565277,
-0.576930046081543,
0.2391725331544876,
0.27013564109802246,
0.20925629138946533,
-0.38753506541252136,
-0.3524772822856903,
0.2047133892774582,
-0.13682684302330017,
0.5946897268295288,
0.35682418942451477,
-0.8828299045562744,
0.038890667259693146,
-0.10832932591438293,
-0.1275191754102707,
-0.01527406182140112,
0.5167115330696106,
-0.9866683483123779,
0.113189697265625,
0.29300829768180847,
0.6993516683578491,
0.11792871356010437,
0.0958828553557396,
-0.09753292053937912,
-0.5532145500183105,
-0.24826161563396454,
0.3532014787197113,
0.2978796362876892,
0.20343650877475739,
-0.25279948115348816,
0.5259335041046143,
0.18756408989429474,
-0.6315765976905823,
-0.9035592079162598,
0.03811872750520706,
-0.780100405216217,
-0.40225398540496826,
1.3115519285202026,
-0.2612517476081848,
-0.49403560161590576,
-0.2517523765563965,
-0.17573297023773193,
0.13755683600902557,
-0.07684025913476944,
0.6930680871009827,
0.6284546852111816,
-0.2959485948085785,
0.1257476508617401,
-0.8308641910552979,
0.16990549862384796,
0.3028148412704468,
-0.6362146139144897,
0.0016391994431614876,
0.37765684723854065,
0.16203735768795013,
0.6367594599723816,
0.5427330732345581,
-0.09503395110368729,
0.33279237151145935,
-0.244844451546669,
-0.17395733296871185,
-0.39355596899986267,
-0.46396732330322266,
-0.19736653566360474,
0.38502851128578186,
0.3461446762084961,
-0.2610219419002533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16201v1 | Blind Baselines Beat Membership Inference Attacks for Foundation Models | 2024-06-23T19:40:11 | 2024-06-23T19:40:11 | Debeshee Das, Jie Zhang, Florian Tramèr | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Membership inference (MI) attacks try to determine if a data sample was used
to train a machine learning model. For foundation models trained on unknown Web
data, MI attacks can be used to detect copyrighted training materials, measure
test set contamination, or audit machine unlearning. Unfortunately, we find
that evaluations of MI attacks for foundation models are flawed, because they
sample members and non-members from different distributions. For 8 published MI
evaluation datasets, we show that blind attacks -- that distinguish the member
and non-member distributions without looking at any trained model -- outperform
state-of-the-art MI attacks. Existing evaluations thus tell us nothing about
membership leakage of a foundation model's training data. | [
-0.42802199721336365,
-0.4816737174987793,
0.07860760390758514,
-0.08115415275096893,
0.021910421550273895,
0.05533080920577049,
0.5696724057197571,
-0.638405978679657,
0.11420060694217682,
0.6348824501037598,
-0.8910658955574036,
-0.2582104504108429,
-0.6084755063056946,
0.2719307839870453,
-0.6805739998817444,
0.7829073071479797,
0.3021836578845978,
0.3331297039985657,
-0.3892275393009186,
-0.4167710244655609,
-0.2678902745246887,
-0.3876425325870514,
0.08033838123083115,
-0.28540024161338806,
0.251365602016449,
0.4144105613231659,
0.5832920670509338,
0.3359975814819336,
0.6094251275062561,
0.2829907536506653,
0.0518173910677433,
-0.3915639817714691,
-0.6725223660469055,
0.015308295376598835,
0.02139873243868351,
-0.6955218315124512,
-0.05289581045508385,
0.33190685510635376,
0.567889928817749,
1.0687867403030396,
0.26086628437042236,
0.17938081920146942,
0.11067287623882294,
0.9372194409370422,
-1.2526949644088745,
-0.26740607619285583,
-0.7382096648216248,
0.18070371448993683,
-0.11228302866220474,
-0.2680874168872833,
-0.5766969919204712,
-0.15214957296848297,
0.1622927486896515,
-0.3749968707561493,
0.6857494711875916,
-0.2208855003118515,
0.7646140456199646,
0.3718940317630768,
-0.3982532322406769,
-0.21937306225299835,
-0.49119409918785095,
0.7301432490348816,
-0.4933115541934967,
0.7239094376564026,
0.6897977590560913,
0.5399465560913086,
-0.3678186535835266,
-0.5033228397369385,
-0.46769794821739197,
-0.32527315616607666,
0.15178930759429932,
0.15857942402362823,
-0.2454410344362259,
0.10959352552890778,
0.35008636116981506,
0.5630738735198975,
-0.5052474141120911,
0.22055082023143768,
-0.37110239267349243,
0.008340391330420971,
0.5849890112876892,
-0.19471171498298645,
0.13831114768981934,
-0.29985135793685913,
-0.8507815599441528,
-0.24386215209960938,
-0.9659003615379333,
-0.3074413537979126,
0.31068217754364014,
-0.08012031018733978,
-0.30699607729911804,
0.7810511589050293,
-0.47608527541160583,
0.8590303063392639,
-0.09716534614562988,
-0.002243262017145753,
0.19427533447742462,
-0.15711505711078644,
-0.8375711441040039,
-0.14681711792945862,
0.425579696893692,
0.4059016704559326,
0.14023298025131226,
-0.46062690019607544,
-0.34857121109962463,
0.2322978377342224,
-0.0830908790230751,
-0.8296304941177368,
-0.3581475615501404,
0.2485925853252411,
-0.4529762864112854,
-0.30397969484329224,
0.614654541015625,
-0.6699426770210266,
-0.6937054395675659,
0.08353950828313828,
0.620140790939331,
-0.09905719012022018,
0.03131513297557831,
0.02835017256438732,
-0.7801843881607056,
0.15530212223529816,
0.21620474755764008,
-0.4202977418899536,
0.2842371165752411,
0.5712693333625793,
0.7648696303367615,
0.10053646564483643,
-0.2540380358695984,
-0.6384199857711792,
-0.0871918648481369,
-0.24915248155593872,
0.6465891003608704,
-0.328220009803772,
-0.5073338150978088,
-0.3549063205718994,
-0.20668891072273254,
-0.2285514771938324,
-0.6455400586128235,
0.046229492872953415,
-0.596179723739624,
0.08894677460193634,
-0.36117276549339294,
-0.8629693388938904,
-0.03367871418595314,
0.23737592995166779,
-0.751800537109375,
0.49096718430519104,
0.28726711869239807,
-1.1017199754714966,
0.7613043785095215,
-0.6060101985931396,
-0.03526877611875534,
-0.0034560207277536392,
-0.03591577336192131,
-0.34696638584136963,
0.24563713371753693,
0.18805566430091858,
0.46637454628944397,
-0.007082613185048103,
-0.376478910446167,
-0.8533540368080139,
-0.5677881240844727,
0.4267202317714691,
-0.44374504685401917,
1.3089238405227661,
0.0663604885339737,
-0.5839616060256958,
-0.25273704528808594,
-0.7618014216423035,
0.11450868099927902,
0.09149383753538132,
-0.06462244689464569,
-0.4228270947933197,
0.24885158240795135,
-0.34180164337158203,
-0.030669311061501503,
-0.3272513747215271,
-0.4890114367008209,
0.05236399918794632,
-0.5245324969291687,
0.3253355622291565,
0.7704693675041199,
0.4861479699611664,
0.23243291676044464,
-0.4039731025695801,
0.4003066122531891,
-0.20285102725028992,
0.2605573832988739,
-0.08644752949476242,
-0.4384668171405792,
-0.7731813192367554,
-0.5185467004776001,
0.698487401008606,
0.42739006876945496,
-0.6524225473403931,
0.38378238677978516,
-0.1357293576002121,
-0.7189013957977295,
-0.29318270087242126,
0.020348068326711655,
0.38266846537590027,
0.4754363000392914,
0.4138445258140564,
-0.455186665058136,
-0.28350088000297546,
-0.8765074610710144,
-0.37530142068862915,
-0.29384490847587585,
-0.18211844563484192,
0.1403428465127945,
0.936264157295227,
-0.17091596126556396,
1.0066369771957397,
-0.24397987127304077,
-0.2562085688114166,
0.1923111230134964,
0.1737552434206009,
-0.2900099456310272,
0.7234570980072021,
0.663346529006958,
-0.9024025201797485,
-0.17776210606098175,
-0.45711207389831543,
-0.9142835140228271,
0.000929328496567905,
-0.05598508194088936,
0.16316750645637512,
-0.3418688178062439,
0.21872706711292267,
-0.4079934358596802,
0.8396118879318237,
0.5457353591918945,
-0.3972918391227722,
0.3982120454311371,
0.3690606355667114,
0.18562154471874237,
-0.7679910659790039,
0.13119685649871826,
-0.32090380787849426,
-0.198509082198143,
-0.41944655776023865,
0.3861939013004303,
0.18837730586528778,
-0.3106430470943451,
-0.4709029793739319,
0.542843759059906,
-0.7444960474967957,
-0.6755707859992981,
-0.08613762259483337,
-0.11838889867067337,
0.1319604516029358,
0.24724574387073517,
-0.29690051078796387,
0.651653528213501,
0.7558392882347107,
-0.6227807998657227,
-0.03017934039235115,
0.4493463337421417,
-0.5732610821723938,
0.7839500308036804,
-0.47531858086586,
0.2370753437280655,
0.0765681266784668,
0.41710710525512695,
-0.7681151032447815,
-0.47178688645362854,
0.3627374470233917,
-0.9132527709007263,
0.2178499698638916,
-0.32973799109458923,
-0.126386821269989,
-0.09693259745836258,
-0.5818007588386536,
0.104123555123806,
0.1117304116487503,
-0.6897520422935486,
0.21738199889659882,
0.3980940282344818,
0.559766411781311,
-1.3362547159194946,
-1.1629160642623901,
0.12121916562318802,
-0.1201118752360344,
-0.38231390714645386,
0.05996154621243477,
-0.14514531195163727,
-0.4013752043247223,
0.04645758494734764,
-0.5851361155509949,
-0.5120763778686523,
0.8815824389457703,
0.39782077074050903,
0.07258743047714233,
-0.24350176751613617,
-0.37491175532341003,
-0.11714264750480652,
0.05232907459139824,
0.0733754113316536,
-0.07150106132030487,
0.2828606069087982,
0.16331394016742706,
-1.0558550357818604,
-0.8674635887145996,
0.42149174213409424,
0.7248656153678894,
-0.1901359260082245,
0.873543381690979,
-0.23417223989963531,
-0.6978780627250671,
-0.3977177143096924,
-0.5175004005432129,
-0.4010277986526489,
-0.4624934196472168,
0.24179236590862274,
-0.31412339210510254,
-0.7736013531684875,
0.32020965218544006,
0.21152476966381073,
0.3191883862018585,
0.5006163716316223,
0.0659368485212326,
-0.279068261384964,
0.9251428842544556,
0.6843775510787964,
-0.06032682955265045,
0.3498765230178833,
-0.40248680114746094,
-0.18729621171951294,
-0.3894350230693817,
-0.14639058709144592,
-0.9879360198974609,
-0.41954460740089417,
-0.44432955980300903,
-0.141896590590477,
0.12759968638420105,
1.0114015340805054,
-0.0768975242972374,
0.32383525371551514,
-0.24610835313796997,
0.6831628084182739,
0.32313913106918335,
0.154840350151062,
0.2914750277996063,
0.21983309090137482,
-0.06158781796693802,
0.19903473556041718,
-0.7826809287071228,
-0.10585001111030579,
1.0931994915008545,
0.25729984045028687,
0.6576643586158752,
0.015122626908123493,
0.8240318894386292,
0.6389914155006409,
0.8397083878517151,
-0.6336701512336731,
0.24153979122638702,
0.33508896827697754,
-0.8152230978012085,
-0.037160322070121765,
-0.7506317496299744,
-0.7732754945755005,
0.306863009929657,
-0.32114166021347046,
-0.7918174862861633,
1.097773790359497,
0.16270263493061066,
0.18491680920124054,
0.41425079107284546,
-0.7942595481872559,
1.0370250940322876,
-0.18579764664173126,
0.21594780683517456,
0.0136343352496624,
-0.5761333703994751,
0.6422579288482666,
-0.2856479287147522,
0.06026948615908623,
0.06353983283042908,
0.06557765603065491,
0.8473590016365051,
-0.6867532134056091,
0.9164876937866211,
-0.462465763092041,
0.5465995669364929,
0.22791367769241333,
0.21899230778217316,
0.2109917253255844,
0.03615713492035866,
-0.2559393048286438,
0.39069896936416626,
-0.13821786642074585,
-0.6557779312133789,
-0.5517463684082031,
0.3620521128177643,
-0.6383540630340576,
-0.4022301435470581,
-0.4230431020259857,
0.04498180374503136,
-0.5295313596725464,
0.20821331441402435,
0.6079311966896057,
0.185638889670372,
-0.5064691305160522,
0.8490090370178223,
0.3352333903312683,
0.25048401951789856,
0.25125443935394287,
0.6764681339263916,
0.342830628156662,
-0.5232698917388916,
0.5156205296516418,
0.05462902784347534,
0.5070348978042603,
0.31743180751800537,
-0.12461051344871521,
-0.1036415547132492,
-0.7375168204307556,
-0.5292197465896606,
-0.001521385507658124,
-0.8607958555221558,
-0.5591608285903931,
-0.6114022135734558,
-0.08745700865983963,
-0.3317270278930664,
-0.12398440390825272,
-0.2675718367099762,
-0.454245924949646,
-0.07838165014982224,
-0.23596610128879547,
-0.07429162412881851,
0.5737869739532471,
-0.13100311160087585,
0.6057716012001038,
-0.7643206119537354,
0.2765430510044098,
0.1902591437101364,
0.06227743625640869,
-0.014317507855594158,
-0.32242754101753235,
-0.09677060693502426,
0.21089738607406616,
-0.22567330300807953,
-1.5288053750991821,
-0.03975407034158707,
0.3151857256889343,
0.6504047513008118,
0.8647800087928772,
0.2740287780761719,
0.6700351238250732,
-0.1197686567902565,
0.47190725803375244,
0.27800342440605164,
-1.14064621925354,
0.28543010354042053,
0.08334390074014664,
-0.06257379800081253,
0.9708503484725952,
0.40815597772598267,
-0.1972263604402542,
-0.44688868522644043,
-0.8385688662528992,
-0.2997005581855774,
0.6715651154518127,
0.618426501750946,
-0.15924763679504395,
0.1858457773923874,
0.4308106601238251,
-0.10445377975702286,
0.3614523112773895,
-0.8091704249382019,
-0.43839231133461,
-0.30318814516067505,
0.2844419479370117,
0.03417477756738663,
-0.08900444954633713,
-0.20748306810855865,
0.12009842693805695,
0.35130372643470764,
-0.14859411120414734,
0.24918906390666962,
0.27753350138664246,
-0.433280885219574,
-0.4197586476802826,
-0.08074788749217987,
0.22979483008384705,
1.008556842803955,
-0.15300822257995605,
-0.11862379312515259,
0.16613946855068207,
-0.45357465744018555,
0.06273581832647324,
0.16618213057518005,
-0.5001532435417175,
0.10578696429729462,
0.8054649233818054,
0.7158445119857788,
0.3458576798439026,
-0.7178894877433777,
0.9055943489074707,
-0.022675830870866776,
-0.3120957016944885,
-0.1667603701353073,
0.49078771471977234,
0.003482314059510827,
0.02307606302201748,
0.4609760642051697,
0.5447739958763123,
0.11820410192012787,
-0.5148631930351257,
0.7205149531364441,
0.8191269040107727,
-0.6912301778793335,
-0.11333221942186356,
0.6561702489852905,
-0.08309698849916458,
-0.26776376366615295,
0.6575003266334534,
0.4574323892593384,
-0.6670005321502686,
0.868083655834198,
0.29145413637161255,
0.725350022315979,
-0.5997094511985779,
0.06862066686153412,
0.022734107449650764,
0.6548619866371155,
0.19060654938220978,
-0.0845290943980217,
-0.5217301845550537,
-0.7056949138641357,
-0.03859305754303932,
-0.5831721425056458,
-0.5149906277656555,
0.295923113822937,
-0.9619830250740051,
0.16625258326530457,
-0.5985801815986633,
0.1576036959886551,
0.05695263296365738,
-0.02259504422545433,
-0.5413644313812256,
0.7283884882926941,
-0.18485483527183533,
1.1873489618301392,
-0.8956423997879028,
0.6218520998954773,
0.10349919646978378,
-0.2279312014579773,
-0.3404809534549713,
0.14374588429927826,
0.11155270040035248,
-0.5683618187904358,
0.3696187734603882,
0.4696738123893738,
0.08593828976154327,
-0.1481846421957016,
-0.5419154763221741,
-0.6011085510253906,
0.7680228352546692,
0.630120575428009,
-0.3965661823749542,
0.35347244143486023,
0.21010416746139526,
0.20744960010051727,
-0.15667980909347534,
0.0711500495672226,
0.23203961551189423,
0.39153072237968445,
-0.18273264169692993,
-0.5119672417640686,
-0.4445924758911133,
-0.10061915963888168,
-0.7882876992225647,
0.005324097815901041,
-0.29472386837005615,
0.9633471965789795,
-0.17897768318653107,
-0.5003001689910889,
0.08614691346883774,
0.9002595543861389,
0.30687469244003296,
0.5345221161842346,
0.8682516813278198,
0.6137921214103699,
0.9419456720352173,
-0.009793117642402649,
1.2268465757369995,
-0.0415482334792614,
0.38350367546081543,
1.0615781545639038,
-0.5312512516975403,
0.8854806423187256,
0.1774328351020813,
0.062155213207006454,
0.11216864734888077,
0.8319860100746155,
-0.3756316900253296,
0.4451324939727783,
-0.0238028634339571,
-0.11376703530550003,
-0.15414613485336304,
0.367046594619751,
-0.6412400603294373,
0.5034652948379517,
0.16487495601177216,
-0.22671495378017426,
-0.3532542288303375,
-0.07183043658733368,
-0.13752874732017517,
-0.3205327093601227,
-0.08141638338565826,
0.7633385062217712,
0.14381113648414612,
-0.3780330717563629,
0.7881343364715576,
0.3409383296966553,
0.23465904593467712,
-0.6960986852645874,
-0.1099611297249794,
-0.33547404408454895,
0.13227011263370514,
-0.33108624815940857,
-0.23172582685947418,
0.21272586286067963,
0.3818773031234741,
-0.007963464595377445,
0.15474312007427216,
0.6656473278999329,
0.3238232135772705,
-0.30057427287101746,
0.48522046208381653,
0.6819060444831848,
0.2316519320011139,
-0.2868804335594177,
-1.060739517211914,
-0.32239818572998047,
0.05290712043642998,
-0.5256204605102539,
0.5456705093383789,
-0.11623246967792511,
-0.210191547870636,
0.7872490286827087,
0.7949993014335632,
-0.1655551642179489,
0.01517490204423666,
-0.24091191589832306,
0.8714094758033752,
-0.35811543464660645,
-0.5980140566825867,
-0.7553871273994446,
0.22397014498710632,
-0.2544236183166504,
-0.49950870871543884,
0.9117909073829651,
0.8462545275688171,
1.1245232820510864,
0.0890798270702362,
0.5062919855117798,
-0.02084164135158062,
0.419302761554718,
-0.6091501712799072,
1.1678311824798584,
-0.7500989437103271,
0.1655871421098709,
-0.2625972032546997,
-1.0618846416473389,
-0.3341020345687866,
0.5044212341308594,
0.028710871934890747,
0.18874089419841766,
0.5650840401649475,
0.7014161348342896,
-0.31667640805244446,
0.3498363494873047,
0.21396426856517792,
0.16538937389850616,
0.15161052346229553,
0.13000068068504333,
0.9180238842964172,
-0.5296777486801147,
0.17661887407302856,
-0.4521728754043579,
-0.37425893545150757,
-0.16077953577041626,
-0.7810304760932922,
-1.1916892528533936,
-0.12580305337905884,
-0.0464056134223938,
-0.5206843614578247,
0.15165647864341736,
0.2812438905239105,
0.9591664671897888,
-1.1908379793167114,
-0.12458737194538116,
-0.1009274497628212,
0.2820369601249695,
-0.29032137989997864,
-0.21591925621032715,
0.48872795701026917,
0.21532124280929565,
-0.4187444746494293,
1.088777780532837,
-0.1350313127040863,
0.03594759479165077,
-0.34759554266929626,
-0.027093395590782166,
-0.16697105765342712,
0.08196122199296951,
-0.10470964014530182,
0.427248477935791,
-0.47388359904289246,
-0.22497764229774475,
-0.1721261590719223,
-0.08990032970905304,
0.09356429427862167,
0.8711633682250977,
-0.8248209357261658,
0.25777292251586914,
0.6176196336746216,
0.8936892747879028,
0.3206634223461151,
0.19832657277584076,
0.2843950688838959,
-0.8128913640975952,
0.33032307028770447,
0.3995009958744049,
0.5055501461029053,
0.4146151840686798,
-0.46685323119163513,
0.5388004183769226,
0.6885078549385071,
-0.07424614578485489,
-1.3814187049865723,
0.04591003805398941,
-0.7240539789199829,
-0.6095945239067078,
0.2711183726787567,
-0.4719991385936737,
-0.4190470278263092,
-0.1301005482673645,
0.5516730546951294,
0.06913856416940689,
0.22336992621421814,
0.6638641357421875,
0.4559612572193146,
0.1189698651432991,
0.20493853092193604,
-0.6406514644622803,
0.42812857031822205,
0.49317818880081177,
-0.9159349203109741,
0.04612726718187332,
0.7168957591056824,
0.552341878414154,
-0.11078159511089325,
0.36502036452293396,
-0.03821845352649689,
0.5918418169021606,
0.20494435727596283,
-0.290903776884079,
-0.26856204867362976,
-0.6160948872566223,
-0.4277151823043823,
0.5574126839637756,
-0.37819164991378784,
-0.2813076972961426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16176v1 | GraphEval2000: Benchmarking and Improving Large Language Models on Graph Datasets | 2024-06-23T18:01:56 | 2024-06-23T18:01:56 | Qiming Wu, Zichen Chen, Will Corcoran, Misha Sra, Ambuj K. Singh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.2.8, I.2.6, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success in natural
language processing (NLP), demonstrating significant capabilities in processing
and understanding text data. However, recent studies have identified
limitations in LLMs' ability to reason about graph-structured data. To address
this gap, we introduce GraphEval2000, the first comprehensive graph dataset,
comprising 40 graph data structure problems along with 2000 test cases.
Additionally, we introduce an evaluation framework based on GraphEval2000,
designed to assess the graph reasoning abilities of LLMs through coding
challenges. Our dataset categorizes test cases into four primary and four
sub-categories, ensuring a comprehensive evaluation. We evaluate eight popular
LLMs on GraphEval2000, revealing that LLMs exhibit a better understanding of
directed graphs compared to undirected ones. While private LLMs consistently
outperform open-source models, the performance gap is narrowing. Furthermore,
to improve the usability of our evaluation framework, we propose Structured
Symbolic Decomposition (SSD), an instruction-based method designed to enhance
LLM performance on GraphEval2000. Results show that SSD improves the
performance of GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and GPT-4o on complex graph problems, with an
increase of 11.11\%, 33.37\%, and 33.37\%, respectively. | [
-0.10409191995859146,
-0.9363002181053162,
0.46429693698883057,
0.2507956624031067,
-0.027472659945487976,
0.5666103959083557,
-0.23161834478378296,
-0.3717191517353058,
-0.2215522825717926,
0.4717327654361725,
-0.4388461410999298,
-1.0588661432266235,
-0.6269683837890625,
0.19881398975849152,
-0.3588577210903168,
0.6984343528747559,
-0.25711920857429504,
0.13218407332897186,
-0.4346049129962921,
-0.16085284948349,
-0.36463892459869385,
-0.689517617225647,
-0.8070687651634216,
-0.18831980228424072,
0.3546019494533539,
0.043741948902606964,
0.5678459405899048,
0.7804463505744934,
0.6570290327072144,
0.3728022873401642,
-0.19444720447063446,
0.3027859032154083,
-0.747378945350647,
0.1823653280735016,
0.06104811280965805,
0.0029222029261291027,
-0.6216704249382019,
-0.21298570930957794,
0.7933288216590881,
1.0874602794647217,
-0.09500417858362198,
0.21317555010318756,
0.047202080488204956,
0.7931320071220398,
-0.4235895872116089,
0.6857999563217163,
-0.4103478789329529,
-0.06721653044223785,
-0.2045208066701889,
0.0235952939838171,
-0.6043147444725037,
-0.5504706501960754,
-0.293354332447052,
-0.5258995294570923,
0.05339334160089493,
0.3052016794681549,
0.7157127261161804,
0.22016286849975586,
-0.456704318523407,
-0.14406637847423553,
-0.5869577527046204,
0.3978494703769684,
-0.6799332499504089,
0.6613420248031616,
0.059412870556116104,
0.3009381592273712,
-0.49099111557006836,
-1.0888980627059937,
-0.3195572793483734,
-0.05289313942193985,
0.1996629387140274,
-0.09113521873950958,
-0.37330278754234314,
0.24244704842567444,
0.5079873204231262,
0.1988210678100586,
-0.8704094886779785,
0.22765080630779266,
-0.3675091564655304,
-0.2613161504268646,
0.6600714325904846,
0.26739734411239624,
0.3729083836078644,
-0.17503327131271362,
-0.016432933509349823,
-0.24259215593338013,
-0.9380465745925903,
-0.23928676545619965,
0.38359105587005615,
0.5043043494224548,
0.14142148196697235,
0.5786656737327576,
-0.290511816740036,
0.6991901397705078,
-0.5040220618247986,
0.12605848908424377,
0.531291127204895,
-0.3484369218349457,
-0.26003915071487427,
0.002447622362524271,
0.6035405993461609,
0.41312697529792786,
0.5150188207626343,
-0.23850765824317932,
-0.21148338913917542,
0.18597416579723358,
-0.07833987474441528,
-1.0484466552734375,
-0.4221450388431549,
0.19441314041614532,
-0.36930951476097107,
-0.15006861090660095,
-0.29871559143066406,
-0.44820573925971985,
-0.36896249651908875,
-0.2472587525844574,
-0.13588623702526093,
-0.4166833460330963,
-0.09861580282449722,
0.11681640148162842,
-0.15365161001682281,
0.032534994184970856,
0.37003082036972046,
-0.5496203899383545,
0.6864184737205505,
0.9909954071044922,
0.8911238312721252,
-0.32162749767303467,
-0.1700536459684372,
-0.7577834725379944,
0.009985207580029964,
-0.5178470611572266,
0.9187306761741638,
-0.5672495365142822,
-0.24596905708312988,
-0.08460157364606857,
0.10731548815965652,
-0.24235562980175018,
-0.6743999123573303,
0.6367183327674866,
-0.6229296922683716,
-0.05290640890598297,
-0.2337028831243515,
-0.8494274616241455,
-0.02986733615398407,
0.4357900619506836,
-0.6937049627304077,
1.2826982736587524,
0.33460620045661926,
-0.7138417959213257,
0.1012478768825531,
-0.5912435054779053,
-0.5455322265625,
0.4256397485733032,
-0.23498685657978058,
-0.2041100710630417,
-0.20582152903079987,
0.30069610476493835,
0.20129279792308807,
-0.19694937765598297,
0.2561364471912384,
-0.44163814187049866,
-0.528144359588623,
-0.346337229013443,
-0.22595076262950897,
0.8219454884529114,
0.04383882135152817,
-0.07624771445989609,
0.2979365289211273,
-0.7777486443519592,
0.3680216372013092,
0.3320050835609436,
-0.3209196925163269,
-0.14100603759288788,
0.27749842405319214,
-0.04678095504641533,
0.006862010806798935,
0.016405608505010605,
-0.5771980881690979,
0.1787528544664383,
-0.6025325655937195,
0.6559343338012695,
1.067290186882019,
-0.09884943813085556,
0.00640821922570467,
0.1376941055059433,
0.5486097931861877,
-0.26309698820114136,
-0.02861764095723629,
-0.04490119591355324,
-0.43603798747062683,
-0.3546501696109772,
-0.06869348883628845,
0.3731139898300171,
0.6414532661437988,
-0.48791468143463135,
0.274109423160553,
-0.48795321583747864,
-0.3725089132785797,
-0.25810420513153076,
0.2647905945777893,
0.5105751752853394,
0.78206866979599,
0.3563982844352722,
-0.09981778264045715,
-0.5441152453422546,
-0.710644543170929,
-0.21634231507778168,
-0.25209540128707886,
-0.06115751713514328,
0.4654361605644226,
0.34984883666038513,
-0.19584573805332184,
0.5319117903709412,
-0.760283887386322,
-0.07761074602603912,
-0.3044731914997101,
-0.18718282878398895,
0.08524814993143082,
0.11144984513521194,
0.2801639437675476,
-0.3923277258872986,
-0.42124268412590027,
-0.059217847883701324,
-0.8132041096687317,
-0.1993837207555771,
0.5243135690689087,
-0.044472597539424896,
0.27354779839515686,
0.7307634949684143,
-0.5344510078430176,
0.2568063735961914,
0.6082324385643005,
-0.33222725987434387,
0.6053195595741272,
-0.1823708862066269,
-0.12259584665298462,
-0.7925673127174377,
-0.08411137759685516,
-0.048800189048051834,
-0.3744807839393616,
-0.3289458453655243,
0.09942533820867538,
0.010079445317387581,
-0.34102103114128113,
-0.2308858036994934,
0.5813157558441162,
-0.4652852416038513,
-0.4445955753326416,
0.03003782406449318,
0.5867823362350464,
0.08318474888801575,
0.29553645849227905,
-0.2484823614358902,
0.7949720025062561,
0.5276293158531189,
-0.22380997240543365,
0.5159533023834229,
0.40903735160827637,
-0.5270971059799194,
0.26664867997169495,
-0.910627007484436,
0.3847846984863281,
-0.17122770845890045,
0.4077839255332947,
-1.2644480466842651,
-0.16447962820529938,
-0.042370956391096115,
-0.1859121471643448,
0.23906752467155457,
-0.18881219625473022,
-0.7655010223388672,
-0.5503385663032532,
-0.12912186980247498,
0.13360607624053955,
0.45100608468055725,
-0.5803480744361877,
0.31413978338241577,
0.39567866921424866,
-0.3706878125667572,
-0.3046879172325134,
-0.2550453245639801,
0.4106484055519104,
0.023298878222703934,
-0.9734740853309631,
0.3250049948692322,
-0.15911707282066345,
-0.34795501828193665,
0.11162348091602325,
-0.1788320243358612,
0.1940578818321228,
0.1265387237071991,
0.21322058141231537,
0.3358595371246338,
-0.2817968428134918,
0.16609105467796326,
-0.09428466111421585,
-0.30461713671684265,
0.15439634025096893,
-0.15477219223976135,
0.7313108444213867,
-0.39466947317123413,
-0.42330968379974365,
-0.1877681463956833,
0.13587525486946106,
0.07770498096942902,
-0.21148109436035156,
0.4080375134944916,
0.21805605292320251,
-0.36702123284339905,
-0.2818419933319092,
-0.2558154761791229,
0.15532469749450684,
-0.48238348960876465,
0.6898630261421204,
-0.34017255902290344,
-0.9319842457771301,
0.4228346347808838,
-0.5144038200378418,
0.06974773854017258,
0.3545064926147461,
0.4388843774795532,
-0.013635660521686077,
1.5384907722473145,
0.21373701095581055,
-0.18084964156150818,
0.13615697622299194,
-0.2937621474266052,
0.263225257396698,
-0.8297392725944519,
-0.2568623125553131,
-0.606196939945221,
-0.266085684299469,
-0.5772336721420288,
-0.3786112666130066,
0.17896287143230438,
0.050214070826768875,
-0.5071977376937866,
0.2414335459470749,
-0.6468979120254517,
0.7665770053863525,
0.055862803012132645,
-0.07759841531515121,
0.4326043426990509,
0.002183477859944105,
-0.0836697444319725,
0.0871497392654419,
-0.5653582811355591,
-0.6418778300285339,
1.043276309967041,
0.22611013054847717,
0.600728452205658,
-0.07104439288377762,
0.6017081141471863,
0.29915282130241394,
0.4209041893482208,
-0.5391769409179688,
0.8227781057357788,
-0.36824536323547363,
-0.21303482353687286,
-0.15361197292804718,
-0.6958431601524353,
-0.9932073950767517,
0.16114561259746552,
0.29085516929626465,
-0.7934386134147644,
-0.2752176523208618,
0.027925116941332817,
0.20101924240589142,
0.12885767221450806,
-0.8807265162467957,
1.055588722229004,
-0.2829844653606415,
-0.06425447762012482,
-0.03840642422437668,
-0.47254353761672974,
0.24685494601726532,
0.18843916058540344,
0.3334401249885559,
-0.3605743646621704,
0.2079809010028839,
0.7665964365005493,
-0.676635205745697,
0.5346330404281616,
-0.39041265845298767,
0.12191633880138397,
0.017403725534677505,
0.07175491005182266,
0.820296585559845,
-0.1568165123462677,
-0.29655224084854126,
0.21931180357933044,
0.1469605267047882,
-0.3793054223060608,
-0.6805850267410278,
0.8288556337356567,
-0.6896523237228394,
-0.5001953840255737,
-0.22177574038505554,
-0.5051943063735962,
-0.3298051357269287,
0.4105047881603241,
-0.05103617534041405,
0.6527692079544067,
-0.35036391019821167,
0.2740141451358795,
0.4282594621181488,
-0.09696513414382935,
0.2588234841823578,
0.1642981767654419,
-0.46010467410087585,
-0.3827751874923706,
0.6595584154129028,
0.2239171713590622,
0.2070360779762268,
0.012729560025036335,
0.1851627081632614,
-0.3889859616756439,
-0.8467925786972046,
-0.47172844409942627,
0.11812980473041534,
-1.0276259183883667,
-0.19819633662700653,
-0.5380293130874634,
-0.3576420545578003,
-0.4374115765094757,
-0.013745269738137722,
-0.2620460093021393,
-0.5035173892974854,
0.09910155087709427,
-0.4076354503631592,
0.23140087723731995,
0.7566555738449097,
0.402713805437088,
-0.013794513419270515,
-0.44459834694862366,
0.23236055672168732,
-0.11641691625118256,
0.4580720067024231,
-0.07974407821893692,
-0.24035516381263733,
0.07272983342409134,
-0.08922538161277771,
-0.13051356375217438,
-0.6206946969032288,
0.2808383107185364,
0.1827058047056198,
0.49516916275024414,
0.12130450457334518,
-0.03508268669247627,
0.8745574355125427,
-0.6955227851867676,
0.5280876159667969,
-0.17554111778736115,
-0.8735533952713013,
0.4244663119316101,
-0.1965784728527069,
0.1260933130979538,
0.5607812404632568,
0.25873255729675293,
-0.4713873565196991,
-0.27850010991096497,
-0.5042029619216919,
-0.9031455516815186,
0.5347939729690552,
0.24270805716514587,
0.027946386486291885,
-0.21183069050312042,
0.4267759919166565,
-0.2878328859806061,
0.055062297731637955,
-0.43050214648246765,
-0.19020700454711914,
-0.11059721559286118,
-0.2747116982936859,
-0.12653806805610657,
0.014378308318555355,
-0.18843890726566315,
-0.44302308559417725,
0.49494633078575134,
-0.3184402883052826,
0.10250032693147659,
-0.10282490402460098,
-0.19878332316875458,
0.08587100356817245,
-0.005019310861825943,
0.24707897007465363,
0.8857199549674988,
-0.22303523123264313,
0.3433118760585785,
0.2580929696559906,
-0.39209187030792236,
-0.02377847023308277,
0.32099154591560364,
-0.1067550852894783,
-0.14763130247592926,
0.6177502870559692,
0.7602388858795166,
0.15556256473064423,
-0.8397282958030701,
0.4751071333885193,
-0.06678758561611176,
-0.15344873070716858,
-0.05419164150953293,
0.14286474883556366,
0.5267873406410217,
0.0925789326429367,
0.11346353590488434,
-0.2595546841621399,
0.034453075379133224,
-0.43878787755966187,
0.10093630105257034,
0.4776262938976288,
-0.20382468402385712,
-0.21347206830978394,
0.6455680131912231,
-0.006310157477855682,
-0.5350430011749268,
1.1503283977508545,
-0.3268510103225708,
-0.5854899883270264,
0.7191832661628723,
0.8222776055335999,
0.672069787979126,
-0.032517626881599426,
0.11958543211221695,
0.42536377906799316,
0.21721141040325165,
0.18359357118606567,
0.4799042344093323,
0.13864831626415253,
-0.6994352340698242,
-0.6188919544219971,
-0.6093965172767639,
-0.4754038453102112,
-0.09591543674468994,
-0.39885324239730835,
0.15435539186000824,
-0.6302640438079834,
0.011983353644609451,
0.1706387847661972,
0.31198567152023315,
-0.5665919780731201,
-0.042146820574998856,
-0.14559808373451233,
1.1198019981384277,
-0.6575430631637573,
0.6906608939170837,
0.456245094537735,
-0.06932207196950912,
-0.937130868434906,
-0.3669557571411133,
0.010744656436145306,
-1.0201218128204346,
0.8318437337875366,
0.21888864040374756,
-0.16505330801010132,
0.2748204469680786,
-0.5865792036056519,
-0.6205057501792908,
1.0560840368270874,
0.5890488624572754,
-0.5460621118545532,
-0.09453916549682617,
0.24011927843093872,
0.629145085811615,
-0.308381050825119,
0.13931095600128174,
0.6353228092193604,
0.5830391645431519,
0.3789438307285309,
-0.5816048383712769,
0.17339694499969482,
-0.4576043486595154,
0.11440172791481018,
0.3587787449359894,
-0.5035985708236694,
0.6327980756759644,
-0.23871776461601257,
-0.403874009847641,
-0.1994846761226654,
0.3665235936641693,
0.5140461325645447,
0.36124804615974426,
0.3510783612728119,
0.5882242321968079,
1.138031005859375,
-0.3202970027923584,
1.2452760934829712,
-0.4127703905105591,
0.3093410134315491,
1.1754244565963745,
-0.8051272630691528,
0.933462917804718,
0.028478316962718964,
-0.5064232349395752,
0.7337749004364014,
0.7826669812202454,
-0.02723800204694271,
0.20315267145633698,
0.41491934657096863,
-0.051316071301698685,
-0.2638365626335144,
-0.007615256123244762,
-0.37284064292907715,
0.29573020339012146,
0.1865425556898117,
-0.07515469193458557,
-0.5001735687255859,
-0.26334160566329956,
0.18805702030658722,
0.09361454844474792,
-0.0898800641298294,
0.6452674865722656,
-0.011741001158952713,
-0.3055330216884613,
0.5716918110847473,
0.14687016606330872,
-0.04077688604593277,
-0.6101453304290771,
-0.09120241552591324,
-0.36776459217071533,
0.2506946921348572,
-0.3480297029018402,
-0.8074005842208862,
0.37605178356170654,
0.010240648873150349,
0.09288224577903748,
-0.3189224302768707,
0.8546037673950195,
-0.09670449048280716,
-0.6197505593299866,
0.4554891586303711,
0.25522246956825256,
0.25431880354881287,
-0.16554997861385345,
-0.7375953197479248,
0.46454840898513794,
-0.18652823567390442,
-0.3138681948184967,
0.36689624190330505,
0.2781791388988495,
-0.34280550479888916,
0.7735778093338013,
0.7947399020195007,
0.18539033830165863,
-0.021062975749373436,
0.5003563165664673,
1.1603717803955078,
-0.5410874485969543,
-0.29883819818496704,
-0.8730080127716064,
0.029803382232785225,
-0.36567455530166626,
-0.04501382261514664,
1.0060629844665527,
1.032000184059143,
0.7006948590278625,
0.4064274728298187,
0.5722579956054688,
0.14250868558883667,
0.3893534243106842,
-0.4718550443649292,
0.4398985505104065,
-0.24200443923473358,
0.32608848810195923,
-0.44444704055786133,
-0.9994313716888428,
-0.42982038855552673,
0.47897395491600037,
-0.4345567226409912,
0.16648899018764496,
0.6897185444831848,
0.7759830355644226,
0.18657827377319336,
0.1117611899971962,
0.019642820581793785,
0.29273533821105957,
0.6334183216094971,
0.5891095995903015,
0.6797599792480469,
-0.38500675559043884,
0.6518712639808655,
0.08339549601078033,
-0.14454464614391327,
0.13442178070545197,
-0.9611361026763916,
-0.7958969473838806,
-0.31961870193481445,
-0.4238738417625427,
-0.504289448261261,
0.17368009686470032,
0.600858747959137,
0.6979315876960754,
-0.6536552906036377,
-0.21942898631095886,
-0.3758937120437622,
0.4159221649169922,
-0.20209138095378876,
-0.24908356368541718,
0.723500669002533,
-0.2962392568588257,
-0.6262218952178955,
0.7393199801445007,
0.5590699911117554,
-0.2905152142047882,
-0.24862036108970642,
-0.27381181716918945,
0.04019276052713394,
-0.05398636311292648,
0.8546894788742065,
0.14036180078983307,
-0.32108721137046814,
-0.45019736886024475,
0.09149132668972015,
0.04569661244750023,
0.30128559470176697,
0.6362354755401611,
-0.6634422540664673,
0.40342390537261963,
0.6735724210739136,
0.5082983374595642,
0.7965199947357178,
0.27654045820236206,
0.26907479763031006,
-0.735730767250061,
-0.07455373555421829,
0.19268950819969177,
0.3740711212158203,
0.45007243752479553,
-0.1317773461341858,
0.6669080257415771,
0.3563025891780853,
-0.6300583481788635,
-1.130287528038025,
0.17529599368572235,
-0.7995768189430237,
-0.3205927610397339,
1.0621823072433472,
-0.14788949489593506,
-0.2131238877773285,
-0.16999918222427368,
-0.04663604125380516,
0.09289205819368362,
0.0011949350591748953,
0.4688052535057068,
0.7205851078033447,
-0.4216788411140442,
-0.06698326021432877,
-0.5609076023101807,
0.2806340157985687,
0.003237395314499736,
-1.217254638671875,
0.45332804322242737,
0.7184669971466064,
0.3838045597076416,
-0.19070181250572205,
0.8132991194725037,
-0.2889106869697571,
-0.09511639922857285,
0.1276164948940277,
-0.1803252398967743,
-0.43998441100120544,
-0.32446321845054626,
-0.07518551498651505,
0.36800235509872437,
0.07740340381860733,
0.21427270770072937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16167v1 | FS-RAG: A Frame Semantics Based Approach for Improved Factual Accuracy in Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T17:18:19 | 2024-06-23T17:18:19 | Harish Tayyar Madabushi | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a novel extension to Retrieval Augmented Generation with the goal
of mitigating factual inaccuracies in the output of large language models.
Specifically, our method draws on the cognitive linguistic theory of frame
semantics for the indexing and retrieval of factual information relevant to
helping large language models answer queries. We conduct experiments to
demonstrate the effectiveness of this method both in terms of retrieval
effectiveness and in terms of the relevance of the frames and frame relations
automatically generated. Our results show that this novel mechanism of Frame
Semantic-based retrieval, designed to improve Retrieval Augmented Generation
(FS-RAG), is effective and offers potential for providing data-driven insights
into frame semantics theory. We provide open access to our program code and
prompts. | [
-0.3440159857273102,
-1.005531668663025,
0.7782665491104126,
-0.1541999876499176,
-0.05228666961193085,
0.1718273162841797,
-0.31247207522392273,
-0.3883504867553711,
0.4821094870567322,
0.5954360365867615,
-0.37230706214904785,
-0.21512463688850403,
-0.5598469972610474,
-0.03618057444691658,
-0.6758397221565247,
1.0000520944595337,
0.08032491058111191,
-0.08249752223491669,
-0.22716635465621948,
-0.12403472512960434,
-0.24172747135162354,
-0.48554015159606934,
-0.4506189823150635,
-0.02642774023115635,
0.4944864809513092,
0.24589724838733673,
0.852020263671875,
0.623184859752655,
0.735893726348877,
0.28154879808425903,
-0.19456498324871063,
0.3190692365169525,
-0.5593462586402893,
0.3433438837528229,
-0.6769548654556274,
-0.5800458192825317,
-0.42881906032562256,
-0.22812782227993011,
1.078569769859314,
0.5571264624595642,
-0.16142413020133972,
0.3563690185546875,
-0.32309967279434204,
0.8107300996780396,
-1.0863444805145264,
0.1926611214876175,
-0.8192320466041565,
-0.17973798513412476,
-0.5870214104652405,
-0.4740689992904663,
-0.8169043660163879,
-0.2394515424966812,
-0.16209089756011963,
-0.7071883678436279,
0.6357144117355347,
0.31096726655960083,
0.9361739158630371,
0.37159836292266846,
-0.4516674280166626,
-0.3732280731201172,
-0.7443509697914124,
0.5660163760185242,
-0.565308690071106,
0.5404502749443054,
0.28507065773010254,
0.3312892019748688,
-0.2830720841884613,
-0.5815938115119934,
-0.7169762849807739,
-0.3630346655845642,
-0.4125290513038635,
-0.11305804550647736,
0.05105934664607048,
0.16358807682991028,
0.635727047920227,
0.5957317352294922,
-0.3766757845878601,
-0.4348921477794647,
-0.23969468474388123,
-0.26036861538887024,
0.7397025227546692,
0.22279717028141022,
0.3337303698062897,
-0.3624306619167328,
-0.39717042446136475,
0.10275106132030487,
-0.7846173644065857,
-0.1706714630126953,
0.08946750313043594,
0.4719490706920624,
0.18810229003429413,
1.003098964691162,
-0.5196380019187927,
0.7055383920669556,
0.10733132064342499,
-0.204768106341362,
0.3544674515724182,
-0.31419092416763306,
0.1369205117225647,
-0.03744092583656311,
0.2476751059293747,
0.2421015501022339,
-0.16417837142944336,
-0.21864593029022217,
-0.5115088820457458,
0.3736550807952881,
0.32848843932151794,
-0.7217943668365479,
0.047290775924921036,
-0.09397944062948227,
-0.24842092394828796,
-0.33878597617149353,
0.2809511721134186,
-0.8136598467826843,
-0.23213225603103638,
-0.44590023159980774,
0.5207508206367493,
-0.45529428124427795,
-0.572347104549408,
-0.0748046338558197,
-0.3901340365409851,
0.2639259696006775,
0.14302851259708405,
-0.7367563843727112,
0.41430047154426575,
0.9054747819900513,
0.4823911190032959,
-0.2199522703886032,
0.08675075322389603,
-1.0767271518707275,
0.3765731155872345,
-0.6289235353469849,
0.7515498995780945,
-0.812635064125061,
-0.32702818512916565,
-0.10370992124080658,
-0.13011561334133148,
0.11127544939517975,
-0.2726725935935974,
0.7171974182128906,
-0.8644038438796997,
0.04992259666323662,
-0.352388858795166,
-0.7579598426818848,
-0.2337881326675415,
0.1329059898853302,
-0.6232997179031372,
1.1077419519424438,
0.06028745323419571,
-0.8227709531784058,
0.1707611083984375,
-0.7384263277053833,
-0.3761756718158722,
0.02399386093020439,
-0.21989886462688446,
0.030177175998687744,
0.5194389224052429,
-0.044249527156353,
0.2842230200767517,
-0.47899141907691956,
0.6780427694320679,
-0.3052298128604889,
-0.26322492957115173,
0.292817622423172,
-0.39926469326019287,
0.3938799798488617,
0.4668799936771393,
-0.21739766001701355,
-0.14277687668800354,
-0.766964316368103,
0.12164582312107086,
0.16275008022785187,
-0.22154630720615387,
-0.556681215763092,
0.028369951993227005,
-0.12384716421365738,
-0.10315743833780289,
0.24634599685668945,
-0.7364825010299683,
-0.07856651395559311,
-0.6620426177978516,
-0.1675766408443451,
0.3522900938987732,
-0.1219111979007721,
0.5518619418144226,
-0.31919246912002563,
0.31778231263160706,
-0.27852386236190796,
-0.2932994067668915,
-0.5277902483940125,
-0.31212642788887024,
-0.6705160737037659,
-0.448720782995224,
0.5190885663032532,
0.5272355675697327,
-1.1451740264892578,
0.15159456431865692,
-0.3893854022026062,
-0.3063206374645233,
-0.09937160462141037,
-0.24115996062755585,
0.7980222105979919,
0.71401047706604,
0.27381810545921326,
-0.33467429876327515,
-0.6067618131637573,
-0.7078415751457214,
-0.4213939905166626,
-0.07929128408432007,
0.09394686669111252,
0.18980582058429718,
0.37688878178596497,
-0.19843356311321259,
1.1864557266235352,
-0.8158023357391357,
0.10931764543056488,
0.11212781816720963,
0.18879421055316925,
-0.022852052003145218,
0.3662966191768646,
0.6533271670341492,
-1.0796566009521484,
-0.14579781889915466,
-0.17725083231925964,
-0.5829000473022461,
-0.08692455291748047,
0.40456435084342957,
-0.1907837986946106,
0.8053948283195496,
0.3686467707157135,
-0.7511866688728333,
0.6614288091659546,
0.34042271971702576,
-0.5142865180969238,
0.5867682099342346,
-0.20344720780849457,
0.3924861550331116,
-0.9367797374725342,
0.31828799843788147,
-0.2253246307373047,
-0.3724498450756073,
-0.5009387731552124,
0.5316498875617981,
0.06296535581350327,
-0.10387661308050156,
-0.15621605515480042,
0.7001055479049683,
-0.25612324476242065,
-0.47259706258773804,
-0.507551372051239,
0.42159923911094666,
0.15094316005706787,
0.30338120460510254,
-0.0561639629304409,
0.8168735504150391,
0.14035964012145996,
-0.5089491605758667,
0.37141379714012146,
0.30673161149024963,
-0.21643799543380737,
0.6185279488563538,
-0.21805529296398163,
-0.10114194452762604,
-0.4691111147403717,
0.4801831543445587,
-1.0421726703643799,
-0.40845808386802673,
-0.013045868836343288,
-0.6900075078010559,
0.7746665477752686,
-0.0837317556142807,
-0.28273531794548035,
-0.1679905503988266,
-0.14944042265415192,
0.27651476860046387,
0.29323244094848633,
-0.5969248414039612,
0.6724680662155151,
0.7300089597702026,
-0.22812870144844055,
-0.8822760581970215,
-0.5195279121398926,
0.003419064451009035,
0.015573263168334961,
-0.7218529582023621,
0.4887077808380127,
0.03438878804445267,
-0.4893825054168701,
0.3910124599933624,
-0.2986084818840027,
-0.16089369356632233,
0.059520404785871506,
-0.2166110724210739,
0.47973504662513733,
-0.6114510893821716,
0.3820161819458008,
-0.03636465594172478,
-0.35262537002563477,
-0.06012781336903572,
0.01330055482685566,
0.35921770334243774,
-0.2631363868713379,
-0.2255459725856781,
0.021468844264745712,
0.397245854139328,
0.322824627161026,
-0.5722036957740784,
0.559589147567749,
0.46690669655799866,
-0.38430631160736084,
-0.13007347285747528,
-0.7539069652557373,
-0.11725421994924545,
-0.42182376980781555,
0.31078851222991943,
-0.5080786347389221,
-1.0833775997161865,
0.31725165247917175,
-0.14670781791210175,
-0.12041941285133362,
0.7549794316291809,
0.3934440016746521,
0.00949922390282154,
0.9499383568763733,
0.5525767207145691,
0.34531131386756897,
0.3967439532279968,
-0.15609557926654816,
0.09388916939496994,
-0.9373577833175659,
0.1139359250664711,
-0.7439029812812805,
0.06456451863050461,
-0.5887638330459595,
-0.775702714920044,
0.21332336962223053,
0.02951982244849205,
-0.3032207489013672,
0.14326147735118866,
-0.3387778699398041,
0.45896583795547485,
0.3555601239204407,
-0.018908610567450523,
0.39939457178115845,
-0.07269856333732605,
-0.2247890681028366,
-0.008343193680047989,
-0.733271598815918,
-0.28935256600379944,
0.9660765528678894,
0.0069151208736002445,
0.5102978944778442,
0.3575950264930725,
0.4976540505886078,
0.27397531270980835,
0.4342626929283142,
-0.6498194336891174,
0.46884849667549133,
-0.40634822845458984,
-1.1111090183258057,
-0.32615533471107483,
-0.5948094129562378,
-0.6084992289543152,
0.2859029769897461,
-0.5890530347824097,
-0.6468895673751831,
0.052572064101696014,
0.27486541867256165,
-0.18530550599098206,
0.23236499726772308,
-0.670799195766449,
0.5659996271133423,
-0.14533491432666779,
-0.484205424785614,
-0.5722959041595459,
-0.6030914783477783,
0.6783648133277893,
-0.2686043083667755,
0.45770469307899475,
-0.23366087675094604,
-0.12828853726387024,
0.5226019620895386,
-0.4657220244407654,
0.43513888120651245,
-0.33593350648880005,
0.03942440077662468,
0.3876359462738037,
0.1844807118177414,
0.6832315921783447,
-0.06920461356639862,
-0.29024261236190796,
-0.1557699590921402,
0.1709357053041458,
-0.2096753567457199,
-0.9014189839363098,
0.6244171857833862,
-0.22937172651290894,
-0.7401195764541626,
-0.45815008878707886,
-0.6800506114959717,
-0.31940406560897827,
0.27041223645210266,
-0.02834392711520195,
0.9168278574943542,
-0.1723921149969101,
0.40803736448287964,
0.721684455871582,
-0.2634929120540619,
0.07671908289194107,
0.792620062828064,
-0.6816178560256958,
-0.4239632785320282,
0.9830672740936279,
0.2080995738506317,
0.21287615597248077,
0.684756875038147,
0.22491057217121124,
-0.4603561758995056,
-0.25715598464012146,
-0.40539872646331787,
0.404074490070343,
-0.7020386457443237,
-0.3465035855770111,
-0.4758222699165344,
-0.09983233362436295,
-0.3779357969760895,
-0.0838356763124466,
-0.3801628351211548,
-0.9668014049530029,
0.3250953257083893,
-0.0960167720913887,
0.6309126019477844,
0.675072431564331,
-0.0221706535667181,
0.23035790026187897,
-0.9812920689582825,
0.6079479455947876,
-0.1290624439716339,
0.6098992228507996,
-0.3242363929748535,
-0.5656822323799133,
-0.12203299254179001,
0.22024957835674286,
-0.14086906611919403,
-0.7255108952522278,
0.08427658677101135,
0.13495704531669617,
0.685865044593811,
0.05099760368466377,
0.3314083218574524,
0.611815333366394,
-0.7822679877281189,
0.7027705311775208,
0.041110605001449585,
-1.0930373668670654,
0.4841538369655609,
-0.510367214679718,
-0.13530333340168,
0.39641594886779785,
0.04664486646652222,
-0.2957402467727661,
-0.2566283643245697,
-0.8731585144996643,
-0.760223388671875,
0.8458132743835449,
0.08534440398216248,
0.08484379947185516,
-0.22185073792934418,
0.5650486946105957,
-0.14234663546085358,
0.2668062746524811,
-0.05505780503153801,
-0.20858746767044067,
0.1672154664993286,
-0.3433738350868225,
-0.046784669160842896,
-0.6110032796859741,
-0.12313953042030334,
-0.060867082327604294,
1.0456030368804932,
-0.35597094893455505,
0.22476771473884583,
0.2615737020969391,
-0.14398594200611115,
-0.25099897384643555,
0.08850689232349396,
0.6138808727264404,
0.711640477180481,
0.029398268088698387,
-0.014701401814818382,
0.2884688377380371,
-0.25296464562416077,
0.030297687277197838,
0.18382064998149872,
-0.3698219656944275,
0.2448488473892212,
0.027412082999944687,
0.7878932952880859,
0.5014020800590515,
-0.5793347358703613,
0.6217797994613647,
0.10718940198421478,
0.156119704246521,
-0.39553913474082947,
0.18090608716011047,
-0.10608845949172974,
0.2986907362937927,
0.4547984302043915,
0.22427533566951752,
0.3040851950645447,
-0.3720873296260834,
0.6826149225234985,
0.5788028836250305,
0.014791542664170265,
-0.021651480346918106,
0.7246085405349731,
0.1821996569633484,
-0.38039833307266235,
0.23552849888801575,
-0.15825949609279633,
-0.423770010471344,
0.41027727723121643,
0.5430097579956055,
0.6626530885696411,
-0.25502485036849976,
0.19195330142974854,
0.49795812368392944,
0.09216514974832535,
-0.21975943446159363,
0.09956008195877075,
-0.16335877776145935,
-0.8245747685432434,
-0.9725226163864136,
-0.8100042939186096,
-0.4556329846382141,
-0.45708948373794556,
-0.728082001209259,
0.48224493861198425,
-0.17135074734687805,
-0.1927274912595749,
0.14778658747673035,
0.011598996818065643,
-0.2870626747608185,
0.3097776174545288,
0.25378528237342834,
1.0521421432495117,
-0.370964378118515,
0.8230509757995605,
0.636102557182312,
-0.5380603671073914,
-0.9434196949005127,
0.05512860417366028,
0.15298651158809662,
-0.5477803349494934,
0.7797908782958984,
-0.06306939572095871,
-0.4529462456703186,
-0.034324761480093,
-0.36729347705841064,
-1.4910571575164795,
0.8920496106147766,
0.558809757232666,
-0.2090640366077423,
-0.03505144268274307,
-0.07868047803640366,
0.45135802030563354,
-0.3639811873435974,
0.18441306054592133,
0.5236335396766663,
0.4507090151309967,
0.3799557089805603,
-0.9008061289787292,
0.1880244016647339,
-0.21169935166835785,
0.2851549983024597,
0.5290263891220093,
-0.4738912582397461,
0.5917399525642395,
-0.1151813343167305,
-0.2959984242916107,
0.275712251663208,
0.8957002758979797,
0.2944711744785309,
0.5003802180290222,
0.6101767420768738,
0.6386562585830688,
0.8930305242538452,
-0.15451541543006897,
1.1606014966964722,
-0.4922284185886383,
0.5086557865142822,
1.1367988586425781,
-0.32927870750427246,
0.9285210371017456,
0.2716481387615204,
-0.06375174224376678,
0.494412362575531,
-0.05237124487757683,
0.4376427233219147,
0.30843672156333923,
0.023356251418590546,
-0.30752578377723694,
-0.10422099381685257,
-0.10997200012207031,
-0.2714850902557373,
0.5484350919723511,
0.8417618274688721,
-0.2148943394422531,
-0.3524654507637024,
0.00852127280086279,
0.18295735120773315,
0.3923041522502899,
-0.22382128238677979,
0.667456865310669,
-0.19370676577091217,
-0.8064960241317749,
0.6341499090194702,
0.07906708866357803,
0.5786865949630737,
-0.6062608957290649,
-0.2009110152721405,
0.02331744134426117,
0.24926789104938507,
-0.26863858103752136,
-0.7243376970291138,
1.0620782375335693,
0.2102852612733841,
-0.442804753780365,
-0.020795008167624474,
0.9468066692352295,
-0.4351832866668701,
-0.48315247893333435,
0.021634556353092194,
0.2906937301158905,
0.1436968892812729,
0.14304958283901215,
-0.4604562222957611,
0.27319207787513733,
-0.15770608186721802,
-0.2850548326969147,
0.09013383090496063,
0.5518776178359985,
-0.1743372678756714,
0.3529534935951233,
0.7067323923110962,
-0.0828780084848404,
0.008107069879770279,
-0.49404701590538025,
0.7658316493034363,
-0.6515233516693115,
-0.4257778525352478,
-0.40067237615585327,
0.5070782899856567,
-0.11359279602766037,
0.11004357039928436,
0.6279491782188416,
0.6645424962043762,
0.9037588834762573,
0.04683922603726387,
0.6980053186416626,
-0.4695638418197632,
1.1997623443603516,
-0.6078780293464661,
0.5493475794792175,
-0.5775588154792786,
0.24282191693782806,
-0.3713464140892029,
-0.8993348479270935,
-0.3696076273918152,
0.49805617332458496,
-0.4704754650592804,
-0.19504126906394958,
0.7150731086730957,
1.1408414840698242,
0.0058861980214715,
0.29899412393569946,
0.2861933708190918,
0.35975518822669983,
0.1761552095413208,
-0.0676257461309433,
0.7423723936080933,
-0.34962162375450134,
0.3186677098274231,
-0.15886448323726654,
-0.3174383342266083,
-0.17742864787578583,
-0.8337865471839905,
-0.234712153673172,
-0.7543148398399353,
-0.10882648825645447,
-0.4274532198905945,
0.24816858768463135,
0.8726977109909058,
0.2810884118080139,
-0.7044159770011902,
0.06764928251504898,
0.13333313167095184,
0.09144391864538193,
0.11675039678812027,
-0.25802743434906006,
0.3168892562389374,
-0.7908453345298767,
-0.6955657005310059,
0.44292303919792175,
0.11932023614645004,
-0.47430968284606934,
-0.06306163221597672,
-0.010058719664812088,
-0.38431593775749207,
0.3023645877838135,
0.7907031178474426,
0.2286399006843567,
-0.7289458513259888,
-0.7095722556114197,
0.008225428871810436,
-0.09277946501970291,
-0.15806955099105835,
0.937564492225647,
-0.8465352058410645,
0.4915672540664673,
0.8166511058807373,
1.0441211462020874,
0.6231151223182678,
0.09044098109006882,
0.6372412443161011,
-0.8267475962638855,
0.35902366042137146,
0.07132012397050858,
0.43312764167785645,
0.4200412333011627,
-0.4395093321800232,
0.7726228833198547,
0.5144033432006836,
-0.41153380274772644,
-0.9204857349395752,
0.34981924295425415,
-0.6666547656059265,
-0.25230884552001953,
1.11799156665802,
-0.058043140918016434,
-0.4138013422489166,
0.1129366084933281,
-0.27667737007141113,
0.3354624807834625,
-0.1611487865447998,
0.4619348645210266,
0.6091370582580566,
0.034063469618558884,
0.29081445932388306,
-0.6316326260566711,
0.5302727222442627,
0.4852830767631531,
-0.4818599224090576,
0.21448759734630585,
0.9740685224533081,
0.21333210170269012,
0.5774014592170715,
0.6977443695068359,
-0.299719899892807,
0.33372437953948975,
-0.07798545807600021,
-0.03600607439875603,
0.12040317803621292,
-0.3717898726463318,
-0.09757877886295319,
0.14636792242527008,
-0.09722265601158142,
0.06933420896530151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16152v1 | Towards Region-aware Bias Evaluation Metrics | 2024-06-23T16:26:27 | 2024-06-23T16:26:27 | Angana Borah, Aparna Garimella, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL | When exposed to human-generated data, language models are known to learn and
amplify societal biases. While previous works introduced benchmarks that can be
used to assess the bias in these models, they rely on assumptions that may not
be universally true. For instance, a gender bias dimension commonly used by
these metrics is that of family--career, but this may not be the only common
bias in certain regions of the world. In this paper, we identify topical
differences in gender bias across different regions and propose a region-aware
bottom-up approach for bias assessment. Our proposed approach uses
gender-aligned topics for a given region and identifies gender bias dimensions
in the form of topic pairs that are likely to capture gender societal biases.
Several of our proposed bias topic pairs are on par with human perception of
gender biases in these regions in comparison to the existing ones, and we also
identify new pairs that are more aligned than the existing ones. In addition,
we use our region-aware bias topic pairs in a Word Embedding Association Test
(WEAT)-based evaluation metric to test for gender biases across different
regions in different data domains. We also find that LLMs have a higher
alignment to bias pairs for highly-represented regions showing the importance
of region-aware bias evaluation metric. | [
-0.6174015998840332,
-0.42816317081451416,
0.45076534152030945,
0.1372404545545578,
0.06114275008440018,
0.3198188543319702,
-0.2642602324485779,
-0.026040561497211456,
0.14360742270946503,
0.5171369910240173,
-0.7988213300704956,
-0.5190286040306091,
-0.756411612033844,
-0.2216196060180664,
-0.1105678379535675,
0.8431081771850586,
0.06208528205752373,
0.28744015097618103,
-0.22275464236736298,
-0.2678321301937103,
-0.8859257698059082,
-0.4886278510093689,
-0.2457018792629242,
-0.3484308421611786,
0.09335388988256454,
0.5636534094810486,
0.3878101110458374,
0.4920980632305145,
0.36376553773880005,
0.1519155353307724,
-0.3582082986831665,
0.08359530568122864,
-0.41659703850746155,
-0.05666834115982056,
-0.49888911843299866,
-0.1960916966199875,
-0.6750666499137878,
0.25727447867393494,
0.2919594645500183,
0.9345614314079285,
-0.013343136757612228,
0.5632343292236328,
-0.011225022375583649,
0.8362784385681152,
-0.83674156665802,
-0.21283048391342163,
-0.831152081489563,
0.3561372458934784,
-0.11890090256929398,
-0.15032131969928741,
0.1274048537015915,
-0.4829818606376648,
0.6467835903167725,
-0.11879622936248779,
0.6362826824188232,
0.035518817603588104,
0.6214200258255005,
0.08029473572969437,
-0.5927004814147949,
-0.1920834481716156,
-0.39912259578704834,
1.0208975076675415,
-0.26628565788269043,
0.6051720976829529,
0.41395333409309387,
0.20001298189163208,
-0.13801760971546173,
-0.02452055923640728,
-0.11006555706262589,
0.12935546040534973,
0.11156674474477768,
0.0962752252817154,
-0.1537587195634842,
-0.4197712242603302,
0.2340690642595291,
0.2877436876296997,
-0.35440561175346375,
-0.07115496695041656,
-0.15108038485050201,
-0.3505536913871765,
0.49643462896347046,
0.13481184840202332,
0.6045398116111755,
-0.20560520887374878,
-0.39081841707229614,
0.2812870740890503,
-0.9772385954856873,
-0.28976428508758545,
0.4757625460624695,
0.5044877529144287,
-0.2850229740142822,
0.30839142203330994,
-0.2798510789871216,
0.3817448019981384,
0.23043999075889587,
-0.06997305899858475,
0.22497114539146423,
-0.5796253085136414,
0.0846102312207222,
0.14791904389858246,
0.33395546674728394,
0.6177496910095215,
0.1993861198425293,
-0.32228758931159973,
0.04200803488492966,
0.32941749691963196,
0.35157281160354614,
-0.4893186092376709,
0.19052952527999878,
0.08815182745456696,
-0.5162479281425476,
-0.13325460255146027,
-0.1596916913986206,
-1.1820995807647705,
-0.9520833492279053,
-0.45824605226516724,
0.12005209922790527,
0.1425108015537262,
-0.36747652292251587,
0.08183428645133972,
-0.15660279989242554,
0.27484169602394104,
0.017996111884713173,
-0.8524103760719299,
0.3792957365512848,
0.933643639087677,
0.668246865272522,
-0.25119760632514954,
-0.13042373955249786,
-0.26600655913352966,
-0.1464201956987381,
-0.32758110761642456,
0.7146046757698059,
-0.4508083164691925,
-0.26113635301589966,
-0.11107730865478516,
-0.08890148252248764,
0.2580445110797882,
-0.5014662742614746,
0.6141819953918457,
-0.19016988575458527,
0.33372634649276733,
-0.9819007515907288,
-0.15483345091342926,
0.04671792685985565,
0.27597692608833313,
-0.42277538776397705,
1.3153973817825317,
0.14389349520206451,
-1.224196195602417,
1.1252195835113525,
-0.664689838886261,
-0.0855717808008194,
-0.47864311933517456,
-0.38559257984161377,
-0.38975414633750916,
-0.06016740947961807,
0.8224479556083679,
0.39326921105384827,
-0.6885267496109009,
0.6472450494766235,
-0.26299145817756653,
-0.28892460465431213,
0.12950843572616577,
-0.5420418977737427,
0.6700368523597717,
-0.09668122977018356,
-0.6235966682434082,
0.1306145340204239,
-0.4028582274913788,
-0.336150199174881,
-0.13516996800899506,
0.19156929850578308,
-0.6448139548301697,
-0.034331467002630234,
-0.2853449583053589,
0.1318584829568863,
0.21119676530361176,
-0.6990405917167664,
0.14557074010372162,
-0.04119330272078514,
0.4003407061100006,
0.9584572911262512,
0.12610799074172974,
0.8985292315483093,
-0.2024514526128769,
0.4391372799873352,
0.008864207193255424,
0.07661537826061249,
0.30635717511177063,
-0.18636353313922882,
-0.7199188470840454,
-0.39175641536712646,
0.5162461996078491,
0.5204569697380066,
-0.5083653330802917,
0.671164333820343,
-0.38222405314445496,
-0.5831941366195679,
-0.37444764375686646,
0.09169028699398041,
0.4351371228694916,
0.4786635637283325,
0.056900475174188614,
-0.6754984855651855,
-0.5998243093490601,
-1.086115837097168,
-0.46440717577934265,
0.03966502845287323,
-0.06613871455192566,
0.42706045508384705,
0.6270170211791992,
0.06770126521587372,
1.2011781930923462,
-0.6122948527336121,
-0.27705228328704834,
-0.339263916015625,
-0.024111265316605568,
-0.051441919058561325,
0.3296918570995331,
0.4954740107059479,
-0.5057502388954163,
-0.09258383512496948,
-0.19192203879356384,
-0.5344712734222412,
-0.5660529136657715,
0.17833004891872406,
-0.8155062198638916,
-0.24675671756267548,
0.11245301365852356,
0.08065680414438248,
0.43236979842185974,
0.4732648730278015,
-0.9049291014671326,
0.33522987365722656,
0.09428152441978455,
0.15075580775737762,
-1.0038659572601318,
-0.1500135064125061,
0.6356841921806335,
-0.2275988608598709,
-0.5754903554916382,
-0.11992114037275314,
-0.109672911465168,
0.19645437598228455,
-0.3046287000179291,
0.740692138671875,
-0.6244579553604126,
-0.8082793951034546,
0.06200012192130089,
0.42889678478240967,
-0.038255952298641205,
0.1762220859527588,
0.07613884657621384,
0.9393991231918335,
0.5863842964172363,
-0.48005005717277527,
-0.27257218956947327,
0.12305758893489838,
-0.5797619223594666,
0.8163894414901733,
-0.3705785870552063,
0.218039408326149,
-0.0546540692448616,
0.37680914998054504,
-0.5647632479667664,
0.11650797724723816,
0.11448798328638077,
-0.3807772099971771,
0.00928848423063755,
-0.21008636057376862,
-0.14334173500537872,
-0.14558476209640503,
-0.3715488910675049,
0.4273900091648102,
0.2769085764884949,
-0.5883822441101074,
0.281668484210968,
1.0643287897109985,
-0.18747514486312866,
-0.9438544511795044,
-0.6654955744743347,
-0.09359844028949738,
-0.7888661026954651,
-0.5121824741363525,
0.2724566161632538,
0.19698700308799744,
-0.35281383991241455,
-0.30295056104660034,
-0.1926226019859314,
-0.20896117389202118,
0.2538418769836426,
0.07271017134189606,
0.10695455968379974,
-0.0057434700429439545,
0.04338884726166725,
0.0697334036231041,
-0.05963695049285889,
-0.15116526186466217,
-0.1898631602525711,
0.6757729053497314,
-0.23979441821575165,
-0.22756847739219666,
-0.1164819523692131,
0.19582445919513702,
0.45111680030822754,
-0.26969850063323975,
0.2559613883495331,
0.7532117366790771,
-0.7073209881782532,
-0.09813536703586578,
-0.7160117626190186,
-0.3826335072517395,
-0.40915989875793457,
0.4541192650794983,
-0.12998300790786743,
-0.8650433421134949,
0.6475062370300293,
-0.14253340661525726,
0.042196862399578094,
0.08674211800098419,
0.6946089863777161,
0.3348512351512909,
0.7885919213294983,
0.8210516571998596,
-0.4757235050201416,
0.27107560634613037,
-0.3512845039367676,
0.336498886346817,
-1.3108011484146118,
0.24339795112609863,
-0.6282265186309814,
-0.2034304440021515,
-0.6752021908760071,
-0.5504659414291382,
0.2769783139228821,
-0.09103041142225266,
-0.5677382349967957,
0.06162998452782631,
-0.4828670620918274,
0.4786410927772522,
0.3754763603210449,
-0.015481753274798393,
0.026454845443367958,
0.3007737696170807,
-0.15791241824626923,
-0.6684662103652954,
-0.6702777743339539,
-0.7004624009132385,
1.06039559841156,
0.5707046389579773,
0.4790273904800415,
0.13684922456741333,
0.5112650394439697,
0.8254923224449158,
0.6059405207633972,
-0.5088040828704834,
0.3820914626121521,
-0.4022185206413269,
-0.7626127004623413,
-0.18676964938640594,
-0.2719239592552185,
-0.7253190875053406,
0.5584405660629272,
-0.33602434396743774,
-1.193882703781128,
0.29066669940948486,
-0.245488703250885,
0.008884238079190254,
0.4160894453525543,
-0.3083759844303131,
0.6226403117179871,
-0.17208600044250488,
-0.4968049228191376,
0.22975978255271912,
0.01674782484769821,
0.42765235900878906,
0.12105025351047516,
0.5085611343383789,
-0.5209800004959106,
0.020788826048374176,
0.8829092383384705,
-0.12157968431711197,
0.9900444746017456,
-0.2694520652294159,
-0.14192301034927368,
0.2049136757850647,
0.07401827722787857,
-0.33211633563041687,
0.16669517755508423,
-0.09984118491411209,
0.48691198229789734,
-0.3744172155857086,
-0.4009101390838623,
-0.47511762380599976,
0.5902944803237915,
-0.8807883858680725,
-0.5520839095115662,
-0.6049578785896301,
-0.5055844187736511,
-0.4738135039806366,
0.07031857967376709,
-0.1519048810005188,
0.7134780883789062,
-0.28608283400535583,
-0.24738024175167084,
0.6304681301116943,
-0.4463704824447632,
0.028299951925873756,
0.39928585290908813,
-0.24899831414222717,
-0.25634071230888367,
0.8001619577407837,
-0.04005585238337517,
0.06169470027089119,
0.024738192558288574,
0.4111713171005249,
-0.31388798356056213,
0.011092722415924072,
-0.6267925500869751,
0.10255559533834457,
-0.7593616247177124,
-0.03925755247473717,
-0.35759279131889343,
0.19307729601860046,
-0.23059074580669403,
-0.3398655354976654,
-0.4579605758190155,
-0.13476082682609558,
0.2586163282394409,
-0.2858235836029053,
0.17030414938926697,
0.5525853037834167,
-0.1641838699579239,
0.14644505083560944,
-0.378030389547348,
0.2051837146282196,
0.1276673525571823,
0.25063952803611755,
0.12596024572849274,
-0.5062560439109802,
0.21520206332206726,
-0.12031394243240356,
-0.33052387833595276,
-0.8910512328147888,
0.474288672208786,
-0.24105343222618103,
0.7024936079978943,
0.060357075184583664,
-0.12261519581079483,
0.45591363310813904,
-0.3540347218513489,
1.0935817956924438,
0.014988795854151249,
-1.326835036277771,
0.5848186612129211,
-0.4160670042037964,
0.13196732103824615,
0.6772841215133667,
0.22640573978424072,
-0.7065953016281128,
-0.30550503730773926,
-0.41594257950782776,
-0.8032412528991699,
0.4795398712158203,
-0.005934396758675575,
0.1881948858499527,
-0.0014371064025908709,
0.42050114274024963,
0.3955129384994507,
0.20160984992980957,
-0.6451098918914795,
-0.44311314821243286,
0.26585230231285095,
-0.058219391852617264,
0.30034786462783813,
-0.23640573024749756,
-0.16447226703166962,
-0.16397786140441895,
0.5830429196357727,
-0.16700361669063568,
0.4310777187347412,
0.29275909066200256,
-0.11006836593151093,
-0.012131606228649616,
0.7202790379524231,
0.47154298424720764,
1.0065513849258423,
-0.2772447168827057,
-0.11112691462039948,
0.40144503116607666,
-0.6209237575531006,
0.2916548550128937,
-0.3990729749202728,
-0.5206857919692993,
-0.20104491710662842,
0.2773241698741913,
0.6820054054260254,
0.0648694559931755,
-0.29712510108947754,
0.5538879632949829,
-0.49046939611434937,
0.010333686135709286,
-0.23113995790481567,
-0.28723859786987305,
0.12482329457998276,
0.11812441796064377,
0.23056991398334503,
-0.19320936501026154,
0.1471942514181137,
-0.7197310924530029,
0.15483134984970093,
0.37732794880867004,
-1.0837576389312744,
-0.0722317174077034,
0.30454882979393005,
0.4274415373802185,
0.0640566349029541,
0.351082980632782,
-0.2031705677509308,
-1.1759634017944336,
0.904782772064209,
0.3791969418525696,
0.9179565906524658,
0.019602863118052483,
0.29176804423332214,
0.48194772005081177,
0.6709744334220886,
0.06883431226015091,
0.6418347358703613,
0.1316973716020584,
-1.1297760009765625,
-0.0938599705696106,
-0.49903595447540283,
-0.39030885696411133,
0.02950192242860794,
-0.8555538654327393,
0.3082757294178009,
-0.23610329627990723,
-0.39191287755966187,
-0.2558704912662506,
0.1975206434726715,
-0.9805141091346741,
0.2994183301925659,
0.15238940715789795,
0.7603554129600525,
-1.2163740396499634,
0.3214623034000397,
0.804317831993103,
-0.07559721916913986,
-0.34298792481422424,
0.46265944838523865,
0.2571464776992798,
-0.6305752992630005,
0.6985846161842346,
0.18651369214057922,
-0.08008741587400436,
-0.6493001580238342,
-0.10892780125141144,
-1.0446557998657227,
1.2700105905532837,
0.04549841582775116,
-0.24863632023334503,
0.3589057922363281,
0.14336274564266205,
0.4368153214454651,
-0.8099850416183472,
0.5997157096862793,
0.9824368357658386,
0.41532716155052185,
-0.6908584833145142,
-1.0444663763046265,
0.18598945438861847,
0.19994071125984192,
0.2783324420452118,
0.25210079550743103,
-0.6672483682632446,
0.7872964143753052,
0.030040908604860306,
-0.16810429096221924,
-0.42514684796333313,
0.7174299359321594,
0.5237152576446533,
0.565624475479126,
0.6143113970756531,
0.2078179121017456,
0.8875741362571716,
-0.4240056872367859,
0.9107827544212341,
-0.3048785626888275,
0.30841144919395447,
1.0444245338439941,
-0.4105546474456787,
0.47615939378738403,
0.25342950224876404,
-0.2838325500488281,
0.35107341408729553,
0.7653452754020691,
0.3274305462837219,
0.5492073893547058,
0.5229724645614624,
-0.051499899476766586,
-0.18323396146297455,
-0.49831074476242065,
-0.2916746735572815,
0.783992350101471,
0.795420229434967,
-0.2458440512418747,
-0.24583521485328674,
-0.2624221742153168,
0.3725701868534088,
0.3453820049762726,
-0.5631173253059387,
0.3739069998264313,
0.06974726915359497,
-0.6037060618400574,
-0.015603921376168728,
0.18914462625980377,
1.2579935789108276,
-0.2197483330965042,
0.04856499657034874,
-0.5174593329429626,
-0.04956210404634476,
-0.11329323798418045,
-0.6083292365074158,
0.09756960719823837,
0.374068021774292,
-0.3291355073451996,
0.1731943041086197,
1.0267139673233032,
-0.4584488272666931,
-0.500832736492157,
0.2766586244106293,
0.8976666331291199,
0.005082192365080118,
0.32554754614830017,
-0.8320955634117126,
0.16706758737564087,
0.09654508531093597,
0.07130438089370728,
0.5232864618301392,
0.17519205808639526,
-0.5498226881027222,
0.6893556118011475,
0.35704416036605835,
0.29919764399528503,
-0.0014132288051769137,
0.4450662136077881,
0.33725446462631226,
-0.5102741122245789,
-0.6357704997062683,
-0.6644665598869324,
0.3158671259880066,
-0.2338806539773941,
-0.5597942471504211,
0.560523271560669,
0.1420959085226059,
0.6313157677650452,
0.2808589041233063,
1.1534185409545898,
0.05397483706474304,
0.7154191136360168,
-0.47794461250305176,
0.7441325783729553,
-0.5239741802215576,
0.3616982102394104,
-0.5113376379013062,
-1.1967979669570923,
-0.003072465769946575,
0.6722368001937866,
-0.7267261743545532,
0.30740249156951904,
0.37665849924087524,
0.617206871509552,
-0.2357606440782547,
0.17641466856002808,
0.10240985453128815,
-0.0550958476960659,
0.22279547154903412,
0.2280239462852478,
0.6744918823242188,
-0.3492335379123688,
-0.23073729872703552,
-0.5129079222679138,
-0.30973055958747864,
0.1765308529138565,
-1.247809886932373,
-0.8899106383323669,
-0.3458418846130371,
-0.4281386435031891,
-0.17022021114826202,
0.22339165210723877,
0.9981882572174072,
0.6095145344734192,
-0.5023761987686157,
-0.37622395157814026,
0.27982479333877563,
0.3029920756816864,
-0.024795660749077797,
-0.32513800263404846,
0.49443355202674866,
0.225980743765831,
-0.5998300909996033,
0.06587723642587662,
0.1540406197309494,
-0.5836023688316345,
-0.8811231851577759,
0.23033298552036285,
-0.07603392750024796,
0.1582816243171692,
0.49202507734298706,
-0.0617925189435482,
-0.7320842742919922,
-0.6382430791854858,
-0.29707878828048706,
-0.09057595580816269,
-0.09947221726179123,
1.0091845989227295,
-0.5692562460899353,
0.3963576853275299,
0.4195943772792816,
0.5821776390075684,
-0.029749933630228043,
0.11467286199331284,
0.9163094162940979,
-0.9451043605804443,
0.052154943346977234,
-0.05761998891830444,
0.5695673823356628,
0.9267130494117737,
-0.3975639045238495,
0.7883756160736084,
0.004519461654126644,
-0.5991438031196594,
-0.8120311498641968,
0.2557273507118225,
-0.6361138820648193,
-0.016685469076037407,
1.1567963361740112,
-0.15276986360549927,
-0.062369294464588165,
-0.21896865963935852,
-0.1185796856880188,
0.15688593685626984,
-0.5185538530349731,
0.9173651933670044,
0.7831718325614929,
0.05831121653318405,
0.18469983339309692,
-0.8928505182266235,
0.29640668630599976,
0.5417215824127197,
-0.7844243049621582,
0.24343425035476685,
0.31709229946136475,
0.6329395771026611,
0.11035219579935074,
0.727097749710083,
-0.2628157138824463,
0.171995609998703,
-0.07892361283302307,
0.2784392237663269,
0.6268047094345093,
-0.1804971694946289,
-0.3470783829689026,
-0.32794108986854553,
-0.038876887410879135,
0.23449279367923737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02518v1 | INDICT: Code Generation with Internal Dialogues of Critiques for Both Security and Helpfulness | 2024-06-23T15:55:07 | 2024-06-23T15:55:07 | Hung Le, Yingbo Zhou, Caiming Xiong, Silvio Savarese, Doyen Sahoo | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.MA, cs.PL | Large language models (LLMs) for code are typically trained to align with
natural language instructions to closely follow their intentions and
requirements. However, in many practical scenarios, it becomes increasingly
challenging for these models to navigate the intricate boundary between
helpfulness and safety, especially against highly complex yet potentially
malicious instructions. In this work, we introduce INDICT: a new framework that
empowers LLMs with Internal Dialogues of Critiques for both safety and
helpfulness guidance. The internal dialogue is a dual cooperative system
between a safety-driven critic and a helpfulness-driven critic. Each critic
provides analysis against the given task and corresponding generated response,
equipped with external knowledge queried through relevant code snippets and
tools like web search and code interpreter. We engage the dual critic system in
both code generation stage as well as code execution stage, providing
preemptive and post-hoc guidance respectively to LLMs. We evaluated INDICT on 8
diverse tasks across 8 programming languages from 5 benchmarks, using LLMs from
7B to 70B parameters. We observed that our approach can provide an advanced
level of critiques of both safety and helpfulness analysis, significantly
improving the quality of output codes ($+10\%$ absolute improvements in all
models). | [
-0.1736573874950409,
-0.29429352283477783,
0.2869292199611664,
0.24364227056503296,
-0.3600538372993469,
0.2993793785572052,
-0.389049768447876,
-0.4515932500362396,
-0.04157954081892967,
0.5602579712867737,
-0.4683430790901184,
-0.5612431168556213,
-0.3575200140476227,
0.1873359978199005,
-0.13162848353385925,
1.5251643657684326,
0.06793975830078125,
0.4064708352088928,
-0.10207569599151611,
0.0006137599120847881,
-0.631037175655365,
-0.6451830863952637,
-0.6784588694572449,
-0.024618634954094887,
0.37492233514785767,
0.4691741168498993,
0.5916106104850769,
0.01517524290829897,
0.8819360136985779,
0.30645549297332764,
0.3149844706058502,
0.08539216965436935,
-0.22416901588439941,
0.5697778463363647,
-0.512536883354187,
-0.26263436675071716,
-0.16921618580818176,
-0.30251288414001465,
0.1363210529088974,
0.14017251133918762,
-0.09971323609352112,
-0.0076517099514603615,
0.3516632616519928,
0.41282498836517334,
-0.44212597608566284,
0.2381139099597931,
-0.7432478666305542,
-0.14870139956474304,
0.03763439133763313,
-0.3503985106945038,
-0.43758416175842285,
-0.46426424384117126,
-0.0395372249186039,
-0.2674202620983124,
-0.24942968785762787,
-0.21863657236099243,
0.16009072959423065,
0.4498371183872223,
-0.24882856011390686,
-0.5812576413154602,
-0.5045488476753235,
0.4762539267539978,
-0.8019982576370239,
0.015185688622295856,
0.052013229578733444,
0.2350200116634369,
-0.26814132928848267,
-0.8755244612693787,
-0.3864942789077759,
-0.8090071678161621,
0.01769065484404564,
0.0383455753326416,
-0.1713637411594391,
0.2038601189851761,
0.05394715070724487,
0.16341273486614227,
-0.2563660740852356,
0.0966164767742157,
-0.18931998312473297,
-0.25470778346061707,
0.8414957523345947,
0.09812886267900467,
0.37434494495391846,
-0.14510220289230347,
-0.604832112789154,
-0.06466055661439896,
-0.8648996353149414,
0.2803974449634552,
0.7061682343482971,
0.41070249676704407,
-0.27483704686164856,
0.3522806167602539,
-0.1100594699382782,
0.21011869609355927,
-0.18049971759319305,
-0.10701223462820053,
0.05067876726388931,
-0.42710551619529724,
-0.019671669229865074,
-0.19888676702976227,
0.9038586616516113,
0.6997883319854736,
0.28306084871292114,
-0.12012095749378204,
-0.5505925416946411,
0.21820168197155,
0.6579891443252563,
-0.7525799870491028,
-0.5001137256622314,
0.16237178444862366,
-0.44875794649124146,
-0.5891282558441162,
0.25689005851745605,
-0.7499595284461975,
-0.7215837836265564,
-0.3824530243873596,
0.23490925133228302,
-0.4062374532222748,
-0.4834606349468231,
-0.18453064560890198,
0.07402241230010986,
0.11247178167104721,
0.3446543216705322,
-0.5000286102294922,
0.16272573173046112,
0.6387207508087158,
0.6543101668357849,
-0.06665606796741486,
0.01888428069651127,
-0.7670996189117432,
-0.08194653689861298,
-0.21708956360816956,
0.6925594806671143,
-0.6319600343704224,
-0.4279196560382843,
0.11542722582817078,
-0.3329631984233856,
0.14365148544311523,
-0.24826662242412567,
0.6068127155303955,
-0.5081762075424194,
-0.20473799109458923,
-0.04992589354515076,
-0.21098926663398743,
-0.10254742205142975,
0.42462828755378723,
-0.4198770523071289,
0.8184904456138611,
0.18431547284126282,
-1.009896993637085,
0.23568427562713623,
-0.8589539527893066,
-0.4235992431640625,
0.3480738401412964,
-0.588836133480072,
-0.16636285185813904,
0.03363098204135895,
0.0402241051197052,
0.31990954279899597,
-0.32643523812294006,
0.13286444544792175,
-0.4123466908931732,
-0.2089836448431015,
0.5382304787635803,
-0.39288005232810974,
0.6426442861557007,
0.3208732604980469,
-0.4654497802257538,
0.527859628200531,
-0.48172932863235474,
0.2502419352531433,
0.06120193004608154,
-0.22652746737003326,
-0.2790195941925049,
-0.17015694081783295,
-0.0505966916680336,
0.2427951544523239,
0.27370333671569824,
-0.5647743940353394,
0.1721627563238144,
-0.38509130477905273,
0.35418567061424255,
0.9196173548698425,
0.40957632660865784,
0.292853444814682,
-0.18768258392810822,
0.8159123659133911,
-0.341280996799469,
0.5170888304710388,
-0.23919574916362762,
-0.3162442743778229,
-0.5498491525650024,
-0.07757721841335297,
-0.20339913666248322,
0.6977788805961609,
-0.941569447517395,
0.36370399594306946,
0.1029997244477272,
-0.3485119640827179,
-0.4091509282588959,
0.30323630571365356,
0.818687915802002,
0.02861013635993004,
0.11764489859342575,
-0.557213306427002,
-0.6022140979766846,
-0.8650840520858765,
-0.22836139798164368,
-0.43275901675224304,
0.1661876142024994,
-0.09390256553888321,
0.433889240026474,
-0.2805580496788025,
0.5917099118232727,
-0.14419862627983093,
-0.020947277545928955,
-0.3431970477104187,
-0.2487119734287262,
-0.019492972642183304,
0.4921647906303406,
0.47350120544433594,
-0.6116830110549927,
-0.6482288241386414,
0.17710468173027039,
-0.7431012392044067,
-0.14621691405773163,
-0.042238205671310425,
-0.13417623937129974,
0.11515329033136368,
0.5891433358192444,
-0.2769303619861603,
0.3658222258090973,
0.4908280074596405,
-0.23790507018566132,
0.6758313775062561,
-0.0016635386273264885,
-0.09119569510221481,
-1.3168292045593262,
0.028807535767555237,
-0.09130352735519409,
-0.09676573425531387,
-0.582628071308136,
0.7020776271820068,
-0.09260199218988419,
-0.058076947927474976,
-0.24856391549110413,
0.22585923969745636,
-0.4416908621788025,
0.2905479371547699,
-0.3406960070133209,
-0.011677475646138191,
-0.23747038841247559,
0.5289985537528992,
-0.18412213027477264,
0.9557843804359436,
0.5195084810256958,
-0.40319812297821045,
0.4798145294189453,
0.09211978316307068,
-0.40376508235931396,
0.6595497727394104,
-0.5479164719581604,
0.5001187920570374,
0.21692204475402832,
0.2088325321674347,
-0.9664216637611389,
-0.2880691885948181,
0.305869460105896,
-0.29178521037101746,
0.4423133432865143,
-0.350254625082016,
-0.6314472556114197,
-0.35485896468162537,
-0.5978274345397949,
0.24967433512210846,
0.27895715832710266,
-0.5257020592689514,
0.2396349310874939,
0.4124201834201813,
-0.4690802991390228,
-0.731059193611145,
-0.389437735080719,
0.13079378008842468,
-0.15885354578495026,
-0.714234471321106,
-0.2531045377254486,
-0.40911877155303955,
-0.6353703737258911,
-0.2726958394050598,
-0.1123700812458992,
0.18276086449623108,
0.12159158289432526,
0.5009984970092773,
0.4050440490245819,
0.08956380933523178,
0.03449704125523567,
-0.04831781983375549,
-0.26051944494247437,
0.40816640853881836,
-0.2879537343978882,
0.36083123087882996,
-0.31687623262405396,
-0.5821683406829834,
-0.38851022720336914,
0.5719236731529236,
0.4836643934249878,
-0.4288805425167084,
0.3890687823295593,
0.4066898822784424,
0.06590374559164047,
-0.4656645357608795,
-0.5548795461654663,
-0.30966314673423767,
-0.5564519762992859,
0.23037756979465485,
-0.34294363856315613,
-0.8551362156867981,
0.38107454776763916,
0.056236445903778076,
0.49989640712738037,
0.12392821162939072,
0.5614063143730164,
0.1662185788154602,
0.8217373490333557,
0.7716776132583618,
-0.0164421945810318,
0.5816815495491028,
-0.1275683492422104,
0.5722888708114624,
-0.696976900100708,
-0.39207062125205994,
-0.45636534690856934,
0.10364808887243271,
-0.5748253464698792,
-0.31205490231513977,
0.6608471870422363,
0.009749280288815498,
-0.32343971729278564,
0.4042721390724182,
-0.9602176547050476,
0.5449178218841553,
0.43318215012550354,
0.06405852735042572,
0.40193983912467957,
-0.08678644895553589,
-0.37683048844337463,
-0.04985888674855232,
-0.4697099030017853,
-0.6982600688934326,
1.1370277404785156,
0.4966852366924286,
1.115453839302063,
0.31832677125930786,
0.8720048069953918,
0.2439342439174652,
0.7782658934593201,
-0.5447010397911072,
0.5932521224021912,
0.051353853195905685,
-0.330998957157135,
0.07615793496370316,
-0.47921356558799744,
-0.4596363306045532,
0.1868348866701126,
0.016409844160079956,
-0.8318567276000977,
-0.08010157942771912,
0.10388258844614029,
-0.5449880957603455,
0.32091638445854187,
-0.9850951433181763,
0.59566330909729,
-0.3069961369037628,
-0.5697004795074463,
-0.23692360520362854,
-0.8807483911514282,
0.5475008487701416,
0.11102862656116486,
0.22726139426231384,
0.016367949545383453,
-0.011792411096394062,
0.38323476910591125,
-0.4290925860404968,
1.1541153192520142,
-0.25072288513183594,
-0.47213438153266907,
0.5430972576141357,
0.4911240041255951,
0.7819230556488037,
0.5540217161178589,
-0.14337967336177826,
-0.11719703674316406,
0.031726859509944916,
0.19320684671401978,
-0.4761712849140167,
0.8647099733352661,
-0.44972723722457886,
-0.6742329597473145,
-0.35304930806159973,
-0.5403132438659668,
-0.22785931825637817,
0.019563980400562286,
0.38340139389038086,
0.5471125841140747,
-0.09615645557641983,
0.12422258406877518,
0.41801100969314575,
-0.17995314300060272,
0.510524332523346,
0.43645617365837097,
-0.051314499229192734,
-0.6085360050201416,
0.5568850636482239,
-0.348681777715683,
0.4545714557170868,
0.27188268303871155,
-0.14731864631175995,
-0.41371700167655945,
-0.7039510011672974,
-0.36203834414482117,
-0.04169195517897606,
-0.9815061092376709,
-0.8571327924728394,
-0.4882780611515045,
-0.5038096308708191,
-0.29143279790878296,
-0.21002072095870972,
-0.3118438720703125,
-0.337531179189682,
0.20821581780910492,
-0.3548884391784668,
0.5642373561859131,
1.1822761297225952,
-0.1530824899673462,
-0.051686592400074005,
-0.7900460362434387,
-0.20055674016475677,
0.04869233816862106,
0.5551238656044006,
-0.017642779275774956,
-0.2479698807001114,
-0.40528127551078796,
-0.25244924426078796,
-0.41404440999031067,
-0.8431774973869324,
0.016002289950847626,
-0.4033651053905487,
0.5280179381370544,
0.42299216985702515,
0.44389188289642334,
0.18061645328998566,
-0.09044237434864044,
0.7850465774536133,
0.501638650894165,
-0.746518611907959,
0.405170738697052,
-0.2908785045146942,
0.06356202811002731,
0.8400300741195679,
-0.05428516864776611,
-0.36403074860572815,
-0.7943187952041626,
-0.3082530200481415,
-0.7991098165512085,
0.43434545397758484,
0.33472591638565063,
0.41711708903312683,
-0.06746283173561096,
0.059102386236190796,
0.28930556774139404,
0.28229767084121704,
-1.0855239629745483,
0.07895106077194214,
-0.2853897511959076,
-0.09608358144760132,
0.3361782431602478,
-0.15109345316886902,
-0.49239587783813477,
0.005481083877384663,
0.6474621295928955,
-0.36680951714515686,
0.23498961329460144,
0.17787665128707886,
0.1519012451171875,
-0.14075967669487,
0.5964376926422119,
0.29395344853401184,
0.35112783312797546,
0.15392984449863434,
0.11470076441764832,
0.1046476811170578,
-0.329707533121109,
0.04865986108779907,
0.082100510597229,
0.006676104851067066,
-0.34245872497558594,
0.5937944650650024,
0.46987420320510864,
0.2403668612241745,
-0.6876980662345886,
0.7929783463478088,
-0.1872977912425995,
0.006298021879047155,
-0.5261165499687195,
0.41834017634391785,
-0.1606474071741104,
0.3810943365097046,
0.19856438040733337,
0.25043347477912903,
0.10772790759801865,
-0.5368399024009705,
0.29329362511634827,
0.7121489644050598,
-0.2270146906375885,
-0.33840441703796387,
0.5408896803855896,
0.6683022975921631,
-0.2182132750749588,
0.3662136197090149,
-0.5200836658477783,
-0.621353030204773,
0.4654029607772827,
0.42690813541412354,
1.362809181213379,
-0.20889757573604584,
0.16169770061969757,
0.4360094368457794,
0.47948917746543884,
0.2551182508468628,
0.4012519419193268,
-0.32323774695396423,
-0.6126554012298584,
-0.38982558250427246,
-0.5904170870780945,
-0.42933595180511475,
0.07652125507593155,
-0.5283396244049072,
-0.06567616015672684,
-0.7834314107894897,
-0.17840594053268433,
-0.44135940074920654,
0.07115388661623001,
-0.48140695691108704,
-0.23290890455245972,
-0.036809150129556656,
0.9560875296592712,
-0.378502756357193,
0.7745997309684753,
0.6060575842857361,
-0.7556898593902588,
-1.0800414085388184,
0.25343555212020874,
-0.03992148116230965,
-0.4898022413253784,
0.32928887009620667,
0.34897345304489136,
-0.517533540725708,
-0.4457263648509979,
-0.7051955461502075,
-0.6191564202308655,
0.8466871380805969,
0.5433330535888672,
-0.6226955056190491,
-0.001020774943754077,
-0.25052812695503235,
0.5762596130371094,
-0.5369698405265808,
0.22699105739593506,
0.3785203695297241,
0.42819008231163025,
-0.1320073902606964,
-0.9907916188240051,
0.23161004483699799,
-0.7194334268569946,
0.03354070335626602,
0.2404957264661789,
-0.6500822305679321,
0.5916688442230225,
-0.5895481705665588,
-0.3152799606323242,
0.43820443749427795,
0.3481478989124298,
0.047448500990867615,
0.22581757605075836,
0.5285210013389587,
0.19661936163902283,
0.44365373253822327,
0.13544242084026337,
1.2094889879226685,
-0.5907989144325256,
-0.07028272747993469,
1.3474987745285034,
-0.4886006712913513,
0.6479385495185852,
0.48620322346687317,
0.02509242668747902,
0.8483442068099976,
0.21774061024188995,
0.1722763329744339,
0.49566131830215454,
0.19505421817302704,
-0.637279212474823,
-0.09864892810583115,
-0.13113780319690704,
-0.5054475665092468,
0.20322610437870026,
0.22434337437152863,
-0.31389421224594116,
-0.19119752943515778,
-0.11467199772596359,
0.06917442381381989,
0.3998236358165741,
-0.13463374972343445,
1.0515066385269165,
0.36592116951942444,
-0.9519581198692322,
0.19088757038116455,
0.19661568105220795,
0.6681363582611084,
-0.9415479302406311,
-0.056851811707019806,
-0.1944308876991272,
0.41096019744873047,
-0.4540523588657379,
-0.994316041469574,
0.33657941222190857,
0.37929826974868774,
0.23279310762882233,
-0.18098092079162598,
0.7131301164627075,
-0.25888413190841675,
-0.0765126645565033,
0.7454175353050232,
0.11178649961948395,
-0.09116246551275253,
-0.003856250084936619,
-0.6477500796318054,
0.011541117914021015,
0.26132455468177795,
-0.08046634495258331,
0.27364179491996765,
0.4962916672229767,
-0.14470840990543365,
0.6668798923492432,
0.7943155765533447,
-0.16715888679027557,
-0.04313711076974869,
0.22592365741729736,
1.1644864082336426,
-0.2112351655960083,
-0.7781691551208496,
-0.7863763570785522,
0.6605483293533325,
-0.29033535718917847,
-0.3510484993457794,
0.9454243183135986,
0.45548126101493835,
0.9396072626113892,
-0.09539563208818436,
1.099759578704834,
-0.04399610683321953,
0.2610868215560913,
-0.6064990162849426,
0.5930257439613342,
-0.09127411991357803,
0.5872119665145874,
-0.3663344979286194,
-0.7989118695259094,
-0.20439137518405914,
0.6514406800270081,
-0.2337397336959839,
0.12468613684177399,
0.7647218108177185,
1.2069664001464844,
0.077203668653965,
0.20283715426921844,
0.1423937976360321,
-0.08042386919260025,
0.49654555320739746,
0.630214512348175,
1.0615087747573853,
-0.0021351671312004328,
0.7618508338928223,
-0.32077133655548096,
-0.20625045895576477,
-0.0923297330737114,
-0.738140344619751,
-0.9455148577690125,
-0.42029160261154175,
-0.16371497511863708,
-0.5240401029586792,
-0.0280176792293787,
1.4055688381195068,
0.7823362946510315,
-0.7228289842605591,
-0.2564093768596649,
-0.3161642849445343,
-0.1092100739479065,
-0.08201288431882858,
-0.2821030020713806,
-0.0009765353170223534,
-0.5440250039100647,
-0.2459051012992859,
0.7338378429412842,
0.4134739637374878,
-0.028285572305321693,
-0.6595728993415833,
-0.37118613719940186,
0.34973084926605225,
0.2509114444255829,
0.4284847676753998,
0.15292300283908844,
-0.4462834298610687,
-0.3796458840370178,
-0.42440637946128845,
-0.226388081908226,
-0.14125488698482513,
1.2862213850021362,
-0.31753039360046387,
0.5765824913978577,
0.3128569722175598,
0.5502892136573792,
-0.04037483409047127,
-0.11927947402000427,
0.7863634824752808,
-1.007516860961914,
0.25211188197135925,
0.43912163376808167,
0.36644136905670166,
0.6347065567970276,
-0.6553911566734314,
0.7570879459381104,
-0.15479257702827454,
-0.544793963432312,
-0.8843476176261902,
0.6179101467132568,
-0.7657771706581116,
-0.15132580697536469,
1.2524185180664062,
-0.2493537813425064,
0.22454611957073212,
-0.14807765185832977,
-0.4845704138278961,
0.07466205209493637,
-0.809707760810852,
0.7131808996200562,
0.438256174325943,
-0.015170738101005554,
-0.10929542034864426,
-0.3139045238494873,
0.7638756036758423,
0.18603374063968658,
-0.9514968991279602,
0.17124611139297485,
0.38310298323631287,
0.42051416635513306,
0.18902109563350677,
0.8166148662567139,
-0.25601303577423096,
0.4571828544139862,
0.16220369935035706,
0.20799392461776733,
-0.15926693379878998,
-0.5976549386978149,
-0.3553490936756134,
0.19101457297801971,
0.5210438966751099,
-0.03340015932917595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16144v1 | Chain-of-Probe: Examing the Necessity and Accuracy of CoT Step-by-Step | 2024-06-23T15:50:22 | 2024-06-23T15:50:22 | Zezhong Wang, Xingshan Zeng, Weiwen Liu, Yufei Wang, Liangyou Li, Yasheng Wang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current research found the issue of Early Answering in large language models
(LLMs), where the models already have an answer before generating the
Chain-of-Thought (CoT). This phenomenon suggests a potential lack of necessary
dependency between the predicted answer and the reasoning process.
Consequently, two important questions arise: (1) Is CoT still necessary if the
model already has an answer? (2) Can the correctness of the answer serve as
valid evidence for the correctness of CoT? To address these questions, we
propose a method, namely Chain-of-Probe (CoP), to probe changes in the mind
during the model's reasoning. The probing results show that in a significant
number of question-answer cases, CoT appears to be unnecessary, and this
necessity correlates with the simplicity of the task, defined by reasoning
steps required. Furthermore, by analyzing patterns in mind change, we examine
the correctness of the model's reasoning. Our validation reveals that many
responses, although correct in their final answer, contain errors in their
reasoning process. To this end, we propose a strategic approach based on CoP to
prioritize answers with correct reasoning among multiple candidates, thereby
bolstering the reliability of the model's reasoning. | [
-0.6492056250572205,
-0.9345893263816833,
1.0567374229431152,
-0.06384541839361191,
-0.17395226657390594,
0.3180237114429474,
0.0036730230785906315,
-0.2554556131362915,
0.10775262862443924,
0.5821540951728821,
-0.4311724603176117,
-0.16389824450016022,
-0.6184049248695374,
0.020272990688681602,
-0.5124238729476929,
0.7754811644554138,
-0.2819732129573822,
0.12146083265542984,
-0.17504030466079712,
-0.03279856592416763,
-0.4310441315174103,
-0.5927620530128479,
-0.8345595598220825,
-0.2921985685825348,
0.7826634645462036,
0.5131236910820007,
0.5128059387207031,
0.7210283875465393,
0.38681188225746155,
0.23518380522727966,
-0.4398805499076843,
0.3761100769042969,
-0.48150116205215454,
0.21738938987255096,
-0.5503720641136169,
-0.8568204045295715,
-0.729580283164978,
0.19351041316986084,
0.44113439321517944,
0.8173224329948425,
-0.03487607464194298,
0.2742616832256317,
-0.0013616905780509114,
0.7825675010681152,
-0.8362523317337036,
-0.35008054971694946,
-0.6831082105636597,
-0.4077768921852112,
-0.0494438074529171,
-0.3362484276294708,
-0.5640247464179993,
-0.1611805111169815,
0.21956764161586761,
-0.21381732821464539,
0.26101037859916687,
0.17153333127498627,
0.6101736426353455,
0.059349726885557175,
-0.7708912491798401,
-0.37559425830841064,
-0.8704508543014526,
0.5960354208946228,
-0.5594920516014099,
0.31525424122810364,
0.37093067169189453,
0.12636463344097137,
-0.46582990884780884,
-0.7270078063011169,
-0.6180453896522522,
-0.256641685962677,
0.13757938146591187,
0.08523960411548615,
0.41129282116889954,
0.10947071760892868,
0.2166530042886734,
0.34284040331840515,
-0.10496064275503159,
-0.12897206842899323,
-0.35855409502983093,
-0.08400353789329529,
0.5718094110488892,
0.3229626417160034,
0.178693488240242,
0.2781457006931305,
-0.5726382732391357,
-0.3252890408039093,
-0.8142192363739014,
0.1564575433731079,
0.2634609043598175,
0.2324865460395813,
0.010191798210144043,
0.6249300241470337,
-0.04546523839235306,
0.6786379218101501,
0.4170076251029968,
0.18575531244277954,
-0.2575503885746002,
-0.5471483469009399,
-0.2587713599205017,
0.336484432220459,
0.7224188446998596,
-0.09458097815513611,
0.2172747254371643,
0.20416802167892456,
-0.21384640038013458,
0.12876956164836884,
0.5736914277076721,
-0.4120869040489197,
-0.08616390079259872,
0.6446431279182434,
0.0037295634392648935,
-0.388852596282959,
0.021334543824195862,
-0.55389404296875,
-0.14229296147823334,
-0.2897915244102478,
0.29377812147140503,
-0.1791360229253769,
-0.4345853924751282,
0.17401911318302155,
0.06146965175867081,
0.42115291953086853,
0.5720789432525635,
-0.4157840311527252,
0.5324084162712097,
0.7382524013519287,
0.7766914963722229,
-0.1822781264781952,
-0.4663560092449188,
-0.7263830900192261,
0.16268126666545868,
-1.09419584274292,
0.7962201833724976,
-0.2995554506778717,
-0.4679471552371979,
-0.341909795999527,
0.004296877421438694,
-0.09234398603439331,
-0.2660594880580902,
0.43800345063209534,
-0.7625895738601685,
0.006557031534612179,
-0.8253833651542664,
-0.8042621612548828,
-0.03615790605545044,
0.6702271103858948,
-0.6607187390327454,
0.9823269248008728,
-0.13230453431606293,
-0.7845996022224426,
0.07850129157304764,
-0.4680107533931732,
-0.1888674646615982,
-0.2184441089630127,
-0.2814914882183075,
-0.08386610448360443,
0.09932772815227509,
0.30661749839782715,
0.24032756686210632,
-0.38764306902885437,
0.2962241470813751,
-0.15436728298664093,
-0.4403459429740906,
0.5151740312576294,
-0.2535317540168762,
0.9629921913146973,
0.0755816251039505,
-0.4940124750137329,
0.04018930718302727,
-0.5708262324333191,
0.20770177245140076,
0.0018867197213694453,
-0.27855783700942993,
-0.2450994849205017,
0.21200266480445862,
-0.478022962808609,
0.192818284034729,
0.018769675865769386,
-0.5127238035202026,
0.3308730125427246,
-0.28179800510406494,
0.06155892461538315,
1.0159571170806885,
0.2063927799463272,
0.43189775943756104,
-0.5461035966873169,
0.6799688935279846,
0.15566106140613556,
0.2803621292114258,
0.07480037957429886,
-0.6803810596466064,
-0.9468048214912415,
0.09815416485071182,
0.2980160117149353,
0.4678349792957306,
-0.5053573846817017,
0.11014941334724426,
0.06424504518508911,
-0.7473251223564148,
-0.3066672682762146,
-0.06954850256443024,
0.4784264862537384,
0.5530077815055847,
0.21352586150169373,
-0.40164339542388916,
-0.5712554454803467,
-0.3995162546634674,
-0.17745721340179443,
-0.4941842555999756,
0.26556482911109924,
0.1492924690246582,
0.6622702479362488,
-0.1395851969718933,
0.8761254549026489,
-0.6236246228218079,
0.1681787520647049,
-0.25580671429634094,
0.12541769444942474,
0.3506532311439514,
0.3440038859844208,
0.11248224973678589,
-0.7670761942863464,
-0.07062367349863052,
0.005652094259858131,
-0.4506441056728363,
0.10939806699752808,
-0.06680713593959808,
-0.47320443391799927,
0.02141214720904827,
0.6528314352035522,
-0.4951373338699341,
0.3542753756046295,
0.5863440036773682,
-0.21037133038043976,
0.9057967066764832,
-0.17359091341495514,
0.370153546333313,
-0.809065043926239,
0.13258638978004456,
-0.41232311725616455,
-0.25520575046539307,
-0.6259662508964539,
0.3822648227214813,
0.04820127412676811,
0.22667557001113892,
-0.5419921875,
0.5849894285202026,
-0.4399819076061249,
0.045536383986473083,
-0.33319422602653503,
0.31689345836639404,
0.17608214914798737,
0.2888408303260803,
-0.07225814461708069,
0.9579041004180908,
0.4042198359966278,
-1.156046986579895,
0.33701586723327637,
0.1733853816986084,
-0.28487974405288696,
0.28568845987319946,
-0.45949622988700867,
0.6577346920967102,
-0.06789278984069824,
0.33978545665740967,
-1.1700626611709595,
0.033069804310798645,
0.26439085602760315,
-0.5171887874603271,
-0.026282314211130142,
-0.13213424384593964,
-0.33508196473121643,
-0.3433516323566437,
-0.0937802717089653,
0.6042288541793823,
0.12669184803962708,
-0.33879977464675903,
0.5851898193359375,
0.10449402779340744,
0.06678714603185654,
-0.667128324508667,
-0.4932699203491211,
-0.18619000911712646,
0.17238390445709229,
-0.2595316767692566,
0.06974217295646667,
-0.15061494708061218,
-0.3321083188056946,
-0.18529309332370758,
-0.4297908842563629,
-0.20214764773845673,
0.06064923107624054,
-0.09909560531377792,
0.29615435004234314,
-0.20469354093074799,
0.22236523032188416,
-0.0872105211019516,
-0.04286384582519531,
0.35976314544677734,
-0.111445851624012,
0.7832087874412537,
-0.30690324306488037,
-0.3538163900375366,
-0.11245454102754593,
0.27828505635261536,
0.870333731174469,
-0.4744671583175659,
0.4545973837375641,
0.11334697157144547,
-0.2555979788303375,
-0.11802835017442703,
-0.7135611176490784,
-0.23471589386463165,
-0.4654652774333954,
-0.08905254304409027,
-0.4856005311012268,
-0.6591047644615173,
0.6724767684936523,
-0.2497594654560089,
-0.25033849477767944,
0.3338756561279297,
0.5460070967674255,
-0.2843707203865051,
0.9336647391319275,
0.43830400705337524,
0.06805204600095749,
0.08718540519475937,
-0.2964310348033905,
0.42806166410446167,
-1.1444439888000488,
-0.173489511013031,
-0.5623705387115479,
-0.1063137948513031,
-0.6615111231803894,
-0.5656428337097168,
0.43424639105796814,
0.13969117403030396,
-0.3620910048484802,
0.1797567754983902,
-0.39571821689605713,
0.4472457468509674,
0.508407473564148,
0.42823562026023865,
0.3041520118713379,
-0.46372050046920776,
-0.5030816793441772,
0.4238286018371582,
-0.7030114531517029,
-0.5400025844573975,
1.1365535259246826,
0.10272622108459473,
0.7165601849555969,
-0.0090492470189929,
0.6916440725326538,
-0.10689174383878708,
0.1425594538450241,
-0.8609482645988464,
0.7769119143486023,
0.3047748804092407,
-0.8735539317131042,
-0.49730753898620605,
-0.2777576446533203,
-0.9240870475769043,
0.06613205373287201,
0.14098122715950012,
-0.5663955807685852,
0.3007974922657013,
0.3152075707912445,
-0.37534597516059875,
0.34848567843437195,
-0.3081262409687042,
0.5362982153892517,
-0.512651264667511,
-0.5285068154335022,
-0.2295845001935959,
-0.747450053691864,
0.36418479681015015,
-0.08514512330293655,
0.10216771811246872,
0.08394880592823029,
-0.20117634534835815,
0.7993402481079102,
-0.6116260290145874,
0.677950918674469,
0.13568848371505737,
-0.3127625584602356,
0.850734293460846,
0.5209468603134155,
0.7690111994743347,
0.00294747157022357,
-0.07794911414384842,
-0.316384494304657,
0.33325740694999695,
-0.4011061489582062,
-0.7483071684837341,
0.4548467695713043,
-0.48441481590270996,
-0.9525090456008911,
-0.7980128526687622,
-0.2934000492095947,
-0.3043555021286011,
0.25358760356903076,
0.23188678920269012,
0.418539822101593,
-0.009756824001669884,
-0.29460519552230835,
0.8167079091072083,
0.037720851600170135,
0.0981784462928772,
0.25855809450149536,
-0.4457379877567291,
-0.244643434882164,
0.32828468084335327,
0.021471723914146423,
0.6942430138587952,
0.25307947397232056,
0.5795169472694397,
-0.20674876868724823,
-0.5120252370834351,
-0.23568452894687653,
0.37224051356315613,
-0.7162204384803772,
0.039476942270994186,
-0.5329947471618652,
-0.2242552489042282,
-0.06437496095895767,
-0.21730902791023254,
-0.7295891046524048,
0.09918929636478424,
-0.07257354259490967,
-0.1510057896375656,
0.3548591136932373,
0.7693407535552979,
0.08284445106983185,
-0.0025585098192095757,
-0.5703067779541016,
0.23321272432804108,
0.4879212975502014,
0.258745938539505,
0.12166565656661987,
-0.15483780205249786,
-0.04669543728232384,
0.39158350229263306,
-0.3448066711425781,
-1.0893815755844116,
-0.07850578427314758,
-0.2001522332429886,
0.3681802451610565,
0.21118098497390747,
0.18185442686080933,
0.9360429644584656,
-0.3765796422958374,
0.7745343446731567,
0.025035621598362923,
-1.1969133615493774,
1.00984787940979,
-0.5457679033279419,
0.3597055673599243,
0.634735643863678,
0.6142420172691345,
-0.37155991792678833,
-0.6466227769851685,
-0.7012010812759399,
-0.7310664653778076,
0.3731135129928589,
0.0439007468521595,
-0.2101384550333023,
-0.2853218615055084,
0.4725329279899597,
-0.21379885077476501,
0.18013879656791687,
-0.3631378412246704,
-0.09365253150463104,
0.38761216402053833,
0.3985864520072937,
0.1442946493625641,
-0.2171761393547058,
-0.23820188641548157,
-0.34263938665390015,
0.5497471690177917,
-0.22973081469535828,
0.3420509099960327,
0.8163670897483826,
0.04875652492046356,
-0.18828774988651276,
0.2451944649219513,
0.5319269299507141,
1.1742446422576904,
-0.441508948802948,
0.2813463807106018,
0.34280234575271606,
-0.5101988315582275,
0.5439596772193909,
-0.8322463631629944,
0.19183823466300964,
-0.09363509714603424,
0.3715697228908539,
0.2920970022678375,
0.09605448693037033,
-0.6528310775756836,
0.676288366317749,
0.0943550169467926,
-0.18940062820911407,
-0.2846429646015167,
0.01341596432030201,
0.020549027249217033,
0.08281166106462479,
0.20651765167713165,
0.27022406458854675,
0.09934638440608978,
-0.8168840408325195,
0.24477775394916534,
0.1671636402606964,
-0.38241854310035706,
-0.06620032340288162,
0.40889880061149597,
-0.04632069915533066,
-0.3235085606575012,
0.7776903510093689,
-0.175562784075737,
-0.7211438417434692,
0.9036338329315186,
0.4994868338108063,
0.7164952754974365,
-0.5962948203086853,
0.20974411070346832,
0.37168243527412415,
0.40617555379867554,
-0.4390287399291992,
0.5751803517341614,
0.08603886514902115,
-0.8805083632469177,
-0.6944235563278198,
-0.09101475030183792,
-0.7593756914138794,
0.1561574786901474,
-0.9378901720046997,
0.4514283835887909,
-0.76174396276474,
-0.28436288237571716,
-0.41094353795051575,
-0.04723237827420235,
-0.6504772901535034,
0.642964243888855,
-0.05108972266316414,
0.9751939177513123,
-0.5114986300468445,
0.7991805076599121,
0.5221546292304993,
-0.17775070667266846,
-1.1370794773101807,
0.18246211111545563,
-0.13430558145046234,
-0.6296916604042053,
0.572325587272644,
-0.05104444548487663,
-0.659390926361084,
-0.011529340408742428,
-0.647330105304718,
-1.155129313468933,
0.9868594408035278,
0.22642777860164642,
-0.89957195520401,
0.011197355575859547,
-0.2195952832698822,
0.5084666013717651,
-0.3780759274959564,
0.3635479509830475,
0.37115076184272766,
0.19320927560329437,
0.20290948450565338,
-0.9599482417106628,
0.29371213912963867,
0.11678235977888107,
-0.04613470658659935,
0.47208449244499207,
-0.5284282565116882,
1.0827860832214355,
-0.5220756530761719,
-0.23812153935432434,
0.0010400553001090884,
0.22872327268123627,
0.5441192984580994,
0.3101658523082733,
0.7365676760673523,
0.28632551431655884,
0.9526245594024658,
0.016669800505042076,
1.1626837253570557,
-0.14736202359199524,
0.366479754447937,
1.3114622831344604,
-0.4112500250339508,
1.2064672708511353,
0.6079971194267273,
-0.27848222851753235,
0.5558701157569885,
0.6583155393600464,
0.2870260775089264,
0.39191773533821106,
0.5237219333648682,
-0.11852077394723892,
-0.4192539155483246,
0.2041197121143341,
-0.2987673580646515,
0.6389219164848328,
0.36438292264938354,
-0.21268582344055176,
0.10384324193000793,
-0.25948458909988403,
0.11771446466445923,
0.019876141101121902,
-0.3305663466453552,
0.4149935245513916,
0.0850786566734314,
-0.9910136461257935,
0.6727274060249329,
-0.37211689352989197,
0.14981834590435028,
-0.529971182346344,
0.06802358478307724,
-0.18169349431991577,
0.16788096725940704,
0.00389907811768353,
-0.8398323655128479,
0.20058290660381317,
-0.03099706582725048,
-0.054682161659002304,
-0.1600138396024704,
0.4177980422973633,
-0.17810951173305511,
-0.6148173213005066,
0.6050403118133545,
0.8388668894767761,
0.12366122752428055,
-0.06050191447138786,
-0.4674324095249176,
0.14008253812789917,
-0.22346444427967072,
-0.3043123781681061,
-0.0425688810646534,
0.32550328969955444,
-0.15833577513694763,
0.7363648414611816,
0.6604747772216797,
0.34252193570137024,
0.1325732171535492,
0.019300783053040504,
0.9763568639755249,
-0.5132361054420471,
-0.46269309520721436,
-0.9679736495018005,
0.5392810702323914,
0.023693043738603592,
-0.399171382188797,
0.45579734444618225,
0.46261152625083923,
0.9229166507720947,
0.15259689092636108,
0.6893457174301147,
0.06342951953411102,
0.44836780428886414,
-0.7131797671318054,
0.41948607563972473,
-0.5100400447845459,
0.3766900897026062,
-0.4673304557800293,
-0.8269625306129456,
0.002176476176828146,
0.48349422216415405,
-0.35388749837875366,
0.027005856856703758,
1.3973097801208496,
0.8599358201026917,
0.0336604118347168,
0.04691152274608612,
0.14056245982646942,
0.36825770139694214,
0.3794041574001312,
0.6941137313842773,
0.929485559463501,
-0.73624587059021,
0.46264567971229553,
-0.21803615987300873,
-0.31615227460861206,
0.011461853981018066,
-1.0014346837997437,
-0.7668623924255371,
-0.771203339099884,
-0.5307174324989319,
-0.5541418194770813,
0.21863466501235962,
0.8209125399589539,
0.460051029920578,
-0.664434015750885,
-0.6783716082572937,
-0.47492924332618713,
0.20168645679950714,
-0.6784356236457825,
-0.1273185759782791,
0.31727197766304016,
-0.3991633951663971,
-0.43655258417129517,
0.4070686995983124,
0.11698678880929947,
0.07087753713130951,
-0.10889659821987152,
0.027387123554944992,
-0.7657333016395569,
0.354078084230423,
0.5131049752235413,
0.02055942267179489,
-0.8656115531921387,
-0.409563273191452,
0.2182721048593521,
-0.022042017430067062,
0.11817188560962677,
1.106372594833374,
-0.7913356423377991,
0.6411913633346558,
0.5114719867706299,
0.5225285291671753,
0.6528960466384888,
-0.10727996379137039,
0.9767771363258362,
-0.46780726313591003,
-0.16138800978660583,
0.3788285553455353,
0.21273989975452423,
0.021468795835971832,
-0.5260030031204224,
0.5988479256629944,
0.014112783595919609,
-0.7223031520843506,
-0.877653181552887,
0.5473141074180603,
-1.1794943809509277,
-0.26113593578338623,
1.0931867361068726,
-0.12461012601852417,
-0.421408087015152,
-0.1306307315826416,
-0.5219087600708008,
0.39999791979789734,
-0.006834918633103371,
0.6729314923286438,
1.0193841457366943,
-0.20978131890296936,
-0.32879048585891724,
-0.39841270446777344,
0.28468891978263855,
0.4634310305118561,
-0.674577534198761,
0.03663943335413933,
-0.09253177791833878,
0.3017432391643524,
0.34710854291915894,
0.9204843044281006,
-0.01280499342828989,
0.35710278153419495,
0.0917455330491066,
-0.33341866731643677,
0.16594378650188446,
-0.4349900782108307,
0.03522143512964249,
-0.0035984665155410767,
0.32478946447372437,
-0.45913535356521606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16135v1 | Crosslingual Capabilities and Knowledge Barriers in Multilingual Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T15:15:17 | 2024-06-23T15:15:17 | Lynn Chua, Badih Ghazi, Yangsibo Huang, Pritish Kamath, Ravi Kumar, Pasin Manurangsi, Amer Sinha, Chulin Xie, Chiyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are typically multilingual due to pretraining on
diverse multilingual corpora. But can these models relate corresponding
concepts across languages, effectively being crosslingual? This study evaluates
six state-of-the-art LLMs on inherently crosslingual tasks. We observe that
while these models show promising surface-level crosslingual abilities on
machine translation and embedding space analyses, they struggle with deeper
crosslingual knowledge transfer, revealing a crosslingual knowledge barrier in
both general (MMLU benchmark) and domain-specific (Harry Potter quiz) contexts.
We observe that simple inference-time mitigation methods offer only limited
improvement. On the other hand, we propose fine-tuning of LLMs on
mixed-language data, which effectively reduces these gaps, even when using
out-of-domain datasets like WikiText. Our findings suggest the need for
explicit optimization to unlock the full crosslingual potential of LLMs. Our
code is publicly available at
https://github.com/google-research/crosslingual-knowledge-barriers. | [
-0.3774853050708771,
-0.6704919338226318,
0.5115565657615662,
0.32589295506477356,
0.1353873908519745,
0.2693808376789093,
-0.5149006843566895,
-0.749908447265625,
-0.23888814449310303,
0.3103858530521393,
-0.6146087646484375,
-0.3423437476158142,
-0.5924226641654968,
0.08792119473218918,
-0.08209019154310226,
0.6931052207946777,
-0.3862423896789551,
0.16401320695877075,
-0.6558085083961487,
-0.28088194131851196,
-0.36736446619033813,
-0.6361367106437683,
-0.19674360752105713,
-0.287967711687088,
0.6360379457473755,
0.2829282581806183,
0.6037916541099548,
0.32616788148880005,
0.3503083288669586,
0.20499683916568756,
-0.023862700909376144,
0.19366855919361115,
-0.4385138750076294,
0.15731661021709442,
-0.3983542323112488,
-0.4730602502822876,
-0.23496243357658386,
-0.2523398697376251,
0.7545011043548584,
1.1067941188812256,
0.24933655560016632,
-0.03143797069787979,
0.16125299036502838,
0.446296751499176,
-0.7424265146255493,
0.15028682351112366,
-0.6037628650665283,
0.2530643343925476,
-0.45003587007522583,
0.07055898755788803,
-0.21034303307533264,
0.17618903517723083,
0.14960604906082153,
-0.787480354309082,
0.087407186627388,
0.1442481279373169,
0.4090115427970886,
0.1618800014257431,
-0.6191011667251587,
-0.3733133375644684,
-0.7319402098655701,
0.873737633228302,
-0.5778040289878845,
0.8877646923065186,
0.3322785794734955,
0.2532290518283844,
0.11372943967580795,
-0.4692806601524353,
-0.3546123504638672,
-0.31172022223472595,
0.10024749487638474,
-0.12885285913944244,
-0.24116705358028412,
-0.42778345942497253,
0.2544371783733368,
0.006961813196539879,
-0.5916187763214111,
0.5223687887191772,
-0.3623076379299164,
-0.23495244979858398,
0.6188100576400757,
0.19990742206573486,
0.3628271222114563,
0.16041886806488037,
-0.22119252383708954,
-0.0034536870662122965,
-0.9406210780143738,
0.05113745480775833,
0.3936379551887512,
0.3272755444049835,
-0.26243826746940613,
0.6728461980819702,
-0.044524699449539185,
0.4872196912765503,
-0.29664677381515503,
-0.27480652928352356,
0.22730907797813416,
-0.4854704439640045,
0.18465164303779602,
-0.2592192590236664,
0.5190750360488892,
0.2215479016304016,
0.546912670135498,
-0.37757763266563416,
-0.10342792421579361,
-0.22237804532051086,
-0.15603190660476685,
-0.5596117377281189,
-0.0075338250026106834,
-0.010133550502359867,
-0.034055810421705246,
0.31225043535232544,
-0.3996351957321167,
-0.5189005136489868,
-0.32913365960121155,
-0.26473087072372437,
0.2822765111923218,
-0.28687360882759094,
-0.3091042637825012,
0.033548589795827866,
0.1193818524479866,
-0.10783569514751434,
0.3769918382167816,
-0.8208856582641602,
0.10879074782133102,
0.5620733499526978,
0.6161704063415527,
-0.35110583901405334,
-0.747264564037323,
-0.2766653895378113,
0.37928563356399536,
-0.2502283751964569,
0.5462705492973328,
-0.6217984557151794,
-0.4020645320415497,
0.12328507006168365,
0.12120478600263596,
-0.4449400305747986,
-0.46302446722984314,
0.0997973084449768,
-0.40576860308647156,
0.09612005203962326,
-0.36571693420410156,
-0.5762760043144226,
0.015067638829350471,
0.37443438172340393,
-0.6845414638519287,
0.7570391297340393,
-0.1839366853237152,
-0.7238329648971558,
0.28077617287635803,
-0.2830086052417755,
-0.6857139468193054,
-0.16219764947891235,
0.01232906524091959,
-0.029998142272233963,
-0.03079737350344658,
0.30714699625968933,
0.46956560015678406,
-0.42624586820602417,
0.1351277232170105,
-0.579072892665863,
0.09691095352172852,
0.27250272035598755,
-0.3833177387714386,
0.6181150078773499,
0.16649089753627777,
-0.20625923573970795,
0.0807998776435852,
-0.6600409746170044,
-0.11961150914430618,
0.1875058114528656,
-0.26392465829849243,
-0.5071302652359009,
-0.17856016755104065,
0.21731241047382355,
0.48342165350914,
0.4102324843406677,
-0.36252763867378235,
0.028789306059479713,
0.05606590583920479,
0.3268449306488037,
0.5111657977104187,
-0.40453270077705383,
0.5660145878791809,
-0.21425144374370575,
0.7255237698554993,
0.045011065900325775,
0.07272014021873474,
0.16615928709506989,
-0.5154610276222229,
-0.5765026211738586,
0.011870366521179676,
0.33780643343925476,
0.6523528099060059,
-0.9929037094116211,
-0.002274684375151992,
-0.2061663419008255,
-0.44945162534713745,
-0.27027031779289246,
0.4985802471637726,
0.42486000061035156,
0.20956112444400787,
0.22199788689613342,
0.00033887484460137784,
-0.07351703196763992,
-0.8653128743171692,
-0.33006420731544495,
0.0067673963494598866,
0.06705699861049652,
0.24760551750659943,
0.6373113989830017,
-0.2501172721385956,
0.46610990166664124,
-0.14123858511447906,
-0.2815209925174713,
-0.2976837754249573,
-0.2434314787387848,
-0.14063796401023865,
0.36768946051597595,
0.4926169812679291,
-0.7953729629516602,
-0.7267756462097168,
0.4418962895870209,
-0.7047282457351685,
-0.24332290887832642,
0.09746142476797104,
0.17103487253189087,
0.3397054374217987,
0.7528778314590454,
-0.5792653560638428,
0.21581637859344482,
0.8277904987335205,
-0.18663008511066437,
0.496103435754776,
-0.36103588342666626,
0.008617809973657131,
-0.8780546188354492,
0.03916483372449875,
0.095436230301857,
-0.0670824944972992,
-0.6768742203712463,
0.1748819798231125,
0.14636921882629395,
-0.024554405361413956,
-0.5717014670372009,
0.8364214301109314,
-0.6902199387550354,
-0.17978708446025848,
-0.09134753048419952,
0.28687191009521484,
0.007348196115344763,
0.3511887788772583,
0.09546434134244919,
0.6322154998779297,
0.3936242461204529,
-0.42071613669395447,
0.28331974148750305,
0.0875425934791565,
-0.42691799998283386,
0.5477940440177917,
-0.36447909474372864,
0.14988736808300018,
0.19521303474903107,
0.08434148877859116,
-0.7660968899726868,
0.009485661052167416,
0.13614267110824585,
-0.19923236966133118,
0.37991881370544434,
-0.09539084136486053,
-0.5572797656059265,
-0.18240061402320862,
-0.04508988931775093,
0.7709362506866455,
0.011516708880662918,
-0.4260336756706238,
0.4806348979473114,
0.3515184819698334,
-0.4174033999443054,
-0.5830038785934448,
-0.7882785797119141,
0.22216957807540894,
-0.1360694169998169,
-0.7942408323287964,
0.38287726044654846,
-0.1779380887746811,
-0.3346320688724518,
0.0671897605061531,
0.1079985648393631,
0.049305208027362823,
0.14729011058807373,
-0.047165147960186005,
-0.11728009581565857,
-0.12763522565364838,
0.11815067380666733,
0.13420742750167847,
0.13214488327503204,
0.17301064729690552,
-0.22045429050922394,
0.41750431060791016,
-0.08705727756023407,
-0.7707658410072327,
0.17574375867843628,
0.41635966300964355,
0.517173707485199,
-0.2967955768108368,
0.7501929998397827,
0.8064695596694946,
-0.47345486283302307,
-0.368569016456604,
-0.5635093450546265,
0.12536023557186127,
-0.3770597279071808,
0.6675365567207336,
-0.8140624165534973,
-1.2027052640914917,
0.8053126931190491,
0.08881639689207077,
0.12902992963790894,
0.3492375910282135,
0.7415158748626709,
0.20255650579929352,
0.8366519808769226,
0.7105053067207336,
-0.04542601853609085,
0.18924172222614288,
0.0448855496942997,
0.2008233368396759,
-0.750268816947937,
-0.43225210905075073,
-0.49841076135635376,
-0.13344880938529968,
-0.593289315700531,
-0.719152569770813,
0.29165953397750854,
0.076602041721344,
0.036216333508491516,
0.047054704278707504,
0.20992913842201233,
0.2476186454296112,
0.4080612361431122,
-0.2971242368221283,
0.464466392993927,
0.0740048959851265,
-0.3153700530529022,
-0.25814536213874817,
-1.0691146850585938,
-0.08843616396188736,
1.0465401411056519,
0.4273529052734375,
0.9692417979240417,
0.21581357717514038,
0.2384360283613205,
0.11975912004709244,
0.10339637845754623,
-0.5332252383232117,
0.34894922375679016,
-0.26483893394470215,
-0.7544899582862854,
-0.4307434558868408,
-0.6800733208656311,
-0.8443149924278259,
0.34608516097068787,
-0.2690024971961975,
-0.6493237614631653,
0.13364355266094208,
-0.17227159440517426,
0.009259825572371483,
0.4741421043872833,
-0.5430647134780884,
0.9063741564750671,
-0.5716371536254883,
-0.6278762221336365,
-0.29974475502967834,
-0.5054457187652588,
0.2662528455257416,
-0.5129085779190063,
0.518274188041687,
-0.2559467554092407,
-0.12441270798444748,
0.6282750368118286,
-0.05393645539879799,
0.9008436799049377,
0.045319732278585434,
-0.5863908529281616,
-0.11306459456682205,
0.15383504331111908,
0.2663699686527252,
-0.04453551769256592,
0.19654521346092224,
0.4220620095729828,
0.08548370748758316,
-0.46610769629478455,
-0.4134274423122406,
0.736411988735199,
-0.6900748610496521,
-0.6866726279258728,
-0.25965115427970886,
-1.0738049745559692,
-0.6561852693557739,
0.1812189668416977,
0.16542446613311768,
0.15630829334259033,
-0.3467596769332886,
0.08694326877593994,
0.539013683795929,
-0.5541543960571289,
0.35476961731910706,
0.6543672680854797,
-0.42985963821411133,
-0.2909209728240967,
0.9554160833358765,
0.34126946330070496,
0.5469526052474976,
0.5755687952041626,
0.0045530120842158794,
-0.4103391766548157,
-0.7274959087371826,
-0.47025370597839355,
0.35075733065605164,
-0.8225725293159485,
0.18294279277324677,
-0.6074610948562622,
-0.1430661529302597,
-0.6679985523223877,
-0.01852433942258358,
-0.3716130554676056,
-0.447019100189209,
-0.17794053256511688,
0.09018415212631226,
0.09145190566778183,
0.7976832389831543,
-0.12320753931999207,
0.01587485335767269,
-0.8587343692779541,
0.30660879611968994,
0.24738915264606476,
0.17748184502124786,
0.07247631996870041,
-0.547593891620636,
-0.6765835881233215,
0.08344659954309464,
-0.011930282227694988,
-0.38894325494766235,
0.36445921659469604,
0.22061817348003387,
0.7640607953071594,
0.13026373088359833,
-0.06994608044624329,
0.5803502798080444,
-0.6181037425994873,
0.4956425428390503,
0.25598353147506714,
-0.8757660388946533,
-0.06023654341697693,
-0.2737019956111908,
0.45829346776008606,
0.21164637804031372,
0.5233445763587952,
-0.7538881897926331,
-0.3630794286727905,
-0.19333414733409882,
-0.7632085084915161,
0.40399736166000366,
0.029402628540992737,
-0.05302746221423149,
0.35336610674858093,
-0.06403987109661102,
0.3179921805858612,
0.12071205675601959,
-0.7968792915344238,
-0.013899742625653744,
0.13910870254039764,
0.045504018664360046,
-0.4022957980632782,
0.0037420878652483225,
-0.189072847366333,
-0.25971367955207825,
0.45700886845588684,
-0.29437536001205444,
-0.18282786011695862,
-0.033105671405792236,
-0.6609067320823669,
-0.2269110083580017,
0.2967304289340973,
0.6722476482391357,
1.0379244089126587,
0.14046449959278107,
0.09851623326539993,
0.49660706520080566,
-0.2462155967950821,
0.11809074878692627,
0.3483014702796936,
0.14096343517303467,
-0.2385602593421936,
0.7817540168762207,
0.8583664894104004,
0.2741241157054901,
-0.6341171860694885,
0.21323856711387634,
-0.0487578809261322,
-0.2863902449607849,
-0.20216655731201172,
-0.15298762917518616,
0.41843754053115845,
0.5726445913314819,
0.2533123791217804,
-0.30025961995124817,
-0.20675908029079437,
-0.5967921018600464,
-0.13551293313503265,
0.5439334511756897,
-0.11268671602010727,
-0.36343899369239807,
0.7934989929199219,
0.17166806757450104,
-0.10094810277223587,
0.3465946614742279,
0.1698049008846283,
-0.5059993267059326,
0.4779551327228546,
0.48846009373664856,
0.5566741824150085,
-0.16261553764343262,
-0.005690963007509708,
-0.21546150743961334,
0.6340473294258118,
0.1256440132856369,
-0.017259789630770683,
0.0525304451584816,
-0.9567311406135559,
-0.6724152565002441,
-0.5026764869689941,
-0.5531442761421204,
0.04134158417582512,
-0.3899461627006531,
0.012103240936994553,
-0.3303334712982178,
0.03445914015173912,
0.009481730870902538,
0.0631144642829895,
-0.7912428379058838,
0.03682401403784752,
0.45878347754478455,
0.9400052428245544,
-0.7905659675598145,
1.011025071144104,
0.598246693611145,
0.03495439514517784,
-0.44663724303245544,
-0.17774982750415802,
-0.06970477104187012,
-0.8302517533302307,
0.5950306057929993,
0.06711552292108536,
-0.06406565010547638,
-0.2249414324760437,
-0.034012094140052795,
-0.6638082265853882,
0.8662766218185425,
0.581985354423523,
-0.8580368161201477,
-0.158431276679039,
0.8236625790596008,
0.5292856097221375,
-0.4185587465763092,
-0.02913348190486431,
0.5335185527801514,
0.6632457971572876,
-0.2539675831794739,
-1.2073230743408203,
-0.0021047003101557493,
-0.32023730874061584,
-0.0267633106559515,
-0.01391056552529335,
-0.5750777125358582,
0.7523370981216431,
-0.11218114197254181,
0.10446619242429733,
-0.0447608046233654,
0.5518866777420044,
0.2658575773239136,
0.557343602180481,
0.543446958065033,
0.6624009609222412,
0.6469714045524597,
0.07025966048240662,
0.9735466837882996,
-0.2507757544517517,
0.06824349611997604,
0.9144812822341919,
-0.720263659954071,
0.6263282299041748,
0.5257866978645325,
-0.12752671539783478,
0.09619688987731934,
0.6053345799446106,
0.0888362005352974,
0.2737281322479248,
0.1274818778038025,
-0.1589784473180771,
-0.3635994791984558,
-0.15627115964889526,
-0.5813468098640442,
0.24447469413280487,
0.5075533986091614,
-0.0374051108956337,
-0.13569240272045135,
0.38867828249931335,
0.021132588386535645,
-0.080360546708107,
-0.32029321789741516,
0.4903998076915741,
0.348252534866333,
-0.4737178385257721,
0.6403356194496155,
0.04685760661959648,
0.6664147973060608,
-0.6130533218383789,
0.21810662746429443,
-0.29531997442245483,
0.1764463186264038,
-0.08901404589414597,
-0.8274965286254883,
0.1198706179857254,
-0.05355475842952728,
-0.14733396470546722,
-0.36039647459983826,
0.6816851496696472,
-0.8494443893432617,
-0.5878952741622925,
0.8616370558738708,
1.0399402379989624,
-0.039104968309402466,
-0.08178882300853729,
-0.8062934279441833,
0.11850027740001678,
-0.012515680864453316,
-0.22485090792179108,
0.5814992785453796,
0.6672036647796631,
-0.4688708484172821,
0.8353477716445923,
0.6372911930084229,
0.14903220534324646,
0.33848491311073303,
0.4404376745223999,
0.7049722671508789,
-0.6915585994720459,
-0.36777186393737793,
-0.6760128736495972,
0.1809924691915512,
0.2473633587360382,
-0.3231978118419647,
0.9801891446113586,
0.49046599864959717,
1.2331572771072388,
-0.056557659059762955,
0.7927036285400391,
0.12887704372406006,
0.3640044629573822,
-0.7244176864624023,
0.840950608253479,
-0.8905397057533264,
0.20102107524871826,
-0.21591515839099884,
-1.055452823638916,
-0.28317686915397644,
0.058241669088602066,
-0.48608890175819397,
0.13123346865177155,
0.7562888860702515,
0.6445711851119995,
-0.21311764419078827,
-0.2762259840965271,
0.5612851977348328,
0.009650957770645618,
0.15713785588741302,
0.9056951999664307,
1.1365052461624146,
-0.01924356073141098,
0.6140908598899841,
-0.3883619010448456,
0.13673940300941467,
-0.0706009492278099,
-0.6920656561851501,
-1.0826048851013184,
-0.4968283474445343,
-0.2559162676334381,
-0.09499160200357437,
0.20085032284259796,
0.4306522011756897,
0.5644398331642151,
-0.7169110774993896,
-0.529898464679718,
0.2956806719303131,
0.24090568721294403,
0.0684109702706337,
-0.11288849264383316,
0.12770767509937286,
-0.18980590999126434,
-0.8290283679962158,
0.5556330680847168,
0.10233040899038315,
0.009763520210981369,
-0.4210439622402191,
-0.25560706853866577,
-0.23324742913246155,
-0.17378279566764832,
0.6786578297615051,
0.28353628516197205,
-0.6095359921455383,
-0.19636841118335724,
0.1617766171693802,
-0.10352324694395065,
-0.13989141583442688,
0.9092196822166443,
-0.22715753316879272,
0.1605840027332306,
0.4523050785064697,
0.8693253993988037,
0.7562974095344543,
-0.5839248895645142,
0.6402651071548462,
-0.6494676470756531,
0.22719937562942505,
0.19040116667747498,
0.5658101439476013,
0.5792801380157471,
-0.08679848164319992,
0.397737592458725,
0.3194650411605835,
-0.3795011639595032,
-0.7480116486549377,
0.14018453657627106,
-0.5792956352233887,
-0.5932352542877197,
1.2709479331970215,
-0.22171863913536072,
-0.1847703903913498,
-0.13644342124462128,
0.2155848741531372,
0.20804740488529205,
0.13227349519729614,
0.39244747161865234,
0.923206090927124,
0.13248564302921295,
-0.3543277680873871,
-0.7012000679969788,
0.2032002955675125,
0.6359983682632446,
-0.8843533992767334,
0.16566558182239532,
0.4295039474964142,
0.38267549872398376,
0.1576625108718872,
0.2010015994310379,
0.03479904681444168,
0.14078880846500397,
-0.03381044790148735,
0.10899783670902252,
-0.17898456752300262,
-0.5985262393951416,
-0.3301084339618683,
0.05931477248668671,
0.053534943610429764,
0.277766615152359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16120v1 | Contextualized End-to-end Automatic Speech Recognition with Intermediate Biasing Loss | 2024-06-23T14:22:59 | 2024-06-23T14:22:59 | Muhammad Shakeel, Yui Sudo, Yifan Peng, Shinji Watanabe | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Contextualized end-to-end automatic speech recognition has been an active
research area, with recent efforts focusing on the implicit learning of
contextual phrases based on the final loss objective. However, these approaches
ignore the useful contextual knowledge encoded in the intermediate layers. We
hypothesize that employing explicit biasing loss as an auxiliary task in the
encoder intermediate layers may better align text tokens or audio frames with
the desired objectives. Our proposed intermediate biasing loss brings more
regularization and contextualization to the network. Our method outperforms a
conventional contextual biasing baseline on the LibriSpeech corpus, achieving a
relative improvement of 22.5% in biased word error rate (B-WER) and up to 44%
compared to the non-contextual baseline with a biasing list size of 100.
Moreover, employing RNN-transducer-driven joint decoding further reduces the
unbiased word error rate (U-WER), resulting in a more robust network. | [
-0.31935128569602966,
-0.5827124118804932,
0.2642606198787689,
0.03455165773630142,
-0.3823423683643341,
-0.24670103192329407,
-0.3922595977783203,
-0.2731102406978607,
0.09220420569181442,
0.2996372878551483,
-0.48510679602622986,
-0.2851670980453491,
-0.6463975310325623,
0.061965543776750565,
-0.6256881356239319,
0.9041374921798706,
-0.15555554628372192,
0.30717405676841736,
-0.08320827782154083,
-0.33240005373954773,
-0.6373610496520996,
-0.3503393828868866,
-1.0655908584594727,
-0.3820157051086426,
0.4140225946903229,
0.2987653613090515,
0.44524073600769043,
0.7577939033508301,
0.1535804122686386,
0.20243024826049805,
-0.29149678349494934,
-0.03748655691742897,
-0.2746541500091553,
0.07224752753973007,
-0.22286464273929596,
-0.18524086475372314,
-0.29813817143440247,
-0.1421431452035904,
0.6860935688018799,
0.8397460579872131,
-0.12092243880033493,
0.17240114510059357,
0.21577784419059753,
0.9643712043762207,
-0.8599311113357544,
-0.009490769356489182,
-0.5550508499145508,
0.1862378567457199,
-0.21561603248119354,
-0.35390540957450867,
-0.4849783480167389,
0.22370599210262299,
0.46300622820854187,
-0.41090330481529236,
0.04634813964366913,
0.13641716539859772,
0.716147243976593,
0.7177491188049316,
-0.43704304099082947,
-0.2957371771335602,
-0.6852846741676331,
0.3194452226161957,
-0.638798177242279,
0.6404352188110352,
0.4271906912326813,
0.31299084424972534,
0.17006291449069977,
-0.5402483940124512,
-0.5682189464569092,
-0.018708890303969383,
0.129680335521698,
0.5154334306716919,
-0.23483502864837646,
0.24736104905605316,
0.20321263372898102,
0.009516164660453796,
-0.45889997482299805,
-0.016796935349702835,
-0.1699507236480713,
-0.4026380777359009,
0.2391965389251709,
-0.21818237006664276,
0.18177583813667297,
0.34819167852401733,
-0.3010272681713104,
-0.05132286623120308,
-0.5321216583251953,
0.1272994577884674,
0.4470801055431366,
0.2582155168056488,
-0.11194393038749695,
0.39038991928100586,
-0.20297472178936005,
0.8045613169670105,
0.35740575194358826,
0.19008494913578033,
0.299454003572464,
-0.29934701323509216,
-0.23019985854625702,
0.6599191427230835,
0.3549911081790924,
0.7723158597946167,
0.13658924400806427,
-0.2713921070098877,
-0.21949923038482666,
-0.054856568574905396,
-0.003733942983672023,
-0.48270052671432495,
-0.005872816778719425,
0.17260323464870453,
-0.31652840971946716,
0.207829549908638,
-0.013608038425445557,
-0.07085725665092468,
0.012820256873965263,
-0.5344229340553284,
0.4477967619895935,
-0.24148182570934296,
0.16595180332660675,
-0.06933344900608063,
-0.26914912462234497,
0.36488077044487,
0.29880812764167786,
-0.48055529594421387,
0.47960978746414185,
0.20760130882263184,
1.0337785482406616,
-0.08916284143924713,
0.03832688182592392,
-0.5614283084869385,
0.5918006300926208,
-0.4225626587867737,
0.5160965323448181,
-0.31317657232284546,
-0.264309823513031,
-0.06656096875667572,
0.04931102320551872,
0.01063650380820036,
-0.4153940677642822,
0.858647882938385,
-0.5248807072639465,
0.3842780590057373,
-0.24254728853702545,
-0.6548462510108948,
-0.13830694556236267,
0.07012470811605453,
-0.4567132592201233,
0.7160230278968811,
-0.2288159728050232,
-0.7573725581169128,
0.42563554644584656,
-0.2868647873401642,
-0.4897719621658325,
-0.31978893280029297,
-0.27315792441368103,
-0.4845031797885895,
0.03121212311089039,
0.35020795464515686,
0.288979172706604,
-0.21909156441688538,
0.23428793251514435,
-0.034419745206832886,
-0.43134039640426636,
0.08293640613555908,
-0.6727637648582458,
0.7369298934936523,
-0.056591518223285675,
-0.7191480994224548,
-0.02882656641304493,
-0.6482817530632019,
-0.12537217140197754,
-0.08721614629030228,
-0.381099671125412,
-0.55748051404953,
0.014941140078008175,
0.2710321545600891,
0.272897869348526,
0.07962372899055481,
-0.5843139290809631,
-0.32271286845207214,
-0.5205315947532654,
0.20840415358543396,
0.8560708165168762,
-0.20066189765930176,
0.9061984419822693,
-0.21563786268234253,
-0.00167398143094033,
0.1083802878856659,
0.06602741777896881,
-0.08699698746204376,
-0.3791709244251251,
-1.037007451057434,
0.09855044633150101,
0.39305803179740906,
0.6350252032279968,
-0.5807725787162781,
0.8611056208610535,
-0.25921866297721863,
0.12673580646514893,
-0.33591848611831665,
-0.13075459003448486,
0.8135403394699097,
1.2446287870407104,
0.4061316251754761,
-0.4789290428161621,
-0.6849981546401978,
-1.2308279275894165,
-0.2698747217655182,
0.05866320803761482,
-0.2633163034915924,
0.48056599497795105,
0.0665680468082428,
-0.35695838928222656,
0.9304653406143188,
-0.0760587528347969,
-0.8529095649719238,
0.02724441885948181,
-0.2435240000486374,
0.28355205059051514,
0.6163567900657654,
0.2339925765991211,
-0.5753070712089539,
-0.6682835221290588,
0.041896600276231766,
-0.2771851122379303,
-0.21803472936153412,
-0.12694309651851654,
-0.2916606664657593,
0.1647905856370926,
0.552442193031311,
-0.2629863917827606,
0.44752854108810425,
0.35138607025146484,
-0.25124984979629517,
0.25605684518814087,
-0.22555780410766602,
-0.3550010621547699,
-0.985103964805603,
-0.04306646063923836,
0.08615080267190933,
-0.278653621673584,
-0.9059572815895081,
-0.6406195163726807,
0.01587619073688984,
0.3351491391658783,
-0.24118705093860626,
0.3902275264263153,
-0.6383106112480164,
-0.37665486335754395,
-0.42489194869995117,
0.1928819864988327,
0.2269129604101181,
0.43365269899368286,
0.21441739797592163,
0.9283601641654968,
0.5830084085464478,
-0.44393736124038696,
0.12003853172063828,
0.07763981074094772,
0.2676219046115875,
0.5119379758834839,
-0.7344065308570862,
0.3152520954608917,
-0.3863195478916168,
0.8576458692550659,
-0.654958188533783,
-0.1643553078174591,
0.082572340965271,
-0.6203328371047974,
0.5813320279121399,
-0.20959770679473877,
-0.002064209198579192,
0.099395252764225,
-0.22255517542362213,
0.48096123337745667,
0.5273110270500183,
-0.5022339820861816,
0.4981716573238373,
0.49361780285835266,
0.026174385100603104,
-0.7893680930137634,
-0.8160883188247681,
0.2600136697292328,
-0.16213425993919373,
-0.4725331962108612,
0.7530655264854431,
0.08660551905632019,
0.15367212891578674,
-0.05332361161708832,
-0.43309125304222107,
0.05599888786673546,
-0.42676421999931335,
-0.004578934982419014,
-0.1319371610879898,
-0.13917548954486847,
-0.016311263665556908,
0.22676819562911987,
-0.33726730942726135,
0.22704298794269562,
-0.7605982422828674,
0.4503210186958313,
-0.05578883737325668,
-0.3213419020175934,
-0.6354365348815918,
0.32284730672836304,
0.05592050403356552,
0.09813137352466583,
0.5368788242340088,
0.9692431688308716,
-0.6943466067314148,
-0.19652065634727478,
-0.5804975628852844,
-0.0644432008266449,
-0.4036535322666168,
0.4405968487262726,
-0.17033207416534424,
-0.6805518865585327,
0.6279923915863037,
0.21024107933044434,
-0.13461071252822876,
0.32487747073173523,
0.47472232580184937,
-0.24559937417507172,
0.9839951395988464,
0.4466376006603241,
-0.39380595088005066,
0.5465973019599915,
-0.36250683665275574,
-0.020355887711048126,
-1.3960672616958618,
-0.2192593216896057,
-0.3294994533061981,
-0.33494237065315247,
-0.2519407868385315,
-0.3108505606651306,
0.5636445879936218,
0.0376058965921402,
-0.34972044825553894,
0.0733494758605957,
-0.7318664193153381,
0.36731505393981934,
0.7740708589553833,
0.4904494285583496,
-0.08676165342330933,
0.007271985057741404,
0.0013318458804860711,
0.20495228469371796,
-0.7098996043205261,
-0.3137660026550293,
1.1549631357192993,
0.36136603355407715,
0.4754911959171295,
0.20859135687351227,
0.589314341545105,
0.40394699573516846,
0.033396948128938675,
-0.5421032905578613,
0.19432485103607178,
-0.1447707563638687,
-0.39501479268074036,
-0.6462350487709045,
-0.25673961639404297,
-0.41129446029663086,
0.15388886630535126,
0.3060950040817261,
-0.5223681926727295,
0.5079956650733948,
0.41488268971443176,
-0.3428753614425659,
0.09117136895656586,
-0.6197564005851746,
0.4985963702201843,
-0.012275626882910728,
-0.6019478440284729,
0.25704339146614075,
-1.1137535572052002,
0.0958438515663147,
0.1961638182401657,
0.23066088557243347,
0.01493594516068697,
-0.32168611884117126,
1.0670655965805054,
-0.5818544626235962,
0.7397704720497131,
-0.5525512099266052,
0.023637786507606506,
0.16666342318058014,
-0.3462296426296234,
0.6439997553825378,
0.09009116142988205,
-0.01055071596056223,
-0.01974409632384777,
-0.40893176198005676,
-0.38946089148521423,
-0.6256699562072754,
0.508795976638794,
-0.7215441465377808,
-0.3903682231903076,
-0.4218626916408539,
-0.3459217846393585,
-0.30319660902023315,
0.06190380081534386,
0.4948176145553589,
0.7914095520973206,
0.1045091301202774,
0.1774892657995224,
0.8638594150543213,
0.03818032890558243,
0.5652171969413757,
0.28662654757499695,
0.4141475558280945,
-0.3121952712535858,
0.8134019374847412,
0.09190388023853302,
0.23152147233486176,
0.3730260729789734,
0.2658558487892151,
-0.512394905090332,
-0.6821227073669434,
-0.8102163076400757,
-0.17126038670539856,
-0.7301110625267029,
-0.15207789838314056,
-0.5480586290359497,
-0.3140758275985718,
-0.3517950773239136,
-0.2970004975795746,
-0.4855513274669647,
-0.22868698835372925,
-0.4268301725387573,
-0.04630386084318161,
0.05905258655548096,
0.13771158456802368,
-0.022645242512226105,
0.5868744254112244,
-0.4034867286682129,
0.0590837299823761,
0.06751497089862823,
0.12396437674760818,
-0.10001509636640549,
-1.10625159740448,
-0.4285009205341339,
0.0627608671784401,
0.21367903053760529,
-0.9121726751327515,
0.2966170310974121,
0.7572715878486633,
0.4149320423603058,
0.6302355527877808,
0.14415937662124634,
0.7967352271080017,
-0.8373581767082214,
0.4418398141860962,
0.3759213387966156,
-0.9676733016967773,
0.4379782974720001,
-0.2489187866449356,
0.6443341374397278,
0.6956800818443298,
0.09708639979362488,
-0.5240711569786072,
-0.033010419458150864,
-0.26969119906425476,
-1.1044948101043701,
0.6882569193840027,
0.2965333163738251,
0.24692896008491516,
0.22202277183532715,
0.3983302712440491,
-0.1371014565229416,
0.015630511566996574,
-0.7210162281990051,
-0.38876742124557495,
-0.15464487671852112,
-0.2895216643810272,
-0.0008345689857378602,
-0.26953956484794617,
-0.4014362096786499,
-0.3729195296764374,
0.7414953708648682,
-0.30071452260017395,
0.33728429675102234,
0.7552071213722229,
-0.3539775311946869,
-0.08387592434883118,
0.18814314901828766,
0.6314482092857361,
0.3630307614803314,
-0.23703999817371368,
0.2713845670223236,
0.4153708219528198,
-0.41420572996139526,
0.16363336145877838,
0.19011147320270538,
-0.5413286685943604,
0.26468366384506226,
0.4806848168373108,
0.996444046497345,
0.13256938755512238,
-0.4541454017162323,
0.7296959757804871,
-0.056133102625608444,
0.08818842470645905,
-0.7654451131820679,
-0.30725041031837463,
-0.19118370115756989,
0.0036096442490816116,
0.5959941744804382,
0.2655419409275055,
0.7078893184661865,
-0.36196169257164,
0.3673684597015381,
0.34438377618789673,
-0.770722508430481,
-0.09059470146894455,
0.6690249443054199,
0.28029632568359375,
-0.12806513905525208,
0.27466318011283875,
-0.0031616888009011745,
-0.5120099186897278,
0.5566121339797974,
0.5696836709976196,
1.059516191482544,
-0.38056060671806335,
-0.25879189372062683,
0.14820453524589539,
0.28198209404945374,
0.11428341269493103,
-0.13767170906066895,
-0.3514311611652374,
-0.6233689785003662,
-0.3772958219051361,
-0.5588961839675903,
-0.3768042325973511,
-0.3023334741592407,
-0.6630064249038696,
0.1523948758840561,
-0.2057325392961502,
-0.3046817481517792,
-0.24881073832511902,
-0.4751899540424347,
-0.42294466495513916,
0.5472056269645691,
0.11436467617750168,
0.6759545803070068,
-0.5286609530448914,
0.7287204265594482,
0.6351038813591003,
-0.24392172694206238,
-0.48994097113609314,
0.1604016274213791,
0.025004412978887558,
-0.5213866829872131,
0.6291639804840088,
0.3014552891254425,
-0.3341943025588989,
-0.02942144311964512,
-0.22995026409626007,
-1.0097131729125977,
1.2255003452301025,
0.16833500564098358,
-0.7749386429786682,
-0.3139866590499878,
0.1286485195159912,
0.33617958426475525,
-0.6263413429260254,
0.5886911153793335,
0.4362189471721649,
0.2735947072505951,
-0.015163281001150608,
-1.062231421470642,
0.01790825091302395,
-0.22644013166427612,
0.24989192187786102,
-0.18504048883914948,
-0.5172207355499268,
0.7318934798240662,
0.1785321682691574,
-0.20823423564434052,
-0.6140782237052917,
0.8550309538841248,
-0.1646295189857483,
0.5379546880722046,
0.6921669840812683,
0.31723132729530334,
0.2001156061887741,
-0.14611399173736572,
0.7262717485427856,
-0.4706363081932068,
-0.16435949504375458,
1.2633397579193115,
-0.21583490073680878,
0.6351200342178345,
0.5062924027442932,
0.019361499696969986,
0.22847454249858856,
0.6947250962257385,
0.7653859853744507,
0.7824415564537048,
0.12287154793739319,
-0.404527485370636,
0.10184744745492935,
-0.23159019649028778,
-0.4361627399921417,
0.41253748536109924,
0.3693564236164093,
-0.38607552647590637,
-0.06278027594089508,
0.15026050806045532,
-0.02102030999958515,
0.022819584235548973,
-0.31449541449546814,
0.9992828369140625,
0.182287335395813,
-0.2884289026260376,
0.5038481950759888,
-0.08967820554971695,
0.7914790511131287,
-0.3860812187194824,
0.08438051491975784,
-0.20725850760936737,
0.16042324900627136,
-0.21862870454788208,
-0.40771764516830444,
0.43999576568603516,
-0.1964445412158966,
-0.372388631105423,
-0.22586709260940552,
0.7529541850090027,
-0.5469134449958801,
-0.26451539993286133,
0.4729430377483368,
0.31293806433677673,
0.06016606092453003,
-0.09280518442392349,
-0.641180157661438,
0.24779006838798523,
-0.1671341508626938,
-0.3475252687931061,
0.3412933051586151,
0.16969282925128937,
0.023362185806035995,
0.5387173891067505,
0.6458662748336792,
-0.09066171944141388,
0.19757884740829468,
0.5186989903450012,
1.0404874086380005,
-0.28029727935791016,
-0.7616578936576843,
-0.6313989162445068,
0.497562438249588,
-0.36748889088630676,
-0.13811524212360382,
0.6821216344833374,
0.6878842115402222,
1.0182271003723145,
0.252267062664032,
0.7651478052139282,
0.11821666359901428,
0.4776327311992645,
-0.6751787662506104,
0.6654772758483887,
-0.35680416226387024,
0.41066762804985046,
-0.2504805028438568,
-0.9577098488807678,
-0.2344532459974289,
0.4260037839412689,
0.02766352891921997,
0.2260754108428955,
0.3897918462753296,
0.4564604163169861,
-0.007170721888542175,
-0.22600935399532318,
0.4164353907108307,
0.04000303894281387,
0.10163521766662598,
0.474730908870697,
0.359622061252594,
-0.6406111121177673,
0.3527531623840332,
-0.5097982883453369,
-0.5852099061012268,
-0.11707985401153564,
-0.5583629608154297,
-0.7806807160377502,
-0.6903611421585083,
-0.1657017320394516,
-0.35865646600723267,
0.671103835105896,
0.7320688962936401,
0.7666645050048828,
-0.7594735622406006,
-0.23626580834388733,
-0.2535831928253174,
-0.19598980247974396,
0.051505330950021744,
-0.17904043197631836,
0.631000280380249,
-0.2734840214252472,
-0.6545007228851318,
0.48481813073158264,
0.23758752644062042,
-0.15860986709594727,
-0.14812986552715302,
-0.48470985889434814,
-0.19811421632766724,
-0.06907088309526443,
0.6024547815322876,
0.16371940076351166,
-0.7868940234184265,
-0.4385168254375458,
-0.07414330542087555,
0.21252644062042236,
-0.15222422778606415,
0.5545818209648132,
-0.6498968601226807,
0.4620300531387329,
0.3125019073486328,
0.7362333536148071,
0.38527712225914,
0.10833557695150375,
0.6999795436859131,
-0.8465574383735657,
0.2917425334453583,
0.2521391808986664,
0.4798273742198944,
0.31707748770713806,
-0.31165918707847595,
0.3740721046924591,
0.14629113674163818,
-0.5910764336585999,
-0.7181096076965332,
0.08249010890722275,
-0.990180253982544,
0.03650413081049919,
0.9508865475654602,
-0.004171451088041067,
-0.44291001558303833,
-0.158521369099617,
-0.4055187404155731,
0.6298858523368835,
-0.6848088502883911,
0.36896371841430664,
0.3257328271865845,
-0.377252995967865,
-0.32544001936912537,
-0.44719773530960083,
0.602424144744873,
0.6416866779327393,
-0.4809859097003937,
-0.12280594557523727,
0.6829430460929871,
0.043548356741666794,
0.04156168922781944,
0.7144530415534973,
0.25473880767822266,
0.32324984669685364,
-0.11181017756462097,
0.07672246545553207,
-0.08447873592376709,
-0.2771349549293518,
-0.5455844402313232,
-0.18115071952342987,
-0.2281465083360672,
-0.31141725182533264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16107v1 | Decoder-only Architecture for Streaming End-to-end Speech Recognition | 2024-06-23T13:50:08 | 2024-06-23T13:50:08 | Emiru Tsunoo, Hayato Futami, Yosuke Kashiwagi, Siddhant Arora, Shinji Watanabe | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Decoder-only language models (LMs) have been successfully adopted for
speech-processing tasks including automatic speech recognition (ASR). The LMs
have ample expressiveness and perform efficiently. This efficiency is a
suitable characteristic for streaming applications of ASR. In this work, we
propose to use a decoder-only architecture for blockwise streaming ASR. In our
approach, speech features are compressed using CTC output and context embedding
using blockwise speech subnetwork, and are sequentially provided as prompts to
the decoder. The decoder estimates the output tokens promptly at each block. To
this end, we also propose a novel training scheme using random-length prefix
prompts to make the model robust to the truncated prompts caused by blockwise
processing. An experimental comparison shows that our proposed decoder-only
streaming ASR achieves 8% relative word error rate reduction in the LibriSpeech
test-other set while being twice as fast as the baseline model. | [
-0.38175931572914124,
-0.5074465274810791,
0.20014174282550812,
-0.017663784325122833,
-0.8289600610733032,
-0.03766409680247307,
-0.3788765072822571,
-0.37995731830596924,
0.5492910146713257,
0.40579473972320557,
-0.5131993889808655,
-0.19793272018432617,
-0.7267518043518066,
0.2753705680370331,
-0.7845562696456909,
0.37816160917282104,
0.10474079102277756,
0.10255267471075058,
0.0395248606801033,
0.010848051868379116,
-0.5238032937049866,
-0.33894264698028564,
-1.2583359479904175,
-0.16363777220249176,
0.3339444398880005,
0.19030246138572693,
0.14501933753490448,
1.1695832014083862,
-0.14194506406784058,
0.286246657371521,
-0.04578028619289398,
-0.002268289914354682,
-0.3061087131500244,
0.325177937746048,
-0.07507028430700302,
0.080433189868927,
-0.11180925369262695,
-0.5830281972885132,
0.665678858757019,
0.4728167951107025,
-0.10695576667785645,
0.020353024825453758,
-0.00008854133920976892,
0.4615125060081482,
-0.7035989761352539,
0.12123027443885803,
-0.6073389053344727,
-0.16093510389328003,
-0.19997218251228333,
-0.4155864417552948,
-0.6347359418869019,
0.02428741566836834,
-0.08597471565008163,
-0.07557251304388046,
-0.07232023030519485,
-0.04917556792497635,
0.5751364231109619,
0.5555590391159058,
-0.12299330532550812,
-0.25707679986953735,
-0.5000678896903992,
0.3982711732387543,
-0.5339544415473938,
0.8289778232574463,
0.5215226411819458,
0.41557565331459045,
0.25447553396224976,
-0.49245887994766235,
-0.4215404689311981,
0.11370430141687393,
0.08727296441793442,
0.14407169818878174,
-0.33781665563583374,
0.10666187107563019,
-0.10341669619083405,
0.166558176279068,
-0.7699288129806519,
0.26521191000938416,
-0.5294139385223389,
-0.24721375107765198,
0.7957057356834412,
0.04346862807869911,
-0.10109497606754303,
-0.007211852818727493,
-0.4287501275539398,
-0.17730848491191864,
-0.5578799247741699,
0.4032619297504425,
0.13965937495231628,
0.6204208135604858,
-0.17428116500377655,
0.34361758828163147,
-0.18881401419639587,
0.7222297191619873,
0.05988386273384094,
0.16361425817012787,
0.2455955594778061,
0.1609978824853897,
-0.17608897387981415,
0.6799017786979675,
0.7861126065254211,
-0.09186732769012451,
0.09016701579093933,
-0.1604926586151123,
-0.5875203609466553,
0.2739599645137787,
0.2513185143470764,
-0.7401167154312134,
-0.10791854560375214,
0.48993855714797974,
-0.351362943649292,
0.02612808160483837,
-0.062262967228889465,
-0.3358171582221985,
-0.29364117980003357,
-0.12088197469711304,
0.36246779561042786,
-0.3364984393119812,
-0.20248444378376007,
0.0892796739935875,
-0.10462319105863571,
0.25368666648864746,
0.12789155542850494,
-0.595660388469696,
0.6601895093917847,
0.4758800268173218,
0.8410166501998901,
-0.38325583934783936,
-0.07852055132389069,
-1.0849874019622803,
-0.038841813802719116,
-0.21831358969211578,
0.9336755275726318,
-0.4363100826740265,
-0.55736243724823,
0.12960779666900635,
-0.11146298795938492,
-0.04791509360074997,
-0.37575146555900574,
0.6732747554779053,
-0.6040157079696655,
-0.47435593605041504,
0.1113256886601448,
-0.8773481845855713,
-0.16664071381092072,
-0.16933050751686096,
-0.5280671119689941,
0.3499056398868561,
-0.2967820465564728,
-0.4776536822319031,
-0.05836660414934158,
-0.6195271015167236,
-0.5803398489952087,
0.19400008022785187,
-0.2807137072086334,
-0.20871691405773163,
0.06578629463911057,
0.17042414844036102,
0.28433266282081604,
-0.15580646693706512,
0.2911139726638794,
0.15581844747066498,
-0.47619134187698364,
0.3331170976161957,
-0.704266369342804,
0.4454803466796875,
0.4610455632209778,
-0.18479153513908386,
0.3989400565624237,
-0.846852719783783,
0.11148332804441452,
0.036856453865766525,
-0.546432375907898,
-0.05576501414179802,
0.10066913068294525,
0.31631380319595337,
0.07723380625247955,
0.04103698953986168,
-0.7711889743804932,
-0.22388707101345062,
-0.14355877041816711,
0.3824714124202728,
0.723441481590271,
-0.2706051766872406,
0.2875809669494629,
-0.32605037093162537,
0.27653267979621887,
-0.04900346323847771,
-0.2793174684047699,
-0.55912184715271,
-0.2977156341075897,
-0.7556709051132202,
-0.7728738188743591,
0.3241998553276062,
0.5853703022003174,
-0.6383011341094971,
0.6451547741889954,
-0.5745318531990051,
-0.14323897659778595,
-0.6685131788253784,
-0.14233003556728363,
0.73945552110672,
0.4549308717250824,
0.5058505535125732,
-0.4629746973514557,
-0.8649235367774963,
-0.6476424336433411,
-0.12833669781684875,
0.01038371492177248,
-0.19405120611190796,
0.1786787509918213,
-0.046178221702575684,
0.028316982090473175,
0.8537994027137756,
-0.2232719212770462,
-0.1324484944343567,
-0.5665016174316406,
-0.1607382744550705,
0.26266762614250183,
0.4471379518508911,
-0.18988876044750214,
-0.5540280342102051,
-0.4535147249698639,
-0.23825371265411377,
-0.29142653942108154,
-0.37852588295936584,
0.04250359535217285,
0.2946312725543976,
0.41686323285102844,
0.5191895961761475,
-0.4122438430786133,
0.6230286955833435,
0.4990334212779999,
-0.296250581741333,
0.17449170351028442,
-0.18245334923267365,
-0.35621505975723267,
-0.8239759802818298,
0.0023016880732029676,
-0.23231475055217743,
-0.5901910066604614,
-1.0738694667816162,
-0.25775694847106934,
-0.023186521604657173,
-0.22191070020198822,
-0.439979612827301,
0.6941664218902588,
-0.4024580419063568,
-0.3000548481941223,
-0.697634756565094,
0.11812923103570938,
-0.029208824038505554,
0.46905702352523804,
0.7116042375564575,
0.6160193085670471,
0.7125269174575806,
-0.8085466027259827,
0.1590990424156189,
0.28150904178619385,
-0.10000106692314148,
0.12673194706439972,
-0.6473097205162048,
0.3024919629096985,
-0.3141688108444214,
0.30587977170944214,
-0.7565361857414246,
-0.014355158433318138,
0.06734724342823029,
-0.7401720881462097,
0.6004630923271179,
0.024073846638202667,
-0.04998647794127464,
-0.12530693411827087,
-0.2547973692417145,
0.2328115552663803,
0.7695068717002869,
-0.6525928378105164,
0.552312433719635,
0.2818360924720764,
-0.12980766594409943,
-0.35191917419433594,
-0.7348191738128662,
-0.05186699703335762,
0.14344345033168793,
-0.4640140235424042,
0.3680539131164551,
-0.09315396845340729,
0.1941698044538498,
-0.1104845404624939,
-0.2444095015525818,
-0.21151132881641388,
-0.2986680865287781,
0.39689990878105164,
-0.0912194475531578,
-0.17661595344543457,
-0.1861071139574051,
0.05860299989581108,
-0.31129762530326843,
-0.13174061477184296,
-0.43636754155158997,
0.7575817108154297,
0.2916208803653717,
-0.3161996901035309,
-0.6230963468551636,
0.7927550077438354,
0.24761991202831268,
-0.33682698011398315,
0.4021356403827667,
0.31819167733192444,
-0.3090851604938507,
-0.3266286849975586,
-0.5035256743431091,
-0.22958983480930328,
-0.45218825340270996,
0.33129268884658813,
-0.4970962107181549,
-0.8989946842193604,
0.5623964071273804,
0.3618939220905304,
-0.11799508333206177,
-0.15148481726646423,
0.37184926867485046,
0.10206649452447891,
0.45867329835891724,
0.41644614934921265,
-0.058658991008996964,
0.4176405072212219,
-0.2698741853237152,
0.29853206872940063,
-0.8634535670280457,
-0.18516036868095398,
-0.37793219089508057,
-0.1435323804616928,
-0.13600866496562958,
-0.3972517251968384,
0.305807501077652,
-0.008180457167327404,
-0.297116219997406,
0.37662234902381897,
-0.43333718180656433,
0.32692837715148926,
0.5462612509727478,
0.2048950493335724,
0.31726616621017456,
0.0795641615986824,
0.1946861743927002,
0.3972579836845398,
-0.7349217534065247,
-0.19861583411693573,
0.6571285128593445,
0.3309219479560852,
0.6006283164024353,
0.08812709152698517,
0.7555983662605286,
0.4390140473842621,
-0.2488381266593933,
-0.8331957459449768,
0.6208809614181519,
-0.24320819973945618,
-0.289497435092926,
-0.4440057575702667,
-0.2605598270893097,
-0.697165846824646,
0.2732187509536743,
0.14251649379730225,
-0.6818361878395081,
0.32978495955467224,
0.14925137162208557,
-0.31393659114837646,
0.3286617398262024,
-0.23106345534324646,
0.4368394911289215,
0.0392390675842762,
-0.1559380441904068,
-0.03246074542403221,
-0.7087559700012207,
0.02784624882042408,
0.022079892456531525,
0.2160545438528061,
0.07768020778894424,
-0.06654813140630722,
0.3867919445037842,
-0.48709189891815186,
0.635917067527771,
-0.35244134068489075,
0.288038432598114,
0.4668203294277191,
0.1304280161857605,
0.5289533138275146,
-0.11237283051013947,
0.002866793656721711,
0.20887157320976257,
-0.2765909731388092,
-0.19271311163902283,
-0.44125670194625854,
0.31293439865112305,
-0.8561010360717773,
-0.4846479892730713,
-0.3188393712043762,
-0.3287595510482788,
-0.045382287353277206,
-0.05729593336582184,
0.28708553314208984,
0.9862807393074036,
0.062300194054841995,
-0.10563551634550095,
0.6608285307884216,
0.04915137588977814,
0.8505809307098389,
0.5052846670150757,
-0.16732878983020782,
-0.37376371026039124,
0.8965321779251099,
-0.013519772328436375,
0.2707902193069458,
0.5736069679260254,
0.15517766773700714,
-0.7306247353553772,
-0.8571275472640991,
-0.6036228537559509,
-0.08244208991527557,
-0.7153787016868591,
-0.3380391597747803,
-0.7973936796188354,
-0.6048479676246643,
-0.25004881620407104,
-0.2934380769729614,
-0.543946385383606,
-0.16936816275119781,
-0.3139329254627228,
-0.09047111123800278,
0.4274236559867859,
0.2529914975166321,
-0.3094453811645508,
0.3446855843067169,
-0.874435544013977,
0.16464491188526154,
0.3172423541545868,
0.12005048245191574,
0.14631663262844086,
-0.8952365517616272,
-0.07997874170541763,
-0.14291125535964966,
0.14430417120456696,
-0.7690012454986572,
0.6006123423576355,
0.4993589520454407,
0.17867445945739746,
0.6312713623046875,
0.29498109221458435,
0.6894235610961914,
-0.7650414705276489,
0.5591347217559814,
0.2151803970336914,
-1.0391238927841187,
0.2543256878852844,
-0.1397104561328888,
0.3951016366481781,
0.43588030338287354,
0.13692356646060944,
-0.45633023977279663,
-0.06639847904443741,
-0.1058909073472023,
-0.7535545825958252,
0.7534072399139404,
0.059547774493694305,
0.07262695580720901,
-0.1568874716758728,
0.14523833990097046,
0.10360162705183029,
0.06548687815666199,
-0.3502667546272278,
-0.23904797434806824,
-0.5634673237800598,
-0.20019614696502686,
0.041997212916612625,
-0.2950648069381714,
0.22008046507835388,
-0.09407313168048859,
0.5381949543952942,
-0.1230124905705452,
0.3906029164791107,
0.4183014929294586,
-0.28164148330688477,
-0.07099401205778122,
0.5906990170478821,
0.5352165102958679,
0.393394410610199,
-0.1230737715959549,
0.3579089939594269,
0.08523313701152802,
-0.27849656343460083,
0.20651273429393768,
0.18313713371753693,
-0.25638630986213684,
0.2934739887714386,
0.10080168396234512,
1.1811548471450806,
0.11144588142633438,
-0.8494184017181396,
0.5606781840324402,
-0.0027185564395040274,
0.12962009012699127,
-0.5187863707542419,
-0.19750025868415833,
0.12307465076446533,
0.2584204077720642,
0.48210781812667847,
0.05539955943822861,
0.3005564212799072,
-0.33542487025260925,
0.25638583302497864,
0.22195731103420258,
-0.44773292541503906,
-0.2990860044956207,
0.5974715352058411,
0.23223116993904114,
-0.4788878560066223,
0.5520982146263123,
-0.46557796001434326,
-0.4003535211086273,
0.20916233956813812,
0.8098664879798889,
1.0660935640335083,
-0.48169198632240295,
-0.12776950001716614,
0.30091696977615356,
-0.16902053356170654,
0.1764974147081375,
0.4539901912212372,
-0.44350722432136536,
-0.6841862797737122,
-0.5510537028312683,
-0.8715192675590515,
-0.20307372510433197,
-0.038490600883960724,
-0.6357460021972656,
0.36590415239334106,
-0.3400525450706482,
0.12708954513072968,
-0.3589331805706024,
-0.47891464829444885,
-0.2195788472890854,
0.27979254722595215,
0.6151950359344482,
0.9906916618347168,
-0.465539813041687,
1.235572099685669,
0.4004203975200653,
-0.14926578104496002,
-0.8835073113441467,
-0.4510277211666107,
-0.010123065672814846,
-0.6463305950164795,
0.3707408010959625,
0.19015586376190186,
-0.43163979053497314,
0.08420923352241516,
-0.10341820120811462,
-0.811981201171875,
1.0016196966171265,
0.04080663621425629,
-0.7304282188415527,
0.03803420439362526,
0.01604200154542923,
0.10045024752616882,
-0.7040100693702698,
0.3309563100337982,
0.3348537087440491,
0.146296426653862,
0.5116541385650635,
-1.0266698598861694,
0.11272893846035004,
-0.349599689245224,
0.4195215106010437,
0.07347684353590012,
-0.3763222396373749,
0.7548848986625671,
0.013412688858807087,
-0.42332541942596436,
0.05455784872174263,
0.8046472072601318,
0.37355512380599976,
0.2637830376625061,
0.520011842250824,
0.25927266478538513,
0.413431853055954,
0.21959750354290009,
0.9377751350402832,
-0.3799179196357727,
0.012814776971936226,
1.1320502758026123,
-0.1019945815205574,
1.2198266983032227,
0.4353853464126587,
0.1691449135541916,
0.20670978724956512,
0.5876862406730652,
0.2388584315776825,
1.1562532186508179,
0.3597303330898285,
-0.3583338260650635,
-0.2270951271057129,
-0.4721508324146271,
-0.053542133420705795,
0.5594536662101746,
0.23025158047676086,
-0.2102721929550171,
-0.12641401588916779,
-0.04417311027646065,
0.09922941774129868,
0.13731560111045837,
-0.798422634601593,
0.7857996821403503,
0.274532288312912,
-0.2982895076274872,
0.7854705452919006,
0.061031244695186615,
0.9899678826332092,
-0.9205164909362793,
0.2298634797334671,
-0.08017566055059433,
0.012185519561171532,
-0.35087940096855164,
-0.32803308963775635,
0.5944001078605652,
0.3390655815601349,
-0.265950471162796,
-0.14827632904052734,
0.707583487033844,
-0.5583517551422119,
-0.12465495616197586,
0.3319735527038574,
0.5481019616127014,
0.49374228715896606,
-0.13889458775520325,
-0.1510150134563446,
0.644580066204071,
-0.11424721032381058,
-0.035964395850896835,
0.26089274883270264,
-0.13537614047527313,
0.08974972367286682,
0.5874465703964233,
0.6871132850646973,
0.19474318623542786,
0.4707403779029846,
0.1869693547487259,
0.8844561576843262,
-0.42664197087287903,
-0.8016043901443481,
-0.7492029070854187,
0.7279717326164246,
0.19525046646595,
0.026941237971186638,
0.28890252113342285,
0.4429214894771576,
0.7699151635169983,
0.044247426092624664,
0.7065891623497009,
-0.07669021934270859,
0.4367663562297821,
-0.4565035402774811,
0.5811030268669128,
-0.34292274713516235,
0.034607164561748505,
0.24936817586421967,
-0.6175525784492493,
-0.172095388174057,
0.6395083069801331,
0.09682498872280121,
-0.1668304055929184,
0.5938683152198792,
0.5659300684928894,
0.06802736222743988,
0.37457582354545593,
0.6627247929573059,
0.13648903369903564,
0.1533617228269577,
0.5027157664299011,
0.5900009870529175,
-0.42033934593200684,
0.3949615955352783,
0.005814197473227978,
-0.07514979690313339,
-0.0644422173500061,
-0.6532012224197388,
-0.8544867634773254,
-0.744588315486908,
-0.2788347601890564,
-0.13399101793766022,
0.41821596026420593,
1.3012816905975342,
0.5575976967811584,
-0.7835447192192078,
-0.47287309169769287,
0.034184779971838,
-0.3241509795188904,
-0.2177850902080536,
-0.1372067630290985,
0.39477187395095825,
-0.2811100482940674,
-0.5445959568023682,
0.942876935005188,
0.3345252573490143,
-0.30972328782081604,
-0.12164462357759476,
-0.2503807246685028,
0.06418021023273468,
0.2744193971157074,
0.4070848226547241,
0.3865797817707062,
-0.6173785328865051,
-0.29670897126197815,
-0.05381213128566742,
0.24453820288181305,
0.3822259306907654,
0.7302904725074768,
-0.825931966304779,
0.5105641484260559,
0.5248103141784668,
0.877477765083313,
0.6755959987640381,
0.08336092531681061,
0.3638770282268524,
-0.6952099800109863,
0.18018794059753418,
0.3440372049808502,
0.4457809031009674,
0.45668333768844604,
-0.08507593721151352,
0.06022557243704796,
-0.14027737081050873,
-0.32039645314216614,
-0.695675253868103,
0.3234698176383972,
-0.9599463939666748,
-0.15336620807647705,
0.9251964092254639,
-0.3367810547351837,
-0.40983232855796814,
-0.22064241766929626,
0.13211891055107117,
0.40808889269828796,
-0.8941385746002197,
0.2813545763492584,
0.0751197338104248,
-0.30392175912857056,
-0.6124423146247864,
-0.3141184151172638,
0.16560769081115723,
0.05728497356176376,
-0.3680625557899475,
0.02210293896496296,
0.31600242853164673,
0.2763916850090027,
0.05220307037234306,
0.8682016134262085,
0.12549561262130737,
0.20477241277694702,
0.09320981800556183,
0.21738044917583466,
-0.6994232535362244,
-0.4805644154548645,
-0.9261041283607483,
0.028111500665545464,
-0.07222917675971985,
-0.5468948483467102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17807v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17807v1 | Enhancing Commentary Strategies for Imperfect Information Card Games: A Study of Large Language Models in Guandan Commentary | 2024-06-23T11:58:26 | 2024-06-23T11:58:26 | Meiling Tao. Xuechen Liang, Yiling Tao, Tianyu Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have unlocked the
potential for generating high-quality game commentary. However, producing
insightful and engaging commentary for complex games with incomplete
information remains a significant challenge. In this paper, we introduce a
novel commentary method that combine Reinforcement Learning (RL) and LLMs,
tailored specifically for the Chinese card game \textit{Guandan}. Our system
leverages RL to generate intricate card-playing scenarios and employs LLMs to
generate corresponding commentary text, effectively emulating the strategic
analysis and narrative prowess of professional commentators. The framework
comprises a state commentary guide, a Theory of Mind (ToM)-based strategy
analyzer, and a style retrieval module, which seamlessly collaborate to deliver
detailed and context-relevant game commentary in the Chinese language
environment. We empower LLMs with ToM capabilities and refine both retrieval
and information filtering mechanisms. This facilitates the generation of
personalized commentary content. Our experimental results showcase the
substantial enhancement in performance achieved by the proposed commentary
framework when applied to open-source LLMs, surpassing the performance of GPT-4
across multiple evaluation metrics. | [
-0.23238582909107208,
-0.6731440424919128,
0.44411501288414,
0.5306962728500366,
-0.5536484718322754,
-0.021109025925397873,
-0.7674005031585693,
-0.4111979603767395,
0.6131146550178528,
0.41162219643592834,
-0.6468572616577148,
-0.5045028328895569,
-0.19268471002578735,
-0.1092020645737648,
0.3515211045742035,
1.5148261785507202,
0.14784228801727295,
0.36252009868621826,
-0.15356752276420593,
-0.06928825378417969,
-0.57573002576828,
-0.44726917147636414,
-0.9851868152618408,
-0.675797164440155,
0.5199776887893677,
0.09688911586999893,
0.4921780228614807,
0.7307524085044861,
0.5255268812179565,
0.2928341031074524,
-0.05306658521294594,
0.591720700263977,
-0.7608894109725952,
0.27379176020622253,
-0.3052602708339691,
-0.4657144844532013,
-0.6133636832237244,
-0.0542050264775753,
0.5261718034744263,
0.08871200680732727,
-0.4078545868396759,
-0.04562368988990784,
0.20137371122837067,
0.26098302006721497,
-0.4130968749523163,
0.6247832775115967,
-0.448991984128952,
0.4497496485710144,
-0.3343407213687897,
-0.7805822491645813,
-0.6463966965675354,
-0.3606058359146118,
0.007992985658347607,
-1.0482009649276733,
-0.03821806609630585,
-0.03592158854007721,
0.8036791682243347,
0.215392604470253,
0.13534772396087646,
-0.34290996193885803,
-1.228777527809143,
0.4537745714187622,
-0.7754085659980774,
-0.33423763513565063,
0.0024875334929674864,
0.38147491216659546,
-0.21659031510353088,
-0.5040497183799744,
-0.5531591773033142,
-0.2692137360572815,
-0.10513980686664581,
0.7172004580497742,
-0.02843249961733818,
0.42897191643714905,
0.3697877824306488,
0.2870660722255707,
0.02596362680196762,
-0.18210914731025696,
-0.15867415070533752,
0.14497677981853485,
0.9688811898231506,
0.29525506496429443,
0.25434109568595886,
-0.11724697053432465,
-0.26672229170799255,
-0.16623227298259735,
-0.5096963047981262,
-0.028546541929244995,
0.5969659090042114,
0.20195052027702332,
-0.05093628540635109,
0.2269982099533081,
-0.0890585407614708,
0.4303588271141052,
0.24894288182258606,
-0.36499667167663574,
-0.0069132219068706036,
-0.022366126999258995,
-0.14434199035167694,
0.11398899555206299,
0.7104935050010681,
0.31209543347358704,
0.026309890672564507,
-0.33472973108291626,
-0.49204835295677185,
-0.1516486257314682,
0.41407981514930725,
-0.3110247552394867,
-0.6692607998847961,
0.04477487504482269,
-0.5400136709213257,
-0.432340145111084,
0.1726575493812561,
-1.106957197189331,
-0.7895908951759338,
-0.14466005563735962,
0.39176997542381287,
-0.34783536195755005,
-0.2647671103477478,
-0.17270660400390625,
-0.36064183712005615,
0.4957299530506134,
0.6148948669433594,
-0.9963728785514832,
0.053894273936748505,
0.504636287689209,
0.6234947443008423,
-0.39086756110191345,
-0.059184424579143524,
-0.8411220908164978,
0.52906733751297,
-0.507113516330719,
0.8858685493469238,
-0.5340888500213623,
-0.5704565048217773,
0.2859436571598053,
-0.4400608539581299,
0.3508463501930237,
-0.51069176197052,
0.795390248298645,
-0.3649594187736511,
0.03349360078573227,
-0.3097535967826843,
-0.4523148238658905,
0.12429888546466827,
0.6585618853569031,
-0.6800798177719116,
0.7122790217399597,
-0.34640952944755554,
-0.8275182843208313,
0.21903468668460846,
-0.8209463953971863,
-0.6735883355140686,
0.5209307670593262,
-0.4721582531929016,
-0.24341003596782684,
0.06439488381147385,
0.2339905947446823,
0.27323147654533386,
-0.11146806925535202,
0.290908545255661,
-0.47260209918022156,
-0.5918529629707336,
0.04699551314115524,
-0.617875337600708,
0.13079527020454407,
0.16645653545856476,
-0.6192828416824341,
0.45078346133232117,
-0.7239220142364502,
0.2607899010181427,
0.2600860297679901,
-0.7781614065170288,
-0.2140161544084549,
0.5086339712142944,
0.041449323296546936,
0.15710151195526123,
0.02067062072455883,
-0.27782681584358215,
0.32925811409950256,
-0.3543614447116852,
0.35412928462028503,
0.6761300563812256,
0.0926806777715683,
0.22988970577716827,
-0.32090744376182556,
0.508053719997406,
-0.07642597705125809,
0.39190351963043213,
-0.25828176736831665,
-0.13417869806289673,
-0.9006374478340149,
0.04890776425600052,
0.2212384045124054,
0.7038808465003967,
-1.145693063735962,
0.028439898043870926,
-0.6107606291770935,
-0.3745574355125427,
-0.5969534516334534,
0.014390094205737114,
0.566091775894165,
-0.0035328050144016743,
0.37630605697631836,
-0.33242037892341614,
-0.49294859170913696,
-0.6351313591003418,
-0.33796605467796326,
-0.4627496898174286,
0.11222588270902634,
0.5989862680435181,
0.08152101188898087,
0.1389418989419937,
0.5119641423225403,
-0.4897185266017914,
-0.4013146162033081,
-0.5862403512001038,
0.1111881285905838,
-0.07973291724920273,
0.4182758033275604,
0.1433916538953781,
-0.52156001329422,
-0.21660174429416656,
0.1637924164533615,
-0.691898763179779,
0.15478701889514923,
-0.5282331109046936,
-0.10831433534622192,
0.02488566003739834,
0.5653364658355713,
-0.450545072555542,
0.5034689903259277,
0.254703551530838,
0.04096907749772072,
0.5072004795074463,
-0.62630295753479,
-0.03603409603238106,
-0.5434771776199341,
0.13466210663318634,
0.0770193412899971,
-0.11450643837451935,
-0.6339230537414551,
0.22446756064891815,
-0.24310067296028137,
0.26394912600517273,
-0.21361146867275238,
0.7420085072517395,
-0.4461837410926819,
0.15021708607673645,
-0.4329574704170227,
0.5209711790084839,
-0.17349043488502502,
0.968448281288147,
0.3155219554901123,
0.4051132798194885,
-0.16918903589248657,
-0.44999831914901733,
0.5434921979904175,
0.11902468651533127,
-0.22518816590309143,
0.7360734343528748,
-0.4897422194480896,
0.023934854194521904,
-0.20261313021183014,
0.49810606241226196,
-0.8954305648803711,
-0.2660132944583893,
0.702928364276886,
-0.3113713562488556,
0.5329179167747498,
-0.219896137714386,
-0.355453222990036,
-0.3233174979686737,
-0.3623877763748169,
0.05246737599372864,
0.4005299508571625,
-0.6121141910552979,
0.7602973580360413,
0.4234641492366791,
-0.00356270931661129,
-0.6218712329864502,
-0.6867236495018005,
0.2793627083301544,
-0.30822017788887024,
-0.2897431254386902,
0.3077695071697235,
-0.2996753752231598,
-0.2174108624458313,
-0.040482740849256516,
0.015818998217582703,
0.1816643476486206,
-0.07658115029335022,
0.09304742515087128,
0.2569412291049957,
-0.10213321447372437,
0.12665770947933197,
-0.12169261276721954,
0.1924848109483719,
0.1553817093372345,
-0.47692635655403137,
0.23779179155826569,
-0.007682736497372389,
-0.1040119156241417,
-0.16272155940532684,
0.08653377741575241,
0.0013464015210047364,
-0.28387507796287537,
0.39861243963241577,
0.5590685606002808,
-0.03387274593114853,
-0.5317263603210449,
-0.697133481502533,
-0.015939105302095413,
-0.4326004087924957,
0.48003503680229187,
-0.2625301778316498,
-0.6346828937530518,
0.4082297086715698,
-0.08807025104761124,
0.255723774433136,
0.2625942826271057,
0.3913004994392395,
-0.0585780069231987,
1.109823226928711,
0.5691865086555481,
-0.23103657364845276,
0.522686779499054,
0.018719259649515152,
0.008854852989315987,
-0.7051166892051697,
-0.5719614028930664,
0.04577711597084999,
-0.30491307377815247,
-0.4194571375846863,
-0.41468721628189087,
0.18875114619731903,
0.01069815456867218,
-0.21274402737617493,
-0.35532793402671814,
-0.3156815469264984,
0.761127769947052,
0.6193462014198303,
0.4460028409957886,
0.23092125356197357,
0.0005579896969720721,
-0.2575407326221466,
-0.013481413014233112,
-1.0164551734924316,
-0.21287235617637634,
0.8524065613746643,
0.33863455057144165,
0.79375821352005,
0.13278108835220337,
0.7158600687980652,
0.3746137320995331,
0.6763625144958496,
-0.48677858710289,
0.4574928879737854,
-0.0436486154794693,
-0.4483150839805603,
-0.42444345355033875,
-0.44881922006607056,
-0.6084956526756287,
0.2044401317834854,
-0.4869307279586792,
-0.44371068477630615,
-0.11881165951490402,
0.2977292239665985,
-0.6473708152770996,
0.4999156892299652,
-0.20587235689163208,
0.6159582138061523,
-0.3256503939628601,
-0.7530994415283203,
-0.1833590269088745,
-0.547439694404602,
0.6196233630180359,
0.40650665760040283,
0.11201855540275574,
0.3148667812347412,
0.05879148468375206,
0.5504832863807678,
-0.19794964790344238,
0.8871745467185974,
-0.2527059018611908,
-0.24886038899421692,
0.4550444185733795,
0.029332095757126808,
0.6364697217941284,
0.27369368076324463,
0.2982313334941864,
-0.13177137076854706,
-0.3105928897857666,
-0.34223809838294983,
-0.6804213523864746,
0.6677740216255188,
-0.8228265643119812,
-0.848495602607727,
-0.3845504820346832,
-0.38573139905929565,
-0.3273319602012634,
0.17039205133914948,
0.2533935308456421,
0.25842297077178955,
-0.5806645750999451,
-0.22759439051151276,
0.8745712637901306,
-0.3196773827075958,
0.4045836329460144,
0.298269659280777,
-0.04541873559355736,
-0.786241888999939,
1.0179827213287354,
-0.11183297634124756,
-0.003275829367339611,
0.38468557596206665,
0.008772530592978,
-0.12069445848464966,
-0.5323100090026855,
-0.42128077149391174,
0.3389812707901001,
-0.8304213285446167,
-0.14314621686935425,
-0.19120249152183533,
-0.41064977645874023,
0.09578541666269302,
0.35274603962898254,
-0.17339082062244415,
0.005083424970507622,
0.06732531636953354,
-0.21338914334774017,
-0.015387721359729767,
0.9577081203460693,
-0.21761789917945862,
0.5769602656364441,
-0.6536476612091064,
-0.21081091463565826,
0.1756446808576584,
0.613350510597229,
0.3927977383136749,
-0.2160831093788147,
-0.39587289094924927,
0.08222811669111252,
-0.2795344293117523,
-0.794137179851532,
0.1548851579427719,
-0.004079589620232582,
0.7671457529067993,
0.7535162568092346,
-0.05036803334951401,
0.7570799589157104,
-0.42214468121528625,
0.8556679487228394,
0.08050777018070221,
-0.7148231863975525,
0.5018140077590942,
-0.6672914028167725,
0.08910014480352402,
0.37444043159484863,
-0.11064983904361725,
-0.6075581908226013,
-0.28395211696624756,
-0.7017669677734375,
-0.7146267890930176,
1.0964807271957397,
0.00376891833730042,
0.13782262802124023,
-0.2858746349811554,
0.6649305820465088,
-0.18827864527702332,
0.2512867748737335,
-0.94562828540802,
-0.3515562415122986,
-0.2091262936592102,
-0.023313868790864944,
-0.19065967202186584,
-0.3220367133617401,
-0.25506213307380676,
0.019742479547858238,
0.693607747554779,
-0.11674582213163376,
0.2570817470550537,
0.3175068497657776,
0.2822195887565613,
-0.11023328453302383,
-0.0028470302931964397,
0.7704678177833557,
0.339559406042099,
0.037968192249536514,
-0.18397840857505798,
0.33965763449668884,
-0.4225085377693176,
-0.09986935555934906,
-0.18361768126487732,
-0.41195255517959595,
0.05678173154592514,
0.5695791244506836,
1.1509127616882324,
0.35391902923583984,
-0.7235978841781616,
0.45072460174560547,
-0.23898528516292572,
-0.24840758740901947,
-0.5070779323577881,
0.3060119152069092,
0.03913479298353195,
0.38624081015586853,
0.20597361028194427,
0.07152403891086578,
-0.19379998743534088,
-0.5759440064430237,
0.10795170813798904,
0.4120456874370575,
-0.914747953414917,
-0.22655096650123596,
0.9713284373283386,
0.44879743456840515,
-0.16151155531406403,
0.2853969931602478,
-0.42726433277130127,
-0.3931554853916168,
0.3298432528972626,
0.4194217026233673,
0.7762701511383057,
-0.13101212680339813,
0.5312789082527161,
0.32119834423065186,
0.21506252884864807,
-0.5103394985198975,
0.2463957518339157,
-0.12493950128555298,
-0.3653036057949066,
-0.7346794605255127,
-0.1916978657245636,
-0.3394727110862732,
0.39397233724594116,
-0.4882420301437378,
0.23070435225963593,
-0.9455426335334778,
-0.1741771548986435,
-0.5336379408836365,
0.30455461144447327,
-0.43333762884140015,
0.18112316727638245,
0.4112360179424286,
0.7806785106658936,
-0.4815153479576111,
0.749778687953949,
0.7278304696083069,
-0.7709042429924011,
-0.9530718922615051,
0.2754020392894745,
-0.14106620848178864,
-0.4877025783061981,
0.5943107008934021,
-0.33293309807777405,
0.00932416319847107,
-0.12475930154323578,
-0.6193545460700989,
-0.4730345606803894,
0.9818212389945984,
0.21216095983982086,
-0.3363879919052124,
-0.09495877474546432,
-0.006402694620192051,
0.8464452624320984,
-0.43115755915641785,
0.6716987490653992,
0.49489185214042664,
0.6051731109619141,
0.27901691198349,
-0.5370535850524902,
-0.09431527554988861,
-0.46598049998283386,
0.1042599007487297,
0.015488308854401112,
-1.1575144529342651,
0.49203649163246155,
-0.13467831909656525,
-0.3549434244632721,
0.1749260276556015,
1.2172350883483887,
0.19094257056713104,
0.18485026061534882,
0.21684151887893677,
0.3150274157524109,
0.8217613697052002,
-0.03706225007772446,
0.9357395768165588,
-0.2946920394897461,
-0.000191793980775401,
1.2416877746582031,
-0.16873352229595184,
0.8241617679595947,
0.10399462282657623,
0.09870701283216476,
0.3488915264606476,
0.5186859965324402,
-0.2082364410161972,
0.47572678327560425,
0.6014848351478577,
-0.18113327026367188,
-0.37876075506210327,
-0.16504952311515808,
-0.09434500336647034,
0.276283860206604,
0.2763996124267578,
-0.01985655352473259,
-0.15126672387123108,
-0.29441162943840027,
0.1874304711818695,
0.3804076910018921,
-0.5620301365852356,
0.9263104796409607,
-0.18432165682315826,
-0.8695727586746216,
0.009144258685410023,
0.23656265437602997,
1.0287437438964844,
-0.8001897931098938,
-0.21543827652931213,
-0.7228537201881409,
0.4113609492778778,
-0.04568095505237579,
-0.4821319282054901,
-0.14618292450904846,
-0.06400594115257263,
0.11284901946783066,
0.17936228215694427,
0.5339115858078003,
-0.682780921459198,
-0.15294070541858673,
0.4264480769634247,
0.39587393403053284,
-0.044172246009111404,
0.15520654618740082,
-0.49212807416915894,
-0.0029188673943281174,
0.09941302239894867,
-0.1313135176897049,
0.4467557370662689,
0.6795550584793091,
0.029431143775582314,
0.6029996871948242,
0.3666641116142273,
0.6040011644363403,
-0.1990186870098114,
-0.16094259917736053,
0.675679624080658,
-0.6416633129119873,
-0.6751801371574402,
-0.9873100519180298,
0.044956911355257034,
-0.512467086315155,
-0.3891822397708893,
0.7375439405441284,
0.48049694299697876,
0.9066939353942871,
-0.18703562021255493,
1.0564872026443481,
0.3163575530052185,
0.13860394060611725,
-0.5703451037406921,
0.8198840022087097,
-0.3428051173686981,
0.43545839190483093,
-0.4215741753578186,
-0.953114926815033,
-0.25400182604789734,
0.3612309396266937,
-0.18031719326972961,
-0.03137509897351265,
0.3560382127761841,
0.3905436396598816,
0.031402453780174255,
0.17146557569503784,
0.13668598234653473,
0.05736910179257393,
0.5187012553215027,
0.8125880360603333,
0.8982912302017212,
-0.20816466212272644,
1.0601344108581543,
-0.04151022806763649,
-0.20177052915096283,
-0.24532656371593475,
-0.9018246531486511,
-1.1935369968414307,
-0.3343462646007538,
-0.26082563400268555,
-0.5748711228370667,
0.4291950762271881,
0.9323037266731262,
0.39246127009391785,
-0.4814675450325012,
-0.3610239326953888,
0.2227909415960312,
-0.014669684693217278,
-0.2163185328245163,
-0.23669715225696564,
0.4679126739501953,
-0.3904598355293274,
-0.7049859762191772,
0.22846734523773193,
0.4233422577381134,
-0.2825831174850464,
-0.3373790979385376,
-0.4016755223274231,
0.19285032153129578,
0.4019874930381775,
0.4448835253715515,
0.5726099610328674,
-0.7318698763847351,
-0.4543745219707489,
-0.2775616943836212,
-0.12430360913276672,
0.1678369641304016,
0.9529250264167786,
-0.574754536151886,
0.465848445892334,
0.4062582850456238,
0.7158517241477966,
0.3714355230331421,
0.16589166224002838,
0.6878746747970581,
-0.6601771116256714,
0.1671474277973175,
0.2021804004907608,
0.06002441421151161,
0.16279564797878265,
-0.39147621393203735,
0.5580894947052002,
0.22568434476852417,
-0.2025509625673294,
-0.5943759083747864,
-0.04647069051861763,
-0.608324408531189,
-0.25797396898269653,
1.3634777069091797,
-0.3732396364212036,
-0.25204116106033325,
0.2232883870601654,
-0.3705945611000061,
0.3014551103115082,
-0.3381431996822357,
0.9069634675979614,
1.043221354484558,
0.08285825699567795,
0.09895642101764679,
-0.6087804436683655,
0.9624106884002686,
0.33410805463790894,
-0.6029607057571411,
0.12258939445018768,
0.518155038356781,
-0.08216584473848343,
0.1044129878282547,
0.8124661445617676,
-0.030630532652139664,
0.348148375749588,
0.112928107380867,
0.20031052827835083,
-0.20717908442020416,
-0.35662662982940674,
-0.20665176212787628,
0.072853684425354,
0.03327031061053276,
0.15934036672115326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16086v1 | SEAM: A Stochastic Benchmark for Multi-Document Tasks | 2024-06-23T11:57:53 | 2024-06-23T11:57:53 | Gili Lior, Avi Caciularu, Arie Cattan, Shahar Levy, Ori Shapira, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Various tasks, such as summarization, multi-hop question answering, or
coreference resolution, are naturally phrased over collections of real-world
documents. Such tasks present a unique set of challenges, revolving around the
lack of coherent narrative structure across documents, which often leads to
contradiction, omission, or repetition of information. Despite their real-world
application and challenging properties, there is currently no benchmark which
specifically measures the abilities of large language models (LLMs) on
multi-document tasks. To bridge this gap, we present SEAM (a Stochastic
Evaluation Approach for Multi-document tasks), a conglomerate benchmark over a
diverse set of multi-document datasets, setting conventional evaluation
criteria, input-output formats, and evaluation protocols. In particular, SEAM
addresses the sensitivity of LLMs to minor prompt variations through repeated
evaluations, where in each evaluation we sample uniformly at random the values
of arbitrary factors (e.g., the order of documents). We evaluate different LLMs
on SEAM finding that multi-document tasks pose a significant challenge for
LLMs, even for state-of-the-art models with 70B parameters. In addition, we
show that the stochastic approach uncovers underlying statistical trends which
cannot be observed in a static benchmark. We hope that SEAM will spur progress
via consistent and meaningful evaluation of multi-document tasks. | [
-0.19183577597141266,
-0.7823293209075928,
0.7132636904716492,
0.423727422952652,
-0.12652193009853363,
0.27106377482414246,
-0.5010377764701843,
-0.3112134635448456,
0.06576458364725113,
0.2194814383983612,
-0.7711512446403503,
-0.5748472213745117,
-1.009940505027771,
0.01445646584033966,
-0.37948372960090637,
0.8704028129577637,
-0.3498011827468872,
-0.0889652743935585,
-0.5287861227989197,
-0.15400128066539764,
-0.5138255953788757,
-0.08873347193002701,
-0.5147529244422913,
-0.16544905304908752,
0.6849761009216309,
0.35998231172561646,
0.4207442104816437,
0.5210182070732117,
0.6721309423446655,
0.32605695724487305,
0.10515177994966507,
0.22632578015327454,
-0.39101749658584595,
0.5252441167831421,
-0.07631993293762207,
-0.47155988216400146,
-0.2188418060541153,
0.010769139043986797,
0.9148950576782227,
0.837809681892395,
0.04783398658037186,
0.3823155462741852,
0.3844873309135437,
0.4724467694759369,
-0.7332063317298889,
0.3572719395160675,
-0.23685739934444427,
-0.11389192193746567,
-0.510477602481842,
0.007872394286096096,
-0.15410540997982025,
-0.3223702013492584,
0.06303080916404724,
-0.2789982259273529,
0.33271995186805725,
-0.026995014399290085,
0.802492082118988,
0.26909762620925903,
-0.23081688582897186,
-0.39729073643684387,
-0.46765390038490295,
0.8603478670120239,
-0.484979510307312,
0.518857479095459,
0.2486538141965866,
0.10974051058292389,
-0.2994745671749115,
-0.7037902474403381,
-0.4011443853378296,
-0.3242354691028595,
0.33643555641174316,
0.4385903477668762,
0.16596314311027527,
-0.23801453411579132,
0.170706644654274,
0.5726550221443176,
-0.6497344970703125,
0.16232286393642426,
0.030293557792901993,
-0.32143592834472656,
0.3472183346748352,
0.4125480651855469,
0.16281349956989288,
-0.05940303951501846,
-0.29545649886131287,
-0.3335292637348175,
-0.02032182738184929,
0.44815462827682495,
0.3485853672027588,
0.33388179540634155,
-0.3936833143234253,
0.6284659504890442,
-0.31676796078681946,
0.48328256607055664,
-0.31321442127227783,
-0.34895288944244385,
0.2056512087583542,
-0.42429906129837036,
-0.15890303254127502,
-0.37246188521385193,
0.8791599273681641,
0.22389774024486542,
-0.2850494384765625,
-0.26272064447402954,
0.004151058383285999,
0.09034774452447891,
0.22996953129768372,
-0.38595524430274963,
0.09743908792734146,
0.42483600974082947,
-0.40279558300971985,
-0.12660232186317444,
-0.24543094635009766,
-0.9884176254272461,
-0.5278623700141907,
-0.3775815963745117,
0.2147275060415268,
-0.5295709371566772,
0.07367001473903656,
-0.09222621470689774,
-0.36514613032341003,
0.07273399829864502,
0.4972776174545288,
-0.3956665098667145,
0.18965114653110504,
0.9504719376564026,
1.0976957082748413,
-0.23474884033203125,
-1.0396051406860352,
-0.6075112223625183,
-0.14210930466651917,
-0.4494682848453522,
1.1411926746368408,
-0.6546844244003296,
-0.21985819935798645,
-0.01400847639888525,
0.06774823367595673,
-0.310960978269577,
-0.10208558291196823,
0.9228236079216003,
-0.10043824464082718,
0.136313334107399,
-0.3432016670703888,
-0.3532945215702057,
0.0634988397359848,
0.4522331655025482,
-0.7147341370582581,
1.2654985189437866,
0.19545385241508484,
-0.9635679125785828,
0.5825121402740479,
-0.1425025314092636,
-0.34624266624450684,
-0.17305441200733185,
-0.03198947012424469,
-0.4025039076805115,
0.2931102216243744,
-0.12906746566295624,
0.18762676417827606,
-0.954545259475708,
0.2316722571849823,
-0.5658531188964844,
-0.250556081533432,
0.05224677175283432,
-0.5854780077934265,
0.40175342559814453,
0.11016891151666641,
-0.27295082807540894,
0.23135821521282196,
-0.7296723127365112,
0.04762175679206848,
-0.07748925685882568,
-0.609111487865448,
-0.3799280822277069,
0.161921426653862,
-0.038762129843235016,
0.317258358001709,
0.47990474104881287,
-0.35245606303215027,
0.2971296012401581,
-0.07403228431940079,
-0.039513759315013885,
0.6305936574935913,
-0.22596950829029083,
0.20568637549877167,
-0.8559698462486267,
0.40875619649887085,
-0.02571282722055912,
0.08814621716737747,
-0.5050272941589355,
-0.4626320004463196,
-0.8790690898895264,
-0.72379070520401,
0.27341556549072266,
0.4357815980911255,
-0.5477681159973145,
0.13976508378982544,
-0.50595623254776,
-1.01160728931427,
-0.655591607093811,
0.14947998523712158,
0.5598655343055725,
0.18870678544044495,
0.32207998633384705,
-0.8182326555252075,
-0.1678355485200882,
-0.8191553950309753,
-0.666004478931427,
-0.0022203538101166487,
-0.24344806373119354,
0.2522474527359009,
0.31966954469680786,
-0.10614647716283798,
0.6042969822883606,
-0.17030975222587585,
-0.2015901654958725,
-0.05620637536048889,
1.0038580894470215,
0.3851178288459778,
0.28195813298225403,
-0.12920062243938446,
-0.4294639527797699,
-0.2643059194087982,
-0.3164317309856415,
-0.6634934544563293,
-0.3358210027217865,
-0.42911043763160706,
0.04640265181660652,
0.2638900578022003,
0.23453444242477417,
-0.6235383749008179,
0.12661664187908173,
0.6358941197395325,
-0.11136613041162491,
0.8367469906806946,
-0.4766518175601959,
0.5845265984535217,
-0.9998593926429749,
-0.0004221706185489893,
0.15199077129364014,
0.03313475847244263,
-0.42001622915267944,
0.23466967046260834,
0.38575077056884766,
-0.13360625505447388,
-0.3451416790485382,
0.3896581828594208,
-0.5553105473518372,
-0.33628785610198975,
-0.08281953632831573,
0.06686772406101227,
0.047651614993810654,
0.4724493622779846,
-0.03638466075062752,
0.5492672920227051,
0.6673927307128906,
-0.5249081254005432,
0.3242872357368469,
0.014628184027969837,
-0.6144207715988159,
0.8049761652946472,
-0.4495983123779297,
0.17333750426769257,
-0.2882814407348633,
0.31054970622062683,
-1.1157913208007812,
-0.09113778918981552,
-0.19854457676410675,
-0.04318306967616081,
0.24270464479923248,
-0.20357820391654968,
-0.7499186396598816,
-0.473631888628006,
-0.6248661279678345,
0.29861441254615784,
-0.03324836492538452,
-0.19225753843784332,
0.8289731740951538,
0.2808854877948761,
-0.5503886342048645,
-0.6224222779273987,
-0.5214962959289551,
0.36248892545700073,
-0.26361411809921265,
-0.8632833361625671,
0.43337252736091614,
-0.07716511189937592,
-0.07134592533111572,
-0.16236403584480286,
-0.36734285950660706,
-0.13765868544578552,
0.07832632213830948,
0.30207347869873047,
0.20447520911693573,
-0.02358989790081978,
-0.05214757099747658,
0.005869416985660791,
-0.09654249995946884,
-0.20761795341968536,
-0.2556599974632263,
0.6935160160064697,
-0.03628472611308098,
-0.6217833161354065,
-0.07405713945627213,
0.5350779891014099,
0.7817087769508362,
-0.27961811423301697,
0.37155425548553467,
0.607598602771759,
-0.22259317338466644,
-0.3130822777748108,
-0.8430562615394592,
0.310421884059906,
-0.35733920335769653,
0.3959135413169861,
-0.8439398407936096,
-0.7149981260299683,
0.6269567012786865,
-0.31089282035827637,
0.2201755791902542,
0.43280428647994995,
0.764018714427948,
0.07403672486543655,
0.34280112385749817,
0.4983678162097931,
-0.14185377955436707,
0.18043342232704163,
0.1768014132976532,
-0.040758535265922546,
-0.8054527640342712,
-0.1453785002231598,
-0.9461492896080017,
-0.17664843797683716,
-0.4768320918083191,
-0.890550434589386,
0.2681545615196228,
0.2957128882408142,
-0.041620656847953796,
0.5251888632774353,
-0.14381593465805054,
0.2280162274837494,
0.9311320781707764,
-0.01852814108133316,
0.33582451939582825,
-0.4798058569431305,
-0.3144906461238861,
-0.03414538875222206,
-0.6563317179679871,
-0.45866864919662476,
0.9800145030021667,
0.3486762046813965,
0.9542058110237122,
0.06628469377756119,
0.6691035032272339,
0.2951699197292328,
0.04812571033835411,
-0.6913609504699707,
0.2302161306142807,
-0.19307367503643036,
-0.14086490869522095,
-0.39699602127075195,
-0.5186517834663391,
-0.8922030329704285,
0.3852057158946991,
-0.21917299926280975,
-0.8759536147117615,
0.07512114942073822,
-0.2814365327358246,
-0.04676952213048935,
0.1120617464184761,
-0.409640371799469,
0.9730691313743591,
-0.25166043639183044,
-0.8360979557037354,
-0.1389918476343155,
-0.3276149034500122,
0.3135839104652405,
-0.41892480850219727,
0.5109618902206421,
-0.37256520986557007,
-0.061977069824934006,
0.6802066564559937,
-0.04495391994714737,
0.7289992570877075,
0.20745454728603363,
-0.06025778502225876,
0.1660410463809967,
0.26843875646591187,
0.7659011483192444,
-0.12566377222537994,
-0.16396564245224,
0.3740133047103882,
0.1405676305294037,
-0.3468306064605713,
-0.11756807565689087,
0.7836164236068726,
-0.550300121307373,
-0.4475971758365631,
-0.5870426297187805,
-0.9433329105377197,
-0.3867174983024597,
0.33154264092445374,
0.20199669897556305,
0.44683414697647095,
-0.4358261227607727,
-0.033659130334854126,
0.2430565059185028,
-0.3557218015193939,
0.7473790049552917,
0.5293415188789368,
0.4960181713104248,
-0.15081225335597992,
0.6207867860794067,
0.21531447768211365,
0.10932210832834244,
0.27883872389793396,
0.16671426594257355,
-0.4492170512676239,
-0.49155962467193604,
-0.49908551573753357,
0.09543247520923615,
-0.6468310952186584,
0.02159574255347252,
-0.8053997755050659,
0.21159473061561584,
-0.5661683678627014,
-0.1386602520942688,
-0.5280677080154419,
-0.1409284472465515,
0.130931556224823,
0.42283666133880615,
-0.23880694806575775,
0.5116970539093018,
0.11184635758399963,
-0.17976893484592438,
-1.0972192287445068,
0.355904757976532,
0.2924107015132904,
0.6340288519859314,
-0.0509873628616333,
-0.5193403363227844,
-0.29795652627944946,
-0.23313800990581512,
-0.4104357063770294,
-0.5502259135246277,
0.3283619284629822,
0.17104536294937134,
0.8157980442047119,
0.028635289520025253,
0.13499024510383606,
0.8082749843597412,
-0.6515081524848938,
0.7652912735939026,
0.07867265492677689,
-1.0426795482635498,
0.31541192531585693,
-0.44432052969932556,
0.6304133534431458,
0.7460513114929199,
0.48723000288009644,
-0.7539909482002258,
-0.826663076877594,
-0.5981671810150146,
-1.1059128046035767,
0.6450294852256775,
0.08650504797697067,
-0.12202704697847366,
0.06829190999269485,
-0.22280392050743103,
0.24348165094852448,
0.3679652214050293,
-0.2512129843235016,
0.02081356942653656,
0.06271087378263474,
-0.20790399610996246,
-0.1006985530257225,
-0.33445996046066284,
-0.2529546022415161,
0.6351848244667053,
0.35099613666534424,
-0.15161249041557312,
0.19066455960273743,
0.14905387163162231,
-0.35459035634994507,
0.18262386322021484,
0.5570846199989319,
0.5900223851203918,
0.7070054411888123,
-0.18513783812522888,
0.28316426277160645,
0.17911818623542786,
-0.2822782099246979,
-0.08730687201023102,
0.41306740045547485,
0.25586846470832825,
0.025888152420520782,
0.743915855884552,
0.5113506317138672,
0.49917519092559814,
-0.6365373134613037,
0.48625871539115906,
-0.1445479691028595,
-0.14068739116191864,
-0.1388210505247116,
-0.18108513951301575,
0.047401878982782364,
0.45166099071502686,
0.36647364497184753,
0.09820670634508133,
0.08402450382709503,
-0.7850081324577332,
0.3435470461845398,
0.28855812549591064,
-0.48123928904533386,
-0.04512888938188553,
0.6681617498397827,
-0.09185660630464554,
-0.2767767310142517,
0.21735966205596924,
-0.15227758884429932,
-0.23725229501724243,
0.6483763456344604,
0.28867074847221375,
0.9227407574653625,
-0.08776234835386276,
0.1481359750032425,
0.2477380335330963,
0.4769446849822998,
-0.5484728813171387,
0.16310608386993408,
-0.008398319594562054,
-0.4899229407310486,
-0.4791780710220337,
-0.8682495355606079,
-0.7717502117156982,
-0.12001538276672363,
-0.5975177884101868,
0.41404470801353455,
-0.18804116547107697,
-0.0019179853843525052,
0.029929375275969505,
-0.011618695221841335,
-0.8771864771842957,
0.1328592449426651,
0.17393918335437775,
0.9009074568748474,
-0.8024328947067261,
0.7363104224205017,
0.35442009568214417,
-0.3951874077320099,
-0.3857968747615814,
0.14923258125782013,
0.3593839406967163,
-0.5752823352813721,
0.23737798631191254,
0.17354236543178558,
0.03619328513741493,
-0.4291881024837494,
0.21017803251743317,
-0.9623841643333435,
1.0331430435180664,
0.331648588180542,
-0.6036149263381958,
-0.03770633786916733,
0.1684335172176361,
0.4051966667175293,
-0.23420356214046478,
0.6264779567718506,
0.5464531183242798,
0.5415446162223816,
-0.15250468254089355,
-1.166237235069275,
-0.005234372336417437,
-0.2708851099014282,
0.13227061927318573,
0.1386493295431137,
-0.7841518521308899,
1.1269489526748657,
0.10799943655729294,
-0.3994227945804596,
-0.0011266344226896763,
0.36729225516319275,
0.4891758859157562,
0.5278311967849731,
0.5888544917106628,
0.7240455150604248,
0.965271532535553,
-0.34078675508499146,
1.3181127309799194,
-0.46318551898002625,
0.4063836932182312,
1.5778920650482178,
-0.4284769296646118,
0.6436281800270081,
0.25356757640838623,
-0.31260162591934204,
0.2657438814640045,
0.7203435301780701,
-0.08143118023872375,
0.33760666847229004,
0.38341033458709717,
-0.2965216338634491,
-0.15256279706954956,
-0.23836949467658997,
-0.22677017748355865,
0.44135013222694397,
0.0579998604953289,
0.0012832286302000284,
-0.4095420837402344,
-0.11199617385864258,
-0.09121182560920715,
0.007221347186714411,
-0.3009558320045471,
0.7881563901901245,
-0.08139704167842865,
-0.8504979014396667,
0.18403276801109314,
0.12066709995269775,
0.7768458724021912,
-0.770026683807373,
0.2646915912628174,
-0.2594510316848755,
-0.008444146253168583,
0.024726049974560738,
-0.7188562154769897,
0.26467370986938477,
0.05863943696022034,
-0.2739025950431824,
-0.15408840775489807,
0.6033002138137817,
-0.43501824140548706,
-0.6397839784622192,
0.38074153661727905,
0.5591813325881958,
0.14355219900608063,
-0.10292386263608932,
-0.636492908000946,
0.16483546793460846,
-0.3903570771217346,
-0.3513988256454468,
0.4425615668296814,
0.762119710445404,
-0.041753120720386505,
0.6567688584327698,
0.7508829236030579,
0.20264990627765656,
0.05287102609872818,
0.2998964488506317,
0.8098821043968201,
-0.6442027688026428,
-0.6054570078849792,
-0.6648759245872498,
0.6552377343177795,
-0.04561106860637665,
-0.40783384442329407,
0.8779067993164062,
0.7006614804267883,
0.7320803999900818,
0.05152328684926033,
0.8755158185958862,
-0.13494567573070526,
0.5591740608215332,
-0.4661870300769806,
0.3615577220916748,
-0.523501455783844,
0.174376979470253,
-0.6061228513717651,
-1.0129650831222534,
-0.13933280110359192,
0.18219053745269775,
-0.212566077709198,
-0.2403164654970169,
1.201061725616455,
0.6276658177375793,
0.0766134113073349,
-0.05191141366958618,
0.3248386085033417,
-0.17231054604053497,
0.2304016351699829,
0.6648726463317871,
0.8124739527702332,
-0.43291741609573364,
0.6080605983734131,
-0.17369037866592407,
-0.4477417469024658,
0.07375836372375488,
-0.9756021499633789,
-0.6226691603660583,
-0.7442690134048462,
-0.33448222279548645,
-0.4164217710494995,
0.06342510133981705,
0.7094007134437561,
0.4579504430294037,
-0.5721495151519775,
-0.3589429259300232,
0.1389944851398468,
0.1669122576713562,
-0.567825436592102,
-0.15495483577251434,
0.39583930373191833,
-0.7960662245750427,
-1.0768827199935913,
0.59017413854599,
0.529451847076416,
-0.2804211676120758,
-0.01527170930057764,
0.3184893727302551,
-0.2905506491661072,
0.0638614296913147,
0.47352340817451477,
0.0841452106833458,
-0.42646515369415283,
-0.3129774332046509,
-0.23976090550422668,
-0.4008883237838745,
-0.04844372346997261,
0.8993327617645264,
-0.21118582785129547,
0.42554807662963867,
0.7208751440048218,
0.89521723985672,
0.7044780850410461,
0.0013052338035777211,
0.5135351419448853,
-0.729073166847229,
0.10996794700622559,
0.051386963576078415,
0.5431080460548401,
0.1529950499534607,
-0.0878152996301651,
0.577517032623291,
0.1453528255224228,
-0.5957698225975037,
-0.6121576428413391,
0.07157538831233978,
-1.0039299726486206,
-0.34667739272117615,
0.8837096095085144,
-0.4698094129562378,
-0.17520417273044586,
-0.42177078127861023,
0.21932002902030945,
0.2537316381931305,
-0.3218349814414978,
0.9841985106468201,
1.0026042461395264,
0.09200466424226761,
-0.2539803087711334,
-0.5140067338943481,
0.18781878054141998,
0.4326026737689972,
-0.8457634449005127,
0.33760640025138855,
0.6261602640151978,
0.114291250705719,
0.31172555685043335,
0.7843266129493713,
-0.032334525138139725,
0.08255340158939362,
0.3901115357875824,
0.09887350350618362,
-0.034171514213085175,
-0.44704481959342957,
-0.19799956679344177,
0.5629646182060242,
0.03349371626973152,
-0.06335125863552094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16079v1 | EERPD: Leveraging Emotion and Emotion Regulation for Improving Personality Detection | 2024-06-23T11:18:55 | 2024-06-23T11:18:55 | Zheng Li, Dawei Zhu, Qilong Ma, Weimin Xiong, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Personality is a fundamental construct in psychology, reflecting an
individual's behavior, thinking, and emotional patterns. Previous researches
have made some progress in personality detection, primarily by utilizing the
whole text to predict personality. However, these studies generally tend to
overlook psychological knowledge: they rarely apply the well-established
correlations between emotion regulation and personality. Based on this, we
propose a new personality detection method called EERPD. This method introduces
the use of emotion regulation, a psychological concept highly correlated with
personality, for personality prediction. By combining this feature with emotion
features, it retrieves few-shot examples and provides process CoTs for
inferring labels from text. This approach enhances the understanding of LLM for
personality within text and improves the performance in personality detection.
Experimental results demonstrate that EERPD significantly enhances the accuracy
and robustness of personality detection, outperforming previous SOTA by
15.05/4.29 in average F1 on the two benchmark datasets. | [
-0.7430445551872253,
-0.5382547974586487,
0.5048215985298157,
0.33386990427970886,
-0.12984462082386017,
-0.04443500563502312,
-0.26494380831718445,
-0.60117506980896,
0.2865784764289856,
0.6009231805801392,
-0.6173456907272339,
-0.39617598056793213,
-0.6323476433753967,
0.256206750869751,
-0.07457567006349564,
0.930435836315155,
0.03570965304970741,
0.01747177541255951,
-0.08239714056253433,
0.0030630198307335377,
-0.40658193826675415,
-0.8429065346717834,
-0.697856605052948,
-0.49885714054107666,
0.765106201171875,
0.5066668391227722,
-0.35605672001838684,
0.36636480689048767,
0.5000284910202026,
0.34830978512763977,
-0.39682459831237793,
0.05298655107617378,
-0.4439622461795807,
0.21395069360733032,
0.009168172255158424,
-0.3867516815662384,
-0.583755612373352,
-0.04836304485797882,
0.2736271619796753,
-0.03774929419159889,
-0.2020704448223114,
-0.03182942047715187,
0.1710754781961441,
0.8636726140975952,
-0.9567581415176392,
-0.031483881175518036,
-0.14779813587665558,
0.354364275932312,
-0.33667659759521484,
-0.4908113479614258,
-0.48158782720565796,
-0.2909467816352844,
0.04879496619105339,
-0.028376994654536247,
0.0459558330476284,
0.21407432854175568,
0.4960019886493683,
0.1077844426035881,
-0.6127650141716003,
-0.24843260645866394,
-0.7645809650421143,
0.30206069350242615,
-0.2336401641368866,
0.16020286083221436,
0.6204249858856201,
0.17513813078403473,
0.013825303874909878,
-0.2960304021835327,
-0.7704409956932068,
0.05705328285694122,
-0.030687853693962097,
0.16992877423763275,
-0.08924731612205505,
0.2389983832836151,
0.32060378789901733,
0.23619574308395386,
-0.19342845678329468,
0.11880635470151901,
0.12145725637674332,
-0.10257357358932495,
0.5147675275802612,
0.12689240276813507,
0.11506160348653793,
-0.05289636552333832,
-0.07753116637468338,
-0.47137483954429626,
-0.38963085412979126,
0.1820407509803772,
0.41067811846733093,
-0.02888469398021698,
0.09881019592285156,
0.45668894052505493,
-0.11590911448001862,
0.18358656764030457,
0.6013584733009338,
0.03300061821937561,
0.2867312729358673,
0.3372946083545685,
-0.1271859109401703,
0.17596645653247833,
0.41030266880989075,
0.6685715913772583,
0.21480929851531982,
0.332252562046051,
-0.025765705853700638,
-0.085852712392807,
0.1791715770959854,
-0.9520854353904724,
-0.21473300457000732,
0.34562623500823975,
-0.8399459719657898,
-0.2655240595340729,
0.1853933334350586,
-1.3302092552185059,
-0.7074542045593262,
-0.17484194040298462,
0.22577454149723053,
-0.6900211572647095,
-0.4365028738975525,
0.032317645847797394,
-0.13767579197883606,
0.32970917224884033,
0.27011433243751526,
-1.2552119493484497,
0.05563099682331085,
0.8252795934677124,
0.7770511507987976,
-0.29327794909477234,
-0.10411450266838074,
-0.3805779814720154,
-0.08649158477783203,
-0.06536654382944107,
1.1141161918640137,
-0.661174476146698,
-0.5090157985687256,
-0.03088657557964325,
-0.12615488469600677,
0.3316802382469177,
-0.41432976722717285,
0.7809875011444092,
-0.16969090700149536,
-0.08030013740062714,
-0.5072751641273499,
-0.8632250428199768,
-0.21112588047981262,
0.2521202564239502,
-0.35296064615249634,
1.0574067831039429,
0.10033529251813889,
-0.5979409217834473,
0.567495584487915,
-0.5816811323165894,
-0.24681483209133148,
0.14775685966014862,
0.15010741353034973,
-0.5127939581871033,
0.19544118642807007,
0.06336855888366699,
0.7203028798103333,
0.3054672181606293,
-0.13119982182979584,
-0.45515939593315125,
-0.12665536999702454,
0.2981545627117157,
0.19934941828250885,
0.2513536214828491,
0.3136030435562134,
-0.19451940059661865,
0.09419874846935272,
-0.7551800608634949,
0.21375103294849396,
-0.3504798710346222,
-0.3469294011592865,
-0.5275253653526306,
0.1364506334066391,
0.29850268363952637,
0.08797865360975266,
-0.029870333150029182,
-0.7496681213378906,
-0.14854343235492706,
0.21695955097675323,
0.024188611656427383,
0.9547230005264282,
0.16313536465168,
0.26341143250465393,
-0.26195111870765686,
0.6226077079772949,
-0.32295477390289307,
0.037049178034067154,
-0.04802535101771355,
-0.34938475489616394,
-0.5953333377838135,
-0.6252453923225403,
-0.10070500522851944,
0.5122294425964355,
0.09977193176746368,
1.4121980667114258,
0.43826204538345337,
-0.7094597220420837,
-0.024705149233341217,
-0.1694151908159256,
0.5216725468635559,
0.5694189667701721,
0.33752739429473877,
-0.31806227564811707,
-0.7960402369499207,
-0.3648640215396881,
-0.6960938572883606,
0.03406229615211487,
-0.3769861161708832,
0.3078318238258362,
0.48662540316581726,
-0.18837639689445496,
0.8148071765899658,
-0.5036559700965881,
-0.5770785212516785,
-0.22582894563674927,
0.4323316216468811,
-0.19870898127555847,
0.5376402735710144,
0.5097469091415405,
-0.8064699769020081,
-0.8766590356826782,
0.038780953735113144,
-0.2632569968700409,
-0.44304439425468445,
0.08365440368652344,
-0.3415625989437103,
-0.020559582859277725,
0.5284669399261475,
-0.0904502347111702,
0.4600463807582855,
0.23296156525611877,
-1.0239399671554565,
0.5245482921600342,
-0.19603769481182098,
0.3876672387123108,
-0.5294092893600464,
0.11579471081495285,
0.30073657631874084,
-0.24800631403923035,
-0.6556709408760071,
-0.004727535881102085,
0.3207475244998932,
0.19917051494121552,
-0.26959386467933655,
0.31166520714759827,
-0.17807337641716003,
0.12093709409236908,
-0.36626723408699036,
-0.18595701456069946,
-0.21084614098072052,
0.4615921378135681,
0.22961948812007904,
0.2732483446598053,
0.3870537281036377,
-0.6226242780685425,
0.1518252193927765,
0.5604281425476074,
-0.4928489923477173,
1.4125758409500122,
-0.25029969215393066,
0.46127012372016907,
-0.5535586476325989,
0.4155237674713135,
-0.8198330402374268,
-0.41780000925064087,
-0.049000535160303116,
-0.20480459928512573,
0.4826575517654419,
0.24350999295711517,
-0.22749558091163635,
-0.31804078817367554,
-0.37183859944343567,
-0.2449478954076767,
0.730915904045105,
-0.5209508538246155,
1.013989806175232,
0.19956885278224945,
-0.15809188783168793,
0.10059589147567749,
-0.7488388419151306,
-0.20461979508399963,
-0.4022386372089386,
-0.3039819300174713,
0.5730258226394653,
-0.326334148645401,
-0.0730966329574585,
-0.11564446985721588,
-0.16051232814788818,
-0.13200177252292633,
-0.15280970931053162,
0.27613747119903564,
0.15002085268497467,
0.23847368359565735,
0.24191826581954956,
-0.05412338301539421,
-0.1284160017967224,
0.046064503490924835,
0.6292653679847717,
0.6467490196228027,
-0.20450851321220398,
-0.06378079205751419,
-0.5981503129005432,
0.4968155026435852,
0.47537463903427124,
-0.22840429842472076,
0.8060463070869446,
0.8028430342674255,
-0.3576817810535431,
-0.18197907507419586,
-0.7258133888244629,
-0.3829147517681122,
-0.5439947843551636,
0.47751545906066895,
-0.39434391260147095,
-0.9604210257530212,
0.6608707904815674,
-0.2756160497665405,
-0.5690239667892456,
0.07329915463924408,
0.711806058883667,
-0.4025239944458008,
1.1100716590881348,
0.9696114659309387,
0.24850958585739136,
1.015724778175354,
0.20934048295021057,
0.17551212012767792,
-1.2894312143325806,
-0.5689259171485901,
-0.66762775182724,
-0.7381190657615662,
-0.7116870880126953,
-0.12335767596960068,
0.24499475955963135,
-0.17051535844802856,
-0.4496324956417084,
0.04587477818131447,
-0.8204009532928467,
0.7424322962760925,
0.22934606671333313,
0.5663573741912842,
0.015236074104905128,
-0.31298598647117615,
0.26851460337638855,
-0.4224473834037781,
0.2137455940246582,
-0.5069153904914856,
1.2270255088806152,
0.23680095374584198,
0.6079784631729126,
0.07129459083080292,
0.7532555460929871,
0.5532111525535583,
0.7404599189758301,
-0.7338017225265503,
0.5087814927101135,
-0.22421108186244965,
-0.5456543564796448,
-0.09207534044981003,
-0.1695406138896942,
-0.32256343960762024,
0.20648153126239777,
-0.3286893665790558,
-1.267867922782898,
0.5607525110244751,
0.4317619204521179,
-0.44993823766708374,
0.1965346485376358,
-1.035731315612793,
0.5343307852745056,
-0.23080308735370636,
-0.3778800368309021,
-0.2666563391685486,
-0.4990129768848419,
0.2560727000236511,
-0.30243468284606934,
-0.15083596110343933,
-0.3402515649795532,
0.07405456900596619,
0.7848365902900696,
-0.5790896415710449,
0.5574817061424255,
-0.2980351746082306,
0.12890441715717316,
-0.0341903492808342,
0.039656251668930054,
0.6283703446388245,
-0.20670311152935028,
-0.30532288551330566,
-0.2744346857070923,
0.15553265810012817,
0.04629835858941078,
-0.6267537474632263,
0.5354552268981934,
-0.544378936290741,
-0.13874471187591553,
-0.4308137595653534,
-0.2699005603790283,
-0.3679911196231842,
0.03923160210251808,
0.48125648498535156,
-0.0880589485168457,
-0.2997018098831177,
0.40316176414489746,
0.9078534245491028,
-0.21607382595539093,
0.28715279698371887,
0.5835632681846619,
-0.21319341659545898,
-0.26098233461380005,
0.40811654925346375,
-0.20992125570774078,
-0.0029805765952914953,
0.46552470326423645,
0.4745245575904846,
-0.4061194658279419,
0.12228962779045105,
0.5197851657867432,
0.0039077019318938255,
-0.6271122694015503,
-0.20898555219173431,
-0.8075922727584839,
0.22124417126178741,
-0.4544393718242645,
-0.39916732907295227,
-0.40143027901649475,
0.23781098425388336,
-0.2304961085319519,
-0.18163417279720306,
0.638568103313446,
0.6364650130271912,
-0.27487969398498535,
0.22752386331558228,
-0.33963119983673096,
0.38382792472839355,
0.5365538597106934,
0.5188114643096924,
-0.023253513500094414,
-0.3854866027832031,
0.25034305453300476,
-0.3356988728046417,
-0.6857002377510071,
-1.2869821786880493,
0.6148529052734375,
0.6159652471542358,
0.16577720642089844,
0.94624263048172,
0.18137024343013763,
0.5485444664955139,
-0.3004176616668701,
0.26762959361076355,
0.12738320231437683,
-1.3625409603118896,
0.7409248948097229,
0.02587311342358589,
-0.09602602571249008,
0.557610034942627,
0.3276365101337433,
-0.9095048308372498,
-0.2221621423959732,
-0.3405716121196747,
-0.5912203788757324,
0.6999140977859497,
0.06878513842821121,
0.07106059044599533,
0.0252732764929533,
0.638841986656189,
-0.00996534712612629,
0.16933710873126984,
-0.5793772339820862,
-0.0800366923213005,
-0.08952880650758743,
-0.3984054625034332,
0.17118310928344727,
-0.6689088344573975,
0.12687045335769653,
-0.7323315143585205,
0.4934009909629822,
-0.09946239739656448,
0.8719894289970398,
0.5597994923591614,
0.4469195604324341,
-0.20958282053470612,
0.3304564654827118,
0.5113853812217712,
0.004470867104828358,
-0.6551055908203125,
0.11416302621364594,
-0.012634772807359695,
-0.6091323494911194,
0.2813950181007385,
-0.3390447199344635,
0.17758828401565552,
-0.4221053421497345,
0.03604864701628685,
0.7198948860168457,
-0.0860852301120758,
-0.6332078576087952,
0.41842809319496155,
-0.0074815344996750355,
-0.3575885593891144,
-0.24455134570598602,
0.19634351134300232,
-0.06238877400755882,
0.3927169740200043,
0.2976621985435486,
0.19636499881744385,
0.20698826014995575,
-0.5670996308326721,
0.3087514638900757,
0.11227985471487045,
-0.4053991436958313,
-0.3259153962135315,
0.5302513837814331,
0.3541226089000702,
-0.5594564080238342,
0.4947201907634735,
-0.44193702936172485,
-0.8248890042304993,
0.9607265591621399,
0.6921746134757996,
1.1387321949005127,
-0.46486613154411316,
0.20035451650619507,
0.30512872338294983,
-0.10421621054410934,
-0.27976301312446594,
0.7733432650566101,
-0.1252228170633316,
-1.0033230781555176,
-0.37416961789131165,
-0.49263131618499756,
-0.7212561368942261,
0.17298929393291473,
-1.0004667043685913,
0.5405495762825012,
-0.6942363381385803,
-0.19676627218723297,
-0.12428564578294754,
-0.11105091124773026,
-0.582099199295044,
0.00040625035762786865,
0.28859347105026245,
0.9159899353981018,
-0.8430877327919006,
0.5899145603179932,
0.7779223918914795,
0.17570772767066956,
-0.790783703327179,
0.030810020864009857,
0.2895234227180481,
-0.4478721022605896,
0.49719375371932983,
0.5506946444511414,
0.012398922815918922,
0.28121417760849,
-0.5686960220336914,
-0.3489198088645935,
0.9210095405578613,
0.23471692204475403,
-0.7214282155036926,
0.43434882164001465,
-0.6333935856819153,
0.8492568135261536,
-0.509759247303009,
0.43116796016693115,
0.8087077140808105,
0.8869283199310303,
0.236823171377182,
-0.4084179103374481,
-0.0915636420249939,
-0.34316620230674744,
0.010220672935247421,
0.2691599428653717,
-0.6517878770828247,
0.7199845910072327,
-0.19056174159049988,
-0.18257591128349304,
-0.06417177617549896,
0.5106135010719299,
0.3128564655780792,
0.32820436358451843,
0.49741435050964355,
0.5350460410118103,
1.0432862043380737,
-0.14164207875728607,
0.9140555262565613,
-0.3281680643558502,
0.549100935459137,
1.0741004943847656,
-0.7435379028320312,
1.1649770736694336,
0.4699660539627075,
-0.32800862193107605,
0.9000504016876221,
0.8044437170028687,
-0.20584842562675476,
0.7236544489860535,
-0.026971645653247833,
-0.4797773063182831,
-0.25120604038238525,
-0.16099826991558075,
-0.1394197791814804,
0.667992115020752,
0.44037625193595886,
-0.3910285532474518,
0.18250015377998352,
0.48969975113868713,
0.025844313204288483,
0.3624535799026489,
-0.32124632596969604,
0.5980696678161621,
-0.36933770775794983,
-0.5138705968856812,
-0.0833141952753067,
-0.14141690731048584,
1.1491292715072632,
-0.4327890872955322,
0.047468509525060654,
-0.354927659034729,
0.4140303134918213,
-0.3607400357723236,
-0.7722949385643005,
0.31768569350242615,
0.2374311089515686,
-0.006503662560135126,
-0.7868769764900208,
0.8792154788970947,
-0.4941146671772003,
-0.09923084825277328,
0.22601963579654694,
0.13953907787799835,
-0.07173812389373779,
-0.4676853120326996,
-0.1547575145959854,
-0.04945695400238037,
-0.10852926969528198,
-0.3541182279586792,
0.3170146942138672,
0.5730471611022949,
0.5381786823272705,
0.7197639346122742,
0.36884939670562744,
0.12571260333061218,
-0.08948462456464767,
-0.3225227892398834,
0.5724185109138489,
-0.727340817451477,
-0.8684253096580505,
-1.007625699043274,
0.3707415759563446,
-0.2879166007041931,
-0.5192784070968628,
0.5006266832351685,
0.06268253922462463,
0.628965437412262,
-0.1600552648305893,
0.5049044489860535,
-0.652776837348938,
0.6345022916793823,
-0.35487768054008484,
0.7229229807853699,
-0.2833534777164459,
-0.10839186608791351,
-0.4743938446044922,
-0.9029135704040527,
-0.27486681938171387,
0.8870745897293091,
-0.1324961930513382,
0.38137468695640564,
0.9277560710906982,
0.761096179485321,
0.2805516719818115,
0.14764121174812317,
0.2062656134366989,
0.1769716441631317,
0.35071104764938354,
0.4542960524559021,
0.44911786913871765,
0.11658097803592682,
0.16368581354618073,
-0.5219675302505493,
-0.5777792930603027,
-0.5965951085090637,
-1.1376948356628418,
-0.9660757780075073,
-0.4703647792339325,
-0.4494168758392334,
-0.2392556071281433,
-0.28500834107398987,
0.8846476078033447,
0.6929710507392883,
-0.7907180786132812,
0.16180704534053802,
-0.3920160233974457,
0.04010932892560959,
-0.4394929111003876,
-0.3025193512439728,
0.12376254051923752,
0.11766795814037323,
-0.7314126491546631,
-0.141677126288414,
0.39071106910705566,
0.10438599437475204,
-0.18552690744400024,
-0.3399851322174072,
-0.07930399477481842,
0.04789651185274124,
0.618797779083252,
0.47834840416908264,
-0.38602834939956665,
-0.6940040588378906,
-0.047752056270837784,
0.0070457435213029385,
0.02863582782447338,
1.0038701295852661,
-0.4255255460739136,
0.5839696526527405,
0.6049185395240784,
0.2197689712047577,
0.39342251420021057,
0.11175985634326935,
0.38605886697769165,
-0.862912118434906,
0.14879655838012695,
0.25822100043296814,
0.1622592657804489,
0.1640591323375702,
-0.8832827210426331,
0.38947418332099915,
0.07795705646276474,
-0.8693528771400452,
-0.5808864235877991,
0.3258918821811676,
-0.9391040802001953,
0.04698232188820839,
0.9333114624023438,
-0.19024313986301422,
-0.2766382396221161,
-0.10293616354465485,
-0.5092217326164246,
-0.017133839428424835,
-0.6866858005523682,
1.095063328742981,
0.9035205841064453,
-0.8530949354171753,
-0.5792469382286072,
-0.1129661500453949,
0.7312746644020081,
0.44714781641960144,
-1.1405109167099,
0.0848434567451477,
0.2372439056634903,
0.17030124366283417,
0.04183807969093323,
0.7737109661102295,
0.0692949891090393,
0.20807959139347076,
-0.2760910093784332,
0.5569005608558655,
0.23550072312355042,
0.11943481862545013,
-0.37064075469970703,
0.10894280672073364,
-0.16235944628715515,
-0.024915089830756187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16078v1 | First Heuristic Then Rational: Dynamic Use of Heuristics in Language Model Reasoning | 2024-06-23T11:11:46 | 2024-06-23T11:11:46 | Yoichi Aoki, Keito Kudo, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Shusaku Sone, Masaya Taniguchi, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-step reasoning is widely adopted in the community to explore the better
performance of language models (LMs). We report on the systematic strategy that
LMs use in this process. Our controlled experiments reveal that LMs rely more
heavily on heuristics, such as lexical overlap, in the earlier stages of
reasoning when more steps are required to reach an answer. Conversely, as LMs
progress closer to the final answer, their reliance on heuristics decreases.
This suggests that LMs track only a limited number of future steps and
dynamically combine heuristic strategies with logical ones in tasks involving
multi-step reasoning. | [
-0.5010429620742798,
-0.727370023727417,
0.9733358025550842,
0.12144028395414352,
0.0003684793191496283,
0.5311039090156555,
-0.07442596554756165,
-0.4003337621688843,
-0.17396028339862823,
0.27797770500183105,
-0.8127666711807251,
-0.1730923056602478,
-0.5104817152023315,
0.021143868565559387,
-0.4110182821750641,
0.38906845450401306,
-0.26628899574279785,
0.08831954747438431,
-0.06058398634195328,
-0.09309248626232147,
-0.40738558769226074,
-0.40377259254455566,
-0.5783098936080933,
-0.8428735136985779,
0.8917535543441772,
0.5295293927192688,
1.0608417987823486,
0.5339561700820923,
0.5198023319244385,
0.34142568707466125,
-0.22808103263378143,
0.11204676330089569,
-0.06383395940065384,
0.36117735505104065,
-0.09498409181833267,
-0.5437405705451965,
0.011015080846846104,
0.08353710919618607,
0.4621589183807373,
0.7992281317710876,
-0.45347830653190613,
0.17878368496894836,
-0.2787575423717499,
0.7234365344047546,
-0.5687440037727356,
0.16928765177726746,
-0.37904366850852966,
0.05484458804130554,
-0.371279239654541,
-0.4164225459098816,
-0.374460905790329,
-0.36139115691185,
0.27301692962646484,
-0.41846004128456116,
-0.42695391178131104,
-0.10613597184419632,
0.6806885600090027,
0.28530290722846985,
-0.25645560026168823,
-0.33469200134277344,
-1.0026946067810059,
0.9490942358970642,
-0.6878228783607483,
0.49110549688339233,
0.19883371889591217,
0.5538780689239502,
-0.10174742341041565,
-0.5751789808273315,
-0.48479804396629333,
-0.5265657305717468,
-0.11323436349630356,
-0.4873007535934448,
0.23503540456295013,
-0.017839547246694565,
0.6732602119445801,
-0.012390249408781528,
-0.23194418847560883,
0.11891680210828781,
-0.3825877010822296,
-0.1291244626045227,
0.573631227016449,
0.43592050671577454,
0.10333887487649918,
0.016293827444314957,
-0.35039395093917847,
-0.13244746625423431,
-0.5725764036178589,
0.3353402614593506,
0.1580401211977005,
0.28223949670791626,
0.3150940239429474,
0.6421146988868713,
-0.22067931294441223,
0.7013307809829712,
-0.2550693452358246,
-0.6369284391403198,
0.03278535604476929,
-0.7820757627487183,
-0.02329968474805355,
0.09255413711071014,
0.5841697454452515,
0.09150081872940063,
0.6741893291473389,
0.1164424940943718,
-0.33384886384010315,
0.30350497364997864,
0.11078228801488876,
-0.5159507989883423,
-0.05622655898332596,
0.21550630033016205,
-0.31919005513191223,
-0.08014931529760361,
-0.3320619463920593,
-0.5316871404647827,
-0.2193080186843872,
-0.5510483384132385,
0.3654238283634186,
-0.5812584757804871,
-0.29745402932167053,
0.27125635743141174,
-0.14664752781391144,
-0.0008379468927159905,
0.45360344648361206,
-0.6676872968673706,
0.5372109413146973,
0.7422890067100525,
0.8436532616615295,
0.08563704788684845,
-0.4317760169506073,
-0.4269133508205414,
0.04409999027848244,
-0.5420196652412415,
0.8553587198257446,
-0.7811302542686462,
-0.25262072682380676,
-0.01899779960513115,
-0.18521440029144287,
-0.04760017246007919,
-0.37619781494140625,
0.47070369124412537,
-0.7170131802558899,
0.28148314356803894,
-0.5793474912643433,
-0.7195240259170532,
-0.41243094205856323,
0.13244542479515076,
-0.6893599629402161,
1.2096062898635864,
0.005472209770232439,
-0.41561007499694824,
0.5875283479690552,
-0.7490355968475342,
-0.37294483184814453,
-0.017501475289463997,
-0.1397455632686615,
-0.08626312017440796,
0.12973855435848236,
-0.09864386916160583,
0.23719584941864014,
-0.4282940924167633,
0.033855993300676346,
-0.3173592984676361,
-0.4035308361053467,
0.2865346074104309,
-0.3780023455619812,
0.5802611708641052,
0.27387315034866333,
-0.365310400724411,
0.3520432710647583,
-0.7143078446388245,
0.25147581100463867,
0.24844631552696228,
-0.5021053552627563,
-0.48299601674079895,
0.4775703549385071,
-0.4086189568042755,
0.48098185658454895,
-0.014748559333384037,
0.08317340910434723,
0.24629433453083038,
-0.20790353417396545,
0.32063573598861694,
0.6090747117996216,
-0.20714467763900757,
0.6790757775306702,
-0.5915268659591675,
0.5797784924507141,
-0.1346616894006729,
0.11318982392549515,
-0.6656747460365295,
-0.5884730219841003,
-0.7382545471191406,
-0.10738606005907059,
0.24706193804740906,
0.879013180732727,
-0.5847628116607666,
0.03882903605699539,
0.1519075185060501,
-0.5194465517997742,
-0.24302466213703156,
0.17615114152431488,
0.2121850550174713,
-0.07747071981430054,
0.19877973198890686,
-0.08315461874008179,
-0.45075318217277527,
-0.638901948928833,
-0.5095264911651611,
-0.1148764044046402,
0.4868614077568054,
-0.09782852977514267,
0.5641972422599792,
0.08227389305830002,
0.5855684876441956,
-0.345857709646225,
0.18644729256629944,
-0.3260960578918457,
0.24589912593364716,
0.17695821821689606,
0.36892470717430115,
0.2968665659427643,
-0.3952856957912445,
-0.5748533010482788,
-0.37157464027404785,
-0.5778084993362427,
-0.11728527396917343,
-0.284686416387558,
-0.1489032357931137,
0.2359641194343567,
0.7826753854751587,
-0.8291387557983398,
0.30380427837371826,
0.317081093788147,
-0.3638114929199219,
0.5713808536529541,
-0.1493528038263321,
0.13153395056724548,
-0.6711229085922241,
-0.49192774295806885,
0.09356507658958435,
-0.22460851073265076,
-0.7594164609909058,
0.18117421865463257,
-0.07816876471042633,
0.3909660875797272,
-0.28693515062332153,
0.5496588945388794,
-0.8721093535423279,
-0.21974410116672516,
-0.22815126180648804,
0.18468469381332397,
-0.14312267303466797,
0.19250179827213287,
-0.00011566901230253279,
0.6327702403068542,
0.6347972750663757,
-0.6986511945724487,
0.3978740870952606,
-0.2774450182914734,
-0.6388593316078186,
0.2160971462726593,
-0.494627982378006,
0.0672360435128212,
-0.05037134513258934,
-0.07564447075128555,
-1.0486031770706177,
0.0042032902128994465,
0.12367496639490128,
-0.2490619719028473,
0.23078683018684387,
0.17242653667926788,
-0.8304365277290344,
-0.6786170601844788,
-0.2626066505908966,
0.2713060677051544,
0.4067465364933014,
-0.2034066915512085,
0.447222501039505,
0.14094091951847076,
-0.08256994932889938,
-0.42893946170806885,
-0.42338326573371887,
-0.014952480792999268,
-0.25199994444847107,
-0.5613120198249817,
0.1491241455078125,
-0.15042045712471008,
-0.6921766996383667,
-0.011019053868949413,
-0.13232672214508057,
0.01149118784815073,
0.30646032094955444,
-0.29129481315612793,
0.07582012563943863,
-0.3132351040840149,
-0.11817511171102524,
-0.059519894421100616,
-0.17409197986125946,
0.14869490265846252,
-0.11779516190290451,
0.9285717606544495,
-0.04165294021368027,
-0.6891713738441467,
-0.651741087436676,
0.49354490637779236,
0.8258638978004456,
-0.12479995936155319,
0.9804489016532898,
0.41227227449417114,
-0.5764042735099792,
0.19517436623573303,
-0.504856526851654,
-0.3526749908924103,
-0.4543227553367615,
0.1327333003282547,
-0.6033334732055664,
-0.6702080965042114,
0.5913592576980591,
-0.30115851759910583,
0.26330122351646423,
0.20031926035881042,
0.71391761302948,
-0.16973568499088287,
1.3913962841033936,
0.46286359429359436,
0.27203795313835144,
0.5162934064865112,
-0.10257063060998917,
0.2938527762889862,
-0.6118417978286743,
-0.5479454398155212,
-0.68074631690979,
-0.3491535186767578,
-0.5584694743156433,
-0.7468963265419006,
0.1999240517616272,
0.5427395701408386,
-0.2401709109544754,
0.2378314733505249,
-0.19764502346515656,
0.5378801822662354,
0.6058184504508972,
-0.1567952036857605,
0.47968021035194397,
0.026450030505657196,
-0.4519868791103363,
-0.12172431498765945,
-0.9533339142799377,
-0.5382076501846313,
0.6917475461959839,
0.49597904086112976,
0.7926861047744751,
0.3686366677284241,
0.5262343883514404,
0.028090182691812515,
0.26176586747169495,
-0.9011889100074768,
0.7363885641098022,
0.35168376564979553,
-0.7728923559188843,
-0.5206518769264221,
-0.18597911298274994,
-0.8682839870452881,
0.40671223402023315,
-0.12824071943759918,
-0.7091063857078552,
-0.18207897245883942,
0.052425336092710495,
-0.49029019474983215,
0.16744282841682434,
-0.5332460403442383,
0.5208449959754944,
-0.3519950211048126,
-0.4999552369117737,
-0.43688151240348816,
-0.501497745513916,
0.46703237295150757,
-0.007068068254739046,
0.5562888383865356,
-0.288982629776001,
-0.22447621822357178,
0.4777945280075073,
-0.6366105079650879,
0.5878382921218872,
-0.10767906159162521,
-0.14472152292728424,
0.23584668338298798,
0.31009891629219055,
0.5007122159004211,
-0.16806606948375702,
0.08914007991552353,
-0.06516284495592117,
0.24934658408164978,
-0.4375987648963928,
-0.45074835419654846,
0.5544217228889465,
-0.2920127511024475,
-1.0095630884170532,
-0.7789565324783325,
-0.469250351190567,
-0.22876086831092834,
0.2647593319416046,
-0.07964875549077988,
0.2733286917209625,
0.13861088454723358,
-0.02133352681994438,
0.6139296889305115,
-0.017475668340921402,
0.6985943913459778,
0.5155227184295654,
-0.4793989360332489,
-0.15344533324241638,
0.22291383147239685,
0.17282426357269287,
0.7499039173126221,
0.08708257973194122,
0.550804853439331,
-0.3121119439601898,
-0.43222153186798096,
-0.4342579245567322,
0.16389842331409454,
-0.8556972146034241,
0.1618233472108841,
-0.5470554232597351,
-0.23306430876255035,
-0.27854666113853455,
-0.02826208807528019,
-0.37816357612609863,
-0.4569559693336487,
0.17110171914100647,
0.11292947828769684,
0.4130358397960663,
0.6464998126029968,
-0.12424135953187943,
0.35603341460227966,
-0.9594486951828003,
0.18313534557819366,
0.12751741707324982,
0.2667683959007263,
0.13505865633487701,
-0.3031044006347656,
-0.17374837398529053,
-0.2769670784473419,
-0.1261228621006012,
-1.219201683998108,
0.09461196511983871,
-0.08758793026208878,
1.022621512413025,
0.38921236991882324,
-0.4490789771080017,
0.6813120245933533,
-0.7582342624664307,
0.7090898752212524,
0.2437785565853119,
-0.8182110786437988,
0.4064890146255493,
-0.37094348669052124,
0.7082238793373108,
0.44761529564857483,
0.7235308885574341,
-0.4547245502471924,
-0.07393193244934082,
-0.2357523888349533,
-0.7531720995903015,
0.8105637431144714,
0.1575995832681656,
-0.040443502366542816,
0.1817038357257843,
0.3568776547908783,
-0.015780407935380936,
0.34553584456443787,
-0.5828983187675476,
-0.2805996537208557,
0.45086097717285156,
0.11048318445682526,
0.010527118109166622,
-0.3097060024738312,
-0.2593989372253418,
-0.6180103421211243,
0.48333540558815,
-0.1593800187110901,
0.04363991320133209,
-0.137612447142601,
-0.06930797547101974,
-0.33416134119033813,
0.10782276093959808,
0.8004079461097717,
0.8176535367965698,
0.11925322562456131,
0.08354700356721878,
0.10970254242420197,
0.04157959669828415,
0.14504475891590118,
-0.053804755210876465,
-0.14936672151088715,
0.08711890131235123,
0.5122783184051514,
0.9193490147590637,
0.37307435274124146,
-0.669461190700531,
0.09361744672060013,
0.17439678311347961,
-0.22541937232017517,
-0.5249689221382141,
0.19828124344348907,
0.32704973220825195,
0.6172526478767395,
0.017854254692792892,
0.22341598570346832,
-0.05815669149160385,
-0.9828004837036133,
0.28444981575012207,
0.3232589066028595,
-0.055855948477983475,
-0.05816901847720146,
0.4774845838546753,
-0.1355312317609787,
-0.7447889447212219,
0.2514185607433319,
-0.23938922584056854,
-0.805145800113678,
0.4388173818588257,
0.23517480492591858,
0.6272717118263245,
-0.5409843921661377,
0.19152313470840454,
0.34623852372169495,
0.4732246696949005,
-0.732759952545166,
0.649266242980957,
-0.2023860365152359,
-0.7827302813529968,
-0.8136107921600342,
-0.5004464387893677,
-0.3598463237285614,
-0.07814158499240875,
-0.34241804480552673,
0.5705403685569763,
-0.4966464936733246,
-0.23183518648147583,
0.10585779696702957,
-0.1080976277589798,
-0.5731531381607056,
-0.05499330908060074,
0.3136749565601349,
1.280537486076355,
-0.4516802728176117,
0.734976589679718,
0.6005661487579346,
-0.45079338550567627,
-0.854503333568573,
-0.008584407158195972,
0.5016980171203613,
-0.7995667457580566,
0.6576910614967346,
0.06956712901592255,
-0.27621278166770935,
-0.2343561053276062,
-0.1424516886472702,
-1.172795295715332,
0.9825373888015747,
-0.10838114470243454,
-0.7797630429267883,
-0.29732054471969604,
0.12813299894332886,
0.49031779170036316,
-0.318364679813385,
0.2777475416660309,
0.8079071640968323,
0.6853758692741394,
0.4596347212791443,
-0.9689245820045471,
0.03743206337094307,
0.14826960861682892,
-0.06495773792266846,
0.4221770465373993,
-0.618000864982605,
1.1453661918640137,
-0.6045025587081909,
-0.10808700323104858,
0.2594549357891083,
0.37742725014686584,
0.5820272564888,
0.4106191396713257,
0.8150722980499268,
0.5252701640129089,
0.8768795728683472,
-0.1719580441713333,
1.1039363145828247,
-0.45875293016433716,
0.22291314601898193,
0.9272387027740479,
-0.46075916290283203,
0.7343373894691467,
0.3278322219848633,
-0.27301785349845886,
0.6673182249069214,
0.9015922546386719,
0.39749443531036377,
0.608123779296875,
0.4035317003726959,
-0.310592383146286,
-0.5019426345825195,
0.17316775023937225,
-0.12165453284978867,
0.4347042739391327,
0.5805004835128784,
-0.16159610450267792,
-0.22906619310379028,
-0.1881152093410492,
0.42694345116615295,
0.1779569387435913,
-0.15363147854804993,
0.6619827151298523,
0.12012691795825958,
-0.9523898959159851,
0.6474305391311646,
0.020025167614221573,
0.3573700189590454,
-0.5388002991676331,
0.09183790534734726,
-0.010477331466972828,
0.23956841230392456,
-0.01122406218200922,
-0.8768215179443359,
0.3337142765522003,
-0.11775139719247818,
-0.17649082839488983,
-0.42585843801498413,
0.8184449672698975,
-0.49424898624420166,
-0.4117755591869354,
0.6205991506576538,
0.9182608127593994,
0.011098984628915787,
0.06509772688150406,
-0.9594781994819641,
0.14536091685295105,
-0.3185276687145233,
-0.5280130505561829,
0.1007179319858551,
0.5789153575897217,
-0.3175603747367859,
0.9164471626281738,
0.7550920248031616,
0.07428325712680817,
0.2135199010372162,
0.49303606152534485,
0.741224467754364,
-0.9952952861785889,
-0.26695969700813293,
-1.1821271181106567,
0.4221951365470886,
-0.055802326649427414,
-0.06236346438527107,
0.5702447891235352,
0.2386532425880432,
0.7132216691970825,
0.34232452511787415,
0.6791828870773315,
0.22998367249965668,
0.529218316078186,
-0.8371009826660156,
0.13258470594882965,
-0.8220268487930298,
0.6226903200149536,
-0.22605350613594055,
-0.8528469800949097,
-0.10222746431827545,
0.6674220561981201,
-0.06661253422498703,
0.42224928736686707,
1.1509147882461548,
0.6212748289108276,
0.314039945602417,
0.1376083642244339,
0.39065736532211304,
0.13107530772686005,
0.27142536640167236,
0.4663342833518982,
1.243082880973816,
-0.076285220682621,
0.172709658741951,
-0.2794817388057709,
-0.3008798062801361,
-0.17899850010871887,
-0.8777471780776978,
-0.8857994079589844,
-0.4204578399658203,
-0.25244367122650146,
-0.4714174270629883,
-0.12433190643787384,
1.1327917575836182,
0.7493956089019775,
-0.6116966009140015,
-0.3337381184101105,
-0.07311421632766724,
0.354815274477005,
-0.2258620262145996,
-0.24356147646903992,
-0.41366586089134216,
-0.5821623206138611,
-0.6782710552215576,
0.457546204328537,
0.31359562277793884,
-0.2106756716966629,
-0.7850317358970642,
-0.11898913979530334,
-0.5995365381240845,
0.5776791572570801,
0.8764302134513855,
0.05781391263008118,
-0.9198137521743774,
-0.19736076891422272,
0.4486426115036011,
-0.11307060718536377,
-0.04450126737356186,
1.1611437797546387,
-0.7067290544509888,
0.070084348320961,
0.7971733808517456,
0.30109307169914246,
0.17727825045585632,
-0.44271257519721985,
0.5288804769515991,
-0.13443441689014435,
0.08138526976108551,
0.019893687218427658,
0.5088614225387573,
0.20804363489151,
-0.033888112753629684,
0.406975656747818,
0.4679286479949951,
-0.39045125246047974,
-0.8526613116264343,
0.3622364401817322,
-0.6506026983261108,
-0.5029966831207275,
1.2372338771820068,
0.18538515269756317,
-0.04520397633314133,
-0.06882517784833908,
-0.09483060240745544,
0.08656803518533707,
-0.377270370721817,
0.5724772214889526,
1.2215443849563599,
-0.5153418183326721,
-0.635248064994812,
-0.8515487909317017,
0.6384364366531372,
0.5704809427261353,
-0.7603371739387512,
-0.3047754168510437,
0.40705516934394836,
0.2502914071083069,
0.472382515668869,
0.7461705803871155,
-0.05494830757379532,
0.14962238073349,
0.0634632334113121,
-0.38566669821739197,
0.3331107497215271,
-0.7399827837944031,
-0.05662664771080017,
0.20815737545490265,
0.38561511039733887,
0.08651701360940933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16071v1 | Dancing in the syntax forest: fast, accurate and explainable sentiment analysis with SALSA | 2024-06-23T10:47:01 | 2024-06-23T10:47:01 | Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Muhammad Imran, David Vilares, Elena Solera, Olga Kellert | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Sentiment analysis is a key technology for companies and institutions to
gauge public opinion on products, services or events. However, for large-scale
sentiment analysis to be accessible to entities with modest computational
resources, it needs to be performed in a resource-efficient way. While some
efficient sentiment analysis systems exist, they tend to apply shallow
heuristics, which do not take into account syntactic phenomena that can
radically change sentiment. Conversely, alternatives that take syntax into
account are computationally expensive. The SALSA project, funded by the
European Research Council under a Proof-of-Concept Grant, aims to leverage
recently-developed fast syntactic parsing techniques to build sentiment
analysis systems that are lightweight and efficient, while still providing
accuracy and explainability through the explicit use of syntax. We intend our
approaches to be the backbone of a working product of interest for SMEs to use
in production. | [
-0.20021885633468628,
-0.6419348120689392,
0.3755318820476532,
0.8434934020042419,
-0.4809984564781189,
0.5182167887687683,
-0.3815652132034302,
-0.3655892610549927,
0.6656467914581299,
0.2016385942697525,
-0.65233314037323,
-0.4811283051967621,
-0.5109352469444275,
-0.16805872321128845,
-0.6509327292442322,
0.9701517224311829,
0.1963527649641037,
0.12165766209363937,
-0.1296171396970749,
-0.5238737463951111,
-0.11343327164649963,
-0.43144312500953674,
-0.47238290309906006,
0.18464331328868866,
0.537245512008667,
0.5324878096580505,
0.9855097532272339,
0.4096531271934509,
0.8103373646736145,
0.28940659761428833,
-0.09749025106430054,
-0.3972172141075134,
-0.39583128690719604,
0.393912672996521,
-0.2593562602996826,
-0.4607933461666107,
-0.27464431524276733,
-0.16336601972579956,
0.3104928731918335,
0.7078432440757751,
-0.18568070232868195,
0.43831494450569153,
-0.06937912851572037,
1.0349743366241455,
-0.7099781632423401,
0.5147221088409424,
-0.6785779595375061,
0.225411519408226,
-0.5021892786026001,
-0.029320159927010536,
-0.2729654014110565,
-0.5629359483718872,
-0.18419532477855682,
-0.3126821517944336,
-0.017219677567481995,
-0.02206292375922203,
0.6554054617881775,
0.18488392233848572,
-0.07864340394735336,
-0.2859634757041931,
-0.7828134894371033,
0.9027167558670044,
-0.1995646059513092,
0.31679221987724304,
-0.0952070876955986,
0.6467116475105286,
0.012155449017882347,
-0.9082704782485962,
-0.6490175724029541,
0.17643673717975616,
0.21305085718631744,
0.16525714099407196,
-0.24681010842323303,
-0.008953685872256756,
0.12019781023263931,
0.5559031367301941,
-0.4835587739944458,
-0.29663628339767456,
-0.14852480590343475,
0.07715413719415665,
0.6378931403160095,
0.1062828004360199,
0.13667668402194977,
-0.2950645685195923,
-0.3879297971725464,
-0.07667499035596848,
-0.5699606537818909,
0.35123834013938904,
0.2677389979362488,
0.21235832571983337,
-0.035010334104299545,
0.581286609172821,
-0.038985706865787506,
0.6044833660125732,
-0.24959874153137207,
-0.014039513655006886,
0.17924517393112183,
-0.21489481627941132,
-0.5832152962684631,
-0.2747655510902405,
0.866816520690918,
0.29039597511291504,
0.3057699501514435,
-0.029714666306972504,
-0.2977331578731537,
0.6719021201133728,
0.2037704586982727,
-0.6020817160606384,
-0.4082484841346741,
0.3733830749988556,
-0.5694743990898132,
-0.5342612862586975,
0.07243575155735016,
-1.2052998542785645,
-0.617901623249054,
-0.057091616094112396,
0.16099125146865845,
-0.18506848812103271,
-0.3286454379558563,
0.05142511799931526,
-0.5762802958488464,
0.4666855037212372,
0.3902551233768463,
-0.539430558681488,
0.34853097796440125,
0.7994613647460938,
0.8963090777397156,
0.24069353938102722,
-0.06465747207403183,
-0.6100466251373291,
-0.2710457146167755,
-0.35866886377334595,
0.6183030009269714,
-0.7568402290344238,
-0.3561130464076996,
-0.14396677911281586,
-0.05955222249031067,
-0.16032172739505768,
-0.4869067966938019,
0.5458773970603943,
-0.3803001344203949,
0.14694584906101227,
-0.3071100413799286,
-0.2690848410129547,
0.03886837512254715,
0.03309266269207001,
-0.5063467025756836,
1.0251524448394775,
0.4417974054813385,
-0.7158211469650269,
0.33361685276031494,
-0.9125214219093323,
-0.6047011017799377,
0.0756097361445427,
-0.08476392924785614,
-0.22691985964775085,
0.30232498049736023,
0.2439446747303009,
0.39743784070014954,
-0.586253821849823,
0.21388055384159088,
-0.40518659353256226,
-0.21079322695732117,
0.49429336190223694,
0.08662926405668259,
1.047694444656372,
0.625838577747345,
-0.4613541066646576,
0.19658036530017853,
-0.7122718691825867,
-0.003993732389062643,
0.1316826045513153,
0.0011839300859719515,
-0.1179063469171524,
0.17819826304912567,
0.21745651960372925,
0.14310510456562042,
0.010261258110404015,
-0.47115668654441833,
0.17857737839221954,
-0.43359917402267456,
0.8290911316871643,
0.6349526643753052,
-0.028163451701402664,
0.5692631602287292,
0.1512296199798584,
1.0146251916885376,
-0.23116225004196167,
0.48322170972824097,
-0.29476383328437805,
-0.4354538321495056,
-0.6296703815460205,
-0.40544962882995605,
0.2664046883583069,
0.4147828221321106,
-0.669248104095459,
0.2322518676519394,
-0.29708394408226013,
-0.3576493561267853,
-0.7189921736717224,
0.09851628541946411,
0.2125396728515625,
0.3776554465293884,
0.24847526848316193,
-0.255718469619751,
-0.7439848184585571,
-0.7014541029930115,
-0.6896607279777527,
-0.23740629851818085,
0.13309922814369202,
-0.00029838268528692424,
0.488632470369339,
-0.12260524928569794,
0.9829333424568176,
-0.6407570242881775,
-0.20369306206703186,
-0.3408171236515045,
0.10211721807718277,
0.17377397418022156,
0.21714606881141663,
0.646416425704956,
-0.9480122327804565,
-0.6802070140838623,
0.053834639489650726,
-0.6370334029197693,
0.040147680789232254,
0.03054237924516201,
-0.16547514498233795,
0.10110270231962204,
0.2683403789997101,
-0.5206570029258728,
-0.0073464903980493546,
0.6542061567306519,
-0.45609694719314575,
0.0886559709906578,
0.48425447940826416,
0.09744364023208618,
-0.9062023758888245,
-0.06206872686743736,
0.2624669373035431,
-0.3769937753677368,
-0.2853859066963196,
0.5162407755851746,
-0.13450182974338531,
-0.45755091309547424,
-0.4269620180130005,
0.06070537865161896,
-0.2850843071937561,
-0.2759914994239807,
-0.014546598307788372,
-0.019809797406196594,
0.27007561922073364,
0.279239684343338,
-0.18485872447490692,
0.8041478991508484,
0.7201664447784424,
-0.09971554577350616,
0.4594118893146515,
-0.19908131659030914,
-0.3283345401287079,
0.701611340045929,
-0.5189897418022156,
0.06200804561376572,
-0.07007095217704773,
0.11961370706558228,
-0.936249852180481,
-0.33948972821235657,
0.2585972249507904,
-0.6753583550453186,
0.011285197921097279,
-0.45017561316490173,
-0.2666653096675873,
-0.35393786430358887,
-0.5527715682983398,
-0.015796203166246414,
0.8743222951889038,
-0.6534622311592102,
0.6072500944137573,
0.788726806640625,
0.05045066028833389,
-0.5302448868751526,
-0.6826198101043701,
0.29443359375,
-0.5575300455093384,
-0.965691328048706,
-0.06289085000753403,
0.12449759244918823,
-0.7560821175575256,
-0.05338038131594658,
-0.31792333722114563,
-0.4247024357318878,
0.34168878197669983,
0.3569440245628357,
-0.11725114285945892,
-0.2541171908378601,
0.00887099839746952,
-0.04648631066083908,
-0.051036737859249115,
0.4044206142425537,
-0.4682105779647827,
0.36860957741737366,
-0.45309528708457947,
0.11894683539867401,
-0.3735463619232178,
0.2271452099084854,
1.003268837928772,
-0.39788347482681274,
0.7334824204444885,
0.5035651326179504,
-0.2900942265987396,
-0.5193782448768616,
-0.13145649433135986,
0.24806556105613708,
-0.47195687890052795,
-0.10563762485980988,
-0.21421317756175995,
-0.5811013579368591,
0.44167521595954895,
-0.2757699191570282,
-0.3520577549934387,
0.44283878803253174,
0.32707011699676514,
-0.6890230178833008,
0.8214876651763916,
0.4878947138786316,
-0.10987028479576111,
0.5228004455566406,
-0.41039925813674927,
0.24835625290870667,
-0.4262307584285736,
-0.2067745327949524,
-1.0102909803390503,
-0.36934447288513184,
-0.4136444926261902,
-0.7097623944282532,
0.27802637219429016,
0.06720075011253357,
0.06360930949449539,
0.21917693316936493,
-0.3005867302417755,
0.734210729598999,
0.4097166359424591,
-0.26229727268218994,
-0.0771622434258461,
-0.16914285719394684,
0.11318104714155197,
-0.04422745108604431,
-0.4799655079841614,
-0.3649645149707794,
0.6415460109710693,
0.3606642186641693,
0.7127888202667236,
0.02457362972199917,
0.6642709970474243,
0.5476313829421997,
0.04742686077952385,
-1.0420137643814087,
0.6176095604896545,
-0.23945751786231995,
-0.18209849298000336,
-0.214555561542511,
-0.24028949439525604,
-0.7220060229301453,
0.22701919078826904,
-0.29270195960998535,
-0.506162703037262,
0.22320683300495148,
0.29249516129493713,
0.05916509032249451,
-0.055134229362010956,
-0.8193153738975525,
1.0913865566253662,
0.04823243245482445,
-0.4896703362464905,
-0.2991400361061096,
-0.7830813527107239,
0.28838950395584106,
0.16300040483474731,
0.6149675250053406,
-0.03466401621699333,
0.2076084166765213,
0.6388243436813354,
-0.6042041182518005,
0.7545674443244934,
-0.6429682374000549,
0.19305656850337982,
0.564760684967041,
0.2190096080303192,
0.6053657531738281,
0.01966710202395916,
-0.19042274355888367,
-0.02502078004181385,
-0.1727088838815689,
-0.32743212580680847,
-0.8714005351066589,
0.7896550297737122,
-0.4919106364250183,
-0.26103851199150085,
-0.46693435311317444,
-0.05063684657216072,
-0.18507622182369232,
-0.1771596223115921,
-0.09873131662607193,
0.15005257725715637,
-0.27291277050971985,
0.5485870838165283,
0.6087227463722229,
0.006340596359223127,
0.4155929684638977,
0.008678993210196495,
-0.1758078932762146,
-0.4699399471282959,
0.9487234354019165,
0.10607410967350006,
-0.08282870799303055,
0.4877384305000305,
0.4982216954231262,
-0.23823584616184235,
-0.4427364468574524,
-0.4365934729576111,
-0.2452685534954071,
-0.6506287455558777,
-0.19952575862407684,
-0.6654782295227051,
0.46252161264419556,
-0.2416980266571045,
-0.5132318139076233,
-0.4946703314781189,
-0.9927350282669067,
0.22016899287700653,
-0.22332841157913208,
0.38026121258735657,
0.5292983651161194,
0.22335852682590485,
0.6112460494041443,
-0.6800580620765686,
0.2941459119319916,
0.060729220509529114,
0.3968515992164612,
-0.41048938035964966,
0.1061214879155159,
-0.3607737421989441,
-0.17329633235931396,
-0.15219038724899292,
-1.239504098892212,
0.49076059460639954,
0.2550426721572876,
0.14329734444618225,
0.3723701536655426,
0.08692482858896255,
0.8821981549263,
0.12016493082046509,
1.0044317245483398,
0.19091397523880005,
-1.5441498756408691,
0.9346204400062561,
-0.3592527210712433,
-0.09653478115797043,
0.5809118747711182,
0.30100342631340027,
-0.4991118311882019,
-0.700488269329071,
-0.6301785707473755,
-0.8906501531600952,
0.6509714722633362,
0.3549458682537079,
0.0034271501936018467,
-0.036520302295684814,
0.21645255386829376,
0.03019813448190689,
0.42931056022644043,
-0.7880364060401917,
-0.08262256532907486,
-0.38202759623527527,
-0.2930314540863037,
-0.161118283867836,
-0.17363454401493073,
-0.16459320485591888,
-0.36892151832580566,
0.625873327255249,
-0.23726902902126312,
0.03255710005760193,
-0.12991324067115784,
-0.32501640915870667,
-0.25505658984184265,
0.38196319341659546,
0.09834112226963043,
0.6536720395088196,
-0.041499294340610504,
0.10826844722032547,
-0.12800399959087372,
-0.23903174698352814,
-0.10773919522762299,
-0.34502387046813965,
-0.024817505851387978,
-0.0564161017537117,
0.2787456214427948,
0.5574556589126587,
0.1285203993320465,
-0.548263669013977,
0.7498395442962646,
-0.11760063469409943,
-0.018836408853530884,
-0.3111453354358673,
0.17825457453727722,
0.27315232157707214,
0.2865394353866577,
-0.10136757791042328,
0.45966610312461853,
0.4089135527610779,
-0.8079711198806763,
-0.2196483016014099,
0.45654115080833435,
-0.41187527775764465,
-0.4095870554447174,
0.5754449963569641,
0.48928147554397583,
-0.24256932735443115,
0.6202268600463867,
-0.07515908032655716,
-0.3297771215438843,
0.7386565208435059,
0.32303547859191895,
1.0993236303329468,
0.07463229447603226,
0.3920946717262268,
0.1517447680234909,
0.32963716983795166,
-0.12407172471284866,
0.6704394221305847,
-0.26902154088020325,
-0.4103042483329773,
-0.3759881258010864,
-0.859880268573761,
-0.44161665439605713,
-0.4851418435573578,
-0.9356282353401184,
0.24789154529571533,
-0.6241305470466614,
-0.14000707864761353,
0.21658314764499664,
-0.21225568652153015,
-0.48508837819099426,
0.33851122856140137,
-0.24793046712875366,
1.0920523405075073,
-1.2051925659179688,
1.003469705581665,
0.7711468935012817,
-0.48202118277549744,
-0.5843911170959473,
0.0062116580083966255,
-0.02678726427257061,
-0.6639693975448608,
0.4904107451438904,
0.018246464431285858,
-0.4431171119213104,
-0.3511649966239929,
-0.6423566937446594,
-0.4613320529460907,
0.9303132891654968,
0.5941393971443176,
-0.5639817118644714,
0.3190942406654358,
-0.012976405210793018,
0.7936064004898071,
-0.3273300528526306,
-0.13807515799999237,
0.6642481088638306,
0.5578488111495972,
0.314585417509079,
-0.4778733551502228,
-0.29007816314697266,
-0.35088828206062317,
-0.02015145868062973,
0.61029452085495,
-0.650094747543335,
0.7820746898651123,
0.013976573944091797,
-0.2823414206504822,
-0.41373497247695923,
0.6363587379455566,
-0.3310048282146454,
0.5530480146408081,
0.4809931516647339,
0.3962535858154297,
0.9901432991027832,
-0.3091217875480652,
1.2467116117477417,
-0.5897071361541748,
0.4434777796268463,
0.9361865520477295,
-0.4624497890472412,
0.8867761492729187,
0.7010085582733154,
-0.36476778984069824,
0.8165476322174072,
0.31822025775909424,
0.1929495483636856,
0.22022709250450134,
0.28214743733406067,
-0.3160311281681061,
-0.21103276312351227,
0.03033015877008438,
-0.08164265751838684,
0.616798996925354,
0.5272734761238098,
-0.42003023624420166,
0.1371588557958603,
0.04046346992254257,
0.05378759279847145,
0.3927285373210907,
-0.34729528427124023,
0.661216139793396,
0.10647614300251007,
-0.5945926904678345,
0.04055008292198181,
0.12459545582532883,
0.25476354360580444,
-0.5969029068946838,
0.011254041455686092,
-0.31889840960502625,
0.2919747233390808,
-0.4938229024410248,
-0.9235207438468933,
0.9604252576828003,
0.28731200098991394,
0.005630203057080507,
-0.5999944806098938,
0.700285792350769,
0.12054577469825745,
-0.3409346640110016,
0.39586141705513,
0.4317034184932709,
0.08151846379041672,
-0.22553293406963348,
-0.6786987781524658,
0.28797781467437744,
-0.1462191641330719,
-0.2219560742378235,
0.15778455138206482,
0.6130657196044922,
-0.13480937480926514,
0.6047514081001282,
0.5248326063156128,
0.0388830192387104,
-0.07567727565765381,
0.14421845972537994,
0.9278368949890137,
-1.0161155462265015,
-0.6770235896110535,
-1.03163480758667,
0.5684333443641663,
-0.14954768121242523,
-0.08927062898874283,
0.9768223166465759,
0.6667786240577698,
0.5886808633804321,
-0.1752822995185852,
0.7170100212097168,
-0.23929449915885925,
0.16615094244480133,
-0.49120739102363586,
0.39190343022346497,
-0.36142104864120483,
0.38920706510543823,
-0.4033406972885132,
-1.057828664779663,
-0.5192079544067383,
0.7432904243469238,
0.07787042111158371,
-0.3346851170063019,
0.832611083984375,
0.674145519733429,
0.10649231821298599,
0.36278048157691956,
0.052918460220098495,
0.28277647495269775,
0.20305895805358887,
0.2257935106754303,
0.9739112854003906,
-0.030106257647275925,
0.27622485160827637,
-0.3361877501010895,
-0.26948925852775574,
-0.0288343895226717,
-1.0622719526290894,
-0.41931530833244324,
-0.44091492891311646,
-0.45773476362228394,
-0.6384803652763367,
0.32993650436401367,
1.2564351558685303,
0.5645838975906372,
-0.6349452137947083,
-0.5250356793403625,
-0.28549709916114807,
0.4341864287853241,
-0.4613543450832367,
-0.32057738304138184,
0.1358170062303543,
-0.46668103337287903,
-0.5380076766014099,
0.5869316458702087,
0.5703524947166443,
-0.35980162024497986,
-0.3587215840816498,
0.028977051377296448,
0.1708306521177292,
0.2291146069765091,
0.7917127013206482,
0.3362747132778168,
-0.3208012580871582,
-0.07477660477161407,
-0.07346926629543304,
0.18449629843235016,
0.25312191247940063,
1.0200122594833374,
-0.8258230090141296,
0.4340042173862457,
0.6483950614929199,
0.4027591943740845,
0.4141055643558502,
-0.06931469589471817,
0.5050196051597595,
-0.8465108871459961,
0.08003352582454681,
0.423302561044693,
0.44006451964378357,
0.2626464068889618,
-0.22702141106128693,
0.6183132529258728,
0.4063131809234619,
-0.3239651620388031,
-0.8185862302780151,
0.10916077345609665,
-1.2779182195663452,
-0.22184309363365173,
1.016128420829773,
-0.16136197745800018,
-0.6095380783081055,
0.08122152835130692,
-0.18542830646038055,
-0.15575151145458221,
-0.3932967185974121,
0.6735807657241821,
0.4328565299510956,
-0.1823771595954895,
0.013705415651202202,
-0.06269905716180801,
0.391598105430603,
0.07155197858810425,
-0.8850529789924622,
0.18313372135162354,
0.6676650047302246,
0.16211365163326263,
0.0510995090007782,
0.9215927124023438,
-0.19335952401161194,
0.28884389996528625,
0.20638512074947357,
0.014786679297685623,
0.21796447038650513,
-0.8146575689315796,
-0.6470860242843628,
0.6944301128387451,
0.43460896611213684,
-0.2837773263454437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16069v1 | FastMem: Fast Memorization of Prompt Improves Context Awareness of Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T10:36:35 | 2024-06-23T10:36:35 | Junyi Zhu, Shuochen Liu, Yu Yu, Bo Tang, Yibo Yan, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Tong Xu, Matthew B. Blaschko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) excel in generating coherent text, but they
often struggle with context awareness, leading to inaccuracies in tasks
requiring faithful adherence to provided information. We introduce FastMem, a
novel method designed to enhance instruction fine-tuned LLMs' context awareness
through fast memorization of the prompt. FastMem maximizes the likelihood of
the prompt before inference by fine-tuning only the last Feed-Forward Network
(FFN) module. This targeted approach ensures efficient optimization without
overfitting, significantly improving the model's ability to comprehend and
accurately follow the context. Our experiments demonstrate substantial gains in
reading comprehension, text summarization and adherence to output structures.
For instance, FastMem improves the accuracy of Llama 3-8B-Inst on the NQ-SWAP
dataset from 59.1% to 71.6%, and reduces the output structure failure rate of
Qwen 1.5-4B-Chat from 34.9% to 25.5%. Extensive experimental results highlight
FastMem's potential to offer a robust solution to enhance the reliability and
accuracy of LLMs in various applications. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/IAAR-Shanghai/FastMem | [
-0.1660732477903366,
-0.9459046721458435,
0.6444125771522522,
0.46528223156929016,
-0.22321894764900208,
-0.052080873399972916,
-0.4619483947753906,
-0.014908812940120697,
-0.14292505383491516,
0.469295859336853,
-0.4345330595970154,
-0.6093332767486572,
-0.5173895955085754,
0.14081555604934692,
-0.1551963984966278,
0.5873568654060364,
-0.05376423895359039,
0.08521929383277893,
-0.28532469272613525,
-0.19886669516563416,
-0.6251814365386963,
-0.41752877831459045,
-0.8835605978965759,
-0.33815252780914307,
0.6546836495399475,
0.6881547570228577,
0.5725588798522949,
1.0987114906311035,
0.27771174907684326,
0.3131325840950012,
-0.3259885609149933,
0.31000766158103943,
-0.5012065768241882,
0.3312419354915619,
-0.18909496068954468,
-0.5239810943603516,
-0.4960159659385681,
-0.14787602424621582,
1.0055431127548218,
0.7318394780158997,
0.12176784873008728,
0.014437409117817879,
0.21186915040016174,
0.6612529158592224,
-0.6142542362213135,
0.3395576477050781,
-0.5080945491790771,
-0.1618352234363556,
-0.1912388950586319,
-0.5724657773971558,
-0.6260173320770264,
-0.4223378896713257,
0.23247720301151276,
-0.6635866165161133,
-0.06456967443227768,
0.24749645590782166,
0.42808470129966736,
0.4036484360694885,
-0.6838629245758057,
-0.20254012942314148,
-0.7497664093971252,
0.8487080335617065,
-0.5664323568344116,
0.4826408922672272,
0.23217864334583282,
0.27561599016189575,
-0.572198748588562,
-0.6675783395767212,
-0.4233592748641968,
-0.12910616397857666,
0.03991374373435974,
-0.03283707797527313,
0.1822919398546219,
0.09807348251342773,
0.4729369580745697,
0.20815186202526093,
-0.3473162055015564,
0.10211054980754852,
-0.04936577007174492,
-0.5551631450653076,
0.21557527780532837,
0.4240431785583496,
0.3645683228969574,
0.14621657133102417,
-0.5904836654663086,
-0.06140277907252312,
-0.8697893023490906,
0.09896913170814514,
-0.05356575548648834,
0.4085845649242401,
0.11796510964632034,
0.24542954564094543,
-0.20244984328746796,
0.6538169384002686,
0.019764266908168793,
-0.2791629135608673,
0.14101891219615936,
-0.32875069975852966,
-0.21018853783607483,
0.16977593302726746,
0.4833633005619049,
0.3540510833263397,
0.09316983073949814,
0.2758494019508362,
-0.26668301224708557,
-0.3557056784629822,
-0.3617189824581146,
-1.2077875137329102,
-0.03767082095146179,
0.014003565534949303,
-0.4416230022907257,
0.21881693601608276,
-0.2938351333141327,
-0.3796519935131073,
-0.4901806116104126,
-0.442319393157959,
0.47950947284698486,
-0.6485106348991394,
0.09665734320878983,
0.12450535595417023,
0.17101052403450012,
0.27624258399009705,
0.7858351469039917,
-0.683893620967865,
0.056097161024808884,
0.7339537739753723,
0.9623159766197205,
0.023473937064409256,
-0.4622200131416321,
-1.0726534128189087,
0.2560206949710846,
-0.3359125554561615,
0.6931058764457703,
-0.34110331535339355,
-0.15431971848011017,
-0.25667843222618103,
0.20966117084026337,
-0.32435178756713867,
-0.5569557547569275,
0.48852136731147766,
-0.4342288672924042,
0.14748802781105042,
-0.222584530711174,
-0.9090759754180908,
-0.33701595664024353,
0.3238046169281006,
-0.6431208252906799,
0.7406426072120667,
-0.07069453597068787,
-0.579131543636322,
0.04535659775137901,
-0.29735007882118225,
-0.5669026970863342,
-0.011270984075963497,
0.16786542534828186,
-0.0463898628950119,
0.13549301028251648,
0.1896704137325287,
0.6937087178230286,
-0.16642814874649048,
0.33600905537605286,
0.02308737114071846,
-0.5958012342453003,
0.1782616227865219,
-0.43389689922332764,
0.4659784138202667,
0.09924126416444778,
-0.14073576033115387,
0.5160735249519348,
-0.6717772483825684,
-0.08405804634094238,
0.10918185114860535,
-0.4970169961452484,
-0.6633747816085815,
0.019637569785118103,
-0.24142378568649292,
0.24179336428642273,
0.2507164478302002,
-0.14738984405994415,
0.11714177578687668,
-0.6572520732879639,
0.48028531670570374,
0.8038564920425415,
0.035664867609739304,
0.7650896310806274,
-0.35119542479515076,
0.38794055581092834,
0.12358539551496506,
-0.007928149774670601,
-0.9179559946060181,
-0.3627791106700897,
-0.595500111579895,
-0.39886415004730225,
0.14764055609703064,
0.7400271892547607,
-0.6599360704421997,
0.18236005306243896,
-0.09062149375677109,
-0.22888560593128204,
-0.06513841450214386,
0.3510511517524719,
0.47086894512176514,
0.7833451628684998,
0.2085338979959488,
-0.1762567013502121,
-0.4739978611469269,
-0.582815408706665,
-0.38580864667892456,
-0.04000534489750862,
-0.008763101883232594,
0.33372578024864197,
0.24858605861663818,
-0.49461033940315247,
0.7478463649749756,
-0.3289957642555237,
-0.1857028305530548,
-0.32958340644836426,
-0.006324572954326868,
0.21626484394073486,
0.5288518667221069,
0.2848239243030548,
-0.4449364244937897,
-0.5160715579986572,
-0.2932069003582001,
-0.32496368885040283,
-0.16407078504562378,
-0.29485490918159485,
-0.3268888294696808,
0.14696136116981506,
0.7092522978782654,
-0.5823878049850464,
-0.04332941770553589,
0.11128721386194229,
-0.521637499332428,
0.38279837369918823,
-0.24850158393383026,
0.002456486923620105,
-1.2400548458099365,
0.08158310502767563,
-0.19626103341579437,
-0.4840507209300995,
-0.6686851382255554,
-0.2169899195432663,
0.407657653093338,
-0.05154666304588318,
-0.7962822318077087,
1.0912715196609497,
-0.5422755479812622,
0.20776045322418213,
-0.4120967984199524,
0.24233534932136536,
0.031750522553920746,
0.40706560015678406,
-0.17039743065834045,
1.0007060766220093,
0.36289167404174805,
-0.8442376852035522,
-0.04462902992963791,
0.43335285782814026,
-0.5963903069496155,
0.3275170624256134,
-0.3720203638076782,
0.07139837741851807,
-0.29050472378730774,
0.4178273677825928,
-0.8954740166664124,
-0.3306995630264282,
0.25492405891418457,
-0.24960337579250336,
0.4553564488887787,
0.11891305446624756,
-0.31488385796546936,
0.015025950036942959,
-0.31829020380973816,
0.43472036719322205,
0.42405664920806885,
-0.6997803449630737,
0.6177051067352295,
0.10624177008867264,
-0.1895413100719452,
-0.5427976250648499,
-0.4058990478515625,
-0.0157011765986681,
-0.13415783643722534,
-0.4300612509250641,
0.10494435578584671,
-0.29518893361091614,
-0.10714351385831833,
-0.4852463901042938,
-0.29069429636001587,
0.019497428089380264,
0.5517913699150085,
0.1362224966287613,
0.11760732531547546,
-0.2519194185733795,
0.22040531039237976,
0.02074544131755829,
-0.2182617038488388,
0.05268887057900429,
-0.42392903566360474,
0.5834313035011292,
-0.172391876578331,
0.10391552746295929,
-0.5635794997215271,
0.2929491400718689,
0.6922187209129333,
-0.19176729023456573,
0.7438355684280396,
0.6440893411636353,
-0.350165992975235,
-0.4890563189983368,
-0.2837396264076233,
-0.4921909272670746,
-0.500618577003479,
0.4443991184234619,
-0.29164737462997437,
-1.204162359237671,
0.5759276151657104,
-0.42882436513900757,
0.028493160381913185,
0.11768630146980286,
0.5002009272575378,
0.0435577929019928,
1.151639699935913,
0.5082952976226807,
-0.09214276075363159,
0.8425344824790955,
0.19820545613765717,
0.09147802740335464,
-0.9038258790969849,
-0.17113354802131653,
-0.403179794549942,
-0.29477664828300476,
-0.09751953929662704,
-0.5464049577713013,
0.10843458026647568,
0.4006626307964325,
-0.3019787669181824,
-0.029823672026395798,
-0.12996815145015717,
0.6162214875221252,
0.5918133854866028,
0.08174560219049454,
0.2334030121564865,
-0.21795113384723663,
-0.18191646039485931,
-0.07782711833715439,
-0.787553608417511,
-0.6554974913597107,
0.74055016040802,
0.39397063851356506,
0.7283395528793335,
-0.20314137637615204,
0.5346216559410095,
0.09735443443059921,
0.3532765507698059,
-0.9134273529052734,
0.8713820576667786,
0.1318034678697586,
-0.3416476845741272,
-0.200548455119133,
-0.6691977381706238,
-0.8293437957763672,
0.15774129331111908,
0.023995347321033478,
-0.5543089509010315,
-0.04907055199146271,
0.5385149717330933,
-0.5990520119667053,
0.05588029325008392,
-0.7897622585296631,
0.9523760676383972,
-0.20816338062286377,
-0.4188459515571594,
-0.04731901362538338,
-0.6533775925636292,
0.4937164783477783,
-0.03691162168979645,
0.0719238743185997,
-0.4857731759548187,
-0.3055984675884247,
0.7568467259407043,
-0.48388034105300903,
0.9015924334526062,
-0.15256322920322418,
-0.19435420632362366,
0.40270864963531494,
0.11910338699817657,
0.7177035212516785,
0.11459721624851227,
-0.07903113216161728,
-0.0025723075959831476,
-0.3212387263774872,
-0.3168093264102936,
-0.6104558706283569,
0.7425990700721741,
-0.3851265609264374,
-0.8173273801803589,
-0.23129074275493622,
-0.8032587766647339,
-0.14877824485301971,
0.4334349036216736,
0.04704960808157921,
0.6602873802185059,
-0.2577374279499054,
0.30816763639450073,
1.096795678138733,
-0.45822662115097046,
0.4777039885520935,
0.6507590413093567,
-0.1738855242729187,
-0.3791636526584625,
0.6959301233291626,
0.024281421676278114,
0.27842986583709717,
0.6206324100494385,
0.388395756483078,
-0.20335233211517334,
-0.4946437180042267,
-0.48950129747390747,
0.043885860592126846,
-0.9763244390487671,
-0.3018980622291565,
-0.7592310905456543,
-0.030016858130693436,
-0.2603442370891571,
-0.11379986256361008,
-0.24801665544509888,
-0.42260441184043884,
-0.34222695231437683,
0.07648526877164841,
0.3810080885887146,
0.17585884034633636,
0.27114400267601013,
0.6527532339096069,
-0.9568926692008972,
-0.035033613443374634,
0.20770816504955292,
0.2750915586948395,
0.10379615426063538,
-0.5732569694519043,
-0.44042474031448364,
-0.1951422542333603,
-0.17886944115161896,
-0.7784719467163086,
0.3697780668735504,
0.4353595972061157,
0.4572277367115021,
0.48785635828971863,
0.13045644760131836,
0.4848114550113678,
-0.702042281627655,
0.529262363910675,
-0.04668642207980156,
-1.19796621799469,
0.5998156070709229,
-0.3909423053264618,
0.8334651589393616,
0.4685162603855133,
0.18608032166957855,
-0.6175165176391602,
-0.4231264293193817,
0.015503652393817902,
-0.9254507422447205,
0.7790866494178772,
-0.15835906565189362,
0.07476487755775452,
-0.2712518572807312,
0.5242441296577454,
0.03773648291826248,
0.10107014328241348,
-0.20576432347297668,
-0.19519272446632385,
0.09934214502573013,
-0.44198518991470337,
-0.3038099706172943,
-0.5919124484062195,
0.12978993356227875,
-0.3088575303554535,
0.7814412713050842,
-0.46592453122138977,
0.12849768996238708,
0.25322067737579346,
-0.35829129815101624,
0.04864058643579483,
0.3884907066822052,
0.949749767780304,
0.624754011631012,
-0.07322718948125839,
0.28691065311431885,
0.4600123465061188,
-0.6078928709030151,
0.18890061974525452,
-0.027779115363955498,
-0.44938918948173523,
-0.006158967036753893,
0.410431444644928,
0.9320721626281738,
0.6008922457695007,
-0.7755918502807617,
0.4383722245693207,
-0.3303404748439789,
0.06853798031806946,
0.003115483559668064,
0.2821003496646881,
0.15459118783473969,
0.41143953800201416,
0.3268111050128937,
0.03262856602668762,
-0.002950265072286129,
-0.43831753730773926,
0.24519357085227966,
0.2793199419975281,
-0.10111113637685776,
-0.30236732959747314,
0.7617031931877136,
0.3165433406829834,
-0.35357922315597534,
0.40653195977211,
0.01656637340784073,
-0.6683385968208313,
0.7374420166015625,
0.876410722732544,
0.9490385055541992,
-0.6160034537315369,
-0.10654367506504059,
0.4728274643421173,
0.33312085270881653,
-0.4127674996852875,
0.3994266986846924,
-0.08369491994380951,
-0.6228776574134827,
-0.5082168579101562,
-0.5243954658508301,
-0.6027327179908752,
-0.03526853397488594,
-0.2938849925994873,
0.2928089499473572,
-0.6375580430030823,
-0.03897734358906746,
-0.37780940532684326,
0.03719981014728546,
-0.5407134890556335,
0.1674312800168991,
0.030891604721546173,
1.2452138662338257,
-0.5501360893249512,
0.9516344666481018,
0.6959617137908936,
0.14303834736347198,
-0.9299564361572266,
0.0871078372001648,
0.05225546658039093,
-0.6217221617698669,
0.28517886996269226,
0.6819049119949341,
-0.0840013176202774,
0.2598167359828949,
-0.44711118936538696,
-0.9545880556106567,
1.189849853515625,
0.4320375323295593,
-0.9418493509292603,
0.3427145481109619,
-0.2403981238603592,
0.12390238791704178,
-0.4661701023578644,
0.38171693682670593,
0.5016165375709534,
0.5194162130355835,
0.04155680537223816,
-0.5492465496063232,
0.3544803857803345,
0.059590864926576614,
0.13498137891292572,
0.39339280128479004,
-0.7531759142875671,
0.7398179769515991,
-0.4929819405078888,
-0.43348821997642517,
0.08342890441417694,
0.7888943552970886,
0.2531861662864685,
0.6016082763671875,
0.5936980843544006,
0.057274919003248215,
1.1751455068588257,
-0.07925932854413986,
0.8511098623275757,
-0.4559425115585327,
-0.12638916075229645,
1.3254199028015137,
-0.4444809556007385,
0.6734572052955627,
0.543106734752655,
0.5888020992279053,
0.15882736444473267,
0.6590827107429504,
0.47052866220474243,
0.4049607813358307,
0.06616489589214325,
-0.36477917432785034,
-0.333493709564209,
-0.08860607445240021,
-0.2620263993740082,
0.17064827680587769,
0.3952823877334595,
-0.3028288185596466,
-0.06948241591453552,
0.30352091789245605,
0.1925494223833084,
0.15308676660060883,
-0.6474166512489319,
0.8115202784538269,
0.3066149055957794,
-0.595059335231781,
0.6125431060791016,
0.07714583724737167,
0.5415680408477783,
-0.6183480620384216,
0.1556410938501358,
-0.4877476990222931,
0.5748810172080994,
0.012082106433808804,
-0.34813687205314636,
0.283418744802475,
-0.22264519333839417,
-0.43684789538383484,
-0.4138220548629761,
0.808440089225769,
-0.7652047276496887,
-0.19128064811229706,
0.17665988206863403,
0.5004369020462036,
0.030918974429368973,
-0.1094309613108635,
-0.3387194275856018,
0.17799508571624756,
-0.09928777068853378,
-0.4650513231754303,
0.23697414994239807,
0.5960436463356018,
-0.40421149134635925,
0.8429120182991028,
0.556666374206543,
-0.1895126849412918,
0.03303445130586624,
0.06899651139974594,
0.6949220299720764,
-0.967897355556488,
-0.5532913208007812,
-1.151953935623169,
0.21567821502685547,
0.1477004587650299,
-0.31973394751548767,
1.0853074789047241,
0.5465238094329834,
0.7722261548042297,
-0.10411778837442398,
0.3602072596549988,
0.48406365513801575,
0.4438604712486267,
-0.6069756150245667,
0.7752267122268677,
-0.41488614678382874,
0.3209173381328583,
0.0022208415903151035,
-1.0040178298950195,
-0.4841899573802948,
0.42694851756095886,
-0.1903896927833557,
-0.24634869396686554,
0.6975085735321045,
0.8479446768760681,
0.031071383506059647,
-0.08023186028003693,
0.34249892830848694,
0.37544435262680054,
0.13427560031414032,
0.8085784316062927,
1.075161099433899,
-0.26728665828704834,
0.5209392309188843,
-0.054376278072595596,
-0.27098989486694336,
-0.380947470664978,
-1.0026092529296875,
-1.1525202989578247,
-0.29788196086883545,
-0.3453836143016815,
-0.26727110147476196,
-0.029940029606223106,
1.1735222339630127,
0.6750835180282593,
-0.7642103433609009,
-0.12631559371948242,
0.0720917284488678,
0.5281450748443604,
-0.2870563268661499,
-0.1699066460132599,
0.20240060985088348,
-0.6396247744560242,
-0.7016739845275879,
0.8067330121994019,
0.38244006037712097,
0.12291363626718521,
0.0431370809674263,
-0.3954744040966034,
-0.11750724911689758,
0.4366987645626068,
0.7430859804153442,
0.18860453367233276,
-0.4687042236328125,
-0.1922537237405777,
0.16187702119350433,
-0.41614481806755066,
0.034411344677209854,
0.8730670809745789,
-0.7112954258918762,
0.2578844428062439,
0.8023119568824768,
0.7958149313926697,
0.10669119656085968,
-0.009086832404136658,
0.8285247683525085,
-0.7685169577598572,
0.26926693320274353,
0.130342498421669,
0.39193400740623474,
0.4400457441806793,
-0.4439651072025299,
0.0901193618774414,
0.0996890440583229,
-0.6175054907798767,
-0.7778558135032654,
0.12819111347198486,
-0.7687870264053345,
-0.20874926447868347,
0.9919676184654236,
-0.1773626208305359,
-0.5806808471679688,
0.029455099254846573,
-0.42331039905548096,
0.3521624803543091,
-0.5043728351593018,
0.45766037702560425,
0.5734202265739441,
0.3635154962539673,
-0.23026591539382935,
-0.48651939630508423,
0.617687463760376,
0.7817169427871704,
-0.7396382093429565,
0.20289327204227448,
0.6159053444862366,
0.3115774691104889,
-0.24285665154457092,
0.6716547608375549,
0.27368104457855225,
0.3234816789627075,
-0.6150436997413635,
-0.048866260796785355,
-0.2848708927631378,
-0.5907666683197021,
-0.5958775877952576,
0.05872200429439545,
-0.07223224639892578,
-0.17048396170139313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16061v1 | PORT: Preference Optimization on Reasoning Traces | 2024-06-23T09:51:06 | 2024-06-23T09:51:06 | Salem Lahlou, Abdalgader Abubaker, Hakim Hacid | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Preference optimization methods have been successfully applied to improve not
only the alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human values, but also
specific natural language tasks such as summarization and stylistic
continuations. This paper proposes using preference optimization methods on
Chain-of-Thought steps in order to improve the reasoning performances of
language models. While the chosen answers are obtained from datasets that
include reasoning traces, we propose two complementary schemes for generating
rejected answers: digit corruption, and weak LLM prompting. Our approach leads
to increased accuracy on the GSM8K, AQuA-RAT, and ARC benchmarks for
Falcon2-11B and Mistral-7B. For example, the approach can lead to up to a
relative 8.47% increase in accuracy on the GSM8K benchmark without any extra
annotations. This work suggests that spending resources on creating more
datasets of reasoning traces would further boost LLM performances on informal
reasoning tasks. | [
-0.6384994387626648,
-0.6321139335632324,
0.8208654522895813,
-0.09979163855314255,
-0.49018654227256775,
-0.002450736705213785,
-0.31785380840301514,
-0.2966713309288025,
0.3326243460178375,
0.8772412538528442,
-0.6843613386154175,
-0.16048888862133026,
-0.2702818214893341,
0.1608036607503891,
0.02454633079469204,
0.8917326331138611,
-0.10818035155534744,
0.007884872145950794,
-0.12175214290618896,
-0.060830678790807724,
-0.5452897548675537,
-0.5807464122772217,
-0.6271287798881531,
-0.37750568985939026,
0.48505550622940063,
0.6833300590515137,
0.3407904803752899,
0.8450967669487,
0.4712666869163513,
0.2710716128349304,
-0.18670369684696198,
0.8104626536369324,
-0.6110422015190125,
0.3406725823879242,
-0.2147907167673111,
-0.519496738910675,
-0.5665135383605957,
-0.14507614076137543,
0.2645608186721802,
0.41715195775032043,
0.11523862928152084,
0.3059900999069214,
-0.06779752671718597,
1.1114057302474976,
-0.7306870818138123,
0.11149035394191742,
-0.7792789340019226,
-0.41969022154808044,
-0.37824225425720215,
-0.5601073503494263,
-0.5412044525146484,
-0.6954923272132874,
0.09734902530908585,
-0.5083268880844116,
-0.027685493230819702,
0.23184005916118622,
0.7481719255447388,
0.34030500054359436,
-0.17874076962471008,
-0.3068641722202301,
-0.4850742816925049,
0.9267502427101135,
-0.7842151522636414,
0.13314777612686157,
0.5324288010597229,
0.1734047532081604,
-0.28282299637794495,
-0.33924347162246704,
-0.20728886127471924,
-0.06365092098712921,
-0.024800218641757965,
0.06793762743473053,
-0.012126541696488857,
0.2422894537448883,
0.4707809388637543,
0.23412543535232544,
-0.34757599234580994,
-0.053394999355077744,
-0.22991344332695007,
-0.2738780379295349,
0.6613180041313171,
0.2507176697254181,
-0.06305520981550217,
0.0294918455183506,
0.02590886689722538,
-0.23338736593723297,
-0.8840793371200562,
0.34985268115997314,
0.5808742046356201,
0.4599028527736664,
0.1401774138212204,
0.40500718355178833,
-0.6126615405082703,
0.8707496523857117,
0.3573272228240967,
-0.16185066103935242,
0.05466974899172783,
-0.4320790469646454,
-0.004681542050093412,
0.08956105262041092,
0.42112070322036743,
0.5242806673049927,
0.6247496604919434,
0.07172700762748718,
-0.24514499306678772,
0.10382094979286194,
0.36326539516448975,
-0.6534919142723083,
-0.19137273728847504,
0.22046425938606262,
-0.350683331489563,
-0.3712621331214905,
-0.01174352876842022,
-0.5358296632766724,
-0.258350670337677,
-0.7073352336883545,
0.16091080009937286,
-0.15191780030727386,
-0.012409214861690998,
0.35596197843551636,
-0.09331393986940384,
0.13073138892650604,
0.5669644474983215,
-1.1247320175170898,
0.29609933495521545,
0.7399134635925293,
0.5770065784454346,
-0.11590774357318878,
0.11501271277666092,
-0.6980370283126831,
-0.030609307810664177,
-0.4552454948425293,
0.8626708984375,
-0.5156545639038086,
-0.34048691391944885,
-0.3448197841644287,
-0.27204447984695435,
0.022834857925772667,
-0.5246732234954834,
1.0117722749710083,
-0.4200734794139862,
-0.020055154338479042,
-0.7598802447319031,
-0.38916513323783875,
-0.30053380131721497,
0.15261955559253693,
-0.6700689196586609,
1.2625335454940796,
-0.09244373440742493,
-0.8853650689125061,
0.26022812724113464,
-0.5399884581565857,
-0.5123292803764343,
-0.21118509769439697,
0.08855266124010086,
-0.3008047342300415,
0.26500919461250305,
0.48015904426574707,
0.4535890221595764,
-0.3238160312175751,
0.40598469972610474,
-0.46210846304893494,
-0.5478432774543762,
0.008103259839117527,
-0.25555282831192017,
0.6928688287734985,
0.27521514892578125,
-0.5989947319030762,
0.31289106607437134,
-0.5870383381843567,
0.2288249284029007,
-0.1461438238620758,
-0.20962494611740112,
-0.5778766870498657,
0.2672354280948639,
-0.439209908246994,
0.1967562437057495,
0.0016521397046744823,
-0.29846400022506714,
0.23527812957763672,
-0.4980975091457367,
0.33794793486595154,
1.1718683242797852,
-0.07431895285844803,
0.31870052218437195,
-0.5000555515289307,
0.4569225311279297,
-0.1977870762348175,
0.03378813713788986,
-0.07744506001472473,
-0.5518996119499207,
-1.1908559799194336,
0.12794888019561768,
-0.03233491629362106,
0.2790791094303131,
-0.6792048811912537,
0.4209863245487213,
-0.3516491949558258,
-0.3618980944156647,
-0.5010559558868408,
-0.01988280564546585,
0.31239959597587585,
0.833020806312561,
0.3306286036968231,
-0.17503142356872559,
-0.696347713470459,
-0.9621328711509705,
-0.333149790763855,
-0.48507779836654663,
0.3127804696559906,
0.6082713603973389,
0.21974796056747437,
0.18961356580257416,
0.945805549621582,
-0.5062329173088074,
0.2639687955379486,
-0.21876774728298187,
-0.195128932595253,
0.3261213004589081,
0.19121068716049194,
0.3578900098800659,
-0.5899178981781006,
-0.24916936457157135,
0.048823170363903046,
-0.2067883312702179,
-0.41648250818252563,
0.010448413901031017,
-0.489391952753067,
0.3313067555427551,
0.18699675798416138,
-0.13705474138259888,
0.22152751684188843,
0.3250798285007477,
-0.1451292783021927,
0.716461181640625,
-0.015253141522407532,
0.2567507326602936,
-0.8449282050132751,
0.18001900613307953,
-0.008755129761993885,
-0.3176150321960449,
-0.5339086055755615,
0.012689962051808834,
0.018463976681232452,
0.23729844391345978,
-0.26847219467163086,
0.5623361468315125,
-0.3752985894680023,
0.17877860367298126,
-0.2853860557079315,
0.008937716484069824,
0.0034277071245014668,
0.48440393805503845,
0.2916756272315979,
0.8669296503067017,
0.3083551526069641,
-0.5656370520591736,
0.18353401124477386,
0.02684297226369381,
-0.14111976325511932,
0.26234447956085205,
-0.4791441261768341,
0.5552801489830017,
-0.10095912963151932,
0.16854116320610046,
-1.0283634662628174,
-0.026478329673409462,
0.05155377835035324,
-0.21763008832931519,
0.01423084456473589,
-0.25634998083114624,
-0.06340384483337402,
-0.36990293860435486,
-0.7443875074386597,
0.2748567461967468,
0.40191367268562317,
-0.6312235593795776,
0.37908241152763367,
0.30118846893310547,
-0.03231633082032204,
-0.6905182600021362,
-0.3834277093410492,
-0.10951264947652817,
-0.5667510628700256,
-0.8005160689353943,
0.12589426338672638,
-0.12666000425815582,
-0.34232860803604126,
-0.502153754234314,
-0.3185471296310425,
0.33671966195106506,
0.1980864703655243,
0.15337984263896942,
0.44965675473213196,
-0.2798335552215576,
-0.15118184685707092,
0.041840534657239914,
-0.35513603687286377,
0.07691729068756104,
-0.30393290519714355,
0.5669913291931152,
-0.31571024656295776,
-0.1750725954771042,
-0.06767194718122482,
0.1550358384847641,
0.47735467553138733,
-0.3087048828601837,
0.08386249840259552,
0.22176256775856018,
-0.059279557317495346,
-0.174077570438385,
-0.9672378897666931,
-0.35275769233703613,
-0.5386117100715637,
-0.08443530648946762,
-0.6270739436149597,
-1.173344373703003,
0.4258975088596344,
-0.11605844646692276,
-0.09844142198562622,
0.18654289841651917,
0.574163556098938,
0.02046508900821209,
0.9419000148773193,
0.19411297142505646,
-0.5221852660179138,
0.23418258130550385,
-0.10649538785219193,
0.314529150724411,
-0.8766449093818665,
0.13997036218643188,
-0.7058196067810059,
-0.22682760655879974,
-0.7394528985023499,
-0.36316490173339844,
0.3403531312942505,
0.09221173077821732,
-0.2645808160305023,
0.3519522249698639,
-0.559510350227356,
0.6576801538467407,
0.7337087988853455,
0.18090131878852844,
0.3449561297893524,
0.18795277178287506,
-0.3301849365234375,
-0.05524986982345581,
-0.661965012550354,
-0.73000568151474,
1.247383713722229,
0.09692847728729248,
0.842908501625061,
-0.14810460805892944,
0.7461439967155457,
0.03500530868768692,
-0.03488641232252121,
-0.8119933009147644,
0.5814465880393982,
-0.11667586117982864,
-0.3145970106124878,
-0.14208103716373444,
-0.33201104402542114,
-0.6455376744270325,
0.13671161234378815,
0.12497711926698685,
-0.9545511603355408,
0.09901263564825058,
0.3581233024597168,
-0.23326259851455688,
0.24861876666545868,
-0.6688228845596313,
0.5623853206634521,
-0.2182135134935379,
-0.4560890197753906,
-0.19395309686660767,
-0.6775151491165161,
0.38271570205688477,
0.13387858867645264,
0.014030760154128075,
-0.07856187969446182,
0.16778410971164703,
0.6490665674209595,
-0.4517382085323334,
0.5917892456054688,
0.07022053748369217,
-0.07626910507678986,
0.4357212781906128,
0.15420277416706085,
0.9468080997467041,
-0.14718742668628693,
-0.4236985445022583,
-0.11864986270666122,
-0.1970139890909195,
-0.12068156898021698,
-0.5212279558181763,
0.622773289680481,
-0.46809515357017517,
-0.7744746208190918,
-0.23442606627941132,
-0.2900664806365967,
-0.385958194732666,
0.14545942842960358,
0.21932515501976013,
0.4991183876991272,
0.2682729661464691,
-0.04082756116986275,
0.5453484058380127,
0.09714988619089127,
0.6244329810142517,
0.2556663453578949,
0.03059452585875988,
-0.33989301323890686,
0.7932566404342651,
-0.19592028856277466,
0.5668092370033264,
0.31168311834335327,
0.4266887307167053,
-0.45942550897598267,
-0.7745079398155212,
-0.5446440577507019,
0.24718044698238373,
-0.6401199102401733,
-0.12665428221225739,
-0.43220406770706177,
0.09425745159387589,
-0.2263747751712799,
-0.23192881047725677,
-0.31187593936920166,
-0.6218959093093872,
-0.019381053745746613,
-0.23159870505332947,
0.43307435512542725,
0.4801562428474426,
0.11562979221343994,
-0.016561146825551987,
-0.39943698048591614,
0.2618791162967682,
0.14834214746952057,
0.34417155385017395,
0.19412395358085632,
-0.5145503282546997,
-0.1865978240966797,
0.23130573332309723,
-0.28974008560180664,
-0.5462777614593506,
0.15394733846187592,
-0.17278914153575897,
0.41759827733039856,
0.569079577922821,
0.15844771265983582,
0.9915023446083069,
-0.2469373643398285,
0.5358970761299133,
-0.21220727264881134,
-0.9556599259376526,
0.9247427582740784,
-0.6355611085891724,
0.1406017541885376,
0.8272224068641663,
0.27490290999412537,
-0.502478301525116,
-0.4644692838191986,
-0.6272352337837219,
-0.6243473887443542,
0.8794659376144409,
0.31206831336021423,
-0.1917266994714737,
0.09115627408027649,
0.3904709219932556,
0.02024439349770546,
0.0773235559463501,
-0.3628444969654083,
-0.3942636251449585,
0.19723908603191376,
0.12122579663991928,
0.07835779339075089,
-0.3623009920120239,
0.08041708171367645,
-0.3878244161605835,
0.9408352971076965,
-0.3826303780078888,
-0.02373099885880947,
0.10786119103431702,
0.05636186525225639,
-0.09947472810745239,
0.21077904105186462,
0.937882125377655,
0.8663004636764526,
-0.31050679087638855,
0.29884132742881775,
0.09179811924695969,
-0.49105381965637207,
0.252769410610199,
-0.3875434398651123,
-0.33267319202423096,
-0.15337084233760834,
0.20994289219379425,
0.7990628480911255,
-0.2414272278547287,
-0.5289778113365173,
0.1147366389632225,
0.09712716937065125,
0.0670802965760231,
0.10531771183013916,
0.28282633423805237,
0.17226453125476837,
-0.13533329963684082,
0.08981072902679443,
0.1538851410150528,
0.3564549386501312,
-0.2685719430446625,
0.04227231442928314,
0.34138134121894836,
-0.349551260471344,
-0.15248644351959229,
0.41683220863342285,
0.3124030828475952,
-0.14785175025463104,
0.5246249437332153,
-0.2648196816444397,
-0.659658670425415,
0.5452387928962708,
0.44660860300064087,
0.9158618450164795,
-0.016059795394539833,
0.04087991267442703,
0.5311034917831421,
0.3230099678039551,
-0.39551255106925964,
0.3718533217906952,
-0.15627257525920868,
-0.9907241463661194,
-0.6880749464035034,
-0.34463217854499817,
-0.47444412112236023,
0.038631606847047806,
-0.6733463406562805,
0.5908514857292175,
-0.3360949158668518,
-0.16191095113754272,
-0.11403779685497284,
0.10560113936662674,
-0.22371946275234222,
0.07081819325685501,
0.09967570006847382,
0.5547069311141968,
-0.7364234924316406,
0.7859984040260315,
0.521030604839325,
-0.13194677233695984,
-1.0815412998199463,
-0.25028443336486816,
0.2205694019794464,
-0.9065118432044983,
0.5073531866073608,
0.14554770290851593,
-0.4466947019100189,
-0.025307631120085716,
-0.21210977435112,
-0.8164940476417542,
0.7434462904930115,
0.5131123661994934,
-0.6078978180885315,
0.253165602684021,
0.07483995705842972,
0.39190971851348877,
-0.3305276930332184,
0.709617555141449,
0.857337474822998,
0.663237988948822,
0.012033497914671898,
-1.039676308631897,
0.26336273550987244,
-0.28514719009399414,
-0.020962359383702278,
0.4898873269557953,
-0.7829470634460449,
0.4867999851703644,
-0.29334884881973267,
0.030834756791591644,
-0.07076136022806168,
0.110391765832901,
0.520529568195343,
0.074130117893219,
0.4556085467338562,
0.5889009833335876,
0.7849924564361572,
-0.280768483877182,
1.0251867771148682,
-0.09247221052646637,
0.19353871047496796,
1.1195627450942993,
-0.13369862735271454,
0.6340449452400208,
0.6554376482963562,
-0.3537519872188568,
0.4184643626213074,
0.8441789746284485,
0.2677114009857178,
0.32146573066711426,
0.3990175127983093,
-0.03955855965614319,
-0.47050684690475464,
-0.16886314749717712,
-0.20286335051059723,
0.4035474359989166,
0.15247654914855957,
-0.1802159696817398,
-0.1563931405544281,
-0.5378405451774597,
0.17438629269599915,
0.006127862259745598,
-0.2269018590450287,
0.751122772693634,
-0.04305595904588699,
-0.9970372319221497,
0.8321211338043213,
0.042308904230594635,
0.7025320529937744,
-0.36048516631126404,
0.024601617828011513,
-0.5278396010398865,
0.04357424005866051,
-0.25305670499801636,
-0.5933966636657715,
0.16698388755321503,
-0.0022953394800424576,
-0.24151408672332764,
-0.4584447741508484,
0.9783129692077637,
-0.16157115995883942,
-0.4008128345012665,
0.09482391923666,
0.26210418343544006,
0.18970994651317596,
-0.3469405174255371,
-0.4912593364715576,
0.046081434935331345,
0.3351864516735077,
-0.17686709761619568,
0.10675100982189178,
0.20367786288261414,
-0.43574798107147217,
0.8783694505691528,
0.7384704947471619,
0.2694016098976135,
-0.04971615970134735,
0.1638355851173401,
0.8784108757972717,
-0.6289102435112,
-0.6459250450134277,
-1.1731914281845093,
0.41249608993530273,
-0.2513434588909149,
-0.38082215189933777,
0.6282366514205933,
0.8916598558425903,
0.7830834984779358,
-0.019833389669656754,
0.6993536949157715,
0.1992824375629425,
0.5429351329803467,
-0.7969871759414673,
0.33671367168426514,
-0.19534695148468018,
0.43603307008743286,
-0.5795456767082214,
-1.0262120962142944,
0.008397223427891731,
0.6264916658401489,
-0.4303082525730133,
0.02059362456202507,
0.8448390364646912,
0.9728684425354004,
-0.04827387258410454,
0.25103554129600525,
-0.015526259317994118,
-0.2631893754005432,
0.29262205958366394,
0.8758764863014221,
0.8987783789634705,
-0.30056217312812805,
0.1792338341474533,
-0.38699764013290405,
-0.04325896501541138,
-0.30483168363571167,
-1.0306205749511719,
-0.9045158624649048,
-0.47256776690483093,
-0.21677425503730774,
-0.3563738763332367,
0.1087031438946724,
0.8424585461616516,
0.7319349646568298,
-0.7829448580741882,
-0.5818028450012207,
-0.1622910350561142,
0.2592630088329315,
-0.13754558563232422,
-0.20420119166374207,
0.48106005787849426,
-0.3916706442832947,
-0.49955737590789795,
0.32764962315559387,
0.5049501061439514,
0.026309490203857422,
0.06125294789671898,
-0.17318756878376007,
-0.12871909141540527,
-0.009528541937470436,
0.5392147302627563,
0.0020685172639787197,
-1.003799557685852,
-0.4984493553638458,
0.26592880487442017,
0.16602261364459991,
0.3013876676559448,
1.1794742345809937,
-0.719717264175415,
0.6387590765953064,
0.7942430377006531,
0.5927196741104126,
0.6871992945671082,
0.4397392272949219,
0.7184538245201111,
-0.42795830965042114,
0.050593942403793335,
0.25690871477127075,
0.3669828474521637,
0.15796469151973724,
-0.291500985622406,
0.7626376152038574,
0.11857688426971436,
-0.35987234115600586,
-0.6331889033317566,
0.09765584021806717,
-1.2528767585754395,
0.04797844961285591,
1.1766413450241089,
-0.017576977610588074,
-0.09088688343763351,
-0.14984209835529327,
-0.40590018033981323,
-0.14274440705776215,
-0.6348810195922852,
0.6236822009086609,
0.9972720146179199,
-0.4930286407470703,
-0.005196484737098217,
-0.2727631628513336,
0.7658151984214783,
0.6144328713417053,
-0.9218640923500061,
0.24890534579753876,
0.4791353940963745,
0.14755457639694214,
-0.10614553093910217,
0.6982823014259338,
-0.10062496364116669,
0.322634220123291,
-0.40669485926628113,
-0.2640282213687897,
-0.17243999242782593,
-0.13954319059848785,
-0.12357722222805023,
-0.19943919777870178,
0.23292957246303558,
0.006087873596698046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16033v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16033v1 | Unlocking the Future: Exploring Look-Ahead Planning Mechanistic Interpretability in Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T06:54:47 | 2024-06-23T06:54:47 | Tianyi Men, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Planning, as the core module of agents, is crucial in various fields such as
embodied agents, web navigation, and tool using. With the development of large
language models (LLMs), some researchers treat large language models as
intelligent agents to stimulate and evaluate their planning capabilities.
However, the planning mechanism is still unclear. In this work, we focus on
exploring the look-ahead planning mechanism in large language models from the
perspectives of information flow and internal representations. First, we study
how planning is done internally by analyzing the multi-layer perception (MLP)
and multi-head self-attention (MHSA) components at the last token. We find that
the output of MHSA in the middle layers at the last token can directly decode
the decision to some extent. Based on this discovery, we further trace the
source of MHSA by information flow, and we reveal that MHSA mainly extracts
information from spans of the goal states and recent steps. According to
information flow, we continue to study what information is encoded within it.
Specifically, we explore whether future decisions have been encoded in advance
in the representation of flow. We demonstrate that the middle and upper layers
encode a few short-term future decisions to some extent when planning is
successful. Overall, our research analyzes the look-ahead planning mechanisms
of LLMs, facilitating future research on LLMs performing planning tasks. | [
-0.36811885237693787,
-0.46542665362358093,
0.9046230912208557,
0.14778423309326172,
-0.05532871559262276,
0.005296212155371904,
-0.16483858227729797,
-0.632466197013855,
0.2751469314098358,
0.6493213176727295,
-1.1840261220932007,
-0.21196933090686798,
-0.44244593381881714,
-0.086086705327034,
-0.2708721458911896,
0.5541626811027527,
-0.21811148524284363,
-0.03657381981611252,
-0.04660448431968689,
0.1894737035036087,
-0.5009407997131348,
-0.6516156792640686,
-0.7736963033676147,
-0.6875501871109009,
0.669403076171875,
0.3209194540977478,
0.8600568175315857,
0.7005448937416077,
0.20604461431503296,
0.2881532907485962,
-0.1404263973236084,
-0.14006958901882172,
-0.42207008600234985,
0.09011399000883102,
-0.43185365200042725,
-0.4728257656097412,
-0.4698243737220764,
-0.16714419424533844,
0.7409488558769226,
0.5048049092292786,
0.09785326570272446,
0.19318394362926483,
0.1800571233034134,
0.6972240209579468,
-0.7586373686790466,
0.5936673879623413,
-0.6752583980560303,
0.10089316964149475,
-0.2674380838871002,
-0.5727167129516602,
-0.41670095920562744,
0.3676874041557312,
0.12626788020133972,
-0.22158585488796234,
-0.33354178071022034,
-0.09900492429733276,
0.43215587735176086,
0.20990002155303955,
-0.1956738382577896,
-0.5186164975166321,
-0.7521271109580994,
0.7086881399154663,
-0.7247693538665771,
0.5373915433883667,
0.23717842996120453,
0.49227482080459595,
-0.40549108386039734,
-0.5883516073226929,
-0.7736427783966064,
-0.0380827896296978,
0.03504011780023575,
0.10562911629676819,
-0.05205564573407173,
0.1006491407752037,
0.12878338992595673,
-0.10492274165153503,
-0.5782644748687744,
0.3182639181613922,
-0.17048606276512146,
-0.013356581330299377,
0.504669725894928,
0.19805927574634552,
0.1566086709499359,
0.07452305406332016,
-0.3645453155040741,
-0.2103826105594635,
-0.7235671877861023,
0.14161455631256104,
0.06492002308368683,
0.3024040460586548,
-0.21364641189575195,
0.792683482170105,
-0.4824898838996887,
0.4989795386791229,
-0.2611653804779053,
0.04864393174648285,
-0.06269361823797226,
-0.25574278831481934,
-0.46892547607421875,
0.031057830899953842,
0.38985833525657654,
0.2635577619075775,
0.533513605594635,
-0.005291858222335577,
-0.24045714735984802,
-0.34906062483787537,
0.24931997060775757,
-0.8004462122917175,
0.06899220496416092,
0.5497976541519165,
-0.5294036269187927,
-0.14650487899780273,
-0.34931233525276184,
-0.6869490146636963,
-0.2826559841632843,
-0.4903731048107147,
0.15823377668857574,
-0.40211188793182373,
-0.3610999584197998,
0.2079932540655136,
0.12181732058525085,
0.7791783213615417,
0.3024391233921051,
-0.9193812608718872,
-0.006654559168964624,
0.8040127754211426,
0.7057977318763733,
0.18868854641914368,
-0.7919887900352478,
-0.2565602660179138,
0.519380509853363,
-0.4497321546077728,
0.9001922607421875,
-0.5817858576774597,
-0.2378556728363037,
0.23100508749485016,
-0.03311218321323395,
-0.03922576457262039,
-0.22287201881408691,
0.2912164330482483,
-0.6137744188308716,
-0.14228633046150208,
-0.26045748591423035,
-0.24528208374977112,
-0.3679380714893341,
0.38347604870796204,
-0.5777743458747864,
0.27966824173927307,
-0.1888655424118042,
-0.4197416603565216,
0.48064205050468445,
-0.7111626267433167,
-0.18055009841918945,
-0.12677492201328278,
-0.38843441009521484,
-0.1301000416278839,
-0.018780212849378586,
0.26783743500709534,
0.7658706903457642,
-0.1133216992020607,
0.22631265223026276,
-0.37324953079223633,
0.01679806411266327,
0.4813041388988495,
-0.39385542273521423,
0.5879742503166199,
0.16893227398395538,
-0.15132282674312592,
0.31643688678741455,
-0.5117449164390564,
0.14856548607349396,
0.19534693658351898,
-0.12245617806911469,
0.06531665474176407,
0.3253401219844818,
-0.33298537135124207,
0.5857054591178894,
0.3827148973941803,
-0.07354940474033356,
0.2787942886352539,
-0.23761756718158722,
0.42687663435935974,
1.150960922241211,
-0.02415601536631584,
0.5739169120788574,
0.025001708418130875,
0.5927689075469971,
-0.03256995603442192,
0.34425389766693115,
-0.4460342228412628,
-0.4221748411655426,
-0.45660725235939026,
0.4267878234386444,
-0.215262308716774,
0.27740171551704407,
-0.7266188859939575,
-0.04123551398515701,
-0.2663012146949768,
-0.19061630964279175,
-0.04767962917685509,
-0.2242651730775833,
0.28135910630226135,
0.09533120691776276,
0.1743321269750595,
0.06341830641031265,
-0.5209017992019653,
-0.7568802237510681,
-0.3796211779117584,
-0.3473585546016693,
0.2836504876613617,
0.02238685078918934,
0.46468308568000793,
-0.25482580065727234,
0.6391722559928894,
-0.4436663091182709,
-0.13404949009418488,
-0.6262542605400085,
0.01784035749733448,
0.3356579840183258,
0.4168045222759247,
0.42619606852531433,
-0.7872408628463745,
-0.16818752884864807,
0.07202190160751343,
-0.7413771748542786,
0.13674449920654297,
-0.5409254431724548,
-0.37205344438552856,
-0.08671578764915466,
0.6498397588729858,
-0.8098146319389343,
0.3793489634990692,
0.6002063155174255,
-0.5560348629951477,
0.7404965758323669,
-0.08639324456453323,
-0.22804376482963562,
-0.7620261907577515,
-0.18096375465393066,
-0.22496876120567322,
0.017323322594165802,
-0.5992882251739502,
0.35159793496131897,
0.14245949685573578,
-0.1446264386177063,
-0.36053380370140076,
0.7816334962844849,
-0.912945568561554,
-0.48729074001312256,
-0.4552890658378601,
-0.06665468961000443,
-0.195698082447052,
0.6771579384803772,
0.055242277681827545,
0.7526445984840393,
0.5421190857887268,
-0.6753007173538208,
-0.058191653341054916,
0.02770005539059639,
-0.07105983048677444,
0.26674291491508484,
-0.17205433547496796,
0.15833549201488495,
-0.2374967336654663,
0.3836963474750519,
-0.40607959032058716,
-0.20530207455158234,
0.2046831101179123,
-0.6296278834342957,
0.5449117422103882,
-0.060702040791511536,
-0.3239106833934784,
-0.45936474204063416,
-0.19894017279148102,
0.23650425672531128,
0.11772754788398743,
-0.4421941637992859,
0.9980262517929077,
0.39253395795822144,
-0.23477016389369965,
-0.7784528732299805,
-0.8188677430152893,
0.25889378786087036,
-0.020203636959195137,
-0.6152979135513306,
0.20783674716949463,
-0.03140278160572052,
-0.41235342621803284,
-0.024733830243349075,
-0.06219123676419258,
-0.04281531646847725,
-0.07676811516284943,
0.09514166414737701,
0.07872043550014496,
-0.21341440081596375,
-0.12745492160320282,
0.06995376944541931,
-0.27563220262527466,
0.4558204114437103,
-0.6711443066596985,
0.825107216835022,
0.2553189694881439,
-0.39601001143455505,
-0.3289925754070282,
0.42777392268180847,
0.7329696416854858,
-0.4815976023674011,
0.8188610672950745,
0.343510240316391,
-0.4935302734375,
-0.34452274441719055,
-0.34574535489082336,
-0.18311548233032227,
-0.4784526228904724,
0.5044240355491638,
-0.6681671142578125,
-0.3955293893814087,
0.7099388837814331,
-0.20546573400497437,
0.16226883232593536,
0.46517106890678406,
0.5670830607414246,
-0.03052292764186859,
0.9867235422134399,
0.8720402121543884,
0.12167830765247345,
0.4829105734825134,
-0.4868588447570801,
0.0353190116584301,
-0.9326266050338745,
-0.5808624625205994,
-0.2979545593261719,
-0.3721252977848053,
-0.2730814218521118,
-0.6089438199996948,
0.11906028538942337,
0.19818617403507233,
0.05412239953875542,
0.19383758306503296,
-0.1475149393081665,
0.501217246055603,
0.4578181505203247,
-0.21693384647369385,
0.07737082988023758,
-0.3865513205528259,
-0.13054926693439484,
0.17042312026023865,
-0.4189991354942322,
-0.5010999441146851,
1.1315516233444214,
0.5079160928726196,
0.6795589923858643,
-0.22650732100009918,
0.5844104886054993,
-0.06557231396436691,
-0.016664551571011543,
-0.6377770304679871,
0.7919242978096008,
0.12616606056690216,
-0.312159925699234,
-0.43011465668678284,
-0.07801616936922073,
-0.9057483673095703,
0.38487187027931213,
-0.19561831653118134,
-0.8069882988929749,
0.4465000629425049,
-0.0247441865503788,
-0.0887354388833046,
0.5015156865119934,
-0.6984802484512329,
0.7315435409545898,
-0.5745707750320435,
-0.21782658994197845,
-0.6057180166244507,
-0.557861328125,
0.03579290211200714,
-0.045736510306596756,
0.23855063319206238,
-0.15083885192871094,
0.015821507200598717,
0.523708701133728,
-0.08689303696155548,
0.6237888932228088,
-0.2224893867969513,
-0.29978999495506287,
0.17107881605625153,
0.018448282033205032,
0.8179612159729004,
-0.24283963441848755,
-0.09432576596736908,
0.24191345274448395,
-0.20828422904014587,
-0.32043778896331787,
-0.5336994528770447,
0.5400078892707825,
-0.4578506648540497,
-0.42556217312812805,
-0.3352406919002533,
-0.5943981409072876,
-0.21610024571418762,
0.3859187066555023,
0.11100829392671585,
0.5286862850189209,
-0.1351633071899414,
-0.3018777668476105,
0.30932924151420593,
-0.3718598783016205,
0.7297550439834595,
0.40656325221061707,
-0.561410665512085,
0.12298084050416946,
0.6966787576675415,
0.32149210572242737,
0.2846563458442688,
0.6950206756591797,
0.22346559166908264,
-0.4752429127693176,
-1.0840238332748413,
-0.47647982835769653,
0.2820237874984741,
-0.8499883413314819,
0.050934214144945145,
-0.5776829123497009,
-0.2967692017555237,
-0.3924143314361572,
-0.1442791074514389,
-0.3568885624408722,
-0.20499765872955322,
-0.06949882209300995,
-0.11583288013935089,
-0.26833173632621765,
0.9688729047775269,
-0.14318625628948212,
0.23280225694179535,
-0.43350866436958313,
0.043048642575740814,
0.08206325769424438,
0.1422603577375412,
0.3434405028820038,
0.10925053060054779,
-0.5941752195358276,
0.027596214786171913,
-0.29661497473716736,
-0.8894579410552979,
0.5530526041984558,
-0.2658858895301819,
0.6720160841941833,
0.6093774437904358,
-0.22636856138706207,
0.7857417464256287,
-0.5330927968025208,
0.5631518959999084,
-0.13318505883216858,
-0.6238662004470825,
0.5947484374046326,
-0.3334982693195343,
0.5920461416244507,
0.14280958473682404,
0.12222085148096085,
-0.3127296268939972,
-0.4600040316581726,
-0.5257395505905151,
-0.8180902004241943,
0.6238235831260681,
0.16025401651859283,
-0.10415378957986832,
0.3364318311214447,
0.3050437569618225,
0.10868123173713684,
0.1294214427471161,
-0.7746904492378235,
-0.017088990658521652,
0.15014131367206573,
0.24105314910411835,
-0.10984767973423004,
-0.5119943618774414,
0.15080907940864563,
0.16440831124782562,
0.37475353479385376,
-0.2226845771074295,
0.6368165016174316,
-0.028240790590643883,
0.0692078247666359,
-0.14859285950660706,
0.42495429515838623,
0.7468655705451965,
1.0147560834884644,
-0.14059190452098846,
0.06817873567342758,
0.007359245792031288,
-0.37273523211479187,
-0.28355398774147034,
0.09424258768558502,
-0.020619608461856842,
-0.2754099369049072,
0.76646488904953,
0.6213867664337158,
0.12201514095067978,
-0.605560839176178,
0.11970525979995728,
0.06048041954636574,
0.10370957106351852,
-0.6416800618171692,
-0.20309357345104218,
-0.039650265127420425,
0.8042566776275635,
0.5057056546211243,
0.09141290932893753,
0.29707056283950806,
-0.9314975142478943,
-0.04282631725072861,
0.4228373169898987,
-0.262034147977829,
-0.4591664671897888,
0.5373692512512207,
-0.1878660023212433,
-0.06410416960716248,
0.42850661277770996,
-0.14306676387786865,
-0.5912001729011536,
0.526419460773468,
0.4285608232021332,
1.14286470413208,
-0.15244239568710327,
-0.0063289860263466835,
0.23811693489551544,
0.4066206216812134,
0.1887848675251007,
0.5387069582939148,
-0.015568903647363186,
-0.6513323783874512,
-0.8698191046714783,
-0.6767880916595459,
-0.38615426421165466,
0.09707458317279816,
-0.46927452087402344,
0.10283666104078293,
-0.14676533639431,
0.04750971496105194,
-0.2601722180843353,
-0.20400139689445496,
-0.7782568335533142,
0.2812996506690979,
0.411773681640625,
0.8392852544784546,
-0.33920416235923767,
0.8446887731552124,
0.6036714911460876,
-0.19808503985404968,
-0.8409715890884399,
0.49711740016937256,
0.11893241852521896,
-1.236229658126831,
0.6490160226821899,
0.39510446786880493,
-0.4563332498073578,
-0.23226597905158997,
-0.5546810030937195,
-1.166753888130188,
1.1639200448989868,
0.31575778126716614,
-0.5895988941192627,
-0.7663774490356445,
0.09411590546369553,
0.2298879772424698,
-0.36197951436042786,
0.08256295323371887,
0.4010046422481537,
0.5734055638313293,
0.21778717637062073,
-0.8090269565582275,
0.133713498711586,
-0.061984144151210785,
-0.25140637159347534,
0.28776994347572327,
-0.4913697838783264,
1.0627127885818481,
-0.5909352898597717,
-0.5617349743843079,
-0.1280830353498459,
0.739914059638977,
0.12895844876766205,
0.45232200622558594,
0.20769324898719788,
0.24410000443458557,
0.4779245853424072,
0.10996861755847931,
1.2713559865951538,
-0.2620619833469391,
-0.021628590300679207,
1.133641242980957,
-0.07212059199810028,
1.0630990266799927,
0.4672037661075592,
-0.07102221995592117,
0.5681633949279785,
0.5352872014045715,
0.5172567963600159,
0.7054158449172974,
0.04397425800561905,
0.1746424436569214,
-0.046879447996616364,
0.011863330379128456,
-0.30959799885749817,
0.7224612236022949,
0.4716925323009491,
-0.34601300954818726,
-0.20112921297550201,
0.06396204978227615,
0.04734979197382927,
-0.2544707655906677,
-0.7803783416748047,
0.7612624168395996,
0.18340149521827698,
-0.7966319918632507,
0.24344438314437866,
-0.09281311184167862,
0.3381454348564148,
-0.6358035206794739,
-0.07459916174411774,
0.19536107778549194,
0.4079262912273407,
0.029014261439442635,
-1.3623840808868408,
0.4102466404438019,
-0.4365858733654022,
0.12879228591918945,
-0.5168421864509583,
0.8262364864349365,
-0.20892295241355896,
-0.18863973021507263,
0.7474145293235779,
0.6384106278419495,
0.0773288682103157,
-0.44384294748306274,
-0.7452934980392456,
0.10655880719423294,
-0.0005451875040307641,
-0.2661752700805664,
0.3770569860935211,
0.8316548466682434,
-0.10547900199890137,
1.061425805091858,
0.7385661005973816,
0.42111483216285706,
0.1789538413286209,
0.07459385693073273,
0.8468804955482483,
-0.9169495701789856,
-0.7145910263061523,
-1.1109455823898315,
0.44837960600852966,
0.07767913490533829,
-0.10023502260446548,
0.42625799775123596,
0.2747662663459778,
0.9233210682868958,
0.05747460201382637,
0.4088066518306732,
0.29308709502220154,
0.15714631974697113,
-1.0616408586502075,
0.67196124792099,
-0.3525352478027344,
0.10280726850032806,
-0.19829976558685303,
-0.8042265772819519,
0.04087773337960243,
0.3542133569717407,
-0.3378167152404785,
-0.07518088817596436,
0.6631052494049072,
0.42862528562545776,
0.2514163553714752,
-0.02538374625146389,
0.3606378436088562,
0.34278345108032227,
0.4565521776676178,
0.7975496649742126,
1.0014055967330933,
0.2993118464946747,
0.4354846775531769,
-0.24998433887958527,
-0.12983207404613495,
-0.050710830837488174,
-0.7502197623252869,
-0.8565192818641663,
-0.769156277179718,
0.28786641359329224,
-0.13474862277507782,
0.044128891080617905,
0.6593372225761414,
0.6667989492416382,
-0.47462522983551025,
-0.4719095826148987,
-0.18526041507720947,
0.11133115738630295,
-0.3898664116859436,
-0.17679110169410706,
0.279852956533432,
-0.2454080581665039,
-0.49450379610061646,
0.47670018672943115,
0.5849413275718689,
0.19578523933887482,
-0.7811411023139954,
-0.25891271233558655,
-0.11557504534721375,
0.07947935909032822,
0.8210928440093994,
0.3319936692714691,
-0.7726473808288574,
0.020950421690940857,
-0.16894927620887756,
0.2374122589826584,
-0.06813953816890717,
0.9824795722961426,
-0.7348687648773193,
0.4852922558784485,
0.3155311346054077,
0.4542059898376465,
0.6823486089706421,
-0.37848609685897827,
1.0136088132858276,
-0.31981563568115234,
0.1595776528120041,
0.17757807672023773,
0.508261501789093,
0.11262762546539307,
-0.5496960282325745,
0.575588583946228,
-0.47268611192703247,
-0.5940732359886169,
-0.4972749948501587,
0.4302498996257782,
-0.8660591840744019,
-0.39032572507858276,
1.0455338954925537,
0.18438775837421417,
-0.3594450354576111,
0.02743082493543625,
-0.1397305428981781,
0.17194387316703796,
-0.34889301657676697,
0.44463175535202026,
0.7157891988754272,
-0.4836372137069702,
-0.46334969997406006,
-0.7577787637710571,
0.3652353286743164,
-0.01159446407109499,
-0.8817926645278931,
0.29792842268943787,
0.416358083486557,
-0.3148539960384369,
0.26719650626182556,
0.980503499507904,
-0.03501169756054878,
0.0803329274058342,
0.05130652338266373,
-0.20985957980155945,
-0.019759532064199448,
-0.6769340634346008,
-0.09908471256494522,
0.03262815251946449,
0.23020201921463013,
-0.13040970265865326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16030v1 | Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual NER Using Phonemic Representations for Low-Resource Languages | 2024-06-23T06:38:56 | 2024-06-23T06:38:56 | Jimin Sohn, Haeji Jung, Alex Cheng, Jooeon Kang, Yilin Du, David R. Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing zero-shot cross-lingual NER approaches require substantial prior
knowledge of the target language, which is impractical for low-resource
languages. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to NER using phonemic
representation based on the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) to bridge the
gap between representations of different languages. Our experiments show that
our method significantly outperforms baseline models in extremely low-resource
languages, with the highest average F-1 score (46.38%) and lowest standard
deviation (12.67), particularly demonstrating its robustness with non-Latin
scripts. | [
-0.2851963937282562,
-0.28909316658973694,
0.2575278580188751,
0.2065383344888687,
-0.22096416354179382,
0.24923403561115265,
-0.20665450394153595,
-0.5320909023284912,
0.6556867361068726,
0.184963196516037,
-0.11269927769899368,
-0.5804129242897034,
-0.39156270027160645,
0.32375237345695496,
0.0862150564789772,
0.39362382888793945,
0.20694556832313538,
0.17492137849330902,
0.31970757246017456,
-0.2568208575248718,
-0.5133458971977234,
-0.5500693917274475,
-0.4966435134410858,
-0.478956013917923,
0.6046434044837952,
0.8890674114227295,
0.64601069688797,
0.35767173767089844,
0.5058901906013489,
0.10866592824459076,
0.05344526097178459,
-0.3177473843097687,
-0.16465769708156586,
-0.024528469890356064,
-0.009296576492488384,
-0.5411036014556885,
-0.41898348927497864,
-0.24264442920684814,
0.757740318775177,
0.962414562702179,
0.04199765995144844,
0.08718734234571457,
-0.3550613820552826,
0.57170569896698,
-0.698345959186554,
-0.058066416531801224,
-0.7000353336334229,
0.3824673295021057,
-0.3737017512321472,
-0.1602609008550644,
-0.593063235282898,
0.06051534414291382,
0.1868729442358017,
-0.8273934721946716,
-0.12689408659934998,
0.03647696226835251,
0.6771498322486877,
0.09324757009744644,
-0.23466600477695465,
-0.07371223717927933,
-0.9672507643699646,
0.9420931935310364,
-0.6590059995651245,
0.7134617567062378,
0.4449102282524109,
0.26784318685531616,
0.14818203449249268,
-0.2448594868183136,
-0.5866833925247192,
-0.27550914883613586,
0.1892704963684082,
0.13684247434139252,
-0.4404599666595459,
-0.12655989825725555,
0.15939374268054962,
0.22369450330734253,
-0.7017291188240051,
0.17837899923324585,
-0.40572425723075867,
-0.2637779414653778,
0.504913330078125,
0.009367144666612148,
0.5764137506484985,
-0.28754502534866333,
-0.4339050054550171,
-0.18880032002925873,
-0.750368058681488,
-0.005555309355258942,
0.3093535602092743,
0.7857545614242554,
-0.22884999215602875,
0.632999837398529,
-0.09989478439092636,
0.6911952495574951,
0.32283344864845276,
-0.1037345677614212,
0.49681296944618225,
-0.16212832927703857,
-0.14336469769477844,
0.5307275652885437,
0.8353028893470764,
0.3620834946632385,
0.35573047399520874,
-0.28858834505081177,
-0.0006909886142238975,
0.03751394525170326,
-0.06558084487915039,
-0.8002516031265259,
0.19209331274032593,
-0.19517482817173004,
-0.339508593082428,
0.10878170281648636,
-0.20958495140075684,
-0.5426611304283142,
0.08170034736394882,
0.16103608906269073,
0.32466480135917664,
-0.7609365582466125,
-0.5412810444831848,
-0.047081269323825836,
0.015624487772583961,
0.6019802689552307,
0.2871359884738922,
-0.9111961126327515,
0.5140612125396729,
0.20592741668224335,
0.9499531984329224,
0.25287678837776184,
-0.11550942808389664,
-0.5582817196846008,
-0.027162909507751465,
-0.7592019438743591,
0.648783802986145,
-0.792955219745636,
-0.4829227030277252,
-0.17628906667232513,
-0.3322261869907379,
-0.07628749310970306,
-0.5934040546417236,
0.1618647426366806,
-0.5009440183639526,
0.05780496820807457,
0.03693144768476486,
-0.2911955416202545,
-0.1936599165201187,
0.23629744350910187,
-0.7834586501121521,
0.9965629577636719,
0.2734133005142212,
-0.5784822106361389,
0.3759016692638397,
-0.5409032106399536,
-0.532447099685669,
0.2712409794330597,
-0.25040963292121887,
0.21156805753707886,
0.10787311941385269,
0.4363907277584076,
0.07791001349687576,
-0.3687609136104584,
-0.09292488545179367,
-0.09112773835659027,
-0.7434015870094299,
-0.13866211473941803,
-0.4888221323490143,
0.8117878437042236,
0.08360771089792252,
-0.19362936913967133,
-0.4072781801223755,
-0.8452867865562439,
0.19846020638942719,
0.17113463580608368,
-0.06867000460624695,
-0.7913246154785156,
-0.7465190291404724,
0.08355358242988586,
0.23681946098804474,
0.2862195372581482,
-0.9082111120223999,
0.233136847615242,
-0.6673423051834106,
0.002327360911294818,
0.15288995206356049,
-0.06414993107318878,
0.976966381072998,
-0.13627775013446808,
0.750551164150238,
-0.059869807213544846,
-0.19782274961471558,
-0.3911454379558563,
-0.6153793931007385,
-0.5676859021186829,
-0.1396181881427765,
0.7832590937614441,
1.0008141994476318,
-0.866584062576294,
0.18474961817264557,
-0.22250287234783173,
-0.4891427755355835,
-0.757515549659729,
0.12361043691635132,
0.6717672944068909,
0.44233477115631104,
0.4025518596172333,
-0.6912251114845276,
-0.49570006132125854,
-0.8374412655830383,
-0.027486033737659454,
-0.6958282589912415,
-0.20625890791416168,
0.34360429644584656,
0.22894001007080078,
0.00015411985805258155,
0.5828389525413513,
-0.0034514148719608784,
-0.44686517119407654,
-0.4616822600364685,
0.30933651328086853,
0.429963082075119,
0.3441216051578522,
0.5912948250770569,
-0.5462571382522583,
-0.8031787872314453,
0.32323265075683594,
-0.5867065191268921,
-0.14539502561092377,
-0.008586875163018703,
0.21055550873279572,
0.26791200041770935,
0.713261604309082,
-0.24345141649246216,
0.48247337341308594,
0.4229961931705475,
-0.16058233380317688,
0.13860538601875305,
-0.03764549642801285,
0.01872824877500534,
-0.9049252271652222,
0.34363847970962524,
0.17288890480995178,
-0.14143481850624084,
-0.8134036660194397,
-0.36773011088371277,
-0.023644642904400826,
-0.5220080614089966,
-0.7313339114189148,
1.0454026460647583,
-0.7203192710876465,
-0.17507493495941162,
-0.12492785602807999,
-0.12605859339237213,
-0.17825332283973694,
0.539338231086731,
0.4428628385066986,
0.6587654948234558,
0.6670926213264465,
-0.27297958731651306,
-0.11919819563627243,
0.15384331345558167,
-0.13442867994308472,
0.7633599638938904,
-0.7117835283279419,
0.06475305557250977,
-0.15973201394081116,
0.10960815846920013,
-0.6829783916473389,
-0.0419887900352478,
0.4333287179470062,
-0.7914100885391235,
0.43943578004837036,
-0.48129040002822876,
-0.25260087847709656,
0.1040862500667572,
-0.01802576705813408,
0.8900485634803772,
0.5214968323707581,
-0.22843870520591736,
0.6236306428909302,
0.4351925253868103,
-0.43320390582084656,
-0.7324919700622559,
-0.858844518661499,
0.1808152198791504,
0.053438302129507065,
-0.6595251560211182,
0.5451337099075317,
0.19580364227294922,
-0.371602863073349,
0.024315759539604187,
-0.16291022300720215,
-0.2647850811481476,
-0.5390492677688599,
0.11979356408119202,
0.22519689798355103,
-0.6311486959457397,
-0.09063293039798737,
-0.4257710874080658,
-0.3499000370502472,
-0.42431044578552246,
0.0008587431511841714,
0.647149384021759,
-0.24025028944015503,
-0.49320533871650696,
-0.5569837093353271,
0.6666375994682312,
0.810394823551178,
-0.14543485641479492,
0.17264051735401154,
0.31429925560951233,
-0.4821043014526367,
-0.08278758078813553,
-0.4354506731033325,
-0.05297721177339554,
-0.3718905746936798,
0.08168685436248779,
-0.37378475069999695,
-0.5200853943824768,
0.7500817179679871,
-0.017333466559648514,
-0.390365332365036,
0.23873308300971985,
0.3175314962863922,
0.1547168493270874,
0.7443984150886536,
0.8835644125938416,
-0.3275492787361145,
0.7006384134292603,
-0.33337366580963135,
0.3785874545574188,
-0.8288843035697937,
-0.20477384328842163,
-0.3111044764518738,
-0.3028753101825714,
-0.447078675031662,
-0.5478307604789734,
0.379294753074646,
0.20837049186229706,
-0.1526813507080078,
0.4233855903148651,
-0.21837250888347626,
0.5712162256240845,
0.7201889157295227,
-0.2578411102294922,
0.25649866461753845,
0.24425235390663147,
-0.6140965819358826,
-0.20298001170158386,
-0.9385078549385071,
-0.3442041873931885,
0.8666775226593018,
0.29839691519737244,
0.829903244972229,
-0.03737495094537735,
1.0481106042861938,
0.1760653555393219,
-0.006743807345628738,
-1.1325466632843018,
0.6286004185676575,
-0.3798764944076538,
-0.6370265483856201,
-0.5442578196525574,
-0.24235202372074127,
-0.7770342826843262,
0.2973249554634094,
-0.05980096012353897,
-0.7227106690406799,
0.6122051477432251,
-0.25059792399406433,
-0.538865327835083,
0.43305060267448425,
-0.7013200521469116,
0.7046470642089844,
-0.2767157256603241,
-0.11798463761806488,
0.11301456391811371,
-0.7261658310890198,
0.04929542914032936,
0.09534202516078949,
0.12048675119876862,
-0.2164650559425354,
-0.05921445041894913,
0.6252227425575256,
-0.5894953608512878,
0.9450774788856506,
-0.2265913188457489,
0.08657606691122055,
0.3775254189968109,
0.2561526894569397,
0.08617084473371506,
-0.054119773209095,
-0.5264033675193787,
0.6708899736404419,
-0.43986865878105164,
-0.403046578168869,
-0.5562869310379028,
0.4831494688987732,
-0.614409863948822,
-0.2850886583328247,
-0.8222454190254211,
-0.5050190091133118,
-0.08421704173088074,
0.4424212574958801,
0.4065369963645935,
0.2818768620491028,
-0.5571589469909668,
0.011012920178472996,
0.07654223591089249,
-0.17275166511535645,
0.4945560693740845,
0.784597635269165,
-0.13711927831172943,
-0.6902406215667725,
0.9539633393287659,
0.5296183824539185,
0.1655745506286621,
0.5395253300666809,
-0.07751729339361191,
-0.1756426841020584,
-0.47857892513275146,
-0.7867287993431091,
0.3303264081478119,
-0.40038371086120605,
-0.26279327273368835,
-0.22778429090976715,
-0.3651576340198517,
-0.32213103771209717,
-0.450206458568573,
-0.48642751574516296,
-0.5688799619674683,
-0.08741047233343124,
0.19234681129455566,
0.21871501207351685,
0.5878111124038696,
-0.6125375032424927,
0.29031622409820557,
-0.6917893290519714,
0.40967386960983276,
0.11278986930847168,
0.41702520847320557,
0.08126086741685867,
-0.5559514760971069,
-0.17953132092952728,
-0.12211000174283981,
0.1544298380613327,
-0.8845438957214355,
0.5842695236206055,
0.282570481300354,
0.5064228773117065,
0.2833753526210785,
0.2790965735912323,
0.870827853679657,
-0.7077524662017822,
0.5943060517311096,
0.6681878566741943,
-1.0255167484283447,
0.5802310109138489,
-0.13131076097488403,
0.596189558506012,
0.6774776577949524,
0.5181664824485779,
-0.8440675735473633,
-0.31839436292648315,
-0.4927400052547455,
-1.1771382093429565,
0.7426908612251282,
0.11655243486166,
0.12815585732460022,
-0.14350280165672302,
-0.04812421277165413,
0.10996748507022858,
-0.39478978514671326,
-0.637005090713501,
-0.10008756071329117,
-0.29988011717796326,
0.03128169849514961,
0.1399269849061966,
0.13514821231365204,
0.3300333321094513,
-0.1985013782978058,
0.595590353012085,
-0.1983126848936081,
0.2977410852909088,
0.4842304289340973,
-0.25052332878112793,
-0.2944726347923279,
0.4407103657722473,
0.20668485760688782,
0.26459091901779175,
-0.3595477044582367,
0.0813908502459526,
0.3564707040786743,
-0.6436545848846436,
0.44000041484832764,
0.11158536374568939,
-0.3767445981502533,
0.3612261116504669,
0.6156672239303589,
0.7191562056541443,
0.2776165306568146,
-0.4667104482650757,
0.6236801743507385,
-0.06116528809070587,
-0.19667860865592957,
-0.3437751233577728,
-0.3547419309616089,
-0.11561960726976395,
0.1382758468389511,
0.6605824828147888,
0.12288302183151245,
-0.06628051400184631,
-0.7288690209388733,
0.1967247724533081,
0.3366904556751251,
-0.6244994401931763,
-0.5002769827842712,
0.2830871641635895,
0.26899006962776184,
-0.44305819272994995,
0.6651357412338257,
-0.2733963429927826,
-0.3099382817745209,
0.642097532749176,
0.911846399307251,
0.755081295967102,
-0.5810332894325256,
0.40543490648269653,
0.6337363719940186,
0.44008445739746094,
0.17435488104820251,
0.666824460029602,
-0.12967044115066528,
-0.8202962875366211,
-0.4441452622413635,
-0.45210498571395874,
-0.8614909648895264,
0.14731504023075104,
-0.6780722141265869,
0.3269936740398407,
-0.6954458355903625,
-0.0435517318546772,
0.1986655741930008,
-0.14781183004379272,
-0.6286122798919678,
0.13493753969669342,
0.5350827574729919,
1.027307391166687,
-0.8137986660003662,
0.8522740602493286,
0.6966245770454407,
-0.7413986921310425,
-0.8902368545532227,
0.30886074900627136,
0.02139422483742237,
-1.0402668714523315,
1.1928908824920654,
0.11024650186300278,
-0.4215909242630005,
-0.23390625417232513,
-0.09106200933456421,
-1.040529727935791,
0.680895984172821,
0.6266675591468811,
-0.7510899305343628,
-0.07783570140600204,
0.4131309390068054,
0.5843925476074219,
-0.5672581791877747,
0.3943305015563965,
0.14214292168617249,
0.3821456730365753,
0.42653605341911316,
-1.339463233947754,
-0.056953586637973785,
-0.7512597441673279,
0.02516707219183445,
0.21335743367671967,
-0.5828214287757874,
0.8069723844528198,
-0.46341830492019653,
-0.596930205821991,
-0.12033911794424057,
0.39818689227104187,
0.1217363253235817,
0.4297921359539032,
0.5282883048057556,
0.6681410074234009,
0.5681234002113342,
0.2582354247570038,
0.6927502155303955,
-0.5461209416389465,
-0.25856518745422363,
0.9779027700424194,
-0.8159875273704529,
1.1584420204162598,
0.5978424549102783,
0.14257310330867767,
0.5157445073127747,
0.23872976005077362,
0.11926698684692383,
0.6628778576850891,
0.06707763671875,
-0.3287286162376404,
-0.22193680703639984,
-0.5218611359596252,
-0.43866702914237976,
0.9041909575462341,
0.37854841351509094,
-0.04267572984099388,
-0.42257052659988403,
-0.013906250707805157,
-0.15628299117088318,
-0.13920733332633972,
-0.4445638060569763,
0.7936840653419495,
0.21704353392124176,
-0.4559061527252197,
1.0290402173995972,
-0.18388788402080536,
0.8874824643135071,
-0.5439544320106506,
-0.41119739413261414,
-0.2469194084405899,
-0.008525615558028221,
-0.10387374460697174,
-0.765169084072113,
0.36476078629493713,
0.2747473120689392,
-0.23375403881072998,
-0.20364004373550415,
0.9854670166969299,
-0.44836586713790894,
-0.6279835104942322,
0.8326097130775452,
0.6327776312828064,
0.3421814441680908,
0.16559189558029175,
-0.27317920327186584,
-0.10986162722110748,
-0.27275094389915466,
0.29388654232025146,
0.06443554162979126,
0.5295765995979309,
-0.2821257710456848,
0.40074145793914795,
0.6773251891136169,
0.282777339220047,
0.05831094831228256,
0.1794985830783844,
0.6211990118026733,
-0.9922851920127869,
-0.6503214836120605,
-0.5216426253318787,
0.26175880432128906,
0.14762216806411743,
-0.4210759103298187,
0.5393843650817871,
0.5616766214370728,
1.0937917232513428,
0.07943205535411835,
0.9501941204071045,
-0.08891350030899048,
0.42366963624954224,
-0.27863889932632446,
0.6463064551353455,
-0.5688446164131165,
0.023617040365934372,
-0.3195990025997162,
-0.9300936460494995,
-0.8135718107223511,
0.8313078284263611,
-0.38799652457237244,
-0.23033075034618378,
0.42180612683296204,
0.7975126504898071,
-0.2584158480167389,
-0.305489718914032,
0.7128360271453857,
-0.03925200551748276,
-0.3161504864692688,
0.7029129266738892,
0.797661304473877,
-0.6220423579216003,
0.7349280714988708,
-0.27073830366134644,
-0.1496845781803131,
-0.42745164036750793,
-0.7625607848167419,
-0.7812216877937317,
-0.2806057631969452,
-0.07405871897935867,
-0.05411006882786751,
0.02956385910511017,
0.8946449756622314,
0.7887296676635742,
-0.7221962809562683,
-0.4128844141960144,
0.2272288054227829,
0.14214050769805908,
-0.13743413984775543,
-0.13605338335037231,
0.09542058408260345,
-0.1545911282300949,
-0.6121305823326111,
0.8647682666778564,
0.576781690120697,
0.07947859168052673,
-0.2614731192588806,
-0.4339462220668793,
-0.28112709522247314,
0.13870394229888916,
0.4320428669452667,
0.8468354344367981,
-0.7147860527038574,
0.03761950880289078,
0.5577415823936462,
-0.13752906024456024,
0.401467502117157,
0.7961640954017639,
-0.9234139919281006,
0.4763173758983612,
0.6498688459396362,
0.3784193694591522,
0.46470144391059875,
-0.45953914523124695,
0.6929317116737366,
-0.7640841603279114,
0.4853631854057312,
0.6104701161384583,
0.4177720248699188,
0.6001073122024536,
-0.22243724763393402,
0.4541665017604828,
-0.06425303220748901,
-0.05984530970454216,
-0.7443766593933105,
0.2688972055912018,
-1.1252018213272095,
-0.03962155431509018,
0.941327691078186,
0.03715839609503746,
-0.38493385910987854,
-0.23777608573436737,
-0.0009658674825914204,
0.13443221151828766,
-0.7432056069374084,
0.3016265332698822,
0.6255613565444946,
-0.10925433039665222,
-0.2213151603937149,
-0.21208921074867249,
-0.09531108289957047,
0.48109862208366394,
-0.30171260237693787,
-0.18241876363754272,
0.22543789446353912,
0.25431081652641296,
0.7765247225761414,
1.1571555137634277,
-0.4195405840873718,
0.3668271005153656,
0.32354360818862915,
0.3438270390033722,
0.19124974310398102,
-0.57917720079422,
-0.4567665457725525,
0.152315154671669,
0.0075004370883107185,
-0.17346008121967316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16021v1 | Harvesting Events from Multiple Sources: Towards a Cross-Document Event Extraction Paradigm | 2024-06-23T06:01:11 | 2024-06-23T06:01:11 | Qiang Gao, Zixiang Meng, Bobo Li, Jun Zhou, Fei Li, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Document-level event extraction aims to extract structured event information
from unstructured text. However, a single document often contains limited event
information and the roles of different event arguments may be biased due to the
influence of the information source. This paper addresses the limitations of
traditional document-level event extraction by proposing the task of
cross-document event extraction (CDEE) to integrate event information from
multiple documents and provide a comprehensive perspective on events. We
construct a novel cross-document event extraction dataset, namely CLES, which
contains 20,059 documents and 37,688 mention-level events, where over 70% of
them are cross-document. To build a benchmark, we propose a CDEE pipeline that
includes 5 steps, namely event extraction, coreference resolution, entity
normalization, role normalization and entity-role resolution. Our CDEE pipeline
achieves about 72% F1 in end-to-end cross-document event extraction, suggesting
the challenge of this task. Our work builds a new line of information
extraction research and will attract new research attention. | [
-0.5323576927185059,
-0.40841394662857056,
0.6388554573059082,
-0.1463189572095871,
-0.19771884381771088,
0.05074646696448326,
-0.24192342162132263,
-0.8383020162582397,
0.16516156494617462,
0.2425544410943985,
-0.52963787317276,
-0.577082097530365,
-0.865961492061615,
0.08053257316350937,
-0.7472018599510193,
1.0858075618743896,
-0.06868860125541687,
-0.27248087525367737,
0.11906811594963074,
0.02459530346095562,
-0.4063556492328644,
-0.3953755497932434,
-0.7350496649742126,
-0.07515197992324829,
0.48162841796875,
0.49638599157333374,
0.0541926734149456,
0.3693211078643799,
0.20676887035369873,
0.059593990445137024,
0.29917898774147034,
0.1139494776725769,
-0.3025611639022827,
0.06487730145454407,
-0.3686645030975342,
-0.3608509600162506,
-0.3743305206298828,
0.544003963470459,
0.6453622579574585,
0.2180383950471878,
0.14874552190303802,
0.21919453144073486,
0.14062435925006866,
0.17468760907649994,
-0.889165997505188,
0.040455080568790436,
-0.6763356328010559,
0.08568663895130157,
-0.48441433906555176,
-0.39921504259109497,
-0.5554614067077637,
0.21803270280361176,
0.2718730568885803,
-0.6215531826019287,
0.6385483741760254,
-0.43407779932022095,
0.8793797492980957,
-0.42035582661628723,
-0.41519981622695923,
-0.4687769114971161,
-0.6727181673049927,
0.8949779868125916,
-0.6123337149620056,
0.3064880967140198,
0.10045915842056274,
0.16354599595069885,
0.2678239643573761,
-0.9040194749832153,
-0.453909307718277,
0.3151758313179016,
-0.03161749988794327,
0.18154054880142212,
-0.1585773229598999,
-0.38339605927467346,
0.19285735487937927,
0.18612119555473328,
-0.3318594992160797,
0.107951320707798,
-0.19305847585201263,
0.01808556355535984,
0.6963582038879395,
0.03705092892050743,
0.2950487434864044,
-0.2823198139667511,
-0.5421289801597595,
-0.08988123387098312,
-0.30999186635017395,
-0.01352966669946909,
0.21788640320301056,
0.10778065025806427,
0.048309002071619034,
0.32808059453964233,
-0.01930227130651474,
0.187828928232193,
0.42289993166923523,
-0.16729386150836945,
-0.04207250848412514,
-0.9005448818206787,
-0.1756226122379303,
0.20412003993988037,
0.7281817197799683,
0.3327504098415375,
-0.0481308251619339,
-0.3526608645915985,
0.137889102101326,
-0.24990509450435638,
0.09542598575353622,
-0.7391546964645386,
0.07614912837743759,
0.5477634072303772,
-0.7160186171531677,
-0.17476719617843628,
0.26396408677101135,
-1.4297114610671997,
-0.5469186305999756,
-0.2618832290172577,
-0.08900920301675797,
-0.5071980953216553,
-0.27233922481536865,
-0.21423368155956268,
-0.9477199912071228,
0.5780020356178284,
0.645186722278595,
-0.5782540440559387,
0.10017253458499908,
0.5669442415237427,
0.8028778433799744,
-0.5766149163246155,
-0.2711995542049408,
-0.7928789258003235,
0.5232810378074646,
0.24677468836307526,
1.01983642578125,
-0.9215273857116699,
-0.6339008808135986,
0.06147971376776695,
0.08341013640165329,
-0.224654421210289,
-0.21485912799835205,
0.8206123113632202,
-0.4259693920612335,
0.26989099383354187,
-0.2988791763782501,
-0.6133064031600952,
0.1566457599401474,
0.19799497723579407,
-0.7749234437942505,
0.9357771277427673,
-0.29990798234939575,
-0.9302276968955994,
0.663567841053009,
-0.5300878286361694,
-0.3734082579612732,
0.04656170308589935,
-0.5966957807540894,
-0.031313419342041016,
-0.03467540442943573,
0.5519721508026123,
0.3159465491771698,
-0.5469810962677002,
0.1275312602519989,
-0.2832801342010498,
0.22257298231124878,
-0.03923356533050537,
-0.18503160774707794,
0.8323560953140259,
0.022823525592684746,
-0.40339553356170654,
-0.15432913601398468,
-1.1564409732818604,
-0.19136396050453186,
0.006327510811388493,
-0.3077858090400696,
-0.5304125547409058,
0.12143459916114807,
0.439035028219223,
0.5212384462356567,
0.4109010398387909,
-0.8102359771728516,
0.41828325390815735,
-0.018315574154257774,
0.12206140160560608,
0.45844319462776184,
0.36220139265060425,
0.8364997506141663,
-0.06641313433647156,
0.5532183647155762,
0.1743229627609253,
0.1364181786775589,
-0.3989080488681793,
-0.3050731122493744,
-0.14077919721603394,
-0.4090327024459839,
0.23114044964313507,
0.6658498644828796,
-0.4232567846775055,
0.41502028703689575,
-0.05118389427661896,
-0.4150453805923462,
-0.29561591148376465,
0.1164691150188446,
0.08689441531896591,
0.32759615778923035,
0.20418289303779602,
-0.42421114444732666,
-0.834087610244751,
-0.5161120891571045,
-0.4227728247642517,
0.019142301753163338,
-0.03351302817463875,
-0.0438096858561039,
0.39926818013191223,
0.1539759486913681,
1.1555354595184326,
-0.46125367283821106,
-0.5870157480239868,
-0.3430338501930237,
0.5135373473167419,
0.03998931124806404,
0.39247453212738037,
0.6549879908561707,
-0.8407639861106873,
-0.4079154431819916,
0.3797377645969391,
-0.8295750617980957,
-0.052954595535993576,
-0.5135203003883362,
-0.07364248484373093,
0.12993258237838745,
0.48977014422416687,
-0.455909788608551,
0.6938325762748718,
0.3259289860725403,
-0.20744845271110535,
0.4746306538581848,
0.2261844128370285,
0.16396677494049072,
-1.0891274213790894,
0.1821335107088089,
0.11501708626747131,
-0.056600216776132584,
-0.5976548790931702,
-0.1812017261981964,
0.050369828939437866,
-0.198449045419693,
-0.2679140567779541,
0.6378829479217529,
-0.9503179788589478,
-0.21223150193691254,
-0.40423592925071716,
0.6447611451148987,
0.38882917165756226,
0.19192644953727722,
0.31427201628685,
0.18274421989917755,
0.4223105311393738,
-0.3017978072166443,
0.2921976149082184,
0.3844396770000458,
-0.18587583303451538,
0.797110915184021,
-0.21714386343955994,
0.17384490370750427,
-0.09318863600492477,
0.4784294366836548,
-0.5505449771881104,
0.21522942185401917,
0.002014333615079522,
-0.3386750817298889,
0.38204410672187805,
-0.2375875860452652,
-0.3992156386375427,
0.06571430712938309,
-0.49139437079429626,
0.1056419312953949,
-0.10088104754686356,
-0.37052682042121887,
1.0705535411834717,
0.8319035768508911,
-0.2132129669189453,
-0.7170371413230896,
-0.34212058782577515,
0.2640327513217926,
-0.1169113889336586,
-0.6361576318740845,
0.3497447967529297,
0.18036998808383942,
-0.06439997255802155,
0.17405028641223907,
-0.40663883090019226,
-0.32988035678863525,
-0.224956214427948,
0.1326770782470703,
0.17016176879405975,
-0.07126255333423615,
-0.22915536165237427,
0.04665324464440346,
-0.1199648305773735,
-0.11701901257038116,
-0.5804252624511719,
0.266542911529541,
0.49867889285087585,
-0.29426538944244385,
-0.6019025444984436,
1.170175313949585,
0.2480033040046692,
-0.424912691116333,
0.5346760749816895,
0.9047200679779053,
-0.6165897250175476,
-0.27414819598197937,
-0.5802447199821472,
-0.0688309371471405,
-0.27380362153053284,
0.22111909091472626,
-0.6119178533554077,
-0.5770525336265564,
0.677702009677887,
-0.1512759029865265,
0.5607571601867676,
0.619012176990509,
0.26785871386528015,
0.019435063004493713,
0.7445781826972961,
0.5849581956863403,
-0.06716538220643997,
0.7352343797683716,
-0.18116232752799988,
-0.005702556110918522,
-0.8656184077262878,
-0.20457379519939423,
-0.9734802842140198,
-0.15093587338924408,
-0.0686933845281601,
-0.38415610790252686,
0.14972296357154846,
0.30347180366516113,
0.3743101954460144,
0.5107786655426025,
-0.13087321817874908,
0.2870587408542633,
0.5452649593353271,
-0.22701111435890198,
0.6185872554779053,
-0.17578791081905365,
0.2570303678512573,
0.08053943514823914,
-0.6829820275306702,
-0.528984010219574,
0.8613160848617554,
0.07696368545293808,
0.4768983721733093,
-0.20124085247516632,
0.883537232875824,
0.267965167760849,
0.1555909663438797,
-0.41175398230552673,
0.22507432103157043,
-0.1325576901435852,
-0.9424890875816345,
-0.4546612501144409,
0.0050325896590948105,
-1.0031217336654663,
0.31047436594963074,
-0.19774918258190155,
-1.1217297315597534,
0.9796426296234131,
-0.38804805278778076,
-0.027769289910793304,
0.31777313351631165,
-0.5549026131629944,
0.8457372188568115,
0.20491743087768555,
-0.15521037578582764,
-0.20316962897777557,
-0.7867183685302734,
0.23117388784885406,
-0.3338037133216858,
0.5496212840080261,
-0.10125718265771866,
-0.01672714576125145,
0.7747619152069092,
0.022222260013222694,
0.8340222835540771,
-0.005980396177619696,
-0.2983998954296112,
0.5706412196159363,
0.018413381651043892,
0.7757816910743713,
0.36930978298187256,
-0.2457936704158783,
0.23955611884593964,
0.3620341718196869,
-0.4526939392089844,
-0.5040966272354126,
0.6061818599700928,
-0.493808776140213,
-0.3797866702079773,
-0.39426547288894653,
-0.41832298040390015,
-0.0565367192029953,
0.23924396932125092,
0.3119204342365265,
0.5754318833351135,
-0.5145086646080017,
-0.05558924749493599,
0.31855320930480957,
-0.010209433734416962,
0.8935884833335876,
0.5565887093544006,
0.42701491713523865,
-0.42530420422554016,
0.6184383034706116,
0.10957552492618561,
0.1623440682888031,
0.7194479703903198,
-0.2889706790447235,
-0.0251271054148674,
-0.4922390282154083,
-0.39552342891693115,
-0.0027218128088861704,
-0.8485652804374695,
-0.15502767264842987,
-1.0545653104782104,
-0.024408919736742973,
-0.6973949074745178,
-0.416520893573761,
-0.3497809171676636,
-0.472659170627594,
-0.5748533010482788,
-0.06975474208593369,
-0.3254072368144989,
0.4726075232028961,
-0.28992974758148193,
0.12661629915237427,
-1.473304033279419,
0.3542024493217468,
-0.09034520387649536,
-0.18826618790626526,
0.004899963270872831,
-0.05708814039826393,
-0.3432648479938507,
-0.46386921405792236,
-0.43492448329925537,
-1.3059775829315186,
0.3098399043083191,
0.29007551074028015,
0.8494700193405151,
0.4010520875453949,
0.07535640895366669,
0.5334600806236267,
-0.35476744174957275,
0.8372077941894531,
0.3203219771385193,
-1.0628849267959595,
0.8924381732940674,
-0.17597688734531403,
0.1756664216518402,
0.582099974155426,
0.352232962846756,
-0.5253223180770874,
-0.560886800289154,
-0.9312297701835632,
-0.7950674891471863,
0.998314380645752,
0.3216373920440674,
-0.48242464661598206,
-0.0494229681789875,
0.19240973889827728,
0.4258115887641907,
0.10562515258789062,
-0.6150162816047668,
-0.12148918211460114,
0.07852517813444138,
0.07046688348054886,
0.12803998589515686,
-0.06353507190942764,
-0.27970242500305176,
0.33184897899627686,
0.5509738922119141,
-0.22799396514892578,
-0.09630494564771652,
0.6129985451698303,
-0.23415832221508026,
-0.052485834807157516,
0.5251737236976624,
0.07400689274072647,
0.8470668792724609,
-0.24477916955947876,
0.0891525000333786,
0.10949116200208664,
-0.4827076494693756,
-0.410841166973114,
0.41851145029067993,
-0.16512762010097504,
0.23265939950942993,
0.8256741762161255,
0.4784429669380188,
0.07001271843910217,
-0.46177977323532104,
0.5639578700065613,
-0.16517794132232666,
0.010353578254580498,
-0.22501060366630554,
-0.29853692650794983,
-0.2330007255077362,
0.41892579197883606,
0.6327865123748779,
-0.28325849771499634,
0.3738177418708801,
-0.8165726065635681,
0.5853046774864197,
0.44348886609077454,
-0.3148471713066101,
-0.3874545693397522,
0.6558180451393127,
0.5375756621360779,
0.26077327132225037,
0.22189216315746307,
0.05653172358870506,
0.012281344272196293,
0.7885407209396362,
0.39996790885925293,
0.834637463092804,
-0.0003605212550610304,
0.27957165241241455,
0.4825884997844696,
0.45305249094963074,
0.2627928853034973,
0.09406046569347382,
-0.09591268002986908,
-0.7202364206314087,
-0.5168259143829346,
-0.6303624510765076,
-0.22086960077285767,
0.04351518303155899,
-0.7125484347343445,
0.515413761138916,
0.015484488569200039,
-0.04885897785425186,
0.4274873733520508,
0.2837342321872711,
-0.6002193093299866,
0.019535116851329803,
0.24773982167243958,
1.2605855464935303,
-0.7375501394271851,
0.9670307636260986,
0.48422232270240784,
-0.6480150818824768,
-0.31625881791114807,
-0.023197365924715996,
0.0801340714097023,
-0.3116608262062073,
0.48300668597221375,
-0.15921610593795776,
0.2984907925128937,
0.009388797916471958,
-0.19861795008182526,
-0.6377757787704468,
1.2147282361984253,
0.04656216502189636,
-0.6898915767669678,
-0.5182998180389404,
-0.11520521342754364,
0.14259755611419678,
-0.7528854012489319,
0.21424813568592072,
0.6718550324440002,
0.6548283696174622,
-0.016952471807599068,
-0.8205622434616089,
0.2504781484603882,
-0.051444053649902344,
-0.14624297618865967,
0.29083406925201416,
-0.36103469133377075,
0.5572198629379272,
0.019064543768763542,
-0.7111830115318298,
-0.20470662415027618,
0.7245684266090393,
0.061739541590213776,
0.7111169695854187,
0.5373796224594116,
0.28447210788726807,
0.7364019751548767,
0.3119461238384247,
1.0968819856643677,
-0.14748261868953705,
0.3451913893222809,
1.3495270013809204,
-0.6219462752342224,
0.483298659324646,
0.44748228788375854,
0.12510567903518677,
0.3543721139431,
0.33970358967781067,
0.07511468231678009,
0.41500502824783325,
-0.43677181005477905,
-0.3748309910297394,
-0.3289426565170288,
-0.19158139824867249,
-0.3474956154823303,
0.39732298254966736,
0.3842208683490753,
-0.46557867527008057,
-0.6322977542877197,
0.09450417011976242,
-0.03144874796271324,
-0.22343027591705322,
-0.04772816598415375,
0.8253222703933716,
0.24681724607944489,
-0.5954539775848389,
-0.29208502173423767,
0.05407080426812172,
0.0894211083650589,
-0.578861653804779,
-0.15915970504283905,
0.03237820044159889,
0.04324812814593315,
-0.23036609590053558,
-0.8449944257736206,
0.3632153868675232,
-0.06218801438808441,
-0.5610020160675049,
-0.21394383907318115,
1.079472541809082,
-0.3347098231315613,
-0.14530202746391296,
0.6216826438903809,
0.7525782585144043,
-0.01879807561635971,
-0.18661388754844666,
-0.41830018162727356,
0.1484178602695465,
0.02571607381105423,
-0.26486140489578247,
0.6045342683792114,
0.8589375019073486,
-0.08551985770463943,
-0.1753331571817398,
0.7576078176498413,
0.021604159846901894,
0.17016448080539703,
0.054579827934503555,
0.7299004793167114,
-0.8162486553192139,
-0.35451024770736694,
-0.7212804555892944,
0.5167989134788513,
-0.6445991396903992,
-0.4745034873485565,
0.5604864954948425,
0.7531328797340393,
0.7567440271377563,
0.08076947182416916,
1.1784805059432983,
-0.517774224281311,
0.3013547956943512,
-0.2531884014606476,
0.11264824122190475,
-0.37336987257003784,
0.028989436104893684,
-0.2731829881668091,
-0.5670788288116455,
-0.007804670371115208,
-0.12252292782068253,
0.08139588683843613,
-0.5167014598846436,
1.1111931800842285,
0.25338292121887207,
-0.032362885773181915,
0.4275497496128082,
0.009005589410662651,
-0.16727358102798462,
0.5950304865837097,
0.6429131031036377,
0.5870846509933472,
-0.5390112996101379,
0.8508428931236267,
0.12619680166244507,
-0.507824718952179,
0.01346074603497982,
-0.9463794827461243,
-0.7050754427909851,
-0.8651134967803955,
-0.46131929755210876,
-0.296188086271286,
-0.022758370265364647,
0.47182220220565796,
0.7104103565216064,
-0.887050986289978,
-0.08873781561851501,
0.16881339251995087,
0.18647751212120056,
-0.32919761538505554,
-0.2974388003349304,
0.3701631724834442,
-0.534092366695404,
-1.18732488155365,
0.5855129957199097,
0.379169762134552,
-0.37437668442726135,
0.3407016396522522,
0.42691031098365784,
-0.7715659737586975,
0.00315865408629179,
0.5696764588356018,
0.4095422029495239,
-0.22010645270347595,
-0.4051147401332855,
-0.3210549056529999,
-0.2270193248987198,
0.1158851832151413,
1.1935794353485107,
-0.4815094470977783,
0.08066965639591217,
0.6919249892234802,
0.8324732780456543,
0.9188863039016724,
-0.06604345142841339,
0.7759700417518616,
-1.0519728660583496,
0.0036376211792230606,
-0.09768489003181458,
0.35657161474227905,
-0.14608705043792725,
-0.5516152381896973,
0.6131158471107483,
0.5005524158477783,
-0.3492380678653717,
-0.6495075225830078,
0.40601229667663574,
-1.491316556930542,
-0.44218042492866516,
1.2195954322814941,
-0.20074887573719025,
-0.06269785761833191,
-0.39773017168045044,
-0.22928813099861145,
0.5377287864685059,
-0.44774940609931946,
0.39695045351982117,
0.9215878844261169,
-0.3376796841621399,
-0.2468913495540619,
-0.4572969675064087,
0.1982448548078537,
-0.13686750829219818,
-1.0443196296691895,
0.06603910773992538,
0.6242029070854187,
0.06409981101751328,
0.6378277540206909,
0.8418638110160828,
-0.31757259368896484,
0.06288077682256699,
0.15187235176563263,
0.3509174585342407,
0.3823758065700531,
-0.4731598496437073,
-0.04428965970873833,
0.8930103182792664,
-0.45832931995391846,
-0.18387122452259064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16020v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16020v2 | AudioBench: A Universal Benchmark for Audio Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T05:40:26 | 2024-06-25T12:27:06 | Bin Wang, Xunlong Zou, Geyu Lin, Shuo Sun, Zhuohan Liu, Wenyu Zhang, Zhengyuan Liu, AiTi Aw, Nancy F. Chen | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | We introduce AudioBench, a new benchmark designed to evaluate audio large
language models (AudioLLMs). AudioBench encompasses 8 distinct tasks and 26
carefully selected or newly curated datasets, focusing on speech understanding,
voice interpretation, and audio scene understanding. Despite the rapid
advancement of large language models, including multimodal versions, a
significant gap exists in comprehensive benchmarks for thoroughly evaluating
their capabilities. AudioBench addresses this gap by providing relevant
datasets and evaluation metrics. In our study, we evaluated the capabilities of
four models across various aspects and found that no single model excels
consistently across all tasks. We outline the research outlook for AudioLLMs
and anticipate that our open-source code, data, and leaderboard will offer a
robust testbed for future model developments. | [
-0.541573166847229,
-0.5792369246482849,
0.48730674386024475,
0.46438542008399963,
0.14741945266723633,
0.010267285630106926,
-0.4718756675720215,
-0.5812315344810486,
-0.22410722076892853,
0.5219696164131165,
-0.5841250419616699,
-0.7783139944076538,
-0.36909735202789307,
-0.12458950281143188,
-0.7213152050971985,
0.5235517024993896,
0.2582850158214569,
0.30582427978515625,
-0.28307825326919556,
-0.49977073073387146,
-0.7073082327842712,
-0.40290477871894836,
-0.6478245258331299,
-0.4210355877876282,
0.43286094069480896,
0.42260289192199707,
0.5645507574081421,
0.477459192276001,
0.6464074850082397,
0.29896607995033264,
-0.22542324662208557,
-0.30382487177848816,
-0.28231754899024963,
0.3621551990509033,
-0.15120017528533936,
-0.20026329159736633,
-0.658438503742218,
0.041585780680179596,
0.8225477933883667,
1.1911777257919312,
-0.5082100033760071,
0.4532471001148224,
-0.07487613707780838,
0.3734872043132782,
-0.6312292218208313,
0.1294393241405487,
-0.6032189726829529,
0.1387195736169815,
-0.12624000012874603,
0.08793578296899796,
-0.44817230105400085,
-0.2787446081638336,
0.04369990527629852,
-0.3634670078754425,
0.1289013922214508,
0.1827281266450882,
0.31365740299224854,
0.2513512670993805,
-0.46065831184387207,
0.045542601495981216,
-0.7059491276741028,
0.9150472283363342,
-0.7610693573951721,
0.9524965882301331,
0.1826666295528412,
0.7390630841255188,
-0.016553908586502075,
-0.7748363614082336,
-0.31244224309921265,
-0.2197362184524536,
0.5676360130310059,
0.031214838847517967,
-0.41618794202804565,
-0.004713247064501047,
0.2724527418613434,
0.5157249569892883,
-0.6423883438110352,
0.3392770290374756,
-0.15304575860500336,
-0.13294169306755066,
0.47640538215637207,
0.1861974000930786,
0.23257264494895935,
-0.15177807211875916,
-0.2596549987792969,
-0.2919910252094269,
-0.5690022706985474,
-0.23783284425735474,
0.3241335153579712,
0.3800080418586731,
-0.09118951857089996,
0.466385155916214,
-0.1090875118970871,
0.6522085070610046,
-0.4622686505317688,
0.10401096194982529,
0.49476000666618347,
-0.2827264964580536,
-0.1453675478696823,
0.4230062961578369,
0.7970515489578247,
0.27992236614227295,
0.04761037975549698,
-0.281101256608963,
-0.19258467853069305,
-0.050987716764211655,
0.17231886088848114,
-0.6647593379020691,
-0.07080299407243729,
0.294637531042099,
-0.4479920268058777,
-0.0011526079615578055,
-0.05643128976225853,
-0.827507734298706,
-0.5716332793235779,
-0.3965919017791748,
0.31944578886032104,
-0.1841667890548706,
-0.5636571645736694,
0.21138980984687805,
-0.18474236130714417,
0.22005616128444672,
0.19001968204975128,
-0.6663305759429932,
0.6973928809165955,
0.8521929979324341,
0.9003910422325134,
-0.450437992811203,
-0.31713175773620605,
-0.8321846723556519,
0.01802852563560009,
-0.48675793409347534,
0.6667128205299377,
-0.5660872459411621,
-0.4866810441017151,
-0.21693845093250275,
-0.04747823253273964,
0.16844314336776733,
-0.8202940225601196,
0.8279567956924438,
-0.21230891346931458,
-0.0435711108148098,
-0.10404567420482635,
-0.6870355010032654,
-0.2531048357486725,
0.024786343798041344,
-0.9683799743652344,
1.080973744392395,
-0.030698465183377266,
-0.3807072043418884,
0.26569831371307373,
-0.6896818280220032,
-0.16362851858139038,
-0.21629972755908966,
-0.1749773770570755,
-0.10055442899465561,
0.24383223056793213,
0.11593835800886154,
0.3056536018848419,
-0.6258030533790588,
0.3710227310657501,
-0.6966317296028137,
-0.32360127568244934,
0.3038407862186432,
-0.48614558577537537,
0.58333420753479,
0.2823634445667267,
-0.3122462332248688,
0.35699084401130676,
-0.9837915301322937,
0.23381824791431427,
-0.06269930303096771,
-0.2896707057952881,
0.0408162847161293,
0.01867491379380226,
0.8246510028839111,
0.24735978245735168,
-0.03082123026251793,
-0.7554491758346558,
-0.2795163691043854,
-0.1578022688627243,
0.35660964250564575,
0.690061628818512,
-0.3518733084201813,
0.06241866573691368,
-0.055046677589416504,
0.629356324672699,
-0.3994918465614319,
-0.08617964386940002,
-0.32520538568496704,
-0.20582877099514008,
-0.35660338401794434,
-0.26781126856803894,
0.5353464484214783,
0.34323790669441223,
0.23409497737884521,
0.5072023868560791,
-0.20388896763324738,
-0.6406404972076416,
-0.4656277894973755,
0.3238387405872345,
0.48746123909950256,
0.1335049271583557,
0.36451295018196106,
-0.5252830982208252,
-0.6239285469055176,
-0.9827461242675781,
-0.3277091681957245,
0.109165258705616,
-0.3258548080921173,
0.23027876019477844,
0.12199582159519196,
-0.16493166983127594,
0.7472982406616211,
-0.1246788278222084,
-0.3040075898170471,
-0.4879552721977234,
0.3515813648700714,
0.38477593660354614,
0.53945392370224,
0.7028393745422363,
-0.5135507583618164,
-0.09240058809518814,
0.0073814173229038715,
-0.5863900780677795,
-0.2917949855327606,
0.2254616767168045,
-0.016776934266090393,
0.019404245540499687,
0.8955499529838562,
-0.618590772151947,
-0.004074945580214262,
0.9006300568580627,
-0.19326768815517426,
0.5755845308303833,
0.23132652044296265,
0.1258453130722046,
-0.8973886370658875,
0.25014540553092957,
-0.2650555968284607,
-0.4121994078159332,
-0.2593570947647095,
-0.04616460204124451,
0.025653202086687088,
-0.4422109127044678,
-0.5119677782058716,
0.712739109992981,
-0.4228891134262085,
-0.7763336300849915,
-0.23328141868114471,
0.35337093472480774,
-0.05058397352695465,
0.2655821740627289,
-0.2070881724357605,
0.6472864747047424,
0.7363390922546387,
-0.25508442521095276,
0.7327090501785278,
0.22088266909122467,
-0.8012251853942871,
0.6336091756820679,
-0.8926312327384949,
0.26961228251457214,
0.21379965543746948,
0.25034070014953613,
-1.0858629941940308,
-0.2503306269645691,
-0.48034194111824036,
-0.3006344735622406,
0.15809068083763123,
0.024577390402555466,
-0.689598023891449,
-0.26794666051864624,
-0.018587930127978325,
0.43593111634254456,
0.4464903771877289,
-0.6761854290962219,
0.7355051636695862,
0.6069015264511108,
-0.42067620158195496,
-0.302505761384964,
-0.5053836703300476,
0.16041888296604156,
-0.19545027613639832,
-0.45497071743011475,
0.08025922626256943,
-0.18710875511169434,
-0.39270326495170593,
0.012983471155166626,
-0.5275261998176575,
-0.23246225714683533,
0.08924935758113861,
0.38114798069000244,
0.0008244740893132985,
-0.5118148922920227,
0.20088623464107513,
-0.381163626909256,
-0.10930895805358887,
0.23386289179325104,
-0.08850207179784775,
0.6091762781143188,
-0.2535560727119446,
-0.6133402585983276,
-0.3048223555088043,
0.41950634121894836,
0.7304950952529907,
-0.5188131928443909,
0.3185575604438782,
0.6759777665138245,
-0.18436506390571594,
-0.24560953676700592,
-0.8313634991645813,
0.03492550551891327,
-0.43727990984916687,
0.6972604393959045,
-0.39410391449928284,
-0.8352704048156738,
0.5315400958061218,
-0.26470884680747986,
0.3238016366958618,
0.369232177734375,
0.5344768762588501,
0.05160542577505112,
1.3956326246261597,
0.5085355043411255,
-0.21709047257900238,
0.4015960395336151,
0.17632804811000824,
-0.11690288782119751,
-0.6795218586921692,
-0.14453384280204773,
-0.7613469362258911,
-0.3816222846508026,
-0.16082125902175903,
-0.4321478605270386,
0.26942870020866394,
-0.040604282170534134,
-0.2022157609462738,
0.237640842795372,
-0.13759495317935944,
0.5623126029968262,
0.41824331879615784,
-0.3390178680419922,
0.3342053294181824,
-0.10649926960468292,
-0.2581527531147003,
0.1579451709985733,
-0.574096143245697,
-0.3313470482826233,
1.263248085975647,
0.3683166801929474,
0.9432781338691711,
0.3050953447818756,
0.17456093430519104,
0.22112779319286346,
-0.046826016157865524,
-0.6792573928833008,
0.528298020362854,
0.007083282805979252,
-0.8879388570785522,
-0.2464108169078827,
-0.37840399146080017,
-0.9387487769126892,
0.4627445638179779,
-0.022447163239121437,
-0.9124783277511597,
0.055738240480422974,
0.035135891288518906,
-0.15339820086956024,
0.30166658759117126,
-0.7169829607009888,
1.2723907232284546,
-0.3566488027572632,
-0.2825777530670166,
-0.5739660263061523,
-0.3476027250289917,
0.2549312710762024,
-0.13188770413398743,
0.3835873007774353,
-0.7091162204742432,
0.1274564117193222,
0.7954761981964111,
0.035178497433662415,
0.36179739236831665,
-0.2036099135875702,
-0.07402924448251724,
0.03233327716588974,
0.1999049335718155,
0.018185295164585114,
-0.025385307148098946,
-0.3979431092739105,
0.2918640971183777,
0.3003882169723511,
-0.3640124499797821,
-0.37766051292419434,
0.9182867407798767,
-0.5403503775596619,
-0.2599705159664154,
-0.22902144491672516,
-0.7082666158676147,
-0.7914625406265259,
0.3613165020942688,
-0.29757019877433777,
0.7066291570663452,
-0.7784358859062195,
0.7991538643836975,
0.5104398131370544,
-0.418599396944046,
0.3327538073062897,
0.6926431655883789,
-0.6383135318756104,
-0.19676965475082397,
0.627132773399353,
-0.40577518939971924,
0.2845798134803772,
0.09870939701795578,
-0.03018738515675068,
-0.38984787464141846,
-0.5745908617973328,
-0.23317937552928925,
-0.05930955335497856,
-0.9173291325569153,
0.06351131945848465,
-0.6301665306091309,
0.08065386116504669,
-0.37625089287757874,
0.3306218087673187,
-0.9689569473266602,
-0.4347832202911377,
0.1662517488002777,
-0.1816985011100769,
0.18520782887935638,
0.8305888175964355,
-0.08467225730419159,
0.15394829213619232,
-0.9284515976905823,
0.5668634176254272,
0.2553575038909912,
0.813148558139801,
-0.11824530363082886,
-0.4048461616039276,
-0.2887730896472931,
-0.24817097187042236,
-0.27830377221107483,
-0.6076404452323914,
0.02045576460659504,
0.31824275851249695,
0.922050952911377,
0.3942112922668457,
-0.2973231375217438,
0.46856963634490967,
-0.6587947607040405,
0.5318391919136047,
0.18631209433078766,
-1.1543512344360352,
0.39943528175354004,
-0.42496806383132935,
0.6858769655227661,
0.6814142465591431,
0.10073541104793549,
-0.7991268038749695,
-0.3909975290298462,
-0.43645450472831726,
-0.8799442648887634,
0.671379029750824,
0.17246177792549133,
0.11815571039915085,
0.2799862325191498,
-0.2488848716020584,
0.2423170655965805,
0.3715088367462158,
-0.3180375397205353,
0.025974547490477562,
-0.16027700901031494,
-0.22602880001068115,
-0.38271450996398926,
-0.07629627734422684,
-0.16301783919334412,
-0.35923272371292114,
0.4722292721271515,
-0.06951460242271423,
0.05424237251281738,
-0.23706310987472534,
-0.141035258769989,
-0.13815264403820038,
0.5681113600730896,
0.18697606027126312,
0.997182309627533,
-0.4835965931415558,
0.06702709943056107,
0.24844424426555634,
-0.17265018820762634,
0.018802836537361145,
0.2381839156150818,
0.5444608926773071,
0.28170686960220337,
0.4814310669898987,
0.9238796234130859,
0.7011696100234985,
-1.3434425592422485,
0.4393537640571594,
-0.18845798075199127,
-0.22439733147621155,
-0.4612235426902771,
0.14602161943912506,
0.4921402335166931,
0.2162170261144638,
0.2412681132555008,
-0.11452392488718033,
0.3700685501098633,
-0.6927037239074707,
0.2571760416030884,
0.3613978624343872,
-0.5392244458198547,
-0.1860727071762085,
0.8816788196563721,
0.1081216037273407,
-0.054181430488824844,
0.6626743674278259,
0.21981024742126465,
-0.0977855771780014,
0.6868301630020142,
0.2463778555393219,
0.8889144062995911,
-0.4469011127948761,
-0.23687219619750977,
0.389702707529068,
0.20229019224643707,
-0.1935172975063324,
0.28648701310157776,
-0.06910908967256546,
-0.42067381739616394,
-0.3885657787322998,
-0.803044319152832,
-0.7865989208221436,
0.17880307137966156,
-0.9375844597816467,
0.24944989383220673,
-0.43104639649391174,
-0.2195407897233963,
0.4193694591522217,
-0.3890114426612854,
-0.7179127931594849,
0.04020695015788078,
0.36265701055526733,
1.145942211151123,
-0.6253135204315186,
0.7369871735572815,
0.5696104168891907,
-0.011876409873366356,
-0.725579559803009,
-0.3173825740814209,
0.3677158057689667,
-0.484460711479187,
0.43184342980384827,
0.3007625639438629,
-0.31587696075439453,
-0.038326483219861984,
-0.4207230508327484,
-0.9688230752944946,
0.7664894461631775,
0.6406514048576355,
-0.759974479675293,
0.13089971244335175,
-0.020456518977880478,
0.4239666759967804,
-0.2815869152545929,
0.33127304911613464,
0.8764058351516724,
0.5915815830230713,
-0.03747972473502159,
-1.2737147808074951,
-0.26309332251548767,
-0.48078304529190063,
-0.1810963749885559,
0.12560749053955078,
-0.3128681480884552,
0.7990490794181824,
0.07805471122264862,
-0.023499470204114914,
0.22759371995925903,
0.42342013120651245,
0.11267183721065521,
0.02959967963397503,
0.8124248385429382,
0.5276281833648682,
0.5881908535957336,
-0.236420139670372,
1.0936188697814941,
-0.22085243463516235,
0.2139839231967926,
1.592603325843811,
-0.5333628058433533,
1.0374058485031128,
0.25759485363960266,
-0.3122279942035675,
0.2955293357372284,
0.47668692469596863,
-0.21158510446548462,
0.2467249035835266,
0.2563599646091461,
-0.06119080260396004,
-0.556481122970581,
-0.346927285194397,
-0.5744423270225525,
0.8226271271705627,
0.25032639503479004,
-0.03047030232846737,
-0.26168280839920044,
0.22043263912200928,
-0.21801505982875824,
-0.09800966084003448,
-0.1933637261390686,
0.7764827609062195,
0.10259400308132172,
-0.4324241578578949,
0.4434777796268463,
-0.1289762556552887,
0.3673028349876404,
-0.8278259634971619,
0.029451580718159676,
-0.018325794488191605,
0.35503554344177246,
-0.07957416772842407,
-0.771914005279541,
0.16977035999298096,
0.008331258781254292,
-0.023359373211860657,
-0.18693789839744568,
0.2586381435394287,
-0.43296676874160767,
-0.515948474407196,
0.7155422568321228,
0.42874184250831604,
0.2786480486392975,
-0.3698355257511139,
-0.7383542060852051,
0.6159477829933167,
-0.3261493742465973,
-0.26647627353668213,
0.15772593021392822,
0.3232263922691345,
0.18543487787246704,
0.6270203590393066,
0.6214125156402588,
0.11462700366973877,
0.1401507705450058,
0.6222164630889893,
0.48075705766677856,
-0.8273123502731323,
-0.6143285036087036,
-0.4750880300998688,
0.03644322603940964,
-0.11352083086967468,
-0.19478528201580048,
0.9547156691551208,
0.9066185355186462,
0.830535352230072,
0.06524057686328888,
0.7143328785896301,
0.14132730662822723,
0.9012760519981384,
-0.41824328899383545,
0.5853347182273865,
-0.9175912737846375,
0.20812875032424927,
-0.5922517776489258,
-1.2963988780975342,
-0.15335500240325928,
0.3094855546951294,
-0.05428948253393173,
0.18673910200595856,
0.8076969981193542,
0.6970864534378052,
-0.3887577950954437,
0.37971949577331543,
0.39589813351631165,
0.2989901006221771,
0.242622509598732,
0.4827384650707245,
0.9288685321807861,
-0.015672851353883743,
0.7495717406272888,
-0.0939718708395958,
-0.0032256795093417168,
-0.13505466282367706,
-0.8047725558280945,
-0.7453134059906006,
-0.3950670659542084,
-0.1862529069185257,
0.021926376968622208,
-0.019527493044734,
0.962601363658905,
0.964885413646698,
-1.0560425519943237,
-0.7262296080589294,
0.048166897147893906,
-0.03896794840693474,
-0.5100789666175842,
-0.18831907212734222,
0.16309063136577606,
-0.20581018924713135,
-0.8767123222351074,
0.9155977368354797,
0.2372218519449234,
-0.27779248356819153,
-0.3486842215061188,
-0.04270615056157112,
-0.017091700807213783,
0.0406164787709713,
0.4518154263496399,
0.19047853350639343,
-0.749001681804657,
-0.045743536204099655,
-0.18493175506591797,
0.010017471387982368,
0.17551974952220917,
0.9786638021469116,
-0.42608442902565,
0.6585872769355774,
0.3742223083972931,
0.8030931949615479,
0.6470257043838501,
-0.2831887900829315,
0.7597616314888,
-0.6001888513565063,
0.31432124972343445,
0.1882735788822174,
0.5339723229408264,
0.5664933919906616,
0.3766231834888458,
0.5282633900642395,
-0.24020890891551971,
-0.47708454728126526,
-1.0639456510543823,
0.005072668194770813,
-1.1879856586456299,
-0.42451557517051697,
0.932609498500824,
0.08062400668859482,
-0.0021236902102828026,
-0.14825165271759033,
-0.16891233623027802,
0.15199486911296844,
-0.40563347935676575,
0.3437708616256714,
0.8556984066963196,
-0.0013131730956956744,
-0.29296642541885376,
-1.2067923545837402,
0.14435815811157227,
0.805076539516449,
-0.941355288028717,
0.3327194154262543,
0.8477822542190552,
0.22775161266326904,
0.04268772900104523,
0.40477514266967773,
-0.28084859251976013,
0.5687037110328674,
0.03983126953244209,
0.48188337683677673,
0.027120033279061317,
-0.46806713938713074,
-0.36045631766319275,
0.3814221918582916,
0.26720431447029114,
-0.03799642622470856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16013v1 | Database-Augmented Query Representation for Information Retrieval | 2024-06-23T05:02:21 | 2024-06-23T05:02:21 | Soyeong Jeong, Jinheon Baek, Sukmin Cho, Sung Ju Hwang, Jong C. Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Information retrieval models that aim to search for the documents relevant to
the given query have shown many successes, which have been applied to diverse
tasks. However, the query provided by the user is oftentimes very short, which
challenges the retrievers to correctly fetch relevant documents. To tackle
this, existing studies have proposed expanding the query with a couple of
additional (user-related) features related to the query. Yet, they may be
suboptimal to effectively augment the query, though there is plenty of
information available to augment it in a relational database. Motivated by
this, we present a novel retrieval framework called Database-Augmented Query
representation (DAQu), which augments the original query with various
(query-related) metadata across multiple tables. In addition, as the number of
features in the metadata can be very large and there is no order among them, we
encode them with our graph-based set encoding strategy, which considers
hierarchies of features in the database without order. We validate DAQu in
diverse retrieval scenarios that can incorporate metadata from the relational
database, demonstrating that ours significantly enhances overall retrieval
performance, compared to existing query augmentation methods. | [
-0.6833794713020325,
-0.7290821671485901,
0.38645780086517334,
-0.08477228134870529,
-0.3464384078979492,
0.41768285632133484,
0.21751780807971954,
-0.4666670262813568,
0.7301912903785706,
0.7739148139953613,
-0.5383894443511963,
-0.7552419900894165,
-0.3087197244167328,
0.1698712706565857,
-0.4787544906139374,
0.57303386926651,
0.3618559241294861,
-0.14580248296260834,
-0.3062112629413605,
-0.49780842661857605,
-0.40844255685806274,
-0.7743920087814331,
-0.02558448351919651,
-0.15951241552829742,
0.5044187903404236,
0.20685547590255737,
0.9225420951843262,
0.7465209364891052,
0.7237986922264099,
0.09501328319311142,
0.00862487219274044,
0.6976528763771057,
-0.4568043053150177,
0.27490657567977905,
-0.14576129615306854,
-0.283610075712204,
-0.38938483595848083,
-0.28390538692474365,
0.7549318075180054,
1.0476956367492676,
-0.12329269200563431,
-0.027539754286408424,
-0.002635723212733865,
0.6634920239448547,
-0.8053025603294373,
0.23091299831867218,
-0.6969366073608398,
-0.005641438066959381,
-0.22499637305736542,
-0.304166704416275,
-0.38422244787216187,
-0.2783373296260834,
-0.2966463565826416,
-0.82989901304245,
-0.042389292269945145,
0.4343548119068146,
0.7252568602561951,
0.13200107216835022,
-0.9090217351913452,
-0.13378392159938812,
-0.579018771648407,
0.22318993508815765,
-0.42589685320854187,
0.5605746507644653,
0.5288981199264526,
0.44271159172058105,
-0.31183260679244995,
-0.8792052268981934,
-0.692958414554596,
0.02386908046901226,
-0.45531442761421204,
-0.03291675075888634,
0.16313064098358154,
0.16486987471580505,
0.434061735868454,
0.6069748401641846,
-0.5019398331642151,
0.03921591863036156,
0.01751619391143322,
-0.20246903598308563,
0.5748487114906311,
0.314748615026474,
0.24065488576889038,
-0.510083794593811,
-0.3842027187347412,
-0.20224113762378693,
-0.6342275142669678,
-0.09391205757856369,
0.22377310693264008,
0.5165643692016602,
0.6015203595161438,
0.7020543217658997,
-0.5196465253829956,
1.1305233240127563,
0.11318182945251465,
0.36382776498794556,
0.12016335874795914,
-0.47726476192474365,
0.013844338245689869,
0.11981440335512161,
0.7879202961921692,
0.31758642196655273,
-0.4692623019218445,
-0.21621765196323395,
-0.29752570390701294,
-0.2711663246154785,
0.1347854882478714,
-0.8042087554931641,
-0.19296148419380188,
0.3261195421218872,
-0.2616366147994995,
-0.044491104781627655,
0.3135514259338379,
-0.6733018755912781,
-0.6611098051071167,
0.11414645612239838,
0.527067244052887,
-0.5632927417755127,
-0.2334022969007492,
-0.0926484540104866,
-0.047758519649505615,
-0.062021635472774506,
0.18080037832260132,
-0.9933506846427917,
0.492141455411911,
0.5606247186660767,
0.6713604927062988,
0.12336374074220657,
0.01138350460678339,
-0.7206054925918579,
0.5753197073936462,
-0.3464411199092865,
0.7293422222137451,
-1.1269614696502686,
-0.6676664352416992,
-0.020726151764392853,
-0.19159471988677979,
0.39304119348526,
-0.4450446665287018,
0.4195427894592285,
-1.214368462562561,
0.05058746784925461,
-0.7941875457763672,
-0.7003702521324158,
-0.2028944194316864,
0.34331968426704407,
-1.2964750528335571,
1.45830500125885,
0.26877281069755554,
-0.8492633104324341,
0.5987210273742676,
-0.7484666109085083,
-0.45671403408050537,
0.24548344314098358,
-0.4164266586303711,
-0.15240909159183502,
-0.13249269127845764,
0.6627945899963379,
0.09892026335000992,
-0.2981105148792267,
-0.13672012090682983,
-0.4216691255569458,
-0.7686365246772766,
0.16583365201950073,
0.1550016552209854,
0.7399463057518005,
-0.05368279293179512,
0.20017901062965393,
-0.3741064667701721,
-0.6904435157775879,
0.22657877206802368,
-0.020286034792661667,
-0.3953309655189514,
-0.6086538434028625,
-0.18409501016139984,
-0.22867046296596527,
0.2756122648715973,
0.41072729229927063,
-0.6170512437820435,
0.4922153651714325,
-0.4698265492916107,
0.2634830176830292,
0.3508441746234894,
0.3496141731739044,
0.5365561246871948,
-0.15206854045391083,
0.26879844069480896,
0.1671985536813736,
-0.132057785987854,
-0.27638575434684753,
-0.15311987698078156,
-0.3889888823032379,
-0.3951079845428467,
0.6866812705993652,
0.33855730295181274,
-0.8943706750869751,
0.41139712929725647,
-0.5621355772018433,
-0.1679893285036087,
-0.6857079863548279,
-0.14980843663215637,
0.03431432694196701,
0.5234572291374207,
0.5432654023170471,
-0.48360171914100647,
-0.5948317646980286,
-0.6384050846099854,
-0.2766772210597992,
-0.15913601219654083,
0.09413809329271317,
0.72828608751297,
0.49401578307151794,
0.0022946533281356096,
1.0700231790542603,
-0.7506110072135925,
-0.3337829113006592,
0.27739179134368896,
-0.1026625782251358,
0.45004090666770935,
0.302944540977478,
0.4967063069343567,
-1.1565632820129395,
-0.4979252517223358,
0.1943565458059311,
-0.7303181886672974,
0.228987917304039,
0.24630329012870789,
-0.3694004714488983,
-0.08187045156955719,
0.2218535989522934,
-0.8060775399208069,
0.6066572070121765,
-0.22420667111873627,
-0.14650565385818481,
0.3503512740135193,
-0.2900080978870392,
0.6328657865524292,
-0.8650338053703308,
0.09175575524568558,
-0.42509588599205017,
-0.409549742937088,
-0.23900172114372253,
0.08053740859031677,
0.36294248700141907,
-0.4890592396259308,
0.13536794483661652,
0.48863375186920166,
-0.7260158658027649,
-0.40046554803848267,
-0.1227291077375412,
0.20640882849693298,
0.5578338503837585,
0.41534119844436646,
-0.2058255672454834,
0.6709868907928467,
0.4799649119377136,
-0.6099598407745361,
0.650826632976532,
0.5645444393157959,
-0.06749539077281952,
0.7282246351242065,
-0.4196334183216095,
0.34943684935569763,
-0.275142103433609,
0.33793047070503235,
-0.8590466380119324,
-0.5106779932975769,
0.05635495483875275,
-0.4236815869808197,
0.3242395222187042,
-0.44560250639915466,
-1.0890090465545654,
-0.6159584522247314,
-0.31097087264060974,
0.12265472859144211,
0.23223687708377838,
-0.8445014357566833,
0.7256536483764648,
0.2955116927623749,
0.3118765354156494,
-1.0492115020751953,
-0.6647159457206726,
0.19690656661987305,
-0.07365194708108902,
-0.666009783744812,
0.7677941918373108,
0.30865418910980225,
0.07739502936601639,
0.4031572937965393,
-0.28257885575294495,
-0.34161117672920227,
-0.09491321444511414,
0.15519089996814728,
0.14126457273960114,
-0.06032140180468559,
0.4841313362121582,
0.2855263650417328,
0.2700199484825134,
-0.3274070620536804,
-0.6334983110427856,
0.4927860200405121,
0.16604448854923248,
-0.7307043671607971,
-0.06664971262216568,
0.6791541576385498,
0.4741259217262268,
-0.7231855988502502,
0.943990170955658,
0.42969390749931335,
-0.6346068978309631,
0.015823598951101303,
-0.42832228541374207,
-0.41400477290153503,
-0.42275944352149963,
0.38375699520111084,
-0.7118620872497559,
-0.7781296372413635,
0.887925922870636,
-0.01819111965596676,
-0.18410848081111908,
0.39889487624168396,
0.0071314736269414425,
-0.3353707790374756,
1.1514983177185059,
0.31592899560928345,
0.17874424159526825,
0.4528357684612274,
-0.33343181014060974,
0.10883618146181107,
-0.8814958333969116,
-0.43000149726867676,
-0.48288586735725403,
-0.20090964436531067,
-0.6206013560295105,
-0.3719179034233093,
0.4053279161453247,
0.21748073399066925,
-0.2446424812078476,
0.3616132438182831,
-0.6253148317337036,
0.5665790438652039,
0.4197182059288025,
0.5277734398841858,
0.6428760290145874,
0.3049180209636688,
-0.22445213794708252,
0.025720298290252686,
-0.644555926322937,
-0.15127034485340118,
1.145176649093628,
-0.3045852482318878,
0.6295962929725647,
0.36874282360076904,
1.0344595909118652,
0.5929911732673645,
-0.15373092889785767,
-0.5414765477180481,
0.5133374929428101,
-0.20258061587810516,
-0.8909071087837219,
-0.3547459840774536,
-0.5946776866912842,
-0.9408131241798401,
0.42569419741630554,
-0.40126755833625793,
-0.6384628415107727,
0.6092168092727661,
0.09211772680282593,
-0.28018805384635925,
0.10335329174995422,
-0.38344240188598633,
0.700225293636322,
-0.22588346898555756,
-0.47236427664756775,
-0.12528927624225616,
-0.6641396880149841,
0.06691187620162964,
-0.10163557529449463,
0.007889092899858952,
-0.02735218033194542,
-0.23610132932662964,
0.4398635923862457,
-0.6165871024131775,
0.22916071116924286,
-0.4233401417732239,
0.4426553249359131,
0.24928922951221466,
0.12131091207265854,
0.7581278085708618,
0.2960399091243744,
-0.561692476272583,
-0.27510344982147217,
0.18264959752559662,
-0.5425168871879578,
-1.1904821395874023,
0.7173608541488647,
-0.31132107973098755,
-0.6513773202896118,
-0.503995954990387,
-0.532455563545227,
-0.3376086354255676,
0.6976796984672546,
0.08154702931642532,
0.6568028926849365,
-0.23922395706176758,
0.20429348945617676,
0.6216414570808411,
0.23151159286499023,
0.17309780418872833,
0.3399924337863922,
-0.438422828912735,
-0.38767167925834656,
0.8068764805793762,
0.5284231305122375,
-0.09511623531579971,
0.6847686767578125,
-0.2277207374572754,
-0.6947262287139893,
-0.680326521396637,
-0.5337426066398621,
0.2679463326931,
-0.8831942081451416,
-0.3156035840511322,
-0.7476653456687927,
0.042011238634586334,
-0.4314740300178528,
0.3869830071926117,
0.06089450418949127,
-0.7369480133056641,
-0.2960060238838196,
-0.05338414013385773,
0.5936652421951294,
0.5281404852867126,
0.1529715657234192,
0.17643383145332336,
-0.9598308205604553,
0.2752835154533386,
0.19525682926177979,
0.6930304765701294,
-0.15835346281528473,
-0.2918577194213867,
-0.4979915916919708,
0.08613819628953934,
-0.08957072347402573,
-1.0713615417480469,
0.2883951663970947,
0.33626073598861694,
0.7999417185783386,
-0.025489022955298424,
0.49578332901000977,
0.8135323524475098,
-0.30458739399909973,
0.5285988450050354,
-0.11332415789365768,
-0.451596736907959,
0.6228850483894348,
-0.31306180357933044,
-0.014664865098893642,
0.7937454581260681,
0.5371347069740295,
-0.30053845047950745,
0.2715877294540405,
-0.3965035378932953,
-0.9667079448699951,
0.7822802066802979,
0.3326670229434967,
0.1498688906431198,
0.03291774168610573,
0.5517416596412659,
0.0681658610701561,
0.25681835412979126,
-0.3493907153606415,
-0.16044721007347107,
-0.4718840718269348,
-0.21659578382968903,
0.5936118960380554,
-0.2548118233680725,
-0.1348637193441391,
0.028642257675528526,
0.4748418927192688,
-0.22725263237953186,
0.42610985040664673,
0.2610680162906647,
-0.3861386477947235,
0.3163710832595825,
0.1440008133649826,
-0.2892829477787018,
0.5449248552322388,
-0.635662853717804,
-0.07403463125228882,
-0.05530843511223793,
-0.4313652813434601,
-0.027273360639810562,
0.689827024936676,
0.1133301705121994,
0.14509618282318115,
0.04987039417028427,
0.7851510047912598,
-0.15279988944530487,
-0.3634830713272095,
0.2882218062877655,
-0.055323220789432526,
0.24053405225276947,
0.029925182461738586,
-0.01908421516418457,
-0.020533056929707527,
0.04455194249749184,
0.7356797456741333,
-0.15592099726200104,
0.7524354457855225,
-0.5538439154624939,
0.24620243906974792,
0.4866580367088318,
-0.5223187208175659,
0.0901646539568901,
0.5646761059761047,
0.29223352670669556,
-0.14025872945785522,
0.8450392484664917,
-0.2461698204278946,
-0.24212613701820374,
0.3166075050830841,
0.40541332960128784,
0.29479801654815674,
0.05896526947617531,
-0.16596293449401855,
0.4649480879306793,
0.14447687566280365,
0.026215070858597755,
0.4954851567745209,
-0.40696099400520325,
-0.5199164748191833,
-0.23293089866638184,
-0.567763090133667,
-0.30042794346809387,
-0.3769671320915222,
-0.8582184910774231,
0.25104063749313354,
-0.3696109652519226,
-0.5092454552650452,
0.03119921311736107,
0.14770279824733734,
-0.38917800784111023,
0.24224625527858734,
-0.2544565200805664,
0.9625225067138672,
-0.27061769366264343,
0.6554627418518066,
0.8625741600990295,
-0.7621892690658569,
-0.4938657283782959,
-0.008477645926177502,
-0.3344835937023163,
-0.41324490308761597,
0.44348520040512085,
-0.004972945433109999,
0.17563648521900177,
0.09859132021665573,
-0.12552820146083832,
-0.9379428625106812,
1.142940640449524,
0.44142186641693115,
-0.4614499807357788,
-0.2812996506690979,
0.26275086402893066,
0.42141664028167725,
-0.561292827129364,
0.21495911478996277,
0.5511142015457153,
0.4121638238430023,
0.32586878538131714,
-0.7489339113235474,
0.21455791592597961,
-0.2975631058216095,
0.1924821436405182,
0.41753891110420227,
-0.32828375697135925,
0.5007241368293762,
-0.05583049729466438,
-0.3224388062953949,
-0.12600164115428925,
0.7696665525436401,
0.13082043826580048,
0.22173161804676056,
0.27860984206199646,
0.3648727834224701,
1.2982587814331055,
-0.19517882168293,
1.3760443925857544,
-0.3775841295719147,
0.4175682067871094,
1.1930453777313232,
-0.36060091853141785,
0.7170722484588623,
0.27797752618789673,
-0.2675199508666992,
0.468283087015152,
0.8393622636795044,
0.16136708855628967,
0.6083531975746155,
-0.13318385183811188,
-0.33575209975242615,
-0.31319737434387207,
-0.32990172505378723,
-0.47280433773994446,
0.5132707357406616,
0.677539050579071,
-0.4209863841533661,
-0.06062329560518265,
-0.11137226969003677,
-0.4004783630371094,
0.2835155427455902,
-0.3736184239387512,
0.7477975487709045,
-0.13034312427043915,
-0.2324966937303543,
0.7903463244438171,
-0.22533173859119415,
0.2490731030702591,
-0.25246575474739075,
-0.300787091255188,
-0.3584887981414795,
-0.3106347918510437,
-0.5650761127471924,
-0.9797095060348511,
0.1574300229549408,
-0.5361000299453735,
-0.3582015633583069,
0.3098868727684021,
0.9247539639472961,
-0.38863831758499146,
-0.3559092879295349,
0.11647757887840271,
0.35909566283226013,
0.00860120914876461,
-0.30822354555130005,
-0.4634883403778076,
-0.13474270701408386,
-0.16471098363399506,
-0.04870811104774475,
0.13512752950191498,
0.6444715857505798,
-0.2801724970340729,
0.4687742292881012,
0.5533979535102844,
-0.16676262021064758,
0.049368757754564285,
0.1701602339744568,
1.187458872795105,
-0.883071780204773,
-0.6149296760559082,
-0.6189094185829163,
0.28567859530448914,
-0.5765638947486877,
0.38795459270477295,
0.6653477549552917,
0.7199450731277466,
0.4920004904270172,
0.14584161341190338,
0.7495591044425964,
-0.15586639940738678,
0.4051666855812073,
-0.4224499464035034,
0.6980649828910828,
-0.649292528629303,
0.5278940200805664,
-0.17940808832645416,
-1.1605145931243896,
-0.4029504358768463,
0.2159530371427536,
-0.1513238251209259,
0.35440874099731445,
0.41475746035575867,
0.8828341960906982,
-0.14706799387931824,
-0.03428446874022484,
0.21190498769283295,
0.16503562033176422,
0.13273963332176208,
0.19355924427509308,
0.7012115120887756,
-0.5235263705253601,
0.7642737627029419,
-0.08785650134086609,
0.007821829989552498,
-0.6516215205192566,
-0.4433801472187042,
-0.646237313747406,
-0.48115628957748413,
-0.08103124052286148,
-0.5769829750061035,
0.1867082118988037,
0.7907252907752991,
0.7589433789253235,
-0.5122318863868713,
0.2219291627407074,
0.3720313012599945,
0.3095175623893738,
-0.26671507954597473,
-0.13933543860912323,
0.68338942527771,
0.00216227350756526,
-0.5620246529579163,
0.2381141483783722,
0.46699342131614685,
-0.027128227055072784,
-0.0762258842587471,
0.12142858654260635,
-0.5344374775886536,
-0.05710817873477936,
0.4355414807796478,
0.19776776432991028,
-0.378968209028244,
-0.33993610739707947,
0.28769752383232117,
-0.18703563511371613,
0.5640408396720886,
0.5923154354095459,
-1.1265753507614136,
0.7425443530082703,
0.6506014466285706,
0.6299422383308411,
1.007728934288025,
0.15464316308498383,
0.34079885482788086,
-1.1171575784683228,
-0.06155978515744209,
0.4836881160736084,
0.22534984350204468,
0.6047762036323547,
-0.7701357007026672,
0.6098706126213074,
0.18202321231365204,
-0.22806888818740845,
-0.9840448498725891,
0.3103281557559967,
-1.1023041009902954,
-0.06568513065576553,
0.6836016774177551,
0.027672534808516502,
-0.39079511165618896,
-0.2562445104122162,
-0.18475928902626038,
0.1803290843963623,
-0.6957274675369263,
0.4729755222797394,
0.5344129800796509,
-0.4015423357486725,
-0.1296759694814682,
-0.1894083470106125,
0.1768912523984909,
0.004669122863560915,
-0.4966140389442444,
0.005577759817242622,
0.6880980134010315,
0.05373191088438034,
0.25604569911956787,
0.7239353656768799,
-0.41225889325141907,
0.4831470549106598,
0.1371224969625473,
-0.19752436876296997,
-0.3931850790977478,
0.0405355766415596,
-0.06328751891851425,
0.387464314699173,
0.19822020828723907,
-0.1830294281244278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16008v2 | Found in the Middle: Calibrating Positional Attention Bias Improves Long Context Utilization | 2024-06-23T04:35:42 | 2024-07-03T17:40:00 | Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Yung-Sung Chuang, Chun-Liang Li, Zifeng Wang, Long T. Le, Abhishek Kumar, James Glass, Alexander Ratner, Chen-Yu Lee, Ranjay Krishna, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs), even when specifically trained to process long
input contexts, struggle to capture relevant information located in the middle
of their input. This phenomenon has been known as the lost-in-the-middle
problem. In this work, we make three contributions. First, we set out to
understand the factors that cause this phenomenon. In doing so, we establish a
connection between lost-in-the-middle to LLMs' intrinsic attention bias: LLMs
exhibit a U-shaped attention bias where the tokens at the beginning and at the
end of its input receive higher attention, regardless of their relevance.
Second, we mitigate this positional bias through a calibration mechanism,
found-in-the-middle, that allows the model to attend to contexts faithfully
according to their relevance, even though when they are in the middle. Third,
we show found-in-the-middle not only achieves better performance in locating
relevant information within a long context, but also eventually leads to
improved retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) performance across various tasks,
outperforming existing methods by up to 15 percentage points. These findings
open up future directions in understanding LLM attention bias and its potential
consequences. | [
-0.5002869367599487,
-0.5043211579322815,
1.1189608573913574,
0.24684077501296997,
-0.09926735609769821,
-0.04722120240330696,
-0.2857721149921417,
-0.09772936999797821,
0.06502284854650497,
0.4926542341709137,
-0.4348110854625702,
-0.1533523052930832,
-0.7516515851020813,
-0.12520243227481842,
-0.26891353726387024,
0.8141161203384399,
0.02169123664498329,
0.021531017497181892,
-0.3387293815612793,
-0.10175352543592453,
-0.71509850025177,
-0.794843852519989,
-0.4757680892944336,
-0.5648394227027893,
0.7241445183753967,
0.6074087023735046,
0.7544270753860474,
0.5771719217300415,
0.2550871670246124,
0.19212205708026886,
-0.25482770800590515,
-0.1021699383854866,
-0.9990360140800476,
0.007800564635545015,
-0.25197336077690125,
-0.609201192855835,
-0.06477323174476624,
0.16609209775924683,
0.9257552027702332,
0.959741473197937,
-0.31364232301712036,
0.07348836958408356,
0.1037614718079567,
1.1936671733856201,
-0.9184768199920654,
-0.2759473919868469,
-0.7457890510559082,
-0.01114681176841259,
-0.690463125705719,
-0.43674835562705994,
-0.3852463662624359,
-0.020164374262094498,
0.37432438135147095,
-0.30336660146713257,
0.4383481442928314,
-0.004904736299067736,
0.5037173628807068,
0.4668647050857544,
-0.7702881693840027,
-0.26967716217041016,
-0.7368469834327698,
0.931181788444519,
-0.715532124042511,
0.5114879608154297,
0.49042120575904846,
0.09568503499031067,
-0.6487234234809875,
-0.18334753811359406,
-0.6235929131507874,
0.05017004907131195,
0.027268951758742332,
0.020840905606746674,
-0.02639772929251194,
-0.10793580114841461,
0.32184240221977234,
0.06902573257684708,
-0.24447059631347656,
0.0032763725612312555,
-0.10987768322229385,
-0.030085310339927673,
0.2842578887939453,
-0.0328308641910553,
0.13914592564105988,
0.1996322125196457,
-0.1706143021583557,
0.08205047994852066,
-1.2844868898391724,
0.1736937314271927,
0.44828590750694275,
0.153348907828331,
-0.056819286197423935,
0.6922675371170044,
0.16514897346496582,
0.80161452293396,
0.3932291865348816,
-0.03778422996401787,
-0.14786459505558014,
-0.25379064679145813,
-0.23097483813762665,
0.36871132254600525,
0.23730282485485077,
0.36710184812545776,
0.16796192526817322,
-0.008826671168208122,
-0.20190945267677307,
-0.3544033169746399,
0.21611419320106506,
-0.49911949038505554,
0.1784702092409134,
-0.1673714965581894,
-0.27218255400657654,
0.1607707291841507,
-0.18164001405239105,
-0.09521209448575974,
-0.23297877609729767,
-0.5248271226882935,
0.03946015238761902,
0.09623792767524719,
0.13388337194919586,
-0.01217400748282671,
-0.049983829259872437,
0.3913135528564453,
0.10522469878196716,
-1.0164554119110107,
0.09360131621360779,
0.7135053277015686,
0.8462514281272888,
-0.14503377676010132,
0.018217535689473152,
-0.6188849210739136,
0.3199916481971741,
-0.6101205945014954,
0.7533925175666809,
-0.5899907946586609,
-0.23536564409732819,
-0.06612954288721085,
-0.01072276383638382,
-0.1009405329823494,
-0.6389486193656921,
0.5396363139152527,
-0.8330885171890259,
0.39294278621673584,
-0.7138286232948303,
-0.3973265588283539,
-0.11245980858802795,
0.2048095315694809,
-0.6464309692382812,
1.234902262687683,
0.0397973395884037,
-0.8324411511421204,
0.1216336190700531,
-0.1780044436454773,
-0.24461345374584198,
-0.23441028594970703,
-0.3642658293247223,
-0.35250821709632874,
0.358183354139328,
0.031371790915727615,
0.48367252945899963,
-0.46953442692756653,
0.1802871823310852,
-0.46500512957572937,
-0.8350111246109009,
0.7155680060386658,
-0.27543187141418457,
0.5553902983665466,
-0.18468061089515686,
-0.5117313265800476,
-0.33454662561416626,
-0.5195568203926086,
-0.39624443650245667,
0.11779393255710602,
-0.5503863096237183,
-0.7087182402610779,
0.12831750512123108,
0.004206936806440353,
0.24270778894424438,
-0.0058174096047878265,
-0.44687604904174805,
-0.1289358139038086,
-0.48516303300857544,
0.20746885240077972,
0.7850661873817444,
0.05347108468413353,
0.8009711503982544,
-0.17702335119247437,
0.21470026671886444,
0.0810510590672493,
-0.04305330291390419,
0.0005160396103747189,
-0.05737514793872833,
-0.8904188871383667,
0.26023203134536743,
0.09278623014688492,
0.15030136704444885,
-0.47911450266838074,
0.22396914660930634,
-0.07579497247934341,
-0.17180490493774414,
-0.4680269658565521,
-0.00959068164229393,
0.42678532004356384,
0.677186906337738,
-0.038650233298540115,
-0.26373904943466187,
-0.33457642793655396,
-1.121038794517517,
-0.32084670662879944,
0.2506376802921295,
0.021874096244573593,
0.3856903314590454,
0.08394236862659454,
-0.3690418004989624,
0.9247753620147705,
-0.2728559374809265,
-0.4022575318813324,
-0.04096120223402977,
-0.341177374124527,
0.5295813679695129,
0.11769672483205795,
0.4341089725494385,
-0.7578835487365723,
-0.5108774900436401,
-0.12300371378660202,
-0.4523216485977173,
-0.25327068567276,
-0.02892949990928173,
-0.17755629122257233,
0.14175012707710266,
0.5869417786598206,
-0.5440829396247864,
0.44889673590660095,
0.6503241062164307,
-0.17076048254966736,
0.5515729784965515,
-0.02550795115530491,
-0.0821862444281578,
-0.8551766872406006,
0.21914148330688477,
0.0014270147075876594,
-0.09371774643659592,
-0.5151491165161133,
-0.23329617083072662,
0.1408887356519699,
0.11783355474472046,
-0.1909763664007187,
0.5680559277534485,
-0.7520103454589844,
-0.3554331064224243,
-0.627484917640686,
0.6474961042404175,
0.04524204507470131,
0.5177122950553894,
-0.43331336975097656,
1.0488831996917725,
0.3424657881259918,
-0.5692585706710815,
-0.041791077703237534,
-0.223566934466362,
-0.19716936349868774,
0.43207046389579773,
-0.4595849812030792,
0.39669936895370483,
-0.42153480648994446,
0.6398585438728333,
-1.0843497514724731,
-0.26481160521507263,
0.0005898118251934648,
-0.2998570501804352,
0.3898773193359375,
-0.2687995433807373,
-0.3396519422531128,
-0.21535460650920868,
-0.21960262954235077,
0.8250586986541748,
0.11705581843852997,
-0.3970918357372284,
0.27131256461143494,
0.811876654624939,
-0.3230037987232208,
-1.040178894996643,
-0.5730445384979248,
0.07944861054420471,
-0.1050056666135788,
-0.3488481044769287,
0.5182779431343079,
0.017252622172236443,
-0.1711379438638687,
-0.16937126219272614,
-0.4518328607082367,
0.3193334937095642,
0.06592301279306412,
0.20950844883918762,
-0.02576783299446106,
-0.20129920542240143,
0.34255674481391907,
-0.08144344389438629,
-0.222000852227211,
0.19860059022903442,
-0.2232574075460434,
0.5112290978431702,
-0.16863182187080383,
-0.4442335069179535,
-0.1872577667236328,
0.49369096755981445,
0.8504164218902588,
0.007545023690909147,
0.35097792744636536,
0.3630898892879486,
-0.30454179644584656,
-0.23457591235637665,
-0.968129575252533,
-0.23757454752922058,
-0.43273505568504333,
0.41863715648651123,
-0.00688157370314002,
-0.872272253036499,
0.6695062518119812,
0.11592599004507065,
-0.1341828554868698,
0.19872364401817322,
0.649771511554718,
-0.07910139113664627,
1.09315025806427,
1.0274608135223389,
-0.15988130867481232,
0.8285175561904907,
-0.09769736975431442,
0.6194047927856445,
-1.2800782918930054,
-0.27764856815338135,
-0.5103903412818909,
-0.5116971731185913,
-0.49804550409317017,
-0.308921217918396,
0.6173108816146851,
0.0918978899717331,
-0.23533210158348083,
-0.18336360156536102,
-0.44276922941207886,
0.8425771594047546,
0.7248982787132263,
0.25329065322875977,
-0.018981480970978737,
-0.14313775300979614,
-0.31743112206459045,
-0.23790162801742554,
-0.8958033323287964,
-0.5752465724945068,
0.9950272440910339,
0.3839421272277832,
0.629021406173706,
0.1401064395904541,
0.4820535480976105,
0.10203695297241211,
0.2812947928905487,
-0.8008042573928833,
0.48208606243133545,
0.06156554073095322,
-0.593895435333252,
-0.22877123951911926,
-0.08486271649599075,
-0.9972308874130249,
0.1738026887178421,
0.17595288157463074,
-0.5802947282791138,
0.24920529127120972,
0.10563565045595169,
-0.5525785088539124,
0.13713161647319794,
-0.5229402780532837,
0.5682987570762634,
-0.19214411079883575,
-0.7395845651626587,
-0.20997080206871033,
-0.9920237064361572,
0.24026192724704742,
-0.17151111364364624,
0.24764351546764374,
-0.39738959074020386,
0.09123211354017258,
0.7559295892715454,
-0.21744035184383392,
0.7797673940658569,
-0.21234332025051117,
-0.18126210570335388,
0.08967006951570511,
-0.04174346104264259,
0.5259543657302856,
0.025889303535223007,
0.061267461627721786,
-0.20429393649101257,
-0.3236903250217438,
-0.6391050219535828,
-0.5558528900146484,
0.9795953035354614,
-0.7862978577613831,
-0.8274173736572266,
-0.6429456472396851,
-0.565092921257019,
-0.18578940629959106,
0.20230461657047272,
0.11766044795513153,
0.22200170159339905,
-0.054959703236818314,
0.4678480625152588,
1.1188710927963257,
-0.05088164284825325,
0.6732029318809509,
0.39771583676338196,
0.09295593947172165,
0.04529258608818054,
0.1404864490032196,
0.21838878095149994,
-0.002500802045688033,
0.34649503231048584,
0.19607241451740265,
-0.2875407636165619,
-0.22153599560260773,
-0.37527599930763245,
0.552469789981842,
-0.8841865658760071,
-0.18444333970546722,
-0.5643564462661743,
-0.09324849396944046,
-0.13796579837799072,
-0.24818448722362518,
-0.4431494176387787,
0.12416623532772064,
-0.4988514184951782,
0.12930160760879517,
-0.10739976912736893,
0.473915159702301,
0.19952470064163208,
0.7617485523223877,
-0.6695221662521362,
-0.09345946460962296,
0.2184383124113083,
0.25402653217315674,
0.41550514101982117,
-0.6792498230934143,
-0.6029154658317566,
0.04395411163568497,
-0.29841557145118713,
-0.8011791110038757,
0.11638092249631882,
-0.1837710589170456,
0.5929136872291565,
0.26576969027519226,
-0.30309173464775085,
0.6877697110176086,
-0.48105475306510925,
0.5398611426353455,
0.057273320853710175,
-0.6838111281394958,
0.04493912309408188,
-0.41572222113609314,
0.8014113306999207,
0.3326508700847626,
0.14177101850509644,
-0.7016612887382507,
-0.21058407425880432,
-0.292385458946228,
-0.8523167371749878,
0.649957537651062,
-0.10708923637866974,
0.10647643357515335,
0.11196215450763702,
0.5413787364959717,
-0.0014412130694836378,
0.02183092013001442,
-0.8703618049621582,
-0.16631467640399933,
0.4784735441207886,
-0.10276354849338531,
-0.010058343410491943,
-0.531806230545044,
-0.31501853466033936,
0.12754133343696594,
0.7203973531723022,
-0.011951755732297897,
0.28078943490982056,
0.36448177695274353,
-0.08479054272174835,
-0.42779091000556946,
0.42860147356987,
0.6412222385406494,
0.9266595840454102,
-0.1643499732017517,
0.3392552435398102,
-0.02722751535475254,
-0.34161341190338135,
-0.05375043302774429,
0.061700813472270966,
-0.3388229310512543,
0.07687565684318542,
0.09123913943767548,
0.8195198774337769,
0.6694320440292358,
-0.4844762086868286,
0.6691131591796875,
0.03546639159321785,
0.40961962938308716,
-0.605251133441925,
-0.19427770376205444,
0.07919918745756149,
0.5299513339996338,
0.9850151538848877,
0.1606464982032776,
0.12658707797527313,
-0.7376857995986938,
0.16907446086406708,
0.5841219425201416,
-0.3920656442642212,
-0.12618447840213776,
0.5116077065467834,
0.0028193925973027945,
-0.2271021008491516,
0.5940725207328796,
0.3346646726131439,
-0.7003236413002014,
0.47547462582588196,
0.7555065751075745,
0.7940416932106018,
-0.04316449910402298,
-0.24148151278495789,
-0.03418934717774391,
0.1441134363412857,
0.005813744384795427,
-0.036167316138744354,
-0.0898633822798729,
-0.5371339917182922,
-0.5254973769187927,
-0.2711643576622009,
-0.23823058605194092,
-0.0883403792977333,
-0.5358961224555969,
0.15380817651748657,
-0.013349239714443684,
-0.45363861322402954,
-0.10451802611351013,
0.07274265587329865,
-0.8006128072738647,
0.00345171638764441,
0.301238089799881,
0.5358923673629761,
-0.7448342442512512,
0.7728105783462524,
0.6027694940567017,
0.16569697856903076,
-0.6076863408088684,
0.23039667308330536,
-0.06131953001022339,
-0.7495976686477661,
0.45423007011413574,
0.3300083577632904,
-0.3940798044204712,
0.017040066421031952,
-0.7268357276916504,
-1.3769474029541016,
1.0681278705596924,
0.250182181596756,
-0.8104246854782104,
-0.3194878399372101,
-0.08083067089319229,
0.5161583423614502,
-0.3631620705127716,
0.20172661542892456,
0.6586164236068726,
0.22333069145679474,
0.12945716083049774,
-0.8492026329040527,
0.07024043053388596,
0.05571447312831879,
0.14360807836055756,
0.4239093065261841,
-0.8091812133789062,
0.8669841885566711,
-0.49704939126968384,
-0.3058018386363983,
-0.290790319442749,
0.28784722089767456,
0.6129183173179626,
0.776620626449585,
0.21300430595874786,
0.47503140568733215,
0.4965892434120178,
-0.14217479526996613,
0.9694368243217468,
-0.1435146927833557,
0.2515948414802551,
1.0235565900802612,
-0.4649905264377594,
0.8563072681427002,
1.062487006187439,
0.1780880093574524,
0.4492647051811218,
0.8138378858566284,
0.4716896712779999,
0.8050196170806885,
0.11485941708087921,
-0.35956165194511414,
-0.016216261312365532,
-0.07492193579673767,
-0.30382516980171204,
0.21567942202091217,
0.5390153527259827,
-0.3036361038684845,
-0.16673660278320312,
0.0002752823638729751,
0.19070307910442352,
0.1623132824897766,
-0.2951769530773163,
0.66450035572052,
0.24110673367977142,
-0.8871091604232788,
0.603722095489502,
0.013418633490800858,
0.3832799196243286,
-0.3844975531101227,
0.005916439928114414,
-0.4607834219932556,
0.3726297616958618,
0.024837957695126534,
-0.74189293384552,
-0.05378345772624016,
-0.3897300660610199,
-0.5617210865020752,
0.0002690022229216993,
0.6142255663871765,
-0.6116735339164734,
-0.025425178930163383,
0.3321878910064697,
0.4453335106372833,
-0.021781163290143013,
-0.14838089048862457,
-0.4680895209312439,
0.22623951733112335,
-0.07128779590129852,
-0.3631829619407654,
0.42230257391929626,
0.6814755797386169,
-0.3842500150203705,
0.6211892366409302,
0.6472644209861755,
-0.1266460418701172,
0.17346464097499847,
-0.014436601661145687,
0.9359989762306213,
-0.7841821312904358,
-0.45714423060417175,
-0.9545544981956482,
0.30986103415489197,
-0.06264243274927139,
-0.07515111565589905,
0.6817827224731445,
0.5861372947692871,
1.0314325094223022,
-0.050369489938020706,
0.647677481174469,
0.30931976437568665,
0.6092034578323364,
-0.40284693241119385,
0.6300755739212036,
-0.5577455759048462,
0.3285788595676422,
-0.051661938428878784,
-1.2046763896942139,
-0.5711216330528259,
0.4143735468387604,
-0.5379703640937805,
0.02356966771185398,
0.6756379008293152,
0.8157015442848206,
-0.2728233337402344,
-0.5581678152084351,
0.3132573366165161,
0.20982520282268524,
0.29092586040496826,
0.7537943124771118,
0.7060169577598572,
-0.5037099123001099,
0.13755840063095093,
-0.010076705366373062,
-0.443804532289505,
-0.7267531156539917,
-0.8654208779335022,
-0.670039713382721,
-0.533027708530426,
0.24772761762142181,
-0.3476141095161438,
0.0772169902920723,
0.8154333233833313,
0.6201236844062805,
-0.4905000627040863,
-0.4759023189544678,
0.09023827314376831,
0.33158400654792786,
0.1998872607946396,
-0.18846067786216736,
0.5161916017532349,
-0.18050670623779297,
-0.6275190114974976,
0.2812301814556122,
0.6240164041519165,
0.23585261404514313,
-0.21527379751205444,
-0.010911023244261742,
-0.5399264693260193,
0.11612094938755035,
0.7682075500488281,
0.2771477699279785,
-0.9779791235923767,
-0.19380460679531097,
0.18971791863441467,
-0.5003098845481873,
0.013501791283488274,
0.9877025485038757,
-0.6609117388725281,
0.4292401075363159,
0.33423879742622375,
0.7599548697471619,
0.5790577530860901,
0.04183737933635712,
0.709982693195343,
-1.07676100730896,
0.24352629482746124,
0.3186897039413452,
0.3762461245059967,
0.5738858580589294,
-0.3449856638908386,
0.3687651753425598,
0.17260369658470154,
-1.1098535060882568,
-0.9583265781402588,
0.07418355345726013,
-0.944833517074585,
-0.060227833688259125,
1.0177112817764282,
0.24444732069969177,
-0.305622935295105,
0.03635123744606972,
-0.4250134825706482,
0.496432363986969,
-0.29667943716049194,
1.2096688747406006,
0.9097979068756104,
-0.06504117697477341,
-0.10424820333719254,
-0.6242597103118896,
0.4278544783592224,
0.8123871088027954,
-0.19607426226139069,
0.24013550579547882,
0.577907919883728,
0.27760136127471924,
0.122320756316185,
0.6890984773635864,
-0.08958187699317932,
0.19948796927928925,
-0.5762125253677368,
-0.15864530205726624,
0.5268538594245911,
-0.45372068881988525,
-0.22712363302707672,
-0.10212955623865128,
0.10910040885210037,
0.01639465056359768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16007v1 | Distributed Rule Vectors is A Key Mechanism in Large Language Models' In-Context Learning | 2024-06-23T04:29:13 | 2024-06-23T04:29:13 | Bowen Zheng, Ming Ma, Zhongqiao Lin, Tianming Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable abilities, one of
the most important being In-Context Learning (ICL). With ICL, LLMs can derive
the underlying rule from a few demonstrations and provide answers that comply
with the rule. Previous work hypothesized that the network creates a "task
vector" in specific positions during ICL. Patching the "task vector" allows
LLMs to achieve zero-shot performance similar to few-shot learning. However, we
discover that such "task vectors" do not exist in tasks where the rule has to
be defined through multiple demonstrations. Instead, the rule information
provided by each demonstration is first transmitted to its answer position and
forms its own rule vector. Importantly, all the rule vectors contribute to the
output in a distributed manner. We further show that the rule vectors encode a
high-level abstraction of rules extracted from the demonstrations. These
results are further validated in a series of tasks that rely on rules dependent
on multiple demonstrations. Our study provides novel insights into the
mechanism underlying ICL in LLMs, demonstrating how ICL may be achieved through
an information aggregation mechanism. | [
-0.38362187147140503,
-0.8171825408935547,
0.4166344106197357,
0.3022976815700531,
-0.16585281491279602,
-0.2003549039363861,
-0.1436515748500824,
-0.08108864724636078,
-0.09144669771194458,
0.3599918484687805,
-0.5851929187774658,
-0.619572103023529,
-0.642565131187439,
-0.01826043240725994,
-0.6249342560768127,
0.9665820002555847,
-0.03552122041583061,
-0.06223152577877045,
-0.5865789651870728,
-0.12214522808790207,
-0.32348760962486267,
-0.6074441075325012,
-0.32116785645484924,
-0.5920192003250122,
0.39149948954582214,
0.6913264989852905,
0.14559540152549744,
0.9430568814277649,
0.48148849606513977,
0.2841276526451111,
0.029724059626460075,
0.23224321007728577,
-0.7238085269927979,
0.17374707758426666,
0.0035497816279530525,
-0.5991733074188232,
-0.47450166940689087,
-0.014983758330345154,
0.9262211322784424,
0.7914433479309082,
-0.08118653297424316,
0.11563672125339508,
0.4347498416900635,
0.5265687108039856,
-0.6340329051017761,
0.18068599700927734,
-0.5732749104499817,
0.059759777039289474,
-0.40474840998649597,
-0.340604692697525,
-0.5665392279624939,
0.06451526284217834,
-0.035730913281440735,
-0.527689516544342,
0.020481674000620842,
-0.11636718362569809,
0.6267353296279907,
0.11734336614608765,
-0.5120849013328552,
-0.39470598101615906,
-0.8963713645935059,
0.7494093775749207,
-0.39149558544158936,
0.1775614321231842,
0.03282556310296059,
0.1897318959236145,
-0.4716681241989136,
-0.641566276550293,
-0.6406204104423523,
0.07011528313159943,
-0.1093023344874382,
-0.06417441368103027,
-0.14309407770633698,
0.0689942017197609,
0.3478896915912628,
-0.15598060190677643,
-0.02949458919465542,
0.24330082535743713,
-0.3062659204006195,
0.21267983317375183,
0.32101961970329285,
0.18578778207302094,
0.2198382169008255,
-0.26803886890411377,
-0.7509548664093018,
0.031179172918200493,
-1.0168708562850952,
0.31961432099342346,
-0.13666757941246033,
0.2760583162307739,
-0.40025559067726135,
0.5577113628387451,
-0.2464982271194458,
0.8932480216026306,
0.11188692599534988,
-0.23267902433872223,
0.19724367558956146,
-0.08699169009923935,
-0.45222488045692444,
0.185734361410141,
0.7697117328643799,
0.11014861613512039,
0.010708325542509556,
-0.06147029250860214,
-0.41786396503448486,
-0.24311497807502747,
-0.029369911178946495,
-0.7323935031890869,
0.2566715478897095,
0.060866471379995346,
-0.5203685760498047,
-0.1284613162279129,
0.13867755234241486,
-0.41400936245918274,
-0.20435842871665955,
-0.6727054119110107,
0.6757258772850037,
-0.282607764005661,
-0.23639921844005585,
-0.04074207320809364,
-0.29079318046569824,
0.4127199351787567,
0.36485040187835693,
-0.6984891295433044,
0.6024189591407776,
1.1489535570144653,
0.896491289138794,
-0.5328447818756104,
-0.6462408900260925,
-0.9854755401611328,
0.26755884289741516,
-0.5439801216125488,
0.7463505864143372,
-0.6793216466903687,
-0.09389322251081467,
0.0768817737698555,
-0.24056276679039001,
-0.1390494704246521,
-0.633361279964447,
0.1561359465122223,
-0.6428576111793518,
-0.35507914423942566,
-0.5303520560264587,
-0.8693308234214783,
-0.1800609678030014,
0.11821281164884567,
-0.3298608362674713,
0.890714168548584,
-0.11877194046974182,
-0.7272526025772095,
0.5479902029037476,
-0.7158803343772888,
-0.5881407260894775,
0.2995019257068634,
-0.5857688188552856,
-0.13151001930236816,
0.13344979286193848,
-0.0616486556828022,
1.0052169561386108,
-0.06113218888640404,
-0.12049079686403275,
-0.43061143159866333,
-0.6629630923271179,
0.36975330114364624,
-0.26620814204216003,
0.7621194124221802,
-0.024762900546193123,
-0.43269556760787964,
0.15622691810131073,
-0.654473066329956,
-0.37556007504463196,
-0.04775446653366089,
-0.5882564783096313,
-0.5523108243942261,
0.23219239711761475,
-0.4702734053134918,
0.42510655522346497,
-0.10228372365236282,
-0.5279492735862732,
0.26938554644584656,
-0.24835063517093658,
0.28231385350227356,
0.8991845846176147,
0.15962158143520355,
0.6561702489852905,
-0.4132958650588989,
0.3337785303592682,
0.2899891436100006,
0.14052248001098633,
-0.19612397253513336,
-0.24540576338768005,
-0.6701107621192932,
-0.5886499285697937,
-0.31575629115104675,
0.28354331851005554,
-0.636444628238678,
-0.030605606734752655,
-0.28257644176483154,
-0.40615102648735046,
-0.17780253291130066,
0.279821515083313,
0.317648708820343,
0.5004076957702637,
0.15119601786136627,
-0.05583919212222099,
-0.34173673391342163,
-0.6506326198577881,
0.05489123612642288,
0.202189102768898,
0.07641954720020294,
0.4907582104206085,
0.4851585328578949,
-0.025359908118844032,
0.8674802184104919,
-0.25511229038238525,
-0.4624806046485901,
-0.4416786730289459,
-0.006920963991433382,
0.29860761761665344,
0.28477397561073303,
0.6490851640701294,
-0.5898239612579346,
-0.48237475752830505,
-0.044249650090932846,
-0.938024640083313,
-0.022923024371266365,
-0.06692780554294586,
-0.3778226375579834,
-0.03337150812149048,
1.0461475849151611,
-0.5490347146987915,
0.3259103000164032,
0.5948238968849182,
-0.17284740507602692,
0.3165418803691864,
-0.39061665534973145,
-0.1069120541214943,
-0.8622674942016602,
-0.527965784072876,
-0.02819334901869297,
-0.3561848998069763,
-0.7163661122322083,
0.05582078918814659,
0.11899904161691666,
0.2002689689397812,
-0.760352611541748,
0.31981900334358215,
-0.5187092423439026,
-0.41462624073028564,
-0.5020637512207031,
0.36681291460990906,
-0.26699674129486084,
0.6317930817604065,
-0.4038681983947754,
0.4978832006454468,
1.1389538049697876,
-1.2266311645507812,
0.29617005586624146,
0.31973037123680115,
-0.2897590398788452,
0.8123229146003723,
-0.6536059379577637,
-0.04158607870340347,
-0.6353788375854492,
0.30246904492378235,
-0.9347175359725952,
-0.23889365792274475,
0.0659378170967102,
-0.07587972283363342,
0.3312813937664032,
-0.25118115544319153,
-0.21303126215934753,
0.11739847809076309,
-0.05129758268594742,
0.47281819581985474,
0.4070168435573578,
-0.7255334258079529,
0.6265762448310852,
0.6339266896247864,
0.29764875769615173,
-0.6371930241584778,
-0.5467212796211243,
-0.19534775614738464,
-0.19276820123195648,
-0.2949865758419037,
0.23062977194786072,
0.031711842864751816,
-0.47370296716690063,
0.005985972471535206,
0.1781347393989563,
0.13766120374202728,
0.18165545165538788,
0.6154438853263855,
-0.06694353371858597,
-0.12398725003004074,
0.4046267569065094,
-0.054061662405729294,
0.2884674668312073,
0.12812018394470215,
-0.3218252658843994,
0.5972248911857605,
0.11002853512763977,
-0.6740321516990662,
-0.25552240014076233,
0.46040335297584534,
0.8584268093109131,
-0.3379513919353485,
0.7996686697006226,
0.17766158282756805,
-0.3583924174308777,
-0.8476132154464722,
-0.0047073084861040115,
-0.13785678148269653,
-0.4996403157711029,
0.35652315616607666,
-0.4596136212348938,
-0.9077123999595642,
0.4748678505420685,
-0.2999090254306793,
0.3092651963233948,
0.5225376486778259,
0.6678040027618408,
-0.19376832246780396,
0.8223139643669128,
0.6731395125389099,
0.12888610363006592,
0.6294897794723511,
-0.2835020124912262,
-0.13574440777301788,
-0.9097751975059509,
-0.2699466645717621,
-0.39034199714660645,
-0.46864908933639526,
-0.5659977197647095,
-0.6038200259208679,
0.6187729835510254,
0.341526597738266,
-0.2326020896434784,
0.07774409651756287,
-0.11636035889387131,
0.5865833759307861,
0.8300685286521912,
0.26032334566116333,
-0.022393254563212395,
0.003210614901036024,
-0.5403367877006531,
0.29806166887283325,
-0.9685666561126709,
-0.06436483561992645,
0.8398216962814331,
0.2156665027141571,
0.7362441420555115,
0.1518651843070984,
0.9522420763969421,
0.2811790406703949,
0.236399844288826,
-0.7568804621696472,
0.815966010093689,
-0.35442042350769043,
-0.16700467467308044,
-0.38489043712615967,
-0.29252657294273376,
-0.8605986833572388,
0.30651408433914185,
-0.2622489631175995,
-0.43580788373947144,
0.22974731028079987,
0.14277829229831696,
-0.12355157732963562,
0.17135502398014069,
-0.5072059631347656,
0.6355896592140198,
0.12895043194293976,
-0.41337475180625916,
-0.32041993737220764,
-0.40135592222213745,
0.29745104908943176,
-0.05434558913111687,
0.3499304950237274,
-0.15489128232002258,
0.12601689994335175,
0.7659198641777039,
-0.3229096233844757,
1.0854531526565552,
-0.2934710383415222,
0.053756874054670334,
0.26616647839546204,
0.22858859598636627,
0.7605205774307251,
-0.1042882576584816,
0.13937629759311676,
0.09279105812311172,
-0.32685762643814087,
-0.3100070655345917,
-0.47579675912857056,
0.8121641278266907,
-0.7964301705360413,
-0.48153209686279297,
-0.24716302752494812,
-0.4662764072418213,
0.18392406404018402,
0.15717332065105438,
0.18910296261310577,
0.8975832462310791,
0.02011418156325817,
0.4151148796081543,
0.7438100576400757,
-0.11195878684520721,
0.8695273399353027,
0.5899726748466492,
-0.08408467471599579,
0.15483778715133667,
0.6331530809402466,
0.28016629815101624,
0.5203403234481812,
0.5652443766593933,
0.24566201865673065,
0.10345795750617981,
-0.5458406209945679,
-0.16665545105934143,
0.16804787516593933,
-1.1906166076660156,
-0.08512506633996964,
-0.6490460634231567,
-0.3265388607978821,
-0.08889608085155487,
-0.1477946788072586,
-0.29055336117744446,
-0.11139049381017685,
-0.394265353679657,
-0.202376127243042,
0.3486741781234741,
1.245059609413147,
-0.19041107594966888,
0.158879816532135,
-0.6426597833633423,
0.2282772958278656,
0.45063504576683044,
0.39009717106819153,
0.24498221278190613,
-0.41058656573295593,
-0.3192160129547119,
0.08041150867938995,
-0.06553473323583603,
-0.7680186033248901,
0.09962084889411926,
0.44353654980659485,
0.7610023617744446,
0.5024827718734741,
0.14021120965480804,
0.7353543043136597,
-0.9893150925636292,
0.6623084545135498,
-0.05718466266989708,
-0.9980401396751404,
0.2109248787164688,
-0.29571306705474854,
0.2877740263938904,
-0.18207930028438568,
0.3075125217437744,
-0.6700347661972046,
-0.6508559584617615,
-0.23881404101848602,
-0.787912905216217,
0.8656172156333923,
-0.13973474502563477,
0.3802417814731598,
-0.3548199534416199,
0.42185935378074646,
0.05754769966006279,
0.024412933737039566,
-0.4368583858013153,
-0.3978811502456665,
0.07603588700294495,
-0.10966606438159943,
0.10538261383771896,
-0.38889357447624207,
-0.2955366373062134,
-0.2418065369129181,
0.42780211567878723,
-0.11708355695009232,
0.3924051821231842,
0.25335589051246643,
-0.21198099851608276,
-0.11086184531450272,
0.09823374450206757,
1.010485291481018,
0.8349899053573608,
0.1359935849905014,
0.33559247851371765,
0.05717027187347412,
-0.2134028673171997,
0.09966284781694412,
-0.24458910524845123,
-0.32496726512908936,
-0.07537633925676346,
0.5496258735656738,
1.1008045673370361,
0.2961352467536926,
-0.3521040081977844,
0.8791548609733582,
-0.11450434476137161,
-0.37423211336135864,
-0.34804874658584595,
0.14376141130924225,
-0.08923786133527756,
0.508284330368042,
0.510256826877594,
0.20431925356388092,
-0.08627192676067352,
-0.41710561513900757,
0.7840650081634521,
0.5586909651756287,
-0.45156991481781006,
-0.32271942496299744,
0.709987998008728,
0.00264037330634892,
-0.2843816876411438,
0.33597734570503235,
-0.26239243149757385,
-0.44443026185035706,
0.5042974948883057,
0.5352885723114014,
0.7310405373573303,
-0.07191520184278488,
0.31899479031562805,
0.08573136478662491,
0.08288974314928055,
-0.23017318546772003,
0.09687651693820953,
-0.14751534163951874,
-0.787223219871521,
-0.5661451816558838,
-0.6747780442237854,
-0.19917747378349304,
-0.17232684791088104,
-0.45832228660583496,
0.42556530237197876,
-0.38789641857147217,
0.3277410566806793,
0.029767736792564392,
-0.6619282960891724,
-0.9132398366928101,
-0.04861336201429367,
0.12414590269327164,
0.7475758790969849,
-0.8581790328025818,
0.8386527299880981,
0.4774577021598816,
-0.07171788811683655,
-0.8898715376853943,
0.20507140457630157,
-0.012941120192408562,
-0.8292098641395569,
1.1650913953781128,
0.08403376489877701,
-0.08771499246358871,
0.08722507208585739,
-0.6037043929100037,
-0.997835099697113,
0.9211316704750061,
0.3892076015472412,
-0.481135755777359,
0.2637859880924225,
0.09452175348997116,
0.26974955201148987,
-0.644428014755249,
0.102381132543087,
0.19205832481384277,
-0.08538946509361267,
0.4555862545967102,
-0.6886297464370728,
0.057982828468084335,
0.18915985524654388,
-0.1338207721710205,
0.12211143225431442,
-0.5852017402648926,
1.2534006834030151,
-0.17595477402210236,
-0.16170181334018707,
-0.7364542484283447,
0.6653362512588501,
0.19221903383731842,
0.02579003944993019,
0.5022948384284973,
0.21786949038505554,
0.7232955694198608,
0.04864322021603584,
1.20081627368927,
-0.2382126748561859,
0.21955092251300812,
0.9872540235519409,
-0.3596111536026001,
1.1084448099136353,
0.38935890793800354,
0.20874576270580292,
0.5437402725219727,
0.26760533452033997,
0.32552456855773926,
0.5587466359138489,
0.3147943615913391,
-0.4705708920955658,
-0.18777698278427124,
-0.27106982469558716,
0.29697659611701965,
0.8114898204803467,
0.27755340933799744,
-0.2056441307067871,
-0.3689053952693939,
0.4101087152957916,
-0.042386338114738464,
0.031756043434143066,
-0.7156431674957275,
1.1419495344161987,
0.058792829513549805,
-0.6426489353179932,
0.6895529627799988,
-0.06121283024549484,
0.5557451248168945,
-0.5043041706085205,
-0.37415045499801636,
-0.17341850697994232,
0.5097969174385071,
-0.19388186931610107,
-0.6750254034996033,
0.18506598472595215,
-0.23429156839847565,
-0.1687312126159668,
-0.4400184452533722,
0.5225434303283691,
-0.5873954892158508,
-0.17803780734539032,
0.3918905556201935,
0.3131691813468933,
0.10916738957166672,
0.2711572051048279,
-0.19284430146217346,
-0.0028433571569621563,
-0.3219897449016571,
-0.30257609486579895,
0.5441201329231262,
0.8935055136680603,
-0.23127587139606476,
0.6486318111419678,
0.3746894299983978,
0.1818595826625824,
0.4118797183036804,
0.044849418103694916,
0.9670593738555908,
-0.21542023122310638,
-0.503212571144104,
-1.241326093673706,
0.43110403418540955,
-0.01994611695408821,
0.0661984458565712,
0.9705238342285156,
0.3176823854446411,
1.1062582731246948,
-0.02129300870001316,
0.7829263806343079,
0.10501349717378616,
0.4459530711174011,
-0.5225775241851807,
0.5725317597389221,
-0.6154755353927612,
0.23104867339134216,
-0.057520028203725815,
-0.5535870790481567,
-0.325010746717453,
0.34090256690979004,
0.02551993913948536,
-0.26430603861808777,
0.6345433592796326,
0.6504079699516296,
-0.27177247405052185,
-0.5068522095680237,
0.4769301414489746,
0.27473562955856323,
0.5209919214248657,
0.3971840441226959,
0.42041900753974915,
-0.15435747802257538,
0.4636577069759369,
-0.11175388842821121,
-0.3715204894542694,
-0.19366829097270966,
-1.0042096376419067,
-1.1005313396453857,
-0.7087045907974243,
-0.22053183615207672,
-0.16796019673347473,
-0.15557512640953064,
1.2273215055465698,
0.8613449335098267,
-0.6662583947181702,
-0.5570605397224426,
-0.2901402711868286,
0.23691049218177795,
-0.5612078309059143,
-0.18454691767692566,
0.3437258303165436,
-0.4560019373893738,
-0.5640430450439453,
0.46212050318717957,
0.5063254833221436,
-0.062100090086460114,
-0.07694562524557114,
-0.2509407699108124,
-0.2114107608795166,
0.16376358270645142,
0.739238977432251,
0.04183599725365639,
-0.4375593364238739,
-0.22673757374286652,
-0.07652464509010315,
-0.300235778093338,
0.09287688136100769,
0.8697102665901184,
-0.6446423530578613,
0.362562894821167,
0.6731646060943604,
0.743460476398468,
0.3862041234970093,
-0.21557553112506866,
0.6139534711837769,
-1.376456618309021,
0.3904019892215729,
-0.09034717082977295,
0.33931493759155273,
0.11706522107124329,
-0.25104451179504395,
-0.09989597648382187,
0.2949282228946686,
-0.5459854006767273,
-0.6781824827194214,
0.358085960149765,
-0.6123157739639282,
-0.2697722613811493,
1.436092734336853,
-0.132272407412529,
-0.5804136395454407,
0.10275780409574509,
-0.0060149552300572395,
0.28527355194091797,
-0.2555851340293884,
0.45549142360687256,
0.6037036776542664,
-0.19044852256774902,
-0.28499069809913635,
-0.7264891266822815,
0.7587693333625793,
-0.15160685777664185,
-0.5637397766113281,
0.25449177622795105,
0.38037994503974915,
0.3183019459247589,
-0.21638746559619904,
0.732426106929779,
0.17530056834220886,
0.20531459152698517,
-0.38498425483703613,
-0.02988864853978157,
-0.17465853691101074,
-0.4811760187149048,
-0.3941931426525116,
0.48323118686676025,
0.10415957123041153,
-0.5257332921028137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15996v1 | Memorizing Documents with Guidance in Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T03:12:03 | 2024-06-23T03:12:03 | Bumjin Park, Jaesik Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training data plays a pivotal role in AI models. Large language models (LLMs)
are trained with massive amounts of documents, and their parameters hold
document-related contents. Recently, several studies identified
content-specific locations in LLMs by examining the parameters. Instead of the
post hoc interpretation, we propose another approach. We propose document-wise
memory architecture to track document memories in training. The proposed
architecture maps document representations to memory entries, which softly mask
memories in the forward process of LLMs. Additionally, we propose document
guidance loss, which increases the likelihood of text with document memories
and reduces the likelihood of the text with the memories of other documents.
Experimental results on Wikitext-103-v1 with Pythia-1B show that the proposed
methods provide different memory entries for documents and high recall of
document-related content in generation with trained document-wise memories. | [
-0.06322119385004044,
-0.5427652597427368,
0.7109445333480835,
-0.2226945012807846,
-0.14962783455848694,
-0.370969295501709,
-0.27298295497894287,
-0.012361578643321991,
-0.015562348067760468,
0.5778833031654358,
-0.4906872808933258,
-0.6894287467002869,
-0.5012667179107666,
-0.46979501843452454,
-0.5771811604499817,
0.9355623126029968,
-0.24659289419651031,
0.2860938012599945,
-0.43254008889198303,
-0.1428947001695633,
-0.650550365447998,
-0.6446933150291443,
-0.7621229887008667,
-0.4409767985343933,
0.7228825688362122,
0.28033989667892456,
0.22582027316093445,
0.8565598130226135,
0.2486867904663086,
0.3121926188468933,
-0.14356498420238495,
0.16131743788719177,
-0.4836644232273102,
0.22576995193958282,
-0.2903527617454529,
-0.7263669371604919,
-0.5287782549858093,
-0.08459604531526566,
0.906545102596283,
0.4261104166507721,
-0.1531594842672348,
-0.24722859263420105,
-0.13811977207660675,
0.43537962436676025,
-0.4216128885746002,
0.23719953000545502,
-0.6318535208702087,
-0.06622029095888138,
-0.2026490867137909,
-0.6081173419952393,
-0.6297971606254578,
0.02653932385146618,
0.045003678649663925,
-0.5984668135643005,
0.3997189998626709,
0.1377442330121994,
0.7330796718597412,
0.021611766889691353,
-0.06414532661437988,
-0.4950166344642639,
-0.7076636552810669,
0.5965865254402161,
-0.4781542122364044,
0.399997353553772,
0.8583635091781616,
0.03804418444633484,
-0.2331904023885727,
-0.5746942758560181,
-0.4307006895542145,
0.06825515627861023,
0.0016967530827969313,
0.13306769728660583,
0.32609087228775024,
0.12438543140888214,
0.28658390045166016,
0.26226016879081726,
-0.4778529107570648,
0.2013099044561386,
-0.47593212127685547,
-0.4518972635269165,
0.3877527117729187,
0.23414912819862366,
0.13026458024978638,
0.21147097647190094,
0.027503106743097305,
-0.23643971979618073,
-0.6198025941848755,
-0.4712584912776947,
0.23215889930725098,
0.07964050024747849,
0.005368426907807589,
0.2566365897655487,
0.05527130514383316,
0.4227215051651001,
0.1081617921590805,
-0.4820796847343445,
0.20135784149169922,
-0.03643888235092163,
-0.09010893106460571,
0.16874633729457855,
0.5301295518875122,
0.20344585180282593,
0.34104713797569275,
-0.471047580242157,
-0.23550795018672943,
-0.2929776608943939,
0.4850377142429352,
-0.8701373934745789,
-0.20184798538684845,
-0.16915586590766907,
-0.3334186375141144,
0.1267794668674469,
-0.27526453137397766,
-0.28338858485221863,
-0.5400400757789612,
-0.31640735268592834,
0.33319756388664246,
-0.928141176700592,
0.19771221280097961,
-0.04225020110607147,
-0.23794770240783691,
0.3371281325817108,
0.6476187109947205,
-1.3136358261108398,
0.09175167232751846,
0.8230262994766235,
0.7911028861999512,
0.016994869336485863,
-0.6340002417564392,
-0.6421818137168884,
0.6044937968254089,
-0.38356146216392517,
0.7859076261520386,
-0.5946927070617676,
-0.4309542179107666,
0.21185524761676788,
-0.07563479244709015,
-0.22955363988876343,
-0.48420456051826477,
0.42909273505210876,
-0.6393264532089233,
0.3358401358127594,
-0.19541813433170319,
-0.9607858061790466,
-0.3586552143096924,
0.49880343675613403,
-0.5848433375358582,
0.8911871314048767,
0.1471024602651596,
-0.6596992611885071,
0.2479282021522522,
-0.0021121816243976355,
-0.46920377016067505,
-0.06133704632520676,
-0.44548067450523376,
-0.388325035572052,
0.19945959746837616,
0.08944495022296906,
0.5280483961105347,
-0.15333130955696106,
0.3054070472717285,
-0.040277618914842606,
-0.631012499332428,
-0.061529118567705154,
-0.501596212387085,
0.2789838910102844,
-0.14289028942584991,
0.11194846034049988,
0.0472070686519146,
-0.6980278491973877,
-0.39124664664268494,
0.12075520306825638,
-0.7248485684394836,
-0.6359702348709106,
-0.023332640528678894,
-0.08918453752994537,
0.1290329247713089,
0.2992381751537323,
-0.20786844193935394,
0.5173349380493164,
-0.2262568324804306,
0.2067175954580307,
0.794219434261322,
0.07547172158956528,
0.766191840171814,
-0.5104994177818298,
0.3975803852081299,
0.023156898096203804,
-0.0726427361369133,
-0.7122710943222046,
-0.40484878420829773,
-0.7109594345092773,
-0.16464769840240479,
-0.0747290775179863,
0.29586827754974365,
-0.33782410621643066,
0.15684249997138977,
-0.20342613756656647,
-0.3973756730556488,
-0.19475436210632324,
0.3518036901950836,
0.4215521812438965,
0.6900561451911926,
0.21938244998455048,
-0.18132303655147552,
-0.3277741074562073,
-0.6561010479927063,
0.04344317689538002,
-0.30904456973075867,
0.09537786990404129,
0.25893712043762207,
0.3597089648246765,
-0.1916050761938095,
0.42239469289779663,
-0.3115808665752411,
-0.4230194389820099,
-0.19257715344429016,
0.15262708067893982,
-0.11492973566055298,
0.4210752844810486,
0.4092385172843933,
-0.7905465364456177,
-0.20364031195640564,
-0.1714116483926773,
-0.5617738962173462,
0.21964804828166962,
-0.46096163988113403,
-0.24269013106822968,
0.36992937326431274,
0.938616931438446,
-1.0041617155075073,
0.35308346152305603,
0.08802151679992676,
-0.15599262714385986,
0.22509920597076416,
-0.6963182687759399,
-0.17118987441062927,
-1.0123940706253052,
-0.013496573083102703,
-0.21929217875003815,
0.07810543477535248,
-0.47949904203414917,
-0.17580868303775787,
0.36552950739860535,
0.07000218331813812,
-0.15431605279445648,
0.7493312954902649,
-0.5564254522323608,
-0.18895432353019714,
-0.2963310778141022,
0.21098339557647705,
0.30640164017677307,
0.7524170875549316,
0.33173230290412903,
0.5243224501609802,
0.6024661660194397,
-0.4427371025085449,
0.10819130390882492,
0.45595401525497437,
-0.3085530698299408,
0.598375141620636,
0.05715945363044739,
0.30212080478668213,
-0.5143561363220215,
0.5723614692687988,
-0.8695951700210571,
-0.0404471755027771,
0.031900715082883835,
-0.38702061772346497,
0.8857747912406921,
-0.07894808799028397,
-0.7320374846458435,
-0.04315562918782234,
-0.3756771981716156,
0.21991604566574097,
0.24650640785694122,
-0.4044145941734314,
0.7845743894577026,
0.17114652693271637,
-0.06301583349704742,
-0.19431349635124207,
-0.6064220666885376,
0.09722751379013062,
-0.36474087834358215,
-0.4274866282939911,
0.4547507166862488,
-0.003045635763555765,
0.07058930397033691,
-0.05069303885102272,
-0.22184766829013824,
-0.18044373393058777,
0.14002367854118347,
0.43899035453796387,
0.25137531757354736,
-0.2863127589225769,
0.6649695634841919,
-0.0531984344124794,
-0.1785341501235962,
-0.00769335450604558,
-0.5742506384849548,
0.7657568454742432,
0.2113637924194336,
-0.11139845103025436,
-0.235392227768898,
0.66608726978302,
0.5866681337356567,
-0.4826757311820984,
1.0182712078094482,
0.6667079329490662,
-0.4700315296649933,
-0.34359729290008545,
-0.6246134638786316,
0.06857074052095413,
-0.48244985938072205,
0.5979605317115784,
-0.2696877419948578,
-0.5311269760131836,
0.6080827116966248,
-0.012065829709172249,
0.09883493930101395,
0.41513344645500183,
0.5498490929603577,
-0.4375385046005249,
0.8259419202804565,
0.6292392611503601,
-0.5311298966407776,
0.7171343564987183,
-0.4154145121574402,
0.09493586421012878,
-0.9448202848434448,
-0.4784308075904846,
-0.5513935685157776,
-0.1434183418750763,
-0.07033566385507584,
-0.43118637800216675,
0.01713731326162815,
0.3743584454059601,
-0.34168699383735657,
0.12160588800907135,
-0.21843542158603668,
0.48136991262435913,
0.6822773218154907,
-0.14691728353500366,
0.2280230075120926,
-0.08028462529182434,
-0.26631855964660645,
0.23813670873641968,
-0.9728495478630066,
-0.4093501567840576,
1.0370360612869263,
0.21047477424144745,
0.8408219218254089,
-0.3114294111728668,
1.0365636348724365,
-0.09758938103914261,
0.2591330409049988,
-0.7476759552955627,
0.6912112236022949,
-0.22037740051746368,
-0.3722088634967804,
-0.1699824035167694,
-0.20213182270526886,
-0.6839572787284851,
-0.07369007170200348,
0.059529587626457214,
-0.8903435468673706,
-0.3114602267742157,
0.15730156004428864,
-0.14339680969715118,
0.33900216221809387,
-0.6933425664901733,
0.7818243503570557,
-0.3769993484020233,
-0.37929868698120117,
-0.36860305070877075,
-0.3091300129890442,
-0.05780693516135216,
-0.10969136655330658,
-0.0027250940911471844,
0.3675588071346283,
0.04055631160736084,
0.8781481385231018,
-0.46325600147247314,
0.7097046971321106,
-0.19437596201896667,
-0.28667041659355164,
0.2602332532405853,
-0.08210109174251556,
0.7676517367362976,
-0.24157115817070007,
-0.3367356061935425,
-0.0630379319190979,
-0.3367648720741272,
-0.10867863893508911,
-0.5460155606269836,
0.9380620718002319,
-0.6283430457115173,
-0.7062182426452637,
-0.22380834817886353,
-0.9612196683883667,
-0.27405041456222534,
0.410717636346817,
0.28051823377609253,
0.6249653100967407,
0.0037304081488400698,
0.12918470799922943,
1.0927942991256714,
-0.38447317481040955,
0.41887810826301575,
0.6244215369224548,
0.005582198966294527,
0.1045646071434021,
0.9185433983802795,
0.32824257016181946,
-0.01737930439412594,
0.7350378036499023,
0.2503718137741089,
-0.2976525127887726,
-1.128782868385315,
-0.3478483259677887,
0.35307347774505615,
-1.0862195491790771,
0.028547445312142372,
-0.5526735186576843,
-0.19342941045761108,
-0.4053243398666382,
-0.38688603043556213,
-0.18402202427387238,
-0.1572289615869522,
-0.5239939093589783,
-0.11482318490743637,
0.39341771602630615,
0.5533221364021301,
0.39456769824028015,
0.4535173177719116,
-0.8601033687591553,
0.35153838992118835,
0.035276059061288834,
0.37998712062835693,
0.2692280411720276,
-0.5936180949211121,
-0.5438822507858276,
-0.24244606494903564,
-0.25249364972114563,
-0.5412788391113281,
0.24994049966335297,
0.25712835788726807,
0.6108287572860718,
0.5925636887550354,
-0.22572103142738342,
0.6436818838119507,
-0.5840586423873901,
0.42648592591285706,
-0.15165908634662628,
-0.3975726068019867,
0.5605182647705078,
-0.74886554479599,
0.650905430316925,
0.525549590587616,
0.3126288652420044,
-0.5338683128356934,
-0.5665502548217773,
-0.4931807219982147,
-0.8092676997184753,
0.9066954255104065,
-0.27866533398628235,
0.13968995213508606,
-0.19235940277576447,
0.5770372152328491,
-0.11620093882083893,
-0.11447244137525558,
-0.20107586681842804,
0.0867084339261055,
-0.024608677253127098,
-0.3515034019947052,
-0.05779989808797836,
-0.20082508027553558,
-0.012365041300654411,
0.00398272555321455,
0.7139760255813599,
-0.0022222627885639668,
0.17251087725162506,
0.034478746354579926,
-0.21606427431106567,
-0.004786602221429348,
-0.020397670567035675,
0.4979442358016968,
0.4737730622291565,
-0.27403852343559265,
0.02686767652630806,
0.10073459893465042,
-0.6689456105232239,
-0.14502213895320892,
-0.047707270830869675,
-0.44341611862182617,
-0.03614974021911621,
0.6425203680992126,
0.783997654914856,
0.32483333349227905,
-0.6368151307106018,
0.37072011828422546,
-0.03264552354812622,
-0.25820329785346985,
-0.32210981845855713,
0.34838101267814636,
0.5797486305236816,
0.25927600264549255,
0.13893097639083862,
-0.15331082046031952,
-0.25596746802330017,
-0.8151587247848511,
0.21032331883907318,
0.35761627554893494,
-0.25809770822525024,
-0.042191531509160995,
0.5384927988052368,
-0.006736741401255131,
-0.4877389967441559,
0.8560569286346436,
0.029007306322455406,
-0.46636417508125305,
0.6152303814888,
0.6308943033218384,
0.7673453092575073,
-0.23936742544174194,
-0.11327704042196274,
0.34169143438339233,
0.11884942650794983,
-0.34263142943382263,
-0.06472840160131454,
-0.3022172451019287,
-0.4089052379131317,
-0.0186596792191267,
-0.6633992195129395,
-0.12871228158473969,
0.2679367959499359,
-0.5883581638336182,
0.1905849128961563,
-0.5798590779304504,
0.27369362115859985,
0.02847716212272644,
-0.007578234188258648,
-0.6391311883926392,
0.362148255109787,
0.4955248534679413,
1.0712354183197021,
-0.3786340653896332,
1.5289238691329956,
0.3933045268058777,
-0.3426778018474579,
-0.9813387989997864,
0.18653851747512817,
-0.07473772764205933,
-0.9326197504997253,
0.4697937071323395,
0.31839442253112793,
-0.10053759813308716,
-0.24402402341365814,
-0.20770825445652008,
-0.6537288427352905,
1.3716562986373901,
0.25087887048721313,
-0.5782596468925476,
-0.5432034134864807,
-0.007546249311417341,
0.5591556429862976,
-0.28967350721359253,
0.18626701831817627,
0.37223097681999207,
0.31434366106987,
0.24992558360099792,
-0.43658018112182617,
-0.1321893185377121,
-0.22512075304985046,
0.04581737890839577,
0.38834258913993835,
-0.6840868592262268,
0.8593315482139587,
-0.11843337118625641,
-0.24344402551651,
0.2804216742515564,
0.38312146067619324,
0.004197319969534874,
0.40853962302207947,
0.0331648513674736,
0.6719504594802856,
0.880917489528656,
0.21369260549545288,
1.2138910293579102,
-0.08216694742441177,
-0.033336542546749115,
1.4426779747009277,
-0.1963765025138855,
0.7060176134109497,
0.47336387634277344,
0.4407413899898529,
0.15695138275623322,
0.3892415761947632,
-0.008206784725189209,
0.6513571739196777,
0.2285860925912857,
-0.094863161444664,
-0.0842989981174469,
-0.09844677150249481,
-0.2946614921092987,
0.4407840669155121,
0.44635316729545593,
-0.7159526348114014,
-0.25883248448371887,
-0.059273503720760345,
0.23428601026535034,
-0.0015639432240277529,
-0.5733562111854553,
0.997851550579071,
0.058028444647789,
-1.0137124061584473,
0.4708223342895508,
0.2553822696208954,
0.2983461320400238,
-1.0122253894805908,
-0.10416731983423233,
-0.5690015554428101,
0.4416098892688751,
-0.11821239441633224,
-0.541802167892456,
0.3106381595134735,
0.03821338340640068,
-0.29989194869995117,
-0.5086200833320618,
0.7436082363128662,
-0.6699993014335632,
-0.4107399880886078,
0.36742424964904785,
0.011761889792978764,
0.0774664506316185,
-0.1698392778635025,
-0.14700588583946228,
-0.07048593461513519,
-0.22763648629188538,
-0.4963650703430176,
0.7259354591369629,
0.7304610013961792,
-0.423941045999527,
0.5962936282157898,
0.37281718850135803,
-0.02061588689684868,
0.0985364019870758,
0.17303906381130219,
0.9635933637619019,
-0.7157076001167297,
-0.6530256271362305,
-0.7603486776351929,
0.033342715352773666,
0.1583445966243744,
-0.35830938816070557,
0.8215367794036865,
0.6062637567520142,
0.7865675091743469,
0.11217772960662842,
0.614046573638916,
0.23934365808963776,
0.13548246026039124,
-0.838952898979187,
0.8205903768539429,
-0.4001975357532501,
0.35016492009162903,
-0.1980610191822052,
-0.9356381297111511,
-0.17490915954113007,
0.6044225692749023,
-0.32988592982292175,
-0.14089670777320862,
0.7155848145484924,
0.9707274436950684,
-0.05198971554636955,
-0.00640105502679944,
0.2399185597896576,
0.21028605103492737,
0.32601192593574524,
0.8631981611251831,
0.7261309027671814,
-0.3601914644241333,
0.7773234844207764,
0.04103303700685501,
0.08096795529127121,
-0.16024145483970642,
-0.5717860460281372,
-1.0963939428329468,
-0.7502865791320801,
-0.15720462799072266,
-0.07200831174850464,
0.005666553042829037,
0.36126527190208435,
0.5711334347724915,
-0.30057528614997864,
0.02119339071214199,
-0.20797507464885712,
0.10339193046092987,
-0.006283351220190525,
-0.08518834412097931,
0.656870424747467,
-0.15699312090873718,
-0.4418121874332428,
0.40550246834754944,
0.5037858486175537,
0.06189098581671715,
-0.3770051598548889,
-0.48190218210220337,
-0.3833114802837372,
0.16592881083488464,
0.2024754136800766,
0.22330349683761597,
-0.3840166926383972,
-0.16999058425426483,
-0.21216394007205963,
-0.32808420062065125,
0.15614648163318634,
0.8733037114143372,
-0.6277360320091248,
0.4333493411540985,
0.5313891172409058,
0.6954498291015625,
0.972526490688324,
-0.2897464632987976,
0.5698808431625366,
-0.6605889797210693,
0.37476715445518494,
0.22969725728034973,
0.4930725395679474,
0.33973240852355957,
-0.34077855944633484,
0.17950443923473358,
-0.11994648724794388,
-0.16008074581623077,
-0.38384905457496643,
-0.02776409313082695,
-0.8862186074256897,
-0.2852373421192169,
1.1485768556594849,
-0.4650394916534424,
-0.3315335512161255,
0.10423341393470764,
-0.3517480194568634,
0.26625457406044006,
-0.2972630262374878,
0.8149756193161011,
0.9633072018623352,
0.3403567373752594,
-0.23987823724746704,
-0.553566575050354,
0.2620568573474884,
0.32367438077926636,
-0.6831032633781433,
0.09463786333799362,
0.6388071179389954,
0.030893992632627487,
0.0795748308300972,
1.0152190923690796,
-0.09065093100070953,
0.3306311070919037,
0.1993146687746048,
-0.3096804618835449,
-0.2958540618419647,
-0.6907211542129517,
-0.36220240592956543,
0.08802704513072968,
0.11392883211374283,
-0.21603696048259735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15992v1 | Can LLM Graph Reasoning Generalize beyond Pattern Memorization? | 2024-06-23T02:59:15 | 2024-06-23T02:59:15 | Yizhuo Zhang, Heng Wang, Shangbin Feng, Zhaoxuan Tan, Xiaochuang Han, Tianxing He, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate great potential for problems with
implicit graphical structures, while recent works seek to enhance the graph
reasoning capabilities of LLMs through specialized instruction tuning. The
resulting 'graph LLMs' are evaluated with in-distribution settings only, thus
it remains underexplored whether LLMs are learning generalizable graph
reasoning skills or merely memorizing patterns in the synthetic training data.
To this end, we propose the NLGift benchmark, an evaluation suite of LLM graph
reasoning generalization: whether LLMs could go beyond semantic, numeric,
structural, reasoning patterns in the synthetic training data and improve
utility on real-world graph-based tasks. Extensive experiments with two LLMs
across four graph reasoning tasks demonstrate that while generalization on
simple patterns (semantic, numeric) is somewhat satisfactory, LLMs struggle to
generalize across reasoning and real-world patterns, casting doubt on the
benefit of synthetic graph tuning for real-world tasks with underlying network
structures. We explore three strategies to improve LLM graph reasoning
generalization, and we find that while post-training alignment is most
promising for real-world tasks, empowering LLM graph reasoning to go beyond
pattern memorization remains an open research question. | [
-0.2331262230873108,
-1.0146042108535767,
0.8051482439041138,
-0.05140361189842224,
-0.29513418674468994,
0.4272245764732361,
-0.27888235449790955,
-0.41732364892959595,
-0.004185952711850405,
0.6021596193313599,
-0.5593591332435608,
-0.9516938328742981,
-0.5744394659996033,
0.21471427381038666,
-0.3089044392108917,
0.7017791867256165,
-0.14902424812316895,
-0.080243319272995,
-0.26065194606781006,
-0.21948595345020294,
-0.3628424406051636,
-0.5698264241218567,
-1.0124951601028442,
-0.641827404499054,
0.6832093000411987,
-0.046751637011766434,
0.4373750686645508,
0.7791904807090759,
0.4334915280342102,
0.3126896917819977,
-0.15898068249225616,
0.6060822010040283,
-0.6249828934669495,
-0.14544843137264252,
-0.049277618527412415,
-0.6297847032546997,
-0.6134140491485596,
0.06330353766679764,
0.8152501583099365,
1.015249490737915,
0.072704017162323,
0.05027550831437111,
-0.031057188287377357,
0.7814281582832336,
-0.3253277540206909,
0.48944294452667236,
-0.6234702467918396,
0.08174702525138855,
-0.05538997799158096,
-0.07500577718019485,
-0.4183019697666168,
-0.4501689374446869,
-0.23699034750461578,
-0.6813018321990967,
0.25768712162971497,
0.27556663751602173,
0.8532148599624634,
0.1946459263563156,
-0.390953004360199,
0.03734846040606499,
-0.39847543835639954,
0.437590092420578,
-0.6018605828285217,
0.440923810005188,
0.22023959457874298,
0.46026110649108887,
-0.4263496398925781,
-0.8803929686546326,
-0.09924013167619705,
-0.11205018311738968,
-0.0640759989619255,
0.0888320580124855,
-0.36350759863853455,
0.289192259311676,
0.7099582552909851,
0.18511353433132172,
-0.556212306022644,
0.08410905301570892,
-0.020800786092877388,
-0.184197798371315,
0.6496908664703369,
0.18655221164226532,
0.09584494680166245,
0.2947801947593689,
-0.05082821846008301,
-0.21054114401340485,
-0.8389378190040588,
-0.0049562957137823105,
0.45587220788002014,
0.3216108977794647,
0.06960742175579071,
0.3737475574016571,
-0.2600080370903015,
0.8524384498596191,
-0.08823300898075104,
0.22439976036548615,
0.36809733510017395,
-0.0756448283791542,
-0.3380892276763916,
-0.12808839976787567,
0.5070153474807739,
0.5295884013175964,
0.650423526763916,
-0.6480416655540466,
-0.06176849082112312,
0.09176089614629745,
0.14643046259880066,
-0.5903250575065613,
-0.134458988904953,
-0.0997098758816719,
-0.3138434588909149,
0.1206488087773323,
-0.006123003549873829,
-0.37290069460868835,
-0.10505534708499908,
-0.4519636929035187,
0.06006111949682236,
-0.3752816617488861,
-0.10217521339654922,
0.22721976041793823,
-0.47328007221221924,
0.22169138491153717,
0.33314308524131775,
-0.7779868245124817,
0.3751794695854187,
0.948655366897583,
0.8051767349243164,
-0.12818603217601776,
-0.2272876352071762,
-0.5187323689460754,
0.31814083456993103,
-0.49065929651260376,
1.0204232931137085,
-0.7362023591995239,
-0.28908389806747437,
-0.1924770623445511,
0.18829388916492462,
-0.4504041373729706,
-0.5935627222061157,
0.4516216814517975,
-0.5877513885498047,
-0.27106204628944397,
-0.3843756318092346,
-0.737196147441864,
-0.2600266933441162,
0.5026760101318359,
-0.41046109795570374,
0.940583348274231,
0.2821631133556366,
-0.5604440569877625,
0.40319299697875977,
-0.34884190559387207,
-0.34908396005630493,
0.04595336690545082,
-0.3266894519329071,
-0.2852228581905365,
0.0531737394630909,
0.2683500051498413,
0.3358290493488312,
-0.20113104581832886,
0.19694764912128448,
-0.6587987542152405,
-0.8648615479469299,
-0.005338131450116634,
-0.25356435775756836,
0.5313112735748291,
-0.11219832301139832,
-0.2391473948955536,
0.08681778609752655,
-0.7919141054153442,
0.43967384099960327,
0.2834224998950958,
-0.3124115467071533,
-0.15114259719848633,
-0.040998734533786774,
-0.647695004940033,
-0.08894992619752884,
-0.1012464091181755,
-0.3891443610191345,
0.43275073170661926,
-0.4608297049999237,
0.6519948840141296,
0.8788453340530396,
-0.12340644001960754,
0.26752814650535583,
-0.2170293927192688,
0.42743706703186035,
-0.3504132330417633,
-0.04132629185914993,
0.14508505165576935,
-0.6085575819015503,
-0.6114558577537537,
-0.2414228320121765,
0.3014548122882843,
0.56424880027771,
-0.45442357659339905,
0.4541397988796234,
-0.2470487654209137,
-0.19609732925891876,
0.010157641023397446,
0.19864816963672638,
0.48968034982681274,
0.6571120619773865,
0.3889927864074707,
-0.2703257203102112,
-0.4685499966144562,
-0.808009684085846,
-0.4260783791542053,
0.00868945848196745,
-0.06983482837677002,
0.45460018515586853,
0.2932664453983307,
-0.4356359839439392,
0.6621275544166565,
-0.6369568705558777,
0.02818799391388893,
-0.25996941328048706,
0.011858254671096802,
0.33252131938934326,
0.04194502532482147,
0.46593260765075684,
-0.3104093372821808,
-0.3205183446407318,
0.017536886036396027,
-0.7849535346031189,
-0.18538586795330048,
0.2181810587644577,
-0.2479768693447113,
0.044651154428720474,
0.9912093281745911,
-0.5463082194328308,
0.20887739956378937,
0.39835381507873535,
-0.18892420828342438,
0.30014973878860474,
-0.3266162574291229,
-0.15599600970745087,
-0.39072197675704956,
-0.16222046315670013,
-0.10033712536096573,
-0.21379515528678894,
-0.38244110345840454,
-0.0772303119301796,
-0.06671524047851562,
0.06507081538438797,
0.11226749420166016,
0.626635730266571,
-0.4429619312286377,
-0.2769787311553955,
-0.152830570936203,
0.17160899937152863,
0.09425713121891022,
0.4168751835823059,
-0.08857602626085281,
0.6971156001091003,
0.5015994310379028,
-0.4262261986732483,
0.24228058755397797,
-0.0035252689849585295,
-0.32028236985206604,
0.266236275434494,
-0.7150304317474365,
0.43595921993255615,
-0.3339652717113495,
0.39938634634017944,
-1.1368883848190308,
-0.10075361281633377,
0.1886405497789383,
-0.08055345714092255,
0.33193376660346985,
-0.3214718699455261,
-0.5838968753814697,
-0.48552843928337097,
0.009338614530861378,
0.05721946805715561,
0.5475408434867859,
-0.5266352295875549,
0.6213198900222778,
0.009121459908783436,
0.3419785499572754,
-0.49480023980140686,
-0.48683178424835205,
-0.011287910863757133,
-0.3694647252559662,
-0.7015120387077332,
0.22729980945587158,
0.02075519599020481,
-0.24856027960777283,
-0.11398933082818985,
-0.30820518732070923,
0.25448077917099,
0.25549235939979553,
0.15937590599060059,
-0.0039505562745034695,
-0.22006863355636597,
0.266152948141098,
0.1046481654047966,
-0.3262712359428406,
0.11599422246217728,
-0.4566385746002197,
0.5090115070343018,
-0.39152199029922485,
-0.5807747840881348,
0.2998064160346985,
0.04391609504818916,
-0.2818005681037903,
-0.009129224345088005,
0.27709081768989563,
0.6478492021560669,
-0.08243235945701599,
-0.5329471230506897,
-0.4645739793777466,
-0.009478033520281315,
-0.4930352568626404,
0.4293271005153656,
-0.3180069625377655,
-1.1212517023086548,
0.5036006569862366,
-0.7845288515090942,
-0.15860530734062195,
0.3124921917915344,
0.16791541874408722,
-0.3617059290409088,
1.306697130203247,
0.34831687808036804,
0.19249075651168823,
0.32029253244400024,
-0.5407896637916565,
0.10618280619382858,
-0.9155721068382263,
-0.15810474753379822,
-0.2039726823568344,
-0.36351388692855835,
-0.6158022284507751,
-0.3938817083835602,
0.24179807305335999,
0.4460320472717285,
-0.557960033416748,
0.1469566375017166,
-0.536807656288147,
0.8157534003257751,
0.453896701335907,
0.18851904571056366,
0.21827679872512817,
0.25371867418289185,
-0.34033089876174927,
0.24485056102275848,
-0.6533301472663879,
-0.5066059827804565,
1.1136780977249146,
0.112978495657444,
0.4425566792488098,
-0.17995846271514893,
0.6998119354248047,
0.22247204184532166,
0.528486430644989,
-0.4971871078014374,
0.7489429116249084,
-0.44830775260925293,
-0.04948771372437477,
-0.32796958088874817,
-0.5825302004814148,
-1.1097873449325562,
0.29478999972343445,
0.1212238147854805,
-0.9169570803642273,
-0.1698060780763626,
0.36764538288116455,
0.2557980716228485,
0.34478890895843506,
-0.7490038275718689,
0.8715022802352905,
-0.2269187867641449,
-0.0711071789264679,
0.007284148596227169,
-0.5613672733306885,
0.3650573492050171,
0.15935325622558594,
0.2535625994205475,
-0.5129778385162354,
0.00789310596883297,
0.39708489179611206,
-0.272799015045166,
0.9175419807434082,
-0.16563163697719574,
0.008463055826723576,
0.15057821571826935,
-0.1789989471435547,
0.6875985860824585,
-0.023965630680322647,
-0.1902291178703308,
0.4387403428554535,
-0.45271146297454834,
-0.2776511609554291,
-0.9417346119880676,
0.5291209816932678,
-0.7356740236282349,
-0.8777124881744385,
-0.08182739466428757,
-0.5918136835098267,
-0.7209154367446899,
0.30765292048454285,
0.1938721090555191,
0.1739889234304428,
-0.23110905289649963,
-0.09871114790439606,
0.6927549839019775,
0.19211021065711975,
0.2163735181093216,
0.10816352814435959,
-0.1864805966615677,
-0.4713101089000702,
0.8375168442726135,
0.1483892947435379,
0.3571084141731262,
0.34443962574005127,
0.3217673897743225,
-0.3861149847507477,
-0.8586471080780029,
-0.49482059478759766,
0.2929430305957794,
-1.1171271800994873,
0.05005224421620369,
-0.5171407461166382,
-0.23594079911708832,
-0.1580616533756256,
-0.20910988748073578,
0.10759831964969635,
-0.4639393389225006,
-0.08886394649744034,
-0.23524776101112366,
0.42086806893348694,
0.48949483036994934,
0.06071086972951889,
0.1984720379114151,
-0.5086867809295654,
0.2568854093551636,
0.434931218624115,
0.5853889584541321,
-0.1041160523891449,
-0.31700506806373596,
-0.013159560039639473,
-0.04977129399776459,
-0.1689213067293167,
-0.3712289035320282,
0.015211879275739193,
0.18892069160938263,
0.912805438041687,
0.32109248638153076,
-0.44602710008621216,
0.7866034507751465,
-0.6224517226219177,
0.3420855402946472,
0.1335313469171524,
-0.6616727709770203,
0.34412682056427,
-0.49460652470588684,
0.17944104969501495,
0.38343754410743713,
0.23885028064250946,
-0.2871534824371338,
-0.34661468863487244,
-0.5843548774719238,
-0.744543194770813,
0.37799835205078125,
0.06308580189943314,
0.16767780482769012,
-0.23669134080410004,
0.6881523132324219,
-0.19659146666526794,
0.15906694531440735,
-0.4464462995529175,
-0.2402229905128479,
-0.4406719207763672,
-0.0500282421708107,
-0.34799015522003174,
0.18977779150009155,
-0.41593801975250244,
-0.5082526803016663,
0.20536820590496063,
-0.6716248989105225,
0.18986524641513824,
-0.11889132112264633,
0.09082358330488205,
0.04222775250673294,
0.10852599143981934,
0.3355294466018677,
0.7067622542381287,
-0.31348633766174316,
0.16608887910842896,
0.3790667951107025,
-0.1819705069065094,
0.15302854776382446,
0.18549859523773193,
-0.22442378103733063,
-0.17480413615703583,
0.6421518325805664,
1.0015374422073364,
0.203334242105484,
-0.6044647097587585,
0.20669008791446686,
0.029966458678245544,
-0.3918362855911255,
-0.07587303966283798,
0.6427357792854309,
0.4959619343280792,
0.3888426721096039,
0.10694073140621185,
-0.23959526419639587,
-0.02658417634665966,
-0.43866345286369324,
-0.03345555067062378,
0.7478657364845276,
-0.14521285891532898,
-0.05325457081198692,
0.5697550773620605,
-0.1682489812374115,
-0.3481327295303345,
0.8261473178863525,
-0.2861384153366089,
-0.17294566333293915,
0.9587547779083252,
0.8120103478431702,
0.7817114591598511,
0.27912381291389465,
0.046732086688280106,
0.43994638323783875,
0.2102271020412445,
-0.10464386641979218,
0.2849248945713043,
0.006932814605534077,
-0.9304220080375671,
-0.4636656939983368,
-0.35055503249168396,
-0.44401708245277405,
-0.13230004906654358,
-0.39133477210998535,
0.11153276264667511,
-0.8239624500274658,
-0.43357211351394653,
0.01652459055185318,
-0.19388657808303833,
-0.5128716826438904,
0.2139943689107895,
0.12279147654771805,
0.85511314868927,
-0.5210914611816406,
0.6752442121505737,
0.553059995174408,
-0.091379314661026,
-0.7436638474464417,
-0.25538408756256104,
-0.1336938589811325,
-1.1811492443084717,
0.7929660081863403,
0.31529733538627625,
-0.1664341688156128,
0.023394932970404625,
-0.7622891664505005,
-0.9103367328643799,
1.1814296245574951,
0.8402968049049377,
-0.6717131733894348,
-0.19683820009231567,
0.20160020887851715,
0.6659375429153442,
-0.3719977140426636,
0.24839700758457184,
0.7703905701637268,
0.5442001223564148,
0.33883774280548096,
-0.48554956912994385,
0.053263306617736816,
-0.25717341899871826,
0.14358952641487122,
0.2919715642929077,
-0.8649152517318726,
0.7995647192001343,
-0.2420194149017334,
-0.32886695861816406,
-0.41405099630355835,
0.36962786316871643,
0.5808831453323364,
0.23706254363059998,
0.49424922466278076,
0.7344801425933838,
1.0271835327148438,
-0.3276437520980835,
1.2377864122390747,
-0.10049115866422653,
0.08795388042926788,
1.1630830764770508,
-0.35407203435897827,
0.2786191403865814,
0.19643355906009674,
-0.3421914875507355,
0.6335107684135437,
0.6882007718086243,
-0.34107065200805664,
0.31268802285194397,
0.6519229412078857,
0.09096873551607132,
-0.5150727033615112,
-0.03439516946673393,
-0.4244983196258545,
0.17371734976768494,
0.4821453392505646,
-0.31836846470832825,
-0.4010162651538849,
-0.3641393184661865,
-0.160990908741951,
0.02478472702205181,
-0.4528575539588928,
0.68055659532547,
0.30441731214523315,
-0.4223947525024414,
0.8179686665534973,
-0.06943535059690475,
0.15507499873638153,
-0.7806886434555054,
-0.3405676782131195,
-0.21127434074878693,
0.18329839408397675,
-0.23587553203105927,
-0.6835272908210754,
0.38875991106033325,
-0.2847142219543457,
-0.027634406462311745,
-0.22026142477989197,
0.7388229370117188,
0.01550228800624609,
-0.5074224472045898,
0.6669189929962158,
0.38021236658096313,
0.08513933420181274,
0.06314978748559952,
-0.6874569654464722,
0.08963224291801453,
-0.273838609457016,
-0.17961910367012024,
0.4785209596157074,
0.3821345269680023,
-0.3219124972820282,
0.7335195541381836,
0.7985802888870239,
0.15259896218776703,
0.10942772775888443,
0.7655259370803833,
0.9183804392814636,
-0.6206834316253662,
-0.2155667245388031,
-0.7970960140228271,
-0.0014361655339598656,
-0.26330652832984924,
-0.19991758465766907,
0.8647510409355164,
0.41394174098968506,
1.0821707248687744,
0.25288695096969604,
0.747974157333374,
0.49696412682533264,
0.1485164314508438,
-0.7872405648231506,
0.06394004821777344,
-0.3933753967285156,
0.1523623764514923,
-0.3280145823955536,
-0.8826520442962646,
-0.5327441096305847,
0.645689845085144,
-0.5836907029151917,
0.24889855086803436,
0.6812326908111572,
0.6119000315666199,
-0.05004217103123665,
0.14107291400432587,
0.3117644488811493,
-0.09354846179485321,
0.28547799587249756,
0.6355190277099609,
0.8723753094673157,
-0.08922341465950012,
0.4513850808143616,
0.03224839270114899,
0.0004139422962907702,
0.1212364137172699,
-0.9954230785369873,
-1.1833909749984741,
0.06013842672109604,
-0.2180296927690506,
-0.3429100215435028,
0.21760302782058716,
0.6415019631385803,
0.4788655936717987,
-0.6070749759674072,
-0.15758320689201355,
-0.5592924356460571,
0.36823710799217224,
-0.5120405554771423,
-0.18876402080059052,
0.5372952222824097,
-0.45975592732429504,
-0.5489981174468994,
0.536673903465271,
0.47525933384895325,
0.17209403216838837,
0.12999175488948822,
-0.049483686685562134,
0.16946734488010406,
0.02639339305460453,
0.5690818428993225,
0.2652896046638489,
-0.6205553412437439,
-0.5649406313896179,
0.05110811069607735,
0.1484886109828949,
0.4049614667892456,
1.0356024503707886,
-0.4243554472923279,
0.22282595932483673,
0.394178569316864,
0.5251432657241821,
0.7879570126533508,
0.1675373911857605,
0.4012313485145569,
-0.6896063089370728,
0.0662086009979248,
0.08726988732814789,
0.5812530517578125,
0.13685420155525208,
-0.2918599843978882,
0.8469757437705994,
0.405849426984787,
-0.35433417558670044,
-0.7618059515953064,
0.3265224099159241,
-0.7357616424560547,
-0.3402597904205322,
1.1046686172485352,
-0.2905935049057007,
-0.17804819345474243,
-0.16209492087364197,
0.07930509001016617,
0.3403374254703522,
-0.09436465054750443,
0.5652341246604919,
0.6085408329963684,
-0.6204021573066711,
-0.16311095654964447,
-0.3819979131221771,
0.33618536591529846,
0.05488976091146469,
-0.9037764668464661,
0.09119776636362076,
0.3981480598449707,
0.38591066002845764,
-0.10315632820129395,
0.8639544248580933,
0.0146445631980896,
0.07275703549385071,
0.12468330562114716,
-0.39409053325653076,
-0.4596819281578064,
-0.26273441314697266,
-0.2578233778476715,
0.14847064018249512,
0.08812154829502106,
0.3158896863460541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15990v1 | Enhancing Cross-Document Event Coreference Resolution by Discourse Structure and Semantic Information | 2024-06-23T02:54:48 | 2024-06-23T02:54:48 | Qiang Gao, Bobo Li, Zixiang Meng, Yunlong Li, Jun Zhou, Fei Li, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing cross-document event coreference resolution models, which either
compute mention similarity directly or enhance mention representation by
extracting event arguments (such as location, time, agent, and patient),
lacking the ability to utilize document-level information. As a result, they
struggle to capture long-distance dependencies. This shortcoming leads to their
underwhelming performance in determining coreference for the events where their
argument information relies on long-distance dependencies. In light of these
limitations, we propose the construction of document-level Rhetorical Structure
Theory (RST) trees and cross-document Lexical Chains to model the structural
and semantic information of documents. Subsequently, cross-document
heterogeneous graphs are constructed and GAT is utilized to learn the
representations of events. Finally, a pair scorer calculates the similarity
between each pair of events and co-referred events can be recognized using
standard clustering algorithm. Additionally, as the existing cross-document
event coreference datasets are limited to English, we have developed a
large-scale Chinese cross-document event coreference dataset to fill this gap,
which comprises 53,066 event mentions and 4,476 clusters. After applying our
model on the English and Chinese datasets respectively, it outperforms all
baselines by large margins. | [
-0.28929200768470764,
-0.4668446481227875,
0.6237990856170654,
-0.16025984287261963,
-0.33672481775283813,
-0.006363782100379467,
-0.4310375452041626,
-0.7421107292175293,
0.30603137612342834,
0.13099035620689392,
-0.26352158188819885,
-0.603716254234314,
-0.6695209741592407,
0.070980004966259,
-0.1621159464120865,
0.9315008521080017,
-0.05198105052113533,
-0.11298540979623795,
-0.07908053696155548,
-0.2128915637731552,
-0.1098957285284996,
-0.7354440689086914,
-0.49113601446151733,
-0.4963950216770172,
0.5367041230201721,
0.38132357597351074,
0.5184671878814697,
0.5022131204605103,
0.3365034759044647,
0.16547195613384247,
-0.2592078447341919,
0.0740387812256813,
-0.21991389989852905,
-0.181691512465477,
-0.6354135870933533,
-0.312541127204895,
-0.4283006489276886,
0.01916680671274662,
0.8546330332756042,
0.5916439890861511,
0.22241376340389252,
-0.15927568078041077,
0.22770147025585175,
0.1121145635843277,
-0.464307963848114,
0.3282012939453125,
-0.735693097114563,
0.21374215185642242,
-0.4486122131347656,
-0.4243408739566803,
-0.4430585503578186,
-0.00315071945078671,
0.2721303701400757,
-0.599606990814209,
0.5457455515861511,
0.01618988998234272,
1.1407549381256104,
-0.4278995096683502,
-0.2922144830226898,
-0.38025155663490295,
-0.5713575482368469,
0.7604421377182007,
-0.6324838399887085,
0.14410406351089478,
0.41615673899650574,
-0.04839862138032913,
0.00985531136393547,
-0.6701874136924744,
-0.2707177996635437,
-0.21936415135860443,
-0.3365861475467682,
0.07398583739995956,
-0.25207749009132385,
0.21897627413272858,
0.3835166394710541,
0.17745038866996765,
-0.6512728333473206,
0.13992369174957275,
-0.295134037733078,
-0.2714873254299164,
0.4102754592895508,
0.26248306035995483,
0.4218277037143707,
-0.5619295239448547,
-0.12058018893003464,
0.36870306730270386,
-0.7735934257507324,
0.02283315546810627,
-0.028736701235175133,
0.5467441082000732,
-0.02041785977780819,
0.3276737928390503,
-0.05943862348794937,
0.2881407141685486,
0.6504892110824585,
-0.2478252649307251,
-0.0453195683658123,
-0.5919377207756042,
-0.021826626732945442,
0.3579360842704773,
0.6457352638244629,
0.457689493894577,
0.008672955445945263,
-0.2351822555065155,
0.3451996445655823,
-0.0856071263551712,
-0.07517233490943909,
-0.9700310826301575,
0.010465849190950394,
0.07093271613121033,
-0.5781912207603455,
0.21605843305587769,
-0.08786028623580933,
-0.49970903992652893,
-0.4104377031326294,
-0.34688934683799744,
-0.07121998071670532,
-0.6072549223899841,
-0.09690814465284348,
-0.36556005477905273,
-0.21410207450389862,
0.25481271743774414,
0.3310544490814209,
-0.6198947429656982,
0.14873561263084412,
0.6747364401817322,
0.80820631980896,
-0.17547568678855896,
-0.3917900025844574,
-0.38025644421577454,
0.5298941135406494,
-0.15683230757713318,
1.0299335718154907,
-0.8217056393623352,
-0.5575538873672485,
-0.08519645780324936,
0.02425863966345787,
-0.17918342351913452,
-0.3035029172897339,
0.8936672806739807,
-0.07655096799135208,
0.29750338196754456,
-0.44745805859565735,
-0.611877977848053,
-0.10952674597501755,
0.5251193642616272,
-0.3797481954097748,
0.8896505236625671,
-0.16870328783988953,
-0.9380893111228943,
0.19604043662548065,
-0.15243801474571228,
-0.7673482894897461,
0.1689242571592331,
-0.6177334785461426,
-0.24673429131507874,
-0.03677934780716896,
0.42700180411338806,
0.5924806594848633,
-0.5842732787132263,
0.3103889524936676,
-0.09563468396663666,
-0.1398841291666031,
-0.2826794385910034,
0.1602620929479599,
0.5122621059417725,
-0.29352065920829773,
-0.19071926176548004,
0.24554069340229034,
-0.8663027286529541,
-0.3303239643573761,
-0.1392858326435089,
-0.06787000596523285,
-0.7972775101661682,
0.0984051525592804,
-0.17655226588249207,
0.2775968015193939,
0.20848125219345093,
-0.6829907894134521,
0.00043399902642704546,
-0.46292760968208313,
0.4045991599559784,
0.3282947540283203,
0.1508186161518097,
0.47452422976493835,
-0.150803342461586,
0.37647685408592224,
0.2653929889202118,
-0.02482885867357254,
-0.5314395427703857,
-0.5826098322868347,
-0.43755707144737244,
0.12587444484233856,
0.030815668404102325,
0.4198548495769501,
-0.48658251762390137,
0.4967091977596283,
-0.38202744722366333,
-0.6989583373069763,
0.013517179526388645,
-0.4213877320289612,
0.49718359112739563,
0.7614904642105103,
0.31724900007247925,
-0.16952449083328247,
-1.014970302581787,
-0.752484917640686,
-0.19453886151313782,
-0.37254437804222107,
0.2218495011329651,
0.24892930686473846,
0.5566794276237488,
0.28599926829338074,
0.851643979549408,
-0.26759347319602966,
-0.3737150728702545,
-0.3015155792236328,
0.39980044960975647,
0.02860942855477333,
0.4110352396965027,
0.6090013384819031,
-0.5128942131996155,
-0.6182465553283691,
0.44890281558036804,
-0.3968709409236908,
0.0327860563993454,
-0.049186792224645615,
0.07058385759592056,
0.31889936327934265,
0.41451579332351685,
-0.3252049684524536,
0.6309643983840942,
0.37168124318122864,
-0.3959220349788666,
0.76528000831604,
0.08016807585954666,
0.27618420124053955,
-1.3312636613845825,
0.15210430324077606,
0.003468650858849287,
-0.1580953598022461,
-0.36198025941848755,
-0.2593386173248291,
0.04907537251710892,
-0.2723606526851654,
-0.24099133908748627,
0.5145458579063416,
-0.5158132910728455,
-0.03403187915682793,
-0.3739891052246094,
0.49997833371162415,
0.17371565103530884,
0.5308652520179749,
0.5524172782897949,
0.5045700669288635,
0.3193747401237488,
-0.396757036447525,
0.21828444302082062,
0.24139322340488434,
-0.28444787859916687,
1.1361027956008911,
-0.4898396134376526,
-0.13151612877845764,
0.09081457555294037,
0.7619361281394958,
-0.8815365433692932,
0.15233615040779114,
0.1275286078453064,
-0.5361794233322144,
0.008561262860894203,
-0.35579103231430054,
-0.19078315794467926,
-0.09810873866081238,
-0.20425930619239807,
0.4576716721057892,
-0.034797750413417816,
-0.4471341669559479,
1.1351522207260132,
0.453676700592041,
-0.3280175030231476,
-0.591926634311676,
-0.7003836631774902,
0.28857186436653137,
-0.00031008670339360833,
-0.689146876335144,
0.7903565168380737,
0.3569973111152649,
0.04765872284770012,
0.2007083296775818,
-0.03244173154234886,
0.014059972949326038,
-0.4464172124862671,
0.5232666730880737,
0.19982655346393585,
-0.360210120677948,
0.29460304975509644,
-0.07781176269054413,
-0.2797187864780426,
0.035024259239435196,
-0.31142520904541016,
0.3641124963760376,
-0.024033725261688232,
-0.33426299691200256,
-0.40807464718818665,
0.8676139712333679,
0.2405872493982315,
-0.2346063256263733,
0.588624894618988,
0.5732844471931458,
-0.7263479828834534,
-0.06684998422861099,
-0.5441566705703735,
-0.07623752951622009,
-0.30540671944618225,
0.5172744393348694,
-0.651419997215271,
-0.9628373980522156,
0.8144205808639526,
-0.01833968050777912,
0.19380837678909302,
0.6951313018798828,
0.6753888130187988,
0.15813404321670532,
0.6553508639335632,
0.267330139875412,
-0.14749054610729218,
0.5043545365333557,
0.12558133900165558,
0.1994871348142624,
-0.9198639988899231,
-0.13056771457195282,
-1.1001687049865723,
-0.11537577956914902,
-0.08891864120960236,
-0.7839093804359436,
0.05913897976279259,
-0.08472424000501633,
-0.062145818024873734,
0.5583155751228333,
-0.39376112818717957,
0.4208495020866394,
0.27970245480537415,
-0.21190549433231354,
0.4635521173477173,
-0.09442850947380066,
-0.37790971994400024,
-0.3901400864124298,
-0.7819973826408386,
-0.30819541215896606,
0.414680153131485,
0.13996706902980804,
0.5438255667686462,
-0.2987139821052551,
0.4831225872039795,
-0.0008306388626806438,
0.10429193824529648,
-0.5560795664787292,
0.5700310468673706,
-0.34059950709342957,
-0.5136517882347107,
-0.11921717971563339,
-0.31268051266670227,
-1.0547151565551758,
0.2082315981388092,
0.07149748504161835,
-0.9854418039321899,
0.5406531691551208,
-0.30199357867240906,
-0.33888280391693115,
0.4751173257827759,
-0.2932579517364502,
0.5763201713562012,
0.18570266664028168,
-0.11681471765041351,
-0.45436564087867737,
-0.49013468623161316,
0.14015021920204163,
0.2878074049949646,
0.09328646212816238,
-0.18664754927158356,
0.27160730957984924,
1.120255947113037,
-0.2671443819999695,
1.1655771732330322,
0.23932994902133942,
-0.1675986498594284,
0.5234143733978271,
-0.07400491088628769,
0.695929229259491,
-0.05130278691649437,
-0.2720496654510498,
0.07973247766494751,
0.11911466717720032,
-0.3134341835975647,
-0.5609068870544434,
0.7667373418807983,
-0.6769322752952576,
-0.4744027554988861,
-0.27875396609306335,
-0.48103517293930054,
-0.13564668595790863,
0.06540318578481674,
0.38101714849472046,
0.6988237500190735,
-0.6059824228286743,
0.1334523856639862,
0.377888947725296,
0.03947915881872177,
0.44877517223358154,
0.6626375317573547,
0.08714833110570908,
-0.5253595113754272,
0.6646233797073364,
0.4906019866466522,
-0.011313983239233494,
0.5552574992179871,
0.2650615870952606,
-0.16865086555480957,
-0.4047570824623108,
-0.16254015266895294,
0.3378514051437378,
-0.9810542464256287,
-0.21282310783863068,
-0.8212851881980896,
-0.4087543785572052,
-0.6562104821205139,
-0.4145382046699524,
-0.2664991617202759,
-0.6126048564910889,
-0.32542961835861206,
-0.2797100245952606,
0.11238208413124084,
0.36379554867744446,
-0.08927120268344879,
0.22176648676395416,
-0.9782606363296509,
0.06150030344724655,
-0.22209326922893524,
0.18841920793056488,
0.3236106038093567,
-0.600116491317749,
-0.6704573035240173,
-0.4752999246120453,
-0.2903807759284973,
-0.8720676898956299,
0.03831112012267113,
0.19956254959106445,
0.6049982905387878,
0.43379655480384827,
0.23715448379516602,
0.9219656586647034,
-0.38200947642326355,
0.9410315752029419,
0.28060802817344666,
-1.1155226230621338,
0.860389769077301,
-0.3761692941188812,
0.3195888102054596,
0.29775696992874146,
0.3807247579097748,
-0.8194991946220398,
-0.45948106050491333,
-0.8740493655204773,
-0.7716835737228394,
0.6913841962814331,
0.03466344624757767,
-0.28726789355278015,
-0.014644228853285313,
0.37698930501937866,
0.04577009379863739,
-0.28954222798347473,
-0.6277119517326355,
0.06882217526435852,
0.11821619421243668,
0.07024262100458145,
0.07831129431724548,
-0.2742424011230469,
-0.3182786703109741,
-0.23285704851150513,
0.7426178455352783,
-0.23434746265411377,
-0.005765419453382492,
0.4047447144985199,
0.130680114030838,
-0.18116973340511322,
0.47731050848960876,
0.4625086784362793,
0.699184775352478,
0.048929743468761444,
0.45059987902641296,
0.38349586725234985,
-0.49244004487991333,
-0.061719637364149094,
0.3425633907318115,
-0.1926528364419937,
0.2835155725479126,
0.656936526298523,
0.7572351098060608,
0.392088383436203,
-0.38708019256591797,
0.17780233919620514,
0.0952211543917656,
-0.10149234533309937,
-0.018638085573911667,
-0.3309342861175537,
0.2639193534851074,
0.2686637341976166,
0.37663406133651733,
-0.35049790143966675,
-0.04248213395476341,
-0.6931365728378296,
0.43312203884124756,
0.23921209573745728,
-0.5726192593574524,
-0.4321463406085968,
0.16176839172840118,
0.6168401837348938,
-0.10136951506137848,
0.2080031782388687,
0.06493788957595825,
-0.7256804704666138,
0.6391560435295105,
0.611883282661438,
0.6990039944648743,
-0.32811272144317627,
0.21783824265003204,
0.7997545599937439,
0.3878728151321411,
0.12730906903743744,
0.09189213812351227,
-0.054405320435762405,
-0.6738471984863281,
-0.5009328722953796,
-0.22682151198387146,
-0.6100549101829529,
-0.07773906737565994,
-0.4658033847808838,
0.24662522971630096,
-0.5304690599441528,
-0.25386905670166016,
0.017316007986664772,
0.5727468132972717,
-0.2021612972021103,
0.16384488344192505,
0.2624368667602539,
0.7820414900779724,
-0.7166275382041931,
0.8823238015174866,
0.6792223453521729,
-0.35804489254951477,
-0.8232775330543518,
-0.14176045358181,
-0.084967240691185,
-0.30699482560157776,
0.41196513175964355,
0.022231457754969597,
-0.06518273055553436,
-0.3323913514614105,
0.02075696364045143,
-0.7750117182731628,
0.9533497095108032,
0.11220665276050568,
-0.6748387813568115,
-0.3785128593444824,
0.35427039861679077,
0.47483140230178833,
-0.6185949444770813,
0.3265141248703003,
0.465025931596756,
0.607782781124115,
0.22193406522274017,
-1.0669960975646973,
0.3817744851112366,
-0.04611742123961449,
-0.09954846650362015,
0.16809111833572388,
-0.5430122017860413,
0.781011700630188,
0.06939072161912918,
-0.49979478120803833,
-0.1483316868543625,
1.017645001411438,
0.2971349358558655,
0.41007155179977417,
0.3140968084335327,
0.5557234883308411,
0.7828689217567444,
-0.03968975692987442,
0.6313364505767822,
-0.3390989899635315,
0.2847212255001068,
1.5767834186553955,
-0.4911177456378937,
0.7204726338386536,
0.29754236340522766,
-0.061015959829092026,
0.5032133460044861,
0.4853367805480957,
0.08764753490686417,
0.0507349818944931,
-0.05613764747977257,
-0.25116196274757385,
-0.36392533779144287,
-0.5398249626159668,
-0.6440513730049133,
0.06671644747257233,
0.6932737827301025,
-0.5559380650520325,
-0.9020944237709045,
0.1004440188407898,
0.048368364572525024,
0.19576331973075867,
-0.39810875058174133,
0.5785672664642334,
0.24120865762233734,
-0.7260046005249023,
0.22340431809425354,
0.2283688485622406,
0.46741151809692383,
-0.642600953578949,
0.15503551065921783,
0.08553758263587952,
0.22177527844905853,
-0.3368236720561981,
-0.950995922088623,
0.6848271489143372,
-0.0989815890789032,
-0.3865327537059784,
0.12841707468032837,
1.1447196006774902,
-0.40376949310302734,
-0.4151594638824463,
0.5855026245117188,
0.2783575654029846,
0.0388217531144619,
-0.11191754043102264,
-0.6425759792327881,
0.12739433348178864,
-0.186820387840271,
-0.10813315212726593,
0.4771275520324707,
0.6904528141021729,
-0.2614792585372925,
0.12179524451494217,
0.2920307517051697,
0.04774858057498932,
-0.10757112503051758,
-0.007019178941845894,
0.816336452960968,
-0.7918716669082642,
-0.7318164110183716,
-0.7321051359176636,
0.1612466424703598,
-0.1958623081445694,
-0.4926782250404358,
0.5997934937477112,
0.6472676992416382,
0.508537232875824,
0.36099159717559814,
0.9052757620811462,
-0.24216072261333466,
0.6613234877586365,
-0.1505618393421173,
0.3582770824432373,
-0.18550880253314972,
-0.16506390273571014,
-0.293163001537323,
-0.41324150562286377,
-0.32337045669555664,
0.3371674120426178,
-0.6349160671234131,
-0.30549436807632446,
0.7900689244270325,
0.6615527868270874,
-0.010889521799981594,
0.4118821918964386,
0.33775314688682556,
0.1369161456823349,
0.4879237711429596,
0.9118867516517639,
0.6593736410140991,
-0.40130653977394104,
0.7248322367668152,
-0.1192726343870163,
-0.09950519353151321,
-0.3026576340198517,
-0.9687760472297668,
-1.0963698625564575,
-1.1227350234985352,
-0.5721254348754883,
-0.5794817805290222,
0.3037106394767761,
0.8151422142982483,
0.6754122972488403,
-0.7728884220123291,
-0.2186511605978012,
0.3073797821998596,
0.22174912691116333,
-0.2151036113500595,
-0.19700734317302704,
0.7499014735221863,
-0.1949567198753357,
-0.6783924698829651,
0.20496124029159546,
0.42836707830429077,
-0.23178546130657196,
-0.0064343237318098545,
0.12006840854883194,
-0.4788230359554291,
0.2838192284107208,
0.7341079711914062,
0.45150139927864075,
-0.6667470335960388,
-0.4707377552986145,
-0.48094096779823303,
-0.43710583448410034,
0.36959579586982727,
1.188853144645691,
-0.6141554713249207,
-0.09182906895875931,
0.7518244981765747,
0.48922625184059143,
0.3830290138721466,
0.03521919995546341,
0.5988794565200806,
-0.8344768285751343,
0.2736453711986542,
0.30014586448669434,
0.45509234070777893,
0.20143868029117584,
-0.36523446440696716,
0.4320276975631714,
0.37091565132141113,
-0.3830018937587738,
-0.5152977108955383,
0.34897181391716003,
-1.2805228233337402,
-0.36651456356048584,
1.0489585399627686,
-0.5117129683494568,
-0.45658642053604126,
-0.44145870208740234,
-0.4691534638404846,
0.381167471408844,
-0.38112911581993103,
0.5301030278205872,
1.0319234132766724,
-0.24505119025707245,
-0.35472503304481506,
0.2987082302570343,
0.33596503734588623,
0.2631438374519348,
-0.8248797655105591,
0.355202853679657,
0.38481518626213074,
0.09913887828588486,
0.574658989906311,
0.8044343590736389,
-0.29089614748954773,
0.3126634657382965,
0.09031529724597931,
0.08056274056434631,
0.1215875968337059,
-0.21959741413593292,
0.06018739566206932,
0.6497822999954224,
-0.30632248520851135,
0.18684352934360504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15981v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15981v1 | Serial Position Effects of Large Language Models | 2024-06-23T02:02:52 | 2024-06-23T02:02:52 | Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in zero-shot
learning applications, generating responses to queries using only pre-training
information without the need for additional fine-tuning. This represents a
significant departure from traditional machine learning approaches. Previous
research has indicated that LLMs may exhibit serial position effects, such as
primacy and recency biases, which are well-documented cognitive biases in human
psychology. Our extensive testing across various tasks and models confirms the
widespread occurrence of these effects, although their intensity varies. We
also discovered that while carefully designed prompts can somewhat mitigate
these biases, their effectiveness is inconsistent. These findings underscore
the significance of serial position effects during the inference process,
particularly in scenarios where there are no ground truth labels, highlighting
the need for greater focus on addressing these effects in LLM applications. | [
-0.21919821202754974,
-0.7736091017723083,
0.9424485564231873,
0.0861019715666771,
-0.11706116795539856,
-0.23467135429382324,
-0.15030279755592346,
-0.3323554992675781,
0.23584510385990143,
0.6430596709251404,
-0.37021082639694214,
-0.5990517139434814,
-0.8765251040458679,
0.037793491035699844,
-0.3748452067375183,
0.8361210227012634,
0.3182501792907715,
0.1290244609117508,
-0.13642318546772003,
-0.1424354463815689,
-0.6618426442146301,
-1.01919686794281,
-0.6296319961547852,
-0.25184348225593567,
0.7527402639389038,
0.37445205450057983,
0.7645702958106995,
0.6204577684402466,
0.28103533387184143,
0.20976929366588593,
-0.06161125376820564,
-0.14442864060401917,
-0.5611459612846375,
0.48169225454330444,
-0.12957990169525146,
-0.9050619602203369,
-0.3794601559638977,
0.027759062126278877,
0.932774543762207,
1.0642086267471313,
0.12171381711959839,
0.011155271902680397,
0.044062141329050064,
0.6900296807289124,
-0.6936178207397461,
-0.11444085091352463,
-0.6568372249603271,
0.05168072506785393,
-0.33203813433647156,
-0.5915102362632751,
-0.8946921825408936,
-0.20286397635936737,
0.1346263736486435,
-0.25442013144493103,
0.360759973526001,
0.08005531132221222,
0.6499491333961487,
0.29434308409690857,
-0.7415303587913513,
-0.1816401183605194,
-0.9252611994743347,
1.068319320678711,
-0.9393600225448608,
0.3834972381591797,
0.3512848913669586,
-0.09386996924877167,
-0.42912647128105164,
-0.3783320486545563,
-0.4192825257778168,
-0.3289167582988739,
-0.09915150701999664,
-0.10839122533798218,
0.10318440943956375,
0.24123065173625946,
0.8345550894737244,
0.006833144463598728,
-0.5876412987709045,
0.36810973286628723,
-0.12950949370861053,
0.07465183734893799,
0.46764475107192993,
0.5215953588485718,
0.14482729136943817,
-0.16117867827415466,
-0.1615111082792282,
-0.011314795352518559,
-1.055289387702942,
0.22707296907901764,
0.28221824765205383,
0.3437027633190155,
0.13022568821907043,
0.7075693011283875,
-0.0847083106637001,
1.0510094165802002,
0.3022879362106323,
-0.3041018843650818,
-0.028805812820792198,
-0.02194073051214218,
-0.33145323395729065,
0.04116707667708397,
0.8016571998596191,
0.40278083086013794,
0.11181540787220001,
-0.17384564876556396,
-0.20621177554130554,
-0.07159125804901123,
0.11109308153390884,
-0.8987171053886414,
0.22405581176280975,
0.30535751581192017,
-0.41662025451660156,
-0.2976732850074768,
0.12299796938896179,
-0.6255336999893188,
-0.7118439674377441,
-0.5177547335624695,
0.17358946800231934,
-0.1528129130601883,
0.05609401687979698,
0.13783146440982819,
-0.06641433387994766,
0.46597400307655334,
0.21090717613697052,
-1.073809027671814,
0.10860777646303177,
0.7574480175971985,
0.7353340983390808,
-0.3726147711277008,
-0.1514289528131485,
-0.5258999466896057,
0.19664710760116577,
-0.5296494960784912,
0.9130406975746155,
-0.7243204116821289,
-0.6414881944656372,
-0.1340293288230896,
0.1463450789451599,
-0.13566963374614716,
-0.7265634536743164,
0.41609758138656616,
-0.6924768090248108,
-0.03189899027347565,
-0.39085495471954346,
-0.5971851348876953,
-0.10385437309741974,
0.0617109052836895,
-0.5496991276741028,
0.7229210138320923,
-0.3950788676738739,
-0.5049718618392944,
0.34070703387260437,
-0.13708104193210602,
-0.6314448714256287,
-0.3688047528266907,
-0.44273641705513,
-0.1752483993768692,
0.365824818611145,
0.050899650901556015,
0.5032811164855957,
-0.20560027658939362,
0.1983364075422287,
-0.5301370024681091,
-0.4236142933368683,
0.5912793874740601,
-0.5070651769638062,
0.6748008131980896,
-0.04572774097323418,
-0.5033648610115051,
0.059472501277923584,
-0.64289391040802,
-0.21518206596374512,
0.09699487686157227,
-0.12216867506504059,
-0.5708641409873962,
0.0632263720035553,
-0.434614896774292,
0.22430291771888733,
0.13050568103790283,
-0.40438616275787354,
0.5282596945762634,
-0.3989047706127167,
0.3207468092441559,
0.6398529410362244,
0.28549596667289734,
0.7636545896530151,
-0.2778387665748596,
0.7006566524505615,
-0.006025767885148525,
0.05978083610534668,
-0.3123977780342102,
-0.5656969547271729,
-0.5595402717590332,
-0.09086215496063232,
0.12569887936115265,
0.7162783145904541,
-0.3676306903362274,
0.19061903655529022,
-0.11551059037446976,
-0.0926613062620163,
0.008563993498682976,
0.12903843820095062,
0.30151453614234924,
0.3742547929286957,
-0.0961344763636589,
-0.12096602469682693,
-0.536230742931366,
-0.8647575378417969,
-0.19281020760536194,
0.1912219524383545,
-0.005466669797897339,
0.23650705814361572,
0.191383495926857,
0.029585963115096092,
0.9298191070556641,
-0.5754639506340027,
0.010660691186785698,
-0.06828731298446655,
0.36063307523727417,
0.420431524515152,
0.22841288149356842,
0.4146724343299866,
-0.5073885321617126,
-0.18681667745113373,
-0.4973732829093933,
-0.9291591644287109,
-0.1310780644416809,
-0.3866632878780365,
-0.10501086711883545,
0.603411853313446,
0.7974860072135925,
-1.0461242198944092,
0.6115511059761047,
0.36809229850769043,
-0.10076842457056046,
0.6696429252624512,
-0.07485847175121307,
0.1714639961719513,
-0.9249053597450256,
0.05236430838704109,
-0.05568758398294449,
-0.17312152683734894,
-0.7627751231193542,
-0.2072642296552658,
-0.09766390919685364,
-0.09758208692073822,
-0.3641566336154938,
0.629681408405304,
-0.5564664006233215,
-0.4205808937549591,
-0.5435046553611755,
0.3390338122844696,
0.11288472265005112,
0.26910680532455444,
0.2923445701599121,
0.7365944981575012,
0.1910039335489273,
-0.7581192851066589,
0.03151790052652359,
0.05230086296796799,
-0.3122556507587433,
0.28259432315826416,
-0.7103861570358276,
0.22372353076934814,
-0.3900867998600006,
0.439292311668396,
-1.4084211587905884,
-0.06965231150388718,
0.14968053996562958,
-0.694362998008728,
0.6156513690948486,
-0.2133886218070984,
-0.516167938709259,
-0.2889586091041565,
-0.3901764750480652,
0.276238352060318,
0.40610000491142273,
-0.32631218433380127,
0.24038472771644592,
0.18294687569141388,
-0.24946801364421844,
-0.9543978571891785,
-0.6451733112335205,
0.04140156880021095,
-0.2364015430212021,
-0.3699216842651367,
0.004490703344345093,
0.07868387550115585,
-0.48070815205574036,
-0.28690922260284424,
-0.04064994677901268,
0.22651435434818268,
0.16753622889518738,
0.5459502935409546,
0.4005208909511566,
-0.2662440240383148,
0.3106948733329773,
-0.14226369559764862,
-0.1935429722070694,
0.1097368523478508,
-0.16510340571403503,
0.6937404870986938,
0.27347803115844727,
-0.3896150588989258,
-0.4962027668952942,
0.2486962229013443,
0.7763006091117859,
-0.08012460917234421,
1.0684950351715088,
0.04561317712068558,
-0.1893846094608307,
-0.11581182479858398,
-0.5689900517463684,
-0.4741327166557312,
-0.44470009207725525,
0.28109464049339294,
-0.14837120473384857,
-0.9367432594299316,
0.41165101528167725,
0.05657542496919632,
-0.003038696711882949,
0.12745481729507446,
0.4842088222503662,
-0.29492852091789246,
1.3475899696350098,
0.40764081478118896,
-0.1422080397605896,
0.6558897495269775,
-0.14782512187957764,
0.3040122389793396,
-0.7148060202598572,
0.19302169978618622,
-0.5507006049156189,
-0.3727183938026428,
-0.4496190547943115,
-0.2841033339500427,
0.2549881935119629,
0.3739112615585327,
-0.4146701991558075,
-0.09324220567941666,
-0.2447386533021927,
0.4634047746658325,
0.5466894507408142,
-0.055495645850896835,
0.2459249049425125,
-0.010962072759866714,
0.02565988339483738,
-0.23710736632347107,
-0.5683990716934204,
-0.5070856213569641,
1.2861089706420898,
0.09535630792379379,
0.7194320559501648,
0.008325629867613316,
0.43082505464553833,
0.23697973787784576,
0.1905830204486847,
-0.9538332223892212,
0.6141479015350342,
-0.12093046307563782,
-0.8098766207695007,
-0.40667054057121277,
-0.20644788444042206,
-1.1869317293167114,
0.08738569915294647,
-0.16400881111621857,
-0.7515953779220581,
0.2635115385055542,
0.08752646297216415,
-0.7317344546318054,
0.2779841125011444,
-0.5781038403511047,
0.6769284009933472,
-0.3228382468223572,
-0.5945903658866882,
-0.1491159051656723,
-0.5409417748451233,
0.5661795139312744,
-0.06892634928226471,
0.17399917542934418,
-0.15379910171031952,
-0.051203928887844086,
0.5421518683433533,
-0.364351749420166,
1.2891123294830322,
-0.4594859182834625,
-0.20081907510757446,
0.14680258929729462,
0.2103351354598999,
0.6970399618148804,
-0.08312821388244629,
-0.16124984622001648,
0.0227434653788805,
0.022592632099986076,
-0.4444165825843811,
-0.6288250684738159,
0.7077815532684326,
-0.7388975620269775,
-0.9254497289657593,
-0.40092945098876953,
-0.8448073863983154,
-0.47932639718055725,
0.23552271723747253,
0.3674471080303192,
0.8322649002075195,
0.058409739285707474,
0.15587380528450012,
0.9888408184051514,
-0.854140043258667,
0.38778260350227356,
0.7370592951774597,
-0.5149540305137634,
-0.32238200306892395,
0.6111037731170654,
0.2872045636177063,
0.4605196714401245,
0.5172351002693176,
0.05504439398646355,
-0.35582399368286133,
-0.6837835907936096,
-0.3002564609050751,
0.5508902668952942,
-0.6240601539611816,
0.07213599979877472,
-0.4423084259033203,
-0.009640965610742569,
-0.8027157783508301,
-0.22459718585014343,
-0.22527822852134705,
-0.5564962029457092,
-0.23647253215312958,
-0.260653555393219,
0.284442275762558,
0.849846363067627,
0.052549783140420914,
0.5338479280471802,
-1.032495141029358,
0.333802729845047,
0.19763930141925812,
0.1839238554239273,
0.12714837491512299,
-0.8000034093856812,
-0.05001791566610336,
-0.004639464896172285,
-0.32000505924224854,
-0.6603387594223022,
0.3798559606075287,
-0.10214009881019592,
0.5856814384460449,
0.5775043964385986,
0.05417824909090996,
0.5746085047721863,
-0.6231054663658142,
0.891267716884613,
0.09119809418916702,
-0.5658869743347168,
0.34102028608322144,
-0.7141042947769165,
0.460541695356369,
0.2523651421070099,
0.5401924252510071,
-0.599210262298584,
-0.1397278755903244,
-0.3293238878250122,
-0.67561274766922,
0.830700159072876,
-0.36996912956237793,
0.09398236870765686,
-0.3557494878768921,
0.6527021527290344,
0.08257298171520233,
0.24169056117534637,
-0.5465542078018188,
-0.5953531265258789,
0.2102186381816864,
0.13341262936592102,
-0.24454408884048462,
-0.7271130084991455,
0.18638698756694794,
-0.11800523102283478,
0.5697759389877319,
0.21440352499485016,
0.39383646845817566,
0.1453312337398529,
-0.13102683424949646,
-0.20123733580112457,
0.24472332000732422,
1.0301398038864136,
0.7463610768318176,
-0.372592955827713,
0.15176105499267578,
0.05994808301329613,
-0.21283361315727234,
0.22833538055419922,
-0.13057942688465118,
-0.5358020067214966,
0.04884211719036102,
0.4394052028656006,
0.7930884957313538,
0.46088993549346924,
-0.5330648422241211,
0.523145854473114,
0.1896515041589737,
-0.11894246190786362,
-0.48816046118736267,
-0.18437686562538147,
0.11603092402219772,
0.2914566397666931,
0.29921355843544006,
-0.11457378417253494,
0.11885834485292435,
-0.5872498750686646,
0.22338241338729858,
0.6816229224205017,
-0.31407731771469116,
-0.2742939889431,
0.6874990463256836,
-0.08311503380537033,
-0.2280198037624359,
0.5563037991523743,
-0.0685470700263977,
-0.3624648153781891,
0.5516721606254578,
0.5596946477890015,
0.5633301138877869,
-0.4832887351512909,
0.14925460517406464,
0.421497106552124,
0.24149742722511292,
-0.14967171847820282,
0.05768910050392151,
0.0494743175804615,
-0.8468400239944458,
-0.7799762487411499,
-0.38166186213493347,
-0.4738018214702606,
0.2099442481994629,
-0.6930003762245178,
0.3014613687992096,
-0.6535432934761047,
-0.41567596793174744,
-0.0352967195212841,
-0.3086749017238617,
-0.35625001788139343,
-0.03993400186300278,
0.6724794507026672,
0.575485110282898,
-0.5499990582466125,
1.054565668106079,
0.6218704581260681,
-0.3976047933101654,
-0.5814105272293091,
-0.007984524592757225,
0.14839290082454681,
-0.9111292958259583,
1.0642321109771729,
0.2698937654495239,
-0.2037847489118576,
-0.004957807250320911,
-0.7389798164367676,
-0.9946844577789307,
0.9730952382087708,
0.44873642921447754,
-0.6099279522895813,
-0.17939911782741547,
0.701056718826294,
0.5011274218559265,
-0.06371854990720749,
0.3180081844329834,
0.4959087669849396,
0.23434999585151672,
0.11018357425928116,
-0.6696188449859619,
-0.11951173841953278,
0.23731577396392822,
0.05642632022500038,
0.395096093416214,
-0.5700864791870117,
0.8250912427902222,
-0.08183474838733673,
-0.1646956354379654,
0.10537062585353851,
0.4128322899341583,
0.4677773714065552,
0.32651686668395996,
0.24393098056316376,
0.6500985622406006,
0.6809049248695374,
0.14312168955802917,
1.2965521812438965,
-0.40626102685928345,
0.15580226480960846,
1.3342006206512451,
-0.649876058101654,
0.9397521615028381,
0.4691605269908905,
-0.16539564728736877,
0.3952471911907196,
0.4368487298488617,
0.35196128487586975,
0.3939911425113678,
0.11666746437549591,
-0.26838889718055725,
-0.32785502076148987,
-0.15927807986736298,
-0.29087474942207336,
0.0166790634393692,
0.6661093831062317,
-0.4701021909713745,
-0.06922321766614914,
0.08198731392621994,
0.18789488077163696,
-0.042296454310417175,
-0.34105193614959717,
0.43055495619773865,
0.4912542402744293,
-0.6813520193099976,
0.8022672533988953,
-0.18332751095294952,
0.848478376865387,
-0.543302059173584,
0.030571790412068367,
-0.46816569566726685,
0.2949524521827698,
-0.25000834465026855,
-0.7327924966812134,
0.3164930045604706,
-0.1857297718524933,
-0.519887387752533,
-0.3118037283420563,
0.7461070418357849,
-0.1190004050731659,
-0.21459947526454926,
0.37214621901512146,
0.33511707186698914,
0.24302025139331818,
-0.23973946273326874,
-0.48457571864128113,
-0.010540484450757504,
-0.09153848886489868,
-0.4413537383079529,
0.5364658832550049,
0.4907565712928772,
-0.05363170802593231,
0.4271602928638458,
0.6579082012176514,
-0.07921329885721207,
0.3299205005168915,
0.0901864767074585,
0.3080504238605499,
-0.9399566650390625,
0.04059162363409996,
-0.9541712999343872,
0.10298183560371399,
0.08176232129335403,
0.07176116108894348,
1.1252830028533936,
0.3899848163127899,
0.5949918627738953,
-0.19222205877304077,
0.8588769435882568,
0.32124295830726624,
0.7042282223701477,
-0.519848644733429,
0.36804449558258057,
-0.31342536211013794,
0.4514564275741577,
-0.22008633613586426,
-0.9766696691513062,
-0.5694042444229126,
0.3524525761604309,
-0.9809672832489014,
-0.06917424499988556,
0.7470913529396057,
0.933351457118988,
0.2719542980194092,
-0.0038691400550305843,
0.653997540473938,
0.5192685127258301,
0.17109394073486328,
0.4460895359516144,
1.1306259632110596,
-0.2370283454656601,
0.3647037744522095,
-0.1706613451242447,
-0.009087401442229748,
-0.2689931094646454,
-0.8557756543159485,
-1.05911386013031,
-0.2629169523715973,
-0.0050840009935200214,
-0.1851099729537964,
-0.006001295521855354,
0.9519736766815186,
0.5191447734832764,
-0.9750413298606873,
-0.28181055188179016,
-0.020804308354854584,
0.042534567415714264,
0.16413216292858124,
-0.231992706656456,
0.26142871379852295,
-0.37661463022232056,
-0.6553872227668762,
0.3979112505912781,
0.3088703155517578,
-0.027638105675578117,
-0.061102863401174545,
0.18410079181194305,
-0.2919453978538513,
0.029795832931995392,
0.9308173060417175,
0.44050806760787964,
-0.7201775908470154,
-0.389414519071579,
0.31986749172210693,
-0.33140864968299866,
0.1305277794599533,
0.9664193987846375,
-0.8501288294792175,
0.06924672424793243,
0.5789375305175781,
0.5663455128669739,
0.25687694549560547,
0.08761405944824219,
0.6677950024604797,
-0.620568037033081,
0.3468451201915741,
-0.0796244814991951,
0.43221235275268555,
0.1511138677597046,
-0.45783522725105286,
0.290445476770401,
0.41807329654693604,
-0.764815092086792,
-0.8377184271812439,
0.15970729291439056,
-0.8245667815208435,
-0.4543546438217163,
1.6175299882888794,
0.16374272108078003,
-0.19186550378799438,
-0.0966077521443367,
-0.2792063355445862,
0.21898967027664185,
-0.29681187868118286,
0.6003497838973999,
0.8535062670707703,
-0.278469443321228,
-0.15110896527767181,
-1.0963689088821411,
0.16809843480587006,
0.7904762029647827,
-0.3808426558971405,
0.21080781519412994,
0.7507151365280151,
0.3928966522216797,
-0.07853493094444275,
0.5924147963523865,
-0.15494057536125183,
-0.05251682549715042,
-0.26846981048583984,
0.23817305266857147,
0.27036163210868835,
-0.22786849737167358,
-0.7552611231803894,
0.08762040734291077,
0.5459135174751282,
0.011629587039351463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15968v1 | ReCaLL: Membership Inference via Relative Conditional Log-Likelihoods | 2024-06-23T00:23:13 | 2024-06-23T00:23:13 | Roy Xie, Junlin Wang, Ruomin Huang, Minxing Zhang, Rong Ge, Jian Pei, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Bhuwan Dhingra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid scaling of large language models (LLMs) has raised concerns about
the transparency and fair use of the pretraining data used for training them.
Detecting such content is challenging due to the scale of the data and limited
exposure of each instance during training. We propose ReCaLL (Relative
Conditional Log-Likelihood), a novel membership inference attack (MIA) to
detect LLMs' pretraining data by leveraging their conditional language modeling
capabilities. ReCaLL examines the relative change in conditional
log-likelihoods when prefixing target data points with non-member context. Our
empirical findings show that conditioning member data on non-member prefixes
induces a larger decrease in log-likelihood compared to non-member data. We
conduct comprehensive experiments and show that ReCaLL achieves
state-of-the-art performance on the WikiMIA dataset, even with random and
synthetic prefixes, and can be further improved using an ensemble approach.
Moreover, we conduct an in-depth analysis of LLMs' behavior with different
membership contexts, providing insights into how LLMs leverage membership
information for effective inference at both the sequence and token level. | [
-0.25541257858276367,
-0.45084527134895325,
0.29818961024284363,
-0.4062225818634033,
-0.1626708209514618,
-0.005946445744484663,
0.028964458033442497,
-0.33822888135910034,
0.5519687533378601,
0.45069846510887146,
-0.700578510761261,
-0.5970126390457153,
-0.5740352869033813,
0.1049257442355156,
-0.7101679444313049,
0.7369834184646606,
0.34990260004997253,
-0.15321089327335358,
-0.13454264402389526,
-0.32611581683158875,
-0.48702049255371094,
-1.0574227571487427,
-0.6830675601959229,
-0.04016231372952461,
0.7830702066421509,
0.2536313235759735,
0.24902169406414032,
0.14798179268836975,
-0.010447232984006405,
0.31389254331588745,
0.22682227194309235,
-0.1168777197599411,
-0.7966594696044922,
-0.024051466956734657,
-0.000900693004950881,
-1.1534568071365356,
-0.5615625977516174,
0.10543578118085861,
0.9084092974662781,
0.5464116930961609,
0.023437781259417534,
0.0705975741147995,
-0.10886475443840027,
0.6769816279411316,
-0.8532394766807556,
-0.01144462451338768,
-1.2251094579696655,
-0.04091936722397804,
-0.22199808061122894,
-0.26221415400505066,
-0.6721407175064087,
0.04127492010593414,
-0.10559802502393723,
-0.39069458842277527,
0.43584588170051575,
0.21656371653079987,
0.8112947344779968,
0.023974142968654633,
-0.3897377848625183,
0.004696882329881191,
-0.35646533966064453,
0.6800099015235901,
-0.8629856109619141,
0.5756398439407349,
0.993920087814331,
0.19989651441574097,
-0.3796374201774597,
-0.7635972499847412,
-0.778473973274231,
-0.03700751066207886,
-0.45520246028900146,
-0.1448066085577011,
-0.0794377252459526,
0.1406318098306656,
0.42108339071273804,
0.48103106021881104,
-0.43773114681243896,
0.320173054933548,
-0.14483274519443512,
-0.5183425545692444,
0.29420405626296997,
-0.009178713895380497,
0.23002660274505615,
-0.057370252907276154,
-0.1927611380815506,
-0.0011250977404415607,
-1.1285244226455688,
-0.18961988389492035,
0.21982398629188538,
0.4135827422142029,
-0.3371427357196808,
0.5232640504837036,
-0.2563135027885437,
0.40054601430892944,
0.04633359611034393,
-0.21481844782829285,
0.24733661115169525,
-0.2863232493400574,
-0.39534318447113037,
0.04721710458397865,
0.5449277758598328,
0.19501778483390808,
0.12558996677398682,
-0.3555893301963806,
-0.36984875798225403,
0.06324686855077744,
-0.03740577772259712,
-0.6912160515785217,
-0.42834043502807617,
0.02954055555164814,
-0.4859364628791809,
0.07103130966424942,
0.16419346630573273,
-0.5958610773086548,
-0.29483795166015625,
-0.20229363441467285,
0.5893615484237671,
-0.2912861406803131,
-0.22667810320854187,
-0.15778161585330963,
-0.052351076155900955,
0.223335400223732,
0.11911812424659729,
-0.9268655180931091,
0.1300790160894394,
0.7798249125480652,
0.7043021321296692,
0.03303603082895279,
-0.31277990341186523,
-0.8074986934661865,
0.18488311767578125,
-0.24705393612384796,
0.46253690123558044,
-0.6017869710922241,
-0.45550116896629333,
0.09812390804290771,
0.09777485579252243,
-0.21717765927314758,
-0.52372145652771,
0.08903881162405014,
-0.9934412240982056,
0.2692606747150421,
-0.4573592245578766,
-0.9692589044570923,
0.016095150262117386,
0.42952829599380493,
-0.7805836796760559,
0.8457905054092407,
0.21084991097450256,
-0.930026650428772,
0.6326383352279663,
0.14776892960071564,
-0.16343292593955994,
-0.21945792436599731,
-0.3572532832622528,
-0.4892008304595947,
0.3172849714756012,
0.07182839512825012,
0.312362939119339,
-0.0888083279132843,
0.0118484515696764,
-0.4169790744781494,
-0.49682924151420593,
0.3341813385486603,
-0.42125317454338074,
0.5878839492797852,
-0.12418119609355927,
-0.06995349377393723,
0.16033555567264557,
-0.6251563429832458,
-0.27813535928726196,
0.016406258568167686,
-0.3338954448699951,
-0.7450032830238342,
0.21738852560520172,
-0.7017061710357666,
-0.008163731545209885,
0.18284308910369873,
-0.2523234784603119,
0.34174203872680664,
-0.19965936243534088,
-0.07106780260801315,
0.8298460245132446,
0.13882268965244293,
0.46599632501602173,
-0.37734612822532654,
0.4756034016609192,
-0.19205570220947266,
0.020050954073667526,
-0.3530222177505493,
-0.14565391838550568,
-1.0465773344039917,
-0.7282745242118835,
0.5084764957427979,
0.2937447130680084,
-0.9140146374702454,
0.6375840306282043,
-0.42717444896698,
-0.048789191991090775,
-0.1464889943599701,
0.0034173880703747272,
0.3538919985294342,
0.3361419439315796,
0.3029724359512329,
-0.31617090106010437,
-0.6578084826469421,
-0.8427655100822449,
-0.19154927134513855,
-0.6453300714492798,
-0.47371309995651245,
0.09243214875459671,
0.35787928104400635,
-0.10980745404958725,
0.9270914793014526,
-0.2632831335067749,
-0.4133821427822113,
-0.3066020607948303,
0.1427096277475357,
0.3131766617298126,
0.3118407428264618,
0.689852774143219,
-0.6877081394195557,
-0.3191579282283783,
-0.492834210395813,
-0.5503597855567932,
-0.16940651834011078,
-0.2865324914455414,
-0.12058340758085251,
0.26556912064552307,
0.7536483407020569,
-0.6975334882736206,
0.6169784069061279,
0.6201512217521667,
-0.6037487387657166,
0.4894951283931732,
-0.09048758447170258,
0.20390383899211884,
-0.8552030920982361,
0.18522906303405762,
-0.47529739141464233,
-0.4608812630176544,
-0.6662554740905762,
0.037835463881492615,
0.25931423902511597,
0.23743760585784912,
-0.20249158143997192,
0.5479891300201416,
-0.5904961824417114,
-0.1464792788028717,
-0.21148665249347687,
-0.3113141655921936,
-0.23876865208148956,
0.5420911908149719,
0.08364983648061752,
0.8431691527366638,
0.541812002658844,
-0.8256599307060242,
-0.19475407898426056,
0.12267851829528809,
-0.494629830121994,
0.45338115096092224,
-0.045735545456409454,
0.3371902108192444,
-0.14093053340911865,
0.4584123194217682,
-0.9219540953636169,
-0.2645328938961029,
0.23989222943782806,
-0.5573370456695557,
0.5021385550498962,
-0.4810730814933777,
-0.7831239700317383,
-0.18849042057991028,
-0.4225330352783203,
0.33783483505249023,
0.5237277150154114,
-0.6220236420631409,
0.7857645153999329,
0.49287283420562744,
0.03669732064008713,
-0.6551090478897095,
-0.3947155773639679,
0.1179141253232956,
-0.6006722450256348,
0.149600550532341,
0.29656949639320374,
0.045444026589393616,
0.03362993150949478,
-0.1553216278553009,
-0.4909146726131439,
-0.13005612790584564,
0.3332151174545288,
0.18043984472751617,
0.3794321119785309,
-0.13540752232074738,
0.23435916006565094,
-0.3141237199306488,
0.01724301092326641,
0.14823321998119354,
-0.1662263721227646,
0.6826009750366211,
0.18260706961154938,
-0.3697441518306732,
-0.5222705006599426,
0.12519019842147827,
0.5002849102020264,
-0.07904750853776932,
0.9552721381187439,
0.06806192547082901,
-0.5032760500907898,
-0.3342292308807373,
-0.6390168070793152,
-0.6507832407951355,
-0.5178955793380737,
0.40403202176094055,
-0.19261479377746582,
-0.8535894155502319,
0.5312944650650024,
0.028525549918413162,
0.17476041615009308,
0.14552852511405945,
0.3576211929321289,
-0.16236858069896698,
0.5195677876472473,
0.5218138694763184,
-0.8054900169372559,
0.5923103094100952,
-0.14038223028182983,
0.1914084255695343,
-0.3123522996902466,
-0.34902629256248474,
-0.6552877426147461,
-0.5029987692832947,
-0.2706691026687622,
-0.650838315486908,
0.14343136548995972,
0.32958388328552246,
0.0114962849766016,
0.4081616699695587,
0.4026452898979187,
0.6821182370185852,
0.3122917413711548,
-0.04701825976371765,
0.3273268938064575,
0.1596498340368271,
-0.10047924518585205,
0.09011070430278778,
-0.7498700022697449,
-0.3089619278907776,
1.066399335861206,
0.14209109544754028,
0.5963825583457947,
0.2715664505958557,
0.8133711814880371,
0.3159317672252655,
0.6890059113502502,
-0.8396903872489929,
0.7073622345924377,
0.12663781642913818,
-0.7608155608177185,
-0.16215984523296356,
-0.703448474407196,
-0.8646809458732605,
0.37626513838768005,
-0.41583162546157837,
-0.7618213891983032,
0.2487998604774475,
0.4542224407196045,
-0.0730312392115593,
0.5798395872116089,
-0.46674031019210815,
0.5345861911773682,
0.030634703114628792,
0.027859481051564217,
-0.44709253311157227,
-0.6906696557998657,
0.5186702013015747,
-0.5093441605567932,
0.2504041790962219,
-0.25817692279815674,
-0.09417656064033508,
0.6537117958068848,
-0.3124067783355713,
1.3465605974197388,
-0.3346794545650482,
0.10854363441467285,
0.30166885256767273,
0.261618047952652,
0.5120713114738464,
-0.004346017725765705,
-0.14438274502754211,
0.14509636163711548,
-0.10273412615060806,
-0.3471887707710266,
-0.6800764799118042,
0.5988470315933228,
-0.3202821612358093,
-0.6847866177558899,
-0.29931485652923584,
-0.21142259240150452,
-0.5273379683494568,
0.0784607082605362,
0.16172313690185547,
0.26249516010284424,
-0.35599422454833984,
0.3169267177581787,
0.5010831356048584,
-0.0763368308544159,
0.32715728878974915,
0.8067160844802856,
-0.3066292703151703,
-0.09971759468317032,
0.9112944602966309,
-0.10096419602632523,
0.36124274134635925,
0.6587677001953125,
-0.049830660223960876,
-0.21357518434524536,
-0.5730634331703186,
-0.02635348029434681,
0.5003098249435425,
-0.5915737152099609,
-0.44210290908813477,
-0.5143863558769226,
0.0815424919128418,
-0.041569169610738754,
0.2893250584602356,
-0.1920367032289505,
-0.5827308297157288,
-0.19456343352794647,
-0.2344202697277069,
0.2035246044397354,
0.31725218892097473,
0.035638391971588135,
0.5511500239372253,
-0.8352112174034119,
0.2619817554950714,
0.2441631555557251,
0.20002709329128265,
0.14044003188610077,
-0.6673164963722229,
-0.15039414167404175,
-0.23002173006534576,
0.04572342336177826,
-0.8222700357437134,
0.2894282937049866,
0.6444997191429138,
0.7230595350265503,
0.6956344246864319,
0.30108314752578735,
0.39556023478507996,
-0.52325040102005,
0.6519967317581177,
0.19211092591285706,
-0.8598111271858215,
0.2027786374092102,
0.07646314054727554,
0.19542820751667023,
0.8304253220558167,
0.6386210322380066,
-0.5612404346466064,
-0.4809110760688782,
-0.6709822416305542,
-0.7658974528312683,
0.6435842514038086,
0.26974767446517944,
0.3616914749145508,
-0.32707980275154114,
0.584981381893158,
-0.00238042208366096,
0.1439472734928131,
-0.7484330534934998,
-0.3857933580875397,
0.20272448658943176,
-0.031815141439437866,
-0.1017785519361496,
-0.4453379511833191,
0.10365275293588638,
-0.1169452965259552,
0.6239460110664368,
-0.07865218818187714,
0.3000873029232025,
-0.024925801903009415,
-0.2807154655456543,
0.3487992584705353,
-0.038683176040649414,
0.0811757817864418,
0.6556936502456665,
-0.2314448207616806,
0.445495069026947,
0.4527107775211334,
-0.19089344143867493,
0.07541239261627197,
-0.40364202857017517,
0.017078902572393417,
0.1569705307483673,
0.971541166305542,
0.5813208818435669,
0.34870022535324097,
-0.7412573099136353,
0.6235846877098083,
-0.22685928642749786,
-0.03502171114087105,
-0.24931283295154572,
0.13471092283725739,
0.16898250579833984,
-0.08958044648170471,
0.38024264574050903,
-0.25938358902931213,
-0.09937109798192978,
-0.8758529424667358,
0.5337589383125305,
0.48013779520988464,
-0.3632645905017853,
-0.7448982000350952,
0.31041422486305237,
-0.0797019749879837,
-0.04787653684616089,
0.7804526090621948,
0.12732185423374176,
-0.7291741967201233,
0.535544216632843,
0.4700753390789032,
0.5360786318778992,
-0.5649774074554443,
-0.1398477554321289,
0.5960492491722107,
0.26834172010421753,
0.1353810876607895,
0.052184320986270905,
-0.2591446042060852,
-0.8620482087135315,
-0.27123376727104187,
-0.5308318734169006,
0.007399456575512886,
0.40404513478279114,
-0.7445821762084961,
0.23642991483211517,
-0.5224159359931946,
-0.28054752945899963,
-0.32402053475379944,
-0.35657045245170593,
-0.46658867597579956,
0.17009304463863373,
0.1560659408569336,
1.029290795326233,
-0.9119101166725159,
1.3267914056777954,
0.02114933915436268,
-0.0029240353032946587,
-0.6130979061126709,
0.3324142098426819,
0.35506364703178406,
-0.8581699132919312,
0.6767946481704712,
0.37823379039764404,
-0.09054265916347504,
-0.2125050574541092,
-0.30570459365844727,
-0.5329419374465942,
0.8655816912651062,
0.43107184767723083,
-0.7619697451591492,
-0.2231850028038025,
-0.05818428844213486,
0.28278863430023193,
-0.14701008796691895,
-0.09129848331212997,
0.8107056617736816,
0.21064817905426025,
0.07945031672716141,
-0.7087737321853638,
0.06730663031339645,
0.06690012663602829,
-0.4347139596939087,
0.38789960741996765,
-0.3038097620010376,
0.6798750162124634,
-0.06191672012209892,
-0.5234420299530029,
0.15712156891822815,
1.0108075141906738,
0.2631852328777313,
0.15730644762516022,
0.9368727803230286,
0.3896162211894989,
1.10221529006958,
0.26023921370506287,
1.14552640914917,
-0.09453388303518295,
0.26227203011512756,
1.3325387239456177,
-0.23249709606170654,
0.9794502854347229,
0.506386935710907,
-0.17313697934150696,
0.28634825348854065,
0.49728456139564514,
0.3187025487422943,
0.7675862908363342,
0.2110077440738678,
-0.756617546081543,
-0.4504002034664154,
0.17283044755458832,
-0.3709084093570709,
0.37184223532676697,
0.6549625396728516,
-0.4253060817718506,
0.008838968351483345,
-0.3714178204536438,
0.09266240149736404,
-0.2051084190607071,
-0.31975436210632324,
0.9062005281448364,
0.4101698100566864,
-0.514163613319397,
0.6931904554367065,
-0.012180310674011707,
0.6055481433868408,
-1.0040547847747803,
0.04102027043700218,
-0.6500149369239807,
0.05251672863960266,
0.005464698653668165,
-0.018414445221424103,
0.3388209939002991,
0.02333665080368519,
-0.08683901280164719,
0.14679156243801117,
0.45872217416763306,
-0.4505590796470642,
-0.28609880805015564,
0.5054524540901184,
0.2744142711162567,
0.15832337737083435,
-0.0786634087562561,
-0.3136867880821228,
0.040346451103687286,
0.10034524649381638,
-0.15087689459323883,
0.6456816792488098,
0.32126033306121826,
-0.31827443838119507,
0.6346017718315125,
0.507643461227417,
0.10342112183570862,
0.10314816236495972,
0.13299430906772614,
0.9694647789001465,
-0.49717527627944946,
-0.4188574552536011,
-0.9490181803703308,
0.02713087573647499,
-0.0942433699965477,
0.0020182053558528423,
0.8056839108467102,
0.6425386071205139,
0.9858255982398987,
-0.07643190771341324,
0.5560788512229919,
0.03724997118115425,
0.31088295578956604,
-1.1062030792236328,
0.8679481148719788,
-0.5374134182929993,
0.49176785349845886,
0.10727602243423462,
-0.8686873316764832,
-0.4187804162502289,
0.5136213898658752,
-0.135842427611351,
-0.06826792657375336,
0.6509597897529602,
1.1280620098114014,
-0.27206045389175415,
-0.08102313429117203,
0.5330381393432617,
0.30467790365219116,
0.4245740473270416,
0.40492478013038635,
0.9323000311851501,
-0.1350986361503601,
0.3222840428352356,
0.06779205799102783,
-0.2163023054599762,
-0.1434476524591446,
-1.0617033243179321,
-1.3005017042160034,
-0.5307542681694031,
-0.1709987372159958,
-0.3099052309989929,
-0.053973376750946045,
0.9644421339035034,
0.8635997176170349,
-1.0632878541946411,
-0.12634488940238953,
0.19261839985847473,
0.04807828739285469,
0.1374659389257431,
-0.11723462492227554,
0.5099042057991028,
-0.2827948033809662,
-0.601675271987915,
0.8155844211578369,
-0.16518163681030273,
0.06927785277366638,
0.08870323747396469,
-0.16474997997283936,
-0.20405307412147522,
0.16537167131900787,
0.4306837320327759,
0.4991256296634674,
-0.7061002254486084,
-0.4709002375602722,
-0.44637295603752136,
0.024310806766152382,
-0.0027699077036231756,
1.1220899820327759,
-0.9211306571960449,
0.2681947350502014,
0.5350181460380554,
0.6779487729072571,
0.568146824836731,
0.009717319160699844,
0.6641750335693359,
-1.1498209238052368,
0.4653300642967224,
0.07399559020996094,
0.5891260504722595,
0.2778395414352417,
-0.16120381653308868,
0.2784474790096283,
0.39320406317710876,
-0.08448780328035355,
-0.783725380897522,
0.21045881509780884,
-0.6123450398445129,
-0.47079038619995117,
0.6807945966720581,
-0.49114030599594116,
0.01775491051375866,
-0.09643413126468658,
0.0007016698946245015,
0.14698699116706848,
-0.1291646808385849,
0.7898030877113342,
0.4739892780780792,
0.39193370938301086,
-0.0391056202352047,
-0.5403914451599121,
0.5640217065811157,
0.5112049579620361,
-0.7511715888977051,
0.19953091442584991,
0.6779846549034119,
0.4815252125263214,
-0.27815601229667664,
0.8831791281700134,
0.0178444255143404,
0.014156224206089973,
-0.10437191277742386,
-0.22080442309379578,
0.18807047605514526,
-0.6291751265525818,
-0.2167801707983017,
0.07741755247116089,
0.19905529916286469,
-0.07171671837568283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15966v1 | Evaluating the Effectiveness of the Foundational Models for Q&A Classification in Mental Health care | 2024-06-23T00:11:07 | 2024-06-23T00:11:07 | Hassan Alhuzali, Ashwag Alasmari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) have the potential to transform mental
health support by providing accessible and culturally sensitive resources.
However, despite this potential, their effectiveness in mental health care and
specifically for the Arabic language has not been extensively explored. To
bridge this gap, this study evaluates the effectiveness of foundational models
for classification of Questions and Answers (Q&A) in the domain of mental
health care. We leverage the MentalQA dataset, an Arabic collection featuring
Q&A interactions related to mental health. In this study, we conducted
experiments using four different types of learning approaches: traditional
feature extraction, PLMs as feature extractors, Fine-tuning PLMs and prompting
large language models (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) in zero-shot and few-shot learning
settings. While traditional feature extractors combined with Support Vector
Machines (SVM) showed promising performance, PLMs exhibited even better results
due to their ability to capture semantic meaning. For example, MARBERT achieved
the highest performance with a Jaccard Score of 0.80 for question
classification and a Jaccard Score of 0.86 for answer classification. We
further conducted an in-depth analysis including examining the effects of
fine-tuning versus non-fine-tuning, the impact of varying data size, and
conducting error analysis. Our analysis demonstrates that fine-tuning proved to
be beneficial for enhancing the performance of PLMs, and the size of the
training data played a crucial role in achieving high performance. We also
explored prompting, where few-shot learning with GPT-3.5 yielded promising
results. There was an improvement of 12% for question and classification and
45% for answer classification. Based on our findings, it can be concluded that
PLMs and prompt-based approaches hold promise for mental health support in
Arabic. | [
-0.7916790843009949,
-0.8661454916000366,
0.619016170501709,
-0.11158817261457443,
-0.22965669631958008,
-0.005898272152990103,
-0.13968129456043243,
-0.3654825985431671,
-0.29313597083091736,
0.38068103790283203,
-0.5098080635070801,
-0.6722156405448914,
-0.8203354477882385,
0.10000714659690857,
-0.34029144048690796,
1.1666972637176514,
-0.1054127961397171,
0.20152321457862854,
0.09736531227827072,
-0.21795430779457092,
-0.548871636390686,
-0.6262516379356384,
-0.9532796144485474,
-0.21122173964977264,
0.6091396808624268,
0.43146997690200806,
0.8473464846611023,
0.30948564410209656,
0.4325051009654999,
0.2021530568599701,
0.0009324833517894149,
0.33476272225379944,
-0.22475050389766693,
0.022167561575770378,
-0.16068165004253387,
-0.47545742988586426,
-0.18632064759731293,
0.14162160456180573,
0.23114989697933197,
0.5188575387001038,
-0.3709263801574707,
0.3666885197162628,
-0.06601782143115997,
0.5530476570129395,
-0.707981288433075,
0.09948509186506271,
-0.2961251139640808,
0.005593874957412481,
0.1373530626296997,
0.029352620244026184,
-0.08531702309846878,
-0.7530877590179443,
0.3263576924800873,
-0.10050927102565765,
0.11343064904212952,
-0.27694231271743774,
0.7829183340072632,
0.2741834819316864,
-0.46382954716682434,
-0.5607492327690125,
-0.6220629811286926,
0.6152669191360474,
-0.8049089312553406,
0.14914655685424805,
0.5855238437652588,
0.47851991653442383,
0.07832644879817963,
-0.5789893865585327,
-0.5352348685264587,
0.059034667909145355,
-0.12608078122138977,
0.03900780528783798,
-0.29815784096717834,
0.1969843953847885,
0.580845057964325,
0.3684464395046234,
-0.5472037196159363,
0.01941758021712303,
-0.32004648447036743,
-0.10118269920349121,
0.5718418955802917,
0.2659403085708618,
0.5212132334709167,
-0.039242710918188095,
0.010135483928024769,
-0.13993704319000244,
-0.46548521518707275,
0.6304016709327698,
-0.3456895053386688,
0.11308666318655014,
-0.12881386280059814,
0.4653056561946869,
-0.27298012375831604,
0.4720439612865448,
0.11746902018785477,
-0.550746738910675,
-0.005377393215894699,
-0.02506847307085991,
-0.1964675635099411,
-0.06880218535661697,
0.5035114288330078,
0.21409471333026886,
0.33203792572021484,
-0.16076982021331787,
-0.1387089639902115,
0.24605734646320343,
0.30559614300727844,
-0.9754419922828674,
-0.14031465351581573,
0.2651302218437195,
-0.412549763917923,
0.1288415938615799,
0.09955157339572906,
-0.2774374485015869,
-0.36487823724746704,
-0.37361687421798706,
0.4511629343032837,
-0.6560313701629639,
-0.23683008551597595,
0.41707146167755127,
0.10454769432544708,
0.4086973965167999,
0.6978139281272888,
-0.5504235625267029,
0.22573262453079224,
0.4264308512210846,
0.6976020336151123,
-0.1476929783821106,
0.1586570143699646,
-0.28634294867515564,
-0.18600419163703918,
-0.2793996036052704,
0.6767767071723938,
-0.3539394438266754,
-0.44501370191574097,
0.1125045046210289,
-0.20446021854877472,
-0.2589245140552521,
-0.7151552438735962,
0.4105337858200073,
-0.6957794427871704,
0.2916693687438965,
-0.5032139420509338,
-0.4406678378582001,
-0.4356534779071808,
0.36037760972976685,
-0.4780155420303345,
0.5923109650611877,
0.3219771087169647,
-0.8761134147644043,
0.30575835704803467,
-0.6830955743789673,
-0.38084352016448975,
0.1328016221523285,
-0.2902231812477112,
-0.3902578353881836,
0.05748124420642853,
0.46395009756088257,
0.5433245897293091,
-0.3655369281768799,
0.11727763712406158,
-0.14393308758735657,
-0.5962290167808533,
0.5790289640426636,
-0.3446934223175049,
0.7030153274536133,
0.2531050741672516,
-0.4077450931072235,
0.00795082375407219,
-0.494415819644928,
0.2486667037010193,
-0.09163958579301834,
-0.33577224612236023,
-0.14968501031398773,
-0.12078187614679337,
-0.13264678418636322,
0.683339536190033,
-0.017327522858977318,
-0.39971232414245605,
-0.059649109840393066,
-0.48984959721565247,
0.16936933994293213,
0.23864498734474182,
0.41167834401130676,
0.06320185959339142,
-0.7575877904891968,
0.9524378180503845,
0.05302657186985016,
0.15488290786743164,
-0.00519935879856348,
-0.45547226071357727,
-0.5877960324287415,
-0.625119686126709,
0.11871007829904556,
0.6629552841186523,
-0.8787376284599304,
0.29539623856544495,
-0.008173911832273006,
-0.5066949725151062,
-0.7406454682350159,
0.08931871503591537,
0.38119491934776306,
0.6001185178756714,
0.4902876317501068,
-0.3616825342178345,
-0.3049474358558655,
-0.745551586151123,
0.026414645835757256,
-0.35496291518211365,
-0.005812749266624451,
0.4304827153682709,
0.36066606640815735,
-0.28519734740257263,
0.8915378451347351,
-0.3697589337825775,
0.030365530401468277,
-0.27590158581733704,
0.501175582408905,
0.09115791320800781,
0.19971397519111633,
0.497175008058548,
-0.7078865170478821,
-0.5863935947418213,
-0.08175467699766159,
-0.6639028191566467,
-0.09668517112731934,
0.3676794767379761,
-0.013819670304656029,
-0.0428759939968586,
-0.02430558390915394,
-0.6447584629058838,
0.7009986639022827,
0.029768511652946472,
-0.10327575355768204,
0.5533360242843628,
0.18944500386714935,
0.2807309329509735,
-0.8802238702774048,
0.11006414890289307,
-0.14033347368240356,
-0.16805581748485565,
-0.6715978384017944,
-0.1543329507112503,
0.009104120545089245,
-0.16416382789611816,
-0.5475924015045166,
0.3407192528247833,
-0.030143216252326965,
0.2260608822107315,
-0.5105066895484924,
-0.36955103278160095,
-0.20400488376617432,
0.43085095286369324,
0.056359026581048965,
0.9637001156806946,
0.4560895562171936,
-0.5708125233650208,
0.29734092950820923,
0.2658091187477112,
-0.45624420046806335,
0.5879294276237488,
-0.6016368865966797,
0.27322396636009216,
-0.3876444697380066,
-0.042425788938999176,
-1.113694190979004,
-0.049474675208330154,
0.24335424602031708,
-0.41479790210723877,
0.1893893927335739,
0.19027982652187347,
-0.4641719162464142,
-0.2695799767971039,
-0.16122698783874512,
0.28817880153656006,
0.5535112619400024,
-0.13114088773727417,
0.2452353686094284,
0.2189801037311554,
-0.4350690245628357,
-0.46808406710624695,
-0.09998757392168045,
-0.3812071681022644,
-0.4876641631126404,
-0.20398826897144318,
0.05196518078446388,
-0.001554498914629221,
-0.17687232792377472,
-0.04670346528291702,
-0.2940133213996887,
-0.068837471306324,
0.3772909939289093,
0.5042627453804016,
0.15678770840168,
-0.37196919322013855,
0.4736233651638031,
0.20500688254833221,
0.03710062429308891,
0.17928147315979004,
0.01583709381520748,
0.5744962692260742,
-0.41609546542167664,
-0.21523705124855042,
-0.5544533729553223,
0.5079984664916992,
0.714297890663147,
-0.5494329929351807,
1.0491807460784912,
0.6730233430862427,
-0.4969612658023834,
-0.008753004483878613,
-0.6940014958381653,
-0.3407711088657379,
-0.36154040694236755,
0.3631521463394165,
-0.38154858350753784,
-1.158658742904663,
0.3188942074775696,
-0.20944391191005707,
0.014691084623336792,
0.27684566378593445,
0.44843143224716187,
-0.4246213436126709,
1.5420368909835815,
0.6313234567642212,
-0.23605535924434662,
0.2929054796695709,
-0.2876765727996826,
0.15046635270118713,
-0.5355948209762573,
-0.024463919922709465,
-0.521661639213562,
-0.20670004189014435,
-0.4569987654685974,
-0.1683821678161621,
0.6766744256019592,
0.5320512652397156,
-0.5369433164596558,
-0.06503021717071533,
-0.1313648819923401,
-0.08465111255645752,
0.13319316506385803,
0.38868093490600586,
0.09323997795581818,
0.12851671874523163,
-0.19623859226703644,
-0.12088432163000107,
-0.7118440866470337,
-0.7038673162460327,
0.8969191908836365,
0.5640996694564819,
0.5687598586082458,
0.22019550204277039,
0.56065833568573,
0.30630195140838623,
0.8417151570320129,
-0.9103882908821106,
0.38772353529930115,
-0.006448851432651281,
-0.48261964321136475,
-0.45192018151283264,
-0.25735560059547424,
-0.7578840851783752,
0.2550453245639801,
-0.3444194495677948,
-0.5770729184150696,
0.08596306294202805,
-0.2114567905664444,
-0.704862117767334,
0.015637710690498352,
-0.4996985197067261,
0.6756731271743774,
-0.4266316592693329,
0.06392539292573929,
-0.21293829381465912,
-0.5688354969024658,
0.2089277058839798,
-0.2007094770669937,
0.13087955117225647,
-0.3263564109802246,
0.1300889104604721,
0.7840037941932678,
-0.23945555090904236,
0.6028152108192444,
-0.21061921119689941,
-0.02163759618997574,
0.28990626335144043,
-0.1541147381067276,
-0.1162906140089035,
0.1886417716741562,
-0.061454709619283676,
-0.12698662281036377,
0.499935507774353,
-0.5137612819671631,
-1.0355831384658813,
0.2211035043001175,
-1.1246159076690674,
-0.8438487648963928,
-0.31520798802375793,
-0.5609416961669922,
-0.6984728574752808,
0.05157644674181938,
0.1562599539756775,
0.3718827962875366,
0.05890784412622452,
0.16272899508476257,
0.8146222233772278,
-0.28266236186027527,
0.08807680010795593,
0.989474892616272,
-0.34534987807273865,
-0.2796890437602997,
0.5100589990615845,
0.22195395827293396,
-0.031093791127204895,
0.16493989527225494,
0.043888919055461884,
-0.36914777755737305,
-0.6413623094558716,
-0.24563559889793396,
0.5065820813179016,
-0.6251190900802612,
-0.31830883026123047,
-0.4988338053226471,
-0.7318193912506104,
-0.43051332235336304,
0.13287432491779327,
0.0796157494187355,
-0.10536166280508041,
-0.2184111773967743,
-0.29461076855659485,
0.3369743824005127,
0.6745738387107849,
0.21405379474163055,
0.41240209341049194,
-0.8386383056640625,
0.1545228511095047,
0.5664557218551636,
0.12152450531721115,
0.20649200677871704,
-0.5517134666442871,
-0.4354105591773987,
0.048620641231536865,
-0.38119199872016907,
-1.3084272146224976,
0.2969517409801483,
0.2051115483045578,
0.5019247531890869,
0.6432125568389893,
0.23123957216739655,
0.7375591993331909,
-0.30352795124053955,
0.3984643220901489,
0.10568436980247498,
-0.6151081323623657,
0.8045855760574341,
0.007983473129570484,
0.421631395816803,
0.8288084864616394,
1.0028884410858154,
-0.5946595668792725,
-0.20617567002773285,
-0.41825756430625916,
-0.5080467462539673,
0.7529860138893127,
0.027122845873236656,
0.06718116253614426,
-0.2422901690006256,
0.7290846705436707,
0.08577939867973328,
0.49542248249053955,
-0.34234848618507385,
-0.3569723665714264,
-0.02148105949163437,
-0.3494669198989868,
-0.10097953677177429,
-0.3014879524707794,
-0.1362563520669937,
-0.2530190944671631,
0.6065905690193176,
-0.10445892065763474,
0.14777734875679016,
0.25993603467941284,
-0.18366840481758118,
-0.11983312666416168,
0.6126266121864319,
0.22250819206237793,
0.8243035674095154,
-0.3175763785839081,
0.19506895542144775,
0.23273825645446777,
-0.44684672355651855,
0.33592134714126587,
0.08103788644075394,
-0.21914523839950562,
-0.12465424090623856,
0.23552468419075012,
0.8061984181404114,
-0.12065576761960983,
-0.8701618909835815,
0.3928312063217163,
-0.1999785304069519,
0.05009934678673744,
0.05977833271026611,
0.39534837007522583,
-0.15150438249111176,
0.31685033440589905,
0.24591681361198425,
-0.33444249629974365,
0.23165538907051086,
-0.5851545333862305,
0.24658894538879395,
0.5301936268806458,
-0.5193398594856262,
-0.22172366082668304,
0.12246537953615189,
-0.3049272298812866,
-0.2199939489364624,
0.6293060779571533,
-0.02971348725259304,
-0.5975223183631897,
0.3280881345272064,
0.4574727416038513,
0.4947407841682434,
-0.507196307182312,
0.5792374014854431,
0.2836061120033264,
0.11511825025081635,
0.052921973168849945,
0.6486244797706604,
-0.2806907296180725,
-0.915466845035553,
-0.1649174988269806,
-0.6454174518585205,
-0.35724401473999023,
0.4020044803619385,
-1.0710196495056152,
-0.03939579054713249,
-0.6877045035362244,
-0.5676757097244263,
-0.0851503536105156,
0.29832980036735535,
-0.8612351417541504,
0.6366440653800964,
0.2994813024997711,
0.9280850887298584,
-0.910918116569519,
0.8609535694122314,
1.213224172592163,
-0.6779090762138367,
-1.033040165901184,
-0.0012532214168459177,
-0.2296164333820343,
-0.6248083710670471,
0.4699491858482361,
0.31050339341163635,
-0.07238716632127762,
0.1145792081952095,
-0.553737223148346,
-0.7879574298858643,
1.0098260641098022,
0.2680506706237793,
-0.04828803986310959,
-0.1455920785665512,
0.2679087519645691,
0.745940089225769,
-0.3928522765636444,
0.41977787017822266,
0.69209223985672,
0.09713080525398254,
0.13553297519683838,
-0.9377592206001282,
-0.054247383028268814,
-0.335787832736969,
0.19192807376384735,
-0.07664148509502411,
-0.24586986005306244,
0.6725429892539978,
-0.07011952251195908,
-0.553777813911438,
0.16358178853988647,
0.6067088842391968,
0.47935834527015686,
0.2774004638195038,
0.39143580198287964,
0.4984348714351654,
0.857115626335144,
-0.06727390736341476,
0.7602424025535583,
-0.328742653131485,
0.20725060999393463,
0.7108380794525146,
-0.39230212569236755,
0.9626703262329102,
0.17630332708358765,
-0.42855826020240784,
0.6312748789787292,
0.6886441111564636,
0.3485102951526642,
0.6295146346092224,
0.2945843040943146,
-0.398573637008667,
-0.2229669690132141,
-0.36395248770713806,
-0.4224809408187866,
0.24170733988285065,
0.681159257888794,
-0.18826372921466827,
-0.20469383895397186,
0.4021664559841156,
0.04631476104259491,
-0.007907014340162277,
-0.48767927289009094,
0.8652359247207642,
0.3143960237503052,
-0.5364934206008911,
0.6428520679473877,
0.36327746510505676,
0.4404349625110626,
-0.5160556435585022,
-0.03359417989850044,
-0.237428680062294,
-0.14076432585716248,
-0.14183416962623596,
-0.49714329838752747,
0.20166237652301788,
0.14082199335098267,
-0.39601457118988037,
0.007872276939451694,
0.8540642261505127,
-0.3495664596557617,
-0.4458828568458557,
-0.02573738619685173,
0.8921688199043274,
0.11596209555864334,
-0.16056473553180695,
-0.7569320797920227,
-0.394279807806015,
-0.25227171182632446,
0.1044553741812706,
0.4865356981754303,
0.33755022287368774,
-0.2946009933948517,
0.5444544553756714,
0.5378236770629883,
0.2666413486003876,
-0.05975831300020218,
-0.10696232318878174,
0.7418549656867981,
-0.6322445273399353,
-0.36905142664909363,
-0.5901814699172974,
0.3062015473842621,
0.2601456344127655,
-0.24963602423667908,
0.7221702337265015,
0.1882127970457077,
0.6315133571624756,
-0.023586072027683258,
0.8630682826042175,
0.26854926347732544,
0.8484704494476318,
-0.4011267423629761,
0.7392081022262573,
-0.33407050371170044,
0.13155212998390198,
0.035458583384752274,
-0.506913959980011,
-0.11898572742938995,
0.8207565546035767,
-0.8537135124206543,
0.12305425852537155,
0.47331252694129944,
0.5002182722091675,
0.29091665148735046,
0.2926170229911804,
0.3561379313468933,
0.06855785101652145,
0.1702471524477005,
0.7204787135124207,
1.1967710256576538,
-0.23068825900554657,
0.01258079707622528,
-0.3705049455165863,
-0.25446343421936035,
0.08901441097259521,
-0.21438679099082947,
-1.0360199213027954,
-0.31501802802085876,
-0.38008004426956177,
-0.2526886761188507,
0.2941851019859314,
1.1558464765548706,
0.7135958075523376,
-1.1612792015075684,
-0.2509234547615051,
0.2812836170196533,
-0.07014912366867065,
-0.26389968395233154,
-0.16792261600494385,
0.5676823854446411,
-0.28855282068252563,
-0.20557433366775513,
-0.08773159980773926,
0.2229880839586258,
0.14097170531749725,
-0.14471612870693207,
-0.01959681138396263,
-0.039495598524808884,
0.012114443816244602,
0.689870297908783,
0.29211121797561646,
-0.8112271428108215,
-0.021361207589507103,
0.18075817823410034,
-0.3497539460659027,
-0.03621953725814819,
0.649339497089386,
-0.9042874574661255,
0.23498401045799255,
0.1363016813993454,
0.9387534260749817,
0.21581417322158813,
0.30523064732551575,
0.3783256709575653,
-0.2744375169277191,
-0.23063506186008453,
0.40663111209869385,
0.17383280396461487,
0.14341780543327332,
-0.2311229109764099,
0.1433066874742508,
-0.04612547904253006,
-0.2805314064025879,
-0.5020872354507446,
0.1485772430896759,
-0.5462756752967834,
-0.17401517927646637,
1.0022921562194824,
-0.5430309176445007,
0.11589150875806808,
-0.40716293454170227,
-0.6684193015098572,
0.386945515871048,
-0.1553804725408554,
1.085789442062378,
0.892521858215332,
-0.4630337059497833,
-0.5700968503952026,
-0.5489658713340759,
0.642260730266571,
0.6346866488456726,
-0.7942995429039001,
-0.6429633498191833,
0.3419349193572998,
0.35129493474960327,
-0.05100676044821739,
0.6220278143882751,
-0.2078622579574585,
0.6226903200149536,
-0.898133397102356,
-0.1875290423631668,
0.11314715445041656,
-0.20251081883907318,
-0.6363070607185364,
0.4178358316421509,
0.4645985960960388,
0.0373711995780468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15963v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15963v1 | Effectiveness of ChatGPT in explaining complex medical reports to patients | 2024-06-23T00:04:07 | 2024-06-23T00:04:07 | Mengxuan Sun, Ehud Reiter, Anne E Kiltie, George Ramsay, Lisa Duncan, Peter Murchie, Rosalind Adam | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, q-bio.OT | Electronic health records contain detailed information about the medical
condition of patients, but they are difficult for patients to understand even
if they have access to them. We explore whether ChatGPT (GPT 4) can help
explain multidisciplinary team (MDT) reports to colorectal and prostate cancer
patients. These reports are written in dense medical language and assume
clinical knowledge, so they are a good test of the ability of ChatGPT to
explain complex medical reports to patients. We asked clinicians and lay people
(not patients) to review explanations and responses of ChatGPT. We also ran
three focus groups (including cancer patients, caregivers, computer scientists,
and clinicians) to discuss output of ChatGPT. Our studies highlighted issues
with inaccurate information, inappropriate language, limited personalization,
AI distrust, and challenges integrating large language models (LLMs) into
clinical workflow. These issues will need to be resolved before LLMs can be
used to explain complex personal medical information to patients. | [
-0.06911665201187134,
-0.6314563155174255,
0.9686902165412903,
0.20387330651283264,
-0.39149531722068787,
0.3389231860637665,
-0.17474265396595,
-0.6156715750694275,
0.10019373893737793,
0.19550932943820953,
-0.5407262444496155,
-0.37433868646621704,
-1.08634352684021,
0.11383805423974991,
-0.10502057522535324,
1.4093762636184692,
-0.20024646818637848,
0.48644116520881653,
0.29629814624786377,
-0.04252805560827255,
-0.6055492162704468,
-0.5710829496383667,
-0.7835968732833862,
-0.3740232586860657,
0.5874263048171997,
0.4343847632408142,
0.7729083895683289,
0.267196387052536,
1.0530614852905273,
0.2604575753211975,
0.1381223350763321,
0.06679367274045944,
-0.7193520665168762,
0.26294392347335815,
0.052452508360147476,
-0.6344837546348572,
-0.3825431168079376,
-0.15199312567710876,
0.1390630453824997,
0.9302424788475037,
-0.29961931705474854,
-0.1942899227142334,
0.12185131758451462,
0.810295820236206,
-0.1333494782447815,
0.4777674973011017,
-0.21706078946590424,
0.42684853076934814,
-0.27247679233551025,
-0.5190647840499878,
-0.2707451283931732,
-0.5004032850265503,
0.4380795955657959,
-0.5648453235626221,
0.3935287296772003,
0.014652994461357594,
0.6104908585548401,
0.07272666692733765,
-0.7460505366325378,
-0.6208057403564453,
-1.2145801782608032,
0.24874377250671387,
-0.5743491053581238,
0.13923290371894836,
0.2581098973751068,
0.7073671817779541,
-0.15995213389396667,
-0.8072828650474548,
-0.4020902216434479,
-0.012102251872420311,
-0.31700870394706726,
0.7518768310546875,
-0.09365171194076538,
0.5445941686630249,
0.2500496804714203,
0.5955285429954529,
-0.788008987903595,
-0.177889883518219,
-0.645461916923523,
-0.16313211619853973,
0.3907182812690735,
0.4857812523841858,
0.513098418712616,
0.056513428688049316,
-0.24187278747558594,
0.31168800592422485,
-0.4945715069770813,
-0.048629261553287506,
-0.13256660103797913,
0.160122811794281,
-0.11216677725315094,
0.7402626276016235,
-0.058935701847076416,
0.47120723128318787,
0.10112643986940384,
-0.35329991579055786,
0.14959639310836792,
-0.4994986057281494,
-0.1847318410873413,
0.18822821974754333,
0.8257074356079102,
0.5813202857971191,
0.16129346191883087,
-0.24166621267795563,
0.212599515914917,
0.21685074269771576,
0.2325965166091919,
-0.9056926965713501,
-0.6213099360466003,
0.6976789832115173,
-0.6923454403877258,
0.004617602098733187,
-0.014279906637966633,
-0.8152282238006592,
-0.717025876045227,
-0.12455671280622482,
0.36274704337120056,
-0.627166211605072,
-0.3340466618537903,
0.3881329298019409,
-0.16213646531105042,
0.025526264682412148,
0.6600567102432251,
-0.8628170490264893,
0.27008044719696045,
0.47403544187545776,
0.7391374707221985,
-0.0030573157127946615,
-0.03654129058122635,
-0.35477113723754883,
0.27017074823379517,
0.06996741145849228,
0.9708148241043091,
-0.474200040102005,
-0.3406446576118469,
0.01763121224939823,
-0.04345083236694336,
-0.5635951161384583,
-0.3738654553890228,
0.384562224149704,
0.10359672456979752,
0.3886299729347229,
-0.437544047832489,
-0.5600680708885193,
-0.16306596994400024,
0.34602752327919006,
-0.3772953748703003,
0.26983606815338135,
0.12175889313220978,
-0.8231391310691833,
0.4113439619541168,
-0.6939030885696411,
-0.32927843928337097,
0.22201374173164368,
-0.4733336865901947,
-0.36695417761802673,
-0.11737069487571716,
0.11669476330280304,
0.6228103041648865,
-0.19110698997974396,
0.24235935509204865,
0.06717196106910706,
-0.26058492064476013,
0.20526044070720673,
-0.08554458618164062,
0.362288236618042,
0.5197502374649048,
-0.32707902789115906,
-0.032528314739465714,
-0.17353826761245728,
-0.2561265230178833,
0.24356113374233246,
-0.4360795021057129,
0.06593114882707596,
0.08517550677061081,
-0.16809244453907013,
0.24974191188812256,
-0.09135564416646957,
-0.498684287071228,
0.26602014899253845,
-0.04243034869432449,
0.46379175782203674,
0.21619100868701935,
0.186943918466568,
-0.021733487024903297,
-0.6371137499809265,
0.8913446068763733,
0.10813837498426437,
0.27216842770576477,
-0.43322476744651794,
-0.8740563988685608,
-0.14818917214870453,
-0.29406335949897766,
0.0957086905837059,
0.5950838327407837,
-0.5713586807250977,
-0.3447316586971283,
-0.14157818257808685,
-0.43971917033195496,
-0.4098406136035919,
-0.328533798456192,
0.44989830255508423,
0.7135747671127319,
0.19560997188091278,
-0.49730920791625977,
-0.2973030209541321,
-0.9559630751609802,
-0.31843438744544983,
-0.21179451048374176,
-0.21886283159255981,
0.6398211717605591,
0.28260138630867004,
-0.27648046612739563,
0.44985032081604004,
-0.4541700482368469,
-0.2930961847305298,
-0.4534215033054352,
0.25349676609039307,
0.019470350816845894,
0.11245983839035034,
0.15118010342121124,
-0.807685375213623,
-0.5285073518753052,
0.28719356656074524,
-0.591682493686676,
-0.037909526377916336,
-0.22961647808551788,
0.17245972156524658,
-0.4118025302886963,
0.0911727100610733,
-0.4626622796058655,
0.25411030650138855,
0.5872717499732971,
-0.5487450361251831,
0.4836299419403076,
-0.48478177189826965,
0.5374563932418823,
-0.8062970638275146,
0.09774031490087509,
0.022730598226189613,
-0.6109310984611511,
-0.8267750144004822,
-0.3514159917831421,
-0.11953182518482208,
-0.32697251439094543,
-0.15082214772701263,
-0.10795865207910538,
-0.3941064178943634,
0.11813222616910934,
0.05600005388259888,
0.23238486051559448,
-0.020935218781232834,
0.360172837972641,
-0.04859470576047897,
0.5306075811386108,
0.16449929773807526,
-0.33057311177253723,
0.21063846349716187,
0.24438342452049255,
-0.07185331732034683,
0.7667193412780762,
-0.5529374480247498,
-0.11237522959709167,
-0.2700749635696411,
0.32844018936157227,
-1.1899387836456299,
-0.4036981463432312,
0.34585556387901306,
-0.49133482575416565,
0.35701072216033936,
-0.2766607403755188,
-0.25863462686538696,
-0.40341445803642273,
0.012572470121085644,
0.3083152174949646,
0.28716132044792175,
0.06013863533735275,
0.41454237699508667,
0.6031526923179626,
-0.5166856050491333,
-0.13360340893268585,
-0.7409130334854126,
0.12515966594219208,
-0.2875749170780182,
-0.7017396688461304,
0.2488374561071396,
-0.13113287091255188,
-0.33598804473876953,
-0.2804073691368103,
-0.04312440752983093,
-0.6179342269897461,
0.007331309840083122,
0.2993146479129791,
-0.14871452748775482,
-0.3195037543773651,
0.39311301708221436,
-0.21005980670452118,
0.07657522708177567,
0.19935645163059235,
0.30399540066719055,
0.6779494881629944,
-0.4112357497215271,
-0.5954214930534363,
-0.5848831534385681,
0.6772226691246033,
0.6435362100601196,
-0.10686983168125153,
0.7812566757202148,
0.6073111891746521,
-0.259768545627594,
0.374634712934494,
-0.4900430142879486,
-0.2858155071735382,
-0.3079450726509094,
0.374491423368454,
-0.15521909296512604,
-0.9531072378158569,
0.7320679426193237,
-0.3491116166114807,
0.14354616403579712,
0.3679819703102112,
0.9231808185577393,
-0.2235618531703949,
1.2314740419387817,
0.36885711550712585,
0.4336042106151581,
0.049668796360492706,
0.03772667050361633,
0.5064573884010315,
-0.5440818071365356,
-0.6179299354553223,
-0.48729056119918823,
-0.07154250144958496,
-0.6500265002250671,
-0.22000278532505035,
0.5742746591567993,
-0.23011711239814758,
-0.06494586169719696,
-0.13012579083442688,
-0.6161647439002991,
0.1594877541065216,
0.035976819694042206,
0.6660051345825195,
0.5961121916770935,
-0.273222953081131,
0.222739577293396,
-0.298065721988678,
-0.8479006290435791,
-0.38700607419013977,
0.8713764548301697,
0.5680307745933533,
0.6218289136886597,
0.4457554817199707,
0.6382277011871338,
0.16922686994075775,
0.14685486257076263,
-0.8909029960632324,
-0.1528213918209076,
-0.17582130432128906,
-0.6069685220718384,
-0.10668431222438812,
-0.38837528228759766,
-1.383297085762024,
0.41652703285217285,
-0.1753334105014801,
-0.5784457325935364,
-0.07864606380462646,
0.19091904163360596,
-0.7935922145843506,
0.0749400183558464,
-1.064470648765564,
0.7761375904083252,
-0.20305994153022766,
0.045360781252384186,
0.007104979828000069,
-0.8433828949928284,
0.5170385241508484,
-0.21313905715942383,
0.43362143635749817,
-0.0805603489279747,
-0.016822876408696175,
0.7770191431045532,
-0.756770133972168,
0.8135493993759155,
0.011011633090674877,
0.18159253895282745,
-0.017901675775647163,
0.1696431189775467,
0.3223881721496582,
0.1981050819158554,
0.19840864837169647,
0.015259611420333385,
0.25040704011917114,
-0.5324867963790894,
-0.5534130334854126,
0.36980703473091125,
-0.6273680925369263,
-0.6128625273704529,
-0.45284274220466614,
-0.4826883375644684,
-0.3524394929409027,
0.10192351043224335,
0.2569723129272461,
0.3897899091243744,
-0.0688878670334816,
0.0022530865389853716,
0.6482923030853271,
-0.18043145537376404,
-0.10846003890037537,
0.4839518070220947,
0.0388171523809433,
0.18225035071372986,
0.6398125886917114,
-0.06678878515958786,
0.33761921525001526,
0.2633016109466553,
0.44719773530960083,
0.15408514440059662,
-0.8521749377250671,
-0.4557989537715912,
0.3171329200267792,
-0.5193591713905334,
0.12326692789793015,
-0.8905210494995117,
-0.11875798553228378,
-0.16733457148075104,
0.007993359118700027,
-0.20419251918792725,
-0.3407253623008728,
0.020178431645035744,
0.09099502116441727,
0.2941458523273468,
1.056756854057312,
0.2656717300415039,
0.31788933277130127,
-1.0248013734817505,
0.19397546350955963,
0.3172571063041687,
0.23026016354560852,
-0.22410321235656738,
-0.2934126853942871,
-0.17529095709323883,
0.06392204761505127,
-0.25493910908699036,
-1.28829824924469,
0.47377997636795044,
0.11086161434650421,
0.5602128505706787,
0.4240017533302307,
-0.11909418553113937,
0.7318649888038635,
-0.5256874561309814,
0.8402032852172852,
0.35743385553359985,
-0.6739423274993896,
0.48888418078422546,
-0.8243380188941956,
0.4312124252319336,
0.5688273906707764,
0.5916346311569214,
-0.9434359669685364,
-0.6084393858909607,
-0.5871000289916992,
-0.6208744049072266,
0.6194437146186829,
0.5011000037193298,
-0.23054656386375427,
0.05107731744647026,
0.3141699731349945,
0.17683462798595428,
0.12253257632255554,
-0.6298078298568726,
-0.29947131872177124,
-0.1799483448266983,
-0.2293744683265686,
0.08166248351335526,
-0.4358120858669281,
-0.5397310256958008,
0.19331088662147522,
0.05504550412297249,
0.0067168776877224445,
0.7551268339157104,
0.6304217576980591,
0.11464300006628036,
-0.30015829205513,
0.5557889938354492,
0.8282277584075928,
1.1365721225738525,
-0.24596890807151794,
0.2829064130783081,
-0.010428882203996181,
-0.7294732928276062,
-0.25044605135917664,
0.08325027674436569,
0.5519387722015381,
0.04567843675613403,
0.6980600357055664,
0.34531962871551514,
0.029401224106550217,
-0.5168933868408203,
0.8707894682884216,
-0.5788068771362305,
-0.34304729104042053,
-0.04134850576519966,
-0.12573525309562683,
0.22441549599170685,
0.32275375723838806,
0.10550976544618607,
0.04689610004425049,
0.3829074203968048,
-0.6187244653701782,
0.10004297643899918,
0.25163495540618896,
-0.684481680393219,
-0.39441508054733276,
0.5115083456039429,
0.20496733486652374,
-0.1590636819601059,
0.4584837853908539,
0.3037145733833313,
-0.6269811987876892,
0.717619776725769,
0.6075122952461243,
0.22112536430358887,
-0.435970664024353,
0.3921957015991211,
0.26041823625564575,
0.38220715522766113,
-0.07475246489048004,
0.3034694194793701,
0.28263336420059204,
-0.5582015514373779,
-0.680838406085968,
0.12781007587909698,
-0.8582293391227722,
0.03817638009786606,
-0.5293458104133606,
-0.06914632767438889,
-0.5006046891212463,
0.04869892820715904,
0.30495789647102356,
-0.1827821433544159,
-0.6200087666511536,
0.18673545122146606,
0.03566773608326912,
0.3473645746707916,
-0.7793152928352356,
0.5688644647598267,
0.6311637163162231,
-0.47500988841056824,
-1.1271660327911377,
-0.04966317489743233,
0.2992660701274872,
-0.9755934476852417,
0.4464063346385956,
0.10178303718566895,
0.28422075510025024,
-0.5382828712463379,
-0.25847649574279785,
-0.513179361820221,
1.0577515363693237,
0.28104114532470703,
-0.6576629877090454,
0.1758873164653778,
0.3039585053920746,
0.8875938057899475,
-0.24487221240997314,
0.6912794709205627,
0.3363598585128784,
0.5005311369895935,
0.23466959595680237,
-1.4117251634597778,
0.15943114459514618,
-0.011539244093000889,
-0.5342521071434021,
0.2841322124004364,
-0.7315682768821716,
1.0191925764083862,
-0.3620409071445465,
-0.29184767603874207,
-0.5024382472038269,
-0.080777108669281,
-0.015281664207577705,
0.4949386417865753,
0.3589562177658081,
0.15989336371421814,
1.252817153930664,
-0.12482323497533798,
1.477009892463684,
-0.027792323380708694,
0.28010934591293335,
0.8159746527671814,
-0.2221018373966217,
0.13918396830558777,
0.2811864912509918,
-0.48053863644599915,
0.3426953852176666,
0.6834864020347595,
0.28761354088783264,
0.2742815911769867,
0.1847022920846939,
-0.4711691439151764,
-0.2900492250919342,
-0.03370358422398567,
-0.6521738171577454,
0.18753741681575775,
0.4541730284690857,
-0.5487761497497559,
-0.23412692546844482,
0.021356673911213875,
0.42329642176628113,
-0.23598581552505493,
-0.1126985251903534,
0.9131416082382202,
0.14428704977035522,
-0.6382601857185364,
0.538559079170227,
-0.20459763705730438,
0.16880330443382263,
-0.6101308465003967,
-0.19278165698051453,
-0.2225526124238968,
0.2599983513355255,
-0.5841965079307556,
-0.8393939733505249,
0.49882835149765015,
-0.050777312368154526,
-0.06885065883398056,
-0.1679406613111496,
0.6000314354896545,
-0.4423290491104126,
-0.1478756219148636,
0.031536027789115906,
0.6778795719146729,
0.5114442706108093,
-0.2677449584007263,
-0.8353849053382874,
-0.23142655193805695,
0.32149752974510193,
-0.10557718575000763,
0.44998684525489807,
0.6762679219245911,
0.122682124376297,
0.7980520725250244,
0.5631557106971741,
0.22100870311260223,
-0.2166614830493927,
-0.02308209426701069,
0.809919536113739,
-0.532322883605957,
-0.21501775085926056,
-0.872724175453186,
0.3551503121852875,
0.045187368988990784,
-0.24199996888637543,
0.714130163192749,
0.3899289667606354,
0.23769184947013855,
0.037550296634435654,
0.8164274096488953,
0.04706348106265068,
0.6407510638237,
-0.5451170802116394,
0.723677933216095,
-0.23652589321136475,
0.19458229839801788,
-0.28495514392852783,
-0.4805970788002014,
-0.6463459730148315,
0.390296071767807,
-0.3830682337284088,
0.015515067614614964,
1.1965789794921875,
0.3576492965221405,
-0.02597738429903984,
0.2538900673389435,
0.37151214480400085,
0.6225622296333313,
0.6495986580848694,
0.8450568914413452,
0.6465806365013123,
-0.18681174516677856,
0.8866180777549744,
-0.2986883521080017,
-0.44251036643981934,
-0.2523404657840729,
-0.6112130284309387,
-0.9037529230117798,
-0.29086461663246155,
-0.3741840422153473,
-0.3250267207622528,
0.25652942061424255,
0.6191754341125488,
0.7146801948547363,
-0.6902189254760742,
0.10976675152778625,
0.21237364411354065,
-0.030242959037423134,
-0.09866727888584137,
-0.17702031135559082,
0.48140737414360046,
0.022402632981538773,
-0.48580673336982727,
0.24827107787132263,
0.38934963941574097,
-0.1621495932340622,
0.03279094770550728,
-0.030804064124822617,
0.05065642669796944,
-0.38216066360473633,
0.595360517501831,
0.2747003734111786,
-0.4294581711292267,
-0.0035169015172868967,
-0.1097886860370636,
-0.29318004846572876,
0.5957070589065552,
1.0990617275238037,
-0.444283664226532,
0.7596593499183655,
0.35349422693252563,
0.4661029875278473,
0.542234480381012,
-0.03133538365364075,
0.8339136838912964,
-0.03798409551382065,
-0.2536577582359314,
0.5998387336730957,
0.5385947823524475,
0.24973136186599731,
-0.7893953919410706,
0.3863730728626251,
0.15241944789886475,
-0.9056023955345154,
-0.371100515127182,
0.03161462023854256,
-1.2636542320251465,
-0.19999642670154572,
1.1450177431106567,
-0.5251913666725159,
0.03913678973913193,
-0.9555960297584534,
-0.6522015333175659,
0.15745165944099426,
-0.6576250195503235,
0.9403297901153564,
0.5334932804107666,
-0.7443796396255493,
-0.37788474559783936,
-0.9861847162246704,
0.5770688056945801,
0.38713881373405457,
-0.9258697032928467,
-0.10091900825500488,
0.35463976860046387,
0.32009050250053406,
-0.14885000884532928,
1.0574531555175781,
-0.5008989572525024,
0.43909090757369995,
-0.29459941387176514,
-0.23288238048553467,
-0.022735154256224632,
0.22950252890586853,
-0.16526278853416443,
0.2223387211561203,
0.12254926562309265,
-0.053239353001117706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17806v1 | MOSSBench: Is Your Multimodal Language Model Oversensitive to Safe Queries? | 2024-06-22T23:26:07 | 2024-06-22T23:26:07 | Xirui Li, Hengguang Zhou, Ruochen Wang, Tianyi Zhou, Minhao Cheng, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG | Humans are prone to cognitive distortions -- biased thinking patterns that
lead to exaggerated responses to specific stimuli, albeit in very different
contexts. This paper demonstrates that advanced Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) exhibit similar tendencies. While these models are designed to
respond queries under safety mechanism, they sometimes reject harmless queries
in the presence of certain visual stimuli, disregarding the benign nature of
their contexts. As the initial step in investigating this behavior, we identify
three types of stimuli that trigger the oversensitivity of existing MLLMs:
Exaggerated Risk, Negated Harm, and Counterintuitive Interpretation. To
systematically evaluate MLLMs' oversensitivity to these stimuli, we propose the
Multimodal OverSenSitivity Benchmark (MOSSBench). This toolkit consists of 300
manually collected benign multimodal queries, cross-verified by third-party
reviewers (AMT). Empirical studies using MOSSBench on 20 MLLMs reveal several
insights: (1). Oversensitivity is prevalent among SOTA MLLMs, with refusal
rates reaching up to 76% for harmless queries. (2). Safer models are more
oversensitive: increasing safety may inadvertently raise caution and
conservatism in the model's responses. (3). Different types of stimuli tend to
cause errors at specific stages -- perception, intent reasoning, and safety
judgement -- in the response process of MLLMs. These findings highlight the
need for refined safety mechanisms that balance caution with contextually
appropriate responses, improving the reliability of MLLMs in real-world
applications. We make our project available at
https://turningpoint-ai.github.io/MOSSBench/. | [
-0.5613358020782471,
-0.9974046945571899,
0.42131245136260986,
0.3832826018333435,
-0.0029047017451375723,
-0.3464685082435608,
-0.04830017313361168,
-0.5881001949310303,
-0.3360385596752167,
0.28902310132980347,
-0.5296986103057861,
-0.06280466169118881,
-0.45424845814704895,
-0.18733248114585876,
-0.4611726701259613,
1.0164088010787964,
0.19049173593521118,
0.06165219843387604,
-0.1049153134226799,
-0.3666342794895172,
-0.3818858861923218,
-0.5959692597389221,
-0.5634196400642395,
0.0679461807012558,
0.5911025404930115,
-0.0020412993617355824,
0.8955497145652771,
0.07117901742458344,
0.5630060434341431,
0.32817572355270386,
0.10064911097288132,
-0.06394768506288528,
-0.4369499087333679,
0.35019451379776,
-0.5502912998199463,
-0.3989059627056122,
-0.5310994386672974,
-0.12280523031949997,
0.46887853741645813,
0.5060557723045349,
-0.0759812518954277,
0.22141321003437042,
0.116201251745224,
0.533031702041626,
-0.9349298477172852,
0.06512627750635147,
-0.716849684715271,
-0.036988046020269394,
-0.14258675277233124,
-0.3378245532512665,
-0.7007989883422852,
-0.08081439137458801,
0.03806670010089874,
-0.3639669120311737,
0.41389715671539307,
0.3747502267360687,
0.5707806348800659,
0.23556727170944214,
-0.8339691758155823,
-0.08993041515350342,
-0.4623050391674042,
0.6978253126144409,
-0.42393380403518677,
0.4103594422340393,
0.4468482434749603,
0.42628780007362366,
-0.32418733835220337,
-0.4352034628391266,
-0.5969969034194946,
-0.5040126442909241,
-0.10669010132551193,
0.05455903336405754,
-0.1585981547832489,
0.1432732790708542,
0.5715962648391724,
-0.08125118166208267,
-0.9565601944923401,
-0.07662153244018555,
-0.36958467960357666,
-0.34608450531959534,
0.5538828372955322,
0.31890371441841125,
0.21961353719234467,
-0.2175782322883606,
-0.800497829914093,
-0.34633076190948486,
-0.5648581981658936,
0.11701983958482742,
0.20017600059509277,
0.2847355902194977,
0.1351492702960968,
0.6443855166435242,
-0.027298670262098312,
0.669205904006958,
-0.10503721237182617,
0.3260190784931183,
0.3204873204231262,
-0.3478485345840454,
-0.24325217306613922,
-0.07767073810100555,
0.5985854864120483,
0.8613532185554504,
0.5041165351867676,
0.05770314112305641,
-0.14456866681575775,
0.25667575001716614,
0.6999370455741882,
-0.660305380821228,
-0.06871771067380905,
0.43164321780204773,
-0.36536091566085815,
-0.31846749782562256,
-0.2173369973897934,
-0.7516540884971619,
-0.620341420173645,
0.07933688908815384,
0.5967706441879272,
-0.5482382774353027,
-0.2893610894680023,
0.17102012038230896,
-0.09562932699918747,
-0.10231515020132065,
0.24769216775894165,
-0.5986497402191162,
0.2735057771205902,
0.4573160409927368,
0.7247923016548157,
-0.1084904745221138,
-0.3878771960735321,
-0.4572318196296692,
0.3014286458492279,
-0.4308936893939972,
0.7348374724388123,
-0.2855647802352905,
-0.48716306686401367,
-0.06521464139223099,
0.1670435070991516,
-0.3104570508003235,
-0.3467554450035095,
0.7380601763725281,
-0.5935922265052795,
0.18251577019691467,
-0.2732292115688324,
-0.2015867829322815,
-0.22698372602462769,
0.5844120979309082,
-0.6937695741653442,
0.9598283171653748,
-0.12109412252902985,
-1.0109840631484985,
0.5938597917556763,
-0.7132404446601868,
-0.3275673985481262,
-0.4293408989906311,
-0.07363847643136978,
-0.2623094618320465,
-0.01062068436294794,
-0.027356626465916634,
0.34893307089805603,
-0.12746545672416687,
0.364266037940979,
-0.539909839630127,
-0.0643736869096756,
0.6887404322624207,
-0.7989135980606079,
0.8096316456794739,
0.3207158148288727,
-0.3180428445339203,
0.48178213834762573,
-0.8413923382759094,
0.2978352904319763,
-0.0197348203510046,
-0.3906346559524536,
-0.4876757562160492,
-0.08442997187376022,
0.38023701310157776,
0.7719071507453918,
-0.14340774714946747,
-0.5466712713241577,
-0.20857402682304382,
-0.21782037615776062,
0.2432137280702591,
1.0013238191604614,
-0.10005076229572296,
0.14859192073345184,
-0.50705486536026,
0.27491092681884766,
0.29887500405311584,
0.3479975759983063,
0.04404185712337494,
-0.359286367893219,
-0.6742600798606873,
-0.06365391612052917,
-0.23452500998973846,
0.3675748407840729,
-0.7359073758125305,
-0.009219192899763584,
-0.10565661638975143,
-0.46353182196617126,
-0.2283688634634018,
-0.17353175580501556,
0.7160987854003906,
0.4092675745487213,
0.4983833134174347,
-0.3865189254283905,
-0.29150304198265076,
-0.9486764073371887,
-0.4344891607761383,
-0.32338351011276245,
-0.03026439994573593,
0.2979341745376587,
0.40877577662467957,
-0.1729239672422409,
0.817460834980011,
-0.47979721426963806,
-0.27097949385643005,
0.08269234746694565,
0.3188032805919647,
-0.13417890667915344,
0.7098166346549988,
1.0288219451904297,
-1.1566367149353027,
-0.22315138578414917,
-0.23085768520832062,
-0.3833339810371399,
0.18744586408138275,
-0.1310127228498459,
-0.25310274958610535,
0.7012666463851929,
0.5546910762786865,
-1.014541506767273,
0.297728955745697,
0.42768996953964233,
-0.5419695973396301,
0.4798947274684906,
-0.14180703461170197,
0.21041874587535858,
-0.9767323136329651,
0.39275383949279785,
-0.013869063928723335,
-0.05992019549012184,
-0.7391852736473083,
0.30853044986724854,
0.40693768858909607,
0.09792791306972504,
-0.5213618874549866,
0.41029196977615356,
-0.29027923941612244,
0.04561702162027359,
0.003557088552042842,
-0.011985071003437042,
0.13056445121765137,
0.44288477301597595,
0.015818199142813683,
0.5483378767967224,
0.39333072304725647,
-0.5888158082962036,
0.4603106677532196,
-0.007995049469172955,
-0.45757341384887695,
0.6679703593254089,
-0.5442265868186951,
-0.04391692951321602,
-0.4607623517513275,
0.28523221611976624,
-1.244778037071228,
-0.38027721643447876,
0.40373456478118896,
-0.31337547302246094,
0.34465473890304565,
0.16235721111297607,
-0.33503636717796326,
-0.33421844244003296,
-0.5135773420333862,
0.3986770510673523,
0.02294369414448738,
-0.2794801890850067,
0.584959864616394,
0.11348064988851547,
-0.18966443836688995,
-0.7913950085639954,
-0.884831964969635,
-0.08389536291360855,
-0.2024243175983429,
-0.6369577050209045,
-0.08198212087154388,
-0.3637305796146393,
-0.31078147888183594,
-0.08202603459358215,
-0.13717849552631378,
-0.1612604558467865,
0.14920111000537872,
0.4755566418170929,
0.1774486005306244,
-0.1337112933397293,
0.3545740842819214,
-0.2799227833747864,
-0.11571447551250458,
0.32366830110549927,
0.30762428045272827,
0.5667286515235901,
-0.21488842368125916,
-0.7488701343536377,
0.1261352151632309,
0.3054736852645874,
0.7661671042442322,
-0.22893621027469635,
0.730665385723114,
0.7139676809310913,
-0.24944569170475006,
0.10475169867277145,
-0.62237948179245,
-0.39639461040496826,
-0.48173075914382935,
0.5593137741088867,
-0.40257710218429565,
-0.5953474044799805,
0.41039445996284485,
0.31671541929244995,
0.12123345583677292,
0.2228308767080307,
0.525206446647644,
-0.0723482072353363,
1.3469398021697998,
0.3629595935344696,
-0.03880421072244644,
0.3569756746292114,
0.174788236618042,
0.008664831519126892,
-0.5113038420677185,
-0.15323936939239502,
-0.57072913646698,
-0.15818016231060028,
-0.6346495747566223,
-0.5586785078048706,
0.45520779490470886,
-0.5137190222740173,
-0.27893128991127014,
0.09437515586614609,
-0.125990092754364,
0.19822514057159424,
0.47194603085517883,
-0.025632867589592934,
0.16854749619960785,
-0.22114473581314087,
-0.17701883614063263,
0.0036713771987706423,
-0.6179065108299255,
-0.29975396394729614,
0.8874990344047546,
0.39916059374809265,
1.031886100769043,
0.4920039176940918,
0.01547316275537014,
0.1656053364276886,
0.3157994747161865,
-0.47246256470680237,
0.46045124530792236,
0.37238723039627075,
-1.694356918334961,
-0.4088497459888458,
-0.3656003475189209,
-0.7547674179077148,
0.7019131183624268,
-0.5317142605781555,
-0.6684186458587646,
0.2693138122558594,
0.39348453283309937,
-0.48736727237701416,
0.00873352400958538,
-0.830244779586792,
0.9370833039283752,
-0.3885078728199005,
-0.7265899181365967,
-0.3281234800815582,
-1.0247303247451782,
0.3935062289237976,
-0.0975520983338356,
0.5230452418327332,
-0.21864429116249084,
0.16816699504852295,
0.11368396133184433,
0.11002457141876221,
0.9680539965629578,
-0.2122999131679535,
-0.11161433160305023,
0.09664992988109589,
0.5475605726242065,
0.43507495522499084,
-0.11814213544130325,
-0.24761030077934265,
-0.11818478256464005,
0.17826513946056366,
-0.4034145474433899,
-0.44028282165527344,
0.6608632802963257,
-0.4355899393558502,
-0.6381376385688782,
-0.6693798899650574,
-0.8007907271385193,
-0.44744426012039185,
0.2711956202983856,
0.23167361319065094,
0.5067304968833923,
-0.3307126760482788,
0.2784409523010254,
0.5690752863883972,
-0.2281080186367035,
0.32939913868904114,
0.7462270855903625,
-0.2362401783466339,
0.1992330551147461,
0.7474186420440674,
0.16938556730747223,
0.6743345856666565,
0.02113725058734417,
-0.061451151967048645,
-0.26245859265327454,
-0.475605309009552,
-0.619101881980896,
-0.3615834712982178,
-0.7222802042961121,
-0.1443818062543869,
-0.6926931142807007,
-0.07115419209003448,
-0.5821158289909363,
0.13070327043533325,
-0.26636001467704773,
-0.4961356222629547,
0.07411210983991623,
-0.2927585244178772,
0.24398741126060486,
0.4491596221923828,
-0.1079043298959732,
-0.09534122794866562,
-0.8256498575210571,
0.3241709768772125,
0.2117263674736023,
0.40671929717063904,
-0.00919209886342287,
-0.2410019189119339,
0.11593951284885406,
0.1328955441713333,
-0.32500237226486206,
-0.6373295187950134,
0.3068896234035492,
0.25223246216773987,
0.7858309745788574,
0.6989068984985352,
0.44491395354270935,
0.4884769320487976,
-0.5358548760414124,
0.5543438792228699,
-0.022208096459507942,
-0.5998526215553284,
0.3176749646663666,
-0.44276565313339233,
0.07803786545991898,
0.4373656213283539,
0.8925002217292786,
-0.5784050822257996,
-0.4466274082660675,
-0.37789860367774963,
-0.8895875811576843,
0.7697455883026123,
0.12200282514095306,
0.36233681440353394,
-0.2081502079963684,
-0.28085145354270935,
0.05729407072067261,
0.08010189980268478,
-0.8685621023178101,
-0.03638804703950882,
-0.34592607617378235,
0.03254609555006027,
-0.30126357078552246,
-0.643036961555481,
-0.5198338031768799,
0.2315179705619812,
0.5851224064826965,
-0.30618569254875183,
-0.19278721511363983,
0.02635892480611801,
-0.33823052048683167,
-0.38202282786369324,
0.5180960297584534,
0.7836716175079346,
0.6998690366744995,
-0.5665344595909119,
0.4911264181137085,
0.2549859583377838,
-0.399568110704422,
-0.10126722604036331,
0.017335010692477226,
0.14327695965766907,
-0.2900477945804596,
0.3705255091190338,
0.43236270546913147,
0.3383106589317322,
-0.8307474851608276,
0.6539708971977234,
-0.18573349714279175,
0.1830010861158371,
-0.12762510776519775,
0.16935957968235016,
0.01142190396785736,
0.18471194803714752,
0.17243194580078125,
0.496725857257843,
0.5142319202423096,
-0.7904115915298462,
0.04285064712166786,
0.6602165699005127,
-0.4960555136203766,
-0.06079508364200592,
0.5138049721717834,
0.24913541972637177,
0.1590852290391922,
0.3168298304080963,
0.17574343085289001,
-0.38498151302337646,
0.44831231236457825,
0.5972856283187866,
0.40013810992240906,
-0.35604995489120483,
-0.013071009889245033,
0.2925308048725128,
0.6418994665145874,
0.18260127305984497,
0.45337823033332825,
0.10862916707992554,
-0.7999308109283447,
0.05559791252017021,
-0.3776947259902954,
-0.19490034878253937,
-0.11858440190553665,
-0.823154628276825,
-0.04028629884123802,
-0.5749924778938293,
-0.6124739646911621,
0.01046789437532425,
-0.5410396456718445,
-0.31305500864982605,
0.3173964023590088,
-0.09751159697771072,
0.956903874874115,
-0.8436194658279419,
0.6008551716804504,
0.6674496531486511,
-0.40394312143325806,
-0.32756540179252625,
-0.035159219056367874,
0.4116223156452179,
-0.7038455605506897,
0.564640998840332,
0.1683066189289093,
-0.2213379293680191,
-0.4008711576461792,
-0.39639484882354736,
-0.8618538975715637,
0.6423407793045044,
0.19677874445915222,
-0.28797945380210876,
0.09816102683544159,
0.3030753433704376,
0.5313869118690491,
0.12602853775024414,
0.22805185616016388,
0.4047154486179352,
0.46976983547210693,
-0.13096362352371216,
-1.110183835029602,
0.39588335156440735,
-0.3533570170402527,
0.0024100567679852247,
0.06057240068912506,
-0.6441625356674194,
1.0901834964752197,
-0.25891876220703125,
-0.24094131588935852,
0.09508837014436722,
0.0015474456595256925,
0.20969662070274353,
0.45129990577697754,
0.559004545211792,
0.2915635108947754,
0.2549220025539398,
0.010090415365993977,
1.1473841667175293,
-0.20477266609668732,
0.15946198999881744,
1.13887619972229,
-0.36114683747291565,
1.0168282985687256,
0.688088059425354,
0.0005241328035481274,
0.10806356370449066,
0.3710482716560364,
0.25474247336387634,
0.509453535079956,
0.10710292309522629,
-0.1456998884677887,
-0.43484365940093994,
-0.13395950198173523,
-0.6345899701118469,
0.2952063977718353,
0.5550136566162109,
-0.3538987636566162,
-0.27580320835113525,
0.1317737102508545,
-0.2137955129146576,
-0.03973565250635147,
-0.08317647874355316,
0.5312739610671997,
0.0739680826663971,
-0.5015230178833008,
0.5802044868469238,
-0.002607495291158557,
0.618642270565033,
-0.598097026348114,
0.16991294920444489,
0.03628455474972725,
0.43740901350975037,
-0.18689589202404022,
-0.9371205568313599,
0.24798831343650818,
-0.20841555297374725,
-0.2796722650527954,
-0.09332726150751114,
0.7141340374946594,
-0.207473024725914,
-0.3423442542552948,
0.3519534170627594,
0.3623550534248352,
0.10266074538230896,
-0.16160304844379425,
-0.7553139328956604,
0.10502275824546814,
-0.2206411510705948,
-0.5121688842773438,
0.45930853486061096,
0.43910303711891174,
-0.5594142079353333,
0.960202157497406,
0.7889841198921204,
-0.3081555664539337,
0.32425519824028015,
0.11710397154092789,
1.0246248245239258,
-0.46380627155303955,
-0.2962726056575775,
-0.7707386612892151,
0.5406167507171631,
-0.06366395205259323,
-0.319175660610199,
0.948785662651062,
0.37366461753845215,
0.9492647051811218,
-0.18087045848369598,
0.5382906198501587,
-0.07557611912488937,
0.5640571713447571,
-0.5237151384353638,
1.0489269495010376,
-0.5669741034507751,
-0.025741100311279297,
-0.46652302145957947,
-0.8050487637519836,
-0.325239896774292,
0.6501815319061279,
-0.43872150778770447,
0.29268085956573486,
0.5166443586349487,
1.1151533126831055,
-0.06944654136896133,
0.04506821185350418,
0.43206626176834106,
0.4600447416305542,
0.2910260856151581,
0.4899005591869354,
1.1720585823059082,
-0.04138365387916565,
0.6839960217475891,
-0.24173970520496368,
-0.041026726365089417,
-0.6171813607215881,
-0.8728803992271423,
-0.9026833176612854,
-0.4951646625995636,
0.022478589788079262,
-0.356391042470932,
0.2285662293434143,
1.039297103881836,
0.6260746717453003,
-0.9948750138282776,
0.022443518042564392,
0.13223400712013245,
-0.0694071352481842,
0.026284512132406235,
-0.23495370149612427,
0.18013422191143036,
-0.29308393597602844,
-0.49289610981941223,
0.15923403203487396,
0.04493135213851929,
0.16163499653339386,
-0.21758779883384705,
0.15520824491977692,
-0.4597570598125458,
0.020090697333216667,
0.6713815927505493,
0.10370776802301407,
-0.5598750710487366,
-0.5479921102523804,
-0.07364777475595474,
-0.4245011806488037,
-0.2721092104911804,
0.5780996680259705,
-0.3722675144672394,
0.6389225125312805,
0.5491301417350769,
0.13276848196983337,
0.25818946957588196,
0.05435400828719139,
0.5278308987617493,
-0.6957204937934875,
0.4146760106086731,
0.22961318492889404,
0.3327251076698303,
0.25466862320899963,
-0.3163629174232483,
0.38605567812919617,
-0.09669685363769531,
-0.32072991132736206,
-0.9256318807601929,
0.40338823199272156,
-0.7894067168235779,
-0.608586311340332,
1.0530610084533691,
-0.1728835254907608,
-0.1543159931898117,
-0.2660071849822998,
-0.7066820859909058,
-0.0550050288438797,
-0.3282625675201416,
1.0887411832809448,
0.7311445474624634,
-0.2166537493467331,
0.07588198035955429,
-0.8021941781044006,
0.6067437529563904,
0.7401608228683472,
-0.4779377281665802,
0.2647646367549896,
0.9027636647224426,
0.32039833068847656,
0.4866091012954712,
0.3379136621952057,
-0.09274623543024063,
0.5953938961029053,
0.19621321558952332,
-0.01404343731701374,
-0.05397636443376541,
-0.39543014764785767,
-0.12373443692922592,
0.34081724286079407,
0.33175399899482727,
-0.06337162107229233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17805v1 | Can LLMs Generate Visualizations with Dataless Prompts? | 2024-06-22T22:59:09 | 2024-06-22T22:59:09 | Darius Coelho, Harshit Barot, Naitik Rathod, Klaus Mueller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Recent advancements in large language models have revolutionized information
access, as these models harness data available on the web to address complex
queries, becoming the preferred information source for many users. In certain
cases, queries are about publicly available data, which can be effectively
answered with data visualizations. In this paper, we investigate the ability of
large language models to provide accurate data and relevant visualizations in
response to such queries. Specifically, we investigate the ability of GPT-3 and
GPT-4 to generate visualizations with dataless prompts, where no data
accompanies the query. We evaluate the results of the models by comparing them
to visualization cheat sheets created by visualization experts. | [
-0.19314523041248322,
-0.8342283368110657,
1.130952000617981,
0.25343000888824463,
-0.04995269700884819,
-0.005121354013681412,
-0.08685196936130524,
-0.2341761291027069,
0.2507406175136566,
0.5383878350257874,
-0.7550932168960571,
-0.8188773989677429,
-0.30809304118156433,
0.20957572758197784,
-0.5876576900482178,
0.9253792762756348,
0.01936851628124714,
0.05197404325008392,
-0.4422336220741272,
0.09698295593261719,
-0.5639362931251526,
-0.5686856508255005,
-0.3881431519985199,
0.0693492591381073,
0.645457923412323,
0.39697325229644775,
0.7511628270149231,
0.878344714641571,
0.23126967251300812,
0.22530007362365723,
0.18767417967319489,
-0.04670916125178337,
-0.7636808156967163,
0.5071170926094055,
-0.1536431610584259,
-0.4304511249065399,
-0.4385298788547516,
0.020924298092722893,
0.5806199312210083,
0.933728814125061,
0.08266830444335938,
0.037516362965106964,
0.008155438117682934,
0.6775216460227966,
-0.15385174751281738,
0.6120578050613403,
-0.7971071004867554,
-0.021568769589066505,
-0.30321750044822693,
-0.45566460490226746,
-0.4211602807044983,
-0.8514237999916077,
0.13392283022403717,
-0.7405139207839966,
0.3151322305202484,
0.21672193706035614,
0.6747003197669983,
0.1814570128917694,
-0.6218178272247314,
-0.5178236961364746,
-0.6835450530052185,
0.6359279751777649,
-0.47814038395881653,
0.21052789688110352,
0.24809546768665314,
0.5680010318756104,
-0.220292329788208,
-0.6149766445159912,
-0.36521127820014954,
-0.4731479287147522,
0.03332116827368736,
0.292688250541687,
-0.5730538368225098,
-0.08174822479486465,
0.6978646516799927,
0.10867714136838913,
-0.6239825487136841,
0.24983377754688263,
-0.4287308156490326,
-0.035496216267347336,
0.5272989869117737,
0.6140545606613159,
0.46068501472473145,
-0.29230797290802,
-0.3391771614551544,
0.17345748841762543,
-1.1408723592758179,
-0.3211081922054291,
0.2873392701148987,
0.4444218575954437,
-0.380669504404068,
0.9116215109825134,
-0.2468789666891098,
0.9485061764717102,
-0.4383653402328491,
0.008274559862911701,
-0.2132139801979065,
-0.24613483250141144,
-0.18113665282726288,
-0.32951340079307556,
0.819344699382782,
0.48038357496261597,
0.533676266670227,
-0.5054253339767456,
-0.3462912142276764,
-0.2657167613506317,
-0.23935198783874512,
-0.8157485723495483,
-0.3830309808254242,
0.4161725342273712,
-0.13451442122459412,
-0.16830994188785553,
-0.09585364907979965,
-0.7892231345176697,
-0.8766763210296631,
-0.3260830044746399,
0.3294427990913391,
-0.05625809729099274,
-0.12463411688804626,
-0.2559105455875397,
-0.2896179258823395,
0.046603184193372726,
0.8195405006408691,
-0.9061741828918457,
0.1523577719926834,
0.30897092819213867,
1.0184767246246338,
-0.4436580538749695,
0.08089615404605865,
-0.5549507141113281,
0.4451428949832916,
-0.6500182151794434,
0.6909477710723877,
-0.49670419096946716,
-0.5447583794593811,
0.0028358022682368755,
-0.06077788770198822,
0.02112681046128273,
-0.5766782760620117,
0.21327294409275055,
-0.6583725810050964,
0.008068791590631008,
-0.7822019457817078,
-0.9044311046600342,
-0.1554275006055832,
0.25521647930145264,
-0.8429287672042847,
0.2918967604637146,
-0.0992126613855362,
-0.8061643242835999,
0.19908438622951508,
-0.838718593120575,
0.043999575078487396,
0.30940747261047363,
-0.5997682809829712,
0.12931913137435913,
-0.10118521749973297,
0.46894359588623047,
0.5735174417495728,
-0.3177464008331299,
0.10184098780155182,
-0.46883490681648254,
-0.3676907420158386,
0.3105233311653137,
-0.574100136756897,
0.4750834107398987,
0.1021595373749733,
-0.44484570622444153,
0.11354708671569824,
-0.5138625502586365,
0.06845850497484207,
0.5020332336425781,
-0.37399643659591675,
0.042920976877212524,
-0.052277013659477234,
-0.12967850267887115,
-0.1504496932029724,
0.3161400854587555,
-0.38827863335609436,
0.6409170627593994,
-0.05378089100122452,
0.19687040150165558,
0.8678832650184631,
0.1665569245815277,
0.2558733820915222,
-0.027149517089128494,
0.9871468544006348,
0.0054772114381194115,
-0.07722416520118713,
-0.245806023478508,
-0.8892255425453186,
-0.671585202217102,
-0.27874284982681274,
0.0941518098115921,
0.666217565536499,
-1.1100966930389404,
-0.3292219340801239,
-0.5403861403465271,
-0.4550883173942566,
-0.02239116095006466,
-0.026080723851919174,
-0.1071109026670456,
0.7572956681251526,
0.13218529522418976,
0.5082285404205322,
-0.3862052857875824,
-0.8746182322502136,
-0.33444875478744507,
-0.07826334238052368,
-0.2755628824234009,
0.6888723373413086,
0.419831246137619,
0.0017444263212382793,
0.8206367492675781,
-0.6321189999580383,
0.16888484358787537,
-0.43958550691604614,
0.08761860430240631,
0.5650038719177246,
-0.06696996092796326,
0.5932365655899048,
-0.4290752410888672,
-0.4369085133075714,
-0.012362901121377945,
-1.1723088026046753,
-0.37805113196372986,
-0.003818581812083721,
0.14788514375686646,
0.22184184193611145,
0.2194732129573822,
-0.6422610878944397,
0.48203206062316895,
0.5358848571777344,
-0.08955607563257217,
0.49409931898117065,
-0.24749547243118286,
0.11942000687122345,
-0.6442570686340332,
0.24019040167331696,
-0.07249809801578522,
-0.25219228863716125,
-0.8879571557044983,
-0.35827910900115967,
0.27291035652160645,
-0.6569788455963135,
-0.30564233660697937,
0.8589236736297607,
-0.7602663636207581,
-0.38150501251220703,
-0.2003985196352005,
0.40725407004356384,
-0.012529062107205391,
0.23168732225894928,
0.009476499632000923,
1.059219241142273,
0.8490903973579407,
-0.6885517835617065,
0.47355422377586365,
0.25543758273124695,
-0.21226562559604645,
0.15082769095897675,
-0.8108803033828735,
0.10281015932559967,
-0.21917425096035004,
0.20513002574443817,
-1.1148663759231567,
-0.6599620580673218,
0.2752934694290161,
-0.2525613009929657,
-0.08963533490896225,
-0.3333274722099304,
-0.685076892375946,
-0.40368324518203735,
-0.3724677562713623,
0.1133655235171318,
0.4804760813713074,
-0.6576285362243652,
0.16060449182987213,
0.13850004971027374,
-0.36249667406082153,
-0.2882138192653656,
-0.8551734685897827,
0.16750989854335785,
-0.16825298964977264,
-0.6422557234764099,
-0.3178090751171112,
-0.25960269570350647,
-0.15987104177474976,
-0.2973778247833252,
0.12414354085922241,
-0.001878434675745666,
-0.0604657344520092,
0.4246516227722168,
0.6809077262878418,
-0.15803971886634827,
0.10840450972318649,
-0.18548427522182465,
0.04282651096582413,
-0.05278753116726875,
-0.07674931734800339,
0.35420146584510803,
-0.024157801643013954,
-0.8083651661872864,
-0.5443564653396606,
0.2969489097595215,
0.622897207736969,
-0.05840069428086281,
0.4796393811702728,
0.2235105186700821,
-0.20275086164474487,
0.2150057852268219,
-0.5680819749832153,
0.03836112469434738,
-0.4685920774936676,
-0.005784948356449604,
-0.22662106156349182,
-1.1301872730255127,
0.7355702519416809,
0.11922499537467957,
-0.1272462159395218,
0.2054772824048996,
0.5119154453277588,
0.11737282574176788,
1.5244992971420288,
0.3296162188053131,
0.15599088370800018,
0.22408737242221832,
-0.023855622857809067,
0.26830077171325684,
-0.3687359690666199,
-0.41578397154808044,
-0.40349823236465454,
0.012321985326707363,
-0.7845067977905273,
-0.17418760061264038,
0.7870632410049438,
0.10862886160612106,
-0.17921829223632812,
-0.22501586377620697,
-0.39336585998535156,
0.5767987966537476,
0.5047098398208618,
-0.1337243765592575,
0.35367122292518616,
0.20905590057373047,
-0.035903334617614746,
-0.17680281400680542,
-0.7120062112808228,
-0.5531262159347534,
1.3048487901687622,
0.08029420673847198,
0.9927074909210205,
0.1599779725074768,
0.45059311389923096,
0.2485799640417099,
0.2731100618839264,
-0.7528679966926575,
0.5946929454803467,
0.3237927556037903,
-0.42867496609687805,
-0.18299855291843414,
-0.7847952842712402,
-1.16771399974823,
0.03718310967087746,
-0.12878349423408508,
-0.909421980381012,
0.1561473160982132,
0.20557919144630432,
-0.2803334593772888,
0.4934832751750946,
-1.0895603895187378,
0.6350701451301575,
-0.24886468052864075,
-0.2671198844909668,
0.3560020923614502,
-0.20756013691425323,
0.514702558517456,
-0.13629189133644104,
0.15390123426914215,
-0.18081748485565186,
-0.15275011956691742,
0.5876187682151794,
-0.3552559018135071,
0.6681937575340271,
-0.5027084946632385,
-0.1635476052761078,
0.14644524455070496,
0.33228006958961487,
0.7750328779220581,
0.011909070424735546,
-0.15946614742279053,
-0.000712646811734885,
-0.2966999113559723,
-0.5556288957595825,
-0.697863757610321,
0.9599467515945435,
-0.5360832214355469,
-1.030417799949646,
-0.25154051184654236,
-0.5990433692932129,
-0.2629556655883789,
0.34491729736328125,
0.020228726789355278,
0.42164134979248047,
0.08458172529935837,
-0.023849787190556526,
0.4796828627586365,
-0.5969752669334412,
0.4475831985473633,
0.6352009177207947,
-0.7131776213645935,
-0.08709855377674103,
0.9407588839530945,
0.40390345454216003,
0.1444198489189148,
0.11750034242868423,
-0.02216392382979393,
-0.7280179858207703,
-0.7313022613525391,
-0.7529410719871521,
0.4075457751750946,
-0.8150516152381897,
-0.19612464308738708,
-0.5884712934494019,
0.08356007188558578,
-0.2832696735858917,
0.01236739568412304,
0.1145232766866684,
-0.47088000178337097,
-0.3340846002101898,
-0.2566492259502411,
0.7190603017807007,
1.4622535705566406,
0.013230345211923122,
0.0781852975487709,
-0.6895867586135864,
0.28583139181137085,
0.3836773931980133,
0.285467267036438,
0.15258382260799408,
0.05834073945879936,
-0.011015630327165127,
0.09350884705781937,
-0.1462642401456833,
-1.1200411319732666,
0.27939799427986145,
-0.2716367840766907,
0.40831640362739563,
0.3364497423171997,
-0.21857008337974548,
0.6033302545547485,
-0.5106968879699707,
1.090050220489502,
0.02894139103591442,
-0.9755417108535767,
0.7458829879760742,
-1.0398141145706177,
0.33355674147605896,
0.03190094605088234,
0.4988900423049927,
-0.44642946124076843,
-0.44952499866485596,
-0.2637972831726074,
-0.7032977342605591,
0.8308560252189636,
0.2935985028743744,
0.14905793964862823,
-0.14572416245937347,
0.2973713278770447,
0.23448596894741058,
0.34667667746543884,
-0.6393007636070251,
-0.3309510350227356,
-0.3816075026988983,
0.2357548326253891,
0.21633243560791016,
-0.045662328600883484,
-0.028589045628905296,
-0.15211805701255798,
0.38266631960868835,
-0.03752170875668526,
0.23976801335811615,
-0.11624694615602493,
0.25774097442626953,
-0.0024999980814754963,
0.32193347811698914,
0.5164738297462463,
1.2141708135604858,
-0.27799123525619507,
-0.10840338468551636,
0.053691279143095016,
-0.07469361275434494,
0.01762755773961544,
0.04971481114625931,
-0.25810202956199646,
0.20865753293037415,
0.30250081419944763,
0.891206681728363,
-0.13778696954250336,
-0.7886449694633484,
0.8683285117149353,
-0.23938243091106415,
-0.07191973179578781,
0.009980334900319576,
0.0022865086793899536,
0.32179582118988037,
0.23054450750350952,
0.582042932510376,
-0.397960364818573,
0.16417022049427032,
-0.3727573752403259,
-0.010953381657600403,
0.6580442190170288,
-0.07059431076049805,
-0.24431833624839783,
1.1502556800842285,
-0.02542366087436676,
0.21688418090343475,
0.7696322798728943,
0.0003202508087269962,
-0.08441540598869324,
0.4835445284843445,
0.5840940475463867,
0.4314267635345459,
-0.023946337401866913,
0.39283788204193115,
0.03981303051114082,
0.16469988226890564,
0.20262524485588074,
0.4002622961997986,
0.03677781671285629,
-0.22653934359550476,
-0.4317771792411804,
-0.11371907591819763,
-0.8055914640426636,
0.4296109080314636,
-0.5486158728599548,
0.20742157101631165,
-0.6014503240585327,
0.0133054805919528,
-0.06387539952993393,
-0.3034931421279907,
-0.8562583923339844,
0.2857353687286377,
0.17575155198574066,
0.7543734312057495,
-0.6187326312065125,
0.5688437819480896,
0.5227994322776794,
-0.5344486236572266,
-0.9622636437416077,
-0.08600272983312607,
-0.029770880937576294,
-1.1111372709274292,
0.6616600155830383,
0.1073780283331871,
0.042553022503852844,
0.09804082661867142,
-1.0062905550003052,
-0.9021199345588684,
1.253060221672058,
0.9919689893722534,
-0.47475218772888184,
0.11883402615785599,
0.47716060280799866,
0.49046581983566284,
0.012448349967598915,
0.5642296075820923,
0.274752676486969,
0.74124675989151,
0.2142457365989685,
-0.6319068074226379,
0.26481518149375916,
-0.13708747923374176,
-0.03244853392243385,
0.007569618057459593,
-0.33757156133651733,
1.0650384426116943,
-0.17276306450366974,
-0.636610209941864,
0.038367774337530136,
0.5281721353530884,
0.4135127067565918,
0.1732395440340042,
0.12046845257282257,
0.16538381576538086,
0.9753749370574951,
-0.3439696729183197,
1.469537377357483,
-0.23510141670703888,
0.18619108200073242,
0.8389232754707336,
-0.4587975740432739,
0.5221848487854004,
0.3391953706741333,
0.023728234693408012,
0.10039465874433517,
0.6117356419563293,
-0.20467577874660492,
0.4337286353111267,
0.1488180160522461,
-0.21870072185993195,
-0.14964067935943604,
-0.26853644847869873,
-0.5990976691246033,
0.0412246435880661,
0.3022637963294983,
-0.11860417574644089,
-0.6753522157669067,
-0.16198615729808807,
0.17637000977993011,
-0.23007144033908844,
-0.35324034094810486,
0.676850438117981,
-0.12662768363952637,
-0.3922397494316101,
0.9606344699859619,
-0.1476186215877533,
0.3357692360877991,
-0.7283300161361694,
-0.18147511780261993,
-0.6207413673400879,
-0.48819130659103394,
-0.396184504032135,
-1.0150971412658691,
-0.03110586851835251,
0.47122839093208313,
0.04974006861448288,
-0.1890859156847,
0.6115813255310059,
-0.31048834323883057,
-0.44358742237091064,
0.2206748127937317,
1.0938794612884521,
0.627400279045105,
-0.21220232546329498,
-0.46929898858070374,
-0.02526380680501461,
0.1801254153251648,
-0.2687348425388336,
0.16155463457107544,
0.4939274787902832,
-0.22008121013641357,
1.0002177953720093,
0.6500632166862488,
0.17899349331855774,
0.2998180389404297,
0.4388711452484131,
0.9491103887557983,
-0.69582599401474,
-0.2875361740589142,
-0.9665489196777344,
0.2516445815563202,
0.04306555166840553,
0.3082917630672455,
1.1328672170639038,
0.7112823128700256,
0.3068808913230896,
-0.3790912628173828,
1.236215591430664,
0.33912110328674316,
0.735302209854126,
-0.6612284779548645,
0.7338654398918152,
-0.7241954803466797,
0.4538571238517761,
-0.12835727632045746,
-0.9484501481056213,
-0.4369833469390869,
-0.09410438686609268,
-0.6487523913383484,
0.17606639862060547,
0.4316556751728058,
0.882408857345581,
-0.25563398003578186,
0.13293986022472382,
0.3844258785247803,
0.3762432932853699,
0.5053516626358032,
0.3060472905635834,
1.0591762065887451,
0.19401361048221588,
0.49151843786239624,
0.32748720049858093,
-0.20307613909244537,
-0.08230730891227722,
-0.894547164440155,
-1.0050525665283203,
-0.18727809190750122,
0.1347697377204895,
-0.009064394980669022,
0.08377734571695328,
0.40168124437332153,
0.3017471730709076,
-0.6875274777412415,
-0.24717235565185547,
-0.11644324660301208,
0.18353867530822754,
0.6031844615936279,
-0.2510550320148468,
0.5923318266868591,
-0.08372102677822113,
-0.6539450287818909,
0.7651269435882568,
0.39682537317276,
0.5796598792076111,
-0.3130686581134796,
0.09294798225164413,
0.285159170627594,
0.19862380623817444,
0.27383068203926086,
0.1643817126750946,
-0.6089015007019043,
-0.1867479532957077,
-0.04931730404496193,
0.010691219009459019,
0.31407231092453003,
0.7238376140594482,
-0.6598533987998962,
0.3757605254650116,
0.4345428943634033,
0.5153262615203857,
0.6419327855110168,
0.2470019906759262,
0.5424521565437317,
-0.8337159156799316,
-0.06929254531860352,
-0.05063691362738609,
0.2804357409477234,
0.6446258425712585,
-0.46255722641944885,
0.4085565209388733,
0.10253854095935822,
-0.41837820410728455,
-0.6632405519485474,
0.27457672357559204,
-0.9361444711685181,
0.07769926637411118,
1.2223432064056396,
-0.20424844324588776,
-0.09381236881017685,
0.05242837220430374,
-0.07679463177919388,
0.10907204449176788,
-0.5816982984542847,
0.4190289378166199,
0.6843627691268921,
-0.5866759419441223,
0.053556863218545914,
-1.129341721534729,
0.4688563346862793,
0.2666598856449127,
-1.251038908958435,
0.16273707151412964,
0.7413640022277832,
0.3489561676979065,
-0.16927604377269745,
0.8580042123794556,
-0.05491906777024269,
-0.09965229779481888,
-0.2623785734176636,
-0.370317667722702,
-0.18471096456050873,
-0.0631609857082367,
-0.3297954201698303,
0.171657532453537,
0.13486267626285553,
0.028038866817951202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15951v1 | Modular Pluralism: Pluralistic Alignment via Multi-LLM Collaboration | 2024-06-22T22:07:40 | 2024-06-22T22:07:40 | Shangbin Feng, Taylor Sorensen, Yuhan Liu, Jillian Fisher, Chan Young Park, Yejin Choi, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | While existing alignment paradigms have been integral in developing large
language models (LLMs), LLMs often learn an averaged human preference and
struggle to model diverse preferences across cultures, demographics, and
communities. We propose Modular Pluralism, a modular framework based on
multi-LLM collaboration for pluralistic alignment: it "plugs into" a base LLM a
pool of smaller but specialized community LMs, where models collaborate in
distinct modes to flexibility support three modes of pluralism: Overton,
steerable, and distributional. Modular Pluralism is uniquely compatible with
black-box LLMs and offers the modular control of adding new community LMs for
previously underrepresented communities. We evaluate Modular Pluralism with six
tasks and four datasets featuring questions/instructions with value-laden and
perspective-informed responses. Extensive experiments demonstrate that Modular
Pluralism advances the three pluralism objectives across six black-box and
open-source LLMs. Further analysis reveals that LLMs are generally faithful to
the inputs from smaller community LLMs, allowing seamless patching by adding a
new community LM to better cover previously underrepresented communities. | [
-0.482141375541687,
-0.46011030673980713,
0.680488109588623,
0.2917541563510895,
-0.09377849847078323,
0.4456842243671417,
-0.3366122543811798,
-0.1368459016084671,
0.6196883916854858,
0.48168888688087463,
-0.44399064779281616,
-0.5143502950668335,
-0.45273488759994507,
0.08733923733234406,
0.043004199862480164,
0.7164137363433838,
0.17256180942058563,
0.2034195214509964,
-0.28116828203201294,
-0.45002874732017517,
-0.5889500379562378,
-0.4997275769710541,
0.21011365950107574,
-0.39869028329849243,
0.9288880228996277,
0.5847901701927185,
0.8191627860069275,
0.4310901463031769,
0.35244277119636536,
0.33316850662231445,
-0.1370886117219925,
0.16668805480003357,
-0.39931464195251465,
-0.06740882992744446,
-0.3926180303096771,
-0.4686594009399414,
-0.7126810550689697,
-0.19081544876098633,
0.6798442602157593,
0.6939408779144287,
-0.2963677942752838,
0.2568960189819336,
-0.12844564020633698,
0.7450682520866394,
-0.5801650881767273,
-0.1608622670173645,
-0.7098652124404907,
-0.07198800146579742,
-0.18845033645629883,
0.438806414604187,
-0.2045396864414215,
-0.5472121834754944,
0.04521786794066429,
-0.25463566184043884,
-0.2375558614730835,
0.019259998574852943,
0.03549592196941376,
-0.010052741505205631,
-0.8238271474838257,
-0.056055355817079544,
-0.5738148093223572,
0.9819983839988708,
-0.8266409039497375,
0.2840014696121216,
-0.03337974473834038,
0.23242917656898499,
-0.06699146330356598,
-0.19453556835651398,
-0.7756494879722595,
0.24952062964439392,
0.003189748851582408,
0.2924997806549072,
0.07222572714090347,
0.08616940677165985,
-0.22211182117462158,
0.41640132665634155,
-0.5108076930046082,
0.3980087637901306,
-0.5351510047912598,
0.02373945526778698,
0.7186091542243958,
0.3016131520271301,
0.34343039989471436,
-0.23942163586616516,
-0.5588176250457764,
0.7238079309463501,
-0.6595646739006042,
-0.0020813995506614447,
0.5575090646743774,
0.46789979934692383,
0.051578689366579056,
0.79082190990448,
0.022751275449991226,
0.5913613438606262,
0.037529055029153824,
-0.12899577617645264,
0.3084379732608795,
-0.5362258553504944,
-0.018282027915120125,
-0.13881348073482513,
0.5904126167297363,
0.23777608573436737,
0.010974052362143993,
-0.13212385773658752,
-0.2823384404182434,
0.04467509314417839,
0.36008182168006897,
-0.2902579605579376,
0.10951127111911774,
0.33714863657951355,
-0.5009663701057434,
-0.19200333952903748,
0.1620270311832428,
-0.3792729377746582,
-0.22872218489646912,
-0.7092330455780029,
0.3565821647644043,
0.057642288506031036,
-0.6425026059150696,
0.32239437103271484,
-0.2431536465883255,
-0.04357751086354256,
0.34133318066596985,
-1.3839035034179688,
0.5367859601974487,
0.9816554188728333,
0.9289292097091675,
-0.5671623349189758,
-0.38942113518714905,
-0.036374252289533615,
0.5140697360038757,
-0.1061515212059021,
0.8166336417198181,
-0.6082236766815186,
-0.37245288491249084,
-0.01676940731704235,
-0.23637741804122925,
-0.13698555529117584,
-0.5476621389389038,
-0.14618681371212006,
-0.5143430233001709,
0.33683452010154724,
-0.3803267776966095,
-0.5719438195228577,
-0.196332648396492,
0.5327109098434448,
-0.7116075158119202,
0.7071008086204529,
0.030092056840658188,
-0.3691816031932831,
0.3170468211174011,
-0.5655818581581116,
-0.05829095467925072,
0.27086305618286133,
-0.4046557545661926,
-0.19229552149772644,
0.27855950593948364,
-0.17215074598789215,
0.28187698125839233,
0.08592776209115982,
0.4651031196117401,
-0.7182492017745972,
-0.22865796089172363,
0.1257239133119583,
-0.11825532466173172,
0.811066210269928,
-0.12758734822273254,
-0.1835687905550003,
0.5118635892868042,
-0.3282136917114258,
-0.07477544993162155,
-0.4209056794643402,
-0.6456499099731445,
-0.25332173705101013,
0.1371445506811142,
-0.03210679814219475,
0.29344967007637024,
0.5095006823539734,
-0.41243457794189453,
0.638664722442627,
-0.2355804741382599,
0.33084967732429504,
1.0008598566055298,
-0.37054166197776794,
0.6487019062042236,
-0.5189482569694519,
0.39019155502319336,
0.05722975358366966,
0.20835644006729126,
0.23683984577655792,
-0.6187305450439453,
-0.36240673065185547,
-0.4370585083961487,
0.06152524799108505,
0.5566646456718445,
-0.20967799425125122,
0.8248764276504517,
-0.18339131772518158,
-0.31718945503234863,
-0.2997432053089142,
0.47059598565101624,
0.15392236411571503,
-0.040700577199459076,
0.3575555384159088,
-0.6939226984977722,
-0.5941931009292603,
-1.2147308588027954,
0.1291983425617218,
-0.352855920791626,
0.1956203281879425,
0.16367395222187042,
0.4147656559944153,
-0.4579176604747772,
1.046391487121582,
-0.3675232231616974,
-0.35519734025001526,
-0.4781094491481781,
-0.04028493911027908,
0.17247264087200165,
0.34919482469558716,
0.23080910742282867,
-0.7225157022476196,
-0.4124540686607361,
0.27723366022109985,
-0.41507652401924133,
0.11678378283977509,
0.4025096297264099,
-0.09068164229393005,
0.09619343280792236,
0.17972032725811005,
-0.5444630980491638,
-0.11781220883131027,
0.8389333486557007,
-0.07113111764192581,
0.7343916893005371,
0.1258847862482071,
-0.1034168004989624,
-1.5628838539123535,
-0.12972648441791534,
-0.3571230471134186,
-0.0703180804848671,
-0.6358539462089539,
-0.023445790633559227,
0.059182826429605484,
0.23582974076271057,
-0.4116190969944,
0.44520702958106995,
-0.3914557099342346,
-0.24046854674816132,
-0.14779424667358398,
0.22361107170581818,
-0.0040530310943722725,
0.3971827030181885,
-0.04548254981637001,
0.44280391931533813,
0.20775333046913147,
-0.16399461030960083,
0.6270395517349243,
0.4066116511821747,
-0.10635066777467728,
0.5297607183456421,
-0.330647349357605,
0.019248569384217262,
-0.13327421247959137,
0.5168187618255615,
-0.8566629886627197,
-0.17226941883563995,
0.07827813923358917,
-0.10622644424438477,
-0.18244047462940216,
-0.28657713532447815,
-0.461662232875824,
-0.17583049833774567,
-0.3932002782821655,
0.823671281337738,
0.3080986738204956,
-0.3050093650817871,
0.8016237616539001,
0.59149169921875,
-0.3514249920845032,
-0.7736935019493103,
-0.5936362743377686,
0.08789214491844177,
-0.25847363471984863,
-0.794693112373352,
0.2184092253446579,
-0.5012894868850708,
-0.5992771983146667,
-0.10516182333230972,
-0.03038477711379528,
-0.2023230642080307,
-0.03235146030783653,
-0.047663185745477676,
0.271065354347229,
-0.5164813995361328,
0.3141312897205353,
0.07281754910945892,
0.023827509954571724,
-0.26444143056869507,
-0.7203276753425598,
0.40801775455474854,
-0.31056052446365356,
-0.6821650266647339,
-0.08545778691768646,
0.6899778842926025,
0.6536550521850586,
-0.10400412231683731,
0.5779489874839783,
0.30630144476890564,
-0.42002734541893005,
-0.03795570135116577,
-0.8654476404190063,
0.07874073833227158,
-0.4939277172088623,
0.10217196494340897,
-0.04346262663602829,
-1.2982264757156372,
0.5179509520530701,
0.16252225637435913,
0.35938745737075806,
0.19342286884784698,
0.842176079750061,
-0.038000352680683136,
0.8312274813652039,
0.6653949022293091,
-0.24982410669326782,
0.3634053170681,
0.23408067226409912,
0.0864860936999321,
-0.6757662296295166,
-0.3160873353481293,
-0.1525270789861679,
-0.7702383995056152,
-0.12361869215965271,
-0.5467002987861633,
0.16329358518123627,
0.04157215356826782,
0.035834502428770065,
0.2970474064350128,
-0.26022183895111084,
0.635197639465332,
0.3113403022289276,
-0.16510988771915436,
0.5859112739562988,
-0.34957969188690186,
-0.10574157536029816,
-0.10652661323547363,
-0.6749293208122253,
-0.6633055210113525,
0.9387973546981812,
0.1123628169298172,
0.64517742395401,
0.8470650315284729,
0.8920614719390869,
0.2588253915309906,
0.35855355858802795,
-0.8676541447639465,
0.46865344047546387,
-0.2688969373703003,
-0.7243750691413879,
-0.29388439655303955,
-0.08095405995845795,
-0.7538727521896362,
0.6454140543937683,
-0.22260136902332306,
-0.6672713160514832,
0.3054673671722412,
0.22427310049533844,
-0.3812204599380493,
0.5076133608818054,
-0.7100843787193298,
0.8156316876411438,
-0.170644611120224,
0.030219493433833122,
-0.34865644574165344,
-0.5761121511459351,
0.7560266256332397,
-0.26768338680267334,
0.35462886095046997,
-0.3147064745426178,
-0.29563361406326294,
0.20376203954219818,
-0.12628863751888275,
1.23209547996521,
0.1302829384803772,
-0.3474631607532501,
-0.07354099303483963,
-0.11688809841871262,
0.2183883786201477,
0.20036286115646362,
-0.09082960337400436,
0.11493872851133347,
-0.17908233404159546,
-0.6245449781417847,
-0.5688275098800659,
0.8557542562484741,
-0.8173981308937073,
-0.8272449970245361,
0.013397100381553173,
-0.6916258931159973,
-0.1456676572561264,
0.3157128393650055,
-0.1764070838689804,
0.37536078691482544,
-0.44362565875053406,
0.1646004468202591,
0.8761320114135742,
0.32964062690734863,
0.36209797859191895,
0.4079365134239197,
-0.42119044065475464,
-0.6095272898674011,
0.8774535655975342,
0.19095158576965332,
0.678917646408081,
0.39415085315704346,
0.17277933657169342,
-0.1475926786661148,
-0.8149365186691284,
-0.49472907185554504,
-0.05107908695936203,
-0.5941978096961975,
-0.05165843293070793,
-0.7078895568847656,
-0.05511128529906273,
-0.6043141484260559,
-0.48128509521484375,
-0.34993311762809753,
-0.7079684138298035,
-0.328769326210022,
-0.19832485914230347,
-0.1924411952495575,
1.089548945426941,
-0.09885593503713608,
0.10209176689386368,
-0.9139513373374939,
0.2522639036178589,
0.8097753524780273,
0.27989518642425537,
-0.1756896674633026,
-0.16606822609901428,
-0.20200426876544952,
-0.17170283198356628,
-0.2573525905609131,
-0.7406107783317566,
-0.1024959459900856,
-0.13115955889225006,
0.7974227070808411,
0.31739744544029236,
-0.2566033899784088,
0.6325249075889587,
-0.445536345243454,
0.8562001585960388,
0.49262097477912903,
-1.1075074672698975,
0.17421075701713562,
-0.5030631422996521,
0.5091785192489624,
0.6004661917686462,
0.06747076660394669,
-0.8797208070755005,
-0.7209445238113403,
-0.48310285806655884,
-0.8180553317070007,
0.3299943506717682,
-0.07169007509946823,
0.37982478737831116,
0.003010376123711467,
-0.05835486575961113,
0.513668417930603,
0.3697252869606018,
-1.046347737312317,
-0.03659364581108093,
-0.13501539826393127,
-0.4062664210796356,
-0.006595667451620102,
-0.24909327924251556,
-0.5638971328735352,
-0.1547805666923523,
0.4750983715057373,
-0.4318448007106781,
-0.24582335352897644,
-0.16246798634529114,
-0.30177679657936096,
-0.17049387097358704,
0.5540376901626587,
0.9454190135002136,
0.9747167825698853,
0.1853434443473816,
0.49061426520347595,
0.2609381377696991,
-0.008235822431743145,
0.32884886860847473,
-0.26772820949554443,
-0.05016087740659714,
-0.17672646045684814,
0.21464264392852783,
0.351280152797699,
0.3560408353805542,
-0.2926942706108093,
0.5697969198226929,
0.03542518988251686,
-0.382222980260849,
-0.29431915283203125,
0.14183001220226288,
0.6618512272834778,
0.529241681098938,
0.2960543632507324,
0.456915944814682,
-0.17309947311878204,
-0.43984732031822205,
0.16767770051956177,
0.7351588010787964,
-0.4219614565372467,
-0.6136202812194824,
0.2078317105770111,
0.30180713534355164,
-0.43432798981666565,
0.06934024393558502,
0.06116771325469017,
-0.4448160231113434,
0.4521130621433258,
0.36157917976379395,
0.7219967246055603,
-0.2160952389240265,
0.32918161153793335,
0.04573383182287216,
0.4414944350719452,
-0.34564727544784546,
0.21680186688899994,
0.0635453537106514,
-1.0733646154403687,
-0.4256841242313385,
-0.38545727729797363,
-0.5038121938705444,
-0.2965541183948517,
-0.6481185555458069,
0.2981564998626709,
-0.59330815076828,
-0.0115802101790905,
-0.1622215062379837,
-0.17489027976989746,
-0.01430167444050312,
-0.2202492505311966,
0.31170427799224854,
0.8094403743743896,
-0.8530709743499756,
0.7193884253501892,
0.6619600653648376,
-0.25817957520484924,
-0.4105899930000305,
0.0038396762683987617,
0.49853384494781494,
-0.7512480020523071,
0.26341816782951355,
0.16853122413158417,
-0.15485060214996338,
-0.09554356336593628,
-0.4167639911174774,
-0.8925890922546387,
1.2079349756240845,
0.3161087930202484,
-0.5118201971054077,
0.04105718061327934,
-0.014332425780594349,
0.34280452132225037,
-0.6568892002105713,
-0.17167571187019348,
0.18912732601165771,
0.6580495834350586,
-0.05259768292307854,
-0.9337984323501587,
-0.04713243618607521,
-0.09889408200979233,
-0.12361820787191391,
0.436006635427475,
-1.040597677230835,
0.807685375213623,
-0.14345192909240723,
-0.016350239515304565,
0.04981732740998268,
0.5980802774429321,
0.36164140701293945,
0.039375390857458115,
0.4950311779975891,
0.5272097587585449,
0.7469307780265808,
0.2313009798526764,
0.3208383023738861,
0.07032785564661026,
0.2500563859939575,
0.9220239520072937,
-0.43933039903640747,
0.8840650320053101,
0.6760437488555908,
-0.12711329758167267,
0.7407118082046509,
0.3085818588733673,
-0.0439152866601944,
0.14517197012901306,
0.18187202513217926,
-0.595481276512146,
-0.37951987981796265,
0.06658121198415756,
-0.39827200770378113,
0.030055386945605278,
0.2556706964969635,
0.08642499148845673,
-0.05643473565578461,
-0.25112009048461914,
-0.405600905418396,
0.20060697197914124,
-0.174518883228302,
0.938169538974762,
0.14356547594070435,
-0.5819610357284546,
0.14240066707134247,
-0.11773061007261276,
0.9253721833229065,
-0.6166596412658691,
0.47181209921836853,
-0.1629253327846527,
-0.027250854298472404,
-0.5783799290657043,
-0.6677227020263672,
0.3553430438041687,
-0.5618784427642822,
-0.7376626133918762,
-0.3202822208404541,
0.4782729148864746,
-0.8613374829292297,
-0.48786360025405884,
0.37723246216773987,
0.7531653642654419,
-0.16586503386497498,
0.3265000879764557,
-0.5552380084991455,
-0.07740632444620132,
-0.06828474253416061,
-0.00966569036245346,
0.44412103295326233,
0.27629217505455017,
-0.193425714969635,
0.5086098313331604,
0.5681562423706055,
0.12270335853099823,
0.1871670037508011,
0.07081732898950577,
0.8742383122444153,
-0.7143237590789795,
-0.29798027873039246,
-0.9443631768226624,
0.7293444871902466,
-0.10423624515533447,
-0.302226722240448,
0.5841545462608337,
0.7466775178909302,
0.8643627166748047,
0.11332099139690399,
0.958561897277832,
0.03652853146195412,
0.0745939314365387,
-0.4186237156391144,
0.36806339025497437,
-0.6126542091369629,
0.3469841778278351,
-0.01979965716600418,
-1.098249912261963,
-0.5742520093917847,
0.08308534324169159,
-0.21391531825065613,
-0.18480613827705383,
0.606948733329773,
0.8066026568412781,
-0.36319392919540405,
0.11759574711322784,
0.5401275753974915,
-0.06716911494731903,
0.2460910528898239,
0.25372061133384705,
0.9860579967498779,
0.22496628761291504,
0.47938984632492065,
0.19910688698291779,
-0.19951499998569489,
-0.07954499125480652,
-0.6384414434432983,
-0.7307447791099548,
-0.39759278297424316,
-0.14813069999217987,
0.062272898852825165,
-0.17480872571468353,
1.2779330015182495,
0.7466828227043152,
-0.8203001022338867,
-0.641232430934906,
0.12760029733181,
0.5634581446647644,
-0.06971696019172668,
-0.1795332282781601,
-0.3594333529472351,
-0.3459447920322418,
-0.6230401992797852,
0.576572597026825,
0.7877776026725769,
0.05641577020287514,
-0.767124354839325,
-0.09408049285411835,
-0.3992655277252197,
0.09543176740407944,
0.5874330997467041,
0.1860092133283615,
-1.1198829412460327,
-0.36847642064094543,
-0.06349983811378479,
-0.2979162931442261,
0.3324441909790039,
1.1331980228424072,
-0.2354373186826706,
0.32997819781303406,
0.46934810280799866,
0.521764874458313,
0.04565524682402611,
0.11720077693462372,
0.9382158517837524,
-0.8019731044769287,
-0.052008919417858124,
0.29456278681755066,
0.3839430510997772,
0.1727542132139206,
-0.16474522650241852,
-0.06684858351945877,
0.3535250127315521,
-0.5988113284111023,
-0.561603844165802,
0.7535653114318848,
-0.9510825872421265,
-0.33563101291656494,
1.0735613107681274,
0.008414708077907562,
0.05839959904551506,
-0.5350788831710815,
-0.18888923525810242,
-0.3622296452522278,
-0.40029841661453247,
0.8631300926208496,
0.8883062601089478,
-0.02294401451945305,
0.09068241715431213,
-0.10282197594642639,
-0.001638782792724669,
0.5687157511711121,
-0.7720364332199097,
0.03365695849061012,
0.7777748703956604,
0.37020277976989746,
0.2825058698654175,
0.8241994976997375,
-0.012046651914715767,
0.10453461855649948,
-0.47168222069740295,
0.14770124852657318,
0.23889048397541046,
-0.1337910294532776,
-0.4766138195991516,
0.36481529474258423,
0.14743275940418243,
0.2262897789478302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15948v1 | Teaching LLMs to Abstain across Languages via Multilingual Feedback | 2024-06-22T21:59:12 | 2024-06-22T21:59:12 | Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yike Wang, Wenxuan Ding, Orevaoghene Ahia, Shuyue Stella Li, Vidhisha Balachandran, Sunayana Sitaram, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual LLMs often have knowledge disparities across languages, with
larger gaps in under-resourced languages. Teaching LLMs to abstain in the face
of knowledge gaps is thus a promising strategy to mitigate hallucinations in
multilingual settings. However, previous studies on LLM abstention primarily
focus on English; we find that directly applying existing solutions beyond
English results in up to 20.5% performance gaps between high and low-resource
languages, potentially due to LLMs' drop in calibration and reasoning beyond a
few resource-rich languages. To this end, we propose strategies to enhance LLM
abstention by learning from multilingual feedback, where LLMs self-reflect on
proposed answers in one language by generating multiple feedback items in
related languages: we show that this helps identifying the knowledge gaps
across diverse languages, cultures, and communities. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our multilingual feedback approach outperforms various strong
baselines, achieving up to 9.2% improvement for low-resource languages across
three black-box and open models on three datasets, featuring open-book,
closed-book, and commonsense QA. Further analysis reveals that multilingual
feedback is both an effective and a more equitable abstain strategy to serve
diverse language speakers, and cultural factors have great impact on language
selection and LLM abstention behavior, highlighting future directions for
multilingual and multi-cultural reliable language modeling. | [
-0.4914817810058594,
-0.7058175802230835,
0.4672413468360901,
0.31009793281555176,
-0.16374436020851135,
0.42042076587677,
-0.6129551529884338,
-0.5692031383514404,
0.28995829820632935,
0.44724687933921814,
-0.7250794768333435,
-0.5454256534576416,
-0.3429742455482483,
0.24318407475948334,
0.15157277882099152,
0.9201737642288208,
-0.27449196577072144,
0.5046348571777344,
-0.34826454520225525,
-0.35390233993530273,
-0.7100828289985657,
-0.63517826795578,
-0.30652865767478943,
-0.6674742102622986,
0.7017895579338074,
0.6408922672271729,
0.1409415900707245,
0.26355981826782227,
0.33601993322372437,
0.2294451892375946,
0.1189364343881607,
0.44083842635154724,
-0.5645139217376709,
0.08794698864221573,
-0.250760942697525,
-0.6588037610054016,
-0.0043112244457006454,
-0.11954999715089798,
0.5681809782981873,
0.7845707535743713,
-0.4246443510055542,
-0.02469785511493683,
0.4612469971179962,
0.7484151721000671,
-0.7914559245109558,
0.08460691571235657,
-0.49150535464286804,
0.33648571372032166,
-0.14739389717578888,
-0.14837761223316193,
-0.4761938452720642,
-0.4522523581981659,
-0.2664790451526642,
-0.5688271522521973,
0.01447305642068386,
-0.2668116092681885,
0.3875553011894226,
0.4375021457672119,
-0.4658486247062683,
-0.38387352228164673,
-0.857088029384613,
0.8269111514091492,
-0.4292945861816406,
0.6786962151527405,
0.6296781301498413,
-0.033694084733724594,
0.16124185919761658,
-0.0761859118938446,
-0.27816376090049744,
-0.24698607623577118,
-0.20674781501293182,
0.39474618434906006,
0.1466652899980545,
-0.234152689576149,
-0.14888189733028412,
0.03629205375909805,
-0.3036019504070282,
0.370400607585907,
-0.5247001051902771,
-0.30811718106269836,
0.3956698477268219,
-0.07915878295898438,
0.013506030663847923,
0.08663197606801987,
-0.5532941818237305,
0.2779114544391632,
-1.1420892477035522,
-0.05096566304564476,
0.4963741898536682,
0.41243869066238403,
-0.05795922130346298,
0.3774712383747101,
0.054271481931209564,
0.3508512079715729,
-0.22449056804180145,
-0.38591018319129944,
0.07583066821098328,
-0.2337607741355896,
0.30501827597618103,
-0.03033389337360859,
0.5281183123588562,
0.3728027641773224,
0.3091047704219818,
-0.26597219705581665,
-0.18604926764965057,
0.11210249364376068,
0.07021576166152954,
-0.6641911268234253,
-0.0008004064438864589,
0.07557565718889236,
-0.21602551639080048,
0.2929929792881012,
-0.10934749990701675,
-0.8722416162490845,
-0.5182944536209106,
-0.28156426548957825,
0.2162150740623474,
-0.37676677107810974,
-0.43112045526504517,
0.0798264667391777,
0.18766476213932037,
0.10828045010566711,
0.3931983411312103,
-0.895969033241272,
0.4117007851600647,
0.4053787887096405,
0.6947268843650818,
-0.3071770966053009,
-0.5459825992584229,
-0.3829638957977295,
0.2726789712905884,
-0.3442606031894684,
0.677560567855835,
-0.3744324743747711,
-0.5255577564239502,
0.07140824943780899,
0.027071915566921234,
-0.008438349701464176,
-0.6928912997245789,
0.1606973260641098,
-0.33705374598503113,
0.13724736869335175,
-0.557167649269104,
-0.4574729800224304,
-0.428678959608078,
0.3909318447113037,
-0.5076521635055542,
0.6224642395973206,
-0.28158798813819885,
-0.2884381115436554,
0.3016228973865509,
-0.36235398054122925,
-0.5315213203430176,
0.1299131065607071,
-0.29415181279182434,
-0.09045935422182083,
0.1421944797039032,
0.4186273217201233,
0.09863723814487457,
0.0013371027307584882,
0.004013499245047569,
-0.17778584361076355,
-0.31799355149269104,
0.20071394741535187,
-0.6106205582618713,
0.5267541408538818,
0.2947567105293274,
-0.39945048093795776,
0.049732547253370285,
-0.29261890053749084,
0.04365920647978783,
0.11321230232715607,
-0.3669750690460205,
-0.3920460343360901,
-0.20598621666431427,
-0.1115049347281456,
0.15464332699775696,
-0.04701917991042137,
-0.4172621965408325,
0.15004977583885193,
-0.3958956003189087,
0.05981333553791046,
0.7165114283561707,
0.010424845851957798,
0.07546042650938034,
-0.46544498205184937,
0.8657768368721008,
0.02892652340233326,
0.014580312184989452,
-0.18216627836227417,
-0.19244614243507385,
-0.788479208946228,
-0.27642756700515747,
0.003157486207783222,
0.7505061030387878,
-0.9994633197784424,
0.053576722741127014,
0.11691395938396454,
-0.3147905468940735,
-0.7405107021331787,
0.7952570915222168,
0.7888208031654358,
0.32289135456085205,
0.4040825664997101,
-0.5703089237213135,
-0.3717315196990967,
-0.7601578235626221,
-0.09348192065954208,
-0.2897629737854004,
0.18070924282073975,
-0.0009267567656934261,
0.46016770601272583,
0.06100986525416374,
0.45158475637435913,
-0.2664826810359955,
-0.5173060297966003,
-0.35223644971847534,
-0.172478586435318,
0.07064415514469147,
0.3518439829349518,
0.417076975107193,
-0.5154930949211121,
-0.3939354717731476,
0.09861771762371063,
-0.7062559723854065,
-0.12984654307365417,
-0.10654392838478088,
-0.019415272399783134,
0.5292163491249084,
0.19645673036575317,
-0.3373437523841858,
0.23571018874645233,
0.5768715739250183,
-0.10823976248502731,
0.6776795983314514,
-0.215408056974411,
0.12337090075016022,
-0.9744824767112732,
-0.10619847476482391,
-0.13699126243591309,
-0.056872256100177765,
-0.4954346716403961,
0.20286427438259125,
0.043163977563381195,
0.3243735134601593,
-0.7262597680091858,
0.6275437474250793,
-0.7209009528160095,
0.22114351391792297,
-0.2673627734184265,
0.2844700813293457,
0.04563901200890541,
0.5684598684310913,
0.3635123670101166,
0.6211602687835693,
0.2316066324710846,
-0.6626517176628113,
0.31341931223869324,
0.3051331341266632,
-0.3953007459640503,
0.6224910020828247,
-0.24140509963035583,
0.12354888021945953,
-0.18039698898792267,
0.07441230118274689,
-0.8128701448440552,
0.03075375221669674,
0.361258864402771,
-0.26695749163627625,
0.41505196690559387,
-0.2049056738615036,
-0.19837269186973572,
-0.3613814413547516,
-0.3652620315551758,
0.35186395049095154,
0.12156512588262558,
-0.7003561854362488,
0.3343517780303955,
0.2744922637939453,
-0.2666904330253601,
-1.0718326568603516,
-0.9201642274856567,
-0.10524764657020569,
-0.16690246760845184,
-0.21896061301231384,
0.036860935389995575,
-0.43763628602027893,
-0.5203883051872253,
-0.017341187223792076,
-0.04863271862268448,
0.014156142249703407,
0.2209310084581375,
0.052362557500600815,
0.18206816911697388,
0.1571437269449234,
0.4457673132419586,
-0.080263152718544,
-0.12242782860994339,
0.04450787603855133,
-0.35777631402015686,
0.644309937953949,
-0.4230189621448517,
-1.0125480890274048,
-0.20313197374343872,
0.46229907870292664,
0.31573936343193054,
-0.3789973258972168,
0.7599565386772156,
0.6563169956207275,
-0.3004210889339447,
-0.19595053791999817,
-0.7196112871170044,
-0.5283002257347107,
-0.4205346405506134,
0.34438177943229675,
-0.4776971936225891,
-0.8660148978233337,
0.7604798674583435,
0.059149593114852905,
0.14204493165016174,
0.11039289832115173,
0.834963321685791,
0.02703891135752201,
0.5722890496253967,
0.6748687624931335,
-0.043799858540296555,
0.17716775834560394,
-0.4002087414264679,
0.17263807356357574,
-0.607528805732727,
-0.34442657232284546,
-0.32763025164604187,
-0.1423143744468689,
-0.3992291986942291,
-0.41872328519821167,
0.36723044514656067,
0.3109267055988312,
0.14028245210647583,
-0.16931892931461334,
-0.2128497064113617,
0.7379686832427979,
0.5142701864242554,
0.17992448806762695,
0.41031160950660706,
0.07637584209442139,
-0.5648514032363892,
-0.4163859486579895,
-0.6416792869567871,
-0.28210145235061646,
0.8147199749946594,
0.238739475607872,
0.8976800441741943,
0.35076069831848145,
0.8965594172477722,
0.02432682365179062,
0.5883488655090332,
-0.8491714596748352,
0.18240311741828918,
-0.03750946745276451,
-0.4738065004348755,
-0.2736986577510834,
-0.4790247082710266,
-0.730050265789032,
0.529155969619751,
0.0505184531211853,
-0.5952296853065491,
0.09653394669294357,
0.018318455666303635,
-0.4129762351512909,
0.5866484045982361,
-0.6947746872901917,
0.578323483467102,
-0.6529061794281006,
-0.7224639058113098,
-0.2659030556678772,
-0.40767648816108704,
0.42739027738571167,
-0.38660097122192383,
0.6960428357124329,
-0.14704298973083496,
0.03685103356838226,
0.4468608498573303,
-0.32713553309440613,
1.232715129852295,
-0.20440934598445892,
-0.5804192423820496,
0.26784706115722656,
0.32668277621269226,
0.3341182768344879,
0.31020915508270264,
0.028148749843239784,
0.26825788617134094,
-0.0882454439997673,
-0.3273916244506836,
-0.5573176741600037,
0.5866249799728394,
-0.7655414938926697,
-0.8533867597579956,
-0.07418008893728256,
-0.6983542442321777,
-0.41303035616874695,
0.11688906699419022,
0.30937591195106506,
0.0826411247253418,
-0.039620425552129745,
-0.1144816130399704,
0.5986126065254211,
-0.2922114431858063,
0.4912368059158325,
1.1111832857131958,
-0.47575604915618896,
-0.6985061764717102,
0.9268276691436768,
0.23833119869232178,
0.32569071650505066,
0.3044246435165405,
0.20305564999580383,
-0.6610450744628906,
-0.5627164244651794,
-0.4369949400424957,
0.45287758111953735,
-0.9429439902305603,
-0.2760651409626007,
-0.3587462306022644,
-0.1052328497171402,
-0.46107518672943115,
-0.1635226607322693,
-0.3990921378135681,
-0.3592718839645386,
-0.07853621989488602,
-0.40414851903915405,
0.09953368455171585,
0.891207218170166,
-0.5171074867248535,
0.04389851167798042,
-0.8384522199630737,
0.02173864096403122,
0.16535937786102295,
0.40999460220336914,
0.20822246372699738,
-0.4092658758163452,
-0.37381720542907715,
0.10229483991861343,
-0.5094739198684692,
-1.0280758142471313,
0.5226097702980042,
0.23326218128204346,
0.9484662413597107,
0.52858966588974,
0.21462440490722656,
0.8169467449188232,
-0.35440292954444885,
0.623637855052948,
0.4198665916919708,
-0.9575024843215942,
0.49081704020500183,
-0.025087738409638405,
0.3772137463092804,
0.44699588418006897,
0.6727611422538757,
-1.0956088304519653,
-0.8687830567359924,
0.03799568489193916,
-0.971306324005127,
0.5212145447731018,
-0.1787608414888382,
0.2644910216331482,
-0.07587407529354095,
0.20218026638031006,
0.5791422128677368,
0.3653157353401184,
-1.2239162921905518,
-0.3044385015964508,
-0.1930292695760727,
0.03395979851484299,
-0.1641155332326889,
-0.2571495771408081,
-0.45855438709259033,
-0.3324267864227295,
0.7510706782341003,
-0.28516295552253723,
-0.08176174759864807,
0.2415579855442047,
-0.43080997467041016,
-0.2274625450372696,
0.4762124717235565,
0.820975124835968,
0.9499927759170532,
0.1936389058828354,
0.3773324489593506,
0.5984590649604797,
-0.5383948683738708,
0.41794317960739136,
-0.12735730409622192,
-0.14809343218803406,
-0.15172834694385529,
0.6191714406013489,
0.570112407207489,
-0.027112487703561783,
-0.37219253182411194,
0.05707510933279991,
-0.016716355457901955,
-0.2917744517326355,
-0.23045842349529266,
-0.24573710560798645,
0.16463501751422882,
0.15416111052036285,
0.3013833463191986,
-0.2081409990787506,
-0.29805752635002136,
-0.37460753321647644,
0.2848324179649353,
0.31846192479133606,
-0.604226291179657,
-0.20362596213817596,
0.5640945434570312,
0.22300587594509125,
0.002304823137819767,
0.5271899700164795,
-0.1348833441734314,
-0.6537742614746094,
0.45742881298065186,
0.7515980005264282,
0.6986204981803894,
-0.5263037085533142,
0.2801658809185028,
0.24371486902236938,
0.7026017904281616,
0.13847875595092773,
0.3448127210140228,
-0.14009256660938263,
-1.0591107606887817,
-0.6645686030387878,
-0.4871945381164551,
-0.5498732924461365,
0.10105878114700317,
-0.7819163799285889,
-0.052455492317676544,
-0.29222264885902405,
0.06674351543188095,
-0.49076130986213684,
0.17568805813789368,
-0.44155752658843994,
-0.2221960872411728,
0.24211567640304565,
0.6812124848365784,
-0.8677910566329956,
0.7589573860168457,
0.7841055393218994,
-0.5667862892150879,
-0.6503825187683105,
0.043030157685279846,
0.44044652581214905,
-0.8384921550750732,
0.5071614384651184,
0.32872501015663147,
-0.42804500460624695,
-0.18883009254932404,
-0.2111227661371231,
-0.6301474571228027,
0.6358721852302551,
0.6636182069778442,
-0.5861674547195435,
0.5974220037460327,
0.21923713386058807,
0.4939305782318115,
-0.1707189679145813,
0.43451127409935,
0.3152322471141815,
0.6483668684959412,
0.022913135588169098,
-0.8946964144706726,
-0.09571309387683868,
-0.17984949052333832,
-0.16659153997898102,
0.17397092282772064,
-0.9356757998466492,
0.47336679697036743,
-0.5311745405197144,
-0.19582480192184448,
-0.1794770359992981,
0.49972137808799744,
0.3740604817867279,
0.23217637836933136,
0.626143217086792,
0.48796698451042175,
0.9908370971679688,
-0.011128086596727371,
0.6775074005126953,
-0.48294469714164734,
0.11606064438819885,
1.1231595277786255,
-0.6665129661560059,
0.753749668598175,
0.6172997355461121,
0.012675506062805653,
0.42902907729148865,
0.6141378879547119,
0.16397452354431152,
0.5529378652572632,
0.2320040911436081,
-0.4439983665943146,
-0.30048465728759766,
-0.47897908091545105,
-0.30678799748420715,
0.5659918785095215,
0.48897668719291687,
0.11544287949800491,
-0.2450360655784607,
0.3300952613353729,
0.26399704813957214,
0.4822031855583191,
-0.21209941804409027,
0.7173983454704285,
0.16895727813243866,
-0.8980877995491028,
0.8189853429794312,
-0.13841207325458527,
0.6729929447174072,
-0.6773549318313599,
-0.10420868545770645,
-0.7759275436401367,
0.29366227984428406,
-0.32429608702659607,
-0.6568840742111206,
0.4087466895580292,
-0.11246006935834885,
-0.22690442204475403,
-0.4966334402561188,
0.43732258677482605,
-0.9313263297080994,
-0.4580834209918976,
0.7639955878257751,
0.9540933966636658,
0.21920651197433472,
0.33388081192970276,
-0.3964976370334625,
-0.02016574703156948,
0.13490600883960724,
0.048084236681461334,
0.18633441627025604,
0.1516347974538803,
-0.07208374887704849,
0.9503483176231384,
0.5980460047721863,
0.44988423585891724,
-0.07376968115568161,
0.46132907271385193,
0.6773980259895325,
-0.5258358120918274,
-0.45439663529396057,
-0.9098466634750366,
0.3121996521949768,
0.22229018807411194,
-0.15292486548423767,
1.00437331199646,
0.48145198822021484,
1.2655361890792847,
-0.06819279491901398,
0.8361842036247253,
0.26599156856536865,
0.45725753903388977,
-0.6867579817771912,
0.7544311285018921,
-0.807378351688385,
0.613419771194458,
-0.11616052687168121,
-0.7819646596908569,
-0.27796316146850586,
0.4936082363128662,
-0.21419909596443176,
0.12465466558933258,
0.9115330576896667,
0.8154491186141968,
0.4209805727005005,
-0.15757900476455688,
0.4728792905807495,
0.10673171281814575,
0.2712446451187134,
0.6102706789970398,
1.2631431818008423,
0.13046781718730927,
0.7039269804954529,
-0.604285478591919,
-0.042571060359478,
0.06419222801923752,
-0.5906063914299011,
-0.7557162046432495,
-0.36746126413345337,
-0.2727874219417572,
-0.22779853641986847,
0.1764230579137802,
0.8363497257232666,
0.6448805928230286,
-1.0260872840881348,
-0.6512553095817566,
0.3533615469932556,
0.6986886858940125,
-0.47294101119041443,
-0.1801043152809143,
0.054372549057006836,
-0.6314803957939148,
-0.7072352766990662,
0.5082710385322571,
0.36847665905952454,
0.05423557385802269,
-0.5742617845535278,
-0.4032292366027832,
-0.11428496986627579,
-0.1938350945711136,
0.4770835041999817,
0.19901730120182037,
-0.9799565076828003,
-0.16040903329849243,
0.006725351791828871,
0.019042309373617172,
0.008092163130640984,
0.8278026580810547,
-0.46867835521698,
0.48560336232185364,
0.2623637020587921,
0.4128127098083496,
0.25926581025123596,
-0.14963041245937347,
0.6958218812942505,
-1.203862190246582,
0.4701150059700012,
0.24171215295791626,
0.34473320841789246,
0.4147423803806305,
-0.3096167743206024,
0.6418495774269104,
0.39384013414382935,
-0.3215712606906891,
-0.6872873902320862,
0.3656780421733856,
-0.1583888828754425,
-0.5160138010978699,
1.1715623140335083,
-0.3048437535762787,
-0.09947840869426727,
-0.34299492835998535,
-0.10851219296455383,
0.17611293494701385,
-0.14038358628749847,
0.9782031178474426,
1.0024744272232056,
-0.03063930571079254,
-0.5734826922416687,
-0.41689613461494446,
0.29827651381492615,
0.7225850820541382,
-0.6988266110420227,
0.27915289998054504,
0.5284697413444519,
0.1980084627866745,
0.22352872788906097,
0.7698812484741211,
-0.06412774324417114,
0.18232673406600952,
-0.19847626984119415,
0.5120020508766174,
-0.039698559790849686,
-0.5271148085594177,
-0.6100907325744629,
0.06581265479326248,
0.22220474481582642,
0.08420852571725845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15940v1 | Beyond Individual Facts: Investigating Categorical Knowledge Locality of Taxonomy and Meronomy Concepts in GPT Models | 2024-06-22T21:12:57 | 2024-06-22T21:12:57 | Christopher Burger, Yifan Hu, Thai Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The location of knowledge within Generative Pre-trained Transformer
(GPT)-like models has seen extensive recent investigation. However, much of the
work is focused towards determining locations of individual facts, with the end
goal being the editing of facts that are outdated, erroneous, or otherwise
harmful, without the time and expense of retraining the entire model. In this
work, we investigate a broader view of knowledge location, that of concepts or
clusters of related information, instead of disparate individual facts. To do
this, we first curate a novel dataset, called DARC, that includes a total of 34
concepts of ~120K factual statements divided into two types of hierarchical
categories, namely taxonomy and meronomy. Next, we utilize existing causal
mediation analysis methods developed for determining regions of importance for
individual facts and apply them to a series of related categories to provide
detailed investigation into whether concepts are associated with distinct
regions within these models. We find that related categories exhibit similar
areas of importance in contrast to less similar categories. However,
fine-grained localization of individual category subsets to specific regions is
not apparent. | [
-0.6814009547233582,
-0.787876546382904,
0.8271082639694214,
-0.3809053301811218,
-0.01282899547368288,
-0.08489707857370377,
-0.07410680502653122,
-0.22302629053592682,
0.13434641063213348,
0.5120444297790527,
-0.4149027466773987,
-0.5628699064254761,
-0.6302675604820251,
-0.15621212124824524,
-0.3226897716522217,
1.1740694046020508,
0.225250244140625,
-0.35405150055885315,
-0.4446098804473877,
-0.21246233582496643,
-0.25409629940986633,
-1.033810019493103,
-0.33700454235076904,
-0.30760934948921204,
0.5322309136390686,
0.16022373735904694,
0.684396505355835,
0.7117175459861755,
0.8174446225166321,
0.28085091710090637,
-0.31638863682746887,
0.02819344587624073,
-0.22590769827365875,
-0.3421116769313812,
-0.5172131657600403,
-0.5344758629798889,
-0.3944295644760132,
0.13360531628131866,
0.5771044492721558,
0.7898262739181519,
-0.16358861327171326,
0.3177763819694519,
-0.06193509325385094,
0.40840283036231995,
-0.5512818098068237,
0.2519570589065552,
-0.5774879455566406,
0.09671969711780548,
-0.25982606410980225,
-0.27253738045692444,
-0.10143198817968369,
-0.4094142019748688,
0.6898545026779175,
-0.47900813817977905,
0.9618518948554993,
-0.2235940396785736,
0.9851845502853394,
0.6767099499702454,
-0.9405622482299805,
-0.1900888830423355,
-0.7929462790489197,
0.44123369455337524,
-0.42262372374534607,
0.16866172850131989,
0.5365660190582275,
0.20178623497486115,
0.03973469138145447,
-0.7030442953109741,
-0.4884648621082306,
0.05787905678153038,
-0.7697763442993164,
0.11655176430940628,
-0.33134588599205017,
0.1094442829489708,
0.4279836416244507,
0.37500253319740295,
-0.534756600856781,
-0.20098568499088287,
0.05638166517019272,
-0.11433194577693939,
0.310558944940567,
0.17751522362232208,
0.10920950025320053,
-0.42135995626449585,
-0.5339428186416626,
-0.030998442322015762,
-0.8103345036506653,
-0.07060562074184418,
0.03832922503352165,
0.17052653431892395,
-0.08954956382513046,
0.444662481546402,
-0.15901288390159607,
0.4728122651576996,
0.07835701107978821,
-0.38810697197914124,
0.16212327778339386,
-0.5700100064277649,
-0.08167026191949844,
-0.03016929142177105,
0.5259029269218445,
-0.10379010438919067,
-0.3000260293483734,
-0.3419737219810486,
-0.010499967262148857,
0.03843777999281883,
0.4613361060619354,
-0.4588228464126587,
-0.3774510622024536,
-0.2654454708099365,
-0.4385496973991394,
-0.12716498970985413,
0.24911409616470337,
-0.437873512506485,
-0.47404661774635315,
-0.8065585494041443,
0.4791712760925293,
0.025488372892141342,
-0.36498695611953735,
-0.3085767924785614,
-0.02134930156171322,
0.2910671830177307,
0.07256978005170822,
-0.9951907396316528,
0.19517548382282257,
0.770997166633606,
0.7636805176734924,
-0.021771617233753204,
-0.32157692313194275,
0.10874981433153152,
0.39087602496147156,
-0.21326042711734772,
1.1671698093414307,
-0.4601464867591858,
-0.3287603259086609,
-0.16006740927696228,
0.12520837783813477,
-0.18430086970329285,
-0.5175440907478333,
0.47366899251937866,
-0.7642363905906677,
0.11117373406887054,
-0.7751249670982361,
-0.5876827836036682,
-0.5506865382194519,
0.3256010413169861,
-0.6008698344230652,
0.8417959213256836,
0.08296220004558563,
-1.093672752380371,
0.8290185332298279,
-0.7628180980682373,
-0.5145560503005981,
-0.2628895044326782,
-0.33377525210380554,
-0.23454470932483673,
0.12194763123989105,
0.1187618151307106,
0.5080600380897522,
-0.5649886131286621,
0.7691190242767334,
-0.19411498308181763,
0.07690197974443436,
0.23532098531723022,
-0.4408269226551056,
0.4558367133140564,
0.11439565569162369,
-0.5338796377182007,
0.14447644352912903,
-0.6582319140434265,
-0.478645384311676,
-0.2107575535774231,
-0.020667050033807755,
-0.7088029980659485,
0.0644221231341362,
-0.457120805978775,
0.24779486656188965,
0.18768392503261566,
-0.13610237836837769,
0.4028245806694031,
0.2534000277519226,
0.22188661992549896,
0.644343376159668,
0.23339849710464478,
0.6515617370605469,
-0.23577064275741577,
0.4754943549633026,
0.29167166352272034,
0.4032321572303772,
0.08534064143896103,
-0.6061581373214722,
-0.8840060234069824,
-0.17216508090496063,
0.2134622484445572,
0.19439095258712769,
-0.7743883728981018,
0.3231242895126343,
-0.403946191072464,
-0.3392704129219055,
-0.2765425741672516,
-0.43612587451934814,
0.201059490442276,
0.9207395911216736,
0.44298186898231506,
-0.44713643193244934,
-0.48298102617263794,
-1.0894638299942017,
0.02984149195253849,
-0.23283825814723969,
0.13063935935497284,
0.28211718797683716,
0.7366539239883423,
-0.42990371584892273,
1.4382778406143188,
-0.8252714276313782,
-0.27637308835983276,
0.39991164207458496,
0.4871242344379425,
0.3157455623149872,
0.30951055884361267,
0.5317082405090332,
-0.9278110861778259,
-0.17742371559143066,
0.20840567350387573,
-0.928534209728241,
0.12258546054363251,
-0.0579947866499424,
-0.14493320882320404,
0.026419227942824364,
0.4371051490306854,
-0.6606682538986206,
0.6981695294380188,
0.14865337312221527,
-0.4807890057563782,
0.6470195651054382,
-0.1936880201101303,
0.3397228717803955,
-0.9462864995002747,
0.07568155974149704,
-0.022436967119574547,
-0.0023752087727189064,
-0.705825924873352,
-0.04837729036808014,
-0.14718708395957947,
0.2691086232662201,
-0.0019565587863326073,
0.41817599534988403,
-0.22197175025939941,
-0.22905103862285614,
-0.24496884644031525,
-0.01877145655453205,
-0.27143606543540955,
0.461808979511261,
0.414709210395813,
0.8433513641357422,
0.39490455389022827,
-0.8253801465034485,
0.1127704307436943,
0.3695456385612488,
-0.5044606924057007,
0.49238789081573486,
-0.33499833941459656,
0.024940794333815575,
-0.08876878768205643,
0.223729208111763,
-0.7797977924346924,
-0.14866167306900024,
0.05042891949415207,
-0.26026564836502075,
0.1269267201423645,
-0.3271046280860901,
-0.6386716961860657,
-0.21758411824703217,
0.22421978414058685,
0.4890374541282654,
0.5770987868309021,
-0.6724754571914673,
0.5410998463630676,
0.7130159735679626,
-0.10547903925180435,
-0.5884607434272766,
-0.5180636048316956,
-0.1076902225613594,
-0.6841859817504883,
-0.5091728568077087,
0.14382223784923553,
0.2807965576648712,
-0.4350646734237671,
0.20816129446029663,
-0.24365420639514923,
-0.22036585211753845,
0.0815381109714508,
0.15396803617477417,
-0.006451860070228577,
-0.3449820280075073,
0.6142841577529907,
-0.09820660203695297,
-0.3524799942970276,
0.17992544174194336,
-0.5294756293296814,
0.20051781833171844,
-0.061942338943481445,
-0.24854131042957306,
-0.15046703815460205,
0.04561261460185051,
0.14577743411064148,
-0.2509070932865143,
0.8970868587493896,
0.8395789265632629,
-0.30196377635002136,
-0.045044343918561935,
-0.7331368327140808,
-0.31982311606407166,
-0.4085111916065216,
0.3285345435142517,
-0.3793880045413971,
-0.917194128036499,
0.5916207432746887,
-0.053347449749708176,
-0.3031109571456909,
0.5932040810585022,
0.4810042679309845,
0.014493018388748169,
0.5744631886482239,
1.0063402652740479,
-0.17943233251571655,
0.25349292159080505,
-0.42930564284324646,
0.2588329017162323,
-0.7427024841308594,
-0.2600044906139374,
-0.6678556799888611,
0.018720196560025215,
-0.6694377064704895,
-0.7576354742050171,
0.7144544124603271,
0.030298594385385513,
-0.7993667125701904,
0.34637197852134705,
-0.21814605593681335,
0.47553613781929016,
0.7098652124404907,
0.18704655766487122,
0.6878716349601746,
0.009152733720839024,
0.010513332672417164,
-0.03856317326426506,
-1.2122197151184082,
-0.5098628401756287,
1.0400785207748413,
0.2639477252960205,
0.5370041728019714,
0.34839028120040894,
0.4545636475086212,
0.14513076841831207,
0.692314863204956,
-0.6927406191825867,
0.20808996260166168,
-0.35771888494491577,
-0.8618631958961487,
-0.29762643575668335,
-0.6344366073608398,
-0.7839499711990356,
0.2213609665632248,
0.10179874300956726,
-0.4491189420223236,
0.6053159236907959,
-0.029443945735692978,
-0.39090290665626526,
0.602715015411377,
-0.6312922239303589,
0.7569977045059204,
0.011348108761012554,
-0.08348557353019714,
-0.24717600643634796,
-0.7270704507827759,
0.4596484303474426,
-0.2142956554889679,
0.3383074998855591,
0.032094474881887436,
0.09285808354616165,
0.6685212850570679,
-0.5216343998908997,
1.0080207586288452,
-0.07303399592638016,
-0.4925386905670166,
0.4144149124622345,
0.04257281869649887,
0.2828023135662079,
-0.01664753071963787,
0.39933183789253235,
0.1892469972372055,
-0.10010915249586105,
-0.18698342144489288,
-0.8303878307342529,
0.4834521412849426,
-0.8542481064796448,
-0.8678972721099854,
-0.46762606501579285,
-0.6460047960281372,
-0.36068886518478394,
-0.008761109784245491,
0.3025299906730652,
0.573280394077301,
0.04195258393883705,
0.016901381313800812,
0.9669749140739441,
-0.13340811431407928,
0.13812321424484253,
0.6287114024162292,
0.1424739509820938,
-0.19342266023159027,
0.8999347686767578,
0.2396986484527588,
0.1322302669286728,
0.7267240285873413,
0.3587578237056732,
-0.515360414981842,
-0.18079017102718353,
0.1657208651304245,
0.3944089710712433,
-0.9383719563484192,
-0.2370842844247818,
-0.49665167927742004,
-0.008289211429655552,
-0.3014655113220215,
-0.048737455159425735,
-0.24034865200519562,
-0.34329989552497864,
-0.26334622502326965,
-0.1604563146829605,
0.45659148693084717,
0.902382493019104,
-0.2950704097747803,
0.4616098999977112,
-0.7608203291893005,
0.2217159867286682,
0.6953504681587219,
0.38371551036834717,
0.24654555320739746,
-0.7660307884216309,
-0.3840407729148865,
-0.07572945207357407,
-0.22596809267997742,
-0.5258328914642334,
0.08009389787912369,
-0.1553751528263092,
0.5451148152351379,
0.6848887801170349,
-0.13865230977535248,
1.0783541202545166,
-0.33609986305236816,
0.6967589259147644,
0.21488645672798157,
-0.8365734815597534,
0.4410640299320221,
-0.5369151830673218,
0.05924373120069504,
0.36206936836242676,
0.6099844574928284,
-0.5881748795509338,
0.04909442365169525,
-0.8598483800888062,
-0.503253698348999,
0.710858941078186,
0.18110430240631104,
-0.20709699392318726,
-0.1696239560842514,
0.5975386500358582,
0.10767557471990585,
0.26183342933654785,
-0.6243464946746826,
-0.5451015830039978,
-0.054940447211265564,
0.018395407125353813,
-0.401407927274704,
-0.2805884778499603,
-0.3154284656047821,
-0.41607150435447693,
0.6830995678901672,
-0.06348481774330139,
0.33319559693336487,
0.25143513083457947,
-0.04893529415130615,
0.05042916536331177,
0.21684260666370392,
0.4568704664707184,
0.8006190061569214,
0.034336674958467484,
0.4726194739341736,
0.07736615836620331,
-0.46697917580604553,
0.30395323038101196,
0.06850210577249527,
-0.34037819504737854,
-0.11764751374721527,
0.6142400503158569,
0.8577187657356262,
0.3970690071582794,
-0.00796794518828392,
0.3485853672027588,
0.20486973226070404,
0.017432987689971924,
-0.23287032544612885,
-0.08880411088466644,
-0.08270872384309769,
0.557057797908783,
0.06618214398622513,
0.0797266960144043,
0.27804702520370483,
-0.7616273164749146,
0.414092093706131,
0.22106115520000458,
-0.40229400992393494,
-0.5003785490989685,
0.6521166563034058,
0.0012294478947296739,
0.35095372796058655,
0.6535678505897522,
-0.17679613828659058,
-0.6694825291633606,
0.7537109851837158,
0.3950974941253662,
0.8050736784934998,
-0.16441628336906433,
0.5963935256004333,
0.6125453114509583,
0.450206995010376,
-0.14977902173995972,
-0.41633734107017517,
-0.32170921564102173,
-0.9357430338859558,
-0.4555770754814148,
-0.48757240176200867,
-0.07145949453115463,
-0.05917392671108246,
-0.7208616137504578,
0.15697111189365387,
0.004724978469312191,
-0.45338407158851624,
-0.2779424786567688,
-0.0740237608551979,
-0.7707288861274719,
0.1399054378271103,
0.0701393112540245,
0.5259469151496887,
-0.8842965364456177,
0.7936902046203613,
0.7170296311378479,
-0.43109723925590515,
-0.9651145339012146,
-0.008859926834702492,
0.07601815462112427,
-0.5784921646118164,
0.8117383122444153,
-0.37512755393981934,
0.000643707113340497,
-0.038004934787750244,
-0.49003124237060547,
-1.1727644205093384,
1.4129709005355835,
0.14205588400363922,
-0.45092540979385376,
-0.14943328499794006,
0.25182002782821655,
0.6274493336677551,
-0.10266843438148499,
0.24051202833652496,
1.0731784105300903,
0.48201775550842285,
0.148360013961792,
-0.9509596228599548,
-0.17254264652729034,
0.13500924408435822,
-0.03822150081396103,
0.3910044729709625,
-0.8028602600097656,
0.8519988656044006,
-0.1417040079832077,
-0.15179365873336792,
-0.1776168942451477,
0.36032184958457947,
0.1478549689054489,
0.24288348853588104,
0.29965513944625854,
0.8950385451316833,
0.9291491508483887,
-0.21377043426036835,
1.176979899406433,
0.15496687591075897,
0.8406554460525513,
1.2832205295562744,
0.06361674517393112,
0.1796053946018219,
0.23087593913078308,
-0.5369160771369934,
0.47526413202285767,
0.8329737782478333,
-0.1184363067150116,
0.7671559453010559,
-0.017987124621868134,
-0.35743623971939087,
-0.2613706886768341,
-0.24752885103225708,
-0.46170252561569214,
0.3711767792701721,
0.34567195177078247,
-0.25804752111434937,
-0.31127095222473145,
-0.09400024265050888,
0.13162639737129211,
-0.30568698048591614,
-0.5550966262817383,
1.0080976486206055,
0.08044875413179398,
-0.5000698566436768,
0.3819636404514313,
-0.24792808294296265,
0.4320949614048004,
-0.6614418625831604,
0.06342697143554688,
-0.40920931100845337,
-0.05554637685418129,
-0.29511910676956177,
-0.5431725382804871,
0.24594746530056,
-0.08797778189182281,
-0.412777304649353,
0.004079028498381376,
0.747748076915741,
-0.3582281172275543,
-0.15515120327472687,
-0.024981100112199783,
0.6495758295059204,
0.10765594244003296,
-0.20551183819770813,
-0.40373244881629944,
-0.5732296705245972,
-0.08556336909532547,
-0.07190806418657303,
0.21934577822685242,
1.0522652864456177,
-0.2013598382472992,
0.45914557576179504,
0.4993545114994049,
-0.19697554409503937,
0.09451032429933548,
0.28519266843795776,
0.7070515751838684,
-0.8212097883224487,
-0.5289848446846008,
-0.6866356730461121,
0.4388855993747711,
0.3333057463169098,
-0.3730844557285309,
0.975443422794342,
0.22194728255271912,
0.8089092373847961,
-0.2715747654438019,
0.6909034252166748,
-0.12345031648874283,
0.31822049617767334,
-0.48301810026168823,
0.7418878078460693,
-0.388529509305954,
0.25894054770469666,
-0.5964528322219849,
-1.0172439813613892,
-0.5083960294723511,
0.504561185836792,
-0.6961517930030823,
-0.11211439967155457,
0.8776339292526245,
0.5479944348335266,
-0.011901475489139557,
0.2359650880098343,
0.28160277009010315,
0.49748528003692627,
0.24589340388774872,
0.21994255483150482,
1.2235984802246094,
-0.14128360152244568,
0.11976149678230286,
-0.5856455564498901,
-0.19232261180877686,
0.1420193761587143,
-0.6386794447898865,
-0.8728537559509277,
-1.0053352117538452,
-0.3597167432308197,
0.1598518043756485,
-0.4106643497943878,
0.4832121729850769,
0.7662332653999329,
-0.6568579077720642,
-0.15716882050037384,
-0.20735326409339905,
0.2959912121295929,
-0.12474780529737473,
-0.24191144108772278,
0.9626761674880981,
-0.3761571943759918,
-0.13110408186912537,
-0.05537419393658638,
0.07709663361310959,
0.10935183614492416,
-0.08823772519826889,
0.30102697014808655,
-0.1832873523235321,
-0.19712138175964355,
0.9483660459518433,
-0.07496605813503265,
-0.6406261324882507,
-0.585267186164856,
-0.12025836855173111,
0.17227797210216522,
0.027873868122696877,
1.3143715858459473,
-1.075171947479248,
0.3768364191055298,
0.16270247101783752,
0.5013349652290344,
0.3700738549232483,
0.4039601683616638,
0.1829308122396469,
-0.7430198192596436,
0.1303185522556305,
0.052698493003845215,
0.2574683725833893,
0.14797277748584747,
-0.377128005027771,
0.8369655013084412,
0.7170630693435669,
-0.69669109582901,
-0.5688629746437073,
0.227019265294075,
-0.7217990159988403,
-0.2296845018863678,
1.0088672637939453,
-0.06371589004993439,
-0.08920025080442429,
-0.3253294825553894,
0.08796840906143188,
0.3674542307853699,
0.01897064968943596,
1.0479319095611572,
0.7811671495437622,
-0.1998242884874344,
0.14496448636054993,
-0.4565795958042145,
0.6404054164886475,
0.1336001604795456,
-1.0073844194412231,
-0.022400347515940666,
0.4739590585231781,
0.38173195719718933,
0.4136629104614258,
0.4978359341621399,
-0.22706009447574615,
0.08838031440973282,
0.06643092632293701,
0.15322507917881012,
0.3466257154941559,
-0.5780155062675476,
-0.3443646728992462,
0.13365234434604645,
-0.1812029629945755,
0.16388408839702606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15938v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15938v1 | RuleR: Improving LLM Controllability by Rule-based Data Recycling | 2024-06-22T20:57:12 | 2024-06-22T20:57:12 | Ming Li, Han Chen, Chenguang Wang, Dang Nguyen, Dianqi Li, Tianyi Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) still lack delicate controllability over their
responses, which is critical to enhancing their performance and the user
experience. However, curating supervised fine-tuning (SFT) datasets to improve
LLM controllability usually relies on human experts or proprietary LLMs, which
requires additional costs. To bridge this gap, we propose Rule-based Data
Recycling (RuleR), a data augmentation method incorporating multiple
constraints into the original data samples according to predefined rules, which
creates new training tasks to consolidate the controllability of LLMs. Instead
of creating new data from scratch, RuleR ``recycles'' existing data by simply
applying rule-based edits to their responses and appending the
rule-instructions in their original instructions. Experimental results
demonstrate RuleR's effectiveness in improving LLM controllability while
maintaining general instruction-following capabilities. The code will be
released on https://github.com/MingLiiii/RuleR. | [
-0.35221412777900696,
-0.6453572511672974,
0.2056964486837387,
0.02447568066418171,
-0.21607230603694916,
0.0059308744966983795,
-0.4391380846500397,
-0.30775436758995056,
0.2065882682800293,
0.8912427425384521,
-0.5427466630935669,
-0.191375732421875,
-0.5400964021682739,
-0.05273083597421646,
-0.6142860054969788,
1.0248149633407593,
-0.249613955616951,
-0.08276180177927017,
-0.3340601623058319,
0.036414965987205505,
-0.43967097997665405,
-0.5094606876373291,
-0.36231833696365356,
-0.5132768154144287,
0.3538009226322174,
1.0989515781402588,
0.9535828232765198,
1.3988670110702515,
0.43657198548316956,
0.3242832124233246,
-0.2743613123893738,
0.6767311096191406,
-0.7416303157806396,
-0.15083125233650208,
-0.1275722086429596,
-0.38567817211151123,
-0.7145081758499146,
0.3010745942592621,
0.6055846214294434,
0.647334098815918,
-0.4680602252483368,
0.06097278371453285,
0.38846805691719055,
0.7879915833473206,
-0.4669192135334015,
0.1605904996395111,
-0.5783888697624207,
-0.08064571022987366,
-0.12572823464870453,
-0.5945583581924438,
-0.4866049885749817,
-0.6392313241958618,
-0.3980102241039276,
-0.693623423576355,
0.1540171355009079,
0.04436419904232025,
0.7166978716850281,
0.39052730798721313,
-0.17250582575798035,
-0.36405110359191895,
-0.8777288198471069,
0.6491479873657227,
-0.707648515701294,
0.4952443540096283,
0.5831398963928223,
0.10111980885267258,
-0.3243762254714966,
-0.49854400753974915,
-0.5956920385360718,
-0.10253224521875381,
-0.1976310759782791,
-0.11321722716093063,
-0.0773971676826477,
-0.19244162738323212,
0.29125097393989563,
0.23268719017505646,
-0.19282324612140656,
0.4543602764606476,
-0.6483184099197388,
-0.1645696759223938,
0.7197824120521545,
0.23346182703971863,
0.08714065700769424,
-0.10256665199995041,
-0.25618839263916016,
0.14914332330226898,
-1.0063400268554688,
0.12197266519069672,
0.5114737749099731,
0.30709201097488403,
0.07212583720684052,
0.6931140422821045,
-0.2518170177936554,
0.6309781074523926,
0.4939318895339966,
-0.48170533776283264,
0.4089512228965759,
-0.24986881017684937,
-0.217620849609375,
0.03759446740150452,
0.3586159944534302,
0.8333638906478882,
0.34143999218940735,
-0.3227972686290741,
-0.35890117287635803,
-0.2817324697971344,
0.21964360773563385,
-0.9600018262863159,
-0.6755574345588684,
0.013127898797392845,
-0.32962995767593384,
-0.22305843234062195,
0.14963051676750183,
-0.33617937564849854,
-0.6192058324813843,
-0.8914433121681213,
0.1616152822971344,
-0.5333894491195679,
-0.0612274631857872,
0.3411617577075958,
-0.050857145339250565,
0.3590342402458191,
0.6337457299232483,
-1.0877445936203003,
0.3426334857940674,
1.0686817169189453,
0.4408484101295471,
-0.26271817088127136,
-0.27776291966438293,
-0.9156320691108704,
0.32809945940971375,
-0.39090496301651,
0.446195513010025,
-0.3991396427154541,
-0.4876985549926758,
-0.41730397939682007,
0.07980702072381973,
0.037664007395505905,
-1.025790810585022,
0.5424145460128784,
-0.2587871551513672,
-0.0027869907207787037,
-0.22650989890098572,
-0.7488088607788086,
0.09623201936483383,
0.41445526480674744,
-0.7361030578613281,
0.9283559918403625,
-0.1440194994211197,
-0.6037653088569641,
0.43489354848861694,
-0.2042040228843689,
-0.36932867765426636,
0.0008739702170714736,
-0.06919470429420471,
-0.7932117581367493,
-0.17279618978500366,
0.395645409822464,
0.5687395930290222,
0.08826935291290283,
0.3428563177585602,
-0.22017884254455566,
-0.4823508560657501,
0.028324641287326813,
-0.30772438645362854,
0.4226454198360443,
0.15805278718471527,
0.0636768788099289,
0.342217355966568,
-0.8294986486434937,
-0.021687408909201622,
-0.19750741124153137,
-0.5887629985809326,
-0.05053861811757088,
0.3318707346916199,
-0.04212196543812752,
0.06755907088518143,
0.46037015318870544,
-0.5741313695907593,
0.4821043312549591,
0.02270214445888996,
0.3486461341381073,
1.0329906940460205,
-0.09372149407863617,
0.5243633389472961,
-0.8059965372085571,
0.2839108407497406,
-0.23645271360874176,
0.22365809977054596,
0.29538294672966003,
0.031069835647940636,
-0.8255069255828857,
-0.5166472792625427,
-0.1462862193584442,
0.6403735280036926,
-0.870646059513092,
0.715725839138031,
-0.3569304049015045,
-0.589113175868988,
-0.35114532709121704,
0.5980642437934875,
0.1492694616317749,
0.5666096210479736,
0.5385996103286743,
-0.20810408890247345,
-0.7097779512405396,
-0.9086071848869324,
0.002012208104133606,
0.028352180495858192,
-0.12991547584533691,
0.22269850969314575,
0.2964518368244171,
-0.28278648853302,
1.0689094066619873,
-0.37355273962020874,
-0.3105370104312897,
-0.378993421792984,
-0.040815386921167374,
-0.07998134940862656,
0.7685221433639526,
0.3214653432369232,
-0.608319103717804,
-0.2593437433242798,
0.028768548741936684,
-0.30487388372421265,
-0.3727872967720032,
-0.14411117136478424,
0.04886471852660179,
0.083670474588871,
0.8505541682243347,
-0.13778747618198395,
0.40817442536354065,
0.35050004720687866,
-0.20435145497322083,
1.0437428951263428,
-0.29633596539497375,
0.1847531944513321,
-0.8398208022117615,
0.005240936763584614,
-0.22962769865989685,
-0.5590323209762573,
-0.5523678660392761,
-0.04805700108408928,
0.2301514744758606,
0.28917014598846436,
-0.31761080026626587,
0.2086624950170517,
-0.1915973573923111,
0.17184746265411377,
-0.40719902515411377,
-0.044931117445230484,
-0.21135982871055603,
0.4023122191429138,
-0.10991037636995316,
0.8840810060501099,
0.11469610035419464,
-0.6968130469322205,
0.44404762983322144,
0.3658798933029175,
-0.22839303314685822,
0.9300817847251892,
-0.32848235964775085,
-0.024837955832481384,
-0.2196033000946045,
-0.015706349164247513,
-0.715062141418457,
-0.1764211505651474,
0.16394773125648499,
-0.3582128882408142,
0.2823773920536041,
-0.2097155600786209,
-0.7821934223175049,
-0.1526295393705368,
-0.4890023171901703,
-0.33050382137298584,
0.5963349938392639,
-0.8109321594238281,
0.42245855927467346,
0.33598968386650085,
-0.1242314800620079,
-0.3663105368614197,
-0.6322535872459412,
0.050834570080041885,
-0.28363150358200073,
-0.11405610293149948,
0.24273717403411865,
-0.3734566271305084,
-0.09733117371797562,
0.0510873906314373,
-0.42995691299438477,
0.04024512693285942,
0.21970081329345703,
0.15972790122032166,
0.20537810027599335,
0.4645771086215973,
0.040615227073431015,
-0.03836080804467201,
-0.1825619339942932,
0.1604156792163849,
-0.09704826027154922,
0.5177801251411438,
0.24481073021888733,
-0.21428866684436798,
-0.7577544450759888,
-0.13048622012138367,
0.5176592469215393,
-0.2973414659500122,
0.4521063268184662,
0.37665119767189026,
-0.11580050736665726,
-0.34167009592056274,
-0.5373338460922241,
-0.10436893999576569,
-0.6078370809555054,
0.368901789188385,
-0.3947296440601349,
-0.850629985332489,
0.3238897919654846,
-0.029203267768025398,
0.4493665397167206,
-0.042904626578092575,
0.38417813181877136,
-0.20666305720806122,
0.7900217771530151,
0.6411839723587036,
-0.32773858308792114,
0.6398001313209534,
-0.16261516511440277,
-0.18229903280735016,
-0.7752924561500549,
-0.2847502827644348,
-0.6515437364578247,
-0.4623273015022278,
-0.5756775736808777,
-0.45118415355682373,
0.07573632895946503,
0.2342243790626526,
-0.42655515670776367,
0.36065739393234253,
-0.6703993678092957,
0.7205452919006348,
0.5607712864875793,
0.3622412085533142,
0.5775867700576782,
-0.19249996542930603,
0.10715720802545547,
-0.1009163036942482,
-0.4792868196964264,
-0.5509148836135864,
0.930466890335083,
0.24096040427684784,
1.2542158365249634,
0.005244196858257055,
1.0025687217712402,
0.18028727173805237,
0.477239191532135,
-0.7963767647743225,
0.8060552477836609,
-0.37647005915641785,
-0.07985842972993851,
-0.2532707750797272,
-0.8122605085372925,
-0.6807188391685486,
0.043912623077631,
-0.2691696584224701,
-0.8223191499710083,
-0.30529096722602844,
0.49777457118034363,
0.14033134281635284,
0.8240072727203369,
-0.5265658497810364,
0.47683894634246826,
-0.08020564913749695,
-0.38128989934921265,
-0.17261724174022675,
-0.1966625601053238,
0.24995219707489014,
-0.02614470012485981,
0.12220180034637451,
-0.09777100384235382,
-0.0037197177298367023,
0.8007247447967529,
-0.9242319464683533,
0.854296088218689,
-0.389498233795166,
-0.4422803521156311,
0.04991690441966057,
0.1672177016735077,
0.8424421548843384,
-0.24678370356559753,
-0.006302757654339075,
-0.5988233089447021,
-0.008398229256272316,
-0.2612724006175995,
-0.723659873008728,
0.7752141952514648,
-0.8461681604385376,
-0.5591869950294495,
0.07189986854791641,
-0.7122220396995544,
-0.1311057209968567,
0.1641693264245987,
-0.12823106348514557,
0.2757856845855713,
-0.021930014714598656,
0.4288104176521301,
0.6271878480911255,
0.1014416515827179,
0.14386463165283203,
0.5595064759254456,
-0.38452789187431335,
-0.4909103214740753,
0.8570120930671692,
0.30896851420402527,
0.1542629450559616,
0.36812064051628113,
0.06880606710910797,
-0.10744062066078186,
-0.8594977855682373,
-0.19525237381458282,
-0.11726726591587067,
-0.2796200215816498,
-0.21550390124320984,
-0.2504672110080719,
-0.2041676789522171,
-0.0825355052947998,
-0.5146021246910095,
-0.3661629557609558,
-0.702773928642273,
-0.2927916944026947,
-0.3445468544960022,
0.6201081871986389,
0.6548824906349182,
-0.26164644956588745,
0.750900387763977,
-0.5719971656799316,
0.38442325592041016,
0.2365930676460266,
0.7372868061065674,
-0.12698480486869812,
-0.5979477763175964,
-0.26798927783966064,
0.002003184286877513,
-0.15074393153190613,
-0.49901556968688965,
0.3805808424949646,
-0.06325104832649231,
0.411562442779541,
0.23673474788665771,
-0.07353255897760391,
0.8506408929824829,
-0.5137162804603577,
0.3305053114891052,
-0.016189094632864,
-0.9636673331260681,
0.1591111570596695,
-0.25644350051879883,
0.36257627606391907,
0.5768759846687317,
-0.0003839669225271791,
-0.7415342926979065,
-0.5654415488243103,
-0.407446026802063,
-0.9504005312919617,
0.6224996447563171,
-0.05859502777457237,
-0.0795016810297966,
0.510276198387146,
0.6363546848297119,
0.2763282060623169,
0.1262510120868683,
-0.4246878921985626,
-0.1092999055981636,
0.059479691088199615,
-0.34671878814697266,
-0.19345907866954803,
-0.10092566907405853,
-0.02278311923146248,
-0.4650879502296448,
1.0001815557479858,
-0.07754883915185928,
-0.15408283472061157,
-0.19539819657802582,
-0.2906271517276764,
-0.09145018458366394,
0.41967201232910156,
0.22360427677631378,
0.5487364530563354,
-0.3789077699184418,
0.12239114940166473,
0.1803177297115326,
-0.6697980761528015,
0.17563675343990326,
0.4151477515697479,
-0.5593298077583313,
-0.5633925199508667,
0.15909837186336517,
0.3662261664867401,
0.025373773649334908,
-0.44147810339927673,
-0.01736322045326233,
0.12435498833656311,
-0.3308916389942169,
-0.3419386148452759,
0.3454267680644989,
0.022035542875528336,
0.011916961520910263,
0.3534697890281677,
0.06301051378250122,
-0.094550721347332,
-0.10321404039859772,
0.8362942337989807,
0.2062487006187439,
-0.26429590582847595,
-0.06896393746137619,
0.7558237314224243,
0.1461302638053894,
-0.09973209351301193,
0.6389027833938599,
-0.23793593049049377,
-0.4527243375778198,
0.5048465132713318,
0.3983891010284424,
0.37247034907341003,
-0.11366457492113113,
0.1163952499628067,
0.35191282629966736,
0.4997142255306244,
-0.10140380263328552,
0.43742427229881287,
0.025419097393751144,
-0.8923978209495544,
-0.5779364109039307,
-0.12238334119319916,
-0.6994908452033997,
0.12595319747924805,
-0.6960527300834656,
0.22047939896583557,
-0.9165998101234436,
0.12300568073987961,
0.0003214292519260198,
0.17994286119937897,
-0.41368401050567627,
0.06339659541845322,
-0.03330743685364723,
0.998418927192688,
-0.6479468941688538,
0.8861522674560547,
0.44200992584228516,
-0.3030910789966583,
-0.9588515162467957,
-0.24465800821781158,
0.33868861198425293,
-0.6290183663368225,
0.20076633989810944,
0.3624662160873413,
-0.2644941210746765,
-0.10040413588285446,
-1.1257641315460205,
-0.552616536617279,
1.1154394149780273,
0.19889824092388153,
-0.5795514583587646,
0.11644867062568665,
0.1875973492860794,
0.340223103761673,
0.008483628742396832,
-0.16858795285224915,
0.9924201369285583,
0.6467983722686768,
0.11783456802368164,
-1.1808750629425049,
-0.06434077024459839,
-0.37018558382987976,
-0.47268205881118774,
0.5163633227348328,
-0.562745988368988,
0.6645498275756836,
-0.23421457409858704,
-0.023896599188447,
0.4361422061920166,
0.5775304436683655,
0.2847573459148407,
-0.06183426454663277,
0.5443052649497986,
0.8115836977958679,
0.9596134424209595,
-0.25243034958839417,
0.48536738753318787,
-0.16085806488990784,
0.31574830412864685,
1.5350368022918701,
-0.3664380609989166,
0.8446908593177795,
0.4817126393318176,
0.07747520506381989,
0.3760553002357483,
0.2286297231912613,
-0.32140088081359863,
0.3698490560054779,
0.29653263092041016,
0.17191781103610992,
-0.17862370610237122,
-0.1276056170463562,
0.08602500706911087,
0.6059085726737976,
0.3147474229335785,
-0.10059205442667007,
-0.20965851843357086,
-0.043451517820358276,
0.4786022901535034,
0.4377136826515198,
-0.5459083318710327,
0.7814614772796631,
-0.43570950627326965,
-0.3534950911998749,
0.6393401026725769,
0.21038052439689636,
0.9118682146072388,
-0.5728512406349182,
-0.04570690169930458,
-0.18202723562717438,
0.5095196962356567,
-0.45170027017593384,
-1.068218469619751,
0.34335657954216003,
0.14415450394153595,
-0.1363445669412613,
-0.6128299832344055,
0.497175008058548,
-0.7251729369163513,
-0.20436489582061768,
0.03859781101346016,
0.4050348103046417,
0.00902618933469057,
0.34577158093452454,
-0.3702905774116516,
-0.07994610071182251,
0.3101370930671692,
-0.11765938997268677,
0.07615073025226593,
0.21349011361598969,
-0.12757675349712372,
1.014434814453125,
0.54229736328125,
0.22924527525901794,
-0.14404833316802979,
-0.26199671626091003,
1.0516996383666992,
-0.6657960414886475,
-0.5215628743171692,
-0.6314031481742859,
0.40021491050720215,
-0.1422407627105713,
0.05223379656672478,
0.8101674914360046,
0.9561485648155212,
1.1133339405059814,
0.018235204741358757,
0.7972388863563538,
-0.08290950953960419,
0.725764811038971,
-0.5660890936851501,
0.8185372948646545,
-0.4176561236381531,
0.29612815380096436,
-0.09535211324691772,
-0.5290126204490662,
-0.45916152000427246,
0.390365868806839,
-0.419228196144104,
-0.0346015989780426,
0.06772374361753464,
1.1081010103225708,
-0.17648623883724213,
-0.11788592487573624,
0.09466185420751572,
0.14029845595359802,
0.56770920753479,
0.5909017324447632,
0.6837044358253479,
0.15941640734672546,
0.6386235356330872,
-0.4492226243019104,
-0.2804049253463745,
-0.16835139691829681,
-0.7534973621368408,
-0.5928539037704468,
-0.3117644786834717,
-0.2201060950756073,
-0.275381475687027,
0.04179494455456734,
1.2521132230758667,
0.7595192790031433,
-0.7620549201965332,
-0.30984562635421753,
0.1365317404270172,
0.15215852856636047,
-0.4403313398361206,
-0.2374727576971054,
0.5093573927879333,
-0.08671059459447861,
-0.7414818406105042,
0.29885411262512207,
-0.10689766705036163,
0.3007311224937439,
0.028430772945284843,
-0.2714582681655884,
0.0008967084577307105,
-0.12239613384008408,
0.48355546593666077,
0.39106661081314087,
-0.2823196053504944,
-0.4268244802951813,
-0.15032273530960083,
-0.08541476726531982,
0.2868981957435608,
0.6627417802810669,
-0.726518452167511,
0.38398727774620056,
0.4725847840309143,
0.6128174662590027,
0.44164934754371643,
0.4146715998649597,
0.43975117802619934,
-0.9862861037254333,
0.08280476182699203,
-0.0763750672340393,
0.3881434500217438,
0.5760084986686707,
-0.27396300435066223,
0.5829235911369324,
-0.08527086675167084,
-0.560379683971405,
-0.5662143230438232,
0.4283871054649353,
-0.9071982502937317,
-0.14494988322257996,
1.0431790351867676,
0.0829191505908966,
0.0015590524999424815,
0.06475507467985153,
-0.5789177417755127,
0.04230225831270218,
-0.4934625029563904,
0.6340469717979431,
0.529473602771759,
-0.23951303958892822,
-0.34835752844810486,
-0.431713342666626,
0.5915746688842773,
0.25329020619392395,
-1.0462902784347534,
0.6778927445411682,
0.8979573845863342,
0.5580813884735107,
-0.13952718675136566,
0.47693079710006714,
-0.204268679022789,
0.19209334254264832,
-0.37229248881340027,
0.2915879189968109,
-0.6801579594612122,
-0.3985455632209778,
-0.18756908178329468,
-0.12706664204597473,
0.3161029517650604,
-0.0748414397239685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15927v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15927v1 | Semantic Entropy Probes: Robust and Cheap Hallucination Detection in LLMs | 2024-06-22T19:46:06 | 2024-06-22T19:46:06 | Jannik Kossen, Jiatong Han, Muhammed Razzak, Lisa Schut, Shreshth Malik, Yarin Gal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We propose semantic entropy probes (SEPs), a cheap and reliable method for
uncertainty quantification in Large Language Models (LLMs). Hallucinations,
which are plausible-sounding but factually incorrect and arbitrary model
generations, present a major challenge to the practical adoption of LLMs.
Recent work by Farquhar et al. (2024) proposes semantic entropy (SE), which can
detect hallucinations by estimating uncertainty in the space semantic meaning
for a set of model generations. However, the 5-to-10-fold increase in
computation cost associated with SE computation hinders practical adoption. To
address this, we propose SEPs, which directly approximate SE from the hidden
states of a single generation. SEPs are simple to train and do not require
sampling multiple model generations at test time, reducing the overhead of
semantic uncertainty quantification to almost zero. We show that SEPs retain
high performance for hallucination detection and generalize better to
out-of-distribution data than previous probing methods that directly predict
model accuracy. Our results across models and tasks suggest that model hidden
states capture SE, and our ablation studies give further insights into the
token positions and model layers for which this is the case. | [
-0.3206825852394104,
-0.6123836636543274,
0.9415507912635803,
-0.012539485469460487,
-0.2826486825942993,
-0.3256799876689911,
-0.06527387350797653,
-0.6220893859863281,
0.39446714520454407,
0.5527260303497314,
-0.729691207408905,
-0.6249369382858276,
-0.6993634104728699,
0.1711416095495224,
-0.6539317965507507,
0.32600316405296326,
0.21265782415866852,
0.1654687076807022,
-0.1508008986711502,
0.14326433837413788,
-0.00914928037673235,
-0.381633996963501,
-0.37292003631591797,
-0.05483311414718628,
0.6504582762718201,
0.12015955150127411,
0.5409805178642273,
0.5826024413108826,
0.6243921518325806,
0.3278149962425232,
-0.31686684489250183,
0.30192315578460693,
-0.15789127349853516,
0.4467262029647827,
-0.07181988656520844,
-0.4278956651687622,
0.01971738412976265,
-0.23655447363853455,
0.49801814556121826,
0.7837317585945129,
-0.11895383894443512,
-0.13148628175258636,
-0.2366892248392105,
0.5434948205947876,
-0.9652096033096313,
-0.16380521655082703,
-0.9790448546409607,
0.09440594166517258,
-0.10702487081289291,
-0.24785315990447998,
-0.6571052670478821,
-0.12042738497257233,
0.023726768791675568,
-0.3377974033355713,
0.3294945955276489,
0.04177962616086006,
0.7689685821533203,
0.7883583903312683,
-0.5124123692512512,
-0.40398406982421875,
-0.7883559465408325,
0.8854596614837646,
-0.6708390712738037,
0.9301803708076477,
0.35762569308280945,
0.12128941714763641,
-0.30045464634895325,
-0.7770186066627502,
-0.37276116013526917,
-0.304698646068573,
-0.009034247137606144,
-0.11250440776348114,
-0.1499667912721634,
0.24348312616348267,
0.2200040966272354,
0.47942379117012024,
-0.4275684952735901,
0.2720029056072235,
-0.16709859669208527,
-0.6535142064094543,
0.40378305315971375,
0.38488540053367615,
0.25721362233161926,
-0.13720552623271942,
-0.5439871549606323,
-0.1594344526529312,
-0.596348762512207,
-0.3091437518596649,
0.38418835401535034,
0.3026047945022583,
0.04738117754459381,
0.6266287565231323,
-0.2923513650894165,
0.6336824893951416,
-0.1892338991165161,
-0.19143912196159363,
0.052724048495292664,
-0.36385300755500793,
-0.1614980697631836,
0.18785466253757477,
0.6172929406166077,
0.027717478573322296,
-0.29422080516815186,
-0.4228844940662384,
-0.3510449528694153,
0.2358197122812271,
0.2654587924480438,
-0.9200996160507202,
-0.21264447271823883,
0.4333048164844513,
-0.3601890206336975,
-0.4479365944862366,
0.028419053182005882,
-0.810870349407196,
-0.7494758367538452,
-0.29889485239982605,
0.48889198899269104,
-0.5602273941040039,
-0.16792403161525726,
0.48121970891952515,
-0.414928674697876,
0.4420906901359558,
0.45623934268951416,
-0.8474019169807434,
0.2648026943206787,
0.7921144366264343,
0.7785118222236633,
-0.3299933969974518,
-0.45076218247413635,
-0.41196638345718384,
-0.014137751422822475,
-0.5479495525360107,
0.9104335904121399,
-0.42863503098487854,
-0.13045884668827057,
-0.2408411055803299,
-0.0787341520190239,
-0.02396186999976635,
-0.5500273108482361,
0.41240057349205017,
-0.47627773880958557,
-0.0008814316825009882,
-0.4020465910434723,
-0.7105168700218201,
-0.11069327592849731,
0.04781519994139671,
-0.7065832018852234,
1.006438136100769,
-0.03877716511487961,
-0.9444487690925598,
0.523561954498291,
-0.34141024947166443,
0.017926696687936783,
-0.10122393071651459,
-0.1521238386631012,
-0.21932585537433624,
0.4131353795528412,
0.11837318539619446,
0.3543717861175537,
-0.11886225640773773,
0.10256469249725342,
-0.4628632962703705,
-0.4942649304866791,
0.3402276039123535,
-0.6296501159667969,
0.7752355933189392,
0.39270660281181335,
-0.4765666425228119,
0.20071494579315186,
-0.7487914562225342,
-0.17201922833919525,
0.0071027386002242565,
0.03454400971531868,
-0.4600413143634796,
0.14330841600894928,
-0.4688188433647156,
-0.09754247218370438,
0.2577279806137085,
-0.49271920323371887,
-0.2659929692745209,
-0.484130859375,
0.027302155271172523,
0.6728878617286682,
0.03269452974200249,
0.555388331413269,
0.03562242537736893,
0.2832832634449005,
0.33088231086730957,
0.1097920760512352,
-0.0495704747736454,
-0.4070792496204376,
-0.7577728629112244,
-0.5757312178611755,
0.18852752447128296,
0.51803058385849,
-0.4576966166496277,
0.8789944648742676,
-0.01842084899544716,
-0.7148619294166565,
-0.6051270365715027,
-0.09237179160118103,
-0.01992848701775074,
0.5614645481109619,
0.21919278800487518,
-0.04703253507614136,
-0.3881187438964844,
-0.7186741232872009,
-0.3089049756526947,
-0.300599068403244,
-0.31266486644744873,
-0.05309862270951271,
0.6199285387992859,
-0.28472262620925903,
0.7882710695266724,
-0.48186761140823364,
-0.14274734258651733,
0.10721688717603683,
0.09556909650564194,
-0.26252272725105286,
0.2513331174850464,
0.17676815390586853,
-0.6106577515602112,
0.21615241467952728,
-0.15364442765712738,
-0.8839239478111267,
0.06291196495294571,
0.06207546591758728,
-0.10661716759204865,
0.42856892943382263,
0.6225447654724121,
-0.7309558391571045,
0.5280493497848511,
0.5653799772262573,
-0.5721908211708069,
0.5412816405296326,
-0.09178782999515533,
-0.0302650835365057,
-0.9622330665588379,
-0.14630474150180817,
-0.28146740794181824,
-0.04185439273715019,
-0.6260769963264465,
0.15243615210056305,
0.17146500945091248,
0.09314214438199997,
-0.7450351715087891,
0.38375112414360046,
-0.37920403480529785,
-0.21668042242527008,
-0.31662675738334656,
0.03391655534505844,
0.0769643560051918,
0.09697774797677994,
0.24327313899993896,
0.6518028378486633,
0.6754932999610901,
-0.6477387547492981,
0.40357425808906555,
-0.10352820158004761,
-0.5398300886154175,
0.22753621637821198,
-0.33337533473968506,
0.12193123251199722,
-0.2684055268764496,
0.2568548023700714,
-0.8562720417976379,
-0.3188621997833252,
0.25599363446235657,
-0.5667209029197693,
0.029390474781394005,
0.09862099587917328,
-0.43942990899086,
-0.01529846340417862,
-0.44564205408096313,
0.2175334393978119,
0.44421783089637756,
-0.6421093344688416,
0.6004992723464966,
0.27343177795410156,
0.37313905358314514,
-0.6444670557975769,
-0.8591059446334839,
0.07796357572078705,
-0.5413475036621094,
-0.7004528045654297,
0.18892982602119446,
0.054942578077316284,
-0.5169060826301575,
0.02585633099079132,
-0.3412395715713501,
-0.07055417448282242,
0.4684945344924927,
0.04784104973077774,
0.07271897047758102,
-0.3588089346885681,
0.17359881103038788,
0.09754542261362076,
-0.23685979843139648,
0.3122002184391022,
-0.4739095866680145,
0.7210416793823242,
-0.26089224219322205,
-0.7482720017433167,
-0.5992775559425354,
0.24321703612804413,
0.6764520406723022,
0.031193263828754425,
0.9165672659873962,
0.7885120511054993,
-0.8245523571968079,
-0.30871862173080444,
-0.7019015550613403,
-0.6131860017776489,
-0.5280711054801941,
0.16627152264118195,
-0.5480421781539917,
-0.9053307771682739,
0.8464794158935547,
-0.08791311085224152,
-0.26914122700691223,
0.4890362620353699,
0.5572224259376526,
0.04187270253896713,
0.9823305606842041,
0.416531503200531,
0.18959131836891174,
0.1497163474559784,
0.03248705714941025,
0.4467560946941376,
-0.5391228199005127,
-0.4034663736820221,
-0.7672523260116577,
-0.03824040666222572,
-0.6601027846336365,
-0.5023636221885681,
0.32805386185646057,
0.16776198148727417,
-0.09968698769807816,
0.05335889011621475,
-0.6769334673881531,
0.5851218700408936,
0.6435539722442627,
0.20061670243740082,
0.34448572993278503,
-0.01861105114221573,
0.16004803776741028,
-0.17289435863494873,
-0.406654953956604,
-0.44077229499816895,
0.6387672424316406,
0.3166610300540924,
1.0705841779708862,
-0.012700371444225311,
1.0489256381988525,
0.08429709076881409,
-0.3178820013999939,
-1.0651909112930298,
0.5884593725204468,
0.10303065180778503,
-0.45824310183525085,
-0.7382513284683228,
-0.5367427468299866,
-0.8463860154151917,
0.3386649787425995,
0.16658355295658112,
-0.9932336807250977,
0.45772644877433777,
-0.018657678738236427,
-0.39590680599212646,
0.6250473260879517,
-0.6191771626472473,
0.7485438585281372,
-0.12174773961305618,
-0.06429831683635712,
-0.06424316763877869,
-0.6568576693534851,
0.501839816570282,
-0.10823827236890793,
-0.23791731894016266,
-0.3012249171733856,
-0.2536253035068512,
0.7861243486404419,
-0.5323979258537292,
0.9219798445701599,
-0.18261831998825073,
-0.39269137382507324,
0.35842546820640564,
0.3865923583507538,
0.6207008361816406,
0.012326546013355255,
-0.21638938784599304,
0.18525391817092896,
0.22200247645378113,
-0.3328530490398407,
-0.5427175760269165,
0.626253068447113,
-0.48540714383125305,
-0.5841871500015259,
-0.43150198459625244,
-0.6062781810760498,
-0.12346624583005905,
0.10694901645183563,
0.5246965289115906,
0.09967318922281265,
0.13999272882938385,
0.1409786343574524,
1.0742433071136475,
-0.24907945096492767,
0.13957062363624573,
0.3323783576488495,
-0.010727622546255589,
-0.27570846676826477,
0.8629029989242554,
-0.12015310674905777,
0.205380380153656,
0.3493447005748749,
0.3045828342437744,
-0.42664018273353577,
-0.6152912974357605,
-0.34786492586135864,
0.30133476853370667,
-0.8203365206718445,
-0.28281256556510925,
-0.8033053278923035,
-0.2590498924255371,
-0.6283664703369141,
-0.23374052345752716,
-0.740268886089325,
-0.3331621587276459,
-0.44320812821388245,
-0.290062814950943,
0.6287497878074646,
0.5090891122817993,
-0.33344602584838867,
0.036724258214235306,
-0.6803799867630005,
0.2757396101951599,
0.19579719007015228,
0.22366461157798767,
-0.16481830179691315,
-0.524585485458374,
-0.0030828898306936026,
0.11296743899583817,
-0.008494650013744831,
-0.978442907333374,
0.4233093559741974,
-0.1675882339477539,
0.3984871506690979,
0.7153706550598145,
0.5016437768936157,
0.7433193325996399,
-0.06043999269604683,
1.017736792564392,
0.024489274248480797,
-1.1570185422897339,
0.5279953479766846,
-0.1151122897863388,
-0.030949721112847328,
0.6833797097206116,
0.3200925886631012,
-0.3965297341346741,
-0.6552900075912476,
-0.42061862349510193,
-0.7470791339874268,
0.680583119392395,
-0.033027030527591705,
0.07462165504693985,
0.032795317471027374,
0.16211603581905365,
0.2186545431613922,
-0.03641177713871002,
-0.45958423614501953,
-0.05782879516482353,
0.24502305686473846,
-0.29278382658958435,
0.24946460127830505,
-0.358634352684021,
-0.1366274207830429,
-0.21512243151664734,
0.44702187180519104,
-0.08121201395988464,
0.5162250399589539,
0.32705891132354736,
-0.06403159350156784,
-0.11323048919439316,
-0.027676070109009743,
0.6302298903465271,
0.3486356735229492,
-0.4061322510242462,
0.6869733929634094,
0.497673898935318,
-0.40719595551490784,
0.20057213306427002,
-0.24081358313560486,
-0.20538432896137238,
0.26395609974861145,
0.2571488916873932,
0.8129778504371643,
0.018843557685613632,
-0.6176239252090454,
0.5498532652854919,
-0.004719588905572891,
-0.31976789236068726,
-0.527819037437439,
0.024260008707642555,
0.17625807225704193,
0.3268482983112335,
-0.05206070840358734,
-0.093002550303936,
0.43058285117149353,
-0.2186633050441742,
0.3248019516468048,
0.5492805242538452,
-0.5285820364952087,
-0.30757200717926025,
0.7601236701011658,
-0.13300198316574097,
-0.10599260777235031,
0.7491764426231384,
-0.34028691053390503,
-0.5497623682022095,
0.5664770007133484,
0.46274176239967346,
1.1139839887619019,
-0.2795732915401459,
0.08219778537750244,
0.033729437738657,
0.5862694978713989,
-0.29368069767951965,
0.3336685001850128,
-0.19732561707496643,
-0.8743653297424316,
-0.31793826818466187,
-0.7747974395751953,
-0.5513375997543335,
0.18487517535686493,
-0.6530579328536987,
0.5378910303115845,
0.0079458924010396,
0.17883406579494476,
-0.32437604665756226,
-0.21024885773658752,
-0.3698551058769226,
0.09866832941770554,
0.45941856503486633,
1.0253546237945557,
-0.9973756074905396,
0.6883447766304016,
0.13578929007053375,
-0.09167031943798065,
-0.5459179282188416,
0.062265124171972275,
0.14365193247795105,
-0.6631370782852173,
0.4140097200870514,
0.1958344578742981,
-0.5084324479103088,
-0.139521062374115,
-0.5556036829948425,
-1.1249316930770874,
1.0689107179641724,
0.5318678021430969,
-0.05591520294547081,
-0.21058426797389984,
0.23346726596355438,
0.4082155227661133,
0.047114383429288864,
0.01173374056816101,
0.6491255760192871,
0.506258487701416,
0.3084215521812439,
-0.43225839734077454,
0.19216370582580566,
0.1734205186367035,
-0.24888630211353302,
0.4050479233264923,
-0.44943708181381226,
0.6530895829200745,
-0.23905175924301147,
-0.33124691247940063,
0.1290651261806488,
0.7825316786766052,
0.45084846019744873,
0.7104200720787048,
0.6018325686454773,
0.822388231754303,
1.0322585105895996,
-0.14141330122947693,
0.8243096470832825,
-0.5191680788993835,
0.2577393054962158,
0.7834033966064453,
-0.44457003474235535,
0.7302014827728271,
0.7948393821716309,
0.032192960381507874,
0.19054430723190308,
0.9078351259231567,
0.13177354633808136,
0.633953332901001,
0.3512704074382782,
-0.45384708046913147,
-0.4071730971336365,
-0.15210825204849243,
-0.3895460367202759,
0.34681499004364014,
0.7413047552108765,
-0.21959300339221954,
-0.23045626282691956,
0.02184954471886158,
0.01987920142710209,
-0.4371342957019806,
0.16003942489624023,
0.8104990720748901,
0.15020084381103516,
-0.4826377332210541,
0.46319904923439026,
-0.1102323904633522,
0.6621687412261963,
-0.641558825969696,
0.18978185951709747,
-0.35199129581451416,
0.09683597832918167,
-0.2063768059015274,
-0.3823931813240051,
0.6442052721977234,
-0.09613952040672302,
0.1690649390220642,
-0.1089562401175499,
1.029876470565796,
-0.17340771853923798,
-0.5627345442771912,
0.4605896770954132,
0.49183300137519836,
0.5846379995346069,
-0.32384583353996277,
-0.13035884499549866,
0.3035978376865387,
-0.11838117986917496,
-0.36198049783706665,
0.2663620114326477,
0.7642347812652588,
0.12508878111839294,
0.632489025592804,
0.4112379550933838,
0.20980766415596008,
0.462206095457077,
-0.12036022543907166,
0.5931165814399719,
-0.7438103556632996,
-0.2341485619544983,
-0.8843984007835388,
0.35681572556495667,
0.08625271916389465,
-0.19620700180530548,
0.7410764098167419,
0.5677195191383362,
0.9928761124610901,
0.052665408700704575,
0.5450325012207031,
0.19747476279735565,
0.3595806062221527,
-0.8193908333778381,
0.6561800837516785,
-0.736803412437439,
0.3595554530620575,
-0.053757473826408386,
-0.8158420324325562,
-0.49592235684394836,
0.4244915843009949,
-0.10576101392507553,
-0.2242068648338318,
0.9264993071556091,
1.2452471256256104,
-0.02790721319615841,
0.24733556807041168,
0.6199342012405396,
0.022656520828604698,
0.058820486068725586,
0.2146928310394287,
1.3075979948043823,
-0.2937919795513153,
0.31576254963874817,
-0.720039963722229,
0.051678065210580826,
-0.165337473154068,
-0.634307324886322,
-0.5476490259170532,
-0.7686205506324768,
-0.32044196128845215,
-0.521438717842102,
-0.16728517413139343,
0.8102095127105713,
0.5445185303688049,
-0.8375780582427979,
-0.06114013120532036,
-0.2577527165412903,
0.28858447074890137,
-0.18004195392131805,
-0.2368624061346054,
0.41928645968437195,
-0.6365319490432739,
-0.7609683871269226,
0.7298623323440552,
0.2910001575946808,
0.13803216814994812,
-0.3858589828014374,
-0.06260481476783752,
0.30042415857315063,
0.27466756105422974,
0.5121498703956604,
-0.11454030126333237,
-1.0068973302841187,
-0.3177957534790039,
0.3088720142841339,
-0.3121333420276642,
-0.18785372376441956,
0.7504357695579529,
-0.5523139834403992,
0.29145538806915283,
0.7934255599975586,
0.7571119070053101,
0.3291275203227997,
-0.2602352499961853,
0.05663030594587326,
-0.4044184982776642,
0.3313349783420563,
0.3479807674884796,
0.29726213216781616,
0.16627109050750732,
-0.5410515069961548,
0.495280385017395,
0.37014731764793396,
-0.4460105001926422,
-1.3179988861083984,
0.2917443811893463,
-0.9667729139328003,
-0.46089258790016174,
1.1785881519317627,
0.1868390440940857,
-0.4530072808265686,
-0.07429657876491547,
0.20574821531772614,
0.22663632035255432,
-0.13758639991283417,
1.0557960271835327,
0.6499875783920288,
-0.2789615988731384,
0.1665104180574417,
-0.2792019546031952,
0.5018638968467712,
0.6441975831985474,
-0.722304105758667,
0.11341813206672668,
0.47344300150871277,
-0.04511469975113869,
0.2228630781173706,
0.3590022921562195,
-0.15387171506881714,
0.047657132148742676,
0.5396440625190735,
0.1044854074716568,
0.2973661720752716,
-0.5397374033927917,
-0.5606750845909119,
0.10919321328401566,
0.07825472950935364,
-0.4702678322792053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15891v1 | The Unlikely Duel: Evaluating Creative Writing in LLMs through a Unique Scenario | 2024-06-22T17:01:59 | 2024-06-22T17:01:59 | Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Paul Williams | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | This is a summary of the paper "A Confederacy of Models: a Comprehensive
Evaluation of LLMs on Creative Writing", which was published in Findings of
EMNLP 2023. We evaluate a range of recent state-of-the-art, instruction-tuned
large language models (LLMs) on an English creative writing task, and compare
them to human writers. For this purpose, we use a specifically-tailored prompt
(based on an epic combat between Ignatius J. Reilly, main character of John
Kennedy Toole's "A Confederacy of Dunces", and a pterodactyl) to minimize the
risk of training data leakage and force the models to be creative rather than
reusing existing stories. The same prompt is presented to LLMs and human
writers, and evaluation is performed by humans using a detailed rubric
including various aspects like fluency, style, originality or humor. Results
show that some state-of-the-art commercial LLMs match or slightly outperform
our human writers in most of the evaluated dimensions. Open-source LLMs lag
behind. Humans keep a close lead in originality, and only the top three LLMs
can handle humor at human-like levels. | [
-0.16997379064559937,
-0.722470760345459,
0.8593121767044067,
-0.06479166448116302,
-0.09957577288150787,
0.5205337405204773,
-0.24671314656734467,
-0.3641323447227478,
0.4332096576690674,
0.4886230230331421,
-0.403452605009079,
-0.5632268190383911,
-0.37592613697052,
0.21474507451057434,
-0.20568586885929108,
0.7403385639190674,
-0.26059821248054504,
-0.013123138807713985,
-0.3882026672363281,
-0.12783432006835938,
-0.2524234354496002,
-0.4131608307361603,
-0.681783139705658,
-0.03664457052946091,
0.7753928303718567,
0.2974412143230438,
0.47187209129333496,
0.48136913776397705,
0.7040834426879883,
0.4862615764141083,
-0.010306327603757381,
0.005077407229691744,
-0.7980579733848572,
0.1762586534023285,
-0.23569291830062866,
-0.8316771388053894,
-0.35829654335975647,
0.3482588529586792,
0.8766975998878479,
0.7249444723129272,
-0.12157945334911346,
-0.13931134343147278,
-0.12703675031661987,
0.5757113695144653,
-0.4675104022026062,
-0.5315433740615845,
-0.743963897228241,
0.2656788229942322,
-0.3947896361351013,
-0.02760361321270466,
-0.3942868113517761,
-0.607130229473114,
-0.006244432181119919,
-0.5394907593727112,
-0.016486631706357002,
0.23535507917404175,
0.5831047892570496,
0.0013552441960200667,
-0.3451225459575653,
-0.3267744481563568,
-0.7336882948875427,
0.6171183586120605,
-0.533720850944519,
-0.012059778906404972,
-0.1763489842414856,
0.3930581212043762,
-0.36758092045783997,
-1.0031222105026245,
-0.8590128421783447,
-0.41808807849884033,
0.35657599568367004,
0.6138441562652588,
-0.5166075825691223,
0.177931547164917,
0.28019559383392334,
0.28903135657310486,
-0.5935040712356567,
0.6071237921714783,
-0.2358880639076233,
0.2079940140247345,
0.8012804985046387,
0.7154968976974487,
0.23029851913452148,
-0.11489713191986084,
-0.6427077054977417,
-0.05429132282733917,
-0.44361814856529236,
0.5254091620445251,
0.834155797958374,
-0.2910912036895752,
-0.14296089112758636,
0.7122519612312317,
-0.0717092975974083,
0.46366339921951294,
-0.1991007924079895,
-0.13073348999023438,
-0.1702626496553421,
0.019449882209300995,
-0.24363301694393158,
-0.14354974031448364,
0.9349890947341919,
0.794925332069397,
0.09408249706029892,
-0.6385977864265442,
-0.2610664963722229,
0.25982558727264404,
0.5235363841056824,
-0.44230037927627563,
-0.1514546424150467,
0.14088459312915802,
-0.36069178581237793,
-0.5797224640846252,
0.19908061623573303,
-0.7344115972518921,
-0.6271180510520935,
-0.19687055051326752,
0.5359002947807312,
-0.2751944363117218,
0.08307422697544098,
-0.07028094679117203,
-0.6127305030822754,
-0.19681385159492493,
0.18642167747020721,
-0.47726625204086304,
0.16663235425949097,
0.723822295665741,
0.7554288506507874,
-0.6508682370185852,
-0.5327700972557068,
-0.3331815302371979,
0.015029453672468662,
-0.486221045255661,
0.9307047128677368,
-0.49130603671073914,
-0.3880203068256378,
-0.10770796239376068,
-0.18162722885608673,
-0.13514108955860138,
-0.4239484965801239,
1.0008639097213745,
-0.3613138496875763,
-0.05482306331396103,
-0.33013638854026794,
-0.7133164405822754,
0.04723011702299118,
0.14448994398117065,
-0.6778186559677124,
0.38387832045555115,
0.10029563307762146,
-0.7009176015853882,
0.21217799186706543,
-0.36209747195243835,
-0.055323343724012375,
0.21399308741092682,
-0.3440443277359009,
-0.26215338706970215,
0.2500735819339752,
-0.3028462827205658,
0.17363205552101135,
-0.5093069076538086,
0.15022361278533936,
-0.6864676475524902,
-0.4248349368572235,
0.7314910888671875,
-0.5965136885643005,
0.8905306458473206,
0.13142839074134827,
-0.2804427742958069,
0.15012027323246002,
-0.6224877834320068,
0.15934142470359802,
0.37439393997192383,
-0.19602596759796143,
-0.14585575461387634,
-0.2547707259654999,
-0.24782434105873108,
0.12865705788135529,
0.1146860346198082,
-0.7586167454719543,
0.3522421717643738,
-0.3294403851032257,
0.14235183596611023,
0.8062655925750732,
0.08415080606937408,
0.48089316487312317,
-0.9523892402648926,
0.9742463231086731,
-0.3064723312854767,
0.08560442179441452,
-0.06067785620689392,
-0.41385501623153687,
-0.9093795418739319,
-0.144976407289505,
0.19836176931858063,
0.6335244178771973,
-0.7221559882164001,
0.3182436525821686,
-0.11900690197944641,
-1.1496450901031494,
-0.5623590350151062,
0.08385489135980606,
0.34876418113708496,
0.4450705051422119,
-0.2059149593114853,
-0.5668959021568298,
-0.49348291754722595,
-0.8041694164276123,
-0.7707746028900146,
-0.15545694530010223,
0.10532461851835251,
0.39685431122779846,
0.13992196321487427,
0.012265714816749096,
0.8390068411827087,
-0.27090203762054443,
-0.060026925057172775,
-0.4356754720211029,
0.1944464147090912,
0.1283167600631714,
0.23761354386806488,
0.6291813254356384,
-0.25490060448646545,
-0.5490204691886902,
-0.07428576052188873,
-0.7247196435928345,
-0.32118529081344604,
-0.3263893127441406,
-0.2832888960838318,
0.1793188452720642,
0.38016051054000854,
-0.6136391758918762,
0.48066970705986023,
0.3533930778503418,
-0.2619750201702118,
0.8297598958015442,
-0.027536697685718536,
0.3771370053291321,
-0.8926810622215271,
0.03664430230855942,
-0.22640401124954224,
0.2960205078125,
-0.4442265033721924,
-0.061217840760946274,
-0.10305403172969818,
-0.1205342710018158,
-0.3786238729953766,
0.6748759746551514,
-0.31351837515830994,
0.16676044464111328,
-0.011634732596576214,
0.3775053918361664,
0.21359987556934357,
0.06251014024019241,
-0.17579126358032227,
0.33058053255081177,
0.482892245054245,
-0.08178357779979706,
0.7030343413352966,
-0.18198557198047638,
-0.3074142634868622,
0.7236803770065308,
-0.42743799090385437,
0.37412330508232117,
-0.07515571266412735,
0.23749025166034698,
-1.0505691766738892,
-0.08082319051027298,
-0.15457546710968018,
-0.20137286186218262,
0.15745289623737335,
0.04120847210288048,
-0.45715489983558655,
-0.4200913608074188,
-0.4891122579574585,
-0.00805849488824606,
0.4053468406200409,
-0.40732207894325256,
0.5566913485527039,
0.32302325963974,
-0.3664533495903015,
-0.4644082486629486,
-0.21526126563549042,
0.5896682739257812,
-0.6089572906494141,
-0.6858777403831482,
0.3687734603881836,
-0.4195501506328583,
-0.5833553671836853,
0.009448613040149212,
0.266303688287735,
0.001762985484674573,
0.11924953013658524,
0.3430798649787903,
0.15533773601055145,
-0.22778688371181488,
-0.08913061022758484,
0.017499703913927078,
0.21592621505260468,
0.18438513576984406,
0.013133782893419266,
0.25197696685791016,
-0.08102190494537354,
-0.4216199815273285,
-0.4866252839565277,
0.4763793647289276,
0.45727527141571045,
0.08839883655309677,
0.4451635479927063,
0.4994637370109558,
-0.18897312879562378,
-0.36757075786590576,
-0.7111924290657043,
0.12152893096208572,
-0.521473228931427,
0.41568073630332947,
-0.1763695627450943,
-0.551990270614624,
0.527000904083252,
-0.17111386358737946,
0.13867004215717316,
0.521011233329773,
0.35443729162216187,
-0.2762186825275421,
0.5956037044525146,
0.5424613952636719,
0.19008684158325195,
0.2655084729194641,
-0.20784223079681396,
0.15133613348007202,
-0.5492558479309082,
-0.3629321753978729,
-0.4164774417877197,
-0.7589063048362732,
-0.3806401491165161,
-0.25218483805656433,
0.4043993353843689,
0.30657023191452026,
-0.0276158656924963,
0.15566815435886383,
-0.12186839431524277,
0.8735475540161133,
0.5186424851417542,
-0.25997841358184814,
0.3259558379650116,
-0.08573982119560242,
-0.6254889965057373,
-0.42795246839523315,
-0.8906122446060181,
-0.8119959831237793,
1.2394368648529053,
0.3191928565502167,
0.8845493197441101,
0.36349380016326904,
0.8766598701477051,
0.07251937687397003,
0.31786948442459106,
-0.6826154589653015,
0.6601714491844177,
-0.2720639109611511,
-0.1888607144355774,
-0.19345201551914215,
-0.4569826126098633,
-1.097867727279663,
-0.04118054360151291,
-0.40267515182495117,
-0.7765749096870422,
-0.006277548614889383,
-0.35508525371551514,
-0.6374972462654114,
0.6537079811096191,
-0.9360774159431458,
0.8132866024971008,
-0.5875803232192993,
-0.4396322965621948,
0.050615742802619934,
-0.39102989435195923,
0.5071855783462524,
-0.07252805680036545,
0.0667061135172844,
0.23108698427677155,
-0.3072732985019684,
0.8191551566123962,
0.004261760041117668,
0.6703892946243286,
0.3333902060985565,
-0.0523051843047142,
0.41515135765075684,
0.40579280257225037,
0.28489452600479126,
0.1470443308353424,
-0.2568419575691223,
0.14547480642795563,
-0.15744365751743317,
0.016170529648661613,
-0.6466392278671265,
1.0112675428390503,
-0.7653634548187256,
-0.6982970833778381,
-0.4991309940814972,
-0.6750354170799255,
-0.05172805115580559,
0.014762548729777336,
0.5702860355377197,
0.3543444573879242,
-0.6680459380149841,
0.059989314526319504,
0.18939079344272614,
-0.18757586181163788,
0.8577532768249512,
0.539843738079071,
-0.06064801663160324,
-0.7870373129844666,
0.7608331441879272,
0.1305118352174759,
0.44089746475219727,
0.008050126023590565,
0.18911366164684296,
-0.3936443030834198,
-0.5021466016769409,
-0.560396671295166,
0.20924098789691925,
-0.816372811794281,
-0.18391671776771545,
-0.9137954711914062,
-0.4331512153148651,
-0.23477555811405182,
-0.7074284553527832,
-0.2700519859790802,
-0.5963815450668335,
-0.40321895480155945,
0.28721126914024353,
0.11342692375183105,
1.2603358030319214,
0.03939001262187958,
0.2382155805826187,
-0.6514648795127869,
0.09728323668241501,
0.43477603793144226,
0.35609662532806396,
0.061453308910131454,
-0.6804365515708923,
0.03848368674516678,
-0.2399124652147293,
-0.7507158517837524,
-0.912710964679718,
0.25283709168434143,
-0.022294458001852036,
0.7182955145835876,
0.44656991958618164,
0.11491210758686066,
0.45020008087158203,
-0.47951194643974304,
0.7835232019424438,
0.49494561553001404,
-0.6268659234046936,
0.20311932265758514,
-0.37382155656814575,
0.15819475054740906,
0.4910527169704437,
0.4095134437084198,
-0.5478194952011108,
-0.5758200883865356,
-0.9863717555999756,
-0.6062530875205994,
0.6258596181869507,
0.12620581686496735,
0.14642439782619476,
-0.0059447153471410275,
0.1404893845319748,
0.20847149193286896,
0.10745725780725479,
-0.7184785008430481,
-0.2009526640176773,
0.3859962224960327,
0.014292668551206589,
-0.04783378168940544,
-0.1405254453420639,
-0.39243268966674805,
-0.17478466033935547,
0.2560918927192688,
0.3871802091598511,
0.04512302577495575,
0.11863018572330475,
0.09476075321435928,
-0.33689606189727783,
0.22787639498710632,
0.49960577487945557,
0.6636840105056763,
-0.04367232322692871,
0.3118171691894531,
0.33705613017082214,
-0.44668325781822205,
0.10335908830165863,
-0.017723729833960533,
0.039821479469537735,
0.15990987420082092,
0.5559070706367493,
0.8784468173980713,
0.21690504252910614,
-0.8733301162719727,
0.534008264541626,
-0.34059613943099976,
-0.08690883964300156,
-0.49681589007377625,
0.5632955431938171,
0.20480488240718842,
0.5689971446990967,
0.29814401268959045,
0.2811357378959656,
0.07512727379798889,
-0.6251534819602966,
0.09640691429376602,
0.5950890779495239,
-0.25678306818008423,
-0.21663740277290344,
0.6201691627502441,
0.3546108305454254,
-0.8567484021186829,
0.010479249060153961,
-0.7072994112968445,
-0.6043486595153809,
0.7922919392585754,
0.5978437662124634,
0.9294480681419373,
-0.1233174130320549,
0.1514853835105896,
0.28146421909332275,
0.5327224731445312,
0.3301827907562256,
0.19542859494686127,
0.46238231658935547,
-0.23052319884300232,
-0.023703020066022873,
-0.6029062271118164,
-0.5473803281784058,
0.36798709630966187,
-0.2870219051837921,
0.5794916749000549,
-0.5721740126609802,
-0.07950353622436523,
-0.0125188659876585,
0.13219322264194489,
-0.6094549894332886,
-0.12833204865455627,
0.008277651853859425,
0.7158988118171692,
-0.7370057702064514,
0.49957403540611267,
0.7295329570770264,
-0.06564014405012131,
-0.6109660863876343,
-0.022714665159583092,
0.05095938220620155,
-0.333126425743103,
0.4050743579864502,
0.058518629521131516,
0.1152990385890007,
0.1720973551273346,
-0.12863443791866302,
-0.5275298953056335,
1.1158058643341064,
0.7056372165679932,
-0.7200726866722107,
0.09237068891525269,
0.12659330666065216,
0.5565291047096252,
-0.5923207402229309,
0.4109570384025574,
0.5738728642463684,
0.22344854474067688,
-0.0042710453271865845,
-1.0335310697555542,
-0.23518306016921997,
-0.3110749423503876,
-0.15982365608215332,
-0.2136297971010208,
-0.6215234994888306,
0.8598381280899048,
-0.5576163530349731,
-0.30893874168395996,
0.3247799575328827,
0.37894365191459656,
0.31592699885368347,
0.5421488285064697,
0.38527441024780273,
0.9285017251968384,
0.6549599170684814,
0.004103205166757107,
1.0644056797027588,
0.09466736763715744,
-0.019604161381721497,
1.018991231918335,
-0.30502694845199585,
0.8232545852661133,
0.280487596988678,
-0.33926740288734436,
0.4658595323562622,
0.3930864632129669,
0.13506051898002625,
0.14596280455589294,
0.3396332561969757,
-0.5243832468986511,
-0.03387453034520149,
-0.1940518021583557,
-0.3596563935279846,
0.7870841026306152,
-0.056431449949741364,
-0.32371020317077637,
-0.22022025287151337,
-0.23862481117248535,
-0.06643826514482498,
0.47726961970329285,
-0.08850598335266113,
0.8350685238838196,
0.19792146980762482,
-0.7886914014816284,
0.4843713045120239,
0.02245260588824749,
0.6194806694984436,
-0.38204672932624817,
-0.011832638643682003,
-0.09850441664457321,
-0.009214639663696289,
0.019444188103079796,
-0.8978700637817383,
-0.01702963560819626,
0.1808321326971054,
0.08116958290338516,
0.05810762196779251,
0.4151805341243744,
-0.4898863732814789,
-0.6567732691764832,
0.11938363313674927,
0.41080158948898315,
0.16473111510276794,
0.3079296350479126,
-0.5847417712211609,
0.2052738219499588,
-0.2513229250907898,
-0.14390811324119568,
0.225857213139534,
0.7593333721160889,
0.21589718759059906,
0.36996588110923767,
0.604885995388031,
0.38637927174568176,
0.0310781542211771,
0.11097569018602371,
0.8016619086265564,
-0.6031087040901184,
-0.49870097637176514,
-0.8577830195426941,
0.5277649760246277,
-0.45408037304878235,
-0.6726352572441101,
0.827866792678833,
0.6913310289382935,
0.5555473566055298,
-0.054651204496622086,
0.781216561794281,
0.16675631701946259,
0.3717518746852875,
-0.5129552483558655,
1.159092664718628,
-0.45566633343696594,
0.23771971464157104,
-0.499642014503479,
-0.8902227878570557,
-0.046940818428993225,
0.2929079532623291,
-0.1861475706100464,
0.08225459605455399,
1.046103835105896,
0.6185972690582275,
0.005955047905445099,
0.058937691152095795,
0.5493131279945374,
0.09563042223453522,
0.12218751013278961,
0.7050843238830566,
1.120503544807434,
-0.18405179679393768,
0.4553171694278717,
-0.4441138505935669,
-0.39476820826530457,
-0.09809008240699768,
-1.178623914718628,
-1.0488883256912231,
-0.6002871990203857,
-0.1255367547273636,
-0.319841206073761,
-0.20737917721271515,
0.6878231763839722,
-0.009026463143527508,
-0.1944260597229004,
-0.42271462082862854,
0.16312770545482635,
0.08436215668916702,
0.20306766033172607,
-0.16347545385360718,
0.038620684295892715,
-0.24594812095165253,
-0.7938016653060913,
0.4364573657512665,
0.4382852017879486,
0.20822693407535553,
-0.3285137116909027,
-0.05741921439766884,
0.10469553619623184,
0.2650395929813385,
0.467012882232666,
0.015492809005081654,
-0.9122706651687622,
0.05623984336853027,
0.22581103444099426,
-0.22495581209659576,
-0.22729241847991943,
0.7583789825439453,
-0.5590685606002808,
0.7487819790840149,
0.2443699687719345,
0.6727461814880371,
-0.06445342302322388,
-0.15595145523548126,
0.471028208732605,
-0.42605921626091003,
0.0392281636595726,
0.6843865513801575,
0.3488315939903259,
0.22734852135181427,
-0.3865470886230469,
0.2274537831544876,
0.48170801997184753,
-0.6882891654968262,
-0.9895357489585876,
0.05165865272283554,
-1.1710152626037598,
-0.05219968035817146,
1.2480831146240234,
-0.29990604519844055,
-0.11290829628705978,
-0.011649052612483501,
-0.3736824095249176,
0.17284895479679108,
-0.12571728229522705,
0.9782071709632874,
0.8435068726539612,
-0.1077997013926506,
0.14596016705036163,
-0.7093132734298706,
0.3564051687717438,
0.45912614464759827,
-0.8978467583656311,
-0.002550995908677578,
0.326307088136673,
0.05665059760212898,
-0.09513365477323532,
0.4332027733325958,
0.23808586597442627,
0.40114933252334595,
0.15588536858558655,
0.13056334853172302,
-0.055912114679813385,
-0.3828219473361969,
-0.27888357639312744,
0.13822545111179352,
0.29685670137405396,
0.3404006361961365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15890v1 | Language Alignment via Nash-learning and Adaptive feedback | 2024-06-22T16:55:21 | 2024-06-22T16:55:21 | Ari Azarafrooz, Farshid Faal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT | Recent research has shown the potential of Nash Learning via Human Feedback
for large language model alignment by incorporating the notion of a preference
model in a minimax game setup. We take this idea further by casting the
alignment as a mirror descent algorithm against the adaptive feedback of an
improved opponent, thereby removing the need for learning a preference model or
the existence of an annotated dataset altogether. The resulting algorithm,
which we refer to as Language Alignment via Nash-learning and Adaptive feedback
(LANA), is capable of self-alignment without the need for a human-annotated
preference dataset. We support this statement with various experiments and
mathematical discussion. | [
-0.1588951200246811,
-0.5157971978187561,
0.44057244062423706,
-0.11932655423879623,
0.16787175834178925,
0.3564932644367218,
-0.27570512890815735,
-0.18411701917648315,
0.4541272222995758,
0.48909395933151245,
-0.7628588080406189,
-0.28062903881073,
-0.45119357109069824,
-0.008844257332384586,
-0.15340737998485565,
1.2530962228775024,
-0.06331373751163483,
0.40905892848968506,
-0.13822174072265625,
-0.5504583120346069,
-0.986871063709259,
-0.1428559422492981,
-0.7720556855201721,
-0.2925666272640228,
0.5343341827392578,
0.7970826029777527,
0.9257436990737915,
0.6482288837432861,
0.3102458119392395,
0.32602065801620483,
0.4085409939289093,
0.14794646203517914,
-0.5740737915039062,
0.09617447108030319,
-0.19980749487876892,
-0.6571067571640015,
-0.6895525455474854,
0.14703118801116943,
1.007718801498413,
0.49389714002609253,
-0.2772391140460968,
0.09578616172075272,
0.13989052176475525,
1.189345121383667,
-0.5667088031768799,
-0.22477327287197113,
-0.6002708673477173,
0.1418507844209671,
-0.29704153537750244,
-0.1372198909521103,
-0.5035087466239929,
-0.5373291969299316,
0.23904110491275787,
-0.5525098443031311,
-0.09381265193223953,
0.08997968584299088,
0.954016923904419,
0.41425928473472595,
-0.2742413878440857,
-0.43849101662635803,
-0.7271409034729004,
0.8551203012466431,
-0.464974045753479,
0.2937641441822052,
0.208333820104599,
0.31778788566589355,
-0.07040237635374069,
0.04543224349617958,
-0.7279320359230042,
-0.20641647279262543,
-0.05834931880235672,
0.2396906316280365,
-0.031523723155260086,
0.11304914951324463,
0.05730728432536125,
0.09813649952411652,
-0.6486237049102783,
0.2938190996646881,
-0.2360929399728775,
-0.056982461363077164,
0.8152115345001221,
0.21150849759578705,
0.6474499702453613,
0.0930948406457901,
-0.3982935845851898,
-0.029744327068328857,
-0.8413376808166504,
-0.01945156417787075,
0.4950241148471832,
0.5541427731513977,
-0.14133991301059723,
0.5300699472427368,
0.28820285201072693,
0.8566383123397827,
0.5295556783676147,
-0.43831437826156616,
0.2078036516904831,
-0.19602161645889282,
-0.09104791283607483,
0.24437570571899414,
0.7525003552436829,
0.41815462708473206,
0.016186708584427834,
-0.18883514404296875,
-0.27259108424186707,
0.12186380475759506,
0.27148863673210144,
-0.13203422725200653,
-0.1866379827260971,
0.04397936165332794,
-0.4488797187805176,
-0.3548676371574402,
-0.20441077649593353,
-0.8125812411308289,
-0.47464632987976074,
-0.429043710231781,
0.9673143625259399,
-0.04664216935634613,
-0.11778803169727325,
-0.38074034452438354,
0.16280747950077057,
0.25697457790374756,
0.30577507615089417,
-1.166115641593933,
0.634771466255188,
0.49138739705085754,
0.7795959711074829,
-0.36915120482444763,
-0.2238711416721344,
-0.7458072304725647,
-0.02399797923862934,
-0.6958717703819275,
0.7273387312889099,
-0.6887621879577637,
-0.33244240283966064,
-0.1594972163438797,
-0.012885143049061298,
-0.21302032470703125,
-0.3591037392616272,
0.3060940206050873,
-0.580498993396759,
0.5352599024772644,
-0.378063440322876,
-0.7948938608169556,
-0.06394357979297638,
-0.07727935165166855,
-0.671158492565155,
0.8926637768745422,
0.0024099552538245916,
-0.7368245720863342,
0.5678500533103943,
-0.9271349310874939,
-0.2661195695400238,
0.06707944720983505,
-0.1585770547389984,
-0.5156021118164062,
0.049012307077646255,
0.08451833575963974,
-0.021360808983445168,
-0.17216786742210388,
0.06539751589298248,
-0.2653227150440216,
-0.28737467527389526,
0.23467980325222015,
-0.12537145614624023,
0.5860061049461365,
0.3484644889831543,
-0.7879272103309631,
0.3044819235801697,
-0.6184390187263489,
-0.12239998579025269,
-0.011212472803890705,
-0.3595837354660034,
-0.2893761098384857,
0.4301518201828003,
-0.18445773422718048,
0.04171545058488846,
0.37238791584968567,
-0.5149329900741577,
0.6413488984107971,
-0.49610570073127747,
-0.18185243010520935,
1.0588431358337402,
-0.48548623919487,
0.9475364685058594,
-0.49847227334976196,
0.8374547362327576,
-0.2856963872909546,
0.17176541686058044,
0.39387696981430054,
-0.30853453278541565,
-0.8403294086456299,
-0.004171318840235472,
0.7284783720970154,
0.5072109699249268,
-0.8584858775138855,
0.28785350918769836,
-0.37692564725875854,
-0.2610566020011902,
-1.1334092617034912,
0.4197230637073517,
0.6932410597801208,
0.30940449237823486,
0.2299928367137909,
-0.7507320046424866,
-0.7734885811805725,
-0.859896719455719,
0.028064753860235214,
-0.09629727154970169,
0.6451470851898193,
0.5672534108161926,
-0.019533788785338402,
-0.14689834415912628,
0.950015664100647,
-0.4735923409461975,
-0.6084539294242859,
-0.39391621947288513,
0.11500810086727142,
0.05163755267858505,
0.540727436542511,
0.6360654234886169,
-0.7015362977981567,
-0.9777491092681885,
0.13563042879104614,
-0.3212023675441742,
-0.14519481360912323,
-0.008402639999985695,
-0.12099096924066544,
0.6128695607185364,
0.2663916051387787,
0.056222617626190186,
0.3296791911125183,
1.0217140913009644,
-0.2077587991952896,
0.4295220673084259,
-0.23517808318138123,
0.2614988386631012,
-1.2442106008529663,
0.12835165858268738,
-0.3448261022567749,
-0.45650872588157654,
-0.8312111496925354,
-0.012981120496988297,
0.011001785285770893,
0.19346068799495697,
-0.04521586373448372,
0.5755037069320679,
-0.6312583684921265,
-0.3126017153263092,
-0.7405593991279602,
0.4515562653541565,
-0.408562034368515,
0.2510843873023987,
0.33756592869758606,
1.0261743068695068,
0.43865716457366943,
-0.43095988035202026,
0.4340270757675171,
0.08760058879852295,
-0.18401731550693512,
0.6265475153923035,
-0.25243252515792847,
0.33845964074134827,
-0.2816724181175232,
0.0496794693171978,
-1.0802173614501953,
-0.034538909792900085,
0.18345977365970612,
-0.5561851263046265,
0.6405551433563232,
-0.36701127886772156,
0.029795564711093903,
-0.19012053310871124,
-0.38377290964126587,
0.3304418921470642,
0.47016727924346924,
-0.5536256432533264,
0.325383722782135,
0.8301897644996643,
-0.022506291046738625,
-1.0777599811553955,
-0.2861039936542511,
0.055343206971883774,
-0.12252306938171387,
-0.14402566850185394,
0.16274394094944,
-0.4078289568424225,
-0.3118026852607727,
0.03935828432440758,
0.2857836186885834,
0.0044608633033931255,
0.13188640773296356,
0.1690223067998886,
0.49940213561058044,
-0.36713308095932007,
0.37420234084129333,
0.006652059033513069,
-0.2918252944946289,
-0.35494333505630493,
-0.2673492431640625,
0.6130180954933167,
0.006642325781285763,
0.0014676033752039075,
-0.4139900505542755,
0.31009170413017273,
0.43913453817367554,
0.07052155584096909,
0.930212140083313,
0.29284682869911194,
-0.27182596921920776,
-0.17054620385169983,
-0.5332726240158081,
0.10698781162500381,
-0.44418224692344666,
0.046877942979335785,
-0.41808149218559265,
-0.9023270010948181,
0.29014450311660767,
0.34568148851394653,
0.043081264942884445,
0.6475648880004883,
0.6827885508537292,
-0.40551885962486267,
1.2680670022964478,
0.9183499217033386,
-0.5724857449531555,
0.49913489818573,
0.039424750953912735,
0.09243234992027283,
-0.9457259178161621,
0.10607649385929108,
-0.6018304228782654,
-0.5778255462646484,
-0.7787231206893921,
-0.11761952191591263,
0.13965561985969543,
-0.28638091683387756,
-0.17123101651668549,
0.5591465830802917,
-0.47663408517837524,
0.771608293056488,
0.530035138130188,
0.09849955141544342,
0.04488583654165268,
-0.5010424852371216,
-0.37114790081977844,
-0.44691601395606995,
-0.6223211884498596,
-0.3165479004383087,
1.2029691934585571,
0.14768743515014648,
0.9700478911399841,
0.43514809012413025,
0.9433428049087524,
0.4720161259174347,
0.5998172760009766,
-0.6968287229537964,
0.2067437767982483,
-0.1983667016029358,
-0.8613513708114624,
-0.5607131123542786,
-0.37139061093330383,
-0.9535485506057739,
-0.10381761193275452,
-0.4533703923225403,
-0.8726851940155029,
0.3127692639827728,
0.3471536934375763,
-0.6502322554588318,
0.32234641909599304,
-0.5408644676208496,
0.8825729489326477,
-0.3459169268608093,
-0.42284366488456726,
-0.21132388710975647,
-0.7098665833473206,
0.2896643280982971,
-0.18951953947544098,
0.5640862584114075,
-0.006323189940303564,
0.013830968178808689,
0.9012752771377563,
-0.5577362179756165,
0.8265736103057861,
-0.3712543547153473,
-0.2022477239370346,
0.03813791275024414,
0.356376588344574,
0.3959112763404846,
-0.30354323983192444,
0.18973393738269806,
-0.7648080587387085,
0.0769689604640007,
-0.33538392186164856,
-0.5722021460533142,
0.8833450675010681,
-1.0849016904830933,
-0.659789502620697,
-0.5229813456535339,
-0.5263550877571106,
-0.29009005427360535,
0.08862640708684921,
0.01844078116118908,
0.3521897792816162,
-0.23248961567878723,
-0.1671288013458252,
0.4349057972431183,
-0.09572695940732956,
0.40514618158340454,
0.5950078368186951,
-0.6036685109138489,
-0.4925590753555298,
1.1911283731460571,
0.14785213768482208,
0.5530582666397095,
0.4951564073562622,
0.265319287776947,
-0.43381768465042114,
-0.5102688074111938,
-0.5392059683799744,
0.3137763440608978,
-0.5408130288124084,
-0.21652139723300934,
-0.25099632143974304,
-0.09457933157682419,
-0.3430554270744324,
-0.34950849413871765,
-0.5934234261512756,
-0.4153088331222534,
-0.14895957708358765,
0.038184527307748795,
0.023082638159394264,
1.3048744201660156,
-0.3957299590110779,
0.05607850104570389,
-0.8443538546562195,
0.01571536995470524,
0.6501425504684448,
0.24545881152153015,
-0.02500656433403492,
-0.5706826448440552,
-0.3011277914047241,
0.2554463744163513,
-0.285338431596756,
-1.03952157497406,
0.36057206988334656,
0.3303655683994293,
0.46808406710624695,
0.46233952045440674,
-0.17629258334636688,
0.892126202583313,
-0.5896689891815186,
0.7711421847343445,
0.3400733768939972,
-1.2685017585754395,
0.7007758021354675,
-0.251263290643692,
0.05171326547861099,
0.8585485219955444,
0.4939674735069275,
-0.5732724666595459,
-0.10693592578172684,
-0.5074964165687561,
-0.18894869089126587,
0.8211510181427002,
-0.16029073297977448,
0.08133252710103989,
0.11137519776821136,
0.4800379276275635,
0.24180397391319275,
0.015593711286783218,
-0.9762552976608276,
-0.35308676958084106,
0.2403659075498581,
-0.4359380900859833,
-0.3284638226032257,
-0.2189105600118637,
-0.2901798188686371,
-0.3189831078052521,
0.9456809759140015,
-0.41420185565948486,
0.2767408788204193,
0.01696404069662094,
-0.4334263503551483,
-0.6175917387008667,
0.12839677929878235,
0.8519538044929504,
0.561884880065918,
-0.0375957116484642,
-0.010644258931279182,
0.498504638671875,
-0.3389933705329895,
0.4717118740081787,
-0.4044775068759918,
-0.3205087184906006,
-0.2342931032180786,
0.12085942924022675,
0.673623263835907,
0.38923490047454834,
-0.43890735507011414,
0.7892872095108032,
-0.2443811446428299,
-0.1632680594921112,
-0.006175511050969362,
0.0870315358042717,
-0.025920283049345016,
0.11068084836006165,
0.12874582409858704,
0.13810153305530548,
0.14706166088581085,
-0.8624429702758789,
0.2661498188972473,
0.7429038286209106,
-0.9926188588142395,
-0.3415810763835907,
0.700543224811554,
0.102706678211689,
-0.39939072728157043,
0.28704458475112915,
-0.09000958502292633,
-0.7608913779258728,
0.28958791494369507,
0.6466984152793884,
0.7914184927940369,
-0.5266602039337158,
0.39999109506607056,
0.42401233315467834,
0.17277231812477112,
0.14128299057483673,
0.2092517763376236,
-0.2321329563856125,
-1.0172646045684814,
-0.44761180877685547,
-0.6113134622573853,
-0.5530610680580139,
-0.382321298122406,
-0.8450372219085693,
0.26398465037345886,
-0.4028738737106323,
-0.14922218024730682,
-0.06656289100646973,
0.29620370268821716,
-0.41558778285980225,
0.2918258607387543,
0.22540916502475739,
0.538675844669342,
-0.9615498781204224,
1.2116508483886719,
0.48714733123779297,
-0.31003227829933167,
-0.8598411679267883,
0.04369469732046127,
0.3559420704841614,
-0.9608473777770996,
0.7474632263183594,
-0.1535433977842331,
-0.310371071100235,
-0.06254956126213074,
-0.5821239948272705,
-1.1746526956558228,
0.9404452443122864,
0.18019825220108032,
-0.5474268198013306,
0.10399968177080154,
-0.33869120478630066,
0.6291201114654541,
-0.658047616481781,
0.12542268633842468,
0.6497277617454529,
0.31347909569740295,
0.030111482366919518,
-1.385596752166748,
-0.15634025633335114,
-0.2183554768562317,
0.032339539378881454,
0.4826887845993042,
-0.7933223247528076,
0.3578958809375763,
-0.31242096424102783,
-0.3571767210960388,
0.2474888265132904,
0.7166223526000977,
-0.359150767326355,
-0.14757196605205536,
0.6632118225097656,
0.7490718364715576,
0.6919365525245667,
-0.05032762140035629,
0.8859226703643799,
-0.14858530461788177,
0.4575187861919403,
1.2892075777053833,
-0.46668076515197754,
0.997448205947876,
0.24001438915729523,
-0.48285603523254395,
0.7141312956809998,
0.40261173248291016,
0.3143713176250458,
0.7183055281639099,
0.029254229739308357,
-0.13417775928974152,
-0.18255577981472015,
-0.025879744440317154,
-0.23866434395313263,
0.5738419890403748,
0.15633118152618408,
-0.2574014961719513,
0.1542932391166687,
-0.1858437955379486,
0.11915507167577744,
0.29647669196128845,
-0.24585986137390137,
1.3262931108474731,
-0.3115980625152588,
-1.0869828462600708,
0.2982651889324188,
-0.22617533802986145,
0.7655089497566223,
-0.4848787486553192,
0.016087546944618225,
-0.13655883073806763,
0.15792179107666016,
-0.29918938875198364,
-0.6324759125709534,
0.31219229102134705,
-0.15481652319431305,
-0.07823966443538666,
0.013755101710557938,
0.5086506009101868,
-0.7181360721588135,
-0.2758399248123169,
0.4158329665660858,
0.23159697651863098,
-0.0811038687825203,
0.9291585087776184,
-0.8231555223464966,
0.11618439853191376,
0.12448309361934662,
0.17684893310070038,
0.525458037853241,
-0.22806519269943237,
0.3555601239204407,
0.5443224310874939,
0.4737231731414795,
0.30176401138305664,
0.17326052486896515,
-0.025493072345852852,
0.6954897046089172,
-0.32921475172042847,
-0.2428789585828781,
-0.8417374491691589,
0.299842894077301,
-0.12778520584106445,
-0.1358402818441391,
0.7545409798622131,
0.5038880705833435,
0.5748595595359802,
0.08279206603765488,
0.7243486642837524,
-0.0510459803044796,
0.8349471092224121,
-0.5658814907073975,
0.7529956698417664,
-0.6866294145584106,
0.08739124983549118,
-0.6344965696334839,
-1.0613867044448853,
-0.5000230669975281,
0.7819600105285645,
-0.4113715887069702,
0.10922323912382126,
0.7228718400001526,
0.9129371643066406,
0.23937013745307922,
-0.15759479999542236,
0.405720055103302,
0.28457215428352356,
0.09728000313043594,
0.551160454750061,
0.5745468139648438,
-0.38917800784111023,
0.11622649431228638,
-0.12165404856204987,
-0.5424843430519104,
-0.14317096769809723,
-0.7784353494644165,
-0.7514074444770813,
-1.0295870304107666,
-0.2905077636241913,
-0.5487170219421387,
0.3273848593235016,
1.2986925840377808,
0.6472261548042297,
-1.0478692054748535,
-0.5728991627693176,
0.21028536558151245,
0.3056461811065674,
-0.10459236055612564,
-0.19472025334835052,
0.4714914858341217,
-0.6908075213432312,
-0.850848376750946,
0.49945002794265747,
0.46656447649002075,
0.004812683444470167,
-0.3247533440589905,
-0.5364184379577637,
-0.4431411325931549,
0.13359670341014862,
0.1259964406490326,
0.5765895843505859,
-0.6172454953193665,
-0.6047372817993164,
-0.15595971047878265,
-0.2241530865430832,
0.3231557309627533,
0.6756185293197632,
-0.5231801271438599,
0.9386166930198669,
0.3129119575023651,
0.48298683762550354,
0.32758525013923645,
-0.07655622065067291,
1.0432372093200684,
-0.45501458644866943,
-0.17389707267284393,
-0.023920375853776932,
0.457876980304718,
0.27710989117622375,
-0.25247249007225037,
0.3559677302837372,
0.14184372127056122,
-0.6873985528945923,
-0.6288936138153076,
0.14186622202396393,
-0.7257059812545776,
0.09046697616577148,
0.8477010130882263,
0.023699456825852394,
-0.38210147619247437,
-0.1161268800497055,
-0.48506733775138855,
-0.0625743567943573,
-0.19727009534835815,
0.9129647612571716,
0.7356298565864563,
-0.037969913333654404,
-0.2772749662399292,
-0.060152143239974976,
0.987827479839325,
0.5131199955940247,
-0.5921939015388489,
-0.07646137475967407,
0.3882659375667572,
0.3015294373035431,
0.24904759228229523,
0.8805648684501648,
-0.13216084241867065,
0.6875705122947693,
-0.2063436359167099,
0.22896304726600647,
0.7548369765281677,
-0.4649422764778137,
-0.6127749681472778,
0.005587821360677481,
0.631049633026123,
-0.15426266193389893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15888v1 | Real-time Speech Summarization for Medical Conversations | 2024-06-22T16:37:51 | 2024-06-22T16:37:51 | Khai Le-Duc, Khai-Nguyen Nguyen, Long Vo-Dang, Truong-Son Hy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | In doctor-patient conversations, identifying medically relevant information
is crucial, posing the need for conversation summarization. In this work, we
propose the first deployable real-time speech summarization system for
real-world applications in industry, which generates a local summary after
every N speech utterances within a conversation and a global summary after the
end of a conversation. Our system could enhance user experience from a business
standpoint, while also reducing computational costs from a technical
perspective. Secondly, we present VietMed-Sum which, to our knowledge, is the
first speech summarization dataset for medical conversations. Thirdly, we are
the first to utilize LLM and human annotators collaboratively to create gold
standard and synthetic summaries for medical conversation summarization.
Finally, we present baseline results of state-of-the-art models on VietMed-Sum.
All code, data (English-translated and Vietnamese) and models are available
online: https://github.com/leduckhai/MultiMed | [
-0.13523487746715546,
-0.7819499969482422,
0.6209841966629028,
0.28555798530578613,
-0.441570520401001,
0.3531036376953125,
0.059538986533880234,
-0.8945578336715698,
0.8711324334144592,
0.5720301866531372,
-0.54572594165802,
-0.6437729001045227,
-0.42286211252212524,
-0.14181892573833466,
-0.38763585686683655,
0.9108194708824158,
0.3141946792602539,
0.061406753957271576,
-0.19974331557750702,
-0.4680637717247009,
-0.24701616168022156,
-0.8484435677528381,
-0.6355851888656616,
-0.390279620885849,
0.4661311209201813,
0.5874735713005066,
0.6457861065864563,
0.7142673134803772,
0.5745764970779419,
0.26882943511009216,
0.05704256519675255,
0.4088995158672333,
-0.31122323870658875,
0.451768696308136,
0.27108198404312134,
-0.32003045082092285,
-0.9144853949546814,
-0.07811682671308517,
0.4554935097694397,
0.6408624649047852,
-0.23381337523460388,
0.2131570279598236,
-0.4760396480560303,
0.48893609642982483,
-0.2170771062374115,
0.14710406959056854,
-0.3505898118019104,
0.3481585383415222,
0.16051019728183746,
-0.29959630966186523,
-0.007965199649333954,
-0.6250896453857422,
0.3318101465702057,
-0.521632969379425,
0.01944517157971859,
-0.23411951959133148,
0.8290799856185913,
0.21705873310565948,
-0.3103783130645752,
-0.05447312444448471,
-0.8756684064865112,
0.462719202041626,
-0.8716058135032654,
0.14094582200050354,
-0.07378890365362167,
0.5748467445373535,
0.21601629257202148,
-1.0759936571121216,
-0.26894885301589966,
-0.15720663964748383,
-0.18645504117012024,
0.5683574676513672,
-0.12475638091564178,
0.20014657080173492,
-0.28638049960136414,
0.3887379765510559,
-0.5633750557899475,
0.2193070650100708,
-0.378546804189682,
-0.1860821396112442,
0.6287863850593567,
0.609610378742218,
0.32307788729667664,
0.139749675989151,
-0.09842108190059662,
0.321349173784256,
-0.5910021662712097,
-0.5698308348655701,
-0.3638900816440582,
0.08619063347578049,
-0.6952604055404663,
0.5339483022689819,
-0.34659409523010254,
0.6478915214538574,
-0.4843734800815582,
-0.4896838366985321,
0.1841382086277008,
-0.7144379615783691,
-0.2663567066192627,
0.3536493182182312,
0.8225545287132263,
0.804143488407135,
0.3728787899017334,
0.14616520702838898,
0.25164735317230225,
-0.01584790088236332,
0.2576999366283417,
-0.9208607077598572,
-0.2312791347503662,
0.5733048319816589,
-0.5723790526390076,
-0.5280593037605286,
-0.12232006341218948,
-0.4165782034397125,
-0.3443777561187744,
-0.30336901545524597,
-0.12014354020357132,
0.0678805485367775,
-0.2398761510848999,
0.12444652616977692,
-0.01663472130894661,
0.02658681757748127,
0.2586950361728668,
-0.43388864398002625,
0.2326785773038864,
0.8064079880714417,
1.319045901298523,
0.15168766677379608,
-0.01707485504448414,
-0.5488137006759644,
0.19220976531505585,
-0.3425944149494171,
0.7923974990844727,
-0.015449252910912037,
-0.7086267471313477,
0.02521509863436222,
0.004216230008751154,
0.01021304540336132,
-0.9079210162162781,
0.3488140404224396,
0.1318102478981018,
0.34301474690437317,
0.24856141209602356,
-0.4500754773616791,
0.08087702095508575,
0.2837578058242798,
-0.21118734776973724,
0.3562614917755127,
-0.04863235354423523,
-0.808515727519989,
0.11463481187820435,
-0.7547397613525391,
-0.5827425718307495,
0.20780505239963531,
-0.48376208543777466,
-0.7684727311134338,
0.010709946043789387,
0.17906689643859863,
0.7169997096061707,
-0.14885632693767548,
0.25646570324897766,
-0.013355264440178871,
-0.4205823838710785,
0.3572106659412384,
-0.21806396543979645,
0.6539815068244934,
0.47433730959892273,
0.1300836056470871,
0.42135992646217346,
-0.6909080147743225,
-0.17217274010181427,
0.2553912103176117,
-0.09619961678981781,
-0.05462317913770676,
0.14745494723320007,
0.08021724224090576,
0.07141824811697006,
0.030596043914556503,
-0.5934514999389648,
0.06958957016468048,
-0.6937441825866699,
0.4162687361240387,
0.3361833691596985,
0.5442444086074829,
0.03488273173570633,
-0.5635248422622681,
0.733309268951416,
0.011582142673432827,
0.18043039739131927,
-0.5570544600486755,
-0.725433349609375,
-0.5002280473709106,
-0.7146459221839905,
0.16219182312488556,
1.0358293056488037,
-0.5020017623901367,
0.2505805790424347,
-0.6123571991920471,
-0.8636082410812378,
-0.9660654664039612,
-0.5068077445030212,
0.48598164319992065,
0.8087295889854431,
0.028496339917182922,
-0.1411677449941635,
-0.5577976703643799,
-0.9888657927513123,
-0.2953469157218933,
-0.3819534182548523,
-0.44890454411506653,
0.463506281375885,
-0.07048840820789337,
-0.3739745616912842,
0.9159042239189148,
-0.9505841135978699,
-0.3779331147670746,
-0.38279590010643005,
0.11806946992874146,
0.26698464155197144,
0.14493751525878906,
0.6499156355857849,
-0.4326360821723938,
-0.3431087136268616,
-0.0009037745767273009,
-0.9783428311347961,
-0.45024803280830383,
-0.3208782970905304,
0.08412812650203705,
0.03273108974099159,
0.4268985390663147,
-0.4019913375377655,
0.29977062344551086,
0.6661073565483093,
-0.2065333127975464,
0.5473939180374146,
-0.5357012152671814,
0.3259414732456207,
-1.4038715362548828,
0.1358260214328766,
-0.0611303485929966,
-0.6228967905044556,
-0.7543710470199585,
-0.35210803151130676,
-0.31830909848213196,
-0.4483657479286194,
-0.628596842288971,
0.49751171469688416,
-0.13004016876220703,
-0.09303568303585052,
-0.21694929897785187,
0.3734131157398224,
-0.015566838905215263,
0.1020757332444191,
0.1836564838886261,
0.7372235655784607,
0.25914761424064636,
-0.7249347567558289,
0.5389854311943054,
0.4230254292488098,
-0.3724309504032135,
0.7560700178146362,
-0.9159981608390808,
-0.2344880849123001,
-0.01688596047461033,
0.3129294514656067,
-0.6970431208610535,
-0.475573867559433,
0.22825856506824493,
-0.6737592816352844,
-0.160554438829422,
-0.2014947086572647,
-0.1809954196214676,
-0.1668669730424881,
-0.15640398859977722,
0.16405263543128967,
0.37453290820121765,
-0.21474692225456238,
0.29351601004600525,
0.9696646332740784,
-0.954830527305603,
-0.08884654194116592,
-0.9413215517997742,
0.58451908826828,
-0.13194169104099274,
-0.567836344242096,
0.43808600306510925,
0.027250362560153008,
-0.475517600774765,
-0.30312901735305786,
0.009183881804347038,
-0.1823703497648239,
0.07609673589468002,
0.18468952178955078,
0.3434389531612396,
-0.06857376545667648,
0.1336698681116104,
0.20657148957252502,
-0.41432732343673706,
0.1716759204864502,
-0.10875342041254044,
0.23743486404418945,
0.028958136215806007,
-0.2980988323688507,
-0.7326502203941345,
0.6885790228843689,
0.7553262114524841,
-0.18801727890968323,
0.5400504469871521,
0.5775721669197083,
-0.4971005320549011,
0.5060750246047974,
-0.4229903519153595,
-0.11819005012512207,
-0.3512108325958252,
0.6112319827079773,
-0.004169902764260769,
-0.7177935838699341,
0.5316786766052246,
-0.11058754473924637,
0.49033045768737793,
0.22818326950073242,
0.7732976078987122,
-0.26197704672813416,
0.998611330986023,
0.3373968303203583,
-0.15718171000480652,
0.44691553711891174,
-0.15731802582740784,
0.3124524652957916,
-0.30350297689437866,
-0.2673633396625519,
-0.34835490584373474,
-0.11832735687494278,
-0.5593909025192261,
-0.21885421872138977,
0.9666959047317505,
-0.5278686285018921,
0.2572294771671295,
-0.005187165457755327,
-0.6028986573219299,
0.37148457765579224,
0.48037245869636536,
0.026536254212260246,
0.46786999702453613,
-0.17244812846183777,
0.2634212076663971,
-0.13442875444889069,
-0.7604486346244812,
-0.43016883730888367,
0.5650538206100464,
0.3523557484149933,
0.6686577796936035,
-0.039113204926252365,
0.7343873381614685,
0.2933451235294342,
0.25306054949760437,
-0.7821091413497925,
0.4837042987346649,
-0.15237115323543549,
-0.24258509278297424,
-0.04241766780614853,
-0.6047067642211914,
-0.8514570593833923,
0.3827250301837921,
-0.30412545800209045,
-0.3219263553619385,
-0.17235709726810455,
0.17894156277179718,
-0.6606903076171875,
0.1557580679655075,
-0.7976588010787964,
0.7403802275657654,
-0.2951374351978302,
0.023426782339811325,
-0.435820996761322,
-1.000594973564148,
0.2776806056499481,
0.1601407378911972,
0.4350600838661194,
-0.2621566355228424,
0.001049255719408393,
0.7161293625831604,
-0.679804801940918,
0.716445803642273,
-0.21546362340450287,
-0.06646954268217087,
0.275680273771286,
-0.18125593662261963,
-0.0013357390416786075,
0.34904715418815613,
0.297290563583374,
0.2931878864765167,
0.14955374598503113,
-0.27604004740715027,
-0.25819697976112366,
0.7437647581100464,
-0.18441426753997803,
-0.08624093979597092,
-0.5067009329795837,
-0.314668744802475,
-0.023750705644488335,
-0.017894914373755455,
0.1967085599899292,
0.6584028601646423,
-0.4467197060585022,
-0.1322350651025772,
0.4272732734680176,
-0.42594629526138306,
0.2433898150920868,
0.6283026933670044,
-0.25618699193000793,
-0.6665498614311218,
0.9025942087173462,
0.3922484219074249,
0.17107577621936798,
0.3642124831676483,
0.23435470461845398,
0.033723119646310806,
-0.25312113761901855,
-0.5117437243461609,
0.46433156728744507,
-0.39768561720848083,
-0.10407567024230957,
-0.9495636224746704,
-0.3599792420864105,
-0.48911571502685547,
-0.3840149939060211,
-0.37115734815597534,
-0.6695224046707153,
-0.2608431279659271,
-0.22903122007846832,
0.3239326477050781,
0.7673293352127075,
0.09587909281253815,
0.4505511224269867,
-1.1498593091964722,
0.6698176264762878,
0.35332244634628296,
0.37452149391174316,
-0.35642072558403015,
-0.17259763181209564,
-0.6382365226745605,
0.07397729158401489,
-0.009558436460793018,
-0.7958307862281799,
0.7240039706230164,
0.2950383126735687,
0.3236689269542694,
0.3479613661766052,
0.021214963868260384,
0.616001307964325,
-0.21026836335659027,
0.991474449634552,
0.15143384039402008,
-0.44245997071266174,
0.53367680311203,
-0.30759578943252563,
0.7258408665657043,
0.4768005311489105,
0.035462670028209686,
-0.9806748628616333,
-0.6710568070411682,
-0.608453094959259,
-1.0410466194152832,
0.5180732607841492,
0.04171043634414673,
-0.03690892830491066,
-0.03786241263151169,
0.2568664252758026,
-0.05922844633460045,
0.09219922870397568,
0.10906503349542618,
-0.4277133345603943,
0.01819547824561596,
-0.41609376668930054,
-0.2023533284664154,
-0.2295203059911728,
-0.1971316635608673,
-0.22396227717399597,
0.6189200282096863,
0.057333774864673615,
0.493207722902298,
0.3601355254650116,
0.003401802619919181,
0.37103399634361267,
0.39050182700157166,
0.9766502976417542,
0.8089310526847839,
-0.33802086114883423,
-0.04215336963534355,
0.13281849026679993,
-0.6626313328742981,
-0.16914881765842438,
-0.00486913975328207,
0.040653046220541,
0.5570852756500244,
0.323055237531662,
0.633630096912384,
0.27172285318374634,
-0.9227346777915955,
0.4444056451320648,
-0.4926815629005432,
-0.08901963382959366,
-0.5571398735046387,
-0.1506420373916626,
0.25440341234207153,
0.04928257688879967,
0.038141701370477676,
-0.15626932680606842,
0.2769874930381775,
-0.4119419753551483,
0.2816163897514343,
-0.06497740000486374,
-0.551582932472229,
-0.20740951597690582,
0.8776430487632751,
0.5211746692657471,
-0.5611603260040283,
0.41212978959083557,
0.30781227350234985,
-0.2860419452190399,
0.4844997525215149,
0.4544307589530945,
0.9850174188613892,
-0.25363796949386597,
0.24971146881580353,
0.0834726095199585,
-0.10361253470182419,
0.4115017354488373,
0.4259726107120514,
0.040322232991456985,
-0.10159694403409958,
-0.5912152528762817,
-0.0019215691136196256,
-1.0920050144195557,
-0.23292484879493713,
-0.30977770686149597,
0.07513358443975449,
-0.14973993599414825,
-0.3420984745025635,
0.10304760932922363,
-0.3142586052417755,
0.045028913766145706,
0.2780570387840271,
0.04972230643033981,
0.5424407124519348,
-0.6972265839576721,
0.4692959487438202,
0.5697718858718872,
-0.24179647862911224,
-0.04437577724456787,
-0.3076530992984772,
-0.030683452263474464,
-0.8130244612693787,
-0.14719057083129883,
0.08324634283781052,
-0.21437250077724457,
-0.0921064168214798,
-0.2852470278739929,
-0.1311432272195816,
1.1341755390167236,
0.5199652910232544,
-0.5234375,
0.03963923454284668,
0.0761914774775505,
0.6893311142921448,
-0.4415731728076935,
0.2397693246603012,
0.4357430040836334,
-0.041212745010852814,
0.019100410863757133,
-1.139748215675354,
-0.4276461601257324,
-0.257364422082901,
-0.5445009469985962,
0.2964474856853485,
-0.6079884767532349,
0.42369896173477173,
-0.3557959198951721,
-0.2762684226036072,
-0.1946703940629959,
0.5236548185348511,
0.24013730883598328,
0.5271552801132202,
0.07002200931310654,
0.2537263333797455,
0.7398412823677063,
-0.05055945739150047,
1.0442287921905518,
-0.5546515583992004,
-0.053226225078105927,
1.3763315677642822,
-0.11797358840703964,
0.5743562579154968,
0.11545044928789139,
-0.03643703833222389,
0.06594909727573395,
0.4066055417060852,
0.45293521881103516,
0.06422441452741623,
0.1952713280916214,
-0.580635666847229,
-0.03639776259660721,
-0.5495516061782837,
-0.5055968761444092,
0.42598915100097656,
0.5490847826004028,
-0.22675834596157074,
-0.0533655509352684,
0.030098136514425278,
0.373399943113327,
-0.0038168802857398987,
-0.04452652111649513,
1.3714733123779297,
0.3072231709957123,
-0.5125765800476074,
0.7166267037391663,
-0.09471119940280914,
0.5604471564292908,
-0.602362334728241,
-0.11467404663562775,
-0.3079560697078705,
0.1894829124212265,
-0.3401775062084198,
-0.6620873212814331,
0.5562291741371155,
0.2165071666240692,
-0.011838299222290516,
-0.21771898865699768,
0.5237796902656555,
-0.6356359124183655,
-0.45356839895248413,
0.01929803565144539,
0.4198172092437744,
0.4785442650318146,
-0.21409204602241516,
-0.4352205693721771,
-0.053208597004413605,
-0.1542821228504181,
0.1477499008178711,
0.13246192038059235,
-0.02389979362487793,
-0.001972745405510068,
0.9006264805793762,
0.33743545413017273,
0.5011530518531799,
0.034917641431093216,
0.4708704948425293,
0.656707227230072,
-0.6785665154457092,
-0.9141750335693359,
-0.7181023359298706,
0.6253284215927124,
-0.18679943680763245,
-0.11426246911287308,
0.32180526852607727,
0.8688502907752991,
0.3083159327507019,
0.014418608509004116,
0.9964868426322937,
0.27991271018981934,
0.9407492876052856,
-0.2344134896993637,
1.1446173191070557,
-0.3318707346916199,
0.056827105581760406,
-0.0928850993514061,
-0.3290800452232361,
-0.5602172017097473,
0.3889661133289337,
0.31483885645866394,
-0.48916560411453247,
0.2615516483783722,
0.6230043172836304,
0.11473304033279419,
-0.0691303238272667,
0.37716612219810486,
0.1651008278131485,
0.625480055809021,
0.2636204957962036,
0.3279346823692322,
-0.3507225811481476,
0.5650666356086731,
-0.21601033210754395,
-0.43138718605041504,
-0.5113847851753235,
-0.6655512452125549,
-0.3905355930328369,
-0.3445416986942291,
-0.543692946434021,
-0.1755504161119461,
0.11713451892137527,
1.0638549327850342,
0.7630522847175598,
-0.683467447757721,
-0.3287075459957123,
0.36375513672828674,
-0.038074661046266556,
-0.319837361574173,
-0.17757460474967957,
0.22417302429676056,
0.0636989176273346,
-0.577506422996521,
0.6915306448936462,
0.5523779988288879,
0.1452997773885727,
-0.022853251546621323,
-0.07568938285112381,
-0.18512548506259918,
0.10335398465394974,
0.7527908086776733,
0.31324347853660583,
-0.495892196893692,
-0.1074972152709961,
-0.019981129094958305,
-0.06773131340742111,
0.25938719511032104,
0.8818053007125854,
-0.8289616703987122,
0.8434966206550598,
0.411752849817276,
0.5104445815086365,
0.49477633833885193,
0.20882651209831238,
0.7447527647018433,
-0.8018625974655151,
0.14943119883537292,
0.44182831048965454,
0.12451215833425522,
0.14425064623355865,
-0.2284228354692459,
0.48408088088035583,
0.24881553649902344,
-0.6554974317550659,
-0.7825702428817749,
0.26745980978012085,
-1.0112444162368774,
0.18570494651794434,
0.46563395857810974,
-0.15104377269744873,
0.09206832945346832,
-0.4022887051105499,
-0.5446112751960754,
0.614219069480896,
-0.2658241093158722,
0.7817538976669312,
0.12153537571430206,
-0.4246278405189514,
0.10927057266235352,
-0.46378588676452637,
0.2530827820301056,
0.14069515466690063,
-1.1363521814346313,
0.2386009246110916,
0.6597660779953003,
0.05227616801857948,
-0.0559396930038929,
1.186105489730835,
-0.30915042757987976,
0.19682249426841736,
-0.19557598233222961,
-0.049969498068094254,
-0.28248879313468933,
-0.3211744725704193,
-0.35674983263015747,
0.18028570711612701,
-0.17398826777935028,
-0.5934329628944397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15883v1 | SimSMoE: Solving Representational Collapse via Similarity Measure | 2024-06-22T16:10:45 | 2024-06-22T16:10:45 | Giang Do, Hung Le, Truyen Tran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Sparse mixture of experts (SMoE) have emerged as an effective approach for
scaling large language models while keeping a constant computational cost.
Regardless of several notable successes of SMoE, effective training such
architecture remains elusive due to the representation collapse problem, which
in turn harms model performance and causes parameter redundancy. In this work,
we present Similarity-based Sparse Mixture of Experts (SimSMoE), a novel
similarity of neural network algorithm, that guarantees a solution to address
the representation collapse issue between experts given a fixed FLOPs budget.
We conduct extensive empirical evaluations on three large language models for
both Pre-training and Fine-tuning tasks to illustrate the efficacy, robustness,
and scalability of our method. The results demonstrate that SimSMoE
significantly enhances existing routing policy and outperforms other SMoE
training methods in performance for the tasks. | [
-0.7332096695899963,
-0.058173805475234985,
0.4633236229419708,
0.03156124800443649,
-0.14124032855033875,
0.05423906818032265,
-0.4829544126987457,
-0.02985541522502899,
0.6975419521331787,
0.49303439259529114,
-0.7037011981010437,
-0.1548532396554947,
-0.7469267249107361,
-0.099878691136837,
-0.12267674505710602,
0.44467923045158386,
0.1422901302576065,
0.08819369971752167,
-0.4186028838157654,
-0.28694361448287964,
-0.49505648016929626,
0.042086370289325714,
-0.75400310754776,
-0.24446216225624084,
0.3020784258842468,
0.18364089727401733,
0.6551409959793091,
0.6548178195953369,
0.18556588888168335,
0.570047914981842,
-0.06996050477027893,
0.6201075315475464,
-0.784522533416748,
-0.05493319407105446,
-0.38508057594299316,
-0.46049121022224426,
-0.1519889384508133,
-0.17086169123649597,
0.6854369640350342,
0.7958341240882874,
-0.5163947343826294,
-0.1168384850025177,
0.2219075858592987,
0.47005581855773926,
-0.5208169221878052,
-0.01339071523398161,
-0.9688721299171448,
-0.1487734466791153,
0.18412648141384125,
-0.2552522122859955,
-0.30251047015190125,
-0.039128627628088,
-0.13834625482559204,
-0.42166048288345337,
0.23525772988796234,
0.08311034739017487,
0.8037004470825195,
0.47110500931739807,
-0.2776537537574768,
-0.1489851325750351,
-0.4326358139514923,
1.1490219831466675,
-0.9630336165428162,
0.31199899315834045,
0.1986384093761444,
0.41127678751945496,
-0.3704396188259125,
-0.3116258680820465,
-0.625362753868103,
-0.40188390016555786,
-0.013368562795221806,
-0.08708559721708298,
0.08341416716575623,
0.24752414226531982,
0.12342090159654617,
0.15023310482501984,
-0.49972018599510193,
0.1187007874250412,
-0.3375159204006195,
-0.1839752197265625,
0.6776788234710693,
0.20923498272895813,
0.3141835629940033,
-0.12881746888160706,
-0.36336398124694824,
-0.026628904044628143,
-0.3411102890968323,
-0.42738932371139526,
0.48938608169555664,
0.15560322999954224,
0.22745883464813232,
0.14905735850334167,
-0.18182216584682465,
0.4244142472743988,
0.0049757687374949455,
-0.3423556089401245,
0.3129364252090454,
0.26756057143211365,
-0.2489764243364334,
-0.22107504308223724,
0.7846221923828125,
0.28085923194885254,
0.08797455579042435,
-0.5157740712165833,
-0.30619046092033386,
-0.38077107071876526,
0.30934619903564453,
-0.7772833704948425,
-0.29716068506240845,
0.09595216065645218,
-0.5300590395927429,
-0.20247016847133636,
0.21067079901695251,
-0.4600864052772522,
-0.34855523705482483,
-0.4643828272819519,
0.6160991787910461,
-0.49940407276153564,
-0.5644907355308533,
-0.014960776083171368,
0.11361539363861084,
-0.22826915979385376,
0.16880744695663452,
-0.967384397983551,
0.7788007855415344,
0.9239890575408936,
0.9544183015823364,
-0.21016354858875275,
-0.5195162892341614,
-0.4881318211555481,
-0.016360918059945107,
-0.2599048912525177,
0.5760695338249207,
-0.4671666920185089,
-0.41394490003585815,
-0.3572288155555725,
-0.21823938190937042,
-0.4728085994720459,
-0.9576556086540222,
0.2055066078901291,
-0.33160609006881714,
-0.20478607714176178,
-0.22452251613140106,
-0.6099434494972229,
-0.30558687448501587,
0.5104175806045532,
-0.743865966796875,
0.8994155526161194,
-0.007560680154711008,
-0.7822723388671875,
0.14449501037597656,
-0.2844226062297821,
-0.031763847917318344,
0.08543504029512405,
-0.7361345887184143,
-0.43826860189437866,
0.25391390919685364,
0.12540943920612335,
0.7779693603515625,
-0.18764930963516235,
0.09028315544128418,
-0.30259594321250916,
-0.6258538365364075,
0.08223874121904373,
-0.1499394029378891,
0.8386603593826294,
0.1267688125371933,
-0.2704753577709198,
0.1601465344429016,
-0.788915753364563,
0.18546754121780396,
0.06021689996123314,
0.07045359909534454,
-0.5984647274017334,
-0.02256777137517929,
-0.06842364370822906,
0.25087663531303406,
0.2674729824066162,
-0.36503732204437256,
0.2747817635536194,
-0.40817955136299133,
0.5018361210823059,
0.7622591257095337,
0.10888195037841797,
0.371140718460083,
-0.34394365549087524,
0.4043794870376587,
0.17889738082885742,
-0.3433402180671692,
0.003594391979277134,
-0.35689494013786316,
-0.49431416392326355,
-0.42069876194000244,
0.5173290371894836,
0.335440069437027,
-0.7976226210594177,
0.3478473126888275,
-0.6788828372955322,
-0.6202518343925476,
-0.6069312691688538,
0.2637627124786377,
0.2837177813053131,
0.25102803111076355,
0.17985770106315613,
-0.31199297308921814,
-0.3130629360675812,
-1.1414577960968018,
-0.21472707390785217,
-0.04823288321495056,
-0.06588124483823776,
0.6141706109046936,
0.26015713810920715,
-0.4746796786785126,
0.5815109610557556,
-0.5778510570526123,
-0.18034660816192627,
-0.019418522715568542,
0.4403495490550995,
0.04389862343668938,
0.7524481415748596,
0.8304999470710754,
-0.6575302481651306,
-0.21645255386829376,
0.3017633855342865,
-0.2813761234283447,
0.16719558835029602,
-0.32656586170196533,
0.20951488614082336,
-0.044333796948194504,
0.6852587461471558,
-0.43799319863319397,
-0.025759801268577576,
0.6593014001846313,
0.09536968916654587,
0.5500083565711975,
-0.43432390689849854,
0.5949816703796387,
-1.289124846458435,
-0.22388242185115814,
-0.17851781845092773,
-0.26664212346076965,
-0.2883159816265106,
0.2083994746208191,
-0.14130890369415283,
-0.27644050121307373,
-0.18080875277519226,
0.15276743471622467,
-0.549712598323822,
-0.2573715150356293,
-0.24632099270820618,
0.03170427307486534,
-0.4537584185600281,
0.7049275636672974,
-0.15039265155792236,
0.8340051174163818,
0.6830917596817017,
-0.33462685346603394,
0.10897094756364822,
-0.020754972472786903,
-0.2348080724477768,
0.28047558665275574,
-0.513225257396698,
0.1554347574710846,
-0.13360369205474854,
-0.2237105369567871,
-1.020810604095459,
-0.1429712474346161,
-0.0898430347442627,
-0.3596305549144745,
0.4315193295478821,
-0.3195584714412689,
-0.29312217235565186,
-0.13956187665462494,
-0.2871778905391693,
0.6559439301490784,
0.5510802865028381,
-0.2969461977481842,
0.8299473524093628,
0.14964866638183594,
-0.16137954592704773,
-0.617969810962677,
-0.7372937202453613,
0.10328087955713272,
-0.07987619936466217,
-0.8454235196113586,
0.3157558739185333,
-0.10290246456861496,
-0.1061859056353569,
0.056637924164533615,
-0.2086392492055893,
-0.41328394412994385,
-0.10589355230331421,
0.3411080241203308,
-0.31407493352890015,
-0.5942569971084595,
-0.19675014913082123,
0.4493787884712219,
-0.10383249819278717,
0.2042550891637802,
-0.10162997245788574,
0.6784214973449707,
-0.026405097916722298,
-0.44513002038002014,
-0.3735162019729614,
0.5402600765228271,
0.6447722911834717,
-0.15197281539440155,
1.0502089262008667,
0.5899392366409302,
-0.3585144281387329,
-0.6032640337944031,
-0.748060405254364,
-0.24730786681175232,
-0.5534655451774597,
0.6641508936882019,
-0.47360119223594666,
-0.7837104201316833,
0.7171634435653687,
-0.5455556511878967,
-0.16318699717521667,
0.33027154207229614,
0.515493631362915,
0.02768832817673683,
0.6087120771408081,
0.7005615234375,
0.04951786622405052,
0.23238249123096466,
-0.4959350824356079,
0.16400839388370514,
-0.42016613483428955,
-0.4412784278392792,
-0.4445610046386719,
-0.5258821249008179,
-0.4779820144176483,
-0.8700726628303528,
0.10174018889665604,
0.0465923473238945,
-0.031206484884023666,
0.4721199870109558,
-0.32660529017448425,
0.7631803154945374,
0.2882806658744812,
0.2425934374332428,
-0.0069853984750807285,
0.20673948526382446,
-0.22879362106323242,
-0.24427570402622223,
-0.9184470772743225,
-0.2648617625236511,
0.5275498032569885,
0.2161416858434677,
0.5167948603630066,
-0.1935148537158966,
1.228931188583374,
0.296450138092041,
-0.042618799954652786,
-0.7234330773353577,
0.8175209760665894,
-0.18474945425987244,
0.04488484561443329,
-0.38253098726272583,
-0.8763556480407715,
-0.6334826350212097,
0.3960961401462555,
-0.2652507722377777,
-0.7268312573432922,
0.49675217270851135,
0.14061090350151062,
-0.2613000273704529,
0.5845604538917542,
-0.5165823101997375,
0.592767596244812,
0.088894784450531,
-0.1758924126625061,
-0.5746564269065857,
-0.47227147221565247,
0.32562974095344543,
0.10911154001951218,
-0.02420986257493496,
-0.09166907519102097,
-0.38440069556236267,
0.9266182780265808,
-0.66925448179245,
0.445296049118042,
-0.11705143004655838,
0.11669532209634781,
0.0996004045009613,
0.35625723004341125,
0.36963051557540894,
-0.004372220020741224,
-0.29696887731552124,
0.36383405327796936,
-0.2698379456996918,
-0.7244014143943787,
-1.082985520362854,
1.2428174018859863,
-0.8773099780082703,
-0.2032211273908615,
-0.0609680712223053,
-0.7635789513587952,
-0.4903770685195923,
0.2814747095108032,
0.256923109292984,
0.5927944183349609,
-0.06909213960170746,
0.0397239550948143,
0.8656150102615356,
0.11975020915269852,
0.3005369305610657,
0.18896235525608063,
0.23825803399085999,
-0.6993438005447388,
1.1740401983261108,
0.2687324583530426,
0.22940510511398315,
0.10920875519514084,
0.040971677750349045,
0.11404958367347717,
-0.8650477528572083,
-0.3908616900444031,
0.22672973573207855,
-0.31851428747177124,
-0.326450914144516,
-0.5664466023445129,
-0.39950230717658997,
-0.2114534080028534,
-0.3700242042541504,
-0.6047573685646057,
-0.42003530263900757,
-0.0938694179058075,
0.07278887182474136,
-0.004958805628120899,
1.0290021896362305,
-0.06690122932195663,
0.40879300236701965,
-0.5644419193267822,
0.18886663019657135,
0.46408048272132874,
0.43552377820014954,
0.47671008110046387,
-0.48984813690185547,
-0.3088180720806122,
0.045809026807546616,
-0.15681767463684082,
-0.7020903825759888,
0.23243671655654907,
0.14915768802165985,
0.8205743432044983,
0.8407878875732422,
-0.1686180830001831,
0.9668784737586975,
-0.6714041233062744,
0.5600589513778687,
0.3415530323982239,
-0.8293128609657288,
0.05490170791745186,
-0.40799209475517273,
-0.18775853514671326,
0.7587943077087402,
0.6555051207542419,
-0.0943078100681305,
-0.13831375539302826,
-0.7251711487770081,
-0.7686959505081177,
0.48697414994239807,
0.47777417302131653,
0.18627193570137024,
-0.0864134132862091,
0.32142147421836853,
0.2836165130138397,
0.2802436053752899,
-0.22941561043262482,
-0.27060267329216003,
0.1359882652759552,
-0.15153905749320984,
0.18721650540828705,
-0.4062679708003998,
0.13962174952030182,
-0.10697594285011292,
0.7139415740966797,
0.06576045602560043,
0.21025767922401428,
-0.10902958363294601,
-0.014034888707101345,
0.0077620563097298145,
0.10051161050796509,
0.7441162467002869,
0.7052597403526306,
-0.15918949246406555,
0.08386778831481934,
0.46337106823921204,
-0.462622731924057,
0.04066074639558792,
-0.10469363629817963,
-0.1717459112405777,
0.0019271662458777428,
0.381939172744751,
0.5814325213432312,
0.7601058483123779,
-0.6453651785850525,
0.6371163129806519,
0.07942507416009903,
-0.5776180028915405,
0.12117276340723038,
0.16711094975471497,
0.13243268430233002,
0.09008187800645828,
0.34647437930107117,
0.7159993052482605,
0.3023758828639984,
-0.40521904826164246,
0.5643965005874634,
0.33732694387435913,
-0.296162873506546,
-0.04361870884895325,
0.5195295810699463,
0.29705220460891724,
-0.3856261074542999,
0.4606786072254181,
-0.3377602696418762,
-0.5050854682922363,
0.7156592011451721,
0.5913223624229431,
0.7016950845718384,
-0.46859338879585266,
0.2626131474971771,
0.37127360701560974,
0.5355092287063599,
-0.44296425580978394,
0.1940332055091858,
-0.033676229417324066,
-0.5412619113922119,
-0.6425861716270447,
-0.3002973198890686,
-0.1184181421995163,
-0.04591771587729454,
-0.7858487367630005,
0.16207288205623627,
-0.6674795746803284,
0.23716267943382263,
-0.6079522371292114,
0.06707864254713058,
-0.36970627307891846,
0.21832647919654846,
0.09092335402965546,
0.9036401510238647,
-1.114586591720581,
0.5740506649017334,
0.8133161664009094,
-0.29160022735595703,
-0.8719126582145691,
0.08482127636671066,
-0.27730822563171387,
-0.5379442572593689,
0.22747139632701874,
0.1381598711013794,
-0.32096096873283386,
-0.16650137305259705,
-0.5853011608123779,
-0.6267564296722412,
1.124022126197815,
0.8567561507225037,
-0.7149747014045715,
0.05956907570362091,
0.051544465124607086,
0.35933151841163635,
-0.5224891304969788,
0.3184921443462372,
0.43992865085601807,
0.0939972773194313,
0.1938522756099701,
-0.8999262452125549,
0.0331009142100811,
-0.10305985063314438,
0.09876702725887299,
0.4174425005912781,
-0.782462477684021,
0.7387831211090088,
-0.0926240012049675,
0.08771984279155731,
0.2549031376838684,
1.0559906959533691,
0.14451591670513153,
0.3476797044277191,
0.8730292916297913,
0.8499050140380859,
0.9199750423431396,
0.33057981729507446,
0.619360625743866,
-0.08145669847726822,
0.5447231531143188,
1.0751705169677734,
0.14789706468582153,
0.9587293267250061,
0.22721001505851746,
-0.15856371819972992,
0.5923256278038025,
0.17734937369823456,
0.12657442688941956,
0.450232595205307,
0.24332718551158905,
0.05054329335689545,
-0.6397969126701355,
0.08114126324653625,
-0.2535044848918915,
0.15080329775810242,
0.24448639154434204,
-0.37190401554107666,
-0.380031555891037,
-0.04245448485016823,
-0.1153937503695488,
0.5745956897735596,
-0.6799273490905762,
0.6867355108261108,
0.1833825409412384,
-0.22438091039657593,
0.6792885065078735,
-0.1695365309715271,
0.5348337888717651,
-0.5922090411186218,
-0.05625556781888008,
-0.1053299680352211,
-0.06712596118450165,
-0.3152416944503784,
-0.3728151321411133,
0.3351799547672272,
-0.6726151704788208,
-0.1643049269914627,
0.04911627992987633,
0.5684939026832581,
-0.7435328364372253,
-0.5366933941841125,
0.14900042116641998,
0.29201459884643555,
0.3028964698314667,
-0.07221949100494385,
-0.8428912162780762,
0.2733706533908844,
0.09028192609548569,
0.21222859621047974,
0.4466022849082947,
0.5408142805099487,
0.0974942296743393,
0.9617521166801453,
0.1334613710641861,
0.24475336074829102,
0.3737124800682068,
-0.15380975604057312,
1.0713673830032349,
-0.47648438811302185,
-0.6382715106010437,
-0.4591222405433655,
0.4091642498970032,
-0.3847556710243225,
-0.1446007788181305,
0.6642698645591736,
0.6172397136688232,
0.6860717535018921,
-0.23978424072265625,
0.34203165769577026,
0.12789498269557953,
0.32811877131462097,
-0.5283927321434021,
0.9160528779029846,
-0.7131835222244263,
0.31126758456230164,
-0.3222232162952423,
-1.1014647483825684,
0.01947944611310959,
0.5103062987327576,
-0.2021646350622177,
0.2791222035884857,
0.5589834451675415,
1.0298410654067993,
-0.8049482107162476,
-0.3659328818321228,
0.6762175559997559,
0.3371894657611847,
-0.05416097864508629,
0.4601038098335266,
0.3515264391899109,
-0.42977938055992126,
0.6191989183425903,
-0.35000643134117126,
-0.15683534741401672,
-0.22291871905326843,
-0.7965959310531616,
-1.2180123329162598,
-0.8257625699043274,
-0.6016803979873657,
-0.22943000495433807,
0.08418761193752289,
1.1815146207809448,
0.9192618727684021,
-0.9881712198257446,
-0.0012347698211669922,
0.1820043921470642,
0.027732113376259804,
-0.4430910050868988,
-0.12678202986717224,
0.40169185400009155,
-0.2991189658641815,
-0.5390249490737915,
0.31229278445243835,
0.41731393337249756,
-0.24245136976242065,
-0.37518569827079773,
-0.2251335084438324,
0.07148882001638412,
0.3486221432685852,
0.29701855778694153,
0.17647796869277954,
-0.7742801904678345,
0.037104297429323196,
-0.5625603795051575,
0.07237312197685242,
-0.09894101321697235,
1.1336863040924072,
-0.7513386607170105,
0.26613524556159973,
0.7820354104042053,
1.16920804977417,
0.171711727976799,
0.19460514187812805,
0.4392285645008087,
-0.8089289665222168,
0.39671260118484497,
0.3190353214740753,
0.5753068327903748,
0.1979745626449585,
-0.32826679944992065,
0.2785208225250244,
0.18966969847679138,
-0.60185706615448,
-0.792073130607605,
0.25362178683280945,
-1.484856367111206,
-0.06450321525335312,
1.0209861993789673,
-0.10418493300676346,
-0.463749498128891,
-0.06246953830122948,
-0.4155798554420471,
-0.3378869891166687,
-0.48940128087997437,
0.8076810836791992,
0.3253684341907501,
0.286340594291687,
-0.27130988240242004,
-0.22389841079711914,
0.2564793527126312,
0.5526488423347473,
-0.39182916283607483,
-0.17227903008460999,
0.13577105104923248,
0.4384250342845917,
0.2642548382282257,
0.46443745493888855,
0.17308251559734344,
0.09760911017656326,
0.2722645699977875,
-0.1093485876917839,
-0.5440585017204285,
-0.33673468232154846,
-0.22414878010749817,
0.3374377489089966,
-0.019422775134444237,
-0.18924444913864136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15877v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15877v2 | BigCodeBench: Benchmarking Code Generation with Diverse Function Calls and Complex Instructions | 2024-06-22T15:52:04 | 2024-06-26T17:05:14 | Terry Yue Zhuo, Minh Chien Vu, Jenny Chim, Han Hu, Wenhao Yu, Ratnadira Widyasari, Imam Nur Bani Yusuf, Haolan Zhan, Junda He, Indraneil Paul, Simon Brunner, Chen Gong, Thong Hoang, Armel Randy Zebaze, Xiaoheng Hong, Wen-Ding Li, Jean Kaddour, Ming Xu, Zhihan Zhang, Prateek Yadav, Naman Jain, Alex Gu, Zhoujun Cheng, Jiawei Liu, Qian Liu, Zijian Wang, David Lo, Binyuan Hui, Niklas Muennighoff, Daniel Fried, Xiaoning Du, Harm de Vries, Leandro Von Werra | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Automated software engineering has been greatly empowered by the recent
advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) for programming. While current
benchmarks have shown that LLMs can perform various software engineering tasks
like human developers, the majority of their evaluations are limited to short
and self-contained algorithmic tasks. Solving challenging and practical
programming tasks requires the capability of utilizing diverse function calls
as tools to efficiently implement functionalities like data analysis and web
development. In addition, using multiple tools to solve a task needs
compositional reasoning by accurately understanding complex instructions.
Fulfilling both of these characteristics can pose a great challenge for LLMs.
To assess how well LLMs can solve challenging and practical programming tasks,
we introduce Bench, a benchmark that challenges LLMs to invoke multiple
function calls as tools from 139 libraries and 7 domains for 1,140 fine-grained
programming tasks. To evaluate LLMs rigorously, each programming task
encompasses 5.6 test cases with an average branch coverage of 99%. In addition,
we propose a natural-language-oriented variant of Bench, Benchi, that
automatically transforms the original docstrings into short instructions only
with essential information. Our extensive evaluation of 60 LLMs shows that LLMs
are not yet capable of following complex instructions to use function calls
precisely, with scores up to 60%, significantly lower than the human
performance of 97%. The results underscore the need for further advancements in
this area. | [
-0.550236701965332,
-0.7174445390701294,
0.5613744854927063,
0.49531519412994385,
-0.027654562145471573,
0.24221888184547424,
-0.4300350546836853,
-0.5582567453384399,
-0.44326040148735046,
0.4643746316432953,
-0.5912245512008667,
-0.7533512115478516,
-0.4557778537273407,
0.2195298969745636,
-0.4612029194831848,
0.5840284824371338,
-0.2984491288661957,
0.23331251740455627,
-0.28359097242355347,
-0.07364728301763535,
-0.4505287706851959,
-0.3148244321346283,
-0.08244641870260239,
-0.2728216052055359,
0.04645639657974243,
0.5101680755615234,
0.4334025979042053,
0.4944452941417694,
0.642917811870575,
0.34375709295272827,
0.2525668442249298,
0.08509327471256256,
-0.29376697540283203,
0.16924922168254852,
-0.10629689693450928,
-0.7165027856826782,
-0.2871794104576111,
-0.17812480032444,
0.4789348840713501,
0.8538275957107544,
0.028717998415231705,
0.5833808183670044,
-0.109031081199646,
0.7689331769943237,
-0.6818615794181824,
0.4673703908920288,
-0.4628758728504181,
0.08026754856109619,
-0.2258577048778534,
0.04697248339653015,
-0.27317318320274353,
-0.5738542079925537,
-0.29604849219322205,
-0.21606415510177612,
0.08073537051677704,
0.06823446601629257,
0.6499587297439575,
0.3992936611175537,
-0.1856902837753296,
-0.3829675614833832,
-0.8012365698814392,
1.0868033170700073,
-0.8173253536224365,
0.19618092477321625,
0.2063942849636078,
0.6332213282585144,
-0.3656209707260132,
-0.7072429060935974,
-0.43248894810676575,
-0.44674307107925415,
0.24465174973011017,
-0.24050816893577576,
-0.08800367265939713,
-0.02140377275645733,
0.5963683128356934,
0.4103814959526062,
-0.6105184555053711,
0.21973727643489838,
-0.2861390709877014,
0.17609259486198425,
0.9185634851455688,
0.28594163060188293,
0.27268314361572266,
0.0514521449804306,
-0.12049681693315506,
-0.2019612342119217,
-0.6693987250328064,
-0.005264454986900091,
0.3696648180484772,
-0.020288702100515366,
-0.07364750653505325,
0.5608597993850708,
-0.2227848321199417,
0.801522970199585,
-0.2730025053024292,
-0.03865958750247955,
0.4419911801815033,
-0.14248725771903992,
-0.29435041546821594,
-0.08697431534528732,
0.5748882293701172,
0.45646435022354126,
0.481242299079895,
-0.22835321724414825,
-0.32223960757255554,
-0.07233545929193497,
0.5013718008995056,
-0.9368529915809631,
-0.05597776919603348,
0.440083384513855,
-0.40174904465675354,
-0.2076401710510254,
0.15097567439079285,
-0.642899215221405,
-0.4224202036857605,
-0.5792649388313293,
0.11805315315723419,
-0.37088409066200256,
0.08910547941923141,
0.026150647550821304,
0.04957856610417366,
0.4600866734981537,
0.1734887808561325,
-0.5690377950668335,
0.4650672376155853,
1.0243743658065796,
0.42676374316215515,
-0.11595454066991806,
-0.4453928470611572,
-0.7554118037223816,
0.03213263303041458,
-0.3960115611553192,
0.5378546118736267,
-0.6187355518341064,
-0.42771783471107483,
-0.025754082947969437,
-0.1108451783657074,
0.13500279188156128,
-0.9135118126869202,
0.4484396278858185,
-0.25744229555130005,
-0.35740578174591064,
-0.1571950614452362,
-0.6228020787239075,
-0.025124184787273407,
0.36317428946495056,
-0.5706143975257874,
1.0838392972946167,
0.29215461015701294,
-0.19995221495628357,
0.11219532042741776,
-0.5299485325813293,
-0.5281484723091125,
0.14976994693279266,
-0.5208747386932373,
-0.30423569679260254,
0.29624488949775696,
-0.10358282923698425,
0.4337728023529053,
-0.8099410533905029,
0.29749536514282227,
-0.586550235748291,
-0.5493861436843872,
0.46791526675224304,
-0.033508241176605225,
0.33341744542121887,
0.16286791861057281,
-0.8496626019477844,
0.228812575340271,
-0.9480060338973999,
0.5215843319892883,
-0.0520160086452961,
-0.34264233708381653,
0.018078073859214783,
0.17041608691215515,
0.1340266317129135,
0.30742064118385315,
-0.033055223524570465,
-0.5404483079910278,
0.23798955976963043,
-0.36971718072891235,
0.46113669872283936,
0.6045348644256592,
-0.31262558698654175,
0.037344276905059814,
-0.36230364441871643,
0.44518372416496277,
-0.33759617805480957,
0.16724689304828644,
0.027417710050940514,
-0.24217325448989868,
-0.5623966455459595,
-0.3663060963153839,
0.43134334683418274,
0.5277826189994812,
-0.3780299127101898,
0.5514213442802429,
-0.2807987332344055,
-0.6569145917892456,
-0.4543245732784271,
0.4729388952255249,
0.618291437625885,
-0.009833061136305332,
0.3492569327354431,
-0.3784559667110443,
-0.5018060207366943,
-1.138390064239502,
-0.31657683849334717,
0.1502717286348343,
-0.29704272747039795,
0.44463983178138733,
0.49244487285614014,
-0.37034887075424194,
0.7854345440864563,
-0.6616785526275635,
-0.02826138213276863,
-0.2841872572898865,
0.3670206367969513,
0.28051015734672546,
0.35847142338752747,
0.5883406400680542,
-0.7263657450675964,
-0.4132559895515442,
-0.052690401673316956,
-0.7213783860206604,
-0.4132787585258484,
0.00022749607160221785,
-0.04106669872999191,
0.12118294835090637,
0.7337678074836731,
-0.5066247582435608,
0.18827316164970398,
0.6770238876342773,
0.19079792499542236,
0.7929421067237854,
-0.0489950105547905,
0.17580698430538177,
-0.7739758491516113,
0.42078930139541626,
-0.05176525563001633,
-0.10287461429834366,
-0.23434601724147797,
0.4716913402080536,
0.13933886587619781,
-0.4318698048591614,
-0.2723918557167053,
0.4836585223674774,
-0.6083040237426758,
-0.3990335762500763,
-0.2979028820991516,
-0.08360227942466736,
-0.1479763239622116,
0.3229254186153412,
-0.48181527853012085,
0.6845894455909729,
0.48405522108078003,
-0.4639321267604828,
0.6117169260978699,
-0.023513568565249443,
-0.5082236528396606,
0.32070162892341614,
-0.7081876397132874,
0.11228446662425995,
0.241481751203537,
0.3040286600589752,
-1.0052458047866821,
-0.4553695619106293,
-0.23521089553833008,
0.02735418826341629,
0.3635489046573639,
-0.10080259293317795,
-0.8520727157592773,
-0.8230705857276917,
-0.5095651149749756,
0.3286813497543335,
0.5548489093780518,
-0.36965304613113403,
0.5177451372146606,
0.218291774392128,
-0.24084852635860443,
-0.3901180326938629,
-0.7466922402381897,
0.05307682603597641,
0.21666571497917175,
-0.675065815448761,
0.4608300030231476,
-0.26529353857040405,
-0.4456435441970825,
-0.07931709289550781,
-0.48557668924331665,
-0.16778802871704102,
0.25657716393470764,
0.5726872682571411,
0.1355949342250824,
-0.2621634602546692,
0.14222180843353271,
-0.2228555828332901,
-0.019936716184020042,
0.2703963816165924,
-0.24567045271396637,
0.6624283790588379,
-0.34334853291511536,
-0.8521559834480286,
-0.18358545005321503,
0.3961459696292877,
0.7244580388069153,
-0.4121687412261963,
0.21865740418434143,
0.5725886821746826,
-0.28085485100746155,
-0.464591920375824,
-0.8156896233558655,
0.10434335470199585,
-0.45965275168418884,
0.3086492419242859,
-0.5971263647079468,
-0.6288402676582336,
0.3419240415096283,
-0.45265838503837585,
0.3311024606227875,
0.1824023574590683,
0.5584849119186401,
0.10189022123813629,
0.9048347473144531,
0.4027394652366638,
-0.06692886352539062,
0.15916140377521515,
-0.15359312295913696,
0.26561322808265686,
-0.49427375197410583,
0.024820826947689056,
-0.7374470829963684,
-0.5821574926376343,
-0.5200732350349426,
-0.5821932554244995,
0.2352079153060913,
0.28456392884254456,
-0.21595171093940735,
0.26894447207450867,
-0.5871077179908752,
0.7757707834243774,
0.5612244606018066,
-0.06557131558656693,
0.12644566595554352,
-0.2602335512638092,
-0.03599439188838005,
0.10165887326002121,
-0.36672690510749817,
-0.48909854888916016,
1.2097769975662231,
0.18869762122631073,
0.9218103289604187,
0.09955689311027527,
0.9556059837341309,
0.29743877053260803,
0.45637691020965576,
-0.6460413336753845,
0.6605377793312073,
-0.23181110620498657,
-0.385704904794693,
-0.02716119773685932,
-0.5033160448074341,
-0.7300881147384644,
0.11737949401140213,
0.0011575700482353568,
-0.6830940246582031,
-0.1488737165927887,
-0.006561181973665953,
-0.252176433801651,
0.10911112278699875,
-0.9857969880104065,
1.0260684490203857,
-0.4829014539718628,
-0.4825771152973175,
-0.3242948651313782,
-0.6216350197792053,
0.49080562591552734,
-0.21444018185138702,
0.3718288242816925,
-0.19253794848918915,
0.1303454339504242,
0.3189791738986969,
-0.44154906272888184,
0.7739237546920776,
-0.053258832544088364,
0.02962714619934559,
0.243348628282547,
0.22682422399520874,
0.45979300141334534,
-0.07722184807062149,
-0.31716740131378174,
-0.20655132830142975,
0.1310596466064453,
-0.5884314775466919,
-0.43707552552223206,
0.9341977834701538,
-0.6195515990257263,
-0.5878334045410156,
-0.1246367022395134,
-0.4410797357559204,
-0.5320589542388916,
0.2181573063135147,
-0.06090515851974487,
0.44059836864471436,
-0.3168945908546448,
0.3176644444465637,
0.491312175989151,
-0.23324713110923767,
0.45336899161338806,
0.3260282874107361,
-0.15592703223228455,
-0.040496062487363815,
0.8457954525947571,
-0.15971043705940247,
0.18419942259788513,
0.13963645696640015,
-0.029424643144011497,
-0.1310950219631195,
-0.7065430879592896,
-0.5611000657081604,
0.05996330827474594,
-0.6666626334190369,
-0.25988468527793884,
-0.5182551145553589,
-0.10205420106649399,
-0.14581283926963806,
-0.3797779679298401,
-0.3849346935749054,
-0.23621954023838043,
0.2899962365627289,
0.12964482605457306,
-0.1280970722436905,
0.7101441025733948,
0.3291231393814087,
-0.17631874978542328,
-1.2164955139160156,
0.3930133581161499,
0.3410528600215912,
0.598642885684967,
0.009129533544182777,
0.19153186678886414,
-0.15488603711128235,
-0.19441728293895721,
-0.446707159280777,
-0.6156588792800903,
0.07399137318134308,
0.011995877139270306,
0.8381779193878174,
-0.1480541229248047,
0.2158939391374588,
0.4884793758392334,
-0.4233097732067108,
0.6098848581314087,
0.09252356737852097,
-1.0935275554656982,
0.40363749861717224,
-0.03679148480296135,
0.5553498268127441,
0.7441784143447876,
0.25665733218193054,
-0.1697111427783966,
-0.40400055050849915,
-0.48908770084381104,
-1.0144155025482178,
0.591293454170227,
0.11287728697061539,
-0.08841115236282349,
0.19829201698303223,
0.09671667963266373,
0.11324697732925415,
0.3829481899738312,
-0.3939415216445923,
0.06815133988857269,
0.13063865900039673,
-0.35316675901412964,
0.04446742683649063,
-0.06353103369474411,
-0.5216296911239624,
-0.01585337333381176,
0.31106725335121155,
-0.3036550283432007,
0.04827267304062843,
-0.05059036239981651,
-0.4182991087436676,
-0.09189414232969284,
0.580617368221283,
0.6585181355476379,
0.9175969958305359,
-0.16618561744689941,
0.016007009893655777,
0.22769197821617126,
-0.25662362575531006,
-0.024013541638851166,
0.5322169065475464,
0.26610422134399414,
-0.12997812032699585,
0.4805015027523041,
0.4938206970691681,
0.48462843894958496,
-1.1958063840866089,
0.4950318932533264,
0.05294615402817726,
-0.2638402283191681,
-0.2310626357793808,
0.3314068615436554,
0.24629582464694977,
0.23188075423240662,
0.3477160632610321,
-0.002112792804837227,
0.14563269913196564,
-0.6945104598999023,
0.3045974671840668,
0.19587881863117218,
-0.17189297080039978,
-0.08438611030578613,
0.46092841029167175,
0.5025947690010071,
-0.3685031533241272,
0.4096362590789795,
-0.36762577295303345,
-0.41592851281166077,
0.9029772877693176,
0.3376784920692444,
0.9726629853248596,
0.02517334558069706,
-0.08716633915901184,
0.29170647263526917,
0.12095040827989578,
-0.03657584637403488,
0.23464329540729523,
-0.011800539679825306,
-0.10935675352811813,
-0.5691377520561218,
-0.819992184638977,
-0.6546387672424316,
-0.15824607014656067,
-0.47128355503082275,
0.11798500269651413,
-0.6499135494232178,
0.04878846928477287,
0.24958854913711548,
0.11239182949066162,
-0.7143711447715759,
0.008848452940583229,
0.2972087562084198,
1.0745772123336792,
-0.39855706691741943,
0.7309298515319824,
0.7384711503982544,
-0.15106528997421265,
-0.7912025451660156,
0.11483842134475708,
0.282907634973526,
-0.3934878706932068,
0.8261041045188904,
0.4421052038669586,
-0.15494108200073242,
-0.14587895572185516,
-0.5648066401481628,
-0.37388670444488525,
0.9970835447311401,
0.26444876194000244,
-0.7905547022819519,
0.05324879661202431,
0.32203781604766846,
0.5370295643806458,
-0.3632528483867645,
0.3137204647064209,
0.5586495399475098,
0.7516999244689941,
-0.06893140077590942,
-1.001166820526123,
0.15459118783473969,
-0.3575061559677124,
0.13385696709156036,
0.2541663348674774,
-0.503812849521637,
0.8382095098495483,
-0.09174014627933502,
-0.06904488801956177,
0.11832009255886078,
0.1017255187034607,
0.37496060132980347,
0.22760923206806183,
0.48922279477119446,
0.3569236397743225,
0.6650123000144958,
-0.1597282886505127,
1.4206902980804443,
-0.5461356043815613,
0.18059411644935608,
1.0622941255569458,
-0.8313553333282471,
0.7752993702888489,
0.324058473110199,
-0.3241577744483948,
0.39749863743782043,
0.31262749433517456,
-0.39165881276130676,
-0.0023764437064528465,
0.8335099220275879,
-0.17832432687282562,
-0.3412562608718872,
0.21277332305908203,
-0.3957917392253876,
0.39848971366882324,
0.1395995318889618,
-0.10506550222635269,
-0.42291274666786194,
-0.10637706518173218,
-0.3220529854297638,
0.19286642968654633,
-0.11479412019252777,
0.5463238954544067,
0.12766583263874054,
-0.7779132127761841,
0.7503407597541809,
0.20825839042663574,
0.44992876052856445,
-0.7975310683250427,
-0.08005283027887344,
-0.12403890490531921,
0.6553950905799866,
-0.31555265188217163,
-0.7775805592536926,
0.3667656481266022,
0.13898314535617828,
-0.12365125119686127,
-0.07282856851816177,
0.5467748045921326,
-0.06033088266849518,
-0.3476949632167816,
0.3993113934993744,
0.3444255590438843,
-0.005100566428154707,
-0.20792613923549652,
-0.7632914185523987,
0.40693774819374084,
0.045280516147613525,
-0.21197253465652466,
0.4554290175437927,
0.45164331793785095,
-0.09538663178682327,
0.8171342015266418,
0.6486687660217285,
-0.22697120904922485,
0.2180616557598114,
0.15714459121227264,
0.9186959266662598,
-0.8791436553001404,
-0.13847726583480835,
-0.7247705459594727,
0.3143215477466583,
-0.39977118372917175,
-0.37099218368530273,
0.5561348795890808,
0.8631563186645508,
0.7954137325286865,
-0.3215179443359375,
0.7701407074928284,
-0.17622503638267517,
0.2421172559261322,
-0.5652515292167664,
0.34806302189826965,
-0.452036052942276,
0.301880419254303,
-0.22231389582157135,
-1.1606550216674805,
-0.40945860743522644,
0.17369990050792694,
-0.39195120334625244,
-0.11849340051412582,
0.7664493322372437,
0.8287873864173889,
-0.180772066116333,
0.10044214874505997,
0.15810784697532654,
0.14296816289424896,
0.490053653717041,
0.6841315627098083,
0.6945560574531555,
-0.22402235865592957,
0.7955083250999451,
-0.06689327210187912,
-0.2988737225532532,
-0.5066937804222107,
-0.601202666759491,
-0.7920413613319397,
-0.1090492308139801,
-0.2332640439271927,
-0.3120171129703522,
0.061863262206315994,
1.0830892324447632,
0.8051058053970337,
-0.9761826395988464,
-0.525235652923584,
-0.22760221362113953,
-0.0266764797270298,
-0.3684804141521454,
-0.19304855167865753,
0.03261362388730049,
-0.6506768465042114,
-0.7560712099075317,
0.4086175858974457,
0.31072932481765747,
-0.2765471637248993,
-0.22894415259361267,
-0.02626047469675541,
-0.043311409652233124,
-0.0930129885673523,
0.6876084208488464,
0.4113311171531677,
-0.5443074703216553,
-0.11361874639987946,
-0.0912398248910904,
-0.522415280342102,
0.01504579558968544,
0.9283850193023682,
-0.3376253843307495,
0.29343387484550476,
0.5379772782325745,
1.0813076496124268,
0.7783572673797607,
0.029661258682608604,
0.7105790972709656,
-0.8005697727203369,
-0.05784767493605614,
0.35972070693969727,
0.21178093552589417,
0.23123885691165924,
0.0745127871632576,
0.7781369686126709,
0.012617703527212143,
-0.5824790596961975,
-0.8797081708908081,
0.3083999454975128,
-1.0882914066314697,
-0.6491043567657471,
1.0996534824371338,
-0.17297622561454773,
-0.3999418318271637,
-0.03753449767827988,
-0.34431132674217224,
-0.07969149202108383,
-0.04523661360144615,
0.7542681097984314,
0.8155779242515564,
-0.25545212626457214,
-0.019494405016303062,
-0.7489444017410278,
0.2555650770664215,
0.4069950580596924,
-1.1076650619506836,
0.23070195317268372,
0.5913865566253662,
0.376645565032959,
0.21743828058242798,
0.3461407423019409,
-0.2043628841638565,
0.3507225215435028,
0.11204083263874054,
0.40231573581695557,
-0.22233374416828156,
-0.054240915924310684,
-0.006624951027333736,
0.4522274434566498,
0.4349326193332672,
-0.13145600259304047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15871v1 | Uncovering Hidden Intentions: Exploring Prompt Recovery for Deeper Insights into Generated Texts | 2024-06-22T15:16:11 | 2024-06-22T15:16:11 | Louis Give, Timo Zaoral, Maria Antonietta Bruno | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Today, the detection of AI-generated content is receiving more and more
attention. Our idea is to go beyond detection and try to recover the prompt
used to generate a text. This paper, to the best of our knowledge, introduces
the first investigation in this particular domain without a closed set of
tasks. Our goal is to study if this approach is promising. We experiment with
zero-shot and few-shot in-context learning but also with LoRA fine-tuning.
After that, we evaluate the benefits of using a semi-synthetic dataset. For
this first study, we limit ourselves to text generated by a single model. The
results show that it is possible to recover the original prompt with a
reasonable degree of accuracy. | [
-0.16903948783874512,
-0.9834052324295044,
1.0456387996673584,
-0.31927794218063354,
-0.21719172596931458,
-0.18903061747550964,
0.05960340425372124,
-0.4453897476196289,
0.3124334216117859,
0.7235532402992249,
-1.094739556312561,
-0.47104546427726746,
-0.512432336807251,
0.35974714159965515,
-0.5249245166778564,
1.1990652084350586,
0.11947315186262131,
-0.3739704191684723,
0.18599198758602142,
0.0009672497981227934,
-0.7615756988525391,
-0.14584462344646454,
-1.0427814722061157,
-0.049392398446798325,
0.7104827761650085,
0.609310507774353,
0.13705402612686157,
0.3902081549167633,
0.14340399205684662,
0.18762712180614471,
0.059669848531484604,
0.3700844943523407,
-0.7695109248161316,
0.17728614807128906,
-0.10861674696207047,
-0.43319013714790344,
0.04300759732723236,
0.33977264165878296,
0.674559473991394,
0.3550156354904175,
0.323440819978714,
0.008239311166107655,
0.17043563723564148,
0.5137872695922852,
-0.8337293863296509,
-0.14291620254516602,
-0.5297856330871582,
0.2989220917224884,
0.18336431682109833,
-0.4145452678203583,
-0.699409008026123,
-0.3436959981918335,
0.03060961700975895,
-0.6616537570953369,
0.2557871639728546,
-0.08531229943037033,
0.7002983689308167,
0.4861411452293396,
-0.5467276573181152,
-0.6659833192825317,
-1.0414607524871826,
0.8940983414649963,
-0.5664880275726318,
-0.27504947781562805,
0.3837982416152954,
0.3925230801105499,
-0.3455779254436493,
-0.7667158246040344,
-0.7493771910667419,
0.025055911391973495,
-0.18212629854679108,
0.281695693731308,
-0.45854002237319946,
-0.20780733227729797,
0.5371013283729553,
0.2722409963607788,
-0.22514571249485016,
0.05098036304116249,
-0.09175606071949005,
-0.29060307145118713,
0.6583476066589355,
0.43748319149017334,
0.5809944868087769,
-0.22936378419399261,
-0.25729140639305115,
-0.10106048732995987,
-0.8295697569847107,
0.4032774567604065,
0.3225031793117523,
0.3977055847644806,
-0.09021951258182526,
0.6720344424247742,
-0.25756192207336426,
0.39611363410949707,
0.08723410964012146,
0.03197324275970459,
-0.1295211762189865,
-0.4739120304584503,
-0.061112333089113235,
0.441025048494339,
0.7786005139350891,
0.1683010309934616,
0.2261040061712265,
0.2385207712650299,
-0.26577475666999817,
0.13811801373958588,
0.2790226638317108,
-0.7238121032714844,
0.039242275059223175,
0.20465761423110962,
-0.6258777379989624,
-0.4017397463321686,
0.01639675721526146,
-0.418260395526886,
-0.6488534212112427,
-0.1422799676656723,
0.2885870635509491,
-0.5481777787208557,
-0.13739803433418274,
0.06682077050209045,
-0.3298574388027191,
0.32599279284477234,
0.5912162661552429,
-0.756907045841217,
-0.1714615821838379,
0.7367806434631348,
0.7279518246650696,
-0.05040187016129494,
-0.1324925422668457,
-0.8024060130119324,
0.11849257349967957,
-0.330476850271225,
0.8936640620231628,
-0.42717403173446655,
-0.42566680908203125,
0.02415909431874752,
0.03897043690085411,
0.3082326650619507,
-0.13231264054775238,
0.7987282872200012,
-0.29237282276153564,
0.5703913569450378,
-0.4669424593448639,
-0.4577615559101105,
-0.12506496906280518,
0.5955127477645874,
-0.6938650012016296,
0.9186104536056519,
-0.3713954985141754,
-0.6789884567260742,
0.502525269985199,
-0.8044845461845398,
-0.3362472355365753,
-0.06923122704029083,
-0.3384622633457184,
-0.3447512686252594,
0.40571415424346924,
0.31813445687294006,
0.30600643157958984,
0.16005943715572357,
-0.11572332680225372,
0.07272497564554214,
-0.5504220128059387,
0.20806516706943512,
-0.9110090732574463,
0.8624147772789001,
0.03171506151556969,
-0.3767060339450836,
0.09770241379737854,
-0.6943565011024475,
-0.13430695235729218,
0.14314864575862885,
-0.136526420712471,
-0.7950624227523804,
-0.13085372745990753,
-0.5482640266418457,
0.04014302045106888,
0.22748443484306335,
-0.9280841946601868,
0.2746025323867798,
-0.6284173727035522,
0.11493589729070663,
0.8371492624282837,
0.43919533491134644,
0.5701597929000854,
-0.15877406299114227,
0.5205854773521423,
-0.01563876122236252,
0.012191724963486195,
-0.6748242974281311,
-0.7435934543609619,
-0.5508819818496704,
-0.21023957431316376,
-0.03480227291584015,
0.21063870191574097,
-0.8834486603736877,
0.09263356775045395,
0.18536153435707092,
-0.2029033899307251,
-0.5018576383590698,
-0.28019487857818604,
0.7317051291465759,
0.5856826901435852,
0.12530066072940826,
0.011015673168003559,
-0.2520959675312042,
-0.8355493545532227,
-0.5663127899169922,
0.05680057033896446,
-0.13217569887638092,
0.5881202220916748,
0.5600705742835999,
-0.25187674164772034,
1.154627799987793,
-0.8250750303268433,
-0.4573153853416443,
-0.3157890737056732,
0.3813264071941376,
0.5529600381851196,
0.48103997111320496,
0.6292165517807007,
-0.833721935749054,
-0.7038456797599792,
-0.020191526040434837,
-1.0850383043289185,
0.05170242860913277,
-0.4114675521850586,
-0.06799546629190445,
-0.012759129516780376,
0.3762873113155365,
-0.7383212447166443,
0.8610854148864746,
0.15912988781929016,
-0.6427753567695618,
0.5514622330665588,
-0.20557187497615814,
0.21096006035804749,
-1.112306833267212,
0.05531533434987068,
-0.26995211839675903,
-0.18803654611110687,
-0.8947643041610718,
-0.19772666692733765,
-0.050516270101070404,
-0.22613824903964996,
-0.5168344974517822,
0.9175155162811279,
-0.6764458417892456,
0.030771935358643532,
-0.7436528205871582,
0.15894447267055511,
0.02700374461710453,
0.36665078997612,
0.10579612106084824,
0.8435618281364441,
0.4586872458457947,
-0.6873857975006104,
-0.20222072303295135,
0.470403790473938,
-0.23583853244781494,
0.5519225001335144,
-0.6758204102516174,
0.5710796117782593,
-0.5976672768592834,
0.025114981457591057,
-1.045295238494873,
-0.5380008220672607,
0.6516091823577881,
-0.8120114207267761,
0.017363935708999634,
-0.2289752960205078,
-0.18628908693790436,
-0.065266452729702,
-0.43647873401641846,
0.32995060086250305,
0.5694332122802734,
-0.7659167051315308,
0.7036494016647339,
0.32844236493110657,
-0.07479210197925568,
-0.6856240630149841,
-0.416826069355011,
0.04615703597664833,
-0.22236283123493195,
-0.11753717064857483,
0.03865078464150429,
-0.09764709323644638,
-0.2792342007160187,
-0.15535347163677216,
0.026732996106147766,
0.24194392561912537,
0.12316914647817612,
0.4725516438484192,
-0.026864858344197273,
-0.04975805804133415,
0.04271431639790535,
0.5438330173492432,
-0.16104121506214142,
0.07433522492647171,
-0.08877509087324142,
0.45690879225730896,
0.1783347725868225,
-0.22218960523605347,
-0.7941532731056213,
0.6258042454719543,
0.21826902031898499,
-0.0902988463640213,
0.648453950881958,
0.47147035598754883,
-0.6379268765449524,
-0.3480006456375122,
-0.13641870021820068,
-0.41651642322540283,
-0.5333795547485352,
-0.1476840376853943,
-0.2764934003353119,
-0.772455096244812,
0.35175618529319763,
-0.04905636981129646,
0.09093204885721207,
0.22835493087768555,
0.3455338478088379,
-0.21083669364452362,
1.2801783084869385,
0.9641954302787781,
0.14460872113704681,
0.6902365684509277,
-0.304641991853714,
0.18451522290706635,
-0.6817320585250854,
-0.2679855227470398,
-0.471730500459671,
-0.4092271029949188,
-0.26308441162109375,
0.10321320593357086,
0.6337888240814209,
0.029467599466443062,
0.17065802216529846,
0.23685188591480255,
-0.5125507712364197,
0.7980747818946838,
0.8230694532394409,
0.3661763072013855,
0.3828663229942322,
-0.07150452584028244,
0.2881872057914734,
0.08139266818761826,
-0.4534614384174347,
-0.7580544352531433,
0.943347156047821,
-0.03572931885719299,
0.23576922714710236,
0.046451419591903687,
1.100242018699646,
0.5105060935020447,
0.18705062568187714,
-0.925366222858429,
0.6718996167182922,
0.1327267587184906,
-0.5478252172470093,
-0.5286856293678284,
-0.34109827876091003,
-1.535820484161377,
-0.025835474953055382,
-0.320209801197052,
-0.9106458425521851,
0.04914059862494469,
0.25848525762557983,
-0.5959405899047852,
-0.00531903188675642,
-0.7642216682434082,
0.7145029306411743,
-0.08388368040323257,
-0.37975260615348816,
-0.08539631217718124,
-0.4695327579975128,
0.4128076434135437,
0.040782514959573746,
0.07454489916563034,
-0.18577387928962708,
0.1787518560886383,
0.7951403856277466,
-0.2157410979270935,
1.0821017026901245,
-0.4370780289173126,
-0.2954294979572296,
0.5163831114768982,
-0.002485307166352868,
0.7563552260398865,
0.2897370457649231,
0.13232092559337616,
-0.18401078879833221,
-0.19971974194049835,
-0.34618744254112244,
-0.8099374771118164,
0.6715143918991089,
-0.4672834575176239,
-0.6035364866256714,
-0.33014971017837524,
-0.5514435768127441,
0.1134282797574997,
0.8403518795967102,
0.37531980872154236,
0.4084901213645935,
-0.5005591511726379,
-0.14012664556503296,
0.8759852051734924,
-0.5289839506149292,
0.9051544666290283,
0.5135337114334106,
-0.04589017108082771,
-0.03412070870399475,
0.6354257464408875,
-0.45892488956451416,
-0.19414907693862915,
0.35021570324897766,
0.4160837233066559,
-0.16595768928527832,
-0.5487009286880493,
-0.40991437435150146,
0.026638787239789963,
-0.5365520715713501,
-0.18637123703956604,
-0.6373147964477539,
0.08328771591186523,
-0.30284178256988525,
-0.1257602423429489,
-0.3052757680416107,
-0.267316997051239,
-0.8440782427787781,
-0.06060764938592911,
0.32939285039901733,
1.05836820602417,
0.05805535241961479,
0.4388537108898163,
-1.0934895277023315,
0.37809598445892334,
-0.05831069126725197,
-0.16083630919456482,
-0.06027631461620331,
-0.2925841212272644,
-0.134846031665802,
0.37945157289505005,
-0.012391970492899418,
-0.8428857922554016,
0.6949580311775208,
0.09116830676794052,
0.36948826909065247,
0.6755984425544739,
0.46711769700050354,
0.14074952900409698,
-0.49098360538482666,
0.9362104535102844,
0.19145970046520233,
-0.6881885528564453,
1.0864559412002563,
-0.510409951210022,
0.589954674243927,
0.5484128594398499,
0.42463982105255127,
-0.36999064683914185,
-0.04451664537191391,
-0.46373268961906433,
-0.5160104632377625,
0.8152853846549988,
0.39721518754959106,
0.49815890192985535,
-0.05710127204656601,
0.7309063673019409,
0.507198691368103,
0.15263614058494568,
-0.5057334303855896,
-0.11962965130805969,
0.005000082775950432,
-0.3302261233329773,
-0.05716646462678909,
-0.20577073097229004,
-0.2677153944969177,
0.1028946191072464,
0.24081851541996002,
-0.42718902230262756,
0.46830815076828003,
0.24619147181510925,
0.005622899625450373,
0.01425341796129942,
0.16590799391269684,
0.5133762359619141,
0.17792783677577972,
0.0968201756477356,
-0.03056921251118183,
-0.06424976140260696,
-0.6138868927955627,
0.047218117862939835,
-0.32070550322532654,
-0.6892426013946533,
-0.053021155297756195,
0.45574450492858887,
0.9423750042915344,
0.06348717212677002,
-0.8626996278762817,
0.6619517207145691,
-0.4451904296875,
0.22431303560733795,
-0.605503261089325,
0.35356125235557556,
-0.6253056526184082,
0.3582870066165924,
0.45458292961120605,
0.1522715836763382,
0.44432365894317627,
-0.9767336249351501,
0.07713817805051804,
0.7762877345085144,
-0.43415936827659607,
-0.615946352481842,
0.5699318051338196,
-0.018078524619340897,
-0.7450962066650391,
0.6028551459312439,
-0.2763645648956299,
-0.41989949345588684,
0.5366438627243042,
0.5889105796813965,
1.0898451805114746,
0.12249045073986053,
0.5248170495033264,
0.40340837836265564,
0.041659846901893616,
0.028419477865099907,
0.5758965015411377,
-0.35852718353271484,
-0.8236017823219299,
-0.1119668260216713,
-0.2412976622581482,
-0.28772544860839844,
-0.0994318500161171,
-0.619940996170044,
0.198301762342453,
-0.4778077304363251,
-0.10216851532459259,
-0.0374080091714859,
-0.16363976895809174,
-0.3980136811733246,
0.088912732899189,
-0.08780567348003387,
0.7213212847709656,
-0.640106737613678,
0.6014816761016846,
0.4761545956134796,
-0.4275897443294525,
-0.6406736373901367,
0.36268293857574463,
0.09837909042835236,
-0.8040696382522583,
0.18482714891433716,
0.4667890667915344,
-0.40211647748947144,
0.10051874816417694,
-1.0018397569656372,
-0.768251895904541,
1.0834760665893555,
0.18890142440795898,
-0.3665427565574646,
-0.21996043622493744,
0.04951208457350731,
0.6482405662536621,
-0.25119268894195557,
0.03980543836951256,
0.5993812680244446,
0.3541080951690674,
0.01725716143846512,
-0.4676547944545746,
0.14566922187805176,
-0.2174796313047409,
-0.5450795888900757,
0.42421358823776245,
-0.462296724319458,
0.7077345848083496,
-0.323693186044693,
-0.6743080019950867,
0.36433401703834534,
0.5083354711532593,
0.18715211749076843,
0.8630508780479431,
0.17480196058750153,
0.2755208909511566,
0.915551483631134,
0.027628080919384956,
1.3064268827438354,
0.09843076020479202,
0.05116868391633034,
1.0053743124008179,
-0.1408839374780655,
0.5833333134651184,
0.6699747443199158,
0.4608759880065918,
0.39306411147117615,
0.3628380596637726,
0.3644105792045593,
0.8727371692657471,
-0.44701075553894043,
-0.4030386507511139,
-0.07110505551099777,
-0.5407024621963501,
-0.07400818169116974,
0.5496143102645874,
0.44323843717575073,
-0.41974014043807983,
-0.09198640286922455,
0.1979667991399765,
-0.12094849348068237,
0.08145724982023239,
-0.6177187561988831,
1.1653552055358887,
0.14942210912704468,
-0.8687580227851868,
0.2705448269844055,
-0.23817873001098633,
0.4382067024707794,
-0.41604405641555786,
-0.3110085427761078,
-0.41833430528640747,
0.2174132764339447,
-0.047584451735019684,
-0.8909376859664917,
0.15318626165390015,
0.12768295407295227,
-0.2441379874944687,
-0.382532000541687,
1.1713517904281616,
-0.14461490511894226,
-0.2856219708919525,
-0.09837006032466888,
0.3908194899559021,
0.28735873103141785,
-0.26398441195487976,
-0.3142854571342468,
0.034106142818927765,
0.24785901606082916,
-0.08617007732391357,
0.22322654724121094,
0.7269611954689026,
0.05263107642531395,
0.4130585789680481,
0.6739746332168579,
-0.3075137138366699,
-0.0978136882185936,
-0.1041950210928917,
0.8097984194755554,
-0.9016464352607727,
-0.6625627279281616,
-0.9868934750556946,
0.5975608229637146,
-0.288634330034256,
-0.4547446370124817,
0.9595556259155273,
0.41759735345840454,
0.7405474185943604,
-0.14767543971538544,
0.8545028567314148,
0.10755171626806259,
0.5848178863525391,
-0.9246323108673096,
0.7377512454986572,
-0.575408399105072,
0.3269871473312378,
-0.5068504214286804,
-0.6031741499900818,
-0.0709620788693428,
0.3073018491268158,
-0.20521627366542816,
-0.2472875863313675,
0.5675912499427795,
0.5671506524085999,
-0.09134554862976074,
0.27068838477134705,
0.41212764382362366,
-0.07496709376573563,
0.2928875684738159,
0.6362408399581909,
1.3256806135177612,
-0.4182782471179962,
0.49692502617836,
-0.06266357004642487,
-0.40713363885879517,
0.02491733990609646,
-0.8006563782691956,
-1.1784780025482178,
-0.4853310286998749,
0.00030119248549453914,
-0.1969929039478302,
0.0073170471005141735,
0.5466145277023315,
0.3161774277687073,
-0.6766759157180786,
0.3400532901287079,
-0.34617990255355835,
0.1587352454662323,
-0.14634773135185242,
-0.2112858146429062,
0.36313968896865845,
-0.08365309983491898,
-0.9325025677680969,
0.8696630001068115,
0.3744073808193207,
0.41513270139694214,
-0.009470985271036625,
-0.15307843685150146,
0.02457156963646412,
0.275542676448822,
0.6818229556083679,
0.5131424069404602,
-0.3325255513191223,
-0.49179160594940186,
0.16771312057971954,
0.10179105401039124,
0.028803212568163872,
1.2982491254806519,
-0.9724373817443848,
0.1841353327035904,
0.44126763939857483,
0.6481490731239319,
0.677177906036377,
0.1689397245645523,
0.5933735966682434,
-1.1376454830169678,
0.09714199602603912,
0.3559114336967468,
0.23231591284275055,
0.03159502521157265,
-0.8768976330757141,
0.3609604835510254,
-0.08398548513650894,
-0.3900747299194336,
-1.0404472351074219,
0.6307711005210876,
-0.7976635694503784,
-0.4417213499546051,
1.1250492334365845,
-0.17338064312934875,
-0.23710933327674866,
-0.09686099737882614,
-0.7572973966598511,
0.34315046668052673,
-0.6143840551376343,
0.9502466320991516,
0.2352539598941803,
-0.5781223773956299,
-0.28335580229759216,
-0.13410711288452148,
0.6980255246162415,
0.31000804901123047,
-0.9677224159240723,
0.02872229740023613,
0.8517228364944458,
-0.03656734526157379,
0.2429482787847519,
0.9461973309516907,
0.24672548472881317,
0.3272688686847687,
0.11518226563930511,
-0.5641483068466187,
0.014230147004127502,
-0.727356493473053,
-0.347790390253067,
0.2119438499212265,
-0.23254378139972687,
-0.24503830075263977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15869v1 | A multitask learning framework for leveraging subjectivity of annotators to identify misogyny | 2024-06-22T15:06:08 | 2024-06-22T15:06:08 | Jason Angel, Segun Taofeek Aroyehun, Grigori Sidorov, Alexander Gelbukh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying misogyny using artificial intelligence is a form of combating
online toxicity against women. However, the subjective nature of interpreting
misogyny poses a significant challenge to model the phenomenon. In this paper,
we propose a multitask learning approach that leverages the subjectivity of
this task to enhance the performance of the misogyny identification systems. We
incorporated diverse perspectives from annotators in our model design,
considering gender and age across six profile groups, and conducted extensive
experiments and error analysis using two language models to validate our four
alternative designs of the multitask learning technique to identify
misogynistic content in English tweets. The results demonstrate that
incorporating various viewpoints enhances the language models' ability to
interpret different forms of misogyny. This research advances content
moderation and highlights the importance of embracing diverse perspectives to
build effective online moderation systems. | [
0.07167427986860275,
-0.7023329138755798,
0.48918431997299194,
0.3807096481323242,
-0.28264084458351135,
0.2546229362487793,
-0.1364293396472931,
-0.38295072317123413,
0.017975956201553345,
0.37444889545440674,
-0.7303194403648376,
-0.3752416968345642,
-0.8284173011779785,
0.3664325475692749,
-0.2976125478744507,
1.143025517463684,
0.07171696424484253,
0.12681251764297485,
-0.22603106498718262,
-0.049625005573034286,
-0.8455696105957031,
-0.3243100643157959,
-0.44774454832077026,
-0.17633871734142303,
0.6919264197349548,
0.2261328250169754,
0.28521570563316345,
0.4507072865962982,
0.2831922769546509,
0.3936513066291809,
0.14864103496074677,
0.45037776231765747,
-0.5994386672973633,
0.41292911767959595,
-0.36890557408332825,
-0.3200742304325104,
0.00273455330170691,
0.24055036902427673,
0.0851064920425415,
0.5914961099624634,
-0.04695289582014084,
0.3868470788002014,
0.2855263948440552,
0.4801299571990967,
-1.0360276699066162,
0.3693179488182068,
-0.4246683120727539,
0.12310148030519485,
-0.2791498601436615,
-0.0818275660276413,
-0.35983264446258545,
-0.2705269157886505,
0.09347487986087799,
-0.7840991020202637,
0.06738109141588211,
-0.09228958189487457,
0.5062206983566284,
0.20728668570518494,
-0.6942369341850281,
-0.5039218068122864,
-0.9596983194351196,
1.203533411026001,
-0.36109042167663574,
0.7218084931373596,
0.517690122127533,
0.08523093163967133,
0.4065127968788147,
-0.09462623298168182,
-0.18734106421470642,
-0.168380007147789,
-0.34727099537849426,
-0.06603636592626572,
0.06290282309055328,
-0.19407494366168976,
0.09879376739263535,
-0.021494366228580475,
-0.3435344099998474,
-0.3159219026565552,
-0.4563910961151123,
-0.19937701523303986,
0.44129207730293274,
0.06760294735431671,
0.2624915838241577,
-0.4344174265861511,
-0.2100987285375595,
0.5785151124000549,
0.05490754917263985,
0.13070225715637207,
0.7240914702415466,
0.42136961221694946,
-0.14085063338279724,
0.41771331429481506,
-0.12190493196249008,
0.3188095688819885,
0.24828413128852844,
-0.5349887609481812,
0.42274022102355957,
-0.23865310847759247,
-0.07654324173927307,
-0.18410885334014893,
0.5608832240104675,
0.1661965399980545,
-0.0016658228123560548,
-0.2437513768672943,
-0.02746679075062275,
0.04808768257498741,
1.0091266632080078,
-0.6232789158821106,
-0.306585431098938,
0.1872093677520752,
-0.8261743783950806,
-0.5406972765922546,
0.13563071191310883,
-0.8784284591674805,
-0.6405835747718811,
-0.4580150246620178,
0.4277031421661377,
-0.38724714517593384,
-0.5764738917350769,
-0.4348422884941101,
-0.43405744433403015,
-0.14351589977741241,
0.5819481611251831,
-0.6342995166778564,
0.08511339873075485,
0.6043035984039307,
0.7571810483932495,
-0.07924419641494751,
-0.3440648019313812,
-0.27872568368911743,
0.010939103551208973,
-0.43624645471572876,
0.3610260784626007,
-0.7756697535514832,
-0.10046301782131195,
0.15021736919879913,
0.07541205734014511,
-0.06353514641523361,
-0.2660716474056244,
0.47464776039123535,
-0.3661975562572479,
0.09916797280311584,
-0.5262095928192139,
-0.2665462791919708,
-0.45109066367149353,
0.5067803263664246,
-0.7852098345756531,
0.931587278842926,
0.053911659866571426,
-0.9072096347808838,
0.5058175921440125,
-0.9387375712394714,
-0.545129120349884,
0.08310529589653015,
0.05247397720813751,
-0.27762240171432495,
0.08939497917890549,
-0.07759031653404236,
0.7223070859909058,
-0.06820321083068848,
0.37906089425086975,
-0.3190838694572449,
-0.05905548110604286,
0.2592277228832245,
-0.24396753311157227,
0.6692023277282715,
0.244726300239563,
-0.09475159645080566,
0.5436260104179382,
-0.4599558711051941,
-0.300655335187912,
0.06924332678318024,
-0.39591309428215027,
-0.7365039587020874,
0.15938349068164825,
0.19200143218040466,
0.35623759031295776,
0.041156429797410965,
-0.5977116823196411,
-0.2834662199020386,
-0.011432711966335773,
0.35075676441192627,
0.7803516983985901,
-0.27182385325431824,
0.33319374918937683,
-0.6188734173774719,
0.3623638451099396,
0.019868776202201843,
0.1841023713350296,
0.1363259255886078,
-0.4172443449497223,
-0.4333003759384155,
-0.2722160816192627,
-0.07611563801765442,
0.5799416899681091,
-1.0109233856201172,
0.2343175709247589,
-0.07347870618104935,
-0.6888988018035889,
-0.3859095275402069,
0.44726133346557617,
0.6856023669242859,
0.24843937158584595,
0.4597407281398773,
-0.28155216574668884,
-0.5912743806838989,
-0.796848475933075,
-0.7423555254936218,
-0.1549970507621765,
0.13048700988292694,
0.33757245540618896,
0.7076387405395508,
-0.09823478758335114,
0.5806185603141785,
-0.20614120364189148,
-0.2295847237110138,
-0.3597325086593628,
0.599006712436676,
-0.4802930951118469,
0.3482542932033539,
0.3257249593734741,
-0.9232126474380493,
-0.2767146825790405,
-0.14382398128509521,
-0.9615920186042786,
0.11819688230752945,
0.0841936469078064,
-0.2958935499191284,
-0.2788890302181244,
0.16879385709762573,
-0.20380590856075287,
0.35321369767189026,
0.31287887692451477,
-0.40918660163879395,
0.5872222781181335,
0.3470941185951233,
0.6876463294029236,
-0.9050602912902832,
0.1755329668521881,
0.531108558177948,
-0.34785932302474976,
-0.9583328366279602,
0.06601446866989136,
0.05084557831287384,
-0.02260724827647209,
-0.5814846754074097,
0.28571295738220215,
-0.24190054833889008,
0.3115876615047455,
-0.3620389699935913,
-0.2392776757478714,
0.002986556850373745,
0.4208182990550995,
-0.1324227899312973,
0.44421279430389404,
0.052764005959033966,
-0.6020222306251526,
0.22528941929340363,
0.16946136951446533,
0.08797384053468704,
0.8044218420982361,
-0.1441756933927536,
0.3488280773162842,
-0.5948387980461121,
0.19491401314735413,
-0.9568885564804077,
-0.3681621849536896,
0.5928478240966797,
-0.258907288312912,
-0.07357306778430939,
-0.39084240794181824,
-0.2907184362411499,
-0.3619130551815033,
-0.49750301241874695,
0.4364728033542633,
-0.348971962928772,
-0.19273628294467926,
1.1165584325790405,
0.5053370594978333,
-0.10512006282806396,
-0.8222273588180542,
-0.327886700630188,
-0.3350276052951813,
-0.27461880445480347,
-0.20693059265613556,
0.17942216992378235,
0.016194481402635574,
-0.32493120431900024,
-0.15594635903835297,
0.10676483809947968,
-0.27787214517593384,
0.2824184000492096,
0.4960983395576477,
0.25170740485191345,
0.21442773938179016,
0.47418680787086487,
0.0732201486825943,
0.11563514918088913,
-0.03998486325144768,
-0.0009474686812609434,
0.6192635297775269,
0.21021170914173126,
-0.09796901047229767,
-0.569892406463623,
0.8277900218963623,
0.4388062655925751,
-0.4168844521045685,
0.8108531832695007,
0.9958575367927551,
-0.6307386755943298,
-0.11574621498584747,
-0.638864278793335,
-0.3012547492980957,
-0.358918160200119,
0.4849814474582672,
-0.3822876513004303,
-0.8172546029090881,
0.25871169567108154,
0.008261125534772873,
0.32177215814590454,
0.3651741147041321,
0.499935507774353,
-0.08216951042413712,
0.7857265472412109,
0.994098961353302,
-0.005019317381083965,
0.5588945150375366,
0.17081710696220398,
0.15425783395767212,
-0.6435908675193787,
-0.22135911881923676,
-0.5104337930679321,
-0.367602676153183,
-0.5188865661621094,
-0.12560759484767914,
0.12103059887886047,
-0.04931061714887619,
-0.39660921692848206,
0.06777923554182053,
-0.5435923933982849,
0.11107107251882553,
0.6233330368995667,
0.5138826370239258,
0.18211005628108978,
-0.2736806273460388,
0.18541692197322845,
-0.34312328696250916,
-0.08998362720012665,
-0.585127592086792,
1.2637832164764404,
0.3979087471961975,
0.5510121583938599,
0.4991225302219391,
0.4366539418697357,
0.54960036277771,
0.7675729393959045,
-0.6548579931259155,
0.14909490942955017,
-0.3249158263206482,
-1.083421230316162,
0.054372821003198624,
-0.35002246499061584,
-0.456998735666275,
0.27298858761787415,
-0.23187504708766937,
-0.831139087677002,
0.05333295091986656,
0.11665234714746475,
-0.39659398794174194,
0.2624962627887726,
-0.8126575946807861,
1.0879768133163452,
-0.0576237253844738,
-0.43461325764656067,
-0.25787732005119324,
-0.561972439289093,
0.6136009097099304,
0.0624425932765007,
0.6538040637969971,
-0.233348086476326,
-0.03107132762670517,
1.0133689641952515,
0.04066111519932747,
1.2784082889556885,
-0.2602725327014923,
0.020880598574876785,
-0.07638100534677505,
0.2584013044834137,
0.1649823635816574,
-0.01815320923924446,
-0.013457021676003933,
0.2517651617527008,
-0.08583012223243713,
-0.18261656165122986,
0.12084995210170746,
0.5957300662994385,
-0.912444531917572,
-0.4008011221885681,
-0.28200843930244446,
-0.5049709677696228,
-0.20472611486911774,
0.2529056966304779,
-0.07552368938922882,
0.16552405059337616,
0.061179835349321365,
0.18197551369667053,
0.18723814189434052,
-0.11044562608003616,
0.40960294008255005,
0.0747184157371521,
-0.15873098373413086,
-0.20365390181541443,
1.0938644409179688,
-0.025001969188451767,
0.05883491784334183,
0.19850581884384155,
0.3711945414543152,
-0.15114815533161163,
-0.1197323128581047,
-0.5564789175987244,
0.025396231561899185,
-0.7720577716827393,
-0.07789047062397003,
-1.0017554759979248,
-0.0895761102437973,
-0.4431002140045166,
0.17083467543125153,
-0.49892866611480713,
0.325685977935791,
-0.4440159201622009,
-0.07905027270317078,
0.3266952335834503,
0.8773153424263,
0.11732906848192215,
0.25456634163856506,
-0.6542492508888245,
0.48097458481788635,
0.5177603363990784,
0.20004408061504364,
0.19804444909095764,
-0.3340851366519928,
-0.03723139315843582,
-0.13010220229625702,
-0.7840824723243713,
-1.4390841722488403,
0.299618661403656,
0.12231417745351791,
0.4938967823982239,
0.5703539252281189,
-0.15808917582035065,
0.5761741995811462,
-0.14672987163066864,
0.6804163455963135,
0.12304007261991501,
-1.0886635780334473,
0.6114711165428162,
-0.35410934686660767,
-0.14172013103961945,
0.6347148418426514,
0.8467977643013,
-0.7754397988319397,
-0.28913477063179016,
-0.4498366415500641,
-0.5654531717300415,
0.5533453226089478,
0.29489660263061523,
0.31523755192756653,
0.18086504936218262,
0.38453409075737,
0.7145061492919922,
0.8998109698295593,
-1.132736325263977,
-0.5556607842445374,
-0.6878131628036499,
-0.4198683798313141,
0.27815771102905273,
-0.22520147264003754,
-0.11876252293586731,
-0.14247526228427887,
0.6814138293266296,
-0.2581125795841217,
0.17584294080734253,
-0.18883492052555084,
-0.3399134576320648,
-0.11318574100732803,
0.38881316781044006,
0.49450206756591797,
0.8290719389915466,
-0.0037561061326414347,
0.14401568472385406,
-0.07515320926904678,
-0.45023828744888306,
-0.0004260671848896891,
0.16114625334739685,
-0.12774601578712463,
-0.1304507553577423,
0.5086753368377686,
0.6130809187889099,
0.14384140074253082,
-0.4271121323108673,
0.5832712054252625,
-0.09824986755847931,
-0.010161066427826881,
-0.11409984529018402,
-0.16502010822296143,
0.061736978590488434,
0.20840609073638916,
0.6162272691726685,
0.22560201585292816,
0.2659018933773041,
-0.7799707055091858,
0.044259000569581985,
0.4464641809463501,
-0.7431550025939941,
-0.22533820569515228,
0.5700308084487915,
0.37924396991729736,
-0.20713694393634796,
0.09934299439191818,
-0.557851254940033,
-0.7923891544342041,
0.361525297164917,
0.10215391963720322,
0.6869404315948486,
-0.5563244819641113,
0.3209625780582428,
0.39708009362220764,
0.28181904554367065,
-0.0018391333287581801,
0.34538763761520386,
-0.0921921581029892,
-0.884085476398468,
-0.32350829243659973,
-0.5889202952384949,
-0.045675210654735565,
0.3394653797149658,
-0.44125330448150635,
0.2876715660095215,
-0.6207483410835266,
-0.11006025224924088,
0.4499052166938782,
-0.08745525032281876,
-0.8484799861907959,
0.139682337641716,
0.15300428867340088,
-0.13783195614814758,
-1.3277455568313599,
0.30568355321884155,
0.7868682146072388,
-0.4956405460834503,
-0.8025640845298767,
0.23635126650333405,
0.5091804265975952,
-0.39133310317993164,
0.7383163571357727,
0.5202880501747131,
0.048119835555553436,
-0.13388603925704956,
-0.42705413699150085,
-0.4835120439529419,
0.7948316931724548,
0.04172350838780403,
-0.40647009015083313,
-0.10422336310148239,
-0.2898070812225342,
0.23892256617546082,
-0.5692428350448608,
0.7546847462654114,
0.19706356525421143,
0.426697701215744,
-0.30339929461479187,
-1.1958270072937012,
0.11854971200227737,
-0.19874882698059082,
0.009530065581202507,
0.11303483694791794,
-0.36753106117248535,
1.2155615091323853,
-0.015856165438890457,
-0.28910040855407715,
-0.2202463001012802,
0.49670079350471497,
0.16670837998390198,
0.2068619430065155,
0.8745569586753845,
0.20391497015953064,
0.5974100828170776,
0.10073430091142654,
0.5830785632133484,
0.15556316077709198,
0.5189106464385986,
0.9338520169258118,
-0.08513645827770233,
0.5443782806396484,
0.41860681772232056,
-0.036064401268959045,
0.6259207129478455,
0.38936108350753784,
0.11820501834154129,
0.431639164686203,
0.0785379558801651,
-0.14831802248954773,
-0.5690823793411255,
-0.5187355875968933,
0.0008013829356059432,
0.6217012405395508,
0.2699003219604492,
-0.471784770488739,
-0.43233367800712585,
0.6456674337387085,
0.1433044672012329,
0.2219938486814499,
-0.19438306987285614,
0.8294289112091064,
-0.19851385056972504,
-0.3826248347759247,
-0.0966833233833313,
0.34769442677497864,
1.1408838033676147,
-0.2659023106098175,
-0.3209380805492401,
0.506659746170044,
-0.05428446829319,
-0.3347688913345337,
-0.38630619645118713,
0.3056468963623047,
-0.027596190571784973,
-0.39096033573150635,
-0.31701788306236267,
0.9608659744262695,
-0.3708699643611908,
-0.749615490436554,
0.39848530292510986,
0.8695334196090698,
-0.13469356298446655,
-0.526175856590271,
-0.7759380340576172,
0.06687656044960022,
-0.03631379455327988,
0.17564769089221954,
-0.09534501284360886,
0.23415155708789825,
-0.08741986751556396,
0.6811929941177368,
0.8025544881820679,
-0.2688847780227661,
-0.03294475004076958,
-0.028439035639166832,
0.6144304275512695,
-0.5585283637046814,
-0.6230723857879639,
-0.9433719515800476,
0.5073408484458923,
-0.1438777893781662,
-0.5869103074073792,
0.7208307981491089,
0.47498857975006104,
0.9906384348869324,
-0.19698157906532288,
0.8668035268783569,
-0.31047502160072327,
1.0253087282180786,
-0.03791976347565651,
0.7166367173194885,
-0.6540802717208862,
0.032983116805553436,
-0.42449671030044556,
-0.3923206031322479,
0.05662214756011963,
0.6177550554275513,
-0.34139761328697205,
0.4157067835330963,
0.7156486511230469,
0.4571085274219513,
-0.1620696783065796,
0.42875388264656067,
0.14812631905078888,
0.1918628066778183,
0.3326379954814911,
0.23519274592399597,
0.9751777052879333,
-0.36133062839508057,
0.331921249628067,
-0.7208150625228882,
-0.21409930288791656,
-0.3424171209335327,
-0.6546387076377869,
-1.2126028537750244,
-0.8298120498657227,
-0.34670671820640564,
-0.32904911041259766,
0.1104392409324646,
1.223168969154358,
0.8666384220123291,
-0.6231462359428406,
-0.0033179456368088722,
0.18480870127677917,
0.3196083605289459,
-0.5144346356391907,
-0.30790212750434875,
-0.06783174723386765,
-0.24926823377609253,
-0.664373517036438,
0.04188506305217743,
0.016514234244823456,
-0.7537623047828674,
-0.44384220242500305,
0.20854948461055756,
-0.5947230458259583,
-0.19018639624118805,
0.7928833961486816,
-0.1887858361005783,
-0.9123310446739197,
-0.5459578037261963,
-0.07763192802667618,
-0.015159967355430126,
0.03339991346001625,
1.0369645357131958,
-0.4208136200904846,
0.31690874695777893,
0.1480773240327835,
0.37738704681396484,
0.025849778205156326,
0.16197799146175385,
0.21658405661582947,
-0.8496938943862915,
-0.13572998344898224,
0.44432374835014343,
0.12370365113019943,
0.3777522146701813,
-0.5726064443588257,
0.0009403246804140508,
0.6053938865661621,
-0.08082012087106705,
-0.5384138226509094,
0.14251787960529327,
-0.6892315745353699,
-0.482877254486084,
1.1133276224136353,
-0.1702452450990677,
-0.23935452103614807,
-0.7591293454170227,
-0.19240987300872803,
0.43551596999168396,
-0.7471809387207031,
0.8591214418411255,
0.9958497881889343,
0.036059606820344925,
-0.29579126834869385,
-1.1207773685455322,
0.5259019732475281,
0.1451295018196106,
-0.9940915703773499,
0.07084831595420837,
0.37558385729789734,
0.6628124117851257,
0.5096164345741272,
0.4174730181694031,
0.15709266066551208,
0.2577558159828186,
-0.4389275908470154,
0.09126676619052887,
0.019216042011976242,
-0.6074685454368591,
0.07671639323234558,
0.5159718990325928,
-0.3774210214614868,
-0.2803078889846802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17803v1 | Understanding the Role of User Profile in the Personalization of Large Language Models | 2024-06-22T14:32:35 | 2024-06-22T14:32:35 | Bin Wu, Zhengyan Shi, Hossein A. Rahmani, Varsha Ramineni, Emine Yilmaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Utilizing user profiles to personalize Large Language Models (LLMs) has been
shown to enhance the performance on a wide range of tasks. However, the precise
role of user profiles and their effect mechanism on LLMs remains unclear. This
study first confirms that the effectiveness of user profiles is primarily due
to personalization information rather than semantic information. Furthermore,
we investigate how user profiles affect the personalization of LLMs. Within the
user profile, we reveal that it is the historical personalized response
produced or approved by users that plays a pivotal role in personalizing LLMs.
This discovery unlocks the potential of LLMs to incorporate a greater number of
user profiles within the constraints of limited input length. As for the
position of user profiles, we observe that user profiles integrated into
different positions of the input context do not contribute equally to
personalization. Instead, where the user profile that is closer to the
beginning affects more on the personalization of LLMs. Our findings reveal the
role of user profiles for the personalization of LLMs, and showcase how
incorporating user profiles impacts performance providing insight to leverage
user profiles effectively. | [
-0.552731990814209,
-0.6239211559295654,
0.8609510660171509,
0.20026186108589172,
0.28521469235420227,
0.2502838969230652,
-0.28255119919776917,
-0.5119259357452393,
0.26190218329429626,
0.8796794414520264,
-0.3731847107410431,
-0.5067816376686096,
-0.39456695318222046,
0.06734540313482285,
-0.32331395149230957,
0.8986819386482239,
0.2294733077287674,
-0.12766851484775543,
-0.32148730754852295,
0.18648725748062134,
-0.6320605278015137,
-0.7762153744697571,
-0.7795754075050354,
-0.49216923117637634,
1.0282927751541138,
0.36629393696784973,
0.5452231764793396,
0.7399240732192993,
0.35938194394111633,
0.3981628119945526,
-0.36394965648651123,
-0.21949808299541473,
-0.7195652723312378,
0.5603016018867493,
-0.19078023731708527,
-0.5008289217948914,
-0.3071680963039398,
-0.11215676367282867,
0.7794062495231628,
0.778560996055603,
0.027352340519428253,
0.30795416235923767,
0.16428354382514954,
0.5128087401390076,
-0.4835282266139984,
0.06715720891952515,
-0.3115421533584595,
-0.2334282547235489,
-0.6894519329071045,
-0.3654819130897522,
-0.39617598056793213,
-0.046592675149440765,
0.30707934498786926,
-0.29986336827278137,
0.08791680634021759,
0.11930284649133682,
0.39612749218940735,
-0.3209558427333832,
-0.7387677431106567,
-0.19145475327968597,
-1.1905789375305176,
0.6258864402770996,
-0.7672412395477295,
0.11619339138269424,
0.17560097575187683,
0.5210132598876953,
-0.44084638357162476,
-0.4905877411365509,
-0.2690283954143524,
-0.07095001637935638,
-0.3077034652233124,
-0.2672276794910431,
0.1440076380968094,
0.1565568447113037,
0.5719432830810547,
0.26472923159599304,
-0.3596142828464508,
0.6422135829925537,
-0.5115283727645874,
-0.35975658893585205,
0.6300932765007019,
0.5834264755249023,
0.2534615397453308,
0.056840814650058746,
-0.10009009391069412,
0.024273058399558067,
-0.836134672164917,
0.4716349244117737,
0.7254966497421265,
0.3887636065483093,
-0.005594168324023485,
0.7082479596138,
-0.41846176981925964,
0.6874539852142334,
-0.20145098865032196,
-0.4456946551799774,
0.14939425885677338,
-0.19103898108005524,
0.07265576720237732,
-0.018563224002718925,
0.8528156280517578,
0.10373596101999283,
0.5793514847755432,
-0.08866193145513535,
-0.3499380946159363,
-0.5493342280387878,
0.04194286838173866,
-1.0455667972564697,
0.2287372201681137,
0.10049346089363098,
-0.40112125873565674,
-0.18651385605335236,
0.3588913083076477,
-0.5186806917190552,
-0.6325121521949768,
-0.378656268119812,
0.006150586064904928,
0.02005876787006855,
0.13042688369750977,
0.054418038576841354,
0.05511216074228287,
-0.15616802871227264,
0.5084752440452576,
-1.2158457040786743,
0.5552455186843872,
0.7011349201202393,
0.6807681918144226,
-0.3338898718357086,
-0.34599319100379944,
-0.5400381684303284,
0.4240003526210785,
-0.022087737917900085,
0.5601434707641602,
-0.8258894085884094,
-0.5070682764053345,
0.3591282069683075,
-0.0716572180390358,
0.0732773020863533,
-0.6218628287315369,
0.11720336973667145,
-0.8952088952064514,
0.22110311686992645,
-0.5923112034797668,
-0.6711764931678772,
-0.16994121670722961,
-0.2116256058216095,
-0.5363858342170715,
0.8742234706878662,
0.03254903852939606,
-0.4259483814239502,
0.3060750365257263,
-0.8282549381256104,
-0.46607714891433716,
0.3955846428871155,
-0.08110816776752472,
-0.15501908957958221,
0.45613744854927063,
-0.18950365483760834,
0.8976418375968933,
-0.05351024493575096,
0.05543288215994835,
-0.586528480052948,
-0.5865577459335327,
0.5713989734649658,
0.14716407656669617,
0.5975900292396545,
0.05930293723940849,
0.0980430468916893,
0.2360583245754242,
-0.6219769716262817,
-0.3465050458908081,
0.20896634459495544,
-0.8280447125434875,
-0.2632162272930145,
0.07341296225786209,
0.4526239335536957,
0.29561153054237366,
0.4534716308116913,
-0.5544015169143677,
0.11118689179420471,
-0.49660924077033997,
0.3615674078464508,
0.8784632086753845,
0.1087522879242897,
0.3223680257797241,
-0.16810715198516846,
0.7383158802986145,
-0.13230827450752258,
-0.23294669389724731,
-0.4014480710029602,
-0.5038871765136719,
-0.34569576382637024,
-0.2145378142595291,
0.27293238043785095,
0.5313944220542908,
0.13874876499176025,
0.6469928026199341,
-0.01619839109480381,
-0.26964902877807617,
-0.09988543391227722,
0.7649636268615723,
0.24497534334659576,
0.474886029958725,
-0.12756013870239258,
-0.619687020778656,
-0.5741574764251709,
-1.1439476013183594,
-0.31132474541664124,
-0.12003520131111145,
-0.290751188993454,
0.6444015502929688,
0.4777654707431793,
-0.301596999168396,
0.9789788126945496,
-0.7546138167381287,
-0.4522320032119751,
-0.4139365255832672,
-0.332940936088562,
0.19980929791927338,
0.09764296561479568,
0.6248072981834412,
-0.5821717381477356,
-0.6705730557441711,
-0.015156219713389874,
-0.36091724038124084,
-0.4435022473335266,
-0.23459045588970184,
-0.12203873693943024,
-0.11624663323163986,
0.34127911925315857,
-0.448080450296402,
0.24089795351028442,
0.5536869168281555,
-0.4515897035598755,
0.37103527784347534,
-0.3740636706352234,
-0.07443002611398697,
-1.0707231760025024,
0.10973971337080002,
0.35359686613082886,
-0.5486268997192383,
-0.7893350720405579,
-0.14112088084220886,
-0.2296612709760666,
0.03929760307073593,
-0.33908510208129883,
0.6891133189201355,
-0.23212556540966034,
-0.40910059213638306,
-0.2558521032333374,
0.2938160002231598,
-0.11097072064876556,
0.22051917016506195,
-0.3847615420818329,
0.9093249440193176,
0.36461305618286133,
-0.45250487327575684,
0.10750099271535873,
0.35691189765930176,
-0.5204979181289673,
0.3248427212238312,
-0.7910452485084534,
0.2411119043827057,
-0.07308817654848099,
0.13211297988891602,
-1.2578498125076294,
-0.38238051533699036,
-0.03273160010576248,
-0.16207054257392883,
0.33042076230049133,
0.1764669120311737,
-0.7466586828231812,
-0.03414135053753853,
-0.42395907640457153,
-0.027540186420083046,
0.44622737169265747,
-0.27101248502731323,
0.5512643456459045,
0.5569753646850586,
-0.09584914892911911,
-0.03249918669462204,
-0.5039135813713074,
0.2809087336063385,
-0.5792457461357117,
-0.7956518530845642,
0.518928050994873,
-0.2577590346336365,
-0.25805842876434326,
-0.4521583616733551,
0.14693476259708405,
0.25033634901046753,
0.6000399589538574,
0.41536372900009155,
0.15196733176708221,
-0.15278907120227814,
0.18009817600250244,
-0.2515694200992584,
-0.003912479616701603,
-0.024703480303287506,
0.20114530622959137,
0.8061530590057373,
0.1342509239912033,
0.0474536307156086,
-0.8096476793289185,
0.3079569637775421,
0.4619326591491699,
-0.2263457477092743,
1.1581699848175049,
0.4389790892601013,
-0.03458902984857559,
-0.09126461297273636,
-0.8141965866088867,
-0.25847190618515015,
-0.5426317453384399,
0.4397960603237152,
-0.40049758553504944,
-1.420042634010315,
0.9123445749282837,
-0.04330796003341675,
0.011418934911489487,
0.2973318099975586,
0.9311017394065857,
-0.5035884976387024,
1.223146677017212,
0.8538450598716736,
-0.19639122486114502,
0.7996317744255066,
0.19346210360527039,
0.06807496398687363,
-1.1539819240570068,
-0.41734230518341064,
-0.45753395557403564,
-0.6004377603530884,
-0.7141421437263489,
0.2309570461511612,
0.13414590060710907,
-0.05638064071536064,
-0.3519176244735718,
0.15982495248317719,
-0.06545525789260864,
0.2991132140159607,
0.36130890250205994,
-0.013262435793876648,
0.24257385730743408,
0.06301720440387726,
0.3162558674812317,
-0.2135203778743744,
-0.1652824729681015,
-0.784670889377594,
0.9260377883911133,
0.5880886316299438,
0.9297348260879517,
0.32991325855255127,
0.7996650338172913,
0.3759761452674866,
-0.10888434201478958,
-0.6234700083732605,
0.739695131778717,
-0.20485882461071014,
-0.5927802920341492,
-0.2979203760623932,
-0.21966801583766937,
-0.9718477725982666,
0.17074397206306458,
-0.19896695017814636,
-1.187132477760315,
-0.08138788491487503,
0.40534090995788574,
-0.45322760939598083,
-0.16195055842399597,
-0.8019949793815613,
0.7273959517478943,
-0.24464958906173706,
-0.34255459904670715,
-0.13452330231666565,
-0.5335622429847717,
0.10298921912908554,
-0.2692471146583557,
0.021423345431685448,
-0.07297305017709732,
-0.31500691175460815,
0.9266002774238586,
-0.2438972443342209,
1.162521243095398,
-0.1808636635541916,
0.1113879606127739,
-0.24224722385406494,
0.08910181373357773,
0.5401120781898499,
0.00864356104284525,
0.005873015616089106,
-0.07498177886009216,
-0.02582547813653946,
-0.06381808966398239,
-0.5775972008705139,
1.1419260501861572,
-0.7005994915962219,
-1.2852277755737305,
0.02569771371781826,
-0.4959416687488556,
-0.35273754596710205,
0.3579978942871094,
-0.14994782209396362,
0.15580350160598755,
-0.23052537441253662,
0.5839129090309143,
0.5988422632217407,
-0.1624474823474884,
0.26895076036453247,
0.38937631249427795,
-0.4700350761413574,
0.017245672643184662,
0.5922090411186218,
0.09684499353170395,
0.19498862326145172,
0.34052523970603943,
0.6007564067840576,
-0.21541117131710052,
-0.6314595937728882,
-0.17684617638587952,
0.6749166250228882,
-0.8372998237609863,
0.23471666872501373,
-0.6679136753082275,
0.1459677368402481,
-0.4696115255355835,
-0.07499100267887115,
0.017247363924980164,
-0.17251652479171753,
-0.4892035126686096,
0.04242309182882309,
0.13127900660037994,
0.9143633842468262,
0.6454572081565857,
0.8725122809410095,
-0.4867427945137024,
0.00901556946337223,
0.23736904561519623,
0.25000160932540894,
-0.03142872080206871,
-0.622325599193573,
-0.3423416018486023,
-0.38399946689605713,
-0.20584189891815186,
-0.7650904059410095,
0.07046018540859222,
0.26748380064964294,
0.7529743313789368,
0.6476492285728455,
-0.674704909324646,
0.6037289500236511,
-0.5403479933738708,
0.6612271070480347,
-0.1788351982831955,
-0.8604415059089661,
0.3252491354942322,
-0.24368980526924133,
0.5100056529045105,
0.5868965983390808,
0.2856309413909912,
-0.8976489305496216,
-0.1938382387161255,
-0.0046670385636389256,
-0.611468493938446,
0.9366862773895264,
-0.0404839962720871,
0.6981838941574097,
0.45500648021698,
0.6362009644508362,
0.012075494043529034,
0.19727948307991028,
-0.4848770201206207,
-0.35612818598747253,
0.5038803815841675,
0.08964516967535019,
-0.3605020344257355,
-0.7560038566589355,
0.05332634970545769,
-0.031522005796432495,
0.3995131552219391,
0.03700139746069908,
-0.2811625599861145,
-0.3559759557247162,
0.18739217519760132,
-0.023868579417467117,
0.14912278950214386,
0.7596162557601929,
0.8281757235527039,
-0.16704069077968597,
-0.19292674958705902,
0.09822054952383041,
-0.16597320139408112,
-0.2674046456813812,
-0.27477771043777466,
-0.25742968916893005,
-0.30948585271835327,
0.4770653545856476,
0.9108831286430359,
0.3245496153831482,
-0.638943076133728,
0.3695873022079468,
-0.04035311937332153,
0.17589370906352997,
-0.4399416744709015,
0.4705580174922943,
0.47312283515930176,
0.3416914939880371,
0.07723944634199142,
-0.19597554206848145,
0.22836528718471527,
-0.6246716976165771,
-0.21007989346981049,
0.5098877549171448,
-0.09351422637701035,
-0.6112655997276306,
0.6559353470802307,
-0.042577050626277924,
-0.6310627460479736,
0.4117451310157776,
0.6300151348114014,
-0.35719069838523865,
0.3508989214897156,
0.593944787979126,
0.6623338460922241,
-0.5779308080673218,
0.012633559294044971,
0.08177778124809265,
-0.23860928416252136,
0.01943323388695717,
-0.07626042515039444,
-0.031235234811902046,
-0.6640529036521912,
-0.30919840931892395,
-0.6370561718940735,
-0.17150522768497467,
0.11687944084405899,
-0.45487356185913086,
0.5340101718902588,
-0.5908810496330261,
-0.3282518684864044,
0.3599352538585663,
-0.10605374723672867,
-0.8292055130004883,
0.05000733211636543,
0.32222509384155273,
0.7262401580810547,
-0.7104647755622864,
0.7706571817398071,
0.8113173842430115,
-0.12550389766693115,
-0.41963326930999756,
-0.19388264417648315,
0.2629775106906891,
-0.6922730803489685,
1.0654914379119873,
0.296773761510849,
-0.22131764888763428,
-0.16223828494548798,
-0.21995939314365387,
-0.784903347492218,
1.0883519649505615,
0.36399078369140625,
-0.517702043056488,
-0.1364378184080124,
0.4165821373462677,
0.8735934495925903,
-0.7511629462242126,
0.003339324612170458,
0.5462949275970459,
0.2890564203262329,
0.24043706059455872,
-0.708689272403717,
0.10672317445278168,
0.13478738069534302,
0.6669938564300537,
0.07981705665588379,
-0.5029162764549255,
0.6666326522827148,
-0.07021375000476837,
-0.23508435487747192,
-0.08581343293190002,
0.41079747676849365,
0.07662345468997955,
-0.16108833253383636,
0.4503214657306671,
0.025169292464852333,
0.5077686905860901,
0.2227320820093155,
1.2900105714797974,
-0.24823276698589325,
0.18384777009487152,
0.899761438369751,
-0.5533193945884705,
0.7651564478874207,
0.6500318050384521,
-0.16506706178188324,
0.5262852311134338,
0.6152821779251099,
-0.17615409195423126,
0.32038387656211853,
0.4416755735874176,
-0.26076775789260864,
-0.2821696400642395,
-0.12599888443946838,
-0.025969794020056725,
0.6506215333938599,
0.24405835568904877,
-0.7228915691375732,
-0.04051734879612923,
-0.0227899719029665,
0.29204732179641724,
0.19318728148937225,
0.02787473425269127,
0.792973518371582,
0.003410736098885536,
-0.3852437138557434,
0.04302506893873215,
0.32536542415618896,
0.6007382869720459,
-0.7257787585258484,
0.1077013686299324,
-0.12944982945919037,
0.20043276250362396,
-0.4355103373527527,
-0.9031059741973877,
0.047947537153959274,
-0.1528482884168625,
-0.3446460962295532,
-0.6072166562080383,
0.8088058233261108,
-0.1405440866947174,
-0.2563794255256653,
0.4457523226737976,
0.4893356263637543,
0.06534421443939209,
-0.15660333633422852,
-0.3632432520389557,
0.25228795409202576,
-0.06300979852676392,
-0.8864598870277405,
0.75164395570755,
-0.04087366536259651,
-0.2661770284175873,
0.7317076325416565,
0.6255348920822144,
0.26409080624580383,
-0.2330196350812912,
0.18939435482025146,
0.798781156539917,
-0.7769992351531982,
-0.3008703291416168,
-1.2338138818740845,
0.4611895978450775,
-0.05587771534919739,
-0.4935116171836853,
0.9709197878837585,
0.7190617322921753,
1.0755579471588135,
-0.18962621688842773,
0.6329740285873413,
0.2017434984445572,
0.500472903251648,
-0.36889877915382385,
0.6946623921394348,
-0.5974143147468567,
0.8172464370727539,
-0.11877917498350143,
-1.0485800504684448,
-0.3880990147590637,
0.09459587931632996,
-0.5236691236495972,
0.37648099660873413,
0.08709061145782471,
0.8899109363555908,
0.22639161348342896,
-0.2978922128677368,
0.5816229581832886,
0.1037268117070198,
0.7589613199234009,
0.25530877709388733,
0.6689813733100891,
0.22435033321380615,
0.19986259937286377,
-0.45899835228919983,
-0.12329387664794922,
-0.4348437488079071,
-0.5961100459098816,
-1.30449378490448,
-0.6948366165161133,
-0.1523643285036087,
-0.02054738439619541,
-0.206532284617424,
0.7388477325439453,
0.6660085320472717,
-0.8633260726928711,
-0.7361857891082764,
0.49624159932136536,
-0.08523514866828918,
0.34913864731788635,
-0.24508637189865112,
0.05514862388372421,
-0.06817613542079926,
-0.8783106207847595,
0.3937169313430786,
0.43004894256591797,
0.01038704439997673,
-0.770256757736206,
0.027308225631713867,
0.04603487625718117,
-0.07685991376638412,
0.6849151253700256,
0.28966227173805237,
-0.9635608196258545,
-0.3795763850212097,
0.1053256243467331,
-0.26995009183883667,
0.21944200992584229,
1.1497211456298828,
-0.611269474029541,
0.5660085082054138,
0.648398756980896,
0.5664698481559753,
0.5795961618423462,
0.1333307921886444,
0.7018930315971375,
-0.6872702836990356,
-0.15242189168930054,
-0.11730611324310303,
0.43579161167144775,
0.46172019839286804,
-0.8407338857650757,
0.12866106629371643,
0.04683378338813782,
-0.5891513228416443,
-0.7183812856674194,
0.1513800472021103,
-0.9784978032112122,
-0.03952648118138313,
1.1909252405166626,
-0.0720067173242569,
-0.02769792638719082,
-0.09044436365365982,
-0.4432413578033447,
-0.29808342456817627,
-0.5777332186698914,
0.6881614327430725,
0.9666009545326233,
-0.4388974606990814,
-0.15242108702659607,
-0.9088892340660095,
0.35916435718536377,
0.12176727503538132,
-0.7249676585197449,
0.03263028338551521,
0.4079771041870117,
0.5040059089660645,
0.08582867681980133,
0.4526859521865845,
0.09410078823566437,
-0.1491585522890091,
-0.778678297996521,
-0.20523586869239807,
-0.3106618821620941,
-0.1726398468017578,
-0.5013455152511597,
0.23216411471366882,
0.4359293282032013,
0.25340917706489563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15862v1 | Speech Analysis of Language Varieties in Italy | 2024-06-22T14:19:51 | 2024-06-22T14:19:51 | Moreno La Quatra, Alkis Koudounas, Elena Baralis, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Italy exhibits rich linguistic diversity across its territory due to the
distinct regional languages spoken in different areas. Recent advances in
self-supervised learning provide new opportunities to analyze Italy's
linguistic varieties using speech data alone. This includes the potential to
leverage representations learned from large amounts of data to better examine
nuances between closely related linguistic varieties. In this study, we focus
on automatically identifying the geographic region of origin of speech samples
drawn from Italy's diverse language varieties. We leverage self-supervised
learning models to tackle this task and analyze differences and similarities
between Italy's regional languages. In doing so, we also seek to uncover new
insights into the relationships among these diverse yet closely related
varieties, which may help linguists understand their interconnected evolution
and regional development over time and space. To improve the discriminative
ability of learned representations, we evaluate several supervised contrastive
learning objectives, both as pre-training steps and additional fine-tuning
objectives. Experimental evidence shows that pre-trained self-supervised models
can effectively identify regions from speech recording. Additionally,
incorporating contrastive objectives during fine-tuning improves classification
accuracy and yields embeddings that distinctly separate regional varieties,
demonstrating the value of combining self-supervised pre-training and
contrastive learning for this task. | [
-0.6487296223640442,
-0.4933975040912628,
0.3011052906513214,
0.3050772249698639,
-0.021993115544319153,
-0.07125362753868103,
-0.43407583236694336,
-0.4353634715080261,
0.41972023248672485,
0.5065014362335205,
-0.4491744339466095,
-0.6046838164329529,
-0.48525291681289673,
0.19191715121269226,
-0.2786596119403839,
0.9014856219291687,
0.32430601119995117,
0.4400298297405243,
0.3786018490791321,
-0.35989078879356384,
-0.13794109225273132,
-0.5560277104377747,
-0.7364321351051331,
-0.1606317162513733,
0.40008509159088135,
0.2925323247909546,
-0.00297784642316401,
0.7414108514785767,
0.26873522996902466,
0.42999953031539917,
-0.04265277460217476,
0.31902360916137695,
-0.2604932188987732,
-0.04320721700787544,
-0.23573645949363708,
-0.41903308033943176,
-0.09717129915952682,
0.06649348139762878,
0.6746511459350586,
0.7757123708724976,
-0.1598210334777832,
-0.027392130345106125,
0.1668226271867752,
0.46899333596229553,
-0.5730328559875488,
0.09174640476703644,
-0.7371474504470825,
0.08404889702796936,
-0.5598822236061096,
-0.19983337819576263,
-0.17307518422603607,
-0.1800580471754074,
0.08592631667852402,
-0.24162620306015015,
0.6541087031364441,
-0.3252308666706085,
0.6960942149162292,
0.3972932994365692,
-0.1927567720413208,
-0.442841500043869,
-0.7829659581184387,
0.6562038064002991,
-0.5208082795143127,
0.27347880601882935,
0.2928210198879242,
0.28277266025543213,
-0.2544216513633728,
-0.44557416439056396,
-0.1661742478609085,
-0.22140082716941833,
-0.18020831048488617,
0.07484710961580276,
-0.3440077304840088,
-0.21380113065242767,
-0.05754765495657921,
0.5921984314918518,
-0.5913546681404114,
0.47206321358680725,
-0.4065749943256378,
-0.37343037128448486,
0.7288258075714111,
-0.1395505666732788,
0.5052177309989929,
-0.000770211685448885,
-0.049953557550907135,
0.008677118457853794,
-0.5142014622688293,
-0.06898701936006546,
0.6011121273040771,
0.6156479120254517,
-0.3071630895137787,
0.37012454867362976,
-0.40939101576805115,
0.6164780259132385,
0.09653554856777191,
-0.05142838880419731,
0.45891764760017395,
-0.21194908022880554,
0.12872126698493958,
-0.0036283668596297503,
0.9149133563041687,
-0.1681143045425415,
0.18558436632156372,
-0.11411737650632858,
-0.17334511876106262,
-0.3946584165096283,
-0.24630238115787506,
-0.39581412076950073,
-0.41185054183006287,
-0.21059563755989075,
-0.1619727909564972,
0.17156320810317993,
0.06095350161194801,
-0.8535024523735046,
-0.2988363206386566,
-0.25428903102874756,
0.11221108585596085,
-0.4794612526893616,
-0.2769330143928528,
-0.0064462521113455296,
0.01528953853994608,
0.06585320085287094,
-0.01548562478274107,
-1.0519804954528809,
0.18577413260936737,
0.3843069076538086,
0.68253093957901,
-0.3824634253978729,
-0.36969897150993347,
-0.5211137533187866,
0.011479852721095085,
-0.2089773714542389,
0.8412951827049255,
-0.5385860204696655,
-0.5657633543014526,
-0.04717063531279564,
0.09554312378168106,
-0.1894405335187912,
-0.9265561103820801,
0.19085627794265747,
-0.08477627485990524,
0.3255673348903656,
-0.02999296225607395,
-0.38557544350624084,
-0.3072147071361542,
-0.031177569180727005,
-1.0005314350128174,
0.874016523361206,
0.11287575215101242,
-0.6462780237197876,
0.6555108428001404,
-0.5272688865661621,
-0.40078049898147583,
-0.0013051211135461926,
-0.5671437978744507,
-0.45917195081710815,
0.415330708026886,
0.37831756472587585,
0.3493039906024933,
-0.04591895267367363,
0.3004983365535736,
-0.09836489707231522,
0.03431174159049988,
0.15125985443592072,
-0.5563773512840271,
0.8068409562110901,
0.4238895773887634,
-0.770658552646637,
0.07058297842741013,
-0.9808642864227295,
-0.16692519187927246,
-0.14009952545166016,
0.012523774988949299,
-0.4008948504924774,
0.16027683019638062,
-0.20158369839191437,
0.04560218006372452,
0.3305988311767578,
-0.4000987112522125,
-0.10607597976922989,
-0.4891846776008606,
0.41867920756340027,
0.30431532859802246,
0.06119120866060257,
0.39689695835113525,
0.0869537740945816,
0.5098837018013,
0.45519471168518066,
0.01249078568071127,
-0.009023778140544891,
-0.11334717273712158,
-0.9767928123474121,
-0.6271705031394958,
0.3731749653816223,
0.4523681700229645,
-0.5255600810050964,
0.6192566752433777,
-0.09767290949821472,
-0.6214496493339539,
-0.5827853679656982,
0.10033906996250153,
0.3217388093471527,
0.13416999578475952,
0.3261912763118744,
-0.2668307423591614,
-0.4353941082954407,
-1.2561625242233276,
0.009285292588174343,
0.1021030843257904,
0.11137393862009048,
0.36374911665916443,
0.44863373041152954,
-0.08427795022726059,
1.0665431022644043,
-0.3318377733230591,
-0.3784884512424469,
-0.24744461476802826,
0.42028453946113586,
0.10511046648025513,
0.8118236064910889,
0.8439438939094543,
-0.8441426753997803,
-0.45041772723197937,
0.4317173361778259,
-0.4315639138221741,
-0.230123370885849,
0.07548575848340988,
-0.01695849932730198,
0.011598754674196243,
0.451997846364975,
0.1307791918516159,
0.24381284415721893,
0.7388255000114441,
-0.08276183158159256,
0.30411338806152344,
-0.29525792598724365,
0.2884996235370636,
-1.0096434354782104,
-0.10981940478086472,
0.15651825070381165,
0.06796736270189285,
-0.6583684086799622,
-0.26244056224823,
-0.2664802670478821,
-0.20930728316307068,
-0.39482346177101135,
0.45532843470573425,
-0.5531905293464661,
-0.2976765036582947,
-0.06883671134710312,
-0.04183153808116913,
-0.3371441960334778,
0.2629205882549286,
0.4747004210948944,
1.156580924987793,
0.5607277750968933,
-0.3609248995780945,
-0.07750416547060013,
-0.2552366852760315,
-0.4158422350883484,
0.0673036128282547,
-0.4498504400253296,
0.02421792782843113,
-0.015672771260142326,
-0.3210020959377289,
-0.9032630920410156,
-0.19442714750766754,
0.20036499202251434,
-0.4215232729911804,
0.14894773066043854,
-0.2025899738073349,
-0.18271483480930328,
0.039059173315763474,
0.42703938484191895,
0.47643688321113586,
0.09294581413269043,
-0.46565333008766174,
0.515925407409668,
0.417219340801239,
-0.41510143876075745,
-0.23435832560062408,
-0.7500729560852051,
-0.3869403302669525,
-0.6832281947135925,
-0.25668638944625854,
0.178680881857872,
0.1935240626335144,
-0.3267292082309723,
-0.2303311973810196,
0.15271195769309998,
-0.5966199040412903,
0.2330544888973236,
-0.0455055795609951,
-0.2028253972530365,
-0.2372799664735794,
0.14343012869358063,
0.23330417275428772,
-0.029096204787492752,
-0.2537819743156433,
-0.5021985769271851,
0.8633227348327637,
0.0012157703749835491,
-0.3316660523414612,
-0.6008999347686768,
0.6098726391792297,
0.1758984923362732,
-0.6514261364936829,
0.5085934400558472,
0.5476138591766357,
-0.19929976761341095,
-0.3885329067707062,
-0.6279661655426025,
-0.09627165645360947,
-0.4220634996891022,
0.46952009201049805,
-0.7719448804855347,
-0.9909371137619019,
0.6420179009437561,
-0.04441225156188011,
-0.14114373922348022,
0.6528418660163879,
0.4191829264163971,
-0.20218248665332794,
0.7326304316520691,
0.8008897304534912,
-0.38504496216773987,
0.6732864379882812,
-0.23157069087028503,
-0.11740682274103165,
-0.3425373136997223,
-0.15731820464134216,
-1.0327941179275513,
-0.031623873859643936,
-1.0478423833847046,
-0.33080512285232544,
0.2662773132324219,
0.025503987446427345,
0.05602237954735756,
0.22288057208061218,
-0.47787943482398987,
0.5240374207496643,
0.4140230715274811,
-0.002089854795485735,
0.2109149992465973,
0.4903397858142853,
-0.02851390838623047,
-0.22432273626327515,
-0.5807188749313354,
-0.3765954375267029,
0.6576634645462036,
0.14630985260009766,
0.6316845417022705,
-0.18027164041996002,
1.1763182878494263,
0.33164823055267334,
-0.02613450214266777,
-0.5862602591514587,
0.2232290506362915,
-0.9605397582054138,
-0.4755430221557617,
-0.3285007178783417,
-0.6202859282493591,
-0.8833820819854736,
0.43825849890708923,
-0.028211697936058044,
-0.7280490398406982,
0.6512527465820312,
0.2692895531654358,
-0.2428015023469925,
0.11681508272886276,
-0.7163254022598267,
0.7763974666595459,
-0.4680095911026001,
0.07736063003540039,
-0.1635584533214569,
-0.18159829080104828,
-0.011871656402945518,
-0.12518909573554993,
0.43664565682411194,
-0.14349733293056488,
0.3218633830547333,
0.7876400351524353,
0.2118602693080902,
1.0547938346862793,
-0.06880702823400497,
-0.3119924068450928,
0.19045743346214294,
0.07584523409605026,
-0.19793738424777985,
-0.06729400157928467,
-0.2999033033847809,
0.46616512537002563,
-0.19144801795482635,
-0.43218517303466797,
-0.5683481097221375,
0.6209502220153809,
-0.8940681219100952,
-0.6554960012435913,
-0.15524345636367798,
-0.412970632314682,
-0.10065840929746628,
0.17803698778152466,
0.579959511756897,
0.6214050054550171,
-0.40407806634902954,
0.15354886651039124,
0.5187444090843201,
-0.16044069826602936,
0.4963238537311554,
0.5361543297767639,
-0.029965562745928764,
-0.4862810969352722,
1.0958932638168335,
0.19326621294021606,
0.16449137032032013,
0.1867043375968933,
0.09384559839963913,
-0.2594853341579437,
-0.9568268656730652,
-0.29017725586891174,
0.3289499282836914,
-0.4383656084537506,
0.2371624857187271,
-0.16528406739234924,
-0.19131673872470856,
-0.41223570704460144,
0.20091502368450165,
-0.4426611661911011,
-0.10522370040416718,
-0.5270960330963135,
0.0539117157459259,
-0.15717779099941254,
0.7286227941513062,
-0.28332000970840454,
0.632510781288147,
-0.6036610007286072,
-0.09041281789541245,
0.26132839918136597,
-0.12475322932004929,
-0.5806226134300232,
-0.4728890061378479,
-0.172942653298378,
0.07833327353000641,
-0.04973771423101425,
-0.9177795648574829,
0.5546742081642151,
0.5121999979019165,
0.8441491723060608,
0.5541306138038635,
-0.2694118320941925,
0.7814710736274719,
-0.4667603373527527,
0.8333294987678528,
0.0915868952870369,
-0.9564598798751831,
0.8210186958312988,
-0.1964576542377472,
0.03866211324930191,
0.7380061745643616,
0.6376127600669861,
-0.04759683087468147,
-0.3792087435722351,
-0.43875402212142944,
-0.5744264721870422,
0.560814619064331,
0.17847836017608643,
0.10609132796525955,
-0.13850192725658417,
0.5375984907150269,
0.36784571409225464,
0.04223482310771942,
-0.8110553026199341,
-0.1609439104795456,
-0.048113979399204254,
-0.1727144569158554,
-0.534368097782135,
0.0573076494038105,
-0.3203970193862915,
-0.12436977028846741,
0.3461955189704895,
-0.24983683228492737,
0.038513895124197006,
0.25086742639541626,
-0.2108844518661499,
0.31744685769081116,
0.5501455664634705,
0.5618439316749573,
0.6667037606239319,
0.4011160135269165,
0.16003446280956268,
0.28405657410621643,
-0.15733565390110016,
0.11735612154006958,
0.27519750595092773,
-0.27495986223220825,
0.19467836618423462,
0.454935222864151,
1.0352238416671753,
0.035644836723804474,
-0.4096923768520355,
0.15328305959701538,
0.07234024256467819,
-0.07497955858707428,
-0.4810166358947754,
0.29929399490356445,
-0.14973780512809753,
0.45287275314331055,
0.29718661308288574,
-0.20042569935321808,
0.6601884961128235,
-0.7239536046981812,
0.22575856745243073,
0.3364294469356537,
-0.4979977607727051,
-0.2328573316335678,
0.09319069236516953,
0.2593017816543579,
-0.2263989895582199,
0.6033386588096619,
-0.18223610520362854,
-0.6087323427200317,
0.807906985282898,
0.5309028625488281,
0.809132993221283,
-0.4025569260120392,
0.41887277364730835,
0.32210636138916016,
0.02449619770050049,
0.4240747094154358,
0.044840257614851,
-0.32148122787475586,
-0.7824273109436035,
-0.28407183289527893,
-0.7683404088020325,
-0.02403395250439644,
0.020776284858584404,
-1.005029559135437,
0.10376235842704773,
-0.09886486083269119,
-0.17840564250946045,
0.10277911275625229,
-0.005082630552351475,
-0.4252743721008301,
0.5255495309829712,
0.2934819459915161,
0.6405452489852905,
-1.2866711616516113,
0.8950162529945374,
0.672617495059967,
-0.14942114055156708,
-0.8318856954574585,
0.05763106420636177,
-0.17505186796188354,
-0.7323505282402039,
1.1325631141662598,
0.20357398688793182,
-0.5598090887069702,
0.1094486340880394,
-0.42403069138526917,
-0.6869896650314331,
0.6097440719604492,
0.32622265815734863,
-0.9427362680435181,
0.09020254760980606,
0.28337594866752625,
0.6130806803703308,
-0.6340475082397461,
0.23297664523124695,
0.9389927983283997,
0.1263866275548935,
0.08197131007909775,
-0.8908664584159851,
-0.6468170285224915,
-0.1003677248954773,
0.005556208081543446,
0.22214654088020325,
-0.48771539330482483,
0.7172331213951111,
0.13469122350215912,
-0.3369789123535156,
0.09249404817819595,
0.8779231905937195,
0.17018866539001465,
0.14101561903953552,
0.5818138718605042,
0.31848999857902527,
0.6757655143737793,
-0.5095322132110596,
0.44886723160743713,
-0.27772536873817444,
0.3479592502117157,
1.331519603729248,
-0.06398465484380722,
0.7509440183639526,
0.3636493682861328,
-0.08540939539670944,
0.5843205451965332,
0.7718656063079834,
-0.19598285853862762,
0.4453749358654022,
0.14424839615821838,
-0.41845476627349854,
-0.40083175897598267,
-0.25368064641952515,
-0.4042767584323883,
1.05986487865448,
0.5367098450660706,
-0.26923248171806335,
-0.31082096695899963,
0.24856619536876678,
-0.13471108675003052,
0.2570222020149231,
-0.3365561366081238,
0.9454809427261353,
-0.31246960163116455,
-0.645659863948822,
0.1730683445930481,
-0.43128788471221924,
0.5184680223464966,
-0.6213765740394592,
0.036890942603349686,
-0.45677170157432556,
-0.114543117582798,
-0.2987113296985626,
-0.5521506667137146,
0.20916101336479187,
0.06799831241369247,
-0.16823306679725647,
0.17929592728614807,
0.05632077157497406,
-0.7512314319610596,
-0.3433384895324707,
0.5473376512527466,
0.33804580569267273,
0.4449858069419861,
0.2047046720981598,
-0.6649696826934814,
0.05093226581811905,
0.4129694700241089,
0.1499636173248291,
0.06267126649618149,
0.5524086952209473,
-0.1026081070303917,
0.4722224473953247,
0.3417400121688843,
0.48566725850105286,
0.3132860064506531,
0.31413379311561584,
0.6269773840904236,
-0.542320191860199,
-0.6070321202278137,
-0.7903167605400085,
0.5196552872657776,
-0.24446606636047363,
-0.35951048135757446,
0.5760931372642517,
0.566346287727356,
0.9841665029525757,
-0.17051056027412415,
0.6207743287086487,
-0.12746432423591614,
0.5601009130477905,
-0.790260910987854,
0.5678299069404602,
-0.7984492778778076,
-0.020206527784466743,
0.142527237534523,
-1.0094084739685059,
-0.14977145195007324,
0.701575517654419,
-0.6061820983886719,
0.0807640329003334,
0.521448016166687,
0.7536847591400146,
0.0036877428647130728,
-0.16194000840187073,
0.3966656029224396,
0.20121167600154877,
0.1821901798248291,
0.07506922632455826,
0.8097594380378723,
0.1686013638973236,
0.33399951457977295,
-0.549220085144043,
-0.2715383470058441,
0.2982608377933502,
-0.6082820892333984,
-0.7056379318237305,
-0.7328934669494629,
-0.3357560336589813,
0.22137929499149323,
0.16521421074867249,
0.6729527711868286,
1.0128493309020996,
-1.358890175819397,
-0.4825243353843689,
0.02424168400466442,
-0.3677229583263397,
0.08808306604623795,
-0.1971125453710556,
0.3005545735359192,
-0.5814437866210938,
-1.1892333030700684,
0.7405555248260498,
0.24291470646858215,
0.20859387516975403,
-0.378283828496933,
0.20245113968849182,
0.09146001935005188,
-0.3602236807346344,
0.20983992516994476,
0.5581504702568054,
-0.8405511975288391,
-0.21495957672595978,
-0.317413866519928,
0.04578208178281784,
0.1720493584871292,
0.9924218058586121,
-0.3203980624675751,
0.6510815620422363,
0.32334938645362854,
0.5212535262107849,
0.5977542996406555,
0.048646554350852966,
0.5541657209396362,
-0.6325189471244812,
0.48583969473838806,
0.24921073019504547,
0.5418053865432739,
0.36305341124534607,
-0.2880316972732544,
0.3183668255805969,
0.00831600371748209,
-0.4617503583431244,
-0.25463172793388367,
0.3531344532966614,
-0.7730857729911804,
-0.13939347863197327,
0.7857313752174377,
-0.5986678004264832,
0.029564067721366882,
0.003977804910391569,
-0.2522699236869812,
0.31208378076553345,
-0.2025272399187088,
0.7889376878738403,
0.6601608395576477,
-0.28496789932250977,
-0.31780165433883667,
-0.23609083890914917,
0.5726816654205322,
0.4301753044128418,
-0.9875847101211548,
-0.2677578926086426,
0.6854652166366577,
0.5397772192955017,
0.41326192021369934,
0.3374631702899933,
-0.23404063284397125,
0.1658666878938675,
-0.22705014050006866,
-0.04613649100065231,
0.4838966429233551,
-0.6350479125976562,
-0.768341064453125,
0.28229936957359314,
0.07099434733390808,
-0.37991705536842346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15846v1 | Revisiting Interpolation Augmentation for Speech-to-Text Generation | 2024-06-22T13:24:58 | 2024-06-22T13:24:58 | Chen Xu, Jie Wang, Xiaoqian Liu, Qianqian Dong, Chunliang Zhang, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu, Dapeng Man, Wu Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Speech-to-text (S2T) generation systems frequently face challenges in
low-resource scenarios, primarily due to the lack of extensive labeled
datasets. One emerging solution is constructing virtual training samples by
interpolating inputs and labels, which has notably enhanced system
generalization in other domains. Despite its potential, this technique's
application in S2T tasks has remained under-explored. In this paper, we delve
into the utility of interpolation augmentation, guided by several pivotal
questions. Our findings reveal that employing an appropriate strategy in
interpolation augmentation significantly enhances performance across diverse
tasks, architectures, and data scales, offering a promising avenue for more
robust S2T systems in resource-constrained settings. | [
-0.5604550242424011,
-0.41602230072021484,
0.35606008768081665,
0.6121877431869507,
-0.34539559483528137,
0.414265900850296,
-0.2666855454444885,
-0.6062628626823425,
0.010210241191089153,
0.24251903593540192,
-0.7438580393791199,
0.1875898540019989,
-0.7799093723297119,
0.17699211835861206,
-0.5464574694633484,
1.010799765586853,
0.26415619254112244,
-0.11468427628278732,
-0.5863337516784668,
0.11495643109083176,
-0.4832906723022461,
-0.7750440835952759,
-0.44782689213752747,
-0.6337341070175171,
0.0937236025929451,
0.6874719858169556,
0.49614253640174866,
0.6652699112892151,
0.1933804303407669,
0.1865159273147583,
-0.07519267499446869,
0.5202990174293518,
-0.569972574710846,
0.39621567726135254,
0.06951440870761871,
-0.3297446668148041,
-0.05995090678334236,
-0.08439939469099045,
0.8387341499328613,
0.4737187922000885,
0.2676350474357605,
0.21087567508220673,
0.4886281192302704,
0.6726560592651367,
-0.396371066570282,
0.26144102215766907,
-0.748456597328186,
-0.05347064509987831,
-0.3254704773426056,
-0.6164979338645935,
-0.17650078237056732,
-0.033167630434036255,
0.1185288280248642,
-0.6090564131736755,
0.3619840145111084,
-0.2686355412006378,
0.7244665026664734,
0.6989310383796692,
-0.28501424193382263,
-0.25326573848724365,
-1.0515711307525635,
0.5371212363243103,
-0.5077657103538513,
0.2845870554447174,
0.37613287568092346,
0.2193690985441208,
0.018167590722441673,
-1.1232198476791382,
-0.4842485189437866,
-0.33254191279411316,
0.000048496618546778336,
0.1870436668395996,
-0.2843828797340393,
0.12341073155403137,
0.6128425598144531,
0.42733508348464966,
-0.039626557379961014,
0.39178183674812317,
-0.5801981091499329,
-0.15184256434440613,
0.48256486654281616,
-0.24770979583263397,
0.07279323786497116,
-0.04232039302587509,
-0.38760483264923096,
-0.18022483587265015,
-0.7036769390106201,
0.1373281180858612,
0.774870753288269,
0.7266579270362854,
0.005035655107349157,
0.750783383846283,
-0.3848748505115509,
0.7826085090637207,
0.17683561146259308,
0.1413716971874237,
0.1519666165113449,
-0.6457589268684387,
0.3209021985530853,
0.3641433119773865,
0.4376955032348633,
0.2813285291194916,
0.2310670018196106,
-0.03336116671562195,
-0.1880234032869339,
-0.0654643177986145,
0.4789659380912781,
-0.909783124923706,
0.00014938607637304813,
0.23885348439216614,
0.23003548383712769,
-0.2879485487937927,
-0.040282849222421646,
-0.5669148564338684,
-0.11196523904800415,
-0.45951515436172485,
0.43684422969818115,
-0.24223457276821136,
-0.20971345901489258,
-0.2914220094680786,
-0.31412947177886963,
-0.07447349280118942,
0.09635985642671585,
-1.1272000074386597,
0.16490408778190613,
0.6727132797241211,
0.8999122977256775,
0.03224101662635803,
-0.000832826248370111,
-0.7189083695411682,
-0.03899390622973442,
-0.2474873661994934,
0.8580057621002197,
-0.323665976524353,
-0.803970217704773,
-0.08010633289813995,
-0.37420913577079773,
0.41451457142829895,
-0.6294429302215576,
0.3404396176338196,
-0.1661859005689621,
0.16590574383735657,
-0.3564446270465851,
-0.38702473044395447,
0.3806855082511902,
0.06655079126358032,
-0.46963340044021606,
1.3668992519378662,
0.20967160165309906,
-0.5723991990089417,
0.47034594416618347,
-0.4666458070278168,
-0.38435372710227966,
0.20469629764556885,
-0.4229966998100281,
-0.540001630783081,
0.37869447469711304,
0.3059854209423065,
0.2866602838039398,
-0.5189669728279114,
-0.07260260730981827,
-0.06300030648708344,
-0.37767305970191956,
0.16037705540657043,
-0.7146756649017334,
0.355065256357193,
0.3828929364681244,
-0.24655507504940033,
-0.32044997811317444,
-0.8169949054718018,
0.49541714787483215,
-0.17645184695720673,
-0.6593179106712341,
-0.07059133797883987,
-0.040365349501371384,
0.253978431224823,
0.06558341532945633,
0.15817499160766602,
-0.6473992466926575,
0.12105560302734375,
-0.45669588446617126,
0.6604912877082825,
0.5009692311286926,
-0.16636887192726135,
0.42024895548820496,
-0.31151118874549866,
0.5152446031570435,
-0.15626300871372223,
-0.315192848443985,
-0.3762337863445282,
-0.45197632908821106,
-0.5298712253570557,
-0.30725982785224915,
0.6936708092689514,
0.5217958688735962,
-1.1794475317001343,
0.2591790556907654,
-0.508748471736908,
-0.5955361127853394,
-0.6678260564804077,
-0.26456865668296814,
0.3446505665779114,
0.4736223518848419,
0.6533536314964294,
-0.029215916991233826,
-0.37827467918395996,
-0.8944762945175171,
-0.530515730381012,
-0.07177803665399551,
-0.18722659349441528,
0.15023738145828247,
-0.19746212661266327,
-0.008501122705638409,
1.1479811668395996,
-0.06330688297748566,
-0.06536852568387985,
-0.17474912106990814,
0.005474878940731287,
-0.22742001712322235,
0.7521626353263855,
0.5121936798095703,
-0.8393102288246155,
-0.499277800321579,
0.0506562776863575,
-0.2758958339691162,
-0.4988136291503906,
-0.19353100657463074,
0.27643483877182007,
-0.25178852677345276,
0.8796759843826294,
-0.046977024525403976,
0.49856406450271606,
0.7747226357460022,
0.13681940734386444,
0.4618777930736542,
-0.5064834356307983,
0.04336290806531906,
-1.1588103771209717,
-0.27094346284866333,
0.09241016954183578,
-0.32014861702919006,
-0.8743371367454529,
-0.0992322787642479,
-0.02413654886186123,
-0.20308995246887207,
-0.29556116461753845,
0.2705315947532654,
-0.374132364988327,
-0.4443758428096771,
-0.47609269618988037,
0.09828886389732361,
-0.012514159083366394,
0.013108044862747192,
-0.08149028569459915,
1.4262633323669434,
0.1821732074022293,
-0.522057294845581,
0.10988510400056839,
0.10956109315156937,
-0.356826514005661,
0.6313299536705017,
-0.5181164741516113,
0.32910510897636414,
-0.38263970613479614,
0.2360072135925293,
-1.1976850032806396,
-0.3011864125728607,
-0.09997855126857758,
-0.6202568411827087,
0.26263198256492615,
-0.19261470437049866,
-0.6268022656440735,
-0.11563179641962051,
-0.010693785734474659,
0.7196291089057922,
0.5686551332473755,
-0.7726337313652039,
0.3317708969116211,
0.4568409323692322,
-0.18899792432785034,
-0.4253208041191101,
-0.8559382557868958,
0.17772717773914337,
-0.17123936116695404,
-0.49437153339385986,
0.8704883456230164,
-0.0071898032911121845,
-0.1334460973739624,
-0.20566624402999878,
-0.11679677665233612,
-0.056108444929122925,
-0.23486222326755524,
0.27101820707321167,
-0.1948971003293991,
0.029277566820383072,
0.4164402186870575,
0.5500411987304688,
-0.3222425878047943,
-0.3176147937774658,
-0.4552963674068451,
0.6938110589981079,
0.1756015121936798,
-0.3352568447589874,
-0.3635605573654175,
0.5625352263450623,
0.2314184457063675,
-0.07615873962640762,
0.03954913094639778,
0.5193194150924683,
-0.3147290050983429,
-0.30840516090393066,
-0.34655967354774475,
-0.3701830208301544,
-0.5637422800064087,
0.5513904094696045,
-0.4987592399120331,
-0.7866308689117432,
-0.11680885404348373,
-0.5437887907028198,
0.2094423472881317,
0.2537028193473816,
0.4443094730377197,
-0.4143633544445038,
0.879478931427002,
0.5823017954826355,
0.4338338077068329,
0.8035753965377808,
-0.2234264761209488,
0.326181560754776,
-0.9068681597709656,
-0.16350340843200684,
-0.5284982323646545,
-0.38316330313682556,
-0.9430355429649353,
-0.618630588054657,
0.8512399792671204,
-0.03556262329220772,
0.1356370896100998,
0.27298372983932495,
-0.7599006295204163,
0.42552486062049866,
0.9525905847549438,
0.2731165587902069,
0.2220018208026886,
0.6833546757698059,
0.3426313102245331,
-0.3718295991420746,
-0.8993569612503052,
-0.3256337344646454,
0.8046587705612183,
0.1197623759508133,
0.10547423362731934,
-0.32966336607933044,
0.5929614901542664,
0.5599254369735718,
0.17008283734321594,
-0.730763852596283,
0.391088604927063,
-0.5452530980110168,
-0.44817137718200684,
-0.48638027906417847,
-0.1831585317850113,
-0.8752632737159729,
0.28075408935546875,
-0.5403977632522583,
-0.6063410639762878,
0.16130021214485168,
0.6329419612884521,
-0.48011523485183716,
0.08973990380764008,
-0.7336251139640808,
0.05956863984465599,
-0.10059941560029984,
-0.3254289925098419,
-0.17804120481014252,
-0.5996946096420288,
-0.013119666837155819,
-0.22305744886398315,
0.08968470990657806,
0.020754732191562653,
0.06436646729707718,
0.45730260014533997,
-0.7545297145843506,
0.4657959043979645,
0.022337166592478752,
-0.09810341894626617,
0.5334068536758423,
-0.4559309482574463,
0.5679322481155396,
-0.18043209612369537,
-0.2850039005279541,
0.26001280546188354,
0.020577793940901756,
-0.43323376774787903,
-0.5193542838096619,
0.6859687566757202,
-0.6515060663223267,
-0.506151556968689,
-0.2844122648239136,
-0.6658689379692078,
-0.7986636757850647,
-0.1836213767528534,
0.7452195286750793,
0.6647830605506897,
0.3375008702278137,
0.3572078049182892,
0.32986363768577576,
-0.27143213152885437,
0.29829466342926025,
-0.24694114923477173,
-0.002752855187281966,
-0.5795244574546814,
1.3459597826004028,
0.6686551570892334,
0.7724637985229492,
0.13359445333480835,
0.19006241858005524,
-0.34001410007476807,
-0.4747074246406555,
-0.7704018950462341,
0.1584223061800003,
-0.44790568947792053,
-0.10215329378843307,
-0.49418744444847107,
-0.5368869304656982,
-0.3755439817905426,
0.09327216446399689,
-0.5276066660881042,
-0.7081064581871033,
-0.46106046438217163,
-0.3223966062068939,
0.42930078506469727,
0.5354810357093811,
-0.4396403133869171,
0.9643269181251526,
-0.5485956072807312,
0.3622642159461975,
0.41227200627326965,
-0.037955813109874725,
-0.49780142307281494,
-0.45486465096473694,
-0.25840499997138977,
0.28078463673591614,
-0.22157417237758636,
-0.6768907904624939,
0.10779398679733276,
0.26368236541748047,
0.17969724535942078,
-0.15524490177631378,
0.03219795227050781,
0.8611733913421631,
-0.5205428004264832,
0.8322548270225525,
0.22665858268737793,
-0.7073730230331421,
0.36224421858787537,
-0.22411412000656128,
0.36113524436950684,
0.2852131128311157,
0.009757217019796371,
-0.3533337414264679,
-0.11189130693674088,
-0.5258916616439819,
-1.2833837270736694,
0.810735285282135,
0.5353752374649048,
0.5615513324737549,
0.6177169680595398,
0.6565704345703125,
0.14592014253139496,
0.4967842996120453,
-0.539966344833374,
-0.29810354113578796,
-0.3461170792579651,
-0.06928522884845734,
-0.12266575545072556,
-0.4452449083328247,
0.013185558840632439,
-0.04862191900610924,
0.5914915204048157,
-0.12223836034536362,
0.24821674823760986,
0.15082179009914398,
0.2306259572505951,
0.04743001610040665,
0.15847063064575195,
0.4667982757091522,
0.09095640480518341,
0.3118212819099426,
0.0014261772157624364,
0.07976524531841278,
-0.5078969597816467,
0.29968079924583435,
0.44410696625709534,
-0.46759381890296936,
-0.09617277979850769,
0.11275595426559448,
1.1907274723052979,
-0.21440744400024414,
-0.5144001841545105,
0.27008405327796936,
0.17549699544906616,
-0.30383315682411194,
0.016329340636730194,
0.009546210989356041,
-0.2277291864156723,
0.36248546838760376,
0.24080754816532135,
0.18965214490890503,
0.008288119919598103,
-0.369753360748291,
0.1459473967552185,
0.37910228967666626,
-0.7507601380348206,
-0.15950368344783783,
0.7057368755340576,
0.18557187914848328,
-0.6595614552497864,
0.448193222284317,
0.14962904155254364,
-0.18127116560935974,
0.42749547958374023,
0.8219977617263794,
0.7336364388465881,
-0.04303934797644615,
0.11021063476800919,
0.2434173822402954,
0.5932695865631104,
0.090165875852108,
0.29459860920906067,
-0.5307968258857727,
-0.38743847608566284,
-0.4366481602191925,
-0.33256852626800537,
-0.4812605082988739,
0.3009187579154968,
-0.33319488167762756,
0.30319109559059143,
-0.3550092279911041,
-0.6584914922714233,
-0.2586781084537506,
-0.3939911425113678,
-0.509009838104248,
0.48079097270965576,
0.2182278335094452,
0.6116776466369629,
-0.43251675367355347,
0.5458923578262329,
0.5229053497314453,
-0.08963294327259064,
-0.6273502111434937,
0.4267168939113617,
-0.2866416573524475,
-0.7157225608825684,
0.5183987617492676,
0.08385514467954636,
-0.3302185535430908,
0.3502098619937897,
-0.34615975618362427,
-0.9837227463722229,
0.8127068877220154,
0.5369911193847656,
-0.5864229798316956,
-0.19255851209163666,
0.7695209383964539,
0.5586027503013611,
-0.09716122597455978,
-0.02537701465189457,
0.6946142911911011,
0.3541608154773712,
-0.09389962255954742,
-0.9776724576950073,
-0.2961702346801758,
-0.15425924956798553,
0.2661857604980469,
-0.09316613525152206,
-0.7579627633094788,
0.6710699200630188,
-0.23373541235923767,
-0.16334962844848633,
-0.01258629746735096,
0.7938676476478577,
0.3589944541454315,
0.3796321749687195,
0.8070133924484253,
0.20446400344371796,
0.49628525972366333,
-0.3738061785697937,
0.9475736618041992,
-0.42438384890556335,
-0.08900509029626846,
1.0803228616714478,
0.16564974188804626,
0.48513102531433105,
0.7751083374023438,
-0.2812820076942444,
-0.0008251765393652022,
0.7126184701919556,
0.4039643108844757,
0.5637828707695007,
0.24719113111495972,
-0.6544618606567383,
-0.22752241790294647,
-0.38962945342063904,
-0.6611005067825317,
0.4385109543800354,
0.7009097933769226,
-0.17699262499809265,
-0.11439290642738342,
0.18264293670654297,
-0.25151047110557556,
0.2827783226966858,
-0.12182266265153885,
0.7218858003616333,
-0.0476679727435112,
-0.6571207642555237,
0.3693637549877167,
-0.32761168479919434,
0.4627242088317871,
-0.540951669216156,
-0.2226954698562622,
0.1943042129278183,
-0.10228687524795532,
-0.09874401986598969,
-0.7011178135871887,
0.018530264496803284,
0.09767208993434906,
-0.08926857262849808,
-0.653262734413147,
0.7221470475196838,
-0.5675725340843201,
-0.30700236558914185,
0.057618606835603714,
0.4857993721961975,
-0.09124860912561417,
-0.27465304732322693,
-0.2126222550868988,
0.05221233516931534,
0.24584516882896423,
0.018651774153113365,
0.34541797637939453,
0.4339641332626343,
-0.04352768510580063,
0.40639445185661316,
0.9243935346603394,
0.34290388226509094,
0.360725998878479,
-0.22764010727405548,
0.8751727938652039,
-0.056056901812553406,
-0.5825134515762329,
-0.5387684106826782,
0.7419703006744385,
-0.30148845911026,
-0.4296867847442627,
0.5331289172172546,
0.5446849465370178,
1.0449867248535156,
0.07423017919063568,
1.4838294982910156,
0.057326629757881165,
0.7355106472969055,
-0.4080156981945038,
0.252005934715271,
-0.6421465873718262,
0.39077112078666687,
-0.05869761109352112,
-0.9802998900413513,
-0.03112071566283703,
0.12338194251060486,
-0.29838138818740845,
-0.07540083676576614,
0.008902940899133682,
0.7272763848304749,
-0.053531061857938766,
-0.01831723004579544,
0.49500441551208496,
-0.19293367862701416,
0.5995890498161316,
-0.2268609255552292,
0.9736810922622681,
-0.551417350769043,
0.6380732655525208,
-0.6526566743850708,
-0.2756655216217041,
-0.2949317395687103,
-0.723977267742157,
-0.2824731469154358,
-0.9397912621498108,
-0.06710708141326904,
-0.6198914647102356,
0.10569089651107788,
1.254595160484314,
0.7532650828361511,
-0.4311479330062866,
-0.2928699553012848,
-0.05094141513109207,
-0.4246295690536499,
-0.16979610919952393,
-0.13983896374702454,
-0.04020286351442337,
-0.5450696349143982,
-1.1733829975128174,
0.6327417492866516,
0.4074784815311432,
0.4786284863948822,
-0.19042950868606567,
0.15989550948143005,
0.30514341592788696,
0.25896012783050537,
0.7972692847251892,
0.4511238932609558,
-0.44311782717704773,
-0.1630193442106247,
-0.31458956003189087,
0.18116061389446259,
0.17168527841567993,
1.0866272449493408,
-1.0388051271438599,
0.8995112776756287,
0.4512738287448883,
0.897587239742279,
0.8629645705223083,
0.41436827182769775,
0.6804870963096619,
-1.1857858896255493,
0.40670937299728394,
0.25631141662597656,
-0.07503191381692886,
0.5267373323440552,
-0.33402982354164124,
0.4428726136684418,
0.23626184463500977,
-0.5706008672714233,
-1.229118824005127,
0.5233319401741028,
-0.7663100361824036,
0.18425939977169037,
1.1800408363342285,
0.3263813555240631,
0.4201592803001404,
0.028885532170534134,
-0.5599717497825623,
0.27143722772598267,
-0.3149243891239166,
0.79826819896698,
0.33068814873695374,
-0.4082164466381073,
0.18383105099201202,
-0.545046865940094,
0.7692111730575562,
0.3865137994289398,
-0.9230630397796631,
0.12450180947780609,
0.3763168454170227,
-0.11574756354093552,
0.14624857902526855,
0.8053393959999084,
0.09082752466201782,
-0.015698634088039398,
0.027176907286047935,
-0.4157712459564209,
-0.08832941949367523,
-0.264612078666687,
-0.01674504764378071,
0.16289418935775757,
0.020782936364412308,
-0.43708905577659607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02514v1 | LOGIC-LM++: Multi-Step Refinement for Symbolic Formulations | 2024-06-22T12:50:41 | 2024-06-22T12:50:41 | Shashank Kirtania, Priyanshu Gupta, Arjun Radhakirshna | cs.LO | cs.LO, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper we examine the limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs) for
complex reasoning tasks. While current approaches leverage formal languages as
intermediate representation of reasoning problems, they struggle with
generating intermediate formal specifications and refining these
representations. To address these issues, this paper proposes Logic-LM++, an
improvement on Logic-LM. It uses the ability of LLMs to do pairwise
comparisons, allowing the evaluation of the refinements suggested by the LLM.
The paper demonstrates that Logic-LM++ outperforms Logic-LM and LLM based
techniques on natural language reasoning tasks on two datasets, FOLIO and
AR-LSAT. Logic-LM++ show an average improvement of 13.5% on standard prompting,
11% on chain of thought prompting and 5% on Logic-LM. | [
-0.3380717635154724,
-0.8914965987205505,
0.9248819947242737,
0.1610819697380066,
0.08006056398153305,
0.40030810236930847,
-0.30833372473716736,
-0.8447505235671997,
-0.08547393232584,
0.5941544771194458,
-0.76185142993927,
-0.3490969240665436,
-0.4973197281360626,
0.4389067590236664,
-0.19101227819919586,
0.45992693305015564,
-0.41946548223495483,
0.4438188076019287,
-0.14471381902694702,
-0.20421642065048218,
-0.6226701736450195,
-0.5613546371459961,
-0.8769883513450623,
-0.7017568349838257,
0.5947710275650024,
0.0840279757976532,
0.813165009021759,
0.17568126320838928,
0.5107525587081909,
0.3030989468097687,
-0.09312006831169128,
0.4983176589012146,
-0.08626900613307953,
0.40888962149620056,
-0.1200140118598938,
-0.6919546127319336,
-0.6580641269683838,
-0.003692475613206625,
0.6713963747024536,
0.7339958548545837,
-0.05349262058734894,
0.17796148359775543,
-0.4432705342769623,
1.0785802602767944,
-0.5376701951026917,
0.293093204498291,
-0.5273524522781372,
-0.04840340092778206,
0.05268295109272003,
-0.09962334483861923,
-0.5744289755821228,
-0.6016638875007629,
-0.02046080119907856,
-0.5692229866981506,
-0.08233128488063812,
0.2138819843530655,
0.6407058835029602,
0.18862587213516235,
-0.34138086438179016,
-0.22362525761127472,
-0.7706351280212402,
1.0461088418960571,
-0.695658802986145,
0.7241223454475403,
-0.028166985139250755,
0.4561762511730194,
-0.4465709626674652,
-0.587547242641449,
-0.7071459889411926,
-0.7361206412315369,
-0.23344552516937256,
-0.15883105993270874,
0.0466148778796196,
0.26543736457824707,
0.7591798901557922,
0.11832606047391891,
-0.2028578668832779,
-0.26588934659957886,
-0.4165458083152771,
-0.088260218501091,
0.7717270851135254,
0.23456953465938568,
0.13979600369930267,
0.0787651315331459,
-0.24298115074634552,
0.027745336294174194,
-1.2356985807418823,
-0.10503873974084854,
0.21555760502815247,
0.38108694553375244,
0.3551953434944153,
0.5651063323020935,
-0.39164912700653076,
1.1189080476760864,
-0.008118889294564724,
-0.13937868177890778,
0.3740423619747162,
-0.6003325581550598,
-0.24943162500858307,
0.01649535819888115,
0.31882724165916443,
0.246464341878891,
0.5690881609916687,
0.1435781717300415,
-0.30091750621795654,
0.2969110906124115,
0.04539313167333603,
-0.7810319662094116,
0.045719701796770096,
0.4424164593219757,
-0.13580840826034546,
0.1259758174419403,
0.059705544263124466,
-0.041178587824106216,
-0.45186352729797363,
-1.2237732410430908,
0.5852670073509216,
-0.3766855299472809,
-0.08986957371234894,
0.724646270275116,
-0.12104645371437073,
0.2870209217071533,
0.7919520735740662,
0.05650411546230316,
0.5513295531272888,
0.9651030898094177,
0.5207319855690002,
0.015946025028824806,
-0.04893447086215019,
-0.7472379803657532,
0.06342325359582901,
-0.4213249981403351,
0.7670823335647583,
-0.6985781192779541,
0.02161301113665104,
-0.05207043141126633,
-0.1857852041721344,
-0.02378115803003311,
-0.8115854263305664,
0.8252373337745667,
-0.37779492139816284,
0.2535017728805542,
-0.5984053611755371,
-0.6368454098701477,
-0.526374876499176,
0.6249236464500427,
-0.8617839813232422,
1.0816709995269775,
-0.01887095347046852,
-0.5073132514953613,
0.23276963829994202,
-0.838605523109436,
-0.5338835120201111,
-0.06147582828998566,
-0.45276445150375366,
-0.10513657331466675,
-0.134939044713974,
0.1632968634366989,
0.47405990958213806,
-0.5895345211029053,
0.5122995376586914,
-0.2866916060447693,
-0.6212190389633179,
0.15939144790172577,
0.0068589081056416035,
0.8278209567070007,
0.09002920985221863,
-0.351423054933548,
0.701991617679596,
-0.8742358684539795,
0.15650586783885956,
0.100973941385746,
-0.15417584776878357,
-0.29715588688850403,
0.12150172144174576,
-0.5230600237846375,
0.5987125039100647,
0.20794734358787537,
-0.4888567626476288,
0.32370802760124207,
-0.5386313199996948,
0.22541077435016632,
0.6346582770347595,
-0.25049087405204773,
0.29348260164260864,
-0.6155698895454407,
0.4405808746814728,
0.03505411371588707,
0.05290115252137184,
-0.1112905964255333,
-0.42289888858795166,
-1.122359037399292,
-0.1414434015750885,
0.07760896533727646,
0.7173655033111572,
-0.8524507284164429,
0.43488436937332153,
-0.034662891179323196,
-0.288396954536438,
-0.67811518907547,
0.3495412766933441,
0.6809034943580627,
0.29574641585350037,
0.4494481086730957,
0.010128065943717957,
-0.6023795008659363,
-0.9067761301994324,
-0.379124253988266,
-0.011950952000916004,
0.05195176228880882,
-0.07399508357048035,
0.3910180628299713,
-0.18793277442455292,
0.5084896683692932,
-0.3966052532196045,
0.02170747146010399,
-0.5126410722732544,
-0.15802451968193054,
0.38808462023735046,
0.2369653731584549,
0.10417864471673965,
-0.6046959161758423,
-0.28899049758911133,
-0.3528182804584503,
-0.5854031443595886,
-0.10778967291116714,
-0.10706774890422821,
-0.22944654524326324,
0.23233391344547272,
0.6862300038337708,
-0.9085703492164612,
0.15530969202518463,
0.2227621078491211,
-0.462914377450943,
0.939966082572937,
-0.17382846772670746,
0.07696148008108139,
-0.8301578760147095,
-0.1631275862455368,
0.24762146174907684,
-0.25198403000831604,
-0.694842517375946,
0.6962982416152954,
0.010321835987269878,
0.02527148649096489,
-0.5398406386375427,
0.712236762046814,
-0.6299178600311279,
0.1691621094942093,
0.09557899087667465,
0.3658807575702667,
0.09192372858524323,
0.39022499322891235,
0.26708266139030457,
0.3314704895019531,
0.6017634868621826,
-0.6754457950592041,
0.7077445983886719,
-0.29655545949935913,
-0.13384297490119934,
0.5338900685310364,
-0.7434875965118408,
0.12715493142604828,
-0.17144028842449188,
0.6390649676322937,
-0.8896842002868652,
0.03984781727194786,
0.3757249116897583,
0.12700727581977844,
0.30774736404418945,
0.39420846104621887,
-0.8721757531166077,
-0.40176036953926086,
-0.8468109965324402,
0.4987082779407501,
0.3060752749443054,
-0.34195956587791443,
0.6339337229728699,
-0.20925487577915192,
0.014911632984876633,
-0.30975639820098877,
-0.36011987924575806,
-0.06809628009796143,
0.09981871396303177,
-0.9034216403961182,
0.0953628197312355,
-0.3030320107936859,
-0.8408179879188538,
-0.23046875,
-0.13181397318840027,
0.3126450479030609,
-0.12714608013629913,
0.09074339270591736,
0.25370991230010986,
-0.2057143598794937,
0.17959094047546387,
0.034247688949108124,
-0.34643787145614624,
0.22131839394569397,
-0.11418052762746811,
0.5611071586608887,
-0.329865425825119,
-0.6544209718704224,
-0.5102617740631104,
0.28277871012687683,
0.40694865584373474,
-0.27888768911361694,
0.4303109049797058,
0.48120537400245667,
-0.4463537633419037,
-0.19242019951343536,
-0.717912495136261,
-0.42785584926605225,
-0.4647766053676605,
0.015395747497677803,
-0.5538114309310913,
-0.8873456120491028,
0.19231873750686646,
-0.30966976284980774,
0.24921981990337372,
0.48854872584342957,
0.2901100814342499,
0.0938718318939209,
1.1334917545318604,
0.19831335544586182,
0.10416051745414734,
0.1378154754638672,
-0.09705755114555359,
0.2655944228172302,
-0.6443251371383667,
-0.3402334451675415,
-0.6212745308876038,
-0.5038101077079773,
-0.419638067483902,
-0.4981221556663513,
0.07937832921743393,
0.11203939467668533,
-0.49275901913642883,
0.406223863363266,
-0.45851829648017883,
0.48464182019233704,
0.42718902230262756,
0.16598814725875854,
0.684136688709259,
-0.10708969831466675,
-0.10812089592218399,
-0.058485060930252075,
-0.5170776844024658,
-0.3212061822414398,
0.9535412788391113,
0.30093568563461304,
0.686460018157959,
0.23254713416099548,
0.55633944272995,
-0.007841466926038265,
0.3907388746738434,
-0.8278625011444092,
1.004875898361206,
0.04935832694172859,
-0.48588141798973083,
-0.14885997772216797,
-0.45621398091316223,
-0.5051422715187073,
0.2897641956806183,
-0.2741621434688568,
-0.5334938168525696,
-0.2558310627937317,
-0.04907764494419098,
-0.28067147731781006,
0.1765824556350708,
-0.6708807945251465,
0.43667417764663696,
-0.350315123796463,
-0.24441778659820557,
-0.4251277446746826,
-0.6230212450027466,
0.6244004368782043,
-0.05196382477879524,
0.38115644454956055,
-0.19858720898628235,
-0.058658912777900696,
0.48000478744506836,
-0.4585803747177124,
0.5697118639945984,
-0.08566829562187195,
-0.46997731924057007,
0.275835245847702,
0.37798693776130676,
0.8038730025291443,
-0.2114311009645462,
-0.26222777366638184,
-0.3232928514480591,
-0.002458566799759865,
-0.38129109144210815,
-0.9541313648223877,
0.6570503115653992,
-0.28570082783699036,
-0.8514986038208008,
-0.3495273292064667,
-0.589490532875061,
-0.41738373041152954,
0.044082947075366974,
-0.29883262515068054,
0.6646048426628113,
0.45226654410362244,
0.0424700491130352,
0.6766244769096375,
-0.16596423089504242,
0.07806120067834854,
0.4786442816257477,
-0.7268489003181458,
-0.14967823028564453,
0.6157294511795044,
-0.010217858478426933,
0.5148725509643555,
0.4797653555870056,
0.16122154891490936,
-0.48352497816085815,
-0.34927988052368164,
-0.358885794878006,
0.5251772999763489,
-0.8242574334144592,
-0.037971001118421555,
-0.24352382123470306,
-0.31939390301704407,
-0.06951150298118591,
-0.035756710916757584,
-0.2167603224515915,
-0.71379554271698,
0.1681346744298935,
-0.17437200248241425,
0.49136337637901306,
0.6679112911224365,
0.418949156999588,
-0.15284627676010132,
-0.6183055639266968,
0.5810986757278442,
0.09062591940164566,
0.26024389266967773,
0.01880708523094654,
-0.37367233633995056,
0.25690025091171265,
-0.060039736330509186,
-0.2007245570421219,
-0.6291009783744812,
-0.11949492990970612,
0.05075428634881973,
0.29238948225975037,
0.2381441593170166,
0.020601090043783188,
1.0157079696655273,
-0.5219533443450928,
0.6540455222129822,
0.2639816105365753,
-0.8294749855995178,
0.5172194838523865,
-0.23275884985923767,
0.4903738498687744,
0.46832311153411865,
0.4058747887611389,
-0.4101731777191162,
-0.6121214032173157,
-0.5878011584281921,
-0.7593426704406738,
0.36780551075935364,
0.2992657423019409,
-0.017903480678796768,
0.2220618724822998,
0.5624574422836304,
-0.06425891816616058,
0.1378294825553894,
-0.6698750257492065,
-0.4161718189716339,
0.46700167655944824,
-0.06702136248350143,
0.011722899042069912,
-0.22205381095409393,
-0.12453583627939224,
-0.8227955102920532,
0.7330626845359802,
0.15308082103729248,
0.10793349146842957,
0.16665272414684296,
0.0751057043671608,
-0.1067156195640564,
0.4645179212093353,
0.7634884715080261,
0.9637233018875122,
-0.11879313737154007,
0.41073375940322876,
0.15559855103492737,
0.024805694818496704,
0.1814437210559845,
0.21123920381069183,
-0.2276831418275833,
0.23309409618377686,
0.5427388548851013,
0.5584291815757751,
0.2338525652885437,
-1.0449509620666504,
0.17060105502605438,
0.03363418206572533,
-0.33382344245910645,
-0.26598235964775085,
0.3097677230834961,
0.2829844057559967,
0.28855323791503906,
0.2528299391269684,
0.019497686997056007,
0.17445653676986694,
-0.7055133581161499,
0.24641524255275726,
0.3911048471927643,
-0.26421815156936646,
-0.15925106406211853,
0.3579627275466919,
0.208245187997818,
-0.42587682604789734,
0.37353676557540894,
-0.503261148929596,
-0.5644036531448364,
0.5345698595046997,
0.6227115988731384,
0.7618265151977539,
-0.05258643999695778,
-0.008739687502384186,
0.5313360691070557,
0.24937202036380768,
-0.36893460154533386,
0.7530219554901123,
0.05211489275097847,
-0.8120062947273254,
-0.7668902277946472,
-0.527277946472168,
-0.5062656402587891,
0.1622917354106903,
-0.3060877025127411,
0.4654402732849121,
-0.6155661344528198,
-0.00653466023504734,
-0.05692795664072037,
0.3025134801864624,
-0.553505539894104,
0.17778867483139038,
-0.14869821071624756,
1.0790880918502808,
-0.41796132922172546,
0.8632263541221619,
0.7660156488418579,
-0.29093751311302185,
-1.0231646299362183,
-0.25085604190826416,
0.13095572590827942,
-0.4596942961215973,
0.7992265224456787,
0.3483613431453705,
-0.6556657552719116,
-0.3011215627193451,
-0.4274638295173645,
-0.45929527282714844,
0.944337785243988,
0.5974756479263306,
-1.0725857019424438,
0.10733962804079056,
0.09118613600730896,
0.5875865817070007,
-0.2704789638519287,
0.12970197200775146,
0.6338406205177307,
0.812822163105011,
0.19749145209789276,
-0.9566913843154907,
0.4858725070953369,
-0.2810673415660858,
-0.1835123598575592,
0.6121923923492432,
-0.38541340827941895,
0.933302640914917,
-0.28279373049736023,
-0.09045474231243134,
0.11159484088420868,
0.4305538833141327,
0.7445141077041626,
0.3309508264064789,
0.5170826315879822,
0.5780731439590454,
0.7953507304191589,
-0.1725451648235321,
1.2019025087356567,
-0.39270082116127014,
0.012900315225124359,
1.4658594131469727,
-0.5254063010215759,
0.9912680387496948,
0.47828325629234314,
-0.3811154067516327,
0.5958462953567505,
0.4383057653903961,
0.19953195750713348,
-0.24898172914981842,
0.5715579390525818,
-0.5009916424751282,
-0.5270076990127563,
-0.016371233388781548,
-0.43736428022384644,
-0.15080228447914124,
0.3250757157802582,
-0.13287396728992462,
-0.34188783168792725,
-0.5919076204299927,
0.2523864805698395,
0.22981178760528564,
-0.4441569745540619,
0.37606385350227356,
0.39663979411125183,
-0.7254521250724792,
0.6535462141036987,
0.20436745882034302,
0.590867817401886,
-0.5308150053024292,
-0.2728234827518463,
0.005638157017529011,
0.41578686237335205,
-0.476833313703537,
-0.7394142150878906,
0.3349905014038086,
-0.11575878411531448,
0.12107111513614655,
-0.23822134733200073,
0.9471936225891113,
-0.5891810655593872,
-0.8588413596153259,
0.620441734790802,
0.559687077999115,
-0.06395924836397171,
-0.38807910680770874,
-0.9227603077888489,
0.042854245752096176,
-0.10236616432666779,
-0.17098791897296906,
-0.03149551525712013,
0.3927643895149231,
-0.40237757563591003,
0.9841468334197998,
0.6790369749069214,
0.1090066134929657,
0.004835030063986778,
0.6022966504096985,
0.7346804738044739,
-0.8835371732711792,
0.08824803680181503,
-1.0688233375549316,
0.3535434603691101,
0.015657315030694008,
0.1876518726348877,
0.7481341361999512,
0.5343741178512573,
0.9485160708427429,
-0.04903263971209526,
0.5016653537750244,
0.1796863079071045,
0.39337652921676636,
-0.7890253663063049,
0.2976856231689453,
-0.592816174030304,
0.48733001947402954,
-0.3597140610218048,
-1.0570728778839111,
-0.7533236145973206,
0.4833248257637024,
-0.23560211062431335,
0.11522036790847778,
0.8886915445327759,
0.8689509034156799,
0.08889828622341156,
0.03555174171924591,
0.07506614178419113,
0.10825716704130173,
0.30171629786491394,
0.7082244753837585,
0.9653269052505493,
-0.3790288269519806,
0.16103149950504303,
-0.10092688351869583,
0.07318153977394104,
0.11407370865345001,
-1.0425864458084106,
-0.784821093082428,
-0.21459755301475525,
-0.5047857165336609,
-0.42759108543395996,
-0.12566998600959778,
1.2799993753433228,
0.47407370805740356,
-0.893556535243988,
-0.46406230330467224,
-0.16357237100601196,
0.4220346212387085,
-0.3003986179828644,
-0.18169096112251282,
0.16537758708000183,
-0.44891300797462463,
-0.4559239149093628,
0.39135828614234924,
0.2990204989910126,
-0.44598013162612915,
-0.48734813928604126,
-0.49133914709091187,
-0.3229869306087494,
0.31070008873939514,
1.0261958837509155,
-0.04672888666391373,
-1.0874780416488647,
-0.43702760338783264,
-0.011049040593206882,
0.14563323557376862,
0.21464702486991882,
0.9846743941307068,
-0.7041144371032715,
0.3874151408672333,
0.6574137210845947,
0.41138139367103577,
0.32442706823349,
-0.0629304051399231,
0.6931225061416626,
-0.5956546068191528,
0.2021046131849289,
0.10877828299999237,
0.5483819246292114,
0.14586776494979858,
0.003199854400008917,
0.5459899306297302,
0.24743300676345825,
-0.05661773681640625,
-0.6434738636016846,
0.6209436655044556,
-1.1490956544876099,
-0.36994290351867676,
1.2580701112747192,
0.18011079728603363,
0.05656176432967186,
-0.01933494582772255,
-0.634296178817749,
0.023229004815220833,
-0.4860835373401642,
0.4421231746673584,
0.7623838186264038,
-0.4476127326488495,
-0.17252813279628754,
-0.4695623517036438,
0.5377591252326965,
0.3127150237560272,
-0.9387004375457764,
-0.07327950745820999,
0.6714944839477539,
0.29300424456596375,
0.2162773162126541,
0.6082143187522888,
-0.31383851170539856,
0.21745435893535614,
-0.48973384499549866,
-0.156986266374588,
-0.15758457779884338,
-0.5818787813186646,
-0.263347327709198,
0.24213983118534088,
0.31273308396339417,
0.25617286562919617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15823v1 | CaT-BENCH: Benchmarking Language Model Understanding of Causal and Temporal Dependencies in Plans | 2024-06-22T11:46:04 | 2024-06-22T11:46:04 | Yash Kumar Lal, Vanya Cohen, Nathanael Chambers, Niranjan Balasubramanian, Raymond Mooney | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding the abilities of LLMs to reason about natural language plans,
such as instructional text and recipes, is critical to reliably using them in
decision-making systems. A fundamental aspect of plans is the temporal order in
which their steps needs to be executed, which reflects the underlying causal
dependencies between them. We introduce CaT-Bench, a benchmark of Step Order
Prediction questions, which test whether a step must necessarily occur before
or after another in cooking recipe plans. We use this to evaluate how well
frontier LLMs understand causal and temporal dependencies. We find that SOTA
LLMs are underwhelming (best zero-shot is only 0.59 in F1), and are biased
towards predicting dependence more often, perhaps relying on temporal order of
steps as a heuristic. While prompting for explanations and using few-shot
examples improve performance, the best F1 result is only 0.73. Further, human
evaluation of explanations along with answer correctness show that, on average,
humans do not agree with model reasoning. Surprisingly, we also find that
explaining after answering leads to better performance than normal
chain-of-thought prompting, and LLM answers are not consistent across questions
about the same step pairs. Overall, results show that LLMs' ability to detect
dependence between steps has significant room for improvement. | [
-0.2846387028694153,
-0.7180080413818359,
0.9381985664367676,
0.6837950348854065,
0.09529147297143936,
-0.008566432632505894,
0.18055495619773865,
-0.40811002254486084,
0.03815976902842522,
0.6242549419403076,
-0.7567179799079895,
-0.4123195707798004,
-0.47767874598503113,
0.060028430074453354,
-0.2223956137895584,
0.37749218940734863,
-0.34061598777770996,
0.5005379319190979,
-0.3522605895996094,
-0.10451631247997284,
-0.7443906664848328,
-0.15146951377391815,
-0.6985328197479248,
-0.7324926853179932,
0.45493245124816895,
0.5456809997558594,
0.5327157974243164,
1.0121876001358032,
0.46859440207481384,
0.2932516932487488,
-0.1073303297162056,
-0.18250329792499542,
-0.2688819468021393,
0.13926024734973907,
-0.35499459505081177,
-0.7459948062896729,
-0.3274275064468384,
-0.051770374178886414,
0.4593455493450165,
0.8170862197875977,
-0.30235856771469116,
0.35509055852890015,
-0.019564377143979073,
0.721222460269928,
-0.6030862331390381,
0.3114859163761139,
-0.6049054265022278,
0.003446974093094468,
-0.08685894310474396,
-0.4176926612854004,
-0.3723493218421936,
-0.4832152724266052,
0.008610804565250874,
-0.5295335054397583,
0.15886567533016205,
0.2191193401813507,
0.7876296639442444,
0.5229266285896301,
-0.4891505837440491,
-0.10713259130716324,
-0.6882175803184509,
0.7746985554695129,
-0.535439133644104,
0.44053301215171814,
0.7082253694534302,
0.7161879539489746,
-0.7279723882675171,
-0.7846569418907166,
-0.3985632061958313,
-0.20245279371738434,
0.11330941319465637,
0.18174904584884644,
0.16776348650455475,
-0.05253014340996742,
0.4403358995914459,
0.26072946190834045,
-0.6773697137832642,
0.2913733124732971,
-0.014807694591581821,
0.07309728115797043,
0.4366025924682617,
0.7453182935714722,
0.204461470246315,
-0.1502370983362198,
-0.7074813842773438,
-0.28377336263656616,
-0.8098599314689636,
0.3715178668498993,
0.025241531431674957,
0.20126983523368835,
0.08616843819618225,
0.38841065764427185,
-0.5194856524467468,
0.5424097180366516,
-0.047931451350450516,
-0.03226194530725479,
-0.10136943310499191,
-0.364716500043869,
-0.28935950994491577,
-0.04994961991906166,
0.5113915205001831,
0.44422367215156555,
0.2062259018421173,
-0.01980019360780716,
-0.08432041853666306,
0.058811791241168976,
0.08545637130737305,
-0.8671456575393677,
0.029602449387311935,
0.20435430109500885,
-0.2364937961101532,
0.16150043904781342,
-0.24034951627254486,
-0.788627028465271,
-0.4607032239437103,
-0.4517112374305725,
0.38548851013183594,
-0.15885156393051147,
0.048716697841882706,
0.21807819604873657,
-0.08262176066637039,
0.31999140977859497,
0.2738415002822876,
-0.8561007976531982,
0.7203962206840515,
0.7695276141166687,
0.5292534232139587,
0.12987293303012848,
-0.5802291631698608,
-0.8270734548568726,
0.1323752999305725,
-0.5959675312042236,
1.1361125707626343,
-0.5129613280296326,
-0.4261094033718109,
-0.05352051183581352,
0.09037885814905167,
-0.06502856314182281,
-0.625465989112854,
0.6390920281410217,
-0.3215422034263611,
-0.047157734632492065,
-1.0286320447921753,
-0.6171125173568726,
-0.2927038371562958,
0.24081048369407654,
-0.4837256669998169,
1.2727255821228027,
-0.43593114614486694,
-0.5764496326446533,
0.6410470008850098,
-0.3573930561542511,
-0.38636112213134766,
-0.11709558218717575,
-0.38815250992774963,
-0.07209312915802002,
-0.048519983887672424,
0.23865549266338348,
0.5813133716583252,
-0.6469433307647705,
0.45277559757232666,
-0.39278361201286316,
-0.2620426118373871,
0.2685721218585968,
-0.14233160018920898,
0.6382604837417603,
0.05691327527165413,
-0.511305034160614,
0.15758727490901947,
-0.9439544081687927,
0.15278096497058868,
0.3439009487628937,
-0.2570148706436157,
-0.3331642150878906,
0.5766270756721497,
-0.4010429382324219,
0.17063479125499725,
-0.04416164383292198,
-0.35351085662841797,
-0.02153383381664753,
-0.09491044282913208,
0.2584091126918793,
0.8552407622337341,
0.1560097634792328,
0.3359270691871643,
-0.545322060585022,
0.3354369103908539,
-0.2871657609939575,
0.38008248805999756,
-0.18363651633262634,
-0.35552921891212463,
-0.7206546664237976,
0.16498689353466034,
0.030418947339057922,
0.6283984780311584,
-0.5811979174613953,
-0.17328457534313202,
-0.20527084171772003,
-0.5144309997558594,
0.2115403711795807,
-0.07175317406654358,
0.5687547326087952,
0.5362771153450012,
0.38732969760894775,
-0.31668850779533386,
-0.5601434707641602,
-0.7885285019874573,
-0.4781852960586548,
-0.4017641842365265,
-0.00018353419727645814,
0.06606779992580414,
0.5033388733863831,
0.07169456779956818,
0.8733776211738586,
-0.5505757927894592,
0.14791326224803925,
-0.24191217124462128,
0.5010095834732056,
0.20842255651950836,
0.27135810256004333,
0.19434717297554016,
-0.5731239318847656,
-0.5489854216575623,
-0.31274741888046265,
-0.617717981338501,
-0.35751187801361084,
-0.10133365541696548,
-0.22233586013317108,
-0.19639328122138977,
0.6680943369865417,
-0.3841450810432434,
0.36054739356040955,
0.3172285258769989,
-0.32939860224723816,
0.6621759533882141,
-0.09903351962566376,
0.0016576290363445878,
-0.9185941219329834,
-0.01414248626679182,
-0.023033149540424347,
-0.04483489319682121,
-0.6527183055877686,
-0.10728301852941513,
0.042433254420757294,
0.15782181918621063,
-0.4229053556919098,
0.7175345420837402,
-0.4458487927913666,
-0.40913090109825134,
-0.09935165196657181,
-0.2010149359703064,
-0.035214949399232864,
0.5504785180091858,
0.2868254482746124,
0.617675244808197,
0.2090107947587967,
-0.6103154420852661,
-0.2817791700363159,
0.06442322582006454,
-0.3773278594017029,
0.3123091459274292,
-0.7117303013801575,
-0.0908823311328888,
0.18683262169361115,
0.3474912941455841,
-0.990426778793335,
-0.10427878051996231,
0.07376730442047119,
-0.28101247549057007,
0.22721868753433228,
0.04510209336876869,
-0.8240547180175781,
-0.2219882756471634,
-0.18757280707359314,
0.0314951092004776,
0.2482966035604477,
-0.6101590991020203,
0.6138021945953369,
0.11260986328125,
-0.09672332555055618,
-0.59666907787323,
-0.6468068957328796,
-0.11982071399688721,
-0.028072912245988846,
-0.3399931788444519,
0.3229531943798065,
-0.14959898591041565,
-0.49907755851745605,
-0.11697366088628769,
-0.5628792643547058,
-0.35575589537620544,
0.1555064618587494,
0.6248511075973511,
0.021270304918289185,
-0.24177221953868866,
0.10872210562229156,
-0.16897070407867432,
-0.26414188742637634,
0.48188915848731995,
0.07663556188344955,
0.5083411931991577,
-0.11605176329612732,
-0.33310070633888245,
-0.14242751896381378,
0.11444483697414398,
0.5842089056968689,
-0.036498695611953735,
0.566361665725708,
0.24788856506347656,
-0.3154234290122986,
-0.19013133645057678,
-0.747570812702179,
-0.17014814913272858,
-0.4419497549533844,
-0.03993722423911095,
-0.38320979475975037,
-0.43843039870262146,
0.7677620053291321,
-0.2021828591823578,
0.181770920753479,
0.29996779561042786,
0.49847739934921265,
-0.11689364910125732,
0.9390702247619629,
0.6109569072723389,
0.1754976212978363,
0.5276321768760681,
-0.2407316267490387,
-0.3804350793361664,
-0.6052489280700684,
-0.17670080065727234,
-0.6296994686126709,
-0.15839087963104248,
-0.5777614712715149,
-0.5396766066551208,
0.08849262446165085,
0.09816136956214905,
-0.3263534903526306,
0.31434890627861023,
-0.03496516868472099,
0.7399071455001831,
0.3503941595554352,
-0.02603207342326641,
0.3601114749908447,
-0.41240590810775757,
-0.6426801681518555,
0.006873277947306633,
-0.6597276329994202,
-0.5466437339782715,
1.0181304216384888,
0.45067793130874634,
0.7285788059234619,
-0.2350093126296997,
0.6945623159408569,
-0.13348910212516785,
0.35175880789756775,
-0.5058510303497314,
0.809537947177887,
-0.10325323045253754,
-0.8056716322898865,
-0.4229443073272705,
-0.2868785858154297,
-0.8678820729255676,
0.4020408093929291,
-0.031433820724487305,
-0.7983983755111694,
0.10820353776216507,
-0.07771554589271545,
-0.2788010537624359,
0.06923988461494446,
-0.6948148012161255,
0.8816894292831421,
-0.4142383933067322,
-0.7173976898193359,
-0.03781464323401451,
-0.729410707950592,
0.36374351382255554,
0.21138940751552582,
0.18832717835903168,
-0.41723862290382385,
0.081973597407341,
0.721709132194519,
-0.6565496921539307,
0.9943805932998657,
0.04414960741996765,
0.2756824791431427,
0.15887770056724548,
0.29521462321281433,
0.5719366669654846,
-0.058186326175928116,
-0.059362754225730896,
0.06297461688518524,
0.15313144028186798,
-0.4680062234401703,
-0.5552012324333191,
0.4625367224216461,
-0.4174642562866211,
-0.7883918285369873,
-0.5070467591285706,
-0.4369998574256897,
-0.4584977626800537,
0.164556086063385,
0.2032063603401184,
0.4511713981628418,
-0.3628699779510498,
-0.0759296640753746,
0.6082166433334351,
-0.13822613656520844,
0.6306575536727905,
1.044991374015808,
-0.49385783076286316,
-0.26959705352783203,
0.5525636076927185,
0.24412092566490173,
0.3886967599391937,
0.7096838355064392,
0.4650695323944092,
-0.38819679617881775,
-0.43996602296829224,
-0.38404300808906555,
0.10828965902328491,
-0.953315258026123,
0.021445920690894127,
-0.5860865712165833,
-0.047043804079294205,
0.17622458934783936,
-0.16657143831253052,
-0.5453310012817383,
-0.32165682315826416,
-0.02470768801867962,
-0.10601211339235306,
0.10321550816297531,
0.8152981400489807,
-0.02787538431584835,
0.16850365698337555,
-0.7333689332008362,
0.20293377339839935,
0.4831339120864868,
0.321207195520401,
0.1391625702381134,
-0.15414975583553314,
-0.09159214049577713,
-0.33577266335487366,
-0.4293709397315979,
-0.8387559652328491,
0.12589426338672638,
-0.14259915053844452,
0.8177881836891174,
0.25065794587135315,
0.012234807014465332,
0.8976077437400818,
-0.8021354675292969,
0.7062478065490723,
0.17000916600227356,
-0.9053564071655273,
0.5750258564949036,
-0.2721581757068634,
0.5812709927558899,
0.7434306144714355,
0.5765454769134521,
-0.3175157904624939,
-0.5259335041046143,
-0.4338783621788025,
-0.4817061722278595,
0.639009416103363,
0.016422385349869728,
-0.39632219076156616,
-0.018861066550016403,
0.14173704385757446,
0.2879805862903595,
-0.22281955182552338,
-0.7100095152854919,
-0.01591634750366211,
0.09224196523427963,
0.3431340456008911,
-0.1732342690229416,
-0.2670532763004303,
0.0658237487077713,
-0.18268893659114838,
0.34938910603523254,
-0.051282577216625214,
0.017224997282028198,
0.16862434148788452,
0.10580906271934509,
-0.5383114218711853,
0.33283379673957825,
0.758699357509613,
1.0442179441452026,
-0.4520472586154938,
0.36243584752082825,
0.5081471800804138,
-0.3901355266571045,
0.10793772339820862,
0.03215395286679268,
0.25094011425971985,
0.018381422385573387,
0.6429761648178101,
0.5055594444274902,
0.5242974162101746,
-0.58626389503479,
0.2191852629184723,
-0.33949756622314453,
-0.20527908205986023,
-0.06713009625673294,
-0.022060617804527283,
0.29528114199638367,
0.407479852437973,
0.15831342339515686,
-0.18872442841529846,
0.13683123886585236,
-0.6560829281806946,
0.16609510779380798,
0.11502280086278915,
-0.37086373567581177,
-0.32164376974105835,
0.6297771334648132,
0.03064337931573391,
-0.2986719012260437,
0.18008530139923096,
-0.0107340756803751,
-0.6787799000740051,
0.832463800907135,
0.507223904132843,
0.9665382504463196,
-0.37384119629859924,
0.22552244365215302,
0.45750534534454346,
0.41916391253471375,
-0.4246198534965515,
0.6896417737007141,
-0.13912025094032288,
-0.39943644404411316,
-0.5464959144592285,
-0.6249954700469971,
-0.6940507292747498,
0.07965238392353058,
-0.789641261100769,
0.2684948444366455,
-0.686572253704071,
-0.1607978343963623,
0.1332857757806778,
0.10096994042396545,
-0.7181876301765442,
0.184501051902771,
-0.35090234875679016,
1.0070794820785522,
-1.0250897407531738,
0.8142707943916321,
0.6323229074478149,
-0.4799078702926636,
-1.0170594453811646,
0.32593849301338196,
0.21474696695804596,
-0.9779117107391357,
1.0373525619506836,
0.18176427483558655,
-0.13209593296051025,
-0.3328346908092499,
-0.26545387506484985,
-0.9029718637466431,
1.1476529836654663,
0.052963558584451675,
-0.6787745952606201,
0.33301568031311035,
0.16936349868774414,
0.7259634733200073,
-0.1114300787448883,
0.4104249179363251,
0.4285277724266052,
0.3745766580104828,
0.45430105924606323,
-0.868935763835907,
0.28204551339149475,
0.056742679327726364,
0.12104558944702148,
0.48200544714927673,
-0.4734937846660614,
0.9270836710929871,
-0.1863328218460083,
-0.4242003262042999,
-0.0029040712397545576,
0.2260609120130539,
0.2799302637577057,
0.755535364151001,
0.5356380939483643,
0.6789511442184448,
0.3843463957309723,
-0.025913137942552567,
1.1794586181640625,
0.00917125679552555,
0.004624845925718546,
1.4456663131713867,
-0.4418674409389496,
1.2881613969802856,
0.48634499311447144,
-0.39873531460762024,
0.5091794729232788,
1.096943736076355,
0.40654581785202026,
0.6581891775131226,
0.39695411920547485,
0.21098515391349792,
-0.3683420419692993,
-0.1577039361000061,
-0.3827114701271057,
0.23401013016700745,
0.31510409712791443,
-0.22581417858600616,
-0.4191417396068573,
-0.4028676450252533,
-0.04743024706840515,
0.09973104298114777,
-0.08475492149591446,
0.7674395442008972,
0.257881224155426,
-0.884570300579071,
0.7954621315002441,
-0.31868141889572144,
-0.18078811466693878,
-0.5253856182098389,
-0.1337914913892746,
-0.5216723680496216,
0.15955638885498047,
-0.02902788482606411,
-0.8382507562637329,
0.20625324547290802,
-0.015054267831146717,
-0.35666877031326294,
-0.2850993573665619,
0.3725440800189972,
-0.08301317691802979,
-0.27089741826057434,
0.5737983584403992,
0.5971577763557434,
0.1317429095506668,
0.18742193281650543,
-0.8007242679595947,
0.15978167951107025,
-0.35629960894584656,
-0.21716174483299255,
0.37656453251838684,
0.4487706124782562,
-0.27943697571754456,
0.8058684468269348,
0.5525176525115967,
-0.14639371633529663,
0.10418754070997238,
0.11036191880702972,
0.6755731701850891,
-0.720739483833313,
-0.47725504636764526,
-0.9998862743377686,
0.3571297228336334,
0.10248494893312454,
-0.26598313450813293,
0.6254424452781677,
0.4073679447174072,
0.7276970148086548,
0.18137814104557037,
0.19871088862419128,
0.33018186688423157,
0.5118599534034729,
-0.9760205745697021,
0.2468843162059784,
-0.7794111371040344,
0.6299425959587097,
-0.07750619947910309,
-1.0924559831619263,
-0.1665426641702652,
0.06288958340883255,
-0.8229658007621765,
-0.29775580763816833,
1.2394729852676392,
0.9175237417221069,
0.07984744012355804,
0.336703360080719,
0.26063576340675354,
0.11434588581323624,
0.22913868725299835,
0.6718242168426514,
1.289834976196289,
-0.1465168446302414,
0.441969633102417,
-0.33035343885421753,
-0.23920121788978577,
-0.263380229473114,
-1.0945682525634766,
-1.0427228212356567,
-0.5663275718688965,
-0.08917924016714096,
0.05019503831863403,
0.169234037399292,
0.7885371446609497,
0.6599249839782715,
-0.7178369164466858,
-0.7186836004257202,
-0.5185913443565369,
0.35927316546440125,
-0.3854343295097351,
-0.18049560487270355,
0.17227593064308167,
-0.5242711901664734,
-0.2731734812259674,
0.43878012895584106,
0.49514663219451904,
-0.12208013981580734,
-0.12667667865753174,
-0.09032515436410904,
-0.41464802622795105,
0.2469538152217865,
0.4167429208755493,
0.49574923515319824,
-1.1090013980865479,
-0.146582692861557,
0.10127928853034973,
-0.19227638840675354,
0.09191082417964935,
0.9246163368225098,
-0.3661692440509796,
0.6928671598434448,
0.6296142339706421,
0.5663229823112488,
0.7203047275543213,
-0.20110903680324554,
0.6347910165786743,
-0.3969375491142273,
-0.2823852598667145,
0.0018297145143151283,
0.35775572061538696,
0.04231273755431175,
-0.06155988946557045,
0.8348026871681213,
0.09043347835540771,
-0.8391757011413574,
-0.7595459222793579,
0.13040012121200562,
-0.8904348015785217,
-0.48181697726249695,
1.0472543239593506,
-0.16824857890605927,
-0.3434267044067383,
-0.03757524490356445,
-0.030387811362743378,
0.1428319364786148,
-0.11670296639204025,
0.8234735727310181,
0.7594885230064392,
-0.36899012327194214,
-0.035497505217790604,
-1.010970950126648,
0.3705030083656311,
0.6465578079223633,
-0.9039344191551208,
0.10973615199327469,
0.26852700114250183,
0.33850184082984924,
0.0966854989528656,
0.7772126793861389,
0.1517113894224167,
0.3946576714515686,
0.25233083963394165,
-0.14620733261108398,
0.16834989190101624,
-0.33743929862976074,
-0.08915065228939056,
-0.19380077719688416,
0.20131021738052368,
-0.4468197524547577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17801v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17801v1 | A multi-speaker multi-lingual voice cloning system based on vits2 for limmits 2024 challenge | 2024-06-22T10:49:36 | 2024-06-22T10:49:36 | Xiaopeng Wang, Yi Lu, Xin Qi, Zhiyong Wang, Yuankun Xie, Shuchen Shi, Ruibo Fu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper presents the development of a speech synthesis system for the
LIMMITS'24 Challenge, focusing primarily on Track 2. The objective of the
challenge is to establish a multi-speaker, multi-lingual Indic Text-to-Speech
system with voice cloning capabilities, covering seven Indian languages with
both male and female speakers. The system was trained using challenge data and
fine-tuned for few-shot voice cloning on target speakers. Evaluation included
both mono-lingual and cross-lingual synthesis across all seven languages, with
subjective tests assessing naturalness and speaker similarity. Our system uses
the VITS2 architecture, augmented with a multi-lingual ID and a BERT model to
enhance contextual language comprehension. In Track 1, where no additional data
usage was permitted, our model achieved a Speaker Similarity score of 4.02. In
Track 2, which allowed the use of extra data, it attained a Speaker Similarity
score of 4.17. | [
-0.3256365656852722,
-0.33456388115882874,
0.08363518863916397,
0.6243664026260376,
-0.3775177299976349,
0.38550856709480286,
-0.10002508014440536,
-0.5074138641357422,
0.30002981424331665,
0.4690658450126648,
-0.8883514404296875,
0.0628335103392601,
0.04485462233424187,
0.27486926317214966,
-0.38598865270614624,
0.9691982269287109,
0.384635329246521,
0.13168050348758698,
0.07251536846160889,
-0.02707398682832718,
-1.0166724920272827,
-0.14236441254615784,
-0.1898476928472519,
-0.2065131813287735,
0.034857042133808136,
0.5620470643043518,
0.34769177436828613,
0.41058042645454407,
0.08476659655570984,
0.23205974698066711,
-0.2038721889257431,
0.32201912999153137,
-0.4512045383453369,
0.20220710337162018,
-0.20172645151615143,
-0.3490440547466278,
-0.3547956943511963,
-0.21793633699417114,
0.9908896684646606,
0.5293788909912109,
0.03445807471871376,
0.16538631916046143,
0.15102273225784302,
0.24379949271678925,
-0.09368482232093811,
-0.10183016210794449,
-1.048463225364685,
0.1663312166929245,
-0.18082961440086365,
-0.4681825041770935,
-0.528984785079956,
-0.41935768723487854,
0.2952274680137634,
-0.5552785396575928,
0.10423702001571655,
-0.08535564690828323,
0.44228678941726685,
0.12290334701538086,
-0.2914935350418091,
-0.48108386993408203,
-0.8015875220298767,
0.6997965574264526,
-0.6237625479698181,
0.3692612051963806,
-0.11197219043970108,
0.235195130109787,
0.11335470527410507,
-0.46673035621643066,
-0.5520457029342651,
0.09271826595067978,
0.212776780128479,
0.15046636760234833,
0.36422356963157654,
-0.4169449210166931,
0.16101042926311493,
0.1258080154657364,
-0.7085871696472168,
-0.22522680461406708,
-1.0741530656814575,
-0.4556376039981842,
0.5701249241828918,
0.08475711196660995,
0.41623425483703613,
-0.3958008289337158,
-1.0849640369415283,
-0.05369388312101364,
-0.691464900970459,
0.08931669592857361,
0.5006417632102966,
0.7518057823181152,
-0.12205231189727783,
0.47786998748779297,
0.06785790622234344,
0.4551006257534027,
-0.11053075641393661,
-0.47532105445861816,
0.8211230039596558,
-0.558447539806366,
-0.03261077031493187,
0.13662362098693848,
0.770048975944519,
0.3109993636608124,
0.3858474791049957,
0.14316435158252716,
-0.09568868577480316,
-0.10911084711551666,
-0.07271981239318848,
-0.742675244808197,
0.3602061867713928,
-0.007076744455844164,
-0.12058423459529877,
-0.05922122299671173,
-0.24522361159324646,
-1.1699801683425903,
-0.3310951590538025,
-0.46332958340644836,
0.4415877163410187,
-0.7730589509010315,
-0.42780616879463196,
-0.14049722254276276,
-0.29537007212638855,
0.5501262545585632,
0.3063560426235199,
-0.9364177584648132,
0.21008464694023132,
0.41112202405929565,
0.6431046724319458,
-0.4219484329223633,
-0.6841225028038025,
-0.6588678359985352,
0.10382980108261108,
-0.6406525373458862,
0.4922298491001129,
-0.24012210965156555,
-0.6828338503837585,
0.0064916228875517845,
0.003993927966803312,
-0.15476791560649872,
-0.6111950874328613,
0.4863263964653015,
-0.10724935680627823,
0.084946408867836,
-0.5829739570617676,
-0.3551579415798187,
0.14948973059654236,
-0.13156968355178833,
-0.3375287353992462,
0.948464035987854,
0.09015380591154099,
-0.4233895242214203,
0.06869133561849594,
-0.4382505416870117,
-0.5543960928916931,
0.44656264781951904,
-0.27085205912590027,
-0.11662479490041733,
-0.19302736222743988,
0.009082525968551636,
0.14108183979988098,
-0.28074708580970764,
0.33519288897514343,
-0.013611678034067154,
-0.2802123725414276,
0.08719995617866516,
-0.39541158080101013,
0.9672116041183472,
0.4779900014400482,
-0.30195125937461853,
0.12945042550563812,
-0.8328428864479065,
0.2763004004955292,
0.20585858821868896,
-0.1650862991809845,
0.0709904283285141,
-0.16547611355781555,
0.2875637412071228,
0.24586200714111328,
0.2950785756111145,
-0.6977633237838745,
0.07449894398450851,
-0.40207645297050476,
0.6584889888763428,
0.530811071395874,
0.1395547091960907,
0.3855148255825043,
-0.4045301675796509,
0.527185320854187,
-0.39202308654785156,
0.274241179227829,
-0.27105191349983215,
-0.7885161638259888,
-0.4729568660259247,
-0.43962565064430237,
0.030094405636191368,
1.1460347175598145,
-0.6082780957221985,
-0.054173074662685394,
-0.4588686525821686,
-0.5361864566802979,
-0.4353209137916565,
0.2726700007915497,
0.38556110858917236,
0.1426801234483719,
0.37747225165367126,
-0.29537099599838257,
-0.6623011827468872,
-1.0672799348831177,
-0.1671711802482605,
-0.16812625527381897,
0.10110055655241013,
0.16792304813861847,
0.4144194424152374,
-0.15536227822303772,
1.1069074869155884,
-0.03674692288041115,
-0.6275972723960876,
-0.09325011074542999,
-0.13171382248401642,
-0.029312288388609886,
0.6941322088241577,
0.6194290518760681,
-0.9332525730133057,
-0.7304896712303162,
-0.001133153447881341,
-0.648615300655365,
-0.32493531703948975,
-0.10234394669532776,
0.2806958854198456,
0.08524354547262192,
0.5976059436798096,
-0.5260722637176514,
0.4161777198314667,
0.3960767090320587,
-0.08058604598045349,
0.5439550280570984,
-0.1973383128643036,
0.04330861568450928,
-1.1527236700057983,
0.07479800283908844,
-0.6299264430999756,
-0.3612159788608551,
-0.8693252205848694,
-0.07991283386945724,
-0.11967917531728745,
-0.6081105470657349,
-0.6951723098754883,
0.5483028888702393,
-0.3455430567264557,
-0.4186168909072876,
-0.10101227462291718,
0.0969199612736702,
-0.2777097821235657,
0.4842403531074524,
-0.3769645392894745,
1.0515862703323364,
0.42563027143478394,
-0.2639401853084564,
0.5542569160461426,
0.6932473182678223,
-0.5173899531364441,
0.7899475693702698,
-0.6429975628852844,
0.26362183690071106,
0.09595310688018799,
0.2505946457386017,
-1.214455008506775,
-0.2843298614025116,
0.05753857642412186,
-0.8677528500556946,
0.19137273728847504,
0.15687064826488495,
-0.3460848033428192,
-0.35777077078819275,
-0.3361373543739319,
0.474928617477417,
0.7128968834877014,
-0.5126323103904724,
0.627126157283783,
0.4601180851459503,
-0.7924278378486633,
-0.4964677393436432,
-0.9673731327056885,
0.1832953691482544,
-0.2888486981391907,
-0.43601274490356445,
0.28107723593711853,
-0.5673961639404297,
0.11743886023759842,
-0.2528182566165924,
0.2854921221733093,
-0.03447398543357849,
-0.30753156542778015,
0.0821375921368599,
0.09765391051769257,
0.09511512517929077,
-0.07081283628940582,
0.17904628813266754,
0.08162647485733032,
-0.2032622992992401,
-0.312215656042099,
0.4527788460254669,
-0.2904975712299347,
-0.3562871813774109,
-0.5348961353302002,
0.6542700529098511,
0.9106188416481018,
-0.5343636870384216,
-0.11598329246044159,
0.7191962599754333,
-0.5246092677116394,
-0.32658469676971436,
-0.5037287473678589,
-0.0037277673836797476,
-0.4476664066314697,
0.2784457206726074,
-0.745322585105896,
-0.8929286599159241,
0.6470987796783447,
-0.015585565008223057,
-0.025343867018818855,
0.44361695647239685,
0.8373277187347412,
0.21880125999450684,
0.6372156739234924,
0.3290989398956299,
-0.11286715418100357,
0.32104405760765076,
0.0979052409529686,
0.09946410357952118,
-0.7229780554771423,
-0.3686547875404358,
-0.4707059860229492,
0.2541447579860687,
-0.665192186832428,
-0.6341000199317932,
0.46675074100494385,
-0.2382436990737915,
-0.030341267585754395,
0.5468425154685974,
-0.5445786118507385,
0.2757497727870941,
0.6739708185195923,
-0.10015340149402618,
-0.06579217314720154,
0.17195869982242584,
-0.21643173694610596,
-0.2515420913696289,
-0.4847913980484009,
-0.17103694379329681,
0.7178417444229126,
0.25207656621932983,
0.3152249753475189,
0.31651437282562256,
0.5460668206214905,
0.3651629686355591,
0.07394380122423172,
-0.33505189418792725,
0.6912789940834045,
-0.18338912725448608,
-1.1783853769302368,
-0.5932446718215942,
-0.2530958652496338,
-0.5628207325935364,
0.4065633714199066,
-0.15473826229572296,
-1.1535780429840088,
0.2004464715719223,
-0.1997208595275879,
-0.31007474660873413,
0.15765433013439178,
-0.5858264565467834,
0.5170059204101562,
-0.0917552188038826,
-0.5403876900672913,
-0.12294086813926697,
-1.2391842603683472,
0.2917698621749878,
-0.3134499490261078,
0.6630339622497559,
-0.22157660126686096,
0.5393331050872803,
0.7470334768295288,
-0.37108805775642395,
0.7486420273780823,
-0.1502360701560974,
-0.23153820633888245,
0.6546308994293213,
0.05094173550605774,
0.14244718849658966,
0.08460275828838348,
-0.11099210381507874,
-0.27045169472694397,
0.22845043241977692,
-0.1662430316209793,
-0.05066834017634392,
0.9202758073806763,
-0.6183888912200928,
-0.43034684658050537,
-0.08280204236507416,
-0.7705205082893372,
-0.3539157211780548,
0.46974945068359375,
0.21224398910999298,
0.7677039504051208,
-0.17692986130714417,
0.23036295175552368,
0.5996378660202026,
-0.6041287183761597,
0.45090094208717346,
0.19509653747081757,
-0.3628692924976349,
-0.9558472633361816,
1.3378046751022339,
-0.012171560898423195,
0.5265554785728455,
0.42313152551651,
0.1328725665807724,
-0.35308748483657837,
-0.1295163929462433,
-0.8124034404754639,
0.2245907336473465,
-0.8420170545578003,
-0.042051348835229874,
-0.3792526125907898,
-0.3760640323162079,
-0.7403887510299683,
-0.0033985543996095657,
-0.6516937613487244,
-0.2638372480869293,
-0.1479148119688034,
0.23587849736213684,
-0.03271223604679108,
0.9880483150482178,
-0.4776754081249237,
0.08171914517879486,
-0.6137418150901794,
0.6119866967201233,
0.7687180638313293,
0.35589802265167236,
-0.35301193594932556,
-0.784996509552002,
0.06204976513981819,
0.10647241026163101,
-0.27150312066078186,
-1.0719351768493652,
0.5104165077209473,
0.3090919256210327,
0.49400487542152405,
-0.14137306809425354,
-0.24113735556602478,
0.6466129422187805,
-0.7892104387283325,
1.0446927547454834,
0.2279447317123413,
-1.3692147731781006,
0.4266844093799591,
-0.6720969080924988,
0.26910459995269775,
0.5248399972915649,
-0.09727603197097778,
-0.3172697424888611,
-0.21340219676494598,
-0.1268947571516037,
-0.7233541011810303,
0.6670243740081787,
0.5252997279167175,
0.14027675986289978,
0.26046544313430786,
0.18248432874679565,
0.32017913460731506,
0.06705935299396515,
-0.6940003633499146,
-0.25050127506256104,
-0.21880297362804413,
-0.27519142627716064,
-0.043063364923000336,
-0.40938085317611694,
0.16644613444805145,
-0.20050175487995148,
0.775748610496521,
-0.1727096289396286,
0.2685090899467468,
0.3267882168292999,
0.029061835259199142,
-0.16288751363754272,
0.46881103515625,
1.2401055097579956,
0.6070919632911682,
-0.36349669098854065,
-0.18214932084083557,
0.5280959010124207,
-0.20108173787593842,
0.23442848026752472,
0.28680330514907837,
-0.18424063920974731,
0.26680687069892883,
0.2672719955444336,
1.108871579170227,
0.058998387306928635,
-0.6730387806892395,
0.5339784026145935,
0.06618712842464447,
-0.38232383131980896,
-0.5460341572761536,
-0.4418379068374634,
0.2686214745044708,
0.3223089575767517,
0.6540351510047913,
0.007026345934718847,
0.15459227561950684,
-0.46574458479881287,
0.1682494729757309,
0.35178354382514954,
-0.4225771725177765,
-0.3300001919269562,
0.8537923693656921,
0.34933292865753174,
-0.7463663816452026,
0.09997092932462692,
-0.12265096604824066,
-0.8467132449150085,
0.4296775460243225,
0.620674729347229,
0.440060019493103,
-0.9990577101707458,
-0.014512388035655022,
0.5177624225616455,
0.5268089771270752,
0.005641256924718618,
0.6126439571380615,
0.12320535629987717,
-0.39076825976371765,
-0.25834524631500244,
-0.4447968304157257,
-0.45061323046684265,
0.3126731216907501,
-0.6292115449905396,
0.5295801162719727,
-0.1190970316529274,
-0.08573893457651138,
0.06090512126684189,
-0.35921066999435425,
-0.6371450424194336,
0.3813946843147278,
0.540439784526825,
0.7230826616287231,
-0.827265202999115,
0.7625658512115479,
0.44897714257240295,
0.013664981350302696,
-0.7226352095603943,
-0.5486065149307251,
-0.006931693758815527,
-0.42830613255500793,
0.5567296147346497,
0.1510203778743744,
-0.3008241057395935,
-0.038836222141981125,
-0.328113853931427,
-0.8247644305229187,
0.9313641786575317,
0.3194747567176819,
-0.5457055568695068,
0.09984728693962097,
0.5237486958503723,
0.501181423664093,
-0.4302433431148529,
-0.02735193632543087,
0.19080717861652374,
0.3067755103111267,
-0.11120446771383286,
-1.6732946634292603,
-0.19599339365959167,
-0.35174575448036194,
0.13632920384407043,
-0.2725529968738556,
-0.7212259769439697,
1.0458252429962158,
-0.37175849080085754,
-0.1041758731007576,
0.669040322303772,
0.5362153649330139,
0.35724571347236633,
0.02938193455338478,
0.9457148909568787,
0.22232961654663086,
0.5698534250259399,
0.29725316166877747,
0.6693136096000671,
-0.20459207892417908,
0.4304966628551483,
1.1958128213882446,
-0.6812131404876709,
0.733140766620636,
0.6225613355636597,
-0.159746453166008,
0.2889840602874756,
0.2388293445110321,
0.1150345727801323,
0.6887313723564148,
0.3189053237438202,
0.03813457116484642,
-0.14154063165187836,
-0.18922634422779083,
-0.7052971720695496,
0.7013744115829468,
0.5806822180747986,
-0.03391779586672783,
0.11864364147186279,
0.3884219527244568,
-0.3607919216156006,
-0.04036654159426689,
0.3425999879837036,
0.6888536214828491,
-0.04831979423761368,
-1.0106123685836792,
0.7025325298309326,
-0.03539628908038139,
0.4236704111099243,
-0.8650522232055664,
-0.12277448177337646,
-0.017776543274521828,
0.2690858542919159,
0.2110685110092163,
-0.7527346014976501,
0.1396920531988144,
-0.1125405877828598,
-0.1204943135380745,
-0.41701459884643555,
0.7802734375,
-0.8512095212936401,
-0.17236213386058807,
0.4132447838783264,
0.5430476665496826,
0.24844887852668762,
0.30187860131263733,
-0.3761868178844452,
0.4075176417827606,
0.5369426608085632,
0.056710388511419296,
-0.01325049065053463,
0.2991445064544678,
-0.14055109024047852,
0.708023726940155,
0.5196686387062073,
0.04855486750602722,
0.25425565242767334,
0.17478874325752258,
0.43967193365097046,
-0.4428304135799408,
-0.7370608448982239,
-0.6315650343894958,
0.23835989832878113,
0.09356813132762909,
-0.4819452166557312,
0.6186310052871704,
0.7842272520065308,
0.6287515163421631,
-0.4239306151866913,
1.2923824787139893,
-0.052691951394081116,
1.1111695766448975,
-0.2864968776702881,
0.27969714999198914,
-0.6540903449058533,
0.13140207529067993,
-0.42864400148391724,
-0.7917810082435608,
0.12454282492399216,
0.4799114465713501,
0.27998724579811096,
-0.13694950938224792,
0.6000345349311829,
0.7050027251243591,
0.17519740760326385,
0.20758973062038422,
0.2610340416431427,
0.008779248222708702,
0.5423412322998047,
0.8104455471038818,
1.0357483625411987,
-0.5397652387619019,
0.7041507959365845,
-0.04838399961590767,
-0.22791479527950287,
-0.24865876138210297,
-0.5768300294876099,
-0.7657421827316284,
-0.9975042939186096,
0.04148118197917938,
-0.2669382691383362,
-0.06074047461152077,
0.920022189617157,
0.803963303565979,
-0.6532672047615051,
-0.45762118697166443,
0.3404914140701294,
-0.1246257871389389,
0.10251819342374802,
-0.22065992653369904,
0.16243241727352142,
-0.06087707728147507,
-0.8982425928115845,
0.8435600399971008,
0.3845488429069519,
0.08971406519412994,
-0.3017538785934448,
-0.019595488905906677,
-0.4060114026069641,
0.163604736328125,
0.5372412800788879,
0.2964611351490021,
-0.834197998046875,
-0.4133426547050476,
0.09088838845491409,
-0.11147597432136536,
-0.14419615268707275,
0.6608882546424866,
-0.5270578265190125,
0.6113154888153076,
0.6155588626861572,
0.5287598967552185,
0.5190474390983582,
-0.00039949483470991254,
0.3250483572483063,
-0.787274181842804,
0.4639945924282074,
0.16935856640338898,
0.40189090371131897,
0.8452413082122803,
0.09883380681276321,
0.27181920409202576,
0.6609513759613037,
-0.3368210196495056,
-1.0908769369125366,
0.3167068064212799,
-1.3395973443984985,
-0.2337486445903778,
1.5969510078430176,
0.14738668501377106,
0.11775027960538864,
-0.06453743577003479,
-0.4599027931690216,
0.40826913714408875,
-0.2605903148651123,
0.14055198431015015,
0.5335471630096436,
0.2737026512622833,
0.19312584400177002,
-0.893604576587677,
0.33619678020477295,
0.6240381598472595,
-0.7271402478218079,
-0.0670313909649849,
0.1817706972360611,
0.6133579015731812,
0.5441192984580994,
0.9376326203346252,
-0.17316505312919617,
0.26733559370040894,
-0.08384545892477036,
0.23671765625476837,
0.22745998203754425,
-0.5552563071250916,
0.029353518038988113,
0.1324607878923416,
-0.13777410984039307,
-0.209699347615242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15812v1 | Intrinsic Dimension Correlation: uncovering nonlinear connections in multimodal representations | 2024-06-22T10:36:04 | 2024-06-22T10:36:04 | Lorenzo Basile, Santiago Acevedo, Luca Bortolussi, Fabio Anselmi, Alex Rodriguez | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | To gain insight into the mechanisms behind machine learning methods, it is
crucial to establish connections among the features describing data points.
However, these correlations often exhibit a high-dimensional and strongly
nonlinear nature, which makes them challenging to detect using standard
methods. This paper exploits the entanglement between intrinsic dimensionality
and correlation to propose a metric that quantifies the (potentially nonlinear)
correlation between high-dimensional manifolds. We first validate our method on
synthetic data in controlled environments, showcasing its advantages and
drawbacks compared to existing techniques. Subsequently, we extend our analysis
to large-scale applications in neural network representations. Specifically, we
focus on latent representations of multimodal data, uncovering clear
correlations between paired visual and textual embeddings, whereas existing
methods struggle significantly in detecting similarity. Our results indicate
the presence of highly nonlinear correlation patterns between latent manifolds. | [
-0.4129229187965393,
-1.001054048538208,
0.43645673990249634,
0.20952557027339935,
0.03662179410457611,
0.126606747508049,
0.1257336437702179,
-0.41077783703804016,
0.6368380188941956,
0.12236320972442627,
-0.20749644935131073,
-0.13440674543380737,
-0.5229625701904297,
-0.16136853396892548,
-0.3755989372730255,
0.6790592670440674,
-0.15220524370670319,
-0.023648109287023544,
-0.8528509736061096,
-0.3323732018470764,
-0.2378644198179245,
-0.7909594774246216,
-0.5295170545578003,
-0.10128491371870041,
0.8550368547439575,
-0.3368167579174042,
0.43019551038742065,
0.36880311369895935,
1.0490812063217163,
0.3352176547050476,
-0.11957569420337677,
0.5085346102714539,
-0.32161983847618103,
0.41849878430366516,
0.011360564269125462,
-0.6333616971969604,
-0.5059173703193665,
0.06240909546613693,
0.86803138256073,
0.7886413931846619,
0.6049485802650452,
0.18027245998382568,
0.22036683559417725,
0.6259722113609314,
-0.6246026754379272,
0.24968554079532623,
-0.281655490398407,
0.63334721326828,
-0.3594795763492584,
-0.6230595111846924,
-0.06512314081192017,
-0.12706327438354492,
0.08819670230150223,
-0.3961450159549713,
0.24534399807453156,
0.03152276948094368,
0.7635623812675476,
0.43474969267845154,
-1.05166757106781,
-0.20408494770526886,
-0.8535488247871399,
0.8012717366218567,
-0.35260817408561707,
0.5451321005821228,
0.47007012367248535,
0.17035754024982452,
-0.0922708734869957,
-0.5555651783943176,
-0.6911340355873108,
-0.2208828330039978,
-0.2231384813785553,
0.25035059452056885,
-0.047205600887537,
-0.27426525950431824,
0.1687706559896469,
0.2374163717031479,
-0.5410019159317017,
0.029865087941288948,
-0.021608928218483925,
-0.27715864777565,
0.30058249831199646,
0.3965683877468109,
0.1445963829755783,
-0.1716499775648117,
-0.4670087993144989,
-0.17658904194831848,
-0.5228172540664673,
0.2635984718799591,
0.5329797267913818,
0.20583079755306244,
-0.4004743993282318,
0.7317195534706116,
0.4381695091724396,
0.5138470530509949,
0.06383484601974487,
-0.22908076643943787,
0.34040361642837524,
-0.5099350810050964,
0.3424910604953766,
-0.22129060328006744,
0.7593765258789062,
0.154157355427742,
-0.22005753219127655,
-0.20293131470680237,
0.048627011477947235,
-0.08122747391462326,
0.14973919093608856,
-0.6385717988014221,
-0.1968325823545456,
0.08282002806663513,
-0.8020231127738953,
-0.35431957244873047,
0.28392690420150757,
-0.7412633299827576,
-0.5235945582389832,
-0.6311981081962585,
0.6676881909370422,
-0.2524144947528839,
-0.24673166871070862,
-0.4635835886001587,
-0.1941499561071396,
-0.13076043128967285,
0.17455318570137024,
-0.7381247282028198,
0.023108990862965584,
0.5770213603973389,
1.2192974090576172,
-0.24374988675117493,
-0.24827063083648682,
-0.38248297572135925,
0.24067632853984833,
-0.5435348153114319,
0.5488793253898621,
-0.697022557258606,
-0.09337154775857925,
-0.2667970657348633,
0.0014753470895811915,
0.37071019411087036,
-0.5134371519088745,
0.2607928216457367,
-0.4092331826686859,
-0.13573774695396423,
0.009602298028767109,
-0.4148271977901459,
-0.18488380312919617,
0.2247951179742813,
-0.7366322875022888,
0.7852680087089539,
0.008821969851851463,
-0.9030138850212097,
0.39461901783943176,
-0.41574883460998535,
-0.24628399312496185,
-0.32013359665870667,
-0.30703896284103394,
-0.7302142977714539,
0.3775492310523987,
0.14308808743953705,
0.6006924510002136,
-0.1997431069612503,
0.09174242615699768,
-0.7694768309593201,
-0.14462408423423767,
0.665988564491272,
-0.6602334976196289,
0.5005567669868469,
-0.1665952205657959,
-0.004879225045442581,
0.026596440002322197,
-0.6772170066833496,
-0.19629216194152832,
-0.2081056386232376,
-0.08008869737386703,
-0.528796911239624,
0.04752581566572189,
-0.19824539124965668,
0.22968435287475586,
0.5311038494110107,
-0.28767240047454834,
0.12004999071359634,
0.14048808813095093,
0.4323118031024933,
0.8187585473060608,
0.16105793416500092,
0.45227134227752686,
-0.16141240298748016,
0.2251649796962738,
0.825974702835083,
-0.10679389536380768,
-0.19704143702983856,
-0.4649815857410431,
-0.6480369567871094,
-0.4346393644809723,
0.2760255038738251,
0.120914526283741,
-0.7269894480705261,
0.7013686895370483,
-0.2684682011604309,
-0.35769543051719666,
-0.22151166200637817,
0.0023841215297579765,
0.0542103573679924,
0.395261287689209,
0.3838520646095276,
-0.2622232437133789,
-0.33634546399116516,
-1.0211119651794434,
0.0003532303380779922,
-0.018234679475426674,
-0.19698253273963928,
0.7363556623458862,
0.7508534789085388,
-0.34488382935523987,
0.9203701019287109,
-0.42712438106536865,
-0.557487428188324,
0.6628038883209229,
0.4919866621494293,
0.3712303638458252,
0.8416274785995483,
0.7334321737289429,
-0.9214167594909668,
-0.709900438785553,
0.30058059096336365,
-1.2563831806182861,
0.3910669982433319,
-0.26179009675979614,
-0.15414460003376007,
-0.14469477534294128,
0.45800164341926575,
-0.1789385974407196,
0.6122273802757263,
0.5761024951934814,
-0.3539230525493622,
0.49532464146614075,
-0.4960234463214874,
0.17134426534175873,
-0.9071347117424011,
0.24381901323795319,
0.2403300404548645,
-0.0932866781949997,
-0.38300517201423645,
-0.13348627090454102,
0.14730101823806763,
-0.27716344594955444,
0.11059705913066864,
0.3133656978607178,
-0.33111298084259033,
-0.1730133295059204,
0.20943064987659454,
0.09552015364170074,
0.0027038089465349913,
0.564009428024292,
-0.21253949403762817,
0.7760452628135681,
0.8958110809326172,
-0.4865425229072571,
0.6289601922035217,
0.37560567259788513,
0.05408749729394913,
0.9687344431877136,
-0.7714580297470093,
0.06125776097178459,
-0.26131168007850647,
0.3476567566394806,
-0.8926738500595093,
-0.12993308901786804,
-0.3496279716491699,
-0.782659649848938,
0.37816062569618225,
-0.08582084625959396,
-0.6321980357170105,
-0.03032868169248104,
-0.3574378490447998,
0.6070131659507751,
0.03780130669474602,
-0.6015908122062683,
0.7621756196022034,
0.4308207929134369,
0.20696604251861572,
-0.29314494132995605,
-0.8896427750587463,
-0.019473591819405556,
-0.38460496068000793,
-0.6428812742233276,
0.3546321392059326,
0.18522638082504272,
0.04480719938874245,
0.03964487463235855,
-0.014247064478695393,
-0.1820162981748581,
-0.02970125526189804,
0.47619226574897766,
0.22838236391544342,
-0.40001147985458374,
0.1903352588415146,
0.025314029306173325,
-0.22486746311187744,
0.17978519201278687,
-0.4640498459339142,
0.4940098226070404,
-0.24344979226589203,
-0.4917660653591156,
-0.610407829284668,
0.4456052780151367,
0.8301785588264465,
-0.2560698091983795,
0.8834037184715271,
1.1030025482177734,
-0.44581139087677,
0.12201797217130661,
-0.07408519834280014,
-0.16466833651065826,
-0.5102151036262512,
0.4209282398223877,
-0.40642401576042175,
-0.5144190192222595,
0.7875263094902039,
-0.13437151908874512,
-0.492779403924942,
0.17470474541187286,
0.34681937098503113,
-0.42175936698913574,
1.2220275402069092,
0.47451019287109375,
0.00067440903512761,
0.49031177163124084,
-0.5784673690795898,
0.7647186517715454,
-1.232559323310852,
-0.6459450721740723,
-0.26875099539756775,
-0.8370360732078552,
-0.8624995350837708,
-0.5062873959541321,
0.9166122078895569,
0.36443862318992615,
-0.42079615592956543,
0.13146013021469116,
-0.1821252852678299,
0.17307601869106293,
0.5767814517021179,
0.4359264075756073,
-0.012557761743664742,
0.17900358140468597,
-0.34893709421157837,
-0.4019833207130432,
-0.2609766721725464,
-0.13860321044921875,
1.0981446504592896,
0.3412826657295227,
0.5458757281303406,
0.5247887969017029,
0.354956716299057,
0.2737809121608734,
-0.3463898003101349,
-0.6917715668678284,
0.2896760404109955,
-0.4659867286682129,
-0.1823311448097229,
-0.07905644178390503,
-0.916111409664154,
-0.9145641326904297,
-0.01161978580057621,
-0.667803168296814,
-0.7925666570663452,
0.5062727928161621,
0.2294911891222,
-0.022912923246622086,
0.524249255657196,
-0.5677183270454407,
0.38361355662345886,
-0.27568021416664124,
-0.8287439942359924,
-0.1794876605272293,
-0.42962032556533813,
0.027148587629199028,
-0.15615656971931458,
-0.2958238422870636,
0.3025270104408264,
-0.23619385063648224,
0.5651830434799194,
-0.17213404178619385,
0.7505766153335571,
-0.012269040569663048,
-0.040612053126096725,
-0.0860515683889389,
0.507118284702301,
0.2765529751777649,
0.3444191515445709,
0.2325303554534912,
0.32762107253074646,
-0.24236498773097992,
-0.5670170783996582,
-0.91800856590271,
1.109494924545288,
-1.0021498203277588,
-0.06324152648448944,
-0.25485959649086,
-0.7485896348953247,
-0.42416730523109436,
-0.08817974478006363,
-0.07737178355455399,
0.8778635263442993,
0.32427269220352173,
0.7303499579429626,
0.4385966360569,
-0.20563843846321106,
0.3501364290714264,
-0.09620131552219391,
-0.22868852317333221,
-0.3672935366630554,
1.4656864404678345,
0.1632412225008011,
-0.038353048264980316,
0.619089663028717,
0.18397830426692963,
-0.2209816575050354,
-0.1856735497713089,
0.04082172363996506,
0.3284881114959717,
-0.356209397315979,
-0.1192883551120758,
-0.5000878572463989,
-0.3055228888988495,
-0.1484135538339615,
-0.2853080928325653,
-0.2037634700536728,
-0.5068626403808594,
-0.614031195640564,
0.25225549936294556,
0.1566588431596756,
0.6836570501327515,
-0.2480843961238861,
0.06160901114344597,
-0.6985349655151367,
0.25471681356430054,
0.45100316405296326,
0.3157205283641815,
0.4323280453681946,
-0.24165350198745728,
-0.354044109582901,
0.2125186324119568,
-0.5819167494773865,
-0.3333417773246765,
0.5863981246948242,
0.3595837354660034,
0.5294414162635803,
0.9153050780296326,
-0.2681732475757599,
0.8372883200645447,
-0.2554323375225067,
1.0320854187011719,
0.46342042088508606,
-0.8632588982582092,
0.47632795572280884,
-0.44181427359580994,
-0.11337050050497055,
-0.13125690817832947,
0.9654776453971863,
-0.18230977654457092,
-0.17266269028186798,
-0.5359001755714417,
-0.7105731964111328,
0.06405333429574966,
0.3310869038105011,
0.06132795289158821,
0.13577362895011902,
0.10016019642353058,
0.07181853801012039,
0.22026072442531586,
-0.37600117921829224,
-0.3109287917613983,
-0.24589551985263824,
-0.04733691364526749,
-0.10156621783971786,
0.09345449507236481,
-0.13767582178115845,
-0.4386166036128998,
-0.12966203689575195,
-0.2956816852092743,
0.9585745930671692,
0.06920349597930908,
-0.032739296555519104,
0.17845311760902405,
-0.7458651065826416,
0.616589367389679,
0.6014216542243958,
-0.19475057721138,
0.6872931122779846,
-0.19271278381347656,
-0.46380987763404846,
-0.04379639774560928,
-0.45075368881225586,
0.2261895388364792,
-0.02390287257730961,
0.8707866668701172,
0.7272276878356934,
-0.23158395290374756,
-0.1115994080901146,
0.5000680685043335,
0.03720317780971527,
0.04992249235510826,
-0.3556671440601349,
-0.2222851812839508,
-0.16037292778491974,
0.34404486417770386,
0.33791598677635193,
0.6903489828109741,
-0.03862540423870087,
-0.6418105959892273,
0.2824143171310425,
0.4990406334400177,
-0.8520141839981079,
-0.831299901008606,
0.43017148971557617,
0.1803630292415619,
-0.3476669192314148,
0.7472699284553528,
0.07367180287837982,
-0.5984119176864624,
0.6838018894195557,
0.43030858039855957,
0.5948489308357239,
0.16110137104988098,
0.13129916787147522,
0.5258389711380005,
-0.13472966849803925,
0.5922346711158752,
0.05786573141813278,
-0.20108604431152344,
-0.7147645354270935,
-0.15425744652748108,
-0.39813563227653503,
-0.10201399028301239,
-0.07482961565256119,
-0.6844154596328735,
-0.004663508385419846,
-0.5951104164123535,
-0.32473549246788025,
0.08363841474056244,
-0.14008159935474396,
-0.6520019769668579,
-0.4122394323348999,
-0.0936354473233223,
0.1909392774105072,
-0.8700714111328125,
0.5216113328933716,
0.3895322382450104,
-0.5922699570655823,
-0.22685396671295166,
0.11536920815706253,
0.3395371437072754,
-0.43774083256721497,
1.327957034111023,
0.009084105491638184,
-0.06608133018016815,
-0.3585997223854065,
-0.5746992230415344,
-1.0085757970809937,
1.082265019416809,
0.11737881600856781,
-0.1001938208937645,
0.06951495260000229,
0.24910889565944672,
0.6792663931846619,
-0.3015577495098114,
0.4694086015224457,
0.03859829157590866,
0.29677924513816833,
-0.11987854540348053,
-0.6336286664009094,
-0.1626855880022049,
-0.4254996180534363,
0.19190925359725952,
0.4367436170578003,
-0.5990327596664429,
1.3157190084457397,
0.121106818318367,
-0.11325448751449585,
-0.18120267987251282,
0.7190750241279602,
-0.04801904410123825,
0.05189603194594383,
0.233543261885643,
0.5910977721214294,
0.7940029501914978,
-0.13963322341442108,
0.6463466286659241,
-0.463318407535553,
0.6273334622383118,
0.7651711702346802,
-0.10490825772285461,
0.7957133650779724,
0.7681689858436584,
-0.3472635746002197,
0.4990459978580475,
0.2803241014480591,
-0.017594609409570694,
0.41318216919898987,
0.014691077172756195,
-0.2111881673336029,
-0.13410577178001404,
-0.3114054501056671,
-0.3991158902645111,
0.3766322135925293,
0.7189871668815613,
-0.2213142067193985,
0.07965968549251556,
0.17263595759868622,
-0.5466726422309875,
-0.11305440962314606,
-0.07224404811859131,
0.62081378698349,
0.06484793871641159,
0.0795714408159256,
0.4349104166030884,
-0.6378793120384216,
0.8602052927017212,
-0.45970895886421204,
-0.3643268048763275,
-0.18469633162021637,
0.28845497965812683,
-0.35710400342941284,
-0.844444751739502,
0.4003543257713318,
-0.43478649854660034,
-0.2582932412624359,
-0.1622927337884903,
0.27520307898521423,
-0.333718866109848,
-0.28290611505508423,
0.38878560066223145,
0.2561778724193573,
-0.051624272018671036,
0.25002288818359375,
-0.3818680942058563,
-0.24285592138767242,
-0.3176235258579254,
0.1498519480228424,
0.45242950320243835,
0.844993531703949,
0.09076759219169617,
0.8202396631240845,
1.0498234033584595,
0.3594418168067932,
0.18099483847618103,
-0.26277148723602295,
0.8345907926559448,
-0.5199140906333923,
-0.37989944219589233,
-0.4978744685649872,
0.46405893564224243,
-0.33254313468933105,
-0.5190218091011047,
0.7733978033065796,
0.5756129026412964,
0.6722499132156372,
-0.15185418725013733,
0.23613190650939941,
0.08362188190221786,
0.15064868330955505,
-0.462259978055954,
0.5518600344657898,
-0.8142706751823425,
0.11152611672878265,
-0.023970412090420723,
-1.0366331338882446,
-0.4494340717792511,
0.8498089909553528,
-0.09149032086133957,
-0.1381744146347046,
0.9693821668624878,
0.9793316721916199,
-0.4416419267654419,
-0.24800945818424225,
0.43004027009010315,
0.3153255879878998,
0.6036465167999268,
0.279512882232666,
0.8611469268798828,
-0.2992796301841736,
0.049754541367292404,
-0.26819485425949097,
-0.2595362067222595,
-0.26515209674835205,
-0.8233322501182556,
-1.0108758211135864,
-1.163347840309143,
-0.17529051005840302,
-0.35797253251075745,
-0.4819115400314331,
0.6119269728660583,
0.9162218570709229,
-0.7899830341339111,
-0.09062021970748901,
-0.034274157136678696,
-0.029850522056221962,
-0.33600422739982605,
-0.24911825358867645,
0.532486617565155,
-0.13699884712696075,
-0.5709857940673828,
0.06530705839395523,
0.4023374319076538,
0.3129587173461914,
-0.8080762624740601,
0.1322464644908905,
-0.06584593653678894,
-0.0659889280796051,
0.8356008529663086,
-0.08988820761442184,
-0.4451891779899597,
-0.24830159544944763,
-0.0687916949391365,
0.023035109043121338,
0.07378622144460678,
1.0825762748718262,
-0.7245770692825317,
0.46519798040390015,
1.0874680280685425,
0.6247663497924805,
0.6292587518692017,
-0.3425467610359192,
0.5572253465652466,
-1.050800085067749,
0.4042411744594574,
0.36038947105407715,
0.5069985389709473,
0.13685178756713867,
-0.3636340796947479,
0.22877183556556702,
0.1779240518808365,
-0.6403464674949646,
-0.7712069749832153,
0.27928176522254944,
-1.2817167043685913,
-0.01782907173037529,
0.6345515251159668,
-0.37174129486083984,
-0.24171535670757294,
-0.010488945059478283,
0.18876038491725922,
-0.12049143761396408,
-0.16992907226085663,
0.786827564239502,
0.39955466985702515,
-0.34464895725250244,
0.10487320274114609,
-0.3589341938495636,
0.033629775047302246,
0.15357136726379395,
-0.6832384467124939,
-0.4015255570411682,
0.03573374077677727,
-0.3122527003288269,
0.8605095148086548,
-0.3075757622718811,
-0.129945769906044,
-0.1938072293996811,
0.373325377702713,
-0.5120463967323303,
-0.1901986002922058,
-0.7591160535812378,
-0.2269858568906784,
0.1835547536611557,
-0.45228636264801025,
-0.0932597741484642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15809v1 | LaMSUM: A Novel Framework for Extractive Summarization of User Generated Content using LLMs | 2024-06-22T10:25:55 | 2024-06-22T10:25:55 | Garima Chhikara, Anurag Sharma, V. Gurucharan, Kripabandhu Ghosh, Abhijnan Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance across
a wide range of NLP tasks, including summarization. Inherently LLMs produce
abstractive summaries, and the task of achieving extractive summaries through
LLMs still remains largely unexplored. To bridge this gap, in this work, we
propose a novel framework LaMSUM to generate extractive summaries through LLMs
for large user-generated text by leveraging voting algorithms. Our evaluation
on three popular open-source LLMs (Llama 3, Mixtral and Gemini) reveal that the
LaMSUM outperforms state-of-the-art extractive summarization methods. We
further attempt to provide the rationale behind the output summary produced by
LLMs. Overall, this is one of the early attempts to achieve extractive
summarization for large user-generated text by utilizing LLMs, and likely to
generate further interest in the community. | [
-0.32250213623046875,
-0.4183451533317566,
0.5240787267684937,
0.32468029856681824,
-0.6053839921951294,
0.0041471510194242,
-0.28141382336616516,
-0.20021307468414307,
0.6783087253570557,
0.9425880908966064,
-0.4279386103153229,
-0.7687128782272339,
-0.6892358064651489,
0.14259213209152222,
-0.7366663813591003,
1.0140355825424194,
0.038260724395513535,
-0.3018950819969177,
-0.21809113025665283,
0.09772250056266785,
-0.1558428853750229,
-0.5977547764778137,
-0.3574446439743042,
-0.4177170991897583,
0.7105446457862854,
0.7177304029464722,
0.35591521859169006,
0.666234016418457,
0.6357704997062683,
0.2694953382015228,
-0.0931374803185463,
0.5589907169342041,
-0.5537293553352356,
0.26158639788627625,
-0.046575576066970825,
-0.3087409734725952,
-0.5184758901596069,
-0.024097802117466927,
0.7315434217453003,
0.4827023148536682,
-0.3481711149215698,
0.2783167064189911,
0.03074800595641136,
0.8472070693969727,
-0.6400027275085449,
0.13340537250041962,
-0.7252857089042664,
-0.0879010260105133,
-0.5591069459915161,
-0.41476890444755554,
-0.2798755466938019,
-0.33758264780044556,
-0.30018728971481323,
-0.16752682626247406,
-0.11225361377000809,
0.009115231223404408,
0.7023105025291443,
-0.029769951477646828,
-0.3868096172809601,
-0.6153445839881897,
-0.5460173487663269,
0.7812360525131226,
-1.2345926761627197,
-0.08382503688335419,
0.07375705987215042,
0.2553984522819519,
0.04577396810054779,
-1.0784631967544556,
-0.7285120487213135,
0.09959657490253448,
-0.0003434931277297437,
0.274365097284317,
0.1378900706768036,
-0.3292580246925354,
-0.1493377834558487,
0.7277131676673889,
-0.3021872937679291,
0.5188363194465637,
-0.36691659688949585,
0.04402065649628639,
0.70448899269104,
0.5681029558181763,
0.22883708775043488,
-0.46719029545783997,
-0.6615545749664307,
0.20253926515579224,
-1.2034738063812256,
-0.09143482148647308,
0.15534168481826782,
0.3199296295642853,
-0.1743459701538086,
0.9872074723243713,
-0.28206968307495117,
0.42226770520210266,
-0.41118815541267395,
-0.22823064029216766,
0.13362111151218414,
-0.14128275215625763,
-0.16708093881607056,
-0.11384167522192001,
1.0879546403884888,
0.5914015769958496,
0.16416537761688232,
-0.047840338200330734,
-0.397440642118454,
-0.44121935963630676,
-0.16203175485134125,
-1.1897807121276855,
-0.045304715633392334,
0.4532073438167572,
-0.7996436953544617,
-0.5714112520217896,
0.5357047915458679,
-0.9165955781936646,
-0.5391331911087036,
-0.1537030190229416,
0.04079166799783707,
0.07774174958467484,
-0.24290229380130768,
-0.003105088835582137,
-0.22905433177947998,
0.13655418157577515,
0.632125735282898,
-1.093890905380249,
0.37817665934562683,
1.1267229318618774,
1.0524022579193115,
-0.8745748400688171,
-0.18104475736618042,
-0.7010679244995117,
0.10314348340034485,
-0.30587124824523926,
0.8580846190452576,
-0.23370791971683502,
-0.34529808163642883,
0.07839865982532501,
-0.16152742505073547,
0.3056718707084656,
-0.8471077084541321,
0.144473135471344,
-0.792111873626709,
0.3584138751029968,
-0.24343474209308624,
-0.6508844494819641,
-0.18877965211868286,
-0.07958294451236725,
-0.7345865964889526,
0.9388726949691772,
-0.0741206631064415,
-0.6975246667861938,
0.13293354213237762,
-0.6587601900100708,
-0.4936230480670929,
0.2965335249900818,
-0.05588880926370621,
-0.2562287449836731,
0.1752922236919403,
0.27285856008529663,
0.8659418821334839,
-0.4301527440547943,
0.21704553067684174,
-0.09708771854639053,
-0.38302507996559143,
0.5077623128890991,
-0.2284143716096878,
0.863412618637085,
0.32543912529945374,
-0.07430978864431381,
0.27056068181991577,
-0.48415976762771606,
-0.2835768461227417,
0.21610623598098755,
-0.5179175734519958,
-0.16950774192810059,
0.2645702064037323,
0.04535217210650444,
0.04865042492747307,
0.4680790305137634,
-0.43487924337387085,
-0.048743437975645065,
-0.3937665820121765,
0.28990593552589417,
0.8996193408966064,
0.1715158075094223,
0.30309584736824036,
-0.4655749797821045,
0.42416104674339294,
-0.2802926003932953,
-0.4661106467247009,
-0.6195638179779053,
-0.3810506761074066,
-0.437016099691391,
-0.5905991792678833,
0.3606925904750824,
0.4755743443965912,
-0.4710589051246643,
0.3251660466194153,
-0.32763826847076416,
-0.5673139095306396,
-0.11699707061052322,
0.6984378099441528,
0.04540324956178665,
0.4185947775840759,
-0.03283083066344261,
-0.30544158816337585,
-0.5816385746002197,
-0.5808533430099487,
0.0555708110332489,
-0.25283578038215637,
-0.48484253883361816,
0.2745756506919861,
0.5001214742660522,
-0.18171235918998718,
0.9175013899803162,
-0.8598688840866089,
-0.5636032819747925,
-0.6305948495864868,
0.2391139268875122,
0.5727502107620239,
0.0999360978603363,
0.35597577691078186,
-0.7073500156402588,
-0.27582448720932007,
-0.05744735151529312,
-0.8298519849777222,
-0.5660330057144165,
-0.13523806631565094,
0.05364004150032997,
-0.006281668785959482,
0.6122601628303528,
-0.5140818357467651,
-0.006383571773767471,
0.6077291369438171,
0.07479693740606308,
0.7584362626075745,
0.036984339356422424,
-0.13178178668022156,
-1.3290071487426758,
0.2933514416217804,
-0.2831057906150818,
-0.6313030123710632,
-0.24493278563022614,
0.20440411567687988,
-0.1016375720500946,
0.016218489035964012,
-0.5829038023948669,
0.6057878136634827,
-0.3217778205871582,
-0.28439345955848694,
-0.6057407259941101,
0.622214674949646,
0.0036754105240106583,
0.3538531959056854,
0.19988147914409637,
0.7665349245071411,
-0.06736459583044052,
-0.5106520652770996,
0.38157397508621216,
0.25139856338500977,
-0.4427308142185211,
0.18896260857582092,
-0.7807063460350037,
-0.16029013693332672,
-0.0217655710875988,
0.24091537296772003,
-0.8328016996383667,
-0.49307358264923096,
-0.06711961328983307,
-0.32538971304893494,
0.02903701923787594,
0.29230427742004395,
-0.4240623116493225,
-0.1659982055425644,
-0.5603734254837036,
-0.10194623470306396,
0.4823119044303894,
-0.580944299697876,
0.7030574679374695,
0.9633498191833496,
-0.6988922953605652,
-0.41424769163131714,
-0.5478924512863159,
0.4288080036640167,
-0.34012553095817566,
-0.3346569836139679,
0.3921716511249542,
-0.0367363840341568,
-0.5726357698440552,
-0.051935695111751556,
0.1740477979183197,
0.1892041265964508,
0.2107389271259308,
0.30359816551208496,
0.24422587454319,
-0.2054678499698639,
-0.028706377372145653,
-0.09276503324508667,
-0.1194603219628334,
0.17959320545196533,
-0.04769506677985191,
0.6514931917190552,
-0.09283210337162018,
-0.3484278619289398,
-0.24865517020225525,
0.5860689878463745,
0.5918424129486084,
-0.2288670390844345,
0.4298778176307678,
0.5738484859466553,
-0.31326350569725037,
-0.5319867730140686,
-0.4475908875465393,
-0.048259999603033066,
-0.47186559438705444,
0.4723789691925049,
0.09071368724107742,
-1.0752589702606201,
0.6556979417800903,
-0.3659534454345703,
0.5252448916435242,
0.7263316512107849,
1.144309401512146,
-0.33243295550346375,
0.7583372592926025,
0.4951232075691223,
-0.12675611674785614,
0.43800243735313416,
-0.07795507460832596,
-0.26210349798202515,
-0.8856993913650513,
-0.2339697927236557,
-0.5134422183036804,
-0.1366731822490692,
-0.2668912708759308,
-0.20956458151340485,
0.2987922132015228,
-0.008837922476232052,
0.0919356420636177,
0.12348881363868713,
-0.11786223948001862,
0.49050354957580566,
0.5517882108688354,
-0.10883833467960358,
0.4171569347381592,
0.07134589552879333,
0.08521170914173126,
0.03740432858467102,
-0.409767210483551,
-0.7214598059654236,
0.9712240695953369,
0.2612156271934509,
0.6355084180831909,
0.4402102828025818,
1.0208051204681396,
0.7022458910942078,
0.6649724245071411,
-0.6854437589645386,
0.7349755764007568,
-0.49703285098075867,
-0.309257447719574,
-0.2983035147190094,
-0.6687088012695312,
-0.9696256518363953,
0.4824187457561493,
-0.16179676353931427,
-0.7523705363273621,
-0.2553129494190216,
-0.17945729196071625,
-0.07492361217737198,
0.42081499099731445,
-0.2936131954193115,
0.4163054823875427,
-0.284778356552124,
-0.16416749358177185,
-0.2181306928396225,
-0.5666012167930603,
0.670063853263855,
-0.25984063744544983,
0.3665607273578644,
-0.3460760712623596,
-0.32734858989715576,
1.0664516687393188,
-0.6743097305297852,
0.944595992565155,
-0.06608743220567703,
-0.2992997169494629,
0.4458174705505371,
0.2007310837507248,
0.39830219745635986,
0.2751741111278534,
-0.19639885425567627,
0.21764348447322845,
-0.3411461412906647,
-0.16553671658039093,
-0.508060872554779,
0.7678245902061462,
-0.4790831506252289,
-0.642570436000824,
-0.2999393939971924,
-0.5322033762931824,
0.21348536014556885,
0.42165160179138184,
-0.05727002024650574,
0.49380460381507874,
-0.16236437857151031,
0.3894332945346832,
0.20613086223602295,
-0.004964644089341164,
0.7560986280441284,
0.4724506139755249,
-0.6965586543083191,
-0.8891733884811401,
1.1335153579711914,
-0.2566032409667969,
0.17631638050079346,
0.5646250247955322,
0.42604440450668335,
-0.255293607711792,
-0.8001667261123657,
-0.37423673272132874,
0.3885192275047302,
-0.7893498539924622,
-0.322825163602829,
-0.569433331489563,
-0.2825942635536194,
-0.19032356142997742,
-0.32389140129089355,
-0.18233820796012878,
-0.7588727474212646,
-0.602181613445282,
-0.0576770082116127,
-0.09677323698997498,
1.1804395914077759,
-0.09080678969621658,
0.3409486413002014,
-0.9580302834510803,
0.3247848451137543,
0.36735308170318604,
-0.07494760304689407,
0.10524694621562958,
-0.27588269114494324,
-0.2006107121706009,
-0.2690225839614868,
-0.1280784010887146,
-0.8968958854675293,
0.786217451095581,
0.16341978311538696,
0.3608914911746979,
0.6246849894523621,
0.05625828355550766,
0.37441685795783997,
-0.16313356161117554,
1.2135546207427979,
0.3715583384037018,
-0.8360113501548767,
0.18123845756053925,
-0.2577255070209503,
0.384143203496933,
0.5235898494720459,
0.09380779415369034,
-0.5658443570137024,
-0.35116514563560486,
-0.2891460359096527,
-1.0974681377410889,
0.4634091258049011,
0.17564132809638977,
0.17299290001392365,
0.01980329491198063,
0.13568148016929626,
0.42904937267303467,
0.4153345823287964,
-0.7485380172729492,
0.011988883838057518,
0.021169105544686317,
-0.30937251448631287,
-0.10132288187742233,
-0.4868864119052887,
-0.08397451788187027,
0.34919339418411255,
0.6690819263458252,
-0.16888029873371124,
-0.19822539389133453,
0.1263289898633957,
-0.21973872184753418,
0.13065017759799957,
0.10836917906999588,
0.6962552070617676,
0.5775102376937866,
-0.33889758586883545,
0.4476320147514343,
0.2349005788564682,
-0.37030521035194397,
-0.27071377635002136,
-0.13265255093574524,
-0.3900316059589386,
-0.09966443479061127,
0.7023652195930481,
0.4488137364387512,
0.06485423445701599,
-0.9581969380378723,
0.6673057079315186,
-0.1271456927061081,
-0.11952996999025345,
-0.3225758969783783,
0.0035022012889385223,
0.31856048107147217,
0.08546208590269089,
0.6508975625038147,
-0.01104096882045269,
0.015035586431622505,
-0.24627703428268433,
0.3091532289981842,
0.41428235173225403,
-0.21023964881896973,
-0.24524062871932983,
0.6720866560935974,
0.3042909502983093,
-0.2822265326976776,
0.31768590211868286,
0.009202628396451473,
-0.4789196252822876,
0.45530515909194946,
0.6452044248580933,
0.827596127986908,
0.2198818176984787,
0.2571936845779419,
0.16499218344688416,
0.0994165688753128,
0.04364309087395668,
0.30523988604545593,
-0.3138260841369629,
-0.5987712740898132,
-0.5661554336547852,
-0.7713354825973511,
-0.70187908411026,
-0.0806189477443695,
-0.28657540678977966,
0.2579832375049591,
-0.29050466418266296,
0.11606432497501373,
-0.16117669641971588,
0.03837883099913597,
-0.030623720958828926,
-0.0441889688372612,
0.3360349237918854,
0.8496115207672119,
-0.5939235687255859,
0.33186668157577515,
0.2766241133213043,
-0.2069418728351593,
-0.47944921255111694,
-0.2819369435310364,
0.06449895352125168,
-0.7109934091567993,
0.47688940167427063,
0.1973837912082672,
-0.1195126622915268,
-0.11342662572860718,
-0.4897458553314209,
-0.6349462866783142,
1.2269331216812134,
0.1800931692123413,
-0.3313593864440918,
-0.04520205408334732,
0.11588338017463684,
0.2377454936504364,
-0.882971465587616,
0.25087815523147583,
0.08738341182470322,
0.30700963735580444,
0.33937251567840576,
-0.4042448401451111,
0.14166247844696045,
-0.3383778929710388,
-0.20641009509563446,
-0.1361244171857834,
-0.5781077742576599,
0.9147024154663086,
-0.36503976583480835,
-0.36623576283454895,
0.10793904215097427,
1.0778133869171143,
0.4845469892024994,
0.3166572153568268,
0.3932705223560333,
0.24371017515659332,
0.9352982044219971,
0.06201968714594841,
1.1871798038482666,
-0.07005713135004044,
0.09000954777002335,
1.168723225593567,
-0.5628218054771423,
1.1331626176834106,
0.3785688877105713,
0.015869207680225372,
0.7789979577064514,
0.46275782585144043,
0.09753485769033432,
0.34340593218803406,
0.0767323225736618,
-0.16318640112876892,
-0.19524095952510834,
-0.04686872288584709,
-0.14704029262065887,
0.6449671387672424,
0.42184963822364807,
-0.440015584230423,
-0.32088059186935425,
-0.4822302460670471,
0.32169482111930847,
0.02659698761999607,
-0.37769004702568054,
1.0419385433197021,
0.41411417722702026,
-0.8202083706855774,
0.23845794796943665,
0.2263617068529129,
0.5691782832145691,
-0.7011889219284058,
-0.12165600061416626,
-0.10143384337425232,
0.08467710018157959,
-0.37802088260650635,
-0.795269250869751,
0.22019712626934052,
0.15565505623817444,
-0.0680779293179512,
-0.30668002367019653,
0.8118298649787903,
-0.3604370653629303,
-0.42146962881088257,
0.036893490701913834,
0.6550205945968628,
0.2332388013601303,
-0.0015962942270562053,
-0.2342745065689087,
-0.08668570965528488,
0.02975504845380783,
-0.37511011958122253,
0.29103562235832214,
0.26974499225616455,
0.045183487236499786,
0.5193154811859131,
1.0201958417892456,
0.5964722037315369,
-0.23453032970428467,
0.15228505432605743,
0.940470278263092,
-0.5805100202560425,
-0.5223456025123596,
-1.1964248418807983,
0.5164558291435242,
-0.3880142271518707,
-0.26058128476142883,
0.7981522679328918,
0.6772376894950867,
0.2528305649757385,
0.07375147938728333,
0.8141182065010071,
-0.028203869238495827,
0.41459986567497253,
-0.7377215027809143,
0.6633314490318298,
-0.6279861330986023,
0.640571117401123,
-0.15171386301517487,
-1.0146452188491821,
-0.48746591806411743,
-0.028988022357225418,
-0.031034883111715317,
-0.29791459441185,
0.5419646501541138,
0.7309316992759705,
0.25880274176597595,
0.08886124193668365,
0.09076404571533203,
0.0997013971209526,
0.5430706739425659,
0.1894361525774002,
0.8160178065299988,
0.15429288148880005,
0.4595320224761963,
0.11399252712726593,
-0.46363529562950134,
-0.3273366391658783,
-1.2537139654159546,
-0.949213445186615,
-0.584952175617218,
0.09971719980239868,
-0.2045983374118805,
-0.2964397966861725,
0.884745180606842,
0.5607165694236755,
-1.0074362754821777,
-0.5907356142997742,
0.17626561224460602,
0.38340580463409424,
-0.1451280415058136,
-0.23321202397346497,
0.5622294545173645,
-0.17373977601528168,
-0.7070314884185791,
0.5292208194732666,
0.35989832878112793,
-0.1811332106590271,
-0.5339720845222473,
-0.21120703220367432,
0.0973530262708664,
0.20204252004623413,
0.6318584084510803,
0.18340672552585602,
-0.5705214738845825,
0.1826760470867157,
-0.0515105277299881,
-0.25851964950561523,
0.046204205602407455,
0.9566075205802917,
-0.5448843836784363,
0.10856633633375168,
0.8999622464179993,
0.5126858949661255,
0.7979860305786133,
0.42132991552352905,
0.6867535710334778,
-0.7023850083351135,
-0.2676951289176941,
0.12932254374027252,
0.5483878254890442,
0.35731402039527893,
-0.13960124552249908,
0.4490594267845154,
0.10722896456718445,
-0.5446783900260925,
-0.7409991025924683,
0.10638809204101562,
-1.0842838287353516,
-0.32755351066589355,
1.332054853439331,
-0.10910017043352127,
-0.36119839549064636,
0.2362229824066162,
-0.32846972346305847,
-0.20311450958251953,
-0.44704023003578186,
0.7319844961166382,
0.35885727405548096,
0.12355201691389084,
-0.0068708620965480804,
-0.09112899005413055,
0.1934444159269333,
0.1177784726023674,
-1.0555245876312256,
0.2568207085132599,
0.4841259717941284,
0.0715603455901146,
0.10170193761587143,
0.8652666807174683,
-0.436379998922348,
0.009511985816061497,
-0.3522278666496277,
0.06004989519715309,
-0.49488565325737,
-0.17844657599925995,
-0.09097809344530106,
1.030981421470642,
-0.05941568315029144,
0.25833162665367126
] |
Subsets and Splits