id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18312v1 | AI-native Memory: A Pathway from LLMs Towards AGI | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | 2024-06-26T12:51:37 | Jingbo Shang, Zai Zheng, Xiang Ying, Felix Tao, Mindverse Team | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the world with the sparks of
artificial general intelligence (AGI). One opinion, especially from some
startups working on LLMs, argues that an LLM with nearly unlimited context
length can realize AGI. However, they might be too optimistic about the
long-context capability of (existing) LLMs -- (1) Recent literature has shown
that their effective context length is significantly smaller than their claimed
context length; and (2) Our reasoning-in-a-haystack experiments further
demonstrate that simultaneously finding the relevant information from a long
context and conducting (simple) reasoning is nearly impossible. In this paper,
we envision a pathway from LLMs to AGI through the integration of
\emph{memory}. We believe that AGI should be a system where LLMs serve as core
processors. In addition to raw data, the memory in this system would store a
large number of important conclusions derived from reasoning processes.
Compared with retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) that merely processing raw
data, this approach not only connects semantically related information closer,
but also simplifies complex inferences at the time of querying. As an
intermediate stage, the memory will likely be in the form of natural language
descriptions, which can be directly consumed by users too. Ultimately, every
agent/person should have its own large personal model, a deep neural network
model (thus \emph{AI-native}) that parameterizes and compresses all types of
memory, even the ones cannot be described by natural languages. Finally, we
discuss the significant potential of AI-native memory as the transformative
infrastructure for (proactive) engagement, personalization, distribution, and
social in the AGI era, as well as the incurred privacy and security challenges
with preliminary solutions. | [
-0.4153067469596863,
-0.9217543601989746,
0.7644492387771606,
-0.23122656345367432,
0.053864527493715286,
0.1729068160057068,
-0.34227094054222107,
-0.7735385298728943,
0.2811279296875,
0.2598007321357727,
-0.22782808542251587,
-0.1797444373369217,
-0.27318453788757324,
-0.14334289729595184,
-0.4981425702571869,
0.7220577001571655,
-0.06022713705897331,
-0.3958783745765686,
-0.3864193856716156,
-0.27629324793815613,
-0.46011918783187866,
-0.7981079816818237,
-0.7613265514373779,
-0.38135021924972534,
0.4353371560573578,
0.2345941662788391,
0.5512761473655701,
0.8787567019462585,
0.19850589334964752,
0.2884986102581024,
-0.17925594747066498,
0.06613173335790634,
-0.4159722924232483,
0.06841877847909927,
-0.04826046898961067,
-0.5726948380470276,
-0.609480082988739,
0.022276746109128,
0.7102689146995544,
0.6492388248443604,
0.0019949048291891813,
-0.07153240591287613,
-0.15953946113586426,
0.6805862188339233,
-0.6894105076789856,
-0.2076082080602646,
-0.6278138160705566,
0.11189047247171402,
-0.21720683574676514,
-0.02673013135790825,
-0.29179778695106506,
0.020259851589798927,
0.07724502682685852,
-0.3745992183685303,
-0.13575208187103271,
-0.015603417530655861,
0.5563678741455078,
0.26630452275276184,
-0.4590340256690979,
-0.33854979276657104,
-1.2077593803405762,
0.8311625123023987,
-0.47650831937789917,
0.13601192831993103,
0.29983648657798767,
0.45101669430732727,
-0.11097276955842972,
-0.7074894905090332,
-0.5154038667678833,
-0.4252844750881195,
0.06346321851015091,
0.08516595512628555,
-0.29595786333084106,
0.09639153629541397,
0.0757390633225441,
0.6314733624458313,
-0.2943522334098816,
0.10604396462440491,
-0.41657811403274536,
-0.10736317932605743,
0.8362812399864197,
0.19572988152503967,
0.24628561735153198,
0.31795603036880493,
-0.25598612427711487,
0.4831865131855011,
-0.6844997406005859,
-0.11010321974754333,
0.1240917444229126,
0.14699578285217285,
-0.009641376323997974,
0.46971261501312256,
-0.3425746262073517,
0.661396861076355,
-0.0557037889957428,
-0.08392851054668427,
-0.12854786217212677,
-0.4756353795528412,
-0.003522150916978717,
0.1728098839521408,
0.6233070492744446,
0.014447436667978764,
0.5680537819862366,
-0.5601308345794678,
-0.187862828373909,
0.44566768407821655,
0.33323702216148376,
-0.6456000804901123,
0.07486264407634735,
0.17734390497207642,
-0.3908711075782776,
0.2413286715745926,
-0.03793581575155258,
-0.388406902551651,
-0.19277647137641907,
-0.3939375579357147,
0.2202451080083847,
-0.5135791897773743,
0.03377748280763626,
-0.08701945096254349,
0.15876972675323486,
0.32184237241744995,
0.14554251730442047,
-0.9936448335647583,
0.6130093932151794,
0.8591791987419128,
0.8819267749786377,
-0.29177942872047424,
-0.241556316614151,
-0.4519243836402893,
0.4880295395851135,
-0.16098083555698395,
0.6054611206054688,
-0.7570846080780029,
-0.611953854560852,
-0.014231342822313309,
-0.36848413944244385,
-0.012424302287399769,
-0.5616545677185059,
0.2593582570552826,
-0.5450617671012878,
0.04534706845879555,
-0.12009385973215103,
-0.6362904906272888,
-0.3346244990825653,
0.44738537073135376,
-0.39192551374435425,
0.7153561115264893,
-0.11461575329303741,
-0.21717646718025208,
-0.027290834113955498,
-0.8501824140548706,
-0.6630893349647522,
0.11871406435966492,
-0.27839627861976624,
0.2282041758298874,
0.3134956359863281,
0.04529336467385292,
0.39982494711875916,
-0.40288007259368896,
0.4412810206413269,
-0.23142419755458832,
-0.5719428658485413,
0.18927541375160217,
-0.4995514452457428,
0.3689080774784088,
0.3905960023403168,
-0.11452952027320862,
-0.031022949144244194,
-0.63660728931427,
-0.21006353199481964,
0.11418062448501587,
-0.48168227076530457,
-0.4002528488636017,
0.10431494563817978,
-0.4574747383594513,
-0.11855606734752655,
0.6900379657745361,
-0.4981871545314789,
0.21035906672477722,
-0.4079117476940155,
0.7545608878135681,
0.7778228521347046,
-0.2221432477235794,
1.0181294679641724,
-0.23574505746364594,
0.30632030963897705,
-0.050592657178640366,
0.3017709255218506,
-0.5563037991523743,
-0.4292412996292114,
-0.7649853825569153,
-0.06472194194793701,
0.06164906919002533,
0.6568904519081116,
-0.2479110211133957,
0.3963809013366699,
-0.3129954934120178,
-0.3003484308719635,
-0.2715066969394684,
0.17780475318431854,
0.11005672812461853,
0.6694104671478271,
0.30312466621398926,
-0.2873563766479492,
-0.3133279085159302,
-0.9599229097366333,
-0.0805312842130661,
-0.3058062493801117,
-0.11688459664583206,
0.8003348708152771,
0.42820751667022705,
-0.6034606695175171,
1.0781885385513306,
-0.23957042396068573,
-0.3620205223560333,
-0.21460925042629242,
-0.17521893978118896,
0.2186374068260193,
0.3704398274421692,
0.30107828974723816,
-0.8003045916557312,
-0.2119465172290802,
0.1392246037721634,
-0.8242497444152832,
0.13307741284370422,
-0.23398271203041077,
-0.09323529154062271,
0.23181785643100739,
0.43259090185165405,
-0.9179597496986389,
0.4708108603954315,
0.22486191987991333,
-0.27876222133636475,
0.3349658250808716,
-0.4433106482028961,
-0.1791687160730362,
-1.1261160373687744,
0.26262548565864563,
-0.0868680477142334,
0.09425242245197296,
-0.7518671751022339,
0.11037024110555649,
-0.3289497196674347,
-0.12817884981632233,
-0.31414794921875,
1.018843173980713,
-0.5346255898475647,
-0.2558272182941437,
-0.5177099704742432,
0.005966024473309517,
-0.20113426446914673,
0.3108484148979187,
-0.1731608808040619,
1.0096001625061035,
0.6549876928329468,
-0.8493805527687073,
0.3694320023059845,
0.19004808366298676,
0.09282686561346054,
0.4376410245895386,
-0.5596708655357361,
0.26165083050727844,
-0.16911554336547852,
0.40452444553375244,
-0.5977584719657898,
-0.1895104944705963,
0.16761577129364014,
-0.5157316327095032,
0.16527089476585388,
0.23851020634174347,
-0.3536604940891266,
-0.1304096132516861,
-0.02204090729355812,
0.6707205772399902,
0.6090751886367798,
-0.47543594241142273,
1.200774073600769,
0.4917745590209961,
-0.15371596813201904,
-0.34484753012657166,
-0.7215319871902466,
0.5473895072937012,
-0.319770872592926,
-0.7328522801399231,
0.5800541639328003,
-0.019182229414582253,
-0.4402766227722168,
0.23389947414398193,
0.10804235935211182,
-0.09465712308883667,
0.24410028755664825,
0.2038351148366928,
0.27431178092956543,
-0.3861064016819,
0.23592157661914825,
-0.12451867014169693,
-0.33561885356903076,
0.08735600858926773,
-0.32796865701675415,
0.5588358044624329,
-0.5504511594772339,
-0.2802930474281311,
-0.16528503596782684,
0.765989363193512,
0.5589632987976074,
-0.4433697760105133,
0.7150068283081055,
0.3756990432739258,
-0.5541824102401733,
0.13765858113765717,
-0.6588290929794312,
-0.0982833132147789,
-0.4418124556541443,
0.21699567139148712,
-0.27835437655448914,
-1.1069673299789429,
0.7930734753608704,
-0.30699703097343445,
-0.036017946898937225,
0.3378487825393677,
0.44751298427581787,
0.005217710044234991,
1.032965064048767,
0.6934499144554138,
-0.5289684534072876,
0.37926027178764343,
-0.3244427442550659,
0.3843716084957123,
-1.0105847120285034,
-0.2390831708908081,
-0.16739502549171448,
-0.6992995738983154,
-0.2687317430973053,
-0.2960766553878784,
0.21944314241409302,
0.045548003166913986,
-0.6372860074043274,
-0.1895470917224884,
-0.3186820149421692,
0.6610763072967529,
0.8029488921165466,
-0.21265874803066254,
0.17716455459594727,
-0.13222907483577728,
0.1886448860168457,
0.27804112434387207,
-0.7076775431632996,
-0.6371172070503235,
0.9008349180221558,
0.4444899559020996,
0.7427486777305603,
-0.04380031302571297,
0.6779345273971558,
0.28297436237335205,
0.3198758065700531,
-0.7996499538421631,
0.863874077796936,
-0.3006901741027832,
-0.4534492492675781,
-0.07069017738103867,
-0.19838860630989075,
-0.8821578621864319,
-0.2409948706626892,
-0.05849061533808708,
-0.9983124732971191,
0.11955372989177704,
0.055526427924633026,
-0.6058066487312317,
0.4464680254459381,
-0.7359777092933655,
0.5871036648750305,
-0.5772210359573364,
-0.4128127098083496,
-0.36424943804740906,
-0.7015904188156128,
0.4413917362689972,
0.10628378391265869,
0.04232003912329674,
-0.04848702251911163,
-0.2616613805294037,
0.5958865284919739,
-0.18500970304012299,
0.8648641705513,
-0.03672248125076294,
0.23801444470882416,
0.5936121344566345,
-0.05332416296005249,
0.34396180510520935,
-0.07507931441068649,
0.03704597055912018,
0.18801067769527435,
-0.4106419086456299,
-0.35575070977211,
-0.4596095383167267,
0.8323673605918884,
-0.766645073890686,
-0.7894607186317444,
-0.3160693943500519,
-0.6379776000976562,
-0.1093629002571106,
0.04585219919681549,
-0.04110139608383179,
0.16265544295310974,
-0.3383627235889435,
0.12041780352592468,
0.7412905097007751,
-0.07485884428024292,
0.6169734597206116,
0.22785896062850952,
-0.021633265540003777,
-0.14138303697109222,
0.9740155339241028,
-0.008872339501976967,
-0.03769494593143463,
0.2742103636264801,
0.3073858618736267,
-0.4039258062839508,
-0.5143892765045166,
-0.2163526564836502,
0.36641842126846313,
-0.7032510638237,
-0.06638021767139435,
-0.5829424262046814,
-0.45015913248062134,
-0.1940068155527115,
-0.3903311789035797,
-0.3933873474597931,
-0.09333673864603043,
-0.5774906873703003,
-0.050740957260131836,
0.4216229021549225,
0.6520819067955017,
-0.09024962037801743,
0.3305770456790924,
-0.9017629623413086,
0.29590946435928345,
0.4212471842765808,
0.33941224217414856,
0.40617769956588745,
-0.4528524875640869,
-0.2964833974838257,
0.1281510889530182,
-0.12260325253009796,
-0.6765269041061401,
0.2535363435745239,
0.46539464592933655,
0.6757665276527405,
0.6908950805664062,
-0.20425425469875336,
0.741463303565979,
-0.6861137747764587,
0.7802273035049438,
0.030728287994861603,
-0.7276519536972046,
0.6004527807235718,
-0.1838407963514328,
0.26427721977233887,
0.6096400022506714,
0.2581222653388977,
-0.6777665615081787,
-0.17454127967357635,
-0.5027201175689697,
-1.0112676620483398,
0.21156913042068481,
-0.2852232754230499,
0.6221513748168945,
-0.36007410287857056,
0.7825435996055603,
0.0024831611663103104,
-0.05872489884495735,
-0.54204922914505,
-0.1765705645084381,
0.21056939661502838,
-0.03751928731799126,
-0.18066856265068054,
-0.31603696942329407,
-0.12145105749368668,
-0.32590538263320923,
0.3089360296726227,
-0.2107044756412506,
0.5371006727218628,
0.1498408019542694,
0.13704794645309448,
0.14876578748226166,
0.23754484951496124,
0.4843848943710327,
0.6169697046279907,
0.06010935455560684,
0.19217362999916077,
0.2639468014240265,
-0.3379475474357605,
0.1709941327571869,
-0.028421707451343536,
-0.3600116968154907,
-0.3191855549812317,
0.16158267855644226,
0.7902565002441406,
-0.16066311299800873,
-0.7581498622894287,
0.2528134882450104,
0.019832132384181023,
0.08517704904079437,
-0.7543410062789917,
0.23962055146694183,
0.12633450329303741,
0.3972984254360199,
0.58906489610672,
0.03708929196000099,
0.11242062598466873,
-0.9910786747932434,
0.2596883177757263,
0.7198114991188049,
-0.33411145210266113,
-0.43703991174697876,
0.846932590007782,
0.3071085214614868,
-0.6066935062408447,
0.8277895450592041,
-0.1408495455980301,
-0.33598607778549194,
0.4873678684234619,
0.60561603307724,
1.0135542154312134,
-0.18422023952007294,
-0.13878819346427917,
0.2088514119386673,
0.11601585894823074,
-0.013992146588861942,
0.023402730002999306,
-0.20741409063339233,
-0.8469038009643555,
-0.6333487629890442,
-0.5146461129188538,
-0.23248307406902313,
0.10445741564035416,
-0.3247508108615875,
-0.20480111241340637,
-0.5818420052528381,
-0.055964477360248566,
-0.5417520999908447,
-0.03989657014608383,
-0.4044635593891144,
0.19925637543201447,
0.6141229271888733,
1.1247848272323608,
-0.7164621353149414,
0.7195006608963013,
0.6656914949417114,
-0.07857072353363037,
-0.4640595018863678,
-0.058412399142980576,
-0.2751762568950653,
-0.8561001420021057,
0.41480594873428345,
0.4222518801689148,
0.025540364906191826,
-0.16841787099838257,
-0.4876720607280731,
-0.8653873801231384,
1.3208916187286377,
0.1041668951511383,
-0.33604902029037476,
-0.09490091353654861,
0.15088097751140594,
0.6455404162406921,
-0.8118000030517578,
0.06703933328390121,
0.8103368282318115,
0.42128774523735046,
0.24710319936275482,
-0.46104300022125244,
-0.000837580009829253,
-0.34330007433891296,
0.034175653010606766,
0.13929057121276855,
-0.6889333128929138,
0.818811297416687,
-0.3813002407550812,
-0.32886165380477905,
0.1434740573167801,
0.9149723052978516,
0.19182558357715607,
0.571241557598114,
0.19839704036712646,
0.7074074745178223,
0.7299672365188599,
0.0811084434390068,
1.3532947301864624,
-0.4214285612106323,
-0.42719727754592896,
0.9484253525733948,
-0.4151870608329773,
0.962260365486145,
0.534958004951477,
0.06202024966478348,
0.24676324427127838,
0.47061145305633545,
0.24683047831058502,
0.3026733100414276,
0.056006453931331635,
-0.7108320593833923,
-0.22135180234909058,
-0.4662875235080719,
-0.21208390593528748,
0.5494893789291382,
0.43124422430992126,
-0.20279835164546967,
-0.06931023299694061,
-0.07104039192199707,
-0.23556439578533173,
0.21811440587043762,
-0.49799349904060364,
0.8892468214035034,
0.24048125743865967,
-0.6973464488983154,
0.2611103951931,
0.03196060284972191,
0.8077345490455627,
-0.5115122199058533,
0.06429167091846466,
-0.45009124279022217,
0.1835697442293167,
0.08999179303646088,
-0.6628793478012085,
0.6572109460830688,
0.09808449447154999,
-0.22796416282653809,
-0.16754719614982605,
1.0120595693588257,
-0.20119623839855194,
-0.2863270044326782,
0.382508248090744,
0.7613604068756104,
0.17496713995933533,
-0.11833798140287399,
-0.5475735664367676,
-0.13461779057979584,
-0.3214030861854553,
-0.21247608959674835,
0.5076333284378052,
0.2871458828449249,
-0.22206322848796844,
0.9798032641410828,
0.6593318581581116,
0.13728930056095123,
0.029534250497817993,
-0.22000424563884735,
0.8330180644989014,
-0.7755595445632935,
-0.5881354212760925,
-1.1066004037857056,
0.2823428809642792,
0.06968516856431961,
-0.12561264634132385,
0.4667932987213135,
0.6416595578193665,
0.5813130736351013,
0.22995290160179138,
0.7401284575462341,
0.03525514900684357,
0.285266637802124,
-0.29314616322517395,
0.6361653208732605,
-0.5785006284713745,
0.17637600004673004,
0.3914318084716797,
-0.9552109241485596,
-0.1869797259569168,
0.43461349606513977,
-0.3939741551876068,
0.02726082317531109,
0.2614108622074127,
0.4791947305202484,
-0.14082805812358856,
-0.1160617470741272,
0.264714777469635,
0.20301376283168793,
0.21719703078269958,
0.8875988721847534,
0.937475860118866,
-0.12198439985513687,
0.5123400092124939,
0.09350943565368652,
-0.19517962634563446,
-0.051217466592788696,
-0.6355346441268921,
-0.5930249094963074,
-0.3997907042503357,
-0.11856205761432648,
0.16248254477977753,
-0.0401938334107399,
0.46740931272506714,
0.5206447839736938,
-0.48299628496170044,
-0.37311822175979614,
-0.30278852581977844,
0.0019496966851875186,
0.08529612421989441,
-0.1791946142911911,
0.061263758689165115,
-0.15121684968471527,
-0.6088192462921143,
0.5496236085891724,
0.6562212705612183,
0.313822865486145,
-0.44166043400764465,
-0.3356102406978607,
-0.2632838189601898,
0.19281744956970215,
0.6151931285858154,
0.7744150161743164,
-0.8357807397842407,
-0.30195340514183044,
0.2046779841184616,
0.028688834980130196,
0.20728303492069244,
0.5620859861373901,
-1.0751622915267944,
0.23155023157596588,
0.20155079662799835,
1.049259066581726,
0.3599024713039398,
0.008537265472114086,
0.6451539993286133,
-0.5417620539665222,
0.21559442579746246,
0.5059041380882263,
0.37994977831840515,
0.18082039058208466,
-0.46379929780960083,
0.5311008095741272,
0.046689778566360474,
-0.6077312231063843,
-0.5684375166893005,
0.4706626534461975,
-0.8633541464805603,
-0.33266034722328186,
1.0899686813354492,
0.01579263247549534,
-0.616059422492981,
0.0772494450211525,
-0.0910756066441536,
0.09741971641778946,
-0.305154949426651,
0.9043851494789124,
0.5545480847358704,
-0.276864618062973,
-0.14202013611793518,
-0.5681856870651245,
0.12897557020187378,
0.36117470264434814,
-0.7863695621490479,
-0.014952562749385834,
0.494105726480484,
-0.2323986142873764,
0.5111510157585144,
0.9490593075752258,
0.039268121123313904,
0.20977313816547394,
-0.0037150338757783175,
-0.15106506645679474,
-0.12513326108455658,
-0.5790244340896606,
-0.3452838361263275,
0.06066995486617088,
-0.049675360321998596,
-0.25278469920158386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18305v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18305v1 | S3: A Simple Strong Sample-effective Multimodal Dialog System | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | 2024-06-26T12:45:43 | Elisei Rykov, Egor Malkershin, Alexander Panchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present a conceptually simple yet powerful baseline for the
multimodal dialog task, an S3 model, that achieves near state-of-the-art
results on two compelling leaderboards: MMMU and AI Journey Contest 2023. The
system is based on a pre-trained large language model, pre-trained modality
encoders for image and audio, and a trainable modality projector. The proposed
effective data mixture for training such an architecture demonstrates that a
multimodal model based on a strong language model and trained on a small amount
of multimodal data can perform efficiently in the task of multimodal dialog. | [
-0.19151674211025238,
-0.7803698778152466,
0.6872284412384033,
0.059545908123254776,
-0.1924971342086792,
0.08381550759077072,
-0.014151699841022491,
-0.24166211485862732,
0.04987029731273651,
0.2606430649757385,
-0.646307110786438,
-0.24178141355514526,
-0.6278941631317139,
0.1425493210554123,
-0.19924379885196686,
1.0257164239883423,
0.12025833129882812,
0.35119950771331787,
-0.3158861994743347,
-0.24109357595443726,
-0.583949625492096,
-0.23233941197395325,
-0.37539413571357727,
-0.13962382078170776,
0.5632430911064148,
0.43289557099342346,
0.7332234978675842,
0.4251806139945984,
0.49551188945770264,
0.3379262387752533,
0.1249333918094635,
0.19920191168785095,
-0.4266723096370697,
0.10610748827457428,
0.22179517149925232,
-0.5547780394554138,
-0.6417027711868286,
-0.10473262518644333,
0.48596012592315674,
0.624721884727478,
-0.1865006536245346,
0.07525242865085602,
0.03689812496304512,
0.09767860174179077,
-0.37403684854507446,
0.2787312865257263,
-0.3840782344341278,
-0.04028572514653206,
-0.17473649978637695,
-0.3206884562969208,
-0.2892821431159973,
-0.03487362340092659,
0.14316286146640778,
-0.6341431140899658,
-0.09270979464054108,
0.1442716270685196,
0.6501677632331848,
0.228424072265625,
-0.888231635093689,
-0.22676973044872284,
-0.48205962777137756,
0.9133065938949585,
-0.3856220841407776,
0.6831094622612,
0.40066152811050415,
0.5163378715515137,
0.29453206062316895,
-0.6124155521392822,
-0.7631872892379761,
-0.21940474212169647,
0.40000057220458984,
0.25733882188796997,
-0.08423535525798798,
0.11754144728183746,
0.0078090461902320385,
0.5227043628692627,
-0.6259400248527527,
-0.08440838754177094,
-0.46180546283721924,
-0.17274421453475952,
0.1639624834060669,
0.2827075719833374,
0.2779010832309723,
-0.3045048415660858,
-0.5622423887252808,
0.013104463927447796,
-0.5460944771766663,
-0.2006339132785797,
0.0542154423892498,
0.2683508098125458,
-0.34214845299720764,
0.5379626750946045,
-0.2546084225177765,
0.855239748954773,
-0.07650765776634216,
-0.6442440748214722,
0.46973320841789246,
-0.7439458966255188,
-0.19039136171340942,
-0.41700026392936707,
0.8766745328903198,
0.6658686399459839,
-0.43972891569137573,
-0.13612627983093262,
-0.2584989070892334,
0.16722749173641205,
0.2981925308704376,
-0.6757614612579346,
0.02313229814171791,
0.3144133985042572,
-0.4661967158317566,
-0.25107109546661377,
-0.21322230994701385,
-0.5356351733207703,
-0.2652489244937897,
-0.4523693025112152,
0.5516168475151062,
-0.5433220267295837,
-0.2703338861465454,
0.07760227471590042,
0.05866791307926178,
-0.13509607315063477,
0.8310099244117737,
-0.7482889890670776,
-0.0480215921998024,
0.35284942388534546,
0.7707208395004272,
-0.2149299532175064,
-0.25470924377441406,
-0.5269343256950378,
0.19264262914657593,
-0.15632177889347076,
0.6373403072357178,
-0.45015305280685425,
-0.39415666460990906,
-0.13023200631141663,
-0.14163319766521454,
-0.08578336238861084,
-0.5403677225112915,
0.33716219663619995,
-0.3844943344593048,
0.4151635468006134,
0.09660384058952332,
-0.44412073493003845,
-0.07718706876039505,
0.5427760481834412,
-0.7214072942733765,
0.8320656418800354,
0.17141222953796387,
-0.4543897807598114,
0.417388379573822,
-0.6845690011978149,
-0.1883230358362198,
0.16895364224910736,
-0.24605099856853485,
0.0201064832508564,
-0.0458081029355526,
0.2968451678752899,
0.5116859674453735,
-0.4467141330242157,
0.3051745295524597,
-0.23671980202198029,
-0.31905049085617065,
0.23067712783813477,
-0.44448918104171753,
0.5491428971290588,
0.5895513892173767,
-0.10767951607704163,
0.20283718407154083,
-0.8391141891479492,
-0.13432495296001434,
0.03762223571538925,
-0.519637942314148,
0.2114335298538208,
-0.36180973052978516,
0.24811680614948273,
0.08946765214204788,
0.34161290526390076,
-0.637330174446106,
0.30061763525009155,
0.22176021337509155,
0.43767136335372925,
0.7869300842285156,
-0.26379507780075073,
0.4745798110961914,
-0.36860746145248413,
0.4875129461288452,
0.07684534043073654,
0.11997761577367783,
-0.5702275037765503,
-0.43048015236854553,
-0.7369765043258667,
-0.5798231363296509,
0.1548914760351181,
0.6311274766921997,
-1.1853609085083008,
0.6048362255096436,
-0.3973495662212372,
-0.3210704028606415,
-0.47668832540512085,
0.3160100281238556,
0.1687912940979004,
0.296338826417923,
0.09452081471681595,
-0.3231540024280548,
-0.5017979145050049,
-1.0222047567367554,
0.3126052916049957,
-0.3020845651626587,
-0.08390429615974426,
0.2417248636484146,
0.2879779040813446,
-0.32413721084594727,
0.6543128490447998,
-0.3722364008426666,
-0.27454161643981934,
-0.8992061018943787,
0.2108968198299408,
0.07432086765766144,
0.49494707584381104,
0.4142046868801117,
-0.814997136592865,
-0.19365543127059937,
-0.2974066436290741,
-0.974547266960144,
0.2313362956047058,
-0.14060509204864502,
-0.11286413669586182,
-0.3575110137462616,
0.5001977682113647,
-0.7287888526916504,
0.11749076843261719,
0.5771915316581726,
-0.23961389064788818,
0.1582213193178177,
0.1497749239206314,
0.4155227839946747,
-1.347571849822998,
-0.1640218198299408,
0.049356698989868164,
-0.24567480385303497,
-0.8499746918678284,
0.0022332514636218548,
-0.10055419057607651,
-0.3797950744628906,
-0.6028367280960083,
0.4427816569805145,
-0.11543277651071548,
0.24306386709213257,
-0.21896710991859436,
-0.013783751986920834,
0.02392936684191227,
0.7252527475357056,
0.030032994225621223,
0.6651536226272583,
0.6849186420440674,
-0.4474468529224396,
0.43158528208732605,
0.4217507541179657,
-0.6936512589454651,
1.037020206451416,
-0.4283284842967987,
0.2533000409603119,
-0.2598344683647156,
0.45037445425987244,
-1.2872874736785889,
-0.4487825930118561,
-0.12762406468391418,
-0.3570977747440338,
0.02336154133081436,
0.019936377182602882,
-0.604945182800293,
-0.17656323313713074,
-0.00992573332041502,
0.54185950756073,
0.27696502208709717,
-0.4019961953163147,
0.8795023560523987,
0.35560035705566406,
-0.24380746483802795,
-0.07164124399423599,
-0.5027425289154053,
0.24602243304252625,
-0.16230745613574982,
-0.7001655697822571,
0.009857358410954475,
-0.4070037603378296,
0.1791473627090454,
-0.4661898910999298,
0.0656513124704361,
-0.15620042383670807,
-0.02577979862689972,
0.28786328434944153,
0.3810107111930847,
-0.18950703740119934,
-0.0566265732049942,
-0.4535520374774933,
-0.12931010127067566,
-0.32399165630340576,
0.33400410413742065,
0.6303905844688416,
-0.33545535802841187,
-0.48555493354797363,
-0.9033761024475098,
0.3917228877544403,
0.8602010607719421,
0.10714884847402573,
0.3321978747844696,
0.632189154624939,
-0.2507766783237457,
0.3071161210536957,
-0.514700174331665,
-0.14669294655323029,
-0.45635828375816345,
0.41424036026000977,
-0.6105403304100037,
-0.933071494102478,
0.11989651620388031,
0.008507726714015007,
0.08643119782209396,
0.08995150029659271,
0.43212807178497314,
-0.24907423555850983,
1.4895981550216675,
0.37340518832206726,
0.1590520292520523,
0.69251948595047,
-0.1805284023284912,
0.1530526876449585,
-0.783031702041626,
-0.26546111702919006,
-0.22596517205238342,
-0.10902033001184464,
-0.13962383568286896,
-0.6610604524612427,
0.5411558151245117,
-0.024065664038062096,
-0.19498659670352936,
0.2539418339729309,
0.1357814073562622,
0.12349607050418854,
0.7953923344612122,
0.32005390524864197,
0.2690742611885071,
-0.06937672942876816,
-0.03092900849878788,
-0.35737645626068115,
-0.7397854924201965,
-0.499242901802063,
1.0968974828720093,
0.37330859899520874,
0.7471702098846436,
0.3204735517501831,
0.480427622795105,
0.2417561113834381,
0.2995205521583557,
-0.7912967205047607,
0.6868364214897156,
0.23775441944599152,
-0.6860820055007935,
-0.12115442752838135,
-0.4092094600200653,
-0.638188362121582,
0.39069226384162903,
-0.4498753249645233,
-0.8260968923568726,
-0.20836342871189117,
0.033090583980083466,
-0.5358205437660217,
0.2927497625350952,
-0.649716854095459,
0.7809282541275024,
-0.2991127073764801,
-0.2859225869178772,
-0.030019627884030342,
-0.7036725878715515,
0.36918726563453674,
0.09257439523935318,
0.2584875524044037,
-0.11561623215675354,
0.2971433997154236,
0.7435184121131897,
-0.2690664231777191,
0.755110502243042,
-0.18969854712486267,
0.0684797391295433,
0.24833428859710693,
0.15591777861118317,
0.24827909469604492,
-0.058421969413757324,
0.3027800917625427,
-0.004632274620234966,
-0.1891910582780838,
-0.5234573483467102,
-0.8152173757553101,
0.22459577023983002,
-0.8582754731178284,
-0.3226916193962097,
-0.15787020325660706,
-0.45361971855163574,
-0.592636227607727,
0.20242320001125336,
0.05040866509079933,
0.7963143587112427,
-0.3270099461078644,
0.6821749210357666,
0.415984570980072,
-0.07817190140485764,
0.21229848265647888,
0.23180437088012695,
-0.1330832988023758,
-0.76570725440979,
1.014610767364502,
-0.34329989552497864,
0.3777547776699066,
0.3015038073062897,
-0.02367430552840233,
-0.27845650911331177,
-0.45370399951934814,
-0.8295349478721619,
-0.046566419303417206,
-0.7285246849060059,
-0.26805728673934937,
-0.9699307680130005,
-0.0566658116877079,
-0.2672283351421356,
-0.21266216039657593,
-0.627271831035614,
-0.3223760426044464,
-0.08506841212511063,
-0.2731894850730896,
-0.24178053438663483,
0.8663281798362732,
0.043455976992845535,
0.7554510831832886,
-0.9009088277816772,
0.5434205532073975,
0.6945610046386719,
0.15379022061824799,
-0.2126569151878357,
-0.3012133538722992,
-0.23392389714717865,
0.07300610095262527,
-0.49794864654541016,
-0.5130356550216675,
0.0499110110104084,
0.04306117817759514,
0.693874716758728,
0.6801062226295471,
-0.5949095487594604,
0.6439163088798523,
-0.33592602610588074,
1.2385390996932983,
0.8005234599113464,
-0.8628640174865723,
0.7262793779373169,
-0.6025506258010864,
0.6087194085121155,
0.921809196472168,
0.18830031156539917,
-0.536845862865448,
-0.318365216255188,
-0.6066697835922241,
-0.5879917144775391,
0.7107174396514893,
0.30944183468818665,
-0.03303491324186325,
0.03883512318134308,
-0.3173425495624542,
0.3430537283420563,
0.4794692397117615,
-0.8421310782432556,
-0.00849872175604105,
-0.48240506649017334,
-0.5701351761817932,
-0.10292251408100128,
-0.15129002928733826,
-0.388522744178772,
-0.13132882118225098,
0.3335573971271515,
-0.313416063785553,
0.49388375878334045,
-0.3491469919681549,
-0.23959682881832123,
0.31683430075645447,
0.2960236072540283,
0.6019171476364136,
0.5472399592399597,
-0.4898299276828766,
0.31943291425704956,
0.041927751153707504,
-0.4043053686618805,
0.2552506625652313,
-0.1839691400527954,
0.09360239654779434,
-0.2932153046131134,
0.5107036828994751,
1.1363718509674072,
0.26547664403915405,
-0.765982985496521,
0.7589002251625061,
-0.20454184710979462,
-0.22388842701911926,
0.16039085388183594,
0.023241819813847542,
-0.16415263712406158,
0.24276535212993622,
0.45646271109580994,
0.24960005283355713,
0.31593817472457886,
-0.7731205224990845,
0.15988169610500336,
0.13264036178588867,
-0.4837663471698761,
-0.386881947517395,
0.6465660929679871,
0.5740089416503906,
-0.13529767096042633,
0.3974108397960663,
-0.0038019355852156878,
-0.3668052554130554,
0.33572840690612793,
0.5875106453895569,
0.46159428358078003,
-0.0894227921962738,
0.22456060349941254,
0.2388731688261032,
0.09366513043642044,
-0.14946149289608002,
0.43019020557403564,
-0.32537907361984253,
-0.9580240845680237,
-0.12561596930027008,
-0.41837698221206665,
-0.5326853394508362,
0.359080046415329,
-0.6119500398635864,
0.06807050108909607,
-0.34278935194015503,
-0.33000144362449646,
-0.18960632383823395,
-0.3232130706310272,
-0.8718338012695312,
0.5220393538475037,
0.362378865480423,
0.5812937021255493,
-0.7739160060882568,
0.3681102693080902,
0.6629573106765747,
-0.33785557746887207,
-0.4863431453704834,
-0.3322494924068451,
0.3935833275318146,
-0.8450348973274231,
0.7589098215103149,
0.3712908923625946,
-0.2703568935394287,
-0.35548973083496094,
-0.6850771903991699,
-0.9198394417762756,
1.0922517776489258,
0.09939924627542496,
-0.22895537316799164,
0.046131428331136703,
0.01244953740388155,
0.18825827538967133,
-0.6694036722183228,
0.524634599685669,
0.3052484095096588,
0.25707048177719116,
0.4777361750602722,
-0.9930294156074524,
-0.14265291392803192,
-0.6272810697555542,
0.08381741493940353,
-0.3227604031562805,
-0.7874525785446167,
0.7104584574699402,
-0.03696328401565552,
-0.2719297409057617,
0.30545902252197266,
0.9602715373039246,
0.5406872630119324,
0.1994633674621582,
0.9115502238273621,
0.4794381260871887,
0.598841667175293,
-0.3484300374984741,
0.9930057525634766,
-0.36827969551086426,
-0.12318062782287598,
1.1425485610961914,
-0.3762889802455902,
0.7014538645744324,
0.376650869846344,
0.021380888298153877,
0.3039078414440155,
0.5114485025405884,
0.3242810368537903,
0.850738525390625,
-0.15146304666996002,
-0.3249659240245819,
-0.6186773777008057,
-0.25074636936187744,
-0.32606616616249084,
0.9826268553733826,
0.38760054111480713,
-0.05919382721185684,
-0.17814339697360992,
0.3667604923248291,
-0.0821985974907875,
-0.4590321183204651,
-0.015999862924218178,
0.9108280539512634,
-0.22111541032791138,
-0.6633649468421936,
0.30603718757629395,
-0.1499568223953247,
0.8469440340995789,
-0.6165030002593994,
-0.03241327032446861,
-0.1817568689584732,
0.01414361409842968,
0.06026197224855423,
-0.6024203896522522,
-0.31663843989372253,
-0.10995769500732422,
0.22542361915111542,
-0.5664786696434021,
0.37998002767562866,
-0.48121020197868347,
-0.4335079491138458,
-0.2041730284690857,
0.846056342124939,
0.10479053854942322,
0.21746385097503662,
-0.5306775569915771,
0.3015182316303253,
0.013138636015355587,
-0.17068594694137573,
0.0680275410413742,
0.4096652865409851,
0.273508757352829,
0.6646896004676819,
0.6637017130851746,
-0.0487198531627655,
-0.10222943127155304,
0.5019385814666748,
0.8063104152679443,
-0.7299556732177734,
-0.7920753955841064,
-0.38639506697654724,
0.6367143392562866,
-0.3030860126018524,
-0.44046738743782043,
0.6945353150367737,
0.7426400184631348,
0.45882609486579895,
0.11564943194389343,
0.9854180216789246,
0.05101451277732849,
0.5628170967102051,
-0.6563180685043335,
0.22552363574504852,
-0.8509491682052612,
-0.03022717870771885,
-0.19501374661922455,
-0.8451539278030396,
-0.2558915317058563,
0.8767248392105103,
0.1832886040210724,
0.23545227944850922,
0.6832950115203857,
0.8547922372817993,
-0.19820570945739746,
0.415035605430603,
0.3684994578361511,
-0.1100936010479927,
0.42257803678512573,
0.5227413177490234,
1.390408992767334,
-0.38414067029953003,
0.3996278643608093,
0.10889257490634918,
-0.4011765122413635,
-0.4193124771118164,
-0.460803747177124,
-0.8800373673439026,
-0.7670110464096069,
-0.10158424824476242,
-0.40363550186157227,
-0.17606042325496674,
0.9911091923713684,
1.0745314359664917,
-0.3832540810108185,
-0.3578709661960602,
0.28403839468955994,
-0.2782593369483948,
0.12081951647996902,
-0.19886241853237152,
-0.13827194273471832,
-0.09552469849586487,
-0.8287962675094604,
0.8588934540748596,
0.44965991377830505,
0.35896822810173035,
-0.3805652856826782,
-0.11255088448524475,
-0.1258767694234848,
0.05710456892848015,
0.8398865461349487,
-0.2124636024236679,
-0.5887875556945801,
-0.4111189544200897,
0.14161957800388336,
-0.41916796565055847,
0.31096547842025757,
0.8973746299743652,
-0.3698292076587677,
0.6720983982086182,
0.33540719747543335,
0.4422188401222229,
0.6120535731315613,
-0.07718777656555176,
0.772867739200592,
-0.5681517720222473,
0.2108691781759262,
0.047755736857652664,
0.5255253911018372,
0.638888955116272,
0.007833917625248432,
0.6196687817573547,
0.23126919567584991,
-0.2424711287021637,
-0.7767162322998047,
0.2900111675262451,
-1.4607136249542236,
-0.1563246250152588,
1.2729332447052002,
0.22309483587741852,
-0.1814430058002472,
-0.28040215373039246,
-0.4703458845615387,
0.07629223167896271,
-0.5442376732826233,
0.5153656601905823,
0.7939181923866272,
-0.25506454706192017,
-0.20146556198596954,
-0.6228665709495544,
0.2808506190776825,
0.4088873565196991,
-0.9245970249176025,
-0.3874063193798065,
0.778794527053833,
0.03502056002616882,
0.4404560327529907,
1.1900675296783447,
0.01622878573834896,
0.22554686665534973,
0.29778167605400085,
-0.12185360491275787,
-0.050032734870910645,
-0.650762140750885,
0.0009674654575064778,
0.39746972918510437,
-0.11101581156253815,
-0.1576172262430191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18301v1 | MSR-86K: An Evolving, Multilingual Corpus with 86,300 Hours of Transcribed Audio for Speech Recognition Research | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | 2024-06-26T12:35:12 | Song Li, Yongbin You, Xuezhi Wang, Zhengkun Tian, Ke Ding, Guanglu Wan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recently, multilingual artificial intelligence assistants, exemplified by
ChatGPT, have gained immense popularity. As a crucial gateway to human-computer
interaction, multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) has also garnered
significant attention, as evidenced by systems like Whisper. However, the
proprietary nature of the training data has impeded researchers' efforts to
study multilingual ASR. This paper introduces MSR-86K, an evolving, large-scale
multilingual corpus for speech recognition research. The corpus is derived from
publicly accessible videos on YouTube, comprising 15 languages and a total of
86,300 hours of transcribed ASR data. We also introduce how to use the MSR-86K
corpus and other open-source corpora to train a robust multilingual ASR model
that is competitive with Whisper. MSR-86K will be publicly released on
HuggingFace, and we believe that such a large corpus will pave new avenues for
research in multilingual ASR. | [
-0.30192530155181885,
-0.36190342903137207,
0.03465192764997482,
0.26239916682243347,
-0.028979578986763954,
0.37521135807037354,
-0.6685173511505127,
-0.5397210121154785,
0.19355784356594086,
0.16642482578754425,
-0.40259045362472534,
-0.20350655913352966,
-0.6653878092765808,
0.2920994758605957,
-0.30767273902893066,
1.0471179485321045,
0.13705945014953613,
0.4753881096839905,
0.11204911768436432,
-0.35329681634902954,
0.129075825214386,
-0.826615035533905,
-0.5986835360527039,
0.03132891282439232,
0.6194546222686768,
0.2044447660446167,
0.4191491901874542,
0.5579648017883301,
0.3010062575340271,
0.384067565202713,
-0.2802834212779999,
0.049998000264167786,
-0.28052160143852234,
0.1957298368215561,
0.2153143286705017,
0.06730572134256363,
-0.36135250329971313,
-0.3719569742679596,
0.9841774702072144,
0.41561251878738403,
-0.18073903024196625,
0.34346267580986023,
0.2471836656332016,
0.49403178691864014,
-0.5402381420135498,
0.2874426245689392,
-0.49229395389556885,
0.030278079211711884,
-0.5830814838409424,
0.02899830788373947,
-0.2644622325897217,
-0.06005000323057175,
0.2669825255870819,
-0.4467216432094574,
0.10217750072479248,
-0.26947537064552307,
0.37335434556007385,
0.19777505099773407,
-0.05763649940490723,
-0.5932329893112183,
-0.7626005411148071,
0.780646562576294,
-0.4200233519077301,
0.9980388283729553,
0.5153425931930542,
0.40149784088134766,
0.25126421451568604,
-0.3633623719215393,
-0.4479661285877228,
-0.3609415590763092,
0.44470083713531494,
0.05878660827875137,
-0.07186786830425262,
-0.11720145493745804,
0.13536028563976288,
0.08358319103717804,
-0.6670568585395813,
-0.08826983720064163,
-0.944861114025116,
-0.4236566722393036,
0.4829179346561432,
-0.20585781335830688,
0.3670324683189392,
-0.305422306060791,
-0.16683104634284973,
-0.034731630235910416,
-0.5003562569618225,
0.12061593681573868,
0.6727176904678345,
0.62003093957901,
-0.21538178622722626,
0.5213953256607056,
-0.10499054938554764,
0.5389066934585571,
-0.21049827337265015,
-0.3167663514614105,
0.5593507885932922,
-0.08543132990598679,
0.08728498965501785,
0.7258761525154114,
0.9811251759529114,
-0.16574858129024506,
0.129228413105011,
-0.13599196076393127,
0.09558936208486557,
-0.05739377811551094,
0.21077504754066467,
-0.5864388346672058,
-0.21298111975193024,
0.11389660835266113,
-0.3751007616519928,
0.08545948565006256,
-0.07442138344049454,
-0.7153772711753845,
-0.10114780813455582,
-0.40006205439567566,
0.1763150840997696,
-0.8357590436935425,
-0.596711277961731,
-0.06134878844022751,
-0.09437739104032516,
0.2139231264591217,
0.22802408039569855,
-0.6734145879745483,
0.13968074321746826,
0.8165023326873779,
1.0320193767547607,
-0.22071561217308044,
-0.8090169429779053,
-0.7349606156349182,
0.04655855894088745,
-0.19615769386291504,
0.6956570148468018,
-0.7627722024917603,
-0.37527403235435486,
0.13916845619678497,
0.1187904104590416,
-0.12529607117176056,
-0.2793562710285187,
0.49268409609794617,
-0.34345269203186035,
0.08989790081977844,
-0.021255725994706154,
-0.22156032919883728,
-0.04370196536183357,
0.2074950933456421,
-0.48564857244491577,
1.1971722841262817,
-0.20994193851947784,
-0.5605999827384949,
0.11308450996875763,
-0.9313182830810547,
-0.282355397939682,
0.21291303634643555,
-0.06392180919647217,
-0.2896807789802551,
-0.20312973856925964,
0.04545332118868828,
0.15781360864639282,
0.18569011986255646,
0.1694430410861969,
-0.22651247680187225,
-0.09653319418430328,
0.35434195399284363,
-0.5654535889625549,
0.7957041263580322,
0.6359602212905884,
-0.18520236015319824,
0.09330293536186218,
-0.8482434749603271,
-0.013530716300010681,
-0.29964351654052734,
-0.7086510062217712,
-0.18586070835590363,
-0.0841827467083931,
0.37823614478111267,
0.20037147402763367,
0.2700394093990326,
-0.9577789306640625,
-0.34666645526885986,
-0.22957655787467957,
0.6608016490936279,
0.47660332918167114,
-0.4760087728500366,
0.32094016671180725,
-0.09653664380311966,
0.6388263702392578,
-0.2541292607784271,
-0.00953204371035099,
-0.32230690121650696,
-0.5004205703735352,
-0.5873180031776428,
-0.2530836760997772,
0.4536976218223572,
0.5013856887817383,
-0.45757976174354553,
0.157518669962883,
-0.37910377979278564,
-0.4469327926635742,
-1.058308720588684,
0.23573258519172668,
0.4467279016971588,
0.28919321298599243,
0.4624946415424347,
-0.05596502870321274,
-0.6804082989692688,
-0.6755338311195374,
-0.11794273555278778,
-0.003254520706832409,
-0.1873125284910202,
0.29542872309684753,
0.1749526411294937,
-0.23822981119155884,
0.5133379697799683,
-0.03794137015938759,
-0.3270396888256073,
-0.2980751395225525,
0.06422895193099976,
-0.20975245535373688,
0.4205261170864105,
0.43495094776153564,
-0.7478037476539612,
-0.7805938124656677,
0.21147723495960236,
-0.6954471468925476,
0.2827841341495514,
0.23629005253314972,
-0.0643814280629158,
0.15235689282417297,
0.6702536940574646,
-0.3200049102306366,
-0.11226298660039902,
0.8524502515792847,
0.054886482656002045,
0.5611634254455566,
-0.2836199998855591,
0.24704544246196747,
-1.2115352153778076,
0.0795198604464531,
-0.1609896719455719,
-0.22302719950675964,
-0.7211341857910156,
-0.08158380538225174,
0.1874300241470337,
-0.57322758436203,
-0.576606035232544,
0.2908640205860138,
-0.5770075917243958,
0.02305418998003006,
-0.20750178396701813,
-0.033170513808727264,
-0.5381764769554138,
0.269539475440979,
0.33394119143486023,
0.8598030805587769,
0.7429550886154175,
-0.5165914297103882,
0.18748055398464203,
0.3711434006690979,
-0.22559891641139984,
0.5400939583778381,
-0.40487679839134216,
0.5101012587547302,
-0.22990743815898895,
0.015638016164302826,
-0.5750909447669983,
-0.2050267904996872,
-0.06992059201002121,
-0.7440215945243835,
0.396822065114975,
-0.5386593341827393,
-0.1773453950881958,
-0.26633161306381226,
-0.3339177370071411,
0.30191048979759216,
0.34682562947273254,
-0.44701141119003296,
0.8487781882286072,
0.725726306438446,
-0.784900426864624,
-0.879188597202301,
-0.46809712052345276,
0.3347516357898712,
-0.2589865028858185,
-0.5916681885719299,
-0.03361973538994789,
-0.39276784658432007,
-0.03720444068312645,
-0.14384672045707703,
0.06256367266178131,
-0.06902782618999481,
-0.39465785026550293,
0.39418408274650574,
0.051070716232061386,
-0.6051065921783447,
-0.06663522124290466,
-0.13009530305862427,
-0.1776544153690338,
-0.07727860659360886,
-0.05743781104683876,
0.6378872990608215,
-0.30688637495040894,
-0.3324158489704132,
-0.3779483437538147,
0.7084298133850098,
0.5095405578613281,
-0.4181463122367859,
0.4153812527656555,
0.8238804936408997,
-0.16043385863304138,
0.030772680416703224,
-0.667443573474884,
0.2166975438594818,
-0.48152250051498413,
0.5293995141983032,
-0.5100967288017273,
-1.0010557174682617,
0.35769933462142944,
0.09721343219280243,
-0.003618696704506874,
0.3613136112689972,
0.6312978863716125,
0.0010283645242452621,
0.8761547803878784,
0.4548199474811554,
-0.39335834980010986,
0.7454903721809387,
0.05888998880982399,
-0.17877984046936035,
-0.8362221121788025,
-0.19941498339176178,
-0.7337359189987183,
-0.06507566571235657,
-0.421277791261673,
-0.2821590304374695,
0.4697445034980774,
-0.39574795961380005,
-0.09618989378213882,
0.28528404235839844,
-0.4604318141937256,
0.47526851296424866,
0.6075741052627563,
-0.032259970903396606,
0.181156188249588,
0.030258478596806526,
0.1615055799484253,
-0.04248071834445,
-0.4677393436431885,
-0.40666913986206055,
1.066856026649475,
0.3641244173049927,
0.5183649063110352,
0.28801438212394714,
0.4441636800765991,
0.23102214932441711,
0.042860448360443115,
-0.7173009514808655,
0.24403707683086395,
-0.33810651302337646,
-0.6287844777107239,
-0.2690136730670929,
-0.3821702003479004,
-0.8022814989089966,
0.08193279057741165,
0.05039925500750542,
-0.5354302525520325,
-0.1268211454153061,
0.26074790954589844,
-0.3653576970100403,
0.0966210663318634,
-0.8073588013648987,
0.6909115314483643,
-0.30514511466026306,
-0.030825484544038773,
-0.09825429320335388,
-0.828998327255249,
0.011288757435977459,
-0.005446076393127441,
0.41280385851860046,
-0.09708110988140106,
0.2247651070356369,
1.0610204935073853,
-0.13663208484649658,
0.5740857720375061,
-0.32684922218322754,
0.17143385112285614,
0.29706814885139465,
0.03817400708794594,
0.24588125944137573,
-0.0877092033624649,
-0.0730598047375679,
0.40030962228775024,
0.12204908579587936,
-0.18795087933540344,
-0.05547710880637169,
0.5940507650375366,
-0.8991139531135559,
-0.05629967525601387,
-0.5172048807144165,
-0.4225543439388275,
-0.346657931804657,
0.21957187354564667,
0.29039016366004944,
0.5789380669593811,
-0.47800812125205994,
0.46463295817375183,
0.5779091119766235,
-0.36186930537223816,
0.25403571128845215,
0.7348852753639221,
0.15444187819957733,
-0.535361647605896,
1.2239426374435425,
0.24639815092086792,
0.13132555782794952,
0.26569920778274536,
0.4543016850948334,
-0.42566797137260437,
-0.5743760466575623,
-0.8052941560745239,
0.08757031708955765,
-0.4720439612865448,
-0.12584112584590912,
-1.1569769382476807,
-0.41791650652885437,
-0.6242551803588867,
-0.04166606441140175,
-0.7230014204978943,
-0.279950886964798,
-0.0220689345151186,
-0.10622671246528625,
0.672126054763794,
0.7845107316970825,
-0.5030186772346497,
0.19439274072647095,
-0.8484245538711548,
0.36191368103027344,
0.1258379966020584,
0.3544374406337738,
-0.08639439195394516,
-0.6722425818443298,
-0.25454169511795044,
0.21672087907791138,
0.021171629428863525,
-0.5812069773674011,
0.42069530487060547,
0.7856649160385132,
0.5043333172798157,
0.5063733458518982,
-0.16520322859287262,
0.7346950173377991,
-1.0082480907440186,
0.6486716270446777,
0.16482751071453094,
-0.721020519733429,
0.2946758568286896,
-0.5012950301170349,
0.25000256299972534,
0.5532199144363403,
0.5379734039306641,
-0.8499429225921631,
-0.49970027804374695,
-0.3685709834098816,
-0.7598206996917725,
0.7905614376068115,
-0.0826554074883461,
0.4424606263637543,
0.33359572291374207,
-0.16398859024047852,
0.45368361473083496,
0.14764033257961273,
-0.31145063042640686,
-0.08232511579990387,
-0.7654224038124084,
-0.4001966416835785,
-0.30867892503738403,
-0.24944999814033508,
-0.06774412840604782,
-0.21311993896961212,
0.6129013895988464,
-0.21527282893657684,
0.33476540446281433,
-0.12562695145606995,
-0.44267937541007996,
0.1224292516708374,
0.44745075702667236,
0.7604646682739258,
0.3691268563270569,
-0.2213546335697174,
0.3017847239971161,
0.15193220973014832,
-1.012686848640442,
-0.07980140298604965,
0.5409189462661743,
0.04485015571117401,
0.019199950620532036,
0.16249944269657135,
0.6337378025054932,
0.29438093304634094,
-0.8971033096313477,
0.2783397138118744,
0.014940522611141205,
-0.20697806775569916,
-0.7046619653701782,
-0.12836025655269623,
0.45027780532836914,
0.17893069982528687,
0.4153132140636444,
-0.009311133064329624,
0.3408210873603821,
-0.5132209062576294,
0.35834360122680664,
0.30297398567199707,
-0.6742283701896667,
-0.4570895731449127,
0.6311418414115906,
-0.007073253858834505,
-0.48355117440223694,
0.4081096649169922,
-0.2627778649330139,
-0.6852264404296875,
0.16557137668132782,
0.3496638834476471,
0.6963768005371094,
-0.6684439778327942,
0.16511259973049164,
0.47174397110939026,
0.06533923745155334,
-0.2039983570575714,
0.24438004195690155,
-0.2124415934085846,
-0.5464800000190735,
-0.22264617681503296,
-0.8396652936935425,
-0.6619283556938171,
0.12829376757144928,
-0.6865471601486206,
0.2285512238740921,
-0.12217575311660767,
0.14250566065311432,
0.4409450590610504,
-0.2771131992340088,
-0.577825665473938,
-0.16189861297607422,
0.3992627263069153,
0.5856924057006836,
-0.5868699550628662,
0.9312220215797424,
0.578814685344696,
-0.2331373244524002,
-0.5583162307739258,
-0.44653356075286865,
0.4726123809814453,
-1.007408618927002,
0.4821197986602783,
-0.07319279760122299,
-0.4277264177799225,
-0.11633092164993286,
-0.4963330030441284,
-0.8939254283905029,
0.6238719820976257,
0.4372718036174774,
-0.40346768498420715,
0.05431409180164337,
0.12613044679164886,
0.5079196691513062,
-0.1938662827014923,
0.1762501448392868,
0.28680914640426636,
0.23498903214931488,
0.14117957651615143,
-1.2602769136428833,
-0.5740902423858643,
-0.4729483425617218,
-0.28182753920555115,
0.010305842384696007,
-0.7396882772445679,
0.7393271923065186,
-0.16493286192417145,
0.03790475055575371,
0.02596471831202507,
0.6444079279899597,
0.24294227361679077,
0.2580132782459259,
0.3035566806793213,
0.15136787295341492,
0.6250483989715576,
0.16450893878936768,
0.5742813348770142,
-0.26440444588661194,
0.06714065372943878,
1.226609468460083,
-0.22145700454711914,
1.2797659635543823,
0.12536799907684326,
-0.2657221853733063,
0.3568480908870697,
0.4218871593475342,
0.01791347935795784,
0.39460641145706177,
-0.16808359324932098,
-0.5441569089889526,
0.0027510952204465866,
-0.1869824379682541,
-0.4853271543979645,
0.7922298312187195,
0.47376108169555664,
-0.18275265395641327,
-0.17651550471782684,
0.45154905319213867,
0.26051536202430725,
-0.13185307383537292,
-0.2730950713157654,
1.0494194030761719,
0.12795938551425934,
-0.16292715072631836,
0.3117755055427551,
-0.28178372979164124,
1.0711545944213867,
-1.0495309829711914,
0.18970555067062378,
0.20349182188510895,
0.28048402070999146,
-0.0991576611995697,
-0.5501211285591125,
0.31314677000045776,
0.4710911512374878,
-0.06463745981454849,
-0.3048926591873169,
0.6992770433425903,
-0.7192351818084717,
-0.6780712604522705,
0.4083360731601715,
0.4850335121154785,
0.506873369216919,
-0.32538771629333496,
-0.7440352439880371,
0.3109965920448303,
-0.08205077052116394,
-0.02865355834364891,
0.604020893573761,
0.5523144006729126,
0.40122878551483154,
0.6525768041610718,
0.8009580969810486,
0.30402249097824097,
0.3560217022895813,
-0.0338822565972805,
0.7669414281845093,
-0.6233593821525574,
-0.8236830234527588,
-0.6320816874504089,
0.3313008248806,
0.06398020684719086,
-0.350839227437973,
0.8969496488571167,
0.925125241279602,
0.7799014449119568,
-0.08682633191347122,
1.0934571027755737,
-0.01191413588821888,
0.9711479544639587,
-0.4354729652404785,
0.9447770118713379,
-0.3720936179161072,
-0.419902503490448,
-0.33167561888694763,
-0.5711379647254944,
-0.027628229930996895,
0.6353603601455688,
0.02702079899609089,
-0.07573699951171875,
0.39019304513931274,
0.6508155465126038,
-0.28741511702537537,
0.2507611811161041,
0.19157753884792328,
0.14842194318771362,
0.14687159657478333,
0.27488401532173157,
0.8718835711479187,
-0.14119656383991241,
0.9640737771987915,
-0.16101153194904327,
-0.18824134767055511,
-0.055079229176044464,
-0.5219196677207947,
-0.6752034425735474,
-0.9347397089004517,
-0.17084790766239166,
-0.275452196598053,
0.06112516298890114,
1.1812824010849,
0.8019760847091675,
-1.0045500993728638,
-0.5208293199539185,
0.5742924213409424,
-0.4161652624607086,
-0.11882747709751129,
-0.15208816528320312,
0.4081982970237732,
-0.23448090255260468,
-0.8344723582267761,
0.7977078557014465,
0.23720821738243103,
-0.05795437470078468,
-0.3674556612968445,
-0.3893885910511017,
-0.08055746555328369,
-0.3991334140300751,
0.7230349779129028,
0.6688537001609802,
-0.3686181306838989,
-0.20344612002372742,
0.30916479229927063,
0.26068341732025146,
0.36383935809135437,
0.9167774319648743,
-0.4321914613246918,
0.6530519723892212,
0.2088172882795334,
0.7549628615379333,
0.5800892114639282,
-0.06173039600253105,
0.6062172651290894,
-0.6823346018791199,
0.22743260860443115,
0.3028615415096283,
0.30897215008735657,
0.6590206623077393,
-0.20399107038974762,
0.2944183051586151,
-0.06992873549461365,
-0.6123624444007874,
-0.96883225440979,
-0.12618842720985413,
-1.0958503484725952,
0.015497512184083462,
1.3498005867004395,
0.010198494419455528,
-0.09520260244607925,
-0.5238597989082336,
-0.3108865022659302,
0.17260833084583282,
-1.0426889657974243,
0.5833441019058228,
0.8006381988525391,
-0.22276124358177185,
-0.39155304431915283,
-0.950865626335144,
0.8900089859962463,
-0.12617158889770508,
-0.5619959831237793,
0.27039849758148193,
0.2820650637149811,
0.4673916697502136,
0.47072097659111023,
0.792270302772522,
-0.14392466843128204,
0.24167990684509277,
0.20220015943050385,
0.10708023607730865,
-0.12851059436798096,
-0.40547487139701843,
-0.43743446469306946,
0.24086475372314453,
0.11907852441072464,
-0.27865228056907654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18297v1 | FactFinders at CheckThat! 2024: Refining Check-worthy Statement Detection with LLMs through Data Pruning | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | 2024-06-26T12:31:31 | Yufeng Li, Rrubaa Panchendrarajan, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid dissemination of information through social media and the Internet
has posed a significant challenge for fact-checking, among others in
identifying check-worthy claims that fact-checkers should pay attention to,
i.e. filtering claims needing fact-checking from a large pool of sentences.
This challenge has stressed the need to focus on determining the priority of
claims, specifically which claims are worth to be fact-checked. Despite
advancements in this area in recent years, the application of large language
models (LLMs), such as GPT, has only recently drawn attention in studies.
However, many open-source LLMs remain underexplored. Therefore, this study
investigates the application of eight prominent open-source LLMs with
fine-tuning and prompt engineering to identify check-worthy statements from
political transcriptions. Further, we propose a two-step data pruning approach
to automatically identify high-quality training data instances for effective
learning. The efficiency of our approach is demonstrated through evaluations on
the English language dataset as part of the check-worthiness estimation task of
CheckThat! 2024. Further, the experiments conducted with data pruning
demonstrate that competitive performance can be achieved with only about 44\%
of the training data. Our team ranked first in the check-worthiness estimation
task in the English language. | [
-0.4129946827888489,
-0.7281904816627502,
0.8179697394371033,
-0.02574101649224758,
-0.6290813684463501,
0.22886653244495392,
-0.3015499711036682,
-0.3995051681995392,
0.1323302984237671,
0.6069460511207581,
-0.5070844888687134,
-0.55914705991745,
-0.6888364553451538,
0.1842222809791565,
-0.4743420481681824,
1.007305383682251,
-0.03338855877518654,
-0.10971445590257645,
-0.2840093672275543,
-0.03789583593606949,
-0.4333376884460449,
-0.47225096821784973,
-0.4518038332462311,
-0.4734038710594177,
0.35387155413627625,
0.5823159217834473,
0.5068674087524414,
0.9160524606704712,
0.5165149569511414,
0.28532132506370544,
-0.19093337655067444,
0.5215994715690613,
-0.5582549571990967,
0.03510311245918274,
-0.3169267177581787,
-0.6174954771995544,
-0.15221619606018066,
0.312032550573349,
0.4662438929080963,
0.2620353698730469,
0.03554408624768257,
0.24873362481594086,
-0.005434597376734018,
0.5843887329101562,
-0.5645262002944946,
0.3254803717136383,
-0.8515728116035461,
-0.13952553272247314,
-0.38153207302093506,
-0.3085170388221741,
-0.2588409185409546,
-0.8806963562965393,
-0.09144926071166992,
-0.12367578595876694,
0.4240567088127136,
0.07058747857809067,
1.1593458652496338,
0.2391333132982254,
-0.4026893079280853,
-0.333378404378891,
-0.523631751537323,
0.7827001810073853,
-0.6295279860496521,
0.4784576892852783,
0.4734134078025818,
0.02490903064608574,
-0.1440054327249527,
-0.6378072500228882,
-0.590160608291626,
-0.16409249603748322,
-0.06215411424636841,
0.09717314690351486,
-0.1330307573080063,
-0.02583758533000946,
0.282205730676651,
0.5071256756782532,
-0.5443094968795776,
0.11048851907253265,
-0.3589833974838257,
-0.44276267290115356,
0.6550285816192627,
-0.23990517854690552,
0.00870506651699543,
-0.1699405461549759,
-0.42844051122665405,
0.012262995354831219,
-0.9255712628364563,
-0.12899665534496307,
0.3467828333377838,
0.31926462054252625,
0.10492835193872452,
0.7421882748603821,
-0.3214634954929352,
0.5262210369110107,
-0.002609045011922717,
-0.21813879907131195,
0.05538909509778023,
-0.7396047115325928,
-0.2505509853363037,
-0.06616365164518356,
0.72621089220047,
0.42416805028915405,
0.12398486584424973,
-0.18913833796977997,
-0.4015825092792511,
0.35791975259780884,
0.03849142789840698,
-0.8593969345092773,
-0.3902119994163513,
0.2506917119026184,
-0.40753671526908875,
-0.3517475128173828,
0.16584691405296326,
-0.7730419039726257,
-0.6445634961128235,
-0.5168390274047852,
0.19822855293750763,
-0.33871057629585266,
-0.13880689442157745,
0.11347949504852295,
-0.07034669071435928,
0.202284574508667,
0.38456565141677856,
-0.22929951548576355,
-0.22031541168689728,
0.9292773604393005,
1.0025302171707153,
-0.2884122431278229,
0.10607382655143738,
-0.8089185357093811,
-0.19454140961170197,
-0.4384816288948059,
1.0333927869796753,
-0.5260529518127441,
-0.1543489694595337,
0.04913989081978798,
0.09814735502004623,
0.1730836182832718,
-0.7741222977638245,
1.0685101747512817,
-0.6330828666687012,
0.23856908082962036,
-0.53338623046875,
-0.7143261432647705,
-0.06853488087654114,
0.5192491412162781,
-0.8017388582229614,
0.907897412776947,
-0.2191268354654312,
-0.6070072054862976,
0.6090645790100098,
-0.48490503430366516,
-0.44929251074790955,
0.05643559619784355,
-0.14927856624126434,
-0.8052790760993958,
0.12036313116550446,
0.20426702499389648,
0.47730720043182373,
-0.32070988416671753,
0.5257391929626465,
-0.10507158190011978,
-0.19994379580020905,
0.27975985407829285,
-0.2843598425388336,
0.7913461923599243,
0.17225831747055054,
-0.44969186186790466,
0.2757156789302826,
-0.8080059885978699,
-0.02576933428645134,
-0.05982987955212593,
-0.6607589721679688,
-0.01624183915555477,
0.21898764371871948,
-0.2343885898590088,
0.30583956837654114,
0.18371456861495972,
-0.6853672862052917,
0.16109445691108704,
-0.3041701912879944,
0.4139113128185272,
0.8193675875663757,
0.062487125396728516,
0.04206226393580437,
-0.650154709815979,
0.463119238615036,
-0.03169991075992584,
0.03482376039028168,
0.014507574029266834,
-0.3289199769496918,
-0.9690588116645813,
-0.3729023039340973,
0.46719416975975037,
0.6987526416778564,
-0.776901125907898,
0.654155969619751,
-0.08470632880926132,
-0.5869447588920593,
-0.42777013778686523,
0.05492853373289108,
0.018217243254184723,
0.26476117968559265,
0.38303142786026,
-0.05889670178294182,
-0.7734849452972412,
-0.8596075177192688,
-0.6580782532691956,
-0.3842275142669678,
-0.029370753094553947,
-0.1422663927078247,
0.5674939155578613,
0.073732890188694,
1.0639995336532593,
-0.4225611984729767,
-0.19738277792930603,
-0.21449780464172363,
0.10112619400024414,
0.15402492880821228,
0.1191980242729187,
0.10862735658884048,
-0.7660379409790039,
-0.1319536715745926,
-0.24016623198986053,
-0.4135286509990692,
-0.12233935296535492,
-0.2273753583431244,
0.10251050442457199,
-0.10047914832830429,
0.35433393716812134,
-0.6676589846611023,
0.19676345586776733,
0.47383221983909607,
-0.399353951215744,
0.5330840349197388,
0.06450586020946503,
0.22809629142284393,
-0.7664430141448975,
-0.13876590132713318,
0.1895769238471985,
-0.6679363250732422,
-0.4756414592266083,
0.0037950293626636267,
0.1599535495042801,
0.11135975271463394,
-0.33663493394851685,
0.18244357407093048,
-0.4869517385959625,
0.1645534187555313,
-0.4012899398803711,
0.07262276113033295,
-0.23987416923046112,
0.14172638952732086,
-0.10147485136985779,
0.7979311347007751,
0.5317056179046631,
-0.7085933685302734,
0.3355018198490143,
0.12713858485221863,
-0.7377246022224426,
0.5262936353683472,
-0.42684730887413025,
0.16418862342834473,
-0.05423747003078461,
0.22976048290729523,
-0.9604432582855225,
-0.15074580907821655,
0.0687539353966713,
-0.3772570490837097,
0.14322566986083984,
-0.2257845550775528,
-0.5162621736526489,
-0.3334226906299591,
-0.4238205850124359,
-0.16072507202625275,
0.43266725540161133,
-0.7475282549858093,
0.3126399517059326,
0.6310804486274719,
-0.2498137205839157,
-0.33728429675102234,
-0.5038333535194397,
0.36076250672340393,
-0.325343519449234,
-0.3469547629356384,
0.2093643844127655,
0.08112583309412003,
-0.29212817549705505,
-0.11217096447944641,
-0.428058385848999,
-0.09078984707593918,
0.17350853979587555,
0.021335436031222343,
0.31994473934173584,
0.029315929859876633,
0.09082939475774765,
-0.37206584215164185,
-0.14339888095855713,
0.28192147612571716,
-0.3048095405101776,
0.21724669635295868,
-0.11049339920282364,
-0.3748799264431,
-0.42639410495758057,
-0.004244079347699881,
0.575093150138855,
-0.5526040196418762,
0.6470387578010559,
0.5898278951644897,
-0.27946358919143677,
-0.3161585032939911,
-0.8361477255821228,
-0.35139229893684387,
-0.47603312134742737,
0.22488552331924438,
0.09036337584257126,
-1.2940127849578857,
0.17802032828330994,
-0.40852847695350647,
0.3810732960700989,
0.4011692702770233,
0.5436968803405762,
0.03338761627674103,
0.8339834809303284,
0.5253177285194397,
-0.11315358430147171,
0.484072208404541,
-0.05540676414966583,
0.515083909034729,
-0.07192890346050262,
-0.08001639693975449,
-0.7625086903572083,
-0.11174609512090683,
-0.6895779967308044,
-0.5570062398910522,
0.2930136024951935,
-0.21898607909679413,
0.04694502428174019,
0.10708551108837128,
-0.5040064454078674,
0.6205905675888062,
0.4219496548175812,
0.11609547585248947,
0.44676393270492554,
0.10949018597602844,
0.44249457120895386,
-0.04217289015650749,
-0.42782607674598694,
-0.5569929480552673,
0.9323816895484924,
0.3539116382598877,
0.4867917001247406,
-0.06500498950481415,
0.6886866688728333,
0.36861759424209595,
0.42579659819602966,
-0.7557744979858398,
0.8238147497177124,
-0.08746907860040665,
-0.4549567699432373,
-0.27306681871414185,
-0.7560983896255493,
-0.7115990519523621,
0.19750963151454926,
-0.2551233172416687,
-0.322304368019104,
0.1755891591310501,
0.25540128350257874,
-0.1932392567396164,
0.5081039667129517,
-0.4064696133136749,
0.4722203016281128,
-0.38432225584983826,
-0.30387943983078003,
-0.39106670022010803,
-0.20871876180171967,
0.456441730260849,
-0.11571373790502548,
0.3593384623527527,
-0.23721948266029358,
-0.0990438312292099,
0.8729234933853149,
-0.4474412500858307,
0.850161075592041,
-0.29638391733169556,
-0.1798865646123886,
0.2979203760623932,
-0.14379659295082092,
0.8742308616638184,
-0.12117018550634384,
-0.018531423062086105,
0.1410958617925644,
-0.21849608421325684,
-0.19578903913497925,
-0.1857062727212906,
0.5453495979309082,
-0.3670932650566101,
-0.6562581062316895,
-0.45815509557724,
-0.18326795101165771,
-0.27856555581092834,
0.29753655195236206,
0.18310315907001495,
0.27279993891716003,
-0.36433178186416626,
0.5212453007698059,
0.8788571953773499,
0.06916198134422302,
0.163727805018425,
0.637566864490509,
0.059666335582733154,
-0.3327029347419739,
1.1291967630386353,
0.36566630005836487,
-0.0967855229973793,
0.33970212936401367,
0.3745536804199219,
-0.3860667049884796,
-0.9191442131996155,
-0.047780271619558334,
0.45525234937667847,
-0.43267929553985596,
-0.41699469089508057,
-0.4977455139160156,
0.04977452754974365,
-0.08616553246974945,
0.15875421464443207,
-0.39662906527519226,
-0.4779600203037262,
0.025753814727067947,
-0.26851364970207214,
0.42065495252609253,
0.7433710098266602,
-0.1127573698759079,
0.1665697693824768,
-0.5626169443130493,
0.4212454855442047,
0.31338992714881897,
0.6084303855895996,
-0.6415692567825317,
-0.3117721378803253,
-0.31740379333496094,
-0.0002765011158771813,
-0.38377538323402405,
-0.8139041662216187,
0.11654364317655563,
0.07470862567424774,
0.36405229568481445,
0.09929657727479935,
0.16501326858997345,
0.3372937738895416,
-0.2857201397418976,
0.8135443329811096,
-0.033521268516778946,
-0.6123388409614563,
0.5275163054466248,
-0.1570739448070526,
-0.04963288456201553,
0.64857017993927,
0.3423345386981964,
-0.2536555826663971,
-0.5367518663406372,
-0.6029417514801025,
-0.8584291934967041,
0.5742577314376831,
0.18869365751743317,
-0.24844788014888763,
-0.08851323276758194,
0.21569819748401642,
0.06333895027637482,
0.34441566467285156,
-0.45626428723335266,
-0.13466808199882507,
-0.0858386904001236,
-0.15851585566997528,
-0.005218167789280415,
-0.32974082231521606,
-0.2710164487361908,
-0.060530565679073334,
0.9425038695335388,
-0.15499289333820343,
-0.0011693037813529372,
0.1590193510055542,
-0.02955777570605278,
-0.06555362045764923,
0.6669687628746033,
0.4337441325187683,
0.800523579120636,
-0.15485292673110962,
0.0951053723692894,
0.008308741264045238,
-0.524769127368927,
0.246482253074646,
0.21916848421096802,
-0.48647618293762207,
0.3617646396160126,
0.16577933728694916,
0.6475799679756165,
-0.06150763854384422,
-0.48680582642555237,
0.5761128067970276,
-0.0022171647287905216,
-0.29876708984375,
-0.07070569694042206,
0.015117471106350422,
0.0816233828663826,
0.12430012971162796,
0.2044946253299713,
0.10905394703149796,
-0.00113095308188349,
-0.5960120558738708,
0.3211100399494171,
0.5765007734298706,
-0.15626299381256104,
-0.2997380495071411,
0.47011756896972656,
0.3012482523918152,
-0.07644679397344589,
0.3916088342666626,
-0.21252265572547913,
-0.825814425945282,
0.5550723075866699,
0.1854676753282547,
0.8615729212760925,
-0.24293935298919678,
0.20437636971473694,
0.4594915211200714,
0.7060850262641907,
-0.46456846594810486,
0.3657063841819763,
0.02625243365764618,
-0.5995820760726929,
-0.7535508871078491,
-0.38329896330833435,
-0.714033305644989,
0.5832010507583618,
-0.3519904911518097,
0.2972460687160492,
-0.413114070892334,
-0.3742496073246002,
0.0063792867586016655,
0.3320736289024353,
-0.8217864036560059,
0.30550941824913025,
-0.0716012716293335,
0.931912899017334,
-0.8759573101997375,
0.6450984477996826,
0.5812655091285706,
-0.0920146107673645,
-0.6599820852279663,
0.14587584137916565,
0.33827659487724304,
-0.6030924320220947,
0.38125887513160706,
0.20143264532089233,
-0.03721850737929344,
-0.09268394857645035,
-0.7866675853729248,
-0.5799701809883118,
0.872161865234375,
0.6545928120613098,
-0.782649040222168,
-0.11216827481985092,
0.0982925295829773,
0.042120255529880524,
0.11085188388824463,
-0.019522612914443016,
0.7729562520980835,
0.8187007904052734,
-0.10770004987716675,
-0.7967455983161926,
-0.06431493163108826,
0.047479454427957535,
-0.5796036720275879,
0.33130958676338196,
-0.7740564942359924,
0.6417154669761658,
0.05070570856332779,
-0.4662933349609375,
-0.230167418718338,
0.7623667120933533,
0.29089412093162537,
0.2846282124519348,
0.825386643409729,
0.4771753251552582,
1.1543223857879639,
-0.3994089663028717,
0.9050371050834656,
-0.3057498037815094,
0.27146998047828674,
0.898672342300415,
-0.17227157950401306,
0.5919631123542786,
0.2829987704753876,
-0.23861224949359894,
0.2240610122680664,
0.5811499953269958,
-0.2634628117084503,
0.2458454668521881,
0.18590989708900452,
-0.24213699996471405,
-0.47621041536331177,
-0.36093345284461975,
-0.12537431716918945,
0.4242781698703766,
0.4465707242488861,
-0.13236947357654572,
-0.3064458668231964,
-0.12860071659088135,
0.21079707145690918,
0.05599284917116165,
-0.22536398470401764,
0.8004209399223328,
-0.06848299503326416,
-0.9082410931587219,
0.485605388879776,
-0.07075834274291992,
0.7594531178474426,
-0.6113142967224121,
-0.14648468792438507,
-0.1334221363067627,
0.08060961961746216,
-0.29418155550956726,
-0.9603135585784912,
0.15531416237354279,
0.365291565656662,
-0.14145830273628235,
-0.46959105134010315,
0.8864721059799194,
-0.6344313025474548,
-0.2361140102148056,
0.02734922058880329,
0.5935502052307129,
0.154738187789917,
-0.3321319818496704,
-0.5837551355361938,
0.24337299168109894,
0.28971242904663086,
-0.25366225838661194,
0.19298958778381348,
0.44569313526153564,
-0.012546890415251255,
0.6248763203620911,
0.771791934967041,
0.5182718634605408,
-0.37855303287506104,
0.01363562885671854,
1.000271201133728,
-0.4279259443283081,
-0.4877891540527344,
-0.9134579300880432,
0.333922803401947,
-0.2907986044883728,
-0.041026849299669266,
0.9738512635231018,
0.8326270580291748,
0.9096048474311829,
0.15852555632591248,
1.0310156345367432,
0.030341630801558495,
0.8514890670776367,
-0.6315202713012695,
0.6600929498672485,
-0.27014121413230896,
0.1943168193101883,
0.06437992304563522,
-0.7670281529426575,
-0.13144627213478088,
0.48964396119117737,
-0.36877724528312683,
-0.09515649080276489,
0.5409164428710938,
1.005632758140564,
-0.09522745758295059,
0.16267748177051544,
0.14312539994716644,
0.3327018618583679,
0.5742929577827454,
0.20639608800411224,
0.8015362620353699,
-0.026729770004749298,
0.7108139991760254,
-0.18209008872509003,
-0.2644070088863373,
-0.24130645394325256,
-1.1631457805633545,
-0.9267176985740662,
-0.4428236782550812,
-0.6374673843383789,
-0.4716782867908478,
0.04248187690973282,
0.7185646891593933,
0.6497251987457275,
-0.9491332769393921,
0.09074646234512329,
-0.053378067910671234,
0.2964015007019043,
-0.10119695216417313,
-0.19745700061321259,
0.45917484164237976,
-0.20257338881492615,
-0.3116002380847931,
0.6336526274681091,
0.11862193048000336,
-0.2701883018016815,
-0.08384162932634354,
0.18757835030555725,
-0.3246174156665802,
0.2666163742542267,
0.46268174052238464,
0.31468191742897034,
-0.5482078790664673,
-0.4052659273147583,
-0.12206711620092392,
0.11772844940423965,
0.0600658617913723,
1.2275042533874512,
-0.7331265211105347,
0.4053904116153717,
0.5187016129493713,
0.8875293135643005,
0.29331862926483154,
0.2906714081764221,
0.3489842712879181,
-0.7251952886581421,
-0.22953203320503235,
0.19714389741420746,
0.3866993188858032,
0.645194411277771,
-0.21979278326034546,
0.614316463470459,
0.32763156294822693,
-0.8292737603187561,
-0.943912923336029,
0.1814526915550232,
-0.633741021156311,
-0.16708427667617798,
1.030849814414978,
0.08088986575603485,
-0.11674420535564423,
-0.3062940537929535,
-0.26241597533226013,
0.334664911031723,
-0.39422303438186646,
0.763986349105835,
0.9122052788734436,
0.18530254065990448,
-0.12342267483472824,
-0.7118278741836548,
0.7615737915039062,
0.34378716349601746,
-0.9234448075294495,
0.38409337401390076,
0.5716234445571899,
0.2635037899017334,
0.06948350369930267,
0.49656346440315247,
0.04120505228638649,
0.3151428699493408,
-0.5613208413124084,
-0.22846627235412598,
-0.10004249960184097,
-0.12727263569831848,
-0.24658192694187164,
0.2924492657184601,
0.10909673571586609,
-0.3036061227321625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18294v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18294v2 | Hierarchical Context Pruning: Optimizing Real-World Code Completion with Repository-Level Pretrained Code LLMs | 2024-06-26T12:26:16 | 2024-06-27T04:40:52 | Lei Zhang, Yunshui Li, Jiaming Li, Xiaobo Xia, Jiaxi Yang, Run Luo, Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Junhao Liu, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some recently developed code large language models (Code LLMs) have been
pre-trained on repository-level code data (Repo-Code LLMs), enabling these
models to recognize repository structures and utilize cross-file information
for code completion. However, in real-world development scenarios, simply
concatenating the entire code repository often exceeds the context window
limits of these Repo-Code LLMs, leading to significant performance degradation.
In this study, we conducted extensive preliminary experiments and analyses on
six Repo-Code LLMs. The results indicate that maintaining the topological
dependencies of files and increasing the code file content in the completion
prompts can improve completion accuracy; pruning the specific implementations
of functions in all dependent files does not significantly reduce the accuracy
of completions. Based on these findings, we proposed a strategy named
Hierarchical Context Pruning (HCP) to construct completion prompts with high
informational code content. The HCP models the code repository at the function
level, maintaining the topological dependencies between code files while
removing a large amount of irrelevant code content, significantly reduces the
input length for repository-level code completion. We applied the HCP strategy
in experiments with six Repo-Code LLMs, and the results demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly enhance completion accuracy while
substantially reducing the length of input. Our code and data are available at
https://github.com/Hambaobao/HCP-Coder. | [
-0.5283944606781006,
-0.48574674129486084,
0.4219847023487091,
0.20867620408535004,
-0.432294636964798,
0.3154747486114502,
-0.3203172981739044,
-0.4826032817363739,
0.15728847682476044,
0.33445239067077637,
-0.5984309315681458,
-0.6185687184333801,
-0.3209629952907562,
0.18671433627605438,
-0.09841766953468323,
0.7439920902252197,
-0.04400975629687309,
-0.1330937296152115,
-0.4992649257183075,
0.016492078080773354,
-0.684726893901825,
-0.6603205800056458,
-0.06109170988202095,
-0.14571526646614075,
0.5642302632331848,
0.6359759569168091,
0.476318359375,
0.9548817873001099,
0.658860445022583,
0.2559570372104645,
-0.14080291986465454,
0.15961197018623352,
-0.5607089996337891,
0.2094113677740097,
0.29431474208831787,
-0.44387149810791016,
-0.35413312911987305,
-0.24769219756126404,
0.5787184834480286,
0.45485350489616394,
-0.14166268706321716,
0.16424818336963654,
0.3101530969142914,
0.7703170776367188,
-0.9060671925544739,
0.10128681361675262,
-0.19395866990089417,
0.2163379043340683,
0.033520229160785675,
-0.7270737886428833,
-0.29833129048347473,
-0.377979040145874,
0.23999066650867462,
-0.618740975856781,
-0.11626677960157394,
-0.06103184446692467,
0.6373832821846008,
0.4667748510837555,
-0.25979939103126526,
-0.15404708683490753,
-0.7366997003555298,
0.6315019726753235,
-0.7558504343032837,
0.21769662201404572,
0.31882208585739136,
0.01824381947517395,
0.005212318617850542,
-0.6328619122505188,
-0.1778729259967804,
-0.32814821600914,
-0.3832162320613861,
0.11891166865825653,
0.30130550265312195,
0.2846407890319824,
0.48825201392173767,
0.3087708652019501,
-0.5200725197792053,
-0.13619695603847504,
-0.3039160966873169,
-0.16420982778072357,
0.033690135926008224,
-0.13362431526184082,
0.32642778754234314,
-0.277848482131958,
-0.3390102684497833,
-0.02820279262959957,
-1.0420706272125244,
0.06781718879938126,
0.16058261692523956,
0.07573718577623367,
-0.007815255783498287,
0.4547395408153534,
-0.10968293994665146,
0.7944231033325195,
-0.0774652510881424,
-0.3991086483001709,
0.24540606141090393,
-0.4519729018211365,
-0.16993004083633423,
-0.13997752964496613,
0.3544104993343353,
0.2676485478878021,
0.4042666554450989,
-0.1420644372701645,
-0.30161914229393005,
-0.18553653359413147,
0.5548419952392578,
-0.8493542671203613,
-0.014805935323238373,
0.41256842017173767,
-0.4243371784687042,
-0.27915462851524353,
0.060885608196258545,
-0.4430231750011444,
-0.31374722719192505,
-0.5747975707054138,
0.0755411833524704,
-0.43509218096733093,
-0.039258699864149094,
-0.21807613968849182,
0.03556816652417183,
0.29416489601135254,
0.3531990349292755,
-0.41097399592399597,
0.19514018297195435,
0.6754838228225708,
0.9892192482948303,
-0.13115379214286804,
-0.43892502784729004,
-0.8598544001579285,
0.42545926570892334,
-0.31286513805389404,
0.5099411606788635,
-0.4061937928199768,
-0.3399554193019867,
0.17319613695144653,
-0.1380939781665802,
0.28247538208961487,
-0.820624589920044,
0.15993793308734894,
-0.5117400884628296,
-0.10535355657339096,
-0.2364603728055954,
-0.439314603805542,
0.20684702694416046,
0.5024020671844482,
-0.5690959095954895,
0.808740496635437,
0.3652603030204773,
-0.8664690852165222,
0.30400511622428894,
-0.1938525140285492,
-0.5986612439155579,
0.19257192313671112,
-0.4407109022140503,
-0.35259026288986206,
-0.029222795739769936,
0.09857739508152008,
0.3504906892776489,
-0.15396112203598022,
0.6254558563232422,
-0.04802422225475311,
-0.8412545323371887,
-0.28983640670776367,
0.26955482363700867,
0.513994038105011,
0.1276615411043167,
-0.4272829294204712,
0.3428382873535156,
-0.4767622947692871,
-0.08255311101675034,
-0.08540444821119308,
-0.6587089896202087,
-0.2426878809928894,
-0.0678323358297348,
0.024424340575933456,
0.2535962462425232,
0.40189266204833984,
-0.22771325707435608,
0.37072691321372986,
-0.19587142765522003,
0.37627559900283813,
0.6766349673271179,
-0.05791890248656273,
0.7766146063804626,
-0.6749086380004883,
0.7717602252960205,
0.02211536467075348,
0.24649988114833832,
-0.3708832561969757,
-0.1665327399969101,
-0.5148727297782898,
-0.41182565689086914,
0.34896835684776306,
0.7267406582832336,
-0.7865604162216187,
0.6627105474472046,
-0.20550504326820374,
-0.18705064058303833,
0.12687845528125763,
0.12546983361244202,
0.5322908759117126,
0.5438578128814697,
0.30242857336997986,
-0.36108455061912537,
-0.8288356065750122,
-0.7948989868164062,
-0.10869830846786499,
-0.16645357012748718,
-0.24058350920677185,
0.3931029736995697,
0.5756652355194092,
-0.35099494457244873,
1.0861613750457764,
-0.474101722240448,
-0.4161258935928345,
-0.10409051924943924,
-0.22526335716247559,
0.08628722280263901,
0.7108359336853027,
0.3815728425979614,
-0.8102964758872986,
-0.1702253371477127,
-0.1410500407218933,
-0.5400183796882629,
-0.134006530046463,
-0.04536961019039154,
0.07421236485242844,
0.04721854627132416,
0.6685521602630615,
-0.5186518430709839,
0.29086166620254517,
0.535067617893219,
0.06371918320655823,
0.8122680187225342,
-0.3605978190898895,
0.1847773641347885,
-0.7890690565109253,
0.1681368201971054,
-0.12200263887643814,
-0.32536956667900085,
-0.405796617269516,
0.3695923388004303,
0.3610744774341583,
-0.23212307691574097,
-0.5855980515480042,
0.37860774993896484,
-0.7668631672859192,
-0.2608484923839569,
0.008245851844549179,
0.01522575318813324,
-0.16339045763015747,
0.78377765417099,
0.11108240485191345,
0.8178486824035645,
0.42752858996391296,
-0.514744222164154,
0.1054171621799469,
-0.10536159574985504,
-0.4486526548862457,
0.08079322427511215,
-0.6135218143463135,
-0.04182233288884163,
0.03149911016225815,
0.49355822801589966,
-0.7882422804832458,
-0.36642664670944214,
0.01672086864709854,
-0.18295791745185852,
0.3969042897224426,
-0.5071481466293335,
-0.6070747971534729,
-0.1440695822238922,
-0.34212827682495117,
0.6440450549125671,
0.6705769896507263,
-0.4254806935787201,
0.3081836402416229,
0.45988309383392334,
-0.17471721768379211,
-0.6400178670883179,
-0.7132952213287354,
0.08310331404209137,
-0.26850759983062744,
-0.5379498600959778,
0.5317551493644714,
-0.05379442870616913,
0.04958340525627136,
-0.3518124520778656,
-0.37209147214889526,
-0.10481476038694382,
0.17215965688228607,
0.2874121069908142,
0.2489514946937561,
0.003497214987874031,
0.04136739671230316,
-0.12163190543651581,
-0.14470967650413513,
-0.03476007655262947,
-0.5401909947395325,
0.5268532037734985,
-0.14589619636535645,
-0.3278968632221222,
-0.3621952533721924,
0.3064749538898468,
0.5551314949989319,
-0.057319276034832,
0.5044639706611633,
0.0945126935839653,
-0.5468140840530396,
-0.17822222411632538,
-0.47141939401626587,
-0.1574004739522934,
-0.46664324402809143,
0.15430715680122375,
-0.2622365355491638,
-1.247391700744629,
0.5239359140396118,
-0.40945613384246826,
0.1342768520116806,
-0.21494406461715698,
0.22637665271759033,
-0.10053244978189468,
0.6125068068504333,
0.7090789675712585,
-0.1302100419998169,
0.8847616314888,
-0.4312379062175751,
0.22556172311306,
-0.6700305342674255,
-0.0682884082198143,
-0.5785776376724243,
-0.2638047933578491,
-0.5545281767845154,
-0.6041398644447327,
0.36670181155204773,
0.35891246795654297,
-0.1651483178138733,
0.4916914701461792,
-0.6364574432373047,
0.6465359330177307,
0.5654542446136475,
0.13285204768180847,
0.432719886302948,
-0.051755260676145554,
-0.02087348699569702,
0.06297268718481064,
-0.9147243499755859,
-0.2677444517612457,
0.6841651797294617,
0.43557408452033997,
0.6022863388061523,
-0.10647673904895782,
0.9400098919868469,
0.1380166858434677,
0.2350950986146927,
-0.8698840141296387,
0.34876906871795654,
0.20564907789230347,
-0.2517862319946289,
-0.28059419989585876,
-0.6737269163131714,
-0.6445072889328003,
0.015550002455711365,
0.10594408959150314,
-0.44440940022468567,
0.4011642038822174,
0.3657552897930145,
-0.3611026108264923,
0.016359703615307808,
-0.6530903577804565,
0.801506519317627,
-0.001170004834420979,
-0.20036061108112335,
-0.10473780333995819,
-0.7527056932449341,
0.30238768458366394,
-0.05457349494099617,
0.33364078402519226,
0.3999452292919159,
-0.285952627658844,
0.4957050085067749,
-0.7187977433204651,
0.6988059878349304,
-0.24050632119178772,
-0.2816048264503479,
0.21962212026119232,
0.22151854634284973,
0.7301551699638367,
0.25464463233947754,
0.2679937481880188,
0.12245656549930573,
-0.017787989228963852,
-0.5525110960006714,
-0.5319299697875977,
0.6720876097679138,
-0.6112513542175293,
-0.6258938908576965,
-0.20034289360046387,
-0.6264773607254028,
-0.2925289273262024,
0.302229642868042,
0.3902984857559204,
0.7856259346008301,
0.12570679187774658,
0.45032012462615967,
0.7564225792884827,
-0.23651739954948425,
0.30845072865486145,
-0.031358152627944946,
-0.14810717105865479,
-0.4760003387928009,
0.647294819355011,
0.16412712633609772,
0.20614907145500183,
0.5274467468261719,
-0.05819921940565109,
-0.0022632020991295576,
-0.7559221386909485,
-0.3292495906352997,
0.08896584808826447,
-0.5145436525344849,
-0.40759727358818054,
-0.4965672791004181,
-0.26487502455711365,
-0.38039013743400574,
-0.5370862483978271,
-0.1842203587293625,
-0.2837463617324829,
-0.00011853020259877667,
0.15019865334033966,
0.08766252547502518,
0.5477049350738525,
0.22362393140792847,
0.45957574248313904,
-1.11443030834198,
0.35937991738319397,
0.08947345614433289,
0.4606805443763733,
0.025235923007130623,
-0.27168118953704834,
-0.5594155788421631,
-0.021947231143712997,
-0.03236601874232292,
-0.7428871989250183,
0.34856557846069336,
-0.12055165320634842,
0.3772147297859192,
0.08504534512758255,
0.15710577368736267,
0.7101691365242004,
-0.4456064701080322,
0.36542725563049316,
0.23827672004699707,
-0.8570575714111328,
0.719940185546875,
-0.6967462301254272,
0.8062492609024048,
0.733339786529541,
0.23867914080619812,
-0.3940366506576538,
-0.5946932435035706,
-0.3711598515510559,
-1.0067099332809448,
0.575985312461853,
0.23639754951000214,
-0.28563565015792847,
0.1252991259098053,
0.5543904304504395,
-0.24225427210330963,
0.3016211688518524,
-0.6584942936897278,
-0.16250135004520416,
0.14355726540088654,
0.015121114440262318,
0.1696120947599411,
-0.24456056952476501,
-0.26189836859703064,
-0.27051353454589844,
0.2862969934940338,
-0.3499223589897156,
0.08823571354150772,
0.402742475271225,
-0.4611736238002777,
-0.08458088338375092,
0.24360550940036774,
0.5025368332862854,
1.1708438396453857,
-0.3120438754558563,
0.009178138338029385,
0.026968924328684807,
-0.5784598588943481,
0.11813639104366302,
-0.26573219895362854,
-0.1583367884159088,
-0.10657817870378494,
0.5707556009292603,
0.22910122573375702,
0.290844202041626,
-0.7552246451377869,
0.5743698477745056,
-0.13704563677310944,
-0.15506114065647125,
-0.3582785427570343,
0.08911734074354172,
0.18287210166454315,
0.011504087597131729,
0.5164778828620911,
0.23044446110725403,
0.08707614988088608,
-0.6290546655654907,
0.36902138590812683,
0.19792337715625763,
-0.350534588098526,
0.14037171006202698,
0.09694930166006088,
0.37897059321403503,
-0.32013681530952454,
0.5252814292907715,
0.12262821197509766,
-0.5885489583015442,
1.0006738901138306,
0.37019410729408264,
0.7082839012145996,
0.14597927033901215,
0.00019735743990167975,
0.4405404329299927,
0.3243102431297302,
-0.17047567665576935,
0.10154443979263306,
-0.5175862312316895,
-0.3804076611995697,
-0.85869961977005,
-0.6313744187355042,
-0.37181660532951355,
-0.014929486438632011,
-0.5695235133171082,
0.22786709666252136,
-0.700453519821167,
-0.0026417921762913465,
-0.6360425353050232,
0.21806292235851288,
-0.22575326263904572,
0.17344725131988525,
-0.05527699366211891,
1.098280906677246,
-0.46479901671409607,
1.0439941883087158,
0.7113463878631592,
-0.15163229405879974,
-0.7161775231361389,
0.2644147574901581,
-0.038604985922575,
-0.28983062505722046,
0.41233664751052856,
0.36696121096611023,
-0.07213792949914932,
0.09331908077001572,
-0.5153451561927795,
-0.8808070421218872,
1.1389484405517578,
0.36165305972099304,
-0.9323386549949646,
-0.3032347559928894,
-0.1328297257423401,
0.4457235038280487,
-0.5026258826255798,
0.05824282765388489,
0.5013348460197449,
0.5243042707443237,
0.1564621776342392,
-0.8475779294967651,
0.17169822752475739,
-0.4579378068447113,
0.16821570694446564,
0.39913424849510193,
-0.22529076039791107,
0.4831297695636749,
-0.39890018105506897,
-0.22058677673339844,
0.1749068647623062,
0.48744112253189087,
0.7890546321868896,
0.0006082050385884941,
0.6870437264442444,
0.3519802391529083,
0.5865662693977356,
-0.07582063972949982,
1.012668490409851,
-0.5963749885559082,
0.3331539034843445,
1.097374439239502,
-0.12344174087047577,
0.5741743445396423,
0.6324747204780579,
0.10700439661741257,
0.42372745275497437,
0.9252472519874573,
0.25553762912750244,
0.47218719124794006,
0.483677476644516,
0.01741693913936615,
-0.11144158244132996,
-0.1391003280878067,
-0.5914416909217834,
-0.16065986454486847,
0.15439215302467346,
0.11570582538843155,
0.10446338355541229,
-0.0966804176568985,
-0.13314372301101685,
-0.11304575204849243,
-0.03974955528974533,
0.7512732148170471,
0.19622521102428436,
-0.8629792928695679,
0.7815667986869812,
-0.317008912563324,
0.9200450778007507,
-0.5437198877334595,
-0.019964294508099556,
-0.34312084317207336,
0.10020118206739426,
-0.4331049919128418,
-0.49477776885032654,
0.37126797437667847,
-0.0562254972755909,
-0.2696690857410431,
-0.4868595004081726,
0.6341068744659424,
-0.34243154525756836,
0.16894812881946564,
0.6137304306030273,
0.5154250264167786,
-0.15065717697143555,
-0.14668110013008118,
-0.4733715355396271,
-0.029686449095606804,
-0.07249331474304199,
-0.3415514826774597,
0.649032473564148,
0.38062217831611633,
0.049635984003543854,
0.6631481051445007,
0.6877747178077698,
0.14011695981025696,
-0.24835646152496338,
0.13953711092472076,
1.0390785932540894,
-0.7651497721672058,
-0.5350210666656494,
-0.5324358344078064,
0.46720829606056213,
0.04569818079471588,
-0.24012118577957153,
0.44596967101097107,
0.5909313559532166,
1.0993684530258179,
-0.06465059518814087,
0.5306544899940491,
-0.19265466928482056,
0.129229336977005,
-0.44309860467910767,
0.5117912888526917,
-0.6310455799102783,
0.6173925995826721,
-0.41130879521369934,
-1.2155317068099976,
-0.4266798794269562,
0.5311077833175659,
-0.1875753551721573,
0.1846591830253601,
0.8828319907188416,
0.8639103174209595,
0.025274666026234627,
-0.31718674302101135,
0.34302762150764465,
0.029787668958306313,
0.0704796314239502,
0.5499796867370605,
1.0695186853408813,
-0.18385949730873108,
0.5771149396896362,
-0.4938585162162781,
-0.46321073174476624,
-0.1972791999578476,
-0.8925474882125854,
-0.5800619721412659,
-0.37853291630744934,
-0.23266993463039398,
-0.31750696897506714,
0.012903721071779728,
0.7283514142036438,
0.9516635537147522,
-0.5770742893218994,
-0.5318506956100464,
-0.3198648989200592,
0.33932122588157654,
-0.09692355990409851,
-0.2260199338197708,
0.043423764407634735,
-0.5231801867485046,
-0.44369375705718994,
0.2271442711353302,
0.5057275891304016,
-0.1651829332113266,
-0.14726899564266205,
-0.3327145278453827,
-0.33939167857170105,
-0.43928858637809753,
0.4953535795211792,
0.1397523432970047,
-0.47020813822746277,
-0.1537446230649948,
0.22282622754573822,
-0.41979271173477173,
0.2748735845088959,
1.3017568588256836,
-0.9505752921104431,
-0.03795032203197479,
0.9273430109024048,
0.5287753939628601,
0.26767656207084656,
0.24674217402935028,
0.7944167852401733,
-0.9616818428039551,
0.18009932339191437,
0.36678093671798706,
0.4129941463470459,
0.014409487135708332,
-0.5734785795211792,
0.619148850440979,
0.19258101284503937,
-0.691347599029541,
-0.7881801128387451,
0.14138297736644745,
-0.8334135413169861,
-0.61822909116745,
1.0164116621017456,
-0.2775056064128876,
-0.3198724389076233,
-0.22217363119125366,
-0.2949499487876892,
0.19322513043880463,
-0.35111314058303833,
0.5420131683349609,
0.49989455938339233,
0.08159680664539337,
-0.2506195306777954,
-0.43865060806274414,
0.7065114974975586,
0.4031970202922821,
-0.8982775211334229,
0.16006581485271454,
0.8052983283996582,
-0.004270023666322231,
0.3944709599018097,
0.7534522414207458,
-0.11437681317329407,
0.5439226627349854,
-0.3129260241985321,
0.09931241720914841,
-0.01678154058754444,
-0.7683347463607788,
-0.36250442266464233,
0.31721949577331543,
-0.0074944524094462395,
0.2797928750514984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18276v1 | Sanskrit Knowledge-based Systems: Annotation and Computational Tools | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | 2024-06-26T12:00:10 | Hrishikesh Terdalkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We address the challenges and opportunities in the development of knowledge
systems for Sanskrit, with a focus on question answering. By proposing a
framework for the automated construction of knowledge graphs, introducing
annotation tools for ontology-driven and general-purpose tasks, and offering a
diverse collection of web-interfaces, tools, and software libraries, we have
made significant contributions to the field of computational Sanskrit. These
contributions not only enhance the accessibility and accuracy of Sanskrit text
analysis but also pave the way for further advancements in knowledge
representation and language processing. Ultimately, this research contributes
to the preservation, understanding, and utilization of the rich linguistic
information embodied in Sanskrit texts. | [
-0.19143123924732208,
-0.6645018458366394,
0.4245987832546234,
0.25399473309516907,
-0.15456946194171906,
0.3553744852542877,
-0.11204544454813004,
-0.5458066463470459,
0.5237010717391968,
0.18718500435352325,
-0.44974634051322937,
-0.30444979667663574,
-0.33464840054512024,
0.39727452397346497,
-0.3216135799884796,
0.7001683115959167,
-0.12388822436332703,
0.21618987619876862,
-0.4765358567237854,
-0.06286599487066269,
-0.6177756786346436,
-0.40665382146835327,
-0.45643359422683716,
-0.30322757363319397,
0.43663549423217773,
0.4316774308681488,
0.6595727205276489,
0.3754526674747467,
0.7220989465713501,
0.24951691925525665,
0.017615906894207,
0.19753116369247437,
-0.1279415339231491,
0.6459971070289612,
-0.21506844460964203,
-0.595874011516571,
-0.13529014587402344,
-0.21590478718280792,
0.7437239289283752,
0.7432986497879028,
0.02531229332089424,
0.43462610244750977,
-0.11767584830522537,
0.33628609776496887,
-0.7837578654289246,
0.25996071100234985,
-0.23622572422027588,
0.16585728526115417,
-0.4556547701358795,
-0.5643120408058167,
-0.3258384168148041,
-0.9603577852249146,
-0.1796770840883255,
-1.2229325771331787,
-0.3810245394706726,
0.15564005076885223,
0.6157461404800415,
0.5619205832481384,
0.04717957600951195,
-0.54172283411026,
-0.782898485660553,
0.7237197160720825,
-0.22020083665847778,
0.32947245240211487,
0.5243198275566101,
0.6480886936187744,
0.022106390446424484,
-0.6340412497520447,
-0.6443419456481934,
0.2845076322555542,
-0.29993873834609985,
0.10132869333028793,
0.07653185725212097,
-0.040726445615291595,
0.11993030458688736,
0.5807682871818542,
-0.6267587542533875,
-0.040493447333574295,
-0.6431044340133667,
-0.48182448744773865,
0.5622559785842896,
0.22587917745113373,
0.7051278948783875,
-0.460908442735672,
-0.062479522079229355,
0.07936549186706543,
-0.6839385032653809,
-0.27486538887023926,
0.14208167791366577,
0.16955910623073578,
0.18352381885051727,
0.8223919868469238,
-0.2990303635597229,
1.0263798236846924,
-0.4579431116580963,
-0.10868511348962784,
0.054684873670339584,
-0.46915996074676514,
-0.37135282158851624,
0.15394903719425201,
0.3374630808830261,
0.14489908516407013,
0.24868299067020416,
-0.22482040524482727,
0.2464723140001297,
0.400500625371933,
-0.13493579626083374,
-0.4017370641231537,
-0.028201384469866753,
0.256278395652771,
-0.3127647936344147,
-0.30663934350013733,
-0.1141837015748024,
-0.7475570440292358,
-0.8585986495018005,
-0.4298427402973175,
0.27083513140678406,
-0.4690309166908264,
-0.518348753452301,
-0.2240755558013916,
-0.7154890298843384,
0.5600727796554565,
0.5549570322036743,
-0.781937301158905,
0.379658967256546,
0.5862605571746826,
0.7778915762901306,
-0.008644141256809235,
-0.15248046815395355,
-0.0800623893737793,
0.4887333810329437,
-0.31088727712631226,
1.0050653219223022,
-0.8383868336677551,
-0.6970623731613159,
-0.027496883645653725,
-0.34728509187698364,
0.023942481726408005,
-0.3284033238887787,
0.6321259140968323,
-0.7733199596405029,
0.06701140105724335,
-0.7500743865966797,
-0.7419069409370422,
-0.38592153787612915,
0.3974500298500061,
-0.32400450110435486,
1.103697419166565,
0.0736195296049118,
-1.0320837497711182,
0.05917024612426758,
-1.1095571517944336,
-0.48682457208633423,
0.4331369698047638,
-0.3105655312538147,
0.4047815799713135,
-0.14401230216026306,
-0.14160925149917603,
0.3021317720413208,
-0.5827831625938416,
-0.17077739536762238,
-0.12239322811365128,
-0.2487141638994217,
0.1748315393924713,
0.24243389070034027,
1.002237319946289,
0.6870813369750977,
-0.06325200200080872,
0.36747094988822937,
-0.8621537089347839,
0.3089248836040497,
0.11135970056056976,
-0.2112877517938614,
-0.7595457434654236,
-0.23814375698566437,
0.22717638313770294,
0.04552873596549034,
0.4613364636898041,
-0.8686810731887817,
0.24344177544116974,
-0.2945649325847626,
0.4998442828655243,
0.7239780426025391,
-0.026479829102754593,
0.3984750211238861,
0.011416226625442505,
0.895232081413269,
-0.1929372251033783,
0.044583357870578766,
-0.29723963141441345,
-0.5830420255661011,
-0.6450069546699524,
-0.0369080975651741,
0.49089738726615906,
0.9141306281089783,
-0.8974096179008484,
0.16553357243537903,
-0.2567835748195648,
-0.7326357960700989,
-0.6006660461425781,
-0.0712897777557373,
0.4433911442756653,
0.6108066439628601,
0.20147539675235748,
-0.2574259042739868,
-0.7286162972450256,
-0.6325336694717407,
-0.11430849879980087,
-0.32063397765159607,
0.2566058933734894,
0.11481760442256927,
0.30433622002601624,
0.0017387442057952285,
1.2847132682800293,
-0.8990247249603271,
-0.13749830424785614,
0.0630270391702652,
0.06309341639280319,
-0.4485172629356384,
0.4282822906970978,
0.24441975355148315,
-1.146710753440857,
-0.4235360622406006,
0.21961060166358948,
-1.1751809120178223,
-0.3387642204761505,
0.2692462205886841,
-0.2482246309518814,
0.23262909054756165,
0.5796648859977722,
-0.5444375872612,
0.7103411555290222,
0.15941958129405975,
-0.4271335005760193,
0.525644063949585,
0.11350581049919128,
0.20711761713027954,
-1.1569585800170898,
0.5296658873558044,
-0.5462322235107422,
-0.07235248386859894,
-0.6212784051895142,
0.16528654098510742,
-0.11460035294294357,
-0.21923092007637024,
-0.22496286034584045,
0.7383254170417786,
-0.2843111753463745,
-0.3974330723285675,
-0.32048389315605164,
0.3619098663330078,
0.008498057723045349,
0.21246084570884705,
0.0059898789040744305,
0.9189246296882629,
0.43371495604515076,
-0.5353906154632568,
0.6270603537559509,
0.6210507154464722,
0.01991383545100689,
0.9359126687049866,
-0.6555894017219543,
-0.01896684430539608,
-0.11598210781812668,
-0.06392639130353928,
-1.029796838760376,
-0.5110791325569153,
0.5540463924407959,
-0.7963644862174988,
0.060736194252967834,
0.1330799162387848,
-0.6331328749656677,
-0.28086817264556885,
-0.13539254665374756,
0.4441302716732025,
0.4249286353588104,
-0.0319003164768219,
0.5506534576416016,
0.6100680232048035,
-0.4467484951019287,
-0.5077565908432007,
-0.9004906415939331,
0.045442674309015274,
-0.07994915544986725,
-0.4718894362449646,
0.008725146763026714,
0.059851810336112976,
-0.6526464223861694,
0.4506789445877075,
0.25314861536026,
-0.29889222979545593,
0.04084815829992294,
0.4355057179927826,
0.10122489929199219,
-0.043202873319387436,
0.7494903206825256,
0.228035569190979,
-0.34573063254356384,
-0.18031103909015656,
-0.6498790383338928,
0.4472871422767639,
-0.11999685317277908,
-0.6534841060638428,
-0.37043941020965576,
0.4311176836490631,
0.4382386803627014,
-0.4063345491886139,
0.4269670844078064,
0.4914993941783905,
-0.6571928262710571,
0.31306174397468567,
-0.4158511459827423,
0.23673778772354126,
-0.4123387932777405,
0.03263485059142113,
-0.4463852047920227,
-0.9648939967155457,
0.7978839874267578,
-0.04921684041619301,
-0.11595077812671661,
0.8514759540557861,
0.356953501701355,
0.0709245502948761,
0.3778206706047058,
0.7080847024917603,
-0.011820484884083271,
0.20986458659172058,
0.1143554300069809,
0.258537620306015,
-0.8982987999916077,
-0.1867171972990036,
-0.7505260705947876,
-0.09367925673723221,
-0.5979561805725098,
-0.28506961464881897,
0.42425400018692017,
0.0102913286536932,
-0.27093157172203064,
0.18844303488731384,
-1.0127824544906616,
0.35587379336357117,
0.7190566062927246,
-0.4081518352031708,
0.42389151453971863,
-0.311449259519577,
-0.22865146398544312,
-0.03413448482751846,
-0.6638288497924805,
-0.43631306290626526,
1.0745806694030762,
0.010421477258205414,
0.6538103818893433,
0.08458234369754791,
0.4011033773422241,
0.37589895725250244,
0.05215315520763397,
-0.504700779914856,
0.5676088929176331,
0.2840358018875122,
-0.9373549222946167,
-0.7085341811180115,
-0.012548810802400112,
-0.6493077874183655,
-0.05804884806275368,
0.030994147062301636,
-0.5890886783599854,
0.2939653992652893,
0.0076657552272081375,
-0.4578098654747009,
0.1590808928012848,
-0.8679675459861755,
0.707764208316803,
-0.04726944863796234,
-0.11381153017282486,
-0.28496548533439636,
-0.8108476996421814,
0.10513746738433838,
0.0017916061915457249,
0.24978049099445343,
0.1725950837135315,
0.041022978723049164,
1.0030149221420288,
-0.47291362285614014,
0.806386411190033,
-0.4288511574268341,
0.07600974291563034,
0.6470534801483154,
-0.05237054452300072,
-0.006849958561360836,
-0.019003352150321007,
-0.15414848923683167,
-0.24011018872261047,
0.4861011803150177,
-0.5670619606971741,
-0.6540042161941528,
0.6028834581375122,
-0.7469833493232727,
-0.32770732045173645,
-0.6669778823852539,
-0.5768262147903442,
-0.06869477778673172,
0.6694313287734985,
-0.04394816607236862,
0.18118348717689514,
-0.00439630588516593,
-0.2621861696243286,
0.674114465713501,
-0.24813403189182281,
0.29737570881843567,
0.10154437273740768,
-0.8366108536720276,
-0.41307759284973145,
1.0054309368133545,
0.40478578209877014,
0.12871205806732178,
0.41738393902778625,
-0.03200150281190872,
-0.34710732102394104,
-0.3003544211387634,
-0.5022131204605103,
0.006121441721916199,
-1.1996287107467651,
-0.17850583791732788,
-0.39098575711250305,
-0.2405187040567398,
-0.5752151608467102,
-0.09978777915239334,
0.06402672082185745,
-1.0457137823104858,
-0.2620992660522461,
-0.13851389288902283,
0.8964102864265442,
1.1676769256591797,
-0.03375253453850746,
0.18717029690742493,
-0.6960978507995605,
0.02523138001561165,
0.4060850441455841,
0.5466997027397156,
-0.022844867780804634,
-0.02948714978992939,
-0.21076816320419312,
-0.10055061429738998,
-0.17644129693508148,
-0.8562323451042175,
-0.17880366742610931,
0.07163138687610626,
0.30883458256721497,
0.25630664825439453,
-0.062308501452207565,
0.7131151556968689,
-0.30914372205734253,
0.9602220058441162,
-0.06123848631978035,
-0.8636868596076965,
0.7980313897132874,
-0.5764756202697754,
0.18850839138031006,
0.6309341788291931,
0.33167529106140137,
-0.8370117545127869,
-0.09406818449497223,
-0.38481006026268005,
-0.5799261331558228,
0.315878301858902,
0.3122762143611908,
-0.21015366911888123,
0.17294885218143463,
0.7591546177864075,
0.05513129010796547,
0.32370617985725403,
-0.28242048621177673,
-0.2644055485725403,
-0.4089840054512024,
-0.22870057821273804,
0.1464332640171051,
-0.07004040479660034,
-0.06999555230140686,
-0.448787122964859,
0.6455667018890381,
-0.13268104195594788,
0.25718939304351807,
0.42915311455726624,
-0.20374207198619843,
-0.17056314647197723,
0.23674580454826355,
0.8480811715126038,
0.866802453994751,
0.22123371064662933,
0.15659601986408234,
0.12368888407945633,
-0.6239103674888611,
-0.001975824823603034,
0.28663501143455505,
-0.45315447449684143,
-0.17450211942195892,
0.03294754400849342,
0.6339482069015503,
0.010951904579997063,
-0.6401401162147522,
-0.040173642337322235,
0.07070382684469223,
0.33298468589782715,
-0.8269965052604675,
0.014416859485208988,
0.38649657368659973,
0.008137529715895653,
0.6272203922271729,
0.05174974724650383,
0.20864711701869965,
-0.2900911271572113,
-0.11362224817276001,
0.3209129869937897,
-0.44650405645370483,
-0.2864491939544678,
0.6088952422142029,
0.15440721809864044,
-0.3407967984676361,
0.29799047112464905,
-0.3478008508682251,
-0.6479026079177856,
0.2410908341407776,
0.26715633273124695,
0.6183074116706848,
-0.21605585515499115,
0.08521728962659836,
0.04780585318803787,
0.16576716303825378,
0.3519602417945862,
0.6838698387145996,
-0.2615116238594055,
-0.34061068296432495,
-0.46284088492393494,
-0.9217882752418518,
-0.6179981231689453,
-0.6247691512107849,
-0.4850671887397766,
0.30990326404571533,
-0.43379220366477966,
-0.09479302167892456,
0.2178145945072174,
-0.052772603929042816,
-0.2940959632396698,
0.35372695326805115,
-0.07107403874397278,
1.0073249340057373,
-0.8777484893798828,
0.680442750453949,
1.1948457956314087,
-0.9983115196228027,
-0.7283772230148315,
-0.40441086888313293,
-0.027456656098365784,
-0.7820771336555481,
0.9429157972335815,
-0.24188587069511414,
-0.1975170075893402,
0.1887933611869812,
-0.4060894846916199,
-1.0807969570159912,
1.2002018690109253,
0.10964704304933548,
0.13237878680229187,
-0.06872110813856125,
0.4371204078197479,
0.7110832333564758,
-0.03424817696213722,
0.22045117616653442,
0.4179903566837311,
0.8689053654670715,
0.15708677470684052,
-1.0208444595336914,
0.06463105976581573,
-0.8028397560119629,
0.06604378670454025,
0.2610684335231781,
-0.550836980342865,
0.7038816809654236,
0.3824954628944397,
-0.10982713103294373,
0.1492023766040802,
0.6916545033454895,
-0.0077598984353244305,
0.22092929482460022,
0.12609395384788513,
0.7969348430633545,
1.0073038339614868,
-0.19898317754268646,
1.0147895812988281,
-0.2281794399023056,
-0.01336572878062725,
0.7283458709716797,
-0.21779786050319672,
0.6728329062461853,
0.6547015905380249,
-0.360898494720459,
0.71198970079422,
0.8106493949890137,
0.2082749456167221,
0.019196735695004463,
0.3898967504501343,
-0.09248912334442139,
-0.16291266679763794,
-0.6836732029914856,
-0.5099478960037231,
0.3399994969367981,
0.6213427186012268,
0.08356700837612152,
-0.11158978193998337,
0.17256878316402435,
-0.05134681984782219,
0.1595645546913147,
-0.2457248419523239,
0.6676055192947388,
-0.009093300439417362,
-0.6554796695709229,
0.33419448137283325,
-0.2077675759792328,
0.41658052802085876,
-0.5314422845840454,
-0.29097890853881836,
0.22545884549617767,
-0.20364321768283844,
-0.5486039519309998,
-0.8641424775123596,
0.9573252201080322,
-0.053650449961423874,
-0.2234530746936798,
-0.14740635454654694,
1.2991000413894653,
-0.07120807468891144,
-0.546201765537262,
-0.069419264793396,
0.4853830337524414,
0.2411632537841797,
0.1086903065443039,
-0.12140102684497833,
0.16473108530044556,
-0.2882034480571747,
0.02202456258237362,
0.06535803526639938,
0.36264726519584656,
-0.32519668340682983,
0.6493702530860901,
0.527798056602478,
0.12556897103786469,
0.415920227766037,
-0.2902066707611084,
0.851008415222168,
-0.8454091548919678,
-0.621513307094574,
-0.5090078115463257,
0.46526142954826355,
-0.25227731466293335,
-0.2825845777988434,
0.9481068253517151,
0.4770546555519104,
0.7702986598014832,
0.019136544317007065,
1.4540530443191528,
-0.5433853268623352,
0.930115818977356,
-0.06526630371809006,
1.015333652496338,
-0.4551723301410675,
0.012439469806849957,
-0.3406772315502167,
-0.7089622020721436,
-0.7641574144363403,
0.42971497774124146,
-0.5267128348350525,
-0.09653134644031525,
0.5600298047065735,
0.31061863899230957,
0.24904945492744446,
0.4914552867412567,
-0.09776425361633301,
-0.04623597115278244,
0.07918091863393784,
0.23101185262203217,
0.8184678554534912,
-0.3560982346534729,
0.4260987639427185,
-0.003110838821157813,
-0.24156449735164642,
-0.13893543183803558,
-0.5219451189041138,
-0.5093072652816772,
-0.910828173160553,
-0.06640249490737915,
-0.11556670814752579,
0.09391537308692932,
0.7276445627212524,
0.28073686361312866,
-0.8665553331375122,
-0.23533667623996735,
-0.17993876338005066,
0.25216150283813477,
0.05356479063630104,
-0.21675804257392883,
0.6685017943382263,
-0.49670398235321045,
-0.34501051902770996,
-0.13122393190860748,
0.5599799752235413,
-0.06714975088834763,
-0.6435260772705078,
-0.07259620726108551,
-0.4278622269630432,
-0.05712875723838806,
0.5561948418617249,
0.7384255528450012,
-0.654405951499939,
-0.36852478981018066,
0.345575749874115,
0.09286852180957794,
0.029836762696504593,
0.6745854616165161,
-0.7230560779571533,
0.5976660847663879,
0.7724273204803467,
1.0581289529800415,
0.14765103161334991,
-0.14563174545764923,
0.47011545300483704,
-0.44692784547805786,
0.14315074682235718,
0.2026042342185974,
0.08989907056093216,
0.6473368406295776,
-0.32211440801620483,
0.6341426968574524,
0.3389522433280945,
-0.5125532746315002,
-0.866765558719635,
0.3201086223125458,
-0.7493643760681152,
-0.17927047610282898,
1.0408297777175903,
-0.1494346708059311,
-0.2921268343925476,
-0.4870602786540985,
-0.5048863887786865,
0.636696457862854,
0.16558308899402618,
0.485376238822937,
0.9629323482513428,
-0.3273702561855316,
0.15893973410129547,
-0.27629661560058594,
0.6091721653938293,
0.47274476289749146,
-1.0451306104660034,
-0.020192166790366173,
0.5494285821914673,
-0.006197750568389893,
0.8876060843467712,
0.8697888851165771,
-0.2989653944969177,
0.42147645354270935,
-0.19810591638088226,
0.25436931848526,
0.026974517852067947,
-0.15751992166042328,
-0.2769007086753845,
0.39928489923477173,
0.40306559205055237,
-0.13977470993995667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18266v2 | "Vorbeşti Româneşte?" A Recipe to Train Powerful Romanian LLMs with English Instructions | 2024-06-26T11:39:51 | 2024-06-27T20:30:47 | Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Alexandru Dima, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Ovio Olaru, Simina Terian, Andrei Terian, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English; hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds other languages. To our knowledge, we are the first to
collect and translate a large collection of texts, instructions, and benchmarks
and train, evaluate, and release open-source LLMs tailored for Romanian. We
evaluate our methods on four different categories, including academic
benchmarks, MT-Bench (manually translated), and a professionally built
historical, cultural, and social benchmark adapted to Romanian. We argue for
the usefulness and high performance of RoLLMs by obtaining state-of-the-art
results across the board. We publicly release all resources (i.e., data,
training and evaluation code, models) to support and encourage research on
Romanian LLMs while concurrently creating a generalizable recipe, adequate for
other low or less-resourced languages. | [
-0.3754139542579651,
-0.44997191429138184,
0.23723971843719482,
0.32952824234962463,
-0.46837836503982544,
-0.14024706184864044,
-0.5809764862060547,
-0.26270461082458496,
0.26190388202667236,
0.4851849675178528,
-0.46650874614715576,
-0.7430328130722046,
-0.6585665345191956,
0.1429367959499359,
-0.5136589407920837,
0.9002612233161926,
-0.3512227535247803,
1.0208486318588257,
-0.16438817977905273,
-0.3751024603843689,
-0.316469669342041,
-0.5241987109184265,
-0.3370853364467621,
-0.40383386611938477,
0.7344111800193787,
0.5081207156181335,
0.08025377988815308,
0.4796992242336273,
0.5575786828994751,
0.22967132925987244,
0.0044793360866606236,
0.3632284700870514,
-0.4904201924800873,
0.0599922239780426,
-0.29129812121391296,
-0.883543848991394,
-0.27516698837280273,
0.050313908606767654,
0.5722799301147461,
0.2503639757633209,
-0.28175508975982666,
0.3103100657463074,
0.13169793784618378,
0.6415781378746033,
-0.4776337146759033,
-0.0035058464854955673,
-0.6822996139526367,
0.11478598415851593,
-0.20646002888679504,
-0.6312692761421204,
-0.5216869115829468,
-0.6229292154312134,
-0.3232921361923218,
-0.24333471059799194,
0.19170618057250977,
-0.008827432058751583,
0.7104832530021667,
-0.004638368263840675,
-0.21564927697181702,
-0.5603545308113098,
-0.9204509854316711,
0.6604074835777283,
-0.29174095392227173,
0.5126449465751648,
0.08395608514547348,
0.3601588010787964,
-0.47340115904808044,
-0.620022177696228,
-0.20175418257713318,
-0.25530973076820374,
0.34044957160949707,
0.12973345816135406,
-0.3457905054092407,
-0.20985005795955658,
-0.05638783052563667,
0.3090656101703644,
-0.6875807046890259,
0.34113577008247375,
-0.4734545648097992,
0.01650243066251278,
0.5004857182502747,
0.08368142694234848,
0.3493911027908325,
0.32362115383148193,
-0.5541379451751709,
-0.13454660773277283,
-1.0664235353469849,
-0.24834132194519043,
0.30950406193733215,
0.10151498019695282,
-0.15694475173950195,
0.946273922920227,
0.22227783501148224,
0.47758257389068604,
-0.43666595220565796,
-0.2457897663116455,
-0.152538001537323,
-0.06381005048751831,
0.06858309358358383,
-0.033956386148929596,
0.8065410256385803,
0.2860633432865143,
0.4551328718662262,
-0.5393761396408081,
-0.33515194058418274,
0.22785262763500214,
0.2013215720653534,
-1.0276762247085571,
0.1893068253993988,
0.11739379167556763,
-0.09603055566549301,
-0.0976921021938324,
0.01952376589179039,
-0.5121963024139404,
-0.06476642191410065,
-0.4250542223453522,
0.21490731835365295,
-0.6546763181686401,
-0.028800642117857933,
0.1154811680316925,
-0.16017405688762665,
0.6397419571876526,
0.21220433712005615,
-0.6622064113616943,
0.36541450023651123,
0.975611686706543,
0.9364835619926453,
-0.3637467622756958,
-0.2775345742702484,
-0.9404944777488708,
0.06370896100997925,
-0.6119124889373779,
0.9799423813819885,
-0.4937061667442322,
-0.5741952061653137,
0.31112948060035706,
0.1541171669960022,
0.19245076179504395,
-0.7190541625022888,
0.6514933109283447,
-0.3620936870574951,
0.27673062682151794,
-0.06684979796409607,
-0.7037158608436584,
0.13616620004177094,
-0.020077669993042946,
-0.5053586959838867,
1.0803122520446777,
-0.31068792939186096,
-0.6544243693351746,
0.2518831193447113,
-0.326945424079895,
-0.6448909640312195,
0.28855153918266296,
-0.36206239461898804,
-0.08363495022058487,
0.419148325920105,
-0.014455572701990604,
0.6930944919586182,
-0.4757206439971924,
0.07980881631374359,
-0.23228895664215088,
-0.422946572303772,
0.1552974134683609,
-0.38557180762290955,
0.7582082748413086,
0.24006663262844086,
-0.5167709589004517,
-0.1081511452794075,
-0.7557194828987122,
0.013548338785767555,
0.060846973210573196,
-0.5935251712799072,
-0.25129300355911255,
0.048636846244335175,
0.26342952251434326,
-0.1253564953804016,
0.2227630317211151,
-0.3493484854698181,
0.28583991527557373,
-0.18311479687690735,
0.530523955821991,
0.7550221681594849,
-0.40314781665802,
0.45819592475891113,
-0.2328191101551056,
0.7755633592605591,
-0.2686272859573364,
-0.03670189529657364,
0.06257355958223343,
-0.23510529100894928,
-0.8517012596130371,
-0.49362054467201233,
0.566342830657959,
0.8386819958686829,
-0.5331465601921082,
0.4147144556045532,
-0.42566972970962524,
-0.9218164682388306,
-0.5580902099609375,
0.3951154053211212,
0.2799268066883087,
-0.10130572319030762,
0.12389969825744629,
-0.16493530571460724,
-0.5978082418441772,
-0.8463529348373413,
-0.08819081634283066,
0.06233920529484749,
-0.05147355794906616,
0.04918026179075241,
0.7219774127006531,
-0.30838319659233093,
0.41412028670310974,
-0.07930081337690353,
-0.49295780062675476,
-0.42613813281059265,
0.03680218383669853,
-0.05692790448665619,
0.3570176959037781,
0.3943863809108734,
-0.5607167482376099,
-0.24599285423755646,
0.2762826085090637,
-0.811431884765625,
0.16728322207927704,
0.33907774090766907,
-0.48733240365982056,
0.3186975419521332,
0.6758394837379456,
-0.43655329942703247,
0.07758896052837372,
0.8301594853401184,
-0.03776944428682327,
0.490493506193161,
-0.49317729473114014,
-0.08571266382932663,
-1.4940532445907593,
0.026954373344779015,
0.1735924333333969,
-0.37323373556137085,
-0.2397838830947876,
0.19186919927597046,
0.09399328380823135,
-0.1175108328461647,
-0.7026283740997314,
0.791999876499176,
-0.7430337071418762,
-0.04292674362659454,
-0.09700190275907516,
0.2674599289894104,
-0.23152956366539001,
0.25403112173080444,
0.28622353076934814,
0.9438120722770691,
0.39559438824653625,
-0.58015376329422,
0.4581962823867798,
0.069048672914505,
-0.6181177496910095,
0.7606345415115356,
-0.5799620151519775,
0.09000418335199356,
-0.10604622960090637,
-0.0014414199395105243,
-0.6258009672164917,
-0.19375017285346985,
0.003995951265096664,
-0.5074063539505005,
0.38627293705940247,
-0.33011242747306824,
-0.35814592242240906,
-0.22350268065929413,
-0.050248436629772186,
-0.22741498053073883,
0.5347841382026672,
-0.5798497796058655,
0.7662696838378906,
0.43033847212791443,
0.07606986165046692,
-0.49025964736938477,
-0.7055820822715759,
0.1315355896949768,
-0.43200981616973877,
-0.49980825185775757,
0.24043267965316772,
-0.2258734405040741,
-0.4298208951950073,
-0.09524254500865936,
0.013297921977937222,
-0.27995386719703674,
0.06588175892829895,
0.018411889672279358,
0.11240296810865402,
-0.2366328090429306,
0.08812829107046127,
-0.256069153547287,
0.0013992130989208817,
-0.01297796331346035,
-0.39172783493995667,
0.5735164284706116,
-0.408491313457489,
-0.12467564642429352,
-0.4494546055793762,
0.34330037236213684,
0.6308902502059937,
-0.41422238945961,
0.7147383689880371,
0.7602229118347168,
-0.47258785367012024,
-0.4454308748245239,
-0.6893044114112854,
-0.09867280721664429,
-0.3871645927429199,
0.4288531243801117,
-0.4924640357494354,
-0.6755174398422241,
0.18710680305957794,
-0.33436402678489685,
0.32585665583610535,
0.007961809635162354,
0.7430952787399292,
-0.30726173520088196,
0.9363035559654236,
0.7268332839012146,
-0.16736994683742523,
0.5378479361534119,
-0.44910162687301636,
-0.14584200084209442,
-0.47750309109687805,
-0.3297278881072998,
-0.8464846014976501,
-0.11032962054014206,
-0.7373786568641663,
-0.6785790920257568,
0.512803316116333,
0.1808841973543167,
0.2264641970396042,
0.40438634157180786,
-0.28556400537490845,
0.4368516802787781,
0.5186557769775391,
0.12691640853881836,
0.14659811556339264,
0.4428490400314331,
-0.339545339345932,
-0.09899784624576569,
-0.8285475969314575,
-1.019993543624878,
1.0669714212417603,
0.1950671672821045,
0.9602100849151611,
0.011867130175232887,
0.9070863723754883,
0.127236470580101,
0.25649288296699524,
-0.8853660821914673,
0.5038056969642639,
-0.23921142518520355,
-0.5842676758766174,
-0.16618379950523376,
-0.4138660132884979,
-1.1774108409881592,
0.3010508418083191,
-0.21523961424827576,
-0.2858193814754486,
-0.3040272295475006,
0.1459832340478897,
0.07879364490509033,
0.2445339411497116,
-0.8912363052368164,
0.7999395132064819,
-0.6902287602424622,
-0.5613043904304504,
-0.4548785388469696,
-0.022436121478676796,
0.09853989630937576,
0.23200449347496033,
0.4482615292072296,
-0.1259116232395172,
-0.3497348129749298,
0.7279210686683655,
-0.36671581864356995,
0.5588957667350769,
-0.03147164732217789,
-0.02409208193421364,
0.15087078511714935,
0.1470547765493393,
0.5924327373504639,
0.19819729030132294,
-0.023589001968503,
0.26040226221084595,
0.0825498104095459,
-0.7337621450424194,
-0.5130556225776672,
0.6698188185691833,
-0.8427557945251465,
-0.5759087204933167,
-0.4176178574562073,
0.1297307014465332,
-0.12015906721353531,
0.11194063723087311,
0.455803781747818,
0.6412518620491028,
-0.8074455857276917,
0.35272133350372314,
0.8798783421516418,
-0.0028083643410354853,
0.31960391998291016,
0.6700200438499451,
0.03238063305616379,
-0.5110476016998291,
0.9211978912353516,
0.13426506519317627,
-0.023391129449009895,
0.5442122220993042,
0.055229440331459045,
-0.08295311778783798,
-0.6111533641815186,
-0.7717120051383972,
0.39970120787620544,
-0.49338459968566895,
0.011604560539126396,
-0.28773725032806396,
-0.05925514176487923,
-0.054795775562524796,
-0.1993720680475235,
-0.7124661803245544,
-0.020661432296037674,
-0.31838542222976685,
-0.19081449508666992,
0.251236230134964,
0.8977327346801758,
-0.07018707692623138,
-0.02899894304573536,
-0.5812647938728333,
0.11927953362464905,
0.16265328228473663,
0.27776822447776794,
-0.33455464243888855,
-0.3527270257472992,
-0.40023908019065857,
0.11067389696836472,
-0.13685162365436554,
-0.7396097779273987,
0.4191327691078186,
-0.03100215271115303,
0.7000833749771118,
0.24325501918792725,
-0.2681829333305359,
0.5267525315284729,
-0.8382335901260376,
0.4543144702911377,
0.36314627528190613,
-0.5995375514030457,
0.6108935475349426,
-0.12485971301794052,
0.057817358523607254,
0.3967086672782898,
0.8243749141693115,
-0.5695676207542419,
-0.33018720149993896,
-0.34308063983917236,
-0.74711674451828,
0.5761299729347229,
0.10362520813941956,
0.457035094499588,
-0.0646241307258606,
0.28449779748916626,
0.25044822692871094,
0.0760054960846901,
-0.6207737922668457,
-0.15584483742713928,
0.1292828619480133,
-0.059376463294029236,
-0.16460174322128296,
-0.3357336223125458,
-0.24626505374908447,
-0.2659129798412323,
0.9600275158882141,
-0.001811659662052989,
0.2572759985923767,
0.12657013535499573,
-0.3587794899940491,
0.0707421600818634,
0.4408290684223175,
0.8191022872924805,
0.9021178483963013,
0.045537568628787994,
0.08607882261276245,
0.42521780729293823,
-0.4508371949195862,
0.3688420355319977,
-0.20729300379753113,
-0.023136401548981667,
0.2753768861293793,
0.5196601152420044,
0.9115212559700012,
0.3025535047054291,
-0.7895087003707886,
0.5307228565216064,
-0.5069303512573242,
-0.19167251884937286,
-0.9847630262374878,
0.16829513013362885,
0.4584859609603882,
0.2293359935283661,
0.31553709506988525,
-0.1447504311800003,
-0.32166874408721924,
-0.6656907200813293,
0.0436624214053154,
0.4670422375202179,
-0.6584084033966064,
-0.39759930968284607,
0.484140545129776,
0.46128612756729126,
-0.7085205912590027,
0.2165573239326477,
-0.11546659469604492,
-0.32986968755722046,
0.1662062108516693,
0.25639012455940247,
0.7134867906570435,
-0.2936283349990845,
0.36536967754364014,
0.39842867851257324,
0.5095731019973755,
-0.22599995136260986,
0.33901676535606384,
0.1272953450679779,
-0.5333535075187683,
-0.3225066065788269,
-0.7666321992874146,
-0.4445699155330658,
0.44636619091033936,
-0.8307194113731384,
0.7845979332923889,
-0.3424888849258423,
-0.04030880331993103,
-0.06401490420103073,
-0.051101602613925934,
-0.8897350430488586,
0.10662422329187393,
0.14620822668075562,
1.1871058940887451,
-0.6535009741783142,
0.8816502690315247,
0.8788475394248962,
-0.20774616301059723,
-0.43886569142341614,
-0.3914552628993988,
-0.3383843004703522,
-1.0439870357513428,
0.4703870713710785,
-0.010647003538906574,
-0.21747514605522156,
-0.08388864994049072,
-0.5418835878372192,
-0.38367268443107605,
0.7624319791793823,
0.7182798385620117,
-0.833145260810852,
-0.2073315978050232,
0.13614311814308167,
0.6038616299629211,
-0.5009552836418152,
0.43342486023902893,
0.4581488072872162,
0.32344067096710205,
-0.06549277156591415,
-0.5875468254089355,
-0.45636969804763794,
-0.3270642161369324,
0.1623419225215912,
-0.11423782259225845,
-0.7216044068336487,
0.08038422465324402,
-0.09247007966041565,
-0.2913539409637451,
0.0692305639386177,
0.7838701009750366,
0.07236645370721817,
-0.15003585815429688,
0.22130097448825836,
0.3318195343017578,
0.7954179644584656,
-0.18615159392356873,
1.0615077018737793,
-0.567902147769928,
-0.23292136192321777,
0.9524654746055603,
-0.15862713754177094,
1.2100993394851685,
0.49058711528778076,
-0.035164233297109604,
0.5004467964172363,
0.6444992423057556,
0.0575125515460968,
0.3161880075931549,
0.3902692496776581,
-0.3531354069709778,
-0.44024303555488586,
-0.15308059751987457,
-0.3043811023235321,
0.6007243990898132,
0.21319645643234253,
-0.2804279625415802,
-0.11045163124799728,
0.21193760633468628,
0.3917752802371979,
0.26623016595840454,
-0.17591381072998047,
0.8852832317352295,
0.2139943242073059,
-0.887540876865387,
1.0865614414215088,
0.13123206794261932,
0.6583085656166077,
-0.6357215642929077,
0.008053305558860302,
-0.5239012837409973,
0.34111231565475464,
0.041517775505781174,
-0.3403863310813904,
-0.06655744463205338,
0.4084148705005646,
-0.05803033336997032,
-0.2908101975917816,
0.11801578104496002,
-0.48948320746421814,
-0.7934163212776184,
0.6618095636367798,
0.4600774645805359,
0.5960730314254761,
0.15215687453746796,
-0.48011747002601624,
0.2418089658021927,
0.02848868817090988,
-0.22320249676704407,
0.2527788579463959,
0.5413114428520203,
-0.0862412378191948,
0.7202650308609009,
0.33277449011802673,
0.6014259457588196,
0.32425209879875183,
0.08850523829460144,
0.6467903852462769,
-0.526216983795166,
-0.08624321967363358,
-0.8380157351493835,
0.36235836148262024,
0.08285494893789291,
-0.5148913264274597,
0.5529218912124634,
0.8904772996902466,
1.1737514734268188,
-0.09176577627658844,
0.8522105813026428,
0.27813807129859924,
0.3654860854148865,
-0.6933520436286926,
0.4707176685333252,
-0.7950299382209778,
0.012872389517724514,
0.3759256899356842,
-1.1372307538986206,
0.1741829216480255,
0.4681534767150879,
-0.03943173214793205,
-0.21018017828464508,
0.7197972536087036,
0.945866048336029,
0.029666390269994736,
-0.08909360319375992,
0.4153103232383728,
0.3100959360599518,
0.18178923428058624,
0.40987443923950195,
0.6901533007621765,
-0.2736816108226776,
0.9597513675689697,
-0.1571568101644516,
-0.3668588399887085,
-0.2586371898651123,
-0.6668721437454224,
-1.204414963722229,
-0.632824718952179,
-0.09755835682153702,
-0.3248157501220703,
0.44152283668518066,
1.0220897197723389,
0.7738481760025024,
-0.9412409067153931,
-0.6976944804191589,
-0.042884375900030136,
0.04546845704317093,
-0.13681352138519287,
-0.09523490071296692,
0.06653359532356262,
-0.4119868278503418,
-1.0738730430603027,
0.5371513962745667,
0.12080687284469604,
0.11637099832296371,
-0.6482172608375549,
-0.3581518530845642,
0.015710707753896713,
0.08680451661348343,
0.5481778979301453,
0.07943177968263626,
-0.7167339324951172,
0.0741163045167923,
0.22901572287082672,
-0.35397008061408997,
0.14014090597629547,
0.9401353597640991,
-0.16022305190563202,
0.3246634900569916,
0.363318532705307,
0.4007459282875061,
0.7778651118278503,
-0.4477933943271637,
0.8863469958305359,
-0.5111895203590393,
0.4136718511581421,
0.2523103952407837,
0.62003093957901,
0.46094653010368347,
0.025917060673236847,
0.71822190284729,
0.12123548984527588,
-0.28747469186782837,
-0.8267884254455566,
-0.16653186082839966,
-0.6432940363883972,
-0.24642039835453033,
1.5590769052505493,
-0.22456859052181244,
-0.6975728273391724,
0.2978323996067047,
-0.2635393738746643,
0.302122563123703,
-0.24554479122161865,
0.6949686408042908,
0.8752014636993408,
0.3747769594192505,
0.04002954810857773,
-0.805791437625885,
0.4033968150615692,
0.3205662965774536,
-0.7719167470932007,
-0.018840661272406578,
0.38457661867141724,
0.5685461759567261,
-0.17204447090625763,
0.4695565402507782,
-0.28037896752357483,
0.3332085609436035,
-0.23521991074085236,
0.6460387706756592,
0.09298235177993774,
-0.5538791418075562,
-0.24729113280773163,
0.09299972653388977,
0.33246907591819763,
0.00434641819447279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18259v1 | Detecting Machine-Generated Texts: Not Just "AI vs Humans" and Explainability is Complicated | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | 2024-06-26T11:11:47 | Jiazhou Ji, Ruizhe Li, Shujun Li, Jie Guo, Weidong Qiu, Zheng Huang, Chiyu Chen, Xiaoyu Jiang, Xinru Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As LLMs rapidly advance, increasing concerns arise regarding risks about
actual authorship of texts we see online and in real world. The task of
distinguishing LLM-authored texts is complicated by the nuanced and overlapping
behaviors of both machines and humans. In this paper, we challenge the current
practice of considering LLM-generated text detection a binary classification
task of differentiating human from AI. Instead, we introduce a novel ternary
text classification scheme, adding an "undecided" category for texts that could
be attributed to either source, and we show that this new category is crucial
to understand how to make the detection result more explainable to lay users.
This research shifts the paradigm from merely classifying to explaining
machine-generated texts, emphasizing need for detectors to provide clear and
understandable explanations to users. Our study involves creating four new
datasets comprised of texts from various LLMs and human authors. Based on new
datasets, we performed binary classification tests to ascertain the most
effective SOTA detection methods and identified SOTA LLMs capable of producing
harder-to-detect texts. We constructed a new dataset of texts generated by two
top-performing LLMs and human authors, and asked three human annotators to
produce ternary labels with explanation notes. This dataset was used to
investigate how three top-performing SOTA detectors behave in new ternary
classification context. Our results highlight why "undecided" category is much
needed from the viewpoint of explainability. Additionally, we conducted an
analysis of explainability of the three best-performing detectors and the
explanation notes of the human annotators, revealing insights about the
complexity of explainable detection of machine-generated texts. Finally, we
propose guidelines for developing future detection systems with improved
explanatory power. | [
-0.29901087284088135,
-0.6467402577400208,
0.7996317744255066,
-0.20328451693058014,
-0.20963628590106964,
0.21312354505062103,
-0.13606609404087067,
-0.7282553315162659,
-0.11784674227237701,
0.5795385837554932,
-0.5566647052764893,
-0.5703272819519043,
-0.7013631463050842,
0.5622795820236206,
-0.5664840340614319,
1.220485806465149,
-0.06854776293039322,
-0.31924208998680115,
-0.23708677291870117,
-0.06970047950744629,
-0.41370752453804016,
-0.5389953255653381,
-0.4733869731426239,
-0.46599337458610535,
0.4002775549888611,
0.49883317947387695,
0.5591102838516235,
0.6657274961471558,
0.41006356477737427,
0.36604127287864685,
-0.08490172773599625,
0.3528439700603485,
-0.2221677452325821,
0.11789613962173462,
-0.053838733583688736,
-0.6754471659660339,
-0.30751198530197144,
-0.2224123477935791,
0.3155766427516937,
0.4501437246799469,
0.3614342510700226,
0.12332157045602798,
-0.0062649850733578205,
0.48766839504241943,
-0.4687907099723816,
-0.08150892704725266,
-0.5420083403587341,
0.12059476971626282,
-0.38062751293182373,
-0.6930634379386902,
-0.6378913521766663,
-0.26111364364624023,
-0.08833953738212585,
-0.45344609022140503,
0.40519577264785767,
0.14110442996025085,
0.6049872040748596,
0.252515971660614,
-0.5227123498916626,
-0.6735640168190002,
-0.8030636310577393,
0.6350848078727722,
-0.44990041851997375,
-0.05692317709326744,
0.09363997727632523,
0.09146878123283386,
-0.1325046569108963,
-0.556188702583313,
-0.7415168881416321,
0.016195474192500114,
-0.08116523176431656,
-0.03159231320023537,
-0.4596598446369171,
-0.17315471172332764,
0.14299438893795013,
0.005405034404247999,
-0.6078664064407349,
0.4647310674190521,
-0.1741694062948227,
-0.3318602442741394,
0.6196279525756836,
0.14699481427669525,
0.6488043069839478,
-0.32359394431114197,
-0.48988479375839233,
0.42529284954071045,
-0.7567413449287415,
0.050704773515462875,
0.4589219391345978,
0.08661191910505295,
0.04423173516988754,
0.5966320633888245,
0.09255804866552353,
0.27453598380088806,
0.043263982981443405,
-0.12266217917203903,
0.011332225985825062,
-0.1929188370704651,
-0.04953617975115776,
0.5109974145889282,
1.0204555988311768,
0.25753647089004517,
0.31104910373687744,
-0.1651940643787384,
-0.22175616025924683,
0.11890760809183121,
0.057136550545692444,
-0.5854160189628601,
-0.11217799782752991,
0.18138498067855835,
-0.6032153964042664,
-0.6435664296150208,
0.07689335197210312,
-0.3160723149776459,
-0.7551688551902771,
-0.14218242466449738,
0.5241646766662598,
-0.07947315275669098,
-0.27660563588142395,
0.06106708571314812,
-0.1427036076784134,
-0.13313548266887665,
0.35200420022010803,
-0.9871132373809814,
0.07766623795032501,
0.7407705187797546,
0.4591115415096283,
-0.2718093991279602,
-0.16904519498348236,
-0.3036065697669983,
0.12242888659238815,
-0.4622945189476013,
1.1120837926864624,
-0.3916915953159332,
-0.08390144258737564,
-0.2452915608882904,
-0.14968125522136688,
0.34645116329193115,
-0.3855929374694824,
0.5141858458518982,
-0.49886441230773926,
0.6680642366409302,
-0.15763013064861298,
-0.45037704706192017,
-0.32637614011764526,
-0.012819466181099415,
-0.4820724129676819,
1.1095651388168335,
-0.22632847726345062,
-0.9042466282844543,
0.6601355075836182,
-0.6303308010101318,
-0.4450541138648987,
0.3923945426940918,
-0.314188152551651,
-0.6273037791252136,
0.07384991645812988,
0.04669254645705223,
0.8013936877250671,
-0.3656671643257141,
0.7564212083816528,
-0.1579895168542862,
-0.650189995765686,
0.7592024207115173,
-0.5498049855232239,
0.788074791431427,
0.20993424952030182,
-0.6928724050521851,
0.2060144543647766,
-0.7473882436752319,
-0.12706881761550903,
0.12411298602819443,
-0.27723342180252075,
-0.3209433853626251,
0.030875777825713158,
0.08346458524465561,
-0.12971477210521698,
0.21838848292827606,
-0.40038326382637024,
-0.13582393527030945,
-0.18866278231143951,
0.6526912450790405,
0.9252377152442932,
-0.13838110864162445,
0.44603264331817627,
-0.1606920212507248,
0.42508363723754883,
-0.13354548811912537,
-0.1253526359796524,
-0.19094206392765045,
-0.5106774568557739,
-0.7073125839233398,
-0.18421657383441925,
0.20011036098003387,
0.3369162380695343,
-0.8886123895645142,
0.603577196598053,
-0.17286820709705353,
-0.322736531496048,
-0.2880331873893738,
0.07659527659416199,
0.5643172264099121,
0.4332285523414612,
0.14455218613147736,
-0.03106740117073059,
-0.6225077509880066,
-0.719703733921051,
-0.5709853768348694,
-0.5348634123802185,
-0.1265690177679062,
0.17984001338481903,
0.7069292664527893,
-0.24689644575119019,
0.955498218536377,
-0.3699985444545746,
0.04281868040561676,
-0.49545249342918396,
0.4346754252910614,
0.03770295903086662,
0.24144712090492249,
0.29168936610221863,
-0.988624632358551,
-0.2774648070335388,
-0.06299833208322525,
-1.166678786277771,
-0.4769342839717865,
-0.32632771134376526,
0.09312179684638977,
0.4292319715023041,
0.587526261806488,
-0.37031736969947815,
0.5310074687004089,
-0.043052200227975845,
-0.4999469220638275,
0.4380791485309601,
-0.15675106644630432,
-0.011891831643879414,
-0.8568143248558044,
0.06363911181688309,
-0.030932722613215446,
-0.4040091633796692,
-0.7596933245658875,
0.02957414835691452,
-0.0733284279704094,
0.061866097152233124,
-0.35938021540641785,
0.34432709217071533,
-0.40136396884918213,
-0.10351447761058807,
-0.4212718904018402,
0.04503371939063072,
-0.0009464991744607687,
0.45406895875930786,
0.018550289794802666,
0.6085916757583618,
0.2319522202014923,
-0.5874384641647339,
0.092383474111557,
0.06758670508861542,
-0.20505160093307495,
0.573782742023468,
-0.5994508266448975,
0.18208441138267517,
-0.3244323432445526,
0.3432570695877075,
-1.173082947731018,
-0.1703420877456665,
0.5160678029060364,
-0.792649507522583,
0.1343420296907425,
-0.0816124752163887,
-0.6974654197692871,
-0.1318448781967163,
-0.28620681166648865,
0.20003458857536316,
0.31297093629837036,
-0.5342631936073303,
0.6336957216262817,
0.41424816846847534,
-0.1715700626373291,
-0.5072001218795776,
-0.6960844397544861,
0.4379531145095825,
-0.5612690448760986,
-0.44597914814949036,
0.28933146595954895,
-0.034391868859529495,
-0.2655971646308899,
0.08473747968673706,
-0.20236298441886902,
-0.15411551296710968,
0.5431671738624573,
0.48309358954429626,
0.330367773771286,
-0.27543914318084717,
0.31411951780319214,
-0.0685509443283081,
-0.6642679572105408,
0.2602101266384125,
-0.2564021944999695,
0.23899158835411072,
-0.11278783529996872,
-0.21383550763130188,
-0.7366113066673279,
0.35885679721832275,
0.3020581603050232,
0.09815504401922226,
0.5231748223304749,
0.9172719120979309,
-0.330567330121994,
-0.12343346327543259,
-0.30633115768432617,
-0.032959386706352234,
-0.48825374245643616,
0.1490909457206726,
-0.4343942701816559,
-0.9919691681861877,
0.25565305352211,
0.17207388579845428,
-0.02493998408317566,
0.6939800977706909,
0.7568923830986023,
-0.4379217326641083,
1.0385056734085083,
0.6665900945663452,
0.2433522641658783,
0.20927926898002625,
0.036908235400915146,
0.22750645875930786,
-0.3468807339668274,
-0.45396873354911804,
-0.6622825860977173,
-0.29834526777267456,
-1.0483304262161255,
-0.035834942013025284,
0.31072959303855896,
-0.3061048090457916,
-0.3173917531967163,
0.21889415383338928,
-0.7771714925765991,
0.7883506417274475,
0.6177141070365906,
0.21535684168338776,
0.6262701153755188,
-0.0994921401143074,
0.41720134019851685,
0.07475442439317703,
-0.35354846715927124,
-1.054943323135376,
1.1814156770706177,
0.2887468934059143,
0.6925620436668396,
0.24044078588485718,
0.9182812571525574,
0.7056939601898193,
0.18545514345169067,
-0.6059528589248657,
0.6810811758041382,
-0.30454424023628235,
-0.8410098552703857,
-0.09829916805028915,
-0.3428694009780884,
-1.1190218925476074,
0.10222195833921432,
-0.49899330735206604,
-0.7343751788139343,
-0.15253570675849915,
0.018674282357096672,
-0.19576045870780945,
0.32462021708488464,
-0.7383959293365479,
0.6482424139976501,
-0.4149794280529022,
-0.15022175014019012,
0.17472024261951447,
-0.8217887282371521,
0.3422510325908661,
-0.10265423357486725,
0.19325436651706696,
-0.14036664366722107,
-0.21940362453460693,
1.035873293876648,
-0.30071142315864563,
1.0080931186676025,
-0.08490895479917526,
-0.19106465578079224,
0.4428284168243408,
0.12723562121391296,
0.2673097252845764,
-0.06795462220907211,
0.09982580691576004,
0.12158004194498062,
-0.25276434421539307,
-0.2786516547203064,
-0.386648952960968,
0.33252570033073425,
-0.7267000675201416,
-0.48607465624809265,
-0.40391162037849426,
-0.27713149785995483,
0.21211588382720947,
0.410409539937973,
0.6937658786773682,
0.3690638840198517,
0.05519355461001396,
0.2173711061477661,
0.8122972249984741,
-0.20428802073001862,
0.35514840483665466,
0.4893170893192291,
0.049364712089300156,
0.017980851233005524,
1.1096996068954468,
-0.18740996718406677,
-0.11040788143873215,
0.830169141292572,
0.34298279881477356,
-0.39572176337242126,
-0.8181815147399902,
-0.548377275466919,
-0.20342455804347992,
-0.8381195068359375,
0.005485713016241789,
-0.9454348683357239,
0.0017157078254967928,
-0.012493166141211987,
-0.2835069000720978,
0.09431099146604538,
-0.48694196343421936,
-0.7937933802604675,
-0.062827929854393,
0.23116324841976166,
1.0317035913467407,
0.032645903527736664,
0.33468642830848694,
-0.5001019835472107,
0.5671857595443726,
0.1736026555299759,
-0.11414941400289536,
-0.11070238053798676,
-0.5321959853172302,
0.17341706156730652,
-0.19614183902740479,
-0.20483508706092834,
-0.9356849789619446,
0.14136123657226562,
-0.09065345674753189,
0.331102579832077,
0.38436222076416016,
0.19712084531784058,
0.2893776595592499,
-0.12342306226491928,
0.6080951690673828,
0.28116753697395325,
-1.0796514749526978,
0.4227651059627533,
-0.22558565437793732,
-0.20240293443202972,
0.42424798011779785,
0.2633502185344696,
-0.319709450006485,
-0.3954491913318634,
-0.5457887053489685,
-0.7477635145187378,
0.829738199710846,
0.43726152181625366,
0.12492367625236511,
0.32905465364456177,
0.33294373750686646,
0.6624242067337036,
0.10147403925657272,
-1.0610547065734863,
-0.3092038333415985,
0.17274858057498932,
-0.5150592923164368,
-0.11150556802749634,
-0.3451128900051117,
0.020984001457691193,
0.35413387417793274,
0.46716219186782837,
-0.11728373169898987,
0.40289226174354553,
-0.02297898381948471,
-0.2744510769844055,
0.04614530876278877,
0.42201653122901917,
0.4269063174724579,
0.4203146696090698,
-0.04960661754012108,
0.7398872971534729,
-0.03722194954752922,
-0.28430411219596863,
0.39793118834495544,
-0.07691583037376404,
-0.41585299372673035,
-0.034110791981220245,
0.9187861680984497,
0.6606847047805786,
0.019243858754634857,
-0.5726293325424194,
0.5315839052200317,
-0.15493269264698029,
-0.23623612523078918,
-0.12160585075616837,
0.38969171047210693,
-0.038309864699840546,
0.17876648902893066,
0.5026767253875732,
0.2550284266471863,
0.34992343187332153,
-0.6248804926872253,
-0.05052323639392853,
0.3011949360370636,
-0.3580687344074249,
-0.47862404584884644,
0.6647834181785583,
0.4228106737136841,
-0.5293365716934204,
0.11216314882040024,
-0.3591330349445343,
-0.7633192539215088,
0.8259089589118958,
0.49157994985580444,
0.9520236253738403,
0.41242021322250366,
0.3963994085788727,
-0.27901172637939453,
0.3986733555793762,
0.19755704700946808,
0.3201702833175659,
-0.32176443934440613,
-0.6992967128753662,
-0.18058376014232635,
-0.12028921395540237,
-0.5448980331420898,
0.08282213658094406,
-0.47365787625312805,
0.28087255358695984,
-0.33158329129219055,
-0.10298186540603638,
0.6162723898887634,
-0.005510059185326099,
-0.46247977018356323,
0.12255172431468964,
0.20155419409275055,
0.3258224427700043,
-1.0446971654891968,
0.08539167046546936,
0.688442587852478,
-0.19300046563148499,
-0.43550318479537964,
0.18015092611312866,
0.24169622361660004,
-1.1154370307922363,
0.6132673621177673,
0.4427177906036377,
-0.3168860077857971,
-0.02165861614048481,
-0.7953130602836609,
-0.24395214021205902,
0.8531857132911682,
0.3136262595653534,
-0.05653911456465721,
0.14629212021827698,
0.14467434585094452,
0.7029008269309998,
-0.22200702130794525,
0.5331326127052307,
0.34078240394592285,
0.5267134308815002,
0.013696035370230675,
-0.43262237310409546,
0.2928289771080017,
-0.1282850056886673,
-0.19748792052268982,
0.3246156871318817,
-0.3444216549396515,
0.5397399663925171,
-0.5312839150428772,
-0.4240078032016754,
0.10475358366966248,
0.5431277751922607,
0.30300185084342957,
1.104683518409729,
0.4144993722438812,
0.182087704539299,
0.7816628813743591,
-0.07215351611375809,
0.7353746891021729,
0.37230184674263,
0.1506289392709732,
1.0254651308059692,
-0.08657411485910416,
0.5311790108680725,
0.2601068913936615,
-0.21429869532585144,
0.6319323778152466,
0.838472843170166,
-0.0012675175676122308,
0.08728548139333725,
0.0886811837553978,
-0.19742530584335327,
-0.5146501064300537,
-0.3676917552947998,
-0.2652396261692047,
0.7239376902580261,
0.04288928210735321,
-0.4977680444717407,
-0.0244564488530159,
-0.040713705122470856,
0.13617929816246033,
0.1682751476764679,
-0.17353671789169312,
0.8920832872390747,
-0.11262594163417816,
-0.5217996835708618,
0.3791429102420807,
0.15060420334339142,
0.7240950465202332,
-0.16205817461013794,
0.21554388105869293,
0.014208989217877388,
0.1028599813580513,
-0.6171008944511414,
-1.232702374458313,
-0.027411792427301407,
0.6247366070747375,
-0.2331721931695938,
-0.4053006172180176,
0.9584625959396362,
-0.15129347145557404,
-0.4192500114440918,
-0.10638222843408585,
0.5741667151451111,
0.5472816824913025,
0.039975859224796295,
-0.46730709075927734,
-0.03495234623551369,
0.24937410652637482,
-0.0025044516660273075,
0.09596023708581924,
0.9487302303314209,
-0.298336923122406,
0.8131617307662964,
0.7727749347686768,
-0.31438663601875305,
-0.2697352170944214,
-0.0884832888841629,
0.6284413933753967,
-0.819595992565155,
-0.4800974428653717,
-1.2537647485733032,
0.33648064732551575,
0.20741848647594452,
-0.21819531917572021,
0.5229153633117676,
0.47513628005981445,
0.4660666286945343,
0.03280331566929817,
0.9030866026878357,
-0.09512430429458618,
0.304491251707077,
-0.6202048063278198,
0.5934045910835266,
-0.6268017292022705,
0.5268620252609253,
-0.15273118019104004,
-0.5990170240402222,
-0.3253631889820099,
0.22114349901676178,
-0.03458502143621445,
0.19667242467403412,
0.6314371824264526,
0.4504488408565521,
0.1078355610370636,
0.291525274515152,
0.013119007460772991,
0.14938350021839142,
0.4319809675216675,
0.7557634711265564,
1.2294601202011108,
-0.32058945298194885,
0.8611009120941162,
0.12053397297859192,
-0.2532702386379242,
-0.417936772108078,
-1.0540398359298706,
-1.1471630334854126,
-0.5440322160720825,
-0.4083062410354614,
-0.0997091606259346,
-0.1566389799118042,
0.5015268325805664,
0.5402625203132629,
-0.7193412184715271,
0.18735718727111816,
-0.28589537739753723,
0.6187418699264526,
0.17116105556488037,
-0.2318938821554184,
0.3028850853443146,
0.10307852178812027,
-0.5942350029945374,
0.04600847139954567,
0.4320438504219055,
0.1303364485502243,
-0.2533763349056244,
-0.03975444659590721,
0.22386550903320312,
-0.09170667827129364,
0.4943283200263977,
0.1569313257932663,
-0.8259856104850769,
-0.18988864123821259,
-0.03235018998384476,
-0.17360790073871613,
-0.017520109191536903,
0.7757045030593872,
-0.6893030405044556,
0.5356189608573914,
0.5805130004882812,
0.4564005434513092,
0.24186104536056519,
-0.07204587012529373,
0.16723299026489258,
-0.5498331189155579,
-0.3457701802253723,
0.22102609276771545,
0.04400937259197235,
0.35286304354667664,
-0.6986287832260132,
0.6003928184509277,
0.31483715772628784,
-0.4452076256275177,
-0.9960087537765503,
0.20314228534698486,
-0.9043242335319519,
-0.48695093393325806,
1.0385830402374268,
0.05658944696187973,
-0.07810115814208984,
-0.5152126550674438,
-0.30470553040504456,
0.2996547222137451,
-0.4638562798500061,
0.736527144908905,
0.43565723299980164,
-0.33509793877601624,
0.0035796465817838907,
-0.22303563356399536,
0.16510386765003204,
0.22122356295585632,
-1.0481892824172974,
0.016838202252984047,
0.3191162943840027,
0.2020283192396164,
0.1489650309085846,
0.7594456672668457,
0.08488842844963074,
0.3934495747089386,
-0.20031216740608215,
0.11304139345884323,
-0.20892353355884552,
-0.3935711085796356,
-0.1331111192703247,
0.1721385419368744,
0.029335753992199898,
-0.21323081851005554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18256v1 | LLaMIPa: An Incremental Discourse Parser | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | 2024-06-26T11:08:17 | Kate Thompson, Akshay Chaturvedi, Julie Hunter, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper provides the first discourse parsing experiments with a large
language model (LLM) finetuned on corpora annotated in the style of SDRT
(Asher, 1993; Asher and Lascarides, 2003). The result is a discourse parser,
LLaMIPa (LLaMA Incremental Parser), which is able to more fully exploit
discourse context, leading to substantial performance gains over approaches
that use encoder-only models to provide local, context-sensitive
representations of discourse units. Furthermore, it is able to process
discourse data incrementally, which is essential for the eventual use of
discourse information in downstream tasks. | [
-0.211610347032547,
-0.8994625210762024,
0.7893521785736084,
0.47287002205848694,
-0.4488087296485901,
0.07502653449773788,
0.05425790697336197,
-0.32895344495773315,
0.3680834472179413,
0.5430944561958313,
-0.27952516078948975,
-0.47106486558914185,
-0.6729445457458496,
0.2231801152229309,
-0.5640257000923157,
0.6811731457710266,
0.057880278676748276,
0.1397000551223755,
-0.16939927637577057,
0.018885117024183273,
-0.4488389790058136,
-0.5335538983345032,
-0.954033374786377,
-0.45127323269844055,
0.5256966948509216,
0.519168496131897,
0.46030130982398987,
0.6118951439857483,
0.3239057660102844,
0.362018883228302,
-0.22733691334724426,
-0.05420947074890137,
-0.39424070715904236,
0.415739506483078,
-0.23194438219070435,
-0.5637752413749695,
-0.3951135575771332,
-0.3988181948661804,
1.0108907222747803,
0.6661258339881897,
0.010301830247044563,
0.2024756520986557,
0.02577729895710945,
0.164911150932312,
-0.41485247015953064,
0.055468183010816574,
-0.6525481343269348,
0.08559195697307587,
-0.39344581961631775,
-0.6001186966896057,
-0.5861776471138,
-0.6315225958824158,
-0.2800736427307129,
-0.3092958331108093,
-0.23801296949386597,
-0.2077501267194748,
0.7930781245231628,
0.3517450988292694,
-0.46485334634780884,
-0.31616532802581787,
-0.6382173895835876,
0.5002784729003906,
-0.7191863059997559,
0.1993553787469864,
0.06633932143449783,
0.11258745193481445,
-0.1936648041009903,
-1.1203421354293823,
-0.6565012335777283,
-0.30966851115226746,
-0.11243262141942978,
-0.2525268793106079,
-0.08090180158615112,
-0.0017124543664976954,
0.23336119949817657,
0.5727874636650085,
-0.40269264578819275,
0.4283411204814911,
-0.34019461274147034,
0.07555095106363297,
0.22182723879814148,
0.3577929735183716,
0.12599492073059082,
-0.2135789692401886,
-0.5380004048347473,
0.2034195512533188,
-0.9138225317001343,
-0.03907579928636551,
0.18250243365764618,
0.103880874812603,
-0.015704836696386337,
0.7314209342002869,
-0.05343538522720337,
0.6208685636520386,
-0.10249342769384384,
-0.5514554977416992,
0.01032899972051382,
0.04463987424969673,
-0.5271353125572205,
0.2158142477273941,
0.5845869183540344,
-0.27492305636405945,
-0.0020684523042291403,
0.23571154475212097,
-0.030255207791924477,
0.3153914213180542,
0.07472670823335648,
-0.8166912198066711,
0.00547315226867795,
0.220650315284729,
-0.19060467183589935,
-0.3472867012023926,
-0.4292362630367279,
-0.8281819224357605,
-0.3889462351799011,
-0.5791112184524536,
-0.10506143420934677,
-0.45887666940689087,
-0.08635368198156357,
-0.11356792598962784,
0.38298577070236206,
0.5104855895042419,
0.46944400668144226,
-0.7077863812446594,
0.564141035079956,
1.034732460975647,
0.955940842628479,
-0.36459314823150635,
-0.33836567401885986,
-0.4904769957065582,
0.1688360571861267,
-0.3225569725036621,
1.2755078077316284,
-0.6625289916992188,
-0.4294583201408386,
0.04658351466059685,
0.06715131551027298,
0.1337655633687973,
-0.4706840217113495,
0.7525420188903809,
-0.5991401672363281,
-0.18914270401000977,
-0.1805317997932434,
-0.7765182256698608,
-0.12272766977548599,
0.4083564281463623,
-0.49382299184799194,
1.0018234252929688,
0.22066186368465424,
-0.774272620677948,
0.1773107945919037,
-0.6416880488395691,
-0.32004958391189575,
0.22974823415279388,
-0.3728524446487427,
-0.057850565761327744,
0.007122087758034468,
0.08303981274366379,
0.3248276114463806,
-0.4704445004463196,
0.6968747973442078,
-0.09498792886734009,
-0.4510304927825928,
0.40709155797958374,
-0.6176976561546326,
0.9846798777580261,
0.18387582898139954,
-0.11574839800596237,
0.19521352648735046,
-0.8976518511772156,
-0.27564868330955505,
0.2528078854084015,
-0.5541902184486389,
-0.35162580013275146,
-0.2608764171600342,
-0.07016752660274506,
0.14322637021541595,
0.5119932293891907,
-0.6646983623504639,
0.3864522874355316,
-0.31113019585609436,
0.32363855838775635,
1.0372438430786133,
0.05809202045202255,
0.05049985274672508,
-0.021419890224933624,
0.6195797324180603,
0.04294688254594803,
-0.21042706072330475,
-0.5436040759086609,
-0.5546761155128479,
-1.079309344291687,
-0.4690108001232147,
0.582011878490448,
0.6335986852645874,
-0.5543763041496277,
0.10289309918880463,
-0.5231340527534485,
-0.3725224733352661,
-0.714546263217926,
-0.08268218487501144,
0.1718231439590454,
0.6782432794570923,
0.1091962531208992,
-0.2546974718570709,
-0.8328229784965515,
-1.0830943584442139,
0.25044575333595276,
-0.07978396862745285,
-0.02602582424879074,
-0.09299440681934357,
0.5146578550338745,
-0.19366824626922607,
0.7311222553253174,
-0.6026937365531921,
-0.13444548845291138,
-0.3180364668369293,
0.18142758309841156,
0.18689295649528503,
0.34454694390296936,
0.26040321588516235,
-0.4995231330394745,
-0.4110877513885498,
0.0594046451151371,
-0.8786247372627258,
-0.2850046753883362,
-0.07802057266235352,
-0.07812678068876266,
-0.03052946925163269,
0.6511019468307495,
-0.6247315406799316,
0.3098406493663788,
0.7625793814659119,
-0.3431830406188965,
0.33726292848587036,
-0.01781485043466091,
0.041865505278110504,
-1.125665307044983,
-0.00262164743617177,
-0.25304514169692993,
-0.5668603777885437,
-0.5930986404418945,
0.2329285740852356,
-0.0613451786339283,
-0.027091454714536667,
-0.672778844833374,
0.5366373658180237,
-0.13923075795173645,
-0.45591357350349426,
-0.44926583766937256,
0.25866588950157166,
0.15163153409957886,
0.5996195673942566,
0.07388410717248917,
1.2459367513656616,
0.19432063400745392,
-0.5978792905807495,
0.1811797320842743,
0.27959248423576355,
-0.4711257517337799,
0.8136292695999146,
-0.741803765296936,
0.3230000138282776,
-0.07316578179597855,
0.16603852808475494,
-1.2088669538497925,
-0.1357787698507309,
0.1777614951133728,
-0.11774195730686188,
0.26583170890808105,
-0.026583049446344376,
-0.6443278789520264,
-0.003604920580983162,
-0.3510829508304596,
0.40579473972320557,
0.12311730533838272,
-0.7187526226043701,
0.2818831503391266,
0.7441107034683228,
-0.527247428894043,
-0.3377982974052429,
-0.7570019364356995,
0.24919505417346954,
-0.33243528008461,
-0.500137209892273,
0.3360339105129242,
0.061478376388549805,
-0.518603503704071,
-0.3566029965877533,
0.6110749244689941,
-0.1741063892841339,
-0.03389476612210274,
0.27400633692741394,
0.20941053330898285,
-0.38478079438209534,
0.023006709292531013,
0.388210266828537,
-0.10391062498092651,
-0.09043250977993011,
0.22421078383922577,
1.0369571447372437,
-0.23649653792381287,
-0.22693109512329102,
-0.748900830745697,
0.6206092834472656,
0.31727683544158936,
0.1551673263311386,
0.5812661051750183,
-0.010824494063854218,
-0.206508070230484,
0.24232220649719238,
-0.447358101606369,
0.22490979731082916,
-0.49833008646965027,
0.07881869375705719,
-0.6301746368408203,
-1.1389966011047363,
0.30739283561706543,
-0.5295612812042236,
0.03142623230814934,
0.270381361246109,
0.6353859901428223,
0.18838591873645782,
0.6382347941398621,
0.7301861047744751,
-0.23611299693584442,
0.2830185294151306,
-0.007111449725925922,
0.050145622342824936,
-1.2441258430480957,
0.13719753921031952,
-0.4666087329387665,
-0.22339113056659698,
-0.6676128506660461,
-0.5343332290649414,
0.19294705986976624,
-0.3165082335472107,
-0.5692715048789978,
0.28800028562545776,
-0.47976621985435486,
0.3455469608306885,
0.39332014322280884,
-0.2720397412776947,
0.8069528341293335,
-0.03204439952969551,
-0.03642243891954422,
-0.3083861470222473,
-0.3444923460483551,
-0.7776760458946228,
0.7671226263046265,
0.5958438515663147,
0.5710511207580566,
0.08421328663825989,
0.5599145293235779,
0.20220156013965607,
0.6063476204872131,
-0.8278709053993225,
0.8714882135391235,
-0.023324081674218178,
-0.032243672758340836,
-0.03448936343193054,
-0.05117499455809593,
-1.1448155641555786,
0.7406381368637085,
0.4065426290035248,
-0.8951600790023804,
0.38972222805023193,
-0.16216810047626495,
-0.2045322060585022,
0.26370999217033386,
-0.23387864232063293,
0.5664837956428528,
-0.006515676621347666,
-0.20462623238563538,
0.06024281680583954,
-0.2571515440940857,
0.7989374399185181,
0.07045337557792664,
0.15268445014953613,
-0.27722299098968506,
-0.3200807273387909,
0.4206230342388153,
-0.07034305483102798,
0.910115659236908,
-0.04475505277514458,
-0.45116668939590454,
0.367682546377182,
0.3782499134540558,
0.49043890833854675,
0.16460396349430084,
-0.13919173181056976,
0.26780450344085693,
-0.19386138021945953,
-0.07057981193065643,
-0.2512366473674774,
0.9122043251991272,
-0.5961893200874329,
-0.6714271903038025,
-0.5678897500038147,
-0.44054481387138367,
-0.06106988340616226,
0.022193986922502518,
0.0654115229845047,
0.07010383903980255,
-0.3995246887207031,
0.019621090963482857,
0.5984310507774353,
-0.13916456699371338,
0.33223956823349,
0.41215747594833374,
-0.49998313188552856,
-0.48877066373825073,
0.5449030995368958,
0.08647691458463669,
0.033209316432476044,
0.49100005626678467,
0.04800725728273392,
0.04746107757091522,
-0.4093784987926483,
-0.24061749875545502,
0.32843610644340515,
-0.890487551689148,
-0.4307998716831207,
-0.8329293131828308,
-0.4081543982028961,
-0.26212209463119507,
-0.1678919792175293,
-0.45495957136154175,
-0.6262351274490356,
-0.5141332149505615,
-0.34331244230270386,
0.20523497462272644,
0.671912670135498,
0.09866534173488617,
0.5320225954055786,
-0.24385486543178558,
0.26354503631591797,
0.35975804924964905,
-0.14425858855247498,
-0.1850213259458542,
-0.6780595183372498,
0.21109336614608765,
-0.21362558007240295,
-0.4621611535549164,
-0.8466017246246338,
0.6579182147979736,
0.04233768209815025,
0.0753379613161087,
0.3274831473827362,
-0.3440644443035126,
0.8892347812652588,
-0.6495162844657898,
0.9457641243934631,
-0.11208517104387283,
-1.0052025318145752,
0.7367511987686157,
-0.35330668091773987,
0.5936147570610046,
0.548577070236206,
0.3522845506668091,
-0.4478756785392761,
-0.5012362599372864,
-0.3403952121734619,
-0.9489096403121948,
0.3927641212940216,
-0.1411026418209076,
0.2895652949810028,
-0.2688233554363251,
0.2797870337963104,
0.4590441584587097,
0.2789386212825775,
-0.9360253214836121,
-0.15217263996601105,
0.14787793159484863,
0.045354053378105164,
0.172430157661438,
-0.8571083545684814,
-0.17983783781528473,
-0.4657421410083771,
0.49560946226119995,
-0.21209809184074402,
0.5028941631317139,
0.17880038917064667,
-0.13004837930202484,
0.11017511039972305,
0.4703163504600525,
0.7804966568946838,
0.8338028192520142,
0.14946570992469788,
0.35596963763237,
0.33869287371635437,
-0.4116014838218689,
0.4217119812965393,
-0.10475211590528488,
-0.6282905340194702,
0.19059564173221588,
0.24816074967384338,
0.8493637442588806,
0.565570056438446,
-0.6267920136451721,
0.29246583580970764,
-0.15790852904319763,
0.04701615497469902,
-0.8764854073524475,
-0.2025856077671051,
0.16722221672534943,
0.2716064751148224,
0.18248377740383148,
-0.42613333463668823,
0.2986546754837036,
-0.48338136076927185,
0.1962965428829193,
0.07275017350912094,
-0.015873773023486137,
-0.18848338723182678,
0.5753714442253113,
-0.2030775249004364,
-0.2557797133922577,
0.3617049753665924,
-0.12712906301021576,
-0.11471796035766602,
0.37637409567832947,
0.877469003200531,
0.724969744682312,
-0.5748047828674316,
0.33794811367988586,
0.33956530690193176,
0.10639940947294235,
0.049294546246528625,
0.3537038266658783,
-0.005003606900572777,
-0.6066460013389587,
-0.6538004875183105,
-0.8267742395401001,
-0.6971169710159302,
0.2924349308013916,
-0.5168039202690125,
0.30487775802612305,
-0.5900117754936218,
-0.03826969116926193,
0.048132020980119705,
-0.26602157950401306,
-0.48159921169281006,
0.005424799397587776,
0.09297177940607071,
0.86930912733078,
-0.3994896709918976,
1.3257453441619873,
0.31761661171913147,
-0.20033779740333557,
-0.38061925768852234,
-0.057467006146907806,
-0.07306548207998276,
-0.8465699553489685,
0.7596622705459595,
0.07540105283260345,
-0.1754927933216095,
-0.09811697900295258,
-0.5302109122276306,
-1.107785701751709,
1.1634459495544434,
0.8312150835990906,
-0.5511178970336914,
0.1908629834651947,
0.4789864122867584,
0.5754662752151489,
-0.6720951795578003,
-0.008616299368441105,
0.9547754526138306,
0.3092171847820282,
0.1628972738981247,
-0.6711324453353882,
0.12970517575740814,
-0.10591544955968857,
0.4610896110534668,
0.00020557317475322634,
-0.660526692867279,
1.22240149974823,
0.3055335581302643,
-0.18494728207588196,
0.18701492249965668,
1.1325165033340454,
0.39473673701286316,
0.14749301970005035,
0.1088329330086708,
0.6055125594139099,
0.8078736066818237,
0.07255250960588455,
1.0918362140655518,
-0.15173104405403137,
-0.0034833087120205164,
1.6729328632354736,
-0.4808167517185211,
1.2224986553192139,
0.597359299659729,
-0.32365429401397705,
0.8654140830039978,
0.6332110166549683,
0.29537734389305115,
0.4233904480934143,
0.1389707326889038,
-0.6010335087776184,
0.27291423082351685,
-0.4700707793235779,
-0.2546842098236084,
0.6449245810508728,
0.6548400521278381,
-0.3791877329349518,
-0.21755725145339966,
0.09756786376237869,
0.5018538236618042,
0.14035175740718842,
-0.4003789722919464,
0.7866421937942505,
0.2536744177341461,
-0.7110573649406433,
0.5967726111412048,
0.16936235129833221,
0.6691961884498596,
-0.4405961334705353,
-0.17730239033699036,
-0.32172873616218567,
0.10791467130184174,
-0.025851983577013016,
-0.8443220257759094,
0.5379473567008972,
0.164369136095047,
0.3244364261627197,
-0.1394990235567093,
0.8463382720947266,
-0.19616791605949402,
-0.5406204462051392,
0.38913023471832275,
0.20980729162693024,
0.25336453318595886,
0.24679134786128998,
-0.36297738552093506,
0.4768148362636566,
-0.1741562932729721,
-0.44781494140625,
0.5958238840103149,
0.4298553764820099,
0.1615900695323944,
0.5987744927406311,
0.43137821555137634,
0.037559472024440765,
0.10083472728729248,
-0.028705716133117676,
1.2270939350128174,
-0.6932374238967896,
-0.32171353697776794,
-0.9739235639572144,
0.4900799095630646,
-0.13677068054676056,
-0.3174830377101898,
0.6811525225639343,
0.535529613494873,
0.6071934103965759,
0.1113545149564743,
0.7011796832084656,
0.058355994522571564,
0.6021861433982849,
-0.5074962377548218,
0.10902578383684158,
-0.19072437286376953,
0.38377782702445984,
-0.0379161462187767,
-0.8388471007347107,
-0.19537466764450073,
0.6936701536178589,
-0.31614017486572266,
-0.46411412954330444,
0.6284996867179871,
0.5200902819633484,
0.03900348022580147,
0.08717517554759979,
0.48243266344070435,
0.3534821569919586,
0.20233091711997986,
0.4358939826488495,
0.7659969329833984,
-0.31217604875564575,
0.09513746947050095,
-0.37979257106781006,
-0.10438218712806702,
-0.02122022584080696,
-0.8154813051223755,
-0.6214441061019897,
-0.41024214029312134,
-0.12681294977664948,
-0.15618006885051727,
-0.01586175709962845,
0.8752130270004272,
0.10557510703802109,
-0.7256661653518677,
-0.5247743725776672,
-0.1145821288228035,
0.1496301293373108,
0.15996606647968292,
-0.26568782329559326,
0.2431497424840927,
-0.36806002259254456,
-0.914484977722168,
0.7123465538024902,
0.5389828085899353,
-0.16845867037773132,
-0.6881579160690308,
0.2914562225341797,
-0.5923150181770325,
0.33016830682754517,
0.8875536322593689,
0.3263518810272217,
-0.5482401251792908,
-0.32847732305526733,
-0.4650239050388336,
-0.16860374808311462,
0.7001035213470459,
0.894503116607666,
-0.8123434782028198,
0.08022478967905045,
0.29869118332862854,
0.5117221474647522,
0.6853904724121094,
-0.07718662172555923,
0.49263685941696167,
-0.7671287655830383,
0.6950659155845642,
0.3427068889141083,
0.5503597259521484,
0.5564941763877869,
-0.49988508224487305,
0.7239415645599365,
-0.1998896449804306,
-0.6890536546707153,
-0.9663645625114441,
0.27674412727355957,
-0.8272648453712463,
-0.1754532903432846,
1.1294305324554443,
-0.3372500240802765,
-0.386358380317688,
-0.16387930512428284,
-0.5049023032188416,
0.02840377204120159,
-0.2895641028881073,
0.572945237159729,
0.43030092120170593,
-0.3086480498313904,
-0.48529788851737976,
-0.8155391216278076,
0.2962549030780792,
0.11302482336759567,
-1.1319385766983032,
-0.06355119496583939,
0.20176562666893005,
0.11331579089164734,
0.16031703352928162,
1.263746738433838,
-0.2013780176639557,
0.01401032879948616,
0.22976680099964142,
-0.22965607047080994,
0.3614847660064697,
-0.2763162851333618,
-0.4559697210788727,
0.6852121949195862,
0.3339292109012604,
0.01366263348609209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18245v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18245v2 | Weak Reward Model Transforms Generative Models into Robust Causal Event Extraction Systems | 2024-06-26T10:48:14 | 2024-06-27T10:19:55 | Italo Luis da Silva, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The inherent ambiguity of cause and effect boundaries poses a challenge in
evaluating causal event extraction tasks. Traditional metrics like Exact Match
and BertScore poorly reflect model performance, so we trained evaluation models
to approximate human evaluation, achieving high agreement. We used them to
perform Reinforcement Learning with extraction models to align them with human
preference, prioritising semantic understanding. We successfully explored our
approach through multiple datasets, including transferring an evaluator trained
on one dataset to another as a way to decrease the reliance on human-annotated
data. In that vein, we also propose a weak-to-strong supervision method that
uses a fraction of the annotated data to train an evaluation model while still
achieving high performance in training an RL model. Our code is available at
https://github.com/oyarsa/event_extraction/tree/causal-event-extraction. | [
-0.08394164592027664,
-0.504296600818634,
0.6457588076591492,
0.25695472955703735,
-0.3235801160335541,
-0.41991543769836426,
-0.26795515418052673,
-0.6411680579185486,
-0.14666157960891724,
0.22341327369213104,
-0.5083037614822388,
-0.22413396835327148,
-0.9961785078048706,
-0.03803237900137901,
-0.09854783862829208,
1.2927545309066772,
-0.09892012923955917,
0.05516666918992996,
-0.08747480064630508,
-0.12090282887220383,
-0.5156858563423157,
-0.38872575759887695,
-0.8096862435340881,
-0.6940542459487915,
0.8699697852134705,
0.21410226821899414,
0.4695426821708679,
0.5331900715827942,
0.5326287150382996,
0.211959108710289,
-0.11139010637998581,
0.17360639572143555,
-0.6787261366844177,
-0.08489835262298584,
-0.6611744165420532,
-0.24955517053604126,
-0.2256593257188797,
0.15261496603488922,
0.34086066484451294,
0.5453470349311829,
-0.12395425885915756,
0.22400830686092377,
0.015140160918235779,
0.1377127319574356,
-1.0809532403945923,
0.2943476140499115,
-0.5007069706916809,
0.1444282978773117,
-0.053470589220523834,
-0.3663090765476227,
-0.562008261680603,
-0.21237094700336456,
0.16838271915912628,
-0.5482837557792664,
0.1078883484005928,
-0.18422234058380127,
1.2554348707199097,
0.2456544190645218,
-0.517368495464325,
0.06926064193248749,
-0.7288526892662048,
0.9959806203842163,
-0.47925177216529846,
0.15850788354873657,
0.43755456805229187,
0.26394203305244446,
-0.1362224668264389,
-0.8346173763275146,
-0.2165154665708542,
-0.045714445412158966,
-0.10957187414169312,
0.22280938923358917,
-0.20322781801223755,
0.0365731455385685,
0.26065269112586975,
0.17260248959064484,
-0.22231034934520721,
0.42477312684059143,
-0.4603993594646454,
0.06169288977980614,
0.862640380859375,
0.47676071524620056,
0.2264430671930313,
-0.4823845326900482,
-0.5223284959793091,
-0.22459650039672852,
-0.6484174728393555,
0.26037201285362244,
0.3152236044406891,
0.6296190619468689,
-0.05891432985663414,
0.4976857006549835,
-0.15068145096302032,
0.6460717916488647,
0.011762691661715508,
0.06738191843032837,
0.019803687930107117,
-0.23781606554985046,
-0.3229430913925171,
-0.037228845059871674,
0.9799900054931641,
-0.029114676639437675,
-0.12053147703409195,
-0.6083942651748657,
-0.36358773708343506,
0.20855659246444702,
0.6041962504386902,
-0.7664363980293274,
-0.2815147340297699,
-0.008164866827428341,
-0.7646456360816956,
-0.6779214143753052,
0.3384104371070862,
-0.8968356251716614,
-0.4873746931552887,
-0.4158121645450592,
0.6975718140602112,
-0.12199277430772781,
-0.19906654953956604,
0.2389606088399887,
-0.5227223634719849,
0.3956972360610962,
0.4580528140068054,
-0.9227699637413025,
0.2400922030210495,
0.562532365322113,
0.6276123523712158,
-0.48937806487083435,
-0.17116965353488922,
-1.042368769645691,
-0.03898552060127258,
-0.07864681631326675,
0.5646782517433167,
-0.2881859242916107,
-0.17600798606872559,
-0.17135901749134064,
0.08274035900831223,
-0.0735170990228653,
-0.5277819633483887,
1.0093348026275635,
-0.6572307348251343,
0.17481876909732819,
-0.03642253950238228,
-0.28392326831817627,
-0.02724349871277809,
-0.026435038074851036,
-0.6297734379768372,
0.777338445186615,
0.11274351179599762,
-0.6725075244903564,
0.7607604265213013,
-0.5251390337944031,
-0.6807703971862793,
0.044817984104156494,
-0.23550663888454437,
-0.8196706771850586,
0.2545536458492279,
0.3763194978237152,
0.6050633192062378,
-0.41173478960990906,
0.7110784649848938,
-0.6047642827033997,
-0.4085015058517456,
-0.019071469083428383,
-0.4533821642398834,
0.893587052822113,
0.20836560428142548,
-0.6443713903427124,
0.602684736251831,
-0.8200773000717163,
-0.2451748251914978,
0.4845077097415924,
-0.38278618454933167,
-0.489176481962204,
0.40113869309425354,
0.2705526053905487,
0.502604067325592,
0.1146204024553299,
-0.323490709066391,
0.2485543042421341,
-0.3999807834625244,
0.13419023156166077,
0.9587444067001343,
0.22158466279506683,
0.3261612057685852,
-0.01730138435959816,
0.3523882329463959,
-0.006523929536342621,
0.3279348313808441,
0.3877606987953186,
-0.31550684571266174,
-0.5664805173873901,
-0.2946948707103729,
0.13171175122261047,
0.4161390960216522,
-0.6744803190231323,
0.7150791883468628,
-0.22092679142951965,
-0.25886237621307373,
-0.37361013889312744,
0.3520549535751343,
0.4363834857940674,
0.49518728256225586,
0.3325037658214569,
-0.5032324194908142,
-0.635676383972168,
-0.7810214161872864,
-0.21951846778392792,
-0.4238680303096771,
-0.18298977613449097,
0.18074540793895721,
0.5319511890411377,
0.021650444716215134,
0.9888206124305725,
-0.4547627866268158,
-0.23476192355155945,
-0.44077956676483154,
0.6644512414932251,
0.26882392168045044,
0.4718392789363861,
0.17433612048625946,
-0.9198556542396545,
0.1954033076763153,
0.01606292836368084,
-1.093852162361145,
-0.015802212059497833,
-0.3409844934940338,
-0.1357540786266327,
-0.41065075993537903,
0.29024478793144226,
-0.4389697015285492,
0.6525616645812988,
-0.03990624099969864,
-0.6034588813781738,
0.6851513981819153,
0.1652604639530182,
0.10870186984539032,
-0.6389505863189697,
0.3510534465312958,
0.07898169755935669,
-0.24834482371807098,
-0.2879377007484436,
-0.016248587518930435,
0.1470160186290741,
-0.049586039036512375,
-0.5746177434921265,
0.5036494135856628,
-0.15384556353092194,
-0.19529277086257935,
-0.1964399516582489,
0.05721500515937805,
0.12137679010629654,
0.7508465051651001,
0.2514397203922272,
0.2579759657382965,
0.30458512902259827,
-0.5735034942626953,
0.35937801003456116,
0.29122382402420044,
-0.374174028635025,
0.45061230659484863,
-0.7474855184555054,
-0.1746872216463089,
-0.03166177123785019,
-0.1111513003706932,
-0.5459001064300537,
-0.2900761365890503,
0.38101115822792053,
-0.2302667796611786,
0.39651089906692505,
-0.3777102828025818,
-0.34349268674850464,
-0.21517813205718994,
-0.14563196897506714,
0.25749439001083374,
0.4309355914592743,
-0.9338337779045105,
0.42382487654685974,
0.17243891954421997,
-0.04427880421280861,
-0.5466511249542236,
-0.3815276026725769,
0.011341705918312073,
-0.6521304845809937,
-0.22941386699676514,
0.09030632674694061,
0.545352041721344,
-0.11772720515727997,
0.22522282600402832,
-0.02511102519929409,
0.05655160918831825,
0.5593541264533997,
0.46882155537605286,
0.4770036041736603,
-0.10043532401323318,
0.2514972984790802,
-0.08574159443378448,
-0.14812308549880981,
0.24563714861869812,
-0.19122417271137238,
-0.07628446817398071,
-0.0011493064230307937,
-0.4911476969718933,
-0.589958131313324,
0.2747061848640442,
0.28822576999664307,
-0.23704837262630463,
0.705132782459259,
0.8506136536598206,
-0.4420076906681061,
-0.10902255773544312,
-0.14111961424350739,
-0.3556373715400696,
-0.3603168725967407,
0.4372735321521759,
-0.3197154104709625,
-0.7093505859375,
0.3688912093639374,
-0.2455277442932129,
-0.1302051693201065,
0.7443631291389465,
0.5221121311187744,
0.21330003440380096,
1.333605408668518,
0.5060962438583374,
-0.27557823061943054,
0.8099656701087952,
-0.028578074648976326,
-0.04317908361554146,
-0.5543780326843262,
-0.2559136748313904,
-0.5653362274169922,
0.05306030437350273,
-0.14003825187683105,
0.047359563410282135,
0.17923183739185333,
0.6160160303115845,
-0.3244113326072693,
0.2635803520679474,
-0.34830641746520996,
0.10596871376037598,
0.42485037446022034,
0.3947310447692871,
0.1311008632183075,
-0.23459875583648682,
0.3097955584526062,
-0.06252965331077576,
-0.9011175632476807,
-0.45623084902763367,
0.9719659686088562,
0.35117602348327637,
0.9636570811271667,
0.08259016275405884,
0.7794868350028992,
0.39571911096572876,
0.5045641660690308,
-0.6509110927581787,
0.03166981041431427,
0.1432633399963379,
-0.41213634610176086,
-0.4499986171722412,
-0.732215404510498,
-1.2009464502334595,
0.3941621780395508,
-0.40275391936302185,
-1.0374584197998047,
0.6305868029594421,
-0.22184346616268158,
-0.31602445244789124,
0.3450145125389099,
-0.7573484182357788,
1.3509763479232788,
-0.2557562291622162,
-0.7705687880516052,
-0.1678510159254074,
-0.7208299040794373,
0.6369168162345886,
0.3080853223800659,
-0.08357436209917068,
0.05083247274160385,
0.4241998791694641,
0.9446741938591003,
-0.3893338143825531,
0.9553433060646057,
-0.2365281581878662,
0.18582217395305634,
0.257213294506073,
-0.02936439774930477,
0.9465586543083191,
0.17061810195446014,
0.09191243350505829,
-0.047658223658800125,
-0.33318930864334106,
-0.5856688618659973,
-0.7913427352905273,
0.3329351544380188,
-0.9555659294128418,
-0.31513485312461853,
-0.3048641085624695,
-0.1399829238653183,
-0.09700071066617966,
-0.081031933426857,
0.025309721007943153,
0.31498071551322937,
-0.34542223811149597,
-0.0667872503399849,
0.4399324953556061,
-0.22249957919120789,
0.21386267244815826,
0.2639104425907135,
0.0731353834271431,
-0.23122043907642365,
1.0074080228805542,
-0.5576253533363342,
0.13689695298671722,
0.1991654634475708,
0.2516891658306122,
-0.25485357642173767,
-0.28823336958885193,
-0.4825756847858429,
-0.11343242973089218,
-0.7353211045265198,
-0.358798623085022,
-0.5837801694869995,
-0.06531311571598053,
-0.2820517420768738,
-0.23117563128471375,
-0.36031246185302734,
-0.19928991794586182,
-0.5903711915016174,
-0.3018430173397064,
0.08926990628242493,
0.7958983778953552,
-0.30364981293678284,
0.2449418008327484,
-0.49796369671821594,
0.4671803116798401,
0.5521309971809387,
0.1751236766576767,
0.16046340763568878,
-0.3594740629196167,
-0.3409254252910614,
-0.527270495891571,
-0.4724060297012329,
-0.9829314351081848,
0.4303940534591675,
-0.07384700328111649,
0.6282716393470764,
0.7530885934829712,
0.018565936014056206,
0.7640225291252136,
-0.07511769235134125,
0.6449017524719238,
0.5740126967430115,
-0.8921607136726379,
0.8033455610275269,
-0.19282491505146027,
0.03372955322265625,
0.6022705435752869,
0.294571191072464,
-0.19393466413021088,
-0.3934450149536133,
-0.9346784949302673,
-1.0497568845748901,
1.0340732336044312,
0.23887784779071808,
-0.5189448595046997,
-0.003931316547095776,
0.26963430643081665,
0.07762885093688965,
-0.10893617570400238,
-0.9614866375923157,
0.030977651476860046,
-0.11641186475753784,
-0.2075955867767334,
-0.2420254498720169,
-0.20736639201641083,
-0.17624767124652863,
-0.06773623079061508,
0.6071853637695312,
0.1477493941783905,
0.22566106915473938,
0.18141843378543854,
-0.275849848985672,
-0.4062943756580353,
0.4226369261741638,
0.28499922156333923,
0.6447411179542542,
-0.5088024735450745,
0.45603230595588684,
0.15767499804496765,
0.035924553871154785,
0.12271492183208466,
0.36371588706970215,
0.04411337897181511,
-0.3485240638256073,
0.7533484697341919,
0.9832183122634888,
0.48723000288009644,
-0.695065438747406,
0.7717446088790894,
-0.21733573079109192,
0.05597896873950958,
0.1788332164287567,
0.05093856900930405,
-0.27756497263908386,
0.36777767539024353,
0.2746185064315796,
-0.032772988080978394,
0.35932740569114685,
-0.2281275987625122,
0.45178234577178955,
0.2664684057235718,
-0.8572884798049927,
-0.3486446440219879,
0.8741926550865173,
0.05328100919723511,
0.06699883937835693,
0.7642425298690796,
-0.4152193069458008,
-0.3868517577648163,
0.6838497519493103,
0.46572428941726685,
0.8726949691772461,
0.14161483943462372,
0.15688003599643707,
0.4303790330886841,
0.33578044176101685,
-0.09080680459737778,
0.048089317977428436,
-0.21699413657188416,
-0.46913254261016846,
-0.7079697251319885,
-0.662385880947113,
-0.20264673233032227,
0.16669078171253204,
-1.0881540775299072,
0.394562691450119,
-0.08213742822408676,
0.012351809069514275,
0.09726962447166443,
-0.07011742889881134,
-0.8617109656333923,
0.12641672790050507,
0.055097728967666626,
0.3922126889228821,
-1.434584140777588,
0.5605195760726929,
0.4030105173587799,
-0.8776813745498657,
-0.807210385799408,
-0.4801252782344818,
-0.18376818299293518,
-0.40036553144454956,
1.0145176649093628,
-0.11267473548650742,
0.22835476696491241,
-0.4732600450515747,
-0.6028931140899658,
-0.3799407184123993,
0.8626262545585632,
0.20994743704795837,
-0.24533647298812866,
0.12923912703990936,
-0.3453991711139679,
0.42792484164237976,
-0.14049258828163147,
0.24868880212306976,
0.3536200523376465,
0.3560946583747864,
-0.07317053526639938,
-0.5554736256599426,
0.30807578563690186,
-0.13408531248569489,
-0.14483562111854553,
0.2249329835176468,
-0.144436314702034,
0.5819786787033081,
-0.11292599141597748,
-0.33956602215766907,
-0.03240314498543739,
0.6980258822441101,
0.30261459946632385,
0.45261576771736145,
0.5120576620101929,
0.5396701693534851,
0.5118092894554138,
-0.08386364579200745,
1.3061317205429077,
0.5116065740585327,
0.6476909518241882,
1.197192668914795,
-0.1512724608182907,
0.6220427751541138,
0.6789939999580383,
-0.207728311419487,
0.32760488986968994,
0.9592211842536926,
0.08135140687227249,
0.8057096600532532,
0.23834668099880219,
-0.0707852691411972,
-0.6878117918968201,
-0.1781187206506729,
-0.028163136914372444,
0.3561406433582306,
0.22297880053520203,
-0.39311617612838745,
-0.5529267191886902,
-0.07672411948442459,
-0.3118835687637329,
-0.2034255564212799,
-0.32781314849853516,
0.9068566560745239,
0.051249194890260696,
-0.5865083336830139,
0.29004478454589844,
0.2672913670539856,
0.4275546967983246,
-0.6692081689834595,
-0.2950969934463501,
0.0918896421790123,
0.08280852437019348,
-0.22295168042182922,
-0.3476325571537018,
0.17214460670948029,
-0.0392669141292572,
-0.10415904968976974,
-0.18270938098430634,
1.025598406791687,
-0.19993992149829865,
-0.2367582619190216,
0.511438250541687,
0.55476313829422,
0.07711422443389893,
0.1238185241818428,
-0.6369869112968445,
-0.0794091522693634,
-0.262359082698822,
-0.3791659474372864,
0.5003308653831482,
0.39609208703041077,
-0.38339748978614807,
0.23048171401023865,
0.6194256544113159,
0.18879152834415436,
-0.09839142858982086,
0.20511892437934875,
0.872303307056427,
-0.7719568014144897,
-0.5603703856468201,
-0.9368899464607239,
0.5694410800933838,
-0.2790907323360443,
-0.4379596412181854,
0.4151467978954315,
0.3636641502380371,
0.49601051211357117,
-0.014117139391601086,
0.6750363707542419,
-0.18700137734413147,
-0.012531924992799759,
-0.4955333471298218,
0.37369856238365173,
-0.6700339317321777,
-0.12405984103679657,
-0.527580201625824,
-0.4846401512622833,
-0.31363236904144287,
0.5559858679771423,
-0.552972137928009,
-0.15120528638362885,
0.37488216161727905,
0.4234302043914795,
-0.35939615964889526,
0.020901372656226158,
0.3018859624862671,
-0.03572835400700569,
0.4204804301261902,
0.8601812720298767,
1.243914246559143,
-0.393190860748291,
0.2539116442203522,
0.1029108539223671,
-0.3429337441921234,
-0.4453645646572113,
-0.8770901560783386,
-0.7123357057571411,
-0.5074987411499023,
-0.27433544397354126,
-0.41226086020469666,
0.32069918513298035,
0.7078841924667358,
0.8634902238845825,
-0.8188360333442688,
-0.11467673629522324,
-0.15816648304462433,
0.6131604313850403,
-0.6183417439460754,
-0.33376163244247437,
0.7957035899162292,
-0.6708561182022095,
-0.4028449058532715,
0.4544826149940491,
0.2723213732242584,
-0.26234737038612366,
-0.005154580809175968,
-0.21442878246307373,
-0.280917763710022,
-0.25638413429260254,
0.5046887397766113,
0.5182085633277893,
-0.514581024646759,
-0.47136396169662476,
-0.7214813232421875,
-0.24690818786621094,
-0.13357721269130707,
0.8621150255203247,
-0.6922574043273926,
0.3663210868835449,
0.33179008960723877,
0.8864585161209106,
0.9850549697875977,
0.0643080472946167,
0.5589081645011902,
-0.7349275350570679,
0.16988317668437958,
0.08568376302719116,
0.2989605963230133,
0.07439934462308884,
-0.5714190602302551,
0.6577314138412476,
0.34263667464256287,
-0.4091661274433136,
-0.9201885461807251,
0.15920278429985046,
-1.0945215225219727,
-0.30288106203079224,
1.0368071794509888,
-0.29190143942832947,
-0.26834017038345337,
-0.2596079707145691,
0.08845196664333344,
0.4661828577518463,
-0.1438208371400833,
0.9665917158126831,
0.41593602299690247,
-0.33130088448524475,
0.048616666346788406,
-0.35662174224853516,
0.4450727105140686,
0.5101264119148254,
-0.880695641040802,
-0.05056588724255562,
0.44727781414985657,
0.09791342169046402,
-0.10856420546770096,
0.4444679915904999,
-0.3012270927429199,
0.5388765931129456,
0.020801100879907608,
0.4777241349220276,
0.007341204676777124,
-0.3949097990989685,
-0.7460664510726929,
0.48575422167778015,
0.1796605885028839,
-0.22117017209529877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18239v1 | Zero-shot prompt-based classification: topic labeling in times of foundation models in German Tweets | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | 2024-06-26T10:44:02 | Simon Münker, Kai Kugler, Achim Rettinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Filtering and annotating textual data are routine tasks in many areas, like
social media or news analytics. Automating these tasks allows to scale the
analyses wrt. speed and breadth of content covered and decreases the manual
effort required. Due to technical advancements in Natural Language Processing,
specifically the success of large foundation models, a new tool for automating
such annotation processes by using a text-to-text interface given written
guidelines without providing training samples has become available.
In this work, we assess these advancements in-the-wild by empirically testing
them in an annotation task on German Twitter data about social and political
European crises. We compare the prompt-based results with our human annotation
and preceding classification approaches, including Naive Bayes and a BERT-based
fine-tuning/domain adaptation pipeline. Our results show that the prompt-based
approach - despite being limited by local computation resources during the
model selection - is comparable with the fine-tuned BERT but without any
annotated training data. Our findings emphasize the ongoing paradigm shift in
the NLP landscape, i.e., the unification of downstream tasks and elimination of
the need for pre-labeled training data. | [
-0.4976266026496887,
-0.9821822047233582,
0.4312114715576172,
0.38787052035331726,
-0.2873498499393463,
0.14234118163585663,
-0.16042537987232208,
-0.42579662799835205,
0.0843578353524208,
0.30309826135635376,
-0.7731717228889465,
-0.8460144996643066,
-0.6938974857330322,
0.2695949375629425,
-0.533939778804779,
1.102079153060913,
0.050373632460832596,
-0.2516189515590668,
0.06883201748132706,
0.02593737281858921,
-0.49808135628700256,
-0.4101337194442749,
-0.6948299407958984,
-0.28642216324806213,
0.5610808730125427,
0.37218472361564636,
0.4610758125782013,
0.5958430171012878,
0.34947437047958374,
0.22299136221408844,
-0.08548060059547424,
-0.2998965084552765,
-0.25113916397094727,
0.16186821460723877,
-0.18036715686321259,
-0.03907221183180809,
-0.10200891643762589,
0.23398391902446747,
0.2722458243370056,
0.9074164032936096,
0.33397066593170166,
0.25460726022720337,
-0.012201814912259579,
0.2925422489643097,
-0.7085986733436584,
0.18527887761592865,
-0.483376145362854,
0.13663756847381592,
0.0435345321893692,
-0.4800608456134796,
-0.3906234800815582,
-0.24547317624092102,
0.4430347979068756,
-0.39564260840415955,
0.626935601234436,
-0.23697036504745483,
0.9093247056007385,
0.3105551600456238,
-0.4346538484096527,
-0.21824312210083008,
-0.6870973706245422,
0.6027522087097168,
-0.3161018192768097,
0.13802985846996307,
0.21805088222026825,
0.2879546284675598,
-0.02974141202867031,
-0.5686188340187073,
-0.3310422897338867,
-0.04719379171729088,
-0.029903119429945946,
-0.17423495650291443,
-0.2978123426437378,
0.07276558876037598,
0.441102534532547,
0.00958323571830988,
-0.4122636318206787,
0.23895184695720673,
-0.19127584993839264,
-0.3235168159008026,
0.5579111576080322,
-0.17786188423633575,
0.15247656404972076,
-0.4806267023086548,
-0.2632594704627991,
-0.024578040465712547,
-0.44186851382255554,
0.06685294955968857,
-0.14069370925426483,
0.6357588171958923,
-0.1306237280368805,
0.42149868607521057,
-0.6366719007492065,
0.7269896268844604,
0.09190119802951813,
0.050822414457798004,
0.15838675200939178,
-0.12737224996089935,
-0.39728888869285583,
0.15043970942497253,
0.7363485097885132,
0.39042264223098755,
0.3454064726829529,
-0.32335302233695984,
-0.08531659841537476,
0.2300189584493637,
0.010396091267466545,
-0.852218747138977,
-0.10743088275194168,
0.10812834650278091,
-0.2668110132217407,
-0.4844837188720703,
-0.012699811719357967,
-0.5784246921539307,
-0.45933815836906433,
-0.3507576286792755,
0.4928334355354309,
-0.23581470549106598,
0.05933349207043648,
0.14517726004123688,
-0.2794893682003021,
0.18832609057426453,
0.7710000872612,
-0.4873943328857422,
-0.12316318601369858,
0.5970379114151001,
1.0225557088851929,
-0.08737487345933914,
0.07380847632884979,
-0.5915383100509644,
-0.24657368659973145,
-0.5065300464630127,
1.1340800523757935,
-0.46673154830932617,
-0.45579496026039124,
0.18548785150051117,
0.10333206504583359,
0.14005453884601593,
-0.00947660394012928,
0.5141689777374268,
-0.35608965158462524,
0.42998912930488586,
-0.4162226617336273,
-0.582055389881134,
-0.010936177335679531,
0.15308429300785065,
-0.39335376024246216,
0.9748221039772034,
0.05306196212768555,
-0.8316652178764343,
0.6910547614097595,
-0.9494414925575256,
-0.5017096996307373,
0.08774467557668686,
-0.11836035549640656,
0.057112451642751694,
-0.03589779511094093,
0.37125375866889954,
0.9747564196586609,
-0.29042869806289673,
0.6215563416481018,
-0.4075756072998047,
-0.35085538029670715,
0.01696842908859253,
-0.3132297098636627,
0.9358242750167847,
0.058138538151979446,
-0.5335572361946106,
0.15307366847991943,
-0.7594466209411621,
-0.3224617838859558,
-0.045214228332042694,
0.05278317257761955,
-0.20122312009334564,
-0.10935290157794952,
0.10014545917510986,
0.5064716935157776,
-0.03837518393993378,
-0.6289138793945312,
0.22093048691749573,
-0.15454769134521484,
0.46390438079833984,
0.5977463126182556,
0.4411395192146301,
0.6952241659164429,
-0.22050856053829193,
0.3229062557220459,
-0.2186710238456726,
-0.03451080247759819,
-0.5669779181480408,
-0.6647844314575195,
-0.6792929768562317,
-0.30950698256492615,
0.4490797519683838,
0.7676001191139221,
-0.8053116202354431,
0.6384719610214233,
-0.26097655296325684,
-0.633513867855072,
-0.32065296173095703,
-0.2867717146873474,
-0.0945335403084755,
0.8541688323020935,
0.4092308282852173,
-0.09383942186832428,
-0.3334687650203705,
-0.7962154746055603,
-0.033813972026109695,
-0.2412530928850174,
-0.1987655758857727,
0.185008242726326,
0.3980560004711151,
-0.10071312636137009,
1.2011834383010864,
-0.44296547770500183,
-0.07231248170137405,
-0.11479194462299347,
0.8544371128082275,
0.030439728870987892,
0.44456249475479126,
0.7074486613273621,
-0.6623721718788147,
-0.38875988125801086,
-0.2286478877067566,
-0.7442819476127625,
-0.6399913430213928,
-0.3140476942062378,
-0.0909169390797615,
0.41652125120162964,
0.5275372266769409,
-0.4335246980190277,
0.6852656602859497,
-0.05887368693947792,
-0.45089349150657654,
0.23567108809947968,
0.29121214151382446,
0.30529749393463135,
-0.8550738096237183,
0.21505440771579742,
0.33877888321876526,
-0.30564039945602417,
-0.9066501259803772,
-0.45542430877685547,
0.07518867403268814,
-0.24521911144256592,
-0.37495845556259155,
0.8999390602111816,
-0.1285267174243927,
0.11188845336437225,
-0.3315185308456421,
-0.060070402920246124,
-0.13366879522800446,
0.29714980721473694,
0.38376012444496155,
0.46092748641967773,
0.5939598083496094,
-0.5786141157150269,
0.1745409071445465,
0.2581908106803894,
-0.10765431076288223,
0.4569759666919708,
-0.4224027097225189,
0.05490988865494728,
-0.34346434473991394,
0.3443804085254669,
-1.1948341131210327,
-0.28113603591918945,
0.40389207005500793,
-0.6051713228225708,
0.1858617067337036,
-0.18984508514404297,
-0.5986915230751038,
-0.25322088599205017,
-0.35840538144111633,
-0.21167771518230438,
0.5579622387886047,
-0.2631950080394745,
0.2928662598133087,
-0.014151150360703468,
-0.32580697536468506,
-0.35168740153312683,
-0.5653932094573975,
0.31110459566116333,
-0.19722825288772583,
-0.3103938698768616,
0.30164608359336853,
0.14794093370437622,
-0.10203305631875992,
0.17329731583595276,
-0.18168160319328308,
-0.2722678482532501,
0.4879802167415619,
0.2241351455450058,
0.23750688135623932,
-0.11127495020627975,
0.407600075006485,
0.20044687390327454,
-0.290957510471344,
-0.03523389622569084,
-0.22890704870224,
0.3238714933395386,
0.1999322474002838,
-0.015693429857492447,
-0.7177108526229858,
0.40137529373168945,
0.2668001651763916,
-0.11418970674276352,
0.7434723377227783,
0.6413483619689941,
-0.4895426630973816,
-0.19652295112609863,
-0.5672630071640015,
-0.36127087473869324,
-0.3525245785713196,
0.04540787637233734,
-0.09286384284496307,
-1.1236660480499268,
0.3573223352432251,
-0.21009284257888794,
0.3273467421531677,
0.7803780436515808,
0.28878360986709595,
-0.22284622490406036,
0.5854659080505371,
0.8696684241294861,
-0.0649421215057373,
0.6521371006965637,
-0.1510467678308487,
0.1611565798521042,
-0.020963778719305992,
0.025942713022232056,
-0.8189837336540222,
-0.18252882361412048,
-0.5281333923339844,
-0.20278029143810272,
0.06325120478868484,
0.13890311121940613,
-0.3073916435241699,
0.29373353719711304,
-0.6120104789733887,
0.20364786684513092,
0.4754716753959656,
-0.14702068269252777,
0.13253594934940338,
0.10979688167572021,
0.4310573637485504,
-0.16361147165298462,
-0.664156436920166,
-0.6049047112464905,
0.9552040696144104,
0.25084537267684937,
0.26294514536857605,
-0.45534318685531616,
0.8193222284317017,
0.5935304164886475,
0.6686037182807922,
-0.7370044589042664,
0.5916568636894226,
-0.04550500214099884,
-0.6397727727890015,
-0.5103151798248291,
-0.17558914422988892,
-0.7108151912689209,
0.02754000946879387,
-0.46829086542129517,
-0.8390053510665894,
0.3917084336280823,
-0.014503988437354565,
-0.5494803786277771,
0.10311289131641388,
-0.7293643951416016,
0.9116296172142029,
0.08922974765300751,
-0.0443754717707634,
0.09348950535058975,
-0.6005363464355469,
0.01978839933872223,
-0.2993223965167999,
0.11276064813137054,
-0.4603334367275238,
-0.09366226196289062,
0.8584722876548767,
-0.02650865912437439,
1.102552056312561,
-0.46985554695129395,
0.06417009979486465,
0.22920449078083038,
-0.1514453887939453,
0.21592673659324646,
0.030049370601773262,
0.02140921726822853,
0.2022184133529663,
-0.06792467832565308,
-0.48654255270957947,
-0.5611577033996582,
0.3586684465408325,
-0.5389909148216248,
-0.6371291875839233,
-0.5057438015937805,
-0.2999664843082428,
-0.26400431990623474,
0.14431661367416382,
0.21992748975753784,
0.39250648021698,
-0.2291741967201233,
0.27490532398223877,
0.4539559781551361,
-0.320431649684906,
0.770986795425415,
0.6154599189758301,
-0.022298140451312065,
-0.060191962867975235,
0.5550183653831482,
0.424778014421463,
-0.17017337679862976,
0.5331965088844299,
0.06109257787466049,
-0.1665026992559433,
-0.4205363392829895,
-0.40923836827278137,
-0.0015894107054919004,
-0.6854588985443115,
-0.35343462228775024,
-0.9736821055412292,
-0.22063110768795013,
-0.5440635681152344,
-0.5270665287971497,
-0.05854412168264389,
-0.6485207676887512,
-0.5833553671836853,
-0.23229286074638367,
0.5810270309448242,
0.4723816215991974,
-0.1438799351453781,
0.5119945406913757,
-0.6563231348991394,
0.33116135001182556,
0.08520039916038513,
0.20672395825386047,
-0.2329077273607254,
-0.37759658694267273,
-0.07542286068201065,
-0.20453186333179474,
-0.1962345540523529,
-1.2009793519973755,
0.08662182837724686,
0.20066574215888977,
0.15675249695777893,
0.43260425329208374,
0.448165625333786,
0.43962812423706055,
-0.4970366954803467,
0.7572107911109924,
-0.050911128520965576,
-0.9943756461143494,
0.7877658009529114,
-0.5169910192489624,
0.33794549107551575,
0.5434985160827637,
0.5976434350013733,
-0.644184410572052,
-0.24966995418071747,
-0.6029490232467651,
-0.8788227438926697,
0.8251556158065796,
0.11741615831851959,
0.19495801627635956,
-0.17043118178844452,
0.4954683184623718,
0.30077502131462097,
0.4256693422794342,
-0.3963329792022705,
-0.2994760274887085,
-0.2268417626619339,
0.04639803245663643,
-0.24008595943450928,
-0.2205934375524521,
0.15601623058319092,
-0.258357971906662,
0.6138727068901062,
-0.11567015945911407,
0.2584138512611389,
0.38970381021499634,
-0.11307896673679352,
-0.07988867908716202,
0.36761710047721863,
0.20947444438934326,
0.5766754150390625,
-0.32019945979118347,
-0.2020113170146942,
0.026846429333090782,
0.04508526250720024,
0.2545246481895447,
0.5705384612083435,
-0.54001784324646,
0.4975513815879822,
0.6042061448097229,
0.9884180426597595,
0.35706204175949097,
-0.40793395042419434,
0.5244648456573486,
0.14029952883720398,
-0.30205535888671875,
-0.028794581070542336,
0.03379932790994644,
-0.24575617909431458,
0.1671144962310791,
0.7292075157165527,
-0.06938515603542328,
0.3413259983062744,
-0.387450248003006,
0.39087769389152527,
0.2146134078502655,
-0.2904638350009918,
-0.3571261465549469,
0.3680959641933441,
0.36421000957489014,
-0.2632400095462799,
0.1567716896533966,
-0.42197170853614807,
-0.2774485647678375,
0.43622204661369324,
0.14182189106941223,
1.180368185043335,
-0.1996910721063614,
0.8151512145996094,
0.3123195469379425,
0.28547802567481995,
-0.08588244765996933,
0.1527850478887558,
-0.36470556259155273,
-0.6237731575965881,
-0.7329031229019165,
-0.5254200100898743,
-0.38566136360168457,
0.18987217545509338,
-0.6973113417625427,
0.39004063606262207,
-0.5681160688400269,
-0.32370877265930176,
0.5849883556365967,
0.04596192389726639,
-0.7352584600448608,
0.3406146168708801,
0.16664771735668182,
1.1821943521499634,
-1.2226425409317017,
0.6249956488609314,
0.8547223210334778,
-0.05950183793902397,
-0.17488230764865875,
0.11795197427272797,
0.11881465464830399,
-0.36292728781700134,
0.6102100014686584,
0.5421886444091797,
0.41071435809135437,
0.13103923201560974,
-0.7314205765724182,
-0.6052525639533997,
0.8213330507278442,
0.3200598955154419,
-0.2984628677368164,
-0.11347591131925583,
0.01847159117460251,
0.6414049863815308,
-0.4081004858016968,
0.026754572987556458,
0.5009527206420898,
0.3530849516391754,
0.1580154001712799,
-0.8547990918159485,
-0.086598239839077,
-0.14147546887397766,
-0.09210903197526932,
0.2915908396244049,
-0.10596088320016861,
0.5430072546005249,
0.056557487696409225,
-0.506250262260437,
-0.22179096937179565,
0.5611969232559204,
-0.16242347657680511,
0.5804731249809265,
0.5128027200698853,
0.24548734724521637,
0.5718902945518494,
-0.3882814645767212,
0.9600719809532166,
-0.23231162130832672,
0.3621657192707062,
0.8505942225456238,
-0.3098246455192566,
0.7107697129249573,
0.2427799105644226,
0.043228186666965485,
0.23835432529449463,
0.9229279160499573,
-0.1068924069404602,
0.5119972229003906,
-0.12584058940410614,
-0.12289895117282867,
-0.33308765292167664,
-0.5009871125221252,
-0.2009533792734146,
0.18785756826400757,
0.2988680899143219,
-0.13026933372020721,
-0.7500600218772888,
0.2369076907634735,
0.09313268959522247,
-0.12779566645622253,
-0.30120858550071716,
0.9680271148681641,
-0.04790431261062622,
-0.39735063910484314,
0.3160399794578552,
0.08546966314315796,
0.7470667958259583,
-0.38951772451400757,
0.1085798591375351,
-0.15091098845005035,
-0.41529926657676697,
-0.0028668404556810856,
-0.7272880673408508,
0.4047001004219055,
0.3918377459049225,
-0.14819808304309845,
-0.48297014832496643,
0.9307754635810852,
-0.10015317797660828,
-0.43831509351730347,
0.25919872522354126,
0.7523407936096191,
-0.0019998406060039997,
-0.4203746020793915,
-0.6268081068992615,
-0.1932324469089508,
-0.04023253172636032,
-0.4586716294288635,
0.08519706130027771,
0.6900956630706787,
-0.32613569498062134,
0.5423516035079956,
0.6493397951126099,
-0.2010972499847412,
-0.18818460404872894,
-0.11878586560487747,
0.8022881746292114,
-0.8668349385261536,
-0.5921010971069336,
-0.8574646711349487,
0.5107458829879761,
-0.16913780570030212,
-0.21280182898044586,
0.5542733669281006,
0.1753378063440323,
0.6881321668624878,
0.04832755774259567,
0.995826244354248,
-0.21179701387882233,
0.6845082640647888,
-0.18801727890968323,
0.5449100136756897,
-0.40980467200279236,
-0.09502029418945312,
-0.30035531520843506,
-0.7924734950065613,
-0.5685279369354248,
0.4688167870044708,
-0.5950411558151245,
-0.16112762689590454,
0.4551490843296051,
0.33550938963890076,
0.12013081461191177,
0.10019923746585846,
0.15579253435134888,
0.11027466505765915,
0.1930583268404007,
0.06121242418885231,
0.5498471856117249,
-0.08284494280815125,
0.1662515550851822,
-0.556646466255188,
-0.32406267523765564,
-0.29073596000671387,
-1.0498688220977783,
-1.2043706178665161,
-0.687238872051239,
-0.6213516592979431,
-0.18515270948410034,
0.21411952376365662,
1.127046823501587,
0.6069249510765076,
-0.9948058128356934,
0.1964203268289566,
-0.045187752693891525,
-0.0448426678776741,
0.19100354611873627,
-0.2518111765384674,
0.47008585929870605,
-0.6125988364219666,
-0.4906814396381378,
0.03150572627782822,
0.39654842019081116,
0.2819690406322479,
-0.01863551139831543,
0.3975389897823334,
-0.1330578327178955,
-0.020108435302972794,
0.6729490756988525,
0.3243064284324646,
-0.657248318195343,
-0.2183670550584793,
0.12322763353586197,
-0.016164010390639305,
-0.022044863551855087,
0.6193646192550659,
-0.9993889331817627,
0.3096078634262085,
0.45188406109809875,
0.9219338893890381,
0.15402813255786896,
0.02043284848332405,
0.41111209988594055,
-0.7385337352752686,
0.36846765875816345,
0.17363908886909485,
0.12186022847890854,
0.4961181581020355,
-0.30018869042396545,
0.5374124050140381,
0.3696374297142029,
-0.22641490399837494,
-0.9138995409011841,
-0.07953811436891556,
-0.7300685048103333,
-0.4399149417877197,
1.101580262184143,
-0.08081991970539093,
-0.05981128662824631,
-0.20037470757961273,
-0.21439778804779053,
0.4014911949634552,
-0.8197336792945862,
0.9230731725692749,
0.9053570032119751,
0.06712070107460022,
-0.2163206785917282,
-0.7797569632530212,
0.6074388027191162,
0.09854385256767273,
-0.8154674768447876,
-0.08929196745157242,
0.5497227907180786,
0.06414878368377686,
0.18836826086044312,
0.7378844022750854,
0.3687725067138672,
0.2943527400493622,
-0.4623197913169861,
0.059631701558828354,
0.07192876935005188,
-0.3849865198135376,
-0.6215056777000427,
0.30439165234565735,
-0.3442753553390503,
-0.1666972041130066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18227v1 | GUIDE: A Guideline-Guided Dataset for Instructional Video Comprehension | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | 2024-06-26T10:24:00 | Jiafeng Liang, Shixin Jiang, Zekun Wang, Haojie Pan, Zerui Chen, Zheng Chu, Ming Liu, Ruiji Fu, Zhongyuan Wang, Bing Qin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | There are substantial instructional videos on the Internet, which provide us
tutorials for completing various tasks. Existing instructional video datasets
only focus on specific steps at the video level, lacking experiential
guidelines at the task level, which can lead to beginners struggling to learn
new tasks due to the lack of relevant experience. Moreover, the specific steps
without guidelines are trivial and unsystematic, making it difficult to provide
a clear tutorial. To address these problems, we present the GUIDE
(Guideline-Guided) dataset, which contains 3.5K videos of 560 instructional
tasks in 8 domains related to our daily life. Specifically, we annotate each
instructional task with a guideline, representing a common pattern shared by
all task-related videos. On this basis, we annotate systematic specific steps,
including their associated guideline steps, specific step descriptions and
timestamps. Our proposed benchmark consists of three sub-tasks to evaluate
comprehension ability of models: (1) Step Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps from videos. (2) Guideline Summarization: models
have to mine the common pattern in task-related videos and summarize a
guideline from them. (3) Guideline-Guided Captioning: models have to generate
captions for specific steps under the guide of guideline. We evaluate plenty of
foundation models with GUIDE and perform in-depth analysis. Given the diversity
and practicality of GUIDE, we believe that it can be used as a better benchmark
for instructional video comprehension. | [
-0.4020126461982727,
-0.8163976073265076,
0.26035431027412415,
0.25237876176834106,
-0.5486958026885986,
-0.3311726450920105,
0.06480418145656586,
0.3620300590991974,
-0.22844772040843964,
0.7277927398681641,
-1.0293068885803223,
-0.6574375629425049,
-0.4008355438709259,
0.05626622214913368,
-0.5781189799308777,
1.1772942543029785,
-0.3136526644229889,
0.2360188215970993,
-0.3866937458515167,
0.040034424513578415,
-0.7509828209877014,
0.15002690255641937,
-0.47628137469291687,
-0.21952159702777863,
0.28335562348365784,
0.712955117225647,
0.12694531679153442,
0.8773790597915649,
0.6125193238258362,
0.16196408867835999,
0.0833868458867073,
0.25411683320999146,
-0.3207838833332062,
0.09443694353103638,
0.12250782549381256,
-0.14539800584316254,
-0.3276597559452057,
-0.06522592157125473,
0.40066322684288025,
0.9804627895355225,
-0.2155923694372177,
0.6007573008537292,
0.31686630845069885,
0.8332431316375732,
-0.5599889159202576,
0.33627399802207947,
-0.15657106041908264,
0.2104928195476532,
0.21276617050170898,
-0.36802250146865845,
-0.2255685180425644,
-0.2853386104106903,
0.38479083776474,
-1.065876841545105,
0.6218019723892212,
-0.07985547184944153,
0.4308900535106659,
0.8509306907653809,
-0.3799283802509308,
-0.05502890422940254,
-0.40841367840766907,
0.41865167021751404,
-0.4320259392261505,
0.4730144739151001,
0.6733790636062622,
0.6233069896697998,
0.25759872794151306,
-0.6696361899375916,
-0.2509274482727051,
0.046194907277822495,
0.09850400686264038,
0.037668272852897644,
-0.12627768516540527,
0.215791717171669,
0.6421698927879333,
0.1258445531129837,
-0.7649784684181213,
-0.38374361395835876,
-0.5234756469726562,
-0.02200234867632389,
0.38623011112213135,
0.2497810572385788,
0.15873560309410095,
-0.417879581451416,
-0.3008020520210266,
-0.2914538085460663,
-0.365014910697937,
0.44229498505592346,
0.24616996943950653,
-0.05002230778336525,
0.008213751949369907,
0.46705979108810425,
-0.5787361860275269,
0.989158034324646,
0.1465781331062317,
-0.437558114528656,
0.1858379989862442,
-0.5589844584465027,
-0.5990413427352905,
-0.00994385126978159,
0.27386608719825745,
0.8403328657150269,
0.687560498714447,
-0.07478031516075134,
0.11899080127477646,
-0.2246900498867035,
0.3544856905937195,
-0.7744752168655396,
-0.5729380249977112,
-0.0284463781863451,
-0.4256740212440491,
0.09279827028512955,
0.05318261310458183,
-0.6716779470443726,
-0.4939694404602051,
-0.7077863812446594,
0.534976601600647,
-0.32613566517829895,
0.09101801365613937,
-0.04241194203495979,
-0.25870490074157715,
0.2165859490633011,
0.3518851697444916,
-0.7996640205383301,
0.6471408605575562,
0.6204065084457397,
0.8616839647293091,
-0.018548017367720604,
-0.3162252902984619,
-0.627843976020813,
0.14818178117275238,
-0.12498388439416885,
0.8214095830917358,
-0.3688930571079254,
-0.09088938683271408,
0.09690729528665543,
0.28702521324157715,
-0.11470964550971985,
-0.2619965672492981,
0.4705701172351837,
-0.3082236349582672,
-0.18034231662750244,
-0.4725232422351837,
-0.7076080441474915,
-0.7849599719047546,
0.4400673806667328,
-0.8154358267784119,
0.5346740484237671,
-0.08306314796209335,
-0.5325477123260498,
0.48128780722618103,
-0.6625943183898926,
-0.40320393443107605,
-0.2111772894859314,
-0.1041010171175003,
0.023538462817668915,
-0.3940480649471283,
0.6911097168922424,
0.5964415669441223,
-0.3391439914703369,
0.26853489875793457,
0.06596110761165619,
-0.508825421333313,
-0.31303736567497253,
-0.5287292003631592,
0.577055811882019,
-0.030293239280581474,
-0.38815274834632874,
0.05476059392094612,
-0.6449316143989563,
0.05034828931093216,
-0.45221415162086487,
0.03255215659737587,
-0.1711481511592865,
0.0105436397716403,
-0.14821761846542358,
-0.01707199588418007,
-0.09699524194002151,
-0.10990113019943237,
-0.02626345120370388,
0.1724640130996704,
0.3869068920612335,
0.7463681101799011,
0.5780506730079651,
0.28059402108192444,
-0.2959325611591339,
0.7921890616416931,
-0.017637277022004128,
0.44248631596565247,
-0.6513605713844299,
-0.28745564818382263,
-0.8301835060119629,
0.006884708069264889,
-0.033188045024871826,
0.41064178943634033,
-0.6486408710479736,
0.002515444066375494,
-0.24687877297401428,
-0.4398402273654938,
-0.3802281618118286,
0.573878824710846,
0.5178548097610474,
0.8487894535064697,
0.6210712790489197,
-0.1748509705066681,
-0.6050857901573181,
-0.812120795249939,
0.097384974360466,
0.13295763731002808,
-0.07591944932937622,
0.3240317404270172,
0.4889467656612396,
0.1887621432542801,
0.6496985554695129,
-0.6278066039085388,
-0.5533677935600281,
0.08637606352567673,
0.07088467478752136,
0.2852652072906494,
0.26758381724357605,
0.10697969049215317,
-0.9894876480102539,
-0.7005932331085205,
-0.2654862403869629,
-0.8460379838943481,
0.1712370216846466,
-0.06865180283784866,
-0.06431880593299866,
-0.33732500672340393,
0.6039530634880066,
-0.16420920193195343,
0.4208613336086273,
0.34281599521636963,
-0.21002891659736633,
0.17687837779521942,
-0.17804501950740814,
0.4425867199897766,
-0.6714353561401367,
0.00003713172554853372,
0.2722087800502777,
0.14037556946277618,
-0.5098314881324768,
-0.2668628990650177,
0.008616647683084011,
-0.06273939460515976,
-0.3958066701889038,
0.2776763141155243,
-0.22681750357151031,
-0.07496166229248047,
0.048744283616542816,
0.07479572296142578,
0.058517299592494965,
0.8651189208030701,
0.19230720400810242,
0.7552719712257385,
0.6630316972732544,
-0.695402979850769,
0.6372537612915039,
0.4732614755630493,
-0.41621285676956177,
0.8214526772499084,
-0.8030239939689636,
-0.17879702150821686,
-0.3604700267314911,
0.2469124048948288,
-0.9826046228408813,
-0.4317834973335266,
0.2683064341545105,
-0.20010346174240112,
0.023682579398155212,
-0.540740966796875,
-0.14511878788471222,
0.04369887709617615,
-0.2656671702861786,
0.3982299268245697,
0.5095949172973633,
-0.32812371850013733,
0.41668301820755005,
0.08162380009889603,
-0.08765539526939392,
-0.8591678738594055,
-0.27317938208580017,
-0.37740370631217957,
-0.39239150285720825,
-0.6181350350379944,
0.23079656064510345,
-0.4579561650753021,
-0.08647643029689789,
0.18319624662399292,
-0.5234294533729553,
-0.4967819154262543,
-0.08192986994981766,
0.7257583141326904,
-0.026924580335617065,
-0.13873112201690674,
-0.15484850108623505,
-0.07110073417425156,
0.06874275207519531,
0.20866040885448456,
-0.2336980253458023,
0.03460051864385605,
0.24752260744571686,
-0.39820384979248047,
-0.28740665316581726,
0.4291389286518097,
0.36172807216644287,
-0.1705373078584671,
0.01803894154727459,
0.5284173488616943,
-0.3730318248271942,
-0.24823710322380066,
-0.6100876927375793,
-0.2121138870716095,
-0.38076749444007874,
0.3089483082294464,
-0.14473608136177063,
-0.36387938261032104,
0.24046209454536438,
0.4022897779941559,
0.2503725290298462,
0.04318864271044731,
-0.1294168382883072,
-0.39455389976501465,
1.0077584981918335,
0.525315523147583,
0.2366091012954712,
0.5292401313781738,
-0.6026479005813599,
-0.31348416209220886,
-0.8398497104644775,
-0.6079620718955994,
-0.2925119400024414,
-0.20095476508140564,
-0.11711239814758301,
-0.36825042963027954,
0.4090464413166046,
0.16318374872207642,
-0.4497140347957611,
0.4365367293357849,
-0.40322014689445496,
0.582879364490509,
0.7786837816238403,
0.2993226945400238,
0.2505575716495514,
0.36021021008491516,
0.05828838050365448,
-0.14268845319747925,
-0.6312487721443176,
-0.504755437374115,
1.208711862564087,
0.0729558989405632,
0.7882626056671143,
-0.02914426103234291,
0.3488112986087799,
0.7323692440986633,
-0.0610322505235672,
-0.6173039078712463,
0.6857171654701233,
-0.24466148018836975,
-0.46184849739074707,
-0.39445760846138,
-0.14472760260105133,
-0.7720256447792053,
-0.08716382831335068,
0.16082410514354706,
-0.4370217025279999,
-0.2537013292312622,
0.31969916820526123,
-0.4890093505382538,
-0.09198641031980515,
-0.6705576777458191,
1.242039442062378,
-0.11752878129482269,
-0.39278459548950195,
-0.04229312762618065,
-0.568682074546814,
0.3164827227592468,
0.04143797978758812,
0.2239164113998413,
0.0932438001036644,
0.14360658824443817,
1.0674611330032349,
-0.4838831424713135,
0.7514044642448425,
-0.4228668808937073,
0.3785758316516876,
0.5324955582618713,
-0.1702992171049118,
0.21166987717151642,
-0.09283636510372162,
0.38112860918045044,
-0.4271722137928009,
0.17503775656223297,
-0.3616008162498474,
-0.7791106700897217,
0.4245401620864868,
-0.563023567199707,
-0.5719035267829895,
-0.07888373732566833,
-0.23582689464092255,
-0.2235148698091507,
0.07086804509162903,
0.1321529895067215,
0.5863009095191956,
0.006335382349789143,
0.30354639887809753,
1.1177752017974854,
0.26341351866722107,
0.43066152930259705,
0.7620583772659302,
0.4408895969390869,
-0.6320353746414185,
0.9813185930252075,
0.12197509407997131,
-0.08369176834821701,
0.3358372151851654,
-0.22369474172592163,
-0.3234711289405823,
-0.7007016539573669,
-0.5038356184959412,
-0.010579693131148815,
-1.0314348936080933,
-0.1318988800048828,
-0.3042681813240051,
-0.05278608575463295,
-0.23890362679958344,
0.13630223274230957,
0.28589895367622375,
-0.06621970981359482,
-0.3209380507469177,
-0.3223823308944702,
0.42302587628364563,
0.7338079810142517,
0.17436520755290985,
0.2927609086036682,
-0.6586900353431702,
0.5290907025337219,
0.8337552547454834,
0.3357132077217102,
-0.10505512356758118,
-0.764242947101593,
-0.3332267105579376,
0.05205949395895004,
-0.39940690994262695,
-0.9697489142417908,
-0.01803930476307869,
0.3338077664375305,
0.829472541809082,
0.6113879680633545,
0.16483712196350098,
1.0375967025756836,
-0.7254816293716431,
0.7692161798477173,
-0.0032387094106525183,
-0.6555087566375732,
0.5654647350311279,
-0.3494441509246826,
0.04792077839374542,
0.5927206873893738,
0.6273638606071472,
-0.4740082919597626,
0.13082489371299744,
-0.5451905727386475,
-0.6199713349342346,
0.5501376986503601,
0.13026079535484314,
-0.05702134966850281,
0.31595274806022644,
0.3242560625076294,
0.22286459803581238,
0.32152584195137024,
-0.3750506341457367,
-0.33255288004875183,
-0.6045681834220886,
-0.2981179654598236,
-0.2318904548883438,
0.16844569146633148,
-0.26060330867767334,
-0.17080111801624298,
0.5590471029281616,
-0.3285065293312073,
-0.15503038465976715,
0.21216030418872833,
-0.41074731945991516,
-0.1689840853214264,
-0.08267263323068619,
0.5622786283493042,
0.7696969509124756,
-0.4398888349533081,
-0.004440817516297102,
0.0177376177161932,
-0.6018009781837463,
0.17574504017829895,
0.26025429368019104,
-0.40342339873313904,
-0.07927612960338593,
0.5938780903816223,
0.7612241506576538,
0.44403398036956787,
-0.8252272009849548,
0.4656597375869751,
0.06478696316480637,
-0.3365662395954132,
-0.4125553071498871,
0.4662799537181854,
-0.2808232009410858,
0.35527175664901733,
0.46706900000572205,
-0.010294109582901001,
0.4116280674934387,
-0.200129896402359,
0.39967331290245056,
0.18099737167358398,
-0.483448326587677,
-0.2794421911239624,
0.572403073310852,
0.44048723578453064,
-0.3376834988594055,
0.4594126343727112,
0.07504577934741974,
-0.19872157275676727,
0.6865321397781372,
-0.17096908390522003,
0.6877951622009277,
0.23007550835609436,
0.5075381994247437,
0.711002767086029,
0.24043598771095276,
-0.3991193473339081,
0.12825165688991547,
-0.6238545179367065,
-0.051563382148742676,
-0.47797298431396484,
-0.2191362828016281,
-0.39477574825286865,
0.2721013128757477,
-1.0222865343093872,
0.191764235496521,
-0.34070223569869995,
0.17569373548030853,
0.13743136823177338,
0.1962282508611679,
-0.8524471521377563,
0.5565325021743774,
-0.07120782881975174,
1.1094231605529785,
-1.0262478590011597,
0.5543784499168396,
0.8021250367164612,
-0.8802348375320435,
-0.8721189498901367,
-0.14106133580207825,
-0.06685710698366165,
-0.5197464823722839,
0.48922449350357056,
0.17522744834423065,
0.2560960054397583,
-0.040219999849796295,
-0.47333481907844543,
-0.6332886219024658,
1.3833807706832886,
0.11129151284694672,
-0.37905755639076233,
-0.4141198694705963,
-0.02376699075102806,
0.40369632840156555,
-0.3818037807941437,
0.29897651076316833,
0.5844755172729492,
0.42924755811691284,
0.1976127326488495,
-0.5632154941558838,
-0.061661455780267715,
-0.3289960026741028,
-0.4176120162010193,
-0.11202917248010635,
-0.2912350594997406,
0.6586629748344421,
-0.2607112228870392,
0.16759346425533295,
-0.0017844248795881867,
0.20939654111862183,
0.04794716835021973,
0.6910868287086487,
0.6860861778259277,
0.2518923878669739,
0.322462260723114,
0.02349955029785633,
0.6437325477600098,
-0.07495291531085968,
-0.0014187803026288748,
1.2067219018936157,
0.3900243639945984,
0.7368767261505127,
0.5729343295097351,
-0.1757214516401291,
0.4766831398010254,
0.7968460321426392,
-0.2441394329071045,
0.6733181476593018,
0.07254014909267426,
0.09477946162223816,
-0.5897363424301147,
-0.2223556637763977,
-0.22663146257400513,
0.11994025856256485,
0.08040682971477509,
-0.37970617413520813,
-0.21182294189929962,
0.026103878393769264,
-0.33898404240608215,
0.13487817347049713,
-0.5475981831550598,
0.8013721704483032,
-0.21955321729183197,
-1.230196475982666,
0.45814231038093567,
-0.5454273819923401,
0.04947888106107712,
-0.7443823218345642,
-0.4345329999923706,
-0.47337606549263,
0.00004541838279692456,
-0.3435063660144806,
-0.7962472438812256,
-0.2563439905643463,
0.4475454092025757,
-0.37605977058410645,
-0.1732480227947235,
0.0644451379776001,
-0.5055505037307739,
-0.2919193208217621,
-0.10380914062261581,
0.25265389680862427,
0.3121298551559448,
-0.12132063508033752,
-0.5285194516181946,
-0.19952110946178436,
0.18482647836208344,
-0.2979024350643158,
0.011915337294340134,
0.376569539308548,
-0.12478192895650864,
0.8224632143974304,
0.3609687387943268,
-0.3017132878303528,
0.10825730860233307,
0.09697636216878891,
0.6912751197814941,
-0.5355647802352905,
-0.2725866138935089,
-0.48633620142936707,
0.7425844669342041,
-0.14894239604473114,
-0.33042722940444946,
0.8617187142372131,
0.29381081461906433,
1.0217546224594116,
-0.15347282588481903,
0.6671207547187805,
0.07012489438056946,
0.23624901473522186,
-0.6986231803894043,
0.25173380970954895,
-0.6550838351249695,
0.2196372151374817,
-0.5050048828125,
-0.9483045339584351,
-0.005292900837957859,
0.5934525728225708,
0.03299904614686966,
0.042894456535577774,
0.7676366567611694,
0.6092147827148438,
-0.1730402112007141,
0.20135587453842163,
0.11748877167701721,
-0.2617180049419403,
0.005746903829276562,
0.5804612040519714,
0.675357460975647,
-0.5510455369949341,
1.2297366857528687,
-0.6763962507247925,
-0.12867693603038788,
-0.21370694041252136,
-1.0307425260543823,
-1.1486042737960815,
-0.6903223991394043,
-0.6152698993682861,
0.03717424347996712,
0.3503861427307129,
0.773198664188385,
1.1552485227584839,
-0.6207513809204102,
-0.22799238562583923,
-0.32869952917099,
0.11429402232170105,
-0.7757284045219421,
-0.1321021169424057,
0.42976176738739014,
-0.018252043053507805,
-0.5711215138435364,
0.2561708390712738,
-0.24374867975711823,
0.07438915222883224,
-0.42318376898765564,
-0.2816025912761688,
0.050652991980314255,
-0.2010698914527893,
0.14562825858592987,
0.33289968967437744,
-0.7241783738136292,
-0.1318107694387436,
0.46104705333709717,
0.3069009482860565,
-0.24636709690093994,
1.0588430166244507,
-0.69492107629776,
0.7307053804397583,
0.5327982306480408,
0.3342890441417694,
0.6587578058242798,
0.2365114539861679,
0.3447021245956421,
-0.7854605913162231,
-0.2884458303451538,
-0.009733823128044605,
0.3267991542816162,
0.4685358703136444,
0.07480920106172562,
0.830684244632721,
0.012438368983566761,
-0.40119022130966187,
-0.8359572887420654,
0.06252562254667282,
-1.0769612789154053,
-0.004149360116571188,
1.1156033277511597,
-0.48424917459487915,
-0.05962059646844864,
-0.14367178082466125,
-0.38172581791877747,
0.26505929231643677,
-0.3826732635498047,
0.553864598274231,
0.6883727312088013,
-0.15762394666671753,
-0.37171435356140137,
-0.7978681325912476,
0.6657375693321228,
0.3173450827598572,
-0.6068790555000305,
0.2115762084722519,
0.532627522945404,
0.5161536931991577,
-0.0630633756518364,
0.29158881306648254,
0.5897406339645386,
0.6861826777458191,
0.03408292680978775,
-0.5493420362472534,
-0.5987911224365234,
-0.6188240051269531,
-0.23780830204486847,
0.23345232009887695,
-0.20033058524131775,
-0.48042210936546326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18221v1 | Enhancing Data Privacy in Large Language Models through Private Association Editing | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | 2024-06-26T10:08:47 | Davide Venditti, Elena Sofia Ruzzetti, Giancarlo A. Xompero, Cristina Giannone, Andrea Favalli, Raniero Romagnoli, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful tools with extensive applications,
but their tendency to memorize private information raises significant concerns
as private data leakage can easily happen. In this paper, we introduce Private
Association Editing (PAE), a novel defense approach for private data leakage.
PAE is designed to effectively remove Personally Identifiable Information (PII)
without retraining the model. Our approach consists of a four-step procedure:
detecting memorized PII, applying PAE cards to mitigate memorization of private
data, verifying resilience to targeted data extraction (TDE) attacks, and
ensuring consistency in the post-edit LLMs. The versatility and efficiency of
PAE, which allows for batch modifications, significantly enhance data privacy
in LLMs. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of PAE in
mitigating private data leakage. We believe PAE will serve as a critical tool
in the ongoing effort to protect data privacy in LLMs, encouraging the
development of safer models for real-world applications. | [
-0.08348794281482697,
-0.7902554869651794,
0.5083408355712891,
0.09008543193340302,
-0.09599504619836807,
0.1590036153793335,
-0.2744075357913971,
-0.31659838557243347,
-0.07095909118652344,
0.7354215979576111,
-0.15136632323265076,
-0.906237006187439,
-0.7321458458900452,
0.001603101845830679,
-0.29040393233299255,
0.8179178237915039,
0.06363334506750107,
-0.2739655077457428,
0.18146005272865295,
-0.1005168929696083,
-0.5203487873077393,
-0.8496004939079285,
-0.8810591697692871,
0.2837553918361664,
0.47508376836776733,
0.2576694190502167,
0.5939727425575256,
0.9555538892745972,
0.5891215205192566,
0.4419732391834259,
-0.29434332251548767,
0.2719934284687042,
-0.5350513458251953,
0.11475855112075806,
-0.4333082437515259,
-0.6221335530281067,
-1.1358191967010498,
-0.21756818890571594,
0.8113816380500793,
0.4284999370574951,
-0.04307831823825836,
0.028669610619544983,
-0.14894235134124756,
0.766917884349823,
-0.9365195035934448,
0.22425468266010284,
-0.7654171586036682,
-0.018324194476008415,
-0.6149402856826782,
0.05096746236085892,
-0.6806154847145081,
-0.13747794926166534,
-0.048408590257167816,
-0.3302271366119385,
0.01839914545416832,
-0.09924149513244629,
0.44910261034965515,
0.017059393227100372,
-0.08963310718536377,
0.16247908771038055,
-0.8704610466957092,
0.42076024413108826,
-0.7854421138763428,
0.4141068756580353,
0.5940420031547546,
0.01740250363945961,
-0.3726920187473297,
-0.47448939085006714,
-0.5018466711044312,
-0.02606799080967903,
0.06129719316959381,
-0.14264433085918427,
-0.27908310294151306,
0.13036057353019714,
0.14569196105003357,
0.6283025741577148,
-0.23657922446727753,
0.2974141836166382,
-0.342069149017334,
-0.14618493616580963,
1.0094740390777588,
0.08413156867027283,
0.25493699312210083,
0.2924233376979828,
-0.079264797270298,
0.0712750256061554,
-0.7565863132476807,
-0.12337340414524078,
0.6051015853881836,
0.07476189732551575,
0.005906276870518923,
0.6699509620666504,
-0.08121372014284134,
0.1658027619123459,
0.23408158123493195,
-0.16314435005187988,
0.008960627019405365,
0.11687054485082626,
-0.5619518756866455,
-0.09485430270433426,
0.9276837706565857,
0.19590577483177185,
0.3550921678543091,
-0.5423499345779419,
-0.1254333257675171,
-0.23112288117408752,
0.045418497174978256,
-0.5548188090324402,
-0.424943745136261,
0.4399498999118805,
-0.5493694543838501,
-0.5334811210632324,
0.09679821133613586,
-1.090264081954956,
-0.8312934637069702,
0.038397278636693954,
0.22382958233356476,
-0.4245985150337219,
-0.13827607035636902,
0.30710646510124207,
0.15651458501815796,
-0.33491092920303345,
0.1724328100681305,
-0.7892529368400574,
0.5990315079689026,
1.0112231969833374,
0.6669179797172546,
-0.2541426122188568,
-0.3253622055053711,
-0.8668670058250427,
0.7831901907920837,
-0.33078864216804504,
0.37143486738204956,
-0.7134093642234802,
-0.830528736114502,
-0.14563314616680145,
0.1572413295507431,
0.13293974101543427,
-0.5807589888572693,
0.23884950578212738,
-0.662021279335022,
0.13976801931858063,
0.0038512665778398514,
-0.812091588973999,
0.0007386207580566406,
-0.0014653141843155026,
-0.6595383286476135,
0.44917258620262146,
-0.37336111068725586,
-0.5481436848640442,
-0.020450551062822342,
-0.8835656046867371,
-0.26126793026924133,
-0.004427080042660236,
-0.0029688975773751736,
-0.8361748456954956,
0.24030952155590057,
0.28696760535240173,
0.5201392769813538,
0.32340577244758606,
0.1634034365415573,
-0.3799820840358734,
-0.05627744644880295,
0.39216211438179016,
-0.5056610703468323,
0.5704748034477234,
0.13000719249248505,
-0.22579190135002136,
0.2881190776824951,
-0.924896240234375,
-0.39112159609794617,
0.1793522983789444,
-0.25521788001060486,
-0.4581713080406189,
-0.15610170364379883,
-0.5223800539970398,
-0.21220463514328003,
0.5343295335769653,
-0.5670333504676819,
0.4313156306743622,
-0.5092257857322693,
0.011503258720040321,
1.2308118343353271,
0.4264889359474182,
0.6971734762191772,
-0.2536007761955261,
0.3965171277523041,
-0.0052396683022379875,
0.43944239616394043,
-0.10332049429416656,
-0.4632870554924011,
-0.34346070885658264,
-0.6430419087409973,
0.4424343407154083,
0.6346274614334106,
0.0801306813955307,
0.622272253036499,
-0.197793647646904,
-0.5012008547782898,
-0.36267244815826416,
0.2784073054790497,
0.47329825162887573,
0.006741592660546303,
0.1786816269159317,
-0.4945441782474518,
-0.3078411817550659,
-0.8200994729995728,
-0.5971038937568665,
0.14449022710323334,
0.07594991475343704,
0.3534753620624542,
0.2102363109588623,
-0.16012360155582428,
0.5798920392990112,
-0.46910905838012695,
-0.46376484632492065,
0.01488510798662901,
-0.08657455444335938,
-0.13610103726387024,
0.7187315821647644,
0.17192918062210083,
-0.5661815404891968,
-0.5946112275123596,
-0.047761812806129456,
-0.6282069087028503,
-0.08548471331596375,
-0.05332005023956299,
-0.22929935157299042,
0.17513896524906158,
0.32548749446868896,
-0.6362689733505249,
0.6555386185646057,
0.45389652252197266,
-0.5152972340583801,
0.2607559561729431,
-0.44653940200805664,
-0.04806055873632431,
-0.8197545409202576,
0.0050864508375525475,
-0.16073095798492432,
-0.3418152928352356,
-0.7393315434455872,
0.2216930389404297,
0.14402545988559723,
-0.479976624250412,
-0.45286044478416443,
0.5882202982902527,
-0.5825858116149902,
0.03476583585143089,
-0.2557602822780609,
-0.20200924575328827,
-0.14477883279323578,
0.39314815402030945,
-0.042796116322278976,
0.8340069651603699,
0.6227736473083496,
-0.6068586707115173,
0.02682945318520069,
0.4357924461364746,
-0.17216938734054565,
0.14691106975078583,
-0.3471074104309082,
0.7895804047584534,
-0.2357357293367386,
0.08082615584135056,
-0.5159476399421692,
-0.12626132369041443,
0.4353371262550354,
-0.09075641632080078,
0.5779069662094116,
-0.19753137230873108,
-0.6001776456832886,
0.3400474786758423,
-0.37011396884918213,
0.06619507819414139,
0.19271178543567657,
-0.6953591704368591,
0.701923668384552,
0.7212293744087219,
-0.31749531626701355,
-0.5442044138908386,
-0.6561667919158936,
0.3955952823162079,
-0.35000672936439514,
-0.5257577300071716,
0.44375932216644287,
-0.2823885679244995,
-0.5220504999160767,
-0.12010067701339722,
-0.10515902191400528,
-0.5202608704566956,
0.3353376090526581,
0.27202335000038147,
0.3251451849937439,
0.13796691596508026,
-0.02363419160246849,
-0.007398547139018774,
-0.2427303045988083,
-0.04623604193329811,
0.22868837416172028,
0.4949091076850891,
-0.005371434614062309,
-0.10741887986660004,
-1.0202604532241821,
0.6239452362060547,
0.4523242712020874,
-0.8328665494918823,
1.0690460205078125,
0.10942302644252777,
-0.4604063928127289,
-0.10027369111776352,
-0.4685715138912201,
-0.05024585500359535,
-0.5303362607955933,
0.33419570326805115,
-0.5096878409385681,
-0.5941668152809143,
0.4049324095249176,
-0.33870992064476013,
0.3199215531349182,
-0.06428325176239014,
0.39111846685409546,
0.3771232068538666,
0.7688841819763184,
0.6561225056648254,
-0.4187203049659729,
0.4606684446334839,
-0.21053114533424377,
0.501336395740509,
-0.720422089099884,
-0.1453227549791336,
-0.24325180053710938,
-0.1757451295852661,
-0.6192363500595093,
-0.3418078124523163,
0.12305763363838196,
0.047589004039764404,
-0.0015947303036227822,
0.04842600226402283,
-0.37175750732421875,
0.9297686219215393,
0.11538843810558319,
0.27661195397377014,
0.5754395127296448,
-0.30963075160980225,
0.6489166617393494,
-0.06523551046848297,
-0.0936114713549614,
-0.7691678404808044,
1.3468891382217407,
0.6761742830276489,
0.5925792455673218,
0.4238428473472595,
1.1549030542373657,
0.24840658903121948,
0.28373730182647705,
-0.2714116871356964,
0.7592523097991943,
-0.4912004768848419,
-0.6377122402191162,
-0.3771575093269348,
-0.2180890142917633,
-0.6763832569122314,
0.1990327388048172,
-0.2254830300807953,
-1.162397861480713,
0.5508872866630554,
0.22974908351898193,
-0.23648877441883087,
0.7272010445594788,
-0.8494272232055664,
0.7986438274383545,
0.008417265489697456,
-0.7731114029884338,
-0.2377830296754837,
-0.17700639367103577,
0.5456887483596802,
-0.3181209862232208,
0.36827343702316284,
0.10066726803779602,
-0.2304835319519043,
0.6503219604492188,
-0.6071929335594177,
0.8802212476730347,
-0.33791881799697876,
-0.2159605622291565,
-0.07905694842338562,
0.4980612099170685,
1.1087294816970825,
0.3878175914287567,
-0.28891071677207947,
0.28571027517318726,
-0.2408991903066635,
-0.28855401277542114,
-0.5180591344833374,
0.7556997537612915,
-0.5356563925743103,
-0.829859733581543,
-0.40241870284080505,
-0.5905969738960266,
-0.33592918515205383,
0.24971932172775269,
-0.14550741016864777,
0.14999565482139587,
-0.1889452040195465,
0.27574029564857483,
0.7309432029724121,
-0.38267117738723755,
0.276175856590271,
0.6723965406417847,
-0.1296597570180893,
-0.1449216902256012,
0.8077904582023621,
0.0012104616034775972,
0.23020654916763306,
0.35344335436820984,
0.429159551858902,
-0.11864768713712692,
-0.9243804812431335,
0.26829323172569275,
0.39891913533210754,
-0.46355101466178894,
0.02695549465715885,
-0.7369868159294128,
-0.09845202416181564,
-0.4256710708141327,
-0.06896022707223892,
-0.7073847651481628,
-0.29145973920822144,
0.047874514013528824,
-0.15453660488128662,
0.40225717425346375,
0.539518415927887,
-0.31267982721328735,
0.46540674567222595,
-0.7516584396362305,
0.38377904891967773,
0.2790260314941406,
0.608659029006958,
-0.18043380975723267,
-0.2896707355976105,
0.13160096108913422,
-0.27112525701522827,
-0.13166964054107666,
-0.8875744938850403,
0.4961220324039459,
0.14103692770004272,
0.1793801188468933,
0.10299654304981232,
-0.03992750123143196,
0.5981948971748352,
-0.640192985534668,
0.6608734726905823,
-0.2637384235858917,
-1.213529348373413,
0.38614535331726074,
-0.29712381958961487,
-0.05762288346886635,
0.5789347290992737,
0.06478181481361389,
-0.271670937538147,
-0.5642843246459961,
-0.7558841109275818,
-0.6028820276260376,
0.5458680987358093,
0.06831416487693787,
0.12660928070545197,
0.12931767106056213,
0.5270518660545349,
0.13293924927711487,
0.35603412985801697,
-0.6730888485908508,
-0.4881337285041809,
0.33304816484451294,
-0.012907938100397587,
0.1793874204158783,
-0.4337625801563263,
-0.022928081452846527,
0.02114766649901867,
0.9110907316207886,
0.48343440890312195,
-0.054955802857875824,
0.022792305797338486,
0.3620871603488922,
-0.05090370774269104,
0.5186180472373962,
0.04704807326197624,
0.6236882209777832,
-0.3404867947101593,
-0.14192190766334534,
0.18636219203472137,
-0.38583311438560486,
0.02618340402841568,
-0.08337236195802689,
-0.2051818072795868,
-0.1004466637969017,
0.0981799066066742,
0.45170241594314575,
-0.10182926803827286,
-0.3839241564273834,
0.5565738081932068,
-0.30899521708488464,
0.02659042552113533,
-0.315058171749115,
0.33311378955841064,
-0.10040464997291565,
0.01664087176322937,
-0.2140546441078186,
0.09741520881652832,
0.04300723224878311,
-0.4912967383861542,
0.08619916439056396,
0.15824998915195465,
0.1692749559879303,
-0.19498933851718903,
0.6921585202217102,
-0.04521355777978897,
-0.6759523153305054,
0.2662324607372284,
0.06471430510282516,
-0.010917609557509422,
0.20853599905967712,
0.3246437609195709,
0.8626708984375,
-0.7507006525993347,
-0.12937772274017334,
0.017686843872070312,
0.24844342470169067,
0.10026602447032928,
0.10256996005773544,
0.1985197365283966,
-0.47092607617378235,
-0.25272539258003235,
-0.10001363605260849,
-0.2748074531555176,
0.8871862292289734,
-0.5390157103538513,
0.2000744491815567,
-1.0442520380020142,
0.17822213470935822,
0.09990233182907104,
-0.13231980800628662,
-0.42370715737342834,
0.15241535007953644,
0.011606615036725998,
0.7922587394714355,
-0.4237178564071655,
1.0527081489562988,
0.13096533715724945,
-0.054784320294857025,
-0.7818965911865234,
0.10734236240386963,
0.2812744379043579,
-0.39311638474464417,
0.4036845862865448,
-0.18401765823364258,
0.10591800510883331,
-0.21308176219463348,
-0.3276350796222687,
-0.5950965285301208,
0.7232606410980225,
0.40566205978393555,
-1.032198429107666,
0.08524022996425629,
0.17187535762786865,
0.43713194131851196,
-0.09707058221101761,
-0.5169371962547302,
0.6301959156990051,
0.5840069651603699,
-0.6360596418380737,
-0.6390491724014282,
-0.035497549921274185,
-0.11059581488370895,
-0.10144200921058655,
0.2325667440891266,
-0.7565208673477173,
0.7350742220878601,
0.15091069042682648,
-0.18835610151290894,
0.20292218029499054,
0.6735667586326599,
0.1825757473707199,
0.2124433070421219,
0.44723063707351685,
0.4222724139690399,
1.0856144428253174,
0.32413598895072937,
1.1976839303970337,
-0.3262943625450134,
-0.013682013377547264,
1.4378236532211304,
-0.5944024324417114,
0.8698774576187134,
0.233448326587677,
-0.08805899322032928,
0.07042404264211655,
-0.013518920168280602,
-0.004550835583359003,
0.5660274028778076,
0.10099238157272339,
-0.7464820742607117,
-0.06442272663116455,
0.25689834356307983,
-0.3205362856388092,
0.6982786059379578,
0.19678273797035217,
-0.5929899215698242,
0.14174897968769073,
-0.20662732422351837,
0.47914811968803406,
0.5891291499137878,
-0.20078976452350616,
0.896325945854187,
-0.05430387705564499,
-0.2602105736732483,
0.1498699188232422,
0.4707890450954437,
0.40001437067985535,
-0.7184354662895203,
0.0919126570224762,
-0.21414029598236084,
0.5630167722702026,
-0.25226205587387085,
-0.6168129444122314,
0.6411823034286499,
0.4360355734825134,
-0.23725660145282745,
-0.15884508192539215,
0.5918419361114502,
-0.4873569905757904,
-0.29386451840400696,
0.1947486847639084,
0.19993315637111664,
0.13316768407821655,
-0.18990428745746613,
-0.6443656086921692,
0.2448028177022934,
0.01065809652209282,
-0.27586835622787476,
0.5988756418228149,
0.4545454978942871,
0.08465434610843658,
0.49471884965896606,
0.8439823389053345,
0.5235673189163208,
0.1509578675031662,
0.00870882160961628,
0.6320072412490845,
-0.4066336750984192,
-0.5670715570449829,
-1.0990610122680664,
0.380226731300354,
-0.2743048071861267,
-0.11794441938400269,
0.8066873550415039,
0.7440718412399292,
0.6241406798362732,
-0.20187102258205414,
0.8649002909660339,
0.35354936122894287,
0.5837222933769226,
-0.5235502123832703,
0.8742970824241638,
-0.0014438886428251863,
0.6310069561004639,
-0.22044506669044495,
-0.6778772473335266,
-0.5670788884162903,
0.28680190443992615,
-0.6704984307289124,
-0.3677506446838379,
0.6040558218955994,
1.189928650856018,
-0.03408899903297424,
0.03971545770764351,
0.27482035756111145,
0.5631612539291382,
0.8415942788124084,
0.5277082324028015,
0.3736957311630249,
-0.5703485608100891,
0.3818035423755646,
-0.7320755124092102,
-0.3243004083633423,
0.4913294017314911,
-0.8785597085952759,
-1.1021456718444824,
-0.2378920465707779,
-0.58327317237854,
-0.13017207384109497,
0.4762287437915802,
0.6483719944953918,
0.6669917106628418,
-0.836004912853241,
-0.14112357795238495,
-0.14405487477779388,
-0.041371915489435196,
-0.08643770962953568,
-0.1942751705646515,
0.713529109954834,
0.09885698556900024,
-0.9685490131378174,
0.9328958988189697,
0.46990740299224854,
0.026914803311228752,
-0.053945474326610565,
0.07286439836025238,
-0.24955013394355774,
0.10907982289791107,
0.19852514564990997,
0.47254860401153564,
-0.5135163068771362,
-0.18561682105064392,
-0.609782874584198,
0.13552972674369812,
0.08007210493087769,
0.6930031180381775,
-0.20970651507377625,
0.594902753829956,
0.2250942587852478,
0.8864662051200867,
0.2496214210987091,
0.12119431048631668,
0.6754151582717896,
-0.9216501116752625,
0.3720656931400299,
0.04889148101210594,
0.45876365900039673,
0.2818525433540344,
-0.9117516875267029,
0.26961424946784973,
0.06600051373243332,
-0.6243385076522827,
-0.8733634352684021,
0.03181866928935051,
-0.7982970476150513,
-0.2716168761253357,
0.8739941716194153,
-0.511023223400116,
-0.6918209791183472,
-0.06351719796657562,
-0.39596641063690186,
0.05004722997546196,
-0.48781269788742065,
1.0609526634216309,
0.591928243637085,
0.33702796697616577,
-0.15130095183849335,
-0.24506117403507233,
0.4706842601299286,
0.27464133501052856,
-1.0185102224349976,
0.6187999844551086,
0.3769286870956421,
0.2846539616584778,
-0.14452506601810455,
0.7266415357589722,
-0.5564969778060913,
0.19502121210098267,
-0.30989882349967957,
-0.2154952436685562,
-0.47570428252220154,
-0.39535653591156006,
-0.5316010117530823,
0.2609366774559021,
0.12151593714952469,
-0.45700305700302124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18219v1 | A Closer Look into Mixture-of-Experts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | 2024-06-26T10:07:57 | Ka Man Lo, Zeyu Huang, Zihan Qiu, Zili Wang, Jie Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Mixture-of-experts (MoE) is gaining increasing attention due to its unique
properties and remarkable performance, especially for language tasks. By
sparsely activating a subset of parameters for each token, MoE architecture
could increase the model size without sacrificing computational efficiency,
achieving a better trade-off between performance and training costs. However,
the underlying mechanism of MoE still lacks further exploration, and its
modularization degree remains questionable. In this paper, we make an initial
attempt to understand the inner workings of MoE-based large language models.
Concretely, we comprehensively study the parametric and behavioral features of
three recent MoE-based models and reveal some intriguing observations,
including (1) Neurons act like fine-grained experts. (2) The router of MoE
usually selects experts with larger output norms. (3) The expert diversity
increases as the layer increases, while the last layer is an outlier. Based on
the observations, we also provide suggestions for a broad spectrum of MoE
practitioners, such as router design and expert allocation. We hope this work
could shed light on future research on the MoE framework and other modular
architectures. Code is available at
https://github.com/kamanphoebe/Look-into-MoEs. | [
-0.6949455738067627,
-0.8339176774024963,
0.5414507985115051,
-0.019590692594647408,
0.02795596420764923,
0.007981089875102043,
-0.3826921582221985,
-0.46818017959594727,
0.21816201508045197,
0.3623582124710083,
-0.28913798928260803,
-0.03669455274939537,
-0.8098976016044617,
-0.24343551695346832,
-0.3909685015678406,
0.7163108587265015,
0.4405917227268219,
-0.12678545713424683,
-0.08651883155107498,
-0.05213277041912079,
-0.7395696043968201,
-0.3341594934463501,
-0.5598761439323425,
-0.40357375144958496,
0.4716622531414032,
0.44432464241981506,
0.7808758616447449,
0.4721587002277374,
0.2990833818912506,
0.3551560938358307,
-0.12268832325935364,
0.1328365057706833,
-0.6200088858604431,
0.1741219013929367,
-0.14978133141994476,
-0.7191393375396729,
-0.5816143155097961,
-0.3249271810054779,
0.6413118839263916,
0.7811334729194641,
-0.26015350222587585,
-0.17080819606781006,
0.12918144464492798,
0.502495527267456,
-0.5991348624229431,
0.18410076200962067,
-0.9765679836273193,
-0.11028815805912018,
-0.5264493823051453,
-0.0026521910913288593,
-0.45620739459991455,
0.27541476488113403,
0.2156786024570465,
-0.18777143955230713,
0.019093293696641922,
0.18116530776023865,
0.509829580783844,
0.22376549243927002,
-0.5759281516075134,
-0.03764882683753967,
-0.5793744325637817,
0.990943431854248,
-0.915763795375824,
0.1504112333059311,
0.44598984718322754,
0.27065154910087585,
-0.37898001074790955,
-0.06649833172559738,
-0.45551037788391113,
-0.12551619112491608,
0.06735578179359436,
-0.08406172692775726,
-0.14996188879013062,
0.0577402226626873,
-0.20981347560882568,
0.6863500475883484,
-0.2668832242488861,
0.421865850687027,
-0.4179724454879761,
0.05902450159192085,
0.7458168268203735,
0.20097331702709198,
0.34833618998527527,
0.012554049491882324,
-0.27280566096305847,
0.2635739743709564,
-0.4388432502746582,
0.04740576073527336,
0.5939861536026001,
-0.11152379959821701,
0.007060232572257519,
0.5594666004180908,
-0.3620630204677582,
0.7897545099258423,
0.17406636476516724,
0.09011123329401016,
0.02116389200091362,
0.0647246241569519,
0.10717719793319702,
-0.15139180421829224,
0.8966386914253235,
0.18348582088947296,
0.5089719891548157,
-0.3350246250629425,
-0.4667970538139343,
-0.6533440947532654,
0.23879915475845337,
-0.5418481230735779,
-0.7156887054443359,
0.19093158841133118,
-0.5034410357475281,
-0.23688891530036926,
-0.018837645649909973,
-0.6056612730026245,
-0.17999498546123505,
-0.3537333011627197,
0.5716348886489868,
-0.5203313231468201,
-0.7668737173080444,
0.23921692371368408,
-0.1959894597530365,
-0.07210758328437805,
0.25842171907424927,
-1.0564295053482056,
0.2746306359767914,
1.035779595375061,
0.628573477268219,
-0.25786522030830383,
-0.43539753556251526,
-0.38042253255844116,
0.14885318279266357,
-0.2341495007276535,
0.6617957949638367,
-1.0536800622940063,
-0.34910884499549866,
-0.2165343165397644,
-0.6068501472473145,
-0.18446260690689087,
-0.598212718963623,
-0.05478927120566368,
-0.7160125374794006,
-0.027269911020994186,
-0.29206082224845886,
-0.6185025572776794,
-0.3813110291957855,
0.15415693819522858,
-0.408017635345459,
1.0853829383850098,
-0.08821647614240646,
-0.6460807919502258,
0.2765923738479614,
-0.5594754219055176,
-0.32114923000335693,
0.009034349583089352,
-0.2970287799835205,
0.2216888964176178,
0.5978014469146729,
0.1739000529050827,
0.7737295627593994,
-0.13621680438518524,
0.40740635991096497,
-0.5095644593238831,
-0.20988044142723083,
0.6770324110984802,
-0.459722638130188,
0.812088131904602,
0.05839079990983009,
-0.19500640034675598,
0.03330465406179428,
-0.751001238822937,
-0.2116975635290146,
-0.20782610774040222,
-0.2247467041015625,
-0.5965726971626282,
0.18500792980194092,
-0.23686560988426208,
0.21725308895111084,
0.31730684638023376,
-0.29614901542663574,
0.2353416383266449,
-0.046113502234220505,
0.531839907169342,
0.9970561861991882,
0.010874483734369278,
0.6667649149894714,
-0.3021433651447296,
0.24198229610919952,
0.19386625289916992,
0.18388152122497559,
-0.3054267466068268,
-0.9598613977432251,
-0.8163661956787109,
-0.6012772917747498,
0.38819068670272827,
0.1561659425497055,
-0.5864758491516113,
0.6410415768623352,
-0.2985163629055023,
-0.5602533221244812,
-0.5701276063919067,
0.35562098026275635,
0.30247312784194946,
0.3208156228065491,
0.1901266723871231,
-0.3484068214893341,
0.12130395323038101,
-1.191704273223877,
-0.2463970184326172,
-0.08707660436630249,
-0.0019200540846213698,
0.24166645109653473,
0.43678247928619385,
-0.17989902198314667,
1.268385648727417,
-0.4909834563732147,
0.050477612763643265,
-0.1189483031630516,
0.18292757868766785,
0.10296648740768433,
0.653010368347168,
0.5939926505088806,
-0.654613196849823,
-0.45068299770355225,
0.29460588097572327,
-0.5552234649658203,
-0.016760189086198807,
0.09016678482294083,
-0.31760719418525696,
-0.3271294832229614,
0.4164661765098572,
-0.6555150747299194,
0.05064369738101959,
0.5098220109939575,
0.18974441289901733,
0.38440078496932983,
-0.18876728415489197,
-0.1747485101222992,
-1.0208832025527954,
-0.11955369263887405,
-0.021305859088897705,
0.002002924680709839,
-0.5732396245002747,
0.4985421597957611,
-0.13742731511592865,
0.16505348682403564,
0.004378586076200008,
0.46864378452301025,
-0.5717825293540955,
-0.0744074359536171,
-0.36874550580978394,
-0.10514829307794571,
-0.35599225759506226,
0.7332558631896973,
-0.21715658903121948,
0.6624274849891663,
0.9427125453948975,
-0.5260657072067261,
0.2694806158542633,
-0.12334191054105759,
-0.49848270416259766,
0.3418707847595215,
-0.5502736568450928,
0.2643505036830902,
-0.06491315364837646,
0.07442561537027359,
-1.0062222480773926,
-0.538195013999939,
0.14319734275341034,
-0.3356036841869354,
0.486558735370636,
-0.19477799534797668,
-0.6449533700942993,
-0.14774517714977264,
-0.1905609518289566,
0.6952146291732788,
0.7351726293563843,
-0.11796706914901733,
0.8033011555671692,
0.6624764800071716,
-0.5353452563285828,
-0.41854017972946167,
-0.6457163691520691,
0.14332011342048645,
-0.10692158341407776,
-0.7365430593490601,
0.07335565984249115,
-0.019062375649809837,
-0.5269246697425842,
0.03804192692041397,
0.05457853898406029,
-0.40825891494750977,
0.18893243372440338,
0.08161123096942902,
-0.2101905792951584,
-0.4793306291103363,
0.048756808042526245,
0.4938162565231323,
-0.044799964874982834,
0.2285919040441513,
-0.3349372446537018,
0.6045374274253845,
-0.1453849822282791,
-0.7060137391090393,
-0.41679516434669495,
0.5240925550460815,
0.6662300229072571,
-0.4731277525424957,
0.6644269227981567,
0.5563449263572693,
-0.1762923002243042,
-0.15035486221313477,
-0.8962210416793823,
-0.26558244228363037,
-0.4747341275215149,
0.5525044798851013,
-0.3059740364551544,
-0.5792487859725952,
0.8188074231147766,
0.1948663741350174,
0.05821320042014122,
0.5191399455070496,
0.6965703368186951,
0.12067849189043045,
0.9858041405677795,
0.46641892194747925,
-0.261417418718338,
0.5407021045684814,
-0.0657653734087944,
0.21367254853248596,
-0.8915510773658752,
-0.3817289173603058,
-0.28809380531311035,
-0.6485782861709595,
-0.17800310254096985,
-0.44599011540412903,
0.30405938625335693,
0.17149962484836578,
0.17757512629032135,
0.0022835074923932552,
-0.12600623071193695,
0.5122205018997192,
0.6667795777320862,
0.23135152459144592,
0.1606355458498001,
-0.16973252594470978,
-0.026378560811281204,
0.29290860891342163,
-1.033958077430725,
-0.15863262116909027,
1.0430824756622314,
0.4155380427837372,
0.6782846450805664,
0.05364716053009033,
0.6558867692947388,
0.14230120182037354,
0.01027554739266634,
-0.7242099642753601,
0.7375346422195435,
0.021047675982117653,
-0.9280226230621338,
-0.2640015184879303,
-0.3723703622817993,
-0.5961980223655701,
0.4414624571800232,
-0.21094171702861786,
-0.6720758676528931,
0.48738130927085876,
0.17010937631130219,
-0.364982545375824,
0.5139924883842468,
-0.8077818751335144,
0.43110623955726624,
-0.24561141431331635,
-0.1885484904050827,
-0.5501878261566162,
-0.6042742729187012,
0.5097052454948425,
-0.37725594639778137,
0.24462270736694336,
-0.10888299345970154,
-0.0790661871433258,
0.44390037655830383,
-0.34604689478874207,
0.9066774845123291,
0.009431304410099983,
-0.39492061734199524,
0.15613891184329987,
0.15371039509773254,
0.3287532329559326,
-0.013313940726220608,
-0.2229059785604477,
0.4080111086368561,
-0.5617175102233887,
-0.7233490943908691,
-0.45757293701171875,
0.8106073141098022,
-0.7200170159339905,
-0.7071419358253479,
0.20041097700595856,
-0.7707530856132507,
-0.2926647961139679,
0.2596128284931183,
0.284990131855011,
0.7840797305107117,
0.1951485127210617,
0.5830895304679871,
0.8216691613197327,
0.0014124714070931077,
0.34454306960105896,
0.19816264510154724,
-0.2808423638343811,
-0.07914608716964722,
1.0038036108016968,
0.2860184609889984,
0.23134301602840424,
0.518616259098053,
0.2102273851633072,
0.09943193942308426,
-0.9220708608627319,
-0.4445768892765045,
-0.09505489468574524,
-0.5040300488471985,
0.08629530668258667,
-0.8194313645362854,
0.09319726377725601,
-0.0675697922706604,
-0.03569469973444939,
-0.45820432901382446,
-0.2842288613319397,
-0.2666500508785248,
0.07525693625211716,
0.24900054931640625,
0.898711085319519,
0.20595908164978027,
0.5098896026611328,
-0.8434761762619019,
0.017871221527457237,
0.5416425466537476,
0.29158779978752136,
0.6249347925186157,
-0.3867834210395813,
-0.44464296102523804,
0.22610613703727722,
-0.10562604665756226,
-0.648971676826477,
-0.05616649612784386,
0.24480712413787842,
0.7894421815872192,
1.088390588760376,
-0.019853459671139717,
0.5423067212104797,
-0.6116406321525574,
0.8308975100517273,
-0.003116865875199437,
-0.7948562502861023,
0.004583775997161865,
-0.7623878717422485,
0.022428691387176514,
0.33088886737823486,
0.057906702160835266,
0.047041889280080795,
-0.8192511796951294,
-0.49115607142448425,
-0.777535080909729,
0.6728463768959045,
0.3506373167037964,
0.5650834441184998,
0.016770321875810623,
0.24268309772014618,
0.6341719627380371,
0.29303407669067383,
-0.3736983835697174,
-0.19487348198890686,
0.16148337721824646,
-0.09754455089569092,
0.031065352261066437,
-0.48051244020462036,
-0.06994450092315674,
-0.2281865030527115,
0.4139558672904968,
0.18921007215976715,
0.1319919228553772,
-0.37847331166267395,
-0.26543036103248596,
0.01130465418100357,
0.21235334873199463,
0.6636863946914673,
0.7486777305603027,
-0.11918935924768448,
0.07309206575155258,
0.14104026556015015,
-0.1746094673871994,
-0.33360177278518677,
-0.14844337105751038,
0.115170918405056,
-0.026569630950689316,
0.568183422088623,
0.8835978507995605,
0.6538520455360413,
-0.5004679560661316,
0.5842528343200684,
0.31208255887031555,
-0.08604545146226883,
0.050676584243774414,
0.4809853136539459,
-0.014297270216047764,
0.4219048023223877,
0.7330240607261658,
0.6190450191497803,
0.3010162115097046,
-0.6292845010757446,
-0.08434750139713287,
0.446636825799942,
-0.031822677701711655,
-0.6873655915260315,
0.3921290338039398,
0.5385110378265381,
-0.3513703942298889,
0.39954614639282227,
-0.08152133226394653,
-0.6405504941940308,
0.4545539915561676,
0.1872648447751999,
0.7909836769104004,
-0.12957021594047546,
-0.1561715453863144,
-0.40374454855918884,
0.256095290184021,
-0.17527663707733154,
-0.14273691177368164,
-0.1990111917257309,
-0.563421905040741,
-0.49623990058898926,
-0.1831006109714508,
-0.22580453753471375,
-0.16217336058616638,
-0.9092528820037842,
0.1239456981420517,
-0.21720409393310547,
-0.17858725786209106,
-0.11758887767791748,
-0.5229197144508362,
-0.4733198285102844,
-0.03776973485946655,
0.11055801808834076,
0.6748165488243103,
-0.6113206148147583,
0.7915141582489014,
0.8323371410369873,
-0.012778403237462044,
-0.4855596423149109,
0.3912205100059509,
-0.2934352457523346,
-0.9115250706672668,
0.5392632484436035,
0.05204278603196144,
0.07585114240646362,
-0.040502529591321945,
-0.3762943744659424,
-0.593643844127655,
0.6933512091636658,
0.3357737362384796,
-0.6151391267776489,
-0.26490330696105957,
-0.11132584512233734,
0.49806874990463257,
-0.15092259645462036,
0.37882089614868164,
0.22198788821697235,
0.3263651728630066,
-0.2703886926174164,
-0.8777289986610413,
-0.27777647972106934,
-0.4641183316707611,
-0.051194723695516586,
0.3406558334827423,
-0.8640673160552979,
1.3308459520339966,
0.11154737323522568,
0.4144482910633087,
-0.00016762754239607602,
0.8221310973167419,
-0.021497365087270737,
0.2612922191619873,
0.4679732918739319,
0.4013718366622925,
0.6894379258155823,
0.23228448629379272,
1.1226869821548462,
-0.5047739148139954,
0.31583550572395325,
0.7282451391220093,
-0.11510252207517624,
0.9703664183616638,
0.44572213292121887,
-0.14258944988250732,
0.5471816062927246,
0.5430817604064941,
0.216010183095932,
0.4456111192703247,
-0.17024028301239014,
-0.20371980965137482,
-0.6220755577087402,
0.39772656559944153,
-0.5317593812942505,
0.3932000398635864,
0.355769544839859,
-0.22453290224075317,
-0.11152839660644531,
0.11211875081062317,
-0.1172557920217514,
-0.2723681330680847,
-0.516662061214447,
0.7389736771583557,
0.11777844280004501,
-0.5926050543785095,
0.15437456965446472,
0.006952081341296434,
0.826877236366272,
-0.4341392517089844,
0.2193809151649475,
-0.10986515879631042,
0.04057682678103447,
-0.04567722976207733,
-0.9203633666038513,
-0.08137547969818115,
-0.21350277960300446,
-0.3407934904098511,
0.06965968012809753,
0.6237918734550476,
-0.45577171444892883,
-0.316667377948761,
0.18111290037631989,
0.43582606315612793,
0.1654265969991684,
-0.39799779653549194,
-0.4799933135509491,
-0.2320111095905304,
-0.07675189524888992,
-0.24166443943977356,
0.49549630284309387,
0.9247262477874756,
-0.04121540114283562,
0.716282308101654,
0.49594631791114807,
-0.05200720578432083,
0.5465734004974365,
-0.36991947889328003,
0.8701305985450745,
-0.17338432371616364,
-0.5350035429000854,
-0.9522490501403809,
0.6981573700904846,
-0.07722468674182892,
-0.5146742463111877,
0.7560746073722839,
0.418186217546463,
0.8268417716026306,
-0.3099224865436554,
0.5913140773773193,
0.09979511052370071,
0.047367021441459656,
-0.7083953619003296,
0.8521124124526978,
-0.7776485681533813,
0.16738799214363098,
-0.2338995486497879,
-0.8685904145240784,
0.005179461091756821,
0.2996278703212738,
-0.5695759654045105,
0.312134325504303,
0.32828083634376526,
0.6992430686950684,
-0.5394434928894043,
-0.030034486204385757,
0.3627534508705139,
0.3771808445453644,
0.17054176330566406,
0.19421300292015076,
1.0422052145004272,
0.1172788068652153,
0.35931944847106934,
-0.17496131360530853,
-0.17754921317100525,
-0.7983304262161255,
-0.5840142965316772,
-1.102567195892334,
-0.5076234936714172,
-0.2418513298034668,
0.33651334047317505,
-0.19284260272979736,
0.8300987482070923,
0.9773085117340088,
-0.7503297328948975,
-0.041549768298864365,
-0.04977922886610031,
0.08811984956264496,
-0.026355527341365814,
-0.19703982770442963,
-0.031023558229207993,
-0.33273589611053467,
-0.8553849458694458,
0.3606722354888916,
0.41183212399482727,
-0.37435340881347656,
-0.3850494623184204,
-0.05715730041265488,
0.024924036115407944,
0.24948899447917938,
0.5008456707000732,
-0.09142647683620453,
-0.8636784553527832,
-0.01800498180091381,
-0.2021508812904358,
0.04976041615009308,
-0.03903790935873985,
0.8356300592422485,
-0.2441861778497696,
0.5158076286315918,
0.7293145060539246,
0.8121849894523621,
-0.02776823379099369,
-0.08994762599468231,
0.7914451360702515,
-0.7457555532455444,
0.16952621936798096,
0.08689575642347336,
0.6024597883224487,
-0.027670549228787422,
-0.31409621238708496,
-0.0596611425280571,
0.0763012245297432,
-0.53863126039505,
-0.9854166507720947,
0.20014560222625732,
-0.9992343783378601,
-0.3337961435317993,
1.1874922513961792,
-0.06656672805547714,
0.04111415892839432,
-0.11506090313196182,
-0.4584764242172241,
-0.2175491899251938,
-0.7107034921646118,
0.7779421806335449,
1.073310375213623,
-0.0234663188457489,
-0.10384907573461533,
-0.5619969964027405,
-0.10906749963760376,
0.6191707849502563,
-0.3169810473918915,
-0.216543048620224,
0.27619174122810364,
0.3295796513557434,
0.13971024751663208,
0.3494166433811188,
0.1522139459848404,
0.05055835843086243,
-0.04088021442294121,
-0.15080346167087555,
-0.3084700107574463,
-0.43447375297546387,
-0.30555492639541626,
0.23062767088413239,
0.18626537919044495,
-0.20178553462028503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18200v1 | SEED: Accelerating Reasoning Tree Construction via Scheduled Speculative Decoding | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | 2024-06-26T09:33:41 | Zhenglin Wang, Jialong Wu, Yilong Lai, Congzhi Zhang, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable emergent abilities across
various tasks, yet fall short of complex reasoning and planning tasks. The
tree-search-based reasoning methods address this by surpassing the capabilities
of chain-of-thought prompting, encouraging exploration of intermediate steps.
However, such methods introduce significant inference latency due to the
systematic exploration and evaluation of multiple thought paths. This paper
introduces SeeD, a novel and efficient inference framework to optimize runtime
speed and GPU memory management concurrently. By employing a scheduled
speculative execution, SeeD efficiently handles multiple iterations for the
thought generation and the state evaluation, leveraging a rounds-scheduled
strategy to manage draft model dispatching. Extensive experimental evaluations
on three reasoning datasets demonstrate superior speedup performance of SeeD,
providing a viable path for batched inference in training-free speculative
decoding. | [
-0.06295377016067505,
-0.7899404764175415,
0.7939622402191162,
0.5463763475418091,
-0.2537226378917694,
0.4502793550491333,
-0.07998461276292801,
-0.33274006843566895,
0.028837701305747032,
0.3641151785850525,
-0.8362043499946594,
-0.28252264857292175,
-0.4805637300014496,
-0.15838852524757385,
-0.4679892063140869,
0.42709094285964966,
-0.12531013786792755,
-0.3893457353115082,
-0.21069204807281494,
0.23684464395046234,
-0.24385982751846313,
-0.2057790756225586,
-0.8324369192123413,
-0.07364355772733688,
0.29629290103912354,
0.1627296358346939,
0.6294651627540588,
1.1758112907409668,
0.17760616540908813,
0.18613310158252716,
-0.033442240208387375,
0.2984716594219208,
-0.6356002688407898,
0.3934897482395172,
-0.02579438127577305,
-0.5267786979675293,
-0.14985264837741852,
-0.03893637657165527,
0.6350307464599609,
0.5578771233558655,
-0.20446640253067017,
0.14848676323890686,
-0.48276135325431824,
0.32604143023490906,
-1.0268363952636719,
0.14152520895004272,
-0.9369810223579407,
0.2610127925872803,
-0.31717878580093384,
-0.8094317317008972,
-0.7786755561828613,
-0.35828226804733276,
-0.3441324532032013,
-0.8828386068344116,
0.4260021150112152,
0.3353674113750458,
0.5301251411437988,
0.4199391305446625,
-0.08710259944200516,
0.034919872879981995,
-0.8148831129074097,
0.78522127866745,
-0.5738722085952759,
0.37249311804771423,
0.0723198726773262,
0.36166244745254517,
-0.4517049789428711,
-0.6722803711891174,
-0.3618625998497009,
0.03979158774018288,
0.1369784027338028,
0.13512186706066132,
-0.040424954146146774,
0.24031352996826172,
0.6153098940849304,
0.4375479817390442,
-0.42211011052131653,
-0.09637989848852158,
0.017879897728562355,
-0.09367463737726212,
0.38049083948135376,
0.14868208765983582,
0.15355224907398224,
-0.004005500581115484,
-0.10482268035411835,
-0.07424380630254745,
-0.8427187204360962,
-0.018986234441399574,
0.3954767882823944,
0.14947964251041412,
0.2257738709449768,
0.48749178647994995,
-0.3409906327724457,
0.8460361361503601,
-0.061254117637872696,
-0.15763074159622192,
-0.24144119024276733,
-0.3726457953453064,
-0.35269227623939514,
0.10387913882732391,
0.7248857617378235,
0.1516641080379486,
-0.0741928368806839,
-0.3316737115383148,
-0.05830102413892746,
0.5566376447677612,
0.11370342969894409,
-0.9960577487945557,
-0.2593841850757599,
0.40057963132858276,
-0.3678455650806427,
-0.38044610619544983,
-0.4035409092903137,
-0.5564332008361816,
-0.2840707302093506,
0.2334897667169571,
-0.2970849871635437,
-0.7308464050292969,
-0.20185169577598572,
0.2510628402233124,
-0.3720506727695465,
0.2071022391319275,
0.38349074125289917,
-0.9547611474990845,
0.17825384438037872,
0.9212631583213806,
0.6693047881126404,
-0.05639362335205078,
-0.0018920224392786622,
-0.6503449082374573,
0.32594066858291626,
-0.8585453033447266,
0.9294056296348572,
-0.8543431758880615,
-0.4981924891471863,
-0.384474515914917,
-0.3023298978805542,
-0.2758501172065735,
-0.11104650050401688,
0.7192289233207703,
-0.686798095703125,
-0.003995549865067005,
-0.1865270584821701,
-0.6730058193206787,
-0.02873740717768669,
0.15556387603282928,
-0.2925741672515869,
1.1731759309768677,
-0.005485094152390957,
-0.9655206203460693,
0.6811054348945618,
-0.4348415732383728,
-0.5763519406318665,
0.37983959913253784,
-0.4228757321834564,
0.10168363898992538,
0.21349111199378967,
0.6147723197937012,
0.49543362855911255,
-0.47043612599372864,
0.3784823715686798,
-0.3315281569957733,
-0.5158563256263733,
-0.2884678244590759,
-0.4392111003398895,
0.6557374596595764,
0.4695829749107361,
-0.3173661530017853,
0.2801796793937683,
-0.5441095232963562,
0.4078984558582306,
0.341013103723526,
-0.031400296837091446,
-0.3312935531139374,
0.5900281071662903,
-0.3959083557128906,
0.04659782350063324,
-0.07306937873363495,
-0.5029084086418152,
0.6006273627281189,
-0.3178013265132904,
0.5125689506530762,
0.7112137079238892,
0.11027611047029495,
0.21935002505779266,
-0.1950168013572693,
0.6430686116218567,
0.07694485038518906,
0.1408126950263977,
-0.6170040369033813,
-0.5255169868469238,
-0.8574144244194031,
-0.03112524002790451,
-0.1735183745622635,
0.48192864656448364,
-0.8775185346603394,
0.12421870231628418,
-0.3754456639289856,
-0.540377676486969,
-0.5233256220817566,
-0.15204501152038574,
0.3219703435897827,
0.2657473087310791,
0.18544906377792358,
0.27768629789352417,
-0.7525951266288757,
-0.6285341382026672,
-0.3665565848350525,
-0.1311548948287964,
0.38562965393066406,
0.4219912588596344,
0.18916891515254974,
-0.08847549557685852,
0.7531371116638184,
-0.5766921639442444,
0.5517984628677368,
-0.3386029303073883,
0.10385065525770187,
0.4187870919704437,
0.3782998025417328,
0.25999918580055237,
-0.3762299120426178,
-0.17760662734508514,
-0.18923965096473694,
-0.7484742999076843,
0.03125372901558876,
-0.49974846839904785,
-0.2595813572406769,
0.04133744165301323,
0.558193564414978,
-0.7383453249931335,
0.16530761122703552,
0.47015801072120667,
-0.4303989112377167,
0.6295557618141174,
-0.10329358279705048,
0.2744826376438141,
-0.9702680706977844,
-0.08826669305562973,
-0.3753204643726349,
-0.15386860072612762,
-0.07768549025058746,
0.33707043528556824,
0.010533593595027924,
0.052742257714271545,
-0.20349323749542236,
0.391737699508667,
-0.6572292447090149,
-0.16961069405078888,
-0.31412243843078613,
-0.24974381923675537,
-0.17462153732776642,
0.07685729116201401,
0.10804806649684906,
1.2733300924301147,
0.6837125420570374,
-0.5202584266662598,
0.14233551919460297,
-0.22232230007648468,
-0.4132117033004761,
-0.15583392977714539,
-0.2642858028411865,
0.3638250529766083,
-0.006927832495421171,
0.48363178968429565,
-0.4460632801055908,
-0.1161249652504921,
0.10310307890176773,
-0.17313170433044434,
-0.0457230769097805,
-0.31490030884742737,
-0.677333652973175,
-0.7607890367507935,
-0.0023545362055301666,
0.5482176542282104,
0.5042615532875061,
-0.573150634765625,
0.4544122815132141,
0.0655333548784256,
0.16536056995391846,
-0.5553551316261292,
-0.27753153443336487,
0.10324453562498093,
-0.07632966339588165,
-0.6618234515190125,
0.3373175859451294,
0.1308247148990631,
-0.25705939531326294,
0.13572460412979126,
-0.19750098884105682,
0.21601977944374084,
0.13716518878936768,
0.3025931119918823,
0.03299899399280548,
-0.3606036603450775,
-0.0630621612071991,
0.3607175350189209,
-0.2239263951778412,
0.19845597445964813,
-0.8615663647651672,
0.3907451331615448,
0.12178950756788254,
-0.4465750753879547,
0.0018928265199065208,
0.3274734616279602,
0.4792807698249817,
0.0008255351567640901,
0.5171780586242676,
0.1386837214231491,
-0.31049543619155884,
-0.6994761824607849,
-0.6923222541809082,
-0.2537113130092621,
-0.4104597270488739,
0.12379410862922668,
-0.5532903075218201,
-0.8226866722106934,
0.1591716706752777,
-0.41985607147216797,
0.27047452330589294,
0.4733259081840515,
0.41720637679100037,
0.07306552678346634,
0.9128497838973999,
0.467760294675827,
0.13888922333717346,
0.14721821248531342,
-0.380184143781662,
0.18415650725364685,
-0.6267391443252563,
-0.15386179089546204,
-0.24845828115940094,
-0.02741323783993721,
-0.31842872500419617,
-1.2284926176071167,
-0.10681305825710297,
0.25707051157951355,
-0.10345830768346786,
0.09551496058702469,
-0.5874801874160767,
0.6908472180366516,
0.5661509037017822,
-0.13887083530426025,
0.43980705738067627,
-0.04966948181390762,
-0.43356218934059143,
0.029483184218406677,
-0.9886409640312195,
-0.36101222038269043,
1.0498311519622803,
0.07163561880588531,
0.5870079398155212,
-0.4239015281200409,
0.5105942487716675,
0.07919581234455109,
0.30405980348587036,
-0.5792653560638428,
0.7308001518249512,
0.059787582606077194,
-0.5179868936538696,
-0.03214174881577492,
-0.41410306096076965,
-0.49453309178352356,
0.34018486738204956,
-0.1537485271692276,
-0.9193375706672668,
-0.11967308819293976,
0.25182974338531494,
-0.5368229746818542,
0.8308399319648743,
-0.6529935598373413,
0.5411166548728943,
-0.2598097622394562,
-0.5288457274436951,
-0.583194375038147,
-0.2402719259262085,
0.8719401955604553,
0.09974817931652069,
0.0014509421307593584,
-0.25064364075660706,
0.15631753206253052,
0.8587256073951721,
-0.5060849189758301,
0.37140655517578125,
-0.0911874994635582,
0.3341345489025116,
0.45443853735923767,
0.2591732442378998,
0.805342972278595,
0.1373886913061142,
-0.0994720384478569,
-0.10809110850095749,
-0.02784869633615017,
-0.4388793408870697,
-0.6417299509048462,
0.876250147819519,
-0.5826860666275024,
-0.8470569849014282,
-0.7169992923736572,
-0.9548482298851013,
-0.4458119869232178,
0.20503556728363037,
0.25170111656188965,
0.041160136461257935,
-0.163260355591774,
0.0643530786037445,
0.5963042974472046,
-0.2642122507095337,
0.5893896818161011,
0.1800738424062729,
-0.4023873805999756,
-0.14941585063934326,
0.6184852123260498,
-0.26743441820144653,
0.10582434386014938,
0.585205614566803,
0.19795474410057068,
-0.14058974385261536,
-0.9082101583480835,
-0.4803660809993744,
0.026052311062812805,
-0.36998990178108215,
-0.0325978547334671,
-1.0241256952285767,
-0.3276708722114563,
-0.2585391700267792,
-0.17983214557170868,
-0.4636484682559967,
-0.4627688527107239,
0.09391718357801437,
-0.40869900584220886,
0.6283571124076843,
0.5280815362930298,
0.08826665580272675,
0.48630034923553467,
-0.5347428321838379,
0.25209125876426697,
-0.06891094893217087,
0.25515884160995483,
0.12527567148208618,
-0.13921672105789185,
-0.002258686814457178,
-0.18292325735092163,
-0.2889050841331482,
-0.7346452474594116,
0.3043636679649353,
-0.18658649921417236,
0.4382949471473694,
0.6931411623954773,
-0.09256730228662491,
0.9170388579368591,
-0.48655253648757935,
0.41399821639060974,
0.08828240633010864,
-0.5767447352409363,
0.745343029499054,
-0.47777649760246277,
0.33413368463516235,
0.21641255915164948,
0.18716712296009064,
-0.33100625872612,
-0.3407862186431885,
-0.8420077562332153,
-0.739032506942749,
0.6737564206123352,
0.30378246307373047,
-0.365609347820282,
-0.18207205832004547,
0.2710320055484772,
0.08047641068696976,
0.006027068942785263,
-0.204651340842247,
-0.20924924314022064,
-0.008786840364336967,
0.40102270245552063,
-0.0295473150908947,
-0.5335788130760193,
-0.04876191169023514,
-0.48876094818115234,
0.6860046982765198,
-0.20216713845729828,
0.2409849613904953,
-0.1208062469959259,
0.19506177306175232,
-0.13164199888706207,
0.3474923074245453,
0.34967854619026184,
0.5258052945137024,
-0.416810005903244,
0.2152056246995926,
0.03394921496510506,
-0.404339462518692,
0.22931014001369476,
0.20014676451683044,
-0.5505481958389282,
-0.13130517303943634,
0.3803258240222931,
1.0300744771957397,
0.24274328351020813,
-0.5058781504631042,
0.011547233909368515,
-0.16227778792381287,
-0.1696537882089615,
-0.10138872265815735,
0.3470698893070221,
0.36063259840011597,
0.10957281291484833,
0.43953225016593933,
0.27863144874572754,
0.005144014488905668,
-0.24418137967586517,
0.1310926377773285,
0.3459721803665161,
-0.04154040291905403,
-0.14594809710979462,
0.8015899658203125,
0.1142406240105629,
0.012661801651120186,
0.9317546486854553,
-0.48163244128227234,
-0.2538923919200897,
0.6097099184989929,
0.7742882370948792,
1.126784324645996,
0.09995092451572418,
0.13815462589263916,
0.4583512544631958,
0.44030559062957764,
-0.10729851573705673,
0.5776907205581665,
-0.18958505988121033,
-0.7999352216720581,
-1.0093910694122314,
-0.7988876700401306,
-0.29931408166885376,
0.08806806802749634,
-0.14322401583194733,
-0.14064520597457886,
-0.6674255728721619,
-0.04697820544242859,
-0.24910414218902588,
-0.0841069445014,
-0.5785948634147644,
0.07172362506389618,
-0.009175190702080727,
1.4526771306991577,
-0.6708305478096008,
1.0480670928955078,
0.43917733430862427,
0.07022235542535782,
-1.0972776412963867,
-0.14328709244728088,
-0.0074084787629544735,
-0.7239562273025513,
0.6246744394302368,
0.3108120560646057,
-0.14473596215248108,
0.19266049563884735,
-0.225884810090065,
-0.9111512303352356,
1.000671625137329,
0.4843059182167053,
-0.8385570645332336,
-0.2741091549396515,
-0.2854302227497101,
0.10104231536388397,
-0.41431111097335815,
0.6253140568733215,
0.6655972003936768,
0.382690966129303,
0.640820324420929,
-0.26935550570487976,
0.22791825234889984,
-0.25934579968452454,
-0.017825478687882423,
0.38074567914009094,
-0.2572260797023773,
0.6323994398117065,
-0.6303970813751221,
-0.5187237858772278,
-0.037804342806339264,
0.8302785754203796,
0.732576847076416,
0.16634149849414825,
0.476330429315567,
0.9350391030311584,
0.9823945760726929,
-0.3892177641391754,
1.3957575559616089,
-0.7383497357368469,
-0.07132375985383987,
1.1510361433029175,
-0.14342403411865234,
0.7000049948692322,
0.5249315500259399,
-0.23308871686458588,
0.46116670966148376,
0.937089741230011,
0.275967538356781,
0.40639761090278625,
0.29083412885665894,
-0.5131175518035889,
-0.7124362587928772,
-0.16026505827903748,
-0.4224186837673187,
0.10932928323745728,
0.6627498269081116,
-0.2211408168077469,
-0.38654571771621704,
-0.47227489948272705,
0.0416247732937336,
-0.17020057141780853,
-0.2519570589065552,
0.29343241453170776,
0.10944540798664093,
-0.999830424785614,
0.3520200550556183,
-0.0013475654413923621,
0.5024056434631348,
-0.6339964866638184,
-0.06554584950208664,
-0.08396176248788834,
0.3127308487892151,
-0.061516258865594864,
-0.4649258553981781,
0.40712547302246094,
-0.051349665969610214,
-0.24912329018115997,
-0.549959659576416,
0.5236278772354126,
0.11456690728664398,
-0.757921576499939,
0.2516062259674072,
0.4888558089733124,
0.027569962665438652,
-0.201169952750206,
-0.6962683200836182,
0.1719437837600708,
-0.20660655200481415,
-0.3164618909358978,
0.028342749923467636,
0.5600616335868835,
-0.4120931327342987,
0.8922079205513,
1.1644163131713867,
0.37816861271858215,
0.324675589799881,
0.010327611118555069,
0.9763323664665222,
-0.8517919778823853,
-0.6344059109687805,
-0.9262328147888184,
-0.042915165424346924,
-0.11393021792173386,
-0.07418257743120193,
0.8715828061103821,
0.8763864636421204,
0.49030801653862,
-0.03737768903374672,
0.8857353329658508,
-0.1377483308315277,
0.18629449605941772,
-0.6416739821434021,
0.38346192240715027,
0.05072478577494621,
0.3012862503528595,
-0.13343365490436554,
-0.8345236778259277,
-0.028390252962708473,
0.3604033589363098,
-0.5169631838798523,
-0.06270693242549896,
1.0142643451690674,
0.6753312945365906,
-0.11095873266458511,
0.3423266112804413,
0.2383268028497696,
0.32860541343688965,
0.4536004364490509,
0.9595048427581787,
0.8940767049789429,
-0.09862418472766876,
0.2942400872707367,
-0.30460381507873535,
-0.3222690224647522,
0.12512807548046112,
-1.3165267705917358,
-0.7076759934425354,
-0.13939109444618225,
-0.16454938054084778,
-0.2512528896331787,
0.4856836199760437,
0.799838125705719,
0.9454300999641418,
-0.7386180758476257,
-0.26679202914237976,
-0.7245403528213501,
0.14715005457401276,
-0.4881720244884491,
-0.24925808608531952,
0.3429218828678131,
-0.4239014685153961,
-0.3898908793926239,
0.8823358416557312,
0.5721479058265686,
-0.3180130124092102,
-0.2567455768585205,
-0.00919415708631277,
-0.2968839406967163,
0.12655554711818695,
0.4717322587966919,
0.3726537227630615,
-0.8538985252380371,
0.01900460198521614,
0.10279472172260284,
0.102076955139637,
-0.19711224734783173,
1.228667974472046,
-1.2459020614624023,
0.6224774718284607,
0.5732289552688599,
0.7885022163391113,
0.7922454476356506,
0.11318640410900116,
0.8153795003890991,
-0.3493516743183136,
0.48505955934524536,
0.3608808219432831,
0.4528992772102356,
0.1576339304447174,
-0.49921590089797974,
0.4545639157295227,
0.6376912593841553,
-0.1488189548254013,
-0.6431050300598145,
0.15004022419452667,
-0.8734222054481506,
-0.3165803551673889,
1.1170490980148315,
-0.0044460659846663475,
-0.2974911332130432,
0.22494904696941376,
0.0910080075263977,
0.12501509487628937,
-0.430466890335083,
0.5080727338790894,
0.5604223608970642,
-0.19172537326812744,
-0.3475258946418762,
-0.6537054181098938,
0.6244342923164368,
0.23522712290287018,
-0.8263759016990662,
0.256724089384079,
0.3774378001689911,
-0.06791074573993683,
-0.056311629712581635,
0.9317183494567871,
0.16752131283283234,
0.092621810734272,
0.5185510516166687,
-0.14151844382286072,
-0.2823963165283203,
-0.44235724210739136,
0.3788124620914459,
0.34641292691230774,
0.07976461201906204,
-0.14278392493724823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18192v2 | Methodology of Adapting Large English Language Models for Specific Cultural Contexts | 2024-06-26T09:16:08 | 2024-06-27T02:17:19 | Wenjing Zhang, Siqi Xiao, Xuejiao Lei, Ning Wang, Huazheng Zhang, Meijuan An, Bikun Yang, Zhaoxiang Liu, Kai Wang, Shiguo Lian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid growth of large language models(LLMs) has emerged as a prominent
trend in the field of artificial intelligence. However, current
state-of-the-art LLMs are predominantly based on English. They encounter
limitations when directly applied to tasks in specific cultural domains, due to
deficiencies in domain-specific knowledge and misunderstandings caused by
differences in cultural values. To address this challenge, our paper proposes a
rapid adaptation method for large models in specific cultural contexts, which
leverages instruction-tuning based on specific cultural knowledge and safety
values data. Taking Chinese as the specific cultural context and utilizing the
LLaMA3-8B as the experimental English LLM, the evaluation results demonstrate
that the adapted LLM significantly enhances its capabilities in domain-specific
knowledge and adaptability to safety values, while maintaining its original
expertise advantages. | [
0.053555674850940704,
-0.7291379570960999,
0.4028075039386749,
0.38277626037597656,
-0.1116354763507843,
0.04926391690969467,
-0.5911029577255249,
-0.38824018836021423,
-0.03479484096169472,
0.43631523847579956,
-0.4258373975753784,
-0.48441869020462036,
-0.33483070135116577,
0.2177739292383194,
-0.061788592487573624,
0.8505700826644897,
-0.2884913682937622,
0.15661853551864624,
0.20093655586242676,
-0.19975726306438446,
-0.5868816375732422,
-0.4060463309288025,
-0.7122514247894287,
-0.044887181371450424,
0.30882540345191956,
0.5753543972969055,
0.6174923777580261,
0.8621536493301392,
0.481131374835968,
0.30576270818710327,
-0.06599794328212738,
0.282332181930542,
-0.5155261754989624,
-0.17565998435020447,
-0.4857955873012543,
-0.478792279958725,
-0.5617100596427917,
-0.1349489986896515,
0.6941426396369934,
0.5126000046730042,
-0.07861741632223129,
0.20481286942958832,
0.07925944775342941,
0.2463064193725586,
-0.566689670085907,
0.17957758903503418,
-0.8761069178581238,
0.14664901793003082,
0.09317410737276077,
-0.5131970047950745,
-0.6700727939605713,
-0.2796715497970581,
0.1752178966999054,
-0.8508148193359375,
-0.25960060954093933,
0.09325369447469711,
0.5261586308479309,
0.2604944109916687,
-0.583405077457428,
-0.28426671028137207,
-0.803855836391449,
1.033055067062378,
-0.7484629154205322,
0.22437848150730133,
0.2941521406173706,
0.30865973234176636,
-0.33335939049720764,
-0.4454525113105774,
-0.4473986327648163,
-0.2735612094402313,
0.07517792284488678,
-0.0383862666785717,
0.4008168578147888,
-0.28521716594696045,
0.09318467229604721,
-0.2660765051841736,
-0.3995268940925598,
0.6334251761436462,
-0.3007168769836426,
-0.11103521287441254,
1.0034022331237793,
0.4044528901576996,
0.5018990635871887,
0.12739787995815277,
-0.2612956464290619,
-0.15110518038272858,
-0.7225114703178406,
0.14715726673603058,
-0.1504778414964676,
0.40138715505599976,
-0.4769788980484009,
-0.1479748785495758,
-0.18993210792541504,
0.5685672163963318,
-0.007428831420838833,
-0.8149266839027405,
0.332349956035614,
-0.1088603138923645,
-0.1284780353307724,
0.14775286614894867,
0.43259432911872864,
0.4813408851623535,
0.5713402032852173,
0.027920501306653023,
-0.12555010616779327,
-0.4020521938800812,
0.017339935526251793,
-0.8030970096588135,
0.0215659998357296,
0.01596980169415474,
-0.4080049395561218,
-0.09408963471651077,
-0.33683642745018005,
-0.47951677441596985,
-0.4893287718296051,
-0.26175326108932495,
0.5420776605606079,
-0.3629605174064636,
-0.163330540060997,
0.09292715042829514,
0.22177015244960785,
0.6559799909591675,
0.36709272861480713,
-0.8967783451080322,
-0.15077456831932068,
0.4092426002025604,
0.7445391416549683,
-0.3382417559623718,
-0.4954146146774292,
-0.34763288497924805,
0.48892340064048767,
-0.6355012655258179,
0.5498161911964417,
-0.5813239812850952,
-0.40701302886009216,
0.04382358863949776,
0.4797361493110657,
0.023694923147559166,
-0.36749759316444397,
0.5182471871376038,
-0.6226691603660583,
0.022105345502495766,
-0.19259066879749298,
-0.14512771368026733,
-0.3656724691390991,
0.25170502066612244,
-0.40560632944107056,
0.6719335913658142,
-0.05821543186903,
-0.458391398191452,
0.3068394064903259,
-0.7766249179840088,
-0.9545927047729492,
0.17364023625850677,
0.015897901728749275,
-0.12115716189146042,
-0.16070668399333954,
0.31574714183807373,
0.6352868676185608,
-0.3388247489929199,
0.1465785801410675,
-0.22625696659088135,
-0.6224219799041748,
0.07362587004899979,
-0.41032081842422485,
0.9966766238212585,
0.1835786998271942,
-0.33674347400665283,
0.21299517154693604,
-0.7848313450813293,
0.11826317012310028,
0.36222919821739197,
-0.4558830261230469,
-0.5276316404342651,
0.3015381693840027,
-0.15964792668819427,
0.16176001727581024,
0.3638925850391388,
-0.03758792579174042,
0.02652609348297119,
-0.2543466091156006,
0.5973079800605774,
1.0047430992126465,
-0.07582173496484756,
0.4937986135482788,
-0.3595598340034485,
0.5154976844787598,
0.04343818128108978,
0.12939637899398804,
-0.2598020136356354,
-0.09272035956382751,
-0.8677725791931152,
-0.19968754053115845,
0.07397707551717758,
1.071601390838623,
-0.8544588685035706,
0.4600358009338379,
-0.2838759422302246,
-0.4221402108669281,
-0.4479220509529114,
0.28148171305656433,
0.10428162664175034,
0.43112102150917053,
0.19676952064037323,
-0.2841528058052063,
-0.41879382729530334,
-0.7067892551422119,
-0.1630948781967163,
-0.2038957178592682,
-0.18208545446395874,
0.34784314036369324,
0.3468623161315918,
-0.19096508622169495,
0.4865642488002777,
-0.28627723455429077,
-0.009058075025677681,
-0.11535918712615967,
-0.1949092000722885,
0.26187360286712646,
0.4207567572593689,
0.6387491226196289,
-0.6134185791015625,
-0.5762768983840942,
0.2834119200706482,
-0.8829621076583862,
-0.06582506000995636,
-0.27027860283851624,
-0.42219534516334534,
0.3673100769519806,
0.5048267841339111,
-0.011625107377767563,
0.10098188370466232,
0.6617072820663452,
-0.265510618686676,
0.4115062654018402,
-0.2607133984565735,
0.270356684923172,
-1.3453730344772339,
-0.19289110600948334,
0.053417596966028214,
-0.060296110808849335,
-0.7060949802398682,
0.24586497247219086,
0.3597797453403473,
0.08005225658416748,
-0.8041033148765564,
0.7420180439949036,
-0.4009421765804291,
0.16670866310596466,
-0.3315284550189972,
0.05845976993441582,
-0.17703156173229218,
0.34007808566093445,
0.3825482130050659,
0.8078427910804749,
0.6278949975967407,
-0.8638259172439575,
0.214263454079628,
0.17588727176189423,
-0.4320489168167114,
0.5344874262809753,
-0.3929622769355774,
0.2878287136554718,
-0.19147837162017822,
0.17076365649700165,
-0.4786565899848938,
-0.4360925853252411,
-0.09563338756561279,
0.10202905535697937,
0.1473791003227234,
-0.01915791630744934,
-0.15171295404434204,
-0.12787337601184845,
-0.17113810777664185,
0.3150944113731384,
0.8128483891487122,
-0.6232218146324158,
0.8340253233909607,
0.221035897731781,
-0.5126283168792725,
-0.5078529119491577,
-0.5370650887489319,
0.04209688678383827,
-0.6051680445671082,
-0.7453058958053589,
0.3180617094039917,
-0.3719831705093384,
-0.34634000062942505,
-0.3634829521179199,
0.053859222680330276,
-0.08326160162687302,
0.48588287830352783,
-0.05167832225561142,
0.24541075527668,
-0.5094760656356812,
-0.032777413725852966,
0.17601290345191956,
0.19628524780273438,
0.12104003876447678,
-0.02008100040256977,
0.21032990515232086,
0.03954368829727173,
0.05412859842181206,
-0.47109276056289673,
0.31331104040145874,
0.6829312443733215,
-0.33260348439216614,
0.9186736941337585,
0.4471341073513031,
-0.3526681661605835,
-0.7584555149078369,
-0.2869667112827301,
-0.3367466330528259,
-0.5909115672111511,
0.8556749820709229,
-0.41265085339546204,
-0.8408994078636169,
0.45349422097206116,
-0.20425936579704285,
0.23873774707317352,
0.11600547283887863,
0.785697877407074,
-0.05866812542080879,
0.944018542766571,
0.8888639807701111,
-0.33262112736701965,
0.5067446827888489,
0.2617633640766144,
0.2885611951351166,
-0.5517979264259338,
-0.12521962821483612,
-0.47328057885169983,
-0.38586074113845825,
-0.5976404547691345,
-0.48466700315475464,
0.6624931693077087,
-0.15672026574611664,
-0.6881882548332214,
0.04147444665431976,
-0.1459573358297348,
0.567074179649353,
0.1926669478416443,
0.06132907420396805,
0.2243320643901825,
0.038145773112773895,
0.09736395627260208,
0.14635321497917175,
-0.7647514343261719,
-0.6052491068840027,
0.9871035814285278,
0.4386652112007141,
0.7753073573112488,
0.2666131258010864,
0.1661229282617569,
0.24612852931022644,
0.5769607424736023,
-0.7202141880989075,
0.5893220901489258,
-0.36996006965637207,
-0.3964928388595581,
-0.24563975632190704,
-0.28702422976493835,
-0.5991612076759338,
0.07681656628847122,
-0.28304117918014526,
-0.6148144006729126,
-0.31220677495002747,
-0.0011403209064155817,
-0.3991904854774475,
0.1357174664735794,
-0.8428052067756653,
0.6966578960418701,
-0.739039957523346,
-0.14204064011573792,
-0.15918812155723572,
-0.42704835534095764,
0.45022302865982056,
-0.6378428339958191,
0.6936572790145874,
-0.31051337718963623,
-0.10965824127197266,
0.813564121723175,
0.10316705703735352,
0.9690703749656677,
-0.15453623235225677,
-0.3505551517009735,
0.1419249176979065,
0.19663026928901672,
0.711086094379425,
-0.1142580583691597,
-0.4600332975387573,
0.1405627578496933,
-0.0363147035241127,
-0.5169382095336914,
-0.5218669176101685,
0.7896058559417725,
-1.1066137552261353,
-1.0275441408157349,
-0.027976019307971,
-1.1247750520706177,
-0.5059027075767517,
0.16403676569461823,
-0.21255096793174744,
-0.043581146746873856,
-0.09338845312595367,
0.11287330836057663,
0.5003690719604492,
-0.7131421566009521,
0.6439611315727234,
1.0642606019973755,
0.056184642016887665,
-0.03758510574698448,
0.6848933696746826,
0.09751254320144653,
0.288586288690567,
0.30622032284736633,
0.31224650144577026,
0.09552637487649918,
-0.6435440182685852,
-0.5370597839355469,
0.15385104715824127,
-0.8892828822135925,
0.0008025954011827707,
-0.1967683583498001,
-0.2806701362133026,
-0.3004130423069,
-0.5928288102149963,
-0.10739728063344955,
-0.04866756871342659,
-0.28966113924980164,
-0.044211577624082565,
0.6445041298866272,
0.42095035314559937,
0.3782469928264618,
0.26167866587638855,
-0.7878096103668213,
0.06616279482841492,
0.18795454502105713,
0.2577625811100006,
-0.040530696511268616,
-1.1821783781051636,
-0.5255352258682251,
-0.12016449123620987,
-0.03747550770640373,
-0.6359437108039856,
0.3590007424354553,
0.35370567440986633,
0.6027392745018005,
0.3494422137737274,
0.2814124822616577,
0.6850248575210571,
-0.7503294348716736,
0.78789883852005,
-0.23064421117305756,
-0.9018452167510986,
0.4770015776157379,
-0.2563198208808899,
0.29137077927589417,
0.13712772727012634,
0.7513524293899536,
-0.48692625761032104,
-0.03372075408697128,
0.10214122384786606,
-0.861088216304779,
0.6221984624862671,
-0.44074389338493347,
0.5454680323600769,
0.1512114703655243,
0.497116357088089,
0.12243194878101349,
-0.3784373700618744,
-0.7732933163642883,
0.16303640604019165,
-0.07134582102298737,
-0.437339186668396,
-0.08704067766666412,
-0.0033560404554009438,
-0.1911163330078125,
-0.1805328130722046,
0.8976266384124756,
-0.5076006054878235,
-0.1795906126499176,
-0.23102575540542603,
-0.4037748873233795,
-0.017641333863139153,
0.39421984553337097,
0.585413932800293,
0.7943090796470642,
0.08793677389621735,
-0.09741831570863724,
0.9668207764625549,
-0.437542587518692,
0.43844032287597656,
-0.18976444005966187,
-0.24604390561580658,
-0.6202782392501831,
0.4557579755783081,
0.7190515398979187,
0.08360236138105392,
-0.9254933595657349,
0.1023375540971756,
0.1678173542022705,
0.11029300838708878,
-0.4682803750038147,
0.42612868547439575,
0.09133707731962204,
0.36443892121315,
0.4551945924758911,
-0.5333883762359619,
-0.29686740040779114,
-0.6928901672363281,
0.016851097345352173,
0.2588416635990143,
-0.0724397599697113,
-0.24822862446308136,
0.584634006023407,
0.5945451855659485,
-0.4206525981426239,
0.42651695013046265,
-0.014530735090374947,
-0.3110642433166504,
0.8028753399848938,
0.9272705912590027,
0.658656120300293,
-0.5981224775314331,
-0.05884827673435211,
0.31913554668426514,
0.46800777316093445,
-0.07581713795661926,
0.3317376673221588,
0.5154741406440735,
-1.0689364671707153,
-0.810123085975647,
-0.5286176204681396,
-0.2820128798484802,
0.2423575222492218,
-0.5029023885726929,
0.429890513420105,
-0.8379709720611572,
0.22513705492019653,
-0.2954685389995575,
-0.16969236731529236,
-0.7177976965904236,
0.45261070132255554,
0.22059820592403412,
1.1710984706878662,
-0.9784443378448486,
1.0893831253051758,
0.8516709804534912,
0.1753201186656952,
-1.0552821159362793,
0.19917838275432587,
0.1540786176919937,
-1.027941107749939,
0.6179517507553101,
-0.11088993400335312,
-0.14801043272018433,
-0.03414786234498024,
-0.46967795491218567,
-1.047891616821289,
1.3523122072219849,
0.4475073516368866,
-0.7666779160499573,
0.12083760648965836,
0.0005238499725237489,
0.5142858028411865,
-0.6999146342277527,
0.05209265276789665,
0.9527067542076111,
0.3835547864437103,
-0.22605134546756744,
-1.1450155973434448,
0.23552903532981873,
-0.18436512351036072,
0.17649070918560028,
-0.14494529366493225,
-0.9506970643997192,
0.4962858557701111,
-0.28828004002571106,
0.08802223950624466,
0.00685183284804225,
0.7373806238174438,
0.3654475808143616,
0.044127725064754486,
0.6376500725746155,
0.009285255335271358,
0.8304147720336914,
0.19004662334918976,
0.8867703676223755,
-0.5761539936065674,
-0.17471688985824585,
0.8732205033302307,
-0.6913993954658508,
0.9843445420265198,
0.17216967046260834,
0.056574974209070206,
0.6167323589324951,
0.5262603163719177,
0.13138094544410706,
0.4395628273487091,
0.05486876517534256,
-0.25318074226379395,
-0.25077515840530396,
-0.31401199102401733,
-0.2690736949443817,
0.8057168126106262,
0.5258709788322449,
-0.4138341546058655,
0.2992965877056122,
0.005619944538921118,
0.44269710779190063,
0.05221965163946152,
-0.7346447706222534,
0.6173479557037354,
-0.024984311312437057,
-0.6075340509414673,
0.8610087037086487,
0.4629615843296051,
0.6721062064170837,
-0.6010958552360535,
0.13351689279079437,
-0.3758997321128845,
0.08892858028411865,
-0.12447047978639603,
-0.5378761887550354,
0.019079940393567085,
0.26154839992523193,
-0.24209704995155334,
-0.07364223897457123,
0.4673886299133301,
-0.267928808927536,
-0.6596994996070862,
0.3667459189891815,
0.17949555814266205,
0.020629141479730606,
0.5969763398170471,
-0.43877941370010376,
0.25781339406967163,
0.125112384557724,
-0.24887853860855103,
0.42107272148132324,
0.5363726019859314,
-0.5661635398864746,
0.7014508247375488,
0.37888476252555847,
0.013859112747013569,
-0.1334628015756607,
-0.07753363996744156,
0.567318320274353,
-0.954188346862793,
-0.6021556258201599,
-0.6505775451660156,
0.527583122253418,
0.25479620695114136,
-0.09670161455869675,
0.6345504522323608,
-0.007844328880310059,
0.9693061113357544,
-0.1354183554649353,
1.1658531427383423,
0.12988784909248352,
0.21057815849781036,
-0.7975361943244934,
0.8259661197662354,
-0.5692954659461975,
0.4180414378643036,
-0.10087238997220993,
-0.823702335357666,
-0.16394196450710297,
0.7059860825538635,
-0.43523919582366943,
0.1772412657737732,
0.6589927077293396,
0.8579940795898438,
0.016116691753268242,
-0.10459821671247482,
0.41271400451660156,
0.6191357374191284,
0.11030922830104828,
0.8662627935409546,
0.6758041977882385,
-0.027281504124403,
0.46933406591415405,
-0.1419157236814499,
-0.5150486826896667,
-0.17752580344676971,
-1.3393720388412476,
-0.9173778295516968,
-0.30215612053871155,
-0.3809871971607208,
-0.0869780033826828,
0.14750194549560547,
1.1235512495040894,
0.8177727460861206,
-0.9011003375053406,
-0.2611004710197449,
0.8048065900802612,
-0.09190690517425537,
-0.29349660873413086,
-0.19100818037986755,
0.45048248767852783,
-0.18534034490585327,
-0.7702173590660095,
0.738694429397583,
0.2664090096950531,
-0.05300204083323479,
-0.21873505413532257,
-0.33658647537231445,
0.20129802823066711,
0.513862133026123,
0.7880443334579468,
0.2207961231470108,
-0.5519571304321289,
-0.8320138454437256,
-0.03516410291194916,
0.10888087749481201,
-0.1285516917705536,
0.6131689548492432,
-0.4175136983394623,
0.06509456783533096,
0.13658931851387024,
0.8872650265693665,
-0.027523431926965714,
-0.2474175989627838,
0.6382713913917542,
-0.5924946069717407,
0.6283477544784546,
0.00992787815630436,
0.35880357027053833,
0.46952083706855774,
-0.4505574405193329,
0.3779996633529663,
-0.0019187612924724817,
-0.5041487216949463,
-0.6434956192970276,
0.30906426906585693,
-0.7295166254043579,
-0.4363553822040558,
1.3162130117416382,
-0.33679863810539246,
-0.27094995975494385,
-0.015465260483324528,
-0.08541053533554077,
0.12837572395801544,
-0.053789637982845306,
1.0531083345413208,
0.6297539472579956,
0.22481384873390198,
-0.2432425171136856,
-0.6308653354644775,
0.2914543151855469,
0.5305227637290955,
-1.0264524221420288,
-0.07125505059957504,
0.17747464776039124,
0.6539337635040283,
-0.18384060263633728,
0.27019527554512024,
0.11113934218883514,
0.4024347960948944,
-0.4619998037815094,
0.08431996405124664,
0.1261902004480362,
-0.3756038546562195,
-0.33338773250579834,
0.0755220577120781,
0.48479974269866943,
0.28224191069602966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18187v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18187v1 | Selective Prompting Tuning for Personalized Conversations with LLMs | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | 2024-06-26T09:03:52 | Qiushi Huang, Xubo Liu, Tom Ko, Bo Wu, Wenwu Wang, Yu Zhang, Lilian Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In conversational AI, personalizing dialogues with persona profiles and
contextual understanding is essential. Despite large language models' (LLMs)
improved response coherence, effective persona integration remains a challenge.
In this work, we first study two common approaches for personalizing LLMs:
textual prompting and direct fine-tuning. We observed that textual prompting
often struggles to yield responses that are similar to the ground truths in
datasets, while direct fine-tuning tends to produce repetitive or overly
generic replies. To alleviate those issues, we propose \textbf{S}elective
\textbf{P}rompt \textbf{T}uning (SPT), which softly prompts LLMs for
personalized conversations in a selective way. Concretely, SPT initializes a
set of soft prompts and uses a trainable dense retriever to adaptively select
suitable soft prompts for LLMs according to different input contexts, where the
prompt retriever is dynamically updated through feedback from the LLMs.
Additionally, we propose context-prompt contrastive learning and prompt fusion
learning to encourage the SPT to enhance the diversity of personalized
conversations. Experiments on the CONVAI2 dataset demonstrate that SPT
significantly enhances response diversity by up to 90\%, along with
improvements in other critical performance indicators. Those results highlight
the efficacy of SPT in fostering engaging and personalized dialogue generation.
The SPT model code (https://github.com/hqsiswiliam/SPT) is publicly available
for further exploration. | [
-0.5343390703201294,
-1.0442464351654053,
0.6038658618927002,
0.3038439154624939,
-0.2940691411495209,
0.26065874099731445,
-0.5109555125236511,
0.0018537841970100999,
0.036261409521102905,
0.4517834782600403,
-0.9675542712211609,
-0.40648153424263,
-0.14198201894760132,
0.17084194719791412,
0.09014646708965302,
1.1190855503082275,
0.289270281791687,
0.13075412809848785,
-0.14889320731163025,
-0.14927981793880463,
-1.1172373294830322,
-0.1437893956899643,
-0.8422458171844482,
-0.40763211250305176,
0.7647799849510193,
0.7737223505973816,
0.450512558221817,
0.354452908039093,
0.13825026154518127,
0.31729361414909363,
-0.13475371897220612,
0.5539913177490234,
-0.6589041352272034,
0.6235082149505615,
-0.37507155537605286,
-0.33069294691085815,
-0.16436989605426788,
-0.28489166498184204,
0.4887706935405731,
0.7147718071937561,
-0.0392492339015007,
-0.1846308559179306,
0.44627588987350464,
0.4949142336845398,
-0.46685540676116943,
0.019103987142443657,
-0.6826485991477966,
0.05681518092751503,
-0.08221910893917084,
-0.450687438249588,
-0.5983994603157043,
-0.28478357195854187,
0.5183970928192139,
-0.5355844497680664,
0.1160660833120346,
-0.030065838247537613,
0.5037639141082764,
0.3880932331085205,
-0.3918215036392212,
-0.32652631402015686,
-0.8287544846534729,
0.7650056481361389,
-0.2665906548500061,
0.12042015790939331,
0.15951164066791534,
0.3638036847114563,
-0.16574712097644806,
-0.5305765867233276,
-0.19570250809192657,
-0.29974913597106934,
-0.06823549419641495,
0.3486674129962921,
-0.10246016830205917,
0.21750731766223907,
0.10087397694587708,
0.3463214933872223,
-0.45771563053131104,
0.39345911145210266,
-0.04587989300489426,
-0.056024886667728424,
0.46177396178245544,
0.48536357283592224,
0.010218932293355465,
0.007719260174781084,
-0.257791131734848,
0.007458731532096863,
-0.5072793960571289,
0.21938206255435944,
0.3336910903453827,
0.4516054689884186,
-0.2495274841785431,
0.4284164309501648,
-0.3609975278377533,
0.6707884073257446,
0.631131649017334,
0.12313348799943924,
-0.056154269725084305,
-0.35060158371925354,
-0.23310810327529907,
-0.2183508425951004,
0.780805230140686,
0.3914947509765625,
0.4603692591190338,
-0.1796262115240097,
0.03831470012664795,
-0.1861661821603775,
0.12904036045074463,
-0.7272014617919922,
-0.3209841549396515,
0.3737269937992096,
-0.28050151467323303,
-0.1655961275100708,
0.004219887312501669,
-0.8291075825691223,
-0.6281049847602844,
-0.4836996793746948,
0.06431960314512253,
-0.5351498126983643,
-0.03870106488466263,
0.07667235285043716,
-0.01311397273093462,
0.21503420174121857,
0.5149884819984436,
-1.038038730621338,
0.07770402729511261,
0.6300978660583496,
0.5977533459663391,
-0.33493340015411377,
-0.1562780886888504,
-0.811802089214325,
0.044732872396707535,
-0.06505411118268967,
1.0082184076309204,
-0.8484730124473572,
-0.6276282072067261,
0.12540236115455627,
-0.18160028755664825,
-0.11865752935409546,
-0.6861938834190369,
0.4808792471885681,
-0.20560480654239655,
0.57868891954422,
-0.47450658679008484,
-0.5075425505638123,
0.09341009706258774,
0.17674702405929565,
-0.15078669786453247,
0.6874852776527405,
0.1363023966550827,
-0.5724666118621826,
0.36404627561569214,
-0.68166583776474,
-0.3410152196884155,
0.39298295974731445,
-0.34831470251083374,
-0.2954356074333191,
0.1889079064130783,
0.3381269872188568,
0.518043577671051,
-0.24884234368801117,
0.5198965668678284,
-0.3019477427005768,
-0.4916558861732483,
0.3906370997428894,
-0.40779373049736023,
0.43880775570869446,
0.3656068444252014,
-0.25929370522499084,
0.6191977858543396,
-0.6588047742843628,
-0.07517247647047043,
0.0006906631169840693,
-0.3007414638996124,
-0.07557065784931183,
-0.05834294110536575,
-0.14906664192676544,
-0.21482495963573456,
0.2942018210887909,
-0.33321622014045715,
0.13972477614879608,
-0.5444757342338562,
0.3710995614528656,
0.9677852988243103,
0.26155373454093933,
0.6165415048599243,
-0.5547135472297668,
0.3101394474506378,
0.20804724097251892,
-0.06952375918626785,
-0.6936793327331543,
-0.4703086316585541,
-0.7366182804107666,
-0.4003756046295166,
0.05626155063509941,
0.7639095187187195,
-0.6975595951080322,
0.7329960465431213,
-0.10818210989236832,
-0.27967390418052673,
-0.4873121976852417,
0.13955803215503693,
0.35750487446784973,
0.6821746230125427,
0.22952771186828613,
-0.1412225216627121,
-0.48881399631500244,
-0.8896951675415039,
-0.4809110164642334,
0.015936443582177162,
-0.38208693265914917,
0.8775479793548584,
0.0006594034493900836,
-0.19567425549030304,
1.2790625095367432,
-0.47464272379875183,
-0.020095013082027435,
-0.3716295659542084,
0.11992480605840683,
0.1223621740937233,
0.393690288066864,
0.2048095166683197,
-0.6750637888908386,
-0.7999879121780396,
-0.08752667158842087,
-0.5398771166801453,
-0.3950001895427704,
-0.439593106508255,
-0.07522231340408325,
-0.1399194747209549,
0.13286778330802917,
-0.47415030002593994,
0.13746102154254913,
0.13121917843818665,
-0.2716399133205414,
0.20323961973190308,
-0.19576804339885712,
0.14262688159942627,
-1.3175933361053467,
-0.07546426355838776,
0.13249652087688446,
-0.22184322774410248,
-0.7839038372039795,
-0.2090304046869278,
-0.21188868582248688,
-0.15084922313690186,
-0.4490911662578583,
0.7135465741157532,
-0.26049354672431946,
0.16212628781795502,
-0.18977688252925873,
0.13874395191669464,
-0.12618112564086914,
0.6495285034179688,
0.032192133367061615,
0.8849204182624817,
0.4861973226070404,
-0.8194366097450256,
0.2962915301322937,
0.6768274307250977,
-0.19662605226039886,
0.9366583228111267,
-0.909741997718811,
0.5107842683792114,
-0.3015829026699066,
0.4609525203704834,
-1.1558455228805542,
-0.3689647614955902,
0.3827710747718811,
-0.19305989146232605,
0.13927389681339264,
0.011915121227502823,
-0.2494029551744461,
0.1033378541469574,
-0.3006506562232971,
0.1299903690814972,
0.4752606451511383,
-0.7801663279533386,
0.6054818630218506,
0.08646949380636215,
-0.4465881288051605,
-0.10832574963569641,
-0.33822888135910034,
0.02912496216595173,
-0.3874197006225586,
-0.843829870223999,
0.32320690155029297,
-0.6658103466033936,
-0.18655768036842346,
-0.6173090934753418,
0.13997609913349152,
0.17192767560482025,
0.06678950786590576,
0.22512643039226532,
0.0924886018037796,
-0.06652918457984924,
-0.05121766775846481,
0.37311527132987976,
-0.23375998437404633,
-0.35787567496299744,
-0.11939779669046402,
0.8667455911636353,
-0.1257188320159912,
-0.16168582439422607,
-0.8188958168029785,
0.4726129174232483,
0.36439648270606995,
-0.2926132380962372,
0.5787389278411865,
0.6808016300201416,
0.05206838622689247,
-0.034551262855529785,
-0.6278294324874878,
-0.5217456817626953,
-0.53216552734375,
0.1914101392030716,
-0.6044408679008484,
-1.3127551078796387,
0.6217790246009827,
-0.2577829957008362,
0.21410736441612244,
-0.09590983390808105,
0.8334127068519592,
-0.1835794895887375,
1.2540562152862549,
0.3077092170715332,
0.06943877786397934,
0.9006507396697998,
0.08482291549444199,
0.02146274410188198,
-0.8355280756950378,
-0.4170469045639038,
-0.40808916091918945,
-0.4559386372566223,
-0.5780118107795715,
-0.15471415221691132,
0.2772884666919708,
-0.3341052532196045,
-0.4494739770889282,
-0.10613437741994858,
-0.6303372979164124,
0.5948867797851562,
0.581627368927002,
0.3512634038925171,
0.13769645988941193,
0.13420671224594116,
0.10092344135046005,
-0.39162856340408325,
-0.5068556070327759,
-0.2796427607536316,
0.6642749905586243,
0.3902284502983093,
0.8161609768867493,
-0.027831172570586205,
0.7346436381340027,
-0.004864504095166922,
0.00794507097452879,
-0.7684845924377441,
0.5705152750015259,
-0.19276027381420135,
-0.25078946352005005,
-0.05440828576683998,
-0.47408655285835266,
-1.1723806858062744,
0.18088985979557037,
-0.2405238002538681,
-0.9613485932350159,
0.18485037982463837,
0.20588700473308563,
-0.8013913035392761,
-0.2429020255804062,
-0.8271996378898621,
0.6486186981201172,
-0.032867200672626495,
-0.3771955966949463,
-0.13678660988807678,
-0.6911742091178894,
0.13170203566551208,
0.14694152772426605,
-0.38597509264945984,
-0.11747509986162186,
0.03138085827231407,
0.2797408699989319,
-0.021502910181879997,
1.15343177318573,
-0.18695639073848724,
-0.0349070243537426,
0.10303965955972672,
0.18672975897789001,
0.6996716856956482,
0.4247961938381195,
0.015909431502223015,
-0.33791616559028625,
-0.16847190260887146,
-0.35378333926200867,
-0.7115082144737244,
0.7921837568283081,
-0.7282435894012451,
-0.7243155837059021,
-0.11164866387844086,
-0.592614471912384,
-0.48900648951530457,
0.052842386066913605,
0.482070654630661,
0.3634752631187439,
-0.3802524209022522,
0.39928415417671204,
1.1131305694580078,
-0.4845828711986542,
0.18667301535606384,
0.7325502634048462,
0.22922824323177338,
-0.5068202614784241,
0.8446505069732666,
-0.33519038558006287,
0.0944153368473053,
0.4846158027648926,
0.483137309551239,
-0.3238065540790558,
-0.37149447202682495,
-0.34363850951194763,
0.09958352893590927,
-0.4222097098827362,
-0.20085568726062775,
-0.726671576499939,
0.029541103169322014,
-0.39556482434272766,
-0.2950376868247986,
-0.07594578713178635,
0.022535480558872223,
-0.7378432154655457,
0.057911474257707596,
0.37810587882995605,
0.5187424421310425,
0.4528524875640869,
0.6473322510719299,
-0.7387515902519226,
0.21993064880371094,
0.40290382504463196,
0.24371284246444702,
-0.36980435252189636,
-0.6436536312103271,
0.14683963358402252,
0.1362239569425583,
-0.3934191167354584,
-0.7542641758918762,
0.15514661371707916,
0.35006052255630493,
0.44729816913604736,
0.4093310832977295,
0.1265345811843872,
0.6701472997665405,
-0.4629403054714203,
0.8472064733505249,
0.05994585156440735,
-0.6889182329177856,
0.8932303786277771,
-0.7328287363052368,
0.7094498872756958,
0.9387026429176331,
0.09548921883106232,
-0.6213744878768921,
-0.4325677454471588,
-0.46123865246772766,
-0.7055221796035767,
0.7811605930328369,
-0.08559955656528473,
0.5369409322738647,
-0.03599863499403,
0.4837091267108917,
0.3289487659931183,
0.20017977058887482,
-0.4129493832588196,
-0.14755961298942566,
0.053401123732328415,
-0.47617843747138977,
-0.02512882463634014,
-0.2650631368160248,
-0.2958749234676361,
-0.22720570862293243,
0.2483074814081192,
-0.3999375104904175,
0.13158823549747467,
0.06758464127779007,
0.1420704573392868,
-0.07940583676099777,
0.29997435212135315,
0.6460610628128052,
0.43910443782806396,
-0.05579666048288345,
-0.20354411005973816,
0.22415706515312195,
-0.07440977543592453,
-0.1508561372756958,
-0.03138221055269241,
-0.2463439702987671,
-0.12834517657756805,
-0.14214292168617249,
1.1293041706085205,
0.4464254081249237,
-0.49499234557151794,
0.30168387293815613,
-0.38695961236953735,
-0.010119644924998283,
-0.1481836885213852,
0.43309202790260315,
-0.0854841098189354,
0.3235248327255249,
0.12819130718708038,
0.10088713467121124,
0.09854886680841446,
-0.40845534205436707,
-0.00015103128680493683,
0.47070205211639404,
-0.24589888751506805,
-0.2877615690231323,
0.5611208081245422,
0.650776207447052,
-0.6386316418647766,
0.5937084555625916,
0.08772493153810501,
-0.1676664799451828,
0.13376474380493164,
0.460281103849411,
0.9995861053466797,
-0.2942024767398834,
0.38627421855926514,
0.1802547127008438,
-0.2689460813999176,
0.09477923810482025,
0.10876064002513885,
-0.47240203619003296,
-0.6290391087532043,
-0.15119712054729462,
-0.3084820806980133,
-0.5944409966468811,
0.25150638818740845,
-0.506757915019989,
0.4240695834159851,
-0.6674941182136536,
0.04859254136681557,
-0.14937642216682434,
0.09922982007265091,
-0.5976133346557617,
0.01678367517888546,
0.02983742207288742,
0.727065920829773,
-0.6434534788131714,
0.5526409149169922,
0.6924809217453003,
-0.26644906401634216,
-0.6076938509941101,
0.18583902716636658,
0.05035398155450821,
-0.7284253239631653,
0.1633017361164093,
0.14038309454917908,
-0.03854268789291382,
0.1795814037322998,
-0.552873432636261,
-0.43300381302833557,
1.0836912393569946,
0.6351274847984314,
-0.6131139397621155,
0.10826269537210464,
0.06564724445343018,
0.461431622505188,
-0.5982541441917419,
0.3269241154193878,
0.6926641464233398,
0.31566551327705383,
0.4472218453884125,
-0.7628616094589233,
-0.04318273812532425,
-0.10941754281520844,
0.17878644168376923,
0.01739054173231125,
-1.0143803358078003,
0.4771905541419983,
0.020219147205352783,
-0.20780110359191895,
0.4023992121219635,
0.7290263772010803,
0.5780155658721924,
0.49703770875930786,
0.5433277487754822,
0.08646713942289352,
0.9960622787475586,
-0.13143447041511536,
0.8377138376235962,
-0.3545707166194916,
-0.04561501368880272,
1.2008509635925293,
-0.317300945520401,
0.4929707944393158,
0.35177138447761536,
0.1627042293548584,
0.4126923084259033,
0.9319344758987427,
0.07798545062541962,
0.5047279596328735,
-0.030283745378255844,
-0.5869479179382324,
-0.2668621242046356,
-0.3221479058265686,
-0.230470672249794,
0.3687715530395508,
0.3350506126880646,
-0.3110300600528717,
0.05881359800696373,
0.14936420321464539,
-0.054777998477220535,
0.24269117414951324,
-0.06181001663208008,
1.1555650234222412,
0.02622278593480587,
-1.185864806175232,
0.41259992122650146,
-0.18630148470401764,
0.9437079429626465,
-0.6450660228729248,
0.15259985625743866,
-0.6710327863693237,
0.12627890706062317,
-0.15930870175361633,
-0.7510237693786621,
-0.01308406237512827,
0.05358390510082245,
-0.27710357308387756,
-0.543042004108429,
0.6966205835342407,
-0.6757342219352722,
-0.10314162075519562,
0.02350752055644989,
0.45205947756767273,
0.0006640493520535529,
0.030403167009353638,
-0.7875058054924011,
0.07081778347492218,
0.27301186323165894,
-0.20519901812076569,
0.4464679956436157,
0.4144509732723236,
0.1537092626094818,
0.7382736206054688,
0.6172975301742554,
-0.18424582481384277,
-0.3603397309780121,
0.48493874073028564,
0.9380536079406738,
-0.40363791584968567,
-0.6829509139060974,
-0.8190014362335205,
0.7451696395874023,
-0.10071547329425812,
-0.5177221894264221,
0.5982184410095215,
0.38275372982025146,
0.5413652062416077,
-0.06294987350702286,
0.6642465591430664,
0.2971707284450531,
0.5595959424972534,
-0.4509921073913574,
0.3117380440235138,
-0.2405393421649933,
0.51659095287323,
-0.15472203493118286,
-0.9844123125076294,
-0.0626785010099411,
0.5477917194366455,
-0.2798362076282501,
0.2374427169561386,
0.42926469445228577,
0.820311963558197,
-0.05761495977640152,
0.2452237606048584,
0.3829469084739685,
0.047354914247989655,
0.5254457592964172,
0.5381947159767151,
1.0086759328842163,
0.14675237238407135,
0.3974725008010864,
0.03058752417564392,
-0.39177456498146057,
-0.30641970038414,
-0.5765941143035889,
-0.9508045315742493,
-0.6634188294410706,
-0.32158830761909485,
-0.35749536752700806,
0.13120675086975098,
1.143676519393921,
0.6468132734298706,
-0.7491976618766785,
-0.16394804418087006,
-0.20840328931808472,
-0.016528446227312088,
0.24588462710380554,
-0.24873924255371094,
-0.1323108673095703,
-0.5811971426010132,
-0.9243949055671692,
0.5942615270614624,
0.4018445312976837,
0.17091421782970428,
-0.1684299260377884,
-0.22232955694198608,
0.24280042946338654,
0.13760435581207275,
0.4683181643486023,
0.24829673767089844,
-0.6010286211967468,
-0.2786034941673279,
0.1460181623697281,
-0.005758147221058607,
0.20616382360458374,
1.1002521514892578,
-0.7658253312110901,
0.472883403301239,
0.5073612928390503,
0.7047472596168518,
0.44282767176628113,
0.25060006976127625,
0.8896199464797974,
-1.1222498416900635,
0.2483302354812622,
0.42649438977241516,
0.10661040991544724,
0.517501950263977,
-0.6976732015609741,
0.20921412110328674,
0.08354067802429199,
-0.7780674695968628,
-0.7540740370750427,
0.5523009896278381,
-1.1051913499832153,
-0.1671832948923111,
1.17427396774292,
0.00013748327910434455,
0.03833155333995819,
-0.12015076726675034,
-0.7015003561973572,
0.06808707863092422,
-0.7550313472747803,
0.6673424243927002,
0.5658115148544312,
-0.5436630845069885,
-0.437574565410614,
-0.04696919769048691,
0.5736057162284851,
0.8404334187507629,
-0.7317976951599121,
0.05061771720647812,
0.5159316062927246,
0.2735573947429657,
-0.13002176582813263,
0.7822015285491943,
0.3571542501449585,
0.262880802154541,
-0.42255887389183044,
-0.6009491086006165,
0.02451290749013424,
-0.3334161043167114,
-0.5708140730857849,
0.062141302973032,
0.06219791993498802,
-0.09818068146705627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18173v1 | UIO-LLMs: Unbiased Incremental Optimization for Long-Context LLMs | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | 2024-06-26T08:44:36 | Wenhao Li, Mingbao Lin, Yunshan Zhong, Shuicheng Yan, Rongrong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Managing long texts is challenging for large language models (LLMs) due to
limited context window sizes. This study introduces UIO-LLMs, an unbiased
incremental optimization approach for memory-enhanced transformers under
long-context settings. We initially conceptualize the process as a streamlined
encoder-decoder framework where the weights-shared encoder and decoder
respectively encapsulate a context segment into memories and leverage these
memories to predict outputs of the subsequent segment. Subsequently, by
treating our memory-enhanced transformers as fully-connected recurrent neural
networks (RNNs), we refine the training process using the Truncated
Backpropagation Through Time (TBPTT) algorithm, which incorporates innovative
incremental optimization techniques. These techniques not only diminish time
complexity but also address the bias in gradient computation through an
unbiased optimization process. UIO-LLMs successfully handle long context, such
as extending the context window of Llama2-7b-chat from 4K to 100K tokens with
minimal 2% additional parameters, while keeping the inference cost nearly
linear as context length increases. | [
-0.3182048201560974,
-0.5907085537910461,
0.5086519718170166,
0.5534116625785828,
-0.4454019367694855,
0.11497367918491364,
-0.5999048352241516,
-0.21103611588478088,
-0.05214321240782738,
0.6095749735832214,
-0.5562509298324585,
-0.18280558288097382,
-0.3557732105255127,
0.17127814888954163,
-0.18354633450508118,
0.8351500630378723,
-0.03852358087897301,
-0.0763377770781517,
-0.2570382058620453,
-0.13066162168979645,
-0.46193256974220276,
-0.5131738185882568,
-0.6277977228164673,
-0.6184626817703247,
0.32251977920532227,
0.4983624815940857,
0.2563234865665436,
0.45696529746055603,
0.18295003473758698,
0.2783030569553375,
-0.25949180126190186,
0.13177211582660675,
-0.6477959156036377,
0.32189029455184937,
0.018058229237794876,
-0.22610537707805634,
-0.28901052474975586,
-0.3336332142353058,
0.8304919004440308,
0.6684962511062622,
-0.3130400776863098,
0.06693753600120544,
0.22844047844409943,
0.8871774077415466,
-0.6466618776321411,
0.027341585606336594,
-0.7885124087333679,
0.2695736289024353,
0.05577005445957184,
-0.47923651337623596,
-0.5535237789154053,
-0.04111575707793236,
0.19070447981357574,
-0.3406220078468323,
-0.3054618835449219,
0.0021651776041835546,
0.5011770129203796,
0.4471808075904846,
-0.550670862197876,
-0.06558936089277267,
-0.6502094864845276,
1.2717869281768799,
-0.5965063571929932,
0.21238501369953156,
-0.0690983459353447,
-0.007089298218488693,
-0.40272048115730286,
-0.6189536452293396,
-0.36036747694015503,
-0.29383423924446106,
0.07793532311916351,
0.24022021889686584,
-0.12850458920001984,
0.354866623878479,
0.2279125452041626,
0.2526262700557709,
-0.07961093634366989,
0.3660031855106354,
-0.2010839283466339,
-0.1244175061583519,
0.36526569724082947,
0.00324650714173913,
0.029365068301558495,
-0.11656371504068375,
-0.868924617767334,
0.31486770510673523,
-0.47194647789001465,
0.01742640696465969,
0.18542450666427612,
0.032362375408411026,
-0.1469649225473404,
0.49999019503593445,
-0.1071750596165657,
0.4320407211780548,
0.04066772386431694,
-0.18016161024570465,
0.2774447500705719,
-0.16196489334106445,
-0.2584834396839142,
0.17011404037475586,
0.8939714431762695,
0.3021395802497864,
0.3139171004295349,
-0.3954952359199524,
-0.2909146547317505,
-0.21555978059768677,
0.31638601422309875,
-0.84156334400177,
0.4952408969402313,
0.22191694378852844,
-0.2519659399986267,
-0.2682758569717407,
-0.2840186059474945,
-0.7828112244606018,
0.09466175734996796,
-0.4719509780406952,
0.4242856800556183,
-0.29595860838890076,
-0.026431815698742867,
0.03219350054860115,
-0.013759375549852848,
0.033869627863168716,
0.32196295261383057,
-0.769336462020874,
0.09453374147415161,
0.44714900851249695,
0.8253340721130371,
-0.5648946762084961,
-0.2963133156299591,
-0.506381630897522,
0.31905651092529297,
-0.2582286596298218,
0.533055305480957,
-0.34917742013931274,
-0.5669685006141663,
-0.0808718353509903,
-0.1555282026529312,
0.01705051399767399,
-0.35707995295524597,
0.5444585680961609,
-0.5170696973800659,
0.18064238131046295,
0.29930901527404785,
-0.5378060340881348,
0.08784516900777817,
0.23577402532100677,
-0.41382136940956116,
1.458374261856079,
0.38913267850875854,
-0.5100756883621216,
0.06720131635665894,
-0.7767273187637329,
-0.5006470084190369,
-0.157081738114357,
-0.1007862314581871,
-0.40229085087776184,
0.39041972160339355,
0.28599199652671814,
0.4953313171863556,
-0.5192338228225708,
0.3688450753688812,
-0.03140968456864357,
-0.5248640179634094,
0.22379817068576813,
-0.6003415584564209,
0.5591658353805542,
0.24924997985363007,
-0.47524407505989075,
0.3027759790420532,
-0.6536381840705872,
-0.024304859340190887,
-0.18883918225765228,
-0.5471649169921875,
-0.4746221601963043,
-0.02507471665740013,
-0.1549016684293747,
-0.0037710070610046387,
0.396040141582489,
-0.6336351037025452,
0.2849597632884979,
-0.39597681164741516,
0.6273033022880554,
0.9767107367515564,
-0.08963445574045181,
0.679258406162262,
0.033257026225328445,
0.2398083359003067,
0.09448100626468658,
0.41650983691215515,
-0.40513595938682556,
-0.14331522583961487,
-0.8115609288215637,
-0.3480735719203949,
0.018754499033093452,
0.4421348571777344,
-0.7071568965911865,
0.7629204392433167,
-0.5330485701560974,
-0.011553224176168442,
-0.2845577895641327,
0.25295498967170715,
0.26980215311050415,
0.7679306864738464,
0.41986939311027527,
-0.44279345870018005,
-0.47691279649734497,
-1.0306601524353027,
-0.026304835453629494,
0.1736140251159668,
-0.2320234328508377,
0.2671148478984833,
0.4386149048805237,
-0.7585064768791199,
0.9694384932518005,
-0.24611255526542664,
-0.4188558757305145,
-0.08991235494613647,
-0.041748885065317154,
0.3489930331707001,
0.3198321461677551,
0.289110392332077,
-0.5822214484214783,
-0.5104047656059265,
0.23074427247047424,
-0.7178585529327393,
-0.13408774137496948,
-0.3037542998790741,
-0.09257484972476959,
0.5122451782226562,
0.6391100287437439,
-0.564087450504303,
0.340857595205307,
0.6254317164421082,
0.08476874232292175,
0.34815850853919983,
-0.30109432339668274,
-0.0449020117521286,
-1.2182172536849976,
-0.15293072164058685,
-0.11712615191936493,
-0.2957990765571594,
-0.3680933713912964,
-0.08504278212785721,
0.1843279004096985,
0.036450937390327454,
-0.368947297334671,
0.6909666061401367,
-0.8694919347763062,
-0.056368011981248856,
-0.4395478069782257,
0.10850852727890015,
-0.053381770849227905,
0.7789129018783569,
0.015553667210042477,
0.8744089603424072,
0.527434229850769,
-0.4757809638977051,
0.24194900691509247,
-0.2162369340658188,
-0.4864671230316162,
0.40315112471580505,
-0.3815832734107971,
0.3120497465133667,
-0.14068159461021423,
0.21793091297149658,
-0.8360440135002136,
0.17354388535022736,
-0.15723071992397308,
-0.2409384846687317,
0.5295795798301697,
-0.16944295167922974,
-0.3903641700744629,
-0.37102147936820984,
-0.5584478974342346,
0.46070048213005066,
0.5741376876831055,
-0.8489039540290833,
0.7978050708770752,
0.3789139986038208,
-0.009860118851065636,
-0.9269628524780273,
-0.46989765763282776,
0.23709902167320251,
-0.2746025323867798,
-0.3930242955684662,
0.40880152583122253,
-0.06620050966739655,
-0.07529233396053314,
-0.263468861579895,
-0.2313394844532013,
0.1243431344628334,
-0.02166730910539627,
0.18565979599952698,
0.13099409639835358,
-0.060362279415130615,
0.10763945430517197,
0.37228429317474365,
-0.2031513750553131,
-0.03587447479367256,
-0.3962860405445099,
0.6513524055480957,
-0.0838603749871254,
-0.07816848158836365,
-0.5502995252609253,
0.4704681932926178,
0.5128177404403687,
0.31059691309928894,
0.6422253251075745,
0.49130070209503174,
-0.09098387509584427,
-0.28502848744392395,
-0.835544228553772,
-0.07279687374830246,
-0.5416858196258545,
0.584943413734436,
-0.38208773732185364,
-1.1422454118728638,
0.36860617995262146,
-0.3313676416873932,
0.09807886928319931,
0.15743395686149597,
0.6425148844718933,
-0.12564922869205475,
0.7638545036315918,
0.4759432077407837,
-0.596867561340332,
0.5522042512893677,
-0.21510858833789825,
-0.009575785137712955,
-1.2681304216384888,
-0.24004678428173065,
-0.15930651128292084,
-0.2699757516384125,
-0.44312071800231934,
-0.6518335938453674,
0.35605427622795105,
0.17998693883419037,
-0.49546411633491516,
0.133756622672081,
-0.6200170516967773,
0.43846970796585083,
0.5317148566246033,
-0.09131339192390442,
0.3779169023036957,
0.3842356204986572,
-0.1170893982052803,
0.08475355058908463,
-0.4478449821472168,
-0.24459965527057648,
1.1054048538208008,
0.45963236689567566,
1.010723352432251,
-0.09539685398340225,
0.5765148401260376,
0.3191176652908325,
0.5352969169616699,
-0.9736510515213013,
0.5812318921089172,
-0.0006480350275523961,
-0.20069915056228638,
-0.4457937479019165,
-0.60517817735672,
-0.9781447649002075,
0.3351956009864807,
0.17468665540218353,
-0.9382339715957642,
-0.061600010842084885,
0.009346574544906616,
-0.030072305351495743,
0.38013604283332825,
-0.5768578052520752,
0.34367305040359497,
-0.37756145000457764,
-0.2807651162147522,
-0.20769312977790833,
-0.6611683964729309,
0.11496992409229279,
-0.09741073101758957,
0.09572476148605347,
-0.0986361876130104,
-0.4624286890029907,
0.5096635818481445,
-0.26394203305244446,
0.6794810891151428,
0.0726078450679779,
-0.19683359563350677,
0.46711525321006775,
-0.27832862734794617,
0.5964842438697815,
0.157561793923378,
-0.23611262440681458,
0.5643805265426636,
-0.2368963062763214,
-0.2558562755584717,
-0.40933069586753845,
0.8915393352508545,
-0.8466621041297913,
-0.6157488226890564,
-0.41341662406921387,
-0.5511615872383118,
-0.24675925076007843,
0.12975925207138062,
0.42322733998298645,
0.26775726675987244,
-0.06173153966665268,
0.6055115461349487,
0.5720381736755371,
-0.15300077199935913,
0.7422944903373718,
0.4049367904663086,
-0.07393858581781387,
-0.5569985508918762,
0.4194999039173126,
-0.18908561766147614,
0.4118717312812805,
0.7490268349647522,
0.2935445010662079,
-0.35818588733673096,
-0.6575266718864441,
-0.4103969931602478,
0.12613731622695923,
-0.5164929628372192,
-0.3433617651462555,
-0.5296471118927002,
-0.28401321172714233,
-0.21766680479049683,
-0.0661894828081131,
-0.5574614405632019,
-0.215110182762146,
-0.45639169216156006,
-0.004688656888902187,
0.3060128390789032,
0.1822204291820526,
0.04705088958144188,
0.6275634765625,
-0.7468597888946533,
0.3501420319080353,
0.23131844401359558,
0.42099490761756897,
0.14119313657283783,
-0.7040938138961792,
-0.328073114156723,
0.09844272583723068,
-0.2270638793706894,
-0.5102844834327698,
0.4229033887386322,
0.10708025097846985,
0.4093242585659027,
0.41424494981765747,
-0.09210482984781265,
0.8111523389816284,
-0.6716158986091614,
0.5713282227516174,
0.5035985708236694,
-0.8287996053695679,
0.40908315777778625,
-0.3457048237323761,
0.430990993976593,
0.5431063771247864,
0.17007599771022797,
-0.41471102833747864,
-0.054364580661058426,
-0.0641699954867363,
-1.1184186935424805,
0.6276232004165649,
0.3127254247665405,
0.5638088583946228,
-0.07662812620401382,
0.7616819143295288,
0.10798442363739014,
0.26005470752716064,
-0.8738752007484436,
-0.41114917397499084,
-0.023650040850043297,
-0.17752045392990112,
0.08081959933042526,
-0.6275674700737,
-0.03542714565992355,
-0.3190405070781708,
0.5232689380645752,
-0.29712429642677307,
0.38147681951522827,
0.09604610502719879,
-0.19267715513706207,
-0.059904132038354874,
0.4995185136795044,
0.5521290898323059,
0.655214250087738,
-0.2012006789445877,
-0.2808285653591156,
0.39691847562789917,
-0.6247884631156921,
0.10476818680763245,
0.04400400072336197,
-0.20040246844291687,
-0.0651426836848259,
0.11718501150608063,
1.040447473526001,
0.5555155277252197,
-0.705447256565094,
0.34691232442855835,
-0.18418438732624054,
0.0038288754876703024,
-0.8084709644317627,
0.025172719731926918,
-0.03188019245862961,
0.23103730380535126,
0.8538872003555298,
-0.23062007129192352,
-0.05511502921581268,
-0.5391244292259216,
0.07708176970481873,
0.5508739948272705,
-0.5402088761329651,
-0.19602467119693756,
0.4189610481262207,
0.37835970520973206,
-0.296186238527298,
0.6603487133979797,
0.2556840777397156,
-0.2794956564903259,
0.5228599309921265,
0.5266106724739075,
0.8811687231063843,
-0.23638343811035156,
-0.1759682148694992,
0.3053077757358551,
0.1648905873298645,
-0.2610473334789276,
0.02390013076364994,
-0.32826054096221924,
-0.773255467414856,
-0.5076987147331238,
-0.7715532779693604,
-0.24588187038898468,
0.3758525550365448,
-0.8294591903686523,
0.1532343029975891,
-0.21463783085346222,
-0.3702940046787262,
-0.5255234241485596,
-0.06117723137140274,
-0.5484902262687683,
0.15533480048179626,
-0.1594032496213913,
0.8470117449760437,
-0.02290135622024536,
1.1196837425231934,
0.21699807047843933,
0.08214167505502701,
-0.3830099105834961,
-0.11800377815961838,
-0.21760523319244385,
-0.979567289352417,
0.4895360767841339,
0.382478803396225,
-0.33022937178611755,
0.23697178065776825,
-0.3263075053691864,
-0.8006578683853149,
1.2269638776779175,
0.2644849717617035,
-0.9862350225448608,
-0.20466111600399017,
0.049670808017253876,
0.4578542411327362,
-0.49260959029197693,
0.134383425116539,
0.6223269701004028,
0.22961023449897766,
0.04931453987956047,
-0.9316637516021729,
-0.16227751970291138,
0.008183397352695465,
0.3506576716899872,
0.465178906917572,
-0.6965988278388977,
0.5570975542068481,
-0.4214574992656708,
-0.19204531610012054,
0.37287187576293945,
0.8709127306938171,
0.1463535726070404,
0.17840443551540375,
0.5928866863250732,
0.5442959070205688,
0.28663963079452515,
0.01751822791993618,
1.1293619871139526,
-0.27648794651031494,
0.381991982460022,
1.2023996114730835,
-0.1616298109292984,
0.7805876731872559,
0.9335993528366089,
-0.03174241632223129,
0.5106020569801331,
0.4771714508533478,
0.21880704164505005,
0.5053873658180237,
0.14250439405441284,
-0.5229841470718384,
-0.005429587326943874,
-0.10222695767879486,
-0.37166762351989746,
0.351420521736145,
0.37981241941452026,
-0.4565035402774811,
0.024425135925412178,
0.15532146394252777,
0.041791122406721115,
-0.06324820965528488,
-0.4086865782737732,
0.8268164992332458,
0.43012163043022156,
-0.7981733679771423,
0.4542255699634552,
-0.03496953472495079,
1.129082202911377,
-0.7625285387039185,
0.320089191198349,
-0.39531025290489197,
0.3877621293067932,
0.09044671058654785,
-0.7550714612007141,
-0.05514343082904816,
-0.08655469119548798,
-0.08669489622116089,
-0.3372328281402588,
0.5741634964942932,
-0.48290425539016724,
-0.40242546796798706,
0.7259302139282227,
0.2074376493692398,
-0.12356523424386978,
-0.19859273731708527,
-0.539954423904419,
0.11830177158117294,
-0.011710540391504765,
-0.6275389194488525,
0.5651443004608154,
0.40556642413139343,
-0.08151117712259293,
0.890673816204071,
0.6112082004547119,
0.059517327696084976,
-0.19068527221679688,
0.3918173909187317,
0.7497453093528748,
-0.8363099694252014,
-0.3836687505245209,
-1.0883842706680298,
0.5354316234588623,
-0.21720096468925476,
-0.22017362713813782,
0.7211576104164124,
0.6819629073143005,
0.705854594707489,
-0.03811641409993172,
0.6535336375236511,
0.43630531430244446,
0.35546085238456726,
-0.5912485718727112,
0.4973945915699005,
-0.6598423719406128,
0.41929376125335693,
-0.047628968954086304,
-1.0666195154190063,
0.029891448095440865,
0.4051584303379059,
-0.03416404128074646,
0.02536381408572197,
0.4855654537677765,
0.5323268175125122,
0.09887312352657318,
-0.24254319071769714,
0.31129640340805054,
0.08036293089389801,
0.19983439147472382,
0.6862604022026062,
0.829872727394104,
-0.36216387152671814,
0.6633625030517578,
-0.4126485288143158,
-0.3010254502296448,
-0.18675044178962708,
-1.1514488458633423,
-1.0411185026168823,
-0.45249664783477783,
-0.16756950318813324,
-0.09157922863960266,
-0.06690838932991028,
0.8232039213180542,
0.5710968971252441,
-0.46751275658607483,
-0.5159531235694885,
0.10430556535720825,
0.15378032624721527,
0.07106012850999832,
-0.2643648087978363,
0.31298333406448364,
-0.45095428824424744,
-0.8955652117729187,
0.45148831605911255,
0.7886297702789307,
-0.02448914386332035,
-0.3073713779449463,
-0.16855187714099884,
-0.00838503148406744,
0.06011677905917168,
1.1405291557312012,
0.26340124011039734,
-0.656791090965271,
-0.26598137617111206,
-0.03762879967689514,
-0.07082246243953705,
0.3854220509529114,
0.7689969539642334,
-0.7955265641212463,
0.5027424693107605,
0.2507954239845276,
0.5763344168663025,
0.7463786602020264,
0.10912889242172241,
0.6148105263710022,
-1.0021378993988037,
0.524081289768219,
0.2912920117378235,
0.45116323232650757,
0.28730231523513794,
-0.4126536250114441,
0.6202012896537781,
-0.06978986412286758,
-0.5238373875617981,
-1.009697437286377,
0.051694974303245544,
-1.154227614402771,
-0.3642471432685852,
1.3499051332473755,
0.16883313655853271,
-0.23853404819965363,
-0.06659440696239471,
-0.10145466029644012,
0.07248496264219284,
-0.6528745293617249,
0.9083130955696106,
0.38447636365890503,
-0.19330047070980072,
-0.30305686593055725,
-0.38902661204338074,
0.3261461555957794,
0.3065093755722046,
-0.8493884801864624,
-0.13531480729579926,
0.31116896867752075,
0.28852924704551697,
0.0500771701335907,
0.7586227059364319,
-0.13139961659908295,
0.009066658094525337,
-0.4844777286052704,
-0.03531099483370781,
-0.08539949357509613,
-0.20011502504348755,
-0.17759057879447937,
-0.051118675619363785,
-0.2593408524990082,
-0.16808933019638062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18164v1 | NeBuLa: A discourse aware Minecraft Builder | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | 2024-06-26T08:24:44 | Akshay Chaturvedi, Kate Thompson, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | When engaging in collaborative tasks, humans efficiently exploit the semantic
structure of a conversation to optimize verbal and nonverbal interactions. But
in recent "language to code" or "language to action" models, this information
is lacking. We show how incorporating the prior discourse and nonlinguistic
context of a conversation situated in a nonlinguistic environment can improve
the "language to action" component of such interactions. We fine tune an LLM to
predict actions based on prior context; our model, NeBuLa, doubles the
net-action F1 score over the baseline on this task of Jayannavar et al.(2020).
We also investigate our model's ability to construct shapes and understand
location descriptions using a synthetic dataset. | [
-0.01692858710885048,
-1.132228136062622,
0.6815222501754761,
0.19386321306228638,
0.2158152312040329,
0.13876424729824066,
0.1160835400223732,
-0.5343371629714966,
0.7282562255859375,
0.49547889828681946,
-0.44843873381614685,
-0.464257150888443,
-0.43741467595100403,
-0.2222711741924286,
-0.5478460192680359,
0.5762989521026611,
0.17473378777503967,
-0.44583505392074585,
-0.3669447600841522,
0.09853847324848175,
-0.5044963955879211,
-0.4422413110733032,
-0.877858579158783,
-0.1723201423883438,
0.42996639013290405,
0.2968357503414154,
0.8390029072761536,
0.6420242786407471,
0.38120225071907043,
0.5005875825881958,
-0.16483090817928314,
0.1148071140050888,
-0.7171398401260376,
0.05456439033150673,
-0.5118365287780762,
-0.43842536211013794,
-0.49058273434638977,
-0.07897444069385529,
0.5731253027915955,
0.7934030294418335,
0.037733227014541626,
0.26816487312316895,
0.038823749870061874,
0.18328794836997986,
-0.5067834854125977,
0.30643194913864136,
-0.46250537037849426,
0.3597484529018402,
-0.009144304320216179,
-0.31284022331237793,
-0.4846300780773163,
0.06578563898801804,
0.06595917791128159,
-0.7780618071556091,
-0.019072119146585464,
0.4026202857494354,
0.4745604395866394,
0.500349760055542,
-0.4704498052597046,
-0.10784626752138138,
-0.6163397431373596,
0.6712280511856079,
-0.480488657951355,
0.40734267234802246,
0.4606213867664337,
-0.08062291145324707,
-0.6208080649375916,
-0.937751054763794,
-0.5364856123924255,
-0.016058793291449547,
-0.12281321734189987,
0.3387373685836792,
-0.2782074809074402,
0.4111683666706085,
0.38045603036880493,
0.2652904689311981,
-0.46398335695266724,
0.13775044679641724,
-0.45936229825019836,
-0.21031378209590912,
0.5094344615936279,
0.4079442024230957,
0.24097874760627747,
-0.6248322129249573,
-0.267015278339386,
0.27392035722732544,
-0.4509832561016083,
0.28317856788635254,
0.18369640409946442,
0.3156011700630188,
-0.2735264003276825,
0.7124482989311218,
-0.1387328803539276,
0.8924148678779602,
0.37205713987350464,
-0.24840939044952393,
-0.23253284394741058,
-0.2706998884677887,
-0.6755858063697815,
0.03578806668519974,
0.5738672018051147,
0.41739439964294434,
-0.12938502430915833,
-0.19221065938472748,
0.4613511264324188,
0.20641471445560455,
0.6780961751937866,
-0.7161635160446167,
-0.3159281313419342,
0.58629310131073,
-0.594685435295105,
-0.5352550148963928,
0.06822843104600906,
-0.355620414018631,
-0.5779607892036438,
-0.24686792492866516,
-0.02781449258327484,
-0.018974415957927704,
-0.5014885663986206,
-0.04557246342301369,
-0.08671527355909348,
0.00005676161526935175,
0.18818417191505432,
-0.6344084143638611,
0.49000170826911926,
0.7434092164039612,
0.8525842428207397,
-0.0023176579270511866,
-0.38338223099708557,
-0.6312121748924255,
0.2886812090873718,
-0.611713707447052,
0.8478165864944458,
-0.6757301688194275,
-0.8451369404792786,
-0.24627763032913208,
-0.03202606737613678,
-0.016539908945560455,
-0.30585646629333496,
0.3632579445838928,
-0.11226191371679306,
0.6565904021263123,
0.029386701062321663,
-0.5191906690597534,
-0.5323758125305176,
0.3583035469055176,
-0.5296956300735474,
0.9574589729309082,
0.22426000237464905,
-0.6510322690010071,
0.23786930739879608,
-0.9024664163589478,
-0.42833244800567627,
0.25061681866645813,
-0.19050711393356323,
-0.028738664463162422,
0.4975104033946991,
-0.10449928045272827,
0.4900948405265808,
-0.11015909910202026,
0.5563350915908813,
-0.2157401591539383,
-0.4906393587589264,
0.15959569811820984,
-0.06853795051574707,
0.4952411651611328,
0.035821933299303055,
-0.3752685785293579,
0.48849740624427795,
-0.3299657106399536,
0.3326285481452942,
-0.20571072399616241,
-0.15521684288978577,
0.035355664789676666,
0.33472970128059387,
-0.34992870688438416,
0.49554842710494995,
0.04102661460638046,
-0.2914240062236786,
0.0817721039056778,
-0.6725847721099854,
0.21339018642902374,
0.7991926670074463,
0.057759325951337814,
0.788608729839325,
-0.38700318336486816,
0.7708884477615356,
-0.040132392197847366,
0.10313407331705093,
-0.015400540083646774,
-0.7592841386795044,
-0.7844818830490112,
-0.026163551956415176,
0.10012154281139374,
0.5720090270042419,
-0.8913977146148682,
0.28767216205596924,
-0.12200815230607986,
-0.5167375206947327,
-0.38116154074668884,
-0.13463546335697174,
0.5976257920265198,
0.7691701650619507,
0.10430075973272324,
-0.6865100860595703,
-0.8444591760635376,
-0.4772169888019562,
-0.04950649291276932,
-0.6024911999702454,
0.13812024891376495,
0.8070576786994934,
0.14294251799583435,
-0.22353476285934448,
1.0085660219192505,
-0.5810409188270569,
-0.10734186321496964,
-0.1577053964138031,
-0.005593848880380392,
0.09410464763641357,
0.24718411266803741,
0.35884910821914673,
-0.6130114197731018,
-0.5016950964927673,
0.041269343346357346,
-0.8481441736221313,
-0.004240412265062332,
-0.23011048138141632,
-0.17979955673217773,
0.07043341547250748,
0.7372661828994751,
-0.4525846540927887,
0.6426663398742676,
0.9714270830154419,
-0.7482461929321289,
0.3869445025920868,
0.11488000303506851,
0.1632496565580368,
-1.442474126815796,
0.2209579348564148,
-0.08396410197019577,
-0.36087965965270996,
-0.7170706987380981,
0.0863269492983818,
-0.2645006477832794,
-0.36725494265556335,
-0.8512038588523865,
0.803866982460022,
-0.318372905254364,
-0.2903929352760315,
-0.4327498972415924,
0.06784352660179138,
-0.22118641436100006,
0.6258957386016846,
0.3852483034133911,
0.760292112827301,
0.7621482014656067,
-0.7312703728675842,
0.09942060708999634,
0.2787499725818634,
-0.33636602759361267,
0.800898015499115,
-0.8323537111282349,
0.10759874433279037,
-0.09694387763738632,
0.25169292092323303,
-0.7784119844436646,
-0.4075872004032135,
0.10444944351911545,
-0.5302092432975769,
-0.0657564252614975,
-0.36467766761779785,
-0.41274142265319824,
-0.347834974527359,
-0.09500188380479813,
0.13201606273651123,
0.32081320881843567,
-0.36222413182258606,
0.727037250995636,
0.697809100151062,
-0.08275692164897919,
-0.30046945810317993,
-0.5934742093086243,
0.20842254161834717,
-0.3127012252807617,
-0.6901221871376038,
0.47476479411125183,
-0.2801823616027832,
-0.41232332587242126,
-0.21270212531089783,
-0.05990668386220932,
-0.29527029395103455,
0.2897873520851135,
0.8823451399803162,
0.04511571675539017,
0.01187785342335701,
0.112090103328228,
-0.12169842422008514,
-0.18387682735919952,
0.1824665367603302,
-0.38652440905570984,
0.5000942349433899,
0.15730275213718414,
-0.1436730921268463,
-0.4574197828769684,
0.393392950296402,
0.4025753140449524,
-0.02020711451768875,
0.5503466129302979,
0.18010631203651428,
-0.20424623787403107,
-0.0966450572013855,
-0.09938094764947891,
-0.20277030766010284,
-0.6130661964416504,
0.24314534664154053,
-0.31290343403816223,
-1.07451331615448,
0.3876194357872009,
-0.5556017756462097,
-0.027945926412940025,
0.17512208223342896,
0.3967475891113281,
-0.24665671586990356,
0.8742331266403198,
0.9269624352455139,
0.10289424657821655,
0.7332658767700195,
-0.14189736545085907,
0.32394784688949585,
-0.983196496963501,
-0.22768905758857727,
-0.16512855887413025,
-0.6813608407974243,
-0.5591659545898438,
-0.8020595908164978,
0.19701088964939117,
-0.07457728683948517,
-0.024698635563254356,
0.5498696565628052,
-0.5229582190513611,
0.7328943014144897,
0.36355313658714294,
-0.15704785287380219,
0.005858565215021372,
-0.16067861020565033,
-0.2497400939464569,
-0.186456099152565,
-0.916210412979126,
-0.3701897859573364,
0.8433673977851868,
0.15503773093223572,
0.3966216444969177,
0.3415321111679077,
0.742358922958374,
-0.14924156665802002,
0.2946111857891083,
-0.8292509913444519,
0.7283530831336975,
0.15508770942687988,
-0.5773951411247253,
0.026039969176054,
-0.3861493170261383,
-1.2341158390045166,
0.13455885648727417,
-0.2983781695365906,
-0.7499556541442871,
-0.11136370152235031,
0.16762675344944,
-0.4548833966255188,
0.05507379770278931,
-0.9379187822341919,
0.8803529739379883,
-0.15706093609333038,
-0.6146207451820374,
-0.07781150937080383,
-0.41547930240631104,
0.17510317265987396,
0.2551734149456024,
0.4406786859035492,
-0.003928763326257467,
-0.003087463555857539,
0.29431891441345215,
-0.19865655899047852,
1.1952658891677856,
-0.09803732484579086,
0.007051714695990086,
0.4630977213382721,
0.5952756404876709,
0.4642227590084076,
0.12958234548568726,
0.01180088147521019,
-0.07187536358833313,
-0.6217520236968994,
-0.28422969579696655,
-0.6615879535675049,
0.9449970722198486,
-0.5337419509887695,
-0.7008839249610901,
-0.40149128437042236,
-0.49108225107192993,
-0.13695091009140015,
0.11444227397441864,
0.05320367217063904,
0.31455159187316895,
-0.6125780940055847,
-0.0072984350845217705,
0.4271310865879059,
-0.12324907630681992,
0.6397503018379211,
0.541276752948761,
-0.4041104018688202,
-0.22157762944698334,
0.6409132480621338,
-0.11473042517900467,
0.19410277903079987,
0.20990820229053497,
0.0590105839073658,
-0.2082436978816986,
-0.4450477659702301,
-0.06824615597724915,
-0.02115880697965622,
-0.37741464376449585,
-0.13480590283870697,
-0.6329605579376221,
-0.20466311275959015,
-0.2049398422241211,
-0.6669670939445496,
-0.15629807114601135,
-0.7149835228919983,
-0.47787797451019287,
-0.4137398600578308,
0.10841631144285202,
0.9334169626235962,
0.11976586282253265,
0.3897600471973419,
-0.35645559430122375,
0.14861617982387543,
0.2536143660545349,
0.38900065422058105,
-0.08388876914978027,
-0.3804869055747986,
-0.015440700575709343,
0.0038602000568062067,
-0.498918354511261,
-0.5692647695541382,
0.4734266698360443,
0.17722508311271667,
0.40274927020072937,
0.11814957112073898,
-0.3222963809967041,
1.140032172203064,
-0.5523267388343811,
1.1956843137741089,
0.22055068612098694,
-0.9820064306259155,
0.8626590967178345,
-0.31429293751716614,
0.7458312511444092,
0.1832851618528366,
0.2572503983974457,
-0.6156154870986938,
-0.44108846783638,
-1.1806679964065552,
-0.6666224002838135,
0.4808230698108673,
0.25521406531333923,
0.19928929209709167,
-0.27929386496543884,
0.2395096719264984,
-0.2654643952846527,
0.1650862842798233,
-0.8841214179992676,
0.025447767227888107,
-0.17213058471679688,
-0.10202097147703171,
-0.22464528679847717,
-0.05145859718322754,
-0.04520631581544876,
-0.22978954017162323,
0.3717572093009949,
-0.3509010076522827,
0.37328553199768066,
0.1425890028476715,
-0.1094394326210022,
-0.10116656124591827,
-0.026852650567889214,
0.6625379920005798,
0.31324246525764465,
0.3157239854335785,
0.2091752290725708,
0.27964794635772705,
-0.38520562648773193,
-0.1392684280872345,
-0.24543313682079315,
0.011172756552696228,
-0.25205814838409424,
0.44665542244911194,
0.6405168175697327,
0.6833991408348083,
-0.5413069128990173,
0.28409886360168457,
-0.11956728249788284,
-0.3105332851409912,
-0.2493203580379486,
0.3666028082370758,
0.3569442331790924,
0.3625962734222412,
-0.40545418858528137,
0.33297765254974365,
0.3065160810947418,
-0.697510838508606,
0.13228541612625122,
0.31334230303764343,
-0.7106130123138428,
-0.4187543988227844,
0.697391927242279,
0.5684888958930969,
-0.5777941942214966,
0.4680175185203552,
-0.3645457625389099,
-0.3705742657184601,
0.5770337581634521,
0.799614667892456,
0.7917073369026184,
-0.22995640337467194,
0.5171905755996704,
0.49417775869369507,
0.07304473221302032,
0.04708673804998398,
0.6538774967193604,
-0.09048724174499512,
-0.5653951168060303,
-0.647247850894928,
-0.34962180256843567,
-0.40054672956466675,
-0.4193136394023895,
-0.06721046566963196,
0.22686618566513062,
-0.8926462531089783,
-0.2195112109184265,
-0.043721675872802734,
0.16275747120380402,
-0.5625841617584229,
0.28749150037765503,
-0.18058472871780396,
0.5333597660064697,
-0.41470786929130554,
0.776498019695282,
0.6292875409126282,
-0.13659654557704926,
-0.867239236831665,
-0.23447205126285553,
0.45824241638183594,
-0.45705389976501465,
0.4598012864589691,
0.1766914278268814,
-0.2372359335422516,
0.14897023141384125,
-0.39900797605514526,
-1.1523692607879639,
1.2302156686782837,
0.3166162669658661,
-0.33561673760414124,
0.09019885957241058,
0.019704783335328102,
0.7115976810455322,
-0.48812636733055115,
0.2713671028614044,
-0.011765430681407452,
0.20150260627269745,
0.3602123558521271,
-1.1850296258926392,
-0.046538811177015305,
-0.41660019755363464,
0.06504102796316147,
0.5189355611801147,
-0.6877304315567017,
0.620610773563385,
-0.19894307851791382,
-0.44544950127601624,
0.03699618950486183,
0.6537337303161621,
-0.03295822814106941,
0.20704036951065063,
0.17205889523029327,
0.604735791683197,
1.0835202932357788,
0.0027227303944528103,
1.3406217098236084,
-0.33312085270881653,
-0.00024735252372920513,
1.26197350025177,
-0.25349271297454834,
0.9845760464668274,
0.3210063874721527,
0.11404189467430115,
0.8401468992233276,
0.3887963593006134,
0.3869159519672394,
0.4375951886177063,
0.19591844081878662,
-0.23228396475315094,
-0.026761246845126152,
-0.4158644676208496,
0.05134553834795952,
0.8379122018814087,
0.5101105570793152,
-0.43932557106018066,
0.16194699704647064,
-0.33374205231666565,
0.1607649177312851,
0.2333611100912094,
-0.45334815979003906,
1.155369758605957,
0.00939430296421051,
-0.8198158740997314,
0.22438926994800568,
0.053746093064546585,
0.56764155626297,
-0.4257575571537018,
0.030794624239206314,
0.021257201209664345,
-0.11058579385280609,
-0.5268642902374268,
-0.715829074382782,
0.8032883405685425,
-0.09144318848848343,
-0.23332186043262482,
-0.4089897572994232,
0.7892287969589233,
-0.4304351806640625,
-0.4220254719257355,
0.07076527178287506,
0.42534008622169495,
0.2281513512134552,
0.03289703279733658,
-0.727486789226532,
0.1078970655798912,
-0.0615496002137661,
0.2113180309534073,
0.13965407013893127,
0.21069110929965973,
-0.12200174480676651,
0.5277503728866577,
0.9168407320976257,
-0.1820950210094452,
-0.20133264362812042,
-0.2138466238975525,
0.6467835903167725,
-0.7824886441230774,
-0.7735106945037842,
-0.528823733329773,
0.9181303381919861,
-0.40393882989883423,
-0.5291017889976501,
0.8129832148551941,
0.5986510515213013,
0.6300210952758789,
0.15288472175598145,
0.5775830149650574,
-0.17902211844921112,
0.26987022161483765,
-0.45647090673446655,
0.4376804232597351,
-0.16891592741012573,
0.015645019710063934,
-0.35215693712234497,
-0.942818820476532,
-0.34021854400634766,
0.9791566133499146,
-0.11593510210514069,
-0.07290033996105194,
0.87296462059021,
0.7449729442596436,
-0.18613271415233612,
0.18199056386947632,
0.49861136078834534,
0.16054631769657135,
0.30367299914360046,
0.676681399345398,
0.7242565155029297,
-0.30557024478912354,
0.0961996391415596,
-0.030443264171481133,
-0.2848249673843384,
0.10535361617803574,
-1.1176742315292358,
-1.106031060218811,
-0.5494714975357056,
-0.43688514828681946,
-0.17864011228084564,
-0.24084672331809998,
0.6929076313972473,
1.1588122844696045,
-0.4467231333255768,
-0.43722787499427795,
-0.4060402512550354,
0.1618211567401886,
-0.23774857819080353,
-0.2296888679265976,
-0.11780303716659546,
-0.06228935718536377,
-0.6476023197174072,
0.8954712748527527,
0.5314373970031738,
0.20352624356746674,
-0.17773614823818207,
-0.2226044237613678,
-0.11864286661148071,
0.32995033264160156,
0.8994074463844299,
0.31553709506988525,
-0.7073302268981934,
-0.461679607629776,
0.24813249707221985,
0.17147377133369446,
0.0042371065355837345,
0.8773737549781799,
-1.143723726272583,
0.5631110072135925,
0.2627289295196533,
0.3082751929759979,
0.4523763060569763,
0.0213316660374403,
0.883933424949646,
-1.0728930234909058,
0.4073405861854553,
0.23289655148983002,
0.19560524821281433,
0.2768919765949249,
-0.6568523645401001,
0.6453126668930054,
0.017566563561558723,
-0.4663619101047516,
-0.3581690490245819,
0.5377800464630127,
-0.9439411163330078,
-0.3888804018497467,
0.9447656869888306,
0.009011375717818737,
-0.2714878022670746,
-0.13394474983215332,
-0.5359209775924683,
-0.26071059703826904,
-0.12750932574272156,
0.9142635464668274,
0.7618487477302551,
-0.21506507694721222,
-0.23938877880573273,
-0.3557576537132263,
0.6829378008842468,
0.4042060375213623,
-1.1876174211502075,
-0.17810046672821045,
0.7714837193489075,
-0.019739115610718727,
0.3200632631778717,
0.8178391456604004,
0.18483281135559082,
0.4214649200439453,
0.16223111748695374,
-0.41001859307289124,
-0.12455106526613235,
-0.49820244312286377,
0.05889634042978287,
0.24442343413829803,
0.11530154198408127,
0.17424093186855316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18139v1 | LOOK-M: Look-Once Optimization in KV Cache for Efficient Multimodal Long-Context Inference | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | 2024-06-26T07:44:24 | Zhongwei Wan, Ziang Wu, Che Liu, Jinfa Huang, Zhihong Zhu, Peng Jin, Longyue Wang, Li Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Long-context Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demand substantial
computational resources for inference as the growth of their multimodal
Key-Value (KV) cache, in response to increasing input lengths, challenges
memory and time efficiency. Unlike single-modality LLMs that manage only
textual contexts, the KV cache of long-context MLLMs includes representations
from multiple images with temporal and spatial relationships and related
textual contexts. The predominance of image tokens means traditional
optimizations for LLMs' KV caches are unsuitable for multimodal long-context
settings, and no prior works have addressed this challenge. In this work, we
introduce LOOK-M, a pioneering, fine-tuning-free approach that efficiently
reduces the multimodal KV cache size while maintaining performance comparable
to a full cache. We observe that during prompt prefill, the model prioritizes
more textual attention over image features, and based on the multimodal
interaction observation, a new proposed text-prior method is explored to
compress the KV cache. Furthermore, to mitigate the degradation of image
contextual information, we propose several compensatory strategies using KV
pairs merging. LOOK-M demonstrates that with a significant reduction in KV
Cache memory usage, such as reducing it by 80% in some cases, it not only
achieves up to 1.5x faster decoding but also maintains or even enhances
performance across a variety of long context multimodal tasks. | [
-0.44410037994384766,
-0.6485687494277954,
0.5436362028121948,
0.4367441236972809,
-0.5543003082275391,
-0.19304952025413513,
-0.3858714699745178,
-0.3590660095214844,
0.19838419556617737,
0.3964555859565735,
-1.034056544303894,
-0.4422179162502289,
-0.3681139349937439,
-0.03941056877374649,
-0.10018117725849152,
0.3991479277610779,
-0.09514354169368744,
-0.08106883615255356,
-0.5285302400588989,
-0.2818129062652588,
-0.33790555596351624,
-0.3009864389896393,
-0.557462751865387,
0.1681380271911621,
0.9182589650154114,
0.43121886253356934,
0.5355905890464783,
0.3924054503440857,
0.5004488825798035,
0.23200015723705292,
0.009233042597770691,
0.6336474418640137,
-0.610209584236145,
0.5983158946037292,
0.04702351614832878,
-0.3118647336959839,
-0.25011929869651794,
-0.06893901526927948,
0.6265771985054016,
0.19911745190620422,
0.21431660652160645,
0.12622475624084473,
-0.05716363713145256,
0.71600741147995,
-1.4488404989242554,
0.18006694316864014,
-0.5661242008209229,
0.04967992752790451,
-0.2701120376586914,
-0.542634129524231,
-0.7839417457580566,
-0.017781341448426247,
0.2179812490940094,
-0.7744994163513184,
-0.016209539026021957,
0.03570551425218582,
0.6144539713859558,
0.5908765196800232,
-0.4609443247318268,
0.08997424691915512,
-0.3765977919101715,
1.1562931537628174,
-0.6005458235740662,
0.7038153409957886,
0.3523668646812439,
0.15837760269641876,
-0.366756796836853,
-0.6540290117263794,
-0.7262451648712158,
-0.13963958621025085,
-0.11766884475946426,
0.18837708234786987,
-0.06459883600473404,
0.021181654185056686,
0.020998895168304443,
0.054231829941272736,
-0.5717460513114929,
-0.10430033504962921,
0.017156457528471947,
-0.27251997590065,
0.06709568202495575,
0.0478881374001503,
0.04283697530627251,
-0.14443278312683105,
-0.5660943984985352,
-0.2881810665130615,
-0.6890533566474915,
0.019574467092752457,
-0.15236780047416687,
0.3780595660209656,
-0.12881021201610565,
0.40363621711730957,
-0.3263581693172455,
0.49485278129577637,
-0.2664657235145569,
-0.28415152430534363,
0.28300580382347107,
-0.6751806735992432,
-0.17556768655776978,
-0.17322202026844025,
0.6471289992332458,
0.7010005116462708,
0.30730530619621277,
0.07508860528469086,
0.03937410190701485,
0.09285260736942291,
0.14444521069526672,
-1.1065008640289307,
-0.10124769061803818,
0.13531477749347687,
-0.6794577836990356,
-0.27009353041648865,
-0.3592565059661865,
-0.8751444816589355,
-0.023298269137740135,
-0.3498777747154236,
0.5142577290534973,
-0.23928746581077576,
0.01907769963145256,
0.010710276663303375,
-0.00045661479816772044,
0.3482716679573059,
0.6050621271133423,
-0.6269252896308899,
-0.06987085938453674,
0.33656102418899536,
0.9820804595947266,
-0.1932314783334732,
-0.3466968238353729,
-0.8135690689086914,
0.2054261416196823,
-0.25162473320961,
0.5247540473937988,
-0.6678794622421265,
-0.3498287796974182,
0.006271681282669306,
0.16242381930351257,
0.04731293022632599,
-0.3007051348686218,
0.35234013199806213,
-0.5794113874435425,
0.09861578047275543,
-0.30954331159591675,
-0.1310228556394577,
0.20274636149406433,
0.47409552335739136,
-0.8325471878051758,
1.2187516689300537,
-0.03808470815420151,
-0.8127217292785645,
0.6311688423156738,
-0.5685536861419678,
-0.4680907726287842,
-0.25877276062965393,
0.08959747850894928,
-0.5184920430183411,
0.26942428946495056,
0.6662951707839966,
0.4894638955593109,
-0.12707598507404327,
-0.09590204805135727,
-0.600326418876648,
-0.3528565466403961,
-0.14962708950042725,
-0.43652135133743286,
0.2249046266078949,
0.24211636185646057,
-0.31725412607192993,
0.30035728216171265,
-0.6573898792266846,
0.24495811760425568,
0.18905067443847656,
-0.3066416382789612,
-0.6040079593658447,
0.29165810346603394,
0.2484235316514969,
0.37818875908851624,
0.4131527841091156,
-0.46922391653060913,
0.2947620749473572,
-0.09278500080108643,
0.33773231506347656,
0.8061256408691406,
-0.2418430596590042,
0.4285055994987488,
-0.04985791817307472,
0.37411433458328247,
0.4292881488800049,
0.3995090425014496,
-0.8927348852157593,
-0.21456412971019745,
-0.9489227533340454,
-0.6177288293838501,
0.0326409712433815,
0.21255095303058624,
-0.9770841598510742,
-0.18775299191474915,
-0.34228211641311646,
-0.10804931819438934,
-0.6099623441696167,
-0.036014623939991,
0.5897994637489319,
0.3409832715988159,
0.6189447641372681,
-0.1419822871685028,
-0.47219157218933105,
-1.3003579378128052,
-0.19610050320625305,
0.1627187877893448,
0.18859131634235382,
0.6529324650764465,
0.3252153992652893,
-0.42319202423095703,
0.9043076634407043,
-0.6393694877624512,
-0.018728554248809814,
0.24316544830799103,
0.04273752495646477,
-0.14627137780189514,
0.5047841668128967,
0.458659827709198,
-0.8031901121139526,
-0.4467802941799164,
-0.11403806507587433,
-0.48960942029953003,
-0.011669379658997059,
0.029634147882461548,
-0.32780617475509644,
0.49116629362106323,
0.6584402918815613,
-0.6986605525016785,
0.5232929587364197,
0.5916755795478821,
-0.21745172142982483,
0.576558530330658,
-0.2946541905403137,
0.4281121790409088,
-1.0607757568359375,
0.14768515527248383,
-0.20598635077476501,
-0.2732671797275543,
-0.31825074553489685,
0.18830883502960205,
0.49708691239356995,
-0.03969072550535202,
-0.49988704919815063,
1.0476043224334717,
-0.6621886491775513,
0.06115598604083061,
0.06359656155109406,
0.04320989176630974,
0.15119455754756927,
0.6273285150527954,
-0.14780497550964355,
0.9606920480728149,
0.41654905676841736,
-0.5519075989723206,
-0.1668485701084137,
0.10552427917718887,
-0.3033013939857483,
0.5543789267539978,
-0.22889482975006104,
0.2288200855255127,
-0.26426950097084045,
0.2883453965187073,
-1.0329481363296509,
-0.13796183466911316,
-0.044183894991874695,
-0.22544459998607635,
0.5479866862297058,
-0.1554986834526062,
-0.6024287939071655,
-0.21429094672203064,
-0.5769623517990112,
0.9191692471504211,
0.002346628811210394,
-0.8560250401496887,
0.6288091540336609,
-0.04438548535108566,
0.05518611520528793,
-0.929787278175354,
-0.46550655364990234,
0.16001370549201965,
0.060879308730363846,
-0.7740765810012817,
0.4677651524543762,
-0.23364444077014923,
0.126116544008255,
-0.16228948533535004,
-0.2548978626728058,
-0.09039809554815292,
-0.08272941410541534,
0.07829787582159042,
0.11332608759403229,
-0.3324824869632721,
0.4145834445953369,
0.3304208517074585,
-0.22384333610534668,
-0.21367760002613068,
-0.2187364548444748,
0.6089420318603516,
0.08942820876836777,
-0.3461465835571289,
-0.3727589249610901,
0.5103973150253296,
1.0463502407073975,
-0.43167009949684143,
0.8309990763664246,
0.6341118812561035,
-0.19200646877288818,
-0.13629691302776337,
-0.6978827118873596,
-0.1666136085987091,
-0.4922558665275574,
0.34189385175704956,
-0.6020188331604004,
-1.119462490081787,
0.46120572090148926,
-0.08860823512077332,
-0.031924281269311905,
0.14739885926246643,
0.557782769203186,
-0.09818878024816513,
0.9811363220214844,
0.4005146920681,
-0.2064768373966217,
0.6311928033828735,
-0.028342846781015396,
0.13565343618392944,
-0.6677002906799316,
-0.4015358090400696,
-0.3049812316894531,
-0.41932129859924316,
-0.5890170335769653,
-0.8639978170394897,
0.38602215051651,
-0.05417408421635628,
-0.11141256242990494,
0.030745333060622215,
-0.2836608588695526,
0.5495530366897583,
0.5830382108688354,
0.4652613699436188,
0.1855836659669876,
-0.1202637329697609,
-0.353642076253891,
-0.28353816270828247,
-0.5586390495300293,
-0.09274749457836151,
1.0219413042068481,
0.029356490820646286,
0.9888526201248169,
-0.06306670606136322,
0.5335742235183716,
-0.004801028873771429,
0.20659852027893066,
-0.799022912979126,
0.5390257835388184,
-0.10537075996398926,
-0.4887002110481262,
-0.06140618398785591,
-0.44311562180519104,
-0.8490297198295593,
0.34105184674263,
-0.21963493525981903,
-0.4431789815425873,
0.0008377343183383346,
0.42392635345458984,
0.07156021893024445,
0.06317218393087387,
-0.731582522392273,
1.0095200538635254,
-0.06496375054121017,
-0.5866764783859253,
-0.44373568892478943,
-0.7471951246261597,
0.27868226170539856,
-0.0911426693201065,
0.05818228796124458,
0.045032430440187454,
-0.15608079731464386,
0.30180296301841736,
-0.27296340465545654,
0.44511327147483826,
-0.2110441029071808,
-0.14446993172168732,
-0.036912910640239716,
0.16220983862876892,
0.6339942216873169,
-0.015236002393066883,
0.26362165808677673,
0.047536831349134445,
0.06104477494955063,
-0.5283715128898621,
-0.6945649981498718,
0.9281142354011536,
-0.4123491644859314,
-0.17856232821941376,
0.08882971107959747,
-0.56043940782547,
-0.07104121148586273,
0.37861156463623047,
0.23780861496925354,
0.7411942481994629,
-0.171798437833786,
0.43932098150253296,
0.6710330843925476,
-0.3305639624595642,
0.5865017175674438,
0.14408358931541443,
-0.30927732586860657,
-0.41541290283203125,
0.7035390734672546,
-0.30471205711364746,
0.4101295471191406,
0.717330813407898,
-0.014106661081314087,
-0.37240058183670044,
-0.3029056191444397,
-0.2823313772678375,
0.1449938714504242,
-0.7261388897895813,
-0.18172861635684967,
-0.6868029236793518,
0.278709352016449,
-0.042549535632133484,
-0.2545647621154785,
-0.6095868945121765,
-0.221893310546875,
-0.27950629591941833,
0.505963146686554,
0.19978609681129456,
0.0558430440723896,
0.256974995136261,
0.46366962790489197,
-0.6950075030326843,
0.3842700719833374,
0.21530799567699432,
0.5764645934104919,
0.057169120758771896,
-0.0017684355843812227,
-0.36541998386383057,
-0.0745241567492485,
-0.12671098113059998,
-0.4173513352870941,
0.32867199182510376,
0.2482868880033493,
0.24024713039398193,
0.6296161413192749,
-0.13547757267951965,
0.994062602519989,
-0.593490481376648,
0.5480789542198181,
0.2009548842906952,
-0.8604364395141602,
0.4708607792854309,
-0.3597566485404968,
0.7008786201477051,
0.550385594367981,
0.14479216933250427,
-0.4296916127204895,
-0.12682609260082245,
0.0236604455858469,
-0.9114714860916138,
0.518142580986023,
0.4090956747531891,
0.04121246188879013,
-0.31000447273254395,
0.25325456261634827,
-0.14740821719169617,
0.23662631213665009,
-0.6308344602584839,
-0.32665887475013733,
-0.14467868208885193,
-0.145675390958786,
-0.19430522620677948,
-0.4914175868034363,
0.15772157907485962,
-0.2995065748691559,
0.3122786581516266,
-0.39637118577957153,
0.35204359889030457,
0.3251299262046814,
-0.439317524433136,
-0.061979301273822784,
0.22665457427501678,
1.1114033460617065,
0.571858286857605,
-0.388484388589859,
0.3525703549385071,
0.06930793076753616,
-0.4521341919898987,
-0.07504911720752716,
-0.19370408356189728,
0.2649403214454651,
0.13895639777183533,
0.21871714293956757,
0.694707989692688,
0.8155914545059204,
-0.715423583984375,
0.4309944212436676,
-0.312795490026474,
-0.04651515185832977,
0.019799694418907166,
-0.2721130847930908,
-0.007685618009418249,
0.4106617867946625,
0.32777610421180725,
-0.07541759312152863,
-0.05009622126817703,
-0.4230223298072815,
0.3046033978462219,
0.7821977734565735,
-0.1709565818309784,
-0.11965318024158478,
0.5418976545333862,
0.08508855104446411,
-0.03900334984064102,
0.5131811499595642,
0.007230234332382679,
-0.6160576343536377,
0.3168964385986328,
0.515227198600769,
0.8841062784194946,
-0.1720634549856186,
-0.3043656051158905,
0.46582889556884766,
0.2453223466873169,
0.07754071056842804,
0.2185014933347702,
-0.35333338379859924,
-0.6082839965820312,
-0.6378337740898132,
-0.7187606692314148,
-0.19097726047039032,
0.23877497017383575,
-0.5593646764755249,
0.3291079103946686,
-0.21497312188148499,
-0.14054402709007263,
-0.07297040522098541,
-0.2056812047958374,
-0.7147489786148071,
0.19726383686065674,
-0.06302758306264877,
0.8772189021110535,
-0.19336190819740295,
0.7287184596061707,
0.18797704577445984,
0.09548237174749374,
-0.17216375470161438,
-0.15233834087848663,
0.06764937937259674,
-0.6902348399162292,
0.8385269045829773,
0.6161026954650879,
-0.5311126708984375,
0.010716765187680721,
-0.7925075888633728,
-0.9116557240486145,
0.9654948115348816,
0.27251431345939636,
-0.6367127299308777,
-0.16127166152000427,
-0.31853634119033813,
0.11789003759622574,
-0.4731717109680176,
0.14255249500274658,
0.33572474122047424,
0.6386421322822571,
0.19808629155158997,
-0.9510656595230103,
0.01635572873055935,
-0.2966648042201996,
0.0036053501535207033,
0.8004968762397766,
-0.5067272186279297,
0.7383323907852173,
-0.29388612508773804,
-0.18389251828193665,
0.19499389827251434,
0.45088663697242737,
0.32160088419914246,
0.5001908540725708,
0.5142351388931274,
0.8405668139457703,
0.3411806523799896,
0.12856632471084595,
0.8394726514816284,
-0.39842137694358826,
0.44523683190345764,
1.1360915899276733,
-0.01314353384077549,
0.926557183265686,
0.8435996174812317,
0.0904400572180748,
0.22679880261421204,
0.5813459157943726,
0.34622442722320557,
0.8616759181022644,
-0.08298084139823914,
-0.35007530450820923,
-0.4897933006286621,
0.16873785853385925,
-0.33562424778938293,
0.5905168652534485,
0.209344744682312,
-0.4650879502296448,
-0.35317423939704895,
-0.12166085094213486,
-0.003680707421153784,
-0.4322430491447449,
-0.24189408123493195,
0.4954890310764313,
0.05323893949389458,
-0.6971814036369324,
0.5314691662788391,
-0.2023678719997406,
0.8136962056159973,
-0.45371556282043457,
0.003616555128246546,
-0.10677257925271988,
0.30009713768959045,
0.18073591589927673,
-0.3053467869758606,
-0.030891042202711105,
-0.376729816198349,
-0.6004410982131958,
-0.16617004573345184,
0.7437325716018677,
-0.5723477602005005,
-0.22026486694812775,
0.4558388590812683,
0.40256643295288086,
-0.0777239054441452,
-0.3759566843509674,
-0.39824241399765015,
0.13614009320735931,
-0.14169186353683472,
-0.4380037784576416,
0.43623074889183044,
0.2969154417514801,
-0.07086459547281265,
0.9113848805427551,
0.9206568002700806,
-0.36629146337509155,
0.1926216185092926,
0.004812675528228283,
1.1159509420394897,
-0.7160715460777283,
-0.43827757239341736,
-1.0987765789031982,
0.536711573600769,
0.02771168015897274,
-0.33135107159614563,
0.47658538818359375,
0.6048698425292969,
0.6734305024147034,
-0.1091972142457962,
0.28698524832725525,
0.36555519700050354,
-0.061829131096601486,
-0.8396294713020325,
0.7467609643936157,
-1.0935876369476318,
-0.3453894555568695,
-0.4958515763282776,
-1.1050121784210205,
-0.2137904167175293,
0.5572472810745239,
0.13614197075366974,
0.10328394174575806,
0.7506451606750488,
0.9314327239990234,
-0.2873920798301697,
-0.3900874853134155,
0.42339658737182617,
-0.010288087651133537,
0.25973761081695557,
0.5008198618888855,
0.7247995138168335,
-0.2868357002735138,
0.45848408341407776,
-0.09194351732730865,
-0.00019962378428317606,
-0.44174155592918396,
-1.1362006664276123,
-0.7547048330307007,
-0.6901208162307739,
0.0490691140294075,
-0.22854653000831604,
-0.11426876485347748,
0.8492478132247925,
0.9892278909683228,
-0.4653984010219574,
0.26919272541999817,
0.29128360748291016,
-0.03817107528448105,
0.22204193472862244,
-0.22215862572193146,
0.2844337821006775,
-0.4436050355434418,
-0.6255031228065491,
0.5753239393234253,
0.7983494997024536,
-0.11686012893915176,
-0.30672401189804077,
-0.19089706242084503,
-0.24248912930488586,
0.17929872870445251,
1.1260194778442383,
-0.019844042137265205,
-0.9733346700668335,
-0.3051980435848236,
0.19408884644508362,
-0.13313260674476624,
0.23125490546226501,
0.8999869227409363,
-0.8265310525894165,
1.0666520595550537,
0.29141902923583984,
0.598717987537384,
0.9665195345878601,
-0.21998853981494904,
0.4954086244106293,
-0.9131225347518921,
0.4522497057914734,
0.021420495584607124,
0.49710994958877563,
0.08784352988004684,
-0.044587764889001846,
0.28604310750961304,
-0.022302795201539993,
-0.5051380395889282,
-0.8731008768081665,
0.2859549820423126,
-1.3183238506317139,
-0.29669132828712463,
0.8534930348396301,
-0.034693747758865356,
-0.2011195719242096,
0.15834812819957733,
-0.18466566503047943,
0.16752953827381134,
-0.4987892508506775,
0.5324125289916992,
0.7379651665687561,
0.3534797728061676,
-0.5896695852279663,
-0.5577630996704102,
0.6095920205116272,
0.5847617387771606,
-0.7766749262809753,
0.054391324520111084,
0.5942837595939636,
0.007821330800652504,
0.08354540169239044,
0.4861534535884857,
0.08220523595809937,
0.3091573417186737,
-0.3058343529701233,
0.03157659247517586,
-0.07569998502731323,
-0.719253659248352,
-0.06683846563100815,
-0.02092311903834343,
-0.2565576434135437,
-0.23083922266960144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18135v1 | Automatic Speech Recognition for Hindi | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | 2024-06-26T07:39:20 | Anish Saha, A. G. Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) is a key area in computational
linguistics, focusing on developing technologies that enable computers to
convert spoken language into text. This field combines linguistics and machine
learning. ASR models, which map speech audio to transcripts through supervised
learning, require handling real and unrestricted text. Text-to-speech systems
directly work with real text, while ASR systems rely on language models trained
on large text corpora. High-quality transcribed data is essential for training
predictive models. The research involved two main components: developing a web
application and designing a web interface for speech recognition. The web
application, created with JavaScript and Node.js, manages large volumes of
audio files and their transcriptions, facilitating collaborative human
correction of ASR transcripts. It operates in real-time using a client-server
architecture. The web interface for speech recognition records 16 kHz mono
audio from any device running the web app, performs voice activity detection
(VAD), and sends the audio to the recognition engine. VAD detects human speech
presence, aiding efficient speech processing and reducing unnecessary
processing during non-speech intervals, thus saving computation and network
bandwidth in VoIP applications. The final phase of the research tested a neural
network for accurately aligning the speech signal to hidden Markov model (HMM)
states. This included implementing a novel backpropagation method that utilizes
prior statistics of node co-activations. | [
-0.25186702609062195,
-0.6020427942276001,
-0.1213059201836586,
0.32332882285118103,
-0.09624651819467545,
0.38265207409858704,
-0.13387715816497803,
-0.5493420362472534,
0.0186202023178339,
0.2166682332754135,
-0.2613271176815033,
-0.24340373277664185,
-0.45691990852355957,
0.13283604383468628,
-0.893768310546875,
0.4223288595676422,
0.0838187038898468,
0.3986891508102417,
0.23175472021102905,
-0.044450122863054276,
-0.42716455459594727,
-0.42736661434173584,
-1.1036670207977295,
-0.4730043411254883,
0.18792936205863953,
0.33873119950294495,
0.3217970132827759,
0.6103076934814453,
0.6529986262321472,
0.39683443307876587,
-0.039569005370140076,
-0.13216662406921387,
0.05015610530972481,
0.1025930866599083,
-0.041110023856163025,
-0.16700060665607452,
-0.2290629893541336,
-0.31406331062316895,
0.7910388112068176,
0.5485413670539856,
-0.5010573863983154,
0.15829291939735413,
0.016122030094265938,
0.6739841103553772,
-0.4565538167953491,
0.18437419831752777,
-0.4109836518764496,
0.12717624008655548,
-0.441925972700119,
-0.1478446125984192,
-0.11109676212072372,
-0.35360264778137207,
-0.010469511151313782,
-0.25198638439178467,
0.1661568582057953,
0.03483884036540985,
0.9012529253959656,
0.43352508544921875,
-0.22866956889629364,
-0.6278477907180786,
-1.1617176532745361,
0.4398651719093323,
-0.4266812205314636,
0.8233374953269958,
0.5893120765686035,
0.6913590431213379,
0.16795562207698822,
-0.3186233639717102,
-0.7832476496696472,
-0.014627140015363693,
0.20689067244529724,
0.1081499457359314,
-0.34830141067504883,
-0.10536402463912964,
0.09138200432062149,
0.5337182879447937,
-0.6789998412132263,
0.25031009316444397,
-0.6110889911651611,
-0.29576265811920166,
0.7156863808631897,
0.11870725452899933,
0.5787990689277649,
0.023323634639382362,
0.10090668499469757,
-0.30876094102859497,
-0.5036535859107971,
0.2871403992176056,
0.29363083839416504,
0.6388532519340515,
-0.33881044387817383,
0.5926806330680847,
-0.2927391529083252,
0.7645186185836792,
0.19180993735790253,
-0.23468230664730072,
0.22193589806556702,
-0.29599398374557495,
-0.2509672939777374,
0.6474646329879761,
0.8559903502464294,
-0.29883986711502075,
0.23808036744594574,
0.18153724074363708,
-0.10065498948097229,
0.2471364140510559,
0.31875041127204895,
-0.27884674072265625,
-0.07228849828243256,
0.08296840637922287,
-0.24526382982730865,
0.06506567448377609,
-0.15100626647472382,
-0.6149505972862244,
-0.15307261049747467,
-0.5398393869400024,
0.540197491645813,
-0.449504554271698,
-0.37779566645622253,
-0.002084169303998351,
-0.09821920096874237,
0.6626532673835754,
0.28919360041618347,
-0.8726527690887451,
0.7356602549552917,
0.34505847096443176,
0.8624399900436401,
-0.2965119779109955,
-0.13518333435058594,
-0.4400552809238434,
0.3046133816242218,
-0.20201091468334198,
0.7130442261695862,
-0.4327353537082672,
-0.797775149345398,
-0.018492935225367546,
-0.25659283995628357,
-0.19226908683776855,
-0.5513046979904175,
0.5103580951690674,
-0.49678248167037964,
-0.08023621141910553,
0.2023545354604721,
-0.3563857972621918,
-0.18169474601745605,
-0.06802799552679062,
-0.5120515823364258,
0.7286718487739563,
-0.31801924109458923,
-0.4481147229671478,
0.25274771451950073,
-0.9028061628341675,
-0.6070088744163513,
0.12531116604804993,
-0.14687104523181915,
-0.5251034498214722,
-0.13249216973781586,
0.05055675283074379,
0.2308894842863083,
-0.2879249155521393,
-0.07824433594942093,
0.3881102204322815,
-0.32905739545822144,
0.28198888897895813,
-0.32418954372406006,
0.7819259762763977,
0.48538368940353394,
-0.23965713381767273,
0.28130120038986206,
-1.0203869342803955,
0.13836203515529633,
-0.0833335667848587,
-0.5730604529380798,
0.04077523946762085,
-0.042700015008449554,
0.37818509340286255,
-0.0011848332360386848,
-0.08245804160833359,
-0.6374357342720032,
-0.3703281581401825,
-0.6041544079780579,
0.28215762972831726,
0.2867973744869232,
-0.30105721950531006,
0.3564840853214264,
0.029415188357234,
0.4292462468147278,
-0.061452899128198624,
0.04488620162010193,
0.15139804780483246,
-0.43038758635520935,
-0.6693645119667053,
-0.12799383699893951,
0.49973541498184204,
0.8423624634742737,
-0.3950047791004181,
0.3696907162666321,
-0.2436961978673935,
-0.5698781609535217,
-0.6380379796028137,
0.11647066473960876,
0.8241217136383057,
0.3502960503101349,
0.3689537048339844,
-0.458759605884552,
-0.8189828991889954,
-0.6679116487503052,
-0.13456441462039948,
-0.22425642609596252,
0.1367431879043579,
0.03133242577314377,
0.06238340586423874,
-0.46849194169044495,
1.0020251274108887,
-0.37221232056617737,
-0.6781904101371765,
-0.25313130021095276,
0.153957337141037,
-0.027084795758128166,
0.7363776564598083,
-0.05697331950068474,
-1.168142557144165,
-0.9359121322631836,
0.21078747510910034,
-0.3811495900154114,
-0.2613369822502136,
0.48629388213157654,
0.44361990690231323,
0.26561620831489563,
0.4783993065357208,
-0.5148816704750061,
0.748476505279541,
0.5739611983299255,
-0.025256913155317307,
0.4637143015861511,
-0.04363911226391792,
0.2764802575111389,
-0.848634660243988,
0.22050192952156067,
-0.05368978530168533,
-0.20142409205436707,
-0.8708885312080383,
-0.19848482310771942,
-0.1795276403427124,
-0.7274609804153442,
-0.3197289705276489,
0.45138680934906006,
-0.5168858766555786,
-0.32992053031921387,
-0.5695201754570007,
-0.22382871806621552,
-0.447255402803421,
0.10832106322050095,
0.1334206610918045,
1.086710810661316,
0.6671611666679382,
-0.7491225004196167,
0.49710536003112793,
0.4230092167854309,
0.1162576973438263,
0.3513922393321991,
-0.5533810257911682,
0.0986848697066307,
0.23684608936309814,
-0.14529269933700562,
-0.9510537385940552,
-0.38101258873939514,
0.1630314141511917,
-1.0160901546478271,
0.6509526968002319,
0.0668715313076973,
-0.3097325563430786,
-0.5109044313430786,
0.10513479262590408,
0.22721680998802185,
0.5777512788772583,
-0.19020307064056396,
0.7755259275436401,
0.9548877477645874,
-0.23601101338863373,
-0.22488927841186523,
-0.6536189913749695,
0.10033555328845978,
-0.04022477567195892,
-0.2835468053817749,
0.14896045625209808,
0.1491364687681198,
-0.23384220898151398,
-0.15669184923171997,
-0.1949596256017685,
-0.6011219620704651,
-0.2897547781467438,
0.5949377417564392,
-0.1627250462770462,
-0.13634942471981049,
-0.14840386807918549,
-0.07100124657154083,
-0.2776644825935364,
-0.2043382078409195,
0.036676354706287384,
0.759037971496582,
-0.12277164310216904,
-0.5540117025375366,
-1.1997549533843994,
0.5277909636497498,
0.41367360949516296,
-0.22459496557712555,
0.21163909137248993,
0.8142592310905457,
-0.6483693718910217,
0.2383069396018982,
-0.7300585508346558,
0.29202353954315186,
-0.5021838545799255,
0.08349935710430145,
-0.4315149486064911,
-0.5644621849060059,
0.43048232793807983,
0.04077130928635597,
-0.5543615818023682,
0.4035433828830719,
0.563827395439148,
-0.026746278628706932,
1.038014531135559,
0.6444212794303894,
-0.24908150732517242,
0.5288200974464417,
-0.02976672537624836,
0.3305602967739105,
-0.690156877040863,
-0.23479688167572021,
-0.8703085780143738,
0.1849796324968338,
-0.4345080256462097,
-0.127470001578331,
0.35564032196998596,
-0.1581016331911087,
-0.03694756329059601,
0.3746525049209595,
-0.7883880734443665,
0.203408345580101,
0.5599383115768433,
-0.1117180660367012,
0.17144252359867096,
0.17696838080883026,
0.01792793907225132,
0.03666207566857338,
-0.28185972571372986,
-0.33807629346847534,
0.739377498626709,
0.19968192279338837,
0.8334782719612122,
0.2499735802412033,
0.4367576241493225,
0.40649259090423584,
-0.23742546141147614,
-0.810891330242157,
0.5920608639717102,
-0.30460795760154724,
-0.5402503609657288,
-0.5150766968727112,
-0.17271070182323456,
-0.9886330366134644,
-0.23209035396575928,
-0.029891539365053177,
-0.7104924917221069,
0.24857968091964722,
0.4719283878803253,
-0.5228044986724854,
-0.004367146175354719,
-0.9610292315483093,
0.34585970640182495,
-0.17935748398303986,
-0.27519553899765015,
-0.3594314754009247,
-0.76378333568573,
-0.09438005089759827,
-0.029541242867708206,
0.08070893585681915,
0.16684165596961975,
0.23535005748271942,
0.8539429903030396,
-0.15307916700839996,
0.7420656085014343,
-0.35482001304626465,
0.3315141201019287,
0.32973429560661316,
-0.23929806053638458,
0.002103250939399004,
-0.2944782078266144,
-0.09317595511674881,
0.20609164237976074,
0.09839915484189987,
-0.14539538323879242,
-0.1936432421207428,
0.491966187953949,
-0.8737958073616028,
-0.5144145488739014,
-0.7132874727249146,
-0.21834714710712433,
-0.3531160056591034,
0.24764752388000488,
0.1619243174791336,
0.3799643814563751,
-0.2221386730670929,
0.13477817177772522,
0.667455792427063,
-0.2641393542289734,
0.5072789788246155,
0.5665041208267212,
-0.32709789276123047,
-0.41129955649375916,
1.0020157098770142,
0.18921977281570435,
0.09262999147176743,
0.5035757422447205,
0.21039848029613495,
-0.5968652367591858,
-0.8713188171386719,
-0.6175010204315186,
0.020974913612008095,
-0.5753130316734314,
-0.1868923306465149,
-0.77655029296875,
-0.907534122467041,
-0.7203702926635742,
-0.003777286736294627,
-0.4661599397659302,
-0.22022582590579987,
-0.3250935673713684,
0.19394560158252716,
0.43173012137413025,
0.690552294254303,
-0.22589918971061707,
0.5424292087554932,
-0.7685262560844421,
0.4383799135684967,
0.46286362409591675,
0.2649795413017273,
0.04283110424876213,
-0.4698277711868286,
-0.24088707566261292,
0.05827798694372177,
-0.3382949233055115,
-0.701570987701416,
0.7241147756576538,
0.6656564474105835,
0.3239651024341583,
0.3459147810935974,
-0.4796271324157715,
0.9425631165504456,
-0.6971960663795471,
0.6533413529396057,
0.43967366218566895,
-1.1308159828186035,
0.8400529026985168,
-0.34153416752815247,
0.3144969642162323,
0.4422485828399658,
0.3991146385669708,
-0.4204954504966736,
0.020138351246714592,
-0.22486934065818787,
-0.6718682646751404,
0.576518177986145,
0.20191672444343567,
-0.1668185591697693,
0.3587433695793152,
0.3284241259098053,
0.015286656096577644,
0.2176428884267807,
-0.3709288537502289,
-0.07779443264007568,
-0.37493759393692017,
-0.4662313759326935,
-0.09696174412965775,
-0.01976626180112362,
0.20009976625442505,
-0.5578015446662903,
0.5694419145584106,
0.09156518429517746,
0.4065358340740204,
0.22814282774925232,
-0.040938690304756165,
-0.24771562218666077,
0.31495562195777893,
0.6035885214805603,
0.4910503625869751,
-0.0017240047454833984,
-0.04036582261323929,
0.2617485225200653,
-0.9227128624916077,
0.37683117389678955,
0.2437949925661087,
0.0054968586191535,
0.06322871893644333,
-0.07603970170021057,
0.643031120300293,
-0.20140424370765686,
-0.7493687868118286,
0.3631027340888977,
-0.2105422168970108,
0.1571141630411148,
-0.9453775882720947,
0.3413187265396118,
-0.002124345162883401,
0.12342465668916702,
0.6655836701393127,
0.10587187856435776,
0.4714514911174774,
-0.7273726463317871,
0.208880215883255,
0.34318453073501587,
-0.6670388579368591,
-0.35498639941215515,
0.5545526146888733,
0.08737024664878845,
-1.0584275722503662,
0.3194858133792877,
-0.20871789753437042,
-0.6943055987358093,
0.40936505794525146,
0.7118871808052063,
0.8126007914543152,
-1.0210087299346924,
-0.20761504769325256,
0.38545000553131104,
-0.2586650848388672,
-0.14954331517219543,
0.47189098596572876,
-0.02703285962343216,
-0.49393588304519653,
-0.1172071173787117,
-0.9678955078125,
-0.5155155658721924,
-0.08574716001749039,
-0.647163987159729,
0.4400297999382019,
-0.5146668553352356,
-0.23265071213245392,
0.14889411628246307,
-0.04060952365398407,
-0.40910178422927856,
0.6787837743759155,
0.014709550887346268,
0.5116954445838928,
-0.742759108543396,
1.0457221269607544,
0.6330317854881287,
-0.4214547574520111,
-0.9138312339782715,
-0.10114677995443344,
0.32966330647468567,
-0.7611179351806641,
0.9167497158050537,
-0.04531729966402054,
-0.6548454761505127,
0.4114146828651428,
-0.1919395625591278,
-1.0333126783370972,
0.823820173740387,
-0.13386239111423492,
-0.739136815071106,
-0.009750845842063427,
0.16095969080924988,
0.7535087466239929,
-0.09870892763137817,
-0.21996769309043884,
0.29942435026168823,
0.14737635850906372,
0.28709831833839417,
-1.5248665809631348,
-0.31471359729766846,
-0.4677760899066925,
0.07464599609375,
0.21728162467479706,
-0.5166961550712585,
0.570254385471344,
0.13496598601341248,
-0.3979862630367279,
-0.023510057479143143,
0.4792173206806183,
0.19723616540431976,
0.5251362323760986,
0.44246506690979004,
0.4857169985771179,
0.39640745520591736,
-0.0486263707280159,
0.6990575194358826,
-0.0588478222489357,
-0.1883472502231598,
0.7752952575683594,
-0.4644623398780823,
1.2110414505004883,
0.373939573764801,
-0.3609718382358551,
0.10602442175149918,
0.4716958701610565,
0.06301221251487732,
0.44749581813812256,
0.3294084966182709,
-0.37078535556793213,
0.34838470816612244,
-0.3152412474155426,
-0.42603036761283875,
0.9793691039085388,
0.6450579166412354,
0.04985072463750839,
0.17988033592700958,
0.36149314045906067,
-0.3259871006011963,
0.2586582601070404,
-0.4966627359390259,
1.0899378061294556,
0.15340709686279297,
-0.4023161828517914,
0.46469002962112427,
-0.07752503454685211,
0.6840680241584778,
-0.7486638426780701,
0.04235072433948517,
0.5078551769256592,
0.3211684226989746,
-0.39666423201560974,
-0.45646318793296814,
1.0183194875717163,
0.4026087522506714,
-0.23665237426757812,
-0.19849731028079987,
0.9279138445854187,
-0.2395620048046112,
-0.42518681287765503,
0.31786075234413147,
0.38602596521377563,
0.3463115692138672,
0.08251936733722687,
-0.5508999824523926,
0.394035667181015,
-0.20422744750976562,
0.2772819697856903,
0.36764687299728394,
0.09255541115999222,
0.10134032368659973,
0.8827489614486694,
0.7794327735900879,
0.5084190368652344,
0.15814906358718872,
0.17253369092941284,
0.6483299732208252,
-0.7645998597145081,
-0.6840237975120544,
-0.6405854821205139,
0.1611730307340622,
-0.0338042713701725,
0.025427911430597305,
0.7346505522727966,
0.7030925154685974,
0.668696403503418,
0.1011800691485405,
0.5910741686820984,
-0.08323923498392105,
1.0305960178375244,
-0.43449872732162476,
0.9727122783660889,
-0.4397469758987427,
0.028959380462765694,
-0.23199234902858734,
-0.36072108149528503,
-0.5492156744003296,
0.7506188154220581,
-0.14712649583816528,
-0.07356631010770798,
0.4733032286167145,
0.7120625376701355,
-0.03224949538707733,
0.16640688478946686,
0.2817314863204956,
-0.09941618144512177,
0.18679945170879364,
0.06371205300092697,
0.7576600313186646,
-0.47326162457466125,
0.5497217774391174,
0.008688499219715595,
0.006139654666185379,
-0.2791854739189148,
-0.2929856479167938,
-0.4217083752155304,
-0.983312726020813,
-0.38152870535850525,
-0.2051561027765274,
0.38968193531036377,
0.9466325640678406,
0.8083276152610779,
-1.0843912363052368,
-0.7846441864967346,
-0.15053389966487885,
-0.2852189838886261,
-0.12794046103954315,
-0.22786478698253632,
0.43528181314468384,
0.10298582166433334,
-0.6675150990486145,
0.3890939950942993,
0.48124709725379944,
0.24085505306720734,
-0.13183580338954926,
-0.07650995254516602,
-0.6489396691322327,
-0.17150676250457764,
0.35698023438453674,
0.7900506258010864,
-0.7036843299865723,
-0.10931398719549179,
-0.1762937307357788,
-0.0943748727440834,
0.39996418356895447,
0.5857734680175781,
-0.4760926365852356,
0.5048578381538391,
0.4665813446044922,
0.7736368179321289,
0.5018743276596069,
0.1733608990907669,
0.5048622488975525,
-0.591731071472168,
0.10447633266448975,
0.4837566018104553,
0.07963406294584274,
0.6950482726097107,
-0.3494530916213989,
0.28260332345962524,
0.11298518627882004,
-0.5390356183052063,
-1.0253733396530151,
0.08863390982151031,
-1.0405402183532715,
0.18082545697689056,
0.8838980793952942,
0.1557675153017044,
-0.2002604454755783,
-0.5905081033706665,
-0.4113822877407074,
0.7579349875450134,
-0.46763336658477783,
0.6380000114440918,
0.4334491193294525,
-0.5594472289085388,
-0.3748700022697449,
-0.5931269526481628,
0.663091778755188,
0.024732984602451324,
-0.604212760925293,
-0.22750066220760345,
0.22691208124160767,
0.19123205542564392,
0.5408178567886353,
0.9257433414459229,
-0.15502510964870453,
0.27584484219551086,
0.1403007060289383,
0.24235041439533234,
0.14784203469753265,
-0.20163612067699432,
-0.7368160486221313,
0.24941056966781616,
0.18056845664978027,
-0.5009093284606934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18134v1 | Assessing "Implicit" Retrieval Robustness of Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | 2024-06-26T07:38:24 | Xiaoyu Shen, Rexhina Blloshmi, Dawei Zhu, Jiahuan Pei, Wei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation has gained popularity as a framework to
enhance large language models with external knowledge. However, its
effectiveness hinges on the retrieval robustness of the model. If the model
lacks retrieval robustness, its performance is constrained by the accuracy of
the retriever, resulting in significant compromises when the retrieved context
is irrelevant. In this paper, we evaluate the "implicit" retrieval robustness
of various large language models, instructing them to directly output the final
answer without explicitly judging the relevance of the retrieved context. Our
findings reveal that fine-tuning on a mix of gold and distracting context
significantly enhances the model's robustness to retrieval inaccuracies, while
still maintaining its ability to extract correct answers when retrieval is
accurate. This suggests that large language models can implicitly handle
relevant or irrelevant retrieved context by learning solely from the
supervision of the final answer in an end-to-end manner. Introducing an
additional process for explicit relevance judgment can be unnecessary and
disrupts the end-to-end approach. | [
-0.24090756475925446,
-0.902613639831543,
0.7519333958625793,
0.006327885203063488,
-0.10831558704376221,
-0.27273374795913696,
-0.42704010009765625,
-0.6570047736167908,
-0.4678419530391693,
0.2646494209766388,
-0.28333580493927,
-0.23615047335624695,
-0.697143018245697,
0.1959037184715271,
-0.6058364510536194,
0.8773589730262756,
0.2738937735557556,
-0.24377590417861938,
-0.20510564744472504,
-0.12610042095184326,
-0.4639469385147095,
-0.5458793044090271,
-0.6144998669624329,
-0.1666133552789688,
0.38889947533607483,
0.095343217253685,
0.7522825598716736,
0.6126871109008789,
0.26616302132606506,
0.3747052848339081,
-0.426971435546875,
0.24791355431079865,
-0.65274578332901,
0.4260875880718231,
-0.5389451384544373,
-0.3038754463195801,
-0.36873695254325867,
-0.27134519815444946,
0.6932831406593323,
0.8169572353363037,
0.13884949684143066,
0.31992802023887634,
0.329240083694458,
0.513293981552124,
-1.1561955213546753,
0.19777871668338776,
-1.0081526041030884,
-0.3884446322917938,
0.0670098066329956,
-0.2339717149734497,
-0.747381865978241,
-0.18379151821136475,
0.4037681818008423,
-0.45883455872535706,
0.1822861284017563,
-0.04115636646747589,
0.7550738453865051,
0.3383047580718994,
-0.5807661414146423,
-0.30505993962287903,
-1.00397789478302,
0.7011301517486572,
-0.48548266291618347,
0.2541225552558899,
0.723847508430481,
0.314134418964386,
0.040423210710287094,
-0.8153311610221863,
-0.22423559427261353,
-0.530272901058197,
-0.1494292914867401,
0.05495906248688698,
-0.03285728394985199,
0.05269688367843628,
0.49099627137184143,
0.3038310408592224,
-0.1820865422487259,
-0.1235010102391243,
-0.1870461106300354,
-0.07186346501111984,
0.46704408526420593,
-0.22012680768966675,
0.2630261480808258,
-0.04691585153341293,
-0.008158180862665176,
0.0503072664141655,
-0.7257097363471985,
-0.02612481638789177,
0.4620937705039978,
0.6836990714073181,
0.32748937606811523,
0.6572551727294922,
-0.3914530277252197,
0.6323966383934021,
0.23955075442790985,
0.21568597853183746,
0.022481556981801987,
-0.3397938311100006,
-0.05806707218289375,
-0.040646325796842575,
0.4033801555633545,
-0.01553255133330822,
0.2852708101272583,
-0.3720523715019226,
-0.44449540972709656,
-0.18911203742027283,
0.3638765513896942,
-0.8196737170219421,
0.06869027763605118,
0.3779553771018982,
-0.09589635580778122,
-0.054303254932165146,
0.09719738364219666,
-0.45425599813461304,
-0.04297185689210892,
-0.18716642260551453,
0.6766946911811829,
-0.25008395314216614,
-0.2616254687309265,
-0.1713879257440567,
0.044385962188243866,
0.09168922156095505,
0.3178589940071106,
-1.00624680519104,
0.13678307831287384,
0.8056246638298035,
0.6430454850196838,
0.11565949767827988,
0.02622745744884014,
-1.103525161743164,
0.3189776837825775,
-0.48431745171546936,
0.5989770889282227,
-0.7056290507316589,
-0.33016371726989746,
0.33452287316322327,
0.06386709213256836,
0.09223603457212448,
-0.5000185370445251,
0.7889798283576965,
-0.8521220088005066,
0.13571980595588684,
-0.5201183557510376,
-0.31674933433532715,
-0.05066268518567085,
0.29686564207077026,
-0.6775267124176025,
0.9681521058082581,
0.056807540357112885,
-0.6762863397598267,
0.5602177977561951,
-0.22132138907909393,
-0.418820858001709,
-0.040522415190935135,
0.047841355204582214,
-0.2655900716781616,
0.1954684853553772,
0.35521817207336426,
0.31523770093917847,
-0.023941846564412117,
0.33483365178108215,
-0.5462071299552917,
-0.6114537119865417,
0.08714766800403595,
-0.5953983664512634,
0.4702424108982086,
0.07341895252466202,
-0.36019280552864075,
-0.030241260305047035,
-0.8028119206428528,
0.046600885689258575,
-0.1495557427406311,
-0.45124492049217224,
-0.6833171844482422,
-0.0426124669611454,
-0.09000707417726517,
0.2542872726917267,
0.34652864933013916,
-0.3827125132083893,
-0.050610896199941635,
-0.5391438007354736,
0.16781316697597504,
0.9186483025550842,
-0.0947721004486084,
0.6165487766265869,
-0.19810612499713898,
0.20627495646476746,
-0.27558043599128723,
0.06698328256607056,
-0.23009835183620453,
-0.18773500621318817,
-0.5851386189460754,
-0.12716974318027496,
0.45602917671203613,
0.38823506236076355,
-0.6686061024665833,
0.36945968866348267,
-0.4495636820793152,
-0.14731799066066742,
-0.3143799901008606,
0.36817166209220886,
0.6034449934959412,
0.6240230202674866,
0.3498479127883911,
0.03478986769914627,
-0.32448092103004456,
-0.8679671883583069,
-0.46480563282966614,
-0.24147193133831024,
0.02750297449529171,
0.5481175184249878,
0.605617880821228,
-0.23925623297691345,
0.7650597095489502,
-0.13432487845420837,
0.018351230770349503,
0.07708217948675156,
0.1597667634487152,
0.052188120782375336,
0.6004334092140198,
0.4113151431083679,
-0.9830116033554077,
-0.4122765362262726,
0.24149616062641144,
-0.7424578666687012,
-0.15928322076797485,
0.1274394541978836,
-0.17132094502449036,
0.24647758901119232,
0.5091418623924255,
-0.6351000070571899,
0.24072609841823578,
0.18931405246257782,
-0.2673514485359192,
0.4749763607978821,
-0.37121033668518066,
0.10733018070459366,
-0.7645393013954163,
0.6808809638023376,
-0.27960798144340515,
-0.22016717493534088,
-0.4483499228954315,
0.3587297797203064,
0.16989700496196747,
0.22671516239643097,
-0.35404956340789795,
0.7088955044746399,
-0.5778300762176514,
-0.25122806429862976,
-0.2595428228378296,
0.22101233899593353,
-0.04400922730565071,
0.17213338613510132,
-0.01403774879872799,
0.9639455676078796,
0.27864670753479004,
-0.808997631072998,
0.0007775256526656449,
0.22837050259113312,
-0.25290408730506897,
0.4321732819080353,
-0.7468674182891846,
0.21354703605175018,
-0.47608211636543274,
-0.026353556662797928,
-0.9239557385444641,
-0.428461492061615,
-0.23203659057617188,
-0.43757787346839905,
0.5466539859771729,
-0.5261344313621521,
-0.5090519189834595,
-0.08885861933231354,
-0.24966071546077728,
0.41691869497299194,
0.525022029876709,
-0.6050102710723877,
0.616303026676178,
0.05055036023259163,
-0.3460817039012909,
-1.0283821821212769,
-0.5035569667816162,
-0.10818038880825043,
-0.17894777655601501,
-0.4626910090446472,
0.05318930000066757,
-0.1126113012433052,
-0.3099524676799774,
0.0008699338068254292,
-0.27326318621635437,
0.004401125945150852,
0.25792133808135986,
0.05271569639444351,
0.19985546171665192,
-0.11638787388801575,
0.0872349664568901,
0.12247537821531296,
-0.08351073414087296,
0.13232772052288055,
-0.06619236618280411,
0.3670288622379303,
-0.18593795597553253,
-0.5365145206451416,
0.12691374123096466,
0.34484925866127014,
0.6657543182373047,
-0.34531575441360474,
0.8850992321968079,
0.5381685495376587,
-0.507993757724762,
-0.12307974696159363,
-0.6311126947402954,
-0.12023348361253738,
-0.5159525871276855,
0.4393870532512665,
-0.375725120306015,
-0.910413920879364,
0.717573344707489,
-0.014764824882149696,
0.14796067774295807,
0.4772513508796692,
0.41023918986320496,
0.2608124613761902,
1.6671617031097412,
0.5964992642402649,
0.24351072311401367,
0.5507468581199646,
-0.06286651641130447,
0.04473232850432396,
-1.1020563840866089,
-0.32750287652015686,
-0.7987224459648132,
0.16588369011878967,
-0.5600793361663818,
0.15804749727249146,
0.2643793821334839,
0.33474001288414,
-0.4853723645210266,
-0.010562810115516186,
-0.3648398816585541,
0.4282645881175995,
0.5137743949890137,
0.10508722811937332,
0.5201398730278015,
0.07217296957969666,
-0.1069570779800415,
0.01206121314316988,
-0.3935820162296295,
-0.627812385559082,
0.9846358895301819,
0.11184671521186829,
0.6604191660881042,
0.42148005962371826,
0.17789039015769958,
0.12910860776901245,
0.4267014265060425,
-0.4681476950645447,
0.2995589077472687,
-0.08933786302804947,
-0.6840882897377014,
-0.19187214970588684,
-0.6122819185256958,
-1.1048774719238281,
0.45082712173461914,
-0.19837509095668793,
-0.9949225783348083,
0.20194216072559357,
0.23798169195652008,
-0.44215714931488037,
-0.09853021800518036,
-0.8596654534339905,
0.6405960321426392,
-0.1481066197156906,
-0.8969427943229675,
0.13194341957569122,
-0.6123055815696716,
0.5182226896286011,
-0.29935258626937866,
0.1897139996290207,
0.1060701310634613,
-0.10211312770843506,
0.2591552734375,
-0.23866169154644012,
0.5808929204940796,
0.011387682519853115,
-0.3841997981071472,
0.10354685038328171,
0.3484320044517517,
0.6373898983001709,
0.23926356434822083,
-0.3014906048774719,
-0.5142921805381775,
0.07244925945997238,
-0.4228338301181793,
-0.8013338446617126,
0.9211786389350891,
-0.5852651000022888,
-0.8500295281410217,
-0.25807783007621765,
-0.47305864095687866,
-0.48210808634757996,
0.5003743767738342,
0.24757501482963562,
0.5715240240097046,
-0.0009156748419627547,
0.3685191869735718,
0.7399640083312988,
-0.27984297275543213,
0.30192703008651733,
0.5842553973197937,
-0.22303317487239838,
-0.18446852266788483,
0.7753919363021851,
0.2309432029724121,
0.4929948151111603,
0.18796977400779724,
0.06598789244890213,
-0.6677758693695068,
-0.47982868552207947,
-0.47749245166778564,
0.1011146605014801,
-0.8390566110610962,
-0.025390485301613808,
-0.6542379856109619,
-0.129425510764122,
-0.38495874404907227,
-0.008784323930740356,
-0.2919081747531891,
-0.12256958335638046,
-0.27029815316200256,
-0.1410517394542694,
0.07409054040908813,
0.6437917351722717,
0.06300468742847443,
-0.02942507341504097,
-0.8094141483306885,
0.11167426407337189,
0.5701617002487183,
0.3802976906299591,
0.014333009719848633,
-0.7121890187263489,
-0.036278679966926575,
0.19373542070388794,
0.08173263072967529,
-0.560998797416687,
0.18112605810165405,
0.3686329126358032,
0.5927838683128357,
0.3895709216594696,
0.22566913068294525,
0.738304853439331,
-0.42563915252685547,
0.809421718120575,
-0.41693490743637085,
-0.8902550935745239,
0.8321903944015503,
-0.466117262840271,
0.4624272882938385,
0.7474882006645203,
0.22401630878448486,
0.0923505425453186,
-0.37756362557411194,
-0.5627858638763428,
-1.228467345237732,
0.5706676244735718,
0.21052590012550354,
0.47028958797454834,
-0.21393795311450958,
0.5866547226905823,
-0.05739041045308113,
0.3086688220500946,
-0.7369810342788696,
0.0032103981357067823,
0.1623867154121399,
-0.012054191902279854,
0.07129603624343872,
-0.48707014322280884,
-0.06631199270486832,
-0.06722299009561539,
0.8465131521224976,
-0.30750516057014465,
0.01941533572971821,
0.1684613674879074,
-0.3454573452472687,
-0.3239469826221466,
0.3317594826221466,
0.4353449046611786,
0.7933228015899658,
-0.4473528265953064,
0.28032323718070984,
0.25599926710128784,
-0.3857351541519165,
-0.037966158241033554,
0.1346241533756256,
-0.5601204633712769,
-0.1514083296060562,
0.4837820529937744,
0.5621939301490784,
0.2858700454235077,
-0.8532306551933289,
0.657325804233551,
-0.14949093759059906,
0.16845862567424774,
-0.23869392275810242,
0.104856938123703,
-0.302542507648468,
0.17063650488853455,
0.6298407912254333,
0.09292728453874588,
0.30228275060653687,
-0.6618809103965759,
0.22161072492599487,
0.7807613611221313,
-0.37155881524086,
-0.2383619248867035,
0.8878858089447021,
-0.09232574701309204,
0.07659319788217545,
0.6527090072631836,
0.028093667700886726,
-0.4348694086074829,
0.40028253197669983,
0.7279803156852722,
0.6984211206436157,
-0.1758800446987152,
-0.16317389905452728,
0.4805859625339508,
0.43023279309272766,
-0.31135353446006775,
0.12161316722631454,
-0.22692176699638367,
-0.46167513728141785,
-0.8656287789344788,
-0.5626677870750427,
-0.1566116213798523,
0.23780854046344757,
-0.9687615036964417,
0.013268419541418552,
-0.25926995277404785,
-0.26184287667274475,
-0.344156950712204,
-0.10486619919538498,
-0.4152318239212036,
0.2888590395450592,
-0.028806960210204124,
0.9066000580787659,
-0.6608586311340332,
0.4620169997215271,
0.6836327910423279,
-0.5434687733650208,
-0.6068835258483887,
0.14859457314014435,
-0.4213590621948242,
-0.5384387969970703,
0.6253728866577148,
0.22797532379627228,
-0.34639284014701843,
-0.030745934695005417,
-0.683322548866272,
-1.1000088453292847,
0.8625050187110901,
0.8692377805709839,
-0.16205382347106934,
0.02442464418709278,
-0.27053219079971313,
0.745038628578186,
0.17933155596256256,
0.520598828792572,
0.4713512361049652,
0.32080399990081787,
0.3103107213973999,
-0.9549121856689453,
0.18531356751918793,
-0.48974424600601196,
0.19002309441566467,
-0.00033939321292564273,
-0.4814361035823822,
0.7085369229316711,
-0.1346292346715927,
-0.47973373532295227,
0.3132164180278778,
0.7274684309959412,
0.24837049841880798,
0.0011619329452514648,
0.4046090245246887,
0.31493592262268066,
0.7470128536224365,
-0.13680113852024078,
1.283024787902832,
-0.2711361050605774,
0.4369143843650818,
1.10289466381073,
-0.2813393771648407,
1.1508795022964478,
0.3225909471511841,
0.16169776022434235,
0.21877864003181458,
0.31323716044425964,
0.41992029547691345,
0.6914697289466858,
-0.20465683937072754,
-0.39305734634399414,
-0.4337758421897888,
-0.2530921697616577,
-0.515916645526886,
0.20108675956726074,
0.46271881461143494,
-0.41656315326690674,
-0.24259315431118011,
-0.19547633826732635,
-0.016439002007246017,
0.1881849467754364,
-0.43094316124916077,
0.8163155913352966,
0.008005492389202118,
-1.0579547882080078,
0.6848496198654175,
-0.2123105823993683,
0.4695678949356079,
-0.5174944996833801,
-0.20233795046806335,
-0.17672845721244812,
0.3241867423057556,
-0.2935134172439575,
-0.7021576166152954,
0.28576335310935974,
0.11494982987642288,
-0.17868341505527496,
0.08407598733901978,
0.804393470287323,
-0.4529929757118225,
-0.36270198225975037,
0.36100709438323975,
0.5681082606315613,
-0.23069454729557037,
-0.1435103565454483,
-0.39755624532699585,
0.028790727257728577,
-0.30006492137908936,
-0.3206944465637207,
0.46478545665740967,
0.5406065583229065,
-0.0007277451222762465,
0.9088093042373657,
0.8383896946907043,
0.02344515547156334,
0.08037542551755905,
0.025798162445425987,
0.7005995512008667,
-0.16118508577346802,
-0.3398440182209015,
-0.948097288608551,
0.4795406460762024,
-0.143262580037117,
-0.13277576863765717,
0.945185124874115,
0.37182292342185974,
0.8050941228866577,
0.15410183370113373,
0.7161251306533813,
0.08676940202713013,
0.4431951642036438,
-0.5377728939056396,
0.5860827565193176,
-0.6468912363052368,
0.5572891235351562,
-0.4598729908466339,
-1.040255069732666,
-0.27116858959198,
0.6265780925750732,
-0.46649351716041565,
0.5966565012931824,
0.32570382952690125,
0.7139298319816589,
-0.2936331629753113,
-0.1707758903503418,
0.3772166073322296,
0.3700089156627655,
0.10242507606744766,
0.30081048607826233,
0.9123578667640686,
-0.37352150678634644,
0.6705306768417358,
-0.09440408647060394,
-0.1704706847667694,
-0.15115202963352203,
-0.9287360906600952,
-0.8320348262786865,
-0.5700016617774963,
-0.09403686970472336,
-0.6417352557182312,
0.2218397855758667,
0.7474607825279236,
0.670741081237793,
-0.8054788708686829,
0.340891033411026,
-0.021242590621113777,
-0.006939874961972237,
-0.153832346200943,
-0.20881974697113037,
0.47834283113479614,
-0.48787587881088257,
-0.9312347769737244,
0.33000943064689636,
0.04384555295109749,
-0.08881458640098572,
-0.23610396683216095,
0.10880716145038605,
-0.20440515875816345,
-0.05829073488712311,
0.8222277760505676,
0.4111381769180298,
-0.6489871144294739,
-0.6295405626296997,
0.013018442317843437,
-0.18931376934051514,
-0.2936663031578064,
0.4117088317871094,
-0.7847474813461304,
0.4936550259590149,
0.3879396319389343,
0.8733727931976318,
0.4367729723453522,
0.40947839617729187,
0.7530323266983032,
-1.0635690689086914,
-0.020058760419487953,
0.05914568156003952,
0.4273442029953003,
0.4281194508075714,
-0.6322529911994934,
0.46873876452445984,
-0.11431252956390381,
-0.628812849521637,
-1.0123493671417236,
0.1255875527858734,
-0.6531564593315125,
-0.27565211057662964,
1.4234766960144043,
-0.17925551533699036,
-0.2845272421836853,
-0.26730331778526306,
-0.29148605465888977,
0.2353895753622055,
-0.32285070419311523,
0.8170733451843262,
0.6557613611221313,
0.27617180347442627,
-0.13867083191871643,
-0.8137364983558655,
0.4248144030570984,
0.6329571604728699,
-0.5526247024536133,
0.1464499533176422,
0.5762738585472107,
0.3164598047733307,
0.25279995799064636,
0.38436686992645264,
-0.1409924179315567,
0.34603118896484375,
-0.17751997709274292,
-0.5173927545547485,
-0.027865568175911903,
-0.3048366606235504,
-0.36964693665504456,
0.32178884744644165,
0.42174020409584045,
0.2403288632631302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18133v1 | ConvoCache: Smart Re-Use of Chatbot Responses | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | 2024-06-26T07:35:10 | Conor Atkins, Ian Wood, Mohamed Ali Kaafar, Hassan Asghar, Nardine Basta, Michal Kepkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present ConvoCache, a conversational caching system that solves the
problem of slow and expensive generative AI models in spoken chatbots.
ConvoCache finds a semantically similar prompt in the past and reuses the
response. In this paper we evaluate ConvoCache on the DailyDialog dataset. We
find that ConvoCache can apply a UniEval coherence threshold of 90% and respond
to 89% of prompts using the cache with an average latency of 214ms, replacing
LLM and voice synthesis that can take over 1s. To further reduce latency we
test prefetching and find limited usefulness. Prefetching with 80% of a request
leads to a 63% hit rate, and a drop in overall coherence. ConvoCache can be
used with any chatbot to reduce costs by reducing usage of generative AI by up
to 89%. | [
-0.4252128303050995,
-1.027172565460205,
0.21751336753368378,
0.09783301502466202,
-0.25952035188674927,
0.16896501183509827,
0.0045126681216061115,
-0.7885259985923767,
0.6314799189567566,
0.6295256018638611,
-0.8836208581924438,
-0.14167235791683197,
-0.10145161300897598,
-0.12174856662750244,
-0.8093308806419373,
0.7183897495269775,
0.513783872127533,
-0.09228157252073288,
-0.41488003730773926,
0.263363242149353,
-0.765450656414032,
-0.3739348351955414,
-1.249638319015503,
-0.48953357338905334,
0.49852755665779114,
0.7509005665779114,
0.9744546413421631,
-0.2728695571422577,
0.2893218696117401,
0.3685043752193451,
0.15250444412231445,
0.0605839379131794,
-0.751132071018219,
0.6705955266952515,
0.15832778811454773,
-0.6066120862960815,
-0.3104715049266815,
0.0013354395050555468,
0.038981515914201736,
0.5025923252105713,
-0.36276233196258545,
-0.10205528140068054,
0.09470932930707932,
0.4715937674045563,
-0.8380488157272339,
0.11022860556840897,
-0.9003092646598816,
0.15718023478984833,
0.0033036626409739256,
-0.29202190041542053,
-0.5601998567581177,
-0.43956443667411804,
0.473488450050354,
-0.8433389067649841,
0.6037744879722595,
-0.15417969226837158,
0.47993457317352295,
0.5706484913825989,
0.3081319034099579,
-0.37982261180877686,
-0.6649580001831055,
0.7011124491691589,
-0.6515294313430786,
0.16140589118003845,
0.5762646198272705,
0.5723613500595093,
-0.497855007648468,
-0.9252244234085083,
-0.8943110704421997,
-0.4341190457344055,
0.10513186454772949,
0.3984878957271576,
-0.3328840732574463,
-0.04140634462237358,
0.09587123245000839,
0.42736753821372986,
-0.4504861831665039,
0.12078005075454712,
0.10746771842241287,
-0.742652416229248,
0.4257790148258209,
0.490631103515625,
0.4120155870914459,
0.31510764360427856,
-0.1844746619462967,
-0.29421356320381165,
-0.5951191186904907,
0.3204476833343506,
0.3697647750377655,
0.24451428651809692,
0.0473971888422966,
0.3198793828487396,
-0.4308733344078064,
0.5573543310165405,
0.13368259370326996,
0.11488952487707138,
0.14669926464557648,
-0.4872925877571106,
-0.35860806703567505,
0.27270883321762085,
0.7068721055984497,
0.31154710054397583,
0.362017422914505,
-0.09742481261491776,
0.2327231615781784,
0.09066197276115417,
0.5366020798683167,
-1.1901609897613525,
-0.4560698866844177,
0.4348849654197693,
-0.23327867686748505,
-0.22052735090255737,
-0.4113509953022003,
-0.693522036075592,
-0.4276166558265686,
0.1435210257768631,
0.11219472438097,
-0.35589274764060974,
-0.024356607347726822,
0.21862338483333588,
-0.21814888715744019,
0.16815568506717682,
0.7540996670722961,
-0.7550129294395447,
0.35141244530677795,
0.49866917729377747,
0.8827452063560486,
0.002152325352653861,
0.038395628333091736,
-0.6081663966178894,
-0.3158787786960602,
-0.21920529007911682,
1.171049952507019,
-0.7030221223831177,
-0.8369645476341248,
-0.007601222023367882,
0.19444595277309418,
0.2227673977613449,
-0.6030256748199463,
0.35488161444664,
-0.6046687364578247,
0.35383927822113037,
-0.20916563272476196,
-0.4982425570487976,
-0.18986858427524567,
0.19944410026073456,
-0.8669576048851013,
0.6299596428871155,
-0.17001326382160187,
-0.4442448616027832,
0.2876686751842499,
-0.5336939096450806,
-0.5423458218574524,
0.3465414345264435,
0.18454742431640625,
-0.4242686629295349,
-0.27664780616760254,
0.1829601377248764,
0.2566850185394287,
-0.3805942237377167,
0.10532695800065994,
-0.4229603707790375,
-0.7057147026062012,
0.13962218165397644,
-0.7266069650650024,
0.9229462146759033,
0.3804823160171509,
-0.31838494539260864,
-0.043648991733789444,
-0.6825307011604309,
0.1983671337366104,
0.05189473554491997,
-0.1234062984585762,
-0.12204089015722275,
0.2513497471809387,
-0.07775042951107025,
-0.14925353229045868,
0.2837580740451813,
-0.6636793613433838,
-0.0055647725239396095,
-0.6860290169715881,
0.4674750566482544,
0.5710806846618652,
0.05693956837058067,
0.24487663805484772,
-0.2830069959163666,
0.39445531368255615,
-0.05866056680679321,
0.19819165766239166,
-0.3964264988899231,
-0.5418150424957275,
-1.0133252143859863,
-0.3164134621620178,
-0.06194327399134636,
0.5361188054084778,
-0.7709158658981323,
0.4766908586025238,
0.10692582279443741,
-0.8302673697471619,
-0.618484616279602,
-0.13479110598564148,
0.3369280993938446,
0.5842734575271606,
0.3977210223674774,
-0.7083868384361267,
-0.13184092938899994,
-0.8621828556060791,
0.08464423567056656,
-0.1711244285106659,
-0.10615674406290054,
0.25527599453926086,
0.04058649763464928,
-0.2221103310585022,
0.8784568905830383,
-0.258897066116333,
0.07772428542375565,
0.10629170387983322,
0.08844270557165146,
0.07093975692987442,
0.5269786715507507,
0.3584788143634796,
-0.5596516132354736,
-0.4391106963157654,
-0.49989962577819824,
-0.41936513781547546,
-0.208335280418396,
-0.24365143477916718,
-0.06934479624032974,
0.2654540240764618,
0.6218317747116089,
-0.7837495803833008,
0.6366934776306152,
0.6468244194984436,
-0.08622409403324127,
0.40986916422843933,
-0.18551163375377655,
0.20720553398132324,
-1.0121169090270996,
0.11013277620077133,
-0.7042919397354126,
-0.37237048149108887,
-0.3827556371688843,
-0.14848533272743225,
-0.40895766019821167,
-0.5029377937316895,
-0.6971928477287292,
0.5962971448898315,
-0.24411243200302124,
0.09622200578451157,
-0.5871691703796387,
0.18088845908641815,
-0.13107147812843323,
0.5121960639953613,
-0.37831851840019226,
0.9230542778968811,
0.46747636795043945,
-0.847832441329956,
0.7344372868537903,
0.1958065927028656,
-0.19372035562992096,
0.4903015196323395,
-1.0502489805221558,
0.5414590239524841,
0.21658945083618164,
0.841605007648468,
-1.354788064956665,
0.002912017982453108,
0.4900910258293152,
-0.44612929224967957,
-0.11031579971313477,
0.04570639505982399,
-0.5690308213233948,
-0.21620285511016846,
-0.28962549567222595,
0.3511805534362793,
0.3088017404079437,
-0.48947542905807495,
0.5122868418693542,
0.46319907903671265,
-0.07565934956073761,
-0.42310643196105957,
-0.4105822443962097,
0.29973021149635315,
0.2679082453250885,
-0.6432790160179138,
0.3758177161216736,
-0.39026719331741333,
0.024058615788817406,
-0.11055279523134232,
-0.05164647102355957,
0.20640750229358673,
0.3757016360759735,
0.4857678711414337,
-0.0766918733716011,
0.19561587274074554,
0.1533401906490326,
-0.1468771994113922,
-0.39582663774490356,
-0.16147483885288239,
-0.0915055200457573,
1.2849793434143066,
0.09334665536880493,
-0.3386480212211609,
-0.9609097838401794,
0.5484780073165894,
0.5796922445297241,
0.05645642802119255,
0.5906083583831787,
0.4100203216075897,
-0.36059635877609253,
0.1953064203262329,
-0.532976508140564,
-0.5401605367660522,
-0.5334020853042603,
0.07107123732566833,
-0.3089660704135895,
-0.8567461371421814,
0.9066519141197205,
0.26931044459342957,
0.3658505082130432,
0.46262940764427185,
0.8791431784629822,
-0.29728570580482483,
0.7945329546928406,
0.44401875138282776,
-0.26300978660583496,
0.8777978420257568,
-0.27226129174232483,
0.3666878342628479,
-0.049057792872190475,
-0.27125871181488037,
-0.7825214862823486,
-0.41951531171798706,
-0.8660038709640503,
-0.12905167043209076,
0.02335214801132679,
-0.4284660220146179,
-0.1992190033197403,
0.4095730483531952,
-0.37644729018211365,
0.24608556926250458,
0.6689265370368958,
0.3443695902824402,
0.1524227410554886,
-0.1559821218252182,
0.3030003011226654,
0.287212610244751,
-0.54032963514328,
-0.21854667365550995,
0.6469364762306213,
-0.16176722943782806,
0.9873642325401306,
-0.13143771886825562,
0.4369156062602997,
0.48113828897476196,
-0.11617967486381531,
-0.9461339712142944,
0.845853865146637,
-0.003006362123414874,
-0.4688606858253479,
-0.4631582796573639,
-0.17292892932891846,
-1.4941859245300293,
-0.06415790319442749,
-0.14444904029369354,
-0.5243666172027588,
-0.02217124216258526,
0.3733404278755188,
-0.5263757109642029,
-0.03289158642292023,
-0.890819251537323,
0.5639920234680176,
0.2648071348667145,
-0.16344231367111206,
-0.8949738144874573,
-0.5891797542572021,
-0.16734786331653595,
0.18451504409313202,
-0.37704434990882874,
-0.22320610284805298,
0.3983090817928314,
0.5894575715065002,
-0.8478657603263855,
1.2353894710540771,
-0.30988478660583496,
-0.11245773732662201,
0.6934190392494202,
0.3074685037136078,
0.7163364291191101,
0.13484632968902588,
0.14842809736728668,
0.09710435569286346,
0.03515540063381195,
-0.6718679070472717,
-0.762411892414093,
0.807548463344574,
-0.6474761962890625,
-0.887690544128418,
-0.19582481682300568,
-0.3608810603618622,
-0.1544429212808609,
0.13280880451202393,
0.174320250749588,
0.46121975779533386,
-0.4853273332118988,
0.33893775939941406,
0.4444763660430908,
-0.3103368580341339,
0.5108372569084167,
0.5649781227111816,
0.2572050094604492,
0.07903779298067093,
0.586664080619812,
-0.08837854117155075,
0.320073664188385,
0.26627588272094727,
0.13258856534957886,
0.052469901740550995,
-0.12401972711086273,
-0.09432552754878998,
-0.345786988735199,
-0.38446828722953796,
-0.3796933591365814,
-1.002180576324463,
-0.2752183675765991,
-0.3398015797138214,
-0.18513061106204987,
-0.6592830419540405,
-0.3883102834224701,
-0.362772673368454,
0.19285261631011963,
0.48999983072280884,
-0.09166830778121948,
0.19220894575119019,
0.5208320021629333,
-0.6202853918075562,
0.20025424659252167,
0.6375771760940552,
0.06115405261516571,
0.04011533781886101,
-0.2825467884540558,
-0.12716516852378845,
0.39902856945991516,
-0.45768752694129944,
-0.6008763313293457,
0.21509630978107452,
0.1979803740978241,
0.5757710933685303,
0.1792256385087967,
0.1484227180480957,
0.8631374835968018,
-0.3267306387424469,
0.9952206611633301,
0.20384658873081207,
-0.7917408347129822,
0.5663928985595703,
0.110616534948349,
0.6548060774803162,
0.6900730133056641,
-0.003324879566207528,
-0.7698836922645569,
-0.885837733745575,
-0.7848672866821289,
-1.0525755882263184,
0.11552346497774124,
0.17197783291339874,
0.708610475063324,
-0.07702423632144928,
0.30132928490638733,
0.29485729336738586,
-0.005482766777276993,
0.06950236856937408,
0.039119310677051544,
-0.2791953384876251,
-0.029215119779109955,
-0.16626030206680298,
-0.20891860127449036,
0.11133985221385956,
0.07474128156900406,
0.4595039486885071,
-0.14057384431362152,
0.5253318548202515,
0.170818492770195,
-0.11340078711509705,
-0.0006856457912363112,
0.052857547998428345,
0.38597172498703003,
0.22392256557941437,
-0.09201625734567642,
0.06782623380422592,
0.1677602082490921,
-0.6530892848968506,
-0.08857458084821701,
-0.06686442345380783,
-0.030306244269013405,
-0.07825510203838348,
0.2651832699775696,
0.3206922709941864,
0.24313172698020935,
-0.6944804191589355,
0.22209829092025757,
-0.5232663750648499,
0.26841700077056885,
-0.47521957755088806,
0.6270256042480469,
0.003136089537292719,
0.2678625285625458,
0.1267516165971756,
0.14123371243476868,
0.3107761740684509,
-0.8997344374656677,
0.22871087491512299,
0.5547683238983154,
-0.34683674573898315,
-0.2407991588115692,
0.34162595868110657,
0.5311888456344604,
-0.5616317391395569,
0.950168788433075,
0.08448821306228638,
-0.32015541195869446,
0.5652072429656982,
0.4314510226249695,
1.0783175230026245,
-0.1661081314086914,
0.2001548558473587,
0.33869168162345886,
-0.23509691655635834,
0.23259462416172028,
0.15691716969013214,
-0.34750160574913025,
-0.9441575407981873,
-0.3144837021827698,
-0.11194734275341034,
-0.8777600526809692,
0.011210320517420769,
-0.35946518182754517,
0.06754416227340698,
-0.4314397871494293,
-0.2717573642730713,
0.20215871930122375,
0.2778196930885315,
-0.9654444456100464,
0.07227106392383575,
-0.2658304274082184,
0.8218196034431458,
-0.4728073179721832,
0.6641393899917603,
0.06796342879533768,
-0.35141521692276,
-0.35006529092788696,
0.10575760900974274,
-0.0623447485268116,
-1.0973862409591675,
0.16705702245235443,
0.14689257740974426,
-0.7034220099449158,
-0.06662680953741074,
-1.1870803833007812,
-0.5850632786750793,
0.9594642519950867,
0.47362378239631653,
-0.5351686477661133,
0.25902703404426575,
-0.40237024426460266,
0.8390366435050964,
-0.2092902660369873,
0.45095545053482056,
0.5223258137702942,
0.12406380474567413,
0.36280468106269836,
-0.7929235696792603,
0.06911416351795197,
-0.4028419852256775,
-0.21434195339679718,
-0.19651752710342407,
-0.9481600522994995,
0.5530979633331299,
-0.14838485419750214,
-0.6052019596099854,
0.22628240287303925,
0.5610949993133545,
0.09237147867679596,
0.347320556640625,
0.6451684832572937,
0.562856912612915,
0.8433324694633484,
0.09359420835971832,
0.9243156909942627,
-0.15500764548778534,
0.12717127799987793,
1.1215718984603882,
-0.11904938519001007,
0.7187608480453491,
0.4803618788719177,
0.0961238443851471,
0.6079634428024292,
0.7096582651138306,
0.27265191078186035,
0.786386251449585,
0.3627411723136902,
-0.41814762353897095,
-0.3103427290916443,
-0.3628235161304474,
-0.3535017967224121,
0.44509822130203247,
0.2624005973339081,
0.28013235330581665,
-0.2861675024032593,
0.0106011051684618,
0.394917368888855,
-0.2749600112438202,
0.098722442984581,
0.9107046127319336,
-0.012625444680452347,
-0.9067974090576172,
0.6839683651924133,
-0.5644877552986145,
0.5046594142913818,
-0.3984423279762268,
-0.11792296171188354,
-0.5687817335128784,
0.3025301396846771,
0.005326371174305677,
-0.6973389983177185,
0.2372245490550995,
-0.08729622513055801,
-0.2231082022190094,
-0.2087438404560089,
0.8095739483833313,
-0.3307403028011322,
-0.10367941856384277,
0.23942480981349945,
0.337471067905426,
0.30994269251823425,
-0.21091125905513763,
-0.7373203039169312,
-0.13159306347370148,
-0.06698856502771378,
-0.12861354649066925,
0.1046854630112648,
0.19704864919185638,
0.04616213217377663,
0.9502550363540649,
0.9878461956977844,
-0.21067029237747192,
-0.276095449924469,
0.43112701177597046,
1.0508965253829956,
-0.53267502784729,
-0.6221606731414795,
-0.714798092842102,
0.2200675755739212,
-0.09884023666381836,
-0.15323254466056824,
0.5068258047103882,
0.3292877972126007,
0.7875796556472778,
0.25263240933418274,
0.6247289776802063,
-0.06594323366880417,
0.3283839225769043,
-0.5753911137580872,
0.712413489818573,
-0.44530797004699707,
0.028740180656313896,
-0.18910357356071472,
-0.5909347534179688,
-0.10473936796188354,
0.5456026196479797,
0.08896182477474213,
-0.07128938287496567,
0.5083615779876709,
1.0439833402633667,
0.30594831705093384,
0.3573559522628784,
0.35528871417045593,
0.047997742891311646,
0.9432559013366699,
0.6294763088226318,
0.807715654373169,
-0.3293173313140869,
0.5891039371490479,
0.07518094778060913,
-0.1661643385887146,
-0.6032651662826538,
-0.6346928477287292,
-0.7705644965171814,
-0.5302848815917969,
-0.15187928080558777,
-0.40406471490859985,
0.17880868911743164,
0.6884958148002625,
0.617569088935852,
-0.9227365851402283,
0.06757893413305283,
-0.07770364731550217,
-0.02184205874800682,
-0.23261573910713196,
-0.2514495253562927,
0.11039016395807266,
-0.7557681202888489,
-0.7573862075805664,
0.34106606245040894,
0.24308188259601593,
0.17146801948547363,
-0.42586591839790344,
0.2524847090244293,
0.09689773619174957,
0.18404312431812286,
0.4869455397129059,
0.32605868577957153,
-0.4150446951389313,
-0.6737695336341858,
0.12347985059022903,
-0.3707340955734253,
-0.036015428602695465,
0.9209964871406555,
-0.8665080070495605,
0.9113101959228516,
0.6931678652763367,
0.6576064825057983,
0.8457058072090149,
-0.2153305560350418,
0.5387140512466431,
-0.4978853762149811,
0.6747047901153564,
0.4072222113609314,
0.24828608334064484,
0.23009340465068817,
-0.3282370865345001,
0.21119330823421478,
0.3322034180164337,
-0.5523374080657959,
-0.3639509379863739,
0.18082760274410248,
-1.1359167098999023,
-0.1438634842634201,
0.73616623878479,
-0.0790439024567604,
-0.03189217671751976,
-0.3381600081920624,
-0.3997625708580017,
0.38805049657821655,
-0.7700521349906921,
1.0450108051300049,
0.6628929376602173,
-0.09697813540697098,
-0.045264869928359985,
-0.33518317341804504,
0.4165319502353668,
0.5563288331031799,
-0.9030184745788574,
-0.04217983037233353,
0.5701835751533508,
0.13314472138881683,
0.342536598443985,
1.0987216234207153,
-0.019176054745912552,
0.4011309742927551,
0.21365182101726532,
0.04128222167491913,
0.2682696580886841,
-0.40989577770233154,
0.23097756505012512,
0.0019422003533691168,
-0.47013434767723083,
-0.5806066393852234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18125v1 | ResumeAtlas: Revisiting Resume Classification with Large-Scale Datasets and Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | 2024-06-26T07:25:18 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Mohamed, Noran Mohamed, Ali Sharkaway, Ahmed Zaky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | The increasing reliance on online recruitment platforms coupled with the
adoption of AI technologies has highlighted the critical need for efficient
resume classification methods. However, challenges such as small datasets, lack
of standardized resume templates, and privacy concerns hinder the accuracy and
effectiveness of existing classification models. In this work, we address these
challenges by presenting a comprehensive approach to resume classification. We
curated a large-scale dataset of 13,389 resumes from diverse sources and
employed Large Language Models (LLMs) such as BERT and Gemma1.1 2B for
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
traditional machine learning approaches, with our best model achieving a top-1
accuracy of 92\% and a top-5 accuracy of 97.5\%. These findings underscore the
importance of dataset quality and advanced model architectures in enhancing the
accuracy and robustness of resume classification systems, thus advancing the
field of online recruitment practices. | [
0.09982121735811234,
-0.2664143443107605,
0.3636622726917267,
0.2777653634548187,
0.43945327401161194,
0.24628275632858276,
-0.38846904039382935,
-0.4866957366466522,
0.11520539969205856,
0.5940583944320679,
-0.2516109347343445,
-0.7205488681793213,
-0.6494936347007751,
-0.05803907290101051,
-0.5286314487457275,
1.0359106063842773,
0.0979122593998909,
0.04508305341005325,
-0.3816361129283905,
-0.32909950613975525,
-0.6271972060203552,
-0.3328794240951538,
-0.6290613412857056,
-0.09418566524982452,
0.6415489315986633,
0.4656497538089752,
0.12757474184036255,
0.5271371603012085,
0.3112797439098358,
0.2702127695083618,
-0.007040516007691622,
0.40542498230934143,
-0.5212011933326721,
0.3402773141860962,
0.0396064892411232,
-0.6299132108688354,
-0.321643203496933,
0.13274745643138885,
0.5833045840263367,
0.7730005383491516,
-0.5721389055252075,
0.5246195793151855,
0.025513499975204468,
0.5201053023338318,
-0.48838141560554504,
0.3882248103618622,
-0.5382239818572998,
-0.059283893555402756,
-0.26176539063453674,
0.06664898991584778,
-0.751492440700531,
-0.4923174977302551,
0.013944150879979134,
-0.3622376620769501,
0.3367767632007599,
0.04095188528299332,
0.5198754072189331,
-0.16491250693798065,
-0.4405703842639923,
-0.30032435059547424,
-0.6314438581466675,
0.8957018256187439,
-0.3600001335144043,
0.5958625078201294,
0.3452470898628235,
0.9290038347244263,
-0.032148219645023346,
-0.7845903038978577,
-0.2525184750556946,
0.035502851009368896,
0.35143429040908813,
0.011023168452084064,
0.08345704525709152,
0.06681361049413681,
0.16869041323661804,
0.5625836253166199,
-0.7458025217056274,
0.8454902768135071,
-0.6029931902885437,
-0.18742011487483978,
0.5761858820915222,
0.10414008796215057,
0.09004389494657516,
0.36163416504859924,
-0.14546772837638855,
-0.3769960105419159,
-0.6148183345794678,
0.007596204988658428,
0.4241575598716736,
0.572644829750061,
0.0755973607301712,
0.4017200469970703,
-0.30374687910079956,
0.923046886920929,
-0.1021275743842125,
-0.3012310862541199,
0.31790387630462646,
0.03654944896697998,
-0.17011725902557373,
-0.012149604968726635,
0.45361101627349854,
0.5325512886047363,
-0.06435740739107132,
-0.17931444942951202,
-0.3467126786708832,
-0.04282766580581665,
0.6354238390922546,
-0.6974390149116516,
-0.16103093326091766,
0.3803142309188843,
-0.6721124649047852,
-0.316546767950058,
0.3601278066635132,
-0.6775162816047668,
-0.6728528738021851,
-0.23506420850753784,
0.07570946961641312,
-0.0269929226487875,
0.2623042166233063,
0.04809121415019035,
0.005541376769542694,
0.271259605884552,
0.9499650001525879,
-0.5415007472038269,
0.04850269481539726,
0.8514464497566223,
0.903956413269043,
-0.3114185035228729,
0.0931033343076706,
-0.6568009257316589,
-0.08736322820186615,
-0.23081083595752716,
0.581471860408783,
-0.6464798450469971,
0.10504862666130066,
0.5841816663742065,
0.216817706823349,
0.0007607754087075591,
-0.566243052482605,
0.601432204246521,
-0.9300422668457031,
0.4594480097293854,
-0.001930702943354845,
-0.6433789730072021,
-0.6219413876533508,
0.6857660412788391,
-0.7422996163368225,
0.675940752029419,
0.48019152879714966,
-0.33522701263427734,
0.5671383142471313,
-0.468740850687027,
-0.030257776379585266,
0.044087670743465424,
-0.29515689611434937,
-0.4156019985675812,
-0.012437681667506695,
-0.07402393966913223,
0.8916990160942078,
-0.3033181428909302,
0.10288317501544952,
-0.04441365599632263,
-0.42586106061935425,
0.13411730527877808,
0.0006173882866278291,
0.7249020934104919,
0.310611367225647,
0.15570393204689026,
0.09483406692743301,
-0.5980293154716492,
-0.10446958243846893,
-0.1507689654827118,
-0.7860574126243591,
0.031542371958494186,
-0.34430962800979614,
0.49441003799438477,
0.26360416412353516,
0.3550797998905182,
-0.8289313912391663,
0.48619696497917175,
-0.23674635589122772,
0.13479068875312805,
0.7553145289421082,
-0.41025036573410034,
0.3999779224395752,
-0.5549837350845337,
0.597990870475769,
-0.16203677654266357,
-0.08864641189575195,
-0.3038468062877655,
-0.6321500539779663,
-0.24397581815719604,
-0.6369660496711731,
0.29227274656295776,
0.8452949523925781,
-0.30335959792137146,
0.8618926405906677,
-0.5201343894004822,
-0.9649949073791504,
-0.2676282525062561,
0.22805821895599365,
0.18504521250724792,
0.30559810996055603,
0.46074044704437256,
-0.38844582438468933,
-0.5648153424263,
-0.7767161130905151,
-0.2544329762458801,
-0.19662056863307953,
-0.40982553362846375,
0.30718812346458435,
0.08670179545879364,
-0.6671107411384583,
0.5685635805130005,
-0.36628854274749756,
-0.6431028246879578,
-0.37181857228279114,
-0.04435267299413681,
0.6021073460578918,
0.5405852794647217,
0.5915520191192627,
-0.7675560712814331,
-0.26521357893943787,
0.04289981722831726,
-0.6702010631561279,
0.21974365413188934,
-0.2981303930282593,
0.2801353931427002,
-0.028285464271903038,
0.3106336295604706,
-0.634186863899231,
0.22951668500900269,
0.19344493746757507,
-0.04763776808977127,
0.28402140736579895,
-0.0763671025633812,
0.2403651922941208,
-0.9275628328323364,
0.044280003756284714,
0.31275245547294617,
-0.35593247413635254,
-0.5002647042274475,
0.20781460404396057,
0.08924508094787598,
-0.08592969924211502,
-0.2798525393009186,
0.372774213552475,
-0.17251130938529968,
-0.05830106511712074,
-0.3471008837223053,
-0.42664891481399536,
-0.22270330786705017,
0.05426514148712158,
-0.33398663997650146,
0.45730555057525635,
0.590038001537323,
-0.6195954084396362,
0.7250733375549316,
0.7309263944625854,
-0.5279638171195984,
0.5971056222915649,
-0.28984126448631287,
0.045933715999126434,
-0.5382450222969055,
1.079964280128479,
-1.4290410280227661,
-0.7168194651603699,
-0.2105221152305603,
-0.31077197194099426,
0.4629855155944824,
-0.06063278764486313,
-0.821540117263794,
-0.5116230249404907,
-0.5046736598014832,
0.4990624487400055,
0.7791650295257568,
-0.7747020125389099,
0.6612434387207031,
0.3637661039829254,
-0.09859128296375275,
-0.5809839367866516,
-0.8522670269012451,
0.104677714407444,
-0.3443569242954254,
-0.1975971907377243,
0.5131773352622986,
0.3680766820907593,
-0.15910758078098297,
-0.8644708395004272,
0.11209321767091751,
-0.5193331837654114,
0.033746495842933655,
0.394710510969162,
0.3566059172153473,
0.16864486038684845,
0.06339843571186066,
-0.10848812013864517,
0.17657311260700226,
-0.21766503155231476,
-0.44212818145751953,
0.6543734669685364,
0.016084399074316025,
-0.21662692725658417,
-0.8458552956581116,
-0.05136779695749283,
0.9661528468132019,
0.06425885111093521,
1.001135230064392,
0.8382106423377991,
-0.4314444363117218,
-0.09542948007583618,
-1.0645129680633545,
0.04642451927065849,
-0.43686556816101074,
0.3624115288257599,
0.23325982689857483,
-0.9247562885284424,
0.5437135696411133,
-0.10294736921787262,
0.5348974466323853,
0.3757239580154419,
0.49095290899276733,
-0.14579148590564728,
0.554777979850769,
0.7081255316734314,
-0.2339603304862976,
0.457185834646225,
-0.21321912109851837,
-0.10504615306854248,
-0.4460683763027191,
-0.5177192091941833,
-0.4777340888977051,
-0.5474366545677185,
-0.6981258988380432,
-0.4286482036113739,
-0.040756188333034515,
-0.43788784742355347,
-0.28552064299583435,
0.6486856341362,
-0.5164373517036438,
0.3444146513938904,
0.30352288484573364,
0.3921058177947998,
-0.02321638911962509,
0.08251430839300156,
0.5275402665138245,
0.06122392416000366,
-0.3918425142765045,
-0.632487952709198,
1.2988452911376953,
0.5621756315231323,
0.7301508188247681,
0.12487046420574188,
0.6537699699401855,
0.5446460247039795,
0.4290564954280853,
-0.49711352586746216,
0.3643437922000885,
-0.4616132378578186,
-0.45668619871139526,
-0.1705402284860611,
-0.4110449254512787,
-0.9162024855613708,
-0.1322685033082962,
-0.13053695857524872,
-0.8222362399101257,
0.2840898931026459,
-0.0389743372797966,
-0.46480831503868103,
0.4400233030319214,
-0.42213010787963867,
0.6978341341018677,
-0.17202912271022797,
-0.1423059105873108,
-0.29206210374832153,
-0.7490834593772888,
0.2647455632686615,
-0.35597944259643555,
0.3849123418331146,
0.12391521781682968,
-0.08849149942398071,
1.0034329891204834,
-0.0978580042719841,
0.936601996421814,
-0.21381613612174988,
-0.14261634647846222,
0.052171364426612854,
0.028807979077100754,
0.5929911136627197,
-0.22027231752872467,
-0.47269508242607117,
0.25704896450042725,
-0.02754686027765274,
-0.5433109402656555,
-0.3535121977329254,
0.7589672207832336,
-0.5392906069755554,
0.05696266517043114,
-0.209761381149292,
-0.6270229816436768,
-0.1875535100698471,
0.008390977047383785,
0.1429402083158493,
0.2410990297794342,
-0.10700257122516632,
0.584178626537323,
0.6128038167953491,
-0.7670287489891052,
-0.04552403837442398,
0.11907996237277985,
-0.3723532259464264,
-0.24162229895591736,
0.9394311904907227,
0.3803451359272003,
-0.15724487602710724,
0.37921157479286194,
-0.35885319113731384,
-0.5077622532844543,
-0.4520631432533264,
-0.19350528717041016,
0.19969435036182404,
-0.666356086730957,
-0.23403313755989075,
-0.6672450304031372,
-0.04334155470132828,
-0.6816596984863281,
-0.19406503438949585,
-0.23849214613437653,
-0.3914985954761505,
-0.2801414132118225,
-0.03851072117686272,
0.14048655331134796,
0.8387966752052307,
0.28972238302230835,
0.4121730625629425,
-0.8680548071861267,
0.12454947084188461,
0.19602738320827484,
0.5171017050743103,
-0.047429099678993225,
-0.7548379898071289,
-0.09205329418182373,
-0.0930452048778534,
-0.22599978744983673,
-0.5304543375968933,
0.2597806453704834,
0.6293861865997314,
0.7491266131401062,
0.47181254625320435,
-0.12310155481100082,
0.3348591923713684,
-0.4650436043739319,
0.7055442929267883,
0.162753626704216,
-0.14545302093029022,
0.5164108872413635,
-0.544380784034729,
0.04142739251255989,
1.059496521949768,
0.7142166495323181,
-0.494743287563324,
-0.03202752396464348,
-0.5418702363967896,
-0.85027676820755,
0.5235223770141602,
0.0804026871919632,
0.28496068716049194,
-0.041283298283815384,
0.5466920137405396,
0.5666285753250122,
0.3718799352645874,
-0.27423372864723206,
0.19771206378936768,
0.19982483983039856,
-0.5236690640449524,
-0.09497563540935516,
-0.1486513316631317,
0.07293801754713058,
-0.2776212990283966,
0.3232007622718811,
0.056633785367012024,
0.4233722388744354,
-0.37553998827934265,
-0.21847212314605713,
0.2764928936958313,
0.0029408112168312073,
0.4884445369243622,
0.9269464015960693,
-0.3057662546634674,
-0.2130890041589737,
0.40547990798950195,
-0.26501551270484924,
0.20334435999393463,
-0.18494993448257446,
0.2749323844909668,
0.10568351298570633,
0.23485377430915833,
0.15433700382709503,
-0.007392196916043758,
-0.8956810832023621,
0.9620103240013123,
-0.020629556849598885,
-0.08557886630296707,
-0.6251566410064697,
0.07398419827222824,
-0.2778050899505615,
0.2279009222984314,
0.5266004204750061,
0.10192039608955383,
0.04320114850997925,
-0.6316287517547607,
0.2984867990016937,
0.3665791153907776,
-0.2519276738166809,
-0.05690043419599533,
0.5585066676139832,
0.08619481325149536,
-0.2628019154071808,
1.043505072593689,
-0.00000568814766666037,
-0.3939466178417206,
0.5370574593544006,
0.27524256706237793,
0.7561318874359131,
-0.4614832401275635,
0.08218085765838623,
0.5142024159431458,
-0.2583578824996948,
-0.8951296210289001,
-0.06138668209314346,
-0.059987638145685196,
-0.5895628929138184,
-0.45086991786956787,
-0.8199144005775452,
-0.598737895488739,
-0.006811163388192654,
-0.8373735547065735,
0.31497442722320557,
-0.887570858001709,
0.05831799656152725,
-0.23291034996509552,
-0.49884334206581116,
-0.7585395574569702,
0.25661835074424744,
0.39765095710754395,
1.0213760137557983,
-0.971258282661438,
0.47313880920410156,
0.9178401231765747,
-0.33717241883277893,
-0.05799274519085884,
-0.13493607938289642,
-0.04527837783098221,
-0.7325693964958191,
0.9643747210502625,
0.9741888642311096,
0.32541602849960327,
-0.017496351152658463,
-0.5691922903060913,
-0.39139145612716675,
1.0525857210159302,
0.2776881158351898,
-0.5121110677719116,
-0.3609670102596283,
-0.2034929245710373,
0.4672251343727112,
-0.4474441707134247,
0.33221152424812317,
0.2353850156068802,
0.28239038586616516,
0.0006501413299702108,
-1.2905699014663696,
-0.1534244418144226,
-0.09537766128778458,
0.11566587537527084,
-0.25391680002212524,
-0.6281517148017883,
0.6960617899894714,
0.1269141286611557,
-0.16906218230724335,
0.10610207170248032,
0.7896202206611633,
0.2804975211620331,
0.22272434830665588,
0.5946032404899597,
0.5456128716468811,
1.1174638271331787,
-0.1342959851026535,
0.8725256323814392,
-0.25597867369651794,
0.42371320724487305,
0.6540008783340454,
-0.44131729006767273,
0.8948398232460022,
-0.09249395877122879,
-0.48026931285858154,
0.9401885867118835,
0.7556338906288147,
-0.3942697048187256,
0.12369304895401001,
0.28467223048210144,
-0.021733500063419342,
-0.6144540309906006,
-0.18358829617500305,
-0.35084667801856995,
0.7213873267173767,
0.31360700726509094,
-0.4877510368824005,
-0.4267854392528534,
0.5848998427391052,
-0.4307103753089905,
0.21270833909511566,
-0.4350619912147522,
0.6441053748130798,
-0.27874910831451416,
-0.3085416555404663,
0.3843107223510742,
0.0902741476893425,
0.9109883904457092,
-0.1667773276567459,
-0.29642558097839355,
0.07656142860651016,
0.4332980811595917,
-0.5166220664978027,
-0.8230878114700317,
0.132766455411911,
-0.048633042722940445,
-0.20650483667850494,
-0.5420258045196533,
0.626471757888794,
-0.23471468687057495,
-0.43495818972587585,
-0.11710012704133987,
0.16829530894756317,
0.47800832986831665,
-0.21440474689006805,
-0.2993853986263275,
-0.024097250774502754,
-0.2411743700504303,
0.14150802791118622,
0.5201343894004822,
0.02403365448117256,
-0.06803546100854874,
0.7765685319900513,
0.6474613547325134,
-0.14649434387683868,
-0.06471271812915802,
-0.18796341121196747,
0.7793475985527039,
-0.5687370300292969,
-0.9728548526763916,
-0.5740250945091248,
0.27602067589759827,
-0.3690357804298401,
-0.26989030838012695,
0.6817281246185303,
0.8549279570579529,
0.8436168432235718,
-0.234792098402977,
0.5877695083618164,
-0.012459389865398407,
0.9144473075866699,
-0.269998162984848,
0.804702877998352,
-0.44338348507881165,
0.2784464955329895,
-0.06432591378688812,
-1.1306666135787964,
-0.5213450789451599,
0.7735005617141724,
-0.3537893295288086,
0.21559175848960876,
0.09038915485143661,
0.5671281218528748,
-0.07414927333593369,
-0.17379775643348694,
0.08830995857715607,
0.015794316306710243,
0.2983304262161255,
0.4999573826789856,
0.6921687722206116,
-0.47126755118370056,
0.2588895857334137,
0.14190085232257843,
-0.3442963659763336,
-0.8227716684341431,
-0.361989289522171,
-0.7584553956985474,
-0.5386260151863098,
-0.44081127643585205,
-0.5814497470855713,
-0.0038280822336673737,
1.2745555639266968,
0.7139964699745178,
-1.0694795846939087,
-0.25201117992401123,
-0.0013296215329319239,
-0.37423601746559143,
-0.2160685807466507,
-0.22384917736053467,
0.11423902958631516,
-0.35713550448417664,
-0.5331233143806458,
0.5559282898902893,
0.025882212445139885,
-0.11220899224281311,
-0.21552301943302155,
0.21304574608802795,
-0.28056636452674866,
-0.40619444847106934,
0.6465482115745544,
0.580740749835968,
-0.7893187403678894,
-0.0979313999414444,
-0.2647150754928589,
-0.4117910861968994,
-0.0316450335085392,
0.5264387726783752,
-0.8194998502731323,
0.28419971466064453,
0.5841318368911743,
1.318730115890503,
0.2410372495651245,
0.3702394366264343,
0.4362106919288635,
-0.8184226751327515,
-0.0062767211347818375,
0.3247191309928894,
0.30511343479156494,
0.496645987033844,
-0.4480604827404022,
0.47910237312316895,
0.0307464599609375,
-0.6835521459579468,
-1.0828795433044434,
0.1031281054019928,
-1.2230145931243896,
-0.1468510627746582,
1.1868470907211304,
-0.2057044953107834,
-0.05361718311905861,
-0.3121235966682434,
-0.18415138125419617,
0.25754204392433167,
-0.2338060885667801,
1.0202032327651978,
0.43276160955429077,
-0.03601038455963135,
0.0375763438642025,
-0.741755485534668,
0.03706592693924904,
0.10870610922574997,
-0.627116322517395,
0.12913185358047485,
0.6768297553062439,
0.14442716538906097,
0.3857969343662262,
0.24057090282440186,
0.037572938948869705,
0.4902968108654022,
-0.4940105974674225,
0.0633770152926445,
-0.017232699319720268,
-0.5064999461174011,
-0.2441740483045578,
0.4971093237400055,
0.1384860724210739,
-0.2673458755016327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18122v1 | Poisoned LangChain: Jailbreak LLMs by LangChain | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | 2024-06-26T07:21:02 | Ziqiu Wang, Jun Liu, Shengkai Zhang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the development of natural language processing (NLP), large language
models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly popular. LLMs are integrating more into
everyday life, raising public concerns about their security vulnerabilities.
Consequently, the security of large language models is becoming critically
important. Currently, the techniques for attacking and defending against LLMs
are continuously evolving. One significant method type of attack is the
jailbreak attack, which designed to evade model safety mechanisms and induce
the generation of inappropriate content. Existing jailbreak attacks primarily
rely on crafting inducement prompts for direct jailbreaks, which are less
effective against large models with robust filtering and high comprehension
abilities. Given the increasing demand for real-time capabilities in large
language models, real-time updates and iterations of new knowledge have become
essential. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), an advanced technique to
compensate for the model's lack of new knowledge, is gradually becoming
mainstream. As RAG enables the model to utilize external knowledge bases, it
provides a new avenue for jailbreak attacks.
In this paper, we conduct the first work to propose the concept of indirect
jailbreak and achieve Retrieval-Augmented Generation via LangChain. Building on
this, we further design a novel method of indirect jailbreak attack, termed
Poisoned-LangChain (PLC), which leverages a poisoned external knowledge base to
interact with large language models, thereby causing the large models to
generate malicious non-compliant dialogues.We tested this method on six
different large language models across three major categories of jailbreak
issues. The experiments demonstrate that PLC successfully implemented indirect
jailbreak attacks under three different scenarios, achieving success rates of
88.56%, 79.04%, and 82.69% respectively. | [
-0.21518950164318085,
-1.0846508741378784,
0.31816190481185913,
0.1291833519935608,
-0.178274467587471,
0.3042156398296356,
-0.18389926850795746,
-0.648348867893219,
0.4582276940345764,
0.9930232763290405,
-0.25677600502967834,
-0.425669401884079,
-0.395170658826828,
-0.007231095340102911,
-0.5895375609397888,
1.039099097251892,
0.1884932667016983,
-0.10206122696399689,
0.3967567980289459,
0.07100734859704971,
-0.5843629240989685,
-0.7635213136672974,
-0.5698226094245911,
0.02237463742494583,
0.544055163860321,
0.26601049304008484,
0.5564302802085876,
0.39764705300331116,
0.4569789469242096,
0.3044627010822296,
-0.31928500533103943,
0.040297750383615494,
-0.412137508392334,
0.4108138382434845,
-0.21631503105163574,
-0.36978980898857117,
-0.3430951237678528,
-0.2532937526702881,
0.1428239643573761,
0.14058881998062134,
-0.3378063142299652,
-0.04329274222254753,
-0.23273982107639313,
1.0470373630523682,
-0.8533919453620911,
-0.280012309551239,
-1.1907154321670532,
0.036337196826934814,
-0.4580604135990143,
0.1346306949853897,
-0.7455660700798035,
-0.14545276761054993,
-0.18033666908740997,
-0.1996377408504486,
-0.01608949527144432,
0.22953666746616364,
0.5453859567642212,
-0.16653673350811005,
-0.27714619040489197,
-0.45999693870544434,
-0.3734493851661682,
0.5170818567276001,
-0.8547583818435669,
-0.06287845969200134,
0.31475192308425903,
0.3130670189857483,
-0.4661238491535187,
-0.8377078771591187,
-0.36519190669059753,
-0.7067633867263794,
0.06242464482784271,
-0.16971707344055176,
-0.08157926797866821,
0.2605515718460083,
0.344758003950119,
0.33175885677337646,
-0.36068445444107056,
0.18012815713882446,
-0.3108859360218048,
-0.04359494894742966,
0.6746662855148315,
0.1744493544101715,
0.706774890422821,
-0.7224875688552856,
-0.43395066261291504,
0.2056666612625122,
-1.1627750396728516,
-0.39844173192977905,
0.7353376746177673,
0.4582023620605469,
-0.11121837049722672,
0.6443417072296143,
0.026126055046916008,
1.0053683519363403,
-0.06908566504716873,
-0.09187984466552734,
-0.22908376157283783,
-0.27261945605278015,
-0.1896832436323166,
0.5417781472206116,
0.8725074529647827,
0.21765317022800446,
0.338850200176239,
-0.15440620481967926,
-0.14506199955940247,
-0.3636680543422699,
0.21860064566135406,
-0.828541100025177,
-0.3148883879184723,
0.3436812460422516,
-0.06831482797861099,
-0.8020996451377869,
0.025067172944545746,
-0.9442798495292664,
-0.9886431694030762,
0.38316622376441956,
0.26314523816108704,
-0.3277677297592163,
-0.296894907951355,
-0.07763400673866272,
-0.20110811293125153,
0.22191481292247772,
0.013022428378462791,
-1.1102877855300903,
0.28526976704597473,
0.6617200374603271,
0.9511340856552124,
0.06494798511266708,
-0.13194821774959564,
-0.6783803701400757,
0.47656258940696716,
-0.2721919119358063,
0.5114049911499023,
-0.029484858736395836,
-0.4307800531387329,
0.07512065023183823,
-0.13965043425559998,
0.03163831681013107,
-0.7857574820518494,
0.16619037091732025,
-0.8428722620010376,
-0.170853391289711,
0.05658967047929764,
-0.3342733383178711,
-0.007712304592132568,
0.46247872710227966,
-0.8854540586471558,
0.5540105104446411,
-0.28560203313827515,
-1.2492905855178833,
-0.1596563458442688,
-0.3721568286418915,
-0.6229298114776611,
-0.09292691946029663,
0.15884950757026672,
-0.3544052839279175,
-0.06119922548532486,
0.2850126624107361,
0.33162227272987366,
-0.35650625824928284,
0.5610535144805908,
-0.398073673248291,
-0.1301492303609848,
0.4266777038574219,
-0.37590739130973816,
0.8522971868515015,
0.330868124961853,
-0.29919692873954773,
0.013724342919886112,
-0.630020797252655,
-0.11153329908847809,
0.5169867277145386,
-0.15414713323116302,
-0.6180541515350342,
0.17814376950263977,
-0.014542289078235626,
0.04576165974140167,
0.42880764603614807,
-0.5329745411872864,
0.3451721966266632,
-0.9054679274559021,
0.5609320402145386,
0.794889509677887,
0.5262383818626404,
0.15308673679828644,
-0.21889135241508484,
0.294258713722229,
-0.22218652069568634,
0.21371497213840485,
-0.24061620235443115,
-0.29722917079925537,
-0.49201318621635437,
0.012804804369807243,
0.2110384851694107,
0.9710671305656433,
-0.6996707320213318,
0.18892164528369904,
0.08454924076795578,
-0.6172442436218262,
-0.2956446409225464,
0.40832892060279846,
0.5129883885383606,
0.4566323459148407,
0.4116670489311218,
-0.16431334614753723,
-0.7369892597198486,
-0.6209208369255066,
-0.7853200435638428,
-0.2484239786863327,
0.23389019072055817,
0.3043639063835144,
0.3241460621356964,
-0.24007214605808258,
0.52390456199646,
-0.43957918882369995,
-0.20564745366573334,
-0.6729187965393066,
-0.23448866605758667,
0.39857155084609985,
0.4933745861053467,
0.3675406873226166,
-0.5541423559188843,
-0.49073129892349243,
-0.0033856721129268408,
-0.7704765200614929,
-0.2026568055152893,
-0.0819072425365448,
0.05864156037569046,
0.2763441503047943,
0.6068946719169617,
-0.467327743768692,
0.2998466193675995,
0.4362630844116211,
-0.3821312487125397,
0.9217391610145569,
-0.12042757868766785,
-0.08595463633537292,
-1.2769479751586914,
-0.05057418718934059,
-0.1743604689836502,
-0.17001444101333618,
-0.8819856643676758,
0.5846097469329834,
0.008210145868360996,
-0.24092808365821838,
-0.771830141544342,
0.7870588302612305,
-0.3874896168708801,
0.15923751890659332,
-0.22641533613204956,
0.2946467101573944,
-0.2157910317182541,
0.0942378118634224,
-0.289728581905365,
0.6195917725563049,
0.32373443245887756,
-0.18274874985218048,
0.7356559634208679,
0.05132194235920906,
-0.3482505977153778,
0.053033649921417236,
-0.6230077743530273,
0.20706768333911896,
0.06549293547868729,
-0.06017911434173584,
-0.638815701007843,
-0.3457050919532776,
0.2563786804676056,
-0.19875599443912506,
0.43407365679740906,
-0.3648935556411743,
-0.6676616668701172,
-0.2896558344364166,
-0.44062384963035583,
0.011646037921309471,
0.42845618724823,
-0.7287434339523315,
0.4509422481060028,
0.29059773683547974,
-0.1541842222213745,
-0.7842951416969299,
-0.5980665683746338,
0.6533356308937073,
-0.560897707939148,
-0.7064467072486877,
0.16788126528263092,
0.020172933116555214,
-0.7342914938926697,
-0.2534334659576416,
-0.013004366308450699,
0.03148376941680908,
0.2678092420101166,
0.13363412022590637,
0.3746302127838135,
0.07052048295736313,
-0.315795361995697,
-0.013182678259909153,
0.10618694871664047,
0.2262740135192871,
-0.01835227757692337,
0.6725127100944519,
0.0820833072066307,
-0.15029658377170563,
-0.23379850387573242,
0.24184593558311462,
0.6289159059524536,
-0.1976282149553299,
0.9992001056671143,
0.10755224525928497,
-0.08018796890974045,
-0.35505178570747375,
-0.7213099002838135,
-0.1673855036497116,
-0.5473468899726868,
0.43638208508491516,
-0.3186704218387604,
-0.6543766260147095,
0.5262652635574341,
-0.25723087787628174,
-0.20698963105678558,
0.07585021108388901,
0.4688256084918976,
0.22204770147800446,
0.8994279503822327,
0.510638415813446,
-0.57920241355896,
0.5288792848587036,
-0.16096681356430054,
0.3282960057258606,
-0.8943579792976379,
-0.1598031222820282,
-0.24127644300460815,
0.13368476927280426,
-0.585444986820221,
0.015232984907925129,
0.25173184275627136,
0.5187020897865295,
-0.530298113822937,
0.522779643535614,
-0.38057348132133484,
0.49555590748786926,
0.22963328659534454,
0.09227264672517776,
0.38791942596435547,
-0.03154357522726059,
-0.5398319959640503,
0.13185007870197296,
-0.5042933225631714,
-0.19670523703098297,
1.0788589715957642,
0.3035154938697815,
0.9572474956512451,
0.362678200006485,
0.8720449209213257,
0.3578828275203705,
0.4144705832004547,
-0.5635930299758911,
0.5775550603866577,
-0.13101311028003693,
-0.9132072329521179,
-0.014313685707747936,
-0.38552653789520264,
-0.8168520927429199,
0.2669800817966461,
0.09674100577831268,
-1.134881615638733,
-0.27448877692222595,
0.032311663031578064,
-0.11413772404193878,
0.6820823550224304,
-0.9121537804603577,
0.8592517375946045,
-0.49336931109428406,
-0.5229695439338684,
-0.04924085736274719,
-0.7817999720573425,
0.9910479784011841,
-0.3500693142414093,
0.5262076258659363,
-0.01511124987155199,
0.26321640610694885,
0.6904885172843933,
-0.9882783889770508,
0.870637834072113,
-0.39115768671035767,
-0.08991439640522003,
0.4358484447002411,
0.5256109237670898,
0.9379759430885315,
0.38316765427589417,
-0.17407697439193726,
-0.2224254161119461,
-0.15063869953155518,
-0.08879651129245758,
-0.5047532320022583,
0.793414294719696,
-0.49747148156166077,
-1.0908677577972412,
-0.4169214963912964,
-0.3669421076774597,
-0.06917513161897659,
0.09991921484470367,
0.20134307444095612,
0.32680973410606384,
0.09494739770889282,
-0.2772029936313629,
0.5315328240394592,
-0.5774966478347778,
0.5755664110183716,
0.5510654449462891,
-0.6277233362197876,
-0.7829396724700928,
0.8936581611633301,
-0.009645226411521435,
0.5756309628486633,
0.20721760392189026,
0.28026410937309265,
0.0907433032989502,
-0.4468531012535095,
-0.44033947587013245,
0.43149498105049133,
-0.6381477117538452,
-0.49149787425994873,
-0.418671578168869,
-0.6856940984725952,
-0.3542385399341583,
-0.23631009459495544,
-0.3175637423992157,
-0.20866039395332336,
0.017016740515828133,
-0.17174667119979858,
0.8084346055984497,
0.6749405264854431,
-0.17884235084056854,
0.32839202880859375,
-0.8725186586380005,
0.5312088131904602,
0.3187960088253021,
0.010977212339639664,
0.21227321028709412,
-0.4747525751590729,
-0.14237616956233978,
-0.24061661958694458,
-0.1672416776418686,
-1.4284436702728271,
0.6069579720497131,
-0.05531533807516098,
0.22519762814044952,
0.3567787706851959,
0.19630998373031616,
0.5743486285209656,
-0.7767598628997803,
0.7027463912963867,
0.3313690423965454,
-0.9089924693107605,
0.9397197365760803,
-0.4209296703338623,
-0.05363629385828972,
0.44094404578208923,
-0.005303299054503441,
-0.615138053894043,
-0.7107178568840027,
-0.5016005039215088,
-1.2965089082717896,
0.4317325949668884,
-0.03460899367928505,
0.3665933310985565,
-0.19537709653377533,
0.3459005355834961,
-0.19284217059612274,
0.23897002637386322,
-1.0938977003097534,
-0.46833088994026184,
0.021780457347631454,
-0.04777594283223152,
0.20020310580730438,
-0.40875348448753357,
-0.1012021154165268,
-0.22958432137966156,
0.6956340670585632,
0.37806236743927,
-0.050988394767045975,
0.14609365165233612,
-0.21322554349899292,
0.23059189319610596,
0.3973519504070282,
0.3161836266517639,
0.24550442397594452,
-0.21244671940803528,
0.18767860531806946,
0.22100964188575745,
-0.7485032677650452,
0.4666522443294525,
0.21006257832050323,
-0.21918518841266632,
-0.2703414857387543,
0.4067329168319702,
0.7132060527801514,
-0.08493458479642868,
-0.9989164471626282,
0.554431140422821,
0.09466864913702011,
0.3168357312679291,
-0.6281150579452515,
0.24886198341846466,
0.005531303118914366,
0.09701699763536453,
0.3020533621311188,
-0.1503494679927826,
-0.08170215040445328,
-0.5989243984222412,
0.22872555255889893,
0.46407878398895264,
-0.43515118956565857,
-0.034634944051504135,
0.6358550190925598,
-0.11806075274944305,
-0.2577921152114868,
0.6640906929969788,
-0.19193163514137268,
-0.6337509751319885,
0.672091543674469,
0.9573283195495605,
0.8908079266548157,
-0.43338608741760254,
-0.061567310243844986,
0.357657790184021,
0.5847836136817932,
0.06555720418691635,
0.15956905484199524,
-0.06485456973314285,
-0.7511152625083923,
-0.5204976797103882,
-0.5898186564445496,
-0.221616730093956,
0.39340728521347046,
-0.3241516649723053,
0.24626818299293518,
-0.6327382922172546,
-0.05712470784783363,
-0.5158143043518066,
-0.12999744713306427,
0.10731949657201767,
-0.046015288680791855,
0.07671567052602768,
1.1080164909362793,
-0.48510879278182983,
0.9828318357467651,
0.2483491152524948,
-0.24857737123966217,
-0.949440598487854,
-0.03508390858769417,
0.1242593303322792,
-0.6110972166061401,
0.8131176233291626,
0.30894437432289124,
0.15765880048274994,
0.03953845053911209,
-0.4904363453388214,
-0.8639293909072876,
0.6850969195365906,
0.2933334410190582,
-0.6514708995819092,
-0.042015191167593,
-0.17922937870025635,
0.1409759521484375,
-0.021033553406596184,
-0.14111970365047455,
0.7407150268554688,
0.44747138023376465,
-0.05152038484811783,
-0.7535658478736877,
0.18046380579471588,
-0.3215603530406952,
-0.040260665118694305,
0.6033467650413513,
-0.31576794385910034,
0.6476954221725464,
-0.5431116223335266,
0.06084049120545387,
0.40823233127593994,
0.3583820164203644,
0.7426974177360535,
0.037719883024692535,
0.31502586603164673,
0.7903075814247131,
0.43210816383361816,
0.11715231090784073,
1.0391899347305298,
-0.3739924132823944,
0.07078753411769867,
1.2691437005996704,
-0.5773006677627563,
0.9115157127380371,
0.6242039203643799,
0.04192587733268738,
0.7375315427780151,
0.25432586669921875,
-0.13918447494506836,
0.788466215133667,
0.8186026811599731,
-0.6722235083580017,
0.28287529945373535,
0.05590805038809776,
-0.35139262676239014,
0.18778455257415771,
0.6337535381317139,
-0.3917226791381836,
-0.13325875997543335,
0.5314350128173828,
0.537991464138031,
0.0975850522518158,
-0.44103315472602844,
0.9771590828895569,
0.205674409866333,
-0.5419118404388428,
0.6002604365348816,
0.517460823059082,
0.5682206749916077,
-0.6941649317741394,
0.202101469039917,
-0.2177056521177292,
0.1135648787021637,
-0.20092542469501495,
-0.3989178240299225,
0.1809621900320053,
0.48950597643852234,
0.16765837371349335,
0.1795874834060669,
1.0463721752166748,
-0.14897863566875458,
-0.2724437415599823,
0.7184316515922546,
0.28672394156455994,
0.011909385211765766,
-0.07189824432134628,
-0.6210554838180542,
0.1870223432779312,
0.0007533817552030087,
-0.48302796483039856,
0.4673903286457062,
-0.021233702078461647,
0.10725375264883041,
0.6768839359283447,
0.6517273187637329,
0.5250036120414734,
0.33338674902915955,
0.05542336031794548,
0.9016122221946716,
-0.8168710470199585,
-0.3122953772544861,
-1.259619116783142,
0.34350574016571045,
-0.22308509051799774,
0.27670490741729736,
0.9718906283378601,
0.5086646676063538,
0.48812371492385864,
0.06517061591148376,
0.852204442024231,
-0.25812095403671265,
0.40566807985305786,
-0.810290515422821,
0.9498555064201355,
-0.19558359682559967,
0.6052664518356323,
-0.5067287683486938,
-0.6589797139167786,
-0.40163299441337585,
0.2970295250415802,
-0.5112596154212952,
-0.019238630309700966,
0.6600199937820435,
0.8290794491767883,
0.2936083972454071,
-0.1845882087945938,
0.07678066194057465,
0.45055949687957764,
0.47356030344963074,
0.5687984228134155,
0.9867783188819885,
-0.4437512457370758,
0.41809824109077454,
-0.3340883255004883,
-0.008214673027396202,
-0.074224092066288,
-0.812872052192688,
-1.0332410335540771,
-0.18811199069023132,
-0.00757864024490118,
-0.6709805130958557,
0.36436522006988525,
0.7363756895065308,
0.3224599361419678,
-0.6436851620674133,
-0.45073917508125305,
-0.4406035840511322,
0.37216076254844666,
0.14263254404067993,
-0.30614981055259705,
0.29672181606292725,
-0.38892537355422974,
-0.20239195227622986,
0.6620608568191528,
0.3329790234565735,
0.026488445699214935,
-0.265583872795105,
0.08833304792642593,
-0.35955777764320374,
0.12056732177734375,
0.4339134693145752,
0.4578498601913452,
-0.7574381828308105,
-0.055909670889377594,
-0.34865495562553406,
-0.1524823158979416,
-0.19978797435760498,
0.7466778755187988,
-0.9151850342750549,
0.5136778950691223,
0.25695207715034485,
0.6398648023605347,
0.39930063486099243,
-0.03902534767985344,
0.4188559055328369,
-0.885159432888031,
0.48167771100997925,
0.06229810044169426,
0.48535579442977905,
0.38966017961502075,
-0.517450749874115,
0.26231083273887634,
0.28974953293800354,
-0.4996182322502136,
-1.0352778434753418,
0.48660001158714294,
-0.5257244110107422,
-0.7100600600242615,
1.076657772064209,
-0.06722993403673172,
-0.46450045704841614,
-0.14211921393871307,
-0.2555363178253174,
0.003959523513913155,
-0.11019373685121536,
0.7134885787963867,
0.4103996455669403,
0.09999295324087143,
0.007652400527149439,
-0.8442938923835754,
0.520118236541748,
0.13783717155456543,
-0.9405351281166077,
0.2502748966217041,
0.2484310269355774,
0.23909273743629456,
0.12374914437532425,
0.3836461305618286,
-0.37103918194770813,
0.07135390490293503,
-0.22643418610095978,
0.047079551964998245,
-0.10147391259670258,
-0.43390634655952454,
-0.29477497935295105,
0.4600612223148346,
0.3206470310688019,
0.3157447278499603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18120v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18120v1 | ArzEn-LLM: Code-Switched Egyptian Arabic-English Translation and Speech Recognition Using LLMs | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | 2024-06-26T07:19:51 | Ahmed Heakl, Youssef Zaghloul, Mennatullah Ali, Rania Hossam, Walid Gomaa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Motivated by the widespread increase in the phenomenon of code-switching
between Egyptian Arabic and English in recent times, this paper explores the
intricacies of machine translation (MT) and automatic speech recognition (ASR)
systems, focusing on translating code-switched Egyptian Arabic-English to
either English or Egyptian Arabic. Our goal is to present the methodologies
employed in developing these systems, utilizing large language models such as
LLama and Gemma. In the field of ASR, we explore the utilization of the Whisper
model for code-switched Egyptian Arabic recognition, detailing our experimental
procedures including data preprocessing and training techniques. Through the
implementation of a consecutive speech-to-text translation system that
integrates ASR with MT, we aim to overcome challenges posed by limited
resources and the unique characteristics of the Egyptian Arabic dialect.
Evaluation against established metrics showcases promising results, with our
methodologies yielding a significant improvement of $56\%$ in English
translation over the state-of-the-art and $9.3\%$ in Arabic translation. Since
code-switching is deeply inherent in spoken languages, it is crucial that ASR
systems can effectively handle this phenomenon. This capability is crucial for
enabling seamless interaction in various domains, including business
negotiations, cultural exchanges, and academic discourse. Our models and code
are available as open-source resources. Code:
\url{http://github.com/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm}}, Models:
\url{http://huggingface.co/collections/ahmedheakl/arazn-llm-662ceaf12777656607b9524e}. | [
-0.23211891949176788,
-0.5393382906913757,
0.19893532991409302,
0.2512204647064209,
-0.34605860710144043,
0.19091537594795227,
-0.19267672300338745,
-0.7645863890647888,
-0.0016264619771391153,
0.7085681557655334,
-0.17813120782375336,
-0.6067521572113037,
-0.8858136534690857,
0.3010077178478241,
-0.9239369630813599,
1.1245421171188354,
-0.7370744347572327,
0.29933878779411316,
0.4209170341491699,
-0.2606140673160553,
-0.001279334770515561,
-0.4218365550041199,
-0.8124943971633911,
-0.508220911026001,
0.36026519536972046,
0.23941856622695923,
0.5465920567512512,
0.8959789872169495,
0.5710490942001343,
0.26426994800567627,
-0.0053064520470798016,
0.1349519044160843,
-0.0004681949794758111,
0.23308923840522766,
0.30806252360343933,
-0.40533286333084106,
-0.5782596468925476,
-0.10489622503519058,
0.6508243680000305,
0.44437456130981445,
-0.3791763484477997,
0.34849685430526733,
0.08934436738491058,
0.5457606315612793,
-0.3753361999988556,
0.16427300870418549,
-0.6398497223854065,
0.08862296491861343,
-0.25032228231430054,
-0.24197886884212494,
-0.13397710025310516,
-0.2928152084350586,
0.0945134088397026,
-0.23716507852077484,
-0.11689593642950058,
0.1952279806137085,
0.7165802121162415,
0.32344290614128113,
-0.5659501552581787,
-0.893021821975708,
-0.9331423044204712,
0.8452752828598022,
-0.7091964483261108,
0.42100730538368225,
0.3386479318141937,
0.2591101825237274,
0.0761827901005745,
-0.7714983820915222,
-0.5100783109664917,
-0.37676602602005005,
0.3139898478984833,
0.1374955177307129,
-0.5341556668281555,
-0.01781211420893669,
-0.0526103712618351,
0.45523515343666077,
-0.22523503005504608,
0.048316504806280136,
-0.37582242488861084,
-0.10507616400718689,
0.6038272380828857,
0.14139622449874878,
0.552021324634552,
0.04811062663793564,
-0.37632882595062256,
-0.023185765370726585,
-0.879326581954956,
0.05231553316116333,
0.5501582026481628,
0.36232873797416687,
-0.37386801838874817,
0.6412628889083862,
-0.00614046398550272,
0.7351953387260437,
-0.17463631927967072,
-0.28751444816589355,
0.07189162820577621,
-0.07940824329853058,
-0.21564428508281708,
0.38911235332489014,
0.609577476978302,
0.05582638829946518,
0.057328127324581146,
-0.08568289875984192,
-0.6593657732009888,
0.44297051429748535,
0.04108767583966255,
-0.6815837621688843,
-0.008876740001142025,
0.11109714210033417,
-0.7947543263435364,
-0.35143330693244934,
-0.2728443443775177,
-0.3641056418418884,
-0.04382874444127083,
-0.12073907256126404,
0.4820464551448822,
-0.2490685135126114,
-0.28268691897392273,
0.43242090940475464,
0.21997685730457306,
0.4005833566188812,
0.43085184693336487,
-0.5721439719200134,
0.6736572980880737,
0.2730967402458191,
0.901095986366272,
-0.3224818706512451,
-0.40610891580581665,
-0.3410432040691376,
0.4203571081161499,
-0.3247818350791931,
0.5690500140190125,
-0.4872826337814331,
-0.7079274654388428,
0.24508878588676453,
-0.3432614207267761,
-0.049601614475250244,
-0.7953640222549438,
0.6850925087928772,
-0.7203600406646729,
-0.08808612823486328,
0.3814859688282013,
-0.28973162174224854,
-0.39366260170936584,
0.06376555562019348,
-0.6156185269355774,
0.789130687713623,
-0.553614616394043,
-0.30224326252937317,
-0.363414466381073,
-0.8121829032897949,
-0.690407395362854,
-0.1934659779071808,
-0.24073809385299683,
-0.44552144408226013,
0.051979515701532364,
0.11596275866031647,
0.26796966791152954,
-0.39941906929016113,
-0.09283877164125443,
0.4468056261539459,
-0.34915095567703247,
0.6488242745399475,
-0.6271085143089294,
0.6651486158370972,
0.49694034457206726,
-0.43797096610069275,
0.04336456209421158,
-0.7683607935905457,
-0.04830019548535347,
0.07864939421415329,
-0.8126266002655029,
-0.007043160032480955,
0.2422509640455246,
0.5257420539855957,
0.18868093192577362,
0.4500564634799957,
-0.31441017985343933,
0.07189295440912247,
-0.2416754812002182,
0.5812219977378845,
0.47310125827789307,
-0.39088666439056396,
0.29929986596107483,
-0.44787871837615967,
0.7076923251152039,
0.118366539478302,
-0.1914498209953308,
-0.00843179039657116,
-0.7274153232574463,
-1.1448198556900024,
-0.1403798907995224,
0.3116607964038849,
0.9146926999092102,
-0.7006927132606506,
0.11647165566682816,
-0.16166509687900543,
-0.12624503672122955,
-0.981392502784729,
0.11186152696609497,
0.71364426612854,
0.2935304045677185,
0.4531330466270447,
-0.2626820206642151,
-0.6614505052566528,
-0.7730880975723267,
-0.3541749119758606,
-0.3533363342285156,
0.05480985343456268,
0.3544772267341614,
0.4029029309749603,
-0.6299379467964172,
0.46688947081565857,
-0.12234488129615784,
-0.2694240212440491,
-0.4180935323238373,
0.21850882470607758,
0.39258626103401184,
0.47469377517700195,
0.03444302827119827,
-0.7644800543785095,
-0.5355615615844727,
0.42706534266471863,
-0.3625604212284088,
-0.44268548488616943,
0.023907160386443138,
0.21185144782066345,
0.4708128273487091,
0.6290984749794006,
-0.36055952310562134,
0.7185294032096863,
1.0016716718673706,
0.01807672716677189,
0.6615411639213562,
-0.1271420568227768,
0.3541489541530609,
-1.1923402547836304,
0.14306266605854034,
-0.2360139787197113,
-0.2515631914138794,
-0.7016221284866333,
0.09586269408464432,
-0.028382334858179092,
-0.07926240563392639,
-0.4971093535423279,
0.687917947769165,
-0.7430523633956909,
-0.25869065523147583,
-0.5569583177566528,
-0.161891907453537,
-0.3378351628780365,
0.3782571256160736,
0.028085727244615555,
1.2410343885421753,
0.2591272294521332,
-0.8155986666679382,
0.4578787386417389,
0.5225180387496948,
-0.5898743867874146,
0.2836950123310089,
-0.548796534538269,
0.3268872797489166,
0.4942764341831207,
0.05771758407354355,
-0.8133305311203003,
0.12170101702213287,
0.6423331499099731,
-0.6453968286514282,
0.31050005555152893,
-0.4427525997161865,
-0.45648348331451416,
0.08666457235813141,
0.15647315979003906,
0.5155600309371948,
0.6148067116737366,
-0.5138329863548279,
0.7730576395988464,
0.360119104385376,
-0.5617887377738953,
-0.5499171614646912,
-0.7919776439666748,
0.5523048043251038,
-0.16089725494384766,
-0.44959914684295654,
0.5231101512908936,
0.07389601320028305,
-0.46695247292518616,
0.010199722833931446,
-0.3829236626625061,
-0.08607300370931625,
-0.19185544550418854,
0.29612046480178833,
0.4771721661090851,
-0.2823231816291809,
-0.37695765495300293,
0.266307532787323,
-0.46499907970428467,
0.0414939746260643,
-0.4257641136646271,
0.5655614733695984,
-0.35819903016090393,
-0.5100288391113281,
-0.47575974464416504,
0.6110197901725769,
0.41267913579940796,
-0.3311755955219269,
0.474232017993927,
0.3047489523887634,
-0.33415237069129944,
-0.024849113076925278,
-0.6312773823738098,
0.14597852528095245,
-0.4665158689022064,
0.5034738779067993,
-0.5948348045349121,
-0.9279817938804626,
0.8328214287757874,
-0.2503550052642822,
0.12868157029151917,
0.2251053750514984,
0.8785132169723511,
-0.20240725576877594,
1.1074390411376953,
0.5913833379745483,
-0.30018606781959534,
0.5103797912597656,
-0.11873134970664978,
0.26177406311035156,
-0.8753763437271118,
0.005199879873543978,
-0.6808937191963196,
-0.43844282627105713,
-0.6031476259231567,
-0.5047442317008972,
0.5612962245941162,
-0.028799517080187798,
0.0010074952151626348,
0.19404318928718567,
-0.23025430738925934,
0.12022846192121506,
0.4460723102092743,
-0.02492465078830719,
0.6929342746734619,
0.2222999483346939,
-0.03458968177437782,
0.1587848663330078,
-0.4588901102542877,
-0.8275880813598633,
1.0768126249313354,
0.2901673913002014,
1.2429901361465454,
0.3023609220981598,
0.6510973572731018,
0.45593327283859253,
0.14162446558475494,
-0.8558412194252014,
0.7090442776679993,
-0.2068149596452713,
-0.36113256216049194,
-0.110073521733284,
-0.3577912151813507,
-1.0401707887649536,
0.21973401308059692,
0.09610012173652649,
-0.35022860765457153,
-0.06208638474345207,
0.0274095069617033,
-0.18762552738189697,
0.5392407178878784,
-0.48717793822288513,
0.2587931752204895,
-0.36463427543640137,
0.1246303990483284,
-0.5711971521377563,
-0.7120109796524048,
-0.02021460048854351,
0.14002873003482819,
0.10772667080163956,
-0.03540854901075363,
-0.4294529855251312,
0.9220796823501587,
-0.2596744894981384,
0.7846075892448425,
0.2537716031074524,
-0.43720003962516785,
0.12405195832252502,
0.15084773302078247,
0.6423821449279785,
-0.2180933952331543,
-0.01848832704126835,
0.6307119131088257,
-0.038448091596364975,
-0.19371432065963745,
-0.22486931085586548,
0.5537831783294678,
-1.1674050092697144,
-0.5744075775146484,
-0.6005707383155823,
-0.7241842150688171,
-0.005361978430300951,
0.1228267103433609,
0.2671939730644226,
0.4321226179599762,
-0.15707938373088837,
-0.1830519437789917,
0.6806443929672241,
-0.2429141253232956,
0.30971449613571167,
0.9564540386199951,
-0.5470420718193054,
-0.5036718845367432,
0.8106905221939087,
0.22522953152656555,
0.18068088591098785,
0.44660377502441406,
-0.2085297852754593,
-0.11858965456485748,
-0.9465811848640442,
-0.6616895198822021,
0.23184220492839813,
-0.6016939282417297,
-0.3006131947040558,
-0.604257345199585,
-0.5907833576202393,
-0.22763052582740784,
-0.26131725311279297,
-0.3130296468734741,
-0.3375014662742615,
-0.3823467493057251,
0.2180207520723343,
0.5191877484321594,
0.7492710947990417,
-0.010435076430439949,
0.2678786516189575,
-0.8844105005264282,
0.3885554075241089,
0.33247795701026917,
0.13098420202732086,
-0.0767974704504013,
-1.0042656660079956,
-0.4661460518836975,
0.009812161326408386,
0.0002469836617819965,
-0.9837139844894409,
0.609014630317688,
0.09445512294769287,
0.35298943519592285,
0.2862674593925476,
-0.20549504458904266,
0.5804206728935242,
-0.9197126030921936,
0.2394975870847702,
0.15136376023292542,
-1.1026504039764404,
0.4412662386894226,
-0.4723217785358429,
0.10231669247150421,
0.30147039890289307,
0.0008786630933173001,
-1.092590570449829,
-0.26285457611083984,
-0.17670217156410217,
-0.807410717010498,
0.6900922656059265,
0.27152562141418457,
0.21227307617664337,
0.22874343395233154,
0.2493162304162979,
0.026450257748365402,
0.3842572271823883,
-0.5996544361114502,
-0.6242562532424927,
0.040436629205942154,
-0.267957478761673,
0.12856198847293854,
-0.2926729619503021,
-0.2532203197479248,
-0.11790509521961212,
0.8685930371284485,
0.1660315990447998,
0.4579877555370331,
-0.004416242241859436,
-0.40249472856521606,
-0.13951653242111206,
0.5037861466407776,
0.6236135959625244,
0.3377738893032074,
-0.12644654512405396,
0.17351600527763367,
0.23948323726654053,
-0.9108989834785461,
0.34167444705963135,
0.4626184403896332,
-0.22653383016586304,
0.1792023479938507,
0.1032097116112709,
0.8793842196464539,
0.30457866191864014,
-0.6228431463241577,
0.0985553041100502,
0.16431142389774323,
0.05221181362867355,
-0.5116162300109863,
-0.022280998528003693,
0.08821186423301697,
0.4072497487068176,
0.5759369730949402,
0.2862841784954071,
0.2054741531610489,
-0.36482247710227966,
-0.11564888060092926,
0.26057592034339905,
-0.20992062985897064,
-0.28151676058769226,
0.5952645540237427,
0.5342786312103271,
-0.7349823713302612,
0.5786889791488647,
0.1917952001094818,
-0.4599173367023468,
0.5922595262527466,
0.8204292058944702,
1.0436738729476929,
-0.5935903191566467,
-0.034180134534835815,
-0.20194661617279053,
0.3995368778705597,
-0.08584021776914597,
0.4168160855770111,
-0.1393328756093979,
-0.9844793677330017,
-0.23917941749095917,
-0.4893297553062439,
-0.7883222699165344,
0.07950475811958313,
-0.9288923144340515,
0.23598745465278625,
-0.19068604707717896,
-0.09524485468864441,
-0.4758426547050476,
0.07426055520772934,
-0.47269219160079956,
0.01788593828678131,
0.19346904754638672,
0.9630929231643677,
-0.5797106623649597,
1.188746690750122,
1.1045833826065063,
-0.1411069929599762,
-0.5269879698753357,
-0.07389204204082489,
0.05560458078980446,
-1.408622145652771,
0.5794591307640076,
-0.13597644865512848,
-0.7397837042808533,
0.5059409141540527,
-0.5085957646369934,
-0.8014190196990967,
1.0554219484329224,
0.17323167622089386,
-0.6323925852775574,
0.12809738516807556,
0.16390983760356903,
0.1964346170425415,
-0.3817923963069916,
-0.08212254196405411,
0.531336784362793,
0.16667945683002472,
0.06584126502275467,
-1.0716947317123413,
-0.4118170738220215,
-0.5701891183853149,
0.20520035922527313,
0.34893569350242615,
-0.48871204257011414,
0.6815078258514404,
-0.17066672444343567,
-0.27042749524116516,
0.5435652732849121,
0.676888108253479,
0.45642000436782837,
0.23389273881912231,
0.29395318031311035,
0.5026355981826782,
0.3139682412147522,
0.16333848237991333,
0.7629314064979553,
-0.5347612500190735,
-0.01671116054058075,
0.8272365927696228,
-0.528317391872406,
1.2372357845306396,
0.724453330039978,
-0.4462288022041321,
0.4477598965167999,
0.359696626663208,
0.25872907042503357,
0.4722641408443451,
0.11611946672201157,
-0.8195536136627197,
-0.04934263974428177,
-0.09398980438709259,
-0.6945445537567139,
0.4085973799228668,
0.540156364440918,
-0.32359856367111206,
-0.06490599364042282,
-0.01012179534882307,
0.2077043652534485,
-0.09371410310268402,
-0.42616334557533264,
0.6664013862609863,
0.41311702132225037,
-0.10989011824131012,
0.5043210983276367,
0.5590234398841858,
1.0822380781173706,
-0.9097696542739868,
-0.07186505198478699,
-0.19352123141288757,
0.062205079942941666,
-0.0702843964099884,
-0.4328443109989166,
0.2097347229719162,
0.38999032974243164,
-0.33623772859573364,
-0.6033619046211243,
0.7944294810295105,
-0.5511797070503235,
-0.7452264428138733,
0.30384430289268494,
0.6863732933998108,
0.3832830488681793,
0.2691316306591034,
-0.7680939435958862,
0.5136227011680603,
0.11906987428665161,
-0.013765827752649784,
0.3520595133304596,
0.08453354239463806,
0.040736015886068344,
0.8144197463989258,
0.7130460739135742,
0.4482036232948303,
0.15730157494544983,
-0.03373459726572037,
0.632270336151123,
-0.6411340236663818,
-0.5530037879943848,
-0.8237974047660828,
0.09236175566911697,
0.531056821346283,
-0.2699047327041626,
0.8256545662879944,
0.5820407271385193,
0.7796566486358643,
-0.07906227558851242,
0.9219644665718079,
0.18298421800136566,
0.5819265842437744,
-0.7003284096717834,
1.0579849481582642,
-0.2466522753238678,
0.39602696895599365,
-0.1419534981250763,
-0.7240126132965088,
-0.08692216128110886,
0.9565126895904541,
-0.3769119679927826,
-0.012611651793122292,
0.40127480030059814,
0.8546497225761414,
0.10222593694925308,
-0.14886394143104553,
0.3117699921131134,
0.3344976305961609,
0.13761833310127258,
0.5120345950126648,
1.0930718183517456,
-0.7329667210578918,
0.8950870037078857,
0.35454654693603516,
-0.10847019404172897,
-0.36726489663124084,
-0.5906814336776733,
-0.542280912399292,
-0.609081506729126,
-0.4568350613117218,
-0.45796677470207214,
0.3484492897987366,
0.957966685295105,
0.4043535888195038,
-0.9853876829147339,
-1.030464768409729,
0.16964279115200043,
0.10908037424087524,
-0.3454951047897339,
-0.05821962654590607,
0.17995159327983856,
0.026905696839094162,
-0.7854334712028503,
0.45713168382644653,
0.49632611870765686,
0.2982662320137024,
-0.15584443509578705,
-0.4985896944999695,
-0.1859801709651947,
0.17427873611450195,
0.3540230989456177,
0.5006616115570068,
-1.0042065382003784,
0.1588635891675949,
-0.05189773812890053,
-0.31062033772468567,
0.07593359798192978,
0.8126824498176575,
-0.6545031666755676,
0.172615647315979,
0.11493217200040817,
0.8317142128944397,
0.4769001603126526,
-0.39429113268852234,
0.5332249999046326,
-0.22107982635498047,
0.18487495183944702,
0.23623517155647278,
0.30024653673171997,
0.2900950014591217,
0.10016310960054398,
0.3313095271587372,
0.04983748123049736,
-0.5247742533683777,
-0.8378213047981262,
0.39187121391296387,
-0.7529155611991882,
0.15104946494102478,
1.2349870204925537,
0.0448889322578907,
-0.02718644216656685,
-0.3845716118812561,
-0.4321182072162628,
0.37715649604797363,
-0.4774163067340851,
0.9237954616546631,
0.6970856189727783,
-0.1487571895122528,
-0.29139772057533264,
-0.6858130693435669,
0.33670809864997864,
0.5033705234527588,
-0.6696654558181763,
-0.4761529862880707,
0.25683000683784485,
0.13343776762485504,
-0.034722696989774704,
0.8016840815544128,
-0.07859417796134949,
0.2970217168331146,
-0.2797531187534332,
0.4121747612953186,
-0.03192954137921333,
-0.09592541307210922,
-0.6702311038970947,
-0.37164631485939026,
0.17383095622062683,
-0.581229567527771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18118v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18118v2 | SafeAligner: Safety Alignment against Jailbreak Attacks via Response Disparity Guidance | 2024-06-26T07:15:44 | 2024-06-28T06:06:59 | Caishuang Huang, Wanxu Zhao, Rui Zheng, Huijie Lv, Shihan Dou, Sixian Li, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Junjie Ye, Yuming Yang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | As the development of large language models (LLMs) rapidly advances, securing
these models effectively without compromising their utility has become a
pivotal area of research. However, current defense strategies against jailbreak
attacks (i.e., efforts to bypass security protocols) often suffer from limited
adaptability, restricted general capability, and high cost. To address these
challenges, we introduce SafeAligner, a methodology implemented at the decoding
stage to fortify defenses against jailbreak attacks. We begin by developing two
specialized models: the Sentinel Model, which is trained to foster safety, and
the Intruder Model, designed to generate riskier responses. SafeAligner
leverages the disparity in security levels between the responses from these
models to differentiate between harmful and beneficial tokens, effectively
guiding the safety alignment by altering the output token distribution of the
target model. Extensive experiments show that SafeAligner can increase the
likelihood of beneficial tokens, while reducing the occurrence of harmful ones,
thereby ensuring secure alignment with minimal loss to generality. | [
-0.29117897152900696,
-0.6967762112617493,
0.25519368052482605,
-0.08441939949989319,
-0.19088239967823029,
0.40754368901252747,
0.11112304776906967,
-0.33333730697631836,
0.04378831386566162,
0.33984100818634033,
-0.34372788667678833,
-0.5257112383842468,
-0.8494395613670349,
0.03822506591677666,
-0.42738673090934753,
1.2524064779281616,
0.13676044344902039,
-0.0007197177037596703,
0.1040244773030281,
0.012490340508520603,
-0.740606963634491,
-0.47967180609703064,
-0.5403882265090942,
-0.03381243348121643,
0.4858855605125427,
0.201351135969162,
0.967215895652771,
0.628606915473938,
1.0196473598480225,
0.2842049300670624,
-0.47690171003341675,
-0.05467762425541878,
-0.3729745149612427,
0.4207802712917328,
-0.43716779351234436,
-0.3658110797405243,
-0.6313058733940125,
-0.045677006244659424,
0.2059626579284668,
0.2624571621417999,
-0.26143506169319153,
-0.05953697860240936,
0.10149750113487244,
0.9051697254180908,
-0.8723976016044617,
-0.32462844252586365,
-0.7769571542739868,
0.018530189990997314,
-0.26524117588996887,
0.27841028571128845,
-0.6082704663276672,
-0.4988902509212494,
-0.14264953136444092,
-0.21354341506958008,
0.24905352294445038,
0.3817041218280792,
0.5700823664665222,
0.23083576560020447,
-0.41735726594924927,
0.02689599059522152,
-0.6525619626045227,
0.5385428071022034,
-0.4790286719799042,
0.061779748648405075,
0.36342573165893555,
0.429464191198349,
-0.5373824238777161,
-0.4800310730934143,
-0.39025765657424927,
0.027270780876278877,
-0.10872681438922882,
-0.2013842761516571,
-0.4260560870170593,
0.3237752914428711,
0.22621335089206696,
0.2059682160615921,
-0.5294978618621826,
0.13370822370052338,
-0.506122887134552,
-0.3122824430465698,
0.6427364945411682,
0.44192975759506226,
0.4434261918067932,
-0.13584370911121368,
-0.4220120906829834,
-0.2936856150627136,
-0.9169312715530396,
-0.003200183855369687,
0.3194544315338135,
0.4122544825077057,
-0.22387690842151642,
0.5227586627006531,
0.05707533285021782,
0.7782522439956665,
0.4650142788887024,
-0.13488131761550903,
0.007389854174107313,
-0.2807936668395996,
-0.06955782324075699,
0.54389888048172,
0.9091917872428894,
0.6621825098991394,
-0.06467631459236145,
-0.37763890624046326,
-0.23973482847213745,
0.09243530035018921,
0.49150973558425903,
-0.8298051953315735,
-0.21196241676807404,
0.300184041261673,
-0.4301599860191345,
-0.8549134731292725,
0.19081759452819824,
-1.0118812322616577,
-1.005899429321289,
0.10932997614145279,
0.2767924964427948,
-0.42338669300079346,
-0.30077388882637024,
0.11135165393352509,
-0.10901772230863571,
0.17392410337924957,
-0.08722186088562012,
-1.1198734045028687,
0.4277401268482208,
0.7782096266746521,
0.9564191699028015,
0.06470730900764465,
-0.055325184017419815,
-0.8995654582977295,
0.18390575051307678,
-0.24069559574127197,
0.5310524106025696,
-0.1494418978691101,
-0.42858386039733887,
-0.22249816358089447,
-0.05651261284947395,
-0.3267548978328705,
-0.2991834580898285,
0.44107264280319214,
-0.9713009595870972,
-0.23522132635116577,
0.019926341250538826,
-0.32121244072914124,
-0.04269459471106529,
0.4380420446395874,
-0.9299593567848206,
0.45232507586479187,
0.0385698527097702,
-1.3081952333450317,
0.24209249019622803,
-0.47938546538352966,
-0.5289708971977234,
-0.26558709144592285,
0.14014576375484467,
-0.6173780560493469,
0.1862604320049286,
0.39436739683151245,
0.13361597061157227,
-0.18201816082000732,
0.2180078774690628,
-0.5356085896492004,
-0.28450533747673035,
0.38756465911865234,
-0.2364235371351242,
0.807331919670105,
0.6946220397949219,
-0.41730910539627075,
0.24638648331165314,
-0.8105984330177307,
-0.11971975862979889,
0.22480282187461853,
-0.11368095129728317,
-0.604472815990448,
0.11124611645936966,
-0.17588971555233002,
0.052525561302900314,
0.23916925489902496,
-0.6067784428596497,
-0.08455003052949905,
-0.33575281500816345,
0.45419102907180786,
0.8232627511024475,
-0.16225728392601013,
0.6995333433151245,
-0.20466916263103485,
0.4723037779331207,
0.13298138976097107,
0.4783785343170166,
-0.11441241949796677,
-0.06588493287563324,
-0.3899935185909271,
-0.6355465054512024,
0.45415812730789185,
0.9714835286140442,
-0.15259762108325958,
0.4313037097454071,
0.01327566523104906,
-0.32768514752388,
-0.6258888244628906,
0.26446661353111267,
0.5556456446647644,
0.5943445563316345,
0.4024006724357605,
-0.2661115527153015,
-0.6874887347221375,
-0.6550491452217102,
-0.4495735466480255,
-0.2563285827636719,
0.21634544432163239,
-0.6106839179992676,
0.04190830513834953,
-0.1703299582004547,
0.8185651302337646,
-0.4310188889503479,
-0.2052682340145111,
-0.5002227425575256,
-0.21816903352737427,
0.26850637793540955,
0.6725720763206482,
0.6330562233924866,
-0.6023697257041931,
-0.29014143347740173,
-0.19606798887252808,
-0.8849894404411316,
0.06581603735685349,
0.05095180496573448,
-0.2361210733652115,
0.014384583570063114,
0.8109071254730225,
-0.620647132396698,
0.48489823937416077,
0.5004772543907166,
-0.5557509064674377,
-0.010986150242388248,
-0.05046143755316734,
-0.02908521145582199,
-1.4649245738983154,
-0.1613065004348755,
-0.14313317835330963,
-0.26463526487350464,
-0.9477086663246155,
0.38863128423690796,
0.19888034462928772,
-0.028704296797513962,
-0.49254798889160156,
0.23251424729824066,
-0.3079083263874054,
0.3355788290500641,
-0.21301722526550293,
0.08893708884716034,
-0.010694333352148533,
-0.3163234293460846,
-0.40448692440986633,
0.9343665838241577,
0.522031843662262,
-0.25139951705932617,
0.26937752962112427,
0.43143486976623535,
-0.2329965978860855,
0.5643500089645386,
-0.9044577479362488,
0.3079378604888916,
-0.4196719825267792,
-0.05705473944544792,
-0.8494581580162048,
-0.341176837682724,
0.3983672857284546,
-0.2301681935787201,
0.5940255522727966,
-0.5529760718345642,
-0.42189139127731323,
-0.31182512640953064,
-0.375880628824234,
0.5298125147819519,
0.563600480556488,
-0.5570093393325806,
0.6384444832801819,
0.5291940569877625,
-0.30676034092903137,
-0.7565106153488159,
-0.48550835251808167,
0.21021009981632233,
-0.6808499693870544,
-0.8458172678947449,
0.12171486765146255,
0.002868476090952754,
-0.6649407148361206,
-0.2707322835922241,
-0.11745217442512512,
-0.04613017663359642,
0.5129508376121521,
0.4356919825077057,
0.649833083152771,
0.04853455722332001,
-0.2258199006319046,
0.19611163437366486,
-0.39526307582855225,
0.19891774654388428,
-0.1845141500234604,
0.39217275381088257,
-0.4336014688014984,
-0.4165889620780945,
-0.42766043543815613,
0.442209392786026,
0.7915120124816895,
-0.4027118682861328,
1.1870821714401245,
0.2047632932662964,
-0.19157865643501282,
0.39840689301490784,
-0.4152403175830841,
-0.21040214598178864,
-0.5674324035644531,
0.23480555415153503,
-0.2647489607334137,
-0.9897996187210083,
0.4763612449169159,
0.10356245934963226,
0.11077585071325302,
0.035811491310596466,
0.16699770092964172,
0.0419800840318203,
1.2247371673583984,
0.769149124622345,
-0.548319935798645,
0.49516215920448303,
0.24518227577209473,
0.6298531293869019,
-0.7102228999137878,
-0.34461548924446106,
-0.47524821758270264,
-0.3022456467151642,
-0.44489359855651855,
-0.03661222755908966,
0.3014761507511139,
0.576822817325592,
-0.5065217614173889,
0.565709114074707,
-0.5932060480117798,
0.8392828702926636,
0.3469056487083435,
0.10341891646385193,
0.26644057035446167,
0.0492577850818634,
-0.3237885534763336,
-0.00976872444152832,
-0.6226705312728882,
-0.540721595287323,
1.1256741285324097,
0.474519819021225,
1.313279151916504,
0.5453190803527832,
1.1054911613464355,
0.31949886679649353,
0.2998550236225128,
-0.43109890818595886,
0.4972991645336151,
-0.030096419155597687,
-0.8910256028175354,
0.06876529008150101,
-0.19098728895187378,
-0.8442087769508362,
0.32513627409935,
-0.29571762681007385,
-0.8838611841201782,
0.028683608397841454,
0.31309962272644043,
-0.5426196455955505,
0.3859710097312927,
-0.5780060887336731,
0.7781085968017578,
-0.39571914076805115,
-0.3744628429412842,
0.0037156755570322275,
-1.0439398288726807,
0.6035047769546509,
-0.17950423061847687,
0.3820461928844452,
-0.18796676397323608,
0.46112918853759766,
0.41481441259384155,
-0.5910300612449646,
0.8506707549095154,
-0.23588377237319946,
0.23589307069778442,
0.335501104593277,
0.366169810295105,
0.6956161260604858,
0.169425830245018,
-0.06391876190900803,
-0.10630933940410614,
-0.11017326265573502,
-0.3186379075050354,
-0.17120003700256348,
0.4694560468196869,
-0.6122873425483704,
-0.927714467048645,
-0.5664129853248596,
-0.8899859189987183,
0.12766101956367493,
0.41680699586868286,
0.17718768119812012,
0.15033367276191711,
-0.34525159001350403,
-0.10739622265100479,
1.1367700099945068,
-0.07194868475198746,
0.46178126335144043,
0.2856000065803528,
-0.1315615326166153,
-0.8665359020233154,
0.3930620849132538,
-0.49718692898750305,
0.34712955355644226,
0.13014452159404755,
-0.1364574134349823,
-0.3905131220817566,
-0.6756361722946167,
-0.3782087564468384,
-0.0028209893498569727,
-0.7224538326263428,
-0.6144781708717346,
-0.48937320709228516,
-0.42360439896583557,
-0.48266685009002686,
-0.40856611728668213,
-0.3781786561012268,
-0.5756378769874573,
-0.03893767669796944,
-0.5869691371917725,
0.7574015259742737,
0.4691884517669678,
-0.5098646283149719,
0.41486191749572754,
-1.0828684568405151,
0.14984175562858582,
0.08088308572769165,
-0.005281167104840279,
-0.30149099230766296,
-0.4006095826625824,
-0.10438516736030579,
-0.1008823812007904,
-0.4611421227455139,
-0.8717844486236572,
0.23121367394924164,
-0.04393848031759262,
0.46801555156707764,
0.5776426196098328,
0.6278314590454102,
0.6106335520744324,
-0.6772894263267517,
0.3899223804473877,
0.6192688941955566,
-0.9223827123641968,
0.7640768885612488,
-0.31911978125572205,
0.03306618705391884,
0.881432831287384,
-0.037943802773952484,
-0.24515098333358765,
-0.6973830461502075,
-0.15444490313529968,
-1.05601966381073,
0.4001257121562958,
0.1673809140920639,
0.2784757912158966,
-0.35872042179107666,
0.19387488067150116,
-0.14801812171936035,
0.045932311564683914,
-0.6885122656822205,
0.06434400379657745,
-0.42572641372680664,
-0.5766854286193848,
0.14675380289554596,
-0.17018811404705048,
-0.7864386439323425,
0.021211562678217888,
0.24030882120132446,
0.08816876262426376,
0.23695527017116547,
0.06133599579334259,
-0.3285973370075226,
0.16317082941532135,
0.656478762626648,
0.5701090693473816,
0.16819064319133759,
-0.3120184540748596,
0.514989972114563,
0.19850069284439087,
-0.715711772441864,
0.6289369463920593,
0.48910775780677795,
-0.3415790796279907,
-0.2809680998325348,
0.16199561953544617,
0.4966711699962616,
-0.3079085350036621,
-0.36940690875053406,
0.5494304895401001,
-0.40324169397354126,
-0.01246225368231535,
-0.10579198598861694,
0.40109387040138245,
-0.16275238990783691,
0.4231649935245514,
0.11635950952768326,
0.32287079095840454,
-0.15199914574623108,
-0.013693517073988914,
0.22960779070854187,
0.5562847256660461,
-0.6623865365982056,
-0.16302426159381866,
1.2423228025436401,
0.21762321889400482,
-0.2136201411485672,
0.8237689733505249,
-0.01788683421909809,
-0.5161289572715759,
0.6952983736991882,
0.869043231010437,
1.0317121744155884,
-0.3705267608165741,
-0.12620265781879425,
0.27040255069732666,
0.8715742230415344,
-0.21771489083766937,
0.05905816704034805,
0.35263463854789734,
-0.5663713216781616,
0.0025621552485972643,
-0.47459569573402405,
0.02760341204702854,
-0.13342402875423431,
-1.0071301460266113,
0.07730024307966232,
-1.012466311454773,
-0.5255394577980042,
-0.40197017788887024,
-0.6444858908653259,
-0.2913527190685272,
-0.04611525312066078,
0.06154891848564148,
1.2270703315734863,
-0.7701578736305237,
0.5781691074371338,
0.5725945830345154,
-0.3608286380767822,
-0.6933085322380066,
0.026248717680573463,
0.5674564242362976,
-0.3897307515144348,
0.5722843408584595,
0.2999861538410187,
-0.3898901343345642,
-0.229344442486763,
-0.29648658633232117,
-0.9239023923873901,
1.1395694017410278,
0.312583327293396,
-0.8200005292892456,
0.07903624325990677,
0.14323143661022186,
0.21470123529434204,
-0.31205618381500244,
-0.23535451292991638,
0.5667762160301208,
0.18877242505550385,
-0.1791110336780548,
-0.5954688787460327,
0.4192843735218048,
-0.25657880306243896,
0.2822330594062805,
0.6935326457023621,
-0.5178245306015015,
0.5684632062911987,
-0.6444556713104248,
-0.026506369933485985,
0.5434790253639221,
0.5893970131874084,
0.6622193455696106,
0.5042861700057983,
0.4606664180755615,
0.7391578555107117,
0.7235739231109619,
-0.2380273938179016,
0.7992767691612244,
-0.598803699016571,
0.0903392881155014,
0.9926709532737732,
-0.38864925503730774,
0.6844128966331482,
0.6890665292739868,
0.19958052039146423,
0.4246515929698944,
0.5107376575469971,
0.019543249160051346,
1.259661078453064,
0.1753358393907547,
-0.684937059879303,
-0.14853572845458984,
0.26718905568122864,
-0.5440563559532166,
0.14824800193309784,
0.2720986008644104,
-0.45359331369400024,
-0.19652336835861206,
0.07263893634080887,
0.5660271048545837,
0.08659518510103226,
-0.3814699649810791,
0.7306485176086426,
0.1326647698879242,
-0.5646303296089172,
0.5972816944122314,
0.20758767426013947,
0.406031996011734,
-0.5509253144264221,
0.41730308532714844,
-0.407812237739563,
0.6077880859375,
-0.20206569135189056,
-0.5127953886985779,
0.5996715426445007,
0.43040332198143005,
-0.5062389373779297,
0.211585134267807,
0.8492438197135925,
-0.10221289098262787,
-0.40287601947784424,
0.32685014605522156,
-0.10560755431652069,
-0.3296458423137665,
0.474469393491745,
-0.5610171556472778,
0.22706472873687744,
-0.1918688416481018,
0.048633843660354614,
0.7139150500297546,
0.05459248274564743,
-0.0926927849650383,
0.5877836346626282,
0.4962961673736572,
-0.34767159819602966,
0.23054130375385284,
-0.17132596671581268,
1.1131737232208252,
-0.522974967956543,
-0.40333080291748047,
-1.109744668006897,
0.8236190676689148,
-0.3096391260623932,
0.1941142976284027,
0.7651298642158508,
0.4271574914455414,
0.579359233379364,
-0.0006373666692525148,
0.8259202837944031,
-0.20530661940574646,
0.2769032120704651,
-0.6044924855232239,
1.0591789484024048,
0.046570971608161926,
0.6860681176185608,
-0.4494033455848694,
-0.7211920619010925,
-0.708857536315918,
0.8591522574424744,
-0.35453006625175476,
-0.3659127950668335,
0.5721537470817566,
1.1689485311508179,
-0.09876929223537445,
-0.07890201359987259,
-0.08268745988607407,
0.02615194208920002,
0.46550488471984863,
0.5258461833000183,
1.0740294456481934,
-0.5710382461547852,
0.7134093046188354,
0.0375906303524971,
-0.3332701325416565,
-0.00697031756862998,
-1.089712381362915,
-1.200973391532898,
0.14321304857730865,
-0.15712173283100128,
-0.9372647404670715,
0.5618431568145752,
0.8886655569076538,
0.6334185004234314,
-0.935882568359375,
-0.03796149045228958,
-0.26202118396759033,
0.2777615487575531,
-0.11317528039216995,
-0.13489116728305817,
0.056988827884197235,
-0.43410709500312805,
-0.25492581725120544,
0.5500814914703369,
0.2708711624145508,
0.28381872177124023,
0.2753206193447113,
-0.2566676139831543,
0.27630481123924255,
0.23221060633659363,
0.3013957142829895,
0.40083029866218567,
-0.4878922402858734,
-0.21602973341941833,
0.08635758608579636,
-0.3098839819431305,
-0.12081459909677505,
0.5766693949699402,
-0.4061512351036072,
0.37126871943473816,
0.2888953983783722,
0.7246301174163818,
-0.05453219264745712,
-0.016527289524674416,
0.6954383254051208,
-0.5009722709655762,
0.46882447600364685,
-0.10424312949180603,
0.39206868410110474,
0.4429655373096466,
-0.4675701856613159,
0.379647433757782,
-0.06023143604397774,
-0.5468301773071289,
-0.9802497029304504,
0.5677984356880188,
-0.7046664953231812,
-0.14918920397758484,
0.8297625184059143,
-0.28895020484924316,
-0.29247722029685974,
-0.21433599293231964,
-0.194119393825531,
0.004209838341921568,
-0.30279505252838135,
1.2565430402755737,
0.42750802636146545,
0.25005751848220825,
-0.22108976542949677,
-0.0126607995480299,
0.46308913826942444,
0.19737137854099274,
-0.6496713757514954,
0.08431223034858704,
0.4064781963825226,
0.6570398807525635,
0.19303128123283386,
0.2909002900123596,
-0.6052504777908325,
0.3688698410987854,
0.04446158558130264,
-0.2609572410583496,
-0.20336103439331055,
-0.5131824016571045,
-0.463524729013443,
0.11230860650539398,
0.4261196553707123,
-0.49234774708747864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18116v1 | BADGE: BADminton report Generation and Evaluation with LLM | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | 2024-06-26T07:07:52 | Shang-Hsuan Chiang, Lin-Wei Chao, Kuang-Da Wang, Chih-Chuan Wang, Wen-Chih Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Badminton enjoys widespread popularity, and reports on matches generally
include details such as player names, game scores, and ball types, providing
audiences with a comprehensive view of the games. However, writing these
reports can be a time-consuming task. This challenge led us to explore whether
a Large Language Model (LLM) could automate the generation and evaluation of
badminton reports. We introduce a novel framework named BADGE, designed for
this purpose using LLM. Our method consists of two main phases: Report
Generation and Report Evaluation. Initially, badminton-related data is
processed by the LLM, which then generates a detailed report of the match. We
tested different Input Data Types, In-Context Learning (ICL), and LLM, finding
that GPT-4 performs best when using CSV data type and the Chain of Thought
prompting. Following report generation, the LLM evaluates and scores the
reports to assess their quality. Our comparisons between the scores evaluated
by GPT-4 and human judges show a tendency to prefer GPT-4 generated reports.
Since the application of LLM in badminton reporting remains largely unexplored,
our research serves as a foundational step for future advancements in this
area. Moreover, our method can be extended to other sports games, thereby
enhancing sports promotion. For more details, please refer to
https://github.com/AndyChiangSH/BADGE. | [
-0.11217673122882843,
-0.46455836296081543,
0.5489287972450256,
0.4665974974632263,
-0.3498038351535797,
0.17336362600326538,
-0.01811252348124981,
-0.6614149808883667,
0.22648076713085175,
0.0180355217307806,
-0.3781591057777405,
-0.9032900929450989,
-0.4352280795574188,
0.14127348363399506,
-0.28563815355300903,
0.6740097403526306,
-0.27281656861305237,
0.23571361601352692,
-0.2514936923980713,
-0.17095708847045898,
-1.0159716606140137,
-0.5523969531059265,
-0.7524384260177612,
-0.5245106220245361,
0.21685470640659332,
0.25209251046180725,
-0.20385803282260895,
0.5586255788803101,
0.6669707298278809,
0.257167786359787,
0.20146742463111877,
0.35568463802337646,
-0.6179063320159912,
0.41265636682510376,
-0.23364391922950745,
-0.46800246834754944,
-0.6863370537757874,
0.25870057940483093,
0.6577876210212708,
0.2382129728794098,
0.07219237089157104,
0.5457201600074768,
0.18060816824436188,
0.5118618607521057,
-0.4884820282459259,
0.7758861780166626,
-0.4766480326652527,
0.03039594367146492,
-0.3862878978252411,
-0.5802566409111023,
-0.48885640501976013,
-0.31146425008773804,
-0.5332937836647034,
-0.4825812876224518,
-0.11059898138046265,
0.26271748542785645,
0.7301998734474182,
-0.22151152789592743,
-0.28639063239097595,
-0.28604257106781006,
-0.7249675989151001,
0.5934503674507141,
-0.4761952757835388,
0.012592107057571411,
0.5410861372947693,
0.6465065479278564,
0.0020013481844216585,
-0.5366460084915161,
-0.30074551701545715,
-0.20935042202472687,
0.05923061817884445,
0.6464508771896362,
0.17569191753864288,
-0.213211327791214,
0.02466008812189102,
0.17097756266593933,
-0.7227792739868164,
0.17140816152095795,
0.015365343540906906,
0.2772902846336365,
0.9955888390541077,
0.6039900183677673,
0.30045267939567566,
-0.22396260499954224,
-0.2500222325325012,
0.24835705757141113,
-0.7443491220474243,
0.22221533954143524,
0.19578960537910461,
0.5315285325050354,
0.03958089277148247,
0.45590800046920776,
-0.21518398821353912,
0.4953462779521942,
0.4868102967739105,
-0.2089613527059555,
0.011251126416027546,
-0.1690184324979782,
-0.06534839421510696,
0.24539652466773987,
0.6349745392799377,
0.9091389775276184,
-0.19175997376441956,
-0.2627507448196411,
-0.32546380162239075,
0.18074741959571838,
-0.1326197385787964,
-0.9342242479324341,
-0.12418863922357559,
0.28225794434547424,
-0.6202248930931091,
-0.4392086863517761,
0.29373684525489807,
-0.41933581233024597,
-0.6166322231292725,
-0.2684752345085144,
0.6100789308547974,
-0.46507513523101807,
-0.22041238844394684,
-0.0238443985581398,
-0.06796039640903473,
0.768831729888916,
0.3770574927330017,
-0.8849653601646423,
0.12357918918132782,
0.8536484837532043,
0.8626476526260376,
-0.3851627707481384,
-0.2681748569011688,
-0.9762433767318726,
0.45000430941581726,
-0.33441153168678284,
0.9410369396209717,
-0.6421886086463928,
-0.6452242732048035,
0.33257371187210083,
-0.11902438849210739,
-0.0011851699091494083,
-0.5532217621803284,
0.07550434023141861,
-0.47791406512260437,
-0.1431429535150528,
-0.42624029517173767,
-0.8982630372047424,
0.17978817224502563,
0.4827544391155243,
-0.4325224459171295,
1.1317157745361328,
0.23995986580848694,
-0.600058913230896,
0.8953502774238586,
-0.7826308608055115,
-0.7353893518447876,
0.7326793670654297,
-0.34152883291244507,
-0.42794960737228394,
0.05824164301156998,
0.19730709493160248,
0.4048365354537964,
-0.4885331392288208,
0.14365288615226746,
-0.3307357132434845,
-0.8722937107086182,
0.2728084325790405,
0.13141505420207977,
0.39320680499076843,
-0.13584548234939575,
-0.3891380727291107,
0.3106040060520172,
-0.6101518869400024,
0.1639225333929062,
-0.1003812849521637,
-0.4936388432979584,
0.07990862429141998,
0.2629352807998657,
-0.0031220568343997,
0.06571871787309647,
0.17323513329029083,
-0.6112788319587708,
0.18866795301437378,
-0.25261130928993225,
0.11981622129678726,
1.0565351247787476,
0.07097279280424118,
0.1730438619852066,
-0.40719762444496155,
0.7413792014122009,
-0.3194918930530548,
0.5568919777870178,
-0.08240705728530884,
-0.41539832949638367,
-0.29125651717185974,
-0.3427315950393677,
0.3714500963687897,
0.3732295036315918,
-0.597650945186615,
0.5764631032943726,
-0.33661437034606934,
-0.5431543588638306,
-0.4865553081035614,
0.058916375041007996,
0.24179118871688843,
0.40018290281295776,
0.11925259977579117,
-0.37493714690208435,
-0.5364625453948975,
-0.5602377653121948,
-0.44368138909339905,
-0.4802660048007965,
0.09957757592201233,
0.5840144157409668,
0.3982946276664734,
0.06468094140291214,
0.8001404404640198,
-0.6727979183197021,
-0.502220094203949,
-0.49516361951828003,
0.27074843645095825,
0.11049333214759827,
0.34351301193237305,
0.7737696766853333,
-0.5688586831092834,
-0.9936317801475525,
-0.02671738900244236,
-0.9823344349861145,
-0.28582578897476196,
0.002989876549690962,
-0.26338183879852295,
0.16505900025367737,
0.355392187833786,
-0.26671093702316284,
0.6294423341751099,
0.31432077288627625,
-0.3070400059223175,
0.8374173641204834,
0.0651826336979866,
0.5635417103767395,
-0.9283615946769714,
0.35281315445899963,
-0.1910093128681183,
-0.44077467918395996,
-0.18236011266708374,
0.0046477653086185455,
-0.037979185581207275,
0.01498423982411623,
-0.31936338543891907,
0.660833477973938,
-0.4888789653778076,
0.04379546642303467,
-0.5374457240104675,
-0.045871466398239136,
-0.08510354906320572,
0.16183820366859436,
-0.15038686990737915,
0.6502622961997986,
0.530985414981842,
-0.5515638589859009,
0.47656598687171936,
0.15611571073532104,
-0.5583120584487915,
0.921914279460907,
-0.3482282757759094,
0.043196696788072586,
-0.08809184283018112,
0.2143460512161255,
-1.1297606229782104,
-0.44713523983955383,
0.17751723527908325,
-0.42410826683044434,
0.6118139624595642,
-0.2760544717311859,
-0.6381340622901917,
-0.6584176421165466,
-0.6467993855476379,
0.26699593663215637,
0.5022447109222412,
-0.6853047013282776,
0.42003074288368225,
0.7714726328849792,
0.02700730599462986,
-0.0690256729722023,
-0.6296926140785217,
0.1847238838672638,
-0.3116104006767273,
-0.21147839725017548,
0.1943664401769638,
-0.4329357147216797,
-0.03931669518351555,
-0.16931450366973877,
-0.3645094037055969,
-0.08453672379255295,
0.16154900193214417,
0.4394741356372833,
0.20134098827838898,
-0.05730234831571579,
0.09273703396320343,
-0.28863999247550964,
-0.056015495210886,
0.12700262665748596,
-0.2722730040550232,
0.541262149810791,
-0.047945763915777206,
-0.2791706621646881,
-0.5633925795555115,
0.5836812257766724,
0.1548081785440445,
-0.121666818857193,
0.6131660342216492,
0.4706345796585083,
-0.0459601916372776,
-0.415458083152771,
-0.2834267318248749,
-0.010863964445888996,
-0.5130943655967712,
0.23808735609054565,
-0.5818057060241699,
-0.7770226001739502,
0.4121814966201782,
-0.209653839468956,
-0.18721097707748413,
0.46834686398506165,
0.5081615447998047,
-0.2531437873840332,
1.3101670742034912,
0.6691972017288208,
-0.16914260387420654,
0.24811309576034546,
0.07440025359392166,
0.0861748680472374,
-0.7625712752342224,
-0.2690223455429077,
-0.2949022352695465,
-0.376818984746933,
-0.4229828417301178,
-0.0548173263669014,
0.33032798767089844,
-0.023925824090838432,
-0.24868933856487274,
0.03319445624947548,
-0.4687003195285797,
0.901360273361206,
0.24428591132164001,
0.1281871795654297,
0.07007481902837753,
-0.3562881648540497,
0.03750813752412796,
-0.17875437438488007,
-0.5636255145072937,
-0.3522205948829651,
1.1139650344848633,
-0.20508696138858795,
0.6894428730010986,
0.35493752360343933,
1.0230244398117065,
0.6367480754852295,
0.8436872363090515,
-0.6904391050338745,
0.749198317527771,
-0.0607525072991848,
-0.39865294098854065,
-0.03581937402486801,
-0.3004375100135803,
-0.8158186078071594,
-0.15201826393604279,
-0.03329703211784363,
-0.6034378409385681,
-0.4205012321472168,
0.05102230980992317,
-0.28375178575515747,
0.2731246054172516,
-0.350016325712204,
0.416366845369339,
-0.3461509346961975,
-0.5022279620170593,
0.33283594250679016,
-0.46550238132476807,
0.7907719612121582,
-0.37481966614723206,
0.10699839890003204,
-0.07119997590780258,
0.2730301022529602,
0.8905787467956543,
-0.4820857644081116,
0.9297536611557007,
-0.41098248958587646,
0.06287554651498795,
0.316030889749527,
0.25555506348609924,
0.29819509387016296,
0.10559387505054474,
-0.14502553641796112,
-0.3505336344242096,
-0.1324901580810547,
-0.2194921374320984,
-0.4384707510471344,
0.8611670732498169,
-0.530478835105896,
-0.6109248995780945,
-0.6838337779045105,
-0.3955211341381073,
-0.3283333480358124,
0.27919891476631165,
0.07097064703702927,
0.271587073802948,
-0.42891064286231995,
-0.041483018547296524,
0.1643492579460144,
-0.21803325414657593,
0.3709055483341217,
0.8019041419029236,
-0.6553351283073425,
-0.18327002227306366,
0.8978373408317566,
0.31267818808555603,
-0.3419356346130371,
0.41523438692092896,
0.21078555285930634,
-0.4998985230922699,
-0.7063930630683899,
-0.03140227869153023,
0.21912239491939545,
-0.7202094197273254,
-0.4786927103996277,
0.06502412259578705,
-0.21769143640995026,
-0.5991129875183105,
0.06810801476240158,
-0.2249685674905777,
-0.19863395392894745,
0.04411656782031059,
-0.25127995014190674,
0.2700587809085846,
1.2016699314117432,
-0.23987312614917755,
0.3308039605617523,
-0.5421114563941956,
0.10182871669530869,
0.21282371878623962,
0.7853633761405945,
0.0015310132876038551,
-0.5896429419517517,
-0.30177077651023865,
-0.3808027505874634,
-0.18701013922691345,
-0.6578091979026794,
0.29788804054260254,
-0.028370250016450882,
0.5347539782524109,
0.25424924492836,
0.051815230399370193,
0.8439099788665771,
-0.7018356919288635,
1.023380160331726,
0.3320256471633911,
-0.8852888345718384,
0.6997602581977844,
-0.5208401679992676,
0.2129061222076416,
0.6449553370475769,
0.12407373636960983,
-0.3760107159614563,
-0.3506779074668884,
-0.33938920497894287,
-1.1122093200683594,
0.7398818731307983,
-0.045245494693517685,
-0.20392495393753052,
-0.3419409394264221,
0.4799741506576538,
0.21509207785129547,
0.2438630312681198,
-0.5566253066062927,
-0.22892728447914124,
-0.10333725064992905,
-0.13519468903541565,
-0.15290088951587677,
-0.32484427094459534,
-0.1513894498348236,
-0.2962226867675781,
0.6383569836616516,
-0.048299454152584076,
0.21868246793746948,
-0.13152116537094116,
-0.3023492991924286,
0.025105051696300507,
-0.051494091749191284,
0.5236833095550537,
0.8696151375770569,
-0.4605782628059387,
0.020807405933737755,
0.040114857256412506,
-0.21285292506217957,
0.09544333070516586,
-0.13440366089344025,
-0.25710591673851013,
-0.14613579213619232,
0.4721623659133911,
0.3336058259010315,
0.21867257356643677,
-0.26826879382133484,
0.6217983365058899,
-0.19310419261455536,
-0.45418304204940796,
-0.06616111099720001,
-0.12023996561765671,
0.12854626774787903,
0.18157537281513214,
0.2613403797149658,
-0.3764805197715759,
-0.02876647748053074,
-0.5095374584197998,
0.40718039870262146,
0.3902578055858612,
-0.3353961408138275,
-0.4996066689491272,
0.962107241153717,
0.45717689394950867,
-0.17502030730247498,
0.15481089055538177,
-0.4981003999710083,
-0.43976837396621704,
0.22218790650367737,
0.7622585296630859,
0.8317261338233948,
-0.2817547619342804,
0.41093096137046814,
0.3881421685218811,
0.0956941694021225,
0.08235421776771545,
0.5662228465080261,
0.014387222006917,
-0.16845335066318512,
-0.5597383379936218,
-0.8377776145935059,
-0.29257604479789734,
0.2833921015262604,
-0.5136939883232117,
-0.10105713456869125,
-0.5482954978942871,
-0.3329983055591583,
-0.1008310317993164,
0.22840650379657745,
-0.6289874911308289,
-0.031561996787786484,
0.3329881727695465,
0.8657557368278503,
-0.908428966999054,
0.6251847743988037,
0.4427836537361145,
-0.7754023671150208,
-0.8307055830955505,
-0.03203415870666504,
0.0651167631149292,
-0.8510885834693909,
1.1227169036865234,
0.36383360624313354,
-0.14901481568813324,
-0.11813794821500778,
-0.589431881904602,
-0.23514851927757263,
1.2134342193603516,
-0.050372686237096786,
-0.39275887608528137,
0.29982879757881165,
0.4474414885044098,
0.3011232018470764,
-0.4750877022743225,
0.15838906168937683,
0.5434907674789429,
0.7604836821556091,
-0.04776780679821968,
-0.6217126846313477,
0.11903376132249832,
-0.2522917091846466,
-0.016258861869573593,
-0.0019444728968665004,
-0.9632304310798645,
0.7244900465011597,
0.3500329256057739,
-0.2145387828350067,
0.28066885471343994,
0.6090191006660461,
0.2412276417016983,
0.16967511177062988,
0.16309630870819092,
0.2628905773162842,
1.0336326360702515,
-0.022739160805940628,
1.1481554508209229,
-0.298330157995224,
0.2663434147834778,
1.2743979692459106,
-1.1416422128677368,
0.688728392124176,
0.23159193992614746,
-0.08220408111810684,
0.13938908278942108,
0.5707802772521973,
-0.3220239579677582,
0.3362877368927002,
0.5518242716789246,
-0.3601241409778595,
-0.3700762987136841,
-0.08637682348489761,
-0.2433575987815857,
0.7355079650878906,
-0.13189579546451569,
-0.11241103708744049,
-0.35019412636756897,
-0.010188502259552479,
-0.07378095388412476,
0.17471915483474731,
-0.4926774203777313,
0.7420767545700073,
-0.11502411961555481,
-0.561582624912262,
0.2551197409629822,
0.11014187335968018,
0.506209135055542,
-0.6611218452453613,
-0.1143350675702095,
-0.38461828231811523,
0.45513418316841125,
-0.05767494812607765,
-0.8652230501174927,
-0.032826151698827744,
0.3808659017086029,
-0.2625533640384674,
-0.27205923199653625,
0.6861922740936279,
-0.32403695583343506,
-0.5043318271636963,
0.30202603340148926,
0.42168712615966797,
0.3383824825286865,
-0.058911655098199844,
-0.5677014589309692,
0.15503603219985962,
-0.24518752098083496,
-0.07737872749567032,
0.5602407455444336,
0.3637547492980957,
-0.05594068765640259,
0.4905370771884918,
0.43854761123657227,
0.3260190486907959,
-0.05261514335870743,
0.3261892795562744,
0.6062241196632385,
-0.6874906420707703,
-0.5365140438079834,
-0.9476890563964844,
0.20390892028808594,
-0.32869306206703186,
-0.10881562530994415,
1.1400372982025146,
1.282103419303894,
0.1498863399028778,
-0.0771225318312645,
0.9863013029098511,
0.06337770819664001,
0.49325597286224365,
-0.3764609098434448,
1.157796859741211,
-0.29795902967453003,
0.2346022129058838,
0.01677156612277031,
-0.5992348790168762,
-0.6473437547683716,
0.18053670227527618,
-0.18053999543190002,
-0.1396285593509674,
0.6219620704650879,
0.47104838490486145,
0.043859682977199554,
-0.09898967295885086,
0.28348055481910706,
0.24364420771598816,
0.8245501518249512,
0.6605492830276489,
0.8182540535926819,
-0.3057405352592468,
0.5064801573753357,
0.4584396779537201,
-0.5596296787261963,
-0.44934338331222534,
-0.8393221497535706,
-1.1901848316192627,
-0.3636695146560669,
-0.25688624382019043,
-0.3905618190765381,
0.21736884117126465,
0.5642838478088379,
0.5393921732902527,
-0.6653291583061218,
-0.4922553300857544,
0.3522445857524872,
-0.21178759634494781,
-0.1995142698287964,
-0.27687308192253113,
0.6920905113220215,
-0.5179010629653931,
-0.5244120359420776,
0.4741836190223694,
0.47646859288215637,
-0.2968099117279053,
0.09828869253396988,
-0.26270052790641785,
-0.49508652091026306,
0.07757499068975449,
0.9331108331680298,
0.3905511200428009,
-0.2584743797779083,
-0.5576105713844299,
-0.18516051769256592,
-0.00904972106218338,
0.16298404335975647,
0.5172138810157776,
-0.7075964212417603,
0.47912129759788513,
0.3676453232765198,
0.5445025563240051,
0.7376309037208557,
0.00948917493224144,
0.6050546765327454,
-0.7673823237419128,
-0.27388638257980347,
0.1312900334596634,
0.1383715718984604,
0.23779356479644775,
-0.04555502533912659,
0.5800299048423767,
0.38469406962394714,
-0.4632002115249634,
-1.020643711090088,
0.0856102779507637,
-0.8799818754196167,
-0.23358917236328125,
1.1128337383270264,
-0.04663382098078728,
-0.558724045753479,
0.07004797458648682,
-0.190479576587677,
0.21201340854167938,
-0.165746808052063,
0.8453661203384399,
0.8724441528320312,
-0.44065117835998535,
0.44804906845092773,
-0.24875551462173462,
0.6666469573974609,
-0.04655708745121956,
-0.8079490661621094,
0.2969346046447754,
0.28113433718681335,
0.44539186358451843,
-0.43977683782577515,
0.9998916983604431,
-0.16408494114875793,
0.42900553345680237,
0.015353180468082428,
-0.11979455500841141,
-0.2811690866947174,
-0.15782883763313293,
0.04470183700323105,
0.3143458068370819,
0.11567240953445435,
-0.31563204526901245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18108v1 | Token-Weighted RNN-T for Learning from Flawed Data | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | 2024-06-26T06:48:11 | Gil Keren, Wei Zhou, Ozlem Kalinli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | ASR models are commonly trained with the cross-entropy criterion to increase
the probability of a target token sequence. While optimizing the probability of
all tokens in the target sequence is sensible, one may want to de-emphasize
tokens that reflect transcription errors. In this work, we propose a novel
token-weighted RNN-T criterion that augments the RNN-T objective with
token-specific weights. The new objective is used for mitigating accuracy loss
from transcriptions errors in the training data, which naturally appear in two
settings: pseudo-labeling and human annotation errors. Experiments results show
that using our method for semi-supervised learning with pseudo-labels leads to
a consistent accuracy improvement, up to 38% relative. We also analyze the
accuracy degradation resulting from different levels of WER in the reference
transcription, and show that token-weighted RNN-T is suitable for overcoming
this degradation, recovering 64%-99% of the accuracy loss. | [
0.28452417254447937,
-0.35737964510917664,
0.15871864557266235,
0.061021532863378525,
-0.4266228675842285,
0.24382759630680084,
-0.1902044713497162,
-0.1103624701499939,
0.2563812732696533,
0.08421622961759567,
-0.280636191368103,
-0.5409163236618042,
-0.8233334422111511,
0.3377302587032318,
-0.4696212708950043,
1.1949522495269775,
0.03826684132218361,
0.6737024188041687,
-0.09227181226015091,
-0.28307589888572693,
-0.35921257734298706,
-0.6967876553535461,
-0.8584203720092773,
-0.3660582900047302,
0.9248178005218506,
0.34157997369766235,
0.21465380489826202,
0.6025605201721191,
0.6313774585723877,
0.20775474607944489,
-0.11705151945352554,
0.07755155861377716,
-0.4835493564605713,
-0.2230835258960724,
-0.05365372449159622,
-0.8632677793502808,
-0.4633331000804901,
-0.0003676902560982853,
0.6771571636199951,
0.5398762226104736,
-0.12209372222423553,
0.4631749093532562,
-0.07923057675361633,
0.43470481038093567,
-0.6044883728027344,
-0.11656901985406876,
-0.45033150911331177,
0.4281916320323944,
-0.38174352049827576,
-0.5279998779296875,
-0.4727291464805603,
-0.2760293483734131,
0.04382268711924553,
-0.5689114928245544,
0.3705526292324066,
0.15719817578792572,
0.7882139086723328,
0.5984414219856262,
-0.3056257665157318,
0.011158243753015995,
-0.5121855735778809,
0.9482038021087646,
-0.7147954702377319,
0.4547251760959625,
0.5275503396987915,
0.024480409920215607,
0.08995760232210159,
-0.772419273853302,
-0.36245080828666687,
-0.19591699540615082,
0.04606282711029053,
0.18357782065868378,
-0.15425245463848114,
0.04099284112453461,
0.45323920249938965,
0.10809814184904099,
-0.37507668137550354,
-0.018852967768907547,
-0.6544983983039856,
-0.7963576912879944,
0.23926645517349243,
-0.09809457510709763,
0.43320775032043457,
-0.08504887670278549,
-0.4740706980228424,
-0.3365311026573181,
-0.5494554042816162,
-0.04518736153841019,
0.5170611143112183,
0.5871586203575134,
-0.06464985013008118,
0.786547064781189,
0.21586103737354279,
0.8683574795722961,
0.15923377871513367,
-0.2437961995601654,
0.6012440919876099,
-0.2948024868965149,
-0.14267075061798096,
0.4996285140514374,
0.49636468291282654,
0.29080772399902344,
0.14156033098697662,
-0.47999894618988037,
-0.5183351635932922,
0.0882221907377243,
0.30304914712905884,
-0.6201572418212891,
-0.25412610173225403,
-0.044735003262758255,
-0.5892404913902283,
-0.4887411892414093,
0.4733850955963135,
-0.27428576350212097,
-0.15444199740886688,
-0.4472184479236603,
0.9147701263427734,
-0.3494696617126465,
-0.013781430199742317,
0.0713968425989151,
-0.706653892993927,
-0.096480593085289,
0.013319037854671478,
-0.2711479067802429,
0.1259208768606186,
0.4499754011631012,
1.0804531574249268,
-0.27832257747650146,
-0.0256219319999218,
-0.9409664869308472,
0.10913880169391632,
-0.2229083627462387,
0.4511030614376068,
-0.4417172074317932,
-0.38161346316337585,
-0.4730433225631714,
-0.4636067748069763,
0.0170730110257864,
-0.4574897289276123,
0.6854522228240967,
-0.3939126431941986,
0.23966766893863678,
-0.5090205669403076,
-0.5392940640449524,
0.06674746423959732,
0.25131359696388245,
-0.6121721863746643,
0.8856302499771118,
0.29322123527526855,
-0.9884850978851318,
0.6703147888183594,
-0.5309634804725647,
-0.8301771283149719,
-0.3217852711677551,
0.06900934875011444,
-0.8809625506401062,
0.26968419551849365,
0.0968729630112648,
0.1062038391828537,
-0.18043392896652222,
0.3435765206813812,
-0.22662080824375153,
-0.617386519908905,
0.35327205061912537,
-0.30856624245643616,
0.803855299949646,
0.06547056138515472,
-0.5379718542098999,
0.19520676136016846,
-0.9267941117286682,
0.08912652730941772,
-0.2016471028327942,
-0.4686211347579956,
-0.4053005278110504,
-0.487183153629303,
0.14234371483325958,
0.2448030412197113,
0.03353669121861458,
-0.8427940607070923,
0.01438524667173624,
-0.18205846846103668,
0.494533509016037,
0.8423840999603271,
-0.016536107286810875,
0.445455402135849,
-0.6379920840263367,
0.40600672364234924,
0.35203370451927185,
0.2018759548664093,
0.42271649837493896,
-0.34997421503067017,
-0.6185401678085327,
-0.49887895584106445,
0.8573901057243347,
0.5733374357223511,
-0.9109541773796082,
0.6592153906822205,
-0.3241855502128601,
-0.37642359733581543,
-0.6515939235687256,
0.06654087454080582,
0.8095439672470093,
1.1067280769348145,
0.7992319464683533,
-0.5209817290306091,
-1.034057855606079,
-0.6143890619277954,
-0.6488566398620605,
-0.28040561079978943,
-0.35146698355674744,
0.11153966188430786,
0.16367101669311523,
-0.19781853258609772,
0.9222190380096436,
0.007579326629638672,
-0.664903998374939,
-0.1795605719089508,
0.5364295840263367,
-0.041673172265291214,
0.6982212662696838,
0.13370001316070557,
-0.8734948039054871,
-0.3014712929725647,
-0.4319034218788147,
-0.2861658036708832,
-0.3314736485481262,
-0.1193007081747055,
0.2036285251379013,
0.1170358806848526,
0.43733423948287964,
-0.2959229648113251,
0.7348167300224304,
0.15772788226604462,
-0.2936702072620392,
0.2638920545578003,
-0.34624966979026794,
0.04071822017431259,
-0.9669409394264221,
0.10721918195486069,
0.28026092052459717,
-0.3155441880226135,
-0.5829085111618042,
-0.497715026140213,
0.266657292842865,
0.2804218530654907,
-0.3266812264919281,
0.5307475328445435,
-0.21389447152614594,
-0.10392893105745316,
0.07203363627195358,
-0.24146655201911926,
0.017810311168432236,
0.29304540157318115,
0.03044518269598484,
0.6151771545410156,
0.3059859871864319,
-0.37662839889526367,
0.09795068949460983,
0.3251403272151947,
-0.17364755272865295,
0.5638260245323181,
-0.8091762661933899,
0.1875876486301422,
-0.25463610887527466,
0.5087310075759888,
-0.6964281797409058,
0.05724436789751053,
0.36047619581222534,
-0.6733740568161011,
0.7053518891334534,
-0.15967044234275818,
-0.4028274714946747,
-0.4320949614048004,
-0.32044047117233276,
0.7113379836082458,
0.459481418132782,
-0.409458190202713,
0.6578012108802795,
0.0644146054983139,
0.30330219864845276,
-0.8804728984832764,
-1.1514073610305786,
0.19157291948795319,
-0.3155703842639923,
-0.13590197265148163,
0.3005075454711914,
0.28040722012519836,
0.03464306518435478,
0.07331950962543488,
-0.5981349945068359,
0.26325663924217224,
-0.1187032088637352,
0.19238519668579102,
0.20648039877414703,
-0.17949412763118744,
0.08627939224243164,
-0.3477862775325775,
-0.32841217517852783,
-0.21578103303909302,
-0.9134104251861572,
0.2716887891292572,
0.2240227460861206,
-0.3584083020687103,
-0.7697349190711975,
-0.14953243732452393,
0.3024897575378418,
-0.19472242891788483,
0.7313097715377808,
0.8984436988830566,
-0.33414506912231445,
-0.1094064861536026,
-0.6588443517684937,
-0.3570437431335449,
-0.3765196204185486,
0.4383808374404907,
-0.1299888789653778,
-0.5980947613716125,
0.5978035926818848,
0.28767603635787964,
-0.2551676332950592,
0.4921410381793976,
0.30206263065338135,
-0.3879055380821228,
0.7277841567993164,
0.4650764763355255,
-0.28347739577293396,
0.7322567701339722,
-0.2312784641981125,
0.2638324797153473,
-0.8578251004219055,
-0.4859110414981842,
-0.610285758972168,
-0.8955596089363098,
-0.22154709696769714,
-0.6228007674217224,
0.5838327407836914,
-0.29806995391845703,
-0.485649049282074,
0.20066410303115845,
-0.47587427496910095,
0.12539644539356232,
1.0275744199752808,
0.7136960029602051,
0.1290617734193802,
0.08759570866823196,
-0.19770854711532593,
0.15308919548988342,
-0.755837619304657,
-0.0741870105266571,
1.4972294569015503,
0.1945676952600479,
0.8123809695243835,
-0.051659371703863144,
0.8370067477226257,
0.6697553396224976,
0.3513566255569458,
-0.5201426148414612,
0.09774517267942429,
-0.2635210156440735,
-0.654316246509552,
-0.5911049246788025,
-1.0712647438049316,
-0.5848438739776611,
-0.2768639922142029,
-0.1631627231836319,
-0.5625233054161072,
0.2169857621192932,
0.504712700843811,
-0.30664464831352234,
0.6092963814735413,
-0.5061621069908142,
0.8559344410896301,
-0.37793323397636414,
0.11399291455745697,
0.146511048078537,
-1.1014717817306519,
0.042657747864723206,
-0.13489702343940735,
-0.1075015515089035,
0.24966387450695038,
-0.29371097683906555,
1.0765480995178223,
-0.8026401996612549,
0.9133991599082947,
-0.6429341435432434,
0.31111159920692444,
0.2410896122455597,
-0.24063917994499207,
0.7496700882911682,
-0.33725541830062866,
-0.28768840432167053,
0.3043982684612274,
-0.236996129155159,
-0.527469277381897,
-0.5536060333251953,
-0.034899476915597916,
-0.8053189516067505,
-0.1669999659061432,
-0.3652263581752777,
-0.4064205586910248,
-0.21345610916614532,
0.15797898173332214,
0.6496843099594116,
0.7718884944915771,
0.287279337644577,
0.36714473366737366,
0.638882040977478,
-0.08359815180301666,
0.07602845132350922,
0.09329745173454285,
0.3624373972415924,
-0.617303192615509,
1.1609623432159424,
0.2752460241317749,
0.2711468040943146,
0.49559614062309265,
0.45266738533973694,
-0.44663071632385254,
-0.8787686228752136,
-0.33153587579727173,
-0.11426835507154465,
-0.6972700357437134,
-0.7823997735977173,
-0.6499180197715759,
-0.00883087981492281,
-0.07112546265125275,
0.13094055652618408,
-0.24893730878829956,
-0.6769020557403564,
-0.5294288992881775,
-0.36427292227745056,
0.40444859862327576,
0.21384428441524506,
-0.26647835969924927,
0.4261091351509094,
-0.7242581844329834,
0.47085142135620117,
-0.14117413759231567,
0.3559330999851227,
-0.06897248327732086,
-1.1856127977371216,
-0.015008705668151379,
0.29689010977745056,
0.1631108671426773,
-0.43994033336639404,
0.06337559223175049,
0.5306267142295837,
0.3470991551876068,
0.2990233898162842,
0.26059386134147644,
0.9450086951255798,
-0.38739076256752014,
0.4931110441684723,
0.533990740776062,
-1.0167967081069946,
0.3363497853279114,
-0.06691617518663406,
0.12491834908723831,
0.7448946833610535,
-0.002152979141101241,
-0.5585336685180664,
-0.5603765249252319,
-0.7462724447250366,
-0.916476309299469,
0.7347167730331421,
0.27896013855934143,
-0.0058108787052333355,
0.1458951234817505,
0.6769792437553406,
0.05092186853289604,
0.11822862923145294,
-0.7089934349060059,
-0.35958823561668396,
-0.413034588098526,
-0.6869795918464661,
-0.13196015357971191,
-0.15276657044887543,
-0.05241885036230087,
-0.36203667521476746,
0.8948349952697754,
-0.11242514848709106,
0.04598996788263321,
0.5561555027961731,
-0.44012513756752014,
-0.3878386318683624,
-0.20780742168426514,
0.5463314056396484,
0.5878303647041321,
-0.1788390874862671,
0.21601206064224243,
0.3713201582431793,
-0.6847374439239502,
0.2737475335597992,
-0.03625677525997162,
-0.42874330282211304,
-0.14575044810771942,
0.5771304965019226,
0.6149824261665344,
0.35573050379753113,
-0.43471235036849976,
0.7591567635536194,
-0.21349294483661652,
-0.10638025403022766,
-0.05255928635597229,
-0.12998798489570618,
-0.15423183143138885,
0.04490013048052788,
0.7014866471290588,
0.6594886779785156,
-0.027112405747175217,
-0.35653963685035706,
0.6908246278762817,
0.3127923011779785,
-0.6897879242897034,
-0.2530679404735565,
0.787484347820282,
-0.00854394119232893,
-0.353595495223999,
0.6508257985115051,
-0.07476595789194107,
-0.7715478539466858,
0.5813331007957458,
0.5387933850288391,
0.8296029567718506,
-0.16292022168636322,
0.15392260253429413,
0.4082358777523041,
0.26219794154167175,
-0.5094790458679199,
0.35818570852279663,
-0.14535468816757202,
-0.6329695582389832,
-0.28251922130584717,
-0.7302882671356201,
-0.17045871913433075,
-0.37610283493995667,
-0.9029046297073364,
0.39721420407295227,
-0.5874249935150146,
-0.49961262941360474,
-0.11636420339345932,
-0.2552395761013031,
-0.6533844470977783,
0.49835205078125,
-0.043195441365242004,
0.8021485209465027,
-0.9056151509284973,
0.723110556602478,
0.65223628282547,
-0.46385374665260315,
-0.9734161496162415,
0.13799850642681122,
0.034134071320295334,
-0.7095808386802673,
0.8659684062004089,
-0.09905942529439926,
-0.03397904708981514,
0.0559510812163353,
-0.2769327163696289,
-0.9564292430877686,
0.9838647842407227,
0.38339757919311523,
-0.5961306691169739,
-0.14236024022102356,
0.22880470752716064,
0.5801371335983276,
0.03253662586212158,
0.09818375110626221,
0.30294179916381836,
0.6091323494911194,
0.3313649594783783,
-0.9215484261512756,
0.14365367591381073,
-0.011753860861063004,
-0.18806171417236328,
0.25135162472724915,
-0.6486544609069824,
0.5317285656929016,
-0.17628121376037598,
0.06536668539047241,
0.007931984961032867,
0.6119174957275391,
0.06733155250549316,
0.497547447681427,
0.7303608655929565,
0.7537201046943665,
0.9487520456314087,
-0.2756496071815491,
0.9072044491767883,
0.18178194761276245,
0.20107397437095642,
1.1495906114578247,
0.1066509261727333,
0.5020841956138611,
0.6742133498191833,
-0.2135123610496521,
0.24567343294620514,
0.7443346977233887,
-0.2341817170381546,
0.5938172936439514,
0.6459789276123047,
-0.0031106318347156048,
-0.12388090044260025,
-0.06700561940670013,
0.0005439679371193051,
0.38287943601608276,
0.07885048538446426,
-0.2743012011051178,
0.08977043628692627,
0.15445367991924286,
-0.3036719560623169,
-0.0930589884519577,
-0.4819878339767456,
0.7463853359222412,
0.21800972521305084,
-0.28474321961402893,
0.2429261952638626,
-0.0018552367109805346,
0.8454135060310364,
-0.3024289608001709,
0.1823439747095108,
-0.05017053335905075,
0.11741843074560165,
-0.39541658759117126,
-0.04866651073098183,
0.3777792751789093,
0.09357703477144241,
-0.12623897194862366,
-0.23717151582241058,
0.6798073053359985,
-0.5186304450035095,
-0.8672027587890625,
0.02255573496222496,
0.1547337770462036,
0.006755842827260494,
0.06541361659765244,
-0.6432263851165771,
0.010346527211368084,
0.06328138709068298,
-0.15619809925556183,
0.07923807948827744,
0.4459771513938904,
-0.12282434105873108,
0.6145507097244263,
0.6385231018066406,
0.42493030428886414,
0.13627108931541443,
0.2881033718585968,
0.5749890804290771,
-0.6340829133987427,
-0.5203495025634766,
-0.8309431672096252,
0.6231557130813599,
-0.1364285945892334,
-0.2784447968006134,
0.5132752656936646,
0.7414555549621582,
0.9120197296142578,
0.16165977716445923,
0.7053266167640686,
-0.026722416281700134,
0.6430625915527344,
-0.46923941373825073,
0.7368707060813904,
-0.7945601940155029,
0.21351948380470276,
-0.31234508752822876,
-0.7920588850975037,
-0.8868821263313293,
0.5172562599182129,
-0.18264491856098175,
0.2870997488498688,
0.5037835240364075,
0.6419315934181213,
-0.12275724112987518,
-0.1802866905927658,
0.27626553177833557,
0.03256453573703766,
0.16936220228672028,
0.3759898543357849,
0.6688718199729919,
-0.6516041159629822,
0.6374595761299133,
-0.2399357259273529,
-0.13561414182186127,
-0.22042302787303925,
-0.8556410074234009,
-1.0601954460144043,
-0.5009087920188904,
-0.5607399344444275,
-0.575386106967926,
0.25124701857566833,
1.1232126951217651,
0.7090705633163452,
-1.088390588760376,
0.477080762386322,
-0.0029375276062637568,
0.18246012926101685,
-0.14390282332897186,
-0.0629739910364151,
0.6267550587654114,
-0.3695708215236664,
-0.40634533762931824,
0.08904566615819931,
0.22719065845012665,
0.1345638632774353,
0.3376680016517639,
-0.13897478580474854,
0.07018732279539108,
-0.23459042608737946,
-0.02269359864294529,
0.33730196952819824,
-0.6803813576698303,
-0.5759189128875732,
-0.1475137621164322,
-0.11412646621465683,
0.1680315136909485,
1.103894591331482,
-0.6325930953025818,
0.46155670285224915,
0.2961925268173218,
0.9015393257141113,
0.49008888006210327,
0.3299606740474701,
0.7526552677154541,
-1.22494375705719,
0.1769944131374359,
0.5963003039360046,
0.3246627748012543,
0.577651858329773,
-0.5072758197784424,
0.44077110290527344,
0.4540296494960785,
-0.11729422211647034,
-1.1344281435012817,
-0.3508642613887787,
-0.8395302295684814,
0.0657198503613472,
1.0373058319091797,
-0.1448083370923996,
-0.32938599586486816,
-0.19583994150161743,
0.0021190152037888765,
0.9338383078575134,
-0.2768736481666565,
1.0486267805099487,
0.43617966771125793,
0.1403137445449829,
0.09794478118419647,
-0.10687962174415588,
0.6168177723884583,
0.7211655378341675,
-0.26927387714385986,
-0.21676574647426605,
0.15028397738933563,
0.42010176181793213,
0.06537576019763947,
0.3652741014957428,
-0.24434824287891388,
0.3959035873413086,
-0.23441044986248016,
0.0731729120016098,
-0.28767117857933044,
-0.3221747875213623,
-0.3309226632118225,
-0.10875578224658966,
0.06824252754449844,
-0.3565993905067444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18094v1 | Shimo Lab at "Discharge Me!": Discharge Summarization by Prompt-Driven Concatenation of Electronic Health Record Sections | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | 2024-06-26T06:10:20 | Yunzhen He, Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present our approach to the shared task "Discharge Me!" at
the BioNLP Workshop 2024. The primary goal of this task is to reduce the time
and effort clinicians spend on writing detailed notes in the electronic health
record (EHR). Participants develop a pipeline to generate the "Brief Hospital
Course" and "Discharge Instructions" sections from the EHR. Our approach
involves a first step of extracting the relevant sections from the EHR. We then
add explanatory prompts to these sections and concatenate them with separate
tokens to create the input text. To train a text generation model, we perform
LoRA fine-tuning on the ClinicalT5-large model. On the final test data, our
approach achieved a ROUGE-1 score of $0.394$, which is comparable to the top
solutions. | [
-0.2735837399959564,
-0.7539973855018616,
0.9904749393463135,
-0.08320947736501694,
-0.41942957043647766,
0.0026114860083907843,
0.30760657787323,
-0.38748785853385925,
0.41070058941841125,
0.7386482954025269,
-0.8723991513252258,
-0.7868970632553101,
-0.19773289561271667,
0.08810103684663773,
-0.44001346826553345,
1.4645264148712158,
0.14371193945407867,
-0.11410488933324814,
-0.09865860641002655,
-0.13733583688735962,
-0.5473779439926147,
-0.40080392360687256,
-0.6848192811012268,
-0.568935215473175,
0.8716369867324829,
0.4830608367919922,
0.008791809901595116,
0.4047159254550934,
0.6168881058692932,
0.20528581738471985,
-0.03291218355298042,
0.11676125228404999,
-0.07862477749586105,
0.3001026511192322,
-0.10757288336753845,
-0.31042733788490295,
-0.7194823026657104,
-0.2744002938270569,
0.29917433857917786,
0.6730571389198303,
-0.23752540349960327,
0.47269120812416077,
0.0055854530073702335,
0.8656529784202576,
-0.6745105981826782,
-0.26901188492774963,
-0.1915198713541031,
0.20361420512199402,
-0.17490287125110626,
-0.27708327770233154,
-0.6720730066299438,
-0.1534314751625061,
-0.02565571665763855,
-0.490405797958374,
0.4687109887599945,
-0.05552941933274269,
0.4638060927391052,
0.04821273684501648,
-0.43319928646087646,
-0.14773692190647125,
-0.8259331583976746,
0.6620681881904602,
-0.7439861297607422,
-0.10038018226623535,
0.16828452050685883,
0.2497730404138565,
0.09536922723054886,
-0.9899150729179382,
-0.2233666181564331,
0.11074705421924591,
-0.22375355660915375,
0.3838113248348236,
0.06607149541378021,
0.4153518080711365,
0.4784282445907593,
0.2874065935611725,
-0.7626552581787109,
0.014694579876959324,
-0.756811797618866,
0.10739822685718536,
0.9576756954193115,
0.641201913356781,
0.30807483196258545,
-0.07017005234956741,
-0.1699991226196289,
-0.05862974002957344,
-0.5625766515731812,
-0.028948023915290833,
-0.13159458339214325,
0.0777285248041153,
-0.38796737790107727,
0.4901283085346222,
-0.3832302987575531,
0.2852865159511566,
0.3506411015987396,
0.00712035596370697,
0.27015092968940735,
-0.47796979546546936,
-0.25576239824295044,
0.40548476576805115,
0.9546410441398621,
0.49776729941368103,
-0.43188193440437317,
0.18497203290462494,
-0.12061025202274323,
-0.31228429079055786,
0.4762316048145294,
-0.911612331867218,
-0.24195562303066254,
0.7729827165603638,
-0.7345423102378845,
-0.44285833835601807,
-0.1757793128490448,
-0.9867158532142639,
-0.22966764867305756,
-0.09472975134849548,
0.6631635427474976,
-0.5280936360359192,
0.36490222811698914,
-0.1059436947107315,
-0.15193019807338715,
-0.1645449697971344,
0.4969092905521393,
-1.0743657350540161,
0.47853901982307434,
0.620463490486145,
0.8430922627449036,
-0.047599852085113525,
-0.11218137294054031,
-1.0683633089065552,
0.29683777689933777,
0.11308056861162186,
0.6308949589729309,
0.039196524769067764,
-0.669297993183136,
0.08874381333589554,
-0.1832575500011444,
0.1829891800880432,
-0.5057819485664368,
0.45071685314178467,
-0.19672507047653198,
0.3258446156978607,
-0.05713827162981033,
-0.5690280795097351,
-0.05366689711809158,
0.004553341306746006,
-0.6476706862449646,
0.41866177320480347,
0.290774405002594,
-0.6708810329437256,
0.06722018122673035,
-0.8007862567901611,
-0.3980901837348938,
0.31417080760002136,
-0.2655199468135834,
-0.44112908840179443,
0.0006365578155964613,
0.07253073155879974,
0.5247099995613098,
-0.16908316314220428,
0.30028265714645386,
-0.04338890686631203,
-0.32801350951194763,
0.16081246733665466,
0.11359326541423798,
0.7668765187263489,
0.31661611795425415,
-0.21725477278232574,
0.38987332582473755,
-0.9554757475852966,
0.18864470720291138,
-0.2960857152938843,
-0.2854625880718231,
-0.27677616477012634,
-0.17742232978343964,
0.1699487864971161,
0.09853342920541763,
0.22530709207057953,
-0.22409296035766602,
0.14550788700580597,
-0.4172718822956085,
0.21201349794864655,
0.5122792720794678,
0.5753425359725952,
0.31353530287742615,
-0.6461558938026428,
0.5927721858024597,
0.11400607973337173,
0.43857914209365845,
-0.8447288870811462,
-0.4023788869380951,
-0.4019170105457306,
-0.2863929867744446,
0.06525813788175583,
0.42164847254753113,
-0.20311973989009857,
0.6290878057479858,
0.16541078686714172,
-0.6061719655990601,
-0.2935427725315094,
-0.0668698102235794,
0.5618228316307068,
0.6174922585487366,
0.7629813551902771,
-0.15028172731399536,
-0.34582141041755676,
-0.9403220415115356,
0.13452300429344177,
0.1123732402920723,
-0.19800178706645966,
-0.4384693503379822,
0.4442877173423767,
-0.27449122071266174,
0.5258166193962097,
-0.5852927565574646,
-0.4437423646450043,
-0.5537363290786743,
0.5551379919052124,
0.5212391018867493,
0.6626160144805908,
0.15751099586486816,
-0.47623521089553833,
-0.4304104447364807,
0.08424916118383408,
-0.7759613990783691,
-0.2289070338010788,
-0.19371125102043152,
0.11675669997930527,
-0.25409677624702454,
0.5165665745735168,
-0.5581125617027283,
0.3260757029056549,
0.24077409505844116,
-0.22470778226852417,
0.6263144612312317,
-0.6781619787216187,
0.3275216221809387,
-1.3832662105560303,
0.22029486298561096,
-0.031504347920417786,
-0.24047070741653442,
-0.5788284540176392,
0.13170237839221954,
-0.043829336762428284,
-0.4210233986377716,
-0.4072841703891754,
0.4214740991592407,
-0.2303895205259323,
0.28302881121635437,
-0.12335305660963058,
-0.10767210274934769,
0.2980453372001648,
0.43068796396255493,
-0.4501291513442993,
0.3644426763057709,
-0.0766022726893425,
-0.8077517151832581,
0.22764506936073303,
0.4756774306297302,
0.039849668741226196,
0.41764035820961,
-0.935190737247467,
0.011021390557289124,
-0.0012989637907594442,
0.39213326573371887,
-0.6499459147453308,
-0.6491756439208984,
0.011841671541333199,
-0.11124101281166077,
0.4100099802017212,
0.23457111418247223,
-0.23336230218410492,
-0.23134326934814453,
-0.636411190032959,
0.3260436952114105,
0.8474462628364563,
-0.11598636955022812,
0.5038720369338989,
0.36305907368659973,
-0.3453672230243683,
-0.29078230261802673,
-0.6263828277587891,
-0.37043923139572144,
-0.4004204273223877,
-0.3927195370197296,
0.8231410384178162,
0.05284203961491585,
-0.3393063545227051,
-0.17355717718601227,
0.24955503642559052,
-0.11682471632957458,
-0.08146025240421295,
0.3542095720767975,
0.24472889304161072,
-0.12979738414287567,
0.13066691160202026,
0.4811171293258667,
-0.2490399032831192,
0.2878565490245819,
-0.06908521056175232,
0.6211245059967041,
0.2660077214241028,
-0.630453884601593,
-0.8845902681350708,
1.0372318029403687,
0.4561772346496582,
-0.24056611955165863,
0.5763406753540039,
0.47630375623703003,
-0.5397136211395264,
-0.0752934142947197,
-0.3939921259880066,
-0.35238152742385864,
-0.4656476378440857,
0.2299579679965973,
0.17570361495018005,
-0.6164618730545044,
0.6113272309303284,
-0.2669476270675659,
0.5337924957275391,
0.41869625449180603,
0.419268935918808,
-0.5628026127815247,
1.0214159488677979,
0.6346938014030457,
0.28704726696014404,
0.33360615372657776,
-0.3770979344844818,
0.2219972312450409,
-0.8265147805213928,
-0.45441317558288574,
-0.4968307614326477,
-0.36978602409362793,
-0.4827474355697632,
-0.27564090490341187,
0.8578545451164246,
0.0709155797958374,
-0.16798385977745056,
0.06244782358407974,
-0.5574247241020203,
0.1554204672574997,
0.49116379022598267,
0.48670366406440735,
0.32220202684402466,
-0.2804979979991913,
0.07704447954893112,
-0.26731637120246887,
-0.42321789264678955,
-0.5085505247116089,
0.9393294453620911,
-0.019600819796323776,
0.5383962392807007,
-0.31425631046295166,
1.383703351020813,
0.49714985489845276,
0.038030195981264114,
-0.3140634596347809,
0.6100521087646484,
-0.3877035081386566,
-0.1692887842655182,
-0.23433877527713776,
0.04174761101603508,
-0.8792182207107544,
-0.13925132155418396,
-0.24272875487804413,
-0.8992958068847656,
-0.08139648288488388,
0.5649033188819885,
-0.6953256726264954,
-0.10598378628492355,
-0.5356357097625732,
0.9255936741828918,
-0.08969569206237793,
-0.4862349033355713,
-0.6188071370124817,
-0.884495198726654,
0.5641053318977356,
-0.2528728246688843,
0.4350303113460541,
0.05150671675801277,
0.1085643321275711,
0.7035092711448669,
-0.833592414855957,
0.6316397190093994,
0.07569392770528793,
0.16747361421585083,
0.44338321685791016,
-0.24174781143665314,
0.29856500029563904,
-0.0857778787612915,
0.005884351208806038,
-0.3608636260032654,
0.08974921703338623,
-0.10442750155925751,
-0.6031110882759094,
0.45495784282684326,
-0.2643267810344696,
-0.33531454205513,
-0.0888676717877388,
-0.17201828956604004,
-0.055470969527959824,
0.1940135657787323,
0.6640178561210632,
0.9384036064147949,
-0.382959246635437,
-0.03812626749277115,
0.9637971520423889,
-0.5662099123001099,
0.33234265446662903,
0.19363872706890106,
-0.39879700541496277,
-0.5591869354248047,
0.7004173994064331,
0.07587118446826935,
0.2763623595237732,
0.7044306993484497,
0.24147126078605652,
-0.22267068922519684,
-0.29587361216545105,
-0.4318036735057831,
0.33066195249557495,
-0.628060519695282,
-0.17126721143722534,
-0.8722964525222778,
-0.2735397219657898,
-0.26787158846855164,
-0.5490741729736328,
-0.16058257222175598,
-0.431304931640625,
-0.2510363757610321,
-0.09497930854558945,
0.3102250397205353,
0.7742198705673218,
0.02165994420647621,
0.6408396363258362,
-1.3881020545959473,
0.2209915667772293,
0.08308002352714539,
-0.3946482837200165,
-0.14021003246307373,
-0.40450289845466614,
-0.49222099781036377,
-0.18427921831607819,
-0.813800036907196,
-1.036888599395752,
0.3904569447040558,
-0.1060090959072113,
0.23222406208515167,
0.4447953999042511,
0.0857699066400528,
0.6881415247917175,
-0.6404697895050049,
1.0279016494750977,
0.6634073853492737,
-0.8626839518547058,
1.1668668985366821,
-0.7162131667137146,
0.3265239894390106,
0.6197589635848999,
0.25226742029190063,
-0.3810124695301056,
-0.6301966905593872,
-0.9980114698410034,
-1.1695846319198608,
0.5044934749603271,
-0.058072835206985474,
0.04020567610859871,
0.05725076422095299,
0.3238147497177124,
0.101356141269207,
0.15256215631961823,
-0.305407851934433,
-0.24400092661380768,
0.251838356256485,
-0.6231500506401062,
0.21499960124492645,
-0.3279196321964264,
-0.24625645577907562,
-0.07633283734321594,
0.5350732803344727,
0.03520079702138901,
0.11131919175386429,
0.2743285000324249,
0.21024464070796967,
-0.005927518475800753,
0.5442385673522949,
0.6241950988769531,
0.6735430359840393,
-0.1505228579044342,
0.08811106532812119,
0.20014294981956482,
-0.4391572177410126,
0.21540606021881104,
-0.239172101020813,
-0.34060388803482056,
0.3741103410720825,
0.3799112141132355,
0.3788285553455353,
0.41100525856018066,
-0.6942638754844666,
0.35780179500579834,
0.1497143805027008,
-0.36171358823776245,
-0.2813790738582611,
0.46381017565727234,
0.21575124561786652,
0.11088588833808899,
0.3439754247665405,
-0.1861140877008438,
0.6350566744804382,
-0.5122011303901672,
0.45123982429504395,
-0.035782501101493835,
-0.3332172632217407,
-0.4097559154033661,
0.9293180704116821,
0.3612356185913086,
-0.3542749881744385,
0.35384896397590637,
0.10271622240543365,
-0.1819603592157364,
0.7745794057846069,
0.7146316170692444,
1.0235974788665771,
-0.26106831431388855,
0.28840550780296326,
0.8758703470230103,
-0.15490296483039856,
-0.015029369853436947,
0.33617401123046875,
-0.048528846353292465,
0.04932187870144844,
-0.3590553402900696,
-0.5162563920021057,
-0.5849450826644897,
0.3807190954685211,
-0.8637949228286743,
0.6959973573684692,
-0.6695452928543091,
-0.08561993390321732,
0.007235117722302675,
-0.187302365899086,
-0.3354320228099823,
0.5215034484863281,
-0.0836738869547844,
0.645235538482666,
-0.8230043053627014,
0.39418962597846985,
0.6625064015388489,
-0.7246323823928833,
-0.9722304344177246,
-0.08794836699962616,
-0.03796202316880226,
-0.16039445996284485,
0.3296692669391632,
0.2986657917499542,
0.03504514321684837,
-0.06068567559123039,
-0.3349930942058563,
-0.1796845942735672,
1.2871290445327759,
-0.004040785599499941,
-0.6890562772750854,
-0.03103087842464447,
-0.2093389630317688,
0.6987273693084717,
-0.2492285519838333,
0.282911479473114,
0.2932562530040741,
0.16912618279457092,
-0.19853919744491577,
-0.7494775652885437,
0.08642842620611191,
-0.3364614248275757,
-0.29631727933883667,
0.3097677230834961,
-0.7030783295631409,
0.8855502009391785,
-0.5027004480361938,
-0.11047404259443283,
-0.04427788406610489,
0.5682207942008972,
0.44779443740844727,
0.7666994333267212,
0.04974391683936119,
0.31124305725097656,
0.9036542177200317,
0.3096912205219269,
0.9860820770263672,
-0.12179332971572876,
0.06117100641131401,
1.3887734413146973,
-0.35924631357192993,
0.7147893309593201,
0.5241764783859253,
-0.35848140716552734,
0.5222707390785217,
0.46987834572792053,
0.32360807061195374,
0.6316878795623779,
-0.05714401975274086,
-0.7642259001731873,
-0.0014258139999583364,
-0.19831913709640503,
-0.5029903054237366,
0.031463999301195145,
0.30674809217453003,
-0.5545941591262817,
-0.12790770828723907,
0.053409066051244736,
0.016101250424981117,
0.019738148897886276,
-0.29958730936050415,
1.0526142120361328,
0.3524431586265564,
-0.814811646938324,
0.0054619163274765015,
0.08068134635686874,
0.21208712458610535,
-0.7944591045379639,
-0.18871192634105682,
-0.26652252674102783,
0.22122904658317566,
-0.4855206310749054,
-0.4225637912750244,
0.4569076597690582,
0.2003384530544281,
-0.4056725800037384,
-0.30346569418907166,
0.5891552567481995,
-0.33641812205314636,
-0.26816919445991516,
-0.08564464002847672,
0.4472406804561615,
0.23898524045944214,
0.22654075920581818,
-0.44351926445961,
-0.14021191000938416,
0.001672217040322721,
0.049199044704437256,
0.5109142065048218,
0.5233715176582336,
-0.08339918404817581,
0.45894089341163635,
0.5387454628944397,
0.047242432832717896,
0.013467383570969105,
0.38050952553749084,
0.7100531458854675,
-0.6748639941215515,
-0.6429122090339661,
-1.16561758518219,
0.9337618947029114,
-0.14155997335910797,
-0.45364704728126526,
0.1417824774980545,
0.7686745524406433,
0.33985796570777893,
-0.35587742924690247,
0.8468733429908752,
-0.06170933321118355,
0.7804825305938721,
-0.7290603518486023,
0.7830823659896851,
-0.6348000168800354,
0.1553841233253479,
-0.2551948130130768,
-0.4727206230163574,
0.013897051103413105,
0.4105399250984192,
0.3541959524154663,
-0.28615692257881165,
1.0566450357437134,
0.2120155394077301,
0.01713254675269127,
-0.17281775176525116,
0.3155722916126251,
-0.17594370245933533,
0.45526283979415894,
0.5670846104621887,
0.6226330995559692,
-0.5848901271820068,
0.04127206653356552,
-0.5493062138557434,
-0.16016972064971924,
-0.3743319511413574,
-0.7446441650390625,
-0.725121259689331,
-0.6224563717842102,
-0.5145101547241211,
-0.2643791735172272,
0.037477076053619385,
1.0569454431533813,
0.3876308798789978,
-0.8181638121604919,
-0.10709840804338455,
-0.09109213948249817,
-0.054134685546159744,
-0.11501648277044296,
-0.1778985559940338,
0.15247857570648193,
-0.4445078670978546,
-0.5502871870994568,
0.1615867018699646,
0.49842342734336853,
-0.040925025939941406,
-0.03749387711286545,
0.20983757078647614,
0.040746256709098816,
-0.391061931848526,
0.42564988136291504,
0.09301136434078217,
-0.3787063658237457,
0.035984210669994354,
-0.09510386735200882,
-0.35419929027557373,
-0.03853464871644974,
1.0278825759887695,
-0.566760241985321,
0.2527191638946533,
0.6193165183067322,
0.3610742688179016,
0.655569314956665,
0.3153989017009735,
0.853214681148529,
-0.6654931902885437,
0.039267610758543015,
0.23498189449310303,
0.2211717814207077,
0.1396564096212387,
-0.6301317811012268,
0.4428786039352417,
-0.06204204633831978,
-0.7143916487693787,
-0.6078750491142273,
-0.03738255053758621,
-1.1241613626480103,
0.12458259612321854,
0.5145857334136963,
-0.09070105105638504,
-0.26054757833480835,
-0.19164486229419708,
-0.33462467789649963,
0.4724022150039673,
-0.24609781801700592,
0.7607748508453369,
0.36035382747650146,
-0.5181679725646973,
-0.029402678832411766,
-0.7369357347488403,
0.4876368045806885,
0.26211655139923096,
-1.3453774452209473,
-0.10556396842002869,
0.6356096863746643,
0.21804901957511902,
0.2391693890094757,
1.2431527376174927,
-0.08960139751434326,
0.6237848401069641,
-0.03248833492398262,
0.11277585476636887,
0.1087438091635704,
-0.19737133383750916,
-0.32214200496673584,
0.04416771978139877,
-0.2706715166568756,
-0.37128356099128723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18088v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18088v2 | LLM-Driven Multimodal Opinion Expression Identification | 2024-06-26T05:52:47 | 2024-06-29T09:55:50 | Bonian Jia, Huiyao Chen, Yueheng Sun, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Opinion Expression Identification (OEI) is essential in NLP for applications
ranging from voice assistants to depression diagnosis. This study extends OEI
to encompass multimodal inputs, underlining the significance of auditory cues
in delivering emotional subtleties beyond the capabilities of text. We
introduce a novel multimodal OEI (MOEI) task, integrating text and speech to
mirror real-world scenarios. Utilizing CMU MOSEI and IEMOCAP datasets, we
construct the CI-MOEI dataset. Additionally, Text-to-Speech (TTS) technology is
applied to the MPQA dataset to obtain the CIM-OEI dataset. We design a template
for the OEI task to take full advantage of the generative power of large
language models (LLMs). Advancing further, we propose an LLM-driven method
STOEI, which combines speech and text modal to identify opinion expressions.
Our experiments demonstrate that MOEI significantly improves the performance
while our method outperforms existing methods by 9.20\% and obtains SOTA
results. | [
-0.43232986330986023,
-0.765985906124115,
0.713042676448822,
0.3115025758743286,
-0.11923904716968536,
-0.033796194940805435,
-0.21827296912670135,
-0.6105509400367737,
0.44750362634658813,
0.14865748584270477,
-0.8389745354652405,
-0.4097311198711395,
-0.5398616194725037,
0.012357420288026333,
-0.09153484553098679,
0.765119194984436,
0.004621933214366436,
0.2500554323196411,
-0.13229981064796448,
-0.28643763065338135,
-0.16802236437797546,
-0.4407911002635956,
-0.6891775131225586,
-0.1143234521150589,
0.8412594199180603,
0.35605326294898987,
0.3041439354419708,
0.1357601135969162,
0.2189353108406067,
0.2610011100769043,
0.12573057413101196,
0.37579357624053955,
-0.28853461146354675,
0.10143774002790451,
0.0890960767865181,
-0.40258297324180603,
-0.6478669047355652,
0.11114075779914856,
0.35787707567214966,
0.21734409034252167,
-0.13907979428768158,
0.1799977868795395,
-0.04404454678297043,
0.34978652000427246,
-0.7326873540878296,
0.259333997964859,
-0.3419637680053711,
0.2696640193462372,
-0.2611721456050873,
-0.17534910142421722,
-0.4111088514328003,
-0.1910819113254547,
0.008857885375618935,
-0.3960637152194977,
-0.25949007272720337,
-0.029306801036000252,
0.7096923589706421,
0.16002586483955383,
-0.6993556022644043,
-0.6694741249084473,
-0.6240337491035461,
1.0174990892410278,
-0.9434322714805603,
0.37385129928588867,
-0.05093817040324211,
-0.0024488791823387146,
0.1283874213695526,
-0.3092370331287384,
-0.9365358352661133,
0.05779175087809563,
-0.010081171989440918,
0.5465145111083984,
-0.17425668239593506,
0.04113510623574257,
0.13178537786006927,
0.41771435737609863,
-0.31069254875183105,
0.20121528208255768,
-0.08742804825305939,
-0.0597657635807991,
0.49692994356155396,
0.08887901157140732,
0.37427765130996704,
-0.517750084400177,
-0.5489373207092285,
-0.0865708440542221,
-0.2731552720069885,
0.1279473453760147,
0.41875430941581726,
0.15811870992183685,
-0.19733326137065887,
0.7560201287269592,
-0.12108957767486572,
0.2908380627632141,
0.10069240629673004,
-0.5950035452842712,
0.5583694577217102,
-0.21736393868923187,
-0.30293840169906616,
0.17935054004192352,
1.1414868831634521,
0.5326213240623474,
-0.109500952064991,
0.16992367804050446,
-0.38636747002601624,
0.22930100560188293,
0.041916120797395706,
-0.6616936922073364,
0.37475281953811646,
0.384333074092865,
-0.6224051713943481,
-0.3284849524497986,
0.1441933810710907,
-1.2038911581039429,
-0.713077962398529,
-0.4433823823928833,
0.4402107298374176,
-0.5142187476158142,
-0.5197049975395203,
-0.17868809401988983,
-0.09039022028446198,
0.08667818456888199,
0.0953136533498764,
-0.6061949133872986,
-0.129696324467659,
0.5603691935539246,
0.6582961082458496,
-0.12095259130001068,
0.0936514362692833,
-0.4599843919277191,
0.13948599994182587,
-0.13233478367328644,
0.606421172618866,
-0.8748176693916321,
-0.3131096363067627,
0.20176644623279572,
-0.11098406463861465,
-0.2805735170841217,
-0.5322415828704834,
0.6559128761291504,
-0.40044480562210083,
0.5242369771003723,
-0.015007147565484047,
-0.3797281086444855,
-0.19600869715213776,
0.06669975072145462,
-0.6761279702186584,
1.0114219188690186,
-0.1466149538755417,
-0.6583130359649658,
0.17738038301467896,
-1.0269867181777954,
-0.3321424126625061,
-0.3676135540008545,
-0.19007708132266998,
-0.37617969512939453,
0.48610737919807434,
0.3718436658382416,
0.6342806220054626,
-0.30779337882995605,
0.3176773190498352,
-0.4952865242958069,
0.23216848075389862,
0.39328959584236145,
-0.7596431374549866,
0.4364232122898102,
0.4262849986553192,
-0.28773272037506104,
0.15990488231182098,
-1.0784951448440552,
0.11165603995323181,
-0.028623230755329132,
-0.24526216089725494,
-0.3605745732784271,
0.013139251619577408,
0.2613220512866974,
0.42430806159973145,
0.39398807287216187,
-0.8996071219444275,
0.2081279307603836,
-0.20211660861968994,
0.6915767788887024,
0.6986879706382751,
0.03883408382534981,
0.20121602714061737,
-0.08932851999998093,
0.4130762219429016,
0.2592582106590271,
0.2448262870311737,
-0.21528439223766327,
-0.611720085144043,
-0.6417338252067566,
-0.802640438079834,
0.18845537304878235,
0.764846920967102,
-0.9223780035972595,
0.13146592676639557,
-0.3476065993309021,
-0.37144288420677185,
-1.120061993598938,
0.0037999190390110016,
0.37467166781425476,
0.385367214679718,
0.3483765423297882,
-0.03282279521226883,
-0.5277591943740845,
-1.145666241645813,
-0.060495637357234955,
-0.22739221155643463,
-0.27772819995880127,
0.6873546242713928,
0.15168851613998413,
-0.3669299781322479,
0.9805402755737305,
-0.24670787155628204,
-0.5056900382041931,
-0.18862201273441315,
0.7457476854324341,
0.2147148847579956,
0.15375125408172607,
0.3804125487804413,
-1.0296063423156738,
-0.05620570480823517,
-0.09597515314817429,
-0.8395780324935913,
-0.4288347363471985,
-0.4627523422241211,
0.0932382121682167,
0.0316869281232357,
0.38433724641799927,
-0.5857170224189758,
0.18738161027431488,
0.787672221660614,
-0.1609511822462082,
0.019761821255087852,
0.0018683894304558635,
0.6145097613334656,
-1.190544843673706,
-0.12792274355888367,
0.39828813076019287,
-0.046906936913728714,
-0.6202016472816467,
-0.1186358854174614,
-0.06848152726888657,
-0.03134998306632042,
-0.73594069480896,
0.30471086502075195,
-0.23305204510688782,
0.1998795121908188,
-0.09867888689041138,
0.3809949457645416,
-0.011602978222072124,
0.640513002872467,
0.11965963244438171,
0.6310721635818481,
0.49949875473976135,
-0.3322257101535797,
0.2599600553512573,
-0.03621700033545494,
-0.4210140109062195,
0.8068180680274963,
-0.4807892143726349,
0.27996909618377686,
-0.39100462198257446,
-0.0970422774553299,
-1.0582178831100464,
-0.2733876705169678,
0.326882928609848,
-0.18167448043823242,
0.24824582040309906,
0.14446723461151123,
-0.406312495470047,
0.1266946941614151,
-0.27064943313598633,
0.6138351559638977,
0.14911068975925446,
-0.5418903231620789,
1.4350605010986328,
0.4858225882053375,
-0.4646216332912445,
-0.4952126443386078,
-0.5882325768470764,
0.04194175824522972,
-0.3482896089553833,
-0.45893076062202454,
0.5014155507087708,
0.03551408648490906,
-0.3005213141441345,
-0.24902977049350739,
0.1543542891740799,
-0.07451078295707703,
-0.23463383316993713,
0.6301078200340271,
0.4211547374725342,
-0.29096904397010803,
0.24463024735450745,
0.1993776559829712,
0.0014616046100854874,
0.04710270091891289,
0.25838813185691833,
0.31507569551467896,
-0.12482603639364243,
-0.4720665514469147,
-0.7749462723731995,
0.9371545314788818,
0.8964797258377075,
-0.17895138263702393,
0.42612770199775696,
0.9368671774864197,
-0.19507844746112823,
0.15292371809482574,
-0.6803076863288879,
0.07989861816167831,
-0.39018797874450684,
0.46068111062049866,
-0.47899872064590454,
-0.586081862449646,
0.07648702710866928,
-0.3010711371898651,
0.04493425041437149,
0.2187700867652893,
0.578498363494873,
-0.3211611807346344,
1.4043142795562744,
0.5445488691329956,
-0.4097699820995331,
0.7517627477645874,
0.00024526339257135987,
0.40206417441368103,
-0.972442090511322,
-0.1086282879114151,
-0.2814013361930847,
-0.5277289152145386,
-0.3826237618923187,
-0.3468257486820221,
0.5284392237663269,
0.09537848085165024,
0.280399888753891,
-0.1326509267091751,
-0.26170605421066284,
-0.01246551238000393,
0.5445712804794312,
0.3271399736404419,
0.11644253879785538,
-0.18539376556873322,
0.135714590549469,
-0.15986882150173187,
-0.4202297329902649,
-0.6870958209037781,
0.741574227809906,
0.416443794965744,
0.47386634349823,
0.411840558052063,
0.5008516907691956,
0.3211960196495056,
0.723148763179779,
-0.909822404384613,
0.6672937870025635,
-0.00173298513982445,
-0.37791791558265686,
-0.05217008665204048,
-0.5126233100891113,
-0.5538888573646545,
0.38465645909309387,
-0.5817675590515137,
-0.7984309792518616,
0.33757293224334717,
0.00962319876998663,
-0.312950998544693,
0.1524164229631424,
-1.0069793462753296,
0.6386284232139587,
-0.35712453722953796,
-0.08231455087661743,
-0.3189343512058258,
-0.3973488211631775,
0.199476420879364,
0.11666004359722137,
0.5528261661529541,
-0.1969122439622879,
-0.14460980892181396,
0.768012523651123,
0.14750255644321442,
1.0014060735702515,
-0.29624679684638977,
-0.3060567378997803,
0.06608512252569199,
-0.42102837562561035,
0.3263828754425049,
0.1440325379371643,
-0.3484707474708557,
0.37194931507110596,
-0.09799174964427948,
-0.03539316728711128,
-0.7464441657066345,
0.8438395857810974,
-0.7122064828872681,
-0.5771278738975525,
-0.16624903678894043,
-0.2986753582954407,
-0.46230363845825195,
0.1467537134885788,
0.21883749961853027,
0.6211699843406677,
-0.16213487088680267,
0.13580401241779327,
0.7163113355636597,
-0.2414146363735199,
0.7652958631515503,
0.36023619771003723,
-0.1145399659872055,
-0.6326442360877991,
1.0440504550933838,
-0.10363873839378357,
0.12472719699144363,
0.6296228766441345,
0.24910278618335724,
-0.3247746527194977,
-0.17560872435569763,
-0.4902026057243347,
0.3300764858722687,
-0.634670078754425,
-0.030532367527484894,
-0.6277050971984863,
0.23085084557533264,
-0.35051894187927246,
0.15150819718837738,
-0.312968373298645,
-0.15254662930965424,
-0.3873787224292755,
-0.16230516135692596,
0.011754989624023438,
0.5614470839500427,
0.16997423768043518,
0.1134306862950325,
-0.7924624681472778,
0.6375836730003357,
0.49360448122024536,
0.004510628525167704,
-0.19475848972797394,
-0.14372049272060394,
0.21277178823947906,
0.23394975066184998,
-0.25400614738464355,
-1.1313103437423706,
0.5086988210678101,
0.5084834098815918,
0.4199077785015106,
0.7197412252426147,
0.30650594830513,
0.7207320928573608,
-0.3462385833263397,
0.993952214717865,
0.5293017625808716,
-1.024219036102295,
0.5230164527893066,
0.027163781225681305,
0.1910005509853363,
0.27139249444007874,
0.5619293451309204,
-0.3838135302066803,
-0.5114343762397766,
-0.36422428488731384,
-0.9362141489982605,
0.49245649576187134,
-0.00293946685269475,
0.12179020047187805,
-0.18911878764629364,
0.181327685713768,
0.03921560198068619,
0.4370999336242676,
-0.9597650766372681,
-0.2989499568939209,
-0.24258875846862793,
-0.8839839100837708,
0.08146268129348755,
-0.5355475544929504,
-0.24190574884414673,
0.17584511637687683,
0.6578165888786316,
-0.3506593108177185,
0.6223983764648438,
0.3959876000881195,
-0.08598040789365768,
0.05111818015575409,
0.681408703327179,
0.700446367263794,
0.15884988009929657,
-0.062402330338954926,
0.16194802522659302,
0.05094394087791443,
-0.055873606353998184,
-0.08473280072212219,
-0.23282390832901,
0.06670276075601578,
0.15488633513450623,
0.3908090591430664,
1.0381559133529663,
0.007569183595478535,
-0.8558374047279358,
0.7225658893585205,
-0.06977822631597519,
-0.03631984069943428,
-0.3260514438152313,
-0.13057713210582733,
-0.10634234547615051,
0.5009111762046814,
0.30002152919769287,
0.2594865560531616,
0.3380168080329895,
-0.8331686854362488,
-0.261963814496994,
0.49605563282966614,
-0.8589683175086975,
-0.45378759503364563,
0.5332157611846924,
0.2210719883441925,
-0.2560303211212158,
0.3608223497867584,
0.11316249519586563,
-0.17530730366706848,
0.2302170693874359,
0.24291396141052246,
0.8151578307151794,
-0.24479453265666962,
0.1484725922346115,
-0.019562553614377975,
-0.004083024803549051,
0.3628123700618744,
0.5650483965873718,
-0.0344238318502903,
-0.7416600584983826,
-0.3375890254974365,
-0.3996894955635071,
-0.1514407843351364,
0.30262354016304016,
-1.0278066396713257,
0.21668635308742523,
-0.23276448249816895,
-0.47909778356552124,
0.2371770441532135,
-0.7981273531913757,
-0.49439626932144165,
0.4295898377895355,
0.5978403091430664,
0.4392872750759125,
-0.9675126671791077,
0.8229739665985107,
0.7049983739852905,
-0.24018234014511108,
-0.557083249092102,
0.06494583189487457,
0.2864741086959839,
-0.6294982433319092,
0.6435027122497559,
0.24208492040634155,
-0.5121548771858215,
-0.16381709277629852,
-0.40064266324043274,
-0.44708776473999023,
0.9533562064170837,
0.2832268476486206,
-0.6024183034896851,
0.08725917339324951,
0.1235787570476532,
0.5002512335777283,
-0.731939971446991,
0.6792241930961609,
0.1607624739408493,
0.6749224066734314,
-0.12002986669540405,
-0.8104172945022583,
-0.18007808923721313,
-0.42730438709259033,
0.002007730072364211,
0.1188117042183876,
-0.6005972027778625,
0.6387823224067688,
-0.04205239191651344,
-0.43402111530303955,
-0.11049235612154007,
0.8724998831748962,
-0.03731343522667885,
0.44803768396377563,
0.9847541451454163,
0.39529451727867126,
0.759685754776001,
-0.16437497735023499,
0.9050605893135071,
-0.27268385887145996,
0.11187037080526352,
0.9194456934928894,
-0.3772202432155609,
1.2867416143417358,
0.8067134618759155,
0.3309430778026581,
0.46579402685165405,
0.28928130865097046,
0.23134462535381317,
0.6670600771903992,
-0.19717486202716827,
-0.584079384803772,
-0.29906266927719116,
-0.46799638867378235,
-0.08734341710805893,
0.4232633113861084,
0.4663291573524475,
-0.4562617540359497,
0.24339278042316437,
0.676345944404602,
0.0686766505241394,
-0.06174173206090927,
-0.2327476143836975,
1.0354535579681396,
-0.058073367923498154,
-0.44168439507484436,
0.13496434688568115,
-0.05698687210679054,
0.8940648436546326,
-0.4915560483932495,
-0.2122555375099182,
0.1152440682053566,
0.08417833596467972,
-0.26181861758232117,
-0.4851599931716919,
0.046982064843177795,
-0.05739148333668709,
-0.5622431039810181,
-0.502587616443634,
0.23997987806797028,
-0.5546289086341858,
-0.5581846833229065,
0.30685853958129883,
0.3897620737552643,
-0.18440061807632446,
0.05160846561193466,
-0.5882360339164734,
0.12066248059272766,
0.172470822930336,
-0.48748740553855896,
0.3025148808956146,
0.7215184569358826,
0.022514265030622482,
0.6243661642074585,
0.38338184356689453,
-0.021228237077593803,
-0.06142570823431015,
0.24754248559474945,
0.7188881039619446,
-0.58717942237854,
-0.21328826248645782,
-0.6774799227714539,
0.5794103741645813,
-0.18529905378818512,
-0.5246239900588989,
0.5867785215377808,
0.33815789222717285,
0.49317899346351624,
-0.2937725782394409,
0.9087483882904053,
-0.29518061876296997,
0.684992253780365,
-0.8518511652946472,
0.2848455011844635,
-0.753427267074585,
0.18784967064857483,
-0.45006176829338074,
-0.5171716809272766,
0.026003338396549225,
0.49524161219596863,
-0.24471145868301392,
-0.10918442904949188,
0.7412248849868774,
0.9367441534996033,
0.058996763080358505,
0.2815209627151489,
0.27302804589271545,
0.35256829857826233,
0.31107276678085327,
0.6248250603675842,
1.0643947124481201,
-0.36022937297821045,
0.4760650098323822,
-0.17157353460788727,
-0.5079174041748047,
-0.07535803318023682,
-0.9974080920219421,
-0.6354699730873108,
-0.5807132720947266,
-0.695706307888031,
-0.018988726660609245,
-0.30119064450263977,
1.1318644285202026,
0.8537791967391968,
-0.9132387042045593,
0.08161620050668716,
0.35763171315193176,
-0.03859388455748558,
-0.5629332065582275,
-0.32102563977241516,
0.14095425605773926,
0.014191759750247002,
-1.1631892919540405,
0.8627605438232422,
0.4348456859588623,
-0.24554458260536194,
-0.175502210855484,
0.16753387451171875,
-0.12046469002962112,
0.4387267827987671,
0.6941697597503662,
-0.08549625426530838,
-1.0669528245925903,
-0.4479236900806427,
-0.0519544780254364,
-0.040330056101083755,
0.18824322521686554,
0.9578295946121216,
-0.5489945411682129,
0.49933695793151855,
0.2511597275733948,
0.3648356795310974,
0.024351563304662704,
-0.11705788224935532,
0.5185422897338867,
-0.8960142135620117,
0.06951730698347092,
0.2363547384738922,
0.5937658548355103,
0.06155293807387352,
-0.3394421339035034,
0.16128329932689667,
0.0837101861834526,
-0.12877093255519867,
-0.6791283488273621,
0.3057750463485718,
-1.396892786026001,
-0.17955167591571808,
1.144562005996704,
-0.19611209630966187,
-0.30602967739105225,
-0.08380041271448135,
-0.6929708123207092,
-0.0858994796872139,
-0.706468939781189,
0.8116105198860168,
0.6693801283836365,
-0.25514325499534607,
-0.5080581903457642,
-0.40184471011161804,
0.07199987024068832,
0.4011033773422241,
-0.7838248610496521,
-0.22165167331695557,
0.5813766717910767,
-0.3606162369251251,
0.6660218834877014,
0.32682326436042786,
-0.12019746005535126,
-0.2685060203075409,
-0.1931931972503662,
0.3261334300041199,
-0.07716158777475357,
-0.17791475355625153,
-0.11419374495744705,
0.8422089219093323,
-0.34182873368263245,
-0.3731743097305298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18087v1 | EHR-Based Mobile and Web Platform for Chronic Disease Risk Prediction Using Large Language Multimodal Models | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | 2024-06-26T05:51:08 | Chun-Chieh Liao, Wei-Ting Kuo, I-Hsuan Hu, Yen-Chen Shih, Jun-En Ding, Feng Liu, Fang-Ming Hung | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Traditional diagnosis of chronic diseases involves in-person consultations
with physicians to identify the disease. However, there is a lack of research
focused on predicting and developing application systems using clinical notes
and blood test values. We collected five years of Electronic Health Records
(EHRs) from Taiwan's hospital database between 2017 and 2021 as an AI database.
Furthermore, we developed an EHR-based chronic disease prediction platform
utilizing Large Language Multimodal Models (LLMMs), successfully integrating
with frontend web and mobile applications for prediction. This prediction
platform can also connect to the hospital's backend database, providing
physicians with real-time risk assessment diagnostics. The demonstration link
can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqmL9DEDFgA. | [
0.011281472630798817,
-0.9536660313606262,
0.7682149410247803,
-0.10588356852531433,
-0.37821507453918457,
0.1629915088415146,
0.06671924889087677,
-0.9225979447364807,
0.6260515451431274,
0.6284631490707397,
-0.35473570227622986,
-0.535879373550415,
-0.43635106086730957,
0.07637917250394821,
-0.039602506905794144,
0.883027195930481,
-0.09811592847108841,
0.29495102167129517,
-0.1990489810705185,
0.0208712350577116,
-0.47041207551956177,
-0.5639181137084961,
-0.7450023889541626,
-0.4729900360107422,
0.7342336177825928,
0.4932061433792114,
0.5788263082504272,
0.38616257905960083,
0.6608458161354065,
0.19991753995418549,
0.32431459426879883,
-0.10434453189373016,
0.007547270972281694,
0.39224833250045776,
0.2931852638721466,
-0.18231840431690216,
-0.4804978668689728,
-0.4786413311958313,
0.22287309169769287,
0.5066965222358704,
-0.25424155592918396,
0.24108047783374786,
-0.2644922733306885,
0.578390896320343,
-0.35234394669532776,
0.07594574242830276,
-0.2747543454170227,
0.3629898130893707,
-0.494866281747818,
-0.4852438271045685,
-0.3031669557094574,
-0.30295801162719727,
0.2547505497932434,
-0.5088048577308655,
-0.12765604257583618,
0.04014665260910988,
0.6623697876930237,
0.13175229728221893,
-0.8554010987281799,
-0.1592760682106018,
-0.8940300345420837,
0.31090959906578064,
-0.2819579839706421,
0.5821967124938965,
0.36095839738845825,
0.6965080499649048,
-0.20091363787651062,
-0.6995132565498352,
-0.20466162264347076,
-0.41607117652893066,
0.08496735244989395,
0.27481842041015625,
0.05088385194540024,
0.05584481358528137,
-0.0034183859825134277,
0.272595077753067,
-0.8430038690567017,
0.1368235945701599,
-0.5396567583084106,
-0.25871750712394714,
0.7124636173248291,
0.43036240339279175,
0.44717833399772644,
-0.22711335122585297,
-0.6297634243965149,
0.21623951196670532,
-0.7598069310188293,
0.05164925009012222,
-0.46004143357276917,
0.08832462877035141,
-0.28514227271080017,
0.6141599416732788,
-0.005976710002869368,
0.34602051973342896,
0.13814103603363037,
-0.612033486366272,
0.5566774606704712,
-0.3204394280910492,
-0.21930450201034546,
0.4313045144081116,
0.5821420550346375,
0.6111534237861633,
-0.2458256632089615,
-0.16793999075889587,
-0.12555010616779327,
0.010080046951770782,
0.1246865913271904,
-0.6226882338523865,
-0.42620572447776794,
0.6467506289482117,
-0.6975061893463135,
-0.010997377336025238,
-0.1565455198287964,
-1.0193736553192139,
-0.5212878584861755,
-0.07955212891101837,
0.17917515337467194,
-0.45944109559059143,
-0.26890915632247925,
0.2109038084745407,
-0.00272575207054615,
-0.21828942000865936,
0.4467903971672058,
-0.4581491947174072,
0.3873146176338196,
0.3411841094493866,
0.754356324672699,
-0.23399706184864044,
0.09812082350254059,
-0.505325198173523,
0.37332457304000854,
0.015700068324804306,
0.856118381023407,
-0.16303837299346924,
-0.7210648655891418,
-0.08765774965286255,
0.017968757078051567,
-0.11389203369617462,
-0.48906683921813965,
0.6510889530181885,
-0.2832365930080414,
-0.3157327473163605,
0.17817965149879456,
-0.29765230417251587,
0.01299062930047512,
0.24830038845539093,
-0.9545207023620605,
1.0735315084457397,
0.08819503337144852,
-0.714836597442627,
0.4018574059009552,
-0.2943512797355652,
-0.5793474316596985,
0.37969252467155457,
0.04820143058896065,
-0.9444564580917358,
-0.06496763974428177,
-0.10722841322422028,
0.4851025640964508,
-0.34891343116760254,
0.6666964888572693,
-0.5189951062202454,
-0.09024084359407425,
0.30563628673553467,
-0.19005532562732697,
0.55254065990448,
0.4350612759590149,
-0.09484429657459259,
0.45114409923553467,
-0.7786337733268738,
0.10635681450366974,
-0.006182691548019648,
-0.3123178482055664,
-0.6619996428489685,
0.19087408483028412,
0.4515650272369385,
0.49442198872566223,
0.26243963837623596,
-0.455657422542572,
0.10416754335165024,
-0.1387779861688614,
0.45893052220344543,
0.4549289345741272,
0.13544033467769623,
-0.16252093017101288,
-0.7240463495254517,
0.6928275227546692,
0.11416497081518173,
0.39954715967178345,
-0.09071726351976395,
-0.819490373134613,
-0.06548124551773071,
-0.12518799304962158,
0.2267245054244995,
0.9665917754173279,
-0.37162333726882935,
0.7065215110778809,
-0.6191791296005249,
-0.837668776512146,
0.019593926146626472,
-0.198673814535141,
0.1286931037902832,
0.34789150953292847,
0.2466103732585907,
-0.5780425071716309,
-0.5846982598304749,
-0.409894198179245,
0.3166925609111786,
-0.1930418163537979,
0.031781841069459915,
0.3889605402946472,
0.5900476574897766,
-0.6133467555046082,
0.33887189626693726,
-0.527778148651123,
-0.4145187437534332,
-0.3290683329105377,
-0.1477280557155609,
0.08575902879238129,
0.5579830408096313,
0.37935203313827515,
-0.9114894270896912,
-0.7873080968856812,
0.30979952216148376,
-0.7512183785438538,
0.19433605670928955,
0.18211479485034943,
-0.002024722518399358,
-0.0970020517706871,
0.5132573843002319,
-0.6194472908973694,
0.461981862783432,
0.9827910661697388,
-0.3989134132862091,
0.6038177609443665,
-0.32045862078666687,
0.036727216094732285,
-1.0977046489715576,
0.34698113799095154,
0.1842152327299118,
-0.4147129952907562,
-0.6865314245223999,
-0.037635449320077896,
-0.12926872074604034,
-0.5315324664115906,
-0.07719624787569046,
0.631232500076294,
-0.2051873356103897,
0.19355860352516174,
0.05892501026391983,
-0.1329696923494339,
-0.10192178934812546,
-0.19765563309192657,
-0.006913325283676386,
0.28874656558036804,
0.34771105647087097,
-0.5835227370262146,
0.26811397075653076,
0.15942341089248657,
-0.4402858018875122,
0.45448416471481323,
-0.6509153246879578,
-0.21504300832748413,
0.10472120344638824,
0.4621838629245758,
-0.7495416402816772,
-0.33516472578048706,
0.31269779801368713,
-0.4400178790092468,
0.3070184588432312,
0.09374549239873886,
-0.34638306498527527,
-0.8821238875389099,
-0.34241601824760437,
0.3897055685520172,
0.05056888237595558,
0.11913799494504929,
0.8534471392631531,
0.8227548003196716,
-0.5913363099098206,
-0.20835283398628235,
-0.8953397274017334,
0.07035452127456665,
-0.29117798805236816,
-0.4900793135166168,
0.668648898601532,
-0.19552114605903625,
-0.25631317496299744,
0.1715279519557953,
0.1586112678050995,
-0.5868464112281799,
0.259660542011261,
0.6752871870994568,
0.544505774974823,
-0.2510276734828949,
0.4383991062641144,
-0.0976720079779625,
-0.19263525307178497,
-0.06641212850809097,
-0.10756440460681915,
0.49152880907058716,
0.21277613937854767,
-0.5852578282356262,
-0.6744396090507507,
0.6201909780502319,
0.7723497152328491,
-0.24875029921531677,
0.6286224722862244,
0.2909638285636902,
-0.6479833722114563,
0.5474616289138794,
-0.6439229846000671,
0.029520902782678604,
-0.39581435918807983,
0.2024812251329422,
-0.19212886691093445,
-0.7447733879089355,
0.557533323764801,
-0.12894128262996674,
-0.20408621430397034,
0.3942866027355194,
0.6828007698059082,
0.10532467067241669,
0.955431342124939,
0.6033309698104858,
-0.2203163057565689,
0.21613752841949463,
0.21954980492591858,
0.0073017640970647335,
-0.5450354814529419,
-0.5868492722511292,
-0.5333712697029114,
0.14899517595767975,
-0.8749186396598816,
-0.3164811432361603,
1.0163922309875488,
-0.24584950506687164,
-0.48642611503601074,
-0.06241011247038841,
-0.4482976198196411,
-0.14642678201198578,
0.42435020208358765,
0.6902143955230713,
0.4876744747161865,
-0.21450376510620117,
-0.16981902718544006,
0.008047963492572308,
-0.49317988753318787,
-0.39713531732559204,
1.4786174297332764,
0.3986629843711853,
0.600639820098877,
0.13373945653438568,
0.7168406844139099,
0.4328802227973938,
0.6473096013069153,
-0.7224176526069641,
-0.11474350094795227,
-0.2456797957420349,
-0.8142572641372681,
-0.31807905435562134,
-0.189787819981575,
-1.216889500617981,
-0.1537371277809143,
-0.4171734154224396,
-0.6630941033363342,
0.09049823880195618,
0.34631064534187317,
-0.6876751184463501,
0.3112725019454956,
-0.6307949423789978,
0.8879788517951965,
-0.7222944498062134,
-0.325895756483078,
-0.23816320300102234,
-0.7970706224441528,
0.3738899230957031,
-0.2526918053627014,
0.4915454387664795,
-0.09178841859102249,
0.2419506162405014,
0.368181049823761,
-0.3486611843109131,
0.8706299066543579,
0.020717091858386993,
0.1849844753742218,
0.14695176482200623,
-0.1576869636774063,
0.35657328367233276,
0.27889928221702576,
-0.13775959610939026,
-0.04655184969305992,
0.19934013485908508,
-0.20760150253772736,
0.020809194073081017,
0.703403651714325,
-0.6465826630592346,
-0.2624431252479553,
-0.6267375946044922,
0.002724874997511506,
-0.19013670086860657,
0.5332236289978027,
0.03762650862336159,
0.4603593945503235,
-0.46743184328079224,
-0.08158321678638458,
0.4774494171142578,
-0.3666052520275116,
0.05329018086194992,
0.29141464829444885,
-0.12820297479629517,
-0.481317937374115,
0.7440827488899231,
-0.06855107098817825,
-0.05257755145430565,
0.669090211391449,
0.5567809343338013,
-0.12740057706832886,
-0.4407021999359131,
-0.3863751292228699,
-0.0008905004942789674,
-0.4037066400051117,
-0.4381353557109833,
-0.5157175660133362,
-0.25516363978385925,
-0.4684503674507141,
-0.14865164458751678,
-0.08622275292873383,
0.1325870305299759,
-0.0845838189125061,
-0.13335981965065002,
0.509486734867096,
0.7266298532485962,
-0.002465030876919627,
0.08181676268577576,
-1.2918411493301392,
0.234634667634964,
0.07693953812122345,
0.5029252171516418,
0.05110457167029381,
-0.03763443976640701,
-0.4600517451763153,
-0.04082952439785004,
-0.5291897058486938,
-0.8988073468208313,
0.6966075897216797,
0.10601631551980972,
0.5416993498802185,
0.6575789451599121,
-0.02674105577170849,
0.5624845623970032,
-0.6879132986068726,
0.5901597738265991,
0.6114321351051331,
-0.695189356803894,
0.4845321476459503,
-0.43406879901885986,
-0.005200639367103577,
0.5623164176940918,
0.5104888677597046,
-0.8548475503921509,
0.11629568040370941,
-0.4635029733181,
-0.8265276551246643,
0.014306177385151386,
-0.42988473176956177,
-0.2033591866493225,
0.1296391636133194,
0.19520209729671478,
0.18026861548423767,
-0.01795228198170662,
-0.7135912179946899,
-0.35327497124671936,
-0.42891639471054077,
-0.27849531173706055,
-0.3577044904232025,
-0.22630298137664795,
0.0029132715426385403,
-0.3905029594898224,
0.3484368920326233,
0.020551860332489014,
0.5176044702529907,
0.46060484647750854,
0.052844829857349396,
-0.5991299748420715,
0.400959849357605,
0.7043007016181946,
0.598746120929718,
-0.3716425597667694,
0.20581278204917908,
0.0208919495344162,
-0.5648423433303833,
-0.0693168193101883,
0.43057599663734436,
-0.022852372378110886,
0.05527324229478836,
0.24523723125457764,
0.530794620513916,
0.4710395336151123,
-1.161738395690918,
0.47023865580558777,
0.2653065323829651,
-0.15115411579608917,
-1.011844515800476,
-0.45258796215057373,
0.2531690299510956,
-0.11331319808959961,
0.2935705780982971,
-0.09491868317127228,
0.2841103971004486,
-0.4321172535419464,
0.5226295590400696,
0.20941483974456787,
-0.7467727065086365,
-0.37452927231788635,
0.8933960199356079,
0.3208944499492645,
0.0937190055847168,
0.45246604084968567,
0.14289256930351257,
-0.3841332197189331,
0.702322781085968,
0.5330139994621277,
0.5387482643127441,
-0.707338809967041,
0.05227477103471756,
0.45314905047416687,
0.09987259656190872,
-0.0684657171368599,
0.38870862126350403,
0.6662819981575012,
-0.5604752898216248,
-0.618908703327179,
-0.24458584189414978,
-0.4267248511314392,
0.21346931159496307,
-0.5201151371002197,
0.5199712514877319,
-0.419647216796875,
-0.4032159149646759,
0.1622081696987152,
-0.025705285370349884,
-0.26596611738204956,
0.3714321255683899,
0.4001174569129944,
0.699777364730835,
-0.6525391936302185,
0.9548429250717163,
0.575360119342804,
-0.3962053656578064,
-0.6212679147720337,
-0.1253432333469391,
0.37409844994544983,
-0.6502776145935059,
0.6136951446533203,
0.30644822120666504,
0.1447816640138626,
-0.21062226593494415,
-0.0018478106940165162,
-0.9052278995513916,
1.1730483770370483,
-0.04623746871948242,
-0.6210305094718933,
-0.12952713668346405,
-0.021098768338561058,
0.512076735496521,
-0.22610948979854584,
-0.006929995026439428,
-0.007147463969886303,
0.5302940607070923,
-0.09975383430719376,
-1.4620343446731567,
0.06379725784063339,
-0.2704506814479828,
-0.28254610300064087,
0.4731420874595642,
-0.43163636326789856,
0.941836953163147,
-0.23592546582221985,
-0.14733421802520752,
0.12211976945400238,
0.2654602527618408,
0.16663752496242523,
0.87447589635849,
0.15103089809417725,
0.6742988228797913,
0.7152062058448792,
0.2027241438627243,
1.243897557258606,
-0.5665715932846069,
0.1647963672876358,
0.8636295199394226,
-0.6314763426780701,
1.0217068195343018,
0.1814664751291275,
-0.19106151163578033,
0.533980131149292,
0.7372174263000488,
-0.033641546964645386,
0.3918733596801758,
0.21154387295246124,
-0.4773373007774353,
-0.21323750913143158,
-0.24333356320858002,
-0.5160378217697144,
0.23815351724624634,
0.795763373374939,
-0.3186543881893158,
-0.04898972064256668,
0.3494032919406891,
-0.2711770534515381,
-0.02804107777774334,
-0.31267333030700684,
0.4797406494617462,
0.019226552918553352,
-0.40585774183273315,
0.3476967513561249,
0.09448803961277008,
0.6146871447563171,
-0.5007060766220093,
-0.12105414271354675,
0.3933558762073517,
0.18575552105903625,
-0.13546642661094666,
-0.6506683230400085,
0.4650771915912628,
-0.5692862272262573,
-0.09381358325481415,
0.017880111932754517,
0.9407710433006287,
-0.24722395837306976,
-0.5562584400177002,
0.359485924243927,
0.6385738253593445,
-0.0574830137193203,
0.12838603556156158,
-0.6522148251533508,
-0.10107395797967911,
-0.4772539436817169,
0.09127651900053024,
0.3336504101753235,
0.38017943501472473,
-0.40786105394363403,
1.013299584388733,
0.646938145160675,
0.19297850131988525,
-0.14997589588165283,
-0.2183312326669693,
0.7989265322685242,
-0.7421118021011353,
-0.27949947118759155,
-0.5702425241470337,
0.298543244600296,
0.13975627720355988,
-0.4826686382293701,
0.2604232728481293,
0.8229280710220337,
0.4085560739040375,
-0.18124505877494812,
0.9201865196228027,
-0.1727118343114853,
0.8981221318244934,
-0.5040723085403442,
0.6218014359474182,
-0.6385579705238342,
-0.13312824070453644,
-0.1938823163509369,
0.08239404857158661,
-0.6387768387794495,
0.27625125646591187,
-0.10369174182415009,
-0.26952987909317017,
0.805076539516449,
0.398968905210495,
0.24476327002048492,
-0.2881919741630554,
0.2039981335401535,
0.1797393262386322,
0.1690460741519928,
0.7578697800636292,
0.43990007042884827,
-0.18652714788913727,
0.2972341477870941,
-0.4119163155555725,
-0.1005048155784607,
-0.8474504351615906,
-0.6412538290023804,
-0.5137981176376343,
-0.508902370929718,
-0.1941962093114853,
-0.35889798402786255,
0.3302702009677887,
1.0743738412857056,
0.5101785063743591,
-0.9252647161483765,
-0.10888724029064178,
0.07177699357271194,
-0.01028809230774641,
-0.4160912036895752,
-0.18345065414905548,
0.611447274684906,
0.582247257232666,
-0.24581746757030487,
0.04927937313914299,
0.28759437799453735,
0.2173701375722885,
-0.07885438948869705,
0.14024604856967926,
-0.1756041795015335,
-0.6128446459770203,
0.7486247420310974,
0.5763298273086548,
-0.8343908786773682,
-0.3285493552684784,
0.137344092130661,
-0.4506645202636719,
0.12779098749160767,
0.7784591913223267,
-0.43421801924705505,
0.34603631496429443,
0.22520384192466736,
0.48562800884246826,
0.3315091133117676,
-0.07911103218793869,
0.5287654399871826,
0.21794134378433228,
0.08808719366788864,
0.4247303307056427,
0.3351125419139862,
0.17015023529529572,
-0.8087657690048218,
0.15221038460731506,
0.4302442669868469,
-0.5372930765151978,
-0.4631580710411072,
0.05731656402349472,
-1.3983566761016846,
-0.21712319552898407,
0.8183161020278931,
-0.14093220233917236,
-0.21577495336532593,
-0.8730580806732178,
-0.036292314529418945,
0.2601063847541809,
-0.42402732372283936,
0.8330713510513306,
0.13649296760559082,
-0.5401455760002136,
0.003985918127000332,
-1.0054365396499634,
0.1384742110967636,
-0.0014901770045980811,
-1.0004442930221558,
-0.14566005766391754,
0.5810790061950684,
0.4195385277271271,
0.09186847507953644,
1.0521396398544312,
-0.18341052532196045,
0.5624866485595703,
-0.19654031097888947,
0.3143855929374695,
0.10743993520736694,
-0.0858055129647255,
0.11307763308286667,
-0.05114048346877098,
0.18968334794044495,
0.11317546665668488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18085v1 | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion from Pretrained Language Models with Knowledge Constraints | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | 2024-06-26T05:46:35 | Ran Song, Shizhu He, Shengxiang Gao, Li Cai, Kang Liu, Zhengtao Yu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual Knowledge Graph Completion (mKGC) aim at solving queries like
(h, r, ?) in different languages by reasoning a tail entity t thus improving
multilingual knowledge graphs. Previous studies leverage multilingual
pretrained language models (PLMs) and the generative paradigm to achieve mKGC.
Although multilingual pretrained language models contain extensive knowledge of
different languages, its pretraining tasks cannot be directly aligned with the
mKGC tasks. Moreover, the majority of KGs and PLMs currently available exhibit
a pronounced English-centric bias. This makes it difficult for mKGC to achieve
good results, particularly in the context of low-resource languages. To
overcome previous problems, this paper introduces global and local knowledge
constraints for mKGC. The former is used to constrain the reasoning of answer
entities, while the latter is used to enhance the representation of query
contexts. The proposed method makes the pretrained model better adapt to the
mKGC task. Experimental results on public datasets demonstrate that our method
outperforms the previous SOTA on Hits@1 and Hits@10 by an average of 12.32% and
16.03%, which indicates that our proposed method has significant enhancement on
mKGC. | [
-0.565983772277832,
-0.5312404632568359,
0.6882056593894958,
0.011024648323655128,
-0.19143052399158478,
0.36362770199775696,
-0.3740290403366089,
-0.3498923182487488,
0.34419873356819153,
0.6670252680778503,
-0.7570325136184692,
-0.7057607173919678,
-0.49196678400039673,
0.3551102876663208,
0.4355354607105255,
0.7335138916969299,
-0.33550235629081726,
0.17224733531475067,
-0.619916558265686,
-0.3978542983531952,
-0.4750211834907532,
-0.7913722991943359,
-0.492233544588089,
-0.3122963607311249,
0.503338098526001,
0.5730900168418884,
0.5046705603599548,
0.23962734639644623,
0.1833169162273407,
0.20535311102867126,
-0.08015719056129456,
0.6708948612213135,
-0.4796643555164337,
0.036011531949043274,
-0.026209114119410515,
-0.469940721988678,
-0.22571948170661926,
-0.07018112391233444,
0.5073413848876953,
1.0502233505249023,
-0.23337015509605408,
-0.13434210419654846,
0.12606211006641388,
0.6577884554862976,
-0.7110769152641296,
0.42764949798583984,
-0.5457109212875366,
0.12579965591430664,
-0.16331186890602112,
-0.04512451961636543,
-0.4797869920730591,
-0.451949805021286,
-0.028408370912075043,
-1.013239860534668,
-0.08951365202665329,
0.01521166693419218,
0.6336138248443604,
0.1744547337293625,
-0.8742620348930359,
-0.18652188777923584,
-0.5006774663925171,
0.6171998381614685,
-0.5006768703460693,
0.773794949054718,
0.7619293928146362,
0.31716015934944153,
-0.03959836810827255,
-0.6296544075012207,
-0.389077752828598,
-0.27256783843040466,
-0.5542166233062744,
0.11510486155748367,
0.1442970484495163,
0.17261238396167755,
0.3768618702888489,
0.10568045824766159,
-0.5203701257705688,
-0.08530610054731369,
-0.2249699831008911,
-0.47881150245666504,
0.3060796856880188,
0.02935095503926277,
0.054464563727378845,
-0.35158851742744446,
-0.2007455676794052,
0.1864272505044937,
-1.0825022459030151,
0.09101138263940811,
0.37106963992118835,
0.3946654796600342,
0.13842692971229553,
0.40595880150794983,
-0.6207835078239441,
0.9772318601608276,
-0.22128483653068542,
-0.24387384951114655,
0.2605628967285156,
-0.6277461051940918,
0.17825230956077576,
-0.09352662414312363,
0.704857587814331,
0.045683834701776505,
0.4395594000816345,
-0.2984585762023926,
0.22042228281497955,
-0.3935874402523041,
-0.05053656920790672,
-0.6947228312492371,
-0.0534655898809433,
-0.20474651455879211,
-0.1329319328069687,
0.274429589509964,
-0.14835700392723083,
-0.44593343138694763,
-0.20191840827465057,
-0.48383548855781555,
0.21078623831272125,
-0.45048120617866516,
-0.358739972114563,
-0.04299132525920868,
0.34022456407546997,
-0.06607785820960999,
0.08710924535989761,
-0.6382467746734619,
-0.054194215685129166,
0.2655602693557739,
0.6219934821128845,
0.1350138932466507,
-0.3823383152484894,
-0.3383377492427826,
0.5626201033592224,
-0.0756261795759201,
0.6048887372016907,
-0.642532229423523,
-0.39080196619033813,
-0.08315491676330566,
0.05112530291080475,
-0.2759803235530853,
-0.49951058626174927,
0.42070916295051575,
-0.7139193415641785,
0.23422202467918396,
-0.9464707970619202,
-0.6209392547607422,
-0.20415763556957245,
0.457461416721344,
-0.452735960483551,
0.9266014695167542,
0.18184983730316162,
-0.9189006686210632,
0.4486452043056488,
-0.38731616735458374,
-0.7972333431243896,
0.0019739815033972263,
-0.1681274026632309,
-0.05290011316537857,
-0.3697989284992218,
0.6352854371070862,
0.37651097774505615,
-0.2949115037918091,
0.2830117344856262,
-0.34076371788978577,
0.015592537820339203,
-0.21686029434204102,
0.06808283925056458,
0.8508785963058472,
0.35877832770347595,
-0.019296642392873764,
0.12488864362239838,
-0.6342390179634094,
0.39094939827919006,
0.030972927808761597,
-0.3829219341278076,
-0.34762290120124817,
-0.04686218872666359,
-0.6302307844161987,
0.2986454665660858,
0.29297879338264465,
-0.28033050894737244,
0.43222740292549133,
-0.2436632364988327,
0.5453691482543945,
0.41207438707351685,
0.17485801875591278,
0.4829278290271759,
0.17419306933879852,
0.8382158875465393,
-0.014539229683578014,
0.1968003362417221,
0.030994819477200508,
-0.49383336305618286,
-0.6427946090698242,
-0.18271063268184662,
0.4904938340187073,
0.640491783618927,
-1.2901768684387207,
0.18576499819755554,
-0.3584142327308655,
-0.42360422015190125,
-0.44229239225387573,
0.2193777859210968,
0.503203809261322,
0.6867430806159973,
0.41255247592926025,
-0.09144634008407593,
-0.6658350825309753,
-0.8409537672996521,
-0.049319490790367126,
-0.11426637321710587,
-0.040431492030620575,
0.6993176341056824,
0.24729576706886292,
0.01986829750239849,
0.9120169878005981,
-0.743515133857727,
-0.4508521556854248,
-0.3598563075065613,
0.024161458015441895,
0.13274523615837097,
0.4230826497077942,
0.5124587416648865,
-0.722322404384613,
-0.7835021615028381,
0.07761374115943909,
-0.7980372309684753,
-0.08003992587327957,
0.2761247456073761,
-0.36509329080581665,
0.05787472799420357,
0.6631388664245605,
-0.7364010214805603,
0.22015899419784546,
0.3255802392959595,
-0.1403084695339203,
0.5331965684890747,
-0.22014737129211426,
0.34603819251060486,
-1.0281426906585693,
-0.01987832598388195,
-0.37167415022850037,
-0.37840214371681213,
-0.608073353767395,
0.23995782434940338,
0.05233106017112732,
-0.24599523842334747,
-0.2947004735469818,
0.5205274820327759,
-0.5147762894630432,
0.1495128720998764,
0.095725879073143,
0.31026533246040344,
0.12275183200836182,
0.706795871257782,
0.11500013619661331,
0.6876071095466614,
0.5421249270439148,
-0.6661261916160583,
0.31439539790153503,
0.28453949093818665,
-0.41075170040130615,
0.4789767563343048,
-0.3532164990901947,
0.21711154282093048,
-0.17870007455348969,
0.27826082706451416,
-0.6725379228591919,
-0.2898220717906952,
0.2813970446586609,
-0.29193761944770813,
0.3271856904029846,
-0.393637090921402,
-0.49865779280662537,
-0.44178903102874756,
0.2429986149072647,
0.6137150526046753,
0.189865380525589,
-0.4274303913116455,
0.7837650179862976,
0.3224162459373474,
0.0548507496714592,
-0.8326782584190369,
-0.4612683057785034,
-0.14977265894412994,
-0.03544492647051811,
-0.6745368242263794,
0.27445220947265625,
-0.01019937265664339,
0.09343405067920685,
0.009401269257068634,
-0.10631861537694931,
-0.0637545958161354,
-0.05617835745215416,
-0.18796159327030182,
-0.07135064154863358,
-0.09949473291635513,
0.06983385980129242,
-0.01605070009827614,
-0.04373062774538994,
-0.20524735748767853,
-0.6291168332099915,
0.6827440857887268,
0.06572269648313522,
-0.6192067265510559,
-0.04724225029349327,
0.26168033480644226,
0.29179108142852783,
-0.605104923248291,
0.935258150100708,
0.5371240377426147,
-0.27100858092308044,
0.16195598244667053,
-0.6068635582923889,
-0.1333850920200348,
-0.43661409616470337,
0.38749831914901733,
-0.6013107895851135,
-1.1616225242614746,
0.819182813167572,
0.03093092329800129,
-0.42789795994758606,
0.19421203434467316,
0.21180717647075653,
0.15129691362380981,
1.1868113279342651,
0.45006680488586426,
-0.1353987455368042,
0.24511386454105377,
-0.2302267700433731,
0.26829808950424194,
-0.6578118801116943,
-0.41814127564430237,
-0.5388455390930176,
0.008600261993706226,
-0.5419819355010986,
-0.27503594756126404,
0.5324008464813232,
0.7512012720108032,
-0.11617599427700043,
0.3684065341949463,
-0.3591369092464447,
0.5778282880783081,
0.7226278781890869,
0.06405546516180038,
0.30820581316947937,
-0.007315213326364756,
-0.7569440007209778,
-0.25047391653060913,
-1.0064103603363037,
-0.031767554581165314,
1.0804072618484497,
-0.3015667796134949,
0.36894094944000244,
0.2278844118118286,
0.5275959372520447,
-0.17833997309207916,
0.35416945815086365,
-0.45595812797546387,
0.502327561378479,
-0.0653151348233223,
-0.8135086297988892,
-0.18332138657569885,
-0.8608554601669312,
-0.7865229845046997,
0.20821525156497955,
-0.06071807071566582,
-0.8041151762008667,
-0.07217264920473099,
0.1422121524810791,
-0.15609103441238403,
0.2069634199142456,
-0.8307062983512878,
1.045006275177002,
-0.18802635371685028,
-0.22484490275382996,
-0.13240055739879608,
-0.6131932139396667,
0.27196961641311646,
0.03864237666130066,
0.32816892862319946,
-0.19135333597660065,
0.3744679093360901,
0.5124072432518005,
-0.6741494536399841,
0.750206470489502,
-0.5927864909172058,
0.03624272346496582,
0.5545995831489563,
-0.1307755410671234,
0.751781702041626,
0.0670052170753479,
0.05660258233547211,
-0.027979593724012375,
-0.059452276676893234,
-0.5484264492988586,
-0.7089388966560364,
0.4582509994506836,
-0.6116033792495728,
-0.8517785668373108,
0.019552504643797874,
-0.6838964819908142,
-0.6217501759529114,
0.4674932360649109,
0.3896001875400543,
0.26020196080207825,
0.05818942189216614,
0.06260789185762405,
0.5030223727226257,
-0.19767619669437408,
0.06696925312280655,
0.6621820330619812,
-0.505016565322876,
-0.509344756603241,
0.9157122373580933,
0.37844985723495483,
0.3700456917285919,
0.4915746748447418,
-0.0296657532453537,
-0.48297998309135437,
-0.5567134022712708,
-0.4352683126926422,
0.19365638494491577,
-0.9482435584068298,
-0.39483314752578735,
-0.6552973389625549,
-0.24534261226654053,
-0.816415011882782,
0.10552791506052017,
-0.08469528704881668,
-0.42062199115753174,
-0.041899338364601135,
-0.13317930698394775,
0.2214864045381546,
0.48018908500671387,
-0.015118486247956753,
0.37719929218292236,
-0.731132447719574,
0.1948002576828003,
0.5469722747802734,
0.419849693775177,
0.04381106048822403,
-0.20939362049102783,
-0.4166218936443329,
0.08210299909114838,
-0.19297447800636292,
-0.9972758293151855,
0.04819479212164879,
0.3030592203140259,
0.7930915355682373,
0.45151427388191223,
0.16750313341617584,
0.8098771572113037,
-0.46176260709762573,
0.5045896172523499,
0.0565452054142952,
-0.8150237202644348,
0.6533528566360474,
-0.43853989243507385,
0.4020078182220459,
0.7100804448127747,
0.8250753283500671,
-0.5768750905990601,
-0.4864959120750427,
-0.3562305271625519,
-0.7712332010269165,
0.7321184873580933,
0.19971685111522675,
-0.1869264841079712,
-0.012202966958284378,
0.6070067882537842,
-0.16292724013328552,
0.24657513201236725,
-0.9041796326637268,
-0.322593092918396,
-0.2402724027633667,
-0.1199563667178154,
0.037824712693691254,
-0.32945388555526733,
-0.0779714584350586,
-0.4299604296684265,
0.8887682557106018,
-0.36715519428253174,
-0.033112235367298126,
0.039143070578575134,
-0.2737211585044861,
0.10725758969783783,
0.2258750945329666,
0.4425792098045349,
0.924537181854248,
-0.04866368696093559,
0.1570826917886734,
0.34193575382232666,
-0.3664350211620331,
0.23788319528102875,
0.39462611079216003,
-0.3871915638446808,
-0.19999030232429504,
0.41787365078926086,
0.7068778872489929,
0.042058028280735016,
-0.45986437797546387,
0.2992401719093323,
-0.005246223881840706,
-0.09948643296957016,
-0.037563640624284744,
-0.1065654456615448,
0.3577025532722473,
0.0776914656162262,
0.2608238160610199,
-0.06830623000860214,
-0.20734310150146484,
-0.16772493720054626,
0.004119366407394409,
0.592465877532959,
-0.39201620221138,
-0.09869620949029922,
0.7836870551109314,
-0.0030017646495252848,
0.1859825700521469,
0.7261856198310852,
-0.7235203385353088,
-0.8730789422988892,
0.4162774682044983,
0.507239818572998,
0.249770388007164,
-0.2719164490699768,
0.15489304065704346,
0.573001503944397,
0.4769623875617981,
0.019481714814901352,
0.42357712984085083,
-0.1930779665708542,
-0.9518932700157166,
-0.9139724373817444,
-0.6083053946495056,
-0.22153429687023163,
0.0013174869818612933,
-0.5464531779289246,
0.22618862986564636,
-0.2459665834903717,
-0.14785002171993256,
-0.12631654739379883,
0.11832638084888458,
-0.667797863483429,
0.06104010343551636,
-0.06798995286226273,
0.7278232574462891,
-0.6569605469703674,
1.1405900716781616,
0.843206524848938,
-0.6420015692710876,
-1.0916779041290283,
-0.3169127106666565,
-0.22760331630706787,
-0.8421129584312439,
0.6608389616012573,
0.11869001388549805,
0.005227630026638508,
0.19172553718090057,
-0.2608565390110016,
-1.0816857814788818,
0.9325419664382935,
0.7831189036369324,
-0.3095554709434509,
-0.0353064090013504,
0.5052109956741333,
0.26180148124694824,
-0.33806177973747253,
-0.013775000348687172,
0.509699285030365,
0.73165363073349,
0.26852861046791077,
-0.9263463616371155,
-0.032958805561065674,
0.023052318021655083,
-0.2453700602054596,
0.3611776828765869,
-0.565992534160614,
0.6145533323287964,
-0.12435131520032883,
-0.08521959185600281,
-0.24905294179916382,
0.6928242444992065,
0.39755895733833313,
0.09762004017829895,
0.48831918835639954,
0.9361395835876465,
1.0494941473007202,
-0.2809695899486542,
0.9983134269714355,
-0.45081862807273865,
0.3966313898563385,
1.203545093536377,
-0.36507856845855713,
0.43087396025657654,
0.19604314863681793,
-0.4379137456417084,
0.3934566080570221,
0.7975843548774719,
0.30640074610710144,
0.7251139283180237,
-0.027982475236058235,
-0.3619731068611145,
-0.6006475687026978,
-0.4852434992790222,
-0.48384004831314087,
0.4199502766132355,
0.23526743054389954,
0.05438848212361336,
-0.07259617745876312,
0.280429482460022,
0.3701331615447998,
-0.006049368064850569,
-0.4834916293621063,
0.5701032280921936,
-0.03597734495997429,
-0.9630367755889893,
0.5836290717124939,
-0.0054949307814240456,
0.3786572217941284,
-0.7723451256752014,
0.2450830638408661,
-0.4491425156593323,
-0.02209249883890152,
-0.17089207470417023,
-0.32568278908729553,
0.33356553316116333,
-0.1997154951095581,
-0.2466987818479538,
-0.17752309143543243,
0.8390701413154602,
-0.7478071451187134,
-0.6033656001091003,
0.39277374744415283,
0.7833373546600342,
-0.010598413646221161,
-0.2349831759929657,
-0.42258337140083313,
-0.4237709045410156,
0.33909595012664795,
-0.059835124760866165,
0.20312738418579102,
0.605221688747406,
-0.08305098116397858,
0.6988934278488159,
0.4107658267021179,
0.08072663098573685,
0.13588851690292358,
0.22217591106891632,
0.8241415619850159,
-0.34627601504325867,
-0.5047553777694702,
-0.6492961049079895,
0.10748296976089478,
0.06522006541490555,
0.02694474533200264,
0.8291208744049072,
0.6145377159118652,
1.1596637964248657,
0.06569388508796692,
0.7260978817939758,
-0.242863729596138,
0.45110011100769043,
-0.874574601650238,
0.8591330647468567,
-0.645564615726471,
0.08959577232599258,
-0.12727729976177216,
-0.8953998684883118,
-0.30568596720695496,
0.446985125541687,
-0.5207241773605347,
0.27632349729537964,
0.8288432359695435,
0.6392759084701538,
-0.06410574167966843,
-0.11925920099020004,
0.1958102434873581,
0.057106852531433105,
0.13804471492767334,
0.7141854166984558,
0.8740218281745911,
0.025834184139966965,
0.9812669157981873,
-0.4695930778980255,
0.14762628078460693,
0.2583146393299103,
-0.8955982327461243,
-0.8789671063423157,
-0.5972298383712769,
-0.23595602810382843,
-0.3480894863605499,
-0.1773100048303604,
0.7372077107429504,
0.9396880865097046,
-0.9737052321434021,
0.008781961165368557,
-0.002757239853963256,
0.49454838037490845,
-0.05654779449105263,
-0.19446268677711487,
0.5411631464958191,
-0.47139814496040344,
-0.4520578682422638,
0.3844982087612152,
0.0031014918349683285,
-0.046101510524749756,
-0.20009593665599823,
-0.31466028094291687,
-0.5131269097328186,
-0.42410218715667725,
0.4903402328491211,
0.25206470489501953,
-0.5665213465690613,
-0.4039754867553711,
0.08490945398807526,
0.12589432299137115,
0.1553591936826706,
1.1197314262390137,
-0.8786489963531494,
0.45382243394851685,
0.2642209529876709,
0.45272842049598694,
0.6314324736595154,
-0.20041176676750183,
0.4705382287502289,
-1.4695136547088623,
0.43682923913002014,
0.11064428091049194,
0.5930957198143005,
0.3715214431285858,
-0.31358829140663147,
0.6236653923988342,
0.44096100330352783,
-0.37396037578582764,
-0.5510882139205933,
0.5986875891685486,
-0.46339964866638184,
-0.3528195321559906,
0.9962041974067688,
-0.4543952941894531,
-0.03791285678744316,
-0.22596117854118347,
0.012748482637107372,
0.5408143401145935,
0.03636773303151131,
0.4194578230381012,
0.9276800155639648,
-0.1383250653743744,
-0.12483616173267365,
-0.5776039958000183,
0.5738013982772827,
0.46036556363105774,
-0.8591879606246948,
0.040690772235393524,
0.6009901762008667,
0.1543426811695099,
0.1985531747341156,
0.9430035352706909,
0.024085508659482002,
-0.06097004562616348,
-0.3295637369155884,
0.05882710963487625,
-0.2449163794517517,
-0.3510507643222809,
0.18562477827072144,
0.3404091000556946,
0.13887347280979156,
0.3081117570400238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18082v1 | Octo-planner: On-device Language Model for Planner-Action Agents | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | 2024-06-26T05:40:10 | Wei Chen, Zhiyuan Li, Zhen Guo, Yikang Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | AI agents have become increasingly significant in various domains, enabling
autonomous decision-making and problem-solving. To function effectively, these
agents require a planning process that determines the best course of action and
then executes the planned actions. In this paper, we present an efficient
on-device Planner-Action framework that separates planning and action execution
into two distinct components: a planner agent based on Phi-3 Mini, a 3.8
billion parameter LLM optimized for edge devices, and an action agent using the
Octopus model for function execution. The planner agent first responds to user
queries by decomposing tasks into a sequence of sub-steps, which are then
executed by the action agent. To optimize performance on resource-constrained
devices, we employ model fine-tuning instead of in-context learning, reducing
computational costs and energy consumption while improving response times. Our
approach involves using GPT-4 to generate diverse planning queries and
responses based on available functions, with subsequent validations to ensure
data quality. We fine-tune the Phi-3 Mini model on this curated dataset,
achieving a 97\% success rate in our in-domain test environment. To address
multi-domain planning challenges, we developed a multi-LoRA training method
that merges weights from LoRAs trained on distinct function subsets. This
approach enables flexible handling of complex, multi-domain queries while
maintaining computational efficiency on resource-constrained devices. To
support further research, we have open-sourced our model weights at
\url{https://huggingface.co/NexaAIDev/octopus-planning}. For the demo, please
refer to \url{https://www.nexa4ai.com/octo-planner}. | [
-0.6151960492134094,
-0.7869439125061035,
0.45066148042678833,
0.10999986529350281,
-0.17812705039978027,
-0.39704430103302,
0.20004713535308838,
-0.3488940894603729,
0.37117379903793335,
0.5970360040664673,
-0.5547346472740173,
-0.24653242528438568,
-0.07740635424852371,
-0.07254169881343842,
0.05047163367271423,
0.5851871371269226,
-0.11558620631694794,
-0.3126527965068817,
0.2829902470111847,
-0.2652865946292877,
-0.17537368834018707,
-0.20595891773700714,
-0.9049692153930664,
-0.4408155679702759,
0.4274618327617645,
0.7607974410057068,
0.6033126711845398,
0.6245777606964111,
0.5641893744468689,
0.3293769955635071,
0.20003969967365265,
0.26855581998825073,
-0.33187833428382874,
0.0013239323161542416,
-0.13544413447380066,
-0.07696251571178436,
-1.1843109130859375,
-0.19245176017284393,
0.40010809898376465,
0.4388815760612488,
-0.34825599193573,
-0.04337790608406067,
-0.19642147421836853,
0.38375556468963623,
-0.6270110607147217,
0.24557770788669586,
-0.6610666513442993,
0.06903352588415146,
0.2335159033536911,
0.10681282728910446,
-0.2365454137325287,
-0.26122790575027466,
0.07129813730716705,
-0.8923289179801941,
-0.07990729063749313,
-0.06592763215303421,
0.33624401688575745,
0.5614321231842041,
-0.4829378128051758,
-0.1463632434606552,
-0.9832805395126343,
0.5551332831382751,
-0.3188818097114563,
0.45562443137168884,
0.3920723795890808,
0.28230392932891846,
0.008246339857578278,
-0.8101059794425964,
-0.790551483631134,
0.09270994365215302,
0.30978530645370483,
0.05844749137759209,
-0.016796711832284927,
0.20212391018867493,
0.39233484864234924,
-0.025327198207378387,
-0.6532570123672485,
0.13747549057006836,
-0.3740230202674866,
0.05427470803260803,
0.8932636976242065,
0.17681026458740234,
0.07324310392141342,
0.1795404553413391,
-0.4648979604244232,
-0.05904419720172882,
-0.9261216521263123,
0.05894775316119194,
0.3264622092247009,
0.3022627830505371,
-0.24034616351127625,
0.7346817851066589,
-0.48604616522789,
0.4198153018951416,
-0.011779004707932472,
-0.5393442511558533,
0.010255349799990654,
-0.2754665017127991,
-0.27130454778671265,
0.17266277968883514,
0.6903234720230103,
0.306011825799942,
-0.029433133080601692,
0.08582796156406403,
-0.3867439329624176,
-0.061345502734184265,
0.30099985003471375,
-0.990663468837738,
-0.34099942445755005,
0.4009491503238678,
-0.1672149896621704,
0.03173132985830307,
-0.5038891434669495,
-0.7737229466438293,
-0.4806183874607086,
0.018307361751794815,
0.43083640933036804,
-0.6892306804656982,
-0.19792351126670837,
0.2776983380317688,
0.1925327479839325,
0.2916995882987976,
0.3709315359592438,
-0.9524053335189819,
0.6405521035194397,
0.46273329854011536,
0.6621993184089661,
-0.019114410504698753,
-0.49208077788352966,
-0.7721522450447083,
0.5264157056808472,
-0.2276146411895752,
0.9185268878936768,
-0.3838178813457489,
-0.6684034466743469,
-0.09240805357694626,
-0.4530930519104004,
-0.5166313648223877,
-0.19792185723781586,
0.6730304956436157,
-0.6029564142227173,
0.047334711998701096,
-0.13309042155742645,
-0.3458879292011261,
-0.4854501783847809,
0.3407209515571594,
-0.924242377281189,
0.9555337429046631,
0.01957036927342415,
-0.41307154297828674,
0.4144209623336792,
-1.2451491355895996,
-0.5460788607597351,
0.10172785818576813,
-0.15104851126670837,
-0.6026920676231384,
-0.3003733158111572,
0.30249521136283875,
0.47988370060920715,
-0.3684512972831726,
-0.2692757546901703,
-0.36089107394218445,
-0.22837576270103455,
-0.16626395285129547,
0.10297703742980957,
0.3232669234275818,
0.15231260657310486,
-0.43539807200431824,
0.31330394744873047,
-0.7316038608551025,
0.2480040341615677,
0.16137000918388367,
-0.39897677302360535,
-0.02176872082054615,
0.13345986604690552,
-0.11898975074291229,
0.299011766910553,
0.1245265081524849,
-0.7073065638542175,
0.5846990942955017,
-0.31429845094680786,
0.4988551735877991,
0.4414093792438507,
0.10299868136644363,
0.5819292068481445,
-0.3064955770969391,
0.5210980176925659,
-0.34761470556259155,
0.4349251687526703,
-0.1486506313085556,
-0.7216961979866028,
-0.5655542016029358,
-0.25070706009864807,
-0.1709582507610321,
0.5628553032875061,
-1.0176174640655518,
0.2569030821323395,
-0.4122142791748047,
-0.6477304697036743,
0.030376005917787552,
0.07082180678844452,
0.29724934697151184,
0.45266830921173096,
0.41271650791168213,
-0.08290708810091019,
0.08863283693790436,
-0.555000901222229,
-0.020911535248160362,
-0.2910713851451874,
0.1864723116159439,
0.2974538207054138,
0.5493879914283752,
-0.25120604038238525,
0.9405660629272461,
-0.6200171709060669,
-0.5070641040802002,
-0.7248433232307434,
0.06662203371524811,
-0.0250852070748806,
0.38248518109321594,
0.6378892660140991,
-1.0358837842941284,
-0.43717312812805176,
0.23265141248703003,
-0.374477356672287,
0.02341855876147747,
0.02428436279296875,
0.19492819905281067,
0.06730622053146362,
0.18217723071575165,
-1.0124800205230713,
0.4038703739643097,
0.3244991898536682,
-0.24718818068504333,
0.34393253922462463,
-0.21310479938983917,
-0.15234196186065674,
-1.061956524848938,
0.11002369970083237,
-0.007271496579051018,
0.1232832670211792,
-0.7729281783103943,
0.1033785417675972,
0.030784323811531067,
-0.4134536683559418,
-0.7785932421684265,
0.6699638962745667,
-0.18726956844329834,
-0.3428875505924225,
-0.2241942286491394,
-0.10506600141525269,
0.006074423436075449,
0.9934526085853577,
0.11488383263349533,
0.8925749659538269,
0.3246295154094696,
-0.9578863978385925,
0.3872322142124176,
0.13856151700019836,
0.11972995847463608,
0.6484956741333008,
-0.7757940292358398,
0.2593340277671814,
0.34588247537612915,
0.07159190624952316,
-0.5330555438995361,
-0.3896813690662384,
0.4447813332080841,
0.018290193751454353,
-0.09680648893117905,
-0.4566510021686554,
-0.5926083922386169,
-0.1983630359172821,
-0.3999707102775574,
0.5207400918006897,
0.3235367238521576,
-0.4929018020629883,
1.3825852870941162,
0.5762895941734314,
-0.15114158391952515,
-0.21646150946617126,
-0.2996845841407776,
-0.5371124148368835,
-0.5019758343696594,
-0.73097825050354,
0.5962495803833008,
-0.0178383756428957,
-0.1270504742860794,
-0.2170068323612213,
-0.06108186021447182,
-0.2575991749763489,
-0.10730461776256561,
0.3358997106552124,
0.006320593878626823,
-0.09835013747215271,
-0.008513441309332848,
0.2505798637866974,
-0.241524800658226,
-0.10289271920919418,
-0.46424180269241333,
0.763270914554596,
-0.13468477129936218,
-0.745652973651886,
-0.6031235456466675,
0.2643967568874359,
0.6051582098007202,
-0.4078337252140045,
0.31550076603889465,
0.4089643061161041,
-0.5639071464538574,
-0.24538928270339966,
-0.33796122670173645,
-0.12381093949079514,
-0.5522896647453308,
0.1210038885474205,
-0.8855599164962769,
-0.21630719304084778,
0.45421895384788513,
-0.2455596923828125,
0.31588587164878845,
0.3666943907737732,
0.4524301588535309,
0.08584092557430267,
1.1415834426879883,
0.7705018520355225,
0.08166149258613586,
0.5660228729248047,
-0.8019263744354248,
0.28206679224967957,
-0.9094921350479126,
-0.19549965858459473,
-0.2939092814922333,
-0.3194426894187927,
-0.5013970136642456,
-0.3678092062473297,
0.7926900386810303,
-0.0827338770031929,
-0.3978694975376129,
0.37753209471702576,
-0.34286513924598694,
0.3559362292289734,
0.44422537088394165,
-0.1505536288022995,
0.246860072016716,
0.07747926563024521,
-0.1702263504266739,
0.33042728900909424,
-0.8125083446502686,
-0.5202767252922058,
1.1850237846374512,
0.23210076987743378,
0.8061719536781311,
0.21877582371234894,
0.5741615295410156,
0.16229592263698578,
-0.04448205232620239,
-0.7521704435348511,
0.8157109618186951,
0.2606874406337738,
-0.26018026471138,
-0.5474124550819397,
-0.26997172832489014,
-0.9508121013641357,
0.6284360885620117,
0.10148477554321289,
-1.0125676393508911,
0.5047786831855774,
0.157713383436203,
-0.7430216670036316,
0.5486928224563599,
-0.8753023147583008,
0.9011584520339966,
-0.48979493975639343,
-0.6128250360488892,
-0.39565345644950867,
-0.17146560549736023,
0.13434943556785583,
0.020267019048333168,
-0.21487537026405334,
-0.38970527052879333,
-0.2907187342643738,
0.626960813999176,
-0.5298690795898438,
0.5091248154640198,
-0.2829959988594055,
0.042089659720659256,
0.4447227120399475,
0.06561556458473206,
0.6630778312683105,
0.22199155390262604,
-0.3453669548034668,
-0.03410586714744568,
-0.21215324103832245,
-0.3467080891132355,
-0.35297659039497375,
0.6164882183074951,
-0.8520527482032776,
-0.1377628743648529,
-0.3649051785469055,
-0.4997670650482178,
-0.22136926651000977,
0.5725528597831726,
0.20095095038414001,
0.4465693235397339,
-0.27674371004104614,
-0.26715919375419617,
0.5925118923187256,
-0.051554542034864426,
0.8025928139686584,
0.564055323600769,
-0.30392664670944214,
-0.2721562087535858,
1.0397993326187134,
0.11422286927700043,
0.11551444232463837,
0.2601659297943115,
-0.015309898182749748,
-0.3925817906856537,
-0.6937968730926514,
-0.5934367179870605,
0.22932633757591248,
-0.3660329580307007,
-0.13914859294891357,
-0.7007762789726257,
-0.015919307246804237,
-0.36977705359458923,
-0.21412713825702667,
-0.7058866620063782,
-0.5541050434112549,
0.03670324385166168,
0.09226904064416885,
0.2799813449382782,
0.6962003111839294,
-0.06278736889362335,
0.8418385982513428,
-0.3808797299861908,
0.5425540804862976,
0.4814274311065674,
0.25178200006484985,
-0.47038841247558594,
0.22432841360569,
-0.07111909985542297,
0.09978550672531128,
-0.7762424945831299,
-0.7419177293777466,
0.4774300754070282,
0.3460967540740967,
0.44932883977890015,
0.6005673408508301,
0.13748972117900848,
0.47059687972068787,
-0.17300033569335938,
0.5447032451629639,
-0.055433180183172226,
-0.564781904220581,
0.778289794921875,
-0.4776644706726074,
0.1876152604818344,
0.41540858149528503,
0.3926115036010742,
-0.16008751094341278,
0.25576460361480713,
-0.8390226364135742,
-0.9086962938308716,
0.9677336812019348,
0.22574825584888458,
-0.41376441717147827,
0.4008103311061859,
0.2290368676185608,
-0.12030556797981262,
0.19327394664287567,
-0.4715540409088135,
0.08882775902748108,
-0.045858290046453476,
0.2058972865343094,
0.26933756470680237,
-0.0111847510561347,
-0.26841914653778076,
-0.049632616341114044,
0.6185897588729858,
-0.5806496739387512,
0.37109702825546265,
0.11833301186561584,
-0.0813804343342781,
-0.03509536385536194,
0.004665910266339779,
0.5951570868492126,
0.7071017622947693,
-0.0838334709405899,
-0.17114970088005066,
0.3799300491809845,
-0.7986185550689697,
0.006700514350086451,
0.5686033368110657,
-0.2378762662410736,
-0.40087389945983887,
0.22165153920650482,
0.4504565894603729,
0.17070195078849792,
-0.5023984313011169,
0.2301122099161148,
-0.2593899369239807,
0.10134989768266678,
-0.37815946340560913,
0.35822808742523193,
-0.15331456065177917,
0.2598828673362732,
0.18585343658924103,
-0.011918344534933567,
0.21083860099315643,
-0.39773768186569214,
-0.057762570679187775,
0.0363609604537487,
-0.2714233100414276,
-0.46979111433029175,
0.6648789644241333,
0.5329201221466064,
-0.419206827878952,
0.647418737411499,
-0.5146938562393188,
-0.45940569043159485,
0.7544097900390625,
0.32199063897132874,
0.8182468414306641,
-0.46217647194862366,
0.11300593614578247,
0.00560923432931304,
0.36685821413993835,
0.19191724061965942,
0.99214768409729,
-0.029381249099969864,
-0.8187941312789917,
-0.15734438598155975,
-0.3940664827823639,
-0.5064422488212585,
0.025560228154063225,
-0.15153874456882477,
0.42976129055023193,
-0.6048129200935364,
-0.16826987266540527,
-0.15560497343540192,
0.34294459223747253,
-0.8076755404472351,
0.09719433635473251,
-0.19473807513713837,
0.9779298901557922,
-0.3934701085090637,
1.0620157718658447,
0.9499544501304626,
-0.4840488135814667,
-0.9439585208892822,
0.023676235228776932,
0.11431458592414856,
-0.7159918546676636,
0.2780461311340332,
0.010305631905794144,
-0.48361971974372864,
0.030063113197684288,
0.06293418258428574,
-0.903535008430481,
1.250340223312378,
0.3102082908153534,
-0.12556162476539612,
-0.046873968094587326,
0.3993479311466217,
0.395020991563797,
-0.5743455290794373,
0.4817112386226654,
0.4950796663761139,
0.37023428082466125,
0.23649169504642487,
-1.1089330911636353,
-0.24286174774169922,
-0.1836310476064682,
-0.18079839646816254,
0.3510018289089203,
-0.7128316164016724,
0.9725664854049683,
-0.3679599463939667,
-0.061690155416727066,
-0.040169961750507355,
0.3709181547164917,
0.38033854961395264,
0.5424229502677917,
0.599877655506134,
0.6574344038963318,
0.5974698662757874,
0.01287029031664133,
1.0039105415344238,
-0.6369034051895142,
0.08823782205581665,
0.8913326859474182,
-0.8079780340194702,
0.9077332019805908,
0.05625726282596588,
0.10947036743164062,
0.1578630805015564,
0.6075662970542908,
0.5489409565925598,
0.6411572694778442,
-0.41749730706214905,
-0.37807053327560425,
0.024214504286646843,
-0.12111994624137878,
-0.26269635558128357,
0.5746562480926514,
0.562262773513794,
0.16740161180496216,
-0.11870525777339935,
0.005246731918305159,
0.10355813056230545,
-0.37982985377311707,
-0.4857092797756195,
0.7240033745765686,
-0.05865262448787689,
-0.6533368229866028,
0.20473520457744598,
0.21578183770179749,
0.12906880676746368,
-0.7266114354133606,
-0.11162180453538895,
-0.30204617977142334,
0.5049058198928833,
-0.18689151108264923,
-0.6416240930557251,
0.15569013357162476,
-0.247583270072937,
0.19790776073932648,
-0.28935685753822327,
0.8585822582244873,
-0.02855381928384304,
-0.20875532925128937,
0.2506214380264282,
0.4937479794025421,
0.046155791729688644,
-0.25943678617477417,
-0.7418971657752991,
0.18124938011169434,
-0.2914641797542572,
-0.2599250078201294,
0.0841561108827591,
0.5405916571617126,
-0.14763368666172028,
1.0371043682098389,
0.7143782377243042,
0.04940547049045563,
0.03924810513854027,
-0.3003711998462677,
1.0640056133270264,
-0.4171407222747803,
-0.9565776586532593,
-0.474530965089798,
0.4496126174926758,
-0.2859635651111603,
-0.6155005693435669,
0.3600321114063263,
0.9301000833511353,
0.7858589887619019,
0.36742356419563293,
0.565940260887146,
-0.07470352947711945,
0.2145872414112091,
-0.48942407965660095,
0.47344204783439636,
-0.4040820300579071,
0.5423482656478882,
0.016555165871977806,
-1.062703251838684,
0.04522262513637543,
0.6135540008544922,
-0.5394468307495117,
0.19312013685703278,
0.5242725610733032,
0.6611852645874023,
-0.4913424849510193,
0.2781217098236084,
0.22287429869174957,
-0.09758932143449783,
0.4798803925514221,
0.5832325220108032,
0.5709990859031677,
-0.3106648921966553,
0.5741829872131348,
-0.4724545478820801,
-0.15803544223308563,
-0.40323418378829956,
-0.5297922492027283,
-0.6146649718284607,
-0.5801367163658142,
-0.1766158491373062,
0.23120243847370148,
0.1668401062488556,
0.9462833404541016,
0.9844458103179932,
-0.29249632358551025,
-0.436658650636673,
0.002616553334519267,
0.39341503381729126,
-0.3634692430496216,
-0.12837685644626617,
0.3629080355167389,
-0.05427990481257439,
-0.6525818705558777,
0.5924090147018433,
0.33227574825286865,
-0.09746991842985153,
-0.22618375718593597,
-0.3029029369354248,
0.024853793904185295,
0.01135560404509306,
0.7236706018447876,
0.6455206274986267,
-0.3744274973869324,
-0.09873443096876144,
-0.11258728802204132,
-0.020565124228596687,
-0.055426567792892456,
0.9818004369735718,
-0.672903299331665,
0.27255865931510925,
0.35906997323036194,
0.2931274175643921,
0.6264082193374634,
-0.12511815130710602,
0.6034209728240967,
-0.4078943729400635,
0.24189713597297668,
0.47873973846435547,
0.48966407775878906,
-0.01726726070046425,
-0.3872646391391754,
0.8716874718666077,
-0.06353932619094849,
-0.5881113409996033,
-0.568682074546814,
0.44499868154525757,
-1.0290582180023193,
0.012412231415510178,
1.0950920581817627,
0.013258685357868671,
-0.10233046114444733,
-0.17969466745853424,
-0.26509469747543335,
-0.06753063946962357,
-0.6696182489395142,
0.6994940638542175,
-0.03492319956421852,
-0.971473217010498,
-0.09158610552549362,
-0.4169509708881378,
0.5884508490562439,
0.060832373797893524,
-1.0178675651550293,
-0.2424595057964325,
0.3607545793056488,
-0.09628161042928696,
0.3052966296672821,
0.9320817589759827,
0.3072102665901184,
0.4286566376686096,
0.1597364842891693,
0.22676914930343628,
-0.04040015488862991,
-0.5979851484298706,
0.027381379157304764,
0.40404441952705383,
0.07916992902755737,
-0.38968425989151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18078v1 | Self-Training with Pseudo-Label Scorer for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | 2024-06-26T05:30:21 | Yice Zhang, Jie Zeng, Weiming Hu, Ziyi Wang, Shiwei Chen, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction (ASQP) aims to predict all quads (aspect
term, aspect category, opinion term, sentiment polarity) for a given review,
which is the most representative and challenging task in aspect-based sentiment
analysis. A key challenge in the ASQP task is the scarcity of labeled data,
which limits the performance of existing methods. To tackle this issue, we
propose a self-training framework with a pseudo-label scorer, wherein a scorer
assesses the match between reviews and their pseudo-labels, aiming to filter
out mismatches and thereby enhance the effectiveness of self-training. We
highlight two critical aspects to ensure the scorer's effectiveness and
reliability: the quality of the training dataset and its model architecture. To
this end, we create a human-annotated comparison dataset and train a generative
model on it using ranking-based objectives. Extensive experiments on public
ASQP datasets reveal that using our scorer can greatly and consistently improve
the effectiveness of self-training. Moreover, we explore the possibility of
replacing humans with large language models for comparison dataset annotation,
and experiments demonstrate its feasibility. We release our code and data at
https://github.com/HITSZ-HLT/ST-w-Scorer-ABSA . | [
-0.5464019179344177,
-0.11561096459627151,
0.314776748418808,
0.29813817143440247,
-0.3567039966583252,
0.22381319105625153,
0.08594294637441635,
-0.46574774384498596,
0.41138890385627747,
0.43572843074798584,
-0.5474658608436584,
-0.7255075573921204,
-0.3894786536693573,
0.1316203773021698,
-0.2155582457780838,
1.4150046110153198,
0.01201800350099802,
0.10843496024608612,
-0.5305240750312805,
-0.34592387080192566,
-0.4651200771331787,
-1.007721185684204,
-0.416294127702713,
-0.2917543947696686,
0.34401899576187134,
0.44916948676109314,
0.3631703555583954,
0.32517170906066895,
0.3282375931739807,
0.25766563415527344,
0.06651464104652405,
-0.0656072124838829,
-0.3551267087459564,
0.17602913081645966,
-0.03347358480095863,
-0.22641441226005554,
-0.583088219165802,
0.3991851210594177,
0.5512573719024658,
0.23822161555290222,
0.0634869709610939,
0.3331871032714844,
0.20707698166370392,
0.8381820917129517,
-0.5860773921012878,
0.3017106354236603,
-0.35008537769317627,
0.2352404147386551,
-0.14329952001571655,
-0.008831201121211052,
-0.1796247363090515,
-0.39642465114593506,
-0.21872839331626892,
-0.25929877161979675,
0.265641450881958,
0.16043917834758759,
0.6035234332084656,
0.19176353514194489,
-0.31345027685165405,
0.059594348073005676,
-0.716295599937439,
0.630654513835907,
-0.6197444796562195,
0.4624601900577545,
0.6055662035942078,
0.3643207848072052,
0.0650365948677063,
-0.47524523735046387,
-0.48572418093681335,
-0.15570740401744843,
-0.03958401456475258,
0.5353370308876038,
0.12191388010978699,
0.23810377717018127,
0.19810321927070618,
0.5586825013160706,
-0.5922464728355408,
0.07286619395017624,
-0.1962931603193283,
-0.47718724608421326,
0.8617072701454163,
0.14235937595367432,
-0.07750438153743744,
-0.5664250254631042,
-0.5949996113777161,
-0.0824703723192215,
-0.6182758808135986,
0.4646655023097992,
0.5588198304176331,
0.21697302162647247,
0.03230509161949158,
0.4333464503288269,
-0.571112334728241,
0.5658610463142395,
0.19761067628860474,
0.1613045632839203,
0.5290077924728394,
-0.2804775536060333,
0.1440449357032776,
0.0489777997136116,
1.1526163816452026,
0.5555089116096497,
-0.23010513186454773,
0.011583813466131687,
-0.5793872475624084,
0.01038382202386856,
0.4925709664821625,
-0.6105592846870422,
-0.7692416310310364,
0.2717382609844208,
-0.3156642019748688,
-0.32750970125198364,
-0.09748275578022003,
-0.6673598289489746,
-0.20070499181747437,
-0.35976964235305786,
0.6423373818397522,
-0.4601493775844574,
-0.04470207542181015,
-0.22450828552246094,
-0.02237716130912304,
0.02464570850133896,
0.11383496224880219,
-0.8411550521850586,
0.06926296651363373,
0.6286807060241699,
0.779569685459137,
-0.043314315378665924,
-0.4283261299133301,
-0.6524759531021118,
-0.4843679964542389,
-0.37170693278312683,
1.0725395679473877,
-0.41285595297813416,
-0.5199082493782043,
-0.04498874768614769,
-0.49991223216056824,
0.09336011856794357,
-0.321528822183609,
0.6222493052482605,
-0.3785746395587921,
0.130531907081604,
-0.3401428461074829,
-0.4888271689414978,
-0.17055971920490265,
0.6760666966438293,
-0.5298527479171753,
1.3287726640701294,
0.3165859282016754,
-0.7473553419113159,
0.3165137767791748,
-0.2977510094642639,
-0.2827084958553314,
0.15200990438461304,
-0.28723835945129395,
-0.9994071125984192,
0.1799083650112152,
0.26075518131256104,
0.2769322991371155,
-0.18841028213500977,
-0.13842226564884186,
-0.5792569518089294,
-0.13558490574359894,
0.3789464831352234,
-0.17590539157390594,
0.35001692175865173,
0.018878506496548653,
-0.11542168259620667,
0.25040268898010254,
-0.6526469588279724,
0.3210238516330719,
-0.26691949367523193,
-0.2379232943058014,
-0.20268595218658447,
-0.19004350900650024,
-0.07523709535598755,
0.5966782569885254,
0.321288138628006,
-0.61910080909729,
0.3878043591976166,
-0.5259310603141785,
0.1455720216035843,
0.6597800850868225,
0.19977110624313354,
0.2532374858856201,
-0.1885315626859665,
0.736668050289154,
0.1699417233467102,
0.5644065141677856,
0.2691076099872589,
-0.48148903250694275,
-0.6411332488059998,
-0.20655356347560883,
0.7036639451980591,
0.2310837358236313,
-1.142983317375183,
0.7331199049949646,
-0.042602457106113434,
-0.6715940237045288,
-0.7066088318824768,
0.19366805255413055,
0.9087074995040894,
0.5035930275917053,
0.5718973875045776,
-0.6753412485122681,
-0.44088104367256165,
-0.8544977307319641,
-0.3936308026313782,
-0.4761057496070862,
0.1632474958896637,
0.008852141909301281,
0.36416199803352356,
-0.05636429786682129,
1.232433795928955,
-0.6625164151191711,
-0.7631047368049622,
-0.26292651891708374,
0.6765385270118713,
0.02359599806368351,
0.40376922488212585,
0.5604203939437866,
-0.7410634756088257,
-0.5777140259742737,
-0.4574260413646698,
-0.47167447209358215,
-0.23949939012527466,
0.04782690480351448,
-0.09597666561603546,
0.1332295536994934,
0.25783517956733704,
-0.22029203176498413,
0.5015131831169128,
0.5556570291519165,
-0.3568217158317566,
0.9198542833328247,
-0.22776298224925995,
0.3436914384365082,
-0.8244265913963318,
-0.2576219141483307,
0.34174075722694397,
-0.3439728915691376,
-0.5555265545845032,
-0.2658129036426544,
0.09616784006357193,
-0.050805460661649704,
-0.4162848889827728,
0.29427576065063477,
-0.20680329203605652,
-0.31197038292884827,
-0.46094462275505066,
-0.27116936445236206,
0.09626147150993347,
0.7285210490226746,
0.34048211574554443,
0.7105116844177246,
0.44185760617256165,
-0.4299520254135132,
0.24751532077789307,
0.3831605911254883,
-0.2681651711463928,
0.6302011013031006,
-0.329665869474411,
0.3182981014251709,
-0.03172627091407776,
0.3833574950695038,
-0.9140903353691101,
0.0817568451166153,
0.5552870035171509,
-0.6961804628372192,
0.302624374628067,
-0.30587178468704224,
-0.42141541838645935,
-0.6038089394569397,
-0.5715183019638062,
0.4610629081726074,
0.30307701230049133,
-0.5322768688201904,
0.6435615420341492,
0.4404677450656891,
-0.020465515553951263,
-0.5548880696296692,
-0.18215815722942352,
-0.14791424572467804,
-0.12578018009662628,
0.021910754963755608,
0.28574731945991516,
-0.16384023427963257,
0.29211845993995667,
-0.2759507894515991,
-0.14957043528556824,
0.1310747265815735,
0.01477057859301567,
0.434369832277298,
0.29352208971977234,
0.058422163128852844,
0.2956730127334595,
0.0740368515253067,
-0.5072106719017029,
0.2812027931213379,
-0.282379150390625,
0.3510684370994568,
-0.33606624603271484,
-0.15942628681659698,
-0.46756306290626526,
0.12832608819007874,
0.1245858445763588,
-0.35062259435653687,
0.5765702724456787,
0.30422213673591614,
-0.021745091304183006,
-0.26267457008361816,
-0.3605596423149109,
-0.15293028950691223,
-0.43346884846687317,
0.29407697916030884,
-0.6393278241157532,
-0.5756900310516357,
0.3195621371269226,
0.06178060546517372,
-0.12032657861709595,
0.5710674524307251,
0.3591114282608032,
-0.48039618134498596,
1.2068123817443848,
0.5469110012054443,
-0.39434584975242615,
0.5389764308929443,
-0.45501068234443665,
0.1504177749156952,
-0.9628238677978516,
-0.1463632881641388,
-0.4019847512245178,
-0.26059195399284363,
-0.4686504602432251,
-0.2710864543914795,
0.5471273064613342,
0.2108698934316635,
-0.1288527399301529,
0.2990350127220154,
-0.6805027723312378,
0.354505330324173,
0.7090810537338257,
0.13433606922626495,
0.21663670241832733,
-0.3396589756011963,
0.15191569924354553,
-0.21955136954784393,
-0.588708758354187,
-0.2610493302345276,
1.1420106887817383,
0.31632328033447266,
0.4283463656902313,
-0.12193578481674194,
1.0249196290969849,
0.6152090430259705,
0.44546350836753845,
-0.8382667303085327,
0.4764525592327118,
-0.201818585395813,
-0.47209835052490234,
-0.24225182831287384,
-0.6078225374221802,
-0.3082801401615143,
0.14067821204662323,
-0.5761047005653381,
-0.46800270676612854,
0.1570163071155548,
0.577664852142334,
-0.39284682273864746,
-0.040328968316316605,
-0.4241946041584015,
1.0768944025039673,
-0.5439000725746155,
-0.12239472568035126,
0.0009656592737883329,
-0.7137804627418518,
0.1595124900341034,
-0.21475593745708466,
0.16536051034927368,
-0.14031004905700684,
0.3248307704925537,
0.8843222260475159,
-0.48486849665641785,
0.9107899069786072,
-0.3375885784626007,
0.23938648402690887,
0.4985995888710022,
0.006444234866648912,
0.31166645884513855,
-0.008344583213329315,
0.0669049620628357,
0.5250459909439087,
0.02014625072479248,
-0.29016631841659546,
-0.6312995553016663,
0.49968770146369934,
-1.0521786212921143,
-0.4283088743686676,
-0.7842709422111511,
0.0008960492559708655,
-0.49575310945510864,
-0.08583638072013855,
0.6295342445373535,
0.4886035621166229,
-0.1131972223520279,
-0.18135720491409302,
0.31634804606437683,
0.25031396746635437,
0.17676983773708344,
0.4291979670524597,
-0.3699261546134949,
-0.6755428314208984,
1.2394747734069824,
0.21930332481861115,
0.0530206672847271,
0.193159818649292,
0.32933565974235535,
-0.6570240259170532,
-0.6368118524551392,
-0.6074147820472717,
0.12496499717235565,
-0.7325877547264099,
-0.6460253596305847,
-0.4341490566730499,
-0.45354163646698,
-0.43451547622680664,
0.14370451867580414,
-0.70810467004776,
-0.3995841443538666,
-0.1905926614999771,
-0.1256054788827896,
0.46538934111595154,
0.7860863208770752,
-0.17118215560913086,
0.36261144280433655,
-0.8166002631187439,
0.29038217663764954,
0.37396129965782166,
0.42922621965408325,
-0.24439236521720886,
-0.8068342208862305,
-0.40151655673980713,
0.022340737283229828,
-0.5412403345108032,
-0.8186675906181335,
0.5081823468208313,
0.32708683609962463,
0.25492554903030396,
0.2932370603084564,
0.47751545906066895,
0.43381938338279724,
-0.2771713435649872,
0.729939341545105,
0.42298513650894165,
-0.9687384366989136,
0.553462028503418,
-0.232897087931633,
0.14271637797355652,
0.8950074315071106,
0.5445026755332947,
-0.3607381582260132,
-0.5772662162780762,
-0.5472191572189331,
-0.8509086966514587,
0.8274564146995544,
0.25864118337631226,
-0.18044094741344452,
0.19053976237773895,
0.5609115362167358,
0.23421810567378998,
0.3908138871192932,
-0.8975468873977661,
-0.3978479206562042,
-0.8022465705871582,
-0.34903398156166077,
-0.3298839032649994,
-0.312467485666275,
0.08075951039791107,
-0.38209035992622375,
0.9365130066871643,
-0.3975546061992645,
0.295427531003952,
0.010765954852104187,
0.07545484602451324,
0.04564622417092323,
0.08959075808525085,
0.009829838760197163,
0.16184721887111664,
-0.2003699541091919,
0.047511473298072815,
0.12194254249334335,
-0.3382223844528198,
0.25836873054504395,
0.1521185338497162,
-0.2288808971643448,
-0.2774509787559509,
0.19474516808986664,
0.73404860496521,
0.19888396561145782,
-0.12055961042642593,
0.7053695917129517,
-0.09355123341083527,
-0.1318642646074295,
-0.5301620364189148,
0.06197986751794815,
-0.21953336894512177,
0.317127525806427,
0.19011399149894714,
-0.014088178984820843,
0.49302372336387634,
-0.5811800956726074,
0.22409379482269287,
0.23774559795856476,
-0.934169590473175,
-0.4999150335788727,
0.5591608285903931,
0.19948197901248932,
-0.3790789544582367,
0.6077853441238403,
-0.6442694067955017,
-1.124174952507019,
0.3818076252937317,
0.2574196755886078,
0.9344599843025208,
-0.22030095756053925,
0.6031843423843384,
0.380045622587204,
-0.1377888321876526,
-0.17032583057880402,
0.1813410371541977,
-0.328159362077713,
-0.5925493836402893,
-0.24279485642910004,
-0.8434468507766724,
-0.48822101950645447,
-0.1203833818435669,
-0.7824493646621704,
0.27093949913978577,
-0.4770497679710388,
-0.42459383606910706,
-0.005601756740361452,
0.12319453060626984,
-0.38139504194259644,
0.6999520063400269,
0.24629588425159454,
0.37419483065605164,
-1.2190734148025513,
0.9046724438667297,
0.808292806148529,
-0.6946961283683777,
-0.726589560508728,
0.20793423056602478,
-0.1468222290277481,
-0.3706912398338318,
0.5913814902305603,
0.33691078424453735,
-0.24732807278633118,
-0.02837318554520607,
-0.3457103967666626,
-0.6529250741004944,
0.6889896988868713,
-0.14561466872692108,
-0.5445245504379272,
0.2125321477651596,
0.10628683120012283,
0.8889687061309814,
-0.39627376198768616,
0.30257704854011536,
0.6032963991165161,
0.08343857526779175,
0.27810728549957275,
-0.5975741147994995,
-0.30811041593551636,
-0.18259570002555847,
-0.04906115680932999,
0.375265896320343,
-0.7702619433403015,
0.5634916424751282,
0.16248583793640137,
0.1232200488448143,
-0.14352139830589294,
1.2173874378204346,
0.24138040840625763,
0.56504225730896,
0.5611841082572937,
0.5550316572189331,
0.25255388021469116,
-0.11743535846471786,
0.8077895641326904,
-0.3145087659358978,
0.6107608675956726,
1.242972493171692,
-0.10847646743059158,
1.1306898593902588,
0.03755975514650345,
-0.22864972054958344,
0.586175799369812,
0.8313267230987549,
0.05981462076306343,
0.6623235940933228,
-0.04040820151567459,
-0.22556957602500916,
-0.6874293684959412,
0.17378495633602142,
-0.1987491399049759,
0.6588159203529358,
0.1926167607307434,
-0.2221572995185852,
0.1606147140264511,
0.1131536141037941,
-0.3154686987400055,
0.17197240889072418,
-0.6040262579917908,
1.0057271718978882,
0.21713092923164368,
-0.7624528408050537,
0.29425525665283203,
-0.042798977345228195,
0.4873722493648529,
-0.3530162572860718,
0.08566032350063324,
-0.12354258447885513,
0.09766068309545517,
-0.22449998557567596,
-0.9559939503669739,
0.2267858237028122,
-0.1825447976589203,
-0.16245795786380768,
-0.2987764775753021,
0.6424618363380432,
-0.4399666488170624,
-0.6184409856796265,
0.28424370288848877,
0.18718187510967255,
0.1258397251367569,
-0.33488592505455017,
-0.9834004044532776,
-0.20461469888687134,
0.0697389468550682,
-0.2760544419288635,
0.5290487408638,
0.22492150962352753,
-0.0709296241402626,
0.5000982284545898,
0.4393843710422516,
0.04750785604119301,
-0.361784428358078,
-0.012042520567774773,
1.0406748056411743,
-0.8140050172805786,
-0.8189601898193359,
-0.6146101355552673,
0.3681691884994507,
-0.10036774724721909,
-0.6115381717681885,
0.660153865814209,
0.7488999366760254,
0.640591025352478,
0.021014729514718056,
0.7069265842437744,
0.19901104271411896,
0.7271842956542969,
-0.5600101947784424,
0.7948040962219238,
-0.46335723996162415,
0.18970605731010437,
-0.176339253783226,
-1.031469702720642,
-0.15944339334964752,
0.5836362838745117,
-0.7566551566123962,
0.192770317196846,
0.5373289585113525,
0.48843950033187866,
0.1286831796169281,
0.13001368939876556,
0.36513638496398926,
0.1733745038509369,
0.17682264745235443,
0.3598814606666565,
0.9337638020515442,
-0.37804338335990906,
0.5355337262153625,
-0.5867726802825928,
-0.2917060852050781,
-0.3731822967529297,
-0.6053944826126099,
-1.097360610961914,
-0.7999065518379211,
-0.6057658791542053,
-0.5429139733314514,
0.09096721559762955,
0.967985987663269,
0.49227312207221985,
-0.7627658247947693,
0.00905235018581152,
0.11977033317089081,
-0.12625719606876373,
-0.23572716116905212,
-0.1583956480026245,
0.37753957509994507,
-0.2807231545448303,
-0.4225206673145294,
0.08561136573553085,
0.24792246520519257,
0.04367109388113022,
-0.3741806745529175,
-0.008345235139131546,
0.1035672277212143,
-0.09580477327108383,
0.5246793031692505,
0.5095760822296143,
-0.28699901700019836,
-0.48722273111343384,
-0.40433982014656067,
-0.09827892482280731,
0.3899848461151123,
0.6698696613311768,
-1.0100845098495483,
0.7544512748718262,
0.36705833673477173,
0.1724454015493393,
0.6788145303726196,
0.4591355621814728,
0.5148274302482605,
-0.9300225377082825,
-0.2718007266521454,
0.5484908223152161,
0.22933636605739594,
0.4540978968143463,
-0.34276264905929565,
0.2108241617679596,
0.1862187683582306,
-0.6990147829055786,
-0.5417166948318481,
0.32289478182792664,
-0.7127711772918701,
-0.05928071215748787,
0.9942346811294556,
-0.3817332088947296,
-0.396932989358902,
-0.28201574087142944,
-0.17568525671958923,
0.25322598218917847,
-0.5158275365829468,
1.1972084045410156,
0.40575283765792847,
-0.44565626978874207,
0.044148217886686325,
-0.11876118928194046,
0.9233586192131042,
0.3179986774921417,
-0.7987316846847534,
-0.03880736604332924,
0.6258498430252075,
0.1309826523065567,
0.12032954394817352,
0.8773548603057861,
0.24459215998649597,
0.3834208846092224,
-0.07421693205833435,
0.5071037411689758,
-0.041693154722452164,
-0.601814866065979,
-0.4508667588233948,
0.08862299472093582,
0.3679598867893219,
-0.4992144703865051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18069v2 | Large Language Models for Cuffless Blood Pressure Measurement From Wearable Biosignals | 2024-06-26T04:54:45 | 2024-06-27T03:58:25 | Zengding Liu, Chen Chen, Jiannong Cao, Minglei Pan, Jikui Liu, Nan Li, Fen Miao, Ye Li | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have captured significant interest from both
academia and industry due to their impressive performance across various
textual tasks. However, the potential of LLMs to analyze physiological
time-series data remains an emerging research field. Particularly, there is a
notable gap in the utilization of LLMs for analyzing wearable biosignals to
achieve cuffless blood pressure (BP) measurement, which is critical for the
management of cardiovascular diseases. This paper presents the first work to
explore the capacity of LLMs to perform cuffless BP estimation based on
wearable biosignals. We extracted physiological features from electrocardiogram
(ECG) and photoplethysmogram (PPG) signals and designed context-enhanced
prompts by combining these features with BP domain knowledge and user
information. Subsequently, we adapted LLMs to BP estimation tasks through
fine-tuning. To evaluate the proposed approach, we conducted assessments of ten
advanced LLMs using a comprehensive public dataset of wearable biosignals from
1,272 participants. The experimental results demonstrate that the optimally
fine-tuned LLM significantly surpasses conventional task-specific baselines,
achieving an estimation error of 0.00 $\pm$ 9.25 mmHg for systolic BP and 1.29
$\pm$ 6.37 mmHg for diastolic BP. Notably, the ablation studies highlight the
benefits of our context enhancement strategy, leading to an 8.9% reduction in
mean absolute error for systolic BP estimation. This paper pioneers the
exploration of LLMs for cuffless BP measurement, providing a potential solution
to enhance the accuracy of cuffless BP measurement. | [
-0.35916197299957275,
-0.7293406128883362,
0.8502765893936157,
0.0580161027610302,
-0.8189800381660461,
-0.019352952018380165,
-0.24432221055030823,
-0.789544403553009,
0.44893231987953186,
0.4281255304813385,
-0.6388863921165466,
-0.6411619782447815,
-0.545062243938446,
0.20794308185577393,
0.04407815262675285,
0.8837266564369202,
-0.084866002202034,
0.28325313329696655,
-0.005807098466902971,
-0.11271600425243378,
-0.34134724736213684,
-0.35844385623931885,
-0.18133632838726044,
-0.5192323923110962,
0.459450364112854,
0.007775878068059683,
0.3311941623687744,
0.5416842699050903,
0.35207802057266235,
0.16835609078407288,
-0.3903094530105591,
0.32898810505867004,
-0.10807056725025177,
0.21236421167850494,
0.12190873175859451,
0.03838701918721199,
-0.6578075289726257,
-0.28737226128578186,
0.9478362202644348,
0.8083903193473816,
0.29342585802078247,
0.7764744162559509,
0.37140393257141113,
0.7949804663658142,
-0.5134453773498535,
0.27324697375297546,
0.07349678874015808,
0.04792506992816925,
-0.20926231145858765,
-0.5081489086151123,
-0.17921485006809235,
0.01821563020348549,
0.31769487261772156,
-0.02068965882062912,
0.02003774791955948,
0.0710408017039299,
0.2972455620765686,
0.4525524377822876,
-0.4163827896118164,
0.059625107795000076,
-1.0061811208724976,
0.7146161794662476,
-0.7799637913703918,
0.6440247893333435,
0.18035760521888733,
-0.12101124227046967,
-0.09779753535985947,
-0.26665422320365906,
-0.20217564702033997,
-0.014880663715302944,
-0.10432678461074829,
0.14260625839233398,
-0.06574418395757675,
0.11751449108123779,
0.1552855670452118,
0.29925140738487244,
-0.6547406911849976,
0.3387625217437744,
-0.08475444465875626,
0.029914218932390213,
0.44491714239120483,
0.1940518617630005,
-0.1263812631368637,
-0.3497275412082672,
-0.3905893862247467,
0.21360713243484497,
-0.4904181659221649,
0.03685866668820381,
-0.1423948109149933,
0.17811153829097748,
-0.6608247756958008,
0.4281295835971832,
-0.1314602494239807,
0.9548683166503906,
-0.26574304699897766,
-0.34762459993362427,
0.3574013113975525,
-0.18422895669937134,
-0.5115281939506531,
0.0301977451890707,
0.5235538482666016,
0.15589585900306702,
-0.08853334188461304,
-0.24856628477573395,
-0.15637414157390594,
-0.10043027251958847,
-0.08729885518550873,
-0.8654531240463257,
-0.024506183341145515,
0.6233958005905151,
-0.32090920209884644,
-0.29525575041770935,
-0.33031749725341797,
-0.674705982208252,
-0.6304695010185242,
-0.40615853667259216,
0.0812152847647667,
-0.22897252440452576,
-0.21128517389297485,
0.01277264952659607,
-0.06446478515863419,
0.07240725308656693,
0.25442638993263245,
-0.7634381055831909,
0.026499032974243164,
0.627032458782196,
1.2113813161849976,
-0.13149696588516235,
0.2168232798576355,
-0.2092197686433792,
0.37122592329978943,
-0.23792913556098938,
0.876307487487793,
0.04841399937868118,
-0.7040680646896362,
-0.26163041591644287,
0.12305203825235367,
0.15591688454151154,
-0.3577291667461395,
0.7162878513336182,
-0.21900135278701782,
-0.40244242548942566,
-0.006096277851611376,
-0.7223328351974487,
0.20773521065711975,
0.30692410469055176,
-0.40702903270721436,
0.6201663613319397,
-0.2528552711009979,
-0.3805254399776459,
0.2041398584842682,
-0.5783405303955078,
-0.49163568019866943,
0.3410639464855194,
-0.09204637259244919,
-0.6246181130409241,
0.16400423645973206,
0.32970714569091797,
0.7419852018356323,
-0.32376134395599365,
0.07522338628768921,
-0.5880284309387207,
-0.3071118891239166,
0.6789343953132629,
-0.5237359404563904,
0.48998022079467773,
-0.14841626584529877,
-0.30562692880630493,
0.26842379570007324,
-0.8190335035324097,
0.12545078992843628,
-0.18396294116973877,
-0.16281616687774658,
-0.3454473614692688,
0.2363104224205017,
0.2952788472175598,
-0.0294063501060009,
0.36116185784339905,
-1.0183347463607788,
-0.046476054936647415,
-0.5117220282554626,
0.6845724582672119,
0.91053307056427,
0.18219099938869476,
0.16107486188411713,
-0.5481758713722229,
0.1848243921995163,
-0.5890021324157715,
0.4078962206840515,
0.2639193534851074,
-0.2117110937833786,
-0.3029821813106537,
-0.8958792090415955,
0.03726289048790932,
0.5793982148170471,
-0.11881573498249054,
0.7278262376785278,
-0.4183150827884674,
-0.8574255108833313,
-0.16069017350673676,
0.18911375105381012,
0.23955008387565613,
0.8373162150382996,
0.4847536087036133,
-0.11882464587688446,
-0.19178597629070282,
-0.5328224897384644,
-0.11110478639602661,
-0.107302226126194,
-0.2598198354244232,
0.5157819986343384,
0.18549644947052002,
-0.35937803983688354,
0.38059237599372864,
-0.5626316666603088,
-0.18590590357780457,
-0.21140797436237335,
0.1067231148481369,
0.45580020546913147,
0.4977220892906189,
0.32193344831466675,
-0.3358970880508423,
-0.0785229280591011,
-0.23836441338062286,
-0.5853947401046753,
-0.29868972301483154,
0.08957094699144363,
-0.060338277369737625,
0.4049704670906067,
0.2621977925300598,
-0.38732221722602844,
0.3040510416030884,
0.8703458309173584,
-0.4009954035282135,
0.6373501420021057,
-0.40814295411109924,
-0.17178834974765778,
-0.9469797015190125,
0.49663597345352173,
0.32089483737945557,
-0.4350850582122803,
-0.6794871091842651,
-0.09560300409793854,
0.17798283696174622,
-0.3412844240665436,
-0.4106333255767822,
1.1356537342071533,
-0.48549938201904297,
-0.04342196136713028,
-0.45955920219421387,
-0.17292244732379913,
-0.11811897903680801,
0.39636343717575073,
0.4791053533554077,
0.00282191950827837,
0.3473109304904938,
-0.5805158615112305,
0.15845762193202972,
0.2933349013328552,
-0.6330794095993042,
0.358115553855896,
-0.8582157492637634,
-0.08433523774147034,
-0.13301250338554382,
0.44597774744033813,
-1.0901625156402588,
-0.3273310661315918,
0.14459183812141418,
-0.2729721963405609,
0.2400992512702942,
-0.15155379474163055,
-0.4519585371017456,
-0.38263043761253357,
-0.3077549636363983,
0.25547856092453003,
0.6820371150970459,
-0.41253721714019775,
0.41330966353416443,
0.4091959297657013,
-0.24462588131427765,
-0.16454100608825684,
-0.8006338477134705,
-0.31934934854507446,
-0.16742047667503357,
-0.3886394500732422,
0.3711005747318268,
-0.2566715180873871,
0.0804259181022644,
-0.24508298933506012,
-0.5503918528556824,
0.03642473369836807,
0.000410077249398455,
0.5867007970809937,
0.9009489417076111,
0.1472519338130951,
0.46027204394340515,
0.05971945449709892,
-0.20633505284786224,
0.09204112738370895,
-0.27160313725471497,
0.5538390874862671,
-0.09725654125213623,
-0.2643849849700928,
-0.7817371487617493,
0.10002626478672028,
0.6498402953147888,
-0.2757842540740967,
0.7974591851234436,
0.6932908296585083,
-0.4975656270980835,
-0.11586315929889679,
-0.4922040104866028,
-0.1599685400724411,
-0.4944649040699005,
0.17961275577545166,
0.13426466286182404,
-1.0531073808670044,
0.4163247346878052,
-0.30980777740478516,
0.07749072462320328,
-0.09871085733175278,
0.4983883202075958,
-0.3103993535041809,
0.8419492840766907,
0.4120127260684967,
0.008269308134913445,
0.6350278258323669,
-0.029001187533140182,
0.10340992361307144,
-1.1500842571258545,
-0.2717575132846832,
-0.28583788871765137,
-0.7349314093589783,
-0.7069336175918579,
-0.22058533132076263,
1.1479878425598145,
0.030583171173930168,
-0.5645585060119629,
-0.1665463149547577,
-0.48443603515625,
0.1719151735305786,
0.20665739476680756,
0.7761397361755371,
0.20041657984256744,
0.05679658055305481,
-0.04902704060077667,
0.11432952433824539,
-0.44944852590560913,
-0.38408875465393066,
1.0631545782089233,
0.21244102716445923,
0.6791013479232788,
0.18616165220737457,
0.6367390751838684,
0.09023851156234741,
0.5159585475921631,
-0.8307484984397888,
0.366414874792099,
-0.1825317144393921,
-0.5053638219833374,
-0.5634062886238098,
-0.26223450899124146,
-0.8338315486907959,
-0.0020090609323233366,
-0.6540822386741638,
-0.8399633765220642,
0.09086421132087708,
0.592697024345398,
-0.7703192830085754,
0.2959772050380707,
-0.46477094292640686,
0.9129253029823303,
-0.6351402997970581,
-0.6532567739486694,
-0.039660342037677765,
-0.6115195751190186,
0.06858130544424057,
-0.27666735649108887,
0.25338733196258545,
-0.44099512696266174,
-0.3818361461162567,
0.402469277381897,
-0.3060797154903412,
1.0704622268676758,
0.020224396139383316,
0.011330799199640751,
-0.08926469087600708,
-0.15926241874694824,
0.3791382908821106,
0.24616722762584686,
-0.20615369081497192,
0.700626790523529,
0.4388130307197571,
-0.6072480082511902,
-0.28607264161109924,
0.8102424144744873,
-0.6467331647872925,
-0.22187502682209015,
-0.6258174777030945,
-0.49220773577690125,
-0.5993324518203735,
0.27757012844085693,
0.06726615875959396,
0.7211776375770569,
-0.21111740171909332,
0.07006068527698517,
0.5124269723892212,
-0.387192040681839,
0.5712814927101135,
0.759850025177002,
0.3089697062969208,
-0.38033297657966614,
0.6092911958694458,
-0.03197365626692772,
0.2838008999824524,
0.5504140257835388,
0.6115157008171082,
-0.5895224213600159,
-0.5137649178504944,
-0.5716279745101929,
0.5193459987640381,
-0.11251173168420792,
-0.11558052897453308,
-0.27701908349990845,
0.023070937022566795,
-0.5794788599014282,
-0.2916331887245178,
-0.11243754625320435,
0.03204439580440521,
-0.3504898250102997,
-0.04877201095223427,
0.41683241724967957,
0.3332522511482239,
-0.194486603140831,
0.2673228085041046,
-1.179519534111023,
0.29708439111709595,
-0.007383248768746853,
0.5750366449356079,
-0.062330957502126694,
-0.38022032380104065,
-0.0905158519744873,
-0.12391451001167297,
-0.029248975217342377,
-0.9603204727172852,
0.6862379908561707,
0.06323167681694031,
0.20576545596122742,
0.17448067665100098,
0.03288950026035309,
0.8442618250846863,
-0.5764212012290955,
0.6400787234306335,
0.20431500673294067,
-0.9486030340194702,
0.567630410194397,
-0.4110989272594452,
0.5270407795906067,
0.13278260827064514,
0.3827570080757141,
-0.6652058362960815,
0.0016764986794441938,
-0.4697335958480835,
-0.890362024307251,
0.24322830140590668,
-0.12607336044311523,
-0.10555689036846161,
0.18657228350639343,
0.4482634663581848,
-0.16472437977790833,
0.27325183153152466,
-0.5947240591049194,
-0.2926120162010193,
0.29422271251678467,
-0.21112819015979767,
-0.5788161754608154,
0.05060003697872162,
-0.021451907232403755,
-0.4656430780887604,
0.5979088544845581,
-0.06724976003170013,
0.29389119148254395,
0.5242002606391907,
0.19028526544570923,
-0.38055092096328735,
0.46462032198905945,
0.549879789352417,
0.6966606974601746,
-0.2726861834526062,
0.005367466248571873,
0.12299833446741104,
-0.266895055770874,
-0.04875108599662781,
0.38832080364227295,
-0.22450031340122223,
-0.09429266303777695,
0.4147948920726776,
0.6795348525047302,
0.12425527721643448,
-1.180280089378357,
0.22813104093074799,
0.3070582449436188,
0.19215799868106842,
-0.8214470744132996,
-0.1655712127685547,
0.11681435257196426,
0.38006728887557983,
-0.012375172227621078,
0.11550337076187134,
-0.27573373913764954,
-0.3278772830963135,
0.10411074757575989,
0.6694950461387634,
-0.27351799607276917,
-0.1907055824995041,
0.6666290760040283,
0.4745807647705078,
-0.010725651867687702,
0.04679684340953827,
0.11265762895345688,
-0.026018185541033745,
0.24383433163166046,
0.4101370871067047,
0.6187039017677307,
-0.4156906008720398,
0.06961400806903839,
0.32964542508125305,
0.24286171793937683,
0.0846940204501152,
0.27468976378440857,
-0.16698738932609558,
-0.7022128701210022,
-0.6685675382614136,
-1.0376719236373901,
-0.6283486485481262,
0.44143399596214294,
-0.41413402557373047,
0.28180110454559326,
-0.7536266446113586,
-0.19948726892471313,
0.2689638137817383,
0.22712217271327972,
-0.5369663834571838,
0.22948038578033447,
0.45354339480400085,
0.6216152906417847,
-0.8116526007652283,
0.6742515563964844,
0.5735419988632202,
0.035287290811538696,
-0.6083901524543762,
-0.061452820897102356,
0.17135798931121826,
-0.9258161187171936,
0.25510692596435547,
-0.0669865682721138,
-0.047302309423685074,
-0.04941360652446747,
-0.2962374985218048,
-0.7504587173461914,
1.1394081115722656,
0.33479857444763184,
-0.7110851407051086,
0.10573217272758484,
0.37414366006851196,
0.8841080069541931,
0.11514163017272949,
-0.025744814425706863,
0.3154793381690979,
0.37109875679016113,
-0.06664006412029266,
-1.0006542205810547,
0.17740853130817413,
-0.14299741387367249,
-0.2281593531370163,
0.43656155467033386,
-0.7759027481079102,
0.6177843809127808,
0.049161382019519806,
0.02519962564110756,
0.4272598326206207,
0.21215680241584778,
0.47359493374824524,
0.25356990098953247,
0.2765972316265106,
0.3202708959579468,
0.7756716012954712,
0.044846825301647186,
1.235171914100647,
-0.5980293154716492,
0.17968642711639404,
1.0129971504211426,
-0.26778674125671387,
0.9701486229896545,
0.4099807143211365,
0.13394427299499512,
0.5068475604057312,
0.8424268364906311,
0.10055568069219589,
0.12261886149644852,
0.2693808674812317,
-0.828616201877594,
-0.4178941547870636,
-0.18041273951530457,
-0.20354600250720978,
0.2677572965621948,
0.6212468147277832,
-0.5560693740844727,
-0.0028782295994460583,
-0.03333582356572151,
-0.21649187803268433,
-0.2753015458583832,
-0.630401074886322,
0.43527334928512573,
0.15427425503730774,
-0.4557132124900818,
0.655735433101654,
0.04847560450434685,
0.5330402255058289,
-0.8437375426292419,
0.13849221169948578,
0.0746842622756958,
0.297315776348114,
-0.25881093740463257,
-0.5795568227767944,
0.15904965996742249,
0.16059629619121552,
0.03077489696443081,
-0.5790992975234985,
0.8579802513122559,
-0.2295808047056198,
-0.6871776580810547,
0.09793014824390411,
0.6871410608291626,
0.1660938709974289,
-0.08581403642892838,
-0.44530215859413147,
0.044739432632923126,
-0.331764817237854,
-0.15921355783939362,
0.25182968378067017,
-0.14151865243911743,
0.25527650117874146,
0.5514925122261047,
0.7196508049964905,
0.7665039300918579,
-0.33874091506004333,
-0.22908194363117218,
0.35349616408348083,
-0.6975384950637817,
-0.6365454196929932,
-0.9571500420570374,
0.20270830392837524,
-0.025715963914990425,
-0.3207898736000061,
0.5002748966217041,
0.256313294172287,
0.706352949142456,
-0.06817425042390823,
0.8249630928039551,
0.18783783912658691,
0.9785852432250977,
-0.45058754086494446,
0.6099542379379272,
-0.678803026676178,
0.13375093042850494,
-0.44026800990104675,
-0.6727619767189026,
-0.3988482654094696,
0.5083557367324829,
-0.42632532119750977,
-0.222621887922287,
0.4934050142765045,
0.4797893166542053,
0.07786650955677032,
-0.05622567608952522,
0.18213538825511932,
0.08314424008131027,
0.1437261700630188,
0.5756816267967224,
0.24064548313617706,
0.061877649277448654,
0.23444990813732147,
-0.30743807554244995,
-0.556451678276062,
-0.16910819709300995,
-0.9499523639678955,
-0.8733430504798889,
-0.09069443494081497,
-0.14335095882415771,
-0.19398464262485504,
-0.08926675468683243,
1.1310803890228271,
0.694720447063446,
-0.6569659113883972,
-0.1960667073726654,
0.07208133488893509,
-0.1305769830942154,
-0.2169325202703476,
-0.06951477378606796,
0.48363229632377625,
0.2384498119354248,
-0.7297424077987671,
0.38495802879333496,
0.43957972526550293,
0.5235669016838074,
-0.3212018609046936,
0.07632739841938019,
0.19714471697807312,
0.056545283645391464,
0.7001554369926453,
0.5477982759475708,
-0.5609744191169739,
-0.502159595489502,
0.11953270435333252,
0.12206558883190155,
-0.21097208559513092,
0.6526333689689636,
-0.6437777876853943,
0.2401304543018341,
0.47549647092819214,
0.612862229347229,
0.41390904784202576,
0.07198633998632431,
0.14188189804553986,
-0.9126191735267639,
0.27891480922698975,
0.30529066920280457,
0.4545231759548187,
0.39824026823043823,
-0.2584124207496643,
0.3598695993423462,
0.46555113792419434,
-0.6712634563446045,
-0.6383730173110962,
0.31309372186660767,
-1.3233872652053833,
-0.33987677097320557,
1.2592767477035522,
0.1554158478975296,
-0.38367801904678345,
0.004935067147016525,
0.15746699273586273,
0.4528246223926544,
-0.17469632625579834,
0.8329721093177795,
0.5115415453910828,
-0.8818027377128601,
0.18421532213687897,
-0.6364375352859497,
0.39887750148773193,
0.49352365732192993,
-0.7999901175498962,
-0.06452233344316483,
0.6758906841278076,
0.5493414998054504,
0.05766220763325691,
0.5970754623413086,
-0.00880051776766777,
0.06688989698886871,
-0.6575613021850586,
-0.13198666274547577,
-0.08187272399663925,
0.23739053308963776,
-0.3915926218032837,
-0.049280982464551926,
-0.05233849585056305,
-0.1483321338891983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18067v1 | Exploring Energy-Based Models for Out-of-Distribution Detection in Dialect Identification | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | 2024-06-26T04:52:48 | Yaqian Hao, Chenguang Hu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | The diverse nature of dialects presents challenges for models trained on
specific linguistic patterns, rendering them susceptible to errors when
confronted with unseen or out-of-distribution (OOD) data. This study introduces
a novel margin-enhanced joint energy model (MEJEM) tailored specifically for
OOD detection in dialects. By integrating a generative model and the energy
margin loss, our approach aims to enhance the robustness of dialect
identification systems. Furthermore, we explore two OOD scores for OOD dialect
detection, and our findings conclusively demonstrate that the energy score
outperforms the softmax score. Leveraging Sharpness-Aware Minimization to
optimize the training process of the joint model, we enhance model
generalization by minimizing both loss and sharpness. Experiments conducted on
dialect identification tasks validate the efficacy of Energy-Based Models and
provide valuable insights into their performance. | [
-0.3341125547885895,
-0.560738205909729,
0.5992318987846375,
-0.3250647783279419,
-0.17976416647434235,
-0.16956953704357147,
-0.6793491840362549,
-0.28481268882751465,
0.38066917657852173,
0.7446764707565308,
-0.4853307008743286,
-0.5280337333679199,
-0.19800330698490143,
-0.16529318690299988,
-0.00951934140175581,
0.45913252234458923,
0.29971832036972046,
0.016629934310913086,
0.006090594921261072,
-0.31236907839775085,
-0.31135404109954834,
-0.524814784526825,
-0.11831535398960114,
-0.3330029845237732,
0.015294540673494339,
0.3449121117591858,
0.6959354877471924,
0.5543982982635498,
0.36263659596443176,
0.33284106850624084,
-0.0555751770734787,
-0.05360347032546997,
-0.389679491519928,
0.07070238888263702,
-0.20555514097213745,
-0.6569243669509888,
-0.5400218963623047,
-0.08771703392267227,
0.5707565546035767,
1.1309804916381836,
-0.49705770611763,
0.14697761833667755,
-0.08909788727760315,
0.6674504280090332,
-0.974036455154419,
0.14488252997398376,
-0.8970533013343811,
-0.047661781311035156,
-0.7016357183456421,
0.1452753245830536,
-0.664043664932251,
-0.12804624438285828,
-0.22843541204929352,
-0.5703776478767395,
0.36223870515823364,
0.024171432480216026,
0.838188648223877,
-0.1600605547428131,
-0.4009771943092346,
-0.13206063210964203,
-0.6102231740951538,
0.8192448019981384,
-0.8213551640510559,
0.5721285939216614,
0.09283335506916046,
0.37782177329063416,
-0.15419666469097137,
-0.048816390335559845,
-0.7271324396133423,
-0.12260789424180984,
0.10340934991836548,
0.3267471492290497,
-0.1355399191379547,
0.2578290104866028,
0.09403857588768005,
0.36963582038879395,
-0.4152933657169342,
0.03392679989337921,
-0.18941622972488403,
0.035243626683950424,
0.6920055747032166,
0.13073588907718658,
0.03197864443063736,
-0.55291348695755,
-0.409627765417099,
-0.21681228280067444,
-0.41392022371292114,
0.013915915973484516,
0.9834323525428772,
0.824432373046875,
-0.17355622351169586,
0.2772639989852905,
-0.2635672092437744,
0.6236086487770081,
0.2257002294063568,
0.09122292697429657,
0.2691779136657715,
-0.03441069275140762,
-0.23076853156089783,
-0.07455803453922272,
0.6106951832771301,
0.3908125162124634,
-0.01579487882554531,
0.011326265521347523,
-0.4828755557537079,
-0.4237988591194153,
-0.12638531625270844,
-0.38830745220184326,
-0.498991996049881,
-0.3155736029148102,
-0.9203450679779053,
-0.20317555963993073,
0.28888803720474243,
-0.9395154118537903,
-0.5210509896278381,
0.052679575979709625,
0.45758551359176636,
-0.5522706508636475,
-1.244116187095642,
0.23868747055530548,
-0.513830304145813,
-0.0028416423592716455,
-0.17203938961029053,
-1.1332045793533325,
0.3733177185058594,
0.5015748739242554,
0.7165603041648865,
0.25309988856315613,
0.4481998085975647,
-0.18150463700294495,
0.018492547795176506,
-0.4528735280036926,
0.3503735065460205,
-0.7920054197311401,
-0.3677528500556946,
0.007325820159167051,
0.0820668563246727,
-0.33895954489707947,
-0.7442445755004883,
0.3425413966178894,
-0.6230226755142212,
0.05981378257274628,
-0.32391679286956787,
-0.536449134349823,
-0.44332900643348694,
-0.28348416090011597,
-0.9181419014930725,
0.9803867936134338,
0.7297146320343018,
-0.44292184710502625,
0.4668777287006378,
-0.7512664198875427,
-0.01000986248254776,
0.06034756824374199,
0.166765958070755,
-0.3292919397354126,
0.9281428456306458,
-0.15766552090644836,
0.2892945408821106,
-0.30566614866256714,
0.18465755879878998,
-0.5430880784988403,
-0.01175788976252079,
-0.1050635352730751,
-0.7744358777999878,
0.9369982481002808,
0.3510359227657318,
-0.05191241577267647,
-0.3659946918487549,
-1.2094600200653076,
0.07764282822608948,
0.23631437122821808,
-0.2886205315589905,
-0.9049634337425232,
-0.10726765543222427,
0.07951677590608597,
-0.21248359978199005,
0.07541027665138245,
-0.7538444399833679,
0.1465335190296173,
-0.4881093502044678,
-0.013454786501824856,
0.5543262958526611,
-0.0741119533777237,
0.5278719067573547,
-0.2996560335159302,
0.5523993372917175,
-0.2489355504512787,
0.15144386887550354,
-0.029506968334317207,
-0.2623025178909302,
-0.7955765128135681,
-0.3786410391330719,
0.46010106801986694,
0.6142347455024719,
-0.7186277508735657,
0.974122941493988,
-0.2444881647825241,
-0.535017192363739,
-0.3524840176105499,
0.10588183999061584,
0.33027368783950806,
0.5446861982345581,
0.4052795469760895,
-0.46307358145713806,
-0.23293082416057587,
-0.6359289884567261,
-0.5177966952323914,
-0.18077519536018372,
-0.19797533750534058,
0.3100750148296356,
0.14212898910045624,
0.13382205367088318,
1.0593349933624268,
-0.26585063338279724,
-0.11128172278404236,
-0.683085560798645,
-0.02964140474796295,
0.4889903664588928,
0.4453125,
0.8548738956451416,
-0.6503636837005615,
-0.3919045925140381,
0.07588240504264832,
-0.5614895224571228,
-0.4822455942630768,
-0.04392063990235329,
0.07803472131490707,
-0.12469667196273804,
0.34381940960884094,
-0.212563619017601,
0.29291582107543945,
0.4646865427494049,
-0.2591480314731598,
0.3633427917957306,
-0.1309654414653778,
0.17325206100940704,
-0.9828083515167236,
-0.10751788318157196,
0.061891328543424606,
-0.1229904517531395,
-0.7347175478935242,
-0.0598924495279789,
0.25552108883857727,
-0.2910444438457489,
-0.3863790035247803,
0.20680256187915802,
-0.649747371673584,
0.1733737736940384,
0.03511303290724754,
-0.197037935256958,
0.4500032961368561,
0.41514867544174194,
0.13013911247253418,
0.25663718581199646,
0.5077630877494812,
-0.30248215794563293,
0.43983563780784607,
-0.22262851893901825,
-0.5056681632995605,
0.6310000419616699,
-0.24566321074962616,
0.24039120972156525,
-0.17555075883865356,
-0.08807887136936188,
-1.2251228094100952,
-0.5515761971473694,
0.09808957576751709,
-0.1818891316652298,
0.7799411416053772,
-0.6130491495132446,
-0.02028883993625641,
-0.0880182683467865,
-0.3778245747089386,
0.3908224403858185,
0.6189714670181274,
-0.8481565117835999,
0.8808267712593079,
0.3453802764415741,
-0.05195901170372963,
-0.28014734387397766,
-0.3322669565677643,
-0.38737916946411133,
-0.6573976278305054,
-0.7515575885772705,
0.23340465128421783,
0.5561719536781311,
-0.6110790371894836,
-0.06600679457187653,
0.08384554833173752,
-0.0901409164071083,
0.09396380186080933,
0.1693635880947113,
0.009508250281214714,
-0.27729231119155884,
0.6096894145011902,
0.08185579627752304,
0.06023300066590309,
0.10310611128807068,
-0.25483307242393494,
0.5292829275131226,
0.0408753864467144,
-0.5866333842277527,
-0.3010837137699127,
0.8340569138526917,
0.472732275724411,
-0.005334385205060244,
0.7834801077842712,
0.4759928286075592,
-0.22857527434825897,
-0.25726810097694397,
-0.6210523247718811,
-0.09739229828119278,
-0.5804262161254883,
0.46091562509536743,
-0.5658898949623108,
-0.012007061392068863,
0.5691999197006226,
-0.6095561981201172,
-0.48248419165611267,
0.6184642910957336,
0.16018900275230408,
-0.2732601463794708,
0.9205003976821899,
0.9387657046318054,
-0.1331503689289093,
0.835606038570404,
-0.42158788442611694,
0.13804902136325836,
-0.7446885108947754,
-0.06668339669704437,
-0.5222556591033936,
-0.0008214730187319219,
-0.5734095573425293,
-0.35143688321113586,
0.8227383494377136,
0.3054448068141937,
0.2669515013694763,
0.1701064556837082,
-0.35229504108428955,
0.4577408730983734,
0.6741584539413452,
0.3055085241794586,
-0.13100580871105194,
-0.17979499697685242,
-0.08192900568246841,
0.21143218874931335,
-0.7137952446937561,
-0.3102051615715027,
1.1274069547653198,
0.2555147409439087,
0.8892820477485657,
0.34153851866722107,
0.7122151255607605,
0.33975154161453247,
-0.04954399913549423,
-0.5293785929679871,
0.4762432277202606,
-0.12344259768724442,
-0.6101078987121582,
-0.31829363107681274,
-0.5111547708511353,
-0.6621500253677368,
0.15228882431983948,
-0.16845804452896118,
-0.5901048183441162,
0.4777648448944092,
0.21548856794834137,
-0.4237624704837799,
0.705145537853241,
-0.9349410533905029,
0.940278172492981,
-0.22002749145030975,
-0.31323808431625366,
-0.30599334836006165,
-0.59347003698349,
0.2828894257545471,
0.19791869819164276,
0.4371573328971863,
-0.4477784335613251,
0.35877713561058044,
0.787294328212738,
-0.8694750666618347,
0.7420256733894348,
-0.8406789302825928,
-0.001969069242477417,
0.5596336126327515,
-0.22339297831058502,
0.5848965048789978,
-0.2464589923620224,
-0.5870139598846436,
0.5978734493255615,
-0.20930418372154236,
-0.4121781289577484,
-0.5315608978271484,
0.4887216091156006,
-0.46106410026550293,
-0.6614901423454285,
-0.05145560950040817,
-0.28926214575767517,
-0.16146934032440186,
-0.010491152293980122,
0.6164395809173584,
0.7378653883934021,
-0.13349394500255585,
0.04327039793133736,
0.4569852650165558,
-0.2097030133008957,
0.6057063341140747,
0.6539535522460938,
0.11760345101356506,
-0.2867166996002197,
0.9450538754463196,
0.23145931959152222,
0.705141007900238,
0.27149826288223267,
0.41584426164627075,
-0.5583140850067139,
-0.511849045753479,
-0.7284656167030334,
-0.06256088614463806,
-0.7662554383277893,
-0.0926651582121849,
-0.0452885739505291,
0.17771948873996735,
-0.5500088334083557,
-0.06298956274986267,
-0.41072070598602295,
-0.3574393093585968,
-0.1505349576473236,
-0.07737208157777786,
0.38996902108192444,
0.6925532221794128,
-0.5257739424705505,
0.4750564992427826,
-0.5902358293533325,
-0.05953461304306984,
0.07722987979650497,
0.3546956181526184,
-0.25187042355537415,
-0.6037379503250122,
-0.1895926147699356,
-0.07113084197044373,
-0.21388556063175201,
-1.3308308124542236,
0.5811218023300171,
0.5183954834938049,
0.4996800720691681,
0.923456072807312,
0.4709601104259491,
0.32588014006614685,
-0.2003720998764038,
0.7378087639808655,
0.5874147415161133,
-1.2166600227355957,
0.45435741543769836,
-0.40928202867507935,
-0.012007515877485275,
0.5901846289634705,
0.3045143485069275,
-0.23750439286231995,
-0.09667593240737915,
-0.46425721049308777,
-0.8453512191772461,
0.4823925495147705,
-0.41975322365760803,
0.36570119857788086,
-0.06901481002569199,
0.23935076594352722,
0.4529035985469818,
0.10728415846824646,
-0.5996146202087402,
0.1739092320203781,
-0.1746726781129837,
-0.3622966706752777,
0.23828749358654022,
-0.22988896071910858,
0.25732845067977905,
-0.03588755428791046,
0.6539303660392761,
-0.30793482065200806,
0.07119622826576233,
-0.11790397018194199,
-0.12013448774814606,
-0.3957275450229645,
0.4131612479686737,
0.0582764632999897,
0.13160990178585052,
-0.4415190815925598,
0.11552328616380692,
0.26822203397750854,
-0.27539509534835815,
0.26084816455841064,
-0.14971423149108887,
0.1801503598690033,
0.3888840973377228,
0.49091488122940063,
0.6260072588920593,
-0.22476674616336823,
-0.45468980073928833,
0.6138542890548706,
0.23043204843997955,
0.16352680325508118,
-0.2807547152042389,
0.3845382630825043,
-0.3357667624950409,
0.3904125690460205,
0.3579977750778198,
0.38325244188308716,
0.517505943775177,
-0.6419030427932739,
-0.23527507483959198,
0.8572978377342224,
-0.6311764121055603,
-0.6564807295799255,
0.32357287406921387,
0.5862298011779785,
-0.22617805004119873,
0.4082075357437134,
-0.45813798904418945,
-0.5372632741928101,
0.7008077502250671,
0.23192501068115234,
0.7871602773666382,
-0.48030441999435425,
-0.23048940300941467,
-0.10018033534288406,
0.10320486128330231,
0.28126731514930725,
0.5290701985359192,
-0.38918253779411316,
-0.7979573607444763,
0.010250276885926723,
-0.5551468729972839,
-0.23103509843349457,
0.1938108503818512,
-1.291662573814392,
0.43392476439476013,
-0.04635098576545715,
-0.48654547333717346,
-0.04810209199786186,
-0.06256496906280518,
-0.5029829144477844,
0.08739154040813446,
0.4872964322566986,
0.8730766177177429,
-1.3976787328720093,
0.8245437145233154,
0.3281297981739044,
0.028866419568657875,
-0.8551960587501526,
0.09539681673049927,
0.1908988356590271,
-0.5696097612380981,
0.21788521111011505,
0.12711964547634125,
-0.24465851485729218,
-0.11338583379983902,
-0.17750899493694305,
-0.8504788279533386,
0.8768320083618164,
0.48886924982070923,
-0.8369837403297424,
0.3097923696041107,
0.012202695943415165,
0.16056619584560394,
-0.04815017804503441,
0.6745083928108215,
0.5674269199371338,
0.4998299777507782,
-0.11948506534099579,
-1.067931890487671,
-0.23469805717468262,
-0.12064492702484131,
-0.04511363059282303,
0.5719125866889954,
-0.9183849692344666,
1.1512970924377441,
-0.2735304534435272,
-0.29619333148002625,
0.19782967865467072,
0.42088645696640015,
-0.3812497854232788,
0.5741143226623535,
0.9002753496170044,
0.44899752736091614,
1.011261224746704,
-0.1616736352443695,
0.7540326714515686,
-0.32424184679985046,
0.4140884280204773,
0.6528235077857971,
-0.4875373840332031,
0.7712989449501038,
0.2107435166835785,
-0.20443768799304962,
0.6285327672958374,
0.46681904792785645,
0.3505821228027344,
1.0932197570800781,
0.40554606914520264,
-0.5826508402824402,
-0.43479347229003906,
-0.2931891679763794,
-0.6483749151229858,
0.7560205459594727,
0.7541496157646179,
-0.49476587772369385,
-0.13655848801136017,
0.324642151594162,
-0.04586079716682434,
0.22172914445400238,
-0.4813099801540375,
0.8163592219352722,
-0.368710458278656,
-0.3298705220222473,
0.8585584759712219,
0.12097415328025818,
0.5997405052185059,
-0.6344527006149292,
0.03330891579389572,
-0.24614444375038147,
0.5061327815055847,
-0.027664583176374435,
-0.19664648175239563,
0.242112398147583,
-0.38190388679504395,
-0.521912693977356,
-0.15300047397613525,
0.6927919983863831,
-0.5969484448432922,
-0.5064602494239807,
0.49887657165527344,
0.4270603656768799,
0.18764229118824005,
-0.05214020982384682,
-0.23719094693660736,
0.17733663320541382,
-0.06818114221096039,
-0.2104395627975464,
0.1734006255865097,
0.6214259266853333,
-0.030514206737279892,
0.12537138164043427,
0.42460885643959045,
0.12273333221673965,
0.003827634733170271,
0.24959887564182281,
0.8288617730140686,
-0.4863883852958679,
-0.4127036929130554,
-0.7562569379806519,
0.1281924843788147,
-0.28105026483535767,
-0.2880483865737915,
0.710344135761261,
0.3819514214992523,
0.7299699783325195,
-0.2630501091480255,
1.062529444694519,
-0.004629782401025295,
0.7097659111022949,
-0.7231032848358154,
0.6660008430480957,
-0.5422980785369873,
0.2290845364332199,
-0.18859907984733582,
-0.519616425037384,
0.1812434047460556,
0.3886071741580963,
-0.45897218585014343,
0.16997185349464417,
0.18716366589069366,
0.9370124936103821,
-0.3493252694606781,
0.05019766464829445,
0.6021787524223328,
-0.011550894007086754,
0.17887482047080994,
0.7082340717315674,
0.9875253438949585,
-0.16401079297065735,
0.20674888789653778,
-0.39045214653015137,
-0.43604880571365356,
-0.623794436454773,
-0.8569043278694153,
-0.9267187118530273,
-0.43720853328704834,
-0.1422727108001709,
-0.12465130537748337,
0.1987580507993698,
1.116122841835022,
1.234378457069397,
-0.9816757440567017,
-0.17264249920845032,
-0.0693085640668869,
-0.1328991800546646,
-0.4885585904121399,
-0.29480084776878357,
0.22397790849208832,
-0.132258340716362,
-0.5703546404838562,
0.9314948320388794,
0.4130295217037201,
-0.2533208131790161,
-0.2382049709558487,
0.13011427223682404,
0.060421355068683624,
0.47901174426078796,
0.06556924432516098,
0.14330099523067474,
-0.5447359681129456,
-0.4201529622077942,
-0.14713244140148163,
0.3005761504173279,
-0.008762591518461704,
0.7042694687843323,
-0.6675717234611511,
0.8402438163757324,
0.5137848854064941,
-0.03528544679284096,
-0.009064574725925922,
0.354065477848053,
0.577151894569397,
-1.2385600805282593,
0.48730963468551636,
0.15479029715061188,
0.6839475631713867,
0.42757055163383484,
-0.42592597007751465,
0.3593827486038208,
0.5608273148536682,
-0.17930248379707336,
-0.8055148124694824,
0.1657552570104599,
-0.7161420583724976,
-0.12024400383234024,
1.0314264297485352,
-0.4896767735481262,
-0.3066965341567993,
-0.41730639338493347,
0.013249805197119713,
0.048875924199819565,
-0.5168249011039734,
0.5863326787948608,
0.45749929547309875,
-0.21839122474193573,
0.25014007091522217,
-0.24870988726615906,
0.4368070960044861,
0.4299006462097168,
-0.4532003700733185,
0.12292450666427612,
0.35444363951683044,
0.21380650997161865,
0.49808385968208313,
0.23296967148780823,
0.47857466340065,
0.06118999049067497,
0.29047250747680664,
0.12915484607219696,
-0.10530370473861694,
-0.3911401927471161,
-0.4450451731681824,
0.48771771788597107,
-0.13388590514659882,
-0.6702826619148254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18064v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18064v1 | Evaluating Quality of Answers for Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Strong LLM Is All You Need | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | 2024-06-26T04:49:41 | Yang Wang, Alberto Garcia Hernandez, Roman Kyslyi, Nicholas Kersting | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a comprehensive evaluation of answer quality in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) applications using vRAG-Eval, a novel
grading system that is designed to assess correctness, completeness, and
honesty. We further map the grading of quality aspects aforementioned into a
binary score, indicating an accept or reject decision, mirroring the intuitive
"thumbs-up" or "thumbs-down" gesture commonly used in chat applications. This
approach suits factual business settings where a clear decision opinion is
essential. Our assessment applies vRAG-Eval to two Large Language Models
(LLMs), evaluating the quality of answers generated by a vanilla RAG
application. We compare these evaluations with human expert judgments and find
a substantial alignment between GPT-4's assessments and those of human experts,
reaching 83% agreement on accept or reject decisions. This study highlights the
potential of LLMs as reliable evaluators in closed-domain, closed-ended
settings, particularly when human evaluations require significant resources. | [
-0.3551482558250427,
-0.9080865383148193,
0.5318076610565186,
0.2328311949968338,
-0.23008231818675995,
0.5328658819198608,
0.015956290066242218,
-0.6165512800216675,
0.06911822408437729,
0.3873778283596039,
-0.12275911122560501,
-0.2974819839000702,
-0.4213787913322449,
0.01895238272845745,
-0.27313604950904846,
1.2107220888137817,
0.10870324820280075,
0.23670494556427002,
-0.6639835238456726,
-0.1682881861925125,
-0.5930353999137878,
-0.5961549878120422,
-0.6799030900001526,
-0.5890671610832214,
0.35055628418922424,
0.42192769050598145,
0.7632285952568054,
0.303376704454422,
0.7580037713050842,
0.2604371905326843,
-0.2717185914516449,
0.42616161704063416,
-0.7315320372581482,
0.299388587474823,
-0.5414605736732483,
-0.1960228532552719,
-0.8797455430030823,
0.16373011469841003,
0.394614040851593,
0.5187241435050964,
-0.36308538913726807,
0.7006751894950867,
-0.09437549114227295,
0.6841623187065125,
-0.4886089563369751,
-0.3308737874031067,
-0.7963154315948486,
-0.18928758800029755,
0.18089838325977325,
-0.2857297956943512,
-0.4464164078235626,
-0.7144089341163635,
-0.021493911743164062,
-0.264372318983078,
0.28620123863220215,
-0.007860850542783737,
1.0497493743896484,
0.16106164455413818,
-0.2067423313856125,
-0.42883944511413574,
-0.8721851706504822,
0.9213026165962219,
-0.527262806892395,
0.2549341917037964,
0.4932277202606201,
0.41072434186935425,
-0.2318943440914154,
-0.6861814856529236,
-0.6607958078384399,
-0.3960655927658081,
0.1399175375699997,
0.4224206805229187,
0.05451083183288574,
0.009262037463486195,
0.05113164708018303,
0.5931111574172974,
-0.7365314960479736,
0.054399460554122925,
-0.5570181012153625,
-0.09180143475532532,
0.6809141039848328,
0.21619467437267303,
0.0462862029671669,
-0.23433980345726013,
-0.5886497497558594,
-0.011727983132004738,
-0.7182989716529846,
-0.029697934165596962,
0.48837554454803467,
0.16886062920093536,
0.3844907879829407,
0.7374592423439026,
-0.1930602490901947,
0.897405743598938,
0.20324088633060455,
-0.23101042211055756,
0.1747448444366455,
-0.5672737956047058,
-0.23651333153247833,
-0.2196105569601059,
0.6968371868133545,
0.4772055447101593,
0.06909666210412979,
-0.0073976521380245686,
-0.5058103799819946,
-0.07684366405010223,
0.6539771556854248,
-0.7164562344551086,
0.13597305119037628,
0.38112956285476685,
-0.5327669382095337,
-0.4297407269477844,
-0.09136760234832764,
-0.6570929288864136,
-0.4118362367153168,
-0.3761928081512451,
0.6549910306930542,
-0.17087122797966003,
-0.30534523725509644,
0.021667731925845146,
-0.1046123281121254,
0.6731989979743958,
0.4334094524383545,
-0.516482412815094,
0.37760990858078003,
0.8683781623840332,
0.6132493615150452,
-0.28788548707962036,
-0.0341615229845047,
-0.7995379567146301,
-0.38285893201828003,
-0.4368455708026886,
0.9793849587440491,
-0.510076642036438,
-0.6130940318107605,
-0.15765786170959473,
-0.6237441897392273,
0.2684181332588196,
-0.7861297726631165,
1.0429257154464722,
-0.8701906800270081,
0.33500543236732483,
-0.15171298384666443,
-0.552655041217804,
-0.07048561424016953,
0.5231291055679321,
-0.2779938876628876,
1.147365689277649,
0.3736584782600403,
-0.49656033515930176,
0.4854821562767029,
-0.27074575424194336,
-0.182332381606102,
0.38417312502861023,
-0.05274418368935585,
-0.44686076045036316,
0.3874462842941284,
-0.03390064463019371,
0.2380409687757492,
-0.36217471957206726,
-0.05029093101620674,
-0.2359025478363037,
-0.34598904848098755,
0.5048750042915344,
-0.5353356599807739,
0.45649483799934387,
0.4185255169868469,
0.04676320403814316,
-0.04704435169696808,
-0.8189725279808044,
0.42141011357307434,
-0.08428514748811722,
-0.6289000511169434,
-0.2547852396965027,
-0.06777600944042206,
-0.030755281448364258,
0.3590717911720276,
0.5666942000389099,
-0.6039140820503235,
0.29914620518684387,
-0.2714100778102875,
-0.16159477829933167,
0.9000396728515625,
0.09556939452886581,
0.22561508417129517,
-0.18167833983898163,
0.7852100133895874,
-0.3304888606071472,
0.2928008437156677,
0.25360724329948425,
-0.47545701265335083,
-0.7433602213859558,
-0.08654525130987167,
0.579657256603241,
0.46550318598747253,
-0.8913218379020691,
0.2790217697620392,
-0.35509321093559265,
-0.6906870007514954,
-0.7875761389732361,
0.3083967864513397,
0.6750230193138123,
0.6464009881019592,
0.16644397377967834,
-0.5436418652534485,
-0.2224426120519638,
-0.7757496237754822,
-0.2569954991340637,
-0.6087901592254639,
-0.07233589142560959,
0.3854061961174011,
0.2738310694694519,
-0.1476506143808365,
0.993327260017395,
-0.2501753866672516,
-0.007392462808638811,
-0.17860442399978638,
0.20712397992610931,
0.41602087020874023,
0.055608805269002914,
0.4344791769981384,
-0.9805604815483093,
-0.36437204480171204,
0.14838239550590515,
-0.6717934608459473,
-0.24693627655506134,
0.14152035117149353,
-0.27578628063201904,
0.13037820160388947,
-0.10259242355823517,
-0.561122715473175,
0.2590465247631073,
0.6732451915740967,
-0.5604119896888733,
0.8566170930862427,
-0.29747962951660156,
0.5084490180015564,
-0.8353267312049866,
0.11367938667535782,
-0.000016473639334435575,
-0.5253913998603821,
-0.5716289281845093,
0.21473827958106995,
-0.1762380748987198,
0.16139091551303864,
-0.4718306362628937,
0.6611989736557007,
-0.21282564103603363,
-0.38205260038375854,
-0.43319475650787354,
0.3049708306789398,
0.21585464477539062,
0.08648096770048141,
-0.173845574259758,
1.0465694665908813,
-0.015515272505581379,
-0.5695797204971313,
0.4207841753959656,
0.2789389193058014,
-0.253752738237381,
0.9779716730117798,
-0.7580904960632324,
0.41857218742370605,
0.05222334712743759,
-0.08495163172483444,
-1.05091392993927,
-0.24360576272010803,
-0.1235460564494133,
-1.0118472576141357,
0.47158706188201904,
-0.09279097616672516,
-0.324535071849823,
-0.5289462208747864,
-0.35728850960731506,
0.15772747993469238,
0.7602173686027527,
-0.6110851764678955,
0.4269179701805115,
0.3054260015487671,
-0.25098374485969543,
-0.8491834402084351,
-0.260233610868454,
0.11944611370563507,
-0.041429292410612106,
-0.5790325403213501,
0.015365340746939182,
-0.19436927139759064,
-0.4084879755973816,
0.032123222947120667,
-0.23858802020549774,
-0.23387525975704193,
0.1134440079331398,
0.019058708101511,
0.41115090250968933,
-0.07257748395204544,
-0.11733528226613998,
-0.16146235167980194,
-0.11451134085655212,
-0.05800245329737663,
0.05345676466822624,
0.3422548472881317,
-0.23270434141159058,
-0.43484535813331604,
0.013285728171467781,
0.16997110843658447,
0.7548185586929321,
-0.3080541789531708,
0.5996507406234741,
0.6026716232299805,
-0.14215004444122314,
0.00018417077080812305,
-0.7782022356987,
0.06973113119602203,
-0.4512336850166321,
0.23291903734207153,
-0.3811611533164978,
-0.8856664299964905,
0.4605500102043152,
0.12665148079395294,
0.1461857259273529,
0.44787973165512085,
0.8445314168930054,
-0.1842828392982483,
1.1429647207260132,
0.4835701584815979,
0.1461055874824524,
0.14878520369529724,
-0.1300165355205536,
0.276207834482193,
-0.8785372376441956,
-0.1643202006816864,
-0.597093403339386,
-0.03905279561877251,
-0.5745711922645569,
-0.3185047507286072,
0.379695326089859,
0.43560609221458435,
-0.13215884566307068,
-0.014883849769830704,
-0.8135271668434143,
0.46639585494995117,
0.5419316291809082,
-0.047385770827531815,
0.3355044424533844,
-0.048373088240623474,
0.25085341930389404,
0.17559920251369476,
-0.28632065653800964,
-0.9052911996841431,
1.0609930753707886,
0.38194358348846436,
0.6854637265205383,
0.2905513644218445,
0.7143227458000183,
0.6125748157501221,
0.6434442400932312,
-0.880366861820221,
0.6038482189178467,
-0.010067456401884556,
-0.6670722365379333,
-0.1244286298751831,
-0.6856940984725952,
-0.7675394415855408,
0.3672676980495453,
-0.14349639415740967,
-0.6168713569641113,
-0.038049228489398956,
0.05790732428431511,
-0.34877118468284607,
0.014915239997208118,
-0.8160530924797058,
0.5589157938957214,
-0.38690751791000366,
-0.6084150671958923,
-0.23036925494670868,
-0.2980865240097046,
0.4902702271938324,
-0.2652856111526489,
0.11500976979732513,
-0.11288060992956161,
0.002066749846562743,
0.5926830172538757,
-0.39855384826660156,
0.264596164226532,
-0.2261088490486145,
-0.05169035121798515,
0.6615237593650818,
0.24061647057533264,
0.20166347920894623,
-0.06758300960063934,
-0.45375141501426697,
0.027330003678798676,
-0.055921874940395355,
-0.3695545792579651,
-0.7240713238716125,
0.808992326259613,
-0.8456876873970032,
-0.5647587776184082,
-0.5370071530342102,
-0.08464936167001724,
-0.19789783656597137,
0.12578478455543518,
0.1391981840133667,
0.3411843478679657,
-0.18306468427181244,
-0.02000465802848339,
0.571183979511261,
-0.3283844292163849,
-0.04913346841931343,
0.5994429588317871,
-0.46045762300491333,
-0.5512388348579407,
1.129895806312561,
0.11227110028266907,
0.44644397497177124,
0.12901726365089417,
0.22846956551074982,
-0.4735989272594452,
-0.6549359560012817,
-0.5628247261047363,
0.252998411655426,
-0.717079758644104,
-0.45752042531967163,
-0.358381450176239,
-0.21054494380950928,
-0.18154455721378326,
-0.08439197391271591,
-0.33908137679100037,
-0.4715232849121094,
-0.13705764710903168,
-0.2896818220615387,
0.2766713500022888,
1.0494502782821655,
-0.08944467455148697,
-0.08907418698072433,
-0.8483728170394897,
0.5547293424606323,
0.4599786102771759,
0.5118114948272705,
-0.23944762349128723,
-0.8729125261306763,
-0.26468250155448914,
0.035696301609277725,
-0.6524458527565002,
-0.6596888899803162,
0.3197273313999176,
0.11933068186044693,
0.5614714622497559,
0.04873402416706085,
-0.1668708175420761,
0.549098789691925,
-0.43661433458328247,
1.2204395532608032,
0.13864731788635254,
-0.7032139301300049,
0.34775859117507935,
-0.30115601420402527,
0.11491021513938904,
0.670996904373169,
0.21343189477920532,
-0.2396567314863205,
-0.3708898425102234,
-0.6405611038208008,
-0.8102338910102844,
0.45605984330177307,
0.19557014107704163,
0.2898295223712921,
-0.14014504849910736,
0.5626377463340759,
0.14962056279182434,
0.3303750157356262,
-0.47758376598358154,
-0.2765747010707855,
-0.032067690044641495,
-0.04534333944320679,
0.19111233949661255,
-0.7164711952209473,
0.20306259393692017,
-0.08491867035627365,
0.7324569225311279,
0.14385609328746796,
0.28007975220680237,
0.10168551653623581,
0.1535094529390335,
-0.059546396136283875,
0.43418261408805847,
0.5692124366760254,
1.0544006824493408,
-0.3632522225379944,
0.01576656475663185,
0.23394456505775452,
-0.6028127074241638,
0.32535406947135925,
-0.15737174451351166,
-0.12898953258991241,
0.05548525229096413,
0.15323764085769653,
0.5007755160331726,
-0.3812749981880188,
-0.587059736251831,
0.678236186504364,
-0.3493276536464691,
0.007015622220933437,
-0.2000657618045807,
0.05811750143766403,
-0.25720667839050293,
0.012081781402230263,
0.5707517862319946,
-0.10372502356767654,
0.33536839485168457,
-0.4280678927898407,
0.15979482233524323,
0.39239180088043213,
-0.37456345558166504,
-0.25653645396232605,
0.5629127025604248,
0.2963385581970215,
-0.621009111404419,
0.6353273987770081,
-0.41112372279167175,
-0.5572575926780701,
0.3917883336544037,
0.32428863644599915,
1.0062029361724854,
-0.4380815923213959,
0.297234445810318,
0.2965383231639862,
0.11278259754180908,
0.009514733217656612,
0.39716559648513794,
0.00014714733697474003,
-0.5941216945648193,
-0.8496525287628174,
-1.1780873537063599,
-0.8919254541397095,
-0.013776284642517567,
-0.7666967511177063,
0.11457107961177826,
-0.20445233583450317,
-0.5272266864776611,
-0.17859439551830292,
0.02284787781536579,
-0.835102379322052,
0.40444105863571167,
0.0027022676076740026,
0.5500867366790771,
-0.5695234537124634,
0.421769380569458,
0.942196786403656,
-0.649078369140625,
-0.6562085747718811,
-0.22820763289928436,
-0.3195933997631073,
-0.6504829525947571,
0.8646558523178101,
-0.07589229941368103,
-0.3917820453643799,
-0.14455538988113403,
-0.5336215496063232,
-0.5931137800216675,
0.867958128452301,
0.2831454873085022,
-0.14635434746742249,
0.14848369359970093,
-0.05732474476099014,
0.9699455499649048,
0.07031359523534775,
0.7636407613754272,
0.5881549715995789,
0.2765501141548157,
0.1413036733865738,
-1.116786003112793,
-0.4615910053253174,
-0.2106722891330719,
0.019876202568411827,
0.04807339608669281,
-0.6952583193778992,
0.5918995141983032,
-0.05892849341034889,
-0.13883493840694427,
0.10579217225313187,
0.7491591572761536,
0.389278769493103,
0.3758890628814697,
0.20735518634319305,
0.5940794944763184,
0.6465969681739807,
-0.11082970350980759,
1.3282994031906128,
-0.13132813572883606,
0.49409857392311096,
0.9279453754425049,
-0.28160426020622253,
1.0949920415878296,
0.4071415960788727,
-0.30780303478240967,
0.4815342426300049,
0.5563972592353821,
0.36587437987327576,
0.35866987705230713,
0.2789187431335449,
-0.3753885328769684,
-0.3442462682723999,
-0.36742308735847473,
-0.03304518759250641,
0.5553491711616516,
0.3869677186012268,
-0.10431800037622452,
-0.15410348773002625,
-0.08847744762897491,
-0.14657539129257202,
0.3542770743370056,
-0.4432428181171417,
0.8701785206794739,
0.18363641202449799,
-0.8022099733352661,
0.7452498078346252,
-0.06771989911794662,
0.47012728452682495,
-0.25964871048927307,
-0.35675570368766785,
-0.35367172956466675,
0.13960367441177368,
-0.3777804672718048,
-1.222823143005371,
0.09525366872549057,
0.4514234960079193,
-0.31942540407180786,
-0.27155381441116333,
0.7396584749221802,
-0.15752506256103516,
-0.46231353282928467,
0.17056997120380402,
0.6703944206237793,
0.42343103885650635,
0.3110654950141907,
-0.7018659710884094,
0.1357012242078781,
-0.032884467393159866,
-0.5162374377250671,
0.23077629506587982,
0.26039639115333557,
0.11953936517238617,
0.6535677909851074,
0.5596696734428406,
0.3222045600414276,
0.027047066017985344,
0.0798998773097992,
0.662479043006897,
-0.4345267415046692,
0.0038405389059334993,
-0.6900687217712402,
0.5606996417045593,
-0.25025907158851624,
-0.1786552369594574,
0.9403495192527771,
0.5472017526626587,
0.7516173720359802,
0.14647439122200012,
0.7830957770347595,
0.06385234743356705,
0.9387246966362,
-0.2873646020889282,
0.6062092185020447,
-0.43187740445137024,
0.23718003928661346,
-0.29405584931373596,
-1.1856927871704102,
-0.05468791350722313,
0.5169745683670044,
-0.38675829768180847,
0.2446015328168869,
0.31474998593330383,
0.5485028028488159,
0.05332689732313156,
-0.440631628036499,
0.5159578323364258,
0.028378568589687347,
0.6541793346405029,
0.27515557408332825,
1.1148688793182373,
-0.4036538600921631,
0.5350890159606934,
0.17521147429943085,
-0.37669795751571655,
-0.20217426121234894,
-0.6988831162452698,
-0.6763800382614136,
-0.3140742778778076,
-0.2731488347053528,
-0.69716477394104,
0.04672464355826378,
0.7921450734138489,
0.304067999124527,
-0.5245420336723328,
-0.19478102028369904,
0.23347222805023193,
0.1797475516796112,
-0.0017224764451384544,
-0.29161545634269714,
0.27287405729293823,
-0.48869726061820984,
-0.5833238959312439,
0.3746803402900696,
0.2560448944568634,
-0.2695716619491577,
-0.45506519079208374,
-0.09703006595373154,
0.06016262248158455,
0.2967703342437744,
0.8629323840141296,
0.2593856751918793,
-0.6257420778274536,
-0.6182462573051453,
0.1396428942680359,
-0.3642916679382324,
0.011656866408884525,
0.387977659702301,
-0.8308686017990112,
0.866997241973877,
0.6893934011459351,
0.7239399552345276,
0.2494058907032013,
0.6408226490020752,
0.42772427201271057,
-0.5685725212097168,
-0.37373289465904236,
0.4665657877922058,
0.0452081635594368,
0.5969915986061096,
-0.17981186509132385,
0.5733480453491211,
-0.10444406419992447,
-1.1368402242660522,
-0.991239607334137,
0.1402961015701294,
-0.9933933615684509,
0.13117071986198425,
1.3894506692886353,
0.013715039938688278,
-0.1938619762659073,
-0.04484480991959572,
-0.46808311343193054,
-0.043855611234903336,
-0.3529714047908783,
0.8383840322494507,
0.6892397999763489,
-0.30731895565986633,
0.08016831427812576,
-0.6468946933746338,
0.3227551281452179,
0.1824129968881607,
-0.6542766094207764,
-0.09338853508234024,
0.7133552432060242,
0.09862536191940308,
0.40258654952049255,
0.7054719924926758,
-0.16538101434707642,
0.44482171535491943,
-0.18034790456295013,
0.3229491412639618,
-0.04444226622581482,
-0.08488475531339645,
-0.4037582278251648,
0.20531333982944489,
0.7170131802558899,
-0.1261313259601593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18060v1 | AdaZeta: Adaptive Zeroth-Order Tensor-Train Adaption for Memory-Efficient Large Language Models Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | 2024-06-26T04:33:13 | Yifan Yang, Kai Zhen, Ershad Banijamal, Athanasios Mouchtaris, Zheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable performance
across various natural language processing tasks, yet it demands more and more
memory as model sizes keep growing. To address this issue, the recently
proposed Memory-efficient Zeroth-order (MeZO) methods attempt to fine-tune LLMs
using only forward passes, thereby avoiding the need for a backpropagation
graph. However, significant performance drops and a high risk of divergence
have limited their widespread adoption. In this paper, we propose the Adaptive
Zeroth-order Tensor-Train Adaption (AdaZeta) framework, specifically designed
to improve the performance and convergence of the ZO methods. To enhance
dimension-dependent ZO estimation accuracy, we introduce a fast-forward,
low-parameter tensorized adapter. To tackle the frequently observed divergence
issue in large-scale ZO fine-tuning tasks, we propose an adaptive query number
schedule that guarantees convergence. Detailed theoretical analysis and
extensive experimental results on Roberta-Large and Llama-2-7B models
substantiate the efficacy of our AdaZeta framework in terms of accuracy, memory
efficiency, and convergence speed. | [
-0.3672163486480713,
-0.7832679152488708,
0.5488281846046448,
0.5572283864021301,
-0.3328595757484436,
-0.08921924978494644,
-0.33459073305130005,
-0.42778345942497253,
0.2347859889268875,
0.3232875466346741,
-0.5167660713195801,
-0.4526382386684418,
-0.42642202973365784,
0.10549627989530563,
0.15157297253608704,
0.6062130331993103,
0.026260310783982277,
0.10752864181995392,
0.34928005933761597,
-0.3217848241329193,
-0.9025935530662537,
-0.07778941839933395,
-0.7659515142440796,
-0.005075738299638033,
0.5398467779159546,
0.6477749943733215,
0.6861968040466309,
0.6798083782196045,
0.22916537523269653,
0.3237723112106323,
-0.1656479835510254,
0.30003806948661804,
-0.4204191267490387,
0.43029940128326416,
-0.1444178968667984,
-0.7631422281265259,
-0.9238418340682983,
-0.4870504140853882,
0.8344557881355286,
0.5059390068054199,
-0.3471190631389618,
0.07569856941699982,
-0.2761768698692322,
0.809466540813446,
-0.8319252133369446,
0.047343574464321136,
-0.7404150366783142,
-0.05361822620034218,
0.0333072803914547,
-0.2245253622531891,
-0.34937670826911926,
-0.2873152792453766,
-0.05576813593506813,
-0.6234270334243774,
0.285487562417984,
-0.11828197538852692,
0.5091845393180847,
0.30718255043029785,
0.07691299915313721,
-0.12701711058616638,
-0.6716234683990479,
0.6517854928970337,
-0.8481655716896057,
0.5156435370445251,
0.17325599491596222,
0.23559734225273132,
-0.2409864366054535,
-0.45559602975845337,
-0.4272034168243408,
0.0518379732966423,
0.4959893524646759,
0.12249521166086197,
-0.2486189901828766,
0.04746909439563751,
0.04801448434591293,
0.2935282289981842,
-0.704055666923523,
0.5807765126228333,
-0.22412221133708954,
0.1065748855471611,
0.46416154503822327,
0.5859158039093018,
0.30300888419151306,
0.42944878339767456,
-0.22447925806045532,
-0.05955074727535248,
-0.7786285877227783,
-0.2491152286529541,
0.27130362391471863,
0.5715808868408203,
0.009639622643589973,
0.0332125648856163,
-0.7657185792922974,
0.9466569423675537,
0.04338856413960457,
0.3829338252544403,
0.276773065328598,
-0.20761464536190033,
-0.3105263113975525,
0.2729546129703522,
0.7081729769706726,
0.25942331552505493,
0.29755884408950806,
-0.34787774085998535,
-0.16020208597183228,
-0.09138182550668716,
0.3056885302066803,
-1.3715988397598267,
-0.1852426826953888,
0.176755890250206,
-0.007026159204542637,
-0.09299348294734955,
-0.47505784034729004,
-0.9454563856124878,
-0.2520045042037964,
-0.14298248291015625,
0.5619542002677917,
-0.40793946385383606,
-0.28705087304115295,
0.49912741780281067,
0.2926045060157776,
0.09703341126441956,
0.6261844038963318,
-1.2382463216781616,
0.246647909283638,
0.6287646889686584,
1.2038090229034424,
0.13288471102714539,
-0.5216127038002014,
-0.7705444097518921,
-0.08182428777217865,
-0.7506512999534607,
0.8223689794540405,
-0.4238366186618805,
-0.06318026036024094,
-0.19072361290454865,
0.020696328952908516,
-0.2500635087490082,
-0.4706091582775116,
0.4757852852344513,
-0.919322669506073,
-0.12763521075248718,
-0.16780135035514832,
-0.35984525084495544,
-0.32899102568626404,
0.19846293330192566,
-0.5142829418182373,
0.643797755241394,
0.16017554700374603,
-0.12472977489233017,
0.2584238052368164,
-0.7940741181373596,
-0.3680865168571472,
-0.1761597841978073,
0.21651434898376465,
-0.5051059126853943,
0.2694578468799591,
0.2700967788696289,
0.6127206683158875,
-0.3577343225479126,
-0.11872469633817673,
-0.45464733242988586,
-0.6354526281356812,
-0.07818640023469925,
-0.45546749234199524,
0.7255194187164307,
0.34843629598617554,
-0.17160171270370483,
0.3429654836654663,
-0.9909175038337708,
0.021108737215399742,
0.1839894950389862,
-0.37110012769699097,
-0.4898970425128937,
-0.003914232831448317,
-0.19418202340602875,
0.019861390814185143,
0.14531110227108002,
-0.4795985519886017,
0.30190181732177734,
-0.5335206389427185,
0.5820898413658142,
0.7976930141448975,
-0.2010589838027954,
0.5097814202308655,
-0.06217074766755104,
0.4379158914089203,
0.08890976756811142,
-0.02967000938951969,
-0.25513339042663574,
-0.4029424488544464,
-0.692368745803833,
-0.32856485247612,
0.3818361461162567,
0.35278958082199097,
-0.4206269383430481,
0.30510640144348145,
-0.7279464602470398,
-0.5753414034843445,
-0.485202819108963,
0.3460964858531952,
0.16105513274669647,
0.2973078489303589,
0.5647952556610107,
-0.2709296941757202,
-0.3590394854545593,
-0.4812527596950531,
-0.020129071548581123,
0.032880086451768875,
-0.12717461585998535,
0.209400475025177,
0.10020121932029724,
-0.09006070345640182,
0.6510372161865234,
-0.6705551147460938,
-0.27111947536468506,
0.04668089374899864,
0.09091879427433014,
0.3404499590396881,
0.43401050567626953,
0.9117311835289001,
-0.5362648963928223,
-0.5691509246826172,
0.017435071989893913,
-0.3916502594947815,
-0.002669458044692874,
0.13243985176086426,
-0.2140990048646927,
0.31258320808410645,
0.3100277781486511,
-0.4721367359161377,
-0.15527670085430145,
0.5772891044616699,
-0.6423793435096741,
0.17979957163333893,
-0.4147860109806061,
-0.10867014527320862,
-1.1989390850067139,
-0.17499691247940063,
-0.1977391093969345,
-0.2232428938150406,
-0.7176917195320129,
-0.16872429847717285,
0.19519561529159546,
0.055105846375226974,
-0.05659869685769081,
0.4298441708087921,
-0.5274238586425781,
-0.02448219619691372,
-0.4759087562561035,
-0.06726741045713425,
0.06439444422721863,
0.4103240370750427,
-0.15932783484458923,
0.9834050536155701,
0.42445826530456543,
-0.8499147295951843,
0.2674247622489929,
0.3999045789241791,
-0.4005671441555023,
0.5151576399803162,
-0.3718699812889099,
0.32973700761795044,
-0.022623170167207718,
-0.11419184505939484,
-1.0009400844573975,
0.16560839116573334,
0.2237362116575241,
-0.5604483485221863,
0.4930652379989624,
-0.4536031484603882,
-0.28737959265708923,
0.1402827501296997,
-0.455120325088501,
0.3272181451320648,
0.3307431638240814,
-0.7019298672676086,
0.6191161274909973,
0.08546285331249237,
-0.4438660144805908,
-0.6760536432266235,
-0.5300925374031067,
0.26048070192337036,
-0.18236008286476135,
-0.44440221786499023,
0.25416338443756104,
-0.24878522753715515,
0.06478987634181976,
-0.08393494039773941,
-0.03967214748263359,
-0.17446540296077728,
0.4386967718601227,
-0.13738411664962769,
0.21059387922286987,
-0.7992814779281616,
0.015145757235586643,
0.09133968502283096,
-0.04249565303325653,
-0.18676325678825378,
-0.2687475383281708,
0.8438043594360352,
-0.22923433780670166,
0.22540691494941711,
-0.09920237958431244,
0.001230692840181291,
0.7920730113983154,
-0.20966920256614685,
0.8647291660308838,
0.6933685541152954,
-0.20466437935829163,
-0.3691624104976654,
-0.5283044576644897,
-0.0038940543308854103,
-0.47010982036590576,
0.6762109398841858,
-0.44172394275665283,
-0.7123432159423828,
0.6451023817062378,
0.12950052320957184,
0.09923896193504333,
0.2716733515262604,
0.8876416683197021,
0.38667723536491394,
0.8054761290550232,
0.46016252040863037,
-0.4290392994880676,
0.8586292266845703,
-0.14950746297836304,
-0.037378277629613876,
-1.025713324546814,
0.2849666178226471,
-0.4748246371746063,
-0.33349642157554626,
-0.4565415382385254,
-0.23515111207962036,
-0.11266931891441345,
-0.0017724419012665749,
-0.37654346227645874,
0.3784344792366028,
-0.2462952584028244,
0.37985074520111084,
0.35544684529304504,
0.03702276200056076,
0.4343220889568329,
0.00027285906253382564,
0.2778250277042389,
0.24774956703186035,
-0.6735497117042542,
0.03558505326509476,
1.0201574563980103,
0.1416928470134735,
0.8069901466369629,
0.3501995801925659,
0.31100204586982727,
0.12963145971298218,
0.29308488965034485,
-0.9143349528312683,
0.3418484926223755,
-0.2630007266998291,
-0.4421352446079254,
-0.5930228233337402,
-0.4954017102718353,
-0.9500942826271057,
0.6499660611152649,
0.01966109313070774,
-0.6768597960472107,
0.5224243998527527,
0.08212863653898239,
-0.7292566895484924,
0.3046586513519287,
-0.8032075762748718,
0.6730813384056091,
-0.11436134576797485,
-0.5863812565803528,
-0.42266249656677246,
-0.3260587155818939,
0.051726289093494415,
0.04409768432378769,
-0.14741891622543335,
-0.5687359571456909,
-0.19255425035953522,
0.6686165928840637,
-0.2937385141849518,
0.7285448312759399,
-0.40077558159828186,
-0.15563558042049408,
0.0834963396191597,
0.26575854420661926,
0.5637661814689636,
-0.009152382612228394,
-0.33808544278144836,
0.19996269047260284,
-0.06996578723192215,
-0.4174116849899292,
-0.5796689391136169,
0.8270890116691589,
-0.7118583917617798,
-0.455179363489151,
-0.1189846619963646,
-0.8411471843719482,
-0.531596302986145,
0.48515191674232483,
-0.12785997986793518,
0.44570794701576233,
-0.1454232782125473,
0.24355466663837433,
0.6199809312820435,
-0.05926791951060295,
0.5138059854507446,
1.0470598936080933,
0.06073892116546631,
-0.5848118662834167,
1.0738269090652466,
0.41118890047073364,
0.13005965948104858,
0.48810842633247375,
0.17161259055137634,
-0.192301407456398,
-1.0597032308578491,
-0.9146448373794556,
0.0187674667686224,
-0.41090914607048035,
-0.5380098223686218,
-0.4044288992881775,
0.119143545627594,
-0.36267054080963135,
0.0731099545955658,
-0.6288781762123108,
-0.37503084540367126,
-0.3387347161769867,
0.05707106366753578,
0.7823055982589722,
0.29826995730400085,
0.06479372829198837,
0.45364972949028015,
-0.6804373264312744,
0.23992739617824554,
0.16104865074157715,
0.8378868699073792,
0.08462575823068619,
-0.7747982740402222,
-0.3945464789867401,
-0.06947094202041626,
-0.05843614414334297,
-0.4353598654270172,
0.315211683511734,
0.3000152111053467,
0.23855407536029816,
0.346431702375412,
0.09224322438240051,
0.8703106641769409,
-0.691534161567688,
0.11699805408716202,
-0.07282814383506775,
-0.5424110293388367,
0.23985138535499573,
-0.5513912439346313,
0.17927037179470062,
0.6026760339736938,
0.1433800309896469,
-0.3296602964401245,
0.09298831969499588,
-0.21541765332221985,
-0.8533152937889099,
0.9368076324462891,
-0.046591416001319885,
0.4410160779953003,
0.222488135099411,
0.5884329676628113,
-0.13556161522865295,
0.005637601483613253,
-0.16192448139190674,
-0.06195719167590141,
-0.12010100483894348,
-0.42630115151405334,
-0.32051342725753784,
-0.451765775680542,
0.21959306299686432,
-0.016538918018341064,
0.6926302313804626,
-0.5240370035171509,
0.1996789425611496,
0.11005789041519165,
-0.22216318547725677,
-0.35708117485046387,
0.3315924108028412,
0.7694900631904602,
0.7662595510482788,
-0.47554317116737366,
-0.19117671251296997,
0.46294501423835754,
-0.7224973440170288,
0.10279767215251923,
0.3115679919719696,
-0.3479408919811249,
-0.09328267723321915,
-0.08552789688110352,
1.04252290725708,
0.3759079575538635,
-0.6534518599510193,
0.2417701929807663,
-0.2694007456302643,
-0.05071815103292465,
-0.046506721526384354,
0.35796916484832764,
0.2120070457458496,
0.43446585536003113,
0.0983443558216095,
-0.005094073712825775,
0.1329633742570877,
-0.3842662274837494,
-0.12888112664222717,
0.38507094979286194,
-0.3644726872444153,
-0.49502551555633545,
0.6294885873794556,
-0.03696059063076973,
-0.2609023153781891,
0.5259861946105957,
0.24673350155353546,
-0.23681512475013733,
0.47972893714904785,
0.6354982256889343,
0.912289023399353,
-0.6563370823860168,
-0.2492614984512329,
0.31243112683296204,
0.1397295594215393,
-0.2968396246433258,
0.38135474920272827,
-0.09574203938245773,
-1.0067692995071411,
-0.4498150944709778,
-0.758033037185669,
-0.4175964891910553,
0.13422498106956482,
-0.6705408692359924,
0.14886482059955597,
-0.7286745309829712,
-0.013765955343842506,
0.010174363851547241,
0.08438882231712341,
-0.2735247015953064,
0.22276556491851807,
0.11655377596616745,
0.9724555611610413,
-0.624401867389679,
0.9338944554328918,
0.6388529539108276,
-0.29238948225975037,
-0.4889760911464691,
-0.07748741656541824,
-0.4691779315471649,
-1.0420001745224,
0.03448030725121498,
0.024478670209646225,
-0.3350068926811218,
0.4311966598033905,
-0.16224879026412964,
-0.9249192476272583,
1.2343021631240845,
0.7068460583686829,
-0.653954029083252,
0.053553029894828796,
-0.17184092104434967,
0.5513178706169128,
-0.14300242066383362,
0.09228715300559998,
0.5553581714630127,
0.14749515056610107,
0.06789228320121765,
-0.6081088781356812,
0.21940605342388153,
-0.21233324706554413,
0.22687116265296936,
0.4242289662361145,
-1.0128498077392578,
0.7637874484062195,
-0.23871800303459167,
0.12246439605951309,
0.25434011220932007,
0.7275689840316772,
0.088881716132164,
0.04452868923544884,
0.5594866871833801,
0.5419791340827942,
0.6197192668914795,
0.05094663053750992,
0.6801988482475281,
-0.26477208733558655,
0.3589182198047638,
1.180133581161499,
-0.2473147213459015,
1.037291407585144,
0.219806969165802,
-0.2333836853504181,
0.3570455014705658,
0.5169602632522583,
-0.11625552177429199,
0.47224441170692444,
-0.023682760074734688,
-0.12878663837909698,
-0.18570102751255035,
0.2067176252603531,
-0.3600289821624756,
0.4278581142425537,
0.4551074802875519,
-0.16705600917339325,
-0.31959888339042664,
-0.31511229276657104,
0.14865539968013763,
-0.25235968828201294,
-0.5582423210144043,
0.7959682941436768,
-0.02693982794880867,
-0.4813414216041565,
0.8295192718505859,
0.13731783628463745,
0.5583938360214233,
-0.47965922951698303,
-0.0008325654780492187,
-0.39386940002441406,
0.6690985560417175,
-0.0028246024157851934,
-0.41598960757255554,
0.14009401202201843,
-0.08426358550786972,
-0.22095413506031036,
0.17715074121952057,
0.5058370232582092,
-0.3413752019405365,
-0.4168684482574463,
0.4239029884338379,
0.33541154861450195,
-0.30962425470352173,
-0.21749301254749298,
-0.5556334257125854,
0.005509538110345602,
-0.4256378412246704,
-0.5542852878570557,
0.6024104356765747,
0.5098785758018494,
-0.07550239562988281,
0.5737589597702026,
0.6143556237220764,
0.16826945543289185,
0.24448876082897186,
0.10659942030906677,
0.7141317129135132,
-0.5813508033752441,
-0.705213189125061,
-1.0594265460968018,
-0.037664443254470825,
0.28946924209594727,
-0.18943212926387787,
0.5271927714347839,
0.5960895419120789,
0.5877681374549866,
-0.0413992702960968,
0.3968432545661926,
0.06491369754076004,
0.3301783800125122,
-0.7613411545753479,
0.812265932559967,
-0.6277186870574951,
0.18100017309188843,
-0.053933773189783096,
-0.7821112275123596,
-0.500009298324585,
0.5404176115989685,
-0.39607560634613037,
0.014973638579249382,
0.13775664567947388,
0.787601113319397,
-0.2337275594472885,
-0.05436219274997711,
0.46464917063713074,
0.7017439603805542,
0.2932622730731964,
0.558323085308075,
0.6254112124443054,
-0.5667962431907654,
0.47745630145072937,
-0.10425125062465668,
-0.07637470215559006,
-0.4753095507621765,
-0.5695118308067322,
-0.6477718353271484,
-0.3234894275665283,
-0.03793776035308838,
-0.3183133602142334,
0.3800772726535797,
0.9248087406158447,
0.5492947697639465,
-0.9189023971557617,
-0.19895623624324799,
-0.19503775238990784,
0.023855717852711678,
-0.15447618067264557,
-0.14621803164482117,
0.5405740737915039,
-0.6925481557846069,
-0.9706356525421143,
0.5233612060546875,
0.4200616478919983,
-0.13495692610740662,
0.0913233831524849,
-0.0341474749147892,
-0.07942844927310944,
0.03040996752679348,
0.6192615628242493,
0.4086633622646332,
-0.19862118363380432,
-0.13871872425079346,
-0.04232580587267876,
0.12024148553609848,
0.5486999750137329,
0.58685302734375,
-0.544626772403717,
0.550474226474762,
0.5321833491325378,
0.8382591605186462,
0.43750739097595215,
-0.011630970053374767,
0.7238283753395081,
-0.2496476173400879,
0.28160378336906433,
0.056286755949258804,
0.465745210647583,
0.2669799327850342,
-0.356006383895874,
0.5692136287689209,
0.13573507964611053,
-0.27021047472953796,
-0.8933465480804443,
-0.12762723863124847,
-0.8919565081596375,
-0.24136540293693542,
0.9245803356170654,
-0.11210382729768753,
-0.25590890645980835,
-0.08779662847518921,
0.00780326034873724,
0.2233065366744995,
-0.33635997772216797,
0.9456132054328918,
0.37688571214675903,
-0.03400806710124016,
-0.13733533024787903,
-0.7135579586029053,
0.27336475253105164,
0.5919997096061707,
-0.6131267547607422,
0.4084494709968567,
0.30927029252052307,
0.6773876547813416,
-0.03678886219859123,
0.7005035877227783,
-0.06009630113840103,
0.4302339553833008,
-0.07018846273422241,
-0.15754176676273346,
-0.3493223190307617,
-0.3998861014842987,
-0.5748084187507629,
0.0108247185125947,
0.3763837516307831,
-0.34542834758758545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18616v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18616v1 | Towards Large Language Model Aided Program Refinement | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | 2024-06-26T04:29:27 | Yufan Cai, Zhe Hou, Xiaokun Luan, David Miguel Sanan Baena, Yun Lin, Jun Sun, Jin Song Dong | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, K.6.3 | Program refinement involves correctness-preserving transformations from
formal high-level specification statements into executable programs.
Traditional verification tool support for program refinement is highly
interactive and lacks automation. On the other hand, the emergence of large
language models (LLMs) enables automatic code generations from informal natural
language specifications. However, code generated by LLMs is often unreliable.
Moreover, the opaque procedure from specification to code provided by LLM is an
uncontrolled black box. We propose LLM4PR, a tool that combines formal program
refinement techniques with informal LLM-based methods to (1) transform the
specification to preconditions and postconditions, (2) automatically build
prompts based on refinement calculus, (3) interact with LLM to generate code,
and finally, (4) verify that the generated code satisfies the conditions of
refinement calculus, thus guaranteeing the correctness of the code. We have
implemented our tool using GPT4, Coq, and Coqhammer, and evaluated it on the
HumanEval and EvalPlus datasets. | [
-0.3703155815601349,
-0.7125861048698425,
0.599679172039032,
0.23679372668266296,
-0.13188403844833374,
0.23088470101356506,
-0.5357179045677185,
-0.43080538511276245,
-0.3181707262992859,
0.685368001461029,
-0.48756957054138184,
-0.5748106241226196,
-0.18132837116718292,
0.42533230781555176,
-0.10585217922925949,
0.7865334749221802,
-0.4637891352176666,
-0.1169004961848259,
-0.19262847304344177,
0.13380931317806244,
-0.3555741310119629,
-0.4383258819580078,
-0.4189819097518921,
-0.4570245146751404,
0.08438613265752792,
0.4598751366138458,
0.4285196363925934,
0.24693048000335693,
0.4411405920982361,
0.40736788511276245,
0.4082369804382324,
0.3461625874042511,
-0.5973693132400513,
0.04850038141012192,
-0.13787350058555603,
-0.3354479968547821,
-0.43926119804382324,
0.005196908488869667,
0.44298750162124634,
0.2784801423549652,
-0.22234435379505157,
0.35100048780441284,
0.20185652375221252,
0.3743009865283966,
-0.5070652961730957,
0.24431265890598297,
-0.6734358668327332,
-0.09792778640985489,
-0.2315441220998764,
-0.49379071593284607,
-0.3790059983730316,
-0.6147503852844238,
-0.27059876918792725,
-0.5028142929077148,
0.2344263643026352,
0.19542153179645538,
0.9998785853385925,
0.3922758400440216,
-0.21353955566883087,
-0.16628803312778473,
-0.9030375480651855,
0.8418336510658264,
-1.052289366722107,
0.3773350417613983,
0.23786601424217224,
0.4726714789867401,
-0.4876340925693512,
-0.8860849738121033,
-0.6379112005233765,
-0.5536497235298157,
-0.03249043971300125,
-0.2728717029094696,
-0.06212204694747925,
0.27267640829086304,
0.6691173911094666,
0.5722011923789978,
-0.5104086399078369,
0.08620503544807434,
-0.4659067690372467,
-0.463775098323822,
0.669265627861023,
0.02251509577035904,
0.2168353646993637,
0.13432861864566803,
-0.12867702543735504,
0.22276926040649414,
-1.1178345680236816,
-0.14266405999660492,
0.4519653916358948,
0.12285475432872772,
-0.07973983883857727,
0.5218297839164734,
-0.19364149868488312,
0.7058307528495789,
-0.025366632267832756,
-0.23943082988262177,
0.29173076152801514,
-0.47082462906837463,
-0.2939581274986267,
-0.1659095585346222,
0.6093559861183167,
0.2609543204307556,
0.29257866740226746,
0.03996643051505089,
-0.5983712077140808,
0.03990865871310234,
0.2381788194179535,
-0.8566869497299194,
-0.35740503668785095,
0.35199910402297974,
-0.2493107169866562,
-0.15089616179466248,
-0.06374522298574448,
-0.4286406338214874,
-0.09489678591489792,
-0.7157973647117615,
0.2694721519947052,
-0.3102363049983978,
-0.15914463996887207,
0.26077699661254883,
0.25799834728240967,
0.39748746156692505,
0.5408665537834167,
-0.5289419889450073,
0.16741468012332916,
0.8642200827598572,
0.49311086535453796,
0.25422435998916626,
0.002832998987287283,
-0.6500117778778076,
0.16307613253593445,
-0.4681106209754944,
0.4731350541114807,
-0.48197856545448303,
-0.1728299856185913,
0.08666900545358658,
0.07687560468912125,
0.4123624861240387,
-0.47433722019195557,
0.5329307913780212,
-0.5261371731758118,
0.14613157510757446,
-0.1303301751613617,
-0.42327913641929626,
-0.1303204894065857,
0.5488053560256958,
-0.4319029152393341,
1.2509536743164062,
0.2589552402496338,
-0.579537034034729,
0.1377798169851303,
-0.6379649639129639,
-0.1882336586713791,
0.23380497097969055,
-0.4456685781478882,
-0.5177584886550903,
-0.07583440840244293,
0.2367343306541443,
0.3217396140098572,
-0.48515784740448,
0.35945555567741394,
-0.39718523621559143,
-0.46655941009521484,
-0.06808934360742569,
-0.14416399598121643,
0.598796546459198,
0.22679035365581512,
-0.4548678696155548,
0.30810242891311646,
-0.7501700520515442,
0.2924259305000305,
-0.04155350849032402,
-0.3379652202129364,
-0.002500272123143077,
-0.30070602893829346,
-0.3563566207885742,
0.3436051905155182,
0.44711798429489136,
-0.5762845873832703,
0.4436538517475128,
-0.43417924642562866,
0.5680020451545715,
0.5981200933456421,
0.06178683415055275,
0.2920563220977783,
-0.1873960793018341,
0.7431609034538269,
-0.3860291838645935,
0.14517343044281006,
-0.1907760351896286,
-0.3447725474834442,
-0.7754400968551636,
-0.2239171415567398,
0.314302921295166,
0.4713718891143799,
-0.880545437335968,
0.5640881657600403,
0.0827912762761116,
-0.3153465688228607,
-0.509886622428894,
0.28980696201324463,
0.35300910472869873,
0.45594340562820435,
0.2763683795928955,
-0.07568269222974777,
-0.8064860105514526,
-0.9185865521430969,
0.21263886988162994,
-0.1314990520477295,
-0.16889594495296478,
0.20034433901309967,
0.3994424343109131,
-0.4861333668231964,
0.7281373739242554,
-0.3368842601776123,
0.11344097554683685,
-0.1775299310684204,
0.3231811225414276,
0.20063957571983337,
0.4774685502052307,
0.26025810837745667,
-0.31919941306114197,
-0.15298117697238922,
-0.09369375556707382,
-0.40499821305274963,
-0.7016164660453796,
-0.019189784303307533,
-0.1088680550456047,
0.19968388974666595,
0.893466055393219,
-0.23537954688072205,
0.2814706563949585,
0.7052637338638306,
-0.03691098466515541,
0.9331037402153015,
-0.5067046284675598,
0.12142367660999298,
-0.6838094592094421,
0.45093122124671936,
-0.21151290833950043,
-0.4728635847568512,
-0.31555360555648804,
0.42803359031677246,
0.1634143590927124,
-0.25785499811172485,
-0.1484566181898117,
0.4446668326854706,
-0.7017585039138794,
-0.2259533405303955,
-0.25039321184158325,
-0.04278036579489708,
0.16419565677642822,
0.2584259510040283,
-0.053185272961854935,
0.7237048745155334,
0.4779529869556427,
-0.5280905961990356,
0.49496200680732727,
-0.08500625193119049,
-0.2844424843788147,
0.32080596685409546,
-0.7223360538482666,
0.40094277262687683,
-0.05895203351974487,
0.43760213255882263,
-0.8864347338676453,
-0.1118197962641716,
0.19047650694847107,
-0.11184676736593246,
0.281074196100235,
-0.354731947183609,
-0.6504436731338501,
-0.5293601155281067,
-0.2694873809814453,
0.28992438316345215,
0.576270580291748,
-0.39779186248779297,
0.582973301410675,
-0.0750214084982872,
-0.3253055810928345,
-0.5030790567398071,
-0.4450807273387909,
0.13138572871685028,
0.14237472414970398,
-0.7672963738441467,
0.3595886528491974,
-0.2746801972389221,
-0.3460529148578644,
-0.20303091406822205,
0.1299276351928711,
0.0798766016960144,
-0.03561941906809807,
0.353188157081604,
0.4170125126838684,
-0.2560805380344391,
0.0349886529147625,
-0.13979284465312958,
-0.1124950423836708,
-0.05150432139635086,
-0.1670583337545395,
0.5764814615249634,
-0.2665281593799591,
-0.5090649127960205,
-0.33663269877433777,
0.07162743806838989,
0.5653526782989502,
-0.777023434638977,
0.12561549246311188,
0.6510499119758606,
-0.16353662312030792,
-0.5667601823806763,
-0.7433491945266724,
-0.28035375475883484,
-0.5432899594306946,
0.1707850694656372,
-0.44183844327926636,
-1.041879415512085,
0.4047968089580536,
-0.3418585956096649,
0.4720531105995178,
0.10029511898756027,
0.7467082142829895,
0.46298685669898987,
0.8790586590766907,
0.7079041600227356,
0.17826564610004425,
0.21605020761489868,
-0.156284898519516,
0.32527515292167664,
-0.6411678194999695,
-0.13580629229545593,
-0.70795077085495,
-0.2386624664068222,
-0.32591164112091064,
-0.6407008767127991,
0.01961635611951351,
0.08789282292127609,
-0.3678777813911438,
0.17911387979984283,
-0.44581034779548645,
0.5925405621528625,
0.3262917697429657,
-0.17337042093276978,
0.21615535020828247,
-0.16838593780994415,
-0.3663158416748047,
0.044675521552562714,
-0.33482125401496887,
-0.7465006709098816,
1.0276631116867065,
0.5943139791488647,
0.6855317950248718,
0.030327124521136284,
0.9608295559883118,
-0.005495130550116301,
0.7133044004440308,
-0.6102709770202637,
0.6754204034805298,
0.1954445093870163,
-0.3598158657550812,
-0.23802143335342407,
-0.5524528622627258,
-0.5886399745941162,
-0.12819957733154297,
-0.1173308864235878,
-0.49954065680503845,
-0.00342688150703907,
0.41278836131095886,
-0.4981725215911865,
-0.022317714989185333,
-0.5867311954498291,
0.730372965335846,
-0.14541316032409668,
-0.467388778924942,
-0.2231772243976593,
-0.3448128402233124,
0.6473038196563721,
-0.31371670961380005,
0.27720046043395996,
-0.30631330609321594,
-0.009844208136200905,
0.27575650811195374,
-0.7228986620903015,
0.6221268177032471,
-0.265263170003891,
-0.5825705528259277,
0.2843272089958191,
0.4501417279243469,
0.8343328237533569,
0.057661738246679306,
-0.228463277220726,
-0.10058917105197906,
-0.04214487597346306,
-0.21227876842021942,
-0.6249622702598572,
0.720242977142334,
-0.5327746868133545,
-0.6571153402328491,
-0.026753196492791176,
-0.3418811857700348,
-0.24946682155132294,
0.31369832158088684,
-0.014183061197400093,
0.4481784403324127,
-0.014199255965650082,
-0.08386799693107605,
0.5183494687080383,
-0.36652475595474243,
0.19006477296352386,
0.6805461645126343,
-0.5246931314468384,
-0.14809569716453552,
0.45672670006752014,
-0.22552408277988434,
0.09434466063976288,
0.18229272961616516,
0.23126909136772156,
-0.30465754866600037,
-0.7568973302841187,
-0.19737043976783752,
0.23247919976711273,
-0.5819825530052185,
-0.3526100814342499,
0.01351225096732378,
-0.13130798935890198,
-0.40237027406692505,
-0.2120891958475113,
-0.24467132985591888,
-0.16226117312908173,
0.07472223043441772,
-0.06233133003115654,
0.20457275211811066,
0.7210814952850342,
0.00026714333216659725,
-0.05496344715356827,
-0.9182584881782532,
0.3426673412322998,
0.20510074496269226,
0.43515098094940186,
-0.24123787879943848,
-0.5539588928222656,
-0.021258564665913582,
-0.03729519993066788,
-0.28218260407447815,
-0.525096595287323,
0.2322862595319748,
0.13761620223522186,
0.43820035457611084,
0.3780777156352997,
0.1678185909986496,
0.5318388938903809,
-0.773386538028717,
0.7237672209739685,
0.09247234463691711,
-0.8653416037559509,
0.36238354444503784,
-0.24714753031730652,
0.3522007167339325,
0.544814944267273,
0.2178894728422165,
-0.461850106716156,
-0.6302890777587891,
-0.5146999955177307,
-0.6131747961044312,
0.4180701673030853,
0.022932952269911766,
-0.016068974509835243,
0.18319071829319,
0.5528612732887268,
0.07900190353393555,
0.13121040165424347,
-0.6014977693557739,
0.25388190150260925,
-0.08667250722646713,
-0.23055791854858398,
-0.04003477469086647,
-0.28360792994499207,
-0.2743998169898987,
-0.12946538627147675,
0.7443402409553528,
-0.132309690117836,
0.019563447684049606,
0.029469281435012817,
0.12241511791944504,
-0.237521693110466,
0.39761045575141907,
0.6027606725692749,
0.900733232498169,
-0.2068823277950287,
0.323250412940979,
-0.0399535670876503,
-0.15089932084083557,
0.24032752215862274,
0.15543268620967865,
-0.2019633799791336,
-0.11633586138486862,
0.26607730984687805,
0.43126845359802246,
0.20411178469657898,
-0.6969122886657715,
0.4793851375579834,
-0.0897635966539383,
-0.31076574325561523,
-0.35036948323249817,
0.09199949353933334,
-0.014460532926023006,
0.2735157012939453,
0.01297751534730196,
-0.14283625781536102,
-0.024332184344530106,
-0.49125298857688904,
0.3893348276615143,
0.26886945962905884,
0.08390370011329651,
-0.34026584029197693,
0.39485064148902893,
0.5308349132537842,
-0.1989191621541977,
0.724616527557373,
-0.4745549261569977,
-0.4427134394645691,
0.23075450956821442,
0.5835000872612,
0.8095588088035583,
-0.3377775549888611,
0.049460336565971375,
0.5767760872840881,
0.38521212339401245,
-0.1353004276752472,
0.5365995764732361,
0.059939268976449966,
-0.6349303126335144,
-0.9084039330482483,
-0.7041240334510803,
-0.30275312066078186,
0.4886554181575775,
-0.11252199113368988,
0.5142896771430969,
-0.814791738986969,
-0.09062600135803223,
-0.1255519539117813,
-0.032641153782606125,
-0.590027928352356,
-0.041290171444416046,
0.25161242485046387,
0.8734523057937622,
-0.6393172144889832,
0.861216127872467,
0.621044933795929,
-0.24553857743740082,
-1.1331175565719604,
-0.026181815192103386,
0.02515868842601776,
-0.7645511627197266,
0.8070133924484253,
0.17346905171871185,
-0.23525771498680115,
-0.014805419370532036,
-0.8117438554763794,
-0.7445033192634583,
0.8722227811813354,
0.5338769555091858,
-0.9893717765808105,
-0.09934188425540924,
0.13591843843460083,
0.48757609724998474,
-0.1331494301557541,
0.17078323662281036,
0.45381417870521545,
0.6046959161758423,
0.25393158197402954,
-1.1582180261611938,
0.2647433876991272,
-0.21314717829227448,
0.020672064274549484,
0.35066255927085876,
-0.21675816178321838,
0.6684232950210571,
-0.28453052043914795,
-0.20613442361354828,
0.07094226032495499,
0.5352325439453125,
0.44609758257865906,
-0.06530968844890594,
0.2558700144290924,
0.5864875912666321,
0.8427582383155823,
-0.09203165024518967,
0.8995335102081299,
-0.6297100782394409,
0.13364872336387634,
1.0674903392791748,
-0.555609941482544,
0.8150781393051147,
0.3021697402000427,
-0.20695394277572632,
0.5562264919281006,
0.4002046287059784,
-0.17732176184654236,
0.014052324928343296,
0.7070701718330383,
-0.3401452898979187,
-0.18959426879882812,
0.21310298144817352,
-0.32140862941741943,
0.32318753004074097,
0.3472532629966736,
-0.24360845983028412,
-0.3974253237247467,
-0.2586226165294647,
0.0062331887893378735,
0.023296739906072617,
-0.4364515542984009,
0.44281888008117676,
0.13473984599113464,
-0.8492124080657959,
0.9012646675109863,
0.5670397281646729,
0.5495602488517761,
-0.6910955309867859,
-0.28601551055908203,
-0.019960764795541763,
0.3558460474014282,
-0.40517380833625793,
-0.5545300245285034,
0.31721243262290955,
0.015281799249351025,
0.18086843192577362,
-0.22135122120380402,
0.8629273176193237,
-0.5519992709159851,
-0.24931064248085022,
-0.04686910659074783,
0.2680031955242157,
0.10807288438081741,
-0.038901519030332565,
-0.8508039712905884,
0.2655103802680969,
0.1379050463438034,
-0.017828717827796936,
-0.044050224125385284,
0.6140298247337341,
-0.09074819833040237,
0.6843400001525879,
0.7584952712059021,
0.18473409116268158,
0.03722379356622696,
0.29928794503211975,
0.752695620059967,
-0.30187132954597473,
-0.5024664998054504,
-0.7994942665100098,
0.3148592412471771,
0.03271298110485077,
0.05171457678079605,
0.8695068955421448,
0.5516406297683716,
0.6877603530883789,
-0.07747621834278107,
0.7003098130226135,
0.12546411156654358,
0.4153293967247009,
-0.705801248550415,
0.3622523546218872,
-0.17651978135108948,
0.4929741621017456,
-0.1973191797733307,
-1.0717509984970093,
-0.39104989171028137,
0.5011299252510071,
-0.5732969641685486,
0.11011160165071487,
0.4707193076610565,
1.2101536989212036,
-0.04951705411076546,
-0.2925357520580292,
0.15510809421539307,
0.17466481029987335,
0.519781768321991,
0.5394907593727112,
0.7808637619018555,
0.10717079788446426,
0.46911725401878357,
-0.0898372158408165,
-0.4922708570957184,
-0.3333394527435303,
-1.2358222007751465,
-0.7151027321815491,
-0.22478388249874115,
-0.5545721650123596,
-0.4364031255245209,
-0.10268029570579529,
1.1086958646774292,
0.699599027633667,
-0.6597309708595276,
-0.3110271692276001,
-0.1971150040626526,
-0.2243630588054657,
0.049771517515182495,
-0.1935243457555771,
0.21818597614765167,
-0.41454267501831055,
-0.4496547281742096,
0.4041554629802704,
0.3957226872444153,
0.09130106121301651,
-0.648893415927887,
-0.35658591985702515,
0.21702785789966583,
0.19316640496253967,
0.4977256953716278,
0.533683180809021,
-0.59532630443573,
-0.31358572840690613,
-0.3671201765537262,
-0.08007931709289551,
0.024779602885246277,
1.0765771865844727,
-0.6388891935348511,
0.34872791171073914,
0.5007611513137817,
0.5145995020866394,
0.2658168077468872,
0.0230607520788908,
0.912072479724884,
-1.0613707304000854,
0.10137749463319778,
0.35793957114219666,
0.5606986880302429,
0.4075687527656555,
-0.18542341887950897,
0.33689793944358826,
-0.06808069348335266,
-0.7108877301216125,
-0.7778396010398865,
0.4552793502807617,
-0.5863043069839478,
-0.17388977110385895,
1.2791115045547485,
-0.2458309680223465,
-0.23200130462646484,
-0.35930848121643066,
-0.5333549380302429,
0.04318336397409439,
-0.29886239767074585,
0.6941972374916077,
0.6571168899536133,
-0.0641380250453949,
-0.42995113134384155,
-0.4477827250957489,
0.8466128706932068,
-0.06189468502998352,
-0.9317932724952698,
0.43251311779022217,
0.7326251268386841,
0.44712987542152405,
0.2292073518037796,
0.6677266955375671,
-0.41610363125801086,
0.1855512410402298,
-0.24293659627437592,
0.5582942962646484,
-0.4951914846897125,
-0.09721405059099197,
-0.24579696357250214,
0.03568749129772186,
0.4730550944805145,
0.3234964609146118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18049v1 | Improving Entity Recognition Using Ensembles of Deep Learning and Fine-tuned Large Language Models: A Case Study on Adverse Event Extraction from Multiple Sources | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | 2024-06-26T03:56:21 | Yiming Li, Deepthi Viswaroopan, William He, Jianfu Li, Xu Zuo, Hua Xu, Cui Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adverse event (AE) extraction following COVID-19 vaccines from text data is
crucial for monitoring and analyzing the safety profiles of immunizations.
Traditional deep learning models are adept at learning intricate feature
representations and dependencies in sequential data, but often require
extensive labeled data. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) excel in
understanding contextual information, but exhibit unstable performance on named
entity recognition tasks, possibly due to their broad but unspecific training.
This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs and traditional deep
learning models in AE extraction, and to assess the impact of ensembling these
models on performance. In this study, we utilized reports and posts from the
VAERS (n=621), Twitter (n=9,133), and Reddit (n=131) as our corpora. Our goal
was to extract three types of entities: "vaccine", "shot", and "ae". We
explored and fine-tuned (except GPT-4) multiple LLMs, including GPT-2, GPT-3.5,
GPT-4, and Llama-2, as well as traditional deep learning models like RNN and
BioBERT. To enhance performance, we created ensembles of the three models with
the best performance. For evaluation, we used strict and relaxed F1 scores to
evaluate the performance for each entity type, and micro-average F1 was used to
assess the overall performance. The ensemble model achieved the highest
performance in "vaccine", "shot", and "ae" with strict F1-scores of 0.878,
0.930, and 0.925, respectively, along with a micro-average score of 0.903. In
conclusion, this study demonstrates the effectiveness and robustness of
ensembling fine-tuned traditional deep learning models and LLMs, for extracting
AE-related information. This study contributes to the advancement of biomedical
natural language processing, providing valuable insights into improving AE
extraction from text data for pharmacovigilance and public health surveillance. | [
-0.13227830827236176,
-0.835396945476532,
0.48438405990600586,
-0.08105798810720444,
-0.25839510560035706,
0.26955196261405945,
-0.39309945702552795,
-0.9975059628486633,
0.2449657917022705,
0.38961902260780334,
0.04812037572264671,
-0.6075087785720825,
-0.7948066592216492,
0.3420262634754181,
-0.5022261738777161,
1.148037314414978,
-0.12531736493110657,
0.02428988367319107,
-0.04525841027498245,
-0.015012683346867561,
-0.3275497853755951,
-0.506672203540802,
-0.9635019302368164,
-0.31503820419311523,
0.48150745034217834,
0.2818826138973236,
0.04223020747303963,
0.4355660378932953,
0.9031564593315125,
0.2905956208705902,
-0.01576884835958481,
0.30276399850845337,
-0.3229464888572693,
0.30804264545440674,
-0.34516698122024536,
-0.12908969819545746,
-0.3745018243789673,
-0.12798066437244415,
0.563228964805603,
0.25139281153678894,
-0.2087918370962143,
0.03961475193500519,
0.16308395564556122,
0.29874947667121887,
-0.7111755013465881,
-0.04053133353590965,
-0.7458370327949524,
0.07847791165113449,
-0.21635574102401733,
-0.18624970316886902,
-0.35012391209602356,
-0.06675051152706146,
0.5703961849212646,
-0.6667469143867493,
0.14739598333835602,
-0.08020713180303574,
1.0779234170913696,
0.056368108838796616,
-0.26951298117637634,
-0.3187001347541809,
-0.7060157656669617,
0.6161782741546631,
-0.6403297781944275,
0.28410130739212036,
0.1599148064851761,
0.0174904465675354,
-0.09283078461885452,
-0.8561068177223206,
-0.3404744267463684,
0.04079874977469444,
0.20316550135612488,
0.21089808642864227,
-0.5587127208709717,
0.16907256841659546,
0.0014942355919629335,
0.2576204836368561,
-0.37335941195487976,
0.7286301255226135,
-0.4546315371990204,
-0.37432044744491577,
0.7294197082519531,
0.16729310154914856,
0.39220714569091797,
-0.13685910403728485,
-0.3005906939506531,
0.01890173926949501,
-0.782109797000885,
0.14362388849258423,
-0.029694072902202606,
0.2558218538761139,
-0.1548091322183609,
0.4107445478439331,
-0.13613297045230865,
0.4451305568218231,
0.28248709440231323,
-0.11388678848743439,
0.26373812556266785,
-0.265014111995697,
-0.533687949180603,
0.25775009393692017,
0.9555487036705017,
0.14289380609989166,
0.1423877328634262,
-0.18933603167533875,
-0.1431749016046524,
-0.1616213470697403,
0.289671927690506,
-1.0857616662979126,
-0.31478574872016907,
0.2556069791316986,
-0.5697309374809265,
-0.3990316092967987,
-0.04744379594922066,
-1.1406943798065186,
-0.6988663077354431,
-0.32710644602775574,
0.3079817593097687,
-0.6277658343315125,
-0.1728946566581726,
0.05700454115867615,
-0.14030693471431732,
0.018332013860344887,
0.5612923502922058,
-0.7231463193893433,
0.2740158140659332,
0.7300350666046143,
0.7165287137031555,
-0.4393257200717926,
0.06235962733626366,
-0.6872347593307495,
0.06736984848976135,
-0.2400856763124466,
0.9286150336265564,
-0.7107710242271423,
-0.190160870552063,
0.055408600717782974,
-0.05208330228924751,
-0.24126173555850983,
-0.823025107383728,
0.7133083939552307,
-0.4964402914047241,
-0.0675962045788765,
0.07479694485664368,
-0.7346768975257874,
-0.17504051327705383,
0.17073380947113037,
-0.561795175075531,
0.3447740375995636,
-0.5370482802391052,
-0.5811097621917725,
0.6048055291175842,
-0.33700013160705566,
-0.6665307283401489,
0.16217567026615143,
-0.5083824992179871,
-0.6757221817970276,
0.24957090616226196,
0.5068450570106506,
0.7711575031280518,
-0.37008529901504517,
0.3777219355106354,
-0.4790983200073242,
-0.15560655295848846,
0.09790976345539093,
-0.5363773703575134,
0.44671931862831116,
0.07603326439857483,
-0.1782393902540207,
0.03601060435175896,
-1.0121265649795532,
-0.3096821904182434,
0.1683240681886673,
-0.6281622648239136,
-0.3953913748264313,
-0.03205203264951706,
-0.019374622032046318,
0.11419707536697388,
-0.11803199350833893,
-0.41800856590270996,
0.17486383020877838,
-0.6550820469856262,
0.465406596660614,
0.5655507445335388,
0.4983125925064087,
0.48155537247657776,
0.06935450434684753,
0.37411579489707947,
0.23117060959339142,
-0.15783078968524933,
-0.04623406380414963,
-0.43814247846603394,
-0.5345022678375244,
-0.3971618413925171,
0.39635205268859863,
0.5699747800827026,
-0.6601393818855286,
0.3408278226852417,
-0.20458471775054932,
-0.41335663199424744,
-0.6128660440444946,
0.04672027379274368,
0.2607359290122986,
0.5392408967018127,
0.4616427421569824,
-0.23759578168392181,
-0.7103293538093567,
-0.7768057584762573,
-0.4355224072933197,
-0.18385225534439087,
-0.1009344831109047,
0.23668673634529114,
0.6327401399612427,
-0.4191989302635193,
0.46391066908836365,
-0.392688512802124,
-0.15573762357234955,
-0.0558273009955883,
0.2494163066148758,
0.03742796927690506,
0.4477424919605255,
0.3143412470817566,
-0.5456081628799438,
-0.08261324465274811,
0.345738023519516,
-0.7226488590240479,
0.15680423378944397,
-0.08558180928230286,
0.14422594010829926,
0.18160034716129303,
0.3946537971496582,
-0.6897095441818237,
0.5274350047111511,
0.2418089658021927,
-0.0961679071187973,
0.431833416223526,
-0.04705900698900223,
0.12676198780536652,
-1.1318477392196655,
0.11536798626184464,
0.4514380991458893,
-0.03149008750915527,
-0.7018360495567322,
-0.06361373513936996,
0.11472773551940918,
-0.036398280411958694,
-0.5582049489021301,
0.4843231439590454,
-0.349378377199173,
0.28392988443374634,
0.008215107023715973,
-0.1840364634990692,
0.2879485487937927,
0.12923312187194824,
0.03475015237927437,
0.4251081645488739,
0.6210519671440125,
-0.7622985243797302,
0.1667006015777588,
0.02246243506669998,
-0.4940842092037201,
0.25232258439064026,
-0.4920119047164917,
0.01492052711546421,
-0.28681373596191406,
0.1761816293001175,
-0.47449591755867004,
-0.6561719179153442,
0.4153313934803009,
-0.2267765998840332,
0.7597246766090393,
-0.028636056929826736,
-0.19449789822101593,
-0.27563267946243286,
-0.1378171294927597,
0.2788093090057373,
0.15796199440956116,
-0.4318237602710724,
0.5818921327590942,
0.7317971587181091,
-0.22681200504302979,
-0.5577992796897888,
-0.6851653456687927,
0.15384502708911896,
-0.5460861921310425,
-0.23733501136302948,
0.5719167590141296,
0.3875063955783844,
-0.25059622526168823,
-0.05201280862092972,
-0.1410258710384369,
-0.26236459612846375,
0.14595486223697662,
0.15344353020191193,
0.25149276852607727,
-0.280854731798172,
0.6303643584251404,
0.1635417938232422,
0.1424597203731537,
-0.10764367133378983,
-0.05583367124199867,
0.31003516912460327,
-0.1683470457792282,
-0.10490871220827103,
-0.70488041639328,
0.4080093801021576,
0.5318464636802673,
-0.5151986479759216,
0.779961109161377,
0.6862388253211975,
-1.0147711038589478,
0.16289351880550385,
-0.6245272755622864,
-0.20543105900287628,
-0.3319348394870758,
0.5383926630020142,
-0.06616471707820892,
-0.8493930101394653,
0.5331815481185913,
-0.15586774051189423,
-0.06928729265928268,
0.8287400007247925,
0.5114437937736511,
-0.08839051425457001,
0.7374905347824097,
0.46137192845344543,
-0.37287771701812744,
0.4992354214191437,
-0.06786347925662994,
0.24606461822986603,
-0.7301642298698425,
-0.42461904883384705,
-0.5072365403175354,
0.00582887465134263,
-0.5567218661308289,
-0.19896584749221802,
0.356186181306839,
0.19561026990413666,
-0.22409266233444214,
0.06707742065191269,
-0.46276041865348816,
0.1797427535057068,
0.30141931772232056,
0.33953624963760376,
0.20247724652290344,
0.21087215840816498,
0.08761651813983917,
0.15578913688659668,
-0.641238272190094,
-0.48484623432159424,
1.1277307271957397,
0.657916247844696,
0.7168639302253723,
0.14067138731479645,
0.9272915720939636,
-0.03988474979996681,
0.17422184348106384,
-0.6679542660713196,
0.23221446573734283,
-0.4279313385486603,
-0.38209694623947144,
-0.16373243927955627,
-0.37944260239601135,
-1.2299247980117798,
0.042640089988708496,
-0.6773877143859863,
-1.0851259231567383,
0.6273949146270752,
-0.06504940241575241,
-1.029085397720337,
0.09807001054286957,
-0.8442680239677429,
0.6869423389434814,
-0.1781201809644699,
-0.25609180331230164,
-0.27225643396377563,
-0.37849655747413635,
0.35480672121047974,
-0.24682627618312836,
0.039197251200675964,
-0.03538588434457779,
-0.02892056480050087,
0.7947719693183899,
-0.10086851567029953,
0.8141737580299377,
0.32746365666389465,
-0.020955407992005348,
0.4110758602619171,
-0.2863466739654541,
0.5349863171577454,
0.4722537100315094,
-0.2100490778684616,
0.3953474760055542,
-0.177880197763443,
0.03383409604430199,
-0.21352222561836243,
0.7719617486000061,
-0.7505723834037781,
-0.5670832395553589,
-0.343099981546402,
-0.08869196474552155,
0.15731872618198395,
0.2871551215648651,
0.5242145657539368,
0.5515590310096741,
-0.3677745759487152,
0.28130781650543213,
0.7250028848648071,
-0.6304357051849365,
0.5286805033683777,
0.45677968859672546,
0.1766996830701828,
-0.4500969350337982,
0.8762258291244507,
0.3437849283218384,
-0.17933619022369385,
0.5794661641120911,
0.05924512445926666,
-0.0673690214753151,
-0.7439717054367065,
-0.39308708906173706,
-0.08994743973016739,
-0.5380393266677856,
-0.6076193451881409,
-1.0642390251159668,
-0.3750639855861664,
-0.7427800893783569,
0.2931407392024994,
-0.3278692066669464,
-0.11396460235118866,
-0.7363285422325134,
-0.2759111225605011,
0.25038930773735046,
0.6839576959609985,
0.0726882740855217,
-0.09756128489971161,
-0.9253683686256409,
0.2553120255470276,
0.1366085708141327,
0.44950416684150696,
-0.02038087509572506,
-0.21710443496704102,
-0.2612904906272888,
-0.1676696538925171,
-0.3709070384502411,
-1.0312312841415405,
0.3985433578491211,
0.43602627515792847,
0.5562270879745483,
0.6979798674583435,
-0.1588137149810791,
0.7839464545249939,
-0.5399771332740784,
0.514786422252655,
0.2804124355316162,
-0.6754615902900696,
0.7159406542778015,
-0.20329801738262177,
0.04120979830622673,
0.646033525466919,
0.21828056871891022,
-0.2956227660179138,
-0.2866813838481903,
-0.5409073233604431,
-1.0363407135009766,
0.5126900672912598,
0.241873100399971,
-0.22827818989753723,
-0.2548731863498688,
0.41962727904319763,
0.08339754492044449,
0.06337407976388931,
-0.481118768453598,
-0.04044976830482483,
0.3933650255203247,
-0.20680870115756989,
-0.1108580008149147,
-0.23292729258537292,
-0.08452528715133667,
-0.29354649782180786,
0.6945041418075562,
0.23953509330749512,
0.26843348145484924,
0.4266696870326996,
-0.1323683261871338,
-0.14651775360107422,
0.3241334855556488,
0.5092544555664062,
0.2953079640865326,
-0.031331922858953476,
0.14334991574287415,
0.18860946595668793,
-0.6000097393989563,
-0.08001479506492615,
0.5617287158966064,
0.09009517729282379,
-0.09022216498851776,
0.6880481839179993,
0.7130217552185059,
0.03661337494850159,
-0.8342036008834839,
0.2721485197544098,
-0.14937995374202728,
0.17480014264583588,
-0.1504126638174057,
0.040277380496263504,
-0.22760172188282013,
0.45025238394737244,
0.3338541090488434,
0.3406532108783722,
0.6092872023582458,
-0.39344730973243713,
0.38522791862487793,
0.28811660408973694,
-0.21594804525375366,
-0.18635132908821106,
0.34623953700065613,
0.2734145224094391,
-0.1816762238740921,
0.5511373281478882,
0.07031642645597458,
-0.15640459954738617,
0.8562735319137573,
0.4711550176143646,
0.7753708958625793,
-0.42345085740089417,
0.14619840681552887,
0.41970914602279663,
0.27722206711769104,
-0.12780874967575073,
-0.1648147851228714,
0.42180243134498596,
-0.7814545631408691,
-0.38563230633735657,
-0.5367044806480408,
-0.08839692175388336,
0.5506056547164917,
-0.6396827101707458,
0.32227054238319397,
-0.26891028881073,
-0.29888245463371277,
0.5029922723770142,
-0.03706624358892441,
-1.045737862586975,
0.23129580914974213,
0.3654599189758301,
0.7220139503479004,
-0.8152700662612915,
0.5816924571990967,
0.8746817111968994,
-0.483494371175766,
-0.7351600527763367,
0.1260967254638672,
-0.0407087467610836,
-0.6500009298324585,
0.25760796666145325,
0.4491168260574341,
0.4298084080219269,
-0.30608299374580383,
-0.1432172656059265,
-0.8600305318832397,
0.9525648355484009,
0.32082241773605347,
-1.024238109588623,
-0.024353090673685074,
0.009348525665700436,
0.7569693326950073,
-0.44874343276023865,
0.04831184074282646,
0.7033705115318298,
0.07671581208705902,
-0.25542059540748596,
-0.8240845203399658,
0.05422843247652054,
-0.22666993737220764,
-0.30446118116378784,
0.1896481066942215,
-0.25713911652565,
0.5938170552253723,
-0.20550434291362762,
-0.3399001359939575,
-0.159558966755867,
0.5470523238182068,
0.36275559663772583,
0.7099379897117615,
0.039104145020246506,
0.5928341150283813,
1.1693193912506104,
0.09315251559019089,
1.0994795560836792,
0.024420104920864105,
0.2871321141719818,
1.061510682106018,
-0.19850149750709534,
1.0224517583847046,
0.557135820388794,
0.09604325890541077,
0.3187640905380249,
0.7879635691642761,
0.09776230156421661,
0.5610800385475159,
0.029504554346203804,
-0.2852542996406555,
-0.24024128913879395,
-0.15342438220977783,
-0.3639568090438843,
0.5937141180038452,
0.7650654315948486,
-0.781388521194458,
-0.12249332666397095,
0.30433520674705505,
-0.09406816214323044,
-0.257134348154068,
-0.5099742412567139,
1.0360933542251587,
0.3017871379852295,
-0.6879451274871826,
0.22915272414684296,
0.017672430723905563,
0.46183744072914124,
0.0064989724196493626,
-0.23175565898418427,
0.16936880350112915,
0.27961334586143494,
-0.2058505266904831,
-0.6040996313095093,
0.15385004878044128,
0.14046724140644073,
-0.09386351704597473,
0.3572896122932434,
1.2102607488632202,
-0.4542114734649658,
-0.7421607375144958,
0.28173673152923584,
0.40139591693878174,
0.05923071876168251,
-0.09600524604320526,
-0.7429084777832031,
0.1547202616930008,
-0.20202873647212982,
-0.3281658887863159,
0.2360660582780838,
0.49093225598335266,
-0.03589118272066116,
0.34756436944007874,
0.37537890672683716,
0.18611623346805573,
-0.1757824718952179,
0.12446770071983337,
0.7667388319969177,
-0.33462122082710266,
-0.2075871229171753,
-1.2137988805770874,
0.48566535115242004,
-0.4421064555644989,
-0.38582009077072144,
0.3655374050140381,
0.5708032846450806,
0.6277685761451721,
0.0076802573166787624,
0.7306181788444519,
0.22663608193397522,
0.35798755288124084,
-0.5773608088493347,
0.7125363349914551,
-0.41782334446907043,
0.38058629631996155,
-0.2467917799949646,
-0.40309712290763855,
-0.5499282479286194,
0.41458699107170105,
-0.4690365493297577,
-0.17408108711242676,
0.4099646210670471,
0.39883819222450256,
0.0992588996887207,
-0.0938696637749672,
0.05508614331483841,
0.30007505416870117,
0.5819069743156433,
0.5887337923049927,
0.618254542350769,
-0.4885392487049103,
0.2829451262950897,
-0.1959676742553711,
-0.09232067316770554,
-0.4506545662879944,
-0.7456161379814148,
-0.8332868814468384,
-0.37227576971054077,
-0.5242198705673218,
-0.3039831519126892,
0.37876981496810913,
1.1239101886749268,
0.549624502658844,
-1.02006995677948,
0.5399620532989502,
-0.12624643743038177,
0.0888567790389061,
-0.10395865887403488,
-0.2416330873966217,
0.5197437405586243,
-0.2661924660205841,
-0.5552451014518738,
0.38109973073005676,
0.49924278259277344,
0.13172921538352966,
0.30343008041381836,
0.1689371019601822,
-0.20157310366630554,
-0.08149018883705139,
0.7698383331298828,
0.23676711320877075,
-0.7508434057235718,
-0.4046741724014282,
-0.16258211433887482,
-0.29987698793411255,
-0.040676549077034,
0.46722549200057983,
-0.6317570209503174,
0.43141284584999084,
0.3141564130783081,
1.0498253107070923,
0.27199259400367737,
-0.2065587192773819,
0.6537550687789917,
-0.512362539768219,
-0.13020271062850952,
0.4456694722175598,
0.5492985248565674,
0.18952439725399017,
-0.6698716282844543,
0.3527541160583496,
0.07339026778936386,
-0.5210992693901062,
-0.7139661908149719,
0.008585238829255104,
-0.8231931924819946,
-0.2775315046310425,
1.2761962413787842,
-0.045203231275081635,
-0.018048275262117386,
-0.15378884971141815,
-0.08182577788829803,
0.5797934532165527,
-0.6639257073402405,
0.9214844703674316,
0.5822790861129761,
-0.22041699290275574,
-0.1933223009109497,
-0.5935961008071899,
0.5117743015289307,
0.15565387904644012,
-0.9506535530090332,
-0.3766345977783203,
0.22029127180576324,
0.22064274549484253,
0.10110080987215042,
0.4961353838443756,
-0.09306905418634415,
0.27395495772361755,
-0.31490665674209595,
0.09808805584907532,
0.2545083165168762,
-0.45367002487182617,
-0.7778612971305847,
0.28618815541267395,
-0.22702327370643616,
-0.2975601851940155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18045v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18045v2 | PharmaGPT: Domain-Specific Large Language Models for Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemistry | 2024-06-26T03:43:09 | 2024-07-03T12:56:40 | Linqing Chen, Weilei Wang, Zilong Bai, Peng Xu, Yan Fang, Jie Fang, Wentao Wu, Lizhi Zhou, Ruiji Zhang, Yubin Xia, Chaobo Xu, Ran Hu, Licong Xu, Qijun Cai, Haoran Hua, Jing Sun, Jin Liu, Tian Qiu, Haowen Liu, Meng Hu, Xiuwen Li, Fei Gao, Yufu Wang, Lin Tie, Chaochao Wang, Jianping Lu, Cheng Sun, Yixin Wang, Shengjie Yang, Yuancheng Li, Lu Jin, Lisha Zhang, Fu Bian, Zhongkai Ye, Lidong Pei, Changyang Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP) by by minimizing the need for complex feature engineering. However, the
application of LLMs in specialized domains like biopharmaceuticals and
chemistry remains largely unexplored. These fields are characterized by
intricate terminologies, specialized knowledge, and a high demand for precision
areas where general purpose LLMs often fall short. In this study, we introduce
PharmGPT, a suite of multilingual LLMs with 13 billion and 70 billion
parameters, specifically trained on a comprehensive corpus of hundreds of
billions of tokens tailored to the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical sectors. Our
evaluation shows that PharmGPT matches or surpasses existing general models on
key benchmarks, such as NAPLEX, demonstrating its exceptional capability in
domain-specific tasks. This advancement establishes a new benchmark for LLMs in
the Bio-Pharmaceutical and Chemical fields, addressing the existing gap in
specialized language modeling. Furthermore, this suggests a promising path for
enhanced research and development in these specialized areas, paving the way
for more precise and effective applications of NLP in specialized domains. | [
-0.05480532720685005,
-0.7164077162742615,
0.7693873643875122,
0.04298710823059082,
-0.14556975662708282,
0.41042450070381165,
-0.3695979714393616,
-0.34628960490226746,
0.16065561771392822,
0.5941883325576782,
-0.31916460394859314,
-0.7409566640853882,
-0.7161723971366882,
0.1534617841243744,
-0.021502459421753883,
1.05184805393219,
0.008338293060660362,
0.27306121587753296,
0.059428103268146515,
-0.08237102627754211,
-0.19949056208133698,
-0.982376754283905,
-0.3657363951206207,
-0.7232450842857361,
0.5341526865959167,
-0.01804937981069088,
0.4714556932449341,
0.2615552246570587,
0.6752793192863464,
0.17822468280792236,
-0.0660436674952507,
0.09559889882802963,
-0.18779298663139343,
0.21708500385284424,
-0.5628935694694519,
-0.0054276734590530396,
-0.8434306979179382,
-0.12114819884300232,
0.5552199482917786,
1.0323249101638794,
-0.2927512526512146,
0.05102932080626488,
-0.06488842517137527,
0.40347084403038025,
-0.49566739797592163,
0.31377971172332764,
-0.6396520137786865,
-0.09062093496322632,
-0.13472197949886322,
0.20661377906799316,
-0.2828541100025177,
0.051031459122896194,
0.39621293544769287,
-0.49073725938796997,
0.11083205044269562,
0.03827720880508423,
0.8833910226821899,
0.06297317892313004,
-0.47434452176094055,
0.08291725069284439,
-0.5866187810897827,
0.7945372462272644,
-0.9110473990440369,
0.43587052822113037,
0.08133712410926819,
0.2622547447681427,
-0.5691938996315002,
-1.1253399848937988,
-0.32642295956611633,
-0.316912978887558,
0.11475247889757156,
-0.12729603052139282,
0.09345420449972153,
0.2461661398410797,
-0.10106955468654633,
0.4350157678127289,
-0.9036250710487366,
0.09101950377225876,
-0.1653936505317688,
-0.16064319014549255,
0.23035241663455963,
0.10469144582748413,
0.3933074474334717,
-0.02526594139635563,
-0.4763524830341339,
0.1567491739988327,
-0.6687976717948914,
-0.4596443772315979,
-0.2304646521806717,
0.4470183551311493,
0.2166430503129959,
0.6873685121536255,
-0.10879142582416534,
0.8460272550582886,
-0.31168487668037415,
-0.10994134843349457,
0.170606330037117,
-0.30795711278915405,
-0.4488566815853119,
0.04689076542854309,
0.8788190484046936,
-0.07202696055173874,
0.39242690801620483,
-0.08493548631668091,
0.07546675950288773,
-0.14517803490161896,
0.15397879481315613,
-0.91995769739151,
-0.44926363229751587,
0.6108148097991943,
-0.1462099403142929,
0.08575791865587234,
-0.2969930171966553,
-0.8720023036003113,
-0.4816809892654419,
-0.2619185745716095,
0.23650479316711426,
-0.6442078948020935,
-0.18042968213558197,
0.5956672430038452,
-0.09005414694547653,
0.2847953736782074,
-0.04733925685286522,
-1.2451432943344116,
0.39059707522392273,
0.9733036756515503,
0.9044132828712463,
-0.7166526317596436,
-0.474493145942688,
-0.31992489099502563,
0.3731327950954437,
-0.04285994917154312,
1.113061547279358,
-0.789860188961029,
-0.4466467499732971,
-0.06806075572967529,
0.015712158754467964,
-0.1877182126045227,
-0.7812951803207397,
0.5103291273117065,
-0.2692281901836395,
-0.05811905488371849,
-0.015788083896040916,
-0.7564477324485779,
-0.07200513035058975,
0.30518805980682373,
-0.24419523775577545,
0.6199420094490051,
0.22113296389579773,
-0.3132859170436859,
0.44596946239471436,
-0.5600422024726868,
-0.43168404698371887,
0.556510329246521,
-0.19864782691001892,
-0.47675660252571106,
0.055696163326501846,
0.1525648981332779,
0.48848944902420044,
-0.3928493857383728,
0.4532315731048584,
-0.23172782361507416,
-0.1354711651802063,
0.2809879183769226,
-0.037279948592185974,
0.4464876651763916,
-0.03854818269610405,
-0.0874137207865715,
0.3438575565814972,
-0.8158612251281738,
0.2295713573694229,
0.04530879482626915,
-0.6456928849220276,
-0.23634426295757294,
-0.3586375117301941,
0.40460580587387085,
0.2087090164422989,
0.2830231487751007,
-0.39905214309692383,
0.5011669397354126,
-0.6714937090873718,
0.9195910692214966,
0.5664719939231873,
0.21918128430843353,
0.28329262137413025,
0.153590127825737,
0.5473994016647339,
-0.5184381008148193,
0.019700108096003532,
-0.15739670395851135,
-0.6859264969825745,
-0.1040235236287117,
-0.9068232774734497,
0.5288883447647095,
0.6725507974624634,
-0.2074728012084961,
0.531363308429718,
-0.27803006768226624,
-0.49625325202941895,
-0.0753399208188057,
0.17965483665466309,
0.21605759859085083,
0.26666319370269775,
0.36414265632629395,
-0.45762383937835693,
-0.11551987379789352,
-0.8846353888511658,
-0.7393596768379211,
0.011561410501599312,
-0.27301955223083496,
0.13402605056762695,
0.7329472899436951,
-0.46539419889450073,
0.6441508531570435,
-0.7341178059577942,
-0.31883901357650757,
-0.39296090602874756,
-0.15941786766052246,
0.4155023396015167,
0.26861441135406494,
0.3560510575771332,
-0.6712155938148499,
-0.5793106555938721,
0.24802903831005096,
-0.41161730885505676,
-0.28421470522880554,
0.3301960229873657,
-0.34486889839172363,
-0.23771728575229645,
0.22146044671535492,
-1.0420037508010864,
-0.0769115537405014,
0.6538674831390381,
-0.3919561207294464,
0.6341025233268738,
-0.28479501605033875,
0.044739145785570145,
-0.9880607724189758,
0.39591291546821594,
0.06757493317127228,
-0.35292771458625793,
-0.8402612805366516,
0.14825737476348877,
0.019369378685951233,
-0.5284501910209656,
-0.8070985674858093,
0.75105220079422,
-0.24106541275978088,
0.08082864433526993,
-0.2971474528312683,
-0.11558233201503754,
0.2580016553401947,
0.49321281909942627,
0.30671876668930054,
0.7262001037597656,
0.5053889751434326,
-0.5113939642906189,
0.5048204064369202,
0.3526432514190674,
-0.3122551739215851,
0.5163154006004333,
-0.8254880905151367,
-0.05760331079363823,
0.3746698200702667,
0.3666066527366638,
-0.7527315616607666,
-0.6020000576972961,
0.29651230573654175,
-0.15230318903923035,
0.44518736004829407,
-0.28216102719306946,
-0.6688165068626404,
-0.062033116817474365,
0.07749418169260025,
0.41689008474349976,
0.6454290747642517,
-0.15551824867725372,
0.7578247785568237,
0.5762872695922852,
-0.598071813583374,
-0.3132961690425873,
-0.645645260810852,
0.19965597987174988,
-0.22310061752796173,
-0.20240123569965363,
0.5350321531295776,
0.13721682131290436,
-0.08067703247070312,
-0.2759958803653717,
-0.098991259932518,
-0.2789000868797302,
-0.41261887550354004,
0.09696773439645767,
0.08084910362958908,
-0.11883357912302017,
0.35759034752845764,
-0.1464042365550995,
-0.2557048201560974,
-0.10858973115682602,
-0.8316957950592041,
0.8552583456039429,
0.06921070069074631,
-0.3558202087879181,
0.013092157430946827,
0.47593531012535095,
0.6303940415382385,
-0.48980578780174255,
0.7414170503616333,
0.39477962255477905,
-0.296234667301178,
-0.38436558842658997,
-0.14253301918506622,
-0.21111391484737396,
-0.4502466320991516,
0.6849367022514343,
-0.1418701708316803,
-0.7488235831260681,
0.338893324136734,
-0.6432369351387024,
-0.11739296466112137,
0.31583139300346375,
1.0200251340866089,
0.6269813776016235,
0.6318248510360718,
0.5549682974815369,
0.0834149494767189,
0.1091398075222969,
0.11937673389911652,
0.5450608730316162,
-0.6302684545516968,
-0.21633726358413696,
-0.28106653690338135,
0.07691052556037903,
-0.24853894114494324,
-0.5039220452308655,
0.5828732252120972,
-0.32135647535324097,
-0.48854318261146545,
0.2808779180049896,
-0.6775897741317749,
0.5351584553718567,
0.5086250901222229,
-0.19613952934741974,
0.35293012857437134,
0.3835380971431732,
-0.38486379384994507,
-0.0953216552734375,
-0.575154185295105,
-0.466926634311676,
1.1158182621002197,
0.257430762052536,
0.58347088098526,
-0.030054405331611633,
0.28974971175193787,
0.022078830748796463,
0.10346303135156631,
-0.9303392171859741,
0.5093405842781067,
-0.4283406734466553,
-0.7547119855880737,
-0.10492288321256638,
-0.17875288426876068,
-0.9096518158912659,
0.37544742226600647,
-0.06131961941719055,
-0.81585693359375,
0.08631988614797592,
-0.04605591297149658,
-0.3522641658782959,
0.34848034381866455,
-0.7814650535583496,
1.1233325004577637,
-0.21718217432498932,
-0.2924090027809143,
-0.007332174107432365,
-0.5537382960319519,
0.1691005825996399,
-0.5130903720855713,
-0.0032633491791784763,
-0.43483462929725647,
-0.2283291220664978,
0.40815824270248413,
-0.5125083327293396,
0.6773166060447693,
0.27340489625930786,
-0.26063504815101624,
0.1228233352303505,
0.039635103195905685,
0.19703556597232819,
0.01499510370194912,
0.019047008827328682,
0.48617643117904663,
0.11054091900587082,
-0.5248905420303345,
-0.30630671977996826,
0.915632963180542,
-0.2608526945114136,
-0.45896363258361816,
-0.663181722164154,
-0.49273285269737244,
-0.5187186002731323,
0.5781470537185669,
0.25470778346061707,
0.21649236977100372,
-0.1987595409154892,
-0.26200810074806213,
0.6134514808654785,
-0.7830212712287903,
-0.007519405335187912,
0.6895385980606079,
-0.30969029664993286,
-0.42482730746269226,
0.907751202583313,
-0.0779513418674469,
0.43048474192619324,
0.5070388913154602,
0.14332842826843262,
-0.32283225655555725,
-0.6470887064933777,
-0.34309831261634827,
0.3987240493297577,
-0.7988015413284302,
-0.10541142523288727,
-0.6856589317321777,
-0.15460632741451263,
-0.6263379454612732,
0.04567626491189003,
-0.43318799138069153,
-0.39309850335121155,
0.16720423102378845,
-0.02032901905477047,
0.5858404636383057,
0.5036717057228088,
0.1744387298822403,
0.2573080360889435,
-0.9812349677085876,
0.4134501516819,
0.35229939222335815,
0.6470562219619751,
-0.4276462197303772,
-0.24633942544460297,
-0.07528133690357208,
-0.29659315943717957,
-0.23826567828655243,
-0.8125371336936951,
0.6721045970916748,
0.6258114576339722,
0.4507945775985718,
-0.06632401794195175,
-0.3668467104434967,
0.20833653211593628,
-0.9467647075653076,
1.0147956609725952,
-0.1670176386833191,
-0.7787405252456665,
0.5105038285255432,
-0.6546007990837097,
0.5347654819488525,
0.34547483921051025,
0.3265041410923004,
-0.4984320104122162,
-0.2537935674190521,
-0.3006986677646637,
-1.1972330808639526,
0.17434453964233398,
0.16214212775230408,
0.042282816022634506,
0.14048229157924652,
0.5625551342964172,
0.26476210355758667,
0.29382410645484924,
-0.4839687645435333,
-0.2800474166870117,
0.1935282200574875,
-0.37262269854545593,
-0.08196452260017395,
-0.017857559025287628,
-0.010854925028979778,
-0.16661886870861053,
0.611020565032959,
-0.0797404795885086,
0.11110946536064148,
0.13366758823394775,
0.08406183123588562,
0.2856246829032898,
0.6675863862037659,
0.46346360445022583,
0.7717567682266235,
-0.17658787965774536,
-0.0018143653869628906,
0.01891680620610714,
-1.0110892057418823,
0.27695274353027344,
0.4902171790599823,
0.21272657811641693,
-0.02892281301319599,
0.3120056092739105,
0.22811859846115112,
0.04763167351484299,
-1.2753865718841553,
0.16632816195487976,
0.16482698917388916,
0.004889235366135836,
-0.08443418145179749,
-0.05503920465707779,
0.05744773894548416,
0.20477017760276794,
0.2812846302986145,
-0.06341252475976944,
0.26001396775245667,
-0.570576548576355,
0.3743059039115906,
0.26411113142967224,
-0.11148601770401001,
-0.22470609843730927,
0.718052327632904,
-0.0059658014215528965,
-0.18447741866111755,
0.3626445531845093,
0.18693795800209045,
-0.5427360534667969,
0.3336745500564575,
0.42325645685195923,
0.7034168243408203,
-0.4513494372367859,
0.12904737889766693,
0.10483238846063614,
-0.07860960811376572,
-0.043853841722011566,
0.04641343280673027,
0.3822323679924011,
-0.47992369532585144,
-0.5515775680541992,
-0.9685486555099487,
-0.5368012189865112,
0.3188338279724121,
0.0019168495200574398,
0.27960455417633057,
-0.6491532921791077,
-0.45256510376930237,
0.4160155653953552,
-0.0240191463381052,
-0.3805905878543854,
-0.004394038580358028,
-0.04467722401022911,
0.5795175433158875,
-0.6773906350135803,
0.9022747874259949,
0.9291068315505981,
-0.22835291922092438,
-0.5723623037338257,
-0.10489709675312042,
-0.03892434388399124,
-0.8181484341621399,
0.6171937584877014,
-0.14979048073291779,
0.030743885785341263,
-0.06340225785970688,
-0.30438685417175293,
-0.6321151256561279,
0.7112764120101929,
0.5824504494667053,
-0.5956119298934937,
0.03082874044775963,
0.6410127878189087,
0.7021621465682983,
-0.2604468762874603,
-0.2941179573535919,
0.8733882308006287,
0.40634673833847046,
-0.07182088494300842,
-1.1565895080566406,
-0.0023696809075772762,
-0.3057384490966797,
-0.1606791615486145,
0.3233557939529419,
-0.4765007495880127,
1.0195564031600952,
0.053920622915029526,
0.056709617376327515,
0.09357152134180069,
-0.04177761450409889,
0.6203179955482483,
-0.02076009102165699,
-0.19844017922878265,
0.3835882544517517,
0.5388711094856262,
-0.08005436509847641,
1.198999285697937,
-0.41088664531707764,
0.2929800748825073,
0.8566402196884155,
-0.6392616629600525,
0.8503608703613281,
0.3807717263698578,
-0.4160183370113373,
0.28493931889533997,
0.6898522973060608,
-0.26258471608161926,
0.5108373761177063,
0.3271125853061676,
-0.6753153800964355,
-0.37092387676239014,
-0.20205280184745789,
-0.31336161494255066,
0.19330520927906036,
0.8185657262802124,
-0.377183198928833,
-0.02011175826191902,
0.08503067493438721,
-0.061169352382421494,
-0.00888244528323412,
-0.23351041972637177,
0.7572059035301208,
0.5120387077331543,
-0.49610522389411926,
0.5376673936843872,
0.14574986696243286,
0.3309631645679474,
-0.9375688433647156,
-0.13905999064445496,
0.07426969707012177,
0.5276726484298706,
-0.03679065778851509,
-0.6844602823257446,
0.03082011081278324,
-0.0823693498969078,
0.15819060802459717,
0.025028394535183907,
0.8904298543930054,
-0.5451192259788513,
-0.5027814507484436,
0.3138607144355774,
0.48446959257125854,
0.10090741515159607,
-0.3861438035964966,
-0.7153323888778687,
-0.10419097542762756,
-0.3683629631996155,
-0.24091839790344238,
0.4386420249938965,
0.45271021127700806,
0.14407265186309814,
0.6690151691436768,
0.4967668354511261,
0.47544801235198975,
-0.07421678304672241,
0.11561818420886993,
0.6777320504188538,
-0.627456784248352,
-0.3466329574584961,
-1.082334041595459,
0.29139190912246704,
0.11380669474601746,
-0.2744748890399933,
0.6539342999458313,
0.5066545605659485,
0.42267757654190063,
-0.43269646167755127,
0.9044659733772278,
0.470037043094635,
0.5012022852897644,
-0.5054184198379517,
0.5486108660697937,
-0.3866389989852905,
0.2188497632741928,
-0.23273025453090668,
-1.1126705408096313,
-0.941905677318573,
0.379759818315506,
-0.3277575373649597,
0.2021207958459854,
0.745569109916687,
0.48536381125450134,
-0.0867701917886734,
-0.3507067859172821,
0.2151307463645935,
0.19333229959011078,
0.5774971842765808,
0.8528423309326172,
0.5124490857124329,
-0.25883448123931885,
0.2255389541387558,
0.17961449921131134,
0.0014380371430888772,
-0.11204823106527328,
-0.7276973128318787,
-0.9880353212356567,
-0.2764303386211395,
-0.3091309666633606,
-0.34954509139060974,
0.22204698622226715,
1.1712983846664429,
0.7056241631507874,
-1.0163308382034302,
-0.11473675817251205,
-0.19367854297161102,
-0.2259681671857834,
-0.132797971367836,
-0.17543920874595642,
0.5888489484786987,
-0.08900522440671921,
-0.7753302454948425,
0.3224547505378723,
0.8142749667167664,
0.22014129161834717,
-0.3727014362812042,
0.19381088018417358,
-0.18230825662612915,
0.1878090798854828,
0.7841920256614685,
0.5015507340431213,
-0.6755414009094238,
0.09556269645690918,
0.06167175620794296,
-0.024849766865372658,
0.20234641432762146,
1.0371993780136108,
-0.7053113579750061,
0.28095340728759766,
0.46907806396484375,
0.5074186325073242,
0.25786662101745605,
-0.11471293866634369,
1.096359133720398,
-0.6915320754051208,
0.31593751907348633,
0.47939130663871765,
0.3165737986564636,
0.5413735508918762,
-0.25999391078948975,
0.4278717041015625,
0.1864054948091507,
-0.7911095023155212,
-0.6563520431518555,
0.36413878202438354,
-1.005692481994629,
-0.6807579398155212,
1.3130285739898682,
-0.10915347188711166,
-0.21407552063465118,
-0.3357013761997223,
-0.3646741211414337,
-0.08300984650850296,
-0.41833561658859253,
0.6010388731956482,
0.7866212725639343,
-0.19310913980007172,
-0.022098664194345474,
-0.8132892847061157,
0.6827958226203918,
0.3315214514732361,
-0.8712724447250366,
0.1935214400291443,
0.30483099818229675,
0.3954913020133972,
0.03639601171016693,
0.6630148887634277,
-0.19950613379478455,
-0.08847270160913467,
-0.12998177111148834,
0.04786263406276703,
0.30660930275917053,
-0.0947064757347107,
-0.43748944997787476,
0.24937096238136292,
0.2798697352409363,
0.2665310502052307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18034v1 | LLMs for Doctors: Leveraging Medical LLMs to Assist Doctors, Not Replace Them | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | 2024-06-26T03:08:24 | Wenya Xie, Qingying Xiao, Yu Zheng, Xidong Wang, Junying Chen, Ke Ji, Anningzhe Gao, Xiang Wan, Feng Jiang, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has had a significant
impact on the healthcare field, providing patients with medical advice,
diagnostic information, and more. However, due to a lack of professional
medical knowledge, patients are easily misled by generated erroneous
information from LLMs, which may result in serious medical problems. To address
this issue, we focus on tuning the LLMs to be medical assistants who
collaborate with more experienced doctors. We first conduct a two-stage survey
by inspiration-feedback to gain a broad understanding of the real needs of
doctors for medical assistants. Based on this, we construct a Chinese medical
dataset called DoctorFLAN to support the entire workflow of doctors, which
includes 92K Q\&A samples from 22 tasks and 27 specialists. Moreover, we
evaluate LLMs in doctor-oriented scenarios by constructing the
DoctorFLAN-\textit{test} containing 550 single-turn Q\&A and DotaBench
containing 74 multi-turn conversations. The evaluation results indicate that
being a medical assistant still poses challenges for existing open-source
models, but DoctorFLAN can help them significantly. It demonstrates that the
doctor-oriented dataset and benchmarks we construct can complement existing
patient-oriented work and better promote medical LLMs research. | [
-0.046689994633197784,
-0.5320124626159668,
1.0025821924209595,
-0.02464371733367443,
-0.3600517809391022,
-0.025509098544716835,
-0.12119228392839432,
-0.8015457987785339,
0.4559413194656372,
0.5558471083641052,
-0.3399355709552765,
-0.2780348062515259,
-0.7675440311431885,
0.40178826451301575,
-0.11875277757644653,
0.6336947679519653,
-0.04279615357518196,
0.7463269233703613,
-0.5360768437385559,
-0.04192288592457771,
-0.24153408408164978,
-0.2570021152496338,
-1.0371406078338623,
-0.4076631963253021,
0.6621816158294678,
0.547555148601532,
0.9356539249420166,
0.5713725686073303,
0.5614086389541626,
0.3042277991771698,
-0.05791127681732178,
0.7051059603691101,
-0.1186884194612503,
0.18780973553657532,
0.08742189407348633,
-0.46072348952293396,
-0.8312968611717224,
-0.04606812074780464,
0.21542653441429138,
0.8904334306716919,
-0.30609768629074097,
-0.18432503938674927,
-0.22194023430347443,
0.7078500986099243,
-0.05348251014947891,
0.1808793842792511,
-0.27414044737815857,
0.10975521057844162,
-0.18314418196678162,
-0.19568192958831787,
0.02117403969168663,
-0.3939121663570404,
-0.024222688749432564,
-0.7678483724594116,
0.06100398674607277,
0.0029011969454586506,
0.5222976803779602,
0.42858248949050903,
-0.29755353927612305,
-0.3285759687423706,
-0.71745765209198,
0.28675588965415955,
-0.9995976686477661,
0.23985613882541656,
0.4383072257041931,
0.38474395871162415,
-0.4100361466407776,
-0.5263528823852539,
-0.47802257537841797,
-0.12344939261674881,
-0.06471841782331467,
0.29996025562286377,
0.3828549385070801,
0.08655863255262375,
0.01159973070025444,
0.5043047070503235,
-0.09408397972583771,
0.4518292546272278,
-0.4188212752342224,
0.18382860720157623,
0.8860436677932739,
0.5820318460464478,
0.3795051574707031,
0.3002508282661438,
-0.16226044297218323,
0.04805535450577736,
-0.8851385712623596,
-0.05221940949559212,
-0.006344489753246307,
-0.0646074041724205,
-0.1032368615269661,
0.5809970498085022,
0.013290343806147575,
0.7760832905769348,
-0.08407307416200638,
-0.4464927911758423,
0.14596587419509888,
-0.4175974428653717,
-0.2847474217414856,
-0.24549318850040436,
0.814021646976471,
0.2763884663581848,
0.4848615229129791,
-0.019507264718413353,
-0.336993932723999,
-0.34012371301651,
0.4156595468521118,
-0.5549150705337524,
-0.35857003927230835,
0.4579409956932068,
-0.45885345339775085,
-0.36990150809288025,
0.17969250679016113,
-0.5784396529197693,
-0.9374555349349976,
-0.29347559809684753,
0.03307535499334335,
-0.08955839276313782,
-0.4611073136329651,
0.25513139367103577,
0.08816244453191757,
0.03860350698232651,
0.5597892999649048,
-0.7271818518638611,
0.33966588973999023,
0.7821990251541138,
0.7014836072921753,
-0.18564611673355103,
-0.16396154463291168,
-0.49268144369125366,
0.06403901427984238,
-0.5680117607116699,
0.771864116191864,
-0.575947105884552,
-0.683585524559021,
0.03383556380867958,
0.06914368271827698,
-0.05599899962544441,
-1.0375722646713257,
0.326560914516449,
0.017759526148438454,
0.23749308288097382,
-0.37354379892349243,
-0.5539669990539551,
0.17375199496746063,
0.2404191792011261,
-0.6378391981124878,
0.5569776296615601,
0.23388515412807465,
-0.29337385296821594,
0.2304149568080902,
-0.7856124043464661,
-0.6933057904243469,
0.09416523575782776,
-0.7005853056907654,
-0.45754656195640564,
0.3408292233943939,
0.3716754913330078,
0.6011064052581787,
-0.6511482000350952,
0.11581792682409286,
-0.19673313200473785,
-0.26400983333587646,
0.414414644241333,
-0.04164067283272743,
0.6048184037208557,
0.07409831136465073,
0.2527047097682953,
0.16410204768180847,
-0.5300203561782837,
-0.4193877875804901,
0.3155435621738434,
-0.40136924386024475,
-0.2772211730480194,
0.1942397952079773,
-0.14722885191440582,
0.28991594910621643,
-0.007549884729087353,
-0.5244830846786499,
0.3332589566707611,
-0.5555636882781982,
0.14954344928264618,
0.6080949902534485,
0.12538951635360718,
0.12605877220630646,
-0.584148108959198,
0.7879884839057922,
0.20361262559890747,
0.41525495052337646,
-0.039154358208179474,
-0.8195986747741699,
-0.36440789699554443,
-0.2787102460861206,
0.15636441111564636,
0.47508272528648376,
-0.8218058943748474,
0.2135837823152542,
-0.09341330826282501,
-0.39487797021865845,
-0.953978419303894,
0.38197073340415955,
0.21032018959522247,
0.8712666034698486,
0.19325102865695953,
-0.29275771975517273,
-0.26488280296325684,
-0.6510661840438843,
-0.19100695848464966,
-0.12236412614583969,
-0.28961822390556335,
0.6022481918334961,
0.01788501814007759,
-0.11855058372020721,
0.48700857162475586,
-0.3868701159954071,
-0.6978402733802795,
-0.27865901589393616,
-0.6010281443595886,
0.34076011180877686,
0.17833149433135986,
0.314142107963562,
-0.7067697644233704,
-0.41029852628707886,
0.13742183148860931,
-0.8467274308204651,
-0.2633052170276642,
-0.07501890510320663,
0.22016622126102448,
0.03367578983306885,
0.4474932849407196,
-0.5584219098091125,
0.06068795174360275,
0.5155562162399292,
-0.46629080176353455,
0.35766786336898804,
-0.43457117676734924,
0.002799171255901456,
-1.3190560340881348,
0.07278737425804138,
-0.07534743845462799,
-0.2734995186328888,
-0.664524495601654,
-0.29992496967315674,
-0.08541032671928406,
-0.11716112494468689,
-0.4326122999191284,
0.7531337141990662,
-0.5127517580986023,
-0.05315351113677025,
-0.5514693260192871,
0.11341159045696259,
-0.10760216414928436,
0.08127029985189438,
0.02591889724135399,
0.6969501376152039,
0.62356036901474,
-0.6038107872009277,
0.48629507422447205,
0.35314732789993286,
-0.2453032284975052,
0.9048269987106323,
-0.6772644519805908,
0.1322011649608612,
0.11183848232030869,
0.11857005208730698,
-0.5684378743171692,
-0.3212320804595947,
0.44356104731559753,
-0.4673893451690674,
0.31256571412086487,
0.10143478214740753,
-0.7733145356178284,
-0.3594649136066437,
-0.004363133106380701,
0.22344200313091278,
0.4385359287261963,
-0.43567708134651184,
0.6384667754173279,
0.603459894657135,
-0.2917661666870117,
-0.32177242636680603,
-0.5136305689811707,
0.20159418880939484,
0.09577678889036179,
-0.5308476686477661,
0.047422267496585846,
-0.08929944783449173,
-0.3091858923435211,
0.060190435498952866,
-0.19508974254131317,
-0.09784284979104996,
0.17484815418720245,
0.3801605999469757,
0.19668568670749664,
-0.06964368373155594,
0.20597845315933228,
0.056294769048690796,
-0.24023108184337616,
0.29411581158638,
-0.07589121162891388,
0.28429731726646423,
0.4546825587749481,
-0.7134628891944885,
-0.39724159240722656,
0.3667200803756714,
0.6785810589790344,
-0.21947462856769562,
0.5781040191650391,
0.24884280562400818,
-0.41786399483680725,
0.16204211115837097,
-0.5098464488983154,
-0.2939342260360718,
-0.42018836736679077,
0.43430131673812866,
-0.15989723801612854,
-0.5700031518936157,
0.3582722246646881,
-0.06230314448475838,
0.41533395648002625,
0.25796201825141907,
0.7237409949302673,
-0.2923303246498108,
0.9361269474029541,
0.4115504026412964,
-0.20248889923095703,
0.04330633953213692,
0.05096696689724922,
-0.05763377621769905,
-0.6090747117996216,
-0.513023316860199,
-0.2288142442703247,
-0.28075912594795227,
-0.28596362471580505,
-0.2581281363964081,
0.6904417872428894,
-0.3580252230167389,
0.22819997370243073,
-0.1437782645225525,
-0.34728673100471497,
0.33424845337867737,
0.25768470764160156,
0.3947562873363495,
0.274190753698349,
-0.32300326228141785,
0.030847353860735893,
0.3418635129928589,
-0.6960463523864746,
-0.2456996887922287,
1.0834200382232666,
0.4073376953601837,
0.8563593626022339,
0.06019698455929756,
0.6769587993621826,
0.011183288879692554,
0.280310720205307,
-0.7604382038116455,
0.5250996947288513,
-0.4598938226699829,
-0.2807149589061737,
-0.21901777386665344,
-0.28768035769462585,
-0.9593779444694519,
0.0805586576461792,
-0.26305148005485535,
-0.09415110945701599,
-0.018996426835656166,
0.2595514953136444,
-0.3644484579563141,
0.32017236948013306,
-0.48368680477142334,
0.6369746327400208,
-0.36801877617836,
-0.08812879770994186,
-0.1566195785999298,
-0.5659282803535461,
0.223516583442688,
-0.21065929532051086,
0.2614157199859619,
-0.1465165615081787,
-0.3200511932373047,
0.4623691439628601,
-0.6930747628211975,
0.9666129946708679,
-0.3585227131843567,
-0.45636019110679626,
-0.10164033621549606,
-0.2508704662322998,
0.40373489260673523,
0.2489989548921585,
-0.06393582373857498,
0.059543244540691376,
0.12298943847417831,
-0.44537457823753357,
-0.6075982451438904,
0.6670593619346619,
-0.5668394565582275,
-0.8395158052444458,
-0.2116178423166275,
-0.5224769711494446,
-0.5832228660583496,
0.10263343155384064,
-0.05772281065583229,
0.19667163491249084,
-0.08432026207447052,
-0.19104349613189697,
0.5100142359733582,
-0.021104086190462112,
0.09381867945194244,
0.5159437656402588,
-0.3073563873767853,
-0.21236416697502136,
0.5246895551681519,
-0.041875239461660385,
0.23020850121974945,
0.19155699014663696,
0.31060969829559326,
-0.06993266195058823,
-0.5010012984275818,
-0.5909876227378845,
0.5162075757980347,
-0.5417070388793945,
-0.12369426339864731,
-0.3866974413394928,
-0.2173364758491516,
-0.3372442424297333,
0.049255333840847015,
-0.2195146083831787,
-0.07908504456281662,
-0.5622638463973999,
0.0579117015004158,
0.4296315312385559,
0.9638193249702454,
0.20595097541809082,
0.13581378757953644,
-0.8722031712532043,
0.4207962453365326,
0.2773151993751526,
0.49825477600097656,
-0.130646213889122,
-0.34772369265556335,
-0.469989538192749,
-0.19941970705986023,
-0.04080873355269432,
-1.0491976737976074,
0.18525591492652893,
0.06543607264757156,
0.7104805111885071,
0.6677050590515137,
-0.18912696838378906,
0.4831143915653229,
-0.5566454529762268,
0.8107906579971313,
0.10226433724164963,
-0.3651902973651886,
0.3649049699306488,
-0.037920571863651276,
0.2759944498538971,
0.3582155108451843,
0.14652806520462036,
-0.5879706144332886,
-0.5676668286323547,
-0.39973124861717224,
-0.46277114748954773,
0.3638458549976349,
-0.15754041075706482,
0.13294193148612976,
0.09223385155200958,
0.5591413378715515,
0.1922065168619156,
0.08811069279909134,
-0.2112986147403717,
-0.24927037954330444,
0.0810282751917839,
-0.43682923913002014,
-0.18536247313022614,
-0.2596646547317505,
-0.46978381276130676,
-0.06375551968812943,
0.47212323546409607,
-0.12768521904945374,
0.19614015519618988,
0.44730305671691895,
0.22872929275035858,
-0.2153182476758957,
0.20533178746700287,
0.7485798597335815,
0.7567762732505798,
0.2087017148733139,
-0.027962317690253258,
0.1673232614994049,
-0.576802670955658,
0.025629539042711258,
0.2112753689289093,
0.2355881631374359,
0.15801359713077545,
0.27961456775665283,
0.41591349244117737,
-0.11414804309606552,
-0.818549633026123,
0.5932220816612244,
-0.01211965549737215,
-0.22704137861728668,
-0.4931228458881378,
0.32913345098495483,
0.25566133856773376,
0.28227850794792175,
0.18289467692375183,
-0.1555318385362625,
-0.09930775314569473,
-0.29440751671791077,
0.10281170904636383,
0.4975902736186981,
-0.30833178758621216,
-0.3706094026565552,
0.631193220615387,
0.39080676436424255,
-0.5770595073699951,
0.3804105520248413,
0.24906764924526215,
-0.15081019699573517,
0.5906765460968018,
0.46202895045280457,
0.5761409997940063,
-0.42909830808639526,
-0.13789331912994385,
-0.019725346937775612,
0.17384479939937592,
-0.2911890745162964,
0.5209705829620361,
0.20177683234214783,
-0.4463793635368347,
-0.41266804933547974,
0.048262108117341995,
-0.743380069732666,
0.12827500700950623,
-0.32400405406951904,
0.31256186962127686,
-0.5453822016716003,
-0.03209219127893448,
-0.13849568367004395,
-0.05658181384205818,
-0.6042414307594299,
0.24819812178611755,
0.021283086389303207,
0.9574342370033264,
-0.6821720600128174,
1.0361261367797852,
1.1182284355163574,
-0.34465593099594116,
-0.7074124813079834,
-0.0989518016576767,
0.08765800297260284,
-1.0502344369888306,
0.14848636090755463,
-0.021714117377996445,
0.11532710492610931,
-0.40031927824020386,
-0.4152388572692871,
-0.17386581003665924,
1.2886533737182617,
0.208644837141037,
-0.726843535900116,
-0.23282721638679504,
0.2854354679584503,
0.697770893573761,
-0.604388415813446,
0.06034268066287041,
0.28925028443336487,
0.3272436261177063,
-0.14097990095615387,
-1.1879198551177979,
0.14262588322162628,
-0.2969910800457001,
-0.3509908616542816,
0.04209993779659271,
-0.48912206292152405,
0.6983463168144226,
-0.5168324708938599,
0.19512304663658142,
0.170041024684906,
0.2987399697303772,
0.3178831934928894,
0.5034189224243164,
0.6093820333480835,
0.3353637158870697,
0.8336319923400879,
0.11472921073436737,
1.1019002199172974,
-0.282347172498703,
-0.22829216718673706,
0.9505212306976318,
-0.3501311242580414,
0.557935893535614,
0.7668923735618591,
-0.13080328702926636,
0.21578769385814667,
0.5188981294631958,
-0.05267481505870819,
0.10240714997053146,
0.09789988398551941,
-0.44626542925834656,
-0.3369859755039215,
-0.08696222305297852,
-0.49700841307640076,
0.30959340929985046,
0.5280383825302124,
-0.6043078303337097,
0.1599149852991104,
-0.014444179832935333,
0.12536776065826416,
0.23630468547344208,
-0.272612065076828,
1.0544085502624512,
0.4982268512248993,
-0.5460760593414307,
0.2216433435678482,
-0.2651101052761078,
0.4095075726509094,
-0.5174841284751892,
-0.17509350180625916,
-0.44119083881378174,
0.0565975122153759,
-0.4414227306842804,
-0.7870184779167175,
0.1266883909702301,
-0.11110837012529373,
-0.08083038777112961,
-0.04807481914758682,
0.6155019402503967,
-0.39744889736175537,
-0.5532281994819641,
0.04667806997895241,
0.8602248430252075,
0.4959139823913574,
0.05646807327866554,
-0.5809199810028076,
-0.2875465452671051,
-0.12107723951339722,
0.11049306392669678,
0.3807094991207123,
0.3534170687198639,
0.22630858421325684,
0.6867861151695251,
0.5481782555580139,
0.6806248426437378,
-0.23505906760692596,
0.3023630380630493,
0.7869213223457336,
-0.6111128330230713,
-0.2410782128572464,
-0.7962510585784912,
0.3617338538169861,
-0.09987831115722656,
-0.24989813566207886,
0.32398656010627747,
0.3373142182826996,
0.45145371556282043,
-0.18722586333751678,
0.6505826711654663,
0.3446267247200012,
0.854862630367279,
-0.6476032137870789,
0.8454229235649109,
-0.9183422923088074,
0.5001868605613708,
0.06516218930482864,
-0.39261165261268616,
-0.35032469034194946,
0.214366152882576,
-0.0011184468166902661,
0.15876774489879608,
0.31658363342285156,
0.6850090026855469,
-0.05821647122502327,
-0.12596763670444489,
0.6175714135169983,
0.027274727821350098,
0.48713529109954834,
0.6768171787261963,
0.6418521404266357,
-0.05946796014904976,
0.4314732253551483,
-0.04597800597548485,
-0.16119341552257538,
-0.22248190641403198,
-0.48920950293540955,
-0.876265287399292,
-0.3624418377876282,
-0.24755725264549255,
-0.22157451510429382,
0.0788068026304245,
0.9342293739318848,
0.6581912040710449,
-0.6510142683982849,
-0.10384392738342285,
0.16794320940971375,
0.14914339780807495,
-0.36215049028396606,
-0.10849660634994507,
0.3307380974292755,
-0.21224409341812134,
-0.7507299184799194,
0.6889615058898926,
0.305942565202713,
0.06880765408277512,
-0.5129044055938721,
-0.3089510500431061,
0.11041901260614395,
0.012599674053490162,
0.25356003642082214,
0.3742556571960449,
-0.7328107953071594,
0.10971106588840485,
0.25583416223526,
-0.23062770068645477,
0.39328476786613464,
0.9754408001899719,
-0.5488818287849426,
0.5330219864845276,
0.06450169533491135,
0.8771529793739319,
-0.08047236502170563,
-0.10924071818590164,
0.7782525420188904,
-0.4519485831260681,
-0.18516118824481964,
0.26213741302490234,
0.5807780623435974,
0.3470155894756317,
-0.5350469350814819,
0.5028820633888245,
0.051416363567113876,
-0.5198212265968323,
-0.6401011943817139,
0.1332727074623108,
-0.8851640224456787,
-0.37094637751579285,
1.2154021263122559,
-0.1876033991575241,
0.1278548687696457,
-0.31253084540367126,
-0.3704299032688141,
0.29409241676330566,
-0.26714351773262024,
0.8082643747329712,
0.43306124210357666,
-0.47060585021972656,
-0.39795711636543274,
-0.5885883569717407,
0.550995945930481,
0.6396291255950928,
-1.2283927202224731,
-0.19403564929962158,
0.38011449575424194,
0.3786369264125824,
-0.11591236293315887,
1.0316420793533325,
-0.36408647894859314,
0.4677828252315521,
-0.36131715774536133,
-0.1583024114370346,
-0.6519013047218323,
-0.2408638596534729,
-0.4520459473133087,
-0.11173465847969055,
0.44942787289619446,
-0.47128695249557495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18027v1 | Automated Clinical Data Extraction with Knowledge Conditioned LLMs | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | 2024-06-26T02:49:28 | Diya Li, Asim Kadav, Aijing Gao, Rui Li, Richard Bourgon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The extraction of lung lesion information from clinical and medical imaging
reports is crucial for research on and clinical care of lung-related diseases.
Large language models (LLMs) can be effective at interpreting unstructured text
in reports, but they often hallucinate due to a lack of domain-specific
knowledge, leading to reduced accuracy and posing challenges for use in
clinical settings. To address this, we propose a novel framework that aligns
generated internal knowledge with external knowledge through in-context
learning (ICL). Our framework employs a retriever to identify relevant units of
internal or external knowledge and a grader to evaluate the truthfulness and
helpfulness of the retrieved internal-knowledge rules, to align and update the
knowledge bases. Our knowledge-conditioned approach also improves the accuracy
and reliability of LLM outputs by addressing the extraction task in two stages:
(i) lung lesion finding detection and primary structured field parsing,
followed by (ii) further parsing of lesion description text into additional
structured fields. Experiments with expert-curated test datasets demonstrate
that this ICL approach can increase the F1 score for key fields (lesion size,
margin and solidity) by an average of 12.9% over existing ICL methods. | [
0.05657001957297325,
-0.5026236772537231,
0.930674135684967,
0.1941482275724411,
-0.37374305725097656,
-0.09978671371936798,
-0.22683554887771606,
-0.39183709025382996,
-0.05279888957738876,
0.7246193289756775,
-0.15292127430438995,
-0.6547540426254272,
-0.7757107615470886,
-0.04011291638016701,
-0.2642271816730499,
0.9737277626991272,
-0.12260393053293228,
0.34269988536834717,
-0.6607657670974731,
-0.15637414157390594,
-0.1279211789369583,
-0.574252724647522,
-0.6645927429199219,
-0.3740640878677368,
0.1769215613603592,
0.447385311126709,
0.3197005093097687,
0.5027411580085754,
0.9378718137741089,
0.27180248498916626,
0.17320725321769714,
0.2759653329849243,
-0.11830990016460419,
0.2055041342973709,
-0.024931499734520912,
-0.10915487259626389,
-0.15471287071704865,
-0.2623675763607025,
0.5273679494857788,
0.7515090703964233,
-0.09345487505197525,
-0.1517450511455536,
-0.13497468829154968,
0.7625486850738525,
-0.3400789201259613,
0.16822536289691925,
-0.6693584322929382,
0.11681802570819855,
0.007182369474321604,
-0.7133481502532959,
-0.4145043194293976,
-0.20842589437961578,
0.41687387228012085,
-0.6532872319221497,
0.19622375071048737,
-0.17715483903884888,
0.8559078574180603,
0.40315213799476624,
-0.5230587720870972,
-0.5131716132164001,
-0.2966550886631012,
0.468766987323761,
-0.8732419610023499,
0.4474152624607086,
0.42513906955718994,
0.42873069643974304,
-0.21457728743553162,
-1.0308088064193726,
-0.16317102313041687,
-0.2572316825389862,
-0.5726395845413208,
0.27819499373435974,
0.21186143159866333,
0.2047112137079239,
0.35099560022354126,
0.3365837037563324,
-0.331104576587677,
0.0792335569858551,
-0.5847458243370056,
-0.16124093532562256,
0.6901820302009583,
0.1818307489156723,
0.4126501679420471,
-0.22489728033542633,
-0.6094571948051453,
0.17201654613018036,
-0.7090157270431519,
0.06984788924455643,
-0.3287120461463928,
0.29598674178123474,
0.013818169012665749,
0.5660720467567444,
-0.24063324928283691,
0.8072133660316467,
0.18500085175037384,
-0.643523633480072,
0.3052452504634857,
-0.00592069374397397,
-0.7059360146522522,
0.22563804686069489,
0.6760290861129761,
0.2612089514732361,
-0.22685009241104126,
-0.351257860660553,
-0.2118198573589325,
-0.2865818738937378,
0.141474649310112,
-0.9662802219390869,
-0.19462253153324127,
0.2778051197528839,
-0.5540790557861328,
-0.578253448009491,
0.049057722091674805,
-0.5663026571273804,
-0.6376462578773499,
-0.41215452551841736,
0.40288764238357544,
-0.5279287099838257,
-0.019137918949127197,
0.13783039152622223,
-0.1100522056221962,
-0.08932359516620636,
0.4004878103733063,
-0.4182489514350891,
0.387264221906662,
0.2988739013671875,
0.6059901714324951,
-0.1254027634859085,
0.31829872727394104,
-0.9120495915412903,
0.30165088176727295,
-0.25631651282310486,
0.7073831558227539,
-0.5694948434829712,
-0.3330768942832947,
-0.06103954464197159,
0.1484052538871765,
-0.367451548576355,
-0.7926611304283142,
0.45222947001457214,
-0.6678290367126465,
0.40005242824554443,
0.008490247651934624,
-0.8012063503265381,
-0.26491957902908325,
0.39874452352523804,
-0.5459920763969421,
0.8340336680412292,
0.5543648600578308,
-0.5811626315116882,
0.6219587922096252,
-0.5140876770019531,
-0.41861492395401,
0.1436125487089157,
-0.41155776381492615,
-0.334670752286911,
0.04714299365878105,
0.4588935673236847,
0.627963125705719,
-0.2595820426940918,
0.735973060131073,
-0.2673909366130829,
0.00635422021150589,
0.23447944223880768,
-0.05415298044681549,
0.78309565782547,
0.08493997156620026,
-0.2930372357368469,
0.08782971650362015,
-0.7357500791549683,
0.10891580581665039,
-0.08151635527610779,
-0.542570948600769,
-0.22289533913135529,
-0.01360809151083231,
-0.2660876512527466,
0.4835505783557892,
-0.024183260276913643,
-0.7348107099533081,
0.22837167978286743,
-0.6575475335121155,
0.07284770160913467,
0.3808371126651764,
0.36330896615982056,
0.3436480462551117,
-0.4020078182220459,
0.3662550747394562,
0.39973151683807373,
-0.045088134706020355,
-0.025505291298031807,
-0.13284967839717865,
-0.49173858761787415,
-0.5970736145973206,
0.08028404414653778,
0.492179811000824,
-0.5295400023460388,
0.5361026525497437,
-0.15837933123111725,
-0.28788983821868896,
-0.3740044832229614,
0.3191784620285034,
0.29583311080932617,
1.057052731513977,
0.33838316798210144,
-0.17177072167396545,
-0.5541179180145264,
-0.9096761345863342,
0.04327298328280449,
0.034803591668605804,
-0.115420401096344,
0.4087927043437958,
0.09994123131036758,
-0.441314160823822,
0.7220123410224915,
-0.6661663055419922,
-0.9408197402954102,
-0.1347486525774002,
-0.06268341094255447,
0.054058924317359924,
0.42774662375450134,
0.3350198268890381,
-0.8102739453315735,
-0.5954302549362183,
0.3652178645133972,
-1.04799485206604,
-0.2757304608821869,
-0.11269621551036835,
-0.11043700575828552,
0.3386628031730652,
1.0409324169158936,
-0.49252137541770935,
0.6079970598220825,
0.3042074143886566,
-0.11282438784837723,
0.08553639054298401,
-0.295280784368515,
0.09278158843517303,
-0.7776145339012146,
0.18794982135295868,
0.07868365198373795,
-0.37454038858413696,
-0.3484770357608795,
-0.01332600973546505,
0.2926994264125824,
-0.10797204822301865,
-0.4213138222694397,
0.7040926814079285,
-0.3054858148097992,
0.11353595554828644,
-0.10097646713256836,
-0.019972003996372223,
0.46760424971580505,
0.3874001204967499,
0.3915337026119232,
0.4044102728366852,
0.3808271288871765,
-0.45106905698776245,
0.01838274858891964,
0.0870165154337883,
-0.43286627531051636,
0.24788714945316315,
-0.35515305399894714,
0.08463940769433975,
-0.1965891569852829,
0.5063635110855103,
-0.6276019215583801,
-0.48776766657829285,
0.18708421289920807,
-0.23552361130714417,
0.615496039390564,
-0.29136720299720764,
-0.5222207903862,
-0.07759542763233185,
0.16091762483119965,
0.33391717076301575,
0.2064494490623474,
-0.44227486848831177,
0.6517770886421204,
0.3751886188983917,
-0.13696229457855225,
-0.15620552003383636,
-0.4486730098724365,
-0.2745455503463745,
-0.3652456998825073,
-0.44128236174583435,
0.4392963945865631,
-0.10809890180826187,
-0.36745837330818176,
0.13594767451286316,
0.007106611505150795,
-0.3304232656955719,
0.0994892418384552,
0.21893088519573212,
0.18007105588912964,
-0.26361197233200073,
0.34313562512397766,
0.09126776456832886,
0.12965364754199982,
0.07254799455404282,
-0.4465894401073456,
0.08623720705509186,
0.015989268198609352,
-0.5827934145927429,
-0.3584887385368347,
0.2965041399002075,
0.7642068266868591,
-0.03425496071577072,
0.5370630025863647,
0.33713439106941223,
-0.8605291843414307,
0.09654030203819275,
-0.6588655114173889,
-0.1215861588716507,
-0.3814440071582794,
0.2958332896232605,
-0.29626646637916565,
-0.4916244447231293,
0.3271804749965668,
-0.22184191644191742,
-0.12202136963605881,
0.6065360903739929,
0.4517501890659332,
-0.31962111592292786,
1.100454568862915,
0.5898037552833557,
-0.07393545657396317,
0.02681831456720829,
-0.20193839073181152,
0.22419904172420502,
-1.0811126232147217,
-0.6298291087150574,
-0.25155916810035706,
-0.0574701763689518,
-0.1013421043753624,
-0.30402398109436035,
0.7241167426109314,
0.14671948552131653,
-0.14127759635448456,
-0.3172633647918701,
-0.588694155216217,
0.25943177938461304,
0.25009068846702576,
0.7060713768005371,
0.19492104649543762,
0.053347863256931305,
-0.11783161014318466,
-0.15199033915996552,
-0.7702184915542603,
-0.24299584329128265,
1.2265827655792236,
0.20022225379943848,
0.22903071343898773,
0.007669410668313503,
0.6862157583236694,
0.09488976001739502,
0.7421749830245972,
-0.8847571611404419,
0.1734458953142166,
-0.4261947274208069,
-0.5456238985061646,
-0.25912636518478394,
-0.19794169068336487,
-0.6944970488548279,
0.14053916931152344,
-0.03945334255695343,
-0.6246914863586426,
0.11784587055444717,
-0.007603040896356106,
-0.42205876111984253,
0.3039632737636566,
-0.5015401244163513,
0.5790573358535767,
-0.5324299335479736,
-0.20599351823329926,
0.08074601739645004,
-0.8935250639915466,
0.4818190038204193,
-0.2659286558628082,
0.43245214223861694,
-0.03378748893737793,
0.0020773857831954956,
0.6111447811126709,
-0.43049904704093933,
0.7162533402442932,
-0.4667470157146454,
0.02992628514766693,
0.09426048398017883,
0.14525549113750458,
0.3948797285556793,
0.19137844443321228,
-0.3567151725292206,
-0.23631352186203003,
0.21029436588287354,
-0.3314996063709259,
-0.8553192615509033,
0.6292458772659302,
-0.5252547860145569,
-0.4529465138912201,
-0.3249727785587311,
-0.7152795195579529,
-0.5129349231719971,
0.19780054688453674,
0.4402187466621399,
0.7355157732963562,
-0.06986326724290848,
0.24300096929073334,
0.6775779128074646,
-0.4498538672924042,
-0.13775083422660828,
0.6437878012657166,
-0.1196124255657196,
-0.6146721839904785,
0.8664929270744324,
-0.05420180782675743,
0.1113944798707962,
0.5424862504005432,
0.3597860038280487,
-0.004880152177065611,
-0.6954697370529175,
-0.42732730507850647,
0.16531792283058167,
-1.023274540901184,
-0.545095682144165,
-0.852683424949646,
-0.5472368597984314,
-0.39335906505584717,
-0.23605412244796753,
0.0015442125732079148,
-0.20271813869476318,
-0.4192001521587372,
-0.044195253401994705,
0.1850765198469162,
0.5269140601158142,
0.05712100490927696,
0.24611245095729828,
-0.9212235808372498,
0.12033193558454514,
-0.09824168682098389,
-0.0014043886912986636,
-0.38375863432884216,
-0.7258470058441162,
-0.39840397238731384,
-0.19856087863445282,
-0.12722168862819672,
-0.49300938844680786,
0.7227973937988281,
0.38600507378578186,
0.6188955903053284,
0.6405082941055298,
0.16835764050483704,
0.7745591998100281,
-0.16001977026462555,
0.4860157370567322,
0.06183788925409317,
-0.4941865801811218,
0.6276443004608154,
-0.0766027495265007,
0.03341493755578995,
0.7388388514518738,
0.23741909861564636,
-0.26600366830825806,
-0.46492812037467957,
-0.892139732837677,
-0.8447698354721069,
0.6665855646133423,
-0.22502535581588745,
-0.3520335555076599,
0.01995132677257061,
0.4269025921821594,
0.24156515300273895,
0.119868203997612,
-0.4870447814464569,
0.2231789082288742,
0.0749749168753624,
-0.6164265871047974,
-0.06806159019470215,
-0.1173945888876915,
-0.6218693852424622,
-0.5036401152610779,
0.7718912363052368,
-0.47702357172966003,
0.2362251728773117,
0.7037402391433716,
-0.5946595072746277,
-0.24554291367530823,
-0.206996887922287,
0.597984254360199,
0.6264898777008057,
-0.4606376886367798,
0.05440862104296684,
0.03286084532737732,
-0.04216219484806061,
-0.037399981170892715,
0.15819361805915833,
0.040310923010110855,
-0.18199336528778076,
0.656350314617157,
0.4184083342552185,
0.320835143327713,
-0.7960904240608215,
0.7048717141151428,
-0.0918719545006752,
-0.36973923444747925,
-0.4644472897052765,
-0.1963423639535904,
-0.19796597957611084,
0.2378653585910797,
0.3003903031349182,
0.3081749677658081,
0.25550806522369385,
-0.024600334465503693,
0.5739816427230835,
0.561460018157959,
-0.7599527835845947,
-0.02988119050860405,
0.2388073056936264,
0.09112799912691116,
0.1885109841823578,
0.7350777387619019,
0.1965889036655426,
-0.5153051614761353,
0.8349220156669617,
0.5813875794410706,
0.4679349958896637,
0.2708035707473755,
0.03200874477624893,
0.3514266014099121,
0.14056961238384247,
0.14914470911026,
-0.057153988629579544,
0.031321726739406586,
-0.5568073391914368,
-0.15116754174232483,
-0.5248047113418579,
-0.21721284091472626,
0.47746965289115906,
-0.7233432531356812,
0.38325342535972595,
-0.4688010811805725,
0.16756963729858398,
-0.15171454846858978,
0.19455981254577637,
-0.8125960826873779,
0.7103577256202698,
0.012531043030321598,
0.9975271224975586,
-0.7769243717193604,
1.0950396060943604,
0.5847101807594299,
-0.2947627305984497,
-1.032989501953125,
0.025588233023881912,
0.1667540818452835,
-0.8054917454719543,
1.0087796449661255,
0.3079048991203308,
0.3581756353378296,
-0.063099205493927,
-0.2080385684967041,
-0.9434065818786621,
1.0859811305999756,
0.3137775957584381,
-0.38719862699508667,
0.028050361201167107,
-0.15000119805335999,
0.507928192615509,
-0.6684802770614624,
0.284721314907074,
0.5918285250663757,
0.31310203671455383,
0.15127553045749664,
-0.6858693361282349,
0.2572823464870453,
-0.2539169192314148,
-0.5937595963478088,
0.040567949414253235,
-0.39681217074394226,
0.31331154704093933,
-0.23800860345363617,
-0.12701649963855743,
-0.019064726307988167,
0.41230013966560364,
0.18285539746284485,
0.634560763835907,
0.4717200994491577,
0.7184819579124451,
0.9489970803260803,
0.14110343158245087,
1.0316885709762573,
-0.5235474109649658,
-0.058982349932193756,
0.812481701374054,
-0.4621231257915497,
0.4975738525390625,
0.47363707423210144,
0.19733528792858124,
0.6492576599121094,
0.7484965920448303,
0.3755762279033661,
0.6941237449645996,
0.08153600245714188,
-0.37904179096221924,
-0.22702376544475555,
-0.020791972056031227,
-0.24123014509677887,
0.31915926933288574,
0.8204717636108398,
-0.7492696046829224,
-0.09719300270080566,
0.24496990442276,
-0.06612105667591095,
-0.2446402907371521,
0.10122014582157135,
1.264400601387024,
0.15880751609802246,
-0.8586706519126892,
0.5314319133758545,
-0.2054392397403717,
0.2545115053653717,
-0.8115748763084412,
-0.08339257538318634,
-0.2843164801597595,
0.3123704791069031,
-0.5004689693450928,
-0.38947656750679016,
0.4623776078224182,
-0.2515396475791931,
-0.28468775749206543,
0.06291575729846954,
0.8102067708969116,
-0.6424046754837036,
-0.8253096342086792,
0.44100672006607056,
0.20937444269657135,
0.10627812147140503,
0.024725819006562233,
-0.4376314878463745,
0.15099003911018372,
0.10829363018274307,
-0.17811839282512665,
0.6419081091880798,
0.6990431547164917,
-0.15289905667304993,
0.5378182530403137,
0.5461661219596863,
0.3552951514720917,
-0.3648854196071625,
0.02592792548239231,
1.0835336446762085,
-0.24103471636772156,
-0.04349130019545555,
-0.49095842242240906,
0.6242212057113647,
-0.2892727553844452,
-0.12399833649396896,
0.21236960589885712,
0.6147193908691406,
0.655474841594696,
0.2195352166891098,
0.994297981262207,
0.09867476671934128,
0.5634941458702087,
-0.8428799510002136,
0.5995782017707825,
-0.7921085953712463,
0.5295457243919373,
-0.016264451667666435,
-0.2063184380531311,
-0.6929340958595276,
0.3875665068626404,
-0.36642900109291077,
-0.3112722933292389,
0.811533510684967,
0.8546403050422668,
-0.26257362961769104,
-0.33639514446258545,
0.2651078701019287,
0.0752994641661644,
0.604363739490509,
0.4701710343360901,
0.36667951941490173,
-0.28591132164001465,
0.4178408980369568,
-0.6426512002944946,
-0.5042915344238281,
-0.26452702283859253,
-0.7897394299507141,
-0.6115662455558777,
-0.584152340888977,
-0.45380890369415283,
-0.172528937458992,
-0.025203382596373558,
1.0154000520706177,
0.9949313998222351,
-0.6882609724998474,
0.027832256630063057,
0.04533073678612709,
-0.10593760758638382,
-0.08851134777069092,
-0.25427860021591187,
0.8323422074317932,
-0.6847063899040222,
-0.3598553240299225,
0.6978510618209839,
0.35533756017684937,
-0.15150925517082214,
0.17054800689220428,
-0.13218502700328827,
0.09453640133142471,
-0.1739942580461502,
0.7385925650596619,
0.060475483536720276,
-0.7180200219154358,
-0.14129501581192017,
-0.11750540882349014,
-0.2856137752532959,
0.2585427761077881,
0.9696668982505798,
-1.1175633668899536,
0.731852650642395,
0.1476261466741562,
0.7265410423278809,
0.4297480285167694,
0.12218742072582245,
0.5853129029273987,
-0.8160903453826904,
0.29850247502326965,
0.44244277477264404,
0.33591029047966003,
0.41526350378990173,
-0.8643971085548401,
0.35141339898109436,
0.27805355191230774,
-0.6152734160423279,
-0.900927722454071,
-0.0585680790245533,
-0.7793627381324768,
-0.4196626842021942,
1.0541852712631226,
-0.21867112815380096,
0.04615636169910431,
-0.1343487799167633,
-0.2725384831428528,
0.22934536635875702,
-0.1376393586397171,
0.7723119854927063,
0.3649669587612152,
-0.4864085018634796,
-0.21867850422859192,
-0.28499913215637207,
0.7585132122039795,
0.23882725834846497,
-0.9085176587104797,
-0.31996917724609375,
0.4120752811431885,
0.4584484398365021,
-0.18332639336585999,
0.936772882938385,
-0.38627567887306213,
0.17185236513614655,
-0.5625085234642029,
-0.0907755121588707,
-0.14399299025535583,
-0.2752348482608795,
-0.1884324848651886,
0.18157736957073212,
0.09472700953483582,
0.023359335958957672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01599v1 | JailbreakZoo: Survey, Landscapes, and Horizons in Jailbreaking Large Language and Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | 2024-06-26T02:20:23 | Haibo Jin, Leyang Hu, Xinuo Li, Peiyan Zhang, Chonghan Chen, Jun Zhuang, Haohan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV, cs.LG | The rapid evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) through developments in
Large Language Models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models (VLMs) has brought
significant advancements across various technological domains. While these
models enhance capabilities in natural language processing and visual
interactive tasks, their growing adoption raises critical concerns regarding
security and ethical alignment. This survey provides an extensive review of the
emerging field of jailbreaking--deliberately circumventing the ethical and
operational boundaries of LLMs and VLMs--and the consequent development of
defense mechanisms. Our study categorizes jailbreaks into seven distinct types
and elaborates on defense strategies that address these vulnerabilities.
Through this comprehensive examination, we identify research gaps and propose
directions for future studies to enhance the security frameworks of LLMs and
VLMs. Our findings underscore the necessity for a unified perspective that
integrates both jailbreak strategies and defensive solutions to foster a
robust, secure, and reliable environment for the next generation of language
models. More details can be found on our website:
\url{https://chonghan-chen.com/llm-jailbreak-zoo-survey/}. | [
-0.48761820793151855,
-0.9443641901016235,
0.5016553997993469,
0.08452937006950378,
-0.11499481648206711,
0.46990904211997986,
-0.15844085812568665,
-0.8085587024688721,
0.26079145073890686,
0.9669086933135986,
-0.3678349256515503,
-0.3945586383342743,
-0.6402872800827026,
0.04315056651830673,
-0.42075589299201965,
0.9408113956451416,
0.1900320053100586,
0.08144626766443253,
-0.13804064691066742,
-0.2834945619106293,
-0.5680216550827026,
-0.6747421026229858,
0.027247099205851555,
-0.007909194566309452,
0.35606062412261963,
0.17849603295326233,
0.6548603773117065,
0.6620515584945679,
0.7176563143730164,
0.3228670656681061,
-0.20659089088439941,
-0.05133051425218582,
-0.2509463131427765,
0.3250780999660492,
-0.24406798183918,
-0.3206534683704376,
-0.15131527185440063,
0.05297612026333809,
0.17973588407039642,
0.5248918533325195,
0.05476203188300133,
0.005825442727655172,
-0.3142390847206116,
0.8297868371009827,
-0.8876615166664124,
-0.2279302328824997,
-0.7407562732696533,
0.16929511725902557,
-0.4795930087566376,
0.21047939360141754,
-0.3791441023349762,
-0.15267913043498993,
0.06011063605546951,
-0.44409438967704773,
-0.33401787281036377,
0.08154220879077911,
0.5507727861404419,
0.08031624555587769,
-0.25649988651275635,
-0.125239297747612,
-0.6771960854530334,
0.7647054195404053,
-0.6214081048965454,
0.14385248720645905,
0.39371243119239807,
0.24268369376659393,
-0.24848443269729614,
-0.5600831508636475,
-0.3042728900909424,
-0.6160417199134827,
0.3851531445980072,
-0.02285371720790863,
-0.25004780292510986,
0.1405854970216751,
0.1936517208814621,
0.2873932719230652,
-0.2834298014640808,
0.387340784072876,
-0.5896399617195129,
-0.20766085386276245,
0.7558737993240356,
0.23130212724208832,
0.6569641828536987,
-0.034094080328941345,
-0.3480500280857086,
0.03126691281795502,
-0.9689019918441772,
0.18137851357460022,
0.5485095977783203,
0.2732659876346588,
-0.14111702144145966,
0.7782762050628662,
-0.13118323683738708,
0.7867498993873596,
-0.28144532442092896,
-0.10778491944074631,
0.20154225826263428,
-0.35977956652641296,
-0.15209068357944489,
-0.07614165544509888,
0.8651666045188904,
0.5711248517036438,
0.37148958444595337,
-0.35768646001815796,
-0.2056950479745865,
-0.16594679653644562,
0.6399328708648682,
-0.42845988273620605,
0.028755052015185356,
0.2772558927536011,
-0.4837065041065216,
-0.8158702254295349,
0.14575515687465668,
-0.9071571826934814,
-1.0569720268249512,
0.03799836337566376,
0.1012190729379654,
-0.4365368187427521,
-0.3000811040401459,
0.1257311850786209,
-0.24050186574459076,
0.5117647051811218,
0.18988248705863953,
-0.9140276312828064,
0.2625395655632019,
0.7930713891983032,
0.8175333738327026,
0.050405509769916534,
-0.4520142674446106,
-0.396318256855011,
-0.00008135336975101382,
-0.31977227330207825,
0.521653413772583,
-0.44200432300567627,
-0.6658205986022949,
0.061522673815488815,
-0.2387569695711136,
0.1344946175813675,
-0.5551875829696655,
0.2730713188648224,
-0.582810640335083,
-0.3023412525653839,
-0.0878395363688469,
-0.37813514471054077,
-0.14044351875782013,
0.44150078296661377,
-0.7317977547645569,
0.4692569971084595,
-0.04746111109852791,
-0.7592057585716248,
0.43939876556396484,
-0.7107479572296143,
-0.5450433492660522,
0.25520023703575134,
-0.18720310926437378,
-0.34020015597343445,
0.07469412684440613,
0.15715305507183075,
0.1684415638446808,
-0.06711481511592865,
0.41662082076072693,
-0.632202684879303,
-0.18834717571735382,
0.08749271184206009,
-0.1590578258037567,
1.1532671451568604,
0.49416112899780273,
-0.658271074295044,
0.32536742091178894,
-0.50777268409729,
-0.2136329561471939,
0.5303524732589722,
-0.16186289489269257,
-0.5517165064811707,
0.4388936460018158,
0.12565475702285767,
0.0307255070656538,
0.2838013768196106,
-0.6902135014533997,
0.4299317002296448,
-0.4028192460536957,
0.8780763745307922,
0.6749680638313293,
-0.07764165103435516,
0.6409364938735962,
-0.010468803346157074,
0.37698641419410706,
0.07489702105522156,
0.6426004767417908,
-0.22644685208797455,
-0.29477930068969727,
-0.37251436710357666,
-0.03507142513990402,
0.0011019756784662604,
0.8478410243988037,
-0.30658191442489624,
0.3416175842285156,
0.02547139674425125,
-0.6866268515586853,
-0.3045418858528137,
0.2697376608848572,
0.21704591810703278,
0.2169085443019867,
0.3425837457180023,
-0.33721256256103516,
-0.6926484107971191,
-0.8946148157119751,
-0.519661009311676,
-0.4101448953151703,
0.17114321887493134,
0.187111958861351,
0.520910382270813,
-0.4197632372379303,
0.9521777033805847,
-0.0769961029291153,
-0.2243691384792328,
-0.48517531156539917,
-0.39216187596321106,
-0.11877142637968063,
0.4905281364917755,
0.8672915697097778,
-0.9080185294151306,
-0.053133875131607056,
-0.16242972016334534,
-0.9267749190330505,
0.12666046619415283,
0.008922453038394451,
0.21634045243263245,
0.06873750686645508,
0.7178926467895508,
-0.9044666886329651,
0.5245925784111023,
0.19077350199222565,
-0.5259721875190735,
0.7176942229270935,
0.17918744683265686,
-0.035946909338235855,
-0.7172256112098694,
-0.20548588037490845,
0.008573015220463276,
-0.06448490172624588,
-0.7902646660804749,
0.7259975671768188,
-0.17571957409381866,
0.04481564462184906,
-0.4983925223350525,
0.35687583684921265,
-0.45202380418777466,
-0.18625304102897644,
-0.19834674894809723,
0.2026064395904541,
-0.23842068016529083,
-0.18937955796718597,
-0.13209748268127441,
0.6670371294021606,
0.7832106947898865,
-0.18034741282463074,
0.6970418095588684,
0.2567368745803833,
-0.4144245982170105,
0.09528043121099472,
-0.48641201853752136,
0.06239006295800209,
0.08195573091506958,
0.20223532617092133,
-0.5238825678825378,
-0.22649389505386353,
0.5069180727005005,
-0.34799277782440186,
0.035054173320531845,
-0.1063259020447731,
-0.4477476477622986,
-0.41619545221328735,
-0.6841166019439697,
0.3095596134662628,
0.4922175705432892,
-0.35453954339027405,
0.5308698415756226,
0.793913722038269,
-0.2066950500011444,
-0.8337106108665466,
-0.7001862525939941,
0.7293283343315125,
-0.6185839772224426,
-0.7086673974990845,
0.14411304891109467,
0.20983150601387024,
-1.0337461233139038,
-0.23179654777050018,
0.06778360903263092,
0.07950638234615326,
0.45472750067710876,
0.3430441617965698,
0.4436090588569641,
-0.19729958474636078,
-0.3583178222179413,
-0.24936923384666443,
0.3011617362499237,
0.4066808521747589,
-0.3021615743637085,
0.47195881605148315,
-0.40805935859680176,
-0.16834436357021332,
0.08043952286243439,
0.453573614358902,
0.8803770542144775,
-0.4825056195259094,
0.8721702098846436,
0.08732921630144119,
-0.12077056616544724,
0.08481916785240173,
-0.5675290822982788,
0.03522208333015442,
-0.4620317220687866,
0.3707868456840515,
-0.16674326360225677,
-1.1391481161117554,
0.5220995545387268,
-0.1274382323026657,
0.40711739659309387,
0.24407564103603363,
0.5457267761230469,
-0.04759051278233528,
0.5813959836959839,
1.0030187368392944,
-0.5738319158554077,
0.6042959690093994,
0.029109328985214233,
0.43239161372184753,
-0.6323308348655701,
-0.45898932218551636,
-0.42241171002388,
-0.043826885521411896,
-0.6179628372192383,
-0.056473538279533386,
-0.022168733179569244,
0.1270672231912613,
-0.2438727617263794,
0.4460563659667969,
-0.38781073689460754,
0.5182980298995972,
0.4306447207927704,
-0.10589594393968582,
0.27864694595336914,
-0.25970059633255005,
-0.08459405601024628,
0.2575458884239197,
-0.32154375314712524,
-0.6737679243087769,
1.2368464469909668,
0.4753217101097107,
0.6952797770500183,
0.20939196646213531,
0.7859959602355957,
0.40648776292800903,
0.16775983572006226,
-0.778100311756134,
0.6893413662910461,
0.011386989615857601,
-0.7343900799751282,
-0.4250289499759674,
-0.060583293437957764,
-0.7716871500015259,
0.35813164710998535,
-0.09388799220323563,
-1.3760639429092407,
-0.07839271426200867,
-0.014800543896853924,
-0.3182220458984375,
0.5445370078086853,
-0.5033904910087585,
0.7919241189956665,
-0.5871285200119019,
-0.3812141716480255,
-0.22166778147220612,
-1.1296335458755493,
0.7920623421669006,
-0.0717892274260521,
0.5029406547546387,
-0.22228646278381348,
0.07696602493524551,
0.5376008749008179,
-0.6618164777755737,
0.7991206645965576,
-0.36078381538391113,
-0.09842376410961151,
0.45357251167297363,
0.05378222092986107,
0.2530871629714966,
0.16425256431102753,
0.32355496287345886,
0.17338116466999054,
-0.04770474508404732,
-0.24855369329452515,
-0.05566806346178055,
0.5066617131233215,
-0.71406489610672,
-0.9890452027320862,
-0.3239116370677948,
-0.5909537672996521,
-0.41418445110321045,
0.35753944516181946,
0.3367270827293396,
0.08826575428247452,
-0.3472974896430969,
0.07156697660684586,
0.7911490797996521,
-0.3690422773361206,
0.5111529231071472,
0.23373422026634216,
-0.6398703455924988,
-0.21356719732284546,
0.5519536137580872,
-0.11842801421880722,
0.130698561668396,
0.0057596988044679165,
-0.017824368551373482,
-0.13251832127571106,
-0.9372915029525757,
-0.503025233745575,
-0.11681374907493591,
-0.47082090377807617,
-0.1333318054676056,
-0.5403503179550171,
-0.5019262433052063,
-0.5570952296257019,
-0.3014346659183502,
-0.34036391973495483,
-0.2275218516588211,
0.07432334125041962,
-0.23591972887516022,
0.6573343276977539,
0.6960865259170532,
-0.09488830715417862,
0.19068770110607147,
-0.7478747367858887,
0.4259754717350006,
0.004179209470748901,
0.17673245072364807,
-0.18470463156700134,
-0.33506977558135986,
-0.04704199358820915,
-0.10054574906826019,
-0.26512420177459717,
-0.8851932287216187,
0.16949225962162018,
-0.07529446482658386,
0.5179306268692017,
0.3439023792743683,
0.012940495274960995,
0.40503019094467163,
-0.7623263001441956,
0.8862001299858093,
0.2846321761608124,
-0.8153003454208374,
0.6945683360099792,
-0.49488967657089233,
0.030078602954745293,
0.7099665403366089,
-0.06215648353099823,
-0.500487208366394,
-0.7957746386528015,
-0.3206630349159241,
-1.1202553510665894,
0.33607882261276245,
-0.016398413106799126,
0.4743528962135315,
0.30379927158355713,
0.1906597912311554,
-0.11438790708780289,
0.15537254512310028,
-0.8043214082717896,
-0.07351281493902206,
-0.26762107014656067,
-0.03209511935710907,
0.049376413226127625,
-0.04714861139655113,
-0.35729971528053284,
-0.3086254894733429,
0.2790757715702057,
0.2515062987804413,
-0.10053907334804535,
-0.10053203999996185,
-0.33049142360687256,
0.16301637887954712,
0.355162113904953,
0.7162622213363647,
0.5343475937843323,
-0.005438291933387518,
-0.10732654482126236,
0.020068295300006866,
-0.9599357843399048,
0.32879403233528137,
0.00988156907260418,
-0.3619248867034912,
-0.2547563314437866,
0.35156166553497314,
0.6186817288398743,
-0.1562023162841797,
-1.101323127746582,
0.6630525588989258,
0.08840694278478622,
-0.2270776927471161,
-0.6008722186088562,
0.18571160733699799,
-0.125277578830719,
0.3435874581336975,
0.37891530990600586,
0.16596662998199463,
0.23102368414402008,
-0.601394772529602,
0.1040613129734993,
0.616946816444397,
-0.17713716626167297,
0.03225447237491608,
0.7285180687904358,
0.1428096890449524,
-0.29703423380851746,
0.9019110202789307,
0.22384265065193176,
-0.43303459882736206,
0.7545278668403625,
0.3621320128440857,
0.9518762230873108,
-0.03953094407916069,
0.09438560158014297,
-0.1488935947418213,
0.8501452207565308,
-0.009047717787325382,
-0.03943391516804695,
-0.11456787586212158,
-0.8586323261260986,
-0.28139522671699524,
-0.5295683145523071,
-0.4423879086971283,
0.4012101888656616,
-0.6318464279174805,
0.08652477711439133,
-0.8013221025466919,
-0.2272990643978119,
-0.06155560910701752,
-0.24927569925785065,
-0.06165069714188576,
-0.026444032788276672,
0.5117225050926208,
1.392647385597229,
-0.5219143629074097,
0.7572758793830872,
0.6382942795753479,
-0.291997492313385,
-0.4446556866168976,
-0.011422408744692802,
0.47260504961013794,
-0.5593163967132568,
0.5121474862098694,
0.3728333115577698,
-0.33020874857902527,
-0.33608993887901306,
-0.8697484135627747,
-0.6878491640090942,
0.7551860809326172,
0.11345291882753372,
-0.664431631565094,
-0.08838369697332382,
0.17291748523712158,
0.3198704123497009,
-0.33111342787742615,
-0.42632031440734863,
1.0155690908432007,
0.4832145869731903,
-0.4216431975364685,
-0.727165937423706,
-0.24220368266105652,
-0.40270134806632996,
0.0006948714144527912,
0.3822193443775177,
-0.6543552875518799,
0.4605126678943634,
-0.6880632638931274,
0.13575342297554016,
0.410186767578125,
0.42101335525512695,
0.6315950155258179,
0.3339692950248718,
0.3683239817619324,
0.6757938265800476,
0.21552221477031708,
-0.17353203892707825,
0.8754763007164001,
-0.251164048910141,
0.0502200722694397,
0.8387715816497803,
-0.4371598958969116,
0.7000339031219482,
0.8418260812759399,
-0.09939274191856384,
0.2812821865081787,
0.5876214504241943,
-0.48509925603866577,
0.6770029664039612,
0.437907338142395,
-0.23390129208564758,
-0.004444405902177095,
0.23371614515781403,
-0.2046612799167633,
0.7495645880699158,
0.45392903685569763,
-0.28790920972824097,
-0.18217577040195465,
0.34572306275367737,
0.16269370913505554,
0.057390861213207245,
-0.5409175753593445,
0.7964900732040405,
0.11291877925395966,
-0.4078703820705414,
0.07536834478378296,
0.31647801399230957,
0.7534627914428711,
-0.6159262657165527,
0.2449832558631897,
-0.16829903423786163,
-0.03950248286128044,
-0.1417570263147354,
-0.8379391431808472,
0.2657873332500458,
0.5838213562965393,
0.08624540269374847,
-0.21865272521972656,
0.7918369770050049,
0.1506073772907257,
-0.11356189846992493,
0.45022836327552795,
0.34320536255836487,
0.007111174985766411,
0.19394564628601074,
-0.736363410949707,
0.3935311734676361,
-0.2314966470003128,
-0.3798328936100006,
0.5173491835594177,
-0.13504008948802948,
-0.1592686027288437,
0.8725091218948364,
0.44409212470054626,
0.042458225041627884,
0.3525243103504181,
-0.057076405733823776,
0.9309142231941223,
-0.7562596797943115,
-0.4024111330509186,
-1.3485532999038696,
0.45612743496894836,
-0.27435413002967834,
-0.33508798480033875,
0.8117931485176086,
0.5819449424743652,
0.8571456074714661,
0.040319181978702545,
0.995991051197052,
-0.3029502034187317,
0.06978718936443329,
-0.5993645191192627,
1.0669212341308594,
-0.2912759780883789,
0.2369544357061386,
-0.5019091367721558,
-0.743272066116333,
-0.25722646713256836,
0.4415775239467621,
-0.42306259274482727,
-0.1399799883365631,
0.17387962341308594,
0.3742351830005646,
0.26612356305122375,
-0.08612585812807083,
0.29987943172454834,
0.07124271988868713,
0.20075781643390656,
0.5130152702331543,
1.2554937601089478,
-0.16063126921653748,
0.39406973123550415,
-0.1297013908624649,
-0.18414856493473053,
-0.2557828724384308,
-0.5514892339706421,
-0.7458503842353821,
-0.3143695294857025,
-0.052883654832839966,
-0.19233301281929016,
0.1472972184419632,
0.6034039855003357,
0.4579295516014099,
-0.6789714097976685,
-0.3980195224285126,
-0.21245136857032776,
0.09980326145887375,
0.012028922326862812,
-0.22015349566936493,
-0.3004942834377289,
-0.34295526146888733,
-0.23136864602565765,
0.543341875076294,
0.6767876744270325,
0.010926383547484875,
-0.5034487247467041,
0.036967042833566666,
-0.008791093714535236,
0.2163545787334442,
0.7337737679481506,
0.6769263744354248,
-1.0799927711486816,
-0.16529744863510132,
0.0032673836685717106,
-0.2710641324520111,
0.056134141981601715,
0.7479532957077026,
-0.717402994632721,
0.33826151490211487,
0.10138827562332153,
0.8985506892204285,
0.015070896595716476,
-0.20662638545036316,
0.5522045493125916,
-0.18034523725509644,
0.35664016008377075,
0.3162600100040436,
0.5057711601257324,
0.22791777551174164,
-0.31104400753974915,
0.42209091782569885,
0.20749278366565704,
-0.39689695835113525,
-1.0207147598266602,
0.6247292757034302,
-0.7392598390579224,
-0.5445858836174011,
0.8104809522628784,
-0.0896516889333725,
-0.28318753838539124,
-0.2278030663728714,
-0.07251187413930893,
-0.1734025627374649,
-0.0464494526386261,
0.9357073903083801,
0.7820117473602295,
-0.055946189910173416,
-0.3013419806957245,
-0.6948294043540955,
0.3333378732204437,
0.05696367844939232,
-0.9395822882652283,
0.2589845359325409,
0.6423804759979248,
0.26321592926979065,
0.2614514231681824,
0.3259473741054535,
-0.5173535943031311,
0.39141789078712463,
-0.0031717903912067413,
-0.10490231215953827,
-0.08048267662525177,
-0.4238404631614685,
-0.42819246649742126,
0.1989213079214096,
0.21758215129375458,
0.0038772178813815117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18002v1 | Decoding with Limited Teacher Supervision Requires Understanding When to Trust the Teacher | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | 2024-06-26T01:16:12 | Hyunjong Ok, Jegwang Ryu, Jaeho Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How can sLLMs efficiently utilize the supervision of LLMs to improve their
generative quality? This question has been well studied in scenarios where
there is no restriction on the number of LLM supervisions one can use, giving
birth to many decoding algorithms that utilize supervision without further
training. However, it is still unclear what is an effective strategy under the
limited supervision scenario, where we assume that no more than a few tokens
can be generated by LLMs. To this end, we develop an algorithm to effectively
aggregate the sLLM and LLM predictions on initial tokens so that the generated
tokens can more accurately condition the subsequent token generation by sLLM
only. Critically, we find that it is essential to adaptively overtrust or
disregard the LLM prediction based on the confidence of the sLLM. Through our
experiments on a wide range of models and datasets, we demonstrate that our
method provides a consistent improvement over conventional decoding strategies. | [
-0.13656526803970337,
-0.2579389810562134,
0.6450204849243164,
0.21322953701019287,
-0.49512922763824463,
0.24873992800712585,
-0.0033609026577323675,
-0.4088033437728882,
-0.04730549827218056,
0.42022284865379333,
-0.33062419295310974,
-0.6545186638832092,
-1.0837171077728271,
0.16411811113357544,
-0.6447395086288452,
1.0264315605163574,
0.05608504265546799,
0.5050978064537048,
-0.42123839259147644,
0.028376422822475433,
-0.3522033393383026,
-0.4735530614852905,
-0.7192407846450806,
-0.5571319460868835,
0.14989547431468964,
0.3987422287464142,
0.503387987613678,
0.5360960364341736,
0.3348222076892853,
0.12052130699157715,
-0.4255215525627136,
0.7280030250549316,
-0.7291373014450073,
0.07902469485998154,
-0.05167030915617943,
-0.6829795837402344,
-0.5534592270851135,
-0.2583272159099579,
0.47876977920532227,
0.47569969296455383,
-0.24561083316802979,
0.34394755959510803,
0.26144248247146606,
0.3293135166168213,
-0.6963921785354614,
0.15560069680213928,
-0.96819669008255,
0.2431536614894867,
0.12015677988529205,
-0.6067696213722229,
-0.9593140482902527,
-0.2865602672100067,
-0.041249725967645645,
-0.6955665946006775,
0.19642825424671173,
0.11941393464803696,
0.42497265338897705,
0.09215181320905685,
-0.4357113540172577,
-0.34383630752563477,
-0.4372541606426239,
0.8818739652633667,
-0.49209925532341003,
0.3301783502101898,
0.7912369966506958,
-0.048388395458459854,
-0.2700859606266022,
-0.9026268720626831,
-0.14262616634368896,
0.08849210292100906,
-0.2822954058647156,
0.20432233810424805,
0.07194644957780838,
0.2502146065235138,
0.24383170902729034,
0.17864178121089935,
-0.03535453602671623,
0.09084966033697128,
-0.4457346200942993,
-0.39175793528556824,
0.30100104212760925,
0.38083893060684204,
-0.01441182754933834,
-0.07470987737178802,
-0.7279843091964722,
0.06508876383304596,
-0.7684845328330994,
0.12965644896030426,
0.16386060416698456,
0.103971466422081,
0.03224394470453262,
0.4593179225921631,
0.2938719391822815,
0.48350661993026733,
0.12178962677717209,
-0.3141842782497406,
-0.0877009779214859,
-0.32879093289375305,
-0.3538878560066223,
0.382194846868515,
0.19054460525512695,
0.5495350360870361,
0.1766534447669983,
-0.39002057909965515,
-0.28668418526649475,
0.39026784896850586,
0.3199038803577423,
-0.48755040764808655,
-0.06822865456342697,
0.16913574934005737,
-0.36728981137275696,
-0.3980041742324829,
0.019298173487186432,
-0.693156361579895,
-0.6676512360572815,
-0.23551669716835022,
0.36639758944511414,
-0.5313525199890137,
-0.19965963065624237,
0.14714525640010834,
-0.1509000062942505,
0.21824538707733154,
0.3092356026172638,
-1.0088696479797363,
0.49475979804992676,
0.8862061500549316,
0.9319530725479126,
-0.3778652846813202,
-0.4857655167579651,
-0.8556419014930725,
0.19435058534145355,
-0.6034246683120728,
0.14899149537086487,
-0.22804442048072815,
-0.6050899028778076,
-0.0068250554613769054,
-0.29485008120536804,
-0.0795033797621727,
-0.17694596946239471,
0.5896958112716675,
-0.7760915160179138,
-0.10608891397714615,
-0.1520473062992096,
-0.9477725625038147,
0.29487210512161255,
0.03299179673194885,
-0.43634968996047974,
0.7247656583786011,
0.34509527683258057,
-0.9493227005004883,
0.6587984561920166,
-0.34718120098114014,
-0.37091201543807983,
-0.0806310623884201,
-0.07289492338895798,
-0.3749708831310272,
0.5110802054405212,
0.560497522354126,
0.4412418007850647,
0.20721516013145447,
0.3426440954208374,
-0.20940974354743958,
-0.7816846370697021,
0.36831170320510864,
-0.438739538192749,
0.9053297638893127,
0.297840416431427,
-0.14706595242023468,
0.054530903697013855,
-0.5559695363044739,
0.22240683436393738,
-0.07823698967695236,
-0.31685683131217957,
-0.29299384355545044,
-0.009793314151465893,
-0.2305382788181305,
-0.45909348130226135,
0.11621022969484329,
-0.29719656705856323,
0.10881255567073822,
-0.6445797681808472,
0.41194412112236023,
1.2810981273651123,
0.17067646980285645,
0.7357189655303955,
-0.18771030008792877,
0.5759913921356201,
0.18082351982593536,
0.31790319085121155,
-0.4600065350532532,
-0.13766099512577057,
-1.1145626306533813,
-0.15658527612686157,
0.23537583649158478,
0.26465684175491333,
-0.8937985897064209,
0.19820982217788696,
-0.4088872969150543,
-0.015783678740262985,
-0.8365046381950378,
0.3812500834465027,
0.4947744905948639,
0.32562726736068726,
0.4551742970943451,
-0.4210924506187439,
-0.9737986922264099,
-0.3165052533149719,
-0.1844397336244583,
-0.03594745695590973,
0.13569515943527222,
0.06088199093937874,
0.29559406638145447,
-0.03326378017663956,
0.9330988526344299,
-0.308851420879364,
-0.34065863490104675,
-0.031923893839120865,
-0.11225979775190353,
0.4339274764060974,
0.4934583604335785,
0.4525102376937866,
-0.5253313779830933,
-0.642475426197052,
-0.12704941630363464,
-0.7596186399459839,
0.40666070580482483,
-0.2601945996284485,
-0.22307831048965454,
0.28629299998283386,
0.6550010442733765,
-0.6956459879875183,
0.44366970658302307,
0.6626761555671692,
-0.5206625461578369,
0.31886669993400574,
-0.3319757580757141,
-0.23525255918502808,
-0.9237546920776367,
-0.39780569076538086,
-0.41079622507095337,
-0.6224384903907776,
-0.6247406005859375,
0.3434324264526367,
0.11178646981716156,
0.12465354800224304,
-0.20561017096042633,
0.19707393646240234,
-0.6963368058204651,
-0.20919330418109894,
-0.26119664311408997,
0.007103233598172665,
-0.050487417727708817,
0.35313135385513306,
-0.061875805258750916,
0.9044576287269592,
0.9509715437889099,
-0.4090297520160675,
0.2383815348148346,
0.20170703530311584,
-0.6603484749794006,
0.4617946445941925,
-0.4423777163028717,
0.30907002091407776,
-0.18838168680667877,
0.268904447555542,
-0.8633108735084534,
-0.05007629096508026,
0.23517116904258728,
-0.5674353837966919,
0.4499894380569458,
-0.2894468307495117,
-0.49427035450935364,
-0.27797383069992065,
-0.23692762851715088,
0.26026633381843567,
0.7994851469993591,
-0.9543762803077698,
0.676678478717804,
0.02040068246424198,
0.33823540806770325,
-0.7937942147254944,
-0.8118513822555542,
0.24429631233215332,
-0.17338353395462036,
-0.19817127287387848,
0.13422490656375885,
0.09213036298751831,
-0.13957203924655914,
0.23890189826488495,
-0.5289642214775085,
-0.07285748422145844,
0.30318978428840637,
0.40282660722732544,
0.2382386177778244,
-0.17312029004096985,
-0.1422652155160904,
0.17277853190898895,
-0.22506308555603027,
0.21613746881484985,
-0.5816788077354431,
0.444894939661026,
0.10639485716819763,
-0.5389634370803833,
-0.13445639610290527,
0.23917599022388458,
0.6337311267852783,
0.009107089601457119,
0.9116052389144897,
0.7984985709190369,
-0.178593710064888,
-0.7794381380081177,
-0.3030444383621216,
-0.3568829894065857,
-0.5269855856895447,
0.10751544684171677,
-0.38972243666648865,
-0.8743383884429932,
0.4238312244415283,
0.1461031138896942,
-0.05700383335351944,
-0.10634709894657135,
0.29537516832351685,
0.028907638043165207,
0.9574971795082092,
0.612152636051178,
-0.32999923825263977,
0.2938963770866394,
-0.27430260181427,
0.01216891873627901,
-0.8316221833229065,
-0.3111911416053772,
0.10780969262123108,
0.022314978763461113,
-0.3916543126106262,
-0.5502303242683411,
0.37516456842422485,
0.34464430809020996,
0.021984681487083435,
0.1694275140762329,
-0.6621370911598206,
0.6369675993919373,
0.7992205023765564,
0.5848014950752258,
0.4242909252643585,
0.28346729278564453,
-0.16177399456501007,
0.06135720759630203,
-0.8874311447143555,
-0.21824060380458832,
1.2988779544830322,
0.5145841836929321,
0.8048644065856934,
0.09287942200899124,
1.1999504566192627,
0.43446648120880127,
0.3862798810005188,
-0.6341809034347534,
0.42587512731552124,
-0.04514018073678017,
-0.5526524782180786,
-0.3002120852470398,
-0.3508734703063965,
-0.8524954319000244,
0.4534359276294708,
-0.2319316416978836,
-0.6023297309875488,
0.17516040802001953,
0.33970192074775696,
-0.20869803428649902,
0.27039262652397156,
-0.6079191565513611,
0.2962277829647064,
0.00971921719610691,
-0.3327392339706421,
-0.1790788620710373,
-0.6545286774635315,
0.4245251715183258,
-0.22474591434001923,
0.1591338813304901,
0.08920446783304214,
-0.06342930346727371,
0.45129409432411194,
-0.2965944707393646,
1.1493993997573853,
-0.3403586745262146,
-0.10858738422393799,
0.4735924303531647,
0.09658560901880264,
0.7916449308395386,
0.15714798867702484,
-0.11048096418380737,
-0.16167190670967102,
0.057815734297037125,
-0.564994752407074,
-0.5995464324951172,
0.5064261555671692,
-0.9090198874473572,
-0.596883237361908,
-0.4490779936313629,
-0.39306023716926575,
-0.3750718832015991,
0.13050465285778046,
0.5428778529167175,
0.21393291652202606,
0.17939303815364838,
0.27640050649642944,
0.6542482972145081,
0.19765284657478333,
0.3734622895717621,
0.14094427227973938,
-0.14629006385803223,
-0.549858033657074,
0.8539403676986694,
0.0008040419197641313,
0.357342004776001,
0.05594633147120476,
0.023846376687288284,
-0.3369271457195282,
-0.9567749500274658,
-0.08408261835575104,
-0.24462734162807465,
-1.0641536712646484,
-0.6126716136932373,
-0.20168691873550415,
-0.24682727456092834,
-0.4113803207874298,
-0.2075558751821518,
-0.03773922100663185,
0.010870562866330147,
-0.7457700967788696,
-0.6351951360702515,
0.43584364652633667,
0.566153883934021,
0.003677572123706341,
0.5013299584388733,
-0.6624518036842346,
0.16045840084552765,
0.3022104501724243,
0.45633623003959656,
0.2611209452152252,
-0.7173312306404114,
-0.3364369571208954,
-0.00855917390435934,
0.15271979570388794,
-0.7334666848182678,
0.291260689496994,
0.1601046621799469,
0.6831459999084473,
0.4717341661453247,
0.38343384861946106,
0.9272956848144531,
-0.3643013834953308,
0.7542580962181091,
0.485142320394516,
-1.281093716621399,
0.24756599962711334,
-0.07923178374767303,
-0.040873415768146515,
0.36973699927330017,
0.07579454779624939,
-0.10684489458799362,
-0.6383068561553955,
-0.5296240448951721,
-0.8993337750434875,
0.9311292171478271,
0.3057597875595093,
0.5004981756210327,
0.04914158955216408,
0.42167627811431885,
0.11815542727708817,
0.1449500322341919,
-0.8855098485946655,
-0.22002831101417542,
-0.5177010893821716,
-0.3039695918560028,
-0.3633096218109131,
-0.9200134873390198,
-0.5060933232307434,
-0.20190684497356415,
0.32467639446258545,
-0.0640614926815033,
0.25788813829421997,
0.21829111874103546,
-0.2670750021934509,
-0.1805058866739273,
0.22775189578533173,
0.6458320021629333,
0.8593616485595703,
-0.19650211930274963,
0.6216958165168762,
0.723366916179657,
-0.3856925666332245,
0.21565385162830353,
-0.5075926184654236,
-0.2163059264421463,
0.06819488108158112,
0.7978586554527283,
1.1651544570922852,
0.15010212361812592,
-0.37019988894462585,
0.5299031138420105,
0.27568188309669495,
-0.4046235978603363,
-0.4622223675251007,
0.27060890197753906,
-0.014310242608189583,
0.3849774897098541,
0.4867907762527466,
0.053691282868385315,
-0.18211545050144196,
-0.22449766099452972,
0.6107125282287598,
0.22969038784503937,
-0.21985973417758942,
-0.16542375087738037,
0.5200046300888062,
0.10728058218955994,
-0.04875534772872925,
0.5013759732246399,
-0.20706313848495483,
-0.4753175675868988,
0.5238597393035889,
0.863855242729187,
0.642799437046051,
-0.04932001978158951,
0.16236081719398499,
0.22878846526145935,
0.35672247409820557,
-0.36397936940193176,
0.05276938155293465,
-0.14416728913784027,
-0.9721451997756958,
-0.5123972296714783,
-0.6669208407402039,
-0.3556133508682251,
-0.1320255696773529,
-1.049091100692749,
0.043759461492300034,
-0.7008908987045288,
-0.3365107476711273,
-0.5741434097290039,
-0.12525081634521484,
-0.49662527441978455,
0.16993138194084167,
0.04945966973900795,
0.9453375339508057,
-0.8747511506080627,
1.0592665672302246,
0.2948148548603058,
-0.05075998976826668,
-0.9696722626686096,
-0.1641586273908615,
-0.3169363737106323,
-1.3288979530334473,
0.6051098704338074,
0.004070050083100796,
-0.342795193195343,
0.2833368480205536,
-0.6744285225868225,
-0.6615391969680786,
1.2675966024398804,
0.3294805884361267,
-0.4587355852127075,
-0.05952323228120804,
-0.12647277116775513,
0.6473897099494934,
-0.40784937143325806,
-0.1825932264328003,
0.5571882724761963,
0.3297908902168274,
0.20064334571361542,
-0.5578213930130005,
0.014937910251319408,
0.19785773754119873,
-0.07937860488891602,
-0.05584195256233215,
-0.25735267996788025,
0.7337037324905396,
-0.35747188329696655,
-0.45781517028808594,
0.2018645703792572,
0.7670645713806152,
0.09831123799085617,
0.7119600772857666,
0.567518949508667,
0.43127819895744324,
0.7605714201927185,
0.18873529136180878,
0.9392067193984985,
-0.40216323733329773,
0.653190553188324,
1.4030383825302124,
0.121648408472538,
0.687109112739563,
0.6964669227600098,
-0.291946142911911,
0.10177221894264221,
0.6604717969894409,
-0.3423022925853729,
0.7431381344795227,
-0.0710916817188263,
-0.3746597468852997,
-0.5491123795509338,
-0.28556695580482483,
-0.24620585143566132,
0.3859998285770416,
0.3375764787197113,
-0.7195267081260681,
-0.0866648256778717,
-0.04363417625427246,
-0.19180133938789368,
0.2266274243593216,
-0.6515067219734192,
0.8172552585601807,
0.32274115085601807,
-0.6171652674674988,
0.7152740359306335,
-0.055545538663864136,
0.6470648050308228,
-0.4863213002681732,
0.27059507369995117,
-0.33666089177131653,
0.045322924852371216,
-0.510456383228302,
-0.6285972595214844,
0.11236902326345444,
-0.11294230073690414,
0.07635600119829178,
-0.42884451150894165,
0.8192232847213745,
-0.4770187437534332,
-0.4351803660392761,
0.47434648871421814,
0.4940626323223114,
-0.07690539956092834,
0.43261444568634033,
-0.15055163204669952,
0.09819074720144272,
0.10769587010145187,
-0.021435828879475594,
0.3840356767177582,
0.3417934775352478,
0.31876710057258606,
0.6965928673744202,
0.6582818627357483,
0.4212629199028015,
0.30541956424713135,
-0.02491399087011814,
0.9139999151229858,
-0.31429168581962585,
-0.38300973176956177,
-1.093725562095642,
0.313355416059494,
0.012161623686552048,
-0.006000615656375885,
0.9132080078125,
0.24195744097232819,
0.8597582578659058,
-0.15765100717544556,
0.7209572792053223,
0.4325595796108246,
0.1602935940027237,
-0.8992910981178284,
0.4273834824562073,
-0.3854628801345825,
0.29507723450660706,
-0.05826769396662712,
-0.6337377429008484,
-0.3392401933670044,
0.6935329437255859,
0.11117802560329437,
-0.31385746598243713,
0.5732885599136353,
0.6332798600196838,
-0.06829910725355148,
-0.07240846008062363,
0.48504820466041565,
-0.019140392541885376,
0.1473703235387802,
0.6353245973587036,
0.9172525405883789,
-0.1373332291841507,
0.7289537787437439,
-0.207506462931633,
0.19874612987041473,
-0.18258512020111084,
-0.8055984377861023,
-1.0929516553878784,
-0.25483328104019165,
0.11537612974643707,
-0.5057172775268555,
0.04965245723724365,
0.8498912453651428,
0.6020298004150391,
-0.835731029510498,
-0.011108794249594212,
-0.4101259410381317,
0.4501642882823944,
-0.23642879724502563,
-0.13431599736213684,
0.423443078994751,
-0.5261385440826416,
-0.6698551177978516,
0.3633904457092285,
-0.03493297100067139,
0.24992159008979797,
-0.225175142288208,
-0.41823267936706543,
0.4456413984298706,
0.06455551832914352,
0.761858344078064,
-0.26492273807525635,
-0.8505768775939941,
-0.46453893184661865,
0.032763756811618805,
-0.23934024572372437,
0.0011710383696481586,
0.9359273910522461,
-0.3222975432872772,
0.6586917042732239,
0.2680874764919281,
0.7566514611244202,
0.6181326508522034,
0.22793163359165192,
0.39287203550338745,
-1.0835286378860474,
0.08551550656557083,
0.31084224581718445,
0.22833429276943207,
0.08150658011436462,
-0.4671177864074707,
0.5810211896896362,
0.16099601984024048,
-0.24978318810462952,
-1.2561992406845093,
0.28978389501571655,
-0.9125334620475769,
-0.2584420144557953,
1.1657270193099976,
-0.5534723401069641,
-0.018537573516368866,
-0.08413399755954742,
-0.06274821609258652,
0.19739611446857452,
-0.4173104166984558,
0.7503923773765564,
0.6681139469146729,
-0.0008811075240373611,
-0.3477497100830078,
-0.09091533720493317,
0.555821418762207,
0.48374873399734497,
-0.24865256249904633,
0.08623306453227997,
0.28172567486763,
0.2793196737766266,
-0.01576889678835869,
0.7650951147079468,
0.1556566059589386,
0.33854883909225464,
0.3531499207019806,
-0.5603452324867249,
-0.48810020089149475,
-0.4623109698295593,
-0.42901840806007385,
0.43664395809173584,
0.45666539669036865,
-0.4469950199127197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17992v1 | Catching Chameleons: Detecting Evolving Disinformation Generated using Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | 2024-06-26T00:21:39 | Bohan Jiang, Chengshuai Zhao, Zhen Tan, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite recent advancements in detecting disinformation generated by large
language models (LLMs), current efforts overlook the ever-evolving nature of
this disinformation. In this work, we investigate a challenging yet practical
research problem of detecting evolving LLM-generated disinformation.
Disinformation evolves constantly through the rapid development of LLMs and
their variants. As a consequence, the detection model faces significant
challenges. First, it is inefficient to train separate models for each
disinformation generator. Second, the performance decreases in scenarios when
evolving LLM-generated disinformation is encountered in sequential order. To
address this problem, we propose DELD (Detecting Evolving LLM-generated
Disinformation), a parameter-efficient approach that jointly leverages the
general fact-checking capabilities of pre-trained language models (PLM) and the
independent disinformation generation characteristics of various LLMs. In
particular, the learned characteristics are concatenated sequentially to
facilitate knowledge accumulation and transformation. DELD addresses the issue
of label scarcity by integrating the semantic embeddings of disinformation with
trainable soft prompts to elicit model-specific knowledge. Our experiments show
that \textit{DELD} significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods.
Moreover, our method provides critical insights into the unique patterns of
disinformation generation across different LLMs, offering valuable perspectives
in this line of research. | [
-0.39597177505493164,
-0.9163994193077087,
0.5292383432388306,
0.035415101796388626,
-0.5674883723258972,
0.1595255434513092,
-0.19793368875980377,
-0.15957552194595337,
-0.04567159712314606,
0.622920572757721,
-0.5755331516265869,
-0.6135013699531555,
-0.9243930578231812,
0.08799757808446884,
-0.4830761253833771,
0.9835847616195679,
0.31932222843170166,
-0.4039804935455322,
-0.1266358345746994,
0.026428718119859695,
-0.34088966250419617,
-0.44909924268722534,
-0.6585217118263245,
-0.28800880908966064,
0.5893294215202332,
0.43567967414855957,
0.4052596092224121,
0.7347593903541565,
0.287315309047699,
0.3272179663181305,
-0.29786303639411926,
0.6253610849380493,
-0.41419491171836853,
0.38868844509124756,
-0.09064169228076935,
-0.4333593547344208,
0.0002836634812410921,
0.07798879593610764,
0.4063796401023865,
0.5221996307373047,
-0.26563897728919983,
0.11757220327854156,
0.022886477410793304,
0.5070950984954834,
-0.6831060647964478,
0.23976853489875793,
-0.9403833150863647,
-0.10966943949460983,
-0.569874107837677,
-0.37889131903648376,
-0.574617326259613,
-0.4295741319656372,
-0.06956622004508972,
-0.02596559002995491,
0.18952424824237823,
-0.1575564295053482,
0.5361554026603699,
0.43113973736763,
-0.3847914934158325,
-0.6420634984970093,
-0.8036535978317261,
0.5955818295478821,
-0.9505190253257751,
0.30004653334617615,
0.198533833026886,
0.16665755212306976,
-0.4911504089832306,
-0.7717778086662292,
-1.0614584684371948,
-0.37145277857780457,
0.14232230186462402,
-0.3007448613643646,
-0.35272666811943054,
-0.29027312994003296,
0.3679800033569336,
0.1378338634967804,
-0.6156109571456909,
0.5462415814399719,
-0.06587931513786316,
-0.08670163154602051,
0.6021235585212708,
-0.07856302708387375,
0.43689244985580444,
-0.12576833367347717,
-0.31066322326660156,
-0.04739446938037872,
-0.6979485750198364,
-0.2434241771697998,
0.3893550634384155,
0.23349419236183167,
-0.06067739054560661,
0.2871839106082916,
-0.033319272100925446,
0.6231271028518677,
0.24242046475410461,
-0.2839394807815552,
0.35238486528396606,
0.005477087572216988,
-0.06063434109091759,
0.4107440710067749,
0.6461555361747742,
0.028924493119120598,
0.25318995118141174,
0.0579049251973629,
-0.3872172236442566,
0.07876589894294739,
0.08508419245481491,
-0.5535292625427246,
-0.40359818935394287,
0.06100648641586304,
-0.2966269254684448,
-0.54179847240448,
-0.16062034666538239,
-1.0829260349273682,
-0.9253938794136047,
-0.21548721194267273,
0.09541463851928711,
-0.5393710732460022,
-0.3400404751300812,
0.26683101058006287,
-0.07104340195655823,
0.1411360204219818,
0.34194818139076233,
-0.7880245447158813,
-0.13277855515480042,
0.8535134792327881,
0.8087035417556763,
-0.06788366287946701,
-0.2333824187517166,
-0.6101489663124084,
0.12787090241909027,
-0.13891063630580902,
0.7297587394714355,
-0.547542154788971,
-0.3457350730895996,
0.062140755355358124,
-0.07128224521875381,
0.17414483428001404,
-0.7687235474586487,
0.4387377202510834,
-0.8403053879737854,
0.08852442353963852,
-0.12496284395456314,
-0.5467201471328735,
-0.312552809715271,
0.40000665187835693,
-0.6677699089050293,
0.7028661966323853,
0.07203464210033417,
-0.9451339244842529,
0.5606405735015869,
-0.443653404712677,
-0.38729146122932434,
0.3232317268848419,
-0.2522770166397095,
-0.6762895584106445,
0.06856868416070938,
0.24580714106559753,
0.35508987307548523,
-0.3384804129600525,
0.3632970452308655,
-0.44966697692871094,
0.0552358478307724,
0.47700393199920654,
-0.6159681677818298,
0.8069846034049988,
0.3571091592311859,
-0.5599215626716614,
-0.31410953402519226,
-0.8519182205200195,
-0.2241232842206955,
0.21491484344005585,
-0.40895751118659973,
-0.722011148929596,
0.23699851334095,
-0.593938946723938,
0.3014895021915436,
0.2786865532398224,
-0.31856343150138855,
0.294086217880249,
0.00870425347238779,
0.38295888900756836,
0.7875365018844604,
0.5198488235473633,
-0.04397374391555786,
-0.29140523076057434,
0.3353910744190216,
0.7208493947982788,
0.19656597077846527,
-0.3741769790649414,
-0.27442917227745056,
-0.9188129305839539,
-0.3360571265220642,
0.045765239745378494,
0.40916192531585693,
-0.9082422256469727,
0.6508215665817261,
-0.22098469734191895,
-0.6789066791534424,
-0.28132423758506775,
0.3193341791629791,
0.27417638897895813,
0.5088636875152588,
0.3828910291194916,
0.017017681151628494,
-0.44855549931526184,
-0.8239631056785583,
-0.1878604292869568,
-0.07831104844808578,
0.18001803755760193,
-0.19543391466140747,
0.5098861455917358,
-0.6655966639518738,
0.876163899898529,
-0.5922605395317078,
0.25611793994903564,
-0.22416633367538452,
0.367720365524292,
0.19132567942142487,
0.5499537587165833,
0.6935913562774658,
-0.9101182818412781,
-0.21841855347156525,
-0.06464220583438873,
-0.7100815176963806,
-0.3829726278781891,
-0.1985042542219162,
0.20142966508865356,
-0.05028866231441498,
0.5371397137641907,
-0.5527169704437256,
0.1341550350189209,
0.36257535219192505,
-0.057021621614694595,
0.41934552788734436,
-0.13773293793201447,
0.22190403938293457,
-0.9353776574134827,
-0.07752254605293274,
0.19829630851745605,
-0.060508135706186295,
-0.7636235356330872,
-0.16105814278125763,
0.05171814188361168,
0.10458389669656754,
-0.4395564794540405,
0.15784165263175964,
-0.4380466639995575,
0.35500583052635193,
-0.23823079466819763,
0.3690021336078644,
-0.2253647744655609,
0.26279357075691223,
-0.11982520669698715,
0.39746910333633423,
0.371448278427124,
-1.0180716514587402,
0.444019079208374,
0.026133853942155838,
-0.5388643741607666,
0.33665600419044495,
-0.47192737460136414,
0.3050900995731354,
-0.5038301944732666,
0.08040483295917511,
-0.8767229914665222,
-0.06801966577768326,
0.47908300161361694,
-0.20067280530929565,
0.5359996557235718,
-0.2714053690433502,
-0.6461906433105469,
-0.4989149868488312,
-0.23204992711544037,
0.43542957305908203,
0.6716143488883972,
-0.7739274501800537,
0.05915962532162666,
0.4766242802143097,
-0.3978690505027771,
-0.5434247851371765,
-0.6291269659996033,
-0.09549635648727417,
-0.4823465347290039,
-0.5753288269042969,
-0.07597250491380692,
0.0018062237650156021,
-0.41668570041656494,
-0.24725434184074402,
-0.24833500385284424,
0.08305132389068604,
0.0912381038069725,
-0.06025979295372963,
0.05009455606341362,
-0.18440833687782288,
0.1432541012763977,
0.2162618190050125,
-0.05808808282017708,
-0.02764872834086418,
-0.6371629238128662,
0.8605321049690247,
0.2446187287569046,
-0.45575985312461853,
-0.45952820777893066,
-0.038764216005802155,
0.9787726998329163,
-0.4355420470237732,
0.8544942736625671,
0.33574020862579346,
-0.2938372492790222,
-0.8363381028175354,
-0.8070393204689026,
-0.12359562516212463,
-0.5356742739677429,
0.43256914615631104,
0.0702354833483696,
-0.5993506908416748,
0.38961145281791687,
-0.5322406888008118,
0.004944508895277977,
0.24473147094249725,
0.4400407671928406,
0.22013968229293823,
0.794926106929779,
0.47757118940353394,
0.03439544141292572,
0.46997296810150146,
-0.17509682476520538,
0.219482421875,
-0.5122494697570801,
-0.5789850354194641,
-0.5669324994087219,
-0.34794601798057556,
-0.7260982394218445,
-0.4659254848957062,
0.19502612948417664,
0.15471836924552917,
-0.15040823817253113,
0.2600177526473999,
-0.4174506664276123,
0.535658061504364,
0.322172075510025,
0.10348623991012573,
0.44329020380973816,
-0.0786377340555191,
-0.005605283658951521,
-0.005590307526290417,
-0.48006555438041687,
-0.5805124044418335,
0.8185379505157471,
0.29189884662628174,
0.8816010355949402,
0.2782520353794098,
0.7933693528175354,
0.7750855088233948,
0.2948169410228729,
-0.3815482556819916,
0.5666998624801636,
-0.22847841680049896,
-0.11484598368406296,
-0.08342786878347397,
-0.5399205088615417,
-0.8651279807090759,
0.13881486654281616,
0.10171433538198471,
-0.6911270618438721,
0.39283859729766846,
0.18393594026565552,
-0.046780962496995926,
0.4676823616027832,
-0.3527100384235382,
0.5564820766448975,
-0.4309835135936737,
-0.13179263472557068,
-0.2146526426076889,
-0.40043190121650696,
0.8308690190315247,
-0.5793188214302063,
0.2296944558620453,
-0.20445603132247925,
-0.07524179667234421,
0.5554409027099609,
-0.33596694469451904,
0.8572229743003845,
-0.3450072407722473,
-0.5021399855613708,
0.5540078282356262,
0.265821248292923,
0.669121503829956,
0.3176771104335785,
-0.133651465177536,
0.023879792541265488,
-0.37335965037345886,
-0.2547907531261444,
-0.66618812084198,
0.8052905797958374,
-0.6769652366638184,
-0.6765627861022949,
-0.4477185606956482,
-0.29029417037963867,
-0.016547678038477898,
0.20897620916366577,
0.37809792160987854,
0.3802649676799774,
0.08243001997470856,
0.010167788714170456,
0.9276110529899597,
-0.47622421383857727,
0.5041375160217285,
0.8194181323051453,
-0.06817410886287689,
-0.21165338158607483,
1.0423024892807007,
0.0020626646000891924,
0.16922864317893982,
0.37294888496398926,
0.18983329832553864,
-0.4572400152683258,
-0.877769947052002,
-0.2384333461523056,
0.35398268699645996,
-0.6889100074768066,
-0.2147389054298401,
-0.5897396206855774,
-0.19255809485912323,
-0.28202131390571594,
0.21275798976421356,
-0.17711780965328217,
-0.05536080151796341,
-0.2844705581665039,
0.13529625535011292,
0.2621035575866699,
0.774897575378418,
0.03428154066205025,
0.22293385863304138,
-1.0654306411743164,
0.07200495153665543,
0.36117425560951233,
0.04304042458534241,
0.06816212087869644,
-0.5927278399467468,
0.0680631548166275,
0.3619306683540344,
-0.3567655682563782,
-1.0400454998016357,
0.3801233768463135,
0.025720400735735893,
0.7602032423019409,
0.7709576487541199,
0.39760708808898926,
0.2561447024345398,
-0.24276970326900482,
0.8458439707756042,
0.10525330901145935,
-0.8390649557113647,
0.7550539374351501,
-0.28440943360328674,
0.24978703260421753,
0.4367332458496094,
0.5564570426940918,
-0.697170078754425,
-0.32720041275024414,
-0.5184280872344971,
-0.625188410282135,
0.6688269376754761,
-0.11974489688873291,
0.049187690019607544,
-0.40029698610305786,
0.4115106463432312,
0.33541223406791687,
0.5997822880744934,
-0.5950798392295837,
-0.14442017674446106,
-0.009834208525717258,
-0.0259394533932209,
-0.09094874560832977,
-0.3911078870296478,
0.025037024170160294,
0.07917336374521255,
0.6450145244598389,
0.15193487703800201,
-0.29241490364074707,
-0.14702028036117554,
-0.3654819130897522,
0.2935594618320465,
0.3441169559955597,
0.7873415350914001,
0.2879619300365448,
0.25516003370285034,
0.5367574095726013,
-0.02140488289296627,
-0.5099563598632812,
0.4200138449668884,
-0.1413053274154663,
-0.3871634900569916,
0.10660873353481293,
0.4169495701789856,
0.6604188084602356,
0.03983433172106743,
-0.8464489579200745,
0.5312636494636536,
0.18144842982292175,
0.08657806366682053,
-0.27224212884902954,
0.20542404055595398,
-0.17216861248016357,
0.2810194194316864,
0.15095661580562592,
0.09730338305234909,
-0.15529368817806244,
-0.47382116317749023,
0.51003497838974,
0.20299376547336578,
-0.14362937211990356,
-0.42283621430397034,
0.3128054738044739,
0.40645524859428406,
-0.4212033152580261,
0.9528670907020569,
-0.6465282440185547,
-0.5532621741294861,
0.5608655214309692,
0.591728925704956,
0.9011630415916443,
-0.42936715483665466,
0.34147411584854126,
0.10816525667905807,
0.37240973114967346,
-0.10244407504796982,
-0.09121968597173691,
-0.10233232378959656,
-0.777624249458313,
-0.03200048580765724,
-0.7383768558502197,
0.05816471576690674,
0.8050745129585266,
-0.38739660382270813,
0.5893316268920898,
-0.516215443611145,
-0.06887568533420563,
0.011046802625060081,
-0.3479556739330292,
-0.4189402163028717,
-0.1598358005285263,
0.33903416991233826,
0.7513774037361145,
-0.8822373747825623,
0.7287690043449402,
0.4656202495098114,
-0.4385751485824585,
-0.37071096897125244,
0.3713754415512085,
0.4084455072879791,
-0.655396580696106,
0.7414794564247131,
0.12262804806232452,
-0.20956408977508545,
0.08427920192480087,
-0.5586248636245728,
-0.6180845499038696,
0.9888258576393127,
0.4155581593513489,
-0.9867571592330933,
0.17417016625404358,
0.18241000175476074,
0.3159826695919037,
-0.1914849877357483,
-0.03807998076081276,
0.8267194628715515,
0.5741315484046936,
0.1294105499982834,
-0.43232986330986023,
0.06636367738246918,
-0.2149115651845932,
-0.011749415658414364,
0.42599374055862427,
-0.5571417808532715,
0.9374899864196777,
-0.33005309104919434,
-0.5331105589866638,
-0.11356155574321747,
0.49254974722862244,
0.2644253671169281,
0.5039526224136353,
0.7465967535972595,
0.5118945837020874,
1.076502799987793,
0.023920094594359398,
0.5205212235450745,
-0.48480337858200073,
0.37671688199043274,
1.1656919717788696,
-0.4582662284374237,
0.48269420862197876,
0.329596608877182,
0.06452469527721405,
0.6127081513404846,
0.5817648768424988,
-0.2965657413005829,
0.632762610912323,
0.6049594879150391,
-0.6377021074295044,
-0.23876722157001495,
-0.02646922692656517,
-0.41991010308265686,
0.7117290496826172,
0.4809478521347046,
-0.390186071395874,
-0.44182088971138,
0.12040665745735168,
0.14702455699443817,
0.2185174524784088,
-0.15441805124282837,
0.7397072315216064,
-0.1372414529323578,
-0.6363893747329712,
0.5645943880081177,
-0.05671217292547226,
0.8892924189567566,
-0.6661127805709839,
-0.07825034111738205,
-0.33275696635246277,
0.39289236068725586,
-0.09046029299497604,
-0.4097220003604889,
0.021029425784945488,
0.0735558420419693,
-0.18244603276252747,
0.11353949457406998,
0.5830764770507812,
-0.750268816947937,
-0.0716964527964592,
0.20006242394447327,
0.6355006694793701,
-0.0740998312830925,
0.1333671361207962,
-0.4176464378833771,
0.31389474868774414,
0.07803740352392197,
-0.03689410910010338,
0.24484704434871674,
0.6963971257209778,
-0.003588545136153698,
0.8409307599067688,
0.6466587781906128,
-0.01637887768447399,
0.169097438454628,
0.03866980969905853,
0.954245388507843,
-0.2986273765563965,
-0.5292017459869385,
-1.2943469285964966,
0.24986129999160767,
-0.2700815796852112,
-0.18099190294742584,
0.7740519642829895,
0.5161715745925903,
0.8054367303848267,
-0.2808079123497009,
0.9840433597564697,
0.022264057770371437,
0.24150989949703217,
-0.5508237481117249,
0.8318197131156921,
-0.3820435404777527,
0.749848484992981,
-0.27288323640823364,
-0.8545663356781006,
-0.009666342288255692,
0.18322153389453888,
-0.2593940794467926,
0.07875073701143265,
0.6321946978569031,
0.8625385165214539,
-0.14205409586429596,
0.21761184930801392,
0.07645238935947418,
0.374859094619751,
0.6909670829772949,
0.3840582072734833,
1.2021394968032837,
0.15040186047554016,
0.3612901568412781,
-0.0851263478398323,
-0.3573637306690216,
-0.27861595153808594,
-0.9684861898422241,
-0.8705877065658569,
-0.6379178762435913,
-0.7080890536308289,
-0.27959710359573364,
-0.025803320109844208,
0.8028895258903503,
0.543687105178833,
-0.7073575854301453,
0.19166682660579681,
-0.22181442379951477,
0.13304364681243896,
-0.15690883994102478,
-0.2196904718875885,
0.11661160737276077,
-0.3852473795413971,
-0.7128360271453857,
0.3492348790168762,
0.2598460614681244,
0.3452637493610382,
-0.38348954916000366,
0.005438037682324648,
-0.28821834921836853,
0.19691753387451172,
0.5302340984344482,
0.4502650499343872,
-0.5908410549163818,
-0.42718714475631714,
-0.4339306652545929,
-0.10514603555202484,
-0.42430412769317627,
0.9931285381317139,
-0.6641502976417542,
0.45564568042755127,
0.5738534927368164,
0.6969244480133057,
0.29808562994003296,
-0.09543101489543915,
0.27972063422203064,
-0.9797670245170593,
0.23576489090919495,
0.3231686055660248,
0.1490764617919922,
0.37236547470092773,
-0.25886836647987366,
0.13293488323688507,
0.5068627595901489,
-0.5319129824638367,
-1.0010687112808228,
0.4575667679309845,
-0.8156577944755554,
-0.25898656249046326,
1.0871237516403198,
-0.1307394951581955,
-0.07880356907844543,
-0.2877374291419983,
-0.06288260221481323,
0.279841810464859,
-0.3197191655635834,
1.0563026666641235,
0.3458439111709595,
-0.04215266928076744,
-0.07206062227487564,
-0.21705453097820282,
0.6336408257484436,
-0.1967264711856842,
-0.9608417749404907,
0.26770898699760437,
0.44930633902549744,
0.4846438467502594,
0.4729125201702118,
0.3115255534648895,
0.061207935214042664,
0.17287923395633698,
0.18380044400691986,
-0.21918985247612,
-0.4153520464897156,
-0.26559680700302124,
-0.31850573420524597,
0.11117076873779297,
0.14991547167301178,
-0.38704201579093933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17990v1 | Explicit Diversity Conditions for Effective Question Answer Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | 2024-06-26T00:12:08 | Vikas Yadav, Hyuk Joon Kwon, Vijay Srinivasan, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answer Generation (QAG) is an effective data augmentation technique
to improve the accuracy of question answering systems, especially in
low-resource domains. While recent pretrained and large language model-based
QAG methods have made substantial progress, they face the critical issue of
redundant QA pair generation, affecting downstream QA systems. Implicit
diversity techniques such as sampling and diverse beam search are proven
effective solutions but often yield smaller diversity. We present explicit
diversity conditions for QAG, focusing on spatial aspects, question types, and
entities, substantially increasing diversity in QA generation. Our work
emphasizes the need of explicit diversity conditions for generating diverse
question-answer synthetic data by showing significant improvements in
downstream QA task over existing widely adopted implicit diversity techniques.
In particular, generated QA pairs from explicit diversity conditions when used
to train the downstream QA model results in an average 4.1% exact match and
4.5% F1 improvement over QAG from implicit sampling techniques on SQuADDU. Our
work emphasizes the need for explicit diversity conditions even more in
low-resource datasets (SubjQA), where average downstream QA performance
improvements are around 12% EM. | [
-0.7273423075675964,
-0.9049548506736755,
0.5331506729125977,
0.33851203322410583,
-0.3134782612323761,
0.23138876259326935,
0.18703730404376984,
-0.37829887866973877,
-0.28480321168899536,
0.2105356901884079,
-0.6394606232643127,
-0.4366830587387085,
-0.2728827893733978,
0.2147132158279419,
-0.23593632876873016,
0.960109531879425,
-0.05890915170311928,
0.15912501513957977,
-0.2572755217552185,
-0.4539036154747009,
-0.6045149564743042,
-0.48830053210258484,
-0.680145263671875,
0.18562695384025574,
0.4218943417072296,
0.3741565942764282,
0.6554068326950073,
0.144974023103714,
0.22569765150547028,
0.28290069103240967,
-0.20531469583511353,
0.46235498785972595,
-0.6802070736885071,
0.3461427688598633,
-0.20879079401493073,
-0.1438821405172348,
-0.18623043596744537,
-0.20726722478866577,
0.8444156050682068,
0.8360257148742676,
-0.2854769825935364,
0.15435588359832764,
-0.24401657283306122,
0.5344025492668152,
-0.7153533697128296,
-0.21882693469524384,
-0.7305852770805359,
0.0017598187550902367,
0.14405742287635803,
-0.14842525124549866,
-0.15534423291683197,
-0.7761456370353699,
0.12996549904346466,
-0.7298557162284851,
0.4647603929042816,
0.23846472799777985,
0.7426376342773438,
0.009546153247356415,
-0.8658162951469421,
-0.16561317443847656,
-0.7730421423912048,
0.6686287522315979,
-0.5600516200065613,
0.2419268935918808,
0.1742618829011917,
0.2822452485561371,
-0.30044910311698914,
-0.5621028542518616,
-0.7409242987632751,
0.23052316904067993,
-0.13396087288856506,
0.20275506377220154,
-0.22155185043811798,
0.2415565550327301,
0.43413931131362915,
0.4244064688682556,
-0.7652361989021301,
-0.12676571309566498,
-0.5963877439498901,
0.03789226710796356,
0.8874956369400024,
0.23155477643013,
0.4259699583053589,
-0.010279078036546707,
-0.20233553647994995,
-0.1956908404827118,
-0.8214282393455505,
0.2686140239238739,
0.702440619468689,
0.25922343134880066,
0.057918135076761246,
0.3827429413795471,
-0.579921543598175,
0.45673105120658875,
0.2633785009384155,
0.22060301899909973,
0.29298868775367737,
-0.8954417705535889,
-0.11078519374132156,
-0.2831464409828186,
0.2719976305961609,
0.14870572090148926,
0.09691556543111801,
-0.15351779758930206,
-0.34260305762290955,
-0.4714049696922302,
0.21002399921417236,
-0.8873557448387146,
-0.03322027623653412,
0.5278923511505127,
-0.20655906200408936,
0.17057472467422485,
-0.12104079872369766,
-0.8330940008163452,
-0.19951452314853668,
-0.08845609426498413,
0.22400982677936554,
-0.0949007198214531,
-0.5100244283676147,
-0.0012396430829539895,
-0.3602866232395172,
0.8647662401199341,
0.202669158577919,
-0.6336722373962402,
-0.023500723764300346,
0.31020161509513855,
0.3674517869949341,
-0.1296861171722412,
-0.04554235190153122,
-0.6328549385070801,
0.028569960966706276,
-0.39824146032333374,
0.8660635352134705,
-0.2995670437812805,
-0.6598960161209106,
0.10406780987977982,
-0.31638088822364807,
0.013678118586540222,
-0.6133890151977539,
0.4690127670764923,
-0.8914746046066284,
0.432058185338974,
-0.50210040807724,
-0.3320847153663635,
-0.10356182605028152,
0.09465280175209045,
-0.6828125715255737,
0.7550131678581238,
0.43289923667907715,
-0.4445011019706726,
0.4689507484436035,
-0.5235164165496826,
-0.44602036476135254,
0.30323198437690735,
-0.03606270253658295,
-0.46748316287994385,
-0.12504759430885315,
0.30755728483200073,
-0.1998593807220459,
-0.08772547543048859,
0.2403622269630432,
-0.4652772843837738,
-0.23201385140419006,
0.0112976199015975,
-0.08243963867425919,
0.7469814419746399,
0.41957199573516846,
-0.22351351380348206,
0.07757305353879929,
-0.4966031014919281,
0.451416015625,
0.06263577193021774,
-0.47366636991500854,
-0.1740235686302185,
0.07879257947206497,
-0.08396513760089874,
0.2030615210533142,
-0.018226755782961845,
-0.5914393067359924,
0.05438211187720299,
-0.2526719868183136,
-0.003128275740891695,
0.6009395718574524,
0.4049791097640991,
0.5389417409896851,
-0.21119999885559082,
0.9259887933731079,
-0.11146929115056992,
0.10836230218410492,
-0.022971710190176964,
-0.7043251395225525,
-0.4366350471973419,
-0.21959276497364044,
0.13424624502658844,
0.47997987270355225,
-0.9556807279586792,
0.1895173341035843,
0.04461020231246948,
-0.16646096110343933,
-0.5645938515663147,
0.24525858461856842,
0.46288084983825684,
0.35835927724838257,
0.3419579863548279,
0.14917145669460297,
-0.7670101523399353,
-0.9848666787147522,
0.01818765141069889,
-0.32584166526794434,
0.10995231568813324,
0.46988704800605774,
0.25390633940696716,
-0.009848343208432198,
1.1445024013519287,
-0.5095274448394775,
0.313773512840271,
-0.4072296619415283,
0.12232024222612381,
0.21130333840847015,
0.5883752107620239,
0.9289452433586121,
-1.24528968334198,
-0.23023782670497894,
-0.3593200147151947,
-0.5718622207641602,
-0.4174947440624237,
0.15170937776565552,
-0.6468229293823242,
0.3012632727622986,
0.24927395582199097,
-0.7434438467025757,
0.20519022643566132,
0.7409199476242065,
-0.6325924396514893,
0.3651910424232483,
0.1775331199169159,
0.29582899808883667,
-0.9603297114372253,
0.12089086323976517,
-0.14837181568145752,
-0.23551902174949646,
-0.7861204743385315,
0.6467952728271484,
-0.23558072745800018,
-0.3093706965446472,
-0.4805589020252228,
0.6051265597343445,
-0.23533788323402405,
0.0594978854060173,
-0.24190568923950195,
0.14602164924144745,
0.0833718404173851,
0.40989789366722107,
-0.0038532009348273277,
0.8345011472702026,
0.21096090972423553,
-0.5926437973976135,
0.2784886956214905,
0.3637181222438812,
-0.022351978346705437,
0.48750928044319153,
-1.0868629217147827,
0.14815007150173187,
-0.454990029335022,
0.487403005361557,
-1.3334399461746216,
-0.26944297552108765,
0.0792161375284195,
-0.3387562930583954,
0.059255603700876236,
-0.046956658363342285,
-0.3270173668861389,
-0.29830339550971985,
-0.2509462833404541,
1.0197306871414185,
0.94709312915802,
-0.6501690745353699,
0.46103593707084656,
0.19728736579418182,
-0.4069194495677948,
-0.46756452322006226,
-0.3162190914154053,
-0.4449795186519623,
-0.028872206807136536,
-0.8406199812889099,
0.07317869365215302,
-0.3435445725917816,
-0.21016447246074677,
0.009520087391138077,
-0.1466454714536667,
-0.3395898640155792,
0.19846874475479126,
-0.014040951617062092,
0.24024607241153717,
-0.3994627892971039,
0.19420728087425232,
0.4728052020072937,
0.4300459623336792,
0.008474130183458328,
-0.21767805516719818,
0.46326717734336853,
0.07682301104068756,
-0.4458116590976715,
0.28425002098083496,
1.0044739246368408,
0.1234498918056488,
-0.4724331498146057,
0.753518283367157,
0.657802164554596,
-0.16273584961891174,
-0.33186519145965576,
-0.35786524415016174,
-0.21772830188274384,
-0.48777133226394653,
0.5723276734352112,
-0.19350174069404602,
-1.1831293106079102,
0.6968868374824524,
0.5233455896377563,
0.42690739035606384,
0.4517323970794678,
0.41964098811149597,
-0.26958972215652466,
1.3491318225860596,
0.2414994090795517,
0.5477908253669739,
0.272673100233078,
0.07303108274936676,
0.3087419271469116,
-0.5213369131088257,
-0.3477473258972168,
-0.5646896958351135,
-0.38744962215423584,
-0.7967082858085632,
-0.29031261801719666,
0.47049468755722046,
0.3449293076992035,
-0.17226195335388184,
-0.28137436509132385,
-0.1727125495672226,
0.42370137572288513,
0.5889262557029724,
-0.11532793939113617,
0.08675703406333923,
-0.07652922719717026,
0.2672106623649597,
0.2369544804096222,
-0.8546332120895386,
-0.11664137244224548,
0.994292676448822,
0.0500091016292572,
0.4142758548259735,
0.3938226103782654,
0.7655993700027466,
0.31261080503463745,
0.24695150554180145,
-0.32367783784866333,
0.5112553834915161,
0.08512991666793823,
-0.9066466093063354,
-0.34754690527915955,
-0.6581045389175415,
-1.1237181425094604,
0.5077943801879883,
-0.3341699242591858,
-0.08830584585666656,
0.41386765241622925,
0.32033228874206543,
-0.4685572683811188,
0.013134037144482136,
-0.9498898386955261,
0.5813385248184204,
-0.041048236191272736,
-0.24701790511608124,
-0.06466047465801239,
-0.4353077709674835,
0.5624661445617676,
-0.11580706387758255,
-0.17875972390174866,
-0.13003166019916534,
0.09605880826711655,
0.36216121912002563,
-0.15314064919948578,
0.37358540296554565,
-0.5375632047653198,
-0.3916579484939575,
0.6955062747001648,
-0.18016864359378815,
0.48245179653167725,
0.2645760774612427,
0.009676859714090824,
-0.09672847390174866,
-0.14692139625549316,
-1.0278446674346924,
-0.7506960034370422,
0.47084319591522217,
-0.8372639417648315,
-0.8338711261749268,
-0.0808439627289772,
-0.8075058460235596,
-0.3699726164340973,
0.004543227609246969,
0.1891874372959137,
0.40351060032844543,
0.05325959250330925,
0.3921377956867218,
0.7767120003700256,
-0.47058311104774475,
0.321591317653656,
0.6631813645362854,
-0.18780770897865295,
-0.3590191602706909,
0.6741062998771667,
-0.04139932617545128,
0.41392967104911804,
0.016127292066812515,
-0.3514830768108368,
-0.6692659258842468,
-0.9078007936477661,
-0.40744322538375854,
0.1014048233628273,
-0.6454676985740662,
-0.1920681744813919,
-0.5273408889770508,
-0.2627704441547394,
-0.5041714310646057,
0.07211535423994064,
0.16469286382198334,
-0.5091550350189209,
0.03497660160064697,
-0.16534242033958435,
0.13534720242023468,
0.44158533215522766,
0.2997535765171051,
0.10427568107843399,
-0.8807111382484436,
0.6945989727973938,
0.7790398001670837,
0.2010255604982376,
-0.37892472743988037,
-0.5171441435813904,
-0.11315475404262543,
0.19278693199157715,
-0.30850234627723694,
-0.9075663685798645,
0.08645861595869064,
0.32051512598991394,
1.074303150177002,
-0.04332629591226578,
0.31036823987960815,
0.4710513651371002,
-0.08216950297355652,
0.8273131251335144,
-0.24551309645175934,
-0.6775522828102112,
0.6289492249488831,
-0.6126257181167603,
0.5571370124816895,
0.49946051836013794,
0.4032987058162689,
-0.175319641828537,
-0.7320597171783447,
-0.5566703677177429,
-1.0984474420547485,
0.48958003520965576,
0.5516613721847534,
0.3971514403820038,
-0.1263432800769806,
0.35211214423179626,
0.07771168649196625,
0.3929958641529083,
-0.7852456569671631,
-0.17332230508327484,
-0.310661256313324,
-0.12553748488426208,
0.14590589702129364,
-0.08449093997478485,
-0.19650065898895264,
-0.06582312285900116,
0.6405051946640015,
-0.2684350609779358,
0.20044034719467163,
0.20935563743114471,
-0.040062617510557175,
-0.11470978707075119,
0.36884158849716187,
0.6416550874710083,
0.851148784160614,
-0.2507910430431366,
-0.13280706107616425,
0.3185347318649292,
-0.18972276151180267,
0.3706815242767334,
0.2894306480884552,
-0.6291866302490234,
-0.0168746430426836,
0.180962935090065,
0.7002856731414795,
-0.3372490108013153,
-0.9057987928390503,
0.31330737471580505,
-0.11984624713659286,
-0.4246581494808197,
-0.06946828961372375,
0.4721238911151886,
-0.1487954556941986,
0.32551875710487366,
0.6881547570228577,
-0.22677524387836456,
0.2448303997516632,
-0.3613876700401306,
0.020315280184149742,
0.7287982106208801,
0.1304144263267517,
-0.1349211484193802,
0.47751158475875854,
0.5839418172836304,
0.04228193312883377,
0.7144836783409119,
-0.760658323764801,
-0.3265606164932251,
0.7952144742012024,
0.61307293176651,
0.8714984655380249,
-0.17698056995868683,
0.33658653497695923,
0.5554335117340088,
0.27012670040130615,
0.2550235092639923,
0.6410358548164368,
-0.1326378881931305,
-0.7394178509712219,
-0.4976632297039032,
-0.5437912344932556,
-0.3000577688217163,
0.0593409538269043,
-0.5750583410263062,
-0.07711361348628998,
-0.42250439524650574,
0.017622364684939384,
-0.4970840513706207,
-0.14919798076152802,
-0.4316061735153198,
0.5007730722427368,
0.29232078790664673,
0.5729607939720154,
-0.7470641136169434,
0.4054650664329529,
0.9654769897460938,
-0.3433375358581543,
-0.8057530522346497,
0.022928643971681595,
-0.5331698656082153,
-0.5135940909385681,
0.6331958770751953,
-0.17560206353664398,
-0.09874047338962555,
-0.04902321845293045,
-0.7807028293609619,
-0.9117056131362915,
1.076072335243225,
0.510737419128418,
-0.21333514153957367,
-0.011674989946186543,
0.13608886301517487,
0.6679642200469971,
-0.2554188668727875,
0.25600817799568176,
0.4686761498451233,
0.4083929657936096,
0.20698705315589905,
-0.3945918083190918,
0.18159125745296478,
-0.6931252479553223,
0.1627303808927536,
0.1976219117641449,
-0.6420669555664062,
0.8010784983634949,
-0.19184927642345428,
-0.38753774762153625,
0.2272559255361557,
0.8297827243804932,
0.805774450302124,
0.43206632137298584,
0.5898967981338501,
0.35941800475120544,
0.6449849605560303,
-0.2556045651435852,
1.2400708198547363,
-0.04275728017091751,
0.12551355361938477,
0.7326286435127258,
-0.29308274388313293,
0.5957314968109131,
0.3791945278644562,
-0.15288609266281128,
0.5998206734657288,
0.7385507225990295,
0.12753503024578094,
0.3868296444416046,
0.18155355751514435,
-0.3356674313545227,
-0.4990329146385193,
-0.23051485419273376,
-0.716756284236908,
0.438353031873703,
-0.0667116791009903,
-0.05579935386776924,
-0.18188217282295227,
-0.3050991892814636,
-0.22401314973831177,
0.09974546730518341,
-0.37055253982543945,
0.5672959685325623,
-0.3733642101287842,
-1.0138423442840576,
0.6676303148269653,
-0.08852827548980713,
0.4603406488895416,
-0.6776896715164185,
-0.17294254899024963,
-0.9299498796463013,
-0.4829696714878082,
-0.23117080330848694,
-0.8099933862686157,
0.12800206243991852,
0.024091370403766632,
-0.5268749594688416,
-0.12545469403266907,
0.5485901832580566,
-0.7459897398948669,
-0.35671764612197876,
-0.10967519879341125,
0.5308801531791687,
-0.2803552746772766,
0.08791409432888031,
-0.35486042499542236,
-0.45887070894241333,
0.07085171341896057,
-0.14316679537296295,
0.21670018136501312,
0.2867144048213959,
-0.0437127947807312,
0.525284469127655,
0.6763871908187866,
0.06714599579572678,
0.5071109533309937,
0.026524413377046585,
0.8037691712379456,
-0.31630319356918335,
-0.6754209399223328,
-0.3433828353881836,
0.5652956962585449,
-0.277437686920166,
-0.4534670412540436,
0.7864711880683899,
0.4101438820362091,
0.5950778126716614,
-0.048641886562108994,
0.8183300495147705,
-0.06021121144294739,
0.48930037021636963,
-0.6480081081390381,
0.4199521839618683,
-0.6202763915061951,
0.10005159676074982,
-0.09899982810020447,
-1.1408838033676147,
0.13841332495212555,
0.15525047481060028,
-0.16018126904964447,
0.543550431728363,
0.6255936026573181,
0.7087743878364563,
0.026492098346352577,
-0.06730775535106659,
0.0738481804728508,
-0.1653262972831726,
0.4538417160511017,
0.6774300932884216,
1.184616208076477,
-0.31643807888031006,
0.8826215863227844,
0.13438573479652405,
0.008342111483216286,
0.024329397827386856,
-0.5487557053565979,
-0.5199633240699768,
-0.36485755443573,
-0.4158759117126465,
-0.30541813373565674,
0.04375166445970535,
0.7729790806770325,
0.800656259059906,
-0.9547368884086609,
0.039808742702007294,
-0.13708502054214478,
0.34638211131095886,
0.14355997741222382,
-0.2795126438140869,
-0.07321396470069885,
-0.5640681982040405,
-0.8586176037788391,
0.22406303882598877,
-0.0337725430727005,
0.24698244035243988,
-0.2200641930103302,
-0.19288533926010132,
-0.23718716204166412,
0.334522545337677,
0.5202684998512268,
0.5882613658905029,
-0.29093992710113525,
-0.1729867309331894,
0.026956086978316307,
-0.15329349040985107,
-0.09985917806625366,
0.7291312217712402,
-0.7470535635948181,
0.27463728189468384,
0.8590952754020691,
0.8219138979911804,
0.20652560889720917,
0.581771731376648,
0.8601820468902588,
-1.1666187047958374,
0.1653069108724594,
0.34509187936782837,
0.20083309710025787,
0.24080400168895721,
-0.16743731498718262,
0.38498300313949585,
0.3058588206768036,
-0.5579126477241516,
-0.7762196660041809,
0.4460352659225464,
-0.8190367221832275,
-0.21932095289230347,
1.6547664403915405,
-0.19292715191841125,
0.11719515919685364,
-0.37619370222091675,
-0.29361364245414734,
0.18663424253463745,
-0.5002450942993164,
0.6348063349723816,
0.36606234312057495,
-0.09128249436616898,
-0.10406605899333954,
-0.19740530848503113,
0.527754008769989,
0.8390142917633057,
-1.237345814704895,
-0.31019315123558044,
0.8838950991630554,
-0.03874912112951279,
-0.06043873727321625,
0.5117917060852051,
0.07842805236577988,
0.8410041332244873,
-0.09673169255256653,
-0.018685733899474144,
-0.020260686054825783,
0.06558381021022797,
-0.2228843718767166,
0.5347616672515869,
0.16625836491584778,
-0.28847774863243103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17987v1 | Multi-step Knowledge Retrieval and Inference over Unstructured Data | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | 2024-06-26T00:00:45 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, CJ McFate, Lori Moon, Nati Seifu, Maksim Eremeev, Jose Barrera, Eric Brown, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Generative AI has
revolutionized natural language applications across various domains. However,
high-stakes decision-making tasks in fields such as medical, legal and finance
require a level of precision, comprehensiveness, and logical consistency that
pure LLM or Retrieval-Augmented-Generation (RAG) approaches often fail to
deliver. At Elemental Cognition (EC), we have developed a neuro-symbolic AI
platform to tackle these problems. The platform integrates fine-tuned LLMs for
knowledge extraction and alignment with a robust symbolic reasoning engine for
logical inference, planning and interactive constraint solving. We describe
Cora, a Collaborative Research Assistant built on this platform, that is
designed to perform complex research and discovery tasks in high-stakes
domains. This paper discusses the multi-step inference challenges inherent in
such domains, critiques the limitations of existing LLM-based methods, and
demonstrates how Cora's neuro-symbolic approach effectively addresses these
issues. We provide an overview of the system architecture, key algorithms for
knowledge extraction and formal reasoning, and present preliminary evaluation
results that highlight Cora's superior performance compared to well-known LLM
and RAG baselines. | [
0.05816487595438957,
-0.9049257040023804,
0.9915570020675659,
0.3565200865268707,
0.21332262456417084,
0.3789592385292053,
-0.10643002390861511,
-0.6630175709724426,
0.3722951412200928,
0.3086355924606323,
-0.3686679005622864,
-0.5640706419944763,
-0.6753267645835876,
-0.036910705268383026,
-0.33315086364746094,
0.6633498668670654,
0.05493197590112686,
0.10808859020471573,
-0.6026116013526917,
-0.12605002522468567,
-0.618346095085144,
-0.47408172488212585,
-0.7414143085479736,
-0.764981210231781,
0.3811909258365631,
0.120893694460392,
0.6124677062034607,
0.46285051107406616,
0.5962523818016052,
0.3952893018722534,
-0.09201668202877045,
0.5093360543251038,
0.04860224574804306,
0.4067670702934265,
-0.19798056781291962,
-0.5822196006774902,
-0.4713233709335327,
-0.07210878282785416,
0.1361839324235916,
0.766464352607727,
-0.3326309025287628,
-0.009970017708837986,
-0.21670745313167572,
0.49000096321105957,
-0.7643790245056152,
0.4938243627548218,
-0.6135520935058594,
0.06262356787919998,
-0.02089136652648449,
-0.018296722322702408,
-0.5818665027618408,
-0.10515560954809189,
0.16590791940689087,
-1.350093126296997,
0.008796704933047295,
0.35831543803215027,
0.690221905708313,
0.7476990222930908,
-0.3528713285923004,
-0.3161422312259674,
-0.7623339891433716,
0.9920752644538879,
-0.3053171634674072,
0.3324980139732361,
0.40417468547821045,
0.30899494886398315,
-0.4191736876964569,
-0.9859134554862976,
-0.6189673542976379,
-0.1632164865732193,
-0.12023531645536423,
0.06955026835203171,
-0.26450034976005554,
0.05197947844862938,
0.2194564789533615,
-0.05473913997411728,
-0.39900287985801697,
-0.03726159408688545,
-0.09902862459421158,
-0.24263261258602142,
0.5217949151992798,
0.14599111676216125,
0.3167366087436676,
-0.3638381361961365,
-0.2371280938386917,
-0.1964220255613327,
-0.474838525056839,
-0.38926729559898376,
0.04591663181781769,
0.37997913360595703,
0.1284664273262024,
0.5977314114570618,
-0.3083893954753876,
0.4908944368362427,
-0.11609739810228348,
0.06101648136973381,
0.3558690547943115,
-0.1269218623638153,
-0.15623705089092255,
0.12346970289945602,
0.7832163572311401,
-0.17475779354572296,
0.016998568549752235,
-0.5835099220275879,
-0.09594579041004181,
0.41464757919311523,
0.455862820148468,
-0.19267591834068298,
-0.1894262284040451,
0.3109171390533447,
-0.2317909449338913,
-0.16142499446868896,
-0.2442861795425415,
-0.7729208469390869,
-0.6506223678588867,
-0.7158071398735046,
0.5892776846885681,
-0.6054531335830688,
-0.024057501927018166,
0.30021679401397705,
-0.43938636779785156,
0.1405806988477707,
0.6593310236930847,
-0.5277892351150513,
0.30935341119766235,
0.8705967664718628,
0.5930285453796387,
-0.3376864194869995,
-0.19022886455059052,
-0.47567808628082275,
0.28781571984291077,
-0.1735020875930786,
0.6628904342651367,
-0.6224361062049866,
-0.039387986063957214,
-0.2755758762359619,
-0.3576729893684387,
0.026279259473085403,
-0.4361247718334198,
0.7084165811538696,
-0.7032014727592468,
-0.011436731554567814,
-0.12622202932834625,
-0.28657132387161255,
-0.22504034638404846,
0.42439618706703186,
-0.5807314515113831,
1.1939945220947266,
-0.24232986569404602,
-0.6267335414886475,
0.46030551195144653,
-0.6722468733787537,
-0.5784616470336914,
0.12376051396131516,
-0.4980621933937073,
-0.011301909573376179,
0.026459336280822754,
0.14524176716804504,
0.22516581416130066,
-0.7059457898139954,
0.5478390455245972,
-0.34670785069465637,
0.006193122360855341,
-0.12424366176128387,
-0.3415129482746124,
0.6489834785461426,
-0.003335121553391218,
-0.41257989406585693,
0.3778305649757385,
-0.9563500285148621,
-0.025670064613223076,
0.18848969042301178,
-0.173203244805336,
-0.7297739386558533,
0.28057095408439636,
-0.1505485326051712,
0.33339187502861023,
0.4945431649684906,
-0.5504650473594666,
0.18240690231323242,
-0.2436850219964981,
0.6523105502128601,
0.6845260262489319,
-0.27155035734176636,
0.5361747741699219,
-0.09528163820505142,
0.20106829702854156,
-0.13327595591545105,
0.15174606442451477,
0.28587791323661804,
-0.4735572338104248,
-0.7184633612632751,
-0.21891915798187256,
0.2661380469799042,
0.6266209483146667,
-0.9967336058616638,
0.5520126223564148,
-0.22268186509609222,
-0.2604428231716156,
-0.6620919108390808,
-0.027496708557009697,
0.36588048934936523,
0.655849039554596,
0.7269368171691895,
-0.05626996234059334,
-0.3742733299732208,
-0.7670404314994812,
-0.16335058212280273,
-0.24587473273277283,
-0.10442172735929489,
0.32800838351249695,
0.6488680839538574,
-0.23579029738903046,
0.8324525952339172,
-0.4166710078716278,
-0.25441625714302063,
0.0177007969468832,
0.7258752584457397,
0.19165277481079102,
0.4716035723686218,
-0.16324976086616516,
-0.9072506427764893,
-0.047164276242256165,
0.24437782168388367,
-1.1701624393463135,
0.20041346549987793,
-0.1835443675518036,
-0.5218816995620728,
-0.078746497631073,
0.424038827419281,
-1.2115908861160278,
0.36889368295669556,
0.2404678761959076,
-0.1452793926000595,
0.3247339427471161,
-0.3451453149318695,
-0.10714157670736313,
-1.1154648065567017,
0.29783305525779724,
-0.12470248341560364,
0.0010146698914468288,
-0.42169588804244995,
0.13774295151233673,
-0.12539984285831451,
0.20689986646175385,
-0.07686246931552887,
0.5376027822494507,
-0.39013153314590454,
-0.15656208992004395,
-0.17630714178085327,
0.2567196190357208,
0.12125898897647858,
0.5792274475097656,
0.25877660512924194,
0.5059994459152222,
0.4751442074775696,
-0.45295846462249756,
0.1738586723804474,
0.595790684223175,
-0.0744781345129013,
0.4859826862812042,
-0.7085049152374268,
0.37973472476005554,
-0.1646651327610016,
0.18427972495555878,
-0.5093859434127808,
-0.3285173773765564,
0.06233244761824608,
-0.4352945387363434,
0.12391775101423264,
0.03633495420217514,
-0.6540610790252686,
-0.16073186695575714,
0.04968118295073509,
0.43737033009529114,
0.3679980933666229,
-0.44136250019073486,
1.37796151638031,
0.5487048029899597,
-0.07647068053483963,
-0.9724274277687073,
-0.4584810435771942,
0.1026047021150589,
-0.011310738511383533,
-0.5337700247764587,
0.46197769045829773,
0.3071269989013672,
-0.5119428634643555,
0.08582508563995361,
-0.32179075479507446,
0.007116587366908789,
0.001997404033318162,
0.4782836437225342,
0.3194921612739563,
0.04025626927614212,
0.15720227360725403,
0.13955387473106384,
-0.20697574317455292,
0.3622496724128723,
-0.3661404550075531,
0.546278715133667,
0.031573113054037094,
-0.583891749382019,
-0.28086599707603455,
0.13018539547920227,
0.7446253895759583,
-0.4363041818141937,
0.5031521320343018,
0.34407609701156616,
-0.5898951888084412,
-0.3279438316822052,
-0.45209836959838867,
-0.22031137347221375,
-0.43047600984573364,
0.10553190112113953,
-0.17518319189548492,
-0.4695671498775482,
0.277089387178421,
-0.4794793426990509,
0.20212720334529877,
0.6003825664520264,
0.30414068698883057,
-0.1667342185974121,
0.963102400302887,
0.43903428316116333,
-0.11282597482204437,
-0.0292438305914402,
-0.21301226317882538,
0.17738758027553558,
-0.8386008739471436,
-0.6568111777305603,
-0.715207040309906,
-0.4604891538619995,
-0.220376655459404,
-0.5337129831314087,
0.5987371802330017,
-0.0000013881050335839973,
-0.42041945457458496,
0.1373709887266159,
-0.5086345672607422,
0.11274280399084091,
0.843679666519165,
0.23172248899936676,
0.573784589767456,
-0.15428303182125092,
-0.19169647991657257,
0.15693531930446625,
-0.6794622540473938,
-0.3462686836719513,
0.9211099147796631,
0.007864654064178467,
0.8152775764465332,
-0.049509335309267044,
0.4653919041156769,
0.19238334894180298,
0.2263859510421753,
-0.860485851764679,
0.5321783423423767,
-0.004787025507539511,
-0.7851770520210266,
-0.4387342035770416,
-0.5249842405319214,
-0.9811059832572937,
0.2512533366680145,
-0.6243618130683899,
-0.6414756774902344,
0.13226942718029022,
0.020696597173810005,
-0.3801432251930237,
0.1324997842311859,
-0.3789934515953064,
0.5548689961433411,
-0.3777959942817688,
-0.466871976852417,
-0.5199641585350037,
-0.9695038795471191,
0.2713179588317871,
-0.12029499560594559,
0.1163790300488472,
-0.013634053990244865,
0.12618684768676758,
0.6422019600868225,
-0.11087698489427567,
0.8535197973251343,
-0.03811996430158615,
0.26365602016448975,
0.07987266033887863,
0.20217587053775787,
0.7109435200691223,
-0.007127406075596809,
-0.24146905541419983,
0.1860761046409607,
-0.2222110629081726,
-0.19801130890846252,
-0.8602655529975891,
0.5055286884307861,
-0.7533652782440186,
-0.4869585931301117,
-0.563957691192627,
-1.0398716926574707,
-0.45377975702285767,
0.3097379803657532,
-0.13068191707134247,
0.11528988182544708,
-0.03792952001094818,
0.25216081738471985,
0.636039137840271,
-0.31919896602630615,
0.2719881236553192,
0.334957480430603,
0.15256813168525696,
-0.3368206024169922,
0.8254947662353516,
-0.21554042398929596,
0.0037176499608904123,
0.6002103090286255,
0.12075310945510864,
-0.4369454085826874,
-0.49512484669685364,
-0.32433632016181946,
0.12723417580127716,
-0.538583517074585,
-0.15870928764343262,
-0.7939410209655762,
-0.03750929608941078,
-0.23429517447948456,
-0.06379944086074829,
-0.4573289752006531,
-0.5264167785644531,
-0.10697206854820251,
-0.006467259954661131,
0.42752572894096375,
0.7901355028152466,
0.08211985230445862,
0.07725738734006882,
-0.6724828481674194,
0.5436486005783081,
0.045873962342739105,
-0.1943783313035965,
0.02453378587961197,
-0.1071447879076004,
0.13054046034812927,
-0.16697129607200623,
-0.3796197772026062,
-0.48472464084625244,
0.31788554787635803,
-0.1866137832403183,
0.48828625679016113,
0.06505174189805984,
0.1171809583902359,
0.6699513792991638,
-0.42893049120903015,
0.3993140459060669,
0.19456978142261505,
-0.7830058336257935,
0.4202864468097687,
-0.1262548863887787,
-0.060009393841028214,
0.593848705291748,
0.5118131041526794,
-0.39399582147598267,
-0.12340639531612396,
-0.7079196572303772,
-0.9925416707992554,
0.5325289964675903,
0.3504334092140198,
-0.30586671829223633,
0.12524735927581787,
0.39287590980529785,
-0.05643659085035324,
0.34979093074798584,
-0.2895490825176239,
-0.24249371886253357,
0.23509946465492249,
-0.4573318064212799,
0.11145389080047607,
0.412519246339798,
-0.32994523644447327,
-0.2771782875061035,
0.619426965713501,
-0.32938796281814575,
0.04342661425471306,
0.17697809636592865,
-0.14535287022590637,
0.15641041100025177,
0.021392621099948883,
0.05522103235125542,
0.48332470655441284,
0.13083766400814056,
0.16120567917823792,
0.18791912496089935,
-0.39593619108200073,
-0.04855987802147865,
0.32755035161972046,
-0.31281083822250366,
-0.19189773499965668,
0.502345860004425,
0.5246336460113525,
0.21205675601959229,
-0.7397212982177734,
0.21408773958683014,
0.04408084973692894,
-0.26067355275154114,
-0.3704475164413452,
-0.06813947856426239,
0.1936171054840088,
0.35004520416259766,
0.21322831511497498,
0.3558077812194824,
0.25556960701942444,
-0.5044329166412354,
0.20021310448646545,
0.6403336524963379,
-0.2097138911485672,
-0.23432795703411102,
0.8408927321434021,
0.1717282235622406,
-0.18591266870498657,
1.047215461730957,
0.005376724526286125,
-0.22644531726837158,
0.66811603307724,
0.33258339762687683,
0.6454069018363953,
0.15949055552482605,
0.31120607256889343,
0.03503134101629257,
0.2413444072008133,
-0.336050420999527,
0.4691767990589142,
-0.1770818531513214,
-0.858056366443634,
-0.6159453392028809,
-0.8172622919082642,
-0.5157820582389832,
-0.01914755254983902,
-0.5681511759757996,
-0.005670398008078337,
-0.4924688935279846,
-0.09952668845653534,
0.1560651808977127,
-0.12660208344459534,
-0.5267728567123413,
0.03529508039355278,
-0.19052459299564362,
0.8416827321052551,
-0.605021595954895,
0.720697820186615,
0.6882228255271912,
-0.5071184635162354,
-0.832693338394165,
-0.3272961974143982,
0.11059034615755081,
-0.8950483798980713,
0.820422887802124,
-0.1743038445711136,
-0.2690991163253784,
-0.1696186363697052,
-0.4757864773273468,
-0.7749848961830139,
1.2513642311096191,
0.48368602991104126,
-0.29139742255210876,
-0.49522048234939575,
0.14713293313980103,
0.6140143871307373,
0.030685467645525932,
0.23321880400180817,
0.58423912525177,
0.6729348301887512,
0.3095109164714813,
-0.76315838098526,
-0.021892346441745758,
-0.165739044547081,
-0.4263291358947754,
0.4600382447242737,
-0.4781612157821655,
0.8215848803520203,
0.012933426536619663,
0.026414550840854645,
0.030410291627049446,
0.7263003587722778,
0.6068671345710754,
0.5558789968490601,
0.39619743824005127,
0.9779883623123169,
1.0344274044036865,
-0.12276672571897507,
0.9864934682846069,
-0.45454034209251404,
-0.007213273085653782,
1.2339884042739868,
-0.5335395336151123,
0.8740465044975281,
0.7077789306640625,
0.07809771597385406,
0.651763916015625,
0.3054395020008087,
0.3184467852115631,
0.17764614522457123,
0.0969618707895279,
-0.34362298250198364,
-0.4580475687980652,
-0.40878280997276306,
0.09830677509307861,
0.4624944031238556,
0.6128255724906921,
-0.18077965080738068,
-0.19929718971252441,
-0.37366387248039246,
-0.21370388567447662,
0.044219497591257095,
-0.0597747340798378,
0.7104079723358154,
0.25455498695373535,
-0.7070257663726807,
-0.07368530333042145,
-0.10128822922706604,
0.4071062505245209,
-0.5390042662620544,
-0.4891335964202881,
0.07885733991861343,
0.13089565932750702,
-0.11468539386987686,
-0.5779386162757874,
0.2281671166419983,
-0.19457334280014038,
-0.06619743257761002,
-0.27126428484916687,
0.8109948635101318,
-0.03376888483762741,
-0.3805745244026184,
0.5186281800270081,
0.7500606775283813,
0.050349004566669464,
-0.20982494950294495,
-0.7279684543609619,
-0.12364020198583603,
-0.5340700745582581,
-0.12261715531349182,
0.18706494569778442,
0.6675043106079102,
-0.3591088354587555,
0.9172309637069702,
0.8529538512229919,
0.08319353312253952,
0.01959988847374916,
0.05957911163568497,
0.6740855574607849,
-0.5761293768882751,
-0.14698414504528046,
-0.5665805339813232,
0.32180917263031006,
-0.17004714906215668,
-0.3860849440097809,
0.4544256329536438,
0.4101576507091522,
0.54026859998703,
0.23854538798332214,
0.6968962550163269,
-0.2980985641479492,
0.11304550617933273,
-0.5482432842254639,
0.5266913175582886,
-0.6228507161140442,
-0.0463181771337986,
-0.10238634794950485,
-0.6228876113891602,
-0.4762762486934662,
0.6046459674835205,
-0.20652610063552856,
-0.13688600063323975,
0.7494745850563049,
0.7066221237182617,
-0.07494063675403595,
0.22121529281139374,
0.052242882549762726,
0.22969047725200653,
0.2608235776424408,
0.5982926487922668,
0.9213685989379883,
-0.2084740847349167,
0.33113783597946167,
-0.11158867925405502,
-0.10847494006156921,
0.3667988181114197,
-0.7844908237457275,
-0.6200144290924072,
-0.5217294692993164,
-0.03224780410528183,
-0.22754183411598206,
0.09134674817323685,
1.041408896446228,
0.8410646915435791,
-0.4835425615310669,
-0.0906284898519516,
-0.4951513409614563,
0.18819402158260345,
-0.2015351504087448,
-0.1707618087530136,
0.3498575687408447,
-0.4245831370353699,
-0.7330251932144165,
0.7520803809165955,
0.32993701100349426,
-0.45630842447280884,
-0.17741945385932922,
-0.07913996279239655,
-0.4339773952960968,
-0.013876307755708694,
0.6384068131446838,
0.31771156191825867,
-0.667359471321106,
-0.12685713171958923,
0.21661511063575745,
-0.13809029757976532,
-0.0844472348690033,
0.7144050002098083,
-0.8062810301780701,
0.22483013570308685,
0.6596505641937256,
1.178731083869934,
0.4875653088092804,
0.04832499474287033,
0.6644588112831116,
-0.49075400829315186,
-0.01251344196498394,
0.5152673721313477,
0.41720151901245117,
0.06946545839309692,
-0.4225500822067261,
0.6271020770072937,
0.37669020891189575,
-0.48738840222358704,
-0.5111590623855591,
0.009337930008769035,
-1.039168119430542,
-0.41914406418800354,
0.9584675431251526,
0.13724260032176971,
-0.3283417820930481,
-0.26028111577033997,
0.02973991259932518,
0.37906649708747864,
-0.38811981678009033,
0.9729809761047363,
0.626723051071167,
-0.47238025069236755,
0.3086753189563751,
-0.6301183104515076,
0.3042014539241791,
0.7449946403503418,
-1.1234912872314453,
-0.051873400807380676,
0.5624887347221375,
-0.14698368310928345,
0.7884986996650696,
0.307953804731369,
-0.1196296289563179,
0.09724166989326477,
0.09869074821472168,
0.4298783838748932,
0.10201366990804672,
-0.937424898147583,
-0.13499535620212555,
0.404511958360672,
-0.07557835429906845,
-0.09714213758707047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17982v1 | EDEN: Empathetic Dialogues for English learning | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | 2024-06-25T23:36:16 | Li Siyan, Teresa Shao, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue systems have been used as conversation partners in English learning,
but few have studied whether these systems improve learning outcomes. Student
passion and perseverance, or grit, has been associated with language learning
success. Recent work establishes that as students perceive their English
teachers to be more supportive, their grit improves. Hypothesizing that the
same pattern applies to English-teaching chatbots, we create EDEN, a robust
open-domain chatbot for spoken conversation practice that provides empathetic
feedback. To construct EDEN, we first train a specialized spoken utterance
grammar correction model and a high-quality social chit-chat conversation
model. We then conduct a preliminary user study with a variety of strategies
for empathetic feedback. Our experiment suggests that using adaptive empathetic
feedback leads to higher perceived affective support, which, in turn, predicts
increased student grit. | [
0.19551849365234375,
-0.916039228439331,
0.7393987774848938,
0.17813272774219513,
0.22240372002124786,
0.5079836845397949,
-0.4389612376689911,
-0.13786680996418,
0.6392418146133423,
-0.035281866788864136,
-0.49337539076805115,
-0.6226621866226196,
-0.48005253076553345,
0.11296454071998596,
-0.1292688250541687,
0.7922688126564026,
0.0421014130115509,
0.5927447080612183,
-0.30806875228881836,
-0.12480664998292923,
-0.5377017855644226,
-0.0628831535577774,
-1.352481484413147,
-0.45869889855384827,
0.7520662546157837,
0.7889940738677979,
0.5362296104431152,
0.3235848844051361,
0.6575739979743958,
0.37366944551467896,
0.12495866417884827,
-0.19095824658870697,
-0.41525548696517944,
0.4200300872325897,
-0.3548838198184967,
-0.6965527534484863,
-0.4973289668560028,
-0.1739920973777771,
0.3545774519443512,
0.656323254108429,
-0.23119235038757324,
-0.18168947100639343,
0.4701477885246277,
0.2785840630531311,
-0.2454032003879547,
0.013269788585603237,
-0.34724417328834534,
0.3462813198566437,
0.12024949491024017,
-0.2547064423561096,
-0.5591896772384644,
-0.24555560946464539,
0.0797635093331337,
-0.6232270002365112,
-0.0766601487994194,
-0.11672893911600113,
0.7152084112167358,
0.14964871108531952,
0.04964015260338783,
-0.3082517981529236,
-0.9196468591690063,
1.1788151264190674,
-0.4910450577735901,
0.5110026597976685,
0.6575567722320557,
0.24417336285114288,
0.1984514445066452,
-0.6350029706954956,
-0.36632317304611206,
0.07112864404916763,
0.12662723660469055,
0.7137750387191772,
0.13748100399971008,
0.28422313928604126,
-0.15217404067516327,
0.45109739899635315,
-0.27136707305908203,
0.24846060574054718,
-0.24530498683452606,
-0.0003648438723757863,
0.652214765548706,
0.34223902225494385,
0.3674393892288208,
0.028403248637914658,
-0.0875907614827156,
-0.15503647923469543,
-0.4643854796886444,
0.6038292646408081,
0.44987741112709045,
0.23343870043754578,
-0.1484876126050949,
0.21561764180660248,
0.09193161875009537,
0.39160895347595215,
-0.15938694775104523,
-0.4740915298461914,
0.14136992394924164,
-0.09178858250379562,
0.02714851312339306,
-0.11482027173042297,
0.513859212398529,
0.6803275346755981,
0.22199484705924988,
-0.09396391361951828,
-0.19671577215194702,
0.2532148063182831,
0.28268030285835266,
-0.8398467898368835,
-0.3253503441810608,
0.5707918405532837,
-0.39876794815063477,
-0.2601304352283478,
-0.052029408514499664,
-0.6777447462081909,
-0.1546507030725479,
-0.18632091581821442,
0.48167628049850464,
-0.8085013628005981,
-0.15037739276885986,
-0.03312484174966812,
-0.23753000795841217,
0.4615461826324463,
0.7589490413665771,
-0.812531590461731,
0.3827548623085022,
0.6948085427284241,
1.0167471170425415,
-0.05709311366081238,
-0.5131393074989319,
-0.6019327044487,
-0.1637675017118454,
-0.06412582844495773,
0.8302296996116638,
-0.9523800015449524,
-0.5362245440483093,
0.20081745088100433,
0.10012087970972061,
-0.021828699856996536,
-0.12515997886657715,
0.3862597644329071,
0.3930897116661072,
0.2812874913215637,
-0.24537858366966248,
-0.6551384925842285,
-0.008149073459208012,
0.5000682473182678,
-0.16999311745166779,
0.44223353266716003,
0.3066103756427765,
-0.31122443079948425,
0.16999201476573944,
-0.7806447148323059,
-0.5709934830665588,
0.35305076837539673,
-0.25360774993896484,
-0.1745942085981369,
-0.02026517689228058,
-0.16353657841682434,
0.3924446403980255,
0.08854283392429352,
0.038574494421482086,
-0.13582566380500793,
-0.3344237208366394,
0.21735022962093353,
-0.3892410397529602,
0.5612638592720032,
0.055984433740377426,
-0.45769214630126953,
-0.027181943878531456,
-0.3440852463245392,
-0.1458694040775299,
0.2176060676574707,
-0.24526013433933258,
-0.28898775577545166,
0.15349656343460083,
0.016457516700029373,
-0.05562742426991463,
-0.12300273776054382,
-1.1422775983810425,
-0.10418672114610672,
-0.5021093487739563,
0.2995280921459198,
0.8676904439926147,
0.05016910284757614,
0.08256468921899796,
-0.6140458583831787,
0.7338030338287354,
0.021619020029902458,
0.36446934938430786,
-0.5997254848480225,
-0.6332010626792908,
-0.9293531775474548,
0.01126074232161045,
0.0946623682975769,
0.5916240811347961,
-0.46855252981185913,
0.14166359603405,
-0.0793643593788147,
-0.5189151763916016,
-1.1846781969070435,
0.3207760155200958,
0.674976646900177,
0.21803300082683563,
0.2874051034450531,
-0.7510800361633301,
-0.16146224737167358,
-0.5047814846038818,
-0.3825196325778961,
-0.13916239142417908,
0.09573082625865936,
0.8468509912490845,
0.1760343760251999,
-0.04435021057724953,
0.6573247909545898,
-0.39206016063690186,
-0.5651935338973999,
-0.2740201950073242,
-0.2873622477054596,
-0.19005988538265228,
0.5154395699501038,
0.2999142110347748,
-0.6268963813781738,
-0.9364820718765259,
0.09312526881694794,
-0.3911990523338318,
0.24751031398773193,
-0.17213375866413116,
-0.13284972310066223,
-0.05189326032996178,
0.3641347587108612,
-0.06860560178756714,
0.48570042848587036,
0.6572436094284058,
-0.6177021265029907,
-0.05907591059803963,
0.20220959186553955,
0.31093260645866394,
-1.2679660320281982,
-0.39438551664352417,
-0.1690109372138977,
-0.5160224437713623,
-0.38195863366127014,
-0.2036854326725006,
-0.18354927003383636,
-0.011932955123484135,
-0.691905677318573,
0.4944485127925873,
0.22979089617729187,
0.12308354675769806,
-0.1368981897830963,
0.5109480619430542,
0.20305432379245758,
0.44688504934310913,
0.003566771512851119,
0.6837134957313538,
0.7143946886062622,
-0.5272205471992493,
0.5098001956939697,
0.7255702614784241,
0.34911489486694336,
1.1791796684265137,
-0.7876752614974976,
0.11230219900608063,
0.002254665829241276,
0.0020099824760109186,
-1.0253710746765137,
-0.17538897693157196,
-0.17456306517124176,
-0.8654814958572388,
0.2784191370010376,
0.014171792194247246,
0.215101420879364,
-0.15635058283805847,
-0.4830985963344574,
-0.1701638102531433,
0.666568398475647,
-0.5199265480041504,
0.7895954251289368,
0.29538270831108093,
-0.40654250979423523,
-0.25482872128486633,
-0.6009982824325562,
-0.09626367688179016,
0.19861985743045807,
-0.42950940132141113,
0.3245428800582886,
-0.35637804865837097,
-0.7419130206108093,
0.20354042947292328,
0.2424357384443283,
0.1986081898212433,
0.3597826361656189,
0.5376519560813904,
-0.045134834945201874,
-0.17455385625362396,
0.4626849293708801,
0.12382130324840546,
-0.07107219845056534,
0.20776613056659698,
0.01640928164124489,
0.8632668256759644,
-0.19725939631462097,
-0.3015593886375427,
-0.493542343378067,
0.323466956615448,
0.2837591767311096,
-0.1379333883523941,
0.8115142583847046,
0.4491669535636902,
-0.19448573887348175,
-0.22708578407764435,
-0.1717739850282669,
-0.68831467628479,
-0.4485034644603729,
0.16751348972320557,
-0.2855178117752075,
-0.9709652066230774,
0.37210527062416077,
-0.04361763224005699,
0.4789089858531952,
0.37570998072624207,
0.22327092289924622,
-0.5218052864074707,
1.0219498872756958,
0.47337889671325684,
0.28930410742759705,
0.6229404211044312,
-0.14519134163856506,
0.19343923032283783,
-0.8548753261566162,
-0.33777326345443726,
-0.32526877522468567,
-0.5464261174201965,
-0.25931793451309204,
-0.03231390565633774,
-0.016461525112390518,
-0.49286726117134094,
-0.025494255125522614,
0.15233246982097626,
-0.12147603183984756,
0.41935595870018005,
0.5284947752952576,
0.37358617782592773,
0.09056422859430313,
-0.24533602595329285,
-0.04775194451212883,
-0.3779286742210388,
-0.42554423213005066,
-0.3660869896411896,
1.0638483762741089,
0.5116431713104248,
0.6877419948577881,
0.211269810795784,
0.9045823812484741,
0.1075495257973671,
0.5254607796669006,
-1.086683988571167,
0.3023955523967743,
-0.16574250161647797,
-0.20938508212566376,
-0.3596116900444031,
-0.24302133917808533,
-1.1684948205947876,
-0.27194592356681824,
-0.25472956895828247,
-0.45969489216804504,
-0.31266409158706665,
0.059691525995731354,
-0.8138297200202942,
0.397064745426178,
-0.5750447511672974,
0.5237800478935242,
-0.1920909434556961,
-0.8993672728538513,
-0.3753414750099182,
-0.5329016447067261,
-0.3881854712963104,
-0.028240662068128586,
0.18311947584152222,
-0.009556158445775509,
0.34747999906539917,
0.7426846623420715,
-0.26920104026794434,
1.0184651613235474,
-0.15986408293247223,
0.06413787603378296,
0.3358987867832184,
0.37271416187286377,
0.225225567817688,
0.2231777161359787,
0.06483075022697449,
-0.1608705073595047,
-0.4059092104434967,
-0.5326021909713745,
-0.5515159964561462,
0.7480464577674866,
-0.862995445728302,
-0.7915913462638855,
-0.20608966052532196,
-0.38965293765068054,
-0.1381104737520218,
-0.07537449896335602,
0.0467614084482193,
0.24149660766124725,
-0.4985150694847107,
0.5696513652801514,
0.6244233846664429,
-0.2648419439792633,
0.7179521322250366,
0.65987628698349,
-0.5533340573310852,
-0.37106844782829285,
0.8167574405670166,
-0.0738120824098587,
0.6687735319137573,
0.22681814432144165,
0.29737353324890137,
0.20746874809265137,
-0.01949383318424225,
-0.24224673211574554,
0.23491808772087097,
-0.6796356439590454,
-0.36336201429367065,
-0.9714078903198242,
-0.2071465104818344,
-0.5777924060821533,
-0.8567964434623718,
-0.5815560817718506,
-0.3398309648036957,
-0.11834254115819931,
-0.3494332730770111,
0.7304578423500061,
1.0915188789367676,
0.05951928719878197,
0.6386011838912964,
-0.8260857462882996,
-0.5496025681495667,
0.5413899421691895,
0.3838951885700226,
-0.26621222496032715,
-0.6659668684005737,
-0.19697614014148712,
0.08158926665782928,
-0.746633768081665,
-0.6446263790130615,
0.5600382685661316,
0.5758313536643982,
0.12051667273044586,
0.5074446797370911,
-0.2832251787185669,
0.4107015132904053,
-0.28410738706588745,
1.0153343677520752,
0.012798773124814034,
-1.1227965354919434,
0.9356499910354614,
-0.22057558596134186,
-0.003037575865164399,
0.749761164188385,
0.5194553136825562,
-0.5915574431419373,
-0.6484984755516052,
-1.094236969947815,
-0.8018957376480103,
0.47281643748283386,
0.026180464774370193,
0.6049596071243286,
0.04586628079414368,
0.14593316614627838,
0.18970987200737,
0.10939894616603851,
-0.586984395980835,
-0.2218029946088791,
-0.1755829006433487,
-0.4542507827281952,
-0.19202187657356262,
0.06889057159423828,
-0.21993272006511688,
-0.3923746347427368,
0.7270693182945251,
-0.18353240191936493,
0.1549718827009201,
0.4213322401046753,
0.07688571512699127,
-0.4830698072910309,
0.16853761672973633,
-0.006871636025607586,
0.4258965253829956,
-0.03293284401297569,
-0.063493512570858,
0.29653140902519226,
-0.7630776762962341,
-0.06851945072412491,
-0.4440023899078369,
-0.059034429490566254,
0.20295727252960205,
0.24535849690437317,
0.7800312638282776,
0.528356671333313,
-0.6743572354316711,
0.925939679145813,
-0.33659207820892334,
-0.16929811239242554,
-0.5941207408905029,
0.4260919690132141,
0.03108222968876362,
0.12733742594718933,
-0.1385365128517151,
0.12662824988365173,
0.0068687554448843,
-0.6868597269058228,
0.3419969081878662,
0.16926074028015137,
-0.9083171486854553,
-0.5278507471084595,
0.41062131524086,
0.775658369064331,
-1.1811001300811768,
0.6412525177001953,
0.003315884619951248,
-0.7133387327194214,
0.40867868065834045,
0.8489440679550171,
0.8977984189987183,
-0.7848771810531616,
0.6072589755058289,
0.3721711039543152,
0.08856625854969025,
0.21031081676483154,
0.7006427645683289,
-0.08804338425397873,
-0.8376798629760742,
-0.11548987030982971,
-0.650528073310852,
-1.0500426292419434,
-0.3012588322162628,
-0.7556736469268799,
0.26742708683013916,
-0.6461181044578552,
0.008546974509954453,
0.0006683826795779169,
-0.0031629044096916914,
-0.9301084280014038,
0.36265042424201965,
-0.168691486120224,
0.6370155811309814,
-1.2038242816925049,
0.5365106463432312,
0.9652904272079468,
-0.5344592332839966,
-1.0359243154525757,
-0.09831317514181137,
-0.08936095237731934,
-0.9277030229568481,
0.23720169067382812,
0.40695273876190186,
-0.03462899103760719,
0.4974808096885681,
-0.44046252965927124,
-0.5683804154396057,
1.206322431564331,
-0.10658981651067734,
-0.7346909046173096,
0.3910427689552307,
-0.12452161312103271,
0.44860216975212097,
-0.5854977369308472,
0.655049741268158,
0.37533557415008545,
0.22457627952098846,
0.033684249967336655,
-0.6430128216743469,
-0.3741210699081421,
-0.36240917444229126,
-0.30010101199150085,
0.014054836705327034,
-0.9804233908653259,
0.7954060435295105,
-0.20639818906784058,
-0.042425185441970825,
-0.22818782925605774,
0.4737752676010132,
-0.16292297840118408,
0.4489307999610901,
0.43025749921798706,
0.6365748643875122,
0.9282909631729126,
-0.287883460521698,
1.0883585214614868,
-0.5686150789260864,
0.2867486774921417,
0.6675078272819519,
-0.3790746331214905,
1.136123776435852,
0.6366488337516785,
-0.29229193925857544,
1.0475144386291504,
0.3860067129135132,
0.2081831842660904,
0.03339690342545509,
-0.17878565192222595,
-0.43796104192733765,
-0.3097335994243622,
-0.6184710264205933,
0.11690682172775269,
0.5767082571983337,
0.5632078647613525,
-0.6580724120140076,
0.2216338962316513,
0.42699018120765686,
0.33772701025009155,
0.4388907253742218,
-0.5037235021591187,
0.8739340305328369,
0.19904083013534546,
-0.8438411951065063,
-0.129975825548172,
-0.29485803842544556,
0.6613949537277222,
-0.3712499141693115,
-0.2772967517375946,
-0.45294615626335144,
0.3468966782093048,
-0.42809394001960754,
-0.9491299986839294,
0.13734985888004303,
-0.03414453938603401,
0.13463705778121948,
-0.4608238935470581,
0.5669669508934021,
-0.7668745517730713,
-0.2663346529006958,
0.5877382755279541,
0.5612544417381287,
0.42903846502304077,
0.2754368185997009,
-0.4571317434310913,
0.007454996462911367,
0.08905912190675735,
-0.21539731323719025,
0.17875181138515472,
0.16759806871414185,
0.5708552002906799,
0.4871675670146942,
0.668328046798706,
0.19873157143592834,
-0.4703561067581177,
0.27488547563552856,
0.7921587824821472,
-0.69645094871521,
-0.2982993423938751,
-0.8632439970970154,
0.656059980392456,
-0.10001841932535172,
-0.5687332153320312,
1.109418511390686,
0.35843420028686523,
0.9916843175888062,
0.04856858029961586,
0.7509333491325378,
-0.020871076732873917,
0.5636365413665771,
-0.3746921718120575,
0.4594607651233673,
-0.5733024477958679,
-0.03807942196726799,
-0.24190151691436768,
-0.9018921256065369,
-0.21651893854141235,
0.9388432502746582,
-0.06578556448221207,
-0.011798047460615635,
1.0223520994186401,
0.6517353057861328,
0.19320298731327057,
0.42669254541397095,
0.7291640639305115,
0.2234201282262802,
0.2685774862766266,
0.6480077505111694,
0.8262451887130737,
-0.3962045907974243,
0.12843769788742065,
-0.32451847195625305,
-0.3427930772304535,
-0.07810759544372559,
-0.28206685185432434,
-0.9256073236465454,
-0.48758405447006226,
-0.36586904525756836,
-0.7884284257888794,
0.37715834379196167,
1.3480256795883179,
0.1607362926006317,
-0.725714385509491,
-0.14296641945838928,
-0.29244017601013184,
-0.04143053665757179,
0.012250515632331371,
-0.2587067186832428,
-0.033309437334537506,
-0.8078143000602722,
-1.205830693244934,
0.37390637397766113,
0.5319631695747375,
0.1617012619972229,
-0.34205162525177,
-0.38571614027023315,
0.03719738498330116,
0.3690480589866638,
0.4811979830265045,
0.18319173157215118,
-0.3186260461807251,
-0.4485224187374115,
0.43079182505607605,
-0.03989427164196968,
0.23993487656116486,
0.6409640908241272,
-0.5261954069137573,
0.4572841227054596,
0.11191847920417786,
0.8081371188163757,
0.028457479551434517,
-0.15597496926784515,
0.7514247298240662,
-0.5653117895126343,
0.0757993757724762,
0.5633545517921448,
0.4247724115848541,
0.5441069006919861,
-0.47269365191459656,
0.49580493569374084,
0.4030408263206482,
-0.7227678894996643,
-0.6847647428512573,
0.11782049387693405,
-0.5123496651649475,
0.12411831319332123,
1.3669871091842651,
-0.7533954381942749,
-0.48058703541755676,
-0.25415438413619995,
-0.33787381649017334,
-0.0012051330413669348,
-0.4734092652797699,
0.5742344260215759,
0.8175821900367737,
-0.023051893338561058,
-0.12821714580059052,
-0.2164311707019806,
0.4979816973209381,
0.9939960837364197,
-0.7351037263870239,
-0.3125070631504059,
0.043055493384599686,
0.06159752234816551,
0.2923314869403839,
0.49190306663513184,
0.12136412411928177,
0.31406283378601074,
0.19836212694644928,
0.2066485732793808,
0.3082909882068634,
-0.6860049962997437,
-0.4345546364784241,
-0.19276271760463715,
0.3697151243686676,
-0.07316768914461136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17975v1 | Inherent Challenges of Post-Hoc Membership Inference for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | 2024-06-25T23:12:07 | Matthieu Meeus, Shubham Jain, Marek Rei, Yves-Alexandre de Montjoye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are often trained on vast amounts of undisclosed
data, motivating the development of post-hoc Membership Inference Attacks
(MIAs) to gain insight into their training data composition. However, in this
paper, we identify inherent challenges in post-hoc MIA evaluation due to
potential distribution shifts between collected member and non-member datasets.
Using a simple bag-of-words classifier, we demonstrate that datasets used in
recent post-hoc MIAs suffer from significant distribution shifts, in some cases
achieving near-perfect distinction between members and non-members. This
implies that previously reported high MIA performance may be largely
attributable to these shifts rather than model memorization. We confirm that
randomized, controlled setups eliminate such shifts and thus enable the
development and fair evaluation of new MIAs. However, we note that such
randomized setups are rarely available for the latest LLMs, making post-hoc
data collection still required to infer membership for real-world LLMs. As a
potential solution, we propose a Regression Discontinuity Design (RDD) approach
for post-hoc data collection, which substantially mitigates distribution
shifts. Evaluating various MIA methods on this RDD setup yields performance
barely above random guessing, in stark contrast to previously reported results.
Overall, our findings highlight the challenges in accurately measuring LLM
memorization and the need for careful experimental design in (post-hoc)
membership inference tasks. | [
-0.3798307180404663,
-0.6596652269363403,
0.40719884634017944,
-0.34116533398628235,
-0.49162840843200684,
0.11357764154672623,
-0.14831627905368805,
-0.4066760241985321,
-0.03710939362645149,
0.2749791145324707,
-0.9107668995857239,
-0.6217645406723022,
-0.6830981373786926,
0.08891794085502625,
-0.16294565796852112,
0.7727546095848083,
0.13011819124221802,
0.016608089208602905,
-0.2790742516517639,
-0.3953956961631775,
-0.42021772265434265,
-0.7296276092529297,
-0.15979166328907013,
-0.23673224449157715,
0.5165259838104248,
-0.05188383162021637,
0.5823376774787903,
0.47201821208000183,
0.577042818069458,
0.12760068476200104,
-0.3093213737010956,
0.24191336333751678,
-0.5472174882888794,
0.031844351440668106,
-0.07556688040494919,
-0.7534358501434326,
-0.3238621652126312,
-0.029578322544693947,
0.6036064028739929,
0.9476909041404724,
-0.25251951813697815,
0.09168393909931183,
-0.07037804275751114,
0.504085898399353,
-0.7812516093254089,
0.12929372489452362,
-0.8501510620117188,
-0.06583531945943832,
-0.31609854102134705,
-0.018506472930312157,
-0.5148841142654419,
-0.3771045207977295,
0.2582867443561554,
-0.4424889385700226,
0.24118302762508392,
-0.06877782940864563,
0.88261479139328,
0.12846142053604126,
-0.44638150930404663,
-0.25005221366882324,
-0.6876067519187927,
0.8510333895683289,
-0.8484512567520142,
0.8181431293487549,
0.6700034141540527,
0.2333717942237854,
-0.3445011079311371,
-0.08347894251346588,
-0.2891640067100525,
-0.05723632499575615,
0.2471473664045334,
-0.24559040367603302,
0.03164133429527283,
-0.015099385753273964,
0.22598865628242493,
0.29007387161254883,
-0.5174794793128967,
0.4360700845718384,
-0.06653506308794022,
0.17556865513324738,
0.6449073553085327,
0.029467899352312088,
-0.06554355472326279,
0.04694882780313492,
-0.29790422320365906,
-0.06041286885738373,
-1.1257972717285156,
-0.21104253828525543,
0.3118625283241272,
0.3667343854904175,
-0.21533483266830444,
0.5883798599243164,
-0.05046942085027695,
0.5718177556991577,
-0.22050923109054565,
0.04358581081032753,
0.2945460081100464,
-0.19085556268692017,
-0.2858501970767975,
-0.3533394932746887,
0.5047411918640137,
0.21594417095184326,
0.19365565478801727,
-0.18419122695922852,
-0.3769591152667999,
0.05674990639090538,
-0.18015828728675842,
-0.5482919812202454,
-0.29189223051071167,
0.05639937147498131,
-0.6264898777008057,
-0.17178623378276825,
0.19810906052589417,
-0.6420112252235413,
-0.5406210422515869,
-0.3365892767906189,
0.4823940098285675,
-0.15936905145645142,
-0.27208730578422546,
0.20915605127811432,
-0.16280853748321533,
0.198642760515213,
0.5501899719238281,
-0.660666823387146,
0.12043777853250504,
0.5946651697158813,
0.7201269268989563,
0.045487064868211746,
-0.16246160864830017,
-0.5390826463699341,
-0.026340708136558533,
-0.39423108100891113,
0.6501478552818298,
-0.6519036293029785,
-0.4767914414405823,
0.15388785302639008,
-0.2216530442237854,
-0.3685615658760071,
-0.521441638469696,
0.1031113788485527,
-0.6740314960479736,
0.1365862488746643,
-0.5790817141532898,
-0.7616700530052185,
0.23338337242603302,
0.13162581622600555,
-0.5019341111183167,
0.8766419887542725,
0.25858715176582336,
-1.0486761331558228,
0.6092458367347717,
-0.13572758436203003,
-0.25867462158203125,
-0.1915285438299179,
-0.28616631031036377,
-0.4373282790184021,
0.5686696767807007,
-0.008306206203997135,
0.18215729296207428,
-0.31329625844955444,
0.05342252925038338,
-0.7198188900947571,
-0.5088703632354736,
0.6447613835334778,
-0.3569670617580414,
0.8559861779212952,
0.1585884541273117,
-0.2741043269634247,
-0.025486169382929802,
-0.6355366110801697,
-0.32002291083335876,
-0.09382152557373047,
-0.3260650038719177,
-0.6207921504974365,
0.44213297963142395,
-0.1828336864709854,
0.2777431905269623,
-0.17874889075756073,
-0.2838306427001953,
0.31358614563941956,
-0.3149367868900299,
0.2215394377708435,
0.9795096516609192,
-0.07122554630041122,
0.45597735047340393,
-0.5001670122146606,
0.6219810843467712,
-0.2182774692773819,
0.26060035824775696,
0.15525327622890472,
-0.26191893219947815,
-0.5723490118980408,
-0.37380436062812805,
0.3913862109184265,
0.25095340609550476,
-0.7380363345146179,
0.7165042161941528,
-0.36397865414619446,
-0.3753981292247772,
-0.42498818039894104,
-0.06538629531860352,
0.25618070363998413,
0.08811971545219421,
0.2633344531059265,
-0.020628733560442924,
-0.2945879399776459,
-0.6929705142974854,
-0.042901962995529175,
-0.38374805450439453,
-0.40549036860466003,
0.2636791467666626,
0.46707046031951904,
-0.30583420395851135,
0.8480183482170105,
-0.4060790240764618,
-0.11915513873100281,
-0.33839505910873413,
0.23667064309120178,
0.026016689836978912,
0.17995847761631012,
0.3025531768798828,
-0.2921808063983917,
0.1436552256345749,
0.07220292836427689,
-0.6214523315429688,
-0.2751180827617645,
-0.14643481373786926,
-0.05680405721068382,
0.4647572636604309,
0.5113480091094971,
-0.8968765735626221,
0.4841664731502533,
0.6192614436149597,
-0.21875645220279694,
0.658042311668396,
0.05261088162660599,
-0.013058102689683437,
-0.8758723735809326,
0.07543390244245529,
-0.25476568937301636,
-0.07632625102996826,
-0.3468721807003021,
0.008267829194664955,
-0.04404367506504059,
0.17734932899475098,
-0.37674814462661743,
0.37298962473869324,
-0.7632101774215698,
-0.1268351972103119,
-0.087555430829525,
-0.020273972302675247,
-0.10178923606872559,
0.0896521806716919,
0.028358031064271927,
0.3433331549167633,
0.3782809376716614,
-0.572414755821228,
-0.16070517897605896,
0.42631858587265015,
-0.6044543981552124,
0.38079553842544556,
-0.4357862174510956,
0.15717379748821259,
-0.2462901771068573,
0.44090527296066284,
-1.0401140451431274,
-0.07600225508213043,
0.12688907980918884,
-0.3093825876712799,
0.43554943799972534,
-0.16191734373569489,
-0.37433117628097534,
-0.26068371534347534,
-0.6389033794403076,
0.3976571559906006,
0.494813472032547,
-0.49386507272720337,
0.23639261722564697,
0.33145517110824585,
0.1084555834531784,
-0.7130932211875916,
-0.6369267702102661,
-0.08375830203294754,
-0.5509463548660278,
-0.49698951840400696,
-0.07495448738336563,
-0.07044399529695511,
-0.3730389177799225,
-0.19025413691997528,
-0.4319937229156494,
0.14369727671146393,
0.4797479212284088,
0.16466517746448517,
0.16931456327438354,
-0.19733399152755737,
0.31564581394195557,
-0.05650380998849869,
0.1748543381690979,
0.07517686486244202,
0.06469208002090454,
0.6605445742607117,
0.36185798048973083,
-0.48207128047943115,
-0.5583668351173401,
0.30961841344833374,
0.5288274884223938,
-0.2723861336708069,
0.9310289025306702,
0.12734533846378326,
-0.34044355154037476,
-0.6944909691810608,
-0.5780182480812073,
-0.3385511338710785,
-0.4367593228816986,
0.3891846239566803,
-0.2906164824962616,
-0.9775694608688354,
0.6591423749923706,
0.014414646662771702,
0.25773370265960693,
0.013146967627108097,
0.3114350140094757,
-0.3175871670246124,
0.5026867985725403,
0.47161850333213806,
0.05309198796749115,
0.5889279842376709,
-0.06594666838645935,
0.25708797574043274,
-0.6619016528129578,
-0.15436509251594543,
-0.8006295561790466,
-0.24853652715682983,
-0.4819967746734619,
-0.6551908254623413,
-0.050243228673934937,
0.23715533316135406,
-0.03164828196167946,
0.19843409955501556,
0.12549830973148346,
0.3024778962135315,
0.26725587248802185,
-0.02438248321413994,
0.25292977690696716,
0.09030914306640625,
0.27925464510917664,
0.024545200169086456,
-0.6326234936714172,
-0.23128332197666168,
1.0110349655151367,
0.4158317744731903,
1.0713119506835938,
0.19225336611270905,
0.7315742373466492,
0.148932084441185,
0.44720908999443054,
-0.7847070693969727,
0.4228581488132477,
0.1980815976858139,
-0.45037728548049927,
-0.26882418990135193,
-0.7434396147727966,
-0.9270585775375366,
0.4806613326072693,
-0.2319023609161377,
-0.7778429388999939,
0.5695664882659912,
0.08248412609100342,
-0.05568503215909004,
0.14009150862693787,
-0.4878152012825012,
0.7689714431762695,
0.15575851500034332,
-0.10170625895261765,
0.18748167157173157,
-0.849919855594635,
0.5041419267654419,
-0.33707085251808167,
0.4506057798862457,
-0.22351917624473572,
0.15737400949001312,
0.7246578335762024,
-0.6845051050186157,
0.7437415719032288,
-0.14085455238819122,
-0.18944144248962402,
0.1463421881198883,
0.35195931792259216,
0.5785518288612366,
-0.012561623938381672,
-0.32561612129211426,
0.3359137773513794,
-0.006080632098019123,
-0.2564447522163391,
-0.459776908159256,
0.37648239731788635,
-0.7613272666931152,
-0.7531638145446777,
-0.331291526556015,
-0.5370570421218872,
-0.3348328471183777,
-0.06887257844209671,
0.35118579864501953,
0.4218897223472595,
-0.2910802364349365,
0.4533054530620575,
0.5079593062400818,
-0.2654438614845276,
0.5331238508224487,
0.43083471059799194,
-0.21878370642662048,
-0.3185964524745941,
0.5755866765975952,
0.3281227946281433,
0.5787734389305115,
0.38371843099594116,
0.18687255680561066,
-0.6355465054512024,
-1.0730565786361694,
-0.276469886302948,
0.5233928561210632,
-0.4841509759426117,
-0.2723866105079651,
-0.4598032534122467,
0.11645209789276123,
-0.37436872720718384,
-0.11561628431081772,
-0.3388778865337372,
-0.3116516172885895,
-0.3152540624141693,
-0.36598101258277893,
0.14223386347293854,
0.5970317125320435,
0.10634155571460724,
0.5879378318786621,
-0.8105822205543518,
-0.1391051709651947,
-0.12704084813594818,
0.15421435236930847,
-0.16674606502056122,
-0.617090106010437,
-0.33432820439338684,
0.07989512383937836,
0.00686888350173831,
-0.9877563714981079,
0.11611893028020859,
0.24785935878753662,
0.5684458613395691,
0.6954103708267212,
0.4038093388080597,
0.6217846870422363,
-0.3615769147872925,
0.683449923992157,
-0.06872019171714783,
-0.9558661580085754,
0.30485799908638,
-0.6261205077171326,
0.18419934809207916,
0.7590662240982056,
0.17211931943893433,
-0.46002545952796936,
-0.5398101210594177,
-0.5305302143096924,
-0.7786872386932373,
0.9363860487937927,
0.3877919316291809,
0.04161330685019493,
-0.1861167699098587,
0.22512397170066833,
0.12265787273645401,
0.37578442692756653,
-0.6055186986923218,
-0.1582299768924713,
0.32132837176322937,
0.15758144855499268,
-0.08125369995832443,
-0.34233641624450684,
-0.04304526001214981,
0.05032952129840851,
0.43889203667640686,
0.11793282628059387,
-0.11567249149084091,
-0.04261978343129158,
-0.2436009794473648,
-0.18161489069461823,
0.0636717677116394,
0.4878610074520111,
1.1910454034805298,
-0.47161972522735596,
0.31402915716171265,
0.12995406985282898,
-0.031115952879190445,
0.16889242827892303,
0.07420026510953903,
-0.09204529970884323,
0.2617487609386444,
0.7591223120689392,
0.679903507232666,
0.12437264621257782,
-0.6338025331497192,
0.6197189092636108,
-0.11725493520498276,
-0.1864394247531891,
0.07839865237474442,
-0.10581419616937637,
0.28442883491516113,
-0.006987588480114937,
0.23712556064128876,
0.020588696002960205,
-0.17753878235816956,
-0.5273593068122864,
0.4221315085887909,
0.687936007976532,
-0.13820041716098785,
-0.5536760687828064,
0.526125431060791,
0.002532794838771224,
-0.338228315114975,
0.7040983438491821,
-0.009088524617254734,
-0.1844264268875122,
0.5015928745269775,
0.45129820704460144,
0.665037989616394,
-0.9552702307701111,
0.4165489971637726,
0.02219734527170658,
0.4844134747982025,
-0.14115828275680542,
0.10349053144454956,
-0.19237013161182404,
-0.6551935076713562,
-0.23759278655052185,
-0.6995440125465393,
-0.16164648532867432,
0.24920175969600677,
-0.8822112679481506,
0.4582068622112274,
-0.423386812210083,
-0.10063422471284866,
-0.37602677941322327,
-0.19915398955345154,
-0.4852524399757385,
-0.02076350525021553,
0.09822749346494675,
0.8279077410697937,
-1.1066832542419434,
0.7910751104354858,
0.34523308277130127,
0.07933200150728226,
-0.5050951242446899,
0.11328371614217758,
0.20340321958065033,
-0.3584265410900116,
0.31128254532814026,
0.24217276275157928,
0.006061908323317766,
-0.36755627393722534,
-0.006399147212505341,
-0.7477498054504395,
0.7328420281410217,
0.5451629757881165,
-0.7416943311691284,
-0.11311879009008408,
0.2027655392885208,
0.47435757517814636,
0.06619234383106232,
0.23434463143348694,
0.6196777820587158,
0.2603318691253662,
0.3033618628978729,
-0.8114499449729919,
-0.033961642533540726,
0.06711188703775406,
0.012290057726204395,
0.3234820067882538,
-0.41661354899406433,
1.10883367061615,
0.06965930759906769,
-0.4035766124725342,
-0.11044871062040329,
0.4890098571777344,
0.5261272192001343,
0.35045763850212097,
0.567172110080719,
0.4720904529094696,
0.865158200263977,
0.07641132175922394,
1.0843960046768188,
0.33468392491340637,
0.5952116250991821,
1.2362332344055176,
-0.5656165480613708,
0.8466823101043701,
0.4198421835899353,
-0.3706837296485901,
-0.10322781652212143,
0.9662764072418213,
0.2133142352104187,
0.5560585260391235,
0.5914854407310486,
-0.5350912809371948,
-0.3003394901752472,
0.006991495843976736,
-0.7567318081855774,
0.390872061252594,
0.2635418176651001,
-0.23545508086681366,
-0.5376128554344177,
-0.19709861278533936,
0.1305612474679947,
-0.2839677333831787,
0.14375439286231995,
0.7294674515724182,
0.2954726219177246,
-0.17858663201332092,
0.6577684283256531,
-0.16158108413219452,
0.46124541759490967,
-0.6547898650169373,
0.011046343483030796,
-0.5718033313751221,
0.24173836410045624,
-0.1262519657611847,
-0.11486949026584625,
0.5030075311660767,
-0.16107165813446045,
0.12753911316394806,
-0.01167711615562439,
0.09869081526994705,
-0.42887815833091736,
-0.5049151182174683,
0.4243275821208954,
0.6580985188484192,
0.18401597440242767,
-0.07591579109430313,
-0.3135099709033966,
0.5811271071434021,
-0.03542197868227959,
-0.6050958633422852,
0.5548524260520935,
0.6014466285705566,
-0.2711946368217468,
0.41576701402664185,
0.5486114621162415,
0.13676249980926514,
0.08489015698432922,
0.12071975320577621,
0.9855142831802368,
-0.3133881390094757,
-0.3911229074001312,
-1.0820709466934204,
0.29529356956481934,
0.27782461047172546,
-0.3233170807361603,
0.8704492449760437,
0.5838404297828674,
0.8924486041069031,
-0.23990467190742493,
0.6170251965522766,
0.1518164426088333,
0.0908677950501442,
-0.7566404938697815,
0.8139265179634094,
-0.631929337978363,
0.6533634066581726,
-0.4485984742641449,
-1.0630372762680054,
-0.6454473733901978,
0.7514245510101318,
-0.3527337610721588,
0.002717788564041257,
0.8010690808296204,
0.8616743087768555,
0.005799500737339258,
-0.06856206059455872,
0.4350813627243042,
0.12342418730258942,
0.7504162788391113,
0.4296600818634033,
1.1545345783233643,
-0.3306454122066498,
0.2509290874004364,
0.03276496380567551,
-0.12890438735485077,
-0.31200098991394043,
-0.7329701781272888,
-1.2216989994049072,
-0.3863678276538849,
-0.39689379930496216,
-0.35891851782798767,
0.1640603393316269,
1.1010313034057617,
0.6794823408126831,
-0.6643943786621094,
-0.28791677951812744,
-0.13421325385570526,
0.29373350739479065,
0.011903352104127407,
-0.18769794702529907,
0.6153370141983032,
-0.11380115151405334,
-0.6400056481361389,
0.5038862228393555,
-0.054373402148485184,
-0.05552629008889198,
0.11680865287780762,
0.16956117749214172,
-0.34824004769325256,
0.13355843722820282,
0.5989558696746826,
0.054949671030044556,
-0.6885640025138855,
-0.6242201924324036,
-0.2255493402481079,
0.19393901526927948,
0.02038726396858692,
0.840674102306366,
-0.37419745326042175,
0.21110762655735016,
0.5468689799308777,
0.8415954113006592,
0.2789713740348816,
0.38614848256111145,
0.5107340216636658,
-0.8080296516418457,
0.17901311814785004,
0.2517777979373932,
0.2545216679573059,
0.21327771246433258,
-0.22668084502220154,
0.2717631161212921,
0.34792181849479675,
-0.43247881531715393,
-1.282886266708374,
0.18999429047107697,
-0.9283599257469177,
-0.41539812088012695,
1.1532351970672607,
-0.34958478808403015,
-0.21212206780910492,
-0.27826571464538574,
0.05696091800928116,
0.14645972847938538,
-0.17978861927986145,
0.8844435811042786,
0.90798020362854,
-0.01834159716963768,
-0.18909385800361633,
-0.41174420714378357,
0.49820804595947266,
0.28646335005760193,
-0.9563486576080322,
0.64496910572052,
0.9072625041007996,
0.35701748728752136,
-0.32738423347473145,
0.6706863641738892,
-0.0508766770362854,
0.013110571540892124,
-0.04925728589296341,
-0.003803539788350463,
-0.04335251823067665,
-0.5349802374839783,
-0.5238785147666931,
0.16120949387550354,
0.17364570498466492,
-0.3618271052837372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17974v1 | Evaluating Fairness in Large Vision-Language Models Across Diverse Demographic Attributes and Prompts | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | 2024-06-25T23:11:39 | Xuyang Wu, Yuan Wang, Hsin-Tai Wu, Zhiqiang Tao, Yi Fang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently achieved significant
progress, demonstrating strong capabilities in open-world visual understanding.
However, it is not yet clear how LVLMs address demographic biases in real life,
especially the disparities across attributes such as gender, skin tone, and
age. In this paper, we empirically investigate \emph{visual fairness} in
several mainstream LVLMs and audit their performance disparities across
sensitive demographic attributes, based on public fairness benchmark datasets
(e.g., FACET). To disclose the visual bias in LVLMs, we design a fairness
evaluation framework with direct questions and single-choice
question-instructed prompts on visual question-answering/classification tasks.
The zero-shot prompting results indicate that, despite enhancements in visual
understanding, both open-source and closed-source LVLMs exhibit prevalent
fairness issues across different instruct prompts and demographic attributes. | [
-0.31579869985580444,
-0.47168323397636414,
0.6475170850753784,
0.3156587481498718,
0.013667927123606205,
-0.3611776530742645,
-0.13894978165626526,
-0.32875868678092957,
-0.42244675755500793,
0.6737794280052185,
-0.6540971398353577,
-0.488472044467926,
-0.3018839657306671,
-0.11696807295084,
-0.02765907160937786,
0.7954325079917908,
0.20297761261463165,
0.45784449577331543,
-0.5431561470031738,
-0.47180792689323425,
-0.7877866625785828,
-0.42216238379478455,
-0.4727236330509186,
0.029633326455950737,
0.6472859382629395,
0.21914047002792358,
0.512168288230896,
0.5226384997367859,
0.4675050675868988,
0.30300864577293396,
-0.15246173739433289,
-0.17428739368915558,
-0.5753806233406067,
0.017695769667625427,
-0.4302457273006439,
-0.49519556760787964,
-0.3988308608531952,
0.058128658682107925,
0.7691887617111206,
0.7344076037406921,
-0.0704813003540039,
0.6316259503364563,
0.05296327546238899,
0.787762463092804,
-1.0620192289352417,
0.13609440624713898,
-0.6292127966880798,
0.3858538568019867,
-0.31958597898483276,
0.060468338429927826,
-0.437524676322937,
-0.47437989711761475,
0.19056753814220428,
-0.2886309027671814,
0.4674774408340454,
0.10580486059188843,
0.5824583172798157,
0.3444800078868866,
-0.4254882037639618,
0.033240173012018204,
-0.3535059988498688,
0.7902498245239258,
-0.4433450996875763,
0.443936288356781,
0.07813596725463867,
0.771879255771637,
0.20013633370399475,
-0.40139156579971313,
-0.6151893138885498,
-0.08778177946805954,
0.024144606664776802,
0.21542134881019592,
-0.346843957901001,
0.07746288925409317,
0.5432363152503967,
0.21607878804206848,
-0.7146978378295898,
0.41650766134262085,
-0.43290966749191284,
-0.19615976512432098,
0.4624888002872467,
0.316895455121994,
0.05118916556239128,
-0.32218050956726074,
-0.2371557354927063,
-0.1126542016863823,
-0.4791637063026428,
0.4943651854991913,
0.5064537525177002,
0.358392596244812,
-0.3577210307121277,
0.6682963967323303,
-0.4008696675300598,
0.8625640273094177,
-0.07141770422458649,
0.13995510339736938,
0.4282853603363037,
-0.23776917159557343,
-0.2710804045200348,
-0.18511036038398743,
0.45257723331451416,
0.8793265223503113,
0.5962729454040527,
0.07549820095300674,
-0.30340832471847534,
0.1626632660627365,
0.033355288207530975,
-0.7317867279052734,
0.24007785320281982,
0.02721346542239189,
-0.6881281137466431,
-0.14482904970645905,
-0.009524356573820114,
-1.107872486114502,
-0.9148761630058289,
-0.2999981939792633,
0.4334631562232971,
0.1357429325580597,
-0.2187509536743164,
0.12158635258674622,
-0.4283553957939148,
0.42953041195869446,
0.7517160773277283,
-0.5389127731323242,
-0.0938466265797615,
0.6154441237449646,
0.443289190530777,
-0.10128996521234512,
-0.07414757460355759,
-1.001273512840271,
-0.3486810326576233,
-0.03716456890106201,
0.4483184516429901,
-0.5192171335220337,
0.09384313225746155,
0.20797550678253174,
-0.11117755621671677,
0.04346704110503197,
-0.6141234636306763,
0.28569093346595764,
-0.4477042257785797,
0.3221158981323242,
-0.7101194858551025,
-0.1066669225692749,
-0.03282037004828453,
0.1656271517276764,
-0.5377579927444458,
0.4279794991016388,
0.036652207374572754,
-0.855970561504364,
0.909230649471283,
-0.6808534264564514,
0.08419311791658401,
0.2979733347892761,
-0.5182712078094482,
-0.3619793951511383,
0.15189743041992188,
0.38690242171287537,
0.3103939890861511,
-0.06472767144441605,
0.38546741008758545,
-0.4251461327075958,
-0.3604603111743927,
0.23994258046150208,
-0.9503093361854553,
0.947022557258606,
0.2006419450044632,
-0.41072478890419006,
0.24408259987831116,
-0.5928211212158203,
-0.2545376121997833,
0.16633515059947968,
0.13426068425178528,
-0.3503272235393524,
-0.05023413896560669,
-0.07517246156930923,
0.20735684037208557,
0.25035983324050903,
-0.6528558135032654,
-0.10604492574930191,
-0.10517396032810211,
0.0771496444940567,
1.228466272354126,
-0.4388871192932129,
0.49955660104751587,
-0.023831985890865326,
0.4154415428638458,
0.17455627024173737,
0.6029489040374756,
-0.15793830156326294,
-0.5455926060676575,
-0.7022172212600708,
-0.3767237365245819,
0.034284453839063644,
0.47957557439804077,
-1.0039052963256836,
-0.031331866979599,
-0.2694895267486572,
-0.017447102814912796,
-0.6881802678108215,
-0.07967855036258698,
0.5738135576248169,
0.677727222442627,
0.08088511228561401,
-0.5189418196678162,
-0.07439873367547989,
-1.1439176797866821,
-0.4330827295780182,
-0.11554966121912003,
-0.09995650500059128,
0.6858957409858704,
0.5814764499664307,
0.24386635422706604,
0.9910484552383423,
-0.27993571758270264,
-0.07840763032436371,
0.12348701804876328,
-0.11648174375295639,
0.1645863950252533,
0.23270481824874878,
0.8541277050971985,
-1.0176650285720825,
-0.11300380527973175,
-0.15478593111038208,
-0.8700153231620789,
-0.4916558563709259,
0.35453855991363525,
-0.06217930093407631,
0.1184510588645935,
0.059683047235012054,
-0.09792207181453705,
0.8374401926994324,
0.46383145451545715,
-0.7644527554512024,
0.46280637383461,
0.05493510141968727,
0.5539385676383972,
-0.11531563848257065,
0.024686645716428757,
0.2469671070575714,
-0.22377732396125793,
-0.32640892267227173,
0.22182559967041016,
0.11701305210590363,
-0.07784083485603333,
-0.9183100461959839,
0.7902687788009644,
-0.1330523043870926,
-0.6228781938552856,
0.2664892077445984,
0.2510811984539032,
-0.15998874604701996,
0.40336576104164124,
-0.09247268736362457,
0.6900739073753357,
0.5050414800643921,
-0.35471323132514954,
0.23661015927791595,
-0.021774491295218468,
-0.406882107257843,
1.1527584791183472,
-0.4503230154514313,
-0.030483737587928772,
-0.8745982050895691,
0.20675647258758545,
-0.775745689868927,
-0.0657728835940361,
0.3117516040802002,
-0.30945196747779846,
-0.29704105854034424,
-0.38725563883781433,
-0.1703852415084839,
-0.5551140308380127,
-0.38099750876426697,
0.7916285991668701,
0.6106429100036621,
-0.5624974966049194,
0.458209753036499,
0.07060334086418152,
-0.02907826565206051,
-0.905867338180542,
-0.5436821579933167,
-0.09660198539495468,
-0.2379087507724762,
-0.7922977209091187,
-0.25786203145980835,
-0.10439634323120117,
-0.6652546525001526,
0.004408782813698053,
0.09511376917362213,
-0.014187835156917572,
-0.0018662629881873727,
0.24987517297267914,
0.26189640164375305,
-0.29926609992980957,
0.0025705364532768726,
-0.29098525643348694,
0.1324964016675949,
-0.23917880654335022,
-0.1414879709482193,
0.4143366515636444,
-0.28794151544570923,
-0.7748565673828125,
-0.14111997187137604,
0.2239065021276474,
0.49828019738197327,
-0.6793690323829651,
0.6159970760345459,
0.5747278928756714,
-0.22886399924755096,
-0.14846941828727722,
-0.7941407561302185,
0.12640386819839478,
-0.45681312680244446,
0.27971649169921875,
-0.1895187497138977,
-1.163147211074829,
0.646855354309082,
0.6238067746162415,
0.2963624894618988,
0.4221014678478241,
0.6137186884880066,
-0.011131559498608112,
0.8620626330375671,
0.3901316225528717,
0.5631383657455444,
0.5079888105392456,
0.20521944761276245,
-0.1992988884449005,
-0.4921458065509796,
-0.4777352511882782,
-0.5405563116073608,
-0.2708423435688019,
-0.5490638613700867,
-0.6871250867843628,
0.2968887984752655,
-0.24836815893650055,
-0.5910055637359619,
-0.19561076164245605,
-0.41800469160079956,
0.5211751461029053,
0.6498170495033264,
0.21679595112800598,
0.29816681146621704,
0.07258455455303192,
0.02061920426785946,
-0.38161349296569824,
-0.5629594326019287,
-0.37495550513267517,
0.9488025307655334,
0.49803075194358826,
0.7389119863510132,
0.05032624676823616,
0.44457972049713135,
0.4373224377632141,
0.4845176041126251,
-0.45637163519859314,
0.5332062840461731,
-0.6326391100883484,
-0.6187211871147156,
-0.317067950963974,
-0.8063227534294128,
-0.7292963862419128,
0.5531474947929382,
-0.18002358078956604,
-0.8086792230606079,
0.5870593190193176,
0.3914969265460968,
-0.2150156944990158,
0.314644455909729,
-0.7141465544700623,
1.1057021617889404,
-0.3716801404953003,
-0.4848436713218689,
-0.061008527874946594,
-0.564306914806366,
0.6568900346755981,
-0.05346774682402611,
0.3230299949645996,
-0.32954058051109314,
0.06601692736148834,
0.48276859521865845,
-0.21120929718017578,
0.7543478608131409,
-0.7387067675590515,
-0.13409629464149475,
0.051913484930992126,
-0.07847900688648224,
-0.09749699383974075,
-0.10177332907915115,
-0.17330728471279144,
0.473551869392395,
-0.18166209757328033,
-0.5313298106193542,
-0.6347413659095764,
0.5025414824485779,
-0.47371232509613037,
-0.49006015062332153,
-0.377340704202652,
-0.34345483779907227,
-0.06597364693880081,
-0.027837790548801422,
-0.030824076384305954,
0.5852910280227661,
-0.24748924374580383,
0.2776135206222534,
0.6619618535041809,
-0.9422545433044434,
0.2777228355407715,
0.8039019107818604,
-0.45918434858322144,
-0.11526262015104294,
0.7874030470848083,
0.09223073720932007,
0.440673291683197,
0.14606204628944397,
0.061737243086099625,
-0.3174166679382324,
-0.3465184271335602,
-0.6912189722061157,
-0.028534268960356712,
-0.9241925477981567,
-0.018517542630434036,
-0.5055390000343323,
-0.07603895664215088,
-0.23286178708076477,
-0.00027250632410869,
-0.1868887096643448,
-0.19299761950969696,
0.2144649624824524,
0.22725899517536163,
0.2272661179304123,
0.7417566776275635,
-0.009176199324429035,
0.02698531560599804,
-0.3166850507259369,
0.6710079312324524,
0.776477575302124,
0.6791318655014038,
0.22309550642967224,
-0.4418693482875824,
0.20262911915779114,
0.18368642032146454,
0.03098343312740326,
-0.600841224193573,
-0.14292775094509125,
-0.1858278214931488,
0.6592867374420166,
0.1760713905096054,
-0.021646976470947266,
0.5566697120666504,
-0.7519480586051941,
0.9991726279258728,
0.4302482008934021,
-0.8042480945587158,
0.4460088908672333,
-0.21766535937786102,
0.2252751886844635,
0.5814077854156494,
-0.2217254489660263,
-0.6039012670516968,
-0.43132784962654114,
-0.07535714656114578,
-0.6062542796134949,
0.627244770526886,
0.3225713074207306,
0.07796518504619598,
0.09303078055381775,
0.11097081750631332,
0.18535393476486206,
0.4708072543144226,
-0.915911853313446,
-0.31905582547187805,
-0.45007219910621643,
-0.28087350726127625,
0.2546975016593933,
0.02472631260752678,
-0.04634654149413109,
-0.17785300314426422,
-0.0367574468255043,
-0.08174490183591843,
0.0194606464356184,
0.07078190892934799,
-0.22082994878292084,
-0.04603569954633713,
0.46124354004859924,
0.5368662476539612,
0.8991086483001709,
-0.21552389860153198,
0.008256823755800724,
0.15596799552440643,
-0.32477331161499023,
0.11396247148513794,
-0.02575191669166088,
-0.38989686965942383,
-0.17509053647518158,
0.3943363130092621,
1.0059971809387207,
-0.1673235148191452,
-0.7943611145019531,
1.052347183227539,
-0.4701424241065979,
-0.11294826865196228,
0.10073152929544449,
0.10560493171215057,
-0.3778369426727295,
0.4635959267616272,
0.457813560962677,
0.011242852546274662,
0.1916773021221161,
-0.5565715432167053,
0.034308962523937225,
0.6501590609550476,
-0.5411378145217896,
0.10291081666946411,
0.8523054122924805,
0.4325064718723297,
-0.259937584400177,
0.5485807657241821,
-0.07029394060373306,
-0.37458619475364685,
0.7825673818588257,
-0.06386297196149826,
0.8350008130073547,
0.013085038401186466,
0.28576329350471497,
0.14275284111499786,
0.5147154331207275,
0.22088514268398285,
0.12065394222736359,
0.046859391033649445,
-0.5815022587776184,
-0.38886022567749023,
-0.7978901863098145,
-0.2128864973783493,
-0.07210951298475266,
-0.5997703671455383,
0.14532874524593353,
-0.3931018114089966,
-0.08618820458650589,
-0.006224171724170446,
-0.5181312561035156,
-1.3506946563720703,
0.3827276825904846,
0.5093297362327576,
0.8684174418449402,
-0.8248449563980103,
0.037005651742219925,
0.43029990792274475,
-0.5258181095123291,
-0.2535000741481781,
-0.0959327220916748,
0.12104567885398865,
-1.3017606735229492,
1.00834059715271,
0.27238717675209045,
-0.03172912821173668,
-0.4808509051799774,
-0.7466304302215576,
-0.24174964427947998,
0.868547260761261,
0.7098850011825562,
-0.7790367603302002,
-0.024130506440997124,
0.22421523928642273,
0.4442531168460846,
-0.2679263949394226,
0.37938278913497925,
0.295616090297699,
0.5559490323066711,
-0.04075159505009651,
-1.2471561431884766,
-0.1371990442276001,
-0.15101578831672668,
0.06519821286201477,
-0.08426567167043686,
-0.613969087600708,
0.9523018002510071,
-0.17384587228298187,
-0.200593963265419,
-0.10109729319810867,
0.5087482333183289,
0.34473225474357605,
0.7581031918525696,
0.876370370388031,
0.423401802778244,
0.6430467367172241,
-0.21588575839996338,
1.0620449781417847,
0.27368292212486267,
0.24324238300323486,
0.908319354057312,
-0.3604123890399933,
0.4677934944629669,
0.3010086119174957,
-0.19765548408031464,
0.2301311194896698,
0.2889963984489441,
0.06638624519109726,
0.4082399308681488,
0.3813329339027405,
-0.2332749366760254,
-0.3891613483428955,
-0.3802919387817383,
-0.4566724896430969,
0.5350285172462463,
-0.1557428240776062,
-0.2942499816417694,
-0.35651907324790955,
0.16265225410461426,
-0.3659980297088623,
0.21519094705581665,
-0.7918251752853394,
0.6126765608787537,
-0.000949260254856199,
-0.5347208380699158,
0.2014843076467514,
-0.20293229818344116,
0.8582410216331482,
-0.45604005455970764,
-0.2868134081363678,
-0.3513965606689453,
0.0599026121199131,
-0.09407219290733337,
-1.268796443939209,
-0.29531779885292053,
0.4077901840209961,
-0.3078705966472626,
-0.1683289259672165,
0.4918006658554077,
-0.35088127851486206,
-0.4666166305541992,
0.2638908326625824,
0.4961262047290802,
0.12385601550340652,
-0.09510043263435364,
-0.7278389930725098,
0.12723907828330994,
-0.05094195902347565,
0.12378130853176117,
0.23086175322532654,
0.4902719557285309,
-0.33613070845603943,
0.6970720887184143,
0.4520609676837921,
-0.023826556280255318,
0.18674661219120026,
0.6303502321243286,
0.557428777217865,
-0.5425430536270142,
-0.4674299955368042,
-0.8790416121482849,
0.8754637241363525,
-0.3247021436691284,
-0.26300665736198425,
0.7604588270187378,
0.3208063542842865,
0.7575579285621643,
-0.019806114956736565,
0.5902184247970581,
0.06937730312347412,
0.24332073330879211,
-0.5307714343070984,
0.7001265287399292,
-0.770366907119751,
0.1022280678153038,
-0.5039755702018738,
-1.0556577444076538,
-0.050172798335552216,
0.5874309539794922,
-0.4606722891330719,
0.3012836277484894,
0.12569595873355865,
0.6885358095169067,
0.0010359780862927437,
-0.1971757411956787,
0.47364336252212524,
0.09193160384893417,
0.28744766116142273,
0.5583670735359192,
1.086277961730957,
0.026719961315393448,
0.3647159934043884,
0.1624053716659546,
-0.4674622714519501,
-0.09798496961593628,
-1.002163052558899,
-0.9403090476989746,
-0.21941672265529633,
-0.08330372720956802,
-0.29003453254699707,
0.3649913966655731,
0.6238335371017456,
0.44928112626075745,
-0.565595805644989,
-0.056504566222429276,
0.3784205913543701,
0.28306442499160767,
0.212174192070961,
-0.28133735060691833,
0.141633078455925,
0.09696287661790848,
-0.5455058813095093,
-0.2615545988082886,
0.4864831566810608,
-0.05821453779935837,
-0.5914347767829895,
-0.15991012752056122,
0.46945443749427795,
-0.10512104630470276,
0.7251483201980591,
0.06685934960842133,
-0.905429482460022,
-0.4662633538246155,
-0.10036679357290268,
-0.14323021471500397,
0.0553271658718586,
0.6504199504852295,
-0.8264715671539307,
0.7400063872337341,
0.444986492395401,
0.4223884642124176,
0.19975389540195465,
-0.015628725290298462,
0.5564354658126831,
-0.7265048027038574,
0.2999267280101776,
0.3095259666442871,
0.3918518126010895,
0.5158844590187073,
-0.12993504106998444,
0.35042744874954224,
0.26261675357818604,
-0.4004851281642914,
-0.9153925180435181,
0.26535728573799133,
-0.8150709271430969,
-0.1470557302236557,
0.9997244477272034,
0.002558841835707426,
-0.18542757630348206,
-0.003769754199311137,
-0.33981001377105713,
-0.12834306061267853,
-0.3382010757923126,
0.2957836985588074,
0.5540172457695007,
0.3235101103782654,
-0.31995779275894165,
-0.9499802589416504,
0.22648081183433533,
0.26448190212249756,
-0.649603545665741,
0.25237715244293213,
0.8896391987800598,
0.19136299192905426,
-0.2920433282852173,
0.756090521812439,
-0.16789020597934723,
0.578143835067749,
-0.10828348994255066,
0.03756153956055641,
0.025775261223316193,
-0.08507518470287323,
-0.5912401080131531,
0.10242696106433868,
-0.05970529094338417,
-0.03054855205118656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17972v1 | LABOR-LLM: Language-Based Occupational Representations with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | 2024-06-25T23:07:18 | Tianyu Du, Ayush Kanodia, Herman Brunborg, Keyon Vafa, Susan Athey | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, econ.EM | Many empirical studies of labor market questions rely on estimating
relatively simple predictive models using small, carefully constructed
longitudinal survey datasets based on hand-engineered features. Large Language
Models (LLMs), trained on massive datasets, encode vast quantities of world
knowledge and can be used for the next job prediction problem. However, while
an off-the-shelf LLM produces plausible career trajectories when prompted, the
probability with which an LLM predicts a particular job transition conditional
on career history will not, in general, align with the true conditional
probability in a given population. Recently, Vafa et al. (2024) introduced a
transformer-based "foundation model", CAREER, trained using a large,
unrepresentative resume dataset, that predicts transitions between jobs; it
further demonstrated how transfer learning techniques can be used to leverage
the foundation model to build better predictive models of both transitions and
wages that reflect conditional transition probabilities found in nationally
representative survey datasets. This paper considers an alternative where the
fine-tuning of the CAREER foundation model is replaced by fine-tuning LLMs. For
the task of next job prediction, we demonstrate that models trained with our
approach outperform several alternatives in terms of predictive performance on
the survey data, including traditional econometric models, CAREER, and LLMs
with in-context learning, even though the LLM can in principle predict job
titles that are not allowed in the survey data. Further, we show that our
fine-tuned LLM-based models' predictions are more representative of the career
trajectories of various workforce subpopulations than off-the-shelf LLM models
and CAREER. We conduct experiments and analyses that highlight the sources of
the gains in the performance of our models for representative predictions. | [
-0.11384955793619156,
-0.3484329581260681,
0.6334450840950012,
-0.09016101062297821,
0.08400987088680267,
0.07299856841564178,
-0.36688581109046936,
-0.5945589542388916,
0.07417591661214828,
0.8319147229194641,
-0.6643511652946472,
-0.37403082847595215,
-0.5580683350563049,
-0.047941405326128006,
-0.46001359820365906,
0.8066785931587219,
0.2647378146648407,
0.03831905871629715,
-0.5848309397697449,
0.2709799110889435,
-0.3318629264831543,
-0.4133453071117401,
-0.6830683350563049,
-0.6448134779930115,
0.43159860372543335,
0.19632719457149506,
0.5865933299064636,
0.6802454590797424,
0.3500608205795288,
0.1970696896314621,
-0.02681208960711956,
-0.06973844021558762,
-0.723149836063385,
-0.12416121363639832,
-0.018130015581846237,
-0.8938281536102295,
-0.16455711424350739,
0.17938831448554993,
0.36791911721229553,
1.244523286819458,
-0.11199932545423508,
0.2218385934829712,
-0.07401175796985626,
0.7326095104217529,
-0.4077167510986328,
0.5211358070373535,
-0.7956607937812805,
0.07316340506076813,
-0.16872303187847137,
-0.1628648191690445,
-0.6445116400718689,
-0.3056127727031708,
0.10227841138839722,
-0.04139687865972519,
0.21018901467323303,
-0.035497359931468964,
0.44898849725723267,
0.1155521348118782,
-0.8020980358123779,
-0.06505708396434784,
-0.9319120645523071,
0.8161189556121826,
-0.6047064661979675,
0.6959730386734009,
0.28622499108314514,
0.3535448908805847,
-0.0979485958814621,
-0.6155464053153992,
-0.17920050024986267,
-0.34941646456718445,
-0.06486807018518448,
0.20363785326480865,
0.15936660766601562,
0.17281198501586914,
0.03735904395580292,
0.4323107600212097,
-0.21215179562568665,
0.5027040243148804,
-0.628682017326355,
0.10158568620681763,
0.6274460554122925,
0.6197336316108704,
-0.291891872882843,
0.4008018970489502,
-0.2458445280790329,
-0.1910807490348816,
-1.042077660560608,
0.22088690102100372,
0.3947139084339142,
0.43100687861442566,
-0.1356474757194519,
0.5369099378585815,
-0.3264037072658539,
1.013562798500061,
0.11989796906709671,
-0.4059719443321228,
0.049879901111125946,
0.08599793910980225,
-0.08267476409673691,
-0.33423665165901184,
0.49477508664131165,
0.34366780519485474,
0.2694966793060303,
-0.34688112139701843,
-0.30315566062927246,
0.21622078120708466,
0.19086778163909912,
-0.41904088854789734,
-0.15349441766738892,
-0.06107981503009796,
-0.4163086712360382,
-0.24624839425086975,
0.05561904236674309,
-0.42310211062431335,
-0.6246306896209717,
-0.5174087882041931,
-0.16638080775737762,
0.16917608678340912,
-0.06499920040369034,
0.11774740368127823,
0.28633150458335876,
0.2531154751777649,
0.3730018138885498,
-0.8181279897689819,
0.18873821198940277,
0.8503609299659729,
0.5970596671104431,
-0.6641795635223389,
-0.04254130646586418,
-0.2723727524280548,
0.021597960963845253,
-0.4555336833000183,
0.5811911225318909,
-0.6516872644424438,
-0.3851868510246277,
0.43218839168548584,
0.24396592378616333,
-0.205378919839859,
-0.7431729435920715,
0.03355845436453819,
-0.8169323205947876,
0.17093093693256378,
-0.03466253727674484,
-0.5546213984489441,
-0.18799859285354614,
0.3418189287185669,
-0.8294243812561035,
0.7893862724304199,
0.45436182618141174,
-0.38614359498023987,
0.38109734654426575,
-0.4785754084587097,
-0.24165737628936768,
-0.3709520399570465,
-0.23387059569358826,
-0.17256443202495575,
0.06299036741256714,
-0.2656843662261963,
0.6790370941162109,
-0.37871816754341125,
0.3961983621120453,
-0.24374936521053314,
-0.4162490963935852,
0.2878475785255432,
-0.37758806347846985,
0.7559118866920471,
0.011065343394875526,
0.003006297629326582,
-0.1591724008321762,
-0.4213811755180359,
-0.49003881216049194,
-0.2168455570936203,
-0.6221562027931213,
0.08799625933170319,
-0.10278024524450302,
-0.1765737235546112,
0.3242880403995514,
0.36821645498275757,
-0.5369550585746765,
0.04135506972670555,
-0.6227921843528748,
-0.0870111882686615,
0.7393524646759033,
-0.20526233315467834,
0.7149764895439148,
-0.5480331778526306,
0.8723740577697754,
-0.05868489295244217,
0.006872956175357103,
0.03453758358955383,
-0.31731557846069336,
-0.5509659647941589,
0.2625643014907837,
0.22976519167423248,
0.6470447778701782,
-0.5378362536430359,
0.1794680804014206,
-0.3809766173362732,
-0.6225028038024902,
-0.015018164180219173,
0.12824241816997528,
0.05044122412800789,
0.6300353407859802,
0.19815826416015625,
-0.2154572308063507,
-0.7981385588645935,
-0.6366177201271057,
-0.3417062759399414,
-0.40509676933288574,
0.13098300993442535,
0.0679020881652832,
0.2085995078086853,
-0.16648302972316742,
0.9482877254486084,
-0.5763658285140991,
-0.19083428382873535,
-0.3873985707759857,
-0.08238830417394638,
0.9890497326850891,
0.2904348075389862,
0.28148433566093445,
-0.7990484833717346,
-0.59891277551651,
0.012532920576632023,
-0.38338831067085266,
0.01958325132727623,
-0.348760187625885,
0.009942710399627686,
-0.02359388954937458,
0.7290647625923157,
-0.5525139570236206,
0.17928454279899597,
0.8031982183456421,
-0.4102528691291809,
0.8246859908103943,
0.10833773761987686,
-0.2961348295211792,
-0.9362625479698181,
-0.03266378492116928,
0.21055808663368225,
-0.31580230593681335,
-0.6334097385406494,
-0.2065759152173996,
-0.16876807808876038,
-0.06741517782211304,
-0.5632221698760986,
0.8759438991546631,
-0.5547235012054443,
-0.29004335403442383,
-0.17062143981456757,
-0.2622205317020416,
-0.27954909205436707,
0.37961170077323914,
0.21959100663661957,
0.7922078371047974,
0.39416712522506714,
-0.6145411729812622,
0.45005059242248535,
0.37518081068992615,
-0.332741379737854,
0.45015519857406616,
-0.2900991439819336,
-0.07092374563217163,
-0.20456767082214355,
0.6013665199279785,
-0.6494426131248474,
-0.08159969747066498,
-0.169213205575943,
-0.023077163845300674,
0.2450304925441742,
-0.22865813970565796,
-0.27490898966789246,
-0.5723001956939697,
-0.20719541609287262,
0.036079637706279755,
0.7428290247917175,
-0.44529199600219727,
0.5363317131996155,
0.34579819440841675,
-0.24811336398124695,
-0.7267187237739563,
-1.02295982837677,
-0.07199742645025253,
-0.28358450531959534,
-0.3852745294570923,
0.6509154438972473,
0.06917071342468262,
-0.288912832736969,
-0.17563392221927643,
-0.13194046914577484,
-0.36779317259788513,
0.009359868243336678,
0.16103948652744293,
0.778692364692688,
-0.27874356508255005,
0.07684900611639023,
-0.19684679806232452,
-0.14919964969158173,
0.3414488136768341,
-0.0015752550680190325,
0.3917231261730194,
0.17913486063480377,
-0.43423137068748474,
0.20332852005958557,
-0.2619660794734955,
0.6681777834892273,
0.056240007281303406,
0.8695196509361267,
0.5786571502685547,
-0.24779807031154633,
0.04713711142539978,
-0.7266864776611328,
-0.2713514566421509,
-0.42241278290748596,
0.4266546368598938,
0.000489724101498723,
-1.0459116697311401,
0.48119860887527466,
-0.4863465428352356,
0.2090216875076294,
0.39040201902389526,
0.6316918730735779,
-0.20153899490833282,
0.6169121265411377,
0.8474780321121216,
-0.19881737232208252,
0.7651528716087341,
-0.49055686593055725,
0.033018939197063446,
-0.7696300148963928,
-0.4868449568748474,
-0.20713208615779877,
-0.3036114275455475,
-0.42264941334724426,
-0.39727744460105896,
0.49017563462257385,
-0.15182217955589294,
-0.1652640551328659,
0.28760093450546265,
-0.09804011136293411,
0.4789717197418213,
0.33977559208869934,
0.0987517386674881,
0.3165149688720703,
-0.0887690931558609,
0.3096216320991516,
0.07387498021125793,
-0.5735688805580139,
-0.3378846049308777,
1.32044517993927,
0.33856961131095886,
0.8619319796562195,
-0.14832386374473572,
0.6184925436973572,
0.2674712836742401,
0.6782559156417847,
-0.5870748162269592,
0.39560532569885254,
-0.6153860688209534,
-0.4624735116958618,
-0.4380262792110443,
-0.27244848012924194,
-1.0311006307601929,
0.27103567123413086,
-0.5744668245315552,
-0.7438650131225586,
0.47623410820961,
0.1922253668308258,
-0.3665326237678528,
0.48853275179862976,
-0.24189187586307526,
0.6017439961433411,
-0.1460416615009308,
-0.24190936982631683,
-0.1902303695678711,
-0.5038585066795349,
0.39005380868911743,
-0.26048967242240906,
0.3828144073486328,
-0.3382228910923004,
-0.05552217736840248,
0.6439468264579773,
-0.3133898675441742,
1.315185546875,
-0.24054180085659027,
-0.05840734392404556,
0.11095131933689117,
0.008442427963018417,
0.7909319996833801,
-0.1697235256433487,
-0.6394943594932556,
0.05318421870470047,
-0.102778360247612,
-0.02539723925292492,
-0.31339460611343384,
0.497577965259552,
-0.5110582113265991,
-0.6215331554412842,
-0.03483559936285019,
-0.6244325041770935,
-0.7564074397087097,
0.12799446284770966,
0.2508494257926941,
0.28708159923553467,
-0.30972835421562195,
0.5516101121902466,
0.5182168483734131,
0.06414984911680222,
0.0018671362195163965,
0.34887081384658813,
-0.18039321899414062,
0.07140655070543289,
0.5092787146568298,
0.1786898821592331,
0.06753037869930267,
0.4879739284515381,
0.14611992239952087,
-0.777834951877594,
-0.2624466121196747,
-0.13234898447990417,
0.4137129783630371,
-0.7666769623756409,
-0.3981642723083496,
-0.3771917223930359,
-0.2222762554883957,
-0.32411080598831177,
-0.3171435296535492,
-0.23618850111961365,
0.00824070256203413,
-0.523500382900238,
-0.3055526316165924,
0.28421851992607117,
0.7622443437576294,
-0.023641077801585197,
0.28229624032974243,
-0.6227384209632874,
0.19921322166919708,
0.4515259861946106,
0.46333542466163635,
-0.1427118331193924,
-0.49816200137138367,
-0.5818523168563843,
0.15723490715026855,
-0.11280401051044464,
-0.8010568618774414,
0.28038710355758667,
0.27682697772979736,
0.6859865188598633,
0.2420341670513153,
0.08145265281200409,
0.3839086890220642,
-0.2576347887516022,
0.7971197962760925,
0.39393308758735657,
-0.49627891182899475,
0.04399443790316582,
-0.43681058287620544,
0.13793888688087463,
0.6806187033653259,
0.3674144148826599,
-0.6530603766441345,
-0.256542831659317,
-0.6017974019050598,
-0.7192986607551575,
0.6100597977638245,
-0.17971301078796387,
0.45753321051597595,
0.02585560455918312,
0.1874626874923706,
0.4958462119102478,
0.21388237178325653,
-0.6840626001358032,
-0.24071364104747772,
0.2682380974292755,
-0.27623188495635986,
-0.22647063434123993,
-0.22109420597553253,
0.16975893080234528,
-0.2747512459754944,
0.38544172048568726,
0.023093458265066147,
0.25908005237579346,
-0.37078896164894104,
-0.06873618066310883,
-0.14553874731063843,
0.13625885546207428,
0.17452538013458252,
0.9601070284843445,
-0.07509107142686844,
0.04522593319416046,
0.600064754486084,
-0.05206839740276337,
0.18786168098449707,
-0.08525584638118744,
0.054920345544815063,
0.17744679749011993,
0.3168770968914032,
0.8948512673377991,
0.2349809855222702,
-0.7619420886039734,
0.5763809084892273,
0.48009392619132996,
-0.2914697229862213,
-0.8839582800865173,
0.20023564994335175,
0.45721355080604553,
0.3649604320526123,
0.38116616010665894,
0.0011068156454712152,
-0.0024364995770156384,
-0.680463433265686,
-0.054348476231098175,
0.3457496166229248,
-0.36803218722343445,
-0.25346317887306213,
0.7783820033073425,
0.13054503500461578,
-0.09517687559127808,
0.6043893694877625,
0.20197655260562897,
-0.15666203200817108,
0.9837164282798767,
0.7311834096908569,
0.4579889178276062,
-0.24055561423301697,
0.1734209656715393,
0.10701929777860641,
-0.031909700483083725,
-0.7520703077316284,
0.11041044443845749,
0.31430089473724365,
-0.9161931872367859,
-0.555250346660614,
-0.5646981596946716,
-0.587884247303009,
0.17650878429412842,
-0.7142813205718994,
0.2245575487613678,
-0.22180895507335663,
-0.07058185338973999,
-0.5335817337036133,
-0.3931058645248413,
-1.2005506753921509,
0.6739851236343384,
0.32362979650497437,
1.0376830101013184,
-1.2115648984909058,
0.6997881531715393,
0.8060552477836609,
-0.050432994961738586,
-0.502703070640564,
-0.05229494348168373,
-0.28363537788391113,
-0.9157649874687195,
0.6217070817947388,
0.15619368851184845,
-0.03448761627078056,
0.053200360387563705,
-0.24825212359428406,
-0.938822865486145,
1.244209885597229,
0.8780718445777893,
-0.6346384882926941,
-0.412239670753479,
0.3028493821620941,
0.516457736492157,
-0.603073000907898,
0.15018443763256073,
0.706864595413208,
0.3859785795211792,
-0.1886211633682251,
-0.9206162691116333,
-0.12730540335178375,
0.10923425108194351,
0.2448054552078247,
-0.00735530024394393,
-0.425563246011734,
1.0080876350402832,
-0.16565866768360138,
-0.14296558499336243,
-0.05754301697015762,
0.6599860191345215,
0.2967926561832428,
0.2282891869544983,
0.8042287230491638,
0.18043777346611023,
0.715746283531189,
-0.08718618005514145,
1.0559139251708984,
-0.6639750599861145,
0.6011996865272522,
0.8710882663726807,
0.030583253130316734,
0.9167355298995972,
0.32998284697532654,
-0.6722733378410339,
0.9761427044868469,
0.6679209470748901,
-0.1594650149345398,
0.3191405236721039,
0.24094311892986298,
-0.18210068345069885,
-0.4058261215686798,
-0.07102911919355392,
-0.4051760733127594,
0.5261042714118958,
0.36309972405433655,
-0.4688863158226013,
-0.04226837679743767,
-0.09988339990377426,
-0.25985538959503174,
0.17153514921665192,
-0.41227254271507263,
0.5357620120048523,
0.29949358105659485,
-0.43516287207603455,
0.4207237660884857,
-0.11606951057910919,
0.9592963457107544,
-0.5488775968551636,
-0.23172135651111603,
-0.3478321135044098,
-0.22806298732757568,
-0.35517382621765137,
-0.866433322429657,
0.5327680110931396,
-0.3376598358154297,
-0.16999895870685577,
-0.39231571555137634,
0.7561402916908264,
-0.6921728849411011,
-0.5187368392944336,
0.12920185923576355,
0.762709379196167,
0.12213419377803802,
-0.002735847607254982,
-0.4577638804912567,
-0.15330928564071655,
-0.09143578261137009,
-0.34592339396476746,
0.3267104923725128,
0.05253627896308899,
-0.0687147006392479,
0.6570728421211243,
0.5768943428993225,
0.37078046798706055,
0.015598190948367119,
-0.07051517069339752,
0.6105294227600098,
-0.5801686644554138,
-0.8538312315940857,
-0.6361131072044373,
0.4691808819770813,
0.10656647384166718,
-0.07226242125034332,
0.17003455758094788,
0.4538285732269287,
0.9986831545829773,
-0.48141348361968994,
0.7487269639968872,
0.1727592647075653,
0.5577296018600464,
-0.650845468044281,
0.42438217997550964,
-0.5124380588531494,
0.1818506270647049,
0.10217729210853577,
-0.9677357077598572,
-0.09465907514095306,
0.30741414427757263,
-0.650495707988739,
0.3138723373413086,
0.47895172238349915,
0.674041748046875,
-0.1706119179725647,
-0.3596513271331787,
0.5022533535957336,
0.0463564395904541,
-0.14580030739307404,
0.49914130568504333,
0.5848399996757507,
0.12261179834604263,
0.5395098328590393,
-0.2888031303882599,
0.16641469299793243,
-0.5776975750923157,
-0.7031489610671997,
-0.5613321661949158,
-0.45473578572273254,
-0.3132723867893219,
-0.23400188982486725,
0.025820059701800346,
0.720150887966156,
0.7611812949180603,
-0.740206241607666,
-0.6715136170387268,
-0.06723049283027649,
-0.09174951910972595,
-0.26468679308891296,
-0.268854022026062,
0.06659527868032455,
-0.035934928804636,
-0.5640562772750854,
0.6524453163146973,
-0.08049622178077698,
-0.2528265118598938,
-0.48753297328948975,
-0.1437683254480362,
0.25643250346183777,
-0.18334630131721497,
0.5223626494407654,
0.4412316381931305,
-0.8121628165245056,
-0.054672133177518845,
-0.14833517372608185,
-0.05528789013624191,
0.11735896021127701,
0.8103808760643005,
-0.9065502882003784,
0.12002838402986526,
0.4339279532432556,
0.7700268030166626,
0.6110237836837769,
-0.027154387906193733,
0.7783210277557373,
-0.7641264200210571,
0.049751657992601395,
0.13939353823661804,
0.5170390009880066,
0.3498103618621826,
-0.7649140954017639,
0.7932600378990173,
0.1462642401456833,
-0.18776963651180267,
-0.6150632500648499,
0.41663768887519836,
-0.6093159317970276,
-0.1791641116142273,
1.111437439918518,
-0.04672757163643837,
-0.04531208053231239,
-0.21371915936470032,
0.19559849798679352,
0.2875579595565796,
-0.27374571561813354,
0.7952224612236023,
0.3582092523574829,
-0.42617878317832947,
-0.40894895792007446,
-0.5946632623672485,
0.03368402272462845,
0.21385784447193146,
-0.6138998866081238,
0.15137726068496704,
0.38885095715522766,
0.38742268085479736,
-0.11444073915481567,
0.9014118313789368,
0.05018565431237221,
0.3181461989879608,
-0.07400867342948914,
0.037497855722904205,
-0.17308904230594635,
-0.23603889346122742,
-0.20020510256290436,
0.1706993281841278,
0.428464412689209,
0.04542329162359238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17969v1 | Encourage or Inhibit Monosemanticity? Revisit Monosemanticity from a Feature Decorrelation Perspective | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | 2024-06-25T22:51:08 | Hanqi Yan, Yanzheng Xiang, Guangyi Chen, Yifei Wang, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To better interpret the intrinsic mechanism of large language models (LLMs),
recent studies focus on monosemanticity on its basic units. A monosemantic
neuron is dedicated to a single and specific concept, which forms a one-to-one
correlation between neurons and concepts. Despite extensive research in
monosemanticity probing, it remains unclear whether monosemanticity is
beneficial or harmful to model capacity. To explore this question, we revisit
monosemanticity from the feature decorrelation perspective and advocate for its
encouragement. We experimentally observe that the current conclusion by
wang2024learning, which suggests that decreasing monosemanticity enhances model
performance, does not hold when the model changes. Instead, we demonstrate that
monosemanticity consistently exhibits a positive correlation with model
capacity, in the preference alignment process. Consequently, we apply feature
correlation as a proxy for monosemanticity and incorporate a feature
decorrelation regularizer into the dynamic preference optimization process. The
experiments show that our method not only enhances representation diversity and
activation sparsity but also improves preference alignment performance. | [
-0.6740687489509583,
-0.5435856580734253,
0.22186070680618286,
0.448121041059494,
-0.43800684809684753,
0.07504507154226303,
-0.49839505553245544,
-0.4327433705329895,
0.943032443523407,
0.38042572140693665,
-0.4718659222126007,
0.04816248267889023,
-0.57071852684021,
0.011087549850344658,
-0.2526010274887085,
1.0181909799575806,
0.006331874988973141,
-0.06120529770851135,
-0.5099422931671143,
-0.4423027038574219,
-0.4747198224067688,
-0.8605889678001404,
-0.7150415182113647,
-0.5020124316215515,
0.9714246988296509,
0.22344212234020233,
0.8571046590805054,
0.6871245503425598,
0.472761332988739,
0.3331077992916107,
-0.39724791049957275,
0.19181916117668152,
-0.5477860569953918,
0.4415309429168701,
0.066114142537117,
-0.4700154662132263,
-0.6992870569229126,
0.008914114907383919,
0.6379258632659912,
0.9359267354011536,
0.01889885403215885,
0.1256701797246933,
0.35418498516082764,
0.9277749061584473,
-0.43205544352531433,
0.08681149035692215,
-0.5192087292671204,
0.10787643492221832,
-0.18929386138916016,
-0.08437714725732803,
-0.27599796652793884,
-0.04422462359070778,
0.2908657193183899,
-0.48732200264930725,
0.19780226051807404,
0.08397101610898972,
0.8379678726196289,
0.19594056904315948,
-0.20609398186206818,
0.085399329662323,
-0.6267488598823547,
0.8269521594047546,
-0.377948135137558,
0.28745037317276,
0.16891930997371674,
-0.10006765276193619,
0.16970278322696686,
-0.1223345398902893,
-0.272524356842041,
-0.46390244364738464,
-0.39907214045524597,
-0.05881170928478241,
-0.035964686423540115,
-0.04456537589430809,
0.4288877546787262,
0.2876611053943634,
-0.2542577385902405,
0.13028857111930847,
-0.26067134737968445,
-0.33949971199035645,
0.536830484867096,
0.058123670518398285,
0.25934815406799316,
-0.20479917526245117,
-0.6780865788459778,
-0.08086305111646652,
-0.42294323444366455,
0.31740042567253113,
0.32371750473976135,
0.5194786190986633,
-0.15086506307125092,
0.4381953477859497,
0.07491316646337509,
0.2662948966026306,
-0.019604358822107315,
0.22020864486694336,
0.21055381000041962,
-0.4509112536907196,
0.05542854964733124,
0.3591475188732147,
0.8237051367759705,
0.09217339009046555,
0.45235177874565125,
-0.15774661302566528,
-0.13668489456176758,
0.1707303822040558,
0.3927294611930847,
-0.788628876209259,
-0.06636297702789307,
-0.019687559455633163,
-0.554373562335968,
-0.3803642988204956,
0.2915046811103821,
-0.6557139158248901,
-0.40626734495162964,
-0.40756484866142273,
0.06972542405128479,
-0.47792211174964905,
-0.5672081708908081,
0.1531488448381424,
-0.2783765196800232,
-0.1264304518699646,
0.31097009778022766,
-1.3404247760772705,
0.2874620258808136,
0.6992025971412659,
1.0458638668060303,
-0.637310802936554,
-0.5389517545700073,
0.11278711259365082,
-0.1315128207206726,
-0.5230892896652222,
0.5307943820953369,
-0.40259620547294617,
-0.19211897253990173,
-0.39532795548439026,
0.021542374044656754,
-0.18202942609786987,
-0.5235740542411804,
0.3396400213241577,
-0.46486911177635193,
-0.1525219827890396,
-0.41444310545921326,
-0.20166116952896118,
-0.24233968555927277,
0.0935232937335968,
-1.00002920627594,
0.38645341992378235,
-0.10856113582849503,
-0.8325307369232178,
0.6871895790100098,
-0.6462768912315369,
-0.4794566333293915,
-0.27558737993240356,
-0.15910828113555908,
-0.4636106491088867,
0.5111281275749207,
-0.004084477201104164,
0.014647864736616611,
0.17049439251422882,
0.1970510333776474,
-0.6537548303604126,
-0.17257246375083923,
0.39898526668548584,
-0.575438916683197,
0.5059080719947815,
0.08531945943832397,
-0.07237222045660019,
0.3363495171070099,
-0.397778183221817,
-0.3756958544254303,
0.2132173329591751,
-0.26239463686943054,
-0.6075104475021362,
0.21688339114189148,
-0.2887458801269531,
0.10659147799015045,
0.50555819272995,
-0.23367157578468323,
0.22249141335487366,
-0.3377848267555237,
0.16027258336544037,
0.995578944683075,
-0.15678814053535461,
0.6449680924415588,
-0.4823529124259949,
0.5545362830162048,
0.2832890748977661,
-0.07949576526880264,
-0.18825437128543854,
-0.2827881872653961,
-1.0006515979766846,
-0.6344130635261536,
0.360477089881897,
0.20386968553066254,
-0.20468972623348236,
0.6003800630569458,
-0.3234350085258484,
-0.11775238811969757,
-0.3657669723033905,
0.10825833678245544,
0.3580077886581421,
0.11566425859928131,
0.3108219802379608,
-0.8047794103622437,
-0.7320424914360046,
-1.1320340633392334,
-0.07741083949804306,
-0.061462145298719406,
0.32107117772102356,
0.08887229114770889,
0.048581287264823914,
0.09848684072494507,
0.6971389055252075,
-0.30770692229270935,
-0.16019880771636963,
-0.4039328396320343,
0.021273985505104065,
0.33519110083580017,
0.5788295865058899,
0.7799789905548096,
-0.5263983011245728,
-0.20134778320789337,
0.017490696161985397,
-0.7187069654464722,
0.19144976139068604,
-0.03757953643798828,
-0.23523752391338348,
0.2693822681903839,
0.19388532638549805,
-0.557558536529541,
0.26938989758491516,
0.41973936557769775,
-0.296178936958313,
0.4786553680896759,
-0.057671431452035904,
0.02178776264190674,
-0.8853399753570557,
-0.06477534770965576,
0.07554972171783447,
-0.1049584299325943,
-0.653835654258728,
-0.056900858879089355,
-0.2418605536222458,
-0.038852304220199585,
-0.11673090606927872,
0.4710586965084076,
-0.38137710094451904,
0.05044100061058998,
-0.3792073726654053,
-0.13647493720054626,
-0.029133114963769913,
0.2395666241645813,
0.28669819235801697,
0.9040156602859497,
0.6744034886360168,
-0.6702901124954224,
0.02899416908621788,
0.3836653530597687,
-0.20673874020576477,
0.0002974596282001585,
-0.4629349708557129,
-0.013087332248687744,
-0.13764695823192596,
-0.20635287463665009,
-0.9531686305999756,
-0.07254329323768616,
-0.20608419179916382,
-0.32022684812545776,
0.5454142689704895,
-0.07698801159858704,
-0.33726373314857483,
-0.12395724654197693,
-0.4813315272331238,
0.31797534227371216,
0.417398065328598,
-0.43616265058517456,
0.2318231463432312,
0.3316684067249298,
-0.06584618985652924,
-0.3750941753387451,
-0.6941395998001099,
-0.05821162089705467,
-0.2716624140739441,
-0.8519943356513977,
0.14834196865558624,
-0.03136748448014259,
-0.13136962056159973,
-0.3502235412597656,
-0.4257299602031708,
0.5513574481010437,
0.4014936685562134,
0.09090441465377808,
0.4514712989330292,
-0.45830896496772766,
0.196027010679245,
0.006808134727180004,
-0.2095218449831009,
0.10944384336471558,
-0.047832656651735306,
0.983697235584259,
-0.1579096019268036,
-0.33638736605644226,
-0.46048301458358765,
0.18565984070301056,
0.7205121517181396,
-0.3465161919593811,
0.8380124568939209,
0.259625643491745,
0.07335710525512695,
-0.12339374423027039,
-0.22577297687530518,
-0.6975342035293579,
-0.5075397491455078,
0.43115562200546265,
-0.3518339991569519,
-1.0626146793365479,
0.49458518624305725,
0.08883525431156158,
-0.23664037883281708,
0.15619555115699768,
0.35189810395240784,
-0.005936040077358484,
1.1027717590332031,
0.5943840742111206,
-0.3081169128417969,
0.7756870985031128,
-0.11073734611272812,
0.3053077161312103,
-0.9623991847038269,
0.1054718941450119,
-0.1783297061920166,
-0.6637099385261536,
-0.8386456370353699,
0.0058802948333323,
0.3404894173145294,
0.13745658099651337,
-0.25057336688041687,
0.4440150558948517,
-0.5851042866706848,
0.1679283231496811,
0.43833327293395996,
0.3683663010597229,
0.07883211970329285,
0.33599868416786194,
-0.24337856471538544,
-0.3629791736602783,
-0.7350841760635376,
-0.6476632356643677,
0.8537560105323792,
0.39235591888427734,
0.986302375793457,
0.17332878708839417,
0.6500422358512878,
0.11551135033369064,
0.11734135448932648,
-0.8923196196556091,
0.7357078790664673,
-0.47687748074531555,
-0.3903350234031677,
-0.2760920822620392,
-0.2625672519207001,
-0.9195734262466431,
0.2712889313697815,
-0.4338056147098541,
-0.6568154096603394,
0.47229763865470886,
0.3690083920955658,
-0.18889880180358887,
0.3022928833961487,
-0.6687901616096497,
0.9503058791160583,
-0.46933290362358093,
-0.7112092971801758,
-0.20024216175079346,
-0.2686566114425659,
0.45554375648498535,
-0.14739978313446045,
-0.13568677008152008,
-0.09852459281682968,
-0.18831788003444672,
0.5413703918457031,
-0.056828804314136505,
0.7835899591445923,
0.17863820493221283,
0.020413585007190704,
-0.23542355000972748,
0.4180770218372345,
0.32945379614830017,
0.003387929406017065,
-0.4249231517314911,
0.27820444107055664,
-0.2858366072177887,
-0.29898494482040405,
-0.5967967510223389,
0.8533524870872498,
-0.7452896237373352,
-1.0470194816589355,
-0.39850345253944397,
-0.7315459251403809,
-0.13267283141613007,
0.17870788276195526,
-0.05736875534057617,
0.17311657965183258,
-0.2353353202342987,
0.19718773663043976,
0.8076376914978027,
0.20884111523628235,
0.5063077807426453,
-0.07018555700778961,
-0.539568305015564,
-0.26108092069625854,
0.926276683807373,
0.10212522000074387,
0.7852823138237,
0.12334537506103516,
0.3350670039653778,
0.03713736683130264,
-0.5890680551528931,
-0.143109530210495,
0.31768879294395447,
-0.47128939628601074,
0.3322077691555023,
-0.6504809260368347,
-0.3536178767681122,
-0.3878571391105652,
-0.06505466997623444,
-0.40494784712791443,
-0.7044686675071716,
-0.3875572085380554,
0.02679142914712429,
0.2382715493440628,
0.32154157757759094,
-0.00150689750444144,
-0.006345601752400398,
-0.5832261443138123,
0.09497585892677307,
0.32488271594047546,
0.2796298861503601,
0.09131649136543274,
-0.6540177464485168,
-0.30170297622680664,
0.005733336787670851,
-0.3045898377895355,
-0.4221947193145752,
0.29279547929763794,
0.0013614414492622018,
0.5452437996864319,
0.930341899394989,
-0.1918123960494995,
0.7754734754562378,
-0.4716155529022217,
0.6952301859855652,
0.3297070860862732,
-0.7783645987510681,
0.4579277038574219,
-0.14014828205108643,
0.2264239341020584,
0.4796939194202423,
0.44480007886886597,
-0.3721301555633545,
-0.5232635736465454,
-0.4533829391002655,
-0.5905979871749878,
0.8631305694580078,
0.16662690043449402,
0.5951704978942871,
-0.0486801378428936,
-0.00683870492503047,
0.03362787142395973,
0.4959193766117096,
-0.6549240946769714,
-0.34769028425216675,
-0.3920675814151764,
0.24708907306194305,
-0.036565810441970825,
-0.4149775505065918,
-0.33790555596351624,
-0.46606358885765076,
0.5004696249961853,
-0.06947627663612366,
0.3130851984024048,
0.08156754076480865,
0.29566699266433716,
-0.11903263628482819,
0.3032527565956116,
0.8562155961990356,
0.7006385922431946,
-0.3289589285850525,
0.20599810779094696,
-0.08797509223222733,
-0.2693805992603302,
0.1289721131324768,
-0.1252143532037735,
-0.34411153197288513,
0.059980131685733795,
0.39246079325675964,
1.2307885885238647,
-0.0679955706000328,
-0.03240727260708809,
0.3164183497428894,
0.09547283500432968,
0.0243906918913126,
-0.10784966498613358,
0.324790358543396,
0.05558718368411064,
0.007624051999300718,
-0.13376498222351074,
0.5949290990829468,
-0.197753444314003,
-0.6860455870628357,
0.1755656599998474,
0.9652494788169861,
-0.5414424538612366,
-0.32410603761672974,
0.5695911645889282,
0.032883696258068085,
-0.20397427678108215,
0.29751160740852356,
-0.0781024843454361,
-0.5596288442611694,
0.8144762516021729,
0.6074443459510803,
1.0866235494613647,
-0.17591126263141632,
-0.026411790400743484,
0.6759389638900757,
0.43888986110687256,
-0.20208850502967834,
-0.03464391082525253,
-0.12275447696447372,
-1.1633706092834473,
-0.1377861648797989,
-0.6278084516525269,
-0.2224833369255066,
-0.1778329759836197,
-0.7067946195602417,
0.5020868182182312,
-0.4815799593925476,
-0.3419167697429657,
0.15174277126789093,
-0.5579389333724976,
-0.08802047371864319,
-0.26943880319595337,
0.30373746156692505,
0.7586563229560852,
-0.6197704076766968,
0.9340535998344421,
0.7453418374061584,
-0.6410335302352905,
-0.6242777109146118,
0.19142819941043854,
0.022537918761372566,
-0.6168186068534851,
0.8425131440162659,
0.3334980309009552,
-0.17670296132564545,
-0.18875662982463837,
-0.49668100476264954,
-0.9760253429412842,
0.9148138761520386,
0.44668397307395935,
-0.5519320964813232,
-0.06282162666320801,
-0.014094873331487179,
0.5023093819618225,
-0.7217898964881897,
0.07420710474252701,
0.46165111660957336,
0.42361676692962646,
0.07291541993618011,
-0.8868678212165833,
0.33580949902534485,
-0.10287801921367645,
0.21084487438201904,
0.4418352246284485,
-0.768395185470581,
0.7697961330413818,
-0.3388310968875885,
-0.3515896797180176,
0.08633778989315033,
0.6245543956756592,
0.31217271089553833,
-0.16461336612701416,
0.634804368019104,
0.5987777709960938,
0.45738664269447327,
-0.09535128623247147,
0.992049515247345,
-0.3852027654647827,
0.36140307784080505,
0.9634895920753479,
-0.29760366678237915,
0.6064832210540771,
0.9562191963195801,
-0.21882948279380798,
0.48726096749305725,
0.39215224981307983,
-0.09047406166791916,
0.5248137712478638,
0.2532159090042114,
-0.3376673758029938,
-0.6598107218742371,
-0.14833199977874756,
-0.17809487879276276,
0.4509133994579315,
0.11904298514127731,
-0.6315323114395142,
-0.07158885151147842,
0.03571965545415878,
0.016316378489136696,
0.06769821792840958,
-0.14475193619728088,
0.8220375180244446,
0.21764132380485535,
-0.7573727369308472,
0.8273131251335144,
-0.48451870679855347,
0.833415150642395,
-0.9612518548965454,
0.1640559434890747,
-0.45247146487236023,
0.13635815680027008,
-0.22449220716953278,
-0.586590588092804,
0.3574644923210144,
-0.44830429553985596,
-0.5583264231681824,
-0.2691750228404999,
0.6536375880241394,
-0.4341188669204712,
-0.3654904365539551,
0.47536003589630127,
0.3690223693847656,
-0.26743283867836,
0.20833462476730347,
-0.5763586163520813,
0.05597808212041855,
0.0032284522894769907,
-0.21055538952350616,
0.6356035470962524,
0.21638701856136322,
0.004463511519134045,
0.6710833311080933,
0.7930382490158081,
0.4803421199321747,
-0.16577090322971344,
0.15155963599681854,
1.0100914239883423,
-0.44413021206855774,
-0.29188841581344604,
-1.0570635795593262,
0.43583035469055176,
-0.2861101031303406,
0.010751968249678612,
0.7664309740066528,
0.6951620578765869,
0.7748995423316956,
-0.18896484375,
0.5225072503089905,
0.015272626653313637,
0.13411659002304077,
-0.4072902798652649,
0.9295793771743774,
-0.7483034133911133,
0.5472611784934998,
-0.05224106088280678,
-0.7762818336486816,
-0.19192542135715485,
0.4667551815509796,
-0.2635383605957031,
-0.03408996760845184,
0.9195341467857361,
1.0591049194335938,
-0.3433998227119446,
-0.003442673711106181,
0.5934249758720398,
-0.1037270575761795,
0.009761648252606392,
0.08910524100065231,
0.8162456154823303,
0.07057179510593414,
0.22711911797523499,
-0.33088892698287964,
-0.20596639811992645,
0.06542439013719559,
-0.7859709858894348,
-0.9741902947425842,
-0.5006508827209473,
-0.36873072385787964,
-0.5443347692489624,
-0.1688217967748642,
1.1623971462249756,
0.825513482093811,
-0.8494948744773865,
-0.5934160351753235,
-0.1158081591129303,
0.2993182837963104,
-0.3827941119670868,
-0.25051385164260864,
0.15990643203258514,
-0.9242161512374878,
-0.5052974224090576,
0.2724800705909729,
0.537026584148407,
0.06673279404640198,
-0.4560207426548004,
0.1429523080587387,
-0.1923089474439621,
0.2971426546573639,
0.6652217507362366,
0.11411496251821518,
-0.6226089000701904,
-0.2445375770330429,
0.03519374877214432,
-0.23315173387527466,
0.4932500720024109,
1.064703106880188,
-0.35528019070625305,
0.5984421372413635,
0.4841992259025574,
0.5474546551704407,
0.19187892973423004,
-0.0927126556634903,
0.4331340491771698,
-0.5449696779251099,
0.3777128756046295,
-0.0028432155959308147,
0.6185075044631958,
0.15960977971553802,
-0.24507370591163635,
0.33068615198135376,
0.42688992619514465,
-0.46170368790626526,
-0.5876691937446594,
0.5701441168785095,
-1.103157877922058,
-0.05792682617902756,
1.0406386852264404,
0.03203513100743294,
-0.38245633244514465,
0.1849966049194336,
-0.15367333590984344,
0.02703031711280346,
-0.5979308485984802,
0.7999907732009888,
0.8738929033279419,
-0.21576732397079468,
-0.440347284078598,
-0.335498183965683,
0.5729201436042786,
0.7920745611190796,
-0.655822217464447,
0.20093218982219696,
0.28772827982902527,
0.12837079167366028,
0.580334484577179,
0.2818383574485779,
-0.13577349483966827,
0.1810431033372879,
-0.2684360146522522,
0.20452603697776794,
-0.07898875325918198,
-0.1795324832201004,
-0.468048095703125,
-0.013354695402085781,
0.4229661226272583,
-0.2746068239212036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17967v1 | Unmasking the Imposters: In-Domain Detection of Human vs. Machine-Generated Tweets | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | 2024-06-25T22:49:17 | Bryan E. Tuck, Rakesh M. Verma | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has significantly
improved the generation of fluent and convincing text, raising concerns about
their misuse on social media platforms. We present a methodology using Twitter
datasets to examine the generative capabilities of four LLMs: Llama 3, Mistral,
Qwen2, and GPT4o. We evaluate 7B and 8B parameter base-instruction models of
the three open-source LLMs and validate the impact of further fine-tuning and
"uncensored" versions. Our findings show that "uncensored" models with
additional in-domain fine-tuning dramatically reduce the effectiveness of
automated detection methods. This study addresses a gap by exploring smaller
open-source models and the effects of "uncensoring," providing insights into
how fine-tuning and content moderation influence machine-generated text
detection. | [
-0.20757494866847992,
-0.7038978338241577,
0.4818059802055359,
-0.012219187803566456,
-0.3962635397911072,
0.6439609527587891,
-0.13601942360401154,
-0.6130881905555725,
-0.2938216030597687,
0.8593034744262695,
-0.3255268335342407,
-0.5261948704719543,
-0.7853704690933228,
0.3899214565753937,
-0.7878281474113464,
0.6626540422439575,
-0.19875118136405945,
-0.21408475935459137,
0.02093377523124218,
0.11369005590677261,
-0.1237943172454834,
-0.40497931838035583,
-0.3356923758983612,
-0.4452170729637146,
0.17633593082427979,
0.4974987804889679,
0.7379208207130432,
0.513472855091095,
0.4234015643596649,
0.17987178266048431,
0.10028256475925446,
0.5257202386856079,
-0.6738212704658508,
-0.022216640412807465,
-0.17589053511619568,
-0.08988145738840103,
0.04293625056743622,
0.025554420426487923,
0.5616021752357483,
0.4185304641723633,
0.1270153969526291,
0.32269689440727234,
0.26326999068260193,
0.4163473844528198,
-0.5169841051101685,
0.0023206269834190607,
-1.0248968601226807,
-0.333193302154541,
-0.29415538907051086,
-0.5217834115028381,
-0.5415723919868469,
-0.4291897416114807,
0.006042271852493286,
-0.3967406153678894,
0.5674018263816833,
0.06378357112407684,
0.8979172706604004,
0.17190848290920258,
-0.23235154151916504,
-0.4818378686904907,
-0.8345885276794434,
0.8199905753135681,
-0.7087175250053406,
0.1468798667192459,
0.32731980085372925,
0.10947342216968536,
-0.43067559599876404,
-0.7804015278816223,
-0.725286066532135,
-0.012618211098015308,
-0.06014150008559227,
-0.10088175535202026,
-0.7171938419342041,
0.021164532750844955,
0.21368063986301422,
0.19501174986362457,
-0.42998963594436646,
0.41621771454811096,
-0.29464584589004517,
-0.1591627597808838,
0.5979126691818237,
-0.0033523438032716513,
0.4541817605495453,
-0.044657643884420395,
-0.1468479335308075,
0.16707855463027954,
-1.0135935544967651,
-0.4588187038898468,
0.5096659064292908,
0.27898597717285156,
0.01370073202997446,
0.5848031640052795,
-0.12053652107715607,
0.4183524549007416,
0.017400329932570457,
0.02322501502931118,
-0.07237500697374344,
0.012145087122917175,
-0.4407176673412323,
-0.18280848860740662,
0.9485480189323425,
0.36485356092453003,
0.6846878528594971,
-0.41081711649894714,
-0.37919965386390686,
0.04078861325979233,
0.09329812228679657,
-0.8012514710426331,
-0.1839752048254013,
-0.0047301072627305984,
-0.38855838775634766,
-0.5247502326965332,
0.3401905596256256,
-0.4114828407764435,
-0.6608530879020691,
-0.23382548987865448,
0.6078401803970337,
-0.26903578639030457,
-0.13156282901763916,
0.08691362291574478,
-0.21377666294574738,
-0.04417784884572029,
0.3223556578159332,
-0.5488899350166321,
0.27093103528022766,
0.6203852891921997,
0.5874344706535339,
-0.15269429981708527,
-0.009326991625130177,
-0.24826738238334656,
0.20511473715305328,
-0.562894880771637,
0.616980791091919,
-0.555812656879425,
-0.2964754104614258,
0.32109400629997253,
0.1652195304632187,
0.16391578316688538,
-0.8221225142478943,
0.45096951723098755,
-0.6572392582893372,
0.13524767756462097,
-0.2284831553697586,
-0.6774345636367798,
-0.1067151427268982,
-0.09319395571947098,
-0.7060672044754028,
1.0199495553970337,
0.35846155881881714,
-0.6585734486579895,
0.4018937051296234,
-0.7126477956771851,
-0.384807288646698,
0.2833854854106903,
-0.0499446801841259,
-0.48696771264076233,
0.24489165842533112,
0.3927076458930969,
0.7579470276832581,
-0.49747589230537415,
0.29223865270614624,
-0.08852717280387878,
-0.6180493831634521,
0.4188084304332733,
-0.5208871364593506,
1.0346384048461914,
0.10732046514749527,
-0.3897115886211395,
0.10809381306171417,
-0.5329232811927795,
-0.32130125164985657,
0.35635432600975037,
-0.13047556579113007,
-0.25091931223869324,
-0.040200479328632355,
-0.13133075833320618,
0.04245799779891968,
-0.0337177999317646,
-0.761616587638855,
-0.4851067364215851,
-0.2783152759075165,
0.6780698895454407,
0.734336793422699,
0.2481629103422165,
0.4269756078720093,
-0.35272589325904846,
0.46636340022087097,
0.09301396459341049,
0.12327166646718979,
-0.23805609345436096,
-0.6337025761604309,
-0.5575771331787109,
-0.17226196825504303,
0.15631181001663208,
0.34142929315567017,
-0.9975643754005432,
0.19554993510246277,
-0.15098470449447632,
-0.4041878581047058,
-0.7978712320327759,
0.3971633017063141,
0.5161488056182861,
0.38136088848114014,
0.2715512216091156,
0.19456510245800018,
-0.44794270396232605,
-0.9541120529174805,
-0.6552553176879883,
-0.055110447108745575,
-0.2522936761379242,
-0.07039794325828552,
0.6486960053443909,
-0.2168864905834198,
0.7208154797554016,
-0.10331367701292038,
-0.0613546147942543,
-0.2488228976726532,
0.0937458798289299,
-0.14046615362167358,
0.2008359730243683,
0.586937427520752,
-0.5455442070960999,
-0.8884754776954651,
-0.20458979904651642,
-0.8261807560920715,
-0.302014023065567,
0.15830840170383453,
0.14628036320209503,
0.41860130429267883,
0.5784490704536438,
-0.5936087965965271,
0.6068164706230164,
0.4726853370666504,
0.0992789939045906,
0.4595232605934143,
0.07909789681434631,
0.08838345110416412,
-0.9313721656799316,
-0.26119959354400635,
0.1707184761762619,
-0.36723005771636963,
-0.7255368828773499,
0.1465122550725937,
0.37411317229270935,
-0.02765500545501709,
-0.413034588098526,
0.5586709976196289,
-0.6654455065727234,
0.16239941120147705,
-0.22460107505321503,
-0.013141302391886711,
0.1420515775680542,
0.13625884056091309,
-0.36639052629470825,
0.9086517691612244,
0.34074127674102783,
-0.32195159792900085,
0.09257008135318756,
-0.11963532119989395,
-0.5993018746376038,
0.06715735048055649,
-0.6970104575157166,
0.39015722274780273,
-0.12673915922641754,
0.20891155302524567,
-1.125045657157898,
-0.5802350640296936,
0.47836536169052124,
-0.691392183303833,
0.2478301078081131,
-0.1913314163684845,
-1.26813542842865,
-0.4912639558315277,
-0.5505598187446594,
0.20203503966331482,
0.68885338306427,
-0.8109444379806519,
0.291156530380249,
0.4674263298511505,
0.3363391160964966,
-0.3558551073074341,
-0.6464766263961792,
0.32443198561668396,
-0.3091795742511749,
-0.4667972922325134,
0.5561413168907166,
0.13495859503746033,
-0.5278633236885071,
0.005034746136516333,
0.026166493073105812,
0.051496732980012894,
0.1262722611427307,
0.15939006209373474,
0.07324385643005371,
-0.06497672945261002,
-0.01068438496440649,
0.08090134710073471,
0.2755841612815857,
0.09855484962463379,
-0.2531547248363495,
0.3323283791542053,
0.21184338629245758,
-0.1877545267343521,
-0.7575500011444092,
0.20521004498004913,
0.4902997612953186,
-0.1214974895119667,
0.8614559769630432,
0.5470411777496338,
-0.7389377355575562,
-0.5186694860458374,
-0.5227095484733582,
-0.23412102460861206,
-0.5163897275924683,
-0.021308165043592453,
0.012937619350850582,
-1.0770095586776733,
0.42863932251930237,
0.10328171402215958,
0.05115022137761116,
0.38492047786712646,
0.5554597973823547,
-0.11820391565561295,
1.0814645290374756,
0.6962035298347473,
0.15883280336856842,
0.410617470741272,
-0.04285864531993866,
0.2938340902328491,
-0.5114123225212097,
-0.14103925228118896,
-0.44866177439689636,
0.007689874619245529,
-0.8780502676963806,
-0.4495798647403717,
0.2165733128786087,
-0.11666437983512878,
-0.3053406774997711,
0.42093536257743835,
-0.659824788570404,
0.6988644003868103,
0.6882301568984985,
0.2809295356273651,
0.3101443350315094,
0.2436913400888443,
0.3482815623283386,
0.0687251091003418,
-0.4297635555267334,
-0.9507743716239929,
1.3895947933197021,
0.4780304431915283,
0.7661260366439819,
0.13314186036586761,
0.4846283197402954,
0.5488491058349609,
0.6265405416488647,
-0.5017813444137573,
0.5623763203620911,
-0.5086973905563354,
-0.660538375377655,
-0.0662941038608551,
-0.2549442946910858,
-0.7128986716270447,
0.13839112222194672,
-0.10886433720588684,
-0.6252245903015137,
-0.09709098190069199,
0.09005231410264969,
-0.10482854396104813,
0.7255950570106506,
-0.8034684658050537,
0.419735848903656,
0.06618326902389526,
-0.26955723762512207,
0.06486865878105164,
-0.49674299359321594,
0.5699878334999084,
-0.38765132427215576,
-0.03693763539195061,
-0.40000346302986145,
-0.0827687457203865,
0.6657842993736267,
-0.17142616212368011,
1.1758688688278198,
-0.10491659492254257,
-0.2322196215391159,
0.5158830881118774,
0.241985023021698,
0.46256327629089355,
-0.12553079426288605,
0.0005582600715570152,
0.3364937901496887,
-0.39743515849113464,
-0.3512018620967865,
-0.13122910261154175,
0.668732225894928,
-0.7382305860519409,
-0.5750405192375183,
-0.00898465234786272,
-0.4555748999118805,
-0.22897720336914062,
0.29367274045944214,
0.6253368854522705,
0.36003294587135315,
-0.29943645000457764,
0.2663768231868744,
0.7908666133880615,
-0.26115143299102783,
0.5190069079399109,
0.6108357310295105,
0.013238990679383278,
-0.16084171831607819,
0.7365137934684753,
0.026006324216723442,
0.23926885426044464,
0.5263604521751404,
0.20133763551712036,
-0.24675321578979492,
-0.8026127815246582,
-0.48892921209335327,
0.30794769525527954,
-0.6967545747756958,
-0.45875200629234314,
-0.5955511927604675,
-0.34330233931541443,
-0.5106126070022583,
-0.04079049080610275,
-0.07755260914564133,
-0.23770874738693237,
-0.7531590461730957,
-0.055158644914627075,
0.2644544839859009,
1.0795042514801025,
0.1455790400505066,
0.7113510966300964,
-0.5634839534759521,
0.4330562353134155,
0.08986877650022507,
0.27476033568382263,
-0.0659933090209961,
-0.8791769742965698,
-0.2586444914340973,
0.1996864378452301,
-0.4493769407272339,
-0.8588981628417969,
0.3308367431163788,
0.05282023921608925,
0.5077212452888489,
0.5358062982559204,
0.17619118094444275,
0.33115747570991516,
-0.3453373610973358,
0.6172494888305664,
0.004341618157923222,
-0.9130726456642151,
0.27866825461387634,
-0.548060953617096,
0.008160735480487347,
0.08328831940889359,
0.3053261935710907,
-0.14723876118659973,
-0.6813255548477173,
-0.5174919366836548,
-0.4749862551689148,
0.611902117729187,
0.4647548198699951,
0.506763756275177,
-0.18277253210544586,
0.31365880370140076,
0.3331295847892761,
0.2811996042728424,
-0.5844905972480774,
-0.03500634431838989,
-0.172281876206398,
-0.13856549561023712,
-0.038439929485321045,
-0.5281762480735779,
-0.06812729686498642,
-0.09765112400054932,
0.42872288823127747,
0.05001749470829964,
0.25269562005996704,
-0.16395993530750275,
-0.36753806471824646,
-0.5057225823402405,
-0.03415057808160782,
0.6294371485710144,
0.6503495573997498,
-0.27094677090644836,
0.1973179429769516,
-0.2394886612892151,
-0.3124270737171173,
-0.06003272160887718,
-0.10046703368425369,
-0.3662775456905365,
0.2555006146430969,
0.5579644441604614,
0.6097910404205322,
0.029802070930600166,
-0.6123991012573242,
0.4437376856803894,
0.21551303565502167,
-0.33369553089141846,
-0.36783137917518616,
-0.022718975320458412,
0.013501128181815147,
-0.010585842654109001,
0.5442519783973694,
0.018752845004200935,
-0.07588931918144226,
-0.5859391093254089,
0.12991046905517578,
0.4557744860649109,
-0.27927011251449585,
-0.7000921368598938,
0.8333169221878052,
0.1633087396621704,
-0.4778750538825989,
0.3259563148021698,
-0.1271916627883911,
-0.4970732033252716,
0.5783156752586365,
0.6337950229644775,
1.0459215641021729,
-0.26247942447662354,
0.26142820715904236,
0.09680309891700745,
0.8330937623977661,
-0.17258580029010773,
0.02941327542066574,
0.29475176334381104,
-1.0573378801345825,
-0.13332800567150116,
-0.25721967220306396,
-0.37343358993530273,
0.5093560814857483,
-0.35909196734428406,
0.13755454123020172,
-0.4959460198879242,
-0.11708296835422516,
0.3863108158111572,
-0.2203356921672821,
-0.7617689967155457,
-0.07122066617012024,
0.1464901715517044,
0.8472493290901184,
-0.8347213268280029,
0.758556604385376,
0.5016108155250549,
-0.3790384531021118,
-0.4736051559448242,
0.4971294403076172,
0.1173987090587616,
-1.0024992227554321,
0.33978718519210815,
0.26419156789779663,
-0.297776997089386,
0.28164857625961304,
-1.1029242277145386,
-0.324187695980072,
0.9153021574020386,
0.6371041536331177,
-0.20698018372058868,
0.07301412522792816,
0.5806195139884949,
0.5582866072654724,
-0.4348274767398834,
-0.15017393231391907,
0.6547383069992065,
0.19708487391471863,
-0.20925909280776978,
-0.8894225358963013,
0.1838706135749817,
0.1185753121972084,
-0.022583413869142532,
0.1569865196943283,
-0.32763710618019104,
0.826481282711029,
-0.15851397812366486,
-0.608036458492279,
0.08617522567510605,
0.3460850119590759,
0.016554268077015877,
0.210615873336792,
0.237068310379982,
0.2675046920776367,
0.5375730991363525,
0.039957985281944275,
0.9266822934150696,
-0.11974436044692993,
0.04013536125421524,
0.8319647312164307,
-0.3108152747154236,
0.6217401623725891,
0.37791940569877625,
0.03430080786347389,
0.3810904324054718,
0.541326105594635,
0.026500912383198738,
0.32458439469337463,
0.21876856684684753,
-0.2916746139526367,
-0.1224566325545311,
-0.297016441822052,
0.07369895279407501,
0.27875396609306335,
0.619511604309082,
-0.5968310832977295,
-0.3886353075504303,
-0.02250024303793907,
0.3233802616596222,
0.3062414228916168,
-0.32051295042037964,
0.6408975124359131,
0.07346998900175095,
-0.45166823267936707,
0.717332124710083,
0.1641695648431778,
0.7217378616333008,
-0.12525275349617004,
-0.01792779006063938,
-0.2670097053050995,
0.15648452937602997,
-0.16067950427532196,
-1.0513370037078857,
0.10160654038190842,
0.3460996150970459,
0.055184368044137955,
-0.28625762462615967,
1.1470977067947388,
-0.24885956943035126,
-0.39028865098953247,
0.5247109532356262,
0.6669202446937561,
0.14537321031093597,
-0.5259270071983337,
-0.5855531692504883,
0.06499435007572174,
-0.03167233616113663,
-0.08681704103946686,
0.08971414715051651,
0.6734418869018555,
-0.4164804518222809,
0.740644097328186,
0.6741424798965454,
-0.22463086247444153,
0.1779322326183319,
0.28508397936820984,
0.9444741606712341,
-0.44826221466064453,
0.025610698387026787,
-0.9842110872268677,
0.19492976367473602,
-0.12100307643413544,
0.0633375272154808,
0.8425267934799194,
0.48111921548843384,
1.0483849048614502,
-0.18763837218284607,
0.9966489672660828,
0.20333628356456757,
0.8593488335609436,
-0.25610071420669556,
0.7488287091255188,
-0.5858562588691711,
0.49291834235191345,
-0.3193191587924957,
-0.6397504806518555,
-0.42431172728538513,
-0.09302885085344315,
-0.010626014322042465,
0.05059901252388954,
0.45643848180770874,
0.9784132838249207,
-0.25735941529273987,
-0.11895925551652908,
0.5424768924713135,
0.1488768756389618,
0.3071396052837372,
0.20887206494808197,
1.1303750276565552,
-0.37580132484436035,
0.5146769881248474,
-0.4177982807159424,
-0.14009538292884827,
-0.4823445677757263,
-0.7754386067390442,
-1.4823226928710938,
-0.46050000190734863,
-0.19667311012744904,
-0.40662866830825806,
0.11380799859762192,
0.610507607460022,
0.4199812114238739,
-0.8070019483566284,
-0.15739589929580688,
-0.07524705678224564,
0.07309328764677048,
0.1516249179840088,
-0.23582521080970764,
0.3162258565425873,
0.014666739851236343,
-0.6521103978157043,
0.28136199712753296,
0.17427480220794678,
0.2826957702636719,
-0.28099218010902405,
0.09910715371370316,
0.14836031198501587,
0.5329583287239075,
0.810633659362793,
0.032867781817913055,
-0.9775798916816711,
-0.36254724860191345,
0.26511433720588684,
-0.13609464466571808,
-0.08408437669277191,
0.7317424416542053,
-0.5587035417556763,
0.23755650222301483,
0.4639985263347626,
0.2895345389842987,
0.10360187292098999,
0.25297388434410095,
0.4944670498371124,
-0.8101418614387512,
-0.044062256813049316,
0.16859428584575653,
0.18142424523830414,
0.5952814817428589,
-0.2657512426376343,
0.4815138280391693,
0.3375852108001709,
-0.4632343649864197,
-1.1464282274246216,
0.14284518361091614,
-0.5583410263061523,
-0.5298422574996948,
1.2215979099273682,
0.13549114763736725,
-0.009035813622176647,
-0.46588361263275146,
0.1501321941614151,
0.33224573731422424,
-0.5647894144058228,
0.8054587244987488,
0.44663774967193604,
0.04425910487771034,
-0.1835625320672989,
-0.8305716514587402,
0.6808916330337524,
-0.21547874808311462,
-0.6259273290634155,
0.1319207102060318,
0.24793453514575958,
0.5408514738082886,
-0.22032983601093292,
0.6828189492225647,
-0.17610935866832733,
0.06817526370286942,
-0.19693778455257416,
0.02943599596619606,
-0.17361021041870117,
-0.19239354133605957,
-0.17381146550178528,
-0.05807448923587799,
-0.03220736235380173,
-0.3519676625728607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17962v2 | SimsChat: A Customisable Persona-Driven Role-Playing Agent | 2024-06-25T22:44:17 | 2024-06-30T21:15:47 | Bohao Yang, Dong Liu, Chen Tang, Chenghao Xiao, Kun Zhao, Chao Li, Lin Yuan, Guang Yang, Lanxiao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) possess the remarkable capability to understand
human instructions and generate high-quality text, enabling them to act as
agents that simulate human behaviours. This capability allows LLMs to emulate
human beings in a more advanced manner, beyond merely replicating simple human
behaviours. However, there is a lack of exploring into leveraging LLMs to craft
characters from several aspects. In this work, we introduce the Customisable
Conversation Agent Framework, which employs LLMs to simulate real-world
characters that can be freely customised according to different user
preferences. The customisable framework is helpful for designing customisable
characters and role-playing agents according to human's preferences. We first
propose the SimsConv dataset, which comprises 68 different customised
characters, 1,360 multi-turn role-playing dialogues, and encompasses 13,971
interaction dialogues in total. The characters are created from several
real-world elements, such as career, aspiration, trait, and skill. Building on
these foundations, we present SimsChat, a freely customisable role-playing
agent. It incorporates different real-world scenes and topic-specific character
interaction dialogues, simulating characters' life experiences in various
scenarios and topic-specific interactions with specific emotions. Experimental
results show that our proposed framework achieves desirable performance and
provides helpful guideline for building better simulacra of human beings in the
future. Our data and code are available at
https://github.com/Bernard-Yang/SimsChat. | [
-0.3784661591053009,
-0.6478936076164246,
0.4660135507583618,
0.434987336397171,
-0.03202604874968529,
0.4629954993724823,
-0.0166182778775692,
-0.4190102219581604,
0.6169384717941284,
0.8859551548957825,
-0.8982679843902588,
-0.4620244801044464,
0.09695746749639511,
0.12270807474851608,
0.2600649297237396,
0.2862718999385834,
0.4610878825187683,
-0.029293540865182877,
-0.35555076599121094,
0.10367466509342194,
-0.520635187625885,
-0.7734736800193787,
-0.8380767107009888,
-0.4145418107509613,
0.5490244030952454,
0.4996644854545593,
0.980200469493866,
0.5662824511528015,
0.22930890321731567,
0.4301784634590149,
0.0757412239909172,
0.45691704750061035,
-0.6655598878860474,
0.5345079302787781,
-0.2759484648704529,
-0.5477476119995117,
-0.7122088670730591,
0.027524592354893684,
0.20390662550926208,
0.1430940330028534,
-0.15262633562088013,
-0.21301759779453278,
-0.1293162852525711,
-0.017174625769257545,
-0.08669375628232956,
0.39586320519447327,
-0.34005945920944214,
0.10185780376195908,
0.016535988077521324,
-0.48276764154434204,
-0.38582664728164673,
-0.21578647196292877,
-0.17974697053432465,
-0.7414341568946838,
-0.2172093242406845,
0.08428337424993515,
0.6511756777763367,
0.05781686305999756,
-0.3244187831878662,
-0.3950042724609375,
-0.6206225752830505,
0.8158147931098938,
-0.9382345676422119,
0.17746476829051971,
0.29753780364990234,
0.8235027194023132,
-0.3912341892719269,
-0.42065495252609253,
-0.1945953369140625,
-0.6036773920059204,
-0.1739823818206787,
0.20513491332530975,
0.40510693192481995,
0.2845991849899292,
0.2681369483470917,
0.055395081639289856,
-0.4097876250743866,
0.0886809378862381,
0.0619799867272377,
-0.11495479196310043,
0.8719477653503418,
0.6942179203033447,
0.6028342247009277,
-0.1932518631219864,
-0.34495097398757935,
-0.053206149488687515,
-0.4743998348712921,
0.29382169246673584,
0.8346008062362671,
0.41259831190109253,
-0.19598041474819183,
0.4207448363304138,
-0.22234728932380676,
0.24939635396003723,
0.053584977984428406,
-0.39015716314315796,
0.05015895143151283,
0.28483521938323975,
-0.07737819850444794,
-0.1079019233584404,
0.6252416372299194,
0.14893507957458496,
0.27679795026779175,
-0.13176459074020386,
-0.06102623790502548,
-0.26697856187820435,
0.2750304043292999,
-1.149309515953064,
0.0562717504799366,
0.3798624575138092,
-0.3152005672454834,
-0.4921102225780487,
-0.09487074613571167,
-0.441413015127182,
-0.6594896912574768,
-0.271212637424469,
-0.025296688079833984,
-0.5628820061683655,
-0.2711166441440582,
-0.061237700283527374,
0.03941010683774948,
0.15341168642044067,
0.46436160802841187,
-0.8269678950309753,
0.2911529541015625,
0.5425868034362793,
0.6765574216842651,
-0.3606152832508087,
-0.21267357468605042,
-0.33057767152786255,
0.3169085383415222,
-0.44288334250450134,
0.6615436673164368,
-0.9579480886459351,
-0.7007463574409485,
-0.15186859667301178,
-0.10617909580469131,
0.10634134709835052,
-0.32352617383003235,
0.5100528597831726,
-0.41891077160835266,
-0.13145780563354492,
-0.5119686722755432,
-0.580496072769165,
0.2007756531238556,
0.567867636680603,
-0.567079484462738,
0.4459388554096222,
0.1421494483947754,
-0.41066935658454895,
-0.04858117550611496,
-0.8873707056045532,
-0.26713839173316956,
0.6042430996894836,
-0.4564172923564911,
0.11434448510408401,
-0.22464708983898163,
-0.06296795606613159,
0.6736845374107361,
-0.31591862440109253,
0.16800567507743835,
-0.3401755690574646,
-0.7598086595535278,
0.6955694556236267,
-0.35880857706069946,
0.6681029200553894,
0.39395225048065186,
0.08377132564783096,
0.12290382385253906,
-0.5076241493225098,
0.17492063343524933,
-0.011324546299874783,
-0.314752995967865,
0.035209815949201584,
0.2519214153289795,
0.12236117571592331,
0.2872207760810852,
0.03415039926767349,
-0.655712366104126,
0.36160963773727417,
-0.38229110836982727,
0.4130490720272064,
0.45806995034217834,
0.2032795548439026,
0.3169574439525604,
-0.6344681978225708,
0.8425918817520142,
-0.04305264353752136,
0.042968202382326126,
-0.3509331941604614,
-0.3905975818634033,
-0.41704434156417847,
-0.6824927926063538,
-0.00607019430026412,
0.636671781539917,
-0.748765766620636,
0.2505423426628113,
-0.028743645176291466,
-0.6020191311836243,
-0.4623553156852722,
-0.10829751193523407,
0.1736607700586319,
-0.021650217473506927,
-0.09354404360055923,
-0.32977864146232605,
-0.6209884881973267,
-0.8413169980049133,
-0.2958567142486572,
-0.3864962160587311,
-0.08528266847133636,
0.7919120192527771,
-0.026036089286208153,
-0.5203102827072144,
1.3125817775726318,
-0.5656477212905884,
-0.2985006868839264,
-0.6940029263496399,
-0.16361580789089203,
-0.2953881323337555,
0.5109437704086304,
0.559402346611023,
-0.6968894004821777,
-0.49492308497428894,
0.018346894532442093,
-0.7116087675094604,
-0.3123485743999481,
-0.5627003312110901,
-0.2248862236738205,
-0.02639908157289028,
0.6377687454223633,
-0.6730397343635559,
0.31338047981262207,
0.4079834520816803,
-0.2357054203748703,
0.5837128162384033,
-0.25250959396362305,
0.4801430106163025,
-1.4343717098236084,
-0.08068116009235382,
-0.33752211928367615,
-0.5434619188308716,
-0.6070829629898071,
0.027410870417952538,
-0.4099874198436737,
-0.3157055079936981,
-0.7186468839645386,
0.9735141396522522,
-0.32762327790260315,
-0.120131716132164,
-0.2687712609767914,
0.2507562041282654,
-0.13352882862091064,
0.632728636264801,
0.027946339920163155,
0.8524941205978394,
0.23649166524410248,
-0.3597472310066223,
0.4568319022655487,
0.5475146770477295,
-0.1457063853740692,
0.7662360668182373,
-0.5798707008361816,
0.22706137597560883,
0.014244758524000645,
0.2781388759613037,
-0.8782843351364136,
-0.46139100193977356,
0.22720223665237427,
-0.2653631567955017,
-0.025662384927272797,
-0.32759663462638855,
-0.4973870515823364,
0.026364296674728394,
-0.05945653095841408,
0.05802871286869049,
0.6572467684745789,
-0.42223936319351196,
0.8860263824462891,
0.4387793242931366,
-0.25825709104537964,
-0.2456343173980713,
-0.6073920726776123,
0.4302874505519867,
-0.05484588444232941,
-0.7997664213180542,
0.3535899221897125,
-0.5986283421516418,
-0.26009994745254517,
-0.23326174914836884,
0.47519299387931824,
-0.14931097626686096,
-0.03565147519111633,
0.6398659348487854,
-0.11176101118326187,
-0.011462264694273472,
-0.02490174025297165,
0.11829782277345657,
-0.10302586108446121,
-0.15925876796245575,
0.39253973960876465,
0.735634982585907,
-0.13422106206417084,
-0.5772565007209778,
-0.6332371830940247,
0.4028225839138031,
0.46886998414993286,
-0.03908053785562515,
0.39388200640678406,
0.5218394994735718,
-0.026830773800611496,
-0.4337025582790375,
-0.4330355226993561,
-0.10841187089681625,
-0.6277056336402893,
0.4349880814552307,
-0.6827052235603333,
-0.9182921648025513,
0.7588489651679993,
-0.11520201712846756,
0.29816916584968567,
-0.2698152959346771,
0.6696317195892334,
-0.06694710999727249,
1.1128500699996948,
0.39112862944602966,
0.20873290300369263,
0.3958154022693634,
0.084562286734581,
0.1718866527080536,
-0.47464314103126526,
-0.11995778232812881,
-0.013211472891271114,
-0.2169860303401947,
-0.6782363653182983,
-0.7041234970092773,
-0.2385173738002777,
-0.5146493911743164,
-0.14466968178749084,
0.2751466929912567,
-0.006811743136495352,
0.7602760791778564,
0.06643195450305939,
-0.017783883959054947,
0.26448023319244385,
-0.3099506199359894,
0.05673373118042946,
-0.17007574439048767,
-0.43758055567741394,
-1.004348635673523,
0.29776138067245483,
0.3776599168777466,
0.9956082701683044,
0.1654287576675415,
0.8234212398529053,
0.4357949495315552,
0.36961111426353455,
-0.7530763745307922,
0.9168400764465332,
0.12862393260002136,
-0.6714046597480774,
-0.28364017605781555,
-0.4784143567085266,
-0.620631754398346,
0.5264419913291931,
-0.19811353087425232,
-0.769014835357666,
0.019563309848308563,
0.1707472801208496,
-0.34942686557769775,
0.37774375081062317,
-0.6365422010421753,
0.5610907077789307,
-0.1308249682188034,
-0.3999033570289612,
-0.0695442333817482,
-0.3161185085773468,
0.4143148362636566,
0.25760307908058167,
-0.1445673108100891,
-0.41457709670066833,
-0.039342887699604034,
0.19874325394630432,
-0.30128178000450134,
1.1881077289581299,
-0.13434232771396637,
0.07403524965047836,
0.4178694784641266,
0.6409087777137756,
0.43763139843940735,
0.2913256883621216,
-0.2657698094844818,
-0.09434898942708969,
0.31641092896461487,
-0.3598276674747467,
-0.5420703291893005,
0.8030821084976196,
-0.8403793573379517,
-0.8589591383934021,
-0.3296026587486267,
-0.8654950857162476,
-0.5256907939910889,
-0.013114712201058865,
-0.10045221447944641,
0.2841194272041321,
-1.1219022274017334,
0.06501726806163788,
0.3517513573169708,
-0.5362680554389954,
0.3434778153896332,
0.3696002960205078,
-0.36210885643959045,
-0.12674038112163544,
1.1219254732131958,
-0.011835834942758083,
0.28295570611953735,
0.18955479562282562,
0.03940213844180107,
-0.009572936221957207,
0.020582059398293495,
-0.42396044731140137,
0.17719514667987823,
-0.40177851915359497,
-0.13364581763744354,
-0.7195807099342346,
-0.4506395161151886,
-0.2772209644317627,
-0.5327980518341064,
-0.37020161747932434,
-0.17487448453903198,
-0.3750455379486084,
-0.08171999454498291,
0.07863185554742813,
0.701531171798706,
0.22677452862262726,
0.7016746401786804,
-0.590412974357605,
0.1826508790254593,
0.4665953516960144,
0.3596571087837219,
-0.07028645277023315,
-0.15954241156578064,
0.10880851745605469,
0.2421240657567978,
-0.3034299910068512,
-0.7269609570503235,
0.8396889567375183,
0.03498011827468872,
0.619751513004303,
0.7250629663467407,
-0.0352647565305233,
0.6268765330314636,
-0.4422052204608917,
0.7947330474853516,
-0.1328495442867279,
-0.7790724039077759,
-0.07299647480249405,
-0.7062024474143982,
-0.0010617967927828431,
0.4252752661705017,
0.046586621552705765,
-0.9648021459579468,
-0.38594162464141846,
-0.5634515285491943,
-0.3057248294353485,
0.9914374947547913,
0.5005703568458557,
0.49807044863700867,
0.12119892984628677,
0.5143225789070129,
0.18421247601509094,
0.1656825840473175,
-0.17122282087802887,
0.01886063814163208,
-0.10070180892944336,
-0.26632171869277954,
-0.027613848447799683,
-0.40191274881362915,
0.09223977476358414,
0.2023170441389084,
0.5269734859466553,
-0.2023743838071823,
0.29732704162597656,
-0.06434519588947296,
-0.02873019501566887,
0.10567254573106766,
0.3751735985279083,
0.5457723140716553,
0.4619322419166565,
-0.47126805782318115,
-0.20564362406730652,
0.18073558807373047,
-0.48238396644592285,
0.16816915571689606,
-0.3471508324146271,
-0.04542899131774902,
-0.25129079818725586,
0.00313835428096354,
0.6542903780937195,
0.2762560248374939,
-1.0437229871749878,
0.42499876022338867,
-0.3966130018234253,
-0.19207225739955902,
-0.31274136900901794,
0.464407354593277,
0.7451421618461609,
0.46099016070365906,
-0.026595517992973328,
-0.2148595154285431,
-0.015231643803417683,
-0.5726234912872314,
0.17346836626529694,
0.28296828269958496,
-0.4432889521121979,
-0.47667744755744934,
0.45541635155677795,
0.5355840921401978,
-0.8268067240715027,
0.15745329856872559,
-0.5140795111656189,
-0.20061463117599487,
0.7238205671310425,
0.7000308632850647,
0.7560640573501587,
-0.48657500743865967,
0.773250162601471,
-0.12215349823236465,
0.09893643110990524,
-0.027779750525951385,
0.3186884820461273,
0.23721882700920105,
-0.6808367371559143,
-0.037066344171762466,
-0.4002181887626648,
-0.956778883934021,
0.0015843883156776428,
-0.13382463157176971,
0.3890516757965088,
-0.6395860314369202,
-0.09166862815618515,
-0.2587779760360718,
0.19325347244739532,
-0.5875566601753235,
0.07328581064939499,
0.00924938078969717,
0.7585782408714294,
-0.5359803438186646,
0.6649828553199768,
0.5167433023452759,
-0.2936129570007324,
-0.6075792908668518,
-0.018190857023000717,
-0.04612339660525322,
-0.5857383012771606,
0.446831613779068,
0.0747695118188858,
-0.11804651468992233,
-0.025848476216197014,
-0.541640043258667,
-0.7031840682029724,
1.2952958345413208,
0.7569231390953064,
-0.31173714995384216,
-0.22471724450588226,
0.7198423147201538,
0.7033612132072449,
-0.9772794842720032,
0.5750460028648376,
0.37368836998939514,
0.26115694642066956,
0.5058645009994507,
-0.3840852975845337,
0.02252774126827717,
-0.2643581032752991,
0.25107893347740173,
-0.454097181558609,
-1.018850326538086,
0.6337159872055054,
-0.11446565389633179,
-0.17381693422794342,
0.3408047556877136,
0.6277215480804443,
0.4109579920768738,
-0.06178659200668335,
0.5074865818023682,
-0.13342002034187317,
0.7116538882255554,
0.0934225395321846,
0.8661370277404785,
-0.2435320019721985,
-0.07107073813676834,
1.0197818279266357,
-0.5810278058052063,
0.4467490315437317,
0.18571822345256805,
0.34418153762817383,
0.42039692401885986,
0.6668581366539001,
0.1730232685804367,
0.1461278796195984,
0.3502124547958374,
-0.09130703657865524,
-0.782837450504303,
-0.1344560980796814,
0.17569400370121002,
0.4275473356246948,
0.4201601445674896,
-0.00982203520834446,
-0.12846270203590393,
0.004175081383436918,
-0.09485478699207306,
-0.017446570098400116,
0.00907585583627224,
0.6217092275619507,
0.17029646039009094,
-0.3838728070259094,
0.07562310993671417,
0.15889963507652283,
0.5185654759407043,
-0.7548881769180298,
-0.2556172311306,
-0.3718014359474182,
0.09959130734205246,
-0.1927652806043625,
-0.5155929923057556,
-0.07213735580444336,
-0.1560167372226715,
0.3537783622741699,
-0.2926766872406006,
0.7943373918533325,
-0.5184205174446106,
-0.26199430227279663,
0.007502474822103977,
0.658177375793457,
0.32051122188568115,
0.060930218547582626,
-0.7194986343383789,
0.2184588611125946,
-0.00791092962026596,
-0.5054588913917542,
0.3319322466850281,
0.5363678336143494,
-0.23457017540931702,
0.9190977215766907,
0.5592241883277893,
-0.01769929938018322,
-0.2732105255126953,
0.09824853390455246,
0.850083589553833,
-0.6824434399604797,
-1.0032627582550049,
-0.465385377407074,
0.4353131949901581,
-0.2718343436717987,
-0.22229193150997162,
0.6186005473136902,
0.5686166882514954,
0.31967124342918396,
-0.10962878167629242,
0.9252288937568665,
0.03476473316550255,
0.3745478093624115,
-0.12008153647184372,
0.9027354717254639,
-0.3247021436691284,
0.35620149970054626,
-0.22839292883872986,
-0.6127489805221558,
0.033911172300577164,
0.5135194659233093,
-0.0508820042014122,
0.2425965815782547,
0.1820918768644333,
1.1766343116760254,
-0.2907246947288513,
0.1023985743522644,
0.9850274920463562,
0.09685055166482925,
0.8396463394165039,
0.2785722613334656,
1.0006587505340576,
0.02604716829955578,
0.39384201169013977,
0.16698649525642395,
-0.10022874176502228,
-0.48552751541137695,
-0.6359942555427551,
-1.5898863077163696,
-0.5647812485694885,
-0.06920532137155533,
-0.18212009966373444,
0.2153865396976471,
1.4318574666976929,
0.8051549792289734,
-0.3380385637283325,
-0.537872850894928,
0.37961336970329285,
-0.012230878695845604,
-0.06500604003667831,
-0.2055443972349167,
-0.01071402058005333,
-0.45087096095085144,
-0.9213191866874695,
0.4901707172393799,
0.1623631864786148,
0.1931479275226593,
-0.42154791951179504,
-0.38516658544540405,
0.17971526086330414,
1.011610507965088,
0.6386351585388184,
0.3359832167625427,
-0.46119171380996704,
-0.11496365815401077,
0.13466237485408783,
-0.5124496221542358,
0.21479029953479767,
1.0070147514343262,
-0.5635136365890503,
0.1919267773628235,
0.36147207021713257,
0.5242341160774231,
0.5562530159950256,
0.25877198576927185,
0.6235844492912292,
-0.8352319002151489,
0.23275445401668549,
0.36150676012039185,
0.06741682440042496,
0.4226430356502533,
-0.6975752711296082,
0.2816103994846344,
-0.030718034133315086,
-0.39293813705444336,
-0.6592382192611694,
0.5684674978256226,
-1.2204151153564453,
-0.20826135575771332,
1.4310251474380493,
-0.19169163703918457,
-0.38110050559043884,
-0.14950275421142578,
-0.8803600072860718,
-0.12318152189254761,
-0.8179209232330322,
0.5095155239105225,
0.4166756272315979,
-0.36563313007354736,
-0.030036741867661476,
-0.3911779820919037,
0.6686661243438721,
0.05616391450166702,
-1.1741442680358887,
0.33463528752326965,
0.3271981477737427,
0.2978496253490448,
-0.10823352634906769,
0.8487057685852051,
0.014040852896869183,
-0.07851462811231613,
-0.12899696826934814,
0.1947680413722992,
-0.48117324709892273,
0.024130871519446373,
0.19250845909118652,
0.21079525351524353,
0.06423424184322357,
0.2885858118534088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17961v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17961v1 | NormTab: Improving Symbolic Reasoning in LLMs Through Tabular Data Normalization | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | 2024-06-25T22:40:03 | Md Mahadi Hasan Nahid, Davood Rafiei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.IR | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities in parsing textual data and generating code. However, their
performance in tasks involving tabular data, especially those requiring
symbolic reasoning, faces challenges due to the structural variance and
inconsistency in table cell values often found in web tables. In this paper, we
introduce NormTab, a novel framework aimed at enhancing the symbolic reasoning
performance of LLMs by normalizing web tables. We study table normalization as
a stand-alone, one-time preprocessing step using LLMs to support symbolic
reasoning on tabular data. Our experimental evaluation, conducted on
challenging web table datasets such as WikiTableQuestion and TabFact,
demonstrates that leveraging NormTab significantly improves symbolic reasoning
performance, showcasing the importance and effectiveness of web table
normalization for enhancing LLM-based symbolic reasoning tasks. | [
-0.1906551569700241,
-0.9928408861160278,
0.449780136346817,
0.46538954973220825,
-0.4510314464569092,
-0.029059220105409622,
-0.08417423814535141,
-0.29984188079833984,
0.11156424134969711,
0.36346176266670227,
-0.436343252658844,
-0.9722039103507996,
-0.29807525873184204,
0.2998655140399933,
-0.25046882033348083,
0.7183859348297119,
0.09418262541294098,
0.20054496824741364,
-0.3078501224517822,
-0.05068208649754524,
-0.5624633431434631,
-0.41167399287223816,
-0.2124556303024292,
-0.3262249231338501,
0.45649370551109314,
0.6904955506324768,
0.9324500560760498,
1.0159574747085571,
0.6675595045089722,
0.20905405282974243,
0.40652409195899963,
0.18232661485671997,
-0.31742408871650696,
0.4436344504356384,
0.036021653562784195,
-0.8316604495048523,
-0.8960216045379639,
-0.18292544782161713,
0.7530657649040222,
0.6038051843643188,
-0.3826862871646881,
0.3373599052429199,
-0.21810275316238403,
0.7047555446624756,
-0.27988171577453613,
0.536480724811554,
-0.8709575533866882,
0.2272035926580429,
-0.3773365020751953,
-0.18178986012935638,
-0.4157577455043793,
-0.7985740303993225,
-0.4985421597957611,
-0.6522409319877625,
0.09797403961420059,
0.025220032781362534,
0.8853840827941895,
0.5639098286628723,
-0.24895234405994415,
0.28856444358825684,
-0.5121937394142151,
0.5492402911186218,
-0.9435845613479614,
0.8413010239601135,
0.29794591665267944,
0.4240640103816986,
-0.44966864585876465,
-0.8317581415176392,
-0.7584713697433472,
-0.48436272144317627,
-0.15423953533172607,
-0.36280956864356995,
-0.5188586115837097,
0.0709226056933403,
0.5096599459648132,
-0.09218716621398926,
-0.8602292537689209,
0.21962343156337738,
-0.06619821488857269,
-0.07440780103206635,
0.3282993733882904,
0.3568483293056488,
0.3577716052532196,
-0.0468597449362278,
0.013286803849041462,
-0.12422474473714828,
-0.7018772959709167,
0.12381621450185776,
0.10618862509727478,
0.5296031832695007,
0.03144361451268196,
0.5241562724113464,
-0.3238723874092102,
0.9253928661346436,
-0.282046377658844,
-0.19931848347187042,
-0.0851462185382843,
0.08327385038137436,
-0.280894935131073,
0.06893511861562729,
0.29218363761901855,
0.6394222378730774,
0.5547947883605957,
-0.26389583945274353,
-0.2589171230792999,
0.46031272411346436,
0.383260577917099,
-0.8630908131599426,
-0.28948718309402466,
0.20199652016162872,
-0.33360347151756287,
-0.012989693321287632,
0.16477209329605103,
-0.5458294749259949,
-0.22388359904289246,
-0.5020207166671753,
0.3205508589744568,
-0.21674185991287231,
0.2238558679819107,
-0.02286348305642605,
-0.009471605531871319,
0.170449361205101,
0.6126789450645447,
-0.5343401432037354,
0.5053300857543945,
0.6615052223205566,
0.7660672068595886,
-0.371469110250473,
0.07979854196310043,
-0.5351774096488953,
0.4570009112358093,
-0.5586176514625549,
1.077866554260254,
-0.5230043530464172,
-0.27877089381217957,
-0.2674928903579712,
-0.2332259565591812,
0.44656407833099365,
-0.6802594065666199,
0.3398178815841675,
-0.48849260807037354,
-0.5186771154403687,
-0.34571102261543274,
-0.3448044955730438,
0.03725054860115051,
0.5707170963287354,
-1.0394961833953857,
0.8851445913314819,
-0.037827957421541214,
-0.40912750363349915,
0.6868274807929993,
-0.7578275799751282,
-0.6650476455688477,
0.2472529411315918,
-0.4542948305606842,
-0.5665691494941711,
-0.2649760842323303,
0.31104475259780884,
0.6211060881614685,
-0.5032891631126404,
0.3913315534591675,
-0.4533761441707611,
-0.49908313155174255,
0.33515578508377075,
-0.02395041100680828,
0.5826069712638855,
0.3282528519630432,
-0.2808520495891571,
0.26860636472702026,
-0.7624363899230957,
0.23826660215854645,
0.17542964220046997,
-0.2664150893688202,
-0.13389445841312408,
-0.05855900049209595,
0.07653149962425232,
0.04153921455144882,
0.0026854912284761667,
-0.5578411221504211,
0.4706018269062042,
-0.1616787165403366,
0.11412753909826279,
0.8335672616958618,
-0.1572151929140091,
0.30954188108444214,
-0.3310607969760895,
0.400424987077713,
0.2155517190694809,
0.04483886808156967,
0.6474494934082031,
-0.2995879650115967,
-0.5782689452171326,
-0.21847620606422424,
0.22789770364761353,
0.5306410193443298,
-0.37959226965904236,
0.24923895299434662,
-0.32149094343185425,
-0.644584596157074,
-0.26281648874282837,
0.2397635579109192,
0.12997396290302277,
0.7066754102706909,
0.6313793063163757,
-0.16131988167762756,
-0.8614931106567383,
-1.1779470443725586,
-0.5017797946929932,
-0.13026851415634155,
-0.18584005534648895,
0.05439439043402672,
0.1887582242488861,
-0.44589272141456604,
1.0765067338943481,
-0.5933964848518372,
-0.48133060336112976,
-0.5975080132484436,
0.07996626943349838,
0.27627211809158325,
0.5211228132247925,
0.1356087476015091,
-0.6902538537979126,
-0.51205974817276,
-0.07855608314275742,
-0.788174569606781,
-0.4435807466506958,
-0.32433006167411804,
-0.07659809291362762,
0.2437492311000824,
0.5482954382896423,
-0.6176291704177856,
0.6524651050567627,
-0.03582331910729408,
-0.5639154314994812,
0.6324091553688049,
0.1664382517337799,
0.15834727883338928,
-0.656499445438385,
-0.19971343874931335,
0.08061496168375015,
-0.29227975010871887,
-0.671664834022522,
-0.21798859536647797,
0.1587972342967987,
0.17397207021713257,
-0.16263559460639954,
0.5997721552848816,
-0.3920755684375763,
-0.08454955369234085,
0.08545397967100143,
0.0894724652171135,
0.06616111844778061,
0.2952229976654053,
-0.22828935086727142,
0.8025111556053162,
0.14821743965148926,
-0.5702688694000244,
0.3597368001937866,
0.29968082904815674,
-0.04828410595655441,
0.5649126172065735,
-0.5277050733566284,
-0.2174273133277893,
0.0074934037402272224,
0.3265540599822998,
-0.8384275436401367,
-0.1530838906764984,
-0.05426408722996712,
-0.2591044008731842,
0.14413781464099884,
0.15433168411254883,
-0.7250548601150513,
-0.11083503067493439,
-0.3192294239997864,
-0.0028493243735283613,
0.29205265641212463,
-0.3347736597061157,
0.739477276802063,
0.5490468144416809,
0.029705295339226723,
-0.4980562925338745,
-0.717383861541748,
0.25373247265815735,
-0.1725119799375534,
-0.5985002517700195,
0.38500723242759705,
0.14996939897537231,
-0.7990021705627441,
-0.13842500746250153,
-0.6314427256584167,
-0.35023534297943115,
0.17364239692687988,
0.3640928268432617,
0.3177981972694397,
-0.1124376431107521,
0.349775493144989,
0.19135713577270508,
-0.006817721761763096,
0.19730904698371887,
0.0322331003844738,
0.5345560908317566,
-0.5502195954322815,
-0.2090347707271576,
-0.6372870206832886,
0.06491534411907196,
0.14854857325553894,
0.009571804665029049,
0.6301495432853699,
0.6398019194602966,
-0.562687337398529,
-0.42700672149658203,
-0.8198030591011047,
-0.5524251461029053,
-0.44752418994903564,
0.3212188184261322,
-0.5524137616157532,
-0.7786549925804138,
0.4568752646446228,
0.012632842175662518,
0.2920060157775879,
0.18892303109169006,
0.586911678314209,
-0.3244333565235138,
0.9301621317863464,
0.5718135833740234,
0.12568899989128113,
0.14815208315849304,
-0.00657262047752738,
0.19377277791500092,
-0.1899033933877945,
-0.38712078332901,
-0.6950939893722534,
-0.5852038860321045,
-0.5600600242614746,
-0.4160696864128113,
0.5358937978744507,
-0.14357727766036987,
-0.359640508890152,
0.1676679402589798,
-0.43362027406692505,
0.5837266445159912,
0.4389618933200836,
0.2786026895046234,
0.7139308452606201,
-0.04779540002346039,
-0.06372576206922531,
-0.16461889445781708,
-0.6021228432655334,
-0.8303921222686768,
1.009814977645874,
0.11460236459970474,
1.0654277801513672,
0.12370260804891586,
0.5785431861877441,
0.5878590941429138,
0.5840596556663513,
-0.5629549026489258,
0.9763239622116089,
-0.08612442761659622,
-0.4517447054386139,
-0.5307750701904297,
-0.521600604057312,
-0.9357993006706238,
0.2116333693265915,
-0.16722944378852844,
-0.844792902469635,
-0.039345573633909225,
0.3043275475502014,
-0.11400774121284485,
0.3044220507144928,
-0.6827560663223267,
1.1584081649780273,
-0.11785674095153809,
-0.2947548031806946,
-0.26305583119392395,
-0.7164552211761475,
0.208418607711792,
0.2109898179769516,
0.12121789157390594,
-0.20191700756549835,
0.051009029150009155,
0.9294959306716919,
-0.282177209854126,
0.8439274430274963,
-0.23024676740169525,
0.08013270050287247,
0.13604556024074554,
0.6995663046836853,
0.44906318187713623,
0.3254149258136749,
-0.026524696499109268,
0.1587287038564682,
0.12830139696598053,
-0.38137441873550415,
-0.7937636375427246,
0.5397591590881348,
-0.5078029036521912,
-0.8752251267433167,
-0.19569939374923706,
-1.1063923835754395,
-0.6437820196151733,
0.08917642384767532,
-0.36222976446151733,
0.07876433432102203,
-0.12047124654054642,
0.5688312649726868,
0.5876613855361938,
0.2440786063671112,
0.24070771038532257,
0.15884537994861603,
-0.15394988656044006,
0.12454234063625336,
0.39153051376342773,
0.23673951625823975,
-0.07494311779737473,
0.38606271147727966,
0.12622766196727753,
-0.48528674244880676,
-0.40655452013015747,
-0.38640162348747253,
0.04526401311159134,
-0.9030693769454956,
-0.6764615178108215,
-0.722721517086029,
0.1935066133737564,
-0.4359905421733856,
-0.16338002681732178,
-0.12278788536787033,
-0.8688523769378662,
-0.16436909139156342,
-0.4098525941371918,
0.5678881406784058,
0.29963427782058716,
-0.06177062913775444,
0.14724914729595184,
-0.8643391728401184,
0.5405916571617126,
0.2879732549190521,
0.41794586181640625,
-0.11753454804420471,
-0.3845100998878479,
0.015027285553514957,
-0.18333610892295837,
-0.1308993101119995,
-1.1247048377990723,
0.2882246971130371,
0.03935927525162697,
0.5969047546386719,
0.2741237282752991,
-0.08639156073331833,
0.9090891480445862,
-0.408479243516922,
0.381732702255249,
-0.11438872665166855,
-0.9292436242103577,
0.388462096452713,
-0.18118026852607727,
0.32744768261909485,
0.3387191891670227,
0.4280150830745697,
-0.3283654749393463,
-0.4045514464378357,
-0.39980748295783997,
-0.5918542146682739,
0.31887200474739075,
0.16191484034061432,
-0.12928128242492676,
0.23370462656021118,
0.2541934549808502,
0.1812203973531723,
0.19214582443237305,
-1.2093472480773926,
0.01600428856909275,
-0.251943439245224,
-0.2006920874118805,
0.22384615242481232,
-0.0015364112332463264,
-0.2157527208328247,
-0.6948593258857727,
0.45524874329566956,
-0.12038998305797577,
0.10968758165836334,
0.03221915662288666,
-0.4981287717819214,
-0.23463451862335205,
0.5429971218109131,
0.344821572303772,
0.8678128719329834,
-0.21966996788978577,
0.3339373767375946,
0.46154776215553284,
-0.4860159456729889,
0.11661040037870407,
0.09214609116315842,
-0.049606870859861374,
-0.009881831705570221,
0.22368112206459045,
0.27686259150505066,
-0.06049551069736481,
-0.7944760918617249,
0.03611006587743759,
0.04136063903570175,
0.1309366077184677,
0.13073290884494781,
0.08236995339393616,
0.18946625292301178,
0.327119916677475,
0.3181072771549225,
-0.6200073957443237,
0.22773633897304535,
-0.4596911072731018,
0.617559552192688,
0.5139241218566895,
0.024438591673970222,
-0.03908216208219528,
0.5444009900093079,
-0.37739935517311096,
-0.33599424362182617,
0.6259428858757019,
-0.12120936810970306,
-0.23792314529418945,
0.7187579274177551,
0.9845021367073059,
0.4787824749946594,
-0.2468484491109848,
0.2872408330440521,
0.2674631178379059,
0.5303636193275452,
0.21618443727493286,
0.6659387946128845,
-0.06384912133216858,
-0.760954737663269,
-0.024351682513952255,
-0.8008126020431519,
-0.4659348726272583,
-0.08102287352085114,
-0.3384536802768707,
0.16262027621269226,
-0.6679946184158325,
-0.2910144329071045,
-0.11836620420217514,
-0.1706228256225586,
-0.6285786628723145,
0.2672809362411499,
-0.2327686846256256,
0.7733324766159058,
-0.7175924181938171,
0.8741891980171204,
0.5741846561431885,
-0.4113073945045471,
-1.186591625213623,
-0.2119494527578354,
0.03771808370947838,
-0.4402059018611908,
0.9385383725166321,
0.08550413697957993,
-0.10648924857378006,
0.011852337047457695,
-0.626522958278656,
-0.4994710087776184,
0.8342989683151245,
0.4306873381137848,
-0.5732051730155945,
-0.04571133479475975,
0.6646595597267151,
0.6604390144348145,
-0.21647079288959503,
-0.1095951721072197,
0.9401605725288391,
1.010901927947998,
-0.32705122232437134,
-0.7218341827392578,
0.5547325611114502,
-0.2216309905052185,
-0.10999862849712372,
0.23455509543418884,
0.03988043591380119,
0.9065864086151123,
-0.20865878462791443,
-0.0019156053895130754,
-0.5337638854980469,
0.7988578081130981,
0.48446089029312134,
0.2107863426208496,
0.4637851417064667,
0.7069546580314636,
0.5904565453529358,
-0.2830752432346344,
0.5647836923599243,
0.178879976272583,
-0.09473587572574615,
0.9850835800170898,
-0.4365919828414917,
0.6956305503845215,
0.832875669002533,
-0.31443917751312256,
0.6378194689750671,
0.4057338833808899,
-0.2813805639743805,
0.020248670130968094,
0.41002291440963745,
0.07574720680713654,
-0.4523319900035858,
-0.017659854143857956,
-0.10646303743124008,
0.43548232316970825,
0.4189358353614807,
0.24749648571014404,
-0.8364297747612,
-0.19179445505142212,
0.11545416712760925,
0.4679899215698242,
-0.21144868433475494,
0.6495620608329773,
0.041174016892910004,
-0.21372435986995697,
0.6752586960792542,
0.09549863636493683,
0.18334980309009552,
-0.3495272397994995,
-0.46085354685783386,
-0.38386082649230957,
0.05631536990404129,
-0.5020880699157715,
-0.7326315641403198,
0.5470907092094421,
0.1731168031692505,
0.13415832817554474,
-0.21161669492721558,
0.6237891316413879,
-0.04406559094786644,
-0.2392849326133728,
-0.024189073592424393,
0.8008850812911987,
0.02131200209259987,
-0.15538202226161957,
-0.6574854850769043,
0.07620285451412201,
-0.14088529348373413,
-0.3239293694496155,
0.3447400629520416,
0.45941779017448425,
-0.6390091180801392,
0.891917884349823,
0.9008205533027649,
-0.07656241208314896,
0.1307772994041443,
0.3456127345561981,
1.0909690856933594,
-0.7668487429618835,
-0.5773512721061707,
-1.0519003868103027,
0.4515477418899536,
-0.08517119288444519,
-0.002004872541874647,
0.7113896012306213,
0.7751396894454956,
0.6112694144248962,
-0.3529650568962097,
0.07192674279212952,
-0.023787658661603928,
0.19607189297676086,
-0.44212931394577026,
0.9649706482887268,
-0.47114861011505127,
0.295704185962677,
-0.26706355810165405,
-1.0436835289001465,
-1.1088359355926514,
0.8366516828536987,
-0.31210583448410034,
-0.17578819394111633,
0.6307445764541626,
1.1790987253189087,
-0.02977333404123783,
-0.13131184875965118,
0.310968816280365,
0.47925445437431335,
0.5305192470550537,
0.1497601717710495,
0.5032051801681519,
0.12086363136768341,
0.49233943223953247,
-0.14985902607440948,
-0.1815112680196762,
-0.054999127984046936,
-0.9278416633605957,
-0.9352326989173889,
-0.6080033779144287,
0.17216633260250092,
-0.25188544392585754,
0.23194196820259094,
1.2304072380065918,
0.336228609085083,
-0.6899868249893188,
-0.6969583630561829,
-0.1766895055770874,
0.32520177960395813,
-0.0830882266163826,
-0.34815308451652527,
0.1942846029996872,
-0.476212739944458,
-0.20315837860107422,
0.2679797112941742,
0.3418198823928833,
-0.07860313355922699,
0.008251745253801346,
0.24893711507320404,
-0.5448535084724426,
0.22343343496322632,
0.4769356846809387,
0.08147963136434555,
-0.7239315509796143,
-0.15955136716365814,
-0.034943271428346634,
-0.2758964002132416,
0.5496434569358826,
0.6166633367538452,
-0.7334436178207397,
-0.01824089325964451,
0.3900526165962219,
0.6384990215301514,
0.5046136975288391,
0.18664221465587616,
0.29851505160331726,
-0.6832800507545471,
0.21204249560832977,
0.687340259552002,
0.35603854060173035,
0.08632328361272812,
-0.4198678433895111,
0.6263127326965332,
0.08992797881364822,
-0.24322935938835144,
-1.2592452764511108,
0.2962905168533325,
-1.2640368938446045,
-0.40938177704811096,
0.9636098742485046,
0.2086598426103592,
-0.21067537367343903,
-0.09530799090862274,
0.024256546050310135,
0.5313923954963684,
-0.43511709570884705,
1.3048388957977295,
0.3365563154220581,
-0.3648862838745117,
-0.06055765599012375,
-0.3904817998409271,
0.63234943151474,
0.39152991771698,
-1.6442893743515015,
0.09798640012741089,
0.7729942798614502,
0.17222359776496887,
-0.11241883784532547,
0.3821651041507721,
-0.2539559304714203,
0.5069767832756042,
-0.20815931260585785,
0.3121664822101593,
-0.2958338260650635,
-0.6053851246833801,
0.1968080699443817,
0.28764808177948,
0.06626732647418976,
0.344835489988327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17947v1 | Do they mean 'us'? Interpreting Referring Expressions in Intergroup Bias | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | 2024-06-25T21:47:53 | Venkata S Govindarajan, Matianyu Zang, Kyle Mahowald, David Beaver, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The variations between in-group and out-group speech (intergroup bias) are
subtle and could underlie many social phenomena like stereotype perpetuation
and implicit bias. In this paper, we model the intergroup bias as a tagging
task on English sports comments from forums dedicated to fandom for NFL teams.
We curate a unique dataset of over 6 million game-time comments from opposing
perspectives (the teams in the game), each comment grounded in a non-linguistic
description of the events that precipitated these comments (live win
probabilities for each team). Expert and crowd annotations justify modeling the
bias through tagging of implicit and explicit referring expressions and reveal
the rich, contextual understanding of language and the world required for this
task. For large-scale analysis of intergroup variation, we use LLMs for
automated tagging, and discover that some LLMs perform best when prompted with
linguistic descriptions of the win probability at the time of the comment,
rather than numerical probability. Further, large-scale tagging of comments
using LLMs uncovers linear variations in the form of referent across win
probabilities that distinguish in-group and out-group utterances. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/venkatasg/intergroup-nfl . | [
-0.6648503541946411,
-0.3856225311756134,
0.23530632257461548,
0.4435023069381714,
-0.5096907019615173,
0.2633460462093353,
0.04417147487401962,
-0.5724564790725708,
0.33778953552246094,
0.23283761739730835,
-0.6810126900672913,
-0.1151936948299408,
-0.5100176334381104,
0.4345583915710449,
-0.14264452457427979,
1.1515042781829834,
0.399537056684494,
0.6228042244911194,
-0.22192439436912537,
-0.349438339471817,
0.2804018557071686,
-0.540432333946228,
-0.26260024309158325,
-0.6852186918258667,
0.36236175894737244,
0.020138321444392204,
0.7830100059509277,
0.4917784035205841,
0.7275012135505676,
0.20488789677619934,
0.0406879298388958,
-0.03475990518927574,
-0.5195859670639038,
0.09623271226882935,
-0.48936372995376587,
-0.3225787281990051,
-0.1570947915315628,
0.4082792103290558,
0.3647178113460541,
0.7582013607025146,
0.13960422575473785,
0.3283538222312927,
-0.04528554156422615,
0.451275110244751,
-0.04358790069818497,
0.19975128769874573,
-1.0395382642745972,
0.2388981580734253,
-0.06485351920127869,
-0.5448448061943054,
-0.16456258296966553,
-0.39882832765579224,
0.1285354197025299,
-0.4025595486164093,
0.5363957285881042,
0.2151378095149994,
0.9688740968704224,
0.39906054735183716,
-0.3178115785121918,
-0.3505779206752777,
-0.32017484307289124,
0.5843380093574524,
-0.8950279951095581,
0.05700863525271416,
0.5436724424362183,
0.2457217574119568,
-0.29022082686424255,
-0.1859913319349289,
-0.5375450253486633,
-0.3757953941822052,
-0.19057928025722504,
0.36572206020355225,
-0.28412795066833496,
0.0319882296025753,
0.4134443998336792,
0.1523122936487198,
-0.28712698817253113,
0.06650440394878387,
-0.4339682161808014,
-0.009245987981557846,
0.8888457417488098,
0.039858605712652206,
0.22246792912483215,
0.4166240096092224,
-0.5920888185501099,
0.4590749740600586,
-0.7546894550323486,
-0.20018886029720306,
0.4390687644481659,
0.4251139163970947,
0.06877323240041733,
0.42004039883613586,
-0.2693004608154297,
0.37352609634399414,
0.3831596076488495,
0.06294327229261398,
0.04684370383620262,
-0.021231558173894882,
-0.20834574103355408,
-0.2405608892440796,
0.696968138217926,
1.0272122621536255,
0.516078531742096,
-0.9129788279533386,
-0.022446347400546074,
0.2611771821975708,
-0.027577657252550125,
-0.47621864080429077,
-0.09929817169904709,
-0.3981201648712158,
-0.472205251455307,
-0.10362550616264343,
0.07009688019752502,
-0.7168018221855164,
-0.7660499215126038,
-0.1022547110915184,
0.3705213963985443,
0.06978116184473038,
-0.052802674472332,
-0.13587871193885803,
-0.49774715304374695,
0.23010624945163727,
0.06335841864347458,
-0.6993624567985535,
0.4719332158565521,
0.48058030009269714,
0.39605847001075745,
0.03642956167459488,
-0.15661342442035675,
-0.4145297408103943,
0.390217661857605,
-0.19246338307857513,
1.0776814222335815,
-0.7113093733787537,
-0.6255353689193726,
0.048504214733839035,
-0.18266470730304718,
0.27747851610183716,
-0.8256049156188965,
0.29249751567840576,
-0.5760592222213745,
-0.1689864993095398,
-0.6689379215240479,
-0.7039947509765625,
-0.09860322624444962,
-0.06525011360645294,
-0.544246256351471,
0.8384076952934265,
-0.15922436118125916,
-0.8911848068237305,
0.7289543747901917,
-0.4244261384010315,
-0.3689848482608795,
0.2828401029109955,
-0.4552115499973297,
-0.044006168842315674,
0.5069791078567505,
-0.022651562467217445,
0.6384807229042053,
-0.733489453792572,
-0.037985660135746,
-0.5323519110679626,
-0.4607025980949402,
0.651159405708313,
0.12562395632266998,
0.38302135467529297,
0.13373231887817383,
-0.3278755247592926,
-0.18447436392307281,
-0.2789698541164398,
0.030469387769699097,
-0.19149096310138702,
-0.2660139799118042,
-0.4528036117553711,
0.21372343599796295,
-0.4525132179260254,
0.47584012150764465,
-0.17105425894260406,
-0.3803069591522217,
0.29965952038764954,
0.10661338269710541,
0.4048556089401245,
0.8878576159477234,
0.03242478519678116,
0.7930631637573242,
-0.20735988020896912,
0.7360436916351318,
0.45633429288864136,
0.13441018760204315,
0.05699290335178375,
-0.3992452323436737,
-0.35775259137153625,
0.10321318358182907,
-0.0780215933918953,
0.29262298345565796,
-0.7832944393157959,
0.16875964403152466,
-0.201666459441185,
-0.29990455508232117,
-0.14741110801696777,
-0.16384479403495789,
0.3575090765953064,
0.5876522064208984,
0.18011340498924255,
-0.11770744621753693,
-0.43474841117858887,
-1.2968729734420776,
-0.6937763690948486,
-0.45418474078178406,
0.06721031665802002,
0.3749712407588959,
0.35090285539627075,
-0.01861916109919548,
0.9319512248039246,
-0.2563256323337555,
-0.4636023938655853,
-0.10893376916646957,
0.21369343996047974,
0.2280581295490265,
-0.08567453920841217,
0.40914827585220337,
-0.7889849543571472,
-0.9553090333938599,
-0.11399579793214798,
-0.6724444627761841,
-0.6986905932426453,
-0.08037695288658142,
-0.03930088132619858,
-0.07825767993927002,
0.7723180651664734,
-0.2117338329553604,
0.4627947509288788,
0.610206127166748,
-0.5810255408287048,
0.2801986038684845,
0.5594263672828674,
-0.04094626009464264,
-0.6852660179138184,
-0.5038273334503174,
0.47478410601615906,
-0.089657261967659,
-0.2948278784751892,
-0.08313910663127899,
-0.4428074061870575,
0.728415310382843,
-0.14553293585777283,
0.3968021273612976,
-0.771991491317749,
-0.2495449036359787,
0.015285208821296692,
0.15387265384197235,
-0.11100384593009949,
0.3691582679748535,
-0.11061754077672958,
0.9380630850791931,
0.455905944108963,
-0.7200434803962708,
0.14275570213794708,
-0.2265917956829071,
-0.21377027034759521,
0.6593165993690491,
-0.2357696294784546,
0.2903428375720978,
-0.29713353514671326,
0.47878298163414,
-1.087697982788086,
-0.26015880703926086,
0.41377532482147217,
-0.46377983689308167,
0.0356484018266201,
-0.08544155955314636,
-0.4151872992515564,
-0.23876075446605682,
-0.1607377678155899,
0.3323671519756317,
0.20392858982086182,
-0.33198708295822144,
0.4374673068523407,
1.030954360961914,
0.004557069391012192,
-0.5895100831985474,
-0.7873305678367615,
-0.008118070662021637,
-0.5426002740859985,
-0.28696104884147644,
0.16091614961624146,
-0.3611176311969757,
-0.8895912170410156,
0.12490350008010864,
-0.41722166538238525,
-0.7059813737869263,
-0.21811401844024658,
0.19051305949687958,
-0.14396853744983673,
-0.06978936493396759,
0.2866155803203583,
-0.26536598801612854,
0.1964295357465744,
0.15965527296066284,
-0.03221217542886734,
0.19785600900650024,
-0.0737333744764328,
0.13090865314006805,
-0.1647481471300125,
0.8010478615760803,
0.018653854727745056,
0.3471941351890564,
0.35441067814826965,
0.16108670830726624,
0.025431662797927856,
-0.4641610383987427,
-0.5428777933120728,
-0.5694355964660645,
-0.37049391865730286,
0.576172411441803,
-0.4687928855419159,
-0.8872290849685669,
0.6501617431640625,
-0.04436477646231651,
0.15697285532951355,
0.3596791625022888,
0.32842087745666504,
-0.6634271740913391,
1.0211957693099976,
0.3742336928844452,
-0.010475832968950272,
0.034529197961091995,
0.12955515086650848,
-0.14864185452461243,
-0.6737682223320007,
-0.03006013110280037,
-0.5234581828117371,
-0.6186574697494507,
-0.3608418107032776,
-0.6209261417388916,
0.22465549409389496,
0.09925932437181473,
0.026189159601926804,
0.023939456790685654,
-0.441608726978302,
0.9105890393257141,
0.2883513271808624,
-0.12102383375167847,
0.16840827465057373,
-0.16332396864891052,
0.02262977696955204,
-0.5912937521934509,
-0.5595844984054565,
-0.2476361095905304,
0.8386151790618896,
0.2785061001777649,
0.9535489678382874,
0.33791929483413696,
0.6261823773384094,
0.7595124244689941,
1.0882768630981445,
-0.8185970783233643,
0.8743942975997925,
-0.18634986877441406,
-0.8789837956428528,
-0.0309893861413002,
-0.31069210171699524,
-0.6368885040283203,
0.4520958960056305,
-0.05993232876062393,
-0.5905874967575073,
-0.09676281362771988,
0.3623077869415283,
-0.08038711547851562,
0.35665562748908997,
-0.3020094335079193,
0.09873628616333008,
0.01309351995587349,
-0.35509422421455383,
0.07655420899391174,
-0.7354767322540283,
0.4579041004180908,
0.04458387568593025,
0.4553753435611725,
-0.4827768802642822,
-0.3340640366077423,
0.8001565933227539,
-0.33207961916923523,
0.957389235496521,
-0.09276984632015228,
-0.32502931356430054,
0.4611695408821106,
-0.12318664789199829,
0.293243408203125,
-0.06314048916101456,
-0.189960777759552,
0.5292791724205017,
-0.37025725841522217,
-0.12713272869586945,
-0.45617035031318665,
0.4417997896671295,
-0.3674134910106659,
-0.5812021493911743,
-0.5993614196777344,
-0.5903297662734985,
-0.4407287538051605,
-0.25473275780677795,
0.6308978796005249,
0.1258373111486435,
-0.38687804341316223,
0.000607077032327652,
0.5112276673316956,
0.008914081379771233,
0.5627214312553406,
0.7649583220481873,
-0.24112185835838318,
-0.2969920039176941,
0.2733936905860901,
0.29704421758651733,
0.05735374614596367,
0.3732181787490845,
0.07131515443325043,
-0.6239889860153198,
-0.2496519535779953,
-0.2150442898273468,
0.5755099654197693,
-0.905778706073761,
-0.2550196051597595,
-0.15547819435596466,
0.3865484893321991,
-0.32710617780685425,
0.20836886763572693,
0.128741055727005,
-0.3876653015613556,
0.08399082720279694,
-0.1834437996149063,
0.037930600345134735,
1.0165983438491821,
-0.2872329652309418,
0.6548115015029907,
-0.6502545475959778,
0.058050934225320816,
0.1838710755109787,
0.4012957513332367,
-0.46648669242858887,
-0.6588951945304871,
-0.5552340745925903,
-0.32774895429611206,
0.07957044988870621,
-1.4294672012329102,
0.13709867000579834,
0.28464367985725403,
0.6967844367027283,
0.2777145504951477,
-0.044704120606184006,
0.5144788026809692,
-0.596785843372345,
0.830956757068634,
0.26655375957489014,
-0.7735457420349121,
-0.18822364509105682,
-0.5178865194320679,
0.1200389489531517,
0.49569904804229736,
0.3056972920894623,
-0.46456995606422424,
-0.3205982446670532,
-0.6149173974990845,
-0.5367329716682434,
0.6983599066734314,
-0.39383283257484436,
0.20558185875415802,
-0.47422319650650024,
0.6005290746688843,
0.1441534161567688,
0.4266740679740906,
-0.9577094912528992,
-0.6277235746383667,
0.1391659826040268,
0.21290352940559387,
-0.0838085487484932,
-0.3679196834564209,
-0.5332309007644653,
-0.03747908025979996,
0.7222773432731628,
-0.3723401427268982,
0.25996583700180054,
0.0763128399848938,
-0.07037913054227829,
-0.3614169657230377,
0.1144760400056839,
0.6416329145431519,
0.8523546457290649,
0.053622156381607056,
0.246053546667099,
0.2162993848323822,
-0.3815896213054657,
0.041483912616968155,
-0.02170875109732151,
-0.14489009976387024,
0.46017947793006897,
0.13982617855072021,
0.3173084259033203,
0.09027890861034393,
-0.3448232412338257,
0.3518297076225281,
-0.19490547478199005,
-0.1573343276977539,
-0.029913101345300674,
-0.3380245864391327,
0.09669838845729828,
0.15079951286315918,
0.7153930068016052,
0.08226320147514343,
0.3013727068901062,
-0.54190593957901,
0.26312345266342163,
0.6690821051597595,
-0.7847360372543335,
-0.6543968319892883,
0.8550223112106323,
0.4641246199607849,
0.049620889127254486,
-0.05341805890202522,
-0.2841856777667999,
-0.6690651178359985,
0.5557876229286194,
0.5184476375579834,
1.1087417602539062,
-0.2901791036128998,
0.2702307105064392,
0.033366601914167404,
0.3856050968170166,
0.3201754689216614,
0.2631673812866211,
-0.10868832468986511,
-0.9475725293159485,
-0.39954569935798645,
-0.5661691427230835,
-0.23058845102787018,
0.09523706138134003,
-0.7539031505584717,
-0.27109581232070923,
-0.4922017455101013,
-0.6283552050590515,
0.12637333571910858,
-0.39323869347572327,
-0.6272707581520081,
0.5011228322982788,
0.37423866987228394,
0.9384702444076538,
-1.024096131324768,
0.7096655368804932,
1.1781331300735474,
-0.5109654068946838,
-0.6906217336654663,
0.6129264235496521,
0.038984525948762894,
-0.7678602337837219,
1.0988116264343262,
0.007291191723197699,
-0.17826658487319946,
-0.15996041893959045,
-0.8454185724258423,
-0.548114001750946,
0.30760252475738525,
0.29044657945632935,
-0.2770049273967743,
-0.034003835171461105,
0.398030549287796,
0.369184285402298,
-0.41570135951042175,
0.2308071106672287,
0.463927686214447,
0.1783251315355301,
0.1282079517841339,
-1.0000362396240234,
-0.0941728949546814,
-0.10072393715381622,
-0.2119274139404297,
0.15847215056419373,
-1.1119481325149536,
0.9381330609321594,
0.031309813261032104,
0.04111141711473465,
-0.3809853792190552,
0.8389164805412292,
-0.1349899172782898,
0.19067856669425964,
0.711178719997406,
0.16163596510887146,
0.5207694172859192,
-0.269387811422348,
0.8221389651298523,
-0.07441282272338867,
0.10042501240968704,
1.1510802507400513,
-0.34449705481529236,
0.35631877183914185,
0.774890124797821,
-0.4991891086101532,
0.1885754019021988,
0.4793670177459717,
0.27160319685935974,
0.42041003704071045,
0.598384439945221,
-0.6400502920150757,
-0.3158413767814636,
-0.23318690061569214,
-0.31073451042175293,
0.4573271572589874,
0.5606730580329895,
-0.47103971242904663,
-0.4797118902206421,
-0.5867748856544495,
0.4657837152481079,
0.3784886300563812,
-0.48075658082962036,
0.8451858162879944,
0.21316726505756378,
-1.0122120380401611,
0.07958836108446121,
-0.26686134934425354,
0.8446802496910095,
-0.6584088206291199,
-0.21518056094646454,
-0.5057365894317627,
0.16925351321697235,
-0.2811855375766754,
-0.7440000176429749,
0.140884131193161,
-0.10950928926467896,
-0.373080849647522,
0.04787301644682884,
0.2781135141849518,
-0.3946860730648041,
-0.07639306783676147,
0.3670339584350586,
0.2406178116798401,
0.7019780278205872,
-0.0002084962179651484,
-0.8700222373008728,
0.14222927391529083,
0.27106794714927673,
-0.21166811883449554,
0.43166834115982056,
0.4252763092517853,
-0.20422059297561646,
0.42756515741348267,
0.23947980999946594,
0.15982531011104584,
0.6498582363128662,
0.22464749217033386,
0.8837292790412903,
-0.5635406970977783,
-0.30234894156455994,
-1.1061347723007202,
0.4290250837802887,
-0.24994929134845734,
-0.41976144909858704,
0.9786372780799866,
0.5535219311714172,
0.621566116809845,
-0.2048938274383545,
1.1616264581680298,
-0.03032068721950054,
0.7936645150184631,
-0.08052397519350052,
0.4866665005683899,
-0.410330593585968,
0.09470383077859879,
-0.25278720259666443,
-0.9549707770347595,
-0.4368955194950104,
0.528619647026062,
-0.07480187714099884,
-0.11063585430383682,
0.3138900101184845,
0.5941910147666931,
0.25371894240379333,
0.05530459061264992,
0.43904244899749756,
0.48633623123168945,
0.22131691873073578,
0.16019868850708008,
1.0817935466766357,
0.056484155356884,
0.5280051827430725,
-0.12802357971668243,
-0.45229050517082214,
-0.04429256543517113,
-1.0642306804656982,
-0.9890550971031189,
-0.4286121428012848,
-0.4672883152961731,
-0.5252914428710938,
0.06401413679122925,
0.8749361038208008,
0.6026805639266968,
-0.4906560182571411,
-0.3172872066497803,
0.3048437833786011,
-0.2984144389629364,
-0.20657925307750702,
-0.2937880754470825,
-0.14355877041816711,
-0.3883576989173889,
-1.048844814300537,
0.38553386926651,
0.17092815041542053,
-0.3197396993637085,
-0.29343122243881226,
0.11970584094524384,
-0.12593674659729004,
0.4880183935165405,
0.3700683116912842,
0.4929712414741516,
-0.8333857655525208,
-0.31971269845962524,
-0.061140965670347214,
-0.013732378371059895,
-0.016731826588511467,
0.46827685832977295,
-0.6960899233818054,
0.3661835789680481,
0.15810133516788483,
0.21669842302799225,
0.1313590556383133,
0.455035537481308,
0.6733173727989197,
-0.8967938423156738,
0.4426242709159851,
0.3832913339138031,
0.20027154684066772,
0.31080618500709534,
-0.19037483632564545,
0.9048218727111816,
0.45637863874435425,
-0.6560547351837158,
-0.9180389642715454,
0.3603096306324005,
-0.6662167906761169,
0.004539763554930687,
1.2681257724761963,
-0.2614043354988098,
0.15141256153583527,
-0.08014529198408127,
-0.030913246795535088,
0.16837988793849945,
-0.3250235617160797,
0.8276364803314209,
0.8133037686347961,
-0.5249292254447937,
0.2098817378282547,
-0.44123315811157227,
0.8992594480514526,
0.20744548738002777,
-0.43242982029914856,
-0.22485537827014923,
0.6128624081611633,
0.34781962633132935,
0.04652858152985573,
1.0189772844314575,
0.1488710641860962,
0.1344745010137558,
0.057604335248470306,
0.008753347210586071,
0.46010515093803406,
0.07353149354457855,
-0.13336215913295746,
-0.07317053526639938,
-0.17460384964942932,
-0.33109137415885925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17935v1 | Sequential Editing for Lifelong Training of Speech Recognition Models | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | 2024-06-25T20:52:09 | Devang Kulshreshtha, Saket Dingliwal, Brady Houston, Nikolaos Pappas, Srikanth Ronanki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) traditionally assumes known domains, but
adding data from a new domain raises concerns about computational
inefficiencies linked to retraining models on both existing and new domains.
Fine-tuning solely on new domain risks Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). To address
this, Lifelong Learning (LLL) algorithms have been proposed for ASR. Prior
research has explored techniques such as Elastic Weight Consolidation,
Knowledge Distillation, and Replay, all of which necessitate either additional
parameters or access to prior domain data. We propose Sequential Model Editing
as a novel method to continually learn new domains in ASR systems. Different
than previous methods, our approach does not necessitate access to prior
datasets or the introduction of extra parameters. Our study demonstrates up to
15% Word Error Rate Reduction (WERR) over fine-tuning baseline, and superior
efficiency over other LLL techniques on CommonVoice English multi-accent
dataset. | [
-0.11913615465164185,
-0.6347224712371826,
0.2843112051486969,
0.03864884376525879,
-0.25069117546081543,
0.25936174392700195,
-0.32004314661026,
-0.39085623621940613,
-0.3003827929496765,
0.5132002234458923,
-0.5588699579238892,
-0.24887126684188843,
-0.5818029642105103,
0.1442536562681198,
-0.22931580245494843,
0.7705997228622437,
-0.18323653936386108,
0.21529777348041534,
-0.08384755253791809,
-0.45342206954956055,
-0.8370953798294067,
-0.6601012945175171,
-1.2621347904205322,
-0.46039408445358276,
0.5429600477218628,
0.3988690972328186,
0.3667953610420227,
0.5124136209487915,
0.260375052690506,
0.3712499141693115,
-0.13481725752353668,
0.4015733003616333,
-0.41537296772003174,
0.2218339592218399,
-0.2757055163383484,
-0.18559131026268005,
-0.5555989742279053,
-0.22629527747631073,
1.1353510618209839,
0.984636127948761,
-0.1652550995349884,
-0.023388853296637535,
0.08811195194721222,
0.7498024702072144,
-0.410532683134079,
-0.2405036985874176,
-0.9496607780456543,
0.03929849714040756,
-0.20241904258728027,
-0.4163345396518707,
-0.4967403709888458,
-0.25871118903160095,
0.2188444584608078,
-0.5582572817802429,
0.33705833554267883,
-0.16915209591388702,
0.5407102704048157,
0.5656108260154724,
-0.18618173897266388,
-0.20578999817371368,
-0.994269073009491,
0.6224253177642822,
-0.6345745921134949,
0.6566071510314941,
0.2185743898153305,
0.1034025326371193,
-0.13118386268615723,
-0.7681261897087097,
-0.6412250399589539,
-0.14141947031021118,
0.30846333503723145,
-0.24555785953998566,
-0.11566454917192459,
0.04120005667209625,
0.383378267288208,
0.06067367643117905,
-0.42133185267448425,
0.170212060213089,
-0.4297949969768524,
-0.2569807767868042,
0.7730491757392883,
0.18480384349822998,
0.1777355670928955,
0.4302320182323456,
-0.06754958629608154,
0.23491889238357544,
-0.7722201347351074,
-0.04958260431885719,
0.10656558722257614,
0.32316628098487854,
0.2544945776462555,
0.4121387004852295,
-0.021400436758995056,
0.8040211796760559,
0.34071066975593567,
-0.11877278983592987,
0.27617865800857544,
-0.03232070431113243,
-0.18288548290729523,
0.09967437386512756,
0.45750880241394043,
0.1367226392030716,
0.5314494371414185,
-0.18113982677459717,
-0.3603358864784241,
0.049281492829322815,
0.3978899419307709,
-0.3939146101474762,
-0.3211424648761749,
0.1688641607761383,
-0.19401328265666962,
0.07097555696964264,
-0.3149009048938751,
-0.09935584664344788,
-0.27192825078964233,
-0.652906596660614,
0.6284343600273132,
-0.5549848079681396,
0.18111705780029297,
0.2874454855918884,
-0.06288719177246094,
-0.30854687094688416,
0.5957993268966675,
-0.6815776228904724,
0.45939603447914124,
0.5364176034927368,
0.8224241733551025,
-0.287810355424881,
-0.7014416456222534,
-0.7804391980171204,
0.158549502491951,
-0.2722979485988617,
0.7872875332832336,
-0.4226020872592926,
-0.7982964515686035,
-0.21004381775856018,
0.04012676700949669,
-0.1877606213092804,
-0.687116801738739,
0.3390809893608093,
-0.7608354091644287,
-0.23916850984096527,
0.042810048907995224,
-0.9214985370635986,
-0.015912199392914772,
-0.37050554156303406,
-0.4962592124938965,
0.8076222538948059,
-0.2276928424835205,
-0.32678595185279846,
0.5449917316436768,
-0.5085684657096863,
-0.6859146356582642,
-0.025516226887702942,
0.10903438180685043,
-0.7044791579246521,
0.08564332872629166,
0.19871334731578827,
0.39433321356773376,
0.309495210647583,
0.49007391929626465,
-0.061464421451091766,
-0.26521268486976624,
0.23803095519542694,
-0.27468714118003845,
0.3556756377220154,
0.08749421685934067,
-0.15882845222949982,
0.07607676833868027,
-1.007360577583313,
-0.1387936770915985,
-0.16966554522514343,
-0.45173174142837524,
-0.43262025713920593,
0.14208853244781494,
-0.02954752743244171,
0.07763435691595078,
0.30968132615089417,
-0.4902176856994629,
0.35306140780448914,
-0.2617066204547882,
0.46705523133277893,
0.8672757148742676,
0.4372220039367676,
0.3463570475578308,
-0.6981236934661865,
0.2604404389858246,
0.03328940272331238,
0.004225882701575756,
-0.22826606035232544,
-0.40776652097702026,
-0.9713686108589172,
-0.0354575589299202,
0.27879849076271057,
0.5657806992530823,
-0.5480921268463135,
0.45988786220550537,
-0.4367140531539917,
-0.36233511567115784,
-0.38275086879730225,
0.3076825439929962,
0.37407171726226807,
0.6097686886787415,
0.473336398601532,
-0.5466253161430359,
-0.8141327500343323,
-0.41524428129196167,
-0.36320802569389343,
0.16993659734725952,
-0.06118697673082352,
0.345556378364563,
0.5481219291687012,
-0.3483947813510895,
1.0227351188659668,
-0.3607921302318573,
-0.38149163126945496,
0.11841538548469543,
0.37955498695373535,
-0.024890214204788208,
0.7627171277999878,
-0.006907873786985874,
-0.6457191109657288,
-0.6341493725776672,
-0.1509278565645218,
-0.5909141302108765,
0.06872797757387161,
-0.6639460921287537,
0.17294281721115112,
0.3562556207180023,
0.48119693994522095,
-0.4890674650669098,
0.39369893074035645,
0.10905534774065018,
0.047704875469207764,
0.5014825463294983,
-0.49292343854904175,
0.09128323942422867,
-0.5635223984718323,
0.0703398585319519,
-0.19400432705879211,
-0.2659492790699005,
-0.8901517391204834,
-0.28863900899887085,
0.09497033059597015,
-0.12729837000370026,
-0.46008753776550293,
0.7305492162704468,
-0.5691291689872742,
0.05248361453413963,
-0.276040256023407,
-0.04124743491411209,
-0.1560659557580948,
0.4548811912536621,
0.32273879647254944,
0.9013137221336365,
0.46651652455329895,
-0.8486829996109009,
0.08909398317337036,
0.620319128036499,
-0.22198593616485596,
0.3797285854816437,
-0.6689732670783997,
0.6206888556480408,
-0.11042613536119461,
0.40173935890197754,
-0.6548197269439697,
0.006228048354387283,
-0.07824889570474625,
-0.5695964097976685,
0.485078364610672,
-0.1950676292181015,
-0.2291884571313858,
-0.3457958996295929,
0.024750782176852226,
0.19011223316192627,
0.4587927460670471,
-0.5559077262878418,
0.4766898453235626,
0.48608091473579407,
-0.4936627447605133,
-0.5096113681793213,
-0.5555875897407532,
0.2257324904203415,
-0.13919425010681152,
-0.4786815643310547,
0.5487228631973267,
-0.2903060019016266,
0.07823920994997025,
-0.09862201660871506,
-0.27810508012771606,
-0.26409220695495605,
0.05115893483161926,
0.24297183752059937,
0.1152895912528038,
-0.04654541239142418,
0.14642620086669922,
0.07866130024194717,
-0.21261505782604218,
-0.29835963249206543,
-0.48077189922332764,
0.26357659697532654,
0.3043167293071747,
-0.15785591304302216,
-0.9190677404403687,
0.4075216054916382,
0.5686578750610352,
-0.19062930345535278,
0.40192651748657227,
0.2834535539150238,
-0.5361471772193909,
-0.3594088852405548,
-0.7815185189247131,
0.033069055527448654,
-0.4907206594944,
0.233682781457901,
-0.36800411343574524,
-1.0075443983078003,
0.4931981563568115,
-0.21025247871875763,
0.2315259426832199,
0.28059253096580505,
0.3258793354034424,
-0.1648518592119217,
0.5540143847465515,
0.6462705731391907,
-0.22553487122058868,
0.5745334625244141,
-0.20967808365821838,
-0.1593044251203537,
-0.9181742072105408,
0.003924810793250799,
-0.3174192011356354,
-0.20241135358810425,
-0.048899002373218536,
-0.4317099153995514,
0.41768571734428406,
-0.05999334529042244,
-0.34052398800849915,
0.17516987025737762,
-0.4155785143375397,
0.534241259098053,
0.4759630262851715,
0.3481537699699402,
0.36680716276168823,
0.0056054494343698025,
0.0788164734840393,
-0.11095812916755676,
-0.5863204002380371,
-0.28167229890823364,
1.3127516508102417,
0.2151305228471756,
0.6790072917938232,
-0.09466692060232162,
0.798167884349823,
0.5459998250007629,
0.1438806653022766,
-0.5735868811607361,
0.3348523676395416,
-0.4736112356185913,
-0.15818506479263306,
-0.5735912919044495,
-0.23261402547359467,
-0.7723626494407654,
-0.10205654799938202,
-0.05670224502682686,
-0.48539525270462036,
0.28454139828681946,
0.7624791264533997,
-0.8862668871879578,
0.22085025906562805,
-0.3576582372188568,
0.4197652041912079,
-0.07821626961231232,
-0.46879255771636963,
-0.3432498872280121,
-0.7185817956924438,
0.1012890636920929,
-0.4725695252418518,
0.1622789055109024,
0.09563283622264862,
0.008447286672890186,
0.7883317470550537,
-0.6396629214286804,
0.8728315830230713,
-0.5084440112113953,
0.13225539028644562,
0.23047983646392822,
-0.1630614846944809,
0.7722910642623901,
-0.0023616869002580643,
-0.1664152592420578,
0.12201793491840363,
-0.24413613975048065,
0.05088650435209274,
-0.6046504378318787,
0.45903444290161133,
-0.664150595664978,
-0.3881608545780182,
-0.37208738923072815,
-0.3486926257610321,
-0.5425221920013428,
0.10065867006778717,
0.21822604537010193,
0.7156344652175903,
-0.22732089459896088,
0.011576465331017971,
0.9243587255477905,
-0.21567268669605255,
0.16780917346477509,
0.6558468341827393,
0.3307839632034302,
-0.49636536836624146,
0.8837161064147949,
0.3483187258243561,
0.37222960591316223,
0.2575348913669586,
0.12831610441207886,
-0.18710246682167053,
-0.9987359642982483,
-0.3202090263366699,
0.15949206054210663,
-0.6169811487197876,
-0.0686054527759552,
-0.9587695002555847,
-0.3551492989063263,
-0.48436808586120605,
-0.4355173707008362,
-0.3698457181453705,
-0.5422107577323914,
-0.5350173711776733,
0.26151931285858154,
0.5176889896392822,
0.5846555829048157,
-0.32653263211250305,
0.5977779626846313,
-0.9687110781669617,
0.6753243207931519,
0.42316535115242004,
0.30565759539604187,
-0.024819539859890938,
-1.0318924188613892,
-0.3339770436286926,
0.003076948458328843,
-0.11229904741048813,
-0.3994932770729065,
0.528519332408905,
0.9910100102424622,
0.44797706604003906,
-0.025215469300746918,
-0.2274751514196396,
1.1631754636764526,
-1.371273398399353,
0.7500903606414795,
-0.12149564176797867,
-1.0899425745010376,
0.6103361248970032,
-0.27730152010917664,
0.5880154371261597,
0.7753944396972656,
0.4653284549713135,
-0.853243350982666,
-0.22551116347312927,
-0.5228067636489868,
-0.7745558619499207,
0.4778473675251007,
-0.41069960594177246,
0.1499326080083847,
0.20976094901561737,
0.677407443523407,
0.22648410499095917,
0.23153237998485565,
-0.2782362103462219,
-0.3657073676586151,
0.07431871443986893,
0.04499400034546852,
-0.28888648748397827,
-0.39908531308174133,
0.17187409102916718,
-0.6048104166984558,
0.9511458277702332,
0.046728264540433884,
0.12357436120510101,
0.18764039874076843,
-0.41276636719703674,
-0.21675850450992584,
0.04672974348068237,
0.7949842810630798,
0.6424375772476196,
-0.15554557740688324,
-0.27520278096199036,
0.4444313049316406,
-0.5998865962028503,
0.2889951765537262,
-0.04127674177289009,
-0.12571799755096436,
0.05985182523727417,
0.24738574028015137,
0.9920410513877869,
0.6310668587684631,
-0.48808199167251587,
0.12654626369476318,
-0.02818167768418789,
-0.2896144688129425,
-0.7408796548843384,
0.2175637185573578,
-0.13357728719711304,
0.033760733902454376,
0.33438700437545776,
0.6199637055397034,
0.16123229265213013,
-0.24050603806972504,
0.7954068183898926,
0.0688367486000061,
-0.07620017975568771,
-0.20585986971855164,
0.7437161207199097,
0.2391495555639267,
-0.45282891392707825,
0.7013413906097412,
0.07014619559049606,
-0.49577951431274414,
0.2553889751434326,
0.3050924241542816,
0.8899623155593872,
-0.5943527221679688,
-0.16099144518375397,
0.47346511483192444,
-0.08914230018854141,
-0.379771888256073,
0.13214218616485596,
-0.06492861360311508,
-0.844376266002655,
-0.36124175786972046,
-0.5745993852615356,
-0.6969261765480042,
0.07786604762077332,
-0.6212971806526184,
0.2654695510864258,
-0.6385366320610046,
-0.09443849325180054,
0.2518862783908844,
-0.1821002960205078,
-0.5422146916389465,
0.4295605719089508,
0.25916674733161926,
0.7844859957695007,
-0.5234040021896362,
1.2424404621124268,
0.2578863203525543,
-0.09834165126085281,
-0.5613322257995605,
-0.1534837782382965,
0.3419472575187683,
-0.6232444643974304,
0.714746356010437,
-0.06742428988218307,
-0.328683078289032,
0.3335593044757843,
-0.33995383977890015,
-0.9941508769989014,
0.919106662273407,
0.07389818131923676,
-0.8873296976089478,
-0.21596059203147888,
-0.04786790534853935,
0.36066940426826477,
-0.2565433382987976,
-0.3688925504684448,
0.734532356262207,
0.13690805435180664,
0.2499314844608307,
-1.0545248985290527,
-0.4129387438297272,
-0.24374450743198395,
-0.022730020806193352,
-0.051979910582304,
-0.3908129930496216,
0.8317291140556335,
-0.3920969069004059,
-0.3234938383102417,
0.19170422852039337,
0.6622529029846191,
0.08949213474988937,
0.19779610633850098,
0.5897998809814453,
0.3788309395313263,
1.0438388586044312,
0.17275775969028473,
0.5771062970161438,
-0.3041427731513977,
0.19667698442935944,
1.7685011625289917,
-0.6228122115135193,
1.0432029962539673,
0.266092985868454,
-0.1385614573955536,
0.24360805749893188,
0.5972300171852112,
-0.06560682505369186,
0.5032359957695007,
0.23163123428821564,
-0.5277640223503113,
-0.20253124833106995,
0.26097428798675537,
-0.19971904158592224,
0.4234856367111206,
0.3981788158416748,
-0.026799006387591362,
0.23232857882976532,
0.35420095920562744,
0.043070368468761444,
0.08010360598564148,
-0.2420950084924698,
0.8878758549690247,
0.14391082525253296,
-0.48231226205825806,
0.7951295375823975,
-0.20102344453334808,
0.8696085810661316,
-0.7648376226425171,
-0.0265080314129591,
-0.14175929129123688,
0.2951242923736572,
-0.09512021392583847,
-0.2959771752357483,
0.508532702922821,
0.2592853903770447,
-0.22964446246623993,
-0.48293769359588623,
0.4453740119934082,
-0.5592048764228821,
-0.443911075592041,
-0.05544336140155792,
0.06749691069126129,
-0.021948253735899925,
-0.025783894583582878,
-0.7265860438346863,
0.25414109230041504,
0.0008226709323935211,
-0.0601167157292366,
0.08015622943639755,
0.21881039440631866,
0.049544934183359146,
0.8458192348480225,
0.7764267325401306,
0.3947950303554535,
0.21413646638393402,
0.14847218990325928,
0.8740947246551514,
-0.6111339330673218,
-0.6288666129112244,
-0.5296090245246887,
0.8645880222320557,
0.042561646550893784,
-0.2988075315952301,
0.5070691704750061,
0.3752776086330414,
0.9449868202209473,
-0.1452833116054535,
1.0360419750213623,
0.25493916869163513,
0.8178936839103699,
-0.7943491339683533,
0.9051252007484436,
-0.5191949009895325,
0.17856377363204956,
-0.23873722553253174,
-0.3841992914676666,
-0.6729897260665894,
0.5944311022758484,
-0.16498732566833496,
-0.08805838972330093,
0.6852051019668579,
0.708176851272583,
0.19856533408164978,
0.03839588165283203,
0.40068289637565613,
0.2806234061717987,
0.22608718276023865,
0.5570792555809021,
0.6401734948158264,
-0.48280373215675354,
-0.11288638412952423,
-0.3232386112213135,
-0.13309183716773987,
0.015101593919098377,
-0.6993266344070435,
-0.7230778336524963,
-0.7788777351379395,
-0.6664734482765198,
0.08918007463216782,
0.5900094509124756,
1.0206769704818726,
0.640359103679657,
-0.95644211769104,
-0.24127498269081116,
0.0967981293797493,
-0.21108511090278625,
-0.2268144190311432,
-0.051533859223127365,
0.327706903219223,
-0.45277464389801025,
-0.601538360118866,
0.8071265816688538,
0.14443057775497437,
0.05943910777568817,
0.13626918196678162,
-0.12096598744392395,
-0.2924937903881073,
-0.029565628618001938,
0.4883902668952942,
0.6250230669975281,
-0.6515250205993652,
-0.600730299949646,
-0.3033652901649475,
0.32188573479652405,
0.23266850411891937,
0.905175507068634,
-0.8016883134841919,
0.6701947450637817,
-0.014731960371136665,
0.8136690258979797,
0.35851532220840454,
0.0046095820143818855,
0.6739744544029236,
-0.7153407335281372,
0.15602457523345947,
0.2947104275226593,
0.3298245668411255,
0.5051421523094177,
-0.4776686728000641,
0.23101499676704407,
0.3569541573524475,
-0.831898033618927,
-0.7679218053817749,
-0.08616022020578384,
-0.8385531306266785,
0.0874161496758461,
0.8474488854408264,
-0.18904738128185272,
0.06821639090776443,
-0.3691745400428772,
-0.17366676032543182,
0.29978349804878235,
-0.2911205589771271,
0.5190942883491516,
0.34863752126693726,
-0.2806355059146881,
-0.13118751347064972,
-0.44113868474960327,
0.7430076003074646,
0.1625414788722992,
-0.5463140606880188,
0.3587598502635956,
0.7878942489624023,
0.5538093447685242,
-0.2474036067724228,
0.9953800439834595,
0.09024734050035477,
0.522153913974762,
0.019093424081802368,
0.21752873063087463,
-0.1522887796163559,
-0.7487714290618896,
-0.8423406481742859,
-0.11923705041408539,
0.2224753201007843,
-0.0975353941321373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17926v1 | FASA: a Flexible and Automatic Speech Aligner for Extracting High-quality Aligned Children Speech Data | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | 2024-06-25T20:37:16 | Dancheng Liu, Jinjun Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for adults' speeches has made significant
progress by employing deep neural network (DNN) models recently, but
improvement in children's speech is still unsatisfactory due to children's
speech's distinct characteristics. DNN models pre-trained on adult data often
struggle in generalizing children's speeches with fine tuning because of the
lack of high-quality aligned children's speeches. When generating datasets,
human annotations are not scalable, and existing forced-alignment tools are not
usable as they make impractical assumptions about the quality of the input
transcriptions. To address these challenges, we propose a new forced-alignment
tool, FASA, as a flexible and automatic speech aligner to extract high-quality
aligned children's speech data from many of the existing noisy children's
speech data. We demonstrate its usage on the CHILDES dataset and show that FASA
can improve data quality by 13.6$\times$ over human annotations. | [
-0.24896349012851715,
-0.3173534572124481,
-0.298299103975296,
0.031972192227840424,
-0.3536103069782257,
0.1343701034784317,
-0.006221413612365723,
-0.19814138114452362,
0.17517542839050293,
0.2187514305114746,
-0.626287043094635,
-0.10316711664199829,
-0.6939585208892822,
0.07343769818544388,
-0.6156628131866455,
0.6926771998405457,
-0.1194186881184578,
-0.0157775841653347,
-0.08538666367530823,
-0.07569205015897751,
-0.27751773595809937,
-0.0936608836054802,
-0.8717725276947021,
-0.18396219611167908,
0.4278724193572998,
0.6847250461578369,
1.0656481981277466,
1.0926494598388672,
0.3767993152141571,
0.2757752239704132,
-0.042978495359420776,
0.30435335636138916,
-0.11993952095508575,
0.4579693078994751,
-0.24987168610095978,
0.16759608685970306,
-0.825506329536438,
0.004318730905652046,
0.8347339630126953,
0.8091012239456177,
-0.3578324317932129,
0.1340402066707611,
0.2525468170642853,
0.8762646913528442,
-0.43761610984802246,
0.014150377362966537,
-0.5472214818000793,
-0.01825004443526268,
-0.3669920861721039,
0.40431877970695496,
0.02079307660460472,
-0.40907540917396545,
0.3713965117931366,
-0.6062411665916443,
0.1605348438024521,
-0.33704325556755066,
1.232329249382019,
0.7116451859474182,
-0.3389356732368469,
-0.363938570022583,
-0.6219931840896606,
0.5735068917274475,
-0.5269284248352051,
0.6700795888900757,
0.4718952476978302,
0.4391533136367798,
-0.24699532985687256,
-0.5252812504768372,
-0.7632271647453308,
0.08706957846879959,
0.025266049429774284,
-0.26095226407051086,
-0.39640992879867554,
-0.21900470554828644,
0.02342034876346588,
0.4618116021156311,
-0.6828542351722717,
0.25245124101638794,
-0.191557377576828,
-0.3263227343559265,
1.0581114292144775,
0.2294989377260208,
0.37926608324050903,
0.1489224135875702,
-0.18141208589076996,
-0.18485771119594574,
-0.5421236157417297,
0.09378664940595627,
0.32461321353912354,
0.6236073970794678,
-0.001290116342715919,
0.4354214072227478,
-0.385549932718277,
0.8822524547576904,
0.3340490162372589,
-0.2278345823287964,
0.4237842857837677,
-0.06427998840808868,
-0.3806827962398529,
0.23260127007961273,
0.7456285953521729,
0.07212425768375397,
0.4274958670139313,
-0.02977922186255455,
-0.4005436301231384,
0.305881142616272,
0.0394677110016346,
-0.5358443260192871,
-0.40511319041252136,
-0.11718465387821198,
-0.3198124170303345,
-0.19924578070640564,
0.21345674991607666,
-1.1604247093200684,
-0.5504917502403259,
-0.5473522543907166,
0.304418683052063,
-0.21571336686611176,
-0.18931914865970612,
-0.02089584246277809,
0.2030649483203888,
0.16457511484622955,
0.22639378905296326,
-0.9273229837417603,
0.5271945595741272,
0.5485748648643494,
0.6197724938392639,
-0.29349732398986816,
-0.10456320643424988,
-0.9527029991149902,
0.07403387874364853,
-0.3420064449310303,
0.5758236050605774,
-0.46381425857543945,
-0.17324164509773254,
-0.18074707686901093,
0.0026585771702229977,
-0.1776314079761505,
-0.560302734375,
0.6824949383735657,
-0.26381996273994446,
0.023659249767661095,
-0.014526559971272945,
-0.47848474979400635,
0.12678150832653046,
-0.5141769647598267,
-0.7539163827896118,
0.7559593319892883,
0.023840753361582756,
-0.15696582198143005,
0.7887970805168152,
-0.5182241201400757,
-0.7024325132369995,
-0.02247615158557892,
-0.32342052459716797,
-0.6681479811668396,
-0.068515345454216,
0.6311290860176086,
0.33552631735801697,
-0.3434903025627136,
0.6226276159286499,
-0.04681684821844101,
-0.2179597169160843,
0.2676819860935211,
-0.8968775868415833,
0.8043449521064758,
0.5631420016288757,
-0.5073056221008301,
0.15056264400482178,
-0.6969442367553711,
-0.2158983051776886,
0.1015239879488945,
-0.3659072816371918,
0.21484597027301788,
0.1386203020811081,
-0.07604339718818665,
0.27411603927612305,
0.2120538204908371,
-0.7695093154907227,
0.19443893432617188,
-0.43072304129600525,
0.3836464285850525,
0.5586637854576111,
-0.3042616844177246,
0.3237376809120178,
-0.48133593797683716,
0.4495161175727844,
-0.02503832057118416,
0.2729806900024414,
0.2115451693534851,
-0.5458053350448608,
-0.7970135807991028,
-0.46637383103370667,
0.5458930134773254,
0.3446386158466339,
-0.5571541786193848,
0.9140773415565491,
-0.5778273940086365,
-0.4410257041454315,
-1.018602967262268,
0.38107678294181824,
0.30199822783470154,
0.651345431804657,
0.29237669706344604,
-0.4026655852794647,
-0.7586671710014343,
-0.9214366674423218,
-0.11106552928686142,
0.00826254766434431,
-0.052927304059267044,
0.11986137181520462,
0.1072370633482933,
-0.10657449066638947,
1.1769407987594604,
-0.2822817265987396,
-0.4851331412792206,
0.17852436006069183,
0.15584416687488556,
0.017960453405976295,
0.7440385222434998,
0.295535683631897,
-0.8668326139450073,
-0.5624598860740662,
-0.25576964020729065,
-0.252760648727417,
-0.32612845301628113,
0.1368366777896881,
0.13197845220565796,
0.27119025588035583,
0.11099488288164139,
-0.35156768560409546,
0.5446480512619019,
0.7486896514892578,
-0.47884437441825867,
0.15686647593975067,
0.36046385765075684,
-0.016215594485402107,
-0.7578269243240356,
0.25900599360466003,
-0.12818361818790436,
-0.3393515944480896,
-0.6551304459571838,
-0.43320295214653015,
-0.07161739468574524,
-0.3206714391708374,
-0.29389849305152893,
0.4521366357803345,
-0.34783464670181274,
-0.039781056344509125,
-0.3747236132621765,
0.15078693628311157,
0.03452441096305847,
-0.09492872655391693,
-0.029498962685465813,
1.2353962659835815,
0.5514956116676331,
-0.3584327697753906,
0.43059808015823364,
0.4678802490234375,
-0.3405803143978119,
0.5425705313682556,
-0.47066619992256165,
0.42740631103515625,
0.0732349306344986,
0.4502565562725067,
-1.014438509941101,
-0.5783919095993042,
0.21509389579296112,
-0.6317841410636902,
0.6044344902038574,
0.022933319211006165,
-0.2183302938938141,
-0.4807690680027008,
0.07183821499347687,
0.05639554560184479,
0.33227118849754333,
-0.7887564897537231,
0.6213530898094177,
0.8703474402427673,
-0.4998207092285156,
-0.856592059135437,
-0.5720606446266174,
0.21372874081134796,
-0.027812523767352104,
-0.6964641213417053,
0.38343167304992676,
0.08650970458984375,
-0.02688569948077202,
0.12440337985754013,
-0.6140995025634766,
-0.5112396478652954,
0.04223357513546944,
0.23242932558059692,
0.2427491396665573,
-0.5800502896308899,
-0.034667789936065674,
0.38705167174339294,
-0.3223186135292053,
-0.33058488368988037,
-0.06354091316461563,
0.39795562624931335,
-0.2371380627155304,
-0.14558488130569458,
-1.0295610427856445,
0.3245435059070587,
0.7810195684432983,
-0.06180369481444359,
0.4221463203430176,
0.27624616026878357,
-0.7840431928634644,
0.07919678837060928,
-0.59275883436203,
0.12257428467273712,
-0.5233657956123352,
-0.084034264087677,
-0.29767054319381714,
-0.6961962580680847,
0.1630883812904358,
0.1648242175579071,
0.23667974770069122,
0.6870638728141785,
0.016139833256602287,
-0.24753865599632263,
1.2096771001815796,
0.042791757732629776,
-0.38157063722610474,
0.3634282052516937,
0.16182595491409302,
-0.22095803916454315,
-0.6321315765380859,
-0.16844980418682098,
-0.599444568157196,
-0.528184711933136,
0.07659345120191574,
-0.0007222460699267685,
-0.29748180508613586,
-0.13893181085586548,
-0.4594089686870575,
0.21442125737667084,
-0.9199680685997009,
0.373264878988266,
0.36579710245132446,
-0.13132324814796448,
0.019819917157292366,
0.12481029331684113,
0.3627600073814392,
-0.043189164251089096,
-0.42735394835472107,
-0.650734543800354,
0.6718058586120605,
0.3913270831108093,
0.8370897173881531,
0.26790252327919006,
0.49215084314346313,
0.18945100903511047,
0.31684407591819763,
-0.7645989656448364,
0.4548025131225586,
-0.97513747215271,
-0.7941910028457642,
-0.5277471542358398,
-0.33444973826408386,
-0.9976744651794434,
-0.12033291161060333,
-0.2711773216724396,
-0.7360602617263794,
0.7390801310539246,
0.41852784156799316,
-0.7200398445129395,
0.03504256531596184,
-0.5774354338645935,
0.42201435565948486,
-0.05649073049426079,
-0.030668631196022034,
0.22387123107910156,
-0.7664453983306885,
-0.06471040099859238,
-0.2045644074678421,
-0.13102762401103973,
-0.2976042926311493,
-0.15674680471420288,
1.1688141822814941,
-0.5134754180908203,
0.7841557264328003,
-0.5444333553314209,
-0.09698962420225143,
0.445604532957077,
0.004570974502712488,
0.2497073858976364,
-0.31265270709991455,
-0.16983282566070557,
0.12535108625888824,
-0.35752803087234497,
-0.19023999571800232,
-0.5516278147697449,
0.8390814661979675,
-0.8436989188194275,
-0.6602203845977783,
-0.40691685676574707,
-0.478878915309906,
-0.3282744586467743,
0.19939807057380676,
-0.002052695956081152,
0.33311983942985535,
0.14728009700775146,
0.5964998602867126,
0.39874300360679626,
0.3055458664894104,
0.34205737709999084,
0.32414743304252625,
0.19596511125564575,
-1.0151702165603638,
0.9683731198310852,
0.5951380133628845,
0.04167458042502403,
-0.16992586851119995,
0.33932793140411377,
-0.4978622794151306,
-0.3848744034767151,
-0.6085161566734314,
0.05450410023331642,
-0.4366080164909363,
-0.5365538001060486,
-0.29819199442863464,
-0.4305081367492676,
-0.6331706643104553,
-0.4674515724182129,
-0.47901180386543274,
-0.7981890439987183,
-0.46882447600364685,
-0.10492319613695145,
0.2888054847717285,
0.5281938910484314,
-0.11802490800619125,
0.5101068615913391,
-0.6362829208374023,
0.4524519145488739,
0.48590007424354553,
0.3774772882461548,
-0.043572038412094116,
-0.6867374181747437,
0.2243623584508896,
0.08328348398208618,
-0.16078214347362518,
-0.6934455633163452,
0.3536425530910492,
0.6623066663742065,
0.4838789999485016,
0.4794478714466095,
-0.008917470462620258,
1.1195411682128906,
-0.3262570798397064,
0.8652074933052063,
0.17861463129520416,
-1.2962398529052734,
0.49562138319015503,
-0.14933504164218903,
0.057699233293533325,
0.849506139755249,
0.049521349370479584,
-0.3289169669151306,
0.18395715951919556,
-0.46384793519973755,
-0.8808674812316895,
0.8719118237495422,
0.19592051208019257,
-0.13565793633460999,
0.3724876940250397,
0.3557036817073822,
0.41869860887527466,
0.0607365146279335,
-0.11534012854099274,
-0.2653690278530121,
-0.5579225420951843,
-0.8317669034004211,
-0.07163479179143906,
0.04231450706720352,
-0.1857783943414688,
-0.5857837200164795,
0.8237491846084595,
-0.04133055731654167,
0.07449472695589066,
0.16936831176280975,
-0.06304273754358292,
-0.47169530391693115,
0.00697379419580102,
0.4102664589881897,
0.2223292589187622,
0.06574579328298569,
0.09402797371149063,
0.08421146869659424,
-0.7069251537322998,
0.4529643952846527,
0.5144351720809937,
-0.21328109502792358,
-0.17511650919914246,
0.15394556522369385,
0.7777827382087708,
-0.07440584152936935,
-0.3332573473453522,
0.5372382402420044,
-0.15792739391326904,
-0.2772802710533142,
-0.2707611620426178,
0.36850306391716003,
-0.022845907136797905,
-0.0319051593542099,
0.6088671088218689,
0.05833182856440544,
-0.08605819195508957,
-0.05258087068796158,
0.8864200711250305,
0.1981208324432373,
-0.5533866286277771,
-0.08121679723262787,
0.7881154417991638,
0.49820631742477417,
-0.7423513531684875,
0.8005731701850891,
0.2222302407026291,
-0.06920907646417618,
0.4260244369506836,
0.5654098987579346,
1.0265930891036987,
-0.7665915489196777,
0.0864640548825264,
0.07258599251508713,
0.14812107384204865,
0.1288549304008484,
0.42054393887519836,
0.03301722928881645,
-0.6263538599014282,
-0.45922672748565674,
-0.5773979425430298,
-0.30031150579452515,
0.2611874043941498,
-0.8539186120033264,
0.22017766535282135,
-0.4686186611652374,
-0.2508241832256317,
0.38455140590667725,
0.07483040541410446,
-0.5701934695243835,
0.6273481249809265,
0.4119119942188263,
0.8521248698234558,
-0.9006857872009277,
0.9285005927085876,
0.5025553107261658,
-0.27051007747650146,
-0.8850383162498474,
0.2983270585536957,
0.40472912788391113,
-0.6096937656402588,
0.5434766411781311,
0.1208588257431984,
-0.576253354549408,
0.11375613510608673,
-0.5467032194137573,
-1.2082828283309937,
0.9430539608001709,
0.44450533390045166,
-0.7071328163146973,
0.14162112772464752,
0.26569053530693054,
0.3804562985897064,
-0.6347252130508423,
-0.4916413128376007,
0.6437393426895142,
0.5160934925079346,
0.07296887785196304,
-0.9956998229026794,
0.09431902319192886,
-0.30204087495803833,
-0.38822126388549805,
0.1805860549211502,
-0.4464954733848572,
0.5876867175102234,
0.2363356351852417,
-0.30055683851242065,
0.1001870259642601,
1.0563647747039795,
-0.0065450770780444145,
0.5820766091346741,
0.9948281049728394,
0.310944527387619,
1.0413005352020264,
-0.14814895391464233,
0.31660544872283936,
0.0739387795329094,
0.02080865576863289,
1.151831865310669,
-0.40010127425193787,
0.7760826945304871,
0.2529294192790985,
0.06769607216119766,
0.37480130791664124,
0.4046756625175476,
0.11529102921485901,
0.35486066341400146,
-0.1028861403465271,
-0.19901637732982635,
-0.21633173525333405,
-0.055667221546173096,
0.0013502556830644608,
0.5812415480613708,
0.8346635103225708,
-0.22540420293807983,
0.021636206656694412,
-0.21050848066806793,
0.07042622566223145,
0.0588366724550724,
-0.17754168808460236,
0.8406586647033691,
0.04672735556960106,
-0.5716294646263123,
0.7555426955223083,
-0.521552562713623,
0.5656543970108032,
-0.38145580887794495,
0.01680583320558071,
0.07102257013320923,
-0.013521990738809109,
-0.45707470178604126,
-0.8588842153549194,
0.6512211561203003,
0.29529130458831787,
0.020558906719088554,
-0.03209006413817406,
0.7272164821624756,
-0.39636096358299255,
-0.12881022691726685,
-0.06521657109260559,
0.1525200456380844,
0.04690852388739586,
0.36199724674224854,
-0.9377120733261108,
0.15025842189788818,
0.04765213280916214,
-0.3022943437099457,
0.05817454308271408,
0.1119244322180748,
0.08277979493141174,
0.5235835909843445,
0.7090354561805725,
-0.028107810765504837,
0.04304995760321617,
0.02673482522368431,
0.8270419836044312,
-0.40615174174308777,
-0.08905630558729172,
-0.6195541620254517,
0.6454305648803711,
-0.2928505539894104,
-0.6229502558708191,
0.34833794832229614,
0.5274525284767151,
0.3112486004829407,
0.2671438455581665,
0.4553528428077698,
0.016314784064888954,
0.7923736572265625,
-0.15123897790908813,
0.9740506410598755,
-0.5405001640319824,
-0.28659677505493164,
-0.2701077163219452,
-0.7166159152984619,
-0.6971904039382935,
1.0429670810699463,
-0.03747023642063141,
-0.2927861511707306,
0.2323763072490692,
0.6707009077072144,
-0.1867370754480362,
0.37475016713142395,
0.12401552498340607,
-0.062476206570863724,
0.5389736890792847,
0.0028224436100572348,
0.5786089301109314,
-0.28741031885147095,
0.48462802171707153,
-0.31227076053619385,
-0.458690345287323,
-0.12258985638618469,
-0.6896378397941589,
-0.26888689398765564,
-0.7462338805198669,
-0.4986664354801178,
-0.16668838262557983,
0.3304787576198578,
1.2401677370071411,
0.7772973775863647,
-1.0310893058776855,
-0.02017142064869404,
-0.038548003882169724,
-0.31325894594192505,
-0.46535882353782654,
-0.19227755069732666,
0.5554323196411133,
0.05128174647688866,
-0.8501015901565552,
1.065262794494629,
-0.1554899662733078,
0.14780957996845245,
0.05518719181418419,
-0.054344262927770615,
-0.13918712735176086,
0.3906913697719574,
0.06490251421928406,
0.516299307346344,
-0.6736668944358826,
-0.5120534896850586,
-0.14123862981796265,
-0.09583870321512222,
0.1630980521440506,
0.5163686871528625,
-0.6318556666374207,
0.5214175581932068,
0.2943026125431061,
0.8323029279708862,
0.18228821456432343,
0.2586662769317627,
0.6032441258430481,
-0.7644083499908447,
-0.15439262986183167,
0.5173996090888977,
0.3594829738140106,
0.5007984042167664,
-0.31285810470581055,
0.3972413241863251,
-0.034324705600738525,
-0.7210736274719238,
-0.9013032913208008,
0.10103684663772583,
-0.8539363145828247,
0.1522495299577713,
1.0353834629058838,
-0.16733412444591522,
-0.18599434196949005,
-0.5369886159896851,
-0.27578306198120117,
0.6772503852844238,
-0.8783870339393616,
0.6347824931144714,
0.6132232546806335,
-0.13632279634475708,
0.22708217799663544,
-0.08495169878005981,
0.573488712310791,
0.4000816345214844,
-0.405557781457901,
0.45330870151519775,
0.5971636176109314,
0.21931184828281403,
0.2460598200559616,
0.30449947714805603,
-0.1310126781463623,
0.29676705598831177,
0.048199113458395004,
-0.003083843272179365,
-0.24780365824699402,
-0.5858886241912842,
-0.7008821964263916,
0.2675224244594574,
-0.12885549664497375,
-0.49873727560043335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17923v1 | PAFT: A Parallel Training Paradigm for Effective LLM Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | 2024-06-25T20:11:37 | Shiva Kumar Pentyala, Zhichao Wang, Bin Bi, Kiran Ramnath, Xiang-Bo Mao, Regunathan Radhakrishnan, Sitaram Asur, Na, Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities in diverse
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. The LLMs generally undergo supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) followed by preference alignment to be usable in downstream
applications. However, this sequential training pipeline leads to alignment tax
that degrades the LLM performance.
This paper introduces PAFT, a new PArallel training paradigm for effective
LLM Fine-Tuning, which independently performs SFT and preference alignment
(e.g., DPO and ORPO, etc.) with the same pre-trained model on respective
datasets. The model produced by SFT and the model from preference alignment are
then merged into a final model by parameter fusing for use in downstream
applications. This work reveals important findings that preference alignment
like DPO naturally results in a sparse model while SFT leads to a natural dense
model which needs to be sparsified for effective model merging. This paper
introduces an effective interference resolution which reduces the redundancy by
sparsifying the delta parameters. The LLM resulted from the new training
paradigm achieved Rank #1 on the HuggingFace Open LLM Leaderboard.
Comprehensive evaluation shows the effectiveness of the parallel training
paradigm. | [
-0.7532851696014404,
-0.830024778842926,
0.41070476174354553,
0.24377824366092682,
-0.4195336401462555,
-0.0011390792205929756,
-0.5022855997085571,
-0.34490349888801575,
0.020601117983460426,
0.7587206959724426,
-0.4560105502605438,
-0.25613123178482056,
-0.8038557171821594,
0.08068611472845078,
-0.2474530190229416,
0.9813640713691711,
-0.2347663789987564,
0.1133686825633049,
0.0029399911873042583,
-0.25459104776382446,
-0.3691475987434387,
-0.46563786268234253,
-0.929909884929657,
-0.4661106467247009,
0.5386649370193481,
0.16381511092185974,
0.6920809149742126,
0.9689421653747559,
0.6412309408187866,
0.3442143499851227,
0.0017856773920357227,
0.4511154592037201,
-0.6006594896316528,
-0.11668571829795837,
-0.1528216004371643,
-0.35866913199424744,
-0.6856492161750793,
0.06828983128070831,
0.9340649247169495,
0.8826359510421753,
-0.19272437691688538,
-0.10884751379489899,
0.4046024680137634,
0.8983970284461975,
-0.4865029454231262,
0.01703796349465847,
-0.797559380531311,
-0.12504735589027405,
-0.27008506655693054,
-0.2599809467792511,
-0.16203683614730835,
-0.2689562141895294,
-0.002132491674274206,
-0.5139593482017517,
0.21404330432415009,
0.16541209816932678,
0.9899358153343201,
0.7356735467910767,
-0.3695228695869446,
0.10367882251739502,
-0.5620397329330444,
0.8022080063819885,
-0.7485167980194092,
0.5725720524787903,
0.10208238661289215,
0.23769192397594452,
-0.32744529843330383,
-0.38806894421577454,
-0.6525012850761414,
0.09693301469087601,
-0.02156801149249077,
-0.18444706499576569,
0.17533521354198456,
0.43137022852897644,
-0.04032003507018089,
0.5661341547966003,
-0.2807251811027527,
0.4605589509010315,
-0.05898009240627289,
0.04329846426844597,
0.5130253434181213,
0.11487802118062973,
-0.1587924361228943,
0.32854312658309937,
-0.5793522000312805,
-0.10726878046989441,
-0.5739525556564331,
-0.08779768645763397,
0.5134095549583435,
0.7079866528511047,
-0.11323020607233047,
0.3296349346637726,
-0.19901634752750397,
0.9328619837760925,
0.5027465224266052,
-0.4001777470111847,
0.2713984549045563,
-0.05004383251070976,
-0.47177010774612427,
0.02632087655365467,
0.8058487176895142,
0.20472772419452667,
0.20361827313899994,
-0.12343926727771759,
-0.27232375741004944,
-0.1723022162914276,
0.24373191595077515,
-0.4706043601036072,
0.05903908610343933,
0.09747444093227386,
-0.4306144118309021,
-0.25278058648109436,
-0.05583629757165909,
-0.6241556406021118,
-0.400704950094223,
-0.9807470440864563,
0.15507294237613678,
-0.3438619077205658,
-0.3310215175151825,
0.43966174125671387,
0.1737782061100006,
0.34558552503585815,
0.42607083916664124,
-1.2335190773010254,
0.4683707058429718,
1.122840166091919,
0.6500241160392761,
-0.46647825837135315,
-0.6949342489242554,
-0.7778937816619873,
0.06103542447090149,
-0.07656308263540268,
0.8131695985794067,
-0.41809239983558655,
-0.10887755453586578,
-0.1858365684747696,
-0.20971553027629852,
-0.29047805070877075,
-0.6223770380020142,
0.6955748200416565,
-0.45586711168289185,
-0.026387326419353485,
-0.2511994242668152,
-0.6513082385063171,
0.023286106064915657,
0.28462517261505127,
-0.376246839761734,
0.8288161158561707,
0.027412649244070053,
-0.6860659718513489,
0.5507934093475342,
-0.3918643891811371,
-0.04994067922234535,
-0.16091610491275787,
-0.06749088317155838,
-0.4639645218849182,
0.007763512898236513,
0.40531685948371887,
0.5233045220375061,
-0.3418586552143097,
0.44912096858024597,
-0.5261764526367188,
-0.4615107476711273,
-0.2971149981021881,
-0.314100444316864,
0.5364189743995667,
0.16671061515808105,
-0.10194969922304153,
0.23104941844940186,
-0.672640323638916,
-0.24803155660629272,
-0.14131313562393188,
-0.49568501114845276,
-0.14888553321361542,
-0.16766759753227234,
0.05027211830019951,
0.06979227811098099,
0.3239329159259796,
-0.40458887815475464,
0.36872410774230957,
-0.6265661120414734,
0.15042126178741455,
0.8303472399711609,
-0.15515106916427612,
0.698041558265686,
-0.4699563682079315,
0.2502248287200928,
-0.1617664098739624,
0.08208121359348297,
0.14178457856178284,
-0.21578210592269897,
-0.952129065990448,
-0.44517219066619873,
0.3794352114200592,
0.38735583424568176,
-0.14943329989910126,
0.7575284242630005,
-0.17900696396827698,
-0.4238722026348114,
-0.5914868116378784,
0.3638172745704651,
0.23336967825889587,
0.7849645018577576,
0.31146883964538574,
-0.23889730870723724,
-0.5010362267494202,
-0.8520022630691528,
-0.4038580358028412,
0.2037096470594406,
0.10760054737329483,
0.17872540652751923,
0.08648713678121567,
0.040163930505514145,
0.8095470070838928,
-0.21635474264621735,
-0.5598239898681641,
-0.05541399121284485,
0.29460132122039795,
0.37379807233810425,
0.6529893279075623,
0.5141223073005676,
-0.6903201341629028,
-0.604666531085968,
0.019092166796326637,
-0.38907068967819214,
-0.16997253894805908,
-0.19055305421352386,
-0.2117791622877121,
0.26988911628723145,
0.5263980627059937,
-0.4591964781284332,
-0.13878020644187927,
0.44640496373176575,
0.008688872680068016,
0.20861473679542542,
-0.1863946169614792,
0.1978731006383896,
-0.8481768369674683,
-0.028942741453647614,
-0.06445521116256714,
-0.29154038429260254,
-0.4141732156276703,
0.10451363772153854,
0.05215441808104515,
0.046254027634859085,
-0.46172523498535156,
0.4747028350830078,
-0.3444055914878845,
0.11923713237047195,
-0.5130460262298584,
-0.1194116398692131,
-0.22100485861301422,
0.5438730716705322,
0.13050223886966705,
0.6957433819770813,
0.3492087423801422,
-0.4345206618309021,
0.21351632475852966,
0.28370869159698486,
-0.08558738976716995,
0.49350041151046753,
-0.39050349593162537,
0.14627420902252197,
-0.13306522369384766,
0.20448508858680725,
-0.8022287487983704,
-0.25635847449302673,
0.0051091439090669155,
0.007362689357250929,
0.537621796131134,
-0.17653168737888336,
-0.7525813579559326,
0.0511467345058918,
-0.2277582734823227,
0.2648831605911255,
0.47930198907852173,
-0.7536327242851257,
0.4319564998149872,
0.3437926769256592,
-0.08167804032564163,
-0.6699402928352356,
-0.38808244466781616,
-0.21494603157043457,
-0.4808368384838104,
-0.6674073338508606,
0.5448218584060669,
0.20516268908977509,
0.12371253222227097,
-0.3431451618671417,
-0.09538301080465317,
-0.0430741012096405,
0.011196691542863846,
0.05373835936188698,
0.24361029267311096,
-0.22284647822380066,
-0.001456608297303319,
0.15379779040813446,
-0.1845855414867401,
-0.30123788118362427,
-0.06736889481544495,
0.7645009756088257,
-0.29262465238571167,
-0.3632669746875763,
-0.45768675208091736,
0.32466936111450195,
0.38082313537597656,
-0.35239407420158386,
0.763098955154419,
0.6501339077949524,
-0.19191958010196686,
-0.1307716965675354,
-0.8934155106544495,
-0.054077908396720886,
-0.4896849989891052,
0.1099545806646347,
-0.23078438639640808,
-1.2512933015823364,
0.26772186160087585,
-0.3980989456176758,
0.09877387434244156,
0.2332780361175537,
0.4266231060028076,
-0.12827034294605255,
0.9322705268859863,
0.9662683010101318,
-0.17300273478031158,
0.5401826500892639,
0.1305932104587555,
0.3079553246498108,
-0.723354697227478,
0.11733061075210571,
-0.378081351518631,
-0.45393314957618713,
-0.5975973606109619,
-0.34622883796691895,
0.3515992760658264,
0.6103129386901855,
-0.6109904646873474,
0.2798834443092346,
-0.42556384205818176,
0.6832640767097473,
0.5050988793373108,
-0.039977170526981354,
0.3368644714355469,
0.14806406199932098,
-0.07160426676273346,
-0.07249727100133896,
-0.49776285886764526,
-0.44510337710380554,
1.0037591457366943,
0.45785051584243774,
0.494903028011322,
-0.21778127551078796,
0.9610798358917236,
-0.2724805772304535,
0.07681511342525482,
-0.5515192747116089,
0.31692466139793396,
-0.5217494368553162,
-0.2244410365819931,
-0.3162861764431,
-0.20421142876148224,
-0.6291596293449402,
0.2754858732223511,
-0.36567431688308716,
-0.7426711916923523,
0.21208706498146057,
0.32058584690093994,
-0.3823101222515106,
0.4413646459579468,
-0.6489099264144897,
0.7525662779808044,
-0.17123588919639587,
-0.5610410571098328,
-0.25001803040504456,
-0.6133279204368591,
0.5054481625556946,
-0.3113766610622406,
-0.18922434747219086,
-0.3791597783565521,
-0.13755770027637482,
0.4361671805381775,
-0.48269233107566833,
0.7462902665138245,
-0.14232800900936127,
-0.004028812050819397,
-0.24496044218540192,
-0.26501157879829407,
0.643135130405426,
0.03861328959465027,
-0.19535905122756958,
0.2815767228603363,
-0.14842495322227478,
-0.3498480021953583,
-0.47322896122932434,
0.8392527103424072,
-0.7677801847457886,
-0.7000144124031067,
-0.28412389755249023,
-0.7329887747764587,
-0.6400139927864075,
0.22157716751098633,
0.05033865571022034,
-0.14129723608493805,
0.09334087371826172,
0.0520801916718483,
0.6859716773033142,
-0.13765066862106323,
0.1634334921836853,
0.4201813340187073,
-0.14748553931713104,
-0.40248003602027893,
0.6247429847717285,
-0.10466847568750381,
0.1868387758731842,
0.40116265416145325,
0.18435055017471313,
-0.2906278967857361,
-0.7969250679016113,
-0.09490776807069778,
0.468440979719162,
-0.3288702070713043,
-0.27571654319763184,
-0.6082091927528381,
-0.33031904697418213,
-0.38204628229141235,
-0.45174098014831543,
-0.6826280951499939,
-0.11062165349721909,
-0.17709456384181976,
0.19342443346977234,
0.2660228908061981,
0.35667189955711365,
-0.09154032915830612,
0.5561618208885193,
-0.7830764055252075,
0.3385920822620392,
0.22564570605754852,
0.7674227952957153,
-0.2768208980560303,
-0.3244006037712097,
0.02347119152545929,
-0.03513987734913826,
-0.332732230424881,
-0.3670831620693207,
0.35539674758911133,
0.169342041015625,
0.4894621968269348,
0.2513614594936371,
-0.07756052166223526,
0.8964700102806091,
-0.409006267786026,
0.4260382652282715,
0.27560311555862427,
-0.8809224367141724,
0.3897700607776642,
-0.7053028345108032,
0.2701159715652466,
0.8986584544181824,
0.33128419518470764,
-0.25146719813346863,
-0.2855445444583893,
-0.3650878965854645,
-0.8798007965087891,
0.787804901599884,
-0.09460954368114471,
-0.03262989595532417,
0.11457347124814987,
0.3526441156864166,
0.4885658323764801,
0.3346317410469055,
-0.47342875599861145,
-0.1378369778394699,
0.15157991647720337,
-0.13460715115070343,
-0.18219627439975739,
-0.1950276792049408,
-0.17197147011756897,
-0.47570180892944336,
0.7090628743171692,
-0.12090139091014862,
0.08652675151824951,
-0.05524791032075882,
0.24024076759815216,
-0.2304960936307907,
0.18172882497310638,
0.2234993427991867,
0.46194496750831604,
-0.4976077973842621,
-0.08301009982824326,
0.10456671565771103,
-0.1560482382774353,
-0.040933866053819656,
0.4110962152481079,
0.08216948062181473,
-0.3243955075740814,
0.1649829000234604,
0.7932100296020508,
0.23792411386966705,
-0.4319097697734833,
0.4356655478477478,
0.08489476889371872,
-0.4171540141105652,
-0.05740047246217728,
0.25726810097694397,
0.2055330127477646,
0.22037477791309357,
-0.07192769646644592,
0.37404853105545044,
0.016017574816942215,
-0.15109014511108398,
0.21205909550189972,
0.4270901083946228,
-0.11050920933485031,
0.14870940148830414,
0.6673046946525574,
0.3557727336883545,
-0.07017944753170013,
0.6198689341545105,
0.07881893962621689,
-0.3236263692378998,
0.3777395486831665,
0.36037757992744446,
0.6874182820320129,
-0.03140385448932648,
-0.13688893616199493,
0.3694409132003784,
0.06253420561552048,
-0.3437604606151581,
0.10412842780351639,
-0.1941860020160675,
-0.8004297614097595,
-0.5794828534126282,
-1.138725996017456,
-0.3931357264518738,
0.446831613779068,
-0.475019246339798,
0.6451709270477295,
-0.6679300665855408,
0.13965988159179688,
0.11804750561714172,
-0.03780970722436905,
-0.5952099561691284,
0.043128106743097305,
0.26187121868133545,
0.8564618229866028,
-0.7201535105705261,
1.1725670099258423,
0.612610399723053,
-0.19832536578178406,
-0.9201592206954956,
0.1233706995844841,
0.14853011071681976,
-0.6848928332328796,
0.5693947076797485,
0.1967286914587021,
-0.02583465911448002,
0.08206133544445038,
-0.2556072473526001,
-0.9708471298217773,
0.8860117197036743,
0.8842469453811646,
-0.8665928244590759,
0.10592734068632126,
0.4605693519115448,
0.5274784564971924,
-0.49767011404037476,
-0.11349515616893768,
0.9134197235107422,
0.43838849663734436,
0.018683910369873047,
-1.3226205110549927,
-0.11133869737386703,
-0.042407285422086716,
0.017961550503969193,
0.5365760922431946,
-0.9222308397293091,
0.831014096736908,
0.277782142162323,
-0.018369201570749283,
0.02641192637383938,
0.4172057509422302,
0.40350815653800964,
0.018964366987347603,
0.7595593333244324,
0.7937760353088379,
0.6726123690605164,
-0.18149951100349426,
0.7167600393295288,
-0.27008020877838135,
0.3362748324871063,
1.4165385961532593,
-0.4096185564994812,
1.0354868173599243,
0.906255304813385,
-0.2746065557003021,
-0.15131230652332306,
0.6146701574325562,
-0.07804830372333527,
0.49929991364479065,
0.09416761249303818,
-0.1568758338689804,
-0.3950548768043518,
-0.11867425590753555,
-0.44790446758270264,
0.6229860782623291,
0.08741699904203415,
-0.23041404783725739,
-0.4424801170825958,
0.013470739126205444,
-0.1658383458852768,
0.37542587518692017,
-0.20219993591308594,
0.7972357273101807,
0.0006409800844267011,
-0.775019645690918,
0.7827303409576416,
0.0025851575192064047,
1.0720233917236328,
-0.6215665936470032,
0.00712096132338047,
-0.23265723884105682,
0.4075829088687897,
-0.1735960990190506,
-0.5690770745277405,
0.5873490571975708,
-0.14591094851493835,
-0.22087059915065765,
-0.5780353546142578,
0.5417526364326477,
-0.5097307562828064,
-0.2183140516281128,
0.38419681787490845,
0.2718815505504608,
-0.06372614204883575,
-0.23942622542381287,
-0.761589527130127,
0.1186954602599144,
-0.09303739666938782,
-0.0919414758682251,
0.6995424628257751,
0.12145642936229706,
0.1895449161529541,
0.34829890727996826,
0.7090978026390076,
0.22237837314605713,
0.057291075587272644,
0.10057663917541504,
0.8244227766990662,
-0.3143472373485565,
-0.4597817361354828,
-0.665316104888916,
0.37393954396247864,
-0.11658383905887604,
-0.40826642513275146,
0.48156553506851196,
0.5417296290397644,
1.0140851736068726,
0.04239455983042717,
0.5503024458885193,
0.1611098051071167,
0.6330686211585999,
-0.5998817086219788,
0.6917339563369751,
-0.599496603012085,
0.48186272382736206,
-0.09463661909103394,
-1.0848402976989746,
-0.3756062388420105,
0.3267287313938141,
-0.47707799077033997,
-0.09389054030179977,
0.5664205551147461,
0.798604428768158,
-0.41123437881469727,
0.10485042631626129,
0.2671874761581421,
-0.02665499970316887,
0.10803675651550293,
0.49624988436698914,
0.44884395599365234,
-0.3479869067668915,
0.23489275574684143,
-0.5458451509475708,
-0.25847387313842773,
-0.07758761197328568,
-0.9211756587028503,
-0.7668167948722839,
-0.5988978743553162,
-0.2132541835308075,
0.11367294192314148,
0.1519976109266281,
1.0407904386520386,
0.8141170144081116,
-0.7439755201339722,
-0.3025966286659241,
-0.5929480195045471,
-0.15627135336399078,
-0.2125508040189743,
-0.21004316210746765,
0.3457696735858917,
-0.8782435059547424,
-0.9390398859977722,
0.3515760898590088,
0.3740285038948059,
0.005877279210835695,
0.07395336776971817,
-0.12492984533309937,
-0.38948023319244385,
-0.14582787454128265,
0.2802262008190155,
0.14903561770915985,
-0.8662369847297668,
-0.12492877244949341,
-0.44056424498558044,
0.01813436485826969,
0.3446715176105499,
0.7658283114433289,
-0.6376344561576843,
0.4238518178462982,
0.4743458032608032,
0.9773511290550232,
0.46145865321159363,
0.07755876332521439,
0.9396774172782898,
-0.7239139080047607,
0.31601375341415405,
0.07679513841867447,
0.38233453035354614,
0.3332572281360626,
-0.5159429907798767,
0.4496617913246155,
0.008067955262959003,
-0.66094571352005,
-0.791705310344696,
0.09843506664037704,
-1.2638081312179565,
-0.1839679479598999,
0.9551271200180054,
0.007196003571152687,
0.006761551834642887,
0.09237303584814072,
-0.33365437388420105,
0.331963449716568,
-0.4485437273979187,
0.7144472002983093,
0.6722443699836731,
-0.41452139616012573,
-0.29535624384880066,
-0.25442251563072205,
0.7021474838256836,
0.7812513709068298,
-0.666874349117279,
0.17109128832817078,
0.2128065973520279,
0.17117741703987122,
-0.16656319797039032,
0.4991917014122009,
-0.14031697809696198,
0.048408616334199905,
-0.0622187964618206,
-0.16884039342403412,
-0.3377384841442108,
-0.025922054424881935,
-0.5880179405212402,
0.33751818537712097,
0.282541960477829,
-0.10167347639799118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17911v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17911v2 | X-ray Made Simple: Radiology Report Generation and Evaluation with Layman's Terms | 2024-06-25T19:52:01 | 2024-06-30T21:53:56 | Kun Zhao, Chenghao Xiao, Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kai Ye, Noura Al Moubayed, Liang Zhan, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology Report Generation (RRG) has achieved significant progress with the
advancements of multimodal generative models. However, the evaluation in the
domain suffers from a lack of fair and robust metrics. We reveal that, high
performance on RRG with existing lexical-based metrics (e.g. BLEU) might be
more of a mirage - a model can get a high BLEU only by learning the template of
reports. This has become an urgent problem for RRG due to the highly
patternized nature of these reports. In this work, we un-intuitively approach
this problem by proposing the Layman's RRG framework, a layman's terms-based
dataset, evaluation and training framework that systematically improves RRG
with day-to-day language. We first contribute the translated Layman's terms
dataset. Building upon the dataset, we then propose a semantics-based
evaluation method, which is proved to mitigate the inflated numbers of BLEU and
provides fairer evaluation. Last, we show that training on the layman's terms
dataset encourages models to focus on the semantics of the reports, as opposed
to overfitting to learning the report templates. We reveal a promising scaling
law between the number of training examples and semantics gain provided by our
dataset, compared to the inverse pattern brought by the original formats. Our
code is available at \url{https://github.com/hegehongcha/LaymanRRG}. | [
-0.03533591702580452,
-0.2678206264972687,
0.510005533695221,
0.007082429248839617,
-0.5086983442306519,
-0.1735842525959015,
-0.15501351654529572,
-0.3655175268650055,
0.042311739176511765,
0.4502323269844055,
-0.3512403666973114,
-0.5828126668930054,
-1.00180983543396,
-0.04081493616104126,
-0.18618889153003693,
1.2005326747894287,
0.23430323600769043,
0.28795138001441956,
-0.10199912637472153,
-0.342963844537735,
-0.5207580327987671,
0.10211832076311111,
-0.4955597519874573,
-0.6619811654090881,
0.4188094139099121,
0.426815003156662,
1.2325917482376099,
1.2486343383789062,
0.8681780099868774,
0.09259439259767532,
0.3692221939563751,
-0.038368988782167435,
-0.3536542057991028,
-0.03410925716161728,
0.07295216619968414,
-0.3848905861377716,
-0.525383472442627,
0.08164230734109879,
0.4090842008590698,
0.9795319437980652,
-0.465925395488739,
0.08243884146213531,
-0.39814066886901855,
0.9980746507644653,
-0.8437640070915222,
0.1883964091539383,
-0.26114633679389954,
0.2549231946468353,
-0.16218248009681702,
-0.8337001204490662,
-0.6660614013671875,
-0.43760374188423157,
0.19276130199432373,
-0.7736555337905884,
0.1872040033340454,
0.10498304665088654,
1.0576224327087402,
0.170578733086586,
-0.4508674740791321,
-0.6120069622993469,
-0.5764612555503845,
0.6794026494026184,
-0.5009061098098755,
0.4069126844406128,
0.2622535526752472,
0.6497570276260376,
0.09061668068170547,
-1.0061880350112915,
-0.04427071288228035,
-0.431123286485672,
-0.33003419637680054,
0.590699315071106,
-0.33939892053604126,
0.030758032575249672,
0.4387342631816864,
0.365669310092926,
-0.983566164970398,
-0.10201610624790192,
-0.3782930076122284,
0.1901678889989853,
0.7536155581474304,
0.2748836576938629,
0.24121105670928955,
-0.6044873595237732,
-0.7001557946205139,
-0.3782844543457031,
-0.6517597436904907,
-0.5018303394317627,
-0.10437537729740143,
0.258971631526947,
-0.24451300501823425,
0.403230220079422,
-0.23667265474796295,
0.6912389993667603,
-0.23177824914455414,
-0.2761061489582062,
0.508399486541748,
-0.02343844808638096,
-0.38114553689956665,
0.16351158916950226,
0.7199994921684265,
0.4695297181606293,
0.051529411226511,
-0.27350741624832153,
-0.26808053255081177,
0.3062129318714142,
0.23131659626960754,
-0.7460054755210876,
-0.33238494396209717,
0.08500547707080841,
-0.8454286456108093,
-0.45104581117630005,
-0.018352540209889412,
-0.7016742825508118,
-0.31120890378952026,
-0.32278043031692505,
0.6171285510063171,
-0.5792106986045837,
-0.18330921232700348,
0.5658939480781555,
-0.13025574386119843,
0.2881389856338501,
0.2859019339084625,
-0.36122703552246094,
0.18650609254837036,
0.5389456748962402,
0.699167013168335,
0.2623346149921417,
0.06322398781776428,
-0.9645612835884094,
0.34029850363731384,
-0.3184279799461365,
0.866640567779541,
-0.6018422245979309,
-0.6006252765655518,
-0.16916728019714355,
-0.5089903473854065,
-0.08825589716434479,
-0.41703563928604126,
0.5702897906303406,
-0.2939588129520416,
0.6499137878417969,
0.057393878698349,
-0.5165780186653137,
0.0481269434094429,
0.06284704059362411,
-0.4322963356971741,
0.5998867750167847,
0.21515394747257233,
-0.8043937087059021,
0.777490496635437,
-0.6943259239196777,
-0.5098525881767273,
0.5744558572769165,
-0.6726356744766235,
-0.388682097196579,
0.16124281287193298,
0.08814087510108948,
0.5138530731201172,
-0.6900267004966736,
0.21056441962718964,
0.2623787820339203,
-0.22303029894828796,
0.052103180438280106,
-0.1152006983757019,
0.5125208497047424,
0.4016575217247009,
-0.16632747650146484,
0.03309549018740654,
-0.9963980317115784,
0.46784844994544983,
-0.06803914159536362,
-0.2196141630411148,
-0.3795166313648224,
-0.020911281928420067,
-0.16139012575149536,
0.19348043203353882,
-0.23445835709571838,
-0.45687517523765564,
-0.10084027051925659,
-0.18477007746696472,
0.03582536429166794,
0.4558837115764618,
-0.28567683696746826,
0.18722812831401825,
-0.8194270133972168,
0.8060634732246399,
-0.05073089152574539,
0.0677943006157875,
-0.39300015568733215,
-0.29850396513938904,
-0.5829698443412781,
-0.6400331854820251,
0.45948290824890137,
0.43670302629470825,
-0.6007832288742065,
0.08152075856924057,
-0.9253029823303223,
-0.5060423612594604,
-0.40665203332901,
-0.1662730723619461,
0.5692868232727051,
0.5592136383056641,
0.15203528106212616,
-0.6405701041221619,
-0.6339512467384338,
-0.8328372836112976,
-0.15601594746112823,
0.03726218268275261,
-0.16011099517345428,
0.23848366737365723,
0.12252634763717651,
-0.1080845445394516,
0.8119876980781555,
-0.865538477897644,
-0.5737915635108948,
-0.2979000508785248,
0.559191882610321,
0.15972521901130676,
0.24071665108203888,
0.2613915801048279,
-0.7862920165061951,
-0.4026844799518585,
0.2062436193227768,
-1.1280262470245361,
-0.04724464192986488,
-0.11561891436576843,
-0.0789099931716919,
0.2043088674545288,
0.6682766675949097,
-0.4268167316913605,
0.4179662764072418,
0.40391379594802856,
-0.21451543271541595,
0.3206472396850586,
-0.3486633896827698,
0.12361510097980499,
-0.8830309510231018,
0.19325891137123108,
0.26561519503593445,
-0.48269662261009216,
-0.42993369698524475,
0.31128987669944763,
0.030393002554774284,
-0.2651464641094208,
-0.30439215898513794,
0.39705148339271545,
-0.4338742792606354,
-0.11025261133909225,
-0.14714325964450836,
0.21109209954738617,
0.15577104687690735,
0.18191708624362946,
0.3209975063800812,
0.18666715919971466,
0.5619578957557678,
-0.4994506239891052,
0.06024613231420517,
0.22717000544071198,
-0.25569745898246765,
0.5672801733016968,
-0.5962526202201843,
0.09739480912685394,
-0.44808587431907654,
0.2836040258407593,
-0.6013202667236328,
-0.2062375247478485,
0.13744455575942993,
-0.4996987581253052,
0.43634331226348877,
-0.310505211353302,
-0.11503176391124725,
-0.007464603520929813,
-0.35672706365585327,
0.28435441851615906,
0.7828635573387146,
-0.3941897451877594,
0.667811930179596,
0.09850577265024185,
0.1354645937681198,
-0.5946745276451111,
-0.5945663452148438,
0.17692717909812927,
-0.14125341176986694,
-0.8759589791297913,
0.2859453558921814,
0.047561075538396835,
-0.2808491587638855,
0.04665077477693558,
-0.11327467113733292,
0.10222582519054413,
-0.23811976611614227,
0.3384263813495636,
0.1697477251291275,
-0.5467949509620667,
-0.025629272684454918,
-0.4135088622570038,
-0.4428289234638214,
0.14300858974456787,
-0.14740221202373505,
0.4452427923679352,
-0.16769450902938843,
-0.18879079818725586,
-0.03642583265900612,
0.23262642323970795,
0.247941255569458,
0.02105005271732807,
0.10795360803604126,
0.48004186153411865,
-0.19488106667995453,
-0.22565609216690063,
-0.15500181913375854,
0.10531754046678543,
-0.4169543385505676,
0.3846961557865143,
-0.33837372064590454,
-0.41527843475341797,
0.11780168116092682,
-0.1575387865304947,
0.05227658897638321,
0.2641600966453552,
0.5662298798561096,
-0.08942250162363052,
0.8356539607048035,
0.5631212592124939,
0.6113660335540771,
0.010945804417133331,
-0.24293799698352814,
0.22305814921855927,
-0.5676639080047607,
-0.5115708112716675,
-0.44537270069122314,
0.07314388453960419,
-0.7316154837608337,
-0.24309301376342773,
0.5269458293914795,
-0.1502312272787094,
0.2897600829601288,
-0.06417921930551529,
-0.43755489587783813,
0.36557042598724365,
0.11985352635383606,
0.166902557015419,
0.4843287169933319,
0.05164346843957901,
0.30333560705184937,
-0.157530277967453,
-1.1383038759231567,
-0.5677683353424072,
1.3036643266677856,
0.432801216840744,
1.0501917600631714,
0.05753781646490097,
0.8284720778465271,
0.4441300928592682,
0.36415061354637146,
-0.9726311564445496,
0.4421592354774475,
-0.6377498507499695,
-0.07828076183795929,
-0.04859079420566559,
-0.6274896860122681,
-1.1657557487487793,
0.37028390169143677,
-0.055820368230342865,
0.020827069878578186,
-0.002314650919288397,
0.13518857955932617,
-0.42936503887176514,
-0.12114521861076355,
-0.6105912923812866,
0.5356302261352539,
-0.28589147329330444,
-0.1343296766281128,
-0.32633882761001587,
-0.6747429966926575,
0.4539666473865509,
0.19416822493076324,
0.5737042427062988,
-0.19345085322856903,
0.10956619679927826,
0.8103387355804443,
-0.5234351754188538,
0.5490686893463135,
-0.0202210433781147,
-0.015671230852603912,
-0.07874690741300583,
0.27973026037216187,
0.14546309411525726,
0.3045625388622284,
0.1937319040298462,
0.009155118837952614,
0.08019211143255234,
-0.4890081286430359,
-0.6602563261985779,
0.5115548968315125,
-0.703353226184845,
-0.30107906460762024,
-0.8113892674446106,
-0.7356969714164734,
-0.21974340081214905,
0.038524821400642395,
0.5393825173377991,
0.7359163165092468,
-0.09962794184684753,
-0.018496183678507805,
0.5938838124275208,
-0.18446241319179535,
0.1304069459438324,
0.3887626826763153,
-0.18681329488754272,
-0.28488707542419434,
1.0216565132141113,
0.02209223434329033,
0.206059068441391,
0.39089635014533997,
0.4970620572566986,
0.020187046378850937,
-0.4190972149372101,
-0.5043134093284607,
0.10407765954732895,
-0.9363232851028442,
-0.4672386944293976,
-0.4521214962005615,
-0.22137458622455597,
-0.11294425278902054,
-0.2769968807697296,
-0.1489647924900055,
-0.4975319802761078,
0.1710469275712967,
0.3400309383869171,
0.29248011112213135,
0.7783548831939697,
-0.3031233549118042,
0.3941318988800049,
-0.6854186654090881,
0.3048625588417053,
0.10805195569992065,
0.38459938764572144,
-0.1534375101327896,
-0.4798465371131897,
-0.33885809779167175,
-0.08095251768827438,
-0.08720754832029343,
-0.32678961753845215,
0.4674225449562073,
0.22396092116832733,
0.2399589568376541,
0.25353193283081055,
-0.20201776921749115,
0.6507500410079956,
-0.32837536931037903,
0.31837356090545654,
0.6760421395301819,
-0.7670890688896179,
0.6089775562286377,
-0.5127876400947571,
0.2659459114074707,
0.3911801874637604,
0.32775041460990906,
-0.6648362874984741,
-0.0780327171087265,
-0.7432107925415039,
-1.0423365831375122,
0.6871707439422607,
0.04441166669130325,
0.03053172491490841,
-0.12247347086668015,
0.47495710849761963,
0.28468069434165955,
0.04495938867330551,
-0.5954492688179016,
-0.16006158292293549,
-0.5027912855148315,
-0.14190571010112762,
0.25504615902900696,
-0.3201981782913208,
-0.6006106734275818,
0.16095249354839325,
0.5191555619239807,
-0.3041612505912781,
0.33866313099861145,
0.14070597290992737,
-0.34545159339904785,
-0.26524654030799866,
0.2591198980808258,
0.5829507112503052,
1.0705626010894775,
-0.5539963841438293,
0.2981524169445038,
-0.2603086531162262,
-0.5069522261619568,
-0.000019256058294558898,
-0.17788243293762207,
0.08511842042207718,
0.2933417856693268,
0.6992311477661133,
0.7137002348899841,
0.19772368669509888,
-0.6043550968170166,
0.7087740898132324,
-0.23256759345531464,
-0.44784530997276306,
-0.2531126141548157,
0.09019402414560318,
-0.34826719760894775,
-0.21982285380363464,
0.5002862811088562,
0.1426510214805603,
0.06662558764219284,
-0.38850003480911255,
0.5096938014030457,
0.22776202857494354,
-0.49986717104911804,
0.058089304715394974,
0.33855414390563965,
0.118796706199646,
0.014295767061412334,
0.48025745153427124,
-0.268498957157135,
-0.023946257308125496,
0.5258973836898804,
0.49903708696365356,
0.5602860450744629,
0.19335034489631653,
0.447939932346344,
0.33748382329940796,
0.17968177795410156,
-0.22906561195850372,
0.21924492716789246,
0.4238075017929077,
-0.549981415271759,
-0.6185967326164246,
-0.37899720668792725,
-0.2149432748556137,
0.21185985207557678,
-1.057233214378357,
0.5805597901344299,
-0.8451693058013916,
0.11026337742805481,
0.10033374279737473,
-0.11007792502641678,
-0.5594336986541748,
0.7359381318092346,
0.1267298012971878,
0.9489570260047913,
-0.6306440830230713,
0.49615827202796936,
0.649116039276123,
-0.4762810170650482,
-0.7695604562759399,
-0.040562812238931656,
-0.24969281256198883,
-1.0780391693115234,
0.9619690775871277,
0.036226965487003326,
-0.19546043872833252,
-0.22172008454799652,
-0.1748548150062561,
-0.6869058609008789,
1.1755279302597046,
0.3589564263820648,
-0.5221468210220337,
-0.057333000004291534,
0.16321206092834473,
0.4403088688850403,
-0.4883183538913727,
0.47279244661331177,
0.3669383227825165,
0.32371318340301514,
0.3111773729324341,
-0.6960450410842896,
0.2432544082403183,
-0.05699073523283005,
0.04165942594408989,
0.20215432345867157,
-0.5024183988571167,
0.5173763632774353,
-0.31949594616889954,
-0.28951942920684814,
-0.303670197725296,
0.5392991900444031,
0.19041767716407776,
0.3728451728820801,
0.32869893312454224,
0.7840911746025085,
0.5863152742385864,
-0.10916019976139069,
1.449558973312378,
-0.22967423498630524,
0.32554423809051514,
1.0631866455078125,
-0.3189471364021301,
0.28259047865867615,
0.14217539131641388,
0.12202869355678558,
0.5976854562759399,
0.22232678532600403,
-0.15118597447872162,
0.6315317749977112,
0.1713046282529831,
-0.04413725435733795,
-0.3869877755641937,
-0.12982022762298584,
-0.3914833068847656,
0.6933295130729675,
0.13914626836776733,
-0.36501258611679077,
-0.625297486782074,
-0.031085936352610588,
0.14644519984722137,
0.1368039846420288,
-0.35619914531707764,
0.6168144345283508,
0.2862231433391571,
-0.33368900418281555,
0.8217071294784546,
0.22798433899879456,
0.5789015293121338,
-0.952377438545227,
-0.031158447265625,
-0.2449146807193756,
-0.007089994382113218,
-0.6438784599304199,
-0.5453272461891174,
0.44167155027389526,
-0.30092933773994446,
-0.1199382096529007,
-0.18362842500209808,
0.41700464487075806,
-0.1842224895954132,
-0.382565438747406,
0.15111704170703888,
0.6683865785598755,
-0.016933830454945564,
0.5219396352767944,
-0.53948575258255,
0.057821039110422134,
-0.017966095358133316,
-0.0936816856265068,
0.4759025573730469,
0.3566673696041107,
-0.18191450834274292,
0.8048198223114014,
0.45137226581573486,
0.2509866952896118,
-0.211669459939003,
0.31708651781082153,
0.6443264484405518,
-0.5443577766418457,
-0.4521937072277069,
-0.6924687027931213,
0.37119901180267334,
0.22351156175136566,
-0.35773712396621704,
0.5254958271980286,
0.681647777557373,
0.6815324425697327,
0.1609562188386917,
1.0179911851882935,
-0.2694912850856781,
0.21697500348091125,
-0.8408765196800232,
0.6219615936279297,
-0.38683751225471497,
0.28366824984550476,
-0.22779731452465057,
-0.4655698537826538,
-0.6195927858352661,
0.7356967926025391,
-0.2802014946937561,
0.16981177031993866,
0.8692749738693237,
0.7174058556556702,
-0.2845316529273987,
0.004986717365682125,
0.6243290901184082,
0.07956381142139435,
0.2362915575504303,
0.4452568590641022,
0.7367115020751953,
-0.5572947859764099,
0.6633372902870178,
-0.048299647867679596,
-0.3270614743232727,
-0.1316453367471695,
-1.0389907360076904,
-0.5801680684089661,
-0.3235454559326172,
-0.7815769910812378,
-0.733461856842041,
0.36814963817596436,
0.8358669281005859,
0.9292712807655334,
-0.27320417761802673,
-0.46233195066452026,
0.06917079538106918,
-0.17478123307228088,
0.026316121220588684,
-0.20669889450073242,
0.6148550510406494,
-0.33753567934036255,
-0.1652735322713852,
0.20761291682720184,
0.4101146459579468,
-0.24279654026031494,
0.01581941545009613,
-0.2269223928451538,
0.17521606385707855,
-0.05690780282020569,
0.569299042224884,
0.14177824556827545,
-0.18282783031463623,
-0.23865710198879242,
-0.21892520785331726,
-0.20361477136611938,
0.43741390109062195,
1.0727896690368652,
-0.9879674315452576,
0.32521235942840576,
0.18163838982582092,
0.3261311948299408,
0.4543682932853699,
-0.1499701887369156,
0.5878236293792725,
-0.8273432850837708,
0.10015683621168137,
0.31167301535606384,
0.2163269966840744,
0.40126368403434753,
-0.46443694829940796,
0.6820241808891296,
0.14970944821834564,
-0.2722141742706299,
-0.9214881062507629,
0.35182616114616394,
-1.0146111249923706,
-0.25543156266212463,
1.1073952913284302,
-0.08550439774990082,
-0.07445099204778671,
0.028788724914193153,
0.11346268653869629,
0.04987885802984238,
-0.2954093813896179,
0.834168553352356,
0.14210572838783264,
-0.5415371656417847,
-0.16883864998817444,
-0.4628581702709198,
0.6993264555931091,
0.5740711092948914,
-0.7654444575309753,
-0.007150618359446526,
0.5652288198471069,
0.5851085782051086,
0.1640421599149704,
0.8497382402420044,
-0.36387985944747925,
0.8086028099060059,
-0.1002439334988594,
0.11412344872951508,
-0.2085186094045639,
-0.07084435969591141,
-0.5703011155128479,
0.2415386587381363,
0.32254913449287415,
0.0797695443034172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17903v1 | Mapping the Past: Geographically Linking an Early 20th Century Swedish Encyclopedia with Wikidata | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | 2024-06-25T19:34:00 | Axel Ahlin, Alfred Myrne, Pierre Nugues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | In this paper, we describe the extraction of all the location entries from a
prominent Swedish encyclopedia from the early 20th century, the \textit{Nordisk
Familjebok} `Nordic Family Book.' We focused on the second edition called
\textit{Uggleupplagan}, which comprises 38 volumes and over 182,000 articles.
This makes it one of the most extensive Swedish encyclopedias. Using a
classifier, we first determined the category of the entries. We found that
approximately 22 percent of them were locations. We applied a named entity
recognition to these entries and we linked them to Wikidata. Wikidata enabled
us to extract their precise geographic locations resulting in almost 18,000
valid coordinates. We then analyzed the distribution of these locations and the
entry selection process. It showed a higher density within Sweden, Germany, and
the United Kingdom. The paper sheds light on the selection and representation
of geographic information in the \textit{Nordisk Familjebok}, providing
insights into historical and societal perspectives. It also paves the way for
future investigations into entry selection in different time periods and
comparative analyses among various encyclopedias. | [
-0.8020813465118408,
-0.17350350320339203,
0.5950043797492981,
-0.2342545986175537,
-0.254249632358551,
-0.2982544004917145,
0.010765878483653069,
-0.6268104910850525,
0.428836464881897,
0.4017137289047241,
-0.4985426664352417,
-0.7034978270530701,
-0.2859763503074646,
0.08391129225492477,
-0.19170130789279938,
0.4429605007171631,
-0.23589661717414856,
0.054218631237745285,
-0.30988189578056335,
-0.34986612200737,
-0.005015913397073746,
-0.8026396036148071,
-0.18751803040504456,
-0.2715482711791992,
0.72543865442276,
0.3504689931869507,
0.7679354548454285,
0.8406205177307129,
0.21421124041080475,
0.299079954624176,
-0.37198272347450256,
0.17667822539806366,
-0.47767719626426697,
0.3849942088127136,
-0.5263538956642151,
-0.5104530453681946,
-0.16669924557209015,
-0.22921380400657654,
0.6185879707336426,
0.7899681925773621,
0.1943977326154709,
0.1990719884634018,
-0.16351954638957977,
0.7643042802810669,
-0.4778542220592499,
-0.14118747413158417,
-0.17611919343471527,
0.11248359829187393,
-0.5008954405784607,
-0.3168242871761322,
-0.2215246707201004,
-0.2296282798051834,
0.1524256318807602,
-0.6554701328277588,
0.5366945862770081,
0.26392772793769836,
0.9398280382156372,
-0.12484364211559296,
-0.6986402869224548,
-0.38908126950263977,
-0.8627685904502869,
0.6141688823699951,
-0.05251292511820793,
0.7103036642074585,
0.5359681844711304,
0.14153744280338287,
-0.6123319268226624,
-0.4268220067024231,
-0.3934575617313385,
0.19890372455120087,
-0.03209233656525612,
-0.0962919071316719,
-0.12021055072546005,
-0.4040871560573578,
0.24337138235569,
-0.0025058055762201548,
-0.5462862849235535,
0.13895376026630402,
-0.7585789561271667,
-0.13970912992954254,
0.7393806576728821,
0.3064725399017334,
0.4212704002857208,
-0.48325273394584656,
-0.39328086376190186,
-0.22118262946605682,
-0.8967469930648804,
-0.11489007622003555,
0.6687353253364563,
-0.02494759112596512,
0.07514508068561554,
0.6890787482261658,
-0.1735721081495285,
0.6639143228530884,
0.03941752389073372,
-0.1666642725467682,
0.18418742716312408,
-0.47902846336364746,
0.31928157806396484,
-0.06787744909524918,
0.41240063309669495,
0.7121064066886902,
0.14653053879737854,
-0.21564874053001404,
-0.09587540477514267,
-0.9545429348945618,
0.4553224742412567,
-0.1336420774459839,
-0.43055978417396545,
-0.09200187772512436,
-0.8390464186668396,
-0.07115910947322845,
0.14457832276821136,
-0.8240157961845398,
-0.5074295401573181,
-0.20333899557590485,
-0.09605516493320465,
-0.026402292773127556,
-0.30672550201416016,
-0.5160118341445923,
-0.4637484550476074,
0.2063392698764801,
0.26181480288505554,
-1.0901248455047607,
-0.009271014481782913,
0.6688828468322754,
1.0001049041748047,
-0.34382641315460205,
-0.40619006752967834,
0.4473778307437897,
0.30267003178596497,
-0.44162338972091675,
1.0280765295028687,
-0.03435710445046425,
-0.722237765789032,
0.14730028808116913,
0.11616414785385132,
0.4616038501262665,
-0.3476818799972534,
0.2668886184692383,
-0.9043769240379333,
0.1926208883523941,
-0.41176384687423706,
-0.15475955605506897,
-0.35149452090263367,
0.033506982028484344,
-1.0029675960540771,
1.2022809982299805,
0.5447492599487305,
-0.7183220386505127,
0.6621577739715576,
-0.44071975350379944,
-0.40712228417396545,
0.08686927706003189,
-0.10687361657619476,
0.11552155762910843,
0.15628056228160858,
0.14490999281406403,
0.1779620349407196,
-0.09827841818332672,
0.060619596391916275,
-0.4108121395111084,
-0.2274509221315384,
-0.10108374804258347,
-0.1635182946920395,
1.405091404914856,
0.28458189964294434,
-0.1472221165895462,
-0.4470449388027191,
-0.6729640960693359,
-0.3299035429954529,
0.037456247955560684,
-0.5041769742965698,
-1.019636631011963,
-0.13151915371418,
-0.001018686918541789,
0.35594111680984497,
0.5358165502548218,
-0.3571780025959015,
0.5974400043487549,
-0.322178453207016,
-0.1475173979997635,
0.48483291268348694,
0.22950215637683868,
0.8290581107139587,
-0.021532313898205757,
0.554832935333252,
-0.2100922018289566,
0.4131481647491455,
0.1998383104801178,
-0.6756003499031067,
-0.535043478012085,
0.1364050805568695,
0.6727855205535889,
0.4574252665042877,
-0.5747559666633606,
0.5379696488380432,
-0.6516104936599731,
-0.6133757829666138,
-0.19991980493068695,
-0.07672709971666336,
-0.4374009072780609,
0.31830763816833496,
-0.019299406558275223,
-0.07390666753053665,
-0.7472758293151855,
-0.8218895792961121,
0.2204219549894333,
-0.438385009765625,
-0.39933690428733826,
0.52616286277771,
0.5538604855537415,
-0.10403083264827728,
0.8113254308700562,
-0.6119115948677063,
-0.009980179369449615,
0.2971843183040619,
-0.028081664815545082,
0.3296562433242798,
0.08040301501750946,
0.8613364696502686,
-1.23070228099823,
-0.39247334003448486,
0.2230784147977829,
-0.5414869785308838,
-0.047217804938554764,
0.027180669829249382,
-0.6998893022537231,
0.41204142570495605,
0.2081606686115265,
-0.479512482881546,
0.5932947397232056,
0.22157081961631775,
-0.5977911353111267,
0.3804965913295746,
-0.3638717830181122,
0.4325399398803711,
-0.9624505043029785,
0.33631858229637146,
-0.6484833359718323,
-0.04255363345146179,
-0.06525526195764542,
-0.19203320145606995,
0.1887120008468628,
0.013745569624006748,
-0.3194079101085663,
0.6319619417190552,
-0.6146782636642456,
-0.1122371181845665,
0.23054718971252441,
0.1235428899526596,
-0.19353730976581573,
0.16912055015563965,
-0.15520089864730835,
0.42423108220100403,
-0.03335045650601387,
-0.2633662223815918,
0.5876127481460571,
0.44242241978645325,
-0.345440536737442,
0.7136462330818176,
0.2648150324821472,
0.06336379051208496,
-0.1889132857322693,
0.15637564659118652,
-1.0527560710906982,
-0.2586762011051178,
0.10995125770568848,
-0.5467173457145691,
0.291697233915329,
-0.2569032609462738,
-0.4571790099143982,
-0.3990386724472046,
-0.15260910987854004,
0.1524554044008255,
0.2758377194404602,
-0.675257682800293,
0.9524283409118652,
0.7824676632881165,
-0.6904701590538025,
-0.6966408491134644,
-0.25531700253486633,
0.21954897046089172,
-0.054719436913728714,
-0.4791020452976227,
0.06013143062591553,
0.038058217614889145,
-0.2801566421985626,
0.41502732038497925,
-0.3175191283226013,
-0.38661274313926697,
0.25323283672332764,
0.472160279750824,
0.5924835205078125,
-0.18254993855953217,
0.11766590923070908,
0.1360996514558792,
-0.06720937788486481,
0.06578381359577179,
-0.3870480954647064,
0.4417295455932617,
0.6383637189865112,
0.2472294718027115,
0.10969228297472,
0.8945844769477844,
0.5483018159866333,
0.15361005067825317,
0.8182582855224609,
0.07413026690483093,
-0.5240265130996704,
0.04980514198541641,
-0.4433462619781494,
0.22453822195529938,
-0.3874703049659729,
0.08242148160934448,
-0.3094424605369568,
-0.5760947465896606,
0.5099979043006897,
-0.15817399322986603,
0.06504750996828079,
1.024102807044983,
0.32085564732551575,
-0.6774309873580933,
0.5562912821769714,
0.48828697204589844,
-0.057484220713377,
0.4450535476207733,
-0.21994662284851074,
0.16230295598506927,
-0.48703545331954956,
-0.731475830078125,
-0.7782810926437378,
-0.4838397204875946,
-0.5099650025367737,
-0.06926374137401581,
0.38036590814590454,
0.18647439777851105,
-0.08909358829259872,
0.1839587390422821,
-0.21134081482887268,
0.5413592457771301,
0.5823556184768677,
-0.20493289828300476,
0.29369333386421204,
0.3802793323993683,
-0.346727192401886,
-0.12205324321985245,
-0.8204335570335388,
-0.4123108685016632,
1.2744991779327393,
0.1275203824043274,
0.4556674063205719,
0.3445550799369812,
0.9096544981002808,
0.34961023926734924,
0.5919185280799866,
-0.47424307465553284,
0.22664906084537506,
-0.24359512329101562,
-1.107775330543518,
-0.43728208541870117,
-0.04648011550307274,
-1.0064822435379028,
0.047487907111644745,
-0.31710919737815857,
-0.5710283517837524,
0.8386938571929932,
-0.07175955921411514,
-0.4436149597167969,
0.12589578330516815,
-0.5301828980445862,
0.5077542066574097,
-0.3107076585292816,
0.06984613835811615,
0.051167912781238556,
-0.8927910327911377,
-0.05404181778430939,
-0.18427446484565735,
0.4522833228111267,
0.3728739023208618,
-0.1522766500711441,
0.8946742415428162,
-0.16770854592323303,
0.5474020838737488,
-0.212435781955719,
-0.1995394080877304,
0.027728227898478508,
0.2398349642753601,
0.2268422544002533,
-0.2742984890937805,
0.035733021795749664,
0.5617175698280334,
0.32742300629615784,
-0.23257146775722504,
-0.6296462416648865,
1.0634818077087402,
-0.7267104983329773,
-0.31557056307792664,
-0.44198745489120483,
-0.34754323959350586,
0.21931636333465576,
0.6251786947250366,
0.44045960903167725,
0.49593499302864075,
-0.10245256870985031,
0.3771180808544159,
0.7256236672401428,
0.2613286077976227,
0.1736910492181778,
0.37163782119750977,
-0.24959047138690948,
-0.5679359436035156,
0.477981835603714,
0.918042004108429,
-0.30415406823158264,
0.44419851899147034,
-0.056613489985466,
-0.6183359622955322,
-0.6224370002746582,
-0.1739671379327774,
0.2913307845592499,
-1.0589240789413452,
-0.16859376430511475,
-0.6205520033836365,
0.16246449947357178,
-0.4397748112678528,
-0.4949161112308502,
-0.006993747781962156,
-0.5082601308822632,
-0.36454087495803833,
-0.20242802798748016,
0.08400402218103409,
0.9584483504295349,
-0.4448342025279999,
0.12204299867153168,
-0.4389229714870453,
0.33189377188682556,
-0.022446099668741226,
0.26422083377838135,
0.06507103890180588,
0.15452830493450165,
-0.3966130316257477,
-0.2884467840194702,
0.10216578841209412,
-1.1549021005630493,
0.08902745693922043,
-0.2041264772415161,
0.6056700348854065,
0.3417775630950928,
0.1000087559223175,
0.4365726411342621,
-0.7147224545478821,
0.96694016456604,
0.05275798961520195,
-0.11827997118234634,
0.2559353709220886,
-0.29477789998054504,
0.2873929440975189,
0.6279116272926331,
0.795200526714325,
-0.5814675688743591,
0.07929827272891998,
-0.7990984320640564,
-1.3143662214279175,
0.2271476835012436,
-0.4162198305130005,
-0.09111101180315018,
0.009807606227695942,
0.6443972587585449,
0.3524625301361084,
-0.175058051943779,
-0.17154651880264282,
-0.5878389477729797,
0.037711095064878464,
-0.2772766649723053,
-0.1255195587873459,
-0.495330810546875,
-0.24083955585956573,
-0.4116213023662567,
0.5257959365844727,
0.39011523127555847,
0.19973811507225037,
0.33887144923210144,
-0.41522255539894104,
-0.04344678297638893,
-0.12168557196855545,
0.4426349699497223,
1.0028326511383057,
-0.018140273168683052,
0.3072717487812042,
0.13828933238983154,
-0.9383713603019714,
0.1650496870279312,
0.06122739240527153,
-0.6229684948921204,
0.63138747215271,
0.47672751545906067,
0.5077129602432251,
0.5076030492782593,
-0.1991804838180542,
0.3857055902481079,
0.131446972489357,
0.11159563809633255,
-0.7723873853683472,
0.05906295403838158,
0.13016696274280548,
0.6077777147293091,
0.8648268580436707,
-0.39286088943481445,
0.24702408909797668,
-0.03560229018330574,
0.21962206065654755,
0.2854646146297455,
0.04494331777095795,
-0.025282755494117737,
0.5876316428184509,
0.2579568028450012,
-0.5457127094268799,
0.5928639769554138,
-0.006926260888576508,
-0.4985324442386627,
0.32822391390800476,
0.30582016706466675,
0.5676442384719849,
-0.35829123854637146,
0.1717536747455597,
0.6018190383911133,
0.4409516453742981,
0.10401418805122375,
0.3079628050327301,
-0.3750068247318268,
-0.3169346749782562,
0.06917664408683777,
-0.5874341130256653,
-0.029384750872850418,
-0.041912741959095,
-0.592769205570221,
0.11670491844415665,
0.02358393743634224,
-0.32174497842788696,
-0.11454134434461594,
0.23084285855293274,
-1.2060165405273438,
0.11010463535785675,
0.05239660292863846,
1.1306416988372803,
-0.8502061367034912,
0.45412465929985046,
0.5754222273826599,
0.1469426155090332,
-0.29165899753570557,
-0.1432085931301117,
0.15577051043510437,
-0.4252745807170868,
0.7982069253921509,
-0.563531219959259,
-0.1866362988948822,
0.03617037087678909,
-0.5838090181350708,
-0.9716755747795105,
1.2455538511276245,
-0.33354148268699646,
-0.47873449325561523,
-0.36740848422050476,
-0.3162175714969635,
0.446125328540802,
-0.4245297610759735,
-0.2225961834192276,
0.5163560509681702,
0.5100802779197693,
-0.29093268513679504,
-0.60273277759552,
-0.20852313935756683,
-0.13880042731761932,
0.10673180222511292,
0.5667955279350281,
0.046930838376283646,
0.5619648098945618,
-0.13994501531124115,
-0.4570123851299286,
0.12714700400829315,
0.5396642684936523,
-0.28916382789611816,
0.17348416149616241,
0.40871068835258484,
0.34184530377388,
0.9896678328514099,
-0.209622323513031,
1.1464768648147583,
0.10286062955856323,
0.48392948508262634,
0.9229869246482849,
-0.0007868651882745326,
0.9613606929779053,
0.7335699200630188,
-0.3710298240184784,
0.5008162260055542,
0.9512129426002502,
-0.07827128469944,
0.8870755434036255,
-0.28392407298088074,
-0.2685226798057556,
0.20239056646823883,
0.12195348739624023,
-0.3547384738922119,
0.22781185805797577,
0.3082459568977356,
-0.5158583521842957,
-0.49672964215278625,
0.058164771646261215,
0.21430934965610504,
-0.5204529166221619,
-0.3330512046813965,
0.8509371280670166,
-0.24697373807430267,
-0.4553850591182709,
0.39825868606567383,
-0.45761987566947937,
0.19968359172344208,
-0.6524830460548401,
-0.07643019407987595,
-0.34434768557548523,
-0.4129692316055298,
-0.13056127727031708,
-0.931614339351654,
0.14083683490753174,
-0.24844689667224884,
-0.5465328097343445,
0.03726127743721008,
0.7101100087165833,
-0.4759000837802887,
-0.19646991789340973,
0.08528737723827362,
0.24904505908489227,
0.3603802025318146,
0.519816517829895,
-0.01264183595776558,
0.0770719051361084,
0.03696679323911667,
-0.453734815120697,
0.13438107073307037,
0.522454023361206,
-0.13901586830615997,
0.15150059759616852,
0.6935858726501465,
0.21881620585918427,
0.10202285647392273,
-0.5983442664146423,
0.46478143334388733,
-0.9107009768486023,
-0.8139501810073853,
-0.588927686214447,
0.4826604127883911,
-0.5088367462158203,
-0.5714008212089539,
0.766577422618866,
0.7039365172386169,
1.0616310834884644,
-0.20500800013542175,
0.711033284664154,
-0.26049304008483887,
0.3759823739528656,
-0.2770008444786072,
1.1286351680755615,
-0.49441400170326233,
-0.3407950699329376,
0.2323833554983139,
-0.9954478144645691,
-0.4472617506980896,
0.6721137762069702,
-0.33229759335517883,
-0.44366690516471863,
0.5861287117004395,
0.42275917530059814,
-0.030479082837700844,
-0.0901196300983429,
0.1266189068555832,
0.3493022620677948,
-0.07365009933710098,
-0.04908803477883339,
0.6581852436065674,
0.00902422796934843,
0.2509308159351349,
-0.48099803924560547,
-0.37418463826179504,
-0.5770635604858398,
-0.8714504837989807,
-0.45647913217544556,
-1.1652876138687134,
0.17147323489189148,
-0.45471644401550293,
0.0804215520620346,
0.8111853003501892,
0.30786147713661194,
-0.6632677316665649,
0.015955237671732903,
0.9232687950134277,
0.4138108491897583,
-0.08615368604660034,
-0.13117611408233643,
0.6458140015602112,
0.43298476934432983,
-0.4034627676010132,
0.3254754841327667,
0.30603542923927307,
0.17189492285251617,
-0.45128580927848816,
0.033428970724344254,
-0.21590390801429749,
-0.19373902678489685,
0.4621756970882416,
0.3803977966308594,
-0.49128106236457825,
-0.47566819190979004,
0.015989059582352638,
-0.1770199090242386,
0.11250324547290802,
0.8429493308067322,
-0.4515000581741333,
0.7583216428756714,
0.7285807132720947,
0.2792556583881378,
0.576360285282135,
-0.16411493718624115,
0.43499886989593506,
-0.4597058892250061,
0.13328136503696442,
0.05423767864704132,
0.18181723356246948,
0.20064128935337067,
-0.6731112003326416,
0.44987747073173523,
0.26854372024536133,
-0.5114977359771729,
-0.8800361752510071,
-0.1348828822374344,
-0.6523331999778748,
-0.2610461115837097,
0.9945564866065979,
0.13862061500549316,
-0.7520555257797241,
-0.6923323273658752,
-0.33243897557258606,
0.3213300406932831,
-0.03311782330274582,
0.9104011654853821,
1.4587101936340332,
-0.1327284723520279,
0.18577736616134644,
-0.9674240350723267,
0.24219997227191925,
-0.46125853061676025,
-0.4163219630718231,
-0.3480289876461029,
0.7870347499847412,
0.5646784901618958,
0.48323190212249756,
0.46751561760902405,
-0.23623457551002502,
0.3115968108177185,
0.152049258351326,
0.25678277015686035,
-0.029126007109880447,
-0.6193422079086304,
-0.30773383378982544,
0.4368302822113037,
-0.18339267373085022,
-0.06546683609485626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17901v1 | Script-Agnostic Language Identification | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | 2024-06-25T19:23:42 | Milind Agarwal, Joshua Otten, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language identification is used as the first step in many data collection and
crawling efforts because it allows us to sort online text into
language-specific buckets. However, many modern languages, such as Konkani,
Kashmiri, Punjabi etc., are synchronically written in several scripts.
Moreover, languages with different writing systems do not share significant
lexical, semantic, and syntactic properties in neural representation spaces,
which is a disadvantage for closely related languages and low-resource
languages, especially those from the Indian Subcontinent. To counter this, we
propose learning script-agnostic representations using several different
experimental strategies (upscaling, flattening, and script mixing) focusing on
four major Dravidian languages (Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, and Malayalam). We find
that word-level script randomization and exposure to a language written in
multiple scripts is extremely valuable for downstream script-agnostic language
identification, while also maintaining competitive performance on naturally
occurring text. | [
-0.17450286448001862,
-0.4003174304962158,
0.42491719126701355,
0.26736581325531006,
-0.15428103506565094,
0.8313109278678894,
-0.5646413564682007,
-0.40534019470214844,
0.36401474475860596,
0.016471533104777336,
-0.526140034198761,
-0.3095567524433136,
-0.4527174234390259,
0.28321078419685364,
-0.4742719233036041,
0.5789197683334351,
-0.374157190322876,
-0.05256979539990425,
0.17450323700904846,
-0.4007411003112793,
-0.32632505893707275,
-0.4910982847213745,
-0.3677283227443695,
-0.1678096354007721,
0.4664250612258911,
0.12494849413633347,
0.682800829410553,
1.1546802520751953,
0.2810424864292145,
0.44473811984062195,
0.31772950291633606,
0.14847125113010406,
-0.017306668683886528,
0.14482980966567993,
-0.14975605905056,
-0.7728129625320435,
0.3832973837852478,
0.16450786590576172,
0.8300101161003113,
0.7261560559272766,
-0.41222500801086426,
0.35103839635849,
-0.5057450532913208,
0.3475070893764496,
-0.7169740200042725,
0.30765217542648315,
-0.5630951523780823,
0.305242657661438,
-0.6699814200401306,
-0.16178283095359802,
-0.2763994038105011,
-0.652911365032196,
0.13998663425445557,
-0.56678307056427,
0.1926143616437912,
-0.13643953204154968,
0.7555493116378784,
0.20826603472232819,
-0.004887429066002369,
-0.7328111529350281,
-1.0026423931121826,
0.8918634057044983,
-0.3452660143375397,
0.1872880905866623,
0.3540988862514496,
0.4467969834804535,
0.11789713054895401,
-0.27345672249794006,
-0.9526097774505615,
-0.061960916966199875,
-0.15374858677387238,
0.19534513354301453,
0.0993897095322609,
-0.1880294382572174,
0.11934500932693481,
0.5580698847770691,
-0.3984270989894867,
0.15919926762580872,
-0.34150299429893494,
-0.5774865746498108,
0.3415446877479553,
0.10909479111433029,
0.6157695055007935,
-0.12929563224315643,
-0.26092106103897095,
-0.3091141879558563,
-0.2694331109523773,
0.17679168283939362,
0.731181800365448,
0.41447845101356506,
0.002461307216435671,
0.4907723367214203,
0.17683610320091248,
0.7812649607658386,
0.05053681507706642,
-0.33629757165908813,
0.22402362525463104,
-0.3526630103588104,
-0.07865246385335922,
0.14122667908668518,
0.5503000020980835,
-0.16069690883159637,
0.4350563585758209,
-0.17134159803390503,
0.0015439747367054224,
0.7281233668327332,
0.23568269610404968,
-0.2841850817203522,
0.023473398759961128,
0.0128222880885005,
-0.19973984360694885,
-0.3152223825454712,
-0.19248339533805847,
-0.9077318906784058,
-0.6549834609031677,
-0.32235583662986755,
0.2626834511756897,
-0.7320243120193481,
-0.689934253692627,
-0.19261828064918518,
-0.3398992121219635,
0.7383320927619934,
0.24550454318523407,
-1.2345761060714722,
0.35967692732810974,
0.2540121376514435,
0.6219146847724915,
-0.2462662309408188,
-0.5592629909515381,
-0.09082463383674622,
0.18677294254302979,
-0.43477797508239746,
0.6726847887039185,
-1.015284538269043,
-0.24608585238456726,
0.14497996866703033,
-0.3354744613170624,
-0.2956770956516266,
-0.3627218008041382,
0.06868423521518707,
-0.6034743189811707,
0.29326653480529785,
0.009488798677921295,
-0.256801575422287,
-0.1282276213169098,
-0.09899032860994339,
-0.4160054624080658,
0.819085419178009,
0.4872265160083771,
-0.666195809841156,
0.5042622685432434,
-0.09715891629457474,
-0.41203927993774414,
0.09440334886312485,
-0.6546618342399597,
-0.301996111869812,
0.30243268609046936,
-0.22197787463665009,
0.1320178061723709,
0.07583414018154144,
-0.05870281904935837,
-0.0881817415356636,
-0.26563793420791626,
0.1541135609149933,
-0.5153692960739136,
0.5229017734527588,
0.5617012977600098,
-0.2011423259973526,
0.002733207307755947,
-0.9766705632209778,
0.21097064018249512,
0.15215538442134857,
-0.2900928556919098,
-0.5553370714187622,
-0.26126155257225037,
-0.016508392989635468,
0.12361171096563339,
0.2241867482662201,
-0.6567623615264893,
0.26400354504585266,
-0.3752709925174713,
0.278057724237442,
0.821682333946228,
-0.3874281048774719,
0.5382619500160217,
-0.1039048433303833,
0.5463951230049133,
0.2357780635356903,
-0.25536614656448364,
-0.337321937084198,
-0.17717792093753815,
-0.7297625541687012,
-0.543874979019165,
0.3679729402065277,
0.5922632217407227,
-0.6408342123031616,
-0.23056884109973907,
-0.11317287385463715,
-0.4612455666065216,
-0.8683469295501709,
0.39206603169441223,
0.6121722459793091,
0.15590813755989075,
0.15955263376235962,
-0.4581243097782135,
-0.6744906902313232,
-0.7843726873397827,
-0.46356475353240967,
-0.1451593041419983,
-0.0047852941788733006,
-0.14996083080768585,
0.06128041446208954,
-0.2366843819618225,
0.8789133429527283,
-0.3486420512199402,
-0.2545919716358185,
-0.40950390696525574,
0.15973025560379028,
0.13563217222690582,
0.043079957365989685,
0.5733785033226013,
-0.6732734441757202,
-0.8964492082595825,
0.19932469725608826,
-0.623510479927063,
-0.055165618658065796,
-0.11730389297008514,
0.3025193214416504,
0.42203301191329956,
0.48519542813301086,
-0.3400830030441284,
0.6140022873878479,
0.5160368084907532,
0.05917659401893616,
0.39758917689323425,
-0.5975574254989624,
-0.035923708230257034,
-1.0379424095153809,
-0.08094505220651627,
-0.0909058004617691,
-0.05583721026778221,
-0.7158409357070923,
0.11096588522195816,
0.3449682593345642,
-0.17306847870349884,
-0.18268704414367676,
0.5310067534446716,
-0.7766169309616089,
0.08807769417762756,
-0.21015124022960663,
0.13770771026611328,
-0.39738908410072327,
0.5737988948822021,
0.3114278018474579,
0.9969642758369446,
0.8188088536262512,
-0.42079323530197144,
0.17889127135276794,
-0.00009670203871792182,
-0.13277935981750488,
0.3448390066623688,
-0.26227182149887085,
0.010174522176384926,
-0.4268513023853302,
-0.01563413254916668,
-1.032691478729248,
-0.51644366979599,
0.004803320858627558,
-0.5621680617332458,
0.6686370968818665,
-0.08486902713775635,
-0.31751036643981934,
-0.18686631321907043,
-0.2571954131126404,
0.3602532148361206,
0.6000372171401978,
-0.31626570224761963,
0.6343381404876709,
0.6481138467788696,
0.0715157687664032,
-0.7373659014701843,
-0.7031534314155579,
-0.17315246164798737,
-0.4532507061958313,
-0.008676469326019287,
-0.04076535254716873,
0.16519218683242798,
-0.25292202830314636,
-0.3286077380180359,
-0.38215500116348267,
-0.14548476040363312,
-0.20228907465934753,
0.25544530153274536,
0.22269786894321442,
0.02045394480228424,
0.0362907238304615,
-0.0941120907664299,
-0.3541208505630493,
-0.2534893751144409,
-0.4571619927883148,
0.6001402735710144,
-0.1682390570640564,
-0.4697902500629425,
-0.40249741077423096,
0.5588627457618713,
0.6056818962097168,
-0.345098078250885,
0.5753030180931091,
0.9253724217414856,
-0.4073297083377838,
-0.195771723985672,
-0.4957629144191742,
0.21554440259933472,
-0.46976613998413086,
0.020311245694756508,
-0.550724446773529,
-0.5924915671348572,
0.8628671169281006,
-0.334192156791687,
-0.31170353293418884,
0.4289086163043976,
0.7972315549850464,
0.2567228674888611,
0.8786516189575195,
0.8498076796531677,
-0.3079894483089447,
0.49002790451049805,
0.007384689059108496,
0.18645519018173218,
-0.46539172530174255,
0.003932730760425329,
-0.653928816318512,
0.030694512650370598,
-0.8661134243011475,
-0.3849717378616333,
-0.017017636448144913,
-0.16304616630077362,
0.14811712503433228,
0.6894551515579224,
-0.48665350675582886,
0.6039862632751465,
0.557238757610321,
-0.290566623210907,
0.1921878159046173,
0.25803834199905396,
-0.6893782019615173,
-0.027821650728583336,
-0.34762296080589294,
-0.471930593252182,
1.0624526739120483,
0.18499426543712616,
0.786345362663269,
0.32035818696022034,
0.8920799493789673,
0.285025030374527,
0.07427669316530228,
-0.4013732969760895,
0.3109440803527832,
-0.04427587613463402,
-0.657596230506897,
-0.22753694653511047,
-0.29883792996406555,
-0.8272250890731812,
0.2081332504749298,
0.06098422780632973,
-0.9439107775688171,
0.3071955740451813,
-0.15979786217212677,
-0.469496488571167,
0.11647984385490417,
-1.201606035232544,
0.3937757909297943,
0.02989373542368412,
-0.3591247498989105,
-0.3202255070209503,
-0.6983809471130371,
-0.02656448446214199,
-0.27884441614151,
0.42775946855545044,
0.10880224406719208,
-0.08008279651403427,
0.3603077232837677,
-0.32639840245246887,
0.8420488238334656,
-0.06641113013029099,
0.12124232947826385,
0.3678848147392273,
0.12578189373016357,
0.19642288982868195,
0.20876173675060272,
-0.1056598648428917,
0.04058225080370903,
0.12126070261001587,
-0.6522494554519653,
-0.3870353698730469,
0.731296718120575,
-1.217280387878418,
-0.43280935287475586,
-0.8643186092376709,
-0.2953662574291229,
-0.08506117761135101,
0.7177626490592957,
0.08463694155216217,
0.5670725703239441,
0.07957679033279419,
-0.38116076588630676,
0.734957218170166,
-0.14089031517505646,
0.6779910326004028,
0.528788685798645,
-0.24798442423343658,
-0.36080724000930786,
1.0339949131011963,
0.05782322958111763,
0.392161101102829,
0.22965461015701294,
0.13487109541893005,
-0.4232754707336426,
-0.7740504145622253,
-0.8565061688423157,
0.1694599837064743,
-0.7836541533470154,
0.12759162485599518,
-0.5196412205696106,
-0.20172829926013947,
-0.15081562101840973,
-0.1817908138036728,
-0.3625483810901642,
-0.4576775133609772,
-0.03691449016332626,
0.04376773163676262,
0.315075159072876,
0.670448362827301,
-0.1378496140241623,
0.30238038301467896,
-0.42892131209373474,
0.3954204022884369,
0.30068516731262207,
0.6717373132705688,
-0.026062076911330223,
-0.12396936118602753,
-0.11748772114515305,
0.04266015812754631,
-0.012302091345191002,
-0.80381840467453,
0.3463573753833771,
0.37821507453918457,
0.8663935661315918,
0.2791846990585327,
-0.11802809685468674,
0.8357367515563965,
-0.5131046175956726,
0.4065036475658417,
0.22685189545154572,
-0.8102705478668213,
0.49943870306015015,
-0.5029193758964539,
0.41095253825187683,
0.9148061275482178,
0.5547537803649902,
-0.4877408742904663,
-0.5059576630592346,
-0.3958800733089447,
-0.7908499240875244,
0.7316420078277588,
0.22162196040153503,
0.2556212246417999,
-0.11671243607997894,
0.4044588506221771,
0.4669778347015381,
0.37541094422340393,
-0.46503686904907227,
-0.4012618064880371,
-0.3983541429042816,
-0.32560381293296814,
-0.03347635641694069,
0.25371888279914856,
-0.02986120991408825,
-0.23302696645259857,
0.029894400388002396,
-0.13838635385036469,
0.26763471961021423,
0.20863796770572662,
-0.35152459144592285,
-0.3308444917201996,
0.18502509593963623,
0.6277341842651367,
0.5919162034988403,
-0.1474531888961792,
0.4179752469062805,
0.06069273129105568,
-0.9958008527755737,
0.23674720525741577,
-0.03619052469730377,
-0.05618704482913017,
-0.03049522452056408,
0.17756123840808868,
0.5297041535377502,
-0.22333648800849915,
-0.4729514420032501,
0.16103826463222504,
-0.3827242851257324,
0.3166297376155853,
-0.745717465877533,
0.26480671763420105,
-0.11060412973165512,
-0.0778084322810173,
0.472899466753006,
0.4057471454143524,
-0.14480963349342346,
-0.8996403217315674,
0.12461446970701218,
0.38311225175857544,
-0.5355241298675537,
-0.44081488251686096,
0.44500860571861267,
-0.1028241515159607,
-0.3660587966442108,
0.473641574382782,
-0.32127562165260315,
-0.4068756401538849,
0.3608095049858093,
0.5118109583854675,
0.8927714228630066,
-0.4631795287132263,
0.21604017913341522,
0.33057889342308044,
0.14953117072582245,
-0.0006260553491301835,
0.16782568395137787,
-0.276295930147171,
-0.610957682132721,
-0.3434017300605774,
-1.037363052368164,
-0.4998946189880371,
-0.2949081063270569,
-0.5167754888534546,
0.440185010433197,
-0.49914923310279846,
0.03126394748687744,
0.3463877737522125,
0.20924487709999084,
-0.6726576685905457,
-0.11666400730609894,
0.38375526666641235,
0.7174009680747986,
-0.8934550285339355,
1.0471619367599487,
0.762511134147644,
-0.6918710470199585,
-0.8285312056541443,
0.11636913567781448,
0.29873451590538025,
-1.1171492338180542,
0.19633014500141144,
0.25803521275520325,
-0.2544936239719391,
0.27465590834617615,
-0.10985612869262695,
-0.9771991968154907,
1.0485705137252808,
0.049054235219955444,
-0.0661805272102356,
0.09584753215312958,
0.4132261574268341,
1.1011134386062622,
-0.4960399270057678,
0.6716485619544983,
0.46133530139923096,
0.45682501792907715,
0.10196813195943832,
-1.0723698139190674,
0.011795823462307453,
-0.2625235915184021,
0.23706868290901184,
0.3158133924007416,
-0.7404033541679382,
0.6996703743934631,
-0.24245227873325348,
-0.6393129825592041,
0.03688567131757736,
0.6089695692062378,
0.11335944384336472,
0.17230097949504852,
0.2586171329021454,
0.48504695296287537,
0.7713338136672974,
-0.0062220399267971516,
0.938496470451355,
-0.12091823667287827,
0.0534994974732399,
0.6649933457374573,
-0.42095062136650085,
0.5251756310462952,
0.527475893497467,
-0.3306751549243927,
0.7191576361656189,
0.3742374777793884,
0.111440010368824,
0.681138813495636,
0.5312488079071045,
-0.25323787331581116,
0.021351169794797897,
0.026520472019910812,
-0.305051326751709,
0.675999641418457,
0.5885716676712036,
-0.10287460684776306,
-0.516510009765625,
0.03268188610672951,
0.12472148984670639,
0.3654482364654541,
-0.14642378687858582,
0.8581230044364929,
-0.14225098490715027,
-0.7328212261199951,
0.7465594410896301,
-0.21424925327301025,
0.6836811304092407,
-0.9845680594444275,
0.06318769603967667,
-0.105815589427948,
0.5122348666191101,
-0.03459794074296951,
-0.6181155443191528,
0.6492420434951782,
-0.16111676394939423,
-0.17795106768608093,
-0.3517490029335022,
0.796741783618927,
-0.5137408375740051,
-0.3438047468662262,
0.3328614830970764,
0.4439385235309601,
-0.03981880098581314,
0.4500860571861267,
-0.23361057043075562,
0.1503714621067047,
-0.04643707349896431,
-0.03404403105378151,
0.8109052181243896,
0.4020993411540985,
-0.33293023705482483,
0.6857409477233887,
0.7040684819221497,
0.22017745673656464,
0.238067626953125,
-0.08281128108501434,
0.7664357423782349,
-0.596264123916626,
-0.3744845688343048,
-0.7281145453453064,
0.13824647665023804,
-0.18236196041107178,
-0.22036249935626984,
1.0625115633010864,
0.2871948778629303,
0.9336552619934082,
-0.3289942145347595,
1.0390329360961914,
-0.21365006268024445,
0.6642054319381714,
-0.04266377165913582,
0.7150084376335144,
-0.17017057538032532,
0.11386905610561371,
-0.3175874352455139,
-0.6453683972358704,
-0.25901228189468384,
0.5488232970237732,
-0.015728985890746117,
-0.199818953871727,
0.6811110377311707,
0.4940527677536011,
-0.0731855109333992,
-0.05952276289463043,
0.19939091801643372,
-0.0672852024435997,
0.011263989843428135,
0.2792550325393677,
0.7520021796226501,
-0.22926115989685059,
0.611310601234436,
-0.212421253323555,
-0.6012468934059143,
0.1160460114479065,
-0.7419596910476685,
-0.8247900605201721,
-0.7234955430030823,
-0.24389533698558807,
-0.2648898959159851,
-0.11534580588340759,
0.7473241686820984,
0.352694034576416,
-0.9015851616859436,
-0.3494056165218353,
-0.15999557077884674,
0.1623692810535431,
-0.3346463739871979,
-0.14159850776195526,
0.3160017728805542,
-0.33503299951553345,
-0.773977518081665,
0.2215542197227478,
0.5214957594871521,
-0.03746400400996208,
-0.6691387891769409,
0.1997321993112564,
-0.2623225152492523,
0.278513640165329,
0.17080910503864288,
0.7248554825782776,
-0.5842179656028748,
-0.44087788462638855,
0.1872628778219223,
-0.256952702999115,
-0.03872346505522728,
0.7607446312904358,
-0.9701814651489258,
0.6952282786369324,
0.6268494725227356,
0.4460127651691437,
0.151470348238945,
-0.2626374363899231,
0.5528049468994141,
-0.8793641924858093,
0.40123307704925537,
-0.07992476224899292,
0.13133041560649872,
0.2917329668998718,
-0.1127176359295845,
0.3407464027404785,
0.3238750100135803,
-0.28807443380355835,
-0.7714939713478088,
0.5241208672523499,
-0.9867167472839355,
0.07662783563137054,
1.07877779006958,
-0.09069729596376419,
-0.407224178314209,
-0.60077965259552,
-0.1371508091688156,
0.379038542509079,
-0.2068822681903839,
0.7762300968170166,
0.8867119550704956,
0.048795055598020554,
-0.001058776630088687,
-0.48935753107070923,
0.7598076462745667,
0.007069418206810951,
-0.21667484939098358,
0.12361784279346466,
0.09681231528520584,
0.3466324210166931,
0.8015950322151184,
0.6991783380508423,
-0.3814234137535095,
0.03167365863919258,
0.14981451630592346,
-0.03982732445001602,
0.14517877995967865,
-0.12269210815429688,
-0.3929573595523834,
0.05063552409410477,
0.040313366800546646,
-0.16153305768966675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17888v1 | CTBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Language Model Capabilities in Clinical Trial Design | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | 2024-06-25T18:52:48 | Nafis Neehal, Bowen Wang, Shayom Debopadhaya, Soham Dan, Keerthiram Murugesan, Vibha Anand, Kristin P. Bennett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | CTBench is introduced as a benchmark to assess language models (LMs) in
aiding clinical study design. Given study-specific metadata, CTBench evaluates
AI models' ability to determine the baseline features of a clinical trial (CT),
which include demographic and relevant features collected at the trial's start
from all participants. These baseline features, typically presented in CT
publications (often as Table 1), are crucial for characterizing study cohorts
and validating results. Baseline features, including confounders and
covariates, are also necessary for accurate treatment effect estimation in
studies involving observational data. CTBench consists of two datasets:
"CT-Repo," containing baseline features from 1,690 clinical trials sourced from
clinicaltrials.gov, and "CT-Pub," a subset of 100 trials with more
comprehensive baseline features gathered from relevant publications. Two
LM-based evaluation methods are developed to compare the actual baseline
feature lists against LM-generated responses. "ListMatch-LM" and
"ListMatch-BERT" use GPT-4o and BERT scores (at various thresholds),
respectively, for evaluation. To establish baseline results, advanced prompt
engineering techniques using LLaMa3-70B-Instruct and GPT-4o in zero-shot and
three-shot learning settings are applied to generate potential baseline
features. The performance of GPT-4o as an evaluator is validated through
human-in-the-loop evaluations on the CT-Pub dataset, where clinical experts
confirm matches between actual and LM-generated features. The results highlight
a promising direction with significant potential for improvement, positioning
CTBench as a useful tool for advancing research on AI in CT design and
potentially enhancing the efficacy and robustness of CTs. | [
-0.45806753635406494,
-0.8015561103820801,
0.5223261713981628,
0.0005289213149808347,
-0.350103497505188,
0.1578824520111084,
-0.2920762896537781,
-0.34731730818748474,
-0.14767448604106903,
0.47766393423080444,
-0.24050825834274292,
-0.8011883497238159,
-0.5436603426933289,
0.13632045686244965,
-0.4745689034461975,
0.8656911849975586,
-0.029656480997800827,
0.3761819005012512,
-0.02224789932370186,
-0.3711897134780884,
-0.8071193099021912,
-0.44415271282196045,
-0.5287176966667175,
-0.2948378026485443,
0.5532991290092468,
0.288786917924881,
0.6541796326637268,
0.6251410841941833,
0.7512656450271606,
0.284035861492157,
-0.12418346107006073,
-0.3377244472503662,
-0.5190377235412598,
0.11396899074316025,
-0.06563803553581238,
-0.6310824751853943,
-0.43574264645576477,
0.11200603097677231,
0.42282411456108093,
0.8445615172386169,
-0.11769787222146988,
-0.015377420000731945,
0.1362776905298233,
0.4008880853652954,
-0.8117972612380981,
-0.0359104685485363,
-0.45531708002090454,
0.06211201474070549,
-0.40093696117401123,
-0.14119255542755127,
-0.3505019247531891,
-0.7065981030464172,
0.3682972192764282,
-0.24665941298007965,
0.4579930305480957,
-0.054776955395936966,
0.8166493773460388,
-0.0006395717500708997,
-0.49312639236450195,
-0.172552227973938,
-0.18783913552761078,
0.5995476245880127,
-0.7872088551521301,
0.18790625035762787,
0.3170911967754364,
0.7140533328056335,
-0.3061569035053253,
-0.8246564269065857,
-0.31377479434013367,
-0.6924397945404053,
-0.21165962517261505,
0.3504072427749634,
-0.1952432543039322,
0.5103804469108582,
0.3844921588897705,
0.4398239850997925,
-1.0066254138946533,
0.20439808070659637,
-0.3763163685798645,
-0.4208853542804718,
0.3707367181777954,
0.24071188271045685,
0.31891873478889465,
-0.09934087097644806,
-0.3998318910598755,
-0.352498322725296,
-0.7157403826713562,
-0.06044072285294533,
-0.11721480637788773,
0.39297786355018616,
-0.12765362858772278,
0.48906058073043823,
-0.20234711468219757,
0.7351824045181274,
-0.15390139818191528,
0.03631465137004852,
0.4476650655269623,
-0.5079146027565002,
-0.2773674726486206,
0.1760958582162857,
0.664019763469696,
0.4002450406551361,
0.039725132286548615,
-0.13343104720115662,
0.029333025217056274,
0.13930444419384003,
0.4277995228767395,
-0.7250522375106812,
-0.08272453397512436,
0.28157490491867065,
-0.5580617189407349,
-0.3065313696861267,
-0.006429840344935656,
-0.7336540222167969,
-0.470834344625473,
-0.1485457420349121,
0.21713384985923767,
-0.47444087266921997,
-0.233093723654747,
-0.23978345096111298,
-0.36264827847480774,
0.2888358533382416,
0.31550896167755127,
-0.3679356873035431,
0.36027562618255615,
0.6061151027679443,
0.9651952385902405,
-0.4411478042602539,
-0.22280941903591156,
-0.5065032243728638,
-0.18286734819412231,
-0.5419635772705078,
0.998390257358551,
-0.43306511640548706,
-0.6603240370750427,
0.19915959239006042,
-0.06881962716579437,
-0.0662279948592186,
-0.5827802419662476,
0.5698585510253906,
-0.24512888491153717,
0.29971134662628174,
-0.3592388331890106,
-0.7501527667045593,
-0.02996404841542244,
0.47450342774391174,
-0.8232268691062927,
1.0652414560317993,
0.4279114007949829,
-0.6064238548278809,
0.6520204544067383,
-0.5711110830307007,
-0.22558434307575226,
0.2464178204536438,
-0.37373611330986023,
-0.3156483471393585,
0.3937082290649414,
0.08175504207611084,
0.05317364260554314,
-0.4679678976535797,
0.4511082172393799,
-0.6100418567657471,
-0.5266159176826477,
0.18027496337890625,
-0.24640783667564392,
0.7398499846458435,
0.3907397389411926,
-0.4370127320289612,
0.3208062946796417,
-0.7127096056938171,
0.36125749349594116,
-0.012713112868368626,
-0.4226025342941284,
-0.044666074216365814,
-0.1887214034795761,
0.31960296630859375,
0.202805295586586,
0.019936466589570045,
-0.47971200942993164,
-0.014518835581839085,
-0.45102015137672424,
0.22818653285503387,
0.4895758330821991,
-0.08820418268442154,
0.055211637169122696,
-0.28050386905670166,
0.6719925999641418,
-0.3661818504333496,
0.11607645452022552,
-0.09958881139755249,
-0.2087460309267044,
-0.6412804126739502,
-0.25462543964385986,
0.5110744833946228,
0.3627423644065857,
-0.5515778064727783,
0.5774706602096558,
-0.16244879364967346,
-0.6861861944198608,
-0.28683412075042725,
-0.07602275162935257,
0.7545365691184998,
0.5019126534461975,
0.3291465938091278,
-0.6542638540267944,
-0.39760202169418335,
-1.2135627269744873,
-0.28337883949279785,
-0.03219333291053772,
-0.14558804035186768,
0.11997172236442566,
0.4060594439506531,
0.2885141372680664,
0.7843076586723328,
-0.1302943229675293,
-0.4185996949672699,
-0.6491624116897583,
0.35275018215179443,
0.12569187581539154,
0.374675452709198,
0.7555676102638245,
-0.2976599335670471,
-0.5003377199172974,
-0.10321558266878128,
-0.7454626560211182,
-0.3594476580619812,
0.008454572409391403,
-0.05357896909117699,
0.15084677934646606,
0.4953063428401947,
-0.3326859772205353,
0.8324021100997925,
0.5111255049705505,
-0.12239091098308563,
0.3419703245162964,
-0.27735692262649536,
0.3083046078681946,
-0.8984344005584717,
0.530093789100647,
-0.3161279559135437,
-0.059025540947914124,
-0.5081250071525574,
0.056961607187986374,
0.08969990164041519,
-0.14087876677513123,
-0.40065646171569824,
0.6224182844161987,
-0.36590731143951416,
-0.2319854348897934,
-0.4397868514060974,
0.4181079864501953,
-0.1075468510389328,
0.22667020559310913,
-0.10808318108320236,
0.8954840302467346,
0.24517956376075745,
-0.13815289735794067,
0.040412940084934235,
0.13903215527534485,
-0.42471015453338623,
0.8882507681846619,
-0.7983072400093079,
0.24687667191028595,
0.3991180956363678,
0.3508337140083313,
-1.0745642185211182,
-0.07676911354064941,
-0.19049817323684692,
-0.35726940631866455,
0.07530979067087173,
0.07629039883613586,
-0.6123403310775757,
-0.5739486813545227,
-0.4448542594909668,
0.30949193239212036,
0.2012312412261963,
0.010467718355357647,
0.5966694355010986,
0.30180513858795166,
-0.07913903146982193,
-0.3959353566169739,
-0.5857723355293274,
0.35006943345069885,
-0.09268392622470856,
-0.31795164942741394,
0.36318331956863403,
0.01747741550207138,
-0.099818155169487,
-0.13298936188220978,
-0.17069898545742035,
-0.1356545388698578,
0.12332037836313248,
0.16579267382621765,
0.14774206280708313,
-0.25312158465385437,
0.19955968856811523,
-0.09159363061189651,
-0.2930150032043457,
-0.0720481276512146,
0.2930060029029846,
0.799712598323822,
-0.19343645870685577,
-0.544974684715271,
-0.6151316165924072,
0.3424775302410126,
0.38165655732154846,
-0.12800125777721405,
0.23657037317752838,
0.4901622235774994,
-0.3567641079425812,
-0.030220840126276016,
-0.790169358253479,
-0.2365424484014511,
-0.41365334391593933,
0.5484645366668701,
-0.41776907444000244,
-0.7722830772399902,
0.46116816997528076,
-0.09680133312940598,
-0.009514404460787773,
0.42184847593307495,
0.7827691435813904,
0.0487268790602684,
0.9836322069168091,
0.6004806160926819,
-0.16479958593845367,
0.5508230924606323,
0.04542543366551399,
-0.04682863876223564,
-0.7015177011489868,
0.09006727486848831,
-0.707740843296051,
-0.4634849429130554,
-0.5332147479057312,
-0.22168737649917603,
0.5916544198989868,
0.00862217228859663,
-0.3662596642971039,
0.39482155442237854,
-0.4632081091403961,
0.36592674255371094,
0.7534180283546448,
0.22197456657886505,
0.25727611780166626,
-0.30938220024108887,
-0.5591603517532349,
-0.001680034096352756,
-0.619812548160553,
-0.44826969504356384,
1.433411717414856,
-0.0005736714228987694,
0.344879686832428,
-0.14540739357471466,
0.6390609741210938,
0.537644624710083,
0.5371553897857666,
-0.5844092965126038,
0.5806632041931152,
-0.07516781985759735,
-0.9075343608856201,
0.019743986427783966,
-0.08362822979688644,
-1.1063734292984009,
0.193970188498497,
-0.09130620211362839,
-0.8338084816932678,
0.06015350669622421,
0.14851731061935425,
-0.4240337014198303,
-0.008180538192391396,
-0.5924983024597168,
1.1421817541122437,
-0.6654371619224548,
-0.4078269302845001,
-0.5859338641166687,
-0.681316077709198,
0.13149072229862213,
0.006644292734563351,
-0.09614726901054382,
-0.22855384647846222,
0.03599466383457184,
0.5851287245750427,
-0.550118625164032,
0.8119325637817383,
-0.1998111754655838,
0.3068717122077942,
0.1537686437368393,
0.3436068892478943,
0.15240716934204102,
-0.22240500152111053,
-0.13114553689956665,
0.29105642437934875,
0.2873588800430298,
-0.3987390995025635,
-0.4377051889896393,
0.5780150294303894,
-0.7269827723503113,
-0.5312597751617432,
-0.563713014125824,
-0.4790118932723999,
-0.39369624853134155,
0.44503253698349,
0.09477680176496506,
0.3675673305988312,
-0.6097743511199951,
0.5663524866104126,
0.04072187468409538,
-0.34065648913383484,
0.18140678107738495,
0.5910918116569519,
-0.028857989236712456,
-0.5761375427246094,
0.41214656829833984,
-0.08592046052217484,
0.4078965187072754,
0.24313320219516754,
0.22988365590572357,
-0.19306519627571106,
-1.0137242078781128,
-0.12112110108137131,
0.015543332323431969,
-0.8792648911476135,
-0.19694937765598297,
-0.28001588582992554,
-0.39834505319595337,
-0.027133846655488014,
-0.2764994204044342,
-0.3448999226093292,
-0.14867937564849854,
0.23516634106636047,
-0.09809648990631104,
0.04237475246191025,
0.4594157934188843,
0.07539719343185425,
0.5518048405647278,
-0.7216821908950806,
0.07395873218774796,
-0.1784064620733261,
0.3717164993286133,
-0.22607944905757904,
-0.3467434048652649,
-0.2436760812997818,
-0.13648729026317596,
-0.5757119655609131,
-0.7900985479354858,
0.19832094013690948,
0.02773265540599823,
0.9218369722366333,
0.3970453143119812,
-0.16024160385131836,
0.8129281997680664,
-0.20142331719398499,
0.727893054485321,
0.13436470925807953,
-1.0100690126419067,
0.8711219429969788,
-0.35417628288269043,
0.3952622413635254,
1.0309549570083618,
-0.051672156900167465,
-0.482732892036438,
-0.4526449143886566,
-0.5704771876335144,
-0.7909131646156311,
0.7803129553794861,
0.4278649687767029,
-0.21361497044563293,
0.04828376695513725,
0.26429957151412964,
0.16287314891815186,
0.25800102949142456,
-0.38250499963760376,
0.19225113093852997,
-0.10788048803806305,
-0.367509663105011,
0.032526906579732895,
-0.16634894907474518,
-0.45389774441719055,
-0.03027215227484703,
0.15135550498962402,
-0.3518567681312561,
0.1583099216222763,
0.09089484065771103,
-0.17155086994171143,
0.057206735014915466,
0.22667750716209412,
0.5139783024787903,
0.9521543383598328,
-0.5501468777656555,
-0.02444758079946041,
0.3894994258880615,
-0.46814894676208496,
-0.26176777482032776,
0.272091805934906,
0.09664700925350189,
-0.12591052055358887,
0.7939149737358093,
0.539919376373291,
0.23999935388565063,
-0.9435068368911743,
0.5391709208488464,
-0.07412110269069672,
-0.19807220995426178,
-0.2769753634929657,
0.2694098651409149,
-0.15118160843849182,
0.160524383187294,
0.07866179943084717,
-0.21329060196876526,
0.2975960671901703,
-0.40410467982292175,
0.37192535400390625,
0.3816866874694824,
-0.57872474193573,
-0.18973293900489807,
0.5215056538581848,
0.21424449980258942,
-0.09786609560251236,
0.760316789150238,
0.4569393992424011,
-0.19152483344078064,
0.907867431640625,
0.29260489344596863,
0.9875455498695374,
-0.143049418926239,
0.008192861452698708,
0.5758252739906311,
0.1591806560754776,
0.12433239817619324,
0.344555526971817,
-0.021285027265548706,
-0.48938068747520447,
0.16616050899028778,
-0.34488603472709656,
-0.5440912246704102,
0.15398277342319489,
-0.8401711583137512,
0.5231253504753113,
-0.492493599653244,
-0.42219480872154236,
0.017700577154755592,
-0.007124111521989107,
-0.9422524571418762,
0.0416325218975544,
0.20703187584877014,
1.1092411279678345,
-0.48920825123786926,
0.9345287084579468,
0.44144776463508606,
-0.6524673104286194,
-0.5337655544281006,
-0.15026423335075378,
0.5848231315612793,
-1.1333686113357544,
0.5179429650306702,
0.3133765757083893,
0.08419519662857056,
-0.18917426466941833,
-0.31722262501716614,
-0.843553900718689,
1.2949219942092896,
0.3125354051589966,
-0.593589723110199,
0.024260139092803,
0.4467364549636841,
0.9267931580543518,
-0.44624629616737366,
0.7583093047142029,
0.8834090828895569,
0.5005592107772827,
0.04300219938158989,
-1.2681266069412231,
0.20565764605998993,
-0.31422820687294006,
0.22979599237442017,
-0.14805784821510315,
-0.49391746520996094,
0.5786256194114685,
-0.018325306475162506,
-0.23759038746356964,
0.45910441875457764,
0.1153201162815094,
0.5124967694282532,
0.21716013550758362,
0.47080880403518677,
0.5488646626472473,
0.5351900458335876,
-0.49851951003074646,
1.1538290977478027,
-0.627234697341919,
0.3743232786655426,
1.1746076345443726,
-0.48569464683532715,
0.8664324879646301,
0.33200356364250183,
-0.2812403440475464,
0.3520682752132416,
0.726896345615387,
-0.21740630269050598,
0.5821429491043091,
0.47194868326187134,
0.16044236719608307,
-0.2922670841217041,
-0.13805830478668213,
-0.5667968988418579,
0.6067866086959839,
0.36127448081970215,
-0.4873015880584717,
-0.6888449192047119,
-0.026096265763044357,
0.17008893191814423,
-0.1663956493139267,
0.20142105221748352,
0.8619164824485779,
0.03096497803926468,
-0.6883991360664368,
0.7568374872207642,
-0.31219515204429626,
0.014396894723176956,
-0.9615440368652344,
-0.08104683458805084,
-0.4190452992916107,
0.5960578918457031,
0.11910092085599899,
-0.8360826373100281,
0.18647177517414093,
-0.08807361125946045,
0.28866469860076904,
0.20666956901550293,
0.30041012167930603,
0.026118069887161255,
-0.4779069125652313,
0.5084723234176636,
0.6582705974578857,
0.04025443643331528,
-0.08100855350494385,
-0.9767863750457764,
0.39669978618621826,
-0.1779579073190689,
-0.3139227330684662,
0.3664950728416443,
0.21043387055397034,
-0.2898242473602295,
0.6134640574455261,
0.514355480670929,
0.0870710238814354,
-0.283908486366272,
0.527188777923584,
1.075872778892517,
-0.802310049533844,
-0.23174986243247986,
-0.6922571063041687,
0.49253177642822266,
-0.35756364464759827,
-0.714454174041748,
0.5214248895645142,
0.7244637608528137,
0.6573677062988281,
0.27915453910827637,
0.9288464784622192,
-0.21409083902835846,
0.437784880399704,
-0.3271293342113495,
0.7256717681884766,
-0.5963329076766968,
0.1858770102262497,
-0.09138783812522888,
-0.7598974704742432,
-0.585033118724823,
0.37645652890205383,
-0.45094168186187744,
0.29062148928642273,
1.040421724319458,
0.8076512813568115,
0.11500053852796555,
0.08644749969244003,
0.3468196988105774,
0.3943534791469574,
0.6329048275947571,
0.5979686379432678,
0.6775752902030945,
-0.16128502786159515,
0.6299259662628174,
-0.28979843854904175,
-0.521704375743866,
-0.3454725444316864,
-0.6953324675559998,
-1.2423752546310425,
-0.31037330627441406,
-0.05706359073519707,
-0.25640010833740234,
0.32664620876312256,
0.799385666847229,
0.7618697881698608,
-1.1479309797286987,
-0.47858062386512756,
-0.10429847240447998,
-0.29607582092285156,
-0.47947484254837036,
-0.21733802556991577,
0.8169975280761719,
-0.5858961939811707,
-0.5231996178627014,
0.2107628732919693,
0.2944059669971466,
-0.27351388335227966,
-0.20237848162651062,
0.1584787666797638,
-0.013972737826406956,
-0.18371309340000153,
0.3679112493991852,
0.07333474606275558,
-1.0212843418121338,
-0.2636950612068176,
-0.023634910583496094,
-0.23916572332382202,
0.25024139881134033,
0.9985602498054504,
-0.8550820350646973,
0.9362385272979736,
0.5121914744377136,
0.48184871673583984,
0.3968314528465271,
-0.14472191035747528,
0.8337960839271545,
-0.2863589823246002,
0.17850641906261444,
0.36336079239845276,
0.5385541319847107,
0.0378689244389534,
0.0912361592054367,
0.6540935039520264,
0.1751936674118042,
-0.45290759205818176,
-0.7434705495834351,
-0.1068636029958725,
-1.266409993171692,
-0.18429382145404816,
0.6934759616851807,
-0.1811789870262146,
0.011157582513988018,
-0.2494717687368393,
-0.4039526581764221,
0.18984021246433258,
-0.2976067364215851,
1.1127046346664429,
0.7401849627494812,
-0.2621033489704132,
-0.2802399694919586,
-0.8735865950584412,
0.47620445489883423,
0.36682838201522827,
-0.9378474950790405,
0.021434929221868515,
0.5530049800872803,
0.30188706517219543,
0.005854742135852575,
0.5807831883430481,
-0.3929508328437805,
0.5446262955665588,
-0.004520798567682505,
0.3248113989830017,
0.000663118320517242,
0.06711333990097046,
-0.08441317826509476,
0.22124579548835754,
-0.0023770558182150126,
-0.018969831988215446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17876v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17876v1 | ET tu, CLIP? Addressing Common Object Errors for Unseen Environments | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | 2024-06-25T18:35:13 | Ye Won Byun, Cathy Jiao, Shahriar Noroozizadeh, Jimin Sun, Rosa Vitiello | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | We introduce a simple method that employs pre-trained CLIP encoders to
enhance model generalization in the ALFRED task. In contrast to previous
literature where CLIP replaces the visual encoder, we suggest using CLIP as an
additional module through an auxiliary object detection objective. We validate
our method on the recently proposed Episodic Transformer architecture and
demonstrate that incorporating CLIP improves task performance on the unseen
validation set. Additionally, our analysis results support that CLIP especially
helps with leveraging object descriptions, detecting small objects, and
interpreting rare words. | [
-0.37271666526794434,
-0.4003279209136963,
0.5771800875663757,
0.019337687641382217,
-0.3422505259513855,
-0.010219045914709568,
0.10637766867876053,
-0.4988497793674469,
0.23805786669254303,
0.22973980009555817,
-0.6710373759269714,
-0.5539563894271851,
-0.719312310218811,
0.33134233951568604,
-0.4081021845340729,
0.596449613571167,
-0.22141133248806,
-0.2811231315135956,
-0.3953133523464203,
-0.1336880475282669,
-0.48283833265304565,
-0.5741179585456848,
-0.1980753093957901,
-0.01774708181619644,
-0.02026124857366085,
0.6006870865821838,
0.6710102558135986,
0.5994976162910461,
0.514058530330658,
0.29610675573349,
-0.05228836461901665,
0.5556365251541138,
-0.28234776854515076,
-0.10311858355998993,
-0.20855869352817535,
-0.5192731022834778,
-0.4849547743797302,
-0.45387062430381775,
0.40108722448349,
0.6112226843833923,
0.009142929688096046,
0.05449184030294418,
0.1893109828233719,
0.3428272604942322,
-1.1575204133987427,
0.14758461713790894,
-0.27944639325141907,
0.4268099367618561,
-0.21816936135292053,
-0.06142185628414154,
-0.14869609475135803,
0.21643155813217163,
0.15811771154403687,
-1.132782220840454,
0.6293453574180603,
0.14543496072292328,
1.0000218152999878,
0.400679349899292,
-0.10796410590410233,
-0.06957641988992691,
-0.9709256291389465,
1.0286251306533813,
-0.15319420397281647,
0.463878333568573,
0.3897860050201416,
0.3423660099506378,
0.1338936984539032,
-1.1874823570251465,
-0.6281459331512451,
0.19974814355373383,
-0.06753410398960114,
0.2695671021938324,
-0.7857356071472168,
0.27588754892349243,
0.41668251156806946,
0.1507931351661682,
0.16934692859649658,
-0.25364622473716736,
-0.5656831860542297,
-0.3259163796901703,
0.1021883562207222,
0.2699785530567169,
0.5167800188064575,
-0.08585665374994278,
-0.1361212581396103,
-0.5147600769996643,
-0.5008549094200134,
0.17176060378551483,
0.1757396161556244,
-0.21018539369106293,
-0.11355587095022202,
0.5652315616607666,
-0.1713542938232422,
0.6526097655296326,
0.1751260757446289,
0.09289639443159103,
0.22041647136211395,
-0.15116213262081146,
0.05947445333003998,
-0.19841822981834412,
0.13748930394649506,
0.9518331289291382,
0.15022526681423187,
-0.2055491805076599,
-0.3389587998390198,
0.3396541178226471,
0.46699005365371704,
-0.7592212557792664,
-0.4844103753566742,
-0.10758945345878601,
-0.460184782743454,
0.10017604380846024,
0.2947326898574829,
-0.5459121465682983,
0.2843463122844696,
-0.12354853749275208,
0.6271300911903381,
-0.39748936891555786,
0.18582166731357574,
0.35928329825401306,
-0.6626172661781311,
-0.021726451814174652,
0.7142021656036377,
-0.6924082636833191,
0.7441404461860657,
0.7209181785583496,
0.9843218922615051,
-0.2568424940109253,
-0.5041042566299438,
-0.9409115314483643,
0.5479288697242737,
-0.3512578308582306,
1.0867007970809937,
-0.4781325161457062,
-0.43801382184028625,
0.1441919505596161,
0.6098264455795288,
0.27076783776283264,
-0.759419322013855,
0.7115620374679565,
-0.19664403796195984,
-0.0029179283883422613,
-0.28492075204849243,
-0.39352571964263916,
-0.5663018226623535,
0.23773789405822754,
-0.7294989228248596,
0.968160092830658,
0.17382553219795227,
-0.5095387697219849,
0.5071165561676025,
-0.7812957167625427,
-0.29359009861946106,
0.06310953199863434,
-0.1761360466480255,
-0.35530394315719604,
0.27984946966171265,
0.8521762490272522,
0.32312366366386414,
0.286918580532074,
-0.30351340770721436,
-0.3501940369606018,
-0.692782998085022,
-0.015356576070189476,
-0.09728552401065826,
0.08483714610338211,
-0.11635689437389374,
0.048199284821748734,
0.18204085528850555,
-0.5830790400505066,
-0.12364262342453003,
-0.029802503064274788,
-0.05983970686793327,
-0.7229846715927124,
-0.05098025128245354,
0.16847211122512817,
-0.37128350138664246,
0.11045965552330017,
-0.784892737865448,
0.06550410389900208,
-0.13151665031909943,
0.3084971010684967,
0.6216842532157898,
0.1852167695760727,
0.392023503780365,
-0.5426774621009827,
0.7257101535797119,
-0.058439698070287704,
0.16944371163845062,
-0.2733929753303528,
-0.4367709457874298,
-0.6802325248718262,
-0.4272725582122803,
0.0397801473736763,
0.3208712041378021,
-0.7052182555198669,
0.4167190194129944,
-0.09851408004760742,
0.014677224680781364,
-0.42360588908195496,
-0.11502449214458466,
0.19713641703128815,
0.32729384303092957,
0.47301796078681946,
-0.3422471880912781,
-0.8757187128067017,
-0.9004079103469849,
0.02420003153383732,
0.2857496440410614,
-0.7369768023490906,
0.30325862765312195,
0.5863693952560425,
-0.48168814182281494,
1.3063777685165405,
-0.8533923029899597,
-0.4422266185283661,
-0.11233166605234146,
0.06522953510284424,
0.16166938841342926,
0.5418139100074768,
0.5941287279129028,
-0.6216257810592651,
-0.18420690298080444,
-0.2507232129573822,
-0.6502031087875366,
0.135155588388443,
0.24557280540466309,
0.18975254893302917,
-0.2654217481613159,
0.5244559049606323,
-0.5729812979698181,
0.6549815535545349,
0.18916621804237366,
-0.06715919077396393,
0.25447362661361694,
-0.4726654291152954,
0.07718738913536072,
-0.584597110748291,
-0.1468409150838852,
-0.3319467008113861,
-0.3930871784687042,
-0.5605325102806091,
-0.03708778694272041,
0.10057718306779861,
-0.3050154149532318,
-0.6713649034500122,
0.32038843631744385,
-0.5101450085639954,
-0.445587158203125,
-0.5692158937454224,
-0.16173583269119263,
0.3452359437942505,
0.47424647212028503,
0.2728849947452545,
0.8816917538642883,
0.6897162795066833,
-0.9317091107368469,
0.21216082572937012,
0.766036868095398,
-0.32441768050193787,
0.553551435470581,
-1.0594035387039185,
0.5365947484970093,
-0.5817880630493164,
0.012268736958503723,
-0.64066481590271,
-0.40741589665412903,
0.30662640929222107,
-0.2986694276332855,
0.15006999671459198,
-0.2758575677871704,
-0.07523835450410843,
-0.4470123052597046,
-0.6713656783103943,
0.42372578382492065,
0.5446704030036926,
-0.8444969058036804,
0.8222238421440125,
0.3264143168926239,
0.3708361089229584,
-0.7792803049087524,
-0.6905032992362976,
-0.34506145119667053,
-0.2077779471874237,
-0.46892890334129333,
0.5504502654075623,
0.04395386204123497,
-0.11823706328868866,
0.43824437260627747,
-0.49791643023490906,
-0.18416082859039307,
0.2890568673610687,
0.5415099859237671,
0.25960272550582886,
-0.2605492174625397,
-0.0012745915446430445,
0.0562870167195797,
0.009674218483269215,
-0.13009750843048096,
0.0468573123216629,
0.4473539888858795,
-0.22436073422431946,
-0.5727742314338684,
-0.20499466359615326,
0.5286982655525208,
0.37910473346710205,
0.10054857283830643,
0.32444947957992554,
0.32920917868614197,
-0.6436684131622314,
-0.42991772294044495,
-0.18984316289424896,
-0.29019099473953247,
-0.5617603063583374,
0.865927517414093,
-0.35797104239463806,
-0.712719738483429,
0.6097940802574158,
-0.16401740908622742,
-0.2632004916667938,
0.39496201276779175,
-0.10356614738702774,
-0.22652505338191986,
0.9309141635894775,
1.1402344703674316,
0.18253806233406067,
0.37917715311050415,
-0.4811422526836395,
0.004397066775709391,
-1.2964462041854858,
-0.06352956593036652,
-0.2572113573551178,
-0.2996140718460083,
0.04639699310064316,
-0.7842275500297546,
0.49068301916122437,
0.7421427965164185,
-0.15338541567325592,
0.4745742380619049,
-0.6775501370429993,
0.7056590914726257,
0.7712410688400269,
0.30244114995002747,
0.2987244129180908,
0.1429687738418579,
0.198139488697052,
-0.22304628789424896,
-0.805568277835846,
-0.5148655772209167,
1.2035281658172607,
0.4525285065174103,
0.9353235363960266,
-0.053999532014131546,
0.6777780055999756,
0.5266368389129639,
0.1947060227394104,
-1.1161210536956787,
0.5316847562789917,
-0.22535164654254913,
-0.2354574203491211,
-0.3203021287918091,
0.32531335949897766,
-0.9455816149711609,
0.26980406045913696,
-0.07891684025526047,
-0.7309633493423462,
0.48983460664749146,
0.368852823972702,
-0.7325321435928345,
0.16285283863544464,
-0.46319320797920227,
0.8560753464698792,
-0.029742347076535225,
0.050009433180093765,
-0.19065137207508087,
-0.17545431852340698,
0.11798685789108276,
0.15946239233016968,
-0.12406989932060242,
0.042155671864748,
-0.4867030084133148,
1.001624345779419,
-0.4888053834438324,
0.7673285603523254,
0.010971414856612682,
0.4253505766391754,
0.47251707315444946,
-0.12963950634002686,
0.8162155747413635,
-0.07572993636131287,
0.5990039110183716,
0.18282566964626312,
-0.10052252560853958,
-0.07773098349571228,
-0.8193995952606201,
-0.08680760115385056,
-0.8048663139343262,
-0.48826560378074646,
-0.33467957377433777,
-0.5239812731742859,
-0.09564603865146637,
0.038053225725889206,
0.6052148342132568,
0.6278252005577087,
-0.30775994062423706,
0.1735968142747879,
0.38536807894706726,
-0.03259412199258804,
0.44006410241127014,
0.6699976921081543,
-0.15359178185462952,
-0.3929442763328552,
0.584685206413269,
-0.14126504957675934,
-0.04398141801357269,
0.3890071511268616,
0.0666981190443039,
-0.08191517740488052,
-0.7394685745239258,
-0.20589567720890045,
-0.10275778919458389,
-1.1224641799926758,
-0.24567510187625885,
-0.8320596218109131,
0.12827350199222565,
-0.17910248041152954,
-0.3825075030326843,
-0.49433571100234985,
-0.3572472631931305,
-0.48805004358291626,
-0.2866775095462799,
0.453565776348114,
0.8286371231079102,
-0.3516301214694977,
0.5939074754714966,
-1.1941204071044922,
0.4576179087162018,
0.7161124348640442,
0.022906549274921417,
-0.01840311475098133,
-0.45784735679626465,
-0.044377680867910385,
-0.15726123750209808,
-0.2996615171432495,
-0.5169828534126282,
0.37086719274520874,
0.5400964617729187,
0.7535018920898438,
0.5966573357582092,
0.27160409092903137,
0.7542990446090698,
-0.8259011507034302,
0.7443186044692993,
0.2457886040210724,
-1.163924217224121,
0.6434187293052673,
-0.12214996665716171,
0.2056078314781189,
0.33532246947288513,
0.4512839913368225,
-0.7199974060058594,
-0.2904803156852722,
-0.6510064005851746,
-0.8432999849319458,
0.8428764939308167,
0.17277392745018005,
0.13115337491035461,
-0.256052166223526,
-0.16987569630146027,
0.00474952207878232,
0.08539342135190964,
-0.39567917585372925,
-0.25728628039360046,
-0.3105790615081787,
-0.0451749823987484,
0.19771622121334076,
-0.39538487792015076,
-0.40054991841316223,
-0.2782713770866394,
0.2493027150630951,
-0.2222888320684433,
0.6146689057350159,
0.6255919933319092,
-0.4008781313896179,
-0.27703744173049927,
0.03923061117529869,
0.6786255240440369,
0.6589649319648743,
-0.5275750160217285,
0.16539134085178375,
0.3804852366447449,
-0.7683175802230835,
0.11385131627321243,
-0.11210343986749649,
-0.34394681453704834,
0.4469044506549835,
0.6910567879676819,
0.910706639289856,
0.5589036345481873,
-0.7141953110694885,
0.673098087310791,
0.08843491226434708,
0.01843813620507717,
-0.5846841335296631,
0.015895752236247063,
-0.22212834656238556,
0.15415224432945251,
0.6337496638298035,
0.4248908758163452,
0.3157047927379608,
-0.6260794401168823,
0.6892423629760742,
0.3150261640548706,
-0.29776766896247864,
-0.6293152570724487,
0.587608814239502,
0.3244035542011261,
-0.48282453417778015,
0.38115373253822327,
-0.25937342643737793,
-0.9668538570404053,
0.7416110634803772,
0.6808043718338013,
0.8520538806915283,
-0.008882026188075542,
-0.0018618771573528647,
0.2830144762992859,
0.283785343170166,
-0.48497286438941956,
0.11800998449325562,
-0.3347638249397278,
-1.2141447067260742,
-0.3675573170185089,
-0.0563785545527935,
-0.8757253289222717,
-0.022006701678037643,
-0.8461964130401611,
0.2519036531448364,
-0.33867645263671875,
0.09872958064079285,
-0.29394710063934326,
-0.7097115516662598,
-0.7951640486717224,
-0.20314662158489227,
0.04251082241535187,
0.7019496560096741,
-0.8234393000602722,
0.5604667663574219,
1.029262900352478,
-0.041399843990802765,
-0.7488130927085876,
0.06626895815134048,
-0.3068457543849945,
-0.8954188227653503,
0.9266095757484436,
0.3877136707305908,
-0.3866875469684601,
-0.35405516624450684,
-0.5629686117172241,
-1.0449771881103516,
0.8165647983551025,
0.21076174080371857,
-0.5123288035392761,
-0.056643396615982056,
-0.26252102851867676,
0.2433548867702484,
-0.35960257053375244,
0.49656131863594055,
0.2869601845741272,
0.12448163330554962,
0.13270030915737152,
-0.8236070275306702,
-0.15981131792068481,
-0.07640299201011658,
-0.017178881913423538,
0.15594521164894104,
-0.2704479396343231,
1.0774179697036743,
-0.10982607305049896,
-0.5661724805831909,
0.05002029240131378,
0.9078989028930664,
0.06736990064382553,
0.38560596108436584,
0.5447260141372681,
0.5613601803779602,
0.8973459005355835,
0.23672287166118622,
1.113998293876648,
-0.09733790159225464,
0.4094617962837219,
1.359144687652588,
-0.28668972849845886,
0.6565786600112915,
0.3973069489002228,
-0.41058167815208435,
0.3437020182609558,
0.14475098252296448,
-0.2600875496864319,
0.9261142611503601,
-0.06881099194288254,
-0.23442722856998444,
-0.37907686829566956,
-0.23812837898731232,
-0.4102214574813843,
0.5002935528755188,
0.2764771282672882,
-0.0652470663189888,
-0.4353044331073761,
0.580007016658783,
-0.3694547712802887,
0.13368573784828186,
-0.7407228350639343,
0.419055312871933,
0.016869736835360527,
-0.38895365595817566,
0.3508280813694,
-0.05245516076683998,
1.1434569358825684,
-0.4703228771686554,
-0.6157246828079224,
-0.08170255273580551,
0.5762361288070679,
-0.03319988027215004,
-0.6949666738510132,
0.609926700592041,
-0.12844662368297577,
-0.12356753647327423,
0.023550009354948997,
1.1239172220230103,
-0.07810429483652115,
-0.38875067234039307,
0.19267064332962036,
0.17348921298980713,
0.27005115151405334,
-0.35196274518966675,
-0.05557665228843689,
0.0396653451025486,
-0.1579015851020813,
0.250282883644104,
0.02751520834863186,
0.48244786262512207,
0.05186932161450386,
0.612315833568573,
0.2619379758834839,
-0.18982437252998352,
-0.04438510537147522,
-0.3516952395439148,
0.8231717348098755,
-0.6311250925064087,
-0.6730358600616455,
-0.46988171339035034,
0.2387584149837494,
-0.18367059528827667,
-0.30808475613594055,
0.9358347654342651,
0.5644217729568481,
1.1104953289031982,
-0.8908547163009644,
0.4947568476200104,
0.05168047547340393,
0.7878830432891846,
-0.4575844407081604,
0.1463959813117981,
-0.13890549540519714,
0.10198419541120529,
-0.3789687752723694,
-0.9986497163772583,
0.008112452924251556,
0.9589084386825562,
-0.1709984540939331,
-0.5616192817687988,
0.8977348804473877,
0.4617413580417633,
-0.4203014075756073,
-0.0656096413731575,
0.4757012724876404,
-0.4042412042617798,
-0.054307855665683746,
0.7938017845153809,
1.364172101020813,
-0.6494790315628052,
0.5729347467422485,
-0.5461592078208923,
0.03284703567624092,
-0.02923554927110672,
-0.8694599270820618,
-1.0788583755493164,
-0.13481445610523224,
-0.5621751546859741,
-0.12367048859596252,
0.029436763375997543,
0.9845672845840454,
0.922447681427002,
-0.9309901595115662,
0.032400455325841904,
-0.1010102853178978,
0.14291347563266754,
-0.5460922718048096,
-0.1668066680431366,
0.43136343359947205,
0.08348388969898224,
-0.991705596446991,
0.5952024459838867,
0.13706310093402863,
0.27086174488067627,
0.3688317835330963,
-0.215102881193161,
0.4019625186920166,
-0.2513865530490875,
0.4856117367744446,
0.5308823585510254,
-0.5290541052818298,
-0.8939002752304077,
-0.038895636796951294,
0.481288343667984,
0.3078802227973938,
0.9160777926445007,
-0.9342277646064758,
0.1315692812204361,
0.3223024308681488,
0.6146950125694275,
0.7307571768760681,
0.18602530658245087,
0.7311792373657227,
-0.7951252460479736,
0.5530046224594116,
0.450706422328949,
0.540381908416748,
0.22004082798957825,
-0.35759514570236206,
0.6763247847557068,
0.3936203718185425,
-0.16176055371761322,
-0.9121922850608826,
0.33756980299949646,
-1.0316007137298584,
-0.2505651116371155,
0.6667739748954773,
-0.4170226454734802,
-0.502528727054596,
-0.3800891041755676,
-0.15338122844696045,
-0.005650913808494806,
-0.47183653712272644,
0.4476161003112793,
0.4802247881889343,
-0.07683415710926056,
-0.38942795991897583,
-0.3618147671222687,
0.6436949968338013,
0.3400668799877167,
-0.7032321691513062,
-0.3467155396938324,
0.35204657912254333,
0.3823753297328949,
0.6068377494812012,
0.4164212644100189,
0.307302325963974,
0.7169568538665771,
0.1280146688222885,
0.09109781682491302,
-0.5277807712554932,
-0.4353792071342468,
-0.4321305453777313,
0.21778392791748047,
-0.10736047476530075,
-1.2221509218215942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17875v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17875v1 | Cloaked Classifiers: Pseudonymization Strategies on Sensitive Classification Tasks | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | 2024-06-25T18:30:25 | Arij Riabi, Menel Mahamdi, Virginie Mouilleron, Djamé Seddah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Protecting privacy is essential when sharing data, particularly in the case
of an online radicalization dataset that may contain personal information. In
this paper, we explore the balance between preserving data usefulness and
ensuring robust privacy safeguards, since regulations like the European GDPR
shape how personal information must be handled. We share our method for
manually pseudonymizing a multilingual radicalization dataset, ensuring
performance comparable to the original data. Furthermore, we highlight the
importance of establishing comprehensive guidelines for processing sensitive
NLP data by sharing our complete pseudonymization process, our guidelines, the
challenges we encountered as well as the resulting dataset. | [
-0.26102888584136963,
-0.474658727645874,
-0.1353425532579422,
0.29278212785720825,
0.17975464463233948,
0.3939107656478882,
-0.21462279558181763,
-0.7533490061759949,
0.04573327675461769,
0.585848867893219,
-0.14070868492126465,
-0.5562658309936523,
-0.664271354675293,
-0.20417700707912445,
-0.3793456256389618,
1.3713622093200684,
0.15312987565994263,
0.04071455076336861,
0.2476113736629486,
-0.03030800260603428,
-0.010552706196904182,
-0.940308153629303,
-0.6047329902648926,
0.23353785276412964,
0.8343114256858826,
-0.012802633456885815,
0.6462271809577942,
0.7726992964744568,
0.43156227469444275,
0.35572975873947144,
-0.1013394296169281,
-0.057090047746896744,
-0.2521505355834961,
0.3096517324447632,
-0.2930821478366852,
-0.5320547223091125,
-0.2681008577346802,
0.1333443969488144,
0.5372602343559265,
0.6184446811676025,
-0.19805091619491577,
0.19003745913505554,
0.06691396981477737,
0.48095449805259705,
-0.8244994282722473,
0.09028748422861099,
-0.31294575333595276,
0.31523874402046204,
-0.5630379319190979,
-0.04347902163863182,
-0.49864405393600464,
-0.5638392567634583,
-0.05470108985900879,
-0.5260053873062134,
0.8230538964271545,
0.07964038848876953,
0.6681519746780396,
0.02468070760369301,
-0.30816522240638733,
-0.05994625762104988,
-1.1326504945755005,
0.7908432483673096,
-0.22996534407138824,
0.18975098431110382,
0.801273763179779,
0.4634668231010437,
0.3265431225299835,
-0.8525211215019226,
-0.024185236543416977,
0.22384248673915863,
0.002738877199590206,
-0.028556792065501213,
-0.24639593064785004,
0.13668762147426605,
0.5418371558189392,
0.4604935646057129,
-0.38988998532295227,
0.2363402545452118,
-0.653706431388855,
-0.8006688952445984,
1.0019803047180176,
-0.013780185952782631,
0.008810183964669704,
0.10342108458280563,
-0.43418946862220764,
-0.14730674028396606,
-0.46603789925575256,
0.23322553932666779,
1.1083136796951294,
0.14894218742847443,
0.05803678184747696,
0.5391594171524048,
-0.24464520812034607,
0.3422173261642456,
-0.08996227383613586,
0.06954325735569,
0.27756041288375854,
-0.37143829464912415,
0.1142384484410286,
-0.07151959836483002,
0.702126681804657,
0.3469219505786896,
0.04315601661801338,
-0.4317649304866791,
-0.2960573434829712,
0.0670183002948761,
0.41257020831108093,
-0.6046894788742065,
-0.3118167519569397,
0.08536003530025482,
-0.3895740211009979,
-0.4380219876766205,
0.3097917139530182,
-0.8650912046432495,
-0.5682335495948792,
-0.10858418792486191,
0.268239289522171,
0.06095114350318909,
-0.06768281757831573,
0.3281646966934204,
-0.431045800447464,
0.18488425016403198,
0.27632594108581543,
-1.0748933553695679,
0.6775224208831787,
0.7502043843269348,
0.6825535893440247,
-0.3470132052898407,
0.18605712056159973,
-0.050575025379657745,
0.29652154445648193,
-0.2052648663520813,
0.15460439026355743,
-0.18604055047035217,
-0.21906274557113647,
0.22163088619709015,
-0.04696359112858772,
-0.07120261341333389,
-0.3379552960395813,
0.7938690781593323,
-0.6446123719215393,
0.4212682843208313,
-0.2800790071487427,
-0.6287488341331482,
-0.23236681520938873,
0.12108377367258072,
-0.8080505132675171,
0.917669415473938,
0.08325064182281494,
-1.2627917528152466,
0.3673350512981415,
-0.6351265907287598,
-0.31630435585975647,
0.36724767088890076,
-0.057121437042951584,
-0.7308383584022522,
-0.28379684686660767,
-0.01646468974649906,
0.9142856001853943,
0.29766109585762024,
0.09441012144088745,
-0.19986437261104584,
-0.24963466823101044,
0.46947845816612244,
-0.21596021950244904,
1.0957448482513428,
0.19364385306835175,
-0.6367506384849548,
0.15307378768920898,
-0.49732571840286255,
-0.12865959107875824,
-0.08166129887104034,
-0.18950045108795166,
-0.3881823420524597,
-0.03473388031125069,
0.5559454560279846,
0.08763930201530457,
0.3392373323440552,
-0.8120150566101074,
0.07623930275440216,
-0.24612261354923248,
0.4192216396331787,
1.0863858461380005,
0.19013945758342743,
0.37667977809906006,
-0.7544291019439697,
0.6671048998832703,
-0.11657589673995972,
0.6675727367401123,
0.18561197817325592,
-0.8366718292236328,
-0.7356025576591492,
-0.5414607524871826,
0.3444466292858124,
0.6957164406776428,
-0.4605267345905304,
0.39415937662124634,
0.043181050568819046,
-0.4079556465148926,
-0.2325313687324524,
-0.1152021586894989,
0.4800592362880707,
0.2994738221168518,
0.13128463923931122,
-0.055909521877765656,
-0.5730865001678467,
-1.0632275342941284,
-0.5302001237869263,
0.16894029080867767,
-0.1481495499610901,
0.4772951900959015,
0.2939620912075043,
-0.39490124583244324,
0.5953194499015808,
-0.5742613077163696,
-0.5037540793418884,
-0.15150120854377747,
0.042587265372276306,
-0.2189370095729828,
0.753800094127655,
0.5682592988014221,
-1.1994229555130005,
-0.4502759277820587,
0.04776105284690857,
-0.5634983777999878,
0.3460920751094818,
-0.1728215217590332,
-0.05854019150137901,
0.02180776558816433,
0.543004035949707,
-0.12839053571224213,
0.5244525074958801,
0.19876793026924133,
-0.24726231396198273,
0.1389484405517578,
-0.033086322247982025,
0.1335308998823166,
-0.997788667678833,
0.047917429357767105,
-0.02852206863462925,
-0.6224881410598755,
-1.1092827320098877,
0.36002159118652344,
-0.08974751830101013,
-0.0017311620758846402,
-0.5123657584190369,
0.35712289810180664,
-0.046062055975198746,
0.3847256600856781,
0.20533256232738495,
-0.431776225566864,
-0.27101677656173706,
0.30223482847213745,
-0.08744940906763077,
0.5543511509895325,
0.8329992294311523,
-0.481699675321579,
0.2223251610994339,
0.2490081787109375,
-0.18750271201133728,
0.10692035406827927,
-0.45048484206199646,
0.39876651763916016,
-0.13569045066833496,
-0.052354373037815094,
-0.6083322763442993,
-0.6085189580917358,
0.6679233312606812,
-0.3097366988658905,
0.5094568729400635,
0.01753273420035839,
-0.6220313906669617,
-0.021313397213816643,
-0.8594411015510559,
0.6441255807876587,
0.44426652789115906,
-0.3542110323905945,
0.5752095580101013,
0.7807077765464783,
-0.009484761394560337,
-0.9358397722244263,
-0.5640443563461304,
0.03588463366031647,
-0.6628256440162659,
-0.26523536443710327,
0.4769165813922882,
-0.1935196816921234,
-0.08340663462877274,
-0.37321072816848755,
0.038933366537094116,
-0.3497220575809479,
0.4389605224132538,
0.6618458032608032,
0.27440667152404785,
0.36318743228912354,
-0.21115176379680634,
0.07098772376775742,
-0.17524798214435577,
0.4411579668521881,
-0.027569537982344627,
0.4049968123435974,
0.07898544520139694,
-0.038941483944654465,
-0.7604859471321106,
0.5635105967521667,
-0.14015276730060577,
0.1367662101984024,
0.886248767375946,
0.6751478910446167,
-0.5791540741920471,
-0.4097963273525238,
-0.661186695098877,
-0.1741192787885666,
-0.5082393288612366,
-0.19141840934753418,
-0.07211164385080338,
-1.1916011571884155,
0.8228408098220825,
0.022226009517908096,
0.16700702905654907,
0.26541459560394287,
0.40350544452667236,
-0.13404251635074615,
0.9498481154441833,
1.1226181983947754,
-0.1746927946805954,
0.504375159740448,
-0.2706671953201294,
0.22070033848285675,
-0.5897291898727417,
-0.6315842866897583,
-0.6727975606918335,
-0.22140304744243622,
-1.1126755475997925,
-0.2208160161972046,
0.29271721839904785,
-0.1949802041053772,
0.0620870515704155,
0.27404776215553284,
-0.7407514452934265,
0.6471267342567444,
0.5242412090301514,
0.5415270924568176,
0.0751585140824318,
0.13480061292648315,
0.3093700706958771,
-0.30683091282844543,
-0.48681002855300903,
-0.441153883934021,
1.3617832660675049,
0.5166853070259094,
0.7240033149719238,
0.09888271987438202,
0.9101995229721069,
0.4772697687149048,
0.1751907467842102,
-0.6756591200828552,
0.5075251460075378,
0.01321330014616251,
-0.840979278087616,
-0.2798210382461548,
-0.5390335917472839,
-1.1120649576187134,
0.011953787878155708,
0.016929810866713524,
-0.7985525727272034,
0.40724608302116394,
-0.027060505002737045,
-0.1467059999704361,
0.13212674856185913,
-0.3584045469760895,
0.4684430658817291,
0.3171795904636383,
-0.29555219411849976,
0.04321686178445816,
-1.0290700197219849,
0.3937610387802124,
-0.44196978211402893,
0.3752606511116028,
0.10261005163192749,
-0.23105843365192413,
1.295071005821228,
-0.017327867448329926,
1.186508059501648,
-0.3931986689567566,
0.3280111253261566,
-0.26822665333747864,
-0.19697926938533783,
0.10635016113519669,
-0.03852323442697525,
0.07205842435359955,
0.4942190647125244,
-0.014262466691434383,
-0.49448493123054504,
-0.3797985017299652,
0.45055684447288513,
-0.8869316577911377,
-0.6717880368232727,
-0.6380211114883423,
-0.3693610429763794,
-0.09037555009126663,
0.2575620114803314,
0.5728247165679932,
-0.08659727871417999,
-0.035906072705984116,
0.33749788999557495,
1.1558175086975098,
0.11386385560035706,
0.47193601727485657,
0.16939809918403625,
-0.013868305832147598,
-0.3685194253921509,
1.0025129318237305,
0.38784509897232056,
0.10326102375984192,
0.3033045828342438,
0.3839486241340637,
-0.20818810164928436,
-0.5434070229530334,
-0.13812822103500366,
0.10261251777410507,
-0.8140549659729004,
-0.2752319872379303,
-0.7842272520065308,
-0.4675503671169281,
-0.30457839369773865,
-0.35473689436912537,
-0.06805779784917831,
-0.8825668692588806,
-0.3474287688732147,
-0.224026158452034,
0.19670821726322174,
0.8382114171981812,
-0.1770302951335907,
0.14967577159404755,
-0.4705713391304016,
0.4402153193950653,
0.07096147537231445,
0.14536485075950623,
-0.45961272716522217,
-0.3344702422618866,
-0.2518596947193146,
-0.15269124507904053,
-0.17342406511306763,
-0.7087982892990112,
0.2614457905292511,
0.4501653015613556,
0.6206873655319214,
0.6078819036483765,
0.37311410903930664,
0.11386946588754654,
-0.30834996700286865,
0.7752248048782349,
-0.13689304888248444,
-0.9829474687576294,
0.4269152581691742,
-0.4026608169078827,
-0.386115163564682,
0.4924831688404083,
0.9840134978294373,
-0.4906041622161865,
-0.6122585535049438,
-0.6874170899391174,
-1.002166986465454,
0.5955873727798462,
0.37149661779403687,
0.3891131579875946,
0.27662885189056396,
0.539840579032898,
0.34680816531181335,
0.4276098608970642,
-0.8951802253723145,
-0.5668037533760071,
-0.17425870895385742,
-0.05836215242743492,
-0.0294928140938282,
-0.08950762450695038,
-0.8862947225570679,
-0.31818830966949463,
0.534872829914093,
0.13078320026397705,
0.030101099982857704,
0.02206491492688656,
0.21161094307899475,
0.30813759565353394,
-0.023912763223052025,
0.31540921330451965,
0.3457784950733185,
0.1707654744386673,
0.20128728449344635,
-0.18907922506332397,
-1.0190255641937256,
0.15926559269428253,
0.10235201567411423,
-0.6063123941421509,
-0.19711561501026154,
0.22044360637664795,
0.3097100853919983,
0.1380244940519333,
-0.25373509526252747,
1.107121467590332,
-0.24829955399036407,
-0.3270167410373688,
-0.37931105494499207,
0.33249542117118835,
-0.5412641763687134,
-0.05334755778312683,
0.3393780589103699,
0.43895483016967773,
0.6784230470657349,
-0.005965234711766243,
0.2900829315185547,
0.4643988311290741,
0.1050327941775322,
-0.44617605209350586,
0.84648197889328,
-0.37409231066703796,
-0.297028511762619,
0.2713329493999481,
-0.06453509628772736,
-0.6580983400344849,
0.19084207713603973,
0.3248682916164398,
0.9493530988693237,
-0.8412954807281494,
0.47654300928115845,
0.11969628185033798,
0.3569413125514984,
-0.13719835877418518,
0.3607199192047119,
-0.537641704082489,
-0.6253789663314819,
0.06336892396211624,
-0.4596734941005707,
-0.45369991660118103,
-0.2190638929605484,
-1.2717970609664917,
0.028841732069849968,
-1.0939222574234009,
-0.19927799701690674,
0.32182958722114563,
-0.16961002349853516,
-0.48773083090782166,
0.07388950884342194,
-0.1497415155172348,
0.39681199193000793,
-0.998885989189148,
0.6003665924072266,
0.32876238226890564,
0.04372731223702431,
-0.539064884185791,
-0.2922191023826599,
0.04628206044435501,
-0.23462630808353424,
0.3860768973827362,
0.31209948658943176,
-0.07252870500087738,
-0.22691474854946136,
-0.6702674627304077,
-0.5952142477035522,
0.7478627562522888,
0.2482910454273224,
-0.43816807866096497,
0.01856907829642296,
0.47316691279411316,
0.6765720248222351,
0.19251400232315063,
-0.6006154417991638,
0.16011567413806915,
0.3271900415420532,
-0.0231664776802063,
-0.6166016459465027,
0.0501667819917202,
-0.2281004935503006,
0.013124904595315456,
0.1318879872560501,
-0.6086338758468628,
0.8368971347808838,
0.203385591506958,
-0.5080128908157349,
-0.22185921669006348,
0.33692219853401184,
-0.4136660695075989,
0.43703338503837585,
0.16013877093791962,
0.36100462079048157,
1.0269858837127686,
-0.21486254036426544,
0.9272249341011047,
0.06721217185258865,
0.21857106685638428,
0.832737922668457,
-0.11884240806102753,
0.6343460083007812,
0.22440101206302643,
-0.11205413192510605,
0.004829197656363249,
0.605278491973877,
-0.19202563166618347,
0.48014891147613525,
0.06593040376901627,
-0.7059488892555237,
0.06825129687786102,
-0.10120116174221039,
-0.27633294463157654,
0.38372331857681274,
0.21758362650871277,
-0.34715139865875244,
0.17925460636615753,
0.5485490560531616,
0.16946223378181458,
0.18702755868434906,
-0.23137332499027252,
1.0434205532073975,
-0.42960137128829956,
0.040746260434389114,
0.14101839065551758,
0.3076392114162445,
0.7578348517417908,
-0.4072854518890381,
0.26693159341812134,
0.12956281006336212,
0.18803513050079346,
-0.6059889793395996,
-0.4776482880115509,
0.6332266926765442,
-0.16794456541538239,
-0.2378666251897812,
-0.5929043292999268,
0.6091947555541992,
-0.12133259326219559,
-0.4170336425304413,
0.038559529930353165,
0.049421269446611404,
0.1800672709941864,
-0.0022980528883635998,
-0.5887531042098999,
0.026165688410401344,
-0.07875490933656693,
-0.2723816931247711,
0.6404138207435608,
0.030797364190220833,
-0.3194581866264343,
0.8010109663009644,
0.8352116942405701,
0.16475878655910492,
0.5334431529045105,
0.07516904920339584,
1.2071986198425293,
-0.5143091678619385,
-0.539882242679596,
-0.7515616416931152,
0.33720532059669495,
-0.18155072629451752,
-0.24489395320415497,
1.3740264177322388,
1.010567307472229,
1.149303674697876,
-0.1550547033548355,
0.5844889283180237,
0.2354862540960312,
0.6802546977996826,
-0.2974342107772827,
1.0822575092315674,
0.10367176681756973,
0.2031339406967163,
0.0014092359924688935,
-0.7845690250396729,
-0.7969874739646912,
0.5930904746055603,
0.016935966908931732,
-0.06866762787103653,
0.15112213790416718,
0.755998432636261,
0.13397902250289917,
0.03998328745365143,
0.2128765732049942,
-0.12062632292509079,
0.469624787569046,
-0.04241178184747696,
0.6896829009056091,
-0.6603756546974182,
-0.3002411127090454,
-0.8046205043792725,
-0.33291760087013245,
0.155167818069458,
-0.5467562675476074,
-1.0912153720855713,
-0.8791272640228271,
-0.6579739451408386,
-0.32706111669540405,
-0.03461150825023651,
0.477321982383728,
0.9484207034111023,
-0.9184372425079346,
-0.1337440460920334,
-0.030705908313393593,
0.10595507174730301,
-0.2780964970588684,
-0.2853166460990906,
0.1952340304851532,
0.07424931973218918,
-0.7594826817512512,
0.1614038348197937,
0.1176750436425209,
0.28823816776275635,
-0.486160546541214,
0.27083998918533325,
0.05991091951727867,
0.13924181461334229,
0.32420292496681213,
0.3967212438583374,
-0.5432786345481873,
-0.15060441195964813,
-0.22169005870819092,
-0.050033122301101685,
-0.11822982877492905,
1.062548279762268,
-0.4566686749458313,
0.6636310815811157,
0.13918235898017883,
0.7149732708930969,
0.6657267212867737,
0.051325369626283646,
0.008023361675441265,
-1.0922508239746094,
0.39278465509414673,
0.8673362731933594,
0.009369002655148506,
0.3691718280315399,
-0.8913315534591675,
0.32078078389167786,
0.1029939204454422,
-0.7291106581687927,
-1.0685051679611206,
0.12773707509040833,
-1.0797772407531738,
0.013344548642635345,
0.8164868354797363,
-0.6734203100204468,
-0.12950387597084045,
-0.7554760575294495,
-0.2755856215953827,
0.039549797773361206,
-0.10454763472080231,
0.9168548583984375,
0.5154893398284912,
-0.07990267127752304,
-0.11894025653600693,
-0.3589843511581421,
1.0371915102005005,
-0.1477382779121399,
-0.8375354409217834,
0.14450190961360931,
0.2905415892601013,
0.261018306016922,
0.2960078716278076,
0.30118539929389954,
-0.23234860599040985,
-0.003883206518366933,
-0.09021277725696564,
-0.32156410813331604,
-0.0019574041943997145,
-0.5196995735168457,
-0.6496688723564148,
0.5132941007614136,
-0.2952202260494232,
-0.13980363309383392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17873v1 | Improving Arithmetic Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models through Relation Tuples, Verification and Dynamic Feedback | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | 2024-06-25T18:21:00 | Zhongtao Miao, Kaiyan Zhao, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current representations used in reasoning steps of large language models can
mostly be categorized into two main types: (1) natural language, which is
difficult to verify; and (2) non-natural language, usually programming code,
which is difficult for people who are unfamiliar with coding to read. In this
paper, we propose to use a semi-structured form to represent reasoning steps of
large language models. Specifically, we use relation tuples, which are not only
human-readable but also machine-friendly and easier to verify than natural
language. We implement a framework that includes three main components: (1)
introducing relation tuples into the reasoning steps of large language models;
(2) implementing an automatic verification process of reasoning steps with a
local code interpreter based on relation tuples; and (3) integrating a simple
and effective dynamic feedback mechanism, which we found helpful for
self-improvement of large language models. The experimental results on various
arithmetic datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving
the arithmetic reasoning ability of large language models. The source code is
available at https://github.com/gpgg/art. | [
-0.05390161648392677,
-0.9799689650535583,
0.5782262086868286,
0.22799372673034668,
-0.11479449272155762,
0.29503563046455383,
-0.2594279646873474,
-0.5323755145072937,
-0.11104928702116013,
0.4080617129802704,
-0.07473893463611603,
-0.3337309956550598,
-0.33214104175567627,
0.31825482845306396,
-0.2358471006155014,
0.6046469807624817,
-0.10773302614688873,
0.15545184910297394,
-0.42845746874809265,
-0.25797876715660095,
-0.22721630334854126,
-0.7484346628189087,
-0.7236056327819824,
-0.4844033420085907,
0.0013814384583383799,
0.2869146168231964,
0.8571245074272156,
0.6038901805877686,
0.3580741584300995,
0.5270765423774719,
-0.20650619268417358,
0.5314748883247375,
-0.33852407336235046,
0.04265177622437477,
-0.05506519973278046,
-0.6208181977272034,
-0.600389838218689,
-0.3151634931564331,
0.932756245136261,
0.8709098100662231,
-0.23155510425567627,
0.0768580362200737,
-0.23395457863807678,
0.822124183177948,
-0.4208031892776489,
0.8552585244178772,
-0.22033213078975677,
0.020057331770658493,
0.08947930485010147,
-0.040881335735321045,
-0.5475650429725647,
-0.5174559354782104,
-0.2769756019115448,
-0.41818222403526306,
-0.17084713280200958,
-0.013850279152393341,
0.48058897256851196,
0.1372736394405365,
-0.5675027966499329,
-0.25844094157218933,
-0.851000189781189,
0.5858255624771118,
-0.8245738744735718,
0.407999187707901,
0.39655187726020813,
0.26094621419906616,
-0.4083673655986786,
-0.5618385076522827,
-0.4955132007598877,
-0.6645742654800415,
-0.3084575831890106,
-0.3224138021469116,
-0.1058628186583519,
0.026722049340605736,
0.7732000946998596,
0.6583986878395081,
-0.2334248572587967,
-0.27444639801979065,
-0.21059547364711761,
-0.31702712178230286,
0.7346584796905518,
0.061386290937662125,
0.23599667847156525,
-0.08938915282487869,
0.09088960289955139,
0.10359621047973633,
-0.8145378828048706,
0.1865893006324768,
0.3323203921318054,
0.04686151444911957,
-0.24827197194099426,
0.8602530360221863,
-0.40303075313568115,
0.9063867926597595,
0.19031591713428497,
-0.02256532572209835,
0.2594574987888336,
-0.22690635919570923,
-0.08743070811033249,
-0.17091508209705353,
0.704099178314209,
0.09989924728870392,
0.6261263489723206,
-0.06008089706301689,
-0.44152140617370605,
0.39478132128715515,
-0.1917392909526825,
-0.767401397228241,
-0.3978899419307709,
0.1438707411289215,
-0.18881180882453918,
-0.44912347197532654,
-0.05620260536670685,
-0.5720759630203247,
-0.4482574164867401,
-0.5035030841827393,
0.5186697840690613,
-0.5935069918632507,
-0.25364211201667786,
0.3958628475666046,
0.2660907506942749,
-0.1032906174659729,
0.5499050617218018,
-0.711079478263855,
0.24368660151958466,
0.786564290523529,
0.6925020217895508,
0.2554670572280884,
-0.056857913732528687,
-1.0620912313461304,
0.10850638151168823,
-0.3074674904346466,
0.7474157214164734,
-0.9737765789031982,
-0.18286633491516113,
0.033623043447732925,
-0.16828061640262604,
-0.012135220691561699,
-0.4804489016532898,
0.3458710014820099,
-0.5885367393493652,
0.29649198055267334,
-0.012193418107926846,
-0.7228987216949463,
-0.2394416630268097,
0.3317055106163025,
-0.7006006240844727,
1.1983342170715332,
0.2544794976711273,
-0.6424317955970764,
-0.3334256410598755,
-0.8076530694961548,
-0.6399776339530945,
0.08496322482824326,
-0.34751495718955994,
-0.43301424384117126,
0.3059338927268982,
0.39461013674736023,
0.13655485212802887,
-0.32334601879119873,
0.22901654243469238,
-0.5359702706336975,
-0.2138860672712326,
0.14343194663524628,
-0.1308981031179428,
0.9197229743003845,
0.06483335793018341,
-0.43698084354400635,
0.14277689158916473,
-1.1702382564544678,
0.028768887743353844,
0.09113261103630066,
-0.3868211507797241,
-0.21148093044757843,
0.05971691384911537,
-0.7673963308334351,
0.08310507982969284,
0.19867776334285736,
-0.16172289848327637,
0.7025262117385864,
-0.4219755232334137,
0.6436919569969177,
0.5104124546051025,
0.20327740907669067,
0.6758976578712463,
-0.16743682324886322,
0.6244663596153259,
0.09074921160936356,
-0.0876227393746376,
-0.2813686430454254,
-0.4042968451976776,
-0.8439772129058838,
0.09816160053014755,
0.6146302819252014,
0.4072275161743164,
-1.086377739906311,
0.41453874111175537,
-0.20329642295837402,
-0.4456501007080078,
0.19153930246829987,
0.06172572448849678,
0.447609007358551,
0.7151906490325928,
0.0792226642370224,
-0.03823729231953621,
-0.3206338584423065,
-0.3822242319583893,
-0.10952483862638474,
-0.717993438243866,
-0.05736375227570534,
-0.07901279628276825,
0.5084755420684814,
-0.09817357361316681,
0.42674264311790466,
-0.4272157549858093,
0.11879605799913406,
-0.18115700781345367,
0.3927385210990906,
0.23718228936195374,
0.3502653241157532,
0.35964852571487427,
-0.5863720178604126,
-0.2774978280067444,
-0.14800964295864105,
-0.6420645713806152,
-0.27704671025276184,
0.008496521040797234,
-0.28044894337654114,
0.2630889415740967,
0.45901957154273987,
-0.6046759486198425,
0.4680037796497345,
0.39328381419181824,
-0.6161924600601196,
0.6860342621803284,
-0.364931583404541,
0.19203023612499237,
-0.5850849151611328,
-0.04128709062933922,
0.093683160841465,
-0.6743761301040649,
-0.44305235147476196,
0.29933544993400574,
0.1638130247592926,
-0.08755706250667572,
-0.11232980340719223,
0.285346657037735,
-0.7259618043899536,
0.06282451748847961,
0.07375742495059967,
-0.3530150353908539,
0.04673030972480774,
0.6208351850509644,
0.24811168015003204,
0.7395159602165222,
0.6591314673423767,
-0.8624688386917114,
0.7471697330474854,
0.08806606382131577,
-0.4248451590538025,
0.4894263744354248,
-0.7417406439781189,
0.26431262493133545,
-0.0013599606463685632,
0.3555184006690979,
-0.7620874643325806,
-0.06487458199262619,
0.17754872143268585,
-0.47587212920188904,
0.3573359251022339,
-0.5975050926208496,
-0.7193824052810669,
-0.26969969272613525,
-0.1728994995355606,
0.3210681676864624,
0.36811959743499756,
-0.29435262084007263,
0.9966275095939636,
0.590905487537384,
-0.09766926616430283,
-0.31368303298950195,
-0.2397531121969223,
-0.04251312091946602,
0.036335136741399765,
-0.9240831732749939,
-0.0379997082054615,
0.1236504539847374,
-0.5120454430580139,
-0.12478123605251312,
-0.09730443358421326,
-0.0181697066873312,
-0.10693880170583725,
-0.02954518422484398,
0.4040951430797577,
-0.27550026774406433,
0.32345131039619446,
-0.3657585680484772,
-0.29752668738365173,
0.2931493818759918,
-0.4350716173648834,
0.48955637216567993,
-0.5992233157157898,
-0.4098983407020569,
-0.10339880734682083,
0.19690507650375366,
0.874861478805542,
-0.6985817551612854,
0.5188075304031372,
0.15005682408809662,
-0.7071045637130737,
-0.17973415553569794,
-0.49899572134017944,
-0.0625094547867775,
-0.43752023577690125,
0.24763880670070648,
-0.5185824632644653,
-0.8454771041870117,
0.6642347574234009,
-0.16301588714122772,
0.08406759798526764,
0.4895748496055603,
0.9763365983963013,
0.09498552232980728,
1.4128755331039429,
0.44775134325027466,
0.10050792247056961,
0.2788548767566681,
-0.500281810760498,
0.2988223135471344,
-0.3686370551586151,
-0.4272698760032654,
-0.718510627746582,
-0.01738513633608818,
-0.36867204308509827,
-0.5779710412025452,
0.4315718710422516,
0.058218736201524734,
-0.3724387288093567,
0.15074418485164642,
-0.3094028830528259,
0.4353432059288025,
0.5409330129623413,
0.09733191132545471,
0.6164615750312805,
0.04316624999046326,
-0.40446290373802185,
0.11891492456197739,
-0.563837468624115,
-0.444010853767395,
0.5477079153060913,
0.34746721386909485,
0.9705066680908203,
0.23634390532970428,
0.3792639672756195,
0.27546998858451843,
0.04730765521526337,
-0.928348958492279,
0.6893376708030701,
-0.0191691555082798,
-0.4817618131637573,
-0.4897388219833374,
-1.0579038858413696,
-0.5592787265777588,
0.09115500003099442,
-0.24983684718608856,
-0.5684595704078674,
0.0873226746916771,
0.45088034868240356,
-0.3513020873069763,
0.3523460030555725,
-0.8143218755722046,
0.8094795346260071,
-0.476353257894516,
-0.5509709119796753,
-0.3033074140548706,
-0.42177334427833557,
0.3445300757884979,
0.06934855878353119,
0.379520982503891,
-0.04311707988381386,
0.1584123969078064,
0.3482525646686554,
-1.202102541923523,
0.5892866253852844,
-0.3180314004421234,
-0.2971290051937103,
0.3846629858016968,
0.5725067257881165,
1.002730131149292,
0.25454843044281006,
-0.3203106224536896,
-0.09931382536888123,
0.2011699229478836,
-0.18666569888591766,
-0.9277647733688354,
0.4697640538215637,
-0.5069292187690735,
-0.5195117592811584,
-0.6130821704864502,
-0.4553908705711365,
-0.5108430981636047,
0.34062740206718445,
-0.13971258699893951,
0.7753675580024719,
0.4472585618495941,
0.2049766331911087,
0.5956817269325256,
-0.02956392616033554,
0.09952801465988159,
0.5009699463844299,
-0.5998666882514954,
-0.401231050491333,
0.5568070411682129,
0.11018453538417816,
0.2069300413131714,
0.5026290416717529,
0.40160101652145386,
-0.7410011887550354,
-0.31842923164367676,
-0.6796140670776367,
0.43733879923820496,
-0.5697363615036011,
-0.2782275676727295,
-0.3072373867034912,
-0.12539611756801605,
-0.5595578551292419,
0.4529467523097992,
-0.31855735182762146,
-0.9684910178184509,
0.14520809054374695,
0.07114829868078232,
0.4231088161468506,
0.7825382947921753,
-0.10510646551847458,
-0.2344459891319275,
-0.9794329404830933,
0.628354549407959,
0.364373117685318,
0.6066230535507202,
0.12608680129051208,
-0.6131057143211365,
-0.1946142017841339,
0.13727188110351562,
0.012515481561422348,
-0.9359990954399109,
0.14227545261383057,
0.17973622679710388,
0.23018352687358856,
0.36784830689430237,
0.298230916261673,
0.8320316672325134,
-0.6046476364135742,
0.4072457253932953,
0.17863193154335022,
-1.0609605312347412,
0.40472954511642456,
-0.15923331677913666,
0.20935142040252686,
0.34906017780303955,
0.02781542018055916,
-0.31345751881599426,
-0.3379072844982147,
-0.5592341423034668,
-0.4563090205192566,
0.5681876540184021,
0.41801291704177856,
0.013034915551543236,
0.1790277510881424,
0.3641511797904968,
-0.42899030447006226,
0.11818979680538177,
-0.7512807846069336,
-0.18505224585533142,
-0.07161810249090195,
-0.029179714620113373,
0.28356802463531494,
-0.38918134570121765,
-0.058287885040044785,
-0.5784661769866943,
0.7767391204833984,
-0.09069417417049408,
0.26655450463294983,
-0.10879077762365341,
-0.05618609860539436,
-0.3693494200706482,
0.08990497142076492,
0.2717956006526947,
0.961567759513855,
-0.02553354948759079,
0.40117067098617554,
0.04740650951862335,
-0.3148241341114044,
0.3442907929420471,
0.23810887336730957,
-0.19636458158493042,
0.1473337560892105,
0.42430999875068665,
0.44464755058288574,
0.22477687895298004,
-0.30375194549560547,
0.5097259283065796,
-0.15738797187805176,
-0.003999135456979275,
-0.4429158866405487,
0.13530026376247406,
0.1611250936985016,
0.05087107792496681,
0.08082296699285507,
-0.10283073037862778,
0.07104787230491638,
-0.6759615540504456,
0.14338238537311554,
0.2560451030731201,
0.0388660803437233,
-0.2438340038061142,
0.5758259296417236,
0.3540981411933899,
-0.48672470450401306,
0.7800461649894714,
-0.35727110505104065,
-0.7435795068740845,
0.506973147392273,
0.4815848469734192,
0.4133087992668152,
-0.132443368434906,
0.2795107364654541,
0.5907670259475708,
0.17218180000782013,
-0.2725858688354492,
0.31515324115753174,
-0.12845459580421448,
-0.5181394815444946,
-0.9054750204086304,
-0.5520074963569641,
-0.7163652181625366,
0.003062685951590538,
-0.43764951825141907,
0.624484658241272,
-0.4004819393157959,
0.012249023653566837,
0.23065851628780365,
0.15837809443473816,
-0.33350953459739685,
0.1476869285106659,
0.1811244636774063,
1.0031578540802002,
-0.6992243528366089,
0.9049125909805298,
1.135151743888855,
-0.543613612651825,
-1.1490048170089722,
-0.3370908498764038,
-0.1326054185628891,
-0.7391157150268555,
0.3229878544807434,
0.1736081838607788,
-0.25689053535461426,
-0.04111594706773758,
-0.5361626148223877,
-0.6001740097999573,
0.4213011860847473,
0.6153324246406555,
-0.6660962104797363,
-0.24442563951015472,
0.2503925561904907,
0.706203818321228,
-0.11263319849967957,
0.4225885570049286,
0.38011330366134644,
0.5494520664215088,
0.5856053829193115,
-0.7088882327079773,
-0.020886924117803574,
-0.5219902992248535,
-0.1226043552160263,
0.5433939099311829,
-0.5241447687149048,
0.5587217211723328,
-0.2889688014984131,
-0.08648338913917542,
-0.05223407223820686,
0.8512476682662964,
0.42798635363578796,
0.18476492166519165,
0.900205135345459,
0.7360706925392151,
0.8570494651794434,
-0.1668137013912201,
1.0820494890213013,
-0.44002994894981384,
0.41902172565460205,
1.0288434028625488,
-0.11756762862205505,
0.6516621112823486,
0.05250206217169762,
-0.6109207272529602,
0.8014241456985474,
0.414307564496994,
0.03204474598169327,
0.004402562975883484,
0.2548450827598572,
-0.31162992119789124,
-0.743999183177948,
0.2460906207561493,
-0.3551410734653473,
0.3876541554927826,
0.37451428174972534,
-0.13799701631069183,
-0.16034898161888123,
-0.5768133997917175,
0.15370860695838928,
0.17984910309314728,
-0.3507465422153473,
0.512766420841217,
0.07218245416879654,
-0.8383272886276245,
0.6424039602279663,
0.24089272320270538,
0.08098048716783524,
-0.4992867112159729,
-0.5779618620872498,
-0.23933975398540497,
0.3259764015674591,
-0.41242077946662903,
-0.7331113219261169,
0.3865337073802948,
0.19080190360546112,
-0.03414858132600784,
0.11167296767234802,
0.6664989590644836,
-0.4633346199989319,
-1.0224837064743042,
-0.0633777379989624,
0.3858111500740051,
0.05271391570568085,
-0.1871057152748108,
-0.7282853722572327,
-0.1000608429312706,
0.11033573746681213,
-0.0352821908891201,
-0.26131558418273926,
0.934014081954956,
-0.3420693278312683,
0.6656835675239563,
0.7458009719848633,
0.3769412040710449,
-0.09457006305456161,
0.4091936945915222,
0.7666028141975403,
-0.5711166858673096,
-0.5973944664001465,
-1.0157467126846313,
0.48781999945640564,
-0.19555337727069855,
0.14917609095573425,
0.5126216411590576,
0.69779372215271,
0.5860195159912109,
-0.01050750631839037,
0.5394121408462524,
-0.21160657703876495,
0.5309643149375916,
-0.5621212720870972,
0.3900661766529083,
-0.2899956703186035,
0.579886794090271,
-0.08659020811319351,
-0.8892626166343689,
-0.6263457536697388,
0.9313970804214478,
-0.375741183757782,
0.1492573320865631,
0.6286803483963013,
0.7937276363372803,
-0.048630982637405396,
-0.024530358612537384,
0.13657818734645844,
0.5124570727348328,
0.44223836064338684,
0.7352989912033081,
1.0370672941207886,
-0.08797978609800339,
0.6445908546447754,
-0.5799246430397034,
-0.4825263023376465,
0.0011027514701709151,
-1.2204008102416992,
-0.9361202120780945,
-0.24478456377983093,
-0.6626961827278137,
-0.7678338289260864,
-0.2521074712276459,
0.9036388397216797,
0.5064424872398376,
-0.8888003826141357,
-0.15485480427742004,
-0.1675567477941513,
0.33406782150268555,
-0.13630934059619904,
-0.17940233647823334,
0.41838353872299194,
-0.1724437177181244,
-0.7033320069313049,
-0.02432866394519806,
0.48766425251960754,
-0.13227185606956482,
-0.44515538215637207,
-0.13964273035526276,
-0.11210516840219498,
-0.030057081952691078,
0.6983435153961182,
0.3025238811969757,
-0.33694595098495483,
-0.2764117121696472,
-0.02637086994946003,
0.06372891366481781,
0.1575695425271988,
0.8392178416252136,
-0.7070239782333374,
0.5669171810150146,
0.8234297633171082,
0.4810412526130676,
0.3758971393108368,
0.11187838017940521,
0.8424814939498901,
-0.28690963983535767,
-0.07142829149961472,
0.2536334991455078,
0.8445881009101868,
0.3700244724750519,
-0.34783533215522766,
0.8782173991203308,
0.35105541348457336,
-0.473605215549469,
-0.8077142238616943,
0.387612909078598,
-0.7390148043632507,
0.2361680418252945,
1.2922799587249756,
-0.33815354108810425,
-0.2025551199913025,
-0.05126667022705078,
-0.22914770245552063,
0.28844359517097473,
-0.24229611456394196,
0.9027904868125916,
0.7799990773200989,
-0.36542055010795593,
-0.22979192435741425,
-0.052166737616062164,
0.2486259788274765,
0.21235854923725128,
-0.8294277191162109,
0.1657017469406128,
0.9518952965736389,
0.13739120960235596,
0.16528324782848358,
0.40041103959083557,
-0.6969959735870361,
0.4379459023475647,
-0.2707810401916504,
-0.18031466007232666,
-0.37361598014831543,
-0.14227402210235596,
-0.238515704870224,
0.02322465367615223,
0.15977327525615692,
0.035755012184381485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17764v1 | BMIKE-53: Investigating Cross-Lingual Knowledge Editing with In-Context Learning | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | 2024-06-25T17:48:56 | Ercong Nie, Bo Shao, Zifeng Ding, Mingyang Wang, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) possess extensive parametric knowledge, but this
knowledge is difficult to update with new information because retraining is
very expensive and infeasible for closed-source models. Knowledge editing (KE)
has emerged as a viable solution for updating the knowledge of LLMs without
compromising their overall performance. On-the-fly KE methods, inspired by
in-context learning (ICL), have shown great promise and allow LLMs to be
treated as black boxes. In the past, KE was primarily employed in English
contexts, whereas the potential for cross-lingual KE in current English-centric
LLMs has not been fully explored. To foster more research in this direction, we
introduce the BMIKE-53 benchmark for evaluating cross-lingual KE on 53 diverse
languages across three KE task types. We also propose a gradient-free KE method
called Multilingual In-context Knowledge Editing (MIKE) and evaluate it on
BMIKE-53. Our evaluation focuses on cross-lingual knowledge transfer in terms
of reliability, generality, locality, and portability, offering valuable
insights and a framework for future research in cross-lingual KE. Our code and
data are publicly accessible via the anonymous repository at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/MIKE. | [
-0.1469324231147766,
-0.5084971189498901,
0.3170102834701538,
0.3137836754322052,
0.06120819225907326,
0.19248619675636292,
-0.6400469541549683,
-0.6101043224334717,
-0.002069785725325346,
0.16714084148406982,
-0.469524085521698,
-0.6622909307479858,
-0.49490994215011597,
0.25322309136390686,
-0.1588440239429474,
0.5684797167778015,
-0.1755577027797699,
0.4934721291065216,
-0.23684990406036377,
-0.2996307611465454,
-0.4988780617713928,
-0.2882031798362732,
-0.5606732964515686,
-0.11052194982767105,
0.5416691303253174,
0.8446985483169556,
0.42650777101516724,
0.37281644344329834,
0.34379714727401733,
0.16257137060165405,
-0.3199983835220337,
0.13325177133083344,
-0.6389247179031372,
-0.07014303654432297,
-0.4929972290992737,
-0.5145377516746521,
-0.5530930757522583,
-0.25417760014533997,
0.9982858300209045,
1.0658081769943237,
0.13500583171844482,
0.17055408656597137,
0.15914808213710785,
0.7392199039459229,
-0.8586097359657288,
-0.03746245056390762,
-0.7655211091041565,
0.12793056666851044,
-0.2275017499923706,
0.05892813950777054,
-0.4855791926383972,
-0.017754707485437393,
0.24257539212703705,
-0.8289704322814941,
-0.09925219416618347,
0.18268989026546478,
0.5198681950569153,
0.23949573934078217,
-0.36294981837272644,
-0.25615230202674866,
-0.19463258981704712,
0.7545296549797058,
-0.7392534017562866,
1.120215892791748,
0.4624452292919159,
0.10404817014932632,
-0.051920074969530106,
-0.40747493505477905,
-0.34108826518058777,
-0.05369943752884865,
-0.16291241347789764,
0.10626976937055588,
-0.17836648225784302,
-0.18176351487636566,
0.37741661071777344,
0.13812629878520966,
-0.4075457751750946,
0.3365255296230316,
-0.28992316126823425,
-0.20505601167678833,
0.4975946843624115,
0.09306650608778,
0.33621150255203247,
-0.2775548994541168,
-0.34007537364959717,
0.154338538646698,
-0.9741047024726868,
0.09786967933177948,
0.23038500547409058,
-0.019510949030518532,
-0.32143980264663696,
0.7995341420173645,
-0.4431186020374298,
0.6735312342643738,
0.24890635907649994,
-0.19218392670154572,
0.21411921083927155,
-0.3351997137069702,
-0.25839537382125854,
0.2561338245868683,
0.7266966104507446,
0.7461214661598206,
0.18720661103725433,
-0.36909016966819763,
-0.0553467720746994,
-0.680981457233429,
-0.17299015820026398,
-0.8127870559692383,
0.10348730534315109,
-0.06205269321799278,
-0.3186771869659424,
-0.012667607516050339,
-0.28338128328323364,
-0.7339972257614136,
-0.4343380630016327,
-0.102664515376091,
0.4717455506324768,
-0.6151703000068665,
-0.03220314159989357,
0.2779654264450073,
-0.08796438574790955,
-0.08199843764305115,
0.4537780284881592,
-0.6771689057350159,
-0.15653519332408905,
0.5597733855247498,
0.7625501751899719,
-0.10616277903318405,
-0.8014212846755981,
-0.4392200708389282,
0.6930157542228699,
-0.5356641411781311,
0.36865803599357605,
-0.5152522921562195,
-0.5215272307395935,
-0.043527454137802124,
0.06566881388425827,
-0.07688160240650177,
-0.5023998618125916,
0.16274301707744598,
-0.4580140709877014,
0.35397154092788696,
-0.6311811804771423,
-0.9078983664512634,
-0.25051620602607727,
0.41710349917411804,
-0.502647340297699,
1.073899507522583,
0.05549732595682144,
-0.9634285569190979,
0.6906279921531677,
-0.6742696762084961,
-0.5182338356971741,
-0.05295456945896149,
0.33452078700065613,
-0.10445944219827652,
0.025563927367329597,
0.3346271812915802,
0.6618918776512146,
-0.29562410712242126,
0.1449621617794037,
-0.30923235416412354,
-0.3423517048358917,
0.15634238719940186,
-0.06737514585256577,
0.8008173704147339,
-0.13598355650901794,
-0.29343900084495544,
-0.03129925578832626,
-0.8394940495491028,
-0.39503076672554016,
-0.2623109221458435,
-0.6078011989593506,
-0.6889551877975464,
-0.3169296979904175,
-0.18306277692317963,
0.27823954820632935,
0.41425979137420654,
-0.9464673399925232,
0.08486093580722809,
-0.15466663241386414,
0.04534072056412697,
0.5284835696220398,
0.03613807260990143,
0.49411147832870483,
-0.27200692892074585,
0.44093266129493713,
0.010420965030789375,
-0.0050732712261378765,
0.07736236602067947,
-0.4261041283607483,
-0.6107799410820007,
-0.36807185411453247,
0.49075737595558167,
0.5859203934669495,
-0.8784370422363281,
0.07207980006933212,
-0.4610067903995514,
-0.5871894359588623,
-0.4719761312007904,
0.4748493731021881,
0.42637211084365845,
0.7743116617202759,
0.502520740032196,
-0.1224776953458786,
-0.3433116376399994,
-0.8319975733757019,
-0.6501821875572205,
0.059863392263650894,
-0.10888493806123734,
0.269422709941864,
0.3976981043815613,
-0.3412797749042511,
0.7473987340927124,
-0.23434732854366302,
-0.19292515516281128,
-0.298007994890213,
-0.13018475472927094,
-0.3749314546585083,
0.44117748737335205,
0.6277101039886475,
-0.31650057435035706,
-0.8023251891136169,
0.3611759543418884,
-0.7954438328742981,
-0.31446632742881775,
-0.0234089232981205,
-0.425779789686203,
0.18743549287319183,
0.7348334193229675,
-0.5391170382499695,
0.15617553889751434,
0.6643379926681519,
-0.2561226189136505,
0.4441010653972626,
0.08241503685712814,
0.37306952476501465,
-1.1157243251800537,
0.30869245529174805,
0.008599509485065937,
-0.21977750957012177,
-0.5320621728897095,
-0.007471148855984211,
0.5321802496910095,
-0.08639824390411377,
-0.6427456736564636,
0.8523818254470825,
-0.36940059065818787,
-0.06260673701763153,
0.17914538085460663,
-0.03900184854865074,
-0.11076962947845459,
0.6505268812179565,
0.007387704681605101,
0.6666103601455688,
0.3465825617313385,
-0.31673622131347656,
0.11523686349391937,
0.22485388815402985,
-0.7029328346252441,
0.8529729843139648,
-0.16431915760040283,
0.00553919468075037,
-0.04526656121015549,
0.2840465009212494,
-0.6670815348625183,
-0.05219441279768944,
0.28854912519454956,
-0.33090952038764954,
0.26005539298057556,
-0.20115356147289276,
-0.5589094161987305,
0.28754937648773193,
-0.34347087144851685,
0.44208452105522156,
-0.1152440682053566,
-0.5401781797409058,
0.4502072036266327,
0.23409590125083923,
-0.14577947556972504,
-0.7877720594406128,
-0.9095596075057983,
0.29121747612953186,
-0.19675956666469574,
-0.5217472910881042,
0.37073230743408203,
-0.23316724598407745,
-0.23988784849643707,
0.22203074395656586,
-0.1264813244342804,
0.046598587185144424,
0.0297267846763134,
-0.29353615641593933,
-0.056671615689992905,
-0.06386920064687729,
-0.006784510798752308,
0.43247607350349426,
0.15883667767047882,
0.0934382900595665,
-0.1545289158821106,
-0.04561861604452133,
0.3224118649959564,
-0.26220962405204773,
-0.36377784609794617,
0.29887527227401733,
0.8133936524391174,
-0.2531645596027374,
0.5728316307067871,
0.559921145439148,
-0.5636447072029114,
-0.4091745913028717,
-0.48739567399024963,
0.1632537692785263,
-0.42551755905151367,
0.6147907972335815,
-0.5273452401161194,
-1.153549313545227,
0.51254802942276,
-0.14337009191513062,
0.3157362639904022,
0.2347021996974945,
0.6960404515266418,
-0.02712167613208294,
0.44772106409072876,
0.537692129611969,
-0.019695743918418884,
0.5269216895103455,
-0.11613257974386215,
-0.004721543285995722,
-0.9848140478134155,
-0.2594394385814667,
-0.24937504529953003,
-0.5850952863693237,
-0.33222901821136475,
-0.4885138273239136,
0.5838990211486816,
-0.00489600095897913,
-0.04687515273690224,
0.17338144779205322,
0.2555926740169525,
0.5415729880332947,
0.334803968667984,
0.14509551227092743,
0.37354084849357605,
-0.28210628032684326,
-0.4971323609352112,
-0.1424805074930191,
-1.0083072185516357,
0.21003669500350952,
1.2869036197662354,
0.33994555473327637,
0.6929599046707153,
0.29941990971565247,
0.4543391168117523,
0.09708373248577118,
0.5248861312866211,
-0.8030067682266235,
0.6438168287277222,
-0.2942742705345154,
-0.7236164212226868,
-0.4876351058483124,
-0.5617616176605225,
-0.5872176885604858,
0.2925640046596527,
-0.19889529049396515,
-0.6163080930709839,
0.35385483503341675,
0.1978015899658203,
-0.09264558553695679,
0.6610307693481445,
-0.7666718363761902,
1.0361889600753784,
-0.1982465237379074,
-0.596088707447052,
-0.4438149333000183,
-0.6836598515510559,
0.49956512451171875,
-0.3592236340045929,
0.38950440287590027,
-0.012273699976503849,
-0.24349993467330933,
0.7117427587509155,
-0.3150087893009186,
0.7871152758598328,
-0.19443169236183167,
-0.2747769355773926,
-0.13225547969341278,
0.5154330134391785,
0.4081343412399292,
0.12694141268730164,
-0.17425678670406342,
0.3441843092441559,
-0.015088747255504131,
-0.3395622968673706,
-0.7167612910270691,
0.6258748173713684,
-0.48281461000442505,
-0.3985176384449005,
0.013253889046609402,
-0.9377195239067078,
-0.8283891081809998,
0.20788343250751495,
0.13991326093673706,
0.4707702100276947,
-0.14645546674728394,
0.4990566372871399,
0.45367610454559326,
-0.4492328464984894,
0.36574676632881165,
0.6923547983169556,
-0.23855164647102356,
-0.4729595184326172,
0.773139476776123,
0.3565118610858917,
0.34186679124832153,
0.9471209049224854,
0.4202379286289215,
-0.13226912915706635,
-0.38004958629608154,
-0.7262357473373413,
0.15031327307224274,
-0.7999247312545776,
-0.09959634393453598,
-0.6864514946937561,
0.1720883548259735,
-0.12531673908233643,
-0.48846977949142456,
-0.4179137647151947,
-0.534841775894165,
0.23835301399230957,
-0.010641643777489662,
0.2819356918334961,
0.6352812647819519,
-0.39254021644592285,
0.14513905346393585,
-0.7363781332969666,
0.04766441881656647,
0.2736320197582245,
0.5534446835517883,
0.22725756466388702,
-0.39882776141166687,
-0.9910487532615662,
0.06801412254571915,
0.13817472755908966,
-0.9267876148223877,
0.04149658977985382,
0.10339883714914322,
0.5016512870788574,
0.030684566125273705,
-0.1574729084968567,
0.757286787033081,
-0.4570358693599701,
0.6109600067138672,
0.10596980154514313,
-1.1931651830673218,
0.07456903159618378,
-0.39853635430336,
0.6098741292953491,
0.6387914419174194,
0.6139340996742249,
-1.066463589668274,
-0.39261123538017273,
-0.19416555762290955,
-0.4936482906341553,
0.5098959803581238,
-0.34244009852409363,
-0.115019790828228,
0.4482545554637909,
0.1408461183309555,
0.3768196105957031,
0.39111563563346863,
-0.447581022977829,
0.030075471848249435,
-0.10999816656112671,
-0.23813870549201965,
-0.11092475056648254,
-0.3387383818626404,
0.11718825250864029,
-0.6355776786804199,
0.7704242467880249,
-0.07984694838523865,
-0.2517744302749634,
0.22323308885097504,
-0.6434470415115356,
-0.2839251160621643,
0.22547727823257446,
0.603366494178772,
0.9337174892425537,
-0.24119000136852264,
0.0008760819910094142,
0.7329248785972595,
-0.462412029504776,
-0.06440316140651703,
-0.1299431324005127,
-0.26649144291877747,
-0.04617191106081009,
0.4872581660747528,
0.6555261611938477,
0.9820020794868469,
-0.6663744449615479,
0.35562482476234436,
0.001037358189933002,
-0.28352686762809753,
0.2729877829551697,
-0.2864490747451782,
0.14904426038265228,
0.023256679996848106,
0.0716094896197319,
-0.10785216838121414,
-0.025519568473100662,
-0.4460400938987732,
0.057484421879053116,
0.23118999600410461,
-0.1346634477376938,
-0.2838697135448456,
0.6465065479278564,
0.34395456314086914,
-0.05967329069972038,
0.311943918466568,
-0.18696057796478271,
-0.5580301880836487,
-0.08796972036361694,
0.27058783173561096,
0.7446867823600769,
-0.23030602931976318,
-0.13899405300617218,
0.34227490425109863,
0.5062265992164612,
0.3000056743621826,
0.01591508835554123,
-0.1275981217622757,
-0.8583621978759766,
-0.7607110738754272,
-0.41591188311576843,
-0.8283640742301941,
0.18228904902935028,
-0.34874027967453003,
0.34462982416152954,
-0.4344992935657501,
0.2463553547859192,
-0.03052658587694168,
0.008776125498116016,
-0.7063760161399841,
0.21189622581005096,
-0.08828020840883255,
1.1626687049865723,
-0.6320180296897888,
0.775861382484436,
0.986691415309906,
0.1354629248380661,
-0.6406497955322266,
0.24695850908756256,
0.18498381972312927,
-0.636637806892395,
0.3591575622558594,
-0.1086418554186821,
-0.09699829667806625,
-0.038197875022888184,
-0.31472668051719666,
-0.8783453702926636,
0.9477201104164124,
0.5898473262786865,
-0.6760047078132629,
-0.017357343807816505,
0.20998260378837585,
0.2417629361152649,
0.07708105444908142,
-0.06704483181238174,
0.32127952575683594,
0.6488263010978699,
-0.09846550971269608,
-1.1658477783203125,
0.01249944418668747,
-0.05878801643848419,
-0.35271787643432617,
0.013554967008531094,
-0.8920352458953857,
0.4929533898830414,
0.03400074318051338,
0.18210460245609283,
-0.3355449438095093,
0.5108816027641296,
-0.006342841777950525,
0.15018784999847412,
0.5734184980392456,
0.8194663524627686,
0.688433051109314,
0.3814786970615387,
0.6610726714134216,
-0.6608031392097473,
0.20161376893520355,
0.969317615032196,
-0.41159787774086,
0.7197682857513428,
0.48639801144599915,
0.07940869778394699,
0.45240411162376404,
0.5434532165527344,
0.18476462364196777,
0.3338089883327484,
-0.006978633347898722,
-0.1918945610523224,
-0.24374431371688843,
0.07145407050848007,
-0.19711466133594513,
0.6261364221572876,
0.2787008583545685,
0.09843722730875015,
-0.23902775347232819,
0.09235479682683945,
0.5639598965644836,
-0.23307913541793823,
-0.4103831946849823,
0.532789409160614,
0.007177453022450209,
-0.5855329036712646,
0.25796619057655334,
0.3171606957912445,
0.8235518336296082,
-0.7735106348991394,
0.14979545772075653,
-0.28180059790611267,
-0.06687603890895844,
-0.22803373634815216,
-0.7913747429847717,
0.32487252354621887,
0.2411477416753769,
-0.07728075981140137,
-0.3615507483482361,
0.5769055485725403,
-0.6870181560516357,
-0.6241815090179443,
0.5072107911109924,
0.7506598234176636,
-0.07968051731586456,
0.2005583643913269,
-0.5638821721076965,
-0.009818431921303272,
-0.024992339313030243,
-0.3318183422088623,
0.45095640420913696,
0.7796006202697754,
-0.11502601206302643,
0.6350945234298706,
0.6130791306495667,
0.22327540814876556,
0.22672918438911438,
-0.1450963020324707,
0.5340903401374817,
-0.5596386790275574,
-0.6458346843719482,
-0.6945080757141113,
0.51161128282547,
0.14701491594314575,
-0.5084207057952881,
0.9877693057060242,
0.9318957924842834,
1.47673499584198,
-0.05397472530603409,
0.8592187762260437,
-0.07014471292495728,
0.5329546928405762,
-0.6586839556694031,
1.025349736213684,
-0.9909186959266663,
-0.06690084934234619,
-0.46771982312202454,
-0.6207233667373657,
-0.3197936713695526,
0.2087404429912567,
-0.37686899304389954,
-0.19910253584384918,
0.8832922577857971,
0.8289908170700073,
-0.2703477442264557,
-0.04164586961269379,
0.5085569620132446,
0.27771157026290894,
-0.1544339954853058,
0.6629163026809692,
0.7224822044372559,
-0.05042218789458275,
0.39168763160705566,
-0.6167394518852234,
-0.05166003853082657,
-0.07053191214799881,
-0.7683828473091125,
-0.9822505712509155,
-0.476467102766037,
-0.22788438200950623,
0.011576082557439804,
0.23616433143615723,
0.9235137104988098,
0.6120476126670837,
-0.5039733648300171,
-0.5793479681015015,
0.4267439842224121,
0.37534916400909424,
-0.33376872539520264,
-0.1416986584663391,
0.3606095314025879,
-0.12819035351276398,
-0.7851775288581848,
0.7633191347122192,
0.17839667201042175,
-0.29345983266830444,
-0.16631370782852173,
-0.07718444615602493,
-0.3532066345214844,
-0.1516914665699005,
0.7076663374900818,
0.07172130793333054,
-0.28163063526153564,
-0.30702444911003113,
-0.06806066632270813,
0.011583584360778332,
-0.029776668176054955,
0.8402237296104431,
-0.3618965446949005,
0.48949432373046875,
0.5889373421669006,
1.0724948644638062,
0.3604575991630554,
-0.30584144592285156,
0.720653235912323,
-0.9289325475692749,
0.13467015326023102,
-0.1416473537683487,
0.5911661386489868,
0.5792028307914734,
-0.3124328553676605,
0.39985769987106323,
0.42829430103302,
-0.3812714219093323,
-0.822397768497467,
-0.062346965074539185,
-0.7681896090507507,
-0.3042055666446686,
1.3462274074554443,
-0.2584434151649475,
-0.10391804575920105,
0.05998673290014267,
-0.13043615221977234,
0.21510204672813416,
-0.16119705140590668,
0.4637499153614044,
1.0053675174713135,
0.10108479857444763,
-0.24381037056446075,
-0.5824589729309082,
0.441468745470047,
0.6335026025772095,
-0.6695170998573303,
0.23523251712322235,
0.4848136603832245,
0.622614324092865,
-0.3887576460838318,
0.2933420240879059,
0.10433035343885422,
0.4997485876083374,
-0.26118212938308716,
0.13694313168525696,
-0.20000199973583221,
-0.3169958293437958,
-0.168924018740654,
0.11332052946090698,
-0.047101933509111404,
-0.014909454621374607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17761v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17761v2 | CaLMQA: Exploring culturally specific long-form question answering across 23 languages | 2024-06-25T17:45:26 | 2024-07-03T16:33:55 | Shane Arora, Marzena Karpinska, Hung-Ting Chen, Ipsita Bhattacharjee, Mohit Iyyer, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are used for long-form question answering
(LFQA), which requires them to generate paragraph-length answers to complex
questions. While LFQA has been well-studied in English, this research has not
been extended to other languages. To bridge this gap, we introduce CaLMQA, a
collection of 1.5K complex culturally specific questions spanning 23 languages
and 51 culturally agnostic questions translated from English into 22 other
languages. We define culturally specific questions as those uniquely or more
likely to be asked by people from cultures associated with the question's
language. We collect naturally-occurring questions from community web forums
and hire native speakers to write questions to cover under-resourced,
rarely-studied languages such as Fijian and Kirundi. Our dataset contains
diverse, complex questions that reflect cultural topics (e.g. traditions, laws,
news) and the language usage of native speakers. We automatically evaluate a
suite of open- and closed-source models on CaLMQA by detecting incorrect
language and token repetitions in answers, and observe that the quality of
LLM-generated answers degrades significantly for some low-resource languages.
Lastly, we perform human evaluation on a subset of models and languages. Manual
evaluation reveals that model performance is significantly worse for culturally
specific questions than for culturally agnostic questions. Our findings
highlight the need for further research in non-English LFQA and provide an
evaluation framework. | [
-0.47948622703552246,
-0.9042711853981018,
0.3211227059364319,
0.3146655261516571,
-0.2182939201593399,
0.2776736617088318,
-0.498090535402298,
-0.7894073128700256,
0.0804196298122406,
0.3683387041091919,
-0.6671722531318665,
-0.316406786441803,
-0.10030950605869293,
0.3838637173175812,
-0.01596011593937874,
0.5006992220878601,
-0.41239655017852783,
0.24862276017665863,
-0.004190907813608646,
-0.44579312205314636,
-0.11699975281953812,
-0.5099543333053589,
-0.649672269821167,
-0.1638757586479187,
0.5650097727775574,
0.5030882358551025,
0.6678444147109985,
0.11356262117624283,
0.3306507170200348,
0.20353953540325165,
-0.36683931946754456,
0.1012452244758606,
-0.7052455544471741,
0.15851028263568878,
-0.254805326461792,
-0.5810772776603699,
-0.048656266182661057,
-0.10939138382673264,
0.3557581603527069,
0.7451645731925964,
-0.10252944380044937,
0.5419461727142334,
-0.3356332778930664,
0.3490203022956848,
-0.6950666308403015,
-0.1998210996389389,
-0.40880492329597473,
0.24986548721790314,
-0.1783408671617508,
0.030944468453526497,
-0.20033732056617737,
-0.619425892829895,
-0.04976210370659828,
-0.3459376394748688,
-0.01645526848733425,
-0.28569284081459045,
0.685981810092926,
0.29994532465934753,
-1.0180248022079468,
-0.285410076379776,
-0.7377057075500488,
0.8538068532943726,
-0.5602785348892212,
0.42758044600486755,
0.48777687549591064,
0.23983579874038696,
-0.3115765154361725,
-0.5633586645126343,
-0.6633251309394836,
-0.10369795560836792,
0.16993474960327148,
0.3251335024833679,
-0.20530754327774048,
-0.1476963311433792,
0.13209259510040283,
0.49511799216270447,
-0.7703551054000854,
0.2839931547641754,
-0.34399479627609253,
-0.3631649911403656,
0.7252563834190369,
0.2562815248966217,
0.4258439242839813,
-0.1126955896615982,
-0.2948336601257324,
0.14805220067501068,
-0.6980849504470825,
0.8175563216209412,
0.22065408527851105,
0.054150886833667755,
-0.11894404143095016,
0.3296864628791809,
-0.6718229055404663,
0.599149763584137,
0.030452385544776917,
-0.33464616537094116,
-0.14618508517742157,
-0.0030067013576626778,
0.002182002179324627,
-0.16600511968135834,
0.6614978313446045,
0.28680339455604553,
0.3435780704021454,
-0.04143168032169342,
-0.04266572371125221,
-0.16785864531993866,
-0.22719025611877441,
-0.8222470283508301,
0.09702590852975845,
0.4734136462211609,
-0.2598104774951935,
-0.17420156300067902,
-0.4588035047054291,
-0.5170835852622986,
-0.4551962912082672,
-0.12137424945831299,
0.119811050593853,
-0.05563099682331085,
-0.4152062237262726,
0.16725341975688934,
0.19311517477035522,
0.7145158648490906,
0.33423662185668945,
-0.4940183162689209,
0.0673867017030716,
0.4684320390224457,
0.20518524944782257,
-0.3106552064418793,
-0.20460551977157593,
-0.1546507626771927,
-0.14325480163097382,
-0.6039290428161621,
0.5704879760742188,
-0.6748278141021729,
-0.4551538825035095,
0.22032323479652405,
0.29929637908935547,
0.26667407155036926,
-0.4784921109676361,
0.7961381077766418,
-0.8848792314529419,
0.37903058528900146,
-0.7016009092330933,
-0.14992965757846832,
-0.22936075925827026,
0.5172385573387146,
-0.4832218885421753,
1.1783673763275146,
0.0914064422249794,
-0.5836952328681946,
0.21536998450756073,
-0.18781960010528564,
-0.47740426659584045,
0.2607977092266083,
-0.12247443944215775,
0.08740178495645523,
0.030072739347815514,
0.31920763850212097,
0.40269190073013306,
-0.7572384476661682,
0.4721563160419464,
-0.0861385390162468,
-0.4450581967830658,
0.5339775085449219,
-0.469811350107193,
0.9583823084831238,
0.6468383073806763,
-0.5246171355247498,
-0.01226869598031044,
-0.5166411399841309,
0.32007017731666565,
0.14137670397758484,
-0.5847276449203491,
-0.1126728504896164,
-0.34369367361068726,
-0.058986786752939224,
0.5769386887550354,
0.3750171959400177,
-0.7341538667678833,
0.0602920800447464,
-0.0037346319295465946,
0.43952664732933044,
0.32108089327812195,
0.2043427675962448,
0.26232534646987915,
-0.35604894161224365,
1.0868593454360962,
0.045243341475725174,
0.10925468057394028,
-0.12690486013889313,
-0.5440731048583984,
-0.7483392357826233,
-0.23444423079490662,
-0.16775473952293396,
0.6945041418075562,
-0.7344473004341125,
-0.3290311098098755,
-0.0013322830200195312,
-0.8000767230987549,
-0.6150981187820435,
0.2596758306026459,
0.28776198625564575,
0.7035964727401733,
0.2893054187297821,
-0.17705699801445007,
-0.10951904207468033,
-0.9132016897201538,
-0.23650187253952026,
-0.33725517988204956,
0.05667947605252266,
0.1618558168411255,
0.39493098855018616,
-0.06208568438887596,
0.6411169767379761,
-0.5355579853057861,
0.26158595085144043,
-0.1524614691734314,
0.14159385859966278,
0.16491033136844635,
0.06489855796098709,
0.393900603055954,
-0.7685715556144714,
-0.43728163838386536,
-0.11431317031383514,
-0.7398891448974609,
0.02029121294617653,
-0.10412437468767166,
-0.3569926619529724,
0.2796837389469147,
0.5275141596794128,
-0.699103593826294,
0.19362685084342957,
0.5034618377685547,
-0.1629543900489807,
0.5397964119911194,
0.21730732917785645,
0.4060381054878235,
-1.2344553470611572,
0.1669929176568985,
-0.209401935338974,
0.04257455840706825,
-0.6715662479400635,
0.6112563610076904,
0.09594439715147018,
-0.4144115746021271,
-0.6152697801589966,
0.7199578881263733,
-0.2798595726490021,
0.43284186720848083,
0.1100725457072258,
-0.1733231097459793,
0.07976597547531128,
0.5049845576286316,
0.3627623915672302,
0.6036925911903381,
0.4067128896713257,
-0.30910930037498474,
0.41809219121932983,
0.11122176796197891,
-0.47649258375167847,
0.4830020070075989,
-0.6036399602890015,
0.4687294065952301,
-0.3242896497249603,
0.48463907837867737,
-0.9213224053382874,
-0.4544139504432678,
-0.06724138557910919,
-0.28244149684906006,
0.050651054829359055,
-0.16490553319454193,
-0.1317480504512787,
-0.416623592376709,
-0.1160062775015831,
0.7982136011123657,
0.5537265539169312,
-0.3537341356277466,
0.3152036666870117,
0.33852458000183105,
-0.41947343945503235,
-0.9399797320365906,
-0.7972576022148132,
-0.014032888226211071,
-0.3866965174674988,
-0.7628056406974792,
-0.26341959834098816,
-0.3224460780620575,
-0.5252243280410767,
-0.3361690938472748,
-0.06914708018302917,
-0.4600309729576111,
0.39398643374443054,
-0.0031623870600014925,
-0.17281000316143036,
-0.5194072127342224,
0.16982541978359222,
-0.008532283827662468,
0.46748366951942444,
0.24036720395088196,
-0.07522442191839218,
0.6126894950866699,
-0.31873655319213867,
-0.3134223222732544,
-0.2474232167005539,
0.8823443651199341,
0.8218284249305725,
-0.7879012823104858,
0.5680592656135559,
0.8561237454414368,
-0.5484793782234192,
-0.15937858819961548,
-0.7290291786193848,
0.013631942681968212,
-0.4859645366668701,
0.29860901832580566,
-0.598800778388977,
-1.3558069467544556,
1.0349147319793701,
0.12803414463996887,
0.01908131130039692,
0.3483794927597046,
0.8416019082069397,
-0.20119275152683258,
0.8059002161026001,
0.5932372212409973,
-0.08369415253400803,
-0.10219336301088333,
0.11909192055463791,
0.3131864666938782,
-0.02036716230213642,
-0.4807488024234772,
-0.4828537702560425,
-0.4012082517147064,
-0.7766718864440918,
-0.7197521328926086,
0.2149394005537033,
0.2048557698726654,
-0.4662979245185852,
-0.21606600284576416,
-0.21312479674816132,
0.5411321520805359,
0.4277290403842926,
-0.10872144252061844,
0.4255363643169403,
-0.23146790266036987,
-0.10227304697036743,
-0.04063079506158829,
-0.6446859240531921,
-0.47222691774368286,
0.6279885768890381,
0.3917311728000641,
0.8713204264640808,
0.5776017308235168,
0.6469529867172241,
0.10455480217933655,
0.47379276156425476,
-0.8924190998077393,
0.4992017149925232,
0.24647141993045807,
-0.912369430065155,
-0.4083498418331146,
-0.44452348351478577,
-0.8171983957290649,
0.01296374574303627,
-0.020325293764472008,
-0.4622611999511719,
0.28724685311317444,
-0.07188556343317032,
-0.2469390630722046,
0.18582965433597565,
-0.2802788019180298,
0.5299376845359802,
-0.45562171936035156,
-0.39085689187049866,
-0.03878147527575493,
-0.6271328926086426,
0.7474916577339172,
-0.4127408564090729,
0.16654238104820251,
-0.30508437752723694,
0.10000766068696976,
0.6219199299812317,
-0.0982491597533226,
0.6759132742881775,
0.05162139981985092,
-0.5076797604560852,
0.6339924931526184,
0.4164313077926636,
0.1377895623445511,
0.2962232828140259,
-0.3156220316886902,
-0.010941742919385433,
0.2761187255382538,
-0.7674122452735901,
-0.381175696849823,
0.8297962546348572,
-0.9562980532646179,
-0.7542920112609863,
-0.35669010877609253,
-0.6501458883285522,
-0.5059726238250732,
0.1283782422542572,
0.2575450539588928,
0.16340245306491852,
-0.1989116668701172,
-0.06204250082373619,
0.6887046098709106,
-0.591927707195282,
0.25848937034606934,
0.8255983591079712,
-0.1393943727016449,
-0.07226530462503433,
0.46388453245162964,
0.00023017037892714143,
0.16975902020931244,
0.3040481507778168,
0.09368264675140381,
-0.2706371545791626,
-0.29782599210739136,
-0.45864760875701904,
0.19769808650016785,
-0.9917721152305603,
-0.13145892322063446,
-0.5242214798927307,
-0.03424425795674324,
-0.3421316146850586,
-0.3366122841835022,
-0.17024463415145874,
-0.46778085827827454,
0.07308166474103928,
-0.13979732990264893,
0.369383841753006,
0.6553083658218384,
0.19490638375282288,
-0.10811641067266464,
-0.6688798069953918,
0.2824086546897888,
0.6416094899177551,
0.10854660719633102,
-0.09201617538928986,
-0.5225517749786377,
-0.02185661345720291,
0.07735150307416916,
0.06559725105762482,
-1.0736801624298096,
0.18839548528194427,
0.25774019956588745,
0.5352391004562378,
0.40451139211654663,
0.6105303168296814,
0.9199346303939819,
-0.26736295223236084,
1.0016131401062012,
-0.13740450143814087,
-0.734384298324585,
0.386516273021698,
-0.5430676341056824,
0.857452392578125,
0.7982447147369385,
1.0964398384094238,
-0.961386501789093,
-0.5019540190696716,
-0.10580671578645706,
-0.9532293081283569,
0.26775220036506653,
-0.21713735163211823,
0.39330723881721497,
-0.21442334353923798,
0.4346751570701599,
-0.04677858203649521,
0.006478135474026203,
-0.6774700880050659,
-0.0022411253303289413,
0.022147413343191147,
-0.02596263773739338,
-0.06312433630228043,
-0.31553444266319275,
-0.3034568727016449,
-0.20812630653381348,
0.44748374819755554,
-0.22252433001995087,
0.029281532391905785,
0.2976500689983368,
-0.32620421051979065,
-0.3981519639492035,
0.5686460137367249,
0.4533284902572632,
0.6607484817504883,
-0.10932374000549316,
0.0853210985660553,
0.6472824215888977,
-0.4197014272212982,
0.29092875123023987,
-0.001675581093877554,
-0.2786255478858948,
-0.2500421106815338,
0.27247610688209534,
0.1280001848936081,
-0.15966281294822693,
-0.9994654059410095,
0.12940016388893127,
-0.475779265165329,
0.006217550486326218,
-0.6204648017883301,
-0.34440112113952637,
0.2869640588760376,
0.1505209058523178,
0.40994688868522644,
-0.3379381597042084,
0.06565286219120026,
-0.8615599274635315,
0.1245371624827385,
0.264273077249527,
-0.6199215650558472,
-0.3008939027786255,
0.6316730976104736,
0.30913132429122925,
-0.05128893628716469,
0.7843679189682007,
-0.07259154319763184,
-0.6508480310440063,
0.5699876546859741,
0.35363343358039856,
0.49233564734458923,
-0.49059000611305237,
0.4448417127132416,
0.4758082628250122,
0.45167383551597595,
0.14269326627254486,
1.025949478149414,
-0.1286906749010086,
-0.6128612756729126,
-0.6089192032814026,
-0.8065939545631409,
-0.6445866823196411,
0.32724371552467346,
-0.8769620060920715,
0.22448942065238953,
-0.33315497636795044,
-0.1016063541173935,
-0.3393758237361908,
0.19547396898269653,
-0.8334879875183105,
0.4746495187282562,
0.41758862137794495,
1.1601319313049316,
-1.0049967765808105,
0.6193558573722839,
0.9786814451217651,
-0.2716999351978302,
-0.9927067756652832,
0.030456900596618652,
0.13145406544208527,
-0.5941987633705139,
0.5098674893379211,
-0.020029999315738678,
-0.337133526802063,
-0.26512452960014343,
-0.5808627605438232,
-0.9243083000183105,
0.9540337324142456,
0.4191734492778778,
-0.1275690346956253,
0.2792999744415283,
0.508404552936554,
0.7752023935317993,
-0.10251527279615402,
0.2931934893131256,
0.5005170106887817,
0.256198912858963,
0.07273397594690323,
-0.8964693546295166,
0.14469842612743378,
-0.6306570172309875,
-0.463161438703537,
-0.02895798161625862,
-0.882800817489624,
0.6866710782051086,
-0.2448367029428482,
-0.02803112380206585,
0.3364698588848114,
0.7239289283752441,
0.31735530495643616,
0.24312196671962738,
0.28526225686073303,
0.3271550238132477,
1.1399214267730713,
-0.1238461583852768,
0.9915475249290466,
-0.4150328040122986,
0.05684124305844307,
1.0798496007919312,
-0.4378536641597748,
0.9706058502197266,
0.2841937243938446,
0.10034117847681046,
0.3256434202194214,
1.04622483253479,
0.43748739361763,
0.05762752518057823,
0.5304816365242004,
-0.6118260622024536,
-0.5140799283981323,
-0.7179765105247498,
-0.31235572695732117,
0.9000332951545715,
0.2432248443365097,
0.09343139082193375,
-0.06815747916698456,
-0.10254334658384323,
0.5134775042533875,
0.09131744503974915,
-0.37971678376197815,
0.32586756348609924,
0.12894567847251892,
-1.0538972616195679,
0.858369767665863,
0.24605564773082733,
0.46118465065956116,
-0.7014317512512207,
0.34210988879203796,
-0.8638117909431458,
-0.11364351958036423,
-0.16179664433002472,
-0.8302139043807983,
0.014981303364038467,
0.40734365582466125,
0.028530629351735115,
-0.12054680287837982,
0.42415210604667664,
-0.6130402088165283,
-0.5040115714073181,
0.08497178554534912,
0.7794737815856934,
0.2676469683647156,
0.2534559667110443,
-0.5920435786247253,
-0.11034785956144333,
0.005693515762686729,
-0.32607391476631165,
0.22828245162963867,
0.5286561250686646,
-0.6096950173377991,
0.8934435844421387,
0.5334706902503967,
-0.2583833336830139,
0.11750449240207672,
0.08515753597021103,
0.7189486026763916,
-0.6732562184333801,
-0.4714339077472687,
-0.32503557205200195,
0.5347648859024048,
0.19013138115406036,
-0.7517040967941284,
0.6838141679763794,
0.36818718910217285,
0.7747073173522949,
-0.002883784705772996,
0.5945131182670593,
0.12543685734272003,
0.20261496305465698,
-0.3132176399230957,
0.7966078519821167,
-0.6595924496650696,
-0.03601321578025818,
-0.122678242623806,
-0.7579593658447266,
-0.1833045780658722,
0.24740806221961975,
-0.20267505943775177,
-0.16990600526332855,
0.4086536169052124,
0.755088210105896,
0.17088192701339722,
0.10667727887630463,
0.418477326631546,
0.2542625665664673,
0.28000062704086304,
0.6342160701751709,
1.2968367338180542,
-0.024343494325876236,
0.5638670921325684,
-0.5542271733283997,
-0.03220142051577568,
0.23456037044525146,
-0.6392280459403992,
-0.7820040583610535,
-0.5982909798622131,
-0.40412184596061707,
-0.21818102896213531,
-0.3025352954864502,
1.0159517526626587,
0.4781387448310852,
-0.8898541331291199,
-0.38811779022216797,
0.8103195428848267,
-0.08562599122524261,
0.1173238679766655,
-0.21582470834255219,
0.2917182743549347,
-0.017630329355597496,
-0.6718903183937073,
0.4969246983528137,
0.003241398138925433,
0.0016502500511705875,
-0.23666930198669434,
0.09357057511806488,
-0.23192892968654633,
0.341305136680603,
0.6281653642654419,
0.6496721506118774,
-0.6780949831008911,
-0.165276899933815,
0.5987887382507324,
-0.16500291228294373,
-0.3056228756904602,
0.7001609206199646,
-0.5490005612373352,
0.42561987042427063,
0.4339812994003296,
0.6074979901313782,
0.4349362254142761,
-0.06291832029819489,
0.6029088497161865,
-0.5748671293258667,
0.4195135831832886,
0.5529390573501587,
0.3140757381916046,
0.3732208013534546,
-0.3918415904045105,
0.37652143836021423,
-0.3211895227432251,
-0.5005409717559814,
-0.7563788890838623,
0.6182900667190552,
-0.9844071865081787,
-0.21789264678955078,
1.236488699913025,
-0.4199768304824829,
0.017384318634867668,
-0.4115588068962097,
-0.0065733883529901505,
0.07096928358078003,
-0.020588774234056473,
0.6896075010299683,
0.7133198976516724,
-0.05657177045941353,
-0.2874380350112915,
-0.4896599352359772,
0.6093684434890747,
0.7229595184326172,
-0.5814138650894165,
-0.25999653339385986,
0.3858935832977295,
0.4464333951473236,
-0.06631678342819214,
0.693762481212616,
-0.07996180653572083,
0.47730883955955505,
-0.6185342669487,
0.04659988731145859,
0.4268777072429657,
0.10305897891521454,
-0.5249579548835754,
0.20293118059635162,
0.4348785877227783,
0.4609664976596832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17755v1 | Accelerating Clinical Evidence Synthesis with Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | 2024-06-25T17:41:52 | Zifeng Wang, Lang Cao, Benjamin Danek, Yichi Zhang, Qiao Jin, Zhiyong Lu, Jimeng Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic medical discovery by AI is a dream of many. One step toward that
goal is to create an AI model to understand clinical studies and synthesize
clinical evidence from the literature. Clinical evidence synthesis currently
relies on systematic reviews of clinical trials and retrospective analyses from
medical literature. However, the rapid expansion of publications presents
challenges in efficiently identifying, summarizing, and updating evidence. We
introduce TrialMind, a generative AI-based pipeline for conducting medical
systematic reviews, encompassing study search, screening, and data extraction
phases. We utilize large language models (LLMs) to drive each pipeline
component while incorporating human expert oversight to minimize errors. To
facilitate evaluation, we also create a benchmark dataset TrialReviewBench, a
custom dataset with 870 annotated clinical studies from 25 meta-analysis papers
across various medical treatments. Our results demonstrate that TrialMind
significantly improves the literature review process, achieving high recall
rates (0.897-1.000) in study searching from over 20 million PubMed studies and
outperforming traditional language model embeddings-based methods in screening
(Recall@20 of 0.227-0.246 vs. 0.000-0.102). Furthermore, our approach surpasses
direct GPT-4 performance in result extraction, with accuracy ranging from 0.65
to 0.84. We also support clinical evidence synthesis in forest plots, as
validated by eight human annotators who preferred TrialMind over the GPT-4
baseline with a winning rate of 62.5%-100% across the involved reviews. Our
findings suggest that an LLM-based clinical evidence synthesis approach, such
as TrialMind, can enable reliable and high-quality clinical evidence synthesis
to improve clinical research efficiency. | [
0.07501966506242752,
-0.44881147146224976,
0.9883953332901001,
0.06128948926925659,
-0.2672196924686432,
-0.1479721963405609,
-0.26961684226989746,
-0.206634983420372,
0.1878092885017395,
0.4899398982524872,
-0.4230961501598358,
-0.7780793905258179,
-0.7616756558418274,
0.0020753357093781233,
-0.47404614090919495,
0.9528875350952148,
-0.20594708621501923,
0.580191969871521,
0.07365874946117401,
-0.21708759665489197,
-0.28830745816230774,
-0.4399050772190094,
-0.5430739521980286,
-0.5579841732978821,
0.5444485545158386,
0.14291058480739594,
0.4182666540145874,
0.4798756241798401,
0.762010931968689,
0.2841204106807709,
0.20781747996807098,
0.2498892992734909,
-0.45756101608276367,
0.4208073019981384,
0.010719295591115952,
-0.6653931140899658,
-0.5200386643409729,
-0.10284220427274704,
0.27411943674087524,
0.7890490889549255,
-0.49904680252075195,
-0.09135008603334427,
-0.25516602396965027,
0.9068368077278137,
-0.38093259930610657,
0.3545950949192047,
-0.7178791165351868,
0.21048995852470398,
-0.16551528871059418,
-0.2285105139017105,
-0.33939874172210693,
-0.6144305467605591,
0.43586045503616333,
-0.7331955432891846,
0.6362555027008057,
0.13094639778137207,
0.4923715889453888,
0.30970683693885803,
-0.1730271577835083,
-0.4794408082962036,
-0.6101464629173279,
0.43857288360595703,
-1.1407335996627808,
0.03303246572613716,
0.07975881546735764,
0.4504813551902771,
-0.42475172877311707,
-0.967086911201477,
-0.5420393943786621,
-0.20566469430923462,
-0.07754139602184296,
0.2478944957256317,
0.1849089115858078,
0.27520421147346497,
0.4190119206905365,
0.5162932872772217,
-0.5778185129165649,
-0.06736480444669724,
-0.3830293118953705,
-0.2566269636154175,
0.8531954884529114,
0.31449007987976074,
0.5163558125495911,
-0.030178431421518326,
0.21036359667778015,
-0.2577510476112366,
-1.0603415966033936,
-0.2209557443857193,
-0.27688175439834595,
0.1732853651046753,
0.40546634793281555,
0.8057196140289307,
-0.2341570258140564,
0.38300541043281555,
-0.22771617770195007,
-0.07811175286769867,
0.2349320352077484,
-0.36434903740882874,
-0.26452597975730896,
0.26013100147247314,
1.0071266889572144,
0.6129255294799805,
-0.06103220582008362,
-0.01983403041958809,
-0.11703669279813766,
0.38797512650489807,
0.4507461190223694,
-0.9139154553413391,
-0.5482089519500732,
0.5329204797744751,
-0.7193558812141418,
-0.28988370299339294,
-0.24514953792095184,
-0.5015736222267151,
-0.8399127125740051,
-0.1382894068956375,
0.4147340953350067,
-0.6266261339187622,
-0.2176477462053299,
0.3092709481716156,
-0.4467985928058624,
-0.033292852342128754,
0.7106889486312866,
-0.5385794639587402,
0.2910803556442261,
0.5679028034210205,
0.6701502799987793,
-0.27560317516326904,
0.05123031511902809,
-0.3225129246711731,
0.2145201712846756,
-0.6947235465049744,
0.7069741487503052,
-0.2103622555732727,
-0.4391252398490906,
0.2671375274658203,
-0.03697330877184868,
-0.13327927887439728,
-0.6214690804481506,
0.6013088822364807,
-0.3242985010147095,
0.3895677924156189,
-0.115513376891613,
-0.9363678693771362,
-0.2041279673576355,
0.15281866490840912,
-0.5768854022026062,
0.5307785868644714,
-0.06796525418758392,
-0.5599108338356018,
0.6301056742668152,
-0.7547798752784729,
-0.6944175362586975,
0.20679166913032532,
-0.4438060522079468,
-0.4677938222885132,
0.36143991351127625,
0.6291232705116272,
0.2531070411205292,
-0.43633517622947693,
0.6800084114074707,
-0.27823466062545776,
-0.2835020124912262,
0.2565512955188751,
-0.04677950218319893,
0.6846576929092407,
0.33488956093788147,
-0.6521652340888977,
0.30627456307411194,
-0.4045581519603729,
-0.11508683115243912,
0.15321575105190277,
-0.07257506251335144,
-0.3646826148033142,
0.3657488524913788,
-0.08895940333604813,
-0.04733189567923546,
-0.2941061854362488,
-0.6210211515426636,
0.398780882358551,
-0.4966493546962738,
0.546875,
0.452531099319458,
0.17104317247867584,
0.10828883200883865,
-0.4681386649608612,
0.35915082693099976,
-0.06263149529695511,
0.14764532446861267,
-0.3812671899795532,
-0.6757269501686096,
-0.8739086985588074,
-0.17735618352890015,
0.6097722053527832,
0.3949348032474518,
-0.6940706968307495,
0.4555200934410095,
-0.5470198392868042,
-0.2807260751724243,
-0.8551639318466187,
-0.19301868975162506,
0.18753808736801147,
0.32048192620277405,
0.3299766778945923,
-0.766425609588623,
-0.45005643367767334,
-0.9016039371490479,
-0.10057961940765381,
-0.3870820105075836,
-0.29473763704299927,
0.30850374698638916,
0.34881582856178284,
-0.3436692953109741,
0.7944028377532959,
-0.8022904992103577,
-0.7882920503616333,
-0.27241843938827515,
0.3583574891090393,
0.39256590604782104,
0.38005200028419495,
0.03087512031197548,
-0.6094837784767151,
-0.3405265212059021,
0.10580170154571533,
-1.118546485900879,
-0.17358198761940002,
-0.262938529253006,
0.0327637605369091,
-0.09493502974510193,
0.6131483316421509,
-0.710089921951294,
0.5261874198913574,
-0.0028706532903015614,
0.043944645673036575,
0.12322437763214111,
-0.19051450490951538,
0.21193215250968933,
-0.6879056096076965,
0.2991360127925873,
-0.19891145825386047,
-0.1258455067873001,
-0.538969099521637,
0.11853019148111343,
0.0034668452572077513,
-0.0995936468243599,
-0.07831990718841553,
0.3459101617336273,
-0.44775012135505676,
0.23468057811260223,
-0.1803501695394516,
-0.0445089116692543,
-0.3123055100440979,
0.3294631540775299,
0.17287679016590118,
0.5403291583061218,
0.28772443532943726,
-0.26875123381614685,
0.030825676396489143,
0.4246861934661865,
-0.5275790691375732,
0.13410119712352753,
-0.700132429599762,
-0.11740929633378983,
-0.040908318012952805,
0.4960035979747772,
-0.8996350765228271,
-0.4712403416633606,
0.22691717743873596,
-0.423001766204834,
0.34910812973976135,
-0.3281319737434387,
-0.41421446204185486,
-0.4973507821559906,
-0.2386525273323059,
0.06286244094371796,
0.6507307887077332,
-0.1473286747932434,
0.6046284437179565,
0.6563443541526794,
-0.7337611317634583,
-0.2034911960363388,
-0.4966953694820404,
0.4782050549983978,
0.14642009139060974,
-0.3588036000728607,
0.3816700875759125,
-0.04931268468499184,
-0.20991042256355286,
-0.0055471425876021385,
0.13827739655971527,
0.11911049485206604,
-0.21749667823314667,
0.31805264949798584,
0.27015578746795654,
-0.07486502081155777,
0.13226540386676788,
0.25569507479667664,
0.1262703537940979,
0.35044366121292114,
-0.20501987636089325,
0.2027764618396759,
0.2646440267562866,
-0.6519965529441833,
-0.16102533042430878,
0.4315449893474579,
0.7086473703384399,
0.06125946342945099,
0.06223729997873306,
0.38836294412612915,
-0.5962167978286743,
-0.27934926748275757,
-0.7164849042892456,
-0.34155964851379395,
-0.3978719711303711,
0.28203341364860535,
-0.024460503831505775,
-0.8322566151618958,
0.1412954330444336,
-0.1461995542049408,
0.4506168067455292,
0.6081262826919556,
0.9841441512107849,
-0.019341273233294487,
1.3741470575332642,
0.19009490311145782,
0.016586266458034515,
0.2656191289424896,
-0.29722175002098083,
0.2910768389701843,
-0.8747822046279907,
-0.133968785405159,
-0.13613811135292053,
-0.18826381862163544,
-0.4466911256313324,
-0.6288713812828064,
0.8769456148147583,
-0.5051001906394958,
0.12147639691829681,
-0.1099310964345932,
-0.6801431179046631,
0.00707388436421752,
0.726370096206665,
0.436817467212677,
0.4238997995853424,
0.030112337321043015,
-0.322029709815979,
-0.23044979572296143,
-0.9078081250190735,
-0.27717161178588867,
1.8069682121276855,
0.2957962155342102,
0.5719995498657227,
-0.03628772869706154,
0.789648711681366,
0.5792130827903748,
1.0560309886932373,
-0.6992540955543518,
0.5553517937660217,
-0.059505660086870193,
-0.915264904499054,
-0.16158883273601532,
-0.2421356588602066,
-0.9089745283126831,
0.28798145055770874,
-0.3793524503707886,
-0.16046927869319916,
-0.03843434900045395,
0.0010177784133702517,
-0.5056044459342957,
0.022438745945692062,
-0.736749529838562,
0.4478512108325958,
-0.16809968650341034,
-0.3539268970489502,
-0.48650074005126953,
-0.6783486008644104,
0.5817004442214966,
-0.023891856893897057,
0.0763244554400444,
-0.014192067086696625,
0.3051455616950989,
0.7724575400352478,
-0.7536370754241943,
0.7152272462844849,
-0.3016115725040436,
0.14696285128593445,
0.2423921376466751,
0.025790387764573097,
0.4692530930042267,
0.1782008707523346,
0.15635086596012115,
0.049390893429517746,
-0.16068050265312195,
-0.17117756605148315,
-0.4093620777130127,
0.5674609541893005,
-0.5565502643585205,
-0.736529529094696,
-0.7121678590774536,
-0.6333175897598267,
-0.35983529686927795,
0.296023964881897,
0.22159218788146973,
0.4091204106807709,
-0.4148356318473816,
-0.07427092641592026,
0.6195818781852722,
-0.3717257082462311,
0.02492399699985981,
0.5652725696563721,
-0.19765689969062805,
-0.5830696225166321,
0.6795584559440613,
-0.026635967195034027,
-0.2223379760980606,
0.26394185423851013,
0.17950528860092163,
-0.2590671181678772,
-1.3173595666885376,
-0.5450606942176819,
0.18149177730083466,
-0.5186123847961426,
-0.17179809510707855,
-0.8709801435470581,
-0.35193267464637756,
-0.47137174010276794,
0.16141042113304138,
-0.21808302402496338,
-0.34507259726524353,
0.31519240140914917,
0.07547164708375931,
0.1272720992565155,
0.7928802967071533,
0.2015129178762436,
0.24780519306659698,
-0.6356224417686462,
0.55997633934021,
0.3076076805591583,
0.21609340608119965,
-0.03490973263978958,
-0.18862779438495636,
-0.15345890820026398,
-0.07872604578733444,
-0.2744426727294922,
-0.6193321943283081,
0.5900009870529175,
0.11594881117343903,
0.522138774394989,
0.4811810553073883,
0.06303780525922775,
0.757494330406189,
-0.9251965284347534,
0.7822669744491577,
0.36673805117607117,
-0.6109033823013306,
0.592912495136261,
-0.46830272674560547,
0.23578129708766937,
0.8028739094734192,
0.23757275938987732,
-0.4768001139163971,
-0.6411875486373901,
-0.6499675512313843,
-1.0440257787704468,
0.6393572092056274,
0.41870948672294617,
-0.47816771268844604,
0.16545234620571136,
0.16728909313678741,
0.2722052335739136,
0.38745126128196716,
-0.3126418888568878,
-0.058511678129434586,
0.11327515542507172,
-0.4994847774505615,
-0.15399186313152313,
-0.0655713900923729,
-0.80438232421875,
-0.30470699071884155,
0.6595738530158997,
-0.3506146967411041,
0.5955466032028198,
0.7371683120727539,
-0.34090662002563477,
-0.17908883094787598,
0.10464879125356674,
0.4391075372695923,
0.808809220790863,
-0.48621949553489685,
-0.052657317370176315,
-0.1935402750968933,
-0.7248167395591736,
-0.0198520515114069,
0.518122673034668,
-0.4295721650123596,
0.1157655119895935,
0.7255229949951172,
0.5299503207206726,
-0.1659119725227356,
-0.9240878820419312,
0.5429666638374329,
-0.5943077206611633,
-0.4729328155517578,
-0.5204410552978516,
0.22468465566635132,
0.03282831236720085,
0.06998174637556076,
0.559620201587677,
0.18538513779640198,
0.6153744459152222,
-0.3498252332210541,
0.24488161504268646,
0.4307599365711212,
-0.2790137231349945,
-0.17448772490024567,
0.8495305180549622,
0.2712618410587311,
-0.04734199494123459,
0.7975605130195618,
0.15436479449272156,
-0.37806904315948486,
0.5237202048301697,
0.12023068964481354,
0.9710028767585754,
0.1689971387386322,
0.07729998230934143,
0.48693332076072693,
0.26140812039375305,
-0.30598002672195435,
0.11276479810476303,
0.2619723677635193,
-0.45755502581596375,
-0.5089117288589478,
-0.323213130235672,
-0.7449321150779724,
0.13122588396072388,
-0.3237582743167877,
0.0520506277680397,
-0.38937222957611084,
-0.215463325381279,
0.2700941264629364,
-0.09901033341884613,
-0.6162264347076416,
0.2555595338344574,
0.12364456802606583,
0.7491781711578369,
-0.7377633452415466,
0.8786399364471436,
0.4977204203605652,
-0.15659035742282867,
-0.6747032403945923,
-0.13866667449474335,
0.2002309411764145,
-0.7990375757217407,
0.08583014458417892,
0.23628339171409607,
0.29882463812828064,
-0.24810324609279633,
-0.5341954827308655,
-0.5305544137954712,
1.1782516241073608,
0.006364232394844294,
-0.7960392832756042,
0.0023937798105180264,
-0.049542367458343506,
1.0117377042770386,
-0.6998000741004944,
0.48899585008621216,
0.4154169261455536,
0.32872313261032104,
0.1881854236125946,
-0.6506864428520203,
0.23447777330875397,
-0.44079262018203735,
-0.2002701759338379,
0.026049746200442314,
-0.09389622509479523,
0.44292914867401123,
-0.3959372341632843,
-0.22711291909217834,
0.14517223834991455,
0.41642341017723083,
0.32882046699523926,
0.47669678926467896,
0.5622702240943909,
0.6996606588363647,
0.7997567057609558,
-0.18427908420562744,
1.0680158138275146,
-0.336224764585495,
0.028455302119255066,
0.9954017400741577,
-0.8283413648605347,
0.6838540434837341,
0.45695579051971436,
-0.40372610092163086,
0.56106036901474,
0.6838911771774292,
0.15399841964244843,
0.5357087850570679,
0.24729116261005402,
-0.23594212532043457,
-0.30476802587509155,
-0.001741836778819561,
-0.4139362573623657,
-0.12175840139389038,
0.5810087323188782,
-0.673496425151825,
0.1167483702301979,
-0.227294459939003,
0.012566771358251572,
-0.14762821793556213,
-0.09951461851596832,
1.0216572284698486,
0.10431718826293945,
-1.2784783840179443,
0.6046300530433655,
-0.2188452184200287,
0.23996591567993164,
-0.9566240310668945,
-0.23937641084194183,
-0.28140634298324585,
0.5212259292602539,
-0.04570458456873894,
-0.6352522969245911,
-0.06468590348958969,
-0.18499159812927246,
0.11590386927127838,
-0.08882086724042892,
0.56197190284729,
-0.49867501854896545,
-0.6950342655181885,
0.012086068280041218,
0.5511326789855957,
-0.028658585622906685,
0.04294252768158913,
-0.6973384022712708,
0.05267656221985817,
0.14626029133796692,
-0.137080118060112,
0.303354948759079,
0.4338364899158478,
-0.34032872319221497,
0.691116452217102,
1.0059616565704346,
0.6083670854568481,
-0.15485893189907074,
0.19938728213310242,
1.049466609954834,
-0.5619406700134277,
-0.3003975749015808,
-0.6294450163841248,
0.12000064551830292,
-0.3819611370563507,
-0.14127351343631744,
0.47702038288116455,
0.4804094731807709,
0.310982346534729,
-0.1498681753873825,
1.1775219440460205,
-0.3099728524684906,
0.6264955997467041,
-0.48926180601119995,
0.8749749064445496,
-0.5215981006622314,
0.15918974578380585,
-0.16984562575817108,
-0.5796472430229187,
-0.5569917559623718,
0.3186167776584625,
-0.22487951815128326,
-0.32176798582077026,
0.9124304056167603,
0.749526858329773,
0.1454138308763504,
0.1285773366689682,
-0.056584205478429794,
0.5881573557853699,
0.7938714623451233,
0.7126373648643494,
0.5069353580474854,
-0.5387745499610901,
0.25103598833084106,
0.13981667160987854,
-0.515110194683075,
-0.17994937300682068,
-0.7610669732093811,
-0.904210090637207,
-0.2709101140499115,
-0.3298436105251312,
-0.3338131010532379,
0.3101505935192108,
0.9262977242469788,
0.8470134735107422,
-1.1195393800735474,
-0.2320270985364914,
-0.30691346526145935,
-0.013284098356962204,
-0.49403852224349976,
-0.12455199658870697,
0.6558687090873718,
-0.31871140003204346,
-0.4657951891422272,
0.3950728476047516,
0.3276672661304474,
-0.35940849781036377,
-0.25461846590042114,
-0.12418975681066513,
-0.33220237493515015,
-0.12727096676826477,
0.4144344627857208,
0.13113941252231598,
-0.6843856573104858,
0.1636013239622116,
-0.13547185063362122,
-0.1641204059123993,
0.07452762871980667,
1.2048027515411377,
-0.8205284476280212,
0.8422098159790039,
0.4557577967643738,
0.6830519437789917,
0.929000735282898,
-0.20818659663200378,
1.1094532012939453,
-0.1107412576675415,
-0.03423575311899185,
0.49893563985824585,
0.5063695907592773,
0.41402071714401245,
-0.07157300412654877,
0.8305842876434326,
0.4145766496658325,
-0.664318859577179,
-0.736093282699585,
-0.10446782410144806,
-0.851287841796875,
-0.3050459623336792,
0.9350858926773071,
-0.16242453455924988,
-0.3055790662765503,
-0.1738981008529663,
-0.4627077579498291,
0.1276388317346573,
-0.38096073269844055,
1.201939582824707,
0.5352877974510193,
-0.22553859651088715,
0.13964219391345978,
-0.5957380533218384,
0.796952486038208,
0.5563651919364929,
-0.7598810195922852,
0.11453142017126083,
0.6925815343856812,
0.19979605078697205,
0.13844794034957886,
0.9897896647453308,
-0.4450487494468689,
0.39133015275001526,
-0.156192809343338,
0.3062630295753479,
0.16527433693408966,
0.020271046087145805,
-0.20236721634864807,
0.13151872158050537,
0.14189206063747406,
0.18923625349998474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17753v1 | Measuring and Benchmarking Large Language Models' Capabilities to Generate Persuasive Language | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | 2024-06-25T17:40:47 | Amalie Brogaard Pauli, Isabelle Augenstein, Ira Assent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We are exposed to much information trying to influence us, such as teaser
messages, debates, politically framed news, and propaganda - all of which use
persuasive language. With the recent interest in Large Language Models (LLMs),
we study the ability of LLMs to produce persuasive text. As opposed to prior
work which focuses on particular domains or types of persuasion, we conduct a
general study across various domains to measure and benchmark to what degree
LLMs produce persuasive text - both when explicitly instructed to rewrite text
to be more or less persuasive and when only instructed to paraphrase. To this
end, we construct a new dataset, Persuasive-Pairs, of pairs each consisting of
a short text and of a text rewritten by an LLM to amplify or diminish
persuasive language. We multi-annotate the pairs on a relative scale for
persuasive language. This data is not only a valuable resource in itself, but
we also show that it can be used to train a regression model to predict a score
of persuasive language between text pairs. This model can score and benchmark
new LLMs across domains, thereby facilitating the comparison of different LLMs.
Finally, we discuss effects observed for different system prompts. Notably, we
find that different 'personas' in the system prompt of LLaMA3 change the
persuasive language in the text substantially, even when only instructed to
paraphrase. These findings underscore the importance of investigating
persuasive language in LLM generated text. | [
-0.11919654905796051,
-0.8468214869499207,
0.6786945462226868,
0.3679552674293518,
-0.1842622309923172,
-0.12264277786016464,
-0.41557130217552185,
0.17067064344882965,
0.11532348394393921,
0.5886405110359192,
-0.22577227652072906,
-0.6741167306900024,
-0.5252906084060669,
0.376250296831131,
-0.5692764520645142,
1.0416892766952515,
-0.14136096835136414,
0.09127739071846008,
-0.45159780979156494,
0.09021445363759995,
-0.32380741834640503,
-0.8973784446716309,
-0.488733172416687,
-0.4967760741710663,
0.927574872970581,
0.580028772354126,
0.4519544243812561,
0.466073215007782,
0.35739606618881226,
0.19473347067832947,
-0.16940173506736755,
-0.3845231831073761,
-0.7211454510688782,
0.45797619223594666,
-0.15927593410015106,
-0.47401851415634155,
-0.17666245996952057,
0.13204258680343628,
1.0094146728515625,
0.5477288961410522,
0.04586600884795189,
0.14180730283260345,
0.2684864401817322,
0.2820053994655609,
-0.5742672085762024,
0.016857650130987167,
-0.8691736459732056,
-0.1532670110464096,
-0.2740626335144043,
-0.21781903505325317,
-0.37954163551330566,
-0.5160888433456421,
-0.015906989574432373,
-0.2224668264389038,
-0.06274991482496262,
-0.0028369631618261337,
0.6023948192596436,
0.16462218761444092,
-0.5843621492385864,
-0.1924475133419037,
-0.5014998912811279,
0.8146057724952698,
-0.7678551077842712,
0.28447696566581726,
0.20559069514274597,
-0.09032342582941055,
-0.15781930088996887,
-0.734435498714447,
-0.6203835606575012,
-0.4989722669124603,
0.15209349989891052,
-0.08070453256368637,
-0.17392387986183167,
-0.19653141498565674,
0.39595240354537964,
0.06745908409357071,
-0.4940972328186035,
0.2704154849052429,
0.14281755685806274,
-0.25680863857269287,
0.5545119047164917,
0.2723213732242584,
0.16544392704963684,
-0.255607008934021,
-0.45079612731933594,
-0.34038418531417847,
-1.0575592517852783,
-0.08133065700531006,
0.5358218550682068,
0.14921964704990387,
0.027559617534279823,
0.6226320862770081,
-0.22525155544281006,
0.3155081272125244,
-0.08370289951562881,
-0.40515410900115967,
-0.018169492483139038,
-0.3045029640197754,
-0.21602343022823334,
0.03625274822115898,
0.9556641578674316,
0.2961210012435913,
0.2372630089521408,
0.045689839869737625,
-0.3342934250831604,
0.19603484869003296,
-0.12112414836883545,
-0.9227042198181152,
-0.21040727198123932,
-0.19666889309883118,
-0.5627122521400452,
-0.2888858914375305,
-0.12631288170814514,
-0.6799577474594116,
-0.5983836054801941,
-0.23912933468818665,
0.3576110303401947,
-0.21882110834121704,
-0.19942352175712585,
0.1924019455909729,
-0.061623282730579376,
0.17084676027297974,
0.07290478050708771,
-0.7464498281478882,
0.15967464447021484,
0.8847371935844421,
0.6276565790176392,
-0.22981521487236023,
-0.3600486218929291,
-0.46775636076927185,
0.17478330433368683,
-0.5506531000137329,
0.8668959140777588,
-0.838592529296875,
-0.4030291736125946,
0.35925912857055664,
-0.15833018720149994,
0.09246113151311874,
-0.6181350946426392,
0.6857205033302307,
-0.23232273757457733,
0.045431800186634064,
-0.47288987040519714,
-0.6296530365943909,
0.08267661929130554,
0.31403401494026184,
-0.5373355150222778,
0.7391285300254822,
-0.2972453236579895,
-0.623235285282135,
0.3534143269062042,
-0.26264721155166626,
-0.5284562706947327,
-0.1671113520860672,
-0.32160571217536926,
-0.44935333728790283,
0.17673683166503906,
-0.0036680111661553383,
0.7564292550086975,
-0.7030554413795471,
0.5924700498580933,
-0.18681105971336365,
-0.033742159605026245,
0.636745274066925,
-0.6099215745925903,
0.31015545129776,
0.06008143350481987,
-0.2020695060491562,
0.3187473714351654,
-0.5979315638542175,
-0.313677579164505,
0.2575555145740509,
-0.6027962565422058,
-0.5265699028968811,
-0.015656564384698868,
0.07878518104553223,
0.017453139647841454,
0.5558379888534546,
-0.3802858591079712,
0.07943237572908401,
0.03915770351886749,
0.3035249710083008,
0.6644480228424072,
0.2190733551979065,
0.044650595635175705,
-0.29420554637908936,
0.5476812124252319,
-0.3154751658439636,
-0.10012419521808624,
-0.29024022817611694,
-0.517828643321991,
-0.5522243976593018,
-0.04219285771250725,
0.12307488918304443,
0.2845103144645691,
-0.5115871429443359,
0.0791582241654396,
-0.19119009375572205,
-0.42258742451667786,
-0.1321025937795639,
0.18932673335075378,
0.5674721598625183,
0.5746057033538818,
0.052545689046382904,
0.04454946145415306,
-0.5899804830551147,
-1.0828560590744019,
-0.5204772353172302,
-0.4135969877243042,
0.02445952221751213,
0.072698675096035,
0.5129902958869934,
0.06367620825767517,
0.5309075117111206,
-0.47749948501586914,
0.14849242568016052,
-0.3618408143520355,
0.3279114067554474,
0.049539871513843536,
0.21289509534835815,
0.38972362875938416,
-0.7562572956085205,
-0.5859655141830444,
-0.298319011926651,
-0.7405440807342529,
-0.6431484818458557,
-0.17714771628379822,
0.20835423469543457,
-0.042770303785800934,
0.6363206505775452,
-0.27212607860565186,
0.11365155875682831,
0.5511088967323303,
-0.2272794395685196,
0.7902873158454895,
-0.04710249602794647,
0.3007495701313019,
-1.1376912593841553,
0.07727759331464767,
0.2814667224884033,
0.09533288329839706,
-0.7453131079673767,
-0.06312685459852219,
-0.04143129289150238,
-0.06572023034095764,
-0.44292306900024414,
0.5675673484802246,
-0.23576472699642181,
0.17976953089237213,
-0.34755244851112366,
0.06642843782901764,
-0.0276198573410511,
0.0785190686583519,
0.01079078670591116,
0.8500160574913025,
0.41490861773490906,
-0.5886976718902588,
0.30365338921546936,
0.3285738229751587,
-0.519465982913971,
0.5917105674743652,
-0.620902955532074,
-0.05993125960230827,
-0.0579117052257061,
0.36361271142959595,
-1.1773062944412231,
-0.3458283841609955,
-0.012672686018049717,
-0.15996024012565613,
0.007693230174481869,
-0.034476377069950104,
-0.5832485556602478,
-0.14611610770225525,
-0.17148302495479584,
0.08406519144773483,
0.41903015971183777,
-0.38180646300315857,
0.29158201813697815,
0.3434482514858246,
-0.42710867524147034,
-0.288280189037323,
-0.45650067925453186,
0.41639822721481323,
-0.6949223279953003,
-0.33837515115737915,
0.3389971852302551,
-0.07438306510448456,
-0.5760810375213623,
-0.3515937328338623,
0.018872609362006187,
0.16725562512874603,
0.11650235950946808,
0.32693731784820557,
0.13887451589107513,
-0.27561241388320923,
0.2882368266582489,
-0.009672467596828938,
-0.17696604132652283,
0.3981283903121948,
-0.059488166123628616,
0.6851871013641357,
-0.026566198095679283,
-0.24449393153190613,
-0.5453932285308838,
0.4333772361278534,
0.5072482824325562,
0.03193958103656769,
0.764819860458374,
0.3052447438240051,
-0.1409277617931366,
0.16683216392993927,
-0.8755214214324951,
-0.30820348858833313,
-0.404198557138443,
0.3939679265022278,
-0.444907546043396,
-0.8046504259109497,
0.21547755599021912,
-0.22840408980846405,
0.07065059244632721,
0.4107566475868225,
0.7148997187614441,
0.2899419665336609,
0.9285102486610413,
0.505700409412384,
-0.24238088726997375,
0.5649051070213318,
0.004280463792383671,
0.020711485296487808,
-0.5661313533782959,
-0.2340749055147171,
-0.8097481727600098,
-0.11420626938343048,
-0.39454126358032227,
-0.2790926694869995,
0.25070351362228394,
0.01363967452198267,
-0.4290764629840851,
0.24120278656482697,
-0.21657666563987732,
0.3145553469657898,
0.511412501335144,
-0.28166869282722473,
0.31042590737342834,
0.17754170298576355,
-0.13590626418590546,
-0.16105589270591736,
-0.5045214891433716,
-1.0970371961593628,
1.1339004039764404,
0.35528117418289185,
0.7367860674858093,
0.03496035560965538,
0.6889628171920776,
0.19211281836032867,
0.6307824850082397,
-0.5054182410240173,
1.0265533924102783,
-0.18900784850120544,
-0.3575097620487213,
-0.11952555179595947,
-0.48184874653816223,
-0.9765404462814331,
0.09762565791606903,
-0.39976078271865845,
-0.5630868077278137,
-0.09104683995246887,
0.05230366811156273,
-0.083611398935318,
0.42587846517562866,
-0.5509598255157471,
0.7174450755119324,
-0.26337283849716187,
-0.4368284344673157,
-0.3528349995613098,
-0.2397375851869583,
0.14313362538814545,
-0.2695171535015106,
-0.1493379771709442,
-0.2880411148071289,
-0.34758588671684265,
1.060696005821228,
0.025239713490009308,
0.9692657589912415,
0.013466037809848785,
-0.4910416901111603,
0.04514821618795395,
-0.07344090938568115,
0.48276981711387634,
-0.029079390689730644,
-0.4316563308238983,
0.10258693248033524,
-0.3072877526283264,
-0.19842930138111115,
-0.28562843799591064,
1.0144758224487305,
-0.6268448233604431,
-0.970318615436554,
-0.0829395204782486,
-0.5022653341293335,
-0.2137041836977005,
0.13506090641021729,
0.15790115296840668,
0.3212580680847168,
-0.5891417860984802,
0.47573328018188477,
0.6913913488388062,
-0.3824566602706909,
0.33240827918052673,
0.5152647495269775,
-0.28044024109840393,
-0.38443925976753235,
0.9687234163284302,
-0.05435017868876457,
0.44873374700546265,
0.7273904085159302,
0.7004976868629456,
-0.4271777272224426,
-0.593974232673645,
0.03503431752324104,
0.3871236741542816,
-0.7034124135971069,
-0.11966703087091446,
-0.5528771281242371,
0.07337526232004166,
-0.6418619155883789,
-0.11138243228197098,
-0.046292271465063095,
-0.22419334948062897,
-0.3906392455101013,
0.08047973364591599,
0.20910583436489105,
1.1084303855895996,
0.026699507609009743,
0.34263405203819275,
-0.48088207840919495,
0.024547168985009193,
0.4011008143424988,
-0.08454407006502151,
-0.14971669018268585,
-0.5179316401481628,
-0.04308174550533295,
-0.10845272243022919,
-0.362333208322525,
-0.9378635883331299,
0.43962085247039795,
-0.18940970301628113,
0.6963681578636169,
0.45883825421333313,
0.06419812142848969,
0.4582465589046478,
-0.3630346357822418,
0.9415826201438904,
0.35035985708236694,
-0.9664266705513,
0.44448399543762207,
-0.4225948750972748,
0.12079156190156937,
0.31933483481407166,
0.5319526195526123,
-0.5615196824073792,
-0.4565304219722748,
-0.5565415024757385,
-0.8219166994094849,
0.21361571550369263,
-0.023931175470352173,
0.2690231204032898,
-0.15948933362960815,
0.3264499604701996,
0.26301419734954834,
0.4900040924549103,
-0.7372521758079529,
-0.2105932980775833,
-0.017397915944457054,
-0.16750892996788025,
-0.33521291613578796,
-0.5626646876335144,
-0.18681743741035461,
0.15364328026771545,
0.7235064506530762,
-0.06789344549179077,
-0.08618536591529846,
0.0028010313399136066,
0.19985871016979218,
0.01584009639918804,
0.4318864643573761,
0.6203112602233887,
0.44932040572166443,
0.06151660531759262,
0.18166027963161469,
0.12671326100826263,
-0.29864031076431274,
0.3292541801929474,
0.016177499666810036,
-0.24381759762763977,
-0.09128082543611526,
0.40608179569244385,
0.8740960955619812,
0.1665075272321701,
-0.6036412119865417,
0.33499595522880554,
0.008220788091421127,
-0.40471968054771423,
0.020949505269527435,
-0.01924680359661579,
0.32253018021583557,
0.23379522562026978,
0.4419565200805664,
-0.4455377161502838,
-0.14337509870529175,
-0.4871984124183655,
-0.0020692716352641582,
0.5261957049369812,
0.035584963858127594,
-0.32453104853630066,
0.7224658727645874,
0.3482286334037781,
-0.5479574799537659,
0.08881592005491257,
0.14477117359638214,
-0.4092625081539154,
0.44591957330703735,
0.7086535692214966,
0.647713303565979,
-0.2880379259586334,
0.13635927438735962,
0.2725234627723694,
0.14833545684814453,
-0.20039249956607819,
0.002398801501840353,
0.16536962985992432,
-0.5449783205986023,
-0.29044339060783386,
-0.35711535811424255,
-0.541258692741394,
0.7008473873138428,
-0.5061311721801758,
0.05292776972055435,
-0.43959563970565796,
-0.2593268156051636,
0.16287600994110107,
0.1186760812997818,
-0.4804190993309021,
0.10351913422346115,
0.27339842915534973,
0.7156773209571838,
-1.2424594163894653,
0.6728237867355347,
0.8892568349838257,
-0.31796813011169434,
-0.584406316280365,
0.6352754235267639,
0.06213830038905144,
-0.6902214884757996,
0.7211772203445435,
0.18264976143836975,
-0.23600994050502777,
-0.12054447829723358,
-0.7079053521156311,
-0.8226189017295837,
0.7864602208137512,
0.4785260856151581,
-0.6372140645980835,
0.26222726702690125,
0.2503937780857086,
0.44883906841278076,
-0.6714592576026917,
-0.1339138001203537,
0.593323826789856,
0.6717816591262817,
-0.06436602771282196,
-0.6951553821563721,
0.228927880525589,
0.11779582500457764,
0.09062693268060684,
0.1521582305431366,
-0.5693825483322144,
0.8477543592453003,
-0.0998915433883667,
-0.2389928549528122,
0.2873935401439667,
0.7994062900543213,
0.2189796417951584,
0.2746107578277588,
0.5498241186141968,
0.15673096477985382,
0.6986231207847595,
0.04621697589755058,
0.9641239643096924,
-0.3052300810813904,
-0.09923426806926727,
0.9010822176933289,
-0.6647804379463196,
1.0402343273162842,
0.6492024660110474,
0.14102387428283691,
0.47507181763648987,
0.23833400011062622,
0.2392708957195282,
0.2528379261493683,
0.4896436929702759,
-0.43698808550834656,
-0.4855228066444397,
-0.3750554621219635,
-0.21468427777290344,
0.29855650663375854,
0.42066189646720886,
-0.42532989382743835,
-0.08452194929122925,
0.21160101890563965,
0.2612065076828003,
0.5958611965179443,
-0.00823491532355547,
0.7540683150291443,
0.06248677894473076,
-0.9168806076049805,
0.5502719283103943,
0.0033878313843160868,
0.5822859406471252,
-0.5753961205482483,
0.031294528394937515,
-0.21379725635051727,
0.17938916385173798,
0.04020767658948898,
-0.9263145923614502,
-0.03936254605650902,
0.2029760330915451,
-0.13198156654834747,
-0.523542582988739,
0.5895534157752991,
-0.5551678538322449,
-0.37228816747665405,
0.23659297823905945,
0.562105119228363,
0.35292285680770874,
0.10466860979795456,
-0.60086590051651,
0.3872198462486267,
0.17569385468959808,
-0.4064007103443146,
0.5051997303962708,
0.46681874990463257,
-0.0018837618408724666,
0.6660404801368713,
0.8340966105461121,
0.22045719623565674,
-0.3414747416973114,
0.2914256751537323,
0.9133899211883545,
-0.6752991676330566,
-0.10695626586675644,
-1.0024305582046509,
0.0668402835726738,
-0.24716341495513916,
-0.45218291878700256,
1.0378198623657227,
0.6393164992332458,
0.6445467472076416,
0.0872531458735466,
0.8601550459861755,
0.11262620985507965,
0.553921103477478,
-0.48813363909721375,
0.49784916639328003,
-0.5197493433952332,
0.4042518436908722,
-0.2562064826488495,
-0.8074497580528259,
-0.2995188236236572,
0.562285304069519,
-0.6484341025352478,
-0.1962343454360962,
0.593198299407959,
0.9795641303062439,
0.3777729272842407,
-0.027630435302853584,
0.46572667360305786,
0.39150330424308777,
0.4855691194534302,
0.36164334416389465,
0.9871615171432495,
-0.016533493995666504,
0.7531687617301941,
0.0928163155913353,
-0.14953428506851196,
-0.13179033994674683,
-1.1150240898132324,
-1.07916259765625,
-0.6515078544616699,
-0.5163071751594543,
-0.46859487891197205,
0.1956423968076706,
0.7401893138885498,
0.23379501700401306,
-0.3800742030143738,
-0.47468301653862,
0.0770597830414772,
0.1603444516658783,
-0.03623421862721443,
-0.16168060898780823,
0.23620595037937164,
-0.12046153843402863,
-0.6265414357185364,
0.4829576015472412,
0.20572780072689056,
0.01971333660185337,
-0.6476923227310181,
0.06780030578374863,
-0.296664297580719,
0.3418770432472229,
0.5077996253967285,
0.20173992216587067,
-0.8060712814331055,
-0.1240389347076416,
-0.135366752743721,
-0.32147178053855896,
-0.05835219845175743,
1.0142927169799805,
-0.5929893851280212,
-0.06428579241037369,
0.5740204453468323,
0.3662738800048828,
0.17617379128932953,
-0.12078869342803955,
0.6468539834022522,
-0.6092877388000488,
-0.1925853192806244,
0.17878486216068268,
0.35672956705093384,
0.7176176309585571,
0.09484168887138367,
0.2030211240053177,
0.1310569792985916,
-0.6767001152038574,
-0.7843929529190063,
0.20026977360248566,
-0.4162435531616211,
-0.341198593378067,
1.7447975873947144,
-0.20603589713573456,
-0.18352404236793518,
-0.10163909941911697,
-0.3479226231575012,
0.12955790758132935,
-0.6233915686607361,
0.5891423225402832,
0.6261800527572632,
0.19911260902881622,
0.1806434690952301,
-0.2071579247713089,
0.44840535521507263,
0.5174531936645508,
-0.8588774800300598,
0.4216274619102478,
0.49592822790145874,
0.40205562114715576,
0.15829932689666748,
0.6300939917564392,
0.23809653520584106,
-0.15135639905929565,
0.09422260522842407,
-0.1385190486907959,
0.10375503450632095,
-0.38820019364356995,
-0.30434396862983704,
0.28957313299179077,
0.09546485543251038,
0.0844464898109436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17746v1 | Recite, Reconstruct, Recollect: Memorization in LMs as a Multifaceted Phenomenon | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | 2024-06-25T17:32:16 | USVSN Sai Prashanth, Alvin Deng, Kyle O'Brien, Jyothir S V, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Jaydeep Borkar, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jacob Ray Fuehne, Stella Biderman, Tracy Ke, Katherine Lee, Naomi Saphra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Memorization in language models is typically treated as a homogenous
phenomenon, neglecting the specifics of the memorized data. We instead model
memorization as the effect of a set of complex factors that describe each
sample and relate it to the model and corpus. To build intuition around these
factors, we break memorization down into a taxonomy: recitation of highly
duplicated sequences, reconstruction of inherently predictable sequences, and
recollection of sequences that are neither. We demonstrate the usefulness of
our taxonomy by using it to construct a predictive model for memorization. By
analyzing dependencies and inspecting the weights of the predictive model, we
find that different factors influence the likelihood of memorization
differently depending on the taxonomic category. | [
-0.15798412263393402,
-0.7458198070526123,
0.31120625138282776,
0.006848032120615244,
-0.029785320162773132,
0.3421327769756317,
-0.07252173125743866,
-0.20311607420444489,
0.4108823835849762,
0.7031723260879517,
-0.42529934644699097,
-0.14090953767299652,
-0.288337767124176,
-0.13508710265159607,
-0.771636962890625,
1.169926643371582,
0.05047927424311638,
0.032885096967220306,
-0.19099876284599304,
-0.24359844624996185,
-0.3672698736190796,
-1.0778570175170898,
-0.49642717838287354,
-0.7186222076416016,
0.7220351099967957,
0.1357329785823822,
0.3118497431278229,
0.6794169545173645,
0.3913591504096985,
0.30634066462516785,
-0.19641976058483124,
-0.12767386436462402,
-0.4976974427700043,
0.09423419088125229,
-0.21702396869659424,
-0.9782398343086243,
-0.2669169306755066,
0.02518550120294094,
0.9463046789169312,
1.0429452657699585,
-0.4936281740665436,
0.2603567838668823,
-0.07546713948249817,
0.8377654552459717,
-0.40254446864128113,
0.1359879970550537,
-0.7737943530082703,
0.0005171722732484341,
0.09049458801746368,
-0.5496206283569336,
-0.3695862591266632,
-0.2391042709350586,
0.39855435490608215,
-0.45846235752105713,
0.5479797124862671,
-0.08577172458171844,
0.37479761242866516,
-0.08855361491441727,
-0.3249994218349457,
-0.36603844165802,
-1.177627444267273,
0.8002817034721375,
-0.2055196315050125,
0.5723576545715332,
0.5474110841751099,
0.18138164281845093,
0.14927762746810913,
-0.8707088232040405,
-0.42379018664360046,
-0.13594351708889008,
-0.09749937057495117,
-0.01010315865278244,
0.13400694727897644,
-0.08820194005966187,
0.4609895646572113,
0.7134038209915161,
-0.13762125372886658,
-0.31182265281677246,
-0.5625312924385071,
-0.4863971769809723,
0.40932905673980713,
0.3848930597305298,
0.3971633017063141,
0.04010307788848877,
-0.4722939133644104,
0.3440410792827606,
-0.7375131845474243,
0.027933211997151375,
-0.0320436917245388,
0.4591885507106781,
0.33784568309783936,
0.5801262259483337,
0.10058040171861649,
0.30734720826148987,
-0.02440527081489563,
-0.6046305894851685,
0.5716714859008789,
-0.3221467435359955,
-0.20902903378009796,
-0.010207233019173145,
0.15484637022018433,
-0.008290153928101063,
0.19154106080532074,
-0.38658851385116577,
-0.2808520197868347,
-0.18194708228111267,
0.5138305425643921,
-0.5414204001426697,
-0.24062351882457733,
0.2141118347644806,
-0.6618555188179016,
0.12562473118305206,
0.03828570619225502,
-0.5134784579277039,
-0.10215824842453003,
-0.7069342732429504,
0.64871746301651,
-0.7435532212257385,
-0.2482071816921234,
0.08358152210712433,
-0.1313624531030655,
-0.3264254033565521,
0.32610902190208435,
-0.7867290377616882,
0.4571094214916229,
0.7895240783691406,
0.7649207711219788,
-0.016909481957554817,
-0.7769267559051514,
-0.18511158227920532,
0.29279330372810364,
0.04558252543210983,
0.4883766770362854,
-0.36621376872062683,
-0.3500930964946747,
0.15969322621822357,
0.13437505066394806,
-0.36252355575561523,
-0.6763255000114441,
0.1359446942806244,
-0.4455338716506958,
0.23607806861400604,
-0.2088758945465088,
-1.0634973049163818,
-0.8481646776199341,
0.10421380400657654,
-1.056803584098816,
0.6437988877296448,
0.1914556473493576,
-0.8129686713218689,
0.3625810444355011,
-0.008665940724313259,
-0.38391563296318054,
-0.03536510095000267,
0.023886505514383316,
-0.5064027309417725,
0.23394399881362915,
-0.6534060835838318,
0.44142061471939087,
0.04577416554093361,
0.3910730481147766,
-0.11627309024333954,
-0.2985812723636627,
0.3137282133102417,
-0.054691147059202194,
0.31751877069473267,
0.14889435470104218,
0.0444779247045517,
0.13660207390785217,
-1.011114478111267,
-0.20513363182544708,
-0.006471967790275812,
-0.7785295844078064,
-0.5709013342857361,
0.3038133382797241,
-0.04080881178379059,
0.25929009914398193,
0.025924434885382652,
-0.3768552243709564,
0.1802763044834137,
-0.15531307458877563,
0.33889108896255493,
0.4122137427330017,
0.1707235425710678,
0.6142273545265198,
-0.8405171632766724,
0.4943344295024872,
0.30983996391296387,
-0.24996227025985718,
-0.4023917615413666,
-0.11565127223730087,
-0.7611647248268127,
-0.32912740111351013,
-0.04865744337439537,
0.6021894216537476,
-0.5903366804122925,
-0.1888466477394104,
-0.21787667274475098,
-0.3702255189418793,
-0.25849607586860657,
0.31916120648384094,
0.7363395094871521,
0.235094353556633,
0.18643397092819214,
-0.6218215227127075,
-0.8436397314071655,
-0.8993945121765137,
-0.15374498069286346,
-0.23009492456912994,
0.2131441831588745,
0.14791956543922424,
0.634268581867218,
-0.17542503774166107,
0.5905523300170898,
-0.24766674637794495,
-0.37521791458129883,
-0.4068757891654968,
0.1789022982120514,
-0.01929815113544464,
0.26162484288215637,
0.5310752987861633,
-0.7689791917800903,
0.007358291652053595,
-0.2431931495666504,
-0.3196009695529938,
0.25275805592536926,
-0.2311507612466812,
0.17784827947616577,
0.318345844745636,
0.81221604347229,
-0.5140376687049866,
0.22585198283195496,
0.13101506233215332,
-0.28079158067703247,
0.3953173756599426,
-0.23146219551563263,
-0.22270731627941132,
-1.0065085887908936,
0.23137116432189941,
-0.40371641516685486,
-0.028424475342035294,
-0.9260395169258118,
0.07673058658838272,
0.01960381679236889,
0.26074129343032837,
-0.42127758264541626,
0.17936185002326965,
-0.4370342493057251,
-0.1623050570487976,
-0.05258236080408096,
-0.20218788087368011,
-0.1790555864572525,
0.41337502002716064,
0.27866318821907043,
0.49650079011917114,
0.2723827660083771,
-0.9111629128456116,
-0.006584872957319021,
-0.07053681463003159,
-0.5362301468849182,
0.25237295031547546,
-0.36167991161346436,
-0.24909208714962006,
-0.5505722165107727,
0.02684798464179039,
-1.0004757642745972,
-0.007268081419169903,
-0.13891418278217316,
-0.24342277646064758,
0.5191423892974854,
0.21099808812141418,
-0.38283008337020874,
-0.25011688470840454,
-0.15762725472450256,
0.3555143177509308,
0.22231054306030273,
-0.2226444035768509,
0.7562979459762573,
0.388045996427536,
-0.07743725180625916,
-0.6277468204498291,
-0.5016781687736511,
-0.5750868320465088,
-0.5312584042549133,
0.20802584290504456,
0.2795233130455017,
-0.2793309986591339,
-0.32581740617752075,
-0.3202837109565735,
-0.03201410919427872,
-0.02953234314918518,
0.36845219135284424,
0.6217391490936279,
0.2484527975320816,
-0.05485216900706291,
0.5540038347244263,
-0.6057060956954956,
0.11627712845802307,
0.1344299167394638,
-0.21205362677574158,
0.9845760464668274,
-0.08885001391172409,
-0.14902381598949432,
-0.03263659402728081,
0.34446820616722107,
0.7570938467979431,
-0.23415374755859375,
0.6728544235229492,
0.5525473952293396,
-0.59816575050354,
-0.08143641799688339,
-0.5520125031471252,
-0.0424545481801033,
-0.29051363468170166,
0.6137206554412842,
-0.4892188608646393,
-0.7684611678123474,
0.8041236400604248,
-0.018772443756461143,
0.11019260436296463,
0.23823536932468414,
0.6168931126594543,
-0.13798290491104126,
0.5246273875236511,
0.6182851791381836,
-0.2108476459980011,
0.5224557518959045,
-0.22092999517917633,
-0.13512656092643738,
-0.8743835091590881,
-0.5638991594314575,
-0.45062464475631714,
-0.21017971634864807,
-0.548778235912323,
-0.16496123373508453,
-0.21900226175785065,
0.3593994081020355,
-0.41669008135795593,
0.3259151577949524,
0.024666793644428253,
0.23151236772537231,
0.7677343487739563,
0.11322423815727234,
0.4874492585659027,
0.13092665374279022,
-0.20664319396018982,
0.10918152332305908,
-0.5711802840232849,
-0.5499348044395447,
1.2860935926437378,
0.4778318405151367,
0.7101893424987793,
0.24874712526798248,
1.0693093538284302,
-0.04587710648775101,
0.4878461956977844,
-0.8862012624740601,
0.5056171417236328,
-0.17232413589954376,
-0.8634713292121887,
-0.24225957691669464,
-0.3763294816017151,
-1.1591993570327759,
0.2649308145046234,
-0.19077162444591522,
-0.8637756109237671,
-0.05067313462495804,
0.2521113455295563,
-0.4122660756111145,
0.46999266743659973,
-0.5648165941238403,
0.2962665855884552,
-0.03624868020415306,
-0.058710288256406784,
-0.30212846398353577,
-0.47349631786346436,
0.5978826880455017,
-0.3334663212299347,
0.3820338547229767,
0.005666881799697876,
-0.017152972519397736,
0.612141489982605,
-0.13099324703216553,
0.9344350099563599,
0.18335898220539093,
-0.06986041367053986,
0.48382604122161865,
0.5887964963912964,
-0.06894095242023468,
-0.3582521080970764,
0.003914345987141132,
-0.2639068365097046,
0.2781783640384674,
-0.08721762150526047,
-0.4167450964450836,
0.4307132661342621,
-0.707615077495575,
-0.5371494293212891,
-0.26611030101776123,
-0.713320791721344,
-0.028617506846785545,
0.11371544748544693,
0.2893616855144501,
0.36727631092071533,
-0.4912598729133606,
0.06625079363584518,
0.6354155540466309,
-0.16114965081214905,
0.4863601624965668,
0.5973235368728638,
-0.8744889497756958,
-0.2621054947376251,
1.172093391418457,
0.612311601638794,
0.6864272952079773,
0.6429357528686523,
-0.08403364568948746,
-0.014696221798658371,
-0.517728865146637,
0.3133390545845032,
0.22910945117473602,
-0.7856190800666809,
0.16542088985443115,
-0.6499965190887451,
-0.23242145776748657,
0.011204748414456844,
0.19146424531936646,
-0.2430068403482437,
-0.7851049304008484,
-0.2949208915233612,
-0.24583108723163605,
0.07982796430587769,
0.8509785532951355,
0.03615967556834221,
0.16556686162948608,
-0.72784024477005,
0.35888949036598206,
0.29341837763786316,
0.4840153157711029,
0.30963805317878723,
-0.5690213441848755,
-0.1626403033733368,
-0.2583411633968353,
-0.26752805709838867,
-0.43846407532691956,
0.5812058448791504,
0.5862402319908142,
0.7261336445808411,
0.18406344950199127,
-0.48248109221458435,
0.4280211329460144,
-0.5471985936164856,
0.5151067972183228,
0.24231792986392975,
-0.8823614120483398,
0.439789742231369,
-0.18354520201683044,
0.3230842649936676,
0.38604652881622314,
0.5184734463691711,
-0.6744936108589172,
-0.40666916966438293,
-0.862571656703949,
-0.9267154932022095,
0.5712018013000488,
-0.06274914741516113,
0.14072075486183167,
-0.24179473519325256,
0.45963215827941895,
0.359754741191864,
0.4969135820865631,
-0.6658552885055542,
-0.48535239696502686,
-0.23472654819488525,
0.10952720791101456,
-0.6526186466217041,
-0.6795968413352966,
-0.06817162036895752,
-0.31683549284935,
0.43631455302238464,
0.2668277621269226,
0.30720752477645874,
0.01790856011211872,
-0.3862142264842987,
-0.08774998039007187,
0.4039888083934784,
0.9187765121459961,
0.6905127763748169,
-0.5817360877990723,
0.3105394244194031,
-0.005638437811285257,
-0.7291707992553711,
0.0643041655421257,
-0.2897285521030426,
-0.385579913854599,
0.15212103724479675,
0.6343913674354553,
0.5963845252990723,
0.35011419653892517,
-0.5537351965904236,
0.037303291261196136,
0.27751675248146057,
-0.24771060049533844,
-0.6516559720039368,
-0.02548411302268505,
0.42081350088119507,
-0.013308013789355755,
0.23363980650901794,
0.06925228983163834,
0.14794930815696716,
-1.2168526649475098,
0.4444102346897125,
0.14693231880664825,
-0.290818452835083,
-0.4213580787181854,
0.4607974588871002,
-0.05049683153629303,
-0.43511584401130676,
0.6955724954605103,
0.13399434089660645,
-0.7854939699172974,
0.6892091631889343,
0.73021000623703,
0.7469081878662109,
-0.7046686410903931,
0.06518775224685669,
0.8266520500183105,
0.13439086079597473,
-0.33957934379577637,
0.6668254733085632,
0.2128361314535141,
-0.8083401322364807,
0.014582720585167408,
-0.6703705191612244,
0.012523533776402473,
0.1011824831366539,
-1.0384594202041626,
-0.11217031627893448,
-0.7674527764320374,
-0.22871659696102142,
0.44648098945617676,
-0.2565971612930298,
-0.65826815366745,
0.3595605790615082,
0.3165796101093292,
0.7999404072761536,
-0.6816286444664001,
0.974457323551178,
0.4015277922153473,
-0.7409597635269165,
-0.8278114199638367,
-0.24396894872188568,
0.3319867253303528,
-0.8956493139266968,
0.8388224840164185,
0.19013851881027222,
0.013547618873417377,
-0.14347313344478607,
-0.15883496403694153,
-0.9215402007102966,
1.2448948621749878,
-0.16480256617069244,
-0.668458878993988,
0.12198289483785629,
0.0574713870882988,
0.6270807981491089,
-0.5757166743278503,
0.18674995005130768,
0.8274987936019897,
0.03347522392868996,
0.16491006314754486,
-1.0924299955368042,
-0.1801481395959854,
-0.10890404134988785,
0.072356678545475,
0.32516175508499146,
-0.5123977065086365,
1.3056093454360962,
-0.6595727801322937,
-0.4293443560600281,
0.12387794256210327,
0.27221035957336426,
0.1017395630478859,
0.38562992215156555,
0.3235715329647064,
0.48517611622810364,
0.9071191549301147,
-0.04500476270914078,
1.175512433052063,
-0.10214226692914963,
0.40859556198120117,
1.4405255317687988,
-0.11841441690921783,
1.076707363128662,
0.7459332942962646,
-0.2999594509601593,
0.4256017506122589,
0.39246150851249695,
0.1726927012205124,
0.36544254422187805,
0.43045440316200256,
-0.2805021107196808,
-0.2588127851486206,
-0.07748888432979584,
-0.3428521752357483,
0.5343066453933716,
0.6679596304893494,
-0.8925840258598328,
0.043704401701688766,
0.09884487092494965,
-0.17389613389968872,
0.17835678160190582,
-0.767301619052887,
0.9261350631713867,
0.16218498349189758,
-0.8239280581474304,
0.6555889248847961,
-0.2238340824842453,
0.4575769901275635,
-0.46575504541397095,
0.02175702340900898,
-0.1826556921005249,
0.3633648753166199,
-0.31425559520721436,
-0.888008713722229,
0.485546350479126,
-0.7403692007064819,
-0.60038161277771,
-0.17876337468624115,
0.4969470500946045,
-0.9174729585647583,
-0.4393053650856018,
0.42004984617233276,
0.6364580392837524,
0.17948654294013977,
0.08809211105108261,
-0.32589414715766907,
-0.3117623031139374,
0.14155136048793793,
-0.2519506514072418,
0.3662899434566498,
0.23806768655776978,
-0.14532960951328278,
1.2816811800003052,
0.45040759444236755,
-0.045360248535871506,
0.13867181539535522,
0.5409660339355469,
0.4604049026966095,
-0.8672282099723816,
-0.10338408499956131,
-0.7814295291900635,
0.3696229159832001,
0.47975578904151917,
-0.16936668753623962,
0.6625028848648071,
0.6177831888198853,
0.929481565952301,
-0.49773839116096497,
0.5814527273178101,
0.28457072377204895,
1.0544639825820923,
-0.439647376537323,
0.5604284405708313,
-0.4411553144454956,
0.32535648345947266,
-0.389222115278244,
-0.7759544849395752,
-0.35313376784324646,
0.34865307807922363,
0.10773659497499466,
0.006589361932128668,
0.7681272625923157,
0.47630175948143005,
0.17848339676856995,
0.08611302077770233,
0.2654053866863251,
0.05464271083474159,
-0.057434067130088806,
0.8093295693397522,
0.8866939544677734,
-0.06970711052417755,
0.4347243309020996,
-0.4023556113243103,
0.03183560445904732,
-0.24866709113121033,
-0.5505109429359436,
-0.9295575618743896,
-1.0240744352340698,
-0.32001301646232605,
-0.513796865940094,
-0.24050235748291016,
1.0284134149551392,
0.24683190882205963,
-0.8279339671134949,
-0.39427751302719116,
0.056126918643713,
0.2484789341688156,
-0.29082196950912476,
-0.1910417079925537,
0.24675077199935913,
-0.27458497881889343,
-0.5212399363517761,
-0.27768948674201965,
0.1827678084373474,
0.517505407333374,
-0.1887117326259613,
0.06888730078935623,
-0.3893897831439972,
0.12914863228797913,
1.0247728824615479,
0.5880808234214783,
-0.9840735793113708,
-0.2774941623210907,
-0.02480086125433445,
-0.19733330607414246,
-0.027820950374007225,
1.1197726726531982,
-0.7596211433410645,
0.4718206226825714,
0.3981321156024933,
0.26150330901145935,
0.40582364797592163,
-0.05363289266824722,
0.6395700573921204,
-0.545224130153656,
-0.01727522537112236,
0.07748573273420334,
0.589637041091919,
0.18569518625736237,
-0.0004272649239283055,
0.48495545983314514,
0.4185725748538971,
-0.23698681592941284,
-0.6150567531585693,
0.5455922484397888,
-0.9719406962394714,
-0.4318004846572876,
1.0740407705307007,
-0.37458154559135437,
-0.08543559908866882,
-0.34059467911720276,
-0.20232881605625153,
0.09643319249153137,
0.12100823223590851,
0.8674662709236145,
1.1018949747085571,
0.1428651362657547,
-0.3431057035923004,
-0.4280643165111542,
0.4995570182800293,
0.6009414196014404,
-0.3655540943145752,
0.18637841939926147,
0.5119296312332153,
0.6191937923431396,
0.5179970264434814,
0.6375325322151184,
-0.1310688853263855,
0.22755907475948334,
0.0051035769283771515,
0.2300836592912674,
0.14295460283756256,
-0.4422357678413391,
-0.3475375175476074,
0.271884948015213,
0.262991726398468,
-0.0026516634970903397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17744v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17744v1 | Following Length Constraints in Instructions | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | 2024-06-25T17:29:52 | Weizhe Yuan, Ilia Kulikov, Ping Yu, Kyunghyun Cho, Sainbayar Sukhbaatar, Jason Weston, Jing Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligned instruction following models can better fulfill user requests than
their unaligned counterparts. However, it has been shown that there is a length
bias in evaluation of such models, and that training algorithms tend to exploit
this bias by learning longer responses. In this work we show how to train
models that can be controlled at inference time with instructions containing
desired length constraints. Such models are superior in length instructed
evaluations, outperforming standard instruction following models such as GPT4,
Llama 3 and Mixtral. | [
-0.20628845691680908,
-0.27979594469070435,
0.8263056874275208,
0.287512868642807,
-0.09916358441114426,
-0.022585084661841393,
0.1276940256357193,
-0.612327516078949,
0.06917949765920639,
0.6218397617340088,
-0.991885781288147,
-0.23597808182239532,
-0.6306057572364807,
0.0710674449801445,
-0.40070104598999023,
1.0950239896774292,
-0.37219634652137756,
0.31291595101356506,
-0.32331445813179016,
-0.10673005878925323,
-0.7277199029922485,
-0.48075830936431885,
-0.1667357236146927,
-0.7137430906295776,
0.45380619168281555,
0.17967535555362701,
0.9356552362442017,
1.1072204113006592,
0.3871608078479767,
0.2473747581243515,
-0.028869645670056343,
0.25339627265930176,
-0.32978489995002747,
-0.09494970738887787,
0.0878162756562233,
-0.6245837211608887,
-0.20427699387073517,
0.2188398540019989,
0.498582661151886,
0.7187784910202026,
-0.15474246442317963,
0.002417132956907153,
0.1279720962047577,
0.5868512392044067,
-0.5945928692817688,
-0.005450860131531954,
0.0904480591416359,
0.3142848312854767,
0.07211139798164368,
-0.2114499807357788,
-0.4198538362979889,
-0.642513632774353,
0.379055917263031,
-0.6052078008651733,
-0.013653400354087353,
0.0010439098114147782,
0.8046932816505432,
0.39717116951942444,
-0.39579787850379944,
-0.5233891010284424,
-0.7591599225997925,
0.759708821773529,
-0.7132108807563782,
0.6290952563285828,
0.5265466570854187,
0.3336947560310364,
-0.07660108804702759,
-0.6884779334068298,
-0.2231556624174118,
-0.22290751338005066,
-0.21835516393184662,
0.04772225394845009,
0.3220885992050171,
0.39096811413764954,
0.682915210723877,
0.05822655186057091,
-0.408998966217041,
0.506730854511261,
-0.640114426612854,
-0.0415046252310276,
0.6337950825691223,
0.30523407459259033,
0.0588458813726902,
-0.13275721669197083,
-0.5128048062324524,
0.008370579220354557,
-0.8096613883972168,
0.013702875934541225,
0.7263111472129822,
-0.2372603863477707,
-0.2201448231935501,
0.6451047658920288,
-0.2944091558456421,
0.9539331793785095,
0.38303861021995544,
0.07008267939090729,
0.001082340138964355,
-0.17558589577674866,
-0.1852399706840515,
0.06568820774555206,
0.3915068209171295,
0.44838517904281616,
0.15177007019519806,
-0.19808296859264374,
-0.5502596497535706,
0.05898788571357727,
0.1874958574771881,
-0.8584248423576355,
-0.09685955196619034,
-0.05276934802532196,
-0.47409680485725403,
0.10841599106788635,
0.10877744853496552,
-0.570763111114502,
-0.13405905663967133,
-0.6958028674125671,
0.2975277602672577,
-0.4512360990047455,
0.4420187473297119,
0.005066880490630865,
-0.13839855790138245,
0.5538984537124634,
0.1978883445262909,
-1.2807804346084595,
0.5142683386802673,
0.9165465831756592,
0.7969932556152344,
-0.08006036281585693,
-0.21101514995098114,
-0.8430299162864685,
0.2287844568490982,
-0.5979400873184204,
0.6593596935272217,
-1.0013364553451538,
-0.49157053232192993,
-0.1534082591533661,
-0.15311242640018463,
-0.032517317682504654,
-0.10280351340770721,
0.24823832511901855,
-0.8312219977378845,
0.46659061312675476,
-0.36342817544937134,
-1.0242090225219727,
-0.27134549617767334,
-0.18585535883903503,
-0.6282274127006531,
0.6956453323364258,
0.23435960710048676,
-0.8013734817504883,
0.4691511392593384,
-0.7946850061416626,
-0.42199283838272095,
-0.19119581580162048,
-0.21908269822597504,
-0.27622342109680176,
0.10676928609609604,
0.6218664050102234,
0.34143581986427307,
-0.05506536364555359,
-0.15991118550300598,
-0.4642641246318817,
-0.6092161536216736,
0.04490352421998978,
-0.3408622443675995,
0.6828084588050842,
0.27609455585479736,
-0.3211788833141327,
0.46180102229118347,
-0.6041374802589417,
0.14875465631484985,
-0.01444662269204855,
-0.36617323756217957,
-0.371518075466156,
0.19339659810066223,
-0.671727180480957,
-0.16394555568695068,
0.2442636340856552,
-0.34492501616477966,
0.2586241364479065,
-0.2704257369041443,
0.6419087648391724,
1.0397210121154785,
0.1930764615535736,
0.6695853471755981,
-0.3420625627040863,
0.7686759233474731,
-0.4947684407234192,
0.3362789750099182,
-0.03971987962722778,
-0.12321790307760239,
-0.6979068517684937,
0.17627249658107758,
0.36570850014686584,
0.6272155046463013,
-0.6086324453353882,
0.05468469485640526,
-0.1533159762620926,
-0.226725235581398,
-0.5993672013282776,
0.34053486585617065,
0.6842858195304871,
0.4615553319454193,
0.3550601601600647,
-0.3962916433811188,
-0.6362302899360657,
-0.7604517340660095,
-0.10476468503475189,
0.13929887115955353,
-0.25969576835632324,
0.3049507439136505,
0.35212114453315735,
-0.18164117634296417,
0.5041248798370361,
-0.4869990348815918,
0.3662011921405792,
-0.24967245757579803,
0.05277489870786667,
0.19929514825344086,
0.40056508779525757,
0.44162997603416443,
-0.6130475997924805,
-0.5700839161872864,
-0.15387941896915436,
-0.7160055041313171,
-0.2851724624633789,
-0.12581367790699005,
-0.1403961479663849,
0.024868780747056007,
0.3697661757469177,
-0.604510486125946,
0.7859457731246948,
0.464262992143631,
0.03941117972135544,
0.5169517993927002,
-0.06504353880882263,
0.05797692388296127,
-0.6983122229576111,
-0.49498477578163147,
-0.021875077858567238,
-0.3894348442554474,
-0.48501092195510864,
-0.0504608079791069,
0.25139814615249634,
0.19928398728370667,
-0.1572311818599701,
0.30852675437927246,
-1.0558586120605469,
-0.5101034641265869,
-0.40587878227233887,
-0.22165440022945404,
0.19269579648971558,
0.5229088664054871,
0.37670546770095825,
0.7491373419761658,
0.46261370182037354,
-0.6962583661079407,
0.38435783982276917,
0.49084973335266113,
-0.6194818615913391,
0.3429121673107147,
-0.858018159866333,
0.48011597990989685,
0.03991023823618889,
0.3363683819770813,
-0.47270816564559937,
-0.5707299709320068,
0.04461259767413139,
-0.25102877616882324,
0.45051947236061096,
-0.30040663480758667,
-0.24572300910949707,
-0.7121618986129761,
-0.2961784601211548,
0.18472492694854736,
0.699295163154602,
-0.8202896118164062,
0.35433846712112427,
-0.1719868928194046,
0.23389093577861786,
-0.9954621195793152,
-0.589755117893219,
-0.7121331095695496,
-0.3554043471813202,
-0.23256371915340424,
0.3167855143547058,
-0.05865427851676941,
-0.053115930408239365,
-0.13052250444889069,
-0.3055607080459595,
-0.027651866897940636,
-0.1468210220336914,
0.45441576838493347,
0.29052719473838806,
-0.08481772243976593,
-0.13685549795627594,
0.14882855117321014,
0.299293577671051,
0.13101010024547577,
-0.20300468802452087,
0.5131107568740845,
0.32606634497642517,
-0.736972451210022,
-1.023769736289978,
0.48571163415908813,
0.10135384649038315,
-0.222992941737175,
0.4941085875034332,
0.2752695679664612,
-0.15080951154232025,
-0.18328754603862762,
-0.47178271412849426,
-0.5369519591331482,
-0.49953708052635193,
0.24398253858089447,
-0.3304012417793274,
-0.8468468189239502,
0.36934560537338257,
0.40742039680480957,
0.2401641607284546,
0.04794452711939812,
0.18639123439788818,
-0.16197408735752106,
1.3974180221557617,
1.052049994468689,
-0.029516523703932762,
0.7447472810745239,
-0.08504676073789597,
-0.15008823573589325,
-1.0987111330032349,
-0.16290979087352753,
-0.2283364087343216,
-0.35502830147743225,
-0.4352174699306488,
-0.31913626194000244,
0.08887258172035217,
0.22893798351287842,
-0.25772225856781006,
0.4020976126194,
-0.5328933596611023,
0.6664024591445923,
0.7075657844543457,
0.39547815918922424,
-0.29242920875549316,
-0.08868800103664398,
-0.24617597460746765,
0.08362281322479248,
-0.8364108800888062,
-0.35014790296554565,
1.0928550958633423,
0.6564330458641052,
1.1553725004196167,
-0.1849242001771927,
0.776658296585083,
0.11156406253576279,
0.30681943893432617,
-0.5551158785820007,
0.3059535622596741,
0.29154372215270996,
-0.5523965954780579,
-0.14625228941440582,
-0.45025619864463806,
-0.7185136675834656,
-0.16158996522426605,
0.2003934532403946,
-0.9264899492263794,
0.07980372756719589,
0.32111915946006775,
-0.6560113430023193,
0.27353471517562866,
-0.7900735139846802,
0.45201146602630615,
-0.6161326169967651,
-0.4082091152667999,
-0.06235792860388756,
-0.9608001708984375,
0.1499796062707901,
0.3168169856071472,
-0.2643333077430725,
0.09245665371417999,
0.007870745845139027,
0.7803027629852295,
-0.6869524717330933,
0.9885370135307312,
-0.22669701278209686,
0.2292095124721527,
0.5344295501708984,
-0.05479126051068306,
0.49086788296699524,
-0.16434156894683838,
0.08974158018827438,
-0.25616419315338135,
-0.19148632884025574,
-0.5262507796287537,
-0.787672758102417,
0.6249164342880249,
-0.840393602848053,
-1.0096118450164795,
-0.1313680112361908,
-0.6224851012229919,
-0.3130437433719635,
0.15668097138404846,
0.49716782569885254,
0.3981455862522125,
0.08325263857841492,
-0.08755534887313843,
0.7601377964019775,
-0.06790086627006531,
0.5862746238708496,
0.21406055986881256,
-0.1997695416212082,
-0.19151011109352112,
0.34564948081970215,
0.14325159788131714,
0.5810970067977905,
0.5360241532325745,
0.0634581446647644,
-0.5766933560371399,
-0.5584588646888733,
-0.5254194736480713,
0.1904875636100769,
-0.8223058581352234,
-0.2569255530834198,
-0.3713732659816742,
-0.4645310044288635,
-0.43801698088645935,
-0.2208481878042221,
-0.15219861268997192,
-0.32871249318122864,
-0.4864653944969177,
-0.5590327382087708,
0.35313180088996887,
1.2138702869415283,
-0.10287445783615112,
0.8996005654335022,
-0.695216715335846,
-0.006493392866104841,
0.4823801517486572,
0.6035244464874268,
0.09859954565763474,
-0.671744167804718,
-0.09783733636140823,
-0.09827393293380737,
-0.49248284101486206,
-1.168566346168518,
0.13927455246448517,
-0.06714169681072235,
0.5661057829856873,
0.6984987258911133,
-0.3544817268848419,
0.9150190949440002,
-0.8014997243881226,
0.4913090765476227,
0.18383662402629852,
-0.8925411105155945,
0.6354624032974243,
0.00054472143528983,
0.47662290930747986,
0.12219143658876419,
1.0016626119613647,
-0.1576310396194458,
0.2063167542219162,
-0.38920584321022034,
-0.3474169075489044,
0.6977433562278748,
-0.008833224885165691,
0.1714809387922287,
0.053885478526353836,
0.7292400002479553,
0.26416414976119995,
0.11961477994918823,
-0.68550705909729,
0.2236524075269699,
-0.21740980446338654,
-0.1420455276966095,
0.26452916860580444,
-0.4989455044269562,
-0.14980493485927582,
0.08425696939229965,
0.5904452800750732,
-0.035143155604600906,
0.45730122923851013,
0.07764168083667755,
-0.04500818997621536,
-0.07261501997709274,
0.04484425485134125,
0.6664129495620728,
1.1038672924041748,
-0.11026673763990402,
-0.27544257044792175,
0.30910611152648926,
-0.08793892711400986,
0.00945854838937521,
0.19756478071212769,
-0.19073055684566498,
-0.198782280087471,
0.6568182110786438,
1.2279300689697266,
-0.14620815217494965,
-0.3486071527004242,
0.3633067011833191,
0.11216156929731369,
-0.1822999268770218,
-0.23991386592388153,
0.45868393778800964,
-0.0545230358839035,
0.4223342835903168,
-0.1310441493988037,
-0.17182637751102448,
0.2947022318840027,
-0.1957160234451294,
0.21387611329555511,
0.3498065173625946,
-0.8582724332809448,
-0.31728431582450867,
0.8743808269500732,
-0.10179750621318817,
-0.3253341019153595,
0.8548880815505981,
0.3037817180156708,
-0.7195726633071899,
0.6299252510070801,
0.54108726978302,
0.40425804257392883,
-0.5336779952049255,
0.11211206018924713,
0.20979203283786774,
0.21811191737651825,
-0.2046034336090088,
0.27423956990242004,
-0.4583282172679901,
-0.3924776613712311,
-0.6052699685096741,
-0.4656520485877991,
-0.3266410827636719,
-0.0380028672516346,
-1.0380756855010986,
0.27588096261024475,
-0.9557204246520996,
-0.08682464808225632,
-0.006067445036023855,
-0.12240844964981079,
-0.6980411410331726,
0.13610239326953888,
0.13584990799427032,
1.0611965656280518,
-0.6486514806747437,
0.7260681986808777,
0.20918242633342743,
-0.3062855005264282,
-1.177438497543335,
-0.35173678398132324,
0.11483606696128845,
-0.9155898094177246,
0.4937843978404999,
0.6457230448722839,
-0.03700368106365204,
-0.40356436371803284,
-0.921828031539917,
-0.7313585877418518,
1.0134825706481934,
0.1101507693529129,
-0.764813244342804,
-0.38909751176834106,
-0.10273796319961548,
0.4428541660308838,
-0.5107778906822205,
0.3947388827800751,
0.6810064315795898,
0.10521221160888672,
0.12802919745445251,
-0.8374088406562805,
-0.17620091140270233,
0.11759946495294571,
0.12260673940181732,
0.33352726697921753,
-0.6926798820495605,
0.5863138437271118,
-0.48394206166267395,
-0.021872004494071007,
0.4512895345687866,
1.1510387659072876,
0.1045113280415535,
0.19420701265335083,
0.3917000889778137,
0.6904039978981018,
0.6031177043914795,
0.050671424716711044,
1.3250768184661865,
0.16217193007469177,
-0.0714554414153099,
1.6068692207336426,
-0.3678337335586548,
0.5502573251724243,
0.3500280976295471,
0.009175989776849747,
0.7650433778762817,
1.180008053779602,
-0.15052630007266998,
0.7836273908615112,
0.25046980381011963,
0.08778943121433258,
-0.08145571500062943,
0.1800103336572647,
-0.3393910527229309,
0.13637757301330566,
0.5379452109336853,
-0.5714542269706726,
0.2616126537322998,
-0.1362924426794052,
0.008433791808784008,
0.1667419821023941,
-0.46305909752845764,
0.7895351052284241,
0.08361868560314178,
-1.050340175628662,
0.5947949290275574,
-0.147449791431427,
0.29558417201042175,
-0.678741991519928,
-0.25615471601486206,
-0.41633516550064087,
-0.04479461908340454,
-0.21669545769691467,
-0.6809324026107788,
-0.12072362005710602,
-0.01709611713886261,
-0.14119470119476318,
-0.014940663240849972,
0.29291069507598877,
-0.16017329692840576,
-0.20875000953674316,
0.3319997191429138,
-0.007833816111087799,
0.07660088688135147,
0.49856385588645935,
-0.6900259256362915,
-0.008564777672290802,
0.3349299132823944,
-0.4272274672985077,
0.12323281913995743,
0.32000264525413513,
-0.5161728858947754,
0.9241275191307068,
0.28188639879226685,
-0.07538894563913345,
0.5915605425834656,
-0.0349772609770298,
0.8133437633514404,
-0.41339999437332153,
-0.5041433572769165,
-0.8261623978614807,
0.11102759093046188,
-0.23514114320278168,
-0.059678319841623306,
0.6165581941604614,
0.35388457775115967,
0.9586413502693176,
-0.005990300327539444,
0.5885176658630371,
0.22435420751571655,
0.6843404769897461,
-0.9635413885116577,
0.12892450392246246,
-0.3219018876552582,
0.4941096007823944,
0.08813486993312836,
-1.1466032266616821,
-0.08622478693723679,
0.5962024331092834,
-0.7286569476127625,
0.397833913564682,
0.4809339940547943,
0.43470123410224915,
-0.3710397183895111,
0.284901887178421,
-0.07545991241931915,
-0.19242945313453674,
0.2677793502807617,
0.9139024019241333,
1.1759734153747559,
0.11529725790023804,
0.23944887518882751,
-0.5355163812637329,
-0.3194524645805359,
-0.04845305532217026,
-0.7876150608062744,
-1.2764697074890137,
-0.052849020808935165,
0.003059270093217492,
-0.20533743500709534,
0.21465294063091278,
0.8254520893096924,
1.0156261920928955,
-0.7316554188728333,
-0.2563610076904297,
0.0014401376247406006,
0.19879089295864105,
-0.24666832387447357,
-0.09793759137392044,
0.45771700143814087,
-0.19244921207427979,
-0.7012849450111389,
0.32329607009887695,
-0.055004965513944626,
0.5622000098228455,
-0.23150402307510376,
-0.3810339868068695,
-0.17791049182415009,
0.2705535590648651,
0.11820179969072342,
0.4632156789302826,
-0.7467312216758728,
-0.567352294921875,
0.0017925933934748173,
0.008982762694358826,
0.18094249069690704,
0.7474509477615356,
-0.39103958010673523,
0.29445648193359375,
0.4081661105155945,
0.6596710085868835,
0.7645542621612549,
0.27366864681243896,
0.871740460395813,
-0.7236878871917725,
0.09443214535713196,
0.2573838233947754,
0.3326255679130554,
0.44282326102256775,
-0.6312568187713623,
0.716637134552002,
-0.29655584692955017,
-0.7630679607391357,
-0.5956078171730042,
0.43093475699424744,
-0.503387987613678,
-0.16470655798912048,
1.0040853023529053,
-0.4759409725666046,
-0.4055270850658417,
0.5661313533782959,
0.0760917216539383,
0.27208858728408813,
-0.13689133524894714,
0.6197831630706787,
0.7809609770774841,
-0.7581382989883423,
-0.25574445724487305,
-0.8213317394256592,
0.5779063701629639,
0.5918145179748535,
-0.5079124569892883,
-0.2842329442501068,
0.7725520133972168,
0.4105556905269623,
-0.04839002341032028,
0.32166117429733276,
-0.020229483023285866,
0.39261195063591003,
-0.10168400406837463,
-0.3796596825122833,
-0.041468437761068344,
-0.6999257802963257,
-0.23764383792877197,
-0.19736339151859283,
0.006392019800841808,
-0.3609521687030792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17739v1 | Find Parent then Label Children: A Two-stage Taxonomy Completion Method with Pre-trained Language Model | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | 2024-06-25T17:25:02 | Fei Xia, Yixuan Weng, Shizhu He, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Taxonomies, which organize domain concepts into hierarchical structures, are
crucial for building knowledge systems and downstream applications. As domain
knowledge evolves, taxonomies need to be continuously updated to include new
concepts. Previous approaches have mainly focused on adding concepts to the
leaf nodes of the existing hierarchical tree, which does not fully utilize the
taxonomy's knowledge and is unable to update the original taxonomy structure
(usually involving non-leaf nodes). In this paper, we propose a two-stage
method called ATTEMPT for taxonomy completion. Our method inserts new concepts
into the correct position by finding a parent node and labeling child nodes.
Specifically, by combining local nodes with prompts to generate natural
sentences, we take advantage of pre-trained language models for
hypernym/hyponymy recognition. Experimental results on two public datasets
(including six domains) show that ATTEMPT performs best on both taxonomy
completion and extension tasks, surpassing existing methods. | [
-0.3058491051197052,
-0.4498002827167511,
0.4665393531322479,
-0.17420218884944916,
-0.2725893259048462,
0.42853087186813354,
-0.028573613613843918,
-0.3884809911251068,
0.16886761784553528,
0.2902832627296448,
-0.7456196546554565,
-0.48073580861091614,
-0.5702540874481201,
0.04941141977906227,
-0.1439010053873062,
0.7696682810783386,
-0.2790133059024811,
-0.44802388548851013,
-0.3576960861682892,
0.29952219128608704,
-0.35402050614356995,
-0.5057787299156189,
-0.7099239826202393,
-0.2919449210166931,
0.47191691398620605,
0.4952186644077301,
0.6032336950302124,
0.975307047367096,
0.44703564047813416,
0.18055360019207,
-0.3954140841960907,
0.3474586009979248,
-0.13880737125873566,
0.06395473331212997,
-0.4567108750343323,
-0.37581005692481995,
-0.43170711398124695,
0.24094580113887787,
0.7198769450187683,
1.1283560991287231,
-0.17017515003681183,
0.14943888783454895,
0.1644081175327301,
0.20098303258419037,
-0.6876540184020996,
0.1729171872138977,
-0.7527535557746887,
0.25568288564682007,
-0.19995275139808655,
-0.4813622236251831,
-0.3563045263290405,
-0.2411319613456726,
0.45938724279403687,
-0.7967653274536133,
0.24696986377239227,
-0.02375306375324726,
0.9950903058052063,
0.09841706603765488,
-0.42163318395614624,
-0.29116716980934143,
-0.6320017576217651,
0.7541370987892151,
-0.5844279527664185,
0.41092684864997864,
0.45535483956336975,
-0.0651274025440216,
-0.29210391640663147,
-0.8454260230064392,
-0.5421606302261353,
-0.20259502530097961,
-0.38463926315307617,
0.07542142271995544,
-0.17366668581962585,
0.05277348309755325,
0.3053327798843384,
0.08149959146976471,
-0.532051682472229,
0.17667165398597717,
-0.1305965781211853,
-0.13844315707683563,
0.008354077115654945,
-0.18482115864753723,
0.4228348135948181,
-0.470832496881485,
-0.47696372866630554,
-0.06628676503896713,
-0.7350743412971497,
-0.31374552845954895,
0.0654497891664505,
0.5315582156181335,
0.2781238257884979,
0.6522692441940308,
-0.28971126675605774,
0.79608553647995,
0.03903660923242569,
-0.3549617826938629,
0.35803818702697754,
-0.574501097202301,
-0.06479000300168991,
-0.12399952858686447,
0.4959094822406769,
0.17129282653331757,
0.1208106279373169,
-0.26805004477500916,
-0.24461552500724792,
0.014556046575307846,
0.39881065487861633,
-0.26573890447616577,
-0.13520434498786926,
0.16397641599178314,
-0.16952039301395416,
-0.21903716027736664,
-0.27227604389190674,
-0.6430811285972595,
-0.12091086804866791,
-0.3303629159927368,
0.518248438835144,
-0.4024638533592224,
-0.30828744173049927,
-0.15083007514476776,
-0.1216060221195221,
0.3432404398918152,
0.41386961936950684,
-0.7089373469352722,
0.36873599886894226,
0.9616488218307495,
0.8978967666625977,
-0.13200388848781586,
-0.6405327320098877,
-0.49788665771484375,
0.41778498888015747,
-0.5576980710029602,
0.598325252532959,
-0.5074265003204346,
-0.09285809844732285,
0.1315915733575821,
-0.08581749349832535,
-0.32625988125801086,
-0.6442462801933289,
0.46072056889533997,
-0.7357021570205688,
0.22092650830745697,
0.17364171147346497,
-0.6740003228187561,
0.02307126671075821,
0.32338055968284607,
-0.31270384788513184,
1.0383679866790771,
0.43978792428970337,
-0.907537579536438,
0.6097890138626099,
-0.5592586994171143,
-0.4200226068496704,
0.40183091163635254,
0.272595077753067,
-0.17206355929374695,
-0.017512081190943718,
-0.057242974638938904,
0.3989524245262146,
0.02456001564860344,
0.3127972483634949,
0.1329880654811859,
0.09455203264951706,
-0.05066719651222229,
0.17628726363182068,
0.7673516869544983,
-0.0360066257417202,
-0.2489813268184662,
-0.1448628455400467,
-0.5331255793571472,
0.05080992355942726,
0.008318877778947353,
-0.22310209274291992,
-0.5726006031036377,
0.10245124995708466,
-0.32079482078552246,
0.25295135378837585,
0.39203208684921265,
-0.49046769738197327,
0.5090183019638062,
-0.3472925126552582,
0.31700578331947327,
0.33522170782089233,
0.17192640900611877,
0.42425790429115295,
-0.16197778284549713,
0.7517832517623901,
0.07353349775075912,
0.3770171105861664,
-0.13935065269470215,
-0.6282781958580017,
-0.8744433522224426,
0.032040759921073914,
0.790722668170929,
0.4798445701599121,
-1.1388589143753052,
0.7189019918441772,
-0.3539453446865082,
-0.4777367115020752,
-0.13493819534778595,
0.11346734315156937,
0.528581440448761,
0.5638261437416077,
0.4455967843532562,
-0.7548638582229614,
-0.7328962683677673,
-0.6837158799171448,
0.21363547444343567,
-0.5913898944854736,
0.033903591334819794,
0.170596644282341,
0.7052401304244995,
-0.49962738156318665,
1.2726103067398071,
-0.7713640332221985,
-0.3968392610549927,
0.02345721796154976,
0.4678226709365845,
0.025934863835573196,
0.5927068591117859,
0.3102089762687683,
-0.6523977518081665,
-0.19633954763412476,
0.005071152467280626,
-0.4630190432071686,
0.19925929605960846,
0.17733505368232727,
-0.20001809298992157,
0.1274600774049759,
0.15459473431110382,
-0.6798657178878784,
0.2178785353899002,
0.2218404859304428,
0.028691302984952927,
0.4642297923564911,
-0.06673876196146011,
-0.14929819107055664,
-1.0714097023010254,
-0.1407715529203415,
-0.06494367122650146,
-0.14116425812244415,
-0.8455474972724915,
0.3077393174171448,
0.042503997683525085,
0.14357535541057587,
-0.47863447666168213,
0.3857479691505432,
-0.5886688828468323,
0.10373067110776901,
-0.17630445957183838,
0.15271450579166412,
-0.3308653235435486,
0.3659087121486664,
0.22429406642913818,
0.4650704860687256,
0.7417429685592651,
-0.7349462509155273,
0.3199726939201355,
0.2362116128206253,
-0.313086599111557,
0.5847732424736023,
-0.21637220680713654,
0.12434372305870056,
-0.21629787981510162,
0.2982291877269745,
-0.9533376693725586,
-0.6260617971420288,
0.5805850028991699,
-0.5925119519233704,
0.3957252502441406,
-0.5051686763763428,
-0.5739096999168396,
-0.8057940006256104,
-0.09492512792348862,
0.5199035406112671,
0.5277155637741089,
-0.7164502739906311,
0.4040384888648987,
0.5045828819274902,
-0.29393166303634644,
-0.6035836935043335,
-0.36936715245246887,
0.34710177779197693,
-0.05804257467389107,
-0.23999257385730743,
0.5629193186759949,
0.2569348216056824,
0.2765975892543793,
0.21042582392692566,
-0.1939530372619629,
-0.3710189759731293,
0.10862594097852707,
-0.15485922992229462,
0.21956992149353027,
-0.22142425179481506,
0.11820212751626968,
0.08574514836072922,
-0.1945224404335022,
0.059620074927806854,
-0.7169862985610962,
0.558047890663147,
0.3650701940059662,
-0.016642918810248375,
-0.49809029698371887,
0.124018095433712,
0.3370901942253113,
-0.26465848088264465,
0.36375415325164795,
0.07129933685064316,
-1.020694375038147,
-0.2575438618659973,
-0.3439241349697113,
0.00659968564286828,
-0.4024966061115265,
0.17744866013526917,
-0.37188106775283813,
-0.731078565120697,
-0.1343773752450943,
-0.16944044828414917,
0.08360136300325394,
0.4292509853839874,
-0.0005918327369727194,
-0.20811200141906738,
0.7796840667724609,
0.6526310443878174,
0.23397594690322876,
0.18291282653808594,
-0.32511094212532043,
0.19061987102031708,
-1.0534008741378784,
-0.3418693542480469,
-0.5873671174049377,
0.02599790133535862,
-0.377635657787323,
-0.6685047745704651,
0.12993080914020538,
0.3910342752933502,
0.1597425788640976,
0.8772681951522827,
-0.5984320044517517,
0.2518733739852905,
0.8620415925979614,
0.04643993452191353,
0.5581544041633606,
0.252038836479187,
-0.04897451773285866,
-0.008730163797736168,
-0.8974462747573853,
-0.5202612280845642,
0.8634987473487854,
0.3414731025695801,
0.46022000908851624,
0.10830006003379822,
1.1758129596710205,
-0.09014327079057693,
0.6964877247810364,
-1.1863895654678345,
0.4391635060310364,
-0.16306377947330475,
-0.4783249497413635,
-0.33415770530700684,
-0.43058449029922485,
-1.1215887069702148,
-0.023828567937016487,
-0.037656355649232864,
-0.781340479850769,
0.3416139781475067,
0.22932404279708862,
-0.5049651265144348,
0.0717298686504364,
-0.4858352541923523,
0.6694112420082092,
-0.06953485310077667,
0.07181454449892044,
0.1241513192653656,
-0.6681205630302429,
0.4384582042694092,
-0.3202415406703949,
0.2880658209323883,
0.16550081968307495,
-0.42105501890182495,
1.209499716758728,
-0.5634976625442505,
0.8436453938484192,
-0.21523506939411163,
-0.2886542081832886,
0.47185319662094116,
0.031752489507198334,
0.2996092438697815,
-0.2805848717689514,
0.43558114767074585,
-0.34386762976646423,
-0.04418615251779556,
-0.18179430067539215,
-0.7644615769386292,
0.31898948550224304,
-0.44149649143218994,
-0.4974997341632843,
-0.7786366939544678,
-0.18901614844799042,
-0.3776065707206726,
0.294829785823822,
0.14297525584697723,
0.3962470293045044,
0.08507988601922989,
-0.17425213754177094,
0.6274181604385376,
0.0878019854426384,
0.2934603989124298,
0.16616703569889069,
-0.32201966643333435,
-0.4731461703777313,
0.8043475151062012,
0.44675010442733765,
0.35427770018577576,
0.37980929017066956,
0.15007199347019196,
-0.4219936430454254,
-0.636996328830719,
-0.2895384430885315,
0.24419766664505005,
-0.4783605933189392,
-0.5144962668418884,
-0.9956879615783691,
-0.46824949979782104,
-0.4008013904094696,
0.07651879638433456,
-0.18498699367046356,
-0.4430270493030548,
-0.008138105273246765,
-0.05865596607327461,
0.26323390007019043,
0.9183727502822876,
-0.20218555629253387,
0.6709214448928833,
-0.7945131063461304,
0.5222976803779602,
0.5690898895263672,
0.2787439525127411,
0.314485102891922,
-0.5302310585975647,
-0.12269136309623718,
0.23683980107307434,
-0.1998959183692932,
-0.8893865942955017,
0.14981156587600708,
0.2774389684200287,
0.4222554564476013,
0.21542774140834808,
-0.24955900013446808,
0.7584921717643738,
-0.658003568649292,
0.45988863706588745,
0.29842254519462585,
-0.9243485927581787,
1.04965341091156,
-0.2948766350746155,
0.13090048730373383,
0.4771564304828644,
0.7811020612716675,
-0.6436020135879517,
-0.1803865134716034,
-0.8958050012588501,
-0.8639620542526245,
0.8230115175247192,
0.2017233967781067,
0.15825261175632477,
-0.046655528247356415,
0.387768417596817,
-0.12743301689624786,
0.2361457794904709,
-0.42025285959243774,
-0.23650558292865753,
0.18170738220214844,
-0.09709519147872925,
0.15502884984016418,
-0.32916495203971863,
-0.21962134540081024,
-0.46388792991638184,
0.7376737594604492,
-0.15147563815116882,
-0.061378173530101776,
0.04370283707976341,
-0.13385210931301117,
-0.2338608354330063,
0.2549338936805725,
0.10788413137197495,
0.9830664396286011,
-0.20219697058200836,
0.3073747456073761,
-0.13425172865390778,
-0.36365193128585815,
0.4324384033679962,
0.1090678870677948,
-0.5766749382019043,
0.27840960025787354,
0.6374275088310242,
0.48457542061805725,
0.39614337682724,
-0.3077792227268219,
0.5780676603317261,
0.33844295144081116,
-0.3119569420814514,
-0.09560679644346237,
0.02042767032980919,
0.14760561287403107,
-0.3162451386451721,
0.5232099890708923,
-0.0466175451874733,
0.008603793568909168,
-0.9778602123260498,
0.6542497873306274,
0.2896064817905426,
-0.33422109484672546,
-0.03180843964219093,
0.3801272213459015,
-0.09244578331708908,
-0.5172623991966248,
0.5095242261886597,
-0.5611298084259033,
-0.9324061870574951,
0.6204883456230164,
0.6271675229072571,
0.7619194388389587,
-0.36518314480781555,
0.7735898494720459,
0.6030965447425842,
0.2744292616844177,
-0.3152332901954651,
0.27671828866004944,
-0.0674777403473854,
-0.8085435628890991,
-0.7292102575302124,
-0.7725728154182434,
-0.5678313970565796,
-0.0877956673502922,
-0.5882685780525208,
0.08994649350643158,
-0.4183354377746582,
-0.32929128408432007,
0.1577441692352295,
-0.1153624951839447,
-0.4499836564064026,
0.5328255891799927,
0.08049582690000534,
0.8953901529312134,
-0.8123139142990112,
0.7137006521224976,
0.8098161220550537,
-0.23224429786205292,
-0.8967158794403076,
0.36970198154449463,
-0.10217227041721344,
-0.43764445185661316,
0.6082758903503418,
0.0040336064994335175,
-0.11284935474395752,
0.28259479999542236,
-0.5426334142684937,
-1.2236151695251465,
0.8498591184616089,
-0.2307765930891037,
-0.5061359405517578,
-0.3413974642753601,
-0.13817498087882996,
0.5496373772621155,
-0.45991283655166626,
0.014766874723136425,
0.7585188150405884,
0.5245922803878784,
0.5842635631561279,
-0.8683531880378723,
0.02297595888376236,
0.04531541094183922,
0.2259761244058609,
0.31108492612838745,
-0.10137739777565002,
0.6043999195098877,
-0.2269534170627594,
-0.519712507724762,
0.17964136600494385,
0.8368115425109863,
0.2533721625804901,
0.07349187880754471,
0.8445233106613159,
0.6847445368766785,
0.9471036195755005,
-0.19539934396743774,
0.5433956980705261,
-0.12913095951080322,
0.5769413709640503,
1.2960408926010132,
-0.31667986512184143,
0.9488871097564697,
0.2406519502401352,
-0.36379778385162354,
0.35962194204330444,
1.099221110343933,
0.08886116743087769,
0.44454601407051086,
0.31498846411705017,
-0.23591193556785583,
-0.0828760415315628,
-0.5590006113052368,
-0.4411090016365051,
0.1632647067308426,
0.4712992012500763,
0.06425286829471588,
-0.24521610140800476,
0.06035247817635536,
0.19833631813526154,
-0.1385485827922821,
-0.3745475113391876,
0.8301617503166199,
0.030025530606508255,
-1.0712019205093384,
0.5984504222869873,
-0.062168460339307785,
0.8215049505233765,
-0.45081400871276855,
0.000704376318026334,
-0.02985086292028427,
-0.3354167640209198,
-0.38106009364128113,
-0.7277987599372864,
0.07728157192468643,
0.012136110104620457,
0.022921793162822723,
-0.23754391074180603,
0.5207109451293945,
-0.7334445118904114,
-0.5851874351501465,
0.37814801931381226,
0.6833748817443848,
0.006105527281761169,
0.22600848972797394,
-0.37848901748657227,
-0.48613235354423523,
-0.3330455720424652,
0.0231391042470932,
-0.229618102312088,
0.406564861536026,
-0.0391312874853611,
0.4998984634876251,
0.4240935146808624,
0.23883727192878723,
0.31329965591430664,
0.08286209404468536,
0.7646531462669373,
-0.5203956365585327,
-0.14983801543712616,
-0.5423802733421326,
0.265164852142334,
-0.03551475331187248,
-0.2556872069835663,
0.46515586972236633,
0.7223432064056396,
1.346115231513977,
-0.11668934673070908,
0.8713459372520447,
-0.4112498462200165,
0.6627246737480164,
-0.5336705446243286,
0.24015077948570251,
-0.7189187407493591,
-0.25967201590538025,
-0.39005807042121887,
-1.1072826385498047,
-0.5302829146385193,
0.4337078034877777,
-0.007624685298651457,
0.008280398324131966,
1.1512017250061035,
0.76691734790802,
-0.24864919483661652,
-0.35103359818458557,
-0.08222517371177673,
0.25469645857810974,
-0.1329464167356491,
0.7243746519088745,
1.140692949295044,
-0.31446775794029236,
0.22947131097316742,
-0.6452984809875488,
-0.6113718748092651,
0.05086717754602432,
-0.5703111290931702,
-0.48538586497306824,
-0.6794092059135437,
-0.7539613842964172,
-0.5302238464355469,
0.23583197593688965,
1.0365712642669678,
0.6084347367286682,
-0.7060815691947937,
-0.08828230202198029,
0.08421441167593002,
0.16547733545303345,
-0.2729009985923767,
-0.19180089235305786,
0.4301303029060364,
-0.5986216068267822,
-0.83770352602005,
0.3245312571525574,
0.2713066339492798,
0.08096882700920105,
-0.013759642839431763,
0.19117453694343567,
-0.5879409909248352,
-0.14960597455501556,
0.49846020340919495,
0.2749353051185608,
-0.7297964096069336,
-0.4150428771972656,
-0.1928378939628601,
-0.20607203245162964,
0.1763385534286499,
0.9163258671760559,
-0.8142722249031067,
0.36926090717315674,
0.543569028377533,
0.5488389134407043,
0.24897995591163635,
0.1400381624698639,
0.40126341581344604,
-0.7489724159240723,
-0.30170029401779175,
0.26768428087234497,
0.2973540425300598,
0.25986775755882263,
-0.1387709230184555,
0.7842715382575989,
0.46328121423721313,
0.123023621737957,
-0.8083296418190002,
0.42674726247787476,
-0.9045337438583374,
-0.22766093909740448,
1.049178957939148,
-0.048684012144804,
-0.353558748960495,
-0.28699949383735657,
-0.0774335190653801,
0.4345630705356598,
0.13629412651062012,
0.45356032252311707,
0.6761075258255005,
0.07316938042640686,
0.10395581275224686,
-0.3722175359725952,
0.6631373763084412,
0.26365694403648376,
-0.7707695364952087,
-0.11043920367956161,
0.31134846806526184,
0.07286426424980164,
0.601712703704834,
0.8604119420051575,
0.07237497717142105,
0.24720722436904907,
-0.2801384925842285,
0.10657753795385361,
0.43158218264579773,
-0.8389124274253845,
-0.08582540601491928,
0.22122737765312195,
0.20655782520771027,
-0.21435117721557617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17737v1 | LLM Targeted Underperformance Disproportionately Impacts Vulnerable Users | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | 2024-06-25T17:24:07 | Elinor Poole-Dayan, Deb Roy, Jad Kabbara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | While state-of-the-art Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on many tasks, there has been extensive research on undesirable
model behavior such as hallucinations and bias. In this work, we investigate
how the quality of LLM responses changes in terms of information accuracy,
truthfulness, and refusals depending on three user traits: English proficiency,
education level, and country of origin. We present extensive experimentation on
three state-of-the-art LLMs and two different datasets targeting truthfulness
and factuality. Our findings suggest that undesirable behaviors in
state-of-the-art LLMs occur disproportionately more for users with lower
English proficiency, of lower education status, and originating from outside
the US, rendering these models unreliable sources of information towards their
most vulnerable users. | [
-0.02356088161468506,
-0.8456835746765137,
0.7572382092475891,
-0.011490984819829464,
0.198332741856575,
0.2751893699169159,
-0.2138831615447998,
-0.6184415221214294,
-0.05013308301568031,
0.5698243379592896,
-0.2924470603466034,
-0.4088951349258423,
-0.7265589833259583,
0.018396029248833656,
-0.5597769021987915,
0.8924782872200012,
0.06960370391607285,
-0.15459340810775757,
-0.39973780512809753,
-0.04005459323525429,
-0.5663543343544006,
-0.9711355566978455,
-0.15824122726917267,
-0.5034842491149902,
0.5355561375617981,
0.5342608094215393,
1.0173817873001099,
0.05809876322746277,
0.5474056601524353,
0.24244852364063263,
0.02806665562093258,
0.041495051234960556,
-0.9294701218605042,
0.020790226757526398,
-0.40146127343177795,
-0.7410109043121338,
-0.4083065092563629,
0.27823004126548767,
0.36980703473091125,
0.6283703446388245,
-0.3029957115650177,
0.2577745020389557,
0.42180585861206055,
0.5111480355262756,
-0.6758155226707458,
-0.11087290197610855,
-0.8125622272491455,
-0.36007368564605713,
-0.19976802170276642,
-0.08410059660673141,
-0.5326701998710632,
-0.4533270299434662,
-0.0823877826333046,
-0.40759363770484924,
0.24677802622318268,
0.05431300029158592,
0.7121067047119141,
0.23008231818675995,
-0.4813194274902344,
-0.6816838383674622,
-0.8440062403678894,
0.7483513951301575,
-0.7364017367362976,
0.42142924666404724,
0.610738217830658,
0.045764219015836716,
-0.33615562319755554,
-0.3696037232875824,
-0.5122483968734741,
-0.34277287125587463,
-0.2964835464954376,
-0.11917682737112045,
-0.489741712808609,
-0.09043916314840317,
0.4038449823856354,
0.22746257483959198,
-0.5089277625083923,
0.6283714771270752,
-0.5025705695152283,
-0.24996845424175262,
0.7975605130195618,
0.3402765989303589,
0.24792879819869995,
-0.1577696055173874,
-0.26542043685913086,
0.13455896079540253,
-0.8393292427062988,
0.35726332664489746,
0.860260009765625,
0.4514850676059723,
0.03525274991989136,
0.8638623356819153,
0.02027500979602337,
0.3362073600292206,
-0.09263763576745987,
-0.4288429319858551,
0.19144916534423828,
-0.012833225540816784,
-0.0639386996626854,
0.01631099171936512,
0.692600429058075,
0.5256201028823853,
0.2533278465270996,
-0.07347950339317322,
-0.6288187503814697,
0.21898551285266876,
0.40512511134147644,
-0.6235493421554565,
0.09517798572778702,
0.38127604126930237,
-0.44209524989128113,
-0.23305632174015045,
0.15570257604122162,
-0.5703625679016113,
-0.590327799320221,
-0.10122492164373398,
0.5949235558509827,
-0.27947697043418884,
-0.19484634697437286,
0.14404092729091644,
0.25167083740234375,
0.026668990030884743,
0.18745695054531097,
-0.7391088008880615,
0.4769233763217926,
0.39149364829063416,
0.6011055111885071,
-0.5083045363426208,
-0.208932027220726,
-0.2853492200374603,
-0.10110532492399216,
-0.17851030826568604,
0.42359474301338196,
-0.6081922650337219,
-0.5304014086723328,
0.06804398447275162,
-0.07897587865591049,
-0.10673984885215759,
-0.7501864433288574,
0.8017523288726807,
-0.6150447726249695,
0.18082813918590546,
-0.5631143450737,
-0.37141287326812744,
-0.21198229491710663,
0.11428368091583252,
-0.546461284160614,
0.8894515037536621,
0.11217606067657471,
-0.8336756229400635,
0.2470637559890747,
-0.5371794700622559,
-0.44125595688819885,
-0.15491822361946106,
-0.005343837663531303,
-0.22162578999996185,
0.4530360996723175,
0.026821589097380638,
0.6624279618263245,
-0.15409815311431885,
0.41409265995025635,
-0.2736429274082184,
-0.7609079480171204,
0.7870798707008362,
-0.7650265097618103,
0.5783592462539673,
0.13595075905323029,
-0.18762564659118652,
-0.17053605616092682,
-0.9695417284965515,
-0.20603050291538239,
0.4471464455127716,
-0.507420003414154,
-0.5212445259094238,
0.031238989904522896,
0.14851804077625275,
0.3301090598106384,
0.189667746424675,
-0.6594998240470886,
0.03284728527069092,
-0.4472614526748657,
0.3338862359523773,
0.8533980250358582,
-0.08443152904510498,
-0.05798273906111717,
-0.5088935494422913,
0.4874519407749176,
0.09163256734609604,
0.24823403358459473,
0.2837373614311218,
-0.2358032464981079,
-0.5104952454566956,
0.11517978459596634,
-0.016902457922697067,
0.5943096876144409,
-0.5830979943275452,
-0.017474660649895668,
-0.37381041049957275,
-0.2932647168636322,
-0.6248232126235962,
0.2779751420021057,
0.44317305088043213,
0.5231925845146179,
0.3974767029285431,
-0.21654118597507477,
-0.29387521743774414,
-1.1383651494979858,
-0.4343695342540741,
-0.5188853740692139,
-0.13017602264881134,
0.3404250144958496,
0.6490525603294373,
-0.3879122734069824,
0.6148427128791809,
-0.2846624553203583,
-0.24986593425273895,
-0.3868664801120758,
-0.12964947521686554,
0.12867873907089233,
0.053127389401197433,
0.39721250534057617,
-0.6785202026367188,
-0.2075793594121933,
-0.38574638962745667,
-0.477279394865036,
-0.23993884027004242,
-0.019332265481352806,
0.5388572812080383,
0.5301917791366577,
0.12616682052612305,
-0.41800209879875183,
0.4690205156803131,
0.8003110289573669,
-0.2900172472000122,
0.43264588713645935,
0.024445677176117897,
0.4019186794757843,
-0.9644883275032043,
0.04226261004805565,
0.008629814721643925,
0.17975257337093353,
-0.5245487093925476,
-0.10321971029043198,
-0.007006590720266104,
0.22980022430419922,
-0.6555152535438538,
0.2851742208003998,
-0.277981162071228,
-0.15417923033237457,
-0.21036846935749054,
0.05236788094043732,
0.05576961860060692,
0.11922083050012589,
-0.27118438482284546,
1.047709584236145,
0.18806104362010956,
-0.4363543689250946,
0.3318268656730652,
0.2564857006072998,
-0.44817253947257996,
0.3868285119533539,
-0.7416884899139404,
-0.03463627025485039,
-0.207673117518425,
-0.14051209390163422,
-0.9734923839569092,
-0.4176173508167267,
0.011628556065261364,
-0.5258093476295471,
0.2518087327480316,
0.10016107559204102,
-0.604328453540802,
-0.3874940872192383,
-0.2545575797557831,
0.22956353425979614,
0.5766050219535828,
-0.23481154441833496,
0.31203991174697876,
0.2457938939332962,
0.024371102452278137,
-0.603720486164093,
-0.9878925681114197,
0.15918861329555511,
-0.324857234954834,
-0.4513535797595978,
0.10444986820220947,
0.012632259167730808,
-0.5699491500854492,
-0.048951487988233566,
0.0081269396468997,
0.08789392560720444,
0.3851201832294464,
0.525514543056488,
0.16497229039669037,
-0.12022006511688232,
-0.04806571081280708,
-0.3622916042804718,
0.13815923035144806,
0.3549850285053253,
0.19497345387935638,
0.4248643219470978,
0.06992118805646896,
-0.6598138213157654,
-0.4430939853191376,
0.22925309836864471,
0.6567700505256653,
0.04189213737845421,
1.0482286214828491,
0.13457421958446503,
-0.19709724187850952,
-0.21848635375499725,
-0.6971361637115479,
-0.35366857051849365,
-0.4686717689037323,
0.4542807638645172,
-0.38398948311805725,
-0.9668918251991272,
0.537584662437439,
0.24166935682296753,
-0.049952711910009384,
0.260555237531662,
0.44000566005706787,
-0.2156766802072525,
0.8614628911018372,
0.7188780903816223,
-0.09289231896400452,
-0.08253896236419678,
0.07445324212312698,
0.2354453057050705,
-0.6128495335578918,
-0.4967729151248932,
-0.6313426494598389,
-0.14771229028701782,
-0.6840863823890686,
-0.17300240695476532,
0.2515864968299866,
-0.03827929124236107,
-0.010230242274701595,
0.1218327060341835,
-0.11423534899950027,
0.38891446590423584,
0.3043158948421478,
0.3176165819168091,
0.5098430514335632,
0.10430369526147842,
-0.03214326128363609,
-0.336311936378479,
-0.7412146925926208,
-0.8176717758178711,
1.3191252946853638,
0.5627943873405457,
1.2732049226760864,
0.37097272276878357,
0.11341816931962967,
0.5238838195800781,
0.24566078186035156,
-0.754193127155304,
0.3479895293712616,
-0.09736800193786621,
-0.7529778480529785,
-0.30101287364959717,
-0.39840757846832275,
-0.805156946182251,
-0.10318990796804428,
-0.34308886528015137,
-0.8952916264533997,
0.12181401252746582,
0.3819465637207031,
-0.21420156955718994,
0.47321125864982605,
-0.5271435379981995,
0.3968287706375122,
-0.45872414112091064,
-0.470961332321167,
-0.08242866396903992,
-0.5065571069717407,
0.49584731459617615,
-0.5384467244148254,
0.5621396899223328,
-0.273171067237854,
-0.01573309116065502,
0.45943713188171387,
0.016719171777367592,
1.2071951627731323,
-0.09108957648277283,
-0.24748188257217407,
0.01630999892950058,
0.2789759337902069,
0.7841930985450745,
-0.13950790464878082,
-0.39304307103157043,
0.3832755386829376,
-0.3653397560119629,
-0.44006121158599854,
-0.5496947169303894,
0.699404239654541,
-0.9991145730018616,
-0.8744255900382996,
-0.3789239823818207,
-0.4244029223918915,
-0.460410475730896,
0.056281235069036484,
0.3229893445968628,
0.3601072132587433,
-0.330579936504364,
0.22198526561260223,
0.7832555770874023,
-0.45042112469673157,
0.20975589752197266,
1.0113310813903809,
-0.11816835403442383,
-0.03325224295258522,
0.6798129081726074,
0.4509759843349457,
0.5522249341011047,
0.06610758602619171,
0.036444950848817825,
-0.367341011762619,
-0.9267172813415527,
0.023602547124028206,
0.17447102069854736,
-0.7011096477508545,
-0.01709127239882946,
-0.5172125697135925,
-0.27784377336502075,
-0.33876121044158936,
-0.081715427339077,
-0.4690994918346405,
-0.0564582534134388,
-0.3509373664855957,
-0.24256984889507294,
0.05440402030944824,
0.9969881176948547,
0.13024140894412994,
0.25689855217933655,
-0.5472967028617859,
0.1934949904680252,
0.30464720726013184,
0.3639254570007324,
-0.14239634573459625,
-1.0758366584777832,
-0.19911913573741913,
0.09080437570810318,
-0.30011996626853943,
-0.6826456189155579,
-0.03750782832503319,
0.04353282228112221,
0.8031359314918518,
0.29825231432914734,
0.27376100420951843,
0.38456571102142334,
-0.2878049314022064,
0.7968392372131348,
-0.0005239434540271759,
-0.7303061485290527,
0.548000693321228,
-0.19957222044467926,
0.06003648042678833,
0.6585665345191956,
0.8399704098701477,
-0.44784167408943176,
-0.5006716847419739,
-0.30427297949790955,
-0.7546713948249817,
0.6662823557853699,
0.23214232921600342,
0.607244074344635,
0.24448567628860474,
0.39371511340141296,
0.38179492950439453,
0.23290930688381195,
-1.0427545309066772,
-0.39636874198913574,
-0.11620024591684341,
0.0796452984213829,
-0.09631507843732834,
-0.8627238869667053,
-0.1031113937497139,
0.015962883830070496,
0.8073592782020569,
0.015484150499105453,
-0.28485772013664246,
0.05666006729006767,
-0.1666850596666336,
-0.32730308175086975,
0.5252828001976013,
0.5010276436805725,
0.9343430399894714,
-0.1380145400762558,
0.13685321807861328,
0.13363000750541687,
-0.6349290013313293,
0.3133109509944916,
-0.10311120003461838,
-0.47246190905570984,
-0.27797409892082214,
0.6181692481040955,
0.7393670082092285,
0.19423604011535645,
-0.6422061324119568,
0.7153167128562927,
-0.087698794901371,
-0.025487177073955536,
-0.18753401935100555,
0.37859654426574707,
-0.13842718303203583,
0.09216326475143433,
0.42707666754722595,
-0.020957017317414284,
0.14706893265247345,
-0.7028459906578064,
0.043293580412864685,
0.44648948311805725,
-0.38444259762763977,
-0.4480489194393158,
0.7650148868560791,
0.198505237698555,
-0.31487616896629333,
0.5239608883857727,
0.10680827498435974,
-0.2974564731121063,
0.10459185391664505,
0.639670193195343,
0.5188438296318054,
-0.30124402046203613,
0.2740330398082733,
0.13323630392551422,
0.7717602849006653,
-0.00025143721722997725,
0.2592870891094208,
0.5084825158119202,
-0.9972050786018372,
-0.2691694498062134,
-0.6143361926078796,
-0.3460507094860077,
0.5460477471351624,
-0.7568572163581848,
0.1356828659772873,
-0.33098259568214417,
-0.3704913854598999,
-0.31584566831588745,
-0.06873376667499542,
-0.6948692202568054,
0.2048627734184265,
0.1623586267232895,
0.6762127876281738,
-1.1028509140014648,
0.6578190922737122,
0.7822009921073914,
-0.36600461602211,
-0.71537846326828,
0.2770545780658722,
0.31509101390838623,
-1.0131943225860596,
0.4240598678588867,
0.11037071794271469,
-0.15783844888210297,
-0.10803065448999405,
-0.5437812209129333,
-0.8870798945426941,
0.8627400398254395,
0.6765320897102356,
-0.6987099051475525,
0.1353221982717514,
0.7183411121368408,
0.47161316871643066,
-0.06723801046609879,
0.11781705170869827,
0.7582444548606873,
0.21232183277606964,
0.07877025008201599,
-1.1425044536590576,
0.13623735308647156,
0.11953582614660263,
0.0870976373553276,
-0.12640348076820374,
-0.9378742575645447,
0.5511286854743958,
-0.43640151619911194,
-0.28782227635383606,
-0.3029734790325165,
0.3376818597316742,
0.30373886227607727,
0.1748947650194168,
0.31808146834373474,
0.48556408286094666,
0.7569441199302673,
-0.037874992936849594,
0.8746622204780579,
-0.05240073800086975,
0.10563626885414124,
0.9720768928527832,
-0.4700995981693268,
0.8120213150978088,
0.4722253978252411,
-0.33985671401023865,
0.4850306510925293,
0.41932299733161926,
0.01838395930826664,
0.3426901400089264,
0.22184856235980988,
-0.13514487445354462,
-0.06899289041757584,
-0.24267880618572235,
-0.08838102221488953,
0.7539651989936829,
0.4321169853210449,
-0.32041653990745544,
0.02578125335276127,
0.15540261566638947,
0.19121389091014862,
0.4697824716567993,
-0.34405624866485596,
0.5412852168083191,
0.010032485239207745,
-0.30576080083847046,
0.6924862265586853,
-0.01741543598473072,
0.8622937202453613,
-0.43620768189430237,
0.02601291798055172,
-0.44571825861930847,
-0.1983097642660141,
-0.6074220538139343,
-1.008261799812317,
0.256481409072876,
0.216788649559021,
-0.4628068506717682,
-0.09991876035928726,
0.7332428097724915,
0.04631531611084938,
-0.5424854159355164,
0.6068452000617981,
0.6722963452339172,
0.33970049023628235,
-0.14318697154521942,
-0.6529343128204346,
0.5141938328742981,
0.05841000750660896,
-0.658855676651001,
0.3174498975276947,
0.2873063385486603,
-0.06007974222302437,
0.9292483329772949,
0.5950354933738708,
0.29973074793815613,
-0.120609350502491,
-0.09844070672988892,
0.9606349468231201,
-0.482106477022171,
-0.033087559044361115,
-0.9018898606300354,
0.5904584527015686,
0.071620412170887,
-0.19974084198474884,
0.9466766715049744,
0.5589767098426819,
1.0967921018600464,
0.28485167026519775,
0.8573763966560364,
0.16945479810237885,
0.6664093136787415,
-0.5648134350776672,
0.7394208908081055,
-0.6873378753662109,
0.8927537798881531,
-0.22172866761684418,
-0.94330233335495,
0.042525798082351685,
0.06974168866872787,
-0.3638218641281128,
0.12499331682920456,
0.4086211621761322,
0.8215461373329163,
-0.07667755335569382,
-0.3708510398864746,
0.7301583886146545,
0.6459055542945862,
0.24653947353363037,
0.5097035765647888,
0.9352502226829529,
-0.2605263888835907,
0.4341411888599396,
-0.10175914317369461,
-0.02830921672284603,
-0.31784361600875854,
-0.5876216888427734,
-1.0089484453201294,
-0.2842003405094147,
-0.1509583592414856,
-0.5056901574134827,
0.15749867260456085,
0.6595891118049622,
0.34339120984077454,
-0.9731705188751221,
-0.040357667952775955,
0.39292943477630615,
0.1048797145485878,
0.5842263698577881,
-0.25782790780067444,
0.21444785594940186,
-0.009710440412163734,
-0.4894334077835083,
0.3285720944404602,
0.08759162575006485,
0.3595161736011505,
-0.6460135579109192,
-0.016445720568299294,
0.38614335656166077,
0.27554070949554443,
0.5760928988456726,
0.22379900515079498,
-0.9928767681121826,
-0.4118809401988983,
0.07384321838617325,
-0.4632231295108795,
-0.0003798343241214752,
0.4851408898830414,
-0.6820430159568787,
0.1413186639547348,
-0.032948363572359085,
0.37800517678260803,
-0.15003670752048492,
0.2984691560268402,
0.3611622750759125,
-0.6369174718856812,
0.0048590488731861115,
0.2730673849582672,
0.06785399466753006,
0.4831606447696686,
-0.6087947487831116,
0.27907875180244446,
0.3011246621608734,
-0.6101900935173035,
-1.0145132541656494,
0.08885029703378677,
-0.40307068824768066,
-0.4266939163208008,
1.28132164478302,
-0.01564008742570877,
0.1051793098449707,
-0.20261235535144806,
0.011038645170629025,
-0.1827414184808731,
-0.437384694814682,
1.0375149250030518,
0.8387141823768616,
-0.2677648961544037,
-0.057000160217285156,
-0.8509629368782043,
0.44250214099884033,
0.12976965308189392,
-0.5790479779243469,
0.1908792108297348,
0.6754531860351562,
0.4640706479549408,
-0.11246208101511002,
0.45784154534339905,
-0.06891333311796188,
-0.01568957231938839,
-0.10951453447341919,
0.07740315049886703,
-0.23047520220279694,
-0.40865251421928406,
-0.4176828861236572,
0.34057751297950745,
0.5822634100914001,
0.2840636372566223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17716v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17716v2 | ViANLI: Adversarial Natural Language Inference for Vietnamese | 2024-06-25T16:58:19 | 2024-07-01T15:19:51 | Tin Van Huynh, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of Natural Language Processing (NLI) datasets and models has
been inspired by innovations in annotation design. With the rapid development
of machine learning models today, the performance of existing machine learning
models has quickly reached state-of-the-art results on a variety of tasks
related to natural language processing, including natural language inference
tasks. By using a pre-trained model during the annotation process, it is
possible to challenge current NLI models by having humans produce
premise-hypothesis combinations that the machine model cannot correctly
predict. To remain attractive and challenging in the research of natural
language inference for Vietnamese, in this paper, we introduce the adversarial
NLI dataset to the NLP research community with the name ViANLI. This data set
contains more than 10K premise-hypothesis pairs and is built by a continuously
adjusting process to obtain the most out of the patterns generated by the
annotators. ViANLI dataset has brought many difficulties to many current SOTA
models when the accuracy of the most powerful model on the test set only
reached 48.4%. Additionally, the experimental results show that the models
trained on our dataset have significantly improved the results on other
Vietnamese NLI datasets. | [
-0.14464206993579865,
-0.9204278588294983,
0.5220391750335693,
0.15610767900943756,
-0.14208291471004486,
-0.16738982498645782,
-0.07719091325998306,
-0.31134432554244995,
0.12596216797828674,
0.8809433579444885,
-0.49522078037261963,
-0.5128691792488098,
-0.5647732615470886,
0.32574284076690674,
-0.17271815240383148,
1.0770461559295654,
0.1672086864709854,
0.12785851955413818,
0.5275633931159973,
-0.19646653532981873,
-0.324653297662735,
-0.7723758220672607,
-0.770244836807251,
-0.16340374946594238,
0.5642145276069641,
0.017580263316631317,
0.9342727065086365,
0.5171052813529968,
0.25115859508514404,
0.2674925625324249,
-0.0669844001531601,
0.23312632739543915,
-0.45555540919303894,
-0.05843318998813629,
0.17582683265209198,
-0.7887582182884216,
-0.29435110092163086,
0.05925165116786957,
0.5341560244560242,
0.5309180021286011,
0.13233420252799988,
-0.08001726865768433,
-0.3278385102748871,
0.45892682671546936,
-0.6528019309043884,
-0.32445406913757324,
-0.8230017423629761,
0.07540712505578995,
-0.2680819630622864,
-0.10686028748750687,
-0.3587450385093689,
-0.4996491074562073,
0.432152658700943,
-0.7710795998573303,
0.14909934997558594,
-0.16004018485546112,
0.9971855282783508,
0.4122493863105774,
-0.3528725206851959,
-0.2847174108028412,
-0.592924952507019,
0.7955631017684937,
-0.9741480350494385,
0.010895037092268467,
0.36240333318710327,
0.2896261513233185,
-0.2957066595554352,
-0.4536736309528351,
-0.6647475361824036,
-0.26552098989486694,
-0.1374756544828415,
0.1490066647529602,
-0.19436036050319672,
0.025874245911836624,
0.25730887055397034,
-0.05746783688664436,
-0.919983983039856,
0.19741925597190857,
-0.2220427542924881,
0.09295781701803207,
0.7842916250228882,
-0.2746330797672272,
0.37078234553337097,
-0.4015110731124878,
-0.5369556546211243,
0.0631493330001831,
-0.7950177788734436,
-0.4530788064002991,
0.5010130405426025,
0.3828469514846802,
0.29827743768692017,
0.5494219064712524,
-0.08465258777141571,
0.7570298314094543,
-0.5679324865341187,
0.03137069568037987,
0.33582255244255066,
-0.4286649525165558,
-0.5631293058395386,
0.3157692849636078,
0.9075410962104797,
0.2854683995246887,
0.4851584732532501,
-0.1999535709619522,
-0.19409491121768951,
0.45634207129478455,
0.30276617407798767,
-0.187885582447052,
-0.2923800051212311,
0.24040770530700684,
-0.12981219589710236,
-0.5654178261756897,
0.2764793932437897,
-0.554238498210907,
-0.44306498765945435,
-0.33708667755126953,
0.573052704334259,
-0.4371928870677948,
-0.38940057158470154,
0.07768909633159637,
-0.23798184096813202,
0.07177817076444626,
0.2616954743862152,
-0.30150312185287476,
-0.011730672791600227,
0.7501313090324402,
0.767565131187439,
-0.010841823183000088,
-0.5037645697593689,
-0.5997294187545776,
0.12063419073820114,
-0.32389163970947266,
0.6901127696037292,
-0.4280059337615967,
-0.3803359866142273,
0.011046606115996838,
-0.13769690692424774,
-0.25793468952178955,
-0.5514946579933167,
0.7659265995025635,
-0.5689678192138672,
0.28674039244651794,
-0.10455761849880219,
-0.5617693066596985,
-0.19678641855716705,
0.16110315918922424,
-0.7643426656723022,
0.9045783281326294,
-0.2690812051296234,
-1.0796327590942383,
0.302866667509079,
-0.7175451517105103,
-0.30359041690826416,
0.06204831600189209,
0.11964046210050583,
-0.49574199318885803,
0.17890948057174683,
0.19091223180294037,
0.3238352835178375,
-0.17660467326641083,
0.6103792786598206,
-0.3399195075035095,
-0.3870093822479248,
0.38439708948135376,
-0.5866108536720276,
1.266557216644287,
0.2342187464237213,
-0.3513718545436859,
0.37447109818458557,
-0.9655580520629883,
-0.21061934530735016,
0.18534183502197266,
-0.025612590834498405,
-0.657324492931366,
-0.3866068720817566,
0.24253816902637482,
0.2323564887046814,
-0.17730067670345306,
-0.46205660700798035,
0.08359555900096893,
-0.5658972859382629,
0.42049992084503174,
0.6726188063621521,
0.048247624188661575,
0.22174333035945892,
-0.1619510054588318,
0.3567134737968445,
-0.2567874491214752,
0.04262017086148262,
-0.009375794790685177,
-0.7478333115577698,
-0.6531479358673096,
-0.26315608620643616,
0.3395691514015198,
0.8926219344139099,
-1.0730421543121338,
0.5086194276809692,
-0.17800843715667725,
-0.4612933099269867,
-0.8854345083236694,
0.01785987988114357,
0.46704310178756714,
0.4798716604709625,
0.26560720801353455,
0.26146256923675537,
-1.0078933238983154,
-0.8475385904312134,
-0.24899137020111084,
-0.2730408310890198,
-0.609338104724884,
0.09567739069461823,
0.6129395961761475,
-0.47176411747932434,
0.7398862838745117,
-0.49044060707092285,
-0.23313847184181213,
-0.4384920299053192,
0.48410195112228394,
0.3617786467075348,
0.19197635352611542,
0.3367801904678345,
-1.1857526302337646,
-0.21428772807121277,
-0.28772252798080444,
-0.8872055411338806,
-0.24770581722259521,
-0.3034333288669586,
-0.3233489990234375,
0.3472149670124054,
0.3660776913166046,
-0.42724066972732544,
0.6483060717582703,
0.5288747549057007,
-0.3316017985343933,
0.6346577405929565,
-0.31261947751045227,
-0.06879928708076477,
-1.0770727396011353,
0.15255089104175568,
0.1206972673535347,
-0.10364896059036255,
-0.9613505601882935,
0.14453265070915222,
-0.3295670449733734,
-0.07172556221485138,
-0.44046667218208313,
0.2735083997249603,
-0.01146608404815197,
0.4060835838317871,
-0.2719157934188843,
0.12580928206443787,
-0.07834190130233765,
0.20917272567749023,
0.3663448989391327,
0.7698690295219421,
0.5340372920036316,
-0.5980390310287476,
0.5086683034896851,
0.1934395283460617,
0.07854704558849335,
0.24530772864818573,
-0.8414109945297241,
0.08719649165868759,
-0.021176926791667938,
0.2721339464187622,
-0.9000215530395508,
-0.030768465250730515,
0.2679292559623718,
-0.3062483072280884,
0.022290673106908798,
-0.031331777572631836,
-0.38911792635917664,
-0.19563235342502594,
-0.4461536407470703,
-0.023880645632743835,
0.14754299819469452,
-0.615696370601654,
0.6083000898361206,
0.42482292652130127,
0.21863432228565216,
-0.6420483589172363,
-0.9166176915168762,
0.5222644209861755,
-0.6773909330368042,
-0.42195528745651245,
0.2323153018951416,
0.17505809664726257,
-0.3471546769142151,
-0.16550853848457336,
0.3267478942871094,
-0.22076332569122314,
0.1944207400083542,
0.2032245397567749,
0.46442657709121704,
-0.5880943536758423,
0.020608017221093178,
-0.47978726029396057,
-0.4876800775527954,
0.16942322254180908,
-0.5598487854003906,
0.08486388623714447,
-0.11122970283031464,
0.022763779386878014,
-0.5937172174453735,
0.15281352400779724,
0.26792991161346436,
-0.07558329403400421,
0.8753601908683777,
0.5647376775741577,
-0.42076003551483154,
0.03261028602719307,
-0.6477639675140381,
0.07484355568885803,
-0.3591190278530121,
0.3612363338470459,
-0.5453208088874817,
-0.5310929417610168,
0.10689020901918411,
-0.020092912018299103,
0.009530811570584774,
0.42838558554649353,
0.06438326090574265,
0.1435389518737793,
0.8432650566101074,
0.5803905129432678,
-0.4286782741546631,
0.05659930035471916,
-0.3385829031467438,
0.0031590538565069437,
-0.5551918148994446,
0.3737212121486664,
-0.5203149318695068,
0.04092276841402054,
-0.9873245358467102,
-0.4278699457645416,
0.06799149513244629,
-0.18008708953857422,
-0.12290101498365402,
0.5031843185424805,
-0.26923033595085144,
0.18517853319644928,
0.8494301438331604,
0.06912178546190262,
0.3949817717075348,
-0.1373855024576187,
0.10465438663959503,
-0.22964493930339813,
-0.6785554885864258,
-0.8847848176956177,
1.3833906650543213,
0.1371871829032898,
0.3941762149333954,
0.20415838062763214,
0.5325961709022522,
0.23252739012241364,
0.35402828454971313,
-0.29601529240608215,
0.3860125243663788,
-0.3965958058834076,
-0.508215069770813,
-0.3870095908641815,
-0.6120566725730896,
-0.7440018653869629,
0.08768274635076523,
-0.2866789698600769,
-0.7070290446281433,
-0.09410607069730759,
-0.04286883771419525,
-0.40116557478904724,
0.41396036744117737,
-0.8611025810241699,
1.0055503845214844,
-0.26004984974861145,
-0.07303278893232346,
0.17330437898635864,
-0.9860466122627258,
0.44303202629089355,
-0.17893056571483612,
0.002031284151598811,
0.0963740348815918,
0.10738162696361542,
0.5609238743782043,
-0.244333878159523,
0.7739803791046143,
-0.20334862172603607,
-0.13157911598682404,
0.39818429946899414,
-0.3311235308647156,
0.31463560461997986,
0.41237640380859375,
-0.4946516156196594,
0.19285744428634644,
-0.32628363370895386,
-0.4434928596019745,
-0.8361408710479736,
0.5329160094261169,
-0.7782795429229736,
-0.6147008538246155,
-0.3883622884750366,
-0.1957504004240036,
0.049588028341531754,
0.1039055809378624,
0.49663984775543213,
0.21163144707679749,
-0.37502148747444153,
-0.15107104182243347,
0.7318165898323059,
-0.3674127459526062,
0.10064054280519485,
0.2521354556083679,
-0.22668001055717468,
-0.44231975078582764,
1.2312209606170654,
0.08846966177225113,
0.1222597286105156,
0.6515403985977173,
0.29001298546791077,
-0.5298129916191101,
-0.5745429992675781,
-0.507282555103302,
0.27442777156829834,
-0.3858398199081421,
0.08456289023160934,
-0.6560811996459961,
-0.4365830719470978,
-0.24548615515232086,
-0.14671754837036133,
-0.2500121295452118,
-0.4165204167366028,
-0.28574246168136597,
-0.19931729137897491,
0.11399386823177338,
0.9227211475372314,
0.29310089349746704,
0.36994120478630066,
-0.4366118311882019,
0.4955943524837494,
0.39583101868629456,
-0.1155553087592125,
-0.3914107084274292,
-0.5414389967918396,
0.35347408056259155,
0.015268752351403236,
0.033203430473804474,
-0.8952233791351318,
0.4991379380226135,
0.1886383295059204,
0.24294094741344452,
0.5272022485733032,
0.3480280041694641,
0.6690623164176941,
-0.3352603614330292,
0.4424883723258972,
-0.18185169994831085,
-0.62017822265625,
0.809633731842041,
-0.14895907044410706,
0.3281131982803345,
0.4617327153682709,
0.4307700991630554,
-0.2178257703781128,
-0.6888354420661926,
-0.8438010215759277,
-0.6896166205406189,
0.5318220853805542,
0.5920674800872803,
-0.13689559698104858,
0.3448409140110016,
0.40702563524246216,
0.19414032995700836,
0.254024863243103,
-0.6575968265533447,
-0.4226372241973877,
-0.4098694622516632,
-0.21272549033164978,
-0.40843769907951355,
-0.3699463903903961,
0.09056464582681656,
0.013962361961603165,
0.9076595902442932,
-0.1283191442489624,
-0.15623436868190765,
0.32835638523101807,
-0.17001166939735413,
0.26230478286743164,
0.15465497970581055,
0.5902167558670044,
0.6658119559288025,
-0.32763710618019104,
0.3180364966392517,
0.4694307744503021,
-0.35502079129219055,
0.048177335411310196,
0.6088045239448547,
-0.5823398232460022,
0.31242406368255615,
0.4954455494880676,
1.0208168029785156,
-0.030236883088946342,
-0.7144181728363037,
0.3288174569606781,
-0.5252606272697449,
0.05733441561460495,
-0.5016993284225464,
0.06342490762472153,
-0.14420907199382782,
0.059849031269550323,
0.4995678663253784,
0.17347592115402222,
0.24694839119911194,
-0.1786491870880127,
0.395964652299881,
0.2886781692504883,
-0.5941540002822876,
-0.4028843343257904,
0.7045401930809021,
-0.020733093842864037,
-0.3853336274623871,
0.5858951807022095,
-0.22919932007789612,
-0.7452359199523926,
0.5354076027870178,
0.39607688784599304,
0.8061509132385254,
-0.22148631513118744,
0.46300235390663147,
0.36077943444252014,
0.44025126099586487,
0.09481173008680344,
0.10135984420776367,
0.21275106072425842,
-0.7020076513290405,
-0.4184427559375763,
-0.5044282674789429,
-0.2283943146467209,
0.5893563032150269,
-0.44029033184051514,
0.35280394554138184,
-0.35115623474121094,
-0.19831803441047668,
0.13610315322875977,
0.11293786764144897,
-0.27045390009880066,
0.4868946075439453,
0.3336026966571808,
0.7640227675437927,
-0.9831258654594421,
0.9907069206237793,
0.9091352820396423,
-0.13176801800727844,
-0.3895742893218994,
0.23571452498435974,
0.26239216327667236,
-0.488958477973938,
0.6321703791618347,
0.518274188041687,
-0.18990911543369293,
-0.027804246172308922,
-0.37803155183792114,
-0.5295432806015015,
0.4694942235946655,
0.4204900562763214,
-0.11610428243875504,
0.0736098662018776,
0.1815868318080902,
0.6570476293563843,
-0.3021654784679413,
0.3341967761516571,
0.7723420262336731,
0.4530424177646637,
0.08397193253040314,
-0.445043683052063,
0.13844792544841766,
-0.3530725836753845,
0.35866472125053406,
-0.1327284723520279,
-0.24966396391391754,
0.43883216381073,
-0.23617111146450043,
-0.14722268283367157,
0.129961758852005,
0.9729837775230408,
0.5737924575805664,
0.37777402997016907,
0.7280609011650085,
0.5314759612083435,
0.6882753372192383,
-0.02837381511926651,
0.9064897894859314,
0.2514444887638092,
-0.051556821912527084,
1.2366989850997925,
-0.27275314927101135,
0.7814334034919739,
0.3141036629676819,
-0.12626805901527405,
0.1666376143693924,
0.4037008583545685,
-0.14839525520801544,
0.19425858557224274,
0.2149415910243988,
-0.268117755651474,
0.01682649366557598,
-0.44882121682167053,
-0.1495140641927719,
0.5645602941513062,
0.3487277328968048,
-0.06258637458086014,
0.06522420793771744,
-0.02851516380906105,
0.18628521263599396,
0.353683739900589,
0.20019660890102386,
0.7398187518119812,
-0.12592412531375885,
-0.5762810111045837,
0.6115131974220276,
-0.11059828102588654,
0.8045916557312012,
-0.7676606774330139,
-0.08619421720504761,
-0.02919749915599823,
0.17065078020095825,
-0.0014901967952027917,
-0.498202383518219,
0.49828004837036133,
0.16971760988235474,
0.12570713460445404,
-0.05750267580151558,
0.45458486676216125,
-0.4197331368923187,
-0.7392090559005737,
0.43357568979263306,
0.1251232624053955,
0.013373932801187038,
-0.3799861967563629,
-0.8088629841804504,
-0.07910127192735672,
0.09438272565603256,
-0.3392358422279358,
-0.012772670947015285,
0.6226231455802917,
0.05927719920873642,
0.6089915633201599,
0.6339625120162964,
0.3899572789669037,
0.06208319962024689,
0.18666934967041016,
0.7747454643249512,
-0.5900324583053589,
-0.44501793384552,
-1.0036653280258179,
0.3671037554740906,
-0.26172709465026855,
-0.5988006591796875,
0.9357256293296814,
0.5301067233085632,
0.8123986721038818,
0.002392832888290286,
0.9742439389228821,
0.35670584440231323,
0.5474527478218079,
-0.6567417979240417,
0.8799023628234863,
-0.4536702036857605,
0.1288965344429016,
-0.41245388984680176,
-0.5732736587524414,
-0.6983808875083923,
0.39469948410987854,
-0.29655349254608154,
-0.23857736587524414,
0.5124849081039429,
0.7500826716423035,
0.20527029037475586,
0.37497150897979736,
0.3245590627193451,
0.5163789987564087,
0.3420870304107666,
0.5344327092170715,
0.8025811910629272,
-0.6376059651374817,
0.5730413198471069,
-0.44742438197135925,
-0.25913360714912415,
-0.05602944642305374,
-0.7437241077423096,
-1.0226762294769287,
-0.37205472588539124,
-0.31320643424987793,
-0.2154938131570816,
0.4717436730861664,
0.7010390758514404,
0.5639386177062988,
-1.364715337753296,
-0.19803939759731293,
-0.41085219383239746,
0.2891218364238739,
-0.14442935585975647,
-0.21726205945014954,
0.6624660491943359,
-0.26482048630714417,
-0.7202890515327454,
0.5859970450401306,
0.11081439256668091,
0.12207666784524918,
-0.17276276648044586,
0.058250121772289276,
-0.8323765993118286,
-0.2352728694677353,
0.2782844305038452,
0.18768619000911713,
-0.8745323419570923,
0.006189227569848299,
-0.10311617702245712,
-0.03006073646247387,
-0.06111035868525505,
0.6510034203529358,
-0.792863130569458,
0.6346721053123474,
0.14670541882514954,
0.8763166069984436,
0.06865467131137848,
0.05173320323228836,
0.9882274270057678,
-0.7185146808624268,
0.43453794717788696,
0.12672463059425354,
0.18894465267658234,
0.47484344244003296,
-0.3671172559261322,
0.7123833894729614,
0.36288148164749146,
-0.2382720410823822,
-0.8803697824478149,
0.09989690780639648,
-0.25590693950653076,
-0.36177927255630493,
0.8250179290771484,
-0.28545713424682617,
-0.42902320623397827,
-0.49648892879486084,
-0.37908434867858887,
0.5127325654029846,
-0.32192692160606384,
0.8561177849769592,
0.3654887080192566,
0.30433306097984314,
0.1022205725312233,
-0.8145204782485962,
0.5824949145317078,
0.5549892783164978,
-0.6020076870918274,
-0.04921916127204895,
0.07315615564584732,
-0.28075599670410156,
0.3100129961967468,
0.3167637288570404,
0.43186894059181213,
0.04018673300743103,
0.025238843634724617,
-0.249198317527771,
0.1842065155506134,
-0.444333016872406,
-0.4568991959095001,
0.2753123641014099,
-0.10914913564920425,
-0.16532878577709198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17706v1 | FedBiOT: LLM Local Fine-tuning in Federated Learning without Full Model | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | 2024-06-25T16:45:47 | Feijie Wu, Zitao Li, Yaliang Li, Bolin Ding, Jing Gao | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models (LLMs) show amazing performance on many domain-specific
tasks after fine-tuning with some appropriate data. However, many
domain-specific data are privately distributed across multiple owners. Thus,
this dilemma raises the interest in how to perform LLM fine-tuning in federated
learning (FL). However, confronted with limited computation and communication
capacities, FL clients struggle to fine-tune an LLM effectively. To this end,
we introduce FedBiOT, a resource-efficient LLM fine-tuning approach to FL.
Specifically, our method involves the server generating a compressed LLM and
aligning its performance with the full model. Subsequently, the clients
fine-tune a lightweight yet important part of the compressed model, referred to
as an adapter. Notice that as the server has no access to the private data
owned by the clients, the data used for alignment by the server has a different
distribution from the one used for fine-tuning by clients. We formulate the
problem into a bi-level optimization problem to minimize the negative effect of
data discrepancy and derive the updating rules for the server and clients. We
conduct extensive experiments on LLaMA-2, empirically showing that the adapter
has exceptional performance when reintegrated into the global LLM. The results
also indicate that the proposed FedBiOT significantly reduces resource
consumption compared to existing benchmarks, all while achieving comparable
performance levels. | [
-0.3717488944530487,
-0.5598084330558777,
0.3797561228275299,
0.23767706751823425,
-0.28519099950790405,
0.19948627054691315,
-0.39675819873809814,
-0.47194331884384155,
0.0231384988874197,
0.44835010170936584,
-0.7531715035438538,
-0.3494635820388794,
-0.26712992787361145,
0.23037679493427277,
0.0619627982378006,
1.1772135496139526,
-0.14528988301753998,
-0.08555589616298676,
-0.4991737902164459,
-0.2866854965686798,
-0.32673531770706177,
0.0899534597992897,
-0.7151767015457153,
-0.4410942792892456,
0.317778080701828,
0.6561569571495056,
0.6094078421592712,
0.8768988251686096,
0.861518383026123,
0.3019804358482361,
-0.008223125711083412,
0.425032377243042,
-1.0145760774612427,
0.13214413821697235,
-0.35571974515914917,
-0.5963825583457947,
-0.6438553929328918,
-0.12296747416257858,
0.8894885182380676,
0.659942090511322,
-0.18216672539710999,
0.33105164766311646,
-0.07145119458436966,
0.795190691947937,
-0.5069828033447266,
0.45579802989959717,
-0.6044692993164062,
0.14230237901210785,
-0.1900482177734375,
-0.15120001137256622,
-0.3066543638706207,
-0.3093176484107971,
-0.09137687087059021,
-0.6696261167526245,
0.44894126057624817,
0.241201251745224,
0.8103303909301758,
0.4851294457912445,
-0.23351135849952698,
0.26814982295036316,
-0.7327122688293457,
0.5876930356025696,
-0.5019445419311523,
0.40817776322364807,
0.10390649735927582,
0.20932811498641968,
-0.4263007938861847,
-0.518190324306488,
-0.3817089796066284,
0.2511582374572754,
-0.1439487785100937,
0.06748811900615692,
-0.4951021671295166,
0.195449098944664,
0.07331090420484543,
0.7273277640342712,
-0.47217363119125366,
0.3491004407405853,
0.0218362994492054,
-0.1814965307712555,
0.5945414900779724,
0.0374772734940052,
-0.12017828226089478,
0.4396684765815735,
-0.4809602200984955,
-0.0081297243013978,
-0.8263461589813232,
-0.021034451201558113,
0.36217987537384033,
0.5378074645996094,
-0.0856710895895958,
0.2765912711620331,
-0.4268558621406555,
0.5980198979377747,
0.3127758800983429,
-0.3723025321960449,
0.16465666890144348,
-0.23509599268436432,
-0.40319347381591797,
-0.12236597388982773,
0.5594475269317627,
0.16469751298427582,
0.05374661087989807,
-0.42188555002212524,
-0.6892095804214478,
-0.19773225486278534,
-0.049657996743917465,
-1.0382235050201416,
-0.3154488503932953,
0.009526755660772324,
-0.20990020036697388,
-0.3145495653152466,
-0.09764118492603302,
-0.6578830480575562,
-0.36439022421836853,
-0.2435542345046997,
0.3826402425765991,
-0.08111337572336197,
-0.23418429493904114,
-0.09847456961870193,
0.29588720202445984,
0.07746647298336029,
0.3808278739452362,
-1.031599521636963,
0.5365443229675293,
0.9243507981300354,
1.0222667455673218,
-0.09397371113300323,
-0.18652057647705078,
-0.9551123380661011,
0.041741419583559036,
-0.10664724558591843,
0.8763276934623718,
-0.2985615134239197,
-0.19001668691635132,
-0.11827124655246735,
0.23803740739822388,
-0.09937624633312225,
-0.6003174185752869,
0.2607840299606323,
-0.5763606429100037,
-0.08007140457630157,
-0.2783229351043701,
-0.7122284770011902,
-0.08063093572854996,
0.08786902576684952,
-0.45678839087486267,
0.3993075489997864,
0.354375422000885,
-0.5848295092582703,
0.1710781753063202,
-0.7568289041519165,
-0.5397762656211853,
0.1799805611371994,
0.0428476445376873,
-0.6043034195899963,
0.16608662903308868,
0.2607382535934448,
0.53326815366745,
-0.36020880937576294,
0.27193230390548706,
-0.41255834698677063,
-0.5299950242042542,
-0.15036870539188385,
-0.21006351709365845,
0.6313735842704773,
0.24995042383670807,
-0.17423224449157715,
0.054639630019664764,
-0.7921878099441528,
-0.1837291121482849,
0.20574545860290527,
-0.49402520060539246,
-0.12987679243087769,
-0.07207033038139343,
-0.1412946581840515,
-0.3060471713542938,
0.4037728011608124,
-0.7037227749824524,
0.41682618856430054,
-0.5337294936180115,
0.40139931440353394,
0.8890166878700256,
-0.07014813274145126,
0.7249442338943481,
-0.5760893821716309,
0.43352705240249634,
-0.10951714962720871,
0.26209524273872375,
0.09485992789268494,
-0.2390269935131073,
-0.6979566216468811,
-0.5830033421516418,
0.17500966787338257,
0.2810415029525757,
-0.4680134654045105,
0.13683940470218658,
-0.4989992678165436,
-0.4499998390674591,
-0.8391274213790894,
0.44186297059059143,
0.24270868301391602,
0.6383968591690063,
0.33841395378112793,
-0.1879735141992569,
-0.22907282412052155,
-0.9345209002494812,
0.005735648795962334,
0.0746089443564415,
0.011364303529262543,
0.4269748032093048,
0.22706839442253113,
-0.49055346846580505,
0.7474207878112793,
-0.6079257130622864,
-0.5443623065948486,
0.027471713721752167,
-0.09236719459295273,
0.24885454773902893,
0.43160706758499146,
0.5515731573104858,
-0.526347815990448,
-0.4576250910758972,
0.47781819105148315,
-0.44057366251945496,
-0.3598153591156006,
-0.08046019077301025,
-0.0811358243227005,
0.3549497425556183,
-0.002205014694482088,
-0.45269814133644104,
-0.002746084937825799,
0.7130858898162842,
-0.25295332074165344,
0.4077540934085846,
-0.3420400321483612,
-0.1393478959798813,
-0.8911949992179871,
0.023032112047076225,
-0.30349403619766235,
-0.572750985622406,
-0.4533831477165222,
0.38087740540504456,
0.09032630920410156,
-0.22305667400360107,
-0.027666602283716202,
0.43858635425567627,
-0.5064892768859863,
-0.15805895626544952,
-0.42216530442237854,
0.07298359274864197,
-0.0019088180270045996,
0.42237338423728943,
-0.22302477061748505,
1.0613075494766235,
0.48773854970932007,
-0.2517361044883728,
0.4120509624481201,
0.29677316546440125,
-0.15024815499782562,
0.5999733209609985,
-0.3518247604370117,
0.031821105629205704,
-0.0594717375934124,
0.209819957613945,
-0.806077778339386,
-0.3576284646987915,
0.12333433330059052,
0.0711190477013588,
0.4306027293205261,
-0.1125621497631073,
-0.5323963761329651,
-0.09742546826601028,
-0.08772268891334534,
0.31773507595062256,
0.37565165758132935,
-0.9332452416419983,
0.3662095069885254,
0.20879893004894257,
0.0037500804755836725,
-0.4947202503681183,
-0.5254300832748413,
-0.31142479181289673,
0.014662875793874264,
-0.8466137647628784,
0.23684486746788025,
-0.20598778128623962,
-0.11943679302930832,
-0.024339035153388977,
-0.40592464804649353,
-0.050905872136354446,
0.2840600907802582,
0.22138017416000366,
0.03594157472252846,
-0.6042996048927307,
0.023045269772410393,
0.2365412563085556,
-0.007653845474123955,
-0.16452012956142426,
-0.3491995632648468,
0.3402780592441559,
-0.6440401077270508,
-0.266596257686615,
-0.4837220013141632,
0.08528981357812881,
0.3536103665828705,
-0.27111688256263733,
0.7550734281539917,
0.7026881575584412,
-0.08058904111385345,
-0.3880249857902527,
-0.639494776725769,
-0.20898336172103882,
-0.5142077207565308,
0.049234539270401,
-0.1301306039094925,
-1.235844373703003,
0.648402214050293,
-0.3570581376552582,
0.1474389135837555,
0.00041037818300537765,
0.28944432735443115,
-0.06097934767603874,
0.6211815476417542,
0.9315248131752014,
-0.20290642976760864,
0.6259917616844177,
-0.28181660175323486,
0.21304257214069366,
-0.6673071384429932,
0.005525998305529356,
-0.19058284163475037,
-0.6268205642700195,
-0.6583683490753174,
-0.3204972445964813,
0.1942233294248581,
-0.021821463480591774,
-0.3506220579147339,
0.3560912311077118,
-0.35790663957595825,
0.9029690027236938,
0.46322372555732727,
0.06915251910686493,
0.4834977388381958,
-0.03562851995229721,
-0.027205554768443108,
0.2588323652744293,
-0.7257377505302429,
0.10052750259637833,
0.7358490824699402,
0.1501433104276657,
0.6844820976257324,
0.281676322221756,
0.885234534740448,
0.06625491380691528,
0.4781346619129181,
-0.593360960483551,
0.35879644751548767,
-0.14183995127677917,
-0.29077616333961487,
-0.0940837413072586,
-0.8482158184051514,
-0.7172951698303223,
0.28088244795799255,
-0.3152812719345093,
-0.6565020084381104,
0.35950174927711487,
0.19302985072135925,
-0.31137534976005554,
0.5229146480560303,
-0.7148803472518921,
0.8133274912834167,
0.058435916900634766,
-0.5993364453315735,
-0.08155626058578491,
-0.5517208576202393,
0.42812538146972656,
-0.4070252776145935,
0.0656791552901268,
-0.314752459526062,
0.0619695819914341,
0.4228651225566864,
-0.4830714464187622,
0.7887893915176392,
-0.27774670720100403,
0.0650915801525116,
-0.09184832125902176,
0.28328919410705566,
0.7993632555007935,
0.4016921818256378,
-0.08419674634933472,
0.290968120098114,
-0.024844268336892128,
-0.5916608572006226,
-0.47028592228889465,
0.9357246160507202,
-0.9383035898208618,
-0.8111376166343689,
-0.14512725174427032,
-0.7870639562606812,
-0.2699756324291229,
0.44330132007598877,
-0.03503063693642616,
0.19427210092544556,
-0.11373128741979599,
0.27230337262153625,
0.5972900390625,
0.014027628116309643,
0.286785364151001,
0.9579846262931824,
-0.09417837113142014,
-0.302095502614975,
0.9124012589454651,
-0.10593892633914948,
0.4197371304035187,
0.6582331657409668,
0.32514846324920654,
0.006130294408649206,
-0.5884369611740112,
-0.16808785498142242,
0.586209237575531,
-0.4144097864627838,
-0.8519197702407837,
-0.15876933932304382,
-0.10968923568725586,
-0.2979365289211273,
-0.3798937201499939,
-0.617813766002655,
-0.23482196033000946,
-0.5195081830024719,
-0.13044556975364685,
0.5027052760124207,
0.4550936818122864,
-0.40350544452667236,
0.8375924229621887,
-0.5220264196395874,
-0.06986722350120544,
-0.004532039165496826,
0.7393671274185181,
-0.09999658912420273,
-0.4108920097351074,
-0.3047945499420166,
0.11466462910175323,
-0.3603197932243347,
-0.2919658422470093,
0.25953802466392517,
0.5448565483093262,
0.2341872751712799,
0.7475756406784058,
0.14211980998516083,
0.9185820817947388,
-0.49823206663131714,
0.20945137739181519,
-0.16830654442310333,
-0.8012071251869202,
0.44231000542640686,
-0.4149585962295532,
0.30470743775367737,
0.6127310991287231,
0.15734417736530304,
-0.3225419819355011,
-0.47192808985710144,
-0.38005051016807556,
-0.553364634513855,
0.8333810567855835,
0.015565579757094383,
0.042030103504657745,
0.21698355674743652,
0.5095635652542114,
0.32372820377349854,
0.0846351608633995,
-0.5734716653823853,
-0.20090313255786896,
0.020639298483729362,
0.10117772221565247,
-0.12256776541471481,
0.02295122854411602,
-0.2562767565250397,
-0.33815568685531616,
0.7266194224357605,
-0.3116656243801117,
0.2987503409385681,
0.0435919351875782,
0.0054312292486429214,
-0.6544650793075562,
0.015994712710380554,
0.4913429915904999,
0.5349951386451721,
-0.4782165586948395,
-0.0011565258027985692,
0.09382788091897964,
-0.33539679646492004,
0.08054738491773605,
0.42677024006843567,
-0.3163324296474457,
-0.25896450877189636,
0.38619792461395264,
0.908811092376709,
0.4289166033267975,
-0.5047116875648499,
0.6374120116233826,
-0.1522899717092514,
-0.2586856782436371,
0.09743817895650864,
0.25528034567832947,
0.07886385917663574,
0.6326344609260559,
-0.06446900218725204,
0.36462002992630005,
-0.1662321537733078,
-0.21617624163627625,
0.18252432346343994,
0.5433931946754456,
-0.10747487097978592,
-0.43977051973342896,
0.6732472777366638,
0.2683151364326477,
-0.23228377103805542,
0.7003722190856934,
-0.10808493942022324,
-0.190303236246109,
0.2892877161502838,
0.9007876515388489,
0.7069705128669739,
-0.2836258113384247,
0.23719976842403412,
-0.027102971449494362,
0.30069735646247864,
-0.055438894778490067,
0.08515945076942444,
-0.36071860790252686,
-0.8319495916366577,
-0.31017711758613586,
-0.8104084730148315,
-0.3552214503288269,
-0.040289800614118576,
-0.5666924715042114,
0.03611350432038307,
-0.713718593120575,
0.07533162087202072,
-0.12942096590995789,
0.46946024894714355,
-0.8512815833091736,
-0.30203038454055786,
0.031558405607938766,
1.0017738342285156,
-0.7384830713272095,
0.8733587265014648,
0.45909789204597473,
-0.22745397686958313,
-0.6918151378631592,
-0.18970048427581787,
-0.04180312529206276,
-1.038476586341858,
0.21282538771629333,
0.0421266071498394,
-0.00006783979188185185,
0.20364166796207428,
-0.3861100375652313,
-0.8665087819099426,
1.4288538694381714,
0.6491448283195496,
-0.8197493553161621,
0.1552630364894867,
0.12695655226707458,
0.602134644985199,
-0.32110854983329773,
-0.1254861056804657,
0.4600011110305786,
0.3878638446331024,
0.0589415468275547,
-0.8062430024147034,
0.1539970189332962,
0.12640497088432312,
-0.14198675751686096,
0.4323965013027191,
-1.0837223529815674,
0.7345712184906006,
-0.3892410099506378,
-0.2794518768787384,
-0.15727350115776062,
0.7142682075500488,
-0.20996874570846558,
0.2444414496421814,
0.3288814127445221,
0.4615190625190735,
1.2297348976135254,
0.03183218091726303,
0.8482818007469177,
-0.1769842654466629,
0.6050428748130798,
1.1475648880004883,
-0.490643173456192,
0.7166668772697449,
0.46654194593429565,
0.012870648875832558,
0.06988564133644104,
0.48623859882354736,
-0.1696118712425232,
0.6685787439346313,
-0.013836256228387356,
-0.5343640446662903,
-0.278747022151947,
-0.01549727562814951,
-0.21570450067520142,
0.4835420846939087,
0.03245220705866814,
-0.18197304010391235,
-0.5092999339103699,
-0.13150779902935028,
0.05453327298164368,
-0.03511948883533478,
-0.3418024778366089,
1.0303008556365967,
0.13060392439365387,
-0.3205210268497467,
0.6937260627746582,
0.07716834545135498,
0.508274495601654,
-0.4282274842262268,
0.2721380293369293,
-0.8619126081466675,
0.5033666491508484,
-0.303598016500473,
-0.38482823967933655,
0.4288226068019867,
0.04110746085643768,
-0.1738242208957672,
-0.32474106550216675,
0.6127845048904419,
-0.4488321542739868,
-0.3766742944717407,
0.3363739550113678,
0.4757985770702362,
0.0877734124660492,
0.15668119490146637,
-0.39780277013778687,
0.004512619227170944,
0.08231901377439499,
-0.2594054639339447,
0.6325244903564453,
0.5685052871704102,
0.21110206842422485,
0.7722739577293396,
0.7205264568328857,
0.2918170988559723,
-0.3152065575122833,
-0.23767773807048798,
0.9477385878562927,
-0.0490405447781086,
-0.2777234613895416,
-0.723584771156311,
-0.12585729360580444,
0.16852881014347076,
-0.16127395629882812,
0.39763662219047546,
0.563170850276947,
1.1119269132614136,
-0.07107897102832794,
0.38512447476387024,
0.23452460765838623,
0.17517916858196259,
-0.2801682949066162,
1.0049057006835938,
-0.691580593585968,
0.2964722216129303,
0.07475631684064865,
-0.9344246983528137,
-0.506935179233551,
0.586105465888977,
-0.3211067020893097,
-0.5823225378990173,
0.297136515378952,
0.986552894115448,
-0.5007744431495667,
0.36656659841537476,
0.4396090507507324,
0.4253813922405243,
0.37466633319854736,
0.5028173923492432,
0.24473348259925842,
-0.32748469710350037,
0.3733430802822113,
-0.5260287523269653,
-0.3239547908306122,
-0.3748261034488678,
-0.8842039704322815,
-0.8198405504226685,
-0.338052362203598,
-0.21812322735786438,
0.09086943417787552,
0.3031764328479767,
1.0989989042282104,
0.5569814443588257,
-0.8104009628295898,
-0.17900775372982025,
-0.04864371195435524,
0.3350736200809479,
-0.3214843273162842,
-0.21568164229393005,
0.18195375800132751,
-0.3700587749481201,
-0.4218210279941559,
0.5495333075523376,
0.2685580551624298,
-0.04979716241359711,
0.053920160979032516,
0.015508794225752354,
-0.040739335119724274,
-0.1328047513961792,
0.3767639696598053,
0.19981680810451508,
-0.4235520362854004,
-0.4883955717086792,
-0.23603709042072296,
0.12225817888975143,
0.2652254104614258,
0.5801466703414917,
-0.5319573879241943,
0.3747846484184265,
0.2756384015083313,
1.0054433345794678,
0.46223026514053345,
0.11388051509857178,
0.5114564299583435,
-1.015252947807312,
0.150752991437912,
0.1432897001504898,
0.42598867416381836,
0.34713149070739746,
-0.5651273727416992,
0.5385797619819641,
0.4028305113315582,
-0.9948879480361938,
-0.9774569272994995,
0.06929774582386017,
-0.9484062790870667,
0.0009447285556234419,
0.8747703433036804,
-0.37707510590553284,
-0.3763546943664551,
0.4154665768146515,
0.12551641464233398,
0.26110097765922546,
-0.5223808288574219,
0.7555370926856995,
0.4214402437210083,
-0.21534889936447144,
-0.05626790225505829,
-0.34913307428359985,
0.5045109391212463,
0.08986498415470123,
-0.6350896954536438,
0.38533079624176025,
0.4676017761230469,
0.5270512700080872,
-0.1931149661540985,
0.5081243515014648,
0.30137521028518677,
0.03595312684774399,
-0.0911627784371376,
-0.13303472101688385,
-0.3734716475009918,
-0.3304106891155243,
-0.27820655703544617,
0.0038674133829772472,
0.0008909026510082185,
-0.09780537337064743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17692v1 | From Distributional to Overton Pluralism: Investigating Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | 2024-06-25T16:32:33 | Thom Lake, Eunsol Choi, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The alignment process changes several properties of a large language model's
(LLM's) output distribution. We analyze two aspects of post-alignment
distributional shift of LLM responses. First, we re-examine previously reported
reductions in response diversity post-alignment. Our analysis suggests that an
apparent drop in the diversity of responses is largely explained by quality
control and information aggregation. Alignment suppresses irrelevant and
unhelpful content while shifting the output distribution toward longer
responses that cover information spanning several responses from the base LLM,
essentially presenting diverse information in a single response. Finding little
evidence that alignment suppresses useful information, it is natural to ask the
opposite question: do aligned models surface information that cannot be
recovered from base models? Our second investigation shows this is not the case
and the behavior of aligned models is recoverable from base models without
fine-tuning. A combination of in-context examples and lower-resolution semantic
hints about response content can elicit responses from base LLMs that are as
similar to alignment-tuned LLM responses as alignment-tuned LLM responses are
to each other. Taken together, these results indicate that current alignment
techniques capture but do not extend the useful subset of assistant-like base
LLM behavior, providing further evidence for the Superficial Alignment
Hypothesis. They also show that in-context alignment can go surprisingly far as
a strategy for imitating aligned LLMs without fine-tuning. Our code and data is
available at https://github.com/thomlake/investigating-alignment. | [
-0.3572610914707184,
-0.6840223073959351,
0.45822805166244507,
-0.1833648830652237,
-0.20653025805950165,
0.12595680356025696,
-0.2511950135231018,
-0.4872359037399292,
0.3409397006034851,
0.6331586837768555,
-0.4853114187717438,
-0.3766365051269531,
-0.7288236618041992,
-0.13021554052829742,
-0.7622093558311462,
1.1083128452301025,
0.09322395920753479,
0.03352806344628334,
-0.0364086888730526,
-0.44732365012168884,
-0.4011707007884979,
-0.45273709297180176,
-0.48303189873695374,
-0.15313176810741425,
0.5541693568229675,
0.2372053861618042,
1.0056450366973877,
0.9561848044395447,
0.6725088357925415,
0.36666339635849,
-0.2885672450065613,
-0.12382461130619049,
-0.6868342161178589,
0.17710725963115692,
-0.20853754878044128,
-0.5587345957756042,
-0.6379987001419067,
-0.09538844227790833,
1.1154820919036865,
0.9242749214172363,
-0.24788089096546173,
0.15438632667064667,
0.15751343965530396,
0.6748483180999756,
-0.7469855546951294,
-0.4948514997959137,
-0.6785082221031189,
-0.31574711203575134,
-0.33218035101890564,
0.06156185641884804,
-0.38504448533058167,
-0.368356853723526,
0.19025498628616333,
-0.48771440982818604,
0.141340970993042,
-0.006312154699116945,
0.783637523651123,
0.23396487534046173,
-0.6307080388069153,
-0.5440142750740051,
-0.9943332076072693,
0.9425037503242493,
-0.7072080969810486,
0.524453341960907,
0.05349188670516014,
0.2599876821041107,
-0.06365371495485306,
-0.2514164447784424,
-0.7079033851623535,
0.09200340509414673,
0.10343975573778152,
0.34288185834884644,
-0.03804609179496765,
-0.07542816549539566,
0.09479261934757233,
0.5475941300392151,
-0.7295459508895874,
0.24726662039756775,
-0.3724851906299591,
0.08013128489255905,
0.7952524423599243,
0.23634175956249237,
0.2812574803829193,
0.12282996624708176,
-0.39800265431404114,
-0.19589918851852417,
-0.8913652896881104,
-0.043593768030405045,
0.5969095826148987,
0.28159257769584656,
-0.05148577690124512,
0.7963097095489502,
0.36848577857017517,
0.6639255881309509,
0.2596193850040436,
-0.03435223922133446,
0.09888111054897308,
-0.3147542178630829,
-0.3110571801662445,
0.23780347406864166,
0.6624009013175964,
0.277344286441803,
0.08071716129779816,
0.03336290642619133,
-0.28055235743522644,
-0.04369329661130905,
0.21564096212387085,
-0.3623355031013489,
0.09789173305034637,
0.19337385892868042,
-0.464557409286499,
-0.06332274526357651,
0.23784132301807404,
-0.6048516631126404,
-0.5620277523994446,
-0.5802280902862549,
0.12401457130908966,
-0.31862977147102356,
-0.5278984308242798,
0.18531136214733124,
-0.10952194035053253,
0.4334070682525635,
0.3985115587711334,
-1.1895556449890137,
0.4711875915527344,
1.059329628944397,
0.84502774477005,
-0.47177770733833313,
-0.31470897793769836,
-0.17920921742916107,
0.2892759442329407,
-0.49698907136917114,
0.570050060749054,
-0.5027976632118225,
-0.19236335158348083,
0.2715204954147339,
-0.009245280176401138,
-0.17816829681396484,
-0.7795317769050598,
0.14306780695915222,
-0.6872810125350952,
0.20841455459594727,
-0.603786051273346,
-0.691875159740448,
0.15759716928005219,
0.18348895013332367,
-0.7074825167655945,
0.6638410687446594,
0.09492562711238861,
-0.7761642932891846,
0.36967793107032776,
-0.3033813536167145,
-0.22802628576755524,
-0.29054751992225647,
-0.23262083530426025,
-0.2348923534154892,
0.31954729557037354,
-0.1601010113954544,
0.019434988498687744,
-0.04506954550743103,
0.07692091912031174,
-0.7724583148956299,
-0.37252652645111084,
0.43947944045066833,
-0.25993967056274414,
0.9584344029426575,
0.15352658927440643,
-0.06694293767213821,
0.14851561188697815,
-0.6216878890991211,
-0.22008374333381653,
0.005432726815342903,
-0.3140676021575928,
-0.4097646176815033,
0.015058957040309906,
-0.23264966905117035,
0.19905723631381989,
0.22705690562725067,
-0.5792496800422668,
0.5580424070358276,
-0.5858970880508423,
0.2990230321884155,
0.9003628492355347,
-0.3739636242389679,
1.064307451248169,
-0.3031731843948364,
0.49906331300735474,
0.0338013656437397,
0.12129133194684982,
0.23141439259052277,
-0.24675363302230835,
-0.534757137298584,
-0.13726535439491272,
0.19830694794654846,
0.3998047411441803,
-0.17946560680866241,
0.47436150908470154,
-0.4996856451034546,
-0.08705934882164001,
-0.8511552810668945,
0.24956552684307098,
0.2409151792526245,
0.27911049127578735,
0.08622324466705322,
-0.5310991406440735,
-0.49244409799575806,
-0.9163808822631836,
-0.17613618075847626,
-0.2592211365699768,
0.048019226640462875,
0.026963703334331512,
0.10724999755620956,
-0.11023591458797455,
0.971651554107666,
-0.4477761685848236,
-0.06652819365262985,
-0.25346073508262634,
-0.03816146403551102,
0.18066078424453735,
0.2591573894023895,
0.525088906288147,
-0.6156787276268005,
-0.29312577843666077,
0.2799358367919922,
-0.5505112409591675,
-0.0840175598859787,
0.10739918798208237,
-0.2725931406021118,
0.52723628282547,
0.5096907019615173,
-0.8279123306274414,
0.26271313428878784,
0.8248744606971741,
-0.13007968664169312,
0.3469686210155487,
0.07898223400115967,
0.02352551929652691,
-1.4239742755889893,
-0.024260491132736206,
-0.18527144193649292,
-0.018783478066325188,
-0.5750775337219238,
0.038925088942050934,
0.014961756765842438,
0.2428080290555954,
-0.03991252928972244,
0.5111857056617737,
-0.5507342219352722,
-0.56275475025177,
-0.5155344605445862,
0.16882845759391785,
-0.1098085418343544,
0.07165468484163284,
-0.018251793459057808,
0.5171286463737488,
0.3115295171737671,
-0.38011425733566284,
0.23628807067871094,
0.3427804708480835,
-0.0749327689409256,
0.5491484999656677,
-0.5651684999465942,
0.1362091451883316,
-0.4403170049190521,
0.3790470361709595,
-1.5018161535263062,
-0.3494234085083008,
0.28556403517723083,
-0.3169916868209839,
0.515474259853363,
-0.1267140656709671,
-0.34230443835258484,
-0.06499816477298737,
-0.5006009340286255,
0.5416456460952759,
0.6151416897773743,
-0.45180177688598633,
0.49176520109176636,
0.4135839641094208,
-0.2606896460056305,
-0.6479876637458801,
-0.7843865156173706,
-0.32317063212394714,
-0.43299978971481323,
-0.684469997882843,
0.21351876854896545,
-0.13863138854503632,
-0.5187362432479858,
-0.24921561777591705,
-0.2560523450374603,
-0.023732464760541916,
0.08183077722787857,
0.08676670491695404,
0.19689369201660156,
-0.5235204100608826,
0.23825481534004211,
0.06091306731104851,
0.28467679023742676,
0.08135086297988892,
-0.1899348348379135,
0.6785020232200623,
0.10295058786869049,
-0.6721743941307068,
-0.3262158930301666,
0.42729923129081726,
0.6393914222717285,
-0.06060744822025299,
0.8998500108718872,
0.3829801678657532,
-0.09937338531017303,
0.18663917481899261,
-0.3785037398338318,
-0.22462062537670135,
-0.47919055819511414,
0.3229440152645111,
-0.07919144630432129,
-0.8205903768539429,
0.7783708572387695,
0.15847833454608917,
0.38095003366470337,
0.46229490637779236,
0.5591025352478027,
-0.3777831792831421,
1.327422022819519,
0.6095989346504211,
-0.11047641187906265,
0.7196707725524902,
-0.08222239464521408,
0.3959881663322449,
-0.9258185625076294,
0.09087010473012924,
-0.5134387612342834,
-0.6115570664405823,
-0.5761789083480835,
0.1581183820962906,
-0.008550608530640602,
0.3329220116138458,
-0.19205151498317719,
0.21923533082008362,
-0.39423683285713196,
0.3662239611148834,
0.36952346563339233,
-0.21293599903583527,
0.20689266920089722,
-0.1741051822900772,
0.601050615310669,
-0.09458842873573303,
-0.5768651366233826,
-0.39649707078933716,
0.9851524233818054,
0.4293394684791565,
0.9332695007324219,
0.6087631583213806,
0.7716484665870667,
-0.13526824116706848,
0.42447811365127563,
-0.7215030193328857,
0.3794209957122803,
-0.16307589411735535,
-0.4034767746925354,
-0.4563674330711365,
-0.2533658742904663,
-1.0464324951171875,
0.19767528772354126,
-0.019724257290363312,
-0.8465044498443604,
0.26650500297546387,
0.44359856843948364,
-0.33412888646125793,
0.05640948563814163,
-0.7798967957496643,
0.675043523311615,
-0.14469103515148163,
-0.01754467934370041,
0.09169622510671616,
-0.8688567876815796,
0.5534646511077881,
-0.04363880306482315,
0.22128117084503174,
0.04749961197376251,
0.12364983558654785,
0.5139933228492737,
-0.18674670159816742,
0.9452963471412659,
0.18110771477222443,
-0.6600865721702576,
-0.0024201390333473682,
0.1192563995718956,
0.47702115774154663,
-0.08231355249881744,
0.03481091558933258,
-0.09479863196611404,
0.051557719707489014,
-0.496491938829422,
-0.8607891201972961,
0.8487675189971924,
-0.9796680212020874,
-0.729149341583252,
-0.11743754893541336,
-0.7867151498794556,
0.0049791098572313786,
-0.003154171397909522,
0.5442721843719482,
0.3438289165496826,
-0.03760883957147598,
0.17821890115737915,
0.690267026424408,
0.15128402411937714,
0.4359591007232666,
0.257885217666626,
-0.35320720076560974,
-0.36250099539756775,
0.6784319877624512,
0.4254301190376282,
0.7684917449951172,
0.32584863901138306,
0.09283588081598282,
-0.5939590930938721,
-0.6448530554771423,
-0.46587327122688293,
0.24797584116458893,
-0.7795270085334778,
0.017328649759292603,
-0.4296284019947052,
-0.1783951371908188,
-0.8922106027603149,
-0.14526277780532837,
-0.44989046454429626,
-0.5111703872680664,
-0.2418215274810791,
0.0006631904398091137,
-0.05456371605396271,
1.0022355318069458,
0.28380581736564636,
0.4839097857475281,
-0.7436642050743103,
-0.09839124232530594,
0.09054706990718842,
0.03559930622577667,
-0.12521669268608093,
-0.8358337879180908,
-0.13921086490154266,
0.2878872752189636,
-0.4205440878868103,
-1.0302830934524536,
0.16760091483592987,
0.1569921374320984,
0.35496437549591064,
0.654299795627594,
-0.050977978855371475,
0.8110284209251404,
-0.29671403765678406,
0.7633129954338074,
0.15796835720539093,
-0.9614927768707275,
0.2572377324104309,
-0.33972886204719543,
0.5484763979911804,
0.26624244451522827,
0.26742926239967346,
-0.473021000623703,
-0.8263141512870789,
-0.6391475796699524,
-0.9229379296302795,
0.5922613739967346,
-0.11850902438163757,
0.3453805446624756,
-0.056289225816726685,
0.3322853446006775,
0.21309295296669006,
0.27912190556526184,
-0.7081798911094666,
-0.0729871541261673,
-0.1161167174577713,
-0.4997757077217102,
-0.08599235117435455,
-0.3191009759902954,
-0.5195671319961548,
-0.11750283092260361,
0.4364514946937561,
-0.19120965898036957,
0.11487405747175217,
0.012021504342556,
-0.28582292795181274,
-0.27721670269966125,
0.2686246633529663,
1.0237385034561157,
0.8563544154167175,
-0.03575581684708595,
0.336340069770813,
-0.031074034050107002,
-0.20153355598449707,
0.03115743398666382,
-0.09527579694986343,
-0.03576725721359253,
-0.11309152841567993,
0.6373369097709656,
0.621976375579834,
0.08394645154476166,
-0.29598668217658997,
0.6266826391220093,
0.18905605375766754,
-0.19406425952911377,
-0.1826314479112625,
0.06391780078411102,
0.12005209177732468,
0.3830137848854065,
0.07789474725723267,
-0.02997574582695961,
0.19435136020183563,
-0.6683183312416077,
0.05348464846611023,
0.8066402673721313,
-0.2522033751010895,
-0.6650727987289429,
0.4491354525089264,
-0.15069805085659027,
-0.40613505244255066,
0.7065414786338806,
0.05044391378760338,
-0.23308560252189636,
0.5996962785720825,
0.8242186307907104,
0.6848462224006653,
-0.4272599220275879,
0.08617272228002548,
0.07155099511146545,
0.1193871721625328,
-0.17337335646152496,
0.12044593691825867,
0.14880876243114471,
-0.9769075512886047,
-0.49559295177459717,
-0.333100825548172,
0.021114768460392952,
0.06148362532258034,
-0.9281173348426819,
0.15576499700546265,
-0.508134663105011,
-0.08644922822713852,
0.1409522444009781,
-0.41500136256217957,
-0.12881037592887878,
-0.17541156709194183,
0.21803218126296997,
0.5812024474143982,
-1.1688339710235596,
0.6154487729072571,
0.8144527673721313,
-0.2052621990442276,
-0.8038351535797119,
0.32718420028686523,
0.1861586719751358,
-0.8211345076560974,
0.3948726952075958,
0.08185026049613953,
0.02528628706932068,
-0.10193181782960892,
-0.7073626518249512,
-1.3098996877670288,
1.0062021017074585,
0.7600355744361877,
-0.5796259641647339,
0.09009253233671188,
0.2639699876308441,
0.6900927424430847,
-0.22262762486934662,
0.2584194839000702,
0.5685478448867798,
0.20161211490631104,
0.37347540259361267,
-1.0166229009628296,
0.03400297462940216,
0.10278495401144028,
0.1459677815437317,
0.766222357749939,
-0.6685163974761963,
1.0196951627731323,
0.049083758145570755,
-0.36196935176849365,
0.1665283739566803,
0.5741558074951172,
0.3489995002746582,
0.09934499114751816,
0.42134296894073486,
0.7550628185272217,
0.6843276023864746,
0.005391283426433802,
1.0406910181045532,
-0.04766106978058815,
0.4404972791671753,
0.9857405424118042,
-0.697664737701416,
0.9425321221351624,
0.9237939119338989,
-0.04307081177830696,
0.26958879828453064,
0.5580994486808777,
0.23552070558071136,
0.4965327978134155,
0.2389993518590927,
-0.1871960610151291,
-0.047064587473869324,
-0.10849412530660629,
-0.371807336807251,
0.25222113728523254,
0.09474506974220276,
-0.38274452090263367,
-0.2645787298679352,
-0.1982443630695343,
-0.333552747964859,
0.029544122517108917,
-0.22379815578460693,
1.075890064239502,
0.056489814072847366,
-0.7977223992347717,
0.6227530241012573,
-0.33954480290412903,
0.4370192885398865,
-0.367279052734375,
0.0190315842628479,
-0.30804502964019775,
0.27700504660606384,
-0.3355930745601654,
-1.0521724224090576,
0.5376020073890686,
-0.5527353286743164,
-0.5172224044799805,
-0.2250950038433075,
0.4643397033214569,
-0.6861613988876343,
-0.18215394020080566,
0.3099561333656311,
0.3348824977874756,
0.10280291736125946,
0.2200974076986313,
-0.5262507200241089,
0.14621956646442413,
-0.04752844572067261,
-0.39820772409439087,
0.5290034413337708,
0.47016581892967224,
-0.3773612380027771,
0.40868130326271057,
0.47590693831443787,
0.06837772578001022,
0.38675376772880554,
0.20156647264957428,
0.6919252276420593,
-0.34034860134124756,
-0.27305200695991516,
-1.0540238618850708,
0.5120307207107544,
-0.21577905118465424,
-0.45780515670776367,
0.5339158177375793,
0.4451470971107483,
0.9984917044639587,
0.06678840517997742,
0.5787144303321838,
0.051844120025634766,
0.2625659108161926,
-0.7009497284889221,
0.35632190108299255,
-0.5960243344306946,
0.26985302567481995,
-0.12594299018383026,
-1.1217663288116455,
-0.31768175959587097,
0.30764228105545044,
-0.36847954988479614,
0.013699899427592754,
0.5932008624076843,
0.7027671933174133,
-0.3399081528186798,
-0.0959552749991417,
0.2626115679740906,
0.22023172676563263,
0.2442268431186676,
0.14203491806983948,
1.1600511074066162,
-0.23198764026165009,
0.4532584547996521,
0.16666939854621887,
-0.07479377090930939,
-0.18025733530521393,
-0.49845966696739197,
-0.5419467687606812,
-0.5992058515548706,
-0.22587838768959045,
-0.4056236743927002,
0.05902703106403351,
0.8542550206184387,
0.6016754508018494,
-0.8488348126411438,
-0.3339668810367584,
-0.28949663043022156,
0.0214353259652853,
-0.11575121432542801,
-0.22490212321281433,
0.24246756732463837,
-0.16707032918930054,
-0.7099622488021851,
0.0375499464571476,
0.2789202332496643,
0.3207114040851593,
-0.14957058429718018,
-0.1662948727607727,
-0.05229617655277252,
-0.041316382586956024,
0.3045872151851654,
0.3219456076622009,
-0.9080901145935059,
-0.37051787972450256,
0.22945725917816162,
-0.4542049169540405,
0.2918761074542999,
0.6900176405906677,
0.03044741041958332,
0.07304620742797852,
0.6142241358757019,
0.7258937954902649,
0.00009691900049801916,
0.36441314220428467,
0.9574849605560303,
-1.0127538442611694,
0.050982166081666946,
0.23416203260421753,
0.3875309228897095,
0.23118796944618225,
-0.39745771884918213,
-0.02145070768892765,
-0.01750914938747883,
-0.6687679886817932,
-0.9322599768638611,
0.7330185770988464,
-0.9907378554344177,
-0.23955680429935455,
1.332482099533081,
0.10836000740528107,
-0.34323710203170776,
0.15006017684936523,
-0.26858213543891907,
0.3028855621814728,
-0.3663577139377594,
0.9136176109313965,
1.0740809440612793,
-0.16699279844760895,
-0.25858810544013977,
-0.2720019817352295,
0.3944540023803711,
0.7800420522689819,
-0.6779998540878296,
0.2087155282497406,
0.5098074078559875,
0.3327997326850891,
0.43583616614341736,
0.5815369486808777,
-0.03434526547789574,
0.1659797877073288,
-0.44764330983161926,
0.00798058696091175,
0.604080319404602,
-0.2257709503173828,
-0.782156229019165,
0.0681726485490799,
0.3922627866268158,
-0.2835373878479004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17681v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17681v2 | VarBench: Robust Language Model Benchmarking Through Dynamic Variable Perturbation | 2024-06-25T16:13:53 | 2024-06-26T15:21:49 | Kun Qian, Shunji Wan, Claudia Tang, Youzhi Wang, Xuanming Zhang, Maximillian Chen, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models achieve impressive scores on traditional benchmarks,
an increasing number of researchers are becoming concerned about benchmark data
leakage during pre-training, commonly known as the data contamination problem.
To ensure fair evaluation, recent benchmarks release only the training and
validation sets, keeping the test set labels closed-source. They require anyone
wishing to evaluate his language model to submit the model's predictions for
centralized processing and then publish the model's result on their
leaderboard. However, this submission process is inefficient and prevents
effective error analysis. To address this issue, we propose to variabilize
benchmarks and evaluate language models dynamically. Specifically, we extract
variables from each test case and define a value range for each variable. For
each evaluation, we sample new values from these value ranges to create unique
test cases, thus ensuring a fresh evaluation each time. We applied this
variable perturbation method to four datasets: GSM8K, ARC, CommonsenseQA, and
TruthfulQA, which cover mathematical generation and multiple-choice tasks. Our
experimental results demonstrate that this approach provides a more accurate
assessment of the true capabilities of language models, effectively mitigating
the contamination problem. | [
-0.3400515615940094,
-0.8280425071716309,
0.3760199546813965,
0.16898398101329803,
-0.1390586495399475,
0.39802074432373047,
-0.282132089138031,
-0.26658764481544495,
-0.4229387044906616,
0.8737354278564453,
-0.6400974988937378,
-0.47174346446990967,
-0.4097362756729126,
-0.32825997471809387,
-0.42733293771743774,
0.7348731756210327,
-0.300604909658432,
-0.048980433493852615,
-0.34629690647125244,
-0.2313050776720047,
-0.4095485210418701,
-0.7219995856285095,
0.023846689611673355,
-0.18526668846607208,
0.16491733491420746,
0.5676261186599731,
0.5158442854881287,
0.6740545630455017,
0.6609286069869995,
0.37482455372810364,
-0.00663532130420208,
-0.2587406039237976,
-0.6412109136581421,
0.7091801762580872,
-0.21932852268218994,
-0.5592097043991089,
-0.19053831696510315,
-0.0023723405320197344,
0.9246408343315125,
0.5485724806785583,
-0.3424537479877472,
0.4731636345386505,
-0.13394662737846375,
0.40961652994155884,
-0.7565366625785828,
0.21000802516937256,
-0.7585686445236206,
-0.021501798182725906,
-0.6601526737213135,
0.18151772022247314,
-0.34132859110832214,
-0.49468204379081726,
-0.2947080731391907,
-0.22163932025432587,
-0.013988442718982697,
-0.3112148642539978,
1.044795036315918,
0.48970291018486023,
-0.08681221306324005,
0.39888378977775574,
-0.8816657066345215,
0.9082515835762024,
-0.6631376147270203,
0.19612449407577515,
0.33805063366889954,
0.8541757464408875,
-0.1631520390510559,
-0.7469444274902344,
-0.3290814161300659,
-0.20792104303836823,
0.4258062541484833,
-0.19297732412815094,
-0.041880734264850616,
-0.24530303478240967,
0.26059672236442566,
0.29334181547164917,
-0.2090822458267212,
0.12737472355365753,
0.12490353733301163,
-0.1912744790315628,
0.46539387106895447,
0.24158397316932678,
0.22401733696460724,
0.13385368883609772,
-0.3609468638896942,
-0.6599217057228088,
-0.7623915076255798,
0.052070777863264084,
0.8059945702552795,
0.45354074239730835,
0.18653516471385956,
0.3050565719604492,
-0.13753023743629456,
0.5209247469902039,
0.031450700014829636,
0.16372676193714142,
0.5645223259925842,
-0.6823261976242065,
-0.05889961123466492,
-0.4124707579612732,
0.7116450667381287,
-0.31955909729003906,
0.13486526906490326,
-0.03738599270582199,
-0.2952735722064972,
-0.13200463354587555,
0.38573750853538513,
-0.9125452041625977,
-0.14173176884651184,
0.12108971923589706,
-0.1933453381061554,
-0.7818467617034912,
0.07909660041332245,
-1.0309908390045166,
-0.25945958495140076,
-0.0590268038213253,
0.2773715853691101,
-0.09102842956781387,
-0.3062693178653717,
0.11072587966918945,
0.2593616843223572,
-0.3646987974643707,
0.066013865172863,
-0.8628087639808655,
0.5681836605072021,
0.3491150140762329,
0.1725119650363922,
-0.2451639175415039,
-0.3054365813732147,
-0.873216986656189,
-0.1796952337026596,
-0.1432349979877472,
0.8038731217384338,
-0.957546591758728,
-0.31168001890182495,
0.0964428186416626,
-0.30539470911026,
0.23476538062095642,
-0.6832405924797058,
0.4028002917766571,
-0.3063856065273285,
0.0077664898708462715,
-0.23037613928318024,
-0.28912100195884705,
0.24357444047927856,
0.04945775121450424,
-0.7081403136253357,
1.0747268199920654,
0.2602722644805908,
-0.684810221195221,
0.2803892493247986,
-0.2921769320964813,
0.022047273814678192,
0.08578494936227798,
-0.46190547943115234,
-0.7178584337234497,
0.07796959578990936,
0.16528448462486267,
0.10375706106424332,
-0.2802221477031708,
0.4102686941623688,
-0.44990384578704834,
-0.1877203732728958,
0.4155963063240051,
-0.8635228276252747,
0.5559942722320557,
0.02388586662709713,
-0.5106019973754883,
0.2957049608230591,
-0.9364920258522034,
0.5158102512359619,
-0.17116712033748627,
-0.3624970316886902,
-0.15765303373336792,
0.13183492422103882,
0.049357686191797256,
0.29749763011932373,
0.058188360184431076,
-0.28435757756233215,
0.03543727099895477,
-0.15300258994102478,
-0.16867253184318542,
0.7569695711135864,
-0.004196720197796822,
-0.023300524801015854,
-0.20021726191043854,
0.7659767270088196,
-0.11313270032405853,
0.37540900707244873,
-0.10119432210922241,
-0.07711267471313477,
-0.47792506217956543,
-0.2888509929180145,
0.6948404312133789,
0.3481537103652954,
-0.5047152638435364,
0.40046778321266174,
-0.2071787416934967,
-0.7610698342323303,
-0.35544919967651367,
0.1289873719215393,
0.6463407278060913,
0.40052667260169983,
0.28639963269233704,
-0.44285160303115845,
-0.31070461869239807,
-0.7723010778427124,
-0.5358926653862,
-0.07721014320850372,
-0.14325818419456482,
0.3312695324420929,
0.2594582140445709,
-0.14871935546398163,
0.5914034247398376,
-0.294481098651886,
0.03404387831687927,
0.07401980459690094,
0.4252587556838989,
0.17277440428733826,
0.5476585030555725,
0.5520159006118774,
-0.585669219493866,
-0.5939390659332275,
-0.26420971751213074,
-0.4155741333961487,
-0.5225390791893005,
0.058066509664058685,
-0.19299833476543427,
-0.17124396562576294,
0.6044083833694458,
-0.1383569836616516,
0.32322388887405396,
0.8115129470825195,
-0.17772319912910461,
1.0473743677139282,
0.013882703147828579,
0.0740603432059288,
-0.7088731527328491,
0.26605674624443054,
-0.35140693187713623,
-0.39780640602111816,
-0.4651622176170349,
0.17813856899738312,
-0.008838689886033535,
-0.09527122229337692,
-0.5127079486846924,
0.3574231266975403,
-0.28571346402168274,
0.1819908767938614,
-0.05887410417199135,
-0.10305605083703995,
-0.17882347106933594,
-0.02377873845398426,
-0.24102480709552765,
0.6410044431686401,
0.6033865213394165,
-0.1506941020488739,
0.3277919888496399,
0.14529578387737274,
-0.444457083940506,
0.09533682465553284,
-0.4276728332042694,
0.12410455197095871,
0.30426615476608276,
0.2103603482246399,
-0.8643174171447754,
-0.1399511992931366,
-0.019068308174610138,
-0.2601994276046753,
0.40513914823532104,
-0.01840156316757202,
-0.5726304054260254,
-0.16608498990535736,
-0.3515761196613312,
0.4116511940956116,
0.1708790510892868,
-0.43578580021858215,
0.2790569067001343,
0.4941454529762268,
-0.15639586746692657,
-0.847214937210083,
-0.6352894902229309,
-0.08080779016017914,
-0.10292185842990875,
-0.3063277006149292,
0.29426297545433044,
-0.29952889680862427,
-0.3687838912010193,
-0.035410430282354355,
-0.5239922404289246,
-0.2412567138671875,
0.2735319137573242,
0.18619252741336823,
0.20169265568256378,
-0.1533137857913971,
0.30355358123779297,
-0.08593598008155823,
-0.1641135960817337,
0.045325327664613724,
0.06885837763547897,
0.7400957345962524,
-0.3482159972190857,
-0.5486022233963013,
-0.2897263169288635,
0.2279340922832489,
0.5781872868537903,
-0.5536564588546753,
0.5215924978256226,
0.481411874294281,
-0.34199240803718567,
-0.26002928614616394,
-0.5476037859916687,
-0.09975957870483398,
-0.5622791051864624,
0.4362056255340576,
-0.5461258292198181,
-0.5992401242256165,
0.5783464908599854,
-0.34429821372032166,
-0.08843813836574554,
0.26070111989974976,
0.5948130488395691,
0.23912307620048523,
0.7640653252601624,
0.8272767663002014,
0.03131008520722389,
0.8536982536315918,
0.12509754300117493,
0.0575789138674736,
-0.25064536929130554,
0.07322436571121216,
-0.7690439820289612,
0.07222946733236313,
-0.7860886454582214,
-0.5811495184898376,
0.012787970714271069,
-0.10427411645650864,
-0.3553576171398163,
0.15854471921920776,
-0.2564087212085724,
0.6324122548103333,
0.2768457233905792,
-0.20400089025497437,
0.1104930192232132,
0.05222341790795326,
-0.6013854146003723,
-0.1546785980463028,
-0.3967386484146118,
-0.5628713965415955,
1.234163761138916,
0.21337273716926575,
0.9035714864730835,
0.03342437744140625,
0.791134238243103,
-0.032035619020462036,
0.26695993542671204,
-0.15638047456741333,
0.4073299467563629,
-0.32139158248901367,
-0.6461598873138428,
-0.5021324157714844,
-0.6612390875816345,
-0.7244039177894592,
0.20601056516170502,
-0.19110818207263947,
-1.1912957429885864,
0.358995258808136,
-0.05309728533029556,
-0.2632606029510498,
0.28235578536987305,
-0.43288496136665344,
0.7795352935791016,
-0.3141648471355438,
-0.7120571732521057,
-0.05528150871396065,
-0.6314168572425842,
0.39784327149391174,
-0.5503160953521729,
0.18434178829193115,
-0.2589855194091797,
0.16667722165584564,
0.3876868188381195,
-0.5608351826667786,
0.6741364598274231,
-0.09584297239780426,
0.001491402625106275,
0.02145540341734886,
0.27471697330474854,
0.41692230105400085,
0.12859252095222473,
-0.36392131447792053,
0.12205515801906586,
0.08012200146913528,
-0.35573330521583557,
-0.5021568536758423,
0.6814695596694946,
-0.6929960250854492,
-0.5510910153388977,
-0.5157803297042847,
-0.5092198252677917,
-0.699214518070221,
0.43168342113494873,
0.1695740967988968,
0.19620487093925476,
-0.18485213816165924,
0.44028547406196594,
0.7069278955459595,
-0.31247222423553467,
0.40510067343711853,
0.5796571373939514,
-0.3423840403556824,
-0.17196163535118103,
0.6789930462837219,
0.023492049425840378,
0.5993796586990356,
0.20541927218437195,
0.3161427080631256,
-0.08506140112876892,
-0.5091969966888428,
-0.00108581711538136,
0.07655787467956543,
-0.5963707566261292,
-0.18953512609004974,
-0.14638493955135345,
-0.3663467764854431,
-0.09812020510435104,
0.1780300736427307,
-1.0083465576171875,
-0.17789247632026672,
0.11090024560689926,
0.029460400342941284,
-0.13749836385250092,
0.5176121592521667,
-0.0704866424202919,
0.174704909324646,
-0.7114647030830383,
0.09922336786985397,
0.21703049540519714,
0.76967453956604,
-0.27039262652397156,
-0.07693598419427872,
-0.1513187140226364,
-0.009663214907050133,
-0.32395225763320923,
-0.645004153251648,
0.23653358221054077,
0.04301239550113678,
0.914505124092102,
0.39432305097579956,
0.17344842851161957,
0.5039997696876526,
-0.5248271226882935,
0.7047789692878723,
0.14594438672065735,
-1.3312623500823975,
0.5418489575386047,
-0.4328226149082184,
0.5020043849945068,
0.9422247409820557,
0.08373706787824631,
-0.2714443802833557,
-0.6894496083259583,
-0.7823175191879272,
-1.0942648649215698,
0.5923344492912292,
0.3725685775279999,
0.10625593364238739,
0.49900442361831665,
0.20856498181819916,
0.281479150056839,
0.5513301491737366,
-0.4959872364997864,
-0.13653258979320526,
-0.28657394647598267,
-0.05472033843398094,
-0.1450125128030777,
-0.30225294828414917,
-0.23742666840553284,
-0.1668258011341095,
0.43514254689216614,
0.08025999367237091,
0.1328057050704956,
-0.5026045441627502,
0.02149113081395626,
-0.33240795135498047,
0.10286854952573776,
0.3919406831264496,
0.8352437615394592,
-0.2712946832180023,
0.24027729034423828,
0.004975572694092989,
-0.6602147817611694,
0.27604737877845764,
0.26802849769592285,
0.14438588917255402,
0.011933363974094391,
0.1458706259727478,
0.5317912101745605,
0.12390951812267303,
-0.86221843957901,
0.4638812839984894,
-0.5033205151557922,
0.04128233343362808,
-0.07725085318088531,
0.263406366109848,
-0.035872697830200195,
0.16964107751846313,
0.16009581089019775,
0.16377203166484833,
-0.16840092837810516,
-0.5248528718948364,
0.628604531288147,
0.07239237427711487,
-0.3289276659488678,
-0.24059617519378662,
0.7462226152420044,
-0.036885976791381836,
-0.17884515225887299,
0.46839794516563416,
0.22568073868751526,
-0.5088540315628052,
0.5514658689498901,
0.35956430435180664,
0.7273726463317871,
-0.7795898914337158,
0.22291144728660583,
0.11923114210367203,
0.16703662276268005,
-0.1440080851316452,
0.33212968707084656,
0.08024787902832031,
-0.6569697856903076,
-0.2850918471813202,
-0.469758003950119,
-0.6568318009376526,
0.49891310930252075,
-0.778252363204956,
0.23114700615406036,
-0.2799646258354187,
-0.22107455134391785,
0.12768904864788055,
0.28784486651420593,
-0.6090157628059387,
0.22837097942829132,
0.1319873183965683,
0.6786916255950928,
-0.9100124835968018,
1.070944905281067,
0.3581862449645996,
-0.4517531991004944,
-0.7683303952217102,
0.5272972583770752,
0.03640605881810188,
-0.3501765727996826,
0.4489802122116089,
-0.004793816711753607,
-0.06125576049089432,
-0.3938013017177582,
-0.4804960787296295,
-1.2762281894683838,
0.5563238859176636,
0.8468749523162842,
-0.6350680589675903,
0.4373365640640259,
0.2873143255710602,
0.6650485396385193,
-0.08948025107383728,
0.19344457983970642,
0.5910442471504211,
0.7355782985687256,
-0.2322709858417511,
-0.8579928278923035,
0.2298794835805893,
-0.5430101752281189,
-0.03285360336303711,
0.049026008695364,
-0.6966332197189331,
0.9882205724716187,
0.29378992319107056,
-0.04968433827161789,
-0.029790423810482025,
0.2064882069826126,
0.29415783286094666,
-0.36816680431365967,
0.49016469717025757,
0.07340941578149796,
1.0410046577453613,
-0.13411694765090942,
0.9652177691459656,
-0.19340667128562927,
0.3813807964324951,
1.5507075786590576,
-0.4189988970756531,
0.9820690155029297,
0.47265779972076416,
-0.21932080388069153,
0.42220744490623474,
0.5288044810295105,
-0.22276920080184937,
0.6906899809837341,
0.7430639863014221,
-0.2733295261859894,
-0.2351730763912201,
0.0633804127573967,
-0.31337228417396545,
0.6670244336128235,
0.22268380224704742,
-0.1245444267988205,
-0.3344742953777313,
-0.06936772167682648,
0.15240494906902313,
0.1870144009590149,
0.3025725185871124,
0.23813609778881073,
-0.22010555863380432,
-0.5825409293174744,
0.8296038508415222,
-0.10914899408817291,
0.10288145393133163,
-0.8098487854003906,
0.14273156225681305,
-0.23772433400154114,
0.4387216567993164,
0.026059219613671303,
-0.4442046284675598,
0.2836536765098572,
0.05877189710736275,
0.008078629150986671,
-0.4712086021900177,
0.6657271981239319,
-0.5225546360015869,
-0.5317627787590027,
0.34707602858543396,
0.5961905717849731,
-0.024330899119377136,
0.010371997021138668,
-0.5319654941558838,
0.48512452840805054,
-0.09863361716270447,
-0.3837110996246338,
0.5073478817939758,
0.2467828094959259,
-0.16484299302101135,
0.6658730506896973,
0.43963897228240967,
0.2940101623535156,
0.17794282734394073,
0.260267049074173,
1.12904953956604,
-0.3366754353046417,
-0.2424989491701126,
-0.6442317366600037,
0.46474412083625793,
-0.16179712116718292,
-0.2707240581512451,
0.7233735918998718,
0.3844667971134186,
0.6016855835914612,
0.12438508868217468,
0.9072619080543518,
0.35121622681617737,
0.28185969591140747,
-0.2030831128358841,
0.8595700263977051,
-0.2903975546360016,
0.5631689429283142,
-0.42566996812820435,
-0.7039699554443359,
-0.536285400390625,
0.29147210717201233,
-0.27279654145240784,
0.11636228114366531,
0.8169126510620117,
0.5681129693984985,
-0.0949399545788765,
-0.27268749475479126,
0.3618544042110443,
0.3655242323875427,
0.6770461201667786,
0.2261735200881958,
0.5982551574707031,
-0.19326987862586975,
0.6187335252761841,
-0.27867260575294495,
-0.3399290144443512,
-0.26145341992378235,
-1.0203341245651245,
-0.5851247906684875,
-0.44677406549453735,
-0.4027344286441803,
-0.2641373872756958,
0.4251880645751953,
0.2911277413368225,
0.7129542231559753,
-0.8699108958244324,
-0.3549313545227051,
-0.22881820797920227,
0.10759159177541733,
-0.4748271107673645,
-0.19655397534370422,
0.41996532678604126,
-0.6973744034767151,
-0.628455400466919,
0.4775935709476471,
-0.09109612554311752,
-0.09774963557720184,
-0.46877321600914,
0.47509872913360596,
-0.1406833827495575,
0.40509364008903503,
-0.024635104462504387,
0.09971893578767776,
-0.21717140078544617,
-0.3991384208202362,
-0.3102779984474182,
-0.004812873899936676,
0.17191188037395477,
0.5806464552879333,
-0.7622907161712646,
0.8802077174186707,
0.5129438638687134,
0.6411668062210083,
0.8550867438316345,
0.055306728929281235,
0.8097665905952454,
-0.9129621982574463,
0.16363409161567688,
0.3722418546676636,
0.07488229870796204,
0.1671990007162094,
-0.3147165775299072,
0.2414088100194931,
0.04660862311720848,
-0.44702449440956116,
-1.2113128900527954,
0.2155396044254303,
-0.5472164750099182,
-0.3419703543186188,
1.041095495223999,
-0.4437461495399475,
-0.3374824821949005,
0.07529738545417786,
0.3394051194190979,
0.3350496292114258,
-0.21317216753959656,
0.8978996872901917,
1.084502935409546,
0.07561788707971573,
0.04728471860289574,
-0.7335735559463501,
0.530112087726593,
0.3256909251213074,
-1.0441609621047974,
0.3246205747127533,
0.27301809191703796,
0.535087525844574,
-0.00751451775431633,
0.21940380334854126,
-0.491536945104599,
0.15156982839107513,
0.41285598278045654,
0.22730286419391632,
-0.030611535534262657,
-0.29164019227027893,
-0.3361116051673889,
0.3037795424461365,
-0.029718995094299316,
-0.3869166672229767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17675v1 | Quantifying AI Psychology: A Psychometrics Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | 2024-06-25T16:09:08 | Yuan Li, Yue Huang, Hongyi Wang, Xiangliang Zhang, James Zou, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional task-solving
capabilities, increasingly adopting roles akin to human-like assistants. The
broader integration of LLMs into society has sparked interest in whether they
manifest psychological attributes, and whether these attributes are
stable-inquiries that could deepen the understanding of their behaviors.
Inspired by psychometrics, this paper presents a framework for investigating
psychology in LLMs, including psychological dimension identification,
assessment dataset curation, and assessment with results validation. Following
this framework, we introduce a comprehensive psychometrics benchmark for LLMs
that covers six psychological dimensions: personality, values, emotion, theory
of mind, motivation, and intelligence. This benchmark includes thirteen
datasets featuring diverse scenarios and item types. Our findings indicate that
LLMs manifest a broad spectrum of psychological attributes. We also uncover
discrepancies between LLMs' self-reported traits and their behaviors in
real-world scenarios. This paper demonstrates a thorough psychometric
assessment of LLMs, providing insights into reliable evaluation and potential
applications in AI and social sciences. | [
-0.41002368927001953,
-0.7426044344902039,
0.7899717092514038,
0.5784061551094055,
0.35358378291130066,
0.3125789165496826,
-0.5807127952575684,
-0.47692790627479553,
0.023910153657197952,
0.17120935022830963,
-0.7282874584197998,
-0.23775362968444824,
-0.5886527895927429,
0.20743899047374725,
-0.36917608976364136,
0.7207246422767639,
0.15475381910800934,
0.24412770569324493,
-0.6338179707527161,
-0.21978811919689178,
-0.39169245958328247,
-0.7218484878540039,
-0.789657711982727,
-0.5621416568756104,
0.5580042600631714,
0.10336542129516602,
0.6197841167449951,
0.48772791028022766,
0.7154081463813782,
0.32086217403411865,
0.12434206902980804,
0.044668350368738174,
-0.3688214421272278,
0.19711074233055115,
-0.06083829328417778,
-0.5030165314674377,
-0.6411032676696777,
0.420461505651474,
0.5359680652618408,
0.8279344439506531,
0.0265372134745121,
0.5325396656990051,
0.03133117035031319,
0.4532165825366974,
-0.5954646468162537,
0.35053521394729614,
-0.2292558252811432,
-0.08411435782909393,
-0.1451202780008316,
0.21955911815166473,
-0.30766138434410095,
-0.26241031289100647,
-0.2109251767396927,
-0.13170748949050903,
-0.04436551779508591,
-0.11098486185073853,
0.4114697575569153,
0.32994508743286133,
-0.5465919375419617,
-0.1179124191403389,
-0.7501833438873291,
0.8721686005592346,
-0.5750190019607544,
0.4451899528503418,
0.5761817693710327,
0.20163390040397644,
-0.10341940820217133,
-0.3317376971244812,
-0.5683811902999878,
-0.4620337188243866,
-0.157062828540802,
-0.14666976034641266,
-0.11091360449790955,
-0.02907414548099041,
0.3189318776130676,
0.35215193033218384,
-0.6082243323326111,
0.3598431348800659,
0.03522956743836403,
-0.1253783106803894,
1.133244514465332,
0.6587833762168884,
0.305623859167099,
0.2618955373764038,
0.25721752643585205,
-0.1568261831998825,
-0.47968223690986633,
0.17589494585990906,
0.3111981749534607,
0.06933888792991638,
-0.45438894629478455,
0.45454534888267517,
-0.12442278116941452,
0.3774900436401367,
-0.013818428851664066,
-0.3660025894641876,
0.26640233397483826,
-0.15845559537410736,
-0.02332998439669609,
-0.30256950855255127,
0.8030486702919006,
0.2564360499382019,
0.5119401216506958,
-0.30176398158073425,
-0.14759977161884308,
0.15754938125610352,
0.2137029767036438,
-0.6314796805381775,
0.011384143494069576,
0.3791041970252991,
-0.6149249076843262,
-0.21133515238761902,
-0.22108647227287292,
-0.5884730219841003,
-0.7220442295074463,
-0.37742310762405396,
-0.06507772207260132,
-0.3019401729106903,
-0.33536863327026367,
-0.30776458978652954,
0.07098950445652008,
0.493649959564209,
0.033301301300525665,
-0.8826687932014465,
0.3553317189216614,
0.9534087181091309,
0.6313683390617371,
-0.3901943266391754,
-0.5484296083450317,
-0.22353240847587585,
-0.08325010538101196,
-0.6488233208656311,
0.5533263683319092,
-0.7219749689102173,
-0.23885402083396912,
0.18154385685920715,
-0.19368889927864075,
0.21469180285930634,
-0.5357640385627747,
0.30957430601119995,
-0.22541482746601105,
-0.035774800926446915,
-0.34185823798179626,
-0.5893182158470154,
0.09613674879074097,
0.6667036414146423,
-0.4269177317619324,
1.060625672340393,
0.23327413201332092,
-0.29817041754722595,
0.31959769129753113,
-0.7225552797317505,
-0.3801932632923126,
0.13662610948085785,
-0.46487194299697876,
-0.05599864199757576,
0.35551702976226807,
0.08456238359212875,
0.6441697478294373,
-0.6202652454376221,
0.2563140094280243,
-0.5178964138031006,
-0.2558004558086395,
0.9209300875663757,
-0.5579168200492859,
0.7783951759338379,
0.04353723302483559,
0.1520988494157791,
0.11429391801357269,
-1.0045154094696045,
0.20492281019687653,
0.11827503889799118,
-0.22267231345176697,
-0.09967145323753357,
0.25641068816185,
0.016147950664162636,
0.1279926598072052,
0.677000105381012,
-0.4846291244029999,
0.11819639801979065,
-0.07386809587478638,
0.39613720774650574,
0.7119899392127991,
-0.1505512148141861,
0.2255345582962036,
-0.20519760251045227,
0.6092679500579834,
-0.3996817469596863,
0.2092662900686264,
0.1938444823026657,
-0.05960279703140259,
-0.5107517242431641,
-0.7500312328338623,
-0.17859740555286407,
0.47779154777526855,
0.025423521175980568,
0.8207469582557678,
-0.2147195190191269,
-0.8252646923065186,
-0.4650319516658783,
0.3427075743675232,
0.3343335688114166,
0.03482093662023544,
-0.00720507325604558,
0.014538555406033993,
-0.3511437475681305,
-0.9059789776802063,
-0.4476366341114044,
-0.3759496212005615,
-0.4436478614807129,
0.29825258255004883,
0.5257702469825745,
-0.3156002163887024,
0.777860164642334,
-0.22380152344703674,
-0.2490394562482834,
-0.25567924976348877,
0.3859313130378723,
0.24358047544956207,
0.20544978976249695,
0.5788554549217224,
-0.49205508828163147,
-0.11193618923425674,
-0.2605612277984619,
-1.0926941633224487,
-0.32112666964530945,
0.05791508033871651,
0.22746892273426056,
0.005227590911090374,
0.5628140568733215,
-0.6373962163925171,
0.24953262507915497,
0.4941898584365845,
-0.40593239665031433,
0.61825031042099,
-0.16180002689361572,
0.029298512265086174,
-0.6440058350563049,
0.19468021392822266,
0.14451363682746887,
0.08447396010160446,
-0.443216472864151,
0.20106011629104614,
-0.061434898525476456,
0.06725472956895828,
-0.0652860477566719,
0.6684543490409851,
-0.3949638605117798,
-0.3939991593360901,
-0.11591637879610062,
-0.035568952560424805,
-0.28733232617378235,
0.378776878118515,
-0.14382067322731018,
0.7803276777267456,
0.4620450437068939,
-0.24095797538757324,
0.6974145174026489,
0.075971320271492,
-0.4170415997505188,
0.9732094407081604,
-0.6223841905593872,
0.26787269115448,
-0.07805792987346649,
0.1915966123342514,
-1.025514841079712,
-0.34133291244506836,
-0.39033886790275574,
-0.45924749970436096,
-0.12985865771770477,
0.34393590688705444,
-0.8504855036735535,
-0.33581408858299255,
-0.2357548326253891,
0.44859376549720764,
0.42582377791404724,
-0.09796994924545288,
0.8794770240783691,
0.31536397337913513,
-0.32861247658729553,
-0.2189268171787262,
-0.5174001455307007,
0.32488805055618286,
-0.45027291774749756,
-0.2834474742412567,
0.25711217522621155,
-0.3568059206008911,
-0.7112149596214294,
-0.20629698038101196,
0.22270309925079346,
0.006288252770900726,
0.22511927783489227,
0.3065744936466217,
0.26840338110923767,
-0.20507897436618805,
0.023372886702418327,
-0.5142735838890076,
-0.07954087853431702,
0.5972868800163269,
0.3154924511909485,
0.731537938117981,
-0.3917970061302185,
-0.3780156672000885,
-0.4955086410045624,
0.26052457094192505,
0.9077338576316833,
-0.44509726762771606,
0.7165219783782959,
0.7828096747398376,
-0.45567628741264343,
0.14135919511318207,
-0.6332885026931763,
-0.1871020644903183,
-0.4122408628463745,
0.6186586022377014,
-0.41168448328971863,
-0.5679095387458801,
0.7742051482200623,
0.06826181709766388,
-0.033588726073503494,
0.11700429767370224,
0.7722365260124207,
-0.2730497717857361,
1.4775348901748657,
0.7498425245285034,
-0.5452035069465637,
0.3465685248374939,
-0.061335403472185135,
0.4806252717971802,
-0.8617830872535706,
-0.4444558620452881,
-0.5223749279975891,
-0.5156919956207275,
-0.6462095975875854,
-0.09116128832101822,
0.4225623607635498,
-0.15827174484729767,
-0.8634129166603088,
-0.21154484152793884,
-0.16714221239089966,
0.4290381371974945,
0.4230606257915497,
-0.1599939912557602,
0.10357467085123062,
-0.2553125321865082,
0.36985287070274353,
-0.07309102267026901,
0.019064996391534805,
-0.634554386138916,
1.038782000541687,
0.5672116875648499,
0.9535366296768188,
0.3000103235244751,
0.41196566820144653,
0.5064232349395752,
0.4551845192909241,
-0.7805037498474121,
0.7976737022399902,
-0.05553630366921425,
-0.5204192996025085,
-0.49805310368537903,
-0.18746858835220337,
-0.5650461316108704,
-0.10627201944589615,
-0.27239447832107544,
-1.403562307357788,
-0.08474906533956528,
-0.16247744858264923,
-0.12019380927085876,
-0.18363749980926514,
-0.42514070868492126,
0.7226904630661011,
-0.7456133365631104,
-0.2694600224494934,
-0.5459702014923096,
-0.371782124042511,
0.190948948264122,
-0.11582435667514801,
-0.006854872684925795,
-0.45973512530326843,
-0.2955150604248047,
0.7028488516807556,
-0.11528313905000687,
0.7847086787223816,
0.10642626881599426,
-0.1436673402786255,
-0.23754151165485382,
0.19849950075149536,
0.2639959156513214,
-0.01819288171827793,
-0.271101176738739,
0.19478778541088104,
0.25207310914993286,
-0.40679648518562317,
-0.9020787477493286,
0.6560524702072144,
-1.1423693895339966,
-0.47043803334236145,
-0.32598379254341125,
-0.9158735275268555,
-0.7707720398902893,
-0.021601909771561623,
-0.1254090517759323,
0.19653622806072235,
-0.4409361779689789,
0.31484922766685486,
0.27541303634643555,
-0.1999795138835907,
0.32794973254203796,
0.5782361626625061,
-0.24712756276130676,
-0.09676015377044678,
0.8018823266029358,
-0.1588267832994461,
0.08840377628803253,
0.323965460062027,
0.11881837248802185,
-0.4464769959449768,
-0.402662456035614,
0.042024873197078705,
0.4557698369026184,
-0.695398211479187,
0.049401525408029556,
-0.24625134468078613,
-0.36159220337867737,
-0.6524171829223633,
-0.17332610487937927,
-0.229999378323555,
0.2494897097349167,
-0.0324413999915123,
-0.09126672893762589,
0.40430763363838196,
0.9356814026832581,
0.0923766940832138,
0.29772406816482544,
-0.3800466060638428,
0.2237091064453125,
0.17761248350143433,
0.40073397755622864,
0.21196943521499634,
-0.43803519010543823,
-0.1254257708787918,
0.03454464301466942,
-0.24381516873836517,
-0.7402904033660889,
0.4113994538784027,
0.08588460087776184,
0.7128612399101257,
0.7261098027229309,
-0.1873507797718048,
0.603330671787262,
-0.24452203512191772,
0.9480495452880859,
-0.007925079204142094,
-0.9018755555152893,
0.3609630763530731,
-0.3519475758075714,
0.06264684349298477,
0.43676507472991943,
0.5061831474304199,
-0.4833156168460846,
-0.3896560072898865,
-0.44856780767440796,
-0.469049870967865,
0.40448686480522156,
0.017618441954255104,
0.2588135600090027,
0.003398312721401453,
0.3221423029899597,
-0.29183825850486755,
0.2008001059293747,
-0.6689393520355225,
-0.3357449471950531,
0.1965084820985794,
-0.6410117745399475,
-0.46209996938705444,
-0.22479386627674103,
-0.16941773891448975,
-0.35071995854377747,
0.38314878940582275,
-0.1349698007106781,
0.3306836485862732,
-0.3086050748825073,
-0.0256712194532156,
0.22140492498874664,
0.1687232106924057,
0.3546505272388458,
0.7392570972442627,
-0.3408878445625305,
0.12361437827348709,
0.0964948758482933,
-0.1927506923675537,
0.4020150899887085,
-0.08457358181476593,
0.4454404413700104,
-0.5944868326187134,
0.7726484537124634,
0.3583108186721802,
-0.23673848807811737,
-0.993324339389801,
0.5290073156356812,
-0.0783776193857193,
0.18225598335266113,
-0.5483065843582153,
0.17084288597106934,
0.1383608877658844,
0.4857701361179352,
0.40249454975128174,
-0.5265123844146729,
0.0237708892673254,
-0.9209374189376831,
-0.13257497549057007,
0.576490044593811,
-0.2759905159473419,
-0.36099037528038025,
0.24409548938274384,
0.14220735430717468,
-0.7405090928077698,
0.8613071441650391,
-0.10159935802221298,
-0.2917155921459198,
0.7303928732872009,
0.44925835728645325,
0.8510661721229553,
-0.09705699235200882,
0.041289035230875015,
0.029379338026046753,
0.3456568717956543,
0.16535238921642303,
0.30174142122268677,
-0.020711518824100494,
-0.9261711835861206,
-0.19185331463813782,
-0.6114644408226013,
-0.36830905079841614,
0.6275255680084229,
-0.7927408814430237,
-0.06684185564517975,
-0.4360812306404114,
-0.22929047048091888,
0.020356109365820885,
0.23488178849220276,
-1.0757325887680054,
0.2779974043369293,
0.41690582036972046,
0.7881068587303162,
-1.0218771696090698,
0.579093873500824,
0.7741038203239441,
-0.47162434458732605,
-0.5551113486289978,
0.06129908189177513,
0.15000323951244354,
-1.243191123008728,
0.8456841707229614,
0.08941466361284256,
0.06486029177904129,
-0.20872712135314941,
-0.5238667130470276,
-0.7324090003967285,
0.9577935934066772,
0.4110540747642517,
-0.16316942870616913,
-0.16939304769039154,
0.5462934970855713,
0.8842372894287109,
-0.6281527280807495,
0.5798718929290771,
0.995986819267273,
0.5264403223991394,
-0.5348376035690308,
-0.7184721231460571,
0.032366298139095306,
-0.35485294461250305,
0.16613556444644928,
-0.19774611294269562,
-0.713078498840332,
0.6250944137573242,
-0.00807703286409378,
0.23199106752872467,
0.357970654964447,
0.6688773036003113,
0.4187493920326233,
0.10146362334489822,
0.42124974727630615,
0.2813015878200531,
0.7942741513252258,
0.027017710730433464,
0.8826203942298889,
-0.6351748108863831,
0.018933255225419998,
0.9368529915809631,
-0.50607830286026,
0.8866738080978394,
0.4842752516269684,
-0.46958330273628235,
0.4461413323879242,
0.6254631876945496,
-0.19308120012283325,
0.166275754570961,
0.46452638506889343,
-0.17743857204914093,
-0.3611420691013336,
-0.3821697533130646,
0.0359332337975502,
0.9096662402153015,
0.6441651582717896,
-0.28098180890083313,
0.11413212865591049,
0.16741077601909637,
-0.15153062343597412,
0.1940932720899582,
-0.3396989703178406,
0.7286775708198547,
-0.018857568502426147,
-0.6751551032066345,
0.16134123504161835,
-0.12157005816698074,
0.5952748656272888,
-0.5468871593475342,
0.10663876682519913,
-0.4983617067337036,
0.4298034906387329,
0.04349932447075844,
-1.1074906587600708,
0.11230482906103134,
0.2496832013130188,
-0.26028093695640564,
-0.32253775000572205,
0.36793553829193115,
-0.17987275123596191,
-0.736947238445282,
0.3382514715194702,
0.6885961890220642,
0.38381144404411316,
-0.04408889636397362,
-0.5780235528945923,
0.2619835436344147,
-0.46740368008613586,
-0.16167709231376648,
0.530602753162384,
0.4390500485897064,
-0.09391617774963379,
0.9825073480606079,
0.3711780309677124,
0.3259822428226471,
-0.27064192295074463,
0.20120100677013397,
0.21631743013858795,
-0.8642582297325134,
-0.2749853730201721,
-1.0679620504379272,
0.14119939506053925,
-0.13686396181583405,
-0.5111897587776184,
0.6763467788696289,
0.455233097076416,
0.5756415128707886,
0.2010888308286667,
0.75998455286026,
0.022214367985725403,
0.24575941264629364,
-0.1996425837278366,
0.6355392932891846,
-0.4913471043109894,
0.06399815529584885,
-0.16283708810806274,
-0.7486602067947388,
0.026670223101973534,
0.7246500849723816,
-0.4837348461151123,
0.25868627429008484,
0.3350060284137726,
0.8194583654403687,
0.2615804374217987,
-0.21836206316947937,
0.4489074647426605,
0.260781466960907,
0.4367988407611847,
0.42771631479263306,
1.0933040380477905,
-0.012039910070598125,
0.04289880022406578,
-0.0968860387802124,
-0.34412357211112976,
-0.14564518630504608,
-0.8386849164962769,
-1.0719835758209229,
-0.6182535290718079,
-0.24569086730480194,
-0.09176318347454071,
-0.2527121305465698,
0.8970369100570679,
0.795592188835144,
-0.45118433237075806,
-0.6343663334846497,
0.27130448818206787,
-0.07746442407369614,
-0.3471001386642456,
-0.3140189051628113,
0.15834426879882812,
-0.2742415964603424,
-0.552055835723877,
0.17141485214233398,
0.28711798787117004,
-0.1152576357126236,
-0.9135900139808655,
-0.0671321228146553,
0.1383761465549469,
0.3059200942516327,
0.7159133553504944,
0.10503579676151276,
-0.9749560952186584,
-0.40234071016311646,
0.11680900305509567,
-0.19439992308616638,
-0.24687474966049194,
0.8074303865432739,
-0.4855325222015381,
-0.17677758634090424,
0.4212336540222168,
0.7304118871688843,
0.021663112565875053,
-0.26480740308761597,
0.6622788906097412,
-0.7290405631065369,
0.12425053119659424,
0.183143749833107,
0.4513665437698364,
0.22579802572727203,
-0.3889221251010895,
0.5558561086654663,
-0.11113576591014862,
-0.5898680090904236,
-1.014286994934082,
0.07002466171979904,
-0.854689359664917,
-0.1250857412815094,
0.9339186549186707,
-0.13900786638259888,
-0.09171442687511444,
0.11597383767366409,
0.195717915892601,
-0.12724144756793976,
-0.16495083272457123,
0.8996345400810242,
0.955630898475647,
-0.5892731547355652,
-0.38655591011047363,
-0.3314878046512604,
0.3014668822288513,
0.3918759524822235,
-0.8982726335525513,
0.2940328121185303,
0.44563621282577515,
0.19527220726013184,
0.3146107792854309,
0.6462444067001343,
0.08636678010225296,
0.05023563653230667,
-0.08329056203365326,
0.16419263184070587,
0.2048107385635376,
-0.20127199590206146,
-0.18104024231433868,
0.024777179583907127,
0.3260680139064789,
0.06718084216117859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17667v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17667v1 | This Paper Had the Smartest Reviewers -- Flattery Detection Utilising an Audio-Textual Transformer-Based Approach | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | 2024-06-25T15:57:02 | Lukas Christ, Shahin Amiriparian, Friederike Hawighorst, Ann-Kathrin Schill, Angelo Boutalikakis, Lorenz Graf-Vlachy, Andreas König, Björn W. Schuller | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Flattery is an important aspect of human communication that facilitates
social bonding, shapes perceptions, and influences behavior through strategic
compliments and praise, leveraging the power of speech to build rapport
effectively. Its automatic detection can thus enhance the naturalness of
human-AI interactions. To meet this need, we present a novel audio textual
dataset comprising 20 hours of speech and train machine learning models for
automatic flattery detection. In particular, we employ pretrained AST,
Wav2Vec2, and Whisper models for the speech modality, and Whisper TTS models
combined with a RoBERTa text classifier for the textual modality. Subsequently,
we build a multimodal classifier by combining text and audio representations.
Evaluation on unseen test data demonstrates promising results, with Unweighted
Average Recall scores reaching 82.46% in audio-only experiments, 85.97% in
text-only experiments, and 87.16% using a multimodal approach. | [
-0.46783214807510376,
-0.5269864201545715,
0.49676385521888733,
0.48488181829452515,
-0.28009429574012756,
-0.04864063486456871,
-0.3892512619495392,
-0.3641071915626526,
0.40826770663261414,
0.2952047884464264,
-0.49441611766815186,
-0.6308386325836182,
-0.6309465169906616,
0.25261738896369934,
-0.7381823658943176,
1.021931529045105,
0.4813109040260315,
0.08885806798934937,
-0.13253749907016754,
-0.1299733817577362,
-0.373012512922287,
-0.5187260508537292,
-0.3502471148967743,
-0.5498893857002258,
0.23859462141990662,
0.5206781029701233,
0.4655911922454834,
0.44722118973731995,
0.20921632647514343,
0.331562876701355,
0.08411777764558792,
0.09133870899677277,
-0.2868366539478302,
0.33532392978668213,
0.1948617845773697,
-0.4970618188381195,
-0.6252776384353638,
0.32234352827072144,
0.2918827533721924,
0.017021408304572105,
0.03388059884309769,
0.047711264342069626,
0.07154309004545212,
0.6544966101646423,
-0.30760544538497925,
0.5746572017669678,
-0.9912849068641663,
0.05696629732847214,
-0.3394237160682678,
-0.5941047668457031,
-0.3293459415435791,
-0.25951796770095825,
-0.08008427917957306,
-0.4302903115749359,
0.4613964259624481,
-0.09697379916906357,
0.6627932190895081,
0.2694457769393921,
-0.2781359553337097,
-0.38867542147636414,
-0.5732172131538391,
0.9218785166740417,
-0.5434010624885559,
0.3657867908477783,
0.42652812600135803,
0.21299591660499573,
0.21449938416481018,
-0.5804657340049744,
-0.9557679891586304,
-0.2754831612110138,
0.07782375812530518,
0.3307688534259796,
-0.3381281793117523,
-0.12105964124202728,
-0.32361236214637756,
0.534701406955719,
-0.47026973962783813,
-0.02499028854072094,
0.07780329138040543,
-0.19984334707260132,
0.5648291110992432,
-0.07234422862529755,
0.22715073823928833,
-0.6281681656837463,
-0.2970377504825592,
-0.3105126917362213,
-0.0051725925877690315,
0.06842236965894699,
0.45956340432167053,
0.4965570569038391,
-0.1843954622745514,
0.3703611195087433,
-0.18818295001983643,
0.06242218613624573,
0.1232745349407196,
0.1641770452260971,
0.4341128170490265,
-0.5799494981765747,
0.11396924406290054,
0.21497663855552673,
0.9414379596710205,
0.5513274073600769,
0.6641457676887512,
-0.1682748943567276,
-0.3109704554080963,
0.5413945913314819,
0.15102329850196838,
-0.5586208701133728,
-0.43516263365745544,
0.15715910494327545,
-0.45839616656303406,
-0.6292192935943604,
0.15529072284698486,
-0.8379026651382446,
-0.3920353949069977,
-0.24537970125675201,
0.4063236713409424,
-0.36832600831985474,
-0.06736289709806442,
0.11071451008319855,
-0.3370225429534912,
0.04254358261823654,
0.022303089499473572,
-0.9628397226333618,
0.029412873089313507,
0.6916535496711731,
0.6617225408554077,
-0.15351848304271698,
-0.10366494953632355,
-0.5467941164970398,
-0.016443418338894844,
0.02056526578962803,
1.233569860458374,
-0.5045784115791321,
-0.4861043393611908,
-0.23978348076343536,
-0.11060883849859238,
0.03803173080086708,
-0.4235643744468689,
1.0719387531280518,
0.04482300207018852,
0.6669846773147583,
0.28993451595306396,
-0.42098695039749146,
0.03223405033349991,
0.32995960116386414,
-0.7473490238189697,
1.02031672000885,
-0.4266223609447479,
-0.6584575772285461,
0.4194454252719879,
-0.7604802846908569,
-0.5032042264938354,
0.1536676585674286,
-0.16007429361343384,
-0.7774761915206909,
-0.0330229178071022,
0.7689288854598999,
0.7560356259346008,
0.044371090829372406,
0.2331608086824417,
-0.15162351727485657,
-0.5477266311645508,
0.3232721984386444,
-0.8244169354438782,
0.32048964500427246,
-0.018495425581932068,
-0.6438550353050232,
0.09689552336931229,
-0.6502755880355835,
0.05556819587945938,
0.07009539753198624,
-0.2597549259662628,
-0.4265415370464325,
-0.3239481747150421,
0.6272438168525696,
-0.08262794464826584,
0.2361261546611786,
-0.7872810363769531,
0.20118291676044464,
-0.3715381920337677,
0.4121257960796356,
0.699406623840332,
-0.39424556493759155,
0.2896442413330078,
-0.5459613800048828,
0.17111468315124512,
-0.18842563033103943,
0.2269626408815384,
-0.460105299949646,
-0.6277968883514404,
-0.37648117542266846,
-0.6701905131340027,
0.18887712061405182,
0.4366443455219269,
-0.4730711579322815,
0.9002938270568848,
-0.41300421953201294,
-0.5338813066482544,
-0.8399604558944702,
-0.1054459884762764,
0.37798649072647095,
0.14626041054725647,
0.4112461805343628,
-0.30014103651046753,
-0.5209010243415833,
-0.7244319319725037,
-0.7510681748390198,
-0.3660573363304138,
-0.2722656726837158,
0.2684614658355713,
0.3530494272708893,
-0.29472821950912476,
1.001564621925354,
-0.22293734550476074,
-1.012160062789917,
-0.06198635324835777,
0.558264970779419,
0.04304184019565582,
0.32344430685043335,
0.5783549547195435,
-1.1242141723632812,
-0.4950467646121979,
-0.12493661791086197,
-0.691293478012085,
-0.13499970734119415,
0.22805048525333405,
0.6890375018119812,
0.14345243573188782,
0.43292495608329773,
-0.6187986731529236,
0.5606109499931335,
0.369581401348114,
-0.3234264552593231,
0.587617814540863,
0.017061173915863037,
0.6313182711601257,
-1.1315245628356934,
0.04898318275809288,
0.08109857887029648,
-0.3199005424976349,
-0.5108338594436646,
-0.5310263633728027,
-0.21629296243190765,
0.02665107324719429,
-0.14452867209911346,
0.720862865447998,
-0.061241574585437775,
0.12886792421340942,
-0.09309787303209305,
0.22011138498783112,
0.2576988935470581,
0.476163774728775,
-0.17115966975688934,
0.6582035422325134,
0.22434014081954956,
-0.24792946875095367,
0.5631090998649597,
0.500299334526062,
-0.17735974490642548,
0.9173023104667664,
-0.5791105628013611,
0.29807886481285095,
-0.1603647768497467,
0.36014464497566223,
-1.4918681383132935,
-0.27574852108955383,
-0.2716490924358368,
-1.1307144165039062,
0.07834265381097794,
0.08709438890218735,
-0.5917366743087769,
-0.28390800952911377,
-0.7849318981170654,
-0.03909942880272865,
0.15641555190086365,
-0.6635529398918152,
0.8451039791107178,
0.22504469752311707,
-0.34257134795188904,
-0.3978629410266876,
-0.6932457089424133,
0.3506626486778259,
-0.20705246925354004,
-0.38337671756744385,
0.406840980052948,
-0.193380206823349,
0.12130171805620193,
-0.3085123896598816,
-0.031046058982610703,
0.03294631838798523,
-0.10664194822311401,
0.4519908130168915,
0.08786740899085999,
0.004191470332443714,
0.027273282408714294,
-0.19950899481773376,
-0.2109781801700592,
0.00039506496977992356,
-0.15293140709400177,
0.5811364650726318,
-0.47739991545677185,
-0.14190877974033356,
-1.1055859327316284,
0.22215081751346588,
1.0406497716903687,
0.03399043530225754,
0.10771358758211136,
1.0385178327560425,
0.0002588268253020942,
0.13084512948989868,
-0.779718816280365,
-0.6366360783576965,
-0.5035526156425476,
0.5876340270042419,
-0.11221688240766525,
-0.48966896533966064,
0.26446419954299927,
0.16613665223121643,
-0.010489033535122871,
0.17755280435085297,
0.5033125281333923,
-0.33865365386009216,
1.5220224857330322,
1.0261955261230469,
-0.4197165369987488,
0.6920964121818542,
-0.05652058124542236,
0.08203472942113876,
-0.48904022574424744,
-0.3646464943885803,
-0.8472367525100708,
-0.23991085588932037,
-0.6777552962303162,
0.02457302063703537,
0.405098021030426,
-0.37870368361473083,
0.0475120022892952,
0.33917877078056335,
-0.7810397148132324,
0.24378161132335663,
0.4052811563014984,
0.0827079638838768,
0.7855049967765808,
0.42043444514274597,
-0.027385380119085312,
-0.23773938417434692,
-0.24613426625728607,
-0.6045965552330017,
1.1082735061645508,
0.3105772137641907,
0.6984252333641052,
0.030239269137382507,
0.5565506815910339,
0.883619487285614,
0.48545098304748535,
-1.2372814416885376,
0.6060181260108948,
-0.496675968170166,
-0.36624473333358765,
-0.26627877354621887,
-0.44150975346565247,
-1.0232865810394287,
-0.26713457703590393,
-0.39821773767471313,
-0.58574378490448,
-0.14432670176029205,
0.14776095747947693,
0.03749437630176544,
0.3569362163543701,
-0.6958438158035278,
0.5704894661903381,
-0.06159479543566704,
0.078542061150074,
0.0017360562924295664,
-0.5811730027198792,
0.11835452914237976,
0.06562842428684235,
0.39367565512657166,
0.0884837657213211,
0.311367928981781,
0.9362674355506897,
0.2084406465291977,
0.5618352293968201,
0.05121608078479767,
0.10254087299108505,
-0.18905708193778992,
-0.10862594097852707,
0.15477459132671356,
0.009158114902675152,
-0.20598028600215912,
0.24477329850196838,
-0.019322913140058517,
-0.3321460485458374,
-0.6680502891540527,
0.5585567355155945,
-0.7115423083305359,
-0.09103994816541672,
-0.22991733253002167,
-0.6984879374504089,
-0.40088918805122375,
0.22248989343643188,
0.3142947852611542,
0.5428720116615295,
-0.2579761743545532,
0.4156145453453064,
0.5064950585365295,
0.2334769070148468,
0.5648198127746582,
0.37962040305137634,
-0.12273599207401276,
-0.4776589870452881,
1.0576238632202148,
-0.41487911343574524,
-0.10723455250263214,
0.37018585205078125,
0.5465906858444214,
-0.5274860262870789,
-0.21618139743804932,
-0.3258388638496399,
0.15563376247882843,
-0.5321179628372192,
-0.08081100136041641,
-0.9124343395233154,
0.05608375370502472,
-0.610008716583252,
-0.016540145501494408,
-0.5923539400100708,
-0.4269128143787384,
-0.17170430719852448,
0.1329793930053711,
0.5105240345001221,
0.7945465445518494,
0.072818323969841,
0.35163435339927673,
-0.7473499178886414,
0.39445433020591736,
0.47308528423309326,
0.22239860892295837,
-0.07215803861618042,
-0.44641920924186707,
0.14975762367248535,
0.0032426188699901104,
-0.5377167463302612,
-0.4993452727794647,
0.588571310043335,
0.34446969628334045,
0.38294729590415955,
0.39007505774497986,
0.05418369919061661,
0.23890487849712372,
-0.007747667375952005,
0.8453711867332458,
0.43673962354660034,
-0.8563823699951172,
0.37275558710098267,
-0.4063752591609955,
0.31259292364120483,
0.6371764540672302,
0.3502826392650604,
-0.33789369463920593,
-0.47900182008743286,
-0.6302834153175354,
-0.853412389755249,
0.37145715951919556,
0.45921528339385986,
0.26824814081192017,
0.1840491145849228,
0.16776122152805328,
0.11398819088935852,
0.5540928244590759,
-0.7897564172744751,
-0.32588258385658264,
-0.580022931098938,
-0.6638283729553223,
-0.06797710061073303,
0.1602509468793869,
0.10211213678121567,
-0.2690282166004181,
0.634751558303833,
-0.32457056641578674,
0.5803510546684265,
0.08518712967634201,
0.18693186342716217,
0.09641104191541672,
0.6700529456138611,
0.38338735699653625,
-0.1076393872499466,
-0.5654167532920837,
0.20206786692142487,
-0.22999799251556396,
-1.052018404006958,
-0.019126664847135544,
0.3639877736568451,
0.1433483511209488,
0.31274059414863586,
0.2924112379550934,
0.46297168731689453,
0.06031712144613266,
-0.4272056818008423,
0.7304508686065674,
-0.4909833073616028,
-0.04167590290307999,
-0.008082377724349499,
-0.27904683351516724,
-0.019755851477384567,
0.10601742565631866,
0.7887362837791443,
0.3943590223789215,
0.2597518563270569,
-1.0314584970474243,
0.664233922958374,
0.6581727862358093,
-1.0659291744232178,
-0.39551761746406555,
0.5754175782203674,
0.3751724064350128,
-0.5038031339645386,
0.15205489099025726,
-0.08301994204521179,
-0.9645490050315857,
0.45107734203338623,
0.1787720024585724,
0.8204459547996521,
-0.33980050683021545,
0.09407481551170349,
-0.3014301359653473,
0.04912795498967171,
0.09983934462070465,
0.2308826893568039,
-0.3996054232120514,
-0.6564146280288696,
0.03531571477651596,
-0.49069973826408386,
-0.46299368143081665,
0.32055583596229553,
-0.7081756591796875,
0.4804925322532654,
-0.1943698674440384,
-0.48140349984169006,
0.47174131870269775,
0.03569537401199341,
-0.5357587337493896,
0.14037536084651947,
0.2063319981098175,
0.33301058411598206,
-0.9363817572593689,
0.5827515125274658,
0.7502757906913757,
-0.26674824953079224,
-0.6321002840995789,
0.4708912968635559,
0.165114164352417,
-0.6690140962600708,
0.5424829125404358,
0.6012203097343445,
-0.5461559295654297,
0.14134913682937622,
-0.6883158087730408,
0.08108901977539062,
0.7801355719566345,
0.20932085812091827,
-0.2534676492214203,
-0.04575695842504501,
-0.05023372173309326,
0.5391925573348999,
-0.23730313777923584,
0.7127475142478943,
0.5069714784622192,
0.5976811647415161,
0.02669057436287403,
-1.3802299499511719,
-0.31146079301834106,
-0.38517647981643677,
-0.4061909317970276,
-0.11238405108451843,
-0.6646665930747986,
0.8923518061637878,
-0.009253451600670815,
-0.0855642557144165,
0.36235105991363525,
0.6665990948677063,
0.3175649046897888,
0.838608980178833,
0.6478684544563293,
0.10042212158441544,
0.5131377577781677,
-0.18826675415039062,
0.7651541829109192,
-0.08770483732223511,
0.4063645303249359,
0.7058022618293762,
-0.09633772075176239,
0.7343797087669373,
0.44149914383888245,
0.16091881692409515,
0.7010340690612793,
0.0015452051302418113,
-0.04141690954566002,
0.4830312132835388,
-0.1285061091184616,
-0.22082100808620453,
-0.08298973739147186,
-0.5127145051956177,
-0.1343195140361786,
0.9220209121704102,
0.2092709094285965,
-0.2676435708999634,
-0.18823979794979095,
0.33854982256889343,
0.23941592872142792,
0.5469845533370972,
-0.23001126945018768,
0.8018923997879028,
0.05875227972865105,
-0.5246010422706604,
0.5054879188537598,
-0.0981137603521347,
1.4388716220855713,
-0.5076850056648254,
-0.09910465776920319,
-0.17120978236198425,
0.4701540172100067,
-0.43036696314811707,
-0.766900360584259,
-0.06621809303760529,
-0.10393853485584259,
-0.4000380039215088,
-0.3565885126590729,
0.5157632827758789,
-0.45704907178878784,
-0.20792502164840698,
0.42965075373649597,
0.3649204671382904,
0.19066260755062103,
-0.40541425347328186,
-0.7585819959640503,
0.058041416108608246,
-0.1599719524383545,
-0.2696252465248108,
0.16492219269275665,
0.5926425457000732,
-0.07254005968570709,
0.6453264355659485,
0.7111274600028992,
0.04760735109448433,
-0.2822241485118866,
0.36093246936798096,
0.8280694484710693,
-0.6277528405189514,
-0.7726059556007385,
-0.7336552739143372,
0.15374262630939484,
-0.2760228216648102,
-0.18399672210216522,
0.9454377889633179,
0.42483752965927124,
0.3940506875514984,
-0.03541664779186249,
0.8202232718467712,
0.2649555504322052,
0.4474409222602844,
-0.3346770703792572,
1.0527080297470093,
-0.559022843837738,
0.2829912304878235,
-0.7439696192741394,
-0.6855884790420532,
-0.318490594625473,
0.5853188633918762,
-0.08207032084465027,
0.2887622117996216,
0.6862288117408752,
0.8261974453926086,
-0.15598943829536438,
0.6098395586013794,
0.30775684118270874,
0.21378788352012634,
0.48894673585891724,
0.26594993472099304,
0.5849734544754028,
-0.7041470408439636,
0.857577919960022,
0.07544784247875214,
-0.41791996359825134,
-0.3736594617366791,
-0.9508751034736633,
-1.115013599395752,
-0.7603253126144409,
-0.22668904066085815,
-0.44084104895591736,
-0.07137849181890488,
0.8394872546195984,
0.7701516151428223,
-0.8016248345375061,
-0.1559089720249176,
0.2547058165073395,
-0.04268157482147217,
-0.4134369492530823,
-0.3795854449272156,
0.3576010763645172,
0.057608041912317276,
-0.8266951441764832,
0.540764570236206,
0.36305496096611023,
-0.09496096521615982,
-0.33563435077667236,
0.2370273321866989,
-0.3189643323421478,
0.18870292603969574,
0.5634884238243103,
0.05456060916185379,
-0.5463327169418335,
-0.1962016075849533,
0.0923856869339943,
-0.15800794959068298,
0.05961786210536957,
0.8652834892272949,
-0.9104868173599243,
0.44612932205200195,
0.400073766708374,
0.3460898697376251,
0.4577038586139679,
0.1619560271501541,
0.2943328022956848,
-1.02347993850708,
0.18402691185474396,
0.3707423508167267,
0.04977663978934288,
0.8612813949584961,
-0.4969058930873871,
-0.020380783826112747,
0.5774387121200562,
-0.6097300052642822,
-0.8738364577293396,
-0.027598846703767776,
-1.2446532249450684,
0.03955050930380821,
0.8041241765022278,
0.3116062879562378,
-0.19510304927825928,
-0.668004035949707,
-0.296885222196579,
0.39530718326568604,
-0.8840042948722839,
1.2540571689605713,
0.3737976849079132,
-0.1972634345293045,
0.25170034170150757,
-0.4187854528427124,
0.5797431468963623,
0.6838705539703369,
-0.734424352645874,
0.08966138958930969,
-0.019666973501443863,
0.3233925700187683,
0.5335351228713989,
0.596598744392395,
-0.2568015158176422,
0.24807797372341156,
-0.4512985944747925,
0.29805371165275574,
-0.33797603845596313,
-0.4066700339317322,
-0.27200108766555786,
0.28844213485717773,
-0.4284997284412384,
-0.17983531951904297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17663v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17663v1 | LLM-ARC: Enhancing LLMs with an Automated Reasoning Critic | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | 2024-06-25T15:52:15 | Aditya Kalyanpur, Kailash Saravanakumar, Victor Barres, Jennifer Chu-Carroll, David Melville, David Ferrucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | We introduce LLM-ARC, a neuro-symbolic framework designed to enhance the
logical reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs), by combining
them with an Automated Reasoning Critic (ARC). LLM-ARC employs an Actor-Critic
method where the LLM Actor generates declarative logic programs along with
tests for semantic correctness, while the Automated Reasoning Critic evaluates
the code, runs the tests and provides feedback on test failures for iterative
refinement. Implemented using Answer Set Programming (ASP), LLM-ARC achieves a
new state-of-the-art accuracy of 88.32% on the FOLIO benchmark which tests
complex logical reasoning capabilities. Our experiments demonstrate significant
improvements over LLM-only baselines, highlighting the importance of logic test
generation and iterative self-refinement. We achieve our best result using a
fully automated self-supervised training loop where the Actor is trained on
end-to-end dialog traces with Critic feedback. We discuss potential
enhancements and provide a detailed error analysis, showcasing the robustness
and efficacy of LLM-ARC for complex natural language reasoning tasks. | [
-0.48032769560813904,
-0.8823192119598389,
0.5776574015617371,
0.11456596106290817,
0.15432673692703247,
0.3907259702682495,
-0.4034424424171448,
-0.47361791133880615,
0.2708366811275482,
0.6974871754646301,
-0.6081260442733765,
-0.4412282407283783,
-0.37613609433174133,
0.43840327858924866,
-0.4177359640598297,
0.671623706817627,
-0.13238294422626495,
0.2219109982252121,
-0.38480567932128906,
-0.12883085012435913,
-0.16649089753627777,
-0.5046341419219971,
-0.8337165117263794,
-0.6112734079360962,
0.42125368118286133,
0.4024268388748169,
0.43160581588745117,
0.3803522288799286,
0.664050817489624,
0.3907143175601959,
0.2194114625453949,
0.40275833010673523,
-0.05012470483779907,
0.28412216901779175,
-0.4921106696128845,
-0.46947193145751953,
-0.6116986274719238,
-0.20104873180389404,
0.4200780391693115,
0.5853636860847473,
-0.17472003400325775,
0.04123669117689133,
-0.2597885727882385,
0.716353714466095,
-0.6626261472702026,
0.35942548513412476,
-0.5647987127304077,
-0.03437008336186409,
0.34088945388793945,
-0.18271569907665253,
-0.539921760559082,
-0.402397096157074,
-0.0452994629740715,
-0.7136300802230835,
-0.23446612060070038,
0.348339706659317,
0.6784597039222717,
0.8515496253967285,
-0.45531561970710754,
-0.20998378098011017,
-0.7394734621047974,
0.5917519927024841,
-0.8127204179763794,
0.0481022484600544,
0.26111656427383423,
0.4984389841556549,
-0.17862647771835327,
-0.7207887768745422,
-0.8215166330337524,
-0.7188234329223633,
0.007721554487943649,
0.060919929295778275,
-0.515676736831665,
0.5154970288276672,
0.47046399116516113,
0.30712977051734924,
-0.2556321918964386,
0.2320128232240677,
0.03137529641389847,
-0.2711293399333954,
0.8168806433677673,
0.2898797392845154,
0.2583268880844116,
-0.055760182440280914,
-0.17615105211734772,
0.029199378564953804,
-0.5831345319747925,
-0.11757904291152954,
0.39591184258461,
-0.12375099956989288,
0.41487622261047363,
0.771601676940918,
-0.4860077500343323,
0.571342408657074,
-0.019618738442659378,
0.11644411087036133,
0.1577749252319336,
-0.14478875696659088,
-0.16444388031959534,
0.1836145967245102,
0.8144136667251587,
0.3747164011001587,
0.7721120119094849,
0.14709343016147614,
-0.42894428968429565,
0.48761123418807983,
0.3760932981967926,
-0.5733770728111267,
-0.3306117057800293,
0.11789575219154358,
-0.005534149240702391,
-0.4291764199733734,
-0.09649074077606201,
-0.3415762186050415,
-0.5954040884971619,
-0.7433093190193176,
0.34775853157043457,
-0.5830325484275818,
-0.23403936624526978,
0.38869842886924744,
0.03459667041897774,
0.3180440366268158,
0.6092130541801453,
-0.6181623339653015,
0.608542799949646,
0.7103039622306824,
0.17199072241783142,
-0.24798595905303955,
-0.4068320393562317,
-0.591921865940094,
0.06746520102024078,
-0.44577860832214355,
1.2606719732284546,
-0.6452910900115967,
0.24277980625629425,
-0.21156620979309082,
-0.26027169823646545,
-0.043283671140670776,
-0.7135270833969116,
0.5334884524345398,
-0.3244068920612335,
0.03746325895190239,
-0.08396938443183899,
-0.6984319090843201,
-0.40310415625572205,
0.7485431432723999,
-0.5516290664672852,
1.1121318340301514,
0.04685019701719284,
-0.533085823059082,
0.059638023376464844,
-0.7420040965080261,
-0.4456489384174347,
-0.1673291027545929,
-0.35086217522621155,
-0.07618018239736557,
0.034704457968473434,
0.5620089769363403,
0.20614300668239594,
-0.508226752281189,
0.26176461577415466,
-0.4307751953601837,
-0.34650641679763794,
0.30947867035865784,
-0.37461820244789124,
0.4945094883441925,
-0.03678083047270775,
-0.48403704166412354,
0.5312944650650024,
-0.7910088300704956,
0.15883782505989075,
0.020917341113090515,
-0.08481588214635849,
0.13154393434524536,
0.1351631134748459,
-0.38361820578575134,
0.1755061149597168,
-0.011546889320015907,
-0.42589035630226135,
0.22997310757637024,
-0.6516032814979553,
0.3707038462162018,
0.915210485458374,
0.079034224152565,
0.38803568482398987,
-0.4037330150604248,
0.6508692502975464,
-0.11147841066122055,
-0.012625397183001041,
-0.13539573550224304,
-0.1909409463405609,
-1.307215929031372,
-0.2408362329006195,
0.15050078928470612,
0.7657061815261841,
-0.8941224217414856,
0.7737170457839966,
0.005709983874112368,
-0.32008787989616394,
-0.4887864589691162,
0.17381615936756134,
0.22006936371326447,
0.665261447429657,
0.31961581110954285,
-0.2932114899158478,
-0.6669523119926453,
-0.8869442939758301,
-0.23378215730190277,
-0.6632375121116638,
0.12737537920475006,
0.18206210434436798,
0.5591927766799927,
-0.46540921926498413,
0.9883973002433777,
-0.3298830986022949,
-0.22206953167915344,
-0.5637786984443665,
-0.0968022570014,
0.006783293094485998,
0.248843252658844,
0.08399629592895508,
-0.07504265755414963,
-0.24546876549720764,
-0.007617644499987364,
-0.9486730694770813,
-0.4374068081378937,
-0.1287500113248825,
-0.00496329553425312,
0.5377246737480164,
0.5938248634338379,
-0.624018132686615,
0.3966273069381714,
0.23254850506782532,
-0.47313207387924194,
0.989274263381958,
-0.15520066022872925,
0.07630650699138641,
-0.8123237490653992,
-0.08567095547914505,
-0.0630478486418724,
-0.259721577167511,
-0.37717142701148987,
0.06233407184481621,
-0.2588202655315399,
0.06436215341091156,
-0.26214322447776794,
0.5885623693466187,
-0.30077821016311646,
-0.18288271129131317,
-0.4492829442024231,
0.36736711859703064,
0.08948705345392227,
0.6727182865142822,
0.02938951924443245,
0.5464847683906555,
0.7565944194793701,
-0.4922782778739929,
0.9181164503097534,
-0.018129220232367516,
-0.332052081823349,
0.7511645555496216,
-0.605178713798523,
0.13865149021148682,
-0.14146669209003448,
0.449738085269928,
-0.7045294642448425,
-0.13925284147262573,
0.3501920998096466,
-0.3123609125614166,
0.047133591026067734,
0.28463155031204224,
-0.6955623030662537,
-0.39788636565208435,
-0.265244722366333,
0.028975894674658775,
0.29573965072631836,
-0.5054810047149658,
1.049354910850525,
0.15819892287254333,
-0.0030417402740567923,
-0.6591945886611938,
-0.5278066992759705,
0.26304200291633606,
0.02263759821653366,
-0.743546724319458,
-0.07173638045787811,
-0.16995592415332794,
-0.7845324277877808,
-0.09698817133903503,
-0.23576906323432922,
0.057415980845689774,
0.13964679837226868,
0.11391845345497131,
0.21354909241199493,
-0.33672896027565,
0.28799569606781006,
0.007776409853249788,
-0.39744237065315247,
0.4582366347312927,
-0.2914135754108429,
0.4859643280506134,
-0.66311115026474,
-0.7642917037010193,
-0.645072877407074,
0.13808882236480713,
0.35437336564064026,
-0.3293409049510956,
0.13258548080921173,
0.3880438208580017,
-0.315142959356308,
-0.5725832581520081,
-0.7943512201309204,
-0.4767813980579376,
-0.46608805656433105,
0.31267133355140686,
-0.29489579796791077,
-0.8401282429695129,
0.46789997816085815,
-0.22606566548347473,
-0.08003713935613632,
0.49191945791244507,
0.4897277355194092,
-0.23482833802700043,
1.0022703409194946,
0.3655746579170227,
-0.12608525156974792,
0.24109026789665222,
-0.35473960638046265,
0.1641261875629425,
-0.7780485153198242,
-0.17433065176010132,
-0.3226022720336914,
-0.3069108724594116,
-0.18056176602840424,
-0.3825705051422119,
0.03445930406451225,
0.015834461897611618,
-0.5857455134391785,
0.1859831064939499,
-0.48287275433540344,
0.6728228330612183,
0.3842719495296478,
-0.0813879743218422,
0.6676901578903198,
-0.2083835005760193,
-0.22811350226402283,
0.06798574328422546,
-0.558714747428894,
-0.6109226942062378,
0.8767252564430237,
0.43180733919143677,
1.0529414415359497,
0.005992163438349962,
0.43389689922332764,
0.2660645544528961,
0.4657273590564728,
-0.9965924620628357,
0.8895254731178284,
0.24984538555145264,
-0.40503278374671936,
-0.16216310858726501,
-0.42346838116645813,
-0.36762404441833496,
0.2101854383945465,
-0.20818978548049927,
-0.6349979639053345,
-0.14987047016620636,
0.24761463701725006,
-0.29300543665885925,
0.31126198172569275,
-0.6781526803970337,
0.7349066734313965,
-0.4846121370792389,
-0.050042688846588135,
-0.4751662015914917,
-0.5233533382415771,
0.30198225378990173,
0.15826673805713654,
-0.2408846914768219,
-0.3172987103462219,
-0.15811659395694733,
0.38095784187316895,
-0.4210484027862549,
0.8623763918876648,
0.09026593714952469,
-0.028094373643398285,
0.42869535088539124,
0.29470816254615784,
0.6093400120735168,
0.22775588929653168,
-0.12351641803979874,
-0.07904292643070221,
-0.2716642916202545,
-0.047495462000370026,
-1.0649241209030151,
0.5442290306091309,
-0.6608198881149292,
-0.9052193760871887,
-0.6333153247833252,
-0.6184092164039612,
-0.3531861901283264,
0.07361233234405518,
-0.21613480150699615,
0.45404183864593506,
-0.01663445308804512,
0.0355195589363575,
0.7645680904388428,
-0.2329058051109314,
0.3496401607990265,
0.5414126515388489,
-0.3599945604801178,
-0.5686361193656921,
0.6122338771820068,
-0.34942686557769775,
0.3837215006351471,
0.3275776207447052,
0.17296385765075684,
-0.2878974974155426,
-0.403817355632782,
-0.36445069313049316,
0.2973133325576782,
-0.9740584492683411,
-0.27480772137641907,
-0.6614585518836975,
-0.435463547706604,
-0.22256684303283691,
-0.06799609959125519,
-0.415856271982193,
-0.6754504442214966,
-0.11916840821504593,
-0.3098600506782532,
0.3969659209251404,
0.7098376750946045,
0.13736377656459808,
0.16197805106639862,
-0.22773313522338867,
0.23373110592365265,
0.2834011912345886,
0.28632429242134094,
-0.15860748291015625,
-0.5016157627105713,
0.11250194162130356,
-0.2777091860771179,
-0.35053834319114685,
-0.549041748046875,
0.1951724737882614,
0.2696867883205414,
0.5583542585372925,
0.38645127415657043,
0.2088886797428131,
0.526091456413269,
-0.41163554787635803,
0.5378866791725159,
0.13774290680885315,
-0.9500458836555481,
0.6921622157096863,
-0.2046133279800415,
0.4055458605289459,
0.726012110710144,
-0.08489980548620224,
-0.3666684627532959,
-0.7451633214950562,
-0.562421977519989,
-0.53257817029953,
0.5560541749000549,
0.1002516895532608,
-0.06668531894683838,
0.0001510956062702462,
0.24976018071174622,
-0.17221997678279877,
0.06756006926298141,
-0.805219292640686,
-0.07453103363513947,
-0.041761305183172226,
-0.3112829029560089,
0.021592840552330017,
0.006097173318266869,
-0.23179642856121063,
-0.5089026093482971,
0.7861266732215881,
-0.6511659622192383,
0.11395977437496185,
0.3546591103076935,
-0.25964197516441345,
0.013034984469413757,
0.1683809757232666,
0.4796835780143738,
0.6857303380966187,
-0.0007068937411531806,
0.3098306953907013,
0.5476683974266052,
-0.13344576954841614,
0.10957466810941696,
0.12768489122390747,
0.10354822874069214,
-0.1607939600944519,
0.5322085022926331,
0.8011367917060852,
0.015407818369567394,
-1.0430444478988647,
0.4057477116584778,
-0.1771301031112671,
-0.30924397706985474,
-0.6990247368812561,
0.3528707027435303,
0.028796501457691193,
0.44061797857284546,
0.10662274807691574,
0.20243053138256073,
0.024538086727261543,
-0.4871419072151184,
0.46701425313949585,
0.3135208189487457,
-0.37399882078170776,
-0.032479770481586456,
0.4700949192047119,
0.2628951072692871,
-0.337608277797699,
0.8287861943244934,
-0.1237974762916565,
-0.6736129522323608,
0.7188074588775635,
0.5752217173576355,
1.0417745113372803,
0.002195384120568633,
0.17048293352127075,
0.287739098072052,
0.4948151111602783,
-0.05677536129951477,
0.23324617743492126,
-0.15358899533748627,
-0.8929950594902039,
-0.8148495554924011,
-0.4479999244213104,
-0.7229410409927368,
-0.3722652196884155,
-0.287895530462265,
0.38012075424194336,
-0.7167454957962036,
-0.005233250092715025,
-0.2402520626783371,
0.1357206553220749,
-0.20419852435588837,
0.11026126146316528,
0.16668076813220978,
1.1770926713943481,
-0.4482574462890625,
0.9311469793319702,
0.644725501537323,
-0.44246622920036316,
-0.9595317840576172,
-0.08517501503229141,
-0.007996169850230217,
-0.7181651592254639,
0.6359113454818726,
0.37790536880493164,
-0.4117961823940277,
0.015669090673327446,
-0.46965593099594116,
-0.709507167339325,
1.0630327463150024,
0.7142224907875061,
-0.46978703141212463,
0.07876621186733246,
0.09520860761404037,
0.807273268699646,
-0.6133254766464233,
0.6344131827354431,
0.7702922224998474,
0.49554920196533203,
0.25448721647262573,
-0.6931941509246826,
0.05331158638000488,
-0.42143288254737854,
-0.1799321174621582,
0.09166323393583298,
-0.4140142798423767,
0.3292812407016754,
-0.421960711479187,
0.09560433775186539,
-0.060276541858911514,
0.8563032150268555,
0.5705041289329529,
0.21903671324253082,
0.6624959111213684,
0.8846194744110107,
0.7462487816810608,
-0.26344069838523865,
1.2316519021987915,
-0.40052783489227295,
0.07720281928777695,
1.2085294723510742,
-0.5026383996009827,
0.7545982003211975,
0.5114485025405884,
0.18090572953224182,
0.8917015790939331,
0.45252180099487305,
-0.009955043904483318,
-0.011996250599622726,
0.5618337988853455,
-0.42812421917915344,
-0.4848618805408478,
-0.19956588745117188,
0.03586694225668907,
0.31687411665916443,
0.2918878495693207,
-0.20042583346366882,
-0.11014527082443237,
-0.17827770113945007,
-0.02491145394742489,
0.33680760860443115,
-0.33708393573760986,
0.8452519774436951,
0.33845987915992737,
-0.9210999608039856,
0.4065227508544922,
-0.13570640981197357,
0.5286972522735596,
-0.5306306481361389,
0.008407306857407093,
-0.2801417112350464,
0.5206071734428406,
-0.3888879120349884,
-0.7926438450813293,
0.5688424706459045,
0.061879511922597885,
0.14530254900455475,
-0.24606294929981232,
0.8386681079864502,
-0.13840600848197937,
-0.6122601628303528,
0.4716770648956299,
0.35458868741989136,
-0.0011042709229514003,
-0.18204064667224884,
-0.814628005027771,
-0.016003483906388283,
-0.16194617748260498,
-0.34287580847740173,
-0.11075174808502197,
0.38347575068473816,
-0.09206393361091614,
1.194993495941162,
0.5333256125450134,
0.0999947190284729,
-0.1923903524875641,
0.5474200248718262,
0.952492356300354,
-0.7754493951797485,
-0.13729611039161682,
-0.9548503160476685,
0.477376252412796,
-0.26082736253738403,
-0.25373777747154236,
0.5685451030731201,
0.36008408665657043,
0.8484059572219849,
0.21698546409606934,
0.5500466227531433,
-0.03906192630529404,
0.20119410753250122,
-0.4492790699005127,
0.6036204099655151,
-0.3376803696155548,
0.5342398285865784,
-0.08154792338609695,
-0.9745194911956787,
-0.5111593008041382,
0.7267963290214539,
-0.40951645374298096,
-0.06146285682916641,
1.118715763092041,
1.0459150075912476,
0.2379993498325348,
0.05465774983167648,
0.1564226746559143,
0.14704135060310364,
0.35671189427375793,
0.6978704929351807,
1.2340571880340576,
-0.19338274002075195,
0.5544840693473816,
-0.23843413591384888,
-0.1354006975889206,
0.2052566260099411,
-0.773485004901886,
-1.1814268827438354,
-0.14001522958278656,
-0.5178402066230774,
-0.4107521176338196,
-0.03734581544995308,
1.1431158781051636,
0.4737677574157715,
-0.8266854882240295,
-0.42743080854415894,
-0.3602531850337982,
0.2687758207321167,
-0.269829124212265,
-0.23418821394443512,
0.008027728646993637,
-0.7088212370872498,
-0.5046653151512146,
0.4966847896575928,
0.5742478966712952,
-0.44936737418174744,
-0.6218649744987488,
-0.3187018930912018,
-0.13028064370155334,
0.3281572461128235,
0.576422393321991,
0.12231606245040894,
-0.8708423376083374,
-0.4652769863605499,
0.14256252348423004,
-0.15826921164989471,
0.1417100429534912,
0.6482027173042297,
-0.8915910720825195,
0.48011115193367004,
0.451599657535553,
0.9114586114883423,
0.30151471495628357,
-0.07696148753166199,
0.9184653162956238,
-0.4006839096546173,
-0.031144458800554276,
0.630113959312439,
0.5081218481063843,
0.27009883522987366,
-0.10274731367826462,
0.7628433704376221,
0.3098635971546173,
-0.5232490301132202,
-0.8328812718391418,
0.48422202467918396,
-1.0912818908691406,
-0.08790761232376099,
1.292006492614746,
0.12615472078323364,
-0.3064779043197632,
0.08533146977424622,
-0.3842121362686157,
-0.04796101152896881,
-0.33286935091018677,
0.6885544061660767,
0.6495952606201172,
-0.45807719230651855,
-0.4802718758583069,
-0.30110108852386475,
0.4017602801322937,
0.6344683766365051,
-1.3548123836517334,
-0.05908694863319397,
0.5558277368545532,
0.230206698179245,
0.11641579121351242,
0.4704425632953644,
-0.024684621021151543,
0.34389451146125793,
-0.15661704540252686,
0.38706791400909424,
-0.17314331233501434,
-0.3868984282016754,
-0.4886557459831238,
-0.02203177660703659,
0.2613840699195862,
0.31980928778648376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17650v1 | ELIZA Reinterpreted: The world's first chatbot was not intended as a chatbot at all | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | 2024-06-25T15:41:40 | Jeff Shrager | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | ELIZA, often considered the world's first chatbot, was written by Joseph
Weizenbaum in the early 1960s. Weizenbaum did not intend to invent the chatbot,
but rather to build a platform for research into human-machine conversation and
the important cognitive processes of interpretation and misinterpretation. His
purpose was obscured by ELIZA's fame, resulting in large part from the
fortuitous timing of it's creation, and it's escape into the wild. In this
paper I provide a rich historical context for ELIZA's creation, demonstrating
that ELIZA arose from the intersection of some of the central threads in the
technical history of AI. I also briefly discuss how ELIZA escaped into the
world, and how its accidental escape, along with several coincidental turns of
the programming language screws, led both to the misapprehension that ELIZA was
intended as a chatbot, and to the loss of the original ELIZA to history for
over 50 years. | [
-0.13847321271896362,
-1.1764659881591797,
0.6153227686882019,
-0.10465648025274277,
-0.1189257800579071,
-0.10766535997390747,
0.19707652926445007,
-0.32088857889175415,
0.532288134098053,
0.330057293176651,
-0.816913902759552,
0.009085025638341904,
-0.6370604038238525,
-0.17652732133865356,
-0.8593027591705322,
1.1235684156417847,
0.2806040048599243,
-0.7008265852928162,
-0.04647376760840416,
0.15456165373325348,
-0.17212747037410736,
-0.5507792830467224,
-0.4261336326599121,
-0.22280433773994446,
0.3715823292732239,
0.32222819328308105,
0.7224192023277283,
0.4915737211704254,
0.5587279200553894,
0.268263578414917,
0.025044286623597145,
0.19239607453346252,
-0.6562411785125732,
-0.24852193892002106,
0.2457626909017563,
-0.7683743238449097,
-0.048090461641550064,
0.21712945401668549,
0.39018914103507996,
0.641834020614624,
0.0014712064294144511,
0.12674565613269806,
0.10686521232128143,
0.6978736519813538,
-0.33633753657341003,
0.16036181151866913,
-0.5884791612625122,
0.15681084990501404,
-0.2701278626918793,
-0.18607275187969208,
-0.6108533143997192,
-0.20439966022968292,
-0.07589402049779892,
-0.7493528723716736,
0.09143806248903275,
0.2964234948158264,
1.0636178255081177,
0.3564607799053192,
-0.1935645192861557,
-0.2069019228219986,
-1.1730636358261108,
0.8352288603782654,
-0.2346537709236145,
-0.22596332430839539,
-0.0758608803153038,
0.37874966859817505,
-0.58541339635849,
-0.9892945289611816,
-0.8201941847801208,
-0.2889058291912079,
0.02457164227962494,
-0.07829093933105469,
-0.8393931984901428,
-0.2869509160518646,
0.21191079914569855,
-0.05790567770600319,
-0.4321064352989197,
-0.13714200258255005,
-0.6269941329956055,
-0.3180861473083496,
0.49923405051231384,
0.3091113865375519,
0.5030443072319031,
-0.2814681828022003,
-0.43427395820617676,
0.27806556224823,
-0.49948257207870483,
0.06435931473970413,
0.2792069613933563,
0.3075892925262451,
-0.12278309464454651,
0.5620291829109192,
-0.06076383218169212,
0.11526127904653549,
-0.12081565707921982,
0.093928761780262,
-0.061271101236343384,
0.055050045251846313,
-0.04753400757908821,
-0.20933052897453308,
0.91079181432724,
0.36374548077583313,
0.606173038482666,
-0.40733790397644043,
0.3847055435180664,
0.1772814840078354,
0.669648289680481,
-0.26664191484451294,
-0.2595975995063782,
0.2809484899044037,
-0.6009598970413208,
-0.3850223124027252,
0.32990238070487976,
-0.21016758680343628,
-0.192758247256279,
-0.012392686679959297,
0.19957804679870605,
-0.40717813372612,
-0.23861920833587646,
-0.32983916997909546,
-0.46109044551849365,
0.2858959436416626,
0.27370932698249817,
-0.663908839225769,
0.2092580497264862,
1.1927547454833984,
0.7840902209281921,
0.13062436878681183,
-0.5250397324562073,
-0.04229182004928589,
-0.181240513920784,
-0.5161154270172119,
0.46484020352363586,
-0.2193193882703781,
-0.23636001348495483,
-0.08659340441226959,
0.31149744987487793,
0.5945362448692322,
-0.09558373689651489,
0.3171355128288269,
-0.5052940845489502,
0.22757887840270996,
0.25359928607940674,
-0.4453012943267822,
-0.3021877408027649,
-0.06343472748994827,
-0.24006259441375732,
0.651092529296875,
-0.1775946468114853,
-0.66981041431427,
0.4218146502971649,
-0.6576192378997803,
-0.6608500480651855,
0.15886430442333221,
-0.03261648491024971,
-0.1804596483707428,
0.2901611924171448,
-0.053660858422517776,
-0.06629543751478195,
-0.087567538022995,
0.5108610391616821,
-0.3858424425125122,
-0.6554126739501953,
0.29161280393600464,
-0.4877936542034149,
1.228554129600525,
-0.1646750569343567,
-0.38191360235214233,
-0.5681151747703552,
-0.479715496301651,
0.1506383866071701,
0.445757120847702,
0.1444842666387558,
-0.3927674889564514,
0.14752140641212463,
-0.12583258748054504,
-0.056349340826272964,
0.3292141258716583,
-0.8198528289794922,
0.08696849644184113,
-0.5212593674659729,
0.7278463840484619,
0.5863121151924133,
-0.1663866490125656,
0.37133046984672546,
-0.8642885088920593,
0.4078619182109833,
-0.376837819814682,
0.5514103770256042,
-0.5094558000564575,
-0.8360201120376587,
-0.7645559310913086,
0.048030611127614975,
0.07708358019590378,
0.5596429705619812,
-0.17862777411937714,
0.33688533306121826,
-0.23405884206295013,
-0.8181992769241333,
-0.7235425710678101,
-0.18036460876464844,
-0.03940606489777565,
0.02342943288385868,
0.15656203031539917,
-0.05713789165019989,
-0.6752101182937622,
-0.9652590155601501,
-0.397580623626709,
-0.7267937660217285,
-0.08351366966962814,
0.38928717374801636,
0.417886883020401,
-0.20283237099647522,
1.1281927824020386,
-0.5587233901023865,
-0.012513197027146816,
-0.16019177436828613,
-0.03602750599384308,
0.3780760169029236,
0.6271044015884399,
0.6325790882110596,
-0.4721956253051758,
-0.2815208435058594,
-0.23000706732273102,
-0.666650116443634,
-0.010883520357310772,
-0.4707365930080414,
-0.6171212196350098,
-0.130710169672966,
0.294009268283844,
-1.1093823909759521,
0.8579686284065247,
0.33548733592033386,
0.34852534532546997,
0.5189566612243652,
-0.21506568789482117,
-0.009755343198776245,
-1.011178731918335,
0.38796907663345337,
-0.7525284886360168,
0.166319340467453,
-0.4735235571861267,
-0.05562776327133179,
-0.07638408988714218,
-0.2904408872127533,
-0.5155562162399292,
0.6766769289970398,
-0.287866473197937,
0.10667065531015396,
-0.46328026056289673,
0.48289158940315247,
0.10513094067573547,
0.49220025539398193,
-0.44869810342788696,
0.22045809030532837,
0.6337894201278687,
-0.5554399490356445,
0.437273770570755,
0.7151780128479004,
0.293647825717926,
0.41239798069000244,
-0.5221642255783081,
0.5653904676437378,
-0.44925549626350403,
0.04123890772461891,
-1.314523696899414,
-0.06338084489107132,
0.4698215425014496,
-0.866746187210083,
-0.03358486667275429,
-0.23569126427173615,
-0.16542811691761017,
-0.5602622032165527,
0.07616699486970901,
0.061065442860126495,
0.6857059001922607,
-0.4791407585144043,
0.5515071153640747,
0.6096718311309814,
-0.33173125982284546,
-0.28387510776519775,
-0.9504749178886414,
0.3522747755050659,
-0.16489221155643463,
-0.7165956497192383,
0.20263822376728058,
-0.18758979439735413,
-0.5277071595191956,
-0.37195199728012085,
-0.03170476853847504,
-0.1884918212890625,
0.24826174974441528,
0.6649516224861145,
0.42780953645706177,
-0.18415801227092743,
0.2421766072511673,
0.04733186960220337,
-0.28800469636917114,
0.3016171157360077,
0.13711050152778625,
0.39665520191192627,
0.34215110540390015,
-0.4831390976905823,
-0.9419254064559937,
0.5475207567214966,
0.5588786602020264,
0.36456525325775146,
0.7693846821784973,
-0.05375140905380249,
-0.20266470313072205,
-0.140223428606987,
-0.32606032490730286,
-0.19075384736061096,
-0.46150290966033936,
0.13475510478019714,
0.04256730154156685,
-0.5805893540382385,
0.3075156807899475,
-0.0732688158750534,
0.5776808261871338,
0.5154609084129333,
-0.02277357131242752,
-0.5283776521682739,
0.5719892382621765,
0.7416013479232788,
-0.2624983787536621,
0.7691848278045654,
0.13583768904209137,
0.4306246042251587,
-0.582775890827179,
-0.14449410140514374,
-0.5530722141265869,
-0.5908358693122864,
-0.7957996129989624,
0.11311447620391846,
0.3171800374984741,
-0.5139790177345276,
-0.4879953861236572,
0.2157910168170929,
-0.43555504083633423,
0.30104100704193115,
0.8399791121482849,
0.19992978870868683,
0.24365627765655518,
-0.1836179792881012,
0.47995325922966003,
-0.16028614342212677,
-0.7139378190040588,
-0.6902376413345337,
1.307034969329834,
0.03954454883933067,
0.6710103750228882,
0.1376330405473709,
0.803162693977356,
0.501246988773346,
0.2619306445121765,
-0.37250611186027527,
0.5610387921333313,
-0.03977693244814873,
-0.7781102061271667,
-0.1992444097995758,
-0.09158924967050552,
-1.5800254344940186,
-0.021722158417105675,
0.04586518183350563,
-0.8567311763763428,
-0.5016631484031677,
0.131380096077919,
-0.6738613843917847,
-0.02105884812772274,
-0.8192732334136963,
0.7413616180419922,
-0.35650235414505005,
0.002143255202099681,
-0.045261528342962265,
-0.9139496684074402,
0.588941216468811,
0.2886056900024414,
0.3438478112220764,
-0.08495747298002243,
0.2810229957103729,
0.5323326587677002,
-0.42941975593566895,
0.9312646389007568,
0.0954374447464943,
0.5570316910743713,
0.7507011890411377,
0.4227654039859772,
0.3923705518245697,
-0.12458427250385284,
0.4456786513328552,
0.27523675560951233,
0.1104554608464241,
-0.4768487513065338,
-0.4456787705421448,
0.43395373225212097,
-0.8363901972770691,
-0.8555486798286438,
0.030133593827486038,
-0.36393773555755615,
0.415918231010437,
0.2920750677585602,
-0.15387600660324097,
0.37332189083099365,
-0.5540343523025513,
0.12382794916629791,
-0.021393902599811554,
-0.2147253006696701,
0.4937790632247925,
0.29050886631011963,
-0.41082924604415894,
0.17945672571659088,
0.31779730319976807,
-0.193956196308136,
0.09927868843078613,
0.5779880881309509,
0.22417066991329193,
0.11150678992271423,
0.004607297945767641,
-0.23634342849254608,
0.2150004655122757,
-0.6290207505226135,
0.22992682456970215,
-0.63995760679245,
-0.30521395802497864,
-0.36074721813201904,
-0.17633137106895447,
-0.38777676224708557,
-0.3749895989894867,
-0.520858645439148,
0.049609631299972534,
0.2996664345264435,
0.6107954382896423,
0.09686402976512909,
0.5312784314155579,
-1.0186610221862793,
0.1058562844991684,
0.09365113079547882,
-0.16951504349708557,
-0.10617207735776901,
-0.5807114243507385,
0.0456501804292202,
0.19368493556976318,
-0.407925009727478,
-0.9243527054786682,
0.20497824251651764,
0.19320635497570038,
0.7169504165649414,
0.39921098947525024,
0.10432978719472885,
0.47589945793151855,
-0.3521067202091217,
0.8576905727386475,
-0.09552166610956192,
-0.6354293823242188,
0.5537351369857788,
-0.10469604283571243,
0.41660282015800476,
-0.039381302893161774,
-0.05847322568297386,
-0.6806123852729797,
-0.48981228470802307,
-0.9558133482933044,
-0.8610557913780212,
0.6822603344917297,
0.3062429130077362,
0.6951979398727417,
0.19083115458488464,
0.4808863401412964,
0.6901838183403015,
0.20618221163749695,
-0.8848572373390198,
-0.4490912854671478,
-0.04153166711330414,
-0.03813297674059868,
0.19307823479175568,
0.19251912832260132,
-0.10397788137197495,
-0.07929643243551254,
0.3332938551902771,
-0.10084200650453568,
0.5257383584976196,
-0.11994583904743195,
-0.29520541429519653,
-0.1798633337020874,
0.04312066361308098,
0.14459466934204102,
0.5268780589103699,
0.42599058151245117,
-0.012302759103477001,
-0.20514829456806183,
-0.1292140781879425,
-0.1734534054994583,
0.18605265021324158,
-0.45970964431762695,
0.17913047969341278,
0.5468344688415527,
0.7235121130943298,
0.3277992010116577,
-0.9306201338768005,
0.39831340312957764,
0.15914274752140045,
0.15529124438762665,
-0.7154728174209595,
0.3312498927116394,
-0.01830834150314331,
0.5712548494338989,
0.42967689037323,
0.014608650468289852,
-0.11886724829673767,
-0.8183431029319763,
0.281266987323761,
0.6390537023544312,
0.0032140144612640142,
-0.34488025307655334,
0.9611608982086182,
-0.03607277572154999,
-0.6695919632911682,
0.9297866225242615,
0.1809355616569519,
-0.2722029387950897,
0.6716088652610779,
0.3144672214984894,
0.99361652135849,
0.08833100646734238,
0.38705697655677795,
0.45318689942359924,
0.71651291847229,
0.431591659784317,
0.32778480648994446,
-0.17258572578430176,
-0.6748024225234985,
0.21889841556549072,
-0.1737394630908966,
-0.2705188989639282,
-0.33882540464401245,
-0.31271907687187195,
0.18605056405067444,
-0.4472396671772003,
-0.39787691831588745,
0.29346898198127747,
-0.32953935861587524,
-0.7807530760765076,
-0.14665241539478302,
0.09094135463237762,
0.8761113882064819,
-0.6824090480804443,
0.10961048305034637,
0.29944631457328796,
-0.24488361179828644,
-0.29486286640167236,
0.20487527549266815,
0.11965245753526688,
-1.1121083498001099,
0.2899572551250458,
0.05912494659423828,
0.21144938468933105,
0.09988223761320114,
-0.9995124340057373,
-0.9994937181472778,
0.7492514848709106,
0.10124347358942032,
-0.468463271856308,
-0.15583407878875732,
0.1565428376197815,
0.5545898675918579,
-0.18311378359794617,
0.2443685382604599,
0.3337650001049042,
0.3816460967063904,
0.0253626499325037,
-0.9213469624519348,
-0.19511663913726807,
-0.24664568901062012,
-0.053003180772066116,
0.2921837866306305,
-0.8247330188751221,
0.9576288461685181,
-0.6541524529457092,
-0.4006364643573761,
0.5617789030075073,
0.4877985119819641,
-0.25077518820762634,
0.33731770515441895,
-0.023742280900478363,
0.017565732821822166,
0.5359190106391907,
-0.35791024565696716,
0.9365930557250977,
-0.17344212532043457,
0.11445688456296921,
0.574576735496521,
-0.23001733422279358,
0.49156078696250916,
0.5480649471282959,
-0.5448858737945557,
0.3639483153820038,
0.5131670236587524,
0.14575476944446564,
0.5974276661872864,
-0.13118276000022888,
0.2229200005531311,
-0.06357675045728683,
0.24862265586853027,
0.012154625728726387,
0.6622574925422668,
0.21086890995502472,
-0.25378289818763733,
-0.06723634153604507,
-0.1617988497018814,
0.26822027564048767,
-0.23487360775470734,
0.1344117671251297,
0.8300857543945312,
0.09270735830068588,
-0.9470612406730652,
-0.002127538900822401,
-0.29023274779319763,
0.06645672023296356,
-0.5450507402420044,
-0.0426299162209034,
-0.3750372529029846,
0.003341400995850563,
0.21231025457382202,
-0.7044079899787903,
0.3057307004928589,
-0.11062110215425491,
0.18347474932670593,
-0.05259370431303978,
0.4633731245994568,
0.04560608044266701,
-0.3976610004901886,
-0.11208175867795944,
0.706841766834259,
0.5582976341247559,
0.013685325160622597,
-0.5293932557106018,
0.15536846220493317,
-0.003921275958418846,
-0.2529410421848297,
-0.10769058018922806,
0.7404221296310425,
0.16947661340236664,
0.6384237408638,
0.6995199918746948,
-0.44512495398521423,
0.07022617757320404,
-0.5199107527732849,
0.7443236112594604,
-0.9893961548805237,
-0.8612251877784729,
-1.084694504737854,
0.5940572619438171,
0.21694688498973846,
-0.40315738320350647,
0.5746883153915405,
0.35822227597236633,
0.36472415924072266,
0.2854568362236023,
1.1263246536254883,
-0.5242028832435608,
0.48242977261543274,
-0.2761731445789337,
0.5338600873947144,
-0.7311406135559082,
-0.181123286485672,
-0.4458690583705902,
-0.5100737810134888,
-0.09030180424451828,
0.37631654739379883,
0.04057438671588898,
0.32117241621017456,
0.6564895510673523,
0.6097155213356018,
0.4763694703578949,
0.38384801149368286,
0.36070990562438965,
0.40050163865089417,
0.19760583341121674,
0.3711213767528534,
1.0297164916992188,
-0.33651164174079895,
0.9078603386878967,
0.16547507047653198,
-0.31280502676963806,
-0.752234935760498,
-0.511035144329071,
-0.5760454535484314,
-0.6771756410598755,
-0.1924176663160324,
-0.25517040491104126,
0.2289939522743225,
0.8170363306999207,
0.6266953945159912,
-0.3102087378501892,
0.23446084558963776,
0.11363622546195984,
0.17919732630252838,
-0.5074455738067627,
-0.23444151878356934,
0.07274572551250458,
0.020582791417837143,
-0.8459101915359497,
0.3427264988422394,
0.3411461412906647,
0.11108523607254028,
-0.5144246220588684,
0.1859569251537323,
0.14893479645252228,
0.09504438191652298,
0.1347644329071045,
0.5173359513282776,
-0.873534619808197,
-0.6055177450180054,
0.20172791182994843,
-0.08587540686130524,
0.4316677451133728,
0.529187798500061,
-0.5846729874610901,
0.46071889996528625,
0.23207126557826996,
0.39845073223114014,
0.2764853835105896,
-0.05326049402356148,
0.5526140928268433,
-0.5544295310974121,
0.4615386128425598,
0.30154097080230713,
0.3004494607448578,
0.15130066871643066,
-0.45263537764549255,
0.2088167369365692,
0.48620814085006714,
-0.5277690887451172,
-0.6082922220230103,
0.16883686184883118,
-0.7146363854408264,
-0.40372738242149353,
0.6457838416099548,
-0.0447622686624527,
-0.30989372730255127,
-0.2254752218723297,
-0.5377740263938904,
0.36647889018058777,
-0.35180985927581787,
1.4715681076049805,
0.9310463666915894,
-0.5485425591468811,
-0.12046793103218079,
-0.683357298374176,
-0.06850285828113556,
0.1328331083059311,
-0.6623488664627075,
0.027521710842847824,
0.5564186573028564,
0.02877405472099781,
0.2478426843881607,
0.7481204271316528,
0.2171749472618103,
0.4160323143005371,
0.6289536356925964,
0.3262416124343872,
0.22592973709106445,
-0.3749014735221863,
0.3511177599430084,
0.2426733821630478,
-0.013860465958714485,
-0.5945063829421997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17647v1 | Variationist: Exploring Multifaceted Variation and Bias in Written Language Data | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | 2024-06-25T15:41:07 | Alan Ramponi, Camilla Casula, Stefano Menini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Exploring and understanding language data is a fundamental stage in all areas
dealing with human language. It allows NLP practitioners to uncover quality
concerns and harmful biases in data before training, and helps linguists and
social scientists to gain insight into language use and human behavior. Yet,
there is currently a lack of a unified, customizable tool to seamlessly inspect
and visualize language variation and bias across multiple variables, language
units, and diverse metrics that go beyond descriptive statistics. In this
paper, we introduce Variationist, a highly-modular, extensible, and
task-agnostic tool that fills this gap. Variationist handles at once a
potentially unlimited combination of variable types and semantics across
diversity and association metrics with regards to the language unit of choice,
and orchestrates the creation of up to five-dimensional interactive charts for
over 30 variable type-semantics combinations. Through our case studies on
computational dialectology, human label variation, and text generation, we show
how Variationist enables researchers from different disciplines to effortlessly
answer specific research questions or unveil undesired associations in language
data. A Python library, code, documentation, and tutorials are made publicly
available to the research community. | [
-0.5805137157440186,
-0.6617727875709534,
0.31926673650741577,
0.46391376852989197,
0.10905129462480545,
0.47259920835494995,
-0.3515538275241852,
-0.22348901629447937,
0.49924513697624207,
0.5896213054656982,
-0.6301584243774414,
-0.5375629663467407,
-0.37996751070022583,
-0.0651165321469307,
-0.21203970909118652,
0.9726876616477966,
-0.13671059906482697,
0.011424996890127659,
-0.15175935626029968,
-0.3891040086746216,
-0.22242778539657593,
-0.4814906716346741,
-0.10686111450195312,
-0.4875146746635437,
0.7222076058387756,
0.37423816323280334,
0.6525124907493591,
0.31675636768341064,
0.3313238024711609,
0.28070807456970215,
-0.0048052058555185795,
-0.027898341417312622,
-0.2834013104438782,
0.3384009897708893,
-0.21148864924907684,
-0.8782925009727478,
-0.11249002069234848,
-0.04943987727165222,
0.6059020161628723,
1.0960296392440796,
-0.0944051742553711,
0.02380514331161976,
-0.14818188548088074,
0.6903102993965149,
-0.6610976457595825,
0.09642843157052994,
-0.34858840703964233,
0.09697531163692474,
-0.5105459094047546,
-0.025329643860459328,
-0.08845216035842896,
-0.2448073923587799,
0.22841979563236237,
-0.5144304633140564,
0.5537429451942444,
-0.2332928627729416,
0.5175230503082275,
0.26087284088134766,
-0.6426091194152832,
-0.17134462296962738,
-0.6756430268287659,
0.8356983065605164,
-0.6036321520805359,
0.47192052006721497,
0.2699435353279114,
0.33658552169799805,
-0.07704541087150574,
-0.5240644812583923,
-0.5129286646842957,
-0.2764454782009125,
-0.06508968770503998,
-0.039999861270189285,
0.07940317690372467,
0.0028756551910191774,
0.16919948160648346,
0.8466771245002747,
-0.6216439008712769,
0.19424372911453247,
0.11545025557279587,
-0.15498845279216766,
0.46225062012672424,
0.342195063829422,
0.560827910900116,
-0.1501598358154297,
0.3199627697467804,
-0.19588805735111237,
-0.32355403900146484,
0.041933052241802216,
0.8574732542037964,
0.3627091646194458,
-0.1937863826751709,
0.5634278059005737,
-0.2680549919605255,
0.7299949526786804,
-0.3713042736053467,
0.28148794174194336,
0.536835253238678,
-0.08193691074848175,
0.009127994999289513,
-0.7426930069923401,
0.8849583864212036,
-0.045029278844594955,
-0.36905422806739807,
-0.17409344017505646,
-0.06121160462498665,
-0.08907731622457504,
0.09545540809631348,
-0.369162380695343,
-0.4450056254863739,
0.2610800862312317,
-0.17163881659507751,
-0.2454853355884552,
0.05781659483909607,
-1.104171633720398,
-0.759401798248291,
-0.37533700466156006,
-0.21357901394367218,
-0.5089555382728577,
-0.46813932061195374,
0.35805001854896545,
-0.3980529010295868,
0.049130912870168686,
0.3500750958919525,
-1.0988930463790894,
0.23843395709991455,
0.5908759832382202,
0.6009203195571899,
-0.5176836848258972,
-0.49185001850128174,
-0.22207318246364594,
-0.12151722609996796,
-0.32749566435813904,
0.5920112729072571,
-0.6438140273094177,
-0.4037696421146393,
0.15583257377147675,
-0.3879128694534302,
0.1034742146730423,
-0.46156132221221924,
0.4148743450641632,
-0.2597178816795349,
0.27298715710639954,
-0.10295868664979935,
-0.5550132393836975,
-0.01472513098269701,
0.24935322999954224,
-0.9698970913887024,
1.1280568838119507,
0.337394118309021,
-1.0043554306030273,
0.5188758969306946,
-0.6040845513343811,
-0.1881820261478424,
0.29966747760772705,
-0.7251864075660706,
-0.29440468549728394,
0.24639789760112762,
0.04418019950389862,
0.16069714725017548,
-0.24871030449867249,
0.24615740776062012,
-0.4092811942100525,
0.06879922747612,
0.4908084273338318,
-0.4391639530658722,
0.7660790085792542,
0.03670228272676468,
-0.2655850946903229,
0.020745357498526573,
-0.8516259789466858,
-0.04579172655940056,
-0.007536233402788639,
-0.5970920920372009,
-0.38124987483024597,
0.22750639915466309,
0.586647093296051,
-0.17593707144260406,
0.18553687632083893,
-0.3949239253997803,
0.31652992963790894,
-0.28789034485816956,
0.11145652830600739,
0.45226144790649414,
-0.31746968626976013,
0.30760377645492554,
-0.1667766273021698,
0.7393267750740051,
-0.07814241945743561,
-0.08080428838729858,
-0.09813513606786728,
-0.4198077321052551,
-0.9070063233375549,
-0.33302587270736694,
0.23589633405208588,
0.28843629360198975,
-0.6781480312347412,
0.4969269037246704,
-0.10458005964756012,
-0.45615243911743164,
-0.5496793985366821,
0.14871926605701447,
-0.021976379677653313,
-0.01852850802242756,
0.1707092821598053,
-0.47906091809272766,
-0.5395203232765198,
-0.9093794822692871,
-0.5578632950782776,
-0.016344934701919556,
-0.3042372167110443,
0.37872689962387085,
0.3670646846294403,
-0.4958437979221344,
1.1294219493865967,
-0.8147113919258118,
0.048048511147499084,
-0.430849552154541,
0.6305485963821411,
0.22664572298526764,
0.40700146555900574,
0.5323160290718079,
-0.7768715620040894,
-0.5876604318618774,
0.16628237068653107,
-0.37567630410194397,
-0.2925066351890564,
-0.2785463035106659,
-0.11049667745828629,
-0.07641739398241043,
0.25574252009391785,
-0.2598094940185547,
0.073084756731987,
0.5436252355575562,
-0.11278002709150314,
0.7579115629196167,
0.012424906715750694,
-0.18725857138633728,
-0.9625969529151917,
0.1875687688589096,
0.07301124930381775,
-0.15502311289310455,
-0.8312409520149231,
0.3629695177078247,
0.003361613256856799,
0.15207111835479736,
0.1462516486644745,
0.1454569399356842,
-0.3229213356971741,
0.2649800181388855,
-0.02734648436307907,
-0.3707873821258545,
-0.19567745923995972,
0.14762617647647858,
0.07644344866275787,
0.6505901217460632,
0.4658752381801605,
-0.01377020962536335,
0.3786265254020691,
-0.03830952197313309,
-0.32096779346466064,
0.32607805728912354,
-0.1700609028339386,
0.26683899760246277,
-0.09266907721757889,
0.05356733128428459,
-0.7824981808662415,
-0.5739350914955139,
0.09008048474788666,
-0.26274630427360535,
0.24622023105621338,
-0.010144392028450966,
-0.38106071949005127,
-0.21946635842323303,
-0.6220799088478088,
0.401162326335907,
-0.06283004581928253,
-0.27881255745887756,
0.703058123588562,
0.6010129451751709,
-0.2048507183790207,
-0.8960050940513611,
-0.6552396416664124,
0.14174391329288483,
-0.16317246854305267,
-0.23691482841968536,
0.14195974171161652,
-0.4371815323829651,
-0.2710537612438202,
-0.17200268805027008,
-0.12083599716424942,
-0.45141467452049255,
-0.06492938846349716,
-0.048750463873147964,
0.012619264423847198,
-0.20652221143245697,
0.05729823186993599,
0.13273580372333527,
0.15918557345867157,
-0.03642619028687477,
-0.015636809170246124,
0.7726200222969055,
-0.37902599573135376,
-0.45847591757774353,
-0.04088560864329338,
0.5727526545524597,
0.3518178164958954,
0.18549782037734985,
0.2995910048484802,
0.5462491512298584,
-0.12635652720928192,
-0.29281777143478394,
-0.5181447267532349,
0.22957976162433624,
-0.4416152536869049,
0.4759630560874939,
-0.3612492084503174,
-1.0054272413253784,
0.5147174000740051,
-0.01702362485229969,
0.05330435559153557,
0.28705599904060364,
0.6450903415679932,
0.23196806013584137,
0.6076495051383972,
0.862632691860199,
-0.20007437467575073,
0.6297934651374817,
-0.20430214703083038,
-0.009836629964411259,
-0.5656812787055969,
-0.11504802852869034,
-0.5193897485733032,
0.04015021026134491,
-0.6394347548484802,
-0.5868044495582581,
0.13129791617393494,
-0.10083455592393875,
0.11053605377674103,
0.12016667425632477,
-0.3904394209384918,
0.67384272813797,
0.39988356828689575,
-0.18659238517284393,
0.13476836681365967,
-0.28266826272010803,
-0.0033867675811052322,
-0.3607412576675415,
-0.4052858054637909,
-0.3796769082546234,
1.3023041486740112,
0.3033964931964874,
1.0317226648330688,
0.13642005622386932,
0.8546519875526428,
0.20533737540245056,
0.22464711964130402,
-0.8055682182312012,
0.253944993019104,
-0.06526925414800644,
-0.5104097723960876,
-0.319873571395874,
-0.6040472388267517,
-0.7526249289512634,
0.6477288007736206,
-0.12096612900495529,
-0.8112950921058655,
0.4245261251926422,
0.2553027868270874,
0.08945479243993759,
0.27364256978034973,
-0.6105996966362,
0.673876941204071,
-0.05812300369143486,
-0.14726632833480835,
0.04424496367573738,
-0.7549658417701721,
0.44487062096595764,
-0.2398584485054016,
0.32547271251678467,
-0.049484461545944214,
-0.18337273597717285,
0.46965333819389343,
-0.19657295942306519,
1.0170388221740723,
0.17463606595993042,
-0.21165479719638824,
-0.23167841136455536,
0.31796297430992126,
0.08548343926668167,
0.24445384740829468,
0.06927742063999176,
0.10018876194953918,
-0.04916379973292351,
-0.44209668040275574,
-0.55223548412323,
0.5288998484611511,
-0.8901033997535706,
-0.3463229238986969,
-0.3020961582660675,
-0.9031297564506531,
-0.3153530955314636,
0.1513131558895111,
0.1776517629623413,
0.09395167231559753,
-0.5682974457740784,
0.014683435671031475,
0.6343539357185364,
-0.4019247889518738,
0.12479840219020844,
0.3618181645870209,
-0.2322373390197754,
-0.2249475121498108,
1.1401811838150024,
-0.0681910514831543,
0.20990023016929626,
0.7427328824996948,
0.40890467166900635,
0.02805187739431858,
-0.34466686844825745,
-0.26146262884140015,
0.056737516075372696,
-0.7252189517021179,
0.15547214448451996,
-0.6156821250915527,
0.03317388519644737,
-0.2631152272224426,
-0.15992601215839386,
-0.44046032428741455,
-0.6553221344947815,
-0.252526193857193,
0.08770717680454254,
-0.014701326377689838,
0.7451544404029846,
-0.2346796989440918,
0.30980056524276733,
-0.15195314586162567,
0.2595865726470947,
0.4811713397502899,
0.3094067871570587,
-0.25880080461502075,
0.07469220459461212,
-0.09295051544904709,
-0.22953657805919647,
-0.42181122303009033,
-1.0225811004638672,
0.3540310263633728,
0.12469077110290527,
0.6430888772010803,
0.4597439467906952,
-0.30352187156677246,
0.14995776116847992,
-0.2995353043079376,
0.8921992182731628,
0.3717736303806305,
-1.1832245588302612,
0.2904077172279358,
-0.4602300524711609,
0.2275247722864151,
0.5412470102310181,
0.2669251263141632,
-1.092737078666687,
-0.7720445990562439,
-0.4437403380870819,
-1.197619915008545,
0.7051880359649658,
0.1679985225200653,
0.1483050137758255,
0.4158824384212494,
0.007475418969988823,
0.7224212884902954,
0.5081004500389099,
-0.8461162447929382,
-0.4689039885997772,
-0.578758716583252,
-0.2993440330028534,
-0.2143011838197708,
-0.03128519281744957,
-0.4074467420578003,
-0.37451887130737305,
0.29213517904281616,
-0.4138750433921814,
-0.10688493400812149,
-0.29947054386138916,
-0.24078138172626495,
0.2317904382944107,
0.5345898270606995,
0.4100323021411896,
0.7210973501205444,
-0.18652167916297913,
0.5781056880950928,
0.07991880178451538,
-0.48299553990364075,
0.00725298747420311,
0.19646602869033813,
-0.13013197481632233,
0.04723862186074257,
0.38393691182136536,
0.7231031060218811,
-0.21808010339736938,
-0.7466513514518738,
0.476297527551651,
-0.13040366768836975,
-0.04721839725971222,
0.045110736042261124,
0.086912140250206,
0.2018323689699173,
-0.11186622083187103,
0.12208976596593857,
-0.06440973281860352,
0.5054588317871094,
-0.3708536624908447,
0.09822309762239456,
0.20993749797344208,
-0.22332650423049927,
-0.3593428432941437,
0.38316139578819275,
0.03951828554272652,
-0.3698764741420746,
0.13991490006446838,
-0.026514582335948944,
-0.30449748039245605,
0.5391516089439392,
0.2988981604576111,
0.8904561400413513,
-0.2693415582180023,
0.6819688081741333,
-0.21326212584972382,
0.3496749699115753,
0.15017609298229218,
0.26875367760658264,
-0.09991643577814102,
-0.8646500706672668,
-0.38782012462615967,
-0.37248319387435913,
-0.8506133556365967,
0.3924509584903717,
-0.8536311388015747,
-0.043585073202848434,
-0.2907252311706543,
0.05090021342039108,
0.48464617133140564,
-0.23948930203914642,
-0.6379022002220154,
-0.09328947961330414,
0.07025445252656937,
0.6575918197631836,
-1.0489501953125,
0.5196889638900757,
0.8574473857879639,
-0.544916033744812,
-0.33501872420310974,
0.38482242822647095,
0.017383387312293053,
-0.6498786211013794,
0.26142990589141846,
0.03575761243700981,
-0.09611136466264725,
-0.388868510723114,
-0.6992705464363098,
-0.5067045092582703,
0.4570760726928711,
0.5836184620857239,
-0.3580067455768585,
0.32868891954421997,
0.5620972514152527,
0.777241051197052,
-0.18304099142551422,
0.4323571026325226,
0.8679494261741638,
0.24175305664539337,
-0.35885825753211975,
-0.48487359285354614,
0.003127290168777108,
-0.36258643865585327,
0.24366705119609833,
0.2820844054222107,
-0.523341715335846,
1.0522626638412476,
0.3003358244895935,
0.12197183817625046,
-0.2505825161933899,
0.32379403710365295,
-0.05480724573135376,
-0.0027078972198069096,
0.39149340987205505,
0.3983258903026581,
0.8658236265182495,
0.03654511645436287,
0.7511671185493469,
-0.06442534923553467,
0.5475298762321472,
1.1475811004638672,
-0.0899948924779892,
0.417333722114563,
0.6665484309196472,
-0.40726473927497864,
0.7729137539863586,
0.5881211161613464,
0.12024423480033875,
0.2092013955116272,
0.5456231832504272,
-0.5805551409721375,
-0.24781019985675812,
0.10275007039308548,
-0.20815090835094452,
0.11478938162326813,
0.532718300819397,
-0.006100215949118137,
-0.26695704460144043,
-0.08359397202730179,
-0.17034099996089935,
0.051474276930093765,
0.23615975677967072,
0.5607254505157471,
-0.1231982409954071,
-0.18862275779247284,
0.33059871196746826,
0.03670016676187515,
0.8005828857421875,
-0.5562924146652222,
0.18845528364181519,
-0.37923210859298706,
-0.10307987034320831,
-0.1614830642938614,
-0.9272121787071228,
0.13582590222358704,
-0.2425101399421692,
-0.1464359015226364,
-0.05616718530654907,
0.3469814360141754,
-0.47768640518188477,
-0.23047511279582977,
0.18155547976493835,
0.6001410484313965,
0.04359450936317444,
0.07723436504602432,
-0.7065380811691284,
-0.02192067913711071,
-0.004496727138757706,
-0.3591468930244446,
0.25700172781944275,
0.4804404675960541,
0.03932555019855499,
0.7488121390342712,
0.4205993413925171,
0.1967880129814148,
0.27612149715423584,
0.38179871439933777,
1.1630853414535522,
-0.529560923576355,
-0.4361836016178131,
-0.681104302406311,
0.3870006501674652,
-0.3278358578681946,
-0.6044063568115234,
0.44516491889953613,
0.8805664777755737,
0.8421202898025513,
-0.19538070261478424,
1.2744674682617188,
-0.2699475884437561,
0.4021351635456085,
-0.23442140221595764,
0.46601343154907227,
-0.5530406832695007,
0.18005168437957764,
-0.27929168939590454,
-0.5459108352661133,
-0.6130406260490417,
0.31513363122940063,
-0.2328709065914154,
-0.23714035749435425,
0.7109806537628174,
0.6529200673103333,
-0.2822679877281189,
-0.006251975893974304,
0.18416598439216614,
-0.11989475041627884,
0.6214659214019775,
0.1412777155637741,
0.9818282127380371,
0.1935947686433792,
0.43256333470344543,
-0.09988704323768616,
-0.5540811419487,
-0.16668348014354706,
-0.5183869004249573,
-0.8538969159126282,
-0.576949954032898,
-0.060271844267845154,
0.008709825575351715,
-0.2124389111995697,
0.8480795621871948,
0.48507070541381836,
-0.8030402660369873,
-0.7758893370628357,
-0.43751993775367737,
0.44258913397789,
-0.11686167865991592,
-0.2826346457004547,
0.18453337252140045,
-0.606295645236969,
-0.8124302625656128,
0.3711409270763397,
0.3074827790260315,
-0.027157042175531387,
-0.5708368420600891,
0.1624898463487625,
0.03790963813662529,
0.19648031890392303,
0.19085818529129028,
0.5119733810424805,
-0.5760848522186279,
0.04847491905093193,
-0.36199769377708435,
-0.1307622343301773,
0.28373801708221436,
1.379333257675171,
-0.15991951525211334,
0.8930228352546692,
0.691531777381897,
0.6819949746131897,
0.5968454480171204,
-0.4465982913970947,
0.7422030568122864,
-1.115752100944519,
0.2207309454679489,
0.4275279641151428,
0.24794338643550873,
0.4972430467605591,
-0.2481096386909485,
0.3784826099872589,
0.39620041847229004,
-0.343421071767807,
-0.8588910102844238,
0.6728299856185913,
-0.9265048503875732,
-0.46500393748283386,
0.9640934467315674,
-0.05862761288881302,
0.09646882861852646,
-0.34070906043052673,
-0.3141854405403137,
0.03455067053437233,
-0.4629378914833069,
0.9468314051628113,
0.8722109198570251,
-0.37663519382476807,
-0.01018296554684639,
-0.5984159111976624,
0.665845513343811,
0.42110952734947205,
-1.164488434791565,
0.19324398040771484,
0.5451179146766663,
0.4111080467700958,
0.21598897874355316,
0.6836312413215637,
0.16899187862873077,
-0.19691237807273865,
0.1736687868833542,
0.38720378279685974,
0.5528691411018372,
0.023037508130073547,
-0.49348559975624084,
0.12308088690042496,
0.07824637740850449,
0.056612104177474976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17642v1 | Banishing LLM Hallucinations Requires Rethinking Generalization | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | 2024-06-25T15:31:01 | Johnny Li, Saksham Consul, Eda Zhou, James Wong, Naila Farooqui, Yuxin Ye, Nithyashree Manohar, Zhuxiaona Wei, Tian Wu, Ben Echols, Sharon Zhou, Gregory Diamos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their powerful chat, coding, and reasoning abilities, Large Language
Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate. Conventional wisdom suggests that
hallucinations are a consequence of a balance between creativity and
factuality, which can be mitigated, but not eliminated, by grounding the LLM in
external knowledge sources. Through extensive systematic experiments, we show
that these traditional approaches fail to explain why LLMs hallucinate in
practice. Specifically, we show that LLMs augmented with a massive Mixture of
Memory Experts (MoME) can easily memorize large datasets of random numbers. We
corroborate these experimental findings with a theoretical construction showing
that simple neural networks trained to predict the next token hallucinate when
the training loss is above a threshold as it usually does in practice when
training on internet scale data. We interpret our findings by comparing against
traditional retrieval methods for mitigating hallucinations. We use our
findings to design a first generation model for removing hallucinations --
Lamini-1 -- that stores facts in a massive mixture of millions of memory
experts that are retrieved dynamically. | [
-0.5633649230003357,
-0.7683010697364807,
0.5709614157676697,
0.05681492015719414,
-0.25592654943466187,
-0.02930249460041523,
-0.3625833988189697,
-0.4921579957008362,
0.6309790015220642,
0.9016460180282593,
-0.356600284576416,
-0.3263760209083557,
-0.6457931995391846,
-0.1302666813135147,
-0.5431362986564636,
0.8201627731323242,
0.36228156089782715,
0.10851223766803741,
-0.1009102612733841,
-0.06002134084701538,
-0.4345765709877014,
-0.8622850775718689,
-0.7104002833366394,
-0.46619582176208496,
0.7381672263145447,
0.13813307881355286,
0.6918011903762817,
0.3295551836490631,
0.4425940215587616,
0.2325150966644287,
-0.15428867936134338,
0.44363874197006226,
-1.0194811820983887,
0.03852641209959984,
0.025767706334590912,
-0.698971152305603,
-0.05036620795726776,
-0.09600544720888138,
0.3012426197528839,
0.8570711612701416,
-0.44021663069725037,
-0.47620582580566406,
-0.09400385618209839,
0.7359172701835632,
-0.384807288646698,
-0.11214341968297958,
-1.172673225402832,
0.4624355435371399,
0.1481305956840515,
-0.5664980411529541,
-0.6337660551071167,
-0.2533593773841858,
0.09288511425256729,
-0.3318916857242584,
0.25103795528411865,
0.13508227467536926,
0.5589919686317444,
0.5585927963256836,
-0.018585439771413803,
-0.572455883026123,
-0.9017118215560913,
0.6206467747688293,
-0.4181745648384094,
0.24183231592178345,
0.7102557420730591,
0.31098127365112305,
-0.301696240901947,
-0.42228952050209045,
-0.45049387216567993,
-0.493782103061676,
-0.015314743854105473,
-0.24709296226501465,
0.002212285064160824,
-0.08518004417419434,
0.3519577085971832,
0.2702944278717041,
-0.40823301672935486,
0.26488885283470154,
-0.6956454515457153,
-0.3755171597003937,
0.36138513684272766,
0.24524390697479248,
0.3395506739616394,
0.04128475859761238,
-0.34443530440330505,
0.39621394872665405,
-0.8146606683731079,
-0.4385104179382324,
0.20698583126068115,
0.13045114278793335,
0.5110929012298584,
0.4551812410354614,
0.14767485857009888,
0.1731880158185959,
0.08079861104488373,
-0.3919307291507721,
-0.17797233164310455,
0.24590706825256348,
-0.23961469531059265,
0.24833306670188904,
0.4789101183414459,
0.3358279764652252,
0.5785909295082092,
-0.8927914500236511,
-0.19826264679431915,
0.029513387009501457,
0.6001619696617126,
-0.6708561182022095,
-0.4275243282318115,
0.12056714296340942,
-0.39847317337989807,
-0.24158988893032074,
0.04280715063214302,
-0.7911930680274963,
-1.0431994199752808,
-0.467678964138031,
0.6289303302764893,
-0.5281673073768616,
-0.18011470139026642,
0.25933516025543213,
-0.17552702128887177,
0.15676270425319672,
0.4212045967578888,
-0.9600521922111511,
0.4997345507144928,
0.6626384854316711,
0.771611213684082,
-0.3239646255970001,
-0.2812413275241852,
-0.31520673632621765,
0.13662131130695343,
-0.41615208983421326,
0.7324199676513672,
-0.2513572871685028,
-0.36038991808891296,
-0.16036255657672882,
-0.14560700953006744,
0.031590670347213745,
-1.203668475151062,
0.156924769282341,
-0.38548505306243896,
-0.012346337549388409,
-0.3882504403591156,
-0.5431092381477356,
-0.5036684274673462,
0.01600278541445732,
-0.6489610075950623,
0.47869551181793213,
-0.348552942276001,
-0.5605862140655518,
0.23000185191631317,
0.14825482666492462,
-0.3627035915851593,
-0.06746520102024078,
-0.3384174108505249,
-0.16199460625648499,
0.5613238215446472,
0.08581500500440598,
0.3514074981212616,
-0.13727256655693054,
0.4488707184791565,
-0.145242378115654,
-0.7243289351463318,
0.26140156388282776,
-0.42939797043800354,
0.5169548392295837,
0.2381688356399536,
-0.38220345973968506,
0.11267988383769989,
-0.7181228995323181,
-0.45937082171440125,
0.13284112513065338,
-0.1680699735879898,
-0.40389084815979004,
0.050942935049533844,
-0.49768373370170593,
-0.02461542934179306,
-0.18054266273975372,
-0.18164344131946564,
0.04545465111732483,
-0.28645801544189453,
0.3384585976600647,
0.8896108865737915,
0.0006941017927601933,
0.25867798924446106,
-0.8304370045661926,
0.20131485164165497,
0.3012057840824127,
-0.07872308790683746,
0.07958033680915833,
-0.35910269618034363,
-0.9918022751808167,
-0.25018855929374695,
-0.3421275317668915,
0.43961137533187866,
-0.6218053698539734,
0.361836314201355,
-0.22910387814044952,
-0.3502950072288513,
-0.36940667033195496,
0.33599963784217834,
-0.1077781468629837,
0.4778680205345154,
0.41730788350105286,
-0.21721602976322174,
-0.6872577667236328,
-0.9131508469581604,
0.04596691206097603,
-0.031258586794137955,
-0.11382512748241425,
0.17941820621490479,
0.37855085730552673,
-0.20237214863300323,
0.5487818717956543,
-0.1465865820646286,
-0.42289063334465027,
-0.20598852634429932,
0.11330224573612213,
-0.07012011855840683,
0.4176522493362427,
0.27575209736824036,
-0.6288078427314758,
0.10557552427053452,
-0.25506147742271423,
-0.9315593242645264,
0.1032300516963005,
-0.4905393421649933,
0.040223587304353714,
0.3060508966445923,
0.44184553623199463,
-0.8160092830657959,
0.4394644498825073,
0.0033939590211957693,
-0.14563553035259247,
0.6342765092849731,
-0.0319276824593544,
-0.14307284355163574,
-0.6768343448638916,
-0.07579221576452255,
-0.17700521647930145,
0.06604070961475372,
-0.6133140921592712,
-0.03980615735054016,
-0.4232938289642334,
0.035308837890625,
-0.2840286195278168,
0.4265415370464325,
-0.1981770545244217,
-0.004959927871823311,
-0.46895232796669006,
0.15369492769241333,
-0.06657233834266663,
0.4592963457107544,
0.18080167472362518,
0.5896338820457458,
0.42239856719970703,
-0.7845542430877686,
0.09371545910835266,
0.04953537508845329,
-0.4143471121788025,
0.2174055576324463,
-0.35782912373542786,
0.300342857837677,
-0.35793688893318176,
0.1520601511001587,
-0.8748675584793091,
-0.13047845661640167,
0.13088062405586243,
-0.20834288001060486,
0.26811790466308594,
0.2747015655040741,
-0.5183008313179016,
-0.31431254744529724,
-0.28099754452705383,
-0.035047344863414764,
0.5872665047645569,
-0.7379956841468811,
0.5894158482551575,
0.4194626212120056,
0.07834598422050476,
-0.36962878704071045,
-0.9549265503883362,
0.518679141998291,
-0.3685697615146637,
-0.4905398488044739,
0.20553840696811676,
-0.2546917498111725,
-0.6282578706741333,
-0.2816452383995056,
-0.3001558482646942,
-0.054908763617277145,
0.13253164291381836,
0.26576390862464905,
0.18345464766025543,
-0.015054631978273392,
0.31071165204048157,
-0.30940359830856323,
-0.04478992894291878,
0.43040576577186584,
-0.24652715027332306,
0.9009669423103333,
0.09863036870956421,
-0.3171689510345459,
-0.296689510345459,
0.14522042870521545,
0.6638098955154419,
0.27512896060943604,
0.9678035378456116,
0.5289252996444702,
-0.6586283445358276,
-0.4238663911819458,
-1.1246713399887085,
-0.5420038104057312,
-0.42849984765052795,
0.40431055426597595,
-0.4468013048171997,
-0.6692908406257629,
0.7541803121566772,
0.14270983636379242,
-0.20897649228572845,
0.09595542401075363,
0.7068355679512024,
0.08457031846046448,
0.689468264579773,
0.15170200169086456,
-0.10744372010231018,
0.052066653966903687,
-0.3535120487213135,
0.4303533434867859,
-0.6544756293296814,
-0.5768604278564453,
-0.1689484417438507,
-0.32131659984588623,
-0.2866613566875458,
-0.3091237246990204,
0.025372479110956192,
0.11083472520112991,
0.025016410276293755,
-0.1449793577194214,
-0.5667308568954468,
0.6990166902542114,
0.4733639061450958,
0.5243247151374817,
0.2790321111679077,
0.27442845702171326,
-0.056682880967855453,
-0.12081355601549149,
-0.6121039390563965,
-0.5088891386985779,
0.9874635338783264,
0.38440218567848206,
0.9091635346412659,
-0.17497989535331726,
0.8522746562957764,
0.1742319017648697,
0.19189922511577606,
-0.7954798936843872,
0.8352569341659546,
-0.003877943381667137,
-0.6005000472068787,
-0.20699897408485413,
-0.5286925435066223,
-0.536342442035675,
0.4479014277458191,
-0.11664994060993195,
-0.86595618724823,
0.1924431473016739,
-0.1258745938539505,
-0.45740848779678345,
0.853912353515625,
-0.4972021281719208,
0.15251871943473816,
-0.2377757579088211,
-0.5714102387428284,
-0.4180072844028473,
-0.3552897572517395,
0.7667277455329895,
-0.23292742669582367,
0.17476877570152283,
0.07446581870317459,
0.140143021941185,
0.6814215183258057,
-0.25528284907341003,
1.1189252138137817,
-0.1549191027879715,
-0.1806264966726303,
0.4075953960418701,
0.44479620456695557,
0.4909811317920685,
-0.08559370785951614,
-0.14306941628456116,
0.11556053906679153,
-0.4045952260494232,
-0.3317868113517761,
-0.6849769949913025,
0.8741700649261475,
-0.7369565963745117,
-0.8936327695846558,
-0.045758821070194244,
-0.7828412652015686,
0.020795345306396484,
-0.28775447607040405,
0.40408387780189514,
0.14178791642189026,
-0.1259000301361084,
0.41834381222724915,
1.0538626909255981,
-0.33601638674736023,
0.17740243673324585,
0.18778608739376068,
-0.48100265860557556,
-0.5681374073028564,
0.9973984360694885,
0.48949140310287476,
0.17846418917179108,
-0.019433598965406418,
0.17091339826583862,
-0.010090291500091553,
-0.8832391500473022,
0.2511882781982422,
0.20321378111839294,
-1.0144996643066406,
0.11270210146903992,
-0.901713490486145,
-0.33376872539520264,
-0.29492390155792236,
-0.1937885731458664,
-0.16252055764198303,
-0.52641761302948,
-0.46642759442329407,
-0.3730173707008362,
0.206081822514534,
0.7604950070381165,
-0.15369899570941925,
0.10832631587982178,
-0.41775503754615784,
0.46418097615242004,
0.4130037724971771,
0.1514522284269333,
0.46810421347618103,
-0.6314708590507507,
-0.20151235163211823,
-0.19125041365623474,
-0.18119442462921143,
-0.5343613028526306,
0.5492349863052368,
-0.11658405512571335,
0.6452516317367554,
0.7299957871437073,
-0.05608871951699257,
0.7440589666366577,
-0.30275025963783264,
0.6399065852165222,
0.15579113364219666,
-0.5907291173934937,
0.2474481165409088,
-0.03288501501083374,
-0.062364500015974045,
0.5917229056358337,
0.4450940191745758,
-0.44533300399780273,
-0.510796844959259,
-0.35222336649894714,
-0.6704854965209961,
0.21559351682662964,
0.017393777146935463,
0.1828051656484604,
-0.2828277051448822,
0.6152337193489075,
0.5384362936019897,
0.23303575813770294,
-0.829901933670044,
-0.03852478414773941,
-0.19251227378845215,
-0.04067772254347801,
0.11776071041822433,
-0.4785009026527405,
-0.17740578949451447,
-0.5903475880622864,
0.4790404736995697,
0.17933115363121033,
0.32448825240135193,
0.14576078951358795,
-0.29207703471183777,
-0.19184339046478271,
-0.09477346390485764,
0.7850461602210999,
0.7117782235145569,
-0.2761126458644867,
0.533390998840332,
0.3618314564228058,
-0.37215954065322876,
0.04977108910679817,
-0.3542226552963257,
-0.2992868423461914,
-0.1767212450504303,
0.3827720880508423,
0.8767607808113098,
0.3298570215702057,
-0.6070822477340698,
0.03000549040734768,
0.1665090024471283,
-0.4036836624145508,
-0.5755900144577026,
0.2829883098602295,
0.23884226381778717,
0.14241789281368256,
0.5390365123748779,
0.0949016585946083,
-0.03721407428383827,
-0.7069118022918701,
0.5399037003517151,
0.4439791738986969,
-0.30437034368515015,
-0.414529949426651,
0.695788562297821,
-0.14659330248832703,
-0.5608452558517456,
0.6932417154312134,
-0.05334053188562393,
-0.5679881572723389,
0.7443680167198181,
0.7582314610481262,
1.0069873332977295,
0.03835367411375046,
-0.0006546865915879607,
0.34488528966903687,
0.5633760094642639,
-0.273264616727829,
0.07952602207660675,
0.29466062784194946,
-0.7439590096473694,
-0.07570726424455643,
-0.5663301944732666,
-0.23173853754997253,
0.43304744362831116,
-0.32228997349739075,
0.05565047636628151,
-0.748315155506134,
-0.022371789440512657,
-0.25577276945114136,
-0.1016339361667633,
-0.5679953098297119,
-0.024926433339715004,
0.5917725563049316,
0.6870884895324707,
-0.5739485621452332,
0.8884448409080505,
0.005872736219316721,
-0.5410477519035339,
-0.3585713505744934,
0.13384591042995453,
0.03342566639184952,
-0.871000349521637,
0.5828986167907715,
0.5377602577209473,
-0.025020500645041466,
0.05028386786580086,
-0.7249318361282349,
-0.5549212098121643,
0.8758876323699951,
0.16148605942726135,
-0.512606680393219,
-0.14724017679691315,
0.12902048230171204,
0.5474480390548706,
-0.6016033887863159,
0.04316691681742668,
0.6413149833679199,
0.5729513168334961,
0.3089272677898407,
-0.44090893864631653,
0.15458306670188904,
-0.10890130698680878,
-0.2858557403087616,
-0.158029705286026,
-0.4938035011291504,
0.7674122452735901,
-0.5058671236038208,
-0.1423579454421997,
0.029184775426983833,
0.5540969371795654,
0.36401379108428955,
0.268811970949173,
0.4374047517776489,
0.730401337146759,
1.1332707405090332,
0.175172820687294,
0.8761882781982422,
-0.2996979355812073,
-0.1831229031085968,
1.1985288858413696,
-0.38963574171066284,
0.5448049902915955,
0.8045526146888733,
0.13947686553001404,
0.3196519613265991,
0.3483160734176636,
-0.21405823528766632,
0.573355495929718,
0.5175449848175049,
-0.14155584573745728,
-0.36890238523483276,
-0.18103723227977753,
-0.16429762542247772,
0.24002353847026825,
0.47421377897262573,
-0.3161540627479553,
0.037716981023550034,
0.3594995439052582,
0.001947592361830175,
0.038183439522981644,
-0.1796974241733551,
0.8010467290878296,
0.324143648147583,
-0.535212516784668,
0.8646252155303955,
-0.5577394962310791,
0.6058695912361145,
-0.2887584865093231,
0.0899626836180687,
-0.42128825187683105,
0.10058333724737167,
-0.16730818152427673,
-0.221354141831398,
0.43764305114746094,
-0.39904701709747314,
-0.05640513449907303,
0.11938983201980591,
0.714806079864502,
-0.39657890796661377,
-0.41832953691482544,
0.5733987092971802,
0.5056593418121338,
0.3909054100513458,
-0.2426791936159134,
-0.16214172542095184,
0.07583339512348175,
0.00023868655262049288,
-0.30949389934539795,
0.48100540041923523,
0.5448099374771118,
0.15004009008407593,
0.9897090196609497,
0.5584078431129456,
0.2954248785972595,
0.26117923855781555,
0.23294827342033386,
0.9988620281219482,
-0.8203999400138855,
-0.14174464344978333,
-1.0128520727157593,
0.13929146528244019,
-0.04684172570705414,
-0.012523271143436432,
0.532049834728241,
0.4459870755672455,
0.543523371219635,
-0.07469934970140457,
0.5647318363189697,
0.3855610489845276,
0.18833500146865845,
-0.583013653755188,
0.8921118974685669,
-0.4859529435634613,
0.6518987417221069,
0.2820315361022949,
-0.8465597629547119,
-0.4313027560710907,
0.6744005680084229,
-0.23325790464878082,
-0.058970022946596146,
0.8008190393447876,
1.0985692739486694,
0.155683234333992,
0.16171592473983765,
0.6791890859603882,
0.538467288017273,
0.31008195877075195,
0.53287273645401,
1.0097172260284424,
-0.03217465803027153,
0.568552553653717,
-0.5195137858390808,
-0.03101927414536476,
-0.28751206398010254,
-0.39442843198776245,
-1.3155173063278198,
-0.23607052862644196,
-0.09076233208179474,
-0.23663288354873657,
0.14809603989124298,
1.0482184886932373,
0.5014238357543945,
-0.9060882329940796,
-0.1522705852985382,
-0.06039221212267876,
0.17296673357486725,
0.004423679318279028,
-0.23329655826091766,
0.2023405283689499,
-0.5427243709564209,
-0.34669607877731323,
0.4961112439632416,
0.32584378123283386,
0.16770674288272858,
-0.8175984025001526,
-0.18054552376270294,
0.0567111074924469,
0.3460298776626587,
0.5611260533332825,
-0.05136040225625038,
-1.2311326265335083,
-0.3606502115726471,
0.08107227832078934,
-0.3136512041091919,
0.24326768517494202,
0.8647332787513733,
-0.8681283593177795,
0.3260467052459717,
0.4209074378013611,
0.5051770210266113,
0.2254939079284668,
-0.24791833758354187,
0.34055620431900024,
-0.23833957314491272,
0.38100898265838623,
0.27656257152557373,
0.35177913308143616,
0.16581033170223236,
-0.5213061571121216,
0.5878064036369324,
0.35469380021095276,
-0.46454039216041565,
-0.870317816734314,
-0.06762216240167618,
-0.6349812746047974,
-0.6056890487670898,
0.8938879370689392,
0.15592311322689056,
-0.2435542792081833,
-0.22126466035842896,
-0.31357407569885254,
0.004308169707655907,
-0.12069085985422134,
1.6370347738265991,
0.9591513872146606,
0.12844350934028625,
-0.18791228532791138,
-0.6353928446769714,
0.4691862165927887,
0.5572633147239685,
-0.6189301609992981,
0.22212356328964233,
0.41618210077285767,
-0.06425143033266068,
0.21470698714256287,
0.6168293356895447,
0.010597271844744682,
-0.011562229134142399,
0.14104388654232025,
0.16142605245113373,
-0.16821026802062988,
-0.7545078992843628,
-0.37398433685302734,
0.4236801564693451,
-0.0780676007270813,
0.33298248052597046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17639v2 | Mitigate the Gap: Investigating Approaches for Improving Cross-Modal Alignment in CLIP | 2024-06-25T15:24:02 | 2024-06-26T10:58:48 | Sedigheh Eslami, Gerard de Melo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive Language--Image Pre-training (CLIP) has manifested remarkable
improvements in zero-shot classification and cross-modal vision-language tasks.
Yet, from a geometrical point of view, the CLIP embedding space has been found
to have a pronounced modality gap. This gap renders the embedding space overly
sparse and disconnected, with different modalities being densely distributed in
distinct subregions of the hypersphere. In this work, we aim at answering two
main questions: 1. Does sharing the parameter space between the multi-modal
encoders reduce the modality gap? 2. Can the gap be mitigated by pushing apart
the uni-modal embeddings via intra-modality separation? We design AlignCLIP, in
order to answer these questions and show that answers to both questions are
positive. Through extensive experiments, we show that AlignCLIP achieves
noticeable enhancements in the cross-modal alignment of the embeddings, and
thereby, reduces the modality gap, while maintaining the performance across
several downstream evaluations, such as zero-shot image classification,
zero-shot multi-modal retrieval and zero-shot semantic text similarity. | [
-0.7055721879005432,
-0.44555410742759705,
0.39896631240844727,
-0.016023360192775726,
-0.5342980623245239,
0.12869136035442352,
-0.216875821352005,
-0.6045960187911987,
0.3906787931919098,
-0.05186590924859047,
-0.6494751572608948,
-0.2977848947048187,
-0.4760285019874573,
-0.0376284159719944,
0.08687137067317963,
0.6332873702049255,
-0.2702445089817047,
0.24973653256893158,
-0.5151187181472778,
-0.40553879737854004,
-0.7585655450820923,
-0.3174181878566742,
0.18409951031208038,
0.05051257088780403,
0.11383131891489029,
0.2869013547897339,
1.0360933542251587,
0.8077892661094666,
0.4973547160625458,
0.19310928881168365,
0.10670097172260284,
-0.001225221436470747,
-0.40789976716041565,
0.02509474568068981,
-0.15461978316307068,
-0.28341561555862427,
-0.13992543518543243,
-0.07912621647119522,
0.7114821076393127,
0.6339515447616577,
0.08591514080762863,
-0.02367403544485569,
0.1969374120235443,
0.14898155629634857,
-1.033403992652893,
-0.2784958779811859,
-0.3103967010974884,
0.14047540724277496,
-0.5463736653327942,
-0.17014026641845703,
0.07378140091896057,
0.00880394782871008,
0.10866018384695053,
-0.8746832609176636,
0.19549576938152313,
0.12126412242650986,
1.08231782913208,
0.31603795289993286,
-0.2712258994579315,
0.1554834097623825,
-0.44377535581588745,
0.9915955066680908,
-0.576552152633667,
0.7015907168388367,
0.06849396228790283,
0.1915946751832962,
0.1722683310508728,
-0.23194578289985657,
-0.5674402713775635,
0.4182731509208679,
0.09033405780792236,
0.20965315401554108,
-0.13038799166679382,
0.02787487953901291,
0.050964877009391785,
0.3401511609554291,
-0.52334064245224,
0.17290054261684418,
-0.41368618607521057,
-0.3971700072288513,
0.18753741681575775,
0.22650490701198578,
0.44875311851501465,
-0.14553099870681763,
-0.784124493598938,
-0.2552565336227417,
-0.9997856616973877,
0.255635529756546,
0.46268853545188904,
-0.01521818246692419,
-0.05465035140514374,
0.5943748354911804,
0.13290248811244965,
0.6884543299674988,
0.1697298139333725,
-0.1757519245147705,
0.12240909039974213,
-0.6851130723953247,
-0.09765830636024475,
0.01296417135745287,
0.7399809956550598,
0.7322322726249695,
-0.2666499614715576,
-0.03976422920823097,
-0.00881114974617958,
0.3217617869377136,
0.03757869079709053,
-0.7901883721351624,
-0.07975868135690689,
-0.21500477194786072,
-0.2425663024187088,
0.15533073246479034,
0.24196051061153412,
-0.6463263034820557,
0.0495934896171093,
-0.35503360629081726,
0.70384681224823,
-0.4452955722808838,
0.0134018175303936,
0.22644712030887604,
-0.30193448066711426,
0.4265750050544739,
0.41296833753585815,
-0.6735514402389526,
0.4238109886646271,
0.5209916830062866,
0.8844026327133179,
-0.16965033113956451,
-0.3522554337978363,
-0.23311197757720947,
0.44956091046333313,
-0.031103843823075294,
0.8089669942855835,
-0.908860981464386,
-0.4123706817626953,
-0.03132927790284157,
0.024800237268209457,
-0.20599184930324554,
-0.43654316663742065,
0.32658258080482483,
-0.23774001002311707,
0.6736369729042053,
-0.6012887358665466,
-0.5137261748313904,
-0.10576920211315155,
0.31857067346572876,
-0.6090424060821533,
0.7516837120056152,
-0.026955770328640938,
-0.793682873249054,
0.5553181171417236,
-0.38244009017944336,
-0.24202997982501984,
-0.09002246707677841,
-0.537359356880188,
-0.48228225111961365,
0.09129207581281662,
0.687850296497345,
-0.01815417781472206,
-0.38471511006355286,
-0.22268249094486237,
-0.49429580569267273,
-0.6071777939796448,
0.26648369431495667,
-0.28263044357299805,
0.4528324007987976,
-0.003112292382866144,
-0.3757493495941162,
0.07277203351259232,
-0.27943676710128784,
0.15134920179843903,
-0.23398958146572113,
0.19966520369052887,
-0.6866162419319153,
-0.2655353248119354,
0.11282217502593994,
0.4619474709033966,
0.01853184401988983,
-0.764822781085968,
0.2643938362598419,
-0.11317440867424011,
0.3720115125179291,
0.6759666800498962,
0.02103634923696518,
0.5661093592643738,
-0.42320382595062256,
0.7579687833786011,
0.317595899105072,
0.37233230471611023,
-0.3103557527065277,
-0.13975073397159576,
-0.5156763195991516,
-0.7623810768127441,
0.34565675258636475,
0.3100232779979706,
-0.62907475233078,
0.3479786813259125,
-0.13778162002563477,
-0.16001777350902557,
-0.7183616757392883,
0.160526841878891,
0.7162397503852844,
0.4792814254760742,
0.37062835693359375,
-0.893441915512085,
-0.382259339094162,
-0.9177333116531372,
0.05141964554786682,
0.345735639333725,
0.058693353086709976,
0.23222777247428894,
0.22911962866783142,
-0.07309966534376144,
0.9876774549484253,
-0.6026400327682495,
-0.4046526253223419,
0.031183354556560516,
-0.1109767034649849,
-0.2454073578119278,
0.6705212593078613,
0.7163732647895813,
-0.7179954051971436,
-0.33418792486190796,
-0.25116413831710815,
-0.3463953137397766,
-0.2376318722963333,
-0.06660281121730804,
-0.2827495038509369,
-0.1279965490102768,
0.6382690668106079,
-0.49881067872047424,
0.5809102654457092,
0.4328208267688751,
-0.19462186098098755,
0.2910597324371338,
0.07905743271112442,
0.300127774477005,
-0.8890460133552551,
0.08781475573778152,
-0.3179337680339813,
-0.3696208894252777,
-0.18237315118312836,
-0.27621716260910034,
-0.03566691651940346,
-0.3332670032978058,
-0.7195465564727783,
0.222601056098938,
-0.6704375147819519,
-0.2163817435503006,
-0.17832650244235992,
0.41676583886146545,
0.3974170684814453,
0.5309728384017944,
0.11372505873441696,
1.0544021129608154,
0.7578486800193787,
-0.3692283630371094,
-0.2570391595363617,
0.6041814088821411,
-0.19818444550037384,
0.7686254382133484,
-0.7776941657066345,
-0.09157989174127579,
0.025731200352311134,
0.27166274189949036,
-1.0565433502197266,
-0.07385911792516708,
0.37688690423965454,
-0.15536333620548248,
0.3736777901649475,
-0.005599025636911392,
0.028810637071728706,
0.0906357690691948,
-0.8057714104652405,
1.2738845348358154,
0.34795427322387695,
-0.3602958619594574,
0.1653003692626953,
0.45845645666122437,
-0.09659550338983536,
-0.7469004988670349,
-0.5797702670097351,
-0.22551217675209045,
-0.02068600058555603,
-0.5604972839355469,
0.6464643478393555,
-0.022806955501437187,
0.2741944193840027,
0.42685577273368835,
-0.3035317659378052,
-0.06843235343694687,
-0.28831085562705994,
0.35222673416137695,
0.2730651795864105,
-0.34280019998550415,
0.015608027577400208,
0.18927143514156342,
0.03522000461816788,
-0.3906441032886505,
-0.10900241136550903,
0.5231456160545349,
-0.1247032880783081,
-0.7790203094482422,
-0.45557233691215515,
0.6228044629096985,
0.6191064119338989,
-0.3581785559654236,
0.3528887927532196,
0.4323153793811798,
-0.15320852398872375,
0.20766088366508484,
-0.476642906665802,
0.05266619473695755,
-0.4294182360172272,
0.15127213299274445,
-0.19231416285037994,
-1.1640985012054443,
0.37897858023643494,
-0.14846719801425934,
-0.20554472506046295,
0.10504978150129318,
0.3647644519805908,
-0.008561339229345322,
0.9692618250846863,
1.0188391208648682,
0.1328985095024109,
0.8781355023384094,
-0.2337149828672409,
0.30961570143699646,
-1.258313536643982,
-0.2015271633863449,
-0.11283747106790543,
-0.5207776427268982,
-0.08484472334384918,
-0.7715535759925842,
0.365357369184494,
0.4265860915184021,
-0.1123356893658638,
0.5970615148544312,
-0.4035731256008148,
0.864458441734314,
0.361029714345932,
0.06659667938947678,
0.13251221179962158,
-0.2135998010635376,
-0.19812016189098358,
-0.6159301400184631,
-0.833096444606781,
-0.17089183628559113,
0.6579121947288513,
0.13744884729385376,
0.9200025796890259,
0.14878372848033905,
0.6239804029464722,
0.033673811703920364,
-0.14569546282291412,
-0.629939079284668,
0.39928966760635376,
0.01913243532180786,
-0.3712373971939087,
-0.046740248799324036,
-0.038095179945230484,
-0.7365924119949341,
0.43181294202804565,
-0.4022429287433624,
-0.5045247673988342,
0.6264798045158386,
0.17188231647014618,
-0.3461456298828125,
0.18575382232666016,
-0.4785211682319641,
1.0791999101638794,
-0.24025534093379974,
-0.5004638433456421,
-0.18216122686862946,
-0.9020196795463562,
0.3322087526321411,
0.17713545262813568,
-0.025340843945741653,
-0.0884033739566803,
-0.26517173647880554,
0.4508589506149292,
-0.6077246069908142,
0.9050373435020447,
0.09202031791210175,
0.26616641879081726,
0.32061752676963806,
0.18156182765960693,
-0.23090049624443054,
-0.028226999565958977,
0.529287576675415,
0.1695380061864853,
0.22572223842144012,
-0.4662275016307831,
-0.7517393231391907,
0.3140271306037903,
-0.6916772127151489,
-0.42151352763175964,
-0.3403981924057007,
-0.5954093933105469,
-0.329336553812027,
0.2103663682937622,
0.48510438203811646,
0.7697353959083557,
-0.35604867339134216,
0.21880096197128296,
0.4514870345592499,
-0.041580747812986374,
0.6220925450325012,
0.2742764353752136,
-0.11388517916202545,
-0.8375867605209351,
0.6128695607185364,
-0.10311564803123474,
0.5076751112937927,
0.3360382318496704,
0.06984014809131622,
-0.3535180687904358,
-0.17507319152355194,
-0.5006332397460938,
0.4302746057510376,
-0.5970927476882935,
-0.5319918394088745,
-0.16080649197101593,
0.1392604410648346,
-0.44523733854293823,
-0.6740570664405823,
-0.48714256286621094,
-0.628899335861206,
-0.2080547958612442,
0.18728788197040558,
-0.12273462861776352,
0.37931033968925476,
-0.21684424579143524,
0.45302388072013855,
-0.8925644755363464,
0.03686472028493881,
0.18959732353687286,
0.33327481150627136,
-0.16451184451580048,
-0.3883230984210968,
-0.15958452224731445,
-0.1241476759314537,
-0.5404642224311829,
-0.6318283677101135,
0.18313845992088318,
0.37372341752052307,
0.5589318871498108,
0.7436457276344299,
-0.004182308912277222,
1.3725610971450806,
-0.5680870413780212,
0.97674161195755,
0.8329178094863892,
-1.3632086515426636,
0.3560706079006195,
-0.10519161820411682,
0.42804592847824097,
0.6449957489967346,
0.47332295775413513,
-0.5127826929092407,
-0.4554750323295593,
-0.4092516005039215,
-0.8043830394744873,
0.5397704243659973,
0.01442505419254303,
-0.018564777448773384,
0.05261312797665596,
-0.05476199835538864,
0.3814851939678192,
0.3324119448661804,
-0.6395649909973145,
0.20121566951274872,
-0.540824830532074,
-0.24210727214813232,
0.3478240668773651,
-0.05052144452929497,
-0.5817039608955383,
-0.4671713709831238,
0.2198016345500946,
-0.21469199657440186,
0.2990131080150604,
0.44429823756217957,
-0.4192446768283844,
-0.212068572640419,
0.24414348602294922,
0.9398800134658813,
0.8160624504089355,
0.2150600403547287,
0.3185917139053345,
-0.07493811100721359,
-0.5068732500076294,
0.09772365540266037,
-0.1356458067893982,
-0.20266488194465637,
0.04752223193645477,
0.3310336172580719,
0.8337308764457703,
0.576845109462738,
-0.7251772284507751,
1.2029975652694702,
0.07110818475484848,
-0.0898439809679985,
0.17518916726112366,
-0.21160642802715302,
-0.362037718296051,
0.30621665716171265,
-0.05636023357510567,
0.16583587229251862,
-0.015783479437232018,
-0.585044801235199,
0.3747999370098114,
0.6645611524581909,
-0.47760531306266785,
-0.6500993967056274,
0.6496848464012146,
0.1805453598499298,
-0.08835018426179886,
0.22694504261016846,
0.23890310525894165,
-0.9769794344902039,
0.09825663268566132,
0.8678407073020935,
0.6364564299583435,
0.031110329553484917,
0.155208021402359,
0.007204308640211821,
0.08961755037307739,
0.12298383563756943,
0.10967640578746796,
-0.5413814187049866,
-0.657395601272583,
-0.44126176834106445,
-0.20371370017528534,
-0.6843776106834412,
-0.3615786135196686,
-0.7109914422035217,
0.3680378496646881,
-0.4404330253601074,
-0.09310118854045868,
-0.42112216353416443,
-0.3523852527141571,
-0.6312963962554932,
-0.17982667684555054,
0.17674821615219116,
0.5509457588195801,
-1.0133144855499268,
0.5331655144691467,
0.6570051908493042,
-0.6468182802200317,
-0.6882410049438477,
0.1886221468448639,
-0.05540397763252258,
-0.7099063992500305,
0.4586119055747986,
0.3511861264705658,
-0.5394288897514343,
-0.524701714515686,
-0.6450852751731873,
-1.0514192581176758,
0.9825212359428406,
0.4589158594608307,
-0.42643284797668457,
0.15944066643714905,
0.11815233528614044,
0.3335937261581421,
-0.4024682939052582,
0.2444653958082199,
0.12054204940795898,
0.10981354862451553,
0.1358499675989151,
-1.036084771156311,
0.14166927337646484,
-0.07175426185131073,
0.05144881829619408,
0.5521559715270996,
-0.7693278789520264,
0.8048086762428284,
0.02842791937291622,
-0.47794967889785767,
-0.06910088658332825,
0.508557140827179,
-0.13298195600509644,
0.22437696158885956,
0.5458835959434509,
0.8782590627670288,
0.38630905747413635,
0.07539671659469604,
0.6216322183609009,
-0.34151968359947205,
0.2585068345069885,
1.0883500576019287,
-0.4871682822704315,
0.7884885668754578,
0.8903602361679077,
0.08801284432411194,
0.5698936581611633,
0.2741415798664093,
0.046394165605306625,
0.8054777383804321,
-0.24159932136535645,
-0.18154874444007874,
-0.42209392786026,
-0.3020079731941223,
-0.4828713834285736,
0.5411522388458252,
0.13426022231578827,
0.12949112057685852,
-0.48927605152130127,
0.3013913631439209,
-0.0014782063663005829,
0.1397172212600708,
-0.12518379092216492,
0.5110259056091309,
-0.04766390472650528,
-0.4609283208847046,
0.35878413915634155,
-0.49311569333076477,
0.6927893757820129,
-0.6825224757194519,
-0.12808091938495636,
0.006395939737558365,
0.2250393033027649,
-0.12824203073978424,
-0.7635068297386169,
0.22060170769691467,
-0.42450225353240967,
-0.09733708947896957,
-0.2297501116991043,
0.5283148288726807,
-0.7697710394859314,
0.020836424082517624,
0.11380968242883682,
0.3431202471256256,
-0.035836536437273026,
0.3110629618167877,
-0.5283696055412292,
0.45197951793670654,
-0.27239471673965454,
0.20247861742973328,
0.35825228691101074,
0.49012279510498047,
-0.18142327666282654,
0.14977331459522247,
0.49933040142059326,
-0.0011556596728041768,
0.27487486600875854,
-0.14594633877277374,
1.281510353088379,
-0.6536810398101807,
-0.5805314779281616,
-0.7027142643928528,
0.2582504451274872,
-0.1620894968509674,
-0.6087175011634827,
0.7818486094474792,
0.7403527498245239,
1.145570158958435,
-0.07226236164569855,
0.37725546956062317,
-0.2763417065143585,
0.3719213604927063,
-0.6597388386726379,
0.1511509120464325,
-0.6743074059486389,
0.10724356025457382,
-0.5263489484786987,
-1.029086947441101,
-0.5528221130371094,
0.5189757347106934,
-0.18957485258579254,
-0.26862961053848267,
0.8871023654937744,
0.7705279588699341,
-0.3772667348384857,
-0.3864746391773224,
0.3602662682533264,
-0.44508689641952515,
0.37751996517181396,
0.7331092953681946,
1.0156121253967285,
-0.5873771905899048,
0.786027729511261,
-0.3437544107437134,
-0.06156691163778305,
-0.25704464316368103,
-0.9056254625320435,
-0.6441507339477539,
-0.5047536492347717,
-0.3514662981033325,
0.03407015651464462,
-0.21680688858032227,
0.7844846248626709,
0.8017035722732544,
-0.48078522086143494,
-0.08897049725055695,
0.19134077429771423,
0.056912053376436234,
-0.1959066540002823,
-0.16152694821357727,
0.3493472933769226,
-0.26518580317497253,
-0.6244993805885315,
0.31357792019844055,
0.6678894758224487,
0.21624049544334412,
-0.14135664701461792,
0.023884110152721405,
-0.0903513953089714,
-0.028979871422052383,
0.3640657961368561,
0.6678932905197144,
-0.7224295735359192,
-0.6339397430419922,
0.2985009253025055,
-0.13273252546787262,
0.37169498205184937,
1.4449108839035034,
-0.7749575972557068,
0.5634781122207642,
0.5721718668937683,
0.8200504779815674,
0.33430323004722595,
0.39120805263519287,
0.8414993286132812,
-0.8064054250717163,
0.46237653493881226,
0.20331135392189026,
0.47570309042930603,
0.36456942558288574,
-0.043784599751234055,
0.23329056799411774,
0.33458152413368225,
-0.5401895046234131,
-0.802142858505249,
0.4435219168663025,
-1.3775391578674316,
-0.3411632478237152,
0.695745050907135,
-0.002600079169496894,
-0.34038543701171875,
-0.12772876024246216,
-0.47332531213760376,
0.1888768970966339,
-0.11249403655529022,
0.4422112703323364,
0.6361196637153625,
-0.3914484977722168,
-0.17526206374168396,
-0.06245908513665199,
0.3440149128437042,
0.8489820957183838,
-0.4236477017402649,
-0.15905649960041046,
0.7514451742172241,
0.3573800325393677,
0.2433994561433792,
0.46100735664367676,
-0.5309509038925171,
0.5103421211242676,
-0.06254220753908157,
0.041059352457523346,
-0.23545342683792114,
-0.46634095907211304,
-0.5308407545089722,
0.031082110479474068,
-0.1526803970336914,
-0.7346336245536804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17633v1 | Knowledge Distillation in Automated Annotation: Supervised Text Classification with LLM-Generated Training Labels | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | 2024-06-25T15:20:25 | Nicholas Pangakis, Samuel Wolken | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Computational social science (CSS) practitioners often rely on human-labeled
data to fine-tune supervised text classifiers. We assess the potential for
researchers to augment or replace human-generated training data with surrogate
training labels from generative large language models (LLMs). We introduce a
recommended workflow and test this LLM application by replicating 14
classification tasks and measuring performance. We employ a novel corpus of
English-language text classification data sets from recent CSS articles in
high-impact journals. Because these data sets are stored in password-protected
archives, our analyses are less prone to issues of contamination. For each
task, we compare supervised classifiers fine-tuned using GPT-4 labels against
classifiers fine-tuned with human annotations and against labels from GPT-4 and
Mistral-7B with few-shot in-context learning. Our findings indicate that
supervised classification models fine-tuned on LLM-generated labels perform
comparably to models fine-tuned with labels from human annotators. Fine-tuning
models using LLM-generated labels can be a fast, efficient and cost-effective
method of building supervised text classifiers. | [
-0.3770964443683624,
-0.6673553586006165,
0.5092944502830505,
-0.13352344930171967,
-0.24386340379714966,
0.469745397567749,
-0.4793131649494171,
-0.6836443543434143,
0.010188650339841843,
0.5323724150657654,
-0.24283172190189362,
-0.5208709239959717,
-0.7930576801300049,
0.5341577529907227,
-0.5291734337806702,
1.2359567880630493,
-0.07158727943897247,
-0.04381285607814789,
-0.3572753965854645,
0.08549743890762329,
-0.02818794548511505,
-0.8116207718849182,
-0.6504751443862915,
-0.6231200695037842,
0.6471683382987976,
0.19668571650981903,
0.5123313665390015,
0.781484842300415,
0.3715461790561676,
0.39839544892311096,
-0.26169174909591675,
0.4643290936946869,
-0.42068538069725037,
-0.00557211646810174,
-0.21120761334896088,
-0.3874516785144806,
-0.23656824231147766,
0.3230424225330353,
0.3435743749141693,
0.7526146173477173,
0.22621938586235046,
0.3276940882205963,
0.4082353711128235,
0.5728477239608765,
-0.6751518845558167,
0.3073312044143677,
-0.7061246037483215,
-0.03255244344472885,
-0.2401990294456482,
-0.21236523985862732,
-0.5225115418434143,
-0.4662265479564667,
0.009010644629597664,
-0.7145475149154663,
0.4530622363090515,
0.11495385318994522,
0.7524241805076599,
0.6607974767684937,
-0.10433077812194824,
-0.30730798840522766,
-0.761685848236084,
0.6724687218666077,
-0.3223828971385956,
0.04498729854822159,
0.6541826128959656,
0.24289891123771667,
-0.1582193672657013,
-0.9212287664413452,
-0.44466784596443176,
-0.24108418822288513,
-0.24257542192935944,
0.01024805847555399,
-0.06042284145951271,
0.13458505272865295,
0.478973388671875,
0.31136995553970337,
-0.1780233532190323,
0.27534809708595276,
-0.49694007635116577,
-0.2362845093011856,
0.9144600033760071,
-0.04732593894004822,
0.04601328819990158,
0.010251983068883419,
-0.14632931351661682,
-0.07229132950305939,
-0.556154191493988,
-0.2673322260379791,
0.369590699672699,
0.27518555521965027,
0.09296094626188278,
0.5177000761032104,
-0.42653271555900574,
0.7813819646835327,
0.18763940036296844,
-0.11054415255784988,
0.27415913343429565,
-0.1809217780828476,
-0.1274394541978836,
0.07910194247961044,
0.7934661507606506,
0.2118029147386551,
0.5977470278739929,
-0.2682693302631378,
-0.1684858798980713,
0.15220403671264648,
0.16786718368530273,
-0.7451898455619812,
-0.7382428050041199,
-0.332682728767395,
-0.07246317714452744,
-0.7035812735557556,
0.00922586489468813,
-0.3579787313938141,
-0.7493448257446289,
-0.8106022477149963,
0.17760157585144043,
-0.13526131212711334,
0.1400631219148636,
-0.06473638862371445,
-0.3617050051689148,
-0.32902735471725464,
0.5309607982635498,
-0.9504529237747192,
-0.01822763681411743,
0.5911986231803894,
0.6486790180206299,
-0.26208585500717163,
-0.19593803584575653,
-0.28706061840057373,
0.15959835052490234,
-0.35816115140914917,
0.7368226647377014,
-0.3894914388656616,
-0.12837249040603638,
0.16248564422130585,
0.030416108667850494,
0.24178214371204376,
-0.5933407545089722,
0.5159019231796265,
-0.5209519267082214,
-0.09160716086626053,
-0.3308337926864624,
-0.7053155899047852,
0.035423289984464645,
0.3328266739845276,
-0.6019420623779297,
1.083236813545227,
0.012779699638485909,
-0.9752928614616394,
0.7310839295387268,
-0.3893897235393524,
-0.37953290343284607,
0.2966610789299011,
-0.1926140934228897,
-0.38710641860961914,
-0.0044343783520162106,
0.23380208015441895,
0.8214753270149231,
-0.24523749947547913,
0.5160757303237915,
-0.3901428282260895,
-0.3608136773109436,
0.40596362948417664,
-0.5299745798110962,
0.6957283616065979,
0.16212493181228638,
-0.1354892998933792,
-0.13666030764579773,
-0.9726548790931702,
-0.27374646067619324,
-0.12191711366176605,
-0.585563063621521,
-0.6002878546714783,
0.021585924550890923,
0.05271344631910324,
0.0590858981013298,
0.31165987253189087,
-0.5012230277061462,
0.28354325890541077,
-0.08642088621854782,
0.5704140663146973,
0.662749171257019,
-0.04573958367109299,
0.3764311969280243,
-0.3941482901573181,
0.16153483092784882,
-0.1928810477256775,
0.048477329313755035,
-0.07409535348415375,
-0.2583446502685547,
-0.7906920909881592,
-0.4989023208618164,
0.4755517244338989,
0.41610074043273926,
-0.9701554179191589,
0.5578461289405823,
-0.15915855765342712,
-0.7820043563842773,
-0.4862411618232727,
0.3129570186138153,
0.19726106524467468,
0.5823930501937866,
0.5090680718421936,
0.10405503213405609,
-0.5569911003112793,
-0.8389268517494202,
-0.2777390480041504,
-0.21856719255447388,
-0.2664714455604553,
-0.024934932589530945,
0.6000747084617615,
-0.35809141397476196,
1.0718193054199219,
-0.6104819774627686,
-0.3560265600681305,
0.04167390242218971,
0.7292929291725159,
-0.3538742959499359,
0.3230867385864258,
0.38675758242607117,
-0.6877478957176208,
-0.5067410469055176,
-0.019023766741156578,
-0.7947593331336975,
-0.5152648687362671,
-0.08787700533866882,
0.14318718016147614,
0.29223310947418213,
0.8162548542022705,
-0.09259851276874542,
0.46747124195098877,
0.19544269144535065,
0.02217112109065056,
0.4295159876346588,
-0.22917290031909943,
0.20613861083984375,
-1.0110394954681396,
-0.037946414202451706,
0.2933492660522461,
-0.2956973612308502,
-0.4830499589443207,
-0.3382937014102936,
0.09681779891252518,
0.2756163477897644,
-0.24875901639461517,
0.31866955757141113,
-0.44957172870635986,
0.2653142213821411,
-0.4894463121891022,
0.12028779089450836,
0.08602146059274673,
0.21666251122951508,
0.16865748167037964,
0.6536528468132019,
0.22300013899803162,
-0.5529642105102539,
0.40847307443618774,
0.13238532841205597,
-0.43190956115722656,
0.5130299925804138,
-0.36962172389030457,
0.11084376275539398,
-0.24890893697738647,
0.3490333557128906,
-0.9491740465164185,
-0.5276914834976196,
-0.023511221632361412,
-0.31647801399230957,
0.42045795917510986,
-0.26676249504089355,
-0.8902132511138916,
-0.30455687642097473,
-0.18979397416114807,
0.23393581807613373,
0.42421260476112366,
-0.6981090903282166,
0.26937219500541687,
0.48159489035606384,
-0.14805984497070312,
-0.3773106336593628,
-0.7671796679496765,
0.12571781873703003,
-0.3523697257041931,
-0.20271484553813934,
0.3673602044582367,
0.13477908074855804,
-0.17326503992080688,
-0.109640933573246,
0.2247665673494339,
-0.12143361568450928,
0.2905980050563812,
0.4596310257911682,
0.15191256999969482,
0.3026891052722931,
0.3437947630882263,
0.29906630516052246,
-0.006895970553159714,
0.050331320613622665,
-0.17466990649700165,
0.13134627044200897,
0.15004439651966095,
-0.25311946868896484,
-0.46574655175209045,
-0.1159173920750618,
0.3447520136833191,
0.009428005665540695,
0.5680723190307617,
0.6696874499320984,
-0.43889400362968445,
-0.07806991040706635,
-0.7606268525123596,
-0.2082270234823227,
-0.4823662340641022,
0.24550238251686096,
-0.11637140065431595,
-1.112349271774292,
0.4076526463031769,
-0.4239603281021118,
0.14051330089569092,
0.4614103436470032,
0.3489254415035248,
-0.4042300283908844,
0.9077824354171753,
0.7777857184410095,
-0.23434889316558838,
0.5875592231750488,
-0.1307523399591446,
-0.19222578406333923,
-0.5687609910964966,
-0.04859817773103714,
-0.6668155789375305,
-0.2306155115365982,
-0.6882244348526001,
-0.3092450499534607,
0.38372573256492615,
0.20756402611732483,
-0.1713252067565918,
0.21137547492980957,
-0.7803841829299927,
0.6435479521751404,
0.5456239581108093,
0.060815442353487015,
0.4721246063709259,
0.09990233927965164,
0.28371748328208923,
0.03995497524738312,
-0.40850141644477844,
-0.711650013923645,
1.1497502326965332,
0.28540676832199097,
0.8037892580032349,
-0.4713618755340576,
0.9799723625183105,
0.42946505546569824,
0.7898936867713928,
-0.47237908840179443,
0.36981678009033203,
-0.28486132621765137,
-0.5359817147254944,
-0.2647967040538788,
-0.31325221061706543,
-0.7746026515960693,
0.08748551458120346,
-0.3869093954563141,
-0.7551780343055725,
-0.03692585602402687,
0.383941650390625,
-0.20143036544322968,
0.13560514152050018,
-0.6956316828727722,
0.4815967082977295,
-0.18720757961273193,
-0.36516958475112915,
0.05400102958083153,
-0.4643273949623108,
0.3144197463989258,
-0.519776463508606,
0.30470556020736694,
-0.05273028090596199,
0.19548657536506653,
0.9046589136123657,
-0.3007240891456604,
1.199876070022583,
-0.110813207924366,
-0.17632143199443817,
0.2942817807197571,
-0.3009187579154968,
0.49519965052604675,
-0.07039255648851395,
0.015067077241837978,
0.26324206590652466,
0.005705174058675766,
-0.09731675684452057,
-0.47405222058296204,
0.45397281646728516,
-0.7757165431976318,
-0.638259768486023,
-0.3532734811306,
-0.4708575904369354,
-0.07880742102861404,
0.018159089609980583,
0.4786315858364105,
0.03190995007753372,
-0.012730775400996208,
0.24582014977931976,
0.6336114406585693,
-0.017870789393782616,
0.26492786407470703,
0.24572278559207916,
-0.023928575217723846,
-0.5261009335517883,
0.709259033203125,
0.41454994678497314,
0.18397396802902222,
0.4330040216445923,
0.1641688495874405,
-0.2529471814632416,
-0.6552594304084778,
-0.4341142773628235,
-0.10334417223930359,
-0.7087036371231079,
-0.466996967792511,
-0.528465211391449,
-0.29594552516937256,
-0.32678842544555664,
-0.3269442617893219,
-0.22455726563930511,
-0.43675729632377625,
-0.6778807640075684,
-0.24240605533123016,
0.6702191829681396,
0.8354174494743347,
-0.16043049097061157,
0.42675459384918213,
-0.5914862155914307,
0.2548244297504425,
0.2082141786813736,
0.051952704787254333,
-0.2663896977901459,
-0.5821104049682617,
-0.38995248079299927,
0.213218092918396,
-0.3542581796646118,
-0.7831935882568359,
0.22530634701251984,
0.11972983926534653,
0.3258765637874603,
0.32937729358673096,
0.3333130478858948,
0.6707236170768738,
-0.4397973120212555,
0.589684247970581,
0.09321381896734238,
-0.6839764714241028,
0.529108464717865,
-0.3375278413295746,
0.1443040668964386,
0.9350408315658569,
0.42547106742858887,
-0.21828581392765045,
-0.6706223487854004,
-0.3222261667251587,
-0.9176555275917053,
0.5510132312774658,
0.02843805029988289,
0.04554237797856331,
-0.05657456815242767,
0.6725467443466187,
0.2384316772222519,
0.2093830406665802,
-0.630081057548523,
-0.18534953892230988,
0.010406868532299995,
-0.428434818983078,
-0.27966931462287903,
-0.25848543643951416,
-0.12420731782913208,
-0.48392829298973083,
0.7503892779350281,
-0.271544486284256,
-0.39602452516555786,
0.11013318598270416,
-0.24349164962768555,
-0.020295407623052597,
0.04601128026843071,
0.3063497245311737,
0.4517402946949005,
-0.018344616517424583,
0.34727340936660767,
0.3178624212741852,
-0.4889240860939026,
0.2419050633907318,
0.44035226106643677,
-0.5809062123298645,
-0.18505997955799103,
0.3333148658275604,
0.609712541103363,
0.06893304735422134,
-0.4028148353099823,
0.20975229144096375,
-0.04947911575436592,
-0.47540193796157837,
-0.43821096420288086,
0.21993276476860046,
0.16706010699272156,
0.277486115694046,
0.3944830298423767,
-0.12435321509838104,
0.27527937293052673,
-0.21593725681304932,
0.1881568729877472,
0.36355704069137573,
-0.24164120852947235,
-0.12589150667190552,
0.6274202466011047,
0.18566539883613586,
-0.08242678642272949,
0.315408855676651,
-0.3628905713558197,
-0.4754721522331238,
0.35286977887153625,
0.27410805225372314,
0.7674417495727539,
0.03544368967413902,
0.18495921790599823,
0.31106317043304443,
0.3635772168636322,
-0.4519605338573456,
-0.22695468366146088,
-0.21734608709812164,
-0.4975612461566925,
-0.5880271792411804,
-0.8831863403320312,
-0.4529368281364441,
0.1882125735282898,
-0.664540708065033,
0.36555272340774536,
-0.3071537911891937,
-0.29666534066200256,
0.4535711407661438,
-0.037450239062309265,
-0.6503266096115112,
0.2115255445241928,
0.30237528681755066,
0.6567186713218689,
-1.1906054019927979,
0.8446424603462219,
0.9518999457359314,
-0.349970281124115,
-0.5118075609207153,
-0.14721277356147766,
-0.08335448056459427,
-0.3070981502532959,
0.8414230942726135,
0.18029171228408813,
-0.0839337632060051,
0.03895360603928566,
-0.8141948580741882,
-0.7224929928779602,
1.156497836112976,
0.41709157824516296,
-0.6926999688148499,
0.2401430755853653,
0.47790205478668213,
0.8173408508300781,
-0.03769981116056442,
-0.0030816069338470697,
0.6664643883705139,
0.3908485174179077,
0.08440005779266357,
-0.9105082154273987,
-0.04095074534416199,
-0.04277915135025978,
0.07432956993579865,
-0.07262148708105087,
-0.4119334816932678,
0.5282601118087769,
0.05575573816895485,
-0.14211328327655792,
-0.08346784114837646,
0.6627169251441956,
0.4162965714931488,
0.4420205354690552,
0.4611831307411194,
0.5429521203041077,
0.9761512279510498,
-0.20003773272037506,
0.5211748480796814,
-0.11775129288434982,
0.2527001202106476,
1.2042768001556396,
-0.2503906190395355,
0.592042088508606,
0.5176129341125488,
-0.15657898783683777,
0.2440103143453598,
0.8003149628639221,
-0.16047652065753937,
0.4076811373233795,
0.5602371692657471,
-0.25171104073524475,
-0.2739885747432709,
-0.16465513408184052,
-0.107489675283432,
0.39193224906921387,
0.3531080484390259,
-0.4877830445766449,
-0.03839525580406189,
0.1812456101179123,
0.06290876865386963,
0.32607054710388184,
-0.2357042282819748,
1.1002998352050781,
0.0027496865950524807,
-0.6660158038139343,
0.6550732254981995,
-0.0006634379969909787,
0.8821976780891418,
-0.12075552344322205,
0.013474802486598492,
-0.054548490792512894,
0.14677736163139343,
-0.32121607661247253,
-0.5921587347984314,
0.23071756958961487,
0.3467652499675751,
-0.27841562032699585,
-0.32610654830932617,
0.9340234994888306,
-0.5391216278076172,
-0.6462310552597046,
0.09390377253293991,
0.2389252483844757,
0.22326047718524933,
-0.10870012640953064,
-0.3468095660209656,
-0.004784971009939909,
-0.09252801537513733,
-0.29785463213920593,
0.4721555709838867,
0.6394691467285156,
-0.23419690132141113,
0.5926194787025452,
0.658470869064331,
-0.03371948003768921,
0.0442454032599926,
0.11021987348794937,
0.9657663702964783,
-0.4336101710796356,
-0.20186904072761536,
-1.1264564990997314,
0.34914442896842957,
-0.3303733170032501,
-0.1511238068342209,
0.5240883231163025,
0.6310001611709595,
1.0493402481079102,
-0.05783820524811745,
1.1678043603897095,
0.14381824433803558,
0.45028558373451233,
-0.35636696219444275,
0.9266791939735413,
-0.3246956169605255,
0.17040523886680603,
-0.32819488644599915,
-0.6599252820014954,
-0.40467482805252075,
0.5323000550270081,
-0.3653124272823334,
-0.08686987310647964,
0.28681668639183044,
0.5390810370445251,
0.11221567541360855,
0.01548815332353115,
0.14028461277484894,
-0.1021270826458931,
0.2983537018299103,
0.20613890886306763,
0.9732532501220703,
-0.09306108206510544,
0.3897481858730316,
-0.5440974831581116,
-0.358325332403183,
-0.1524423509836197,
-1.046417474746704,
-1.234231948852539,
-0.7173842191696167,
-0.7678951621055603,
0.008553828112781048,
0.06081485375761986,
0.7210609316825867,
0.6485079526901245,
-0.6360963582992554,
0.2021578848361969,
-0.2391406148672104,
-0.07341601699590683,
-0.014528190717101097,
-0.22093741595745087,
0.326069712638855,
-0.49197855591773987,
-0.7777443528175354,
0.014002310112118721,
-0.0013628358719870448,
0.36274510622024536,
-0.3438304662704468,
0.19200849533081055,
0.030136875808238983,
-0.21571163833141327,
0.6844251751899719,
0.06803733110427856,
-0.6080323457717896,
-0.31866610050201416,
-0.34558624029159546,
-0.17179614305496216,
-0.29985013604164124,
0.5808131098747253,
-0.8174596428871155,
0.2925141453742981,
0.4188089966773987,
0.7648894786834717,
0.5001445412635803,
0.18265391886234283,
0.2701418101787567,
-1.0420424938201904,
0.06253550201654434,
0.14579427242279053,
0.2806304097175598,
0.4980519115924835,
-0.41929876804351807,
0.609315812587738,
0.18738427758216858,
-0.6572768688201904,
-0.9521926641464233,
-0.08172430098056793,
-0.6529526114463806,
-0.32710400223731995,
1.341907024383545,
-0.24429145455360413,
-0.07860703021287918,
-0.3025780916213989,
-0.33014702796936035,
0.654519259929657,
-0.20203204452991486,
1.1145018339157104,
0.8033314347267151,
-0.07004042714834213,
0.037342168390750885,
-0.6569468975067139,
0.8048025369644165,
-0.04722177982330322,
-0.971856951713562,
0.4226985275745392,
0.6409972310066223,
0.25270548462867737,
0.38438302278518677,
0.5671582221984863,
0.08575531840324402,
-0.14330244064331055,
-0.2588953673839569,
0.3230290412902832,
-0.35042694211006165,
-0.22471879422664642,
-0.023858092725276947,
0.11213962733745575,
0.2122323364019394,
-0.06219693645834923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17626v1 | CoSafe: Evaluating Large Language Model Safety in Multi-Turn Dialogue Coreference | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | 2024-06-25T15:13:02 | Erxin Yu, Jing Li, Ming Liao, Siqi Wang, Zuchen Gao, Fei Mi, Lanqing Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) constantly evolve, ensuring their safety
remains a critical research problem. Previous red-teaming approaches for LLM
safety have primarily focused on single prompt attacks or goal hijacking. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to study LLM safety in multi-turn
dialogue coreference. We created a dataset of 1,400 questions across 14
categories, each featuring multi-turn coreference safety attacks. We then
conducted detailed evaluations on five widely used open-source LLMs. The
results indicated that under multi-turn coreference safety attacks, the highest
attack success rate was 56% with the LLaMA2-Chat-7b model, while the lowest was
13.9% with the Mistral-7B-Instruct model. These findings highlight the safety
vulnerabilities in LLMs during dialogue coreference interactions. | [
-0.6098882555961609,
-0.7819463014602661,
0.3617677092552185,
0.27551600337028503,
-0.09594409167766571,
0.05625169724225998,
-0.23286856710910797,
-0.7372442483901978,
-0.06370190531015396,
0.9426612854003906,
-0.4765726327896118,
-0.5658482313156128,
-0.7513864636421204,
0.2839236557483673,
-0.5459001660346985,
1.0323561429977417,
0.27775296568870544,
0.11404339224100113,
-0.22968780994415283,
-0.19495095312595367,
-0.4128047525882721,
-1.1259171962738037,
-0.7038895487785339,
-0.14735502004623413,
0.3942166864871979,
0.49170663952827454,
0.6245443224906921,
-0.24940288066864014,
0.8798163533210754,
0.26431477069854736,
-0.3006754219532013,
-0.013891525566577911,
-0.6147148609161377,
0.2813030481338501,
-0.13564565777778625,
-0.37876829504966736,
-0.7118082046508789,
0.06108172982931137,
0.3028561472892761,
0.5060745477676392,
-0.23176029324531555,
-0.11679651588201523,
-0.0856248140335083,
0.2488895207643509,
-0.5447028875350952,
-0.10450335592031479,
-0.9167681932449341,
-0.11689910292625427,
-0.012349658645689487,
0.10123555362224579,
-0.8954938650131226,
-0.4174923896789551,
0.3058658242225647,
-0.09997548162937164,
-0.06876484304666519,
0.35704711079597473,
0.5442578196525574,
0.018205950036644936,
-0.42420366406440735,
-0.6350882649421692,
-0.37521830201148987,
0.9454963803291321,
-0.7107561826705933,
-0.021138479933142662,
0.3660750389099121,
0.4205579459667206,
-0.583708643913269,
-0.4207644462585449,
-0.5489552021026611,
-0.422437459230423,
0.10352922230958939,
-0.10040771961212158,
-0.22990088164806366,
0.3827517628669739,
0.12248016148805618,
0.2980230748653412,
-0.32958492636680603,
0.3248460292816162,
-0.09797292202711105,
-0.19611325860023499,
0.6550641059875488,
0.2505625784397125,
0.4833412170410156,
-0.13117659091949463,
-0.7594747543334961,
-0.2090754359960556,
-0.8781666159629822,
-0.1502676159143448,
0.21494795382022858,
0.34794071316719055,
-0.32029634714126587,
0.5032483339309692,
0.01027555949985981,
0.4740806818008423,
0.26127761602401733,
-0.49380773305892944,
-0.05931071192026138,
-0.692920982837677,
-0.17153312265872955,
0.1835019439458847,
1.0241800546646118,
0.6660399436950684,
0.46031641960144043,
-0.2883619964122772,
0.11656241863965988,
0.04337003827095032,
0.3537803292274475,
-0.6579790711402893,
0.09243026375770569,
0.3367213010787964,
0.009951841086149216,
-0.33596619963645935,
-0.040529944002628326,
-0.6996230483055115,
-0.3014305531978607,
0.29426708817481995,
0.12404263019561768,
-0.3013690412044525,
-0.2881788909435272,
0.1911366730928421,
0.17459067702293396,
0.3789229094982147,
0.2084800750017166,
-0.6233765482902527,
0.3396714925765991,
0.8440800309181213,
0.7504054307937622,
-0.5447188019752502,
-0.3964000940322876,
-0.6239048838615417,
0.2162521779537201,
-0.26853951811790466,
0.70978844165802,
-0.28987106680870056,
-0.7126964926719666,
0.16094346344470978,
-0.016808664426207542,
-0.07233311235904694,
-0.4409714639186859,
0.554915189743042,
-0.503041684627533,
-0.1576365828514099,
-0.29978320002555847,
-0.3931984305381775,
-0.1740110218524933,
0.6942323446273804,
-0.5905315279960632,
0.6770322918891907,
-0.5432963371276855,
-0.8056895136833191,
0.05964238941669464,
-0.5250946879386902,
-0.48593002557754517,
-0.2201051265001297,
-0.13786572217941284,
-0.4062565267086029,
-0.2682730555534363,
0.03365771844983101,
0.5375345945358276,
-0.49499788880348206,
0.2908937931060791,
-0.5908685326576233,
0.027068959549069405,
0.4449264109134674,
-0.27144336700439453,
0.7798464894294739,
-0.20402801036834717,
-0.16561323404312134,
0.1537974625825882,
-0.43662694096565247,
-0.04520250856876373,
0.02301291562616825,
-0.18224990367889404,
-0.29451125860214233,
-0.3675861656665802,
-0.2877712547779083,
0.38869810104370117,
0.12209393084049225,
-0.639773964881897,
-0.13896793127059937,
-0.23796190321445465,
0.31867653131484985,
0.37702879309654236,
0.41338250041007996,
0.5114745497703552,
-0.15035951137542725,
0.4118916988372803,
-0.005333938170224428,
0.4323272407054901,
-0.10694991052150726,
-0.5298610329627991,
-0.8191915154457092,
-0.29881247878074646,
-0.14817070960998535,
0.4302172362804413,
-0.45993131399154663,
0.3481563329696655,
0.3124168813228607,
-0.7596330642700195,
-0.04479370266199112,
-0.10170605778694153,
0.74245685338974,
0.2850239872932434,
0.38739994168281555,
-0.10455087572336197,
-0.33130136132240295,
-0.9658829569816589,
0.043998416513204575,
-0.25391411781311035,
0.4751404821872711,
0.36539530754089355,
0.5740669965744019,
-0.3715044856071472,
0.783295214176178,
-0.40719494223594666,
-0.06930779665708542,
-0.455068975687027,
0.14420409500598907,
0.09902413189411163,
0.6057889461517334,
0.7001277208328247,
-0.5524443984031677,
-0.4657694399356842,
-0.3319060802459717,
-0.6591794490814209,
0.04134698212146759,
0.009666831232607365,
-0.33296912908554077,
0.4151364862918854,
0.5252345204353333,
-0.7454695701599121,
0.26979148387908936,
0.9662871360778809,
-0.18614725768566132,
0.6749374866485596,
0.2818179726600647,
0.17373837530612946,
-1.0729455947875977,
-0.18583309650421143,
-0.039520759135484695,
-0.09723535925149918,
-0.9151232838630676,
0.1735895723104477,
-0.13196219503879547,
-0.014882879331707954,
-0.8698031306266785,
0.2383597195148468,
-0.2855604588985443,
-0.04580908268690109,
-0.22898156940937042,
0.0731966495513916,
-0.1468176394701004,
0.38166171312332153,
0.08889643847942352,
0.8053774237632751,
0.407744437456131,
-0.86444491147995,
0.2102494090795517,
0.41138461232185364,
-0.4905678927898407,
0.619655430316925,
-0.8563339710235596,
0.7250233888626099,
0.2774360775947571,
0.4001164734363556,
-0.9885014891624451,
-0.20791079103946686,
0.022912615910172462,
-0.2630375325679779,
0.11209777742624283,
0.01935550943017006,
-0.3623276650905609,
-0.15317580103874207,
-0.1793450564146042,
0.24713706970214844,
-0.02810157649219036,
-0.651488721370697,
0.4620249569416046,
0.9224357008934021,
-0.3835431635379791,
-0.7485255002975464,
-0.5127888321876526,
0.37597760558128357,
-0.13610784709453583,
-0.9051917791366577,
0.036496154963970184,
-0.2697843909263611,
-0.6084021329879761,
-0.49589428305625916,
-0.07485511898994446,
-0.15822842717170715,
0.45311239361763,
0.5329599976539612,
0.30367544293403625,
0.36021003127098083,
-0.21165978908538818,
0.009657933376729488,
-0.24163290858268738,
0.07566043734550476,
0.3150375187397003,
0.8655453324317932,
-0.3499470055103302,
-0.5500997304916382,
-0.37954267859458923,
0.6183565855026245,
0.7991420030593872,
-0.11520469188690186,
0.8467422127723694,
0.14913922548294067,
-0.3258141875267029,
0.07701016962528229,
-0.7185701131820679,
-0.3124469816684723,
-0.4411725699901581,
0.4940016269683838,
-0.25645944476127625,
-1.191132664680481,
0.29769182205200195,
-0.031831350177526474,
0.5098671317100525,
0.24440127611160278,
0.809901773929596,
-0.27603065967559814,
0.7360634803771973,
0.5859373211860657,
0.07010165601968765,
0.12904910743236542,
0.046661198139190674,
0.12890824675559998,
-0.5724301338195801,
-0.473998099565506,
-0.7138776183128357,
0.16156050562858582,
-0.23989467322826385,
-0.42780137062072754,
0.8271741271018982,
0.1275770664215088,
-0.21212728321552277,
0.6304250955581665,
-0.09999999403953552,
0.33015212416648865,
0.3391934335231781,
-0.24501852691173553,
0.5120159387588501,
-0.1736355870962143,
-0.3325742185115814,
0.14571203291416168,
-0.6198350787162781,
-0.5262661576271057,
0.8467084169387817,
0.5492104291915894,
1.1550968885421753,
0.34187328815460205,
0.6734489798545837,
0.10011951625347137,
0.27040258049964905,
-0.6268073320388794,
0.8134541511535645,
0.12241441011428833,
-0.8753209710121155,
-0.5069448947906494,
-0.19450393319129944,
-0.7723839282989502,
0.3037998676300049,
-0.5245671272277832,
-0.39713215827941895,
-0.12425880134105682,
0.21041464805603027,
-0.32082661986351013,
0.0776323601603508,
-0.7402700185775757,
0.6069797277450562,
-0.5007802844047546,
-0.030081812292337418,
-0.43675243854522705,
-0.5014694333076477,
0.6476595401763916,
-0.1404348909854889,
0.25656265020370483,
-0.2858775854110718,
0.2816868722438812,
0.7843693494796753,
-0.35262030363082886,
1.1987662315368652,
0.14317020773887634,
-0.029933685436844826,
0.43787717819213867,
0.186958909034729,
0.6836245059967041,
0.17938977479934692,
-0.09089818596839905,
0.545319139957428,
0.02923785150051117,
-0.18717913329601288,
-0.16237448155879974,
0.7677634358406067,
-0.7951698303222656,
-0.9605717658996582,
-0.5669801831245422,
-0.4899557828903198,
-0.3726333975791931,
0.039493247866630554,
0.18301816284656525,
0.1926349401473999,
-0.4306369721889496,
0.4034821391105652,
0.5387075543403625,
-0.26134738326072693,
0.8250322341918945,
0.5653322339057922,
-0.07187359035015106,
-0.769660234451294,
0.3177238404750824,
-0.2333160936832428,
0.8165297508239746,
0.025082841515541077,
0.06623242795467377,
-0.18440477550029755,
-0.6337166428565979,
-0.34084489941596985,
0.2227432131767273,
-0.65507972240448,
-0.36459043622016907,
-0.8520467877388,
-0.1656126230955124,
-0.4134376049041748,
-0.15147297084331512,
-0.5713154673576355,
-0.21434728801250458,
-0.010026704519987106,
-0.19119955599308014,
0.3189745247364044,
0.693997859954834,
0.26267069578170776,
0.34951525926589966,
-0.9984526634216309,
-0.1957765370607376,
0.46491456031799316,
-0.11278930306434631,
-0.03159911930561066,
-0.2988627851009369,
-0.24345195293426514,
-0.29830479621887207,
-0.19150815904140472,
-0.8157636523246765,
0.17473991215229034,
-0.11016963422298431,
0.6646993160247803,
0.16418330371379852,
0.42272913455963135,
0.2174481600522995,
-0.49560585618019104,
0.8662968277931213,
0.8772394061088562,
-0.773686945438385,
0.12336156517267227,
-0.20801323652267456,
0.35913828015327454,
0.6400102376937866,
0.47923776507377625,
-0.6440825462341309,
-0.3486400246620178,
-0.4079684317111969,
-0.6474998593330383,
0.46109744906425476,
0.08412354439496994,
0.02364550344645977,
-0.25765249133110046,
0.18011365830898285,
0.2611423432826996,
0.28993508219718933,
-0.5666508078575134,
-0.2066672444343567,
0.14489972591400146,
0.012868591584265232,
0.07292024791240692,
-0.5881879925727844,
-0.5571578741073608,
0.14844730496406555,
0.4954485297203064,
-0.24176520109176636,
0.13296377658843994,
0.06923631578683853,
-0.26813891530036926,
-0.008000005036592484,
0.42197850346565247,
0.7951710224151611,
0.4441036581993103,
0.061937857419252396,
0.37094369530677795,
0.5931356549263,
-0.5890969634056091,
0.17649154365062714,
-0.49139443039894104,
-0.007311519701033831,
-0.24946971237659454,
0.545009195804596,
0.7062046527862549,
0.5175861120223999,
-0.6820641160011292,
0.39158400893211365,
-0.13841164112091064,
-0.09690522402524948,
-0.4848348796367645,
0.2477964460849762,
0.14956225454807281,
0.14729708433151245,
0.24245774745941162,
0.013840505853295326,
-0.33592507243156433,
-0.609555721282959,
0.12844309210777283,
0.7339393496513367,
-0.258164644241333,
-0.353910356760025,
-0.024660542607307434,
0.7233656048774719,
-0.3109239339828491,
0.17571978271007538,
0.11085032671689987,
-0.8006922602653503,
0.41490957140922546,
0.5888534784317017,
0.863924503326416,
-0.2410721629858017,
0.032870374619960785,
0.44374537467956543,
0.52961266040802,
-0.005418592598289251,
-0.06066158413887024,
0.32672473788261414,
-0.8985430002212524,
-0.35687023401260376,
-0.4865066707134247,
-1.1995465755462646,
0.1445816606283188,
-0.5359036326408386,
0.15898030996322632,
-0.6629050970077515,
-0.5300899147987366,
-0.24738377332687378,
-0.25221988558769226,
-0.22084565460681915,
0.11729077994823456,
0.15156808495521545,
0.928669273853302,
-0.5513448119163513,
0.6473398208618164,
0.5492806434631348,
-0.0794556513428688,
-0.4211706519126892,
-0.05988673120737076,
0.07242674380540848,
-0.6163291931152344,
0.5567675828933716,
0.046338148415088654,
-0.42665842175483704,
-0.36039644479751587,
-0.6964151859283447,
-0.9137497544288635,
1.0196664333343506,
0.46368369460105896,
-0.8895639777183533,
-0.032812051475048065,
0.331109881401062,
0.17745214700698853,
-0.5390114784240723,
0.11730068922042847,
0.5860401391983032,
0.3568934202194214,
0.1592681109905243,
-1.3252267837524414,
-0.16477641463279724,
0.4105116128921509,
-0.42539897561073303,
0.03065217100083828,
-1.0173571109771729,
0.7147114276885986,
-0.3056061267852783,
-0.1941789835691452,
-0.10966767370700836,
0.5841969847679138,
0.4939119517803192,
0.24459627270698547,
0.7667366862297058,
0.5782527327537537,
0.7523866891860962,
-0.020879244431853294,
0.9342789649963379,
-0.3548184931278229,
0.30588796734809875,
1.345490574836731,
-0.4540964365005493,
0.9776028990745544,
0.4621371924877167,
0.03482994809746742,
0.2745290994644165,
0.20959773659706116,
0.4088320732116699,
0.40640372037887573,
-0.09129559248685837,
-0.2571272850036621,
-0.5755931735038757,
-0.11981286108493805,
-0.2744257152080536,
0.4270862638950348,
0.37944161891937256,
-0.046850983053445816,
-0.10448658466339111,
0.07586564123630524,
0.5729225873947144,
-0.09911832213401794,
-0.2000436633825302,
0.8472539186477661,
0.47032055258750916,
-0.8411664962768555,
0.5237400531768799,
-0.11260636895895004,
0.7481942176818848,
-0.3597048223018646,
0.24686852097511292,
-0.14480233192443848,
0.21122360229492188,
-0.19130457937717438,
-0.8672612309455872,
0.2878623306751251,
0.19208233058452606,
-0.1449347287416458,
0.2776491641998291,
0.746226966381073,
-0.34568801522254944,
-0.13491688668727875,
0.597511887550354,
0.25022250413894653,
-0.056694235652685165,
0.043706152588129044,
-0.5409500002861023,
0.5094007253646851,
-0.2206593006849289,
0.04501518979668617,
0.5716246366500854,
-0.2143341600894928,
-0.08672059327363968,
0.7890949845314026,
0.5327484607696533,
-0.3306376039981842,
0.21199457347393036,
-0.07978664338588715,
0.7923881411552429,
-0.7011650800704956,
-0.245880588889122,
-0.8073209524154663,
0.17618495225906372,
-0.19799745082855225,
-0.2800375819206238,
0.882696807384491,
0.08829835057258606,
0.6295127272605896,
0.05077357590198517,
0.6659863591194153,
0.26705604791641235,
0.39385855197906494,
-0.5358576774597168,
0.8099234700202942,
0.0928933396935463,
0.11430784314870834,
-0.3813435435295105,
-0.7360296249389648,
-0.08859342336654663,
0.2328788936138153,
-0.38462740182876587,
-0.28653502464294434,
0.8731815814971924,
0.7979336380958557,
0.5244446992874146,
0.411187082529068,
0.4412860870361328,
0.32505491375923157,
0.6817784309387207,
0.6187018156051636,
0.8784396648406982,
-0.10882610827684402,
0.8519553542137146,
-0.18887807428836823,
-0.29164552688598633,
-0.29645395278930664,
-0.9454038739204407,
-1.4993058443069458,
-0.2741464376449585,
-0.3917141258716583,
-0.6782380938529968,
0.042541805654764175,
1.1439207792282104,
0.7511895895004272,
-1.0273981094360352,
-0.3942675292491913,
0.13924899697303772,
0.009078803472220898,
0.10046042501926422,
-0.0768093690276146,
0.05120512470602989,
-0.21659442782402039,
-0.8523321151733398,
0.7605366110801697,
0.4776144325733185,
-0.04893577843904495,
-0.47358936071395874,
-0.26063698530197144,
-0.4676452875137329,
0.187959223985672,
0.6460711359977722,
0.1951565444469452,
-0.673191249370575,
-0.5589971542358398,
0.0581614151597023,
-0.4684504270553589,
-0.13855776190757751,
0.7034266591072083,
-0.14536932110786438,
0.14515945315361023,
0.3387738764286041,
0.7911961078643799,
0.3633764982223511,
-0.0930367261171341,
0.5878251791000366,
-0.32243987917900085,
0.10004953294992447,
0.28415772318840027,
0.29959049820899963,
0.3938295841217041,
-0.2995731234550476,
0.46371227502822876,
0.24954071640968323,
-0.6272931098937988,
-0.9142990112304688,
0.4234072268009186,
-1.2661030292510986,
0.07390587031841278,
1.571796178817749,
-0.39471274614334106,
-0.22329337894916534,
-0.4228224456310272,
-0.2573217749595642,
0.026680173352360725,
-0.5298315286636353,
0.5414260625839233,
0.8693047165870667,
-0.21448053419589996,
-0.06708435714244843,
-0.19105949997901917,
0.31674623489379883,
0.40829795598983765,
-0.8958208560943604,
0.009840776212513447,
0.2999859154224396,
0.42467230558395386,
0.5632166862487793,
0.2956371605396271,
-0.13654020428657532,
0.29721149802207947,
-0.17490781843662262,
0.17411980032920837,
-0.18565919995307922,
-0.5029385685920715,
-0.024033905938267708,
0.5977462530136108,
0.2200559377670288,
-0.06275254487991333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17624v1 | Self-assessment, Exhibition, and Recognition: a Review of Personality in Large Language Models | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | 2024-06-25T15:08:44 | Zhiyuan Wen, Yu Yang, Jiannong Cao, Haoming Sun, Ruosong Yang, Shuaiqi Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As large language models (LLMs) appear to behave increasingly human-like in
text-based interactions, more and more researchers become interested in
investigating personality in LLMs. However, the diversity of psychological
personality research and the rapid development of LLMs have led to a broad yet
fragmented landscape of studies in this interdisciplinary field. Extensive
studies across different research focuses, different personality psychometrics,
and different LLMs make it challenging to have a holistic overview and further
pose difficulties in applying findings to real-world applications. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive review by categorizing current studies into
three research problems: self-assessment, exhibition, and recognition, based on
the intrinsic characteristics and external manifestations of personality in
LLMs. For each problem, we provide a thorough analysis and conduct in-depth
comparisons of their corresponding solutions. Besides, we summarize research
findings and open challenges from current studies and further discuss their
underlying causes. We also collect extensive publicly available resources to
facilitate interested researchers and developers. Lastly, we discuss the
potential future research directions and application scenarios. Our paper is
the first comprehensive survey of up-to-date literature on personality in LLMs.
By presenting a clear taxonomy, in-depth analysis, promising future directions,
and extensive resource collections, we aim to provide a better understanding
and facilitate further advancements in this emerging field. | [
-0.6057723760604858,
-0.5301697850227356,
0.818917453289032,
0.4093526005744934,
-0.14105117321014404,
0.3265688121318817,
-0.48800018429756165,
-0.7021031379699707,
0.4669864773750305,
0.37389621138572693,
-0.5188661217689514,
-0.12407935410737991,
-0.7371989488601685,
0.26141688227653503,
-0.6428288221359253,
0.5286109447479248,
-0.20864908397197723,
0.14903393387794495,
-0.3775293529033661,
-0.308336079120636,
-0.2834204435348511,
-0.8254490494728088,
-0.6132627129554749,
-0.4411560297012329,
0.6887374520301819,
0.15964040160179138,
0.12323705106973648,
0.09441125392913818,
0.5681597590446472,
0.3811953365802765,
-0.12035997211933136,
-0.13763166964054108,
-0.3173840641975403,
0.29531118273735046,
-0.39902305603027344,
-0.11717860400676727,
-0.3070814609527588,
0.17414343357086182,
0.7884560823440552,
0.6594979763031006,
0.22869044542312622,
0.23032940924167633,
0.11523544043302536,
0.7759665250778198,
-0.5148168802261353,
0.014493639580905437,
-0.07581696659326553,
0.03164932131767273,
-0.5298158526420593,
0.030099285766482353,
-0.2987883388996124,
-0.26130202412605286,
0.3222491443157196,
0.21549758315086365,
-0.08670361340045929,
0.012251138687133789,
0.4337095618247986,
-0.32859769463539124,
-0.7289369702339172,
-0.3872479498386383,
-0.9824897050857544,
0.837410032749176,
-0.53933185338974,
0.2305125743150711,
-0.08807453513145447,
0.40940436720848083,
0.030410004779696465,
-0.3505793809890747,
-0.6030964255332947,
-0.27568599581718445,
-0.05116096884012222,
0.08062857389450073,
-0.25487688183784485,
-0.37307798862457275,
0.04170745611190796,
0.6744544506072998,
-0.5346471071243286,
0.40880197286605835,
-0.16865861415863037,
-0.11266044527292252,
0.9792792797088623,
0.4092012047767639,
0.22825177013874054,
-0.031189313158392906,
-0.13994868099689484,
-0.11914528906345367,
-0.8352043032646179,
-0.044011328369379044,
0.5393171310424805,
0.006161177065223455,
-0.0454413965344429,
0.4674812853336334,
-0.5179955363273621,
0.353514701128006,
0.13086079061031342,
-0.26130253076553345,
0.29462724924087524,
-0.2841357886791229,
0.05885470658540726,
-0.2955091893672943,
1.025743842124939,
0.23281873762607574,
0.3381187319755554,
0.02505243383347988,
-0.11037706583738327,
-0.30691471695899963,
0.12269172817468643,
-0.8020567297935486,
0.18689802289009094,
0.5693036317825317,
-0.6625235080718994,
-0.133969247341156,
-0.023022489622235298,
-0.9069769978523254,
-0.6708003878593445,
-0.34667646884918213,
0.24227041006088257,
-0.09013327956199646,
-0.6113556027412415,
-0.09697163105010986,
0.3264518976211548,
0.4039573073387146,
0.45579779148101807,
-0.8264572620391846,
0.20805923640727997,
0.6265822649002075,
0.7239336967468262,
-0.6516523957252502,
-0.34274542331695557,
0.0767182856798172,
-0.14966300129890442,
-0.29195937514305115,
0.8502344489097595,
-0.3460296094417572,
-0.41727176308631897,
0.22608135640621185,
-0.003593379631638527,
0.24224421381950378,
-0.5348696112632751,
0.31444841623306274,
-0.2382836788892746,
0.26164910197257996,
-0.583288848400116,
-0.40791019797325134,
-0.026953905820846558,
0.4638858437538147,
-0.36145782470703125,
0.6501079201698303,
0.07279019057750702,
-0.6034777164459229,
0.0623958557844162,
-0.40060997009277344,
-0.22889497876167297,
0.270997017621994,
-0.44947555661201477,
-0.1539795845746994,
0.2012873888015747,
-0.22440095245838165,
0.9201667308807373,
-0.11802035570144653,
0.2606363296508789,
-0.3840031921863556,
-0.043061695992946625,
0.6612277030944824,
-0.0401090532541275,
0.43372663855552673,
0.12458840012550354,
-0.25886082649230957,
0.28710371255874634,
-0.7611955404281616,
-0.04231342300772667,
0.2962571382522583,
-0.18520225584506989,
-0.2537863254547119,
0.2166687697172165,
0.18154732882976532,
0.3509748578071594,
0.6545886993408203,
-0.6060418486595154,
0.27641335129737854,
-0.30263257026672363,
0.3845134973526001,
0.6888271570205688,
-0.18970714509487152,
0.339088499546051,
-0.09576556086540222,
0.5270913243293762,
-0.07394921779632568,
0.16955158114433289,
-0.08003011345863342,
-0.2766245901584625,
-0.6132490634918213,
-0.18827754259109497,
-0.08750584721565247,
0.25620660185813904,
-0.08471893519163132,
0.541688859462738,
-0.1015901267528534,
-0.9430734515190125,
-0.2530406415462494,
0.1257285177707672,
0.40129363536834717,
-0.010146358981728554,
0.01751389540731907,
-0.6261806488037109,
-0.4513498842716217,
-1.0824029445648193,
-0.34675824642181396,
-0.16177622973918915,
-0.009749787859618664,
0.532528281211853,
0.662874162197113,
-0.3597971200942993,
0.7252302169799805,
-0.4000195860862732,
-0.3442267179489136,
-0.44500961899757385,
-0.05691630020737648,
0.08695974946022034,
0.1693039983510971,
0.6248396635055542,
-0.502019464969635,
-0.6507207155227661,
0.06758731603622437,
-0.613306999206543,
0.0809619352221489,
0.22482432425022125,
0.11305353790521622,
0.187615305185318,
0.36332446336746216,
-0.581226646900177,
0.2902132272720337,
0.4394371509552002,
-0.32790666818618774,
0.8031238317489624,
0.052124422043561935,
-0.027437034994363785,
-0.6799691319465637,
0.11488835513591766,
0.04387528821825981,
-0.007864906452596188,
-0.6448553800582886,
0.24060183763504028,
-0.08851314336061478,
0.1878867745399475,
-0.31313520669937134,
1.044596552848816,
-0.5914212465286255,
-0.2908066511154175,
-0.48871204257011414,
0.20801229774951935,
-0.10972516983747482,
0.2205388993024826,
0.19434860348701477,
0.49787548184394836,
0.6125331521034241,
-0.5442310571670532,
0.48735302686691284,
0.32907506823539734,
-0.5860360860824585,
0.869767963886261,
-0.4889528453350067,
0.2079264372587204,
-0.12123171985149384,
0.1460694968700409,
-1.0310488939285278,
-0.4731895923614502,
0.20236897468566895,
-0.17922812700271606,
0.5884947180747986,
0.16368107497692108,
-0.43512019515037537,
-0.4780324399471283,
-0.40434807538986206,
0.1491551697254181,
0.47413769364356995,
-0.4555928707122803,
0.7730140089988708,
0.32498323917388916,
-0.5472285151481628,
-0.2542857229709625,
-0.41690048575401306,
0.1770276427268982,
-0.445810467004776,
-0.33804425597190857,
0.2884331941604614,
-0.4886634945869446,
-0.7174197435379028,
-0.5992327332496643,
-0.07046987116336823,
-0.034315187484025955,
0.17037391662597656,
-0.005068523343652487,
0.06756135821342468,
0.060153279453516006,
-0.0049189552664756775,
-0.4723367393016815,
0.13486400246620178,
0.2975761890411377,
0.2813509404659271,
0.5203803181648254,
-0.5690509676933289,
-0.38498637080192566,
-0.34867724776268005,
0.4151822626590729,
0.5748306512832642,
-0.10268403589725494,
0.5947151184082031,
0.7755540013313293,
-0.020023807883262634,
0.0788181945681572,
-0.8341348767280579,
0.025396911427378654,
-0.44342041015625,
0.5432447791099548,
-0.34499892592430115,
-1.0103727579116821,
0.5866219401359558,
-0.006527295336127281,
-0.0734298825263977,
0.33850520849227905,
1.0302332639694214,
-0.34686627984046936,
0.9309062361717224,
0.6757285594940186,
0.03001326695084572,
0.48576778173446655,
0.059181369841098785,
0.41735872626304626,
-1.151424765586853,
-0.46647191047668457,
-0.4455592930316925,
-0.3837530314922333,
-0.5850098729133606,
0.11492989957332611,
0.08643448352813721,
-0.3552919328212738,
-0.24150575697422028,
0.1548568308353424,
-0.501919150352478,
0.1774713546037674,
0.029327496886253357,
-0.14680631458759308,
0.2883177697658539,
-0.2811853289604187,
0.2741917073726654,
-0.26520949602127075,
0.048410814255476,
-0.794607400894165,
1.1625264883041382,
0.6335837244987488,
0.9651162028312683,
0.5579501986503601,
0.6148827075958252,
-0.029498526826500893,
0.6694129109382629,
-0.9098808765411377,
0.7269861698150635,
0.06411921232938766,
-0.8078628778457642,
-0.32574713230133057,
-0.1915750354528427,
-0.8138720989227295,
0.29081520438194275,
-0.07700678706169128,
-1.2303810119628906,
0.10905712842941284,
-0.0016330191865563393,
-0.07761611044406891,
0.050428640097379684,
-0.49604344367980957,
0.6825827360153198,
-0.5993674397468567,
-0.358296275138855,
-0.09384963661432266,
-0.5095861554145813,
0.7093033790588379,
-0.4353397786617279,
0.23501014709472656,
-0.44179797172546387,
0.02189052291214466,
0.7964016199111938,
0.14739666879177094,
0.714780330657959,
-0.033851753920316696,
-0.474384605884552,
0.09256450086832047,
0.38651901483535767,
0.22131389379501343,
-0.17800703644752502,
0.16506162285804749,
0.15660610795021057,
0.4220242500305176,
-0.037807684391736984,
-0.6910147070884705,
0.7679487466812134,
-0.6645351648330688,
-0.862065851688385,
-0.6474176049232483,
-0.31814810633659363,
-0.5769675374031067,
0.11321038752794266,
-0.17999275028705597,
0.35724878311157227,
-0.4796633720397949,
0.2283463478088379,
0.5550236701965332,
-0.3501216769218445,
0.4107704162597656,
0.7473750114440918,
-0.5887416005134583,
-0.09369836747646332,
0.7874605059623718,
-0.03320419415831566,
0.2714252769947052,
0.18468698859214783,
0.2767546772956848,
-0.5043132305145264,
-0.8167006969451904,
0.03277510404586792,
0.650654137134552,
-0.754578709602356,
0.3519820272922516,
-0.5567501783370972,
-0.10306961834430695,
-0.5693404674530029,
0.1490311175584793,
-0.44135385751724243,
-0.02982761338353157,
-0.365723192691803,
0.28156787157058716,
0.054688215255737305,
1.1023005247116089,
0.3534192740917206,
0.3894437849521637,
-0.4025048017501831,
0.028281426057219505,
0.3782208263874054,
0.5848046541213989,
0.4065062701702118,
-0.5157124400138855,
-0.1317126452922821,
-0.5208012461662292,
-0.5626810193061829,
-0.7916565537452698,
0.40540674328804016,
-0.0313735231757164,
0.7049455046653748,
0.846067488193512,
-0.2928583323955536,
0.34853941202163696,
-0.4172991216182709,
0.7974037528038025,
0.12225721776485443,
-0.7490488290786743,
0.370194673538208,
-0.36117902398109436,
-0.03512905165553093,
0.533694863319397,
0.6819084286689758,
-0.6215438842773438,
-0.08141535520553589,
-0.6075322031974792,
-0.608970582485199,
0.3830360174179077,
0.17565634846687317,
0.301836758852005,
0.04200928658246994,
0.40634867548942566,
-0.03966164216399193,
0.4293147027492523,
-0.9575494527816772,
-0.3221474885940552,
0.0937126874923706,
-0.17365671694278717,
-0.19991227984428406,
-0.39959558844566345,
-0.09647070616483688,
-0.32070547342300415,
0.6291850805282593,
-0.3037753701210022,
0.376321017742157,
0.13902227580547333,
0.1301289051771164,
0.1420183628797531,
0.5716829299926758,
0.49949052929878235,
0.7815935611724854,
-0.3259771168231964,
-0.05386928468942642,
-0.028451958671212196,
-0.3242846727371216,
0.20962461829185486,
-0.2856297791004181,
0.19744303822517395,
-0.27576425671577454,
0.36986345052719116,
0.4351516664028168,
0.20211909711360931,
-0.8634598851203918,
0.7730831503868103,
0.011328603141009808,
-0.05917543172836304,
-0.7413080930709839,
-0.03437376022338867,
0.3066319227218628,
0.3697659969329834,
0.30496537685394287,
-0.37466734647750854,
0.09199940413236618,
-1.0014876127243042,
-0.3711468577384949,
0.7643503546714783,
-0.3259962797164917,
-0.49754342436790466,
0.22688795626163483,
0.21480117738246918,
-0.3082030415534973,
0.23919664323329926,
-0.3046680986881256,
-0.3767673373222351,
0.4461832344532013,
0.24556976556777954,
0.9230906963348389,
-0.24036897718906403,
-0.04039406403899193,
0.2357816994190216,
0.05164062976837158,
-0.12130435556173325,
0.2019379436969757,
-0.00895662046968937,
-0.871757984161377,
-0.25067567825317383,
-0.8142901062965393,
-0.7471508979797363,
0.4657787084579468,
-0.3945431113243103,
0.13992373645305634,
-0.5211385488510132,
-0.06992167234420776,
-0.04141077399253845,
0.286852091550827,
-0.579328715801239,
-0.07078155875205994,
0.4468981623649597,
0.7692628502845764,
-0.6629332900047302,
0.49695679545402527,
0.7234936356544495,
-0.237718865275383,
-0.4021734595298767,
-0.15037472546100616,
0.14548178017139435,
-0.5117700695991516,
0.7791310548782349,
0.1904449164867401,
0.16108731925487518,
-0.11913622170686722,
-0.4310947060585022,
-1.0145514011383057,
0.9571512341499329,
-0.04202067479491234,
-0.45520690083503723,
-0.10209022462368011,
-0.1911165416240692,
0.6586987972259521,
-0.5866631269454956,
0.5528346300125122,
0.7653212547302246,
0.6850513815879822,
0.11075564473867416,
-0.796087920665741,
-0.16327986121177673,
-0.10680734366178513,
0.05998461693525314,
-0.035410840064287186,
-1.076554536819458,
0.6561054587364197,
0.09717725962400436,
-0.24572165310382843,
0.5803021192550659,
0.6780648827552795,
0.4033333957195282,
0.12493202835321426,
0.22491629421710968,
0.1899256855249405,
0.43263182044029236,
-0.16845698654651642,
0.915902316570282,
-0.16839538514614105,
0.34707769751548767,
0.9118350148200989,
-0.7582187056541443,
0.9634276628494263,
0.36986294388771057,
-0.6872240900993347,
0.7842732071876526,
0.7157343626022339,
-0.33677175641059875,
0.17069011926651,
0.2351285070180893,
-0.30256205797195435,
-0.10153059661388397,
-0.05350418761372566,
-0.09750238806009293,
0.6189156174659729,
0.4574728310108185,
-0.29588764905929565,
-0.20478056371212006,
0.14689813554286957,
-0.06236577779054642,
0.05435032770037651,
-0.25924551486968994,
0.48588576912879944,
0.10636355727910995,
-0.6071712374687195,
-0.15457521378993988,
0.025165662169456482,
0.9585813879966736,
-0.7422771453857422,
0.27245619893074036,
-0.15435223281383514,
0.05018523707985878,
-0.3051551580429077,
-1.128787636756897,
0.37890592217445374,
-0.1694691926240921,
0.012948576360940933,
-0.6320292949676514,
0.9341777563095093,
-0.13480441272258759,
-0.10567992180585861,
0.3419121205806732,
0.7303575873374939,
0.5492135286331177,
-0.22236372530460358,
-0.48025715351104736,
0.1929876059293747,
-0.3246447741985321,
-0.3877773582935333,
0.7606507539749146,
0.14095823466777802,
0.1291653960943222,
0.8868939280509949,
0.27177825570106506,
0.007449409458786249,
-0.25146484375,
0.1410043090581894,
0.35814404487609863,
-0.865947425365448,
-0.2618083357810974,
-0.8973913788795471,
0.14661109447479248,
0.06727862358093262,
-0.41408029198646545,
1.0065701007843018,
0.386941134929657,
0.5929536819458008,
-0.14748521149158478,
0.5874831080436707,
-0.12028094381093979,
0.5830583572387695,
-0.2344464510679245,
0.7048752307891846,
-0.5144930481910706,
-0.09463730454444885,
-0.530389666557312,
-0.8235378861427307,
0.05839664861559868,
0.5204322934150696,
-0.4858820140361786,
0.45657458901405334,
0.6718645095825195,
0.39155271649360657,
0.2916037142276764,
-0.14447182416915894,
0.3769794702529907,
0.45568692684173584,
0.21125122904777527,
0.4528617858886719,
1.1451900005340576,
-0.027380669489502907,
0.03570585325360298,
-0.1841733604669571,
-0.2617805004119873,
-0.4243340492248535,
-0.9124789237976074,
-1.1493654251098633,
-0.7569890022277832,
-0.5147063136100769,
-0.19700463116168976,
-0.6146935224533081,
0.7108526825904846,
0.5890909433364868,
-0.4846697747707367,
-0.3653833568096161,
0.4128821790218353,
0.11279302090406418,
0.10388295352458954,
-0.2740984559059143,
0.16112403571605682,
0.03743555396795273,
-0.7034927606582642,
0.26102903485298157,
0.4344586431980133,
0.2932717800140381,
-1.257129430770874,
0.1107487827539444,
0.06119503453373909,
0.1304338276386261,
0.9259068369865417,
0.44429853558540344,
-0.94994056224823,
-0.3880257308483124,
-0.08728224039077759,
-0.0051934742368757725,
0.07050656527280807,
0.8155166506767273,
-0.5284436941146851,
0.2362300604581833,
0.3365216851234436,
0.4552960693836212,
0.3463834822177887,
-0.3256179988384247,
0.2507108747959137,
-0.5350494980812073,
-0.3451727628707886,
0.19599473476409912,
0.5302006602287292,
0.5640762448310852,
-0.43508780002593994,
0.3956095576286316,
0.2475556582212448,
-0.5199870467185974,
-0.7994097471237183,
0.569520890712738,
-1.233616590499878,
-0.147847518324852,
1.248255968093872,
0.044473543763160706,
-0.20376187562942505,
-0.10703195631504059,
-0.055392201989889145,
-0.28173723816871643,
0.06189033016562462,
0.7903634905815125,
1.1814051866531372,
-0.610931932926178,
-0.1650117188692093,
-0.5247845649719238,
0.2703343331813812,
0.25987759232521057,
-0.895455539226532,
0.07797824591398239,
0.2959088087081909,
0.5981706380844116,
0.44901975989341736,
0.8142553567886353,
-0.4133606553077698,
-0.11447613686323166,
-0.695395827293396,
0.30310386419296265,
0.3799152672290802,
-0.21247601509094238,
-0.5724523067474365,
0.18480922281742096,
0.4952182173728943,
0.6324959397315979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17618v1 | Towards Building an End-to-End Multilingual Automatic Lyrics Transcription Model | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | 2024-06-25T15:02:32 | Jiawen Huang, Emmanouil Benetos | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Multilingual automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) is a challenging task due
to the limited availability of labelled data and the challenges introduced by
singing, compared to multilingual automatic speech recognition. Although some
multilingual singing datasets have been released recently, English continues to
dominate these collections. Multilingual ALT remains underexplored due to the
scale of data and annotation quality. In this paper, we aim to create a
multilingual ALT system with available datasets. Inspired by architectures that
have been proven effective for English ALT, we adapt these techniques to the
multilingual scenario by expanding the target vocabulary set. We then evaluate
the performance of the multilingual model in comparison to its monolingual
counterparts. Additionally, we explore various conditioning methods to
incorporate language information into the model. We apply analysis by language
and combine it with the language classification performance. Our findings
reveal that the multilingual model performs consistently better than the
monolingual models trained on the language subsets. Furthermore, we demonstrate
that incorporating language information significantly enhances performance. | [
-0.22116556763648987,
-0.29804161190986633,
0.11395984888076782,
0.22575901448726654,
-0.2522028088569641,
0.43377378582954407,
-0.512951672077179,
-0.8707207441329956,
0.3054960072040558,
0.482980340719223,
-0.5668808817863464,
-0.5290704965591431,
-0.3751663565635681,
0.5062382221221924,
-0.37446364760398865,
1.1299302577972412,
-0.1282082051038742,
0.048086754977703094,
0.06488212943077087,
-0.2535606324672699,
-0.162737637758255,
-0.5208637118339539,
-0.769990861415863,
0.14724460244178772,
0.5745989680290222,
0.2828601896762848,
0.708503007888794,
0.33899492025375366,
0.26759129762649536,
0.3079681396484375,
-0.05278520658612251,
0.2728859782218933,
-0.4318053424358368,
0.2548971474170685,
0.1708819568157196,
-0.43960076570510864,
-0.278175413608551,
0.011622194200754166,
0.7292446494102478,
0.45224010944366455,
-0.14877060055732727,
0.4416816532611847,
-0.13373057544231415,
0.2728731632232666,
-0.0028111343272030354,
0.03546440973877907,
-0.8936660885810852,
0.060775574296712875,
-0.1938968300819397,
0.004057647660374641,
-0.4334790110588074,
-0.1185159981250763,
0.01570209115743637,
-0.6044694185256958,
0.09982506930828094,
0.2765754163265228,
0.9486355781555176,
0.24160730838775635,
-0.3774438202381134,
-0.5736599564552307,
-0.7883918881416321,
0.6789794564247131,
-0.5538827180862427,
0.7638827562332153,
0.15926137566566467,
0.5754572153091431,
0.38356536626815796,
-0.5015798807144165,
-0.35788682103157043,
-0.340667188167572,
-0.13999547064304352,
0.1646708846092224,
-0.03544672951102257,
0.024654831737279892,
-0.05289798602461815,
0.2891514301300049,
-0.5007338523864746,
-0.05867035686969757,
-0.6346323490142822,
-0.24562205374240875,
0.547333836555481,
-0.3776865303516388,
0.6707195043563843,
-0.21145577728748322,
-0.5422523617744446,
0.11342708021402359,
-0.75217205286026,
0.29113060235977173,
0.7394684553146362,
0.9230818748474121,
-0.05177055671811104,
0.4572156071662903,
0.2529903054237366,
0.7755647897720337,
-0.3135465085506439,
-0.15403486788272858,
0.3970034420490265,
-0.19285708665847778,
-0.045773230493068695,
0.24651165306568146,
0.657135546207428,
0.04384247958660126,
0.27243903279304504,
-0.6709322929382324,
-0.45697635412216187,
0.007776942104101181,
0.02286255732178688,
-0.40366676449775696,
0.13907650113105774,
0.21662317216396332,
-0.3550861179828644,
0.14998283982276917,
-0.15017884969711304,
-0.31517794728279114,
0.07565773278474808,
-0.8713528513908386,
0.5399184823036194,
-0.45837417244911194,
-0.2417573481798172,
0.1108405739068985,
-0.004190577194094658,
-0.21520806849002838,
-0.016170131042599678,
-0.4537097215652466,
0.14088226854801178,
0.39607635140419006,
0.7721056938171387,
0.02345399744808674,
-0.46814441680908203,
-0.41136953234672546,
0.2512391209602356,
-0.2610257863998413,
0.5433803200721741,
-0.4698677062988281,
0.0767454132437706,
0.037084467709064484,
0.19057515263557434,
-0.24654072523117065,
-0.2220606803894043,
0.5406776070594788,
-0.6185142993927002,
0.33856073021888733,
-0.17306949198246002,
-0.5805666446685791,
-0.35040053725242615,
0.03273855149745941,
-1.0634301900863647,
0.7200610041618347,
0.1552986055612564,
-0.4177180230617523,
0.10480886697769165,
-0.5387887358665466,
-0.5530964732170105,
-0.144608274102211,
-0.051144588738679886,
-0.33044400811195374,
0.17017559707164764,
0.17198102176189423,
0.2921973764896393,
-0.3309802711009979,
0.14179542660713196,
0.03811671584844589,
-0.386522501707077,
0.41442084312438965,
-0.46420255303382874,
0.7350347638130188,
0.4283462166786194,
-0.05385449156165123,
-0.1376105695962906,
-0.7610388398170471,
0.15458805859088898,
-0.21404261887073517,
-0.4162432551383972,
-0.21086592972278595,
-0.15141452848911285,
0.6280108094215393,
0.5614787936210632,
0.34633851051330566,
-0.661472499370575,
0.1267339438199997,
-0.2962769865989685,
0.2808946669101715,
0.40745842456817627,
-0.2473399043083191,
0.15220589935779572,
-0.3430745303630829,
0.9418561458587646,
-0.32176685333251953,
0.08660801500082016,
-0.030453575775027275,
-0.25587624311447144,
-0.39267778396606445,
-0.350245863199234,
0.6294609308242798,
0.7789203524589539,
-0.8728212118148804,
0.1901896446943283,
-0.42107921838760376,
-0.1746973693370819,
-1.3601665496826172,
0.49101680517196655,
0.6671403050422668,
0.2783690094947815,
0.535300076007843,
0.111366406083107,
-0.7332776188850403,
-0.977108359336853,
-0.26176318526268005,
-0.11690563708543777,
0.07399387657642365,
0.26353347301483154,
-0.019240127876400948,
0.06537186354398727,
0.49381592869758606,
0.025810105726122856,
-0.5034680962562561,
-0.6021650433540344,
0.1712488979101181,
0.581579327583313,
0.34764111042022705,
0.753739058971405,
-0.9032294154167175,
-0.9050881266593933,
0.22221717238426208,
-0.44605153799057007,
-0.23337796330451965,
-0.3668919801712036,
-0.2708624303340912,
0.09352104365825653,
0.409446656703949,
-0.42484378814697266,
0.0045200553722679615,
0.7458593845367432,
-0.26377761363983154,
0.48623985052108765,
0.07088732719421387,
0.40461844205856323,
-1.1862390041351318,
0.17550799250602722,
-0.3722570836544037,
-0.32689622044563293,
-0.8817685842514038,
0.06703543663024902,
0.16347730159759521,
-0.01060155127197504,
-0.4452514946460724,
0.2982693612575531,
-0.6434729099273682,
-0.240299254655838,
-0.20834040641784668,
0.014201303943991661,
0.03784641996026039,
0.4650333821773529,
0.12781788408756256,
0.7365190386772156,
0.7819885015487671,
-0.3693355321884155,
0.4897945523262024,
0.07351364195346832,
-0.490672767162323,
0.5143930912017822,
-0.6281309127807617,
-0.006802476476877928,
-0.46204039454460144,
-0.055111080408096313,
-1.1998746395111084,
-0.11494497209787369,
-0.11067631840705872,
-0.7101171612739563,
0.8758661150932312,
-0.4058886468410492,
-0.6048798561096191,
-0.27899158000946045,
0.16582682728767395,
0.4287465512752533,
0.5112575888633728,
-0.5917503833770752,
0.41392096877098083,
0.2547858655452728,
-0.2729177176952362,
-0.5898505449295044,
-0.5061303973197937,
0.4505630135536194,
-0.38520103693008423,
-0.36101773381233215,
0.41436225175857544,
-0.07708656042814255,
0.011070352979004383,
-0.013308245688676834,
0.1776539385318756,
0.028755519539117813,
-0.1231837347149849,
-0.2306102216243744,
0.15828955173492432,
-0.1919364184141159,
0.6097403764724731,
0.09812501817941666,
-0.09503861516714096,
-0.13963216543197632,
-0.3954164981842041,
0.36070239543914795,
-0.020412949845194817,
-0.36664292216300964,
-0.45200762152671814,
0.6418145298957825,
0.6961995363235474,
-0.49014514684677124,
0.6218751668930054,
0.5870275497436523,
-0.4108206331729889,
-0.20056790113449097,
-0.43379685282707214,
0.2963345944881439,
-0.36795949935913086,
0.3647478222846985,
-0.5496806502342224,
-0.38890817761421204,
0.6907460689544678,
0.23525163531303406,
0.37565597891807556,
0.29518401622772217,
0.2281823754310608,
-0.27806979417800903,
1.0379769802093506,
0.3939943015575409,
-0.2103075534105301,
0.29603198170661926,
-0.25315773487091064,
0.02883331850171089,
-0.9011627435684204,
-0.059828538447618484,
-0.6354196667671204,
-0.5817831754684448,
-0.5433778166770935,
-0.411436527967453,
0.6721062660217285,
0.1132190078496933,
0.06587573140859604,
0.5265489816665649,
-0.4307650327682495,
0.32241564989089966,
0.401584655046463,
0.16415750980377197,
0.21094819903373718,
0.15859174728393555,
-0.1100250855088234,
0.019040275365114212,
-0.5717694163322449,
-0.38157010078430176,
1.0842972993850708,
0.23653623461723328,
0.6711153388023376,
0.5128324031829834,
0.6604064702987671,
-0.05521320179104805,
0.4913620352745056,
-0.524583101272583,
-0.07221086323261261,
-0.48951271176338196,
-0.8241044282913208,
-0.4760044515132904,
-0.38263431191444397,
-0.6876748204231262,
0.19512180984020233,
0.04537253454327583,
-0.45440489053726196,
-0.19247309863567352,
0.26170843839645386,
-0.2510964870452881,
0.336438924074173,
-0.4827224910259247,
0.6164319515228271,
-0.7083679437637329,
-0.23913098871707916,
0.40480586886405945,
-0.797152578830719,
0.10824541747570038,
-0.02397233247756958,
0.8986861109733582,
-0.1133614256978035,
-0.17464202642440796,
0.6435835957527161,
-0.09667161852121353,
0.7700977325439453,
-0.15642483532428741,
-0.35163256525993347,
0.18715478479862213,
-0.10423117876052856,
0.5020486116409302,
-0.15015338361263275,
-0.1683131456375122,
-0.13063423335552216,
-0.11252417415380478,
-0.23162579536437988,
-0.6038922071456909,
0.48580336570739746,
-0.9101449847221375,
-0.06256938725709915,
0.1477220505475998,
-0.548326849937439,
-0.37609899044036865,
0.10462652146816254,
0.4204466640949249,
0.500109851360321,
0.06927746534347534,
0.28084415197372437,
0.4859791398048401,
-0.2380911409854889,
0.31620246171951294,
0.57215416431427,
-0.517336368560791,
-0.7207260131835938,
0.8664523959159851,
0.34528014063835144,
0.5754292011260986,
0.7535524368286133,
0.1038430780172348,
-0.6790566444396973,
-0.2688004970550537,
-0.9108526706695557,
0.2901723384857178,
-0.9059244394302368,
-0.2742997109889984,
-0.6925793290138245,
-0.12200997769832611,
-0.5791304111480713,
0.10824627429246902,
-0.43254798650741577,
-0.6532036066055298,
-0.18825963139533997,
-0.21519403159618378,
0.5410188436508179,
0.5028552412986755,
-0.14306023716926575,
0.2775421738624573,
-0.7987037301063538,
0.5450837016105652,
0.0027240891940891743,
0.4930495321750641,
-0.10369211435317993,
-0.7861062288284302,
-0.592541515827179,
0.10147087275981903,
0.20205892622470856,
-1.1250123977661133,
0.3215165138244629,
0.713642418384552,
0.5736356377601624,
0.1514255851507187,
-0.05954482778906822,
0.8875478506088257,
-0.6798482537269592,
0.5483829975128174,
0.2086784541606903,
-0.8235927224159241,
0.21078245341777802,
-0.10339266061782837,
0.2757872939109802,
0.6694355010986328,
0.5823968052864075,
-0.9572545886039734,
-0.518434464931488,
-0.2208888828754425,
-0.9474323987960815,
0.5137350559234619,
0.1995786726474762,
0.19164599478244781,
0.16408000886440277,
0.33886659145355225,
0.4029732644557953,
0.4648456275463104,
-1.0766905546188354,
-0.3092406690120697,
-0.25224795937538147,
-0.5753626227378845,
-0.4750906825065613,
0.19011686742305756,
0.09464098513126373,
-0.3405473530292511,
0.8985676169395447,
-0.13565996289253235,
0.035450082272291183,
0.10080361366271973,
-0.23105083405971527,
-0.27936097979545593,
0.3084709942340851,
0.18930821120738983,
0.2568538188934326,
0.0638359934091568,
0.03758648782968521,
-0.09323897212743759,
-0.09998729825019836,
0.1999729871749878,
0.18874360620975494,
-0.3155202865600586,
0.3048195242881775,
0.5439304709434509,
1.1023476123809814,
0.48082801699638367,
-0.7221170663833618,
0.16160547733306885,
0.05280793458223343,
0.0925702452659607,
-0.368266224861145,
-0.34706395864486694,
0.23091211915016174,
-0.1710532158613205,
0.26805171370506287,
-0.11259642988443375,
0.26237961649894714,
-0.5243286490440369,
0.3233621120452881,
0.4296458065509796,
-0.5028740167617798,
-0.3035527765750885,
0.7563894391059875,
-0.15663477778434753,
-0.22715812921524048,
0.34276527166366577,
-0.0718393623828888,
-0.9589884281158447,
0.5464187860488892,
0.5925264358520508,
0.823078989982605,
-0.6704294085502625,
0.06997831165790558,
0.45542988181114197,
0.6397498846054077,
0.26211413741111755,
0.6680012941360474,
-0.13592924177646637,
-0.27724793553352356,
-0.5795696377754211,
-0.8897579908370972,
-0.09503085911273956,
-0.025259697809815407,
-0.7125818133354187,
0.3431798219680786,
0.3143836259841919,
0.0653296485543251,
-0.1972540318965912,
-0.2758125960826874,
-0.8969268798828125,
0.43213504552841187,
0.12633079290390015,
0.836689829826355,
-1.0595126152038574,
0.47709208726882935,
0.76026451587677,
-0.2347387671470642,
-0.7628633379936218,
-0.421766072511673,
-0.24256865680217743,
-0.8083012104034424,
0.5630976557731628,
0.31586554646492004,
-0.07761044055223465,
-0.059091225266456604,
-0.35768070816993713,
-1.3302948474884033,
0.7134106755256653,
0.18324242532253265,
-0.5576480031013489,
-0.16052614152431488,
0.48295122385025024,
0.8474217057228088,
-0.4795715808868408,
0.11549229919910431,
0.27816691994667053,
0.5359044671058655,
0.41322407126426697,
-1.0547808408737183,
-0.42417964339256287,
-0.433463454246521,
-0.22739821672439575,
0.13741818070411682,
-0.5186903476715088,
1.0662076473236084,
-0.006177807692438364,
-0.2457728385925293,
0.30532053112983704,
0.5850588083267212,
-0.13870403170585632,
0.12246643006801605,
0.5879731178283691,
0.5305296778678894,
0.6133880615234375,
-0.07337260246276855,
0.8869245052337646,
-0.7356940507888794,
0.2443462312221527,
1.2746049165725708,
-0.3077079951763153,
0.8492487072944641,
0.4189051687717438,
-0.18558035790920258,
0.182356059551239,
0.707185685634613,
0.263406902551651,
0.6153782606124878,
0.3455108106136322,
-0.21001359820365906,
-0.33689138293266296,
-0.07826818525791168,
-0.2520482540130615,
0.5180832147598267,
0.3563553988933563,
-0.6209409832954407,
-0.11211080849170685,
0.26495569944381714,
-0.07531526684761047,
0.08239556103944778,
-0.184042289853096,
0.8503736853599548,
-0.17756444215774536,
-0.7643381953239441,
0.5231360197067261,
-0.11004964262247086,
0.4171389937400818,
-0.7179301977157593,
0.13210523128509521,
0.09418950229883194,
-0.09208278357982635,
-0.0675722137093544,
-0.4326218068599701,
0.18914151191711426,
0.10976959764957428,
-0.1538519710302353,
-0.39949384331703186,
0.19457396864891052,
-1.2349923849105835,
-1.0941740274429321,
0.4278338551521301,
0.46571752429008484,
0.2635497748851776,
0.14958807826042175,
-0.5433613061904907,
0.059468600898981094,
0.05289633572101593,
-0.06104131042957306,
0.01799602247774601,
0.6421932578086853,
0.22631391882896423,
0.47063300013542175,
0.6135997772216797,
0.5363554954528809,
0.23375651240348816,
0.3303203880786896,
0.476054310798645,
-0.3422906696796417,
-0.6664944291114807,
-0.541218638420105,
0.6052565574645996,
0.0502464585006237,
-0.16462978720664978,
0.6418372392654419,
0.7870938181877136,
0.894769012928009,
-0.10109509527683258,
1.1468769311904907,
0.07761871814727783,
1.0689328908920288,
-0.8098360896110535,
0.7450464367866516,
-0.9569336175918579,
0.19172616302967072,
-0.3335020840167999,
-0.6161214113235474,
-0.19000451266765594,
0.2506047785282135,
0.32655173540115356,
0.18730877339839935,
0.230436310172081,
0.48463383316993713,
-0.1636316329240799,
-0.052830930799245834,
0.3252118229866028,
0.12359149754047394,
0.4093518853187561,
0.7045424580574036,
0.8620430827140808,
-0.624488353729248,
0.5703250169754028,
-0.4397498667240143,
-0.31602683663368225,
0.15153397619724274,
-0.8379788398742676,
-0.7615877985954285,
-0.834296464920044,
-0.1172112300992012,
-0.01046909112483263,
-0.13351179659366608,
1.111145257949829,
0.6238997578620911,
-0.8218219876289368,
-0.3615962266921997,
0.4614352285861969,
0.13173963129520416,
-0.3590928316116333,
-0.16322049498558044,
0.5393785834312439,
-0.5680616497993469,
-0.8089289665222168,
0.38427600264549255,
-0.0034573425073176622,
0.2203579545021057,
-0.2299400120973587,
-0.06999614834785461,
-0.2530958354473114,
-0.006943473592400551,
0.4917212724685669,
0.1142391711473465,
-0.7772771120071411,
-0.14520816504955292,
0.24493767321109772,
0.2317659705877304,
-0.08721248805522919,
0.6901046633720398,
-0.3883405327796936,
0.682513952255249,
0.12829802930355072,
0.5333230495452881,
-0.09523990750312805,
0.0010706573957577348,
0.4578372538089752,
-1.1004515886306763,
-0.21955333650112152,
0.25343891978263855,
0.4933883845806122,
0.4939453899860382,
-0.46585598587989807,
0.2420935183763504,
-0.09852632880210876,
-0.2876904010772705,
-0.832862913608551,
0.14813490211963654,
-0.46058836579322815,
-0.1973152756690979,
1.1566030979156494,
-0.16767726838588715,
-0.1566694974899292,
-0.01139202993363142,
-0.3202347755432129,
0.5209505558013916,
-0.1073785275220871,
0.7914817333221436,
0.8168566823005676,
-0.08902347832918167,
-0.08778244256973267,
-0.6313378810882568,
0.6692273020744324,
0.08896730095148087,
-0.5428451299667358,
0.22626659274101257,
0.554167628288269,
0.14975911378860474,
0.2351178526878357,
0.36830341815948486,
-0.0994676724076271,
0.5001142621040344,
-0.5132285952568054,
0.24427272379398346,
-0.1485634446144104,
-0.8506544232368469,
-0.32159623503685,
0.1255193054676056,
0.036970119923353195,
-0.17449329793453217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17600v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17600v1 | "Seeing the Big through the Small": Can LLMs Approximate Human Judgment Distributions on NLI from a Few Explanations? | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | 2024-06-25T14:42:17 | Beiduo Chen, Xinpeng Wang, Siyao Peng, Robert Litschko, Anna Korhonen, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human label variation (HLV) is a valuable source of information that arises
when multiple human annotators provide different labels for valid reasons. In
Natural Language Inference (NLI) earlier approaches to capturing HLV involve
either collecting annotations from many crowd workers to represent human
judgment distribution (HJD) or use expert linguists to provide detailed
explanations for their chosen labels. While the former method provides denser
HJD information, obtaining it is resource-intensive. In contrast, the latter
offers richer textual information but it is challenging to scale up to many
human judges. Besides, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as
evaluators (``LLM judges'') but with mixed results, and few works aim to study
HJDs. This study proposes to exploit LLMs to approximate HJDs using a small
number of expert labels and explanations. Our experiments show that a few
explanations significantly improve LLMs' ability to approximate HJDs with and
without explicit labels, thereby providing a solution to scale up annotations
for HJD. However, fine-tuning smaller soft-label aware models with the
LLM-generated model judgment distributions (MJDs) presents partially
inconsistent results: while similar in distance, their resulting fine-tuned
models and visualized distributions differ substantially. We show the
importance of complementing instance-level distance measures with a
global-level shape metric and visualization to more effectively evaluate MJDs
against human judgment distributions. | [
-0.600569486618042,
-0.4770607352256775,
0.8427457213401794,
-0.08381986618041992,
-0.27165117859840393,
-0.21489638090133667,
-0.4646359384059906,
-0.7049161195755005,
0.21657462418079376,
0.49641942977905273,
-0.580622136592865,
-0.39758020639419556,
-0.5189110040664673,
0.08706723153591156,
0.1757751703262329,
0.9385712146759033,
0.28552743792533875,
-0.06437671184539795,
-0.00796099379658699,
-0.08941517770290375,
-0.1331728994846344,
-0.2831130921840668,
-0.45630449056625366,
-0.4470893144607544,
0.9363043904304504,
0.4103592336177826,
0.8665181398391724,
0.7924923896789551,
0.3922230303287506,
0.23767322301864624,
-0.4892168641090393,
0.2964193820953369,
-0.3281434178352356,
-0.39208170771598816,
-0.220921590924263,
-0.7862774133682251,
-0.3542614281177521,
0.14292214810848236,
0.7807838916778564,
1.207984209060669,
0.005453348159790039,
0.2090246081352234,
0.28372108936309814,
0.6839592456817627,
-0.8206110000610352,
-0.19791433215141296,
-0.36215630173683167,
0.2852097451686859,
-0.21076877415180206,
0.08860579878091812,
-0.5718343257904053,
-0.20504090189933777,
0.457163006067276,
-0.6318968534469604,
0.24495436251163483,
0.37893202900886536,
0.7757230401039124,
0.4267665147781372,
-0.48535946011543274,
-0.1335439831018448,
-0.6938712000846863,
1.0927098989486694,
-0.8927821516990662,
0.20379196107387543,
0.2441573292016983,
0.4582211673259735,
-0.11302462220191956,
-0.4558098018169403,
-0.4759346544742584,
-0.220500648021698,
-0.31207165122032166,
-0.0668717622756958,
-0.108357734978199,
0.0776812806725502,
0.42983853816986084,
0.1734585016965866,
-0.15771107375621796,
0.4954964220523834,
-0.17953693866729736,
-0.20987465977668762,
0.7806376814842224,
0.30822813510894775,
-0.15089689195156097,
-0.5616564750671387,
-0.40272486209869385,
-0.32727426290512085,
-0.7386357188224792,
0.0342574305832386,
0.24545873701572418,
0.20382602512836456,
-0.22122322022914886,
0.3995457589626312,
-0.10471463948488235,
0.8839949369430542,
-0.10988117009401321,
-0.41265860199928284,
0.266838014125824,
-0.20831407606601715,
-0.5569034218788147,
-0.04729163646697998,
0.9263167977333069,
0.5125874876976013,
0.29235053062438965,
0.006615560036152601,
-0.11069689691066742,
-0.3199903964996338,
0.17979328334331512,
-0.7283707857131958,
-0.23536254465579987,
-0.20267519354820251,
-0.7594419121742249,
-0.3012412190437317,
0.16692054271697998,
-1.1098568439483643,
-0.9897046089172363,
-0.30481356382369995,
0.220130056142807,
-0.08613406121730804,
-0.10117112100124359,
0.04639282450079918,
-0.25859498977661133,
0.09086030721664429,
0.6300488114356995,
-0.7841196656227112,
0.19609037041664124,
0.6062695980072021,
0.6848865747451782,
-0.17266039550304413,
-0.12021448463201523,
-0.39254263043403625,
0.17020170390605927,
-0.3458435833454132,
0.6514232158660889,
-0.49008285999298096,
-0.37046754360198975,
-0.25100842118263245,
-0.29301807284355164,
0.06818749010562897,
-0.7274442911148071,
0.5145299434661865,
-0.28610551357269287,
-0.08255425095558167,
-0.2444494515657425,
-0.6152699589729309,
-0.18838398158550262,
0.23187464475631714,
-0.6735498905181885,
0.6451192498207092,
-0.06693314015865326,
-1.0170162916183472,
0.6672131419181824,
-0.4444279074668884,
-0.13196225464344025,
0.03896945342421532,
-0.2866833508014679,
-0.3453541696071625,
0.40248116850852966,
0.33377471566200256,
0.4342142343521118,
-0.29567500948905945,
-0.10284119099378586,
-0.6065493822097778,
-0.37355026602745056,
0.43036213517189026,
-0.7392577528953552,
0.6627732515335083,
0.2180994749069214,
-0.1459352970123291,
0.2403961718082428,
-0.7120612263679504,
-0.04446359723806381,
-0.06857233494520187,
-0.44185611605644226,
-0.5870321989059448,
0.05005930736660957,
0.08591052144765854,
-0.008739653043448925,
-0.059435345232486725,
-0.3204668462276459,
0.33913275599479675,
-0.5436713099479675,
0.17815013229846954,
0.8082030415534973,
0.29386377334594727,
0.6921586990356445,
-0.20525972545146942,
0.5163789391517639,
0.02285602316260338,
0.26373547315597534,
0.11402468383312225,
-0.7005455493927002,
-0.6317624449729919,
-0.40825313329696655,
0.6418337225914001,
0.24706794321537018,
-0.7167336940765381,
0.2642303705215454,
-0.3453619182109833,
-0.5220873355865479,
-0.7313401103019714,
0.16434581577777863,
0.36095505952835083,
0.30004599690437317,
0.21275001764297485,
-0.2293478548526764,
-0.5441524386405945,
-1.1458970308303833,
-0.3832148015499115,
-0.09191550314426422,
-0.6459271311759949,
0.45899781584739685,
0.5852630138397217,
-0.3246266543865204,
1.0960115194320679,
-0.575075626373291,
-0.2911680340766907,
-0.2034723460674286,
0.2145022600889206,
0.2702372372150421,
0.23226004838943481,
0.5024806261062622,
-0.6713342070579529,
-0.19816221296787262,
0.02916690520942211,
-0.5298826694488525,
-0.12180770188570023,
-0.25946077704429626,
-0.18821009993553162,
0.004624670371413231,
0.25851011276245117,
-0.40804755687713623,
0.6861950159072876,
0.31521177291870117,
-0.41417232155799866,
0.6120432615280151,
-0.3955938220024109,
-0.1843302994966507,
-0.5996240377426147,
-0.3540118932723999,
0.4150581359863281,
-0.22786317765712738,
-0.38352063298225403,
0.10384754836559296,
-0.036945801228284836,
0.5366955399513245,
-0.4674992561340332,
0.6500614881515503,
-0.46060651540756226,
-0.23509067296981812,
-0.24262884259223938,
0.2726685404777527,
0.14350995421409607,
0.27507027983665466,
-0.10460598021745682,
0.4716219902038574,
0.19086672365665436,
-0.56093430519104,
0.058380503207445145,
-0.12847019731998444,
-0.6160879135131836,
0.5751202702522278,
-0.48044097423553467,
-0.10471488535404205,
-0.12938736379146576,
0.42651185393333435,
-0.9086621999740601,
-0.4349234104156494,
0.32858550548553467,
0.0004759034782182425,
0.21704760193824768,
-0.4053681194782257,
-0.5242109298706055,
-0.51998370885849,
-0.516441822052002,
0.3432168960571289,
0.668402910232544,
-0.7741979956626892,
0.7881365418434143,
0.3849491477012634,
0.17087839543819427,
-0.35897836089134216,
-0.8754597306251526,
0.19398118555545807,
-0.4647601842880249,
-0.5672814249992371,
0.022042574360966682,
-0.17322231829166412,
-0.6196256279945374,
-0.2780720889568329,
-0.12744593620300293,
0.05648382008075714,
0.2022101730108261,
0.2991690933704376,
0.1044774055480957,
-0.3560841381549835,
0.06329172104597092,
-0.09054088592529297,
0.1474895030260086,
0.19672082364559174,
-0.11299419403076172,
0.04012675955891609,
-0.14593113958835602,
-0.31369340419769287,
-0.5904871225357056,
0.15531882643699646,
0.2746981978416443,
0.14444676041603088,
0.5892019271850586,
0.5005368590354919,
-0.3075465261936188,
-0.2099253237247467,
-0.615699827671051,
-0.17433606088161469,
-0.46324315667152405,
-0.028839226812124252,
-0.48264676332473755,
-0.6690256595611572,
0.2707741856575012,
-0.12626606225967407,
-0.11770742386579514,
0.44511353969573975,
0.6186932921409607,
-0.39799240231513977,
1.107630968093872,
0.5916053652763367,
-0.004352525807917118,
0.3330397605895996,
-0.17987598478794098,
-0.09588705003261566,
-0.9839985370635986,
-0.07507050782442093,
-0.4511107802391052,
-0.6153268814086914,
-0.7096753716468811,
-0.6591724157333374,
0.41689029335975647,
0.23936499655246735,
-0.04298235848546028,
-0.24468626081943512,
-0.42019420862197876,
0.6880841851234436,
0.780198335647583,
0.3071277439594269,
0.3138086497783661,
0.04957667365670204,
-0.13564936816692352,
-0.2722342014312744,
-0.8201096057891846,
-0.7204614281654358,
0.9235544800758362,
0.6122598648071289,
0.8886979222297668,
0.13137957453727722,
0.7876221537590027,
0.31690624356269836,
0.7870003581047058,
-0.7784157991409302,
0.43483054637908936,
-0.068623848259449,
-0.45108744502067566,
-0.34518203139305115,
-0.6908857226371765,
-0.9596220850944519,
0.7425433397293091,
-0.34797221422195435,
-0.9014387130737305,
0.5154087543487549,
0.3410431146621704,
-0.47048527002334595,
0.3162660002708435,
-1.101289987564087,
0.8386562466621399,
0.02961411140859127,
-0.22617453336715698,
0.012469405308365822,
-0.7401330471038818,
0.5052196383476257,
-0.1225707158446312,
0.6851779222488403,
-0.029387563467025757,
-0.05314025655388832,
0.96892249584198,
-0.6525325775146484,
1.3130388259887695,
-0.29729458689689636,
-0.22463902831077576,
0.3752250671386719,
0.007521667052060366,
0.36164942383766174,
0.043209176510572433,
-0.1710793524980545,
0.16977562010288239,
-0.2311982363462448,
-0.4500056505203247,
-0.7541072964668274,
0.5086169838905334,
-0.7108854055404663,
-0.610641598701477,
-0.21895378828048706,
-0.47642913460731506,
-0.07792870700359344,
-0.05493294447660446,
0.17279192805290222,
0.15382009744644165,
0.0848051980137825,
0.05043293908238411,
0.42953407764434814,
-0.16530820727348328,
0.40743985772132874,
0.2944336533546448,
-0.14571893215179443,
-0.23876367509365082,
0.7018375992774963,
0.0007357753347605467,
0.18621990084648132,
0.2820143699645996,
0.6638396382331848,
-0.30998632311820984,
-0.5795138478279114,
-0.6309167742729187,
0.3760461211204529,
-0.7823392152786255,
-0.04883407801389694,
-0.21941739320755005,
0.34701472520828247,
-0.13997025787830353,
-0.06756298989057541,
-0.14454950392246246,
-0.2944510281085968,
-0.25951486825942993,
-0.085300974547863,
0.2793230712413788,
1.0573983192443848,
-0.14629890024662018,
0.41112029552459717,
-0.502392053604126,
0.27754315733909607,
0.4687829315662384,
0.2460932433605194,
0.24316614866256714,
-0.6871240139007568,
-0.2719736695289612,
0.30210840702056885,
-0.017301829531788826,
-0.9171257019042969,
0.18719525635242462,
0.006919605191797018,
0.3073735237121582,
0.6070294380187988,
0.04128175601363182,
0.8797373175621033,
-0.6176868081092834,
0.7590962648391724,
0.2867320775985718,
-0.6226668953895569,
0.44533705711364746,
-0.09756969660520554,
0.33492836356163025,
0.47943150997161865,
0.11406535655260086,
-0.3021697700023651,
-0.42029088735580444,
-0.45545271039009094,
-0.7591973543167114,
0.7354137897491455,
0.09708589315414429,
-0.20096230506896973,
0.11337018758058548,
0.3913290500640869,
0.03951979801058769,
-0.08971501886844635,
-0.6415295004844666,
-0.2809997797012329,
0.0535505972802639,
-0.22352102398872375,
-0.23162144422531128,
-0.28369876742362976,
-0.2670842409133911,
-0.3085375428199768,
0.4399859607219696,
-0.26870492100715637,
-0.07834120839834213,
0.18272846937179565,
-0.14194655418395996,
-0.004386298358440399,
0.2920607328414917,
0.5830773711204529,
0.6583390831947327,
-0.2540561258792877,
0.43175747990608215,
0.36955195665359497,
-0.3311785161495209,
-0.05638820305466652,
-0.12546002864837646,
-0.2960924208164215,
0.024031301960349083,
0.5900194048881531,
1.060249924659729,
0.25698286294937134,
-0.7428463697433472,
0.5683504343032837,
-0.1377919614315033,
-0.19847765564918518,
-0.07934048026800156,
0.1663082242012024,
0.13514374196529388,
0.5397050380706787,
0.39653223752975464,
0.20762915909290314,
0.21199679374694824,
-0.3028712868690491,
0.056735388934612274,
0.2505638301372528,
-0.4070536494255066,
-0.10186776518821716,
0.6838613152503967,
0.09567001461982727,
-0.4562303423881531,
0.3780321776866913,
-0.29684528708457947,
-0.1781967729330063,
0.6721816658973694,
0.11635929346084595,
0.4995036721229553,
0.17409548163414001,
0.07469558715820312,
0.1103472113609314,
0.34484973549842834,
-0.26236534118652344,
-0.24743983149528503,
-0.14836138486862183,
-0.6181118488311768,
-0.7291369438171387,
-0.7026073932647705,
-0.6551774144172668,
-0.17138396203517914,
-0.8692021369934082,
-0.00512340571731329,
-0.4244164824485779,
-0.2323368787765503,
0.3765564262866974,
-0.17897523939609528,
-0.87154620885849,
0.297544002532959,
0.6129388213157654,
0.9241580367088318,
-0.7345607876777649,
0.8290191292762756,
0.6227293014526367,
-0.33316510915756226,
-0.8365978002548218,
0.27585098147392273,
0.07169908285140991,
-0.5626460313796997,
0.6957356929779053,
0.20620137453079224,
-0.09232624620199203,
-0.2723934054374695,
-0.509483814239502,
-0.48259061574935913,
0.8126909136772156,
0.21174104511737823,
-0.8254055976867676,
0.0870111882686615,
0.052159279584884644,
0.6732454895973206,
-0.35568729043006897,
0.42349568009376526,
0.9514808654785156,
0.7185081839561462,
-0.08332771807909012,
-0.8013129830360413,
0.051228638738393784,
0.0788511335849762,
0.24001240730285645,
0.09256507456302643,
-0.2393897920846939,
0.46788400411605835,
-0.6492196917533875,
0.0121273472905159,
-0.018529750406742096,
0.6891188621520996,
0.5383291840553284,
0.4007735252380371,
0.9475219249725342,
0.38442495465278625,
0.9335263967514038,
-0.009281323291361332,
1.5372992753982544,
0.22494228184223175,
0.5909836292266846,
1.2026867866516113,
-0.06536652147769928,
0.8298921585083008,
0.6572465896606445,
-0.3781206011772156,
0.457248330116272,
0.736815869808197,
-0.1747942715883255,
0.37155231833457947,
0.500396728515625,
-0.2227739691734314,
-0.3990103602409363,
-0.0834786593914032,
-0.06607385724782944,
0.2532806992530823,
0.42601919174194336,
-0.3512573838233948,
-0.06365478038787842,
0.1617438644170761,
-0.19013312458992004,
-0.0055290707387030125,
-0.47390124201774597,
0.6610279083251953,
0.23550909757614136,
-0.43782201409339905,
0.6890885233879089,
0.16528530418872833,
0.9452834725379944,
-0.1683339774608612,
0.1689937710762024,
-0.18288205564022064,
0.177290141582489,
-0.1765373796224594,
-0.8686256408691406,
0.06474064290523529,
0.04580889269709587,
-0.2805510461330414,
-0.18922272324562073,
0.537177324295044,
-0.17006860673427582,
-0.649340033531189,
0.21189908683300018,
0.4425410330295563,
0.4608057141304016,
-0.08916071057319641,
-0.5333229899406433,
0.03258548304438591,
0.05558948963880539,
-0.5650200247764587,
0.33172523975372314,
0.6904860734939575,
-0.16020263731479645,
0.5923380255699158,
0.2683486342430115,
0.1650151163339615,
0.25911587476730347,
0.5520628690719604,
0.5658905506134033,
-0.7793818116188049,
-0.3690418303012848,
-1.0224539041519165,
0.2453313022851944,
-0.3192650079727173,
-0.28365251421928406,
0.6696312427520752,
0.30110788345336914,
0.7317511439323425,
-0.322070449590683,
0.5820841789245605,
0.22313332557678223,
0.563499927520752,
-0.5601080656051636,
0.5814300179481506,
-0.7581480741500854,
0.4069540500640869,
-0.26376914978027344,
-0.7736791968345642,
-0.5394763946533203,
0.6487942934036255,
-0.45634594559669495,
0.059209294617176056,
0.4750119745731354,
0.5761104822158813,
-0.05162329971790314,
-0.056877460330724716,
0.35314661264419556,
0.4561554491519928,
0.2306382656097412,
0.49131086468696594,
0.9055628776550293,
-0.13095487654209137,
0.6253488063812256,
-0.23974522948265076,
-0.1653338372707367,
-0.40176284313201904,
-0.8094316720962524,
-0.9683614373207092,
0.1404699832201004,
-0.37646207213401794,
-0.1801542192697525,
-0.1758299022912979,
0.850313127040863,
0.9502350687980652,
-0.5711530447006226,
-0.07684633135795593,
0.22381123900413513,
0.4407976567745209,
-0.13280001282691956,
-0.2618058919906616,
0.38782283663749695,
0.026390688493847847,
-0.7305250763893127,
0.33979281783103943,
0.12126544862985611,
0.15439990162849426,
-0.36707180738449097,
-0.15718574821949005,
0.12903711199760437,
-0.027762634679675102,
0.6702735424041748,
-0.07233273237943649,
-1.1360180377960205,
-0.6866716742515564,
-0.5551160573959351,
-0.18655970692634583,
0.13493746519088745,
0.6685002446174622,
-0.8057489395141602,
0.3125838041305542,
0.34040898084640503,
0.5733626484870911,
0.5508710145950317,
-0.010413550771772861,
0.2550295293331146,
-1.0558481216430664,
0.25376227498054504,
0.11062341928482056,
0.38575536012649536,
0.39814913272857666,
-0.10047400742769241,
0.5724940299987793,
0.19625261425971985,
-0.27954310178756714,
-0.7930979132652283,
0.3772079050540924,
-1.0407568216323853,
-0.4662814140319824,
1.324405550956726,
-0.0518324188888073,
-0.49370822310447693,
-0.023006310686469078,
-0.24605800211429596,
-0.1392740160226822,
-0.3901174068450928,
0.6950091123580933,
0.6343607306480408,
-0.2269500344991684,
-0.08184298872947693,
-0.7356884479522705,
0.4005499482154846,
0.3028261363506317,
-0.7851915955543518,
0.019069107249379158,
0.43001970648765564,
0.33712419867515564,
0.2906714975833893,
0.4998219311237335,
0.2932942509651184,
0.05917242169380188,
-0.036228690296411514,
0.14824292063713074,
0.37139877676963806,
-0.14112141728401184,
-0.3908802568912506,
0.23508159816265106,
0.2181670218706131,
-0.05276926979422569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17588v2 | LongIns: A Challenging Long-context Instruction-based Exam for LLMs | 2024-06-25T14:31:26 | 2024-06-26T13:28:04 | Shawn Gavin, Tuney Zheng, Jiaheng Liu, Quehry Que, Noah Wang, Jian Yang, Chenchen Zhang, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Ge Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The long-context capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have been a hot
topic in recent years. To evaluate the performance of LLMs in different
scenarios, various assessment benchmarks have emerged. However, as most of
these benchmarks focus on identifying key information to answer questions,
which mainly requires the retrieval ability of LLMs, these benchmarks can
partially represent the reasoning performance of LLMs from large amounts of
information. Meanwhile, although LLMs often claim to have context windows of
32k, 128k, 200k, or even longer, these benchmarks fail to reveal the actual
supported length of these LLMs. To address these issues, we propose the LongIns
benchmark dataset, a challenging long-context instruction-based exam for LLMs,
which is built based on the existing instruction datasets. Specifically, in our
LongIns, we introduce three evaluation settings: Global Instruction & Single
Task (GIST), Local Instruction & Single Task (LIST), and Local Instruction &
Multiple Tasks (LIMT). Based on LongIns, we perform comprehensive evaluations
on existing LLMs and have the following important findings: (1). The
top-performing GPT-4 with 128k context length performs poorly on the evaluation
context window of 16k in our LongIns. (2). For the multi-hop reasoning ability
of many existing LLMs, significant efforts are still needed under short context
windows (less than 4k). | [
-0.3769521117210388,
-0.7355161905288696,
0.9319403171539307,
0.15725266933441162,
-0.28044477105140686,
-0.12610533833503723,
-0.6182854175567627,
-0.5287651419639587,
-0.14759843051433563,
0.3746214807033539,
-0.5549026727676392,
-0.5591511130332947,
-0.5304580926895142,
0.3550897240638733,
-0.23683907091617584,
0.8078872561454773,
-0.5053957104682922,
-0.22417248785495758,
-0.43575119972229004,
-0.19055692851543427,
-0.578486442565918,
-0.4052999019622803,
-0.5233979225158691,
-0.043275829404592514,
0.7235116362571716,
0.21025173366069794,
0.16722357273101807,
0.4958541691303253,
0.37495994567871094,
0.25236254930496216,
-0.25831836462020874,
0.26509004831314087,
-0.5872233510017395,
0.031837303191423416,
-0.17977863550186157,
-0.06218119338154793,
-0.5281233787536621,
-0.04852009564638138,
0.809980571269989,
0.7430990934371948,
0.11338911205530167,
0.21083161234855652,
0.31413528323173523,
0.8877322673797607,
-0.7671377658843994,
0.08777177333831787,
-0.3099094331264496,
-0.05824586749076843,
-0.41743171215057373,
-0.049748994410037994,
-0.3959207832813263,
-0.1975235790014267,
0.32422301173210144,
-0.3827032446861267,
-0.3236720561981201,
-0.10096277296543121,
0.4239731729030609,
0.07931581139564514,
-0.8392347693443298,
-0.5416597127914429,
-0.4526415169239044,
1.1592981815338135,
-0.5877500176429749,
0.33689314126968384,
0.22128593921661377,
0.5580286383628845,
-0.2734104096889496,
-0.7175410389900208,
-0.1242862343788147,
-0.37073203921318054,
0.09312532842159271,
0.027877165004611015,
0.1581120640039444,
0.10107164084911346,
0.41507863998413086,
0.20037394762039185,
-0.5819997787475586,
0.3133215606212616,
-0.48126211762428284,
-0.08932420611381531,
0.5757915377616882,
0.4105178713798523,
-0.2801758348941803,
-0.2774212658405304,
-0.786239743232727,
0.053254518657922745,
-0.8311429023742676,
0.23922841250896454,
0.06865223497152328,
0.21054209768772125,
-0.09844717383384705,
0.24789614975452423,
-0.24280352890491486,
1.0081441402435303,
-0.4996967911720276,
-0.24741065502166748,
0.27250936627388,
-0.14159874618053436,
-0.28108906745910645,
-0.06059683859348297,
0.6438184976577759,
0.39840930700302124,
0.16858719289302826,
-0.13784843683242798,
-0.4328564405441284,
-0.2370109111070633,
0.011763066984713078,
-1.0031955242156982,
0.48590025305747986,
0.32881060242652893,
-0.18240594863891602,
0.26786714792251587,
-0.1358051598072052,
-0.9822289943695068,
-0.1237458661198616,
-0.5147600173950195,
0.4485153257846832,
-0.329720675945282,
0.2432090789079666,
0.17796555161476135,
0.20010188221931458,
0.5185261964797974,
0.4542613923549652,
-0.47494760155677795,
0.413846492767334,
1.103168249130249,
0.6406753659248352,
-0.6598799824714661,
-0.5273513197898865,
-0.3435395061969757,
-0.03008805401623249,
-0.4005190432071686,
0.4449039399623871,
-0.5389334559440613,
-0.2766568958759308,
-0.010665783658623695,
0.286444753408432,
-0.2018449753522873,
-0.466153621673584,
0.40675532817840576,
-0.6689026355743408,
0.13088931143283844,
-0.45299628376960754,
-0.9648863077163696,
-0.023568855598568916,
0.6217780709266663,
-0.5671355128288269,
0.9174045920372009,
0.1740502566099167,
-0.5298728942871094,
0.0657268539071083,
-0.706455647945404,
-0.4549502730369568,
0.021731233224272728,
-0.3782615065574646,
-0.04762501269578934,
-0.10901740938425064,
0.06803648918867111,
0.631657063961029,
-0.5751852989196777,
0.27658897638320923,
-0.06211795657873154,
-0.9197217226028442,
0.17593199014663696,
-0.7838361263275146,
0.5774045586585999,
0.10633771866559982,
-0.5507019758224487,
0.017850250005722046,
-0.5648193359375,
0.267382949590683,
0.08508241921663284,
-0.3301091194152832,
-0.28725525736808777,
0.02012416534125805,
-0.4896455407142639,
0.008790385909378529,
0.33555668592453003,
-0.5317054390907288,
0.2719939649105072,
-0.011751480400562286,
0.38077226281166077,
1.018303394317627,
-0.1268884837627411,
0.1072782352566719,
-0.16601760685443878,
0.4102981388568878,
-0.11888737231492996,
0.15245312452316284,
-0.14121918380260468,
-0.27626699209213257,
-0.5972268581390381,
-0.16959793865680695,
0.21585185825824738,
0.552262008190155,
-0.5614826083183289,
0.3569987714290619,
-0.6568317413330078,
-0.26323264837265015,
-0.03351541608572006,
0.39752134680747986,
0.49356740713119507,
0.39432641863822937,
0.3104162812232971,
-0.170795738697052,
-0.24574494361877441,
-1.0139142274856567,
-0.20848560333251953,
0.31917887926101685,
-0.09874337911605835,
0.45595476031303406,
0.812789797782898,
-0.23720042407512665,
0.6343309879302979,
-0.39593398571014404,
0.014128525741398335,
-0.029558639973402023,
-0.15343157947063446,
0.5299685597419739,
0.13169264793395996,
0.19643303751945496,
-0.3019656538963318,
-0.4069109559059143,
-0.2813512980937958,
-0.6932522654533386,
0.23367874324321747,
0.12875287234783173,
0.03160933405160904,
0.14433787763118744,
0.45992493629455566,
-0.5458526611328125,
0.3033415377140045,
0.6887202858924866,
-0.07927330583333969,
0.6734801530838013,
-0.18260709941387177,
0.21770071983337402,
-0.9554752707481384,
-0.06886879354715347,
-0.0013816050486639142,
-0.22630175948143005,
-0.24850688874721527,
0.016754429787397385,
0.37351474165916443,
-0.14647699892520905,
-0.581225574016571,
0.7914291024208069,
-0.6767907738685608,
-0.18472938239574432,
-0.1301775872707367,
0.3120063841342926,
0.03781850263476372,
0.517826497554779,
-0.21403087675571442,
1.1280485391616821,
0.5937110185623169,
-0.5151106119155884,
0.5847305655479431,
-0.18831752240657806,
-0.8891556859016418,
0.5610791444778442,
-0.5084529519081116,
0.37320491671562195,
-0.014147917740046978,
0.5721112489700317,
-0.5830082893371582,
-0.22511452436447144,
-0.1266053020954132,
0.16924600303173065,
0.4006105661392212,
-0.09048629552125931,
-0.42267295718193054,
-0.5058358311653137,
-0.4029911756515503,
0.6733862161636353,
0.5455631017684937,
-0.7617486119270325,
0.2659737467765808,
-0.1861281543970108,
-0.018642127513885498,
-0.7921890616416931,
-0.4617205858230591,
0.2096378058195114,
-0.3631453216075897,
-0.6363828182220459,
0.18768589198589325,
-0.13525168597698212,
-0.226276695728302,
-0.2722248435020447,
-0.21576184034347534,
0.04753826931118965,
-0.003205042565241456,
0.11407691985368729,
-0.03258752077817917,
-0.390491783618927,
0.26211047172546387,
-0.19600476324558258,
-0.07994132488965988,
0.25312334299087524,
-0.07940053939819336,
0.14512582123279572,
-0.5286051034927368,
-0.5947853922843933,
-0.32884180545806885,
0.3793402314186096,
0.7025253176689148,
-0.1271962672472,
0.44003012776374817,
0.17736060917377472,
-0.21624357998371124,
-0.39064666628837585,
-0.7500230073928833,
-0.09829366952180862,
-0.46018752455711365,
0.645669162273407,
-0.5797489881515503,
-0.9985765218734741,
0.38149774074554443,
-0.4513317942619324,
-0.002213953295722604,
0.3102942109107971,
0.13899287581443787,
-0.05580342188477516,
0.6222750544548035,
0.009371032007038593,
-0.342446893453598,
0.022353651002049446,
-0.222158282995224,
0.0052844807505607605,
-1.044964075088501,
-0.05585150048136711,
-0.1992628425359726,
-0.34286263585090637,
-0.4585144817829132,
-0.644029438495636,
0.44170212745666504,
-0.114959716796875,
-0.39840805530548096,
0.09349378198385239,
-0.2819017767906189,
0.7024969458580017,
0.3365161120891571,
0.23603565990924835,
-0.045755282044410706,
-0.08778008818626404,
0.04953669756650925,
0.0464262031018734,
-0.3356640040874481,
-0.5977256298065186,
1.1378628015518188,
0.5045378804206848,
0.7870053052902222,
0.04979265481233597,
0.7117322087287903,
0.0889030247926712,
0.1733478456735611,
-0.7500886917114258,
0.8304411172866821,
-0.16577006876468658,
-0.6573687195777893,
-0.4563519358634949,
-0.6464349031448364,
-1.0475417375564575,
-0.07603460550308228,
0.5307790040969849,
-0.846928596496582,
-0.18775026500225067,
-0.3295575678348541,
-0.224806547164917,
0.3444923460483551,
-0.6586509346961975,
0.9911181926727295,
-0.6412063837051392,
-0.6325640678405762,
-0.030386490747332573,
-0.7250453233718872,
0.2872770130634308,
-0.04946614429354668,
0.19074192643165588,
-0.2066895216703415,
-0.205499067902565,
0.9657928347587585,
-0.2696512043476105,
0.8123695850372314,
-0.152354434132576,
-0.14653576910495758,
0.5257155895233154,
-0.028378678485751152,
0.5566445589065552,
-0.03466673940420151,
-0.27630650997161865,
-0.012879791669547558,
0.06704510003328323,
-0.6038238406181335,
-0.8544946312904358,
0.9694270491600037,
-0.5571908950805664,
-0.77223140001297,
-0.38082602620124817,
-0.41666412353515625,
-0.45685598254203796,
0.04811389371752739,
-0.0580412931740284,
0.6957299709320068,
-0.20950928330421448,
0.35077616572380066,
0.5983210206031799,
-0.10036386549472809,
0.3601040244102478,
0.2543809711933136,
0.0020629840437322855,
-0.23424556851387024,
0.8349433541297913,
0.1795804649591446,
0.33957892656326294,
0.15350855886936188,
0.25574126839637756,
-0.2834547162055969,
-0.4578964114189148,
-0.5550451278686523,
0.18779397010803223,
-1.0260101556777954,
-0.09404754638671875,
0.03308229148387909,
-0.3368518650531769,
0.0683404728770256,
-0.0847192332148552,
-0.4887539744377136,
0.012642921879887581,
-0.0894588753581047,
0.04775016009807587,
0.18445198237895966,
0.8312113881111145,
0.23598088324069977,
0.12514430284500122,
-0.6648237109184265,
-0.017552148550748825,
0.5953890681266785,
0.7117142081260681,
0.10756292194128036,
-0.5668641328811646,
-0.23545055091381073,
-0.11765014380216599,
-0.19907234609127045,
-0.7611083984375,
-0.27057868242263794,
-0.04299062117934227,
0.45601052045822144,
0.3215453028678894,
-0.08425755053758621,
0.7304306626319885,
-0.6385932564735413,
0.9487396478652954,
-0.0005871133762411773,
-0.7139228582382202,
0.2913966178894043,
-0.16628731787204742,
0.41774269938468933,
0.7234539985656738,
0.4685884118080139,
-0.32304510474205017,
0.15309806168079376,
-0.14513985812664032,
-0.7520145773887634,
0.4692315459251404,
0.01683608628809452,
0.3586423099040985,
-0.21609416604042053,
0.5558590888977051,
0.19304941594600677,
-0.016010310500860214,
-0.6228629946708679,
-0.10465289652347565,
0.17737871408462524,
-0.11422750353813171,
-0.2265489548444748,
-0.5589267015457153,
-0.3406306207180023,
-0.26632165908813477,
0.5215912461280823,
-0.1883970946073532,
0.23141033947467804,
0.15524937212467194,
-0.12850238382816315,
0.34658142924308777,
0.7073726058006287,
0.8363074064254761,
1.1867218017578125,
-0.47551384568214417,
0.10278984159231186,
0.5519034266471863,
-0.118403360247612,
0.17608501017093658,
0.11764978617429733,
0.273170530796051,
-0.2654765546321869,
0.6215336918830872,
0.9921812415122986,
0.3061148226261139,
-0.6761400699615479,
0.815527081489563,
0.00010958695929730311,
-0.08998098224401474,
-0.42878782749176025,
-0.08657560497522354,
0.21564598381519318,
0.09779901802539825,
0.38183292746543884,
-0.5177745223045349,
-0.15933986008167267,
-0.4275149703025818,
0.11256834119558334,
0.32227420806884766,
-0.534308671951294,
-0.12112794816493988,
-0.05121893063187599,
0.2253410369157791,
-0.21909281611442566,
0.8034822344779968,
-0.2631198465824127,
-0.45504599809646606,
0.6811615824699402,
0.4266447424888611,
0.6309415102005005,
-0.17058728635311127,
-0.3513118028640747,
0.40429815649986267,
0.23405250906944275,
-0.1452462375164032,
0.2057558000087738,
-0.12368813902139664,
-0.18507631123065948,
-0.64014732837677,
-0.41695618629455566,
-0.4491173326969147,
0.5502444505691528,
-0.5070313215255737,
0.2107119858264923,
-0.4002423584461212,
-0.09748368710279465,
-0.4775107800960541,
0.24326545000076294,
-0.6036218404769897,
0.29264184832572937,
0.22121243178844452,
1.2245824337005615,
-0.48864632844924927,
0.6555790305137634,
0.28346502780914307,
0.1458030492067337,
-0.6232632994651794,
-0.025805139914155006,
-0.03180525451898575,
-0.6153022646903992,
0.6889839768409729,
0.6787236332893372,
0.040485650300979614,
-0.46547937393188477,
-0.4622449576854706,
-0.6695242524147034,
1.285775065422058,
0.19480940699577332,
-0.8439822793006897,
-0.2540515065193176,
0.39377617835998535,
0.4011206328868866,
-0.3985745906829834,
0.3393076956272125,
0.6555084586143494,
0.6048620343208313,
-0.008232031017541885,
-0.9609591960906982,
0.15574783086776733,
-0.017234353348612785,
-0.11323659867048264,
0.2462419867515564,
-0.7390555143356323,
0.722939133644104,
0.03910130262374878,
0.07699208706617355,
0.1635015457868576,
0.6148306727409363,
0.4081631302833557,
0.4093613624572754,
0.6585983037948608,
0.4998384714126587,
0.5220164060592651,
-0.04317958280444145,
1.2163275480270386,
-0.2778577208518982,
0.2775835692882538,
1.2835043668746948,
-0.4432426393032074,
0.9625566005706787,
0.6141764521598816,
-0.2950078547000885,
0.45755597949028015,
0.6896270513534546,
0.11705005168914795,
0.1625569611787796,
0.7300544381141663,
-0.4022313058376312,
-0.268399178981781,
0.3437706530094147,
-0.5011857151985168,
0.40089666843414307,
0.4336313009262085,
-0.14535236358642578,
-0.4348853528499603,
-0.05568907782435417,
-0.034060508012771606,
-0.15449833869934082,
-0.1746092140674591,
0.3782513439655304,
0.3667713403701782,
-0.8061718344688416,
0.7652172446250916,
-0.07260804623365402,
0.6256369352340698,
-0.8245344161987305,
0.024110889062285423,
-0.3057190179824829,
0.18386349081993103,
0.16427552700042725,
-0.9086077809333801,
-0.0068028951063752174,
0.09236906468868256,
0.16219674050807953,
-0.03668457642197609,
0.5295013785362244,
-0.183249369263649,
-0.34765592217445374,
0.6193737983703613,
0.38653868436813354,
0.3971443772315979,
-0.008077196776866913,
-0.7057744264602661,
0.20688128471374512,
-0.2576826512813568,
-0.6752968430519104,
0.5354195833206177,
0.5050932168960571,
-0.2448902428150177,
0.6128596663475037,
0.15753161907196045,
-0.034712210297584534,
-0.09393826127052307,
0.03092547319829464,
0.760513186454773,
-0.8381767272949219,
-0.16236181557178497,
-0.825306236743927,
0.3489820063114166,
-0.13021141290664673,
-0.3581431806087494,
0.5672199726104736,
0.8041576743125916,
0.7057362794876099,
0.1810702085494995,
0.3748471438884735,
0.2589205801486969,
0.6195489764213562,
-0.6718856692314148,
0.4132378399372101,
-0.7630605697631836,
0.3468865156173706,
-0.040262363851070404,
-0.9657493829727173,
0.02535480074584484,
0.10259796679019928,
-0.6209082007408142,
0.35299649834632874,
0.8643161058425903,
0.6152788996696472,
-0.24750249087810516,
-0.02420368790626526,
0.48052743077278137,
0.08029061555862427,
0.3205243647098541,
1.1519907712936401,
1.0881236791610718,
-0.4946940839290619,
0.47805845737457275,
-0.3078894019126892,
-0.2981594502925873,
-0.1259562373161316,
-1.06167471408844,
-1.0390039682388306,
-0.41096732020378113,
-0.09032441675662994,
-0.21203911304473877,
0.43327146768569946,
0.7996469140052795,
0.5020644068717957,
-0.6389559507369995,
-0.545527994632721,
0.311545193195343,
0.06916679441928864,
-0.013954092748463154,
-0.16402307152748108,
0.7979655265808105,
-0.3169012665748596,
-0.5637089014053345,
0.9050596356391907,
0.1135464459657669,
-0.0910661369562149,
-0.2533392310142517,
-0.31083059310913086,
-0.011933328583836555,
-0.02447597123682499,
0.7528489828109741,
0.18465831875801086,
-0.7859432697296143,
-0.6013162732124329,
0.07255229353904724,
-0.3045584261417389,
0.10516418516635895,
0.6736730933189392,
-0.6120039820671082,
0.38411951065063477,
0.3366541564464569,
0.9663681387901306,
0.5870997905731201,
-0.23104305565357208,
0.291412353515625,
-0.7204269766807556,
0.017011219635605812,
0.23292693495750427,
0.35198599100112915,
0.23071648180484772,
-0.0430416502058506,
0.5128657221794128,
0.010060780681669712,
-0.741266667842865,
-0.8041285872459412,
0.03136894106864929,
-0.9276718497276306,
-0.3853923976421356,
1.281080722808838,
-0.36233851313591003,
-0.4977816045284271,
0.238083615899086,
0.16798602044582367,
-0.11921604722738266,
-0.07373886555433273,
0.5031744241714478,
0.7548884153366089,
-0.10914701968431473,
0.05857023969292641,
-0.89947909116745,
0.3159047067165375,
0.6544947028160095,
-0.7668946385383606,
0.17526812851428986,
0.45895645022392273,
0.4577592611312866,
0.06436318904161453,
0.5200499296188354,
-0.10670074075460434,
0.21782195568084717,
-0.25731736421585083,
-0.1810070127248764,
-0.124933622777462,
-0.4325018525123596,
-0.27779316902160645,
0.1271277517080307,
0.031737204641103745,
-0.09702318161725998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17574v1 | Beyond Text-to-SQL for IoT Defense: A Comprehensive Framework for Querying and Classifying IoT Threats | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | 2024-06-25T14:14:35 | Ryan Pavlich, Nima Ebadi, Richard Tarbell, Billy Linares, Adrian Tan, Rachael Humphreys, Jayanta Kumar Das, Rambod Ghandiparsi, Hannah Haley, Jerris George, Rocky Slavin, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo, Glenn Dietrich, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing the promise of natural language interfaces to databases, prior
studies have emphasized the development of text-to-SQL systems. While
substantial progress has been made in this field, existing research has
concentrated on generating SQL statements from text queries. The broader
challenge, however, lies in inferring new information about the returned data.
Our research makes two major contributions to address this gap. First, we
introduce a novel Internet-of-Things (IoT) text-to-SQL dataset comprising
10,985 text-SQL pairs and 239,398 rows of network traffic activity. The dataset
contains additional query types limited in prior text-to-SQL datasets, notably
temporal-related queries. Our dataset is sourced from a smart building's IoT
ecosystem exploring sensor read and network traffic data. Second, our dataset
allows two-stage processing, where the returned data (network traffic) from a
generated SQL can be categorized as malicious or not. Our results show that
joint training to query and infer information about the data can improve
overall text-to-SQL performance, nearly matching substantially larger models.
We also show that current large language models (e.g., GPT3.5) struggle to
infer new information about returned data, thus our dataset provides a novel
test bed for integrating complex domain-specific reasoning into LLMs. | [
0.03875906392931938,
-1.0578374862670898,
0.46366941928863525,
-0.27665412425994873,
-0.11949720233678818,
0.24793033301830292,
0.1267748475074768,
-0.8762754201889038,
0.023870762437582016,
0.6889747977256775,
-0.42494654655456543,
-0.5931714177131653,
-0.3863082826137543,
-0.06321567296981812,
-0.8230489492416382,
0.9679957032203674,
0.5117633938789368,
-0.26054200530052185,
-0.18244969844818115,
0.4158775210380554,
-0.4275140166282654,
-0.7225614190101624,
-0.5760408639907837,
-0.02465709298849106,
0.1713385134935379,
0.22548925876617432,
0.27162253856658936,
0.3672914505004883,
0.8351995348930359,
0.22489166259765625,
0.3787858486175537,
0.20638507604599,
-0.21889062225818634,
0.160420224070549,
-0.08550230413675308,
-0.5791089534759521,
-0.36127984523773193,
-0.2944570779800415,
0.3376309871673584,
0.505057692527771,
-0.03333595395088196,
-0.21939519047737122,
-0.25699734687805176,
0.7674667239189148,
-0.3522069752216339,
-0.18010543286800385,
-1.2651736736297607,
0.1233588382601738,
-0.3767491281032562,
-0.5345401167869568,
-0.7787290811538696,
0.02636842429637909,
0.5012009143829346,
-0.3076414167881012,
0.2708069682121277,
0.40509703755378723,
0.7697687149047852,
0.10917357355356216,
-0.8999360799789429,
-0.009179124608635902,
-0.843517005443573,
0.7033775448799133,
-0.4142574965953827,
0.40355032682418823,
0.5368885397911072,
0.26542267203330994,
-0.39141762256622314,
-0.7096300721168518,
-0.27300524711608887,
-0.32934802770614624,
-0.02428758144378662,
0.06163456663489342,
-0.21205084025859833,
-0.17032112181186676,
0.10182327777147293,
0.006375418044626713,
-0.8269986510276794,
-0.03411831706762314,
-0.24751296639442444,
0.010836223140358925,
0.9735299348831177,
0.14692796766757965,
0.14683187007904053,
-0.05841299891471863,
-0.7526504397392273,
0.23495618999004364,
-0.9505190849304199,
-0.16431820392608643,
0.07608653604984283,
0.5717076063156128,
0.02990502119064331,
0.6579616069793701,
-0.4884258508682251,
0.8065072894096375,
-0.07489454001188278,
-0.02016749046742916,
-0.1547248810529709,
-0.5234647989273071,
-0.18641149997711182,
0.295147180557251,
0.6782284379005432,
0.5303227305412292,
-0.04834356904029846,
-0.6455419063568115,
-0.1396699994802475,
-0.11392173916101456,
0.497945636510849,
-0.7248745560646057,
-0.303457111120224,
0.399823397397995,
-0.3518178462982178,
-0.2760325074195862,
0.14746281504631042,
-0.71234130859375,
-0.7394375205039978,
-0.10248827189207077,
0.2755127549171448,
-0.39023375511169434,
-0.3074018061161041,
0.30980008840560913,
-0.16761153936386108,
0.21761927008628845,
0.2524268329143524,
-0.6135496497154236,
0.46647873520851135,
0.7117953896522522,
0.5804993510246277,
-0.3818151652812958,
0.08993998169898987,
-0.35508862137794495,
0.4554721415042877,
-0.2041029930114746,
1.0851552486419678,
-0.23930267989635468,
-0.5988169312477112,
-0.2934812605381012,
-0.24152447283267975,
-0.10475188493728638,
-0.595707893371582,
0.46261677145957947,
-0.7849847674369812,
0.3413609564304352,
0.28315627574920654,
-0.5566678643226624,
-0.018750255927443504,
0.4601821303367615,
-0.5410069823265076,
0.7981012463569641,
-0.09466245025396347,
-0.7344669699668884,
0.5384696125984192,
-0.879136323928833,
-0.9293531179428101,
0.13511617481708527,
0.02691800706088543,
-0.5581339001655579,
0.012193460017442703,
0.07008522748947144,
0.6732733249664307,
-0.6105982065200806,
0.09651901572942734,
-0.4806077480316162,
0.03200973570346832,
0.3253648579120636,
-0.3233346939086914,
0.5989604592323303,
0.3175557553768158,
-0.3210922181606293,
-0.056934308260679245,
-0.9388768076896667,
0.1997639685869217,
0.2032526433467865,
-0.17626044154167175,
-0.37524861097335815,
0.650892972946167,
-0.2039211243391037,
-0.3088003695011139,
0.25468963384628296,
-0.9385302662849426,
-0.07643181085586548,
-0.4927132725715637,
0.45611849427223206,
0.4147401452064514,
0.14518730342388153,
0.19044585525989532,
-0.20732182264328003,
0.05100797489285469,
0.17316259443759918,
0.2597425878047943,
0.020850202068686485,
-0.5337263345718384,
-0.35841599106788635,
-0.3221715986728668,
-0.0650687888264656,
0.8892585635185242,
-0.7397688627243042,
0.2964729070663452,
-0.5668367743492126,
-0.33269596099853516,
0.03575320169329643,
-0.26575106382369995,
-0.002045844681560993,
0.6286991238594055,
0.48053303360939026,
0.21813803911209106,
-0.6946635246276855,
-0.7255575060844421,
-0.41260582208633423,
-0.22168247401714325,
-0.13418881595134735,
0.25035807490348816,
0.31548380851745605,
-0.17010536789894104,
1.0623359680175781,
-0.6950303912162781,
-0.32720229029655457,
0.09353480488061905,
-0.02197946049273014,
0.13847017288208008,
0.3669004440307617,
0.4861115515232086,
-0.9443431496620178,
-0.4613170027732849,
0.5726701617240906,
-0.6976000666618347,
0.349652498960495,
0.021000459790229797,
-0.0037102012429386377,
0.25958141684532166,
0.5903728604316711,
-0.3984427750110626,
0.6433219909667969,
0.003852774389088154,
-0.6025252938270569,
0.3771239221096039,
0.3668839931488037,
0.14643797278404236,
-1.3543474674224854,
-0.039611250162124634,
-0.13457955420017242,
-0.3164796233177185,
-0.7830252051353455,
-0.04985353723168373,
-0.21585746109485626,
-0.1932973563671112,
-0.33179131150245667,
0.5603896379470825,
-0.1055360957980156,
0.03195274993777275,
-0.06288529187440872,
-0.044744253158569336,
-0.06019683927297592,
0.16939765214920044,
-0.007463337387889624,
0.7440198063850403,
0.4845150411128998,
-0.7790125608444214,
0.7211548686027527,
-0.004549448378384113,
-0.3426533043384552,
0.7484393119812012,
-0.722974956035614,
0.0923500806093216,
0.22695079445838928,
0.20955409109592438,
-0.9415653347969055,
-0.2769804000854492,
0.09631545096635818,
-0.6347368359565735,
0.06979783624410629,
-0.3749891221523285,
-0.7522342801094055,
-0.25012916326522827,
-0.43411606550216675,
0.28992533683776855,
0.21539413928985596,
-0.49837538599967957,
0.7764341235160828,
0.34989413619041443,
0.012209738604724407,
-0.3495405316352844,
-1.0517208576202393,
0.25553423166275024,
-0.4719766676425934,
-0.5556123852729797,
0.4895668923854828,
0.17043371498584747,
-0.3079434037208557,
0.13495582342147827,
-0.027219075709581375,
-0.572562575340271,
0.3732471764087677,
0.2219819575548172,
0.3605209290981293,
-0.17907202243804932,
0.33582255244255066,
-0.23074325919151306,
-0.08306531608104706,
0.3701324164867401,
-0.6858310699462891,
0.20536434650421143,
0.10185788571834564,
-0.6213923096656799,
-0.40759944915771484,
0.6161078214645386,
0.18020062148571014,
-0.3017789423465729,
0.6181640625,
0.46084991097450256,
-0.3616678714752197,
-0.12800653278827667,
-0.3207477033138275,
-0.4337160289287567,
-0.44825100898742676,
0.4772997796535492,
-0.3964312672615051,
-0.8880261778831482,
0.26580119132995605,
-0.04011518880724907,
0.24972005188465118,
0.6192313432693481,
0.07074739784002304,
-0.5954247117042542,
0.9201788902282715,
0.6123012900352478,
0.054106034338474274,
0.6577321887016296,
-0.16431941092014313,
0.6392222046852112,
-0.6901098489761353,
-0.4132446348667145,
-0.5491294860839844,
-0.0315307080745697,
-0.6460321545600891,
-0.07137711346149445,
0.5137240290641785,
-0.056813158094882965,
-0.2425018548965454,
0.2616816461086273,
-0.5249645113945007,
0.35017260909080505,
0.07383541762828827,
0.3688586950302124,
0.47285330295562744,
0.4312956929206848,
0.24340307712554932,
0.2182050198316574,
-0.4851122498512268,
-0.29305797815322876,
1.5333260297775269,
0.009695800021290779,
0.6257632374763489,
0.7143921852111816,
0.5624478459358215,
0.42015692591667175,
0.27329927682876587,
-0.7202799916267395,
0.7385626435279846,
-0.3526785969734192,
-0.8755106925964355,
-0.1695975959300995,
-0.5934426188468933,
-1.352853775024414,
-0.129011332988739,
-0.01894637942314148,
-0.9566360116004944,
-0.07691445201635361,
-0.10343773663043976,
-0.2665487229824066,
0.42403140664100647,
-0.9925528168678284,
0.2859495282173157,
-0.4120315611362457,
-0.497061163187027,
-0.2744375765323639,
-0.6671775579452515,
0.32447266578674316,
0.029925277456641197,
-0.05884108319878578,
-0.08348660916090012,
-0.05755810812115669,
0.48079660534858704,
-0.4023458659648895,
0.9382516741752625,
-0.01781396195292473,
-0.1997358351945877,
0.537562370300293,
-0.06346055120229721,
0.4384813904762268,
0.28025513887405396,
-0.24366965889930725,
-0.13105139136314392,
0.1198582798242569,
-0.42621883749961853,
-0.5746914744377136,
0.6145883202552795,
-0.4189014732837677,
-0.4901714324951172,
-0.4205324649810791,
-0.28597569465637207,
-0.4342140853404999,
0.3224019408226013,
0.21860893070697784,
0.641472339630127,
-0.1440572440624237,
0.6214159727096558,
1.0568478107452393,
0.15424038469791412,
0.4012738764286041,
0.5091618895530701,
-0.1375035047531128,
-0.16430333256721497,
1.0480190515518188,
-0.01948733814060688,
0.296231210231781,
1.1451082229614258,
0.04934331774711609,
-0.6686367988586426,
-0.7793394327163696,
-0.25131672620773315,
-0.29808297753334045,
-0.33276471495628357,
-0.5814458727836609,
-0.6264052391052246,
-0.33960628509521484,
-0.21539226174354553,
0.09998641163110733,
-0.13028450310230255,
-0.3808285593986511,
-0.2769486904144287,
-0.014775335788726807,
0.9342380166053772,
0.7311819195747375,
0.42580896615982056,
0.2918568551540375,
-0.8451416492462158,
0.21413758397102356,
0.2531903386116028,
0.49769270420074463,
-0.2148885428905487,
-0.1967891901731491,
-0.31722018122673035,
0.13301953673362732,
-0.1658201515674591,
-0.7934674620628357,
-0.11406997591257095,
0.16240282356739044,
0.2784675657749176,
0.125707745552063,
0.3714626133441925,
0.41725096106529236,
-0.2079361081123352,
0.8914002776145935,
-0.029957300052046776,
-0.48601222038269043,
0.8213627338409424,
-0.6497882008552551,
-0.15026690065860748,
0.3496316969394684,
0.11716824769973755,
-0.012006144970655441,
0.3269341289997101,
-0.6098499298095703,
-0.9085282683372498,
0.4885040521621704,
0.0704813003540039,
0.019420353695750237,
0.14613062143325806,
0.2463189661502838,
-0.22274281084537506,
0.25298449397087097,
-0.7241866588592529,
0.023231854662299156,
-0.12438245862722397,
-0.15843376517295837,
0.428318589925766,
0.16446632146835327,
-0.34911099076271057,
-0.03016572631895542,
0.44028958678245544,
-0.23276223242282867,
0.7270957231521606,
0.04228852689266205,
-0.02062426134943962,
0.42399778962135315,
0.21241635084152222,
0.4076944589614868,
0.19398103654384613,
-0.2511117458343506,
0.09561450034379959,
0.2838258445262909,
-0.635190486907959,
-0.03085409663617611,
0.2455698847770691,
-0.02155899628996849,
-0.20308052003383636,
0.5599033832550049,
0.5026943683624268,
-0.35463643074035645,
-0.7015578150749207,
0.4892611801624298,
-0.13685278594493866,
-0.31272265315055847,
-0.12606041133403778,
0.09237434715032578,
-0.3296637535095215,
0.1093045175075531,
0.497610479593277,
0.10653283447027206,
0.3734886646270752,
-0.47668957710266113,
0.3012710213661194,
0.6427739858627319,
-0.23098443448543549,
-0.18545062839984894,
0.4670782685279846,
0.3919000029563904,
-0.11757586151361465,
0.6281129121780396,
-0.04778026416897774,
-0.3246658742427826,
0.5670624375343323,
0.4227507710456848,
1.0345700979232788,
-0.08925285935401917,
-0.09731768071651459,
0.01875261962413788,
0.38126540184020996,
0.48371440172195435,
0.6592445373535156,
-0.12615865468978882,
-0.5194715857505798,
-0.34634485840797424,
-0.2567734718322754,
-0.1068742424249649,
0.08623529225587845,
-0.39935100078582764,
0.1496230810880661,
-0.7283393740653992,
-0.207434743642807,
-0.10478109121322632,
0.20864906907081604,
-0.4012307822704315,
0.4241459369659424,
-0.43566036224365234,
0.7349199056625366,
-0.407351553440094,
0.8265839219093323,
0.8242077827453613,
-0.013145286589860916,
-0.5259630084037781,
0.1804068237543106,
0.0807592123746872,
-0.6459122896194458,
0.5540139675140381,
-0.09523385763168335,
-0.3590390086174011,
0.016068384051322937,
-0.4826515018939972,
-0.6945143938064575,
0.9351935386657715,
0.030050484463572502,
-0.22824405133724213,
0.2834049165248871,
0.4195755422115326,
0.4715466797351837,
-0.27473780512809753,
0.03312462568283081,
0.15741853415966034,
0.34409868717193604,
-0.1680167019367218,
-0.4745851755142212,
-0.06499134004116058,
-0.23888221383094788,
-0.14021234214305878,
0.34652671217918396,
-0.4113446772098541,
0.4959363341331482,
-0.22717450559139252,
-0.20617960393428802,
-0.08984736353158951,
0.6162742972373962,
-0.15038973093032837,
0.5324686169624329,
0.2648715376853943,
0.488883376121521,
0.40926676988601685,
-0.3613484501838684,
1.1106786727905273,
-0.029881734400987625,
-0.022876955568790436,
1.2864656448364258,
-0.4281923472881317,
1.2644473314285278,
0.3870150148868561,
-0.47062742710113525,
0.3621140420436859,
0.6107296943664551,
0.09058471024036407,
0.6596161723136902,
0.0054316334426403046,
-0.47586631774902344,
0.192560613155365,
-0.3979754149913788,
-0.4380369186401367,
0.23890289664268494,
0.6703636646270752,
-0.01190340518951416,
-0.10170143842697144,
-0.02892233245074749,
-0.2002270668745041,
-0.014485964551568031,
0.06942451745271683,
1.1975370645523071,
-0.14054608345031738,
-0.23000019788742065,
0.24876514077186584,
0.12306316196918488,
0.5804849863052368,
-0.7364369034767151,
0.15588130056858063,
0.014271240681409836,
0.21320189535617828,
-0.45795178413391113,
-1.060316562652588,
0.7847714424133301,
0.03976453095674515,
-0.3243803381919861,
-0.1400284618139267,
0.821173369884491,
-0.14666007459163666,
-0.10135824233293533,
0.011690839193761349,
0.14048397541046143,
-0.01942587085068226,
-0.28261035680770874,
-0.5263186693191528,
-0.185902401804924,
0.17505867779254913,
-0.03842690587043762,
0.299086332321167,
0.5653565526008606,
-0.24151571094989777,
0.6633176803588867,
0.9843119382858276,
-0.2222433090209961,
0.1583138406276703,
-0.1560819149017334,
0.6846849322319031,
-0.5496025681495667,
-0.41918107867240906,
-0.7604311108589172,
0.49258312582969666,
-0.34195685386657715,
-0.23679344356060028,
0.6491769552230835,
0.7088197469711304,
0.7923915982246399,
0.08278346061706543,
0.8732848763465881,
-0.22667498886585236,
0.7663016319274902,
-0.6646358966827393,
0.5065325498580933,
-0.5607888698577881,
0.7029157876968384,
0.14505906403064728,
-0.49665430188179016,
-0.2680525779724121,
0.2657425105571747,
-0.24717657268047333,
-0.005765795707702637,
0.613680362701416,
0.8427675366401672,
0.08762846887111664,
0.2092725783586502,
0.030622519552707672,
0.13121561706066132,
0.6375945210456848,
0.4413909912109375,
0.898464024066925,
-0.7323049902915955,
0.5866269469261169,
0.0032269377261400223,
0.06703826785087585,
-0.4698117971420288,
-0.9094067811965942,
-0.7080364227294922,
-0.6047417521476746,
-0.2577439248561859,
-0.30714282393455505,
0.17593757808208466,
0.6738401651382446,
1.0203803777694702,
-0.7952561378479004,
-0.13595712184906006,
-0.39310023188591003,
0.23536579310894012,
-0.137814000248909,
-0.24585698544979095,
0.2651737928390503,
0.030373895540833473,
-0.2590920627117157,
0.5448101162910461,
0.3444605767726898,
0.39672404527664185,
0.014425842091441154,
0.34797099232673645,
-0.4124423563480377,
0.013056306168437004,
0.8936264514923096,
0.22412927448749542,
-0.5560370087623596,
-0.1085113063454628,
0.04217179864645004,
-0.20599247515201569,
-0.19918185472488403,
0.5933261513710022,
-0.8524470925331116,
0.31066906452178955,
0.5263237953186035,
1.1051661968231201,
0.3748495578765869,
-0.3620136082172394,
0.48829811811447144,
-1.040197730064392,
0.009183406829833984,
0.36192846298217773,
-0.032764483243227005,
0.2601116895675659,
-0.8728559613227844,
0.6736423373222351,
0.2872696816921234,
-0.24567541480064392,
-0.8752198219299316,
0.498058021068573,
-0.8484587669372559,
-0.31135669350624084,
0.6971815824508667,
0.14815589785575867,
-0.11188896000385284,
-0.44598445296287537,
-0.05949323996901512,
-0.19473962485790253,
-0.4069098234176636,
0.5506776571273804,
0.37596747279167175,
-0.40080416202545166,
-0.06783939898014069,
-0.4671795964241028,
0.4994939863681793,
0.47840046882629395,
-1.5108301639556885,
0.1516738384962082,
0.2037835270166397,
0.1070241704583168,
0.06432674080133438,
0.293175607919693,
-0.1775374859571457,
0.10474706441164017,
-0.0026997781824320555,
-0.47975578904151917,
0.12193570286035538,
-0.48897507786750793,
0.20922726392745972,
0.009604093618690968,
-0.04973074421286583,
-0.3606257736682892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17566v1 | FrenchToxicityPrompts: a Large Benchmark for Evaluating and Mitigating Toxicity in French Texts | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | 2024-06-25T14:02:11 | Caroline Brun, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly popular but are also prone to
generating bias, toxic or harmful language, which can have detrimental effects
on individuals and communities. Although most efforts is put to assess and
mitigate toxicity in generated content, it is primarily concentrated on
English, while it's essential to consider other languages as well. For
addressing this issue, we create and release FrenchToxicityPrompts, a dataset
of 50K naturally occurring French prompts and their continuations, annotated
with toxicity scores from a widely used toxicity classifier. We evaluate 14
different models from four prevalent open-sourced families of LLMs against our
dataset to assess their potential toxicity across various dimensions. We hope
that our contribution will foster future research on toxicity detection and
mitigation beyond Englis | [
-0.1842627376317978,
-0.5396701693534851,
0.6212636828422546,
0.5555353760719299,
0.07838195562362671,
-0.3946968913078308,
-0.036047033965587616,
-0.34714025259017944,
-0.13621440529823303,
0.8954142928123474,
-0.4031156301498413,
-0.528583288192749,
-0.7653645873069763,
0.3871142566204071,
-0.4498148560523987,
0.839540958404541,
0.0603957325220108,
0.03987688571214676,
-0.3621431589126587,
-0.2656192183494568,
-0.43766939640045166,
-0.69704669713974,
-1.0077521800994873,
-0.25936299562454224,
1.1568255424499512,
0.5028005838394165,
0.42863428592681885,
-0.20456494390964508,
0.48338583111763,
0.1837349534034729,
-0.2035895138978958,
-0.0015708887949585915,
-0.5932796597480774,
0.398857444524765,
-0.6646513342857361,
-0.13870656490325928,
-0.04793170839548111,
-0.10715523362159729,
0.3240406811237335,
0.491166889667511,
0.15975260734558105,
0.018634434789419174,
0.3315611481666565,
0.6956451535224915,
-0.840400218963623,
-0.1458166539669037,
-0.3360576331615448,
-0.024560173973441124,
0.015817686915397644,
-0.482868492603302,
-0.7077586650848389,
-0.5855494141578674,
-0.084661103785038,
-0.1693163812160492,
-0.37355920672416687,
-0.1960090696811676,
0.4096212387084961,
0.24343092739582062,
-0.7736456990242004,
-0.37501969933509827,
-0.6085747480392456,
0.8524439930915833,
-0.5430760383605957,
0.39465203881263733,
0.15664790570735931,
0.33369481563568115,
-0.249753937125206,
-0.6788668632507324,
-0.3605150580406189,
-0.4474996030330658,
-0.016169890761375427,
0.013053981587290764,
-0.21660183370113373,
-0.2174985259771347,
0.3038129210472107,
0.2302367240190506,
-0.7733932733535767,
0.288428395986557,
-0.11652369797229767,
-0.5250611305236816,
0.7498301267623901,
0.31446605920791626,
0.700308084487915,
-0.11975396424531937,
-0.3784138560295105,
-0.05067416653037071,
-1.1962252855300903,
-0.14965775609016418,
0.5087050199508667,
0.25049981474876404,
0.007899266667664051,
0.5130282044410706,
0.05783194303512573,
0.34452545642852783,
-0.8272890448570251,
0.03604518994688988,
0.1603662669658661,
-0.25995323061943054,
0.10108204185962677,
-0.11025220900774002,
1.1669650077819824,
0.8453551530838013,
0.7901862263679504,
-0.1391727477312088,
-0.17771829664707184,
-0.05773013457655907,
0.08983071893453598,
-1.0369808673858643,
-0.40673738718032837,
0.44370347261428833,
-0.15556268393993378,
-0.4351405203342438,
-0.4033581018447876,
-1.0075132846832275,
-0.750632107257843,
0.1394597440958023,
0.44707292318344116,
-0.3635394871234894,
-0.1816556602716446,
-0.06279341131448746,
-0.23993365466594696,
-0.04514468088746071,
0.2386484444141388,
-0.44192516803741455,
0.19846931099891663,
0.15807774662971497,
0.872772216796875,
-0.49600109457969666,
0.003602755954489112,
-0.6898595094680786,
0.061714060604572296,
-0.18088966608047485,
0.904453456401825,
-0.5806750655174255,
-0.9812757968902588,
0.08819837123155594,
0.2072385996580124,
0.2675628066062927,
-0.9546216130256653,
1.097046136856079,
0.03690507635474205,
0.003912420477718115,
-0.6646162271499634,
-0.3064822852611542,
-0.010939533822238445,
0.16923260688781738,
-0.9564764499664307,
1.0863155126571655,
0.084037646651268,
-0.8439969420433044,
0.11289408802986145,
-0.2606588304042816,
-0.5417470335960388,
0.06175515055656433,
0.14721831679344177,
-0.19271551072597504,
-0.17457859218120575,
0.021382177248597145,
0.48849159479141235,
-0.4692651927471161,
0.05953269824385643,
-0.2344030737876892,
-0.041180893778800964,
0.20722165703773499,
-0.5702295899391174,
0.9102159738540649,
0.3930743634700775,
0.08270201832056046,
0.16375641524791718,
-0.44831377267837524,
-0.2924345135688782,
0.2518167793750763,
-0.2564554810523987,
-0.4753764569759369,
0.05235922709107399,
0.48977527022361755,
0.5541570782661438,
-0.12129651010036469,
-0.5465351343154907,
-0.2024734616279602,
-0.14202944934368134,
0.6157252788543701,
0.689303994178772,
0.7061778903007507,
0.02361818216741085,
-0.6466593742370605,
0.35971057415008545,
0.08093325793743134,
0.3071911633014679,
-0.11856161803007126,
-0.5079231858253479,
-0.27023154497146606,
-0.23452699184417725,
-0.15283307433128357,
0.724364161491394,
-0.6241032481193542,
0.49827760457992554,
-0.27931997179985046,
-0.6492176651954651,
0.325530081987381,
0.09838897734880447,
0.26638054847717285,
0.5072990655899048,
0.26391348242759705,
-0.2456071525812149,
-0.03892044350504875,
-0.8892122507095337,
-0.5409534573554993,
0.16848105192184448,
-0.10633724182844162,
0.41502639651298523,
0.7217614650726318,
-0.31842854619026184,
0.4998369812965393,
-0.36343276500701904,
-0.2797018885612488,
-0.04018883407115936,
0.017251931130886078,
-0.10375474393367767,
0.3046867847442627,
0.8794105052947998,
-0.46097949147224426,
-0.5246140360832214,
-0.22447122633457184,
-0.6004065275192261,
-0.5429165959358215,
0.14109593629837036,
-0.1432911902666092,
-0.08504823595285416,
0.7001764178276062,
-0.29993879795074463,
0.016099777072668076,
0.6591275930404663,
-0.23508408665657043,
0.6276648044586182,
0.12558095157146454,
0.17570212483406067,
-0.9077804684638977,
0.09060808271169662,
0.6092050671577454,
-0.28256455063819885,
-0.4842715561389923,
-0.06322890520095825,
-0.17018306255340576,
-0.10571777075529099,
-0.9182082414627075,
1.0333025455474854,
-0.09016576409339905,
0.6455594301223755,
0.08782651275396347,
0.28735166788101196,
0.25270646810531616,
-0.03843342512845993,
0.21131084859371185,
0.9205889105796814,
0.28968650102615356,
-0.6277252435684204,
0.4444258213043213,
0.1692754328250885,
-0.19741734862327576,
0.5931624174118042,
-0.5857310891151428,
-0.3091634511947632,
0.06538145989179611,
0.3952990770339966,
-0.8613137602806091,
-0.15187761187553406,
0.14860932528972626,
-0.30154651403427124,
0.15970781445503235,
0.03403885290026665,
-0.7908629775047302,
-0.41411054134368896,
-0.28223738074302673,
0.45131587982177734,
0.48713386058807373,
-0.47940725088119507,
0.2900409698486328,
0.24844425916671753,
-0.536208987236023,
-0.3597383499145508,
-0.7411242127418518,
0.21892674267292023,
-0.48519307374954224,
-0.5679354667663574,
-0.10049738734960556,
-0.30588001012802124,
-0.3501553237438202,
-0.09315343201160431,
0.07726191729307175,
0.08597050607204437,
-0.008415729738771915,
0.23499765992164612,
-0.14389261603355408,
0.29265692830085754,
0.3083745539188385,
0.06266321241855621,
-0.08710138499736786,
0.39792025089263916,
0.07252586632966995,
0.4253728985786438,
0.396569162607193,
-0.21127210557460785,
-0.02062683366239071,
0.4397643208503723,
0.7405323386192322,
-0.3181334137916565,
0.8418677449226379,
0.1307896226644516,
-0.43286994099617004,
-0.5782795548439026,
-0.4246380031108856,
-0.2760963439941406,
-0.4817180335521698,
0.3606714904308319,
-0.11352399736642838,
-0.6524612903594971,
0.6533495187759399,
-0.4773864448070526,
-0.14801058173179626,
0.502761960029602,
0.9459083080291748,
0.251688152551651,
0.933107852935791,
0.22062665224075317,
-0.35654547810554504,
0.21524927020072937,
-0.06282030791044235,
0.22591491043567657,
-0.516101598739624,
-0.22007690370082855,
-0.6377939581871033,
0.2361656129360199,
-0.5152605772018433,
-0.438151478767395,
0.5321971774101257,
-0.18893851339817047,
-0.6045904755592346,
0.09808460623025894,
-0.4307025074958801,
0.5877118110656738,
0.14775119721889496,
0.22189880907535553,
0.3454180061817169,
-0.05410604551434517,
-0.3723459243774414,
-0.10183139145374298,
-0.6408458948135376,
-0.8236923217773438,
1.0220359563827515,
0.5332334637641907,
0.7114931344985962,
0.1396438181400299,
0.5451053380966187,
0.3628873825073242,
0.4528202414512634,
-0.7428038120269775,
0.442006915807724,
-0.31150293350219727,
-0.8770134449005127,
-0.0330616720020771,
-0.70504230260849,
-0.5234575867652893,
-0.15555204451084137,
-0.10816536098718643,
-1.0342992544174194,
0.06833656132221222,
0.004462323617190123,
-0.3360380530357361,
0.42507418990135193,
-0.809714138507843,
1.0497158765792847,
-0.3989064693450928,
-0.978257954120636,
0.007836032658815384,
-0.2950819730758667,
0.61324542760849,
-0.33536776900291443,
0.6574326157569885,
-0.34170061349868774,
0.03037538379430771,
0.41069281101226807,
-0.34852123260498047,
0.7881993651390076,
-0.014264163561165333,
-0.5666002035140991,
0.3664202392101288,
0.41534924507141113,
0.5981353521347046,
0.26660680770874023,
-0.3757701516151428,
0.08491803705692291,
-0.046849291771650314,
-0.39893993735313416,
-0.14029790461063385,
1.2078487873077393,
-0.483222097158432,
-0.1603536605834961,
-0.3654797077178955,
-0.5446209907531738,
-0.3798050284385681,
0.09008950740098953,
0.7224280834197998,
0.3722333312034607,
-0.5166735649108887,
-0.12582603096961975,
0.7771050333976746,
-1.0775521993637085,
0.3422276973724365,
0.461609423160553,
-0.2722679376602173,
-0.07332528382539749,
1.265002727508545,
0.00496947905048728,
0.462947279214859,
0.11397232860326767,
0.26381686329841614,
-0.48429057002067566,
-0.6039318442344666,
0.07885472476482391,
0.2770824134349823,
-1.0747100114822388,
-0.21571394801139832,
-0.5071340799331665,
-0.4556238055229187,
-0.16802412271499634,
-0.16378822922706604,
-0.22177478671073914,
-0.014675197191536427,
-0.2811478078365326,
-0.21827638149261475,
0.6211193799972534,
0.7877500057220459,
-0.08221138268709183,
0.07140754163265228,
-1.3538801670074463,
-0.008017866872251034,
0.2696205973625183,
0.5225592255592346,
-0.33570435643196106,
-0.472536563873291,
0.1788291335105896,
-0.25680193305015564,
-0.34818553924560547,
-1.1096245050430298,
0.4875858724117279,
0.06396535038948059,
0.6800937652587891,
0.3262351155281067,
0.5484630465507507,
-0.3862095773220062,
-0.5110125541687012,
1.114331841468811,
0.2681407034397125,
-0.7358084321022034,
0.6030675172805786,
-0.6477036476135254,
-0.055184319615364075,
0.41431689262390137,
0.9223006963729858,
-0.7272876501083374,
-0.6170303225517273,
-0.16837528347969055,
-0.9730477929115295,
0.21387198567390442,
0.3955546021461487,
0.2866838872432709,
-0.4514670968055725,
0.19108320772647858,
0.05994784086942673,
-0.17670337855815887,
-0.7909930944442749,
-0.17263051867485046,
0.08737177401781082,
-0.3748796880245209,
-0.34497901797294617,
-0.5823796391487122,
-0.34257107973098755,
-0.17078545689582825,
0.7643170952796936,
0.3016587197780609,
-0.03915765509009361,
0.1486491560935974,
-0.31893596053123474,
-0.4249703586101532,
0.36585184931755066,
0.45484328269958496,
0.44826585054397583,
-0.16520282626152039,
0.04882403835654259,
0.2896136939525604,
-0.5592889785766602,
0.33592256903648376,
-0.04505854845046997,
-0.032983940094709396,
-0.2754535973072052,
0.5881668925285339,
0.3585223853588104,
0.05490526556968689,
-1.0348584651947021,
0.6064069867134094,
0.05551544204354286,
-0.2676921486854553,
-0.24967189133167267,
0.07893212139606476,
0.26107877492904663,
0.07103860378265381,
0.09833861887454987,
-0.17149284482002258,
0.29200902581214905,
-0.5706577301025391,
0.3403099775314331,
0.35285598039627075,
-0.5344071984291077,
-0.048889223486185074,
0.6062983870506287,
0.7925128936767578,
-0.002276859013363719,
0.2940928041934967,
-0.13286785781383514,
-0.5120261907577515,
0.4141348600387573,
0.11804796755313873,
0.7831834554672241,
-0.5110495090484619,
0.19107721745967865,
0.6958147287368774,
0.5197760462760925,
0.1576215624809265,
0.36796513199806213,
0.7141451835632324,
-0.7425448298454285,
-0.47978687286376953,
-0.8376615047454834,
-0.21343056857585907,
0.527748703956604,
-0.37187063694000244,
0.30605602264404297,
-0.3342089354991913,
0.01871970295906067,
0.11765343695878983,
-0.25861501693725586,
-0.3690332770347595,
0.08442502468824387,
0.15335555374622345,
1.2916014194488525,
-1.5156924724578857,
0.6483481526374817,
0.5685151219367981,
-0.5851274132728577,
-0.6098255515098572,
0.12772801518440247,
0.3042932450771332,
-0.37205854058265686,
0.5744065046310425,
0.20254278182983398,
0.0073407976888120174,
0.12162954360246658,
-0.47483181953430176,
-0.18533852696418762,
0.765455424785614,
0.44425052404403687,
-0.9225553870201111,
0.28908854722976685,
0.2847129702568054,
0.36869898438453674,
0.030895844101905823,
0.3288419246673584,
0.9182175397872925,
0.7421537041664124,
0.1524049937725067,
-0.7851243615150452,
0.2599867582321167,
-0.4365657567977905,
-0.2346521019935608,
0.13538046181201935,
-0.5786502957344055,
0.4950765371322632,
0.0826883614063263,
-0.1681692898273468,
0.02264716476202011,
-0.136065274477005,
-0.027811072766780853,
0.16571438312530518,
0.34983137249946594,
0.7305707931518555,
0.3789268136024475,
-0.17066551744937897,
1.2241662740707397,
-0.22292934358119965,
0.05484510213136673,
0.8967780470848083,
-0.5726928114891052,
0.7960175275802612,
0.31939390301704407,
-0.2236512452363968,
0.3825336992740631,
0.662466287612915,
0.23309609293937683,
0.400861918926239,
0.5145975351333618,
-0.7097808718681335,
-0.37203896045684814,
-0.48780006170272827,
-0.15074382722377777,
-0.03724345192313194,
0.6802299618721008,
-0.4453025460243225,
-0.4445483684539795,
0.35987430810928345,
-0.030727822333574295,
0.42712336778640747,
-0.3085351586341858,
0.6579166650772095,
0.36867257952690125,
-0.34752440452575684,
0.4645029306411743,
-0.4810250699520111,
0.4317995011806488,
-0.4342203140258789,
-0.1561325192451477,
-0.28651291131973267,
0.07940971106290817,
-0.23292076587677002,
-1.1745541095733643,
0.3255538046360016,
-0.062102001160383224,
0.08452043682336807,
0.03224584460258484,
0.7542662024497986,
-0.23197998106479645,
-0.48980844020843506,
0.8527436852455139,
0.5675439238548279,
0.01769966632127762,
-0.6486924886703491,
-0.5157482028007507,
0.08725912123918533,
-0.340145468711853,
-0.3636215329170227,
0.27290335297584534,
0.5000749826431274,
-0.3038952946662903,
0.7682431936264038,
0.30650612711906433,
0.13338252902030945,
-0.04738148674368858,
0.3165704607963562,
1.132333517074585,
-0.4192572236061096,
0.06769251078367233,
-0.7277334332466125,
0.7032387256622314,
-0.061946287751197815,
-0.06552992761135101,
0.765644907951355,
0.48964259028434753,
0.4149188697338104,
0.1261909157037735,
1.1021419763565063,
0.28984740376472473,
0.5119070410728455,
-0.5041331648826599,
0.7599145770072937,
-0.6231843829154968,
0.4997340738773346,
-0.29774484038352966,
-1.1757094860076904,
-0.43315812945365906,
0.14225928485393524,
-0.37385231256484985,
0.2055409699678421,
0.8804264068603516,
1.032982587814331,
0.1456901729106903,
-0.2573467493057251,
0.282986044883728,
0.5170228481292725,
0.3170226216316223,
0.7506717443466187,
1.0565581321716309,
-0.0001864023070083931,
0.6352722644805908,
-0.30053776502609253,
-0.2576541006565094,
-0.3839172422885895,
-1.1691672801971436,
-0.9970231652259827,
-0.5289402008056641,
-0.28914692997932434,
-0.5094821453094482,
0.4084337651729584,
0.7140232920646667,
0.18123692274093628,
-1.0652962923049927,
0.1789180189371109,
-0.26077988743782043,
0.1488351970911026,
0.1955437958240509,
-0.2509240508079529,
0.09680115431547165,
-0.15045420825481415,
-0.5780200958251953,
0.1505291908979416,
0.21241410076618195,
0.13732989132404327,
-0.33896487951278687,
-0.26427897810935974,
0.03693237900733948,
0.3674081861972809,
1.0586756467819214,
0.3920186758041382,
-0.3926723897457123,
-0.6018840670585632,
-0.19291415810585022,
-0.42063280940055847,
-0.41775602102279663,
0.6914452314376831,
-0.4262407422065735,
0.4324689209461212,
0.7812550067901611,
0.08330251276493073,
0.1292756050825119,
-0.45085299015045166,
0.7218553423881531,
-0.931648313999176,
0.1560354083776474,
0.5795660018920898,
0.40368151664733887,
0.4134614169597626,
-0.48399606347084045,
0.6085349917411804,
0.0916728526353836,
-0.6316409111022949,
-0.7244242429733276,
0.3838874101638794,
-0.9229908585548401,
-0.5285952091217041,
1.669116735458374,
-0.12525680661201477,
-0.025544477626681328,
-0.17226555943489075,
-0.3612922430038452,
0.023704353719949722,
-0.2297993302345276,
0.3156834542751312,
0.6879386305809021,
0.12086344510316849,
-0.3384166359901428,
-1.1677473783493042,
0.75145024061203,
0.18405629694461823,
-0.9155088067054749,
0.3051072955131531,
0.5818695425987244,
0.45921850204467773,
-0.014945012517273426,
0.4396889805793762,
-0.2991124093532562,
0.18510405719280243,
-0.1209351047873497,
0.2657758891582489,
0.28110283613204956,
-0.38663241267204285,
-0.2171773761510849,
-0.1555810272693634,
0.3043467700481415,
0.4373454451560974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17563v1 | Multi-property Steering of Large Language Models with Dynamic Activation Composition | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | 2024-06-25T14:00:42 | Daniel Scalena, Gabriele Sarti, Malvina Nissim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Activation steering methods were shown to be effective in conditioning
language model generation by additively intervening over models' intermediate
representations. However, the evaluation of these techniques has so far been
limited to single conditioning properties and synthetic settings. In this work,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of various activation steering
strategies, highlighting the property-dependent nature of optimal parameters to
ensure a robust effect throughout generation. To address this issue, we propose
Dynamic Activation Composition, an information-theoretic approach to modulate
the steering intensity of one or more properties throughout generation. Our
experiments on multi-property steering show that our method successfully
maintains high conditioning while minimizing the impact of conditioning on
generation fluency. | [
-0.47975316643714905,
-1.052554726600647,
0.3124382793903351,
0.6274266839027405,
-0.06248439848423004,
0.3970867991447449,
-0.554933488368988,
-0.36719560623168945,
0.19153176248073578,
0.059220172464847565,
-0.3642667531967163,
-0.02686644159257412,
-0.7098388671875,
-0.46090373396873474,
-0.24565722048282623,
1.0461171865463257,
0.018298571929335594,
-0.155214324593544,
0.11744485050439835,
-0.2193603813648224,
-0.2333083599805832,
-0.4362366199493408,
-0.47832927107810974,
-0.6500451564788818,
0.5620788931846619,
0.24214845895767212,
1.1711443662643433,
0.6985264420509338,
0.04025615006685257,
0.37150225043296814,
-0.3328379690647125,
-0.020921586081385612,
-0.5428386330604553,
0.5668429136276245,
-0.10406681150197983,
-0.3295331299304962,
-0.5815498232841492,
-0.023893024772405624,
1.0732004642486572,
0.8819168210029602,
-0.260552316904068,
-0.2702820301055908,
0.14943315088748932,
0.40775880217552185,
-0.9702519774436951,
0.16241933405399323,
-0.6454640626907349,
0.0031143093947321177,
-0.00835508108139038,
-0.5081594586372375,
-0.6608218550682068,
0.14795827865600586,
0.2723492681980133,
-0.7278392314910889,
-0.012137498706579208,
-0.16346193850040436,
0.597136378288269,
-0.05921367555856705,
-0.8942596316337585,
-0.22682876884937286,
-1.2409292459487915,
1.0554893016815186,
-0.5065410137176514,
0.6609559059143066,
0.36256805062294006,
0.046582940965890884,
-0.21046864986419678,
-0.3709598779678345,
-0.6235970854759216,
-0.7476000785827637,
0.19993995130062103,
0.24619819223880768,
0.09089340269565582,
0.3233778178691864,
0.28173476457595825,
0.09554149955511093,
-0.053839173167943954,
0.1353125125169754,
-0.12094287574291229,
-0.15529848635196686,
0.5323817729949951,
-0.046625178307294846,
0.2739920914173126,
0.0610467828810215,
-0.45147469639778137,
-0.36044326424598694,
-0.708852231502533,
-0.10044845193624496,
0.7014878988265991,
0.3726164698600769,
-0.05374300107359886,
0.6586154699325562,
-0.2495429962873459,
0.6764667630195618,
0.546059787273407,
-0.4279528856277466,
0.2852506935596466,
-0.8603945970535278,
0.030734404921531677,
0.13612130284309387,
0.4845842123031616,
0.15559354424476624,
-0.08817687630653381,
-0.25532227754592896,
-0.4174210727214813,
-0.1593170315027237,
0.16792447865009308,
-0.7153834700584412,
-0.14025449752807617,
0.30477744340896606,
-0.3253517150878906,
-0.3844284117221832,
0.09571021050214767,
-0.854056179523468,
-0.4499720633029938,
-0.4986072778701782,
0.35824108123779297,
-0.4582723081111908,
-0.7565598487854004,
0.1300668865442276,
-0.18440541625022888,
0.2926379442214966,
-0.04214770346879959,
-1.4539196491241455,
0.1564139872789383,
0.49764740467071533,
0.4455602467060089,
-0.21544578671455383,
-0.4132375717163086,
-0.4888453781604767,
0.6154353618621826,
-0.22148030996322632,
0.5789737701416016,
-0.7723875641822815,
-0.1436646431684494,
0.15586799383163452,
-0.2880234122276306,
-0.23266378045082092,
-0.4027721881866455,
-0.017261868342757225,
-0.6583648920059204,
-0.04899762570858002,
-0.011501661501824856,
-0.34318801760673523,
0.005722879897803068,
0.1310049295425415,
-0.9842055439949036,
1.0222394466400146,
0.2957809269428253,
-0.6079661846160889,
0.5642531514167786,
-0.5930178761482239,
-0.8603885769844055,
-0.37488341331481934,
0.07722798734903336,
-0.2688334882259369,
0.4450717270374298,
-0.06702359765768051,
0.25769996643066406,
0.030617186799645424,
0.5361649990081787,
-0.14525814354419708,
-0.05299735441803932,
0.49215900897979736,
-0.70998215675354,
0.44673773646354675,
0.15622060000896454,
-0.5179088115692139,
0.40143445134162903,
-1.092462182044983,
-0.14781522750854492,
-0.032693780958652496,
-0.7867604494094849,
-0.23544077575206757,
0.12049025297164917,
-0.16156627237796783,
0.18505121767520905,
0.3814302086830139,
-0.21049906313419342,
0.4436909854412079,
-0.2877977192401886,
0.06806637346744537,
0.5849902629852295,
0.2580976188182831,
0.9571710228919983,
-0.3412656784057617,
0.848088800907135,
0.15779048204421997,
-0.04139157012104988,
-0.1813248246908188,
-0.32470816373825073,
-0.9535343647003174,
-0.19008874893188477,
0.21412694454193115,
0.3201070725917816,
-0.8562963604927063,
0.5061184763908386,
-0.14459893107414246,
-0.40862753987312317,
-0.4300812780857086,
0.28138384222984314,
0.5785028338432312,
0.10275863856077194,
0.3968568742275238,
0.03932027891278267,
-0.1584709882736206,
-0.739941418170929,
-0.15551330149173737,
-0.03971731662750244,
0.433984637260437,
-0.17319312691688538,
0.08187060058116913,
0.07749204337596893,
0.45355337858200073,
-0.2888822853565216,
0.25749027729034424,
-0.5799885392189026,
0.5040538907051086,
-0.07898050546646118,
0.6442332863807678,
0.7516773343086243,
-0.7007564902305603,
-0.5502876043319702,
0.09627793729305267,
-0.14115728437900543,
-0.1046285331249237,
-0.4586753845214844,
-0.3256198763847351,
0.0018080933950841427,
0.40948835015296936,
-0.79152911901474,
0.19592608511447906,
0.7711411118507385,
-0.30551955103874207,
0.7932818531990051,
-0.3924422264099121,
0.024846382439136505,
-0.7035617232322693,
-0.009674769826233387,
0.07863035053014755,
-0.012019188143312931,
-1.0621258020401,
0.16608117520809174,
-0.10220354050397873,
0.13978874683380127,
-0.43638718128204346,
0.41693198680877686,
-0.6484498381614685,
0.1841563731431961,
-0.34192541241645813,
-0.08657518774271011,
0.00023764451907481998,
0.5620539784431458,
-0.07632433623075485,
0.5945749282836914,
0.6194438338279724,
-0.8337288498878479,
0.6616863012313843,
0.012729338370263577,
-0.30057021975517273,
0.6685249209403992,
-0.3316045105457306,
0.003313360968604684,
-0.2890913784503937,
-0.0019310367060825229,
-0.9809842705726624,
-0.19855649769306183,
0.09816514700651169,
-0.05613945052027702,
0.6873373985290527,
-0.047060802578926086,
-0.39537400007247925,
0.0755251795053482,
-0.3524710237979889,
0.32908156514167786,
0.26865673065185547,
-0.30199894309043884,
0.9212135672569275,
0.12689651548862457,
-0.16541504859924316,
-0.5185632109642029,
-0.5784037113189697,
-0.20909163355827332,
-0.3884909152984619,
-0.5671297311782837,
0.7354211211204529,
-0.17046061158180237,
-0.2752779722213745,
-0.04166297987103462,
0.029640572145581245,
-0.03985914587974548,
0.21822728216648102,
-0.04945924133062363,
-0.10365975648164749,
-0.03562683239579201,
0.25637581944465637,
0.4159614145755768,
-0.23675231635570526,
-0.14247414469718933,
-0.14227555692195892,
0.8277797102928162,
0.2664368450641632,
-0.5406343340873718,
-0.450335294008255,
0.4234129786491394,
0.8484640121459961,
-0.493097186088562,
1.134344458580017,
0.45925867557525635,
0.06437220424413681,
-0.4006907641887665,
-0.28359395265579224,
-0.35148385167121887,
-0.5118770599365234,
0.6299488544464111,
-0.5874348282814026,
-0.2853759229183197,
0.6871126294136047,
-0.026498258113861084,
0.10633616149425507,
0.3400035798549652,
0.755541205406189,
0.04636125639081001,
1.4598208665847778,
0.5699568390846252,
-0.11915417015552521,
1.099071741104126,
-0.472496896982193,
0.38000577688217163,
-0.7087498307228088,
-0.4763382375240326,
-0.4620698094367981,
-0.4663963317871094,
-0.45976704359054565,
-0.13810941576957703,
0.27013757824897766,
0.24820353090763092,
-0.27528202533721924,
0.17877204716205597,
-0.17123207449913025,
-0.08254367113113403,
0.7333143949508667,
0.1744624227285385,
0.3994412422180176,
0.08664924651384354,
-0.31544625759124756,
0.15272444486618042,
-0.8865039944648743,
-0.09052392840385437,
0.9105211496353149,
0.3384557366371155,
0.868002712726593,
0.12767140567302704,
0.3753267824649811,
-0.09664175659418106,
0.21357037127017975,
-0.8850017189979553,
0.4773211181163788,
0.2278023213148117,
-0.7161442637443542,
-0.4842835068702698,
-0.27315667271614075,
-1.0811294317245483,
0.2115471065044403,
-0.6822577714920044,
-0.5999032258987427,
0.1967131495475769,
0.32484114170074463,
-0.2231951653957367,
0.08137153089046478,
-0.5533495545387268,
0.7873696684837341,
-0.6232119798660278,
-0.5479694604873657,
-0.5719918012619019,
-0.4287208020687103,
0.29272785782814026,
-0.24546051025390625,
0.09882257133722305,
-0.10486426204442978,
-0.11466766148805618,
0.4077147841453552,
-0.3065755069255829,
0.5398201942443848,
-0.37180423736572266,
-0.2546098828315735,
0.1953066736459732,
0.21644361317157745,
0.7439212799072266,
-0.3602963089942932,
-0.4247020184993744,
-0.606925368309021,
-0.41030153632164,
-0.33572328090667725,
-0.9201186299324036,
0.6538040041923523,
-0.6394924521446228,
-0.42313817143440247,
-0.054534316062927246,
-0.6005150079727173,
-0.4295182228088379,
0.14942364394664764,
0.07875889539718628,
0.5727586150169373,
-0.027162177488207817,
0.4159584939479828,
0.3955942392349243,
-0.1304389238357544,
0.4689168930053711,
0.4348585903644562,
-0.15707898139953613,
-0.3721432387828827,
1.0907785892486572,
0.1758328676223755,
0.9020561575889587,
0.19234402477741241,
0.2913181781768799,
-0.2806793749332428,
-0.848794162273407,
-0.1873898059129715,
0.19971929490566254,
-0.6682315468788147,
0.10710568726062775,
-0.37977540493011475,
-0.14986205101013184,
-0.15138894319534302,
-0.024097144603729248,
-0.5907680988311768,
-0.508728563785553,
-0.23098106682300568,
-0.47473251819610596,
0.10679835081100464,
0.6720394492149353,
0.04734760522842407,
0.853635847568512,
-0.5589384436607361,
0.3919549882411957,
0.34088826179504395,
0.3763945400714874,
0.23059089481830597,
-0.4801962375640869,
-0.44494563341140747,
0.2355213463306427,
-0.620791494846344,
-1.072056770324707,
0.2217416614294052,
0.5075535774230957,
0.8906435966491699,
0.8074643611907959,
0.018299298360943794,
0.4738593101501465,
-0.0912904441356659,
0.7069445848464966,
0.4097568690776825,
-0.9307119846343994,
0.31036627292633057,
-0.27790841460227966,
0.33177265524864197,
0.5610260963439941,
0.3048690855503082,
-0.10455632209777832,
-0.7460585832595825,
-0.6581268310546875,
-1.0182923078536987,
0.353092223405838,
-0.002435332862660289,
0.5568327903747559,
0.14218658208847046,
0.09242045134305954,
-0.12536847591400146,
0.46031031012535095,
-0.7512063980102539,
-0.2602709233760834,
-0.07037574052810669,
-0.20811164379119873,
0.3164074122905731,
-0.45333003997802734,
-0.09020300209522247,
-0.25732874870300293,
0.8012308478355408,
-0.06451760977506638,
0.061358191072940826,
-0.36389970779418945,
-0.10467160493135452,
-0.08530685305595398,
0.22282984852790833,
0.6772910952568054,
0.8739180564880371,
0.06309950351715088,
0.26837629079818726,
0.010517542250454426,
-0.22816431522369385,
0.5643310546875,
-0.04001118242740631,
-0.39806291460990906,
-0.241648867726326,
0.5572172403335571,
1.1147637367248535,
0.3036606013774872,
-0.2137797474861145,
0.49481770396232605,
0.5736958384513855,
-0.07343297451734543,
0.2139860838651657,
0.26099708676338196,
0.05105386674404144,
0.09327207505702972,
0.2910010814666748,
-0.10421586036682129,
-0.22842784225940704,
-0.713290274143219,
0.05293787270784378,
0.5440153479576111,
-0.4138380289077759,
-0.6157584190368652,
0.5543965101242065,
0.2449445128440857,
0.06336837261915207,
0.6677323579788208,
-0.23258188366889954,
-0.5554563999176025,
0.4912082850933075,
0.6543192863464355,
0.8382576704025269,
-0.714667558670044,
0.13852737843990326,
0.15840211510658264,
0.10501957684755325,
-0.13707417249679565,
0.4706651270389557,
-0.20427927374839783,
-1.096303939819336,
-0.678570568561554,
-0.38554272055625916,
-0.23110051453113556,
-0.009759529493749142,
-0.5113523602485657,
0.31601661443710327,
-0.3424006998538971,
-0.5738767385482788,
0.11233500391244888,
-0.39945924282073975,
-0.5173941254615784,
0.10463819652795792,
0.0006637145997956395,
0.5834881067276001,
-0.9979088306427002,
0.9023497700691223,
0.5887612104415894,
-0.5166610479354858,
-0.7938419580459595,
-0.012920263223350048,
-0.26184317469596863,
-0.4410932958126068,
0.729909360408783,
-0.17350947856903076,
-0.2362474501132965,
0.00954268965870142,
-0.4738209545612335,
-0.7505598664283752,
0.7434713840484619,
0.45142272114753723,
-0.25661081075668335,
-0.04280782490968704,
0.13490742444992065,
0.49016073346138,
-0.34999221563339233,
0.1477339118719101,
0.8781645894050598,
1.1342252492904663,
0.2300122082233429,
-0.9629258513450623,
-0.07789216190576553,
-0.18847042322158813,
-0.082916758954525,
-0.0018989014206454158,
-0.5779373645782471,
0.5834102630615234,
-0.0552748441696167,
-0.10226333886384964,
0.133928120136261,
0.8235781788825989,
0.2585242986679077,
-0.17058753967285156,
0.6405227780342102,
0.39338570833206177,
0.7064514756202698,
-0.06274741142988205,
1.0713540315628052,
-1.0156437158584595,
0.188523069024086,
0.8710305690765381,
-0.12771572172641754,
0.5795144438743591,
0.5711573362350464,
-0.09930326789617538,
0.5535899996757507,
-0.06566163152456284,
0.15108376741409302,
0.7671840190887451,
0.48554977774620056,
-0.69129478931427,
-0.08644174784421921,
-0.3483020067214966,
-0.17154456675052643,
0.614668607711792,
0.4597301781177521,
-0.3160662353038788,
0.1419120877981186,
0.3888223469257355,
0.11009237915277481,
-0.05608691647648811,
0.06695958226919174,
0.8144934773445129,
-0.2693866491317749,
-1.0704493522644043,
0.6086843013763428,
0.1328713446855545,
0.4054056406021118,
-0.8652042746543884,
0.1544361263513565,
-0.06567731499671936,
0.0892489030957222,
-0.1106218621134758,
-0.7095957398414612,
0.031439799815416336,
-0.5263479351997375,
-0.19039002060890198,
-0.4967704117298126,
0.6680132150650024,
-0.9479255080223083,
-0.16745398938655853,
0.5041515827178955,
0.3075282871723175,
-0.42115986347198486,
-0.06997466087341309,
-0.42811721563339233,
0.2896507978439331,
-0.12823286652565002,
-0.7662104368209839,
0.17405684292316437,
0.4274643063545227,
0.1733572781085968,
0.715760350227356,
0.6730359196662903,
0.5544254183769226,
0.4452459216117859,
0.26325249671936035,
0.9098399877548218,
-0.6053219437599182,
-0.48783570528030396,
-0.5674458146095276,
0.8359033465385437,
-0.10988926142454147,
-0.17561699450016022,
0.7373601794242859,
0.37752485275268555,
0.40885111689567566,
0.006079706363379955,
0.8957508206367493,
0.13326852023601532,
-0.1214461401104927,
-0.6678739190101624,
0.418548047542572,
-0.36713242530822754,
0.2669246196746826,
-0.1014319583773613,
-1.5622615814208984,
-0.20472735166549683,
0.4553011655807495,
0.006688335910439491,
0.3579258322715759,
0.7045296430587769,
0.9145261645317078,
-0.13906298577785492,
-0.398298978805542,
0.14175564050674438,
0.3224068284034729,
0.6036941409111023,
0.3629615902900696,
1.1826092004776,
0.056402258574962616,
0.33488860726356506,
-0.3343915641307831,
-0.3283599019050598,
-0.18113070726394653,
-1.2308579683303833,
-0.6267995238304138,
-0.4267372190952301,
-0.4192948043346405,
-0.5925212502479553,
-0.13200408220291138,
0.8385398983955383,
1.1161185503005981,
-0.8378908038139343,
-0.25310370326042175,
-0.05444030836224556,
0.08751136064529419,
-0.4012153744697571,
-0.17756864428520203,
0.2612583041191101,
-0.3926699757575989,
-0.9139774441719055,
0.8663324117660522,
0.29931238293647766,
0.3529863655567169,
-0.9207269549369812,
-0.19546300172805786,
-0.2148551493883133,
0.19094663858413696,
0.6823655962944031,
0.26338496804237366,
-0.3543303310871124,
-0.18488965928554535,
-0.23389175534248352,
-0.2030080407857895,
0.131574347615242,
1.119735836982727,
-0.42063358426094055,
0.792346179485321,
0.9145611524581909,
0.42860057950019836,
0.7360901832580566,
0.24290643632411957,
0.8997308611869812,
-0.9136306643486023,
0.595747709274292,
0.04633399471640587,
0.26727741956710815,
0.19563892483711243,
-0.04389388486742973,
-0.10635371506214142,
0.20664171874523163,
-0.19208554923534393,
-0.4185481369495392,
0.3605544865131378,
-1.0139306783676147,
-0.14871157705783844,
1.4236372709274292,
0.04222339764237404,
0.13443197309970856,
-0.14239376783370972,
-0.2776722311973572,
0.26031333208084106,
-0.47273990511894226,
0.4773392379283905,
0.8435304164886475,
-0.08625509589910507,
-0.07019343227148056,
-0.509294331073761,
0.34783026576042175,
0.5546522736549377,
-0.6193301677703857,
0.06786931306123734,
0.480550080537796,
-0.08784272521734238,
0.30572906136512756,
0.37556856870651245,
0.0031405529007315636,
-0.06791031360626221,
-0.05962451174855232,
-0.05255625396966934,
-0.08016554266214371,
-0.8213472366333008,
-0.2601581811904907,
0.2128744274377823,
0.3857164680957794,
0.10408689826726913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17557v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17557v1 | The FineWeb Datasets: Decanting the Web for the Finest Text Data at Scale | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | 2024-06-25T13:50:56 | Guilherme Penedo, Hynek Kydlíček, Loubna Ben allal, Anton Lozhkov, Margaret Mitchell, Colin Raffel, Leandro Von Werra, Thomas Wolf | cs.CL | cs.CL | The performance of a large language model (LLM) depends heavily on the
quality and size of its pretraining dataset. However, the pretraining datasets
for state-of-the-art open LLMs like Llama 3 and Mixtral are not publicly
available and very little is known about how they were created. In this work,
we introduce FineWeb, a 15-trillion token dataset derived from 96 Common Crawl
snapshots that produces better-performing LLMs than other open pretraining
datasets. To advance the understanding of how best to curate high-quality
pretraining datasets, we carefully document and ablate all of the design
choices used in FineWeb, including in-depth investigations of deduplication and
filtering strategies. In addition, we introduce FineWeb-Edu, a 1.3-trillion
token collection of educational text filtered from FineWeb. LLMs pretrained on
FineWeb-Edu exhibit dramatically better performance on knowledge- and
reasoning-intensive benchmarks like MMLU and ARC. Along with our datasets, we
publicly release our data curation codebase and all of the models trained
during our ablation experiments. | [
-0.7350714802742004,
-0.4349168539047241,
0.20308470726013184,
-0.10189484059810638,
-0.3629360795021057,
0.09733609855175018,
-0.34295377135276794,
-0.402249813079834,
0.02803090773522854,
0.5467485785484314,
-0.42518970370292664,
-0.6441628336906433,
-0.5645141005516052,
0.18236044049263,
-0.7254061102867126,
1.0418469905853271,
0.16972146928310394,
0.01595069095492363,
-0.38695424795150757,
-0.09315382689237595,
0.13979797065258026,
-0.43438780307769775,
-0.44846078753471375,
-0.4120188057422638,
0.575810968875885,
0.4886542558670044,
0.5607349276542664,
0.9432476758956909,
0.5875300765037537,
0.16072037816047668,
-0.0629071295261383,
0.30272385478019714,
-1.0531948804855347,
-0.321591854095459,
-0.44391709566116333,
-0.41506925225257874,
-0.2869146764278412,
0.27895042300224304,
0.3356851637363434,
0.82328861951828,
-0.21572217345237732,
0.3234996795654297,
0.24611623585224152,
0.7031715512275696,
-0.7376415729522705,
-0.1145772859454155,
-0.6321378946304321,
-0.2685949504375458,
-0.6330715417861938,
0.0035238133277744055,
-0.3551086485385895,
-0.5458124876022339,
-0.03629045933485031,
-0.7700179815292358,
0.31269243359565735,
0.022062428295612335,
0.8602745532989502,
0.27804622054100037,
-0.32525724172592163,
-0.21159395575523376,
-0.48624545335769653,
0.7605341672897339,
-0.6623611450195312,
0.6046252250671387,
0.54811692237854,
-0.05931650102138519,
-0.2809757888317108,
-1.0295305252075195,
-0.5500551462173462,
0.28958016633987427,
0.11458631604909897,
-0.09510671347379684,
-0.2424047738313675,
0.11110715568065643,
-0.021128324791789055,
0.6887655854225159,
-0.7217491865158081,
0.6294886469841003,
-0.39425721764564514,
-0.34433144330978394,
0.4670921266078949,
0.11944636702537537,
0.19666415452957153,
0.05765088275074959,
-0.20923161506652832,
-0.2805691659450531,
-0.9472432732582092,
-0.28046485781669617,
0.49303966760635376,
0.41355055570602417,
-0.0533549040555954,
0.5254396796226501,
-0.43342071771621704,
0.7912623286247253,
-0.15978045761585236,
-0.26367440819740295,
0.24880309402942657,
-0.22235992550849915,
-0.07683973014354706,
-0.20313405990600586,
0.7842884659767151,
0.5082817077636719,
0.5504498481750488,
-0.2900804877281189,
-0.3470088541507721,
0.02454698085784912,
0.23549282550811768,
-1.074193000793457,
-0.41155874729156494,
0.22847430408000946,
-0.5078632831573486,
-0.12504932284355164,
0.02249956503510475,
-0.6227155327796936,
-0.3889664113521576,
-0.6888224482536316,
0.2740562856197357,
-0.3661523759365082,
-0.11042477190494537,
0.1809634566307068,
-0.0743657797574997,
0.0006078031146898866,
0.2863719165325165,
-0.9414227604866028,
0.35810908675193787,
0.7579053640365601,
0.6723380088806152,
-0.4562028646469116,
-0.4030084013938904,
-0.3223342299461365,
0.00630533741787076,
-0.4169248938560486,
0.879260241985321,
-0.45467883348464966,
-0.18107560276985168,
0.21586400270462036,
-0.17244580388069153,
0.2903965711593628,
-0.7260552644729614,
0.4136088192462921,
-0.7121024131774902,
-0.021883470937609673,
-0.05947522819042206,
-0.7277205586433411,
-0.030909128487110138,
0.21639251708984375,
-0.8267238140106201,
0.8326069116592407,
0.0665760338306427,
-0.7824833989143372,
0.4634251594543457,
-0.417481929063797,
-0.5852707028388977,
-0.01858769729733467,
-0.028040027245879173,
0.024742281064391136,
0.09180829674005508,
0.36050212383270264,
0.6617777347564697,
-0.4442279040813446,
0.3116086721420288,
-0.3192085027694702,
-0.45369407534599304,
-0.08095438033342361,
-0.47373726963996887,
0.6430279612541199,
0.558374285697937,
-0.017754798755049706,
-0.22653396427631378,
-1.2234431505203247,
0.03889954090118408,
0.06994388997554779,
-0.5747652053833008,
-0.5586814284324646,
0.030487552285194397,
0.13157561421394348,
-0.053888123482465744,
0.41286036372184753,
-0.4758383333683014,
0.22552137076854706,
-0.34649398922920227,
0.4777545928955078,
0.8391644954681396,
-0.32086503505706787,
0.39466649293899536,
-0.2442808598279953,
0.32987383008003235,
-0.053928423672914505,
0.13099735975265503,
-0.09170403331518173,
-0.011078732088208199,
-0.8822458982467651,
-0.2074272781610489,
0.4581802785396576,
0.1503172516822815,
-0.47415030002593994,
0.16700059175491333,
-0.4244304895401001,
-0.749464750289917,
-0.6918832063674927,
0.2796327769756317,
0.320116251707077,
0.13753169775009155,
0.4594271779060364,
-0.16668438911437988,
-0.4763352572917938,
-0.8005537390708923,
-0.16141772270202637,
0.17697422206401825,
-0.2259991466999054,
0.1734149158000946,
0.2661992311477661,
-0.46545958518981934,
0.9988846182823181,
-0.6015351414680481,
-0.28932642936706543,
-0.1938292682170868,
0.09430541098117828,
0.08989819884300232,
0.3880497217178345,
0.3495701849460602,
-0.5496723055839539,
-0.25265684723854065,
-0.16630421578884125,
-0.4988294839859009,
-0.26908645033836365,
0.0659424290060997,
-0.26768630743026733,
-0.025872690603137016,
0.6323021054267883,
-0.43044084310531616,
0.07650254666805267,
0.6886897683143616,
-0.05092153325676918,
0.5089502930641174,
-0.002659294055774808,
-0.0989110991358757,
-1.0815905332565308,
0.0798715353012085,
-0.20624183118343353,
-0.3159524202346802,
-0.27245014905929565,
0.25722289085388184,
-0.005898834206163883,
-0.010493824258446693,
-0.49438008666038513,
0.686842143535614,
-0.36806944012641907,
-0.0714312195777893,
-0.2732559144496918,
0.48986735939979553,
0.1058000847697258,
0.2797622084617615,
-0.37133046984672546,
0.9174249768257141,
0.36993467807769775,
-0.8457520008087158,
0.05752982571721077,
0.4988192021846771,
-0.4763551950454712,
0.2745532989501953,
-0.3144998550415039,
0.11916177719831467,
0.04001207649707794,
0.1490439772605896,
-0.5781671404838562,
-0.40321362018585205,
-0.3575151860713959,
-0.2272021472454071,
0.20659078657627106,
-0.017180321738123894,
-0.6102699637413025,
-0.3345778286457062,
-0.22315864264965057,
0.1693432778120041,
0.33438464999198914,
-1.0114526748657227,
0.15926535427570343,
0.6080403327941895,
-0.07055113464593887,
-0.6013832688331604,
-0.5633593797683716,
0.04308445006608963,
0.013040325604379177,
-0.2749941945075989,
0.28020596504211426,
-0.1127467080950737,
-0.1280873864889145,
-0.1724681705236435,
-0.19990529119968414,
-0.20033687353134155,
0.3093935251235962,
0.19414961338043213,
0.051240406930446625,
-0.13718768954277039,
0.058930691331624985,
-0.12875668704509735,
-0.09445983916521072,
0.03576338291168213,
-0.25121328234672546,
0.8502115607261658,
0.0797860398888588,
-0.4133695960044861,
-0.4280502498149872,
-0.05239877477288246,
0.41217318177223206,
-0.2009887993335724,
0.690730094909668,
0.5045151114463806,
-0.36182701587677,
-0.4105544090270996,
-0.5630835294723511,
-0.1388884037733078,
-0.48477375507354736,
0.10662245005369186,
-0.13185608386993408,
-1.0101269483566284,
0.2952148914337158,
-0.2685377895832062,
0.35266169905662537,
0.3377605378627777,
0.23588305711746216,
-0.16649334132671356,
0.8071672320365906,
0.6476826667785645,
-0.39308878779411316,
0.4775530695915222,
-0.3994802236557007,
0.0369466207921505,
-0.5524864792823792,
-0.25803565979003906,
-0.7166149616241455,
-0.3457610309123993,
-0.6059388518333435,
-0.2303645759820938,
-0.20265136659145355,
0.49207520484924316,
-0.4319981336593628,
0.1579243689775467,
-0.34947168827056885,
0.7626556754112244,
0.8622628450393677,
0.13951341807842255,
0.5095552802085876,
0.2293229103088379,
-0.16123776137828827,
0.13696619868278503,
-0.5602303743362427,
-0.8515214920043945,
1.3557730913162231,
0.03514798358082771,
1.0971641540527344,
-0.06747650355100632,
0.7986972332000732,
0.08731275051832199,
0.30047816038131714,
-0.5850599408149719,
0.6264302134513855,
-0.6540184617042542,
-0.595335841178894,
-0.22521983087062836,
-0.36994197964668274,
-1.0689914226531982,
-0.03148525208234787,
-0.13455574214458466,
-0.46314537525177,
-0.12680530548095703,
0.22696805000305176,
-0.16553102433681488,
0.3259972333908081,
-0.5250003337860107,
0.5586028695106506,
-0.006810828112065792,
-0.37319374084472656,
-0.3781871497631073,
-0.40834176540374756,
0.10573927313089371,
-0.29176342487335205,
0.368066668510437,
0.016294879838824272,
0.20675578713417053,
0.9529904723167419,
-0.47798579931259155,
0.7724397778511047,
0.07381606847047806,
-0.1288319081068039,
0.43274202942848206,
0.17461486160755157,
0.45172807574272156,
-0.24021176993846893,
-0.024070313200354576,
0.4908152222633362,
-0.12171769142150879,
-0.3277329206466675,
-0.10292811691761017,
0.7180923819541931,
-1.0204006433486938,
-0.41965049505233765,
-0.026639940217137337,
-0.06517133861780167,
-0.2857491374015808,
0.5541238784790039,
0.4379441738128662,
0.7814485430717468,
-0.2868198752403259,
0.6115966439247131,
0.5777678489685059,
-0.2887120842933655,
0.38725870847702026,
0.5541343688964844,
-0.21402958035469055,
-0.2617225646972656,
1.133712649345398,
0.17406892776489258,
0.09602633118629456,
0.3753146827220917,
0.10694412887096405,
-0.27585509419441223,
-1.053369164466858,
-0.2629041075706482,
0.1055266410112381,
-0.7581819891929626,
-0.4931447207927704,
-0.6062572598457336,
-0.26108619570732117,
-0.3211885690689087,
-0.2001258134841919,
-0.5247765183448792,
-0.296237051486969,
-0.6223692297935486,
-0.32451149821281433,
0.30097177624702454,
0.8793032169342041,
-0.3576686680316925,
0.5930474400520325,
-0.8889451622962952,
0.44427454471588135,
0.18356527388095856,
0.7140330672264099,
0.11535368114709854,
-0.37686780095100403,
-0.3739398419857025,
0.16467033326625824,
-0.29853254556655884,
-0.02742593362927437,
0.0877731516957283,
0.31024688482284546,
0.5227823257446289,
0.7368158102035522,
0.11367271095514297,
0.7888028025627136,
-0.6414777636528015,
0.7911856174468994,
0.07324039191007614,
-0.7165166735649109,
0.4275205135345459,
-0.39952483773231506,
0.10635945200920105,
0.8049151301383972,
0.6237251162528992,
-0.280269980430603,
-0.3951297104358673,
-0.5484809279441833,
-0.954427182674408,
0.7632858157157898,
0.008105792105197906,
0.2673379182815552,
-0.21054759621620178,
0.3669379949569702,
0.4684649705886841,
0.2916366457939148,
-0.5625124573707581,
-0.27955490350723267,
-0.21800343692302704,
-0.4355522096157074,
-0.17718926072120667,
-0.21227693557739258,
-0.10332641750574112,
0.0507265068590641,
0.6645137071609497,
-0.11734043061733246,
-0.15031373500823975,
-0.26001060009002686,
-0.5053088665008545,
0.07655712217092514,
0.07952790707349777,
0.09622009843587875,
0.7708462476730347,
-0.04895183444023132,
0.30194658041000366,
-0.12190815806388855,
-0.8975806832313538,
0.03175381198525429,
0.004143512342125177,
-0.05029398947954178,
-0.2263425886631012,
0.5679960250854492,
0.5728766322135925,
0.09346670657396317,
-0.994285523891449,
0.49229058623313904,
0.05629663169384003,
-0.06355936080217361,
0.13389523327350616,
0.35465219616889954,
0.16689680516719818,
0.13395366072654724,
0.33489951491355896,
-0.2170753926038742,
0.2598263919353485,
-0.2502848505973816,
0.2541491389274597,
0.18116998672485352,
0.07780472189188004,
-0.26062262058258057,
0.6584182977676392,
0.36261025071144104,
-0.03914686664938927,
0.9320746660232544,
0.026407059282064438,
-0.25896888971328735,
0.30437591671943665,
0.4279099702835083,
0.2609953284263611,
0.055909156799316406,
0.14952148497104645,
0.4135623872280121,
0.2378562092781067,
-0.3728101849555969,
0.16132156550884247,
0.08044696599245071,
-0.7727959752082825,
-0.33541515469551086,
-1.0788941383361816,
-0.4270431399345398,
0.5637802481651306,
-0.654769241809845,
0.2905212938785553,
-0.4980754256248474,
-0.11647550016641617,
-0.25995972752571106,
0.17398367822170258,
-1.0072884559631348,
0.6052934527397156,
0.21920128166675568,
1.0396254062652588,
-0.7028234004974365,
0.580939531326294,
0.409540593624115,
-0.3042971193790436,
-0.8859410881996155,
-0.13655734062194824,
-0.14127719402313232,
-0.864933967590332,
0.4874171018600464,
0.35726138949394226,
0.00032579281833022833,
0.5064632892608643,
-0.7426490783691406,
-0.9067975878715515,
0.8017411828041077,
0.4501871168613434,
-0.9439969658851624,
0.014132033102214336,
0.3269546627998352,
0.3741363286972046,
0.16693565249443054,
0.08738096058368683,
0.6297299861907959,
0.2701290547847748,
-0.18216629326343536,
-0.727658212184906,
-0.23069100081920624,
0.042983002960681915,
-0.29262420535087585,
0.10432383418083191,
-0.7682216763496399,
0.7707241177558899,
-0.13076509535312653,
-0.275216668844223,
-0.03664924576878548,
0.3972150981426239,
0.15107305347919464,
0.09523177891969681,
0.2601528465747833,
0.9259039163589478,
0.96039879322052,
-0.21593531966209412,
0.8168318271636963,
-0.255952924489975,
0.1673104465007782,
1.2694551944732666,
-0.032289378345012665,
1.0600380897521973,
0.293161004781723,
-0.275351345539093,
0.32549184560775757,
0.994162917137146,
-0.02572166547179222,
0.683600127696991,
0.23425261676311493,
0.04227655753493309,
-0.32207396626472473,
-0.10438209772109985,
-0.22283843159675598,
0.584194004535675,
0.2107105404138565,
-0.027846762910485268,
-0.3468576967716217,
0.1770540028810501,
0.021401679143309593,
0.06968630850315094,
-0.4296967089176178,
0.9142143726348877,
0.12231038510799408,
-0.43221917748451233,
0.6744341254234314,
-0.15991757810115814,
0.8272109627723694,
-0.4086713194847107,
0.22664712369441986,
-0.6474022269248962,
0.1665349006652832,
-0.31475892663002014,
-0.78166663646698,
-0.06591711938381195,
0.17032888531684875,
-0.11498663574457169,
-0.1826208382844925,
0.5662084221839905,
-0.20102228224277496,
-0.09332729876041412,
0.3201025128364563,
0.5590815544128418,
0.5131062865257263,
-0.0486547015607357,
-0.31802329421043396,
0.2630120515823364,
-0.124444879591465,
-0.5739588737487793,
0.5304046273231506,
0.6966769695281982,
0.0557883158326149,
0.8757493495941162,
0.952828049659729,
0.128940150141716,
0.1068536788225174,
0.4426988661289215,
1.0404866933822632,
-0.5229196548461914,
-0.4962771236896515,
-0.7314384579658508,
0.17710183560848236,
0.024292444810271263,
-0.3765745162963867,
0.6132461428642273,
0.8534112572669983,
1.25154709815979,
0.19105345010757446,
0.8038236498832703,
0.24506302177906036,
0.5260787606239319,
-0.6125590801239014,
0.926030158996582,
-0.6833826303482056,
0.04145263135433197,
-0.014593643136322498,
-1.0277562141418457,
-0.18929539620876312,
0.5812014937400818,
0.22096775472164154,
-0.10248707234859467,
0.454391747713089,
0.6016337871551514,
-0.20975326001644135,
0.05812222138047218,
0.1899886280298233,
0.3324369788169861,
0.40375202894210815,
0.10943378508090973,
0.723688542842865,
-0.23169606924057007,
0.6452315449714661,
-0.098139189183712,
-0.05268849432468414,
-0.3832199275493622,
-0.858411967754364,
-1.0525606870651245,
-0.46787789463996887,
0.00040097589953802526,
-0.09280796349048615,
-0.07687698304653168,
0.8540474772453308,
0.717767596244812,
-0.7567218542098999,
-0.0014352008001878858,
-0.2742927372455597,
-0.08933264762163162,
0.21448779106140137,
-0.12783101201057434,
0.3547147512435913,
-0.31422170996665955,
-0.6894536018371582,
0.41036590933799744,
-0.18307390809059143,
0.2537781298160553,
-0.30857619643211365,
0.14619792997837067,
0.055097706615924835,
0.03337359428405762,
0.6436165571212769,
-0.03442905470728874,
-0.40052658319473267,
-0.2200891077518463,
-0.19388772547245026,
-0.3268822431564331,
-0.027365101501345634,
0.4904729127883911,
-0.8625684976577759,
0.17161758244037628,
0.25583529472351074,
0.8364630937576294,
0.41612544655799866,
-0.06361041218042374,
0.4339090883731842,
-0.6011927723884583,
0.08421551436185837,
0.13390792906284332,
0.27665144205093384,
0.4030829668045044,
-0.03032936528325081,
0.6502310633659363,
-0.07505183666944504,
-0.5076331496238708,
-0.9314553737640381,
-0.2187052220106125,
-0.7562071681022644,
-0.5213920474052429,
1.1517791748046875,
-0.04233141243457794,
0.011114914901554585,
-0.09383098036050797,
-0.01142308209091425,
0.3557113707065582,
-0.29090091586112976,
0.7024388313293457,
0.8773512244224548,
0.38097378611564636,
0.25544270873069763,
-0.524757444858551,
0.48592880368232727,
-0.06142755597829819,
-0.8545168042182922,
0.303535133600235,
0.6456013917922974,
0.41337868571281433,
0.014869490638375282,
0.5197211503982544,
0.05652029067277908,
-0.20684631168842316,
0.05074743181467056,
0.1473696082830429,
-0.30576175451278687,
-0.5964943766593933,
-0.003952257800847292,
0.22350287437438965,
0.10812092572450638,
-0.025078028440475464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17553v1 | Retrieval-Augmented Code Generation for Situated Action Generation: A Case Study on Minecraft | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | 2024-06-25T13:43:24 | Chalamalasetti Kranti, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Minecraft Collaborative Building Task, two players collaborate: an
Architect (A) provides instructions to a Builder (B) to assemble a specified
structure using 3D blocks. In this work, we investigate the use of large
language models (LLMs) to predict the sequence of actions taken by the Builder.
Leveraging LLMs' in-context learning abilities, we use few-shot prompting
techniques, that significantly improve performance over baseline methods.
Additionally, we present a detailed analysis of the gaps in performance for
future work | [
-0.2774257957935333,
-1.2047882080078125,
0.771468997001648,
0.23205535113811493,
0.2017386555671692,
-0.031970418989658356,
-0.01688552275300026,
-0.43911442160606384,
0.0452626496553421,
0.5156932473182678,
-0.6802588105201721,
-0.5164539813995361,
-0.2672540843486786,
-0.004978679120540619,
-0.2535567581653595,
0.2545330226421356,
-0.17489098012447357,
-0.24551331996917725,
-0.4294449985027313,
0.05201039835810661,
-0.8264147043228149,
-0.3091975450515747,
-0.386955201625824,
-0.22081637382507324,
0.2847139537334442,
0.5930657386779785,
0.5028588771820068,
0.5411468744277954,
0.4500032067298889,
0.48872098326683044,
-0.0793413519859314,
0.36237186193466187,
-0.518307089805603,
0.2586404085159302,
-0.17089761793613434,
-0.21713827550411224,
-0.3840532898902893,
-0.20387513935565948,
0.336814284324646,
0.46670323610305786,
-0.09607803076505661,
0.5721381306648254,
0.045552417635917664,
0.41152191162109375,
-0.5815628170967102,
0.2727259397506714,
-0.38502806425094604,
0.23333294689655304,
0.12051522731781006,
-0.23187358677387238,
-0.48074546456336975,
-0.3954479992389679,
-0.014207390137016773,
-0.31621071696281433,
0.15921136736869812,
0.22902995347976685,
0.207170769572258,
0.27201002836227417,
-0.09956671297550201,
-0.36511048674583435,
-0.4318316578865051,
0.7580408453941345,
-0.6945132613182068,
0.13444659113883972,
0.5353841185569763,
0.12178713083267212,
-0.576255202293396,
-0.8541918396949768,
-0.44164806604385376,
-0.23887787759304047,
-0.128937229514122,
0.026284711435437202,
0.09211821854114532,
0.000075618750997819,
0.6751353740692139,
0.16615794599056244,
-0.6686024069786072,
0.025751160457730293,
-0.5206604599952698,
0.06906071305274963,
0.886787474155426,
0.35788896679878235,
0.22769874334335327,
-0.5776412487030029,
-0.26985636353492737,
0.15329425036907196,
-0.8869841694831848,
0.06025443598628044,
0.07830965518951416,
0.49481576681137085,
-0.2196018546819687,
0.9073110222816467,
-0.09354355186223984,
0.931704044342041,
0.2630710303783417,
-0.13686397671699524,
0.010024095885455608,
-0.22574283182621002,
-0.41032537817955017,
0.11327875405550003,
0.4552290737628937,
0.22339515388011932,
-0.12288372963666916,
0.17121167480945587,
-0.13042603433132172,
-0.28377097845077515,
0.5957026481628418,
-0.6866744160652161,
-0.22664104402065277,
0.5050601363182068,
-0.6005887985229492,
-0.31908029317855835,
-0.009890515357255936,
-0.3555748164653778,
-0.4170502722263336,
-0.29536816477775574,
0.4431096315383911,
-0.11823440343141556,
-0.2056034654378891,
-0.32088199257850647,
-0.019369453191757202,
0.1672384887933731,
0.13195867836475372,
-0.6027644872665405,
0.13284626603126526,
0.6577901840209961,
0.8111682534217834,
-0.059272509068250656,
-0.3511982858181,
-1.1632136106491089,
0.35763198137283325,
-0.3135196268558502,
0.6011934280395508,
-0.613182008266449,
-0.886674702167511,
0.39708542823791504,
-0.3414841890335083,
0.3477603793144226,
-0.518864095211029,
-0.10993222147226334,
-0.6357246041297913,
0.4187958240509033,
-0.15492410957813263,
-0.5374334454536438,
-0.2112635374069214,
0.5555657744407654,
-0.7893449068069458,
1.1105843782424927,
0.2530876398086548,
-0.49041542410850525,
0.28608837723731995,
-0.8206545114517212,
-0.4023088812828064,
0.36747732758522034,
-0.47969943284988403,
-0.30055785179138184,
0.3382536768913269,
-0.003910341765731573,
0.7505629658699036,
0.14755591750144958,
0.11629003286361694,
-0.21264134347438812,
-0.6424187421798706,
0.027378814294934273,
0.09059828519821167,
0.40774160623550415,
0.058979179710149765,
-0.36940088868141174,
0.2136865258216858,
-0.5953691005706787,
0.18718299269676208,
-0.04397543519735336,
-0.5726408958435059,
0.07464314997196198,
0.22768200933933258,
-0.3092956840991974,
0.5031577944755554,
0.3229365348815918,
-0.18821915984153748,
0.3906528055667877,
-0.29879239201545715,
-0.319679856300354,
0.6454503536224365,
0.38373032212257385,
0.41277074813842773,
-0.33524006605148315,
0.6769596338272095,
-0.28362512588500977,
-0.08454466611146927,
-0.20437994599342346,
-0.46953195333480835,
-0.09367428719997406,
-0.19889813661575317,
-0.05154773220419884,
0.5063660740852356,
-1.127569556236267,
0.030727846547961235,
-0.04147385433316231,
-0.14389078319072723,
-0.1171899363398552,
0.42479056119918823,
0.7146807312965393,
0.4085669219493866,
0.15226849913597107,
-0.28615471720695496,
-0.7725255489349365,
-0.1791151612997055,
0.023136252537369728,
-0.4242837131023407,
-0.07934305816888809,
0.7165209650993347,
0.24023409187793732,
0.025782467797398567,
0.8034183382987976,
-0.6361978054046631,
0.06909700483083725,
-0.3244342803955078,
0.19951584935188293,
0.24816928803920746,
0.40333059430122375,
0.5609036684036255,
-0.8282505869865417,
-0.6639939546585083,
-0.10114079713821411,
-0.9702389240264893,
0.00930327270179987,
0.008947466500103474,
-0.14549808204174042,
0.06797872483730316,
0.9895136952400208,
-0.4428732991218567,
0.5832240581512451,
0.8018416166305542,
-0.1428414285182953,
0.4855683743953705,
-0.06492265313863754,
0.18381018936634064,
-1.4499118328094482,
0.04129084572196007,
-0.2851462662220001,
-0.1777140349149704,
-0.34623879194259644,
0.34953343868255615,
-0.30737242102622986,
-0.2765427529811859,
-0.8441138863563538,
0.6609150767326355,
-0.8629526495933533,
-0.35465943813323975,
-0.3567650318145752,
0.46593087911605835,
-0.310855895280838,
0.4683944582939148,
0.30721092224121094,
0.7803797125816345,
0.4539982080459595,
-0.7694430351257324,
0.5127494931221008,
0.48633912205696106,
-0.35266998410224915,
0.4901641011238098,
-0.6173035502433777,
0.27471160888671875,
0.22602081298828125,
-0.08776544034481049,
-0.9099439382553101,
-0.6956520676612854,
-0.1663558930158615,
-0.6007745265960693,
0.3831671476364136,
-0.5669317841529846,
-0.6220757961273193,
-0.6139917373657227,
-0.2508748173713684,
0.2583095133304596,
0.5136107206344604,
-0.6953725218772888,
0.511732280254364,
0.2348014861345291,
-0.14198581874370575,
-0.31967785954475403,
-0.6409275531768799,
-0.2318483293056488,
-0.0556347593665123,
-0.7122761011123657,
0.2927525043487549,
-0.2172536551952362,
-0.5399364233016968,
0.04475743696093559,
0.08448285609483719,
-0.17035908997058868,
0.09772193431854248,
0.7193841338157654,
0.2844223082065582,
-0.31638386845588684,
0.12793387472629547,
-0.2829098403453827,
0.22109387814998627,
0.13244394958019257,
0.08793783187866211,
0.47200992703437805,
0.11676189303398132,
-0.655661940574646,
0.01040438562631607,
0.627924382686615,
0.27307847142219543,
-0.27571699023246765,
0.8264241218566895,
0.3669201731681824,
-0.37910306453704834,
-0.30392953753471375,
-0.41772744059562683,
-0.047946996986866,
-0.5930168032646179,
0.212718203663826,
-0.4291362762451172,
-1.044237494468689,
0.5179362297058105,
-0.6912893056869507,
0.3039648234844208,
0.026462523266673088,
0.6478564143180847,
-0.12744134664535522,
1.0680185556411743,
0.8430604934692383,
0.1684705764055252,
0.9258022904396057,
-0.22523744404315948,
-0.0007883994258008897,
-0.8714895844459534,
-0.3068944811820984,
-0.2697574496269226,
-0.509615421295166,
-0.6554535627365112,
-0.6900547742843628,
0.454899400472641,
0.2514314353466034,
-0.1753075271844864,
0.5493744611740112,
-0.3246365785598755,
0.7671721577644348,
0.3903108835220337,
0.16273638606071472,
-0.08063695579767227,
0.032722603529691696,
-0.3076769709587097,
0.17348484694957733,
-0.8134127259254456,
-0.5037007331848145,
0.7995733022689819,
-0.17194503545761108,
0.49902984499931335,
0.5285226106643677,
1.2836992740631104,
0.29094696044921875,
0.25800931453704834,
-0.8788730502128601,
0.6615424752235413,
0.32438620924949646,
-0.6114591360092163,
-0.3120392858982086,
-0.3473562002182007,
-1.2241400480270386,
-0.1131628006696701,
-0.29898449778556824,
-0.7117160558700562,
-0.13196785748004913,
0.1444355547428131,
-0.7937565445899963,
0.11329982429742813,
-0.8466536998748779,
0.6763712763786316,
-0.08494693785905838,
-0.790110170841217,
-0.32265138626098633,
-0.5086991786956787,
0.3182709217071533,
0.1397344470024109,
0.14684458076953888,
0.2926725149154663,
0.24129925668239594,
-0.07049956172704697,
-0.33411404490470886,
0.9018436670303345,
-0.2083616405725479,
0.08370542526245117,
0.7701615691184998,
0.8149847388267517,
0.7325968742370605,
-0.0052979192696511745,
-0.30589213967323303,
-0.5165016651153564,
-0.4872337281703949,
-0.4307710528373718,
-0.5365135669708252,
0.9870485067367554,
-0.3855241537094116,
-0.6405645608901978,
-0.06494149565696716,
-0.33688655495643616,
-0.25950857996940613,
0.04506666585803032,
0.02991560474038124,
0.6339566111564636,
-0.48984161019325256,
0.2575393617153168,
0.5423517227172852,
-0.32307618856430054,
0.9722731709480286,
0.5668826103210449,
-0.2894347906112671,
-0.15038783848285675,
0.39668047428131104,
-0.08757642656564713,
0.09182839840650558,
0.3100053369998932,
-0.1433824896812439,
-0.00011219743464607745,
-0.5085762143135071,
-0.33631062507629395,
0.022777128964662552,
-0.4969944953918457,
-0.4588017761707306,
-0.18808643519878387,
-0.11234430968761444,
-0.1447525918483734,
-0.9088068604469299,
-0.23117943108081818,
-0.18466821312904358,
-0.3249857723712921,
-0.3157516419887543,
0.23912252485752106,
1.2297120094299316,
0.00006908666546223685,
0.06268610060214996,
-1.3166532516479492,
0.22669021785259247,
0.5297683477401733,
0.4738020896911621,
0.048051606863737106,
-0.2891448736190796,
-0.41706448793411255,
-0.3189339339733124,
-0.2704594135284424,
-0.7284687757492065,
0.37007564306259155,
-0.18078988790512085,
0.7107619047164917,
-0.024598056450486183,
-0.05755399167537689,
0.7938498258590698,
-0.7312914729118347,
1.3063637018203735,
0.08354311436414719,
-0.7486789226531982,
0.9285045862197876,
-0.3083321750164032,
0.5701267123222351,
0.31134164333343506,
0.24737772345542908,
-0.2526959180831909,
0.07952557504177094,
-0.8688371777534485,
-0.7770423889160156,
0.8013263940811157,
0.12460772693157196,
0.27696311473846436,
-0.4654290974140167,
0.3360755741596222,
-0.2386050969362259,
0.09703584760427475,
-0.4145262837409973,
0.11803583800792694,
0.3076153099536896,
-0.039472728967666626,
0.36195141077041626,
-0.2971245050430298,
-0.28001827001571655,
0.21496164798736572,
0.3924185335636139,
-0.22802352905273438,
0.42495375871658325,
0.15720216929912567,
-0.33161699771881104,
-0.46764111518859863,
0.0031463010236620903,
0.7635698318481445,
0.7193536758422852,
0.05009346827864647,
0.05322689190506935,
0.4299772083759308,
-0.280720055103302,
-0.20333757996559143,
-0.07205243408679962,
0.3600338399410248,
-0.19406796991825104,
0.5761198401451111,
0.47813090682029724,
0.2997000515460968,
-0.6484024524688721,
0.594761073589325,
0.1860741227865219,
-0.0889967754483223,
-0.29829561710357666,
0.18698285520076752,
0.07634121179580688,
0.8626198172569275,
0.03966159373521805,
-0.152759850025177,
0.18056082725524902,
-0.6566986441612244,
0.4231324791908264,
0.1904776394367218,
-0.32784491777420044,
-0.3056532144546509,
0.48643648624420166,
0.46269041299819946,
-0.6887189745903015,
0.6789898872375488,
-0.3263988494873047,
-0.3300601840019226,
0.5925527215003967,
0.6248550415039062,
1.150215983390808,
-0.18784980475902557,
0.24738462269306183,
0.5592342019081116,
-0.19563457369804382,
-0.21876566112041473,
0.6441938877105713,
-0.23637816309928894,
-0.39114469289779663,
-0.8424898386001587,
-0.4975243806838989,
-0.4895919859409332,
-0.3427083492279053,
-0.49118155241012573,
0.18717385828495026,
-0.6491050124168396,
-0.13802585005760193,
-0.5855926871299744,
0.3158796429634094,
-0.6841078996658325,
-0.022977348417043686,
0.4486747682094574,
0.7073396444320679,
-0.44513002038002014,
0.5400708913803101,
0.9684741497039795,
-0.5359967350959778,
-1.000266671180725,
0.05997471883893013,
0.35645556449890137,
-0.4966011345386505,
0.7166922688484192,
-0.17686036229133606,
-0.2385348379611969,
-0.11294522881507874,
-1.0314151048660278,
-0.7653248310089111,
1.382879376411438,
-0.02940795198082924,
-0.365434467792511,
0.0799037292599678,
-0.28217557072639465,
0.7004726529121399,
-0.2955530881881714,
-0.06801006197929382,
-0.13902470469474792,
0.07284889370203018,
0.35370805859565735,
-1.0278937816619873,
0.11261484026908875,
-0.22034023702144623,
0.13905850052833557,
0.3199830949306488,
-0.7088841795921326,
0.48251956701278687,
-0.3640688359737396,
0.04710039123892784,
0.1409786343574524,
0.7811229228973389,
0.7492696642875671,
0.2789533734321594,
0.04061449319124222,
0.07936901599168777,
0.6862029433250427,
0.18780890107154846,
1.4229861497879028,
-0.3295188248157501,
0.08779235929250717,
1.370845079421997,
-0.29896146059036255,
1.3057278394699097,
0.3546215295791626,
-0.07734794914722443,
0.7034730911254883,
0.3074983060359955,
0.2703997492790222,
0.4422176778316498,
0.12920816242694855,
-0.42213645577430725,
-0.18294347822666168,
0.005291649606078863,
-0.1706489771604538,
0.5372585654258728,
0.3362424671649933,
-0.39761337637901306,
0.13778232038021088,
-0.25484439730644226,
-0.004954350180923939,
0.2216230034828186,
-0.45684242248535156,
1.014271855354309,
0.07247064262628555,
-0.7285212874412537,
0.22381044924259186,
-0.19566164910793304,
0.4194967448711395,
-0.45355159044265747,
-0.4569341242313385,
-0.380007266998291,
-0.004270715638995171,
-0.4105445444583893,
-0.9264815449714661,
0.38083961606025696,
0.13138243556022644,
-0.21886087954044342,
-0.3524567484855652,
0.6757605671882629,
-0.4897456467151642,
-0.17684119939804077,
0.02094152756035328,
0.6424780488014221,
0.13615745306015015,
0.028758587315678596,
-0.6221117377281189,
0.14552505314350128,
-0.011765499599277973,
-0.3013880252838135,
0.34463900327682495,
0.7233599424362183,
-0.23709546029567719,
0.426473468542099,
0.6080332398414612,
-0.17690083384513855,
0.1867809295654297,
0.0018683124799281359,
0.8610342741012573,
-0.7431360483169556,
-0.16280987858772278,
-0.6247523427009583,
0.8157951235771179,
-0.24332967400550842,
0.061902694404125214,
0.8781518340110779,
0.6266942620277405,
0.9256715774536133,
-0.21151326596736908,
0.3762179911136627,
-0.3767969310283661,
0.3216378390789032,
-0.546113908290863,
0.3450049161911011,
-0.3073427677154541,
0.4012138247489929,
-0.45369651913642883,
-0.978694498538971,
-0.5254371762275696,
0.5784445405006409,
-0.264658123254776,
0.14582198858261108,
0.42072272300720215,
0.8609646558761597,
-0.10859451442956924,
-0.3878321051597595,
0.639667809009552,
-0.016023170202970505,
0.27930954098701477,
0.3567039668560028,
0.7629836201667786,
-0.34079596400260925,
0.4772774875164032,
0.04977501556277275,
0.10881633311510086,
-0.39483311772346497,
-1.01805579662323,
-1.04340660572052,
-0.30790385603904724,
-0.41279464960098267,
-0.39366257190704346,
-0.2170255482196808,
1.2659813165664673,
0.8520061373710632,
-0.7750160694122314,
-0.33739173412323,
0.014445113949477673,
0.1884523183107376,
-0.2583353519439697,
-0.1847425401210785,
0.1988343596458435,
-0.2042466104030609,
-0.617008626461029,
0.7816935181617737,
0.24809671938419342,
0.1372862607240677,
-0.10074294358491898,
-0.37348735332489014,
-0.3557441532611847,
0.11424069851636887,
1.062611699104309,
0.38141992688179016,
-0.47978654503822327,
-0.3801614046096802,
0.13583660125732422,
-0.12840892374515533,
-0.11474395543336868,
0.7530288696289062,
-0.9155251979827881,
0.657464325428009,
0.9685900211334229,
0.43088898062705994,
0.5662012696266174,
0.40908533334732056,
0.6510140299797058,
-1.5416178703308105,
0.18217380344867706,
0.146279975771904,
0.11401781439781189,
0.27882611751556396,
-0.43145281076431274,
0.7723587155342102,
-0.12512986361980438,
-0.5576505661010742,
-0.5734515190124512,
0.1977187991142273,
-0.6240935325622559,
-0.23190809786319733,
1.098572850227356,
-0.18014079332351685,
-0.20412887632846832,
0.05871519446372986,
-0.522678017616272,
0.06636849045753479,
-0.13339398801326752,
0.7757958769798279,
0.6624723076820374,
-0.4629218876361847,
-0.302001029253006,
-0.4748293161392212,
0.6607963442802429,
0.07683772593736649,
-0.6901236176490784,
-0.16421590745449066,
1.1615185737609863,
-0.016456760466098785,
0.28294312953948975,
0.4994131028652191,
-0.07222525775432587,
0.4327438473701477,
0.37144237756729126,
0.11602653563022614,
-0.16074898838996887,
-0.3783310055732727,
-0.12721337378025055,
0.3310917913913727,
0.26612791419029236,
-0.1791130006313324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17542v2 | CDQuant: Accurate Post-training Weight Quantization of Large Pre-trained Models using Greedy Coordinate Descent | 2024-06-25T13:29:14 | 2024-06-26T07:44:42 | Pranav Ajit Nair, Arun Sai Suggala | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently demonstrated remarkable
performance across diverse language tasks. But their deployment is often
constrained by their substantial computational and storage requirements.
Quantization has emerged as a key technique for addressing this challenge,
enabling the compression of large models with minimal impact on performance.
The recent GPTQ algorithm, a post-training quantization (PTQ) method, has
proven highly effective for compressing LLMs, sparking a wave of research that
leverages GPTQ as a core component. Recognizing the pivotal role of GPTQ in the
PTQ landscape, we introduce CDQuant, a simple and scalable alternative to GPTQ
with improved performance. CDQuant uses coordinate descent to minimize the
layer-wise reconstruction loss to achieve high-quality quantized weights. Our
algorithm is easy to implement and scales efficiently to models with hundreds
of billions of parameters. Through extensive evaluation on the PaLM2 model
family, we demonstrate that CDQuant consistently outperforms GPTQ across
diverse model sizes and quantization levels. In particular, for INT2
quantization of PaLM2-Otter, CDQuant achieves a 10% reduction in perplexity
compared to GPTQ. | [
-0.0859522745013237,
-0.499029278755188,
0.5729739665985107,
0.1884438693523407,
-0.41255587339401245,
0.385180801153183,
-0.3434806764125824,
0.019148780032992363,
-0.27955546975135803,
0.27080222964286804,
-0.21888983249664307,
-0.5493772029876709,
-0.8276610374450684,
-0.34500083327293396,
-0.4272027313709259,
1.0853304862976074,
-0.170291468501091,
0.3556489944458008,
-0.2920663058757782,
-0.10749325901269913,
0.014918855391442776,
-0.8817077279090881,
-0.9200295805931091,
-0.3547656536102295,
0.353353351354599,
0.2144191563129425,
1.1302388906478882,
0.4309316873550415,
0.43967869877815247,
0.20494286715984344,
0.12072929739952087,
-0.11283806711435318,
-0.7001855373382568,
-0.12544311583042145,
0.3809434473514557,
-0.7899839282035828,
-0.4281594157218933,
0.10720368474721909,
0.5541841983795166,
0.6526657342910767,
-0.45697399973869324,
0.03632734715938568,
0.03440837934613228,
0.7826215028762817,
-0.7914841175079346,
0.002936373697593808,
-0.36247584223747253,
0.03643077239394188,
-0.2563856840133667,
-0.12248148024082184,
-0.164835587143898,
-0.46031999588012695,
0.17812585830688477,
-0.8180180788040161,
0.37949538230895996,
-0.28617629408836365,
0.7816641926765442,
0.4099010229110718,
-0.6599349975585938,
0.028852161020040512,
-0.6138956546783447,
0.9003719687461853,
-0.4950903356075287,
0.49078312516212463,
0.38032692670822144,
0.20674973726272583,
0.19571290910243988,
-0.8692768812179565,
-0.5429397225379944,
-0.24189434945583344,
0.2956579923629761,
0.1197371780872345,
-0.13162563741207123,
0.1967361867427826,
0.2896853983402252,
0.6193854808807373,
-0.8887321949005127,
-0.05837002769112587,
0.037290170788764954,
-0.11055275797843933,
0.4019489586353302,
-0.2285715937614441,
0.28550902009010315,
0.18107885122299194,
-0.4621434211730957,
-0.48599693179130554,
-0.9291229248046875,
0.025458939373493195,
0.33208662271499634,
-0.1294821798801422,
-0.16202585399150848,
0.5228356122970581,
-0.29555830359458923,
0.6498225927352905,
0.11265506595373154,
-0.0682201161980629,
-0.10346824675798416,
-0.13227468729019165,
-0.13550861179828644,
0.12507058680057526,
0.6731359362602234,
0.11896144598722458,
0.14879277348518372,
-0.09322928637266159,
-0.45772799849510193,
0.040384214371442795,
0.0020304543431848288,
-1.0930899381637573,
-0.9569814801216125,
0.39478856325149536,
-0.3667100667953491,
-0.07971423119306564,
-0.12822659313678741,
-0.0038101691752672195,
-0.2671642005443573,
-0.3869401514530182,
0.6164842247962952,
-0.629693329334259,
-0.2803443968296051,
0.29125967621803284,
-0.12239182740449905,
0.34036222100257874,
0.6594126224517822,
-0.568549394607544,
0.47475025057792664,
0.8948679566383362,
0.9230353236198425,
0.12238951027393341,
0.23715339601039886,
-0.787283182144165,
0.08060578256845474,
-0.41226068139076233,
0.6280773878097534,
-0.3640247583389282,
-0.3961922824382782,
-0.12885892391204834,
-0.3897929787635803,
0.2438708394765854,
-0.4884257912635803,
0.7634814977645874,
-0.9344289302825928,
-0.006005255971103907,
-0.43190959095954895,
-0.5191320180892944,
-0.07969316095113754,
0.24315178394317627,
-0.7059600353240967,
0.9152956008911133,
0.48126739263534546,
-0.9219108819961548,
0.3392758071422577,
-0.27810049057006836,
-0.37013599276542664,
0.27908962965011597,
0.10905589908361435,
-0.6559322476387024,
0.21494384109973907,
0.35313481092453003,
0.1877843290567398,
-0.8139330148696899,
0.06404202431440353,
-0.4160563051700592,
-0.46196508407592773,
0.037431638687849045,
-0.22504356503486633,
0.939608633518219,
0.45554888248443604,
-0.17519846558570862,
-0.12015704810619354,
-0.47954821586608887,
0.443252831697464,
0.3548438847064972,
-0.3223058581352234,
-0.5652744174003601,
-0.014708239585161209,
0.11176911741495132,
0.08007105439901352,
0.3888333737850189,
-0.3782051205635071,
0.37520676851272583,
-0.26703810691833496,
0.5169823169708252,
0.31695204973220825,
-0.3602116107940674,
0.6128241419792175,
-0.20312714576721191,
0.6718926429748535,
-0.11566505581140518,
0.18589235842227936,
0.33483096957206726,
-0.11996762454509735,
-0.6380626559257507,
-0.42672640085220337,
0.6875236630439758,
0.505463182926178,
-1.1453239917755127,
0.38735145330429077,
-0.5930355191230774,
-0.6356101632118225,
-0.252525269985199,
-0.03957942873239517,
0.45169883966445923,
-0.08614989370107651,
0.11295010149478912,
-0.5979790687561035,
-0.3235476613044739,
-0.5676977038383484,
-0.21688677370548248,
-0.24087919294834137,
-0.36741095781326294,
-0.05231667682528496,
0.06934617459774017,
0.08280535042285919,
0.8711252212524414,
-0.5821747779846191,
-0.04740440845489502,
-0.1547250747680664,
0.44225990772247314,
0.09000648558139801,
0.6503200531005859,
0.47499072551727295,
-0.9724680781364441,
-0.5326709151268005,
-0.06852862238883972,
-0.4806824326515198,
-0.030177373439073563,
-0.026716597378253937,
-0.0822625532746315,
-0.004860464483499527,
0.31243807077407837,
-0.9757434725761414,
0.16743908822536469,
0.8193097114562988,
0.034247178584337234,
0.5131186842918396,
-0.31779441237449646,
0.2281421273946762,
-0.6641620397567749,
0.07791782915592194,
-0.1401139348745346,
-0.37584352493286133,
-0.3565073013305664,
0.053498126566410065,
0.3559214174747467,
-0.27212193608283997,
-0.27684909105300903,
0.24968399107456207,
-0.5986121892929077,
-0.25965631008148193,
-0.18234840035438538,
0.14507074654102325,
0.03371281921863556,
0.17276833951473236,
0.21304874122142792,
0.8078585267066956,
0.5304726958274841,
-0.41874414682388306,
0.4637930691242218,
0.11914630979299545,
-0.3398709297180176,
0.6621924638748169,
-0.9700373411178589,
0.3015173077583313,
-0.1275276243686676,
0.5943613648414612,
-0.8958110809326172,
0.11689840257167816,
0.006902223918586969,
-0.30327174067497253,
0.383987158536911,
-0.4278874695301056,
-0.884796679019928,
-0.4344986081123352,
-0.5381470322608948,
0.9630869030952454,
0.5077822208404541,
-0.6016067266464233,
0.18885906040668488,
0.294525682926178,
-0.15392017364501953,
-0.2939035892486572,
-0.3484109044075012,
0.17001184821128845,
-0.2094566524028778,
-0.5222030878067017,
0.4386753737926483,
-0.33535799384117126,
0.011213568039238453,
-0.34867388010025024,
-0.2488163709640503,
-0.23852071166038513,
0.07788219302892685,
0.0014243214391171932,
0.02759004384279251,
-0.09433452785015106,
0.14291587471961975,
0.10991840064525604,
-0.18290989100933075,
0.0031799899879842997,
-0.8463161587715149,
0.7380875945091248,
0.04467068240046501,
0.025259535759687424,
-0.1752471625804901,
0.08508270978927612,
0.20179812610149384,
-0.5520610213279724,
0.6372369527816772,
0.8491063117980957,
-0.31457582116127014,
-0.36490654945373535,
-0.3450050354003906,
0.012597172521054745,
-0.42509809136390686,
0.4751160144805908,
-0.6377506852149963,
-0.9575542211532593,
0.06931409239768982,
-0.2752625346183777,
-0.2652035355567932,
0.16509346663951874,
0.4977674186229706,
0.12652328610420227,
1.147118091583252,
0.594667375087738,
-0.03696100413799286,
0.504002571105957,
-0.46698370575904846,
0.24014149606227875,
-0.7084671258926392,
0.257080078125,
-0.4696486294269562,
-0.10071539133787155,
-0.4331098198890686,
-0.7237525582313538,
0.6841328144073486,
0.5391804575920105,
-0.47230976819992065,
0.3943934738636017,
-0.4618900716304779,
0.5508086681365967,
0.5854759812355042,
0.3299316167831421,
0.25092124938964844,
0.03587309271097183,
0.21496808528900146,
0.03367794677615166,
-0.8228716850280762,
-0.30031195282936096,
1.3639941215515137,
0.1915721893310547,
0.7973331809043884,
0.20503418147563934,
0.764276921749115,
0.2232535034418106,
0.5433409810066223,
-0.8984602689743042,
0.2823764979839325,
-0.3267453610897064,
-0.24798046052455902,
-0.3655240535736084,
-0.7296101450920105,
-0.8238022327423096,
0.2196948230266571,
0.0566226951777935,
-0.3835223317146301,
-0.07073218375444412,
0.19511575996875763,
-0.6542044878005981,
0.1663217693567276,
-0.6095486879348755,
0.8779196739196777,
-0.23499035835266113,
-0.25989097356796265,
-0.4074168801307678,
-0.596072256565094,
0.6090695858001709,
-0.3145787715911865,
-0.026179155334830284,
0.023090677335858345,
-0.30386224389076233,
0.7503265142440796,
-0.9692624807357788,
0.28969505429267883,
-0.22713260352611542,
-0.6698670983314514,
0.34325605630874634,
0.36115556955337524,
0.7234095335006714,
0.3002444803714752,
0.0825410857796669,
0.2850791811943054,
0.38340672850608826,
-0.6295238733291626,
-0.6238088607788086,
0.7624650001525879,
-0.8968634009361267,
-0.48988568782806396,
-0.4287441074848175,
-0.5014685392379761,
-0.3006504774093628,
-0.054585494101047516,
0.2701234221458435,
0.4479174017906189,
-0.09647467732429504,
0.0005640789750032127,
0.6319547295570374,
-0.3462110757827759,
0.2720593512058258,
0.3131268620491028,
0.12984533607959747,
-0.6784312129020691,
0.850901186466217,
0.0716693252325058,
0.327399879693985,
0.7892888188362122,
0.031061721965670586,
-0.3571414649486542,
-0.5484598875045776,
-0.20950958132743835,
0.24130485951900482,
-0.4924118220806122,
-0.5824851989746094,
-0.6063854098320007,
-0.07847850024700165,
-0.4027826488018036,
0.006744251120835543,
-0.6243698596954346,
-0.7484968304634094,
-0.02635921724140644,
0.20869885385036469,
0.15643218159675598,
0.29456713795661926,
-0.1423891931772232,
0.6980252265930176,
-0.9541194438934326,
0.40259236097335815,
0.5425991415977478,
0.15048761665821075,
-0.1665067970752716,
-0.5299085974693298,
-0.4630226194858551,
0.1986011415719986,
-0.5333364605903625,
-0.44687139987945557,
0.48089009523391724,
0.33376678824424744,
-0.16487205028533936,
0.4522656500339508,
0.3083142042160034,
0.6731289625167847,
-0.37603116035461426,
0.7015011310577393,
0.30847060680389404,
-1.2468373775482178,
0.2733982503414154,
-0.22912578284740448,
0.3600795269012451,
0.2332836538553238,
0.6088239550590515,
-0.3841085135936737,
-0.06959041208028793,
-0.6745288372039795,
-0.6473557353019714,
0.5809942483901978,
0.28822287917137146,
-0.00982255395501852,
0.2699292004108429,
0.43644604086875916,
-0.0952606201171875,
0.3936006426811218,
-0.6713639497756958,
-0.10719680041074753,
-0.12007427215576172,
-0.19871346652507782,
-0.24621179699897766,
-0.3900567889213562,
-0.09915141761302948,
-0.07090811431407928,
0.46139147877693176,
-0.1322133094072342,
0.27525418996810913,
0.19662046432495117,
-0.35647571086883545,
-0.29563745856285095,
-0.05099940299987793,
0.19819927215576172,
0.4483206272125244,
-0.15979920327663422,
0.2257121056318283,
-0.12276659905910492,
-0.37673065066337585,
0.2083750069141388,
0.35696473717689514,
-0.08073102682828903,
-0.17586074769496918,
0.2539542317390442,
0.36827680468559265,
0.27359575033187866,
-0.581566333770752,
0.907606303691864,
-0.1651279181241989,
-0.16872525215148926,
-0.4064306914806366,
-0.11184125393629074,
-0.1539086401462555,
0.24174819886684418,
0.31895098090171814,
-0.16047461330890656,
0.3327672481536865,
-0.28753745555877686,
0.20535807311534882,
0.6802778840065002,
-0.16138651967048645,
-0.36120787262916565,
0.9633663892745972,
0.027156783267855644,
0.2608345150947571,
0.6328230500221252,
-0.179433211684227,
-0.604727566242218,
0.5608073472976685,
0.20896898210048676,
0.791070282459259,
-0.3597520589828491,
0.3799178898334503,
0.43836602568626404,
0.11001889407634735,
-0.3295249938964844,
0.25430357456207275,
-0.4142192006111145,
-0.679567277431488,
-0.6704760193824768,
-0.6388456225395203,
-0.20538334548473358,
-0.19247299432754517,
-0.610237717628479,
0.13138946890830994,
-0.5311655402183533,
-0.3452063798904419,
-0.351897269487381,
0.313713401556015,
-0.6734443306922913,
0.35171228647232056,
0.2108033299446106,
0.6621832847595215,
-0.33757948875427246,
1.2494261264801025,
0.5264984369277954,
-0.21563003957271576,
-0.7689711451530457,
0.051973599940538406,
-0.16589480638504028,
-0.661824107170105,
0.8715170621871948,
-0.15950842201709747,
0.2678155303001404,
0.4498368799686432,
-0.7631418704986572,
-0.9716699123382568,
1.0907444953918457,
0.6808726191520691,
-0.6300430297851562,
-0.030176522210240364,
0.2743954658508301,
0.37276580929756165,
0.1362278163433075,
0.4945153295993805,
0.4958733022212982,
0.3380267918109894,
0.17451679706573486,
-0.949749231338501,
0.10115793347358704,
0.1124141663312912,
0.3673132658004761,
0.38199517130851746,
-0.7978052496910095,
1.0256019830703735,
-0.38609421253204346,
-0.4524417221546173,
0.4479655623435974,
0.5988886952400208,
0.2894350290298462,
-0.1250755339860916,
0.6199722290039062,
0.7631720304489136,
0.706339955329895,
-0.3106742799282074,
1.2836707830429077,
-0.5188342928886414,
0.6708753108978271,
0.8405916690826416,
-0.35322967171669006,
0.669237494468689,
0.2576175034046173,
-0.62680584192276,
0.19408220052719116,
0.7821997404098511,
0.34046652913093567,
0.5249624848365784,
0.6924070119857788,
-0.5912420749664307,
-0.5772420763969421,
-0.05439380556344986,
-0.29797032475471497,
0.2193983644247055,
0.07144612818956375,
0.2666432559490204,
-0.14860183000564575,
-0.0886017456650734,
0.2147977203130722,
-0.12902231514453888,
-0.29403120279312134,
0.5007288455963135,
0.25831714272499084,
-0.4536437690258026,
1.2104766368865967,
0.1394548863172531,
0.5623762607574463,
-0.7233024835586548,
0.051372844725847244,
-0.27119413018226624,
0.08024577796459198,
-0.05253392830491066,
-0.2931053042411804,
-0.22749628126621246,
-0.30861717462539673,
0.04474693909287453,
-0.33872029185295105,
0.27863118052482605,
-0.7100306153297424,
-0.34169650077819824,
0.02217462845146656,
0.48827511072158813,
-0.03342856466770172,
-0.752575159072876,
-0.7169157266616821,
0.22214367985725403,
-0.1761016994714737,
-0.29349732398986816,
0.29779958724975586,
0.7830988168716431,
0.019513200968503952,
0.7085471153259277,
0.6405627131462097,
0.21476025879383087,
-0.22562800347805023,
0.040650490671396255,
0.9233382344245911,
-0.49576660990715027,
-0.3846690356731415,
-0.41443485021591187,
0.30595433712005615,
0.18471592664718628,
-0.08844967186450958,
0.615199089050293,
0.7152456045150757,
0.9695981740951538,
-0.08902938663959503,
0.7397958636283875,
-0.014624523930251598,
0.34970903396606445,
-0.631208598613739,
0.6656405925750732,
-0.5814464688301086,
0.2743052542209625,
-0.25893837213516235,
-1.0743459463119507,
-0.5359268188476562,
0.5408483147621155,
-0.434751957654953,
0.2512148916721344,
0.7857837080955505,
0.6652839779853821,
0.13551455736160278,
-0.34513843059539795,
0.36841636896133423,
0.11507397890090942,
0.4021332263946533,
0.9400541186332703,
0.797806978225708,
-0.8005474209785461,
0.7301253080368042,
-0.24485503137111664,
-0.3516298234462738,
0.04705626145005226,
-0.5755928754806519,
-0.5367926955223083,
-0.49859246611595154,
-0.6614609360694885,
-0.21510732173919678,
0.15006671845912933,
0.6989904046058655,
1.0011812448501587,
-0.6789435148239136,
-0.305639386177063,
-0.16625945270061493,
-0.09443553537130356,
-0.12280160933732986,
-0.22927188873291016,
0.5483309626579285,
-0.29191794991493225,
-0.9755709767341614,
0.03931207209825516,
0.07886846363544464,
0.08942429721355438,
0.05749129131436348,
-0.3218994140625,
0.24725639820098877,
-0.22658678889274597,
0.7570619583129883,
0.17141638696193695,
-0.34397149085998535,
-0.12518978118896484,
-0.5084847211837769,
-0.2601383626461029,
-0.0816197320818901,
1.0817718505859375,
-0.9058390259742737,
0.20872759819030762,
0.2486514002084732,
0.5557389259338379,
0.646024763584137,
0.18728332221508026,
0.7902722358703613,
-0.5905828475952148,
0.29952335357666016,
0.30915653705596924,
0.19205807149410248,
0.38153916597366333,
-0.22852575778961182,
0.6629588603973389,
0.2657110393047333,
-0.5875495076179504,
-0.6782036423683167,
0.0813707783818245,
-1.122343897819519,
-0.15023593604564667,
1.0322085618972778,
-0.3231174349784851,
-0.0633988082408905,
0.2548803985118866,
-0.39107638597488403,
0.3503322899341583,
-0.3524817228317261,
0.7378662824630737,
0.4569641947746277,
0.20426802337169647,
-0.5368413329124451,
-0.34667637944221497,
0.7537516355514526,
0.6490594744682312,
-0.7028796076774597,
0.11904023587703705,
0.47207552194595337,
0.07409965246915817,
-0.30630922317504883,
0.5582624673843384,
-0.20337675511837006,
0.26360589265823364,
-0.10080726444721222,
0.3210547864437103,
0.3430122435092926,
0.11010226607322693,
-0.25861626863479614,
0.17335505783557892,
0.4678747355937958,
0.019112322479486465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17535v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17535v1 | Disce aut Deficere: Evaluating LLMs Proficiency on the INVALSI Italian Benchmark | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | 2024-06-25T13:20:08 | Fabio Mercorio, Mario Mezzanzanica, Daniele Potertì, Antonio Serino, Andrea Seveso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced their ability to generate and manipulate human language, highlighting
their potential across various applications. Evaluating LLMs in languages other
than English is crucial for ensuring their linguistic versatility, cultural
relevance, and applicability in diverse global contexts, thus broadening their
usability and effectiveness. We tackle this challenge by introducing a
structured benchmark using the INVALSI tests, a set of well-established
assessments designed to measure educational competencies across Italy. Our
study makes three primary contributions: Firstly, we adapt the INVALSI
benchmark for automated LLM evaluation, which involves rigorous adaptation of
the test format to suit automated processing while retaining the essence of the
original tests. Secondly, we provide a detailed assessment of current LLMs,
offering a crucial reference point for the academic community. Finally, we
visually compare the performance of these models against human results.
Additionally, researchers are invited to submit their models for ongoing
evaluation, ensuring the benchmark remains a current and valuable resource. | [
-0.31625697016716003,
-0.384611576795578,
0.486958384513855,
0.1335214525461197,
-0.03762003406882286,
0.27308595180511475,
-0.4314184784889221,
-0.675167441368103,
-0.1910925805568695,
0.30016645789146423,
-0.18849322199821472,
-0.4523366689682007,
-0.600532591342926,
0.5586361289024353,
-0.5156583189964294,
0.2915573716163635,
-0.27412545680999756,
0.6441283226013184,
-0.5707943439483643,
-0.2954535484313965,
-0.25197941064834595,
-0.4263472259044647,
-0.797600507736206,
-0.42579975724220276,
0.1485479772090912,
0.5125662088394165,
0.17629751563072205,
0.2676326632499695,
0.6780333518981934,
0.3226151764392853,
-0.21927665174007416,
0.2488274872303009,
-0.3921459913253784,
-0.07417621463537216,
-0.15753568708896637,
-0.4117867350578308,
-0.44797539710998535,
0.08458182215690613,
0.9805085062980652,
0.9437059164047241,
0.005088241770863533,
0.21394610404968262,
0.4447784125804901,
0.649046778678894,
-0.5522118806838989,
0.11927682161331177,
-0.4881080389022827,
-0.21814146637916565,
-0.11660607159137726,
-0.051818832755088806,
-0.4634287357330322,
-0.7849426865577698,
-0.08530939370393753,
-0.1893613040447235,
-0.17602835595607758,
-0.2940727174282074,
0.5609164834022522,
0.2653590738773346,
-0.4652387499809265,
-0.3481212854385376,
-0.49513235688209534,
0.5040460824966431,
-0.7338892817497253,
0.7376919388771057,
0.1861201971769333,
0.42598187923431396,
-0.2574336528778076,
-0.7245911955833435,
-0.2871655821800232,
-0.7785223722457886,
0.3000822365283966,
0.08581964671611786,
-0.007783318869769573,
-0.1701715737581253,
0.15865033864974976,
0.46738696098327637,
-0.5949525833129883,
0.4220755100250244,
-0.14882631599903107,
0.023131797090172768,
0.8198569416999817,
0.4439038038253784,
0.24798521399497986,
0.34822720289230347,
-0.4048726558685303,
-0.1389332115650177,
-0.9638755321502686,
0.20825913548469543,
0.3685051500797272,
0.24817171692848206,
-0.09259261935949326,
0.5503461360931396,
-0.26253023743629456,
0.616126537322998,
-0.40359658002853394,
-0.20250973105430603,
0.18177387118339539,
-0.4279237985610962,
0.014591853134334087,
-0.24138186872005463,
0.6536885499954224,
0.4074157476425171,
0.557051956653595,
-0.2398977279663086,
-0.31827446818351746,
-0.017415862530469894,
-0.07343517243862152,
-0.8863781690597534,
0.09608206897974014,
-0.20753160119056702,
-0.031748417764902115,
0.00914568267762661,
0.2064535915851593,
-0.8520130515098572,
-0.2511252462863922,
-0.14250077307224274,
0.41458722949028015,
-0.30537328124046326,
0.19331832230091095,
0.1585819572210312,
0.20120827853679657,
0.12269431352615356,
0.2888137400150299,
-0.7385498881340027,
0.5549883842468262,
0.6460130214691162,
0.6765446662902832,
-0.5216482877731323,
-0.3072638213634491,
-0.28167563676834106,
-0.016270486637949944,
-0.5208005309104919,
0.7729123830795288,
-0.6673246026039124,
-0.6897383332252502,
0.30824121832847595,
0.019365066662430763,
-0.008428733795881271,
-0.7973496317863464,
0.7634411454200745,
-0.3359921872615814,
-0.007869676686823368,
-0.2856266498565674,
-0.8749015927314758,
-0.2094816416501999,
0.4145265519618988,
-0.5735076069831848,
1.2448937892913818,
0.18461591005325317,
-0.38567933440208435,
0.4752155840396881,
-0.533194899559021,
-0.2685154676437378,
0.26253458857536316,
-0.11138074100017548,
-0.2117873877286911,
0.1626889705657959,
-0.07630182057619095,
0.2428484410047531,
-0.6802204847335815,
0.26037684082984924,
-0.2860100269317627,
-0.6076188087463379,
0.43179985880851746,
-0.6337350606918335,
0.6932204365730286,
-0.02288004197180271,
-0.3380032181739807,
-0.0831533893942833,
-0.8245536684989929,
0.1733090728521347,
-0.1097579300403595,
-0.5200931429862976,
-0.22827069461345673,
0.014079184271395206,
-0.06692630052566528,
0.0397239625453949,
0.3520490527153015,
-0.5173375606536865,
0.20770592987537384,
-0.5528525710105896,
0.5062462687492371,
0.5021883249282837,
-0.012082692235708237,
0.22279506921768188,
-0.21524003148078918,
0.5487562417984009,
-0.3317340612411499,
0.19543008506298065,
-0.061090562492609024,
-0.4484725296497345,
-0.7244142889976501,
-0.4737459123134613,
0.4496825933456421,
0.49264413118362427,
-0.42246487736701965,
0.3769168555736542,
-0.4305194616317749,
-0.6938404440879822,
-0.5379458069801331,
0.26144638657569885,
0.35572385787963867,
0.27036240696907043,
0.058570582419633865,
-0.5895428657531738,
-0.15525656938552856,
-0.8373438715934753,
-0.3563508689403534,
-0.21810005605220795,
-0.05545905604958534,
0.18962125480175018,
0.8579134345054626,
-0.18963773548603058,
0.7143504023551941,
0.12407685816287994,
-0.07477250695228577,
-0.23042066395282745,
-0.08911833167076111,
0.1179133877158165,
0.3079378306865692,
0.45378002524375916,
-0.5635907649993896,
-0.5098389983177185,
0.012711121700704098,
-0.6657082438468933,
-0.1805793195962906,
0.3481399416923523,
0.13756942749023438,
0.21066512167453766,
0.47654399275779724,
-0.14837683737277985,
0.38133227825164795,
0.47209247946739197,
-0.2787415385246277,
0.4153212904930115,
-0.2576877474784851,
0.5485045909881592,
-0.8646888732910156,
-0.09744295477867126,
0.07781004160642624,
-0.19216333329677582,
-0.26558592915534973,
0.19267791509628296,
0.23277652263641357,
-0.036313850432634354,
-0.6108716130256653,
0.861742377281189,
-0.4353064298629761,
-0.3945468068122864,
0.1499166637659073,
0.273210346698761,
-0.08980991691350937,
-0.054178543388843536,
-0.14476102590560913,
1.2120133638381958,
0.33499374985694885,
-0.41248658299446106,
0.3242951035499573,
0.06317968666553497,
-0.7804242968559265,
0.7288830876350403,
-0.6630033254623413,
-0.08294317871332169,
0.3043861985206604,
0.03265300393104553,
-1.0505880117416382,
-0.20096498727798462,
0.1662198156118393,
-0.29431477189064026,
0.28219515085220337,
0.04969784617424011,
-0.8422171473503113,
-0.3097986578941345,
-0.2846749722957611,
0.35902589559555054,
0.31682631373405457,
-0.5805539488792419,
0.38745591044425964,
0.3363431990146637,
-0.09496666491031647,
-0.004393555223941803,
-0.7152219414710999,
0.3395085036754608,
-0.3734700381755829,
-0.610767126083374,
0.2340310961008072,
-0.40167146921157837,
-0.7247534394264221,
-0.2190716415643692,
0.09578895568847656,
-0.39837393164634705,
0.45490068197250366,
-0.031967636197805405,
0.22421880066394806,
-0.31341657042503357,
-0.004283278249204159,
-0.13243992626667023,
-0.08466443419456482,
0.10342060774564743,
-0.18563702702522278,
0.19809523224830627,
-0.22240614891052246,
-0.8172389268875122,
-0.7083812355995178,
0.11426209658384323,
0.9056509733200073,
-0.2770369052886963,
0.4664824903011322,
0.051373038440942764,
-0.47056299448013306,
-0.1886216253042221,
-0.6312642097473145,
-0.23832936584949493,
-0.4311370849609375,
0.44725218415260315,
-0.47718119621276855,
-0.7294904589653015,
0.34615984559059143,
-0.28769156336784363,
-0.003545633051544428,
0.23065024614334106,
0.5543363690376282,
-0.10660602897405624,
0.9221872687339783,
0.6546590328216553,
-0.2035568207502365,
0.2582429349422455,
-0.2679068148136139,
0.09111035615205765,
-0.7778903841972351,
-0.3601137399673462,
-0.8328301310539246,
-0.06979548931121826,
-0.5906178951263428,
-0.45930975675582886,
0.5558486580848694,
-0.013482620008289814,
-0.24124951660633087,
0.2267075777053833,
-0.18816566467285156,
0.6061162352561951,
0.03649416193366051,
0.01827090047299862,
0.7013526558876038,
0.05972494184970856,
-0.2656429409980774,
-0.3506263792514801,
-0.651418924331665,
-1.1585396528244019,
1.135106086730957,
0.3036942780017853,
0.7023113965988159,
0.11601919680833817,
0.6536745429039001,
0.15286019444465637,
0.500044047832489,
-0.675479531288147,
0.7192245125770569,
-0.36097490787506104,
-0.39262980222702026,
-0.1987302303314209,
-0.2624419629573822,
-0.5541261434555054,
0.3486807942390442,
-0.06654267013072968,
-0.6555394530296326,
0.0630657747387886,
-0.3063196539878845,
-0.21741995215415955,
0.3823324739933014,
-0.5815425515174866,
0.7713820934295654,
-0.5788099765777588,
-0.735205352306366,
-0.23483262956142426,
-0.08469165861606598,
0.18304243683815002,
-0.202112078666687,
0.3687343895435333,
-0.2747843563556671,
-0.49322694540023804,
0.5880345106124878,
-0.05872904509305954,
0.8783995509147644,
0.28284788131713867,
-0.16594727337360382,
0.13079597055912018,
-0.0719953402876854,
0.20473915338516235,
0.24349689483642578,
-0.6864749789237976,
0.1939874142408371,
-0.05661242455244064,
-0.42724844813346863,
-0.37441885471343994,
0.814105749130249,
-0.6584600210189819,
-0.4021892547607422,
-0.4772725999355316,
-0.3876689374446869,
-0.44028162956237793,
-0.06323495507240295,
0.18503589928150177,
0.5926397442817688,
-0.8435066342353821,
0.1370937079191208,
0.7075522541999817,
0.017980627715587616,
0.4364667236804962,
0.8622097969055176,
0.1042671650648117,
-0.37098315358161926,
0.759609043598175,
0.15266144275665283,
0.395145982503891,
0.2801874876022339,
-0.07706762105226517,
-0.4841902256011963,
-0.7259908318519592,
-0.5780804753303528,
0.2678920328617096,
-0.7847899198532104,
0.031107384711503983,
-0.18656602501869202,
-0.10194969922304153,
-0.31216442584991455,
-0.3138785660266876,
-0.3563096225261688,
-0.23110046982765198,
-0.34066489338874817,
0.057644907385110855,
0.08678692579269409,
1.1531568765640259,
0.09753335267305374,
-0.04714123532176018,
-0.6054173707962036,
-0.10604836046695709,
0.41846558451652527,
0.2667620778083801,
-0.31650733947753906,
-0.9809650778770447,
-0.20037901401519775,
0.10704785585403442,
-0.31498584151268005,
-0.8305442333221436,
0.2751489281654358,
0.40420013666152954,
0.9088078141212463,
0.28926005959510803,
-0.29522597789764404,
0.6315028071403503,
-0.5073462128639221,
0.8248806595802307,
-0.16783727705478668,
-0.9766175150871277,
0.2543773353099823,
-0.06356890499591827,
-0.019311746582388878,
1.0213278532028198,
0.5534772276878357,
-0.29335224628448486,
-0.39171791076660156,
-0.44876453280448914,
-0.6747063994407654,
0.31044432520866394,
0.018129698932170868,
0.22287039458751678,
0.030336441472172737,
0.5844982266426086,
0.04384665563702583,
0.1256617307662964,
-0.5695328712463379,
0.021768886595964432,
0.3455953299999237,
-0.1914335936307907,
-0.4656022787094116,
-0.43758314847946167,
-0.045128267258405685,
-0.39960503578186035,
0.6993283033370972,
-0.054700300097465515,
-0.09639669209718704,
0.0908546894788742,
-0.3236621022224426,
0.0972616896033287,
0.3574539124965668,
0.4677601456642151,
0.9095888137817383,
0.15919561684131622,
-0.09358760714530945,
0.8283872008323669,
-0.21243345737457275,
0.2946252226829529,
0.042317211627960205,
-0.20131999254226685,
-0.04478291794657707,
0.6070258617401123,
0.432722806930542,
0.8667851090431213,
-0.940263032913208,
0.5076428055763245,
-0.14736419916152954,
-0.11662796884775162,
-0.4996371567249298,
0.15502414107322693,
0.1262359917163849,
0.3966420292854309,
0.26564663648605347,
-0.24986225366592407,
0.03312342241406441,
-0.6737874746322632,
0.2706839144229889,
0.41891729831695557,
-0.48930448293685913,
-0.3404105305671692,
0.5971048474311829,
0.4272477626800537,
-0.43236422538757324,
0.4332464039325714,
-0.20774701237678528,
-0.4331035017967224,
0.6540306210517883,
0.5121557712554932,
0.925446629524231,
-0.37601858377456665,
0.10180159658193588,
0.6444333791732788,
0.538211464881897,
-0.27844807505607605,
0.2206530123949051,
0.010372746735811234,
-0.5753282904624939,
-0.11986306309700012,
-0.6227161884307861,
-0.7690994143486023,
-0.19089138507843018,
-0.6344190239906311,
0.4482932984828949,
-0.286246657371521,
0.015348580665886402,
-0.45846959948539734,
0.26820915937423706,
-0.46042925119400024,
0.3216348886489868,
0.17848658561706543,
1.2544392347335815,
-1.1486568450927734,
0.9370862245559692,
0.8653265237808228,
-0.4003340005874634,
-0.4296243488788605,
-0.011871309950947762,
-0.18050864338874817,
-0.7706073522567749,
0.6147759556770325,
0.12482376396656036,
-0.23570360243320465,
0.09687503427267075,
-0.3634212613105774,
-0.6839942336082458,
1.0283452272415161,
0.62112957239151,
-0.6328902840614319,
0.15372435748577118,
0.3181045949459076,
0.7494407892227173,
-0.7758340835571289,
0.6908590793609619,
0.8738791346549988,
0.6775885224342346,
0.10704988241195679,
-0.7980078458786011,
-0.3838708698749542,
-0.18414492905139923,
0.16612987220287323,
-0.1585196852684021,
-0.5466810464859009,
0.566760241985321,
-0.013902229256927967,
-0.22982382774353027,
0.408170223236084,
0.644927442073822,
0.24471670389175415,
0.25624120235443115,
0.2116866409778595,
0.6220858097076416,
0.7949091196060181,
-0.3324448764324188,
0.9651469588279724,
-0.48419690132141113,
0.04083774983882904,
0.9361768364906311,
-0.6375636458396912,
1.187093734741211,
0.3713478147983551,
-0.4183502793312073,
0.5398927927017212,
0.7325889468193054,
0.011337044648826122,
0.12222076952457428,
0.33990320563316345,
-0.6144895553588867,
-0.3052294850349426,
-0.2571047842502594,
-0.36803916096687317,
0.5759908556938171,
0.3691779375076294,
-0.04308604076504707,
-0.2758483588695526,
-0.01886596530675888,
0.04205109924077988,
0.6560053825378418,
-0.3646235167980194,
0.6324825882911682,
0.04023247957229614,
-0.6441828608512878,
0.5953900814056396,
-0.07200530171394348,
0.5986160635948181,
-0.5077475309371948,
0.03055860847234726,
-0.46244239807128906,
0.15643392503261566,
-0.09888140857219696,
-0.7658193707466125,
0.2443166971206665,
0.4726373851299286,
0.1429532915353775,
-0.21240611374378204,
0.198614239692688,
-0.6088688373565674,
-0.7502477169036865,
0.5986132025718689,
0.4497743248939514,
0.43531307578086853,
0.30594390630722046,
-0.5819754600524902,
0.3733084201812744,
-0.11059404164552689,
-0.030785545706748962,
0.33930888772010803,
0.22348172962665558,
-0.16054199635982513,
0.9478627443313599,
0.35202687978744507,
0.2735084295272827,
0.044897112995386124,
0.25450578331947327,
0.7544851899147034,
-0.3949377238750458,
-0.13450555503368378,
-0.7388345003128052,
0.5037775635719299,
0.06551603227853775,
-0.588996171951294,
0.8738409280776978,
0.7621431946754456,
1.1055254936218262,
0.19554956257343292,
0.6156123876571655,
0.3578697443008423,
0.38277867436408997,
-0.4702083170413971,
0.6747851371765137,
-0.9402192234992981,
0.3617399036884308,
-0.1359349936246872,
-1.0224254131317139,
-0.20196828246116638,
0.5237441658973694,
-0.3790455758571625,
0.03575671464204788,
0.7288147211074829,
0.8334423303604126,
0.3216310739517212,
-0.0718771293759346,
0.6560289263725281,
0.16767847537994385,
0.026962202042341232,
0.6231508851051331,
1.0764410495758057,
-0.48295560479164124,
0.26643621921539307,
-0.19537924230098724,
-0.27594631910324097,
-0.0830758735537529,
-0.9469850659370422,
-0.959181010723114,
-0.53687983751297,
-0.3273833394050598,
0.10496719926595688,
0.4377801716327667,
0.8618658185005188,
0.4036312997341156,
-0.8144777417182922,
-0.7600010633468628,
0.13824717700481415,
0.04111636057496071,
-0.0414249524474144,
-0.1191336065530777,
-0.054182011634111404,
-0.27166947722435,
-1.1562196016311646,
0.7580834627151489,
0.3222123384475708,
0.14206506311893463,
-0.43210965394973755,
-0.12729638814926147,
-0.027602750808000565,
0.11328501254320145,
0.51284259557724,
0.2480478137731552,
-0.7522094249725342,
-0.10810214281082153,
-0.057137295603752136,
-0.36061403155326843,
-0.032810796052217484,
0.6136122345924377,
-0.6689454317092896,
0.5183783173561096,
0.5328854322433472,
0.5343967080116272,
0.3161662817001343,
-0.28512048721313477,
0.452903687953949,
-0.10616345703601837,
0.2561451196670532,
0.3750110864639282,
0.5235498547554016,
0.5984699130058289,
0.1003432348370552,
0.682893693447113,
0.114009328186512,
-0.5215163230895996,
-0.9587591290473938,
-0.023477107286453247,
-0.494914174079895,
0.02985396236181259,
0.8962804079055786,
-0.401284396648407,
0.0044565098360180855,
-0.07497965544462204,
0.2238048017024994,
-0.03128001093864441,
-0.0799817219376564,
0.732286274433136,
0.7271002531051636,
0.20840223133563995,
0.05070602521300316,
-0.6634945273399353,
0.24037685990333557,
0.35712453722953796,
-0.9312915205955505,
-0.3033404052257538,
0.2247222363948822,
0.35652121901512146,
-0.22721382975578308,
0.463276207447052,
-0.4341816008090973,
0.31453537940979004,
-0.31912729144096375,
0.1313253939151764,
0.17186830937862396,
-0.45163047313690186,
-0.7176715135574341,
0.05917938053607941,
0.4391750395298004,
0.12376711517572403
] |
Subsets and Splits