id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19314v1 | LiveBench: A Challenging, Contamination-Free LLM Benchmark | 2024-06-27T16:47:42 | 2024-06-27T16:47:42 | Colin White, Samuel Dooley, Manley Roberts, Arka Pal, Ben Feuer, Siddhartha Jain, Ravid Shwartz-Ziv, Neel Jain, Khalid Saifullah, Siddartha Naidu, Chinmay Hegde, Yann LeCun, Tom Goldstein, Willie Neiswanger, Micah Goldblum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Test set contamination, wherein test data from a benchmark ends up in a newer
model's training set, is a well-documented obstacle for fair LLM evaluation and
can quickly render benchmarks obsolete. To mitigate this, many recent
benchmarks crowdsource new prompts and evaluations from human or LLM judges;
however, these can introduce significant biases, and break down when scoring
hard questions. In this work, we introduce a new benchmark for LLMs designed to
be immune to both test set contamination and the pitfalls of LLM judging and
human crowdsourcing. We release LiveBench, the first benchmark that (1)
contains frequently-updated questions from recent information sources, (2)
scores answers automatically according to objective ground-truth values, and
(3) contains a wide variety of challenging tasks, spanning math, coding,
reasoning, language, instruction following, and data analysis. To achieve this,
LiveBench contains questions that are based on recently-released math
competitions, arXiv papers, news articles, and datasets, and it contains
harder, contamination-free versions of tasks from previous benchmarks such as
Big-Bench Hard, AMPS, and IFEval. We evaluate many prominent closed-source
models, as well as dozens of open-source models ranging from 0.5B to 110B in
size. LiveBench is difficult, with top models achieving below 65% accuracy. We
release all questions, code, and model answers. Questions will be added and
updated on a monthly basis, and we will release new tasks and harder versions
of tasks over time so that LiveBench can distinguish between the capabilities
of LLMs as they improve in the future. We welcome community engagement and
collaboration for expanding the benchmark tasks and models. | [
-0.38950231671333313,
-0.5169012546539307,
0.3183940351009369,
0.2081606388092041,
-0.27784445881843567,
0.18374158442020416,
-0.16489450633525848,
-0.601699709892273,
-0.2422344833612442,
0.6648955941200256,
-0.6891757845878601,
-0.5361716151237488,
-0.4863035976886749,
-0.11380365490913391,
-0.45768630504608154,
0.7207859754562378,
-0.2633150815963745,
0.0712592750787735,
-0.5568657517433167,
-0.37131941318511963,
-0.2426290661096573,
-0.4356238543987274,
-0.2591031491756439,
-0.24530796706676483,
0.38458380103111267,
0.2794267237186432,
0.6069837808609009,
0.6534079909324646,
0.6750068664550781,
0.2321830540895462,
-0.2337389886379242,
0.14461100101470947,
-0.4202418923377991,
0.24271708726882935,
-0.1884729415178299,
-0.4249280095100403,
-0.3615048825740814,
0.4679770767688751,
0.13771234452724457,
0.8321358561515808,
-0.3723372519016266,
0.5976846814155579,
-0.03071179799735546,
0.6029441356658936,
-0.8176088929176331,
0.015198453329503536,
-0.5262556076049805,
0.3489801287651062,
-0.2996985614299774,
0.1817457526922226,
-0.2708539068698883,
-0.7453627586364746,
-0.49406537413597107,
-0.6158406734466553,
0.2125760316848755,
-0.16167615354061127,
0.7041375041007996,
0.5983687043190002,
-0.394180029630661,
0.26447275280952454,
-0.4014977216720581,
0.672581672668457,
-0.5343275666236877,
0.3262348771095276,
0.34283730387687683,
0.8553611636161804,
-0.18931584060192108,
-0.7505112886428833,
-0.14296020567417145,
-0.17118461430072784,
0.5370944142341614,
0.22456805408000946,
-0.19983506202697754,
-0.2953419089317322,
0.18890319764614105,
0.2397068738937378,
-0.30667150020599365,
-0.05096851661801338,
-0.45025017857551575,
-0.2693259119987488,
0.686860203742981,
0.05038443207740784,
0.07693218439817429,
-0.2600793242454529,
-0.5945755839347839,
-0.21088850498199463,
-0.9159747362136841,
-0.09110832959413528,
0.24464192986488342,
0.07524044811725616,
0.008157835341989994,
0.5860705971717834,
-0.2790599465370178,
0.42985832691192627,
-0.32723209261894226,
0.2866351306438446,
0.16463139653205872,
-0.2304600477218628,
-0.07895537465810776,
-0.21015794575214386,
0.4514302611351013,
0.5207341313362122,
0.4579915404319763,
-0.2555219829082489,
-0.08645250648260117,
0.03870300203561783,
0.349989116191864,
-0.7546483874320984,
-0.12873587012290955,
0.13337023556232452,
-0.28372034430503845,
-0.6156692504882812,
-0.004464542027562857,
-0.5612384080886841,
-0.7589551210403442,
-0.2340034693479538,
0.4042748808860779,
0.14974337816238403,
-0.0659184604883194,
-0.049113623797893524,
0.1066378578543663,
-0.08933313190937042,
0.6789034008979797,
-0.31287088990211487,
0.4787420630455017,
1.0703016519546509,
0.614332914352417,
-0.5490110516548157,
-0.1436750292778015,
-0.9712865948677063,
-0.1652938276529312,
-0.18343336880207062,
0.9453795552253723,
-0.27031847834587097,
-0.4820977747440338,
-0.23616451025009155,
0.06746028363704681,
0.3211807906627655,
-1.188251256942749,
0.34862807393074036,
-0.6484663486480713,
-0.04463557153940201,
-0.2830541431903839,
-0.5859968662261963,
-0.026810457929968834,
0.314602792263031,
-0.7581523060798645,
1.2828360795974731,
0.20241843163967133,
-0.40241339802742004,
0.367400586605072,
-0.2377411127090454,
-0.10267994552850723,
0.198699489235878,
-0.33346349000930786,
-0.2129901647567749,
-0.04023822769522667,
-0.09371019899845123,
0.29368969798088074,
-0.34200024604797363,
0.4211379885673523,
-0.9042085409164429,
-0.4152314364910126,
0.2630416750907898,
-0.5581637620925903,
0.7960195541381836,
0.3794802725315094,
-0.38297736644744873,
0.12962661683559418,
-0.9864497184753418,
0.45875242352485657,
-0.0854349434375763,
-0.4609656035900116,
0.10328651964664459,
0.06955715268850327,
-0.09256001561880112,
0.28609687089920044,
0.09337802976369858,
-0.5315811634063721,
-0.19884207844734192,
-0.06959693133831024,
0.16427062451839447,
1.1183305978775024,
0.13136030733585358,
-0.06095196306705475,
-0.6939224600791931,
0.5590634346008301,
-0.09810099750757217,
0.35309287905693054,
0.11851446330547333,
-0.3977277874946594,
-0.5712903738021851,
-0.12488306313753128,
0.4185871183872223,
0.6656468510627747,
-0.11764755845069885,
0.3382691442966461,
-0.2579422891139984,
-0.8001863360404968,
-0.4784543216228485,
0.41214826703071594,
0.3955351412296295,
0.40701550245285034,
0.3954404890537262,
-0.4255704879760742,
-0.24191056191921234,
-0.8000718355178833,
-0.6007956862449646,
0.20793093740940094,
-0.3572358787059784,
0.3345854580402374,
0.3672018349170685,
0.19525359570980072,
0.7888599038124084,
-0.48708099126815796,
-0.07150597870349884,
0.26514387130737305,
0.03250917047262192,
0.2959789037704468,
0.5092808604240417,
-0.024243135005235672,
-0.4105083644390106,
-0.3936512768268585,
-0.28784459829330444,
-0.8013713955879211,
-0.2439483404159546,
0.3980102837085724,
-0.19842077791690826,
-0.16847413778305054,
0.7569277882575989,
-0.27846646308898926,
0.5578820109367371,
0.42932507395744324,
-0.15326716005802155,
0.4690534770488739,
-0.08344734460115433,
0.10999659448862076,
-0.9153600335121155,
0.16108796000480652,
-0.3194099962711334,
-0.4739571213722229,
-0.10933183878660202,
0.4045255482196808,
0.21861140429973602,
-0.36893442273139954,
-0.9122346043586731,
0.9114595055580139,
-0.2679201364517212,
-0.1402052789926529,
-0.06882800161838531,
0.45508521795272827,
0.020514437928795815,
0.24932362139225006,
-0.430675208568573,
0.779281497001648,
0.04246744513511658,
-0.3657776415348053,
0.6175453662872314,
0.2446354627609253,
-0.7307748794555664,
0.5344424247741699,
-0.8174625039100647,
0.2793131470680237,
0.32122185826301575,
0.18285609781742096,
-0.5467404127120972,
-0.1673360913991928,
0.08497434109449387,
-0.24466009438037872,
-0.10279262065887451,
0.13565251231193542,
-0.6731016635894775,
-0.14695438742637634,
-0.5076963901519775,
0.2687981128692627,
0.5947839617729187,
-0.6497092247009277,
0.33031347393989563,
0.1379299908876419,
0.09506414830684662,
-0.5005786418914795,
-0.68683922290802,
-0.1580819934606552,
0.017690030857920647,
-0.7688089609146118,
0.0716121569275856,
-0.4944920241832733,
-0.5775299668312073,
0.13062287867069244,
-0.6071175336837769,
-0.06990110874176025,
0.6527193784713745,
0.4840383529663086,
0.20758435130119324,
0.01602611131966114,
-0.12419229000806808,
-0.1952984482049942,
-0.2916407883167267,
0.28172069787979126,
0.2788885235786438,
0.24639810621738434,
0.10139619559049606,
-0.9878004789352417,
-0.03371893987059593,
0.15944184362888336,
0.3547225296497345,
-0.14882756769657135,
0.2864019274711609,
0.12112750858068466,
-0.5710999369621277,
-0.21651603281497955,
-0.7625709772109985,
-0.03165768086910248,
-0.5175843834877014,
0.3106396496295929,
-0.2468419075012207,
-0.706543505191803,
0.5305436849594116,
-0.3246176838874817,
0.2230207771062851,
0.14731913805007935,
0.3906498849391937,
-0.038128066807985306,
0.6932948231697083,
0.16201163828372955,
0.015262970700860023,
0.19666416943073273,
0.20321208238601685,
-0.2857428193092346,
-0.6056296825408936,
-0.3093933165073395,
-0.46159499883651733,
-0.37173905968666077,
-0.2981191873550415,
-0.9882467985153198,
0.31386274099349976,
0.17683014273643494,
-0.6113035678863525,
0.046365294605493546,
-0.348628431558609,
0.7808879613876343,
0.725165605545044,
0.47560471296310425,
0.5799673795700073,
-0.1399076282978058,
-0.35207557678222656,
-0.12145905196666718,
-0.1817137598991394,
-0.44885313510894775,
1.366716980934143,
0.12623460590839386,
0.7193682193756104,
-0.007901999168097973,
0.8172435164451599,
0.5758883357048035,
0.657286524772644,
-0.12757527828216553,
0.7005175352096558,
-0.09619583189487457,
-1.131063461303711,
0.05363307520747185,
-0.32748284935951233,
-0.6804657578468323,
0.23883867263793945,
0.029198065400123596,
-0.8356066942214966,
0.06478344649076462,
-0.18332406878471375,
-0.29381662607192993,
0.5074203014373779,
-0.41986316442489624,
0.8614357113838196,
-0.36094221472740173,
-0.8527414202690125,
-0.14488407969474792,
-0.6957168579101562,
0.3565257787704468,
-0.3269973695278168,
0.4464292526245117,
-0.7162520885467529,
-0.17127148807048798,
0.5824605226516724,
-0.6800979971885681,
0.8237687945365906,
-0.17367501556873322,
-0.027351221069693565,
0.22199267148971558,
0.42051538825035095,
0.603460431098938,
0.1514710634946823,
-0.3438090980052948,
0.1386754810810089,
0.1021130159497261,
-0.5119736790657043,
-0.3169585168361664,
0.6898921132087708,
-0.862138569355011,
-0.6762536764144897,
-0.44308334589004517,
-0.3250584006309509,
-0.4913714826107025,
0.39296844601631165,
0.023062411695718765,
0.02557559497654438,
-0.32085302472114563,
0.3390463590621948,
0.7455659508705139,
-0.22609223425388336,
0.13089744746685028,
0.6713102459907532,
-0.41848182678222656,
-0.5380872488021851,
0.8035059571266174,
-0.09846951812505722,
0.5470334887504578,
0.02245529368519783,
-0.05818553268909454,
-0.036822184920310974,
-0.4116002321243286,
-0.23582135140895844,
0.016216544434428215,
-0.9695471525192261,
-0.40285223722457886,
-0.3410639762878418,
-0.2164316028356552,
-0.11526256799697876,
-0.11185165494680405,
-0.5474866628646851,
-0.4457211494445801,
-0.39250507950782776,
-0.16863101720809937,
0.07986855506896973,
0.5728569030761719,
-0.3155876696109772,
-0.2063354253768921,
-0.8610195517539978,
0.42056161165237427,
0.33697792887687683,
0.7129215598106384,
-0.32157212495803833,
-0.40098997950553894,
0.21766473352909088,
-0.026935730129480362,
-0.41422998905181885,
-0.7644246816635132,
0.03392966836690903,
-0.16725289821624756,
0.7452443838119507,
0.3658367693424225,
0.28558751940727234,
0.4474179744720459,
-0.33450740575790405,
0.5982044339179993,
-0.055746618658304214,
-0.8713303208351135,
0.46328848600387573,
-0.2768041789531708,
0.2705260217189789,
1.126841425895691,
0.1708933711051941,
-0.505974531173706,
-0.4586397111415863,
-0.6187189221382141,
-0.6465533375740051,
0.6787872910499573,
-0.043820273131132126,
-0.008321055211126804,
0.14029474556446075,
0.3230631947517395,
0.258175790309906,
0.41267335414886475,
-0.705457866191864,
-0.17996558547019958,
-0.11001890152692795,
-0.013939463533461094,
-0.05082359537482262,
-0.12503384053707123,
-0.4750250279903412,
-0.1768033504486084,
0.5437008142471313,
0.015304598957300186,
-0.16848501563072205,
-0.23631705343723297,
-0.20758205652236938,
-0.2878689169883728,
0.2855624258518219,
0.2698218822479248,
0.5210841298103333,
-0.5145169496536255,
0.2582247257232666,
0.5204433798789978,
-0.35048189759254456,
0.22443611919879913,
0.4856969118118286,
-0.16962525248527527,
-0.36203083395957947,
0.3219887912273407,
0.23437584936618805,
0.6949092745780945,
-0.9914953112602234,
0.5200355648994446,
0.06570692360401154,
-0.34310004115104675,
-0.31442704796791077,
0.4298968017101288,
0.42258596420288086,
0.33193302154541016,
0.33922407031059265,
0.1640291064977646,
-0.18389111757278442,
-0.2668101489543915,
0.3766006529331207,
0.20450466871261597,
-0.4948267340660095,
0.007115170359611511,
1.1109678745269775,
0.28022947907447815,
-0.3114585876464844,
0.7109603881835938,
-0.19255122542381287,
-0.20267625153064728,
0.8502160906791687,
0.04309192672371864,
0.6237894296646118,
0.019064392894506454,
0.027961725369095802,
0.17228637635707855,
0.2821149528026581,
0.015690511092543602,
0.5274453163146973,
-0.15033841133117676,
-0.4972473680973053,
-0.0705365240573883,
-0.5360201001167297,
-0.9670078158378601,
0.04768947884440422,
-0.830768346786499,
0.3207813799381256,
-0.7349805235862732,
0.16179159283638,
-0.2577706277370453,
0.20010273158550262,
-0.4939976930618286,
0.22203540802001953,
0.20870983600616455,
1.5171124935150146,
-0.5368066430091858,
0.4445943236351013,
0.4970635175704956,
-0.2255927473306656,
-0.7895705103874207,
-0.37935757637023926,
0.3955383598804474,
-0.9813030958175659,
0.39170610904693604,
0.31085461378097534,
0.24429313838481903,
-0.09302137047052383,
-0.5670536160469055,
-0.8604998588562012,
1.2218060493469238,
0.5924398899078369,
-0.41151946783065796,
0.18262165784835815,
0.12945623695850372,
0.2463105320930481,
0.11892355978488922,
0.3146056830883026,
0.28962430357933044,
0.7200050950050354,
-0.08782176673412323,
-0.648276150226593,
0.3620685636997223,
-0.6007298231124878,
-0.35760602355003357,
0.049642547965049744,
-0.9217721223831177,
0.8031249642372131,
-0.11932869255542755,
-0.16807019710540771,
0.14735041558742523,
0.48101508617401123,
0.6502349376678467,
0.5034347176551819,
0.526765763759613,
0.5790738463401794,
0.8430614471435547,
-0.2932157814502716,
0.8720700740814209,
-0.3819156587123871,
0.335271418094635,
1.4488139152526855,
-0.7025197744369507,
0.9236820340156555,
0.2581983506679535,
-0.6359943747520447,
0.33274105191230774,
0.8104669451713562,
-0.45945096015930176,
0.42488083243370056,
0.7704591751098633,
-0.5151107907295227,
-0.5772350430488586,
-0.07780147343873978,
-0.6721508502960205,
0.09349504858255386,
-0.2835931181907654,
0.05927031487226486,
-0.6873637437820435,
-0.09979251772165298,
0.06308946013450623,
0.1616504192352295,
0.07121983915567398,
0.5109960436820984,
0.008238047361373901,
-0.6639720797538757,
0.31997403502464294,
-0.09119512140750885,
0.41446658968925476,
-0.5841150283813477,
0.19296154379844666,
-0.6449074149131775,
0.40723347663879395,
-0.20842455327510834,
-0.4500446617603302,
0.15000411868095398,
0.024621928110718727,
0.05648915097117424,
-0.2353236973285675,
0.6605682969093323,
0.10662912577390671,
-0.49756327271461487,
0.4032420516014099,
0.8959448933601379,
0.383505254983902,
-0.39507049322128296,
-0.7074311375617981,
0.2804050147533417,
-0.1138639748096466,
-0.5209598541259766,
0.4473942518234253,
0.16097697615623474,
-0.08938398212194443,
0.9064418077468872,
0.7261800169944763,
0.09532845765352249,
0.416570246219635,
0.10121726244688034,
1.0142557621002197,
-0.7819223403930664,
-0.02275615930557251,
-0.43373700976371765,
0.30864718556404114,
-0.020198777318000793,
-0.16538618505001068,
0.5299818515777588,
0.8161802887916565,
0.829671323299408,
0.22767789661884308,
0.6467509269714355,
0.24017539620399475,
0.7199937105178833,
-0.0928979218006134,
0.7330980896949768,
-0.766402006149292,
0.46007415652275085,
0.043094754219055176,
-0.6718178987503052,
-0.23029528558254242,
0.11946987360715866,
0.014875235967338085,
0.23082531988620758,
0.7422149777412415,
0.7063629031181335,
-0.17275966703891754,
0.15731824934482574,
0.21736788749694824,
-0.11074768006801605,
0.4333275556564331,
0.692959725856781,
0.8131862282752991,
-0.22684375941753387,
0.8912646770477295,
-0.6855565905570984,
-0.20572519302368164,
-0.22138479351997375,
-1.1135404109954834,
-0.741768479347229,
0.0317615270614624,
-0.44116726517677307,
-0.40289580821990967,
0.09070263057947159,
0.7506585717201233,
0.6558005213737488,
-0.9662477970123291,
-0.07802025228738785,
-0.2752645015716553,
0.2824820876121521,
-0.3178887367248535,
-0.19665659964084625,
0.14276470243930817,
-0.13314439356327057,
-0.48227179050445557,
0.6197218894958496,
-0.034257907420396805,
-0.04454474896192551,
-0.2988661825656891,
0.12411141395568848,
-0.15980161726474762,
0.023495646193623543,
0.07091137766838074,
0.2533704340457916,
-0.4034247398376465,
-0.3689790964126587,
0.1700425148010254,
-0.299077570438385,
0.0805094763636589,
0.47357720136642456,
-0.8031353950500488,
0.4029748737812042,
0.14212632179260254,
0.7346974015235901,
0.5772653222084045,
0.052775852382183075,
0.38043123483657837,
-0.5862318873405457,
-0.09702522307634354,
0.23555904626846313,
0.20353573560714722,
0.1980612725019455,
-0.2367265224456787,
1.005361557006836,
0.4210134744644165,
-0.42476096749305725,
-1.0856016874313354,
0.010870015248656273,
-1.0759936571121216,
-0.2754824161529541,
0.9717770218849182,
-0.28995510935783386,
-0.20854932069778442,
0.03461673483252525,
0.28669115900993347,
0.2758157253265381,
0.004866499453783035,
0.7440492510795593,
0.9446068406105042,
0.049506112933158875,
0.05794341862201691,
-0.9277483820915222,
0.013312971219420433,
0.6487649083137512,
-1.3768507242202759,
0.24150016903877258,
0.5782420039176941,
0.6976561546325684,
-0.1242678165435791,
0.517223060131073,
-0.4325982630252838,
0.5758541226387024,
0.01381046324968338,
0.1624443680047989,
-0.5719364285469055,
-0.025600532069802284,
-0.17759327590465546,
0.4622443616390228,
0.0874018520116806,
-0.12978705763816833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19307v1 | The Odyssey of Commonsense Causality: From Foundational Benchmarks to Cutting-Edge Reasoning | 2024-06-27T16:30:50 | 2024-06-27T16:30:50 | Shaobo Cui, Zhijing Jin, Bernhard Schölkopf, Boi Faltings | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding commonsense causality is a unique mark of intelligence for
humans. It helps people understand the principles of the real world better and
benefits the decision-making process related to causation. For instance,
commonsense causality is crucial in judging whether a defendant's action causes
the plaintiff's loss in determining legal liability. Despite its significance,
a systematic exploration of this topic is notably lacking. Our comprehensive
survey bridges this gap by focusing on taxonomies, benchmarks, acquisition
methods, qualitative reasoning, and quantitative measurements in commonsense
causality, synthesizing insights from over 200 representative articles. Our
work aims to provide a systematic overview, update scholars on recent
advancements, provide a pragmatic guide for beginners, and highlight promising
future research directions in this vital field. | [
-0.4086357653141022,
-0.7161722183227539,
0.8988258838653564,
-0.11434061080217361,
-0.09233827888965607,
-0.5620397329330444,
0.11507018655538559,
-0.46343761682510376,
-0.09550615400075912,
0.2977321147918701,
-0.4232885539531708,
-0.11988570541143417,
-0.6116527915000916,
-0.1038074791431427,
-0.09114131331443787,
0.8273299336433411,
0.3286130428314209,
-0.08781741559505463,
-0.5504697561264038,
-0.5935250520706177,
-0.675930917263031,
-0.10140927135944366,
-0.5056959390640259,
-0.015075819566845894,
0.7789561152458191,
0.447919100522995,
0.43478575348854065,
0.46601855754852295,
0.4750560224056244,
0.33372434973716736,
-0.27944517135620117,
-0.12146492302417755,
-0.516167402267456,
-0.1369655281305313,
-0.8021276593208313,
-0.3987616300582886,
-0.12189674377441406,
0.14918343722820282,
0.42648032307624817,
1.0976380109786987,
-0.1707674115896225,
0.19396531581878662,
-0.12366210669279099,
0.772179365158081,
-1.0956497192382812,
-0.08953814953565598,
-0.3810228705406189,
-0.029725728556513786,
-0.36785179376602173,
-0.25038161873817444,
-0.1693120151758194,
-0.4253533184528351,
0.08014246076345444,
-1.1229441165924072,
0.24979542195796967,
0.23514029383659363,
0.4643297493457794,
0.4326939880847931,
-0.9771206974983215,
-0.05644414201378822,
-0.47575584053993225,
0.8211792707443237,
-0.5323590040206909,
0.35275429487228394,
0.22141307592391968,
0.49641355872154236,
-0.11050991714000702,
-1.0919272899627686,
-0.6887219548225403,
-0.15250352025032043,
-0.3105526566505432,
0.2579163908958435,
-0.33537325263023376,
0.03172890096902847,
0.335644006729126,
0.14805495738983154,
-0.4917459785938263,
0.06967140734195709,
-0.5043302774429321,
-0.1712190806865692,
0.8121700286865234,
0.30138176679611206,
0.4993532598018646,
-0.0246772151440382,
-0.5268628597259521,
0.24178090691566467,
-0.8148002028465271,
-0.007354563567787409,
0.389552503824234,
-0.10400731861591339,
0.04445938393473625,
0.05468223989009857,
-0.41618889570236206,
0.7174460887908936,
-0.058123864233493805,
0.05016005411744118,
-0.1680527627468109,
-0.32347536087036133,
-0.031452495604753494,
0.3265628218650818,
0.4076482057571411,
0.44617465138435364,
-0.06355617195367813,
-0.24144364893436432,
0.15362615883350372,
-0.03007562831044197,
0.23124349117279053,
-0.27222350239753723,
-0.09104841202497482,
0.3329935371875763,
-0.5209948420524597,
-0.18702808022499084,
0.1513437032699585,
-0.5550915598869324,
-0.6341348886489868,
-0.637396514415741,
0.10688944905996323,
-0.08107069134712219,
-0.5077921748161316,
0.45562803745269775,
-0.47894346714019775,
0.23477128148078918,
0.5182996988296509,
-0.5549241304397583,
0.29557350277900696,
0.9114246964454651,
0.5771938562393188,
-0.13862451910972595,
-0.4578535258769989,
-0.3595118224620819,
0.38582611083984375,
-0.3211463391780853,
1.0307343006134033,
-0.26860660314559937,
-0.13993047177791595,
-0.09381577372550964,
-0.10194191336631775,
-0.13370802998542786,
-0.45577558875083923,
0.9626337289810181,
-0.2956880033016205,
-0.289490669965744,
-0.6517730355262756,
-0.4571978449821472,
-0.4207870662212372,
0.3443036377429962,
-0.7033785581588745,
0.333599328994751,
-0.3468620479106903,
-0.7879170179367065,
0.8759596347808838,
-0.6082674860954285,
-0.5068309903144836,
0.23579141497612,
0.07090681791305542,
0.07272996753454208,
0.3946355879306793,
-0.17190732061862946,
0.3226909935474396,
-0.4915124177932739,
0.6982190608978271,
-0.40226778388023376,
-0.05273178964853287,
0.335457980632782,
-0.37234029173851013,
1.0398969650268555,
0.30703413486480713,
-0.23440298438072205,
-0.15911217033863068,
-0.6787652373313904,
-0.6353413462638855,
0.017366068437695503,
0.20374786853790283,
-0.6444531679153442,
0.0799233615398407,
0.23751138150691986,
0.24622756242752075,
-0.12334291636943817,
-0.4440385103225708,
-0.1311562955379486,
0.15620458126068115,
0.45111244916915894,
0.6463894248008728,
0.44583994150161743,
0.26324933767318726,
-0.48844215273857117,
-0.12851575016975403,
0.05895324423909187,
0.29140016436576843,
0.1347690373659134,
-0.5943083167076111,
-0.3402343690395355,
-0.06391322612762451,
-0.18702177703380585,
0.43762442469596863,
-0.2451574206352234,
-0.04099104925990105,
-0.1822408139705658,
-0.5899763703346252,
0.1279926598072052,
-0.009117640554904938,
0.43442487716674805,
0.9259787797927856,
0.3043113946914673,
-0.25888338685035706,
-0.05915829539299011,
-0.8134804368019104,
-1.0173734426498413,
-0.13083861768245697,
0.2023645043373108,
0.4446803033351898,
0.469681978225708,
-0.049566980451345444,
0.8872131705284119,
-0.6054388880729675,
-0.2501610815525055,
-0.2422749251127243,
0.34661436080932617,
0.2011488378047943,
0.7210217118263245,
0.3281678259372711,
-1.0610588788986206,
0.05717146396636963,
-0.06654661148786545,
-0.7842494249343872,
-0.09050062298774719,
-0.3817581534385681,
-0.21421866118907928,
-0.5305723547935486,
0.7492380738258362,
-0.5566715002059937,
0.3288276195526123,
-0.19905969500541687,
-0.6426640152931213,
0.58193439245224,
-0.02950194478034973,
0.26803675293922424,
-0.6162601113319397,
0.4547077715396881,
0.32200220227241516,
0.2874869108200073,
-0.6853725910186768,
0.11163553595542908,
-0.10640586167573929,
0.076788991689682,
-0.7381976842880249,
0.6974092721939087,
-0.20452500879764557,
-0.06284241378307343,
0.2551492154598236,
0.3891874849796295,
-0.02111397683620453,
0.3129977285861969,
-0.030619435012340546,
0.45390909910202026,
0.24679577350616455,
-0.7620986104011536,
0.3096272647380829,
0.1714872568845749,
-0.28965696692466736,
1.2388750314712524,
-0.687264084815979,
-0.3999522626399994,
-0.2658509612083435,
0.1857972890138626,
-0.7471897006034851,
-0.387839674949646,
0.10265803337097168,
-0.17994888126850128,
0.07581138610839844,
-0.24098582565784454,
-0.332326740026474,
-0.04274517297744751,
0.041704803705215454,
0.7834464907646179,
0.2147735059261322,
-0.4229194223880768,
0.3761121332645416,
0.4562978148460388,
-0.08017459511756897,
-0.6293963193893433,
-0.660896897315979,
0.26386910676956177,
-0.501085638999939,
-0.4766976237297058,
-0.008239888586103916,
0.12022588402032852,
-0.8144167065620422,
-0.18850857019424438,
-0.12757641077041626,
-0.0987466350197792,
0.37427112460136414,
-0.0014513276983052492,
-0.11357412487268448,
-0.13859310746192932,
0.2867927849292755,
0.08406078815460205,
-0.5058836936950684,
0.421825647354126,
-0.26132509112358093,
-0.1366880238056183,
-0.2440904676914215,
-0.46603482961654663,
-0.725125789642334,
0.3964347243309021,
0.5239817500114441,
-0.0793009027838707,
0.22883340716362,
0.061806052923202515,
-0.22798609733581543,
0.16536663472652435,
-0.7680605053901672,
-0.19090111553668976,
-0.3905429244041443,
0.10334943979978561,
-0.010581874288618565,
-0.44248950481414795,
0.39967915415763855,
-0.452632874250412,
-0.0014140157727524638,
0.7255165576934814,
0.09215064346790314,
0.08022117614746094,
0.49065011739730835,
0.251128613948822,
0.06674472242593765,
0.0008259477908723056,
-0.02453008107841015,
0.3160547912120819,
-0.8459663987159729,
-0.38995909690856934,
-0.5082545876502991,
-0.19492243230342865,
-0.49253222346305847,
-0.06407949328422546,
0.34974992275238037,
-0.018255360424518585,
-0.5070892572402954,
0.16669507324695587,
-0.32039961218833923,
0.6423143148422241,
0.5192282795906067,
0.16132719814777374,
0.6199331283569336,
-0.5340360999107361,
0.12014396488666534,
0.11698723584413528,
-0.7357436418533325,
-0.4111310839653015,
0.758058488368988,
0.10892586410045624,
0.4741775691509247,
0.6609291434288025,
0.5776920318603516,
0.3691490888595581,
0.14573347568511963,
-0.5083616375923157,
0.5136736631393433,
0.22997570037841797,
-1.0283910036087036,
-0.30156803131103516,
-0.19094087183475494,
-1.0053685903549194,
0.17819802463054657,
-0.1931024044752121,
-0.7596029043197632,
0.6411612629890442,
0.39152559638023376,
-0.3152293860912323,
0.29858285188674927,
-0.47589972615242004,
1.136615514755249,
-0.21461528539657593,
-1.0666708946228027,
-0.5216309428215027,
-0.7912821769714355,
0.9183109402656555,
0.40153780579566956,
0.39506611227989197,
-0.1156863197684288,
-0.19551783800125122,
0.7374898195266724,
-0.18203532695770264,
0.8818888068199158,
-0.19364899396896362,
0.07367775589227676,
0.23149490356445312,
-0.0522909015417099,
0.20818226039409637,
0.4481963813304901,
0.5812373161315918,
0.1967143416404724,
0.037525225430727005,
-0.7243654131889343,
-0.677011251449585,
0.6023184657096863,
-0.3835551142692566,
-0.6223528385162354,
-0.6403262615203857,
-0.39945006370544434,
-0.38829517364501953,
0.37911519408226013,
0.02045854553580284,
0.5571799874305725,
-0.3842444121837616,
-0.10328951478004456,
1.1623882055282593,
-0.14713498950004578,
0.3416348099708557,
0.31453800201416016,
0.5649788975715637,
-0.3647567629814148,
0.9494559168815613,
-0.07600963115692139,
0.019120050594210625,
0.36428302526474,
0.42918112874031067,
-0.3906538784503937,
-0.6374639272689819,
-0.28229328989982605,
0.24509690701961517,
-1.0042763948440552,
-0.15334966778755188,
-0.5511611104011536,
0.4766632318496704,
-0.26069745421409607,
-0.46798014640808105,
-0.19117513298988342,
-0.616641640663147,
-0.06222236528992653,
-0.08134618401527405,
0.27107059955596924,
0.7320619225502014,
-0.30673107504844666,
0.008193795569241047,
-0.6407429575920105,
0.25425228476524353,
0.8990058898925781,
0.20505954325199127,
0.3142623007297516,
-0.041591908782720566,
-0.023136144503951073,
-0.3726176619529724,
-0.04208545386791229,
-0.7855654358863831,
-0.10469846427440643,
-0.12685942649841309,
1.0730034112930298,
1.0018277168273926,
0.38663342595100403,
0.6882935762405396,
-0.27592161297798157,
0.7878623008728027,
0.5312886238098145,
-0.7367188930511475,
0.6650826334953308,
-0.5642697215080261,
-0.014509003609418869,
0.785677433013916,
0.5273844003677368,
-0.6524269580841064,
0.10391286760568619,
-0.8561605215072632,
-0.8819663524627686,
0.2603118121623993,
-0.025824204087257385,
-0.10574407130479813,
-0.11665444076061249,
0.11323384940624237,
0.0547175370156765,
-0.10814714431762695,
-0.3018760681152344,
-0.13067664206027985,
-0.1034495010972023,
0.17039081454277039,
-0.07218694686889648,
-0.016290772706270218,
-0.6362782716751099,
-0.2550719976425171,
0.541172444820404,
-0.05713330954313278,
-0.04809015616774559,
0.3493877053260803,
-0.4473286271095276,
0.269131600856781,
0.2932489216327667,
0.8792637586593628,
0.8585663437843323,
0.0009423003648407757,
0.33484944701194763,
0.2592455744743347,
-0.5373035669326782,
0.060760729014873505,
0.1629231721162796,
0.07867362350225449,
-0.34376946091651917,
0.7092256546020508,
0.36784934997558594,
0.6161630749702454,
-0.8624857068061829,
0.6312198042869568,
0.20169907808303833,
-0.012687812559306622,
-0.1465398371219635,
0.08686996251344681,
-0.07220395654439926,
0.2565348446369171,
0.5648906826972961,
0.14231933653354645,
0.8407302498817444,
-0.5439468026161194,
0.26022106409072876,
0.2733244001865387,
-0.14676924049854279,
-0.048070549964904785,
0.6993275284767151,
0.4187512993812561,
0.2762632668018341,
0.37575072050094604,
0.0528959296643734,
-0.15278925001621246,
0.7335717678070068,
0.16016055643558502,
0.8286048769950867,
0.2403733730316162,
0.0402449369430542,
0.6837489604949951,
0.23303638398647308,
-0.09443119913339615,
-0.44633492827415466,
-0.4948042631149292,
-0.4919220805168152,
-0.10962283611297607,
-0.21932458877563477,
-0.46257489919662476,
-0.31710609793663025,
-0.8339115977287292,
-0.14820486307144165,
-0.3075323700904846,
0.09827998280525208,
0.026965657249093056,
-0.10014230757951736,
-0.4540061354637146,
0.2692996561527252,
-0.2394895851612091,
1.1171952486038208,
-1.2627002000808716,
0.07792401313781738,
0.5848871469497681,
-0.8432322144508362,
-0.3550783097743988,
0.030508430674672127,
0.41608765721321106,
-0.690894365310669,
0.6322256326675415,
-0.07249848544597626,
0.04530314356088638,
-0.13590706884860992,
-0.6094774007797241,
-0.6617035865783691,
1.1910121440887451,
-0.10188819468021393,
-0.393267959356308,
0.22139529883861542,
-0.0028448542580008507,
0.07087569683790207,
0.054423607885837555,
0.031220806762576103,
0.8180121183395386,
0.5237593054771423,
0.21927271783351898,
-0.3001597821712494,
0.385483980178833,
-0.12415304034948349,
0.13308922946453094,
0.1574244350194931,
-0.5566636919975281,
0.4182508587837219,
-0.2919352054595947,
-0.09066638350486755,
-0.1580578237771988,
0.5294763445854187,
0.5578101277351379,
0.9836133122444153,
0.31337547302246094,
0.899927020072937,
0.7266113758087158,
-0.17168377339839935,
1.068494439125061,
-0.041647881269454956,
0.19317790865898132,
0.8168312311172485,
-0.04191506281495094,
0.5153452157974243,
0.7926168441772461,
-0.31030941009521484,
0.3755476176738739,
0.45716530084609985,
0.24770517647266388,
0.4812611937522888,
0.06535160541534424,
-0.4044331908226013,
-0.4475322365760803,
-0.10948936641216278,
-0.21675759553909302,
0.14459852874279022,
0.4292023479938507,
0.009578052908182144,
-0.30310773849487305,
-0.13708962500095367,
0.16727593541145325,
0.15947988629341125,
-0.5045974254608154,
0.8971532583236694,
0.12011805176734924,
-0.8185103535652161,
-0.021837830543518066,
-0.4806269407272339,
0.3405196964740753,
-0.3341791033744812,
-0.03596813604235649,
-0.6117960810661316,
0.015308979898691177,
-0.2800035774707794,
-0.7739760875701904,
0.34143519401550293,
-0.34947535395622253,
-0.01808183453977108,
-0.06313519924879074,
0.7300481796264648,
0.3101860284805298,
-0.15254996716976166,
-0.2924804985523224,
0.4672818183898926,
0.25915083289146423,
0.2299901694059372,
-0.45038455724716187,
-0.15246494114398956,
-0.5988454818725586,
-0.01943664625287056,
0.27011963725090027,
0.7512350082397461,
-0.07411704957485199,
0.58171546459198,
0.8038487434387207,
-0.06105727702379227,
-0.047525327652692795,
-0.26739662885665894,
0.7189493179321289,
-0.8150060772895813,
-0.39709970355033875,
-0.4925692081451416,
0.9003119468688965,
-0.5632972717285156,
-0.7785745859146118,
0.6660574078559875,
0.340082585811615,
0.6300448179244995,
-0.04941842705011368,
0.6586914658546448,
-0.1135159358382225,
0.16802535951137543,
-0.6163539886474609,
0.7700854539871216,
-0.6456325650215149,
0.1546609103679657,
-0.4801854193210602,
-0.39693573117256165,
-0.5893932580947876,
0.40298011898994446,
-0.46012601256370544,
-0.10319472849369049,
0.5132964253425598,
0.5105986595153809,
-0.2765171229839325,
0.07968183606863022,
0.23755334317684174,
-0.12079636007547379,
-0.001180738676339388,
0.4476539194583893,
0.883155882358551,
-0.17182669043540955,
0.30003634095191956,
-0.024917826056480408,
-0.33426353335380554,
-0.40622881054878235,
-1.0059391260147095,
-0.5161842107772827,
-0.5365225672721863,
-0.5354152917861938,
-0.05793767049908638,
0.13379116356372833,
0.3766154646873474,
0.5915325284004211,
-0.7049286365509033,
0.016764124855399132,
-0.8381190299987793,
0.5510515570640564,
-0.5961316227912903,
-0.23836486041545868,
0.32379603385925293,
-0.5947009921073914,
-0.3446379601955414,
-0.06300066411495209,
0.266776978969574,
-0.33371227979660034,
0.07292333245277405,
-0.2529078722000122,
-0.4288977384567261,
0.2406339943408966,
0.5734554529190063,
0.7923768758773804,
-0.7979264855384827,
0.052185602486133575,
-0.35113200545310974,
0.08747191727161407,
-0.2892129719257355,
1.2918164730072021,
-0.6813986897468567,
0.41509148478507996,
0.47159385681152344,
0.6304251551628113,
0.05756745859980583,
-0.4124585688114166,
0.3208891451358795,
-0.17854292690753937,
0.15738816559314728,
0.365892618894577,
0.5270495414733887,
0.04412348195910454,
-0.2714080512523651,
0.6474855542182922,
0.7724168300628662,
-0.4934714436531067,
-0.8095725178718567,
0.5085679292678833,
-1.099831223487854,
-0.4707547724246979,
0.8143190741539001,
0.09649635851383209,
-0.05667673796415329,
-0.4984823763370514,
0.05883786827325821,
0.06809971481561661,
-0.16246278584003448,
0.6842706799507141,
0.20720155537128448,
-0.4205490052700043,
-0.44819551706314087,
-0.572364866733551,
0.512862503528595,
0.1589251607656479,
-0.8786852359771729,
0.1865488737821579,
0.8344918489456177,
0.1393706053495407,
0.3115164339542389,
0.23422551155090332,
0.025221653282642365,
0.7999082803726196,
0.33978787064552307,
-0.3737834692001343,
0.02990289218723774,
-0.04581718146800995,
-0.13778181374073029,
0.0466255284845829,
0.007174372207373381,
0.1585092693567276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19292v1 | From Artificial Needles to Real Haystacks: Improving Retrieval Capabilities in LLMs by Finetuning on Synthetic Data | 2024-06-27T16:05:13 | 2024-06-27T16:05:13 | Zheyang Xiong, Vasilis Papageorgiou, Kangwook Lee, Dimitris Papailiopoulos | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent studies have shown that Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle to
accurately retrieve information and maintain reasoning capabilities when
processing long-context inputs. To address these limitations, we propose a
finetuning approach utilizing a carefully designed synthetic dataset comprising
numerical key-value retrieval tasks. Our experiments on models like GPT-3.5
Turbo and Mistral 7B demonstrate that finetuning LLMs on this dataset
significantly improves LLMs' information retrieval and reasoning capabilities
in longer-context settings. We present an analysis of the finetuned models,
illustrating the transfer of skills from synthetic to real task evaluations
(e.g., $10.5\%$ improvement on $20$ documents MDQA at position $10$ for GPT-3.5
Turbo). We also find that finetuned LLMs' performance on general benchmarks
remains almost constant while LLMs finetuned on other baseline long-context
augmentation data can encourage hallucination (e.g., on TriviaQA, Mistral 7B
finetuned on our synthetic data cause no performance drop while other baseline
data can cause a drop that ranges from $2.33\%$ to $6.19\%$). Our study
highlights the potential of finetuning on synthetic data for improving the
performance of LLMs on longer-context tasks. | [
-0.3160685896873474,
-1.0667582750320435,
0.9421871304512024,
-0.20143134891986847,
-0.3348427414894104,
0.1251310259103775,
-0.44557926058769226,
-0.6796945333480835,
0.11170988529920578,
0.6303470730781555,
-0.47617653012275696,
-0.40150943398475647,
-0.3482685387134552,
0.30572688579559326,
-0.618046224117279,
0.9014278054237366,
0.1996251344680786,
0.05860485881567001,
-0.13617266714572906,
0.05662188678979874,
-0.547696053981781,
-0.7500028610229492,
-0.5002749562263489,
-0.284698486328125,
0.6109492182731628,
0.485455185174942,
0.6990697383880615,
0.8421546816825867,
0.6640300750732422,
0.2697061002254486,
-0.1926034688949585,
0.5044971108436584,
-0.9018939733505249,
0.1692444533109665,
-0.3854545056819916,
-0.7050765752792358,
-0.1330096423625946,
-0.014812435023486614,
0.5345834493637085,
0.5548180341720581,
-0.07141171395778656,
0.05909985676407814,
0.20633617043495178,
0.7347297072410583,
-0.42343446612358093,
0.033040087670087814,
-0.9586264491081238,
-0.11680030077695847,
-0.37387195229530334,
-0.34294968843460083,
-0.29983246326446533,
-0.4198605418205261,
0.16509075462818146,
-0.8125252723693848,
0.3197598457336426,
-0.056773822754621506,
0.8033162355422974,
0.4607403576374054,
-0.3174177408218384,
-0.24543356895446777,
-0.7533442974090576,
0.8487942218780518,
-0.7431015968322754,
0.38513725996017456,
0.427888423204422,
0.4851275086402893,
-0.2791197896003723,
-0.9125102758407593,
-0.5681141018867493,
-0.509334146976471,
-0.09502920508384705,
-0.03800923749804497,
0.34531524777412415,
0.1400008648633957,
0.41222110390663147,
0.5223179459571838,
-0.2543899118900299,
0.05065847188234329,
-0.6536170840263367,
-0.18026787042617798,
0.6757359504699707,
0.30681806802749634,
-0.10146898031234741,
-0.27160346508026123,
-0.1410725712776184,
-0.16688960790634155,
-0.8295884728431702,
-0.050628770142793655,
0.1201256513595581,
0.6206892728805542,
0.2581351697444916,
0.7771844863891602,
-0.47737258672714233,
0.7659127116203308,
0.20534496009349823,
0.085797518491745,
0.0918416976928711,
-0.5774276256561279,
-0.18803752958774567,
-0.0690193846821785,
0.2719758450984955,
0.32393646240234375,
0.45423319935798645,
-0.2385151982307434,
-0.4436046779155731,
-0.09086146950721741,
0.36509257555007935,
-0.79483962059021,
-0.2667349874973297,
0.04909885302186012,
-0.28438493609428406,
-0.2371511161327362,
0.1500711292028427,
-0.4219261109828949,
-0.5323755145072937,
-1.0850586891174316,
0.748933732509613,
-0.6326674818992615,
0.16870354115962982,
0.04038477689027786,
-0.16861848533153534,
0.11736823618412018,
0.34703370928764343,
-0.7566412687301636,
0.35856643319129944,
1.0719174146652222,
1.013739824295044,
-0.465872585773468,
0.023152930662035942,
-0.6432123780250549,
-0.027950191870331764,
-0.36564362049102783,
0.7068583965301514,
-0.47325965762138367,
-0.20309746265411377,
-0.15426160395145416,
0.1822766810655594,
0.12096171826124191,
-0.929273247718811,
0.6122776865959167,
-0.4293672740459442,
-0.07292542606592178,
-0.2653743326663971,
-0.4732261896133423,
-0.09807933866977692,
0.24833548069000244,
-0.8179614543914795,
0.8939841389656067,
0.03112827241420746,
-0.28488069772720337,
0.24371880292892456,
-0.3827013075351715,
-0.45045310258865356,
-0.035846684128046036,
-0.3423900008201599,
-0.10115538537502289,
0.2705004811286926,
0.010105660185217857,
0.5795709490776062,
-0.341827392578125,
0.3496856987476349,
-0.3141894042491913,
-0.9067199230194092,
0.3610862195491791,
-0.732307493686676,
0.4422396421432495,
0.2647867798805237,
-0.25139686465263367,
-0.04606528952717781,
-0.833551824092865,
0.08804810792207718,
-0.25224074721336365,
-0.38083744049072266,
-0.5396378636360168,
-0.09758777916431427,
0.04702448472380638,
0.18865275382995605,
0.08837521076202393,
-0.5780530571937561,
0.26654955744743347,
-0.8642539381980896,
0.564116895198822,
0.7259193062782288,
-0.004656080622226,
0.43557384610176086,
-0.6713794469833374,
0.26701483130455017,
0.0020728472154587507,
-0.2019607126712799,
0.2844926416873932,
0.007303763646632433,
-0.8021175861358643,
-0.22665496170520782,
0.4532070755958557,
0.5075619220733643,
-0.9492391347885132,
0.15957598388195038,
-0.3154563903808594,
-0.4949924349784851,
-0.8353424668312073,
0.08054269105195999,
0.35191670060157776,
0.4812822937965393,
0.6183520555496216,
-0.02382008172571659,
-0.5568347573280334,
-1.0416109561920166,
-0.3767191767692566,
0.4193611145019531,
-0.41388484835624695,
0.37034058570861816,
0.31273582577705383,
-0.26328521966934204,
0.9296391606330872,
-0.5624444484710693,
-0.4599420726299286,
0.20629745721817017,
0.11359314620494843,
0.47512269020080566,
0.6928643584251404,
0.15094247460365295,
-0.7784479260444641,
-0.34090134501457214,
0.09048455208539963,
-0.40871649980545044,
-0.012863964773714542,
-0.3265608847141266,
-0.17823904752731323,
0.308172345161438,
0.576311469078064,
-0.8993744254112244,
0.23793847858905792,
0.1735163778066635,
-0.16471143066883087,
0.765564501285553,
-0.046680375933647156,
0.21980199217796326,
-0.8784257769584656,
0.1729586273431778,
-0.05219108238816261,
-0.40416696667671204,
-0.49098435044288635,
0.0970223918557167,
0.0859759971499443,
0.1673731803894043,
-0.4962966740131378,
0.8018591403961182,
-0.21702879667282104,
0.10014577955007553,
-0.014597759582102299,
0.1466750204563141,
-0.0004904068191535771,
0.2750524580478668,
-0.10433253645896912,
1.2544773817062378,
0.1280767023563385,
-0.7344250679016113,
0.3636873960494995,
0.03764833137392998,
-0.4856095314025879,
0.5114604234695435,
-0.5116463303565979,
0.07919269055128098,
-0.08805526793003082,
-0.03833691403269768,
-0.7441351413726807,
-0.36421406269073486,
-0.1351856291294098,
-0.3424023985862732,
0.22264955937862396,
-0.10193589329719543,
-0.4548857808113098,
-0.08316287398338318,
-0.3345112204551697,
0.2987530529499054,
0.457918643951416,
-0.6147416234016418,
0.3606998324394226,
0.18762902915477753,
-0.14558424055576324,
-0.2686445116996765,
-0.6829683780670166,
0.03517219424247742,
-0.5301864147186279,
-0.347624272108078,
0.7151700258255005,
-0.054505106061697006,
-0.3126172125339508,
-0.29326415061950684,
-0.31130364537239075,
-0.1956484168767929,
0.016054298728704453,
0.004198011010885239,
0.1974221020936966,
-0.133774071931839,
0.4364594519138336,
0.006137901917099953,
-0.13921847939491272,
0.012069476768374443,
-0.24918332695960999,
0.4549793601036072,
-0.06773214042186737,
-0.06698465347290039,
-0.3031221926212311,
0.09174229949712753,
0.5285873413085938,
-0.043995317071676254,
0.6263209581375122,
0.5622190237045288,
-0.48391780257225037,
-0.16915775835514069,
-0.7939644455909729,
-0.5482633709907532,
-0.559514582157135,
0.2739312946796417,
-0.6916313171386719,
-0.907295286655426,
0.4324834942817688,
-0.1029604822397232,
-0.031271882355213165,
0.4873477816581726,
0.3289113938808441,
-0.3881937265396118,
1.1529126167297363,
0.33770179748535156,
0.20635473728179932,
0.5149746537208557,
-0.5089236497879028,
-0.09676145017147064,
-0.9581257104873657,
-0.22925357520580292,
-0.24350380897521973,
-0.2947544455528259,
-0.7114527821540833,
-0.4841545820236206,
0.4471855163574219,
0.21795614063739777,
-0.2932109236717224,
0.16017015278339386,
-0.6356534957885742,
0.6290692090988159,
0.6355370879173279,
0.5604602694511414,
0.4713546335697174,
0.08832874894142151,
-0.2317110002040863,
-0.05725473538041115,
-0.5860523581504822,
-0.5759533047676086,
1.085388422012329,
0.18447302281856537,
0.878646194934845,
0.07727788388729095,
0.639634370803833,
0.19499854743480682,
0.08873065561056137,
-0.9606776237487793,
0.4849300980567932,
-0.39438655972480774,
-0.4906843304634094,
-0.509060263633728,
-0.4696039855480194,
-0.881018340587616,
0.15616245567798615,
-0.27554401755332947,
-0.4171212911605835,
0.18462242186069489,
0.18710146844387054,
-0.6853233575820923,
-0.1733798086643219,
-0.608822226524353,
0.4824649691581726,
-0.1703452616930008,
-0.7328140139579773,
-0.39662474393844604,
-0.5063639283180237,
0.38692551851272583,
-0.3096475899219513,
0.037376269698143005,
-0.06523218750953674,
0.10973580181598663,
0.6578665971755981,
-0.38810086250305176,
0.6624441146850586,
0.06044585630297661,
-0.19337093830108643,
0.21934270858764648,
0.3525009751319885,
0.6327370405197144,
0.1462073028087616,
-0.5063678026199341,
-0.10178930312395096,
0.6298182010650635,
-0.25469014048576355,
-0.7247012853622437,
1.0025081634521484,
-0.4921175539493561,
-0.8300726413726807,
-0.2667733132839203,
-0.7180435061454773,
-0.30652281641960144,
0.26031842827796936,
0.08916226029396057,
0.5638505816459656,
0.05153384059667587,
0.6742381453514099,
0.599800705909729,
0.19943881034851074,
0.06209343671798706,
0.25871026515960693,
0.1924019753932953,
-0.27459752559661865,
0.9761101007461548,
0.5967029333114624,
0.40250203013420105,
0.1803598552942276,
0.08634010702371597,
-0.5003277063369751,
-0.44321408867836,
-0.25570058822631836,
0.2628847062587738,
-0.6814687252044678,
-0.4807300865650177,
-0.3062911033630371,
-0.36274388432502747,
-0.22092878818511963,
-0.030725425109267235,
-0.24306650459766388,
-0.7319648265838623,
-0.5790944695472717,
-0.061025213450193405,
0.6421940326690674,
0.5759970545768738,
0.05704938620328903,
0.25893938541412354,
-0.7491863965988159,
0.41124799847602844,
0.17793993651866913,
0.6227164268493652,
-0.005060560069978237,
-0.6445358395576477,
-0.3308655321598053,
0.4752383232116699,
-0.26119017601013184,
-0.5361562371253967,
0.41365018486976624,
0.21215160191059113,
0.37699681520462036,
-0.026138363406062126,
0.13381770253181458,
1.2096021175384521,
-0.5354503393173218,
0.4943144917488098,
-0.35473573207855225,
-0.7628748416900635,
0.12035553902387619,
-0.4944838285446167,
0.3227806091308594,
0.7888044714927673,
0.2836935222148895,
-0.4807165265083313,
-0.2902677357196808,
-0.49738234281539917,
-0.7130334973335266,
0.5762460827827454,
0.24806785583496094,
0.19205766916275024,
0.004620115738362074,
0.8177726864814758,
0.15680469572544098,
0.17869660258293152,
-0.47039738297462463,
0.20184265077114105,
0.13351216912269592,
-0.5050031542778015,
-0.1806551069021225,
-0.08405454456806183,
-0.10340084135532379,
-0.5683327913284302,
0.5898774266242981,
-0.27880802750587463,
0.15759728848934174,
0.4298906922340393,
-0.13596849143505096,
0.14709985256195068,
0.1517677903175354,
0.466403990983963,
0.7627559900283813,
-0.24951167404651642,
0.2955974340438843,
0.4084397852420807,
-0.2997407019138336,
-0.0541033074259758,
0.2015874683856964,
-0.11845111846923828,
-0.1653868407011032,
0.21687914431095123,
0.45272207260131836,
0.15790750086307526,
-0.8862625956535339,
0.007306566461920738,
0.30765819549560547,
-0.11692437529563904,
-0.3585129678249359,
0.3708666265010834,
-0.02100902795791626,
0.41826143860816956,
0.47404414415359497,
-0.1586156040430069,
0.515458881855011,
-0.6849563121795654,
0.5193502902984619,
0.5640813112258911,
-0.18589353561401367,
-0.04352238401770592,
0.5051564574241638,
0.05114227905869484,
-0.2527097165584564,
0.6734559535980225,
0.07455476373434067,
-0.20398835837841034,
0.6450183391571045,
0.7262848019599915,
0.4228675961494446,
0.0317377969622612,
-0.22289040684700012,
0.40997862815856934,
-0.04585491120815277,
-0.30324122309684753,
0.3396323025226593,
-0.026931816712021828,
-0.30605170130729675,
-0.49077436327934265,
-0.6358593106269836,
-0.19026660919189453,
0.33874791860580444,
-0.4826837480068207,
0.4577583074569702,
-0.33728909492492676,
-0.31089159846305847,
-0.08341344445943832,
0.3119778633117676,
-0.7038114666938782,
0.2569791078567505,
-0.10227293521165848,
0.9214721918106079,
-0.4396948218345642,
0.7742299437522888,
0.2190624177455902,
-0.41450536251068115,
-0.6463439464569092,
-0.13208803534507751,
-0.10074956715106964,
-0.5357775688171387,
0.5452827215194702,
0.2774699926376343,
-0.07596190273761749,
0.4479934871196747,
-0.4948943257331848,
-1.1607736349105835,
1.2172114849090576,
0.32364124059677124,
-0.8353597521781921,
-0.2231801152229309,
0.20169444382190704,
0.6904652714729309,
-0.1473589688539505,
0.08847062289714813,
1.0273061990737915,
0.3408716022968292,
0.16090898215770721,
-1.0749129056930542,
0.15975867211818695,
0.009111488237977028,
-0.049384716898202896,
0.16597890853881836,
-0.37014147639274597,
0.8322552442550659,
-0.020425934344530106,
-0.3886541724205017,
0.3624005913734436,
0.41662895679473877,
0.492173969745636,
0.1594875305891037,
0.1849593073129654,
0.27019062638282776,
0.8991566300392151,
-0.13242748379707336,
0.9068291187286377,
-0.17062510550022125,
0.30218473076820374,
1.132365107536316,
0.044939249753952026,
1.055190920829773,
0.7443762421607971,
0.09290177375078201,
0.2426598072052002,
0.6281188130378723,
0.08440593630075455,
0.589088499546051,
0.4844368100166321,
-0.18269553780555725,
-0.3399178981781006,
-0.1607392281293869,
-0.14567360281944275,
0.25562942028045654,
0.5108649730682373,
-0.24062733352184296,
0.01948685385286808,
0.22292552888393402,
-0.17810332775115967,
0.2807832360267639,
-0.25021377205848694,
0.7767501473426819,
0.2912456691265106,
-0.7455171346664429,
1.2245066165924072,
-0.06011407822370529,
0.8091422319412231,
-0.19728152453899384,
-0.43639081716537476,
-0.20687103271484375,
0.3464367687702179,
-0.22228015959262848,
-0.913820207118988,
0.4238560199737549,
-0.15510034561157227,
-0.12069418281316757,
-0.05201396718621254,
0.6238569021224976,
-0.6689291000366211,
-0.5325151085853577,
-0.14068008959293365,
0.2710218131542206,
0.14538031816482544,
-0.18607452511787415,
-0.5135601758956909,
0.0755852460861206,
-0.19000552594661713,
-0.08903566747903824,
0.15882624685764313,
0.389446884393692,
-0.35886135697364807,
0.7919893860816956,
0.8886814117431641,
0.2234133780002594,
-0.02644471265375614,
-0.02708091028034687,
0.9566324949264526,
-0.8795896768569946,
-0.31045421957969666,
-0.9011743664741516,
0.356629341840744,
-0.07412022352218628,
-0.02378173917531967,
0.5757287740707397,
0.7036536931991577,
0.9982010722160339,
-0.1989322006702423,
0.4749322831630707,
0.14326775074005127,
0.7912412285804749,
-1.010179042816162,
0.7408362627029419,
-0.4719586968421936,
0.29646292328834534,
0.09761793911457062,
-0.892430305480957,
-0.33013662695884705,
0.741219162940979,
-0.3900892436504364,
-0.00937409233301878,
0.4930368661880493,
0.9840478301048279,
-0.3106115460395813,
-0.3569721281528473,
0.290161669254303,
0.3918449878692627,
0.3858368694782257,
0.47794967889785767,
0.7913186550140381,
-0.40577298402786255,
0.3179641366004944,
-0.39825281500816345,
0.08781838417053223,
-0.2384430319070816,
-0.6343982815742493,
-0.7460883855819702,
-0.6725375652313232,
0.1403326839208603,
-0.2674647867679596,
0.26648297905921936,
1.119938850402832,
0.7157970666885376,
-0.7184109687805176,
-0.2892002761363983,
-0.2208423763513565,
-0.03766224533319473,
-0.04621696472167969,
-0.3537054657936096,
0.29706719517707825,
-0.520063042640686,
-0.8099116086959839,
0.48592785000801086,
-0.24092185497283936,
0.23023465275764465,
-0.1033402755856514,
-0.012264039367437363,
-0.1604582518339157,
0.17676334083080292,
0.9078143239021301,
0.09879286587238312,
-0.9573533535003662,
-0.5785521864891052,
0.15222886204719543,
-0.20680241286754608,
-0.06152322143316269,
0.47415611147880554,
-1.3232228755950928,
0.23393003642559052,
0.5416471362113953,
0.7468002438545227,
0.5396922826766968,
0.46108531951904297,
0.6720809936523438,
-0.6215990781784058,
0.061021678149700165,
0.4519081115722656,
-0.030468976125121117,
0.24272340536117554,
-0.6083613038063049,
0.6224958896636963,
0.03149790316820145,
-0.518634557723999,
-0.9574631452560425,
-0.10401829332113266,
-0.7787294983863831,
-0.2924543023109436,
1.2290897369384766,
0.4048607349395752,
-0.06624581664800644,
-0.07347112894058228,
-0.5957476496696472,
0.3876001238822937,
-0.21793687343597412,
1.1403687000274658,
0.6956965327262878,
-0.18213526904582977,
0.05208571255207062,
-0.8840845823287964,
0.9608476758003235,
0.6480292677879333,
-0.7345770001411438,
0.2992081344127655,
0.7312695980072021,
0.2980155944824219,
-0.00524689769372344,
0.25881457328796387,
-0.015943504869937897,
0.2790653109550476,
-0.5141659379005432,
-0.5358725786209106,
-0.24462437629699707,
-0.5389387607574463,
-0.4491128921508789,
-0.16771964728832245,
0.0938863605260849,
0.14568188786506653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00119v1 | Efficient Long-distance Latent Relation-aware Graph Neural Network for Multi-modal Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2024-06-27T15:54:12 | 2024-06-27T15:54:12 | Yuntao Shou, Wei Ai, Jiayi Du, Tao Meng, Haiyan Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The task of multi-modal emotion recognition in conversation (MERC) aims to
analyze the genuine emotional state of each utterance based on the multi-modal
information in the conversation, which is crucial for conversation
understanding. Existing methods focus on using graph neural networks (GNN) to
model conversational relationships and capture contextual latent semantic
relationships. However, due to the complexity of GNN, existing methods cannot
efficiently capture the potential dependencies between long-distance
utterances, which limits the performance of MERC. In this paper, we propose an
Efficient Long-distance Latent Relation-aware Graph Neural Network (ELR-GNN)
for multi-modal emotion recognition in conversations. Specifically, we first
use pre-extracted text, video and audio features as input to Bi-LSTM to capture
contextual semantic information and obtain low-level utterance features. Then,
we use low-level utterance features to construct a conversational emotion
interaction graph. To efficiently capture the potential dependencies between
long-distance utterances, we use the dilated generalized forward push algorithm
to precompute the emotional propagation between global utterances and design an
emotional relation-aware operator to capture the potential semantic
associations between different utterances. Furthermore, we combine early fusion
and adaptive late fusion mechanisms to fuse latent dependency information
between speaker relationship information and context. Finally, we obtain
high-level discourse features and feed them into MLP for emotion prediction.
Extensive experimental results show that ELR-GNN achieves state-of-the-art
performance on the benchmark datasets IEMOCAP and MELD, with running times
reduced by 52\% and 35\%, respectively. | [
-0.4860440790653229,
-0.9356422424316406,
0.38483351469039917,
0.17938075959682465,
-0.4300706684589386,
-0.11532974988222122,
-0.2635672390460968,
-0.6915974020957947,
0.4853020906448364,
0.0731586143374443,
-0.618342936038971,
-0.4488813877105713,
-0.3948107659816742,
0.0326753668487072,
0.09863998740911484,
0.8175480961799622,
0.04612355679273605,
-0.33262309432029724,
-0.1719379872083664,
-0.3730524480342865,
-0.09851641952991486,
-0.7543278336524963,
-0.5538997650146484,
-0.32700735330581665,
0.91693115234375,
0.042551439255476,
0.43258026242256165,
-0.028965776786208153,
0.2337639480829239,
0.4542037546634674,
-0.39810672402381897,
0.4752528667449951,
-0.6196112036705017,
0.13316844403743744,
0.31412196159362793,
0.05814697965979576,
-0.6254863739013672,
-0.23821401596069336,
0.44654005765914917,
0.29889100790023804,
0.0032358819153159857,
-0.29627490043640137,
-0.06546923518180847,
0.6508479118347168,
-0.587394654750824,
0.6717037558555603,
-0.503492534160614,
0.26758819818496704,
-0.02166130393743515,
-0.08389339596033096,
-0.3760130703449249,
-0.25466299057006836,
0.2603801488876343,
-0.20208989083766937,
-0.3125811219215393,
0.1299874633550644,
0.734316349029541,
-0.07884062826633453,
-0.8585529327392578,
-0.09137021005153656,
-0.5730905532836914,
0.2914122939109802,
-0.6698942184448242,
0.6392444968223572,
0.32901790738105774,
0.11761598289012909,
-0.08958534896373749,
-0.5446797013282776,
-0.6659684777259827,
-0.179306760430336,
-0.18318477272987366,
0.5331799983978271,
-0.42128950357437134,
0.428596556186676,
0.16971565783023834,
0.27930185198783875,
-0.5762615203857422,
0.02921333536505699,
-0.033024150878190994,
-0.24999380111694336,
0.34186023473739624,
0.20239733159542084,
-0.04429405927658081,
-0.5629180073738098,
-0.3137035369873047,
-0.008794212713837624,
-0.30818140506744385,
0.1740548312664032,
0.3875272572040558,
0.39769142866134644,
-0.2318686991930008,
0.2850596606731415,
-0.07647218555212021,
0.5063111782073975,
0.06209831312298775,
0.032081346958875656,
0.4950476586818695,
-0.3309114873409271,
-0.10574457049369812,
0.0375724695622921,
1.2090413570404053,
0.34356755018234253,
0.18519945442676544,
-0.001405344344675541,
0.1284477412700653,
0.12029238045215607,
0.04099172726273537,
-0.9912890791893005,
-0.05556868389248848,
0.14117641746997833,
-0.39202648401260376,
0.010315688326954842,
-0.18282650411128998,
-1.0976330041885376,
-0.22223493456840515,
-0.22642691433429718,
0.036875784397125244,
-0.3327001929283142,
-0.23755250871181488,
-0.28018680214881897,
0.3880915343761444,
-0.08066298067569733,
0.33800041675567627,
-0.6604081988334656,
0.25010403990745544,
0.45098501443862915,
1.0573116540908813,
0.00804528221487999,
-0.206735298037529,
-0.5921211838722229,
-0.005373379215598106,
0.06335069984197617,
0.404946506023407,
-0.4007570445537567,
-0.37420740723609924,
0.02291041426360607,
0.1276857554912567,
-0.19474934041500092,
-0.20099355280399323,
0.5652064085006714,
-0.6886489987373352,
0.24137510359287262,
0.09288340061903,
-0.5125110149383545,
-0.42129623889923096,
0.46103549003601074,
-0.7929565906524658,
0.8089686632156372,
0.15481889247894287,
-1.078709602355957,
-0.361976683139801,
-0.6506977677345276,
-0.7156348824501038,
-0.3334629237651825,
-0.020896194502711296,
-0.68471360206604,
0.044197928160429,
0.36212560534477234,
0.5501607060432434,
-0.08529423177242279,
0.12613525986671448,
-0.5749001502990723,
-0.18469086289405823,
0.17998911440372467,
-0.633795976638794,
0.26935291290283203,
0.07860954850912094,
-0.3112972676753998,
0.27149632573127747,
-0.7584131956100464,
-0.05721273645758629,
-0.012851757928729057,
-0.20333550870418549,
-0.24490830302238464,
-0.06167776510119438,
-0.11803895980119705,
0.6027604937553406,
0.0692063644528389,
-0.5293391942977905,
-0.12139531224966049,
-0.4146113991737366,
0.45611459016799927,
0.806150496006012,
0.031189916655421257,
0.3173920810222626,
0.10135374218225479,
0.40847471356391907,
0.24888214468955994,
-0.004938135389238596,
-0.25732314586639404,
-0.25585946440696716,
-0.6058386564254761,
-0.07871455699205399,
-0.06928219646215439,
0.6336950063705444,
-0.5226718783378601,
0.7154349088668823,
-0.2724992036819458,
-0.36313414573669434,
-0.2417663186788559,
-0.06676547974348068,
0.3474824130535126,
1.0330606698989868,
0.2791029214859009,
-0.2720454931259155,
-0.3945939540863037,
-0.5946927070617676,
0.20060184597969055,
-0.318058043718338,
0.24180330336093903,
1.180377721786499,
0.261065274477005,
-0.2453143447637558,
0.7784276008605957,
-0.5805535316467285,
-0.24654968082904816,
0.018328135833144188,
0.44163912534713745,
0.06576056778430939,
0.035362377762794495,
0.3304198980331421,
-0.8832643032073975,
-0.5201355814933777,
0.2244722694158554,
-0.6913637518882751,
-0.04112431779503822,
0.16031141579151154,
-0.3030669391155243,
0.30303889513015747,
0.2888202369213104,
-0.7067536115646362,
0.4814426004886627,
0.7548503875732422,
-0.3482024371623993,
0.2914033830165863,
-0.12473021447658539,
0.34125348925590515,
-0.9992273449897766,
0.09386017918586731,
0.0565858893096447,
-0.4567142724990845,
-0.6708018183708191,
-0.7117463946342468,
-0.029410697519779205,
-0.37205684185028076,
-0.5625642538070679,
0.23339298367500305,
-0.35496798157691956,
-0.10127026587724686,
-0.0075844572857022285,
0.4311361312866211,
0.14941366016864777,
0.9419389963150024,
0.010407953523099422,
0.44157370924949646,
0.1892002671957016,
-0.3732943832874298,
0.802958071231842,
0.32444965839385986,
-0.08161229640245438,
0.7800623178482056,
-0.3958061635494232,
0.5839300751686096,
-0.16059564054012299,
0.6720072031021118,
-0.8735237717628479,
0.08732368052005768,
0.35195431113243103,
-0.0990491583943367,
0.34355708956718445,
-0.11576501280069351,
-0.2240036427974701,
-0.47658905386924744,
0.040982700884342194,
0.49493640661239624,
0.21111798286437988,
-0.4497446119785309,
1.290778398513794,
0.05192737281322479,
-0.473673015832901,
-0.4078196883201599,
-0.49618878960609436,
0.0690031424164772,
-0.234086811542511,
-0.9531468152999878,
0.24460703134536743,
-0.04069814831018448,
0.23346303403377533,
-0.0989958643913269,
0.15995235741138458,
0.08792674541473389,
-0.16927525401115417,
0.6291905045509338,
0.2229555994272232,
-0.03336566686630249,
0.2577599883079529,
-0.22855740785598755,
-0.18010012805461884,
0.1682458519935608,
0.1559009999036789,
0.7010817527770996,
-0.4598674178123474,
-0.3192296326160431,
-0.5559066534042358,
0.5897360444068909,
0.7469564080238342,
-0.3728592097759247,
0.40410012006759644,
0.9138263463973999,
-0.2603788673877716,
0.24407407641410828,
-0.39817044138908386,
-0.12093105912208557,
-0.4549288749694824,
0.8314042687416077,
-0.3939480483531952,
-0.967179536819458,
0.7480056285858154,
-0.5876718759536743,
-0.5177244544029236,
0.24161578714847565,
0.5101355910301208,
-0.005944530013948679,
0.9702872633934021,
0.20969471335411072,
-0.5563501715660095,
0.6862449645996094,
-0.17227010428905487,
0.3470390737056732,
-0.9323151707649231,
-0.25857576727867126,
-0.27338436245918274,
-0.390226811170578,
-0.30973199009895325,
-0.4505092203617096,
0.44873353838920593,
-0.22260957956314087,
-0.265125036239624,
-0.030259519815444946,
-0.16777770221233368,
0.24606895446777344,
0.1719179004430771,
0.2547426223754883,
0.052729323506355286,
-0.08229267597198486,
-0.008260171860456467,
-0.16366510093212128,
-0.41982418298721313,
0.21917982399463654,
0.4434903860092163,
0.33899828791618347,
0.5293000936508179,
-0.014394890516996384,
0.45804303884506226,
-0.015198595821857452,
0.15494847297668457,
-0.9663771390914917,
0.6328063607215881,
-0.10820680856704712,
-0.03983081504702568,
-0.24395062029361725,
-0.9004411697387695,
-0.8072419762611389,
0.13152456283569336,
-0.2083713263273239,
-1.0269092321395874,
-0.00508770952001214,
-0.008433535695075989,
-0.06499531865119934,
0.3607361614704132,
-0.5680080652236938,
0.8716426491737366,
-0.46559008955955505,
-0.23646965622901917,
-0.33591052889823914,
-1.015857458114624,
0.07376088947057724,
0.032741110771894455,
0.134072408080101,
-0.20134888589382172,
0.5117025971412659,
0.6785317659378052,
-0.4454851746559143,
0.747353196144104,
-0.2763735353946686,
-0.06809606403112411,
0.3627937138080597,
0.1559094786643982,
0.8831290006637573,
-0.19890201091766357,
-0.16000208258628845,
0.21930548548698425,
-0.5867864489555359,
0.13122659921646118,
-0.8173762559890747,
0.5850948691368103,
-0.7279694676399231,
-0.12291380017995834,
-0.172879159450531,
-0.6091461777687073,
-0.3903273046016693,
0.10321763902902603,
0.0511474609375,
0.5447220802307129,
-0.5390998125076294,
0.0014291290426626801,
0.2604721188545227,
0.002049026545137167,
0.637888491153717,
0.10743684321641922,
-0.16521978378295898,
-0.8200713396072388,
0.9096426963806152,
0.06441634148359299,
0.24216988682746887,
0.40120935440063477,
0.3245678246021271,
-0.4617100954055786,
0.13661421835422516,
-0.3647770583629608,
0.150094136595726,
-0.572843074798584,
-0.35817766189575195,
-0.779252827167511,
-0.12525291740894318,
-0.2285301387310028,
-0.1675357073545456,
-0.4475475251674652,
-0.024349035695195198,
-0.4329484701156616,
-0.07829206436872482,
0.5938907265663147,
0.3941135108470917,
-0.01312677375972271,
0.305011510848999,
-0.8904998302459717,
0.3563385009765625,
0.6212440133094788,
0.27151477336883545,
0.24105925858020782,
-0.2074916809797287,
-0.1423587054014206,
0.12532086670398712,
-0.23681694269180298,
-0.961726725101471,
0.42649129033088684,
0.47244328260421753,
-0.05004297196865082,
0.7589513659477234,
0.10158738493919373,
0.7119144797325134,
-0.41776594519615173,
0.49291568994522095,
0.6558415293693542,
-1.1603398323059082,
0.36759546399116516,
-0.23223404586315155,
0.2786349356174469,
0.29562661051750183,
0.3897802233695984,
-0.710695207118988,
0.03808112069964409,
-0.48986026644706726,
-1.0384541749954224,
0.6753447651863098,
0.1445484161376953,
0.1723799705505371,
0.12064062058925629,
0.07978884130716324,
-0.3468901813030243,
0.31568652391433716,
-0.618554413318634,
-0.2209031581878662,
-0.24762524664402008,
-0.3161745071411133,
-0.0034784763120114803,
-0.1852184534072876,
-0.2011163830757141,
-0.23913873732089996,
0.40268808603286743,
-0.4594974219799042,
0.5437445640563965,
0.20068375766277313,
-0.007663564290851355,
-0.09503540396690369,
0.3431303799152374,
0.4315933585166931,
0.059767745435237885,
-0.4290015995502472,
0.26649266481399536,
0.4304387867450714,
-0.17315763235092163,
0.08608970046043396,
0.5150978565216064,
0.4372907876968384,
-0.01050968561321497,
0.04772227257490158,
1.2695709466934204,
0.22849462926387787,
-0.29515063762664795,
0.7345410585403442,
-0.12320446968078613,
0.08104556798934937,
-0.07985459268093109,
-0.579973578453064,
0.39530208706855774,
0.4985862970352173,
-0.009926902130246162,
-0.12359853833913803,
0.08213955909013748,
-0.491281121969223,
0.1397619992494583,
0.3120288848876953,
-0.5662241578102112,
-0.46960723400115967,
0.3488442301750183,
0.34630918502807617,
-0.3285592794418335,
0.8153793215751648,
-0.3584723472595215,
-1.0922459363937378,
0.4921567440032959,
0.6878283619880676,
0.9179794192314148,
-0.2999292016029358,
0.1350080966949463,
0.13980485498905182,
-0.43848392367362976,
0.48230811953544617,
0.34022319316864014,
-0.14985708892345428,
-0.65910404920578,
-0.49387988448143005,
-0.24931471049785614,
-0.5464786291122437,
-0.15738384425640106,
-0.3449521064758301,
0.0660332441329956,
-0.17914029955863953,
-0.41453981399536133,
-0.2175738513469696,
-0.06878430396318436,
-0.6449477076530457,
0.13837100565433502,
0.4545789062976837,
0.3037218451499939,
-0.7183108925819397,
0.4426233768463135,
0.2057875096797943,
-0.08371288329362869,
-0.9344585537910461,
-0.5178201794624329,
-0.03424667939543724,
-0.39044880867004395,
0.5279386639595032,
0.4273968040943146,
-0.4053903818130493,
-0.12612640857696533,
-0.14766547083854675,
-0.44097018241882324,
1.1124335527420044,
0.3467119038105011,
-0.6861247420310974,
-0.03988714888691902,
0.06720812618732452,
0.48094967007637024,
-0.5640556216239929,
0.6315715312957764,
0.029043275862932205,
0.4301326274871826,
0.3660423755645752,
-0.8525403738021851,
-0.00451837619766593,
-0.3903287351131439,
-0.2634503245353699,
0.4945560693740845,
-0.9921647906303406,
0.7509976029396057,
-0.03656627982854843,
-0.05447651818394661,
-0.4058516025543213,
0.9097583293914795,
0.018874969333410263,
0.5552557110786438,
0.880128026008606,
0.6118162274360657,
0.881496012210846,
-0.1092299148440361,
0.5874179601669312,
-0.43670254945755005,
0.39525169134140015,
1.01194429397583,
-0.5192417502403259,
0.9099593162536621,
0.17455928027629852,
-0.13596108555793762,
0.7255339622497559,
0.4557441771030426,
0.08844403922557831,
0.3322666883468628,
0.28068873286247253,
-0.5291413068771362,
-0.1387546956539154,
-0.4199638366699219,
-0.3193153142929077,
0.626909613609314,
0.301522433757782,
-0.24083971977233887,
-0.11729173362255096,
-0.0018289875006303191,
0.3548503816127777,
-0.4650620222091675,
-0.3065948486328125,
0.8980094194412231,
0.2736009955406189,
-0.22821028530597687,
0.42251870036125183,
-0.4532236158847809,
0.6540057063102722,
-0.7436034679412842,
0.10934481769800186,
0.01907671056687832,
0.017099780961871147,
-0.3366250693798065,
-0.43201881647109985,
0.15563847124576569,
-0.161666601896286,
-0.05635281652212143,
0.14988483488559723,
0.9777854681015015,
-0.7994542717933655,
-0.2754787504673004,
0.7382818460464478,
0.5609046220779419,
0.030499203130602837,
-0.31818240880966187,
-0.4876330494880676,
0.12797841429710388,
-0.33133360743522644,
-0.5267931222915649,
0.2774820029735565,
0.6358239054679871,
0.3044532239437103,
0.4417395293712616,
0.552081286907196,
0.004878779407590628,
-0.32622283697128296,
0.437349796295166,
1.0617603063583374,
-0.6305188536643982,
-0.7959866523742676,
-0.7681009769439697,
0.5221138000488281,
-0.09887541830539703,
-0.20135004818439484,
0.22240906953811646,
0.2972692847251892,
0.1693570464849472,
0.3051036596298218,
0.40248027443885803,
0.1303202211856842,
-0.007380436174571514,
-0.33991849422454834,
0.5769160985946655,
-0.4806368350982666,
-0.39926230907440186,
-0.6966119408607483,
-0.8044129014015198,
-0.2323814481496811,
0.6047286987304688,
-0.13375429809093475,
0.22237960994243622,
0.6039504408836365,
0.5897011160850525,
-0.11611481010913849,
0.3433366119861603,
0.1702152043581009,
0.30781662464141846,
0.5186160802841187,
1.0348608493804932,
0.7386667728424072,
-0.19306600093841553,
0.6009126901626587,
-0.31828901171684265,
0.02003621496260166,
-0.29791733622550964,
-1.2117626667022705,
-0.6477373242378235,
-0.527790904045105,
-0.3157501518726349,
-0.5947697758674622,
-0.10140622407197952,
0.9818052053451538,
0.7137168645858765,
-0.39646100997924805,
0.02268344536423683,
0.10078390687704086,
0.04562293365597725,
0.08429626375436783,
-0.2349245250225067,
0.7779732942581177,
0.20464225113391876,
-0.6269737482070923,
0.4894488453865051,
0.5136343836784363,
0.21623115241527557,
0.028028467670083046,
-0.33568307757377625,
-0.2291296124458313,
-0.03657611086964607,
0.8433217406272888,
0.19775539636611938,
-0.30973708629608154,
-0.594785213470459,
-0.08144302666187286,
-0.005652297753840685,
0.4338170886039734,
0.6857678294181824,
-0.6335073113441467,
0.6390896439552307,
0.46040451526641846,
0.6669140458106995,
0.7005966305732727,
0.1598273366689682,
0.3651590347290039,
-0.7954605221748352,
0.20586135983467102,
0.40238866209983826,
0.5464286208152771,
0.4241921007633209,
-0.3292241394519806,
0.24519649147987366,
0.3060436546802521,
-0.781495988368988,
-0.3127433657646179,
0.43914034962654114,
-1.464890956878662,
0.25874894857406616,
1.0530718564987183,
-0.5544394254684448,
-0.1915195882320404,
0.1249765083193779,
-0.403861403465271,
0.5472167730331421,
-0.6742122769355774,
0.5161547660827637,
0.4516521692276001,
-0.4182456433773041,
-0.2657056450843811,
0.046135950833559036,
0.04509492963552475,
0.2618003785610199,
-1.0165704488754272,
0.31029650568962097,
0.6932899951934814,
-0.26857712864875793,
0.26208436489105225,
0.7054998874664307,
0.12656868994235992,
-0.16288195550441742,
-0.09458578377962112,
-0.050816092640161514,
-0.33311906456947327,
-0.2126757949590683,
-0.34010472893714905,
0.3972930610179901,
-0.4673076570034027,
-0.04401692375540733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19280v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19280v1 | HuatuoGPT-Vision, Towards Injecting Medical Visual Knowledge into Multimodal LLMs at Scale | 2024-06-27T15:50:41 | 2024-06-27T15:50:41 | Junying Chen, Ruyi Ouyang, Anningzhe Gao, Shunian Chen, Guiming Hardy Chen, Xidong Wang, Ruifei Zhang, Zhenyang Cai, Ke Ji, Guangjun Yu, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The rapid development of multimodal large language models (MLLMs), such as
GPT-4V, has led to significant advancements. However, these models still face
challenges in medical multimodal capabilities due to limitations in the
quantity and quality of medical vision-text data, stemming from data privacy
concerns and high annotation costs. While pioneering approaches utilize
PubMed's large-scale, de-identified medical image-text pairs to address these
limitations, they still fall short due to inherent data noise. To tackle this,
we refined medical image-text pairs from PubMed and employed MLLMs (GPT-4V) in
an 'unblinded' capacity to denoise and reformat the data, resulting in the
creation of the PubMedVision dataset with 1.3 million medical VQA samples. Our
validation demonstrates that: (1) PubMedVision can significantly enhance the
medical multimodal capabilities of current MLLMs, showing significant
improvement in benchmarks including the MMMU Health & Medicine track; (2)
manual checks by medical experts and empirical results validate the superior
data quality of our dataset compared to other data construction methods. Using
PubMedVision, we train a 34B medical MLLM HuatuoGPT-Vision, which shows
superior performance in medical multimodal scenarios among open-source MLLMs. | [
-0.15406860411167145,
-0.3606642484664917,
0.7182114720344543,
-0.1242704764008522,
-0.6444982290267944,
0.041660014539957047,
-0.1740344911813736,
-0.5825527906417847,
0.01227865181863308,
0.6504530310630798,
-0.17155197262763977,
-0.5757727026939392,
-0.4699968993663788,
0.06994593143463135,
-0.07885467261075974,
0.8554205894470215,
-0.012234361842274666,
0.47735595703125,
-0.2892336845397949,
-0.4587273895740509,
-0.22970187664031982,
-0.4483555853366852,
-0.15267716348171234,
-0.2688753604888916,
0.6674067974090576,
0.2244054228067398,
0.7277547717094421,
0.6654138565063477,
0.7341337203979492,
0.26939213275909424,
0.1758977174758911,
0.43695068359375,
-0.16892851889133453,
0.07420904189348221,
0.12421505153179169,
-0.3556371033191681,
-0.37944087386131287,
-0.06337300688028336,
0.8727861046791077,
0.41595396399497986,
-0.07704265415668488,
-0.022888829931616783,
0.19889169931411743,
0.7838972806930542,
-0.25676605105400085,
0.30419403314590454,
-0.4654287099838257,
0.11199042201042175,
-0.18437105417251587,
-0.3820103704929352,
-0.22225874662399292,
-0.19093085825443268,
0.20509622991085052,
-0.5931357145309448,
0.04387366771697998,
0.14594846963882446,
1.0895155668258667,
0.4408717453479767,
-0.7239820957183838,
0.05858456715941429,
-0.47461432218551636,
0.680038332939148,
-0.7200027108192444,
0.7561067938804626,
0.1185954287648201,
0.41769060492515564,
-0.0750465840101242,
-0.9311693906784058,
-0.16842202842235565,
-0.12862184643745422,
0.10691745579242706,
0.2495853453874588,
0.01042797602713108,
0.2301866114139557,
0.12299437820911407,
0.3301171064376831,
-0.6588761806488037,
0.014824376441538334,
-0.509685754776001,
-0.2244264930486679,
0.3476191461086273,
0.18561585247516632,
0.23314784467220306,
-0.31716492772102356,
-0.6563453078269958,
0.018625132739543915,
-0.6836826801300049,
-0.19129876792430878,
-0.26143619418144226,
-0.07640326768159866,
-0.15129297971725464,
0.8905726075172424,
-0.4020160734653473,
0.7063632607460022,
-0.18080492317676544,
-0.4282110631465912,
0.6140019297599792,
-0.6775938272476196,
-0.5596228241920471,
-0.0860457643866539,
0.9118598699569702,
0.7841942310333252,
0.07835929840803146,
-0.10953523963689804,
0.06241094693541527,
-0.13119056820869446,
0.45298469066619873,
-0.7658988237380981,
-0.3217577636241913,
0.5882235169410706,
-0.4986836612224579,
-0.420672744512558,
-0.22296179831027985,
-0.879439651966095,
-0.8207423090934753,
-0.16430889070034027,
0.5417261123657227,
-0.6002857089042664,
-0.009075261652469635,
0.17307499051094055,
-0.23912854492664337,
0.3292100727558136,
0.4474466145038605,
-0.6219156384468079,
-0.28619036078453064,
0.30264630913734436,
0.7394781708717346,
-0.09607654064893723,
-0.17578956484794617,
-0.18645529448986053,
0.28332632780075073,
-0.48438265919685364,
0.8515818119049072,
-0.09600307792425156,
-0.07285911589860916,
-0.04028209671378136,
0.09269124269485474,
0.18326131999492645,
-0.5393983125686646,
0.4398592710494995,
-0.1926470249891281,
0.23133301734924316,
-0.24492697417736053,
-0.38293397426605225,
-0.2815384864807129,
0.46456849575042725,
-0.6603683829307556,
0.5955830216407776,
0.13827744126319885,
-0.743270218372345,
0.6706659197807312,
-0.25261953473091125,
-0.32768088579177856,
0.3869415521621704,
-0.5131494402885437,
-0.7359036803245544,
0.005116730462759733,
0.6100483536720276,
0.6644557118415833,
-0.34791964292526245,
0.3755030333995819,
-0.2475242018699646,
-0.07357337325811386,
0.18588902056217194,
-0.5121046304702759,
0.5357134938240051,
-0.022700725123286247,
-0.24879580736160278,
0.25848519802093506,
-0.7356253862380981,
0.026901358738541603,
0.15832239389419556,
-0.5468280911445618,
-0.3883863091468811,
-0.11258337646722794,
-0.006653338670730591,
0.1622919738292694,
0.15570315718650818,
-0.6482963562011719,
0.23272226750850677,
-0.4678649306297302,
0.5615168809890747,
0.5614515542984009,
0.1428481489419937,
0.3545977473258972,
-0.5629138350486755,
0.3240073025226593,
0.12758485972881317,
0.6243979334831238,
-0.1387293040752411,
-1.0553244352340698,
-0.4898594915866852,
-0.7434750199317932,
0.258743017911911,
0.28198957443237305,
-1.2487802505493164,
-0.16223742067813873,
-0.2508532702922821,
-0.6647560596466064,
-0.7605710625648499,
0.024114158004522324,
0.23822751641273499,
0.7534939646720886,
0.44198617339134216,
-0.20276503264904022,
-0.5253734588623047,
-1.010406732559204,
-0.036782022565603256,
-0.2216690182685852,
-0.18928086757659912,
0.5924652218818665,
0.2117462158203125,
-0.6756114363670349,
0.4735189974308014,
-0.22576484084129333,
-0.5542551279067993,
0.013779190368950367,
-0.10182572901248932,
0.1899120956659317,
0.31955739855766296,
0.3830755650997162,
-0.9499617218971252,
-0.26542943716049194,
0.1947067379951477,
-0.9215423464775085,
-0.057481199502944946,
-0.1627998650074005,
0.07870611548423767,
0.16879931092262268,
0.2828429937362671,
-0.4158259332180023,
0.42965930700302124,
0.8347530961036682,
-0.3366708755493164,
0.6893727779388428,
-0.5569878816604614,
0.5711031556129456,
-1.0244330167770386,
-0.12844617664813995,
0.034326694905757904,
-0.4062540829181671,
-0.6110934615135193,
-0.0646761804819107,
0.4385800063610077,
0.11707887798547745,
-0.5379325747489929,
0.4817882478237152,
-0.48960867524147034,
0.08062398433685303,
0.16077740490436554,
-0.11821537464857101,
0.35409510135650635,
0.3211469054222107,
0.05518004298210144,
0.5418635010719299,
0.5621492266654968,
-0.32806485891342163,
0.6009951829910278,
0.3173377811908722,
-0.49199774861335754,
0.6259465217590332,
-0.6995838284492493,
-0.21658876538276672,
-0.12300075590610504,
0.03679768741130829,
-1.0565117597579956,
-0.47637441754341125,
0.21423284709453583,
-0.4193322956562042,
0.1847929209470749,
-0.20505225658416748,
-0.5430689454078674,
-0.35259267687797546,
-0.5967332720756531,
0.5395243763923645,
0.5563081502914429,
-0.5306305289268494,
0.6798907518386841,
0.46981966495513916,
-0.058978594839572906,
-0.4246330261230469,
-0.8800475001335144,
0.27808770537376404,
-0.2582850754261017,
-0.33336082100868225,
0.31644436717033386,
0.16532865166664124,
-0.035312991589307785,
-0.10515265166759491,
0.10254938155412674,
-0.19401386380195618,
-0.49272748827934265,
0.47897785902023315,
0.5721682906150818,
-0.2149939239025116,
0.42341750860214233,
0.003103843191638589,
0.19999384880065918,
-0.13829460740089417,
-0.1261444091796875,
0.2699569761753082,
-0.08215007930994034,
-0.491627961397171,
-0.4009106159210205,
0.11381532996892929,
0.8758562207221985,
-0.2372770607471466,
0.35463806986808777,
0.6226665377616882,
-0.31285643577575684,
0.3687645494937897,
-0.7933198809623718,
-0.06005621328949928,
-0.4168710708618164,
0.4398910105228424,
-0.0487675778567791,
-0.8172955513000488,
0.0906236320734024,
-0.0691877007484436,
0.07922220975160599,
0.31729716062545776,
0.8599412441253662,
-0.4470713436603546,
0.8789187669754028,
0.2354602813720703,
0.3439978063106537,
0.3587445020675659,
-0.10031284391880035,
-0.18681953847408295,
-1.0121403932571411,
-0.6852685213088989,
-0.153577983379364,
-0.04072332754731178,
-0.5975711941719055,
-0.8691821098327637,
0.7093136310577393,
-0.37533071637153625,
-0.11136586964130402,
0.05988876894116402,
-0.7644515633583069,
0.07091351598501205,
0.6520806550979614,
0.5937632918357849,
0.4448396861553192,
0.09086886048316956,
-0.434324711561203,
-0.2559177279472351,
-0.8171430826187134,
-0.27875766158103943,
1.4798431396484375,
0.4651423692703247,
0.8376569151878357,
-0.07138245552778244,
0.6071427464485168,
0.09006252139806747,
0.2506144344806671,
-0.8207321763038635,
0.3841114342212677,
-0.1477842479944229,
-0.5049596428871155,
-0.18005824089050293,
-0.3825848698616028,
-0.9683995246887207,
0.3380449712276459,
-0.640283465385437,
-0.34372612833976746,
0.31787732243537903,
0.21062099933624268,
-0.41427433490753174,
0.35256287455558777,
-0.7987313270568848,
0.7068338990211487,
-0.33929672837257385,
-0.3593681752681732,
0.03815356269478798,
-0.6430052518844604,
0.2576274871826172,
-0.3754611313343048,
0.27643924951553345,
0.043569449335336685,
-0.29923608899116516,
0.5878568887710571,
-0.2471724897623062,
0.7624260783195496,
-0.02784198708832264,
-0.13243260979652405,
0.04151726886630058,
-0.3306494653224945,
0.1921035647392273,
0.1359657645225525,
0.4270886182785034,
0.6011978387832642,
0.14723296463489532,
-0.31718090176582336,
-0.19382432103157043,
0.4317966401576996,
-0.5823360085487366,
-0.31477662920951843,
-0.3352985382080078,
-0.6114049553871155,
-0.34029319882392883,
0.3049790561199188,
0.28639987111091614,
0.7613331079483032,
-0.00540732778608799,
0.47878897190093994,
0.5461524128913879,
-0.5508267283439636,
0.1757737249135971,
0.14289836585521698,
-0.38051271438598633,
-0.8489351868629456,
0.6691878437995911,
0.046760350465774536,
0.2197187840938568,
0.27308276295661926,
0.21526964008808136,
-0.5419825315475464,
-0.7386865615844727,
-0.5414392352104187,
0.3597469627857208,
-0.47942984104156494,
-0.3217020034790039,
-0.5486761927604675,
-0.16517457365989685,
-0.3826792538166046,
-0.03262960910797119,
-0.3377012610435486,
-0.18363718688488007,
-0.014548871666193008,
0.3368373513221741,
0.3473595976829529,
0.5127009749412537,
0.00881579052656889,
0.10952571034431458,
-1.0375746488571167,
0.7758422493934631,
0.46484237909317017,
0.4268965423107147,
-0.44437119364738464,
-0.4536683261394501,
-0.3005460500717163,
0.0468105673789978,
-0.011417044326663017,
-0.9146011471748352,
0.4908691942691803,
0.10080939531326294,
0.5232808589935303,
0.44297805428504944,
-0.14055591821670532,
0.7014827728271484,
-0.8345915675163269,
0.7864170670509338,
0.35966426134109497,
-0.3142114281654358,
0.4785226285457611,
-0.27668285369873047,
0.6059100031852722,
0.2640341818332672,
0.1794804334640503,
-0.2480120062828064,
-0.6168040037155151,
-0.4083375036716461,
-0.6391609907150269,
0.07510140538215637,
0.20279914140701294,
-0.17069272696971893,
0.2646576464176178,
0.2742868959903717,
0.07784988731145859,
0.40384501218795776,
-0.5870305895805359,
-0.021219728514552116,
-0.3617725074291229,
-0.3196600675582886,
-0.22290167212486267,
-0.30847063660621643,
-0.16726504266262054,
-0.4652503430843353,
0.29284119606018066,
-0.12476890534162521,
0.4787934422492981,
0.5293498635292053,
0.14563235640525818,
0.22491857409477234,
0.3458402156829834,
0.3885822892189026,
0.4162314534187317,
-0.16822800040245056,
0.3358283042907715,
-0.12696465849876404,
-0.8615877628326416,
0.10736644268035889,
0.1287609189748764,
0.07092726975679398,
0.17681576311588287,
0.44380706548690796,
0.6296932101249695,
0.08637392520904541,
-0.9088216423988342,
0.5396735668182373,
-0.08596353232860565,
-0.5117360949516296,
0.1839246153831482,
-0.30023524165153503,
0.01758209988474846,
0.6364131569862366,
0.2818346321582794,
0.07875026762485504,
0.3607947528362274,
-0.2674466371536255,
0.41281625628471375,
0.4775172472000122,
-0.48305031657218933,
-0.049847397953271866,
0.8467411994934082,
0.055136483162641525,
0.13958188891410828,
0.4826829731464386,
0.3486063480377197,
-0.2944098114967346,
0.44657450914382935,
0.244291752576828,
0.4682876169681549,
-0.21852914988994598,
0.3240963816642761,
0.2747363746166229,
0.42990580201148987,
-0.12451783567667007,
0.4188809394836426,
0.057962965220212936,
-0.7067184448242188,
-0.5592851042747498,
-0.4807392656803131,
-0.414903849363327,
0.21035093069076538,
-0.4419538080692291,
0.20067885518074036,
-0.28995636105537415,
-0.404790997505188,
0.28049200773239136,
-0.3156614601612091,
-0.5138200521469116,
0.3611738085746765,
0.1544663906097412,
0.2862403690814972,
-0.5708328485488892,
1.0787842273712158,
0.8719615340232849,
-0.28391268849372864,
-0.6851648688316345,
-0.24615521728992462,
0.07951254397630692,
-1.0418379306793213,
0.3693806231021881,
0.10100414603948593,
0.18527953326702118,
-0.07895394414663315,
-0.4678829312324524,
-0.2483583688735962,
1.0434443950653076,
0.21145349740982056,
-0.7873450517654419,
-0.20294493436813354,
0.30413293838500977,
0.612640380859375,
-0.13801415264606476,
-0.26657834649086,
0.18086887896060944,
0.33912771940231323,
0.14145596325397491,
-1.0536611080169678,
-0.005274753551930189,
-0.03940073400735855,
-0.1278863400220871,
0.12799793481826782,
-0.4473085403442383,
0.7377240061759949,
-0.5993524193763733,
0.013888881541788578,
-0.12041085958480835,
0.04710257425904274,
0.25208160281181335,
0.20599974691867828,
0.38970625400543213,
0.4417312741279602,
0.5134097337722778,
-0.09996446222066879,
0.9732651710510254,
-0.0993868038058281,
0.3488903343677521,
0.9124691486358643,
-0.10020192712545395,
0.688973069190979,
0.8519614338874817,
-0.09290165454149246,
0.1422199159860611,
0.42709189653396606,
-0.31502917408943176,
0.6892180442810059,
-0.3261823058128357,
-0.2791981101036072,
-0.2788565158843994,
-0.14391393959522247,
-0.4344387650489807,
0.5565696954727173,
0.3094402253627777,
-0.5336586833000183,
-0.1369381695985794,
0.4652155041694641,
-0.2795903980731964,
-0.2622144818305969,
-0.34872326254844666,
0.8842567205429077,
0.06226889044046402,
-0.18618811666965485,
0.8277657628059387,
-0.34553250670433044,
0.6736682057380676,
-0.3853490352630615,
-0.1956644356250763,
-0.027866829186677933,
0.10211566835641861,
-0.08582494407892227,
-1.009980320930481,
0.20068958401679993,
-0.16888317465782166,
0.3265698254108429,
0.018543755635619164,
0.7885575294494629,
-0.5229005813598633,
-0.2648864984512329,
0.016721084713935852,
0.5689681172370911,
0.1712271124124527,
-0.25119540095329285,
-0.6009692549705505,
-0.08541542291641235,
0.1758316159248352,
0.001492018811404705,
0.20630182325839996,
0.5519580841064453,
0.09926383942365646,
0.7934621572494507,
0.48565924167633057,
0.39392250776290894,
-0.007723630405962467,
0.04707471281290054,
0.9314060807228088,
-0.5029373168945312,
-0.18469472229480743,
-0.9283961653709412,
0.48278895020484924,
-0.03797735646367073,
-0.007022417150437832,
0.7326444387435913,
0.6169425845146179,
0.39048653841018677,
-0.15492109954357147,
0.5698192119598389,
0.20857657492160797,
0.2812403738498688,
-0.5713337063789368,
0.9416226744651794,
-0.9965463876724243,
-0.09949563443660736,
-0.2246202528476715,
-0.2880862057209015,
-0.6585870385169983,
0.37725865840911865,
0.010734599083662033,
-0.22484858334064484,
0.7889342308044434,
0.6201820969581604,
0.12247251719236374,
-0.41743364930152893,
0.7628797888755798,
0.2563704252243042,
0.17559240758419037,
0.6326497793197632,
0.7097299695014954,
-0.42102667689323425,
0.6510816812515259,
-0.2924033999443054,
-0.4922626316547394,
-0.3031753897666931,
-0.5550483465194702,
-0.9578514695167542,
-0.6728724241256714,
-0.3179279565811157,
-0.37180936336517334,
-0.034078799188137054,
0.49683454632759094,
0.7473709583282471,
-0.41967278718948364,
0.29613083600997925,
0.3131503760814667,
-0.13600267469882965,
-0.17378145456314087,
-0.12056566029787064,
0.4260181486606598,
-0.12986402213573456,
-0.4861307144165039,
0.11389860510826111,
0.7249528765678406,
0.35644209384918213,
-0.22561798989772797,
-0.014938201755285263,
-0.11408087611198425,
-0.05101517587900162,
0.8543292284011841,
0.021496253088116646,
-0.7968308329582214,
-0.19143395125865936,
0.0442054457962513,
-0.3752460181713104,
0.5955953598022461,
0.41873103380203247,
-0.777595579624176,
0.9230161309242249,
0.20269165933132172,
0.6191733479499817,
0.3900347054004669,
-0.10301358252763748,
0.2962685823440552,
-0.5703654289245605,
0.321184366941452,
0.3328564465045929,
0.5168859362602234,
0.3726470470428467,
-0.32816317677497864,
0.3613314628601074,
0.20225068926811218,
-0.7095175385475159,
-0.7878440022468567,
0.0439855232834816,
-1.2990479469299316,
-0.28936707973480225,
1.440017580986023,
-0.007415715605020523,
-0.23589569330215454,
-0.37583595514297485,
-0.6692361235618591,
0.25385963916778564,
-0.18198874592781067,
0.6983945369720459,
0.34579232335090637,
-0.15117722749710083,
-0.5087645053863525,
-0.850651204586029,
0.5826941728591919,
0.04795793816447258,
-0.9789101481437683,
-0.1943873167037964,
0.6474097967147827,
0.29946425557136536,
0.02153932675719261,
0.78998202085495,
-0.5914300084114075,
0.3041667342185974,
-0.008434007875621319,
0.26389455795288086,
-0.10718868672847748,
-0.20802050828933716,
-0.3265961706638336,
0.23579394817352295,
0.02859259769320488,
-0.6385409832000732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01449v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01449v2 | ColPali: Efficient Document Retrieval with Vision Language Models | 2024-06-27T15:45:29 | 2024-07-02T13:02:58 | Manuel Faysse, Hugues Sibille, Tony Wu, Bilel Omrani, Gautier Viaud, Céline Hudelot, Pierre Colombo | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CV | Documents are visually rich structures that convey information through text,
as well as tables, figures, page layouts, or fonts. While modern document
retrieval systems exhibit strong performance on query-to-text matching, they
struggle to exploit visual cues efficiently, hindering their performance on
practical document retrieval applications such as Retrieval Augmented
Generation. To benchmark current systems on visually rich document retrieval,
we introduce the Visual Document Retrieval Benchmark ViDoRe, composed of
various page-level retrieving tasks spanning multiple domains, languages, and
settings. The inherent shortcomings of modern systems motivate the introduction
of a new retrieval model architecture, ColPali, which leverages the document
understanding capabilities of recent Vision Language Models to produce
high-quality contextualized embeddings solely from images of document pages.
Combined with a late interaction matching mechanism, ColPali largely
outperforms modern document retrieval pipelines while being drastically faster
and end-to-end trainable. | [
-0.20016644895076752,
-0.45460057258605957,
0.42188015580177307,
0.3013436794281006,
-0.2149537205696106,
0.0037065783981233835,
0.018368957564234734,
-0.5769014954566956,
-0.030889000743627548,
0.4588949978351593,
-0.23713771998882294,
-0.48051178455352783,
-0.33573898673057556,
-0.08614005148410797,
-0.526207685470581,
0.3830741345882416,
-0.05350258946418762,
0.2065611183643341,
-0.5097780823707581,
-0.17753981053829193,
-0.4342955946922302,
-0.014119895175099373,
-0.3812257647514343,
-0.060238681733608246,
0.5447210073471069,
0.37040984630584717,
0.5732318758964539,
0.5843111872673035,
0.9980958104133606,
0.35000744462013245,
0.0227794349193573,
0.2094954550266266,
-0.6088495254516602,
0.2988068163394928,
-0.20767252147197723,
-0.6764583587646484,
-0.18737190961837769,
0.14342308044433594,
0.8167333006858826,
0.6226938962936401,
-0.07173675298690796,
-0.09751306474208832,
0.036480724811553955,
0.5964368581771851,
-1.3176933526992798,
0.26127591729164124,
-0.5666060447692871,
0.38671961426734924,
-0.34426361322402954,
-0.4822085499763489,
-0.7091580033302307,
-0.39062759280204773,
0.14274969696998596,
-0.822638213634491,
0.4661828875541687,
0.2575414180755615,
0.9662818908691406,
-0.07267250865697861,
-0.22753387689590454,
-0.23456232249736786,
-0.2723371088504791,
0.585918128490448,
-0.07600872963666916,
0.8594396114349365,
0.295409232378006,
0.5890361666679382,
-0.06794808804988861,
-1.1916829347610474,
-0.5123821496963501,
-0.1342778205871582,
-0.13828696310520172,
0.2985476553440094,
-0.2789915204048157,
-0.16913726925849915,
0.2742880582809448,
0.570754885673523,
-0.6017886400222778,
-0.19292353093624115,
-0.18701677024364471,
-0.18257881700992584,
0.2126769870519638,
0.02607719786465168,
0.36209046840667725,
-0.133833646774292,
-0.5268158316612244,
-0.5043289065361023,
-0.5069048404693604,
-0.16776172816753387,
0.31527644395828247,
-0.07029292732477188,
0.2270798683166504,
0.6002337336540222,
-0.43135586380958557,
1.1463701725006104,
-0.3690429627895355,
-0.039900459349155426,
0.267487108707428,
-0.436898410320282,
-0.4296097159385681,
-0.18262237310409546,
0.6267516016960144,
0.5612347722053528,
0.051521286368370056,
-0.22479413449764252,
-0.2755220830440521,
-0.07035436481237411,
0.33544108271598816,
-0.796117901802063,
-0.14648683369159698,
-0.35506582260131836,
-0.499887615442276,
-0.3087519705295563,
0.0579863041639328,
-0.9253495335578918,
-0.539482057094574,
-0.10515905916690826,
0.39780735969543457,
-0.768785297870636,
0.3459717333316803,
-0.17814745008945465,
-0.5453341007232666,
0.44279026985168457,
0.8241091370582581,
-0.9225826263427734,
0.31641966104507446,
0.7494483590126038,
1.0451385974884033,
-0.09251059591770172,
-0.3590187132358551,
-1.0925514698028564,
0.1938554346561432,
-0.4789969325065613,
0.9895198941230774,
-0.8535240292549133,
-0.4440036118030548,
0.22081732749938965,
0.029028872027993202,
-0.14211690425872803,
-0.5700852870941162,
0.6621609330177307,
-0.6772607564926147,
0.22472594678401947,
-0.4518195390701294,
-0.5232217907905579,
-0.13291536271572113,
0.19780603051185608,
-0.7124364972114563,
0.7038986682891846,
0.22712048888206482,
-0.9075219035148621,
0.5790976881980896,
-0.2057732194662094,
-0.22294370830059052,
0.474181592464447,
-0.449668288230896,
-0.09523480385541916,
0.16539360582828522,
-0.11027651280164719,
0.35414257645606995,
-0.48619982600212097,
-0.18579310178756714,
-0.2186572551727295,
-0.5500510334968567,
-0.27305400371551514,
-0.453535258769989,
0.3882288336753845,
0.4393065571784973,
0.10316711664199829,
-0.12427613139152527,
-0.8192458152770996,
-0.001814267598092556,
0.10355843603610992,
-0.489959716796875,
-0.5422754287719727,
-0.031965550035238266,
0.32781538367271423,
-0.04449855163693428,
0.5484352707862854,
-0.4278745949268341,
0.26746004819869995,
-0.10198134928941727,
0.24892351031303406,
0.33108335733413696,
-0.29856550693511963,
0.5434946417808533,
-0.032201215624809265,
0.31030163168907166,
-0.000429777690442279,
0.20963379740715027,
-0.4938201606273651,
-0.44062426686286926,
-0.5280226469039917,
-0.38136258721351624,
0.25252023339271545,
0.6239393949508667,
-0.905343234539032,
-0.23919720947742462,
-0.5050070881843567,
-0.5374805331230164,
-0.5325924158096313,
0.2194538563489914,
0.5983710289001465,
0.7229691743850708,
0.11048390716314316,
-0.8031262159347534,
-0.018289003521203995,
-1.126340389251709,
-0.2162223905324936,
-0.007400784641504288,
0.11998042464256287,
0.7093197703361511,
0.40395745635032654,
0.07823213189840317,
0.5904935002326965,
-0.5341054201126099,
-0.19879783689975739,
0.08784136921167374,
0.25152862071990967,
-0.005453916732221842,
0.31538161635398865,
0.5872146487236023,
-1.33522367477417,
-0.6351463198661804,
0.36572641134262085,
-1.039914846420288,
-0.036383096128702164,
0.1281510293483734,
-0.2975856065750122,
0.10395914316177368,
0.6016565561294556,
-0.517022967338562,
0.5883556604385376,
0.17041738331317902,
-0.4794470965862274,
0.20398105680942535,
-0.47198286652565,
0.467890202999115,
-0.8583897948265076,
0.3948858082294464,
0.14303027093410492,
-0.23479275405406952,
-0.4788130223751068,
0.47222673892974854,
0.5221202373504639,
-0.3534926176071167,
-0.5732813477516174,
0.5427919626235962,
-0.7304107546806335,
-0.5227356553077698,
-0.06648693233728409,
0.5750431418418884,
0.3077544569969177,
0.2366439253091812,
0.01425282470881939,
1.0397623777389526,
0.6063573956489563,
-0.15550905466079712,
0.3679845929145813,
0.5289550423622131,
-0.5571421384811401,
1.0289109945297241,
-0.4924469292163849,
-0.22350870072841644,
-0.308356910943985,
0.02527988702058792,
-0.8511290550231934,
-0.1542966365814209,
0.08567161858081818,
-0.25529205799102783,
0.4920695126056671,
-0.203863725066185,
-0.681058943271637,
-0.30187535285949707,
-0.36070626974105835,
0.38146066665649414,
0.19231347739696503,
-0.7037360072135925,
0.5838856101036072,
0.15223734080791473,
-0.0018099546432495117,
-0.8037979602813721,
-0.4783296287059784,
0.3119566738605499,
0.17402830719947815,
-0.756125271320343,
0.574261486530304,
0.11847429722547531,
-0.15170492231845856,
-0.04313306882977486,
-0.05938425660133362,
-0.201148122549057,
-0.009844860062003136,
0.11527937650680542,
0.21943986415863037,
-0.045075271278619766,
0.09787869453430176,
-0.15716081857681274,
0.028858698904514313,
-0.41953539848327637,
-0.2567059397697449,
0.6250211000442505,
-0.19394414126873016,
-0.32171186804771423,
-0.2592538595199585,
0.553076446056366,
0.7028648257255554,
-0.7663115859031677,
0.6457576751708984,
0.6664020419120789,
-0.3161434531211853,
0.05017201974987984,
-0.7465313076972961,
0.3088088929653168,
-0.4425002336502075,
0.3761998116970062,
-0.7510223388671875,
-0.5917178988456726,
0.47446852922439575,
-0.04145263880491257,
-0.21066679060459137,
0.19793985784053802,
0.20452679693698883,
0.05112640559673309,
0.7478439211845398,
0.7369989156723022,
-0.03195212408900261,
0.8109159469604492,
-0.45631277561187744,
-0.02403244376182556,
-0.8610349297523499,
-0.8359638452529907,
-0.6341786980628967,
-0.053503651171922684,
-0.7113776803016663,
-0.5407301187515259,
0.12794989347457886,
0.45287707448005676,
0.05684923753142357,
0.55124831199646,
-0.5454595685005188,
0.4442231357097626,
0.9552339315414429,
0.10729171335697174,
0.31369510293006897,
0.17672176659107208,
-0.3947139084339142,
0.1362430304288864,
-0.7547226548194885,
-0.3404023051261902,
0.7135565876960754,
-0.14502619206905365,
0.8074396252632141,
0.14570163190364838,
0.5990651249885559,
0.23721826076507568,
0.10851934552192688,
-0.587475061416626,
0.6343559622764587,
-0.35473474860191345,
-0.04169957712292671,
0.012302533723413944,
-0.4659367501735687,
-0.9629876017570496,
0.6253914833068848,
-0.3963617980480194,
-0.8878980278968811,
0.7782589793205261,
-0.13349688053131104,
0.0676368996500969,
0.13031411170959473,
-0.8837043642997742,
1.163481593132019,
0.02775261364877224,
-0.9995939135551453,
-0.35811370611190796,
-0.5124488472938538,
0.00503946840763092,
0.027482882142066956,
-0.12790293991565704,
0.030018731951713562,
-0.17552688717842102,
0.3298264145851135,
-0.41745349764823914,
0.37122538685798645,
-0.009546589106321335,
0.08678476512432098,
0.21851502358913422,
0.22082854807376862,
0.44003307819366455,
-0.05622096732258797,
-0.30678558349609375,
-0.08995255827903748,
-0.01848180964589119,
-0.6449410319328308,
-0.7031087875366211,
0.9834887385368347,
-0.4859902560710907,
-0.5423126816749573,
-0.47316643595695496,
-0.5026528835296631,
0.07205172628164291,
0.5389728546142578,
0.31853288412094116,
0.7522321343421936,
-0.35864418745040894,
0.21442176401615143,
0.7620537281036377,
-0.24570299685001373,
0.6018747091293335,
0.6406074166297913,
-0.043255750089883804,
-0.30608493089675903,
1.0393444299697876,
-0.09874182939529419,
0.05441702529788017,
0.8218527436256409,
-0.26975682377815247,
-0.23180167376995087,
-0.5569906830787659,
-0.2726113498210907,
0.09886568784713745,
-0.9566088914871216,
-0.19854170083999634,
-0.6086374521255493,
-0.05745185539126396,
-0.3476896584033966,
-0.2775975167751312,
-0.20915675163269043,
-0.10577014088630676,
-0.2810557186603546,
0.34551724791526794,
-0.08399607241153717,
0.538856565952301,
0.10295332968235016,
0.035326723009347916,
-0.7441679239273071,
0.3057343661785126,
0.5622629523277283,
0.6477755308151245,
-0.059402793645858765,
-0.21379192173480988,
-0.20746703445911407,
-0.4673672318458557,
-0.4133714735507965,
-0.8817353248596191,
0.5621509552001953,
0.23677313327789307,
0.760040819644928,
0.3366752862930298,
-0.30275487899780273,
0.5721738934516907,
-0.6070382595062256,
0.4448956549167633,
0.3397451639175415,
-0.6631073355674744,
0.8804614543914795,
-0.354590505361557,
0.2674916684627533,
0.787024736404419,
0.48811402916908264,
-0.33047860860824585,
-0.062388382852077484,
-0.36786994338035583,
-0.7580010890960693,
0.49228349328041077,
0.20206411182880402,
-0.16403773427009583,
-0.19077610969543457,
0.39412668347358704,
-0.06660982966423035,
0.36352795362472534,
-0.32395103573799133,
0.29864826798439026,
-0.24940508604049683,
-0.21371249854564667,
0.03612416982650757,
-0.28088778257369995,
-0.052446503192186356,
-0.07024437934160233,
0.2580018937587738,
-0.36647263169288635,
0.31064867973327637,
0.4208763837814331,
-0.4419020414352417,
0.009095286019146442,
0.05265000835061073,
0.4907993972301483,
0.5904417037963867,
-0.4121738374233246,
0.10133962333202362,
-0.11171504110097885,
-0.5223925709724426,
-0.17762553691864014,
0.36047670245170593,
-0.197553813457489,
-0.094676673412323,
0.5355885624885559,
1.0520761013031006,
0.23381027579307556,
-0.766034722328186,
0.9289398789405823,
-0.3194563388824463,
0.08059342950582504,
-0.1367604285478592,
0.24573250114917755,
-0.29307642579078674,
0.3965180218219757,
0.4116103947162628,
0.17167381942272186,
0.4813850522041321,
-0.8791850209236145,
0.272493451833725,
0.6317873001098633,
-0.6288763880729675,
0.09442257881164551,
0.8817121386528015,
0.25783950090408325,
-0.41995564103126526,
0.7474930882453918,
0.011645429767668247,
-0.10286635160446167,
0.2728981077671051,
0.3554527163505554,
0.6125543713569641,
0.10960809141397476,
0.32676729559898376,
0.14186128973960876,
-0.018679296597838402,
-0.15769292414188385,
0.3037858307361603,
-0.4713517725467682,
-0.5236548185348511,
-0.14318761229515076,
-0.785569429397583,
-0.3439171612262726,
-0.36276426911354065,
-0.621437668800354,
0.26423168182373047,
-0.24893875420093536,
0.027900932356715202,
0.11185289174318314,
0.19557476043701172,
-0.7136850953102112,
0.32774630188941956,
0.26170721650123596,
1.3877005577087402,
-0.6091217398643494,
0.7624722123146057,
0.6140276193618774,
-0.7143216133117676,
-0.14772896468639374,
-0.21941691637039185,
-0.29194045066833496,
-0.8848603963851929,
0.7662869691848755,
0.15459845960140228,
-0.19382967054843903,
0.04273267835378647,
-0.413798451423645,
-0.6129409074783325,
1.379355788230896,
0.38869813084602356,
-0.716446042060852,
-0.033303581178188324,
-0.1051822081208229,
0.6391800045967102,
-0.3255325257778168,
0.6347658634185791,
0.27933499217033386,
0.3804076313972473,
0.14795251190662384,
-0.648307740688324,
-0.062376968562603,
-0.5808078646659851,
0.3531910181045532,
0.042766958475112915,
-0.9805471897125244,
0.6605710983276367,
0.02714131772518158,
-0.271812379360199,
0.3269977867603302,
0.6376699209213257,
0.015290096402168274,
0.4240020215511322,
0.3136028051376343,
0.9017490744590759,
0.8770021796226501,
-0.23941262066364288,
1.5699695348739624,
-0.5170385837554932,
0.038369204849004745,
0.8354320526123047,
-0.3030296862125397,
1.0764009952545166,
0.3792790174484253,
0.2598457336425781,
0.3232058882713318,
0.4391469657421112,
-0.2662602365016937,
0.8213608860969543,
0.05603383108973503,
-0.5391996502876282,
-0.33439961075782776,
-0.5261194109916687,
-0.21085914969444275,
0.5060669183731079,
0.025635063648223877,
-0.5023040771484375,
-0.2865963578224182,
-0.08367457985877991,
-0.5778137445449829,
0.2946261763572693,
-0.16182754933834076,
0.6304106712341309,
-0.024223148822784424,
-0.7075964212417603,
0.42310830950737,
-0.21552661061286926,
0.3315828740596771,
-0.3669694662094116,
-0.19856959581375122,
-0.4862745702266693,
0.04943623021245003,
-0.051872652024030685,
-0.7119894623756409,
-0.1874908059835434,
-0.22445423901081085,
-0.2713015377521515,
-0.21204379200935364,
0.9493570327758789,
-0.37064892053604126,
-0.5063623785972595,
0.38025668263435364,
0.5230734944343567,
0.007447777781635523,
0.03887341544032097,
-0.47875601053237915,
0.11054036021232605,
-0.21892741322517395,
-0.1373668611049652,
0.47449442744255066,
0.5449508428573608,
-0.18071338534355164,
0.8861697912216187,
0.4335216283798218,
-0.07147321105003357,
-0.004929110407829285,
0.2509126365184784,
0.9145180583000183,
-0.6226736307144165,
-0.3627132475376129,
-0.44499272108078003,
0.11829089373350143,
-0.38538283109664917,
-0.19522923231124878,
0.7200508117675781,
1.0199512243270874,
0.7345035076141357,
-0.05995537340641022,
0.49411576986312866,
0.15124070644378662,
-0.08314858376979828,
-0.4409008026123047,
0.8373236656188965,
-0.8967587947845459,
-0.02676348015666008,
-0.32540231943130493,
-1.1982953548431396,
-0.30805546045303345,
0.5498682260513306,
-0.09491460770368576,
-0.17398717999458313,
0.6161836981773376,
0.8474871516227722,
-0.25138163566589355,
-0.08324768394231796,
0.4714493453502655,
-0.03326253592967987,
0.07257332652807236,
0.5043894052505493,
0.7269421219825745,
-0.6481877565383911,
0.6384540796279907,
-0.06075723096728325,
-0.22039276361465454,
-0.3745248019695282,
-0.6242954730987549,
-0.5808095335960388,
-0.6423748731613159,
-0.28671756386756897,
-0.05571099743247032,
0.3912214934825897,
0.19232024252414703,
0.7329038977622986,
-0.4432510733604431,
-0.07199060916900635,
-0.3220336437225342,
0.10300689190626144,
0.019885288551449776,
-0.21933530271053314,
0.2617219090461731,
-0.40200042724609375,
-0.9072219729423523,
0.5268486142158508,
0.6085276007652283,
0.07901520282030106,
-0.031476717442274094,
0.05836273729801178,
-0.31471753120422363,
-0.1363406926393509,
0.6011777520179749,
0.28413039445877075,
-0.33294975757598877,
-0.14777995645999908,
0.0437798872590065,
-0.4527393579483032,
0.24408914148807526,
0.6978931427001953,
-0.8778164386749268,
0.7280769348144531,
1.0500736236572266,
0.4641161859035492,
0.8314110636711121,
-0.09474878758192062,
0.5589827299118042,
-0.36186808347702026,
0.25868162512779236,
-0.0298573300242424,
0.6390724182128906,
0.5588202476501465,
-0.17432548105716705,
0.7479280233383179,
0.5447654128074646,
-0.24232465028762817,
-0.6661575436592102,
0.056110966950654984,
-1.1601299047470093,
-0.2514713406562805,
0.617577075958252,
-0.30715757608413696,
-0.6371613144874573,
0.3732679486274719,
-0.13895109295845032,
0.2688460946083069,
-0.2644195854663849,
0.5750913023948669,
0.38879263401031494,
0.2627260684967041,
-0.42434757947921753,
-0.6047771573066711,
0.23446474969387054,
0.3750289976596832,
-0.599855363368988,
-0.2592983841896057,
0.663037896156311,
-0.04465685039758682,
0.4301226735115051,
0.720760703086853,
-0.18630211055278778,
0.5027338266372681,
0.36389511823654175,
0.08641491830348969,
-0.014048732817173004,
-0.6032361388206482,
0.04627106338739395,
0.5191499590873718,
-0.09164446592330933,
-0.11530624330043793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19276v1 | VERISCORE: Evaluating the factuality of verifiable claims in long-form text generation | 2024-06-27T15:43:18 | 2024-06-27T15:43:18 | Yixiao Song, Yekyung Kim, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing metrics for evaluating the factuality of long-form text, such as
FACTSCORE (Min et al., 2023) and SAFE (Wei et al., 2024), decompose an input
text into "atomic claims" and verify each against a knowledge base like
Wikipedia. These metrics are not suitable for most generation tasks because
they assume that every claim is verifiable (i.e., can plausibly be proven true
or false). We address this issue with VERISCORE, a metric for diverse long-form
generation tasks that contain both verifiable and unverifiable content.
VERISCORE can be effectively implemented with either closed or fine-tuned
open-weight language models, and human evaluation confirms that VERISCORE's
extracted claims are more sensible than those from competing methods across
eight different long-form tasks. We use VERISCORE to evaluate generations from
16 different models across multiple long-form tasks and find that while GPT-4o
is the best-performing model overall, open-weight models such as Mixtral-8x22
are closing the gap. We show that an LM's VERISCORE on one task (e.g.,
biography generation) does not necessarily correlate to its VERISCORE on a
different task (e.g., long-form QA), highlighting the need for expanding
factuality evaluation across tasks with varying fact density. | [
0.03245751932263374,
-0.6549218893051147,
1.0012633800506592,
0.257816344499588,
0.09686291962862015,
0.30121496319770813,
-0.555646538734436,
-0.6236810684204102,
-0.011959990486502647,
0.465130090713501,
-0.44781962037086487,
-0.4879702925682068,
-0.5611956715583801,
0.29532110691070557,
-0.22011798620224,
1.4936376810073853,
-0.26431331038475037,
-0.40679433941841125,
-0.789033830165863,
-0.1416490375995636,
-0.18428562581539154,
-0.5411177277565002,
-0.4055636525154114,
-0.3153194785118103,
0.5206642746925354,
0.4208179712295532,
0.6071100234985352,
0.5207979679107666,
0.4208020567893982,
0.3840685188770294,
-0.07008329778909683,
0.4948276877403259,
-0.5926498174667358,
0.4440857768058777,
-0.38998544216156006,
-0.47431233525276184,
-0.4693809151649475,
0.013703430071473122,
0.7486425638198853,
0.3493689000606537,
-0.05716429650783539,
0.677132248878479,
-0.10712061077356339,
0.5980157852172852,
-0.7505804896354675,
-0.10431087762117386,
-0.5109724402427673,
0.1315297782421112,
-0.4419093132019043,
-0.00925427582114935,
-0.3791664242744446,
-0.5343227982521057,
0.012716836296021938,
-0.16176089644432068,
0.39947599172592163,
0.17831766605377197,
0.9377797245979309,
0.13664767146110535,
-0.36483901739120483,
-0.508493959903717,
-1.0356724262237549,
0.9368496537208557,
-0.6075896620750427,
0.3003512918949127,
0.26412200927734375,
0.5355060696601868,
0.04336399585008621,
-1.0295478105545044,
-0.7667911052703857,
-0.6094731092453003,
0.1084759384393692,
0.3579791486263275,
-0.453855037689209,
-0.13613319396972656,
0.5046326518058777,
0.6841099858283997,
-0.5172264575958252,
0.08818723261356354,
-0.616636335849762,
-0.37247318029403687,
0.5706354975700378,
0.10537860542535782,
0.3332223892211914,
-0.5487193465232849,
-0.8867905139923096,
0.22419008612632751,
-0.7501313090324402,
-0.0441824346780777,
0.4656484127044678,
0.06562630832195282,
-0.11104276776313782,
0.9018892645835876,
-0.46712347865104675,
0.37989541888237,
-0.040175214409828186,
-0.4069403409957886,
0.33659395575523376,
-0.8441705703735352,
-0.1187540739774704,
0.20555807650089264,
0.7941029071807861,
0.22635595500469208,
0.04741215705871582,
-0.3296266496181488,
-0.14881329238414764,
0.3708586096763611,
0.46436670422554016,
-0.8085282444953918,
0.37588879466056824,
0.26420244574546814,
-0.36633041501045227,
-0.24709275364875793,
-0.127131387591362,
-0.4383135437965393,
-0.2860649824142456,
-0.3653693199157715,
0.3975917100906372,
-0.3798503279685974,
-0.1503136157989502,
0.13663055002689362,
-0.16902466118335724,
-0.13020442426204681,
0.2217588722705841,
-0.4272737503051758,
0.44181695580482483,
0.8016293048858643,
0.8338155150413513,
-0.35524076223373413,
-0.42001399397850037,
-0.47050562500953674,
0.11534646898508072,
-0.02636001817882061,
0.965909481048584,
-0.168647900223732,
-0.23580703139305115,
0.04547929763793945,
-0.1323859840631485,
0.009576193988323212,
-0.4606119394302368,
1.057429313659668,
-0.2589643597602844,
0.5435833930969238,
-0.40842553973197937,
-0.6357943415641785,
0.01368896383792162,
0.6028452515602112,
-0.6194170117378235,
1.1591836214065552,
0.3222867250442505,
-0.7781974673271179,
0.6952220797538757,
-0.25292685627937317,
-0.4446401000022888,
0.10944119095802307,
-0.40981921553611755,
-0.6425440907478333,
0.34163111448287964,
-0.26345357298851013,
0.4231502413749695,
-0.7354483008384705,
0.2872203588485718,
-0.2004619985818863,
0.06023151054978371,
0.33574405312538147,
-0.5723430514335632,
0.519646406173706,
0.36091718077659607,
-0.4872230291366577,
-0.025250324979424477,
-0.7467676997184753,
0.04714386910200119,
-0.03509896248579025,
-0.5782219171524048,
-0.09945053607225418,
0.15553206205368042,
-0.1792241930961609,
0.17720071971416473,
0.4579170346260071,
-0.9746057391166687,
-0.10779163986444473,
-0.15004153549671173,
0.4358082413673401,
0.3757125735282898,
-0.06189972162246704,
0.06427890807390213,
-0.7560768127441406,
0.3846447169780731,
-0.09392596036195755,
0.11609604209661484,
0.12344532459974289,
-0.2291298508644104,
-0.538695752620697,
-0.42238351702690125,
0.1408108025789261,
0.5457479357719421,
-0.40325024724006653,
0.3624858856201172,
-0.6936792135238647,
-0.7989030480384827,
-0.20906521379947662,
0.3103756904602051,
0.4593636095523834,
0.7789795398712158,
0.23200713098049164,
-0.28756260871887207,
-0.5085843205451965,
-0.9785782694816589,
-0.4140565097332001,
-0.32628804445266724,
0.11297887563705444,
0.08705370873212814,
0.5929137468338013,
-0.14179135859012604,
1.0398011207580566,
-0.40666940808296204,
0.08722645044326782,
-0.23143187165260315,
0.18365128338336945,
0.24022126197814941,
0.2788005471229553,
0.5426787734031677,
-0.7666423320770264,
-0.3672245144844055,
0.18492217361927032,
-0.8558223247528076,
0.2207101732492447,
-0.20879390835762024,
0.03648331016302109,
0.21668554842472076,
0.10721544921398163,
-1.0187819004058838,
0.3230592906475067,
0.49296483397483826,
-0.336813747882843,
0.862478494644165,
-0.4770925045013428,
0.43254730105400085,
-1.094482660293579,
0.025179971009492874,
0.21436677873134613,
-0.5071312189102173,
-0.4227270185947418,
-0.03028499148786068,
-0.014755927957594395,
-0.04928939417004585,
-0.25118595361709595,
0.28458428382873535,
-0.4154003858566284,
-0.2103099822998047,
-0.1430056393146515,
0.21124590933322906,
0.140224888920784,
0.048677604645490646,
-0.17718924582004547,
0.720162034034729,
0.34027740359306335,
-0.49470654129981995,
0.3631947338581085,
0.029363028705120087,
-0.6612310409545898,
0.8304048180580139,
-0.6845371127128601,
0.001416752696968615,
-0.25575873255729675,
0.283060222864151,
-0.9702578783035278,
-0.16887183487415314,
0.09787622094154358,
-0.521236002445221,
0.1317666918039322,
0.08517143875360489,
-0.6415250301361084,
-0.4512971043586731,
-0.4379582405090332,
0.2569276690483093,
0.6384888291358948,
-0.5568852424621582,
0.678980827331543,
0.11265870928764343,
-0.3399583697319031,
-0.5076885223388672,
-0.4893474578857422,
0.2352716624736786,
-0.3652763366699219,
-0.9109452366828918,
0.5469534397125244,
-0.1739388406276703,
-0.25286057591438293,
0.00553868617862463,
-0.24595096707344055,
0.14796608686447144,
-0.022065967321395874,
0.4530823230743408,
0.22488628327846527,
-0.33005282282829285,
-0.016413001343607903,
0.1282532513141632,
-0.06512663513422012,
0.28555962443351746,
-0.08389854431152344,
0.17535443603992462,
-0.11465843766927719,
-0.3640158474445343,
-0.1278192102909088,
0.2515251934528351,
0.6075709462165833,
-0.2746141850948334,
0.5316209197044373,
0.50580233335495,
-0.42658671736717224,
-0.440929114818573,
-0.7443383932113647,
0.25109854340553284,
-0.3988652229309082,
0.34527692198753357,
-0.1995689868927002,
-0.9793370366096497,
0.33615243434906006,
-0.2671758532524109,
0.27632179856300354,
0.7026237845420837,
0.8304351568222046,
-0.10859736055135727,
0.7980282306671143,
0.4139745831489563,
0.10138238221406937,
-0.0016119786305353045,
-0.007376410067081451,
0.07134110480546951,
-0.4417130649089813,
-0.08611032366752625,
-0.7833933234214783,
0.01395440474152565,
-0.520481526851654,
-0.4546769857406616,
0.23775845766067505,
-0.17833706736564636,
-0.27141740918159485,
0.2149921953678131,
-0.3166637122631073,
0.3268343508243561,
0.293321818113327,
0.19501666724681854,
0.5425664186477661,
0.3150697350502014,
0.3767268657684326,
-0.11161484569311142,
-0.6090273261070251,
-0.5902712345123291,
1.1321204900741577,
0.44870683550834656,
0.25288844108581543,
0.3014404773712158,
0.7364890575408936,
0.7396161556243896,
0.6783513426780701,
-0.5570764541625977,
0.35993871092796326,
-0.3514317572116852,
-0.9452552199363708,
-0.11532745510339737,
-0.695955753326416,
-0.5937666296958923,
-0.027338610962033272,
-0.454912006855011,
-0.7263725996017456,
-0.24029362201690674,
0.16293644905090332,
-0.4124075770378113,
0.18069763481616974,
-0.40075382590293884,
0.676662027835846,
-0.39505836367607117,
-0.42798319458961487,
-0.5095541477203369,
-0.41843006014823914,
0.6895919442176819,
-0.08788567036390305,
0.3340107202529907,
-0.11820153892040253,
0.1531514972448349,
0.6891062259674072,
-0.5895189642906189,
0.8478931188583374,
0.049099721014499664,
-0.20286215841770172,
0.5369063019752502,
-0.087438203394413,
0.45172473788261414,
0.0862920731306076,
-0.15014401078224182,
-0.05166056007146835,
0.05734105780720711,
-0.23416434228420258,
-0.5433160662651062,
0.7784030437469482,
-0.7811586856842041,
-0.5993406772613525,
-0.44459840655326843,
-0.11549848318099976,
-0.08524098992347717,
0.19296149909496307,
0.5206459164619446,
0.44300219416618347,
-0.41167140007019043,
0.16892680525779724,
0.6703353524208069,
-0.020776355639100075,
-0.12469117343425751,
0.16411949694156647,
-0.12597204744815826,
-0.578677773475647,
1.1477243900299072,
0.248478502035141,
0.43763449788093567,
0.08816858381032944,
0.34714874625205994,
-0.324298620223999,
-0.5541724562644958,
-0.44466277956962585,
0.32683107256889343,
-0.8037183880805969,
-0.19546596705913544,
-0.5939005613327026,
-0.2149917185306549,
-0.22875840961933136,
0.09087954461574554,
-0.44729939103126526,
-0.46721991896629333,
0.1831469088792801,
-0.3151962459087372,
0.21727755665779114,
0.556787371635437,
-0.17579898238182068,
0.16100913286209106,
-0.7702730894088745,
0.5281694531440735,
0.28684568405151367,
0.15107452869415283,
-0.45538651943206787,
-0.49925997853279114,
-0.19586443901062012,
-0.054329607635736465,
-0.16037091612815857,
-0.6839268803596497,
-0.27599161863327026,
0.14829954504966736,
0.536099910736084,
0.14476974308490753,
-0.03029344417154789,
0.31701189279556274,
-0.524296224117279,
0.8946749567985535,
0.4870505630970001,
-0.8829877376556396,
0.25635698437690735,
-0.02012399025261402,
-0.012182923033833504,
0.8598354458808899,
0.47364529967308044,
-0.37419143319129944,
-0.26656854152679443,
-0.7775252461433411,
-0.6909031867980957,
0.20838086307048798,
0.34117797017097473,
0.2691059410572052,
-0.04155551642179489,
0.36490514874458313,
0.4428732395172119,
0.28899702429771423,
-0.6283898949623108,
-0.1325293779373169,
-0.21420153975486755,
-0.32966941595077515,
0.01372655387967825,
-0.5097880363464355,
-0.2978712320327759,
0.04931800812482834,
0.4892467260360718,
0.11419003456830978,
0.028653768822550774,
0.32672640681266785,
-0.09797081351280212,
-0.11343906074762344,
0.34830334782600403,
0.5960440039634705,
0.8899257779121399,
-0.09252659976482391,
0.3226444721221924,
0.16674211621284485,
-0.5141677856445312,
0.035233981907367706,
0.17023257911205292,
-0.40320509672164917,
0.2264988273382187,
0.521385908126831,
0.8315942287445068,
0.1756851226091385,
-0.6107614040374756,
0.5425704121589661,
-0.04196092113852501,
-0.4335225820541382,
-0.6067405343055725,
0.12276472896337509,
-0.10379311442375183,
0.2396242320537567,
0.1614570915699005,
0.1291990727186203,
0.05788938328623772,
-0.6520239114761353,
0.11658143997192383,
0.21327391266822815,
-0.19281508028507233,
-0.46413877606391907,
0.6561431288719177,
0.15340611338615417,
-0.1829753816127777,
0.4530485272407532,
-0.140541210770607,
-0.48677361011505127,
0.5493786931037903,
0.5801445245742798,
0.8124963641166687,
0.15508036315441132,
0.5837602615356445,
0.5618537664413452,
0.3054632246494293,
-0.2518543601036072,
0.362559974193573,
-0.3416931927204132,
-0.6762862205505371,
-0.714552640914917,
-0.6075814366340637,
-0.4005434215068817,
-0.10270701348781586,
-0.42557546496391296,
0.024321923032402992,
-0.5222084522247314,
-0.6681262254714966,
0.05765359476208687,
0.1375611126422882,
-0.7808042764663696,
0.3356403410434723,
0.31122496724128723,
0.9763525128364563,
-0.8589297533035278,
0.23150025308132172,
0.5997754335403442,
-0.4455106258392334,
-0.5691113471984863,
-0.16837559640407562,
-0.07875391840934753,
-0.46892794966697693,
0.7696660161018372,
0.10777043551206589,
-0.3912780284881592,
-0.18810151517391205,
-0.602830708026886,
-0.8234086632728577,
1.258020281791687,
0.3528234362602234,
-0.22998619079589844,
-0.15864361822605133,
0.2553461194038391,
0.3867942988872528,
-0.2576516568660736,
0.06297454982995987,
0.2276514172554016,
0.5657718181610107,
-0.1376807689666748,
-0.7154401540756226,
0.25991225242614746,
0.03610529750585556,
-0.1938844472169876,
-0.024902354925870895,
-0.6925379633903503,
0.7988386750221252,
-0.2000008225440979,
-0.6525529026985168,
0.2033640295267105,
1.1921321153640747,
0.670866072177887,
0.49936315417289734,
0.7664098739624023,
0.5709041953086853,
0.993678867816925,
0.1460093855857849,
1.1287225484848022,
-0.32287701964378357,
0.39719006419181824,
1.0954631567001343,
-0.4848352074623108,
0.6247999668121338,
0.32336679100990295,
-0.35814204812049866,
0.6410815715789795,
0.1798354536294937,
-0.01792396791279316,
-0.017757028341293335,
0.40093788504600525,
-0.447202205657959,
-0.4462985694408417,
-0.11916664987802505,
-0.3396764099597931,
0.45704934000968933,
0.12678909301757812,
-0.2949853539466858,
-0.5479625463485718,
-0.2543472349643707,
0.5675212144851685,
0.4254641532897949,
-0.07482343912124634,
0.27000099420547485,
-0.02457347884774208,
-0.9445944428443909,
0.36261996626853943,
0.06288687139749527,
0.5185713768005371,
-0.7393587231636047,
0.05036407709121704,
-0.1137247234582901,
0.07839004695415497,
-0.4673599600791931,
-0.7933942675590515,
0.07096407562494278,
0.48326632380485535,
-0.46681925654411316,
-0.14555057883262634,
1.0031154155731201,
-0.19176946580410004,
-0.5507084131240845,
-0.07444480061531067,
0.6839707493782043,
0.07914029806852341,
0.10887639969587326,
-0.45309481024742126,
0.11349882185459137,
-0.021120628342032433,
-0.49222448468208313,
0.13206641376018524,
0.5297051668167114,
0.005652206484228373,
0.5598748326301575,
0.6591581106185913,
0.2999376356601715,
-0.07068629562854767,
-0.1653062254190445,
0.6315049529075623,
-0.6039313673973083,
-0.2695973515510559,
-0.8036891222000122,
0.6169953346252441,
-0.4529292583465576,
-0.6318544745445251,
1.0669007301330566,
0.7400661706924438,
0.5953932404518127,
0.11224823445081711,
1.1612399816513062,
-0.2409765124320984,
0.6651439070701599,
-0.6190710663795471,
0.6530413627624512,
-0.39807066321372986,
-0.12702059745788574,
-0.08176882565021515,
-1.0119436979293823,
0.10516580939292908,
-0.012290154583752155,
-0.24172824621200562,
-0.006141709163784981,
0.5938047170639038,
0.41808637976646423,
-0.05398552864789963,
0.13667763769626617,
0.0942901000380516,
0.1862926483154297,
0.2989281415939331,
0.41025295853614807,
1.0593883991241455,
-0.120033398270607,
0.3745615780353546,
-0.09018094837665558,
-0.3030235171318054,
0.10233397781848907,
-1.0764398574829102,
-0.6424247026443481,
-0.4536084830760956,
-0.4455726146697998,
-0.6335862874984741,
0.019879072904586792,
0.5679224729537964,
0.3877837061882019,
-0.3715549111366272,
-0.15119530260562897,
0.28035861253738403,
0.053116489201784134,
-0.10908320546150208,
-0.13271094858646393,
0.20146064460277557,
-0.4079994559288025,
-0.48175355792045593,
0.4977235794067383,
0.2122451364994049,
-0.17244403064250946,
-0.530541181564331,
-0.10742149502038956,
0.2519952952861786,
0.06990162283182144,
0.7678071856498718,
0.623514711856842,
-0.25212526321411133,
-0.6336372494697571,
-0.05774978548288345,
-0.2557290196418762,
-0.047595541924238205,
0.723625898361206,
-0.8251315951347351,
0.1812698245048523,
0.5415931344032288,
0.7443001866340637,
0.6990005970001221,
0.13688750565052032,
0.5689124464988708,
-0.48745813965797424,
-0.469002902507782,
0.06158557906746864,
0.30016714334487915,
0.3811805248260498,
-0.3307666778564453,
0.45185762643814087,
0.3275086283683777,
-0.7472700476646423,
-1.0295640230178833,
0.4247400164604187,
-1.1435902118682861,
-0.10103987157344818,
1.0233017206192017,
-0.08365029096603394,
-0.5011696219444275,
0.15429113805294037,
-0.01889740489423275,
0.17953886091709137,
-0.00965842790901661,
0.6959620118141174,
0.6756058931350708,
0.04318369925022125,
0.33429473638534546,
-0.7760156989097595,
0.4855734705924988,
0.4230141341686249,
-0.9160977005958557,
0.1770922988653183,
0.722200870513916,
0.4526351988315582,
0.5353366136550903,
0.6592416763305664,
-0.10319241881370544,
0.3293199837207794,
-0.06734266132116318,
-0.053127605468034744,
-0.09547355771064758,
-0.3035888373851776,
0.25506332516670227,
0.29765233397483826,
0.22400055825710297,
0.08357442915439606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19271v1 | AutoPureData: Automated Filtering of Web Data for LLM Fine-tuning | 2024-06-27T15:37:57 | 2024-06-27T15:37:57 | Praneeth Vadlapati | cs.CL | cs.CL | Up-to-date and reliable Large Language Models (LLMs) are consistently sought
after. Typically, LLMs are trained on a fixed dataset and then deployed.
However, the training data continually becomes outdated. Enable automatic
training of AI using web data involves significant concerns regarding data
quality and safety due to bias, spam, and other unsafe or unwanted text. Pure
data is essential for producing reliable models. Training a model on impure
data may result in undesirable outcomes. This research proposes a system that
collects web data and automatically filters out unwanted text with the
assistance of existing trusted AI models. In the experiment, a small sample of
web data was collected and filtered, demonstrating the system's effectiveness
in purifying the data. | [
-0.38990259170532227,
-0.8667197823524475,
0.2642171382904053,
-0.08392025530338287,
-0.3560468554496765,
-0.09411211311817169,
-0.08780515938997269,
-0.692903459072113,
-0.17685432732105255,
0.7957136034965515,
-0.4025019705295563,
-0.6250458359718323,
-0.4683743119239807,
0.29459646344184875,
-1.1252590417861938,
1.0297081470489502,
-0.1056583896279335,
-0.00437341770157218,
0.01847062259912491,
0.054341480135917664,
-0.3356285095214844,
-0.37877559661865234,
-0.8146795630455017,
-0.22690340876579285,
0.2793351709842682,
0.5245912671089172,
0.7430632710456848,
1.1565431356430054,
0.5842247605323792,
0.42081329226493835,
0.41524839401245117,
0.4501461982727051,
-0.6071247458457947,
0.4338506758213043,
-0.4393273890018463,
-0.5280905961990356,
-0.3777123987674713,
0.040242962539196014,
0.4998646676540375,
0.39383646845817566,
-0.3240724802017212,
0.29243212938308716,
0.29510390758514404,
0.5668250918388367,
-0.5753600597381592,
-0.0001446509559173137,
-0.9808810949325562,
-0.008141394704580307,
-0.17441624402999878,
-0.328734815120697,
-0.24901370704174042,
-0.5746517181396484,
-0.19653527438640594,
-0.6347187757492065,
0.10436943173408508,
0.37472981214523315,
1.1890252828598022,
0.7533519268035889,
-0.2420579344034195,
-0.26337558031082153,
-0.6972885131835938,
0.6944757699966431,
-0.6045363545417786,
0.3633935749530792,
1.044252634048462,
0.15843647718429565,
-0.26910921931266785,
-0.5584688186645508,
-0.8071876764297485,
-0.10291793942451477,
-0.16634820401668549,
-0.12107978016138077,
-0.3379741311073303,
-0.10847257822751999,
-0.21558129787445068,
0.3133612275123596,
-0.7499516606330872,
0.5129401683807373,
-0.3846195340156555,
-0.2078746110200882,
0.8267373442649841,
0.36258459091186523,
0.5187837481498718,
-0.2539452910423279,
-0.11568597704172134,
0.1457454115152359,
-0.6154890060424805,
-0.2977389991283417,
0.4802454710006714,
0.24272647500038147,
0.18925440311431885,
0.5467191338539124,
-0.6378401517868042,
0.8245919346809387,
0.12847813963890076,
-0.07160638272762299,
-0.10717039555311203,
-0.13582134246826172,
-0.5451579093933105,
-0.33777305483818054,
0.8129374384880066,
0.26446542143821716,
0.5747863054275513,
-0.13403111696243286,
-0.3530423641204834,
0.06915956735610962,
0.43579408526420593,
-0.6527107357978821,
-0.5788806080818176,
0.25769659876823425,
-0.4883178174495697,
-0.2347680777311325,
-0.11701597273349762,
-0.7030413150787354,
-0.3621128499507904,
-0.6131214499473572,
0.18264834582805634,
-0.4628632366657257,
0.1489095538854599,
-0.03051912970840931,
0.2517925798892975,
-0.009363646619021893,
0.3449520766735077,
-0.8050675988197327,
0.2815936803817749,
0.4526326656341553,
0.36694419384002686,
-0.4050081670284271,
-0.15145675837993622,
-0.3677854835987091,
0.30116701126098633,
-0.17731106281280518,
1.0211869478225708,
-0.40106356143951416,
-0.1863141506910324,
0.10213884711265564,
0.21117296814918518,
-0.05082867294549942,
-0.6961133480072021,
0.46690914034843445,
-0.8057021498680115,
0.024430889636278152,
0.5143683552742004,
-0.7453628778457642,
-0.34103283286094666,
0.26284924149513245,
-0.6782124042510986,
0.7432106733322144,
-0.0300753153860569,
-0.3189581334590912,
0.5010814070701599,
-0.20504045486450195,
-0.5085693001747131,
0.20875877141952515,
0.04971842095255852,
-0.40272295475006104,
-0.30349838733673096,
0.2993878424167633,
0.4910704791545868,
-0.2638528645038605,
0.4568597376346588,
-0.40025556087493896,
-0.299308717250824,
0.2079349309206009,
-0.7047955989837646,
0.7433202862739563,
0.5581109523773193,
-0.2814522683620453,
-0.0010328419739380479,
-1.0004570484161377,
0.05282782390713692,
0.06082447990775108,
-0.5215485692024231,
-0.49856507778167725,
0.10789348930120468,
0.23675167560577393,
0.014011065475642681,
0.3756796419620514,
-0.5341253280639648,
-0.05041646584868431,
-0.42063045501708984,
0.26529088616371155,
0.7820720076560974,
0.08830101042985916,
0.18156105279922485,
-0.36827531456947327,
0.43269866704940796,
-0.03343714028596878,
0.3875730037689209,
0.158478781580925,
-0.3421969711780548,
-1.1923807859420776,
-0.2625677287578583,
0.20904681086540222,
0.7441369891166687,
-0.7164157629013062,
0.8887003064155579,
-0.11788076907396317,
-0.47123873233795166,
-0.6476415395736694,
0.61043781042099,
0.19955335557460785,
0.35123777389526367,
0.4379098117351532,
-0.19295233488082886,
-0.4608292877674103,
-1.126579761505127,
-0.09258543699979782,
0.1355227679014206,
-0.03163107484579086,
0.14813514053821564,
0.35856080055236816,
-0.5642343163490295,
1.1173070669174194,
-0.41738057136535645,
-0.5565370917320251,
0.06456185132265091,
0.017732298001646996,
-0.1947084218263626,
0.6887983679771423,
0.27980464696884155,
-0.7912901043891907,
-0.5661009550094604,
-0.1385921686887741,
-0.6817888021469116,
-0.2827417552471161,
0.12614424526691437,
-0.1685875654220581,
0.21891382336616516,
0.4269524812698364,
-0.3934343457221985,
0.5859708786010742,
0.5302472710609436,
-0.12212161719799042,
0.05053412914276123,
-0.3567885756492615,
0.18676432967185974,
-0.9980003833770752,
0.3380957841873169,
0.18375305831432343,
-0.6530789136886597,
-0.4905814528465271,
0.010237372480332851,
0.032839030027389526,
-0.009968136437237263,
-0.18391920626163483,
0.6177541017532349,
-0.2245165854692459,
0.40582045912742615,
-0.6502957940101624,
0.23465196788311005,
0.18476267158985138,
0.34001341462135315,
-0.019640222191810608,
0.6355539560317993,
0.09738365560770035,
-0.9412664771080017,
0.3909520208835602,
0.4640388786792755,
-0.1313806176185608,
0.5345338582992554,
-0.20615407824516296,
-0.03914676606655121,
-0.006582224741578102,
0.1492827981710434,
-1.0960191488265991,
-0.3099117875099182,
0.3637946844100952,
-0.3988344669342041,
0.020473551005125046,
-0.058887675404548645,
-0.7253890037536621,
-0.38655465841293335,
0.1387111097574234,
0.034833505749702454,
0.35548460483551025,
-0.5889056921005249,
0.20925018191337585,
0.9722844362258911,
-0.1981639713048935,
-0.26361313462257385,
-0.5369821786880493,
0.1795443892478943,
-0.30137044191360474,
-0.16713406145572662,
-0.09074839949607849,
-0.06626430153846741,
-0.17617389559745789,
-0.05746409296989441,
0.21070848405361176,
-0.8689358234405518,
0.29612448811531067,
0.34691837430000305,
0.3081061840057373,
0.3174596130847931,
-0.03759179636836052,
0.22331759333610535,
-0.08914250135421753,
0.00821974128484726,
-0.13369157910346985,
0.5570700168609619,
0.3194294273853302,
-0.255105197429657,
-1.1822375059127808,
0.08151713758707047,
0.46442389488220215,
-0.10738097131252289,
0.4807789921760559,
0.4502813518047333,
-0.5968664288520813,
-0.42397499084472656,
-0.5646549463272095,
0.008653690107166767,
-0.5936388969421387,
-0.002959426259621978,
0.013852576725184917,
-0.7007357478141785,
0.2353428304195404,
0.18929532170295715,
0.1796334832906723,
0.5954940319061279,
0.3404054343700409,
-0.43878453969955444,
1.1712266206741333,
0.5860401391983032,
-0.4506963789463043,
0.38715818524360657,
-0.16690076887607574,
-0.02850501425564289,
-0.4206404387950897,
-0.09440498054027557,
-0.7242318391799927,
-0.20231831073760986,
-0.4007594585418701,
0.1632757931947708,
0.004176551941782236,
-0.1828303188085556,
-0.2834016978740692,
0.2868489921092987,
-0.7135555148124695,
0.33149099349975586,
0.677283763885498,
0.2936992645263672,
0.6237756609916687,
0.10409672558307648,
0.10934270173311234,
0.0948847234249115,
-0.31941190361976624,
-0.6713756918907166,
1.0535361766815186,
0.25157245993614197,
1.009389877319336,
-0.09871267527341843,
0.31562912464141846,
0.5409120917320251,
0.5254068374633789,
-0.5113708972930908,
0.5774880051612854,
-0.46722471714019775,
-0.7600714564323425,
-0.33391937613487244,
-0.2631285488605499,
-1.2112596035003662,
0.055802520364522934,
-0.13683153688907623,
-0.36307916045188904,
0.23335742950439453,
0.3719926178455353,
-0.48530158400535583,
0.34517019987106323,
-0.5169566869735718,
0.35372745990753174,
-0.1922483891248703,
-0.3998279869556427,
-0.5176730751991272,
-0.3493002653121948,
0.25433430075645447,
-0.4303934574127197,
0.2227013111114502,
-0.24036265909671783,
0.05331933870911598,
0.6996864676475525,
-0.5335800647735596,
1.037758231163025,
-0.0896170362830162,
-0.27705520391464233,
0.3119235336780548,
0.3070973753929138,
0.4575658440589905,
-0.07510066777467728,
0.018987033516168594,
0.12883953750133514,
-0.18548457324504852,
-0.18780294060707092,
-0.24400746822357178,
0.6993167400360107,
-0.8397137522697449,
-0.550771951675415,
-0.30596688389778137,
-0.4824562668800354,
-0.34779271483421326,
0.3203732669353485,
0.06421075016260147,
0.08202243596315384,
0.06821200251579285,
0.27953457832336426,
0.5369250774383545,
-0.25672927498817444,
0.41671907901763916,
0.8767647743225098,
-0.03076004609465599,
-0.38022464513778687,
0.7196202278137207,
0.05106034502387047,
-0.09129104018211365,
0.20003041625022888,
-0.15390872955322266,
-0.23647470772266388,
-0.9280366897583008,
-0.6383570432662964,
-0.059159018099308014,
-0.46355295181274414,
-0.5998802781105042,
-0.7300972938537598,
-0.3734479248523712,
-0.3444419503211975,
0.14307236671447754,
-0.14521203935146332,
-0.26160335540771484,
-0.6913624405860901,
0.07408776879310608,
0.6251820921897888,
0.7532714009284973,
0.016473183408379555,
0.5692590475082397,
-0.9692735075950623,
0.3752163350582123,
0.13213342428207397,
0.5145931243896484,
-0.057010915130376816,
-0.6974593997001648,
-0.42853793501853943,
0.22959443926811218,
-0.15235848724842072,
-0.42231619358062744,
0.8309803605079651,
0.24434733390808105,
0.4721278250217438,
0.37265998125076294,
-0.049020055681467056,
0.8774744272232056,
-0.46373364329338074,
0.433944970369339,
-0.35626503825187683,
-0.6733667254447937,
0.6786808371543884,
-0.537575900554657,
0.3480425775051117,
1.1637102365493774,
0.47713086009025574,
-0.2567775547504425,
-0.7388403415679932,
-0.2686110734939575,
-0.7191110849380493,
0.7289097309112549,
0.020461978390812874,
0.1593896895647049,
0.11680149286985397,
0.7742897272109985,
0.23492316901683807,
0.38218173384666443,
-0.4992539882659912,
-0.17899656295776367,
-0.013518096879124641,
-0.537060558795929,
0.04435688257217407,
-0.03393594175577164,
0.18305478990077972,
-0.4698842167854309,
0.8958059549331665,
0.19862577319145203,
-0.22101663053035736,
-0.025795305147767067,
-0.5413076281547546,
-0.33047807216644287,
-0.1328294724225998,
0.020888801664114,
0.41450783610343933,
0.12578214704990387,
-0.13631181418895721,
0.0414583794772625,
-0.7365463972091675,
0.25521036982536316,
0.1353655606508255,
-0.49282634258270264,
-0.20286650955677032,
-0.0866207405924797,
0.42292436957359314,
0.08541902899742126,
-0.9428099393844604,
0.12632916867733002,
-0.010895265266299248,
0.1560821682214737,
-0.5191567540168762,
0.5382727980613708,
-0.23425477743148804,
-0.21631629765033722,
0.44700270891189575,
-0.03268337994813919,
0.5172678828239441,
-0.23959504067897797,
0.6437256932258606,
0.2643997371196747,
-0.23950032889842987,
0.00017309145187027752,
0.6687234044075012,
0.24903693795204163,
-0.28803539276123047,
0.7899374961853027,
0.10532074421644211,
-0.24844028055667877,
0.39618706703186035,
0.2976233661174774,
0.5199552178382874,
-0.5800715088844299,
-0.01236792840063572,
0.2664664089679718,
0.19968169927597046,
0.14809927344322205,
0.12043016403913498,
0.08588684350252151,
-0.6209079623222351,
-0.16738489270210266,
-1.021450400352478,
-0.3372984528541565,
0.5728575587272644,
-0.44191664457321167,
0.13628560304641724,
-0.5088872313499451,
-0.22535274922847748,
-0.18591409921646118,
-0.04716392233967781,
-0.7023457884788513,
0.8283172249794006,
-0.01421542838215828,
0.6796640753746033,
-0.6395325660705566,
1.1046578884124756,
0.2884056866168976,
-0.42141634225845337,
-0.8385553956031799,
-0.07053151726722717,
-0.03734483942389488,
-0.9956661462783813,
0.6235516667366028,
-0.1781671792268753,
-0.13703195750713348,
0.2932743430137634,
-0.5446611046791077,
-1.0715211629867554,
0.6643267869949341,
0.1884201020002365,
-0.7469217777252197,
0.06232064217329025,
0.47829657793045044,
0.7091915011405945,
-0.021132152527570724,
-0.0483127124607563,
0.6560729146003723,
0.6008423566818237,
-0.416614830493927,
-1.0714231729507446,
-0.15941151976585388,
-0.4103013873100281,
-0.32822996377944946,
0.03820794075727463,
-0.6347041726112366,
0.7020371556282043,
0.5677209496498108,
-0.22376896440982819,
0.270842969417572,
0.51204514503479,
-0.0367925763130188,
-0.07196370512247086,
0.6103872060775757,
0.5206176042556763,
0.7158440351486206,
0.1293141096830368,
0.7368514537811279,
-0.4889041483402252,
0.23279094696044922,
1.0858561992645264,
-0.46695566177368164,
1.0134332180023193,
0.11611620336771011,
0.06168314069509506,
0.4121943414211273,
0.8945819735527039,
-0.43570294976234436,
0.39598941802978516,
0.18776939809322357,
0.05108526721596718,
-0.12345482409000397,
-0.1502234935760498,
0.20583583414554596,
0.8313233852386475,
0.4161999821662903,
-0.43450745940208435,
-0.40705713629722595,
0.3415848910808563,
0.12627311050891876,
0.26821327209472656,
-0.19768288731575012,
1.049958348274231,
-0.0863327905535698,
-0.8485614657402039,
0.5851187705993652,
0.1611987054347992,
0.7016441822052002,
-0.40157607197761536,
0.13532595336437225,
-0.26134562492370605,
0.3295324146747589,
-0.2923383414745331,
-0.5988869667053223,
0.39801040291786194,
0.3110865354537964,
-0.03269514441490173,
-0.2362038493156433,
0.8158878087997437,
-0.5112292766571045,
-0.2995084524154663,
0.22613564133644104,
0.5785394310951233,
0.29348206520080566,
0.002381630940362811,
-0.7644674777984619,
-0.04061092436313629,
0.08279144763946533,
-0.28838029503822327,
0.2560921907424927,
0.11718190461397171,
-0.06350282579660416,
1.0953584909439087,
0.7903988361358643,
0.21289804577827454,
0.04997924342751503,
-0.043298520147800446,
0.6857444047927856,
-0.4588557183742523,
-0.6428212523460388,
-0.813492476940155,
0.12757772207260132,
-0.1352301985025406,
-0.10443051159381866,
0.8876467347145081,
0.8618965744972229,
0.5714629292488098,
0.2760998010635376,
0.9323713183403015,
0.1989682912826538,
0.7415065765380859,
-0.2952848970890045,
1.3830362558364868,
-0.6257174611091614,
0.05162801221013069,
0.3176521062850952,
-0.7634236812591553,
-0.3143368661403656,
0.5903881192207336,
0.021900318562984467,
-0.11636251211166382,
0.4475078284740448,
0.7681462168693542,
-0.13879255950450897,
0.23658648133277893,
0.14865687489509583,
0.25089114904403687,
0.26934462785720825,
0.20389150083065033,
0.3878432810306549,
-0.36512354016304016,
0.4940374195575714,
-0.2740787863731384,
-0.11108258366584778,
-0.22319288551807404,
-0.34174251556396484,
-0.7663872838020325,
-0.6366942524909973,
-0.14770549535751343,
-0.06109713762998581,
0.15532244741916656,
0.8247498273849487,
0.9098007082939148,
-1.03817617893219,
-0.21530549228191376,
-0.06055217981338501,
-0.3129371106624603,
0.22782178223133087,
-0.19144198298454285,
0.35171809792518616,
-0.3643471598625183,
-1.0638997554779053,
0.5481879115104675,
0.11250164359807968,
0.22737844288349152,
-0.605798065662384,
0.42166969180107117,
-0.3977329730987549,
0.17688268423080444,
0.3002093732357025,
0.14991828799247742,
-0.42998796701431274,
-0.26526305079460144,
-0.2893689274787903,
-0.47242650389671326,
0.0633876696228981,
0.341330349445343,
-0.8619118332862854,
0.11021459102630615,
0.2690317630767822,
0.6793277263641357,
0.21424500644207,
0.12898877263069153,
0.7054346799850464,
-0.3676292896270752,
0.09469332545995712,
0.19298015534877777,
0.4466663897037506,
0.33477354049682617,
-0.7531363368034363,
0.3326859474182129,
-0.058097586035728455,
-0.6036389470100403,
-0.7312862873077393,
-0.13577701151371002,
-0.4983829855918884,
-0.4356640577316284,
1.1913468837738037,
-0.0041722748428583145,
-0.38888251781463623,
-0.7283809781074524,
-0.11402340978384018,
0.4923441410064697,
-0.38724491000175476,
1.108860969543457,
0.6036121249198914,
-0.04054567962884903,
0.17414624989032745,
-0.7400504350662231,
0.6951931118965149,
0.2726079225540161,
-1.2322641611099243,
0.07990963757038116,
0.7092381119728088,
0.44398754835128784,
-0.27038025856018066,
0.5536971688270569,
0.11851990222930908,
0.058106113225221634,
-0.38871729373931885,
-0.10937649011611938,
0.04082173854112625,
-0.37014511227607727,
-0.3479728400707245,
0.23787890374660492,
-0.138229638338089,
-0.09900899231433868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19263v1 | Read Anywhere Pointed: Layout-aware GUI Screen Reading with Tree-of-Lens Grounding | 2024-06-27T15:34:16 | 2024-06-27T15:34:16 | Yue Fan, Lei Ding, Ching-Chen Kuo, Shan Jiang, Yang Zhao, Xinze Guan, Jie Yang, Yi Zhang, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Graphical User Interfaces (GUIs) are central to our interaction with digital
devices. Recently, growing efforts have been made to build models for various
GUI understanding tasks. However, these efforts largely overlook an important
GUI-referring task: screen reading based on user-indicated points, which we
name the Screen Point-and-Read (SPR) task. This task is predominantly handled
by rigid accessible screen reading tools, in great need of new models driven by
advancements in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). In this paper, we
propose a Tree-of-Lens (ToL) agent, utilizing a novel ToL grounding mechanism,
to address the SPR task. Based on the input point coordinate and the
corresponding GUI screenshot, our ToL agent constructs a Hierarchical Layout
Tree. Based on the tree, our ToL agent not only comprehends the content of the
indicated area but also articulates the layout and spatial relationships
between elements. Such layout information is crucial for accurately
interpreting information on the screen, distinguishing our ToL agent from other
screen reading tools. We also thoroughly evaluate the ToL agent against other
baselines on a newly proposed SPR benchmark, which includes GUIs from mobile,
web, and operating systems. Last but not least, we test the ToL agent on mobile
GUI navigation tasks, demonstrating its utility in identifying incorrect
actions along the path of agent execution trajectories. Code and data:
screen-point-and-read.github.io | [
-0.24965976178646088,
-0.7235690355300903,
1.0190203189849854,
0.20959702134132385,
-0.053041521459817886,
0.046712201088666916,
0.16021840274333954,
-0.19265471398830414,
-0.23623833060264587,
0.6158058047294617,
-0.5997486710548401,
-1.0354070663452148,
-0.2827214002609253,
-0.07744847983121872,
-0.3778020441532135,
1.0746192932128906,
-0.1765531599521637,
-0.5638125538825989,
-0.14632976055145264,
-0.31340649724006653,
-0.4140301048755646,
-0.019109895452857018,
-0.3516186773777008,
-0.02808857522904873,
0.8262367248535156,
0.6028397679328918,
0.8102529048919678,
0.6630739569664001,
0.25174039602279663,
0.24677063524723053,
-0.07168146967887878,
0.32282963395118713,
-0.4622825086116791,
0.10532395541667938,
-0.2832697629928589,
-0.41124847531318665,
-0.620962917804718,
-0.12919172644615173,
0.8054898381233215,
0.5285794734954834,
0.24597996473312378,
0.05338544771075249,
0.08810611069202423,
0.7228782773017883,
-0.7357523441314697,
0.12958714365959167,
-0.12776418030261993,
0.17020730674266815,
-0.05448869243264198,
-0.3598026633262634,
-0.9116186499595642,
-0.39320307970046997,
-0.13437460362911224,
-0.9885472059249878,
0.08981815725564957,
0.04790760576725006,
0.7620149254798889,
0.4295639395713806,
-0.790165364742279,
-0.07900576293468475,
-0.48955708742141724,
0.23125962913036346,
-0.15608839690685272,
0.4100436270236969,
0.3432992994785309,
0.4136897921562195,
0.011898107826709747,
-0.49513688683509827,
-0.536652684211731,
-0.40982720255851746,
-0.23909735679626465,
0.4419231712818146,
-0.048650845885276794,
0.12295259535312653,
0.5227062702178955,
-0.035430971533060074,
-0.5705532431602478,
-0.4323635995388031,
0.23025482892990112,
0.1471295803785324,
0.37272945046424866,
-0.1856958568096161,
0.6461765170097351,
-0.21930308640003204,
-0.2807835638523102,
-0.17190565168857574,
-0.5704318881034851,
0.13757012784481049,
-0.03723892197012901,
-0.01349062379449606,
-0.07678394764661789,
0.5995288491249084,
-0.1345725953578949,
0.766752302646637,
0.5534178018569946,
-0.40381890535354614,
-0.041799575090408325,
-0.2278587967157364,
-0.12432549148797989,
0.07630998641252518,
0.18352237343788147,
0.6250510215759277,
0.1849239319562912,
-0.21240073442459106,
-0.23543567955493927,
-0.25595858693122864,
0.3533279001712799,
-0.4898339509963989,
-0.30991750955581665,
0.010924265719950199,
-0.5915865898132324,
-0.3431151807308197,
0.07333258539438248,
-0.3816993236541748,
-0.7982726097106934,
0.0650806874036789,
0.47344085574150085,
-0.42628034949302673,
-0.4503338634967804,
-0.32754555344581604,
-0.22745148837566376,
0.1660713404417038,
0.7082249522209167,
-0.46352672576904297,
0.1382678747177124,
0.43026041984558105,
0.9066212773323059,
-0.14600327610969543,
-0.48673149943351746,
-0.615114688873291,
0.4781927168369293,
-0.5177744030952454,
1.0316691398620605,
-0.2737463712692261,
-0.48295265436172485,
-0.037625085562467575,
0.04451039806008339,
-0.3800572454929352,
-0.2684754431247711,
0.24856530129909515,
-0.38911697268486023,
0.16602498292922974,
-0.17787352204322815,
-0.08868737518787384,
-0.2932235598564148,
0.6773679852485657,
-0.6437869668006897,
1.0927404165267944,
0.15116316080093384,
-0.8675940632820129,
0.3652030825614929,
-0.8660650253295898,
-0.5387681722640991,
-0.10352606326341629,
-0.12505559623241425,
-0.4406523108482361,
0.24440065026283264,
0.14031894505023956,
0.15487341582775116,
0.2969384789466858,
0.216278538107872,
-0.3845597803592682,
-0.06941580772399902,
0.007065033074468374,
-0.5657949447631836,
0.7731049656867981,
0.17633506655693054,
-0.6075414419174194,
0.49722447991371155,
-0.8636208772659302,
0.05209318920969963,
0.022442685440182686,
-0.04658353701233864,
-0.42876335978507996,
0.4274611175060272,
0.12922058999538422,
0.3126888573169708,
0.015411745756864548,
-0.3354446291923523,
0.3183777332305908,
0.14238835871219635,
0.11461461335420609,
0.355621337890625,
-0.13314057886600494,
0.7636668086051941,
-0.13829365372657776,
0.3410983085632324,
0.05628041550517082,
0.0232129767537117,
-0.5908980965614319,
-0.1895657330751419,
-0.6761384010314941,
-0.2746725380420685,
-0.23768693208694458,
0.7780812978744507,
-0.8412405252456665,
0.28589656949043274,
-0.2740771770477295,
-0.5409653186798096,
0.17203082144260406,
-0.3540074825286865,
0.49626824259757996,
0.7613261938095093,
0.044696349650621414,
-0.07773419469594955,
0.23614034056663513,
-0.42723187804222107,
-0.05944780260324478,
-0.1959080845117569,
0.07359734922647476,
0.5121263265609741,
0.28841984272003174,
-0.09254469722509384,
1.2376872301101685,
-0.5328629016876221,
-0.42908647656440735,
-0.3063671886920929,
-0.19687603414058685,
-0.04633461311459541,
0.27015596628189087,
0.5833386182785034,
-0.6460713744163513,
-0.7195702195167542,
0.41115662455558777,
-0.9686740636825562,
-0.38303419947624207,
-0.2970297336578369,
-0.38738322257995605,
0.005943309981375933,
0.7379605770111084,
-0.7360583543777466,
0.6905698180198669,
0.4003724753856659,
-0.8127161264419556,
0.5000776052474976,
-0.35807740688323975,
0.03245461359620094,
-1.186948299407959,
0.3902532458305359,
0.3021802008152008,
-0.5249466896057129,
-0.7323373556137085,
0.24619540572166443,
0.4750892221927643,
-0.5727813243865967,
-0.19744962453842163,
0.7192546725273132,
-0.6818023324012756,
-0.42174506187438965,
-0.17842824757099152,
0.2495591789484024,
0.35113948583602905,
0.35174885392189026,
0.27655625343322754,
1.0058599710464478,
0.2098027616739273,
-0.2753581404685974,
-0.02689012885093689,
0.40584835410118103,
-0.02623690851032734,
0.7872012853622437,
-0.2761108875274658,
-0.02867809869349003,
-0.07799823582172394,
0.8406923413276672,
-1.2466431856155396,
0.026271721348166466,
0.5125756859779358,
-0.30751660466194153,
0.28533419966697693,
-0.30979880690574646,
-0.3546859323978424,
0.11620908975601196,
-0.24616269767284393,
0.4603721797466278,
-0.11281366646289825,
-0.7563881874084473,
0.9424518942832947,
0.319102942943573,
-0.181044802069664,
-0.44110190868377686,
-0.2607657313346863,
-0.012023215182125568,
-0.40213051438331604,
-0.9900290966033936,
0.35009047389030457,
0.21521936357021332,
-0.2859405279159546,
-0.23534753918647766,
-0.3039442300796509,
-0.08679119497537613,
-0.014003712683916092,
0.3967861831188202,
0.21673211455345154,
-0.4748415946960449,
0.0017507628072053194,
-0.03267167508602142,
-0.49219733476638794,
-0.0023679176811128855,
-0.644830048084259,
0.023527128621935844,
-0.10315774381160736,
-0.3590433895587921,
-0.3918200433254242,
0.3251414895057678,
0.7956551313400269,
-0.26279914379119873,
0.028098925948143005,
0.27845796942710876,
-0.2708914279937744,
-0.10059920698404312,
-0.3728705942630768,
0.11078386008739471,
-0.4801834225654602,
0.4175361692905426,
-0.7638376951217651,
-0.2000797986984253,
0.4850785434246063,
-0.41340744495391846,
0.16348305344581604,
0.2695751190185547,
0.12593789398670197,
-0.34380850195884705,
1.4127801656723022,
0.8476204872131348,
-0.14973978698253632,
0.9085204005241394,
-0.16762109100818634,
0.28882768750190735,
-0.5122389793395996,
-0.0461190864443779,
-0.42381909489631653,
-0.22954662144184113,
-0.20319314301013947,
-0.4648568034172058,
0.5251930952072144,
0.1981077641248703,
-0.2446470409631729,
-0.050927143543958664,
-0.5804367661476135,
0.6913717985153198,
0.5741122364997864,
0.08142617344856262,
0.5349974036216736,
0.29523417353630066,
-0.398601233959198,
0.19651944935321808,
-0.5895796418190002,
-0.5453326106071472,
0.49644020199775696,
0.4683036208152771,
0.8257364630699158,
-0.09689740836620331,
0.2453974187374115,
0.380889892578125,
0.15353968739509583,
-0.6922644376754761,
0.7187796831130981,
-0.008431317284703255,
-0.45315584540367126,
-0.43626895546913147,
0.15117302536964417,
-0.6298975944519043,
0.3857659101486206,
0.3509151339530945,
-0.8416950106620789,
0.28520694375038147,
0.11740536242723465,
-0.20800252258777618,
0.4071190059185028,
-0.8491791486740112,
1.2232478857040405,
-0.5001277923583984,
-0.43864119052886963,
-0.17396435141563416,
-0.7610720992088318,
-0.07857923209667206,
0.46373945474624634,
-0.012655752710998058,
0.05868588015437126,
0.09285596013069153,
0.2880721390247345,
-0.5077952742576599,
0.7725778818130493,
-0.5166312456130981,
-0.5272316932678223,
0.16135850548744202,
0.42101314663887024,
0.6786855459213257,
0.36613938212394714,
0.08572877943515778,
-0.07718097418546677,
0.16088464856147766,
-0.2376735657453537,
-0.6269108653068542,
0.4042934477329254,
-0.8568733930587769,
-0.4608958959579468,
-0.8240088820457458,
-0.7149118781089783,
-0.14989633858203888,
0.41958069801330566,
0.31660956144332886,
0.6288416981697083,
-0.08908026665449142,
-0.17897629737854004,
0.6196328401565552,
-0.20250767469406128,
0.29800355434417725,
0.6406922340393066,
-0.439995139837265,
-0.09516690671443939,
1.112821102142334,
-0.1854339987039566,
0.21322019398212433,
0.641847550868988,
-0.25343939661979675,
-0.4444305896759033,
-0.5664946436882019,
-0.9094936847686768,
0.061862628906965256,
-0.6418495178222656,
0.0949167013168335,
-0.41205742955207825,
-0.3067043125629425,
0.02407553791999817,
-0.5611622929573059,
-0.22159932553768158,
-0.23509085178375244,
-0.22519931197166443,
-0.1603783518075943,
0.19486312568187714,
0.5690715312957764,
-0.010737106204032898,
0.450971782207489,
-0.37194427847862244,
0.47325462102890015,
-0.07452639192342758,
0.24737729132175446,
-0.31250810623168945,
-0.26693883538246155,
0.14192697405815125,
-0.15778401494026184,
-0.6076397895812988,
-0.8884361386299133,
0.28356513381004333,
0.11160917580127716,
0.13461121916770935,
0.7626670002937317,
0.10104213654994965,
0.957206666469574,
-0.7054898738861084,
0.4117070734500885,
0.17400407791137695,
-0.7435094118118286,
0.6913678646087646,
-0.5856482982635498,
0.4481758773326874,
0.4558742046356201,
-0.1465052217245102,
-0.8668068647384644,
-0.48830077052116394,
-0.29840320348739624,
-0.5926874876022339,
0.8767524361610413,
-0.08923475444316864,
-0.1844782829284668,
0.2915026545524597,
-0.023518798872828484,
0.10192783176898956,
-0.18077623844146729,
-0.780396044254303,
-0.019020356237888336,
-0.23696742951869965,
-0.1632378250360489,
-0.35797691345214844,
-0.25944310426712036,
-0.1347237080335617,
-0.09648199379444122,
0.2987847626209259,
-0.3460640609264374,
0.2546026408672333,
0.33420056104660034,
-0.743901789188385,
-0.1270274519920349,
0.16086602210998535,
0.5884143114089966,
0.7871297597885132,
-0.22528855502605438,
0.15218409895896912,
0.02655710093677044,
-0.6145528554916382,
0.1777169555425644,
0.2763005197048187,
-0.5967857241630554,
0.1698809713125229,
0.07159353792667389,
0.7783758640289307,
0.18270529806613922,
-0.48835745453834534,
0.35244929790496826,
-0.061953168362379074,
-0.20413847267627716,
-0.3214130997657776,
-0.1517997682094574,
-0.27917900681495667,
0.4134756028652191,
0.5139002203941345,
0.09260875731706619,
0.11365949362516403,
-0.4981192350387573,
0.2515464127063751,
0.21008853614330292,
-0.6665050983428955,
-0.2169886827468872,
0.5540760159492493,
0.5271645784378052,
-0.2711620330810547,
0.5948697328567505,
-0.11120527982711792,
-0.41935205459594727,
0.47436317801475525,
0.7270912528038025,
0.5970205664634705,
0.20964036881923676,
0.6579651832580566,
-0.04883985593914986,
0.11998387426137924,
0.18824854493141174,
0.06735816597938538,
-0.31709012389183044,
-0.5783268213272095,
-0.12532083690166473,
-0.0911429151892662,
-0.2647145688533783,
-0.2393355816602707,
-0.30579033493995667,
0.042348697781562805,
-0.36596956849098206,
0.030535435304045677,
-0.10014919936656952,
0.23933808505535126,
-0.10898185521364212,
0.3701421320438385,
0.1447107195854187,
0.9663788080215454,
-0.5487427711486816,
0.8942647576332092,
0.8989182710647583,
-0.16001643240451813,
-0.7276579141616821,
0.4201441705226898,
0.2613407075405121,
-0.5686747431755066,
0.4555884897708893,
0.46543294191360474,
-0.2874654233455658,
0.5187274217605591,
-0.003367263125255704,
-0.7569860816001892,
1.1918890476226807,
0.10513882339000702,
-0.4173089265823364,
-0.3962765038013458,
-0.051217786967754364,
0.13140201568603516,
-0.1927274465560913,
0.7068362832069397,
0.3775433897972107,
0.5349823236465454,
-0.04524583742022514,
-0.7236385941505432,
0.17786169052124023,
-0.5830404162406921,
-0.1530095934867859,
0.1479160040616989,
-0.434928297996521,
0.4712831377983093,
-0.3659727871417999,
-0.28857144713401794,
0.18711508810520172,
0.35229817032814026,
0.5525862574577332,
1.0361309051513672,
0.5943189859390259,
0.402498722076416,
0.8207404017448425,
-0.046424273401498795,
1.1403192281723022,
-0.48536139726638794,
0.17446531355381012,
0.8849014639854431,
-0.46922653913497925,
0.6797070503234863,
0.2819809317588806,
0.16176766157150269,
0.2030140906572342,
0.7178899645805359,
0.24351291358470917,
0.6347782611846924,
-0.10558316856622696,
-0.37264496088027954,
-0.012064986862242222,
-0.03859887272119522,
-0.5238751769065857,
-0.04109871760010719,
0.37277108430862427,
-0.19031541049480438,
-0.543381929397583,
0.339265376329422,
-0.2656116187572479,
0.12477760016918182,
-0.4681621193885803,
0.8254765272140503,
-0.0014822877710685134,
-0.7324589490890503,
0.3083204925060272,
0.06817597895860672,
0.29154789447784424,
-0.6929276585578918,
0.12604732811450958,
-0.31030160188674927,
0.5275394320487976,
-0.1319192498922348,
-0.9393824338912964,
0.09703761339187622,
0.10765823721885681,
-0.4429871737957001,
-0.7077527046203613,
1.140244960784912,
-0.1566893756389618,
-0.42845267057418823,
0.3344304859638214,
0.4576481580734253,
0.1298656165599823,
-0.4236060380935669,
-0.6068403720855713,
-0.1364733725786209,
0.05032370239496231,
-0.14652715623378754,
0.3850228190422058,
0.5690523982048035,
-0.5644374489784241,
0.806806206703186,
0.5299476981163025,
-0.22429817914962769,
-0.07111772149801254,
0.08569824695587158,
0.5343644022941589,
-0.7427681088447571,
-0.9015170335769653,
-0.5277662873268127,
0.731285810470581,
-0.1684178113937378,
-0.409354031085968,
0.8392975330352783,
0.7598081231117249,
0.6977376341819763,
0.07857921719551086,
0.7808818221092224,
-0.008053572848439217,
0.2557307481765747,
-0.314529150724411,
1.059836983680725,
-0.7206363081932068,
-0.1393907517194748,
-0.3155314326286316,
-1.246787190437317,
-0.3409186899662018,
1.0252809524536133,
-0.5739791393280029,
-0.15393920242786407,
0.9942337870597839,
0.8216805458068848,
-0.3952787518501282,
-0.2862027883529663,
0.4482208788394928,
0.13581883907318115,
0.25407490134239197,
0.31955134868621826,
0.9809052348136902,
-0.20970654487609863,
0.6663301587104797,
0.15632855892181396,
-0.3010195791721344,
-0.389769971370697,
-0.7428574562072754,
-0.7873134613037109,
-0.4906718134880066,
-0.24031217396259308,
-0.6883797645568848,
0.4292309880256653,
0.36700811982154846,
0.7791758179664612,
-0.5802494883537292,
-0.3631366193294525,
-0.4224245548248291,
0.4011329710483551,
-0.22758197784423828,
-0.1599356085062027,
0.35636308789253235,
-0.054367683827877045,
-0.42155709862709045,
0.37697988748550415,
0.6704115867614746,
-0.2677918076515198,
0.20264987647533417,
-0.1959141045808792,
-0.04685705527663231,
-0.34696465730667114,
0.8171890377998352,
0.6683313846588135,
-0.7210848927497864,
-0.31745991110801697,
-0.016892515122890472,
-0.3944927155971527,
0.18271806836128235,
0.8019014000892639,
-0.6286790370941162,
0.44025689363479614,
0.3452904224395752,
0.38667532801628113,
0.49135616421699524,
0.3476221263408661,
0.6409215331077576,
-0.6250764727592468,
0.2009691596031189,
-0.03150785341858864,
0.03293868526816368,
-0.07213598489761353,
-0.259784072637558,
0.41047027707099915,
-0.04383166879415512,
-0.38452664017677307,
-0.7318507432937622,
0.19578571617603302,
-1.2333078384399414,
-0.15788981318473816,
1.1406967639923096,
-0.08865474909543991,
-0.32170623540878296,
-0.16926725208759308,
-0.9138157367706299,
0.20419913530349731,
-0.4987902045249939,
0.7245296835899353,
0.5086811184883118,
0.19136251509189606,
-0.41764822602272034,
-0.4028531014919281,
0.38908523321151733,
0.3860164284706116,
-0.912047803401947,
0.042416710406541824,
0.7358188629150391,
0.286260724067688,
0.11135926097631454,
0.8562172651290894,
0.2230173647403717,
0.5370856523513794,
0.12645754218101501,
-0.2072693556547165,
-0.07799939811229706,
-0.6785937547683716,
-0.10883450508117676,
0.2226046919822693,
0.08371450006961823,
-0.24583874642848969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19255v1 | Enhancing Video-Language Representations with Structural Spatio-Temporal Alignment | 2024-06-27T15:23:36 | 2024-06-27T15:23:36 | Hao Fei, Shengqiong Wu, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang, Tat-Seng Chua, Shuicheng Yan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | While pre-training large-scale video-language models (VLMs) has shown
remarkable potential for various downstream video-language tasks, existing VLMs
can still suffer from certain commonly seen limitations, e.g., coarse-grained
cross-modal aligning , under-modeling of temporal dynamics, detached
video-language view. In this work, we target enhancing VLMs with a fine-grained
structural spatio-temporal alignment learning method (namely Finsta). First of
all, we represent the input texts and videos with fine-grained scene graph (SG)
structures, both of which are further unified into a holistic SG (HSG) for
bridging two modalities. Then, an SG-based framework is built, where the
textual SG (TSG) is encoded with a graph Transformer, while the video dynamic
SG (DSG) and the HSG are modeled with a novel recurrent graph Transformer for
spatial and temporal feature propagation. A spatial-temporal Gaussian
differential graph Transformer is further devised to strengthen the sense of
the changes in objects across spatial and temporal dimensions. Next, based on
the fine-grained structural features of TSG and DSG, we perform object-centered
spatial alignment and predicate-centered temporal alignment respectively,
enhancing the video-language grounding in both the spatiality and temporality.
We design our method as a plug&play system, which can be integrated into
existing well-trained VLMs for further representation augmentation, without
training from scratch or relying on SG annotations in downstream applications.
On 6 representative VL modeling tasks over 12 datasets in both standard and
long-form video scenarios, Finsta consistently improves the existing 13
strong-performing VLMs persistently, and refreshes the current state-of-the-art
end task performance significantly in both the fine-tuning and zero-shot
settings. | [
-0.17829807102680206,
-0.8359788656234741,
0.549842119216919,
0.13460879027843475,
-0.40922069549560547,
0.3309885263442993,
-0.2625739574432373,
-0.4127894937992096,
0.2618991732597351,
0.20414455235004425,
-0.4787658154964447,
-0.636283278465271,
-0.3794003427028656,
-0.39750251173973083,
-0.15867294371128082,
0.8916664719581604,
-0.2799428701400757,
0.08456283062696457,
0.38488009572029114,
-0.15906426310539246,
-0.42557501792907715,
-0.0993814468383789,
-0.2593650817871094,
-0.16764216125011444,
0.4069780707359314,
0.13297517597675323,
0.6602824926376343,
0.9776381254196167,
0.2855696678161621,
0.3148401081562042,
0.02499012090265751,
0.44463396072387695,
-0.41401907801628113,
0.047905147075653076,
-0.34452638030052185,
0.15157590806484222,
-0.45005959272384644,
-0.6705313324928284,
0.8818389177322388,
0.7213709354400635,
-0.04361629858613014,
0.33265823125839233,
0.05056971311569214,
0.5829464793205261,
-0.5379760265350342,
0.3420296609401703,
-0.5239407420158386,
0.19156308472156525,
-0.4744432866573334,
-0.44875815510749817,
-0.22695280611515045,
-0.16235104203224182,
0.06581378728151321,
-0.7845730781555176,
0.13886788487434387,
-0.0701170265674591,
1.1343705654144287,
0.5626727938652039,
-0.27330392599105835,
0.44539427757263184,
-1.040544867515564,
0.3778012692928314,
-0.5304840207099915,
0.7964866757392883,
0.08685140311717987,
0.6909018754959106,
0.00013526552356779575,
-0.4550931453704834,
-0.41847172379493713,
0.30556583404541016,
0.05031776428222656,
-0.07414858043193817,
0.004469668492674828,
0.1074911430478096,
0.09103679656982422,
0.1760425567626953,
-0.8042981624603271,
0.26019197702407837,
-0.32657086849212646,
0.0065268781036138535,
0.47431355714797974,
0.3827173411846161,
0.3045508563518524,
-0.22608111798763275,
-0.6271868348121643,
-0.16980108618736267,
-0.5919623970985413,
0.35244348645210266,
0.23349879682064056,
0.6622502207756042,
-0.2588457465171814,
0.6425021886825562,
-0.03639565780758858,
0.6427571177482605,
0.28559648990631104,
0.0038939486257731915,
0.24415633082389832,
-0.32900470495224,
-0.6254255771636963,
0.24199506640434265,
0.7279168367385864,
0.45199912786483765,
0.13631168007850647,
0.03515208885073662,
0.029416309669613838,
0.01970391906797886,
0.35979023575782776,
-0.680884599685669,
-0.059976279735565186,
-0.04738585278391838,
-0.056215159595012665,
-0.10666187107563019,
0.12591901421546936,
-0.6491528153419495,
-0.12397833913564682,
-0.471831738948822,
0.3712978959083557,
-0.45896586775779724,
-0.06581556051969528,
0.33877164125442505,
0.20412400364875793,
0.34613052010536194,
0.41753917932510376,
-1.0887339115142822,
0.3887288570404053,
0.546590268611908,
0.7115855813026428,
0.15978403389453888,
-0.5833081007003784,
-0.859831690788269,
0.6391225457191467,
-0.482403039932251,
0.79677814245224,
-0.5789650678634644,
0.18084321916103363,
0.1087581068277359,
0.5351653099060059,
0.12160828709602356,
-0.030975574627518654,
0.060245465487241745,
-0.48825207352638245,
0.059190135449171066,
-0.3327726721763611,
-0.10242420434951782,
-0.08232704550027847,
0.07452201843261719,
-0.48515936732292175,
1.3846230506896973,
0.05801941454410553,
-0.44176599383354187,
0.5074297189712524,
-0.12562215328216553,
-0.4338642358779907,
0.05089716985821724,
-0.5052961707115173,
-0.5960081815719604,
-0.051845766603946686,
0.32830262184143066,
0.557867169380188,
0.18753939867019653,
0.6884030103683472,
-0.3371078670024872,
-0.4257073700428009,
-0.169225811958313,
-0.49125176668167114,
0.09383563697338104,
-0.02149377018213272,
-0.4836117625236511,
0.32631486654281616,
-0.535597026348114,
-0.1754458248615265,
-0.17500580847263336,
-0.09109567850828171,
-0.1916382610797882,
0.1259882152080536,
0.35780614614486694,
0.26585862040519714,
0.2186548411846161,
-0.5174182653427124,
0.3642852008342743,
-0.46119895577430725,
0.26304683089256287,
0.7904537916183472,
-0.0963146910071373,
0.6256791949272156,
0.10442628711462021,
0.3377448320388794,
-0.09442437440156937,
0.10549447685480118,
-0.2186724692583084,
-0.10297416150569916,
-0.09772439301013947,
-0.1048145443201065,
-0.21628281474113464,
0.22897008061408997,
-0.7199517488479614,
0.15443745255470276,
-0.7905231714248657,
-0.38178834319114685,
-0.2519901394844055,
0.191806823015213,
0.4370052218437195,
0.5467217564582825,
0.593494713306427,
-0.3125928044319153,
-0.7860392332077026,
-0.5176576972007751,
0.34357041120529175,
-0.10037402808666229,
0.07501748949289322,
0.276457816362381,
0.09036730229854584,
-0.011620387434959412,
0.9121923446655273,
-0.6304404139518738,
-0.3433166742324829,
0.05400028079748154,
-0.022630194202065468,
-0.013031928800046444,
0.2992299795150757,
0.9195756316184998,
-0.7314620018005371,
-0.6275291442871094,
0.6333672404289246,
-0.5503696203231812,
0.06897909939289093,
0.005475088022649288,
-0.054622020572423935,
0.2479449361562729,
0.45607781410217285,
-0.3810233771800995,
0.4094662368297577,
0.44826510548591614,
-0.551964521408081,
0.5463648438453674,
-0.24292264878749847,
0.3274240791797638,
-1.0456997156143188,
0.04470048099756241,
0.06918585300445557,
-0.2841010093688965,
-0.46724218130111694,
-0.26317912340164185,
-0.20863573253154755,
-0.3184802830219269,
-0.6874104738235474,
0.6756333708763123,
-0.2612243890762329,
-0.5921613574028015,
-0.10602296888828278,
0.26022741198539734,
0.09120519459247589,
0.8770561814308167,
0.4383433759212494,
0.5942243933677673,
0.601835310459137,
-0.4235174357891083,
0.09026511013507843,
0.19802914559841156,
-0.28672587871551514,
0.3234288990497589,
-0.4767778813838959,
-0.28716519474983215,
-0.3075139820575714,
0.04672229662537575,
-1.1533596515655518,
-0.372688353061676,
0.18233640491962433,
-0.27613699436187744,
0.40810444951057434,
-0.5693244934082031,
-0.13399547338485718,
-0.022953471168875694,
-0.2854369580745697,
0.6071147322654724,
0.2169504016637802,
-0.584370493888855,
0.6815791130065918,
0.17102140188217163,
-0.21838931739330292,
-0.9569920897483826,
-0.6286488771438599,
-0.09065365791320801,
-0.20075729489326477,
-0.41267457604408264,
0.7405353784561157,
0.1428556591272354,
0.07108191400766373,
0.2959500551223755,
-0.5191246271133423,
-0.005906764883548021,
-0.21324792504310608,
0.23434334993362427,
0.24389216303825378,
-0.6328740119934082,
-0.014715873636305332,
0.24805597960948944,
-0.06450969725847244,
-0.3816428482532501,
-0.4294978678226471,
0.7875880599021912,
-0.4053616225719452,
-0.4958321452140808,
-0.17190223932266235,
0.21788960695266724,
0.6981390118598938,
-0.37861958146095276,
0.3347688913345337,
0.9889479875564575,
-0.5246255397796631,
0.1657896190881729,
-0.32407239079475403,
0.20904254913330078,
-0.48725536465644836,
0.6709727644920349,
-0.07158643752336502,
-1.0316566228866577,
0.5141041874885559,
0.07323021441698074,
-0.024521125480532646,
0.09441498667001724,
0.4532025158405304,
-0.47933727502822876,
0.7700227499008179,
0.5534419417381287,
-0.2092675417661667,
1.050954818725586,
-0.3457410931587219,
0.2302904576063156,
-0.7272679209709167,
-0.38366103172302246,
-0.15078826248645782,
-0.42179808020591736,
-0.4073711335659027,
-0.6962729692459106,
0.16700619459152222,
0.17299090325832367,
-0.6564212441444397,
0.48468688130378723,
-0.2581242322921753,
0.4701904356479645,
-0.2899671792984009,
0.09848150610923767,
-0.016085101291537285,
0.3420056402683258,
0.06397037208080292,
-0.39033108949661255,
-0.5488771200180054,
-0.4760247468948364,
0.4828830659389496,
0.49309128522872925,
0.637506365776062,
0.2681881785392761,
0.4155938923358917,
0.31372520327568054,
-0.0983276292681694,
-0.6296527981758118,
0.4911518394947052,
-0.6261323690414429,
-0.039245475083589554,
-0.5973261594772339,
-0.0720951184630394,
-0.7746778726577759,
0.09692913293838501,
-0.09044303745031357,
-0.8972745537757874,
0.3313729465007782,
0.11480677127838135,
-0.6512455940246582,
0.5224556922912598,
-0.28490498661994934,
0.9247161746025085,
-0.5432989001274109,
-0.8220168352127075,
0.06013830006122589,
-0.6639994978904724,
0.021747443825006485,
0.3034650385379791,
0.20867742598056793,
-0.054570212960243225,
0.10063998401165009,
0.2710084915161133,
-0.548499584197998,
1.133907675743103,
-0.35423994064331055,
-0.18785443902015686,
0.2283739298582077,
0.11529401689767838,
0.4361012578010559,
-0.010938524268567562,
0.4177078902721405,
-0.013734248466789722,
-0.054587412625551224,
-0.4553813934326172,
-0.9098997116088867,
0.4276379644870758,
-0.6863995790481567,
-0.29751479625701904,
-0.0031939169857650995,
-0.504698634147644,
-0.1336415410041809,
0.2834281623363495,
-0.19633948802947998,
0.8502012491226196,
-0.28132888674736023,
0.14686308801174164,
0.6605497598648071,
-0.1270291954278946,
0.4334939122200012,
0.4731146991252899,
-0.5145964622497559,
-0.6032221913337708,
1.0380069017410278,
-0.02852502651512623,
0.14879432320594788,
0.7443049550056458,
0.00944148562848568,
-0.23798786103725433,
-0.4334029257297516,
-0.5577954649925232,
0.22615289688110352,
-0.4529130160808563,
-0.3694194555282593,
-0.46150389313697815,
-0.21472743153572083,
-0.3849087357521057,
-0.4813137352466583,
-0.6360195875167847,
-0.30629590153694153,
-0.07817882299423218,
-0.5102856159210205,
0.459502637386322,
0.600040078163147,
0.1426970213651657,
0.4901598393917084,
-0.7401232123374939,
0.3008761703968048,
0.16354615986347198,
0.4737831652164459,
-0.22168990969657898,
-0.48550012707710266,
-0.5600414872169495,
-0.13295426964759827,
-0.04136130213737488,
-0.5490657687187195,
0.3866877853870392,
0.17580042779445648,
0.40201395750045776,
0.5615181922912598,
-0.6259646415710449,
1.443790078163147,
-0.8365233540534973,
0.8585700392723083,
-0.023462677374482155,
-0.789518415927887,
0.4839039146900177,
-0.8377760648727417,
0.08019555360078812,
0.4066803753376007,
0.2797926664352417,
-0.4143056273460388,
-0.056031107902526855,
-0.34406188130378723,
-0.9043850898742676,
0.4489687979221344,
-0.12646465003490448,
0.03822505846619606,
0.040741972625255585,
0.24730172753334045,
0.04602804034948349,
0.07545764744281769,
-0.6696050763130188,
0.07582458108663559,
-0.45359426736831665,
-0.2768944203853607,
0.016058411449193954,
-0.04751577600836754,
0.20880039036273956,
-0.3399006128311157,
0.5175961256027222,
-0.46480464935302734,
-0.046839017421007156,
0.15722279250621796,
-0.03908742219209671,
-0.4336511790752411,
0.1661490797996521,
0.7796950340270996,
0.2251427173614502,
-0.26548242568969727,
0.23634380102157593,
0.09197617322206497,
-0.41515904664993286,
0.224797785282135,
0.2071448266506195,
-0.012376544997096062,
0.08067966252565384,
0.4844162166118622,
1.0212440490722656,
1.0655767917633057,
-0.567577600479126,
0.2908964157104492,
0.44799908995628357,
0.03527907654643059,
-0.021980980411171913,
-0.28483816981315613,
-0.3009635806083679,
0.6524236798286438,
0.3616828918457031,
0.2262093871831894,
-0.15606212615966797,
-0.5840877294540405,
0.3285594880580902,
0.3618474006652832,
-0.4481407105922699,
-0.7196968793869019,
0.7355989813804626,
-0.2201310694217682,
-0.3342222571372986,
0.06626695394515991,
0.0057912422344088554,
-0.5757158398628235,
0.3390564024448395,
0.5185173749923706,
0.7598134279251099,
-0.4649050235748291,
0.4872282147407532,
0.43409478664398193,
0.18928928673267365,
-0.2157982438802719,
0.37778136134147644,
-0.38145506381988525,
-0.7050042748451233,
-0.7214276194572449,
-0.6614014506340027,
-0.051739055663347244,
0.018955165520310402,
-0.6734568476676941,
0.3411562740802765,
-0.3289937674999237,
-0.2133556306362152,
-0.3654760420322418,
0.16701561212539673,
-0.5688339471817017,
0.06035032123327255,
0.4390659034252167,
0.6824964880943298,
-1.202683925628662,
0.9946350455284119,
0.7922146916389465,
-0.3697017431259155,
-0.8807429075241089,
-0.16741804778575897,
-0.16301463544368744,
-0.5151299834251404,
0.7777165174484253,
-0.09886869788169861,
-0.5348820686340332,
-0.29599305987358093,
-0.19352595508098602,
-1.1236590147018433,
1.4255918264389038,
0.5539720058441162,
-0.6061489582061768,
-0.438355028629303,
0.3770321309566498,
0.881823718547821,
-0.35755565762519836,
-0.26832449436187744,
0.20441897213459015,
0.2464015781879425,
0.1753425896167755,
-0.9359714388847351,
-0.16918662190437317,
-0.38360828161239624,
0.013713786378502846,
0.46335211396217346,
-0.5209179520606995,
0.5719888210296631,
-0.11707013100385666,
-0.3666190505027771,
-0.2502739429473877,
0.8423853516578674,
0.3084537386894226,
0.42735084891319275,
0.3189075291156769,
0.36932799220085144,
0.6646085381507874,
0.0448610819876194,
0.6996176242828369,
-0.0879625752568245,
0.20588937401771545,
1.572314977645874,
-0.38547104597091675,
0.8870574235916138,
0.7226229906082153,
-0.020986447110772133,
0.6435084939002991,
0.42043536901474,
0.061124980449676514,
0.6851075291633606,
-0.3712056875228882,
0.10760161280632019,
-0.341716468334198,
-0.25167179107666016,
-0.19073568284511566,
0.5021626949310303,
0.39361482858657837,
-0.12776030600070953,
-0.533774733543396,
0.14159680902957916,
-0.30753186345100403,
0.36779800057411194,
-0.25368064641952515,
0.43377843499183655,
-0.15444302558898926,
-0.30852681398391724,
0.2823891341686249,
-0.31086283922195435,
0.2656981945037842,
-0.7288163900375366,
-0.11149857193231583,
-0.0907590314745903,
-0.05151432380080223,
-0.31608060002326965,
-0.8754748702049255,
0.6031524538993835,
0.17147117853164673,
-0.12985602021217346,
-0.432233601808548,
0.4807240068912506,
-0.845909595489502,
-0.2074519693851471,
0.3508610129356384,
0.16907674074172974,
-0.1749132126569748,
0.3886638581752777,
-0.26559653878211975,
0.5564844608306885,
-0.22071573138237,
-0.08221973478794098,
0.20181414484977722,
0.6439051032066345,
-0.443551242351532,
0.4797717034816742,
0.34252452850341797,
0.16935411095619202,
-0.048086825758218765,
0.33777227997779846,
0.8651751279830933,
-0.57282555103302,
-0.3989703953266144,
-0.870100200176239,
0.6974744200706482,
0.1964050531387329,
0.07147998362779617,
0.5845953822135925,
0.8350855708122253,
0.9263157844543457,
-0.044723991304636,
0.32132688164711,
0.06955751031637192,
-0.31096717715263367,
-0.9324740767478943,
0.306929349899292,
-0.4014497995376587,
0.28280800580978394,
-0.6205732822418213,
-0.9081884026527405,
-0.26480841636657715,
0.4412628412246704,
-0.467654287815094,
-0.3367478847503662,
0.41699644923210144,
0.5839475393295288,
-0.38671964406967163,
-0.27179041504859924,
0.30927684903144836,
0.26257458329200745,
0.48156607151031494,
0.48419976234436035,
0.6961631178855896,
-0.6296063661575317,
0.3708623945713043,
-0.16454195976257324,
0.17390161752700806,
-0.07481981068849564,
-0.893922746181488,
-0.6738437414169312,
-1.0135835409164429,
-0.3727779686450958,
0.06822317093610764,
0.13507366180419922,
0.8973994255065918,
0.6326857209205627,
-0.46340304613113403,
-0.28877583146095276,
0.20005716383457184,
-0.12658023834228516,
-0.43373289704322815,
-0.2563776671886444,
0.5095877647399902,
-0.1283278465270996,
-0.5861611366271973,
0.7222828269004822,
0.7033036351203918,
0.23281173408031464,
-0.2630956172943115,
-0.04354797303676605,
-0.08470116555690765,
-0.19419459998607635,
0.8633564114570618,
0.5091850161552429,
-0.7185040712356567,
-0.81943678855896,
0.16312621533870697,
-0.049151744693517685,
0.3166794180870056,
0.8318834900856018,
-0.799199640750885,
0.2567088007926941,
0.4431885778903961,
0.6978161334991455,
0.8849645256996155,
0.28374162316322327,
0.5762482285499573,
-1.1311832666397095,
0.26110735535621643,
-0.11877653747797012,
0.6305376887321472,
0.32100391387939453,
-0.513306200504303,
0.40368661284446716,
-0.026142213493585587,
-0.15132197737693787,
-0.8790537118911743,
0.2907801568508148,
-1.4227216243743896,
-0.08999970555305481,
0.8197453618049622,
0.26729026436805725,
-0.4490151107311249,
-0.004307635128498077,
-0.3088882565498352,
0.40384650230407715,
-0.25302284955978394,
0.6018838882446289,
0.3612467050552368,
0.10363613069057465,
-0.09378824383020401,
-0.2665502727031708,
0.45246216654777527,
0.14304929971694946,
-0.5829290747642517,
0.35707566142082214,
0.5332001447677612,
0.31355181336402893,
0.15755975246429443,
0.5589305758476257,
-0.2778397500514984,
0.4005301594734192,
-0.34520867466926575,
-0.11987405270338058,
-0.45109835267066956,
-0.7284069657325745,
-0.5163808465003967,
0.08818882703781128,
-0.3448100984096527,
-0.06789388507604599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19251v1 | AutoRAG-HP: Automatic Online Hyper-Parameter Tuning for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-27T15:18:21 | 2024-06-27T15:18:21 | Jia Fu, Xiaoting Qin, Fangkai Yang, Lu Wang, Jue Zhang, Qingwei Lin, Yubo Chen, Dongmei Zhang, Saravan Rajmohan, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models have transformed ML/AI
development, necessitating a reevaluation of AutoML principles for the
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems. To address the challenges of
hyper-parameter optimization and online adaptation in RAG, we propose the
AutoRAG-HP framework, which formulates the hyper-parameter tuning as an online
multi-armed bandit (MAB) problem and introduces a novel two-level Hierarchical
MAB (Hier-MAB) method for efficient exploration of large search spaces. We
conduct extensive experiments on tuning hyper-parameters, such as top-k
retrieved documents, prompt compression ratio, and embedding methods, using the
ALCE-ASQA and Natural Questions datasets. Our evaluation from jointly
optimization all three hyper-parameters demonstrate that MAB-based online
learning methods can achieve Recall@5 $\approx 0.8$ for scenarios with
prominent gradients in search space, using only $\sim20\%$ of the LLM API calls
required by the Grid Search approach. Additionally, the proposed Hier-MAB
approach outperforms other baselines in more challenging optimization
scenarios. The code will be made available at https://aka.ms/autorag. | [
-0.7369595170021057,
-0.8302116990089417,
0.28854334354400635,
0.052365437150001526,
-0.05178498104214668,
0.03430315852165222,
0.02716973051428795,
-0.2699320912361145,
0.2995215952396393,
0.24357900023460388,
-0.46821996569633484,
-0.10256394743919373,
-0.4100019037723541,
0.14241454005241394,
-0.1085212379693985,
1.1381523609161377,
-0.11038108170032501,
-0.33979323506355286,
-0.22323377430438995,
-0.11725011467933655,
-0.21101465821266174,
-0.44561997056007385,
-0.6622779965400696,
0.1256648600101471,
0.6292558908462524,
0.20464468002319336,
0.5480997562408447,
1.2194560766220093,
0.5761222243309021,
0.22891564667224884,
0.04021555185317993,
0.5850180983543396,
-0.8224365711212158,
0.4745084047317505,
-0.15216892957687378,
-0.10245312005281448,
-0.38723257184028625,
-0.16198033094406128,
0.6686669588088989,
0.07265002280473709,
-0.49940335750579834,
0.46789124608039856,
0.15479493141174316,
0.687218189239502,
-1.2235177755355835,
0.14817413687705994,
-0.9476361870765686,
-0.0328381173312664,
-0.15872827172279358,
-0.6521763205528259,
-0.2132352590560913,
-0.18445342779159546,
-0.0890675038099289,
-1.2133859395980835,
0.25593793392181396,
0.5962496995925903,
1.0880212783813477,
0.7164732217788696,
-0.3674871623516083,
-0.4343709647655487,
-0.723719596862793,
0.8822715282440186,
-0.39401543140411377,
0.0805567055940628,
0.6762952208518982,
0.6110239624977112,
-0.32343146204948425,
-0.7341899275779724,
-0.3724891245365143,
0.004160820972174406,
-0.08439885824918747,
0.21252956986427307,
-0.01041338499635458,
0.18427544832229614,
0.3412957191467285,
0.3046484589576721,
-0.6462655663490295,
0.005747045855969191,
-0.06810474395751953,
-0.20881541073322296,
0.6206316351890564,
0.25201937556266785,
-0.08057040721178055,
-0.12367958575487137,
-0.3266286551952362,
-0.013944147154688835,
-0.6764790415763855,
-0.14144501090049744,
0.4851686954498291,
0.33109191060066223,
0.13948369026184082,
0.29867008328437805,
-0.18894214928150177,
0.9496028423309326,
0.4955345094203949,
-0.023985877633094788,
0.03127726539969444,
-0.3249894380569458,
-0.0866469293832779,
-0.2110040932893753,
0.4978797733783722,
-0.0000932171824388206,
0.042243875563144684,
0.17633606493473053,
-0.3225633203983307,
-0.42552313208580017,
0.45808151364326477,
-0.7366994619369507,
-0.1447875201702118,
0.0003778755199164152,
-0.559777557849884,
-0.20690470933914185,
-0.12686967849731445,
-1.0903483629226685,
-0.4359211027622223,
-0.27204322814941406,
1.0185366868972778,
0.06137022748589516,
0.13902205228805542,
-0.2529945373535156,
-0.1648969054222107,
0.460836261510849,
0.05701193958520889,
-1.0254817008972168,
0.16680260002613068,
0.4224710166454315,
0.49766868352890015,
-0.13874036073684692,
-0.3998887538909912,
-1.0963263511657715,
0.4673961102962494,
-0.1247139722108841,
0.8840802907943726,
-0.6744545698165894,
-0.44503748416900635,
-0.044344257563352585,
-0.32932400703430176,
-0.22106319665908813,
-0.6169794797897339,
0.3429088294506073,
-0.5903501510620117,
0.5530206561088562,
-0.167402982711792,
-0.591138482093811,
0.1351896971464157,
0.2763127088546753,
-0.5207421779632568,
1.338402271270752,
0.06518644094467163,
-0.5451192855834961,
0.4335746765136719,
-0.61906498670578,
-0.21054527163505554,
0.18317076563835144,
-0.049215544015169144,
-0.7579371333122253,
-0.022472284734249115,
0.5242495536804199,
0.12642405927181244,
-0.4282481074333191,
0.12636515498161316,
-0.2681613862514496,
-0.564641535282135,
-0.4073391556739807,
-0.1249350756406784,
0.7574367523193359,
0.3828575909137726,
-0.42784544825553894,
0.05937070772051811,
-0.6690911054611206,
0.29775694012641907,
0.09183689951896667,
-0.5502936244010925,
-0.1946551650762558,
0.2882492244243622,
-0.08828072994947433,
0.20565243065357208,
0.5129988193511963,
-0.36754781007766724,
0.24838319420814514,
-0.3931596875190735,
-0.02537418343126774,
0.487510621547699,
0.2039767950773239,
0.24451661109924316,
-0.5689577460289001,
0.5113341212272644,
-0.40106651186943054,
0.4116152226924896,
-0.2174862176179886,
-0.5230988264083862,
-0.6699824333190918,
-0.45525774359703064,
0.46922415494918823,
0.5268705487251282,
-0.7092543840408325,
0.7238315939903259,
0.4802843928337097,
-0.3425838351249695,
-0.7918227910995483,
0.21055862307548523,
0.4588993787765503,
0.42898431420326233,
0.72527015209198,
-0.07813447713851929,
-0.6620417833328247,
-0.6813258528709412,
-0.5400993227958679,
-0.21040602028369904,
-0.033408667892217636,
0.7957978844642639,
0.36243557929992676,
-0.49907758831977844,
0.9557092785835266,
-0.45792117714881897,
-0.5966224670410156,
-0.01077080238610506,
0.4742761552333832,
-0.06609392911195755,
0.28385138511657715,
0.5618301630020142,
-0.7581287622451782,
-0.733437180519104,
-0.1449916511774063,
-0.5090833306312561,
-0.3392055928707123,
-0.003525161650031805,
-0.1461416333913803,
0.1495191603899002,
0.4586285352706909,
-0.49785006046295166,
0.5435940623283386,
0.3640569746494293,
0.019276374951004982,
0.4224684238433838,
-0.7924686670303345,
0.0026412508450448513,
-1.137988567352295,
0.17863640189170837,
-0.03188195824623108,
-0.0981416329741478,
-0.1727888137102127,
0.5968219041824341,
0.12121739983558655,
-0.11730969697237015,
-0.12832657992839813,
0.6938605904579163,
-0.504652202129364,
-0.16255490481853485,
-0.5514503121376038,
0.0019421686884015799,
-0.06021919846534729,
0.6030647158622742,
-0.42723461985588074,
0.6991437673568726,
0.6455276012420654,
-0.7782485485076904,
0.5085042119026184,
0.139812633395195,
0.011430831626057625,
0.4828519821166992,
-0.49181434512138367,
0.1596411168575287,
-0.4462772309780121,
0.5617417097091675,
-0.837368369102478,
-0.4285382628440857,
-0.06043268367648125,
-0.4989227056503296,
0.4475669264793396,
-0.24162103235721588,
-0.4164823591709137,
-0.1760661005973816,
-0.2554723918437958,
0.39732205867767334,
0.6660426259040833,
-0.6748262047767639,
0.7333917617797852,
0.739017903804779,
-0.11735276877880096,
-0.7235788702964783,
0.0542454868555069,
-0.04165130481123924,
-0.28967493772506714,
0.07381253689527512,
0.48698246479034424,
-0.18887518346309662,
0.012976527214050293,
-0.16391117870807648,
0.21099846065044403,
-0.18501442670822144,
-0.0032257898710668087,
-0.09466410428285599,
0.19788165390491486,
-0.011743576265871525,
0.04359851032495499,
0.2840649485588074,
-0.30222421884536743,
-0.09848473221063614,
-0.5248405337333679,
0.2533802390098572,
0.12128724157810211,
-0.15783275663852692,
-0.13862285017967224,
0.3371838927268982,
0.3508349061012268,
-0.5349552035331726,
0.5844362378120422,
0.8468174338340759,
-0.45949238538742065,
-0.3680519759654999,
-0.48138073086738586,
-0.012260673567652702,
-0.5180219411849976,
0.1978064775466919,
-0.13751119375228882,
-0.7107163071632385,
0.34516698122024536,
-0.15846291184425354,
0.22141972184181213,
0.6781798601150513,
0.9235490560531616,
-0.3466017246246338,
1.3764327764511108,
0.5894935131072998,
-0.08967859297990799,
0.2639932334423065,
-0.14596179127693176,
-0.05752035602927208,
-0.7050926685333252,
-0.23003849387168884,
-0.752964973449707,
-0.524527907371521,
-0.9674444198608398,
-0.32120075821876526,
0.8308924436569214,
-0.10349556803703308,
-0.3729526400566101,
0.2573190927505493,
-0.4612576365470886,
0.6030561327934265,
0.5564973950386047,
-0.20959007740020752,
0.07086243480443954,
0.12603679299354553,
-0.3372487723827362,
-0.02971017360687256,
-0.8775679469108582,
0.14467301964759827,
1.018426537513733,
0.08596660196781158,
0.7892202734947205,
-0.08370065689086914,
0.9125295281410217,
0.20554955303668976,
-0.0313979871571064,
-0.8088774681091309,
0.29090386629104614,
0.024325942620635033,
-0.9990272521972656,
-0.4897210896015167,
-0.6633075475692749,
-1.2618293762207031,
0.19540467858314514,
-0.40663421154022217,
-0.41269293427467346,
0.4048628509044647,
0.5278807878494263,
-0.6010288000106812,
0.17624440789222717,
-0.29712575674057007,
0.49292153120040894,
-0.2636680006980896,
-0.6205883622169495,
-0.35121920704841614,
-0.8193426132202148,
-0.1744193136692047,
-0.3921983242034912,
0.18727611005306244,
0.04197096824645996,
-0.268719345331192,
0.47841504216194153,
-0.3349399268627167,
0.2699246406555176,
-0.505283534526825,
0.07044915854930878,
0.368374228477478,
0.06515315175056458,
0.7470044493675232,
-0.1482493281364441,
-0.07400765269994736,
-0.34983646869659424,
-0.0025900572072714567,
-0.4818522036075592,
-0.6818302273750305,
0.768907368183136,
-0.7183359265327454,
-0.4158395826816559,
-0.41674476861953735,
-0.7665457725524902,
-0.3332955837249756,
0.201304093003273,
0.37219107151031494,
0.5914278030395508,
0.05474434420466423,
0.35338082909584045,
0.7229747176170349,
-0.4408981502056122,
0.4565031826496124,
0.5433181524276733,
-0.29896700382232666,
-0.4100838005542755,
1.4612661600112915,
0.0210146252065897,
-0.11668981611728668,
0.49530747532844543,
0.562850296497345,
-0.44378241896629333,
-0.38697534799575806,
-0.7561234831809998,
0.17892299592494965,
-0.21203014254570007,
-0.4051763117313385,
-0.4335101246833801,
-0.23485969007015228,
-0.2290223389863968,
-0.09503982961177826,
-0.20121949911117554,
-0.3639735281467438,
-0.3346494138240814,
0.4445699155330658,
0.27369797229766846,
0.8250184655189514,
-0.2661508619785309,
0.13328662514686584,
-0.7629480957984924,
0.754210352897644,
0.5907590985298157,
0.44332972168922424,
-0.20415425300598145,
-0.7552490234375,
-0.5080491900444031,
0.04736318439245224,
-0.428714394569397,
-0.6182814240455627,
0.6012841463088989,
0.7331683039665222,
0.7253531813621521,
0.10204430669546127,
0.07496549189090729,
0.8484495878219604,
-0.448807954788208,
0.32299330830574036,
-0.48591601848602295,
-0.5435999631881714,
0.40943101048469543,
-0.7214887738227844,
0.2896419167518616,
0.6840296387672424,
0.7374143600463867,
-0.014849899336695671,
-0.23253801465034485,
-0.4609644412994385,
-0.8830497860908508,
0.5081971287727356,
0.1989748328924179,
-0.17311201989650726,
0.28182828426361084,
0.6107404232025146,
0.07339920103549957,
0.11860327422618866,
-0.2286829948425293,
-0.36192622780799866,
-0.02595146931707859,
-0.2513229250907898,
0.2363855391740799,
-0.10211629420518875,
0.0754685252904892,
-0.5628210306167603,
0.7043783068656921,
-0.24051471054553986,
0.3661186993122101,
-0.055287811905145645,
-0.09820224344730377,
-0.529771089553833,
-0.06949083507061005,
0.2435508668422699,
0.6623684167861938,
-0.33754971623420715,
-0.2940157353878021,
0.25353652238845825,
-0.4055429995059967,
0.12943482398986816,
0.4821005165576935,
-0.17588335275650024,
-0.18793198466300964,
-0.10160746425390244,
0.6637299060821533,
0.10123764723539352,
-0.4720929265022278,
0.19076360762119293,
-0.07727173715829849,
-0.34679439663887024,
-0.13492082059383392,
0.2066962718963623,
-0.3828606605529785,
-0.08772490173578262,
0.7865409851074219,
-0.2630883455276489,
0.32122519612312317,
-0.5025492310523987,
0.3928850293159485,
0.5155593752861023,
-0.1859174221754074,
0.1638467162847519,
0.8373626470565796,
0.20509007573127747,
-0.41346168518066406,
0.3997703492641449,
-0.5031734108924866,
-0.24501155316829681,
0.5219507217407227,
0.7385360598564148,
0.8651307225227356,
-0.36107826232910156,
0.07603026926517487,
0.5278074145317078,
0.057820383459329605,
-0.004940934479236603,
0.24900315701961517,
-0.20203089714050293,
-0.27206283807754517,
-0.49319061636924744,
-0.8878619074821472,
-0.4995865225791931,
-0.02040155790746212,
-0.868349015712738,
0.21118544042110443,
-0.327077716588974,
-0.0415169894695282,
-0.26268306374549866,
0.1944175660610199,
-0.3827112019062042,
0.21158678829669952,
0.03606857359409332,
0.5532747507095337,
-0.18247194588184357,
0.7263652086257935,
0.609107255935669,
0.09898672252893448,
-0.4905194640159607,
0.24421444535255432,
0.14220485091209412,
-0.7669647932052612,
0.2722170352935791,
-0.235957533121109,
-0.24738597869873047,
0.61497563123703,
-0.5087536573410034,
-1.2237708568572998,
0.9368314146995544,
0.135063037276268,
-0.4723356068134308,
-0.30861154198646545,
-0.1941981315612793,
0.6969138979911804,
-0.3766803741455078,
0.397433340549469,
0.49689674377441406,
0.5397918820381165,
0.06577876210212708,
-1.236335039138794,
-0.421085000038147,
-0.14520591497421265,
-0.14417552947998047,
0.5154920220375061,
-0.6470886468887329,
0.6708799004554749,
-0.13251172006130219,
-0.09686560183763504,
0.1277153491973877,
0.41237083077430725,
0.3764321208000183,
0.3367179036140442,
0.36827507615089417,
0.6812267899513245,
0.6165245175361633,
0.23178274929523468,
1.008284568786621,
-0.49633485078811646,
0.6771856546401978,
0.9291523098945618,
-0.41793787479400635,
0.9245513677597046,
0.03826327621936798,
-0.023457271978259087,
0.5040338635444641,
0.4697842299938202,
-0.01799929141998291,
0.4741935431957245,
0.2716251313686371,
-0.1355648636817932,
-0.1495107263326645,
-0.13042810559272766,
-0.3544102609157562,
0.6868456602096558,
0.5885446667671204,
-0.09194213151931763,
-0.4146290123462677,
-0.07651136815547943,
-0.29584017395973206,
-0.015110048465430737,
-0.4096507430076599,
1.0811080932617188,
-0.29635533690452576,
-0.6654598712921143,
0.8443496823310852,
0.055896565318107605,
0.520514190196991,
-0.6024410724639893,
-0.17547978460788727,
-0.1327541023492813,
0.11836989223957062,
-0.06325746327638626,
-0.21989357471466064,
0.1742117553949356,
-0.0021655200980603695,
0.01460314355790615,
-0.2858926057815552,
0.9416080117225647,
-0.5181149840354919,
-0.3928738236427307,
0.2099331170320511,
0.7174667716026306,
0.016077060252428055,
0.07849224656820297,
-0.9871358275413513,
-0.15239852666854858,
-0.2766984701156616,
-0.14792171120643616,
0.6443904042243958,
0.20997710525989532,
0.23370786011219025,
0.6419596076011658,
0.4697614908218384,
0.1469981074333191,
0.1158272996544838,
-0.3560251295566559,
0.7376741170883179,
-0.5754181742668152,
-0.46262383460998535,
-0.5192567110061646,
0.08746252954006195,
0.12361591309309006,
-0.45116326212882996,
0.8250275254249573,
0.7112723588943481,
0.7881416082382202,
0.17566917836666107,
0.6799037456512451,
-0.11628039926290512,
0.8695594668388367,
-0.3175598680973053,
0.9687643647193909,
-0.8398076891899109,
-0.1420106589794159,
-0.13077332079410553,
-1.2090084552764893,
-0.1082838848233223,
0.600044846534729,
0.031064199283719063,
0.3193337619304657,
0.5615463256835938,
1.0050708055496216,
-0.10824860632419586,
-0.44309136271476746,
0.22813372313976288,
0.019964782521128654,
0.021327227354049683,
0.5408599376678467,
0.6118820905685425,
-0.46609506011009216,
0.6543166637420654,
0.04639925807714462,
-0.3225960433483124,
-0.4738069176673889,
-0.8434234857559204,
-0.7166019678115845,
-0.668355405330658,
0.02770232781767845,
-0.14933547377586365,
0.3880443572998047,
1.210142970085144,
0.6677941083908081,
-0.7254490256309509,
-0.41850221157073975,
0.05489310622215271,
-0.19053740799427032,
-0.15439946949481964,
-0.21754981577396393,
0.24089334905147552,
-0.6452153921127319,
-0.590836226940155,
0.5478843450546265,
0.317935049533844,
-0.20110924541950226,
-0.4153394103050232,
-0.11381055414676666,
-0.4779399633407593,
0.20908856391906738,
0.43158939480781555,
0.6517661213874817,
-0.37264174222946167,
0.04938577115535736,
0.04689782112836838,
-0.14803214371204376,
0.04416225478053093,
0.9557783603668213,
-1.182348608970642,
0.8901786804199219,
0.6051751971244812,
0.9266914129257202,
0.7552050948143005,
0.33634108304977417,
0.7176856994628906,
-0.6796471476554871,
-0.008229763247072697,
0.2761823236942291,
0.03700098767876625,
0.013478136621415615,
-0.3263881504535675,
0.08781059831380844,
0.23916654288768768,
-0.9794958829879761,
-0.6621311902999878,
0.14859448373317719,
-0.36187925934791565,
-0.09431629627943039,
1.0190035104751587,
0.17477776110172272,
-0.04292382672429085,
-0.4966144561767578,
-0.2994677424430847,
0.3526236116886139,
-0.17860659956932068,
1.168939232826233,
0.3530290424823761,
-0.30588263273239136,
-0.022952605038881302,
-0.6163063049316406,
0.9678117632865906,
0.5588557124137878,
-0.9616953134536743,
-0.05228588730096817,
0.5246186256408691,
-0.3776940405368805,
-0.10132000595331192,
0.2627556324005127,
0.07329991459846497,
0.5019037127494812,
-0.1934550404548645,
-0.17683397233486176,
-0.2608680725097656,
-0.6659339070320129,
-0.35167235136032104,
0.1955718696117401,
-0.06814758479595184,
0.020553428679704666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19238v1 | Revealing Fine-Grained Values and Opinions in Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T15:01:53 | 2024-06-27T15:01:53 | Dustin Wright, Arnav Arora, Nadav Borenstein, Srishti Yadav, Serge Belongie, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Uncovering latent values and opinions in large language models (LLMs) can
help identify biases and mitigate potential harm. Recently, this has been
approached by presenting LLMs with survey questions and quantifying their
stances towards morally and politically charged statements. However, the
stances generated by LLMs can vary greatly depending on how they are prompted,
and there are many ways to argue for or against a given position. In this work,
we propose to address this by analysing a large and robust dataset of 156k LLM
responses to the 62 propositions of the Political Compass Test (PCT) generated
by 6 LLMs using 420 prompt variations. We perform coarse-grained analysis of
their generated stances and fine-grained analysis of the plain text
justifications for those stances. For fine-grained analysis, we propose to
identify tropes in the responses: semantically similar phrases that are
recurrent and consistent across different prompts, revealing patterns in the
text that a given LLM is prone to produce. We find that demographic features
added to prompts significantly affect outcomes on the PCT, reflecting bias, as
well as disparities between the results of tests when eliciting closed-form vs.
open domain responses. Additionally, patterns in the plain text rationales via
tropes show that similar justifications are repeatedly generated across models
and prompts even with disparate stances. | [
-0.5583606362342834,
-0.8437131643295288,
0.6319239139556885,
-0.12194254994392395,
-0.27285057306289673,
-0.17876407504081726,
-0.3148610591888428,
-0.020099779590964317,
0.09279439598321915,
0.6257060170173645,
-0.46662068367004395,
-0.5683044195175171,
-0.5421142578125,
-0.05789514258503914,
-0.11171816289424896,
1.262113094329834,
0.33190691471099854,
0.17635847628116608,
0.024224989116191864,
-0.18370266258716583,
-0.24134200811386108,
-0.7658373117446899,
-0.36422058939933777,
-0.41229158639907837,
0.6672517657279968,
0.3496611416339874,
0.9194857478141785,
0.43716540932655334,
0.3569364845752716,
0.16167429089546204,
-0.37625783681869507,
-0.15631593763828278,
-0.6737332940101624,
0.03973717615008354,
-0.44736799597740173,
-0.5633280873298645,
-0.4051957130432129,
0.44724297523498535,
0.4332173466682434,
0.7744572162628174,
0.3032170534133911,
0.3781810700893402,
0.1803368777036667,
0.4892161786556244,
-0.4505229890346527,
0.08446559309959412,
-0.9950848817825317,
0.04117560014128685,
-0.4847942292690277,
-0.26946017146110535,
-0.5103181600570679,
-0.46463122963905334,
0.2337789386510849,
-0.1780865639448166,
0.4017829895019531,
-0.16412493586540222,
0.8277583122253418,
-0.13966800272464752,
-0.4989662170410156,
-0.3348376750946045,
-0.5061943531036377,
1.0802453756332397,
-0.9838871955871582,
-0.02435842901468277,
0.16513283550739288,
0.15789230167865753,
-0.2988818287849426,
-0.33428293466567993,
-0.5528826117515564,
-0.20420341193675995,
-0.11218468099832535,
-0.06542445719242096,
0.15136924386024475,
-0.0011282998602837324,
0.20407797396183014,
0.5412527918815613,
-0.49824389815330505,
0.2199479341506958,
-0.06492152810096741,
-0.237470805644989,
0.5303133130073547,
0.3778820037841797,
0.022165440022945404,
-0.5679452419281006,
-0.27998068928718567,
-0.3757845163345337,
-0.8945038318634033,
0.476468950510025,
0.6943585276603699,
0.7120409607887268,
-0.2437719851732254,
0.8776819705963135,
0.02833082154393196,
0.6347130537033081,
0.4921683371067047,
-0.1167164295911789,
0.06308943778276443,
-0.29228779673576355,
-0.007007096894085407,
-0.046680133789777756,
0.9606326222419739,
0.5153926014900208,
0.4194949269294739,
0.36030828952789307,
-0.31559431552886963,
0.12673252820968628,
-0.09670376777648926,
-0.8395857214927673,
0.027222605422139168,
0.15178027749061584,
-0.7196946144104004,
-0.5156333446502686,
0.09906967729330063,
-1.2532737255096436,
-0.8482937216758728,
-0.46000710129737854,
-0.15617242455482483,
-0.19188450276851654,
-0.1819407045841217,
0.06168864667415619,
-0.054260630160570145,
0.5723039507865906,
0.4209214150905609,
-0.8495915532112122,
0.02780696004629135,
0.9651618599891663,
0.7854945063591003,
-0.31569069623947144,
0.1922345608472824,
-0.6851075887680054,
-0.30631497502326965,
-0.3743250072002411,
0.8934371471405029,
-1.094691514968872,
-0.3714201748371124,
0.0422368049621582,
0.06622093170881271,
0.19401460886001587,
-0.5389872789382935,
0.44662827253341675,
-0.4630407691001892,
0.2987796366214752,
-0.7363030910491943,
-0.3689088523387909,
0.08177430182695389,
0.6350215077400208,
-0.7064896821975708,
1.0536267757415771,
-0.08726628124713898,
-0.8924845457077026,
0.3772397041320801,
-0.41972455382347107,
0.009465634822845459,
-0.1946541965007782,
-0.6568117141723633,
-0.1802532821893692,
0.4642055928707123,
-0.02698695659637451,
0.5817270874977112,
-0.41432034969329834,
0.46554455161094666,
-0.573022723197937,
-0.042772311717271805,
0.6354450583457947,
-0.7403166890144348,
0.6271357536315918,
0.09609118103981018,
-0.44708016514778137,
0.14742013812065125,
-0.7644933462142944,
-0.10482852905988693,
-0.05718490108847618,
-0.25318604707717896,
-0.4197846055030823,
0.19095967710018158,
-0.049472395330667496,
0.39068469405174255,
0.2426336109638214,
-0.4394584894180298,
0.2827272117137909,
-0.6020069718360901,
0.3000384271144867,
1.0775898694992065,
0.061607323586940765,
0.4812524616718292,
-0.3304622769355774,
0.48949649930000305,
0.22745241224765778,
-0.09537962079048157,
0.03422335535287857,
-0.4152054190635681,
-0.5320638418197632,
-0.05071021616458893,
-0.04811262711882591,
0.37103456258773804,
-0.40805450081825256,
0.09501712024211884,
-0.16604098677635193,
-0.35144898295402527,
-0.36230209469795227,
-0.17692214250564575,
0.27700039744377136,
0.3811187744140625,
0.08149661868810654,
-0.09527844190597534,
-0.12512730062007904,
-1.0034300088882446,
-0.55178302526474,
-0.3946446478366852,
-0.12397867441177368,
0.4580099582672119,
0.6603006720542908,
0.1428612619638443,
1.1087437868118286,
-0.49718722701072693,
0.1275329440832138,
-0.02953038364648819,
0.41724762320518494,
0.309329092502594,
0.1500222086906433,
0.4696537256240845,
-0.7610405087471008,
-0.22984543442726135,
0.2112119048833847,
-0.2904818058013916,
-0.4145745635032654,
-0.17074348032474518,
0.009689440950751305,
0.058655355125665665,
0.27915897965431213,
-0.4192081689834595,
0.3384961187839508,
0.5318616032600403,
-0.567546010017395,
0.6692105531692505,
0.3070301115512848,
0.16860082745552063,
-1.0672354698181152,
-0.05175500363111496,
0.10652478039264679,
-0.12532933056354523,
-0.4090755879878998,
-0.0003502516483422369,
-0.30352848768234253,
0.2683657705783844,
-0.5115612745285034,
0.5842484831809998,
-0.018194561824202538,
0.041354358196258545,
-0.04778273031115532,
0.2143794298171997,
0.04530914127826691,
0.09677229076623917,
0.06958784908056259,
0.8643913865089417,
0.014777434058487415,
-0.2859106957912445,
0.08399549126625061,
0.10147590935230255,
0.0101179089397192,
0.6256134510040283,
-0.6985710859298706,
0.14140911400318146,
-0.39056169986724854,
0.1335137039422989,
-1.1190125942230225,
-0.18362295627593994,
0.0055043501779437065,
-0.31576114892959595,
-0.1408499777317047,
-0.321899950504303,
-0.25813359022140503,
-0.047031890600919724,
-0.5536064505577087,
0.4211999177932739,
0.2201959788799286,
-0.26966074109077454,
0.46006548404693604,
0.5104830265045166,
-0.2844075560569763,
-0.6056524515151978,
-0.3417348265647888,
-0.11113707721233368,
-0.5962822437286377,
-0.40066808462142944,
0.005594298709183931,
0.03714652359485626,
-0.7860192656517029,
-0.37982168793678284,
0.11782661825418472,
0.052926111966371536,
-0.09490346163511276,
0.17648173868656158,
0.20771178603172302,
-0.3493901491165161,
0.2632705867290497,
-0.17329996824264526,
0.050097569823265076,
0.12020766735076904,
-0.24962913990020752,
0.8962385058403015,
-0.5469475984573364,
-0.2115790992975235,
0.05600180849432945,
0.3671765625476837,
0.8164755702018738,
-0.3215923607349396,
0.6098721623420715,
0.4430229663848877,
-0.017113538458943367,
-0.09719441831111908,
-0.381811261177063,
-0.20308665931224823,
-0.4646763503551483,
0.19629353284835815,
-0.1674507111310959,
-1.0350728034973145,
0.8066492080688477,
0.04254886880517006,
0.2737651467323303,
0.6162165403366089,
0.9267765283584595,
0.09702596068382263,
0.8078157305717468,
0.2339199185371399,
-0.06092212721705437,
0.2942753732204437,
-0.11942127346992493,
0.2757835388183594,
-0.4882975220680237,
-0.19012399017810822,
-0.7728895545005798,
-0.24352385103702545,
-0.917641282081604,
-0.6615681648254395,
0.2490462064743042,
-0.23615175485610962,
-0.3901051878929138,
-0.17515511810779572,
-0.5209782123565674,
0.5019658803939819,
0.08936669677495956,
-0.08182772248983383,
0.19311682879924774,
-0.11355452239513397,
-0.13978075981140137,
-0.37318551540374756,
-0.2852073907852173,
-1.100045084953308,
0.9230289459228516,
0.4003206193447113,
0.959678053855896,
0.08147288858890533,
0.3762967884540558,
0.22989487648010254,
0.29332029819488525,
-1.132408857345581,
0.674677312374115,
-0.2606736719608307,
-0.6008692383766174,
-0.12974496185779572,
-0.48025283217430115,
-0.8388091325759888,
0.30123135447502136,
-0.2677995562553406,
-0.718824028968811,
0.37272295355796814,
0.14383558928966522,
-0.4440155029296875,
0.30684903264045715,
-0.2262147068977356,
0.7940518856048584,
-0.22473661601543427,
-0.492218017578125,
0.11601762473583221,
-0.6071584224700928,
0.360739529132843,
-0.15502086281776428,
0.21517229080200195,
-0.2793236970901489,
0.12257586419582367,
0.8299788236618042,
-0.29279786348342896,
1.166083574295044,
-0.08575037866830826,
-0.4445246458053589,
0.27563992142677307,
-0.004410309251397848,
0.43303772807121277,
0.2257012575864792,
-0.31185758113861084,
-0.02420179732143879,
0.1814284771680832,
-0.20475976169109344,
-0.407305508852005,
0.7740337252616882,
-0.7735264301300049,
-0.6876327991485596,
-0.5714128613471985,
-0.8209095001220703,
-0.11343759298324585,
0.1592010110616684,
0.19934916496276855,
0.6456702351570129,
-0.4255666136741638,
0.2931266129016876,
0.9282623529434204,
-0.47599178552627563,
0.3753686249256134,
0.33077728748321533,
-0.17370842397212982,
-0.15456150472164154,
0.5364096760749817,
0.1198318749666214,
0.5294165015220642,
0.203460693359375,
0.714778482913971,
-0.26140087842941284,
-0.2563449740409851,
-0.15950782597064972,
0.1943730264902115,
-0.540650486946106,
-0.07381020486354828,
-0.42958688735961914,
0.15573516488075256,
-0.2332875281572342,
-0.29002857208251953,
-0.571259081363678,
-0.2220640778541565,
-0.3939187526702881,
0.07219468802213669,
0.41427236795425415,
0.8801788091659546,
0.35535725951194763,
0.5365397334098816,
-0.6073623895645142,
0.1580900251865387,
0.14600372314453125,
0.05744095519185066,
-0.13208727538585663,
-0.4696752429008484,
0.2787072956562042,
0.31812164187431335,
-0.4601997137069702,
-0.9891473650932312,
0.3031475245952606,
0.022132666781544685,
0.21314997971057892,
0.7401040196418762,
0.3282729685306549,
0.7093626260757446,
-0.6289589405059814,
1.3250176906585693,
-0.02369881235063076,
-0.8421884775161743,
0.3456260561943054,
-0.6712732315063477,
0.2531490921974182,
0.6585585474967957,
0.24844512343406677,
-0.4474022388458252,
-0.5265730023384094,
-0.5525129437446594,
-0.750662088394165,
0.3373132050037384,
-0.06842280179262161,
0.35773801803588867,
-0.23030905425548553,
0.4060194492340088,
0.33494532108306885,
0.23520015180110931,
-0.8117570877075195,
-0.01267338078469038,
-0.16241835057735443,
-0.35224682092666626,
0.06932519376277924,
-0.23901522159576416,
-0.3279286026954651,
-0.03896065056324005,
0.2437414675951004,
-0.3845849633216858,
-0.05508001521229744,
0.060211487114429474,
0.2406206727027893,
0.04303750768303871,
0.6926465034484863,
0.5720347166061401,
0.6520901322364807,
-0.03830801695585251,
0.504070520401001,
-0.05285879597067833,
-0.4874269962310791,
0.2077987790107727,
-0.19939137995243073,
-0.21489928662776947,
0.07330339401960373,
0.35812264680862427,
0.4874059557914734,
-0.04787676781415939,
-0.45478421449661255,
0.6895691752433777,
0.04458019882440567,
0.08959594368934631,
-0.2691916227340698,
-0.23918552696704865,
0.07907464355230331,
0.1518516093492508,
0.10551051050424576,
-0.11847823113203049,
-0.030654529109597206,
-0.8897373080253601,
0.19188576936721802,
0.9262820482254028,
-0.4144490361213684,
-0.6081622242927551,
0.35627102851867676,
0.051651231944561005,
-0.10108579695224762,
0.12538479268550873,
-0.2532564401626587,
-0.6271787285804749,
0.5309205651283264,
0.3747260272502899,
0.6000468134880066,
-0.2260960042476654,
0.45192885398864746,
0.09289366751909256,
0.28007882833480835,
0.0045467643067240715,
0.2244880497455597,
0.4140505790710449,
-0.6856099963188171,
-0.4543411135673523,
-0.5973700881004333,
-0.16857144236564636,
0.5249394178390503,
-0.7921764850616455,
0.33614036440849304,
-0.47553810477256775,
-0.3473837077617645,
0.03969264402985573,
0.10978203266859055,
-0.47810542583465576,
0.03288891166448593,
0.1744171380996704,
0.6978839635848999,
-1.185532569885254,
0.38948965072631836,
0.5113569498062134,
-0.17159533500671387,
-0.7766380310058594,
0.2246665358543396,
0.3657761514186859,
-0.7031052112579346,
0.5722706317901611,
0.1408495455980301,
-0.2249206304550171,
-0.5154819488525391,
-0.6404926180839539,
-0.6086443066596985,
0.6001500487327576,
0.3240112066268921,
-0.5868578553199768,
-0.02816709317266941,
0.614884078502655,
0.5055758357048035,
-0.5701856017112732,
0.34356436133384705,
0.7540502548217773,
0.5717934370040894,
0.15321770310401917,
-0.8026085495948792,
0.04023311287164688,
0.048256807029247284,
-0.09478337317705154,
0.3067519962787628,
-0.5728162527084351,
1.209029197692871,
0.030073219910264015,
-0.05755368992686272,
-0.06779498606920242,
0.45204949378967285,
0.40392589569091797,
0.4112577736377716,
0.5223408937454224,
0.17257587611675262,
0.7653247117996216,
-0.16714097559452057,
0.7974016666412354,
-0.24985146522521973,
0.5081747770309448,
1.1116794347763062,
-0.2927704155445099,
0.7814260721206665,
0.7800551056861877,
0.04574023559689522,
0.39016032218933105,
0.822388768196106,
0.13737477362155914,
0.2463439255952835,
0.5015753507614136,
-0.26755857467651367,
-0.2733953297138214,
-0.4187295436859131,
-0.17622102797031403,
0.5826223492622375,
0.5077491402626038,
-0.37810182571411133,
-0.462213933467865,
-0.17579665780067444,
0.4605414867401123,
0.18764981627464294,
-0.4140242636203766,
0.708464503288269,
0.21652652323246002,
-0.5799396634101868,
0.3845510482788086,
-0.24316391348838806,
0.605760395526886,
-0.4711815118789673,
-0.21570582687854767,
-0.16348691284656525,
0.06028135493397713,
-0.2759495973587036,
-1.0535914897918701,
0.13323266804218292,
0.2980842590332031,
-0.307778000831604,
-0.10134251415729523,
0.48723655939102173,
-0.3820125460624695,
-0.52316814661026,
-0.017914796248078346,
0.4753451347351074,
0.13974176347255707,
0.0648130476474762,
-0.5463476777076721,
0.1553776115179062,
0.07558195292949677,
-0.5190058946609497,
0.25865522027015686,
0.8060500025749207,
-0.43625128269195557,
0.3340452015399933,
0.6542214155197144,
0.24875470995903015,
-0.07195700705051422,
-0.00046076069702394307,
1.0561424493789673,
-0.6147612929344177,
-0.28724873065948486,
-1.138670802116394,
0.5417700409889221,
-0.15420134365558624,
-0.47451236844062805,
0.7394248843193054,
0.5359256267547607,
0.6714949607849121,
0.08869218081235886,
0.7108136415481567,
-0.0028367997147142887,
0.3554461896419525,
-0.607365071773529,
0.5530405640602112,
-0.2286950796842575,
0.5163747668266296,
-0.3320678472518921,
-0.6363849639892578,
-0.06646300852298737,
0.6932438015937805,
-0.7831454277038574,
0.01735498383641243,
0.5700680613517761,
0.8951253890991211,
-0.026537761092185974,
-0.11894097179174423,
0.11417803913354874,
0.31974557042121887,
0.608061671257019,
0.4759629964828491,
0.980755090713501,
-0.02709450013935566,
0.2519015073776245,
0.15866513550281525,
-0.23067131638526917,
-0.038639508187770844,
-1.1117044687271118,
-1.1165543794631958,
-0.4749303460121155,
-0.08656442910432816,
-0.6244757771492004,
-0.415610134601593,
1.1072845458984375,
0.3981260359287262,
-0.8076860904693604,
-0.33577680587768555,
0.1565355509519577,
-0.0017752224812284112,
0.3052944540977478,
-0.3293773829936981,
0.4453166127204895,
-0.1587902009487152,
-0.7493714094161987,
-0.14474056661128998,
0.06552214175462723,
-0.09545523673295975,
-0.44471606612205505,
0.1395537108182907,
0.0461290217936039,
0.4637891352176666,
0.7365906834602356,
-0.0760606974363327,
-0.9678972363471985,
-0.805100679397583,
0.13390465080738068,
-0.13479258120059967,
0.13822880387306213,
0.99886155128479,
-0.583629310131073,
0.26815545558929443,
0.5948739647865295,
0.39159876108169556,
-0.10054734349250793,
0.2302074432373047,
0.6122741103172302,
-0.746239423751831,
0.20188301801681519,
0.49737808108329773,
0.26223304867744446,
0.27255383133888245,
-0.35354578495025635,
0.022676890715956688,
0.11476825922727585,
-0.5132635235786438,
-0.761604368686676,
0.4601101279258728,
-1.150079607963562,
-0.14586658775806427,
1.6096693277359009,
-0.13633237779140472,
-0.15534575283527374,
-0.05184304341673851,
-0.24165314435958862,
-0.08907171338796616,
-0.4927118122577667,
0.7239298820495605,
0.852558970451355,
0.005082632414996624,
-0.047710660845041275,
-0.6677780151367188,
0.5568175911903381,
0.22041581571102142,
-0.8267026543617249,
0.3968856632709503,
0.6659358739852905,
0.299064040184021,
0.2131461203098297,
0.3719055950641632,
-0.429559588432312,
-0.16389718651771545,
-0.4681382477283478,
-0.35181528329849243,
0.41597506403923035,
-0.01265667099505663,
-0.40835314989089966,
0.41254088282585144,
0.07165338844060898,
0.1958593726158142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19237v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19237v2 | FlowVQA: Mapping Multimodal Logic in Visual Question Answering with Flowcharts | 2024-06-27T15:01:48 | 2024-06-28T05:43:46 | Shubhankar Singh, Purvi Chaurasia, Yerram Varun, Pranshu Pandya, Vatsal Gupta, Vivek Gupta, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.IR, cs.LG | Existing benchmarks for visual question answering lack in visual grounding
and complexity, particularly in evaluating spatial reasoning skills. We
introduce FlowVQA, a novel benchmark aimed at assessing the capabilities of
visual question-answering multimodal language models in reasoning with
flowcharts as visual contexts. FlowVQA comprises 2,272 carefully generated and
human-verified flowchart images from three distinct content sources, along with
22,413 diverse question-answer pairs, to test a spectrum of reasoning tasks,
including information localization, decision-making, and logical progression.
We conduct a thorough baseline evaluation on a suite of both open-source and
proprietary multimodal language models using various strategies, followed by an
analysis of directional bias. The results underscore the benchmark's potential
as a vital tool for advancing the field of multimodal modeling, providing a
focused and challenging environment for enhancing model performance in visual
and logical reasoning tasks. | [
-0.3236277401447296,
-0.7991567254066467,
0.7632281184196472,
0.13478019833564758,
-0.09222593903541565,
0.13434015214443207,
0.2716330885887146,
-0.1525902897119522,
-0.34146779775619507,
0.6346635222434998,
-0.7588872313499451,
-0.49908432364463806,
-0.5729370713233948,
-0.2847459614276886,
-0.3661381006240845,
0.12520666420459747,
-0.4362027049064636,
0.2838359773159027,
-0.6989193558692932,
-0.6125916838645935,
-0.9122844934463501,
-0.010574565269052982,
-0.322297602891922,
-0.02743801474571228,
0.4303247034549713,
0.2848360538482666,
0.8406524062156677,
0.30173105001449585,
0.6685749888420105,
0.4690892994403839,
0.2103990912437439,
0.0942925363779068,
-0.2966082692146301,
0.5599290728569031,
-0.2004973292350769,
-0.22586438059806824,
-0.11954019963741302,
0.10032539814710617,
0.6251877546310425,
0.6791795492172241,
-0.0510622039437294,
0.4671371877193451,
-0.5364987850189209,
0.7082506418228149,
-0.9185919165611267,
0.12855754792690277,
-0.3383084535598755,
0.06788010895252228,
-0.014168960973620415,
-0.19893352687358856,
-0.2292875200510025,
-0.5353518128395081,
0.19911719858646393,
-0.6851267218589783,
-0.2708214819431305,
-0.011430795304477215,
0.901057243347168,
0.5879367589950562,
-0.771429717540741,
0.07291119545698166,
-0.5653482675552368,
0.5152963399887085,
-0.22344399988651276,
0.7587868571281433,
-0.05768699198961258,
0.9675309062004089,
0.17523176968097687,
-1.075119137763977,
-0.6164317727088928,
0.12039653211832047,
0.29919540882110596,
0.37127071619033813,
-0.41454431414604187,
-0.2610338032245636,
0.42798522114753723,
-0.23329398036003113,
-0.7993658781051636,
-0.7851320505142212,
-0.45273563265800476,
-0.28269335627555847,
0.440412312746048,
0.2872295677661896,
0.526001513004303,
-0.06387162953615189,
-0.62086021900177,
-0.4006561040878296,
-0.185295969247818,
0.6250816583633423,
-0.05374232307076454,
0.08781538903713226,
-0.05797233432531357,
0.7215728759765625,
-0.6461946964263916,
0.7818797826766968,
-0.3939381241798401,
-0.13546568155288696,
0.2934124767780304,
-0.6534773707389832,
-0.2781977653503418,
-0.5440558195114136,
0.7248662114143372,
0.5034487247467041,
0.38218924403190613,
0.16407538950443268,
0.13659189641475677,
-0.039830282330513,
0.18139468133449554,
-0.6863303780555725,
-0.2887469232082367,
0.15661479532718658,
-0.37571829557418823,
0.22883623838424683,
-0.041268035769462585,
-0.6735721826553345,
-0.6382613778114319,
-0.4519532322883606,
0.5092195868492126,
-0.5639389753341675,
-0.3582777976989746,
0.021916281431913376,
-0.5880665183067322,
0.6396529674530029,
0.7929601669311523,
0.03896196931600571,
-0.10701802372932434,
0.6329689025878906,
0.7484201192855835,
0.019498975947499275,
-0.4625411033630371,
-0.787835419178009,
-0.14112542569637299,
-0.43272078037261963,
1.1647601127624512,
-0.8430137038230896,
0.012135714292526245,
-0.24500058591365814,
-0.0029262874741107225,
-0.09282645583152771,
-0.47537216544151306,
0.5151795744895935,
-0.43250563740730286,
-0.05764971300959587,
-0.7108255624771118,
-0.23579968512058258,
-0.4211282730102539,
0.20663492381572723,
-0.6232014894485474,
0.7363444566726685,
0.1782509684562683,
-0.5918563604354858,
0.527510404586792,
-0.3334697186946869,
-0.1767391562461853,
0.48291537165641785,
-0.46673333644866943,
-0.04772889241576195,
-0.24311791360378265,
0.23276536166667938,
0.2774203419685364,
-0.1779519021511078,
0.15458713471889496,
-0.4641181528568268,
-0.1539101004600525,
0.5019768476486206,
-0.329700767993927,
0.942676305770874,
0.38452857732772827,
-0.1959780901670456,
0.3770647644996643,
-0.5573788285255432,
0.5463762283325195,
0.1733328253030777,
-0.14098408818244934,
-0.26726239919662476,
-0.04030629247426987,
-0.19047901034355164,
0.5841213464736938,
-0.0505366325378418,
-0.352373868227005,
-0.16757062077522278,
0.3578118681907654,
0.3704735040664673,
0.40839532017707825,
-0.05287454277276993,
0.2997957170009613,
-0.12371107190847397,
0.8416541814804077,
0.21936391294002533,
0.08729232847690582,
-0.31991687417030334,
-0.9032987356185913,
-0.6183773875236511,
-0.6285620927810669,
0.07830210030078888,
0.6689720749855042,
-1.1794277429580688,
-0.418449342250824,
-0.30594947934150696,
-0.7176064252853394,
-0.6079748868942261,
0.12191148847341537,
0.25454822182655334,
0.7400833964347839,
0.29106801748275757,
-0.23956522345542908,
-0.1565757840871811,
-0.9160363674163818,
-0.33850806951522827,
-0.2746398150920868,
0.150636225938797,
0.3298279345035553,
0.612309992313385,
-0.07647909969091415,
0.6970265507698059,
-0.3208504021167755,
0.24843716621398926,
-0.03943465277552605,
0.3544211983680725,
-0.23720568418502808,
0.0878969132900238,
0.5738291144371033,
-0.9395724534988403,
-0.24272379279136658,
-0.20161159336566925,
-0.8131735920906067,
-0.12583637237548828,
-0.042541008442640305,
-0.6019712686538696,
-0.373749703168869,
0.5001999139785767,
-0.6451824903488159,
0.6293585300445557,
0.5832067728042603,
-0.8358932137489319,
0.4600216746330261,
0.07356686145067215,
0.6025804281234741,
-0.44156715273857117,
0.07112446427345276,
0.0005679130554199219,
-0.3163180947303772,
-0.5961593389511108,
0.43412506580352783,
0.325471431016922,
-0.44951555132865906,
-0.7811405658721924,
0.6316362023353577,
-0.37068045139312744,
-0.10530848801136017,
0.11978887021541595,
0.3351696729660034,
0.3225821852684021,
0.4391121566295624,
0.13107584416866302,
0.8090792894363403,
0.7030781507492065,
-0.21859410405158997,
0.7465878129005432,
0.20431198179721832,
-0.5347155928611755,
0.9389544725418091,
-0.7389357089996338,
-0.13375002145767212,
-0.3955758213996887,
0.23094423115253448,
-1.4551364183425903,
-0.05799422785639763,
0.11783704161643982,
-0.3518659770488739,
-0.29477664828300476,
-0.14302949607372284,
-0.20888307690620422,
-0.38892364501953125,
-0.054497554898262024,
0.6495020389556885,
0.40047603845596313,
-0.3022712171077728,
0.9707717895507812,
0.2714375853538513,
-0.19543664157390594,
-0.5108908414840698,
-0.6838923096656799,
-0.16981767117977142,
-0.07330834865570068,
-0.9978567361831665,
-0.3830280900001526,
-0.1446729302406311,
-0.4553731083869934,
-0.06100870668888092,
-0.055187519639730453,
-0.3725869059562683,
-0.010884598828852177,
0.29156234860420227,
0.1489514708518982,
-0.3600998520851135,
0.01952674612402916,
-0.19009628891944885,
0.04499538242816925,
0.274662047624588,
-0.19762088358402252,
0.09133882820606232,
-0.5243952870368958,
-0.7421751618385315,
-0.2602105140686035,
0.4345853626728058,
0.8104251623153687,
-0.6681560277938843,
0.26008301973342896,
0.6346526741981506,
-0.2635335624217987,
-0.08579599112272263,
-0.33993181586265564,
0.4036560654640198,
-0.43301719427108765,
0.31620776653289795,
-0.5428826808929443,
-0.6385252475738525,
0.35422223806381226,
-0.09214361011981964,
-0.17424453794956207,
0.2136925309896469,
0.6426454782485962,
-0.3887037932872772,
0.8979939818382263,
0.10671420395374298,
0.7176056504249573,
0.12669198215007782,
-0.07835721224546432,
0.12712258100509644,
-0.4597468972206116,
-0.5070164203643799,
-0.4227747917175293,
-0.25070151686668396,
-0.43551793694496155,
-1.0175031423568726,
0.34756553173065186,
-0.03486998379230499,
-0.38450148701667786,
0.0369531512260437,
-0.35258612036705017,
0.4102104604244232,
0.6557990312576294,
-0.04049964249134064,
0.22283373773097992,
-0.34738078713417053,
-0.3595242202281952,
-0.04966175556182861,
-0.5439804196357727,
-0.3110852837562561,
0.8818451166152954,
0.22724302113056183,
0.6093775033950806,
0.2885865569114685,
0.0424560122191906,
-0.11099769175052643,
0.14119136333465576,
-0.5055567622184753,
0.6929978132247925,
0.13961710035800934,
-0.6889910101890564,
-0.4289727509021759,
-0.4432881772518158,
-0.6727074384689331,
0.7267410755157471,
-0.3696329891681671,
-0.4560985863208771,
0.08175655454397202,
0.05055859312415123,
-0.2009785771369934,
0.19736360013484955,
-0.9421164393424988,
1.222472071647644,
-0.4078518748283386,
-0.4854070544242859,
0.1670742928981781,
-0.519497811794281,
0.5833094120025635,
0.3821498155593872,
0.2602493166923523,
-0.49025610089302063,
-0.10625241696834564,
0.30701354146003723,
-0.4706222414970398,
0.28935712575912476,
-0.3253903090953827,
0.017009718343615532,
0.6721338033676147,
0.17988722026348114,
0.03673511743545532,
0.04873132333159447,
0.26655539870262146,
0.272207647562027,
0.3316541910171509,
-0.6206011176109314,
-0.8095272779464722,
0.4954073131084442,
-0.5761883854866028,
-0.3596445918083191,
-0.3904598653316498,
-0.5000496506690979,
-0.46896594762802124,
0.29316142201423645,
-0.05318596214056015,
0.5403889417648315,
0.03174540400505066,
0.27952322363853455,
0.7234640121459961,
-0.2972402274608612,
0.19705042243003845,
0.2239908128976822,
-0.22747506201267242,
-0.2608291506767273,
0.7763532400131226,
-0.11275278776884079,
0.2333301454782486,
0.4804231822490692,
0.12006214261054993,
-0.4574342370033264,
-0.3797634541988373,
-0.5851002931594849,
0.006260935682803392,
-1.218704342842102,
-0.05761801451444626,
-0.5568386912345886,
-0.21954575181007385,
-0.28096601366996765,
0.10447584092617035,
-0.38438647985458374,
-0.3807595372200012,
0.23650692403316498,
0.19985967874526978,
0.062010783702135086,
0.42162641882896423,
0.37756413221359253,
-0.4062175154685974,
-0.452301561832428,
0.6228208541870117,
1.090622067451477,
0.49248677492141724,
-0.1785532385110855,
-0.2745603322982788,
0.3038192093372345,
-0.05830330029129982,
-0.3505611717700958,
-0.9146957397460938,
-0.04162027686834335,
-0.15465831756591797,
0.6835631132125854,
0.10975980758666992,
-0.15918773412704468,
0.8684780597686768,
-0.5835201740264893,
0.7314444780349731,
0.314691424369812,
-0.821478009223938,
0.6872192621231079,
-0.4869861900806427,
0.9604342579841614,
0.581947386264801,
0.32017213106155396,
-0.4674049913883209,
-0.3996748626232147,
-0.21464656293392181,
-0.5695345997810364,
0.1762474626302719,
0.30575114488601685,
-0.1276320070028305,
0.23955759406089783,
-0.06013373285531998,
-0.11934765428304672,
0.2377786934375763,
-0.5594109892845154,
-0.24800387024879456,
-0.758640706539154,
-0.15516668558120728,
0.1364940106868744,
0.15427637100219727,
-0.14864742755889893,
-0.5482540726661682,
0.14542225003242493,
-0.28437909483909607,
0.22618752717971802,
0.14226850867271423,
-0.109739288687706,
0.10049137473106384,
0.16840055584907532,
0.754845380783081,
0.9920953512191772,
0.1680806577205658,
0.19828073680400848,
0.061639461666345596,
-0.2505183517932892,
0.06619718670845032,
0.15394145250320435,
-0.15553201735019684,
0.03698454424738884,
0.611772358417511,
0.8256973624229431,
-0.08017686754465103,
-1.2301807403564453,
0.9056224226951599,
-0.4900813102722168,
-0.4462186396121979,
-0.07402268052101135,
0.1453259289264679,
0.39789363741874695,
0.6308530569076538,
0.1699976921081543,
0.2671864330768585,
0.3626401722431183,
-0.4132835566997528,
0.032100267708301544,
0.6735124588012695,
-0.46111661195755005,
-0.02809801511466503,
0.8399693369865417,
0.2918097674846649,
-0.02667856216430664,
0.4076401889324188,
-0.09034781903028488,
-0.14706839621067047,
0.5987984538078308,
-0.2552189528942108,
0.6840152740478516,
0.18669751286506653,
0.42558255791664124,
0.4534592628479004,
0.3836517333984375,
0.35633087158203125,
0.7656854391098022,
-0.214742049574852,
-0.5566235184669495,
-0.31132686138153076,
-0.16418321430683136,
-0.546027421951294,
-0.1984996497631073,
-0.48821666836738586,
0.19131042063236237,
-0.358085036277771,
-0.23894882202148438,
0.16075506806373596,
-0.3898358643054962,
-1.0556401014328003,
0.30597856640815735,
0.6362070441246033,
0.9448046088218689,
-0.7165092825889587,
0.43454524874687195,
0.9699723124504089,
-0.4718322157859802,
-0.5401783585548401,
-0.178945854306221,
0.1132892370223999,
-0.7486333250999451,
0.8535604476928711,
-0.018228666856884956,
-0.4742162525653839,
-0.549421489238739,
-0.8192265629768372,
-1.0282509326934814,
1.3384321928024292,
0.46237942576408386,
-0.15384730696678162,
0.2611538767814636,
0.10528361797332764,
0.49983182549476624,
-0.3282671272754669,
0.5426899194717407,
0.3106096386909485,
0.5173707604408264,
0.398404061794281,
-0.6173987984657288,
0.12552618980407715,
-0.5585536956787109,
0.287259042263031,
-0.10934488475322723,
-0.7623181939125061,
0.8933992385864258,
-0.2856784462928772,
-0.33965378999710083,
-0.06932322680950165,
0.6459440588951111,
0.48589324951171875,
0.340655118227005,
0.45354288816452026,
0.4022212028503418,
0.8289292454719543,
-0.502960205078125,
0.9431524872779846,
0.037865154445171356,
-0.14070580899715424,
1.2067416906356812,
-0.3265247941017151,
0.9658867716789246,
0.5162325501441956,
0.017930705100297928,
0.8859816193580627,
0.32586729526519775,
0.2163061499595642,
0.55008864402771,
0.17831870913505554,
0.17189273238182068,
-0.6825062036514282,
-0.021250706166028976,
-0.3037882149219513,
0.6187812089920044,
0.06334441155195236,
0.1466873288154602,
-0.2112036645412445,
-0.00764043303206563,
-0.5026286840438843,
0.33840063214302063,
-0.2568538188934326,
0.48114293813705444,
-0.2755817770957947,
-0.8819456696510315,
0.4638862907886505,
-0.21842756867408752,
-0.008443443104624748,
-0.47327858209609985,
-0.15288566052913666,
-0.2356186807155609,
-0.13248397409915924,
0.20409895479679108,
-1.102043628692627,
0.09659308940172195,
-0.09957975894212723,
0.06841617822647095,
-0.4771615266799927,
0.6171795725822449,
-0.3510064482688904,
-0.5971635580062866,
0.1596500128507614,
0.791615903377533,
-0.14263807237148285,
0.1368941217660904,
-0.9770927429199219,
0.048712052404880524,
-0.38273587822914124,
-0.21084445714950562,
-0.23177526891231537,
0.90727698802948,
-0.12745335698127747,
1.2291139364242554,
0.36116641759872437,
-0.2529497444629669,
0.3545348346233368,
0.21244750916957855,
0.7066136002540588,
-0.721422553062439,
-0.4171394109725952,
-0.38657569885253906,
0.9176585674285889,
-0.13278408348560333,
-0.5937066078186035,
0.6413399577140808,
0.3656260371208191,
0.8078421950340271,
0.0002319709601579234,
0.7630282640457153,
0.16891472041606903,
0.30029740929603577,
-0.6158183217048645,
0.4819871485233307,
-0.8428463339805603,
-0.2550158202648163,
-0.44805365800857544,
-0.5180383920669556,
-0.026646137237548828,
0.41172006726264954,
-0.2093748301267624,
0.20762087404727936,
0.9020419716835022,
0.4095905125141144,
0.05077074095606804,
0.017454715445637703,
0.3945310711860657,
-0.11984430253505707,
0.04469539225101471,
0.6908406019210815,
1.3712577819824219,
-0.40909895300865173,
0.8255330324172974,
-0.2564696967601776,
-0.1677720546722412,
0.14394424855709076,
-0.8700142502784729,
-0.9931712746620178,
-0.8383296728134155,
-0.619814932346344,
-0.19586871564388275,
-0.2048816829919815,
0.3627496361732483,
0.928921639919281,
-0.6701971292495728,
-0.0753396600484848,
0.24711455404758453,
0.20034798979759216,
-0.43953782320022583,
-0.2218782603740692,
-0.211518794298172,
-0.05779143422842026,
-0.3655443489551544,
0.21054202318191528,
0.5688244104385376,
0.06909053027629852,
-0.371847927570343,
-0.11165741086006165,
-0.3339807093143463,
0.18309138715267181,
0.6405032277107239,
0.13999977707862854,
-0.7885879874229431,
-0.10826624184846878,
0.1933785229921341,
-0.27517926692962646,
0.16583725810050964,
0.7537561058998108,
-0.6330224275588989,
0.7769535779953003,
0.8594139814376831,
0.6126665472984314,
0.4470081329345703,
0.242364302277565,
0.40949711203575134,
-0.5139271020889282,
0.09909211099147797,
0.14905402064323425,
0.5295631885528564,
0.39831823110580444,
0.1691705584526062,
0.44452735781669617,
0.26997873187065125,
-0.17882703244686127,
-0.46029260754585266,
0.24928972125053406,
-0.995255708694458,
-0.47174209356307983,
1.115634799003601,
-0.05487723648548126,
-0.2694557309150696,
0.018671510741114616,
-0.08897516131401062,
-0.1759956181049347,
-0.1389002501964569,
-0.07981161028146744,
0.8735904693603516,
-0.13646544516086578,
-0.4832566976547241,
-0.8521178960800171,
0.15796174108982086,
0.254498690366745,
-1.005892276763916,
-0.0921393483877182,
0.8307045698165894,
0.24423125386238098,
0.09614447504281998,
0.8173681497573853,
0.09336493909358978,
0.7086299061775208,
0.23470909893512726,
-0.04983123019337654,
0.06484302878379822,
-0.42884561419487,
-0.18524593114852905,
0.3948359191417694,
-0.10825596749782562,
-0.18900957703590393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19232v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19232v2 | RuBLiMP: Russian Benchmark of Linguistic Minimal Pairs | 2024-06-27T14:55:19 | 2024-06-28T10:43:25 | Ekaterina Taktasheva, Maxim Bazhukov, Kirill Koncha, Alena Fenogenova, Ekaterina Artemova, Vladislav Mikhailov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Minimal pairs are a well-established approach to evaluating the grammatical
knowledge of language models. However, existing resources for minimal pairs
address a limited number of languages and lack diversity of language-specific
grammatical phenomena. This paper introduces the Russian Benchmark of
Linguistic Minimal Pairs (RuBLiMP), which includes 45k pairs of sentences that
differ in grammaticality and isolate a morphological, syntactic, or semantic
phenomenon. In contrast to existing benchmarks of linguistic minimal pairs,
RuBLiMP is created by applying linguistic perturbations to automatically
annotated sentences from open text corpora and carefully curating test data. We
describe the data collection protocol and present the results of evaluating 25
language models in various scenarios. We find that the widely used language
models for Russian are sensitive to morphological and agreement-oriented
contrasts but fall behind humans on phenomena requiring understanding of
structural relations, negation, transitivity, and tense. RuBLiMP, the codebase,
and other materials are publicly available. | [
-0.4484606683254242,
-0.7082479000091553,
0.2750800549983978,
0.370619535446167,
-0.2205144464969635,
-0.18104495108127594,
-0.35927727818489075,
-0.3114525377750397,
0.03753674775362015,
0.23408864438533783,
-0.31416794657707214,
-0.544113278388977,
-0.2827751338481903,
0.21305720508098602,
-0.4633013904094696,
0.9275384545326233,
0.19649940729141235,
0.14104901254177094,
-0.6148809194564819,
-0.35297268629074097,
-0.28714779019355774,
-0.33079296350479126,
0.04163030534982681,
-0.4118448793888092,
0.1592094749212265,
0.5584263801574707,
0.855591893196106,
0.46802279353141785,
0.8170075416564941,
0.3094237744808197,
-0.15339556336402893,
-0.2510526180267334,
-0.2123676985502243,
0.16793368756771088,
0.05166856199502945,
-0.40109574794769287,
-0.15037445724010468,
-0.046298518776893616,
0.9029281139373779,
0.9399123787879944,
-0.12530675530433655,
0.4380618631839752,
-0.09246684610843658,
0.5919671654701233,
-0.6566532850265503,
-0.22038371860980988,
-0.6609883308410645,
0.0916975811123848,
-0.39623019099235535,
0.07003705203533173,
-0.3681979477405548,
0.061450328677892685,
-0.10617858916521072,
-0.3243447244167328,
0.34548136591911316,
0.028823405504226685,
0.7699167728424072,
0.04506034776568413,
-0.21129469573497772,
-0.04208080843091011,
-0.3069218695163727,
0.5964519381523132,
-0.5148248076438904,
0.2760961949825287,
0.609108567237854,
0.18155892193317413,
-0.18080182373523712,
-0.5424800515174866,
-0.31168127059936523,
-0.6514801979064941,
-0.42090511322021484,
-0.17115281522274017,
-0.3263058066368103,
-0.2698439359664917,
0.3164965808391571,
0.2550303637981415,
-0.9433490633964539,
-0.01253349520266056,
-0.14504681527614594,
-0.0006057964637875557,
0.43551281094551086,
0.2819765508174896,
0.2970837354660034,
-0.4948379695415497,
-0.3800182640552521,
0.08675529807806015,
-0.6648657321929932,
-0.08415680378675461,
0.42636919021606445,
0.29986560344696045,
-0.5601454973220825,
0.8391388654708862,
-0.6421889662742615,
0.8796372413635254,
-0.2932518422603607,
0.056695301085710526,
0.2214583158493042,
-0.5840163826942444,
-0.32993608713150024,
-0.5817785859107971,
0.8493466973304749,
-0.0012096087448298931,
-0.22576922178268433,
-0.257377564907074,
-0.3125801682472229,
0.38413071632385254,
-0.17292903363704681,
-0.394822359085083,
-0.4209577739238739,
-0.10024508088827133,
-0.3173380196094513,
-0.20911559462547302,
-0.2521292567253113,
-0.9362366795539856,
-0.35149678587913513,
-0.33329564332962036,
0.10860499739646912,
-0.444547563791275,
-0.05897112563252449,
0.0113693717867136,
-0.06011762097477913,
0.18535463511943817,
0.07918532192707062,
-0.8536272048950195,
0.9401239156723022,
0.9206816554069519,
1.0013689994812012,
-0.1826712042093277,
-0.27298107743263245,
-0.6479172110557556,
-0.40268442034721375,
-0.1424352377653122,
0.9523250460624695,
-0.808298647403717,
-0.18015128374099731,
0.061546776443719864,
-0.34556442499160767,
0.19913268089294434,
-0.6385036706924438,
0.4859400987625122,
-0.07014000415802002,
0.22779269516468048,
0.009648117236793041,
-0.41293197870254517,
0.22590409219264984,
0.1185152605175972,
-0.33419355750083923,
1.0704275369644165,
-0.00020261348981875926,
-0.66523677110672,
0.2460949867963791,
-0.4694717228412628,
-0.22114726901054382,
0.6178070306777954,
-0.12345004826784134,
-0.14155249297618866,
0.34498679637908936,
-0.08990176022052765,
0.35077717900276184,
-0.605599045753479,
0.3185178339481354,
-0.33393216133117676,
0.05429620295763016,
0.46579495072364807,
0.08539707958698273,
0.6271232962608337,
0.2971916198730469,
0.048518866300582886,
-0.006713273469358683,
-1.0219981670379639,
0.10420412570238113,
0.07704195380210876,
-0.18632711470127106,
-0.5481619238853455,
-0.19520919024944305,
0.5517411231994629,
0.09395912289619446,
0.17031654715538025,
-0.2155303657054901,
0.1612912267446518,
-0.2880246937274933,
0.25720980763435364,
0.539347767829895,
-0.18635641038417816,
0.6446025967597961,
-0.4802367687225342,
0.4753226339817047,
-0.15736979246139526,
0.052757419645786285,
0.010779832489788532,
-0.6475702524185181,
-0.9757625460624695,
-0.33025020360946655,
0.4628746211528778,
0.3148929178714752,
-0.622887909412384,
0.24017080664634705,
-0.3083083927631378,
-0.5626851916313171,
-0.42545193433761597,
0.31968313455581665,
0.7201993465423584,
0.15531548857688904,
0.09358417987823486,
-0.30647292733192444,
-0.42699334025382996,
-1.1560602188110352,
-0.7024146914482117,
0.0077940612100064754,
0.026337048038840294,
-0.029269253835082054,
0.8114743828773499,
0.1603180170059204,
0.7917674779891968,
-0.3569006025791168,
-0.2481820285320282,
-0.22225205600261688,
0.32295894622802734,
0.03987305238842964,
0.5790035128593445,
0.5275969505310059,
-0.7900383472442627,
-0.7175753116607666,
0.12723831832408905,
-0.35143986344337463,
-0.19677075743675232,
0.2277776151895523,
-0.0035187765024602413,
0.2635533809661865,
0.08666937798261642,
-0.6137542128562927,
0.16539356112480164,
0.8029584884643555,
-0.6747234463691711,
0.434266597032547,
-0.04733278602361679,
-0.12558779120445251,
-0.7456234693527222,
0.37705719470977783,
0.28168150782585144,
-0.47089287638664246,
-1.0356954336166382,
0.3184361755847931,
-0.13551369309425354,
-0.2489042580127716,
-0.39325228333473206,
0.6936954855918884,
-0.512418806552887,
-0.3794563114643097,
0.10637898743152618,
0.5167984962463379,
-0.36904284358024597,
0.28986629843711853,
0.05067375674843788,
0.37757718563079834,
0.5524601340293884,
-0.3739318251609802,
0.37273356318473816,
0.40891942381858826,
-0.5965234637260437,
0.6258605718612671,
-0.360990047454834,
0.35785144567489624,
0.053794339299201965,
-0.4737386703491211,
-1.0169093608856201,
-0.252920925617218,
0.27708762884140015,
-0.5459352731704712,
0.03392266854643822,
-0.48151201009750366,
-0.5886821150779724,
0.29011332988739014,
-0.1363731175661087,
0.41708609461784363,
0.6685993075370789,
-0.08569759130477905,
0.1332179456949234,
0.550649106502533,
-0.27414265275001526,
-0.38083553314208984,
-0.5567482709884644,
0.18137378990650177,
-0.1255023032426834,
-0.6619374752044678,
-0.039808448404073715,
-0.10550078749656677,
-0.7399997115135193,
0.15709514915943146,
-0.04636193811893463,
-0.3875434696674347,
0.13989289104938507,
0.24155357480049133,
0.07478876411914825,
-0.31094038486480713,
0.15306410193443298,
-0.5317145586013794,
-0.17499010264873505,
-0.29498061537742615,
0.15227296948432922,
0.8008595705032349,
-0.4295199513435364,
-0.06392168253660202,
-0.2088015079498291,
0.2101443111896515,
0.12960079312324524,
-0.15496116876602173,
0.529870867729187,
0.37661731243133545,
-0.4603897035121918,
-0.2911217212677002,
-0.7372121810913086,
-0.01210453175008297,
-0.41975605487823486,
0.16549380123615265,
-0.5460931658744812,
-0.6005518436431885,
0.4786120653152466,
0.19916905462741852,
-0.38305261731147766,
0.2729412317276001,
0.495156466960907,
0.09563641995191574,
0.3640565872192383,
0.5744190216064453,
-0.0660332590341568,
0.3870812952518463,
0.06943868845701218,
-0.20172019302845,
-0.4172928035259247,
-0.16931813955307007,
-0.9607364535331726,
-0.14937123656272888,
-0.6281335353851318,
-0.5073129534721375,
0.1364380419254303,
-0.1668342798948288,
0.10514212399721146,
0.4360291659832001,
-0.2588476240634918,
0.6187422871589661,
0.6239840388298035,
-0.09269510209560394,
0.40376418828964233,
0.10196775943040848,
-0.1482848972082138,
-0.31177303194999695,
-0.7903845906257629,
-0.5240806937217712,
0.8407544493675232,
-0.0592949353158474,
0.5257828831672668,
0.11393847316503525,
0.5077040791511536,
0.48128700256347656,
0.005960002541542053,
-0.6051562428474426,
0.8182560205459595,
-0.13290639221668243,
-0.6575124263763428,
-0.12584997713565826,
-0.577705979347229,
-0.8533556461334229,
0.40320250391960144,
-0.5925664901733398,
-0.6426486968994141,
-0.09183823317289352,
0.06589289009571075,
0.08044759184122086,
-0.1997835636138916,
-0.5421006083488464,
1.2028721570968628,
-0.061567217111587524,
-0.49851205945014954,
-0.3168374300003052,
-0.5698580741882324,
0.4533528685569763,
0.22614458203315735,
0.25272905826568604,
-0.4208090305328369,
-0.30745595693588257,
0.7248337268829346,
-0.05319211259484291,
0.6320781707763672,
0.02522026002407074,
0.48383617401123047,
0.0076821111142635345,
0.5708639621734619,
0.3186800479888916,
-0.03337545692920685,
0.2968800365924835,
-0.0669424831867218,
0.06266724318265915,
-0.5908750295639038,
-0.255454957485199,
0.8798339366912842,
-0.5798656940460205,
-0.3471735715866089,
-0.6412472128868103,
-0.4938381016254425,
-0.21050719916820526,
0.2810475826263428,
-0.050825364887714386,
0.41335344314575195,
-0.5646136403083801,
0.3659444749355316,
-0.014532546512782574,
-0.08544732630252838,
0.5166259407997131,
0.713006854057312,
-0.08020148426294327,
-0.5906233191490173,
0.5947362780570984,
-0.2702583968639374,
0.38542962074279785,
0.43778160214424133,
0.2265007644891739,
0.06731021404266357,
-0.5533624291419983,
0.134718120098114,
0.5294650197029114,
-0.8227487206459045,
-0.17525026202201843,
-0.32143253087997437,
0.2212136685848236,
-0.4510754346847534,
-0.014893859624862671,
-0.31967276334762573,
-0.6342423558235168,
0.11261438578367233,
0.28712406754493713,
0.14465366303920746,
0.831804096698761,
-0.11881095170974731,
0.2428818941116333,
-0.6338555812835693,
0.48892539739608765,
-0.07739513367414474,
0.2943718731403351,
-0.6920541524887085,
-0.5109965205192566,
-0.1930108219385147,
-0.17594891786575317,
-0.10772452503442764,
-0.6560418009757996,
0.4370025396347046,
0.22444374859333038,
0.38299205899238586,
0.1566893458366394,
-0.0071592023596167564,
0.7025206685066223,
-0.4842471480369568,
0.7645200490951538,
0.391503244638443,
-1.3204877376556396,
0.49109330773353577,
-0.4272546172142029,
0.39383402466773987,
0.4490995705127716,
0.2529090642929077,
-0.8705362677574158,
-0.38697218894958496,
-0.7890924215316772,
-0.2756064832210541,
0.7975610494613647,
0.6161789894104004,
-0.1863606572151184,
0.24443243443965912,
0.18092294037342072,
0.10703827440738678,
0.17714640498161316,
-1.0144096612930298,
-0.292062908411026,
0.32395341992378235,
-0.22914211452007294,
-0.4272090792655945,
-0.39650070667266846,
-0.4779244363307953,
0.021086620166897774,
0.4156121611595154,
0.012951113283634186,
0.08733620494604111,
0.0657513216137886,
-0.409688800573349,
-0.0829489678144455,
0.3218081593513489,
1.0169912576675415,
0.6346393823623657,
0.0834788903594017,
0.31302180886268616,
0.22803600132465363,
-0.3601433336734772,
0.20408040285110474,
-0.1956743597984314,
-0.3055449426174164,
0.27293089032173157,
0.41154611110687256,
0.5040012001991272,
0.14955580234527588,
-0.6961296200752258,
0.6215651631355286,
0.08235642313957214,
0.009408591315150261,
-0.33998697996139526,
-0.2956054210662842,
-0.039303313940763474,
0.06726502627134323,
-0.031380437314510345,
0.41607892513275146,
0.09443537145853043,
-0.5509255528450012,
0.23877602815628052,
0.6003418564796448,
-0.19640174508094788,
-0.7210385203361511,
0.1858140528202057,
0.2676410377025604,
-0.4908428490161896,
0.19493766129016876,
-0.2555396854877472,
-0.17418663203716278,
0.41704657673835754,
0.33532971143722534,
0.6693094372749329,
-0.22338275611400604,
0.48568400740623474,
0.2836191654205322,
0.6069817543029785,
-0.10974452644586563,
0.07792256027460098,
-0.05165032297372818,
-0.6530194878578186,
-0.19754242897033691,
-0.4476815164089203,
-0.3764711320400238,
0.19554603099822998,
-0.6422255039215088,
0.7647282481193542,
-0.5097057223320007,
-0.04695051535964012,
0.079609215259552,
0.008414543233811855,
-0.6521336436271667,
-0.014303735457360744,
0.31856635212898254,
0.7177927494049072,
-1.1801834106445312,
0.6604980230331421,
0.7923726439476013,
-0.32234442234039307,
0.0017924121348187327,
-0.3753216564655304,
0.1146029606461525,
-0.7306037545204163,
0.8457543849945068,
-0.16298677027225494,
0.1346280425786972,
-0.4634481966495514,
-0.47656312584877014,
-0.7353202700614929,
0.4114225208759308,
0.5457549691200256,
-0.24591854214668274,
0.24780453741550446,
0.42577293515205383,
0.7328457832336426,
-0.3522781729698181,
0.11564471572637558,
0.5520654916763306,
0.45929789543151855,
-0.2533743679523468,
-0.9210001230239868,
0.2165481001138687,
-0.4270547032356262,
-0.0015573642449453473,
0.2198878675699234,
-0.5966459512710571,
0.7801175117492676,
0.23539696633815765,
-0.4000466465950012,
0.4720900356769562,
0.27388620376586914,
-0.10004688799381256,
0.3441993296146393,
0.2328297644853592,
0.6670032739639282,
0.28227129578590393,
-0.19392172992229462,
0.8652122020721436,
-0.21383191645145416,
0.3647153675556183,
1.0981853008270264,
-0.08557011187076569,
1.0938349962234497,
0.5670549869537354,
-0.34002256393432617,
0.1158626601099968,
0.24708367884159088,
-0.11765921115875244,
0.4952521026134491,
0.3318861424922943,
-0.19780607521533966,
-0.38961276412010193,
-0.11873038858175278,
-0.21227094531059265,
0.5394314527511597,
0.1872478723526001,
0.0682651475071907,
-0.14051151275634766,
-0.13118505477905273,
0.18520581722259521,
0.3600023090839386,
0.033211562782526016,
0.8253404498100281,
0.04201829433441162,
-0.8409540057182312,
0.8039534091949463,
0.02247837744653225,
0.30034637451171875,
-0.5612170696258545,
0.1178271546959877,
-0.5210912823677063,
0.20837819576263428,
-0.31927916407585144,
-0.4027707874774933,
0.11827077716588974,
0.23759347200393677,
0.17664118111133575,
-0.17142584919929504,
0.686772882938385,
-0.5156362652778625,
-0.4792543649673462,
0.1775992512702942,
0.5077394843101501,
0.23129644989967346,
0.2335844486951828,
-0.436739057302475,
0.040801893919706345,
-0.21951550245285034,
-0.05393192172050476,
0.5411572456359863,
0.4366021156311035,
0.4900575280189514,
0.7630075216293335,
0.5227181911468506,
0.42152708768844604,
0.3000721037387848,
-0.1956828534603119,
0.8100718855857849,
-0.7330187559127808,
-0.15619102120399475,
-0.7456662058830261,
0.6652600765228271,
-0.11462867259979248,
-0.5906864404678345,
0.8543232083320618,
0.6608562469482422,
0.8152239322662354,
-0.3146402835845947,
0.5122367143630981,
-0.2102775275707245,
0.3283484876155853,
-0.6133922338485718,
0.4275258481502533,
-0.5290482044219971,
0.11211494356393814,
-0.1987457126379013,
-0.9005021452903748,
-0.7574740648269653,
0.5560767650604248,
-0.24527546763420105,
-0.3499850928783417,
1.0199300050735474,
0.770960807800293,
-0.11442654579877853,
-0.28915053606033325,
0.7735171318054199,
0.3346230387687683,
-0.1163729727268219,
0.39741450548171997,
1.0062819719314575,
-0.3996078670024872,
0.5329003930091858,
-0.5508328676223755,
-0.07957281172275543,
-0.257747620344162,
-0.7987968325614929,
-1.15132474899292,
-0.8375362157821655,
-0.4563746750354767,
-0.12181998789310455,
0.09883210808038712,
0.9926060438156128,
0.4693413972854614,
-0.7341582179069519,
-0.7065321207046509,
-0.23210644721984863,
0.05804697796702385,
-0.023209532722830772,
-0.15089239180088043,
-0.15104150772094727,
-0.6799532175064087,
-0.555124819278717,
0.39788126945495605,
0.2755715250968933,
0.05915018916130066,
-0.10074068605899811,
0.07101542502641678,
-0.31703463196754456,
-0.3170720040798187,
0.23316922783851624,
0.2052018642425537,
-0.7655712962150574,
-0.12017706781625748,
0.0024061009753495455,
-0.05490215867757797,
0.1543106585741043,
1.0207184553146362,
-0.4976533055305481,
0.3668942153453827,
0.9178487062454224,
0.21677124500274658,
0.3975417912006378,
-0.050451572984457016,
0.48933446407318115,
-0.9189533591270447,
0.7225024104118347,
0.4430711269378662,
0.5143017768859863,
0.4009333550930023,
0.2521421015262604,
0.6302777528762817,
0.5579334497451782,
-0.5272705554962158,
-1.215030312538147,
0.3218178153038025,
-1.0007952451705933,
-0.006122053600847721,
1.307522177696228,
-0.14020413160324097,
-0.11101863533258438,
0.011994551867246628,
0.1124759092926979,
-0.2782975435256958,
-0.3075256943702698,
0.605660617351532,
0.8563311100006104,
0.1377149522304535,
-0.26578888297080994,
-0.5386380553245544,
0.7253996729850769,
0.7089763283729553,
-0.8372878432273865,
0.09595189988613129,
0.5873627662658691,
0.22878104448318481,
0.2593049108982086,
0.3325897753238678,
0.18429382145404816,
0.2968973219394684,
0.4959426522254944,
0.06369879096746445,
0.22076210379600525,
-0.3409883677959442,
-0.6991749405860901,
0.256858229637146,
0.26631179451942444,
-0.08298400789499283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19230v1 | Spiking Convolutional Neural Networks for Text Classification | 2024-06-27T14:54:27 | 2024-06-27T14:54:27 | Changze Lv, Jianhan Xu, Xiaoqing Zheng | cs.NE | cs.NE, cs.CL | Spiking neural networks (SNNs) offer a promising pathway to implement deep
neural networks (DNNs) in a more energy-efficient manner since their neurons
are sparsely activated and inferences are event-driven. However, there have
been very few works that have demonstrated the efficacy of SNNs in language
tasks partially because it is non-trivial to represent words in the forms of
spikes and to deal with variable-length texts by SNNs. This work presents a
"conversion + fine-tuning" two-step method for training SNNs for text
classification and proposes a simple but effective way to encode pre-trained
word embeddings as spike trains. We show empirically that after fine-tuning
with surrogate gradients, the converted SNNs achieve comparable results to
their DNN counterparts with much less energy consumption across multiple
datasets for both English and Chinese. We also show that such SNNs are more
robust to adversarial attacks than DNNs. | [
-0.07898372411727905,
-0.6090188026428223,
0.15555845201015472,
0.13456213474273682,
-0.46603766083717346,
0.03891560062766075,
-0.677903413772583,
-0.16080500185489655,
0.17085160315036774,
0.13846400380134583,
-0.1798752397298813,
-0.29536134004592896,
-0.7615933418273926,
0.05958373472094536,
-0.5250677466392517,
1.309899091720581,
0.017786934971809387,
0.13717225193977356,
0.05496428161859512,
0.002629474038258195,
-0.11665116250514984,
-0.261735737323761,
-0.9941775798797607,
-0.6337510943412781,
0.8606696128845215,
0.20234425365924835,
0.5579075217247009,
0.6898282766342163,
0.5356813669204712,
0.19894354045391083,
-0.14644992351531982,
0.38809654116630554,
-0.4393141567707062,
0.06840677559375763,
0.04562484472990036,
-0.32099422812461853,
0.12901654839515686,
-0.08904233574867249,
0.34748566150665283,
0.5100570917129517,
0.07889380306005478,
-0.06646812707185745,
0.18280862271785736,
0.623138427734375,
-0.560458242893219,
0.036912769079208374,
-0.7563150525093079,
0.3741459846496582,
-0.34095263481140137,
-0.4940840005874634,
-0.5226486325263977,
-0.2343502789735794,
0.005450959783047438,
-0.36250588297843933,
0.4011753797531128,
-0.057572584599256516,
0.7196455001831055,
0.29081088304519653,
-0.3788183331489563,
-0.168447345495224,
-0.4676271975040436,
0.5068128705024719,
-0.4616933763027191,
0.3599424660205841,
0.32167962193489075,
-0.012277696281671524,
-0.09939772635698318,
-0.8767491579055786,
-0.38086432218551636,
-0.3484489917755127,
-0.012422329746186733,
0.26536694169044495,
0.038819897919893265,
0.33669400215148926,
0.2871273458003998,
0.34701812267303467,
-0.2947564423084259,
0.22471246123313904,
-0.14383509755134583,
-0.15354423224925995,
0.8096699118614197,
0.009748623706400394,
0.25793009996414185,
-0.014359302818775177,
-0.41743239760398865,
0.047890402376651764,
-0.4727654755115509,
0.003552912035956979,
0.26449960470199585,
0.603911817073822,
0.2808722257614136,
0.4829253852367401,
0.13401734828948975,
0.28714874386787415,
0.13922090828418732,
0.19589179754257202,
0.046458110213279724,
-0.3071520924568176,
-0.1487322300672531,
0.4392094612121582,
0.7996008992195129,
0.6672876477241516,
0.2481202930212021,
-0.3623102307319641,
-0.16395089030265808,
0.2383558303117752,
0.3090682923793793,
-1.243564486503601,
-0.36549872159957886,
-0.006639920640736818,
-0.45505884289741516,
-0.35323965549468994,
-0.3989591896533966,
-0.297099232673645,
-0.658190906047821,
0.04486281797289848,
0.7145004272460938,
-0.5868174433708191,
-0.2683037221431732,
0.6034864187240601,
-0.3490751087665558,
-0.19426095485687256,
0.4244261384010315,
-1.2434338331222534,
0.31232649087905884,
0.5898245573043823,
1.0108089447021484,
-0.1822826862335205,
-0.5168206095695496,
-0.41805651783943176,
-0.2896086871623993,
-0.6244379878044128,
0.5599985718727112,
-0.07832854241132736,
-0.05397069826722145,
0.28604134917259216,
-0.0775241106748581,
-0.13153769075870514,
-0.07696692645549774,
0.30032938718795776,
-0.3424225151538849,
-0.4357968866825104,
0.09135231375694275,
-0.5684487223625183,
-0.0956236943602562,
0.3676117956638336,
-0.45275673270225525,
1.1198025941848755,
-0.35560497641563416,
-1.0268067121505737,
0.42462414503097534,
-0.3325580954551697,
-0.871389627456665,
0.12487931549549103,
-0.14989779889583588,
-0.41572079062461853,
0.2276856154203415,
-0.04585050791501999,
1.0317715406417847,
-0.19322480261325836,
0.1890197992324829,
0.13149596750736237,
-0.45145124197006226,
0.12446647882461548,
-0.7006116509437561,
0.541938841342926,
0.1273171752691269,
-0.3792542517185211,
-0.01715444028377533,
-0.6916010975837708,
-0.20453205704689026,
0.06860755383968353,
-0.5139192342758179,
-0.2641226649284363,
0.33922719955444336,
0.07852277159690857,
-0.2406415045261383,
0.39512118697166443,
-0.6406324505805969,
0.20853014290332794,
-0.5476405620574951,
0.556954026222229,
0.29682835936546326,
-0.1543470174074173,
0.6239432096481323,
-0.20907025039196014,
-0.05275209620594978,
-0.01774545945227146,
-0.2064574956893921,
-0.15792794525623322,
-0.415302038192749,
-0.9232397079467773,
0.09031552076339722,
0.350674033164978,
0.3823394179344177,
-1.0747302770614624,
0.6765606999397278,
-0.34990009665489197,
-0.7390654683113098,
-0.29636675119400024,
-0.21730467677116394,
0.11017336696386337,
0.23197254538536072,
0.39702099561691284,
-0.015179947949945927,
-0.0808972641825676,
-0.5739778876304626,
-0.4809432923793793,
0.16528958082199097,
0.09952398389577866,
0.06934304535388947,
0.4568587839603424,
-0.03599925339221954,
0.21647123992443085,
-0.12346214801073074,
-0.0014313881983980536,
-0.35156911611557007,
0.2063004970550537,
0.04219873994588852,
0.6872991919517517,
0.5006412863731384,
-0.5646443963050842,
-0.6049964427947998,
0.34832194447517395,
-0.2778305113315582,
0.24001628160476685,
-0.5033199191093445,
0.23221713304519653,
-0.19992393255233765,
0.7831722497940063,
-0.403516948223114,
0.805772602558136,
0.19130446016788483,
-0.05767742544412613,
0.35579922795295715,
-0.37761956453323364,
0.1669701784849167,
-0.9480933547019958,
-0.24070881307125092,
0.2173772156238556,
-0.3212188482284546,
-0.9336851835250854,
-0.12900003790855408,
0.33929237723350525,
-0.11161590367555618,
-0.3455135226249695,
0.2150575816631317,
-0.25511518120765686,
0.23461805284023285,
-0.4538663625717163,
-0.07776018232107162,
-0.04795520380139351,
0.4453608989715576,
0.09302084892988205,
0.6115489602088928,
0.7718604803085327,
-0.8423089981079102,
0.4216291010379791,
0.03575810045003891,
-0.44569331407546997,
0.10548939555883408,
-0.29598087072372437,
0.11414988338947296,
-0.18437916040420532,
0.20827704668045044,
-0.6502879858016968,
0.03653358295559883,
0.1399000585079193,
-0.5172162652015686,
0.5522354245185852,
0.049368903040885925,
-0.6796257495880127,
-0.1268312782049179,
-0.3574625551700592,
0.2768547236919403,
0.12992225587368011,
-0.8180356621742249,
0.3084372580051422,
0.09829381853342056,
0.3540732264518738,
-0.4108475148677826,
-1.194870948791504,
0.0014233979163691401,
-0.11142678558826447,
-0.27078163623809814,
0.6283464431762695,
0.025727294385433197,
0.632176399230957,
-0.2697922885417938,
-0.22681954503059387,
0.01007275190204382,
0.2861792743206024,
-0.029489759355783463,
-0.4533500671386719,
-0.07846507430076599,
0.4981151819229126,
0.15393953025341034,
-0.20628367364406586,
-0.15524069964885712,
-0.2814183235168457,
0.5608222484588623,
0.15203943848609924,
-0.2721930146217346,
-0.7120895981788635,
0.38159987330436707,
0.5503583550453186,
-0.23359104990959167,
0.6119373440742493,
0.7104261517524719,
-0.7614583969116211,
-0.4409215450286865,
-0.05644422769546509,
-0.269070565700531,
-0.4604754149913788,
0.7576466798782349,
-0.44830647110939026,
-0.7285192608833313,
0.05128538981080055,
-0.5438762903213501,
0.1269845813512802,
0.32613232731819153,
0.3014659881591797,
-0.021712757647037506,
1.2341841459274292,
0.6011123061180115,
0.11614630371332169,
0.7470788955688477,
-0.3224499523639679,
0.4117128252983093,
-0.6887831091880798,
-0.17762801051139832,
-0.5235986113548279,
-0.4855823516845703,
-0.6584836840629578,
-0.26158782839775085,
-0.048194512724876404,
0.14133301377296448,
-0.387072890996933,
0.462661474943161,
-0.8907749652862549,
0.356521338224411,
0.28664618730545044,
0.36423155665397644,
-0.3235483467578888,
0.2503061592578888,
0.15300960838794708,
-0.2681020200252533,
-1.0522295236587524,
-0.17484813928604126,
0.6882519125938416,
0.5613114237785339,
0.6701617240905762,
-0.31199365854263306,
0.623464047908783,
0.011578246019780636,
0.0855395644903183,
-1.271496295928955,
0.4356461465358734,
-0.7990788817405701,
-0.32108715176582336,
-0.1897776871919632,
-0.3225766718387604,
-0.939680278301239,
-0.03412729129195213,
-0.6186903119087219,
-0.8601540923118591,
0.04450355842709541,
-0.12906232476234436,
-0.4058392345905304,
0.6612226963043213,
-0.6832627058029175,
0.7577424645423889,
-0.3704410195350647,
-0.12607009708881378,
-0.2888343036174774,
-0.3250594437122345,
-0.2142685353755951,
0.16363653540611267,
-0.20030763745307922,
-0.11141391843557358,
-0.02475695312023163,
0.945946216583252,
-0.3476608991622925,
0.7167624831199646,
-0.10521848499774933,
0.19481128454208374,
0.09817030280828476,
-0.09067413210868835,
0.4974590539932251,
0.08116581290960312,
-0.2781912386417389,
0.24529486894607544,
-0.10776903480291367,
-0.20533934235572815,
-0.7909384369850159,
0.5964067578315735,
-0.6346626877784729,
-0.4318154454231262,
-0.6157928705215454,
-0.2010980099439621,
-0.054890844970941544,
0.2361125499010086,
0.5445930361747742,
0.4742255210876465,
-0.015569772571325302,
0.5293315052986145,
0.6620619893074036,
0.1642763465642929,
0.5562864542007446,
-0.00023525195138063282,
-0.13650844991207123,
-0.312136173248291,
1.0541657209396362,
0.5507777333259583,
-0.06236230954527855,
0.38834336400032043,
0.2825712561607361,
-0.23129487037658691,
-1.0309768915176392,
-0.6498112082481384,
-0.2158227562904358,
-0.5440717339515686,
-0.4500669538974762,
-0.39232492446899414,
-0.7421237826347351,
-0.14960715174674988,
-0.25132912397384644,
-0.5602902770042419,
-0.15758618712425232,
-0.7051060795783997,
-0.20049971342086792,
0.8071814179420471,
0.639225423336029,
-0.02934066392481327,
0.768611490726471,
-0.5568708777427673,
0.20353813469409943,
0.2739628255367279,
0.43125811219215393,
-0.058093201369047165,
-0.41354140639305115,
-0.6562812328338623,
-0.2078196257352829,
-0.10634230822324753,
-0.9048738479614258,
0.095469631254673,
0.5649480819702148,
0.09334671497344971,
0.443737655878067,
0.008871597237884998,
0.6938192248344421,
-0.9248335361480713,
0.8339470028877258,
0.6969083547592163,
-0.8634950518608093,
0.4874792993068695,
0.019742794334888458,
0.004780296701937914,
0.7304971218109131,
0.5222662091255188,
-0.5879025459289551,
0.14602388441562653,
-0.4893063008785248,
-0.811789870262146,
0.8121786117553711,
0.24163173139095306,
0.5468690991401672,
-0.13515102863311768,
0.7739320993423462,
0.11066221445798874,
0.19315631687641144,
-0.45827823877334595,
-0.6945242881774902,
-0.32737112045288086,
-0.4035520851612091,
-0.2426234781742096,
-0.07418033480644226,
0.09911005944013596,
-0.5405786633491516,
0.47067752480506897,
-0.19546690583229065,
0.07989991456270218,
0.23971439898014069,
-0.005205776542425156,
0.21441271901130676,
-0.10130967944860458,
0.24905744194984436,
-0.20445209741592407,
0.01945527456700802,
0.5548730492591858,
0.5710842609405518,
-0.7937641739845276,
0.29726117849349976,
0.12807521224021912,
-0.21455228328704834,
0.20313850045204163,
0.06158078834414482,
1.064480185508728,
0.30577343702316284,
0.061637651175260544,
0.637251615524292,
-0.3855102062225342,
-0.19784532487392426,
0.09840380400419235,
0.2203352153301239,
0.09428949654102325,
0.1335674375295639,
0.22348712384700775,
0.48709431290626526,
0.11711450666189194,
-0.2958473265171051,
0.1104375496506691,
0.14883849024772644,
-0.5603610873222351,
-0.20223800837993622,
0.35883522033691406,
0.34299778938293457,
-0.7906134128570557,
0.08310572057962418,
-0.3627852499485016,
-0.5999857187271118,
0.4928378462791443,
0.8364195227622986,
0.914415180683136,
-0.06789997965097427,
0.04186565801501274,
0.34748563170433044,
0.46678265929222107,
-0.27454447746276855,
0.14241093397140503,
-0.38417866826057434,
-0.7890543937683105,
-0.15534375607967377,
-0.6360762119293213,
-0.03222198411822319,
0.24734699726104736,
-0.4847756028175354,
0.2358204871416092,
-0.8752055764198303,
-0.34246134757995605,
0.19010010361671448,
0.17614774405956268,
-0.43047669529914856,
0.6130848526954651,
0.13144870102405548,
1.2221626043319702,
-0.7495978474617004,
0.7542587518692017,
0.8552373051643372,
-0.20662370324134827,
-0.5923774242401123,
0.2046412229537964,
-0.615299642086029,
-0.3130322992801666,
0.38648420572280884,
0.5907067656517029,
-0.26911696791648865,
0.36624258756637573,
-0.767828106880188,
-0.591680645942688,
0.845406711101532,
0.3230416774749756,
-0.5665319561958313,
0.19045154750347137,
0.16274990141391754,
0.5261918902397156,
-0.2472715526819229,
0.1566348820924759,
0.540073037147522,
0.08830024302005768,
-0.30327466130256653,
-0.5891426801681519,
-0.10138817876577377,
-0.3323994278907776,
0.06444639712572098,
0.09601697325706482,
-0.872018039226532,
0.6177793741226196,
0.4152302145957947,
-0.5340555310249329,
-0.07464901357889175,
1.0175297260284424,
-0.08354728668928146,
0.4978143870830536,
0.36447229981422424,
0.5675208568572998,
0.8619491457939148,
-0.23666897416114807,
0.6041923761367798,
-0.3262435793876648,
0.27938711643218994,
0.4253908097743988,
0.071940578520298,
0.882917582988739,
0.30681073665618896,
-0.045782431960105896,
0.1976538896560669,
0.7817255258560181,
0.2214278280735016,
0.6054062843322754,
0.4470953941345215,
-0.42146992683410645,
-0.3993851840496063,
-0.07357127964496613,
-0.4025750458240509,
0.2233888953924179,
0.7898998856544495,
-0.07375477999448776,
-0.16098782420158386,
0.24610398709774017,
0.13424052298069,
0.15624287724494934,
-0.6182432770729065,
0.679492175579071,
0.28157076239585876,
-0.34698382019996643,
0.5513865947723389,
0.014351014979183674,
1.1674953699111938,
-0.562265157699585,
0.29888907074928284,
-0.05556417629122734,
0.18729910254478455,
-0.3741801083087921,
-0.8887128233909607,
0.20928160846233368,
0.201832115650177,
-0.16268369555473328,
-0.27609604597091675,
0.9378992915153503,
-0.32189086079597473,
-0.39179688692092896,
0.3737770915031433,
-0.10532377660274506,
0.44635534286499023,
0.035778142511844635,
-0.7724406719207764,
-0.2570914626121521,
-0.04126675799489021,
-0.17180633544921875,
0.28119391202926636,
0.6639288067817688,
0.22483371198177338,
0.489617258310318,
0.5117696523666382,
0.37912604212760925,
0.15755212306976318,
0.18035094439983368,
0.6267443299293518,
-0.6335522532463074,
-0.5864049196243286,
-0.7467151284217834,
0.3780153691768646,
-0.11563508212566376,
-0.5756946802139282,
0.7318388223648071,
0.49149245023727417,
0.6954315304756165,
0.21865133941173553,
0.8327548503875732,
0.24155761301517487,
0.08741510659456253,
-0.5687081813812256,
1.30684232711792,
-0.7926611304283142,
-0.23296195268630981,
0.2087005376815796,
-0.381441593170166,
-0.6322473883628845,
0.7032127976417542,
-0.042322877794504166,
-0.09602058678865433,
0.8218827247619629,
0.6743252277374268,
-0.03104940615594387,
0.05732237920165062,
0.46955591440200806,
-0.09901126474142075,
0.1366305947303772,
0.32089653611183167,
0.757578432559967,
-0.8038763999938965,
0.4307418167591095,
-0.3163907527923584,
-0.06539396941661835,
-0.29425135254859924,
-0.8299124836921692,
-1.1406420469284058,
-0.5818594694137573,
-0.5059501528739929,
-0.28692200779914856,
0.11590608209371567,
0.7236518859863281,
0.6892211437225342,
-0.8201777338981628,
0.13329067826271057,
-0.6506785154342651,
-0.06590095162391663,
-0.1400003731250763,
-0.08060102164745331,
0.6422476172447205,
-0.6289317011833191,
-0.6662046313285828,
0.4480733275413513,
0.3094179630279541,
-0.0224571842700243,
-0.1149027943611145,
0.0957137793302536,
-0.1942930370569229,
0.1133836954832077,
0.5008131265640259,
0.12441904097795486,
-0.24098822474479675,
-0.47831931710243225,
-0.0966770276427269,
-0.3891249895095825,
0.1314835399389267,
0.6782386302947998,
-0.4175874590873718,
0.4983513355255127,
0.7939143180847168,
1.0806782245635986,
0.7680829167366028,
-0.4166128635406494,
0.04135271534323692,
-1.008055329322815,
0.23764513432979584,
0.2765515148639679,
0.33598920702934265,
0.40089261531829834,
-0.38570454716682434,
-0.09647765010595322,
0.036748722195625305,
-0.7504011392593384,
-0.7045270204544067,
0.21535146236419678,
-0.7136358618736267,
-0.13808800280094147,
1.1367833614349365,
-0.18095867335796356,
-0.4760739505290985,
-0.07058153301477432,
-0.5245715975761414,
0.7642894387245178,
-0.2462710440158844,
0.5652099847793579,
0.4407980144023895,
-0.0920870378613472,
-0.010606100782752037,
-0.40272578597068787,
1.0610417127609253,
0.6647292375564575,
-0.5235807299613953,
0.12395042926073074,
-0.046107735484838486,
-0.09549764543771744,
0.4469170868396759,
0.4038839042186737,
0.47090354561805725,
0.25330209732055664,
0.24484415352344513,
-0.09788835048675537,
0.14491389691829681,
-0.6106122732162476,
-0.576630711555481,
-0.012514048255980015,
-0.05957229807972908,
-0.6328511238098145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19228v1 | Tools Fail: Detecting Silent Errors in Faulty Tools | 2024-06-27T14:52:34 | 2024-06-27T14:52:34 | Jimin Sun, So Yeon Min, Yingshan Chang, Yonatan Bisk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Tools have become a mainstay of LLMs, allowing them to retrieve knowledge not
in their weights, to perform tasks on the web, and even to control robots.
However, most ontologies and surveys of tool-use have assumed the core
challenge for LLMs is choosing the tool. Instead, we introduce a framework for
tools more broadly which guides us to explore a model's ability to detect
"silent" tool errors, and reflect on how to plan. This more directly aligns
with the increasingly popular use of models as tools. We provide an initial
approach to failure recovery with promising results both on a controlled
calculator setting and embodied agent planning. | [
-0.018314242362976074,
-0.5268124341964722,
0.8574597239494324,
0.14254218339920044,
-0.005596937611699104,
0.31401392817497253,
0.3294641375541687,
-0.16337701678276062,
0.06488814949989319,
0.5114566087722778,
-1.1554523706436157,
-0.3559361696243286,
-0.6533413529396057,
0.22413335740566254,
-0.7886546850204468,
0.8208529949188232,
-0.22095446288585663,
0.0826733410358429,
-0.21732670068740845,
-0.07051685452461243,
-0.6096968054771423,
-0.2864017188549042,
-0.9246082305908203,
-0.5321945548057556,
0.5611547827720642,
0.6227149367332458,
0.9141690731048584,
0.27778077125549316,
0.6934651136398315,
0.276828408241272,
0.15313191711902618,
0.27385225892066956,
-0.5106090307235718,
0.06559153646230698,
0.06382587552070618,
-0.8896644115447998,
-0.6338670253753662,
0.11598939448595047,
0.11742918938398361,
0.9363061189651489,
-0.2550657093524933,
-0.0010854038409888744,
0.09437715262174606,
0.028297582641243935,
-0.6247461438179016,
0.07650116086006165,
-0.6132687330245972,
0.3945234417915344,
-0.026545584201812744,
-0.07080451399087906,
-0.3093092739582062,
-0.4679712653160095,
-0.2347652167081833,
-0.6606853604316711,
0.36222681403160095,
-0.12133108079433441,
0.5645868182182312,
0.7352178692817688,
-0.3535713851451874,
-0.45653989911079407,
-1.1242175102233887,
0.9802234172821045,
-0.7370744943618774,
0.28328630328178406,
0.4747592508792877,
0.44921472668647766,
-0.6187623143196106,
-0.8140509128570557,
-0.4819030165672302,
-0.19523994624614716,
0.11787708848714828,
0.2494063377380371,
-0.26398468017578125,
0.018760019913315773,
0.638204038143158,
0.017837129533290863,
-0.1251533478498459,
0.2308226376771927,
-0.18683896958827972,
-0.4768000841140747,
0.47023072838783264,
0.5248730182647705,
0.33269256353378296,
-0.05274279788136482,
-0.2765631675720215,
-0.22248893976211548,
-0.8620879650115967,
-0.25316670536994934,
0.4650305509567261,
0.10883142054080963,
-0.00023901317035779357,
0.6165040135383606,
0.13791555166244507,
0.5033126473426819,
-0.3192356824874878,
-0.5799611210823059,
-0.2695994973182678,
-0.3965824544429779,
-0.38612210750579834,
0.042804475873708725,
0.32418546080589294,
0.24599593877792358,
0.21219652891159058,
-0.03947469964623451,
-0.7284088134765625,
0.13141995668411255,
0.397039532661438,
-0.27792060375213623,
-0.4418291449546814,
0.36108672618865967,
-0.24870797991752625,
-0.4797478914260864,
-0.15706266462802887,
0.060471270233392715,
-0.7635098695755005,
-0.04883995279669762,
0.6131597757339478,
-0.08647119253873825,
-0.4340757727622986,
0.03600872680544853,
-0.4561191201210022,
0.26311203837394714,
0.7905066013336182,
-0.25669893622398376,
0.43248191475868225,
0.5795378684997559,
1.1211400032043457,
0.04664243757724762,
-0.20399078726768494,
-0.5570707321166992,
-0.07527802884578705,
-0.7555340528488159,
0.9461304545402527,
0.17482469975948334,
-1.0595085620880127,
-0.0064023518934845924,
0.27870815992355347,
0.262468546628952,
-0.6497870683670044,
0.4829822778701782,
-0.046703800559043884,
-0.05784867703914642,
-0.6762330532073975,
-0.3182426989078522,
-0.3949633538722992,
0.4780316948890686,
-0.9638750553131104,
0.8145272731781006,
0.22025395929813385,
-0.5485868453979492,
0.576041042804718,
-0.7119303941726685,
-0.35256460309028625,
-0.21215420961380005,
-0.10448018461465836,
-0.6039540767669678,
0.28385648131370544,
-0.4910638630390167,
0.53728848695755,
-0.32049548625946045,
-0.11748436093330383,
-0.6703745722770691,
-0.5391619205474854,
0.20724472403526306,
-0.3412911593914032,
1.0596911907196045,
-0.24947166442871094,
-0.4154208302497864,
0.1274949461221695,
-0.6427690386772156,
-0.05541568621993065,
0.36717069149017334,
-0.1273842751979828,
0.05074142664670944,
0.5479419231414795,
-0.025151098147034645,
-0.007949663326144218,
0.09211362153291702,
-0.5024898648262024,
-0.06291691213846207,
-0.3540639281272888,
0.19226962327957153,
0.8600379824638367,
-0.2701345980167389,
0.20508821308612823,
-0.5192539095878601,
0.828429102897644,
-0.1601988673210144,
0.20588961243629456,
0.04009207710623741,
-0.1281026154756546,
-1.0300192832946777,
0.19564038515090942,
0.1227923110127449,
0.6228426098823547,
-0.6528586149215698,
0.37309160828590393,
0.1660623699426651,
-0.6226573586463928,
-0.25524279475212097,
0.31514793634414673,
0.4648924469947815,
0.37503668665885925,
-0.09380710124969482,
-0.6859946250915527,
-0.4847762882709503,
-0.6281545162200928,
0.09488468617200851,
-0.3204897344112396,
-0.23191775381565094,
0.21764735877513885,
0.4245142936706543,
-0.4198644459247589,
1.0439437627792358,
-0.3669922649860382,
-0.605373203754425,
-0.43694400787353516,
0.10106474161148071,
0.15383726358413696,
0.23341070115566254,
0.40782949328422546,
-0.732557475566864,
0.021953102201223373,
-0.0653979703783989,
-1.0480666160583496,
-0.13590501248836517,
0.036349911242723465,
0.2616235613822937,
0.1041349470615387,
0.41778844594955444,
-0.5301945209503174,
0.6097331047058105,
0.27380526065826416,
-0.13188180327415466,
0.893819272518158,
-0.13285952806472778,
-0.3697929382324219,
-0.6528737545013428,
0.15562982857227325,
-0.2845732271671295,
-0.45863860845565796,
-0.43100616335868835,
-0.365939736366272,
-0.1438448131084442,
0.24040895700454712,
-0.683544933795929,
0.6452344655990601,
-0.6082811951637268,
-0.5771448612213135,
-0.7477449774742126,
0.11965715885162354,
-0.06837067008018494,
0.11787596344947815,
-0.26075586676597595,
0.6928623914718628,
0.3481707274913788,
-0.6392326951026917,
0.6519508957862854,
0.21084357798099518,
0.28538116812705994,
0.7819650173187256,
-0.8897519707679749,
0.3527504801750183,
0.05110954865813255,
-0.04471992701292038,
-0.8345400094985962,
-0.6587302088737488,
0.37582603096961975,
-0.38180696964263916,
0.19375953078269958,
-0.32181185483932495,
-0.8254231214523315,
-0.3507451117038727,
-0.39854466915130615,
-0.2530827224254608,
0.36877769231796265,
-0.41536039113998413,
0.9056382775306702,
0.48949161171913147,
0.011235209181904793,
-0.6049559116363525,
-0.6222215294837952,
-0.004923398140817881,
0.0036845956929028034,
-0.553152859210968,
-0.2954808473587036,
-0.3097890615463257,
-0.5956056118011475,
0.16509205102920532,
-0.5144869089126587,
-0.08687237650156021,
0.7762796878814697,
0.7190176248550415,
0.2336203008890152,
0.0009669561986811459,
0.20092004537582397,
-0.12065944075584412,
-0.17788559198379517,
0.4264417886734009,
0.03516732156276703,
0.3469478487968445,
-0.12581799924373627,
-0.9347195029258728,
0.017172716557979584,
-0.020733512938022614,
0.39978155493736267,
0.25490498542785645,
0.19254490733146667,
0.4730492830276489,
-0.6244668960571289,
-0.4712839126586914,
-0.6609584093093872,
-0.5251619815826416,
-0.4994999170303345,
0.35362616181373596,
-0.244119331240654,
-0.23527397215366364,
0.4874626398086548,
-0.40064528584480286,
0.485712468624115,
0.10634804517030716,
0.49851879477500916,
-0.23170113563537598,
1.19364595413208,
1.215782642364502,
0.0008421167731285095,
0.1198572963476181,
-0.37193048000335693,
0.09963348507881165,
-0.4938122034072876,
-0.09849057346582413,
-0.4271596372127533,
-0.4196411073207855,
-0.1516992598772049,
-0.17805343866348267,
0.6029853224754333,
0.13285613059997559,
0.023767312988638878,
0.2975243031978607,
-0.3426316976547241,
0.30389899015426636,
0.7340818643569946,
-0.06504936516284943,
0.4106021225452423,
-0.11995042860507965,
-0.1308766007423401,
0.24131019413471222,
-0.7786301970481873,
-0.9941229224205017,
0.982075035572052,
0.24174976348876953,
0.9376113414764404,
-0.05811670050024986,
0.7655476331710815,
0.21190014481544495,
0.42601442337036133,
-1.102083683013916,
0.7173917293548584,
0.10497543215751648,
-0.5885428190231323,
-0.42803460359573364,
0.1552475392818451,
-1.1060646772384644,
0.04543717950582504,
0.03943625092506409,
-0.39041292667388916,
0.2077999860048294,
0.3362307846546173,
-0.4208720028400421,
0.3967706561088562,
-0.6392592787742615,
0.9265090227127075,
-0.35252320766448975,
-0.11792001128196716,
0.06598634272813797,
-0.444694459438324,
0.34212639927864075,
-0.30724966526031494,
0.1860480159521103,
-0.3694230020046234,
-0.11574302613735199,
0.8054773807525635,
-0.3829083740711212,
1.0354655981063843,
-0.14277981221675873,
-0.06442511081695557,
0.38131898641586304,
0.5420477986335754,
0.7341558933258057,
-0.22244209051132202,
-0.022734088823199272,
-0.06500808894634247,
0.2933701276779175,
-0.2974649965763092,
-0.5789129734039307,
0.40055525302886963,
-0.7327883243560791,
-0.4889415204524994,
-0.5230676531791687,
-0.4721543490886688,
-0.08220673352479935,
0.40492308139801025,
0.04215172678232193,
0.27828991413116455,
-0.23893076181411743,
-0.11987427622079849,
0.5413467884063721,
0.11425206065177917,
0.6866984367370605,
0.8568570613861084,
-0.20557808876037598,
0.1661154329776764,
0.7276946902275085,
0.38517582416534424,
0.26079151034355164,
-0.5188267230987549,
-0.12511907517910004,
0.0554366298019886,
-0.5069199204444885,
-0.14874492585659027,
0.01564343459904194,
-1.0429871082305908,
-0.3491637110710144,
-0.42535465955734253,
-0.2947733998298645,
0.18472518026828766,
-0.1749393194913864,
-0.5083878040313721,
-0.18555955588817596,
-0.5350180268287659,
-0.34072908759117126,
0.2108955681324005,
1.2110031843185425,
-0.4476814866065979,
0.39951756596565247,
-0.8214055299758911,
-0.10158322006464005,
0.24171651899814606,
-0.1570684313774109,
-0.18393495678901672,
-0.08209102600812912,
-0.08796271681785583,
-0.045557186007499695,
-0.5242204666137695,
-0.9118770956993103,
0.41463130712509155,
-0.1229478120803833,
0.5881903171539307,
0.46236345171928406,
0.16263921558856964,
0.28391775488853455,
-0.2590532898902893,
0.507953941822052,
0.2422894835472107,
-0.6626546382904053,
0.7542062997817993,
-0.058775048702955246,
0.14161667227745056,
0.24645227193832397,
0.6154013872146606,
-0.519774317741394,
-0.37528541684150696,
-0.7895915508270264,
-0.5787991285324097,
0.5897810459136963,
0.14638787508010864,
0.10334048420190811,
0.060125019401311874,
0.2318234145641327,
0.165631502866745,
0.37360385060310364,
-0.7999182939529419,
0.03733273223042488,
0.17930930852890015,
0.013127229176461697,
0.06441245228052139,
-0.20443880558013916,
-0.5580952167510986,
0.4125690162181854,
0.3959546983242035,
-0.5301291346549988,
0.2961507737636566,
0.2151394784450531,
-0.18518207967281342,
-0.5982562899589539,
0.0503830723464489,
0.22189642488956451,
0.9185093641281128,
-0.18788059055805206,
0.3193904757499695,
0.4480012357234955,
-0.4040162265300751,
0.25363391637802124,
-0.061968717724084854,
-0.08722877502441406,
0.15468962490558624,
0.5679314136505127,
0.3836081624031067,
0.4463087320327759,
-0.8945189714431763,
0.45602306723594666,
0.15475034713745117,
-0.06366647779941559,
-0.8033344745635986,
0.3501048982143402,
0.12176379561424255,
0.3239598572254181,
0.2525021731853485,
0.25675445795059204,
0.22227604687213898,
-0.7898472547531128,
0.07809370756149292,
0.6854763031005859,
-0.6781097054481506,
-0.5604395270347595,
0.48838010430336,
0.10875841230154037,
-0.6320362687110901,
0.3531424403190613,
-0.4873882532119751,
-0.4980539083480835,
0.8553551435470581,
0.2319214940071106,
1.0523309707641602,
0.13621476292610168,
0.22919398546218872,
-0.24689051508903503,
0.6105209589004517,
-0.4376729428768158,
0.662096381187439,
0.3562978506088257,
-0.8556602597236633,
-0.2879110276699066,
-0.291145920753479,
-0.8184581995010376,
-0.17677953839302063,
-0.286163866519928,
0.49826112389564514,
-0.7461526393890381,
-0.39807596802711487,
-0.2694799304008484,
0.12258197367191315,
-0.888762354850769,
0.19237680733203888,
-0.27654317021369934,
0.7664483785629272,
-0.8352462649345398,
0.5069388151168823,
0.8206899166107178,
-0.5066783428192139,
-0.9293467998504639,
-0.09903784096240997,
0.6321192383766174,
-0.8705050349235535,
0.737112283706665,
-0.07215717434883118,
-0.543559193611145,
0.057273779064416885,
-0.7989174127578735,
-0.8451292514801025,
1.3647509813308716,
0.5841585397720337,
-0.5285322070121765,
-0.08000745624303818,
-0.2203029990196228,
0.22848813235759735,
0.0973329246044159,
0.3134075403213501,
0.408974289894104,
0.6572374701499939,
0.13041898608207703,
-1.4629299640655518,
0.12166228890419006,
0.3015038073062897,
-0.5677703619003296,
0.23736333847045898,
-0.4748201370239258,
0.9658670425415039,
-0.42932838201522827,
-0.3788684010505676,
0.04926147684454918,
0.08365432173013687,
0.2846803367137909,
0.7796288728713989,
0.6302229762077332,
0.5338742136955261,
0.7579625844955444,
-0.17792049050331116,
1.081678867340088,
0.19633953273296356,
0.20159652829170227,
0.783421516418457,
-0.5111104846000671,
0.7868213653564453,
0.0601898618042469,
-0.36832568049430847,
0.29168832302093506,
0.5957276821136475,
-0.18166105449199677,
0.1717679798603058,
0.019898273050785065,
-0.13556835055351257,
-0.45056289434432983,
-0.17782796919345856,
-0.01395424548536539,
0.3931400775909424,
0.21693050861358643,
0.21110644936561584,
-0.47308146953582764,
0.16725172102451324,
-0.027887165546417236,
-0.24896186590194702,
-0.3395686149597168,
0.6939530372619629,
0.5693217515945435,
-0.2963709235191345,
0.24494872987270355,
-0.06788015365600586,
0.34308111667633057,
-0.529841423034668,
-0.2471613883972168,
-0.144953191280365,
0.25743240118026733,
-0.3665369749069214,
-0.6370972394943237,
0.36401206254959106,
-0.576479434967041,
-0.07116376608610153,
0.02182716876268387,
1.380839228630066,
0.30713382363319397,
-0.7863103747367859,
0.4213559925556183,
0.9138251543045044,
0.21503686904907227,
-0.21376533806324005,
-0.6942995190620422,
0.28714612126350403,
-0.28715622425079346,
0.07283255457878113,
-0.037051789462566376,
0.2286445051431656,
0.027507038787007332,
1.0713582038879395,
0.5052759051322937,
0.15346793830394745,
-0.028782449662685394,
-0.24272282421588898,
0.7390488386154175,
-0.8511362075805664,
-0.11291535943746567,
-0.7181634306907654,
0.5324657559394836,
-0.17106401920318604,
0.06304550170898438,
0.8767138719558716,
0.17528751492500305,
0.8948853611946106,
0.049262382090091705,
0.8427897691726685,
0.10935935378074646,
0.7510459423065186,
-0.4630500078201294,
0.6308663487434387,
-0.7856979966163635,
0.39818957448005676,
-0.052669890224933624,
-0.7937412261962891,
-0.2577744722366333,
0.5830404758453369,
-0.016743427142500877,
0.02794031612575054,
0.5980389714241028,
0.8550322651863098,
-0.058070771396160126,
-0.35098788142204285,
0.5205800533294678,
0.17628493905067444,
0.2067924439907074,
0.3928256332874298,
1.0636175870895386,
-0.27208229899406433,
0.707226037979126,
-0.06107378751039505,
-0.11551720649003983,
-0.3591436743736267,
-0.7763711214065552,
-0.8498472571372986,
-0.24935263395309448,
-0.4125812351703644,
-0.546200156211853,
0.19700437784194946,
0.7526997327804565,
0.8094422221183777,
-0.5777944922447205,
-0.4700653851032257,
-0.12707345187664032,
0.7485912442207336,
-0.04239850491285324,
-0.08708395063877106,
-0.04080093652009964,
-0.4821072220802307,
-0.5773194432258606,
0.6437803506851196,
0.4474876821041107,
0.21097463369369507,
-0.6703743934631348,
-0.21315647661685944,
0.31894218921661377,
0.0760507881641388,
0.3516705334186554,
0.6192469596862793,
-0.8592306971549988,
-0.2641705274581909,
0.12645547091960907,
-0.03723922744393349,
-0.294304758310318,
0.7789621949195862,
-0.766670823097229,
0.35941988229751587,
0.11483926326036453,
0.2727348208427429,
0.2197677195072174,
-0.6104577779769897,
0.8985822200775146,
-0.6172662377357483,
0.021575864404439926,
0.41486191749572754,
0.5687273144721985,
0.3197866380214691,
-0.21117903292179108,
0.9718142747879028,
0.3481789231300354,
-0.5629093647003174,
-1.2983087301254272,
0.2707606256008148,
-0.9558572769165039,
-0.20441463589668274,
0.904607355594635,
-0.11820088326931,
-0.21609942615032196,
-0.53066486120224,
-0.5218120217323303,
0.0829029455780983,
0.23834504187107086,
0.8498544096946716,
0.735677182674408,
-0.002689695917069912,
-0.06451001763343811,
-0.8891587853431702,
0.6037742495536804,
0.2788354456424713,
-0.7452062964439392,
-0.3785386383533478,
0.5144391655921936,
0.5546925067901611,
0.4849593937397003,
0.7799810767173767,
0.24952846765518188,
0.7351640462875366,
0.1938953846693039,
0.13086837530136108,
0.029239283874630928,
-0.2874278426170349,
0.03213426098227501,
0.028034018352627754,
0.6587505340576172,
0.02171313390135765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19227v1 | Aligning Teacher with Student Preferences for Tailored Training Data Generation | 2024-06-27T14:51:17 | 2024-06-27T14:51:17 | Yantao Liu, Zhao Zhang, Zijun Yao, Shulin Cao, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown significant promise as copilots in
various tasks. Local deployment of LLMs on edge devices is necessary when
handling privacy-sensitive data or latency-sensitive tasks. The computational
constraints of such devices make direct deployment of powerful large-scale LLMs
impractical, necessitating the Knowledge Distillation from large-scale models
to lightweight models. Lots of work has been done to elicit diversity and
quality training examples from LLMs, but little attention has been paid to
aligning teacher instructional content based on student preferences, akin to
"responsive teaching" in pedagogy. Thus, we propose ARTE, dubbed Aligning
TeacheR with StudenT PreferencEs, a framework that aligns the teacher model
with student preferences to generate tailored training examples for Knowledge
Distillation. Specifically, we elicit draft questions and rationales from the
teacher model, then collect student preferences on these questions and
rationales using students' performance with in-context learning as a proxy, and
finally align the teacher model with student preferences. In the end, we repeat
the first step with the aligned teacher model to elicit tailored training
examples for the student model on the target task. Extensive experiments on
academic benchmarks demonstrate the superiority of ARTE over existing
instruction-tuning datasets distilled from powerful LLMs. Moreover, we
thoroughly investigate the generalization of ARTE, including the generalization
of fine-tuned student models in reasoning ability and the generalization of
aligned teacher models to generate tailored training data across tasks and
students. In summary, our contributions lie in proposing a novel framework for
tailored training example generation, demonstrating its efficacy in
experiments, and investigating the generalization of both student & aligned
teacher models in ARTE. | [
-0.2315109670162201,
-0.6061652898788452,
0.5719925761222839,
-0.4279346168041229,
-0.10949182510375977,
-0.09603355079889297,
-0.36626696586608887,
0.09119832515716553,
0.03149395436048508,
0.298812597990036,
-0.26837778091430664,
-0.380073219537735,
-0.3892754316329956,
-0.21538083255290985,
-0.4277423322200775,
1.0250943899154663,
-0.08597490191459656,
0.43836984038352966,
-0.5968549251556396,
-0.20245005190372467,
-0.5814793109893799,
-0.36477431654930115,
-0.6272067427635193,
-0.5145238637924194,
0.48074954748153687,
0.8970848917961121,
0.7513610124588013,
0.9213338494300842,
0.2417263388633728,
0.21482481062412262,
0.2629644274711609,
0.15516242384910583,
-0.3364953398704529,
0.1855638027191162,
-0.5140876770019531,
-0.4334704577922821,
-0.5230521559715271,
0.2376367598772049,
0.856610894203186,
0.8677860498428345,
-0.0381721667945385,
0.232111394405365,
0.22883102297782898,
0.5553227066993713,
-0.6343761682510376,
-0.6026492118835449,
-0.739662766456604,
0.10416004061698914,
-0.02394052967429161,
-0.0433054082095623,
-0.43713438510894775,
-0.5333274006843567,
0.2865208685398102,
-0.48906075954437256,
0.33247023820877075,
-0.1674855351448059,
0.7124583721160889,
0.4455316662788391,
-0.83689284324646,
-0.18806813657283783,
-0.6706240177154541,
0.9465563297271729,
-0.37363576889038086,
0.5515397787094116,
0.3405840992927551,
0.38697606325149536,
-0.05065644159913063,
-0.7879272699356079,
-0.5898880958557129,
0.36532390117645264,
0.17948244512081146,
0.09774592518806458,
0.3790491819381714,
-0.11276495456695557,
0.04626696556806564,
0.4392702877521515,
-0.3561888039112091,
0.3740595877170563,
-0.11467908322811127,
-0.12135203927755356,
0.43421652913093567,
0.28648248314857483,
0.05200037360191345,
0.1448105424642563,
-0.6428607702255249,
-0.11814697086811066,
-0.8261379599571228,
0.36314964294433594,
0.6511962413787842,
0.19422677159309387,
-0.018781455233693123,
0.4839251935482025,
-0.06039353460073471,
0.9447730183601379,
0.2125091403722763,
-0.4964393675327301,
0.0032301638275384903,
-0.07000253349542618,
0.05509546771645546,
0.11870571970939636,
0.7310078144073486,
0.4405572712421417,
0.2182866781949997,
-0.0921901986002922,
-0.1671426147222519,
0.0900898277759552,
0.11865486204624176,
-0.9263964891433716,
-0.21962669491767883,
0.19450463354587555,
-0.1748616099357605,
-0.3961295187473297,
-0.3253481388092041,
-0.6521292328834534,
-0.4087180197238922,
-0.7529483437538147,
0.34193167090415955,
-0.2806449830532074,
-0.2922501564025879,
0.03176289051771164,
0.15390412509441376,
0.2954358756542206,
0.1914437860250473,
-1.1157796382904053,
0.1740478128194809,
0.7307974696159363,
0.6311092972755432,
-0.48820850253105164,
-0.4439585506916046,
-0.6783871054649353,
0.3405672609806061,
-0.15568368136882782,
0.5278127193450928,
-0.8604241013526917,
-0.28449103236198425,
0.0816068947315216,
-0.2334739863872528,
-0.02702934481203556,
-0.17786431312561035,
0.46382299065589905,
-0.2962780296802521,
0.41606229543685913,
-0.305306613445282,
-0.8888198733329773,
0.19789205491542816,
0.22834648191928864,
-0.3705522418022156,
1.0918418169021606,
0.08786996454000473,
-0.7505180239677429,
0.42207348346710205,
-0.5003008246421814,
-0.2383977323770523,
-0.20866598188877106,
-0.43846824765205383,
-0.6563180685043335,
-0.16777080297470093,
0.197881281375885,
0.5564479231834412,
-0.210203617811203,
0.4988245666027069,
-0.24008119106292725,
-0.2686308026313782,
0.3256065249443054,
-0.3498408794403076,
0.6924310922622681,
0.40993744134902954,
-0.31512993574142456,
0.19088904559612274,
-0.49306514859199524,
0.015152162872254848,
0.0215203445404768,
-0.40556222200393677,
-0.41830897331237793,
0.12812472879886627,
-0.11018146574497223,
-0.05867946520447731,
0.4648975729942322,
-0.48297280073165894,
0.33837857842445374,
-0.12945224344730377,
0.4087625741958618,
1.09699285030365,
-0.23987793922424316,
0.7880023717880249,
-0.38579797744750977,
0.46940726041793823,
-0.13676443696022034,
0.11672692745923996,
0.0033502154983580112,
-0.041805051267147064,
-0.5794810056686401,
-0.34128493070602417,
0.2625066936016083,
0.20759019255638123,
-0.5777469873428345,
0.07767940312623978,
-0.5505332350730896,
-0.455003947019577,
-0.5945093631744385,
0.35235396027565,
0.31911298632621765,
1.082667589187622,
0.12177928537130356,
-0.008962591178715229,
-0.3058067262172699,
-0.7552968263626099,
-0.23206104338169098,
0.15852224826812744,
-0.03983413800597191,
0.3771508038043976,
0.1479412466287613,
0.12750466167926788,
1.351492166519165,
-0.453071266412735,
-0.030962318181991577,
-0.06856908649206161,
-0.32030799984931946,
0.02031448669731617,
0.6794652938842773,
0.6506046652793884,
-0.9180251955986023,
-0.7441931962966919,
-0.17487415671348572,
-0.39316728711128235,
-0.04721812158823013,
0.09704624861478806,
-0.5341469049453735,
-0.012414995580911636,
0.3017168939113617,
-0.019385896623134613,
0.059521764516830444,
0.5220998525619507,
-0.28155219554901123,
0.13921493291854858,
0.04677777737379074,
0.004378631245344877,
-1.5313135385513306,
-0.0955982431769371,
-0.228476881980896,
-0.43739962577819824,
-0.4387527108192444,
-0.09779796749353409,
-0.028009403496980667,
-0.30539771914482117,
-0.5586399435997009,
0.6101281046867371,
-0.27452659606933594,
-0.18067796528339386,
-0.3394288718700409,
0.2172982543706894,
0.28446927666664124,
0.37078985571861267,
0.4014906585216522,
0.8262220621109009,
0.6698299050331116,
-0.5643141865730286,
0.3675321936607361,
0.1993548572063446,
-0.2501588463783264,
0.977211594581604,
-0.6635845899581909,
0.40058380365371704,
0.22167621552944183,
0.055178023874759674,
-0.7733059525489807,
-0.21901226043701172,
-0.12510772049427032,
-0.1926218718290329,
0.314571350812912,
-0.4466370940208435,
-0.207589253783226,
-0.052755992859601974,
-0.30980056524276733,
0.5569426417350769,
0.6713574528694153,
-0.8999249935150146,
0.6843747496604919,
0.41816720366477966,
0.006537214852869511,
-0.7693503499031067,
-0.3222402036190033,
-0.36963140964508057,
-0.4874694347381592,
-0.5045487880706787,
0.28934445977211,
-0.18945914506912231,
-0.010977855883538723,
-0.0023499117232859135,
-0.19076396524906158,
-0.11057943850755692,
0.29805925488471985,
0.23262038826942444,
0.3653962314128876,
-0.1990348845720291,
0.27886146306991577,
0.24310313165187836,
0.05497447028756142,
-0.05659940466284752,
-0.5525251626968384,
0.41082414984703064,
-0.21312442421913147,
-0.5609819293022156,
-0.17220129072666168,
0.27010348439216614,
0.4526576101779938,
-0.3300272524356842,
0.6073207259178162,
0.5794661045074463,
-0.14863808453083038,
-0.3324776887893677,
-0.436829537153244,
-0.36061859130859375,
-0.5026060938835144,
0.13116347789764404,
-0.24396876990795135,
-0.6275407671928406,
0.30152183771133423,
-0.32936912775039673,
0.3759234845638275,
-0.03472733125090599,
0.5687815546989441,
-0.13187368214130402,
0.9395288228988647,
0.6368451714515686,
-0.02374604344367981,
0.8364437818527222,
-0.40435901284217834,
0.12676697969436646,
-0.9107933044433594,
-0.16447587311267853,
-0.41514313220977783,
-0.590700626373291,
-0.3178461790084839,
0.07740286737680435,
0.45862358808517456,
-0.18005241453647614,
-0.42542266845703125,
-0.07764221727848053,
-0.8052729368209839,
0.716702938079834,
0.634349524974823,
0.16614116728305817,
0.12891864776611328,
0.07512930780649185,
-0.09867225587368011,
-0.022920625284314156,
-0.7446193099021912,
-0.7481914758682251,
1.6504082679748535,
0.24248504638671875,
0.7420274615287781,
0.21766239404678345,
0.7336084842681885,
-0.019435379654169083,
0.26521462202072144,
-0.6371387839317322,
0.44538626074790955,
-0.16290391981601715,
-0.6561532616615295,
-0.34267303347587585,
-0.2560173571109772,
-1.0002835988998413,
0.07871319353580475,
-0.1923959106206894,
-0.4046586751937866,
0.048728253692388535,
0.27663150429725647,
-0.2646215558052063,
0.45111775398254395,
-0.9601045250892639,
0.9560079574584961,
-0.2740325629711151,
-0.8724053502082825,
0.03776608407497406,
-0.5231393575668335,
0.18581286072731018,
-0.03658600151538849,
0.08094548434019089,
-0.0857730433344841,
-0.1849420815706253,
0.7414076328277588,
-0.6231533288955688,
0.8448486328125,
-0.21574392914772034,
-0.08070897310972214,
0.38426005840301514,
0.004059366416186094,
0.3286574184894562,
0.014914450235664845,
-0.3220893442630768,
-0.24665339291095734,
-0.09877757728099823,
-0.6456418633460999,
-0.5529260635375977,
0.9987736940383911,
-1.0622212886810303,
-0.6794962286949158,
-0.1705535352230072,
-0.8568791151046753,
-0.38057777285575867,
0.20610788464546204,
0.31674134731292725,
0.4932279884815216,
0.22870168089866638,
0.08032327890396118,
0.900107741355896,
0.36808064579963684,
0.35677066445350647,
0.7532228827476501,
-0.109379842877388,
-0.2473457306623459,
1.2912745475769043,
0.19539688527584076,
0.4486570656299591,
0.16245098412036896,
0.37077200412750244,
-0.36171388626098633,
-0.4598839581012726,
-0.38658982515335083,
-0.10716117918491364,
-0.7555953860282898,
-0.20996549725532532,
-0.11691168695688248,
0.032331276684999466,
-0.3471807539463043,
-0.6954038739204407,
-0.5494694113731384,
-0.2330443561077118,
-0.4453713297843933,
-0.02956259436905384,
0.34043800830841064,
0.5834707021713257,
0.23363471031188965,
0.47893986105918884,
-0.2647150456905365,
-0.023961933329701424,
0.656745970249176,
0.40681949257850647,
-0.12893667817115784,
-0.7327021360397339,
-0.28350773453712463,
0.2665643095970154,
-0.6490368247032166,
-0.5619796514511108,
0.03845540061593056,
0.41312649846076965,
0.3358427584171295,
0.5936647057533264,
0.3458538353443146,
0.39241573214530945,
-0.4169490337371826,
0.7515218257904053,
0.09827308356761932,
-0.9446820020675659,
0.7614509463310242,
-0.329572468996048,
-0.15446393191814423,
0.5287805199623108,
0.5429956912994385,
-0.10996263474225998,
-0.36708128452301025,
-0.623202919960022,
-0.7752655744552612,
0.5973351001739502,
-0.31731462478637695,
0.3693048655986786,
0.2392522394657135,
0.5240417718887329,
0.4810734689235687,
0.2004929631948471,
-0.7615479230880737,
-0.20634311437606812,
-0.4840538799762726,
-0.6137369275093079,
0.12745070457458496,
0.0022633089683949947,
-0.37108704447746277,
-0.2529555559158325,
0.5694525837898254,
-0.38530266284942627,
-0.3047819435596466,
0.02089465968310833,
0.12243010103702545,
0.05191060155630112,
0.2277640849351883,
0.31707140803337097,
0.7095471024513245,
0.03157370164990425,
0.407668799161911,
0.1534731090068817,
-0.4577763080596924,
0.35022443532943726,
-0.15450817346572876,
-0.35503458976745605,
-0.28808361291885376,
0.14652830362319946,
0.5809609889984131,
0.12043586373329163,
-0.5121351480484009,
0.6836433410644531,
0.012357156723737717,
-0.06287635117769241,
-0.3762980103492737,
0.5221280455589294,
-0.025915246456861496,
0.15435092151165009,
0.13090158998966217,
-0.16095291078090668,
-0.09251617640256882,
-0.360614150762558,
-0.06718592345714569,
0.506952702999115,
-0.15912781655788422,
-0.2861907184123993,
0.752089262008667,
0.46214377880096436,
-0.22587907314300537,
0.6411449313163757,
0.14298555254936218,
-0.30704814195632935,
0.5368472337722778,
0.6050860285758972,
0.6893373131752014,
-0.41131359338760376,
0.1014685407280922,
0.21159879863262177,
-0.171391099691391,
0.05961111932992935,
0.18278950452804565,
-0.30440372228622437,
-0.8078139424324036,
-0.14928194880485535,
-0.3646867573261261,
-0.6414483785629272,
-0.013244717381894588,
-0.7905938029289246,
0.5301191806793213,
-0.43967968225479126,
-0.1988842785358429,
-0.10576711595058441,
-0.005137401167303324,
-0.6645326614379883,
0.05877044424414635,
-0.04599621519446373,
0.5499393939971924,
-1.0762600898742676,
1.0776275396347046,
1.036147117614746,
-0.246951162815094,
-1.174999713897705,
-0.06502603739500046,
-0.2734149098396301,
-0.7773927450180054,
0.41238802671432495,
-0.19728699326515198,
0.13741645216941833,
0.047360531985759735,
-0.6253052949905396,
-0.6806240677833557,
1.355771780014038,
0.8500803709030151,
-0.4490755796432495,
0.05992112308740616,
0.2977967858314514,
0.3032906949520111,
-0.5690891146659851,
0.08141683787107468,
0.20049533247947693,
0.03091292455792427,
0.1964617669582367,
-0.5855193138122559,
-0.1453346610069275,
0.005884387530386448,
-0.1688884049654007,
0.11443975567817688,
-0.8238046169281006,
0.8334255814552307,
-0.1676395982503891,
0.09491957724094391,
-0.3773597180843353,
0.5545417666435242,
-0.0028510147240012884,
0.5578988790512085,
0.4617028832435608,
0.6935003399848938,
0.9016488790512085,
-0.08302632719278336,
0.8657506108283997,
-0.4319063425064087,
0.13710662722587585,
1.2228906154632568,
-0.21208912134170532,
0.7282415628433228,
0.6288179159164429,
-0.08096832036972046,
0.5306441187858582,
0.7770289182662964,
0.19485193490982056,
0.45195460319519043,
-0.09861025214195251,
-0.32692715525627136,
-0.43825650215148926,
-0.4856306314468384,
-0.4774327874183655,
0.38620826601982117,
0.0697605311870575,
-0.20415250957012177,
-0.009323223493993282,
0.19810757040977478,
0.044804926961660385,
0.3571534752845764,
-0.5584709048271179,
0.6831992864608765,
-0.21258017420768738,
-0.826644241809845,
0.5122998356819153,
-0.24306467175483704,
0.38570886850357056,
-0.4957635998725891,
0.1384178102016449,
-0.26716846227645874,
0.1753082126379013,
-0.4006694257259369,
-0.8916960954666138,
0.07666362822055817,
0.0616791658103466,
-0.30132126808166504,
-0.44411465525627136,
0.3706991374492645,
-0.7676331996917725,
-0.30638664960861206,
-0.39860421419143677,
0.09563807398080826,
0.21157032251358032,
0.5474997162818909,
-0.25667452812194824,
0.06995318830013275,
0.08676070719957352,
-0.20115390419960022,
0.5698192119598389,
0.476734459400177,
0.06392087787389755,
0.6358845233917236,
0.5198050737380981,
-0.03847159817814827,
-0.02647974155843258,
-0.008510250598192215,
0.9784122705459595,
0.030957801267504692,
-0.36910659074783325,
-0.6907405257225037,
0.6308327317237854,
0.06400584429502487,
-0.44400548934936523,
0.6989457607269287,
0.777897298336029,
0.9240878820419312,
0.16390705108642578,
0.6642715334892273,
0.26031139492988586,
0.4846642315387726,
-0.4949091672897339,
0.38179728388786316,
-0.5606082677841187,
0.49589189887046814,
-0.048281848430633545,
-0.945361852645874,
0.43363040685653687,
0.5134961605072021,
-0.5719673037528992,
0.04447567090392113,
0.37280526757240295,
0.5355091094970703,
-0.3092276453971863,
-0.1870165467262268,
0.1182696670293808,
-0.30574825406074524,
0.3130115866661072,
0.7497753500938416,
0.639613151550293,
-0.23224036395549774,
0.5125048160552979,
-0.3979838788509369,
-0.18747980892658234,
-0.05333542451262474,
-0.9309459924697876,
-1.0460454225540161,
-0.8618463277816772,
-0.5243955850601196,
-0.1905103325843811,
-0.13098908960819244,
0.955293595790863,
0.7135642170906067,
-0.49453336000442505,
-0.10068655014038086,
-0.10795699059963226,
0.5757139325141907,
0.09652777016162872,
-0.2371988147497177,
0.5483587980270386,
-0.3477458953857422,
-1.157163381576538,
0.0935937687754631,
-0.4763053357601166,
0.2925771176815033,
-0.33732396364212036,
-0.30602917075157166,
0.14823172986507416,
0.032143671065568924,
0.15938743948936462,
0.1788017451763153,
-0.4666959047317505,
-0.36493682861328125,
0.10717093199491501,
-0.17825959622859955,
-0.15982970595359802,
0.7771538496017456,
-0.7883281111717224,
0.5338974595069885,
0.20406651496887207,
0.787200391292572,
0.25369563698768616,
-0.0723053589463234,
0.5244560241699219,
-0.9151117205619812,
0.18108031153678894,
0.2510308027267456,
0.2634032368659973,
0.4293449819087982,
-0.3336385190486908,
0.46662190556526184,
0.0891786441206932,
-0.7975279092788696,
-1.1110410690307617,
0.31620797514915466,
-0.7529385089874268,
-0.04413310065865517,
1.0628926753997803,
-0.32829996943473816,
-0.05779241397976875,
0.1757173389196396,
-0.11341197788715363,
0.26912418007850647,
-0.197021022439003,
0.7229222655296326,
0.6055797934532166,
-0.025443172082304955,
0.21044625341892242,
-0.27018505334854126,
0.40204793214797974,
0.6196495294570923,
-0.42923545837402344,
-0.03966426104307175,
0.3597663938999176,
0.5446540713310242,
-0.1571468561887741,
0.3284222185611725,
0.24171985685825348,
0.31354019045829773,
-0.09373516589403152,
0.13749001920223236,
-0.4830366373062134,
-0.271486759185791,
-0.05621794983744621,
0.16758087277412415,
0.28921929001808167,
-0.5090548992156982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19226v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19226v1 | Simulating Classroom Education with LLM-Empowered Agents | 2024-06-27T14:51:07 | 2024-06-27T14:51:07 | Zheyuan Zhang, Daniel Zhang-Li, Jifan Yu, Linlu Gong, Jinchang Zhou, Zhiyuan Liu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) have been employed in various intelligent
educational tasks to assist teaching. While preliminary explorations have
focused on independent LLM-empowered agents for specific educational tasks, the
potential for LLMs within a multi-agent collaborative framework to simulate a
classroom with real user participation remains unexplored. In this work, we
propose SimClass, a multi-agent classroom simulation framework involving user
participation. We recognize representative class roles and introduce a novel
class control mechanism for automatic classroom teaching, and conduct user
experiments in two real-world courses. Utilizing the Flanders Interactive
Analysis System and Community of Inquiry theoretical frame works from
educational analysis, we demonstrate that LLMs can simulate traditional
classroom interaction patterns effectively while enhancing user's experience.
We also observe emergent group behaviors among agents in SimClass, where agents
collaborate to create enlivening interactions in classrooms to improve user
learning process. We hope this work pioneers the application of LLM-empowered
multi-agent systems in virtual classroom teaching. | [
-0.5212949514389038,
-1.037646770477295,
0.5363328456878662,
-0.0983424261212349,
0.061556536704301834,
0.34650662541389465,
-0.42655420303344727,
-0.1794756054878235,
0.1446113884449005,
0.30795565247535706,
-0.3901166617870331,
-0.3549903333187103,
-0.21092045307159424,
0.09308234602212906,
-0.3663603663444519,
0.4246554374694824,
0.06082063168287277,
0.40116435289382935,
-0.6218312382698059,
0.3975989818572998,
-0.2241925448179245,
-0.906435489654541,
-0.39472872018814087,
-0.38232359290122986,
0.5693467855453491,
0.7785936594009399,
0.8283494114875793,
0.18426959216594696,
0.1524699479341507,
0.4724395275115967,
0.4483160078525543,
0.16592219471931458,
-0.18042010068893433,
-0.038791634142398834,
-0.06155059114098549,
-0.4683864116668701,
-0.5805342793464661,
0.3153640329837799,
0.8318679332733154,
0.500609815120697,
-0.40023162961006165,
-0.26019152998924255,
0.3195714056491852,
0.0015777001390233636,
-0.419182151556015,
0.36123743653297424,
-0.20078600943088531,
-0.07214053720235825,
0.17865274846553802,
-0.04309149086475372,
-0.649797260761261,
-0.21423164010047913,
-0.20196673274040222,
-0.6520742177963257,
-0.1116490364074707,
-0.06008029356598854,
0.30072787404060364,
0.02206086739897728,
-0.5874481797218323,
-0.1764254868030548,
-0.5020229816436768,
0.8538458347320557,
-0.474510133266449,
0.36320963501930237,
0.24608629941940308,
0.6166062355041504,
-0.3360428810119629,
-0.8682011365890503,
-0.8140885233879089,
-0.26510268449783325,
-0.016275880858302116,
0.3105611503124237,
0.37016916275024414,
0.3565473258495331,
0.08467300236225128,
0.008763243444263935,
-0.21633128821849823,
0.19016143679618835,
-0.22684963047504425,
-0.12051264941692352,
0.5414055585861206,
0.3431313931941986,
0.5325353145599365,
-0.028829025104641914,
-0.8103613257408142,
-0.3499164879322052,
-0.18152664601802826,
0.10202629119157791,
0.38067594170570374,
0.4803768992424011,
-0.08495990186929703,
0.541066586971283,
0.24040865898132324,
0.5843209028244019,
-0.6124030351638794,
-0.2791326344013214,
-0.03685825318098068,
0.07622624188661575,
-0.3049929141998291,
0.13114574551582336,
0.48988428711891174,
0.35544243454933167,
0.44441062211990356,
-0.03586764261126518,
0.016776643693447113,
0.4114568829536438,
0.02594767138361931,
-0.898624062538147,
-0.01696164160966873,
0.01650296524167061,
0.008892751298844814,
-0.2857815623283386,
0.09511248022317886,
-0.798728346824646,
-0.1853509396314621,
-0.739154577255249,
0.6586272716522217,
-0.1730012595653534,
-0.45173338055610657,
0.1878892481327057,
-0.07104384899139404,
0.30403438210487366,
0.7830364108085632,
-0.5903229713439941,
0.9861643314361572,
0.566310465335846,
0.4911125600337982,
-0.2975711226463318,
-0.9715920090675354,
-0.49815332889556885,
0.3193371593952179,
-0.00045481364941224456,
0.42648667097091675,
-0.9457077383995056,
-0.5986374020576477,
0.20645712316036224,
-0.044508881866931915,
-0.1934225857257843,
-0.18358011543750763,
-0.045641157776117325,
-0.577717661857605,
0.291840136051178,
-0.24168728291988373,
-0.8960173726081848,
0.01136583462357521,
0.4576535224914551,
-0.40123891830444336,
0.8029709458351135,
0.012290558777749538,
-0.2906967103481293,
0.11751053482294083,
-0.49763694405555725,
0.20322664082050323,
0.35159972310066223,
-0.49962863326072693,
-0.2583111822605133,
-0.44042691588401794,
-0.1480749398469925,
0.5228378176689148,
0.09069980680942535,
0.1641768515110016,
-0.29475224018096924,
-0.8696130514144897,
0.43113723397254944,
-0.2896614670753479,
0.8361050486564636,
-0.07973504811525345,
-0.16374053061008453,
0.4577864110469818,
-0.18784406781196594,
0.2196391522884369,
0.12165018916130066,
-0.21679002046585083,
-0.4254415035247803,
-0.2399788498878479,
0.16840258240699768,
0.19942229986190796,
0.008114890195429325,
-0.3386072516441345,
0.693532407283783,
0.2858192026615143,
-0.15251825749874115,
0.8021751046180725,
0.030430009588599205,
0.5769640207290649,
-0.5420032739639282,
0.6439898610115051,
-0.25537678599357605,
0.20985166728496552,
-0.06827443093061447,
-0.3686935007572174,
-0.7089104056358337,
-0.5820515751838684,
0.2656461298465729,
0.4310734272003174,
-0.9041653275489807,
0.0636110007762909,
0.005153660662472248,
-0.1582648605108261,
-0.2643459439277649,
0.2276468127965927,
0.09593301266431808,
-0.1465001255273819,
0.21814461052417755,
-0.3010926842689514,
-0.25923481583595276,
-0.33813753724098206,
-0.1554611176252365,
-0.22737076878547668,
-0.01175615657120943,
0.34984290599823,
0.33565855026245117,
-0.3299582004547119,
1.0911520719528198,
-0.3195982873439789,
-0.5072267651557922,
-0.6204185485839844,
-0.20282979309558868,
-0.4546337425708771,
0.4734340310096741,
0.652586042881012,
-0.6551762223243713,
-0.5333403944969177,
-0.5208502411842346,
-0.8244751691818237,
-0.07849809527397156,
-0.1030716821551323,
-0.2774558365345001,
0.15113766491413116,
0.7517811059951782,
-0.23668798804283142,
0.4634092152118683,
0.26846012473106384,
-0.24883189797401428,
0.431824654340744,
-0.28814783692359924,
0.22175320982933044,
-0.8342335820198059,
-0.6654759049415588,
-0.3379594385623932,
-0.3061572015285492,
-0.5864991545677185,
0.14680235087871552,
0.3072723150253296,
-0.22296862304210663,
-0.6027241349220276,
0.5692480206489563,
-0.5520417094230652,
-0.18969926238059998,
-0.5973547697067261,
0.3651365637779236,
-0.2224339246749878,
0.6308315396308899,
0.10316102206707001,
0.8931325674057007,
0.6111220121383667,
-0.5088972449302673,
0.2712481617927551,
0.03071480616927147,
-0.11079909652471542,
0.3173636198043823,
-0.2855704724788666,
0.011263174936175346,
-0.09541936218738556,
0.34513670206069946,
-0.822799801826477,
-0.5871084928512573,
0.12964434921741486,
-0.1010584756731987,
0.19955924153327942,
-0.09281149506568909,
-0.9626456499099731,
-0.1151014193892479,
-0.31636378169059753,
0.2517733573913574,
0.5151365995407104,
-0.7797134518623352,
0.8125682473182678,
0.26650479435920715,
0.11498673260211945,
-0.441415399312973,
-0.2938450276851654,
0.0723361223936081,
-0.07324681431055069,
-0.3981013000011444,
-0.10297535359859467,
-0.26245468854904175,
-0.5665761828422546,
0.054994385689496994,
0.3642033636569977,
0.13298405706882477,
0.4133276641368866,
0.5275090336799622,
0.4291181266307831,
0.22596591711044312,
0.402336448431015,
0.3495396673679352,
0.15451157093048096,
0.12532421946525574,
0.15868698060512543,
0.6614980101585388,
-0.3483150899410248,
-0.8814021348953247,
-0.5129086971282959,
0.24448548257350922,
0.6204676628112793,
-0.08739786595106125,
0.6590313911437988,
0.15625406801700592,
-0.2624042332172394,
-0.6115003824234009,
-0.37594303488731384,
-0.8831360936164856,
-0.5611560940742493,
0.27358657121658325,
-0.05866745859384537,
-0.9206554293632507,
0.23212449252605438,
-0.38956576585769653,
0.2390710711479187,
-0.4896489381790161,
0.54681396484375,
0.11129765212535858,
0.6640392541885376,
0.5400698184967041,
0.30572229623794556,
0.5502673387527466,
-0.25176936388015747,
-0.14254894852638245,
-0.40241730213165283,
-0.549545407295227,
-0.25217872858047485,
-0.2894234359264374,
-0.20728237926959991,
-0.8011572957038879,
0.4522292912006378,
0.08103109896183014,
-0.23752854764461517,
-0.10842625051736832,
-0.002625587861984968,
0.7267990708351135,
0.5614268183708191,
0.0630006268620491,
0.4117494523525238,
0.3317395746707916,
-0.2715768814086914,
-0.02158045396208763,
-0.5661635398864746,
-0.7761417031288147,
0.7316524386405945,
0.04799187555909157,
0.9252070784568787,
0.3876818120479584,
0.9489779472351074,
0.39546138048171997,
0.6754431128501892,
-0.8014300465583801,
1.1447166204452515,
0.3711588978767395,
-0.6157087683677673,
-0.4780697822570801,
-0.24755558371543884,
-0.7026938199996948,
0.8368265628814697,
-0.3380862772464752,
-0.33459702134132385,
-0.1666804552078247,
-0.05838807299733162,
0.07575768977403641,
0.5043556690216064,
-0.8981108665466309,
0.596049427986145,
-0.06252194195985794,
-0.9158251285552979,
-0.20151202380657196,
-0.4261796772480011,
0.1997598111629486,
-0.01307144295424223,
0.5616722106933594,
-0.088069386780262,
-0.2129388451576233,
0.4070679545402527,
-0.49994122982025146,
1.2949681282043457,
-0.23444610834121704,
0.025373205542564392,
0.6267679333686829,
0.2249225229024887,
0.24211539328098297,
0.04849732667207718,
-0.2701002061367035,
-0.13224560022354126,
-0.5702121257781982,
-0.5639585852622986,
-0.6989988684654236,
0.8227154612541199,
-0.9840698838233948,
-0.8893723487854004,
-0.6479883193969727,
-0.5984898805618286,
-0.20417438447475433,
-0.01565920002758503,
-0.4208337068557739,
0.23226982355117798,
-0.17892006039619446,
-0.15638518333435059,
0.2249598205089569,
0.144466832280159,
0.8685834407806396,
0.7712125182151794,
-0.7214095592498779,
-0.15033140778541565,
0.8483088612556458,
0.22369635105133057,
0.3933151662349701,
-0.1654922515153885,
0.21187706291675568,
-0.17006416618824005,
0.09945656359195709,
-0.45698076486587524,
0.11017125844955444,
-0.6436507105827332,
0.08070337772369385,
-0.7410239577293396,
-0.26419419050216675,
-0.3218146562576294,
-0.6529672145843506,
0.07441858947277069,
-0.2966836392879486,
-0.1452658474445343,
-0.28526580333709717,
0.1731264740228653,
0.7291463613510132,
-0.12999631464481354,
0.7593854665756226,
-0.5540007948875427,
-0.11942551285028458,
1.0825835466384888,
0.15860521793365479,
0.261953204870224,
-0.21327441930770874,
0.04974653571844101,
-0.17940782010555267,
-0.26806530356407166,
-0.7799944877624512,
0.3440115451812744,
0.16837000846862793,
0.7041615843772888,
0.3441998064517975,
0.3111681640148163,
0.37087634205818176,
-0.3790816068649292,
0.8322543501853943,
0.1787956953048706,
-0.8676650524139404,
0.14480900764465332,
-0.0913403332233429,
-0.045797690749168396,
0.21790190041065216,
0.1986205279827118,
-0.26338788866996765,
-0.7849096059799194,
-0.6759821772575378,
-0.6633619666099548,
0.8649535775184631,
0.1489478498697281,
0.4716681241989136,
0.17238649725914001,
0.11043880879878998,
0.10071573406457901,
0.3080730438232422,
-0.7704319357872009,
-0.4759739637374878,
-0.22828994691371918,
-0.11728288233280182,
-0.01442438829690218,
-0.4244835078716278,
-0.10972624272108078,
-0.07135428488254547,
0.6388788223266602,
0.035575468093156815,
-0.18321433663368225,
-0.008853358216583729,
0.006250055506825447,
-0.1107206642627716,
0.4433158040046692,
0.3668788969516754,
0.371878057718277,
-0.07241018116474152,
0.5354148149490356,
0.35104936361312866,
-0.6339176297187805,
0.4111810028553009,
-0.161199152469635,
0.16043569147586823,
-0.21624013781547546,
0.3493628203868866,
0.34129396080970764,
0.3921559154987335,
-0.6625465750694275,
0.7439634799957275,
-0.41713476181030273,
-0.07668153941631317,
-0.6773982048034668,
0.6213864684104919,
0.13995346426963806,
0.37995871901512146,
0.39030560851097107,
-0.1801183819770813,
0.09793031215667725,
-0.5029643177986145,
0.36266738176345825,
0.3199020326137543,
-0.3195574879646301,
-0.1355573683977127,
0.5670483708381653,
0.36599284410476685,
-0.4475441575050354,
0.4254279136657715,
-0.07152076065540314,
-0.4392072558403015,
0.8200326561927795,
0.7740507125854492,
0.4731164872646332,
-0.5695529580116272,
0.2840712070465088,
0.20152142643928528,
0.24643254280090332,
-0.07365288585424423,
0.36049336194992065,
-0.09341475367546082,
-0.6842235922813416,
-0.24846942722797394,
-0.24011293053627014,
-1.0016237497329712,
-0.26518940925598145,
-0.45529472827911377,
0.3592815399169922,
-0.3461534082889557,
0.030513949692249298,
-0.28856897354125977,
0.11961416155099869,
-0.18291541934013367,
-0.06408581882715225,
0.06490110605955124,
0.5911329984664917,
-1.0324310064315796,
1.2196240425109863,
1.0009899139404297,
0.042745787650346756,
-0.9099589586257935,
0.040200844407081604,
0.14810115098953247,
-0.5361001491546631,
0.4816402196884155,
0.20824596285820007,
-0.27330976724624634,
0.30633679032325745,
-0.8332405090332031,
-0.1421971470117569,
1.045448660850525,
0.3412460386753082,
-0.5728309750556946,
0.0868464782834053,
0.2534053325653076,
0.361163854598999,
-0.3592756390571594,
0.3506494462490082,
0.0037473957054316998,
0.4734210669994354,
0.14143410325050354,
-0.5304728746414185,
-0.28530043363571167,
0.030477827414870262,
-0.1892600804567337,
-0.18951193988323212,
-0.9104062914848328,
0.865397572517395,
-0.42337435483932495,
0.10415000468492508,
-0.21473145484924316,
0.9121561050415039,
0.6276436448097229,
0.5525943040847778,
0.7913436889648438,
0.20697316527366638,
0.6508889198303223,
0.11760682612657547,
0.8766364455223083,
-0.22212542593479156,
0.39029642939567566,
1.0655356645584106,
-0.48859983682632446,
0.6249300241470337,
0.46355104446411133,
-0.05271841585636139,
0.4398145377635956,
0.13221800327301025,
0.25148752331733704,
0.1170627549290657,
0.37171122431755066,
-0.8837733864784241,
-0.8248249292373657,
-0.20089475810527802,
-0.41939011216163635,
0.5090107917785645,
0.3604080379009247,
0.20998284220695496,
-0.22048059105873108,
0.45761561393737793,
0.0876631885766983,
0.4200877845287323,
-0.522494375705719,
0.6651277542114258,
0.19179527461528778,
-0.31804779171943665,
0.05539577081799507,
-0.029917219653725624,
0.41658318042755127,
-0.5706443190574646,
-0.3161957561969757,
-0.06563446670770645,
0.19256898760795593,
-0.0405564047396183,
-0.47893911600112915,
-0.4504542350769043,
-0.16544480621814728,
0.31494414806365967,
-0.21080954372882843,
0.7309401631355286,
-0.8424077033996582,
-0.41261130571365356,
0.490948349237442,
0.6338112950325012,
0.13453607261180878,
0.38664519786834717,
-0.01637355051934719,
0.22534619271755219,
-0.2160840481519699,
-0.17561066150665283,
0.6204167008399963,
0.5603111982345581,
-0.16493721306324005,
0.6676064729690552,
0.4474462866783142,
-0.31129926443099976,
0.2785071134567261,
0.17070767283439636,
1.067555546760559,
-0.2903133034706116,
-0.3111381530761719,
-0.5877626538276672,
0.3417520821094513,
-0.17131206393241882,
0.2332625538110733,
0.9738287925720215,
0.5620983839035034,
0.9481071829795837,
-0.28270483016967773,
0.8528469800949097,
0.22705362737178802,
0.12125343829393387,
-0.26538220047950745,
0.6771504878997803,
-0.6229146718978882,
0.32337650656700134,
-0.2503814399242401,
-0.8084059953689575,
-0.14312034845352173,
0.4276624023914337,
0.009405769407749176,
0.18191097676753998,
0.3421840965747833,
0.6278499364852905,
-0.24895243346691132,
0.20481207966804504,
0.8482758402824402,
-0.03593410551548004,
0.32881805300712585,
0.12290483713150024,
1.1650876998901367,
-0.10245954990386963,
0.2698184549808502,
-0.49654021859169006,
-0.46377167105674744,
-0.44395479559898376,
-0.5037994384765625,
-1.3373087644577026,
-0.40892553329467773,
-0.34677863121032715,
-0.08373686671257019,
0.05519312247633934,
1.46053147315979,
0.4820949137210846,
-0.4235278069972992,
-0.6982806921005249,
0.1417805701494217,
0.2633787989616394,
-0.06750442832708359,
-0.24947652220726013,
0.22423547506332397,
-0.5971766710281372,
-1.207290530204773,
0.3790748417377472,
-0.139786958694458,
0.4910784363746643,
-0.3693995177745819,
-0.22250355780124664,
0.02125106193125248,
0.20197923481464386,
0.5403278470039368,
0.013125748373568058,
-0.5261878371238708,
-0.13622607290744781,
-0.06732627004384995,
-0.5183500051498413,
-0.41791361570358276,
0.8920159935951233,
-0.9351040124893188,
0.4698144793510437,
0.008016742765903473,
0.2940058708190918,
0.22975938022136688,
0.17065244913101196,
0.06730900704860687,
-0.7251424193382263,
0.4440152645111084,
0.13580402731895447,
0.17501257359981537,
-0.033643245697021484,
-0.1886652410030365,
0.30047449469566345,
0.1978575438261032,
-0.5594000816345215,
-0.7764612436294556,
-0.014695234596729279,
-1.0816653966903687,
-0.43112248182296753,
1.154830813407898,
-0.19160012900829315,
-0.2082156389951706,
-0.13302843272686005,
-0.4626587927341461,
0.23032146692276,
-0.592499852180481,
0.6717910766601562,
0.4730030298233032,
-0.02340463176369667,
-0.21212735772132874,
-0.47617605328559875,
0.25168389081954956,
0.15776580572128296,
-0.9927788972854614,
-0.14343862235546112,
0.5488354563713074,
0.07436130940914154,
-0.11988509446382523,
0.5574651956558228,
0.049829497933387756,
0.19267569482326508,
-0.09707821905612946,
0.43990832567214966,
-0.6386013627052307,
-0.6676770448684692,
-0.0813441127538681,
0.594468355178833,
0.03119555301964283,
-0.22959330677986145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19223v1 | T-FREE: Tokenizer-Free Generative LLMs via Sparse Representations for Memory-Efficient Embeddings | 2024-06-27T14:49:08 | 2024-06-27T14:49:08 | Björn Deiseroth, Manuel Brack, Patrick Schramowski, Kristian Kersting, Samuel Weinbach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Tokenizers are crucial for encoding information in Large Language Models, but
their development has recently stagnated, and they contain inherent weaknesses.
Major limitations include computational overhead, ineffective vocabulary use,
and unnecessarily large embedding and head layers. Additionally, their
performance is biased towards a reference corpus, leading to reduced
effectiveness for underrepresented languages.
To remedy these issues, we propose T-FREE, which directly embeds words
through sparse activation patterns over character triplets, and does not
require a reference corpus. T-FREE inherently exploits morphological
similarities and allows for strong compression of embedding layers. In our
exhaustive experimental evaluation, we achieve competitive downstream
performance with a parameter reduction of more than 85% on these layers.
Further, T-FREE shows significant improvements in cross-lingual transfer
learning. | [
0.07570013403892517,
-0.5003257393836975,
0.43760156631469727,
0.38900816440582275,
-0.5394723415374756,
0.4663798213005066,
-0.38888925313949585,
-0.23544298112392426,
0.5634693503379822,
0.16847945749759674,
-0.12377281486988068,
-0.6454154849052429,
-0.7230004668235779,
0.061995480209589005,
-0.3557285964488983,
0.4731457531452179,
-0.32369402050971985,
0.04379051551222801,
-0.06841500848531723,
-0.12064386159181595,
-0.34212666749954224,
-0.43215593695640564,
-0.7223367691040039,
-0.11177807301282883,
0.5970631837844849,
0.23310422897338867,
0.6225224733352661,
1.0323196649551392,
-0.2477077841758728,
0.228547602891922,
0.04438777640461922,
0.1690322458744049,
-0.5149351358413696,
0.24018733203411102,
-0.016106581315398216,
-0.5356321334838867,
-0.3362223207950592,
-0.1316511183977127,
0.8910451531410217,
0.9125058054924011,
0.16430222988128662,
-0.15507185459136963,
0.1676156222820282,
0.4362814724445343,
-0.6691511869430542,
0.3514399528503418,
-0.6223044395446777,
0.2335972785949707,
-0.32515615224838257,
-0.2719952166080475,
-0.4797113537788391,
-0.29424652457237244,
-0.29443490505218506,
-0.8364875316619873,
0.27032336592674255,
0.24089066684246063,
0.7706573009490967,
0.36567458510398865,
-0.29392504692077637,
-0.012670116499066353,
-0.534502387046814,
1.038020133972168,
-0.1736476719379425,
0.747325599193573,
0.2891075909137726,
-0.02337516099214554,
0.07422862201929092,
-0.6214523911476135,
-0.03831479325890541,
-0.24536941945552826,
0.1708919107913971,
-0.0843646377325058,
-0.44661927223205566,
0.28766268491744995,
0.06459099799394608,
0.40133482217788696,
-0.47556236386299133,
0.12941652536392212,
-0.18572013080120087,
-0.17374680936336517,
0.1852714717388153,
-0.0023967945016920567,
0.5510200262069702,
-0.07004241645336151,
-0.3759535551071167,
0.23859161138534546,
-0.9918362498283386,
-0.45920735597610474,
0.02341901697218418,
0.5259555578231812,
-0.1840495765209198,
0.7613425850868225,
0.38266000151634216,
0.35230445861816406,
0.1610894501209259,
0.11496832221746445,
0.13099095225334167,
-0.20225027203559875,
-0.09561599045991898,
-0.08838579803705215,
0.7754158973693848,
0.12493308633565903,
0.21886108815670013,
-0.7874712944030762,
-0.4037555456161499,
-0.08340633660554886,
-0.006744244135916233,
-1.0491232872009277,
0.14941556751728058,
0.3219752907752991,
-0.47656118869781494,
-0.3304835557937622,
-0.22046680748462677,
-0.788976788520813,
-0.1813666820526123,
0.1521582305431366,
0.4370259642601013,
-0.4629858136177063,
-0.39435869455337524,
-0.03488602489233017,
-0.2913992404937744,
0.1434849202632904,
0.22382541000843048,
-1.1731854677200317,
0.15959890186786652,
0.5803976655006409,
1.2274889945983887,
-0.32349497079849243,
0.06970911473035812,
-0.7039346694946289,
0.6575080156326294,
-0.6982479691505432,
0.49457329511642456,
-0.46472591161727905,
-0.7059144377708435,
0.10252608358860016,
-0.17647580802440643,
-0.16737712919712067,
-0.7338327765464783,
0.3098520338535309,
-0.4570424258708954,
-0.1127646267414093,
-0.30644550919532776,
-0.7487183213233948,
0.07147173583507538,
0.05440139397978783,
-0.916626513004303,
0.9030563831329346,
0.39657652378082275,
-0.5749038457870483,
0.381803035736084,
-0.4002646505832672,
-0.21180343627929688,
0.36747604608535767,
-0.23726174235343933,
-0.0631839707493782,
0.4121788740158081,
0.21609017252922058,
0.5028727054595947,
-0.2231924831867218,
0.19474519789218903,
-0.3595629930496216,
-0.5323188900947571,
0.037785064429044724,
-0.2434680461883545,
0.9201808571815491,
0.08308995515108109,
-0.25755757093429565,
0.3190222382545471,
-0.45166510343551636,
-0.043971482664346695,
0.18101851642131805,
-0.48229026794433594,
-0.49792712926864624,
-0.18269428610801697,
0.13633474707603455,
-0.03481999412178993,
0.18915008008480072,
-0.7367948293685913,
0.30389177799224854,
-0.24851740896701813,
0.734745979309082,
0.7890954613685608,
-0.12537409365177155,
0.6126485466957092,
-0.48097795248031616,
0.512382984161377,
0.21665295958518982,
-0.3061796724796295,
0.10391451418399811,
-0.35976725816726685,
-1.1545885801315308,
-0.7517915368080139,
0.46004730463027954,
0.539753794670105,
-1.1294420957565308,
0.3267507553100586,
-0.7449948787689209,
-0.005903596058487892,
-0.5716730952262878,
0.3307962417602539,
0.34457701444625854,
0.005603419151157141,
0.43751856684684753,
-0.20066744089126587,
-0.47234851121902466,
-0.6904422044754028,
-0.23134154081344604,
-0.07181156426668167,
-0.23857977986335754,
0.07116027921438217,
0.31034284830093384,
-0.14185188710689545,
0.7418994903564453,
-0.2231924831867218,
-0.21985524892807007,
-0.6335595846176147,
-0.0027029237244278193,
-0.3632766306400299,
0.6272449493408203,
0.6607664227485657,
-0.3018445372581482,
-0.40565040707588196,
-0.2823166847229004,
-0.6168786883354187,
-0.22139641642570496,
0.057196635752916336,
0.012358264997601509,
0.34209105372428894,
0.628930926322937,
-0.6518853902816772,
0.23308925330638885,
0.5236968994140625,
-0.26488813757896423,
0.09201106429100037,
-0.1808357685804367,
-0.22997713088989258,
-1.422642707824707,
0.181572824716568,
-0.09017913788557053,
-0.3965582549571991,
-0.8467079997062683,
0.06872762739658356,
0.30169907212257385,
-0.27645182609558105,
-0.6178951859474182,
0.8494217395782471,
-0.457848459482193,
-0.03313056752085686,
0.041714657098054886,
0.24371621012687683,
-0.0766742005944252,
0.5784479379653931,
-0.07266087830066681,
1.1353492736816406,
0.31582993268966675,
-0.49690794944763184,
0.004144482780247927,
0.10266053676605225,
-0.28094568848609924,
0.21233318746089935,
-0.6133923530578613,
0.14265617728233337,
-0.1409153789281845,
0.07628770917654037,
-0.7249118685722351,
-0.05126674845814705,
0.48466265201568604,
-0.2647135555744171,
0.6565403938293457,
-0.17589673399925232,
-0.5658251643180847,
0.036613579839468,
-0.7272897958755493,
0.7414504885673523,
0.40936219692230225,
-0.5657203793525696,
0.6610348224639893,
0.24589556455612183,
0.2289820909500122,
-0.6165583729743958,
-0.9630086421966553,
0.22918103635311127,
-0.16758380830287933,
-0.34303370118141174,
0.5853993892669678,
-0.13003115355968475,
-0.0922287330031395,
0.38834524154663086,
-0.10014425963163376,
-0.09865830838680267,
0.13484583795070648,
0.12857671082019806,
0.07178241014480591,
-0.11928866058588028,
0.22854836285114288,
0.163633331656456,
-0.2950957417488098,
-0.463575541973114,
-0.7157164216041565,
0.6322789788246155,
0.07486967742443085,
-0.2747691571712494,
-0.40880125761032104,
0.7312461733818054,
0.5274454951286316,
0.005723321344703436,
0.7658427357673645,
0.5412907004356384,
-0.5011872053146362,
-0.36722561717033386,
-0.5615111589431763,
0.48196813464164734,
-0.4766310751438141,
0.32294702529907227,
-0.4929189682006836,
-1.419548749923706,
0.44579142332077026,
0.08383218944072723,
0.04808562248945236,
0.34046024084091187,
0.3530294895172119,
0.2707706391811371,
0.8088987469673157,
0.5644326210021973,
-0.1343432068824768,
0.5864786505699158,
-0.2831248939037323,
0.12720899283885956,
-0.7447049617767334,
-0.2548297643661499,
-0.4212929606437683,
-0.11802513152360916,
-0.6199840903282166,
-0.9734598398208618,
0.05714108794927597,
0.3066283166408539,
-0.20338095724582672,
0.2282768338918686,
-0.1629745066165924,
0.44421184062957764,
0.44777971506118774,
0.10986527055501938,
0.16098524630069733,
0.20192347466945648,
-0.47043001651763916,
-0.1020134836435318,
-0.6392889022827148,
-0.34151387214660645,
1.071042537689209,
0.2318231463432312,
0.7031197547912598,
0.20896291732788086,
0.8360196948051453,
0.24362045526504517,
0.2394612431526184,
-1.1488093137741089,
0.698081374168396,
-0.5557189583778381,
-0.26617616415023804,
0.05945361405611038,
-0.49972090125083923,
-0.9812973141670227,
0.29036691784858704,
-0.13824570178985596,
-0.6113476157188416,
0.19938479363918304,
0.020127635449171066,
-0.18018588423728943,
0.9626467823982239,
-0.6241269111633301,
0.40449461340904236,
-0.04699933901429176,
-0.46190840005874634,
-0.2657261788845062,
-0.007197307888418436,
0.11174313724040985,
-0.14016635715961456,
-0.02218264527618885,
-0.08912885934114456,
-0.7905665636062622,
0.6360004544258118,
-0.35044389963150024,
0.8830108046531677,
-0.28981560468673706,
0.015420744195580482,
0.1538081020116806,
0.31906548142433167,
0.2610153555870056,
-0.16832120716571808,
0.02258019708096981,
0.47890132665634155,
-0.20756682753562927,
-0.67512446641922,
-0.5047356486320496,
0.7405277490615845,
-0.7719149589538574,
-0.8813349008560181,
-0.13615632057189941,
-0.5448199510574341,
-0.2936115264892578,
0.2989068031311035,
0.06084604561328888,
0.25474098324775696,
-0.28120291233062744,
0.3326222598552704,
0.6061030030250549,
-0.45427486300468445,
0.5222397446632385,
0.057690512388944626,
-0.2062317430973053,
-0.8521959185600281,
1.0886061191558838,
0.20523814857006073,
0.34188342094421387,
0.719377875328064,
0.12845396995544434,
-0.1335250735282898,
-0.6705828309059143,
-0.6493527889251709,
0.4156138300895691,
-0.5438688397407532,
-0.19163599610328674,
-0.7013561725616455,
-0.18168996274471283,
-0.2699525058269501,
-0.2633635997772217,
-0.2740015387535095,
-1.0066548585891724,
-0.6303832530975342,
-0.22614899277687073,
-0.01863684691488743,
0.7813659310340881,
-0.19390016794204712,
0.09670916944742203,
-0.8039902448654175,
0.3234158456325531,
0.3315242826938629,
0.5768048167228699,
0.2063383013010025,
-0.04988456517457962,
-0.351112961769104,
-0.2764579653739929,
-0.20866867899894714,
-0.6829618811607361,
0.45490363240242004,
0.28553056716918945,
0.55057293176651,
0.5465226769447327,
-0.14293865859508514,
0.8975852131843567,
-0.41666653752326965,
1.04544997215271,
0.14868661761283875,
-1.2685637474060059,
0.184489905834198,
-0.25781312584877014,
0.02540448307991028,
0.18803980946540833,
0.2467656433582306,
-0.544546365737915,
-0.4631257951259613,
-0.30355116724967957,
-0.9073315262794495,
0.5511555075645447,
0.05219163000583649,
0.2295881062746048,
-0.29289430379867554,
0.31319835782051086,
0.23931050300598145,
0.20496876537799835,
-0.6005489230155945,
-0.1666870266199112,
-0.5132313966751099,
-0.2132491022348404,
-0.011248168535530567,
-0.7212580442428589,
0.11849933862686157,
-0.11581527441740036,
0.455092191696167,
0.07550128549337387,
0.6962941884994507,
-0.06387641280889511,
-0.41767868399620056,
-0.2700495719909668,
0.3530186116695404,
0.5810117721557617,
0.16317987442016602,
-0.07006005942821503,
0.2734908163547516,
0.23783008754253387,
-0.30441009998321533,
0.1948738843202591,
-0.1400659829378128,
-0.5473697185516357,
0.26678019762039185,
0.3507263958454132,
0.8365225791931152,
0.5341079235076904,
-0.3455583155155182,
0.6889747977256775,
0.08561914414167404,
-0.44047361612319946,
-0.09860087186098099,
-0.23292860388755798,
0.1470755785703659,
0.1332055777311325,
0.2666172385215759,
-0.08687932789325714,
-0.24405907094478607,
-0.1884101778268814,
-0.002228210214525461,
0.5443243980407715,
-0.4156072735786438,
-0.5139257907867432,
0.8251699209213257,
0.2719447612762451,
-0.1368599534034729,
0.5579752922058105,
-0.11791753023862839,
-0.397763192653656,
0.1054808646440506,
0.8448980450630188,
1.4990167617797852,
-0.24912738800048828,
0.05714701488614082,
0.4403645694255829,
0.1921965479850769,
-0.061267536133527756,
0.2420085221529007,
-0.42203155159950256,
-0.7523282766342163,
-0.37047967314720154,
-0.5299370288848877,
-0.3401269018650055,
0.10486258566379547,
-0.282195508480072,
0.025352703407406807,
-0.7463231086730957,
-0.04709199443459511,
-0.6069582104682922,
-0.06836074590682983,
-0.48225483298301697,
-0.35629093647003174,
0.14010131359100342,
1.1215914487838745,
-0.6358685493469238,
1.0841525793075562,
0.28770649433135986,
-0.518099844455719,
-0.7550110220909119,
-0.00018487786292098463,
-0.17326687276363373,
-0.9869571328163147,
0.8160771131515503,
0.3231290876865387,
-0.15335112810134888,
0.06461840122938156,
-0.329460471868515,
-0.9385588765144348,
1.194140076637268,
0.7962831258773804,
-0.18034754693508148,
-0.43865129351615906,
0.38379213213920593,
0.18948127329349518,
-0.30341392755508423,
-0.030612535774707794,
0.14241687953472137,
0.3049545884132385,
0.09733901917934418,
-0.6765301823616028,
0.3604453206062317,
-0.24318063259124756,
0.5040522217750549,
0.29460594058036804,
-0.784549355506897,
0.8343946933746338,
-0.07419821619987488,
-0.875449001789093,
0.43727192282676697,
0.6534601449966431,
0.11213672906160355,
-0.23739980161190033,
0.49724432826042175,
0.7749248147010803,
0.6860009431838989,
-0.25216370820999146,
0.8543854355812073,
-0.5815666317939758,
0.06526683270931244,
0.5331998467445374,
0.11859475821256638,
0.8519966006278992,
0.6682097315788269,
0.12948526442050934,
0.42884889245033264,
0.36365383863449097,
0.12231405824422836,
0.4761052429676056,
0.33198627829551697,
-0.7070922255516052,
-0.42540648579597473,
-0.423527330160141,
-0.21493983268737793,
0.024515250697731972,
0.7311697006225586,
-0.3456096351146698,
-0.4223460853099823,
-0.07717782258987427,
0.10840649157762527,
-0.24134860932826996,
-0.47150593996047974,
0.5379419922828674,
0.27295735478401184,
-0.16081546247005463,
0.7189200520515442,
0.017840666696429253,
0.9556434750556946,
-0.5416614413261414,
-0.001925844931975007,
-0.3322046995162964,
0.012864340096712112,
-0.2019205242395401,
-0.3883773684501648,
0.35096272826194763,
0.129367396235466,
0.21146339178085327,
-0.7136884331703186,
0.6557534337043762,
-0.653282880783081,
-0.17506134510040283,
0.4989810287952423,
0.7851255536079407,
0.1433442234992981,
0.3781237304210663,
-0.42039039731025696,
0.04096200689673424,
-0.09906584769487381,
-0.20962458848953247,
0.2806582748889923,
0.39310652017593384,
-0.25889524817466736,
0.7794583439826965,
0.4524567723274231,
0.32510635256767273,
0.31051310896873474,
0.19375205039978027,
0.8987773656845093,
-0.8114390969276428,
-0.3571179211139679,
-0.6993945837020874,
0.21882976591587067,
0.2515251636505127,
0.19848208129405975,
0.6015633344650269,
0.7035544514656067,
0.8225846886634827,
-0.07510121911764145,
0.7627246975898743,
0.01635143533349037,
0.2977350652217865,
-0.5267977714538574,
0.6277446746826172,
-0.7414572834968567,
0.16525717079639435,
0.03003518655896187,
-0.7824339270591736,
-0.8376060128211975,
0.23964707553386688,
0.17806750535964966,
0.06819948554039001,
0.6672626733779907,
0.7088218927383423,
-0.02863708883523941,
-0.21106775104999542,
0.6179310083389282,
0.06905262917280197,
0.4432627260684967,
0.7980431914329529,
0.697465181350708,
-0.29531583189964294,
0.7122369408607483,
-0.11948239803314209,
-0.07964116334915161,
-0.12548251450061798,
-0.8827421069145203,
-1.035335659980774,
-0.5141538977622986,
-0.1419532150030136,
-0.3404316008090973,
0.06499763578176498,
1.3324508666992188,
0.4803047776222229,
-0.8155233860015869,
-0.35825181007385254,
-0.09934797883033752,
0.10507398843765259,
0.01918718032538891,
-0.1423051506280899,
0.5531754493713379,
-0.5678135752677917,
-0.9501410126686096,
0.5939509272575378,
0.4064323902130127,
0.34176528453826904,
-0.17306281626224518,
-0.05140622705221176,
0.28549158573150635,
0.06743988394737244,
0.5940609574317932,
0.2505180537700653,
-0.8576166033744812,
-0.5399195551872253,
-0.0726093202829361,
-0.20834900438785553,
0.15993613004684448,
1.0445623397827148,
-0.7083858847618103,
0.33312270045280457,
0.5262108445167542,
0.8571579456329346,
0.44400596618652344,
-0.2536669671535492,
0.613353431224823,
-0.9725327491760254,
0.34779778122901917,
0.17550300061702728,
0.5662065744400024,
0.5047069191932678,
-0.0654650628566742,
0.32299476861953735,
0.4435192048549652,
-0.10487593710422516,
-0.6066102981567383,
0.22883795201778412,
-1.1171101331710815,
-0.2196735292673111,
1.2542864084243774,
-0.2613896429538727,
-0.25301891565322876,
-0.1596459150314331,
0.2446407675743103,
0.5886231660842896,
-0.6249796748161316,
0.44629061222076416,
0.5671483278274536,
0.1770126223564148,
-0.24632832407951355,
-0.34120529890060425,
0.4832659959793091,
0.26919206976890564,
-0.34780848026275635,
0.15626424551010132,
0.38273563981056213,
0.40645286440849304,
0.022462105378508568,
0.7290304899215698,
-0.3562331199645996,
-0.08973380923271179,
0.055985577404499054,
-0.034038905054330826,
-0.4003540277481079,
-0.05061541125178337,
-0.5573151707649231,
0.5288604497909546,
0.28547853231430054,
-0.48912566900253296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19215v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19215v1 | SeaKR: Self-aware Knowledge Retrieval for Adaptive Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-27T14:38:33 | 2024-06-27T14:38:33 | Zijun Yao, Weijian Qi, Liangming Pan, Shulin Cao, Linmei Hu, Weichuan Liu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces Self-aware Knowledge Retrieval (SeaKR), a novel
adaptive RAG model that extracts self-aware uncertainty of LLMs from their
internal states. SeaKR activates retrieval when the LLMs present high
self-aware uncertainty for generation. To effectively integrate retrieved
knowledge snippets, SeaKR re-ranks them based on LLM's self-aware uncertainty
to preserve the snippet that reduces their uncertainty to the utmost. To
facilitate solving complex tasks that require multiple retrievals, SeaKR
utilizes their self-aware uncertainty to choose among different reasoning
strategies. Our experiments on both complex and simple Question Answering
datasets show that SeaKR outperforms existing adaptive RAG methods. We release
our code at https://github.com/THU-KEG/SeaKR. | [
-0.26912176609039307,
-0.6224945783615112,
0.6511149406433105,
0.10994558036327362,
-0.27175840735435486,
0.39208000898361206,
0.3843802511692047,
-0.22910816967487335,
0.18808822333812714,
0.620691180229187,
-0.32882875204086304,
-0.08427059650421143,
-0.43961864709854126,
0.021765349432826042,
-0.1248851791024208,
0.7658101320266724,
0.10774339735507965,
0.029689542949199677,
-0.37024247646331787,
-0.15751586854457855,
-0.20090465247631073,
-0.40818846225738525,
-0.5976982712745667,
-0.1474609673023224,
0.23326638340950012,
0.6908653378486633,
0.43615344166755676,
0.43097880482673645,
0.7134156823158264,
0.328677237033844,
-0.1857178807258606,
0.17221902310848236,
-0.4057745337486267,
0.867257833480835,
-0.5542774796485901,
-0.27134421467781067,
-0.42409271001815796,
-0.3253526985645294,
0.4837646186351776,
0.3778754472732544,
-0.2967418134212494,
0.48119112849235535,
-0.006623954977840185,
1.040681004524231,
-1.0108225345611572,
-0.16885244846343994,
-0.8379641175270081,
0.029475349932909012,
-0.30720001459121704,
-0.33202752470970154,
-0.2933191657066345,
-0.07988561689853668,
0.2824389934539795,
-0.8300126194953918,
0.3308541476726532,
0.26911672949790955,
-0.0017741997726261616,
0.7762208580970764,
-0.5862200260162354,
-0.7173552513122559,
-0.7379027605056763,
0.7311413884162903,
-0.4884275197982788,
0.665590226650238,
0.3842877149581909,
0.6904098987579346,
-0.3485964238643646,
-1.0746735334396362,
-0.6989943385124207,
0.20947124063968658,
0.2660767138004303,
0.5552834272384644,
-0.04795133322477341,
-0.045959558337926865,
0.004253804683685303,
0.5965414047241211,
-0.3269088864326477,
-0.30945342779159546,
-0.5820034742355347,
-0.2129913568496704,
0.693352997303009,
0.1705997735261917,
-0.09946886450052261,
-0.6323654055595398,
-0.6836849451065063,
0.025382807478308678,
-0.5590929388999939,
0.1413542777299881,
0.18928959965705872,
0.2188749760389328,
0.12172214686870575,
0.669486939907074,
-0.5017818808555603,
0.8237186670303345,
0.31726887822151184,
-0.33320122957229614,
0.13762056827545166,
-0.0053957304917275906,
-0.11601114273071289,
0.35808631777763367,
0.5140286087989807,
0.133848175406456,
-0.37335628271102905,
0.07364062964916229,
-0.24501897394657135,
-0.5382457971572876,
0.5473936796188354,
-0.2763708233833313,
-0.11350566893815994,
0.12381722033023834,
-0.5246679186820984,
-0.3582976758480072,
-0.2561303377151489,
-1.1361689567565918,
-0.6804059743881226,
0.16691818833351135,
0.9822155237197876,
-0.20459717512130737,
-0.3561031222343445,
0.0513446182012558,
-0.17820826172828674,
0.271145761013031,
0.23082706332206726,
-0.5831402540206909,
0.18473942577838898,
0.45872434973716736,
0.4494086503982544,
-0.21609924733638763,
-0.07426086813211441,
-0.2507014274597168,
0.5206207633018494,
-0.47031956911087036,
1.0188732147216797,
-0.48297351598739624,
-0.6379508376121521,
-0.31033945083618164,
-0.42342203855514526,
0.2794380486011505,
-0.5225216150283813,
0.6820974349975586,
-1.079228162765503,
0.3425427973270416,
-0.5712884068489075,
-0.8729111552238464,
-0.2807599902153015,
0.045917510986328125,
-0.6485752463340759,
1.169203758239746,
0.26693490147590637,
-0.9428495764732361,
0.2857857346534729,
-0.5982012748718262,
-0.20231658220291138,
0.32003989815711975,
0.07252378761768341,
-0.2678973078727722,
0.16381540894508362,
0.1919327825307846,
0.5664966106414795,
-0.33919331431388855,
-0.11523598432540894,
-0.3877030313014984,
-0.026587041094899178,
0.05401641130447388,
-0.15248437225818634,
0.5162068605422974,
0.8852209448814392,
0.09881787747144699,
-0.20744504034519196,
-0.7356567978858948,
0.19784532487392426,
0.16906511783599854,
-0.4196773171424866,
-0.4963819682598114,
-0.037912219762802124,
-0.6915213465690613,
0.07800168544054031,
0.5955395102500916,
-0.5209017992019653,
0.41828107833862305,
-0.23687829077243805,
0.1629435271024704,
0.8686210513114929,
0.5553526282310486,
0.6394015550613403,
-0.5109187364578247,
0.6643253564834595,
-0.08677459508180618,
0.039882875978946686,
0.08816087245941162,
-0.32894670963287354,
-0.7511485815048218,
-0.14917348325252533,
0.41266724467277527,
0.3730974793434143,
-1.2001932859420776,
-0.058913152664899826,
-0.0012005481403321028,
-0.7359052896499634,
-0.9497358798980713,
0.1812974065542221,
0.32777559757232666,
0.7898887395858765,
0.6208133101463318,
-0.04474809393286705,
-0.7661923766136169,
-0.5877307653427124,
-0.5301480889320374,
-0.1657683253288269,
0.26774275302886963,
0.37509945034980774,
0.2509377896785736,
-0.20329175889492035,
0.9946056604385376,
-0.5078173279762268,
-0.24678240716457367,
-0.33997997641563416,
0.2246384471654892,
0.11906581372022629,
0.38143259286880493,
0.11427783221006393,
-0.9045411944389343,
-0.6632657647132874,
-0.3591010570526123,
-0.7828429937362671,
-0.12078102678060532,
-0.12388813495635986,
-0.18832820653915405,
0.17619483172893524,
0.6212754249572754,
-0.6467004418373108,
0.38745495676994324,
0.5052229762077332,
-0.2984223961830139,
0.6177508234977722,
-0.4255807101726532,
0.19188900291919708,
-1.349303126335144,
-0.14125707745552063,
-0.5010105967521667,
-0.23472940921783447,
-0.5774031281471252,
0.13634851574897766,
0.01887788064777851,
0.3259468674659729,
-0.20862890779972076,
0.7908115983009338,
-0.5042147636413574,
-0.5733826160430908,
-0.3602136969566345,
0.13580681383609772,
-0.053435660898685455,
0.06573347747325897,
-0.2753174901008606,
1.0616363286972046,
0.512854278087616,
-0.9038084149360657,
0.3557288646697998,
0.20630714297294617,
-0.5096433162689209,
0.6780957579612732,
-0.4651342034339905,
0.33108633756637573,
-0.24035733938217163,
-0.05859125033020973,
-1.073981761932373,
-0.3722607493400574,
0.187224343419075,
-0.645645797252655,
0.2841084897518158,
-0.2502715289592743,
-0.233248770236969,
-0.3098127245903015,
0.10430967807769775,
0.6743853092193604,
0.5176082849502563,
-0.6486982703208923,
1.0178172588348389,
0.5878407955169678,
-0.2990049123764038,
-0.7127709984779358,
-0.210709810256958,
-0.320141077041626,
-0.1788339465856552,
-0.15044842660427094,
0.352676123380661,
-0.352403461933136,
-0.1840110719203949,
0.06536536663770676,
-0.6290298700332642,
-0.14257219433784485,
0.03618762269616127,
0.09355061501264572,
-0.0029613052029162645,
0.09397910535335541,
0.43694746494293213,
0.2298654317855835,
-0.26835358142852783,
-0.06672517955303192,
-0.031173819676041603,
0.3801024854183197,
-0.08436619490385056,
-0.5229548811912537,
0.15701934695243835,
-0.018824182450771332,
0.48647329211235046,
-0.19992396235466003,
0.28343307971954346,
0.4931371808052063,
-0.20133961737155914,
-0.27887067198753357,
-0.9687142968177795,
0.079225555062294,
-0.5812652111053467,
-0.03135358914732933,
-0.8322142958641052,
-1.0320429801940918,
0.5495128035545349,
-0.42218631505966187,
-0.22401559352874756,
0.8326261639595032,
0.5566459894180298,
-0.6669243574142456,
0.8566696047782898,
0.4494432806968689,
0.049936745315790176,
0.02497764676809311,
-0.07961985468864441,
0.05143805593252182,
-1.174167275428772,
-0.2777218520641327,
-0.2882732152938843,
-0.12765660881996155,
-0.6241328120231628,
-0.6011215448379517,
0.6362071633338928,
0.5210275053977966,
-0.4414597749710083,
-0.19001539051532745,
-0.9119567275047302,
0.26972895860671997,
0.8734235167503357,
0.1771049052476883,
0.4069279432296753,
-0.19217807054519653,
-0.4078074097633362,
-0.10973438620567322,
-0.8716481328010559,
-0.0022317562252283096,
1.2450010776519775,
-0.03541627526283264,
0.9133296608924866,
0.24411973357200623,
0.8385592699050903,
0.550087034702301,
-0.07604609429836273,
-0.3953302502632141,
0.5677837133407593,
0.10323286056518555,
-0.9614908695220947,
-0.4502653479576111,
-0.6010734438896179,
-1.1135666370391846,
0.08387602865695953,
-0.29476597905158997,
-0.18417342007160187,
0.200398251414299,
0.07112625986337662,
-0.5797342658042908,
0.3129197955131531,
-0.450215220451355,
0.4396417438983917,
-0.38329777121543884,
-0.030125601217150688,
-0.4877120554447174,
-0.6709333062171936,
0.23292969167232513,
-0.37474510073661804,
0.343473881483078,
-0.11362188309431076,
-0.12290365248918533,
0.9141244888305664,
-0.07430750131607056,
0.5311753749847412,
-0.4204273223876953,
0.25320178270339966,
0.6346296668052673,
0.6302326321601868,
0.4435771107673645,
-0.1546715497970581,
-0.324152410030365,
-0.1497422605752945,
0.10788382589817047,
-0.407917320728302,
-0.6988980770111084,
0.5672581791877747,
-0.7698262333869934,
-0.8192372918128967,
-0.6696068644523621,
-0.6559696793556213,
-0.177787646651268,
0.5516543388366699,
0.31027111411094666,
-0.0961557924747467,
0.22582747042179108,
0.32694607973098755,
0.755721390247345,
-0.3075248897075653,
0.2706203758716583,
0.8471972346305847,
-0.31130632758140564,
-0.7472130656242371,
0.8853319883346558,
0.3484172821044922,
0.18588808178901672,
0.32959890365600586,
0.3264569938182831,
-0.4050423502922058,
-0.3863702118396759,
-0.13165447115898132,
-0.010475749149918556,
-0.9362407326698303,
-0.6846657991409302,
-0.652590811252594,
-0.3427045941352844,
-0.5253247618675232,
-0.32953858375549316,
-0.5554322600364685,
-0.8181697130203247,
-0.08026420325040817,
-0.1627562791109085,
0.6168871521949768,
1.1775027513504028,
-0.5576329827308655,
0.29078760743141174,
-0.5377179384231567,
0.7063167095184326,
0.8217775225639343,
0.58458411693573,
-0.20932833850383759,
-0.8994196653366089,
-0.05360228568315506,
-0.006321981083601713,
-0.2660433053970337,
-0.9382315874099731,
0.286975234746933,
0.09216798096895218,
0.931143045425415,
0.06545079499483109,
0.44659075140953064,
0.8005788326263428,
-0.2022230327129364,
0.6332622766494751,
-0.08160073310136795,
-0.9555776119232178,
0.7082111835479736,
-0.18719539046287537,
0.4159923195838928,
0.5754868388175964,
0.5155587196350098,
-0.3387176990509033,
0.0015563149936497211,
-0.8249440789222717,
-0.834696352481842,
0.4573121666908264,
-0.08788460493087769,
-0.1595354974269867,
0.13602885603904724,
0.8231140971183777,
0.16302327811717987,
0.1891583800315857,
-0.5058466792106628,
-0.31529948115348816,
-0.41223227977752686,
-0.4067656993865967,
0.1993829756975174,
-0.8663040399551392,
0.10801426321268082,
-0.2972171902656555,
0.8218026161193848,
-0.012599506415426731,
0.48484212160110474,
0.6417136192321777,
-0.18277454376220703,
-0.40028971433639526,
0.0903230533003807,
0.31288009881973267,
0.487271249294281,
-0.18723928928375244,
0.4598906338214874,
0.6747578382492065,
-0.4231298565864563,
0.19265635311603546,
-0.028698502108454704,
-0.1337224543094635,
-0.24032357335090637,
0.24601498246192932,
0.3066059648990631,
0.33903610706329346,
-0.4058040976524353,
0.2855486273765564,
0.003741662949323654,
0.006581219844520092,
-0.47300419211387634,
0.15298841893672943,
0.012638363987207413,
0.684148371219635,
0.7330281734466553,
0.12316029518842697,
0.35114628076553345,
-0.12960337102413177,
0.40508121252059937,
0.34790876507759094,
-0.21710360050201416,
0.06323449313640594,
0.728525698184967,
-0.20654180645942688,
-0.33294498920440674,
0.40302979946136475,
-0.45789235830307007,
-0.5502505302429199,
0.13825364410877228,
0.5030620098114014,
0.6226114630699158,
-0.9095278382301331,
0.10187088698148727,
0.41777440905570984,
0.10164383053779602,
-0.11658556014299393,
0.647163987159729,
-0.16918601095676422,
-0.854564905166626,
-0.3116566836833954,
-0.7884464859962463,
-0.5228106379508972,
-0.24065780639648438,
-0.6353493332862854,
-0.07078550010919571,
-0.498366117477417,
-0.1692190319299698,
-0.2831057608127594,
0.1906215250492096,
-0.5447548031806946,
0.2194903939962387,
-0.39507266879081726,
0.9164982438087463,
-0.28933799266815186,
0.7182947993278503,
0.631821870803833,
-0.29967519640922546,
-0.6394774913787842,
-0.1303141564130783,
-0.12512904405593872,
-1.0159335136413574,
0.6705678105354309,
-0.45259666442871094,
-0.15550579130649567,
0.29807233810424805,
-0.6575663685798645,
-1.5231266021728516,
1.3385249376296997,
-0.045303624123334885,
-0.10917866230010986,
0.2013397067785263,
0.18305517733097076,
0.5385709404945374,
-0.332660049200058,
-0.034899383783340454,
0.2207871973514557,
0.30611151456832886,
0.5086355209350586,
-0.6949425935745239,
-0.08554920554161072,
-0.0488666333258152,
-0.11751465499401093,
-0.025693511590361595,
-0.7612822651863098,
0.7632699012756348,
-0.3460742235183716,
-0.00322993122972548,
-0.11695391684770584,
0.9674413204193115,
0.5657477974891663,
0.42378413677215576,
0.5798853635787964,
0.7961974143981934,
0.820705235004425,
0.19539320468902588,
0.6989564895629883,
-0.5730018019676208,
0.23495714366436005,
1.3972148895263672,
-0.16244101524353027,
1.0231342315673828,
0.4194284677505493,
-0.03758331015706062,
0.4990474581718445,
0.4702076017856598,
0.2649490535259247,
0.8985610008239746,
-0.2030300498008728,
-0.43631213903427124,
-0.4139418601989746,
0.21571356058120728,
-0.43469682335853577,
0.7109760642051697,
0.5263159275054932,
-0.006814651191234589,
-0.14765183627605438,
0.04364890977740288,
-0.3175418972969055,
-0.20981326699256897,
-0.4133600890636444,
1.1668273210525513,
0.07124140113592148,
-0.6652607321739197,
0.38492584228515625,
-0.27587708830833435,
0.3319409489631653,
-0.4036569893360138,
-0.2402764856815338,
-0.18523085117340088,
0.02011769451200962,
-0.10834819078445435,
-1.1051547527313232,
0.25182294845581055,
-0.2937977910041809,
-0.21421463787555695,
-0.20844200253486633,
1.456028699874878,
-0.270303338766098,
-0.5990674495697021,
0.08932320028543472,
0.7490636110305786,
0.20017868280410767,
0.06712925434112549,
-0.9171871542930603,
-0.07855085283517838,
0.1388426423072815,
-0.44516581296920776,
0.1984332799911499,
0.8647869825363159,
0.33042430877685547,
1.3174618482589722,
0.6853476762771606,
0.016339585185050964,
0.3838261067867279,
-0.4617275297641754,
0.7254730463027954,
-0.7354447245597839,
-0.2823856472969055,
-0.34545373916625977,
0.41602247953414917,
0.06425361335277557,
-0.1613895148038864,
0.9467453956604004,
0.5498204827308655,
0.7597397565841675,
0.0929097905755043,
0.8765182495117188,
-0.21103185415267944,
1.303802490234375,
-0.2747949957847595,
0.7044543623924255,
-0.6543405055999756,
0.3790060579776764,
-0.2025420069694519,
-0.7206348776817322,
-0.028793781995773315,
0.8076053857803345,
-0.33898019790649414,
0.14480794966220856,
0.23682403564453125,
0.6271644234657288,
0.055470991879701614,
-0.062418412417173386,
0.35405075550079346,
0.5293388962745667,
-0.005373064428567886,
0.08628334850072861,
0.7787929773330688,
-0.47456809878349304,
0.5640453696250916,
-0.5909892320632935,
-0.022832956165075302,
-0.2919781804084778,
-0.7474546432495117,
-0.43652844429016113,
-0.8949516415596008,
0.09379718452692032,
-0.2957155108451843,
0.012571247294545174,
0.8440423011779785,
0.5524471998214722,
-0.5800732970237732,
-0.015276837162673473,
-0.02481018379330635,
0.36090371012687683,
-0.03690971061587334,
-0.2304886430501938,
0.3538717031478882,
-0.7177494764328003,
-0.11815357208251953,
0.614112913608551,
0.09742307662963867,
0.2296343743801117,
-0.25260964035987854,
-0.21409787237644196,
-0.2792990803718567,
0.09418992698192596,
0.5857354998588562,
0.2500845491886139,
-0.4946812391281128,
-0.23048296570777893,
0.06279290467500687,
-0.07981274276971817,
-0.07777469605207443,
0.437913179397583,
-1.0413110256195068,
1.0264484882354736,
0.6217930316925049,
0.6390002965927124,
0.8195854425430298,
0.07424505054950714,
0.3708094358444214,
-0.6888427138328552,
-0.17812767624855042,
0.39689263701438904,
0.2199990153312683,
0.2565659284591675,
-0.5731643438339233,
0.7405074834823608,
0.1787009835243225,
-1.085813283920288,
-0.7109811305999756,
0.1130158007144928,
-0.9227511882781982,
-0.5086425542831421,
0.8913940191268921,
0.10595620423555374,
-0.04359083250164986,
-0.26604679226875305,
-0.14878052473068237,
0.36369723081588745,
-0.16595765948295593,
1.1938027143478394,
0.41699549555778503,
-0.25494450330734253,
-0.38679367303848267,
-0.698965311050415,
0.8377304077148438,
0.47363489866256714,
-0.48229315876960754,
-0.1206907406449318,
0.1112523004412651,
0.45614752173423767,
0.1751154363155365,
0.8430304527282715,
0.11720298230648041,
0.35275954008102417,
-0.0037476711440831423,
0.3342415988445282,
0.09385544806718826,
-0.2516939043998718,
-0.06125781312584877,
0.25160783529281616,
0.21413511037826538,
0.23934946954250336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19172v1 | Annotation Errors and NER: A Study with OntoNotes 5.0 | 2024-06-27T13:48:46 | 2024-06-27T13:48:46 | Gabriel Bernier-Colborne, Sowmya Vajjala | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a well-studied problem in NLP. However,
there is much less focus on studying NER datasets, compared to developing new
NER models. In this paper, we employed three simple techniques to detect
annotation errors in the OntoNotes 5.0 corpus for English NER, which is the
largest available NER corpus for English. Our techniques corrected ~10% of the
sentences in train/dev/test data. In terms of entity mentions, we corrected the
span and/or type of ~8% of mentions in the dataset, while
adding/deleting/splitting/merging a few more. These are large numbers of
changes, considering the size of OntoNotes. We used three NER libraries to
train, evaluate and compare the models trained with the original and the
re-annotated datasets, which showed an average improvement of 1.23% in overall
F-scores, with large (>10%) improvements for some of the entity types. While
our annotation error detection methods are not exhaustive and there is some
manual annotation effort involved, they are largely language agnostic and can
be employed with other NER datasets, and other sequence labelling tasks. | [
-0.38313692808151245,
-0.4191894233226776,
0.4408857226371765,
0.28969115018844604,
-0.029649831354618073,
-0.21191474795341492,
-0.2664130628108978,
-0.827238142490387,
0.32211214303970337,
0.5980081558227539,
-0.062148675322532654,
-0.3927805721759796,
-0.5636597871780396,
0.7765108942985535,
-0.5130067467689514,
1.1435376405715942,
-0.07925941795110703,
0.24492855370044708,
-0.12539565563201904,
-0.2695031762123108,
-0.3076355457305908,
-0.4897676408290863,
-1.1963173151016235,
-0.08881746977567673,
0.8334270119667053,
0.4119536876678467,
0.05608556419610977,
0.49109965562820435,
0.8648445010185242,
0.17555512487888336,
-0.3482517898082733,
0.33681774139404297,
-0.005834453273564577,
0.011540952138602734,
-0.08248152583837509,
-0.3940877318382263,
-0.6561782956123352,
-0.16160333156585693,
0.5517397522926331,
0.43674907088279724,
0.17867136001586914,
0.0838087946176529,
-0.0780554786324501,
0.2052282840013504,
-0.4653184413909912,
0.30422475934028625,
-0.49457550048828125,
0.15913374722003937,
-0.4127504527568817,
-0.2283216416835785,
-0.5359153747558594,
-0.20970280468463898,
0.2804315984249115,
-0.768699049949646,
0.31637415289878845,
0.23989777266979218,
1.0368746519088745,
0.3682858645915985,
-0.1389511376619339,
-0.2796975076198578,
-0.7511191964149475,
0.7888200879096985,
-0.6922739148139954,
0.34307652711868286,
0.515710711479187,
0.15336313843727112,
-0.05451779440045357,
-0.7230721116065979,
-0.6853040456771851,
-0.09368269890546799,
-0.3067144453525543,
-0.10654977709054947,
-0.1687626987695694,
0.062238145619630814,
0.8415910601615906,
0.12427559494972229,
-0.04734398052096367,
0.281074196100235,
-0.26081526279449463,
-0.23918597400188446,
0.5970931053161621,
-0.13932561874389648,
0.2738149166107178,
-0.373598575592041,
-0.29247575998306274,
-0.07960839569568634,
-0.778059184551239,
-0.3168465495109558,
0.22091948986053467,
0.37994349002838135,
0.008387742564082146,
0.32107725739479065,
-0.04074271395802498,
0.5256509780883789,
0.06890568137168884,
-0.0741434395313263,
0.4796276390552521,
-0.34289631247520447,
-0.1160900667309761,
0.3528446555137634,
0.4489978551864624,
0.42274659872055054,
0.6159856915473938,
-0.2684539258480072,
-0.5405799746513367,
-0.24691012501716614,
0.0969557985663414,
-0.5490567684173584,
-0.569693386554718,
0.11925458163022995,
-0.18269070982933044,
-0.1796131134033203,
-0.04993360489606857,
-0.4961814284324646,
-0.6497619152069092,
-0.18921829760074615,
0.4984252452850342,
-0.35597196221351624,
0.04818975180387497,
-0.29518553614616394,
-0.2484235018491745,
0.24891480803489685,
0.8562950491905212,
-0.8922885060310364,
0.3203316330909729,
0.38042134046554565,
0.5496488809585571,
0.36151912808418274,
-0.3615204691886902,
-0.518804669380188,
-0.021076899021863937,
-0.2323109656572342,
1.3259193897247314,
-0.12561848759651184,
0.01609990932047367,
-0.26977670192718506,
-0.0029477830976247787,
-0.09715940803289413,
-0.43600040674209595,
0.6314918994903564,
-0.28014251589775085,
0.20155483484268188,
-0.5267929434776306,
-0.8794542551040649,
-0.4856533706188202,
0.3682614266872406,
-1.0143870115280151,
0.7924421429634094,
-0.11955304443836212,
-1.160123348236084,
0.5715669393539429,
-0.9521393775939941,
-0.2506715953350067,
-0.026008974760770798,
-0.11788494139909744,
-0.4775364100933075,
0.16211622953414917,
0.2576727271080017,
0.4633685052394867,
-0.2431238740682602,
-0.052929818630218506,
-0.01623004674911499,
-0.35846272110939026,
0.4595816433429718,
-0.1767096072435379,
0.48705053329467773,
-0.2955743372440338,
-0.5293360352516174,
-0.19909250736236572,
-0.9854297637939453,
-0.09402540326118469,
-0.045639488846063614,
-0.30351102352142334,
-0.5832948684692383,
0.017950858920812607,
0.4332313537597656,
0.08867596089839935,
-0.18423932790756226,
-0.7928937077522278,
0.08137530088424683,
-0.19750246405601501,
0.31949424743652344,
0.3643537163734436,
0.04629333317279816,
0.10828478634357452,
-0.28570500016212463,
0.1342846006155014,
0.05857979133725166,
-0.18202827870845795,
-0.5116069912910461,
-0.5503103733062744,
-0.9069559574127197,
-0.01642478071153164,
1.0381609201431274,
0.6445930004119873,
-0.4285314381122589,
0.3018764555454254,
-0.18822245299816132,
-0.34604403376579285,
-0.37290653586387634,
-0.1237010508775711,
0.47614985704421997,
0.5633872747421265,
0.7988705039024353,
-0.12385641783475876,
-1.091247320175171,
-0.6434168219566345,
-0.2410898357629776,
-0.30794277787208557,
0.10207553207874298,
0.15831005573272705,
0.7523943185806274,
-0.08317675441503525,
0.866820216178894,
-0.17611566185951233,
-0.5306687355041504,
0.1317238211631775,
0.20475327968597412,
-0.27180030941963196,
0.5498567223548889,
0.32749179005622864,
-0.7559710741043091,
-0.34071508049964905,
-0.005600017961114645,
-0.6126826405525208,
-0.22399306297302246,
-0.2943872809410095,
0.4972490072250366,
0.6384159326553345,
0.6787975430488586,
-0.28630661964416504,
0.4927603006362915,
0.15745297074317932,
-0.1767507791519165,
0.24332334101200104,
-0.26708200573921204,
0.05736451596021652,
-0.9315032958984375,
0.12992635369300842,
0.12343332171440125,
-0.2417355477809906,
-0.5484366416931152,
-0.43499955534935,
0.2156352698802948,
0.48531633615493774,
-0.267889142036438,
0.6738882064819336,
-0.8030704259872437,
0.07020318508148193,
-0.16816222667694092,
0.3585629165172577,
0.06298727542161942,
-0.05205629765987396,
0.16248719394207,
0.29428622126579285,
0.30103859305381775,
-0.46635475754737854,
0.2641086280345917,
0.49353331327438354,
-0.11753067374229431,
0.7078805565834045,
-0.5329803228378296,
0.25780147314071655,
-0.2269713282585144,
0.2581072151660919,
-0.9443905353546143,
-0.37116605043411255,
0.28399142622947693,
-0.5449520349502563,
0.5445674657821655,
-0.12709297239780426,
-0.41122981905937195,
0.04196387901902199,
-0.26329436898231506,
-0.08839402347803116,
0.12361408770084381,
-0.6790159940719604,
0.6113964319229126,
0.3449874222278595,
0.005521892569959164,
-0.6713991165161133,
-0.9574565291404724,
0.25160956382751465,
-0.18551254272460938,
-0.4372480809688568,
0.4423219561576843,
0.3757980167865753,
-0.2784457504749298,
0.18468710780143738,
-0.24004729092121124,
-0.1692250669002533,
0.15799587965011597,
0.32375699281692505,
0.019133029505610466,
-0.28630530834198,
0.5171091556549072,
-0.17841596901416779,
-0.33035850524902344,
-0.022559992969036102,
-0.13362248241901398,
0.019275851547718048,
0.035523973405361176,
-0.012043564580380917,
-0.3445092439651489,
-0.06427396088838577,
0.12366010248661041,
-0.13515886664390564,
0.46715247631073,
0.6455183029174805,
-0.7702400088310242,
-0.10806146264076233,
-0.8304138779640198,
-0.21660888195037842,
-0.28749194741249084,
0.2629603445529938,
-0.29770559072494507,
-0.790895402431488,
0.6591547727584839,
0.21499541401863098,
0.16511228680610657,
0.5933336615562439,
-0.2276025265455246,
-0.29683998227119446,
0.6705480217933655,
0.6302438378334045,
0.2817462384700775,
0.2978954315185547,
-0.12191352248191833,
0.3785873353481293,
-1.1238384246826172,
-0.3001762926578522,
-0.8182066679000854,
-0.30194568634033203,
-0.8244585394859314,
-0.39352062344551086,
-0.11297500878572464,
0.10156619548797607,
0.05716698244214058,
0.5241486430168152,
-0.40332844853401184,
0.4411895275115967,
0.36912083625793457,
-0.3789794445037842,
0.3723304569721222,
0.09352272748947144,
0.09973445534706116,
-0.2642973065376282,
-0.44569987058639526,
-0.7289766669273376,
1.1347228288650513,
0.3074553608894348,
0.48661255836486816,
0.028139131143689156,
1.0135427713394165,
0.0634787455201149,
0.5434867739677429,
-0.5862632989883423,
0.48454079031944275,
-0.3309329152107239,
-0.5857198238372803,
-0.4243069887161255,
-0.29879581928253174,
-0.8196811676025391,
0.01386826578527689,
-0.44791051745414734,
-0.7639952301979065,
0.3237806260585785,
0.41601234674453735,
-0.6706494092941284,
0.42672833800315857,
-0.6285721063613892,
0.970414400100708,
-0.15475480258464813,
0.07786756753921509,
0.28794166445732117,
-0.6376209259033203,
-0.038136567920446396,
-0.3028859794139862,
0.03846575319766998,
-0.02330281212925911,
-0.16865110397338867,
0.9941649436950684,
-0.16942016780376434,
0.6597910523414612,
-0.22568735480308533,
0.05333981290459633,
0.20474271476268768,
-0.43907150626182556,
0.5494235754013062,
0.017378132790327072,
-0.04342762380838394,
0.20710806548595428,
-0.15146534144878387,
-0.13168595731258392,
-0.6084197759628296,
0.46597808599472046,
-0.49086910486221313,
-0.3021150827407837,
-0.6677868366241455,
-0.22227835655212402,
0.14799709618091583,
0.10509215295314789,
0.3397761583328247,
0.49465760588645935,
-0.20870321989059448,
0.2324056476354599,
0.6770580410957336,
-0.052827008068561554,
0.6566086411476135,
0.39772388339042664,
-0.3572618365287781,
-0.4856451153755188,
0.6586647033691406,
0.5989006757736206,
-0.050102196633815765,
0.47882339358329773,
-0.11915292590856552,
-0.3724493980407715,
-0.6464694142341614,
-0.5581661462783813,
0.33992642164230347,
-0.7305038571357727,
-0.23000727593898773,
-0.9608427286148071,
0.04583055526018143,
-0.40650564432144165,
0.11338340491056442,
-0.25058668851852417,
-0.6713032722473145,
-0.32546478509902954,
-0.22957780957221985,
0.755204439163208,
0.6467332243919373,
-0.15903981029987335,
0.3366434574127197,
-0.8324581384658813,
-0.1944577395915985,
-0.18183618783950806,
0.14116497337818146,
-0.2462560087442398,
-0.6198503375053406,
-0.2372896820306778,
-0.30086880922317505,
0.08834386616945267,
-0.9304602742195129,
0.038241226226091385,
0.21708878874778748,
0.2681860029697418,
0.3147737979888916,
-0.1444409042596817,
0.6791675686836243,
-0.4129304885864258,
0.4712257385253906,
-0.03818517550826073,
-0.9727753400802612,
0.4844881594181061,
0.049250807613134384,
-0.0993690937757492,
0.6885844469070435,
0.38589805364608765,
-0.7708004713058472,
-0.0946054756641388,
-0.9575924873352051,
-0.9348222017288208,
0.6352890133857727,
0.016346817836165428,
-0.005689811892807484,
-0.16000890731811523,
0.5043192505836487,
-0.19026918709278107,
0.1429312378168106,
-0.8224527835845947,
-0.30726534128189087,
0.20958870649337769,
-0.06369347870349884,
-0.08124764263629913,
-0.21602694690227509,
0.2663418650627136,
0.027048911899328232,
0.893147885799408,
-0.13130119442939758,
-0.031968433409929276,
0.645203173160553,
-0.24247609078884125,
-0.026907332241535187,
0.16529639065265656,
0.5840098857879639,
0.48611196875572205,
-0.21818514168262482,
0.22935445606708527,
0.5032650232315063,
-0.6011672019958496,
-0.04646389186382294,
0.44469043612480164,
-0.5593991875648499,
0.40936964750289917,
0.4187574088573456,
0.8538715243339539,
0.3873351216316223,
-0.5313088893890381,
0.31542032957077026,
-0.09950969368219376,
0.22233973443508148,
-0.8302988409996033,
-0.15448006987571716,
0.0697731077671051,
0.00342090567573905,
0.21910174190998077,
0.25424057245254517,
0.15480893850326538,
-0.1214834451675415,
0.18073034286499023,
-0.061868876218795776,
-0.5110529661178589,
-0.434661865234375,
0.4420216381549835,
0.26480838656425476,
-0.3516077399253845,
0.5932468175888062,
-0.6673204898834229,
-0.4694923758506775,
0.6219695210456848,
0.43957817554473877,
0.8403688669204712,
-0.39110901951789856,
0.14859017729759216,
0.5117297768592834,
0.6222885251045227,
-0.30396318435668945,
0.3200053870677948,
0.3165091574192047,
-0.8655264973640442,
-0.6079979538917542,
-0.44620198011398315,
-0.6026545166969299,
0.12304958701133728,
-0.44971784949302673,
0.6175541281700134,
-0.5771734118461609,
-0.3280866742134094,
0.7017565965652466,
0.026778120547533035,
-0.42582494020462036,
0.4563320279121399,
0.2249605804681778,
0.7845447659492493,
-0.9434539079666138,
0.5916274189949036,
1.2959848642349243,
-0.7006750702857971,
-1.0985466241836548,
0.025731340050697327,
0.010816534049808979,
0.023577094078063965,
0.9753624796867371,
0.4305724799633026,
0.2737112045288086,
0.12613287568092346,
-0.166986346244812,
-0.9966095685958862,
0.8791772127151489,
0.0074926079250872135,
-0.6536663174629211,
-0.04594593122601509,
-0.14750586450099945,
0.5642468929290771,
-0.3969767689704895,
0.7488059997558594,
0.4357253909111023,
0.8222979307174683,
-0.3077523410320282,
-1.0076805353164673,
0.09896182268857956,
-0.08538861572742462,
-0.05262068659067154,
0.5532381534576416,
-0.3554964065551758,
1.0001790523529053,
-0.43664830923080444,
-0.12022791057825089,
0.008625471964478493,
0.5635482668876648,
0.12950605154037476,
0.5961146354675293,
0.6318129301071167,
0.7410697937011719,
1.092494010925293,
-0.4352613687515259,
0.9302448630332947,
0.13038671016693115,
0.35531407594680786,
1.2968653440475464,
-0.541000485420227,
0.9076870083808899,
0.6485148668289185,
0.035593658685684204,
0.40414854884147644,
0.492179811000824,
-0.4316508173942566,
-0.03237537667155266,
0.4823462963104248,
-0.07718794047832489,
0.03282865136861801,
-0.10538384318351746,
-0.17401698231697083,
0.4684602618217468,
0.2604414224624634,
-0.42828550934791565,
-0.14107970893383026,
0.039165254682302475,
0.3834613561630249,
-0.07855582237243652,
-0.1860877424478531,
0.6902552247047424,
0.11970382928848267,
-0.4136604964733124,
0.15487918257713318,
0.13687218725681305,
0.6871262788772583,
-0.11997336149215698,
-0.32026320695877075,
-0.22418569028377533,
0.3448096811771393,
-0.4966951310634613,
-0.3043070137500763,
0.4429445266723633,
0.1960175335407257,
-0.22485767304897308,
0.04227087274193764,
0.8878856897354126,
-0.31296777725219727,
-0.34496766328811646,
0.41184189915657043,
0.2763936221599579,
0.5485321879386902,
-0.17395266890525818,
-0.27830246090888977,
-0.10211870074272156,
0.042951397597789764,
-0.10301290452480316,
-0.023727143183350563,
0.5430626273155212,
-0.3955417573451996,
0.21567639708518982,
0.4566648304462433,
0.059906888753175735,
0.10130210965871811,
0.031727492809295654,
0.28218570351600647,
-0.8683704733848572,
-0.17133338749408722,
-0.6877818703651428,
0.5801355838775635,
-0.5108678340911865,
-0.6607128977775574,
1.0025368928909302,
0.6150178909301758,
1.2403604984283447,
-0.047562241554260254,
0.7207071185112,
-0.14055152237415314,
0.8087340593338013,
-0.49563461542129517,
0.4618600308895111,
-0.28147217631340027,
0.4069385528564453,
-0.43695002794265747,
-0.9744511246681213,
-0.7631254196166992,
0.9397664666175842,
-0.42195427417755127,
0.03434133529663086,
1.0183883905410767,
0.704323947429657,
0.11006172001361847,
0.3148818910121918,
0.16302219033241272,
0.3863598704338074,
0.04412652552127838,
0.18896016478538513,
0.9184775948524475,
-0.9718936681747437,
0.3474663197994232,
-0.33338481187820435,
0.21121282875537872,
-0.36696577072143555,
-1.0156464576721191,
-0.6684393882751465,
-0.3781302273273468,
-0.9578884840011597,
-0.40183621644973755,
0.18392175436019897,
1.0451151132583618,
0.2967623472213745,
-1.0918660163879395,
0.10307487100362778,
-0.04650013893842697,
0.0961422249674797,
-0.09674010425806046,
-0.14594897627830505,
0.41773882508277893,
-0.4166363477706909,
-0.7595709562301636,
0.2167164385318756,
0.17890602350234985,
0.08942151814699173,
0.04440208151936531,
0.13082268834114075,
-0.33307379484176636,
-0.08149676024913788,
0.326864629983902,
0.28942734003067017,
-0.7551011443138123,
-0.7153703570365906,
0.15323638916015625,
-0.027538005262613297,
0.08725044131278992,
0.6201923489570618,
-0.42832985520362854,
0.280222088098526,
0.5083038806915283,
0.6428526043891907,
0.23311664164066315,
-0.17563439905643463,
0.11505182832479477,
-0.5586540102958679,
-0.2538505494594574,
0.2113485187292099,
0.5971449017524719,
0.8225650787353516,
-0.1847231537103653,
0.7834710478782654,
0.31081369519233704,
-0.5996032357215881,
-1.0132551193237305,
-0.29564207792282104,
-0.9175892472267151,
0.31372684240341187,
0.8736761212348938,
-0.5939127802848816,
-0.30587419867515564,
-0.3577592670917511,
-0.1746070832014084,
0.2238241583108902,
-0.18360957503318787,
0.5980548858642578,
0.745788037776947,
-0.11996155977249146,
-0.012611557729542255,
-0.6541337370872498,
0.6462953686714172,
0.584836483001709,
-0.8721432685852051,
-0.16686047613620758,
0.608922004699707,
0.4102104604244232,
0.8735723495483398,
0.5991222262382507,
-0.05094363912940025,
0.4326414465904236,
0.04715438932180405,
0.6564813256263733,
0.08271336555480957,
-0.4596788287162781,
-0.579484760761261,
-0.13049449026584625,
0.17452196776866913,
-0.1524951010942459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00114v1 | OmniJARVIS: Unified Vision-Language-Action Tokenization Enables Open-World Instruction Following Agents | 2024-06-27T13:46:11 | 2024-06-27T13:46:11 | Zihao Wang, Shaofei Cai, Zhancun Mu, Haowei Lin, Ceyao Zhang, Xuejie Liu, Qing Li, Anji Liu, Xiaojian Ma, Yitao Liang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present OmniJARVIS, a novel Vision-Language-Action (VLA) model for
open-world instruction-following agents in open-world Minecraft. Compared to
prior works that either emit textual goals to separate controllers or produce
the control command directly, OmniJARVIS seeks a different path to ensure both
strong reasoning and efficient decision-making capabilities via unified
tokenization of multimodal interaction data. First, we introduce a
self-supervised approach to learn a behavior encoder that produces discretized
tokens for behavior trajectories $\tau$ = {$o_0$, $a_0$, $\dots$} and an
imitation learning (IL) policy decoder conditioned on these tokens. These
additional behavior tokens will be augmented to the vocabulary of pretrained
Multimodal Language Models (MLMs). With this encoder, we then pack long-term
multimodal interactions involving task instructions, memories, thoughts,
observations, textual responses, behavior trajectories, etc. into unified token
sequences and model them with autoregressive transformers. Thanks to the
semantically meaningful behavior tokens, the resulting VLA model, OmniJARVIS,
can reason (by producing chain-of-thoughts), plan, answer questions, and act
(by producing behavior tokens for the IL policy decoder). OmniJARVIS
demonstrates excellent performances on a comprehensive collection of atomic,
programmatic, and open-ended tasks in open-world Minecraft. Our analysis
further unveils the crucial design principles in interaction data formation,
unified tokenization, and its scaling potentials. | [
-0.1771906167268753,
-0.9433050155639648,
0.3789762854576111,
0.23272605240345,
0.12964583933353424,
-0.15046271681785583,
-0.2851341664791107,
-0.1633264273405075,
0.30661189556121826,
0.7673087120056152,
-0.3662256896495819,
-0.6001519560813904,
-0.10503929108381271,
-0.28899040818214417,
0.008635840378701687,
0.8538209795951843,
-0.1779348999261856,
-0.2407466620206833,
-0.4355681538581848,
-0.17841529846191406,
-0.34059301018714905,
-0.5748206973075867,
-0.3750821053981781,
0.050912484526634216,
0.639187216758728,
0.2977749705314636,
0.5062887668609619,
0.6361501216888428,
0.308648943901062,
0.3879927694797516,
0.07449844479560852,
0.5269206762313843,
-0.39545610547065735,
0.2995869815349579,
-0.3890473544597626,
-0.18791775405406952,
-0.4302171468734741,
0.06211148202419281,
0.5159105062484741,
0.5157967805862427,
-0.09250648319721222,
0.33941027522087097,
0.06600980460643768,
0.19658604264259338,
-0.7825478315353394,
0.5678471922874451,
-0.03641856089234352,
0.24243313074111938,
0.10181578248739243,
-0.01656407304108143,
-0.48902037739753723,
-0.08177533000707626,
-0.056342367082834244,
-0.5273728370666504,
-0.30751779675483704,
0.33628159761428833,
0.20457865297794342,
0.21565784513950348,
-0.3997842073440552,
-0.2422754466533661,
-0.7610642313957214,
0.7123708724975586,
-0.27008935809135437,
0.39463716745376587,
0.11951512098312378,
0.14982257783412933,
-0.4222702383995056,
-0.9175232648849487,
-0.742317795753479,
-0.14484958350658417,
-0.0037666810676455498,
0.15468987822532654,
-0.10037042945623398,
0.23704402148723602,
0.11661793291568756,
0.06464409083127975,
-0.3871675133705139,
-0.15643230080604553,
-0.5822721123695374,
-0.23308011889457703,
0.22084833681583405,
0.37236255407333374,
0.24307246506214142,
-0.269635945558548,
-0.6502235531806946,
-0.27840912342071533,
-0.3632151186466217,
0.5912578105926514,
0.23877565562725067,
0.4340280294418335,
0.094650499522686,
0.9975128173828125,
-0.26355358958244324,
0.8006809949874878,
-0.16433486342430115,
0.009584764949977398,
0.16176150739192963,
-0.3484047055244446,
-0.6263136863708496,
0.10024049878120422,
0.8116253614425659,
0.14824901521205902,
-0.013552894815802574,
-0.16858096420764923,
0.059282336384058,
0.015324373729526997,
0.494448721408844,
-0.7289203405380249,
-0.13814270496368408,
0.16897441446781158,
-0.6331354975700378,
-0.433759480714798,
0.2361147105693817,
-0.863972544670105,
-0.31257137656211853,
-0.3720747232437134,
0.5356652140617371,
-0.28011345863342285,
-0.5669128894805908,
0.14039282500743866,
0.11026926338672638,
0.3591833710670471,
0.22341667115688324,
-0.6965317130088806,
0.3579499125480652,
0.7337395548820496,
0.7150138020515442,
-0.4101096987724304,
-0.6056632399559021,
-0.9223648905754089,
0.19833986461162567,
-0.4116872251033783,
0.4167199730873108,
-0.9826924800872803,
-0.43765005469322205,
-0.001761182094924152,
-0.08471072465181351,
-0.20438867807388306,
-0.08028529584407806,
0.12136970460414886,
-0.2039358913898468,
0.22120033204555511,
0.05965576320886612,
-0.28628864884376526,
-0.2846379578113556,
0.5070690512657166,
-0.4557556211948395,
0.8528645634651184,
-0.11200571805238724,
-0.38771089911460876,
0.23291905224323273,
-1.307788372039795,
-0.23832502961158752,
-0.20412710309028625,
-0.20676757395267487,
0.1519501507282257,
0.19936779141426086,
0.12442468851804733,
0.4692062437534332,
0.0571160651743412,
0.004671708680689335,
-0.21218903362751007,
-0.18566769361495972,
0.16910110414028168,
-0.5173289179801941,
0.7359422445297241,
0.1270647644996643,
-0.22886508703231812,
0.462494820356369,
-0.6425377130508423,
0.34253737330436707,
0.04666293039917946,
-0.3608647584915161,
-0.4306274354457855,
0.07539382576942444,
-0.23539166152477264,
0.25487151741981506,
0.13678985834121704,
-0.7939081788063049,
0.3937808871269226,
-0.20841723680496216,
0.1555410772562027,
0.9117943644523621,
-0.06798417866230011,
0.5075277090072632,
0.10753127932548523,
0.5097431540489197,
0.16506344079971313,
0.5989323854446411,
-0.5724005699157715,
-0.5077041983604431,
-0.7818670272827148,
-0.2668650448322296,
0.10937038064002991,
0.32172513008117676,
-0.8335251808166504,
-0.046871788799762726,
-0.053585782647132874,
-0.1687750667333603,
-0.5545423030853271,
0.09173499047756195,
0.7161206007003784,
0.48762503266334534,
0.35803794860839844,
-0.3178083300590515,
-0.5589156746864319,
-0.3018764853477478,
-0.21526412665843964,
-0.31685778498649597,
0.3636118173599243,
0.2195151001214981,
0.6097109317779541,
-0.2364380657672882,
1.0692715644836426,
-0.32845479249954224,
-0.4034733176231384,
-0.2036522924900055,
0.08888322860002518,
0.022809267044067383,
0.6926915645599365,
0.36688902974128723,
-0.875399112701416,
-0.3680994212627411,
0.20663318037986755,
-0.9642574787139893,
0.3332281708717346,
0.11856035888195038,
-0.474417507648468,
0.47725579142570496,
0.9357008934020996,
-0.4953136146068573,
0.8768487572669983,
0.5592223405838013,
-0.6324218511581421,
0.4628957509994507,
-0.3231509029865265,
0.1230175644159317,
-0.9858524799346924,
0.010531076230108738,
-0.36936116218566895,
-0.21591296792030334,
-0.6275468468666077,
0.39346617460250854,
-0.14961831271648407,
-0.07330165058374405,
-0.7744578123092651,
0.6800304651260376,
-0.3839496672153473,
-0.13856232166290283,
0.010816710069775581,
-0.08100665360689163,
-0.1899670511484146,
1.051092505455017,
0.06279829889535904,
0.7299345135688782,
0.6643803715705872,
-0.6382124423980713,
0.6160162687301636,
0.3545707166194916,
-0.14468006789684296,
0.7768220901489258,
-0.6666079759597778,
0.04040393605828285,
-0.27902042865753174,
-0.00027525954646989703,
-0.6788949966430664,
-0.14911817014217377,
0.5407759547233582,
-0.4282474219799042,
0.03735891357064247,
-0.39038950204849243,
-0.5269367098808289,
-0.4589395225048065,
-0.0788956955075264,
0.1884864866733551,
0.47811588644981384,
-0.8453314900398254,
1.285338282585144,
0.24585066735744476,
0.2656887173652649,
-0.5979292988777161,
-0.6477291584014893,
-0.011083049699664116,
0.2061695158481598,
-0.29566600918769836,
-0.13299737870693207,
-0.3473498821258545,
-0.29927170276641846,
0.1679348349571228,
-0.21961477398872375,
0.12751737236976624,
-0.17843466997146606,
0.7407974004745483,
0.30139341950416565,
-0.3138081729412079,
0.19522547721862793,
-0.05539606884121895,
0.03039679303765297,
0.22692283987998962,
-0.7080573439598083,
0.48111945390701294,
-0.3737877607345581,
-0.7820420861244202,
-0.03982849046587944,
0.15180686116218567,
0.6291024088859558,
-0.5930547118186951,
0.7758292555809021,
0.5269876718521118,
-0.057631153613328934,
-0.1310938000679016,
-0.2607485055923462,
0.18817320466041565,
-0.5055286884307861,
0.1565910130739212,
-0.4887727200984955,
-0.677023708820343,
0.1645752191543579,
-0.19379444420337677,
0.47838202118873596,
0.2356683313846588,
0.4226142168045044,
-0.257858544588089,
1.3046621084213257,
0.7177960872650146,
0.19649560749530792,
0.560863196849823,
-0.34151020646095276,
-0.008104064501821995,
-0.9245930314064026,
-0.7579383254051208,
-0.02254822850227356,
-0.3061355650424957,
-0.3734641671180725,
-0.7042087316513062,
0.3363470733165741,
-0.1704745590686798,
-0.37368541955947876,
0.011632627807557583,
-0.44480979442596436,
0.9203857183456421,
0.7882899045944214,
0.0005748563562519848,
-0.043969105929136276,
0.19441884756088257,
-0.6179659366607666,
0.20914199948310852,
-0.6290373206138611,
-0.32377228140830994,
1.144026517868042,
-0.04181089252233505,
0.8859363794326782,
0.3237873613834381,
0.7888363599777222,
0.3588760495185852,
0.1467801034450531,
-0.45717862248420715,
0.6230853796005249,
0.1417875736951828,
-0.31462669372558594,
-0.38204333186149597,
-0.3000674247741699,
-1.0547035932540894,
0.6075537800788879,
-0.21823301911354065,
-0.8406181931495667,
0.0887751579284668,
0.24987681210041046,
-0.261074960231781,
0.5663647651672363,
-0.7795442938804626,
1.1742560863494873,
-0.25389042496681213,
-0.45583412051200867,
-0.022199535742402077,
-0.5117857456207275,
0.3204735517501831,
0.47187140583992004,
0.01723247952759266,
0.2105025202035904,
-0.11926248669624329,
0.34719595313072205,
-0.36235350370407104,
1.0956323146820068,
-0.34676724672317505,
0.1514682173728943,
0.5248435139656067,
0.3179377317428589,
0.4445939064025879,
-0.17919932305812836,
0.30219176411628723,
-0.18921838700771332,
-0.1536809355020523,
-0.4164941906929016,
-0.5903969407081604,
0.9124634861946106,
-0.6614723801612854,
-0.43725764751434326,
-0.5334390997886658,
-0.2900640368461609,
-0.11315809190273285,
0.34308958053588867,
-0.38893017172813416,
0.840602695941925,
-0.6046001315116882,
0.22256885468959808,
0.8294637799263,
-0.13520081341266632,
0.6239081621170044,
0.5802435874938965,
-0.8345010280609131,
-0.2799328565597534,
1.289011836051941,
-0.262812077999115,
0.24794434010982513,
0.15228350460529327,
0.11884932219982147,
-0.16574519872665405,
-0.15146003663539886,
-0.552011251449585,
-0.0387260876595974,
-0.7891550064086914,
-0.08470045775175095,
-0.8252138495445251,
-0.13917101919651031,
-0.314554899930954,
0.022240137681365013,
-0.35557544231414795,
-0.1691276878118515,
-0.37215885519981384,
-0.02674192376434803,
0.2937200963497162,
0.9442363977432251,
-0.16314120590686798,
0.033575814217329025,
-0.541481077671051,
0.32057273387908936,
0.6418106555938721,
0.5836141109466553,
0.06104190647602081,
-0.18339885771274567,
-0.06914755702018738,
0.3038261830806732,
-0.12241467088460922,
-0.3862910270690918,
0.23828120529651642,
0.10183122754096985,
0.7301119565963745,
0.3220648765563965,
0.069706991314888,
0.8021135330200195,
-0.4804246723651886,
0.8046932816505432,
0.27784857153892517,
-0.7661452293395996,
0.49946847558021545,
-0.015612856484949589,
0.39936956763267517,
0.19211673736572266,
0.10140588879585266,
-0.6208140254020691,
-0.2305334508419037,
-0.47473669052124023,
-0.4997035562992096,
0.9867933392524719,
0.31876376271247864,
0.29193148016929626,
-0.2931968867778778,
0.016449157148599625,
0.010603565722703934,
0.322886198759079,
-0.49008336663246155,
-0.30417129397392273,
-0.5943194627761841,
-0.2568868100643158,
-0.03175543248653412,
-0.10247644037008286,
-0.09353405982255936,
-0.24560034275054932,
0.32149362564086914,
-0.42874598503112793,
0.3982532024383545,
0.20351114869117737,
-0.4348823130130768,
0.1168479397892952,
-0.04910268634557724,
0.7484425902366638,
0.36383920907974243,
-0.03934076800942421,
0.22342108190059662,
-0.04950162023305893,
-0.4870496392250061,
-0.13437148928642273,
-0.23217624425888062,
0.14335371553897858,
-0.21792607009410858,
0.06917913258075714,
0.9448658227920532,
0.16875378787517548,
-0.8392249941825867,
0.6846240758895874,
-0.23261266946792603,
-0.11146311461925507,
-0.40418142080307007,
0.2879283130168915,
-0.18687820434570312,
0.6431995034217834,
0.03475678339600563,
0.4043795168399811,
-0.061695024371147156,
-0.7746614813804626,
-0.169233500957489,
0.2954590320587158,
-0.6665841937065125,
-0.4288541078567505,
0.7742975950241089,
0.3075820207595825,
-0.28172847628593445,
0.500798225402832,
-0.1367931365966797,
-0.32077696919441223,
0.6485030651092529,
0.5223053097724915,
0.8289386034011841,
-0.1887427717447281,
0.4338744580745697,
0.09159042686223984,
0.34858810901641846,
-0.00010732412192737684,
0.5890458226203918,
-0.39398956298828125,
-0.41868412494659424,
-0.4435136616230011,
-0.6028187274932861,
-0.4624437689781189,
-0.4338471293449402,
-0.655983030796051,
-0.1958989053964615,
-0.5807815194129944,
0.18032364547252655,
-0.20653489232063293,
-0.600364089012146,
-0.9347427487373352,
-0.05290447175502777,
0.0819019302725792,
0.8052233457565308,
-0.3695298433303833,
0.7385926842689514,
0.7955965399742126,
-0.7433154582977295,
-0.3789704144001007,
-0.1639450639486313,
0.05724131688475609,
-0.8638392686843872,
0.7823002934455872,
0.13866771757602692,
-0.19779570400714874,
-0.013974271714687347,
-0.7760569453239441,
-0.934834361076355,
0.9197396039962769,
0.023791715502738953,
-0.11034667491912842,
-0.06266963481903076,
-0.008314179256558418,
0.45280978083610535,
-0.5999199151992798,
0.17499136924743652,
0.4036771059036255,
0.4314064383506775,
0.18142691254615784,
-0.6805883646011353,
-0.251691997051239,
-0.26058366894721985,
0.005174562800675631,
0.4686940610408783,
-0.5877883434295654,
0.7421814203262329,
-0.4084099531173706,
0.03805770352482796,
0.0779733657836914,
0.9037339687347412,
-0.191475510597229,
0.1998557448387146,
0.4332909882068634,
0.4005812704563141,
0.43522533774375916,
0.07297024130821228,
1.0787346363067627,
-0.03507782146334648,
-0.07703810930252075,
1.1260945796966553,
-0.171263188123703,
0.9293174147605896,
0.5625256299972534,
0.10535426437854767,
0.7450452446937561,
-0.028424961492419243,
0.23098233342170715,
0.581260621547699,
-0.07587967813014984,
-0.14440229535102844,
-0.19129566848278046,
-0.17310188710689545,
0.06245831027626991,
0.6976181268692017,
0.47167104482650757,
-0.3086519241333008,
-0.07113555073738098,
0.6356783509254456,
-0.08685778826475143,
0.04762476310133934,
-0.7227135300636292,
1.0177985429763794,
-0.4304102659225464,
-0.7726952433586121,
0.3027690649032593,
-0.15006040036678314,
0.5007070899009705,
-0.5887698531150818,
-0.2806452512741089,
-0.11857433617115021,
0.23513562977313995,
0.06938067823648453,
-0.769527018070221,
0.1952158659696579,
0.012973085977137089,
-0.05618368089199066,
-0.4029208719730377,
0.5069471001625061,
-0.6599169969558716,
-0.35585758090019226,
-0.023834779858589172,
0.4034806191921234,
0.2201308310031891,
-0.030126696452498436,
-0.4219526946544647,
0.12532779574394226,
-0.0013929445995017886,
-0.3459204137325287,
0.4333028197288513,
0.4254258871078491,
-0.165450781583786,
0.6317792534828186,
0.7721218466758728,
-0.14561893045902252,
0.30672597885131836,
-0.23008061945438385,
0.9808610081672668,
-0.6043578386306763,
-0.44199615716934204,
-0.6194754838943481,
0.5956157445907593,
-0.22652308642864227,
-0.262079119682312,
0.7716905474662781,
0.31131353974342346,
0.9591900110244751,
0.0010736677795648575,
0.6840485334396362,
-0.3011878728866577,
0.18056632578372955,
-0.5338913202285767,
0.39461687207221985,
-0.47651299834251404,
-0.33410927653312683,
-0.028911735862493515,
-0.9153719544410706,
-0.15258142352104187,
0.5367070436477661,
0.015622396022081375,
-0.06237398087978363,
0.4880334734916687,
0.6276066899299622,
-0.38367030024528503,
-0.1750289499759674,
0.49963146448135376,
0.19968955218791962,
0.3331510126590729,
0.17091180384159088,
0.5811012983322144,
-0.05948140472173691,
1.0060421228408813,
-0.027107127010822296,
-0.11460275948047638,
-0.16051284968852997,
-0.6866573095321655,
-1.347361445426941,
-0.6100266575813293,
-0.022903650999069214,
-0.2716757357120514,
0.09642031043767929,
1.4449528455734253,
0.6145848631858826,
-0.66382896900177,
-0.11144464462995529,
-0.12482422590255737,
0.143004909157753,
-0.48730891942977905,
-0.18593566119670868,
0.2158687561750412,
-0.45570531487464905,
-0.7182914018630981,
0.5631849765777588,
0.5092189908027649,
0.16069556772708893,
-0.6980227828025818,
-0.4566665589809418,
-0.04100099578499794,
0.24232128262519836,
0.8930409550666809,
0.7454681396484375,
-1.0143707990646362,
-0.2499837726354599,
0.03260438144207001,
-0.09922564774751663,
-0.16968442499637604,
0.8301405906677246,
-1.0941706895828247,
1.1363705396652222,
0.3107116222381592,
0.48103752732276917,
0.4035934507846832,
-0.18506556749343872,
0.4741900861263275,
-0.8363243341445923,
0.25321057438850403,
0.08103571087121964,
0.2463604211807251,
-0.07446762919425964,
0.12788169085979462,
0.4930749237537384,
-0.018506595864892006,
-0.2168973982334137,
-0.8124349117279053,
0.16818492114543915,
-0.5562196373939514,
-0.2033267319202423,
1.0319055318832397,
-0.23000505566596985,
-0.7694164514541626,
-0.011998740956187248,
-0.6868912577629089,
-0.1646336317062378,
-0.4179226756095886,
0.4282725155353546,
0.28342872858047485,
-0.00118924246635288,
-0.22134509682655334,
-0.4234836995601654,
0.2896844148635864,
0.021530134603381157,
-0.7253666520118713,
0.031301822513341904,
0.6501169800758362,
-0.10415420681238174,
0.13299812376499176,
0.3481343686580658,
0.04064808785915375,
0.4651840925216675,
0.07412286847829819,
0.38091617822647095,
-0.7586816549301147,
-0.7213537693023682,
-0.05907692015171051,
0.11897686868906021,
-0.29294854402542114,
-0.6690170168876648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19170v1 | The Illusion of Competence: Evaluating the Effect of Explanations on Users' Mental Models of Visual Question Answering Systems | 2024-06-27T13:44:03 | 2024-06-27T13:44:03 | Judith Sieker, Simeon Junker, Ronja Utescher, Nazia Attari, Heiko Wersing, Hendrik Buschmeier, Sina Zarrieß | cs.CL | cs.CL | We examine how users perceive the limitations of an AI system when it
encounters a task that it cannot perform perfectly and whether providing
explanations alongside its answers aids users in constructing an appropriate
mental model of the system's capabilities and limitations. We employ a visual
question answer and explanation task where we control the AI system's
limitations by manipulating the visual inputs: during inference, the system
either processes full-color or grayscale images. Our goal is to determine
whether participants can perceive the limitations of the system. We hypothesize
that explanations will make limited AI capabilities more transparent to users.
However, our results show that explanations do not have this effect. Instead of
allowing users to more accurately assess the limitations of the AI system,
explanations generally increase users' perceptions of the system's competence -
regardless of its actual performance. | [
-0.6230389475822449,
-0.7769895792007446,
0.7709061503410339,
-0.016911787912249565,
-0.26922807097435,
-0.30280643701553345,
-0.06907961517572403,
-0.5629422068595886,
-0.09900392591953278,
0.4476688504219055,
-0.6511218547821045,
0.09300315380096436,
-0.4787977635860443,
0.17164461314678192,
-0.3622593581676483,
0.7726286053657532,
-0.07940496504306793,
0.09239710867404938,
-0.8617632389068604,
0.046413589268922806,
-1.0616942644119263,
0.0130411172285676,
-0.6623420715332031,
-0.09782081097364426,
0.18726617097854614,
0.7548334002494812,
1.0461233854293823,
0.6581240296363831,
0.5022114515304565,
0.4366273581981659,
0.3800677955150604,
-0.20967046916484833,
-0.4902678430080414,
-0.018526650965213776,
-0.22930924594402313,
-0.8063268661499023,
-0.14980271458625793,
-0.10977181047201157,
0.6424927711486816,
0.6592166423797607,
0.10887733101844788,
0.18015536665916443,
0.12056401371955872,
0.5344031453132629,
-0.7953576445579529,
0.06829043477773666,
-0.34374749660491943,
0.17692628502845764,
0.2624587416648865,
-0.32358598709106445,
-0.04694969207048416,
-0.006487495731562376,
0.3207172453403473,
-0.7989358305931091,
0.27803564071655273,
0.033615462481975555,
0.9031264185905457,
0.6254576444625854,
-0.385226845741272,
0.022194363176822662,
-1.141209363937378,
0.5393984317779541,
-0.15960989892482758,
0.2009332925081253,
0.45015132427215576,
0.7703894972801208,
0.38550782203674316,
-0.6717144846916199,
-0.9633384346961975,
-0.08223103731870651,
-0.1385728418827057,
0.472805380821228,
-0.32943448424339294,
0.5558494925498962,
0.5302881002426147,
0.3240715265274048,
-0.7327348589897156,
-0.06288173049688339,
-0.7122214436531067,
-0.27417272329330444,
0.6675294637680054,
0.24672402441501617,
0.4170418977737427,
-0.11269967257976532,
-0.48364371061325073,
0.11925000697374344,
-0.051084015518426895,
0.16005758941173553,
0.2372952103614807,
-0.48101961612701416,
-0.0259933490306139,
0.8065336346626282,
-0.09567339718341827,
0.9418508410453796,
-0.004527989309281111,
0.10743115097284317,
-0.22017109394073486,
-0.19587236642837524,
-0.5265697836875916,
-0.24544501304626465,
0.3836521506309509,
0.6998258829116821,
0.4578181803226471,
-0.03751903772354126,
-0.1365407109260559,
0.48327770829200745,
0.5808452367782593,
-0.31637492775917053,
0.11154612898826599,
0.301361083984375,
-0.47110509872436523,
-0.010567042045295238,
0.3802865743637085,
-0.9683933854103088,
-0.4063516855239868,
-0.32527339458465576,
0.7674758434295654,
-0.49077025055885315,
-0.17268019914627075,
0.16420583426952362,
-0.6065569519996643,
0.15688224136829376,
0.6175536513328552,
-0.6509304046630859,
0.37124648690223694,
0.2009996622800827,
0.4203443229198456,
-0.08873406797647476,
-0.26381897926330566,
-0.017606131732463837,
-0.1894068419933319,
-0.2934684455394745,
0.37545162439346313,
-0.3919166028499603,
-0.3110819160938263,
-0.11675155907869339,
0.09368529170751572,
-0.10082781314849854,
-0.49443280696868896,
0.13651326298713684,
-0.8436766266822815,
0.0012908184435218573,
-0.45260170102119446,
-0.323555588722229,
-0.44054436683654785,
0.13178619742393494,
-0.5930472612380981,
0.4272826611995697,
0.039401520043611526,
-0.48813921213150024,
0.5511376261711121,
-0.8124656081199646,
-0.03288529813289642,
0.14972920715808868,
-0.25937849283218384,
0.17336991429328918,
0.23076827824115753,
0.1804695874452591,
0.0694490447640419,
0.03961872309446335,
-0.29713839292526245,
-0.09935510158538818,
-0.6180646419525146,
0.5199180245399475,
-0.6179017424583435,
0.9779560565948486,
0.5098029375076294,
-0.3244836628437042,
-0.09198140352964401,
-0.3211413323879242,
-0.14558999240398407,
0.31623855233192444,
-0.03548608347773552,
-0.1138637587428093,
-0.1180848777294159,
-0.5842472910881042,
-0.09705159813165665,
0.6970358490943909,
-0.4151705205440521,
-0.19154073297977448,
-0.30117714405059814,
0.13541436195373535,
0.7875256538391113,
0.13405439257621765,
0.5896918177604675,
-0.394103467464447,
1.124856948852539,
0.09128377586603165,
0.3968496024608612,
-0.2495298534631729,
-0.6321380138397217,
-0.690163791179657,
-0.14834976196289062,
0.09031758457422256,
0.8995919823646545,
-0.9825988411903381,
-0.1055276170372963,
-0.14366701245307922,
-0.11066734045743942,
-0.44553688168525696,
0.07226887345314026,
0.4437228739261627,
0.7667718529701233,
0.11759519577026367,
-0.48180660605430603,
-0.21776315569877625,
-1.1499031782150269,
-0.2165394276380539,
-0.5363266468048096,
-0.18780434131622314,
0.6877122521400452,
0.6854685544967651,
0.2012796550989151,
0.9471854567527771,
-0.34677648544311523,
-0.023942764848470688,
0.029273714870214462,
-0.06045551970601082,
-0.1385934054851532,
0.43626290559768677,
0.4833809733390808,
-1.1767449378967285,
-0.12648259103298187,
-0.11857070028781891,
-1.0600254535675049,
0.11950742453336716,
-0.43378332257270813,
0.11521222442388535,
0.08949604630470276,
0.4827984869480133,
-0.42588648200035095,
0.9393705129623413,
0.207560196518898,
-0.39919304847717285,
0.8122165203094482,
-0.5332902073860168,
0.5058344006538391,
-0.24684233963489532,
-0.04352670907974243,
0.1595521718263626,
-0.18540512025356293,
-0.539012610912323,
0.28788697719573975,
-0.16837064921855927,
-0.38081133365631104,
-0.08301302790641785,
0.40917304158210754,
-0.3388958275318146,
-0.35496026277542114,
-0.10127643495798111,
0.41862285137176514,
0.18706145882606506,
0.4095166027545929,
-0.21612130105495453,
0.8282331824302673,
0.7954227328300476,
-0.5385475158691406,
0.48094871640205383,
0.08965509384870529,
-0.26556846499443054,
0.9453644156455994,
-0.6787555813789368,
-0.13470454514026642,
-0.5703489184379578,
-0.221120685338974,
-1.700517177581787,
-0.48666417598724365,
0.37033575773239136,
-0.8275557160377502,
0.09806614369153976,
-0.17015844583511353,
-0.07117407768964767,
-0.7573336958885193,
0.11538980156183243,
0.5161051154136658,
0.5556671619415283,
-0.3732815980911255,
0.5901614427566528,
-0.13694320619106293,
0.21692316234111786,
-0.9285101294517517,
-0.9278229475021362,
0.1623615324497223,
-0.4770296812057495,
-0.5766552090644836,
0.20919159054756165,
-0.1292412430047989,
-0.755810022354126,
0.22822986543178558,
-0.03210921213030815,
-0.40243393182754517,
0.40618348121643066,
0.3941868245601654,
0.4518898129463196,
-0.253418505191803,
0.3652395009994507,
0.18363520503044128,
0.19382993876934052,
0.34151491522789,
-0.17555950582027435,
-0.03156682103872299,
-0.36138400435447693,
-0.6486031413078308,
-1.0791584253311157,
0.12904959917068481,
0.8059434294700623,
-0.3743802309036255,
0.7698459029197693,
0.329363614320755,
-0.40362030267715454,
0.21758605539798737,
-0.6235678791999817,
-0.3293989598751068,
-0.4937129020690918,
0.39208969473838806,
-0.47195902466773987,
-0.4459116458892822,
0.6267979145050049,
0.3141739070415497,
-0.22598160803318024,
0.5443510413169861,
0.1988310068845749,
-0.3878529369831085,
1.430261492729187,
0.5641290545463562,
0.49406519532203674,
0.4649614095687866,
-0.3206636309623718,
-0.21899311244487762,
-0.5778678059577942,
-0.33252498507499695,
-0.3777066171169281,
-0.474907785654068,
-0.3619316518306732,
-0.26984861493110657,
0.5425217151641846,
0.33769580721855164,
-0.3535129427909851,
-0.08069466799497604,
-0.707245945930481,
0.4952242970466614,
0.6388031244277954,
0.5740734934806824,
0.30968591570854187,
0.06348618865013123,
0.02950061671435833,
-0.31413209438323975,
-0.8784652948379517,
-0.3987909257411957,
0.9494038820266724,
0.3676001727581024,
0.6091845035552979,
0.022735588252544403,
0.2903563976287842,
0.4855806529521942,
0.3621976375579834,
-0.7773789167404175,
0.5251816511154175,
0.170286625623703,
-1.0052454471588135,
-0.787306547164917,
-0.14841069281101227,
-0.7095015645027161,
-0.06993488222360611,
-0.48265591263771057,
-0.8461548686027527,
0.37270650267601013,
0.4801495373249054,
-0.4394244849681854,
0.30573147535324097,
-0.9483640789985657,
0.792811930179596,
-0.4755128026008606,
-0.515299916267395,
-0.45843592286109924,
-0.5954188704490662,
0.5072617530822754,
0.09778288751840591,
0.094560906291008,
0.5120203495025635,
-0.33188822865486145,
0.7354191541671753,
-0.3788297474384308,
0.9275813698768616,
-0.6328876614570618,
0.2889481484889984,
0.47864553332328796,
0.15488821268081665,
0.09503152221441269,
0.11463386565446854,
-0.23752754926681519,
0.05730941519141197,
-0.018953850492835045,
-0.5829557776451111,
-1.0393744707107544,
0.32564976811408997,
-0.5795386433601379,
-1.1125729084014893,
0.008341147564351559,
-0.5973476767539978,
-0.0987972617149353,
0.1363569051027298,
0.2981378436088562,
0.2352771908044815,
-0.09332957863807678,
-0.05134395882487297,
0.5187824964523315,
-0.4388371407985687,
-0.03492743894457817,
-0.04868888482451439,
-0.11795581877231598,
-0.13259293138980865,
0.7197700142860413,
0.1033194437623024,
0.3596840798854828,
-0.06799601763486862,
0.03521424159407616,
-0.31771764159202576,
-0.7710025310516357,
-0.7906066179275513,
0.25045594573020935,
-0.8871883749961853,
0.29222288727760315,
-0.14752179384231567,
0.07501301169395447,
-0.12049712240695953,
-0.24919813871383667,
0.24631883203983307,
-0.6698947548866272,
-0.602479100227356,
-0.013362618163228035,
0.1912440061569214,
0.7924573421478271,
-0.21263498067855835,
0.5471420288085938,
-0.1151873990893364,
0.4118507206439972,
0.8754121661186218,
0.41410285234451294,
0.27103036642074585,
-0.7424848079681396,
-0.3857094347476959,
0.3530668318271637,
-0.4382062554359436,
-1.2429159879684448,
-0.019935324788093567,
0.02994772233068943,
0.7055939435958862,
1.051405429840088,
-0.04921819642186165,
0.7517927289009094,
-0.202590212225914,
0.9868263006210327,
0.20244452357292175,
-0.8585736155509949,
0.6206069588661194,
-0.21605278551578522,
0.14686274528503418,
0.3920629024505615,
0.4811871349811554,
-0.20683883130550385,
-0.5288392305374146,
-0.7204786539077759,
-0.15765346586704254,
0.7264133095741272,
0.1546635776758194,
0.3350783586502075,
0.07780265808105469,
0.9003496170043945,
-0.21435649693012238,
0.08932051062583923,
-0.5539848804473877,
-0.47897225618362427,
-0.6303900480270386,
0.18715785443782806,
-0.0962974950671196,
-0.31174057722091675,
-0.4202200174331665,
-0.23795387148857117,
0.3009898066520691,
-0.10673639923334122,
0.6419307589530945,
0.6803529858589172,
-0.14955444633960724,
-0.38196349143981934,
0.05632315203547478,
0.8119544982910156,
1.2188777923583984,
0.18342331051826477,
0.0800940990447998,
0.5573093891143799,
-0.07962474226951599,
-0.2204434871673584,
0.017878448590636253,
0.1704830378293991,
-0.24760499596595764,
0.5593218803405762,
0.8528101444244385,
-0.47944775223731995,
-0.7017121911048889,
0.5375317931175232,
-0.1485767811536789,
-0.5683237314224243,
-0.2552129626274109,
0.4764176607131958,
-0.1017405092716217,
0.5907816886901855,
0.4365294873714447,
0.36238935589790344,
0.19960638880729675,
-0.5151299238204956,
-0.03847259283065796,
0.8669961094856262,
-0.635004460811615,
-0.08909738063812256,
1.2503048181533813,
-0.30349430441856384,
-0.6729070544242859,
0.6707948446273804,
0.3811390995979309,
-0.5083457231521606,
1.1752606630325317,
0.4199630320072174,
0.40558794140815735,
-0.1740449070930481,
0.3896734416484833,
0.2990558445453644,
0.6518879532814026,
0.2846452593803406,
0.389125794172287,
-0.29545858502388,
-0.9372018575668335,
-0.34265047311782837,
0.013427546247839928,
-0.37832537293434143,
0.10809309035539627,
-0.9009658098220825,
-0.1334565281867981,
-0.457834929227829,
-0.3253460228443146,
0.049376968294382095,
-0.4178207218647003,
-0.7429986596107483,
0.6700378060340881,
0.12689745426177979,
0.9637296795845032,
-0.874610185623169,
0.1950235515832901,
0.5738036632537842,
-0.6050906181335449,
-0.3769366443157196,
-0.004099630750715733,
-0.1556181162595749,
-1.1206533908843994,
0.7210240364074707,
-0.13901400566101074,
-0.011187282390892506,
-0.1265391856431961,
-0.842003345489502,
-0.33307963609695435,
0.968669593334198,
0.5871896743774414,
-0.021240761503577232,
-0.040949542075395584,
0.1549425721168518,
0.8857613205909729,
-0.221567764878273,
0.0893416777253151,
0.39082056283950806,
0.8568711876869202,
-0.190855473279953,
-0.9044786691665649,
-0.06743381172418594,
-0.052596475929021835,
0.015928974375128746,
-0.5066891312599182,
-0.3671729862689972,
0.5843592882156372,
-0.6697787642478943,
-0.1894301176071167,
0.22928760945796967,
0.6480928659439087,
-0.22331105172634125,
0.3330059349536896,
1.0071529150009155,
0.4336564540863037,
0.6080113053321838,
-0.06643712520599365,
1.3230640888214111,
-0.1369144469499588,
0.06289380043745041,
0.5556452870368958,
0.395581990480423,
0.2769278883934021,
0.6613234877586365,
-0.006334512960165739,
0.7714400887489319,
0.4229952096939087,
0.03560727834701538,
0.12127212435007095,
0.061338383704423904,
-0.1616511344909668,
-0.5650326609611511,
-0.11596556007862091,
-0.2301059514284134,
0.5798577666282654,
0.42401033639907837,
-0.5710278153419495,
0.07441159337759018,
0.3705044686794281,
-0.5583562850952148,
0.2647669315338135,
-0.35688725113868713,
0.5446653962135315,
-0.2801370918750763,
-1.017671823501587,
0.813943088054657,
-0.07720504701137543,
-0.09309732168912888,
-0.17428907752037048,
-0.17233988642692566,
-0.1832328736782074,
-0.030270766466856003,
-0.15607383847236633,
-0.9408886432647705,
0.2768711447715759,
-0.12855221331119537,
-0.11352457106113434,
-0.09697061777114868,
0.6560009121894836,
-0.10251718014478683,
-0.33090659976005554,
-0.09373287111520767,
0.5735909938812256,
0.3635256886482239,
0.014580224640667439,
-0.8677920699119568,
-0.3575366139411926,
-0.006090532056987286,
-0.0052847242914140224,
-0.2787545323371887,
0.4942566454410553,
-0.14387109875679016,
0.9353727698326111,
0.043519482016563416,
-0.01726524904370308,
-0.08695962280035019,
-0.5839325785636902,
0.558348536491394,
-0.0931224599480629,
-0.4417338967323303,
-0.7221277952194214,
0.6690732836723328,
-0.016258448362350464,
-0.09500101953744888,
0.6361758708953857,
0.26033031940460205,
0.7094336152076721,
-0.3376444876194,
0.8085309267044067,
-0.057339515537023544,
-0.019163629040122032,
-0.3691423833370209,
0.6972622871398926,
-1.3083884716033936,
0.3006051778793335,
-0.27520516514778137,
-0.5938888192176819,
-0.2809823751449585,
0.5935387015342712,
-0.5615718960762024,
0.19490723311901093,
0.6491142511367798,
0.8340516686439514,
-0.18437278270721436,
0.049087006598711014,
0.6309513449668884,
0.3815757632255554,
-0.30913931131362915,
0.3211657404899597,
0.9330188632011414,
-0.1313316524028778,
0.7186044454574585,
-0.34481024742126465,
-0.6283776760101318,
-0.15560777485370636,
-0.5734997391700745,
-0.7877028584480286,
-0.5552356243133545,
-0.07661569863557816,
-0.45642831921577454,
0.09062972664833069,
0.025681529194116592,
0.6903219819068909,
-0.5019883513450623,
-0.26956987380981445,
-0.1501350998878479,
0.39541929960250854,
-0.47645053267478943,
-0.30559200048446655,
0.12566375732421875,
-0.0241935383528471,
-0.6953573226928711,
-0.026164652779698372,
0.04858151823282242,
0.17951399087905884,
-0.5269889831542969,
-0.11895058304071426,
0.15533298254013062,
0.20666775107383728,
0.34520968794822693,
0.49349865317344666,
-0.778069257736206,
-0.5008777976036072,
0.18840710818767548,
0.3478156626224518,
0.23699642717838287,
0.523604691028595,
-0.7756378650665283,
1.127549648284912,
0.45001086592674255,
0.4098403751850128,
0.4499330222606659,
0.1629055142402649,
0.6025551557540894,
-0.22934779524803162,
-0.05506657436490059,
0.04433697834610939,
0.3198155462741852,
-0.0008626681519672275,
-0.6132351756095886,
0.24422240257263184,
0.25899362564086914,
-0.32089704275131226,
-0.5958021879196167,
0.24375545978546143,
-0.8039052486419678,
-0.454563707113266,
0.7304278612136841,
-0.20400503277778625,
-0.06972496211528778,
-0.3401587903499603,
-0.3800809681415558,
0.34540021419525146,
0.0010049635311588645,
0.9952599406242371,
0.7224231362342834,
-0.4369179308414459,
-0.3174448013305664,
-0.8423513770103455,
0.42891165614128113,
0.5668357014656067,
-0.6112787127494812,
-0.0984148159623146,
0.667823076248169,
0.19076958298683167,
0.2121681123971939,
0.4740590751171112,
-0.08943560719490051,
0.9253557324409485,
0.11385075747966766,
-0.294328898191452,
-0.2715074419975281,
-0.5415632128715515,
-0.6512394547462463,
0.2105499655008316,
0.17387183010578156,
-0.26685068011283875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00111v1 | Accurate Prediction of Ligand-Protein Interaction Affinities with Fine-Tuned Small Language Models | 2024-06-27T13:04:58 | 2024-06-27T13:04:58 | Ben Fauber | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We describe the accurate prediction of ligand-protein interaction (LPI)
affinities, also known as drug-target interactions (DTI), with instruction
fine-tuned pretrained generative small language models (SLMs). We achieved
accurate predictions for a range of affinity values associated with
ligand-protein interactions on out-of-sample data in a zero-shot setting. Only
the SMILES string of the ligand and the amino acid sequence of the protein were
used as the model inputs. Our results demonstrate a clear improvement over
machine learning (ML) and free-energy perturbation (FEP+) based methods in
accurately predicting a range of ligand-protein interaction affinities, which
can be leveraged to further accelerate drug discovery campaigns against
challenging therapeutic targets. | [
-0.2510436177253723,
-0.5151646137237549,
0.6953020691871643,
-0.3054306209087372,
-0.015152066014707088,
-0.16283054649829865,
-0.057646576315164566,
-0.3352396786212921,
0.23574329912662506,
0.05256522819399834,
-0.6977393627166748,
-0.48616650700569153,
-0.5991055965423584,
0.1630503088235855,
0.22581477463245392,
0.5367359519004822,
0.25039294362068176,
0.5245398283004761,
-0.268046110868454,
-0.1770586520433426,
-0.17214639484882355,
-0.15076051652431488,
-0.5378188490867615,
-0.6224997043609619,
0.8207421898841858,
0.3547555208206177,
0.41852807998657227,
0.7925207018852234,
0.7597963213920593,
0.143783837556839,
0.010917591862380505,
0.05281620845198631,
-0.5511778593063354,
-0.227016881108284,
-0.2990688383579254,
-0.4815373718738556,
-0.639375627040863,
0.3360852897167206,
0.3793916404247284,
0.9379944205284119,
-0.04846956580877304,
0.14776457846164703,
-0.2460324615240097,
0.6187064051628113,
-0.72198885679245,
-0.2015087753534317,
-0.7643552422523499,
0.2488975077867508,
-0.2827546000480652,
-0.39202550053596497,
-0.5521508455276489,
0.07447376102209091,
0.14439573884010315,
-0.5242124199867249,
0.19067716598510742,
0.039930686354637146,
0.9988307952880859,
0.4334888458251953,
-0.540661633014679,
-0.4282635748386383,
-0.4303061366081238,
0.8476783633232117,
-0.8313868045806885,
0.2733708918094635,
0.27339524030685425,
0.1186375841498375,
-0.7777484655380249,
-0.5417757630348206,
-0.2932305634021759,
-0.3069796562194824,
-0.22018460929393768,
-0.059345219284296036,
0.0753258615732193,
0.6265413761138916,
0.4219057261943817,
0.1825382113456726,
-0.6397295594215393,
0.2643762230873108,
-0.42924022674560547,
-0.02556736394762993,
0.5312314629554749,
0.36840108036994934,
0.4292970895767212,
-0.1148131787776947,
-0.24568548798561096,
0.43665024638175964,
-0.7882140874862671,
0.12089025229215622,
0.0544966422021389,
0.9156156778335571,
-0.02446574531495571,
0.8804354071617126,
0.16187816858291626,
1.0197657346725464,
0.5909297466278076,
0.14772345125675201,
-0.04264206066727638,
-0.4310499131679535,
-0.4342539608478546,
0.19612528383731842,
0.8544818758964539,
0.6518154740333557,
0.008189884014427662,
-0.18424361944198608,
0.2975713014602661,
-0.0010391927789896727,
0.05236615240573883,
-1.0241550207138062,
-0.3108743727207184,
0.70799320936203,
-0.4423370361328125,
-0.19481006264686584,
0.052007220685482025,
-0.8248875141143799,
-0.3989708125591278,
-0.26556918025016785,
0.6983445882797241,
-0.5849659442901611,
0.1291719675064087,
0.20477700233459473,
-0.08698213845491409,
0.4047119915485382,
0.013936552219092846,
-0.9018611907958984,
0.21205852925777435,
0.4810604751110077,
0.866706132888794,
-0.2809610664844513,
-0.2893966734409332,
-1.4612889289855957,
0.4341943562030792,
0.06991814821958542,
0.8012378811836243,
-0.7116913199424744,
-0.2839502692222595,
-0.1037975624203682,
-0.15281957387924194,
-0.4671408534049988,
-0.30070760846138,
0.5011653900146484,
-0.17123666405677795,
0.019564302638173103,
-0.19119048118591309,
-1.1025370359420776,
0.2927244007587433,
0.061659011989831924,
-0.6255279779434204,
0.3393830358982086,
0.013446745462715626,
-0.7403406500816345,
0.4729945957660675,
-0.7486236095428467,
-0.31808868050575256,
0.07419846206903458,
0.0322386659681797,
-0.2724113166332245,
0.38149693608283997,
-0.117068812251091,
0.24382901191711426,
0.07070434838533401,
0.05597968399524689,
-0.7673423886299133,
-0.4808332622051239,
0.24282599985599518,
0.37434208393096924,
0.5151255130767822,
0.3236018121242523,
-0.09927428513765335,
0.2667738199234009,
-1.0506792068481445,
0.43098726868629456,
-0.3496221601963043,
-0.1845739781856537,
-0.1836496740579605,
-0.2680160105228424,
-0.2997383773326874,
0.4582796096801758,
0.3164635896682739,
-0.6262580156326294,
0.3230092227458954,
-0.6735355854034424,
0.3443501591682434,
0.5104231834411621,
0.054003022611141205,
0.7509027719497681,
-0.03134601190686226,
0.33326455950737,
0.04540153592824936,
-0.0005496930098161101,
0.20699094235897064,
-0.490064412355423,
-0.544959306716919,
-0.16064880788326263,
0.7536224722862244,
0.3110673129558563,
-0.29347145557403564,
0.5210904479026794,
-0.22114181518554688,
-0.5811828374862671,
-0.5090762972831726,
0.09125204384326935,
0.419669508934021,
0.15238210558891296,
0.2095681130886078,
-0.194529190659523,
-0.6790160536766052,
-0.4285111725330353,
-0.45937755703926086,
-0.15844592452049255,
-0.22130049765110016,
0.4269728660583496,
0.5418329238891602,
-0.3254031836986542,
1.0247262716293335,
-0.4475671648979187,
-0.5100464820861816,
-0.2680698335170746,
0.16576716303825378,
0.3870607316493988,
0.5729840993881226,
0.45302140712738037,
-0.6072940826416016,
-0.8164561986923218,
-0.1603996455669403,
-0.4762704074382782,
0.006748107261955738,
-0.09185285866260529,
-0.1556515097618103,
-0.21575044095516205,
0.3502310812473297,
-0.7791432738304138,
0.4034082591533661,
0.32101961970329285,
-0.4937773644924164,
0.11938684433698654,
-0.37496107816696167,
-0.09005606919527054,
-0.7776725888252258,
0.26346060633659363,
0.46101370453834534,
0.11157068610191345,
-1.2765437364578247,
-0.25596949458122253,
-0.0319226011633873,
-0.07500436902046204,
-0.7642928957939148,
0.9087662100791931,
-0.3056279122829437,
0.06620682030916214,
-0.2895408272743225,
-0.06616667658090591,
0.044017333537340164,
0.2993330657482147,
0.26157325506210327,
0.7114243507385254,
0.34642860293388367,
-0.5600940585136414,
-0.08836973458528519,
0.3081701695919037,
0.1633758842945099,
0.4012894332408905,
-0.7479897141456604,
0.027750302106142044,
0.13168707489967346,
-0.00016548688290640712,
-0.6441060304641724,
-0.4175480902194977,
0.46965745091438293,
-0.6022313237190247,
0.38200852274894714,
-0.41012537479400635,
-0.09953366965055466,
-0.20688261091709137,
-0.6342546343803406,
0.2894456386566162,
0.049258772283792496,
-0.3499239981174469,
0.8317959308624268,
0.3394917845726013,
0.39664018154144287,
-0.5194775462150574,
-0.48825109004974365,
-0.14333277940750122,
-0.2039370983839035,
-0.1656416803598404,
0.2053455412387848,
-0.43861082196235657,
-0.11215915530920029,
-0.3140847384929657,
0.02752172201871872,
-0.20184415578842163,
-0.00307131907902658,
0.49956732988357544,
0.11529762297868729,
0.13726092875003815,
-0.06677070260047913,
-0.13304473459720612,
-0.2051381915807724,
-0.17337046563625336,
-0.11320991814136505,
0.5848981738090515,
-0.37860363721847534,
-0.06186816841363907,
-0.42233726382255554,
0.2939155697822571,
0.6273370385169983,
-0.17975346744060516,
0.9168714284896851,
0.5647372603416443,
-0.5339191555976868,
0.13797563314437866,
0.026712464168667793,
-0.23693595826625824,
-0.45695778727531433,
0.09465499222278595,
-0.7377309799194336,
-0.5378389954566956,
0.507522702217102,
-0.042955804616212845,
-0.3885367512702942,
0.2550777196884155,
0.3973878026008606,
-0.16994841396808624,
1.1396784782409668,
0.8996360898017883,
0.1213926151394844,
0.17844726145267487,
-0.24884548783302307,
0.2631451487541199,
-0.8554481267929077,
-0.12366120517253876,
-0.36478960514068604,
-0.3009631335735321,
-0.3660218417644501,
-0.2849522531032562,
0.3270949125289917,
0.3443615138530731,
-0.19734534621238708,
0.37743720412254333,
-0.2606692314147949,
0.39336270093917847,
0.6592560410499573,
0.13468757271766663,
0.04074881225824356,
0.03815487399697304,
-0.10460454970598221,
-0.2900080680847168,
-0.8396934866905212,
-0.20103363692760468,
1.3025250434875488,
0.45261839032173157,
0.5995381474494934,
-0.05142700672149658,
0.6487082242965698,
0.38684341311454773,
0.05440205708146095,
-0.8157834410667419,
0.36095568537712097,
-0.3303893804550171,
-0.47079145908355713,
-0.11573555320501328,
-0.43377411365509033,
-0.7917339205741882,
-0.17584076523780823,
-0.5015515685081482,
-0.910065233707428,
0.6029051542282104,
0.15951652824878693,
-0.6967580318450928,
0.25771793723106384,
-0.8013641834259033,
1.0760754346847534,
-0.2601671814918518,
-0.4396604299545288,
-0.08624236285686493,
-0.8074696063995361,
0.051287487149238586,
-0.010039815679192543,
-0.03945664316415787,
-0.326254665851593,
0.015617972239851952,
0.32688596844673157,
-0.6056159734725952,
0.6562713384628296,
-0.19028209149837494,
-0.11839164048433304,
0.030003847554326057,
0.06276161223649979,
0.2975751459598541,
-0.10701686888933182,
-0.48350998759269714,
0.20803199708461761,
0.1659061759710312,
-0.5324556827545166,
-0.481818288564682,
0.7013403177261353,
-0.6000038385391235,
-0.14933271706104279,
-0.40197497606277466,
-0.5156331658363342,
-0.10340738296508789,
0.332506388425827,
0.6032556891441345,
0.4520221948623657,
-0.11978035420179367,
-0.3650938868522644,
0.6383494734764099,
-0.07212663441896439,
0.06339586526155472,
0.8341360688209534,
0.13551108539104462,
-0.5291939377784729,
0.9953989386558533,
-0.024164807051420212,
0.26511523127555847,
0.48204508423805237,
-0.06617183238267899,
-0.33099737763404846,
-0.7028963565826416,
-0.39312508702278137,
0.4279904067516327,
-0.40824565291404724,
-0.3540327847003937,
-0.37079283595085144,
-0.07710400223731995,
-0.30653107166290283,
-0.245921790599823,
-0.35272616147994995,
-0.19037650525569916,
-0.45249566435813904,
0.04780032858252525,
0.12784409523010254,
0.23621346056461334,
-0.3007364571094513,
0.33316823840141296,
-1.0589356422424316,
0.17608784139156342,
-0.09998622536659241,
0.6820560097694397,
-0.5210893750190735,
-0.49770259857177734,
-0.25823527574539185,
0.37237784266471863,
0.19427061080932617,
-0.7557316422462463,
0.14571119844913483,
0.8438489437103271,
0.42274826765060425,
0.5231571793556213,
0.17328254878520966,
0.5440720915794373,
-0.5052184462547302,
0.63083815574646,
0.26211345195770264,
-0.8529946804046631,
0.9444689154624939,
-0.5518214702606201,
0.19626301527023315,
0.6359593272209167,
0.3240858316421509,
-0.242457777261734,
-0.24926315248012543,
-0.5299097895622253,
-0.485796719789505,
0.7923332452774048,
0.2363644242286682,
-0.4120006859302521,
-0.09964439272880554,
0.8126196265220642,
0.08249320834875107,
0.13825252652168274,
-0.585462749004364,
-0.47829195857048035,
0.22104817628860474,
-0.5844576954841614,
0.05932646989822388,
-0.36503323912620544,
-0.27808627486228943,
-0.2712673842906952,
0.7821304798126221,
-0.23552654683589935,
0.2268429696559906,
-0.07092071324586868,
0.010339952073991299,
-0.756112277507782,
0.11246127635240555,
0.5562419295310974,
0.5197992920875549,
-0.9247462749481201,
0.05203055962920189,
0.18182744085788727,
-0.49993351101875305,
0.25232675671577454,
0.3599402606487274,
-0.35199129581451416,
0.039411962032318115,
0.05018598958849907,
0.6044368147850037,
-0.26077985763549805,
-1.100338101387024,
0.3615497052669525,
-0.30723997950553894,
-0.1217479407787323,
0.033411797136068344,
0.1879105120897293,
-0.17094101011753082,
0.312735915184021,
0.07361025363206863,
0.17671631276607513,
0.2396717071533203,
-0.38769423961639404,
0.5213943123817444,
0.6583523750305176,
-0.6711647510528564,
-0.2740127742290497,
0.7523199319839478,
0.3501668870449066,
-0.13060861825942993,
0.21218609809875488,
-0.13176852464675903,
-0.17438797652721405,
0.45692119002342224,
0.3499052822589874,
0.592578113079071,
-0.05567961931228638,
0.2899731397628784,
0.6749878525733948,
-0.04270746186375618,
0.30655404925346375,
0.06308303028345108,
0.2624846398830414,
-0.7842779755592346,
-0.19965104758739471,
-0.7843851447105408,
-0.3970145285129547,
0.2312815636396408,
-0.5505381226539612,
0.4405568242073059,
-0.44621607661247253,
-0.3164130449295044,
0.5600951910018921,
0.7588247060775757,
-0.4033089876174927,
0.2724713385105133,
0.12331445515155792,
0.9459478259086609,
-0.9441417455673218,
1.0945377349853516,
0.9279487133026123,
-0.4329666197299957,
-0.6031822562217712,
-0.07361261546611786,
-0.061034396290779114,
-0.20959216356277466,
0.5754137635231018,
0.3347574770450592,
-0.1747514009475708,
0.25531312823295593,
-0.35893765091896057,
-0.8254404664039612,
0.8976392149925232,
0.34162381291389465,
-0.5805160999298096,
0.051983725279569626,
0.5792520046234131,
0.6404243111610413,
-0.598996639251709,
0.08502849191427231,
0.8346033096313477,
0.4415627717971802,
0.055655766278505325,
-0.8192901015281677,
-0.005332827568054199,
-0.4706127941608429,
-0.2257431000471115,
0.1640503704547882,
-0.4302002191543579,
0.5445701479911804,
-0.4652477204799652,
-0.13590870797634125,
0.5590841770172119,
0.561173141002655,
0.2545342743396759,
0.6181038618087769,
0.38219842314720154,
0.6621482968330383,
0.6699399948120117,
-0.1843627542257309,
0.6941393613815308,
-0.5711239576339722,
0.3594866096973419,
0.9580999612808228,
-0.39848747849464417,
0.6996535658836365,
0.6852791905403137,
-0.410134881734848,
0.10160532593727112,
0.7727667093276978,
-0.4994782507419586,
0.6342345476150513,
0.05914026126265526,
-0.2514408230781555,
-0.2593153715133667,
-0.43340224027633667,
-0.07617542147636414,
0.244711771607399,
0.5643264055252075,
0.049120817333459854,
-0.06455521285533905,
0.1818527728319168,
-0.3388814926147461,
0.18655993044376373,
-0.49843090772628784,
0.6615025997161865,
-0.040273163467645645,
-0.4383947551250458,
0.6490949392318726,
0.03683912381529808,
0.6952428221702576,
-0.5733702182769775,
0.08182787150144577,
0.04801696911454201,
0.42867642641067505,
-0.2500816285610199,
-0.6402563452720642,
-0.06827879697084427,
-0.3162711262702942,
-0.48446542024612427,
0.5830642580986023,
0.9966545104980469,
-1.0350146293640137,
-0.46347349882125854,
0.2126103788614273,
0.34347522258758545,
-0.10758616775274277,
0.19778427481651306,
-0.8351448178291321,
0.14844803512096405,
0.144448384642601,
0.19718985259532928,
0.5834398865699768,
0.0930512398481369,
0.5220925807952881,
0.66233229637146,
0.28900501132011414,
0.18077220022678375,
-0.1266411691904068,
-0.09825925529003143,
0.6172612309455872,
-0.38446521759033203,
0.09459991753101349,
-0.701837956905365,
0.5005651116371155,
-0.00407253997400403,
-0.02259969897568226,
0.6110978126525879,
0.5759511590003967,
0.3178793787956238,
-0.3677635192871094,
0.48901328444480896,
-0.059566937386989594,
0.4348471462726593,
-0.4666411578655243,
0.5809844732284546,
-0.5871791243553162,
0.21740774810314178,
-0.08003632724285126,
-0.5464577078819275,
-0.508073091506958,
0.3321768641471863,
-0.3956364393234253,
-0.023637501522898674,
0.40428417921066284,
0.9144639372825623,
0.0012991746189072728,
-0.19065093994140625,
0.04009854421019554,
0.13818234205245972,
0.41388997435569763,
0.7670468688011169,
0.3073282837867737,
-0.6955209374427795,
0.2839239537715912,
-0.4938351809978485,
-0.05197211354970932,
-0.27437207102775574,
-0.8738740682601929,
-1.0494197607040405,
-0.2938348054885864,
-0.34156522154808044,
-0.5448769927024841,
0.2682549059391022,
1.2572999000549316,
0.6086713671684265,
-1.1242642402648926,
-0.14919498562812805,
-0.16034254431724548,
-0.05077113211154938,
-0.07295248657464981,
-0.12389048933982849,
0.48991724848747253,
-0.3182574510574341,
-0.8515634536743164,
0.3514997363090515,
0.3781309127807617,
0.2795765697956085,
0.11775536835193634,
-0.4906207025051117,
-0.5700076818466187,
0.07817342132329941,
0.3639589548110962,
0.6673858165740967,
-0.5763443112373352,
-0.19379299879074097,
-0.04763069376349449,
-0.16386054456233978,
-0.10826881229877472,
0.8160854578018188,
-0.5547032952308655,
0.32674065232276917,
0.17612771689891815,
0.15861760079860687,
0.05200555548071861,
0.25133025646209717,
1.157081127166748,
-0.699284553527832,
0.2886124849319458,
0.04905640706419945,
0.19232012331485748,
0.15624399483203888,
-0.34840717911720276,
0.5231287479400635,
0.1815922111272812,
-0.28037020564079285,
-0.9761549234390259,
0.25526583194732666,
-1.021559715270996,
-0.2945072054862976,
0.9244670271873474,
-0.07612740248441696,
-0.31375381350517273,
0.040887828916311264,
0.0018764924025163054,
0.31075218319892883,
-0.23075704276561737,
0.7233909964561462,
0.18814359605312347,
-0.315267413854599,
-0.06493981927633286,
-0.26565301418304443,
1.1634551286697388,
0.4736263155937195,
-0.4263817071914673,
0.12402591854333878,
0.5005543231964111,
0.08910196274518967,
0.008506697602570057,
0.3770485818386078,
0.1814647763967514,
0.341543585062027,
-0.196629136800766,
-0.2324088215827942,
-0.054328106343746185,
-0.28292644023895264,
-0.28901588916778564,
-0.09797939658164978,
0.12777568399906158,
-0.09213577955961227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19146v1 | Resolving Discrepancies in Compute-Optimal Scaling of Language Models | 2024-06-27T13:02:43 | 2024-06-27T13:02:43 | Tomer Porian, Mitchell Wortsman, Jenia Jitsev, Ludwig Schmidt, Yair Carmon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Kaplan et al. and Hoffmann et al. developed influential scaling laws for the
optimal model size as a function of the compute budget, but these laws yield
substantially different predictions. We explain the discrepancy by reproducing
the Kaplan scaling law on two datasets (OpenWebText2 and RefinedWeb) and
identifying three factors causing the difference: last layer computational
cost, warmup duration, and scale-dependent optimizer tuning. With these factors
corrected, we obtain excellent agreement with the Hoffmann et al. (i.e.,
"Chinchilla") scaling law. Counter to a hypothesis of Hoffmann et al., we find
that careful learning rate decay is not essential for the validity of their
scaling law. As a secondary result, we derive scaling laws for the optimal
learning rate and batch size, finding that tuning the AdamW $\beta_2$ parameter
is essential at lower batch sizes. | [
-0.26074182987213135,
-0.6662917137145996,
0.4541248083114624,
0.3729901909828186,
0.1400884985923767,
-0.16851583123207092,
-0.5367791652679443,
-0.4443207383155823,
-0.10869090259075165,
0.4198302626609802,
-0.387439101934433,
0.37507230043411255,
-0.5659392476081848,
-0.07587656378746033,
-0.2103656679391861,
0.7516454458236694,
0.18416500091552734,
0.1777547001838684,
-0.1355760097503662,
-0.15225614607334137,
-0.09548086673021317,
-0.0014033329207450151,
-1.1439437866210938,
-0.44090011715888977,
0.4808294475078583,
0.4509211480617523,
1.001604437828064,
1.1024448871612549,
0.5969989895820618,
0.12131080776453018,
-0.122726671397686,
-0.13673119246959686,
-0.39243265986442566,
-0.12162839621305466,
0.042965780943632126,
-0.6715587377548218,
-0.4116789400577545,
-0.07689324021339417,
0.49882209300994873,
0.7562153935432434,
-0.4012581706047058,
0.17325595021247864,
0.07815705239772797,
0.9399926662445068,
-0.7203138470649719,
0.19272682070732117,
-0.6557039618492126,
-0.15951292216777802,
-0.2104947417974472,
0.08925820887088776,
-0.6896478533744812,
-0.21876507997512817,
-0.08005017787218094,
-0.6884220838546753,
0.37538251280784607,
0.03904839605093002,
0.8682765960693359,
0.48732176423072815,
-0.326711505651474,
-0.24861204624176025,
-0.7296082377433777,
1.008015751838684,
-0.9621052742004395,
0.3603798449039459,
0.5203054547309875,
0.16428335011005402,
0.17384321987628937,
-0.7809086441993713,
-0.3978731334209442,
-0.3503328561782837,
0.15157650411128998,
-0.09062235057353973,
-0.5988626480102539,
0.03130769357085228,
0.6746308207511902,
0.25867369771003723,
-0.5028371214866638,
0.5284333825111389,
-0.585616409778595,
-0.2232108861207962,
0.6903186440467834,
0.06863478571176529,
0.22214090824127197,
0.247561976313591,
0.0837642028927803,
-0.38492631912231445,
-0.7368742227554321,
0.20579269528388977,
0.42854592204093933,
0.6886342167854309,
-0.28667595982551575,
0.2521769404411316,
-0.00901640672236681,
0.6901475787162781,
0.2923513948917389,
-0.20746345818042755,
0.415403813123703,
-0.07537447661161423,
-0.09149203449487686,
0.10362463444471359,
0.4325265884399414,
0.43030259013175964,
0.5843052864074707,
0.0764831081032753,
0.0151071073487401,
-0.22982461750507355,
0.48489466309547424,
-0.8294100761413574,
-0.25821205973625183,
0.00908773671835661,
-0.3563646674156189,
-0.19231277704238892,
-0.012679739855229855,
-0.528228223323822,
-0.3847743272781372,
-0.28193235397338867,
0.47341009974479675,
0.15715424716472626,
-0.4692808985710144,
-0.25048157572746277,
-0.05541367828845978,
0.2512558400630951,
0.2788149118423462,
-1.2578365802764893,
0.4377565383911133,
0.5366848707199097,
0.6603226661682129,
0.17220693826675415,
-0.2310018539428711,
-0.37132126092910767,
-0.30201828479766846,
-0.7987255454063416,
0.3499872088432312,
-0.434030145406723,
-0.08723311126232147,
0.07485464960336685,
-0.2644888758659363,
-0.01917441375553608,
-0.7442244291305542,
0.468679279088974,
-0.41703665256500244,
0.0033284530509263277,
-0.6581528782844543,
-0.563766598701477,
-0.05879697948694229,
-0.2791000008583069,
-0.7076942920684814,
1.024082899093628,
0.47250664234161377,
-0.7439108490943909,
0.6056097745895386,
-0.32451239228248596,
-0.6602340936660767,
0.11403004825115204,
-0.027504166588187218,
-0.4834088981151581,
0.36386650800704956,
-0.0396752692759037,
0.3192499577999115,
-0.6127878427505493,
0.023859933018684387,
-0.3715870678424835,
-0.291767954826355,
0.0013396897120401263,
-0.10221174359321594,
1.105455994606018,
0.4254891276359558,
-0.4170725643634796,
-0.11285088956356049,
-0.8722374439239502,
0.15398390591144562,
0.26405397057533264,
-0.4802738428115845,
-0.22161707282066345,
0.4030631184577942,
0.08626226335763931,
-0.1410733163356781,
0.1327774077653885,
-0.5423494577407837,
0.056850794702768326,
-0.270010769367218,
0.6130959391593933,
0.614087700843811,
-0.12608350813388824,
0.5885505676269531,
-0.22092384099960327,
0.4184727966785431,
-0.2517724633216858,
0.2410193532705307,
0.1074993684887886,
-0.40868839621543884,
-0.5911937355995178,
-0.10360414534807205,
0.12732531130313873,
0.3017657697200775,
-0.17467258870601654,
-0.20211896300315857,
-0.10363835841417313,
-0.5496252179145813,
-0.45052680373191833,
0.10861320793628693,
0.2459801584482193,
0.5309630036354065,
0.601902425289154,
-0.06110439449548721,
-0.4633578062057495,
-1.2489101886749268,
-0.6319617033004761,
-0.4195114076137543,
-0.07774341106414795,
0.39989978075027466,
0.22903163731098175,
0.09523084759712219,
0.779098391532898,
-0.5458207726478577,
-0.11802688241004944,
-0.385843425989151,
0.01972530037164688,
0.050277452915906906,
0.40467265248298645,
0.7835258841514587,
-0.7314361333847046,
-0.9432451725006104,
0.17147959768772125,
-0.1260482370853424,
-0.37547028064727783,
-0.09723576158285141,
0.47583815455436707,
0.3580017685890198,
0.8904798626899719,
-0.19198057055473328,
0.10468745976686478,
0.46463868021965027,
0.17800110578536987,
0.5247098803520203,
-0.4075339436531067,
-0.09243498742580414,
-0.8492584824562073,
-0.2889193594455719,
0.21531392633914948,
-0.12064280360937119,
-0.7715705037117004,
0.2500188648700714,
0.5877364873886108,
0.4007922410964966,
-0.2952829599380493,
0.317223459482193,
-0.30538123846054077,
-0.0832202285528183,
-0.3139313757419586,
0.049274031072854996,
-0.20879052579402924,
0.5650879740715027,
-0.3791066110134125,
0.9708715677261353,
0.49338865280151367,
-0.6367871761322021,
-0.01239760685712099,
-0.22628501057624817,
-0.007362763397395611,
0.4567783772945404,
-0.8317506313323975,
-0.06285355240106583,
0.330723375082016,
0.0523550920188427,
-0.7909294962882996,
-0.33696088194847107,
-0.1936078667640686,
-0.49595123529434204,
0.5132969617843628,
-0.22803671658039093,
-0.5111343860626221,
-0.26984190940856934,
-0.2700687646865845,
0.33946681022644043,
0.9215371012687683,
-0.5012121200561523,
0.5112320780754089,
0.4309415817260742,
0.19378311932086945,
-0.6847294569015503,
-0.7905229330062866,
-0.27864375710487366,
-0.17910364270210266,
-0.46771928668022156,
0.3314840793609619,
-0.1172727420926094,
-0.5709984302520752,
-0.13642752170562744,
-0.2941149175167084,
-0.34154313802719116,
0.07324162125587463,
0.008885706774890423,
-0.09416171163320541,
-0.6514031291007996,
-0.09749183058738708,
0.15050983428955078,
0.22856874763965607,
0.4939781725406647,
-0.2871539890766144,
0.2871541380882263,
-0.20316320657730103,
0.06561902910470963,
-0.28995636105537415,
-0.24913568794727325,
0.700819730758667,
0.006712373346090317,
0.8104246854782104,
0.601692259311676,
-0.36942288279533386,
-0.20807059109210968,
-0.673759400844574,
-0.0744016170501709,
-0.4846993684768677,
0.3289833962917328,
-0.17167343199253082,
-0.5864381790161133,
0.7178119421005249,
0.0539146363735199,
0.10720030963420868,
1.0004122257232666,
0.5857864022254944,
0.011024783365428448,
1.000076413154602,
0.7106990814208984,
0.048479169607162476,
0.4622352719306946,
-0.12807974219322205,
0.09102431684732437,
-1.1705032587051392,
0.11207883059978485,
-0.8519557118415833,
-0.1780586987733841,
-1.096683382987976,
-0.07654551416635513,
0.2015407681465149,
-0.05876601114869118,
-0.5277561545372009,
0.41243839263916016,
-0.1169377937912941,
0.7131415605545044,
0.5034524202346802,
-0.08711058646440506,
-0.04374838247895241,
0.0676269680261612,
-0.11841420084238052,
-0.10532699525356293,
-0.8058092594146729,
0.008609917014837265,
1.2167404890060425,
0.06370027363300323,
0.5312443375587463,
0.271923691034317,
0.3548477292060852,
0.30267706513404846,
0.08088235557079315,
-0.5150437355041504,
0.38110610842704773,
-0.4020497500896454,
-0.7257747054100037,
-0.4224141240119934,
-0.7136717438697815,
-1.0364940166473389,
0.301359623670578,
0.01590028777718544,
-0.8228239417076111,
-0.03327628970146179,
0.17990253865718842,
-0.07499473541975021,
0.44348716735839844,
-0.6755586266517639,
0.7616736888885498,
0.20423957705497742,
-0.489372581243515,
-0.5732529163360596,
-0.7617212533950806,
-0.05047262832522392,
-0.2151239514350891,
0.426420122385025,
-0.1466951072216034,
0.08902841061353683,
0.878202497959137,
-0.5668942928314209,
0.6338549852371216,
-0.26617780327796936,
0.07564909756183624,
0.3331216871738434,
0.23814165592193604,
0.3482249677181244,
-0.19133360683918,
0.11991528421640396,
-0.0730578601360321,
0.04343685135245323,
-0.7033188939094543,
-0.46973520517349243,
0.6142207980155945,
-1.0376421213150024,
-0.4278513193130493,
-0.16001084446907043,
-0.4614275395870209,
-0.1883663386106491,
0.24583709239959717,
0.4974516034126282,
0.7698517441749573,
-0.041425760835409164,
0.4996461868286133,
0.6472294330596924,
-0.012240826152265072,
0.5248517394065857,
0.6596860289573669,
-0.1874648630619049,
0.04973426088690758,
0.9344413876533508,
0.4569905400276184,
0.6432018280029297,
0.30722081661224365,
0.4810684621334076,
0.06856277585029602,
-0.4818570911884308,
-0.33444687724113464,
0.37110793590545654,
-0.5988882184028625,
0.012608462944626808,
-0.3585556745529175,
-0.23609048128128052,
-0.3377549648284912,
-0.33657947182655334,
-0.6536210775375366,
-0.6083924174308777,
-0.3015219271183014,
0.05957149341702461,
0.34102490544319153,
0.7694858312606812,
-0.49519047141075134,
0.3145070970058441,
-0.24776741862297058,
-0.1800568699836731,
-0.039076827466487885,
0.06987299770116806,
0.2696397304534912,
-0.9639124274253845,
-0.5371829271316528,
0.018292970955371857,
-0.18953268229961395,
-0.6368980407714844,
-0.03441382944583893,
0.35922732949256897,
0.5399641990661621,
0.5313897728919983,
-0.0004415732983034104,
0.31757640838623047,
-0.39621540904045105,
0.7032873630523682,
0.01931893453001976,
-0.8451145887374878,
0.38936489820480347,
-0.34427592158317566,
0.5090394020080566,
0.41715848445892334,
0.17436367273330688,
-0.3693329095840454,
-0.4990885257720947,
-0.8630754351615906,
-0.960399329662323,
0.8191144466400146,
0.18922193348407745,
0.4684978723526001,
0.1935669481754303,
0.6796639561653137,
0.05649576708674431,
-0.06847092509269714,
-0.44697535037994385,
-0.3218171298503876,
0.3399999439716339,
-0.07979366928339005,
-0.11664911359548569,
-0.3278461992740631,
0.12934966385364532,
-0.25665098428726196,
0.7724199891090393,
-0.04539947956800461,
-0.11130501329898834,
-0.057478517293930054,
-0.15300580859184265,
-0.3861031234264374,
0.03777588903903961,
0.9444968104362488,
1.107190489768982,
-0.1727122962474823,
-0.0026550129987299442,
0.24790334701538086,
-0.8496488928794861,
-0.0697239562869072,
-0.20271359384059906,
-0.20172497630119324,
-0.3749992549419403,
0.5839331150054932,
0.8592930436134338,
0.3376079797744751,
-0.38715341687202454,
0.3603772819042206,
-0.18770425021648407,
-0.34397441148757935,
-0.2782486379146576,
0.3553924262523651,
-0.025451311841607094,
0.2706749737262726,
0.45616430044174194,
0.48141106963157654,
-0.05876661464571953,
-0.1808522492647171,
0.026916295289993286,
0.2181653529405594,
-0.29670271277427673,
-0.3299051821231842,
0.8365373015403748,
0.03414519131183624,
-0.4719896614551544,
0.9954625368118286,
-0.06959599256515503,
-0.3371468484401703,
0.906051754951477,
0.47437721490859985,
0.6573317646980286,
-0.45001330971717834,
0.2553434371948242,
0.7343549728393555,
0.745503842830658,
-0.33197543025016785,
-0.08302636444568634,
-0.05631803348660469,
-0.693880021572113,
-0.19865864515304565,
-0.20418524742126465,
-0.49304404854774475,
0.03149464353919029,
-1.269372820854187,
0.07750598341226578,
-0.6340591311454773,
-0.35467419028282166,
0.35586971044540405,
0.2164963185787201,
-0.5575435757637024,
0.19101549685001373,
-0.18954184651374817,
0.7839233875274658,
-0.7378935813903809,
0.5145342350006104,
0.36327633261680603,
-0.39414793252944946,
-1.0442848205566406,
0.11984619498252869,
0.267795592546463,
-0.8593952655792236,
0.4202563762664795,
-0.18714237213134766,
-0.07405158132314682,
0.04953339695930481,
-0.3598567545413971,
-0.9202269911766052,
0.7702603936195374,
0.5232717394828796,
-0.5076841115951538,
0.18789590895175934,
-0.18214702606201172,
0.7344250082969666,
-0.35315918922424316,
0.12864519655704498,
0.5267849564552307,
0.19318701326847076,
0.036159053444862366,
-1.0917195081710815,
-0.023036031052470207,
0.08353456854820251,
-0.05157093703746796,
0.4379696846008301,
-0.6978924870491028,
1.1092774868011475,
-0.7801958918571472,
-0.003731953212991357,
-0.36726659536361694,
0.5306876301765442,
-0.23462754487991333,
0.1944935917854309,
0.3746616244316101,
0.5441810488700867,
0.8308447003364563,
0.053179215639829636,
1.2646119594573975,
-0.3121834993362427,
0.6494128108024597,
1.0530301332473755,
-0.22861045598983765,
1.0444649457931519,
0.350043386220932,
-0.6962915658950806,
0.4118075370788574,
0.877630889415741,
-0.11399130523204803,
0.24007312953472137,
0.20046645402908325,
0.2410060465335846,
0.07963188737630844,
0.21638181805610657,
-0.42005544900894165,
0.2417897880077362,
0.11693751811981201,
-0.3000876307487488,
-0.08135305345058441,
-0.2687114179134369,
0.6275644898414612,
-0.0636260136961937,
-0.34339064359664917,
0.5504827499389648,
-0.06834938377141953,
-0.5537816882133484,
0.7298398017883301,
0.1492922157049179,
0.0907374769449234,
-0.5775597095489502,
0.44045963883399963,
-0.35380369424819946,
0.5010029077529907,
-0.16894738376140594,
-0.48802450299263,
0.11126622557640076,
-0.008438128046691418,
-0.3326009213924408,
0.01972312480211258,
0.3056371510028839,
-0.16096504032611847,
-0.41577044129371643,
0.3208516538143158,
0.3092411160469055,
0.10555006563663483,
0.06279054284095764,
-0.679098904132843,
0.3449862599372864,
0.2021905481815338,
-0.41674479842185974,
0.42861250042915344,
-0.06257479637861252,
0.02516520395874977,
0.5590959191322327,
0.4096605181694031,
0.17196498811244965,
0.1779278963804245,
0.19685977697372437,
0.4751546084880829,
-0.05540986359119415,
-0.4442717134952545,
-0.867651641368866,
0.08567088097333908,
-0.015505473129451275,
-0.41396471858024597,
0.7575022578239441,
0.5573086142539978,
0.9038504958152771,
0.13268451392650604,
0.4807995557785034,
-0.029281416907906532,
0.21171997487545013,
-0.5341426134109497,
0.6299257874488831,
-0.9073954224586487,
0.15458063781261444,
0.015337859280407429,
-1.2228243350982666,
-0.19882149994373322,
0.6414211392402649,
-0.0018084448529407382,
0.40061530470848083,
0.9861472249031067,
0.6536359786987305,
0.007221295032650232,
0.12894988059997559,
0.19151337444782257,
0.6697524785995483,
0.15849626064300537,
0.18320322036743164,
0.014167305082082748,
-0.3682621419429779,
0.1409793645143509,
-0.20168152451515198,
-0.30702608823776245,
-0.38420554995536804,
-0.6442353129386902,
-0.6163802742958069,
-0.9772263169288635,
-0.677375078201294,
-0.5444844365119934,
-0.14972014725208282,
0.8258157968521118,
0.7131954431533813,
-0.6307750344276428,
-0.5187897682189941,
-0.19278424978256226,
-0.10443378239870071,
-0.6310214996337891,
-0.20840154588222504,
0.3208848834037781,
-0.5032008290290833,
-0.43985071778297424,
0.14370602369308472,
0.2068878561258316,
-0.11807578802108765,
-0.24360771477222443,
-0.12318181246519089,
0.09539655596017838,
0.6173035502433777,
0.22014136612415314,
0.5510281324386597,
-0.8540230989456177,
-0.20588356256484985,
-0.1534736603498459,
-0.3783186078071594,
0.2786236107349396,
1.0722111463546753,
-0.2735269069671631,
0.48185431957244873,
0.2556116580963135,
0.5818217396736145,
0.7219704985618591,
-0.5347602367401123,
0.4251348376274109,
-0.5563740134239197,
-0.01496727392077446,
-0.17889590561389923,
0.20610742270946503,
0.2963108420372009,
-0.4412979483604431,
0.6092910170555115,
0.023178940638899803,
-0.7375950217247009,
-0.9745355248451233,
0.2904602885246277,
-0.9572836756706238,
-0.2955613136291504,
0.9785628318786621,
0.060406967997550964,
-0.24866940081119537,
0.33203449845314026,
0.020670931786298752,
-0.05428001284599304,
-0.17940400540828705,
0.5869120359420776,
0.9760660529136658,
-0.38078364729881287,
-0.16387738287448883,
-0.9835841655731201,
0.6720931529998779,
0.4019825756549835,
-0.41333237290382385,
0.3509339392185211,
0.25131937861442566,
0.3973013758659363,
0.038298510015010834,
0.5430513620376587,
0.11516290158033371,
0.20166906714439392,
0.3705653250217438,
-0.3319263756275177,
0.1478874534368515,
-0.273935467004776,
-0.23160074651241302,
-0.05386142432689667,
0.27128052711486816,
0.3629781901836395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19116v1 | CHEW: A Dataset of CHanging Events in Wikipedia | 2024-06-27T11:53:15 | 2024-06-27T11:53:15 | Hsuvas Borkakoty, Luis Espinosa-Anke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce CHEW, a novel dataset of changing events in Wikipedia expressed
in naturally occurring text. We use CHEW for probing LLMs for their timeline
understanding of Wikipedia entities and events in generative and classification
experiments. Our results suggest that LLMs, despite having temporal information
available, struggle to construct accurate timelines. We further show the
usefulness of CHEW-derived embeddings for identifying meaning shift. | [
-0.13972799479961395,
-1.1197243928909302,
0.46646013855934143,
-0.07829150557518005,
-0.12427877634763718,
0.04840007796883583,
-0.04015054926276207,
-0.6012829542160034,
0.9563727974891663,
0.11901026219129562,
-0.9531179666519165,
-0.20697560906410217,
-0.3541880249977112,
0.06383205950260162,
-0.6427448987960815,
0.8817593455314636,
-0.16868019104003906,
-0.03551376610994339,
0.019490955397486687,
-0.15634553134441376,
-0.09690015017986298,
0.11234743148088455,
-0.5139356851577759,
-0.3470243215560913,
0.8407608270645142,
0.4268627464771271,
0.7891973853111267,
0.8513908982276917,
0.2188609540462494,
0.16426332294940948,
-0.17601396143436432,
0.2521473169326782,
-0.49765798449516296,
0.1742079257965088,
-0.5457622408866882,
-0.6785690784454346,
-0.000007909663509053644,
0.12125132977962494,
0.8053120374679565,
0.8113717436790466,
-0.27539539337158203,
0.19990640878677368,
-0.6297785043716431,
0.523655891418457,
-0.536191463470459,
0.1600339114665985,
-0.9000359177589417,
0.2983319163322449,
-0.8280460238456726,
-0.23808075487613678,
-0.47254931926727295,
-0.3003498315811157,
-0.01160532608628273,
-0.8948162794113159,
0.2624276280403137,
-0.1757427603006363,
1.3371412754058838,
0.13671551644802094,
-0.5819917917251587,
-0.3872886002063751,
-0.511420488357544,
0.4458349049091339,
-0.4478006958961487,
0.5999574661254883,
0.21458794176578522,
0.10408250987529755,
-0.4874849021434784,
-1.1252779960632324,
-0.8416280746459961,
-0.1284475028514862,
0.052952706813812256,
-0.08919356763362885,
-0.22348080575466156,
-0.40774932503700256,
0.21405264735221863,
0.42583659291267395,
-0.008026042021811008,
0.22231708467006683,
-0.35908785462379456,
-0.12086495757102966,
0.34686607122421265,
0.5768433213233948,
0.7970436811447144,
-0.8524371385574341,
-0.41445639729499817,
0.05904519185423851,
-0.898370623588562,
0.23782746493816376,
0.3112706243991852,
0.11733262240886688,
0.06815969198942184,
0.8651267290115356,
0.09500566124916077,
0.52147376537323,
0.4117266535758972,
0.01394158136099577,
0.2600553035736084,
-0.03150857239961624,
-0.2873347997665405,
0.14463846385478973,
0.5318717956542969,
0.5218316912651062,
0.10301803797483444,
-0.283997118473053,
0.35351496934890747,
-0.34670183062553406,
0.2103118896484375,
-0.6631534695625305,
-0.21293970942497253,
0.02867145650088787,
-0.6351003050804138,
-0.5227606892585754,
0.22764402627944946,
-0.7212703824043274,
-0.62555330991745,
-0.2554631233215332,
-0.010368900373578072,
-0.4653548002243042,
-0.37350764870643616,
-0.17393124103546143,
-0.7106531858444214,
0.6576971411705017,
0.2997249364852905,
-1.1270323991775513,
0.07870935648679733,
0.6293443441390991,
0.8530421257019043,
-0.38482484221458435,
-0.6010117530822754,
-0.6835266947746277,
0.5199350714683533,
-0.7593305110931396,
0.8419992923736572,
-0.612904965877533,
-0.3306233882904053,
-0.028418781235814095,
0.3344362676143646,
0.032548051327466965,
-0.5887120962142944,
0.317924827337265,
-0.9172755479812622,
-0.009912368841469288,
-0.33093976974487305,
-0.8918189406394958,
0.03296103700995445,
0.30713704228401184,
-1.0901453495025635,
1.1201763153076172,
0.050660762935876846,
-1.0850595235824585,
0.776558518409729,
-0.2779269218444824,
-0.7173724174499512,
0.05970223248004913,
-0.2694414258003235,
-0.09844167530536652,
0.23781166970729828,
-0.0638541653752327,
-0.00756593095138669,
0.1814655363559723,
0.45788460969924927,
-0.33908402919769287,
-0.2222939282655716,
0.7102369070053101,
-0.2572195529937744,
1.0096604824066162,
-0.09943922609090805,
-0.46855512261390686,
-0.05597776174545288,
-0.7332699298858643,
-0.15117232501506805,
0.08075083047151566,
-0.5942043662071228,
-0.28703081607818604,
0.5988180637359619,
-0.041375163942575455,
0.05361521616578102,
0.09444699436426163,
-0.39723241329193115,
0.5247008800506592,
-0.3302331566810608,
0.4576873779296875,
0.8761410713195801,
0.2592017650604248,
0.39449581503868103,
-0.5126944780349731,
0.22644519805908203,
-0.12478514760732651,
0.10687189549207687,
-0.23737655580043793,
-0.4665597677230835,
-0.8161510825157166,
0.10967312753200531,
0.28428488969802856,
0.549285352230072,
-0.436795711517334,
0.1811010092496872,
-0.32941052317619324,
-0.28198230266571045,
-0.3825294077396393,
0.1228175163269043,
-0.49396276473999023,
0.5127900242805481,
0.29611876606941223,
-0.004464731551706791,
-0.6869989037513733,
-0.6775637865066528,
-0.32181882858276367,
-0.451602965593338,
-0.21636734902858734,
0.30569687485694885,
0.32453104853630066,
-0.3714635372161865,
0.8469664454460144,
-0.550023078918457,
0.10450168699026108,
0.12688620388507843,
0.33440065383911133,
-0.0308439452201128,
-0.18315567076206207,
0.22616632282733917,
-1.0567833185195923,
-0.45871877670288086,
-0.19999276101589203,
-0.6663134098052979,
0.12076442688703537,
-0.46773862838745117,
-0.3700551390647888,
0.29082611203193665,
1.0165343284606934,
-0.6989267468452454,
0.4889753758907318,
0.16790753602981567,
-0.39986932277679443,
0.5204803347587585,
0.3324642777442932,
0.14819598197937012,
-0.9466850757598877,
-0.07965199649333954,
-0.5930781960487366,
-0.13504981994628906,
-0.4302940368652344,
-0.30744457244873047,
0.3284703195095062,
0.28172558546066284,
-0.6989232301712036,
0.5997735261917114,
-0.48323705792427063,
-0.14783476293087006,
-0.12443502992391586,
0.3338748812675476,
0.01790626347064972,
-0.028521528467535973,
0.025753488764166832,
0.3780554234981537,
0.33736515045166016,
-0.7174608111381531,
0.6131358742713928,
0.5024350881576538,
-0.4498983323574066,
0.5734178423881531,
0.03128314018249512,
0.13762696087360382,
-0.1476144939661026,
0.18681901693344116,
-0.60523921251297,
-0.6025205254554749,
0.34257110953330994,
-0.5168877243995667,
0.6238605976104736,
-0.20638178288936615,
-0.6186768412590027,
-0.12715886533260345,
-0.6014316082000732,
-0.1728355586528778,
0.10123244673013687,
-0.7078226208686829,
0.5354305505752563,
0.5758812427520752,
-0.04072706401348114,
-0.5478796362876892,
-0.6393136978149414,
0.42843204736709595,
-0.31787100434303284,
-0.6767221689224243,
0.8678480982780457,
-0.14023250341415405,
-0.46039465069770813,
0.6128022074699402,
-0.3642338216304779,
-0.06922212243080139,
-0.004607494920492172,
0.24394960701465607,
0.07979079335927963,
-0.2804563045501709,
0.641516923904419,
-0.09645824879407883,
0.27585846185684204,
0.22596977651119232,
-0.02257777750492096,
0.4157262444496155,
0.35084885358810425,
0.020652104169130325,
-0.2962377965450287,
0.17091892659664154,
0.35039910674095154,
0.1557404100894928,
0.689940333366394,
0.7882094979286194,
-0.5608294010162354,
-0.12350679188966751,
-0.49106353521347046,
0.14743056893348694,
-0.44839003682136536,
0.1555299311876297,
-0.18300604820251465,
-0.7525925040245056,
0.5774891972541809,
-0.1789972186088562,
-0.16139881312847137,
0.7548543810844421,
0.5701004862785339,
-0.5254167318344116,
0.36747026443481445,
0.32524004578590393,
-0.14680606126785278,
0.8654231429100037,
0.157315194606781,
-0.4951186180114746,
-1.026582956314087,
-0.5781776905059814,
-0.14264461398124695,
-0.5533279776573181,
-0.83010333776474,
-0.5495173335075378,
-0.09878160804510117,
0.22915160655975342,
-0.19700375199317932,
0.0036345492117106915,
0.11922482401132584,
0.5819966793060303,
0.33979177474975586,
0.04479159787297249,
0.21692754328250885,
-0.09725801646709442,
-0.033900052309036255,
-0.23804090917110443,
-0.1876620054244995,
-0.265195369720459,
0.9195454120635986,
-0.14338399469852448,
0.9533035755157471,
0.3104531168937683,
0.3933297097682953,
0.5280309319496155,
0.21935506165027618,
-0.6748596429824829,
0.37286627292633057,
-0.10679469257593155,
-0.8613235950469971,
-0.6712859869003296,
-0.34113144874572754,
-1.3649822473526,
-0.21761660277843475,
-0.024104280397295952,
-0.8642932176589966,
0.06559515744447708,
-0.31201398372650146,
0.36394962668418884,
0.6623319387435913,
-0.3568575084209442,
0.6091048717498779,
-0.29846715927124023,
-0.14201799035072327,
-0.3124430775642395,
-0.699544370174408,
0.15413276851177216,
0.2480251044034958,
0.09779045730829239,
-0.6400544047355652,
-0.3347986936569214,
0.7765368819236755,
-0.30654776096343994,
1.0703240633010864,
0.09487807750701904,
0.25619083642959595,
0.5458217859268188,
0.4791293740272522,
0.6729231476783752,
0.5611932873725891,
-0.07707701623439789,
-0.26839426159858704,
-0.19406409561634064,
-0.298692911863327,
-0.6072884202003479,
0.8501107096672058,
-0.6817454695701599,
-0.5684899687767029,
-0.30234721302986145,
-0.2972581684589386,
-0.23312225937843323,
0.21598435938358307,
0.3312213122844696,
0.3402227759361267,
-0.7374124526977539,
-0.14160655438899994,
0.7830379605293274,
-0.12624281644821167,
0.45280230045318604,
0.7274695038795471,
-0.22411945462226868,
-0.19847005605697632,
0.5735118985176086,
0.2649521231651306,
0.04227793589234352,
0.8579369187355042,
0.27398958802223206,
-0.20613618195056915,
-0.10803525894880295,
-0.6549630761146545,
0.23931990563869476,
-1.0085810422897339,
-0.24153345823287964,
-0.42724141478538513,
-0.27238792181015015,
-0.20796550810337067,
-0.24371904134750366,
-0.048239246010780334,
-0.5966325998306274,
-0.7413521409034729,
-0.6004270911216736,
0.6443254351615906,
1.016940712928772,
-0.3947780430316925,
-0.2932792901992798,
-0.7243841290473938,
0.457701712846756,
0.307842880487442,
0.30592331290245056,
-0.31060484051704407,
-0.26967790722846985,
-0.038512855768203735,
-0.28113818168640137,
-0.2647307515144348,
-1.6208914518356323,
0.08806589990854263,
0.42338019609451294,
0.869960367679596,
0.41712459921836853,
0.018975673243403435,
0.6510295271873474,
-0.6701147556304932,
0.9045865535736084,
0.10964424163103104,
-1.0101726055145264,
0.9152212142944336,
-0.3421883285045624,
0.4113991856575012,
0.2865053117275238,
0.6623196005821228,
-1.1126757860183716,
-0.1726224720478058,
-0.8453860878944397,
-0.7744588851928711,
0.7009447813034058,
-0.3122291564941406,
0.3866800367832184,
-0.4433937966823578,
0.5141058564186096,
0.2219666838645935,
0.14182543754577637,
-0.6246398687362671,
-0.36142778396606445,
0.023608220741152763,
0.03273927792906761,
0.26586422324180603,
-0.358615517616272,
-0.0351068377494812,
-0.33295175433158875,
0.3200213313102722,
-0.05621494725346565,
0.054108381271362305,
0.08636800199747086,
-0.679671585559845,
-0.3687925636768341,
0.15982362627983093,
0.32978370785713196,
0.9632907509803772,
-0.21007640659809113,
0.3654780387878418,
0.5298846364021301,
-0.5571324229240417,
-0.03271728381514549,
0.08861692249774933,
-0.2250811755657196,
0.3599220812320709,
0.6199162602424622,
0.6824327707290649,
0.7863917946815491,
-0.6150076985359192,
0.3266649544239044,
0.17585328221321106,
0.19539514183998108,
-0.3245224058628082,
0.1529744565486908,
0.5071151256561279,
0.2420053631067276,
0.3442131578922272,
-0.4317225515842438,
0.30936554074287415,
-0.834776759147644,
0.4382457733154297,
-0.027412885800004005,
-0.452728271484375,
-0.5727365612983704,
0.47494369745254517,
0.031042713671922684,
-0.10837535560131073,
1.1734777688980103,
-0.38441500067710876,
-0.3114757537841797,
0.7198514938354492,
0.47577959299087524,
0.526450514793396,
-0.35071077942848206,
0.6220832467079163,
0.32183510065078735,
0.30547744035720825,
0.5098946690559387,
0.10122736543416977,
0.06350652873516083,
-0.7591568827629089,
-0.33951762318611145,
-0.3418106436729431,
-0.3859502971172333,
0.3432370722293854,
-0.8940877914428711,
0.6443350911140442,
-0.2064085602760315,
-0.2106558233499527,
0.4207581877708435,
0.07374979555606842,
-0.7175813913345337,
-0.06592768430709839,
0.11302246153354645,
1.2881622314453125,
-0.5806439518928528,
0.6217494010925293,
0.770366370677948,
-0.36000165343284607,
-0.3429783880710602,
0.35950174927711487,
0.2905668020248413,
-0.7852164506912231,
0.8061413764953613,
0.013691646046936512,
0.19572040438652039,
-0.35015326738357544,
-0.6508169174194336,
-1.0057246685028076,
1.2361767292022705,
0.3134671747684479,
-0.24462929368019104,
-0.37576159834861755,
-0.15885472297668457,
0.32336029410362244,
0.08742526918649673,
-0.1206224337220192,
0.5503722429275513,
0.4603129029273987,
0.051983773708343506,
-0.7081570625305176,
-0.07219666242599487,
-0.07606400549411774,
-0.3177965581417084,
0.713005781173706,
-0.7072276473045349,
0.7896001935005188,
-0.3708035349845886,
-0.6971524953842163,
-0.42174866795539856,
0.7043256759643555,
-0.1858980655670166,
0.4470301568508148,
0.5005794167518616,
0.5248071551322937,
1.4102226495742798,
-0.02404564432799816,
0.8692014217376709,
0.30706191062927246,
0.2298414409160614,
1.2616275548934937,
-0.22357143461704254,
0.9994951486587524,
0.552347719669342,
-0.40975067019462585,
0.921800971031189,
1.0459346771240234,
-0.10780267417430878,
0.6137984395027161,
0.5357221364974976,
-0.24303728342056274,
-0.16634444892406464,
0.10145537555217743,
-0.1979667991399765,
0.22715933620929718,
0.7852428555488586,
-0.1712656021118164,
-0.3596803843975067,
0.16971096396446228,
0.40529105067253113,
-0.4133560061454773,
-0.3881452977657318,
0.774467408657074,
-0.039025865495204926,
-0.5108605027198792,
-0.1476617306470871,
-0.06071774661540985,
0.3409310281276703,
-0.5205622315406799,
-0.05947175994515419,
-0.2782496213912964,
-0.17141975462436676,
-0.19464296102523804,
-1.0754929780960083,
0.5628117322921753,
-0.03248517960309982,
-0.47821658849716187,
0.10770757496356964,
0.8893203139305115,
-0.11221803724765778,
-0.34940245747566223,
0.3733219504356384,
0.3103085458278656,
0.17723314464092255,
0.4659595787525177,
-0.5393129587173462,
0.35063788294792175,
0.04190502688288689,
-0.5665276646614075,
0.2536409795284271,
0.7828906178474426,
-0.18306013941764832,
0.38136759400367737,
0.3803016245365143,
-0.04034552723169327,
0.6171061992645264,
-0.023358287289738655,
0.7485169768333435,
-1.1030247211456299,
-0.2872932553291321,
-0.8726425766944885,
0.29622095823287964,
-0.2108561396598816,
-0.5887783169746399,
0.6595737934112549,
0.7641882300376892,
0.8084485530853271,
0.24749049544334412,
0.5328091382980347,
-0.3528476059436798,
0.3600284457206726,
-0.9451619982719421,
0.4085730314254761,
-0.4841073155403137,
-0.11333920061588287,
0.19053031504154205,
-0.2263888120651245,
0.11973626911640167,
0.34065091609954834,
0.13482165336608887,
-0.3660163879394531,
0.7023832201957703,
0.3106563985347748,
0.009361659176647663,
0.12035928666591644,
-0.01356512401252985,
0.25432872772216797,
0.2757749557495117,
0.16521239280700684,
1.16364586353302,
0.0169136393815279,
0.6148778200149536,
-0.01292217243462801,
0.09760906547307968,
-0.5542942881584167,
-0.9058319330215454,
-0.7544138431549072,
-1.0032641887664795,
-0.5892844796180725,
-0.4460349380970001,
0.19071808457374573,
0.5831051468849182,
0.43518495559692383,
-0.5746767520904541,
-0.0655127540230751,
0.019676856696605682,
0.33139660954475403,
-0.029399679973721504,
-0.37360525131225586,
0.6328176856040955,
-0.7129651308059692,
-0.6285846829414368,
0.8633745908737183,
0.2655740976333618,
0.008554353378713131,
-0.06885203719139099,
0.1895965188741684,
-0.4450826942920685,
0.3628007471561432,
0.2804294228553772,
0.5522920489311218,
-0.6933733224868774,
-0.5425583720207214,
0.39014196395874023,
-0.21972200274467468,
0.2667069435119629,
0.9298957586288452,
-0.5987665057182312,
0.7762709259986877,
0.6112128496170044,
0.49020108580589294,
1.34740149974823,
-0.38822299242019653,
0.3625447750091553,
-0.8823668956756592,
-0.23454199731349945,
0.021633630618453026,
0.19657009840011597,
0.4226972758769989,
-0.43698176741600037,
0.52894127368927,
0.4122792184352875,
-0.404758483171463,
-0.7482425570487976,
0.3309173882007599,
-0.8631482124328613,
-0.4069932997226715,
1.1102235317230225,
0.1875915378332138,
-0.3797439932823181,
0.0077918414026498795,
0.27905189990997314,
0.48788386583328247,
0.10134073346853256,
0.7636173367500305,
1.2878955602645874,
-0.6163562536239624,
0.10845763981342316,
-0.7429858446121216,
0.5864505171775818,
-0.2699877619743347,
-1.0567594766616821,
-0.22056733071804047,
0.5000004768371582,
0.6482489109039307,
0.17745286226272583,
0.798099935054779,
-0.0016904283547773957,
0.3175322711467743,
0.277092844247818,
-0.23473572731018066,
0.17781132459640503,
-0.30596596002578735,
0.10861940681934357,
-0.22947773337364197,
-0.021724719554185867,
-0.19593624770641327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19102v1 | Statements: Universal Information Extraction from Tables with Large Language Models for ESG KPIs | 2024-06-27T11:28:50 | 2024-06-27T11:28:50 | Lokesh Mishra, Sohayl Dhibi, Yusik Kim, Cesar Berrospi Ramis, Shubham Gupta, Michele Dolfi, Peter Staar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Environment, Social, and Governance (ESG) KPIs assess an organization's
performance on issues such as climate change, greenhouse gas emissions, water
consumption, waste management, human rights, diversity, and policies. ESG
reports convey this valuable quantitative information through tables.
Unfortunately, extracting this information is difficult due to high variability
in the table structure as well as content. We propose Statements, a novel
domain agnostic data structure for extracting quantitative facts and related
information. We propose translating tables to statements as a new supervised
deep-learning universal information extraction task. We introduce SemTabNet - a
dataset of over 100K annotated tables. Investigating a family of T5-based
Statement Extraction Models, our best model generates statements which are 82%
similar to the ground-truth (compared to baseline of 21%). We demonstrate the
advantages of statements by applying our model to over 2700 tables from ESG
reports. The homogeneous nature of statements permits exploratory data analysis
on expansive information found in large collections of ESG reports. | [
-0.16938665509223938,
-0.9095036387443542,
0.5279356241226196,
0.008112877607345581,
-0.2580428719520569,
0.051962219178676605,
-0.2006225734949112,
-0.5553824305534363,
0.09059038758277893,
0.7331926226615906,
-0.20674538612365723,
-0.928954541683197,
-0.8210321068763733,
-0.025596287101507187,
-0.3452351987361908,
1.0836362838745117,
0.3285458981990814,
-0.14093168079853058,
0.0024581928737461567,
-0.005802039988338947,
-0.2210569530725479,
-0.3146228790283203,
-0.27225247025489807,
-0.14953304827213287,
0.35495516657829285,
0.6263783574104309,
0.4863550662994385,
0.6788080930709839,
0.4878975749015808,
0.2807670831680298,
0.13408325612545013,
0.3149046003818512,
-0.2410995066165924,
0.26896533370018005,
-0.06786985695362091,
-0.2114224135875702,
-0.316621333360672,
-0.02992180548608303,
0.4869052469730377,
0.6660752892494202,
-0.3238101601600647,
0.4705570340156555,
0.30103230476379395,
0.7951872944831848,
-0.5108429789543152,
1.0188642740249634,
-0.5713426470756531,
0.2778232991695404,
0.0857049822807312,
0.020901795476675034,
-0.47193360328674316,
-0.5922040343284607,
0.3524094820022583,
-0.3487752377986908,
0.0872400626540184,
-0.011926708742976189,
0.9292217493057251,
0.14074252545833588,
-0.8930085301399231,
-0.6162314414978027,
-0.5259101390838623,
0.5282195210456848,
-0.5925475358963013,
0.4753224551677704,
0.08184070140123367,
0.36759111285209656,
0.02032371051609516,
-1.0035207271575928,
-0.31598302721977234,
-0.1810958832502365,
-0.22168558835983276,
0.18951451778411865,
-0.21830247342586517,
-0.003452403238043189,
0.17876209318637848,
0.022608954459428787,
-0.49427786469459534,
-0.05853389948606491,
-0.37118101119995117,
-0.06279754638671875,
0.7848639488220215,
0.12540921568870544,
0.06796963512897491,
-0.3343375027179718,
-0.4281790256500244,
-0.24613584578037262,
-0.7990155816078186,
-0.08108032494783401,
0.03359677642583847,
0.5905290842056274,
-0.09065065532922745,
0.3421165645122528,
-0.5143195390701294,
0.3595327138900757,
-0.30750349164009094,
0.045100271701812744,
0.10754716396331787,
-0.18742001056671143,
-0.408962219953537,
0.1558336317539215,
0.4238430857658386,
0.43807485699653625,
0.029779711738228798,
-0.6268060207366943,
-0.05721684917807579,
0.09705863893032074,
0.12015601992607117,
-0.9492021203041077,
-0.4043543338775635,
0.10902520269155502,
-0.4379388689994812,
-0.39033713936805725,
0.44267913699150085,
-1.1778007745742798,
-0.5412291288375854,
-0.5309313535690308,
0.22420229017734528,
0.009553306736052036,
0.0053589786402881145,
-0.1681755632162094,
-0.15779712796211243,
0.3885986804962158,
0.4490624666213989,
-0.585594892501831,
0.3100159466266632,
0.5669749975204468,
0.6094440221786499,
-0.2830668091773987,
0.24681980907917023,
-0.5426161885261536,
0.46288880705833435,
-0.21072173118591309,
0.7666314244270325,
-0.61463463306427,
-0.512901782989502,
0.09511452168226242,
0.2309938222169876,
0.18841856718063354,
-0.6038336753845215,
0.5188765525817871,
-0.27063700556755066,
0.044947654008865356,
-0.6998735666275024,
-0.5406241416931152,
-0.08360525965690613,
0.054883696138858795,
-0.5889137983322144,
0.8605254292488098,
-0.1876518428325653,
-0.1601317971944809,
0.6509576439857483,
-0.9131396412849426,
-0.41598352789878845,
0.09467518329620361,
-0.5416523814201355,
-0.40249499678611755,
0.21546213328838348,
0.23224203288555145,
0.5852614045143127,
-0.5401526689529419,
0.8057603240013123,
-0.16337066888809204,
0.2017766386270523,
0.10206962376832962,
-0.26980939507484436,
0.6745075583457947,
0.5606664419174194,
-0.32874947786331177,
-0.04820377007126808,
-0.8995940089225769,
0.28075194358825684,
0.04207583889365196,
-0.5794932842254639,
-0.05203258991241455,
0.24566134810447693,
-0.042108844965696335,
0.026516985148191452,
0.2923787832260132,
-0.5456663370132446,
0.4567180871963501,
0.24282880127429962,
0.4446702003479004,
0.9548248648643494,
0.2514989674091339,
0.3166550397872925,
0.12003699690103531,
0.23408852517604828,
-0.09159743785858154,
0.03220545873045921,
-0.046447306871414185,
-0.17636285722255707,
-0.649949312210083,
-0.03710910677909851,
0.4716666340827942,
0.41615813970565796,
-0.4306124448776245,
0.380991131067276,
-0.48640525341033936,
-0.4565657675266266,
-0.11896182596683502,
-0.18832966685295105,
0.06873646378517151,
0.6996862292289734,
0.3200589120388031,
0.13819727301597595,
-0.5911507606506348,
-1.105143427848816,
-0.6950628161430359,
-0.13468366861343384,
-0.062096189707517624,
0.3071146607398987,
0.8131867051124573,
0.06055239960551262,
0.7518939971923828,
-0.836967408657074,
-0.2644367218017578,
-0.13434496521949768,
0.3930192291736603,
0.22541792690753937,
0.20279084146022797,
0.14915238320827484,
-1.0602221488952637,
-0.6605709195137024,
0.28511926531791687,
-0.9119831919670105,
-0.15815913677215576,
-0.01731550507247448,
0.15844400227069855,
0.06945373117923737,
0.38061803579330444,
-0.44294652342796326,
0.33968091011047363,
0.26872706413269043,
-0.34209391474723816,
0.268675297498703,
0.0748472660779953,
0.1390054076910019,
-1.0686784982681274,
-0.013236328028142452,
0.09161244332790375,
-0.2623717188835144,
-0.5537049174308777,
0.12762266397476196,
0.11697719991207123,
-0.23673947155475616,
-0.17967574298381805,
0.3745620548725128,
-0.5921446084976196,
-0.25593313574790955,
0.3428887128829956,
0.016136838123202324,
0.1627853810787201,
0.561934769153595,
-0.04364168643951416,
0.4777836799621582,
0.4116325080394745,
-0.7604759335517883,
0.4257160425186157,
0.519883394241333,
-0.44933804869651794,
0.4200306236743927,
-0.756808340549469,
0.19914935529232025,
-0.19481892883777618,
0.11495360732078552,
-0.9844338297843933,
-0.47678202390670776,
-0.035430874675512314,
-0.5246604681015015,
0.3258257210254669,
0.06861096620559692,
-0.42583250999450684,
-0.14059793949127197,
-0.1314263492822647,
-0.742020308971405,
0.4514182507991791,
-0.6459965109825134,
0.8024685978889465,
0.8482707142829895,
-0.24681569635868073,
-0.6067284941673279,
-0.8284851312637329,
0.22505520284175873,
-0.30935314297676086,
-0.42102721333503723,
0.07913385331630707,
0.3342055082321167,
-0.2904871702194214,
0.15925189852714539,
-0.7635267972946167,
-0.11979158967733383,
0.2894158661365509,
0.3466753363609314,
0.14657263457775116,
-0.14799724519252777,
0.31072744727134705,
-0.07612068206071854,
0.1686193197965622,
0.22404959797859192,
-0.19310492277145386,
0.26067426800727844,
-0.4733290374279022,
0.06689119338989258,
-0.24090436100959778,
0.44018977880477905,
0.2752997577190399,
-0.0737065002322197,
0.7372288107872009,
0.34675300121307373,
-0.38414087891578674,
-0.16851545870304108,
-0.3499694764614105,
-0.08071845024824142,
-0.45625820755958557,
0.6396810412406921,
-0.3580337464809418,
-0.8021544218063354,
0.6729815602302551,
-0.5110542178153992,
0.28232961893081665,
0.7106711268424988,
-0.0077962870709598064,
-0.22932331264019012,
1.068183422088623,
0.7747983336448669,
0.11601639539003372,
0.23337949812412262,
-0.21910692751407623,
0.142970472574234,
-0.2815886437892914,
-0.6305902004241943,
-0.9725834131240845,
-0.21490314602851868,
-0.5584448575973511,
0.07282904535531998,
0.5924901962280273,
-0.031001925468444824,
-0.31881433725357056,
0.16459056735038757,
-0.4136878252029419,
0.44809943437576294,
0.14636358618736267,
-0.06010451912879944,
0.3433733880519867,
0.26628178358078003,
0.2419532984495163,
-0.09232815355062485,
-0.27376124262809753,
-0.6986443400382996,
1.0215835571289062,
0.22856952250003815,
0.7645843029022217,
0.4798419177532196,
0.757874608039856,
0.8019073009490967,
0.5164790749549866,
-0.5575502514839172,
0.5322090983390808,
-0.2970963418483734,
-0.6005269289016724,
-0.43208178877830505,
-0.8330397605895996,
-0.7786296010017395,
0.4993131756782532,
-0.19992399215698242,
-0.949539065361023,
0.13564617931842804,
-0.11785601079463959,
-0.268772691488266,
0.1927899569272995,
-0.8729222416877747,
0.8111737370491028,
-0.3106614947319031,
0.03650336340069771,
0.03820544853806496,
-0.6161715388298035,
-0.032131362706422806,
-0.06987816095352173,
0.16773439943790436,
-0.24479413032531738,
-0.06972483545541763,
0.7657849788665771,
-0.3444744944572449,
1.0062271356582642,
-0.434929758310318,
-0.023706508800387383,
0.420289546251297,
-0.11465712636709213,
0.9266079068183899,
-0.028922434896230698,
0.011642055585980415,
0.11886388063430786,
0.08605077117681503,
-0.12319491803646088,
-0.657468318939209,
0.4260912537574768,
-0.6903053522109985,
-0.6303337216377258,
-0.442425012588501,
-0.07789438962936401,
-0.33128821849823,
0.14959122240543365,
-0.06810823827981949,
0.4381093382835388,
-0.6161494851112366,
0.8175656795501709,
0.5376284122467041,
-0.3600822985172272,
0.4091600775718689,
0.709088921546936,
-0.060270458459854126,
-0.32265961170196533,
0.7936643362045288,
0.4486851096153259,
0.18793237209320068,
0.3303103446960449,
0.2506842315196991,
-0.6201844215393066,
-0.21025197207927704,
-0.15568973124027252,
-0.2499690055847168,
-0.7503290176391602,
-0.5361525416374207,
-0.8512574434280396,
0.026499401777982712,
-0.6983420848846436,
0.07828465849161148,
-0.16578920185565948,
-0.6784526705741882,
0.031032608821988106,
-0.5018106698989868,
0.10874701291322708,
0.8497502207756042,
-0.18172337114810944,
0.44290170073509216,
-0.8862412571907043,
0.3818720579147339,
0.5201455354690552,
0.0038830398116260767,
-0.35307055711746216,
-0.21940982341766357,
-0.16563431918621063,
0.00037266837898641825,
-0.4243157207965851,
-1.0761393308639526,
0.6391919851303101,
0.47275596857070923,
0.5503836870193481,
0.2923111617565155,
0.0020459690131247044,
0.5966958999633789,
-0.33854764699935913,
0.820746660232544,
0.18572525680065155,
-1.0246036052703857,
0.614682137966156,
-0.26092854142189026,
-0.06232669949531555,
0.5802048444747925,
0.36432796716690063,
-0.6032139658927917,
-0.020898310467600822,
-0.8608560562133789,
-0.8863818049430847,
0.6665047407150269,
-0.07726288586854935,
0.027296297252178192,
-0.03619309514760971,
0.25343000888824463,
0.16817262768745422,
0.6067756414413452,
-0.7642330527305603,
-0.3050510287284851,
0.27445122599601746,
-0.04699144884943962,
0.2595434784889221,
-0.16182392835617065,
-0.1919499784708023,
-0.07875029742717743,
0.4124926030635834,
-0.16029253602027893,
0.09792482107877731,
0.10201679915189743,
-0.08627557009458542,
0.10223180800676346,
0.6685327887535095,
0.12705686688423157,
0.7865568399429321,
-0.23031388223171234,
0.31613612174987793,
0.26441943645477295,
-0.3212127685546875,
-0.05068078637123108,
0.027757974341511726,
-0.30662286281585693,
0.015304813161492348,
0.07396384328603745,
0.5197469592094421,
-0.0835084319114685,
-0.402951717376709,
0.40656372904777527,
-0.10079772025346756,
-0.0687238946557045,
-0.3001914322376251,
-0.1640923172235489,
0.07965049892663956,
0.31095582246780396,
0.4767080247402191,
-0.10722829401493073,
0.32092419266700745,
-0.9478781819343567,
0.5057080984115601,
0.2200307548046112,
-0.40251660346984863,
-0.29397740960121155,
0.8271801471710205,
0.2976009249687195,
0.04575563967227936,
0.5560232996940613,
0.06451651453971863,
-0.289978563785553,
0.9356463551521301,
0.44132646918296814,
0.7690528631210327,
-0.21926331520080566,
0.8536567091941833,
0.41013097763061523,
0.3093529939651489,
-0.2330111414194107,
0.4457184970378876,
-0.14008969068527222,
-0.6012657880783081,
-0.37363141775131226,
-0.5466419458389282,
-0.44023260474205017,
0.3869440257549286,
-0.786525309085846,
0.09663808345794678,
-0.43701061606407166,
0.013757188804447651,
0.2847832441329956,
0.13399259746074677,
-0.8600091338157654,
0.27319830656051636,
0.06220001354813576,
0.5794934034347534,
-0.987187922000885,
0.6239237785339355,
0.2367488294839859,
-0.5523499250411987,
-0.8611700534820557,
-0.3960784375667572,
0.032745689153671265,
-0.8623408675193787,
0.7643515467643738,
0.17565271258354187,
0.24281595647335052,
-0.4406364858150482,
-1.2061327695846558,
-0.6273557543754578,
1.0798301696777344,
0.5808696746826172,
-0.45349958539009094,
-0.13992203772068024,
0.4318433403968811,
0.44031044840812683,
-0.6108934283256531,
-0.3825285732746124,
0.5972766876220703,
0.7931437492370605,
-0.2169909030199051,
-0.3721793591976166,
0.10240890830755234,
-0.04468932002782822,
-0.29095450043678284,
0.30023038387298584,
-0.6907812356948853,
0.7497820854187012,
-0.05514920502901077,
-0.4616442620754242,
-0.3866334855556488,
0.8672639727592468,
-0.11071473360061646,
0.3347974717617035,
0.2580423355102539,
0.33901146054267883,
1.1778700351715088,
-0.3425302505493164,
1.0978271961212158,
-0.06499040871858597,
0.4651043117046356,
1.250749945640564,
-0.2390073835849762,
0.49034374952316284,
0.30235615372657776,
-0.08367741852998734,
0.16060702502727509,
0.5087921619415283,
-0.2710549235343933,
0.6175310015678406,
0.15417742729187012,
-0.12086871266365051,
-0.10008265823125839,
-0.3786265254020691,
-0.3844747245311737,
0.5494983196258545,
0.5372034907341003,
-0.4161674976348877,
-0.3799903392791748,
-0.594468891620636,
-0.013246992602944374,
-0.18234701454639435,
-0.165422260761261,
0.8714756965637207,
0.19391170144081116,
-0.42385047674179077,
-0.020947245880961418,
-0.09812936931848526,
0.0218513123691082,
-0.47744953632354736,
-0.5514090657234192,
-0.19082936644554138,
-0.16868416965007782,
-0.2685341238975525,
-0.8149098753929138,
0.44060975313186646,
0.14121274650096893,
0.1977723240852356,
-0.564439594745636,
0.7275999188423157,
-0.5260114073753357,
-0.1822310984134674,
-0.13930173218250275,
0.8048437833786011,
0.2624179422855377,
-0.2161538451910019,
-0.5484130382537842,
-0.3341304361820221,
0.46189165115356445,
-0.2716234624385834,
0.022268224507570267,
0.7925928831100464,
0.19613130390644073,
0.34609073400497437,
0.34792986512184143,
0.03783414140343666,
-0.134651780128479,
0.0010969690047204494,
0.755395233631134,
-0.8403765559196472,
-0.5870686173439026,
-0.7946032285690308,
0.4952642321586609,
-0.6098271608352661,
-0.2945569157600403,
0.7239096760749817,
0.5949955582618713,
0.6211286187171936,
0.05511673167347908,
1.0935488939285278,
-0.21949586272239685,
0.3454757630825043,
-0.5370842814445496,
0.5137948393821716,
-0.43222180008888245,
0.13351453840732574,
-0.09589078277349472,
-1.1564847230911255,
-0.03547602891921997,
0.4788399338722229,
-0.2370080202817917,
-0.3001254200935364,
0.4112517833709717,
0.5176761150360107,
0.09382428228855133,
0.366364449262619,
0.41055166721343994,
0.46897101402282715,
0.6363908648490906,
0.16368913650512695,
0.7334162592887878,
-0.3796483278274536,
0.6938785910606384,
0.15346424281597137,
0.21054713428020477,
-0.09614956378936768,
-0.769407331943512,
-0.4570521116256714,
-0.6294952034950256,
-0.5290875434875488,
-0.44849860668182373,
-0.05353905260562897,
0.6589333415031433,
0.4403202533721924,
-0.9558320641517639,
0.07474304735660553,
-0.119479238986969,
0.0204913467168808,
0.1560293287038803,
-0.2883296608924866,
0.7852863073348999,
-0.09872838854789734,
-0.41002652049064636,
0.2577916383743286,
0.34622517228126526,
-0.020959360525012016,
0.13055598735809326,
0.1857597976922989,
-0.09116436541080475,
0.02830095775425434,
0.5068802237510681,
0.4706551730632782,
-0.27248960733413696,
-0.6345451474189758,
-0.057861268520355225,
-0.1127236858010292,
0.08733860403299332,
0.5942809581756592,
-0.33368170261383057,
0.1199895441532135,
0.3563016355037689,
0.9628623127937317,
0.7602773308753967,
0.027232710272073746,
0.442746639251709,
-0.9393464922904968,
-0.17962996661663055,
0.10959772765636444,
0.3673725128173828,
0.2618851065635681,
-0.4640856087207794,
1.2096025943756104,
-0.06552308052778244,
-0.5662474036216736,
-0.7491687536239624,
0.3008633852005005,
-0.8732673525810242,
-0.4036470353603363,
1.1566566228866577,
-0.19223618507385254,
-0.35392361879348755,
0.06238194555044174,
0.002596622332930565,
0.26172971725463867,
-0.7675777673721313,
0.8507863283157349,
0.7447996139526367,
-0.24260714650154114,
0.13274803757667542,
-0.7585989832878113,
0.4196418523788452,
0.1693241447210312,
-1.1678029298782349,
0.15367914736270905,
0.7904587388038635,
0.22463536262512207,
0.24444296956062317,
0.49736669659614563,
-0.28249579668045044,
-0.35325172543525696,
0.054161958396434784,
0.12868641316890717,
0.13303998112678528,
-0.5007798075675964,
-0.1963806003332138,
0.6318178176879883,
-0.4900168180465698,
-0.18984557688236237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19097v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19097v1 | Fairness and Bias in Multimodal AI: A Survey | 2024-06-27T11:26:17 | 2024-06-27T11:26:17 | Tosin Adewumi, Lama Alkhaled, Namrata Gurung, Goya van Boven, Irene Pagliai | cs.CL | cs.CL | The importance of addressing fairness and bias in artificial intelligence
(AI) systems cannot be over-emphasized. Mainstream media has been awashed with
news of incidents around stereotypes and bias in many of these systems in
recent years. In this survey, we fill a gap with regards to the minimal study
of fairness and bias in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) compared to Large
Language Models (LLMs), providing 50 examples of datasets and models along with
the challenges affecting them; we identify a new category of quantifying bias
(preuse), in addition to the two well-known ones in the literature: intrinsic
and extrinsic; we critically discuss the various ways researchers are
addressing these challenges. Our method involved two slightly different search
queries on Google Scholar, which revealed that 33,400 and 538,000 links are the
results for the terms "Fairness and bias in Large Multimodal Models" and
"Fairness and bias in Large Language Models", respectively. We believe this
work contributes to filling this gap and providing insight to researchers and
other stakeholders on ways to address the challenge of fairness and bias in
multimodal A!. | [
-0.5268242359161377,
-0.632086455821991,
0.6376652121543884,
0.24382366240024567,
0.2630917727947235,
-0.024881059303879738,
-0.10308665782213211,
-0.6283310055732727,
0.14890585839748383,
0.1159021407365799,
-0.5444800853729248,
-0.04140115901827812,
-0.8313721418380737,
-0.07474258542060852,
-0.3229445517063141,
1.021530032157898,
0.15866634249687195,
0.6005050539970398,
-0.5053940415382385,
-0.5323748588562012,
-0.3366583585739136,
-0.9170313477516174,
-0.5530896186828613,
-0.19524402916431427,
0.6040060520172119,
0.026221053674817085,
0.7368412613868713,
0.19772350788116455,
0.5729581117630005,
0.40703123807907104,
0.045343030244112015,
-0.04301605373620987,
-0.2221280038356781,
0.06020503491163254,
-0.1349925547838211,
-0.5414133667945862,
-0.6569125652313232,
0.34664463996887207,
0.5912912487983704,
0.8709692358970642,
0.12929609417915344,
0.5117889046669006,
-0.03267107903957367,
0.7136377096176147,
-0.8811155557632446,
0.0575716570019722,
-0.34407809376716614,
0.34568625688552856,
-0.5633639693260193,
0.0509842112660408,
-0.2605452239513397,
-0.42876124382019043,
-0.042501844465732574,
-0.6192888021469116,
0.005870486609637737,
0.1578749269247055,
0.4939688444137573,
0.5476785898208618,
-0.721501886844635,
-0.31470394134521484,
-0.6303975582122803,
1.0386638641357422,
-0.5779629349708557,
0.3461848497390747,
0.1951795369386673,
0.35425007343292236,
0.23559267818927765,
-0.4511619210243225,
-0.8328513503074646,
-0.25515031814575195,
-0.033845268189907074,
0.03305007144808769,
-0.1810050904750824,
0.16572068631649017,
0.521594762802124,
0.08232176303863525,
-0.4072522521018982,
0.2521626055240631,
-0.17701728641986847,
-0.4063161313533783,
0.6489692330360413,
0.17012622952461243,
0.2421400398015976,
-0.13158728182315826,
-0.11153673380613327,
-0.056699562817811966,
-0.5629538893699646,
0.19678397476673126,
0.6954028010368347,
-0.08767488598823547,
-0.010284204967319965,
0.6686776280403137,
-0.11656806617975235,
0.4082449674606323,
-0.10034015774726868,
-0.009168031625449657,
0.5677714347839355,
-0.566668689250946,
0.08308422565460205,
-0.060727447271347046,
0.6736899018287659,
0.536207377910614,
0.34954318404197693,
0.0993439108133316,
-0.29766735434532166,
0.35973799228668213,
0.11085064709186554,
-0.5137628316879272,
0.1633775532245636,
0.13871178030967712,
-0.7924308776855469,
-0.04944309592247009,
-0.03259890526533127,
-0.7848774194717407,
-0.587683379650116,
-0.35225996375083923,
0.38507071137428284,
0.16321860253810883,
-0.3405018150806427,
-0.3188403844833374,
-0.01888808235526085,
0.1275889128446579,
0.35387805104255676,
-0.3923928141593933,
0.058944590389728546,
0.554493248462677,
0.5599375367164612,
-0.041325643658638,
-0.27461907267570496,
-0.4258243441581726,
-0.04882936552166939,
-0.07842499017715454,
0.7296203970909119,
-0.6638413667678833,
-0.1555938571691513,
-0.0051497225649654865,
-0.33480846881866455,
0.056798916310071945,
-0.5430662035942078,
0.5251122713088989,
-0.3722124397754669,
0.391656756401062,
-0.32303550839424133,
-0.40361905097961426,
-0.07888898253440857,
0.3908897638320923,
-0.7718946933746338,
0.5288498401641846,
-0.11723201721906662,
-0.7539761662483215,
0.5289232134819031,
-1.0357111692428589,
-0.3926113247871399,
-0.3095909357070923,
-0.5142627358436584,
-0.21628980338573456,
0.22160044312477112,
0.3548263609409332,
0.10199351608753204,
-0.25416043400764465,
0.5764177441596985,
-0.5982797741889954,
-0.17121511697769165,
0.5344473719596863,
-0.7816439867019653,
0.7286096215248108,
0.43653061985969543,
-0.4908495843410492,
0.23795901238918304,
-0.3241346478462219,
-0.09165047109127045,
0.012338703498244286,
0.010581539943814278,
-0.31071898341178894,
0.17837534844875336,
0.1390717476606369,
0.5559422969818115,
0.2858409583568573,
-0.42147693037986755,
-0.0672881007194519,
-0.025442538782954216,
0.3959991931915283,
1.238322138786316,
-0.7099961042404175,
0.8169220685958862,
-0.4483588933944702,
0.548086941242218,
0.266499787569046,
0.5827345252037048,
-0.13062173128128052,
-0.43106311559677124,
-0.713135302066803,
-0.19886808097362518,
0.3074844777584076,
0.3543524444103241,
-0.7014488577842712,
0.06407812237739563,
-0.13243846595287323,
-0.014330619014799595,
-0.7855097055435181,
-0.11338203400373459,
0.4247151017189026,
0.4136093258857727,
0.13505633175373077,
-0.39574581384658813,
-0.3204055726528168,
-1.047549843788147,
-0.27690085768699646,
-0.12176334112882614,
0.07716237753629684,
0.7738342881202698,
0.4895220100879669,
-0.23985330760478973,
1.082680106163025,
-0.09989288449287415,
-0.39136937260627747,
0.0801410898566246,
0.10733533650636673,
-0.015429958701133728,
0.4024432599544525,
0.7707871794700623,
-1.0620253086090088,
-0.14752154052257538,
-0.4815048575401306,
-0.9704571962356567,
-0.1546945571899414,
0.2997128367424011,
0.03676088899374008,
0.29430270195007324,
0.45498883724212646,
-0.5974957942962646,
0.3215097188949585,
0.45051005482673645,
-0.41541969776153564,
0.3262750208377838,
0.17222897708415985,
0.4775475263595581,
-0.6076703071594238,
0.2069486677646637,
0.006170873995870352,
-0.1366845816373825,
-0.4227680265903473,
0.08963408321142197,
-0.15971994400024414,
0.0016518582124263048,
-0.6576362252235413,
0.7785945534706116,
-0.2598003149032593,
-0.36111265420913696,
-0.09551595896482468,
0.14815707504749298,
-0.06270039826631546,
0.411411851644516,
-0.23268933594226837,
0.7158609628677368,
0.44134366512298584,
-0.5808525681495667,
0.32949134707450867,
-0.014106043614447117,
-0.31640130281448364,
0.8598847985267639,
-0.5240773558616638,
0.03554355725646019,
-0.4726121723651886,
0.5895211100578308,
-0.7424570918083191,
0.02999783121049404,
0.4448249042034149,
-0.6388123631477356,
-0.1956164836883545,
0.15815821290016174,
-0.43068286776542664,
-0.286270409822464,
-0.40766721963882446,
1.1391452550888062,
0.3012290596961975,
-0.29888758063316345,
0.6601012349128723,
0.8159744739532471,
-0.360392689704895,
-0.9089217782020569,
-0.41712328791618347,
-0.02965572476387024,
-0.2984118163585663,
-0.6412864327430725,
0.12571537494659424,
-0.32128581404685974,
-0.6100799441337585,
0.07686206698417664,
-0.012538166716694832,
-0.09229222685098648,
0.10148441046476364,
0.17730320990085602,
0.05539105087518692,
-0.19366294145584106,
0.07694624364376068,
-0.08446303009986877,
-0.12460897117853165,
0.06532879173755646,
-0.014747139066457748,
0.5546192526817322,
0.033753253519535065,
-0.6025112271308899,
-0.3946886360645294,
0.5791076421737671,
0.516596794128418,
-0.3455580174922943,
0.3520503044128418,
0.818158745765686,
-0.29371321201324463,
0.26719704270362854,
-0.7370997071266174,
-0.23094050586223602,
-0.4434486925601959,
0.462991863489151,
-0.08123951405286789,
-1.1084765195846558,
0.5178263783454895,
0.32677415013313293,
0.060489241033792496,
0.45695188641548157,
0.5034633874893188,
-0.14115941524505615,
1.5198086500167847,
0.6923249959945679,
-0.4298495054244995,
0.5337924361228943,
0.13491542637348175,
0.25577664375305176,
-0.5227504968643188,
-0.32641130685806274,
-0.7247954607009888,
-0.688646137714386,
-0.6576545834541321,
-0.22591139376163483,
0.4028092324733734,
-0.4075174331665039,
-0.4298149645328522,
-0.5777961611747742,
-0.3094429075717926,
0.22366183996200562,
0.9136096239089966,
-0.0014933476923033595,
0.3063112497329712,
-0.1545943319797516,
0.2877582609653473,
-0.1557994931936264,
-0.6907777786254883,
-0.3593089282512665,
1.277369737625122,
0.3256765902042389,
0.7026840448379517,
0.26950690150260925,
0.33074772357940674,
0.6197865605354309,
0.445186048746109,
-0.4408150911331177,
0.45044082403182983,
-0.138729989528656,
-1.0066709518432617,
-0.37555086612701416,
-0.7672328948974609,
-0.7863190174102783,
0.22840861976146698,
-0.2999930679798126,
-0.38250863552093506,
0.1940123289823532,
0.2587250769138336,
-0.2838019132614136,
0.26277172565460205,
-0.7278839349746704,
0.720072865486145,
-0.46182265877723694,
-0.31925201416015625,
-0.335629940032959,
-0.7300947904586792,
0.49857261776924133,
-0.08340393751859665,
0.8142938613891602,
-0.3031871020793915,
0.046354521065950394,
0.8569796085357666,
-0.23473431169986725,
0.5165141224861145,
-0.4333033561706543,
-0.11524391919374466,
0.14091262221336365,
-0.2828176021575928,
0.20425967872142792,
0.11479299515485764,
0.023420393466949463,
0.22789034247398376,
0.006160408724099398,
-0.5579138994216919,
-0.48764127492904663,
0.5680212378501892,
-0.8855170607566833,
-0.49803367257118225,
-0.8201293349266052,
-0.5588790774345398,
-0.13359934091567993,
0.09969791024923325,
0.14079226553440094,
0.377701073884964,
-0.128949373960495,
0.05768388509750366,
0.6418639421463013,
-0.5386171340942383,
0.5597811341285706,
0.35223904252052307,
-0.2240079790353775,
0.048592597246170044,
0.9137561917304993,
0.14058923721313477,
0.040575284510850906,
0.18626034259796143,
-0.14962227642536163,
-0.3685394525527954,
-0.3153625428676605,
-0.4763491153717041,
-0.08666665107011795,
-0.3959965705871582,
-0.07525626569986343,
-0.7127220034599304,
-0.1270710676908493,
-0.5018757581710815,
0.10846386849880219,
-0.5380885601043701,
-0.42756861448287964,
-0.06025971844792366,
0.23412640392780304,
0.034089844673871994,
0.785622239112854,
-0.18320117890834808,
0.20199710130691528,
-0.5429987907409668,
0.4749380946159363,
0.2814582586288452,
0.4110678732395172,
0.18054386973381042,
-0.3042766749858856,
0.0011436979984864593,
0.2917441725730896,
-0.18982374668121338,
-0.45430684089660645,
0.0006062515312805772,
0.00610333913937211,
0.8152434229850769,
0.4954952895641327,
0.046023204922676086,
0.4514741897583008,
-0.49799680709838867,
0.9672876596450806,
0.2922927737236023,
-0.8266488313674927,
0.25357523560523987,
-0.06480899453163147,
0.1275973618030548,
0.40919777750968933,
0.41865074634552,
-0.44736447930336,
-0.4119070768356323,
-0.37904003262519836,
-0.8920162320137024,
0.6896255612373352,
0.18896034359931946,
0.2731958031654358,
0.09201300889253616,
-0.05435887724161148,
0.0711539164185524,
0.6495116949081421,
-1.0662630796432495,
-0.507983922958374,
-0.1881895363330841,
-0.28146204352378845,
-0.2977549433708191,
-0.22716496884822845,
-0.3108817934989929,
-0.17594213783740997,
0.2883695363998413,
0.03404911234974861,
0.4295509159564972,
-0.11954300850629807,
-0.5726672410964966,
0.2628602981567383,
0.2927930951118469,
0.697519063949585,
0.7577650547027588,
-0.03539370745420456,
0.1222076267004013,
-0.04353770986199379,
-0.40207016468048096,
0.28764793276786804,
0.23129743337631226,
-0.23804329335689545,
-0.18410275876522064,
0.18592610955238342,
0.5431984066963196,
-0.1877470463514328,
-0.9185938835144043,
0.7686094641685486,
-0.17974033951759338,
-0.014580538496375084,
-0.4087531268596649,
-0.14166788756847382,
-0.5023218393325806,
0.49977409839630127,
0.5115471482276917,
0.16296818852424622,
0.34711921215057373,
-0.7452965974807739,
0.008902099914848804,
0.720437228679657,
-0.4472699761390686,
-0.16459427773952484,
0.7276546359062195,
0.45810675621032715,
-0.013060061261057854,
0.6708282828330994,
-0.24192321300506592,
-0.33128416538238525,
0.6803883910179138,
-0.011883518658578396,
0.47061842679977417,
0.04812512919306755,
0.2150673270225525,
-0.23925386369228363,
0.3485056459903717,
0.03564070910215378,
-0.028145717456936836,
0.014739477075636387,
-0.8730810284614563,
-0.3203013837337494,
-0.5333376526832581,
-0.23836614191532135,
-0.07058412581682205,
-0.4325515031814575,
-0.1795768439769745,
-0.2735902667045593,
-0.5128782391548157,
-0.07936171442270279,
-0.15836408734321594,
-0.8663045763969421,
0.2098020613193512,
0.39137470722198486,
0.5626009702682495,
-0.7361191511154175,
0.4300090968608856,
0.6038326025009155,
-0.5765753984451294,
-0.23900437355041504,
-0.22425729036331177,
0.056247010827064514,
-0.6867369413375854,
0.6686940789222717,
0.1455790102481842,
-0.029601730406284332,
-0.3263774812221527,
-0.5879507660865784,
-0.695904016494751,
0.8976994752883911,
0.4256089925765991,
-0.32943081855773926,
-0.25902271270751953,
0.23937952518463135,
0.23823928833007812,
-0.2908366322517395,
0.8142281174659729,
0.4215976595878601,
0.7108516693115234,
-0.49603429436683655,
-1.1148568391799927,
-0.31810852885246277,
-0.46649760007858276,
-0.16536574065685272,
-0.04329494386911392,
-0.832549512386322,
0.9931463599205017,
0.006999988574534655,
0.046572644263505936,
-0.022664928808808327,
0.460027813911438,
0.292715460062027,
0.9066779017448425,
0.6066015958786011,
0.5350111722946167,
0.6870220303535461,
-0.20236913859844208,
0.8566797375679016,
-0.0832282155752182,
0.09385140985250473,
0.9221005439758301,
-0.5417664647102356,
0.1530165821313858,
0.5039354562759399,
-0.29190170764923096,
0.14883209764957428,
0.6164922118186951,
0.2679181396961212,
0.3467130661010742,
0.2019468992948532,
-0.2871112823486328,
-0.06657110899686813,
-0.4822606146335602,
-0.7944528460502625,
0.38128209114074707,
0.15758395195007324,
-0.12360674142837524,
-0.0603443942964077,
0.3303503096103668,
0.0683504045009613,
0.13394618034362793,
-0.7301223278045654,
0.5732329487800598,
-0.011218582279980183,
-0.5472943782806396,
-0.30594661831855774,
0.1348029226064682,
1.2674661874771118,
-0.5087698698043823,
0.08897306770086288,
-0.5949917435646057,
0.08027105033397675,
-0.07513948529958725,
-0.730394184589386,
0.10153514891862869,
-0.008713511750102043,
-0.4280526041984558,
-0.2963346242904663,
0.4026394486427307,
-0.10349851101636887,
-0.5123564600944519,
0.2444647252559662,
0.7928651571273804,
0.07184459269046783,
-0.12274271249771118,
-0.6928731203079224,
0.18680553138256073,
-0.2511969208717346,
-0.11716939508914948,
0.39816394448280334,
0.3554591238498688,
-0.2333143800497055,
0.9034218192100525,
0.46779343485832214,
-0.09955617040395737,
0.43044576048851013,
0.165995791554451,
0.7280514240264893,
-0.7018678784370422,
-0.3689199388027191,
-0.7971450090408325,
0.43851450085639954,
-0.10866973549127579,
-0.2309611588716507,
0.6917446255683899,
0.5146937966346741,
0.9573851823806763,
0.1098124235868454,
0.8833754658699036,
-0.1826997697353363,
0.32309064269065857,
-0.4831230938434601,
0.8298540711402893,
-0.8257543444633484,
-0.04109053686261177,
-0.6031966805458069,
-0.9745177030563354,
-0.15959106385707855,
0.4920862019062042,
-0.2345506101846695,
0.6997185349464417,
0.31984782218933105,
0.712610125541687,
0.007416306994855404,
-0.1374141275882721,
0.17558082938194275,
0.2625437080860138,
0.22859284281730652,
0.4841032028198242,
1.237177848815918,
-0.0888446718454361,
0.3868953287601471,
0.16534997522830963,
-0.3779762089252472,
-0.2803725302219391,
-0.6737346649169922,
-0.5083332657814026,
-0.3916913568973541,
-0.06499475240707397,
-0.13866636157035828,
0.2792681157588959,
0.786517322063446,
0.7004640698432922,
-0.6721026301383972,
-0.21047258377075195,
0.5072092413902283,
0.5321688652038574,
0.1125740110874176,
-0.1466580033302307,
0.13533715903759003,
-0.28238430619239807,
-0.8931378126144409,
-0.1650518774986267,
0.09459636360406876,
-0.28638607263565063,
-0.32919490337371826,
-0.2569757401943207,
-0.1620253622531891,
0.06171872094273567,
0.8423793911933899,
0.0983908399939537,
-0.4653496742248535,
-0.40448400378227234,
0.008473222143948078,
-0.1701568067073822,
-0.0659661591053009,
0.8802466988563538,
-0.7265616655349731,
0.2906741201877594,
0.41397812962532043,
0.45545437932014465,
0.12285370379686356,
-0.20479407906532288,
0.4716181755065918,
-0.5160173773765564,
0.33498576283454895,
0.3727530837059021,
0.33240631222724915,
0.14860406517982483,
-0.05984491854906082,
0.2633393406867981,
0.3142942190170288,
-0.5876153707504272,
-0.8967229127883911,
0.50003582239151,
-0.7248607277870178,
-0.3386729657649994,
0.8764635324478149,
0.23510411381721497,
0.12064719200134277,
0.013157106004655361,
-0.06926948577165604,
0.15608465671539307,
-0.3889082670211792,
0.7054756879806519,
0.6660431027412415,
-0.15026091039180756,
-0.117548368871212,
-0.6865315437316895,
0.35956084728240967,
0.5558255314826965,
-0.6766476035118103,
-0.3795926868915558,
0.7975788116455078,
-0.04304303973913193,
0.0661754310131073,
0.967630922794342,
-0.24807873368263245,
0.27110910415649414,
-0.2608542740345001,
0.11094854027032852,
0.14425908029079437,
-0.45167019963264465,
-0.2867770791053772,
0.14033637940883636,
-0.01474757306277752,
0.010428696870803833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00108v1 | A Case Study on Contextual Machine Translation in a Professional Scenario of Subtitling | 2024-06-27T11:20:14 | 2024-06-27T11:20:14 | Sebastian Vincent, Charlotte Prescott, Chris Bayliss, Chris Oakley, Carolina Scarton | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Incorporating extra-textual context such as film metadata into the machine
translation (MT) pipeline can enhance translation quality, as indicated by
automatic evaluation in recent work. However, the positive impact of such
systems in industry remains unproven. We report on an industrial case study
carried out to investigate the benefit of MT in a professional scenario of
translating TV subtitles with a focus on how leveraging extra-textual context
impacts post-editing. We found that post-editors marked significantly fewer
context-related errors when correcting the outputs of MTCue, the context-aware
model, as opposed to non-contextual models. We also present the results of a
survey of the employed post-editors, which highlights contextual inadequacy as
a significant gap consistently observed in MT. Our findings strengthen the
motivation for further work within fully contextual MT. | [
-0.3630000650882721,
-0.3778490722179413,
0.46954360604286194,
-0.3238949179649353,
-0.6214639544487,
0.013023515231907368,
-0.056132007390260696,
-0.31795579195022583,
0.10727769136428833,
0.7349213361740112,
-0.3841795325279236,
-0.4346593916416168,
-0.9966537952423096,
0.23680278658866882,
-0.5410441756248474,
1.0963335037231445,
-0.49163660407066345,
0.09233634918928146,
-0.12402952462434769,
-0.3983888626098633,
-1.069407343864441,
-0.7995530962944031,
-0.2944892942905426,
-0.23482270538806915,
0.4714859127998352,
0.13254277408123016,
0.8343157172203064,
0.7598775029182434,
0.6873168349266052,
0.19304780662059784,
0.29958683252334595,
0.4387257993221283,
-0.10707789659500122,
0.09593890607357025,
-0.3096713125705719,
-0.43911033868789673,
-0.590047299861908,
0.19796736538410187,
0.2759217619895935,
0.6755988597869873,
0.29395779967308044,
0.3110589385032654,
0.14133808016777039,
0.5353237986564636,
-0.5120341181755066,
-0.08910557627677917,
-0.4595973491668701,
0.2882920205593109,
-0.20066826045513153,
-0.7946549654006958,
-0.5307736396789551,
0.25835227966308594,
0.0266107227653265,
-0.5480432510375977,
0.06920859962701797,
0.043437641113996506,
1.0357524156570435,
0.794514000415802,
-0.7453007698059082,
-0.04600974917411804,
-0.8026507496833801,
0.48352140188217163,
-0.4692193865776062,
0.31102851033210754,
0.30027928948402405,
0.3235666751861572,
-0.04309207201004028,
-0.8837196230888367,
-0.33954688906669617,
0.34255480766296387,
-0.34948089718818665,
0.3832700550556183,
-0.0650516003370285,
-0.09514583647251129,
0.024603471159934998,
0.2801492512226105,
-0.025007829070091248,
0.09817884117364883,
-0.30858126282691956,
-0.009900148026645184,
0.21555756032466888,
0.20609882473945618,
0.4102587103843689,
-0.15932394564151764,
-0.06351961940526962,
0.08128971606492996,
-0.8230526447296143,
-0.02835065871477127,
0.055766090750694275,
-0.1331346333026886,
0.19977957010269165,
0.7648950815200806,
0.025274241343140602,
0.4048568606376648,
-0.22483524680137634,
0.2181275337934494,
0.09041109681129456,
-0.44719141721725464,
-0.45691099762916565,
0.20067457854747772,
0.2664349377155304,
0.8572540879249573,
0.1626770943403244,
-0.03712233901023865,
-0.24696260690689087,
0.00957493670284748,
0.35571199655532837,
-0.3190614879131317,
-0.1621807962656021,
0.1408797800540924,
-0.29255256056785583,
0.07297436892986298,
0.2581688463687897,
-0.0640246793627739,
-0.38006171584129333,
-0.69638991355896,
0.39785754680633545,
-0.053251732140779495,
0.0072244564071297646,
-0.25531265139579773,
-0.4111696183681488,
0.18901032209396362,
0.45630785822868347,
-0.422751784324646,
-0.24961820244789124,
0.5937706232070923,
0.8905808925628662,
0.05356932058930397,
-0.18860715627670288,
-0.8807432651519775,
0.4066769778728485,
-0.698071300983429,
0.7673987150192261,
-0.28991106152534485,
-0.39047306776046753,
-0.12295383960008621,
0.24453389644622803,
0.05296573042869568,
-0.6235694289207458,
0.632742166519165,
-0.6068952083587646,
0.2450961023569107,
-0.2703233063220978,
-0.057926736772060394,
-0.08813786506652832,
-0.018786368891596794,
-0.43666625022888184,
0.7570101618766785,
0.18907244503498077,
-0.7136339545249939,
0.8347151875495911,
-0.596777081489563,
-0.6189966201782227,
-0.13716603815555573,
0.10032365471124649,
-0.18797849118709564,
0.4784436821937561,
0.38222673535346985,
0.42797407507896423,
-0.01521134003996849,
0.6666439175605774,
0.1070471778512001,
-0.4165116548538208,
0.3454643487930298,
-0.45263272523880005,
0.3187081515789032,
0.3306986391544342,
-0.38845860958099365,
0.29828542470932007,
-0.08357911556959152,
-0.45359373092651367,
-0.5286865830421448,
-0.2603383958339691,
-0.5610198974609375,
-0.14319749176502228,
0.1034809872508049,
0.5103261470794678,
-0.16269050538539886,
-0.27826425433158875,
0.0291459821164608,
-0.012000635266304016,
0.4802548885345459,
0.6180817484855652,
-0.0198053065687418,
0.5017252564430237,
-0.17612941563129425,
0.5573868751525879,
0.18397055566310883,
-0.022273773327469826,
-0.4313933849334717,
-0.211588054895401,
-0.8324960470199585,
-0.3034120500087738,
0.772686779499054,
0.7130988240242004,
-1.2275924682617188,
0.16905179619789124,
-0.4057301878929138,
-0.057944271713495255,
-0.9304423928260803,
-0.059517547488212585,
0.3107866644859314,
0.6251148581504822,
0.41439932584762573,
-0.44933104515075684,
-0.967198371887207,
-0.9400290846824646,
-0.4981851279735565,
0.5470277667045593,
-0.32518595457077026,
0.2322477549314499,
0.32436585426330566,
-0.7041161060333252,
1.090153455734253,
-0.256780743598938,
-0.654168963432312,
-0.1258714497089386,
0.13983839750289917,
0.375875324010849,
0.6356045007705688,
0.20828752219676971,
-0.5955243110656738,
-0.7682084441184998,
0.27478042244911194,
-1.0641380548477173,
-0.42181292176246643,
-0.22530291974544525,
-0.4014088809490204,
0.4699248969554901,
0.6317452788352966,
-0.6595392823219299,
0.4485146999359131,
0.6040780544281006,
0.06924953311681747,
0.5386947989463806,
-0.5783224105834961,
0.6785701513290405,
-1.0278769731521606,
0.25686103105545044,
-0.12454064190387726,
-0.6004961133003235,
-0.44354358315467834,
0.024455716833472252,
-0.11201605945825577,
-0.12730346620082855,
-0.650230348110199,
0.20483456552028656,
-0.3824443817138672,
-0.3833148777484894,
-0.2632163166999817,
0.28245124220848083,
0.25912272930145264,
0.20301304757595062,
0.25069451332092285,
0.8748993277549744,
0.10011567920446396,
-0.5709344148635864,
0.03712267056107521,
0.12624485790729523,
-0.4741150438785553,
0.7753888368606567,
-0.4037015736103058,
-0.021300094202160835,
-0.2414316087961197,
0.5647249221801758,
-0.859255850315094,
-0.41069164872169495,
0.14144869148731232,
-0.5163936614990234,
0.4080105423927307,
-0.11473143100738525,
-0.6582868695259094,
-0.013596586883068085,
0.03324538841843605,
-0.08514481037855148,
0.3724985718727112,
-0.3224779963493347,
0.17699716985225677,
0.5568695664405823,
-0.20920194685459137,
-0.41730615496635437,
-1.0210301876068115,
0.6913471817970276,
-0.40708163380622864,
-0.536264181137085,
0.44580990076065063,
0.2987670600414276,
-0.13350161910057068,
-0.019100643694400787,
-0.32313287258148193,
-0.23908883333206177,
0.15647336840629578,
-0.155225932598114,
0.047092895954847336,
-0.19725985825061798,
-0.2581872045993805,
0.6089757084846497,
-0.43677428364753723,
-0.16105884313583374,
-0.29136690497398376,
0.2357611209154129,
0.31505087018013,
0.15997706353664398,
-0.7377235293388367,
0.6329175233840942,
0.6153069734573364,
-0.32112956047058105,
0.8178808093070984,
0.640419065952301,
-0.37955740094184875,
0.1666305512189865,
-0.30717921257019043,
-0.051015254110097885,
-0.4105696976184845,
0.40097978711128235,
-0.5479930639266968,
-0.6001463532447815,
0.3576950132846832,
-0.15773174166679382,
0.04079192131757736,
0.6180759072303772,
-0.01814934052526951,
-0.6094191670417786,
1.2836260795593262,
0.4778924882411957,
0.5517181158065796,
0.6383441686630249,
-0.22289402782917023,
0.34477025270462036,
-1.4037014245986938,
-0.010513748973608017,
-0.1547773778438568,
-0.31722307205200195,
-0.35321322083473206,
-0.3553566634654999,
0.8013339638710022,
0.28581371903419495,
0.2445363998413086,
0.8662773966789246,
-0.3423055410385132,
0.38119179010391235,
0.4033239781856537,
0.09342721104621887,
0.5461917519569397,
-0.14551448822021484,
-0.04208056256175041,
-0.4295825958251953,
-0.8034777641296387,
-1.006293773651123,
0.5968337059020996,
0.2537175118923187,
0.1447516232728958,
0.1706463098526001,
0.10056819766759872,
0.7351941466331482,
0.8662489652633667,
-0.49858272075653076,
0.13944615423679352,
-0.40559157729148865,
-0.6142916679382324,
-0.20335277915000916,
-0.1822669953107834,
-0.8742787837982178,
0.5361243486404419,
-0.06829656660556793,
-0.3395547568798065,
0.18087022006511688,
0.30062365531921387,
-0.14734022319316864,
0.14690756797790527,
-0.8370675444602966,
1.2122728824615479,
-0.04123471677303314,
-0.30996426939964294,
-0.14562663435935974,
-0.8719143271446228,
0.16804200410842896,
-0.28272169828414917,
0.6436861753463745,
0.254410058259964,
-0.08289866894483566,
0.4600222110748291,
-0.4990711808204651,
0.5577356815338135,
-0.051504846662282944,
-0.10473959892988205,
0.2795211970806122,
0.3207832872867584,
0.2891097664833069,
-0.02750125341117382,
-0.14676958322525024,
0.20739150047302246,
0.34439995884895325,
-0.11548013985157013,
-0.41689005494117737,
0.31066107749938965,
-0.558111846446991,
-0.8493943214416504,
-0.32077404856681824,
-0.5119692087173462,
-0.007146154064685106,
0.41626662015914917,
0.5347942113876343,
0.6347671747207642,
0.266402930021286,
0.6661567091941833,
0.43016132712364197,
-0.336100310087204,
0.39987993240356445,
0.3160301744937897,
0.1099061444401741,
-0.527301013469696,
0.5544260144233704,
0.5062082409858704,
0.1638045758008957,
0.5533788800239563,
0.0151599096134305,
-0.23328842222690582,
-0.42074060440063477,
-1.0879473686218262,
-0.26295003294944763,
-1.0391709804534912,
-0.1904187649488449,
-0.753189742565155,
0.13179486989974976,
-0.4639788866043091,
-0.6320261359214783,
-0.32145893573760986,
-0.25486627221107483,
-0.2014070302248001,
-0.2136932909488678,
-0.1446184664964676,
0.4156814515590668,
0.04803204536437988,
0.6024731993675232,
-1.0474207401275635,
0.0675666481256485,
-0.20605814456939697,
0.09798511862754822,
-0.4957026243209839,
-0.7570170164108276,
-0.8105587959289551,
0.13484103977680206,
-0.32257309556007385,
-0.5490646362304688,
0.6093479990959167,
0.04268324375152588,
0.5653514862060547,
-0.18638041615486145,
0.13781768083572388,
0.7911336421966553,
-0.7261137962341309,
0.887273907661438,
-0.03978201374411583,
-1.261027455329895,
0.31952857971191406,
-0.5597640872001648,
0.6900218725204468,
0.5838454365730286,
0.3205515444278717,
-0.9401994943618774,
-0.3198411762714386,
-0.25951260328292847,
-0.9113377332687378,
0.6182621717453003,
0.17117920517921448,
0.26068422198295593,
0.04992608726024628,
0.33082276582717896,
0.2762000262737274,
0.6652743220329285,
-0.5927008390426636,
-0.05555452033877373,
-0.2234453707933426,
0.06841834634542465,
-0.4862893223762512,
-0.0389011912047863,
0.04439835250377655,
-0.21843087673187256,
0.6859164834022522,
0.2377246618270874,
0.08909246325492859,
0.650326132774353,
-0.6560457944869995,
0.05608111247420311,
0.2978580892086029,
0.6846159100532532,
0.6544061303138733,
-0.16803985834121704,
0.3709336221218109,
0.2504175305366516,
0.02214951068162918,
-0.05614178627729416,
-0.36871668696403503,
-0.030441969633102417,
0.24760226905345917,
0.5023375749588013,
0.6915552020072937,
0.07227986305952072,
-0.5226971507072449,
0.2739024758338928,
0.294757217168808,
0.016352057456970215,
-0.14683252573013306,
-0.3667081892490387,
-0.29020002484321594,
-0.1224810779094696,
0.3703187108039856,
0.4951339364051819,
0.45507481694221497,
-0.8054757118225098,
0.4006009101867676,
0.03571484982967377,
-0.6768296360969543,
-0.2590603232383728,
0.9887236952781677,
0.557583212852478,
-0.4232003390789032,
0.11036716401576996,
0.11994753777980804,
-0.6998730301856995,
0.5064754486083984,
0.4076780378818512,
0.762865424156189,
0.0023892915342003107,
-0.05504252761602402,
-0.039518456906080246,
0.5355610251426697,
0.011004273779690266,
-0.4300214648246765,
-0.03535302355885506,
-0.2698049247264862,
-0.6290549039840698,
-0.15705181658267975,
-0.45432236790657043,
-0.2951892912387848,
-0.40764370560646057,
0.4397802948951721,
-0.013042023405432701,
-0.42008471488952637,
-0.3493785560131073,
-0.4638175368309021,
-0.5141599178314209,
0.4575766921043396,
-0.1094704270362854,
0.44398975372314453,
-0.6647652387619019,
1.0167824029922485,
0.7737606763839722,
-0.29208409786224365,
-0.36639299988746643,
-0.19295793771743774,
-0.3203374743461609,
-0.0665212944149971,
0.6330921053886414,
0.4862811267375946,
-0.43493208289146423,
0.16141998767852783,
0.12265438586473465,
-0.7263632416725159,
1.0099945068359375,
0.3338165581226349,
-0.26124462485313416,
0.261643648147583,
0.30935004353523254,
0.8900526762008667,
-0.5561691522598267,
0.06307470798492432,
0.6043474078178406,
0.3215544819831848,
-0.16177622973918915,
-1.0285757780075073,
0.06524443626403809,
-0.1656002253293991,
0.0055682966485619545,
0.2846030592918396,
-0.4185570180416107,
0.31570059061050415,
0.25413864850997925,
-0.37872177362442017,
-0.267210453748703,
0.3021722137928009,
-0.2924138009548187,
0.45079270005226135,
0.26042991876602173,
0.08775685727596283,
0.25419074296951294,
-0.004336027894169092,
1.2575668096542358,
-0.25639715790748596,
0.05960199981927872,
1.2624273300170898,
-0.00041017457260750234,
0.7390316128730774,
0.7831379175186157,
0.20856094360351562,
0.4916127920150757,
0.8974125981330872,
0.4680176079273224,
0.5612877011299133,
-0.19931700825691223,
-0.06104646250605583,
-0.16601860523223877,
-0.48809635639190674,
-0.4799966514110565,
0.24334390461444855,
0.2666955590248108,
-0.6575683355331421,
0.30448442697525024,
0.09468597173690796,
0.09489195048809052,
0.26646822690963745,
-0.13754834234714508,
0.5385039448738098,
0.3452552855014801,
-1.0168198347091675,
0.36002564430236816,
0.3574831187725067,
0.5421648621559143,
-0.1625702828168869,
0.14250391721725464,
-0.2219248116016388,
0.1337263137102127,
-0.3517405092716217,
-0.7537814378738403,
1.184682011604309,
0.14799249172210693,
-0.2101384550333023,
-0.6600722670555115,
0.1860121339559555,
-0.358962744474411,
-0.15341050922870636,
-0.016681231558322906,
0.3126978576183319,
0.23969323933124542,
-0.23356804251670837,
-0.1331929862499237,
0.06263657659292221,
-0.27631840109825134,
-0.052452538162469864,
0.021832581609487534,
0.5541903972625732,
-0.2110445499420166,
0.13350476324558258,
0.498908668756485,
-0.438902348279953,
-0.10081504285335541,
-0.08183544874191284,
0.405068963766098,
-0.4092443585395813,
-0.4327329993247986,
-0.791664183139801,
0.9845163822174072,
-0.011257150210440159,
-0.2678530812263489,
0.9623907208442688,
0.6730536222457886,
0.992676317691803,
-0.3832879960536957,
0.7394365668296814,
0.06156507134437561,
-0.10441731661558151,
-0.5688613653182983,
0.5814769864082336,
-0.6483150124549866,
0.40132981538772583,
-0.5282763838768005,
-0.9802855849266052,
-0.7523698210716248,
0.22272977232933044,
-0.6140983700752258,
-0.49489206075668335,
0.9956714510917664,
0.508622407913208,
-0.116749607026577,
-0.452581524848938,
0.5444799065589905,
-0.1271389126777649,
0.23504337668418884,
0.061912454664707184,
0.5748909115791321,
-0.7784315347671509,
0.567005455493927,
0.05274135246872902,
-0.1308789998292923,
-0.14774471521377563,
-1.082165241241455,
-0.6768838167190552,
-0.33610424399375916,
-0.33469903469085693,
-0.15246346592903137,
0.007008053828030825,
0.7649834156036377,
0.7734512090682983,
-0.5837849378585815,
-0.04418989270925522,
0.15253198146820068,
0.13316138088703156,
-0.39293113350868225,
-0.162533700466156,
0.18364493548870087,
0.0371270477771759,
-0.9887710809707642,
0.27845364809036255,
0.5123376846313477,
-0.17897017300128937,
0.10687961429357529,
0.03306182101368904,
-0.16071926057338715,
0.23749974370002747,
1.0312951803207397,
-0.32156312465667725,
-0.5878960490226746,
-0.3424362540245056,
-0.10405969619750977,
-0.04497512802481651,
0.256442666053772,
0.9170108437538147,
-0.3646520674228668,
0.6196919083595276,
0.4958561360836029,
0.6841437816619873,
0.41191112995147705,
0.11282575875520706,
1.0356706380844116,
-0.7575287818908691,
0.0845242589712143,
-0.3038041889667511,
0.5140161514282227,
0.5063350200653076,
-0.7526450157165527,
0.5280827879905701,
0.45903098583221436,
-0.41106581687927246,
-0.8732919096946716,
0.2916879653930664,
-0.5729860663414001,
-0.22390004992485046,
0.795687735080719,
-0.20006351172924042,
0.04611584171652794,
-0.3401384651660919,
-0.6211909055709839,
0.7629536390304565,
-0.14788863062858582,
0.5480214953422546,
0.7909390330314636,
-0.0726592093706131,
-0.18723136186599731,
-0.9607908129692078,
0.13086123764514923,
0.49191880226135254,
-0.6846276521682739,
-0.1681343913078308,
0.5066230893135071,
0.15301702916622162,
-0.12519000470638275,
0.42750370502471924,
-0.11995892971754074,
0.20417505502700806,
-0.05527481809258461,
-0.09866175800561905,
-0.2815965712070465,
-0.518987774848938,
-0.20960935950279236,
-0.15364688634872437,
-0.11731933057308197,
-0.03145512565970421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19073v1 | AMBROSIA: A Benchmark for Parsing Ambiguous Questions into Database Queries | 2024-06-27T10:43:04 | 2024-06-27T10:43:04 | Irina Saparina, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Practical semantic parsers are expected to understand user utterances and map
them to executable programs, even when these are ambiguous. We introduce a new
benchmark, AMBROSIA, which we hope will inform and inspire the development of
text-to-SQL parsers capable of recognizing and interpreting ambiguous requests.
Our dataset contains questions showcasing three different types of ambiguity
(scope ambiguity, attachment ambiguity, and vagueness), their interpretations,
and corresponding SQL queries. In each case, the ambiguity persists even when
the database context is provided. This is achieved through a novel approach
that involves controlled generation of databases from scratch. We benchmark
various LLMs on AMBROSIA, revealing that even the most advanced models struggle
to identify and interpret ambiguity in questions. | [
-0.39757972955703735,
-1.2118284702301025,
0.5436796545982361,
0.5076241493225098,
-0.22430382668972015,
-0.02455730549991131,
-0.10557762533426285,
-0.8417323231697083,
0.33697229623794556,
0.4077949821949005,
-1.0440281629562378,
-0.44210779666900635,
-0.49525508284568787,
0.39133891463279724,
-0.6901545524597168,
0.24792006611824036,
-0.14727996289730072,
-0.0397353433072567,
-0.2581973373889923,
-0.22664488852024078,
-0.5027499794960022,
-0.46755507588386536,
-0.5615061521530151,
-0.12563106417655945,
0.32437989115715027,
0.2400962859392166,
0.9764547348022461,
0.5132995247840881,
0.45717594027519226,
0.27586933970451355,
-0.19995127618312836,
0.25142017006874084,
-0.10425540059804916,
0.6571663022041321,
-0.3454170525074005,
-0.7532318830490112,
-0.18348006904125214,
-0.3623215854167938,
0.5942204594612122,
1.1269347667694092,
-0.42114701867103577,
0.23928748071193695,
-0.3270937502384186,
0.6354579329490662,
-1.0741474628448486,
-0.3522818684577942,
-0.9562107920646667,
0.3284216523170471,
-0.5443220734596252,
-0.06626438349485397,
-0.27368634939193726,
-0.3681009113788605,
-0.08356934040784836,
-0.778369665145874,
0.2737056612968445,
0.24083641171455383,
1.2440135478973389,
0.36579421162605286,
-0.6837266087532043,
-0.4744066298007965,
-0.541041910648346,
0.5377496480941772,
-0.3827236294746399,
0.48403361439704895,
0.04154185578227043,
0.7514300346374512,
-0.4986063241958618,
-0.7980762124061584,
-0.5659553408622742,
0.212087482213974,
0.02194090187549591,
-0.19920848309993744,
-0.527155339717865,
-0.24695052206516266,
0.26238468289375305,
0.24207095801830292,
-0.5995861291885376,
-0.01537386979907751,
-0.09638437628746033,
-0.06966791301965714,
0.34701061248779297,
0.4272282123565674,
0.187564417719841,
-0.34647896885871887,
-0.35616329312324524,
0.16115467250347137,
-0.7976491451263428,
0.09393414855003357,
0.4894607663154602,
0.13035021722316742,
0.25373658537864685,
0.8620691299438477,
-0.5170688033103943,
1.1603952646255493,
-0.21738378703594208,
0.7154964208602905,
0.12633155286312103,
-0.10620228946208954,
-0.2586635947227478,
0.18188543617725372,
0.7084135413169861,
0.2477867156267166,
0.0726897120475769,
-0.3325355052947998,
-0.04827110096812248,
0.04673583433032036,
0.46713730692863464,
-0.38523435592651367,
0.05042540282011032,
0.29780644178390503,
-0.46785733103752136,
-0.1443457156419754,
-0.09734461456537247,
-0.9806661605834961,
-0.5895059704780579,
-0.15710152685642242,
0.2401132434606552,
-0.3927304148674011,
-0.18422190845012665,
0.11248365789651871,
-0.09318240731954575,
0.13732776045799255,
0.4818735718727112,
-1.2118728160858154,
0.7961934208869934,
0.7897331714630127,
0.5072596669197083,
-0.14744269847869873,
-0.16640715301036835,
-0.24880942702293396,
0.42728888988494873,
-0.39175891876220703,
1.009064793586731,
-0.6904998421669006,
-0.6313620209693909,
-0.154482901096344,
-0.004036799073219299,
-0.17042651772499084,
-0.9171077013015747,
0.6368651390075684,
-0.48509979248046875,
-0.00001862199860624969,
-0.6080764532089233,
-0.6569633483886719,
-0.15772394835948944,
0.32262590527534485,
-0.4451974928379059,
1.058516263961792,
0.21440283954143524,
-0.4776504337787628,
0.611235499382019,
-0.43378543853759766,
-0.10542429238557816,
-0.02912643924355507,
-0.5890291333198547,
-0.1570981740951538,
0.3081451654434204,
0.22602157294750214,
-0.06424551457166672,
-0.6952266097068787,
0.3785977363586426,
-0.6257649064064026,
-0.4935528635978699,
0.578755795955658,
-0.35071325302124023,
0.7588087916374207,
0.2788535952568054,
-0.06315780431032181,
-0.13765013217926025,
-0.8301424980163574,
0.436710387468338,
0.14745424687862396,
-0.29950767755508423,
-0.31380176544189453,
0.2501891255378723,
-0.20614641904830933,
0.059061240404844284,
0.6222976446151733,
-0.5496291518211365,
0.0997437909245491,
-0.5769519805908203,
0.34274330735206604,
0.4196754992008209,
0.18353307247161865,
-0.165228933095932,
-0.03906910866498947,
0.40852802991867065,
0.2790088355541229,
0.15544633567333221,
0.2566888630390167,
-0.5468682050704956,
-0.9012868404388428,
0.09037155658006668,
0.3017154932022095,
0.7046725153923035,
-0.2459903210401535,
0.42906105518341064,
-0.2726922035217285,
-0.40060675144195557,
-0.7128312587738037,
0.11793653666973114,
0.11914992332458496,
0.5771191716194153,
0.5113667249679565,
-0.1720578372478485,
-0.6710699200630188,
-1.1811202764511108,
-0.8963558077812195,
-0.38251423835754395,
-0.23884797096252441,
0.6266952753067017,
0.34099075198173523,
-0.025172356516122818,
1.1177940368652344,
-0.5727238059043884,
-0.04419809952378273,
0.5006905198097229,
0.20965558290481567,
0.4318435490131378,
0.339499294757843,
0.4056240916252136,
-0.8910439014434814,
-0.3164726495742798,
-0.034737616777420044,
-1.0242745876312256,
-0.18329772353172302,
0.2707359790802002,
-0.20255734026432037,
-0.006210171151906252,
0.48508405685424805,
-0.7709835767745972,
0.28175094723701477,
0.298264741897583,
-0.6547085642814636,
0.3257235586643219,
-0.028471393510699272,
0.3501180410385132,
-0.8925546407699585,
0.19843219220638275,
-0.5035523772239685,
-0.02507968246936798,
-0.43683120608329773,
-0.19627141952514648,
0.512198269367218,
-0.2767070233821869,
-0.5238152146339417,
0.3992954194545746,
-0.2941293716430664,
-0.45280691981315613,
0.19984138011932373,
0.2448406219482422,
0.2207576483488083,
0.06786071509122849,
-0.16281801462173462,
0.7847884893417358,
0.44026806950569153,
-0.4694088399410248,
0.5494863390922546,
0.408952921628952,
-0.4454182982444763,
0.8175345063209534,
-0.6156316995620728,
-0.18504613637924194,
0.10380996763706207,
-0.17828400433063507,
-1.1200902462005615,
-0.2809566557407379,
0.364987313747406,
-0.39414530992507935,
0.16987566649913788,
-0.020273949950933456,
-0.5994744896888733,
-0.4489552676677704,
0.18415087461471558,
0.3085757791996002,
0.04285073280334473,
-0.6416365504264832,
0.5662758946418762,
0.17694191634655,
-0.026150181889533997,
-0.8790141940116882,
-0.7468976378440857,
0.2772681713104248,
-0.349284827709198,
-0.8499467372894287,
0.42415913939476013,
0.30970299243927,
-0.2781592607498169,
0.469997763633728,
-0.1797204315662384,
-0.3645915389060974,
0.35454919934272766,
0.28325361013412476,
-0.006770594511181116,
-0.49873435497283936,
0.04998258128762245,
0.4965023100376129,
0.0731169581413269,
0.28823938965797424,
0.10865563154220581,
0.32034575939178467,
-0.16300098598003387,
-0.5842594504356384,
-0.021177614107728004,
0.5688900351524353,
0.060015689581632614,
-0.107674740254879,
0.5363525152206421,
0.13531583547592163,
-0.458746999502182,
-0.02949177473783493,
-0.5327408313751221,
0.20015117526054382,
-0.5010545253753662,
0.09554186463356018,
-0.8200117945671082,
-0.7603397369384766,
0.7264788746833801,
-0.2983913719654083,
-0.22407136857509613,
0.40353572368621826,
0.46029654145240784,
-0.0790473148226738,
1.014033555984497,
0.09133914113044739,
0.4377155601978302,
0.16644853353500366,
0.44539570808410645,
0.06649178266525269,
-0.5827776789665222,
-0.2349482625722885,
-0.7429139614105225,
-0.18262724578380585,
-0.438833087682724,
-0.41463780403137207,
0.2796202600002289,
0.15050193667411804,
-0.061852358281612396,
0.2585471570491791,
-0.39970260858535767,
0.6333116292953491,
0.3091329038143158,
0.014222703874111176,
0.34282049536705017,
-0.2917670011520386,
-0.0845068097114563,
-0.10300075262784958,
-0.14693158864974976,
-0.5246996879577637,
0.9764138460159302,
0.01753801666200161,
0.7483665347099304,
0.6823992133140564,
0.6481449604034424,
0.31902793049812317,
0.024914253503084183,
-0.44645392894744873,
0.5621708631515503,
-0.18415869772434235,
-1.0896836519241333,
-0.10353501886129379,
-0.4002481698989868,
-1.2814443111419678,
0.765392541885376,
-0.3754017651081085,
-1.0567258596420288,
0.559867799282074,
0.19666926562786102,
-0.18847990036010742,
0.03584640473127365,
-0.9811553955078125,
1.2716742753982544,
-0.06056487560272217,
-0.4136543571949005,
-0.00035579450195655227,
-0.6914471983909607,
0.5535242557525635,
-0.08190196007490158,
-0.009607699699699879,
-0.6878823637962341,
-0.5747680068016052,
0.43648892641067505,
-0.3871725797653198,
0.5749973654747009,
-0.30308911204338074,
0.1523846685886383,
0.23087988793849945,
0.24923230707645416,
0.24698007106781006,
0.09150407463312149,
-0.5208624005317688,
0.1412782073020935,
0.47231751680374146,
-0.5589648485183716,
-0.6437528133392334,
0.6894204616546631,
-0.6201234459877014,
-0.6962642669677734,
-0.2663074731826782,
-0.4315565228462219,
-0.5988962054252625,
0.48751726746559143,
0.07352616637945175,
-0.014742516912519932,
-0.5330007076263428,
0.10837522894144058,
0.648246705532074,
-0.17777860164642334,
0.12084772437810898,
0.8395593762397766,
-0.14146138727664948,
-0.004967207089066505,
0.5169229507446289,
-0.00820934772491455,
-0.15818025171756744,
0.5209434628486633,
-0.2948273718357086,
-0.4341985881328583,
-0.4670845866203308,
-0.6428757309913635,
0.011887576431035995,
-0.9164653420448303,
-0.2737031579017639,
-0.7453643083572388,
0.12790876626968384,
-0.407490611076355,
0.06803232431411743,
-0.36201757192611694,
-0.7326077818870544,
-0.4509958326816559,
0.22093702852725983,
0.12381042540073395,
0.49247056245803833,
0.33936217427253723,
0.30036288499832153,
-0.5867229700088501,
0.16270487010478973,
0.14944256842136383,
0.4475404620170593,
-0.41052424907684326,
-0.05216808244585991,
0.19969245791435242,
-0.14306597411632538,
-0.44380995631217957,
-1.3419784307479858,
0.18432138860225677,
0.2945375144481659,
0.6074072122573853,
0.2461843639612198,
-0.0011437556240707636,
0.7907132506370544,
-0.5442370176315308,
0.7696093916893005,
0.00493198586627841,
-1.184398889541626,
0.8485749363899231,
-0.23415765166282654,
0.1990005522966385,
0.861230194568634,
0.3788405656814575,
-0.40700820088386536,
-0.4197389483451843,
-0.4785807430744171,
-0.9673195481300354,
0.6660455465316772,
0.10641270130872726,
-0.14699850976467133,
-0.04176518693566322,
0.573036789894104,
0.12122242152690887,
0.49616262316703796,
-0.42219048738479614,
-0.4122976064682007,
-0.07827217131853104,
-0.13630184531211853,
0.09984420984983444,
-0.3743855357170105,
-0.14596551656723022,
0.09875953197479248,
0.24269483983516693,
0.10411732643842697,
0.19120128452777863,
0.03202300891280174,
-0.1272570788860321,
-0.3598054349422455,
0.41070136427879333,
0.2726882994174957,
0.8441526293754578,
-0.5327861309051514,
0.24182045459747314,
0.40213921666145325,
-0.10577880591154099,
0.1386968493461609,
0.36122366786003113,
0.025809399783611298,
0.1782645732164383,
0.0019040118204429746,
0.6345663666725159,
0.3322722911834717,
-0.9698768854141235,
0.45298153162002563,
-0.44428423047065735,
-0.1056118905544281,
-0.3947250247001648,
0.35779955983161926,
0.14165420830249786,
0.08760868012905121,
0.1138487383723259,
-0.05670289322733879,
0.5678185820579529,
-0.29777032136917114,
0.2272683084011078,
0.4144915044307709,
-0.40020427107810974,
0.15890730917453766,
0.8293760418891907,
0.06479717046022415,
-0.07440266013145447,
0.6417734622955322,
0.042675863951444626,
0.05656438693404198,
0.4880800247192383,
0.5431393384933472,
0.4670208990573883,
-0.34944549202919006,
-0.23273231089115143,
0.03828658163547516,
0.27681252360343933,
0.5167721509933472,
0.7766686677932739,
-0.17038652300834656,
-0.6595607399940491,
0.1333160698413849,
-0.5819252133369446,
-0.8693546056747437,
-0.39968982338905334,
-1.0520069599151611,
0.4509948790073395,
-0.34993603825569153,
-0.3339088559150696,
0.5194632411003113,
0.007719071581959724,
-0.39609000086784363,
0.21372444927692413,
-0.028499294072389603,
1.222184181213379,
-0.8817428946495056,
0.9343713521957397,
0.8224380612373352,
-0.15429051220417023,
-0.26926329731941223,
-0.3497411906719208,
0.17489303648471832,
-0.9985986351966858,
0.36208781599998474,
0.0741434171795845,
0.16936147212982178,
-0.23470008373260498,
-0.11415337026119232,
-0.9361801743507385,
0.959872305393219,
0.5665687322616577,
-0.2934451997280121,
-0.18542785942554474,
0.39948907494544983,
0.44181397557258606,
-0.31411290168762207,
0.13721978664398193,
0.8067302703857422,
0.4549245238304138,
0.10315950214862823,
-0.5309457182884216,
0.2152523398399353,
-0.342558354139328,
0.14047172665596008,
0.6670531630516052,
-0.33124399185180664,
0.9164674282073975,
0.1271289587020874,
-0.18441595137119293,
0.31139037013053894,
0.7271307706832886,
0.14816436171531677,
0.41690993309020996,
0.5212053060531616,
0.5537833571434021,
1.1225950717926025,
-0.45774877071380615,
0.971544623374939,
-0.22200988233089447,
0.17077763378620148,
1.258634328842163,
-0.4085007905960083,
1.062046766281128,
0.8001344203948975,
-0.43207865953445435,
0.6156832575798035,
1.0300652980804443,
-0.12431184947490692,
0.29714328050613403,
0.33371368050575256,
-0.49480947852134705,
-0.2890413999557495,
-0.16810813546180725,
-0.6569164991378784,
0.3078373670578003,
1.06699538230896,
-0.24880991876125336,
-0.6556119322776794,
-0.33745571970939636,
-0.17057274281978607,
0.10218048095703125,
0.2526056468486786,
0.6551669836044312,
-0.07297489792108536,
-0.7936574816703796,
0.674583911895752,
0.12978103756904602,
0.07862594723701477,
-0.7930743098258972,
0.2061586230993271,
-0.018281739205121994,
0.037478018552064896,
-0.2722283601760864,
-0.8712746500968933,
0.5197557210922241,
-0.050039857625961304,
-0.10799666494131088,
0.24562165141105652,
0.6601775884628296,
-0.19041647017002106,
-0.2127830684185028,
0.3030621409416199,
0.4778922498226166,
0.3662295937538147,
0.09175880998373032,
-1.1630942821502686,
0.38935917615890503,
-0.1054777055978775,
-0.296791136264801,
0.17204146087169647,
0.8736838698387146,
0.022113025188446045,
0.6660897135734558,
0.22832171618938446,
-0.034784507006406784,
0.4937274158000946,
-0.15108104050159454,
0.949043333530426,
-0.7784304618835449,
-0.27936044335365295,
-0.645544707775116,
0.0699440985918045,
-0.2438400536775589,
-0.5283662676811218,
0.8232811093330383,
0.7256300449371338,
0.39951470494270325,
0.08394978195428848,
0.40192750096321106,
-0.3349507451057434,
0.7118741869926453,
-0.5730754137039185,
0.20779410004615784,
-0.853899359703064,
0.5540784001350403,
-0.029638906940817833,
-0.8882215619087219,
-0.3005111813545227,
0.2936849594116211,
-0.44222337007522583,
-0.11015897244215012,
0.6409246325492859,
0.8255531191825867,
-0.17417006194591522,
0.4759055972099304,
0.26166486740112305,
0.1328575164079666,
0.27096349000930786,
0.6968287229537964,
1.1759772300720215,
-0.3827049732208252,
0.5498130321502686,
-0.26830872893333435,
-0.031469620764255524,
-0.31583932042121887,
-0.859623372554779,
-0.5261515974998474,
-0.3014906942844391,
-0.15019191801548004,
-0.37918293476104736,
0.42671847343444824,
0.7036986947059631,
0.5110535621643066,
-0.9289684891700745,
-0.361804336309433,
-0.19903746247291565,
0.3049294352531433,
-0.18076451122760773,
-0.21682776510715485,
0.1694522649049759,
-0.5915586352348328,
-0.6452186703681946,
0.4879993200302124,
0.25576919317245483,
0.12352177500724792,
0.016178492456674576,
0.3846166431903839,
-0.3615548014640808,
0.04420396313071251,
0.15213146805763245,
0.4219617247581482,
-0.6971564292907715,
-0.026749856770038605,
-0.23228101432323456,
0.038120336830616,
0.09720207005739212,
0.7048134207725525,
-0.5842809081077576,
0.6590251922607422,
0.26638534665107727,
0.6501887440681458,
0.6131532788276672,
0.1825014352798462,
0.6346145272254944,
-0.969651997089386,
0.19920511543750763,
0.23280970752239227,
0.30518874526023865,
0.16882260143756866,
-0.4409882128238678,
0.6139507293701172,
0.10159927606582642,
-0.344833105802536,
-0.9606261253356934,
0.29004329442977905,
-0.9557768702507019,
-0.5341676473617554,
0.5760393738746643,
-0.19368720054626465,
-0.4737422466278076,
-0.20516808331012726,
0.02399539202451706,
-0.03608233854174614,
-0.218876451253891,
0.46287044882774353,
0.7190781235694885,
-0.602287232875824,
0.1783919781446457,
-0.7031911015510559,
0.3859964609146118,
0.9481082558631897,
-0.8804298639297485,
0.27781540155410767,
0.564504086971283,
0.042979493737220764,
-0.04045388102531433,
0.5433985590934753,
-0.2611057460308075,
0.42165809869766235,
0.15177012979984283,
-0.3645689785480499,
0.38668376207351685,
0.011128603480756283,
-0.2049858421087265,
0.3465234935283661,
0.3252295255661011,
-0.14713482558727264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19071v1 | EmPO: Theory-Driven Dataset Construction for Empathetic Response Generation through Preference Optimization | 2024-06-27T10:41:22 | 2024-06-27T10:41:22 | Ondrej Sotolar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Empathetic response generation is a desirable aspect of conversational
agents, crucial for facilitating engaging and emotionally intelligent
multi-turn conversations between humans and machines. Leveraging large language
models for this task has shown promising results, yet challenges persist in
ensuring both the empathetic quality of the responses and retention of the
generalization performance of the models. In this paper, we propose a novel
approach where we construct theory-driven preference datasets and use them to
align LLMs with preference optimization algorithms to address these challenges.
To measure empathetic response generation, we employ the EmpatheticDialogues
dataset, assessing empathy with the diff-EPITOME and BERTscore metrics, and
evaluate the generalization performance on the MMLU benchmark. We make all
datasets, source code, and models publicly available. | [
-0.6041697263717651,
-0.8505529761314392,
0.6003419160842896,
-0.013348612003028393,
0.015211529098451138,
-0.2638089656829834,
-0.3185802102088928,
-0.05504078418016434,
0.43170198798179626,
0.2571755647659302,
-0.8341219425201416,
-0.14003591239452362,
-0.31062427163124084,
0.3339678645133972,
0.26272502541542053,
0.7756906151771545,
0.0065919021144509315,
0.07806214690208435,
-0.40025556087493896,
-0.14010128378868103,
0.028464650735259056,
-0.6018683314323425,
-0.5245181918144226,
-0.61739581823349,
0.4725315570831299,
0.5715042352676392,
0.3698395788669586,
0.4997301399707794,
0.2846459746360779,
0.2706315517425537,
0.19948023557662964,
0.5219084620475769,
-0.4696970283985138,
0.3802543580532074,
0.264178067445755,
-0.19414225220680237,
-0.7778943777084351,
0.02563500963151455,
0.1586814522743225,
0.2998199164867401,
-0.3196972608566284,
0.1410513073205948,
0.1354009509086609,
0.5427396893501282,
-0.6110708117485046,
-0.09899993985891342,
-0.5877845287322998,
0.4688047766685486,
0.3583765923976898,
-0.6676455736160278,
-0.4835745096206665,
-0.45314502716064453,
0.17933009564876556,
-0.5631757974624634,
0.11381980776786804,
0.24254177510738373,
0.2804434597492218,
0.23138871788978577,
-0.43085977435112,
-0.48687970638275146,
-0.5810374021530151,
1.0078963041305542,
-0.6523535847663879,
0.1527860015630722,
0.40234270691871643,
0.1484452337026596,
-0.09157630056142807,
-0.16853220760822296,
-0.37756651639938354,
-0.3252211809158325,
0.07824505865573883,
0.2856115400791168,
-0.13175837695598602,
0.17310646176338196,
0.31837406754493713,
0.2632319927215576,
-0.4173697531223297,
0.06172334402799606,
0.2763388156890869,
-0.027024105191230774,
0.6347957253456116,
0.649630606174469,
-0.016932399943470955,
-0.11429693549871445,
0.033103276044130325,
0.09790314733982086,
-0.46149638295173645,
-0.1408991664648056,
0.582855224609375,
0.34699133038520813,
-0.11823196709156036,
0.7137823104858398,
-0.08884128928184509,
0.6642147898674011,
0.34378567337989807,
-0.2027396708726883,
0.2640489339828491,
-0.003723409492522478,
-0.2663148045539856,
-0.0014660105807706714,
0.7522403597831726,
0.6827260851860046,
0.5066294074058533,
0.003914147615432739,
0.014330839738249779,
0.12162589281797409,
0.40076082944869995,
-0.9569103121757507,
0.20998236536979675,
0.6623030304908752,
-0.562123715877533,
-0.7662981748580933,
-0.40538206696510315,
-1.0531229972839355,
-0.25855138897895813,
-0.45163270831108093,
-0.15090155601501465,
-0.3161624073982239,
-0.35192859172821045,
-0.04900406673550606,
0.1050550788640976,
0.29879048466682434,
0.12291737645864487,
-1.2134482860565186,
0.21570613980293274,
0.6469680666923523,
0.7511109113693237,
0.021903634071350098,
-0.23461411893367767,
-0.42872345447540283,
0.3326704502105713,
-0.05513851344585419,
0.7080551385879517,
-0.8044315576553345,
-0.49533459544181824,
0.2248307466506958,
-0.33241787552833557,
0.06700684130191803,
-0.19008472561836243,
0.6573677659034729,
0.04047807678580284,
0.09996504336595535,
-0.23498466610908508,
-0.8385480642318726,
0.292585551738739,
0.7504352331161499,
-0.34924206137657166,
0.61369788646698,
-0.02931918203830719,
-0.7701272964477539,
0.3199259340763092,
-0.8029537200927734,
-0.2702871561050415,
-0.4184865355491638,
-0.22839109599590302,
-0.38893699645996094,
0.3920201361179352,
0.2379993051290512,
0.6962646842002869,
-0.6626308560371399,
0.17387811839580536,
-0.7205369472503662,
0.11321989446878433,
0.4750794768333435,
-0.10313650965690613,
0.23616056144237518,
0.40808847546577454,
-0.026591038331389427,
-0.09284842759370804,
-0.7989524602890015,
0.14626552164554596,
0.27281367778778076,
-0.13215214014053345,
-0.37222447991371155,
0.04949893802404404,
-0.02326030842959881,
0.23484911024570465,
0.16343630850315094,
-0.889254629611969,
0.0022753344383090734,
-0.1654631346464157,
0.3704977333545685,
1.0291674137115479,
-0.13458995521068573,
0.42902806401252747,
-0.2522988021373749,
0.540736734867096,
-0.03996782749891281,
0.5402836203575134,
-0.035035934299230576,
-0.26325008273124695,
-0.5117754936218262,
-0.13783302903175354,
-0.23086193203926086,
0.24813033640384674,
-0.1051059290766716,
0.6644205451011658,
-0.0077263545244932175,
-0.5229254961013794,
-0.6316776871681213,
-0.15076151490211487,
0.452884316444397,
0.7957150340080261,
0.18257717788219452,
-0.03849857673048973,
-0.4194672703742981,
-1.0116043090820312,
-0.1753971427679062,
-0.03006209246814251,
-0.22019974887371063,
1.07149076461792,
-0.00603704247623682,
-0.30069050192832947,
0.9869922399520874,
-0.7848140001296997,
-0.02619927003979683,
-0.07032684236764908,
-0.046556416898965836,
0.017475472763180733,
0.3157634437084198,
0.5547856092453003,
-0.6467126607894897,
-0.2862405776977539,
0.05559638515114784,
-0.7587771415710449,
-0.32522180676460266,
0.2761639952659607,
-0.31051021814346313,
0.28898099064826965,
0.020203847438097,
-0.3157603144645691,
-0.045974500477313995,
0.6828444004058838,
-0.2824779748916626,
0.3235798478126526,
0.06056685745716095,
0.4096706211566925,
-1.3562300205230713,
0.29526829719543457,
0.10765654593706131,
-0.012213537469506264,
-0.783729612827301,
-0.35000044107437134,
-0.23746922612190247,
-0.17292112112045288,
-0.392995148897171,
0.45190444588661194,
-0.1624804139137268,
-0.21154667437076569,
-0.12944360077381134,
0.06407519429922104,
-0.16345128417015076,
0.5999747514724731,
-0.023954667150974274,
0.19364549219608307,
0.5146814584732056,
-0.6765625476837158,
0.563957154750824,
0.611747682094574,
0.37946444749832153,
0.7834519743919373,
-0.6422687768936157,
0.49559807777404785,
0.03374868631362915,
0.09217896312475204,
-0.6277197003364563,
-0.4355665445327759,
0.28705164790153503,
-0.3746378719806671,
0.07996905595064163,
-0.2021123468875885,
-0.43378764390945435,
-0.29281434416770935,
-0.43867412209510803,
0.45537927746772766,
0.5929586291313171,
-0.5646596550941467,
0.9092292785644531,
0.45392802357673645,
-0.041262488812208176,
-0.4052940309047699,
-0.6035449504852295,
-0.4496745765209198,
-0.3907579183578491,
-0.6541416049003601,
-0.09208998829126358,
-0.40892651677131653,
-0.2560543119907379,
-0.28736981749534607,
0.24037086963653564,
0.2266882210969925,
-0.08374401181936264,
0.27205324172973633,
-0.06650534272193909,
0.27650123834609985,
0.20211978256702423,
0.3333209753036499,
-0.18964660167694092,
0.18437449634075165,
0.19015827775001526,
0.924834668636322,
-0.037357769906520844,
-0.4107990562915802,
-0.21835315227508545,
0.3362947106361389,
0.5240913033485413,
0.018865276128053665,
0.34459519386291504,
0.3560943603515625,
-0.12636405229568481,
-0.06787816435098648,
-0.37010136246681213,
-0.4156816303730011,
-0.49292588233947754,
0.052698321640491486,
-0.6499834656715393,
-0.7628659009933472,
0.5348441004753113,
-0.20662319660186768,
0.1453278511762619,
-0.012179036624729633,
0.9282306432723999,
0.2718909978866577,
1.4731829166412354,
0.35782918334007263,
-0.09643592685461044,
0.5224941968917847,
0.038145069032907486,
0.09346093982458115,
-0.9726437926292419,
-0.1587216854095459,
-0.2934636175632477,
-0.274293452501297,
-0.7674934267997742,
0.10375577211380005,
0.4132157266139984,
-0.7164751291275024,
-0.37622058391571045,
-0.13431379199028015,
-0.5028623342514038,
0.11192812025547028,
0.36903098225593567,
0.3206448554992676,
0.19895996153354645,
0.11591805517673492,
-0.1008310541510582,
-0.17214816808700562,
-0.48137345910072327,
-0.6822214126586914,
1.4794179201126099,
0.34693557024002075,
0.9039109945297241,
0.004726146347820759,
0.8610931634902954,
0.1411997675895691,
0.23694424331188202,
-1.058358073234558,
0.5572440028190613,
0.07438532263040543,
-0.32215312123298645,
-0.22484281659126282,
-0.4465324878692627,
-0.9197419881820679,
0.10051029920578003,
-0.18860939145088196,
-0.5624727010726929,
0.06035248562693596,
0.47769707441329956,
-0.14593695104122162,
0.02075965516269207,
-0.5149741768836975,
0.4433278441429138,
-0.21042148768901825,
-0.5089665055274963,
-0.2894846796989441,
-0.5718376636505127,
0.18489733338356018,
-0.2008887380361557,
-0.20618793368339539,
-0.4340795576572418,
-0.013764360919594765,
0.41963377594947815,
-0.3356671929359436,
0.5771957039833069,
-0.18943850696086884,
-0.2180766612291336,
0.01778394542634487,
0.16110628843307495,
0.2949405312538147,
0.09447621554136276,
-0.49188417196273804,
-0.05774860456585884,
-0.34353673458099365,
-0.4189865291118622,
-0.6036622524261475,
0.7250946164131165,
-0.8326733112335205,
-0.30558064579963684,
-0.04661015048623085,
-0.4624197483062744,
-0.5013270378112793,
-0.03565985709428787,
0.3281203806400299,
0.38357022404670715,
-0.6369032263755798,
-0.21557612717151642,
0.4478907883167267,
-0.2767990529537201,
0.16064263880252838,
0.513248085975647,
-0.16857555508613586,
-0.4660937488079071,
0.6985357403755188,
-0.24666817486286163,
0.24107243120670319,
0.30436164140701294,
0.529667854309082,
-0.164702370762825,
0.10307170450687408,
-0.1561143547296524,
0.06644043326377869,
-0.23736676573753357,
-0.2660887837409973,
-0.7270436882972717,
0.18629489839076996,
-0.4803861081600189,
-0.39084896445274353,
-0.4569960832595825,
-0.19905629754066467,
-0.3044596016407013,
-0.17250819504261017,
0.5127748250961304,
0.7196705341339111,
-0.28903928399086,
0.062241580337285995,
-0.6212844848632812,
0.1237935796380043,
0.3462138772010803,
0.32349956035614014,
0.11609598994255066,
-0.2982877492904663,
-0.06287864595651627,
0.20215527713298798,
-0.6113536357879639,
-0.7716614007949829,
0.679684579372406,
0.15781204402446747,
0.3745698928833008,
0.6759935617446899,
0.017382200807332993,
0.34164679050445557,
-0.5010227560997009,
0.38983944058418274,
0.2609625458717346,
-0.8736412525177002,
1.0005587339401245,
-0.4915093779563904,
-0.31879398226737976,
0.218200221657753,
0.4009547531604767,
-0.4053725004196167,
-0.2820737659931183,
-0.7942771315574646,
-0.6475244760513306,
0.6723418235778809,
0.3276740610599518,
0.1853022277355194,
-0.10625596344470978,
0.45369094610214233,
0.3285096287727356,
0.3471539616584778,
-0.2264097034931183,
-0.3014846742153168,
-0.14122237265110016,
-0.3218676745891571,
-0.17837108671665192,
-0.3522792458534241,
-0.6412662267684937,
0.11746277660131454,
0.34260129928588867,
-0.46291500329971313,
0.6253036260604858,
0.13204583525657654,
0.19811902940273285,
-0.4766804575920105,
0.21975162625312805,
0.4762524366378784,
0.289802223443985,
-0.4960559606552124,
-0.2222912460565567,
-0.004583460744470358,
-0.10055810213088989,
0.2711973488330841,
-0.07752659171819687,
0.18752829730510712,
-0.44553372263908386,
-0.020099658519029617,
0.5576462149620056,
-0.13335026800632477,
-0.6501514315605164,
0.3267783522605896,
-0.22951005399227142,
-0.10294275730848312,
-0.2510605454444885,
-0.011225045658648014,
-0.2557328939437866,
0.25500527024269104,
0.07271391153335571,
-0.324135422706604,
0.39066657423973083,
-0.45420700311660767,
0.17033657431602478,
0.3146474063396454,
0.0020596736576408148,
-0.4791032373905182,
0.3331947326660156,
0.5659667253494263,
-0.3087461590766907,
0.592194139957428,
0.22998347878456116,
-0.40871933102607727,
0.6612831354141235,
0.624865710735321,
1.0182760953903198,
-0.4537425637245178,
0.279999315738678,
0.3530838191509247,
-0.14977675676345825,
0.2342260628938675,
0.402243047952652,
-0.05351227894425392,
-1.2137380838394165,
0.1864289790391922,
-0.5047358870506287,
-0.7972820401191711,
-0.24556982517242432,
-1.0302397012710571,
0.07938584685325623,
-0.5046542286872864,
-0.39763206243515015,
-0.15517477691173553,
-0.053559284657239914,
-0.7797366380691528,
0.11079982668161392,
0.10094011574983597,
0.4813995063304901,
-0.9919246435165405,
0.3771412670612335,
0.6972565650939941,
-0.28618064522743225,
-0.5759280323982239,
0.08456230908632278,
-0.0132064213976264,
-1.0939980745315552,
0.44740065932273865,
0.13244910538196564,
-0.023473555222153664,
0.09041374176740646,
-0.5327845811843872,
-0.5406477451324463,
1.1855205297470093,
0.5310344099998474,
-0.4991803467273712,
0.3263883590698242,
0.10194654017686844,
0.7276532053947449,
-0.9578476548194885,
0.48618176579475403,
0.692421019077301,
0.45935168862342834,
-0.07534269988536835,
-0.715077817440033,
0.17249144613742828,
-0.276838481426239,
0.01019149087369442,
0.19623789191246033,
-1.1228210926055908,
0.5983406901359558,
-0.21274346113204956,
0.2027820646762848,
0.015708504244685173,
0.06828845292329788,
0.7151873707771301,
0.4541378915309906,
0.39068931341171265,
0.6881642937660217,
0.5790653824806213,
0.046098969876766205,
1.0668326616287231,
-0.5235214829444885,
0.5428897738456726,
0.7707530856132507,
-0.5484424829483032,
0.6879103779792786,
0.6799442172050476,
-0.055236004292964935,
0.017482653260231018,
0.7673665881156921,
-0.05374636873602867,
0.4609265625476837,
0.20695245265960693,
-0.2724822163581848,
-0.22594863176345825,
-0.6034771800041199,
-0.31006965041160583,
0.5150855779647827,
0.33641186356544495,
-0.6441305875778198,
0.19782860577106476,
-0.044979535043239594,
-0.03296411409974098,
-0.10832291096448898,
-0.2102271169424057,
0.8751189112663269,
0.10005686432123184,
-0.47049573063850403,
0.22698131203651428,
-0.3537006378173828,
0.5868799686431885,
-0.32551291584968567,
0.049996472895145416,
-0.5101617574691772,
0.07024966925382614,
-0.20048506557941437,
-0.6675714254379272,
0.015351555310189724,
0.048137765377759933,
-0.25385525822639465,
-0.13990366458892822,
0.6601106524467468,
-0.39078256487846375,
-0.3127841055393219,
0.6378732323646545,
0.6331531405448914,
0.12093044817447662,
0.3783886730670929,
-0.7677955627441406,
0.09543630480766296,
-0.050286345183849335,
-0.6686009764671326,
0.4356452226638794,
0.4569465219974518,
0.5865950584411621,
0.9008474349975586,
0.5512630343437195,
-0.004929143935441971,
-0.18792816996574402,
0.25021231174468994,
0.9927276372909546,
-0.5791186094284058,
-0.38604646921157837,
-0.9045023322105408,
0.27746179699897766,
-0.1032637357711792,
-0.31046241521835327,
0.5086056590080261,
0.40721896290779114,
0.3459833264350891,
-0.2111426293849945,
0.8967822194099426,
-0.22174198925495148,
0.4812593460083008,
-0.5247029662132263,
0.3605221211910248,
-0.655457615852356,
-0.061623670160770416,
-0.5947005748748779,
-1.0046908855438232,
-0.05438575893640518,
0.5622516870498657,
-0.1846196949481964,
0.275384783744812,
0.44426998496055603,
0.9518653154373169,
-0.015607930719852448,
0.0057854498736560345,
0.6720178723335266,
0.09466099739074707,
0.41225433349609375,
0.8034000992774963,
0.8473674654960632,
-0.12923315167427063,
0.18964603543281555,
-0.08006609976291656,
-0.38040846586227417,
-0.34796157479286194,
-0.9837200045585632,
-0.8572633266448975,
-0.46543100476264954,
-0.036042921245098114,
-0.3749323785305023,
-0.146987184882164,
1.3611946105957031,
0.3351711332798004,
-0.6017971038818359,
-0.2863873541355133,
-0.13528324663639069,
-0.21804764866828918,
0.2156156748533249,
-0.23750759661197662,
0.1518898755311966,
-0.28879618644714355,
-1.0213851928710938,
0.05177447572350502,
0.31567320227622986,
0.20290015637874603,
-0.17938876152038574,
-0.5913462042808533,
0.27915939688682556,
0.26907920837402344,
0.6691992878913879,
0.19023239612579346,
-0.49290230870246887,
-0.10911731421947479,
-0.03973887860774994,
0.10983752459287643,
0.09074793756008148,
1.1197868585586548,
-0.24605897068977356,
0.5679688453674316,
0.32001808285713196,
0.5285840034484863,
0.21768848598003387,
0.0776841938495636,
1.0917418003082275,
-0.7079018950462341,
0.21418580412864685,
0.3314549922943115,
0.5179425477981567,
0.28816863894462585,
-0.5420477986335754,
0.7511377930641174,
-0.0668376162648201,
-0.8175956010818481,
-0.8951967358589172,
0.5450016856193542,
-1.0271738767623901,
0.27671492099761963,
1.362410068511963,
-0.12945982813835144,
-0.06138590723276138,
0.22288717329502106,
-0.2681864798069,
0.2947348654270172,
-0.8806222677230835,
0.8011984825134277,
0.44233283400535583,
-0.8945466876029968,
-0.09731858223676682,
0.04532208666205406,
0.4732218086719513,
0.5282248258590698,
-0.9058651328086853,
0.23064887523651123,
0.6776251196861267,
0.04573647305369377,
0.04968193173408508,
0.6959415674209595,
0.04258652403950691,
-0.057853229343891144,
-0.0381455235183239,
0.23678332567214966,
-0.06626206636428833,
0.016839368268847466,
-0.3287856876850128,
0.03351898491382599,
0.011283009313046932,
-0.20027531683444977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19065v1 | STBench: Assessing the Ability of Large Language Models in Spatio-Temporal Analysis | 2024-06-27T10:34:02 | 2024-06-27T10:34:02 | Wenbin Li, Di Yao, Ruibo Zhao, Wenjie Chen, Zijie Xu, Chengxue Luo, Chang Gong, Quanliang Jing, Haining Tan, Jingping Bi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid evolution of large language models (LLMs) holds promise for
reforming the methodology of spatio-temporal data mining. However, current
works for evaluating the spatio-temporal understanding capability of LLMs are
somewhat limited and biased. These works either fail to incorporate the latest
language models or only focus on assessing the memorized spatio-temporal
knowledge. To address this gap, this paper dissects LLMs' capability of
spatio-temporal data into four distinct dimensions: knowledge comprehension,
spatio-temporal reasoning, accurate computation, and downstream applications.
We curate several natural language question-answer tasks for each category and
build the benchmark dataset, namely STBench, containing 13 distinct tasks and
over 60,000 QA pairs. Moreover, we have assessed the capabilities of 13 LLMs,
such as GPT-4o, Gemma and Mistral. Experimental results reveal that existing
LLMs show remarkable performance on knowledge comprehension and spatio-temporal
reasoning tasks, with potential for further enhancement on other tasks through
in-context learning, chain-of-though prompting, and fine-tuning. The code and
datasets of STBench are released on https://github.com/LwbXc/STBench. | [
-0.5670620203018188,
-1.0244301557540894,
0.8786532282829285,
0.4138483703136444,
-0.30782583355903625,
0.2848873734474182,
-0.30774006247520447,
-0.5219269394874573,
0.1072344034910202,
0.46881914138793945,
-0.6128788590431213,
-0.659274697303772,
-0.5536121129989624,
-0.17602603137493134,
-0.47422996163368225,
0.5977733731269836,
-0.33509090542793274,
-0.10743627697229385,
-0.35411110520362854,
-0.2340300977230072,
-0.24114130437374115,
-0.39051711559295654,
-0.7301926016807556,
-0.11226848512887955,
0.5502827167510986,
0.4759598672389984,
0.6959987282752991,
0.558110773563385,
0.5086569786071777,
0.29923903942108154,
0.03781715780496597,
0.16310249269008636,
-0.5703862905502319,
-0.024996262043714523,
-0.3168075978755951,
-0.08174405246973038,
-0.23722755908966064,
-0.33806946873664856,
0.9541966915130615,
0.943707287311554,
-0.12421221286058426,
0.22419364750385284,
-0.19126279652118683,
0.46814924478530884,
-0.2237926423549652,
0.11798732727766037,
-0.5639939904212952,
-0.12555967271327972,
-0.3282715380191803,
-0.28928545117378235,
-0.07761450111865997,
-0.3410036265850067,
0.22066926956176758,
-0.34017103910446167,
0.1789439171552658,
0.05389906466007233,
0.8319306373596191,
0.5273079872131348,
-0.46476301550865173,
0.011641295626759529,
-0.8121228218078613,
0.5443956851959229,
-0.49654680490493774,
0.5121182799339294,
0.4581661522388458,
0.6946327686309814,
-0.3281759023666382,
-0.8631014823913574,
-0.5891159176826477,
-0.051078055053949356,
0.24052013456821442,
0.14569832384586334,
0.11202123016119003,
-0.2504879832267761,
0.20410946011543274,
0.20411013066768646,
-0.8568191528320312,
0.25728046894073486,
-0.22270017862319946,
0.10481007397174835,
0.5959848165512085,
0.29694634675979614,
0.16139838099479675,
-0.2922765016555786,
-0.5621961355209351,
-0.2682177722454071,
-0.4890002906322479,
0.1892121583223343,
0.27650436758995056,
0.12862038612365723,
-0.16892655193805695,
0.3581029772758484,
-0.06710462272167206,
0.5702144503593445,
-0.3436812162399292,
0.08030594140291214,
0.03902218118309975,
-0.47785478830337524,
-0.21899424493312836,
-0.3526597321033478,
0.8477795124053955,
0.17491604387760162,
-0.004017430357635021,
-0.3580753803253174,
0.26671281456947327,
-0.37351393699645996,
0.2826595604419708,
-0.5256057381629944,
-0.12821973860263824,
0.39904728531837463,
-0.0035445555113255978,
0.07623110711574554,
-0.08849268406629562,
-1.0706180334091187,
-0.29027149081230164,
-0.34242936968803406,
0.0378902293741703,
-0.6158111691474915,
-0.3216538429260254,
0.047436393797397614,
-0.07523570209741592,
0.2987557649612427,
0.26844626665115356,
-0.47255903482437134,
0.13275237381458282,
0.8355605006217957,
0.7287139296531677,
-0.289713054895401,
-0.8960452079772949,
-0.20883895456790924,
0.10746518522500992,
-0.4822395443916321,
1.1129586696624756,
-0.7608505487442017,
-0.2289573848247528,
-0.16587381064891815,
0.10865020006895065,
-0.19922131299972534,
-0.4445101022720337,
0.47830766439437866,
-0.7277109622955322,
-0.17644964158535004,
-0.4477313160896301,
-0.2982048988342285,
-0.23828205466270447,
0.27816808223724365,
-0.6786527037620544,
1.5765399932861328,
0.2069743275642395,
-0.6990394592285156,
0.5339618921279907,
-0.26921528577804565,
-0.3846355676651001,
0.03830183297395706,
-0.07713650166988373,
-0.31645873188972473,
0.04527584835886955,
0.22275178134441376,
0.2918369770050049,
-0.27977821230888367,
0.5734994411468506,
-0.504255473613739,
-0.1923438459634781,
0.2681730389595032,
-0.15192371606826782,
0.5335231423377991,
0.17917713522911072,
-0.2536976635456085,
0.24186773598194122,
-0.6401961445808411,
0.11178991198539734,
0.1959809809923172,
-0.3946567475795746,
0.07238245010375977,
0.2445647120475769,
-0.04120808094739914,
0.29177531599998474,
0.20162974298000336,
-0.2035994827747345,
0.09691064804792404,
-0.47424426674842834,
0.2933862805366516,
0.5712171792984009,
0.14370450377464294,
0.4802400767803192,
-0.18577063083648682,
0.5701715350151062,
-0.09484343230724335,
0.04534547030925751,
0.2819306254386902,
-0.2966904938220978,
-0.5505781173706055,
-0.20423057675361633,
0.175424262881279,
0.40437012910842896,
-1.0476505756378174,
0.33755210041999817,
-0.8526672124862671,
-0.9203053712844849,
-0.20640015602111816,
0.1333237588405609,
0.02406245470046997,
0.21800296008586884,
0.3201768398284912,
-0.2672457993030548,
-0.5945881605148315,
-0.5888544321060181,
-0.2654586434364319,
-0.1662290096282959,
-0.11777550727128983,
0.3990604281425476,
0.5331857800483704,
-0.34539496898651123,
0.735348105430603,
-0.013948369771242142,
0.37689048051834106,
-0.44721993803977966,
0.18356458842754364,
0.03699639439582825,
-0.0486656092107296,
0.7141592502593994,
-0.3605348467826843,
-0.37832292914390564,
-0.13860686123371124,
-0.40788549184799194,
-0.28935906291007996,
0.0662558302283287,
-0.38007691502571106,
0.041310250759124756,
0.41182753443717957,
-0.6259508728981018,
0.4942004382610321,
0.6133066415786743,
-0.34058016538619995,
0.5857573747634888,
-0.11677525192499161,
0.20606480538845062,
-0.7517210245132446,
0.16978365182876587,
-0.40053513646125793,
-0.2276749163866043,
-0.6859297156333923,
0.06966506689786911,
-0.07372875511646271,
-0.09417746216058731,
-0.36323991417884827,
0.7127513289451599,
-0.16394732892513275,
-0.6653909683227539,
-0.26574546098709106,
0.4805459976196289,
-0.08152151107788086,
0.4708510637283325,
0.1349053531885147,
0.4139128029346466,
0.4350186288356781,
-0.6398351788520813,
0.39742860198020935,
-0.0013447474921122193,
-0.6421111226081848,
0.1369689702987671,
-0.4271123707294464,
0.25313031673431396,
-0.1556791216135025,
0.16004425287246704,
-1.136366844177246,
-0.33135414123535156,
-0.13912831246852875,
-0.1519281268119812,
0.05934440717101097,
-0.2114441692829132,
-0.9395168423652649,
-0.4577876329421997,
-0.14776498079299927,
0.2814909517765045,
-0.008778433315455914,
-0.6788822412490845,
0.7521778345108032,
0.5306517481803894,
-0.3179590702056885,
-0.1884196549654007,
-0.46856701374053955,
0.0769612193107605,
-0.3373042047023773,
-0.6548361778259277,
0.043508175760507584,
-0.01690252125263214,
-0.27392494678497314,
-0.15891657769680023,
-0.1858820766210556,
-0.07718106359243393,
0.22442154586315155,
0.122087262570858,
0.045707590878009796,
0.07194962352514267,
0.18209393322467804,
-0.2346474677324295,
-0.26199766993522644,
0.06290303170681,
-0.0032205923926085234,
0.8614143133163452,
-0.0703878328204155,
-0.5728359222412109,
0.021100345999002457,
0.06867604702711105,
0.5912258625030518,
-0.24023965001106262,
0.5911693572998047,
0.66017746925354,
-0.23811514675617218,
-0.34692785143852234,
-0.33199822902679443,
-0.08322251588106155,
-0.41527411341667175,
0.4561164677143097,
-0.3075235188007355,
-0.9311099648475647,
0.6318488121032715,
-0.15080596506595612,
0.11334249377250671,
0.3046729862689972,
0.6257504224777222,
-0.060684025287628174,
0.6913381218910217,
0.3600913882255554,
-0.2360345423221588,
0.4246286451816559,
0.0266548004001379,
0.5519115924835205,
-0.44165048003196716,
-0.10492890328168869,
-0.541826605796814,
-0.5298715233802795,
-0.44350162148475647,
-0.9493427276611328,
0.30999135971069336,
-0.010250112973153591,
-0.36668217182159424,
0.0663117840886116,
-0.13335642218589783,
0.41356605291366577,
0.3798671066761017,
-0.19213972985744476,
0.18673604726791382,
0.16523593664169312,
0.02078157104551792,
0.011565406806766987,
-0.6955626606941223,
-0.5650244355201721,
0.7366981506347656,
0.5226169228553772,
0.3777630627155304,
0.15675579011440277,
0.16606006026268005,
-0.30471083521842957,
0.029427174478769302,
-0.6366991996765137,
0.7524515390396118,
-0.02530568279325962,
-0.6158185601234436,
-0.431231826543808,
-0.6141358613967896,
-0.9333173036575317,
0.39051949977874756,
0.07837215065956116,
-0.7339251041412354,
0.08246184140443802,
-0.26243501901626587,
-0.3688419759273529,
0.5236153602600098,
-0.6471726298332214,
0.912904679775238,
-0.8215906620025635,
-0.5689123868942261,
-0.22531117498874664,
-0.4955887198448181,
0.07860781252384186,
-0.054290201514959335,
0.45736628770828247,
-0.48199495673179626,
-0.011936047114431858,
0.7209054231643677,
-0.12707769870758057,
0.7565341591835022,
-0.3104790449142456,
0.07405978441238403,
0.1930413544178009,
0.3610304892063141,
0.3982106149196625,
0.1378459334373474,
-0.046916358172893524,
0.35028788447380066,
0.4570234715938568,
-0.42639726400375366,
-0.5500993728637695,
0.6412204504013062,
-0.6679193377494812,
-0.25763311982154846,
-0.41675883531570435,
-0.676585853099823,
-0.6331417560577393,
0.13219106197357178,
-0.000849494943395257,
0.3019150197505951,
-0.4387704133987427,
0.06860137730836868,
0.3220002353191376,
-0.32794269919395447,
0.40735265612602234,
0.7014176845550537,
-0.49738603830337524,
-0.0953853651881218,
0.7162359356880188,
0.033281587064266205,
0.045504964888095856,
0.2883624732494354,
0.14323635399341583,
-0.3690511882305145,
-0.8160037398338318,
-0.2725033760070801,
0.2900533378124237,
-0.5193969011306763,
-0.02759608067572117,
-0.4844861924648285,
-0.06255637109279633,
-0.14394511282444,
-0.1371164619922638,
-0.38420772552490234,
-0.2547180950641632,
0.08777984231710434,
-0.3956269323825836,
0.5080533623695374,
0.858329713344574,
-0.005007629748433828,
0.22863183915615082,
-0.6662867069244385,
0.274711012840271,
0.18080362677574158,
0.4985586702823639,
0.035098589956760406,
-0.4294658601284027,
-0.19367247819900513,
-0.08725851029157639,
0.0002033190248766914,
-0.673846423625946,
0.4362436532974243,
0.06270886957645416,
0.5465361475944519,
0.3418782651424408,
-0.18873246014118195,
1.0066121816635132,
-0.5018349289894104,
0.7970557808876038,
-0.3733507990837097,
-0.6360193490982056,
0.47099804878234863,
-0.42663490772247314,
0.4603046178817749,
0.6282510757446289,
0.3600766956806183,
-0.4199373424053192,
-0.5287529230117798,
-0.7519450783729553,
-1.0800310373306274,
0.6980171203613281,
-0.19497545063495636,
-0.35319462418556213,
0.1977252960205078,
0.22300481796264648,
0.11819031834602356,
0.2365647405385971,
-0.31378233432769775,
0.1218729168176651,
-0.22015145421028137,
-0.2909049391746521,
-0.5016427040100098,
-0.3465389013290405,
-0.10936053842306137,
-0.25295156240463257,
0.167416051030159,
-0.13132229447364807,
0.15204794704914093,
0.009470504708588123,
-0.09854020923376083,
-0.08707080036401749,
0.5056463479995728,
0.35232454538345337,
0.8499406576156616,
-0.17705422639846802,
0.48709362745285034,
0.6549068689346313,
-0.3737333118915558,
-0.2546512484550476,
0.23663397133350372,
0.20348387956619263,
-0.22794316709041595,
0.644122302532196,
0.7709183096885681,
0.7026445269584656,
-0.8065139055252075,
0.1925828903913498,
-0.0980411246418953,
-0.17540252208709717,
-0.2768098711967468,
-0.11757001280784607,
0.2662886381149292,
0.2683703601360321,
0.16313794255256653,
-0.27938929200172424,
-0.10843964666128159,
-0.5976507067680359,
0.07838664203882217,
0.2787485718727112,
-0.18862774968147278,
-0.47353947162628174,
0.2593849003314972,
-0.2579510509967804,
0.17532941699028015,
0.3923887610435486,
-0.2732032239437103,
-0.6901867389678955,
0.5474070310592651,
0.06939435750246048,
0.44076231122016907,
-0.20455540716648102,
0.11589785665273666,
0.3280864655971527,
0.43971768021583557,
0.07620308548212051,
0.4909592568874359,
0.014830724336206913,
-0.6680437922477722,
-0.5162774324417114,
-0.7332220077514648,
-0.5005479454994202,
0.08155164122581482,
-0.424485981464386,
-0.18274952471256256,
-0.62776118516922,
-0.1260133981704712,
-0.2101902961730957,
0.3858489990234375,
-0.8576868772506714,
-0.14208680391311646,
-0.10783316940069199,
1.0379531383514404,
-0.6716317534446716,
0.7407468557357788,
0.7937590479850769,
0.041259944438934326,
-0.687861442565918,
-0.11991024762392044,
0.005366133060306311,
-0.6995940208435059,
0.5804546475410461,
-0.17426030337810516,
-0.16173650324344635,
-0.17384235560894012,
-0.4651423692703247,
-0.9253279566764832,
0.9802606701850891,
0.2459418773651123,
-0.46639513969421387,
0.1145782619714737,
0.5844694972038269,
0.8885229229927063,
-0.1544705331325531,
0.2795082628726959,
1.1667600870132446,
0.6717750430107117,
0.19090889394283295,
-1.0501633882522583,
-0.16243372857570648,
-0.1392265111207962,
-0.17397359013557434,
0.14247621595859528,
-0.5826185345649719,
0.43067505955696106,
0.0047491989098489285,
-0.45943495631217957,
-0.23027442395687103,
0.4666116535663605,
0.38948163390159607,
0.4429287016391754,
0.5043728947639465,
0.883151650428772,
0.8803591728210449,
-0.5101991295814514,
1.2613564729690552,
-0.1708294004201889,
0.08934620022773743,
1.159453272819519,
-0.48176395893096924,
1.2192422151565552,
0.3750040829181671,
-0.3842405378818512,
0.6143835783004761,
0.7266371250152588,
0.21490801870822906,
0.42586731910705566,
0.05777725949883461,
0.03730392828583717,
-0.44397082924842834,
0.06632209569215775,
-0.04756790027022362,
0.5460867881774902,
0.4901580810546875,
0.39346611499786377,
-0.4122368395328522,
-0.13663816452026367,
-0.08157014846801758,
-0.1850869357585907,
-0.20890650153160095,
0.8200424909591675,
0.04523051902651787,
-0.6672475337982178,
0.287868469953537,
-0.23246267437934875,
0.07586903125047684,
-0.7257421016693115,
0.33906683325767517,
-0.1418619155883789,
0.17568406462669373,
-0.09441767632961273,
-1.0902135372161865,
0.49022090435028076,
0.03244148939847946,
0.07026210427284241,
-0.1803060621023178,
0.5267770886421204,
-0.3500564992427826,
-0.39664971828460693,
0.6391615271568298,
0.5822949409484863,
0.06422465294599533,
0.06834099441766739,
-0.6297010183334351,
0.3266492187976837,
-0.14294584095478058,
-0.1703517884016037,
0.2778105139732361,
0.7096459269523621,
0.14489199221134186,
0.8479112386703491,
0.5909573435783386,
0.2886154055595398,
0.25136882066726685,
0.339647501707077,
0.7533748745918274,
-0.810715913772583,
-0.4648491442203522,
-0.5713408589363098,
0.404217928647995,
-0.03541669249534607,
-0.0016084775561466813,
1.0292826890945435,
0.4604351818561554,
0.7007524371147156,
0.25147345662117004,
0.6526108980178833,
0.04831666499376297,
0.9572243690490723,
-0.49382340908050537,
0.3969070017337799,
-0.47154730558395386,
0.25635629892349243,
0.04052848741412163,
-0.575893223285675,
-0.1708233654499054,
0.5494517683982849,
-0.9885526895523071,
0.13933606445789337,
0.8835782408714294,
0.730135440826416,
-0.043863579630851746,
0.08095432072877884,
0.11382941156625748,
0.3072216808795929,
0.3792746961116791,
0.7690296173095703,
1.266574501991272,
-0.1606464684009552,
0.5169393420219421,
-0.25150078535079956,
-0.23047469556331635,
-0.34414172172546387,
-0.7220581769943237,
-1.1038885116577148,
-0.6604794263839722,
0.010411151684820652,
0.03379442170262337,
-0.3004396855831146,
0.46306857466697693,
0.5953831672668457,
-0.7771043181419373,
-0.24576297402381897,
0.15180303156375885,
0.18613748252391815,
-0.1253403127193451,
-0.24248363077640533,
0.49491938948631287,
-0.2382148653268814,
-0.5739999413490295,
0.7950519323348999,
0.37898555397987366,
-0.031638022512197495,
-0.16227853298187256,
0.048190221190452576,
-0.13390880823135376,
-0.012072094716131687,
0.5834457278251648,
0.35228434205055237,
-0.42519187927246094,
-0.315661758184433,
0.009704560041427612,
0.01839957758784294,
-0.059935588389635086,
0.847514271736145,
-0.42568331956863403,
0.37259671092033386,
0.8016662001609802,
0.6373769044876099,
0.7225654721260071,
0.09251401573419571,
0.31396886706352234,
-0.7933599948883057,
0.10512226819992065,
0.1710367649793625,
0.5066686272621155,
0.3765493631362915,
0.13557781279087067,
0.4682033360004425,
-0.018061380833387375,
-0.7815108895301819,
-0.7028053998947144,
0.21188132464885712,
-1.031302809715271,
-0.3530160188674927,
1.1849868297576904,
0.3335423767566681,
-0.394800066947937,
-0.5520792007446289,
-0.018435407429933548,
0.047816045582294464,
-0.08880043029785156,
0.6814979910850525,
0.7367261648178101,
-0.06876066327095032,
-0.2912193536758423,
-0.9462941884994507,
0.4647074341773987,
0.23567360639572144,
-1.021175503730774,
0.3222237229347229,
0.5101508498191833,
0.24835382401943207,
0.13372822105884552,
0.627013087272644,
-0.03889679163694382,
0.1076938733458519,
-0.1244267150759697,
-0.15307757258415222,
0.04909774661064148,
-0.4977899193763733,
-0.17107130587100983,
0.25623995065689087,
0.3294796645641327,
0.3346564471721649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00106v1 | UnUnlearning: Unlearning is not sufficient for content regulation in advanced generative AI | 2024-06-27T10:24:35 | 2024-06-27T10:24:35 | Ilia Shumailov, Jamie Hayes, Eleni Triantafillou, Guillermo Ortiz-Jimenez, Nicolas Papernot, Matthew Jagielski, Itay Yona, Heidi Howard, Eugene Bagdasaryan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | Exact unlearning was first introduced as a privacy mechanism that allowed a
user to retract their data from machine learning models on request. Shortly
after, inexact schemes were proposed to mitigate the impractical costs
associated with exact unlearning. More recently unlearning is often discussed
as an approach for removal of impermissible knowledge i.e. knowledge that the
model should not possess such as unlicensed copyrighted, inaccurate, or
malicious information. The promise is that if the model does not have a certain
malicious capability, then it cannot be used for the associated malicious
purpose. In this paper we revisit the paradigm in which unlearning is used for
in Large Language Models (LLMs) and highlight an underlying inconsistency
arising from in-context learning. Unlearning can be an effective control
mechanism for the training phase, yet it does not prevent the model from
performing an impermissible act during inference. We introduce a concept of
ununlearning, where unlearned knowledge gets reintroduced in-context,
effectively rendering the model capable of behaving as if it knows the
forgotten knowledge. As a result, we argue that content filtering for
impermissible knowledge will be required and even exact unlearning schemes are
not enough for effective content regulation. We discuss feasibility of
ununlearning for modern LLMs and examine broader implications. | [
0.0059481095522642136,
-0.7358915209770203,
0.27329784631729126,
-0.22743213176727295,
-0.38035768270492554,
0.30383431911468506,
-0.5195370316505432,
-0.25978562235832214,
-0.5492613911628723,
0.7327288389205933,
-0.40395015478134155,
-0.39179345965385437,
-0.5130692720413208,
-0.27238401770591736,
-0.7675660848617554,
1.0530755519866943,
-0.0868896022439003,
-0.10198234766721725,
-0.4701623022556305,
-0.07818806171417236,
-0.44266587495803833,
-0.4740534722805023,
-0.710485577583313,
-0.6788091659545898,
0.10328419506549835,
0.622261643409729,
0.2762690484523773,
0.5779364705085754,
0.11423524469137192,
0.3121582865715027,
-0.3670039176940918,
0.2830890119075775,
-0.8514285683631897,
0.15485651791095734,
-0.10806815326213837,
-0.616970956325531,
0.11242254078388214,
0.12662798166275024,
0.6707594990730286,
1.0447828769683838,
-0.30463171005249023,
-0.2238941192626953,
0.5601511597633362,
1.022598147392273,
-0.8278175592422485,
-0.0010964188259094954,
-0.5370603799819946,
0.22067216038703918,
-0.022269422188401222,
-0.14256154000759125,
-0.4316696226596832,
-0.11796247214078903,
0.01915292628109455,
-0.6386848092079163,
0.1244586780667305,
-0.0273183174431324,
0.7313879728317261,
0.38308197259902954,
-0.31183844804763794,
-0.5499385595321655,
-1.1073905229568481,
0.7847674489021301,
-0.6424922347068787,
0.3204067647457123,
0.6776021122932434,
-0.026035740971565247,
-0.31778281927108765,
-0.944853663444519,
-0.5556658506393433,
-0.1414630115032196,
0.08903081715106964,
0.20744840800762177,
-0.477319598197937,
0.27059268951416016,
0.3628194034099579,
0.5662091970443726,
-0.03094932623207569,
0.5560498833656311,
-0.6449005007743835,
-0.03730027377605438,
0.38866713643074036,
-0.11623559147119522,
0.2543693780899048,
-0.05166276544332504,
-0.49265503883361816,
0.24019235372543335,
-1.1525276899337769,
0.2891474664211273,
0.5415462255477905,
0.12161152064800262,
-0.08759018033742905,
0.5480540990829468,
-0.17754435539245605,
0.452940434217453,
-0.13069045543670654,
0.056230172514915466,
-0.08152838796377182,
0.24516509473323822,
-0.37628069519996643,
-0.06781690567731857,
0.810129702091217,
0.14483614265918732,
0.3735150694847107,
-0.47057074308395386,
-0.24960003793239594,
-0.32684803009033203,
0.5394670963287354,
-0.47407272458076477,
-0.1881721019744873,
0.26538050174713135,
-0.38205599784851074,
-0.10416451841592789,
0.38386446237564087,
-0.6725478172302246,
-0.3199526071548462,
-0.345507949590683,
0.4449959993362427,
-0.5483487248420715,
-0.2342183142900467,
-0.08938620239496231,
-0.08897838741540909,
0.10449440777301788,
0.17706313729286194,
-0.858834445476532,
0.18055395781993866,
0.6720048189163208,
0.6919881105422974,
-0.11549597978591919,
-0.30312877893447876,
-0.08660831302404404,
0.19215872883796692,
-0.569221019744873,
0.3098963797092438,
-0.40801480412483215,
-0.5634646415710449,
0.3179440498352051,
0.13040517270565033,
0.04837419465184212,
-0.6126714944839478,
0.34357237815856934,
-0.8102878928184509,
0.29042989015579224,
-0.1454264372587204,
-1.0584971904754639,
-0.775900661945343,
-0.10792071372270584,
-0.4649621844291687,
0.486430823802948,
0.08919307589530945,
-0.30550506711006165,
0.5404605269432068,
-0.5778536200523376,
-0.5480790138244629,
0.28333479166030884,
-0.13690070807933807,
-0.3714412450790405,
0.14945200085639954,
-0.23656220734119415,
0.3224872052669525,
-0.024810509756207466,
0.535305917263031,
-0.11805543303489685,
-0.6774895191192627,
0.19971753656864166,
-0.7805394530296326,
1.000739574432373,
0.38681018352508545,
-0.47608456015586853,
0.08944696933031082,
-0.5936965942382812,
-0.08523338288068771,
0.005694855470210314,
-0.5179489850997925,
-0.35641324520111084,
0.11446834355592728,
-0.4101601243019104,
-0.09732622653245926,
0.04612283036112785,
-0.6923196315765381,
0.019251586869359016,
-0.5549510717391968,
0.7912763357162476,
0.9032846689224243,
-0.01982526294887066,
0.9394412636756897,
-0.5103272795677185,
0.3522982597351074,
-0.16813711822032928,
0.053191959857940674,
-0.009807405062019825,
-0.2598417103290558,
-0.7728407979011536,
-0.2765527665615082,
0.2772827446460724,
0.3974358141422272,
-0.6674716472625732,
0.4263530969619751,
0.05516795068979263,
-0.2523411810398102,
-0.626134991645813,
0.4953691363334656,
0.7238657474517822,
0.4700097143650055,
0.2669176757335663,
-0.16327644884586334,
-0.5525295734405518,
-0.5492668747901917,
-0.17247779667377472,
-0.07940256595611572,
-0.0704987645149231,
0.040121544152498245,
0.39287108182907104,
-0.12882916629314423,
0.6925985217094421,
-0.09837384521961212,
-0.6443266272544861,
-0.42579910159111023,
0.02244643308222294,
-0.0780443623661995,
0.6809625625610352,
0.08153288811445236,
-0.8949800133705139,
-0.2789365351200104,
-0.00021379170357249677,
-1.2706031799316406,
0.299358606338501,
-0.07703699916601181,
0.3347630798816681,
0.3904954791069031,
1.0018086433410645,
-0.48404744267463684,
0.5905304551124573,
0.3242109715938568,
0.17733782529830933,
0.2585640549659729,
-0.6822004318237305,
-0.1726331263780594,
-0.8213467001914978,
0.18249009549617767,
-0.4764084815979004,
-0.13260741531848907,
-0.8969940543174744,
0.43410995602607727,
0.0216822512447834,
0.07316288352012634,
-0.5823882222175598,
0.44940245151519775,
-0.5376304984092712,
0.21090075373649597,
-0.7870108485221863,
-0.10155877470970154,
0.01707145944237709,
0.5755015015602112,
-0.038312558084726334,
0.6178468465805054,
0.5948854684829712,
-1.0571613311767578,
0.3795892298221588,
0.24765212833881378,
-0.6012563109397888,
0.21848785877227783,
-0.3688862919807434,
0.03404141962528229,
-0.4466803967952728,
0.10450290888547897,
-0.7277933359146118,
-0.20877723395824432,
0.2475288063287735,
-0.40720313787460327,
0.6121181845664978,
-0.18341849744319916,
-0.4323394000530243,
-0.08738156408071518,
-0.13932199776172638,
0.45622581243515015,
0.8915596604347229,
-0.7095022201538086,
0.39933666586875916,
0.41426563262939453,
0.24618719518184662,
-0.6204932332038879,
-0.7008641958236694,
-0.07548409700393677,
-0.3250862956047058,
-0.13364098966121674,
0.3242340683937073,
0.06732285767793655,
-0.2662133574485779,
0.27266088128089905,
-0.0336579829454422,
-0.02308734878897667,
0.16876232624053955,
0.6112371683120728,
-0.05763358622789383,
0.07403536140918732,
0.30790168046951294,
0.1141800805926323,
-0.11066021025180817,
0.05441829934716225,
-0.2605631649494171,
0.4753246605396271,
0.23550274968147278,
-0.6579946875572205,
-0.554283082485199,
0.4025484025478363,
0.46442288160324097,
-0.023991594091057777,
0.7412099838256836,
0.35428884625434875,
-0.6676145792007446,
-0.32829344272613525,
-0.4186917543411255,
0.012179078534245491,
-0.48745736479759216,
0.2958632707595825,
0.0627242848277092,
-1.1145603656768799,
0.4912128448486328,
-0.1256602257490158,
0.2975466251373291,
0.43087372183799744,
0.3811991512775421,
-0.4561872184276581,
0.7141355872154236,
0.852599024772644,
0.2011069655418396,
0.4986921548843384,
-0.45165878534317017,
0.24755597114562988,
-1.0510629415512085,
-0.6959453821182251,
-0.3273546099662781,
-0.2573561668395996,
-0.7398937940597534,
0.1934223771095276,
0.007379699032753706,
0.40930312871932983,
-0.50713711977005,
0.060342513024806976,
-0.21543383598327637,
0.7411748170852661,
0.8958165049552917,
0.3144616186618805,
0.5436341762542725,
0.1219993308186531,
0.0857681855559349,
0.21403437852859497,
-0.8299363255500793,
-0.39566129446029663,
1.1855251789093018,
0.125470831990242,
0.8026060461997986,
0.12273247539997101,
0.40656280517578125,
0.33663851022720337,
0.2698257565498352,
-0.7918676733970642,
0.3076154589653015,
-0.5352059602737427,
-0.43561726808547974,
-0.4733056128025055,
-0.5044870972633362,
-1.0958354473114014,
0.017355211079120636,
-0.13906992971897125,
-0.6239226460456848,
0.33956390619277954,
0.18748027086257935,
-0.5666686296463013,
1.0357356071472168,
-0.6177921891212463,
0.5442968010902405,
0.036479610949754715,
-0.274981290102005,
-0.17412659525871277,
-0.4465707242488861,
0.47412702441215515,
-0.35438641905784607,
0.2236822247505188,
0.16386310756206512,
0.19812390208244324,
0.8858479857444763,
-0.4600997865200043,
1.267950415611267,
-0.11141189187765121,
-0.07683031260967255,
0.41375821828842163,
0.1481495201587677,
0.23365724086761475,
-0.23619577288627625,
0.3163313567638397,
0.09470050036907196,
-0.07948773354291916,
-0.35103723406791687,
-0.44298556447029114,
0.5822544693946838,
-0.946541965007782,
-0.7331243753433228,
-0.3078215718269348,
-0.4306599497795105,
-0.05111625790596008,
0.32634395360946655,
0.8727828860282898,
0.27050143480300903,
-0.14566320180892944,
0.3895569443702698,
0.9222201108932495,
-0.13573862612247467,
0.5683525800704956,
0.7049563527107239,
0.057292740792036057,
-0.07462573051452637,
1.0408012866973877,
0.13737702369689941,
0.24362421035766602,
0.40400248765945435,
0.09175384789705276,
-0.37876927852630615,
-0.775239884853363,
-0.1545693427324295,
0.14442329108715057,
-0.7469801306724548,
-0.22840839624404907,
-0.39873701333999634,
-0.5758354663848877,
-0.23186823725700378,
-0.07118814438581467,
-0.2948412001132965,
0.05359084904193878,
-0.7542462348937988,
-0.14602048695087433,
0.05812890827655792,
1.1345655918121338,
-0.387602835893631,
0.5008247494697571,
-0.7230268716812134,
0.02223154902458191,
0.3293808400630951,
0.44019240140914917,
0.3060991168022156,
-1.1484129428863525,
-0.18699052929878235,
0.29301130771636963,
-0.45800888538360596,
-0.48316460847854614,
0.26137804985046387,
0.38709256052970886,
0.6476695537567139,
0.8215724229812622,
0.28332388401031494,
0.5546358227729797,
-0.4878169000148773,
0.47170117497444153,
0.07465831190347672,
-0.9573163390159607,
0.24557164311408997,
-0.005719392094761133,
0.1695394068956375,
0.4725489020347595,
0.486742228269577,
-0.7080460786819458,
-0.4432953894138336,
-0.6730419397354126,
-0.9992002844810486,
0.6190417408943176,
-0.17522072792053223,
0.5875524878501892,
0.11533991247415543,
0.6834645867347717,
0.34074169397354126,
0.4073258638381958,
-0.46037694811820984,
-0.052165959030389786,
-0.1744493991136551,
0.07712388783693314,
-0.2690562307834625,
-0.5337601900100708,
-0.03520591929554939,
-0.24323925375938416,
0.7848556041717529,
0.29246407747268677,
0.028077861294150352,
-0.14938829839229584,
-0.33101126551628113,
-0.4770492613315582,
0.2579841911792755,
0.3598918318748474,
0.7244406938552856,
0.007161399349570274,
-0.024309055879712105,
-0.04720254987478256,
-0.4075342118740082,
0.11158622056245804,
-0.41538962721824646,
-0.6397829055786133,
-0.5693764686584473,
0.4613664746284485,
0.7665086388587952,
0.3394688367843628,
-0.7288311123847961,
0.578525960445404,
0.28165242075920105,
-0.3540443778038025,
-0.602118730545044,
0.19644446671009064,
-0.1836535930633545,
0.07216087728738785,
0.10300977528095245,
0.08349975198507309,
-0.13835054636001587,
-0.7466632127761841,
0.3717060983181,
0.5329872965812683,
-0.8224543929100037,
-0.22344397008419037,
0.7096638679504395,
-0.05004936456680298,
-0.14710792899131775,
1.3057676553726196,
-0.10565119236707687,
-0.3019351661205292,
0.4392945468425751,
0.5460261106491089,
0.7350790500640869,
-0.31132423877716064,
0.2260875403881073,
0.10816796123981476,
0.3268374800682068,
-0.3702778220176697,
-0.09738129377365112,
0.00842063408344984,
-0.8647952675819397,
-0.5124718546867371,
-0.38235190510749817,
-0.32924243807792664,
0.4868909418582916,
-0.8457210659980774,
-0.21352508664131165,
-0.616594672203064,
0.3297423720359802,
-0.3466980755329132,
-0.30917492508888245,
-0.45819568634033203,
0.09939202666282654,
-0.2148798555135727,
0.7515612244606018,
-0.8507544994354248,
0.6076079607009888,
0.5319956541061401,
-0.5354324579238892,
-0.6353536248207092,
-0.0052297827787697315,
0.1345483362674713,
-0.8887725472450256,
0.2072540521621704,
0.15245066583156586,
0.2665857970714569,
0.12081825733184814,
-0.8197979927062988,
-0.47903919219970703,
0.8901805877685547,
0.38006389141082764,
-0.380237877368927,
-0.06141311302781105,
0.07663064450025558,
0.4416002929210663,
-0.13098205626010895,
-0.1104627251625061,
0.37163424491882324,
0.09488589316606522,
0.4240838885307312,
-0.5123800039291382,
-0.032640788704156876,
-0.04303208738565445,
-0.20471645891666412,
0.1696542352437973,
-0.4620315134525299,
0.9285208582878113,
-0.4660768210887909,
-0.5283334851264954,
0.23082512617111206,
0.7485736012458801,
-0.3396604359149933,
0.14693555235862732,
0.3322862386703491,
0.5769806504249573,
0.8214082717895508,
-0.034835733473300934,
0.8250059485435486,
0.06143257021903992,
0.21477000415325165,
1.043857455253601,
-0.12350975722074509,
0.7868447303771973,
0.22468601167201996,
-0.057366743683815,
0.2880953848361969,
0.5904775261878967,
-0.016788480803370476,
0.587448000907898,
0.1398123949766159,
-0.2667997181415558,
-0.36639294028282166,
-0.18030013144016266,
-0.10854937881231308,
0.7580702900886536,
0.2819007933139801,
-0.2910151183605194,
-0.3468019664287567,
0.315884530544281,
0.254391610622406,
0.27069035172462463,
-0.40890583395957947,
1.245114803314209,
0.1986171007156372,
-0.6006003618240356,
0.4888828694820404,
0.0010828281519934535,
0.5228889584541321,
-0.62384432554245,
-0.02492648921906948,
-0.3533434569835663,
0.2699616849422455,
-0.333461195230484,
-0.8186163902282715,
0.358589768409729,
0.08245496451854706,
-0.07650237530469894,
-0.14361996948719025,
0.42764219641685486,
-0.5328106880187988,
-0.04679809510707855,
0.34196195006370544,
0.6892082095146179,
0.2767102122306824,
-0.2818583846092224,
-0.4181130528450012,
-0.4154722988605499,
0.2203379124403,
-0.017636537551879883,
0.692379891872406,
0.540286660194397,
-0.04762595519423485,
0.8893061876296997,
0.8287070989608765,
0.12236622720956802,
-0.229476198554039,
0.055860355496406555,
0.9129870533943176,
-0.3813602030277252,
-0.431300550699234,
-0.9271710515022278,
0.3752347528934479,
0.2930145263671875,
-0.07222124934196472,
0.6369322538375854,
0.37391790747642517,
1.1608859300613403,
0.3448829650878906,
0.9019125699996948,
0.1592029482126236,
0.2866189479827881,
-0.8024630546569824,
1.0200475454330444,
-0.9436450004577637,
0.46852636337280273,
0.160727858543396,
-0.7448092103004456,
-0.2234395295381546,
0.15138040482997894,
-0.005332228261977434,
0.24946556985378265,
0.523013174533844,
0.4700005352497101,
0.015079351142048836,
0.28753435611724854,
0.7256055474281311,
0.24302954971790314,
0.18477356433868408,
0.351606160402298,
0.8864369988441467,
-0.051027562469244,
0.5232059955596924,
-0.35708969831466675,
-0.3872848153114319,
0.06442182511091232,
-0.614009439945221,
-0.862464427947998,
-0.8138329982757568,
0.024672260507941246,
-0.28350192308425903,
0.25966784358024597,
0.7520290613174438,
0.37638214230537415,
-0.9076305627822876,
-0.2743188440799713,
-0.3563889265060425,
0.2861424386501312,
-0.3004003167152405,
-0.1489185392856598,
0.4421609044075012,
-0.4308316111564636,
-0.61312335729599,
0.42817679047584534,
0.07389269769191742,
0.3357963562011719,
-0.39355477690696716,
-0.01090813335031271,
-0.019747454673051834,
-0.22810888290405273,
0.5799797773361206,
0.979668140411377,
-0.6660864949226379,
-0.07364261895418167,
-0.323163777589798,
0.2470090389251709,
0.006768396589905024,
0.8020479679107666,
-0.649422824382782,
0.4654189348220825,
0.25409597158432007,
0.5353270769119263,
0.16082800924777985,
-0.01418771967291832,
0.45934468507766724,
-0.8763254880905151,
0.033191025257110596,
0.10392288118600845,
0.3801788091659546,
0.38357385993003845,
-0.3375917673110962,
0.15230236947536469,
0.2307954877614975,
-0.5838355422019958,
-0.7685162425041199,
0.4339081048965454,
-0.34682387113571167,
-0.6619668006896973,
1.1727935075759888,
-0.3034713566303253,
-0.4122444987297058,
-0.4263518452644348,
0.20234669744968414,
0.4473892152309418,
-0.4289746582508087,
0.8338338732719421,
0.42994120717048645,
0.06535500288009644,
-0.1017058789730072,
-0.5727787613868713,
0.7216863632202148,
0.25246623158454895,
-0.45149922370910645,
0.39482247829437256,
0.24604348838329315,
0.3217197358608246,
-0.09077560156583786,
0.54152512550354,
-0.14018939435482025,
0.1379719078540802,
-0.26898422837257385,
0.08021512627601624,
-0.397484689950943,
-0.5509470701217651,
-0.6235358119010925,
0.20997123420238495,
0.01577657274901867,
-0.17241708934307098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19032v1 | Improving Weak-to-Strong Generalization with Reliability-Aware Alignment | 2024-06-27T09:37:34 | 2024-06-27T09:37:34 | Yue Guo, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are now rapidly advancing and surpassing human
abilities on many natural language tasks. However, aligning these super-human
LLMs with human knowledge remains challenging because the supervision signals
from human annotators may be wrong. This issue, known as the "super-alignment"
problem, requires enhancing weak-to-strong generalization, where a strong LLM
must generalize from imperfect supervision provided by a weaker source. To
address this issue, we propose an approach to improve weak-to-strong
generalization by involving the reliability of weak supervision signals in the
alignment process. In our method, we query the weak supervisor for multiple
answers, estimate the answer reliability, and enhance the alignment process by
filtering out uncertain data or re-weighting reliable data. Experiments on four
datasets demonstrate that our methods effectively identify the quality of weak
labels and significantly enhance weak-to-strong generalization. Our work
presents effective techniques for error-robust model alignment, reducing error
propagation from noisy supervision and enhancing the accuracy and reliability
of LLMs. Codes are publicly available at
http://github.com/Irenehere/ReliableAlignment. | [
0.0884237065911293,
-0.552982747554779,
0.6127623915672302,
0.10332529991865158,
-0.19985175132751465,
0.051464349031448364,
-0.5403856039047241,
-0.4604460597038269,
0.1422569900751114,
0.444769948720932,
-0.26551109552383423,
-0.515764057636261,
-0.8607403635978699,
-0.090675950050354,
-0.41986083984375,
1.1501922607421875,
-0.18510854244232178,
0.07574819773435593,
-0.34352174401283264,
-0.3771771490573883,
-0.5155825614929199,
-0.22419461607933044,
-0.32743313908576965,
-0.41608864068984985,
0.4396497309207916,
0.4983920753002167,
1.267744541168213,
0.9442777633666992,
0.844763994216919,
0.31168708205223083,
-0.257220596075058,
0.3140650689601898,
-0.6314250826835632,
0.3847355246543884,
-0.4020642936229706,
-0.4180094599723816,
-0.9887358546257019,
-0.3979938328266144,
0.7456669211387634,
0.8567410111427307,
-0.3264450132846832,
0.06783720850944519,
0.33802545070648193,
0.4022003412246704,
-0.5294875502586365,
-0.014953652396798134,
-0.659820556640625,
-0.4515976905822754,
-0.3185083270072937,
0.2242400348186493,
-0.2573322057723999,
-0.4461900293827057,
0.02820788323879242,
-0.5816748142242432,
0.2874717712402344,
-0.07137540727853775,
1.3361899852752686,
0.4016726613044739,
-0.32503122091293335,
0.07735120505094528,
-0.9058876633644104,
0.9801556468009949,
-0.7656559944152832,
0.5148434638977051,
0.47875699400901794,
0.19146667420864105,
-0.36538809537887573,
-0.39438697695732117,
-0.3274838328361511,
-0.02290245145559311,
-0.027454668655991554,
0.08506612479686737,
0.11884193867444992,
0.09697738289833069,
0.11848177015781403,
0.2933307886123657,
-0.5333760380744934,
0.26023730635643005,
-0.02411792427301407,
-0.4573706090450287,
0.5770968794822693,
0.06327244639396667,
0.3149823546409607,
0.2869791090488434,
-0.17307046055793762,
-0.02179710753262043,
-0.5836489796638489,
-0.4955042898654938,
0.5108853578567505,
0.4583525061607361,
0.11025087535381317,
0.6794288158416748,
-0.07740876823663712,
0.7638674378395081,
0.33085572719573975,
-0.28927016258239746,
0.2539790868759155,
-0.702569842338562,
0.020820997655391693,
0.016278626397252083,
0.7053868770599365,
0.34129831194877625,
0.23353563249111176,
-0.3842703700065613,
-0.29239609837532043,
0.10698273032903671,
0.40910622477531433,
-0.2980879545211792,
-0.06492256373167038,
0.3094329833984375,
-0.17891305685043335,
-0.14641743898391724,
0.032632358372211456,
-0.5020349025726318,
-0.3321632444858551,
-0.433860719203949,
0.43076327443122864,
-0.4150446653366089,
-0.1614154875278473,
0.03885248675942421,
0.19481997191905975,
0.30916517972946167,
0.19262507557868958,
-1.245792031288147,
0.014125010930001736,
0.69930100440979,
0.5539566874504089,
0.1442575305700302,
-0.356525182723999,
-0.6256871223449707,
0.5824555158615112,
-0.3663271367549896,
0.6101478338241577,
-0.2796764671802521,
0.19183386862277985,
-0.1710258275270462,
-0.041779231280088425,
0.06743431091308594,
-0.5552396774291992,
0.996911346912384,
-0.41462159156799316,
0.06316199153661728,
-0.09979977458715439,
-0.6120516657829285,
0.31989240646362305,
0.2488781064748764,
-0.41355445981025696,
1.0427786111831665,
0.13772545754909515,
-0.8166094422340393,
0.30557507276535034,
0.019396189600229263,
-0.3617977201938629,
-0.21510690450668335,
-0.05794716253876686,
-0.9928187131881714,
0.14052516222000122,
0.5435093641281128,
0.48527371883392334,
-0.052968159317970276,
0.722240686416626,
-0.6551769375801086,
-0.5147297978401184,
0.03753970190882683,
-0.2925710082054138,
0.6433351039886475,
-0.15540775656700134,
-0.30178502202033997,
0.19566170871257782,
-0.6621710658073425,
-0.01370821800082922,
0.11615893989801407,
-0.30017608404159546,
-0.39370906352996826,
0.1592075675725937,
-0.40588560700416565,
-0.173937126994133,
0.5277273058891296,
-0.33020249009132385,
0.3964223265647888,
-0.43570154905319214,
-0.103963702917099,
0.9152930378913879,
-0.24749599397182465,
0.594265341758728,
-0.3398001492023468,
0.31669700145721436,
-0.18995703756809235,
0.26896947622299194,
0.2284209132194519,
-0.3267338275909424,
-0.7520020008087158,
-0.16610562801361084,
0.4860078692436218,
0.6142739057540894,
-0.5754124522209167,
0.7691901326179504,
-0.6660736799240112,
-0.4552847146987915,
-0.5983169078826904,
0.9023087024688721,
0.6850957274436951,
0.7362755537033081,
0.6749958395957947,
-0.21777257323265076,
-0.7434840202331543,
-0.8830626606941223,
-0.2810148596763611,
-0.39812082052230835,
-0.12391361594200134,
-0.1392069160938263,
0.11455723643302917,
-0.6359373331069946,
0.8842999339103699,
-0.387412428855896,
-0.25656434893608093,
-0.2396363765001297,
0.07528971135616302,
0.3357754349708557,
0.6216980218887329,
0.2113787829875946,
-0.5494186282157898,
-0.21244417130947113,
-0.08667489141225815,
-0.9873842000961304,
-0.3140767514705658,
0.021546902135014534,
-0.4300747215747833,
-0.020692605525255203,
0.4908563494682312,
-0.6198871731758118,
-0.020418882369995117,
0.6444573402404785,
-0.22684548795223236,
0.6888725757598877,
-0.06452193111181259,
-0.1684642881155014,
-1.2192577123641968,
0.032664600759744644,
0.15175402164459229,
-0.155039981007576,
-0.5630227327346802,
0.056382760405540466,
0.16456730663776398,
0.2326182723045349,
-0.14957112073898315,
0.15107181668281555,
-0.56458979845047,
0.07126609981060028,
-0.12476087361574173,
0.10317468643188477,
-0.06275399029254913,
0.07524046301841736,
-0.21975068747997284,
0.48698559403419495,
0.6490281224250793,
-0.3020630478858948,
0.4065268039703369,
0.34791427850723267,
-0.08603425323963165,
0.8715054392814636,
-0.5774675607681274,
0.23816189169883728,
-0.25180065631866455,
0.3805209994316101,
-0.973493754863739,
-0.4656105935573578,
0.2528497278690338,
-0.27638620138168335,
0.7101423144340515,
-0.4588227868080139,
-0.3618229925632477,
-0.1442180722951889,
-0.0876341387629509,
0.32848477363586426,
0.09875651448965073,
-0.5019788146018982,
0.7241753339767456,
0.13030502200126648,
-0.27333584427833557,
-0.9764062762260437,
-0.6398809552192688,
0.2353401631116867,
-0.23636528849601746,
-0.745457112789154,
0.32447460293769836,
0.22744259238243103,
-0.20049430429935455,
-0.04278141260147095,
-0.4939750134944916,
-0.011632375419139862,
0.05572456866502762,
0.06564781814813614,
0.48352283239364624,
-0.24308642745018005,
0.2806740403175354,
-0.08169210702180862,
-0.34270575642585754,
-0.2062385082244873,
-0.4415871798992157,
0.13773392140865326,
-0.11424198001623154,
-0.4081476032733917,
-0.5235816240310669,
0.2151380330324173,
0.6426877379417419,
-0.038531992584466934,
0.7338842749595642,
0.6854770183563232,
-0.4931478798389435,
0.04788516089320183,
-0.693580687046051,
-0.2695721387863159,
-0.43530815839767456,
0.3162950277328491,
-0.006276350002735853,
-0.8362382054328918,
0.31064125895500183,
0.06806410849094391,
0.11453104764223099,
0.22144751250743866,
0.14080068469047546,
-0.5208824872970581,
1.273350715637207,
0.775714635848999,
-0.4794353246688843,
0.30732327699661255,
0.10131267458200455,
0.12614862620830536,
-0.744516909122467,
-0.04655242711305618,
-0.5375141501426697,
-0.4188053607940674,
-0.0675349161028862,
-0.2188088446855545,
0.026919344440102577,
0.5227357745170593,
-0.2285144180059433,
0.6047182679176331,
-0.47720766067504883,
0.43632352352142334,
0.37851688265800476,
0.21076896786689758,
0.3071598708629608,
-0.046097006648778915,
0.003697013948112726,
-0.2084350734949112,
-0.5075700879096985,
-0.7402334213256836,
1.1119076013565063,
0.48306554555892944,
1.1074966192245483,
0.37404364347457886,
0.7820016145706177,
-0.1440427601337433,
0.560161828994751,
-0.5362929701805115,
0.4998306930065155,
-0.2636494040489197,
-0.49795907735824585,
-0.40877851843833923,
-0.6458608508110046,
-0.7021231651306152,
-0.006512187886983156,
-0.397431880235672,
-0.7991382479667664,
0.11422900855541229,
0.6225329041481018,
-0.20053894817829132,
0.23163500428199768,
-0.7492181658744812,
0.8921782970428467,
-0.5714938044548035,
-0.4631473124027252,
0.1536274403333664,
-0.7659835815429688,
0.4695934057235718,
-0.15203857421875,
0.1333846151828766,
-0.08972998708486557,
0.06369557976722717,
0.6598658561706543,
-0.5721017718315125,
0.9348063468933105,
-0.012545901350677013,
-0.3914816379547119,
0.13828177750110626,
-0.2799425721168518,
0.9760313034057617,
-0.10651405900716782,
-0.03023875132203102,
0.03383805975317955,
-0.5081067681312561,
-0.5986325740814209,
-0.7074563503265381,
0.5980304479598999,
-0.6071204543113708,
-0.47761285305023193,
-0.1356402188539505,
-0.6364256739616394,
-0.5124760270118713,
0.09743984043598175,
0.3415044844150543,
0.1562783420085907,
0.09522117674350739,
0.17407524585723877,
0.7707878351211548,
0.23723843693733215,
0.014512076042592525,
0.17078596353530884,
-0.10087631642818451,
-0.5337967872619629,
1.0359925031661987,
0.29613766074180603,
0.35078707337379456,
0.28323009610176086,
0.12176503986120224,
-0.4300219416618347,
-0.8083222508430481,
-0.3511461615562439,
0.3433437645435333,
-0.5981940031051636,
-0.44053512811660767,
-0.3723972737789154,
0.053547509014606476,
-0.5083481669425964,
-0.28306663036346436,
-0.6015975475311279,
-0.2859503924846649,
-0.3413742482662201,
-0.22002652287483215,
0.11238795518875122,
0.3414314389228821,
-0.03686791658401489,
0.4406057894229889,
-0.8102854490280151,
0.4121605455875397,
0.5410135984420776,
0.5585675239562988,
-0.31354212760925293,
-0.6204665899276733,
-0.2787032425403595,
0.09384645521640778,
-0.34620460867881775,
-0.7386528253555298,
-0.1823592483997345,
0.2459636628627777,
0.5282179713249207,
0.6223900318145752,
-0.11636345833539963,
0.9167221188545227,
-0.16202877461910248,
0.3892045021057129,
0.34490472078323364,
-0.9289860129356384,
0.6207559704780579,
-0.4764474332332611,
0.2997385859489441,
0.8753981590270996,
0.18643894791603088,
-0.13659901916980743,
-0.8879848718643188,
-0.5378419160842896,
-1.1265314817428589,
0.2523758113384247,
0.26925498247146606,
-0.06022769585251808,
0.14010165631771088,
0.5362149477005005,
-0.2548166513442993,
-0.14233839511871338,
-0.5876996517181396,
-0.012290163896977901,
-0.10689554363489151,
-0.627785861492157,
-0.14705899357795715,
-0.2662584185600281,
-0.1944679319858551,
-0.12049910426139832,
0.95176100730896,
-0.309059739112854,
-0.08637753129005432,
-0.04824203625321388,
-0.19476673007011414,
-0.36721688508987427,
0.47958114743232727,
0.4892478287220001,
0.7271194458007812,
-0.3815310597419739,
0.42520350217819214,
0.326859712600708,
-0.4901306629180908,
0.5033800005912781,
0.2109447866678238,
-0.1503012329339981,
-0.14131125807762146,
0.6044474840164185,
0.23485781252384186,
0.3012525737285614,
-0.44116249680519104,
0.5314485430717468,
0.03905579075217247,
-0.00846494734287262,
0.13862161338329315,
0.12597522139549255,
0.2939947545528412,
0.18176141381263733,
0.3824332058429718,
0.007012926507741213,
-0.32689738273620605,
-0.2475026696920395,
0.3975871205329895,
0.4842698574066162,
-0.5469934940338135,
-0.21402551233768463,
0.8283742070198059,
0.11192388087511063,
-0.15563362836837769,
0.7338557243347168,
-0.061537615954875946,
-0.4676244556903839,
0.4129302203655243,
0.6629126667976379,
0.6098436117172241,
-0.33452579379081726,
-0.07649318873882294,
0.2573942244052887,
0.4432551860809326,
-0.7182236909866333,
0.2995373606681824,
0.3546070456504822,
-0.9536840319633484,
-0.9265462160110474,
-0.5035269260406494,
-0.5938940048217773,
-0.13123944401741028,
-0.6602666974067688,
0.23631498217582703,
-0.33758899569511414,
-0.4923158884048462,
-0.39040815830230713,
-0.2871357202529907,
-0.3135867714881897,
0.2737330496311188,
0.02576613426208496,
0.36154887080192566,
-1.0017719268798828,
0.7841971516609192,
0.8113874793052673,
-0.268004834651947,
-1.0130815505981445,
0.16454879939556122,
0.042338091880083084,
-0.4527033269405365,
0.32336029410362244,
0.03510564565658569,
-0.13995522260665894,
-0.11505816876888275,
-0.9050779938697815,
-1.0156832933425903,
1.0994504690170288,
0.893153190612793,
-0.9795840978622437,
0.06807256489992142,
-0.16509371995925903,
0.5663707852363586,
0.010171213187277317,
-0.0605192594230175,
0.5169512033462524,
0.5612657070159912,
-0.10643924027681351,
-0.8810975551605225,
0.12638668715953827,
0.024709569290280342,
-0.057229042053222656,
0.5011867880821228,
-0.6430112719535828,
0.1608213633298874,
-0.2957364618778229,
-0.1413787603378296,
0.14939340949058533,
1.045233130455017,
0.38296133279800415,
0.18041463196277618,
0.5123924612998962,
1.1339831352233887,
0.9925596714019775,
-0.2479635328054428,
0.6430827975273132,
0.01080632396042347,
0.3582940101623535,
1.4968739748001099,
-0.21437706053256989,
0.7029401063919067,
0.5936391353607178,
-0.07351883500814438,
0.4518078565597534,
0.2457563877105713,
-0.07382624596357346,
0.1168317198753357,
-0.019503192976117134,
-0.19106650352478027,
-0.5462433695793152,
-0.1532946228981018,
-0.31695058941841125,
0.3261776566505432,
0.1213022917509079,
-0.4080975353717804,
-0.16953681409358978,
-0.43635094165802,
0.047161661088466644,
0.11315906792879105,
-0.22006100416183472,
0.6285080909729004,
-0.01537349447607994,
-0.5642536878585815,
0.5607159733772278,
-0.17580169439315796,
0.7467939853668213,
-0.6053286194801331,
0.07696324586868286,
-0.23798541724681854,
0.296098530292511,
-0.44819939136505127,
-0.7113098502159119,
0.468078076839447,
-0.11245878785848618,
-0.3711211085319519,
-0.22631242871284485,
0.8514684438705444,
-0.5394495129585266,
-0.5507559776306152,
0.2571161389350891,
0.3053801357746124,
-0.004460128489881754,
0.20956918597221375,
-0.4910334050655365,
0.12360204011201859,
-0.21288827061653137,
-0.003116240259259939,
0.41981494426727295,
0.11048518121242523,
-0.07048769295215607,
0.6510481834411621,
0.5596911907196045,
0.17418520152568817,
-0.04722258821129799,
0.19424401223659515,
0.6293278932571411,
-0.49651992321014404,
0.07009745389223099,
-0.9378457069396973,
0.5522477626800537,
-0.18268394470214844,
-0.3516796827316284,
0.7004569172859192,
0.3380436599254608,
0.6474428176879883,
0.3023827075958252,
0.6085880398750305,
0.10815783590078354,
0.25450530648231506,
-0.4241768419742584,
0.621879518032074,
-0.2790491580963135,
0.4181799292564392,
-0.5906428098678589,
-1.355254888534546,
-0.8102186322212219,
0.45042333006858826,
-0.19951944053173065,
-0.08355176448822021,
0.26487627625465393,
1.0507203340530396,
-0.3779171109199524,
-0.3560146391391754,
0.12331234663724899,
0.31821686029434204,
0.29172205924987793,
0.5073129534721375,
0.8697243928909302,
-0.42748498916625977,
1.1199837923049927,
-0.14350421726703644,
-0.1655634045600891,
-0.06719497591257095,
-1.0389561653137207,
-0.42045217752456665,
-0.07606358826160431,
-0.6152568459510803,
-0.6204219460487366,
0.2889949381351471,
0.6359780430793762,
0.7350167632102966,
-0.7665731310844421,
0.07726683467626572,
-0.1795223206281662,
0.3832966089248657,
-0.5440896153450012,
-0.18743188679218292,
0.46564263105392456,
-0.4607205092906952,
-0.5422622561454773,
0.4687720239162445,
0.26614999771118164,
0.2172207534313202,
0.0178819727152586,
-0.2421739399433136,
-0.11547049134969711,
-0.18694311380386353,
0.06092951074242592,
0.42283812165260315,
-0.5441802740097046,
-0.6874706149101257,
-0.2515089511871338,
-0.35480567812919617,
0.018114730715751648,
0.2870253920555115,
-0.2148505449295044,
0.3896915316581726,
0.33949014544487,
0.849642276763916,
-0.12349037081003189,
0.5352699160575867,
0.7420385479927063,
-0.9992977380752563,
-0.45724380016326904,
0.2286762297153473,
0.607036292552948,
0.6854027509689331,
-0.30199331045150757,
0.5797643661499023,
0.2634012699127197,
-0.7913995981216431,
-0.8014535307884216,
0.2507353723049164,
-1.007033109664917,
0.08066798001527786,
1.1683598756790161,
-0.21217483282089233,
-0.0501723438501358,
-0.4612455666065216,
-0.181754931807518,
0.4390130341053009,
-0.19197165966033936,
0.8337100744247437,
0.8318706154823303,
-0.07572858780622482,
0.005647971294820309,
-0.10218455642461777,
0.1268681138753891,
0.8628543019294739,
-0.5632774233818054,
0.1258617788553238,
0.4948405623435974,
0.34539994597435,
0.3039941191673279,
0.43652284145355225,
-0.035995401442050934,
0.1423223614692688,
-0.28049811720848083,
0.10124722123146057,
0.2572641968727112,
-0.28830182552337646,
-0.40707239508628845,
0.285213440656662,
0.2571645677089691,
0.017654774710536003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18977v1 | RoboUniView: Visual-Language Model with Unified View Representation for Robotic Manipulaiton | 2024-06-27T08:13:33 | 2024-06-27T08:13:33 | Fanfan Liu, Feng Yan, Liming Zheng, Chengjian Feng, Yiyang Huang, Lin Ma | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV | Utilizing Vision-Language Models (VLMs) for robotic manipulation represents a
novel paradigm, aiming to enhance the model's ability to generalize to new
objects and instructions. However, due to variations in camera specifications
and mounting positions, existing methods exhibit significant performance
disparities across different robotic platforms. To address this challenge, we
propose RoboUniView in this paper, an innovative approach that decouples visual
feature extraction from action learning. We first learn a unified view
representation from multi-perspective views by pre-training on readily
accessible data, and then derive actions from this unified view representation
to control robotic manipulation. This unified view representation more
accurately mirrors the physical world and is not constrained by the robotic
platform's camera parameters. Thanks to this methodology, we achieve
state-of-the-art performance on the demanding CALVIN benchmark, enhancing the
success rate in the $D \to D$ setting from 88.7% to 96.2%, and in the $ABC \to
D$ setting from 82.4% to 94.2%. Moreover, our model exhibits outstanding
adaptability and flexibility: it maintains high performance under unseen camera
parameters, can utilize multiple datasets with varying camera parameters, and
is capable of joint cross-task learning across datasets. Code is provided for
re-implementation. https://github.com/liufanfanlff/RoboUniview | [
-0.06582801043987274,
-0.5002667307853699,
0.5601357221603394,
-0.13301417231559753,
-0.3095511794090271,
-0.07504810392856598,
-0.0951693207025528,
-0.3866516947746277,
0.48298394680023193,
0.816266655921936,
-0.6325013637542725,
-0.6658430099487305,
-0.837343156337738,
-0.21710243821144104,
-0.37722328305244446,
0.6194243431091309,
-0.10774311423301697,
-0.04655463248491287,
0.1265457421541214,
-0.4661080837249756,
-0.26967939734458923,
-0.4532671570777893,
0.2862395644187927,
-0.18002547323703766,
0.4568527042865753,
-0.01556827500462532,
0.6909602880477905,
0.779199481010437,
0.6891033053398132,
0.3983984589576721,
0.3023727238178253,
0.3800291121006012,
-0.3304055631160736,
-0.27037668228149414,
-0.18191465735435486,
-0.36623868346214294,
-0.5029315948486328,
0.07444310188293457,
0.3446952998638153,
0.8214473128318787,
-0.15777599811553955,
0.05254555866122246,
0.07127834111452103,
0.7406450510025024,
-0.8554137945175171,
0.18313130736351013,
-0.3898674547672272,
0.1005118191242218,
0.1784493625164032,
-0.22253672778606415,
-0.24039454758167267,
-0.02217746153473854,
0.11853791773319244,
-0.8853992819786072,
0.14807970821857452,
-0.09832118451595306,
1.0688576698303223,
0.3283498287200928,
-0.07685063779354095,
0.5279825925827026,
-0.8108313679695129,
0.7349606156349182,
-0.3945055902004242,
0.5281215906143188,
0.07650919258594513,
0.2773698568344116,
-0.25723156332969666,
-0.5460429787635803,
-0.3838152587413788,
-0.3438413441181183,
-0.18124039471149445,
0.5471505522727966,
-0.3548775017261505,
0.3084573447704315,
0.2219976782798767,
0.029193907976150513,
-0.7030786275863647,
-0.009629311040043831,
-0.5453864336013794,
0.13562682271003723,
0.7196305394172668,
0.1395931988954544,
0.1394171267747879,
-0.6119323968887329,
-0.8620700240135193,
-0.3705746531486511,
-0.2702215015888214,
0.17066752910614014,
0.5056739449501038,
0.33986178040504456,
0.014584352262318134,
0.6447346210479736,
-0.39501336216926575,
0.955428421497345,
-0.30636081099510193,
-0.12715356051921844,
0.20012089610099792,
0.08639995008707047,
-0.7096793055534363,
-0.7175960540771484,
0.9534982442855835,
0.6979143023490906,
-0.00879644975066185,
-0.026147546246647835,
-0.030567403882741928,
-0.08674947172403336,
0.6258789896965027,
-0.4255616068840027,
-0.9076640009880066,
0.3225698471069336,
-0.635736882686615,
-0.14356788992881775,
0.6494534611701965,
-0.5585286617279053,
-0.4393104612827301,
-0.6088381409645081,
0.5509886145591736,
-0.4575601816177368,
-0.5465515851974487,
0.18798047304153442,
-0.12366277724504471,
0.047823820263147354,
1.014443278312683,
-0.5553917288780212,
0.20153382420539856,
0.41370874643325806,
0.6379896998405457,
-0.4381569027900696,
-0.5801547169685364,
-0.7478341460227966,
0.3642953932285309,
-0.3280433118343353,
0.6120985150337219,
-0.27144718170166016,
-0.19502544403076172,
0.02873307280242443,
0.3143947720527649,
-0.3163793087005615,
-0.767625093460083,
-0.2086939513683319,
-0.30083268880844116,
0.1612681746482849,
0.22312584519386292,
-0.21011582016944885,
-0.8714695572853088,
0.37578636407852173,
-0.9154916405677795,
0.7275245785713196,
0.3976390063762665,
-0.2656099498271942,
0.5169284343719482,
-0.7781805396080017,
-0.3061138093471527,
0.30645236372947693,
-0.3384687602519989,
-0.18624281883239746,
0.021751029416918755,
0.1278311163187027,
0.6621877551078796,
0.029178909957408905,
0.24734337627887726,
-0.3597933351993561,
0.09229773283004761,
-0.10794103890657425,
-0.3779856562614441,
0.7961222529411316,
-0.2764337658882141,
-0.11700987070798874,
0.5918029546737671,
-0.6934488415718079,
0.04486946016550064,
0.05965450406074524,
-0.022439725697040558,
-0.21233966946601868,
-0.15643206238746643,
0.21481110155582428,
0.24112200736999512,
0.141130730509758,
-0.3142411708831787,
0.3913052976131439,
-0.17277225852012634,
-0.10079943388700485,
0.4610438346862793,
-0.3382374346256256,
0.5470631718635559,
0.17262312769889832,
0.6957978010177612,
-0.12300752103328705,
0.2892824113368988,
-0.11640159785747528,
-0.2510281801223755,
-0.37400537729263306,
-0.7405457496643066,
0.14016099274158478,
0.8283541798591614,
-0.8306945562362671,
0.5157478451728821,
0.032166436314582825,
-0.1417122185230255,
-0.39697492122650146,
0.4869026839733124,
0.5393832325935364,
0.46427908539772034,
0.5289958715438843,
-0.4321669042110443,
-0.45015618205070496,
-0.8830880522727966,
-0.055194709450006485,
-0.1859525591135025,
-0.48945480585098267,
0.046622566878795624,
0.3874069154262543,
-0.0005185542977415025,
0.6483694314956665,
-0.5553793907165527,
-0.44409269094467163,
-0.7025240063667297,
0.21504497528076172,
0.061645496636629105,
0.37759509682655334,
0.634274423122406,
-1.074979543685913,
0.2091219276189804,
0.2961495816707611,
-1.0375696420669556,
0.24680876731872559,
-0.08813679218292236,
-0.2600523829460144,
0.466317743062973,
0.5548442006111145,
-0.5479211211204529,
1.1779022216796875,
0.7775564193725586,
0.13123925030231476,
0.30757802724838257,
-0.322321355342865,
0.28814560174942017,
-0.9618861079216003,
0.07007542997598648,
0.24791763722896576,
-0.47077903151512146,
-0.25967952609062195,
0.48247820138931274,
-0.016695929691195488,
0.154070645570755,
-0.7433465123176575,
0.15938621759414673,
-0.41832372546195984,
-0.11758597940206528,
-0.40661942958831787,
0.45684465765953064,
-0.116656094789505,
0.8070464730262756,
0.4269239008426666,
0.1265326589345932,
0.4046371281147003,
-0.6865465044975281,
0.7021154165267944,
-0.08129894733428955,
-0.0343569852411747,
0.3485320806503296,
-0.4892306327819824,
-0.48016121983528137,
0.12996049225330353,
0.06883556395769119,
-0.9261036515235901,
-0.5966820120811462,
0.5306330919265747,
-0.3229932188987732,
0.15958209335803986,
-0.6236259341239929,
-0.43595200777053833,
-0.4310624599456787,
-0.26420873403549194,
-0.048728086054325104,
0.2933703660964966,
-0.8093226552009583,
1.2143052816390991,
0.25237998366355896,
0.24662135541439056,
-0.46767690777778625,
-0.43601492047309875,
-0.10880859196186066,
-0.0761183574795723,
-0.41897931694984436,
0.17629574239253998,
0.2072519212961197,
-0.11200208216905594,
0.0863228365778923,
-0.12574099004268646,
0.15569628775119781,
-0.16671635210514069,
0.3660781979560852,
0.7936811447143555,
0.1440402716398239,
-0.12333888560533524,
-0.001960400491952896,
-0.46373680233955383,
-0.09827465564012527,
-0.13263453543186188,
0.5562352538108826,
0.03158828616142273,
-0.42191970348358154,
-0.7546217441558838,
0.3330412209033966,
0.42643120884895325,
-0.1875675469636917,
0.3959992527961731,
0.5431678891181946,
-0.2280450463294983,
-0.16061359643936157,
-0.11958078294992447,
-0.1263866126537323,
-0.46249479055404663,
0.8223600387573242,
-0.12564300000667572,
-0.41161835193634033,
0.22315280139446259,
-0.5851002335548401,
0.14998120069503784,
0.1615600883960724,
0.3440573215484619,
-0.4563024342060089,
0.8385363817214966,
0.9973048567771912,
0.03479471430182457,
0.6810258030891418,
-0.7117056250572205,
0.09019019454717636,
-0.875748336315155,
-0.43092435598373413,
0.07514644414186478,
-0.5832517743110657,
-0.6043014526367188,
-0.5747095346450806,
0.3286398947238922,
0.228534996509552,
-0.00937811378389597,
0.8464025855064392,
-0.3664669692516327,
0.3156836926937103,
0.5664857029914856,
0.20677639544010162,
0.24256324768066406,
0.07223383337259293,
0.20766223967075348,
-0.12453661113977432,
-0.7131981253623962,
-0.6006920337677002,
0.9308964610099792,
-0.1985422968864441,
0.8168179988861084,
0.029209613800048828,
0.7030525207519531,
0.08600477129220963,
0.024829396978020668,
-0.8033691048622131,
0.8597529530525208,
-0.40172359347343445,
-0.0541437603533268,
-0.31032097339630127,
-0.27484390139579773,
-0.9060897827148438,
0.6059252619743347,
-0.19484907388687134,
-1.151693344116211,
-0.06069524958729744,
0.3875765800476074,
-0.3749842941761017,
0.7031093835830688,
-0.7371021509170532,
0.9289849400520325,
-0.36159807443618774,
-0.3675726354122162,
-0.11680897325277328,
-0.8875657320022583,
0.3473218083381653,
0.627345860004425,
-0.08942466229200363,
-0.03334185481071472,
0.05273089185357094,
0.476042240858078,
-0.42967134714126587,
0.7689947485923767,
-0.22753378748893738,
-0.08763419836759567,
0.13515718281269073,
0.35394683480262756,
0.09993322938680649,
0.284510999917984,
0.5324593782424927,
0.3831377327442169,
-0.20584218204021454,
-0.1988207995891571,
-0.9237843751907349,
0.3364080786705017,
-0.6983543634414673,
-0.4444955587387085,
-0.257904976606369,
-0.7746320962905884,
0.04022729769349098,
0.10950720310211182,
0.17444083094596863,
0.4485985338687897,
-0.06433284282684326,
0.09535950422286987,
0.5867918729782104,
-0.09293394535779953,
0.5990510582923889,
0.3604904115200043,
-0.9025537371635437,
-0.26970624923706055,
0.9355633854866028,
-0.14297151565551758,
0.47488340735435486,
0.7928372621536255,
-0.14286422729492188,
0.16228480637073517,
-0.262378066778183,
-0.616212010383606,
-0.10238795727491379,
-0.32210153341293335,
-0.3923845589160919,
-0.7326269149780273,
-0.18417896330356598,
-0.1008848026394844,
-0.32672691345214844,
-0.731033444404602,
-0.4603603184223175,
-0.28195732831954956,
-0.11123076826334,
0.5171374678611755,
0.6767660975456238,
-0.4001283347606659,
0.36811548471450806,
-0.6158725023269653,
1.0705806016921997,
0.5237334370613098,
0.10044313967227936,
-0.38219261169433594,
-0.4275878369808197,
0.043828632682561874,
-0.10990015417337418,
-0.4343944489955902,
-0.4398725926876068,
0.6781345009803772,
-0.2996145784854889,
0.4039144515991211,
0.35123878717422485,
-0.09873402118682861,
0.820275068283081,
-0.23855632543563843,
0.6762775778770447,
0.4897768199443817,
-0.5894457697868347,
0.8053870797157288,
-0.3776010572910309,
0.24273422360420227,
0.32831230759620667,
0.3451741933822632,
-0.030302146449685097,
-0.3821823298931122,
-0.7281724810600281,
-1.109732985496521,
0.7560701370239258,
0.005385694094002247,
-0.11606884002685547,
0.5988975763320923,
0.03456246107816696,
0.33149421215057373,
0.3619188070297241,
-0.4426482319831848,
-0.1859491765499115,
-0.17983746528625488,
-0.09354949742555618,
0.2525317966938019,
0.49080803990364075,
-0.41050809621810913,
-0.5639031529426575,
0.3049964904785156,
-0.3544212877750397,
0.31368890404701233,
0.018697060644626617,
-0.24353930354118347,
-0.05112340673804283,
-0.32477086782455444,
0.3913506865501404,
0.748420774936676,
-0.20535457134246826,
-0.28257450461387634,
-0.1346099078655243,
-0.7054570317268372,
-0.4041575789451599,
0.3498196303844452,
-0.09344620257616043,
-0.04453121870756149,
0.5437312126159668,
0.6080834865570068,
0.19199523329734802,
-0.6090007424354553,
0.5655319094657898,
0.04563242197036743,
-0.3793581426143646,
-0.1931626945734024,
0.49040329456329346,
-0.27453574538230896,
0.5213386416435242,
0.32738685607910156,
0.6173673868179321,
0.23331409692764282,
-0.43190309405326843,
0.03378274664282799,
0.320088267326355,
-0.363807737827301,
-0.3985629975795746,
0.7609661817550659,
0.08746650815010071,
-0.21978287398815155,
0.5215924382209778,
-0.07226384431123734,
-0.38332605361938477,
0.6250077486038208,
-0.028847070410847664,
0.990459144115448,
-0.13763836026191711,
0.5221821069717407,
0.3251906931400299,
0.381995290517807,
0.04854189604520798,
0.5648173093795776,
-0.014062185771763325,
-0.6382662653923035,
-0.35724836587905884,
-0.27437740564346313,
-0.35918930172920227,
0.18988032639026642,
-1.078348994255066,
0.22222602367401123,
-0.6551473736763,
0.20319077372550964,
-0.28693222999572754,
-0.33765292167663574,
-0.8500068783760071,
0.21016716957092285,
0.03598324581980705,
0.4528156816959381,
-0.4660109579563141,
0.8380346298217773,
0.8748623728752136,
-0.5086814761161804,
-0.7379184365272522,
0.11620645225048065,
0.27597957849502563,
-0.8292906284332275,
0.5976585149765015,
0.14018988609313965,
-0.671348512172699,
-0.5541249513626099,
-0.9078786969184875,
-0.5601657032966614,
1.1439456939697266,
0.5526952147483826,
-0.621902585029602,
0.30900219082832336,
-0.236159086227417,
0.28172215819358826,
-0.4920445382595062,
-0.039587318897247314,
0.2891786992549896,
0.24104294180870056,
0.12898579239845276,
-0.7664982676506042,
-0.49439650774002075,
-0.22422084212303162,
0.2274905890226364,
0.31916964054107666,
-0.7991302013397217,
0.5616832375526428,
-0.471109002828598,
0.1679101437330246,
0.3516356945037842,
0.8012232780456543,
0.28811192512512207,
0.09183140844106674,
0.2664490044116974,
0.47932755947113037,
0.4970901608467102,
-0.09856658428907394,
1.088321566581726,
0.03618676960468292,
0.27608904242515564,
1.2727527618408203,
-0.33510175347328186,
0.9739881753921509,
0.5487188696861267,
-0.13376592099666595,
0.5735657215118408,
-0.17720139026641846,
0.09255866706371307,
0.7596507668495178,
-0.06507163494825363,
0.06124594435095787,
-0.5609471201896667,
0.1980285495519638,
-0.015150323510169983,
0.9406889081001282,
0.1228964775800705,
-0.2581043243408203,
-0.12465280294418335,
0.38432395458221436,
-0.12433727085590363,
0.4748893678188324,
-0.2831903398036957,
0.6017894148826599,
-0.3314235210418701,
-0.18006260693073273,
0.11995930224657059,
-0.1533881425857544,
0.5123468041419983,
-0.8579609990119934,
-0.5272666811943054,
-0.010226561687886715,
0.33278825879096985,
-0.08038211613893509,
-0.8806927800178528,
-0.04858368635177612,
-0.268412321805954,
-0.20764736831188202,
-0.35645315051078796,
0.590848445892334,
-0.38313642144203186,
-0.607779860496521,
0.6467959880828857,
0.5056798458099365,
0.025153104215860367,
0.042818307876586914,
-0.5260364413261414,
0.32160669565200806,
0.009021132253110409,
-0.24406027793884277,
0.37548911571502686,
0.4584807753562927,
0.10427118837833405,
0.6677674055099487,
0.2848246991634369,
-0.06900068372488022,
-0.10971125215291977,
0.17559131979942322,
0.9609155058860779,
-0.7142433524131775,
-0.23792389035224915,
-0.46997198462486267,
0.9414358735084534,
-0.1568872332572937,
-0.5604944825172424,
0.6189261078834534,
0.36966463923454285,
1.352948546409607,
-0.26614728569984436,
0.7268468141555786,
-0.315435528755188,
0.44349876046180725,
-0.6784632205963135,
0.6302176117897034,
-0.7292684316635132,
-0.10104592144489288,
-0.7206487059593201,
-0.7013511657714844,
-0.6918478012084961,
0.8360768556594849,
-0.14251574873924255,
0.24485209584236145,
0.5552703738212585,
0.6952739357948303,
-0.21730537712574005,
-0.04208539053797722,
0.7431432008743286,
-0.05351785942912102,
0.14816132187843323,
0.30824393033981323,
0.5986999869346619,
-0.7216037511825562,
0.4253883361816406,
-0.4292469620704651,
-0.3215402364730835,
-0.22942382097244263,
-0.8853329420089722,
-0.7607788443565369,
-0.5244614481925964,
-0.5768887996673584,
0.03672927990555763,
0.07739114761352539,
0.9501088261604309,
0.970565915107727,
-0.5179248452186584,
-0.3067705035209656,
0.06510293483734131,
-0.04600119963288307,
-0.7702569365501404,
-0.16506458818912506,
0.29331862926483154,
0.1950293779373169,
-0.7144907712936401,
0.30602025985717773,
0.7596389651298523,
-0.299762099981308,
-0.23544876277446747,
-0.1313154101371765,
-0.2988239526748657,
-0.5524345636367798,
0.883930504322052,
0.5418195724487305,
-0.9587277173995972,
-0.2606094181537628,
-0.0678069069981575,
0.2763214707374573,
0.1333477646112442,
0.8704914450645447,
-1.1898040771484375,
0.6800816655158997,
0.0717969462275505,
0.3113454282283783,
0.1853736937046051,
0.128773495554924,
0.5048733949661255,
-0.51725834608078,
0.5028154253959656,
0.1290653944015503,
0.425081729888916,
0.22911196947097778,
-0.19591958820819855,
0.6095065474510193,
0.3061997890472412,
-0.08672071248292923,
-0.3386363387107849,
0.3599872589111328,
-1.4619337320327759,
-0.1302148401737213,
0.8745207190513611,
-0.12132902443408966,
-0.5380359888076782,
0.205586239695549,
-0.46803146600723267,
0.1028655394911766,
-0.349813312292099,
0.6417747139930725,
0.06285970658063889,
-0.392688125371933,
-0.49783754348754883,
-0.8311643600463867,
-0.04685064032673836,
0.005198851693421602,
-0.875925600528717,
0.24568840861320496,
0.6839519143104553,
0.0683940052986145,
0.2249966412782669,
0.11154457181692123,
-0.34939369559288025,
0.6161143183708191,
-0.18781130015850067,
0.41126328706741333,
-0.18523266911506653,
-0.9741992354393005,
-0.23539569973945618,
0.22375957667827606,
-0.5688810348510742,
-0.6420993804931641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18972v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18972v1 | Applying LLMs for Rescoring N-best ASR Hypotheses of Casual Conversations: Effects of Domain Adaptation and Context Carry-over | 2024-06-27T08:03:13 | 2024-06-27T08:03:13 | Atsunori Ogawa, Naoyuki Kamo, Kohei Matsuura, Takanori Ashihara, Takafumi Moriya, Takatomo Kano, Naohiro Tawara, Marc Delcroix | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been successfully applied for rescoring
automatic speech recognition (ASR) hypotheses. However, their ability to
rescore ASR hypotheses of casual conversations has not been sufficiently
explored. In this study, we reveal it by performing N-best ASR hypotheses
rescoring using Llama2 on the CHiME-7 distant ASR (DASR) task. Llama2 is one of
the most representative LLMs, and the CHiME-7 DASR task provides datasets of
casual conversations between multiple participants. We investigate the effects
of domain adaptation of the LLM and context carry-over when performing N-best
rescoring. Experimental results show that, even without domain adaptation,
Llama2 outperforms a standard-size domain-adapted Transformer-LM, especially
when using a long context. Domain adaptation shortens the context length needed
with Llama2 to achieve its best performance, i.e., it reduces the computational
cost of Llama2. | [
-0.209599569439888,
-0.545802116394043,
0.6259629726409912,
0.20169417560100555,
-0.6607839465141296,
0.21387678384780884,
-0.5437164902687073,
-0.745308518409729,
0.008317675441503525,
0.29285386204719543,
-0.32698336243629456,
-0.33002719283103943,
-0.6383856534957886,
0.3391665816307068,
-0.6590313911437988,
0.7547892928123474,
0.07125186175107956,
-0.19400055706501007,
-0.33210721611976624,
-0.30894866585731506,
-0.4320301115512848,
-0.6432415246963501,
-0.8495954275131226,
-0.4195099174976349,
0.25213417410850525,
0.4600721001625061,
0.26619967818260193,
0.37088483572006226,
0.5187425017356873,
0.26159417629241943,
-0.22477519512176514,
0.17330950498580933,
-0.7426170706748962,
0.2120441496372223,
-0.08407693356275558,
-0.7072071433067322,
-0.47725731134414673,
-0.36336714029312134,
0.8037084937095642,
0.6009848713874817,
-0.25661441683769226,
0.20346307754516602,
0.3979642987251282,
0.3713938295841217,
-0.3686688244342804,
0.023940298706293106,
-0.8061695098876953,
-0.37297508120536804,
-0.15655586123466492,
-0.48469120264053345,
-0.3989987373352051,
-0.26639026403427124,
0.4962552785873413,
-0.40786978602409363,
0.14990569651126862,
0.0584879107773304,
0.5640340447425842,
0.37435033917427063,
-0.44461488723754883,
-0.3572336733341217,
-0.9459840655326843,
0.9259527921676636,
-0.8116331100463867,
0.4241141676902771,
0.6580559611320496,
0.46108201146125793,
-0.22510254383087158,
-0.6017959117889404,
-0.5330761671066284,
-0.1835167109966278,
0.013985628262162209,
-0.14113913476467133,
-0.5185655355453491,
-0.14074495434761047,
0.05355856195092201,
0.0551593154668808,
-0.13300049304962158,
0.1957223266363144,
-0.5495710968971252,
-0.11529523134231567,
0.6039308905601501,
0.20813480019569397,
-0.14991459250450134,
0.16057385504245758,
-0.3623398244380951,
0.12494122982025146,
-0.690341591835022,
-0.02104170061647892,
-0.33851614594459534,
0.07697918266057968,
-0.40531057119369507,
0.1669001281261444,
-0.2544601261615753,
0.5138174891471863,
0.23809313774108887,
-0.5075086355209351,
0.17997513711452484,
-0.35143378376960754,
-0.07418491691350937,
0.23393450677394867,
0.5495568513870239,
0.7169719934463501,
0.3628184199333191,
-0.40045079588890076,
-0.1120370402932167,
0.08901795744895935,
-0.010208426974713802,
-0.6795111894607544,
-0.04369339719414711,
0.025197789072990417,
-0.38908448815345764,
-0.13694876432418823,
-0.34721702337265015,
-0.7463310956954956,
-0.2478332817554474,
-0.3372339904308319,
0.359679251909256,
-0.1585906445980072,
0.10159996896982193,
0.03777758777141571,
-0.1508033722639084,
0.3286576271057129,
0.6453471183776855,
-0.5950157046318054,
0.7199432849884033,
0.6309833526611328,
0.9899982213973999,
-0.6851354837417603,
-0.3349854052066803,
-0.6258648633956909,
0.2234618067741394,
-0.3387037217617035,
1.0548714399337769,
-0.41544291377067566,
-0.5808982849121094,
-0.13127823173999786,
0.0590202659368515,
-0.1080019399523735,
-0.6617580056190491,
0.6343937516212463,
-0.5125192999839783,
0.03829723969101906,
-0.2115275263786316,
-0.33965644240379333,
-0.1205320656299591,
0.06362633407115936,
-0.14745330810546875,
0.8879830241203308,
-0.15609703958034515,
-0.46634605526924133,
0.18400651216506958,
-0.32218047976493835,
-0.7237944602966309,
-0.19071321189403534,
-0.2270858883857727,
-0.2283882349729538,
0.3713877499103546,
-0.06424069404602051,
0.5454556345939636,
-0.6120713353157043,
0.16870594024658203,
-0.14935415983200073,
-0.5381345748901367,
0.6695848107337952,
-0.42657166719436646,
0.3405497372150421,
0.07816747575998306,
-0.6319761872291565,
-0.07744553685188293,
-0.6470586061477661,
-0.39516481757164,
0.15691068768501282,
-0.48903852701187134,
-0.4349900484085083,
0.2569773495197296,
-0.16339439153671265,
-0.05103384330868721,
-0.11542078107595444,
-0.5128697752952576,
-0.07671895623207092,
-0.3054767847061157,
0.4030265510082245,
0.7231767177581787,
0.060277536511421204,
0.5549423694610596,
-0.6607334613800049,
0.1522412896156311,
-0.17747581005096436,
-0.20058202743530273,
0.17147883772850037,
-0.45993176102638245,
-0.9011661410331726,
-0.1779535561800003,
0.17438921332359314,
0.36214524507522583,
-0.6431214213371277,
0.07666203379631042,
-0.5996788740158081,
-0.35182592272758484,
-0.25154349207878113,
0.041655030101537704,
0.332856148481369,
0.4329606592655182,
0.3429432511329651,
-0.3454962372779846,
-0.430936723947525,
-0.5935479402542114,
-0.13318929076194763,
-0.07955924421548843,
-0.1225966066122055,
0.6303085088729858,
0.12075616419315338,
-0.6255260705947876,
0.9644855856895447,
-0.39803552627563477,
-0.3445413112640381,
-0.24842214584350586,
-0.1407986432313919,
0.09605636447668076,
0.16606777906417847,
0.5180032253265381,
-0.3954828381538391,
-0.45379477739334106,
-0.12002183496952057,
-0.5183064341545105,
-0.25520792603492737,
-0.18431226909160614,
-0.004087009001523256,
0.47275301814079285,
0.3155837953090668,
-0.46613451838493347,
0.3571871519088745,
0.625529944896698,
0.005155750550329685,
0.2671463191509247,
-0.02243572659790516,
0.16634009778499603,
-1.1049473285675049,
-0.12312886863946915,
-0.2650534212589264,
-0.20768538117408752,
-1.0209758281707764,
-0.3196535110473633,
-0.2014017105102539,
0.19294439256191254,
-0.23721091449260712,
0.6236279606819153,
-0.643111526966095,
-0.2914201617240906,
-0.5910869836807251,
0.21569572389125824,
-0.16762545704841614,
0.29070064425468445,
0.33088287711143494,
0.791968822479248,
0.6076810359954834,
-0.9965611100196838,
0.018963757902383804,
0.3580411970615387,
-0.44458767771720886,
0.22063399851322174,
-0.6696224212646484,
0.5654061436653137,
-0.0059583052061498165,
0.48178744316101074,
-1.2410818338394165,
-0.20331962406635284,
0.04094899073243141,
-0.4815552532672882,
0.3156202733516693,
-0.06776182353496552,
-0.09249860048294067,
0.031189575791358948,
-0.34996384382247925,
0.5382125973701477,
0.6733518242835999,
-0.8369737267494202,
0.6596455574035645,
0.37338921427726746,
-0.3572782874107361,
-0.16479334235191345,
-0.8318068981170654,
0.28575408458709717,
-0.673975944519043,
-0.3708091974258423,
0.5123444199562073,
-0.004745978396385908,
-0.24548682570457458,
-0.38117727637290955,
-0.38240694999694824,
0.06721647828817368,
0.16853390634059906,
0.286040335893631,
0.13916167616844177,
-0.21133935451507568,
-0.2051192969083786,
-0.053326644003391266,
-0.0681038573384285,
0.22901807725429535,
0.3409534990787506,
0.5725774168968201,
0.047435421496629715,
-0.24680817127227783,
-0.5191732048988342,
0.17798206210136414,
0.532366931438446,
0.24750269949436188,
0.4465991258621216,
0.3831784427165985,
-0.32230761647224426,
-0.3776388168334961,
-0.8856322765350342,
-0.381012499332428,
-0.5139026045799255,
0.1938987821340561,
-0.3613782525062561,
-1.1427425146102905,
0.46498069167137146,
-0.4181944727897644,
0.04701520875096321,
0.1695651113986969,
0.5228659510612488,
-0.1626170575618744,
0.26320138573646545,
0.43437460064888,
-0.25138747692108154,
0.4333755075931549,
-0.04623108729720116,
0.11910435557365417,
-1.2220382690429688,
-0.23469872772693634,
-0.5201569199562073,
-0.22996357083320618,
-0.33519062399864197,
-0.8282715082168579,
0.33933529257774353,
-0.056148961186409,
0.08299973607063293,
0.40071985125541687,
-0.20048190653324127,
0.2661447525024414,
0.40684303641319275,
0.11414334177970886,
0.40195655822753906,
0.38561272621154785,
0.47916293144226074,
0.10509476065635681,
-0.7814971804618835,
-0.41910862922668457,
1.082421898841858,
0.3996330201625824,
0.8735091686248779,
0.4002957344055176,
0.7155653238296509,
0.22911705076694489,
0.3504803478717804,
-0.7908538579940796,
0.6730634570121765,
-0.10217300057411194,
-0.18550361692905426,
-0.2269715666770935,
-0.3691273033618927,
-1.0252060890197754,
0.005174873862415552,
-0.03450312092900276,
-0.8406670689582825,
0.47885382175445557,
-0.038021594285964966,
-0.4722376763820648,
-0.17698748409748077,
-0.30588871240615845,
0.01008427981287241,
-0.1605682075023651,
-0.37471023201942444,
-0.2064976990222931,
-0.6076989769935608,
0.32807275652885437,
-0.34429195523262024,
0.35425764322280884,
-0.12777842581272125,
-0.04000835493206978,
1.1074855327606201,
0.14054760336875916,
1.0343958139419556,
0.05000179260969162,
-0.2048494666814804,
0.6277472972869873,
0.1988840103149414,
0.4753263592720032,
-0.08574448525905609,
-0.20474931597709656,
0.5553232431411743,
0.11950056999921799,
0.0962711051106453,
-0.5016975998878479,
0.7211570739746094,
-0.8278561234474182,
-0.838846743106842,
-0.44561687111854553,
-0.12698516249656677,
-0.25084519386291504,
-0.13647282123565674,
0.24425271153450012,
0.6109927892684937,
-0.2036220133304596,
0.5670662522315979,
0.43466871976852417,
-0.0790993720293045,
0.46457070112228394,
0.6820218563079834,
0.021170472726225853,
-0.3932030498981476,
0.8217644095420837,
-0.011802572757005692,
0.5706554055213928,
0.23697230219841003,
0.5498951077461243,
-0.37212833762168884,
-0.622211754322052,
-0.19025839865207672,
0.1835336536169052,
-0.7309090495109558,
-0.3479752838611603,
-0.7076095342636108,
-0.14653317630290985,
-0.3274417221546173,
-0.24790871143341064,
-0.189021497964859,
-0.28026050329208374,
-0.41625845432281494,
0.12145821750164032,
0.5874541401863098,
0.5330414772033691,
-0.2623714506626129,
0.3546905219554901,
-0.6734743118286133,
0.5136457085609436,
0.40580233931541443,
0.061057232320308685,
0.09300011396408081,
-1.2225233316421509,
0.0814162939786911,
0.1554877758026123,
0.10684917867183685,
-0.7186777591705322,
0.2513714134693146,
0.6663829684257507,
0.6141974925994873,
0.32503435015678406,
0.19388581812381744,
0.849035382270813,
-0.5328323841094971,
0.6693834066390991,
0.04174785315990448,
-0.7880381941795349,
0.33961379528045654,
-0.34414029121398926,
0.23463958501815796,
0.7190711498260498,
0.26218345761299133,
-0.4613029956817627,
-0.01683145761489868,
-0.1795385330915451,
-0.6052332520484924,
0.6900599002838135,
0.3391663134098053,
0.2093125432729721,
-0.03259363770484924,
0.43353450298309326,
-0.025157218798995018,
-0.05632789805531502,
-0.31302908062934875,
-0.22717207670211792,
0.17579591274261475,
0.15404409170150757,
-0.44781848788261414,
-0.5006075501441956,
-0.24516181647777557,
-0.33287614583969116,
0.32897940278053284,
-0.2355111688375473,
0.8156073689460754,
0.28639936447143555,
-0.030304865911602974,
-0.13700062036514282,
0.32611751556396484,
0.795936107635498,
0.2879277169704437,
-0.24354960024356842,
0.34185531735420227,
0.9109739065170288,
-0.35969001054763794,
0.20316895842552185,
-0.15464745461940765,
0.11630810052156448,
0.11118069291114807,
0.5744344592094421,
0.7445029616355896,
0.5015029311180115,
-0.6594995260238647,
0.2841647267341614,
-0.15170398354530334,
-0.16688936948776245,
-0.22228968143463135,
0.20485614240169525,
0.3623226284980774,
0.31258612871170044,
0.4478091895580292,
-0.0014701404143124819,
0.31274840235710144,
-0.8309548497200012,
0.27526265382766724,
0.30905404686927795,
-0.10660113394260406,
-0.30832773447036743,
0.4438849985599518,
0.22070087492465973,
-0.5582693219184875,
0.21939614415168762,
0.1273406445980072,
-0.6367548704147339,
0.5707665681838989,
1.0354363918304443,
0.7920841574668884,
-0.440016508102417,
-0.3030572235584259,
0.2301972508430481,
-0.01591951958835125,
-0.2453317642211914,
-0.025028355419635773,
-0.4319323003292084,
-0.7530022859573364,
-0.3205997347831726,
-0.5889356732368469,
-0.571923553943634,
-0.1547115594148636,
-0.8405407667160034,
0.0764608085155487,
-0.2995346486568451,
-0.2616588771343231,
-0.3076680302619934,
-0.20200452208518982,
-0.576149582862854,
0.0747196301817894,
0.23782619833946228,
0.6121352314949036,
-0.5180227160453796,
0.930529773235321,
0.4621376395225525,
0.4868606626987457,
-0.5552184581756592,
0.2545444667339325,
0.13579848408699036,
-0.913902759552002,
0.5268324017524719,
0.1119016781449318,
-0.7632930874824524,
-0.0010608535958454013,
-0.38080018758773804,
-1.2240675687789917,
1.5045655965805054,
0.1595328450202942,
-0.8708667755126953,
0.2768505811691284,
0.1931110918521881,
0.5214420557022095,
-0.4514089524745941,
-0.06916744261980057,
0.8073916435241699,
-0.04632614552974701,
0.5542728304862976,
-1.2738275527954102,
0.27599450945854187,
0.022046081721782684,
-0.17280028760433197,
-0.25029510259628296,
-0.8678091764450073,
0.4255295693874359,
-0.39980944991111755,
-0.42653048038482666,
0.17452681064605713,
0.6658130884170532,
0.6044343113899231,
0.5656664967536926,
0.5207700729370117,
-0.09862715750932693,
0.61787348985672,
0.12645134329795837,
0.8402187824249268,
-0.2810460031032562,
0.15713100135326385,
1.3808213472366333,
-0.5429118275642395,
1.1898219585418701,
0.4466976821422577,
-0.19438019394874573,
0.44058486819267273,
0.45281633734703064,
0.32998305559158325,
0.7374864816665649,
0.22423116862773895,
-0.3437008857727051,
0.0406673327088356,
-0.14367467164993286,
-0.5789603590965271,
0.5876718759536743,
0.4852021336555481,
-0.011678425595164299,
0.012667270377278328,
-0.22381578385829926,
0.04724050313234329,
-0.28181982040405273,
-0.07990829646587372,
1.087026834487915,
0.5365778207778931,
-0.5246578454971313,
0.8831060528755188,
0.05135619640350342,
0.9335252642631531,
-0.32736167311668396,
0.16373738646507263,
-0.5387471914291382,
0.22033709287643433,
-0.15245456993579865,
-0.45015037059783936,
0.5025477409362793,
0.24536554515361786,
0.11523006856441498,
-0.016455573961138725,
1.0468220710754395,
-0.39007315039634705,
-0.24981215596199036,
0.4258669316768646,
0.396838903427124,
0.3579748868942261,
0.04704933986067772,
-0.22971242666244507,
0.34821823239326477,
-0.004480098374187946,
-0.1147911474108696,
0.661619246006012,
0.29682037234306335,
-0.030310101807117462,
0.8037732839584351,
0.7769509553909302,
-0.15234023332595825,
0.0072349184192717075,
0.08066699653863907,
1.1013232469558716,
-0.6051637530326843,
-0.36277809739112854,
-0.912702202796936,
0.14050348103046417,
0.04799672216176987,
-0.10723964124917984,
0.8868497014045715,
0.437412291765213,
0.47808659076690674,
0.05920092388987541,
0.5612534880638123,
0.28045734763145447,
0.49557414650917053,
-0.5227941274642944,
0.4877539873123169,
-0.4176129102706909,
0.3286159634590149,
-0.3970481753349304,
-0.8881968855857849,
-0.08919264376163483,
0.9100792407989502,
-0.35114791989326477,
-0.1382870078086853,
0.6242006421089172,
0.670843780040741,
-0.02963271737098694,
0.03018299676477909,
0.32321518659591675,
0.10330166667699814,
0.22668316960334778,
0.5976220965385437,
1.021545648574829,
-0.38052862882614136,
0.39182397723197937,
-0.11513110250234604,
-0.33038878440856934,
-0.36427590250968933,
-0.7824550271034241,
-1.1957697868347168,
-0.3893458843231201,
-0.322528213262558,
-0.24899034202098846,
0.1929006427526474,
0.9330964684486389,
0.5695701241493225,
-0.7906413078308105,
-0.5529371500015259,
0.24993842840194702,
-0.25040414929389954,
0.06309973448514938,
-0.17815305292606354,
0.38826486468315125,
0.0932491198182106,
-0.41937437653541565,
0.8855370283126831,
0.1613764464855194,
0.09358634799718857,
0.24649536609649658,
-0.21954071521759033,
-0.04901110753417015,
0.15018142759799957,
0.9454949498176575,
0.16415822505950928,
-0.6653919816017151,
-0.5246616005897522,
0.0872444435954094,
0.09739068150520325,
0.07494993507862091,
0.5955005884170532,
-0.5937589406967163,
0.06588280946016312,
0.17851503193378448,
0.8576000332832336,
0.6617529392242432,
0.2802799344062805,
0.6128688454627991,
-0.4271630346775055,
-0.060724880546331406,
0.02937285602092743,
0.1590728759765625,
0.2848656177520752,
-0.24959978461265564,
0.48633745312690735,
0.22507573664188385,
-0.6423289179801941,
-0.9776573777198792,
-0.08103397488594055,
-1.2189552783966064,
-0.12737545371055603,
1.8623684644699097,
0.0400940477848053,
-0.15696091949939728,
-0.3647192418575287,
-0.2615315020084381,
0.16015496850013733,
-0.5452775955200195,
0.9120957851409912,
0.5066273212432861,
-0.2837924659252167,
-0.12833689153194427,
-0.38925912976264954,
0.6074273586273193,
0.45667320489883423,
-0.8125141859054565,
0.10599075257778168,
0.19240912795066833,
0.7197330594062805,
0.0699767991900444,
1.0195218324661255,
0.40968477725982666,
0.14247854053974152,
-0.07846894860267639,
-0.4488704204559326,
0.1492488980293274,
-0.4824742376804352,
-0.5959669947624207,
-0.016208456829190254,
0.28046494722366333,
-0.33429214358329773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18966v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18966v2 | UniGen: A Unified Framework for Textual Dataset Generation Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T07:56:44 | 2024-06-28T08:12:28 | Siyuan Wu, Yue Huang, Chujie Gao, Dongping Chen, Qihui Zhang, Yao Wan, Tianyi Zhou, Xiangliang Zhang, Jianfeng Gao, Chaowei Xiao, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 and Llama3 have significantly
impacted various fields by enabling high-quality synthetic data generation and
reducing dependence on expensive human-generated datasets. Despite this,
challenges remain in the areas of generalization, controllability, diversity,
and truthfulness within the existing generative frameworks. To address these
challenges, this paper presents UniGen, a comprehensive LLM-powered framework
designed to produce diverse, accurate, and highly controllable datasets. UniGen
is adaptable, supporting all types of text datasets and enhancing the
generative process through innovative mechanisms. To augment data diversity,
UniGen incorporates an attribute-guided generation module and a group checking
feature. For accuracy, it employs a code-based mathematical assessment for
label verification alongside a retrieval-augmented generation technique for
factual validation. The framework also allows for user-specified constraints,
enabling customization of the data generation process to suit particular
requirements. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superior quality of data
generated by UniGen, and each module within UniGen plays a critical role in
this enhancement. Additionally, UniGen is applied in two practical scenarios:
benchmarking LLMs and data augmentation. The results indicate that UniGen
effectively supports dynamic and evolving benchmarking, and that data
augmentation improves LLM capabilities in various domains, including
agent-oriented abilities and reasoning skills. | [
-0.19651643931865692,
-0.2724350392818451,
0.4005902409553528,
0.21220970153808594,
-0.2727709710597992,
0.5578988790512085,
-0.5997799038887024,
-0.1755138635635376,
-0.11160925775766373,
0.7056345343589783,
-0.4022134840488434,
-0.9330644607543945,
-0.17011991143226624,
0.20303036272525787,
-0.5717839598655701,
0.9958378076553345,
-0.039866670966148376,
-0.2817077338695526,
-0.09783529490232468,
-0.1893826574087143,
-0.21955469250679016,
-0.4310145676136017,
-0.04696682468056679,
-0.5636205673217773,
0.2076803594827652,
0.4818689227104187,
0.7509524822235107,
0.5398914217948914,
0.3108568787574768,
0.3524948060512543,
0.2581244111061096,
0.44056323170661926,
-0.4116872251033783,
0.6179155707359314,
-0.31780022382736206,
-0.16272619366645813,
-0.554384708404541,
-0.19463036954402924,
0.694497287273407,
0.8990007042884827,
-0.22536443173885345,
0.1644754856824875,
0.2618383467197418,
0.7047934532165527,
-0.5008587837219238,
-0.041563816368579865,
-0.8061754703521729,
-0.008290981873869896,
-0.6352697014808655,
0.02153782546520233,
-0.221968874335289,
-0.1403476446866989,
-0.4009552597999573,
-0.6838371753692627,
0.2598583996295929,
-0.2632891535758972,
0.3419439196586609,
0.3528376519680023,
-0.641736626625061,
0.028297418728470802,
-0.8838554620742798,
0.7675845623016357,
-0.5454816818237305,
0.41785991191864014,
-0.027212781831622124,
0.2909398078918457,
-0.5073465704917908,
-1.0824828147888184,
-0.5210487246513367,
0.29771867394447327,
0.4454953670501709,
0.2681838572025299,
-0.2285281866788864,
0.06489735096693039,
0.10664959251880646,
0.4797818064689636,
-0.48740625381469727,
0.1753319352865219,
-0.07293315976858139,
-0.12966035306453705,
0.710241436958313,
0.2450794130563736,
0.34861963987350464,
-0.06252928823232651,
-0.1650916486978531,
-0.090870201587677,
-0.9173017144203186,
-0.09222052991390228,
0.5041595101356506,
0.5661983489990234,
0.19711793959140778,
0.6846086382865906,
-0.39155125617980957,
0.5406816005706787,
-0.18009264767169952,
0.0552411712706089,
0.2809693217277527,
-0.2668246924877167,
-0.32687216997146606,
0.12081316113471985,
0.9223182797431946,
0.2506404221057892,
0.18542443215847015,
-0.4307247996330261,
-0.2898310720920563,
0.2970985174179077,
0.14992450177669525,
-0.7319799065589905,
-0.14801301062107086,
0.11995496600866318,
-0.25548073649406433,
-0.6367558836936951,
0.1898810863494873,
-1.0256354808807373,
-0.5683265328407288,
-0.36833593249320984,
-0.0870911031961441,
-0.1616830825805664,
-0.2240132987499237,
0.2971380650997162,
0.23569367825984955,
-0.016283998265862465,
0.20617727935314178,
-0.8511043190956116,
0.3597468137741089,
0.44173187017440796,
0.330262154340744,
-0.39073994755744934,
-0.07640223950147629,
-0.3484843373298645,
0.4199727773666382,
-0.41928568482398987,
0.7875858545303345,
-0.6453538537025452,
-0.33882251381874084,
0.06763630360364914,
-0.20814241468906403,
0.24237918853759766,
-0.45737534761428833,
0.9085461497306824,
-0.39507776498794556,
0.19280624389648438,
-0.3790208697319031,
-0.5066643357276917,
-0.09354893863201141,
-0.2722030580043793,
-0.6600664854049683,
1.3806275129318237,
0.34824493527412415,
-0.708734929561615,
0.6355204582214355,
-0.6910483241081238,
-0.5441069602966309,
0.4286503493785858,
-0.4387650191783905,
-0.38349097967147827,
0.24567000567913055,
0.3668694794178009,
0.35459834337234497,
-0.8127465844154358,
0.5208226442337036,
-0.2151808738708496,
-0.2734432518482208,
0.330767959356308,
-0.4751988351345062,
0.6128632426261902,
0.19900263845920563,
-0.4637320637702942,
0.017754781991243362,
-1.0715010166168213,
0.3208026885986328,
0.07066282629966736,
-0.6884549856185913,
-0.08898502588272095,
-0.02268892154097557,
0.3427526354789734,
0.1639990210533142,
0.007182548753917217,
-0.890316903591156,
0.3044293224811554,
-0.12476208060979843,
0.20862315595149994,
0.5289902687072754,
0.039385173469781876,
0.25995710492134094,
-0.1315983235836029,
0.4647367000579834,
-0.2151363343000412,
-0.2422093003988266,
-0.0030107542406767607,
-0.19683513045310974,
-0.5165818929672241,
-0.3070514500141144,
0.6569404006004333,
0.4598885774612427,
-0.8075653910636902,
0.6019442081451416,
-0.41845017671585083,
-0.27270475029945374,
-0.5716715455055237,
0.6704347729682922,
0.2810925543308258,
0.4113386571407318,
0.29602402448654175,
-0.2227998971939087,
-0.9127449989318848,
-0.6308537125587463,
-0.29459789395332336,
0.11414851993322372,
-0.412679523229599,
-0.10093498975038528,
0.20767028629779816,
-0.36269596219062805,
1.038239598274231,
-0.08570442348718643,
-0.34642720222473145,
-0.5668408274650574,
0.19995762407779694,
0.2271149456501007,
0.22390572726726532,
0.3115483522415161,
-0.5220848917961121,
-0.39224639534950256,
0.20409366488456726,
-1.0778111219406128,
-0.5274184346199036,
-0.0845373198390007,
-0.10255154967308044,
0.32143622636795044,
0.45710834860801697,
-0.38213032484054565,
0.3275207281112671,
0.4730800688266754,
-0.16226038336753845,
0.14338918030261993,
-0.28327688574790955,
0.04319431260228157,
-1.2043720483779907,
0.2582906484603882,
-0.22910217940807343,
-0.3013717830181122,
-0.5865996479988098,
-0.15008005499839783,
-0.08858723193407059,
-0.025236522778868675,
-0.08382539451122284,
0.27879294753074646,
-0.44532719254493713,
-0.3189798593521118,
-0.25945451855659485,
-0.006779857911169529,
0.14338867366313934,
0.26349225640296936,
-0.3103247582912445,
0.8531187176704407,
0.35464587807655334,
-0.5119808912277222,
0.670211136341095,
0.27688947319984436,
-0.57901930809021,
0.6291792988777161,
-0.6884311437606812,
0.1428312063217163,
-0.08883024007081985,
0.21586474776268005,
-0.7233057022094727,
-0.46228450536727905,
-0.28858476877212524,
-0.2658960223197937,
0.35180458426475525,
0.019352123141288757,
-0.8482122421264648,
-0.34344053268432617,
-0.26916471123695374,
0.21366922557353973,
0.5241484642028809,
-0.6640594005584717,
0.6480743288993835,
0.3567768335342407,
-0.15055227279663086,
-0.6382318735122681,
-0.7516058683395386,
0.31798675656318665,
-0.18306036293506622,
-0.5182706713676453,
0.6052629947662354,
0.021295031532645226,
-0.35661008954048157,
-0.0984799712896347,
0.04592281952500343,
0.23812757432460785,
0.051296938210725784,
0.3665279150009155,
0.05388074740767479,
-0.04567936062812805,
0.34333372116088867,
0.46687522530555725,
-0.18575723469257355,
-0.054372332990169525,
-0.48012596368789673,
0.4041377902030945,
0.06526447832584381,
-0.49566584825515747,
0.08669988065958023,
0.2957615256309509,
0.5633850693702698,
-0.3324069678783417,
0.23211002349853516,
0.5513154864311218,
-0.25608909130096436,
-0.5220817923545837,
-0.2109808325767517,
0.1316615492105484,
-0.4846692383289337,
0.2787404954433441,
-0.3867335915565491,
-0.8163101077079773,
0.5791492462158203,
-0.4540928602218628,
0.29358911514282227,
0.3974452614784241,
0.7226976752281189,
-0.13450513780117035,
1.0194097757339478,
0.46392473578453064,
0.0016073110746219754,
0.013139995746314526,
0.11397461593151093,
-0.07575402408838272,
-0.9429657459259033,
-0.09487099200487137,
-0.3363715708255768,
-0.35498613119125366,
-0.7710892558097839,
-0.3033081293106079,
0.3122381865978241,
-0.028571275994181633,
-0.3594585955142975,
-0.0807502418756485,
-0.5657982230186462,
0.5340735912322998,
0.4016280472278595,
-0.2467534840106964,
0.6822760701179504,
0.4158835709095001,
-0.48593059182167053,
-0.24700818955898285,
-0.41502687335014343,
-0.595041036605835,
1.6593014001846313,
0.0988057553768158,
0.9812616109848022,
0.3118971586227417,
0.4543508291244507,
0.48929131031036377,
0.42351680994033813,
-0.13036398589611053,
0.4690251052379608,
-0.42969822883605957,
-0.5888815522193909,
-0.2860183119773865,
-0.3719508945941925,
-1.047512173652649,
0.23747847974300385,
-0.36649489402770996,
-0.6067120432853699,
0.09472039341926575,
-0.17141380906105042,
-0.09971863031387329,
0.49668315052986145,
-0.04667235538363457,
0.3646198809146881,
-0.20636996626853943,
-0.5406157374382019,
0.2988634705543518,
-0.5600772500038147,
0.3872317969799042,
-0.5314363837242126,
-0.07630971819162369,
-0.2148391455411911,
-0.050293631851673126,
0.5564644932746887,
-0.4260694086551666,
0.7846059799194336,
-0.07904544472694397,
-0.29545944929122925,
0.41415348649024963,
0.06756873428821564,
0.4459768831729889,
0.13698837161064148,
-0.3406990170478821,
-0.00999728124588728,
-0.5520254969596863,
-0.20361067354679108,
-0.4105887711048126,
0.7099503874778748,
-0.6231786012649536,
-0.04856622964143753,
-0.14505305886268616,
-0.7286949753761292,
-0.5063294172286987,
0.3346934914588928,
0.4555179178714752,
0.39960893988609314,
-0.4922527074813843,
0.4129129946231842,
0.7244858145713806,
-0.3071359694004059,
0.4741549789905548,
0.567476212978363,
-0.4822857677936554,
-0.5667520761489868,
0.9320944547653198,
-0.11931701004505157,
-0.044820837676525116,
0.26676589250564575,
-0.26641809940338135,
-0.5846390724182129,
-0.44565966725349426,
-0.7480674982070923,
-0.004081164486706257,
-0.6596649289131165,
-0.5074705481529236,
-0.5257779955863953,
-0.0467558428645134,
-0.2591318190097809,
-0.0382314957678318,
-0.5278026461601257,
-0.4558546245098114,
-0.014308602549135685,
-0.38375458121299744,
0.5718625783920288,
0.9482184052467346,
-0.2289012223482132,
0.24017873406410217,
-0.6095636487007141,
0.151820108294487,
0.41918399930000305,
0.46027058362960815,
-0.4317794740200043,
-0.29804524779319763,
0.1283843219280243,
0.006360504310578108,
-0.3020108640193939,
-0.7204048037528992,
0.2761412560939789,
0.32952040433883667,
0.5433342456817627,
0.16109773516654968,
0.26196280121803284,
-0.050603266805410385,
-0.22099852561950684,
0.43010053038597107,
-0.0860230028629303,
-1.0160419940948486,
0.2775985598564148,
-0.8508768081665039,
0.25421229004859924,
0.8231094479560852,
-0.16988718509674072,
-0.43280699849128723,
-0.29569730162620544,
-0.4714479446411133,
-0.8769003748893738,
0.358669638633728,
0.4622267484664917,
0.14991603791713715,
0.43232107162475586,
0.32675376534461975,
0.21737846732139587,
0.4966799318790436,
-0.5129840970039368,
-0.2382047325372696,
-0.27757230401039124,
-0.6331114172935486,
0.005032306537032127,
-0.07856287062168121,
-0.055295951664447784,
-0.19680915772914886,
0.5802156925201416,
-0.38587841391563416,
0.040800996124744415,
-0.07989128679037094,
-0.20432108640670776,
-0.2931094169616699,
0.5708000659942627,
0.3704870939254761,
0.5869142413139343,
-0.1076674535870552,
0.11825070530176163,
0.14195097982883453,
-0.5176688432693481,
0.33121925592422485,
0.3570014238357544,
-0.24149975180625916,
0.004901180975139141,
0.23109936714172363,
0.5600435733795166,
0.05965802073478699,
-0.5295141339302063,
0.2540281414985657,
-0.0949406698346138,
-0.3723522424697876,
-0.004429502412676811,
-0.058748289942741394,
0.0288473479449749,
0.07013251632452011,
0.41309854388237,
-0.3117464780807495,
0.0440417043864727,
-0.20041708648204803,
0.4117177426815033,
0.27646544575691223,
-0.17618641257286072,
-0.26070719957351685,
0.7326239943504333,
0.32163897156715393,
0.37858718633651733,
0.7391203045845032,
-0.25585559010505676,
-0.4226612448692322,
0.2393723726272583,
0.6438918113708496,
0.5969525575637817,
-0.4495433568954468,
0.4795655608177185,
-0.00019516960310284048,
0.37872692942619324,
0.15995167195796967,
0.6690298318862915,
0.09205905348062515,
-0.8964838981628418,
-0.5339320302009583,
-0.6352792382240295,
-0.350496768951416,
0.25371038913726807,
-0.6160928606987,
-0.07335029542446136,
-0.4243336319923401,
-0.13474245369434357,
-0.1283508837223053,
0.1703111231327057,
-0.6056078672409058,
0.19670237600803375,
-0.07306775450706482,
0.60807204246521,
-0.8317540884017944,
0.8298395872116089,
0.8393595218658447,
-0.33334940671920776,
-0.6228531002998352,
-0.20359903573989868,
0.07189018279314041,
-0.6429018378257751,
0.4404767155647278,
-0.16151036322116852,
-0.0511319674551487,
0.05747387185692787,
-0.46415916085243225,
-0.6816392540931702,
1.1519931554794312,
0.6284356117248535,
-0.4958168864250183,
0.37522104382514954,
0.6264089941978455,
0.6971647143363953,
-0.47502145171165466,
-0.08269023150205612,
0.6490921974182129,
0.5996101498603821,
0.21299272775650024,
-0.4367942214012146,
0.21397367119789124,
-0.41281643509864807,
0.10490258783102036,
0.3847707211971283,
-0.27000513672828674,
0.7870562672615051,
-0.1491914689540863,
-0.28312060236930847,
-0.06336040049791336,
0.8088628649711609,
0.30335065722465515,
-0.06260396540164948,
0.2640633285045624,
0.6926575303077698,
1.1243096590042114,
-0.21736416220664978,
0.9135438203811646,
-0.35503479838371277,
0.0492670014500618,
1.0825247764587402,
-0.7464131116867065,
0.33012717962265015,
-0.004456919617950916,
-0.133183091878891,
0.6229421496391296,
0.3469366729259491,
-0.15352687239646912,
0.2647869884967804,
0.28222280740737915,
-0.6642126441001892,
-0.4075387418270111,
-0.41274988651275635,
-0.4021845757961273,
0.743008553981781,
0.4169926047325134,
-0.48357102274894714,
-0.3462319076061249,
-0.013044663704931736,
0.1453230381011963,
0.2913273274898529,
-0.10354693979024887,
0.6105965375900269,
-0.18755637109279633,
-0.39192405343055725,
0.27157145738601685,
0.30924832820892334,
0.4877052903175354,
-0.3352769911289215,
0.019683584570884705,
-0.5363827347755432,
0.39828285574913025,
-0.2335389405488968,
-0.7868226170539856,
-0.04772607982158661,
0.3131925165653229,
-0.15552105009555817,
-0.15836647152900696,
0.9456924200057983,
-0.5366700291633606,
-0.6887595057487488,
0.07581876963376999,
0.7005746364593506,
-0.04149850830435753,
-0.08508794754743576,
-0.5321298241615295,
0.26575374603271484,
0.10025985538959503,
-0.1889798492193222,
0.32067176699638367,
0.6624103784561157,
-0.21118822693824768,
0.44338980317115784,
0.8107354044914246,
0.10438377410173416,
-0.19862248003482819,
0.3400745093822479,
1.0359832048416138,
-0.517498254776001,
-0.12890839576721191,
-0.5073040723800659,
0.4900728166103363,
-0.3523571491241455,
-0.28379586338996887,
0.57082599401474,
0.5819261074066162,
0.47048476338386536,
0.32881397008895874,
1.1260377168655396,
0.17361094057559967,
0.663781464099884,
-0.42677900195121765,
0.7220072746276855,
-0.36329808831214905,
0.38432538509368896,
-0.3433200716972351,
-1.1394329071044922,
-0.4654553234577179,
0.36325833201408386,
0.19525499641895294,
0.36718809604644775,
0.4373912215232849,
0.4652163088321686,
-0.059918664395809174,
0.039769891649484634,
0.270730584859848,
0.09082340449094772,
0.4991213381290436,
0.6272044777870178,
0.6363277435302734,
-0.36221855878829956,
0.41794317960739136,
0.09014062583446503,
-0.17942358553409576,
0.31635114550590515,
-0.9040259718894958,
-0.931847095489502,
-0.4271271526813507,
-0.0595143586397171,
-0.25352951884269714,
0.027648596093058586,
0.8333074450492859,
0.38751792907714844,
-0.6775107979774475,
-0.1153053417801857,
-0.3179949223995209,
-0.11878377944231033,
0.1674695461988449,
-0.15606911480426788,
0.3602651059627533,
-0.21833589673042297,
-0.6196537613868713,
0.6556054949760437,
0.3740609586238861,
0.262511670589447,
-0.3946516215801239,
-0.014008581638336182,
0.21686264872550964,
0.1094205379486084,
0.4140656292438507,
0.3795439600944519,
-0.2971636950969696,
0.15251731872558594,
-0.09877067059278488,
-0.2300686240196228,
-0.10404712706804276,
0.9425536394119263,
-0.7936318516731262,
0.4018089473247528,
0.2628597915172577,
0.8134863376617432,
0.22439660131931305,
0.046024423092603683,
0.9536501169204712,
-1.0932680368423462,
-0.09451302886009216,
0.05997256189584732,
0.37154829502105713,
0.6629241704940796,
-0.26975980401039124,
0.6859961748123169,
0.06249172240495682,
-0.5118065476417542,
-0.8334667682647705,
0.28896564245224,
-0.6754190325737,
-0.19942957162857056,
1.117850422859192,
0.0537518672645092,
0.0632299929857254,
-0.3977075517177582,
0.050387077033519745,
0.33416154980659485,
-0.4691562354564667,
0.5679827928543091,
0.46390852332115173,
-0.017479773610830307,
0.07269122451543808,
-0.2907118499279022,
0.7475314736366272,
0.4186663329601288,
-1.2650656700134277,
0.45710113644599915,
0.5716578960418701,
0.16687585413455963,
-0.16492128372192383,
0.520682692527771,
-0.3674478530883789,
-0.003366917371749878,
-0.2924586236476898,
0.5132525563240051,
-0.2959952652454376,
-0.29726701974868774,
-0.26079025864601135,
0.10042069852352142,
-0.10919252038002014,
0.14914542436599731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00102v1 | Curriculum Learning with Quality-Driven Data Selection | 2024-06-27T07:20:36 | 2024-06-27T07:20:36 | Biao Wu, Fang Meng, Ling Chen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The impressive multimodal capabilities demonstrated by OpenAI's GPT-4 have
generated significant interest in the development of Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs). Visual instruction tuning of MLLMs with machine-generated
instruction-following data has shown to enhance zero-shot capabilities across
various tasks. However, there has been limited exploration into controlling the
quality of the instruction data.Current methodologies for data selection in
MLLMs often rely on single, unreliable scores or use downstream tasks for
selection, which is time-consuming and can lead to potential overfitting on the
chosen evaluation datasets. To mitigate these limitations, we propose a novel
data selection methodology that utilizes image-text correlation and model
perplexity to evaluate and select data of varying quality. This approach
leverages the distinct distribution of these two attributes, mapping data
quality into a two-dimensional space that allows for the selection of data
based on their location within this distribution. By utilizing this space, we
can analyze the impact of task type settings, used as prompts, on data quality.
Additionally, this space can be used to construct multi-stage subsets of
varying quality to facilitate curriculum learning. Our research includes
comprehensive experiments conducted on various datasets. The results emphasize
substantial enhancements in five commonly assessed capabilities compared to
using the complete dataset. Our codes, data, and models are publicly available
at: \url{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/EHIT-31B4} | [
-0.30271074175834656,
-0.8776825666427612,
0.48584869503974915,
-0.03532501682639122,
-0.2780396640300751,
0.09814687073230743,
-0.09421935677528381,
0.003338669426739216,
-0.21918322145938873,
0.694488525390625,
-0.385396271944046,
-0.9126448035240173,
-0.48994576930999756,
-0.24111637473106384,
-0.31009215116500854,
1.199398159980774,
-0.2807188332080841,
0.12319017201662064,
-0.41665568947792053,
-0.30861589312553406,
-0.7380059361457825,
-0.3941885530948639,
-0.33817562460899353,
0.04254848137497902,
0.6647833585739136,
0.6225423216819763,
0.6640376448631287,
0.8905796408653259,
0.8128541707992554,
0.12333524972200394,
0.4608251452445984,
0.48392412066459656,
-0.6658799052238464,
0.2972272038459778,
-0.12088574469089508,
-0.23955023288726807,
-0.295510858297348,
0.17644956707954407,
0.7622925043106079,
0.4836702048778534,
0.18255794048309326,
0.4319688081741333,
0.23998737335205078,
0.6840044260025024,
-0.8205322027206421,
0.3402571380138397,
-0.42139241099357605,
0.19865460693836212,
-0.24358625710010529,
-0.24008537828922272,
-0.3245677649974823,
-0.3700938820838928,
0.11851014196872711,
-0.7205193638801575,
0.1693514585494995,
0.018824851140379906,
0.9006559252738953,
0.27488166093826294,
-0.5563064813613892,
-0.2727157175540924,
-0.4813529849052429,
1.0964313745498657,
-0.29946696758270264,
0.5404825210571289,
0.8284382820129395,
0.4568163752555847,
0.21471118927001953,
-0.524860680103302,
-0.3745216429233551,
-0.12183231115341187,
0.11982528865337372,
0.5010603666305542,
0.33947423100471497,
-0.2261245846748352,
0.13420544564723969,
0.46441182494163513,
-0.8524348139762878,
0.1899401992559433,
-0.3885384202003479,
-0.22080160677433014,
0.2696180045604706,
0.3797094225883484,
0.14101989567279816,
-0.10877344757318497,
-0.32962295413017273,
-0.616441547870636,
-0.810940146446228,
0.15634621679782867,
0.4279077649116516,
0.32137641310691833,
-0.04099612310528755,
0.7513942718505859,
0.008281123824417591,
0.7258003950119019,
-0.3438323736190796,
-0.30001750588417053,
0.22717593610286713,
-0.5396620631217957,
-0.31088587641716003,
-0.46112725138664246,
0.60535728931427,
0.30264830589294434,
-0.21060387790203094,
0.20468322932720184,
-0.34052976965904236,
0.029513446614146233,
0.22215083241462708,
-0.9422281980514526,
-0.462289035320282,
0.07660520821809769,
-0.47725909948349,
-0.15933533012866974,
0.08373513072729111,
-1.0420395135879517,
-0.10182702541351318,
-0.5658515691757202,
0.39150843024253845,
-0.6059057116508484,
0.09170106798410416,
-0.10497432947158813,
0.21073110401630402,
-0.06718849390745163,
0.3329170048236847,
-0.7586508393287659,
-0.16258704662322998,
0.25454801321029663,
0.7933161854743958,
-0.3844287395477295,
-0.22621339559555054,
-0.5956968665122986,
0.08831192553043365,
-0.4429537057876587,
0.5936790704727173,
-1.1222931146621704,
-0.3373841345310211,
0.034622885286808014,
-0.4584002196788788,
0.017570719122886658,
-0.36620980501174927,
0.44286954402923584,
-0.6164524555206299,
0.4179498851299286,
-0.29776114225387573,
-0.42960238456726074,
-0.33228760957717896,
0.23990967869758606,
-0.8623373508453369,
1.020002007484436,
0.48325666785240173,
-0.641474187374115,
0.6807644367218018,
-0.44181784987449646,
-0.3710961937904358,
-0.18835440278053284,
-0.4189614951610565,
-0.8202261328697205,
-0.23356515169143677,
0.5250113010406494,
0.5944462418556213,
-0.19262094795703888,
0.16029661893844604,
-0.3255188465118408,
-0.2567248046398163,
0.06843610107898712,
-0.596816897392273,
0.489324152469635,
0.4329932630062103,
-0.040817104279994965,
0.09143893420696259,
-0.8521589636802673,
0.1790773719549179,
0.05400173366069794,
-0.49357059597969055,
-0.17343708872795105,
-0.14320053160190582,
0.04475954547524452,
0.37265703082084656,
0.0815444067120552,
-0.2417794167995453,
0.24186807870864868,
0.18783557415008545,
0.1506245881319046,
0.5674489736557007,
-0.049214787781238556,
0.33987659215927124,
-0.4846288561820984,
0.47651156783103943,
0.2915767431259155,
0.25851887464523315,
-0.44138988852500916,
-0.4704800546169281,
-0.7242867946624756,
-0.5353241562843323,
0.22936944663524628,
0.5217427015304565,
-1.2405263185501099,
0.2833200991153717,
-0.05854206532239914,
-0.3154730200767517,
-0.7531507015228271,
0.4060099422931671,
0.4726313054561615,
0.4756401479244232,
0.733596682548523,
-0.5104316473007202,
-0.22185958921909332,
-0.5056535005569458,
0.4122610092163086,
0.062368229031562805,
-0.09914759546518326,
0.46539565920829773,
0.36062294244766235,
-0.0760871097445488,
0.8286476731300354,
-0.6604021191596985,
-0.5915594100952148,
-0.057453930377960205,
0.2625378966331482,
0.11540640890598297,
0.48125752806663513,
0.5397042036056519,
-0.7089164853096008,
-0.39740583300590515,
-0.18584172427654266,
-0.822796642780304,
0.08676774054765701,
-0.4239948093891144,
-0.47092512249946594,
-0.018303770571947098,
0.09681561589241028,
-0.14512722194194794,
0.4097329080104828,
0.5232715010643005,
-0.1838008314371109,
0.5688555240631104,
-0.24840201437473297,
0.49810150265693665,
-0.9132540225982666,
-0.08986648917198181,
0.26262155175209045,
0.2078561931848526,
-0.28990867733955383,
0.03364129737019539,
0.3384321331977844,
-0.07355838268995285,
-0.22576066851615906,
0.2607710063457489,
-0.4626804292201996,
-0.011153074912726879,
0.04842672124505043,
-0.04764065518975258,
0.2075437605381012,
0.5502007603645325,
-0.026556724682450294,
0.8743047118186951,
0.7541317939758301,
-0.2690622806549072,
0.20809896290302277,
0.4796861708164215,
-0.44390782713890076,
0.7655866146087646,
-0.23666612803936005,
0.034956205636262894,
-0.13252325356006622,
0.04396040365099907,
-1.011825442314148,
-0.31251588463783264,
0.046578481793403625,
-0.25338661670684814,
0.4480522871017456,
0.0266058761626482,
-0.6386277079582214,
-0.1131458580493927,
-0.2896978557109833,
0.46334320306777954,
0.36388152837753296,
-0.4475705623626709,
0.20584404468536377,
0.19284529983997345,
0.034143611788749695,
-0.467582643032074,
-0.6243504881858826,
-0.024947121739387512,
-0.01851917803287506,
-0.25352203845977783,
-0.059360504150390625,
-0.1541801244020462,
0.28247857093811035,
-0.11244062334299088,
-0.12909236550331116,
-0.3581800162792206,
-0.12326622754335403,
0.2257232367992401,
0.6723678112030029,
-0.3366923928260803,
0.15184424817562103,
0.4970199763774872,
0.02983936294913292,
-0.31257110834121704,
-0.4225327670574188,
0.2044278234243393,
0.2765163481235504,
-0.8098451495170593,
-0.511203408241272,
0.2817865312099457,
0.4814269244670868,
-0.6273608803749084,
0.572425127029419,
0.8400471806526184,
0.05542455613613129,
-0.21852652728557587,
-0.38043397665023804,
-0.2565931975841522,
-0.4170333445072174,
0.42887401580810547,
-0.23651671409606934,
-0.9993281364440918,
0.08866696059703827,
0.29992803931236267,
0.30426615476608276,
-0.05557631701231003,
0.2625488042831421,
-0.1464301347732544,
0.9416033029556274,
0.39894261956214905,
-0.02869248576462269,
0.6092388033866882,
-0.32439252734184265,
0.22686126828193665,
-0.7937808632850647,
-0.23905600607395172,
-0.2901783585548401,
-0.21248336136341095,
-0.43341198563575745,
-0.6516802906990051,
0.5639917850494385,
-0.1931019276380539,
-0.41307201981544495,
0.054581861943006516,
-0.42574408650398254,
0.4052736759185791,
0.6631260514259338,
0.4354947805404663,
0.2389840930700302,
0.28283897042274475,
-0.2069292515516281,
-0.19997383654117584,
-0.5291793346405029,
-0.5436415076255798,
1.4209500551223755,
0.2317887842655182,
0.8234182596206665,
0.10938732326030731,
0.4262655973434448,
0.115563303232193,
0.20927338302135468,
-0.3129083812236786,
0.4323502779006958,
-0.5310032367706299,
-0.41509267687797546,
-0.4008399546146393,
-0.6445866227149963,
-0.9166838526725769,
0.21977761387825012,
-0.5236301422119141,
-0.4743097424507141,
-0.16748833656311035,
0.1184040755033493,
-0.44541627168655396,
0.3158720135688782,
-0.5582722425460815,
0.8098563551902771,
-0.2760452330112457,
-0.6329532265663147,
-0.07930627465248108,
-0.6763728260993958,
0.24474065005779266,
-0.27851399779319763,
0.020158952102065086,
-0.02369212731719017,
0.17112991213798523,
0.4082874655723572,
0.1593366116285324,
0.7316855192184448,
0.02853941172361374,
-0.07476551830768585,
0.34899014234542847,
0.28069016337394714,
0.23602940142154694,
-0.010683356784284115,
-0.16514885425567627,
0.14198674261569977,
-0.11077328771352768,
-0.49721482396125793,
-0.7444168925285339,
0.7450892925262451,
-0.9369686841964722,
-0.2479875534772873,
0.05734184384346008,
-0.7776972055435181,
-0.35878846049308777,
0.10026232898235321,
0.02657325379550457,
0.656568169593811,
0.14854080975055695,
0.34405452013015747,
0.6807439923286438,
-0.49295511841773987,
0.07624112069606781,
0.3155454397201538,
-0.07909901440143585,
-0.5414737462997437,
1.5717424154281616,
0.4055359661579132,
0.4770651161670685,
0.4653379023075104,
-0.12397579848766327,
-0.26025819778442383,
-0.6254583597183228,
-0.4518895149230957,
-0.03424651175737381,
-0.8302178978919983,
-0.3480890691280365,
-0.4445361793041229,
-0.2080947905778885,
-0.29460301995277405,
-0.11807253211736679,
-0.24986618757247925,
-0.11203640699386597,
-0.5950649380683899,
0.019438669085502625,
-0.1680954545736313,
0.6041587591171265,
0.37722957134246826,
0.2674627900123596,
-0.7452357411384583,
0.2591293156147003,
0.4068351686000824,
0.5189074873924255,
-0.049346428364515305,
-0.6102908253669739,
-0.2629142999649048,
0.17325279116630554,
-0.7368406653404236,
-0.4733368158340454,
0.32907113432884216,
0.28904855251312256,
0.5467482805252075,
0.550993025302887,
-0.08709321916103363,
0.6166499257087708,
-0.22372595965862274,
0.8391894102096558,
0.1995004415512085,
-0.592797577381134,
0.7613739967346191,
-0.347858190536499,
0.30695492029190063,
0.461330384016037,
0.5059331655502319,
-0.014686844311654568,
-0.5921784043312073,
-0.27302035689353943,
-0.8291444778442383,
0.5234153866767883,
0.3997020423412323,
0.03042077273130417,
0.20580770075321198,
0.12046512961387634,
0.4841725826263428,
0.2710956931114197,
-0.38276514410972595,
-0.1614350825548172,
-0.7066265344619751,
-0.3885688781738281,
0.0035610711202025414,
-0.21139560639858246,
-0.03598986193537712,
-0.27865028381347656,
0.4614197611808777,
-0.2782078683376312,
0.08520451188087463,
-0.07116849720478058,
-0.13503655791282654,
0.10064535588026047,
0.1612570434808731,
0.49935969710350037,
0.7223442792892456,
-0.010753406211733818,
0.04926907271146774,
-0.09418807178735733,
-0.6636282205581665,
0.037832777947187424,
-0.2165205031633377,
-0.024231337010860443,
-0.23178519308567047,
0.44403061270713806,
1.0091335773468018,
0.0699278861284256,
-0.5090349316596985,
0.4990401864051819,
0.17924094200134277,
-0.15990032255649567,
0.1535782665014267,
0.4133540093898773,
-0.5594252943992615,
0.33541712164878845,
0.29632383584976196,
-0.12421172857284546,
0.06260702013969421,
-0.367757648229599,
0.4345456659793854,
0.2464471310377121,
-0.2901555597782135,
-0.21369849145412445,
0.6195136904716492,
0.07783354073762894,
0.22118279337882996,
0.9769058227539062,
-0.1283595860004425,
0.11518128216266632,
0.634205162525177,
0.47783201932907104,
0.325827032327652,
-0.196745365858078,
0.4410235285758972,
0.527466893196106,
0.16043832898139954,
-0.10878495872020721,
0.1710052341222763,
0.04492662101984024,
-0.7404726147651672,
-0.3971100449562073,
-0.5885076522827148,
-0.3940521478652954,
0.2947494685649872,
-0.866041898727417,
0.3225156366825104,
-0.502845287322998,
-0.16110500693321228,
-0.23704317212104797,
-0.08415882289409637,
-0.8309246301651001,
0.3811948597431183,
0.20815058052539825,
0.558480978012085,
-0.9247580766677856,
1.0408093929290771,
0.5564852952957153,
-0.7572889924049377,
-0.8117508292198181,
0.0704415887594223,
0.10565656423568726,
-0.7283338904380798,
0.7058854699134827,
0.07560236006975174,
0.27137070894241333,
0.00835909228771925,
-0.5167400240898132,
-0.8181331157684326,
1.217908263206482,
0.34242305159568787,
-0.5388222336769104,
0.09124653786420822,
0.09955431520938873,
0.5077405571937561,
-0.423134446144104,
0.4851474165916443,
0.5498086810112,
0.37807372212409973,
0.5083613395690918,
-0.6144692301750183,
-0.20307734608650208,
0.050288885831832886,
0.10084167867898941,
0.10056404769420624,
-0.4528767764568329,
0.8369019031524658,
-0.29168152809143066,
-0.1281394362449646,
-0.04776449874043465,
0.6374306678771973,
0.3345542550086975,
0.39062321186065674,
0.17827805876731873,
0.5630972385406494,
0.6550806760787964,
-0.09941144287586212,
0.7112600803375244,
-0.12384729087352753,
0.6029868125915527,
1.096794605255127,
-0.3843173086643219,
0.7971115112304688,
0.37583038210868835,
-0.22482073307037354,
0.42217084765434265,
0.6940585970878601,
-0.43837693333625793,
0.7151980400085449,
-0.070401631295681,
-0.09828275442123413,
-0.3112824857234955,
-0.08390688896179199,
-0.12702375650405884,
0.5794333815574646,
0.4717333912849426,
-0.30245161056518555,
-0.43942752480506897,
0.2758959233760834,
-0.27044403553009033,
0.023432642221450806,
-0.12200238555669785,
0.5085049271583557,
-0.21888482570648193,
-0.5566754937171936,
0.5419945120811462,
-0.46014246344566345,
0.3816480338573456,
-0.4625677764415741,
-0.42704030871391296,
-0.24611185491085052,
-0.2670554518699646,
-0.23492565751075745,
-1.2480343580245972,
0.055376552045345306,
-0.19252943992614746,
-0.10668724030256271,
-0.2930978834629059,
0.34050625562667847,
-0.7462291717529297,
-0.3594876229763031,
-0.047632403671741486,
0.5402625799179077,
0.0958983302116394,
0.1595994532108307,
-0.5095512866973877,
0.219116672873497,
-0.005651471670717001,
-0.176481693983078,
0.5929429531097412,
0.421286404132843,
-0.19831976294517517,
0.7545854449272156,
0.8532282710075378,
0.1160692423582077,
-0.23032136261463165,
0.07013662159442902,
0.9808434247970581,
-0.32151636481285095,
-0.3474405109882355,
-0.5832947492599487,
0.6637142896652222,
-0.06287610530853271,
-0.39370259642601013,
0.6637804508209229,
0.6444295048713684,
1.0701137781143188,
-0.0022707751486450434,
0.8458747863769531,
0.08513746410608292,
0.2558518052101135,
-0.7378615140914917,
0.6320759654045105,
-0.5252423882484436,
0.25475019216537476,
-0.33596283197402954,
-0.8772948980331421,
-0.564749538898468,
0.6351927518844604,
-0.4622438848018646,
0.09421910345554352,
0.8268675208091736,
0.9509768486022949,
-0.3065551519393921,
-0.09855854511260986,
0.6509318351745605,
-0.18559172749519348,
0.38526496291160583,
0.6077814698219299,
0.6672482490539551,
-0.22665780782699585,
0.585371732711792,
-0.06658793985843658,
-0.3160330355167389,
-0.1330224722623825,
-0.6552906632423401,
-1.1137166023254395,
-0.946295440196991,
-0.28675761818885803,
-0.11153417825698853,
0.04914925619959831,
0.7573667168617249,
0.7097488045692444,
-0.8239207863807678,
0.009376523084938526,
0.2898610830307007,
0.07284228503704071,
-0.12005282193422318,
-0.1841970533132553,
0.5239022970199585,
-0.5401484966278076,
-0.4676625430583954,
0.15019141137599945,
0.3887236714363098,
0.1098710298538208,
-0.1973617672920227,
0.08283665776252747,
0.03515470772981644,
-0.1201310008764267,
0.7206701636314392,
-0.0981234610080719,
-0.486420601606369,
-0.294818639755249,
-0.14954237639904022,
-0.35150089859962463,
0.22511087357997894,
0.8114317059516907,
-0.4477098286151886,
0.6809141039848328,
0.31731176376342773,
0.8216333985328674,
0.32286572456359863,
-0.12495039403438568,
0.15307320654392242,
-0.7923233509063721,
-0.07759146392345428,
0.22256344556808472,
0.1525653451681137,
0.24555401504039764,
-0.4621995985507965,
0.30720826983451843,
0.126443549990654,
-0.7409931421279907,
-0.553399920463562,
0.1007058247923851,
-0.7771182060241699,
-0.25481584668159485,
1.1314072608947754,
-0.34288498759269714,
0.06747794896364212,
-0.12123171985149384,
-0.42972514033317566,
0.2074456512928009,
-0.4382527768611908,
0.9502218961715698,
0.7153435945510864,
-0.11182233691215515,
-0.2809427082538605,
-1.0567878484725952,
0.11985506862401962,
0.24110063910484314,
-0.8081295490264893,
-0.3021678030490875,
0.7472972273826599,
0.12112383544445038,
-0.1004963219165802,
0.07911380380392075,
-0.14300864934921265,
0.26395004987716675,
-0.15658274292945862,
-0.049890875816345215,
-0.2835516333580017,
-0.6751562356948853,
-0.09598363190889359,
0.3705417811870575,
-0.10895927995443344,
-0.41582924127578735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18934v1 | The single-use restriction for register automata and transducers over infinite alphabets | 2024-06-27T07:01:23 | 2024-06-27T07:01:23 | Rafał Stefański | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.CL, F.4.3 | This thesis studies the single-use restriction for register automata and
transducers over infinite alphabets. The restriction requires that a
read-access to a register should have the side effect of destroying its
contents. This constraint results in robust classes of languages and
transductions. For automata models, we show that one-way register automata,
two-way register automata, and orbit-finite monoids have the same expressive
power. For transducer models, we show that single-use Mealy machines and
single-use two-way transducers admit versions of the Krohn-Rhodes decomposition
theorem. Moreover, single-use Mealy machines are equivalent to an algebraic
model called local algebraic semigroup transductions. Additionally, we show
that single-use two-way transducers are equivalent to single-use streaming
string transducers (SSTs) over infinite alphabets and to regular list functions
with atoms.
Compared with the previous work arXiv:1907.10504, this thesis offers a
coherent narrative on the single-use restriction. We introduce an abstract
notion of single-use functions and use them to define all the discussed
single-use models. We also introduce and study the algebraic models of local
semigroup transduction and local rational semigroup transduction. | [
-0.19381970167160034,
-0.43746045231819153,
0.5661337375640869,
-0.1259145587682724,
-0.30701351165771484,
0.10401584953069687,
0.022922612726688385,
-0.6645421385765076,
0.022407809272408485,
0.9356577396392822,
-0.07041320949792862,
-0.35212814807891846,
-0.3640378415584564,
0.2531673014163971,
-0.776032567024231,
0.5772530436515808,
-0.3274013102054596,
-0.10365036129951477,
-0.14578990638256073,
-0.4869604706764221,
0.12959490716457367,
-0.8729846477508545,
-0.25366222858428955,
0.259593665599823,
0.26447051763534546,
0.15108898282051086,
0.8722462058067322,
0.7262402772903442,
0.5238290429115295,
0.4282163679599762,
0.018689604476094246,
-0.36403888463974,
0.05247420445084572,
0.3803390860557556,
0.025262324139475822,
-0.17876997590065002,
-0.3183012008666992,
0.10559812188148499,
1.166227102279663,
0.812818706035614,
0.08438622206449509,
0.22123983502388,
-0.20878426730632782,
0.43325871229171753,
-0.5261504650115967,
0.14005924761295319,
-0.2449314296245575,
0.07572876662015915,
-0.3830638527870178,
-0.1534544825553894,
-0.5282570719718933,
-0.7008599042892456,
0.036264535039663315,
-0.5931675434112549,
-0.05935249105095863,
-0.21073700487613678,
0.41361770033836365,
0.3931235074996948,
-0.5595462322235107,
-0.670607328414917,
-1.1007847785949707,
0.7989946007728577,
-0.6579186320304871,
0.44149696826934814,
0.5436217784881592,
0.3085111677646637,
-0.028204837813973427,
-0.9035540819168091,
-0.3995482921600342,
-0.20059871673583984,
-0.3104356527328491,
-0.091498464345932,
-0.30220654606819153,
0.37875333428382874,
0.2360311597585678,
0.6028775572776794,
-0.4803193509578705,
-0.2285584658384323,
-0.6651475429534912,
-0.007123496849089861,
0.4955407381057739,
0.19503314793109894,
0.5549945831298828,
-0.015931228175759315,
-0.526235818862915,
0.273406445980072,
-0.6924077868461609,
0.010587139055132866,
0.2444869875907898,
0.38189300894737244,
0.16998086869716644,
0.3272402584552765,
0.21887823939323425,
0.8073267340660095,
-0.6240918040275574,
-0.2518308460712433,
-0.23219524323940277,
-0.2358396053314209,
-0.22222529351711273,
-0.330313116312027,
0.5304188132286072,
-0.45695653557777405,
0.33500444889068604,
-0.4323643743991852,
-0.0787402018904686,
0.34115397930145264,
-0.01639372482895851,
-0.6785638928413391,
0.09418463706970215,
-0.023543231189250946,
-0.5709097385406494,
0.08013078570365906,
-0.08764202147722244,
-0.29916489124298096,
-0.24818195402622223,
-0.1700473576784134,
0.46047142148017883,
-0.18314433097839355,
-0.326554536819458,
0.5370090007781982,
-0.2027553766965866,
-0.10912900418043137,
-0.2187231481075287,
-0.8893933892250061,
0.8413682579994202,
0.4724022150039673,
0.5884144306182861,
0.18837891519069672,
-0.19422027468681335,
-0.0024863258004188538,
0.40469253063201904,
0.011073158122599125,
0.6034774780273438,
-0.736677885055542,
-0.477434903383255,
0.06567685306072235,
-0.2211151421070099,
-0.2989719808101654,
-0.47030195593833923,
0.338687002658844,
-0.6984221935272217,
0.05556754395365715,
-0.03951525315642357,
-0.773162841796875,
-0.4761343002319336,
-0.4253317713737488,
-0.8634108901023865,
0.44363337755203247,
0.48336732387542725,
-0.17989467084407806,
0.13904151320457458,
-0.4945565462112427,
-0.9440472722053528,
0.22233149409294128,
-0.0607827827334404,
-0.20518362522125244,
0.23892538249492645,
-0.6560818552970886,
-0.04819268733263016,
-0.10664592683315277,
-0.15668027102947235,
-0.5112836360931396,
-0.11920135468244553,
0.16842596232891083,
-0.2259484976530075,
1.261030912399292,
0.5718769431114197,
0.16261164844036102,
-0.06954043358564377,
-0.8488918542861938,
0.20298698544502258,
-0.12913109362125397,
-0.5465104579925537,
-0.44705671072006226,
0.2569667100906372,
-0.20129261910915375,
0.3054540455341339,
0.18013571202754974,
-0.7648735046386719,
0.5982023477554321,
-0.012648839503526688,
0.9214481711387634,
0.460805207490921,
-0.014675391837954521,
0.41287994384765625,
-0.2276115119457245,
0.7112392783164978,
-0.2200719714164734,
0.261493980884552,
-0.1397690773010254,
-0.303281307220459,
-0.32804256677627563,
-0.6364006400108337,
0.5138999819755554,
0.44824546575546265,
-0.4758717119693756,
0.008595745079219341,
0.2614229917526245,
-0.3762264847755432,
-0.5141535401344299,
-0.15747560560703278,
0.33340686559677124,
0.14462000131607056,
0.2715368866920471,
-0.5001026391983032,
-0.4474523365497589,
-0.668382465839386,
-0.553027331829071,
-0.3700483739376068,
0.1117391586303711,
-0.0503089502453804,
0.0376671701669693,
0.09167994558811188,
0.3763035535812378,
-0.0749717727303505,
-0.20597343146800995,
-0.0499429851770401,
-0.018135540187358856,
-0.04824690893292427,
0.4503718614578247,
0.34799671173095703,
-0.46285825967788696,
-0.6189631223678589,
-0.22165396809577942,
-0.7137153148651123,
0.034408941864967346,
-0.1690743863582611,
0.12191881239414215,
0.35078728199005127,
0.20192116498947144,
-0.595373809337616,
0.9342430830001831,
0.3066455125808716,
-0.569386899471283,
0.052122633904218674,
-0.16070932149887085,
-0.031221499666571617,
-0.39537283778190613,
-0.07756916433572769,
-0.38549312949180603,
-0.628760576248169,
-0.8971970081329346,
0.5329408645629883,
-0.11211485415697098,
-0.24315786361694336,
-0.2679368257522583,
0.4880380630493164,
-0.5434663891792297,
-0.2951982915401459,
-0.2791195511817932,
-0.4355945885181427,
-0.40909525752067566,
0.4113863706588745,
0.1925254911184311,
0.5337947010993958,
0.8358328342437744,
-0.8269797563552856,
-0.052640337496995926,
0.41241180896759033,
-0.28398504853248596,
0.0009071503882296383,
-0.49632692337036133,
0.15409980714321136,
-0.000004127621650695801,
-0.08215028792619705,
-1.090095043182373,
0.17812930047512054,
0.42100492119789124,
-0.20378603041172028,
0.06026878580451012,
-0.18626487255096436,
-0.49126318097114563,
-0.20436924695968628,
-0.03652876615524292,
0.6230264902114868,
0.6130772829055786,
-0.37839236855506897,
0.7840617895126343,
0.6426240801811218,
0.09550508111715317,
-0.22115686535835266,
-0.759665310382843,
-0.30277544260025024,
-0.024930234998464584,
-0.5681105256080627,
-0.05337085947394371,
-0.2818617820739746,
-0.23534733057022095,
0.3281441926956177,
-0.3632811903953552,
-0.42859143018722534,
0.29216840863227844,
0.24915075302124023,
-0.002400944707915187,
0.05170436576008797,
-0.001970364712178707,
0.07231679558753967,
-0.2287420630455017,
-0.12187879532575607,
-0.2927708029747009,
0.3668570816516876,
-0.14850355684757233,
-0.34290480613708496,
-0.55214524269104,
0.9266658425331116,
0.8187594413757324,
-0.2528737485408783,
0.46867814660072327,
-0.055709030479192734,
-0.38919195532798767,
-0.24814099073410034,
0.08717702329158783,
0.002026615897193551,
-0.5355706810951233,
-0.0988023653626442,
-0.46571651101112366,
-1.0294809341430664,
0.5832322835922241,
0.13416939973831177,
0.3878001570701599,
0.45443618297576904,
0.5633652210235596,
0.12170001119375229,
1.0259963274002075,
0.45622241497039795,
0.20103424787521362,
0.5130649209022522,
-0.15452797710895538,
0.26794707775115967,
-0.5969733595848083,
0.14365455508232117,
-0.8643378019332886,
-0.36820417642593384,
-0.6151598691940308,
0.0015808575553819537,
0.3932645320892334,
0.1199188232421875,
-0.43614575266838074,
0.659217894077301,
-0.6259671449661255,
0.5384451150894165,
0.6051442623138428,
-0.14068453013896942,
0.40613290667533875,
0.15586179494857788,
-0.013952162116765976,
0.2141885608434677,
-0.6805503368377686,
-0.686352014541626,
1.153436303138733,
0.27493560314178467,
0.9925320744514465,
0.20806826651096344,
0.9429810643196106,
0.38691696524620056,
0.44220685958862305,
-0.7794876098632812,
0.6376335024833679,
-0.45766380429267883,
-1.0532279014587402,
-0.27853691577911377,
-0.641325831413269,
-0.8696076273918152,
0.008155491203069687,
0.5630691051483154,
-0.8291552066802979,
0.4432748556137085,
0.3208591341972351,
-0.4314540922641754,
0.7212493419647217,
-0.7383049726486206,
0.6584179997444153,
-0.2256932556629181,
-0.12118872255086899,
-0.0077918171882629395,
-0.5859701037406921,
0.2279614359140396,
0.23568299412727356,
0.1497635692358017,
0.10366138815879822,
-0.045289330184459686,
0.47770118713378906,
-0.4883913993835449,
0.7475841045379639,
-0.22023257613182068,
-0.19311195611953735,
0.8025729060173035,
0.6775190234184265,
0.2199951559305191,
-0.030182242393493652,
-0.1371588110923767,
0.2274966984987259,
0.7373923063278198,
-0.25987759232521057,
-0.22030983865261078,
0.24584394693374634,
-0.6950926184654236,
-0.47665417194366455,
-0.6186041831970215,
-0.5113756656646729,
-0.0009037256240844727,
0.5000580549240112,
0.315917432308197,
0.838264524936676,
-0.030127499252557755,
-0.06313538551330566,
0.3670755624771118,
0.28762662410736084,
0.49675390124320984,
0.7598353028297424,
-0.33520570397377014,
-0.008364340290427208,
1.0740488767623901,
0.45655113458633423,
0.6850700378417969,
0.2575846016407013,
0.11260095983743668,
-0.33474740386009216,
-0.3190988600254059,
-0.2853197455406189,
0.12148821353912354,
-0.7698808908462524,
-0.10732290893793106,
-0.3294614255428314,
-0.15666143596172333,
-0.44563621282577515,
0.049700282514095306,
-0.3195372223854065,
-1.3630661964416504,
-0.06767556071281433,
0.4954048693180084,
-0.14439751207828522,
0.890900731086731,
-0.5214450359344482,
0.14294010400772095,
-0.64224773645401,
0.5542170405387878,
0.5297074317932129,
0.6343457698822021,
0.09173388034105301,
-0.4474404752254486,
-0.1800737977027893,
-0.3507630527019501,
-0.27620041370391846,
-1.0628430843353271,
0.050664033740758896,
0.15080887079238892,
0.41464176774024963,
0.40449243783950806,
0.15911386907100677,
0.04638083279132843,
-0.35481274127960205,
0.39525794982910156,
-0.14211924374103546,
-1.2645190954208374,
-0.27914518117904663,
-0.29800671339035034,
0.19616957008838654,
0.5912649631500244,
0.538919985294342,
-0.9429388046264648,
-0.5951247215270996,
-0.38337433338165283,
-0.6254116296768188,
0.5277240872383118,
0.12657172977924347,
0.008843491785228252,
-0.10544803738594055,
0.3333234488964081,
0.10589323937892914,
0.22897492349147797,
-0.6562693119049072,
-0.444712370634079,
-0.3280538022518158,
-0.11059270799160004,
0.5102088451385498,
-0.23248645663261414,
-0.113901786506176,
-0.3564862012863159,
0.7458719611167908,
0.35295024514198303,
0.5929245948791504,
0.20064540207386017,
-0.1950017213821411,
-0.4362860918045044,
0.46376943588256836,
0.5924763083457947,
0.847927987575531,
-0.11837666481733322,
0.42850691080093384,
-0.29204025864601135,
-0.39877572655677795,
0.41000497341156006,
0.11045560240745544,
-0.5683640241622925,
-0.06731290370225906,
0.3772057294845581,
0.4660378694534302,
-0.09620913863182068,
-0.16662004590034485,
-0.22765053808689117,
-0.20723804831504822,
0.05940040573477745,
-0.24602055549621582,
0.22238710522651672,
-0.031389251351356506,
0.02263720892369747,
0.03955114632844925,
0.02713705785572529,
0.2979731261730194,
-0.7817702293395996,
-0.06083342805504799,
0.5800001621246338,
-0.2513284981250763,
-0.514955461025238,
0.705414891242981,
-0.020568981766700745,
-0.5460683107376099,
0.37322962284088135,
-0.4465714693069458,
-0.5438024997711182,
0.48605453968048096,
0.8237081170082092,
1.1532427072525024,
-0.5685958862304688,
0.06695342808961868,
0.33291706442832947,
0.4617749750614166,
0.31151703000068665,
0.6189147233963013,
-0.37971365451812744,
-0.5623770952224731,
-0.07330109924077988,
-0.46724632382392883,
-0.5434042811393738,
0.01951974630355835,
-0.6987293362617493,
-0.2226191610097885,
-0.7683171629905701,
-0.03698161244392395,
0.47652944922447205,
-0.20115035772323608,
-0.5075796842575073,
-0.25611841678619385,
0.15910232067108154,
0.538055956363678,
-0.5554088354110718,
0.69011390209198,
0.6353117823600769,
-0.35278934240341187,
-0.6813929080963135,
-0.446694016456604,
-0.06581942737102509,
-0.7593721747398376,
0.3070245683193207,
-0.22293943166732788,
-0.22119085490703583,
-0.008036661893129349,
-0.5445695519447327,
-0.8272275328636169,
0.4533264935016632,
0.25587719678878784,
-0.4297669529914856,
0.03385937958955765,
0.5481592416763306,
0.43069779872894287,
-0.03694672882556915,
-0.04147712141275406,
0.6847753524780273,
0.6651392579078674,
-0.1692344844341278,
-0.7716500759124756,
0.03896462917327881,
-0.04448021948337555,
-0.09437531232833862,
0.6734410524368286,
-0.8301699161529541,
1.038779377937317,
0.04532593861222267,
-0.899622917175293,
0.6349139213562012,
0.4631446301937103,
-0.18531948328018188,
0.15937039256095886,
0.3344283103942871,
0.7638115882873535,
0.470387727022171,
0.04421648010611534,
1.0897679328918457,
-0.4067884683609009,
0.5446868538856506,
0.7289766073226929,
-0.43724068999290466,
0.3073197603225708,
0.2104554921388626,
-0.4103522300720215,
0.41660499572753906,
-0.054040536284446716,
0.28320059180259705,
0.3281089663505554,
0.43378105759620667,
-0.8588082194328308,
-0.5750381946563721,
-0.039265621453523636,
-0.3811289966106415,
0.45302948355674744,
0.22857114672660828,
-0.35175779461860657,
-0.4847802519798279,
-0.06521161645650864,
0.1438414752483368,
-0.0687023401260376,
-0.26785436272621155,
0.507645308971405,
0.13153092563152313,
-0.46214061975479126,
0.623028576374054,
0.22448396682739258,
-0.03492704778909683,
-0.8037010431289673,
0.07057993113994598,
-0.2581596374511719,
0.22326618432998657,
-0.0890234038233757,
-0.5905365347862244,
0.4176778197288513,
0.02631818875670433,
-0.14244431257247925,
-0.3188590407371521,
0.9331716895103455,
-0.4597185552120209,
-0.4998081922531128,
0.046788014471530914,
0.3113008439540863,
0.26901087164878845,
0.3514181077480316,
-0.29170694947242737,
0.0731966570019722,
-0.14154526591300964,
-0.35947591066360474,
0.015220673754811287,
0.18401773273944855,
-0.13217812776565552,
0.6016601324081421,
0.22202494740486145,
0.1123107522726059,
0.3412909507751465,
-0.2291194349527359,
0.6867953538894653,
-0.7516534924507141,
-0.47023501992225647,
-0.5838621854782104,
0.02656705491244793,
0.6597227454185486,
-0.27517661452293396,
0.8628919124603271,
0.4657757580280304,
0.7791783213615417,
-0.004125426057726145,
1.1098849773406982,
-0.14404866099357605,
0.7885048985481262,
-0.2183072865009308,
0.749664306640625,
-0.501105546951294,
-0.11204331368207932,
-0.22541910409927368,
-0.4107585549354553,
-0.4295428395271301,
0.577862560749054,
-0.14551086723804474,
0.13884679973125458,
0.679801881313324,
0.38376379013061523,
-0.1583976149559021,
0.3064635992050171,
0.4297933876514435,
0.07114046066999435,
0.19865782558918,
0.8273693323135376,
1.0981624126434326,
-0.31635522842407227,
0.3657640218734741,
-0.3672015368938446,
-0.020630108192563057,
0.397506982088089,
-0.46747323870658875,
-0.7367185950279236,
-0.7770112156867981,
-0.2820999026298523,
-0.3981645405292511,
-0.3194901645183563,
0.3661949932575226,
0.6382076144218445,
-0.8408473134040833,
-0.7477694749832153,
0.06537943333387375,
0.4495655596256256,
-0.43350890278816223,
-0.1272648423910141,
0.47450050711631775,
-0.19738498330116272,
-0.5478368997573853,
0.4749138057231903,
0.538063645362854,
0.17220886051654816,
-0.3492240607738495,
-0.13348489999771118,
-0.08619008958339691,
0.48237884044647217,
0.5253823399543762,
1.2536053657531738,
-0.2767498195171356,
-0.21129027009010315,
-0.036710210144519806,
-0.0896107405424118,
-0.1010633334517479,
1.3015755414962769,
-0.6466360092163086,
0.5872476100921631,
0.569534420967102,
0.46697622537612915,
0.3997935652732849,
-0.17816831171512604,
0.12139611691236496,
-0.29973018169403076,
0.1011982187628746,
0.4900878369808197,
0.3202351927757263,
-0.1529502272605896,
-0.10340157151222229,
0.4129197895526886,
0.3296935260295868,
-0.6929558515548706,
-0.7749576568603516,
0.7973735332489014,
-0.8765966892242432,
-0.35495448112487793,
0.6813051104545593,
-0.11562134325504303,
-0.21565818786621094,
-0.22858044505119324,
0.39266571402549744,
0.5040688514709473,
-0.0704507976770401,
0.616064727306366,
0.6866506934165955,
-0.1957082748413086,
0.12192365527153015,
-0.30823901295661926,
0.657600462436676,
0.5189042687416077,
-0.8395444750785828,
0.21730786561965942,
0.4304004907608032,
0.3168398439884186,
0.22054295241832733,
0.9434165954589844,
-0.4214881956577301,
0.4277406930923462,
-0.059460870921611786,
0.2381087690591812,
-0.4564991593360901,
-0.7497338056564331,
-0.6062178015708923,
0.311612069606781,
0.043845172971487045,
-0.2798205018043518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18928v1 | Enhanced ASR Robustness to Packet Loss with a Front-End Adaptation Network | 2024-06-27T06:40:01 | 2024-06-27T06:40:01 | Yehoshua Dissen, Shiry Yonash, Israel Cohen, Joseph Keshet | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | In the realm of automatic speech recognition (ASR), robustness in noisy
environments remains a significant challenge. Recent ASR models, such as
Whisper, have shown promise, but their efficacy in noisy conditions can be
further enhanced. This study is focused on recovering from packet loss to
improve the word error rate (WER) of ASR models. We propose using a front-end
adaptation network connected to a frozen ASR model. The adaptation network is
trained to modify the corrupted input spectrum by minimizing the criteria of
the ASR model in addition to an enhancement loss function. Our experiments
demonstrate that the adaptation network, trained on Whisper's criteria, notably
reduces word error rates across domains and languages in packet-loss scenarios.
This improvement is achieved with minimal affect to Whisper model's
foundational performance, underscoring our method's practicality and potential
in enhancing ASR models in challenging acoustic environments. | [
-0.29494041204452515,
-0.35974782705307007,
-0.012815102934837341,
0.18626157939434052,
-0.27612221240997314,
0.11165937036275864,
-0.24866950511932373,
-0.45630279183387756,
0.13258413970470428,
0.3833153545856476,
-0.3669026792049408,
-0.12273401021957397,
-0.724818229675293,
0.1186421811580658,
-0.645510733127594,
0.6207743883132935,
0.058901309967041016,
-0.053853217512369156,
0.14674752950668335,
-0.16101136803627014,
-0.569229781627655,
-0.34020134806632996,
-1.2266168594360352,
-0.44666486978530884,
0.1847330927848816,
0.07098310440778732,
0.6288465857505798,
0.47782906889915466,
0.47458142042160034,
0.4211937487125397,
-0.10751554369926453,
0.0020054501947015524,
-0.43703803420066833,
0.15157513320446014,
0.12274233996868134,
-0.46779197454452515,
-0.4501742124557495,
-0.23016344010829926,
0.7711458206176758,
0.7007076740264893,
-0.502339780330658,
-0.23534320294857025,
0.3002215325832367,
0.8212747573852539,
-0.7123647928237915,
0.22846750915050507,
-1.0272667407989502,
0.11208174377679825,
-0.12486585974693298,
-0.2888813018798828,
-0.26563072204589844,
-0.03353842720389366,
0.39651286602020264,
-0.8052775263786316,
0.26121702790260315,
0.012030009180307388,
0.9041988849639893,
0.4771372973918915,
0.1473231464624405,
-0.1618533581495285,
-0.956616222858429,
0.28885310888290405,
-0.7146326899528503,
0.9946613311767578,
0.6423130631446838,
0.2746947407722473,
-0.1929953396320343,
-0.5309514999389648,
-0.5693826675415039,
-0.02587149478495121,
0.5576403141021729,
0.5419918298721313,
-0.7872327566146851,
0.0010846368968486786,
-0.045406606048345566,
0.21184885501861572,
-0.20742428302764893,
0.2449193000793457,
-0.37792345881462097,
-0.764670729637146,
0.49041375517845154,
0.04081730917096138,
0.11494524031877518,
0.4081946909427643,
0.09421730041503906,
-0.30440691113471985,
-0.4306999444961548,
0.1705765277147293,
0.4158298671245575,
0.6239407658576965,
-0.10980574041604996,
0.02255627140402794,
-0.23142297565937042,
0.6642102599143982,
0.16377024352550507,
-0.058925483375787735,
0.22548167407512665,
0.08611399680376053,
-0.05394835025072098,
0.4480643570423126,
0.5298671722412109,
0.45201870799064636,
0.19107648730278015,
-0.32756492495536804,
-0.4805569648742676,
0.3691768944263458,
0.31635570526123047,
-0.6226160526275635,
-0.747032105922699,
0.009687677025794983,
-0.41982606053352356,
-0.18444028496742249,
-0.2762877643108368,
-0.28342416882514954,
-0.5070825815200806,
0.04626868665218353,
0.9572954177856445,
-0.4166305959224701,
-0.3522617518901825,
0.33377805352211,
-0.37626680731773376,
0.13176187872886658,
0.6173611283302307,
-0.4960201382637024,
0.9243895411491394,
0.4027896821498871,
1.1426233053207397,
0.06454142183065414,
-0.1994682401418686,
-0.7420309782028198,
-0.0495540015399456,
-0.5871378183364868,
0.9692842960357666,
0.011910500004887581,
-0.6101576685905457,
-0.3208675682544708,
-0.21922554075717926,
-0.3008699119091034,
-0.7776308059692383,
0.5732969045639038,
-0.5625377297401428,
-0.05806518718600273,
0.009069983847439289,
-0.4132377803325653,
-0.14251893758773804,
-0.0346965566277504,
-0.6165190935134888,
0.4347057640552521,
-0.42320242524147034,
-0.7533871531486511,
0.2037985622882843,
-0.751685619354248,
-0.4809405207633972,
-0.12861356139183044,
0.3299042582511902,
-0.6349979043006897,
0.41705426573753357,
0.23476995527744293,
0.2653387784957886,
0.029453067108988762,
-0.39231249690055847,
-0.18379415571689606,
-0.47788766026496887,
0.36795157194137573,
-0.6066228151321411,
0.7010020613670349,
0.08881958574056625,
0.020364733412861824,
-0.12271741032600403,
-1.1121479272842407,
0.016298798844218254,
0.04215369373559952,
-0.729813814163208,
-0.4921893775463104,
0.3340321481227875,
-0.10731308162212372,
-0.22425954043865204,
-0.4283742904663086,
-0.6291529536247253,
-0.35347649455070496,
-0.7960320115089417,
0.515287458896637,
0.7187339663505554,
-0.09966909885406494,
0.3137233853340149,
-0.5034504532814026,
0.32598820328712463,
0.08430088311433792,
-0.2935529947280884,
0.04987216368317604,
-0.506950318813324,
-1.0112111568450928,
-0.2396870255470276,
0.5386406779289246,
0.7354682087898254,
-0.9578772187232971,
0.3843846321105957,
-0.4381906986236572,
-0.32669758796691895,
-0.8321771621704102,
0.0063025797717273235,
0.3780052661895752,
0.8884302377700806,
0.28155040740966797,
-0.8369259238243103,
-0.6335313320159912,
-0.4282008707523346,
-0.32508522272109985,
-0.3437305986881256,
-0.32190996408462524,
0.3910330533981323,
0.06150026246905327,
-0.14571671187877655,
0.820303738117218,
-0.3386213481426239,
-0.4192974269390106,
-0.04743952304124832,
-0.15899765491485596,
0.1570977419614792,
0.5676321387290955,
-0.04044077545404434,
-0.5552661418914795,
-0.3192014694213867,
-0.1848646104335785,
-0.25404536724090576,
-0.34044983983039856,
0.11176630854606628,
0.19353628158569336,
0.051050253212451935,
0.29263782501220703,
-0.22459036111831665,
0.630057156085968,
0.7346773147583008,
-0.26304200291633606,
0.5969929695129395,
-0.22046169638633728,
-0.10332188755273819,
-0.9849115610122681,
-0.03096037171781063,
-0.1301124095916748,
-0.2324429452419281,
-0.8812050223350525,
-0.4688577651977539,
-0.19536641240119934,
-0.4310016930103302,
-0.09316687285900116,
0.30399808287620544,
-0.4316803812980652,
-0.24840328097343445,
-0.48941460251808167,
0.15916907787322998,
0.2867072522640228,
0.04036147892475128,
0.19355164468288422,
0.9953909516334534,
0.8877952694892883,
-0.7476790547370911,
0.18136294186115265,
0.5829451084136963,
0.05852081626653671,
0.49289944767951965,
-0.7790563702583313,
0.3403889238834381,
-0.3056653141975403,
0.4068387746810913,
-0.7268562912940979,
-0.0568825826048851,
0.2288181632757187,
-0.49606001377105713,
0.5515658855438232,
-0.35285210609436035,
0.07245530188083649,
-0.13430704176425934,
-0.23048925399780273,
-0.12371284514665604,
0.5530198216438293,
-0.6408583521842957,
0.5123688578605652,
0.37129220366477966,
-0.11546467244625092,
-0.2772058844566345,
-0.718086302280426,
0.4187339246273041,
-0.2054649144411087,
-0.6022142171859741,
0.2433435171842575,
-0.19547955691814423,
-0.07746850699186325,
-0.2541288733482361,
-0.37754741311073303,
-0.3159927427768707,
0.2588484585285187,
0.3872120976448059,
-0.0531509704887867,
-0.3804638683795929,
0.1448340117931366,
-0.21381880342960358,
-0.24751316010951996,
-0.034782689064741135,
-0.5046405792236328,
0.37226131558418274,
-0.12061154842376709,
0.05462367832660675,
-0.8803097605705261,
0.35721516609191895,
0.2219604253768921,
-0.17605677247047424,
0.45660609006881714,
0.47900956869125366,
-0.5041195750236511,
-0.36194947361946106,
-0.5489535927772522,
-0.4225166141986847,
-0.5644254088401794,
0.3365233838558197,
-0.5030853152275085,
-0.5660030841827393,
0.6968708634376526,
-0.04079723730683327,
-0.28953778743743896,
0.14339664578437805,
-0.05681699886918068,
-0.2252938151359558,
0.4916439950466156,
0.8496374487876892,
-0.32539236545562744,
0.5232373476028442,
-0.12988102436065674,
-0.08577296882867813,
-1.0983587503433228,
0.10193350911140442,
-0.5836040377616882,
-0.006168747786432505,
-0.15188999474048615,
-0.18328611552715302,
0.4921483099460602,
0.19888438284397125,
-0.034157171845436096,
0.23906712234020233,
-0.42193010449409485,
-0.01981826312839985,
0.3760477900505066,
0.5537046790122986,
0.2657112777233124,
0.30114760994911194,
0.15110184252262115,
-0.11766821146011353,
-1.0511029958724976,
-0.06314738839864731,
0.7319120764732361,
0.6482807397842407,
0.7912009358406067,
0.28387001156806946,
0.5968407988548279,
0.13995037972927094,
0.10433391481637955,
-0.88321453332901,
0.37152034044265747,
-0.4382539987564087,
-0.19478005170822144,
-0.527626633644104,
-0.5983433723449707,
-1.0701980590820312,
0.14026594161987305,
-0.3851777911186218,
-0.8195544481277466,
0.325872540473938,
0.5149938464164734,
-0.5673497915267944,
0.17195400595664978,
-0.5195515155792236,
0.1867157518863678,
0.337591290473938,
0.011762114241719246,
0.09931045770645142,
-0.4940483868122101,
0.002453168388456106,
-0.2792011797428131,
0.17081071436405182,
-0.008742127567529678,
0.006862268783152103,
1.0301021337509155,
-0.6304604411125183,
0.8906738758087158,
-0.45801764726638794,
-0.06280858814716339,
0.2996388077735901,
0.13368622958660126,
0.5891010761260986,
-0.34099555015563965,
-0.3553677499294281,
0.3444834351539612,
-0.3178442120552063,
-0.003223063889890909,
-0.6300916075706482,
0.22078576683998108,
-0.9701310992240906,
-0.4057084023952484,
-0.07152117788791656,
-0.5297573804855347,
-0.40297672152519226,
0.053940095007419586,
0.4916187822818756,
0.9471359252929688,
0.027234181761741638,
0.11847998946905136,
0.6993435621261597,
-0.2138490378856659,
0.6210479140281677,
0.6992404460906982,
0.0562591552734375,
-0.5271621942520142,
1.0502605438232422,
0.3780800700187683,
0.3266350030899048,
-0.031457334756851196,
0.603506863117218,
-0.24073396623134613,
-1.1279666423797607,
-0.44382959604263306,
-0.4178079664707184,
-0.7283876538276672,
-0.37090906500816345,
-0.6754257678985596,
-0.5619615316390991,
-0.3642127513885498,
0.02958352491259575,
-0.7744928002357483,
-0.44631409645080566,
-0.3660876452922821,
0.3127414584159851,
0.6743763089179993,
0.2976589500904083,
-0.3651270866394043,
0.76441890001297,
-0.812117874622345,
0.14241376519203186,
0.2567702531814575,
0.4697960615158081,
-0.025729773566126823,
-1.0115708112716675,
0.0512520894408226,
-0.12010638415813446,
0.05519399419426918,
-0.7539807558059692,
0.46749821305274963,
1.2533310651779175,
0.2897910475730896,
0.23875491321086884,
0.32915180921554565,
0.8696399927139282,
-0.8701214790344238,
0.3150864839553833,
0.3455355167388916,
-1.1323020458221436,
0.5298222303390503,
-0.3086448907852173,
0.5924647450447083,
0.44264429807662964,
-0.12486661970615387,
-0.39728060364723206,
-0.28255966305732727,
-0.4280461370944977,
-0.8175103068351746,
0.36096346378326416,
0.32123038172721863,
0.1878465712070465,
0.5396493077278137,
0.4731573462486267,
-0.1361318975687027,
0.14166145026683807,
-0.40905389189720154,
-0.027054185047745705,
-0.7170384526252747,
-0.1403142362833023,
-0.11408645659685135,
0.14244604110717773,
-0.09962266683578491,
-0.18245051801204681,
0.7210270166397095,
-0.3671746551990509,
0.46898871660232544,
0.4131762683391571,
-0.014102322049438953,
-0.31920647621154785,
0.12477134168148041,
0.3777024745941162,
0.05192327871918678,
-0.007910535670816898,
0.20809267461299896,
0.5441280603408813,
-1.0073498487472534,
0.09413217753171921,
0.3551461100578308,
-0.2722724378108978,
-0.06369230896234512,
0.4684198498725891,
0.9957937598228455,
0.17552237212657928,
-0.2682052254676819,
0.565127432346344,
-0.4059200882911682,
-0.007272730581462383,
-0.35439157485961914,
0.20416408777236938,
-0.07208353281021118,
0.2388109713792801,
0.5544448494911194,
0.658666729927063,
0.46763506531715393,
-0.36742326617240906,
0.3739495277404785,
0.44418901205062866,
-0.3982290029525757,
-0.38763073086738586,
0.5991317629814148,
0.2205970287322998,
-0.7568082213401794,
0.5523035526275635,
-0.020485155284404755,
-0.8123257160186768,
0.21711012721061707,
0.9391858577728271,
0.9748102426528931,
-0.5891541242599487,
-0.10911935567855835,
-0.0035784163046628237,
0.29184669256210327,
-0.04806050285696983,
0.35331791639328003,
0.016306350007653236,
-1.2010068893432617,
-0.21353162825107574,
-0.7594799995422363,
-0.3638707399368286,
-0.1475483775138855,
-0.7996190786361694,
-0.08383212983608246,
-0.5542282462120056,
-0.315061092376709,
-0.050552744418382645,
-0.06865010410547256,
-0.44985267519950867,
0.4352222979068756,
0.06877283751964569,
0.9355295896530151,
-0.6945035457611084,
0.7999528646469116,
0.4526049792766571,
0.18927155435085297,
-0.9264179468154907,
0.2980175316333771,
0.0503002405166626,
-0.7331708669662476,
0.24047398567199707,
0.10062064975500107,
-0.6146857738494873,
0.22181859612464905,
-0.23662421107292175,
-1.0047334432601929,
1.0267307758331299,
0.33113551139831543,
-0.6628872752189636,
0.45367544889450073,
-0.30063194036483765,
0.528343141078949,
-0.18764200806617737,
-0.21309655904769897,
0.25131332874298096,
0.08283477276563644,
0.15063810348510742,
-1.4454549551010132,
-0.056550148874521255,
-0.21029092371463776,
0.13983310759067535,
0.05497422069311142,
-0.4681006968021393,
0.49714022874832153,
-0.17334826290607452,
-0.29649582505226135,
0.016491137444972992,
0.7635954022407532,
0.12031187117099762,
0.5249484181404114,
0.9827869534492493,
0.3506048321723938,
0.8299656510353088,
-0.07825256884098053,
0.5814748406410217,
-0.09357011318206787,
-0.10571581870317459,
0.9531667828559875,
-0.23791639506816864,
1.34254789352417,
0.35071900486946106,
-0.10177601873874664,
0.18564288318157196,
0.25653067231178284,
0.20462395250797272,
0.8688270449638367,
0.3466200530529022,
-0.40445953607559204,
-0.024145035073161125,
-0.06919790804386139,
-0.23249545693397522,
0.8762167096138,
0.5809919834136963,
0.05631016194820404,
-0.011564509943127632,
0.2823805809020996,
-0.04554446414113045,
0.14399699866771698,
-0.6574325561523438,
1.023700475692749,
0.1434250771999359,
0.047240905463695526,
0.7923070192337036,
-0.19715933501720428,
0.6870824694633484,
-0.42031505703926086,
0.19992013275623322,
0.025160258635878563,
0.3115687370300293,
-0.23284807801246643,
-0.10021940618753433,
0.5883289575576782,
-0.23485004901885986,
-0.2252948135137558,
0.28446799516677856,
1.2028933763504028,
-0.22261449694633484,
-0.5362322330474854,
0.1965964138507843,
0.2908390760421753,
0.35109078884124756,
-0.010704387910664082,
-0.518477737903595,
0.8041063547134399,
-0.2672898769378662,
-0.01625526137650013,
0.14192357659339905,
0.03968396410346031,
0.375436395406723,
0.854287326335907,
0.676949679851532,
0.411557674407959,
0.2769288718700409,
-0.08406706899404526,
1.0217173099517822,
-0.18639105558395386,
-0.7213433384895325,
-0.4680183231830597,
0.5150869488716125,
-0.0625147670507431,
-0.21238723397254944,
0.6146389245986938,
0.24412523210048676,
0.3540584146976471,
0.19873420894145966,
0.7681474089622498,
0.33652111887931824,
0.6041333079338074,
-0.5863932371139526,
1.0725352764129639,
-0.20650282502174377,
0.48977139592170715,
-0.45186924934387207,
-0.48424801230430603,
-0.48384910821914673,
0.9242312908172607,
0.1214071586728096,
-0.09843794256448746,
0.11494670808315277,
0.9037562608718872,
-0.05406385287642479,
0.1529841274023056,
0.5791601538658142,
0.5402989387512207,
0.06660237163305283,
0.29010647535324097,
0.5934403538703918,
-0.9476835131645203,
0.5881063342094421,
-0.32483819127082825,
-0.49473798274993896,
0.2016630470752716,
-0.847031831741333,
-0.5858628153800964,
-0.5163833498954773,
-0.7139719128608704,
-0.6035974621772766,
0.6973304152488708,
0.6655899882316589,
0.8978570103645325,
-0.7450461983680725,
-0.12855687737464905,
-0.10923096537590027,
-0.38104569911956787,
-0.23141978681087494,
-0.129258394241333,
0.39770036935806274,
-0.07987827807664871,
-0.21796365082263947,
1.0954387187957764,
0.17839673161506653,
0.1416281908750534,
0.10058631747961044,
-0.2536914348602295,
0.4499607980251312,
0.214802086353302,
0.411034494638443,
0.410308301448822,
-0.4579349160194397,
-0.6762288808822632,
-0.3195335865020752,
0.4748999774456024,
0.0341125912964344,
0.3342307507991791,
-0.865996778011322,
0.7172128558158875,
0.02881627529859543,
0.7188811302185059,
0.27698829770088196,
-0.1600678712129593,
0.7416990399360657,
-0.7815598845481873,
0.19150090217590332,
0.22942127287387848,
0.2701941430568695,
0.6459089517593384,
-0.23429957032203674,
0.10647861659526825,
0.2678113579750061,
-0.5867105722427368,
-0.930259108543396,
0.1592031568288803,
-0.8094696998596191,
-0.0227590911090374,
0.8775235414505005,
-0.41382741928100586,
-0.01609998568892479,
-0.5255905389785767,
-0.2002425640821457,
0.2559660077095032,
-0.4946543872356415,
0.9815340042114258,
0.34999680519104004,
-0.19300466775894165,
-0.40183398127555847,
-0.4017009139060974,
0.6224611401557922,
0.15165075659751892,
-0.515834391117096,
0.07340236008167267,
0.4040309488773346,
0.5731749534606934,
0.3281436264514923,
0.7398813962936401,
0.3181317448616028,
0.29099202156066895,
0.45683553814888,
-0.10305335372686386,
-0.11913514882326126,
-0.29966193437576294,
-0.8935792446136475,
0.11997606605291367,
0.44486165046691895,
-0.5071806907653809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18925v1 | Selective Vision is the Challenge for Visual Reasoning: A Benchmark for Visual Argument Understanding | 2024-06-27T06:32:56 | 2024-06-27T06:32:56 | Jiwan Chung, Sungjae Lee, Minseo Kim, Seungju Han, Ashkan Yousefpour, Jack Hessel, Youngjae Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual arguments, often used in advertising or social causes, rely on images
to persuade viewers to do or believe something. Understanding these arguments
requires selective vision: only specific visual stimuli within an image are
relevant to the argument, and relevance can only be understood within the
context of a broader argumentative structure. While visual arguments are
readily appreciated by human audiences, we ask: are today's AI capable of
similar understanding?
We collect and release VisArgs, an annotated corpus designed to make explicit
the (usually implicit) structures underlying visual arguments. VisArgs includes
1,611 images accompanied by three types of textual annotations: 5,112 visual
premises (with region annotations), 5,574 commonsense premises, and reasoning
trees connecting them to a broader argument. We propose three tasks over
VisArgs to probe machine capacity for visual argument understanding:
localization of premises, identification of premises, and deduction of
conclusions. Experiments demonstrate that 1) machines cannot fully identify the
relevant visual cues. The top-performing model, GPT-4-O, achieved an accuracy
of only 78.5%, whereas humans reached 98.0%. All models showed a performance
drop, with an average decrease in accuracy of 19.5%, when the comparison set
was changed from objects outside the image to irrelevant objects within the
image. Furthermore, 2) this limitation is the greatest factor impacting their
performance in understanding visual arguments. Most models improved the most
when given relevant visual premises as additional inputs, compared to other
inputs, for deducing the conclusion of the visual argument. | [
-0.6038028001785278,
-0.8615257143974304,
0.7332788109779358,
-0.1323385089635849,
-0.6759570837020874,
-0.3657653033733368,
-0.1400422751903534,
-0.45440906286239624,
-0.2698310613632202,
0.5516376495361328,
-0.38941627740859985,
-0.31138551235198975,
-0.6501972675323486,
0.2965569794178009,
-0.32420995831489563,
0.5983176231384277,
-0.1180952936410904,
0.1267034262418747,
-0.5139630436897278,
-0.5392700433731079,
-0.6578329205513,
-0.27198559045791626,
-0.5780549645423889,
0.06533712893724442,
0.67849200963974,
0.38043051958084106,
0.6729872822761536,
0.809348464012146,
0.8048022985458374,
0.42695388197898865,
-0.0862404927611351,
0.274227499961853,
-0.17729789018630981,
-0.0310506671667099,
-0.40526914596557617,
-0.6367597579956055,
-0.06333582103252411,
0.3017190098762512,
0.8220835328102112,
0.7219825983047485,
0.2732771933078766,
0.2890423536300659,
-0.09059718996286392,
0.8286431431770325,
-0.718644917011261,
0.14293037354946136,
-0.8717415928840637,
0.16911965608596802,
-0.3350985050201416,
0.05365235358476639,
-0.6606663465499878,
-0.05929769203066826,
0.36674124002456665,
-0.7729472517967224,
0.30323326587677,
-0.011778387241065502,
1.3224289417266846,
0.856497585773468,
-0.39031606912612915,
0.16431735455989838,
-0.5489206314086914,
0.6229788661003113,
-0.11422497779130936,
0.33872753381729126,
0.30599334836006165,
0.5474294424057007,
0.11135154217481613,
-1.0452618598937988,
-0.33220887184143066,
-0.21678613126277924,
-0.1552782654762268,
0.3166428506374359,
-0.5377137064933777,
0.1158183291554451,
0.7346953749656677,
-0.13484947383403778,
-0.5965144038200378,
-0.3485782742500305,
-0.7796236276626587,
-0.16788706183433533,
0.5817602872848511,
0.19378912448883057,
0.18965397775173187,
-0.24480348825454712,
-0.44532179832458496,
-0.14471088349819183,
-0.17522287368774414,
0.2503502666950226,
0.07832775264978409,
-0.23037363588809967,
0.08536029607057571,
0.5221028327941895,
-0.3523070812225342,
1.2493352890014648,
0.4256952106952667,
0.14525999128818512,
-0.021972959861159325,
-0.052138444036245346,
-0.6969363689422607,
-0.30844739079475403,
0.6146523952484131,
0.4003544747829437,
0.4702288806438446,
0.27981239557266235,
0.13636744022369385,
0.5967547297477722,
0.3636814057826996,
-0.4900035262107849,
-0.23677125573158264,
-0.006557221058756113,
-0.7886984348297119,
-0.10675229132175446,
0.09815314412117004,
-0.6863371133804321,
-0.6880189776420593,
-0.3853846490383148,
0.2933148741722107,
-0.38756585121154785,
0.053464580327272415,
0.006194269750267267,
-0.7395246624946594,
0.4731929898262024,
0.6172664165496826,
-0.6110445261001587,
-0.012425985187292099,
0.4503534138202667,
0.5757834911346436,
-0.2677757143974304,
-0.29042235016822815,
-0.6716674566268921,
0.038053203374147415,
-0.6778867840766907,
1.3248052597045898,
-0.9837537407875061,
-0.1171792671084404,
-0.2900952994823456,
0.1578557938337326,
-0.39963197708129883,
-0.7539743781089783,
0.8293570876121521,
-0.37806516885757446,
0.11059447377920151,
-0.5110693573951721,
-0.2813049256801605,
-0.5207543969154358,
0.3161454200744629,
-0.6527974605560303,
0.3705744743347168,
-0.03547241538763046,
-0.7708881497383118,
0.98068767786026,
-0.4640088975429535,
-0.4798636734485626,
0.4235665798187256,
-0.6369706392288208,
-0.15003730356693268,
0.35435566306114197,
0.43249404430389404,
0.32085368037223816,
-0.1228809729218483,
0.23084744811058044,
-0.25496774911880493,
-0.2998383939266205,
0.2623637914657593,
-0.6381034851074219,
0.8776114583015442,
0.3856743574142456,
-0.49750587344169617,
0.5494627356529236,
-0.5928385257720947,
-0.3366529941558838,
0.16249899566173553,
-0.11273617297410965,
-0.11532022058963776,
0.42262622714042664,
-0.39708811044692993,
-0.051394667476415634,
0.1391066312789917,
-0.25394105911254883,
0.05455517768859863,
-0.14765505492687225,
0.4022151827812195,
0.9804298877716064,
-0.2178201824426651,
0.46115514636039734,
0.022775614634156227,
0.6056252121925354,
-0.005054459907114506,
0.4874493479728699,
-0.19597209990024567,
-0.847694993019104,
-0.9219335317611694,
-0.5807011723518372,
0.0160396546125412,
0.6557872295379639,
-0.727295458316803,
-0.25387996435165405,
-0.2511240839958191,
-0.23091503977775574,
-0.38648539781570435,
-0.03131447732448578,
0.10307016968727112,
0.5694486498832703,
0.18886268138885498,
-0.15415410697460175,
-0.4872402846813202,
-1.2475731372833252,
-0.35195469856262207,
-0.2808551490306854,
0.10947045683860779,
0.5943712592124939,
0.44195982813835144,
-0.21333147585391998,
0.9574885368347168,
-0.3157641291618347,
-0.26533082127571106,
-0.3566266596317291,
-0.10690359026193619,
0.22095173597335815,
-0.015487189404666424,
0.5786368250846863,
-0.949851393699646,
-0.5484024286270142,
0.26920899748802185,
-1.193670630455017,
0.008513207547366619,
-0.4027984142303467,
-0.0503460168838501,
0.06435242295265198,
0.439391553401947,
-0.6127915978431702,
0.8463424444198608,
0.16410097479820251,
-0.5102697014808655,
0.28264108300209045,
-0.08332598954439163,
0.04659489914774895,
-0.4794568717479706,
0.019658345729112625,
0.17184801399707794,
-0.1424235701560974,
-0.36348050832748413,
0.17322349548339844,
-0.015736227855086327,
-0.2077714204788208,
-0.4436422288417816,
0.6408104300498962,
-0.39351800084114075,
0.11653023213148117,
-0.1631404459476471,
0.17766691744327545,
0.07082907110452652,
0.2626418173313141,
0.23326167464256287,
0.6592512726783752,
0.7313957214355469,
-0.32821205258369446,
0.7497907280921936,
0.06344496458768845,
-0.4314260482788086,
0.8533135652542114,
-0.5985838770866394,
-0.02879173308610916,
-0.465408056974411,
0.23998987674713135,
-1.1254656314849854,
-0.5164532661437988,
0.5256206393241882,
-0.4791640639305115,
0.135446235537529,
-0.4291382431983948,
0.026209615170955658,
-0.5131152868270874,
0.016774477437138557,
0.33095601201057434,
0.44924935698509216,
-0.6465377807617188,
1.1136027574539185,
0.252358078956604,
0.18755587935447693,
-0.7117790579795837,
-0.6055951714515686,
0.2567936182022095,
-0.4511920213699341,
-1.0171256065368652,
0.001595253823325038,
0.22707848250865936,
-0.7747769355773926,
0.16530215740203857,
0.014278088696300983,
0.13787508010864258,
-0.1747536063194275,
0.5731754899024963,
0.35556256771087646,
-0.1784343421459198,
-0.06549864262342453,
-0.3346309959888458,
-0.21862247586250305,
0.03515813872218132,
-0.29772135615348816,
0.0033974102698266506,
-0.5334604978561401,
-0.39473041892051697,
-0.6029579639434814,
0.46193742752075195,
0.6618152260780334,
-0.6128683686256409,
0.2000836282968521,
0.7065748572349548,
-0.2688913345336914,
-0.1689096838235855,
-0.7910757660865784,
0.004099711775779724,
-0.5394201874732971,
0.2881569564342499,
-0.5911237597465515,
-0.5602730512619019,
0.3641378581523895,
0.06854646652936935,
0.020155763253569603,
0.5566763281822205,
0.3846486508846283,
-0.17284318804740906,
1.2642754316329956,
0.3036898672580719,
0.15641944110393524,
0.614990770816803,
-0.2689347565174103,
0.08355706930160522,
-0.4997921884059906,
-0.35682275891304016,
-0.19266478717327118,
-0.42498546838760376,
-0.45937779545783997,
-0.6278414726257324,
0.14841404557228088,
-0.03341341018676758,
-0.08012474328279495,
-0.01983651891350746,
-0.9084973931312561,
0.5446404814720154,
0.8226946592330933,
0.030911099165678024,
-0.16148829460144043,
0.4885143041610718,
-0.29892849922180176,
-0.06740264594554901,
-0.6394606232643127,
-0.546454668045044,
0.7130221724510193,
0.22974279522895813,
0.4732307493686676,
-0.3108932673931122,
0.2767065167427063,
0.2973781228065491,
0.4090678095817566,
-0.7785415649414062,
0.9390020966529846,
-0.45224514603614807,
-0.7187470197677612,
0.007328864187002182,
-0.17261163890361786,
-1.084416151046753,
0.5236971974372864,
-0.1474461555480957,
-0.877876877784729,
0.3205696940422058,
0.14903436601161957,
-0.25223302841186523,
0.40069276094436646,
-0.9351494312286377,
1.2658435106277466,
-0.30020955204963684,
-0.7800150513648987,
-0.3335610330104828,
-0.5703815221786499,
0.24980740249156952,
0.5603857636451721,
-0.015557297505438328,
0.017043093219399452,
0.26760250329971313,
0.9127732515335083,
-0.10609950870275497,
0.7896819114685059,
-0.32639673352241516,
0.43806058168411255,
0.8202012777328491,
-0.056532226502895355,
0.22369393706321716,
-0.21664486825466156,
0.11948587000370026,
0.10862953215837479,
-0.11427628993988037,
-0.43458643555641174,
-0.5262513160705566,
0.22814713418483734,
-0.48755526542663574,
-1.135105848312378,
-0.4834405481815338,
-0.34033071994781494,
0.06383562088012695,
-0.01171084400266409,
0.2655910551548004,
0.34960073232650757,
0.05200181156396866,
0.25958046317100525,
0.46119919419288635,
-0.2022131383419037,
0.433820515871048,
-0.0335150845348835,
0.10778360813856125,
-0.5795331001281738,
1.0593246221542358,
-0.007855027914047241,
-0.17601759731769562,
0.09385619312524796,
0.38592255115509033,
-0.32015180587768555,
-0.5947234034538269,
-0.6982959508895874,
0.15300071239471436,
-1.1921091079711914,
0.10301707684993744,
-0.4262031316757202,
0.1307322233915329,
-0.08809059858322144,
-0.382144957780838,
0.05997907742857933,
-0.17405188083648682,
-0.27757295966148376,
-0.13923156261444092,
0.17121848464012146,
0.7382597923278809,
-0.0014773980947211385,
0.026178838685154915,
-0.416610985994339,
0.5874425172805786,
0.6729266047477722,
0.19446304440498352,
-0.3680300712585449,
-0.45527124404907227,
0.14206722378730774,
-0.18334709107875824,
-0.22469869256019592,
-1.0870968103408813,
0.23679767549037933,
-0.1350034773349762,
0.9397072792053223,
1.0293300151824951,
-0.21598997712135315,
0.8718447685241699,
-0.32192331552505493,
0.9482711553573608,
0.04338390380144119,
-0.559247612953186,
0.8974016904830933,
-0.34996113181114197,
0.22606392204761505,
0.5469759702682495,
0.14764077961444855,
-0.04069565236568451,
-0.09957575052976608,
-0.5465667843818665,
-0.43883562088012695,
0.5670251846313477,
-0.10646851360797882,
-0.1788894236087799,
-0.1287907510995865,
0.37106379866600037,
-0.13431350886821747,
-0.20951727032661438,
-0.6263172030448914,
0.1600409299135208,
-0.2108052521944046,
-0.06788692623376846,
0.17442700266838074,
-0.039008378982543945,
-0.30594369769096375,
-0.6411469578742981,
0.01862545870244503,
-0.15077221393585205,
0.14721323549747467,
0.44035011529922485,
0.014120608568191528,
-0.009036685340106487,
0.08713196218013763,
0.6606372594833374,
0.8232671618461609,
-0.07479134947061539,
0.22831015288829803,
0.29534703493118286,
-0.4658563435077667,
-0.18276181817054749,
0.06983170658349991,
-0.5055105090141296,
0.03107595257461071,
0.5007650256156921,
1.17220139503479,
-0.6885990500450134,
-0.8048145771026611,
0.48197904229164124,
-0.2889588475227356,
-0.39883923530578613,
-0.22687901556491852,
0.12489437311887741,
-0.15908144414424896,
0.5495471954345703,
0.26802337169647217,
0.6304763555526733,
0.03693990781903267,
-0.4903722405433655,
0.010827720165252686,
0.8088685274124146,
-0.5773177742958069,
-0.10054519772529602,
0.972457230091095,
0.2897648215293884,
-0.15285471081733704,
0.6872615814208984,
-0.08421347290277481,
-0.5340220928192139,
0.7501101493835449,
0.09502111375331879,
0.9286707639694214,
0.19159211218357086,
0.28179317712783813,
0.4143284857273102,
0.5525614619255066,
0.08158287405967712,
0.26699474453926086,
-0.27971142530441284,
-0.5411096811294556,
-0.32531729340553284,
-0.3760932981967926,
-0.24122972786426544,
-0.0697941780090332,
-0.32253432273864746,
0.01284724846482277,
-0.6765236258506775,
-0.46557632088661194,
0.09313679486513138,
-0.1713775396347046,
-0.8770591616630554,
0.35248205065727234,
0.44300156831741333,
0.7785457372665405,
-0.8054338097572327,
0.42593348026275635,
0.9456390738487244,
-0.4932814836502075,
-0.5819659233093262,
-0.22165875136852264,
-0.18227043747901917,
-0.6786841750144958,
0.8114466667175293,
0.38446927070617676,
-0.23512785136699677,
-0.4646049737930298,
-0.8962498903274536,
-0.44305938482284546,
0.7764468193054199,
0.5844749808311462,
-0.44526243209838867,
0.2539823353290558,
-0.06479392200708389,
0.38453227281570435,
-0.35974881052970886,
0.10446999222040176,
0.4226672351360321,
0.7980840802192688,
0.0974198654294014,
-0.566025972366333,
0.0863334983587265,
-0.25022968649864197,
-0.2783564031124115,
-0.24031254649162292,
-0.6037542223930359,
0.6305059790611267,
-0.6851692199707031,
-0.37754741311073303,
-0.1368614137172699,
0.5297617316246033,
0.21507717669010162,
0.5365347266197205,
0.6483799815177917,
0.610636293888092,
0.6612664461135864,
-0.1403723955154419,
1.2767475843429565,
0.11019832640886307,
-0.26565277576446533,
0.7558638453483582,
-0.2701844274997711,
0.9996083974838257,
0.6013309955596924,
-0.09014822542667389,
0.37896203994750977,
0.8204241991043091,
-0.36359351873397827,
0.45419687032699585,
0.05134588107466698,
-0.24908366799354553,
-0.8231328129768372,
-0.34564465284347534,
-0.16215041279792786,
0.5850475430488586,
0.4256068170070648,
-0.508989155292511,
0.13744571805000305,
-0.09641940146684647,
-0.5494353175163269,
0.1472788006067276,
-0.29480552673339844,
0.7083250880241394,
-0.10668922960758209,
-1.1284552812576294,
0.5910165905952454,
-0.10697941482067108,
0.20777790248394012,
-0.38838210701942444,
-0.11912288516759872,
-0.1177184134721756,
0.38097330927848816,
-0.2775225043296814,
-0.8279876112937927,
0.11913004517555237,
0.13750918209552765,
-0.04454328119754791,
-0.08477829396724701,
0.9404459595680237,
0.2531256079673767,
-0.7776751518249512,
0.22294928133487701,
0.3726685345172882,
0.06186825782060623,
-0.12649577856063843,
-0.6240478754043579,
0.23427431285381317,
0.1760464608669281,
-0.15622098743915558,
-0.11667896807193756,
0.45858705043792725,
-0.416507363319397,
0.63338702917099,
0.5561782121658325,
0.04309465363621712,
0.27009886503219604,
0.18186905980110168,
0.7675124406814575,
-0.47667044401168823,
-0.16941885650157928,
-1.0385786294937134,
0.4804375171661377,
-0.35031071305274963,
-0.3116379380226135,
0.54094398021698,
0.36204952001571655,
0.8186425566673279,
-0.1884526163339615,
0.7822890281677246,
0.18912620842456818,
-0.13259993493556976,
-0.20344243943691254,
0.44747239351272583,
-0.7039391398429871,
-0.20700287818908691,
-0.18505354225635529,
-0.7251092195510864,
-0.48733434081077576,
1.1881955862045288,
-0.6601653695106506,
-0.1968691051006317,
0.666763961315155,
0.506828248500824,
-0.10160867869853973,
-0.07138822972774506,
0.3973301947116852,
-0.029484787955880165,
0.11236456036567688,
0.5565593838691711,
1.2786561250686646,
-0.002557936357334256,
0.8839455842971802,
0.05455746501684189,
-0.34557363390922546,
-0.030235938727855682,
-0.652492344379425,
-1.2339380979537964,
-0.45786425471305847,
-0.45860958099365234,
-0.05257029831409454,
0.13515551388263702,
0.3896997272968292,
0.9345198273658752,
-0.45790767669677734,
-0.04933249205350876,
-0.2511543333530426,
0.1827627569437027,
-0.2814647853374481,
-0.17078185081481934,
0.41362425684928894,
-0.19455072283744812,
-0.46402037143707275,
0.4148988723754883,
0.5585956573486328,
-0.3047712743282318,
-0.010355127044022083,
0.035692181438207626,
-0.008126900531351566,
0.14704780280590057,
0.7019875049591064,
0.26382356882095337,
-1.245444416999817,
-0.3573228418827057,
0.05106557533144951,
0.11634484678506851,
0.25602537393569946,
0.6910977363586426,
-0.993782103061676,
0.8366608619689941,
0.7947268486022949,
0.6240793466567993,
0.5720363259315491,
0.1018684133887291,
0.28075215220451355,
-0.188511461019516,
0.4242469072341919,
0.098903127014637,
0.8001869916915894,
0.3770482540130615,
0.04499124363064766,
0.5916083455085754,
0.5288894176483154,
-0.21130357682704926,
-0.4936077892780304,
0.34878212213516235,
-1.271152138710022,
-0.4816507399082184,
1.1232413053512573,
-0.08757742494344711,
-0.49491438269615173,
0.05619259923696518,
-0.7222827672958374,
0.06183886155486107,
-0.164378821849823,
0.5109241008758545,
0.6604942679405212,
-0.2749095857143402,
-0.4260842800140381,
-0.6568472981452942,
0.4429665803909302,
0.5712186098098755,
-0.6771212816238403,
-0.0029000642243772745,
0.9105051159858704,
0.11212949454784393,
0.2520380914211273,
0.5488744974136353,
-0.013337361626327038,
0.6064993739128113,
0.4522794485092163,
-0.5864254236221313,
0.07056912779808044,
-0.5770524740219116,
-0.19721494615077972,
0.551444411277771,
0.06124700605869293,
-0.6275299787521362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18921v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18921v2 | Capturing Minds, Not Just Words: Enhancing Role-Playing Language Models with Personality-Indicative Data | 2024-06-27T06:24:00 | 2024-06-29T05:58:28 | Yiting Ran, Xintao Wang, Rui Xu, Xinfeng Yuan, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao, Deqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Role-playing agents (RPA) have been a popular application area for large
language models (LLMs), attracting significant interest from both industry and
academia.While existing RPAs well portray the characters' knowledge and tones,
they face challenges in capturing their minds, especially for small
role-playing language models (RPLMs). In this paper, we propose to enhance
RPLMs via personality-indicative data. Specifically, we leverage questions from
psychological scales and distill advanced RPAs to generate dialogues that grasp
the minds of characters. Experimental results validate that RPLMs trained with
our dataset exhibit advanced role-playing capabilities for both general and
personality-related evaluations. Code and data are available at
\href{https://github.com/alienet1109/RolePersonality}{this URL}. | [
-0.6456648707389832,
-0.5968781113624573,
0.8122396469116211,
0.3209185302257538,
-0.19032719731330872,
-0.06550949811935425,
-0.5137762427330017,
-0.5362118482589722,
0.4013563394546509,
0.8574998378753662,
-0.7564419507980347,
-0.39457565546035767,
-0.5517488718032837,
-0.18259784579277039,
-0.0989183783531189,
0.8935191035270691,
0.5236858129501343,
-0.026167400181293488,
-0.39273369312286377,
-0.11055727303028107,
-0.38747280836105347,
-0.6820091605186462,
-0.817169189453125,
-0.6233913898468018,
0.7420622110366821,
0.5240031480789185,
0.5100829005241394,
0.4260950982570648,
0.17154322564601898,
0.1856968253850937,
0.33675551414489746,
0.3502604067325592,
-0.30266284942626953,
0.6253373026847839,
-0.275941401720047,
-0.8031624555587769,
-0.6454447507858276,
0.3150802254676819,
0.5432894229888916,
0.44480010867118835,
-0.25877758860588074,
0.15065106749534607,
-0.18697093427181244,
0.7662262916564941,
-0.32224276661872864,
0.6365155577659607,
-0.38633450865745544,
0.22676515579223633,
-0.342051237821579,
-0.28095561265945435,
-0.6338793635368347,
-0.12444151937961578,
0.2257368266582489,
-0.5819627642631531,
0.08466291427612305,
-0.046182259917259216,
0.4173436164855957,
0.1484435796737671,
-0.20187066495418549,
-0.28182294964790344,
-0.7789474725723267,
0.7050433158874512,
-0.6238626837730408,
0.25444215536117554,
0.568229079246521,
0.3153071105480194,
-0.17162886261940002,
-0.2959537208080292,
-0.674986720085144,
-0.3316120505332947,
-0.06264694780111313,
0.24033109843730927,
0.10185176134109497,
-0.015956982970237732,
0.38824328780174255,
0.19993893802165985,
-0.18688972294330597,
-0.08842319250106812,
-0.17488275468349457,
0.06620470434427261,
0.9188514351844788,
0.15557312965393066,
0.32733672857284546,
0.14272841811180115,
0.09068810939788818,
-0.3862767815589905,
-0.6906918287277222,
0.27596065402030945,
0.47123828530311584,
0.49721601605415344,
-0.132935032248497,
0.667610228061676,
-0.07423709332942963,
0.5030995011329651,
0.3439059555530548,
-0.06553550809621811,
-0.06848794221878052,
0.16502468287944794,
-0.022833043709397316,
-0.3780846893787384,
0.6087648272514343,
0.3733546733856201,
0.7517934441566467,
-0.09537073969841003,
-0.17107005417346954,
0.07032734155654907,
0.5247480869293213,
-0.87725830078125,
-0.5110694766044617,
0.3950980603694916,
-0.40888047218322754,
-0.23110297322273254,
0.03347992151975632,
-1.1111341714859009,
-0.8922297358512878,
-0.16496075689792633,
0.13235081732273102,
-0.30630072951316833,
-0.6844941973686218,
-0.1575762778520584,
-0.2336951196193695,
0.5181905031204224,
0.2448650449514389,
-1.0058457851409912,
0.350053995847702,
0.7199907302856445,
0.47843122482299805,
-0.05808599293231964,
-0.2951008379459381,
-0.5146563053131104,
-0.05903215333819389,
-0.40606430172920227,
0.967947781085968,
-0.8010841012001038,
-0.505760133266449,
0.006561713293194771,
-0.372807115316391,
-0.07514721155166626,
-0.5197443962097168,
0.3332899808883667,
-0.4386039972305298,
0.1913825422525406,
-0.49715420603752136,
-0.48975998163223267,
0.1449475735425949,
0.3642440438270569,
-0.6686277985572815,
0.7927578687667847,
-0.16941384971141815,
-0.31202995777130127,
0.3830995559692383,
-0.7390212416648865,
-0.36563706398010254,
0.1830994188785553,
-0.7106110453605652,
-0.26066622138023376,
0.33503857254981995,
0.4274868667125702,
0.7852142453193665,
-0.019903259351849556,
0.13862860202789307,
-0.30320459604263306,
-0.0851607620716095,
0.7742247581481934,
-0.226799875497818,
0.33189162611961365,
-0.1108226552605629,
0.015187248587608337,
0.1561865657567978,
-0.4570474922657013,
0.15497587621212006,
0.06878067553043365,
-0.014083507470786572,
-0.13910166919231415,
0.19184012711048126,
-0.08814548701047897,
0.44707322120666504,
0.2636195421218872,
-0.432580828666687,
0.13321922719478607,
-0.25425341725349426,
0.22004787623882294,
0.5634159445762634,
0.09226413816213608,
0.33988574147224426,
-0.5234427452087402,
0.9252497553825378,
0.003452352713793516,
-0.06270120292901993,
0.04008098691701889,
-0.751194179058075,
-0.6697273254394531,
-0.5677347183227539,
-0.030466191470623016,
0.45025357604026794,
-0.6688303351402283,
0.6025192141532898,
-0.18798533082008362,
-0.7498456239700317,
-0.5702336430549622,
-0.16874119639396667,
0.48337501287460327,
0.24374337494373322,
0.2542770802974701,
-0.5331172943115234,
-0.42698395252227783,
-0.9234909415245056,
-0.3866417407989502,
-0.5204429626464844,
-0.23023675382137299,
0.7653998732566833,
0.1660464107990265,
0.19930753111839294,
1.315920114517212,
-0.6202056407928467,
-0.4784564971923828,
-0.7842284440994263,
0.1385078728199005,
-0.14521721005439758,
0.2565927505493164,
0.4715096950531006,
-0.6612982153892517,
-0.5204254984855652,
-0.16141077876091003,
-0.7120944857597351,
-0.19307279586791992,
-0.11534631997346878,
0.014109857380390167,
-0.11946883797645569,
0.46009111404418945,
-1.0646361112594604,
0.2379048466682434,
0.473483681678772,
-0.5255302786827087,
0.6415685415267944,
-0.19675478339195251,
0.11402423679828644,
-0.8674066066741943,
0.3596116602420807,
0.21691863238811493,
-0.26542648673057556,
-0.8449384570121765,
0.3696036636829376,
-0.13248774409294128,
-0.22368377447128296,
-0.23750559985637665,
0.7159594297409058,
-0.4970928430557251,
-0.26964011788368225,
-0.2730163037776947,
0.5955928564071655,
-0.038904834538698196,
0.6613744497299194,
0.42818740010261536,
1.0919350385665894,
0.4580141007900238,
-0.5361213684082031,
0.15886586904525757,
0.3490299582481384,
-0.35403212904930115,
0.7802378535270691,
-0.4874139726161957,
0.32897382974624634,
-0.3166176974773407,
0.4364364743232727,
-0.7241767048835754,
-0.4001023471355438,
0.08312596380710602,
-0.5508203506469727,
0.32541242241859436,
-0.10495588183403015,
-0.25718095898628235,
-0.046707626432180405,
-0.20863653719425201,
0.009754810482263565,
0.5558462738990784,
-0.22636818885803223,
0.9467073082923889,
0.826098620891571,
-0.47692498564720154,
-0.6407960653305054,
-0.5717089772224426,
0.18546725809574127,
-0.5122283697128296,
-0.15773990750312805,
0.2786146104335785,
-0.21743610501289368,
-0.2830095887184143,
-0.2825961410999298,
0.10628965497016907,
-0.17074397206306458,
-0.07456891238689423,
0.09015567600727081,
0.011668635532259941,
0.05137249827384949,
0.2503565549850464,
-0.058913495391607285,
0.12938308715820312,
0.38765275478363037,
0.17830732464790344,
0.6737294793128967,
-0.138361856341362,
0.02874414436519146,
-0.4529670178890228,
0.505316972732544,
0.6471427083015442,
-0.5245146155357361,
0.5287490487098694,
0.37685954570770264,
-0.23545585572719574,
-0.4508887231349945,
-0.5294901728630066,
-0.4243236780166626,
-0.42016538977622986,
0.5219815969467163,
-0.605621874332428,
-0.7166550159454346,
0.8067114949226379,
0.10153137892484665,
-0.032508425414562225,
-0.043290235102176666,
0.41329196095466614,
-0.06825443357229233,
1.0486986637115479,
0.8068844676017761,
0.06786411255598068,
0.6103670597076416,
0.04066291078925133,
0.17052757740020752,
-1.1064174175262451,
-0.12050935626029968,
-0.22269131243228912,
-0.2439665049314499,
-0.3540692925453186,
-0.5495033860206604,
0.06341375410556793,
-0.34471726417541504,
0.14390581846237183,
0.29141274094581604,
-0.3428167998790741,
0.5511395931243896,
0.18063965439796448,
0.27916333079338074,
0.1407238095998764,
-0.30485406517982483,
0.1856812834739685,
-0.3335372507572174,
-0.3354858458042145,
-0.7842724323272705,
1.2045443058013916,
0.5919201970100403,
0.5475276708602905,
0.3163093328475952,
0.6755753755569458,
0.2636266350746155,
0.6117002964019775,
-1.045563817024231,
0.9805294871330261,
-0.08149117976427078,
-0.6931961178779602,
-0.4759198725223541,
-0.2705860435962677,
-0.6535291075706482,
0.25301241874694824,
-0.3525984287261963,
-0.808258593082428,
0.29255354404449463,
0.2882324159145355,
-0.6323978304862976,
-0.115691177546978,
-0.45582127571105957,
0.7436916828155518,
0.07971519231796265,
-0.06736823916435242,
-0.48157602548599243,
-0.555417001247406,
0.33373838663101196,
0.08782083541154861,
-0.11162698268890381,
-0.14099262654781342,
-0.05947752296924591,
0.6169204115867615,
0.0203020628541708,
1.0915015935897827,
-0.5389714241027832,
-0.42982369661331177,
0.30874234437942505,
-0.010337195359170437,
0.4301392138004303,
0.14153432846069336,
-0.07432802021503448,
-0.28762176632881165,
-0.07671835273504257,
-0.22421029210090637,
-1.0036084651947021,
0.5261829495429993,
-0.7324844598770142,
-0.6457531452178955,
-0.3504338562488556,
-0.6266461610794067,
-0.7194891571998596,
-0.006748801097273827,
-0.1279594898223877,
0.36092710494995117,
-0.6914582848548889,
0.12999042868614197,
1.0185964107513428,
-0.04327903315424919,
0.10859014838933945,
0.4868980348110199,
-0.3145749270915985,
-0.28754687309265137,
0.8139916062355042,
-0.03298208862543106,
0.33684176206588745,
0.32985249161720276,
0.08305089175701141,
-0.4272771179676056,
-0.3760230541229248,
-0.31357094645500183,
0.35941535234451294,
-0.6427344679832458,
0.04169481247663498,
-0.8174415230751038,
-0.01194903813302517,
-0.4368133246898651,
0.24254857003688812,
-0.3458159863948822,
-0.4826761484146118,
-0.23646225035190582,
-0.14944756031036377,
0.3538156747817993,
0.7506436109542847,
0.035793617367744446,
0.5166297554969788,
-0.49785059690475464,
0.23703666031360626,
0.6927471160888672,
0.19631631672382355,
0.18867255747318268,
-0.27976223826408386,
-0.2004421353340149,
-0.030338022857904434,
0.023083770647644997,
-0.9755241870880127,
0.6405097246170044,
0.4499439597129822,
0.6306460499763489,
0.2943117320537567,
-0.17275270819664001,
0.6796302795410156,
-0.39679279923439026,
0.8594585061073303,
-0.2692872881889343,
-0.9057574272155762,
0.554607629776001,
-0.46747535467147827,
0.1625409573316574,
0.7787537574768066,
-0.025197219103574753,
-0.7201868891716003,
-0.6185517311096191,
-0.5854260325431824,
-0.41617944836616516,
0.7053928375244141,
0.03580482304096222,
0.15247033536434174,
-0.08244659006595612,
0.585965096950531,
-0.09536515176296234,
0.3910413682460785,
-0.6477275490760803,
-0.10378070920705795,
-0.1865364909172058,
-0.48349589109420776,
-0.18269522488117218,
0.00540652172639966,
-0.2930895984172821,
0.08906100690364838,
0.576859176158905,
-0.3836991488933563,
0.5912860035896301,
0.3099215030670166,
0.014891894534230232,
0.08241572231054306,
0.2904914319515228,
0.7255964875221252,
0.4777637720108032,
-0.18780282139778137,
0.15553531050682068,
-0.09677617251873016,
-0.7881151437759399,
-0.12311563640832901,
-0.1024322584271431,
0.19400304555892944,
-0.5151529908180237,
0.29472872614860535,
0.47921228408813477,
-0.06802765280008316,
-0.9694055914878845,
0.5274296402931213,
-0.3156295418739319,
0.28786158561706543,
-0.5432016849517822,
0.3747541010379791,
0.19148212671279907,
0.3651829659938812,
0.3393508195877075,
-0.15362519025802612,
-0.0562058687210083,
-0.9443513751029968,
0.3307034969329834,
0.5680232644081116,
-0.542675256729126,
-0.4777633249759674,
0.25644707679748535,
0.4094044268131256,
-0.5123995542526245,
0.4457939863204956,
-0.30546748638153076,
-0.43008100986480713,
0.7234129309654236,
0.5562881231307983,
0.9834874868392944,
-0.28740501403808594,
0.326147198677063,
-0.015331733971834183,
0.22869831323623657,
-0.02392507717013359,
0.4131419360637665,
-0.23348496854305267,
-1.0620485544204712,
-0.44097521901130676,
-0.09955570846796036,
-0.77931147813797,
0.28035956621170044,
-0.8375982046127319,
0.05656864866614342,
-0.7369675636291504,
-0.37127232551574707,
-0.3016292154788971,
0.4137541949748993,
-0.6337984800338745,
0.37051013112068176,
0.20701798796653748,
0.8622819185256958,
-0.8995078802108765,
1.049896240234375,
0.7321376800537109,
-0.39664798974990845,
-0.6644853353500366,
0.3032296299934387,
-0.3176164925098419,
-0.6922957301139832,
0.39684391021728516,
0.263791024684906,
-0.09775008261203766,
0.24496565759181976,
-0.3954876959323883,
-0.42878949642181396,
1.2238011360168457,
0.03225831314921379,
-0.16066333651542664,
-0.242990642786026,
0.09371397644281387,
0.8132304549217224,
-0.9863355755805969,
0.3161541521549225,
0.8003751039505005,
0.42664235830307007,
-0.32510292530059814,
-0.6238723993301392,
0.016286320984363556,
-0.39462822675704956,
-0.20130474865436554,
-0.10549686849117279,
-0.6765400171279907,
0.6199269890785217,
-0.11213880032300949,
-0.26439446210861206,
0.18222521245479584,
1.0695273876190186,
0.6716259121894836,
0.0687837079167366,
0.6208362579345703,
0.39980414509773254,
0.7757611274719238,
0.13440760970115662,
0.8333065509796143,
-0.3670823276042938,
0.012352623045444489,
1.2704979181289673,
-0.5179008841514587,
1.0312247276306152,
0.45279088616371155,
0.08187882602214813,
0.663984477519989,
0.26619136333465576,
0.14883482456207275,
0.47977524995803833,
-0.021584127098321915,
-0.4398099482059479,
-0.5721269845962524,
-0.07269452512264252,
0.004307528492063284,
0.5992476940155029,
0.8693423271179199,
-0.19989919662475586,
0.2639165222644806,
-0.039834871888160706,
-0.01807083934545517,
0.511005699634552,
-0.14576414227485657,
0.6409297585487366,
0.28243696689605713,
-0.9699839353561401,
-0.3554477095603943,
-0.16012784838676453,
0.6734153628349304,
-0.6439369916915894,
-0.09944900125265121,
-0.28307920694351196,
0.17513398826122284,
0.05024247244000435,
-1.008715271949768,
0.14652657508850098,
0.03240984305739403,
-0.16553089022636414,
-0.45128366351127625,
0.757469117641449,
-0.7404342293739319,
-0.2062157243490219,
0.20545896887779236,
0.7397730350494385,
0.3395882546901703,
-0.1359310746192932,
-0.586669385433197,
-0.06438284367322922,
-0.25051525235176086,
-0.171805277466774,
0.3309175968170166,
0.36415761709213257,
0.060792457312345505,
0.8272470831871033,
0.2827669680118561,
0.4017375111579895,
-0.33150261640548706,
0.3229256570339203,
0.6420996189117432,
-0.7955909371376038,
-0.5718442797660828,
-0.5040121078491211,
0.5357093811035156,
-0.3518037796020508,
-0.5094894170761108,
0.6190440654754639,
0.2746061682701111,
0.36270928382873535,
-0.24379800260066986,
0.7212175130844116,
-0.12667842209339142,
0.5222387313842773,
-0.28334227204322815,
0.9583046436309814,
-0.008220003917813301,
-0.02127244882285595,
-0.12836647033691406,
-0.824842095375061,
-0.13112202286720276,
0.8574308753013611,
-0.22520029544830322,
0.21464870870113373,
0.3986299932003021,
0.8343914151191711,
0.0914214700460434,
0.009714147076010704,
0.46673792600631714,
0.017100052908062935,
0.6484667062759399,
0.5983014106750488,
0.8220537304878235,
-0.1502220779657364,
0.1740141212940216,
-0.08236702531576157,
-0.5856410264968872,
0.01470851805061102,
-0.8555607199668884,
-1.4066132307052612,
-0.42658719420433044,
-0.3670054078102112,
-0.13932913541793823,
-0.13426929712295532,
1.0308501720428467,
0.7521952986717224,
-0.4404003918170929,
-0.43736541271209717,
-0.10174114257097244,
-0.20683656632900238,
-0.535904586315155,
-0.2529918849468231,
-0.032062482088804245,
-0.2953716218471527,
-0.8589720129966736,
0.8280022144317627,
0.052538227289915085,
-0.02675483375787735,
-1.0053762197494507,
0.11341510713100433,
0.004368228372186422,
0.7962928414344788,
0.753907322883606,
0.44409337639808655,
-0.6218701601028442,
-0.5209422707557678,
0.125529944896698,
0.04814475029706955,
-0.14239436388015747,
1.104170799255371,
-0.8478046655654907,
0.2169482260942459,
0.3033425807952881,
0.2973286807537079,
0.2901090085506439,
0.196575328707695,
0.9480746388435364,
-1.183313250541687,
0.11770875751972198,
0.32081159949302673,
0.08980975300073624,
0.4975714385509491,
-0.601495623588562,
0.2884215712547302,
-0.1050509363412857,
-0.5310868620872498,
-0.7020508050918579,
0.6657997965812683,
-0.9952617287635803,
0.05125531926751137,
1.0291582345962524,
-0.33967089653015137,
-0.102922223508358,
-0.09878720343112946,
-0.14048223197460175,
0.08378731459379196,
-0.474273145198822,
0.971379816532135,
0.9919736981391907,
-0.37100520730018616,
-0.45843151211738586,
-0.43149203062057495,
0.794796347618103,
0.42431482672691345,
-1.0826810598373413,
0.5202968716621399,
0.4092978537082672,
0.015322810970246792,
0.27966198325157166,
0.9535014033317566,
-0.2353658378124237,
0.0894085243344307,
-0.2230406105518341,
0.22895002365112305,
0.12390509992837906,
-0.5791893005371094,
-0.3567216992378235,
0.13459628820419312,
0.31799373030662537,
0.23156437277793884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18916v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18916v1 | TrustUQA: A Trustful Framework for Unified Structured Data Question Answering | 2024-06-27T06:13:05 | 2024-06-27T06:13:05 | Wen Zhang, Long Jin, Yushan Zhu, Jiaoyan Chen, Zhiwei Huang, Junjie Wang, Yin Hua, Lei Liang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language question answering (QA) over structured data sources such as
tables and knowledge graphs (KGs) have been widely investigated, for example
with Large Language Models (LLMs). The main solutions include question to
formal query parsing and retrieval-based answer generation. However, current
methods of the former often suffer from weak generalization, failing to dealing
with multiple sources simultaneously, while the later is limited in
trustfulness. In this paper, we propose UnifiedTQA, a trustful QA framework
that can simultaneously support multiple types of structured data in a unified
way. To this end, it adopts an LLM-friendly and unified knowledge
representation method called Condition Graph (CG), and uses an LLM and
demonstration-based two-level method for CG querying. For enhancement, it is
also equipped with dynamic demonstration retrieval. We have evaluated
UnifiedTQA with 5 benchmarks covering 3 types of structured data. It
outperforms 2 existing unified structured data QA methods and in comparison
with the baselines that are specific to a data type, it achieves
state-of-the-art on 2 of them. Further more, we demonstrates potential of our
method for more general QA tasks, QA over mixed structured data and QA across
structured data. | [
-0.01818292960524559,
-0.9264103174209595,
0.8846361637115479,
0.2917674779891968,
-0.3818610608577728,
0.4183613955974579,
0.2514761686325073,
-0.22692467272281647,
-0.013821997679769993,
0.32283973693847656,
-0.2709009349346161,
-0.8431651592254639,
-0.19611138105392456,
0.04381208494305611,
-0.3744807541370392,
0.6450843214988708,
-0.23242028057575226,
0.23394252359867096,
-0.48332417011260986,
-0.450691282749176,
-0.3665698170661926,
-0.7343707084655762,
-0.5809025168418884,
-0.4762193560600281,
0.14229565858840942,
0.25422343611717224,
1.0368281602859497,
0.41303500533103943,
0.19717463850975037,
0.25838083028793335,
0.12849070131778717,
0.3351505398750305,
-0.26147934794425964,
0.3447088301181793,
-0.11633558571338654,
-0.29462262988090515,
-0.3004228174686432,
-0.12102537602186203,
0.6267533302307129,
0.7002155184745789,
-0.36095911264419556,
0.15994013845920563,
0.10891258716583252,
0.5065338611602783,
-0.4221116304397583,
0.2618575096130371,
-0.6011561751365662,
-0.11402788758277893,
0.07577376067638397,
-0.10259942710399628,
-0.2786444127559662,
-0.6200928688049316,
-0.14042767882347107,
-0.969483494758606,
-0.3422580659389496,
0.12347400933504105,
0.8605225682258606,
0.4296955168247223,
-1.0277271270751953,
0.058349210768938065,
-0.46596744656562805,
0.4987355172634125,
-0.47829240560531616,
0.6504116654396057,
0.0892704576253891,
0.3584012985229492,
-0.5702188611030579,
-1.0960253477096558,
-0.6243037581443787,
-0.07676016539335251,
-0.22960993647575378,
0.27037882804870605,
-0.0769023448228836,
0.17013207077980042,
-0.003505941014736891,
0.2998993396759033,
-0.6886043548583984,
-0.1362745761871338,
0.16044797003269196,
-0.5455465912818909,
0.5661870241165161,
0.10134332627058029,
0.5053450465202332,
-0.42260831594467163,
-0.6829261779785156,
-0.11834125965833664,
-0.6680618524551392,
0.4423213303089142,
0.1020764634013176,
0.021147988736629486,
0.17965149879455566,
0.5926457047462463,
-0.799659788608551,
0.6328703761100769,
-0.10516200214624405,
-0.0030068818014115095,
-0.07862221449613571,
-0.42332011461257935,
-0.4436465799808502,
-0.29314181208610535,
0.9795457124710083,
0.2060934156179428,
0.1920589953660965,
-0.46729397773742676,
0.1741340011358261,
0.08056119829416275,
0.10802977532148361,
-0.6246505975723267,
-0.2693929076194763,
0.43130192160606384,
-0.04795316606760025,
-0.06985444575548172,
0.2556470036506653,
-0.6269304752349854,
-0.14819912612438202,
-0.2522484362125397,
0.49300745129585266,
-0.4247249662876129,
-0.09742721915245056,
0.0978211909532547,
0.12034925073385239,
0.2818277180194855,
0.19060097634792328,
-0.16175536811351776,
0.39473873376846313,
0.44547295570373535,
0.17151731252670288,
-0.1747535765171051,
0.10297571122646332,
-0.7536243796348572,
0.2708401381969452,
-0.29206275939941406,
0.5546641945838928,
-0.5219388604164124,
-0.2567771375179291,
-0.10328065603971481,
-0.17741326987743378,
-0.1608353555202484,
-0.17007982730865479,
0.9408296346664429,
-0.9607277512550354,
0.3748384714126587,
-0.3427664637565613,
-0.5387127995491028,
-0.2035846710205078,
0.4859846532344818,
-0.5821478962898254,
1.5043683052062988,
0.33578723669052124,
-0.8912642598152161,
0.341154009103775,
-0.5122269988059998,
-0.23513495922088623,
0.20338287949562073,
-0.451252281665802,
-0.18751037120819092,
-0.4578540325164795,
0.49293315410614014,
0.4925609827041626,
-0.14112582802772522,
0.7392377853393555,
-0.49866217374801636,
-0.32128292322158813,
0.32772135734558105,
-0.2108595222234726,
0.6556479930877686,
0.2994050979614258,
-0.1947156935930252,
0.13939259946346283,
-0.7813278436660767,
0.7227575182914734,
0.20654867589473724,
-0.5170653462409973,
-0.46544545888900757,
-0.17763356864452362,
-0.15537190437316895,
0.31643253564834595,
0.1802632212638855,
-0.7461482882499695,
0.16447439789772034,
-0.09767380356788635,
0.4181444048881531,
0.4273872375488281,
0.3373737335205078,
0.20922520756721497,
0.10040293633937836,
0.5238907337188721,
0.07931433618068695,
0.1678052395582199,
0.39604106545448303,
-0.479779452085495,
-0.4116295576095581,
-0.07410881668329239,
0.4136832356452942,
0.5242756605148315,
-1.1013271808624268,
0.1334901750087738,
-0.18238377571105957,
-0.0591004453599453,
-0.6008554100990295,
0.11033500730991364,
0.6872317790985107,
0.809643566608429,
0.6043558120727539,
-0.08535003662109375,
-0.36267533898353577,
-0.9447161555290222,
-0.2858339846134186,
-0.35268282890319824,
-0.4062363803386688,
0.2437879890203476,
0.1104266569018364,
-0.14533540606498718,
0.9855591058731079,
-0.462433397769928,
0.14720383286476135,
-0.022838668897747993,
0.04884671792387962,
0.03638119995594025,
0.27084872126579285,
0.21542803943157196,
-1.070949912071228,
-0.3677672743797302,
-0.2407529056072235,
-0.7323566675186157,
0.212855264544487,
0.059878963977098465,
-0.42648574709892273,
0.05048336833715439,
0.35281553864479065,
-0.6682555079460144,
0.3360480070114136,
0.67820805311203,
-0.6293318271636963,
0.20026634633541107,
0.11616890877485275,
0.45510488748550415,
-1.5513908863067627,
0.10487806051969528,
-0.2759653329849243,
-0.4654724597930908,
-0.3549893796443939,
0.48930299282073975,
0.10045547038316727,
-0.1340280920267105,
-0.17303535342216492,
0.5049781203269958,
-0.02684755064547062,
-0.00499538891017437,
0.43133798241615295,
0.3661706745624542,
0.45555517077445984,
0.4719740152359009,
-0.21861478686332703,
0.7394582629203796,
0.4975883960723877,
-0.5063608288764954,
0.3568311333656311,
0.6557621359825134,
0.13481350243091583,
0.7290711402893066,
-0.9331197738647461,
0.43469539284706116,
0.1022842600941658,
0.42540648579597473,
-1.104313850402832,
-0.3198408782482147,
0.22187399864196777,
-0.5195013880729675,
0.1816094070672989,
-0.1508311629295349,
-0.6198592185974121,
-0.544165849685669,
-0.15231211483478546,
0.32331374287605286,
0.20301461219787598,
-0.7250639796257019,
0.622678816318512,
0.16123762726783752,
0.024572176858782768,
-0.7034379839897156,
-0.42828115820884705,
-0.007316698785871267,
-0.07236035913228989,
-0.9385066628456116,
0.24261578917503357,
-0.2701307535171509,
-0.2226221263408661,
0.17078375816345215,
-0.646596372127533,
-0.6364546418190002,
0.353290855884552,
0.29530221223831177,
0.14646005630493164,
-0.21818986535072327,
0.12392151355743408,
0.31117692589759827,
0.05915962532162666,
0.08210495114326477,
-0.3508634567260742,
0.3283007740974426,
-0.2729131877422333,
-0.3747596740722656,
-0.5235688090324402,
0.3855277895927429,
0.32871460914611816,
-0.20482954382896423,
0.43815696239471436,
0.5694769620895386,
-0.2548854649066925,
-0.1639426052570343,
-0.23263238370418549,
0.053069550544023514,
-0.4776301085948944,
0.14105789363384247,
-0.529252827167511,
-1.2605395317077637,
0.448892742395401,
0.025668999180197716,
-0.07551702111959457,
0.3796181380748749,
0.23242667317390442,
-0.2901667654514313,
0.9734525680541992,
0.2979278862476349,
-0.1734192967414856,
-0.2967604696750641,
0.15135768055915833,
0.16180168092250824,
-0.47618454694747925,
-0.6257534623146057,
-0.7267090678215027,
0.11008055508136749,
-0.33566156029701233,
-0.2130660116672516,
0.5326134562492371,
0.5073914527893066,
-0.2732895314693451,
0.04978610575199127,
-0.4894649386405945,
0.34665611386299133,
0.6190247535705566,
0.09436074644327164,
0.806657612323761,
-0.31363925337791443,
-0.4469524919986725,
0.2165907919406891,
-0.5911442637443542,
-0.43527117371559143,
1.095954418182373,
0.09655006974935532,
0.7391225099563599,
0.08445210009813309,
0.6729146242141724,
0.1510797142982483,
0.2570212483406067,
-0.45140939950942993,
0.4062223732471466,
0.21975311636924744,
-0.5619832277297974,
-0.4973441958427429,
-0.785179853439331,
-0.8521518111228943,
0.23635470867156982,
-0.11570873111486435,
-0.6607158780097961,
-0.0799681693315506,
0.17961494624614716,
-0.37631142139434814,
0.11633285880088806,
-0.6184207797050476,
0.7524353265762329,
0.04431883245706558,
0.010883739218115807,
0.2751259207725525,
-0.7883801460266113,
0.5731338262557983,
0.1207771748304367,
-0.019897988066077232,
-0.012675994075834751,
0.21983866393566132,
0.8605244755744934,
-0.2562849819660187,
0.2115706354379654,
-0.1612948626279831,
-0.029472997412085533,
0.46905744075775146,
0.23222990334033966,
0.5296688079833984,
0.812296450138092,
-0.12081282585859299,
-0.14225910604000092,
0.6916203498840332,
-0.636320948600769,
-0.8759602308273315,
0.5896361470222473,
-0.6583450436592102,
-0.48327967524528503,
-0.2629416584968567,
-0.6895298361778259,
-1.0508232116699219,
0.3690096139907837,
0.014835081994533539,
0.5169802308082581,
-0.3322368264198303,
0.5272765755653381,
0.6710307002067566,
0.12911367416381836,
0.19899074733257294,
0.4318510890007019,
-0.03849148005247116,
-0.20673519372940063,
0.3422739505767822,
-0.385364830493927,
0.15571825206279755,
0.4740583002567291,
0.14510899782180786,
-0.756271481513977,
-0.5977950096130371,
-0.48305314779281616,
-0.08968427777290344,
-0.5211244225502014,
-0.6397619843482971,
-0.7068299651145935,
-0.1915678083896637,
-0.47223517298698425,
0.1917501837015152,
-0.2020965814590454,
-0.5359156727790833,
0.00893448106944561,
-0.36287036538124084,
0.413693368434906,
0.4526829123497009,
0.4483979344367981,
0.03593390807509422,
-0.9041779637336731,
0.8790284991264343,
0.8222976326942444,
0.6370863914489746,
-0.5696141123771667,
-0.12594595551490784,
0.25069713592529297,
0.21473504602909088,
-0.24839405715465546,
-0.869564950466156,
-0.08678765594959259,
0.10155195742845535,
0.6588976979255676,
0.1788610965013504,
0.540794312953949,
0.46387556195259094,
0.0005984383751638234,
0.7198651432991028,
-0.07029089331626892,
-0.9799180030822754,
0.12004509568214417,
-0.5387520790100098,
0.06912288814783096,
1.014002799987793,
0.5121225714683533,
-0.4897005259990692,
-0.5419933199882507,
-0.6518173217773438,
-0.5857048630714417,
0.21718059480190277,
0.42005056142807007,
-0.04213342443108559,
0.2149503529071808,
0.6816101670265198,
-0.1374470442533493,
0.28986304998397827,
-0.7067482471466064,
-0.34149160981178284,
-0.5199176073074341,
-0.3175371289253235,
0.38923075795173645,
-0.15375351905822754,
-0.41136470437049866,
-0.21316899359226227,
0.5043019652366638,
-0.6047653555870056,
0.09396512061357498,
0.451678991317749,
-0.005878969095647335,
-0.054050762206315994,
0.988771378993988,
-0.19013313949108124,
0.7519586086273193,
-0.3206092417240143,
0.036399759352207184,
-0.0509701631963253,
-0.26843371987342834,
0.143235445022583,
0.39221858978271484,
-0.3919084072113037,
-0.29007667303085327,
0.03386709839105606,
0.17589989304542542,
0.29791459441185,
-0.4012444019317627,
0.35085350275039673,
-0.286413311958313,
-0.3366580903530121,
0.06950841099023819,
-0.001121830428019166,
0.31781890988349915,
0.18023817241191864,
0.441853404045105,
-0.48124921321868896,
0.33579495549201965,
-0.5404424071311951,
0.622605562210083,
0.3444881737232208,
-0.45227786898612976,
-0.12308372557163239,
0.8259227871894836,
0.11300099641084671,
0.25369030237197876,
0.7712525129318237,
-0.36371174454689026,
-0.531731128692627,
0.4229219853878021,
0.4437808096408844,
0.40024319291114807,
-0.1836206465959549,
0.8148829340934753,
0.03728615492582321,
0.10610069334506989,
0.030937206000089645,
0.896484911441803,
0.05299686640501022,
-0.822858989238739,
-0.3226023316383362,
-0.7132291793823242,
-0.6831860542297363,
-0.01094811875373125,
-1.0313364267349243,
-0.6343626976013184,
-0.34951189160346985,
0.1448460817337036,
-0.3735063076019287,
0.34691324830055237,
-0.7295687794685364,
0.5705071091651917,
-0.24793367087841034,
0.884594202041626,
-0.5732993483543396,
1.0263988971710205,
0.7798224687576294,
-0.4482056796550751,
-1.605365514755249,
-0.137619748711586,
-0.17583881318569183,
-0.7207052707672119,
0.17717963457107544,
-0.27496102452278137,
-0.025416428223252296,
0.019831154495477676,
-0.7845903635025024,
-0.8548383116722107,
1.4275575876235962,
0.41782432794570923,
-0.14416088163852692,
-0.04929869621992111,
0.2489268183708191,
0.5812839269638062,
-0.16869550943374634,
-0.18853090703487396,
0.735113263130188,
0.7078127264976501,
0.30295220017433167,
-0.643588662147522,
0.5405081510543823,
-0.09130778908729553,
-0.23027107119560242,
0.06948096305131912,
-0.6527032256126404,
0.4479048252105713,
0.002791570033878088,
-0.3619169592857361,
0.25064894556999207,
0.8284792304039001,
0.47675326466560364,
0.4724541902542114,
0.3752824366092682,
0.7128562331199646,
1.0737857818603516,
-0.27819207310676575,
1.1818331480026245,
-0.0450998991727829,
0.354287326335907,
1.1863652467727661,
-0.19769187271595,
0.6191496849060059,
0.3215737044811249,
-0.24089807271957397,
0.6271794438362122,
0.6818416118621826,
0.3574887216091156,
0.15169009566307068,
0.11110254377126694,
0.12505735456943512,
-0.5915128588676453,
-0.2985931932926178,
-0.425607830286026,
0.4694826304912567,
-0.03601617366075516,
0.19424240291118622,
-0.40109825134277344,
-0.6566596031188965,
0.21171927452087402,
0.37954771518707275,
-0.20658466219902039,
0.5306286215782166,
0.15668828785419464,
-0.3765842020511627,
0.36297619342803955,
0.02812400832772255,
0.2587990164756775,
-0.7782798409461975,
-0.01978212594985962,
-0.4665909707546234,
-0.45490506291389465,
-0.19992490112781525,
-0.8122356534004211,
0.08481712639331818,
-0.33798423409461975,
0.18403159081935883,
-0.09817568212747574,
0.5316091179847717,
-0.4858652949333191,
-0.2501034438610077,
0.23147174715995789,
0.7546119689941406,
-0.30540403723716736,
-0.3867744505405426,
-0.701592206954956,
-0.34266623854637146,
-0.1862916499376297,
-0.314055472612381,
0.24069032073020935,
0.5941785573959351,
-0.21157541871070862,
0.7377864122390747,
0.6328534483909607,
-0.37861043214797974,
0.04931175336241722,
0.1335161328315735,
1.0536787509918213,
-0.46903347969055176,
-0.5717945098876953,
-0.11478327214717865,
0.4492441713809967,
-0.2336307317018509,
-0.24161961674690247,
0.8688685297966003,
0.4397425055503845,
0.5180773735046387,
0.4479147791862488,
0.4653851389884949,
0.033640772104263306,
0.45510920882225037,
-0.8140041828155518,
0.6698465943336487,
-0.5102275609970093,
-0.23035044968128204,
-0.44115445017814636,
-0.9261195063591003,
-0.4395059645175934,
-0.0701683759689331,
0.23540428280830383,
0.012233887799084187,
1.0054274797439575,
0.4442213177680969,
0.005079678259789944,
0.030493322759866714,
0.2588738203048706,
0.28559359908103943,
0.346266508102417,
0.6067192554473877,
0.6866108775138855,
-0.4530417025089264,
0.8190465569496155,
-0.15542124211788177,
0.15119151771068573,
0.4073113799095154,
-0.6032969951629639,
-0.631056547164917,
-0.5323434472084045,
-0.22871890664100647,
-0.5625736713409424,
-0.029794417321681976,
0.6055854558944702,
0.6922484636306763,
-0.9634425640106201,
0.4186062216758728,
0.19177018105983734,
0.5028708577156067,
0.019173361361026764,
-0.3035784959793091,
0.7613434791564941,
-0.014148756861686707,
-0.3910316228866577,
0.7053716778755188,
0.09158089011907578,
-0.12784521281719208,
-0.07910637557506561,
0.0027612056583166122,
-0.06510213017463684,
0.15965688228607178,
0.4584570527076721,
0.5007871985435486,
-0.4147644340991974,
-0.6935604810714722,
0.14271531999111176,
-0.19695445895195007,
0.09733518213033676,
0.8408361673355103,
-0.7922176122665405,
0.22103002667427063,
0.3206025958061218,
0.9818150401115417,
0.23724891245365143,
0.6254279017448425,
0.5460489988327026,
-0.9853466153144836,
-0.24020561575889587,
0.3169272840023041,
0.3661881685256958,
0.29922378063201904,
-0.6891469955444336,
0.5404804944992065,
0.056966669857501984,
-0.5054741501808167,
-0.46175727248191833,
0.35558608174324036,
-1.472809076309204,
-0.1108306497335434,
1.245529294013977,
-0.29462766647338867,
-0.023284371942281723,
-0.6606981158256531,
0.10707211494445801,
0.17236338555812836,
-0.7012292742729187,
0.731082558631897,
0.3288826644420624,
-0.2410489320755005,
0.2481314092874527,
-0.1484670341014862,
0.5157772302627563,
0.3329004943370819,
-1.3265280723571777,
-0.2491336613893509,
0.7314903736114502,
0.5621877312660217,
-0.12331634014844894,
0.77133709192276,
-0.45387759804725647,
0.1660933941602707,
-0.35321328043937683,
-0.19866320490837097,
-0.3269072473049164,
-0.4740283787250519,
-0.07479836791753769,
0.5896852016448975,
-0.0032504284754395485,
-0.08302337676286697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18910v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18910v1 | Factor-Conditioned Speaking-Style Captioning | 2024-06-27T05:52:10 | 2024-06-27T05:52:10 | Atsushi Ando, Takafumi Moriya, Shota Horiguchi, Ryo Masumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper presents a novel speaking-style captioning method that generates
diverse descriptions while accurately predicting speaking-style information.
Conventional learning criteria directly use original captions that contain not
only speaking-style factor terms but also syntax words, which disturbs learning
speaking-style information. To solve this problem, we introduce
factor-conditioned captioning (FCC), which first outputs a phrase representing
speaking-style factors (e.g., gender, pitch, etc.), and then generates a
caption to ensure the model explicitly learns speaking-style factors. We also
propose greedy-then-sampling (GtS) decoding, which first predicts
speaking-style factors deterministically to guarantee semantic accuracy, and
then generates a caption based on factor-conditioned sampling to ensure
diversity. Experiments show that FCC outperforms the original caption-based
training, and with GtS, it generates more diverse captions while keeping style
prediction performance. | [
-0.5885725617408752,
-0.6253392100334167,
0.044857386499643326,
0.7692569494247437,
-0.6508327722549438,
0.6180191040039062,
-0.39639368653297424,
-0.08154644072055817,
0.3995673954486847,
0.3868032991886139,
-0.9161684513092041,
-0.21721798181533813,
-0.5141637325286865,
0.3526571989059448,
-0.2500841021537781,
0.7852594256401062,
0.3791113495826721,
0.6342551708221436,
-0.23513883352279663,
0.03584415465593338,
-0.41495802998542786,
-0.48933646082878113,
-0.40830692648887634,
-0.35838422179222107,
0.10718006640672684,
0.6616548299789429,
0.4289643466472626,
0.48276814818382263,
0.2854330241680145,
0.29216641187667847,
0.2532154321670532,
0.49293965101242065,
-0.6105400919914246,
0.004079324658960104,
0.11218695342540741,
-0.4154188632965088,
-0.03838459402322769,
0.2040206491947174,
0.5187165141105652,
0.61632239818573,
-0.30065926909446716,
-0.23510541021823883,
-0.22243903577327728,
0.6517476439476013,
-0.1714162826538086,
0.4489497244358063,
-0.7646060585975647,
0.36581146717071533,
0.04194396734237671,
-0.9822050333023071,
-0.744872510433197,
-0.2524905800819397,
0.23103180527687073,
-0.6794565916061401,
0.6030959486961365,
0.4446280002593994,
0.8030853867530823,
0.12631238996982574,
-0.45213693380355835,
-0.14121858775615692,
-0.8747986555099487,
0.8597756028175354,
-0.37988579273223877,
0.4645751118659973,
0.48001158237457275,
0.6055108308792114,
0.10409560054540634,
-0.43367403745651245,
-0.6878650188446045,
-0.14420881867408752,
-0.28479817509651184,
0.1299988031387329,
-0.0016038411995396018,
-0.07892338931560516,
0.12170160561800003,
0.4173157215118408,
-0.3382555842399597,
-0.14494146406650543,
-0.6567224264144897,
-0.33328601717948914,
0.7518011927604675,
-0.13454106450080872,
0.15029412508010864,
-0.3442102074623108,
-0.5613614916801453,
-0.3729620575904846,
-0.6800793409347534,
-0.009152072481811047,
0.32875221967697144,
0.5961889624595642,
-0.24100373685359955,
0.2695816457271576,
-0.568503737449646,
0.4197562336921692,
0.3014166057109833,
-0.3956248462200165,
0.42361000180244446,
-0.31184378266334534,
-0.2178078591823578,
-0.032384444028139114,
0.5675637125968933,
0.5539705157279968,
0.44811397790908813,
-0.39407792687416077,
-0.13258053362369537,
-0.30350998044013977,
0.1589977741241455,
-0.6213730573654175,
-0.19455936551094055,
-0.061980899423360825,
-0.3497518002986908,
-0.6550000905990601,
0.37692755460739136,
-1.015272855758667,
-0.4468945264816284,
-0.4875248372554779,
0.18810316920280457,
-0.37713757157325745,
-0.18325433135032654,
-0.10938338190317154,
-0.2792082726955414,
0.38468801975250244,
0.16160531342029572,
-1.0968620777130127,
0.30738967657089233,
0.2345503866672516,
0.6242935657501221,
-0.130842387676239,
0.02190198190510273,
-0.9858649373054504,
-0.12606921792030334,
-0.33902066946029663,
0.5646041035652161,
-0.4819793403148651,
-0.3753719925880432,
0.23907001316547394,
-0.2361256331205368,
0.3009640872478485,
-0.24944262206554413,
0.300320029258728,
-0.5097656846046448,
0.0830141007900238,
-0.3860614597797394,
-0.3183613419532776,
-0.12334276735782623,
-0.2924961447715759,
-0.7305710911750793,
0.4543437063694,
0.14506322145462036,
-0.6016786098480225,
0.6620490550994873,
-0.18663908541202545,
-0.5753507018089294,
0.27826809883117676,
-0.28257060050964355,
-0.4847355782985687,
0.07318487763404846,
0.5425813794136047,
0.6456282734870911,
0.042886972427368164,
0.3084501624107361,
-0.14546677470207214,
-0.20588088035583496,
0.5030155181884766,
-0.16287703812122345,
0.5129508972167969,
0.4220929443836212,
-0.24015361070632935,
0.37992024421691895,
-0.6850999593734741,
-0.040333572775125504,
0.24764253199100494,
-0.08512374013662338,
0.12955382466316223,
0.12359791994094849,
0.0771203488111496,
0.15033018589019775,
-0.21870385110378265,
-0.5559769868850708,
-0.1459016352891922,
-0.18911942839622498,
0.5414942502975464,
0.6989680528640747,
-0.016068292781710625,
0.6432458162307739,
-0.455841064453125,
0.6727770566940308,
-0.2574344873428345,
-0.006975104566663504,
-0.21227891743183136,
-0.1862035095691681,
-0.8821629881858826,
-0.11721312254667282,
0.0980347990989685,
0.6153482794761658,
-1.3962947130203247,
0.3351644277572632,
-0.30326369404792786,
-0.5787395238876343,
-0.02601579949259758,
0.05813149735331535,
0.33248886466026306,
0.2408849000930786,
0.2860623598098755,
-0.044782981276512146,
-0.7322272062301636,
-0.8998814225196838,
0.09687983989715576,
0.012337872758507729,
0.0314178466796875,
0.3562053442001343,
0.13933970034122467,
0.35629093647003174,
0.720085084438324,
-0.5756873488426208,
-0.3350987434387207,
-0.6960178017616272,
0.32695117592811584,
-0.18033646047115326,
0.5506162643432617,
0.7471365332603455,
-0.9719088077545166,
-0.46474114060401917,
-0.2735077142715454,
-0.1851203888654709,
-0.11674892157316208,
-0.3958152234554291,
-0.0837550163269043,
0.18509118258953094,
0.8206072449684143,
-0.22760561108589172,
-0.1066160649061203,
0.5573844909667969,
-0.4076654613018036,
0.7246147990226746,
0.16913704574108124,
0.09164753556251526,
-0.6313295960426331,
-0.38501107692718506,
0.1312732994556427,
-0.27081069350242615,
-0.5373269319534302,
0.19106078147888184,
-0.11852020025253296,
-0.37755241990089417,
-0.34763309359550476,
0.38247963786125183,
-0.5908013582229614,
0.23869465291500092,
-0.18802617490291595,
0.002204513642936945,
0.025284383445978165,
0.9894917607307434,
0.23655560612678528,
0.6903073787689209,
0.7578060030937195,
-0.21000288426876068,
0.24283204972743988,
0.26677730679512024,
-0.5835400223731995,
0.38104796409606934,
-0.42278093099594116,
0.1630478948354721,
-0.4210072159767151,
0.3114043176174164,
-1.0837328433990479,
-0.2502099275588989,
0.01270768791437149,
-0.4382159113883972,
0.6979492902755737,
-0.006321622524410486,
-0.3872714936733246,
-0.4314503073692322,
-0.26728227734565735,
0.15628914535045624,
0.46621131896972656,
-0.5938858985900879,
0.7483041286468506,
0.11727668344974518,
-0.44118404388427734,
-0.7180178165435791,
-0.7065918445587158,
-0.17686808109283447,
-0.20184212923049927,
-0.4816737174987793,
0.5185038447380066,
-0.19333608448505402,
0.08433868736028671,
-0.3277950882911682,
-0.33867979049682617,
-0.11800975352525711,
-0.05376821756362915,
-0.02695055492222309,
0.24949218332767487,
0.06412048637866974,
0.09544149041175842,
0.022239021956920624,
0.24951638281345367,
-0.021847175434231758,
-0.2895236909389496,
0.8001576662063599,
-0.2443796843290329,
0.05317261815071106,
-0.16482843458652496,
0.6609593033790588,
0.23016653954982758,
-0.6089629530906677,
0.36647722125053406,
0.8844398856163025,
-0.09327027946710587,
-0.7170653343200684,
-0.46790632605552673,
-0.533638060092926,
-0.5129503011703491,
0.49625739455223083,
-0.14244243502616882,
-1.0586779117584229,
0.3871406614780426,
0.47877776622772217,
-0.10761946439743042,
0.13947410881519318,
0.2700709402561188,
-0.19375891983509064,
0.8413085341453552,
0.8265930414199829,
0.08106211572885513,
0.8965610861778259,
-0.2555150091648102,
0.2450678050518036,
-0.12422090023756027,
-0.2715159058570862,
-0.38690125942230225,
-0.2450771927833557,
-0.6705461740493774,
-0.5182684063911438,
0.07745978981256485,
0.052499786019325256,
-0.09769201278686523,
0.039397988468408585,
-0.2959090769290924,
0.42569810152053833,
0.7882152199745178,
0.16830237209796906,
0.07989129424095154,
0.5351138114929199,
-0.1491810828447342,
-0.06574907153844833,
-0.5215837955474854,
-0.05156182125210762,
1.1402018070220947,
0.2160041779279709,
0.7260764241218567,
0.1415969431400299,
0.8007892966270447,
0.471783310174942,
0.3528884947299957,
-0.8480658531188965,
0.47593092918395996,
-0.40167784690856934,
-0.42111653089523315,
-0.42865189909935,
-0.6236767768859863,
-0.49066445231437683,
0.15638546645641327,
-0.5272316932678223,
-0.609950840473175,
0.21533425152301788,
0.24579337239265442,
-0.32414382696151733,
0.08907251805067062,
-0.4218998849391937,
0.3696536123752594,
-0.12483786791563034,
0.10213041305541992,
-0.23327942192554474,
-0.7118622660636902,
0.36667630076408386,
0.20289494097232819,
0.24525772035121918,
-0.09735802561044693,
0.4142555892467499,
0.7346982359886169,
-0.24495956301689148,
0.8357241153717041,
-0.24803656339645386,
0.2812000811100006,
0.405874639749527,
0.060546327382326126,
0.23422901332378387,
-0.012000223621726036,
0.22177362442016602,
-0.08037479966878891,
-0.26746201515197754,
-0.4134693443775177,
-0.7532216310501099,
0.2609817683696747,
-0.6815718412399292,
-0.6426379680633545,
-0.38996392488479614,
-0.5235011577606201,
-0.5469049215316772,
0.2282245010137558,
0.34165823459625244,
0.8268411755561829,
-0.19544871151447296,
0.4045636057853699,
0.6356658935546875,
-0.1744278371334076,
0.4734705090522766,
0.4666116237640381,
-0.1905822455883026,
-0.842184841632843,
1.234473466873169,
-0.03676175698637962,
0.5953049659729004,
0.6883930563926697,
0.2790105640888214,
-0.24826602637767792,
-0.7071856260299683,
-0.4484293758869171,
0.34048548340797424,
-0.706061840057373,
-0.20037008821964264,
-0.27783724665641785,
-0.055258095264434814,
-0.30902478098869324,
-0.23494461178779602,
-0.010299711488187313,
-0.5622930526733398,
-0.03959566727280617,
-0.5693859457969666,
0.3233330249786377,
0.23875485360622406,
-0.001881890231743455,
0.5590642690658569,
-0.5306686758995056,
0.30219942331314087,
0.5960627198219299,
0.3468901813030243,
-0.11893898248672485,
-0.31793177127838135,
0.06591087579727173,
-0.28554219007492065,
-0.1890503317117691,
-0.9019528031349182,
0.6495377421379089,
0.5771164894104004,
0.7475960850715637,
0.5691204071044922,
0.17168563604354858,
0.09417912364006042,
-0.4374314546585083,
0.6696645021438599,
0.40356171131134033,
-0.7765846848487854,
0.3287079632282257,
-0.4226101040840149,
0.20802336931228638,
0.576356828212738,
0.2119651734828949,
-0.47488120198249817,
-0.5128175020217896,
-0.4893854558467865,
-0.776448667049408,
0.7150722146034241,
0.2288626730442047,
0.4439277946949005,
-0.15026621520519257,
-0.02250436507165432,
0.15876956284046173,
0.4504085183143616,
-0.833021879196167,
-0.44572147727012634,
-0.8474587202072144,
0.09633725881576538,
-0.2117074728012085,
-0.28562742471694946,
-0.3139708638191223,
-0.2908862233161926,
0.8622871041297913,
-0.45283523201942444,
0.5862880349159241,
0.08775420486927032,
-0.059821560978889465,
-0.15158773958683014,
0.5091307163238525,
0.8843411803245544,
0.49507030844688416,
-0.36931732296943665,
0.08172698318958282,
-0.27265143394470215,
-0.18645015358924866,
-0.08247008174657822,
0.3155851364135742,
-0.2787458896636963,
0.11807861179113388,
0.2582595944404602,
0.9730176329612732,
-0.012325973249971867,
-0.5803021788597107,
0.4949089586734772,
-0.10535917431116104,
-0.15551690757274628,
-0.2816873788833618,
0.04303021356463432,
0.09842632710933685,
-0.15513257682323456,
0.6829203367233276,
0.20991037786006927,
0.016706418246030807,
-0.641394853591919,
0.4170834720134735,
0.3400358259677887,
-0.3675697445869446,
0.12419766932725906,
0.6401107907295227,
0.723931074142456,
-0.024659426882863045,
0.4413504898548126,
-0.7253279685974121,
-0.6128749847412109,
0.6886891722679138,
0.6291400194168091,
0.8661665916442871,
-0.05975795537233353,
0.5717730522155762,
0.5040194988250732,
0.1191895380616188,
0.15035301446914673,
0.6741088032722473,
-0.39192643761634827,
-0.8643099069595337,
-0.41596218943595886,
-0.8501845002174377,
-0.28129878640174866,
-0.04084724932909012,
-0.8106765151023865,
0.22966058552265167,
-0.7786964774131775,
-0.043442338705062866,
0.010254318825900555,
-0.07908882200717926,
-0.7287014126777649,
0.3531568646430969,
0.4263720214366913,
1.0503792762756348,
-1.0368731021881104,
0.6423389911651611,
0.362206369638443,
-0.5300000905990601,
-0.9843016862869263,
-0.17620207369327545,
0.2609812319278717,
-0.7858464121818542,
0.5659970045089722,
0.26096704602241516,
-0.26096969842910767,
-0.007056216709315777,
-0.8226398825645447,
-0.9525922536849976,
0.9685006737709045,
0.06789886206388474,
-0.549484372138977,
0.12671563029289246,
0.07518522441387177,
0.19450610876083374,
-0.5694953203201294,
-0.33346372842788696,
0.5306580066680908,
0.3277888298034668,
0.2973083257675171,
-0.5933618545532227,
0.07742252200841904,
-0.5519838333129883,
-0.12006950378417969,
-0.2084646075963974,
-0.6024889349937439,
0.7072052955627441,
-0.2901289463043213,
-0.4056454300880432,
0.2589303255081177,
1.1140042543411255,
0.1776951551437378,
-0.002956334501504898,
0.7475823163986206,
0.06917978078126907,
0.7682165503501892,
-0.4724980890750885,
1.114251732826233,
-0.09906091541051865,
0.16794300079345703,
1.114345669746399,
0.23426884412765503,
0.5425570607185364,
0.3221825957298279,
-0.18530340492725372,
0.6005480885505676,
0.3757587671279907,
-0.4168645739555359,
0.8744658827781677,
0.2760399281978607,
-0.11388286203145981,
-0.42997586727142334,
-0.15742258727550507,
-0.07638713717460632,
0.6460269689559937,
0.1498918980360031,
-0.502363920211792,
0.07227540016174316,
0.12048108130693436,
-0.04255509749054909,
0.3616958260536194,
-0.23549926280975342,
0.5068669319152832,
0.03192269802093506,
-0.7300224304199219,
0.5696607828140259,
0.03270110487937927,
0.8967257738113403,
-0.736230194568634,
0.0023257506545633078,
-0.2726222276687622,
-0.44836050271987915,
-0.1925046592950821,
-0.48688241839408875,
-0.051580365747213364,
-0.3656030297279358,
-0.37330004572868347,
-0.3733087182044983,
0.365582138299942,
-0.7846306562423706,
-0.6548739075660706,
-0.121073879301548,
0.37518545985221863,
-0.14857809245586395,
0.176322340965271,
-0.15165922045707703,
-0.20138031244277954,
0.18326367437839508,
0.06115938350558281,
0.025208257138729095,
0.22341640293598175,
0.00390798831358552,
0.7271732091903687,
0.49442240595817566,
0.03636148199439049,
0.10907655209302902,
0.7065162658691406,
0.6247643232345581,
-0.4319874346256256,
-0.9296802878379822,
-0.41730833053588867,
0.3853631317615509,
-0.21984368562698364,
-0.13776467740535736,
0.4594022333621979,
0.14319650828838348,
0.8208330273628235,
-0.5496066808700562,
0.7554607391357422,
-0.05216469243168831,
0.18880082666873932,
-0.6639565229415894,
0.6636704802513123,
-0.33389046788215637,
-0.10938813537359238,
-0.3313712775707245,
-0.6891278624534607,
-0.15186215937137604,
0.41845300793647766,
0.0036757958587259054,
0.24768617749214172,
0.6648566126823425,
0.8047910332679749,
0.1930086463689804,
0.23480324447155,
0.1260344684123993,
-0.13834552466869354,
0.29619669914245605,
0.18974991142749786,
0.6386371850967407,
0.09167398512363434,
0.7706868052482605,
-0.7402768731117249,
-0.22090019285678864,
-0.3116925358772278,
-1.0340027809143066,
-0.7660811543464661,
-0.703923225402832,
-0.4270874857902527,
-0.1712149679660797,
-0.2624845504760742,
0.9227124452590942,
1.1222541332244873,
-0.909622311592102,
-0.08939182758331299,
0.1776408851146698,
0.046350572258234024,
-0.7873292565345764,
-0.26945555210113525,
0.2491047978401184,
-0.39218488335609436,
-0.752716064453125,
0.48272261023521423,
-0.14101096987724304,
0.05906087905168533,
-0.2936098277568817,
-0.10999533534049988,
0.1819152981042862,
0.2212129682302475,
0.7461168169975281,
0.19002898037433624,
-0.7096818685531616,
-0.38588041067123413,
-0.09561430662870407,
0.04849803447723389,
0.036484744399785995,
1.0808207988739014,
-0.5083080530166626,
0.5969052910804749,
0.5229213237762451,
0.3708101212978363,
0.4696616232395172,
0.17717278003692627,
0.8017992973327637,
-1.2565410137176514,
0.03964528813958168,
0.1809011995792389,
0.5555421113967896,
0.6763445734977722,
-0.312113881111145,
0.3738490641117096,
0.3484300673007965,
-0.07399900257587433,
-0.5332143902778625,
0.4250292479991913,
-1.6289399862289429,
-0.21919019520282745,
1.247604489326477,
0.03536006808280945,
0.07073335349559784,
0.18974275887012482,
-0.29552793502807617,
0.17696049809455872,
-0.6278021335601807,
0.7882354855537415,
0.6080077290534973,
-0.004281509667634964,
-0.2756434381008148,
-0.26706913113594055,
0.8040423393249512,
0.3749012351036072,
-0.476492315530777,
0.1492743045091629,
0.6214557886123657,
0.3919219672679901,
0.2255362868309021,
0.4072987139225006,
-0.06159086525440216,
0.5081029534339905,
0.07575268298387527,
0.002834128448739648,
-0.5953317880630493,
-0.4546557068824768,
-0.015816401690244675,
0.29094836115837097,
-0.04402034729719162,
-0.10275037586688995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18907v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18907v1 | Historia Magistra Vitae: Dynamic Topic Modeling of Roman Literature using Neural Embeddings | 2024-06-27T05:38:49 | 2024-06-27T05:38:49 | Michael Ginn, Mans Hulden | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dynamic topic models have been proposed as a tool for historical analysis,
but traditional approaches have had limited usefulness, being difficult to
configure, interpret, and evaluate. In this work, we experiment with a recent
approach for dynamic topic modeling using BERT embeddings. We compare topic
models built using traditional statistical models (LDA and NMF) and the
BERT-based model, modeling topics over the entire surviving corpus of Roman
literature. We find that while quantitative metrics prefer statistical models,
qualitative evaluation finds better insights from the neural model.
Furthermore, the neural topic model is less sensitive to hyperparameter
configuration and thus may make dynamic topic modeling more viable for
historical researchers. | [
-0.3694884181022644,
-1.016695261001587,
0.8230855464935303,
0.045536741614341736,
-0.30076122283935547,
0.08563525229692459,
-0.24726241827011108,
-0.11234676837921143,
0.7641649842262268,
0.2760119140148163,
-0.3661644458770752,
-0.3153369426727295,
-0.3550821542739868,
-0.22419169545173645,
-0.5849956274032593,
0.9385473728179932,
-0.01897929050028324,
0.4629870653152466,
-0.2677362561225891,
-0.15830554068088531,
-0.3460700511932373,
-0.5006703734397888,
-0.2585575580596924,
-0.1588381677865982,
0.8912633061408997,
-0.26667889952659607,
0.7924879789352417,
0.6696547269821167,
0.4651888608932495,
0.32922112941741943,
-0.4502021372318268,
0.09681741148233414,
-0.45687583088874817,
0.704058825969696,
-0.263703316450119,
-0.5257763862609863,
-0.2857060730457306,
0.022304318845272064,
0.9890086054801941,
0.6942736506462097,
0.027844572439789772,
0.13310134410858154,
-0.2435714155435562,
0.3828025758266449,
-0.4068063795566559,
-0.09254931658506393,
-0.534461498260498,
0.33542531728744507,
-0.09095042943954468,
-0.600226104259491,
-0.3641195595264435,
-0.8174602389335632,
0.6129218935966492,
-0.5122919678688049,
0.41804400086402893,
-0.2648508548736572,
0.8400148749351501,
0.1063547134399414,
-0.3123224973678589,
-0.35133254528045654,
-1.0948512554168701,
0.5791823267936707,
-0.4910068213939667,
0.22716687619686127,
0.003954581916332245,
0.07260318100452423,
-0.07835058122873306,
-0.8257392644882202,
-0.39917096495628357,
-0.44400039315223694,
0.24975411593914032,
-0.0050199562683701515,
-0.2451014518737793,
-0.3764653503894806,
0.11587753146886826,
0.29822394251823425,
-0.7154208421707153,
0.03805902972817421,
-0.08513674885034561,
0.07425744831562042,
0.15138550102710724,
0.44347479939460754,
0.4664739966392517,
-0.1434766948223114,
-0.3785129487514496,
-0.08978648483753204,
-0.8607182502746582,
-0.35056406259536743,
0.6415068507194519,
0.14450311660766602,
0.22348900139331818,
0.430761456489563,
0.2986465096473694,
0.3878021240234375,
-0.1728726327419281,
-0.18685895204544067,
-0.15319591760635376,
-0.09452509880065918,
0.05844451114535332,
-0.08397295325994492,
0.3180217146873474,
0.13632585108280182,
0.09528380632400513,
-0.4764522910118103,
0.005490661598742008,
-0.1546221375465393,
0.5084913969039917,
-0.8262736797332764,
-0.33350199460983276,
-0.044265713542699814,
-0.5870479941368103,
-0.1894078403711319,
0.003375749569386244,
-0.982451856136322,
-0.5904799699783325,
-0.3078145980834961,
0.2900656461715698,
-0.6279526948928833,
-0.08899862319231033,
-0.29576486349105835,
-0.2751643657684326,
0.041373077780008316,
0.7228263020515442,
-0.8272510170936584,
0.097537100315094,
0.7135332822799683,
1.068328619003296,
-0.291054904460907,
-0.12133916467428207,
-0.07676509767770767,
0.06851942837238312,
-0.4249899983406067,
0.8652467131614685,
-0.4349348843097687,
-0.4443337619304657,
0.31069323420524597,
0.002863185713067651,
-0.07670247554779053,
-0.25074291229248047,
0.4986313581466675,
-0.7629616260528564,
0.13154451549053192,
-0.6292876601219177,
-0.7839210629463196,
-0.28052613139152527,
0.34494975209236145,
-0.971978485584259,
0.8224383592605591,
-0.07203090190887451,
-0.8672258257865906,
0.4733406901359558,
-0.45834243297576904,
-0.027559956535696983,
-0.10752761363983154,
-0.3391524851322174,
-0.2913559079170227,
0.06084570288658142,
-0.05615349858999252,
0.2470848709344864,
-0.4170466363430023,
0.7019497752189636,
-0.6009230613708496,
-0.4493846595287323,
0.5149317979812622,
-0.873770534992218,
0.6067862510681152,
0.24212121963500977,
-0.41775619983673096,
0.0960921049118042,
-0.5503125786781311,
-0.522200882434845,
0.17948444187641144,
-0.202477365732193,
-0.46147000789642334,
0.48106199502944946,
0.13056232035160065,
-0.22004002332687378,
0.35341331362724304,
-0.24095949530601501,
0.6692068576812744,
-0.4011240005493164,
0.2773679792881012,
0.597282350063324,
0.09048155695199966,
0.6392841339111328,
-0.3718024790287018,
0.45739662647247314,
-0.34693726897239685,
-0.25347134470939636,
-0.17030207812786102,
-0.6245495676994324,
-0.6399378180503845,
-0.2089967131614685,
0.9308767318725586,
0.6493474841117859,
-0.6542537212371826,
0.2059020698070526,
-0.2666688859462738,
-0.7884686589241028,
-0.11437902599573135,
-0.19877924025058746,
0.007005184423178434,
0.11846095323562622,
0.021190879866480827,
-0.19683213531970978,
-0.26041528582572937,
-0.7063254117965698,
0.1819923371076584,
-0.5012654662132263,
-0.005799887701869011,
0.1459897756576538,
0.5199636816978455,
0.2686500549316406,
0.8997097015380859,
-0.5962641835212708,
0.1812276691198349,
-0.16196736693382263,
0.4625164568424225,
0.22297096252441406,
0.508440375328064,
1.1461161375045776,
-0.7732624411582947,
-0.15656237304210663,
-0.27690228819847107,
-0.6984109878540039,
0.15305139124393463,
-0.3292108476161957,
-0.24769175052642822,
-0.035592399537563324,
0.15237849950790405,
-0.4686562418937683,
0.6179651021957397,
-0.0440099723637104,
-0.3920143246650696,
0.49408671259880066,
-0.6302809715270996,
0.21889455616474152,
-1.1779817342758179,
0.04225446656346321,
0.05309154465794563,
-0.07853448390960693,
-0.5529860854148865,
0.11071168631315231,
0.1811724305152893,
-0.3590332865715027,
-0.47363826632499695,
0.47583162784576416,
-0.40702950954437256,
-0.03624139726161957,
-0.4133383631706238,
0.03927268832921982,
-0.0030016647651791573,
0.25614163279533386,
0.14076824486255646,
0.7496690154075623,
0.3760251998901367,
-0.4083709716796875,
0.5637112259864807,
0.08794160187244415,
-0.3065112233161926,
0.1277703046798706,
-0.5784819722175598,
-0.13316243886947632,
-0.023027582094073296,
0.23502203822135925,
-1.0698316097259521,
0.21924059092998505,
0.016965171322226524,
-0.295555055141449,
0.672443687915802,
-0.2580047845840454,
-0.7304857969284058,
-0.11838903278112411,
-0.4783895015716553,
0.13274329900741577,
0.37111973762512207,
-0.37252581119537354,
0.4873521029949188,
0.2646787166595459,
-0.4960627257823944,
-0.4750972390174866,
-0.38300493359565735,
0.11470577120780945,
-0.5790238380432129,
-0.7130331993103027,
0.6820661425590515,
-0.1329205334186554,
-0.3827850818634033,
-0.06243085116147995,
0.17266136407852173,
-0.2200559377670288,
0.2626623213291168,
0.07780792564153671,
0.4109111428260803,
-0.6637146472930908,
0.5271241664886475,
0.11637105792760849,
0.12347700446844101,
-0.09915722906589508,
0.1204737052321434,
0.849227249622345,
0.07212576270103455,
-0.2321399450302124,
-0.4661140441894531,
0.46536561846733093,
0.7022247910499573,
-0.24860475957393646,
0.9792420268058777,
0.4872972071170807,
-0.45827993750572205,
0.10285617411136627,
-0.5239852070808411,
-0.35315510630607605,
-0.39348259568214417,
0.27699577808380127,
0.06334786862134933,
-0.5392575860023499,
0.8218650221824646,
-0.1529363989830017,
-0.04744429513812065,
0.5169811248779297,
0.9936090111732483,
-0.22509443759918213,
0.5136260390281677,
0.6102234125137329,
-0.03978937491774559,
0.8052496910095215,
-0.44433754682540894,
-0.07125459611415863,
-0.4636881351470947,
-0.19094841182231903,
-0.6581531167030334,
-0.43511149287223816,
-0.7896828651428223,
-0.33175456523895264,
0.29497483372688293,
-0.24679261445999146,
-0.16018061339855194,
0.10146784037351608,
-0.14952614903450012,
0.0498960055410862,
0.560645580291748,
0.07790274918079376,
-0.005449840798974037,
-0.0033648971002548933,
-0.13112634420394897,
-0.18829569220542908,
-0.5730057954788208,
-0.9518216252326965,
0.9059926867485046,
0.45774444937705994,
0.9421185255050659,
0.33563271164894104,
0.4058942496776581,
0.4032050669193268,
0.30639883875846863,
-0.535430371761322,
0.4070003032684326,
-0.21159197390079498,
-0.9594570994377136,
-0.3294107913970947,
-0.04431261122226715,
-0.9467346668243408,
0.414608895778656,
-0.5626385807991028,
-0.9411335587501526,
0.8268685340881348,
-0.08611616492271423,
-0.802227795124054,
0.7127388119697571,
-0.4672183394432068,
0.7562971115112305,
-0.024345148354768753,
-0.5876176357269287,
0.07488656044006348,
-0.33538392186164856,
-0.03617873787879944,
-0.012996782548725605,
-0.3357989490032196,
-0.18719565868377686,
-0.10816515237092972,
0.8075726628303528,
-0.25926321744918823,
0.8221539258956909,
0.00010915118764387444,
-0.034655168652534485,
0.18647921085357666,
0.2209378480911255,
0.25455087423324585,
0.5963072776794434,
-0.3484364151954651,
-0.3849666118621826,
0.12372875213623047,
-0.3128938674926758,
-0.8515571355819702,
0.8731095790863037,
-0.8139998912811279,
-0.8024335503578186,
-0.7637027502059937,
-0.6526420712471008,
0.055521901696920395,
-0.23295597732067108,
-0.06079079210758209,
0.7656270265579224,
-0.7157917618751526,
0.40700671076774597,
0.8642033934593201,
-0.5046043992042542,
0.788827657699585,
0.574233889579773,
-0.15520000457763672,
-0.25332996249198914,
0.6393095850944519,
0.4052739441394806,
-0.20546990633010864,
0.4647877514362335,
0.043901097029447556,
-0.030867287889122963,
-0.7074821591377258,
-0.6701250672340393,
0.24614353477954865,
-0.4928033947944641,
0.0944710448384285,
-0.6425183415412903,
-0.04963051155209541,
-0.30575478076934814,
-0.134919211268425,
-0.5354258418083191,
-0.4224310517311096,
-0.8362424969673157,
-0.05498307943344116,
0.47659868001937866,
0.5390702486038208,
0.059359122067689896,
0.3966297209262848,
-0.5765628218650818,
0.018164051696658134,
0.10171367228031158,
-0.060401227325201035,
0.07825946807861328,
-0.3579046428203583,
-0.10807852447032928,
-0.18861694633960724,
-0.6080601811408997,
-1.4944911003112793,
0.9315063953399658,
-0.0855780765414238,
0.6174840331077576,
0.6964336633682251,
0.1737557351589203,
0.4068925082683563,
-0.8085155487060547,
0.8191117644309998,
-0.15978413820266724,
-0.6602663397789001,
0.570331335067749,
-0.472491979598999,
-0.03685341402888298,
0.4417061507701874,
0.7066115140914917,
0.004046390298753977,
-0.29110008478164673,
-0.5679352283477783,
-0.8457928895950317,
0.2185036987066269,
0.25099173188209534,
0.45491304993629456,
-0.19876953959465027,
0.4962371587753296,
0.30124250054359436,
0.04037804529070854,
-0.47385480999946594,
-0.27684158086776733,
0.08922502398490906,
0.2238849401473999,
-0.03446252644062042,
-0.3799034655094147,
0.021028753370046616,
-0.5887277722358704,
0.3634796738624573,
0.28036370873451233,
0.6725653409957886,
0.1303403228521347,
-0.2799273133277893,
0.04222749546170235,
0.12295562773942947,
0.9223291873931885,
1.21378755569458,
-0.665170431137085,
0.126021608710289,
0.25584638118743896,
-0.42540448904037476,
0.03815893456339836,
0.39484724402427673,
-0.3564470708370209,
0.5865567326545715,
0.33720773458480835,
0.9592500925064087,
0.30794650316238403,
-0.2849962115287781,
0.36057668924331665,
-0.09825193881988525,
0.0011443457333371043,
-0.7826669216156006,
0.013151810504496098,
0.3459608852863312,
0.6565256118774414,
0.5056895613670349,
-0.31898993253707886,
0.12151788920164108,
-0.9324869513511658,
0.11762336641550064,
0.20166616141796112,
-0.39525240659713745,
-0.2169927954673767,
0.6387717127799988,
0.047906018793582916,
-0.24009022116661072,
0.5462695956230164,
0.10473517328500748,
-0.5416937470436096,
0.9154781103134155,
0.5583624839782715,
0.442158579826355,
-0.2699091136455536,
0.526000440120697,
0.16003020107746124,
0.10264728963375092,
0.10887442529201508,
0.22189871966838837,
0.2234066128730774,
-0.3934577405452728,
-0.2857062518596649,
-0.5537451505661011,
-0.5543023347854614,
-0.01573510654270649,
-0.6414308547973633,
0.13101071119308472,
-0.15028250217437744,
-0.42279312014579773,
0.42845940589904785,
0.15209971368312836,
-0.3066330850124359,
0.17187154293060303,
-0.04589538648724556,
0.8544883131980896,
-0.8217827081680298,
1.213316798210144,
0.660875141620636,
-0.6199835538864136,
-0.05628645792603493,
0.05795597285032272,
-0.21447643637657166,
-0.2484559416770935,
0.7253769636154175,
-0.391332745552063,
0.3575512170791626,
-0.3190963566303253,
-0.21834272146224976,
-0.8806625008583069,
1.3341350555419922,
0.5325437188148499,
-0.3686276078224182,
-0.3087907135486603,
-0.3109155297279358,
0.7272439002990723,
-0.28153738379478455,
0.36058473587036133,
0.09576323628425598,
0.38928794860839844,
0.2183608114719391,
-0.4496394395828247,
-0.26635271310806274,
-0.1842462718486786,
-0.02345290221273899,
0.3441992402076721,
-0.36814674735069275,
1.0451773405075073,
0.15908007323741913,
0.019555354490876198,
0.6975947022438049,
1.0004929304122925,
0.017149239778518677,
0.5961520075798035,
0.20616236329078674,
0.4738486111164093,
0.7904812693595886,
-0.4140734374523163,
1.2730822563171387,
-0.3341433107852936,
0.4263404905796051,
0.7830647826194763,
-0.33769339323043823,
0.854152262210846,
0.3177178204059601,
-0.24844315648078918,
0.5473039150238037,
1.0187225341796875,
-0.25237029790878296,
0.6043126583099365,
0.450825572013855,
-0.4357437789440155,
-0.015410915948450565,
0.1472538560628891,
-0.7786756753921509,
0.2599243223667145,
0.28572455048561096,
-0.7647313475608826,
-0.31387922167778015,
0.20108474791049957,
0.2713881731033325,
-0.11394346505403519,
-0.06889311224222183,
0.6092907190322876,
-0.19546371698379517,
-0.4211025536060333,
0.12434028089046478,
0.021042408421635628,
0.42376813292503357,
-0.4883714020252228,
-0.002672612899914384,
-0.4829621911048889,
-0.019829770550131798,
0.534688413143158,
-0.4638618528842926,
0.2968834340572357,
0.19120118021965027,
-0.47708770632743835,
-0.17892907559871674,
0.7394181489944458,
-0.2116348147392273,
-0.5289788246154785,
-0.029927046969532967,
0.7228949069976807,
0.21459783613681793,
0.08953564614057541,
-0.46841925382614136,
-0.005143972113728523,
-0.3304445445537567,
-0.39494678378105164,
0.409458726644516,
0.5746299624443054,
-0.0987100899219513,
0.4766516387462616,
0.3994901776313782,
0.00213946052826941,
-0.01964184083044529,
0.04235926270484924,
1.0031696557998657,
-0.9627670645713806,
-0.43879449367523193,
-1.037213683128357,
0.16544607281684875,
-0.10390028357505798,
-0.42932751774787903,
0.6373841762542725,
0.6152163147926331,
0.03920786455273628,
-0.12930014729499817,
0.15454474091529846,
0.2952239215373993,
0.3837851881980896,
-0.4326187074184418,
1.2325966358184814,
-0.7180609703063965,
0.2176162153482437,
-0.4012196958065033,
-1.1214470863342285,
-0.30985233187675476,
0.6428706645965576,
-0.4225756824016571,
-0.08228381723165512,
0.7666226029396057,
0.49574676156044006,
0.07228490710258484,
0.2888409197330475,
0.26790180802345276,
-0.043837226927280426,
0.1393769532442093,
0.022516610100865364,
1.1169244050979614,
0.29295387864112854,
0.08907132595777512,
-0.16475051641464233,
-0.08281136304140091,
-0.48652389645576477,
-0.9698941111564636,
-0.8173152804374695,
-0.7061826586723328,
-0.22013336420059204,
-0.22844047844409943,
0.4522416293621063,
0.7876124382019043,
0.35156890749931335,
-0.7066214084625244,
-0.07731789350509644,
0.4500057101249695,
0.26466089487075806,
0.17655779421329498,
-0.15464100241661072,
0.8305056691169739,
-0.07054180651903152,
-0.9321311712265015,
0.39230555295944214,
0.23183174431324005,
0.12598156929016113,
-0.6262864470481873,
0.3201322853565216,
-0.6180343627929688,
0.36414965987205505,
0.3254154920578003,
0.21187980473041534,
-0.5796740651130676,
-0.2073216438293457,
0.07080714404582977,
-0.18866929411888123,
0.15089057385921478,
1.1091257333755493,
-0.6663357615470886,
0.3670995533466339,
0.7987534403800964,
0.6875988245010376,
0.782183825969696,
-0.2620534300804138,
0.7943726778030396,
-0.17339585721492767,
0.24462765455245972,
0.41423147916793823,
0.8385325074195862,
0.04333047941327095,
-0.09711085259914398,
0.3593844771385193,
0.4477360248565674,
-0.40283340215682983,
-1.0090619325637817,
-0.17386461794376373,
-1.1562551259994507,
-0.7048564553260803,
0.9852819442749023,
-0.4052210748195648,
-0.37879541516304016,
0.027820639312267303,
-0.22346828877925873,
0.6207910776138306,
-0.2164301723241806,
0.7295677065849304,
0.8360282778739929,
0.13484659790992737,
0.11949823051691055,
-0.8646231889724731,
-0.07173938304185867,
0.35469716787338257,
-0.5313383936882019,
-0.5098153352737427,
0.4746047556400299,
0.1864563226699829,
0.3387259840965271,
0.0802251473069191,
-0.10270961374044418,
0.21461376547813416,
-0.06042632460594177,
-0.05218177288770676,
0.11897303909063339,
-0.5402372479438782,
-0.01942099817097187,
0.5831299424171448,
-0.11919569224119186,
-0.015972552821040154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18906v1 | Sonnet or Not, Bot? Poetry Evaluation for Large Models and Datasets | 2024-06-27T05:36:53 | 2024-06-27T05:36:53 | Melanie Walsh, Anna Preus, Maria Antoniak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can now generate and recognize text in a wide
range of styles and genres, including highly specialized, creative genres like
poetry. But what do LLMs really know about poetry? What can they know about
poetry? We develop a task to evaluate how well LLMs recognize a specific aspect
of poetry, poetic form, for more than 20 forms and formal elements in the
English language. Poetic form captures many different poetic features,
including rhyme scheme, meter, and word or line repetition. We use this task to
reflect on LLMs' current poetic capabilities, as well as the challenges and
pitfalls of creating NLP benchmarks for poetry and for other creative tasks. In
particular, we use this task to audit and reflect on the poems included in
popular pretraining datasets. Our findings have implications for NLP
researchers interested in model evaluation, digital humanities and cultural
analytics scholars, and cultural heritage professionals. | [
-0.11410634219646454,
-0.42298778891563416,
0.3615955114364624,
0.1295521855354309,
-0.24450162053108215,
0.07574760913848877,
-0.36519020795822144,
-0.6665989756584167,
0.23591554164886475,
0.6603431701660156,
-0.4281134605407715,
-0.47033917903900146,
-0.6727023720741272,
0.15902353823184967,
-0.7494341135025024,
1.061084508895874,
-0.046619489789009094,
0.1556943655014038,
-0.4365590214729309,
0.01624896377325058,
-0.6058049201965332,
-0.27461060881614685,
-0.762993335723877,
-0.4065091907978058,
0.6844051480293274,
0.04670298099517822,
0.16458022594451904,
0.11417581140995026,
0.5887009501457214,
0.33111706376075745,
-0.07928628474473953,
0.15352311730384827,
-0.4639270305633545,
0.3942960500717163,
-0.11831753700971603,
-0.8266218900680542,
-0.28270038962364197,
0.4127117395401001,
0.7403149008750916,
0.7343593239784241,
0.363435834646225,
0.6278513669967651,
0.024152951315045357,
0.9502212405204773,
-0.5659813284873962,
0.05903899669647217,
-0.8106942772865295,
0.39435407519340515,
-0.5279259085655212,
-0.3331467807292938,
-0.28288617730140686,
-0.2101002335548401,
0.1999754160642624,
-0.21179668605327606,
0.3035242259502411,
0.1731761246919632,
0.48435989022254944,
0.28940901160240173,
-0.12817879021167755,
-0.1388401985168457,
-0.6524407267570496,
0.6946502923965454,
-0.5634433627128601,
0.22172866761684418,
0.39855220913887024,
0.43048161268234253,
-0.2192867249250412,
-0.6576058864593506,
-0.7415445446968079,
-0.4379050135612488,
0.18523454666137695,
0.3187560439109802,
-0.24330519139766693,
-0.2132449597120285,
0.3245466649532318,
0.5214919447898865,
-0.815478503704071,
0.02420785464346409,
-0.131216898560524,
0.013998680748045444,
0.861856997013092,
0.2179262489080429,
0.5106849074363708,
-0.5234148502349854,
-0.36511290073394775,
0.16821055114269257,
-0.37275832891464233,
0.24698375165462494,
0.6088883280754089,
0.13768842816352844,
-0.13100175559520721,
0.866306722164154,
0.08423149585723877,
0.602851927280426,
-0.5247772336006165,
-0.0759245902299881,
0.11796136200428009,
0.08302795886993408,
-0.09932879358530045,
-0.0165457371622324,
0.8700358271598816,
0.24468502402305603,
0.19292187690734863,
-0.4508231282234192,
-0.5878905057907104,
0.28649279475212097,
0.545220673084259,
-0.12144222855567932,
-0.15911351144313812,
0.2439468950033188,
-0.6151105165481567,
-0.298208087682724,
0.084412582218647,
-0.35483846068382263,
-0.818077027797699,
-0.3358970880508423,
0.6962583065032959,
-0.17519567906856537,
-0.07066167145967484,
0.055984433740377426,
-0.6806278824806213,
0.051360245794057846,
0.34857630729675293,
-0.485186904668808,
0.3173913359642029,
0.9422397017478943,
0.7835065126419067,
-0.34606286883354187,
-0.5740315914154053,
-0.41543644666671753,
-0.3519641160964966,
-0.606383740901947,
0.8123411536216736,
-0.41761690378189087,
0.022731764242053032,
-0.3458119332790375,
0.1919674426317215,
-0.13781504333019257,
-0.709462583065033,
0.5534884929656982,
-0.3967742621898651,
0.23589427769184113,
-0.04769864305853844,
-0.6480481624603271,
-0.2391706109046936,
0.24238868057727814,
-0.934263288974762,
0.8471269607543945,
0.1436159759759903,
-0.6858658194541931,
0.2870740294456482,
-0.5459707379341125,
-0.42569103837013245,
0.23574914038181305,
-0.3088150918483734,
-0.20015551149845123,
0.40514135360717773,
-0.16524115204811096,
0.5570139288902283,
-0.5043519735336304,
0.1361423283815384,
-0.09737277030944824,
-0.3252338171005249,
0.42680248618125916,
-0.4299484193325043,
0.713041365146637,
0.2134155035018921,
-0.4098329246044159,
0.25078660249710083,
-0.7223407030105591,
-0.08479474484920502,
0.3042876124382019,
-0.21839936077594757,
0.0011379678035154939,
0.019142858684062958,
0.4075523614883423,
0.00841530691832304,
0.1938537359237671,
-0.6181734800338745,
-0.018112193793058395,
-0.5128561854362488,
0.4863642752170563,
0.5997470617294312,
-0.23449446260929108,
-0.022430991753935814,
-1.0434473752975464,
1.0202244520187378,
-0.37942761182785034,
-0.16313225030899048,
0.09015024453401566,
-0.7044597864151001,
-0.5093033313751221,
-0.10491080582141876,
0.40161213278770447,
0.4540916681289673,
-0.6254323720932007,
0.6203102469444275,
-0.11486855149269104,
-0.9847325086593628,
-0.7041969895362854,
0.33689314126968384,
0.16175641119480133,
0.3759616017341614,
0.0766168013215065,
-0.4524375796318054,
-0.5560396313667297,
-0.6401523947715759,
-0.43141043186187744,
-0.0501248799264431,
0.21048249304294586,
0.17958781123161316,
0.5794205665588379,
0.06229154393076897,
0.803347647190094,
-0.08692068606615067,
-0.3387085795402527,
-0.707177460193634,
0.2695017158985138,
0.22512692213058472,
0.3222832679748535,
0.5925968289375305,
-0.505721926689148,
-0.10670841485261917,
-0.1771223098039627,
-0.5680843591690063,
-0.24028389155864716,
-0.10532607138156891,
-0.025489386171102524,
0.022835323587059975,
0.1048712357878685,
-0.46571165323257446,
0.30915793776512146,
0.7753535509109497,
-0.13761550188064575,
0.5707763433456421,
0.0007279023993760347,
0.0836823359131813,
-0.7957770228385925,
0.22457240521907806,
-0.2030843198299408,
-0.3957732021808624,
-0.38067129254341125,
-0.02328738197684288,
-0.15134459733963013,
-0.3607322871685028,
-0.29951047897338867,
0.7037476301193237,
-0.2576264441013336,
-0.34293079376220703,
-0.47288885712623596,
0.20035088062286377,
0.15808680653572083,
0.003269942244514823,
0.13496486842632294,
0.48236846923828125,
0.6293537616729736,
-0.18356026709079742,
0.8335890769958496,
-0.10242941975593567,
-0.6344169974327087,
0.5053611993789673,
-0.38133475184440613,
0.21765735745429993,
-0.24399439990520477,
0.47094491124153137,
-1.0075896978378296,
-0.04387162998318672,
-0.17675639688968658,
-0.5464192628860474,
0.16515111923217773,
-0.1103241965174675,
-0.568932294845581,
-0.47024616599082947,
-0.3965281546115875,
0.4266515076160431,
0.42746639251708984,
-0.16127349436283112,
0.49754706025123596,
0.38387855887413025,
0.04031332582235336,
-0.4894099533557892,
-0.6950578689575195,
0.3998068571090698,
-0.3032163381576538,
-0.5709937214851379,
-0.055567964911460876,
-0.014826707541942596,
-0.2597726583480835,
-0.05475394055247307,
-0.044251661747694016,
0.028724780306220055,
0.4762025475502014,
0.33645856380462646,
-0.05655084550380707,
-0.22671116888523102,
0.2925325334072113,
-0.40843015909194946,
-0.1353738158941269,
-0.03247090429067612,
-0.31273797154426575,
0.8392037153244019,
-0.09058574587106705,
-0.6090506315231323,
-0.6744411587715149,
0.2122352421283722,
0.48568564653396606,
-0.35270801186561584,
0.31444185972213745,
0.711334228515625,
-0.4350798428058624,
-0.565581202507019,
-0.6276885867118835,
0.23316152393817902,
-0.3298616111278534,
0.07999547570943832,
-0.08022651076316833,
-0.7020536065101624,
0.4031248390674591,
0.12706726789474487,
-0.03653903305530548,
0.7849934697151184,
0.5400822758674622,
-0.34801724553108215,
0.2634398937225342,
0.5328992605209351,
-0.09034457057714462,
0.250053733587265,
-0.459296852350235,
0.08871272206306458,
-0.8957737684249878,
-0.11440227180719376,
-0.5615493059158325,
-0.9168342351913452,
-0.40103012323379517,
-0.41452547907829285,
0.3847375214099884,
-0.09303362667560577,
0.0996922105550766,
0.2898346185684204,
-0.3787977397441864,
0.1824282705783844,
0.5176129341125488,
0.08264847099781036,
0.24811658263206482,
-0.4361812174320221,
0.24411170184612274,
0.18239764869213104,
-0.5354112982749939,
-0.7910674810409546,
1.2435089349746704,
0.2517627775669098,
0.5145888924598694,
0.06749388575553894,
0.8036995530128479,
0.597946047782898,
-0.0665629580616951,
-1.0419882535934448,
0.5264777541160583,
-0.5364524126052856,
-0.5691830515861511,
-0.3621216416358948,
-0.3255845308303833,
-1.371119499206543,
-0.1981136053800583,
-0.37321189045906067,
-0.46501344442367554,
-0.3124946057796478,
-0.21428146958351135,
-0.2643173635005951,
0.48830682039260864,
-0.41341158747673035,
0.7994325160980225,
-0.3741954565048218,
0.2538815438747406,
-0.164642333984375,
-0.38487008213996887,
0.2160697728395462,
-0.2881489396095276,
0.15780863165855408,
-0.3410603702068329,
-0.2366611510515213,
0.9739091992378235,
-0.3442935347557068,
0.737546980381012,
0.11689623445272446,
-0.11342494189739227,
0.4418043792247772,
0.16373863816261292,
0.14046232402324677,
-0.3108922243118286,
-0.18610936403274536,
0.05409850925207138,
0.3335496187210083,
-0.3589748740196228,
-0.7346372008323669,
0.4824237823486328,
-0.7595182061195374,
-0.3714916408061981,
-0.18570999801158905,
-0.40114399790763855,
-0.2357056587934494,
0.11900150030851364,
0.28104496002197266,
0.42893603444099426,
0.006056307815015316,
0.3127305805683136,
0.14270539581775665,
-0.31054067611694336,
0.4422501027584076,
0.16803187131881714,
-0.24280904233455658,
-0.27675384283065796,
0.7855251431465149,
0.3870462477207184,
0.16979847848415375,
0.40621256828308105,
0.5427584648132324,
-0.22573910653591156,
-0.6885378360748291,
-0.5569941997528076,
0.16132114827632904,
-0.6604260206222534,
0.07616809755563736,
-0.4302288889884949,
-0.43509340286254883,
-0.4357035160064697,
0.02033272013068199,
-0.3124488890171051,
-0.5129492282867432,
-0.19316786527633667,
0.2100076973438263,
0.5303177237510681,
1.2118072509765625,
0.26183441281318665,
0.04057829827070236,
-0.7339588403701782,
0.39083701372146606,
0.29196232557296753,
0.5472432374954224,
0.16369444131851196,
-0.5766967535018921,
0.10453309863805771,
-0.5699619054794312,
-0.03282466530799866,
-0.7597556710243225,
0.03263946622610092,
0.1110534742474556,
0.66004878282547,
0.10926251113414764,
0.12017207592725754,
0.29270416498184204,
-0.65254807472229,
1.1859703063964844,
0.12002910673618317,
-0.9506934285163879,
0.692929208278656,
-0.27677467465400696,
-0.0028978423215448856,
0.27282029390335083,
0.30448663234710693,
-0.7459834218025208,
-0.4898105561733246,
-0.7115121483802795,
-0.5717584490776062,
0.31520140171051025,
0.19362574815750122,
0.4746353030204773,
-0.02475142665207386,
0.3118569552898407,
0.36265888810157776,
0.48501694202423096,
-0.7359241843223572,
-0.21183320879936218,
-0.09496293216943741,
-0.3136478364467621,
-0.41400521993637085,
-0.06859970837831497,
-0.15637768805027008,
-0.08806456625461578,
0.3467385172843933,
0.14393773674964905,
0.08127985894680023,
0.19016936421394348,
-0.03228502348065376,
-0.13109572231769562,
0.22348037362098694,
0.48551884293556213,
0.7654610872268677,
0.1582401990890503,
0.4907597303390503,
0.12033006548881531,
-0.5155695676803589,
-0.00744975358247757,
-0.12794609367847443,
0.016565296798944473,
0.01121844444423914,
1.0064983367919922,
0.6606422066688538,
-0.22371122241020203,
-1.0048149824142456,
0.65476393699646,
0.11910074949264526,
-0.0341440849006176,
-0.453402042388916,
0.4209681451320648,
-0.016779953613877296,
0.3928876221179962,
0.024072209373116493,
0.007884783670306206,
0.16176053881645203,
-0.7819608449935913,
0.06889467686414719,
0.6069183349609375,
-0.45704078674316406,
-0.22492143511772156,
0.45022618770599365,
-0.11877626925706863,
-0.5301147103309631,
-0.0598781444132328,
-0.09400441497564316,
-0.5282930135726929,
0.5838935375213623,
0.43759968876838684,
1.1719059944152832,
0.36105167865753174,
-0.013503910973668098,
-0.0859372615814209,
0.363826185464859,
0.10904277861118317,
0.5776008367538452,
0.057775210589170456,
-0.7074417471885681,
-0.3900686204433441,
-0.7669862508773804,
-0.273125559091568,
0.3517046570777893,
-0.2500467598438263,
0.39893749356269836,
-0.7292916178703308,
-0.33789345622062683,
0.14196516573429108,
0.18021821975708008,
-0.7037602066993713,
0.23403850197792053,
0.42734798789024353,
0.7392605543136597,
-0.8964919447898865,
0.395727276802063,
0.9066060781478882,
-0.2814597487449646,
-0.6899511814117432,
-0.04706490784883499,
0.11283258348703384,
-0.6692861318588257,
0.785222589969635,
0.027245616540312767,
-0.30643129348754883,
-0.0675390362739563,
-0.5800898671150208,
-0.5802667737007141,
0.870399534702301,
0.33424830436706543,
-0.26896384358406067,
0.33276891708374023,
-0.03726131469011307,
0.6233490705490112,
-0.2760127782821655,
0.3021077513694763,
0.17304253578186035,
0.3456251621246338,
-0.0880858525633812,
-1.206125020980835,
-0.30460986495018005,
-0.5242993831634521,
0.0003929812810383737,
-0.10617043077945709,
-0.6631402969360352,
0.743596076965332,
0.4113853871822357,
-0.12435850501060486,
0.27964678406715393,
0.3813363015651703,
0.070110023021698,
0.43667569756507874,
0.5778676867485046,
0.7974782586097717,
0.9824098944664001,
0.11667727679014206,
1.0478461980819702,
-0.08652152121067047,
0.09205776453018188,
0.9308925271034241,
-0.35700759291648865,
0.9099002480506897,
0.04658574238419533,
-0.4081805646419525,
0.3370756506919861,
0.6552851796150208,
-0.1636725813150406,
-0.10368466377258301,
0.743706226348877,
-0.22442848980426788,
-0.2852509915828705,
-0.2689351439476013,
-0.24352046847343445,
0.8768704533576965,
-0.16141624748706818,
-0.31062158942222595,
-0.08080821484327316,
-0.026043975725769997,
-0.21824146807193756,
0.34743601083755493,
-0.33375126123428345,
0.7478109002113342,
0.11733634024858475,
-0.4193059504032135,
0.3337894678115845,
-0.09577019512653351,
0.5101264119148254,
-0.39431998133659363,
0.09480423480272293,
0.25371456146240234,
-0.33609265089035034,
-0.38220691680908203,
-0.9971619844436646,
0.29378414154052734,
0.3106115162372589,
-0.1785547435283661,
-0.08234338462352753,
0.5794202089309692,
-0.07819575816392899,
-0.5621587038040161,
0.24781450629234314,
0.6731907725334167,
0.6089332103729248,
-0.10089025646448135,
-0.6531190276145935,
-0.019011681899428368,
-0.4172859489917755,
-0.11306113004684448,
0.008135322481393814,
0.6666224598884583,
-0.003770744428038597,
0.6642628908157349,
0.6386406421661377,
0.6979359984397888,
0.05483144149184227,
0.5609567165374756,
0.352879136800766,
-0.678769588470459,
-0.19597983360290527,
-0.7006402015686035,
0.3422040641307831,
0.10857852548360825,
-0.43539807200431824,
0.5654214024543762,
0.6975011825561523,
0.8598393797874451,
0.08838537335395813,
0.8520119190216064,
0.13962632417678833,
0.7134028077125549,
-0.6997196674346924,
0.947594165802002,
-0.7781137824058533,
0.10273607820272446,
-0.4558945298194885,
-0.9093437194824219,
-0.26581987738609314,
0.41223010420799255,
-0.5354917049407959,
0.06181890144944191,
0.6129603385925293,
0.3583413362503052,
0.21231788396835327,
0.20664380490779877,
0.4352927505970001,
-0.0831649899482727,
0.12310365587472916,
0.33398911356925964,
1.4135321378707886,
-0.17465299367904663,
0.03318864107131958,
-0.15070681273937225,
-0.07790947705507278,
0.16285239160060883,
-1.0772961378097534,
-0.8794199824333191,
-0.7079277038574219,
-0.15241385996341705,
-0.06932341307401657,
-0.488961786031723,
1.2051323652267456,
0.47231054306030273,
-0.7034779787063599,
-0.36521226167678833,
0.21764051914215088,
0.13900582492351532,
-0.09249529242515564,
-0.1509227603673935,
0.3436060845851898,
-0.6663318872451782,
-0.45469430088996887,
0.4083094298839569,
0.4576733708381653,
0.03851981833577156,
-0.48084619641304016,
0.2816711664199829,
0.01944943144917488,
-0.06226223707199097,
0.5498501658439636,
-0.2599449157714844,
-0.9400847554206848,
-0.2539844512939453,
-0.22209234535694122,
0.04639085754752159,
-0.03651018068194389,
0.853053867816925,
-0.44708675146102905,
0.6489809155464172,
0.786771297454834,
0.9436642527580261,
0.08710262924432755,
-0.2154620885848999,
0.25762075185775757,
-0.4026641547679901,
-0.1313517540693283,
0.6438143253326416,
0.5474399924278259,
0.2183315008878708,
-0.19530285894870758,
0.44169336557388306,
0.617432177066803,
-0.505693256855011,
-0.6527215242385864,
0.21989072859287262,
-1.1862009763717651,
-0.310150682926178,
0.8426128029823303,
-0.1552705317735672,
-0.2275046706199646,
-0.17171357572078705,
-0.0787874236702919,
0.18615280091762543,
0.2295137345790863,
0.5157678127288818,
0.8164190649986267,
-0.23100055754184723,
-0.22636690735816956,
-1.1164369583129883,
0.4229707717895508,
0.4141634404659271,
-0.6054999828338623,
-0.2418287843465805,
0.23438489437103271,
0.24595333635807037,
0.0988456979393959,
0.5631040334701538,
-0.032236918807029724,
0.1903565526008606,
-0.23749707639217377,
0.23877578973770142,
0.25188690423965454,
-0.42443281412124634,
-0.4176565706729889,
0.17950846254825592,
0.4429461359977722,
0.0022945962846279144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00100v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00100v1 | Enhancing In-Context Learning via Implicit Demonstration Augmentation | 2024-06-27T05:25:46 | 2024-06-27T05:25:46 | Xiaoling Zhou, Wei Ye, Yidong Wang, Chaoya Jiang, Zhemg Lee, Rui Xie, Shikun Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | The emergence of in-context learning (ICL) enables large pre-trained language
models (PLMs) to make predictions for unseen inputs without updating
parameters. Despite its potential, ICL's effectiveness heavily relies on the
quality, quantity, and permutation of demonstrations, commonly leading to
suboptimal and unstable performance. In this paper, we tackle this challenge
for the first time from the perspective of demonstration augmentation.
Specifically, we start with enriching representations of demonstrations by
leveraging their deep feature distribution. We then theoretically reveal that
when the number of augmented copies approaches infinity, the augmentation is
approximately equal to a novel logit calibration mechanism integrated with
specific statistical properties. This insight results in a simple yet highly
efficient method that significantly improves the average and worst-case
accuracy across diverse PLMs and tasks. Moreover, our method effectively
reduces performance variance among varying demonstrations, permutations, and
templates, and displays the capability to address imbalanced class
distributions. | [
-0.4033205807209015,
-0.474979966878891,
0.38468363881111145,
0.2938678562641144,
-0.4202973246574402,
0.13422182202339172,
-0.20149068534374237,
-0.2512289881706238,
-0.2676243185997009,
0.07685139030218124,
-0.37345248460769653,
-0.4706610143184662,
-0.46030959486961365,
-0.21605320274829865,
-0.44660428166389465,
0.9920081496238708,
0.16572855412960052,
0.050952814519405365,
-0.5633648037910461,
-0.2837340533733368,
-0.3625198006629944,
-0.37774479389190674,
-0.43754786252975464,
-0.3684547245502472,
0.029289262369275093,
0.5901586413383484,
0.49386993050575256,
0.37100133299827576,
-0.11310931295156479,
0.25268346071243286,
0.18184351921081543,
0.3898167908191681,
-0.5939732789993286,
-0.07416392862796783,
0.019684065133333206,
-0.5283498167991638,
0.0068741790018975735,
-0.09027315676212311,
0.935432493686676,
0.8199508190155029,
0.21912533044815063,
-0.01828646846115589,
0.5254940390586853,
0.321124792098999,
-0.7219518423080444,
0.040907833725214005,
-0.6465463042259216,
-0.08827150613069534,
0.0782310962677002,
-0.2109624743461609,
-0.5498879551887512,
-0.17194020748138428,
0.34255245327949524,
-0.6029894351959229,
0.11251899600028992,
-0.2709178030490875,
0.4633294939994812,
0.36891499161720276,
-0.41707807779312134,
-0.03753605857491493,
-0.7525358200073242,
0.6411202549934387,
-0.6995773911476135,
0.3726368248462677,
0.1001012772321701,
0.17579756677150726,
-0.12832482159137726,
-0.7817410230636597,
-0.5933431386947632,
-0.43056416511535645,
-0.2914506196975708,
-0.05557166412472725,
0.025150325149297714,
-0.045247048139572144,
0.4237176179885864,
0.3422800600528717,
-0.3262450695037842,
0.2759549021720886,
-0.07227993756532669,
-0.19219914078712463,
0.40186169743537903,
-0.08156199008226395,
0.3324625492095947,
0.19073398411273956,
-0.5102251768112183,
-0.611047089099884,
-0.850415825843811,
0.2885003089904785,
0.32443827390670776,
0.00016286461323034018,
-0.1468496471643448,
0.41536200046539307,
-0.13875141739845276,
0.456906795501709,
0.23126885294914246,
-0.1276983618736267,
0.3976118266582489,
-0.16335582733154297,
-0.33592909574508667,
0.20026497542858124,
0.4288511276245117,
0.025936661288142204,
-0.33204734325408936,
0.06135614588856697,
-0.09278635680675507,
-0.11727491021156311,
0.0058419122360646725,
-0.9269785284996033,
-0.2497207224369049,
0.0920545682311058,
0.04250556230545044,
-0.2876073122024536,
0.2161554992198944,
-0.6098592281341553,
-0.5347532033920288,
-0.3314566910266876,
0.8161823153495789,
-0.5375456809997559,
-0.1615413874387741,
-0.02309790626168251,
-0.023826928809285164,
-0.0047781215980648994,
0.45656219124794006,
-0.8284439444541931,
0.2661009430885315,
0.6310102343559265,
0.5377506613731384,
0.07458225637674332,
-0.39933446049690247,
-0.709481954574585,
0.31440335512161255,
-0.4435270428657532,
0.5180824995040894,
-0.48930060863494873,
-0.17039701342582703,
-0.05595563352108002,
-0.20801061391830444,
0.13279643654823303,
-0.6141185164451599,
0.1946471929550171,
-0.16116975247859955,
0.13909156620502472,
-0.033370357006788254,
-0.715490996837616,
-0.1719200611114502,
0.0036948418710380793,
-0.5125675201416016,
1.0065321922302246,
0.07368147373199463,
-0.4418027102947235,
0.8892290592193604,
-0.8342685103416443,
-0.5021121501922607,
0.21509602665901184,
-0.36371883749961853,
-0.36188656091690063,
0.2680548429489136,
0.5939068794250488,
0.47343483567237854,
0.1375446617603302,
-0.039321161806583405,
-0.27779242396354675,
-0.6497646570205688,
0.2856752872467041,
-0.740043580532074,
0.45090922713279724,
-0.03347814828157425,
-0.6982396841049194,
0.16113418340682983,
-0.6019788384437561,
-0.06529556959867477,
-0.27573683857917786,
-0.03165092691779137,
-0.4147700369358063,
-0.12496986240148544,
-0.3202506899833679,
0.15443900227546692,
0.17756959795951843,
-0.4227393865585327,
0.08089988678693771,
-0.7656276822090149,
0.14029549062252045,
0.8689249753952026,
-0.06936439126729965,
0.7349430918693542,
-0.13649404048919678,
0.331318199634552,
0.23945631086826324,
0.2973625361919403,
-0.6141344308853149,
-0.0702638030052185,
-0.6386111974716187,
-0.4889395833015442,
0.13377174735069275,
0.2781946659088135,
-0.5780444741249084,
0.17867839336395264,
-0.2926700711250305,
-0.3244182765483856,
-0.5162009000778198,
0.3261229395866394,
0.44536837935447693,
0.5184343457221985,
0.31153202056884766,
-0.16340018808841705,
-0.25160807371139526,
-0.8352243900299072,
-0.12492070347070694,
-0.22558005154132843,
-0.075470931828022,
0.17356902360916138,
0.19804561138153076,
-0.04233822226524353,
0.731929361820221,
-0.04173070564866066,
-0.1401255875825882,
-0.1345423310995102,
0.33412933349609375,
0.13433951139450073,
0.6870121955871582,
0.5808411836624146,
-0.8549781441688538,
-0.48790082335472107,
0.15884999930858612,
-0.6280741095542908,
-0.053337614983320236,
-0.21952776610851288,
-0.11584491282701492,
0.3214268982410431,
0.5963417887687683,
-0.2975254952907562,
0.6647455096244812,
0.38156455755233765,
-0.19700691103935242,
0.37126055359840393,
-0.4549259543418884,
0.16273105144500732,
-0.6659983396530151,
-0.30397820472717285,
-0.1397559940814972,
-0.17750878632068634,
-0.46211308240890503,
0.1001613661646843,
0.3026700019836426,
-0.02856307290494442,
-0.6228358745574951,
0.6231532096862793,
-0.39990270137786865,
-0.09641511738300323,
-0.2621091306209564,
-0.045884620398283005,
-0.023149795830249786,
0.34618711471557617,
-0.21099402010440826,
1.0666205883026123,
0.7115535736083984,
-0.6189047694206238,
-0.06835877150297165,
0.1851603090763092,
-0.5055534839630127,
0.5426632761955261,
-0.38010603189468384,
-0.02886796183884144,
-0.3104095458984375,
0.43229609727859497,
-1.2559897899627686,
-0.2720222771167755,
-0.015658628195524216,
-0.2753664255142212,
0.4878830015659332,
-0.1888822615146637,
-0.6140344738960266,
0.04957084730267525,
-0.35723504424095154,
0.3937596380710602,
0.8819724321365356,
-1.134137749671936,
0.5338540077209473,
0.12819978594779968,
0.17355230450630188,
-0.8420958518981934,
-0.576389491558075,
-0.038730423897504807,
-0.32422325015068054,
-0.46407565474510193,
0.36514362692832947,
-0.23852159082889557,
-0.12194350361824036,
-0.27336445450782776,
-0.21773888170719147,
0.36289310455322266,
0.11641659587621689,
0.4079799950122833,
-0.03761814534664154,
-0.16954846680164337,
0.41697221994400024,
0.4268939197063446,
0.05320482701063156,
-0.1316671520471573,
-0.4754480719566345,
0.5147091746330261,
-0.2612559199333191,
-0.8659490942955017,
-0.399663507938385,
0.3104608654975891,
0.5134401321411133,
-0.01806969754397869,
0.596474289894104,
0.5398476719856262,
-0.33306533098220825,
-0.3470681607723236,
-0.632354736328125,
-0.33333608508110046,
-0.5235193371772766,
0.45497676730155945,
-0.4425358176231384,
-0.7453803420066833,
0.31210750341415405,
-0.3754483759403229,
0.17832587659358978,
0.12269337475299835,
0.17232337594032288,
-0.10387340933084488,
1.4677900075912476,
0.5934795141220093,
0.03980595991015434,
0.6537149548530579,
-0.30560141801834106,
0.16614481806755066,
-0.80775386095047,
-0.22284533083438873,
-0.06016727164387703,
-0.28133073449134827,
-0.2632181644439697,
-0.5018228888511658,
0.7334060072898865,
0.4813872277736664,
-0.35249900817871094,
0.0031850426457822323,
-0.21282733976840973,
0.5947851538658142,
0.6488514542579651,
0.6418284177780151,
0.1786443293094635,
0.2660851776599884,
-0.30569982528686523,
-0.17158132791519165,
-0.678789496421814,
-0.6797504425048828,
1.0593925714492798,
0.23608477413654327,
0.582203209400177,
0.10158538818359375,
0.6630045771598816,
0.2746582329273224,
0.6679428219795227,
-0.14360159635543823,
0.6374819278717041,
-0.36070504784584045,
-0.09918484836816788,
-0.5425207018852234,
-0.07390115410089493,
-0.5241889357566833,
0.3320738971233368,
-0.32522544264793396,
-0.7290501594543457,
0.3509061932563782,
0.5496220588684082,
-0.13210147619247437,
0.20143428444862366,
-0.8940770626068115,
0.924532413482666,
-0.32423627376556396,
-0.6224430203437805,
-0.3672178387641907,
-0.41537272930145264,
0.34222397208213806,
0.005281130783259869,
0.07888158410787582,
0.10809111595153809,
-0.06484214961528778,
0.15208515524864197,
-0.594253420829773,
0.9564418792724609,
-0.38642337918281555,
-0.09832405298948288,
0.057510245591402054,
0.07099105417728424,
0.7685274481773376,
0.27789321541786194,
-0.07954137027263641,
-0.3494429588317871,
-0.46192264556884766,
-0.5372912287712097,
-1.0852220058441162,
0.8788831233978271,
-0.6452682018280029,
-0.6482529044151306,
0.08143335580825806,
-0.425906240940094,
-0.3423433303833008,
-0.22983519732952118,
0.154711052775383,
0.8814678192138672,
-0.14089445769786835,
0.2915474772453308,
0.8017487525939941,
-0.4410555064678192,
0.4291819632053375,
0.22403118014335632,
-0.1433030515909195,
-0.3051096498966217,
1.0264136791229248,
-0.11408126354217529,
0.5672854781150818,
0.49088266491889954,
0.1822105199098587,
-0.6872223615646362,
-0.6815811395645142,
-0.5425387620925903,
-0.048445090651512146,
-1.25551176071167,
0.18859514594078064,
-0.7620462775230408,
0.05618977174162865,
-0.39104026556015015,
-0.3413454294204712,
-0.024571163579821587,
-0.3445121645927429,
-0.39591655135154724,
-0.3587043881416321,
0.24750085175037384,
0.5205438733100891,
-0.18090830743312836,
0.5834148526191711,
-0.18700268864631653,
-0.05290166661143303,
0.770086944103241,
0.20173324644565582,
0.07708021998405457,
-0.6009752154350281,
-0.10317490249872208,
0.22358067333698273,
-0.214479461312294,
-0.5584967136383057,
0.31881681084632874,
0.46056780219078064,
0.7751430869102478,
0.6297370195388794,
0.062178291380405426,
1.2237592935562134,
-0.24384741485118866,
0.8959189057350159,
0.20451058447360992,
-1.0932564735412598,
0.5925788879394531,
-0.01184515468776226,
0.1782611906528473,
0.4032388925552368,
0.2156049907207489,
0.030803531408309937,
-0.7185125946998596,
-0.8005748987197876,
-1.030213475227356,
0.5213912725448608,
-0.08717390149831772,
0.5545395612716675,
0.10375779122114182,
0.04719684645533562,
0.360408753156662,
0.1172945573925972,
-0.7039044499397278,
-0.29617545008659363,
-0.558920681476593,
-0.35428333282470703,
-0.309539258480072,
-0.2267054170370102,
-0.13250166177749634,
-0.6041721701622009,
0.8123696446418762,
-0.4041329026222229,
-0.06067909300327301,
0.10232100635766983,
-0.5786910057067871,
0.1261139065027237,
0.22174914181232452,
0.9161768555641174,
0.9647548794746399,
-0.04389604926109314,
0.3408443331718445,
0.5559697151184082,
-0.2555234432220459,
0.20875541865825653,
0.2282099723815918,
-0.08483050763607025,
-0.08631745725870132,
0.26756560802459717,
1.2807124853134155,
0.5434180498123169,
-0.8862051963806152,
0.7529652714729309,
0.14957758784294128,
0.04743426293134689,
-0.4172498881816864,
0.2016458511352539,
-0.3168131113052368,
0.4076370596885681,
0.8053438663482666,
-0.03492431715130806,
0.18419785797595978,
-0.44840937852859497,
0.544599711894989,
0.5512024164199829,
-0.4614734351634979,
-0.1591002643108368,
0.7188385725021362,
-0.011906054802238941,
-0.13129940629005432,
0.27917903661727905,
-0.11637530475854874,
-0.408111035823822,
0.5196550488471985,
0.7490085959434509,
0.6921551823616028,
-0.07139159739017487,
0.3467863202095032,
0.2627575993537903,
0.2316991686820984,
0.01936832070350647,
-0.1538267880678177,
-0.3164803683757782,
-0.523445188999176,
-0.5574572682380676,
-0.3573650121688843,
-0.3579818904399872,
0.32494527101516724,
-0.2852739691734314,
0.36689189076423645,
-0.30479684472084045,
0.2979605197906494,
-0.17113789916038513,
-0.1603306531906128,
-0.6811086535453796,
0.18211902678012848,
0.20474080741405487,
0.7041769623756409,
-1.0408459901809692,
0.681276798248291,
0.7379376888275146,
-0.3260282576084137,
-0.6859925985336304,
0.16423749923706055,
-0.46515658497810364,
-0.6623345017433167,
0.6803370118141174,
0.28820884227752686,
0.06650293618440628,
0.1717797964811325,
-0.7720476984977722,
-0.49947038292884827,
0.9741518497467041,
0.7523044347763062,
-0.2581242024898529,
0.4865248501300812,
0.2625283896923065,
0.5381686091423035,
-0.6715295314788818,
0.6640046834945679,
0.2693542242050171,
0.3704226016998291,
0.05488494411110878,
-0.5843048691749573,
0.04802686721086502,
-0.16297923028469086,
-0.010389681905508041,
-0.0478338748216629,
-0.3021286427974701,
0.625832200050354,
-0.28413125872612,
-0.24666057527065277,
-0.06465663760900497,
0.8265916705131531,
0.49201732873916626,
0.3713285028934479,
0.8629639744758606,
0.35324040055274963,
0.6478498578071594,
0.020137712359428406,
1.1976747512817383,
-0.01777782291173935,
-0.17057675123214722,
1.14241623878479,
-0.13288046419620514,
0.6069056987762451,
0.568766713142395,
-0.07457758486270905,
0.6156057119369507,
0.523334264755249,
0.40418100357055664,
0.5559810400009155,
0.047064900398254395,
-0.8219344615936279,
-0.451211154460907,
-0.13044612109661102,
-0.20934277772903442,
0.13483616709709167,
0.5398629903793335,
-0.2959970235824585,
-0.2297266572713852,
0.5237028002738953,
-0.3457653522491455,
0.30894896388053894,
-0.28611698746681213,
0.8372008800506592,
-0.2805935740470886,
-0.5378168225288391,
0.5950661897659302,
-0.5756503343582153,
0.6326427459716797,
-0.47398245334625244,
-0.5738997459411621,
-0.22116829454898834,
0.12111221998929977,
-0.09283129125833511,
-0.7662023305892944,
-0.18047162890434265,
-0.4092722535133362,
-0.07886333018541336,
-0.3088746666908264,
0.5129348635673523,
-0.7094264626502991,
-0.28377029299736023,
0.126083642244339,
0.09267107397317886,
0.23264099657535553,
0.037923574447631836,
-0.2897018790245056,
-0.11505547910928726,
-0.10847805440425873,
0.05399945750832558,
0.5294275283813477,
0.538439154624939,
-0.2797352969646454,
0.6502816081047058,
0.6977418661117554,
-0.23433838784694672,
0.33399564027786255,
0.16489890217781067,
0.907090961933136,
-0.021841561421751976,
-0.5595314502716064,
-0.8856256604194641,
0.8893764019012451,
-0.39992523193359375,
-0.2526000142097473,
0.7588613629341125,
0.543249249458313,
1.1055669784545898,
-0.2997315227985382,
0.8793116807937622,
0.23081393539905548,
0.33799684047698975,
-0.4188894033432007,
0.37887242436408997,
-0.601104199886322,
0.4615465998649597,
-0.4124065935611725,
-0.5314852595329285,
-0.18524862825870514,
0.46307018399238586,
-0.059677425771951675,
-0.19876965880393982,
0.5145153403282166,
0.8505147099494934,
-0.3516957461833954,
-0.047743748873472214,
0.5826617479324341,
0.10408133268356323,
0.38905811309814453,
0.4322369396686554,
1.0175575017929077,
-0.3934571146965027,
0.5037791132926941,
-0.6114820241928101,
-0.3249221742153168,
-0.17749500274658203,
-1.102586030960083,
-0.8406763672828674,
-0.6505097150802612,
-0.37467435002326965,
-0.03477160260081291,
0.12142026424407959,
1.035239338874817,
1.0202234983444214,
-0.7292778491973877,
-0.12431193143129349,
-0.21154622733592987,
0.12503118813037872,
-0.5481051206588745,
-0.22119513154029846,
0.4316233694553375,
-0.4759085476398468,
-0.8956138491630554,
0.6245173215866089,
0.16207529604434967,
0.2944552004337311,
-0.36283227801322937,
-0.21338200569152832,
0.14513255655765533,
-0.21344774961471558,
0.8299000263214111,
0.24896040558815002,
-0.7195919752120972,
-0.37925413250923157,
-0.369953453540802,
0.21353325247764587,
0.055212751030921936,
0.6525341868400574,
-1.1444464921951294,
0.5412585139274597,
0.3333934545516968,
0.7854519486427307,
0.7240840792655945,
0.08087308704853058,
0.7173717617988586,
-1.1562291383743286,
0.5017837882041931,
0.11928954720497131,
0.21579240262508392,
0.33685511350631714,
-0.4256589114665985,
0.34139275550842285,
-0.06128069385886192,
-0.21915987133979797,
-1.1818125247955322,
0.1465158611536026,
-0.6668865084648132,
-0.13425752520561218,
0.8219283819198608,
-0.0854070782661438,
0.05749703198671341,
-0.03311691805720329,
-0.2904292941093445,
0.09851635247468948,
-0.3990563154220581,
0.6404318809509277,
0.31478580832481384,
-0.08501072227954865,
-0.48953235149383545,
-0.4289204776287079,
0.5981684923171997,
0.5538195967674255,
-0.7207624316215515,
-0.017948012799024582,
0.45542284846305847,
0.18352612853050232,
-0.04919363185763359,
0.3409767746925354,
-0.04648847505450249,
0.3833981454372406,
-0.39329928159713745,
-0.05559195578098297,
-0.1105511412024498,
-0.3089847266674042,
-0.5733576416969299,
0.28351277112960815,
0.14099720120429993,
-0.15614473819732666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18895v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18895v1 | Can we teach language models to gloss endangered languages? | 2024-06-27T05:17:04 | 2024-06-27T05:17:04 | Michael Ginn, Mans Hulden, Alexis Palmer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interlinear glossed text (IGT) is a popular format in language documentation
projects, where each morpheme is labeled with a descriptive annotation.
Automating the creation of interlinear glossed text can be desirable to reduce
annotator effort and maintain consistency across annotated corpora. Prior
research has explored a number of statistical and neural methods for
automatically producing IGT.
As large language models (LLMs) have showed promising results across
multilingual tasks, even for rare, endangered languages, it is natural to
wonder whether they can be utilized for the task of generating IGT. We explore
whether LLMs can be effective at the task of interlinear glossing with
in-context learning, without any traditional training. We propose new
approaches for selecting examples to provide in-context, observing that
targeted selection can significantly improve performance. We find that
LLM-based methods beat standard transformer baselines, despite requiring no
training at all. These approaches still underperform state-of-the-art
supervised systems for the task, but are highly practical for researchers
outside of the NLP community, requiring minimal effort to use. | [
-0.6040469408035278,
-0.6566808223724365,
0.216594859957695,
0.31371963024139404,
-0.1490103006362915,
0.2311544269323349,
-0.47332796454429626,
-0.4996475577354431,
0.19063232839107513,
0.45102450251579285,
-0.3397125005722046,
-0.3666950762271881,
-0.7502653002738953,
0.12458854913711548,
-0.5311658978462219,
0.9953192472457886,
0.13151681423187256,
-0.13175511360168457,
-0.12342949211597443,
-0.007327902130782604,
0.057974521070718765,
-0.7124601006507874,
-0.6537221074104309,
-0.2746458053588867,
0.20552460849285126,
0.6047027111053467,
0.7306124567985535,
0.5849925875663757,
0.4065258502960205,
0.20186516642570496,
-0.21762894093990326,
0.3325293958187103,
-0.49083849787712097,
0.1890072524547577,
0.0004556225030682981,
-0.1487807184457779,
-0.27556949853897095,
-0.026394998654723167,
0.4511376917362213,
0.7965923547744751,
-0.009558177553117275,
-0.06923066824674606,
0.1224026158452034,
0.390496164560318,
-0.5073728561401367,
0.21122612059116364,
-0.9123694896697998,
-0.15921759605407715,
-0.293285995721817,
-0.3730144500732422,
-0.38579484820365906,
-0.19691301882266998,
0.38905587792396545,
-0.6603471636772156,
0.02702464908361435,
0.008312150835990906,
0.8861649036407471,
0.2798929214477539,
-0.36529478430747986,
-0.672421932220459,
-0.6532399654388428,
0.39917123317718506,
-0.9956234693527222,
0.016204150393605232,
0.5375970005989075,
0.15343700349330902,
-0.11262446641921997,
-0.8066544532775879,
-0.2837860584259033,
-0.7236625552177429,
-0.17327867448329926,
0.26824483275413513,
-0.052468184381723404,
0.37059286236763,
0.2702966332435608,
0.31460830569267273,
-0.24191170930862427,
0.43648770451545715,
-0.4013190269470215,
0.09851028770208359,
0.49474820494651794,
-0.08172851800918579,
0.34557074308395386,
-0.1637868881225586,
-0.4294240176677704,
-0.1147134006023407,
-0.746336817741394,
-0.17792394757270813,
0.41209518909454346,
0.6721921563148499,
0.03378607705235481,
0.38659587502479553,
-0.09111086279153824,
0.46951496601104736,
-0.11825525015592575,
-0.10419847816228867,
-0.1319517195224762,
0.06582380086183548,
0.05363326147198677,
-0.2785595655441284,
0.5675992965698242,
0.3277880549430847,
0.4685491621494293,
-0.4249027967453003,
-0.39250466227531433,
-0.31916335225105286,
0.2863924205303192,
-0.6211968660354614,
-0.17888715863227844,
-0.13710083067417145,
-0.07711361348628998,
0.10141343623399734,
-0.18242254853248596,
-0.689866304397583,
-0.0261587705463171,
-0.37712422013282776,
0.5383513569831848,
-0.5653642416000366,
-0.20341245830059052,
-0.017858969047665596,
0.04538441449403763,
0.0742020383477211,
0.14149710536003113,
-1.3084912300109863,
0.40170228481292725,
0.49437156319618225,
0.8291885256767273,
-0.12607499957084656,
-0.36837705969810486,
-0.4098983108997345,
0.022800395265221596,
-0.4128279387950897,
0.48151275515556335,
-0.37482330203056335,
-0.3947478234767914,
0.20892104506492615,
-0.10603529959917068,
-0.05075225234031677,
-0.6659322381019592,
0.38452476263046265,
-0.5033659934997559,
0.06686010211706161,
0.004493303131312132,
-0.6288440823554993,
-0.22632838785648346,
0.016384579241275787,
-0.38461819291114807,
1.1756699085235596,
0.3657948970794678,
-0.5314221978187561,
0.3441530168056488,
-0.594951868057251,
-0.3344554007053375,
0.4800536334514618,
0.10483831912279129,
-0.3388407230377197,
0.057068318128585815,
0.15940257906913757,
0.42127159237861633,
-0.25239452719688416,
0.6024829745292664,
-0.08473992347717285,
-0.3059132993221283,
-0.23591876029968262,
-0.46531596779823303,
0.43066543340682983,
0.12379024922847748,
-0.7136532068252563,
0.1430598795413971,
-0.492379754781723,
0.0796273797750473,
-0.16319894790649414,
-0.6331799626350403,
-0.5149895548820496,
-0.12085255235433578,
0.45329976081848145,
0.20930303633213043,
0.03402160853147507,
-0.17861177027225494,
0.3427281081676483,
-0.42343631386756897,
0.35625702142715454,
0.6489700675010681,
-0.341704398393631,
0.3961212635040283,
-0.11080427467823029,
0.7320151329040527,
-0.37665051221847534,
0.217765212059021,
0.16563932597637177,
-0.12505728006362915,
-1.1786608695983887,
-0.24998457729816437,
0.3975570499897003,
0.4210774898529053,
-1.0536770820617676,
0.3174228370189667,
-0.3805706202983856,
-0.4668475091457367,
-0.26409992575645447,
-0.10984496027231216,
0.48116567730903625,
0.48371821641921997,
0.40063759684562683,
-0.10694814473390579,
-0.37807202339172363,
-1.038895606994629,
-0.06689276546239853,
-0.06945101916790009,
0.18395721912384033,
0.18295851349830627,
0.33739131689071655,
-0.2333025187253952,
0.8359076380729675,
-0.11955627053976059,
-0.17309162020683289,
-0.007023459766060114,
0.2462480068206787,
-0.13695545494556427,
0.3144685626029968,
0.7731155157089233,
-0.7087775468826294,
-0.7655543088912964,
0.016536058858036995,
-0.7696952223777771,
-0.3840042054653168,
0.04965153709053993,
-0.016354305669665337,
0.39087486267089844,
1.0002506971359253,
-0.0770949050784111,
0.2578071057796478,
0.6844461560249329,
0.037639547139406204,
0.2469266951084137,
-0.43307211995124817,
-0.18864856660366058,
-0.6852301955223083,
0.08068149536848068,
-0.03011142462491989,
-0.22925440967082977,
-0.9206339120864868,
0.0734754353761673,
0.11860916763544083,
0.18681874871253967,
-0.29096120595932007,
0.7995740175247192,
-0.6009132862091064,
0.00003276228380855173,
-0.4866304397583008,
0.1791621893644333,
-0.5420054793357849,
0.3835904896259308,
0.22484314441680908,
0.8423162698745728,
0.6540746688842773,
-0.513697624206543,
-0.3652983605861664,
0.3918897211551666,
-0.3373072147369385,
0.12624366581439972,
-0.06358148902654648,
-0.14295147359371185,
-0.36657941341400146,
-0.11368739604949951,
-0.8183808922767639,
-0.3848101794719696,
0.04032672196626663,
-0.027002276852726936,
0.5605525374412537,
-0.2960015833377838,
-0.2557518482208252,
-0.34378817677497864,
0.041557569056749344,
-0.07289323210716248,
0.4473980665206909,
-0.7902616262435913,
0.3971409499645233,
0.4375532865524292,
-0.44885581731796265,
-0.657010555267334,
-0.585725724697113,
0.4759955406188965,
-0.6237413883209229,
-0.3191816806793213,
0.20973244309425354,
-0.2310132086277008,
-0.3539080321788788,
-0.24205909669399261,
-0.022041672840714455,
-0.07077132165431976,
0.48232945799827576,
0.2784832715988159,
0.10620328038930893,
-0.14903612434864044,
0.49812498688697815,
-0.04626329243183136,
-0.06913846731185913,
-0.16799527406692505,
-0.2077779620885849,
0.4149892330169678,
-0.37587693333625793,
-0.16326268017292023,
0.11078839749097824,
0.5325167179107666,
0.5845035910606384,
-0.016248274594545364,
0.5525953769683838,
0.31591975688934326,
-0.24692212045192719,
-0.47943630814552307,
-0.41224998235702515,
-0.24345217645168304,
-0.4791368544101715,
0.3411409854888916,
-0.27475616335868835,
-0.8736537098884583,
0.22905460000038147,
-0.3553309142589569,
0.20883046090602875,
0.3189300000667572,
0.366396427154541,
0.15797242522239685,
0.6201498508453369,
0.9540890455245972,
0.2357456386089325,
0.7531037926673889,
-0.25568637251853943,
0.19436171650886536,
-0.6764954924583435,
0.04385863244533539,
-0.08170650899410248,
0.10711564123630524,
-0.589657723903656,
-0.12202518433332443,
0.895831286907196,
0.4105682969093323,
-0.10650549829006195,
0.20024296641349792,
-0.5444350242614746,
0.38631442189216614,
0.8216586112976074,
-0.00408907188102603,
0.20663288235664368,
0.1246042475104332,
0.06212698295712471,
0.028896892443299294,
-0.8294901251792908,
-0.9825001358985901,
0.9365543723106384,
0.09899783134460449,
0.5948888063430786,
-0.09589344263076782,
0.5914056301116943,
0.26032501459121704,
0.8683297634124756,
-0.9070200324058533,
0.40330591797828674,
-0.5242818593978882,
-0.40276601910591125,
-0.4733470678329468,
0.034720007330179214,
-0.8022242784500122,
0.3990958631038666,
-0.11690910905599594,
-0.47007477283477783,
0.021933740004897118,
0.24478201568126678,
-0.28743886947631836,
0.2649981379508972,
-0.6485077738761902,
0.47944843769073486,
-0.5144087076187134,
-0.11515810340642929,
0.29239702224731445,
-0.8503214716911316,
0.2739018499851227,
-0.39405956864356995,
0.2645883560180664,
-0.19234493374824524,
-0.07999452948570251,
0.6046769618988037,
-0.527748703956604,
0.8756567239761353,
-0.10019231587648392,
-0.19029490649700165,
0.21136075258255005,
0.022194381803274155,
0.3289685845375061,
-0.1615266501903534,
-0.3408622443675995,
0.11445575952529907,
-0.2804771363735199,
-0.13742364943027496,
-0.19648677110671997,
0.4832025468349457,
-0.5453439354896545,
-0.9143232703208923,
-0.23927468061447144,
-0.7368940711021423,
-0.48259973526000977,
-0.0052766818553209305,
0.3530551791191101,
0.2825997471809387,
-0.008112689480185509,
0.046952180564403534,
0.2908273935317993,
-0.006627620663493872,
0.8608392477035522,
0.39346787333488464,
-0.05004192888736725,
-0.3229922652244568,
0.6323682069778442,
0.4416404366493225,
0.7441608905792236,
0.2170257866382599,
0.2653571367263794,
-0.13872481882572174,
-0.8550155162811279,
-0.3721231520175934,
0.15524674952030182,
-1.1285929679870605,
-0.16004686057567596,
-0.8151916265487671,
-0.4232316315174103,
-0.009613770060241222,
-0.3850931227207184,
-0.07380951941013336,
-0.297908216714859,
-0.3791574239730835,
-0.153689906001091,
0.6267961263656616,
0.900932252407074,
-0.43288367986679077,
0.7980741858482361,
-0.399788498878479,
0.050560660660266876,
0.3887014389038086,
0.16339698433876038,
0.021451594308018684,
-0.5114807486534119,
-0.18871481716632843,
0.07660503685474396,
0.013684112578630447,
-0.31522321701049805,
0.7150834202766418,
0.4846631586551666,
0.5524504780769348,
0.09143807739019394,
0.07843193411827087,
0.6034408807754517,
-0.4000849425792694,
0.5738876461982727,
-0.12385612726211548,
-1.1041967868804932,
0.19365786015987396,
-0.5213958024978638,
0.12302099913358688,
0.49771299958229065,
0.7909778356552124,
-0.5510668158531189,
-0.681341290473938,
-0.4725269079208374,
-1.3508392572402954,
0.7270545959472656,
-0.003914299421012402,
0.35814324021339417,
-0.23971213400363922,
0.4713166058063507,
0.42114388942718506,
0.17105244100093842,
-1.0598121881484985,
-0.2169952094554901,
-0.11557445675134659,
-0.08648510277271271,
-0.18064042925834656,
-0.23293164372444153,
-0.0979001522064209,
0.04536949843168259,
0.8177642822265625,
-0.5988988876342773,
-0.4024907052516937,
0.16352424025535583,
-0.1738813817501068,
-0.13068467378616333,
0.19997985661029816,
0.4692661464214325,
0.6999035477638245,
-0.1940242201089859,
0.21447108685970306,
0.14773471653461456,
-0.3364783227443695,
-0.02207549475133419,
0.0767609030008316,
-0.44535836577415466,
-0.1633346527814865,
0.2626652717590332,
0.8474720120429993,
0.14128775894641876,
-0.7936464548110962,
0.5344022512435913,
0.10121986269950867,
-0.24799329042434692,
-0.3584577143192291,
-0.18738232553005219,
0.2725885808467865,
0.21589452028274536,
0.3629385530948639,
-0.07424193620681763,
-0.0034739032853394747,
-0.5192790031433105,
0.19544914364814758,
0.6009095311164856,
-0.4148363471031189,
0.005538356490433216,
0.7377598285675049,
0.05545556917786598,
-0.19752319157123566,
0.523775577545166,
-0.050584547221660614,
-0.5795271992683411,
0.5249232053756714,
0.6163427829742432,
0.7336587905883789,
-0.01423294935375452,
0.016759395599365234,
0.23535630106925964,
0.3931683301925659,
-0.2426004260778427,
0.09760159254074097,
0.0658794641494751,
-0.3553166091442108,
-0.19194944202899933,
-0.8238042593002319,
-0.547127366065979,
0.34378406405448914,
-0.5547713041305542,
0.3001331388950348,
-0.19991017878055573,
-0.12238850444555283,
0.11013034731149673,
-0.5987338423728943,
-0.26474547386169434,
0.1958952099084854,
0.5049746036529541,
0.7304157614707947,
-1.0643597841262817,
0.6456321477890015,
0.2636880576610565,
-0.4678667485713959,
-0.5947862267494202,
0.30287039279937744,
-0.40904390811920166,
-0.7001137733459473,
0.7954279184341431,
0.021413162350654602,
-0.1961255669593811,
0.10335186868906021,
-0.7010653018951416,
-1.1590352058410645,
0.6180139780044556,
0.5459631681442261,
-0.4904520809650421,
-0.17274583876132965,
0.07148639112710953,
0.8100263476371765,
-0.22994737327098846,
0.2833229899406433,
0.4436724781990051,
0.5344944596290588,
0.05347713828086853,
-1.1781483888626099,
-0.13680855929851532,
-0.1108015850186348,
0.122901551425457,
0.13482049107551575,
-0.6417474150657654,
1.0539849996566772,
-0.014341568574309349,
-0.37400299310684204,
0.27439022064208984,
0.34675875306129456,
-0.14265115559101105,
-0.116214320063591,
0.5538954734802246,
0.13137999176979065,
0.5848928689956665,
-0.15022151172161102,
1.0175271034240723,
-0.26100772619247437,
0.1610785871744156,
1.1556048393249512,
-0.18438611924648285,
0.7553849220275879,
0.38107267022132874,
0.09234276413917542,
0.15501517057418823,
0.7991442680358887,
0.1287330687046051,
0.5650947093963623,
0.5855618119239807,
-0.34335532784461975,
-0.38412490487098694,
-0.1604379415512085,
-0.021682636812329292,
0.6042490601539612,
0.6832607984542847,
-0.2304404228925705,
-0.444909930229187,
0.4964677691459656,
0.21372932195663452,
0.2592659890651703,
-0.3361516296863556,
0.8310768008232117,
0.05834643542766571,
-0.9466485381126404,
1.1686784029006958,
-0.39283719658851624,
1.0853384733200073,
-0.8274624943733215,
0.016170227900147438,
-0.18935580551624298,
0.023821067065000534,
-0.18645472824573517,
-0.6335805654525757,
0.3227127194404602,
-0.22205421328544617,
0.10793866962194443,
-0.4523867964744568,
0.3744758367538452,
-0.8318928480148315,
-0.1700357049703598,
0.6065090298652649,
0.6181619763374329,
0.3659147024154663,
0.062037136405706406,
-0.19119274616241455,
-0.5097243189811707,
-0.07635205239057541,
-0.2105114907026291,
0.24095866084098816,
0.2016378492116928,
-0.6112298965454102,
0.8888037800788879,
0.4052096903324127,
-0.014385851100087166,
0.4434884190559387,
0.17218239605426788,
0.8529900908470154,
-0.35473304986953735,
-0.10229673236608505,
-0.6630866527557373,
0.3420078456401825,
0.04868742823600769,
-0.3041240870952606,
0.7919238209724426,
0.5180987119674683,
0.8643272519111633,
-0.33400484919548035,
1.0904884338378906,
-0.127539724111557,
0.4102379381656647,
-0.5501821041107178,
0.6311176419258118,
-0.6689925193786621,
-0.048144057393074036,
-0.010228538885712624,
-0.6047754287719727,
-0.534777820110321,
0.1295461803674698,
-0.24177588522434235,
-0.11274401098489761,
0.5519285202026367,
0.7447630167007446,
-0.16349633038043976,
-0.19367431104183197,
0.5276310443878174,
0.10965162515640259,
0.3014734387397766,
0.30592209100723267,
1.0875009298324585,
-0.2240668386220932,
0.5392377376556396,
-0.27623438835144043,
-0.2380342036485672,
-0.34388816356658936,
-0.9724550843238831,
-0.8342148065567017,
-0.8555504679679871,
-0.1954449862241745,
-0.07903337478637695,
0.22953851521015167,
0.964687168598175,
0.8257659077644348,
-0.5863754153251648,
-0.46861574053764343,
-0.1231008842587471,
-0.3109786808490753,
0.02732994221150875,
-0.16750341653823853,
0.48078128695487976,
-0.5839468836784363,
-1.0235282182693481,
0.5920348763465881,
0.34784337878227234,
0.5586515665054321,
-0.19149258732795715,
0.24059785902500153,
-0.30614227056503296,
-0.07821307331323624,
0.606462299823761,
0.3841610252857208,
-0.983606219291687,
-0.3614957928657532,
-0.2656800448894501,
-0.14522844552993774,
0.2538343369960785,
0.4053504168987274,
-0.6051345467567444,
0.47470101714134216,
0.13797232508659363,
0.41911962628364563,
0.7056710124015808,
-0.062277939170598984,
0.46972301602363586,
-0.737712025642395,
0.1575363725423813,
0.4973142147064209,
0.44355496764183044,
0.601377546787262,
-0.23716653883457184,
0.8761123418807983,
-0.267124205827713,
-0.5652579069137573,
-0.6835052967071533,
0.13122239708900452,
-0.667724072933197,
-0.25944721698760986,
1.3729602098464966,
-0.15407848358154297,
-0.04963020235300064,
-0.13583925366401672,
-0.21188466250896454,
0.18388597667217255,
0.010289181023836136,
0.904526948928833,
0.4838412404060364,
-0.09725122153759003,
0.0467318557202816,
-0.7242223620414734,
0.8485884666442871,
0.2920672297477722,
-1.1382966041564941,
0.43609824776649475,
0.262614905834198,
0.4091958701610565,
0.24542135000228882,
0.5404996871948242,
0.2505427598953247,
-0.0108059486374259,
-0.07277553528547287,
0.29409322142601013,
0.20527692139148712,
-0.21879613399505615,
-0.34271806478500366,
0.0733526274561882,
0.31747427582740784,
0.3103237748146057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18880v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18880v1 | SSP: Self-Supervised Prompting for Cross-Lingual Transfer to Low-Resource Languages using Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T04:21:59 | 2024-06-27T04:21:59 | Vipul Rathore, Aniruddha Deb, Ankish Chandresh, Parag Singla, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, very large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional
performance on several English NLP tasks with just in-context learning (ICL),
but their utility in other languages is still underexplored. We investigate
their effectiveness for NLP tasks in low-resource languages (LRLs), especially
in the setting of zero-labelled cross-lingual transfer (0-CLT), where no
labelled training data for the target language is available -- however training
data from one or more related medium-resource languages (MRLs) is utilized,
alongside the available unlabeled test data for a target language. We introduce
Self-Supervised Prompting (SSP), a novel ICL approach tailored for the 0-CLT
setting.
SSP is based on the key observation that LLMs output more accurate labels if
in-context exemplars are from the target language (even if their labels are
slightly noisy). To operationalize this, since target language training data is
not available in 0-CLT, SSP operates in two stages. In Stage I, using source
MRL training data, target language's test data is noisily labeled. In Stage II,
these noisy test data points are used as exemplars in ICL for further improved
labelling. Additionally, our implementation of SSP uses a novel Integer Linear
Programming (ILP)-based exemplar selection that balances similarity, prediction
confidence (when available) and label coverage. Experiments on three tasks and
eleven LRLs (from three regions) demonstrate that SSP strongly outperforms
existing SOTA fine-tuned and prompting-based baselines in 0-CLT setup. | [
-0.34511882066726685,
-0.3694094717502594,
0.4606873691082001,
0.48816806077957153,
-0.15671813488006592,
-0.1353498101234436,
-0.5036601424217224,
-0.42632371187210083,
0.049476295709609985,
0.29467055201530457,
-0.6478744745254517,
-0.2828173041343689,
-0.2864609658718109,
0.3144843280315399,
-0.30665045976638794,
1.0842450857162476,
-0.04812487214803696,
0.09584973752498627,
-0.16761073470115662,
-0.07067620009183884,
-0.47985655069351196,
-0.4776689410209656,
-0.7557638883590698,
-0.3238549530506134,
0.4896724820137024,
0.6680793762207031,
0.20573128759860992,
0.40700387954711914,
0.0773610919713974,
0.16410741209983826,
-0.04846519976854324,
0.08924701064825058,
-0.3025898337364197,
0.2037457376718521,
-0.4745713770389557,
-0.27818334102630615,
-0.07015153020620346,
-0.0991673618555069,
0.7488421201705933,
0.783240556716919,
0.1386183798313141,
0.3928745687007904,
0.5193737745285034,
0.6109621524810791,
-0.6506339311599731,
0.16408982872962952,
-0.5704182982444763,
0.36145666241645813,
-0.1293129175901413,
-0.2827172577381134,
-0.6622198224067688,
0.13962523639202118,
-0.021681135520339012,
-0.3523094058036804,
0.05413336306810379,
0.03590869531035423,
0.47445622086524963,
0.37822288274765015,
-0.2961319386959076,
-0.2962965965270996,
-0.6186044812202454,
0.9098615050315857,
-0.656032145023346,
0.40833646059036255,
0.47730112075805664,
0.01429681945592165,
0.08933495730161667,
-0.49008989334106445,
-0.34598469734191895,
-0.42404842376708984,
-0.2061334103345871,
0.15818893909454346,
-0.02496189810335636,
-0.18212772905826569,
0.4118095338344574,
-0.08859717845916748,
-0.5403769016265869,
0.44818615913391113,
-0.39905640482902527,
-0.08652651309967041,
0.4682095944881439,
-0.17481787502765656,
0.19376184046268463,
-0.31747639179229736,
-0.731325626373291,
0.024064483121037483,
-0.7975506782531738,
0.28159719705581665,
-0.1732824295759201,
0.6960667967796326,
-0.37066367268562317,
0.4763507544994354,
-0.3362729549407959,
0.8348795175552368,
0.3132861852645874,
-0.029046760872006416,
-0.00006222788942977786,
-0.41059625148773193,
-0.10223152488470078,
0.29827001690864563,
0.7891235947608948,
0.11242315173149109,
0.28052765130996704,
-0.013454987667500973,
-0.18717323243618011,
-0.21511435508728027,
-0.30635586380958557,
-0.6126493811607361,
-0.06782007217407227,
0.02724933810532093,
-0.35607045888900757,
-0.0942564606666565,
-0.5378829836845398,
-0.5960710644721985,
0.007755879778414965,
-0.38239577412605286,
0.31297603249549866,
-0.4200761020183563,
-0.023993561044335365,
-0.07285917550325394,
0.3364052474498749,
0.13523933291435242,
0.22196531295776367,
-1.1768590211868286,
0.05367136001586914,
0.24003243446350098,
0.8594768643379211,
-0.535499632358551,
-0.5553556084632874,
-0.8926442861557007,
0.3538869023323059,
-0.45969557762145996,
0.7957395911216736,
-0.3711759150028229,
-0.20831498503684998,
-0.073445163667202,
-0.05271797999739647,
-0.2903252840042114,
-0.4274943470954895,
0.3371923267841339,
-0.2169305831193924,
0.18191172182559967,
-0.3835558593273163,
-0.47753503918647766,
0.2723654508590698,
0.27761411666870117,
-0.324093222618103,
1.2430830001831055,
0.10925017297267914,
-0.5061501264572144,
0.2680739164352417,
-0.5455727577209473,
-0.41781097650527954,
0.2749454379081726,
-0.3323502540588379,
0.06869955360889435,
0.05171694606542587,
0.4387364983558655,
0.7036108374595642,
-0.04687286540865898,
0.15992306172847748,
-0.2221105545759201,
-0.2877882421016693,
0.11153630167245865,
-0.5364825129508972,
0.8644404411315918,
0.27584710717201233,
-0.4043870270252228,
-0.06881878525018692,
-0.5104093551635742,
0.46000057458877563,
0.12328944355249405,
-0.30710503458976746,
-0.4219444990158081,
-0.48149144649505615,
-0.07393423467874527,
0.7286665439605713,
0.3506932854652405,
-0.4661691188812256,
0.3419915437698364,
-0.19255173206329346,
0.2472805380821228,
0.7480190992355347,
-0.2137126475572586,
0.5464534759521484,
-0.08828585594892502,
0.656713604927063,
-0.2366960197687149,
0.0538187250494957,
-0.25568875670433044,
-0.31404629349708557,
-0.639598548412323,
-0.2523469030857086,
0.370710551738739,
0.5952463746070862,
-1.0137042999267578,
0.22213856875896454,
-0.10794857144355774,
-0.24580411612987518,
-0.39980393648147583,
0.29201382398605347,
0.5512450933456421,
0.6814492344856262,
0.5199573040008545,
-0.1435045748949051,
-0.21875141561031342,
-0.8798443078994751,
-0.0903511568903923,
-0.20390337705612183,
-0.027986161410808563,
0.2902296185493469,
0.15843304991722107,
0.24320508539676666,
0.7584503889083862,
-0.1443418711423874,
-0.5565146803855896,
-0.5653060078620911,
0.20151212811470032,
0.19948165118694305,
0.5496992468833923,
0.5178207159042358,
-0.41384074091911316,
-1.1288503408432007,
-0.06439433991909027,
-0.616950511932373,
-0.5155167579650879,
-0.44927722215652466,
0.08075543493032455,
0.47839000821113586,
0.7619196176528931,
-0.4341944456100464,
0.14460094273090363,
0.8861464262008667,
-0.11901240795850754,
0.6147614121437073,
-0.31857556104660034,
-0.097529336810112,
-0.7992334365844727,
-0.01255613099783659,
-0.05481940135359764,
-0.23076577484607697,
-0.643796443939209,
-0.1710374802350998,
0.2308865338563919,
-0.15464083850383759,
-0.8459518551826477,
0.8556225895881653,
-0.6880016922950745,
-0.15988916158676147,
-0.1918851137161255,
0.08454595506191254,
-0.17266981303691864,
0.7155713438987732,
0.38213106989860535,
0.7899243831634521,
0.617821455001831,
-0.4806751012802124,
-0.07860428094863892,
0.1571119725704193,
-0.21648909151554108,
0.8448760509490967,
-0.37344416975975037,
0.12542961537837982,
-0.03635462746024132,
0.24525250494480133,
-0.9158207774162292,
0.12080270051956177,
0.26155930757522583,
-0.1709076166152954,
0.42678332328796387,
-0.4438077211380005,
-0.3756498396396637,
-0.08532550930976868,
0.058445654809474945,
0.4340176582336426,
0.38265013694763184,
-0.7676777243614197,
0.22649139165878296,
0.04197096452116966,
-0.4483410120010376,
-0.5135434865951538,
-0.7533470392227173,
0.1632181704044342,
-0.12490501999855042,
-0.2543267607688904,
0.21826040744781494,
-0.2637394368648529,
0.19177904725074768,
-0.10011683404445648,
-0.09639117121696472,
-0.08545012772083282,
-0.12321929633617401,
0.061138007789850235,
0.2738282382488251,
-0.15418791770935059,
0.20533964037895203,
0.039141129702329636,
-0.36630988121032715,
-0.06501585245132446,
-0.23238354921340942,
0.5897074341773987,
-0.2988739013671875,
-0.5828115344047546,
-0.6081703305244446,
0.396961510181427,
0.04561278596520424,
-0.24161803722381592,
0.42483025789260864,
0.5605336427688599,
-0.06616468727588654,
-0.5140811204910278,
-0.2569102346897125,
-0.2494783252477646,
-0.4331575930118561,
0.15789230167865753,
-0.4874694347381592,
-0.8618144392967224,
0.15216484665870667,
-0.0766119509935379,
0.04773677885532379,
0.2122795581817627,
0.45158734917640686,
-0.20101074874401093,
1.0936243534088135,
0.5545133352279663,
-0.22962215542793274,
0.5631371140480042,
-0.12954933941364288,
0.12932397425174713,
-0.7896720170974731,
0.025864312425255775,
-0.43512970209121704,
-0.2553987205028534,
-0.4453791379928589,
-0.5074862837791443,
0.3557821214199066,
0.11069250851869583,
0.040879011154174805,
0.3541255593299866,
-0.49263399839401245,
0.649649977684021,
0.6732181906700134,
-0.1724819391965866,
0.2698651850223541,
0.11825808137655258,
-0.17057986557483673,
-0.3084874451160431,
-1.083961844444275,
-0.1311759501695633,
0.8059368133544922,
0.18627572059631348,
0.8538586497306824,
-0.24176831543445587,
0.8829513788223267,
0.24853351712226868,
0.24110762774944305,
-0.6540963053703308,
0.6742951273918152,
-0.2395446002483368,
-0.39029860496520996,
-0.5966938138008118,
-0.2635887563228607,
-0.9548552632331848,
0.285200297832489,
-0.1906055063009262,
-0.8347468972206116,
0.33407026529312134,
0.2505227029323578,
-0.5051686763763428,
0.16905425488948822,
-0.6130174398422241,
0.6612018942832947,
-0.5240461230278015,
-0.4216598570346832,
-0.013727255165576935,
-0.5699837803840637,
0.1878015547990799,
-0.16281063854694366,
0.19086666405200958,
-0.20608758926391602,
0.03356654569506645,
0.45004552602767944,
0.053322091698646545,
1.0322169065475464,
-0.1996069848537445,
-0.20259684324264526,
0.11451029032468796,
0.2887333631515503,
0.7375621795654297,
-0.17738214135169983,
-0.0007852569688111544,
0.16694173216819763,
0.1742454618215561,
-0.3085794746875763,
-0.539155125617981,
0.8125896453857422,
-0.3829724192619324,
-0.39485296607017517,
-0.413635790348053,
-0.7310250401496887,
-0.3316042125225067,
0.28988319635391235,
0.2405337542295456,
0.27507200837135315,
0.30118823051452637,
0.34641358256340027,
0.6218960881233215,
-0.2466896027326584,
0.5095898509025574,
0.7562959790229797,
-0.20740775763988495,
0.09314049035310745,
1.0526779890060425,
0.36644068360328674,
0.5776521563529968,
0.2346142828464508,
0.3155427575111389,
-0.40698978304862976,
-0.4855285882949829,
-0.7454686164855957,
0.20282454788684845,
-0.6899185180664062,
-0.17131918668746948,
-0.5774100422859192,
-0.3761923313140869,
-0.4321306347846985,
-0.4614134430885315,
-0.5763073563575745,
-0.5105873942375183,
-0.10448741912841797,
0.15867692232131958,
-0.06534411758184433,
0.47447365522384644,
-0.4882615804672241,
0.15563905239105225,
-0.6577128767967224,
0.2447412759065628,
0.33566293120384216,
0.17881785333156586,
-0.0835743173956871,
-0.7545968890190125,
-0.30815616250038147,
-0.09070037305355072,
0.20382462441921234,
-0.7942069172859192,
0.5884462594985962,
0.241205096244812,
0.5007646083831787,
0.16832704842090607,
0.43256375193595886,
0.6703562140464783,
-0.46555590629577637,
0.7119969129562378,
0.15084421634674072,
-0.8727880716323853,
0.5780142545700073,
-0.2313113957643509,
0.6229129433631897,
0.5705546736717224,
0.4637922942638397,
-0.7536004185676575,
-0.5023914575576782,
-0.5937568545341492,
-0.8235809206962585,
0.9152422547340393,
-0.10325971245765686,
0.03129463642835617,
-0.06272129714488983,
0.08987611532211304,
0.01973632164299488,
-0.05726822838187218,
-1.0001083612442017,
-0.19224852323532104,
0.07387439906597137,
-0.13314814865589142,
0.08759945631027222,
-0.20388518273830414,
-0.04819567874073982,
-0.011470558121800423,
0.7685866951942444,
-0.5540575981140137,
-0.061565227806568146,
0.4118453562259674,
-0.19168059527873993,
-0.08042358607053757,
0.46186816692352295,
0.32131093740463257,
0.4838446080684662,
0.03862760215997696,
0.17852306365966797,
0.5897796154022217,
0.016972772777080536,
0.2813817858695984,
0.07709427922964096,
-0.48680588603019714,
-0.12560473382472992,
0.3981543183326721,
0.6085087656974792,
0.427268385887146,
-0.5790464878082275,
0.5279917120933533,
0.06382055580615997,
0.055973783135414124,
-0.2326403558254242,
-0.04150275141000748,
-0.02786402404308319,
0.23388104140758514,
0.32796186208724976,
-0.2485131323337555,
0.1132705807685852,
-0.3094562292098999,
0.21051494777202606,
0.4559394419193268,
-0.6168175935745239,
-0.22644144296646118,
0.5016689896583557,
0.020670780912041664,
-0.1054162085056305,
0.6050217151641846,
-0.2793141007423401,
-0.24437594413757324,
0.4422394335269928,
0.9306296110153198,
0.5569030046463013,
-0.35551562905311584,
0.48789697885513306,
0.43676403164863586,
0.3150395452976227,
-0.024518899619579315,
0.15707187354564667,
-0.44570112228393555,
-0.6651844382286072,
-0.8208079934120178,
-0.44820550084114075,
-0.5058069229125977,
0.2960704267024994,
-0.8058531880378723,
0.19456006586551666,
-0.3985745310783386,
0.2605303227901459,
-0.06161252409219742,
-0.13234056532382965,
-0.6852784752845764,
0.1998315006494522,
0.43419742584228516,
0.9067928791046143,
-1.1101326942443848,
1.0207223892211914,
0.601477324962616,
-0.12675423920154572,
-0.9015942811965942,
-0.1822848618030548,
-0.002080007456243038,
-0.9625928401947021,
0.9172810912132263,
0.12099871039390564,
-0.09010254591703415,
0.18021123111248016,
-0.6689773797988892,
-1.1125099658966064,
0.7566874027252197,
0.4143930971622467,
-0.6994368433952332,
0.06421705335378647,
0.24708427488803864,
0.5182428359985352,
-0.38362231850624084,
0.00495882099494338,
0.3539515435695648,
0.45683300495147705,
0.2007886916399002,
-0.9689781665802002,
0.2541695833206177,
-0.026659106835722923,
-0.08173025399446487,
-0.12228157371282578,
-0.7679275274276733,
0.5766221284866333,
-0.28405866026878357,
-0.19671012461185455,
-0.06764194369316101,
0.8122844696044922,
0.5244645476341248,
0.1583615392446518,
0.7654040455818176,
0.14920148253440857,
0.5783222317695618,
0.20559589564800262,
0.8784685730934143,
-0.49610185623168945,
0.12763744592666626,
1.4632474184036255,
-0.44725796580314636,
0.9538944363594055,
0.7707041501998901,
-0.0700339749455452,
0.18574565649032593,
0.5897117853164673,
0.0889253318309784,
0.44059649109840393,
-0.05400100350379944,
-0.19506219029426575,
-0.4272899925708771,
-0.6004233956336975,
-0.3121662735939026,
0.46817830204963684,
0.23032739758491516,
-0.1691460758447647,
-0.3890906870365143,
0.16100969910621643,
-0.04096503555774689,
-0.15726633369922638,
-0.27822718024253845,
0.5484588146209717,
0.1970457136631012,
-0.8225550055503845,
0.6263822317123413,
-0.32626914978027344,
0.611487865447998,
-0.8060539364814758,
-0.04905422031879425,
-0.2568802237510681,
-0.06812451779842377,
-0.13266468048095703,
-0.9695895910263062,
0.17254270613193512,
-0.14292462170124054,
-0.023092573508620262,
-0.8548954129219055,
0.8318803906440735,
-0.833877444267273,
-0.319202721118927,
0.4609350860118866,
0.6404409408569336,
0.409565806388855,
0.04580559954047203,
-0.8712456226348877,
-0.23474569618701935,
0.23284165561199188,
-0.2736247181892395,
0.7712161540985107,
0.4404934048652649,
-0.2695256471633911,
0.8318889737129211,
0.7966464757919312,
0.3935333788394928,
-0.05225913226604462,
0.1844346523284912,
0.6476966142654419,
-0.6086150407791138,
-0.5760000944137573,
-0.55908203125,
0.34977811574935913,
0.09230176359415054,
-0.2189805656671524,
0.8982856273651123,
0.39342546463012695,
0.9972332119941711,
-0.05062050372362137,
0.7972770929336548,
-0.13116192817687988,
0.6055229306221008,
-0.6715786457061768,
0.4416317641735077,
-0.6148059964179993,
0.202861487865448,
-0.01319583598524332,
-0.7023399472236633,
-0.09759873151779175,
0.5832668542861938,
-0.2443045824766159,
-0.1358657032251358,
0.6397903561592102,
0.6547079086303711,
-0.06426198780536652,
-0.28419822454452515,
0.6614124178886414,
0.09984657168388367,
0.07780185341835022,
0.5822374224662781,
0.8108010292053223,
0.16572009027004242,
0.6384798288345337,
-0.5703501105308533,
-0.28094545006752014,
-0.19518664479255676,
-0.9996911287307739,
-0.843127965927124,
-0.6152501106262207,
-0.2579525113105774,
-0.24005015194416046,
0.004769813735038042,
1.1404809951782227,
0.7597028017044067,
-0.8450831770896912,
-0.329057514667511,
0.354905366897583,
0.06523872911930084,
-0.4330749213695526,
-0.21438954770565033,
0.4854344427585602,
-0.7495194673538208,
-0.8726391792297363,
0.8151271343231201,
0.3703071177005768,
0.2166983038187027,
-0.5358960032463074,
0.020458318293094635,
-0.20813782513141632,
-0.2430964708328247,
0.6561568975448608,
0.6555781364440918,
-0.4409640431404114,
-0.1849534958600998,
-0.02376898005604744,
-0.21928060054779053,
-0.06002308800816536,
0.599865198135376,
-0.7487276196479797,
0.361355185508728,
0.45285749435424805,
0.5972052216529846,
0.5931330919265747,
-0.15667694807052612,
0.5371840596199036,
-0.9491258263587952,
0.23724301159381866,
0.20182248950004578,
0.21218717098236084,
0.37809956073760986,
-0.5107400417327881,
0.6887170672416687,
0.007438171189278364,
-0.5336445569992065,
-0.7974879741668701,
0.25068190693855286,
-0.7127871513366699,
-0.33271926641464233,
1.2703416347503662,
-0.2191004604101181,
-0.2255643904209137,
-0.15670821070671082,
-0.14927788078784943,
-0.10698813199996948,
-0.35982421040534973,
0.7757329940795898,
0.5133297443389893,
-0.42690029740333557,
-0.3349483013153076,
-0.7020109295845032,
0.6265956163406372,
0.8394319415092468,
-0.6804113984107971,
0.11720091104507446,
0.3520076870918274,
0.22267331182956696,
0.17646436393260956,
1.0101076364517212,
0.1458018720149994,
0.11864857375621796,
-0.35319119691848755,
0.1011987030506134,
-0.013290389440953732,
-0.5147272348403931,
-0.4731636047363281,
-0.017006123438477516,
-0.05093725770711899,
-0.018946321681141853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18871v1 | DeSTA: Enhancing Speech Language Models through Descriptive Speech-Text Alignment | 2024-06-27T03:52:35 | 2024-06-27T03:52:35 | Ke-Han Lu, Zhehuai Chen, Szu-Wei Fu, He Huang, Boris Ginsburg, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Hung-yi Lee | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Recent speech language models (SLMs) typically incorporate pre-trained speech
models to extend the capabilities from large language models (LLMs). In this
paper, we propose a Descriptive Speech-Text Alignment approach that leverages
speech captioning to bridge the gap between speech and text modalities,
enabling SLMs to interpret and generate comprehensive natural language
descriptions, thereby facilitating the capability to understand both linguistic
and non-linguistic features in speech. Enhanced with the proposed approach, our
model demonstrates superior performance on the Dynamic-SUPERB benchmark,
particularly in generalizing to unseen tasks. Moreover, we discover that the
aligned model exhibits a zero-shot instruction-following capability without
explicit speech instruction tuning. These findings highlight the potential to
reshape instruction-following SLMs by incorporating rich, descriptive speech
captions. | [
-0.00427805632352829,
-0.5010185241699219,
0.4535458981990814,
-0.14770950376987457,
-0.4603478014469147,
0.4755733907222748,
-0.0788637176156044,
-0.38385090231895447,
0.3721885085105896,
0.8074223399162292,
-0.4976241886615753,
-0.534307062625885,
-0.5698661804199219,
-0.05666044354438782,
-0.6460167765617371,
1.1580462455749512,
-0.001984940143302083,
-0.06925082206726074,
-0.3055284023284912,
0.07713785767555237,
-0.8813124895095825,
-0.32946524024009705,
-0.32985419034957886,
-0.23471792042255402,
0.5054124593734741,
0.16876059770584106,
0.8975130915641785,
1.0180469751358032,
0.7161057591438293,
0.28292515873908997,
0.06637004017829895,
0.1986231654882431,
-0.1745639145374298,
0.36723703145980835,
-0.17238689959049225,
-0.3676237463951111,
-0.7437873482704163,
-0.18647132813930511,
0.9401969909667969,
0.5205342173576355,
-0.09166111052036285,
0.08895362913608551,
0.012700569815933704,
0.4560161232948303,
-0.45482876896858215,
0.21253277361392975,
-0.7856355905532837,
-0.2195819914340973,
-0.18708597123622894,
-0.2828497290611267,
-0.4236777424812317,
-0.2602267563343048,
0.38816797733306885,
-0.4830610156059265,
0.0824589803814888,
-0.21901099383831024,
0.9444479942321777,
0.6807608604431152,
-0.2866224944591522,
0.004279115237295628,
-0.9066961407661438,
0.8562711477279663,
-0.9352394342422485,
0.23106662929058075,
0.11819537729024887,
0.6149465441703796,
0.17536254227161407,
-0.4825421869754791,
-0.45964184403419495,
-0.1734490692615509,
-0.21162134408950806,
0.04378120228648186,
-0.17584331333637238,
0.19886165857315063,
-0.02258164808154106,
0.29974764585494995,
-0.6415072679519653,
0.43976113200187683,
-0.2154039740562439,
-0.12230487167835236,
0.7129917740821838,
0.3940768837928772,
0.4953487515449524,
-0.04983922839164734,
-0.5124302506446838,
0.12439725548028946,
-0.5234917998313904,
-0.15338079631328583,
0.201239675283432,
0.8212120532989502,
-0.5139514803886414,
0.6305832266807556,
-0.05128035694360733,
1.137478232383728,
-0.09772629290819168,
-0.1945214569568634,
0.13968844711780548,
-0.44605398178100586,
-0.3478158712387085,
0.5375351905822754,
0.4916025400161743,
0.3384876251220703,
0.1975579708814621,
-0.13182584941387177,
-0.29729506373405457,
0.12210220098495483,
0.4927416443824768,
-0.5629794001579285,
-0.009625833481550217,
0.011717218905687332,
-0.1064879521727562,
-0.4534333348274231,
-0.05892297625541687,
-0.8763487935066223,
-0.5204499363899231,
-0.7390731573104858,
0.5047376155853271,
-0.1940942108631134,
-0.2026791125535965,
0.08290737122297287,
0.15801677107810974,
0.3901236951351166,
0.20596112310886383,
-1.039589285850525,
0.4402099549770355,
0.7783264517784119,
0.7392041683197021,
-0.14147767424583435,
-0.05892132222652435,
-0.7055737376213074,
0.5339310765266418,
-0.29642972350120544,
0.5688096880912781,
-0.8567180037498474,
0.15991993248462677,
0.12531980872154236,
-0.09051807969808578,
-0.2134980857372284,
-0.29279908537864685,
0.31174415349960327,
-0.44313567876815796,
0.31017565727233887,
0.19798576831817627,
-0.6092782020568848,
-0.32895663380622864,
0.14205233752727509,
-0.6756170392036438,
0.566758394241333,
0.00472741574048996,
-0.6021121740341187,
-0.08325881510972977,
-0.6136112809181213,
-0.44844353199005127,
0.1522805243730545,
-0.4442942142486572,
-0.3885733485221863,
0.298164039850235,
0.23624280095100403,
0.26461857557296753,
-0.11119376868009567,
0.4648832678794861,
0.15964683890342712,
-0.5193603038787842,
0.27036333084106445,
-0.5388587117195129,
0.41147610545158386,
0.14414101839065552,
-0.4796659052371979,
0.3612460196018219,
-0.7464863657951355,
0.048165541142225266,
0.002065427368506789,
0.1065395176410675,
-0.20539391040802002,
0.021886290982365608,
-0.15880966186523438,
-0.1409146934747696,
0.5810708999633789,
-0.2641669511795044,
0.15587100386619568,
-0.7128250598907471,
0.509196400642395,
0.4498600959777832,
-0.33813798427581787,
0.5782658457756042,
-0.2800522446632385,
1.0018771886825562,
-0.2554306089878082,
-0.15120744705200195,
-0.5239707827568054,
-0.07565052807331085,
-0.4860192537307739,
-0.34932589530944824,
0.5875917673110962,
0.6851697564125061,
-0.5191313624382019,
0.364552766084671,
-0.5687502026557922,
-0.38352659344673157,
-0.815754234790802,
-0.10828938335180283,
0.782244861125946,
0.6472659111022949,
0.42976823449134827,
0.026612678542733192,
-0.8399903178215027,
-1.0030982494354248,
0.006728074047714472,
0.058596208691596985,
0.16199427843093872,
0.03905942291021347,
-0.015515749342739582,
-0.10255733132362366,
0.7938272356987,
-0.3991285562515259,
-0.4729512929916382,
-0.4598165452480316,
-0.14846278727054596,
0.07130327820777893,
0.37378954887390137,
0.2981262505054474,
-0.6862098574638367,
-0.6238953471183777,
0.16299442946910858,
-0.5371176600456238,
-0.3286993205547333,
-0.10545750707387924,
0.05980530381202698,
0.40734755992889404,
0.4294142723083496,
-0.6232997179031372,
0.21761175990104675,
0.6224930286407471,
-0.0623728446662426,
0.4366856515407562,
-0.05179256573319435,
0.02272527478635311,
-1.1962288618087769,
0.027415787801146507,
-0.13818170130252838,
-0.19806714355945587,
-0.8775190711021423,
0.09787879884243011,
-0.22048602998256683,
-0.19874562323093414,
-0.3954482078552246,
0.430287629365921,
-0.4608615040779114,
-0.21191160380840302,
-0.5923487544059753,
0.5857882499694824,
0.18276049196720123,
0.12398019433021545,
0.33097460865974426,
0.721097469329834,
0.8091247081756592,
-0.2953440248966217,
0.2571784257888794,
0.25089144706726074,
-0.17230355739593506,
0.3727192282676697,
-0.5956215858459473,
-0.06637246161699295,
-0.26081034541130066,
0.026867974549531937,
-1.2069306373596191,
-0.3062911927700043,
0.11244107037782669,
-0.40918266773223877,
0.7717806696891785,
-0.0708836168050766,
-0.22972449660301208,
-0.06333097815513611,
-0.12462522089481354,
0.3658866286277771,
0.512382984161377,
-0.19269590079784393,
0.6445635557174683,
0.39512863755226135,
-0.4393894672393799,
-0.7381603717803955,
-0.7004508972167969,
0.2499462217092514,
-0.5331571698188782,
-0.19706833362579346,
0.700608491897583,
0.3729598820209503,
-0.31355834007263184,
-0.09417847543954849,
-0.2392144501209259,
-0.21662336587905884,
-0.10699419677257538,
0.03952166065573692,
0.5613352656364441,
-0.4832460284233093,
0.25843170285224915,
0.09025194495916367,
-0.11490075290203094,
-0.17231234908103943,
-0.05902351066470146,
0.6876083016395569,
0.05273553356528282,
-0.009526723064482212,
-1.0290489196777344,
0.30296045541763306,
0.5937329530715942,
-0.4593757688999176,
0.5126842856407166,
0.2926434576511383,
-0.4220074713230133,
0.1695001870393753,
-0.3374253213405609,
-0.13570787012577057,
-0.4009949862957001,
0.41617441177368164,
-0.19470609724521637,
-0.6180174946784973,
0.2566404938697815,
0.3688444197177887,
0.2230842262506485,
0.23810234665870667,
0.15071652829647064,
-0.36584532260894775,
1.1584100723266602,
0.7154229283332825,
-0.11408736556768417,
0.5228345394134521,
0.12991546094417572,
0.3248521089553833,
-0.6252471804618835,
-0.11743596941232681,
-0.5429257154464722,
-0.38649922609329224,
-0.4879351258277893,
-0.2587657570838928,
-0.08228645473718643,
0.009820081293582916,
-0.33820974826812744,
0.6889472007751465,
-0.7931467890739441,
0.43958574533462524,
0.24347639083862305,
-0.1326398402452469,
0.233939990401268,
0.09614792466163635,
0.2786824107170105,
-0.4407441020011902,
-0.46707481145858765,
-0.9688581824302673,
0.6904233694076538,
0.34624430537223816,
0.7790515422821045,
0.12862065434455872,
0.7858735918998718,
0.1938677877187729,
0.04961378499865532,
-0.7375710606575012,
0.5138198733329773,
-0.5758858323097229,
-0.368775874376297,
-0.4341411590576172,
-0.22520631551742554,
-0.7321966886520386,
0.10685466229915619,
-0.07831056416034698,
-0.6367098689079285,
-0.45648664236068726,
0.2966243624687195,
-0.7065337300300598,
0.057090580463409424,
-0.6347607970237732,
0.8498411178588867,
-0.5509597063064575,
0.05305793508887291,
-0.1113390102982521,
-0.7178537845611572,
0.3070316016674042,
-0.039153166115283966,
0.2171621322631836,
-0.11548812687397003,
-0.3479250967502594,
0.5965058207511902,
-0.14343687891960144,
1.1635725498199463,
-0.23323170840740204,
-0.44945383071899414,
0.3014947175979614,
0.01981828361749649,
0.3307989835739136,
-0.5171273350715637,
0.09913097321987152,
-0.1586911380290985,
0.07999366521835327,
-0.2364586591720581,
-0.7543622851371765,
0.7424119710922241,
-0.48010361194610596,
-0.7263932824134827,
-0.20018357038497925,
-0.7943669557571411,
-0.28382933139801025,
0.1629832684993744,
-0.17637386918067932,
0.7404229044914246,
0.09949270635843277,
-0.036701008677482605,
0.5652402639389038,
-0.3097882866859436,
0.4680813252925873,
0.5778241157531738,
-0.30817294120788574,
-0.5161064267158508,
0.9416729807853699,
0.04603786766529083,
0.48203521966934204,
0.9151506423950195,
0.10841101408004761,
-0.8091142773628235,
-0.6836580634117126,
-0.5104442238807678,
0.28386202454566956,
-0.25044363737106323,
-0.34709399938583374,
-0.5042034983634949,
-0.36295557022094727,
-0.6361029148101807,
-0.11202231049537659,
-0.3996891975402832,
-0.5725705027580261,
-0.41046276688575745,
-0.18873469531536102,
0.30927878618240356,
0.6113240122795105,
0.25660449266433716,
0.7646990418434143,
-0.8743165731430054,
0.3301789164543152,
0.05017245560884476,
0.274699866771698,
-0.005373799707740545,
-0.9329967498779297,
-0.07222563773393631,
0.3181537985801697,
-0.4584711492061615,
-0.8376109004020691,
0.5113585591316223,
0.29523909091949463,
0.5694555640220642,
0.3228474259376526,
0.1554468274116516,
0.9255962371826172,
-0.6891776323318481,
0.7987574338912964,
0.3438488245010376,
-0.8770352005958557,
0.7671887874603271,
-0.4732026755809784,
0.38658133149147034,
0.40388381481170654,
0.30336976051330566,
-0.1423025131225586,
-0.5698524713516235,
-0.32013532519340515,
-0.5637375116348267,
0.49368661642074585,
-0.0327460952103138,
0.4739323854446411,
0.1954827457666397,
0.2902776598930359,
0.1360214203596115,
0.21112069487571716,
-0.7044798135757446,
-0.07826138287782669,
-0.19953982532024384,
-0.7096158266067505,
-0.15561670064926147,
-0.2198808342218399,
-0.16846249997615814,
-0.09353410452604294,
0.6662694811820984,
0.011236880905926228,
0.059816230088472366,
-0.10900026559829712,
-0.0008323505171574652,
0.07005279511213303,
0.5033506155014038,
1.0155311822891235,
0.6454599499702454,
-0.02467849664390087,
0.41791263222694397,
-0.12745827436447144,
-0.13827569782733917,
0.20146262645721436,
0.36402538418769836,
-0.15084217488765717,
0.09155219793319702,
0.3769366145133972,
0.8440960645675659,
0.5391656160354614,
-0.8242341876029968,
0.39190682768821716,
0.24888388812541962,
0.026405945420265198,
-0.14786937832832336,
0.0781015157699585,
0.14492332935333252,
0.17757491767406464,
0.14367996156215668,
-0.3265553414821625,
-0.04620649665594101,
-0.3658348619937897,
0.346587210893631,
0.5242091417312622,
-0.6986663937568665,
-0.3144570589065552,
0.9145492315292358,
0.2038957178592682,
-0.5283833742141724,
0.29083073139190674,
0.2678707242012024,
-0.27834105491638184,
0.5322070121765137,
0.7494056224822998,
0.8451561331748962,
-0.2844688594341278,
0.44575628638267517,
0.16889473795890808,
0.07429680973291397,
0.2113610804080963,
0.2337595671415329,
-0.044312696903944016,
-0.438488245010376,
-0.6940747499465942,
-0.6604189872741699,
-0.18480464816093445,
0.20005489885807037,
-0.8491032719612122,
0.4114395081996918,
-0.11798118054866791,
-0.05987820029258728,
0.1899368315935135,
-0.09227211773395538,
-0.14482147991657257,
0.12280671298503876,
0.4303363561630249,
0.6230484247207642,
-0.8140641450881958,
0.8516885638237,
0.6475518941879272,
-0.3585297167301178,
-0.6469264626502991,
-0.10701927542686462,
-0.08658403903245926,
-0.7578431963920593,
0.4625101387500763,
0.47031721472740173,
-0.22423385083675385,
0.11722265183925629,
-0.31761258840560913,
-0.8473703265190125,
0.9156127572059631,
0.6636888384819031,
-0.9351653456687927,
-0.2169647216796875,
0.43093517422676086,
0.7951235175132751,
-0.6491310596466064,
-0.045092180371284485,
0.5778160095214844,
0.22071827948093414,
0.08323489874601364,
-1.1306706666946411,
-0.06308038532733917,
0.2190628945827484,
0.035383425652980804,
0.2761245369911194,
-0.30701497197151184,
0.37926986813545227,
-0.25282320380210876,
-0.4042013883590698,
0.4218945801258087,
0.6368219256401062,
0.16320250928401947,
0.2812916040420532,
0.3336992561817169,
0.6198302507400513,
0.48737579584121704,
0.03304498642683029,
0.6993935108184814,
-0.16598725318908691,
-0.034415245056152344,
1.78422212600708,
-0.45214247703552246,
0.9500280618667603,
0.482221782207489,
-0.08256105333566666,
0.6168563365936279,
0.31949618458747864,
0.10720355063676834,
0.7653666138648987,
0.16665546596050262,
-0.39084509015083313,
-0.21679814159870148,
-0.4742332398891449,
-0.32329338788986206,
0.7921704053878784,
0.033828649669885635,
-0.612525463104248,
-0.48063698410987854,
-0.034519992768764496,
-0.27183768153190613,
0.810427188873291,
-0.44929492473602295,
0.9541211128234863,
-0.019789867103099823,
-0.585566520690918,
0.7573116421699524,
-0.3762953579425812,
0.5633123517036438,
-0.42386358976364136,
-0.19918237626552582,
0.16266945004463196,
-0.017465228214859962,
-0.26172131299972534,
-0.8040115237236023,
0.708897590637207,
0.23057110607624054,
-0.34599360823631287,
-0.2923799157142639,
0.38791462779045105,
-0.718181848526001,
-0.3644612729549408,
0.06639395654201508,
0.2580718398094177,
0.3484154939651489,
0.18246333301067352,
-0.5164153575897217,
0.20624007284641266,
0.044160738587379456,
0.46385684609413147,
0.24423907697200775,
0.12114667147397995,
-0.0672660693526268,
0.46358171105384827,
0.019319264218211174,
0.03802287578582764,
0.17431189119815826,
0.43761175870895386,
0.40101394057273865,
-0.7157117128372192,
-0.3790879249572754,
-1.0981744527816772,
0.585107684135437,
0.08201497048139572,
0.08368445932865143,
0.4478757083415985,
0.6979644894599915,
0.6696114540100098,
-0.1681182086467743,
0.7215345501899719,
0.09634659439325333,
0.7550796270370483,
-0.44018682837486267,
0.4491529166698456,
-0.3982359766960144,
0.19553253054618835,
-0.1601318120956421,
-0.8670238852500916,
-0.37763848900794983,
0.30663472414016724,
-0.25216203927993774,
-0.31336191296577454,
0.19519998133182526,
0.8229781985282898,
0.14137113094329834,
-0.0766139104962349,
0.38970252871513367,
0.009944853372871876,
0.2219095677137375,
0.2910710573196411,
0.8717809915542603,
-0.4175485670566559,
0.6686623692512512,
-0.14540420472621918,
-0.12986670434474945,
0.19912484288215637,
-0.9782530069351196,
-0.6728125810623169,
-0.4792898893356323,
-0.5925912261009216,
0.10288054496049881,
-0.09972596913576126,
0.5724843740463257,
0.512252151966095,
-0.8024882674217224,
-0.11907365173101425,
-0.1658819317817688,
-0.005362577270716429,
-0.34465470910072327,
-0.3053540885448456,
0.23199522495269775,
-0.5727002620697021,
-0.9969403147697449,
0.5232312083244324,
0.2614081799983978,
0.5302887558937073,
-0.2753852903842926,
0.07755312323570251,
-0.017916394397616386,
0.10167522728443146,
0.48329290747642517,
0.08267572522163391,
-1.0553077459335327,
-0.16863541305065155,
-0.061184149235486984,
-0.1484290063381195,
0.004489328246563673,
0.5114120841026306,
-0.6636804938316345,
0.41416460275650024,
0.28000620007514954,
0.8237802386283875,
0.07047605514526367,
0.3430200517177582,
0.7075445055961609,
-0.6939225792884827,
-0.10329439491033554,
0.3495549261569977,
0.025940118357539177,
0.4092203378677368,
-0.25283610820770264,
0.22900015115737915,
-0.38284793496131897,
-0.356388121843338,
-1.0674107074737549,
0.3039773106575012,
-1.3370236158370972,
0.04448169842362404,
0.9384545087814331,
-0.01628628373146057,
0.17034262418746948,
0.2094171643257141,
-0.3324267268180847,
0.38886505365371704,
-0.13751359283924103,
0.8392896056175232,
0.4980541467666626,
-0.09323533624410629,
-0.37726420164108276,
-0.6385151743888855,
0.3713943064212799,
0.4046638309955597,
-0.6055476069450378,
0.39712950587272644,
0.4346695840358734,
0.15377628803253174,
0.13324616849422455,
0.3585506081581116,
-0.4734485447406769,
0.1303645670413971,
-0.3463011085987091,
-0.06307289749383926,
-0.09300881624221802,
-0.4737635850906372,
-0.7383044362068176,
-0.13640651106834412,
0.00872876588255167,
-0.6364755034446716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18872v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18872v1 | Efficacy of Language Model Self-Play in Non-Zero-Sum Games | 2024-06-27T03:52:35 | 2024-06-27T03:52:35 | Austen Liao, Nicholas Tomlin, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Game-playing agents like AlphaGo have achieved superhuman performance through
self-play, which is theoretically guaranteed to yield optimal policies in
competitive games. However, most language tasks are partially or fully
cooperative, so it is an open question whether techniques like self-play can
effectively be used to improve language models. We empirically investigate this
question in a negotiation game setting known as Deal or No Deal (DoND).
Crucially, the objective in DoND can be modified to produce a fully cooperative
game, a strictly competitive one, or anything in between. We finetune language
models in self-play over multiple rounds of filtered behavior cloning in DoND
for each of these objectives. Contrary to expectations, we find that language
model self-play leads to significant performance gains in both cooperation and
competition with humans, suggesting that self-play and related techniques have
promise despite a lack of theoretical guarantees. | [
-0.24052214622497559,
-0.7516627907752991,
0.6314702033996582,
0.2314988523721695,
0.13991399109363556,
0.08797016739845276,
-0.20822924375534058,
-0.6182258725166321,
0.5782291889190674,
0.6340996623039246,
-0.25363510847091675,
-0.2865266501903534,
-0.41452711820602417,
0.04033543914556503,
-0.4583573639392853,
0.929248571395874,
0.26051872968673706,
0.004968896042555571,
0.002838330576196313,
-0.231393501162529,
-0.352359801530838,
-0.4862515926361084,
-0.7862130999565125,
-0.7154815793037415,
0.16809366643428802,
0.47689568996429443,
0.8546140193939209,
0.723582923412323,
0.3257078528404236,
0.3628687858581543,
0.16578495502471924,
-0.2754262089729309,
-0.531552791595459,
0.43964534997940063,
-0.14876829087734222,
-0.5623210072517395,
-0.6414369344711304,
0.5244758129119873,
0.3459587097167969,
0.2976403832435608,
-0.5935725569725037,
-0.24381417036056519,
-0.06560700386762619,
0.2523823082447052,
-0.22625158727169037,
0.11958258599042892,
-0.4939092993736267,
0.0006862186710350215,
0.07431566715240479,
0.00387991382740438,
-0.31359848380088806,
-0.06360351294279099,
-0.014895911328494549,
-0.8248600363731384,
0.01270702201873064,
-0.16359196603298187,
0.7868431210517883,
0.020736124366521835,
-0.38348835706710815,
-0.4012143313884735,
-0.6690875291824341,
0.6280569434165955,
-1.1262317895889282,
-0.11444861441850662,
0.5005768537521362,
0.10498198866844177,
-0.3896446228027344,
-0.40740764141082764,
-0.7179224491119385,
-0.6471761465072632,
-0.08169727772474289,
0.3473385274410248,
-0.21844635903835297,
0.37269341945648193,
0.3509216010570526,
0.5981532335281372,
-0.35324645042419434,
0.09721264243125916,
-0.19037537276744843,
0.1772480607032776,
0.8913502097129822,
-0.010608344338834286,
0.47141534090042114,
-0.08370482176542282,
-0.26130691170692444,
0.021180620416998863,
-0.2854481637477875,
0.18730251491069794,
0.3865976631641388,
0.31200137734413147,
-0.290343701839447,
0.613249659538269,
-0.3402721881866455,
0.6120374202728271,
0.2909688651561737,
-0.09423694759607315,
-0.19231879711151123,
-0.2854435443878174,
-0.17679926753044128,
-0.16814658045768738,
0.8449645638465881,
0.40767520666122437,
0.4500991404056549,
-0.555814266204834,
-0.5062113404273987,
0.38822418451309204,
0.3760586678981781,
-0.3064897060394287,
-0.364764004945755,
0.247055321931839,
-0.3638248145580292,
-0.6176179647445679,
-0.3749946653842926,
-0.6882051229476929,
-0.014679908752441406,
0.021549852564930916,
0.850225567817688,
-0.24234840273857117,
-0.332206130027771,
0.21889591217041016,
-0.21600894629955292,
0.41264864802360535,
0.07043018937110901,
-0.9223694205284119,
0.8986824154853821,
0.41415533423423767,
0.9755963683128357,
-0.08155154436826706,
-0.6941146850585938,
-0.457812637090683,
-0.09205080568790436,
-0.8435325622558594,
0.7786003351211548,
-0.2993341386318207,
-0.7019633054733276,
-0.19676238298416138,
-0.5692780613899231,
0.016278084367513657,
-0.366394579410553,
0.18525397777557373,
-0.4070883095264435,
0.03333606570959091,
-0.11021003127098083,
-0.6838066577911377,
0.2873466908931732,
0.6132441163063049,
-0.543224573135376,
0.6469109654426575,
0.032133180648088455,
-0.10768494009971619,
0.18460355699062347,
-0.9238265752792358,
-0.7115870118141174,
0.13618965446949005,
-0.03960462659597397,
-0.30897119641304016,
0.3554229438304901,
-0.219009667634964,
0.018162144348025322,
-0.22700785100460052,
0.09515586495399475,
-0.48580601811408997,
-0.44710761308670044,
0.5364036560058594,
-0.10147906094789505,
0.3721386790275574,
0.06352157145738602,
-0.6670567393302917,
-0.16208207607269287,
0.0343790166079998,
-0.0025209286250174046,
0.44193726778030396,
-0.004954758565872908,
-0.19565074145793915,
-0.04619233310222626,
-0.41779622435569763,
0.5730538964271545,
0.24071282148361206,
-0.6230449080467224,
0.5221630930900574,
-0.349155068397522,
0.329129159450531,
0.5172336101531982,
-0.07487062364816666,
0.819807767868042,
-0.8420720100402832,
0.8829846978187561,
-0.49367353320121765,
0.5109743475914001,
-0.0017834192840382457,
-0.6695168018341064,
-0.6917719841003418,
-0.27623841166496277,
0.586000382900238,
0.24713757634162903,
-0.8328260183334351,
0.005147362127900124,
0.24063658714294434,
-0.40946656465530396,
-0.7059146165847778,
-0.09690721333026886,
0.642887532711029,
0.2884600758552551,
0.2319084107875824,
-0.3767508566379547,
-0.14074960350990295,
-0.7777424454689026,
-0.32566168904304504,
-0.3092518746852875,
0.3926008939743042,
0.6195042729377747,
0.20792889595031738,
0.33445292711257935,
0.9154523611068726,
-0.3736843168735504,
-0.6679179668426514,
-0.27015548944473267,
0.36501196026802063,
0.06634797155857086,
0.31826502084732056,
0.9198207259178162,
-0.45071256160736084,
-0.7014185786247253,
-0.1013607457280159,
-0.8308239579200745,
-0.21690058708190918,
-0.12981785833835602,
-0.047075722366571426,
0.32826706767082214,
0.3984386920928955,
-0.46500876545906067,
0.3894714415073395,
1.0297619104385376,
-0.5290158987045288,
0.5444087386131287,
-0.6338726282119751,
0.5702636241912842,
-0.4969765543937683,
-0.026178278028964996,
-0.2561464309692383,
-0.47495603561401367,
-0.916113018989563,
0.3632158637046814,
-0.21105065941810608,
-0.13420383632183075,
-0.33958202600479126,
0.6672792434692383,
-0.5264683365821838,
-0.1473912000656128,
-0.7678502202033997,
0.5834043622016907,
-0.19019737839698792,
0.38791006803512573,
0.21528519690036774,
0.8986178040504456,
0.8956548571586609,
-0.848247766494751,
-0.07325945049524307,
0.10240882635116577,
-0.1975601315498352,
0.5395307540893555,
-0.8636208176612854,
0.1248784139752388,
0.17925038933753967,
0.04374808073043823,
-0.9941751956939697,
0.08583007752895355,
0.17005659639835358,
-0.5113714337348938,
0.22626347839832306,
-0.17766912281513214,
-0.2233232706785202,
-0.1786247193813324,
-0.11125832051038742,
0.3192500174045563,
0.6574843525886536,
-0.2756258249282837,
0.5038166046142578,
0.5555355548858643,
0.04332227259874344,
-0.48024535179138184,
-0.6759364604949951,
0.2715965509414673,
-0.10956701636314392,
-0.3655659556388855,
0.4554813802242279,
-0.3755933940410614,
-0.315951406955719,
0.019714942201972008,
-0.05514601618051529,
-0.08603690564632416,
0.4472781717777252,
-0.017671868205070496,
-0.012051348574459553,
-0.07015510648488998,
-0.1848275363445282,
-0.1964004933834076,
-0.2125803679227829,
-0.18238288164138794,
0.0203291904181242,
0.43825405836105347,
0.05578937754034996,
-0.24519380927085876,
-0.11862573772668839,
0.41278696060180664,
0.5432533621788025,
-0.28566357493400574,
0.6992228031158447,
-0.32742440700531006,
-0.1319350153207779,
-0.28200337290763855,
-0.6187836527824402,
-0.3118349313735962,
-0.46411147713661194,
-0.08948326855897903,
-0.49154558777809143,
-0.8119820356369019,
0.6708005666732788,
0.07427705824375153,
0.031185729429125786,
0.2957752048969269,
0.0526408888399601,
-0.2882687449455261,
0.8738453984260559,
0.5937820672988892,
0.16387273371219635,
0.47520995140075684,
-0.2289017289876938,
-0.013658258132636547,
-0.7541280388832092,
-0.06962165236473083,
-0.4937173128128052,
-0.41735512018203735,
-0.6219973564147949,
-0.30060288310050964,
0.06696250289678574,
0.1997738629579544,
0.10628941655158997,
0.5979997515678406,
-0.28934380412101746,
0.7169036865234375,
0.5884906649589539,
-0.022936392575502396,
0.4359149634838104,
-0.6233103275299072,
0.12717458605766296,
-0.059027645736932755,
-0.9574434757232666,
-0.37773552536964417,
1.0541713237762451,
-0.07685822248458862,
0.5258021354675293,
0.5348253846168518,
1.1630650758743286,
0.5591096878051758,
0.37404313683509827,
-0.5571954846382141,
0.6152876019477844,
-0.048245303332805634,
-0.732063353061676,
-0.6893762946128845,
-0.5351015329360962,
-1.2585476636886597,
0.14126324653625488,
-0.35068756341934204,
-0.642377495765686,
0.23975872993469238,
0.13109907507896423,
-0.3471200466156006,
0.1300080567598343,
-0.6797033548355103,
1.0443280935287476,
-0.4320221245288849,
-0.24775052070617676,
-0.2785710096359253,
-0.2220410853624344,
0.48699840903282166,
-0.20497830212116241,
0.39076000452041626,
-0.05244150012731552,
-0.10213562846183777,
0.602113664150238,
0.0045569599606096745,
0.5305184125900269,
-0.002459496958181262,
-0.02538665197789669,
0.27224743366241455,
0.8375602960586548,
0.5427595973014832,
-0.0803680345416069,
-0.10340914130210876,
0.4252837896347046,
-0.02718738652765751,
-0.6477400064468384,
-0.7737377882003784,
0.8985961675643921,
-0.7624212503433228,
-0.8327582478523254,
-0.6585482954978943,
-0.45954421162605286,
0.21189214289188385,
0.16795456409454346,
0.12080704420804977,
0.056647539138793945,
-0.6153392791748047,
-0.06921764463186264,
0.30364683270454407,
0.031827930361032486,
0.7440743446350098,
0.9324018359184265,
-0.3019554316997528,
-0.34513863921165466,
0.7437452077865601,
0.2690250277519226,
0.654589831829071,
-0.11954987049102783,
0.2380545288324356,
-0.3209349811077118,
-0.37784284353256226,
-0.05343985930085182,
0.37510719895362854,
-0.22571122646331787,
-0.26840487122535706,
-0.45291319489479065,
-0.04240407794713974,
-0.35933974385261536,
-0.3908737003803253,
-0.5726928114891052,
-0.45378878712654114,
0.13253279030323029,
0.07405710965394974,
0.09431590139865875,
1.1500446796417236,
-0.7204806804656982,
0.34649306535720825,
-0.30747857689857483,
0.4986606240272522,
0.5244283080101013,
0.48315882682800293,
-0.08443419635295868,
-0.46327218413352966,
-0.17929813265800476,
0.1407729536294937,
-0.15886849164962769,
-1.078128457069397,
0.4143918752670288,
0.06668221205472946,
0.7573967576026917,
0.05206342041492462,
0.4248327910900116,
0.4894009530544281,
-0.309827983379364,
0.8839718699455261,
0.18092982470989227,
-1.2113302946090698,
0.18360544741153717,
-0.5490930676460266,
0.21682314574718475,
0.29555338621139526,
-0.13035042583942413,
-0.6128731369972229,
-0.5555583238601685,
-1.039188265800476,
-0.5748590230941772,
1.1736522912979126,
0.6648808717727661,
0.23610247671604156,
-0.2113245129585266,
0.31799814105033875,
-0.1428993046283722,
0.3808959722518921,
-0.9501157999038696,
-0.529854953289032,
-0.08893884718418121,
0.4819057285785675,
-0.4047626852989197,
-0.20919594168663025,
-0.1425689309835434,
0.3051137626171112,
0.6365894079208374,
-0.028890253975987434,
0.18935701251029968,
0.20475532114505768,
0.08723507076501846,
-0.17209158837795258,
0.2598849833011627,
0.6734885573387146,
0.415326327085495,
0.04081793874502182,
-0.09906921535730362,
-0.08791632205247879,
0.20857182145118713,
0.3867863714694977,
-0.07317227125167847,
-0.21750830113887787,
-0.20647838711738586,
0.28054279088974,
0.36312928795814514,
0.40221595764160156,
-0.5771529674530029,
0.7336221933364868,
-0.25794678926467896,
-0.5195574760437012,
-0.006377200596034527,
0.3040889799594879,
-0.10508032888174057,
0.4479994773864746,
0.01757623255252838,
-0.09911836683750153,
0.25610050559043884,
-0.8353317975997925,
0.5057854652404785,
0.6080837845802307,
-0.13325800001621246,
-0.046538978815078735,
0.6367157697677612,
0.13157100975513458,
-0.9730551838874817,
0.5029851198196411,
-0.48088857531547546,
-0.5473818778991699,
0.7259555459022522,
0.7118152976036072,
0.5768715739250183,
-0.3125961124897003,
0.7467589974403381,
0.007262153085321188,
0.33194494247436523,
-0.3176746070384979,
0.21943840384483337,
-0.24166610836982727,
-0.7269373536109924,
-0.7115011215209961,
-0.01548069715499878,
-0.5394008755683899,
-0.08161611109972,
-0.5845822095870972,
0.04866158589720726,
-0.2255539447069168,
-0.37879636883735657,
-0.17979399859905243,
0.07928186655044556,
-0.4356518089771271,
-0.09799330681562424,
0.14161944389343262,
0.5391950011253357,
-0.8017032146453857,
0.6114970445632935,
0.44885697960853577,
-0.6221426129341125,
-0.5166654586791992,
0.1724642664194107,
-0.46809452772140503,
-0.3645508885383606,
0.3252671957015991,
-0.40947985649108887,
-0.06620121002197266,
0.18764005601406097,
-0.5372549295425415,
-0.838874101638794,
0.932817816734314,
0.6902429461479187,
-0.3359350562095642,
-0.01464903261512518,
-0.26957106590270996,
0.6506164073944092,
-0.4135375916957855,
0.46425336599349976,
0.5162936449050903,
0.4742487967014313,
0.34053441882133484,
-1.220945954322815,
-0.282961905002594,
0.005528122652322054,
-0.24224205315113068,
0.15731482207775116,
-1.0495659112930298,
0.8054445385932922,
-0.24726831912994385,
-0.014449778012931347,
0.3112708032131195,
0.5756105184555054,
0.22157955169677734,
0.1584940403699875,
0.4261109232902527,
0.4573374390602112,
0.3887070119380951,
-0.11520183086395264,
1.1704415082931519,
-0.5055763721466064,
0.5948330760002136,
1.01371169090271,
-0.6531592607498169,
0.46740952134132385,
0.05172000452876091,
0.0709436908364296,
0.31044986844062805,
0.15765567123889923,
0.21285292506217957,
0.602695882320404,
0.15247505903244019,
-0.01383956614881754,
-0.6860849857330322,
-0.13295872509479523,
-0.042268138378858566,
0.7074295282363892,
0.037126339972019196,
0.09923765808343887,
-0.3659036457538605,
-0.2717438042163849,
0.07171080261468887,
0.4549126923084259,
0.06893354654312134,
0.9994161128997803,
0.012885499745607376,
-1.011160135269165,
0.03298240900039673,
0.07557617872953415,
0.6878631711006165,
-0.6868039965629578,
-0.2645033299922943,
-0.6143688559532166,
0.013159405440092087,
0.21016642451286316,
-0.6855746507644653,
0.12386513501405716,
-0.2738730311393738,
0.010527555830776691,
-0.3026740550994873,
0.4178498387336731,
-0.6117695569992065,
-0.034370336681604385,
0.768155574798584,
0.5959473848342896,
0.28182435035705566,
0.10635106265544891,
-0.8691537976264954,
-0.24209082126617432,
-0.23330117762088776,
-0.09289178997278214,
0.6777964234352112,
0.4293837547302246,
0.30611562728881836,
0.6638261675834656,
0.6342174410820007,
0.36771467328071594,
-0.15739555656909943,
-0.366931289434433,
0.5083150863647461,
-0.5959314703941345,
-0.5888687968254089,
-0.788233757019043,
0.4350716769695282,
-0.19290630519390106,
-0.13045409321784973,
0.91192626953125,
0.4938443899154663,
0.7173179388046265,
0.10527382791042328,
0.5019068121910095,
-0.05333394929766655,
-0.0330539345741272,
-0.2751828730106354,
0.7771943807601929,
-0.655113697052002,
-0.035775501281023026,
-0.42697930335998535,
-0.715467631816864,
-0.10938289016485214,
0.8646652102470398,
-0.1586347371339798,
0.370839923620224,
0.6650910377502441,
0.5115246772766113,
0.006396217737346888,
-0.2023855447769165,
1.1163688898086548,
0.27782437205314636,
0.2364821583032608,
0.3212665319442749,
0.6981928944587708,
-0.47484639286994934,
0.670310914516449,
-0.27643364667892456,
-0.4500386416912079,
-0.010391280055046082,
-0.8047536611557007,
-0.8981084227561951,
-0.3821014165878296,
-0.5521907806396484,
-0.5786606669425964,
0.32278507947921753,
0.6563616394996643,
0.8469339609146118,
-0.31543487310409546,
-0.7163090109825134,
-0.02366279996931553,
0.15180233120918274,
-0.5538779497146606,
-0.16521157324314117,
-0.11233454942703247,
-0.5080466270446777,
-0.7246930599212646,
0.8336865901947021,
0.3011510372161865,
0.14397472143173218,
-0.24170845746994019,
-0.36632511019706726,
-0.4133419990539551,
0.6817183494567871,
0.34422582387924194,
0.629277765750885,
-0.4083072543144226,
0.014748438261449337,
0.24898892641067505,
-0.17868421971797943,
-0.06582633405923843,
0.9657354354858398,
-0.7333891987800598,
0.4939251244068146,
0.013785216026008129,
0.14130666851997375,
0.6443852782249451,
0.07224755734205246,
0.8766022324562073,
-0.3888692557811737,
0.05830642953515053,
0.22361111640930176,
0.0792548879981041,
-0.013316809199750423,
-0.19891342520713806,
0.6438186168670654,
0.060964297503232956,
-0.8420464396476746,
-0.5887407660484314,
0.23901773989200592,
-0.47790664434432983,
-0.2525997459888458,
1.179517388343811,
-0.35867390036582947,
-0.16263042390346527,
-0.07070054113864899,
-0.022538822144269943,
0.09828095883131027,
-0.7299516797065735,
1.0543005466461182,
0.7919015884399414,
-0.3120069205760956,
-0.11520205438137054,
-0.3007555902004242,
0.48401516675949097,
0.4941314458847046,
-0.45425349473953247,
-0.13341215252876282,
0.40987247228622437,
0.017464859411120415,
0.09917828440666199,
1.0876199007034302,
0.162075936794281,
0.3586784601211548,
0.05971987545490265,
0.17043590545654297,
-0.03996090963482857,
-0.42981237173080444,
-0.44824832677841187,
-0.05190620943903923,
0.5409131050109863,
-0.20686060190200806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18859v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18859v1 | Two-Pronged Human Evaluation of ChatGPT Self-Correction in Radiology Report Simplification | 2024-06-27T03:05:35 | 2024-06-27T03:05:35 | Ziyu Yang, Santhosh Cherian, Slobodan Vucetic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Radiology reports are highly technical documents aimed primarily at
doctor-doctor communication. There has been an increasing interest in sharing
those reports with patients, necessitating providing them patient-friendly
simplifications of the original reports. This study explores the suitability of
large language models in automatically generating those simplifications. We
examine the usefulness of chain-of-thought and self-correction prompting
mechanisms in this domain. We also propose a new evaluation protocol that
employs radiologists and laypeople, where radiologists verify the factual
correctness of simplifications, and laypeople assess simplicity and
comprehension. Our experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of
self-correction prompting in producing high-quality simplifications. Our
findings illuminate the preferences of radiologists and laypeople regarding
text simplification, informing future research on this topic. | [
-0.09971299767494202,
-0.2878948450088501,
0.780539333820343,
0.40631070733070374,
-0.4050545394420624,
-0.3323163092136383,
-0.3172031342983246,
-0.5873655676841736,
0.1907876431941986,
0.31435278058052063,
-0.4447842240333557,
-0.1297612190246582,
-0.5509819984436035,
0.5003926753997803,
-0.08590416610240936,
0.9378929734230042,
-0.13084857165813446,
0.3796859383583069,
-0.004943563602864742,
0.1060866266489029,
-0.6583161950111389,
-0.11506101489067078,
-0.4784303605556488,
-0.5900493264198303,
0.6990354061126709,
0.6358476877212524,
1.2202033996582031,
0.6214036345481873,
0.7846596837043762,
0.2839397192001343,
0.10494429618120193,
0.16474078595638275,
-0.2801046073436737,
0.01991182565689087,
0.03838995471596718,
-0.07198991626501083,
-0.5967779159545898,
-0.045386169105768204,
0.23208774626255035,
0.7661550045013428,
-0.2859230637550354,
0.12258899211883545,
0.03822651132941246,
0.9048418998718262,
-0.5161858797073364,
0.2611626982688904,
-0.020204201340675354,
0.14769265055656433,
0.136082261800766,
-0.6035095453262329,
-0.5305731892585754,
-0.43779534101486206,
0.26238760352134705,
-0.5842748284339905,
0.18184372782707214,
0.021374786272644997,
0.49892011284828186,
0.29705312848091125,
-0.45797762274742126,
-0.659049928188324,
-0.920426607131958,
0.20241472125053406,
-0.4671798348426819,
-0.025233393535017967,
0.38303613662719727,
0.39005541801452637,
-0.052027035504579544,
-0.9223939776420593,
-0.403786301612854,
-0.2794526219367981,
-0.6159708499908447,
0.4209708273410797,
-0.31405261158943176,
0.30818745493888855,
0.476495623588562,
0.3293968439102173,
-0.5632309317588806,
-0.13772405683994293,
-0.6268998980522156,
-0.22191400825977325,
0.7940733432769775,
0.11471039056777954,
0.5501114726066589,
-0.46699419617652893,
-0.35240158438682556,
-0.10143611580133438,
-0.5901321768760681,
-0.6062402129173279,
0.14780740439891815,
0.026840200647711754,
0.20667152106761932,
0.4421599805355072,
-0.5540990829467773,
0.324508935213089,
-0.0450374111533165,
-0.0027572661638259888,
0.355451762676239,
-0.11867235600948334,
-0.24950948357582092,
0.20948052406311035,
0.9192760586738586,
0.6488953232765198,
0.18161240220069885,
0.0317954458296299,
-0.16749046742916107,
-0.13723896443843842,
0.26289933919906616,
-0.6603874564170837,
-0.45424067974090576,
0.17374682426452637,
-0.6537778973579407,
-0.28672993183135986,
-0.16520285606384277,
-0.3932966887950897,
-0.4968538284301758,
-0.30246686935424805,
0.9107266664505005,
-0.3503247797489166,
-0.17777584493160248,
0.7482903599739075,
0.051245491951704025,
-0.07616272568702698,
0.8148055672645569,
-0.4819392263889313,
0.19736260175704956,
0.30841541290283203,
0.4851686656475067,
0.5634467005729675,
-0.3968244194984436,
-0.3158336877822876,
0.21113331615924835,
-0.25142407417297363,
1.0814443826675415,
-0.016018705442547798,
-0.4985690116882324,
-0.3623879849910736,
-0.37592291831970215,
0.03340282663702965,
-0.4925330579280853,
0.7466140985488892,
-0.17111705243587494,
0.5303643941879272,
-0.4638689160346985,
-0.40248942375183105,
0.10530465841293335,
-0.016060180962085724,
-0.4773878753185272,
0.7409072518348694,
-0.013103164732456207,
-1.0603563785552979,
0.2239554524421692,
-0.5111005902290344,
-0.41584643721580505,
0.4104886054992676,
-0.37257349491119385,
-0.5376285910606384,
-0.14089283347129822,
0.3501313030719757,
0.23881517350673676,
-0.40172523260116577,
0.26910239458084106,
0.27802950143814087,
-0.3972155451774597,
0.2564280927181244,
-0.3498920202255249,
0.5077836513519287,
0.5287052989006042,
-0.2369421273469925,
-0.03230958431959152,
-0.18547450006008148,
0.16584521532058716,
0.031470127403736115,
-0.1952981799840927,
-0.11212584376335144,
-0.27325594425201416,
-0.3041243851184845,
0.34634020924568176,
0.11058460175991058,
-0.3642219007015228,
0.39014485478401184,
-0.08662355691194534,
0.143813356757164,
0.34897080063819885,
0.19326452910900116,
-0.04612705111503601,
-0.6488934755325317,
0.6272863745689392,
-0.07570932805538177,
0.5721239447593689,
-0.49948111176490784,
-0.4850624203681946,
-0.8237525224685669,
-0.3767717778682709,
0.6605614423751831,
0.39907076954841614,
-0.5580840110778809,
0.022848479449748993,
-0.3543468415737152,
-0.582385241985321,
-0.6992942690849304,
-0.06900065392255783,
0.5607989430427551,
0.5490070581436157,
0.24521899223327637,
-0.3299221694469452,
-0.5734696388244629,
-0.9571650624275208,
-0.45917052030563354,
-0.24636264145374298,
-0.18196724355220795,
0.058943480253219604,
0.13003607094287872,
-0.14628446102142334,
0.7931245565414429,
-0.6858820915222168,
-0.4497619569301605,
-0.3137664198875427,
0.7513267993927002,
-0.10280343890190125,
0.23591801524162292,
0.1439720094203949,
-0.5400625467300415,
-0.6126842498779297,
-0.17172814905643463,
-0.8509388566017151,
-0.34185314178466797,
-0.29203173518180847,
0.17235706746578217,
0.04017733410000801,
0.7107683420181274,
-0.4967901408672333,
0.6966333389282227,
0.3079180419445038,
-0.10035023093223572,
0.5782042145729065,
-1.0333250761032104,
0.4071286618709564,
-0.578719973564148,
0.08598336577415466,
-0.36000749468803406,
-0.5644869804382324,
-0.6468503475189209,
-0.1904100924730301,
0.1649819165468216,
-0.2452995330095291,
-0.16872382164001465,
0.15772145986557007,
-0.9068911671638489,
-0.1220984235405922,
-0.181065171957016,
0.15679647028446198,
-0.15295453369617462,
0.08181774616241455,
0.0024646776728332043,
0.6296467781066895,
0.48277994990348816,
-0.3718222975730896,
0.10257948935031891,
0.35284140706062317,
-0.1446141004562378,
0.30678480863571167,
-0.7389135956764221,
0.46596476435661316,
-0.4847550094127655,
0.4858323633670807,
-1.1432487964630127,
-0.4690794348716736,
0.29214850068092346,
-0.4056757092475891,
0.1607688069343567,
-0.1345260888338089,
-0.38798338174819946,
-0.5328006744384766,
-0.30353161692619324,
0.4095267355442047,
0.544429361820221,
-0.24393142759799957,
0.4669771194458008,
0.049727607518434525,
-0.33637896180152893,
-0.33588671684265137,
-0.686212420463562,
0.38461366295814514,
0.1753172129392624,
-0.68925541639328,
-0.06511004269123077,
-0.18379828333854675,
-0.06179284304380417,
-0.26548945903778076,
-0.06603273004293442,
0.1285078525543213,
-0.3270268440246582,
0.35078129172325134,
0.1567171961069107,
-0.06489864736795425,
0.2796955108642578,
-0.31531691551208496,
-0.3561423718929291,
0.0019911692943423986,
0.252711683511734,
0.44489914178848267,
-0.37139129638671875,
-0.522332489490509,
-0.6300423741340637,
0.214610755443573,
0.23160861432552338,
0.03447491675615311,
0.254921555519104,
0.4188369810581207,
-0.12519937753677368,
0.2413480132818222,
-0.8393416404724121,
-0.3054450750350952,
-0.42971327900886536,
-0.03026888705790043,
-0.3826739490032196,
-0.7289754152297974,
0.326339453458786,
-0.38544130325317383,
-0.41598188877105713,
0.5145518183708191,
0.6294490694999695,
-0.415530800819397,
1.0558655261993408,
0.15319620072841644,
0.5577998757362366,
-0.23621582984924316,
0.11492938548326492,
0.49331966042518616,
-0.5974051356315613,
-0.317518025636673,
-0.4610884487628937,
0.07228537648916245,
-0.6745930314064026,
-0.36442339420318604,
0.7772645354270935,
-0.23962539434432983,
0.365724116563797,
0.13694033026695251,
-0.4961656928062439,
0.6806900501251221,
0.15285639464855194,
0.4995936453342438,
0.5689790844917297,
-0.09708644449710846,
0.19531075656414032,
-0.14525975286960602,
-0.8098357915878296,
-0.5589717626571655,
0.879987359046936,
0.4963425099849701,
1.0021169185638428,
0.009070715866982937,
0.8814272880554199,
0.48735371232032776,
0.36417990922927856,
-0.8801634907722473,
0.5354239344596863,
-0.18877606093883514,
-0.2865627408027649,
-0.38895341753959656,
-0.3182935416698456,
-1.0203551054000854,
0.17438261210918427,
-0.14638611674308777,
-0.2495679259300232,
-0.07567868381738663,
0.39520135521888733,
-0.6281759738922119,
-0.2558401823043823,
-0.9246020317077637,
0.6584165692329407,
-0.02813645638525486,
0.06886676698923111,
-0.5368838310241699,
-0.8124340176582336,
0.20845426619052887,
-0.02438567765057087,
0.35663866996765137,
-0.04836444929242134,
0.14331655204296112,
0.4397566616535187,
-0.7180773615837097,
0.8064035177230835,
0.060438208281993866,
0.006629616022109985,
0.19797834753990173,
0.4678291380405426,
0.41819635033607483,
-0.029932405799627304,
0.11682897061109543,
-0.018271654844284058,
-0.09573705494403839,
-0.10311231017112732,
-0.5954765677452087,
0.1661071628332138,
-0.7415981292724609,
-0.9269644021987915,
-0.6203493475914001,
-0.43582412600517273,
-0.07843251526355743,
0.28252482414245605,
0.4033934473991394,
0.5776699185371399,
-0.13559064269065857,
-0.17087063193321228,
0.37391552329063416,
-0.17993435263633728,
-0.04578886926174164,
0.5290371775627136,
-0.38356417417526245,
-0.16836996376514435,
0.5142387747764587,
0.10016664117574692,
0.3254445493221283,
0.09916599839925766,
0.7862686514854431,
-0.09514573961496353,
-0.2131984978914261,
-0.40155819058418274,
0.5790566802024841,
-1.0227006673812866,
-0.14424222707748413,
-0.6434985399246216,
-0.2855287194252014,
-0.3596141040325165,
-0.08568012714385986,
-0.1960664838552475,
-0.5122047066688538,
0.127452090382576,
0.3604203760623932,
0.19950442016124725,
1.1208654642105103,
-0.3469221591949463,
0.3034297525882721,
-0.5857767462730408,
0.34623104333877563,
0.6473188996315002,
0.1296570748090744,
-0.22863680124282837,
-0.5119920969009399,
-0.015813350677490234,
-0.08751311898231506,
-0.1593390256166458,
-0.873272180557251,
0.24412578344345093,
-0.02318490855395794,
0.26098740100860596,
0.06151136755943298,
0.06959731131792068,
0.8428711891174316,
-0.40683647990226746,
0.3739750385284424,
0.5941034555435181,
-1.1146897077560425,
0.6005083918571472,
-0.6063860058784485,
0.44810521602630615,
0.5189616084098816,
0.22115090489387512,
-1.018864631652832,
-0.37008577585220337,
-0.6999249458312988,
-0.5900561809539795,
0.7664186358451843,
0.315826952457428,
-0.03338693827390671,
-0.0183577723801136,
0.29188045859336853,
0.012437350116670132,
-0.11206010729074478,
-0.43342432379722595,
-0.15550723671913147,
-0.14430773258209229,
-0.031559739261865616,
0.4681326746940613,
-0.7222039699554443,
-0.3931492269039154,
0.07070773839950562,
0.5097989439964294,
-0.36279547214508057,
0.4247862696647644,
0.8008782267570496,
-0.093157559633255,
-0.41635143756866455,
0.5870217680931091,
0.7934154272079468,
1.1839677095413208,
-0.10055209696292877,
0.439158171415329,
0.2794272005558014,
-0.3523060381412506,
-0.08494759351015091,
-0.41071873903274536,
-0.15832950174808502,
0.30382218956947327,
0.39975741505622864,
0.5563477873802185,
0.09956225007772446,
-0.346420019865036,
0.9296244978904724,
-0.43151840567588806,
-0.391078382730484,
-0.1714109629392624,
-0.1773507297039032,
0.13230404257774353,
-0.10556712001562119,
0.3246990144252777,
0.3730595111846924,
0.588138222694397,
-0.4580976963043213,
0.12806957960128784,
0.017028629779815674,
-0.2074691206216812,
-0.1258590966463089,
0.3394196629524231,
0.16478553414344788,
-0.2073156088590622,
0.6199168562889099,
-0.1257864385843277,
-0.5375364422798157,
0.38170915842056274,
0.4136729836463928,
0.7673109173774719,
-0.459970086812973,
0.511358916759491,
0.5104079246520996,
0.3233018219470978,
-0.4485587775707245,
0.301439106464386,
0.18927566707134247,
-0.3759947419166565,
-0.6179654598236084,
0.1375563144683838,
-0.6516314148902893,
-0.10907398164272308,
-0.8328574895858765,
0.649135947227478,
-0.38623684644699097,
-0.13580261170864105,
0.274400532245636,
-0.45262888073921204,
-0.48794570565223694,
0.4634210169315338,
0.23566196858882904,
0.8625681400299072,
-0.6025634407997131,
0.6909562945365906,
0.6052405834197998,
-0.532988429069519,
-1.296181082725525,
0.36371952295303345,
-0.020295120775699615,
-0.974788248538971,
0.8513688445091248,
0.19759045541286469,
-0.4287202060222626,
-0.45040225982666016,
-0.3305601477622986,
-0.47121909260749817,
0.945034384727478,
0.39204689860343933,
-0.5664466023445129,
-0.02002662792801857,
0.37443807721138,
0.9404165148735046,
-0.11635111272335052,
0.8279730677604675,
0.25275740027427673,
0.39675432443618774,
0.40590646862983704,
-1.49542236328125,
0.3437396287918091,
0.18961971998214722,
0.014767286367714405,
0.04999938979744911,
-0.7676709890365601,
0.6594521403312683,
-0.4637950360774994,
-0.27465713024139404,
-0.35844868421554565,
0.5429316759109497,
-0.17353175580501556,
0.07565519958734512,
0.6187432408332825,
0.12574875354766846,
0.7148959636688232,
0.13424737751483917,
1.1123193502426147,
-0.15533316135406494,
0.5826711058616638,
1.0433268547058105,
-0.1379256546497345,
0.48330962657928467,
0.48295333981513977,
-0.1858021467924118,
0.526817262172699,
0.15877372026443481,
0.18396684527397156,
0.24395783245563507,
0.08682835102081299,
-0.20044086873531342,
-0.5531095266342163,
-0.0746544599533081,
-0.2880720794200897,
0.5992742776870728,
0.062116168439388275,
-0.13658590614795685,
-0.3876841366291046,
-0.3976251184940338,
0.35154783725738525,
-0.06183841452002525,
-0.11726295948028564,
0.9398781061172485,
0.09145788848400116,
-0.9717400670051575,
0.6350703835487366,
0.01573013700544834,
0.24637141823768616,
-0.5487239360809326,
0.07773522287607193,
-0.20187623798847198,
0.17014895379543304,
-0.5497249364852905,
-0.9165198802947998,
0.4713406562805176,
-0.13313983380794525,
0.12313611060380936,
-0.3845404088497162,
0.7920711636543274,
-0.520729124546051,
-0.18868513405323029,
0.0037681052926927805,
0.20315256714820862,
0.37911373376846313,
-0.06620939075946808,
-0.6502084732055664,
-0.02718796767294407,
0.1932065784931183,
-0.1592121124267578,
0.08449563384056091,
0.31178024411201477,
-0.1940612941980362,
0.8254811763763428,
0.3406720757484436,
0.1718585342168808,
-0.3083554208278656,
0.48250705003738403,
0.8401390910148621,
-0.38431739807128906,
-0.5496599078178406,
-0.7284128069877625,
0.26946118474006653,
0.024324771016836166,
-0.31348076462745667,
0.6817936897277832,
0.6314506530761719,
0.4822560250759125,
-0.23426389694213867,
0.8066762089729309,
0.01905045472085476,
0.5272473096847534,
-0.640584409236908,
0.5262895822525024,
-0.3082222640514374,
0.3134469985961914,
-0.24551773071289062,
-0.19485466182231903,
-0.44503292441368103,
0.49782848358154297,
-0.4902589023113251,
0.16188661754131317,
1.1068700551986694,
0.7917132377624512,
-0.04869706928730011,
0.232465922832489,
0.43226251006126404,
0.21383805572986603,
-0.04983239248394966,
0.33845868706703186,
0.7846179604530334,
-0.6260450482368469,
0.7034023404121399,
-0.24331235885620117,
-0.2425721436738968,
-0.4021855294704437,
-0.934710681438446,
-0.6951922178268433,
-0.32833778858184814,
-0.7673540711402893,
-0.37500566244125366,
0.12391922622919083,
0.9518342018127441,
0.5801510810852051,
-0.40827739238739014,
-0.13109934329986572,
0.35159066319465637,
-0.3496231138706207,
-0.03745102882385254,
-0.10376100987195969,
0.5979859828948975,
-0.2624594569206238,
-0.17510268092155457,
0.09430870413780212,
0.5218024849891663,
-0.07380622625350952,
-0.27987995743751526,
-0.1600206196308136,
0.37158966064453125,
-0.013228675350546837,
0.2317897528409958,
0.025021567940711975,
-0.6206206679344177,
-0.2553689479827881,
-0.1482880711555481,
-0.5204344391822815,
0.48490557074546814,
1.0844074487686157,
-0.5154964923858643,
0.9120372533798218,
0.5486918091773987,
0.041398316621780396,
0.4723227620124817,
0.07777660340070724,
0.4677930772304535,
-0.6853960156440735,
-0.04608460143208504,
0.06210697442293167,
0.25487783551216125,
0.627427339553833,
-0.7258234024047852,
0.4954926371574402,
0.009528905153274536,
-0.7890259623527527,
-0.45136895775794983,
0.1177293062210083,
-0.9475682973861694,
-0.2361905872821808,
1.1095763444900513,
-0.21260201930999756,
-0.13494475185871124,
-0.22631946206092834,
-0.7572914958000183,
0.2681584358215332,
-0.21478889882564545,
0.8689719438552856,
0.41789716482162476,
-0.44304296374320984,
-0.39157846570014954,
-0.3294455111026764,
0.7745237946510315,
0.5944651961326599,
-0.8879597187042236,
0.23598547279834747,
0.37415611743927,
0.5110508799552917,
0.1145484521985054,
1.226190447807312,
-0.17170295119285583,
0.6880900859832764,
-0.13207024335861206,
0.4749646782875061,
-0.05295894294977188,
-0.004789338447153568,
-0.44179433584213257,
-0.20793406665325165,
0.3852536380290985,
0.18965578079223633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18856v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18856v1 | FFN: a Fine-grained Chinese-English Financial Domain Parallel Corpus | 2024-06-27T02:53:55 | 2024-06-27T02:53:55 | Yuxin Fu, Shijing Si, Leyi Mai, Xi-ang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE | Large Language Models (LLMs) have stunningly advanced the field of machine
translation, though their effectiveness within the financial domain remains
largely underexplored. To probe this issue, we constructed a fine-grained
Chinese-English parallel corpus of financial news called FFN. We acquired
financial news articles spanning between January 1st, 2014, to December 31,
2023, from mainstream media websites such as CNN, FOX, and China Daily. The
dataset consists of 1,013 main text and 809 titles, all of which have been
manually corrected. We measured the translation quality of two LLMs -- ChatGPT
and ERNIE-bot, utilizing BLEU, TER and chrF scores as the evaluation metrics.
For comparison, we also trained an OpenNMT model based on our dataset. We
detail problems of LLMs and provide in-depth analysis, intending to stimulate
further research and solutions in this largely uncharted territory. Our
research underlines the need to optimize LLMs within the specific field of
financial translation to ensure accuracy and quality. | [
-0.1244722306728363,
-0.782326340675354,
0.2902213931083679,
0.5915287137031555,
-0.2922993302345276,
0.08342226594686508,
-0.5232054591178894,
-0.5238511562347412,
-0.09620088338851929,
0.7461590766906738,
-0.20967867970466614,
-0.4670576751232147,
-0.6682268977165222,
0.0887439101934433,
-0.7146144509315491,
1.1783320903778076,
-0.0665021762251854,
0.33611661195755005,
0.047539301216602325,
0.10549571365118027,
0.09077996015548706,
-0.30146992206573486,
-1.1095775365829468,
-0.4308415949344635,
0.4990869462490082,
0.10077404230833054,
0.8912133574485779,
0.8790400624275208,
0.9784923791885376,
0.3255642056465149,
-0.03965350240468979,
0.2592082619667053,
-0.6155633926391602,
-0.5067682862281799,
-0.09370415657758713,
-0.23733070492744446,
-0.7491520047187805,
0.0340200699865818,
0.6446107029914856,
0.7672985196113586,
-0.075603187084198,
0.08612105250358582,
0.530510425567627,
0.7690668106079102,
-0.028486227616667747,
0.5027427077293396,
-0.4742322564125061,
-0.037330664694309235,
-0.5933448076248169,
-0.25202903151512146,
-0.4311313033103943,
-0.18485496938228607,
0.2905665934085846,
-0.7087879180908203,
0.07351619005203247,
0.19096480309963226,
1.1208858489990234,
0.08287536352872849,
-0.5624272227287292,
-0.16914471983909607,
-0.681993842124939,
0.8559621572494507,
-0.7192268967628479,
0.3734167218208313,
0.2442195862531662,
0.24300658702850342,
-0.29781574010849,
-0.8365301489830017,
-0.26116475462913513,
-0.07177788764238358,
-0.1439390629529953,
0.14278343319892883,
-0.3114256262779236,
-0.04793775454163551,
-0.11991310864686966,
0.5349384546279907,
-0.5969707369804382,
0.17596526443958282,
-0.4968360364437103,
-0.23892158269882202,
0.74528568983078,
0.28179991245269775,
-0.062267132103443146,
-0.10656239092350006,
-0.6871054172515869,
-0.13277089595794678,
-0.6957419514656067,
0.1299745738506317,
0.37441274523735046,
0.5814834833145142,
-0.3065761625766754,
0.5354756712913513,
-0.1364501267671585,
0.5461646914482117,
-0.12216611206531525,
-0.39648503065109253,
0.13065023720264435,
-0.4935131072998047,
-0.44422534108161926,
0.16359584033489227,
0.9673827290534973,
0.5806188583374023,
0.3199697434902191,
-0.14809058606624603,
-0.6210208535194397,
-0.6364142894744873,
0.10040554404258728,
-0.7610642313957214,
-0.1597057580947876,
0.3471248149871826,
-0.6000404953956604,
-0.3391808271408081,
0.20605817437171936,
-0.6270277500152588,
-0.22373293340206146,
-0.3737243711948395,
0.156330406665802,
-0.3301885724067688,
-0.056661661714315414,
0.25617605447769165,
0.00441137608140707,
0.372400164604187,
0.25998684763908386,
-0.7581083178520203,
0.20068761706352234,
1.0979788303375244,
0.6867569088935852,
-0.10934258997440338,
-0.2362627238035202,
-0.49268683791160583,
0.16027036309242249,
-0.4568338096141815,
0.7620574831962585,
-0.14574120938777924,
-0.15531569719314575,
0.06039770692586899,
0.06124764308333397,
0.028779545798897743,
-0.5180807113647461,
0.5059208273887634,
-0.6268501281738281,
0.05384829267859459,
-0.14456692337989807,
-0.5838673710823059,
-0.26834776997566223,
0.31155917048454285,
-0.5859823226928711,
0.5587127804756165,
0.07464709132909775,
-0.6429889798164368,
0.10331402719020844,
-0.47010537981987,
-0.43866822123527527,
-0.08379894495010376,
0.04313637316226959,
-0.32278603315353394,
-0.2180735021829605,
0.3800487220287323,
0.6290780305862427,
-0.7423384785652161,
0.5352747440338135,
-0.3009558618068695,
-0.3579908609390259,
0.5690321922302246,
-0.7829189300537109,
0.44861772656440735,
0.34888118505477905,
0.0011642486788332462,
0.16013088822364807,
-0.595731794834137,
-0.5468961596488953,
0.26930859684944153,
-0.2815813422203064,
-0.5013781785964966,
0.05643944442272186,
0.2721044421195984,
0.0519377700984478,
0.6577355861663818,
-0.5405578017234802,
-0.06797061860561371,
-0.8280026912689209,
0.686519205570221,
0.8752902150154114,
-0.3144741654396057,
0.3960190415382385,
-0.5638678073883057,
0.2086143046617508,
0.24508962035179138,
0.12568169832229614,
-0.34998083114624023,
-0.23139482736587524,
-0.5048432946205139,
-0.08739931136369705,
0.5273842811584473,
0.6104075908660889,
-0.4769718050956726,
-0.02696298621594906,
-0.24212032556533813,
-0.24962683022022247,
-0.4215012192726135,
0.23660090565681458,
0.17597150802612305,
0.4222552478313446,
0.21993201971054077,
0.04042178392410278,
-0.17999838292598724,
-0.9362559914588928,
-0.2057407647371292,
0.09800158441066742,
-0.17975732684135437,
0.23496197164058685,
0.15566493570804596,
-0.058870818465948105,
0.6661946773529053,
-0.38447579741477966,
-0.45502132177352905,
-0.10106389969587326,
0.0736229419708252,
0.5207815170288086,
0.3663323223590851,
0.7071290612220764,
-0.9154045581817627,
-0.41413626074790955,
0.5638625621795654,
-0.5681834816932678,
0.10655025392770767,
-0.692359983921051,
-0.2584773004055023,
0.2642776072025299,
0.589566707611084,
-0.3898893892765045,
0.023603098466992378,
0.6978493332862854,
-0.19065748155117035,
0.3528592586517334,
-0.15678727626800537,
0.06151612848043442,
-1.1879886388778687,
-0.07057300209999084,
0.24422715604305267,
-0.2720125913619995,
-0.324870765209198,
-0.00042509526247158647,
0.12757836282253265,
0.13971969485282898,
-0.5610390901565552,
0.828115701675415,
-0.2186678797006607,
-0.16327963769435883,
-0.48487505316734314,
0.442558228969574,
-0.08271780610084534,
0.4485986530780792,
-0.23962025344371796,
0.874907910823822,
0.38888368010520935,
-0.3888111114501953,
0.6133406162261963,
0.0588340163230896,
-0.30283433198928833,
0.22106072306632996,
-0.6556322574615479,
-0.3161305785179138,
0.08544047176837921,
0.08341138064861298,
-1.0177098512649536,
-0.24573685228824615,
0.29888325929641724,
-0.2697054147720337,
0.29538828134536743,
0.35435017943382263,
-0.5022966265678406,
-0.4660809636116028,
-0.23326674103736877,
0.2899937033653259,
0.216793030500412,
-0.4728168547153473,
0.2978053092956543,
0.20606128871440887,
-0.4780706763267517,
-0.6779908537864685,
-0.7546033263206482,
0.11641858518123627,
-0.09721513092517853,
-0.9548062682151794,
0.49491778016090393,
0.3123611509799957,
-0.3839668035507202,
0.1850932389497757,
-0.2666637599468231,
-0.17987756431102753,
0.2230512648820877,
-0.23525837063789368,
0.5990787148475647,
-0.9120084643363953,
-0.11956875026226044,
0.04988330230116844,
-0.1604347825050354,
0.19937588274478912,
-0.595390796661377,
0.3588443696498871,
-0.3069738745689392,
-0.1756729930639267,
-0.2927732467651367,
0.07650257647037506,
0.3984791934490204,
-0.3385082483291626,
0.8091400861740112,
0.43955695629119873,
-0.34748703241348267,
-0.12050649523735046,
-0.43118977546691895,
0.09326642751693726,
-0.5408356189727783,
0.30318596959114075,
-0.2681947350502014,
-1.219201683998108,
0.7763631343841553,
-0.08832648396492004,
0.3190617263317108,
0.8783206343650818,
0.5475119352340698,
-0.010245096869766712,
0.6904926896095276,
0.5458084940910339,
-0.17357414960861206,
0.268502801656723,
-0.055700354278087616,
0.18712763488292694,
-0.37495163083076477,
-0.08420789241790771,
-0.27335572242736816,
-0.35658273100852966,
-0.49568694829940796,
-0.44130322337150574,
0.11080457270145416,
0.1738811880350113,
-0.18493854999542236,
0.505277156829834,
-0.052981358021497726,
0.49496766924858093,
0.4391096532344818,
0.05594021454453468,
0.4070238173007965,
-0.16012829542160034,
-0.16548962891101837,
0.06957083940505981,
-0.42447227239608765,
-0.4530799388885498,
1.2698293924331665,
0.7352030873298645,
0.6294668912887573,
-0.18219046294689178,
0.4119640588760376,
0.16997641324996948,
0.43703949451446533,
-0.5558443665504456,
0.24162736535072327,
-0.7739854454994202,
-0.258671373128891,
-0.5156760811805725,
-0.735462486743927,
-0.8730026483535767,
0.0978793129324913,
0.045833371579647064,
-0.29082638025283813,
0.007649250328540802,
-0.18308062851428986,
-0.8461472392082214,
0.34807711839675903,
-0.19802148640155792,
1.037909984588623,
-0.43357402086257935,
-0.21145819127559662,
-0.13325703144073486,
-0.3143274188041687,
0.876604437828064,
-0.7547374367713928,
0.3250969350337982,
-0.24571506679058075,
-0.14150680601596832,
0.5555446147918701,
-0.5254687666893005,
0.6631143689155579,
0.44095003604888916,
-0.5449910759925842,
0.22177492082118988,
-0.3049928843975067,
0.631314218044281,
0.1443619430065155,
-0.12736822664737701,
0.43419861793518066,
-0.06833221763372421,
-0.6183732748031616,
-0.36838382482528687,
0.7673805952072144,
-0.7329312562942505,
-0.4870603382587433,
-0.31030577421188354,
-0.7780095934867859,
-0.0052971565164625645,
0.16794688999652863,
0.0861462876200676,
0.2402314394712448,
-0.40621817111968994,
0.4396797716617584,
0.36871621012687683,
-0.35998860001564026,
0.523402214050293,
0.6065718531608582,
-0.38975900411605835,
-0.37123945355415344,
0.9889644384384155,
0.10964290797710419,
0.02474774233996868,
0.6011655330657959,
0.27578359842300415,
-0.16820579767227173,
-0.5745598077774048,
-0.4614380896091461,
0.27930402755737305,
-0.29102304577827454,
-0.3825288712978363,
-0.4140741229057312,
-0.6695339679718018,
-0.5742855072021484,
-0.2640056908130646,
-0.618299126625061,
-0.1533486694097519,
-0.315779447555542,
-0.057316962629556656,
0.45393702387809753,
0.5665116906166077,
-0.048216644674539566,
0.5593452453613281,
-1.2977946996688843,
0.346418559551239,
0.025780275464057922,
0.3233453035354614,
0.01614339090883732,
-0.5373742580413818,
-0.6416483521461487,
0.29613593220710754,
-0.19017063081264496,
-0.36957675218582153,
0.5248346924781799,
-0.06498956680297852,
0.48221027851104736,
0.7550665736198425,
0.15803371369838715,
0.6647281646728516,
-0.3613303303718567,
0.6255313158035278,
0.13886989653110504,
-0.6875022053718567,
0.09089720994234085,
-0.7549540996551514,
0.16563856601715088,
0.09792451560497284,
0.2789665758609772,
-0.6311920881271362,
-0.718380868434906,
-0.23065327107906342,
-0.9724363088607788,
0.9092168807983398,
0.14166764914989471,
0.3080242872238159,
-0.06731884181499481,
0.29852792620658875,
0.160374715924263,
0.27844318747520447,
-0.5492600202560425,
-0.1735536903142929,
0.055606722831726074,
-0.07423225790262222,
-0.12683247029781342,
-0.2368098944425583,
0.013162234798073769,
-0.12799720466136932,
0.5879674553871155,
-0.06838944554328918,
0.042530421167612076,
-0.025686806067824364,
0.34824419021606445,
-0.2349235713481903,
-0.029727749526500702,
0.713238000869751,
0.5383680462837219,
-0.10187751054763794,
-0.27694442868232727,
0.04952708259224892,
-0.46323251724243164,
-0.22858577966690063,
0.4821218252182007,
-0.14690136909484863,
-0.13202545046806335,
0.3467402458190918,
0.7079360485076904,
0.48531094193458557,
-0.8257466554641724,
0.6980193257331848,
-0.0043134852312505245,
-0.4077642858028412,
-0.6362156271934509,
-0.17858508229255676,
0.2728070616722107,
0.7050306797027588,
0.5399696230888367,
0.215412437915802,
0.020293373614549637,
-0.36249828338623047,
0.6192546486854553,
0.111629918217659,
-0.3361491858959198,
-0.14182645082473755,
0.9827279448509216,
0.3277926743030548,
0.09836891293525696,
0.726814329624176,
-0.005789286457002163,
-0.34033429622650146,
0.6997403502464294,
0.37563619017601013,
1.1270149946212769,
-0.05078218877315521,
0.1744258850812912,
0.13889575004577637,
0.3789714276790619,
-0.6282427906990051,
0.18968544900417328,
0.36491185426712036,
-0.7221876978874207,
-0.7629863619804382,
-0.9899677634239197,
-0.3635166585445404,
0.20614904165267944,
-0.51478511095047,
0.4041079878807068,
-0.35778820514678955,
-0.042030710726976395,
0.1258968859910965,
-0.13466843962669373,
-0.46355485916137695,
-0.004954115953296423,
0.39224010705947876,
1.1321910619735718,
-0.40984970331192017,
1.072317361831665,
0.3597746193408966,
-0.3065846562385559,
-0.681175172328949,
0.07749410718679428,
0.0847492441534996,
-0.7354246973991394,
0.6335673928260803,
-0.01452803984284401,
0.2314387857913971,
-0.15040850639343262,
-0.37055703997612,
-0.9133358001708984,
1.0489997863769531,
0.5371241569519043,
-0.8961617350578308,
-0.23650014400482178,
0.6325225830078125,
0.46304190158843994,
-0.430029034614563,
-0.24056117236614227,
0.5057135820388794,
0.616891086101532,
0.10761943459510803,
-1.1198238134384155,
-0.36995360255241394,
-0.12863603234291077,
-0.14679832756519318,
0.36197078227996826,
-1.1393885612487793,
1.174291968345642,
0.0915253609418869,
-0.013069244101643562,
0.08912374079227448,
1.1232596635818481,
-0.07028087973594666,
0.5739684700965881,
0.1923290491104126,
0.23439165949821472,
0.6863363981246948,
-0.188020721077919,
1.0734825134277344,
-0.5822075605392456,
0.3427392244338989,
0.9268359541893005,
-0.25549912452697754,
1.0235562324523926,
0.20182675123214722,
-0.1780986338853836,
-0.034608665853738785,
0.7889561653137207,
-0.2074451595544815,
0.25102564692497253,
0.33182376623153687,
-0.06300061196088791,
-0.3792382776737213,
-0.07856114953756332,
-0.18082614243030548,
0.41664400696754456,
0.32719945907592773,
-0.5925830602645874,
-0.31534042954444885,
0.20684029161930084,
0.08548180013895035,
0.22076071798801422,
-0.41596555709838867,
0.4706076681613922,
0.666546106338501,
-0.347496896982193,
0.2103351652622223,
0.4969821870326996,
0.83774334192276,
-0.5812714695930481,
0.37384068965911865,
-0.5322455763816833,
0.3719191551208496,
0.13186496496200562,
-0.7679902911186218,
0.7064439058303833,
0.1714164763689041,
-0.04571622237563133,
-0.5111674666404724,
0.5363359451293945,
-0.5761358737945557,
-0.7121731638908386,
0.5568634867668152,
0.45516493916511536,
0.21738877892494202,
-0.3626919090747833,
-0.7221161127090454,
-0.19966930150985718,
-0.00024384386779274791,
-0.5001599788665771,
0.5388821959495544,
0.89908766746521,
-0.10482262074947357,
0.4460551142692566,
0.9254910349845886,
-0.005621800664812326,
-0.26027876138687134,
-0.22582164406776428,
0.7543892860412598,
-0.9526538848876953,
-0.3991318345069885,
-0.9963979125022888,
0.12082421779632568,
0.07140905410051346,
-0.4019196927547455,
0.8001833558082581,
0.9099214673042297,
1.0747209787368774,
0.05452308431267738,
0.46194446086883545,
0.711290180683136,
0.3435221314430237,
-0.6461872458457947,
1.0464869737625122,
-0.7124965786933899,
0.4825057089328766,
-0.3048328459262848,
-0.9002495408058167,
-0.3097284734249115,
0.2572326362133026,
-0.24496592581272125,
-0.5166028141975403,
0.5796305537223816,
0.6090786457061768,
-0.163213849067688,
0.3434802293777466,
0.44512608647346497,
0.35386478900909424,
-0.061889149248600006,
0.6676503419876099,
0.5153028964996338,
-0.623742938041687,
1.0146234035491943,
-0.2798103392124176,
0.23837065696716309,
-0.31227225065231323,
-0.7418605089187622,
-0.8086228966712952,
-0.38667216897010803,
-0.3524138033390045,
-0.16086924076080322,
-0.038574282079935074,
0.8956769108772278,
0.1456170231103897,
-0.8806885480880737,
-0.6494953036308289,
0.22729136049747467,
0.029980100691318512,
-0.36381226778030396,
-0.18087874352931976,
0.4505901038646698,
-0.3789524734020233,
-0.8932374715805054,
0.3592272400856018,
0.4234621524810791,
0.24077990651130676,
-0.32010573148727417,
-0.11059724539518356,
0.20073401927947998,
0.2723053991794586,
0.6796530485153198,
-0.08044330775737762,
-0.7098090052604675,
-0.10819198936223984,
0.39035260677337646,
-0.659532368183136,
-0.014687473885715008,
0.6468740701675415,
-0.1646798700094223,
-0.19458365440368652,
0.5127245783805847,
1.0775916576385498,
0.2416733056306839,
0.12052779644727707,
0.9299643039703369,
-0.49899396300315857,
0.15943624079227448,
-0.029196174815297127,
0.3285296559333801,
0.03737686574459076,
-0.39236730337142944,
0.3702084422111511,
0.19888590276241302,
-0.5413325428962708,
-0.5785600543022156,
-0.5399475693702698,
-1.0650631189346313,
-0.5202538371086121,
1.053317904472351,
-0.3226355314254761,
-0.6391975283622742,
0.08364242315292358,
-0.08738593012094498,
0.09174464643001556,
-0.5258033871650696,
0.36599788069725037,
1.0392000675201416,
0.2268015742301941,
-0.14907053112983704,
-0.8907665610313416,
0.4176112413406372,
0.22960394620895386,
-0.2917039394378662,
0.2642494738101959,
0.2338094860315323,
-0.1256689578294754,
-0.08582121878862381,
0.5869359970092773,
-0.12390442937612534,
0.3219600319862366,
0.08622916787862778,
-0.23355647921562195,
-0.12089107930660248,
-0.2363954782485962,
-0.08368706703186035,
0.2857741415500641,
-0.2573755085468292,
-0.06726974993944168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01606v1 | On Discrete Prompt Optimization for Diffusion Models | 2024-06-27T02:53:01 | 2024-06-27T02:53:01 | Ruochen Wang, Ting Liu, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Boqing Gong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML, 68T01 | This paper introduces the first gradient-based framework for prompt
optimization in text-to-image diffusion models. We formulate prompt engineering
as a discrete optimization problem over the language space. Two major
challenges arise in efficiently finding a solution to this problem: (1)
Enormous Domain Space: Setting the domain to the entire language space poses
significant difficulty to the optimization process. (2) Text Gradient:
Efficiently computing the text gradient is challenging, as it requires
backpropagating through the inference steps of the diffusion model and a
non-differentiable embedding lookup table. Beyond the problem formulation, our
main technical contributions lie in solving the above challenges. First, we
design a family of dynamically generated compact subspaces comprised of only
the most relevant words to user input, substantially restricting the domain
space. Second, we introduce "Shortcut Text Gradient" -- an effective
replacement for the text gradient that can be obtained with constant memory and
runtime. Empirical evaluation on prompts collected from diverse sources
(DiffusionDB, ChatGPT, COCO) suggests that our method can discover prompts that
substantially improve (prompt enhancement) or destroy (adversarial attack) the
faithfulness of images generated by the text-to-image diffusion model. | [
-0.49185439944267273,
-1.0532726049423218,
0.9207277894020081,
0.5657891035079956,
-0.11944721639156342,
0.05595523864030838,
-0.12499096244573593,
0.19445104897022247,
-0.1447845995426178,
-0.04345941171050072,
-1.1140884160995483,
-0.3849889934062958,
-0.48840177059173584,
0.1612137258052826,
-0.2180386334657669,
0.762948751449585,
-0.036424532532691956,
-0.10241547971963882,
-0.35020551085472107,
0.09319104999303818,
-0.5741685032844543,
-0.06737377494573593,
-1.1271347999572754,
0.1016785204410553,
0.8171302676200867,
0.13361099362373352,
0.5395283102989197,
0.5961400270462036,
0.14683416485786438,
0.2317606806755066,
-0.3888099193572998,
-0.031038783490657806,
-0.5886451005935669,
0.1825072318315506,
-0.20570074021816254,
-0.07285044342279434,
0.1478218287229538,
-0.1605558842420578,
0.6107523441314697,
0.6593282222747803,
0.05557955801486969,
-0.19767975807189941,
0.1263321489095688,
0.7960465550422668,
-0.615710973739624,
-0.1734064221382141,
-0.21719762682914734,
0.1280440390110016,
-0.21510091423988342,
-0.2123880237340927,
-0.3062888979911804,
-0.6904777884483337,
0.21984286606311798,
-0.914858341217041,
0.17046412825584412,
0.16794539988040924,
0.5423040390014648,
0.5168715715408325,
-0.2335958033800125,
-0.49201565980911255,
-0.5110765099525452,
0.9172031879425049,
-0.1540513038635254,
0.01001900713890791,
0.06646224111318588,
0.37270256876945496,
-0.3438553810119629,
-0.8330500721931458,
-0.39070549607276917,
-0.13899445533752441,
0.1112816259264946,
0.006115596275776625,
-0.42509371042251587,
0.2745300829410553,
0.31829482316970825,
0.10249976813793182,
-0.7112074494361877,
0.12704099714756012,
0.07309682667255402,
-0.09599427133798599,
0.33040332794189453,
0.2884679138660431,
0.5876004695892334,
0.10910174995660782,
-0.42832404375076294,
0.05100530758500099,
-0.4812225103378296,
0.21089135110378265,
0.28686726093292236,
0.13537615537643433,
-0.19547297060489655,
0.10139484703540802,
0.058680299669504166,
0.508503794670105,
0.18180595338344574,
0.1634884625673294,
-0.062364645302295685,
-0.36412739753723145,
0.16396597027778625,
-0.34946104884147644,
0.7663691639900208,
0.2868581712245941,
0.12040059268474579,
0.07179835438728333,
-0.36711224913597107,
0.05623375624418259,
0.06212078407406807,
-1.0177826881408691,
-0.21743981540203094,
0.25034940242767334,
-0.6073832511901855,
-0.4047449231147766,
-0.4712866246700287,
-1.1083695888519287,
-0.6980581879615784,
-0.09410087019205093,
0.29587000608444214,
-0.2074608951807022,
-0.0017125941812992096,
0.09170332551002502,
-0.3383525013923645,
-0.12201139330863953,
0.5053218603134155,
-0.804011344909668,
0.25826895236968994,
0.5201368927955627,
1.155163288116455,
-0.29896196722984314,
0.019405655562877655,
-0.5295430421829224,
-0.393996000289917,
-0.36789271235466003,
0.8401660919189453,
-0.6713464856147766,
-1.0126088857650757,
0.1915295571088791,
-0.37881842255592346,
-0.05598427727818489,
-0.27304333448410034,
0.6086341738700867,
-0.45806100964546204,
0.4663594961166382,
-0.3521158993244171,
-0.4695221185684204,
0.08327773958444595,
-0.00017261803441215307,
-0.6546365022659302,
1.0389920473098755,
0.237389475107193,
-0.6702914237976074,
-0.06240096315741539,
-0.999393880367279,
-0.26078781485557556,
0.21246770024299622,
-0.25306299328804016,
-0.2822551131248474,
0.21014316380023956,
0.19369328022003174,
0.1588982343673706,
-0.5219113826751709,
0.22692762315273285,
-0.06702247262001038,
-0.15533992648124695,
0.11541221290826797,
-0.34298598766326904,
0.7988569736480713,
0.2462085783481598,
-0.16426317393779755,
0.02688838168978691,
-0.7161581516265869,
-0.24379076063632965,
0.12687186896800995,
-0.21324317157268524,
-0.37819039821624756,
0.24506531655788422,
0.09484066069126129,
0.17213185131549835,
0.2875540852546692,
-0.5860746502876282,
0.36555320024490356,
-0.1639123558998108,
0.3377399444580078,
1.0110321044921875,
0.421653687953949,
0.8118939995765686,
-0.16828252375125885,
1.0366538763046265,
-0.16257178783416748,
0.3876040577888489,
-0.4659263491630554,
-0.7736507058143616,
-0.2470967173576355,
-0.5706492066383362,
0.25743696093559265,
0.5866896510124207,
-1.0632245540618896,
-0.00967981293797493,
0.0530206635594368,
-0.19591209292411804,
-0.13948175311088562,
-0.261952668428421,
0.22542324662208557,
0.874065101146698,
0.195859894156456,
0.07850641012191772,
0.04999997839331627,
-0.8147971034049988,
-0.13556623458862305,
0.10986325144767761,
0.05352627858519554,
0.6585134267807007,
0.24856479465961456,
-0.3759476840496063,
1.0624994039535522,
-0.8759229183197021,
-0.06531182676553726,
0.09892644733190536,
0.2919219136238098,
0.3349928557872772,
0.4513862431049347,
0.9650932550430298,
-0.806857705116272,
-0.7489793300628662,
-0.17578639090061188,
-0.5629075169563293,
-0.6349426507949829,
-0.42897623777389526,
-0.3166670501232147,
-0.14681008458137512,
0.42588290572166443,
-0.7880953550338745,
0.42433640360832214,
0.2757705748081207,
-0.27771586179733276,
0.5069841742515564,
-0.09590029716491699,
0.06965310871601105,
-0.7591233849525452,
0.056619804352521896,
0.38987624645233154,
-0.0031484896317124367,
-0.7118538618087769,
0.057366084307432175,
0.06363067030906677,
-0.6355281472206116,
-0.5043048858642578,
1.1796869039535522,
-0.46441829204559326,
0.417131632566452,
-0.25381648540496826,
0.18379013240337372,
0.02003040909767151,
0.5840897560119629,
-0.21963585913181305,
0.9492741227149963,
0.9748652577400208,
-0.8060993552207947,
0.13102565705776215,
0.3325411379337311,
-0.22170165181159973,
0.9059886932373047,
-0.7910428047180176,
0.14561496675014496,
-0.572822093963623,
0.1791117787361145,
-1.2935309410095215,
0.18807625770568848,
0.5642643570899963,
-0.33452272415161133,
0.2809522747993469,
0.055980466306209564,
-0.1851489543914795,
-0.3733024597167969,
-0.4682619869709015,
0.6537293195724487,
0.8293067216873169,
-0.6278596520423889,
0.5175349116325378,
-0.11920080333948135,
-0.46782058477401733,
-0.6685845851898193,
-0.2230871021747589,
-0.03029281087219715,
-0.22343964874744415,
-0.8025801777839661,
0.5619325041770935,
-0.45730918645858765,
-0.05743062496185303,
-0.02725852094590664,
0.06442021578550339,
-0.11356492340564728,
0.22323080897331238,
-0.07976416498422623,
-0.01789078302681446,
0.011660565622150898,
0.13363243639469147,
0.3984123170375824,
-0.2765839099884033,
0.1354282796382904,
-0.43650904297828674,
0.30606338381767273,
0.39319664239883423,
-0.009730163030326366,
-0.47077175974845886,
0.7555108070373535,
0.21655146777629852,
0.03302513435482979,
0.4084014892578125,
0.40862423181533813,
-0.3299735486507416,
-0.5427834987640381,
-0.005221821833401918,
-0.08061949908733368,
-0.6077738404273987,
0.3159676194190979,
-0.471996545791626,
-0.7036909461021423,
0.5600405931472778,
-0.5392125248908997,
0.1604890674352646,
0.20898611843585968,
0.4634028375148773,
-0.1290886551141739,
1.0222511291503906,
0.7261161208152771,
0.11828158050775528,
0.8072255849838257,
-0.11217526346445084,
0.1818757802248001,
-0.5864620208740234,
-0.17904044687747955,
-0.8487839698791504,
-0.4503515362739563,
-0.2671833336353302,
-0.4324229657649994,
0.6020322442054749,
-0.07714780420064926,
-0.1844894289970398,
-0.10267765074968338,
-0.627181887626648,
0.495449960231781,
0.46633321046829224,
0.06485550105571747,
-0.17309479415416718,
0.14311395585536957,
-0.3645998239517212,
-0.3280516266822815,
-0.8127092123031616,
-0.21954524517059326,
0.3603796362876892,
0.32841116189956665,
0.9728018641471863,
-0.03506758436560631,
0.6678451299667358,
0.5910489559173584,
0.06052849814295769,
-0.8589969277381897,
0.6168426275253296,
-0.08502262830734253,
-0.1965363323688507,
-0.14360548555850983,
-0.4385315179824829,
-0.9968124628067017,
0.034791264683008194,
0.022413479164242744,
-0.5241041779518127,
0.48163285851478577,
0.17280462384223938,
-0.36241716146469116,
-0.1512671709060669,
-0.584739625453949,
0.7703065872192383,
-0.034807369112968445,
-0.37190595269203186,
-0.011603881604969501,
-0.5916350483894348,
0.17733991146087646,
-0.2804449200630188,
0.4058210551738739,
0.07737787812948227,
-0.3881502151489258,
0.4722132682800293,
-0.60292649269104,
0.7378758788108826,
-0.5602181553840637,
-0.23710651695728302,
0.21166007220745087,
0.264520525932312,
0.5599011778831482,
0.02758706547319889,
-0.0385020487010479,
-0.2146599441766739,
-0.2854672372341156,
-0.452597439289093,
-1.0449199676513672,
0.5999064445495605,
-0.5381484031677246,
-0.5501608848571777,
-0.22869889438152313,
-0.17382967472076416,
0.004616314545273781,
0.18911302089691162,
0.5704059600830078,
0.7013477087020874,
-0.38025397062301636,
-0.30971452593803406,
0.9644940495491028,
-0.6610717177391052,
0.9801785945892334,
0.14207173883914948,
-0.10340423882007599,
-0.41358816623687744,
1.0501521825790405,
-0.2583279013633728,
0.15527889132499695,
0.5309878587722778,
0.4390910863876343,
-0.49938565492630005,
-0.6091101765632629,
-0.7570175528526306,
0.14073680341243744,
-0.7817314863204956,
-0.10879828035831451,
-0.6787363290786743,
0.13726571202278137,
0.052504297345876694,
-0.5331491827964783,
-0.13026274740695953,
-0.43601685762405396,
-0.9399529099464417,
0.2961053252220154,
0.2775774300098419,
0.5190779566764832,
-0.0047249565832316875,
0.6148476600646973,
-0.722682774066925,
0.2964005470275879,
0.198404461145401,
0.21873408555984497,
-0.04331193119287491,
-0.3037320673465729,
-0.18587641417980194,
-0.25115206837654114,
-0.2980921268463135,
-0.9038507342338562,
0.26618629693984985,
0.326911598443985,
0.65196293592453,
0.46290621161460876,
0.029741961508989334,
0.2708544433116913,
-0.8754004836082458,
1.194226622581482,
0.33772915601730347,
-0.8908735513687134,
0.7003526091575623,
-0.493173211812973,
0.27372419834136963,
0.3163483440876007,
0.5755886435508728,
-0.4998648464679718,
0.08088767528533936,
-0.43777501583099365,
-0.7373535633087158,
0.40631765127182007,
0.19751980900764465,
0.4105012118816376,
-0.2441941350698471,
0.5845895409584045,
0.147995725274086,
0.32218557596206665,
-0.39694464206695557,
-0.48862093687057495,
0.003074329113587737,
-0.4739776849746704,
0.32930466532707214,
-0.3714124262332916,
-0.08645427227020264,
0.11619167029857635,
0.6110701560974121,
-0.12553457915782928,
0.47331807017326355,
0.053216736763715744,
0.0943945124745369,
0.014395136386156082,
-0.03616701066493988,
0.9469009637832642,
0.40619373321533203,
0.3061325252056122,
-0.2563400864601135,
-0.34941354393959045,
-0.45675042271614075,
0.46741780638694763,
0.17229865491390228,
-0.5732618570327759,
0.2880496084690094,
-0.13156253099441528,
0.8419932126998901,
-0.018106505274772644,
-0.3285660147666931,
0.8411079049110413,
-0.38508084416389465,
-0.25841644406318665,
0.07966969907283783,
-0.021311908960342407,
-0.44656357169151306,
0.2191120982170105,
0.501507580280304,
0.2114863246679306,
0.3727828562259674,
0.10208223015069962,
0.07638388872146606,
0.5904501080513,
-0.271621972322464,
-0.2670731544494629,
0.9599905014038086,
0.5491743087768555,
-0.6733475923538208,
0.36463281512260437,
-0.25105705857276917,
-0.37754663825035095,
0.6398287415504456,
0.3170008957386017,
1.1416643857955933,
-0.2359122633934021,
0.5560627579689026,
0.259420782327652,
0.11680493503808975,
-0.11909788846969604,
0.3064837157726288,
-0.11017309874296188,
-0.40620648860931396,
-0.30132362246513367,
-0.3330554664134979,
-0.3926202952861786,
-0.33649590611457825,
-0.19203059375286102,
0.3835321068763733,
-0.7018657326698303,
-0.369035929441452,
-0.08012410253286362,
-0.17974533140659332,
-0.4789435863494873,
0.21029923856258392,
-0.07623797655105591,
0.9990917444229126,
-0.6186410784721375,
0.29628872871398926,
0.5698103308677673,
-0.11114668101072311,
-0.2580021321773529,
-0.11434421688318253,
0.011757832951843739,
-0.6075807213783264,
0.5495717525482178,
-0.08024550974369049,
-0.021899521350860596,
0.362434446811676,
-0.7754883766174316,
-0.6319989562034607,
0.7780051827430725,
0.22057634592056274,
-0.4060012996196747,
-0.14223182201385498,
-0.35521209239959717,
0.28317710757255554,
-0.2756612300872803,
0.14801302552223206,
0.2762278616428375,
0.3876815736293793,
0.15707877278327942,
-0.2928062379360199,
0.13803979754447937,
-0.3581235408782959,
0.5184496641159058,
0.1657402366399765,
-0.5586171746253967,
0.9083468914031982,
-0.06601022183895111,
-0.585731029510498,
0.3644493520259857,
0.6081971526145935,
0.1335763931274414,
0.39166259765625,
0.34137919545173645,
0.36327433586120605,
0.9015734195709229,
-0.0788143202662468,
1.253515601158142,
-0.2899048924446106,
0.28229957818984985,
0.5604379773139954,
-0.12514536082744598,
0.046913739293813705,
0.5121451616287231,
-0.11420545727014542,
0.5706884264945984,
0.9728364944458008,
0.16153033077716827,
1.0643644332885742,
0.38616952300071716,
-0.6694292426109314,
0.30556511878967285,
-0.2010064274072647,
-0.3204842507839203,
-0.4802553951740265,
0.5044732689857483,
-0.24571582674980164,
-0.3987979590892792,
0.28445741534233093,
-0.12103862315416336,
0.13561010360717773,
-0.3292209506034851,
0.5548053979873657,
0.1481037735939026,
-0.4810470640659332,
0.38914984464645386,
0.21805699169635773,
0.7612776756286621,
-0.46526899933815,
0.061879612505435944,
-0.5321534872055054,
-0.30144190788269043,
0.012329569086432457,
-0.5073614716529846,
-0.0252970103174448,
-0.1154908537864685,
-0.26213639974594116,
-0.5483205914497375,
0.7547311186790466,
-0.1603241115808487,
-0.22698742151260376,
-0.13280203938484192,
0.4209931194782257,
0.02265046164393425,
-0.019662216305732727,
-0.8937550187110901,
0.0729144886136055,
-0.054181355983018875,
-0.32072341442108154,
0.13052619993686676,
0.7023375034332275,
0.07375826686620712,
0.6673790812492371,
0.4588905870914459,
-0.060213152319192886,
0.08200493454933167,
0.05530412867665291,
0.9302157759666443,
-0.5129824876785278,
-0.9209376573562622,
-1.0262470245361328,
0.76351398229599,
0.0018488020868971944,
-0.3701261878013611,
0.3549257814884186,
0.21941882371902466,
0.1367063671350479,
-0.3081589937210083,
1.0071760416030884,
0.02656065858900547,
0.25038623809814453,
-0.5926698446273804,
0.4313173294067383,
-0.546923816204071,
0.1418316662311554,
-0.4667515158653259,
-1.1160808801651,
-0.2328720986843109,
0.6064701676368713,
-0.08182993531227112,
0.15487413108348846,
0.8708377480506897,
0.8690144419670105,
0.05933229252696037,
-0.0003523711930029094,
0.2080584019422531,
-0.2852935194969177,
0.43107369542121887,
0.644404947757721,
1.1085642576217651,
-0.2325018048286438,
0.21815986931324005,
0.013425440527498722,
-0.6047239899635315,
-0.041002001613378525,
-1.13581120967865,
-0.8927205801010132,
-0.5506687164306641,
-0.6294460296630859,
-0.24601955711841583,
-0.07100596278905869,
0.735018253326416,
0.5657631754875183,
-0.23149338364601135,
0.1850757747888565,
-0.3590225279331207,
0.37563204765319824,
0.07225748151540756,
-0.26017165184020996,
0.24556304514408112,
-0.4513334333896637,
-0.8365569114685059,
0.402942955493927,
0.4405714273452759,
0.4056049585342407,
-0.2976883351802826,
-0.03214895352721214,
0.11894398927688599,
0.36261212825775146,
0.5793170928955078,
0.4674108028411865,
-0.2828008234500885,
-0.0513392835855484,
0.2813960909843445,
-0.3109692633152008,
0.006143562030047178,
1.0762770175933838,
-0.6195810437202454,
0.29030275344848633,
0.6380722522735596,
1.1193307638168335,
0.29182279109954834,
0.20671607553958893,
0.5593667030334473,
-1.1828210353851318,
0.2925821840763092,
0.22342024743556976,
0.10715098679065704,
0.23587049543857574,
-0.6149673461914062,
0.3452762961387634,
0.4722629189491272,
-0.5129415392875671,
-0.6033936142921448,
0.3574114739894867,
-0.9363047480583191,
-0.48992109298706055,
1.151882529258728,
0.04165031388401985,
-0.30076688528060913,
-0.004811652936041355,
-0.5065392255783081,
-0.189283549785614,
-0.6022621393203735,
0.4913136661052704,
0.6946495175361633,
-0.1776992231607437,
-0.460543155670166,
-0.3843773603439331,
0.910514771938324,
0.3334577679634094,
-0.7416983842849731,
-0.3292508125305176,
0.8489564061164856,
-0.0010834693675860763,
0.006268128752708435,
1.0586676597595215,
0.14988596737384796,
0.36386850476264954,
-0.11927980184555054,
-0.2739797830581665,
0.09979097545146942,
-0.42385926842689514,
-0.6791931390762329,
0.1582990139722824,
-0.13344617187976837,
-0.44529882073402405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18847v1 | Learning Retrieval Augmentation for Personalized Dialogue Generation | 2024-06-27T02:38:13 | 2024-06-27T02:38:13 | Qiushi Huang, Shuai Fu, Xubo Liu, Wenwu Wang, Tom Ko, Yu Zhang, Lilian Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Personalized dialogue generation, focusing on generating highly tailored
responses by leveraging persona profiles and dialogue context, has gained
significant attention in conversational AI applications. However, persona
profiles, a prevalent setting in current personalized dialogue datasets,
typically composed of merely four to five sentences, may not offer
comprehensive descriptions of the persona about the agent, posing a challenge
to generate truly personalized dialogues. To handle this problem, we propose
$\textbf{L}$earning Retrieval $\textbf{A}$ugmentation for
$\textbf{P}$ersonalized $\textbf{D}$ial$\textbf{O}$gue $\textbf{G}$eneration
($\textbf{LAPDOG}$), which studies the potential of leveraging external
knowledge for persona dialogue generation. Specifically, the proposed LAPDOG
model consists of a story retriever and a dialogue generator. The story
retriever uses a given persona profile as queries to retrieve relevant
information from the story document, which serves as a supplementary context to
augment the persona profile. The dialogue generator utilizes both the dialogue
history and the augmented persona profile to generate personalized responses.
For optimization, we adopt a joint training framework that collaboratively
learns the story retriever and dialogue generator, where the story retriever is
optimized towards desired ultimate metrics (e.g., BLEU) to retrieve content for
the dialogue generator to generate personalized responses. Experiments
conducted on the CONVAI2 dataset with ROCStory as a supplementary data source
show that the proposed LAPDOG method substantially outperforms the baselines,
indicating the effectiveness of the proposed method. The LAPDOG model code is
publicly available for further exploration.
https://github.com/hqsiswiliam/LAPDOG | [
-0.4115704298019409,
-0.7292227149009705,
0.6159089803695679,
0.0780106708407402,
-0.09636316448450089,
0.23529617488384247,
-0.14799129962921143,
-0.42122378945350647,
0.27662599086761475,
0.6348553895950317,
-0.6056405901908875,
-0.2422911524772644,
-0.03344554081559181,
-0.07886570692062378,
0.12391484528779984,
1.0418503284454346,
0.4253101944923401,
-0.062118902802467346,
-0.346561461687088,
-0.1979028731584549,
-0.5513015985488892,
-0.5482512712478638,
-0.8201603293418884,
-0.5477891564369202,
0.4758700430393219,
0.3980453312397003,
0.2242840677499771,
0.22141627967357635,
0.17256982624530792,
0.27439287304878235,
-0.005741048138588667,
0.27825596928596497,
-0.58967524766922,
0.5825983285903931,
0.04162253439426422,
-0.3187122046947479,
-0.23218709230422974,
0.04479426145553589,
0.46905040740966797,
0.48836514353752136,
-0.34116795659065247,
0.20221936702728271,
0.0002054529031738639,
0.6882238984107971,
-0.6186789870262146,
0.1705239713191986,
-0.45132511854171753,
0.02042526565492153,
0.07665365934371948,
-0.34698745608329773,
-0.5934703350067139,
-0.4134519100189209,
0.5292370319366455,
-0.6212771534919739,
0.37055110931396484,
0.24194969236850739,
0.6455481052398682,
0.07759092003107071,
-0.1732298880815506,
-0.28760290145874023,
-0.7429589629173279,
0.5830228328704834,
-0.4220694303512573,
0.15751250088214874,
0.46047472953796387,
0.5610491037368774,
-0.06888899207115173,
-0.9377433657646179,
-0.5208189487457275,
-0.5479453802108765,
-0.19932205975055695,
0.25352728366851807,
-0.16670270264148712,
0.09809179604053497,
0.21847429871559143,
0.47616085410118103,
-0.33560192584991455,
0.0916486456990242,
-0.27646616101264954,
-0.209892138838768,
0.7204350829124451,
0.4217509925365448,
-0.0323517769575119,
-0.2334199845790863,
-0.3216630816459656,
-0.4016692042350769,
-0.5682020783424377,
0.43324515223503113,
0.5568057894706726,
0.2215898633003235,
-0.015201197005808353,
0.45525598526000977,
-0.3514281213283539,
0.5687553286552429,
0.6246545314788818,
-0.13298065960407257,
0.3638259172439575,
-0.2688295841217041,
-0.1873696744441986,
0.1167844757437706,
0.7389993667602539,
0.3082037568092346,
-0.028798624873161316,
-0.18383674323558807,
-0.20533739030361176,
-0.6065254807472229,
0.5674702525138855,
-0.9047002196311951,
-0.43270209431648254,
0.3108990788459778,
-0.37613701820373535,
-0.48083505034446716,
-0.09115960448980331,
-0.7670552134513855,
-0.6505966782569885,
-0.22560328245162964,
0.2475171685218811,
-0.448381632566452,
0.1485581398010254,
-0.21933069825172424,
-0.20666618645191193,
0.19696469604969025,
0.4891224801540375,
-0.938677191734314,
-0.006869316101074219,
0.324544221162796,
0.5888992547988892,
0.14030125737190247,
-0.05413693189620972,
-0.9615443348884583,
0.08051257580518723,
0.05164613947272301,
0.7058179378509521,
-0.7902987003326416,
-0.5591683983802795,
0.11451376229524612,
-0.18914978206157684,
-0.1921398639678955,
-0.5986729860305786,
0.5060335397720337,
-0.48418372869491577,
0.6238093972206116,
-0.2614838778972626,
-0.5273512005805969,
-0.24346326291561127,
0.21683353185653687,
-0.46207505464553833,
0.7860345840454102,
0.37801745533943176,
-0.6218172311782837,
0.21694037318229675,
-0.5740050673484802,
-0.2657453119754791,
0.473569393157959,
-0.4312484562397003,
-0.4699501395225525,
0.12257260084152222,
0.36088356375694275,
0.5028631687164307,
-0.39070335030555725,
0.18700271844863892,
-0.15256138145923615,
-0.48747915029525757,
0.21684898436069489,
-0.27725130319595337,
0.5529553890228271,
0.18685685098171234,
-0.16282321512699127,
0.07864558696746826,
-0.7786828875541687,
-0.1329040676355362,
0.19431355595588684,
-0.5145106911659241,
-0.22280681133270264,
0.060337115079164505,
-0.09709557890892029,
-0.1334831714630127,
0.2500111758708954,
-0.8076277375221252,
0.18165245652198792,
-0.38945794105529785,
-0.0056417896412312984,
0.6680819988250732,
0.5129535794258118,
0.40408042073249817,
-0.4601248800754547,
0.5506768226623535,
-0.023082979023456573,
-0.13984699547290802,
-0.6219459772109985,
-0.2433214634656906,
-0.6017103791236877,
-0.3228498101234436,
0.1940949261188507,
0.5866063237190247,
-0.6680241227149963,
0.48301205039024353,
-0.10700929164886475,
-0.19423365592956543,
-0.7403385043144226,
0.05480032414197922,
0.583587110042572,
0.8176894187927246,
0.23294751346111298,
-0.3866284489631653,
-0.5984222888946533,
-0.9259184002876282,
-0.17450886964797974,
-0.27687573432922363,
-0.4034070670604706,
0.7914949655532837,
0.06155947595834732,
-0.1349579244852066,
1.01819908618927,
-0.560826301574707,
-0.4670836329460144,
-0.5030182003974915,
0.15498439967632294,
0.12257469445466995,
0.3498426079750061,
0.4828389286994934,
-0.7406138777732849,
-0.6073269844055176,
0.03334445133805275,
-0.6778600811958313,
0.015291612595319748,
-0.3446064889431,
-0.024082370102405548,
-0.11172359436750412,
0.235270157456398,
-0.5166943073272705,
0.34248748421669006,
0.11876748502254486,
-0.12582457065582275,
0.524010181427002,
-0.3782635033130646,
0.2625858187675476,
-1.2539992332458496,
0.32063809037208557,
0.25088343024253845,
-0.44010111689567566,
-0.5903509855270386,
0.043149735778570175,
-0.26390692591667175,
-0.2489629089832306,
-0.3808724582195282,
0.5799175500869751,
-0.18343566358089447,
-0.015273905359208584,
-0.14689388871192932,
0.35323366522789,
0.023449720814824104,
0.8271169662475586,
0.08492479473352432,
0.892936646938324,
0.15471316874027252,
-0.6972127556800842,
0.49949198961257935,
0.7720687985420227,
-0.30902355909347534,
0.7734549641609192,
-0.8045670986175537,
0.5961377024650574,
-0.38796910643577576,
0.53424471616745,
-0.6581758856773376,
-0.4306410253047943,
0.4850192368030548,
-0.6635959148406982,
0.30291327834129333,
-0.33416905999183655,
-0.31086352467536926,
-0.11471489071846008,
-0.3730153441429138,
0.07608788460493088,
0.6427322626113892,
-0.8952720165252686,
0.5881299376487732,
0.4581014811992645,
-0.3540152311325073,
-0.29534292221069336,
-0.0629926398396492,
-0.08454861491918564,
-0.3701895475387573,
-0.6377745270729065,
0.35958677530288696,
-0.21077567338943481,
-0.15763001143932343,
-0.3761399984359741,
0.15685728192329407,
0.26136165857315063,
-0.2035737931728363,
0.18491898477077484,
0.14585375785827637,
0.07975888252258301,
0.15547612309455872,
0.14806674420833588,
0.02184062823653221,
-0.07062509655952454,
-0.072977215051651,
0.7022786736488342,
-0.08805103600025177,
0.048633329570293427,
-0.43794697523117065,
0.2461298108100891,
0.2774120271205902,
-0.4374842047691345,
0.7938638925552368,
0.8917934894561768,
-0.04098498076200485,
-0.024187888950109482,
-0.6415426731109619,
-0.20943795144557953,
-0.49243924021720886,
0.32190099358558655,
-0.607429027557373,
-0.8943511843681335,
0.5718899965286255,
-0.05640494078397751,
0.1272437423467636,
0.21193565428256989,
0.5642426609992981,
-0.2623123228549957,
1.2444648742675781,
0.33854034543037415,
-0.09245505928993225,
0.6657744646072388,
-0.20576858520507812,
0.0742204487323761,
-1.457486629486084,
-0.7430562376976013,
-0.33772748708724976,
-0.17351268231868744,
-0.5470832586288452,
-0.23970328271389008,
0.5965508818626404,
-0.08733616024255753,
-0.23472562432289124,
0.19820377230644226,
-0.36646562814712524,
0.2543765902519226,
0.8329758644104004,
0.35929226875305176,
0.2306004911661148,
0.32650816440582275,
-0.1979708969593048,
-0.22112512588500977,
-0.41339829564094543,
-0.4196866750717163,
1.0732423067092896,
0.45969289541244507,
0.7544221878051758,
0.17667734622955322,
0.7795057892799377,
0.532011866569519,
-0.03374097868800163,
-0.6432717442512512,
0.484920859336853,
0.06472538411617279,
-0.2846321761608124,
-0.20965014398097992,
-0.5068904161453247,
-1.038169026374817,
0.49069181084632874,
-0.07834981381893158,
-1.3791677951812744,
0.25297388434410095,
0.23219256103038788,
-0.6514380574226379,
-0.14223383367061615,
-0.5053763389587402,
0.5812839865684509,
-0.22737360000610352,
-0.5624198317527771,
-0.45124420523643494,
-0.8841775059700012,
0.33758971095085144,
0.019991565495729446,
-0.4228094816207886,
0.0003337220987305045,
0.3998754322528839,
0.37910979986190796,
-0.33526745438575745,
0.687046468257904,
-0.35958173871040344,
0.09402487426996231,
0.4079928696155548,
-0.012082957662642002,
0.8607302904129028,
0.4828699231147766,
-0.10282126069068909,
-0.5559155344963074,
-0.13999031484127045,
-0.30948808789253235,
-0.6297090649604797,
0.6304885149002075,
-0.6268157958984375,
-0.6890024542808533,
-0.29648494720458984,
-0.31514620780944824,
-0.46970334649086,
-0.11920777708292007,
0.31292247772216797,
0.5495235919952393,
-0.42819851636886597,
0.37022945284843445,
0.7841099500656128,
-0.576861560344696,
0.24474051594734192,
0.7325877547264099,
0.023411588743329048,
-0.41662564873695374,
1.0987372398376465,
-0.7146168947219849,
-0.033751487731933594,
0.45509621500968933,
0.04750578850507736,
-0.5345137715339661,
-0.3982480764389038,
-0.556248128414154,
0.1357744187116623,
-0.4627189636230469,
-0.147603377699852,
-0.7614761590957642,
-0.15417638421058655,
-0.37704217433929443,
0.14840033650398254,
-0.1474030613899231,
-0.1697029024362564,
-0.36210066080093384,
-0.029677990823984146,
0.14277346432209015,
0.49504125118255615,
0.19109201431274414,
0.40102267265319824,
-0.8979312181472778,
0.2214502990245819,
0.3856180012226105,
-0.0016134842298924923,
-0.17172075808048248,
-0.6703088283538818,
-0.25396788120269775,
0.3429700434207916,
-0.6375113129615784,
-0.688041627407074,
0.5294287204742432,
0.35347306728363037,
0.7571307420730591,
0.33851897716522217,
0.13590051233768463,
0.5579744577407837,
-0.4604067802429199,
0.6556442379951477,
0.12722870707511902,
-0.4376365542411804,
0.8263687491416931,
-0.417955607175827,
0.22154070436954498,
0.9820953011512756,
0.2414073348045349,
-0.5901419520378113,
-0.2905733287334442,
-0.6732019782066345,
-0.8018134832382202,
0.8820067644119263,
0.34265416860580444,
0.3516893684864044,
0.09884130209684372,
0.5579503178596497,
0.12673111259937286,
0.404035359621048,
-0.37384551763534546,
-0.12691046297550201,
0.11761871725320816,
-0.10554710030555725,
-0.06550848484039307,
-0.14608581364154816,
-0.048647359013557434,
-0.2246330827474594,
0.670287013053894,
-0.17801205813884735,
0.4292429983615875,
0.33522725105285645,
-0.19998422265052795,
-0.06836064904928207,
0.09138721972703934,
0.3026468753814697,
0.36697033047676086,
-0.5889255404472351,
-0.47908130288124084,
-0.16661016643047333,
-0.2681989371776581,
-0.03235296532511711,
0.4260382056236267,
-0.2837793529033661,
-0.0346241258084774,
-0.0728069543838501,
1.1754511594772339,
0.1021929457783699,
-0.9335876703262329,
0.5012426972389221,
-0.3536689877510071,
0.040397386997938156,
-0.6931469440460205,
0.1519329696893692,
-0.36626410484313965,
0.5921027064323425,
0.4745863974094391,
-0.018931899219751358,
0.39429187774658203,
-0.5699041485786438,
0.24629248678684235,
0.34900331497192383,
-0.29867270588874817,
-0.31724435091018677,
0.7089723348617554,
0.6171280145645142,
-0.47256916761398315,
1.0753676891326904,
-0.31812840700149536,
-0.3741034269332886,
0.2180808186531067,
0.3987165093421936,
0.9229516386985779,
-0.2516099512577057,
0.6241248846054077,
0.4579668641090393,
-0.20110614597797394,
0.20778459310531616,
-0.24741284549236298,
-0.4393787086009979,
-0.508792519569397,
-0.10704216361045837,
-0.7991346120834351,
-0.46791067719459534,
0.4668469727039337,
-0.7419871091842651,
0.06642096489667892,
-0.30026906728744507,
0.02486271783709526,
-0.14423592388629913,
0.2823735773563385,
-0.8029218912124634,
0.17545443773269653,
0.18744909763336182,
0.49165502190589905,
-0.3267487585544586,
0.6206818222999573,
0.7598618865013123,
-0.6243379712104797,
-0.5559753179550171,
0.2124084234237671,
-0.15214888751506805,
-0.678677499294281,
0.3066460192203522,
0.21902582049369812,
0.07773389667272568,
0.05455002933740616,
-0.25161033868789673,
-0.36723169684410095,
1.2719902992248535,
0.38452279567718506,
-0.7628879547119141,
-0.2984393239021301,
-0.15011632442474365,
0.6855461001396179,
-0.8132562041282654,
0.3400767147541046,
0.6493897438049316,
0.01875828392803669,
0.4414798319339752,
-0.6990742087364197,
-0.10488307476043701,
-0.3637142777442932,
0.050933919847011566,
-0.018582798540592194,
-0.8670095801353455,
0.4122367203235626,
-0.32608169317245483,
-0.08058782666921616,
0.3763997554779053,
0.5182549953460693,
0.5726759433746338,
0.40834176540374756,
0.29729869961738586,
0.5154498219490051,
0.820592999458313,
0.2458873689174652,
1.388372778892517,
-0.28755801916122437,
0.23992809653282166,
1.4824362993240356,
-0.1889209896326065,
0.6869024038314819,
0.19131237268447876,
-0.05584048107266426,
0.6139001846313477,
0.7172142863273621,
-0.004007583949714899,
0.6827244162559509,
-0.0337514691054821,
-0.7421584129333496,
-0.23432917892932892,
-0.16068780422210693,
-0.15245431661605835,
0.5556303858757019,
0.3580577075481415,
-0.8078687191009521,
0.10556226968765259,
0.08317562937736511,
-0.17687249183654785,
0.026871055364608765,
-0.0028326683677732944,
1.1022359132766724,
-0.0450337678194046,
-0.9727883338928223,
0.3755650818347931,
0.020536739379167557,
0.2839421331882477,
-0.40441280603408813,
-0.09900642931461334,
-0.5573036670684814,
0.3556770384311676,
0.13656751811504364,
-0.44492191076278687,
-0.20435374975204468,
-0.12687446177005768,
0.057995423674583435,
-0.33822101354599,
0.7071454524993896,
-0.6724181771278381,
-0.25424477458000183,
-0.07140128314495087,
0.5532266497612,
0.10975006967782974,
-0.1849592924118042,
-0.6376041769981384,
-0.14910343289375305,
0.2578209936618805,
-0.2739848494529724,
0.6027078032493591,
-0.17168028652668,
0.251302033662796,
0.7281467914581299,
0.4197920262813568,
-0.25382867455482483,
-0.2124425768852234,
0.3327285945415497,
0.9587490558624268,
-0.3664588928222656,
-0.576757550239563,
-0.41569456458091736,
0.6653269529342651,
-0.3629826009273529,
-0.32608240842819214,
0.6714354157447815,
0.7806260585784912,
0.6856239438056946,
-0.08496693521738052,
0.8803285956382751,
-0.12339487671852112,
0.7338234782218933,
-0.44273337721824646,
0.5054180026054382,
-0.42443934082984924,
0.6299142241477966,
-0.020689209923148155,
-1.017850637435913,
0.4287271499633789,
0.723293662071228,
0.01630534417927265,
0.12083517014980316,
0.4166090786457062,
0.6060076951980591,
-0.025829266756772995,
0.012492415495216846,
0.2529984712600708,
-0.058327700942754745,
0.4970710277557373,
0.5181877017021179,
0.7941323518753052,
-0.33477237820625305,
0.498659610748291,
-0.3444894552230835,
-0.13421015441417694,
-0.32077091932296753,
-0.27382415533065796,
-1.0771061182022095,
-0.8003667593002319,
-0.33321303129196167,
-0.5050110816955566,
0.35005220770835876,
0.9398971199989319,
0.643629789352417,
-0.4407270848751068,
-0.11299373209476471,
-0.1254679262638092,
-0.2774524986743927,
0.16762030124664307,
-0.2879621684551239,
-0.03596740961074829,
-0.5462157130241394,
-0.9954237937927246,
0.7738386988639832,
0.1373896598815918,
0.02360289916396141,
-0.26794448494911194,
-0.357437402009964,
0.04096143692731857,
-0.017815429717302322,
0.5578393936157227,
0.4853963255882263,
-0.596603512763977,
-0.3663898706436157,
-0.11020947247743607,
0.16553416848182678,
0.16224463284015656,
1.1412973403930664,
-1.202393889427185,
0.8088069558143616,
0.34194254875183105,
0.6403143405914307,
1.0600497722625732,
0.47078999876976013,
0.9878213405609131,
-1.1852720975875854,
0.10546547919511795,
0.45288777351379395,
0.1736781746149063,
0.530629575252533,
-0.621110200881958,
0.4479212462902069,
0.06822024285793304,
-0.5802636742591858,
-0.6660903692245483,
0.3432144224643707,
-0.8905786871910095,
0.1457349956035614,
0.9383414387702942,
-0.42383554577827454,
0.05165678262710571,
0.10562008619308472,
-0.5376986265182495,
0.07192417234182358,
-0.8259763717651367,
0.8018892407417297,
0.2818533778190613,
-0.5189157128334045,
-0.543574333190918,
-0.32753103971481323,
0.5493367314338684,
0.32105547189712524,
-0.7502827644348145,
-0.10923614352941513,
0.7239757180213928,
0.1581583023071289,
0.07495942711830139,
0.7249029278755188,
0.09151353687047958,
0.397430419921875,
-0.05033990368247032,
-0.21620872616767883,
-0.16641266644001007,
-0.17737175524234772,
-0.32389989495277405,
0.12394264340400696,
0.0037152497097849846,
-0.26861372590065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18832v1 | OutlierTune: Efficient Channel-Wise Quantization for Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T02:02:26 | 2024-06-27T02:02:26 | Jinguang Wang, Yuexi Yin, Haifeng Sun, Qi Qi, Jingyu Wang, Zirui Zhuang, Tingting Yang, Jianxin Liao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Quantizing the activations of large language models (LLMs) has been a
significant challenge due to the presence of structured outliers. Most existing
methods focus on the per-token or per-tensor quantization of activations,
making it difficult to achieve both accuracy and hardware efficiency. To
address this problem, we propose OutlierTune, an efficient per-channel
post-training quantization (PTQ) method for the activations of LLMs.
OutlierTune consists of two components: pre-execution of dequantization and
symmetrization. The pre-execution of dequantization updates the model weights
by the activation scaling factors, avoiding the internal scaling and costly
additional computational overheads brought by the per-channel activation
quantization. The symmetrization further reduces the quantization differences
arising from the weight updates by ensuring the balanced numerical ranges
across different activation channels. OutlierTune is easy to implement and
hardware-efficient, introducing almost no additional computational overheads
during the inference. Extensive experiments show that the proposed framework
outperforms existing methods across multiple different tasks. Demonstrating
better generalization, this framework improves the Int6 quantization of the
instruction-tuning LLMs, such as OPT-IML, to the same level as half-precision
(FP16). Moreover, we have shown that the proposed framework is 1.48x faster
than the FP16 implementation while reducing approximately 2x memory usage. | [
-0.0635169968008995,
-0.6684525012969971,
0.4688047170639038,
0.21426118910312653,
-0.5166524052619934,
0.02067408710718155,
-0.3602011203765869,
0.2693385183811188,
-0.15532150864601135,
0.21296949684619904,
-0.36559125781059265,
-0.4861263632774353,
-0.46516910195350647,
-0.31230780482292175,
-0.5188177227973938,
0.5861340761184692,
0.37450480461120605,
0.30539005994796753,
-0.03886310011148453,
-0.037711530923843384,
0.026907959952950478,
-0.5504333972930908,
-0.7404437065124512,
-0.12396009266376495,
0.12209209054708481,
0.4070800840854645,
0.7602763772010803,
0.5196926593780518,
0.49356475472450256,
0.3364297151565552,
-0.2536959648132324,
-0.04762919992208481,
-0.6617909669876099,
-0.018787404522299767,
0.31473416090011597,
-0.4318709969520569,
-0.4325272738933563,
-0.30561569333076477,
0.909235954284668,
0.5308446884155273,
-0.1665046364068985,
0.2017311155796051,
0.1451716274023056,
0.6593665480613708,
-0.6974505186080933,
-0.05265088379383087,
-0.5201281905174255,
-0.10343006253242493,
-0.4093737006187439,
-0.16153515875339508,
-0.3835187554359436,
-0.44891679286956787,
-0.2664424479007721,
-0.5481500029563904,
-0.06266367435455322,
-0.2650175392627716,
0.4477163553237915,
0.4649523198604584,
-0.31525087356567383,
0.090418241918087,
-0.3997421860694885,
0.8623431324958801,
-1.1068711280822754,
0.6868118643760681,
0.18635901808738708,
0.1034439206123352,
-0.3553900718688965,
-0.6871122717857361,
-0.4055294990539551,
-0.13122354447841644,
0.14658766984939575,
0.031814198940992355,
-0.2719201445579529,
0.2923535704612732,
0.38543033599853516,
0.49540433287620544,
-0.7862712740898132,
0.2266513705253601,
0.044421903789043427,
-0.10971699655056,
0.425334095954895,
-0.2894275188446045,
0.19829683005809784,
0.1196017861366272,
-0.14668282866477966,
-0.19834382832050323,
-0.8899580240249634,
0.0799504891037941,
0.7343197464942932,
-0.010395835153758526,
0.07111535221338272,
0.4386540353298187,
-0.09663859009742737,
0.6346201300621033,
0.2348625212907791,
0.016354892402887344,
0.24424169957637787,
-0.2546279728412628,
-0.3874996304512024,
0.3424704670906067,
0.8104344606399536,
-0.020748963579535484,
0.16709987819194794,
0.017792196944355965,
-0.2851993143558502,
-0.08205273002386093,
0.02263481169939041,
-1.1067081689834595,
-0.4642854332923889,
0.3728006184101105,
-0.4254409074783325,
-0.30644896626472473,
-0.05724908784031868,
-0.4857649505138397,
-0.307807058095932,
-0.19471731781959534,
0.751910388469696,
-0.6414217352867126,
-0.4151107668876648,
0.12062335759401321,
0.07495051622390747,
0.044657714664936066,
0.04064129292964935,
-0.6680665016174316,
-0.03233860433101654,
0.7903026938438416,
0.6351706981658936,
0.09469956159591675,
-0.04897334799170494,
-0.8829110264778137,
-0.12652303278446198,
-0.43032190203666687,
0.4574531018733978,
-0.3686228394508362,
-0.10855047404766083,
-0.26076024770736694,
-0.36668020486831665,
0.08347028493881226,
-0.5807130336761475,
0.34604504704475403,
-0.838535487651825,
-0.011906156316399574,
-0.11513905227184296,
-0.7542246580123901,
-0.15499858558177948,
-0.004154054448008537,
-0.622679591178894,
1.250596523284912,
0.2515355944633484,
-0.529673159122467,
0.11250682175159454,
-0.6729375720024109,
-0.12835273146629333,
0.15940751135349274,
-0.026064066216349602,
-0.5809471607208252,
0.4320394992828369,
0.2685614824295044,
0.3082467317581177,
-0.4324377775192261,
0.3614136576652527,
-0.29962489008903503,
-0.866878867149353,
0.49288007616996765,
-0.6007218956947327,
0.8948401808738708,
0.08293669670820236,
-0.5856906771659851,
0.3127362132072449,
-0.7333083748817444,
0.46180853247642517,
-0.2597252130508423,
-0.3954070508480072,
-0.45627260208129883,
-0.26206040382385254,
-0.17375341057777405,
0.04818139597773552,
0.14157108962535858,
-0.37509065866470337,
-0.0452309288084507,
-0.5919662714004517,
0.7304316163063049,
0.7612956166267395,
-0.13515780866146088,
0.7076179385185242,
0.006521852687001228,
0.5120814442634583,
0.1989927440881729,
0.3192872405052185,
-0.1343597024679184,
-0.32290247082710266,
-0.6906068325042725,
-0.7143020033836365,
0.6317994594573975,
0.43122783303260803,
-0.6739436984062195,
0.7037270069122314,
-0.46038907766342163,
-0.4986991882324219,
-0.55795818567276,
0.2892606854438782,
0.6617733240127563,
0.27382993698120117,
0.3365118205547333,
-0.0769064649939537,
-0.40860578417778015,
-0.6358555555343628,
-0.4132263660430908,
-0.046524178236722946,
-0.06793322414159775,
-0.2594164311885834,
0.1269518882036209,
-0.18015359342098236,
0.8701558113098145,
-0.061034347862005234,
-0.16464479267597198,
-0.1115305945277214,
0.19545157253742218,
0.3611904978752136,
0.5400335192680359,
0.2611473500728607,
-0.6810901165008545,
-0.5767162442207336,
-0.06198711320757866,
-0.39297980070114136,
-0.29873842000961304,
0.1330905556678772,
-0.21697242558002472,
0.27382490038871765,
0.8546488881111145,
-0.4626065790653229,
0.28126582503318787,
0.9019168615341187,
-0.18062236905097961,
0.28702080249786377,
0.08198405057191849,
0.10369446128606796,
-0.980550229549408,
-0.02008182741701603,
-0.22551801800727844,
-0.3345950245857239,
-0.6378117203712463,
-0.201887845993042,
0.3716747760772705,
-0.16128769516944885,
-0.48936697840690613,
0.24445152282714844,
-0.2864620089530945,
-0.03882351517677307,
0.08683521300554276,
-0.08927195519208908,
-0.16448386013507843,
0.5441567897796631,
-0.2492104172706604,
0.8256690502166748,
0.5104153156280518,
-0.3888441324234009,
0.3345368206501007,
-0.19062931835651398,
-0.4607801139354706,
0.48014402389526367,
-0.47207197546958923,
0.12400632351636887,
-0.256910115480423,
0.07779984176158905,
-1.0159968137741089,
0.1921682506799698,
0.1934555023908615,
-0.39990606904029846,
0.15187068283557892,
-0.5278200507164001,
-0.5322190523147583,
0.07419012486934662,
-0.48065385222435,
0.8950753211975098,
0.4853707551956177,
-0.7256174087524414,
0.5446212291717529,
0.19981388747692108,
0.14771951735019684,
-0.4666973948478699,
-0.5824123620986938,
-0.19484344124794006,
-0.672614336013794,
-0.5914400815963745,
0.24920037388801575,
-0.20672167837619781,
-0.2747117280960083,
-0.012689635157585144,
-0.19771955907344818,
0.03479009121656418,
-0.038631074130535126,
-0.010464079678058624,
-0.12295464426279068,
-0.3511805534362793,
0.35114187002182007,
0.12934792041778564,
-0.2755604684352875,
-0.02350415475666523,
-0.6035639047622681,
0.6457726955413818,
-0.3055779039859772,
-0.35586249828338623,
-0.3317511975765228,
0.32740655541419983,
0.5380401611328125,
-0.3583695590496063,
0.35377052426338196,
0.6400808691978455,
-0.2594274580478668,
-0.2059168815612793,
-0.5433762073516846,
-0.3730964660644531,
-0.5360289216041565,
0.5919047594070435,
-0.3838752210140228,
-0.9541333317756653,
0.3012552261352539,
-0.21399396657943726,
-0.09741513431072235,
0.046153485774993896,
0.43673720955848694,
0.01373573113232851,
1.1843454837799072,
0.3123832941055298,
-0.012074695900082588,
0.8109132051467896,
-0.44209566712379456,
0.4492467939853668,
-0.7552220225334167,
0.3346775770187378,
-0.1545146405696869,
-0.4572257399559021,
-0.3600752353668213,
-0.6332505345344543,
0.7413418889045715,
0.4870690703392029,
-0.4546990990638733,
0.24078917503356934,
-0.22782114148139954,
0.578647792339325,
0.7431220412254333,
0.14126962423324585,
0.4066140055656433,
0.3323327302932739,
0.06012405455112457,
-0.14409880340099335,
-0.9719256162643433,
-0.1098693311214447,
1.250800371170044,
0.18516243994235992,
0.7163615822792053,
0.42446470260620117,
0.7068819403648376,
0.15227322280406952,
0.40534666180610657,
-0.8690704107284546,
0.4563571810722351,
-0.3231745958328247,
-0.24829068779945374,
-0.6568098664283752,
-0.8373474478721619,
-0.7326458096504211,
0.1923253834247589,
-0.20170913636684418,
-0.49481603503227234,
0.18547208607196808,
0.4179789423942566,
-0.5708119869232178,
0.21620823442935944,
-0.8336186408996582,
1.0234100818634033,
-0.2546427845954895,
-0.13277260959148407,
-0.33613458275794983,
-0.371825635433197,
0.41292473673820496,
-0.256847620010376,
0.265713632106781,
0.02399827167391777,
-0.020326802507042885,
0.6758934855461121,
-0.698829174041748,
0.61128830909729,
-0.027822572737932205,
-0.23838569223880768,
0.3909553587436676,
0.157753124833107,
0.7095866203308105,
0.2964000105857849,
-0.0505487434566021,
0.15868163108825684,
-0.015473069623112679,
-0.33523255586624146,
-0.8511509299278259,
0.7275121212005615,
-0.6984367966651917,
-0.17747361958026886,
-0.22658778727054596,
-0.5094550251960754,
-0.40695998072624207,
0.1394582837820053,
0.5177862048149109,
0.8051176071166992,
0.19496852159500122,
0.3299788236618042,
0.9297929406166077,
-0.02674959972500801,
0.6256476640701294,
0.37721171975135803,
0.059680961072444916,
-0.7681265473365784,
0.9623345136642456,
0.01298233587294817,
0.4034137427806854,
0.5783915519714355,
0.2592824697494507,
-0.4650273323059082,
-0.5532640218734741,
-0.42111989855766296,
0.23417964577674866,
-0.6683438420295715,
-0.5342652797698975,
-0.3819745182991028,
-0.16467520594596863,
-0.2675922214984894,
0.1124144196510315,
-0.723070502281189,
-0.4882187843322754,
-0.27441975474357605,
0.21209147572517395,
0.4653461277484894,
0.04283825680613518,
-0.18132469058036804,
0.885244607925415,
-0.8770432472229004,
0.11982998251914978,
0.4720412492752075,
0.2831058204174042,
-0.19269582629203796,
-0.7628203630447388,
-0.42547696828842163,
0.18748697638511658,
-0.14152491092681885,
-0.7899153232574463,
0.15044189989566803,
0.4460766911506653,
0.24065999686717987,
0.5039790272712708,
0.03162340447306633,
0.9566661715507507,
-0.06218467280268669,
0.3397028148174286,
0.22983281314373016,
-1.4025657176971436,
0.12688739597797394,
-0.18674682080745697,
0.48956969380378723,
0.4155365228652954,
0.24243560433387756,
-0.4173423647880554,
-0.25713199377059937,
-0.6551287174224854,
-0.98650062084198,
0.46481946110725403,
0.06149591505527496,
0.03764574974775314,
0.21181975305080414,
0.21785403788089752,
-0.28592419624328613,
0.389777809381485,
-0.705905556678772,
-0.11116931587457657,
-0.06365284323692322,
-0.41591784358024597,
-0.17121413350105286,
-0.4631654620170593,
0.11249338090419769,
-0.26504167914390564,
0.8479412198066711,
-0.36362624168395996,
0.11493153125047684,
-0.015237279236316681,
-0.572387158870697,
-0.3321080207824707,
0.33653026819229126,
0.3607384264469147,
0.7560364007949829,
-0.1485363245010376,
0.28734642267227173,
0.21336409449577332,
-0.4637523889541626,
0.17700646817684174,
0.2350958287715912,
-0.12044671177864075,
-0.05741824954748154,
0.15719367563724518,
0.7131344676017761,
0.5683627128601074,
-0.8022146821022034,
0.6686841249465942,
-0.11395323276519775,
-0.11210545897483826,
-0.31603410840034485,
-0.14579585194587708,
0.012549854815006256,
0.6638455986976624,
0.23514994978904724,
-0.15013664960861206,
0.13707377016544342,
-0.3297923803329468,
0.05511142686009407,
0.554350733757019,
-0.3902827203273773,
-0.14474008977413177,
0.5089740753173828,
-0.048102330416440964,
-0.08346958458423615,
0.8614002466201782,
-0.43919023871421814,
-0.48928123712539673,
0.2593633830547333,
0.4437747597694397,
0.848554253578186,
-0.39584916830062866,
0.06572626531124115,
0.18017341196537018,
0.21936075389385223,
-0.11376897245645523,
0.41135480999946594,
0.06139974668622017,
-0.6714511513710022,
-0.961049497127533,
-0.5938653945922852,
0.02316105179488659,
0.37288960814476013,
-0.32398125529289246,
0.413779079914093,
-0.2956453859806061,
-0.23444980382919312,
-0.3133026957511902,
-0.29434171319007874,
-0.23689530789852142,
0.09233404695987701,
0.07970965653657913,
0.723889172077179,
-0.6035336852073669,
1.0605132579803467,
0.7660799026489258,
0.1870751976966858,
-0.9158323407173157,
-0.2142454832792282,
-0.16852493584156036,
-0.4872117042541504,
0.3873317241668701,
-0.03922414779663086,
0.04907635971903801,
0.7008252739906311,
-0.1365634948015213,
-1.0986049175262451,
0.9707142114639282,
0.7271315455436707,
-0.9013077020645142,
0.182317316532135,
0.23536987602710724,
0.2264580875635147,
0.015671249479055405,
0.4346272349357605,
0.7543702721595764,
0.39547649025917053,
0.0774177610874176,
-0.7268285751342773,
0.07928603142499924,
-0.205590158700943,
0.15334835648536682,
0.6778454780578613,
-0.39659497141838074,
0.7896445393562317,
0.0812561884522438,
0.08808957785367966,
0.06792300194501877,
0.5923737287521362,
0.3186967074871063,
-0.19051297008991241,
0.8277058601379395,
0.9120568633079529,
0.6763282418251038,
-0.15963487327098846,
0.4436279237270355,
-0.4001731276512146,
0.33294677734375,
0.8554698824882507,
0.2829970717430115,
0.5722475647926331,
0.5210207104682922,
-0.16785110533237457,
0.1731393039226532,
0.47206804156303406,
0.3549421727657318,
0.5283890962600708,
0.5056719183921814,
-0.4438081383705139,
-0.5886347889900208,
0.3277340233325958,
-0.4453389644622803,
0.4149071276187897,
0.4163926839828491,
-0.21021167933940887,
-0.22582925856113434,
-0.0701606422662735,
0.30916181206703186,
-0.23712071776390076,
-0.4467451870441437,
0.5248420834541321,
0.17519502341747284,
-0.5453913807868958,
0.8546366691589355,
-0.009323890320956707,
0.6620612740516663,
-0.6902328729629517,
0.06956761330366135,
-0.29737943410873413,
0.5505359172821045,
-0.12100671976804733,
-0.23748157918453217,
0.18112152814865112,
-0.31082281470298767,
-0.002190276049077511,
-0.37684008479118347,
0.3781689703464508,
-0.7031663060188293,
-0.5079634189605713,
-0.04717397689819336,
0.38086214661598206,
-0.0004998628864996135,
-0.7198110222816467,
-0.6471200585365295,
0.32998421788215637,
-0.09675746411085129,
-0.27747008204460144,
0.4531300663948059,
0.5386244654655457,
-0.4136729836463928,
0.45530936121940613,
0.7863685488700867,
0.012134838849306107,
0.3347129821777344,
0.10583031922578812,
0.9505369663238525,
-0.4298698306083679,
-0.5832423567771912,
-0.9402316808700562,
0.5657915472984314,
0.10444916039705276,
-0.3806522488594055,
0.6586828827857971,
0.696137547492981,
0.6607229709625244,
0.028969725593924522,
0.45373979210853577,
0.14301057159900665,
0.09656158089637756,
-0.691678524017334,
0.5669153928756714,
-0.6111531257629395,
0.49986156821250916,
-0.2020951509475708,
-1.1267738342285156,
-0.4358624815940857,
0.6252106428146362,
-0.24227751791477203,
0.04883119836449623,
0.6469302773475647,
1.2084237337112427,
-0.18820489943027496,
-0.06519526988267899,
0.28946250677108765,
0.24489909410476685,
0.2660194933414459,
0.7134782075881958,
0.9929705262184143,
-0.5295562148094177,
0.7501285076141357,
-0.45571470260620117,
-0.4865948557853699,
-0.25460490584373474,
-0.967543363571167,
-0.8283552527427673,
-0.3975880444049835,
-0.546197772026062,
-0.44741061329841614,
0.23138578236103058,
0.9654205441474915,
0.8960689902305603,
-0.7582038640975952,
-0.44327250123023987,
-0.33014819025993347,
0.12228644639253616,
-0.36461755633354187,
-0.24709269404411316,
0.5010855197906494,
-0.46993952989578247,
-0.7514822483062744,
0.518541693687439,
0.33443430066108704,
-0.009824875742197037,
-0.19811712205410004,
-0.09351297467947006,
0.11415264755487442,
-0.19051587581634521,
0.6160845756530762,
0.07161620259284973,
-0.28592073917388916,
0.014675186946988106,
-0.03204738348722458,
0.14782209694385529,
-0.01753779500722885,
1.0393426418304443,
-0.8068786263465881,
0.2022942751646042,
0.5561621785163879,
0.47212740778923035,
0.4836777448654175,
0.07242104411125183,
0.5379287600517273,
-0.8536232709884644,
0.36642488837242126,
0.37398621439933777,
0.07347474992275238,
0.31030187010765076,
-0.23830966651439667,
0.30069854855537415,
0.23579569160938263,
-0.5502886772155762,
-0.9888204336166382,
0.17294059693813324,
-0.6706125140190125,
-0.07536718994379044,
1.2257509231567383,
0.0009124675416387618,
-0.15807320177555084,
0.13476745784282684,
-0.020552033558487892,
0.15408341586589813,
-0.47283247113227844,
0.5981958508491516,
0.2483517825603485,
0.11199916154146194,
-0.43097010254859924,
-0.3200910687446594,
0.8449073433876038,
0.7285044193267822,
-0.5290511846542358,
-0.058359839022159576,
0.3091756999492645,
0.13258759677410126,
-0.20780710875988007,
0.5377872586250305,
-0.24505062401294708,
0.35900798439979553,
-0.38861173391342163,
-0.062071293592453,
-0.07334819436073303,
-0.07007021456956863,
-0.42453643679618835,
-0.09663508832454681,
0.1521984487771988,
-0.04840986430644989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18783v2 | Psychological Profiling in Cybersecurity: A Look at LLMs and Psycholinguistic Features | 2024-06-26T23:04:52 | 2024-06-28T21:22:56 | Jean Marie Tshimula, D'Jeff K. Nkashama, Jean Tshibangu Muabila, René Manassé Galekwa, Hugues Kanda, Maximilien V. Dialufuma, Mbuyi Mukendi Didier, Kalala Kalonji, Serge Mundele, Patience Kinshie Lenye, Tighana Wenge Basele, Aristarque Ilunga, Christian N. Mayemba, Nathanaël M. Kasoro, Selain K. Kasereka, Hardy Mikese, Pierre-Martin Tardif, Marc Frappier, Froduald Kabanza, Belkacem Chikhaoui, Shengrui Wang, Ali Mulenda Sumbu, Xavier Ndona, Raoul Kienge-Kienge Intudi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The increasing sophistication of cyber threats necessitates innovative
approaches to cybersecurity. In this paper, we explore the potential of
psychological profiling techniques, particularly focusing on the utilization of
Large Language Models (LLMs) and psycholinguistic features. We investigate the
intersection of psychology and cybersecurity, discussing how LLMs can be
employed to analyze textual data for identifying psychological traits of threat
actors. We explore the incorporation of psycholinguistic features, such as
linguistic patterns and emotional cues, into cybersecurity frameworks. Our
research underscores the importance of integrating psychological perspectives
into cybersecurity practices to bolster defense mechanisms against evolving
threats. | [
-0.5625770092010498,
-1.0385923385620117,
0.47203528881073,
0.2885322570800781,
0.06435883790254593,
0.5787706971168518,
-0.22952307760715485,
-0.9508233666419983,
0.251799076795578,
0.6814858317375183,
-0.951336145401001,
-0.1752493977546692,
-0.7193806767463684,
0.05471370369195938,
-0.4794335961341858,
1.1369661092758179,
0.3607237637042999,
0.010262846946716309,
-0.03260434791445732,
0.3928724229335785,
-0.40868645906448364,
-1.5030466318130493,
-0.679955005645752,
-0.39219826459884644,
0.33740103244781494,
0.02172468788921833,
0.4571044445037842,
0.10793706029653549,
0.902910590171814,
0.28136417269706726,
0.038979846984148026,
-0.4162120223045349,
-0.5219329595565796,
0.3805198073387146,
-0.1276826411485672,
-0.7711904048919678,
-0.29450827836990356,
0.12493320554494858,
0.2972361147403717,
0.3547293245792389,
-0.06400987505912781,
0.31179237365722656,
-0.15553662180900574,
0.3084086775779724,
-0.5878476500511169,
-0.21597838401794434,
-0.5785364508628845,
0.18401634693145752,
-0.5125786662101746,
-0.304060161113739,
-0.4000132083892822,
-0.1617753952741623,
0.3635380268096924,
-0.3085904121398926,
0.054726146161556244,
0.06552261859178543,
0.422431617975235,
-0.10886730253696442,
-0.31825384497642517,
-0.12872819602489471,
-0.8846210241317749,
0.7914212942123413,
-0.23539112508296967,
0.3621067702770233,
0.7360319495201111,
0.25679460167884827,
0.08522698283195496,
-0.32455968856811523,
-0.1584302932024002,
-0.3355661928653717,
0.004220705479383469,
-0.2793292701244354,
-0.5107821822166443,
0.006306161638349295,
0.4312758147716522,
0.07377127557992935,
-0.47459420561790466,
0.5766289830207825,
-0.419016569852829,
-0.38024693727493286,
1.1409622430801392,
0.4383903741836548,
0.22180654108524323,
0.3450993597507477,
-0.19333416223526,
-0.13209962844848633,
-0.557951033115387,
0.16786165535449982,
0.6907203197479248,
0.27298638224601746,
-0.4818125069141388,
0.4444205164909363,
0.0764954537153244,
0.05158861353993416,
0.011601676233112812,
-0.5157998204231262,
0.07394848018884659,
-0.09531084448099136,
-0.11604361981153488,
0.14490492641925812,
0.5988959670066833,
0.19033131003379822,
0.6246646642684937,
-0.044487547129392624,
-0.021029731258749962,
0.13172124326229095,
0.6683070063591003,
-0.6565372943878174,
-0.2541070282459259,
0.3639768064022064,
-0.8158666491508484,
-0.6412132978439331,
0.13090066611766815,
-0.9742943048477173,
-0.9888943433761597,
-0.04424728825688362,
-0.23545479774475098,
-0.35519951581954956,
-0.42175599932670593,
-0.11436623334884644,
-0.24069519340991974,
0.23311971127986908,
-0.04045168310403824,
-0.6442298889160156,
0.5283418893814087,
0.6271860599517822,
0.7095834016799927,
-0.00963355228304863,
-0.09581880271434784,
-0.1762312948703766,
-0.07336298376321793,
-0.2529194951057434,
0.4153062701225281,
-0.7441685795783997,
-0.4711156189441681,
0.28338244557380676,
-0.2068372666835785,
0.3643089830875397,
-0.22554470598697662,
0.03047815151512623,
-0.6347087025642395,
-0.002873262856155634,
-0.038540683686733246,
-0.24402406811714172,
0.030275532975792885,
0.3094700574874878,
-0.40671756863594055,
1.0701466798782349,
-0.04299876093864441,
-0.8007388710975647,
0.10033968836069107,
-0.6439756751060486,
-0.5557243227958679,
0.3348599970340729,
-0.05200977623462677,
-0.18089155852794647,
0.35572290420532227,
-0.13347534835338593,
0.6453022956848145,
-0.3271249234676361,
-0.03357940539717674,
-0.5934222340583801,
-0.2652647793292999,
0.9648965001106262,
-0.22910280525684357,
0.9192625284194946,
0.17035987973213196,
-0.21686770021915436,
-0.12022769451141357,
-0.7659494876861572,
0.018332205712795258,
0.2564253807067871,
-0.09024360030889511,
-0.11181427538394928,
0.1867545247077942,
0.24823659658432007,
0.08846205472946167,
0.5865014791488647,
-0.5999549627304077,
-0.22972233593463898,
-0.2509756088256836,
0.2583686411380768,
0.7164877653121948,
0.1878519058227539,
0.09966440498828888,
-0.14929790794849396,
0.9606578350067139,
-0.16547584533691406,
0.38166019320487976,
0.1613617092370987,
-0.1699148267507553,
-0.14942944049835205,
-0.8621736764907837,
-0.20573051273822784,
1.1821647882461548,
-0.17699165642261505,
0.5865247845649719,
0.1687966287136078,
-0.8928430080413818,
-0.2419503778219223,
0.10776627063751221,
0.5206517577171326,
-0.2713826596736908,
-0.0058423359878361225,
-0.08441199362277985,
-0.8744416236877441,
-0.9414600133895874,
-0.3985024094581604,
-0.4750747084617615,
-0.3001798689365387,
0.02144341729581356,
0.2973269820213318,
-0.12944865226745605,
0.5957667231559753,
-0.6161024570465088,
-0.14503848552703857,
-0.35130736231803894,
0.07257702201604843,
-0.06494014710187912,
0.10393595695495605,
0.6127251982688904,
-0.6244115233421326,
-0.23081348836421967,
-0.09333363175392151,
-0.9168317914009094,
-0.2692811191082001,
-0.00908577535301447,
0.35465672612190247,
-0.18485654890537262,
1.120605707168579,
-0.48038896918296814,
0.3569524884223938,
0.2564197778701782,
-0.4690360426902771,
0.8045579791069031,
0.1168183833360672,
0.042977117002010345,
-0.6996723413467407,
0.03255001828074455,
0.25976747274398804,
-0.10562801361083984,
-1.0731353759765625,
0.4190022051334381,
-0.35476991534233093,
-0.41798165440559387,
-0.40973401069641113,
0.19361726939678192,
-0.4363250732421875,
0.050042182207107544,
-0.22201740741729736,
0.327107310295105,
-0.3442077040672302,
0.10673287510871887,
-0.1916152983903885,
0.37893423438072205,
0.9902825951576233,
-0.34925803542137146,
0.6303988099098206,
-0.07433292269706726,
-0.32084551453590393,
1.193481206893921,
-0.3487565517425537,
0.23111023008823395,
-0.05099588632583618,
0.19529733061790466,
-0.7003523111343384,
-0.22275535762310028,
-0.13350525498390198,
-0.422332763671875,
0.37240901589393616,
-0.022608138620853424,
-0.6819544434547424,
-0.24952572584152222,
-0.5402317047119141,
0.4577857553958893,
0.3257448077201843,
0.17587581276893616,
0.4853482246398926,
0.7510272860527039,
-0.43103256821632385,
-0.3405698239803314,
-0.8372129201889038,
0.4468552768230438,
-0.863036572933197,
-0.468747079372406,
0.35388290882110596,
-0.0013590534217655659,
-0.7579712867736816,
-0.7483804225921631,
0.26565495133399963,
0.018134696409106255,
0.8094647526741028,
0.395892471075058,
0.45297321677207947,
-0.1638641357421875,
-0.05259530246257782,
-0.7596904039382935,
0.04874749109148979,
0.5905251502990723,
-0.1565246284008026,
0.7373077273368835,
-0.01791912317276001,
-0.10710909217596054,
-0.5474043488502502,
0.7813584804534912,
0.34676244854927063,
-0.30614233016967773,
0.8662832975387573,
0.7707322835922241,
-0.44846993684768677,
0.1568082869052887,
-0.7083918452262878,
-0.6615905165672302,
-0.46412575244903564,
0.7012934684753418,
-0.4468943178653717,
-1.1869035959243774,
0.5479902029037476,
-0.11087775230407715,
-0.2809301018714905,
-0.09614186733961105,
0.5546573400497437,
-0.5373910665512085,
0.9740322828292847,
1.2933412790298462,
-0.4359591007232666,
0.8441874980926514,
0.36945629119873047,
0.6332593560218811,
-0.4196455180644989,
-0.38506564497947693,
-0.5910677909851074,
-0.3558799922466278,
-1.1848353147506714,
0.36507970094680786,
0.35529932379722595,
-0.08255642652511597,
-0.3765225410461426,
0.2175421565771103,
-0.2013516128063202,
0.29503169655799866,
0.2987741529941559,
0.29377394914627075,
-0.21570949256420135,
0.12810690701007843,
0.15790626406669617,
-0.05441772937774658,
-0.14354515075683594,
-0.5006749629974365,
1.1080073118209839,
0.6914989948272705,
0.5781168341636658,
0.4330355226993561,
0.5408205389976501,
0.4322485625743866,
-0.24568293988704681,
-0.38109180331230164,
0.8562032580375671,
-0.0038864987436681986,
-0.7053838968276978,
-0.2690809965133667,
-0.14740188419818878,
-0.8702003359794617,
-0.30473586916923523,
-0.6471301317214966,
-1.8411033153533936,
0.16529424488544464,
-0.13731037080287933,
-0.2328922152519226,
0.06255873292684555,
-0.2819792628288269,
0.34385743737220764,
-0.2422323375940323,
-0.04613437503576279,
-0.5701108574867249,
-0.6536933779716492,
0.22406455874443054,
-0.4866983890533447,
0.1337893158197403,
-0.18519073724746704,
-0.0459757074713707,
0.8615268468856812,
0.021123524755239487,
1.2273497581481934,
-0.026787150651216507,
-0.27057918906211853,
-0.015878019854426384,
0.22307445108890533,
0.2797577679157257,
-0.131413996219635,
0.011113883927464485,
0.3847268521785736,
0.15248386561870575,
-0.3288068473339081,
-0.42941203713417053,
0.45565420389175415,
-0.8146721124649048,
-0.8163946866989136,
-0.496109277009964,
-0.3680732548236847,
-0.5502259731292725,
0.053849950432777405,
0.2598487138748169,
0.16176189482212067,
-0.4946722388267517,
0.2849358022212982,
0.8643677234649658,
-0.1655493676662445,
0.38768285512924194,
0.48019593954086304,
-0.12821505963802338,
-0.24654091894626617,
0.7803282737731934,
-0.06308131664991379,
0.2655860185623169,
0.48090872168540955,
0.01213166955858469,
0.03970244154334068,
-0.4486307203769684,
0.4723251760005951,
0.5386481881141663,
-0.5477500557899475,
-0.09812602400779724,
-0.4804581105709076,
-0.5609393119812012,
-0.4121525287628174,
-0.4274683892726898,
0.1481049805879593,
-0.13029196858406067,
0.021104563027620316,
-0.313314825296402,
0.8080871105194092,
0.7756609916687012,
0.15103578567504883,
0.7801898717880249,
-0.3718659579753876,
0.19560015201568604,
-0.1888536959886551,
0.06548408418893814,
-0.1897823065519333,
-0.43611055612564087,
-0.47999492287635803,
-0.28309401869773865,
-0.38785097002983093,
-1.2088420391082764,
0.28284358978271484,
0.019248658791184425,
0.49077045917510986,
0.5023512840270996,
-0.2314353734254837,
0.31580981612205505,
-0.14271418750286102,
0.9723914861679077,
0.09397729486227036,
-0.9612759351730347,
0.6725062727928162,
-0.44291120767593384,
0.08692655712366104,
0.4047304689884186,
0.7424682974815369,
-0.6023635864257812,
-0.5253023505210876,
-0.7015181183815002,
-0.5334106683731079,
0.5771437287330627,
0.17929424345493317,
0.16023623943328857,
0.14602714776992798,
0.14385931193828583,
-0.39197346568107605,
0.3234747648239136,
-0.711741030216217,
-0.3194701671600342,
0.050325728952884674,
-0.160481795668602,
-0.17293232679367065,
-0.3995254933834076,
-0.36845606565475464,
0.19057859480381012,
0.3993549942970276,
0.058773063123226166,
0.4166851341724396,
-0.21369606256484985,
0.05059047415852547,
0.32286959886550903,
0.1695868968963623,
0.5590099096298218,
0.28711169958114624,
0.06707439571619034,
0.22844144701957703,
0.3469220697879791,
-0.8191338181495667,
0.2872549593448639,
-0.13058362901210785,
0.22992795705795288,
-0.33829373121261597,
0.5751041173934937,
0.3806271255016327,
-0.05642660707235336,
-0.9052435755729675,
0.4752415716648102,
0.16200445592403412,
-0.17687846720218658,
-0.44206035137176514,
0.01259449403733015,
0.05786485597491264,
0.5609602928161621,
0.3456641137599945,
-0.25973471999168396,
0.06837543100118637,
-0.855590283870697,
-0.010491957888007164,
0.689690887928009,
-0.23984917998313904,
-0.3956214487552643,
0.13752926886081696,
-0.06870759278535843,
-0.6544475555419922,
0.6903352737426758,
0.26634499430656433,
-0.7344872951507568,
0.48136454820632935,
0.6585335731506348,
1.1255356073379517,
-0.6064965724945068,
0.0090156439691782,
-0.24801579117774963,
0.7677738070487976,
0.25539857149124146,
0.5711491703987122,
0.0813211128115654,
-0.5549824833869934,
0.1494613140821457,
-0.373304158449173,
-0.1433529406785965,
0.25425830483436584,
-0.648638904094696,
0.43458396196365356,
-1.0107197761535645,
-0.5719940066337585,
0.051637809723615646,
0.04188936948776245,
-0.8837327361106873,
0.29317066073417664,
0.6310135126113892,
0.7595254182815552,
-0.9844014644622803,
0.38085100054740906,
0.48951461911201477,
0.07172296941280365,
-0.3146699368953705,
-0.06930409371852875,
0.487662136554718,
-0.7590131163597107,
0.8251139521598816,
0.18116448819637299,
-0.10456734150648117,
-0.43639251589775085,
-0.47654369473457336,
-0.8523067235946655,
0.8318579196929932,
0.5693917274475098,
-0.2513670027256012,
-0.021060992032289505,
0.7307566404342651,
0.7301573753356934,
-0.5523830056190491,
0.29077935218811035,
0.8095730543136597,
0.5218637585639954,
-0.7987492084503174,
-0.773189902305603,
0.09915748983621597,
-0.5005232095718384,
-0.049986567348241806,
0.1938624233007431,
-0.6606919765472412,
0.5229401588439941,
0.11413397639989853,
-0.21169935166835785,
-0.33233311772346497,
0.49225103855133057,
0.33810779452323914,
0.17886893451213837,
0.27983036637306213,
0.16935615241527557,
0.8327488899230957,
0.20101116597652435,
0.8357082605361938,
-0.3019397556781769,
-0.2704163193702698,
0.7303904294967651,
-0.35791370272636414,
0.8134363293647766,
0.4198816418647766,
-0.382460355758667,
0.6113964319229126,
0.6686625480651855,
-0.36796900629997253,
0.130640909075737,
0.47689923644065857,
-0.2782173752784729,
-0.0906171128153801,
-0.3156454563140869,
0.04853489249944687,
0.9455575942993164,
0.6721621155738831,
-0.4035722315311432,
0.19941183924674988,
0.38222968578338623,
0.35924196243286133,
-0.04884596914052963,
-0.24071499705314636,
0.9345059990882874,
0.21435578167438507,
-0.2004818171262741,
0.31341657042503357,
0.268337219953537,
0.6683434247970581,
-0.8541824817657471,
0.4315551817417145,
0.15990136563777924,
-0.08332227915525436,
-0.33134278655052185,
-0.7438334226608276,
0.30121472477912903,
0.40987923741340637,
-0.174855038523674,
-0.29600048065185547,
0.7503339648246765,
0.1351546347141266,
-0.4426366686820984,
0.4811951816082001,
0.1905360221862793,
0.29500338435173035,
-0.29991528391838074,
-0.5168943405151367,
0.20460063219070435,
-0.2609090805053711,
-0.09223400056362152,
0.7536510825157166,
0.5052569508552551,
-0.31486207246780396,
0.949047327041626,
0.6720321774482727,
0.502825915813446,
-0.10766489803791046,
-0.05645060911774635,
0.46905800700187683,
-0.6416453719139099,
-0.7907601594924927,
-1.3919172286987305,
0.1898740530014038,
-0.44488605856895447,
-0.5164604187011719,
0.7491464018821716,
0.21718499064445496,
0.6850664615631104,
0.006678410340100527,
0.7478358745574951,
0.14563514292240143,
0.11947762221097946,
-0.5189502835273743,
0.6205988526344299,
0.027829814702272415,
0.3621203303337097,
-0.3567343056201935,
-0.7624143958091736,
-0.07526066899299622,
0.27562639117240906,
-0.20535360276699066,
0.08902628719806671,
0.5676702857017517,
0.9267606139183044,
0.20451150834560394,
0.10591889917850494,
0.45290350914001465,
0.13219495117664337,
0.33395424485206604,
0.2851422429084778,
0.8566902279853821,
-0.05812371149659157,
0.21666522324085236,
-0.11378000676631927,
-0.49374210834503174,
-0.4764062762260437,
-0.9382647275924683,
-1.2486827373504639,
-0.4623422920703888,
-0.5055031776428223,
-0.2586115300655365,
-0.014356521889567375,
0.7162115573883057,
0.736784040927887,
-0.5784385800361633,
-0.4844919741153717,
0.48093488812446594,
-0.2858135998249054,
-0.2799067795276642,
-0.309083491563797,
-0.3140179216861725,
-0.030409829691052437,
0.11253395676612854,
0.4577031135559082,
0.39107805490493774,
0.11277421563863754,
-0.7024763822555542,
0.4774249494075775,
-0.10516434907913208,
0.7666257619857788,
0.6560832858085632,
0.1963735818862915,
-0.6923938989639282,
-0.36523759365081787,
0.25034207105636597,
-0.10996216535568237,
-0.3579872250556946,
1.0388414859771729,
-0.4909608066082001,
-0.07750394940376282,
0.37010443210601807,
0.7208587527275085,
0.09980303049087524,
-0.3885161876678467,
0.7967123985290527,
-0.9620184898376465,
0.15244168043136597,
0.13746242225170135,
0.30266448855400085,
0.20704533159732819,
-0.9128087162971497,
0.3738325238227844,
0.17799322307109833,
-0.32428932189941406,
-1.1510419845581055,
0.4896887242794037,
-0.8435971140861511,
-0.3687860071659088,
0.7618212699890137,
-0.08347208052873611,
0.12170320749282837,
-0.3227217495441437,
-0.06879433244466782,
-0.14929014444351196,
0.06712738424539566,
0.9371443390846252,
0.9114176630973816,
0.03526131063699722,
-0.3182643949985504,
-0.5164507627487183,
0.609978973865509,
0.11551303416490555,
-0.8738712072372437,
0.34083637595176697,
-0.11550869047641754,
-0.05576903745532036,
0.43903520703315735,
0.3350371718406677,
-0.1255868375301361,
0.31107011437416077,
0.04105137661099434,
-0.07280076295137405,
0.27267417311668396,
-0.4371570944786072,
-0.37024685740470886,
0.342903196811676,
-0.07269164174795151,
0.27150437235832214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18776v1 | Implicit Discourse Relation Classification For Nigerian Pidgin | 2024-06-26T22:10:15 | 2024-06-26T22:10:15 | Muhammed Saeed, Peter Bourgonje, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite attempts to make Large Language Models multi-lingual, many of the
world's languages are still severely under-resourced. This widens the
performance gap between NLP and AI applications aimed at well-financed, and
those aimed at less-resourced languages. In this paper, we focus on Nigerian
Pidgin (NP), which is spoken by nearly 100 million people, but has
comparatively very few NLP resources and corpora. We address the task of
Implicit Discourse Relation Classification (IDRC) and systematically compare an
approach translating NP data to English and then using a well-resourced IDRC
tool and back-projecting the labels versus creating a synthetic discourse
corpus for NP, in which we translate PDTB and project PDTB labels, and then
train an NP IDR classifier. The latter approach of learning a "native" NP
classifier outperforms our baseline by 13.27\% and 33.98\% in f$_{1}$ score for
4-way and 11-way classification, respectively. | [
-0.5935218334197998,
-0.5250356793403625,
0.17364418506622314,
0.5225810408592224,
-0.10083527117967606,
0.2834153175354004,
-0.39310744404792786,
-0.6559999585151672,
-0.1262456476688385,
0.2108260691165924,
-0.1124715805053711,
-0.3636017143726349,
-0.5931798815727234,
0.3487764000892639,
-0.23931071162223816,
1.285927414894104,
0.13420063257217407,
0.10827498883008957,
-0.19395849108695984,
-0.13637089729309082,
-0.03920393064618111,
-0.6034964919090271,
-0.8859874606132507,
-0.28339409828186035,
0.6051157116889954,
0.2020057588815689,
0.5591228008270264,
0.17811928689479828,
0.21174263954162598,
0.4036503732204437,
-0.3712279498577118,
0.25261807441711426,
-0.35877880454063416,
0.07214809209108353,
-0.38627171516418457,
-0.13244815170764923,
-0.3042411208152771,
0.12874403595924377,
0.5139704346656799,
0.7541857957839966,
0.2005452960729599,
0.04921664297580719,
0.23199503123760223,
0.5650495290756226,
-0.7044132351875305,
0.4052872657775879,
-0.4571444094181061,
-0.06558878719806671,
-0.3025950789451599,
0.09154562652111053,
-0.40851548314094543,
-0.40494847297668457,
0.3581652045249939,
-0.6724331378936768,
0.15916380286216736,
0.10923081636428833,
0.661650538444519,
0.43377116322517395,
-0.6724223494529724,
-0.38784259557724,
-0.7379748821258545,
0.4456786811351776,
-0.4824918508529663,
0.03392757475376129,
0.5768894553184509,
0.11541605740785599,
-0.28437501192092896,
-0.7606072425842285,
-0.6374800205230713,
-0.20637688040733337,
-0.5239363312721252,
-0.03694913536310196,
-0.1496889889240265,
0.28311532735824585,
0.45927107334136963,
0.4874734878540039,
-0.4412217140197754,
0.23479323089122772,
-0.657780110836029,
-0.14763975143432617,
0.8388829827308655,
-0.24162566661834717,
0.04392123594880104,
-0.4345564842224121,
-0.36260396242141724,
0.07841774076223373,
-0.7082878947257996,
-0.03258044272661209,
0.577340841293335,
0.368190199136734,
-0.07716871052980423,
0.2715601325035095,
-0.12372483313083649,
0.5480574369430542,
0.186987966299057,
-0.4072920083999634,
0.08772570639848709,
-0.1371857076883316,
0.09795187413692474,
0.5902388095855713,
1.1966358423233032,
0.04110890254378319,
0.3773770332336426,
0.11466509103775024,
0.0432647280395031,
0.17892910540103912,
0.06214482709765434,
-0.834189236164093,
-0.18659251928329468,
0.04072914645075798,
-0.10522649437189102,
0.1391570270061493,
-0.1553116887807846,
-0.5068240165710449,
-0.2835518717765808,
-0.17071384191513062,
-0.049905382096767426,
-0.4295952618122101,
-0.4370608925819397,
-0.3867451548576355,
0.3288188576698303,
0.343858540058136,
0.43256381154060364,
-0.7665963768959045,
0.501085102558136,
0.9203488230705261,
1.0269869565963745,
-0.32246896624565125,
-0.028735347092151642,
-0.1954459249973297,
-0.12468449771404266,
-0.32608017325401306,
0.9171818494796753,
-0.24491365253925323,
-0.392360657453537,
-0.17608575522899628,
-0.11451797187328339,
-0.2836959958076477,
-0.4444305896759033,
0.7372498512268066,
-0.23788321018218994,
0.5282325148582458,
-0.022670555859804153,
-0.3816179037094116,
-0.37251153588294983,
0.12733641266822815,
-0.6213119029998779,
0.9582984447479248,
0.3133741617202759,
-1.026955008506775,
0.17310558259487152,
-0.6108509302139282,
-0.5618233680725098,
0.33591318130493164,
-0.24691662192344666,
-0.2051287740468979,
-0.05724824219942093,
0.0638890489935875,
0.5918483138084412,
-0.37829717993736267,
0.5572326183319092,
-0.18529124557971954,
-0.48857447504997253,
0.18578478693962097,
-0.5191965103149414,
0.904682457447052,
0.17971879243850708,
-0.2413683384656906,
-0.20989792048931122,
-0.7322095632553101,
-0.0021583668421953917,
-0.4075125753879547,
-0.23737987875938416,
-0.6899586915969849,
-0.28970208764076233,
0.20969527959823608,
0.5099228024482727,
-0.0612722672522068,
-0.7131941914558411,
0.2284681499004364,
-0.603396475315094,
0.38624975085258484,
0.5429611802101135,
-0.19440999627113342,
0.5065970420837402,
-0.049714818596839905,
0.6028622388839722,
-0.07236253470182419,
-0.4151388108730316,
-0.07204857468605042,
-0.6602920889854431,
-0.7431977391242981,
-0.3347671627998352,
0.9462186694145203,
0.6116734743118286,
-0.7179040312767029,
0.14497171342372894,
-0.4400199353694916,
-0.31344839930534363,
-0.6275326013565063,
-0.262446790933609,
0.6409804224967957,
0.6656270623207092,
0.3758440911769867,
-0.06536982208490372,
-0.3628551661968231,
-0.9872596263885498,
0.030813103541731834,
-0.4833452105522156,
-0.07475163787603378,
0.20280474424362183,
0.6810435652732849,
-0.07670917361974716,
0.7060471773147583,
-0.08247146755456924,
-0.5248361229896545,
-0.1200811117887497,
0.43849337100982666,
0.21177372336387634,
0.741982638835907,
0.6255996823310852,
-0.8099607825279236,
-0.9873884320259094,
0.3856349587440491,
-0.501255214214325,
-0.11365702003240585,
0.010627309791743755,
-0.026213085278868675,
0.6561436653137207,
0.5149834752082825,
-0.3884168863296509,
0.6998392343521118,
0.6417544484138489,
-0.3540486693382263,
0.40657204389572144,
-0.12029784917831421,
-0.047060031443834305,
-0.7918304204940796,
0.22261455655097961,
0.07022473961114883,
-0.29641038179397583,
-0.5001926422119141,
-0.2621040344238281,
-0.05615749955177307,
-0.09535494446754456,
-0.5586762428283691,
0.7921546101570129,
-0.6005867719650269,
-0.1520509272813797,
-0.17696626484394073,
-0.24621307849884033,
-0.2052280604839325,
0.8313956260681152,
0.4023061990737915,
0.9934284687042236,
0.21380320191383362,
-0.702754020690918,
0.3485013544559479,
0.35417765378952026,
-0.40186938643455505,
1.0425173044204712,
-0.6986243724822998,
0.19007350504398346,
-0.07524383068084717,
0.3365328907966614,
-1.0177462100982666,
-0.10677776485681534,
0.607154369354248,
-0.31429535150527954,
0.7620933055877686,
-0.5872375965118408,
-0.28231918811798096,
-0.1713489443063736,
0.028304653242230415,
0.46396753191947937,
0.16189374029636383,
-0.49635049700737,
0.5622668862342834,
0.35372206568717957,
-0.6713976860046387,
-0.7488013505935669,
-0.5980964303016663,
0.01340191625058651,
-0.23039653897285461,
-0.4781455099582672,
0.7178410291671753,
0.18173930048942566,
-0.3680420517921448,
0.23374822735786438,
-0.03680470213294029,
-0.42441555857658386,
0.039486803114414215,
0.45883017778396606,
-0.0746479481458664,
-0.3497268259525299,
0.211109921336174,
0.37139424681663513,
-0.3368673622608185,
0.07014349848031998,
0.011761849746108055,
0.310092955827713,
-0.48164501786231995,
-0.07110855728387833,
-0.30247125029563904,
0.593489408493042,
0.41726449131965637,
-0.08676844090223312,
1.0106346607208252,
0.5249956250190735,
-0.21560443937778473,
0.08753706514835358,
-0.30540329217910767,
0.1433226466178894,
-0.3895341455936432,
0.2603449523448944,
-0.5461707711219788,
-0.7430620193481445,
0.23780035972595215,
-0.34245195984840393,
0.0658433809876442,
0.4777770936489105,
0.2039313018321991,
-0.16563010215759277,
0.8485322594642639,
0.4773526191711426,
-0.06745355576276779,
0.054278161376714706,
-0.44480177760124207,
0.018244720995426178,
-1.150373101234436,
-0.11568630486726761,
-0.6427047848701477,
-0.5038613080978394,
-1.0941007137298584,
-0.08934576064348221,
0.5091577768325806,
0.052213866263628006,
-0.3322655260562897,
0.16736382246017456,
-0.39739567041397095,
0.3754749894142151,
0.48720452189445496,
-0.12888962030410767,
0.4743993580341339,
0.10192341357469559,
-0.22635678946971893,
-0.3517463207244873,
-0.9412093162536621,
-0.5568472146987915,
1.0095003843307495,
0.17765626311302185,
0.4742092788219452,
0.02830450050532818,
0.5215391516685486,
0.05472150072455406,
0.8206920623779297,
-0.838489294052124,
0.33254456520080566,
-0.24393947422504425,
-0.5607633590698242,
-0.19535310566425323,
-0.5131221413612366,
-1.101966142654419,
0.5878022909164429,
-0.21769972145557404,
-0.48144596815109253,
0.48303326964378357,
0.09329209476709366,
-0.27924787998199463,
0.16761259734630585,
-0.5546820759773254,
0.8968847393989563,
-0.4635447561740875,
-0.5039914846420288,
-0.02908170595765114,
-0.6002984642982483,
0.5973053574562073,
-0.08562349528074265,
0.2692188322544098,
-0.1769012212753296,
-0.06643436849117279,
0.7307776808738708,
-0.522013247013092,
0.5720170736312866,
-0.14800900220870972,
-0.1364448219537735,
0.09881068021059036,
-0.14683638513088226,
-0.01656554825603962,
0.24436141550540924,
-0.20261722803115845,
0.4642229676246643,
-0.13860571384429932,
-0.1927848607301712,
-0.5267554521560669,
0.8665722012519836,
-0.8069275617599487,
-0.5197992920875549,
-1.0641469955444336,
-0.30858850479125977,
-0.10268458724021912,
-0.05135974660515785,
0.3971695303916931,
0.2757595479488373,
-0.4156702160835266,
0.274691641330719,
0.560340940952301,
-0.31949952244758606,
0.4182697534561157,
0.5017905235290527,
-0.1077553927898407,
-0.4115544557571411,
0.6858134865760803,
0.2464020699262619,
0.014850454404950142,
0.30401405692100525,
0.1049763411283493,
-0.5494797825813293,
-0.2858451306819916,
-0.42785459756851196,
0.5603702664375305,
-0.3067461848258972,
-0.3631172776222229,
-0.6541113257408142,
-0.3578483760356903,
-0.34448423981666565,
0.06095336005091667,
-0.5176953077316284,
-0.6698203086853027,
-0.310684472322464,
0.1556718349456787,
0.43190228939056396,
0.6232115626335144,
-0.20528782904148102,
0.5579667091369629,
-0.2567655146121979,
0.3024596869945526,
0.27052223682403564,
0.33624836802482605,
-0.22869165241718292,
-0.746309220790863,
0.03231543302536011,
0.014544758945703506,
-0.38097691535949707,
-0.8997921943664551,
0.6579934358596802,
0.6469882726669312,
0.39176976680755615,
0.5245469212532043,
0.420907586812973,
0.6995357275009155,
-0.47022414207458496,
0.26516687870025635,
0.03928038850426674,
-0.7563046216964722,
0.4187186658382416,
-0.024076782166957855,
0.23343192040920258,
0.5054649710655212,
1.1896476745605469,
-0.7013052105903625,
-0.1365291178226471,
-0.6258643269538879,
-0.9350529313087463,
0.9525303244590759,
0.19278424978256226,
0.011311380192637444,
-0.03686137869954109,
0.23472119867801666,
0.1087675616145134,
0.42424944043159485,
-0.8458836078643799,
-0.4357294738292694,
-0.1503453105688095,
-0.030955785885453224,
-0.12674835324287415,
-0.3116767406463623,
0.10311171412467957,
-0.427353173494339,
0.8285391330718994,
-0.3292711675167084,
0.2504597306251526,
0.2243417650461197,
-0.1879468709230423,
0.16489273309707642,
0.36938604712486267,
0.3816356062889099,
0.6741617321968079,
-0.06416068971157074,
0.002283775247633457,
0.028963623568415642,
-0.46714043617248535,
0.3945764899253845,
0.45827847719192505,
-0.4657309055328369,
0.23735995590686798,
0.1878824383020401,
0.773625910282135,
0.29152798652648926,
-0.36735332012176514,
0.48833051323890686,
-0.3812759220600128,
-0.1273765116930008,
-0.5703883171081543,
-0.19298221170902252,
0.10586056113243103,
-0.02105296030640602,
0.35283756256103516,
-0.01471650693565607,
0.09896220266819,
-0.47902363538742065,
-0.21227048337459564,
0.2853265702724457,
-0.34934142231941223,
-0.22686699032783508,
0.3072471618652344,
0.4485267698764801,
-0.23404711484909058,
0.8754903078079224,
-0.5035719275474548,
-0.7969295978546143,
0.20028574764728546,
0.45761093497276306,
0.6623538136482239,
-0.4870128333568573,
0.45172834396362305,
0.620490312576294,
0.18321087956428528,
-0.07736939191818237,
-0.014552131295204163,
-0.27606910467147827,
-0.6496078372001648,
-0.7421568632125854,
-0.5363613963127136,
-0.4750959873199463,
0.4105220437049866,
-0.7250258922576904,
0.03919326141476631,
-0.5954324007034302,
-0.12651336193084717,
-0.016754494979977608,
0.2587123215198517,
-0.553676426410675,
-0.0977550521492958,
0.1223812997341156,
0.5179095268249512,
-0.7427759766578674,
0.8328088521957397,
0.8922394514083862,
-0.13928104937076569,
-0.3811739683151245,
-0.3409748375415802,
-0.11467496305704117,
-0.1423899531364441,
1.0421593189239502,
0.3123490810394287,
0.03640482574701309,
-0.036954328417778015,
-0.4667605459690094,
-0.862797200679779,
0.5783547759056091,
0.5381168127059937,
-0.564974308013916,
0.06163758412003517,
0.06733005493879318,
0.7429823279380798,
-0.18380789458751678,
0.49351122975349426,
0.5267525911331177,
0.4568319618701935,
-0.028712401166558266,
-1.2319749593734741,
-0.30198895931243896,
-0.3962792158126831,
0.17230066657066345,
0.19725686311721802,
-0.5038509368896484,
0.8646061420440674,
0.016649343073368073,
-0.6156536936759949,
-0.03792755305767059,
0.959811806678772,
0.16159096360206604,
0.4089151918888092,
0.3819330632686615,
0.28724241256713867,
0.8194242715835571,
-0.3786037862300873,
0.9684082269668579,
-0.20367182791233063,
-0.07251223176717758,
1.3952884674072266,
-0.28423482179641724,
0.710719883441925,
0.30227237939834595,
-0.3244335949420929,
0.728202760219574,
0.5221670269966125,
0.4170980453491211,
0.24244382977485657,
0.1314181536436081,
-0.34914472699165344,
0.09293778240680695,
-0.29896485805511475,
-0.45758429169654846,
0.731138288974762,
0.8962353467941284,
-0.03863523527979851,
-0.011180629022419453,
0.05121678113937378,
0.26227715611457825,
0.45928412675857544,
-0.49787411093711853,
0.8289271593093872,
0.28733205795288086,
-0.7465018630027771,
0.8547656536102295,
0.006440003402531147,
0.9493262767791748,
-0.4230234920978546,
-0.1249329075217247,
-0.31777775287628174,
0.16973905265331268,
-0.2760743200778961,
-0.6356947422027588,
0.4588855504989624,
0.0035353791899979115,
-0.04675421491265297,
-0.3344813883304596,
0.5398377180099487,
-0.7016189694404602,
-0.39559757709503174,
0.17476382851600647,
0.359668493270874,
0.2531716227531433,
-0.24637162685394287,
-0.8087093234062195,
-0.23056115210056305,
-0.28932827711105347,
-0.0036093948874622583,
0.4009495675563812,
0.5111669898033142,
-0.3223261833190918,
0.7477218508720398,
0.5473601818084717,
0.2455430030822754,
-0.09992802143096924,
-0.5075262188911438,
0.612076997756958,
-0.4445800483226776,
-0.575709879398346,
-0.5296087861061096,
0.10626017302274704,
-0.18037214875221252,
-0.5158877968788147,
0.7160999178886414,
0.46845200657844543,
1.2113522291183472,
0.08178761601448059,
0.6625243425369263,
-0.1246393695473671,
0.7955958247184753,
-0.3043462634086609,
0.5039806962013245,
-0.12262322753667831,
0.1653105467557907,
-0.4460113048553467,
-0.9570291638374329,
0.02687401883304119,
1.1357882022857666,
-0.46634626388549805,
-0.2473740428686142,
0.7178893089294434,
0.4796488583087921,
-0.11712466180324554,
-0.05715401470661163,
0.013133635744452477,
0.2881021499633789,
-0.07575906813144684,
0.6000710725784302,
1.145531177520752,
-0.5031963586807251,
0.5018436908721924,
-0.4932194948196411,
-0.07458116114139557,
0.08602693676948547,
-0.9720919728279114,
-0.824055552482605,
-0.5325391888618469,
-0.6147282719612122,
-0.2598728835582733,
0.06338582932949066,
0.9645431637763977,
0.656641960144043,
-0.9703904390335083,
-0.4607434868812561,
0.1223083958029747,
0.4346030354499817,
-0.11278577893972397,
-0.22954384982585907,
0.35868558287620544,
0.02158414013683796,
-0.9958642721176147,
0.16134832799434662,
0.034242842346429825,
0.07968674600124359,
-0.4993348717689514,
-0.20059116184711456,
-0.422943651676178,
-0.6384943723678589,
0.6628338694572449,
0.6571070551872253,
-0.6380085349082947,
0.19761012494564056,
-0.38138413429260254,
-0.09737097471952438,
0.10569806396961212,
0.7046794295310974,
-1.1256935596466064,
0.17649376392364502,
0.3175120949745178,
0.5269263386726379,
0.6295454502105713,
0.13905878365039825,
0.6681535243988037,
-0.8892806768417358,
0.5705519914627075,
0.43018993735313416,
0.21673616766929626,
0.5792555809020996,
-0.3898383378982544,
0.6884397864341736,
0.1091637834906578,
-0.5367467999458313,
-0.751388430595398,
0.08854270726442337,
-0.633554995059967,
-0.30225077271461487,
1.1741764545440674,
-0.4843517541885376,
-0.25012388825416565,
-0.4935874044895172,
-0.34883370995521545,
0.06192384660243988,
-0.6392567157745361,
0.512471616268158,
0.28572916984558105,
-0.06988595426082611,
-0.15235356986522675,
-0.29093873500823975,
0.7611000537872314,
0.014547836035490036,
-0.5998711585998535,
-0.2840879261493683,
0.5688844323158264,
-0.017085354775190353,
0.4846782386302948,
0.7233883738517761,
0.12760889530181885,
0.29310303926467896,
-0.30410289764404297,
-0.10851527750492096,
0.08556506037712097,
-0.4019382894039154,
-0.2978050410747528,
0.17318470776081085,
-0.21675705909729004,
0.17135396599769592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18762v1 | Categorical Syllogisms Revisited: A Review of the Logical Reasoning Abilities of LLMs for Analyzing Categorical Syllogism | 2024-06-26T21:17:20 | 2024-06-26T21:17:20 | Shi Zong, Jimmy Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | There have been a huge number of benchmarks proposed to evaluate how large
language models (LLMs) behave for logic inference tasks. However, it remains an
open question how to properly evaluate this ability. In this paper, we provide
a systematic overview of prior works on the logical reasoning ability of LLMs
for analyzing categorical syllogisms. We first investigate all the possible
variations for the categorical syllogisms from a purely logical perspective and
then examine the underlying configurations (i.e., mood and figure) tested by
the existing datasets. Our results indicate that compared to template-based
synthetic datasets, crowdsourcing approaches normally sacrifice the coverage of
configurations (i.e., mood and figure) of categorical syllogisms for more
language variations, thus bringing challenges to fully testing LLMs under
different situations. We then proceed to summarize the findings and
observations for the performances of LLMs to infer the validity of syllogisms
from the current literature. The error rate breakdown analyses suggest that the
interpretation of the quantifiers seems to be the current bottleneck that
limits the performances of the LLMs and is thus worth more attention. Finally,
we discuss several points that might be worth considering when researchers plan
on the future release of categorical syllogism datasets. We hope our work will
not only provide a timely review of the current literature regarding
categorical syllogisms, but also motivate more interdisciplinary research
between communities, specifically computational linguists and logicians. | [
-0.29241013526916504,
-0.621139645576477,
0.650712788105011,
0.37833380699157715,
-0.2300548255443573,
0.10629627108573914,
-0.14193695783615112,
-0.33634495735168457,
0.17899274826049805,
0.6878868341445923,
-0.4973447024822235,
-0.5514537692070007,
-0.5030943751335144,
0.655497670173645,
-0.3471587300300598,
0.5980749130249023,
0.024704860523343086,
0.17037512362003326,
-0.5960756540298462,
-0.29610833525657654,
-0.5257312059402466,
-0.9464892148971558,
-0.3211263418197632,
-0.20900367200374603,
0.29153040051460266,
0.059672895818948746,
0.7119450569152832,
0.4636458456516266,
0.568722665309906,
0.30464044213294983,
-0.3262069821357727,
0.134698748588562,
-0.5217057466506958,
0.34894177317619324,
-0.29649901390075684,
-0.8529111742973328,
-0.3503156006336212,
-0.005610858555883169,
0.7255391478538513,
0.5412570834159851,
-0.5045122504234314,
0.2980996072292328,
-0.18705403804779053,
0.5922674536705017,
-0.688938558101654,
0.3759904205799103,
-0.6609075665473938,
0.20306813716888428,
-0.29151055216789246,
0.280325710773468,
-0.6659351587295532,
-0.5297327041625977,
-0.0014458460500463843,
-0.42739495635032654,
-0.05746317654848099,
0.25709056854248047,
0.44066211581230164,
0.5352457761764526,
-0.5230848789215088,
-0.15869569778442383,
-0.5994304418563843,
0.9487499594688416,
-0.6030564904212952,
0.28231802582740784,
0.3585995137691498,
0.40760403871536255,
-0.29664045572280884,
-0.7433661222457886,
-0.5309369564056396,
-0.25249430537223816,
-0.08987711369991302,
0.17061208188533783,
-0.5935788750648499,
-0.09385398775339127,
0.6765553951263428,
0.4029994308948517,
-0.5650336742401123,
0.005521462764590979,
-0.0774291530251503,
-0.06974156945943832,
0.6144742965698242,
0.44638025760650635,
0.3234589695930481,
-0.5454676151275635,
-0.47371912002563477,
0.016225511208176613,
-0.6249343156814575,
0.11484154313802719,
0.021261587738990784,
-0.11742338538169861,
0.05795934423804283,
0.8412315845489502,
-0.44519805908203125,
0.702860414981842,
-0.30358782410621643,
-0.2258581519126892,
0.15850937366485596,
-0.3329852521419525,
-0.38451555371284485,
-0.059224240481853485,
0.6533641815185547,
0.14921358227729797,
0.5577573180198669,
0.2095460593700409,
-0.2896966338157654,
0.4172482192516327,
0.01635178178548813,
-0.5791540741920471,
-0.34387457370758057,
-0.001173588098026812,
-0.3886999785900116,
0.049131955951452255,
-0.2829757630825043,
-0.5906185507774353,
-0.6590451598167419,
-0.4560963213443756,
0.06074579432606697,
-0.167328342795372,
-0.2592357397079468,
0.3947605490684509,
-0.0020286771468818188,
0.06571995466947556,
0.46185019612312317,
-0.45314285159111023,
0.3239339292049408,
0.7558649182319641,
0.5321061611175537,
-0.091566301882267,
0.07039349526166916,
-0.48261964321136475,
-0.05765312910079956,
-0.33968451619148254,
1.1063690185546875,
-0.4719139039516449,
-0.216116264462471,
-0.17232920229434967,
-0.08487541973590851,
-0.17968633770942688,
-0.6716086268424988,
0.11504219472408295,
-0.2894832491874695,
0.1381140947341919,
-0.3373996615409851,
-0.4919191598892212,
-0.21518699824810028,
0.418609619140625,
-0.8727347254753113,
0.7841152548789978,
-0.05799048766493797,
-0.6046003699302673,
0.25501492619514465,
-0.003969296813011169,
-0.08487523347139359,
-0.06810835748910904,
-0.33732011914253235,
-0.2363402247428894,
0.2569272518157959,
0.29320821166038513,
0.433738112449646,
-0.7166071534156799,
0.6170982122421265,
-0.5825561881065369,
-0.04592299088835716,
0.7133971452713013,
-0.1928393393754959,
1.1208937168121338,
0.06841102987527847,
-0.13722479343414307,
0.05008431524038315,
-0.5519521832466125,
0.047288939356803894,
-0.0021301473025232553,
0.18052130937576294,
-0.24125058948993683,
0.3538961410522461,
-0.3758002817630768,
0.4116056561470032,
-0.015693262219429016,
-0.27138370275497437,
0.14820346236228943,
-0.17373202741146088,
0.5350291728973389,
0.7456597089767456,
-0.2177085131406784,
0.02267611399292946,
-0.302558034658432,
0.8179088830947876,
-0.20779286324977875,
0.31468069553375244,
0.054006367921829224,
-0.5787038207054138,
-0.747907817363739,
-0.5623390674591064,
0.22772151231765747,
0.6620602607727051,
-0.8078266978263855,
-0.07028069347143173,
-0.13112126290798187,
-0.3567613363265991,
-0.280156672000885,
0.03498736768960953,
0.5498515963554382,
0.20227272808551788,
0.09096448868513107,
-0.36408716440200806,
-0.5496492385864258,
-1.010295033454895,
-0.4177926778793335,
-0.5695651173591614,
0.28403541445732117,
0.11272674798965454,
0.5521054267883301,
0.13670961558818817,
0.9498656392097473,
-0.4510785639286041,
0.23186840116977692,
-0.264945924282074,
-0.06878600269556046,
0.23351363837718964,
0.07951373606920242,
0.379523903131485,
-0.4899007976055145,
0.139805868268013,
-0.32561957836151123,
-0.8384405970573425,
-0.2104092389345169,
0.2025870829820633,
-0.16318005323410034,
0.3076331913471222,
0.397561639547348,
-0.8048232197761536,
0.5874331593513489,
0.37129467725753784,
-0.43205592036247253,
0.8613499402999878,
0.3928241431713104,
-0.06327715516090393,
-0.7675671577453613,
-0.20180118083953857,
0.19541728496551514,
-0.2967921197414398,
-0.3143976628780365,
0.14009487628936768,
-0.15258967876434326,
-0.028915150091052055,
-0.43086063861846924,
0.5424566864967346,
-0.3912961483001709,
-0.3069015145301819,
0.13648462295532227,
0.2545667886734009,
-0.1919431835412979,
0.21772553026676178,
0.06263111531734467,
0.4641648828983307,
0.36747464537620544,
-0.23711420595645905,
0.6744533181190491,
0.14754371345043182,
-0.4892520606517792,
0.8370462656021118,
-0.47393080592155457,
-0.14422821998596191,
-0.19446319341659546,
0.6688593029975891,
-1.0044444799423218,
-0.11804959923028946,
0.3792613744735718,
-0.22562088072299957,
-0.2103937864303589,
0.06990037858486176,
-0.8794431686401367,
-0.40922635793685913,
-0.19247856736183167,
0.4367437958717346,
0.5242254137992859,
-0.4039953649044037,
0.34703630208969116,
0.597287654876709,
-0.0531361848115921,
-0.4019000828266144,
-0.4746096432209015,
0.22486616671085358,
-0.4761946201324463,
-0.5104174017906189,
-0.24284864962100983,
0.04803638532757759,
-0.9040342569351196,
-0.12801167368888855,
-0.3415817320346832,
-0.09901998192071915,
0.16323545575141907,
0.1308833807706833,
0.16194893419742584,
-0.2735140919685364,
0.38868847489356995,
-0.2754381597042084,
-0.21233709156513214,
0.45105868577957153,
-0.14985790848731995,
0.3297935128211975,
-0.34182360768318176,
-0.3549093008041382,
-0.3609270453453064,
-0.015915775671601295,
0.22451604902744293,
-0.4165802001953125,
0.5242151021957397,
0.3039989173412323,
-0.5545501708984375,
-0.2759098708629608,
-0.6994595527648926,
-0.07127603888511658,
-0.32188743352890015,
0.21236203610897064,
-0.29831790924072266,
-0.9070150852203369,
0.3773852586746216,
-0.0019401157042011619,
-0.19123920798301697,
0.4705880880355835,
0.639122724533081,
-0.011907978914678097,
1.1085947751998901,
0.35984888672828674,
0.1150842234492302,
0.05502769351005554,
-0.14340022206306458,
0.21357287466526031,
-0.5052807331085205,
-0.5363409519195557,
-0.674552857875824,
-0.10232052206993103,
-0.8341997265815735,
-0.5386600494384766,
0.1472962200641632,
0.1534789800643921,
-0.26770415902137756,
0.04103103652596474,
-0.13825656473636627,
0.3418715000152588,
0.028477147221565247,
0.18094469606876373,
0.5948917269706726,
-0.015832679346203804,
0.07955425977706909,
-0.08153405040502548,
-0.8229705095291138,
-0.551238477230072,
0.7679950594902039,
0.128146693110466,
0.8034310936927795,
0.2861953675746918,
0.3024511933326721,
0.021585671231150627,
0.5630534291267395,
-0.7759555578231812,
0.8615514636039734,
-0.2499532401561737,
-0.6915574669837952,
-0.20207765698432922,
-0.4400465190410614,
-0.7387084364891052,
0.5617979168891907,
-0.11557416617870331,
-0.9113630652427673,
0.3266083598136902,
0.17538221180438995,
0.0040036216378211975,
0.31200486421585083,
-0.4194400906562805,
0.6664137244224548,
-0.15365007519721985,
-0.10797034204006195,
-0.44571635127067566,
-0.5014514327049255,
0.8120457530021667,
-0.08539220690727234,
0.21033385396003723,
-0.45818087458610535,
-0.09121691435575485,
0.6372265815734863,
-0.4876514971256256,
0.9575788378715515,
0.21741525828838348,
-0.38954269886016846,
0.3588157594203949,
0.22618412971496582,
0.16298767924308777,
0.2957162857055664,
-0.2721148133277893,
0.2525063157081604,
0.2250826060771942,
-0.43404191732406616,
-0.7936868071556091,
0.4239777624607086,
-0.34259501099586487,
-1.1202515363693237,
-0.6020983457565308,
-0.5279321074485779,
-0.35891637206077576,
-0.011183155700564384,
-0.17513540387153625,
0.5914838910102844,
0.007768184877932072,
0.3939930200576782,
0.7386871576309204,
-0.23824207484722137,
0.08173791319131851,
0.24534425139427185,
-0.5830888748168945,
-0.4885041117668152,
0.709599494934082,
0.0733102485537529,
0.3168289363384247,
0.3961946368217468,
0.04280046746134758,
-0.4026046693325043,
-0.28323256969451904,
-0.278599351644516,
0.3904326856136322,
-0.722352147102356,
-0.2108568251132965,
-0.27729734778404236,
0.06359244883060455,
-0.10640937834978104,
0.36939841508865356,
-0.10010867565870285,
-0.6698455214500427,
-0.22670729458332062,
0.07445748150348663,
0.5429616570472717,
0.7126572132110596,
0.22101689875125885,
-0.0400422140955925,
-0.28559374809265137,
0.3494439423084259,
0.20179718732833862,
0.1557011753320694,
-0.035709451884031296,
-0.1706313192844391,
0.13904987275600433,
-0.07019563019275665,
-0.140011265873909,
-0.9184183478355408,
0.19243954122066498,
-0.14007039368152618,
0.5847993493080139,
0.16697505116462708,
0.024244055151939392,
0.8129107356071472,
-0.15171056985855103,
0.7588502764701843,
0.28742367029190063,
-0.926323652267456,
0.47990721464157104,
-0.2714962661266327,
0.31871297955513,
0.11876561492681503,
0.33325567841529846,
-0.43227899074554443,
-0.5361154675483704,
-0.48293694853782654,
-0.4836471676826477,
0.5145344734191895,
0.3956272006034851,
-0.2487855851650238,
-0.1932438611984253,
0.28408730030059814,
0.09713312238454819,
0.2990438640117645,
-0.6605749726295471,
-0.19358843564987183,
-0.08847422152757645,
-0.08608873933553696,
-0.4488338232040405,
-0.16431762278079987,
-0.04648888483643532,
-0.3550347685813904,
0.19615870714187622,
0.03787516802549362,
-0.04548163712024689,
0.04320488125085831,
-0.3150842487812042,
0.2728827893733978,
0.28108784556388855,
0.3044237196445465,
0.9134097695350647,
0.11894301325082779,
0.3014861047267914,
0.24583123624324799,
-0.2577912211418152,
0.34338217973709106,
-0.00430092541500926,
0.055283281952142715,
-0.05013618618249893,
0.4786991477012634,
0.7722415924072266,
0.2735055685043335,
-0.926781415939331,
0.21175223588943481,
-0.09525754302740097,
-0.0902513712644577,
-0.23673754930496216,
0.17437326908111572,
0.07150612771511078,
0.5168189406394958,
-0.0021006104070693254,
-0.19168932735919952,
-0.0030494998209178448,
-0.6073223948478699,
-0.09139947593212128,
0.49248477816581726,
-0.15456247329711914,
-0.29729142785072327,
0.31339848041534424,
-0.12094017118215561,
-0.24386677145957947,
0.6440499424934387,
-0.07803706079721451,
-0.4459080994129181,
0.8933850526809692,
0.6436520218849182,
0.6104103326797485,
-0.2335996776819229,
0.36602169275283813,
0.0542023591697216,
0.582043468952179,
-0.31156596541404724,
0.3882816433906555,
-0.060013528913259506,
-0.5090007185935974,
-0.6502506136894226,
-0.5375936627388,
-0.3464878797531128,
0.05964881181716919,
-0.696394681930542,
0.10136181116104126,
-0.3869793713092804,
-0.28722840547561646,
-0.2775244414806366,
-0.12803706526756287,
-0.6015385389328003,
0.23959770798683167,
0.12564735114574432,
0.8229483366012573,
-0.5536764860153198,
0.4660171568393707,
0.9885745048522949,
-0.06473193317651749,
-0.7163576483726501,
-0.14153002202510834,
0.17601598799228668,
-0.820405125617981,
0.6863113641738892,
0.0371910035610199,
-0.15585944056510925,
0.02565944939851761,
-0.4335806369781494,
-0.898516833782196,
0.9413576126098633,
0.6911588311195374,
-0.47502923011779785,
0.16173318028450012,
0.27272796630859375,
0.5874413251876831,
-0.20924963057041168,
0.394011914730072,
0.7350346446037292,
0.42469751834869385,
-0.18112312257289886,
-0.8567465543746948,
0.19314894080162048,
-0.2979676127433777,
0.28574755787849426,
0.30872654914855957,
-0.6694960594177246,
0.8225930333137512,
-0.02299182489514351,
-0.25260666012763977,
0.28144723176956177,
0.6083658337593079,
0.7715792655944824,
0.30070969462394714,
0.5462280511856079,
0.7595154047012329,
0.7855625748634338,
-0.1346590220928192,
1.1865606307983398,
0.13946732878684998,
0.3755316436290741,
0.6502957940101624,
-0.3210749328136444,
0.753198504447937,
0.3709031045436859,
-0.42005300521850586,
0.5416658520698547,
0.7042371034622192,
0.10346612334251404,
0.07471011579036713,
0.6670202612876892,
-0.14485050737857819,
-0.7631922364234924,
-0.32373687624931335,
-0.3510217070579529,
0.47962385416030884,
0.4725005328655243,
-0.028681932017207146,
-0.31976109743118286,
0.023894120007753372,
-0.07439131289720535,
0.08788558840751648,
-0.3751859962940216,
0.48903071880340576,
0.37413352727890015,
-0.5191856622695923,
0.7483989000320435,
-0.1764805018901825,
0.08620408922433853,
-0.11205986142158508,
-0.1332555115222931,
-0.33909130096435547,
-0.14622631669044495,
-0.22347024083137512,
-0.7474991083145142,
0.084588922560215,
0.28073734045028687,
-0.06546071916818619,
-0.20553304255008698,
0.6551908850669861,
0.10078059881925583,
-0.5964008569717407,
0.024059616029262543,
0.6264795660972595,
0.2834668755531311,
0.16037288308143616,
-0.5386205315589905,
0.15095195174217224,
-0.03861960396170616,
-0.18707464635372162,
0.13259074091911316,
0.5519152879714966,
-0.4795498251914978,
1.0084829330444336,
0.43759995698928833,
-0.009597559459507465,
-0.07427007704973221,
0.09284356981515884,
0.579452633857727,
-0.900384247303009,
-0.359006404876709,
-0.9907963275909424,
0.37063610553741455,
0.11937602609395981,
-0.4279891848564148,
0.8800157308578491,
0.3701825439929962,
0.8408527374267578,
0.009877348318696022,
0.36477553844451904,
0.2566605508327484,
0.07347240298986435,
-0.8518614768981934,
0.30225670337677,
-0.4724673926830292,
0.3342575430870056,
-0.37636736035346985,
-0.8753441572189331,
-0.46003738045692444,
0.615046501159668,
-0.6133220791816711,
-0.12727923691272736,
0.8503311276435852,
0.6522615551948547,
0.1810094118118286,
0.4105323255062103,
0.11339563131332397,
0.48885059356689453,
0.04298052936792374,
0.5530266761779785,
1.494339942932129,
0.0458282008767128,
0.35308876633644104,
-0.23493008315563202,
-0.1197505071759224,
-0.11005253344774246,
-0.9127638936042786,
-0.8840823173522949,
-0.4776609539985657,
-0.3105922043323517,
-0.17397178709506989,
0.2598592936992645,
0.4765668213367462,
0.3457919657230377,
-0.4839476943016052,
-0.5467175245285034,
0.058237139135599136,
0.5242348909378052,
-0.07396776974201202,
-0.21043452620506287,
0.17056730389595032,
-0.05937853455543518,
-0.41044801473617554,
-0.08444487303495407,
0.22927097976207733,
-0.38506004214286804,
-0.3625393509864807,
0.19995161890983582,
0.08000476658344269,
0.02354947291314602,
0.8885948657989502,
0.05750918760895729,
-1.1777483224868774,
-0.024348460137844086,
-0.02710656076669693,
-0.12396886199712753,
-0.12146676331758499,
0.8907726407051086,
-1.16023850440979,
0.29551583528518677,
0.5287718772888184,
0.4005858600139618,
0.3251897096633911,
-0.07175909727811813,
0.35865843296051025,
-0.08238770067691803,
0.08110517263412476,
0.23970918357372284,
0.4216933846473694,
0.09613505005836487,
0.053592026233673096,
0.4052329957485199,
0.4689898192882538,
-0.2056574821472168,
-1.0848616361618042,
0.3549928069114685,
-0.9123172760009766,
-0.2760906517505646,
1.160591959953308,
0.04888506606221199,
-0.2698996961116791,
0.008875531144440174,
-0.09486367553472519,
0.06793282181024551,
-0.08999630808830261,
0.8043464422225952,
0.7036818265914917,
-0.2980520725250244,
-0.0467974953353405,
-0.6952099204063416,
0.24706365168094635,
0.5657004117965698,
-1.075125813484192,
-0.0565166249871254,
0.7842151522636414,
0.03464527800679207,
-0.12993381917476654,
0.4179771840572357,
-0.16676932573318481,
0.423168420791626,
-0.3386407494544983,
-0.06549784541130066,
0.36490076780319214,
-0.1837836056947708,
-0.42961999773979187,
-0.04570416361093521,
-0.0889323428273201,
0.25937214493751526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18740v1 | Re-Ranking Step by Step: Investigating Pre-Filtering for Re-Ranking with Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T20:12:24 | 2024-06-26T20:12:24 | Baharan Nouriinanloo, Maxime Lamothe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been revolutionizing a myriad of natural
language processing tasks with their diverse zero-shot capabilities. Indeed,
existing work has shown that LLMs can be used to great effect for many tasks,
such as information retrieval (IR), and passage ranking. However, current
state-of-the-art results heavily lean on the capabilities of the LLM being
used. Currently, proprietary, and very large LLMs such as GPT-4 are the highest
performing passage re-rankers. Hence, users without the resources to leverage
top of the line LLMs, or ones that are closed source, are at a disadvantage. In
this paper, we investigate the use of a pre-filtering step before passage
re-ranking in IR. Our experiments show that by using a small number of human
generated relevance scores, coupled with LLM relevance scoring, it is
effectively possible to filter out irrelevant passages before re-ranking. Our
experiments also show that this pre-filtering then allows the LLM to perform
significantly better at the re-ranking task. Indeed, our results show that
smaller models such as Mixtral can become competitive with much larger
proprietary models (e.g., ChatGPT and GPT-4). | [
-0.49275457859039307,
-0.5235227346420288,
1.017620325088501,
-0.08203206211328506,
-0.4489416182041168,
0.04132157191634178,
-0.2388056069612503,
-0.5343533158302307,
0.2659342885017395,
0.9405404925346375,
-0.3409740626811981,
-0.7080373764038086,
-0.7049806714057922,
0.2543300688266754,
-0.5005233883857727,
0.9946801066398621,
0.1045784279704094,
-0.1472756564617157,
-0.20166991651058197,
-0.026011601090431213,
-0.2638334631919861,
-0.6252070665359497,
-0.46885207295417786,
-0.6694440841674805,
0.9447320103645325,
0.39406290650367737,
0.7387503385543823,
0.3235466480255127,
0.6876208186149597,
0.23044760525226593,
-0.0629204660654068,
-0.34898391366004944,
-0.7565708160400391,
0.4431646466255188,
-0.28120899200439453,
-0.5672000646591187,
-0.4798884093761444,
0.38866400718688965,
0.7495594620704651,
0.6276338696479797,
-0.11599171161651611,
0.23539935052394867,
0.16784757375717163,
0.5984490513801575,
-0.5858454704284668,
-0.14152933657169342,
-0.8913750648498535,
-0.07986219972372055,
-0.5115568041801453,
-0.5032413005828857,
-0.6540073156356812,
-0.5392847061157227,
0.28065359592437744,
-0.42715030908584595,
0.27063000202178955,
0.22144706547260284,
0.7973891496658325,
0.2140602171421051,
-0.3408174216747284,
-0.10014794766902924,
-0.5938677787780762,
0.7696053981781006,
-0.8511795401573181,
0.5847382545471191,
0.44271111488342285,
0.17290781438350677,
-0.26442521810531616,
-1.0751866102218628,
-0.38195717334747314,
-0.5608015060424805,
-0.12130925804376602,
-0.11103589087724686,
0.03503014147281647,
0.16442438960075378,
0.28633278608322144,
0.42045262455940247,
-0.587622880935669,
0.14639398455619812,
-0.280258446931839,
-0.12953121960163116,
0.27115198969841003,
0.03136969730257988,
0.06971067190170288,
0.06357947736978531,
-0.15624603629112244,
-0.13468416035175323,
-0.976444661617279,
-0.2776276171207428,
0.08533722907304764,
0.38489317893981934,
0.5808653235435486,
0.6054604649543762,
-0.33261242508888245,
0.8232928514480591,
0.01017431728541851,
0.06415904313325882,
0.14370688796043396,
-0.5588368773460388,
-0.2802946865558624,
-0.11371717602014542,
0.6756298542022705,
-0.04631657153367996,
0.1124505028128624,
-0.09612515568733215,
-0.42076581716537476,
-0.4605380594730377,
0.4013315737247467,
-0.9750801920890808,
-0.18269212543964386,
-0.1233857274055481,
-0.47349873185157776,
-0.09755981713533401,
-0.1519249677658081,
-0.6364638805389404,
-0.22453022003173828,
-0.3410170078277588,
0.7694958448410034,
0.06190982460975647,
-0.04672783240675926,
-0.009178516454994678,
0.1981763243675232,
0.37155163288116455,
0.4357859194278717,
-0.4406000077724457,
0.3010146915912628,
0.6905494928359985,
0.8601433038711548,
-0.16023094952106476,
-0.3110973536968231,
-0.9251615405082703,
-0.14483021199703217,
-0.3433569371700287,
0.8469212651252747,
-0.797670304775238,
-0.3238256275653839,
-0.06349590420722961,
-0.30949798226356506,
0.11479967087507248,
-0.7417731285095215,
0.6620423197746277,
-1.18008291721344,
0.35373038053512573,
-0.31911492347717285,
-0.5472885370254517,
-0.03690893575549126,
0.3637850284576416,
-0.6893694996833801,
0.8889275193214417,
-0.13736841082572937,
-0.5866101384162903,
0.38168221712112427,
-0.5638031959533691,
-0.5656474828720093,
0.09357765316963196,
-0.03167955204844475,
-0.22221064567565918,
0.07532674074172974,
0.1910930722951889,
0.3505885601043701,
-0.4896724224090576,
0.00696494709700346,
-0.33881497383117676,
-0.5613260269165039,
-0.13250575959682465,
-0.32283133268356323,
0.3129025399684906,
0.33285897970199585,
-0.09524653851985931,
0.16743747889995575,
-0.23153652250766754,
0.1328907459974289,
-0.24899736046791077,
-0.6772235035896301,
-0.440695583820343,
-0.1408238708972931,
-0.22837096452713013,
0.40061110258102417,
0.3263503909111023,
-0.41027188301086426,
0.11184406280517578,
-0.32536500692367554,
0.177564799785614,
0.6734856963157654,
0.05348974093794823,
0.4491148591041565,
-0.21044526994228363,
0.7263816595077515,
-0.39349567890167236,
-0.001411060686223209,
-0.0825595110654831,
-0.6673167943954468,
-0.6051845550537109,
-0.02651987224817276,
0.6295738220214844,
0.3583346903324127,
-0.7212636470794678,
0.3082902431488037,
-0.31732529401779175,
-0.5563512444496155,
-0.6650034785270691,
0.27302876114845276,
0.22445082664489746,
0.2876719832420349,
0.4387544095516205,
-0.2971579432487488,
-0.19208061695098877,
-0.6787063479423523,
-0.5704556703567505,
-0.16527016460895538,
-0.15606991946697235,
0.3797489404678345,
0.3511064052581787,
-0.18091492354869843,
0.8347665071487427,
-0.8577477335929871,
-0.5326733589172363,
-0.32387059926986694,
0.22498548030853271,
0.5899535417556763,
0.07797854393720627,
0.07477187365293503,
-0.8310590386390686,
-0.45197489857673645,
-0.20955254137516022,
-0.418742299079895,
-0.36179235577583313,
0.0539514422416687,
-0.36808717250823975,
-0.03308098018169403,
0.7651993632316589,
-0.567171573638916,
0.48066961765289307,
0.34819793701171875,
-0.2419767528772354,
0.5143684148788452,
-0.4485240876674652,
0.43090835213661194,
-0.7512133717536926,
0.2028225064277649,
-0.05041714385151863,
-0.5246918201446533,
-0.5340466499328613,
0.13012664020061493,
-0.13356807827949524,
-0.19350813329219818,
-0.3632802367210388,
0.5571401119232178,
-0.5288424491882324,
-0.18889135122299194,
-0.503059983253479,
0.4196180999279022,
0.06989914923906326,
0.2529013156890869,
0.0504242479801178,
0.5850319862365723,
0.1684088259935379,
-0.7275591492652893,
-0.06253115832805634,
0.0312051884829998,
-0.4325515925884247,
0.07866933196783066,
-0.5156722068786621,
0.23346658051013947,
-0.014488974586129189,
0.4538027048110962,
-1.0452615022659302,
0.09765779972076416,
-0.02091841772198677,
-0.43866708874702454,
0.3748836815357208,
-0.31412720680236816,
-0.5742202401161194,
-0.10359102487564087,
-0.369853675365448,
0.5665856003761292,
0.3944947123527527,
-0.45377039909362793,
0.5925979018211365,
0.2535800635814667,
-0.41265931725502014,
-0.49909481406211853,
-0.3752428889274597,
0.34832748770713806,
-0.17551787197589874,
-0.4567021429538727,
0.625696063041687,
-0.19544069468975067,
-0.07657590508460999,
0.04645490646362305,
-0.18276748061180115,
-0.013002772815525532,
0.15011414885520935,
0.005630707833915949,
0.222416490316391,
-0.20280727744102478,
0.03560885787010193,
-0.2613973617553711,
-0.180583655834198,
-0.10988640040159225,
-0.1774856448173523,
0.6200675964355469,
0.07932155579328537,
-0.4756517708301544,
-0.21082627773284912,
0.22484001517295837,
0.8271914124488831,
-0.39450982213020325,
0.7746146321296692,
0.4719732999801636,
-0.3222377300262451,
0.1023821011185646,
-0.8706396818161011,
-0.3891587257385254,
-0.46247658133506775,
0.31860125064849854,
-0.24331796169281006,
-1.1246861219406128,
0.30784177780151367,
0.13738089799880981,
0.1543843001127243,
0.2719951272010803,
0.44679728150367737,
-0.03456562012434006,
0.6876131892204285,
0.47078216075897217,
-0.36906352639198303,
0.8218792676925659,
0.13533204793930054,
0.4627808928489685,
-0.9182129502296448,
-0.057590946555137634,
-0.6687551140785217,
-0.4652451276779175,
-0.7394523620605469,
-0.4493977427482605,
0.4374716877937317,
0.0035687140189111233,
-0.04576868191361427,
0.2364192008972168,
-0.08061863481998444,
0.6761666536331177,
0.6720607876777649,
0.03588263690471649,
0.5963249206542969,
-0.06675723195075989,
-0.10340225696563721,
0.0021974786650389433,
-0.416912317276001,
-0.37044888734817505,
1.4245948791503906,
0.08890707045793533,
0.9334630966186523,
0.18016943335533142,
0.9754300117492676,
0.44956645369529724,
0.7452303171157837,
-0.5575262904167175,
0.7076606154441833,
-0.2525542676448822,
-0.6361938118934631,
-0.4927830994129181,
-0.5476869940757751,
-1.1264705657958984,
0.8815457820892334,
-0.2332741916179657,
-0.4639868438243866,
-0.12175431847572327,
-0.01183872390538454,
-0.39975497126579285,
0.27695438265800476,
-0.5969500541687012,
0.6489312052726746,
-0.16503946483135223,
-0.5118628740310669,
-0.43880152702331543,
-0.4041186273097992,
0.3381809592247009,
-0.31191134452819824,
0.0952766165137291,
0.04597097635269165,
0.004538256675004959,
0.7355406284332275,
-0.26641106605529785,
0.41207998991012573,
-0.13331863284111023,
0.0011991527862846851,
0.13553881645202637,
0.06226484477519989,
0.4871579110622406,
-0.06407595425844193,
-0.2613753378391266,
0.07131227850914001,
-0.218925341963768,
-0.1519107073545456,
-0.5727279186248779,
1.049403190612793,
-0.40810686349868774,
-1.164934754371643,
-0.5641651749610901,
0.026493003591895103,
-0.06121673807501793,
0.5539772510528564,
0.2966691255569458,
0.2666071057319641,
0.10467968136072159,
0.5461950898170471,
0.6756272315979004,
-0.22023725509643555,
0.1587708294391632,
0.7930551767349243,
-0.4914875626564026,
-0.29832831025123596,
0.6521568894386292,
0.273349404335022,
0.32453274726867676,
0.6030502915382385,
0.2168140858411789,
-0.5779922604560852,
-0.8777716159820557,
0.13645312190055847,
0.5238170027732849,
-0.660531222820282,
-0.14020970463752747,
-0.5339682102203369,
-0.21371735632419586,
-0.5253550410270691,
0.07270283252000809,
-0.23961974680423737,
0.0069480957463383675,
-0.24875503778457642,
-0.07623042166233063,
-0.10638382285833359,
0.7935251593589783,
0.05882153660058975,
0.07561726868152618,
-0.7584843635559082,
0.461342990398407,
0.29541951417922974,
0.6023048758506775,
0.035806141793727875,
-0.8424822688102722,
-0.24376270174980164,
-0.3409499228000641,
-0.3779616057872772,
-0.5981967449188232,
0.3123837411403656,
0.045108046382665634,
0.8587660193443298,
0.13191914558410645,
0.11298886686563492,
0.6125887036323547,
-0.6327043175697327,
0.6646550297737122,
-0.19985097646713257,
-0.6977875232696533,
0.5326419472694397,
-0.12294258922338486,
0.3466166853904724,
0.8049329519271851,
0.3455256223678589,
-0.38010382652282715,
-0.3654598593711853,
-0.28996455669403076,
-1.1599196195602417,
0.7981421947479248,
0.39605459570884705,
-0.12542328238487244,
0.13575862348079681,
0.5198729634284973,
-0.07091237604618073,
0.32022830843925476,
-0.9947862029075623,
-0.19181011617183685,
0.23572604358196259,
0.15911051630973816,
-0.37224090099334717,
-0.47639375925064087,
0.34818559885025024,
-0.1860082745552063,
0.8027632832527161,
0.2918914258480072,
0.04157121479511261,
0.33589082956314087,
-0.307472288608551,
-0.004955057520419359,
0.39938873052597046,
0.4440968632698059,
0.6395893692970276,
-0.45260316133499146,
0.09720687568187714,
0.056156303733587265,
-0.422564834356308,
0.16622574627399445,
0.007883071899414062,
-0.11602956801652908,
-0.002444383455440402,
0.4366620182991028,
0.4046955704689026,
0.41605114936828613,
-0.5013564229011536,
0.3283030390739441,
-0.1510007381439209,
0.02057352289557457,
-0.1799020767211914,
-0.0011737170862033963,
0.018729763105511665,
0.19840183854103088,
0.38956841826438904,
-0.17960608005523682,
0.29150524735450745,
-0.582109808921814,
0.4334371089935303,
0.39466848969459534,
-0.18631373345851898,
-0.1751575469970703,
0.5711514949798584,
0.3113900423049927,
-0.46633288264274597,
0.7760570049285889,
0.054231785237789154,
-0.498384028673172,
0.05083605274558067,
0.4032288193702698,
0.7781291007995605,
-0.40063926577568054,
-0.04488464817404747,
0.3295721411705017,
0.45417097210884094,
-0.33502471446990967,
-0.05826827883720398,
-0.2649815082550049,
-0.6365131735801697,
-0.5707821846008301,
-0.6985180974006653,
-0.41348835825920105,
0.41276803612709045,
-0.6413925290107727,
0.2798973023891449,
-0.22593767940998077,
-0.38606318831443787,
-0.16587761044502258,
0.0981362983584404,
-0.8122594356536865,
0.10928989201784134,
0.24310941994190216,
0.9515939950942993,
-0.6291772127151489,
0.902917742729187,
0.5738556981086731,
-0.32959309220314026,
-0.49863186478614807,
0.5782490968704224,
-0.3053358793258667,
-0.464230477809906,
0.8319997787475586,
0.2278653234243393,
-0.4567336440086365,
0.18424202501773834,
-0.1890963912010193,
-1.0999960899353027,
1.0411403179168701,
0.4128343462944031,
-0.478807270526886,
-0.14108365774154663,
-0.07368670403957367,
0.5991145968437195,
-0.18400771915912628,
0.4499870836734772,
0.6279895901679993,
0.44993793964385986,
0.18072758615016937,
-0.9314727783203125,
-0.007757601793855429,
-0.02020210400223732,
-0.22979891300201416,
0.34663233160972595,
-0.31667566299438477,
0.8397047519683838,
-0.15718881785869598,
-0.08068767935037613,
0.037166960537433624,
0.4564281702041626,
0.37009701132774353,
0.3070550560951233,
0.6454313397407532,
0.47801443934440613,
0.6673437356948853,
0.09812211990356445,
1.0987540483474731,
-0.014593539759516716,
0.2341880053281784,
1.2570936679840088,
-0.7059991955757141,
1.328620433807373,
0.3863871991634369,
-0.1473509520292282,
0.5032814145088196,
0.5747479796409607,
0.44170984625816345,
0.6596865653991699,
0.30555781722068787,
-0.20731903612613678,
-0.6723650693893433,
0.07284577190876007,
-0.3750525414943695,
0.3207073509693146,
0.18540139496326447,
-0.4628855288028717,
-0.3826664090156555,
-0.18890509009361267,
-0.13973115384578705,
-0.11891517788171768,
-0.3112410306930542,
0.6605541706085205,
0.30826058983802795,
-0.9267158508300781,
0.4312512278556824,
-0.17520175874233246,
0.6379627585411072,
-0.7310881018638611,
-0.16837619245052338,
-0.4267410933971405,
0.11545420438051224,
-0.012423297390341759,
-1.0622087717056274,
-0.030767280608415604,
0.04433571547269821,
-0.15129953622817993,
-0.39927253127098083,
0.7397841215133667,
-0.3806007206439972,
-0.3306415379047394,
0.6477621793746948,
0.5205579996109009,
0.31452274322509766,
-0.4864349365234375,
-0.4313376247882843,
-0.0793261006474495,
0.14710821211338043,
-0.5646935105323792,
0.6862025260925293,
0.19341237843036652,
-0.01709827408194542,
0.992693305015564,
0.8411234617233276,
0.19044658541679382,
-0.10573830455541611,
0.2639140784740448,
0.8553237318992615,
-0.9052354097366333,
-0.5997166633605957,
-0.8907249569892883,
0.06630091369152069,
0.046194273978471756,
0.11283250153064728,
0.6921108961105347,
0.526948869228363,
0.8554267883300781,
0.22587285935878754,
0.5331728458404541,
0.40588805079460144,
0.5018119215965271,
-0.6390840411186218,
0.8592397570610046,
-0.7519952654838562,
0.6623316407203674,
-0.32658523321151733,
-1.223980188369751,
-0.45837706327438354,
0.39885422587394714,
-0.5147162079811096,
0.31092917919158936,
0.5713833570480347,
0.7953150272369385,
0.05833256617188454,
-0.24967803061008453,
0.6085456013679504,
0.3267706632614136,
0.5726016759872437,
0.3715783953666687,
0.8292250037193298,
-0.11282426118850708,
0.8003893494606018,
0.2420177310705185,
-0.14112704992294312,
-0.43531230092048645,
-0.8788582682609558,
-0.7275097966194153,
-0.41427740454673767,
-0.19559994339942932,
-0.1987476795911789,
-0.15301620960235596,
0.7699539065361023,
0.6886089444160461,
-0.5968208909034729,
-0.18278607726097107,
0.3660588562488556,
0.3550933599472046,
0.1958247721195221,
-0.17997907102108002,
0.1038971021771431,
-0.2563895881175995,
-0.47580331563949585,
0.5706807374954224,
0.25621429085731506,
-0.2667030692100525,
-0.23001201450824738,
-0.041074059903621674,
-0.43196603655815125,
0.025126850232481956,
0.6352112889289856,
-0.03740217164158821,
-0.7651320695877075,
-0.34765321016311646,
-0.04559751972556114,
0.05350638926029205,
0.05393262207508087,
1.0158253908157349,
-1.088792324066162,
0.30810460448265076,
0.6251426935195923,
0.5242365598678589,
0.6266602873802185,
0.1717740148305893,
0.5806494355201721,
-0.4554581642150879,
-0.435427725315094,
0.3891829550266266,
0.4503011107444763,
0.2824520468711853,
-0.2778083086013794,
0.4171616733074188,
0.012720157392323017,
-0.8394564390182495,
-0.8873224258422852,
0.15184153616428375,
-0.6445948481559753,
-0.11678779870271683,
1.058167576789856,
-0.08812160044908524,
0.14187856018543243,
-0.15216025710105896,
-0.11273499578237534,
0.03467125818133354,
-0.4517185389995575,
0.6113411784172058,
0.8063308596611023,
-0.1775897592306137,
-0.07187368720769882,
-0.5049070119857788,
0.321866899728775,
0.36726316809654236,
-0.654562771320343,
0.06559691578149796,
0.29913708567619324,
0.5700643658638,
0.14353828132152557,
0.8665515780448914,
-0.22340545058250427,
-0.08554641902446747,
-0.5399157404899597,
-0.2941524386405945,
0.08675990253686905,
-0.3573794662952423,
-0.34220921993255615,
0.34396472573280334,
0.5222400426864624,
-0.14167730510234833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18731v1 | WavRx: a Disease-Agnostic, Generalizable, and Privacy-Preserving Speech Health Diagnostic Model | 2024-06-26T19:59:21 | 2024-06-26T19:59:21 | Yi Zhu, Tiago Falk | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | Speech is known to carry health-related attributes, which has emerged as a
novel venue for remote and long-term health monitoring. However, existing
models are usually tailored for a specific type of disease, and have been shown
to lack generalizability across datasets. Furthermore, concerns have been
raised recently towards the leakage of speaker identity from health embeddings.
To mitigate these limitations, we propose WavRx, a speech health diagnostics
model that captures the respiration and articulation related dynamics from a
universal speech representation. Our in-domain and cross-domain experiments on
six pathological speech datasets demonstrate WavRx as a new state-of-the-art
health diagnostic model. Furthermore, we show that the amount of speaker
identity entailed in the WavRx health embeddings is significantly reduced
without extra guidance during training. An in-depth analysis of the model was
performed, thus providing physiological interpretation of its improved
generalizability and privacy-preserving ability. | [
0.052959226071834564,
-0.7153884172439575,
0.4254315197467804,
-0.3296141028404236,
-0.178010493516922,
-0.24485749006271362,
0.062047943472862244,
-0.4780501425266266,
0.4822482764720917,
0.6061789989471436,
-0.4276278018951416,
-0.6552562713623047,
-0.5633306503295898,
-0.2996246814727783,
-0.4449678659439087,
0.755913257598877,
0.48140302300453186,
-0.20024700462818146,
-0.31459376215934753,
-0.6133925914764404,
-0.4712490141391754,
-0.6520516276359558,
-0.4709015190601349,
-0.26542115211486816,
0.3770048916339874,
-0.047093890607357025,
0.848120391368866,
0.8683697581291199,
0.16695727407932281,
0.08436655253171921,
-0.21505992114543915,
-0.2318059653043747,
-0.08532249927520752,
0.4692693054676056,
-0.2440497726202011,
-0.3150651156902313,
-0.676072359085083,
0.0013034234289079905,
0.7941514253616333,
0.8333881497383118,
-0.6973865032196045,
0.40104663372039795,
-0.22362729907035828,
0.35902324318885803,
-0.5074429512023926,
0.08889077603816986,
-0.1759432554244995,
0.1745283305644989,
-0.3255462944507599,
-0.10263042151927948,
-0.0783342495560646,
-0.20093053579330444,
0.2551007568836212,
-0.22156287729740143,
0.10702649503946304,
-0.17434664070606232,
0.5349743366241455,
0.5814574956893921,
-0.31634652614593506,
0.4674514830112457,
-0.8503175377845764,
0.3080766201019287,
-0.50455242395401,
0.8809135556221008,
0.25052210688591003,
0.4312339127063751,
0.05255953222513199,
-0.7595831751823425,
-0.29907771944999695,
-0.037209298461675644,
0.4472246468067169,
0.20343145728111267,
-0.9864203929901123,
0.23026318848133087,
-0.16182881593704224,
0.3503919839859009,
-0.8870195150375366,
0.013159424066543579,
-0.11927022784948349,
-0.7720352411270142,
0.5261160731315613,
0.1555471420288086,
0.664334237575531,
0.10861629247665405,
-0.3120192289352417,
0.06424547731876373,
-0.4081079065799713,
0.3737677037715912,
-0.14361955225467682,
0.2666650712490082,
-0.3877595365047455,
0.29765084385871887,
-0.2394237220287323,
0.6568347811698914,
-0.5505588054656982,
-0.4222481846809387,
0.34500378370285034,
0.16460150480270386,
-0.3062076270580292,
0.10382506251335144,
0.6974508166313171,
0.19931183755397797,
-0.05124098062515259,
-0.5078364014625549,
0.3459133803844452,
0.30888304114341736,
-0.0014299828326329589,
-0.7569472789764404,
-0.2813713252544403,
0.5735840797424316,
-0.7371511459350586,
-0.13978078961372375,
-0.27899911999702454,
-0.42622867226600647,
-0.37044212222099304,
-0.28711187839508057,
0.37108686566352844,
-0.3485647737979889,
-0.7395535111427307,
0.33533981442451477,
-0.283314973115921,
-0.296880304813385,
-0.12773464620113373,
-0.750145435333252,
0.489306777715683,
0.6339452266693115,
0.7079240083694458,
-0.23654206097126007,
0.08777084201574326,
-0.9500419497489929,
0.242917001247406,
-0.18475407361984253,
0.5210554599761963,
-1.0335431098937988,
-0.6215957999229431,
-0.23446021974086761,
-0.04159853234887123,
0.07966843992471695,
-0.6446490287780762,
0.2875257134437561,
-0.0621892549097538,
-0.11319569498300552,
-0.12381435930728912,
-0.4379018247127533,
-0.13095009326934814,
-0.008303781971335411,
-0.38863489031791687,
0.6593764424324036,
0.16295015811920166,
-0.664512574672699,
0.14871466159820557,
-0.42099428176879883,
-0.06406249850988388,
0.1567147970199585,
-0.42049670219421387,
-0.5970181822776794,
0.24186933040618896,
0.01878027245402336,
0.46179088950157166,
-0.1205146536231041,
0.15608695149421692,
-0.37396302819252014,
-0.02434271201491356,
0.10439244657754898,
-0.40229207277297974,
0.5893275737762451,
0.1348647028207779,
-0.09570735692977905,
0.2890213429927826,
-1.135765552520752,
0.06000495329499245,
-0.031602438539266586,
0.04715123400092125,
-0.49637463688850403,
0.046643950045108795,
-0.5293196439743042,
-0.2063412219285965,
-0.039074402302503586,
-0.9657038450241089,
0.1070634052157402,
-0.3898688554763794,
0.5776176452636719,
0.22788727283477783,
0.37816405296325684,
0.11290237307548523,
-0.4270550012588501,
0.7859326004981995,
0.0780358761548996,
0.6016747355461121,
-0.2382923811674118,
-1.1140671968460083,
0.06320586800575256,
-0.6127336621284485,
0.3261030912399292,
0.5975332260131836,
0.13970345258712769,
0.18066127598285675,
-0.495002418756485,
-0.3835376501083374,
-0.6677437424659729,
-0.2824494540691376,
0.20451760292053223,
0.554902195930481,
0.36822509765625,
-0.44351819157600403,
-0.062062762677669525,
-0.9853387475013733,
-0.3142704963684082,
0.0034920477773994207,
-0.0457119420170784,
0.3037859797477722,
-0.17023417353630066,
-0.6655840873718262,
0.796329140663147,
-0.3544314205646515,
-0.439221054315567,
0.13026006519794464,
-0.16796889901161194,
-0.14350731670856476,
0.4217400550842285,
0.46374431252479553,
-0.48668915033340454,
0.06987447291612625,
0.13860100507736206,
-0.48679429292678833,
-0.028920650482177734,
0.458672434091568,
0.021140826866030693,
-0.524452805519104,
0.33982932567596436,
-0.3696090579032898,
0.9620898962020874,
1.0452854633331299,
-0.4188585579395294,
0.36815187335014343,
-0.4581077992916107,
-0.1484495997428894,
-1.0274111032485962,
-0.01899983547627926,
-0.09393884986639023,
-0.5962553024291992,
-0.5880610942840576,
0.0337245911359787,
-0.04695172235369682,
-0.7809768915176392,
-0.2573145031929016,
0.41956067085266113,
-0.11848875880241394,
0.27946653962135315,
-0.2781279683113098,
-0.14603376388549805,
0.15458467602729797,
0.07247676700353622,
0.10811108350753784,
0.3391001224517822,
1.0635325908660889,
-0.7385056018829346,
0.31837669014930725,
0.16423630714416504,
-0.08993948251008987,
0.3869984447956085,
-0.810015857219696,
0.3117775321006775,
-0.01168947946280241,
0.20186859369277954,
-0.8013536334037781,
-0.021700730547308922,
0.195559561252594,
-0.8881000876426697,
0.2205333262681961,
-0.2790633738040924,
-0.06107504293322563,
-0.10510380566120148,
0.31533917784690857,
0.5658231377601624,
0.7555603384971619,
-0.46265631914138794,
0.6949523091316223,
0.8230221271514893,
-0.12085585296154022,
-0.42562010884284973,
-0.7673741579055786,
-0.14936868846416473,
-0.18288621306419373,
-0.5805209875106812,
0.599366307258606,
0.047951530665159225,
-0.29972559213638306,
0.14466117322444916,
-0.30932238698005676,
-0.12815995514392853,
0.07735882699489594,
0.600082516670227,
0.03572259098291397,
-0.02730390802025795,
0.43261897563934326,
0.009754507802426815,
-0.3628435432910919,
0.12136118859052658,
-0.37202030420303345,
0.06759587675333023,
0.26361823081970215,
-0.32574400305747986,
-1.189038634300232,
0.7890230417251587,
0.7529750466346741,
-0.5824419856071472,
0.55116206407547,
0.3655429780483246,
-0.6998187303543091,
-0.17829568684101105,
-0.402969628572464,
-0.06332731246948242,
-0.36998075246810913,
0.14106346666812897,
-0.07009062170982361,
-0.7328063249588013,
0.6241443157196045,
-0.19280694425106049,
-0.16653499007225037,
-0.012691366486251354,
0.3736647665500641,
0.29693281650543213,
1.2558907270431519,
0.7651729583740234,
-0.3038424253463745,
0.06784961372613907,
0.019984133541584015,
0.28349944949150085,
-0.7351852655410767,
-0.448405921459198,
-0.7384624481201172,
0.04115763679146767,
-0.4880838096141815,
-0.303933709859848,
0.5602368116378784,
-0.5761726498603821,
-0.06447988003492355,
-0.25810107588768005,
-0.9855431318283081,
0.18709540367126465,
0.22029440104961395,
0.21771802008152008,
0.04764143377542496,
-0.18256361782550812,
-0.2725537121295929,
-0.1537158489227295,
-0.4369511902332306,
-0.2724533975124359,
0.9321081042289734,
0.36094895005226135,
0.557979166507721,
0.2907363474369049,
0.720842719078064,
0.4797307252883911,
0.0007859864272177219,
-0.7332203984260559,
0.03325763717293739,
-0.15633746981620789,
-0.5041118264198303,
-0.334669828414917,
-0.4175114929676056,
-1.2891706228256226,
0.24496321380138397,
0.05644211173057556,
-1.434244155883789,
0.5549899339675903,
0.4412454068660736,
-0.8276318311691284,
0.4805690348148346,
-0.350564569234848,
0.8734736442565918,
0.002463861834257841,
-0.319534569978714,
-0.24157306551933289,
-0.6023823618888855,
0.23906370997428894,
0.40521156787872314,
0.5333296060562134,
-0.38710835576057434,
0.047810982912778854,
0.8397408127784729,
-0.3625572919845581,
0.7362645864486694,
-0.4210677444934845,
-0.07198532670736313,
0.09198019653558731,
0.15105701982975006,
0.17030170559883118,
0.24633139371871948,
-0.006119869649410248,
0.29828643798828125,
0.42938628792762756,
-0.23630677163600922,
-0.7085493803024292,
0.6997032761573792,
-0.6404989361763,
-0.6345657110214233,
-0.3942411541938782,
-0.2478853464126587,
-0.6349672079086304,
0.008407325483858585,
0.12127459794282913,
0.9335891604423523,
-0.3732481598854065,
0.18913054466247559,
0.7699227929115295,
-0.30463773012161255,
-0.024004457518458366,
0.619801938533783,
-0.28066644072532654,
-0.3793809115886688,
1.1158281564712524,
0.0017849440919235349,
0.1482517123222351,
0.257906049489975,
0.7263930439949036,
-0.2629161477088928,
-0.4167603850364685,
0.16476625204086304,
0.26820695400238037,
-0.31564801931381226,
0.01268738228827715,
-0.6303730010986328,
-0.07695876061916351,
-0.43876999616622925,
0.45555248856544495,
-0.5419555902481079,
-0.3980962336063385,
-0.238424614071846,
-0.051828306168317795,
0.3575555086135864,
0.8083975911140442,
-0.5863961577415466,
-0.177036315202713,
-0.7741004228591919,
0.6980756521224976,
0.6710280179977417,
0.33366215229034424,
0.02119475044310093,
-0.4196527898311615,
0.08358977735042572,
0.36472979187965393,
-0.261016309261322,
-0.8810145854949951,
0.6193984746932983,
0.578663170337677,
0.6316202878952026,
0.6157293915748596,
0.25871214270591736,
0.39866185188293457,
-0.5188575387001038,
0.851804792881012,
0.36939892172813416,
-1.0778566598892212,
0.8742069602012634,
-0.0013384252088144422,
0.15147337317466736,
0.1437252312898636,
0.14384713768959045,
-0.947970986366272,
-0.332771897315979,
-0.9442571401596069,
-0.7389553785324097,
0.04044723883271217,
-0.031931959092617035,
0.12604281306266785,
-0.05945052579045296,
0.5004926919937134,
0.3593832850456238,
-0.11020492017269135,
-0.02257164567708969,
-0.3536134958267212,
-0.5442489385604858,
0.039654068648815155,
0.03771497309207916,
-0.1307792216539383,
-0.4836083650588989,
-0.7904386520385742,
0.2692312002182007,
0.11357533186674118,
0.48375585675239563,
0.5077804327011108,
0.36202123761177063,
0.11099430918693542,
0.35378697514533997,
0.46445709466934204,
0.4536784589290619,
-0.2035214751958847,
0.16917626559734344,
-0.16168330609798431,
-0.6213485598564148,
0.2972567081451416,
0.005725442431867123,
0.22960126399993896,
0.29697033762931824,
0.07766124606132507,
0.74575275182724,
0.1388963907957077,
-0.5664247870445251,
0.8893082141876221,
-0.19798891246318817,
-0.21696512401103973,
-0.13366176187992096,
0.37999168038368225,
0.19198614358901978,
0.2286062389612198,
0.09440109133720398,
0.26686927676200867,
0.32342225313186646,
-0.6051611304283142,
0.15876242518424988,
0.556183934211731,
-0.7781554460525513,
-0.6570917367935181,
1.4098472595214844,
0.2158629447221756,
-0.6314594149589539,
0.5373356342315674,
0.10750941932201385,
-0.047607529908418655,
0.3527677059173584,
0.33183109760284424,
0.7272469401359558,
-0.5946812629699707,
0.17935027182102203,
-0.017409570515155792,
-0.00999542884528637,
0.2769653797149658,
0.3034752905368805,
-0.2788422405719757,
-0.5475724339485168,
-0.045138031244277954,
-0.3810611665248871,
-0.6214643716812134,
0.2914848029613495,
-1.3035236597061157,
-0.211101695895195,
-0.2619000971317291,
-0.6755629181861877,
0.34685808420181274,
-0.3402698338031769,
-0.6346480250358582,
0.37305164337158203,
0.6078616380691528,
0.8152380585670471,
-0.6673597693443298,
1.221419334411621,
0.3549259305000305,
-0.030103720724582672,
-0.6902644634246826,
0.12419217824935913,
0.19281065464019775,
-0.8985265493392944,
0.13549107313156128,
0.12394676357507706,
-0.27512964606285095,
0.05904728174209595,
-0.5058594942092896,
-1.0657967329025269,
0.9651083946228027,
0.8523794412612915,
-0.7285474538803101,
0.2035224288702011,
0.061963457614183426,
0.49244123697280884,
-0.197490394115448,
-0.23297837376594543,
0.450003981590271,
0.27313703298568726,
-0.30913588404655457,
-1.1824477910995483,
0.06194901093840599,
-0.1736464947462082,
0.11761125922203064,
-0.1343998908996582,
-0.5838951468467712,
0.5066163539886475,
-0.49772223830223083,
-0.4069664776325226,
0.10249045491218567,
0.5623388886451721,
0.07309788465499878,
0.16953207552433014,
0.2968866527080536,
0.7596014142036438,
1.4177299737930298,
-0.020501770079135895,
1.3211551904678345,
-0.4558812975883484,
0.08738449215888977,
0.723945677280426,
-0.2099827527999878,
0.8692082166671753,
-0.0807005986571312,
-0.1575223207473755,
0.39192381501197815,
0.17557182908058167,
0.4648342430591583,
0.7258626222610474,
0.3808775544166565,
-0.4934846758842468,
-0.535868227481842,
-0.3025626540184021,
-0.878004789352417,
0.6944479942321777,
0.514828085899353,
-0.3388465642929077,
0.007650400977581739,
0.30405393242836,
-0.09542164206504822,
-0.045719049870967865,
-0.04430432617664337,
0.6060287356376648,
0.09677261114120483,
-0.06179463118314743,
0.673076331615448,
-0.40394192934036255,
0.37124040722846985,
-0.8310407996177673,
-0.096435546875,
0.16836631298065186,
0.06685081869363785,
-0.11502974480390549,
-0.3478560447692871,
0.37914806604385376,
-0.4748739004135132,
-0.2633955180644989,
0.046515900641679764,
0.43448883295059204,
-0.44512420892715454,
-0.16629552841186523,
0.4370439350605011,
0.3461064398288727,
0.39118269085884094,
-0.18877141177654266,
-0.32495635747909546,
0.47831645607948303,
-0.07984314113855362,
0.13792674243450165,
0.4047100841999054,
0.23288284242153168,
0.18444480001926422,
0.8390576243400574,
0.4076884686946869,
0.3538294732570648,
-0.11179771274328232,
0.24075265228748322,
0.4922982454299927,
-0.5119019746780396,
-0.6240198612213135,
-0.5265167951583862,
0.475738525390625,
0.12886185944080353,
-0.5058304667472839,
0.2989303767681122,
0.3623078167438507,
0.08755303174257278,
0.4421067237854004,
1.1935877799987793,
0.6644886136054993,
0.8561571836471558,
-0.26266688108444214,
1.1435441970825195,
-0.753313422203064,
-0.10648344457149506,
0.10712771862745285,
-0.24606932699680328,
-0.43963804841041565,
0.35088062286376953,
0.22221696376800537,
-0.3845628499984741,
0.5306413173675537,
0.46612149477005005,
0.05662181228399277,
0.21048562228679657,
0.7124607563018799,
0.24795211851596832,
0.5533439517021179,
0.35206201672554016,
0.4521777629852295,
-0.03453955054283142,
0.31481799483299255,
-0.44593220949172974,
-0.47913095355033875,
-0.08199193328619003,
-0.7250334024429321,
-0.6280360221862793,
-0.7625934481620789,
-0.8705917596817017,
-0.21628938615322113,
0.40513354539871216,
0.5208969712257385,
1.1063152551651,
-0.6038417816162109,
0.2625110149383545,
0.18501850962638855,
-0.17367111146450043,
-0.6646475195884705,
-0.11004170775413513,
0.41040611267089844,
0.31223955750465393,
-0.22142495214939117,
0.842741847038269,
0.33707109093666077,
0.09779815375804901,
-0.14317826926708221,
0.2715587913990021,
0.6610127687454224,
0.17035847902297974,
0.2402910739183426,
0.8267649412155151,
-0.8846310377120972,
-0.3611237406730652,
-0.3714960813522339,
0.33330926299095154,
0.12625040113925934,
0.6587526202201843,
-0.9448128938674927,
0.8807669281959534,
0.11577870696783066,
0.44080159068107605,
0.12545204162597656,
0.0968550518155098,
0.6170886754989624,
-0.5980343818664551,
0.2872275114059448,
0.5605840086936951,
0.44827577471733093,
0.3568502366542816,
-0.5034399628639221,
0.029645996168255806,
0.3223046362400055,
-0.6458342671394348,
-0.8797785043716431,
0.16050562262535095,
-1.2844433784484863,
0.03324688971042633,
1.0855872631072998,
-0.002995113143697381,
-0.44136497378349304,
-0.2973475158214569,
0.019922686740756035,
0.2691706418991089,
-0.42299312353134155,
0.5078864693641663,
0.07921481132507324,
-0.46918606758117676,
0.02829526737332344,
-0.46997570991516113,
0.5495166182518005,
0.07761354744434357,
-0.3189670145511627,
0.2964814007282257,
0.11459236592054367,
0.7819287776947021,
0.007762916386127472,
0.546916663646698,
-0.1781436800956726,
0.5049471855163574,
0.03242942690849304,
0.32460471987724304,
-0.35752493143081665,
-0.09148600697517395,
-0.3293660581111908,
0.3192760646343231,
-0.14013102650642395,
-0.7881646752357483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18725v1 | Jailbreaking LLMs with Arabic Transliteration and Arabizi | 2024-06-26T19:48:48 | 2024-06-26T19:48:48 | Mansour Al Ghanim, Saleh Almohaimeed, Mengxin Zheng, Yan Solihin, Qian Lou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This study identifies the potential vulnerabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs) to 'jailbreak' attacks, specifically focusing on the Arabic language and
its various forms. While most research has concentrated on English-based prompt
manipulation, our investigation broadens the scope to investigate the Arabic
language. We initially tested the AdvBench benchmark in Standardized Arabic,
finding that even with prompt manipulation techniques like prefix injection, it
was insufficient to provoke LLMs into generating unsafe content. However, when
using Arabic transliteration and chatspeak (or arabizi), we found that unsafe
content could be produced on platforms like OpenAI GPT-4 and Anthropic Claude 3
Sonnet. Our findings suggest that using Arabic and its various forms could
expose information that might remain hidden, potentially increasing the risk of
jailbreak attacks. We hypothesize that this exposure could be due to the
model's learned connection to specific words, highlighting the need for more
comprehensive safety training across all language forms. | [
-0.20019225776195526,
-0.8020925521850586,
0.36805304884910583,
0.007589865941554308,
-0.24464893341064453,
0.16983464360237122,
-0.01598263718187809,
-0.8934479355812073,
0.15950815379619598,
0.6532227396965027,
-0.3735255300998688,
-0.5025681853294373,
-0.7769894003868103,
0.08116764575242996,
-0.5020713806152344,
0.9339674115180969,
-0.3888450562953949,
0.17326873540878296,
0.49893826246261597,
-0.14941298961639404,
-0.7340077757835388,
-0.6672968864440918,
-0.5965175032615662,
0.06771213561296463,
0.6897605061531067,
0.3833063244819641,
0.9054933786392212,
0.5716371536254883,
0.5879348516464233,
0.28695428371429443,
-0.12440237402915955,
-0.12311665713787079,
-0.30206409096717834,
0.3044920563697815,
-0.04402625188231468,
-0.5325189828872681,
-0.17661671340465546,
-0.05202900245785713,
0.19533538818359375,
0.2967996299266815,
-0.18966138362884521,
0.07165665924549103,
-0.34600454568862915,
0.6710895299911499,
-0.7122243046760559,
-0.19307860732078552,
-0.9370514154434204,
-0.179661825299263,
-0.42497098445892334,
0.052785709500312805,
-0.261532187461853,
-0.43467825651168823,
-0.2604939639568329,
0.06985417008399963,
-0.1779859960079193,
0.26068204641342163,
0.6265049576759338,
-0.0019113074522465467,
-0.3501823842525482,
-0.6047528982162476,
-0.5627412796020508,
0.5595312714576721,
-0.8234779834747314,
0.076259084045887,
0.563581109046936,
0.5140432119369507,
-0.2740805745124817,
-0.3885432183742523,
-0.34278810024261475,
-0.5947468876838684,
0.15384767949581146,
-0.3602375090122223,
-0.24108684062957764,
0.20650364458560944,
0.4175800085067749,
0.24837522208690643,
-0.5408466458320618,
0.4730825126171112,
-0.506489098072052,
-0.23325017094612122,
0.7147407531738281,
0.16238124668598175,
0.8975400328636169,
-0.18627962470054626,
-0.27530771493911743,
0.021408436819911003,
-1.3622562885284424,
-0.05350065231323242,
0.9085054397583008,
0.32829663157463074,
-0.02590896375477314,
0.6492494344711304,
0.25610291957855225,
0.5656623244285583,
-0.4739360213279724,
-0.14299613237380981,
0.07075154781341553,
-0.13829705119132996,
0.07138018310070038,
0.3993586599826813,
0.7078168988227844,
0.3693188726902008,
0.3474383056163788,
-0.39492982625961304,
-0.22832821309566498,
-0.045244090259075165,
0.3066384792327881,
-1.0236788988113403,
0.022726796567440033,
0.32761549949645996,
-0.28671151399612427,
-0.5673527717590332,
0.2505045533180237,
-0.4696609079837799,
-0.6765992045402527,
0.3728773891925812,
0.2793395519256592,
-0.7133117914199829,
0.009220116771757603,
0.0041791535913944244,
0.041001033037900925,
0.3145311176776886,
0.1878952533006668,
-0.8184487223625183,
0.1975756585597992,
0.5618420243263245,
0.9400063157081604,
-0.12407322227954865,
-0.3431302607059479,
-0.21443262696266174,
0.3006410002708435,
-0.22384294867515564,
0.5179375410079956,
-0.403450608253479,
-0.6684499979019165,
0.2762570381164551,
-0.1553051918745041,
0.12398863583803177,
-0.6807133555412292,
0.4190460443496704,
-0.9625484347343445,
-0.40650635957717896,
-0.03515731543302536,
-0.4039921164512634,
-0.2530539631843567,
0.03555209934711456,
-1.0406670570373535,
0.4892701506614685,
-0.1330772042274475,
-0.8205400109291077,
0.07908324897289276,
-0.3276166319847107,
-0.6443847417831421,
-0.12032057344913483,
0.03562500327825546,
-0.5153234601020813,
0.04097041115164757,
0.08601988852024078,
0.18071027100086212,
-0.2240358591079712,
0.28882157802581787,
-0.13473638892173767,
-0.48974114656448364,
0.6791754961013794,
-0.6192550659179688,
0.650799572467804,
0.421281099319458,
-0.4610484838485718,
0.007602005731314421,
-0.650352418422699,
-0.30648234486579895,
0.23343662917613983,
-0.2745099365711212,
-0.36119163036346436,
-0.047408293932676315,
0.2684457004070282,
0.30686742067337036,
0.24794434010982513,
-0.6846606135368347,
0.312203973531723,
-0.43729540705680847,
0.5265367031097412,
0.7080065608024597,
0.19318139553070068,
0.1372213065624237,
-0.3501308858394623,
0.6925404071807861,
0.09046534448862076,
-0.04541515186429024,
-0.30321940779685974,
-0.2178926169872284,
-0.21565128862857819,
-0.37861043214797974,
0.45175525546073914,
0.7426589131355286,
-0.6010011434555054,
0.06068147346377373,
0.10031749308109283,
-0.5603627562522888,
-0.5406714081764221,
0.28335821628570557,
0.4174802005290985,
0.056676145642995834,
0.17894667387008667,
-0.26125821471214294,
-0.6265922784805298,
-0.9159945845603943,
-0.5439278483390808,
-0.30251985788345337,
0.14746661484241486,
0.2979039251804352,
0.5091665983200073,
-0.3604131042957306,
0.46038711071014404,
-0.24580594897270203,
0.016884053125977516,
-0.5268084406852722,
0.21168266236782074,
0.22379101812839508,
0.4733942449092865,
0.7802743911743164,
-0.7137149572372437,
-0.44015148282051086,
-0.331233412027359,
-0.41953256726264954,
-0.22227410972118378,
-0.10087695717811584,
0.07797548174858093,
0.0350409671664238,
0.7142623662948608,
-0.7896336913108826,
0.741012454032898,
0.41185247898101807,
-0.4830569922924042,
0.8961705565452576,
0.11786734312772751,
0.30510008335113525,
-1.0866198539733887,
-0.10810533910989761,
-0.283726304769516,
-0.159623384475708,
-0.8113217353820801,
0.28239959478378296,
0.0724697858095169,
-0.23769569396972656,
-0.8112086653709412,
0.43680962920188904,
-0.5041638612747192,
0.08167729526758194,
-0.49096935987472534,
-0.07451049983501434,
-0.46336740255355835,
-0.10339953005313873,
-0.36083418130874634,
1.2177410125732422,
0.49777165055274963,
-0.18252460658550262,
0.5053651928901672,
0.17194347083568573,
-0.7535147666931152,
-0.32865774631500244,
-0.81430983543396,
0.208487406373024,
-0.017492087557911873,
0.051875557750463486,
-1.0305458307266235,
-0.21550598740577698,
0.27796027064323425,
-0.3068019151687622,
0.5143764615058899,
-0.07754742354154587,
-0.7314618229866028,
-0.046248048543930054,
-0.447794109582901,
0.5841633081436157,
0.4825776517391205,
-0.449555367231369,
0.14348262548446655,
0.32458940148353577,
-0.34799426794052124,
-0.7217416167259216,
-0.5168932676315308,
0.4203263819217682,
-0.5210678577423096,
-0.5894269943237305,
0.29370248317718506,
0.060865264385938644,
-0.6128161549568176,
-0.3134029507637024,
-0.053064312785863876,
0.0267350971698761,
0.5840363502502441,
0.583193302154541,
0.40625524520874023,
0.044474631547927856,
-0.30423951148986816,
-0.01614605262875557,
0.09105008095502853,
0.14566846191883087,
0.12419188767671585,
0.6230823397636414,
-0.0024911193177103996,
-0.4743516743183136,
-0.31751561164855957,
0.5447683334350586,
0.7383933067321777,
-0.3103874623775482,
1.2083752155303955,
0.08466265350580215,
-0.24874219298362732,
-0.024083971977233887,
-0.4969481825828552,
-0.15150706470012665,
-0.5184621214866638,
0.37820306420326233,
-0.3966701626777649,
-1.0599617958068848,
0.6969185471534729,
-0.2738093435764313,
-0.02802765928208828,
-0.04790371283888817,
0.5974062085151672,
0.015411398373544216,
0.9296572804450989,
0.6633844375610352,
-0.4873504936695099,
0.48305922746658325,
0.15390434861183167,
0.3311820924282074,
-0.45999619364738464,
0.05113521218299866,
-0.6435846090316772,
-0.23050422966480255,
-0.8543975949287415,
-0.233692929148674,
0.13709649443626404,
0.11548014730215073,
-0.2551460564136505,
0.5310258865356445,
0.30508485436439514,
0.5772559642791748,
0.2810559570789337,
0.12467976659536362,
0.2818235456943512,
0.04081963375210762,
-0.19543731212615967,
0.05479591712355614,
-0.31454557180404663,
-0.7246018648147583,
1.185280680656433,
0.41822928190231323,
0.9575966000556946,
0.5747503042221069,
0.8041096925735474,
0.46341994404792786,
0.337626576423645,
-0.7512060403823853,
0.5504852533340454,
0.1617811620235443,
-0.7548068761825562,
-0.10683462768793106,
-0.2736920118331909,
-1.0263463258743286,
0.1431126892566681,
0.149086132645607,
-1.1508193016052246,
-0.2540413737297058,
-0.0989781990647316,
-0.2622283697128296,
0.4518788158893585,
-0.4672772288322449,
0.5963740944862366,
-0.23090684413909912,
-0.19347265362739563,
-0.3573231101036072,
-0.8622318506240845,
0.5266767740249634,
-0.2742673456668854,
0.6233526468276978,
-0.23746022582054138,
0.12147136777639389,
0.6238126754760742,
-0.6692380905151367,
0.8399548530578613,
0.0483553409576416,
-0.2861560583114624,
0.41989681124687195,
0.5151460766792297,
0.5241560935974121,
0.15439407527446747,
-0.008536804467439651,
0.3497566878795624,
-0.1831146627664566,
-0.37668007612228394,
-0.5235196352005005,
0.725567638874054,
-1.0128973722457886,
-0.9422930479049683,
-0.5320191979408264,
-0.6764420866966248,
-0.26864126324653625,
-0.03860552981495857,
0.17990127205848694,
0.3018268346786499,
-0.2414586991071701,
-0.31121236085891724,
0.46473458409309387,
-0.41572490334510803,
0.4498734474182129,
0.7854694128036499,
-0.43393567204475403,
-0.3529932498931885,
0.5968560576438904,
-0.035248737782239914,
0.1477045714855194,
0.1583382934331894,
-0.151845782995224,
0.027678420767188072,
-0.9565564393997192,
-0.4573470950126648,
0.3757331967353821,
-0.5534811615943909,
-0.2674761116504669,
-0.1816166490316391,
-0.35179609060287476,
-0.33939969539642334,
-0.17382067441940308,
-0.17468535900115967,
-0.487857848405838,
-0.05697862058877945,
-0.4796275198459625,
0.4264912009239197,
0.7257590293884277,
-0.18291686475276947,
0.5334234237670898,
-0.9935746192932129,
0.25820040702819824,
0.14606168866157532,
0.0373697392642498,
-0.16959485411643982,
-0.792218029499054,
-0.28029119968414307,
-0.2589477300643921,
-0.21109837293624878,
-1.427201747894287,
0.3952987790107727,
-0.05193035304546356,
0.3270810842514038,
0.47937825322151184,
-0.11593452095985413,
0.4306771457195282,
-1.1393564939498901,
0.7795855402946472,
0.3084051311016083,
-0.7814378142356873,
0.7449048757553101,
-0.4326205551624298,
-0.00406840443611145,
0.6403790712356567,
0.5387071967124939,
-0.657876193523407,
-0.5816170573234558,
-0.3167622983455658,
-1.1522692441940308,
0.5308331847190857,
0.16427867114543915,
0.358396977186203,
-0.13645893335342407,
0.4536200165748596,
0.26242774724960327,
0.37909799814224243,
-0.6089238524436951,
-0.6073558330535889,
0.1420210301876068,
-0.13229495286941528,
-0.05214625969529152,
-0.6973344087600708,
-0.045746296644210815,
-0.1450003981590271,
0.615753173828125,
0.35948556661605835,
0.019480478018522263,
-0.23996014893054962,
-0.48431631922721863,
-0.05052341893315315,
0.5383360385894775,
0.48985761404037476,
0.5611976385116577,
-0.12824569642543793,
0.17521454393863678,
-0.10196836292743683,
-0.9074082374572754,
0.47736290097236633,
0.1459496021270752,
-0.29466861486434937,
-0.0935869961977005,
0.4395667016506195,
0.8224793672561646,
0.02827773615717888,
-1.1236246824264526,
0.29876965284347534,
-0.07640859484672546,
0.11580201983451843,
-0.3025664985179901,
0.11122792214155197,
-0.18420042097568512,
0.18945536017417908,
0.31136325001716614,
-0.018027979880571365,
0.16920876502990723,
-0.7692235112190247,
0.23565395176410675,
0.5041085481643677,
-0.2691473960876465,
-0.31832921504974365,
0.7005107402801514,
-0.01523144356906414,
-0.2034335434436798,
0.6267930269241333,
0.08575350046157837,
-0.5179230570793152,
0.6268908977508545,
0.735565721988678,
0.8361718058586121,
-0.6140839457511902,
0.1437489241361618,
0.2226162850856781,
0.6225407719612122,
0.1250188946723938,
0.3598896861076355,
0.20509861409664154,
-0.8935182690620422,
-0.41234543919563293,
-0.5581634044647217,
-0.419018417596817,
0.29282301664352417,
-0.5867262482643127,
0.15414398908615112,
-0.5588151812553406,
-0.11001762747764587,
-0.17909540235996246,
-0.3657470643520355,
-0.32109084725379944,
-0.03781938552856445,
0.49705010652542114,
1.1061657667160034,
-0.8797875642776489,
0.8400691747665405,
0.8821245431900024,
-0.2483152151107788,
-0.8396748900413513,
0.08412753790616989,
0.1288270801305771,
-0.835407555103302,
0.7820249795913696,
0.5139739513397217,
-0.08813788741827011,
-0.16969700157642365,
-0.8387464880943298,
-0.8868823647499084,
0.8743779063224792,
0.4125045835971832,
-0.6069621443748474,
-0.031833965331315994,
0.27944910526275635,
0.10246676206588745,
-0.1319991946220398,
0.23654675483703613,
0.8768087029457092,
0.32197457551956177,
-0.018489856272935867,
-0.8452364206314087,
0.20530736446380615,
-0.19358451664447784,
0.16057246923446655,
0.326632022857666,
-0.5171298384666443,
0.6911753416061401,
-0.4712301790714264,
-0.16321371495723724,
0.3347466289997101,
0.6562763452529907,
0.299254447221756,
-0.12388746440410614,
0.2245980203151703,
0.6553564071655273,
0.476101815700531,
0.10233446210622787,
0.9268018007278442,
-0.5144704580307007,
-0.06728383153676987,
0.8935072422027588,
-0.36836668848991394,
0.7458484172821045,
0.6998383402824402,
-0.20418094098567963,
0.7104246616363525,
0.4790586531162262,
0.11953208595514297,
0.791006326675415,
0.5402646064758301,
-0.5346471071243286,
0.11858554929494858,
-0.043237823992967606,
-0.21021035313606262,
0.5994800329208374,
0.568122148513794,
-0.3648760914802551,
-0.24141883850097656,
0.2806297242641449,
0.5703921318054199,
-0.07116523385047913,
-0.4400278329849243,
0.6335054636001587,
0.3403114378452301,
-0.383818119764328,
0.5879191160202026,
0.5367135405540466,
0.4905478358268738,
-0.6843709945678711,
0.04933994635939598,
-0.04525104910135269,
-0.23155929148197174,
0.03001514822244644,
-0.44150304794311523,
0.13337844610214233,
0.40936264395713806,
0.22678545117378235,
0.020089896395802498,
0.872524082660675,
-0.10588706284761429,
-0.20790769159793854,
0.3112705647945404,
0.4721165597438812,
0.21848085522651672,
-0.025233719497919083,
-0.5344659090042114,
0.373381108045578,
-0.06472305208444595,
-0.37580186128616333,
0.6821173429489136,
0.03396131470799446,
0.08119470626115799,
0.7101535201072693,
0.485391765832901,
0.4003857672214508,
0.15340076386928558,
0.05074707791209221,
0.9961743354797363,
-0.8901726603507996,
-0.3532063663005829,
-1.2766146659851074,
0.3038639426231384,
0.18203005194664001,
0.1005144789814949,
1.0639339685440063,
0.30380839109420776,
0.552326500415802,
-0.028384219855070114,
1.0866260528564453,
-0.04538610950112343,
0.20705370604991913,
-0.8309467434883118,
0.9092508554458618,
-0.1272374391555786,
0.5649626851081848,
-0.3347961902618408,
-0.8063511848449707,
-0.13079902529716492,
0.3389420509338379,
-0.4997907876968384,
-0.16180136799812317,
0.7237859964370728,
0.819447934627533,
0.3666892349720001,
0.013713194988667965,
0.410762220621109,
0.42900335788726807,
0.1998506486415863,
0.5051747560501099,
1.0520284175872803,
-0.4130334258079529,
0.4937319755554199,
-0.06201222911477089,
-0.16041073203086853,
-0.16195598244667053,
-0.6091909408569336,
-1.071853756904602,
-0.0985022485256195,
-0.2459474354982376,
-0.5604992508888245,
0.3785894513130188,
0.8913852572441101,
0.1646643579006195,
-0.9976336359977722,
-0.3215194642543793,
0.05259642004966736,
0.08890140801668167,
0.03182254731655121,
-0.14041629433631897,
0.20148874819278717,
-0.16627755761146545,
-0.4500278830528259,
0.6873132586479187,
0.20011182129383087,
0.32590243220329285,
-0.2374843955039978,
0.26946893334388733,
-0.029716769233345985,
0.19633568823337555,
0.33176660537719727,
0.3584403097629547,
-0.586260199546814,
-0.2841842770576477,
-0.2623622715473175,
-0.22424182295799255,
-0.00001963702197826933,
0.9134483337402344,
-0.5365965962409973,
0.11747200787067413,
0.11355580389499664,
0.673873782157898,
0.16142123937606812,
0.11326922476291656,
0.5767687559127808,
-0.6810858845710754,
0.4168320596218109,
0.09303485602140427,
0.489061564207077,
0.3243335485458374,
-0.3308677673339844,
0.10372304916381836,
0.1303170770406723,
-0.48628419637680054,
-0.7331233024597168,
0.7925638556480408,
-0.4828725755214691,
-0.509625256061554,
1.354756474494934,
-0.2749776840209961,
-0.389299213886261,
-0.21400591731071472,
-0.3768380880355835,
0.0033557231072336435,
-0.44539400935173035,
0.9080163836479187,
0.8874375224113464,
0.19262099266052246,
-0.08951225131750107,
-0.9258370995521545,
0.4887998402118683,
0.2481718361377716,
-0.5335798263549805,
-0.14420808851718903,
0.483493447303772,
0.3275468945503235,
-0.10941872000694275,
0.242915540933609,
-0.34611448645591736,
0.36961621046066284,
-0.10242508351802826,
0.0585896261036396,
-0.003346417797729373,
-0.3326026499271393,
-0.5249842405319214,
0.1590254306793213,
0.539077639579773,
0.03443197160959244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18708v1 | Learn it or Leave it: Module Composition and Pruning for Continual Learning | 2024-06-26T19:18:28 | 2024-06-26T19:18:28 | Mingyang Wang, Heike Adel, Lukas Lange, Jannik Strötgen, Hinrich Schütze | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In real-world environments, continual learning is essential for machine
learning models, as they need to acquire new knowledge incrementally without
forgetting what they have already learned. While pretrained language models
have shown impressive capabilities on various static tasks, applying them to
continual learning poses significant challenges, including avoiding
catastrophic forgetting, facilitating knowledge transfer, and maintaining
parameter efficiency. In this paper, we introduce MoCL-P, a novel lightweight
continual learning method that addresses these challenges simultaneously.
Unlike traditional approaches that continuously expand parameters for newly
arriving tasks, MoCL-P integrates task representation-guided module composition
with adaptive pruning, effectively balancing knowledge integration and
computational overhead. Our evaluation across three continual learning
benchmarks with up to 176 tasks shows that MoCL-P achieves state-of-the-art
performance and improves parameter efficiency by up to three times,
demonstrating its potential for practical applications where resource
requirements are constrained. | [
0.061774931848049164,
-0.7209957838058472,
0.5258609652519226,
0.31630897521972656,
-0.5887787938117981,
0.1997389793395996,
-0.4801395535469055,
0.03757315129041672,
-0.44377732276916504,
0.368584007024765,
-0.7561349272727966,
-0.3365112245082855,
-0.4819851219654083,
-0.32246679067611694,
0.00865645706653595,
0.7964140176773071,
-0.15278372168540955,
-0.11139264702796936,
-0.5575481057167053,
-0.2151104062795639,
-0.6822441220283508,
-0.40696269273757935,
-0.6550796627998352,
-0.32075485587120056,
0.6112270355224609,
0.7075296640396118,
0.29333609342575073,
0.7059857845306396,
0.37359049916267395,
0.17324213683605194,
0.1783435046672821,
0.36606913805007935,
-0.4837924540042877,
0.3219289779663086,
-0.2540912628173828,
-0.29385924339294434,
-0.2191494107246399,
0.026678377762436867,
0.9541757702827454,
1.0770254135131836,
-0.3607322871685028,
0.17463429272174835,
0.37465620040893555,
0.7380848526954651,
-0.9733383059501648,
0.2627416253089905,
-0.6843324303627014,
0.05073526129126549,
0.006691013462841511,
-0.1496291160583496,
-0.6718665361404419,
-0.10885126888751984,
0.22901515662670135,
-0.6303612589836121,
-0.15619046986103058,
-0.10706788301467896,
0.49536094069480896,
0.3554193377494812,
-0.3037395179271698,
-0.2280043065547943,
-0.5705003142356873,
1.230487585067749,
-0.47942376136779785,
0.3621993362903595,
0.038492072373628616,
-0.029034394770860672,
0.18921633064746857,
-0.7729367017745972,
-0.22251056134700775,
-0.6419084072113037,
0.12020906060934067,
0.27805396914482117,
0.22635433077812195,
-0.11222941428422928,
-0.0431457944214344,
0.2598872482776642,
-0.6611026525497437,
-0.25467151403427124,
-0.5981611609458923,
-0.38647952675819397,
0.2998409569263458,
0.11356893926858902,
0.3081549406051636,
0.4587540626525879,
-0.5854976177215576,
0.051149263978004456,
-0.9954570531845093,
-0.29009267687797546,
0.1847081482410431,
-0.12052427232265472,
0.1244848296046257,
0.26518794894218445,
0.07719911634922028,
0.9899886250495911,
-0.22446350753307343,
-0.44109484553337097,
0.06363746523857117,
0.054459523409605026,
-0.16229656338691711,
-0.2632962465286255,
0.5861623287200928,
0.01103335339576006,
0.03809855878353119,
-0.35372546315193176,
-0.199992373585701,
-0.009837955236434937,
0.5407822728157043,
-0.4238449037075043,
-0.7204541563987732,
-0.08413410186767578,
-0.3355488181114197,
0.013421667739748955,
0.06175948306918144,
-0.44636666774749756,
0.1283946931362152,
-0.7246402502059937,
0.5681623220443726,
-0.8392056822776794,
-0.4935096204280853,
-0.026467064395546913,
-0.1136445701122284,
-0.14777591824531555,
0.2887990176677704,
-0.5267854928970337,
0.32868966460227966,
0.7083539366722107,
1.1061877012252808,
-0.8597304224967957,
-0.45361965894699097,
-0.7752564549446106,
0.43133705854415894,
-0.35878655314445496,
0.39573410153388977,
-0.5459505319595337,
-0.4155021905899048,
-0.11539299041032791,
0.13254238665103912,
-0.3479293882846832,
-0.8979819416999817,
0.05505098029971123,
-0.22626471519470215,
0.15645432472229004,
0.14269322156906128,
-0.5124270915985107,
-0.202267587184906,
0.2546890079975128,
-0.2374936044216156,
0.9277953505516052,
0.2708017826080322,
-0.2622998356819153,
0.44866394996643066,
-0.33430683612823486,
-0.6910980343818665,
0.2758823037147522,
0.281486839056015,
-0.6549580693244934,
0.3052467107772827,
-0.2731812596321106,
0.5195464491844177,
0.10041432082653046,
0.5018623471260071,
-0.4329064190387726,
-0.22629138827323914,
0.0897955372929573,
-0.4394869804382324,
0.6068096160888672,
0.2905142307281494,
-0.38980191946029663,
0.15645571053028107,
-0.7903132438659668,
0.006841028109192848,
-0.045834362506866455,
-0.4637625217437744,
-0.21819797158241272,
0.134245827794075,
-0.25844717025756836,
0.1847611963748932,
0.5113366842269897,
-0.3848416805267334,
0.2770630419254303,
-0.24842001497745514,
0.6512808203697205,
0.7845799922943115,
0.2676749527454376,
0.5670427083969116,
-0.8075494170188904,
0.43710920214653015,
0.024887962266802788,
0.21185335516929626,
-0.2788269817829132,
-0.25503474473953247,
-0.9827764630317688,
-0.4253672957420349,
0.09039950370788574,
0.4623483717441559,
-0.8717868328094482,
0.26882991194725037,
-0.1555660516023636,
-0.6875130534172058,
-0.007611630018800497,
0.66451096534729,
0.39808204770088196,
0.46474236249923706,
0.5069136023521423,
-0.3197409510612488,
-0.48726969957351685,
-0.43971356749534607,
0.05860638990998268,
-0.26837611198425293,
-0.10075049102306366,
0.21066723763942719,
0.5210375785827637,
-0.05562170594930649,
0.7351582646369934,
-0.34413373470306396,
-0.05578071251511574,
-0.41119876503944397,
0.215983584523201,
-0.1513119339942932,
1.1225271224975586,
0.01953430287539959,
-0.7782770991325378,
-0.5008508563041687,
0.007925337180495262,
-0.5382058024406433,
-0.03705884516239166,
-0.5648545026779175,
-0.04363660886883736,
0.14225278794765472,
0.2481616735458374,
-0.4177210330963135,
-0.18262720108032227,
0.5409985780715942,
0.19514968991279602,
0.7809680104255676,
-0.4783487617969513,
-0.24164611101150513,
-0.5258182883262634,
0.2590990662574768,
-0.27258387207984924,
-0.28550007939338684,
-0.27406835556030273,
0.1715814173221588,
0.26738882064819336,
-0.3775765895843506,
-0.6634160280227661,
0.6386667490005493,
-0.4554087519645691,
0.21635566651821136,
-0.22902290523052216,
0.06374430656433105,
-0.03248162195086479,
0.6662233471870422,
0.24523405730724335,
0.8007498383522034,
0.7105116248130798,
-1.200118899345398,
0.3554288148880005,
-0.3763076364994049,
-0.16645807027816772,
0.20623447000980377,
-0.4890652596950531,
0.05183350667357445,
0.20223379135131836,
0.12098556756973267,
-0.771911084651947,
-0.14958177506923676,
0.47751209139823914,
-0.1250079721212387,
0.3840782940387726,
-0.13002607226371765,
-0.4517532289028168,
-0.1713247448205948,
-0.016425134614109993,
0.5195940136909485,
0.8148126602172852,
-0.38874730467796326,
0.6972188949584961,
0.2462894767522812,
-0.13957025110721588,
-0.12550285458564758,
-0.5038478374481201,
-0.2275547981262207,
-0.24632228910923004,
-0.33433741331100464,
0.49812573194503784,
-0.2976090610027313,
-0.028618361800909042,
0.0006081500323489308,
-0.4911448061466217,
-0.3230743110179901,
0.4119117259979248,
0.3995154798030853,
0.22034430503845215,
-0.1990295797586441,
0.4343765676021576,
-0.2285112887620926,
-0.3090594708919525,
-0.0523943156003952,
-1.000229001045227,
0.5518414378166199,
0.030128689482808113,
-0.42585667967796326,
-0.6367599368095398,
0.17330330610275269,
0.6901928186416626,
-0.18515083193778992,
0.7797127962112427,
0.5891286134719849,
-0.05391845479607582,
-0.5103040933609009,
-0.5152945518493652,
-0.029138019308447838,
-0.4645126760005951,
0.1862662136554718,
-0.2218220978975296,
-0.9535035490989685,
0.09295304864645004,
-0.5161421298980713,
0.24091649055480957,
0.383588582277298,
0.4462010860443115,
-0.4350132942199707,
0.7652909755706787,
0.9598398208618164,
-0.07503008097410202,
0.7157102823257446,
-0.13152636587619781,
-0.012772529385983944,
-0.5577803254127502,
-0.39741945266723633,
-0.13944080471992493,
-0.1868317723274231,
0.002770577324554324,
-0.4375990331172943,
0.24796521663665771,
0.09322839975357056,
-0.3769323527812958,
0.35871976613998413,
-0.5852974057197571,
0.2959688603878021,
0.4548400938510895,
0.39504414796829224,
0.03485891968011856,
-0.1337883025407791,
-0.09037242829799652,
-0.1127285361289978,
-1.0488735437393188,
-0.18066319823265076,
0.920905590057373,
0.01901371031999588,
0.4009767770767212,
-0.06832802295684814,
0.6725237369537354,
0.49794915318489075,
0.5099924802780151,
-0.6082131266593933,
0.7284824848175049,
-0.03133688494563103,
-0.1058310717344284,
0.08375890552997589,
-0.8044300079345703,
-0.6101573705673218,
0.02373644895851612,
0.2696364223957062,
-0.5621751546859741,
-0.20906822383403778,
0.6210447549819946,
-0.10551542043685913,
0.36929255723953247,
-0.6269751191139221,
1.0462223291397095,
-0.45797526836395264,
-0.648098886013031,
-0.4878772795200348,
-0.4559052288532257,
0.4142136573791504,
0.033140555024147034,
-0.019243676215410233,
-0.026480339467525482,
-0.4823867976665497,
0.7233423590660095,
-0.38264837861061096,
0.9199564456939697,
-0.27616235613822937,
0.14664076268672943,
0.5382816791534424,
0.20078971982002258,
0.4738750159740448,
0.07929546386003494,
-0.020482316613197327,
-0.2594941258430481,
0.05335735157132149,
-0.7491500973701477,
-0.4867191016674042,
0.5141628980636597,
-0.4504983723163605,
-0.5429838299751282,
-0.45012950897216797,
-0.6308507323265076,
-0.33201369643211365,
0.0850888043642044,
-0.011168114840984344,
0.5598844289779663,
0.16410508751869202,
0.6015707850456238,
1.0695257186889648,
-0.16005487740039825,
0.30139821767807007,
0.3971928656101227,
0.12061086297035217,
-0.4348514676094055,
1.5568722486495972,
0.12902617454528809,
0.5628064870834351,
0.5391126871109009,
0.30458372831344604,
0.05918233096599579,
-0.615631639957428,
-0.1590903401374817,
0.24210985004901886,
-0.5714228749275208,
-0.046429917216300964,
-0.6200049519538879,
-0.08751863241195679,
-0.04848355054855347,
-0.43979164958000183,
-0.2587161660194397,
-0.30062031745910645,
-0.366983026266098,
0.16634522378444672,
-0.202894926071167,
0.29194965958595276,
0.01895587332546711,
0.40381085872650146,
-1.0478423833847046,
-0.03257458284497261,
0.39631226658821106,
0.0026514672208577394,
-0.07015867531299591,
-0.6229608058929443,
-0.1714923083782196,
-0.17673780024051666,
-0.37985676527023315,
-0.6139655709266663,
0.3042789399623871,
0.5403659343719482,
0.7221342325210571,
0.3598621189594269,
0.1483396589756012,
0.7301087975502014,
-0.26084986329078674,
0.9625905752182007,
0.42266833782196045,
-0.9666372537612915,
0.5939860343933105,
-0.24652521312236786,
0.7614051699638367,
0.5636559128761292,
0.4561087489128113,
-0.41416051983833313,
-0.38767296075820923,
-0.7824260592460632,
-0.896126925945282,
0.27240896224975586,
-0.25226089358329773,
0.06779621541500092,
0.018484285101294518,
0.3769034445285797,
0.22432170808315277,
0.4122595489025116,
-0.8540522456169128,
0.09827426820993423,
-0.0639689490199089,
-0.34453514218330383,
0.0922318547964096,
-0.35099679231643677,
-0.0028844811022281647,
-0.25429224967956543,
1.130069375038147,
-0.11427641659975052,
0.05571810528635979,
-0.20755572617053986,
-0.7464003562927246,
0.39746490120887756,
0.02062326669692993,
0.7540746927261353,
1.1343480348587036,
-0.025814585387706757,
0.2644951045513153,
0.34006306529045105,
-0.5016002058982849,
0.20731034874916077,
-0.6573522090911865,
-0.08165104687213898,
-0.05324411019682884,
0.5054412484169006,
0.3016897141933441,
0.5879038572311401,
-1.2144930362701416,
0.2284104824066162,
0.4754950702190399,
-0.34392502903938293,
-0.3075719177722931,
0.5131869316101074,
-0.03201335296034813,
-0.24378708004951477,
0.36765795946121216,
0.4313819706439972,
-0.338958203792572,
-0.7252093553543091,
0.6178181767463684,
0.06369757652282715,
-0.5796612501144409,
-0.16003140807151794,
0.31494489312171936,
0.18635281920433044,
-0.025262577459216118,
0.6572115421295166,
-0.38176286220550537,
-0.647980809211731,
0.6255333423614502,
0.5005888342857361,
0.5518409013748169,
-0.03729485347867012,
0.2521204352378845,
0.44463083148002625,
0.308718204498291,
-0.379756361246109,
-0.0005432629841379821,
-0.7111234664916992,
-0.2779574394226074,
-0.5460476279258728,
-0.5917214751243591,
-0.5381946563720703,
-0.08711780607700348,
-0.4386804699897766,
-0.16183649003505707,
-0.8704553246498108,
0.31166163086891174,
-0.7322208881378174,
0.12861154973506927,
-0.23305019736289978,
0.32816973328590393,
-0.13295264542102814,
0.7580780386924744,
-0.770926296710968,
1.1380727291107178,
0.7291941046714783,
-0.23402011394500732,
-0.6113711595535278,
-0.057712621986866,
0.22425848245620728,
-0.376809298992157,
0.6653463244438171,
0.3944529592990875,
-0.05268891900777817,
0.0006779255345463753,
-0.5146307349205017,
-0.6384283900260925,
1.1573750972747803,
0.3270713984966278,
-0.5223714709281921,
0.264107346534729,
-0.35226577520370483,
0.03500396013259888,
-0.3784998059272766,
-0.38061055541038513,
0.32537055015563965,
0.4272546172142029,
0.26724773645401,
-0.4282110333442688,
-0.17063948512077332,
-0.1739082783460617,
-0.23735196888446808,
0.19862422347068787,
-0.6403164863586426,
0.8235780596733093,
0.1444125473499298,
-0.36417117714881897,
0.13687342405319214,
0.8403519988059998,
0.39959055185317993,
0.3662313222885132,
0.6349015831947327,
0.46260330080986023,
0.8903602361679077,
-0.26373720169067383,
0.6418678164482117,
-0.45346799492836,
0.2642296254634857,
1.134753704071045,
-0.309611976146698,
0.7808012962341309,
0.44589146971702576,
-0.11438767611980438,
0.4255661070346832,
0.5635448694229126,
-0.07393766194581985,
0.6866945028305054,
0.10194160044193268,
-0.7186917066574097,
-0.7012147903442383,
0.05355596914887428,
-0.03309602662920952,
-0.11231037974357605,
0.4834025204181671,
0.08337972313165665,
0.07331190258264542,
0.4613081216812134,
-0.0595245398581028,
0.12179594486951828,
-0.38895636796951294,
0.6972495317459106,
0.1301591992378235,
-0.9941762685775757,
0.2647388279438019,
-0.1663229912519455,
0.6310337781906128,
-1.0531567335128784,
-0.0049269781447947025,
-0.01760716736316681,
0.47899970412254333,
0.03069537878036499,
-0.2129872888326645,
0.5949797630310059,
-0.3394157588481903,
-0.24561506509780884,
-0.6931500434875488,
0.7348259091377258,
-0.46568354964256287,
-0.3896007239818573,
0.02547629363834858,
0.25751471519470215,
-0.10679852962493896,
-0.03854985535144806,
-0.7649756669998169,
0.22840000689029694,
0.10700695216655731,
0.15671074390411377,
0.6678668260574341,
0.3591267168521881,
0.3220793902873993,
1.2542028427124023,
0.7825839519500732,
0.2493126541376114,
0.17371360957622528,
-0.49457213282585144,
0.8150967955589294,
-0.2893659174442291,
-0.3443540930747986,
-0.8298994898796082,
0.6930152773857117,
-0.07478248327970505,
-0.2863914966583252,
0.5932195782661438,
0.40695831179618835,
0.9278687834739685,
-0.20108623802661896,
0.6814855933189392,
-0.20501306653022766,
0.07090166956186295,
-0.8424527049064636,
0.4132837653160095,
-0.7131901383399963,
0.3354721963405609,
0.23371131718158722,
-0.852804958820343,
-0.3031618595123291,
0.6781601905822754,
-0.36040833592414856,
-0.06776456534862518,
0.9529944062232971,
0.509986162185669,
-0.2823641300201416,
-0.4395945966243744,
0.46200376749038696,
-0.15138880908489227,
0.10933203995227814,
0.7451066374778748,
0.7006691098213196,
0.11713439971208572,
0.6828280687332153,
-0.45590561628341675,
-0.03242301940917969,
-0.15445898473262787,
-0.9159854054450989,
-0.5520217418670654,
-0.736458420753479,
-0.8119713664054871,
-0.04897421970963478,
0.3048401176929474,
0.806405246257782,
1.004917860031128,
-0.6762901544570923,
-0.19645416736602783,
-0.434858113527298,
0.2620677649974823,
-0.8440094590187073,
-0.22318647801876068,
0.12090887874364853,
-1.0403709411621094,
-0.3517076373100281,
0.5576369762420654,
0.6416946053504944,
-0.47076138854026794,
-0.35194435715675354,
-0.29557931423187256,
-0.26279935240745544,
-0.3330303132534027,
0.34759634733200073,
0.5311594605445862,
-0.5291039347648621,
-0.12800812721252441,
-0.32407793402671814,
-0.02006581798195839,
-0.17042578756809235,
1.14510977268219,
-0.8160902261734009,
0.4369927644729614,
0.3474598526954651,
1.1002236604690552,
0.4523395001888275,
-0.12376262992620468,
0.7837009429931641,
-0.9364041686058044,
0.3589823544025421,
0.5259101986885071,
0.3648518919944763,
0.24472582340240479,
0.031350575387477875,
0.3452356159687042,
0.8233006000518799,
-0.6237937211990356,
-0.7252694964408875,
0.24814511835575104,
-1.052211880683899,
-0.5300504565238953,
0.9053112864494324,
-0.6713643670082092,
-0.37107762694358826,
-0.24338191747665405,
-0.023383457213640213,
0.021824277937412262,
-0.030496003106236458,
0.5526108145713806,
0.5786224007606506,
0.23714913427829742,
-0.6081772446632385,
-0.7430434823036194,
0.2442077249288559,
0.7024329304695129,
-0.5867020487785339,
-0.019790036603808403,
0.5107937455177307,
0.44839906692504883,
0.06160695105791092,
0.4740719795227051,
0.23933573067188263,
0.5462092161178589,
0.03918680548667908,
-0.22664527595043182,
-0.3115072548389435,
-0.8315820097923279,
0.0165257565677166,
0.7291995286941528,
-0.033932849764823914,
-0.23840536177158356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18702v1 | Simulating The U.S. Senate: An LLM-Driven Agent Approach to Modeling Legislative Behavior and Bipartisanship | 2024-06-26T19:10:51 | 2024-06-26T19:10:51 | Zachary R. Baker, Zarif L. Azher | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | This study introduces a novel approach to simulating legislative processes
using LLM-driven virtual agents, focusing on the U.S. Senate Intelligence
Committee. We developed agents representing individual senators and placed them
in simulated committee discussions. The agents demonstrated the ability to
engage in realistic debate, provide thoughtful reflections, and find bipartisan
solutions under certain conditions. Notably, the simulation also showed promise
in modeling shifts towards bipartisanship in response to external
perturbations. Our results indicate that this LLM-driven approach could become
a valuable tool for understanding and potentially improving legislative
processes, supporting a broader pattern of findings highlighting how LLM-based
agents can usefully model real-world phenomena. Future works will focus on
enhancing agent complexity, expanding the simulation scope, and exploring
applications in policy testing and negotiation. | [
-0.4447234869003296,
-1.1842024326324463,
0.7091400027275085,
0.05184514448046684,
-0.2702910304069519,
0.22748400270938873,
0.15755140781402588,
-0.14103072881698608,
0.6173149943351746,
0.966559648513794,
-0.872373104095459,
-0.17155517637729645,
-0.13523928821086884,
-0.029989037662744522,
-0.04557175189256668,
0.6568589806556702,
0.45141151547431946,
0.41688817739486694,
-0.5653902888298035,
0.3260189890861511,
-0.2647857367992401,
-0.7133907079696655,
-0.1829540729522705,
-0.8258887529373169,
0.5318233370780945,
0.36731240153312683,
0.5784657597541809,
0.6556292772293091,
0.6193664073944092,
0.3998655080795288,
-0.03267728537321091,
-0.0690307691693306,
-0.5695838332176208,
0.0744544118642807,
-0.3225002884864807,
-0.6552004814147949,
-0.6947205066680908,
0.390484482049942,
0.799306333065033,
0.838739275932312,
-0.3751167356967926,
-0.2981607913970947,
-0.1816960871219635,
0.4676746129989624,
-0.1134488508105278,
0.7664250731468201,
-0.6606745719909668,
-0.297839879989624,
-0.06869624555110931,
-0.19216737151145935,
-0.4326491951942444,
-0.3128267824649811,
0.18210652470588684,
-0.3608580529689789,
-0.19085660576820374,
0.21789348125457764,
0.5499867796897888,
0.16384902596473694,
-0.8406411409378052,
-0.0448550246655941,
-0.864579975605011,
0.18628375232219696,
-0.7441142201423645,
0.018487151712179184,
0.014552630484104156,
0.37727347016334534,
-0.5649663209915161,
-1.0093430280685425,
-0.7526046633720398,
-0.6431367993354797,
0.08757974952459335,
0.23755034804344177,
-0.00678405212238431,
0.4006854295730591,
0.30132776498794556,
0.08150829374790192,
-0.42859548330307007,
-0.14552654325962067,
-0.287166565656662,
-0.23439307510852814,
0.6345309615135193,
0.7574490904808044,
-0.04135269671678543,
0.2107815444469452,
-0.5175482630729675,
-0.2529699206352234,
-0.4729066789150238,
0.42571189999580383,
0.6914147138595581,
0.6590379476547241,
-0.032008156180381775,
0.668570876121521,
-0.46536508202552795,
0.42647454142570496,
-0.26094669103622437,
0.19310301542282104,
0.0164775513112545,
-0.3669217526912689,
-0.16972170770168304,
0.050435300916433334,
0.28058353066444397,
0.22430174052715302,
0.12650436162948608,
0.001211931579746306,
-0.3236406445503235,
0.25609931349754333,
0.3028128147125244,
-0.8985199332237244,
-0.0654173195362091,
0.2787408232688904,
-0.5082399845123291,
-0.47330278158187866,
0.3034413754940033,
-0.7210784554481506,
-0.4635671377182007,
-0.7508137822151184,
0.35671842098236084,
-0.1345231980085373,
-0.1868579387664795,
-0.24264734983444214,
-0.32974791526794434,
0.29683881998062134,
0.4548593759536743,
-0.45235705375671387,
0.5568973422050476,
1.009409785270691,
0.4060269892215729,
-0.1462656408548355,
-0.4955316483974457,
-0.6419966220855713,
0.2482316792011261,
-0.4379591941833496,
1.0130220651626587,
-0.8060670495033264,
-0.6543536186218262,
0.03216094523668289,
0.10178428888320923,
0.08755874633789062,
-0.8767575621604919,
-0.161085307598114,
-0.7604424953460693,
-0.4017486274242401,
-0.5241775512695312,
-0.608055591583252,
-0.17878052592277527,
0.688879132270813,
-0.8600071668624878,
0.05779282748699188,
0.2539558708667755,
-0.1787453293800354,
0.2128238081932068,
-0.7766751646995544,
-0.11736532300710678,
-0.00447771605104208,
-0.2804931104183197,
-0.26345691084861755,
-0.09301050007343292,
-0.46672123670578003,
0.14814038574695587,
-0.22279800474643707,
0.28540605306625366,
-0.5430383086204529,
-0.5991830229759216,
0.497640460729599,
-0.1642492562532425,
1.1021945476531982,
0.056571897119283676,
-0.17812266945838928,
0.7603257894515991,
-0.4743501842021942,
-0.13131456077098846,
-0.032677195966243744,
-0.13106657564640045,
-0.018319368362426758,
-0.040439192205667496,
-0.3074924349784851,
-0.06828062236309052,
0.04560915753245354,
-0.5283686518669128,
0.49176883697509766,
-0.48946404457092285,
0.2189551740884781,
0.9676639437675476,
0.4607101380825043,
0.7561064958572388,
-0.6163681149482727,
0.39166131615638733,
0.3026634156703949,
0.1436208337545395,
-0.12753073871135712,
-0.5794997811317444,
-0.607761561870575,
-0.20172567665576935,
0.48421305418014526,
0.8356764316558838,
-0.6999587416648865,
-0.14546015858650208,
-0.1804027408361435,
-0.3428559899330139,
-0.1342753767967224,
-0.36430177092552185,
0.035529009997844696,
0.12290428578853607,
0.05667522922158241,
-0.3859364092350006,
-0.01920377090573311,
-0.8430116176605225,
-0.27151498198509216,
-0.623329222202301,
0.37256842851638794,
0.08102621883153915,
0.864949107170105,
-0.41963258385658264,
0.8759303092956543,
-0.11508646607398987,
-0.050811417400836945,
-0.04186399653553963,
0.44146230816841125,
-0.228738471865654,
0.42718175053596497,
0.2723788022994995,
-0.5661454796791077,
-0.12882111966609955,
0.03636924922466278,
-0.6063364744186401,
-0.010078450664877892,
-0.12938691675662994,
-0.18599849939346313,
0.26549291610717773,
0.390634149312973,
-0.7846612334251404,
0.8928942680358887,
0.028388842940330505,
-0.5605241656303406,
0.6645216345787048,
-0.13168217241764069,
0.12978526949882507,
-0.7216581106185913,
-0.2074970304965973,
-0.4466274082660675,
-0.1840832680463791,
-0.7215480208396912,
0.1321658045053482,
-0.17067141830921173,
-0.21347548067569733,
-0.5011662840843201,
0.6222553849220276,
-0.5372179746627808,
-0.13803508877754211,
-0.5459149479866028,
-0.1330185979604721,
-0.193526029586792,
0.566382884979248,
-0.19089721143245697,
0.747642457485199,
0.26340189576148987,
-0.5379419922828674,
0.859458327293396,
-0.1823503077030182,
-0.12785761058330536,
0.6306602954864502,
-0.47596630454063416,
0.2611945867538452,
-0.31028348207473755,
0.31439051032066345,
-0.8565356135368347,
-0.35526254773139954,
0.5506476759910583,
-0.0006089080707170069,
0.48754632472991943,
0.030501794070005417,
-0.5485699772834778,
-0.17570701241493225,
-0.06000756844878197,
-0.0014864756958559155,
0.453786164522171,
0.019177308306097984,
1.037677526473999,
0.6764335036277771,
-0.37092679738998413,
-0.21877522766590118,
-0.6280014514923096,
0.13890357315540314,
-0.048562563955783844,
-0.5604705214500427,
0.6233770847320557,
0.006317506544291973,
-1.1245124340057373,
0.26648464798927307,
0.40923359990119934,
0.10877218842506409,
-0.06853596121072769,
0.3871220052242279,
0.32687073945999146,
-0.21140432357788086,
-0.22186054289340973,
0.05949956178665161,
-0.04286673665046692,
0.415243536233902,
0.11209363490343094,
0.389019638299942,
-0.4259602427482605,
-0.5404050946235657,
-0.7859528064727783,
0.6468570828437805,
0.5573136806488037,
-0.08807463943958282,
0.49524080753326416,
-0.13785184919834137,
-0.13259927928447723,
-0.45844700932502747,
-0.4680068790912628,
-0.7888103127479553,
-0.5073533058166504,
0.2338511347770691,
-0.33191290497779846,
-0.6235612630844116,
0.809051513671875,
-0.6574702858924866,
0.43723806738853455,
-0.27085965871810913,
0.7602707147598267,
-0.11179156601428986,
0.8195033073425293,
0.6501169800758362,
0.1120310053229332,
0.32067716121673584,
-0.23320715129375458,
-0.06951677799224854,
-0.2741060256958008,
-0.5545526742935181,
-0.4532109200954437,
-0.3618217706680298,
-0.5624420642852783,
-0.8463121056556702,
0.08657810091972351,
-0.4959782361984253,
-0.22365809977054596,
-0.038962580263614655,
-0.19225966930389404,
0.18502306938171387,
0.7615836262702942,
-0.05640115961432457,
0.011648501269519329,
0.13745982944965363,
-0.1824106127023697,
0.1976611167192459,
-0.3136116564273834,
-0.6608673930168152,
0.6513116359710693,
0.07295385748147964,
0.607267439365387,
0.18616153299808502,
0.6067962646484375,
0.48496395349502563,
0.6059136986732483,
-0.6162190437316895,
1.066781997680664,
0.45741960406303406,
-0.717460572719574,
-0.6233541369438171,
-0.5674303770065308,
-0.9686800837516785,
0.40238678455352783,
-0.075798898935318,
-0.38547319173812866,
0.09922289103269577,
0.06584914773702621,
-0.11051367968320847,
0.20116418600082397,
-0.38476377725601196,
0.8414116501808167,
-0.09260986745357513,
-0.2819192111492157,
-0.5577923059463501,
-0.8649519085884094,
0.20381267368793488,
0.4394892752170563,
0.012864307500422001,
-0.49603521823883057,
-0.22792689502239227,
0.10631346702575684,
-0.6108721494674683,
0.9284214377403259,
-0.5513466000556946,
0.235539510846138,
0.793639063835144,
0.29508745670318604,
0.7423985600471497,
0.016913190484046936,
-0.3129369020462036,
-0.058624256402254105,
0.014652746729552746,
-0.42547887563705444,
-0.7625964879989624,
0.4673416316509247,
-0.7111114263534546,
-1.2010915279388428,
-0.602165937423706,
-0.9547106027603149,
-0.1428026258945465,
-0.024626711383461952,
-0.42121779918670654,
0.2822158634662628,
-0.6639187932014465,
0.05093811824917793,
0.22604376077651978,
0.3486849069595337,
0.4782167673110962,
0.6069744229316711,
-0.3374083638191223,
-0.4722500145435333,
0.9274886846542358,
0.5114039778709412,
-0.034646276384592056,
0.09594925493001938,
0.035169728100299835,
-0.2514585852622986,
-0.2599157392978668,
-0.36470118165016174,
0.25068727135658264,
-0.4487161636352539,
0.047305990010499954,
-0.24751563370227814,
-0.19302357733249664,
-0.5034428834915161,
0.10004988312721252,
-0.04828084260225296,
-0.5600519776344299,
-0.27491554617881775,
-0.14143197238445282,
0.08480286598205566,
0.7912719249725342,
0.10007482767105103,
0.3470675051212311,
-0.22508326172828674,
-0.14687305688858032,
0.7617218494415283,
0.04436347633600235,
-0.33013084530830383,
-0.3567315936088562,
0.15790602564811707,
0.09563786536455154,
-0.5776751041412354,
-1.2041476964950562,
0.2141941487789154,
-0.13033427298069,
0.9930660128593445,
0.4568529427051544,
0.24347223341464996,
0.5747173428535461,
-0.2974258363246918,
0.939827561378479,
-0.24202369153499603,
-0.6610902547836304,
0.32838958501815796,
-0.4554859697818756,
-0.0017300460021942854,
0.3812926411628723,
-0.10901226848363876,
0.3597697615623474,
-0.4837666451931,
-0.5317240357398987,
-0.41275742650032043,
0.570296585559845,
0.29948994517326355,
0.5983995199203491,
0.3549591898918152,
0.3922310173511505,
-0.055666327476501465,
0.40392404794692993,
-0.2591050863265991,
-0.2543625235557556,
-0.04100828617811203,
0.2007717490196228,
0.15677392482757568,
-0.3020551800727844,
-0.4264247417449951,
0.11274097114801407,
0.6624364256858826,
-0.06382758170366287,
0.32687893509864807,
0.1660161167383194,
0.32707110047340393,
-0.10662122070789337,
0.012596835382282734,
0.9307651519775391,
0.5742654800415039,
-0.08806604146957397,
0.18525293469429016,
0.12125546485185623,
-0.09097249060869217,
0.3756806552410126,
0.27144375443458557,
-0.14995428919792175,
-0.0043070814572274685,
0.11657077074050903,
0.686636745929718,
-0.17977556586265564,
-0.7160518169403076,
0.49785834550857544,
-0.013322139158844948,
-0.5247400999069214,
-0.3223409056663513,
0.019796129316091537,
0.4290749430656433,
0.881929874420166,
0.14985771477222443,
-0.043623991310596466,
0.2844530940055847,
-1.1336520910263062,
0.4558839201927185,
0.7260336875915527,
-0.480060338973999,
-0.2667267620563507,
0.7149319648742676,
0.363518089056015,
-0.9929190874099731,
0.7664227485656738,
-0.4012819826602936,
-0.29357853531837463,
1.31715989112854,
0.572131335735321,
0.5305696129798889,
-0.2182125598192215,
0.23964157700538635,
-0.1757507175207138,
0.4053628444671631,
0.2619784474372864,
0.4516916871070862,
-0.01193557120859623,
-0.47351282835006714,
-0.010033889673650265,
-0.031730055809020996,
-1.088242769241333,
-0.18693384528160095,
-0.44481778144836426,
0.2679464817047119,
-0.5512038469314575,
-0.8433176875114441,
-0.10215715318918228,
0.3154813349246979,
-0.280872642993927,
-0.3031765818595886,
0.2606474459171295,
0.9498752951622009,
-0.6051923036575317,
0.7943395972251892,
0.9758883118629456,
-0.17044466733932495,
-0.6039026379585266,
0.06811739504337311,
0.309072881937027,
-0.42774704098701477,
0.3849155008792877,
0.08193215727806091,
-0.1458563357591629,
-0.13059577345848083,
-0.6761229038238525,
-0.357525110244751,
1.191872000694275,
0.74556565284729,
-0.30539393424987793,
-0.032297346740961075,
0.39514926075935364,
0.40951666235923767,
-0.5640421509742737,
0.13000178337097168,
0.43044424057006836,
0.6390978693962097,
-0.054488591849803925,
-0.5270839929580688,
-0.013528741896152496,
-0.4055977761745453,
0.09915163367986679,
-0.22836783528327942,
-1.2559068202972412,
1.1266225576400757,
-0.28927579522132874,
0.11240485310554504,
0.04969547688961029,
1.2103853225708008,
0.7893456220626831,
0.8606292009353638,
0.5727803707122803,
0.21728721261024475,
0.6498633027076721,
0.15610371530056,
0.761461079120636,
-0.4143525958061218,
-0.11093772202730179,
0.7246569395065308,
-0.9521307349205017,
0.4738030433654785,
0.7940188050270081,
0.15112753212451935,
0.7914430499076843,
0.3638629615306854,
0.10875187814235687,
0.484470397233963,
0.6239420771598816,
-0.5102291107177734,
-0.27977409958839417,
-0.3789799213409424,
-0.11373705416917801,
0.3505002558231354,
0.30429667234420776,
0.049600984901189804,
0.034512557089328766,
-0.03465493768453598,
-0.29037296772003174,
0.16440609097480774,
-0.28131023049354553,
0.7867085337638855,
0.38590678572654724,
-0.7819309830665588,
-0.27379488945007324,
-0.08349417895078659,
-0.1956050843000412,
-0.4379422068595886,
-0.7262784242630005,
-0.0805259644985199,
-0.02894618920981884,
0.36351701617240906,
-0.833670437335968,
0.2710290253162384,
-0.22317634522914886,
-0.05990690737962723,
-0.4630395174026489,
0.7017911076545715,
-0.31926846504211426,
-0.24093681573867798,
0.4411228597164154,
0.6454747915267944,
0.35345765948295593,
0.13934177160263062,
-0.7735887765884399,
0.21041490137577057,
-0.20380368828773499,
-0.8604241013526917,
0.39265984296798706,
0.7537796497344971,
-0.17367205023765564,
0.7510694861412048,
0.7049580216407776,
0.11637181043624878,
-0.13171134889125824,
0.16404594480991364,
1.1490459442138672,
-0.47963714599609375,
-0.6854211091995239,
-0.7537950873374939,
0.5573479533195496,
-0.3021874725818634,
0.0878034383058548,
0.26489076018333435,
0.514409065246582,
0.6063567996025085,
-0.25158223509788513,
0.5623036026954651,
0.20018142461776733,
0.3379160761833191,
-0.3256671726703644,
0.6955848336219788,
-0.3640568256378174,
0.2928873300552368,
0.14439979195594788,
-0.7463152408599854,
-0.046266108751297,
0.49090054631233215,
-0.12315140664577484,
-0.011276905424892902,
0.34588080644607544,
1.270573377609253,
0.1308208405971527,
0.13464002311229706,
0.5289351940155029,
0.18655702471733093,
0.13866735994815826,
0.06798797845840454,
1.2218042612075806,
0.12415988743305206,
0.767551600933075,
-0.5637027025222778,
-0.014014137908816338,
-0.3170417547225952,
-0.4415837228298187,
-1.150994896888733,
-0.47625914216041565,
-0.22152619063854218,
-0.3637961149215698,
0.1264699101448059,
1.0374085903167725,
0.7031769156455994,
-0.5785976648330688,
-0.5729605555534363,
-0.037841420620679855,
0.22117610275745392,
-0.14546866714954376,
-0.24876461923122406,
-0.18395130336284637,
-0.16508518159389496,
-0.8022319078445435,
0.36920177936553955,
0.3323715031147003,
0.042229726910591125,
-0.3728954792022705,
-0.08162122219800949,
0.08977952599525452,
0.711906909942627,
0.28744906187057495,
0.16263604164123535,
-0.980274498462677,
-0.23836718499660492,
0.14993003010749817,
-0.4656190872192383,
-0.214193657040596,
0.9129936695098877,
-0.8171946406364441,
0.4419355094432831,
0.67093825340271,
0.46022406220436096,
0.4463798701763153,
0.5011891722679138,
0.6004213094711304,
-0.03556317836046219,
0.3787490129470825,
0.5318679809570312,
0.00672137038782239,
-0.3297196924686432,
-0.3396089971065521,
0.5262292623519897,
0.4911239743232727,
-0.7292003035545349,
-1.133805513381958,
0.3137414753437042,
-1.1624257564544678,
-0.29552212357521057,
0.7689195871353149,
-0.26251327991485596,
-0.4879024922847748,
-0.16307006776332855,
-0.33330756425857544,
0.35590678453445435,
-0.5193583965301514,
0.6254870891571045,
0.5077447891235352,
-0.41158679127693176,
-0.20357823371887207,
-0.5473431348800659,
-0.032778430730104446,
0.10922767221927643,
-1.0141311883926392,
0.09525122493505478,
0.4248761534690857,
0.07055945694446564,
-0.12851229310035706,
0.9522721767425537,
0.12487433850765228,
0.3087101876735687,
0.5378426313400269,
-0.009216085076332092,
-0.35228314995765686,
-0.5144842863082886,
-0.20095917582511902,
0.3420116603374481,
-0.26707667112350464,
0.14972202479839325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18696v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18696v1 | Sequence Graph Network for Online Debate Analysis | 2024-06-26T18:58:23 | 2024-06-26T18:58:23 | Quan Mai, Susan Gauch, Douglas Adams, Miaoqing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online debates involve a dynamic exchange of ideas over time, where
participants need to actively consider their opponents' arguments, respond with
counterarguments, reinforce their own points, and introduce more compelling
arguments as the discussion unfolds. Modeling such a complex process is not a
simple task, as it necessitates the incorporation of both sequential
characteristics and the capability to capture interactions effectively. To
address this challenge, we employ a sequence-graph approach. Building the
conversation as a graph allows us to effectively model interactions between
participants through directed edges. Simultaneously, the propagation of
information along these edges in a sequential manner enables us to capture a
more comprehensive representation of context. We also introduce a Sequence
Graph Attention layer to illustrate the proposed information update scheme. The
experimental results show that sequence graph networks achieve superior results
to existing methods in online debates. | [
-0.8953732848167419,
-1.2708971500396729,
0.5722914934158325,
0.24358515441417694,
-0.3324558436870575,
0.16234374046325684,
0.07106631249189377,
-0.47177791595458984,
0.7173905372619629,
0.2481282353401184,
-0.4325311481952667,
-0.03420667350292206,
-0.48473790287971497,
0.020714910700917244,
-0.5534473061561584,
0.7772451639175415,
0.18648761510849,
-0.09854516386985779,
0.1239202544093132,
-0.22689242660999298,
-0.3143196105957031,
-0.4246894121170044,
-1.0764864683151245,
-0.3314744234085083,
0.8619836568832397,
0.23081077635288239,
0.5177969336509705,
0.5477526187896729,
0.38854438066482544,
0.4945633113384247,
-0.4012352228164673,
0.059657033532857895,
-0.8198457956314087,
0.41202327609062195,
-0.23982904851436615,
-0.006052577402442694,
-0.6857463121414185,
-0.25145652890205383,
0.740217387676239,
0.9110011458396912,
-0.031973760575056076,
-0.05792807415127754,
0.018462516367435455,
0.6342126131057739,
-0.28768208622932434,
0.047170449048280716,
-0.5683598518371582,
0.5292254686355591,
-0.29695117473602295,
-0.5319715738296509,
-0.382036417722702,
-0.6719530820846558,
0.4281088709831238,
-0.6503760814666748,
-0.03977501019835472,
-0.04308628663420677,
0.8071956634521484,
-0.19732965528964996,
-0.5546030402183533,
-0.20416750013828278,
-0.7155030965805054,
-0.285514235496521,
-0.8013904690742493,
-0.04807170853018761,
-0.005048850551247597,
0.30414247512817383,
-0.31510475277900696,
-1.2623831033706665,
-0.4272930324077606,
0.292825311422348,
-0.028592495247721672,
0.34748196601867676,
-0.23494820296764374,
0.2648560404777527,
0.3997325003147125,
0.23291069269180298,
-0.12392682582139969,
-0.10227465629577637,
-0.33893707394599915,
0.11520534008741379,
0.7584361433982849,
0.2578308880329132,
-0.0030254097655415535,
-0.2877171039581299,
-0.2653321921825409,
0.17336493730545044,
-0.3272317945957184,
0.11702442169189453,
0.6822519898414612,
0.20033740997314453,
0.1967853158712387,
0.48669642210006714,
-0.47517290711402893,
0.9969373345375061,
0.5522688031196594,
0.45264875888824463,
0.0050356523133814335,
-0.4103759527206421,
-0.24510473012924194,
0.3336958587169647,
0.9019712209701538,
0.47996655106544495,
-0.011973711661994457,
0.18750573694705963,
0.3637314736843109,
-0.2939370274543762,
0.2757515609264374,
-0.9141502380371094,
-0.36853256821632385,
0.3278176784515381,
-0.5797495245933533,
-0.249935582280159,
0.14276809990406036,
-1.1573517322540283,
-0.48895880579948425,
-0.1277347207069397,
0.26877424120903015,
0.12167253345251083,
-0.3241437077522278,
-0.04623013362288475,
-0.46863508224487305,
0.07758273929357529,
0.5683616995811462,
-0.30070868134498596,
0.6143794059753418,
0.6338518857955933,
0.9992613196372986,
0.005369676277041435,
0.3704169988632202,
-0.6103916764259338,
-0.06486533582210541,
-0.30271100997924805,
1.0525974035263062,
-0.6248741745948792,
-0.3086091876029968,
0.0007892620051279664,
0.016428403556346893,
-0.07423549890518188,
-0.14065498113632202,
0.3259093463420868,
-0.9014728665351868,
0.40981581807136536,
-0.2867104411125183,
-1.182425856590271,
-0.06381061673164368,
0.4951067268848419,
-1.0639954805374146,
0.5813745856285095,
-0.42983579635620117,
-1.2141432762145996,
-0.07509888708591461,
-1.0994255542755127,
-0.47856056690216064,
0.2822806239128113,
-0.1462295651435852,
-0.4364921450614929,
-0.3687286078929901,
-0.02383597381412983,
0.29262635111808777,
0.27069851756095886,
0.2608283460140228,
-0.5430665612220764,
-0.25300511717796326,
0.5382193922996521,
0.040006671100854874,
0.660831868648529,
0.2777087986469269,
-0.5050027370452881,
0.5077040195465088,
-0.6938832998275757,
0.03895578533411026,
0.1593288779258728,
-0.12310446053743362,
-0.13164712488651276,
0.44990426301956177,
-0.3829931914806366,
0.06405496597290039,
-0.24997736513614655,
-0.5527831315994263,
0.24124941229820251,
-0.6294546127319336,
0.930175244808197,
0.7159141302108765,
0.4941592216491699,
0.17330171167850494,
-0.30716991424560547,
0.33218881487846375,
-0.14391107857227325,
-0.0027118392754346132,
-0.4103105366230011,
-1.0902568101882935,
-0.8045469522476196,
0.37384527921676636,
0.4172619879245758,
0.6558070778846741,
-0.5697159171104431,
0.09205341339111328,
-0.40648725628852844,
-0.09045422077178955,
-0.23556838929653168,
-0.2690473198890686,
0.2037518173456192,
0.40953728556632996,
0.09130573272705078,
-0.6935807466506958,
-0.5641941428184509,
-0.4704049229621887,
-0.3954160511493683,
-0.1171131432056427,
0.12714193761348724,
0.6092031002044678,
0.10824786871671677,
0.15031899511814117,
1.2644411325454712,
-0.6414834856987,
0.17339548468589783,
-0.3962487280368805,
0.703119695186615,
-0.07426753640174866,
0.1319735199213028,
0.1695132702589035,
-0.913936972618103,
-0.5474176406860352,
-0.02000332437455654,
-0.5958079695701599,
-0.010448429733514786,
-0.2880537211894989,
-0.27899888157844543,
-0.14414659142494202,
0.5113324522972107,
-0.2915985584259033,
0.6029384136199951,
0.05806492269039154,
-0.36813151836395264,
-0.21182838082313538,
0.1829819232225418,
0.35153934359550476,
-1.2198837995529175,
0.12509268522262573,
0.06238401308655739,
-0.5017334222793579,
-0.926930844783783,
-0.07908424735069275,
-0.39909955859184265,
-0.3809159994125366,
-0.4112582504749298,
0.5465039610862732,
-0.17887896299362183,
-0.186387836933136,
-0.2422294020652771,
0.6790847182273865,
0.18428336083889008,
0.49865540862083435,
0.20383524894714355,
0.17709645628929138,
-0.06766954064369202,
-0.4160066545009613,
0.6712533831596375,
0.4379749298095703,
-0.46770909428596497,
0.5635009407997131,
-0.8597732186317444,
0.6687412858009338,
-0.2145913541316986,
0.6674352288246155,
-1.3272767066955566,
-0.3860507905483246,
0.6090373396873474,
-0.4757864773273468,
0.1882106214761734,
-0.3284248113632202,
0.06695976853370667,
-0.4801718592643738,
-0.2970533072948456,
0.49566853046417236,
-0.11044501513242722,
0.006687099114060402,
0.4399365484714508,
0.611429750919342,
-0.4841768443584442,
-0.42281514406204224,
-0.35318952798843384,
0.40588054060935974,
-0.25087276101112366,
-0.8134191632270813,
0.4733853340148926,
-0.052220139652490616,
-0.5559306740760803,
0.26782599091529846,
0.38536959886550903,
-0.15435394644737244,
0.014165470376610756,
0.22340649366378784,
-0.2031751275062561,
-0.31474390625953674,
0.060771167278289795,
-0.27304407954216003,
0.07279343158006668,
0.06599967926740646,
-0.31814900040626526,
0.39407309889793396,
0.17864000797271729,
-0.21309199929237366,
-0.6115933656692505,
0.7931488156318665,
0.17789000272750854,
-0.032285358756780624,
0.4756087064743042,
0.1663321554660797,
-0.459591269493103,
-0.04959004744887352,
-0.5342718362808228,
-0.15665994584560394,
-0.4655945599079132,
0.3998488187789917,
-0.306465744972229,
-0.9392885565757751,
0.7820489406585693,
-0.5221313834190369,
0.13510622084140778,
0.38569796085357666,
0.4364120662212372,
-0.28713804483413696,
0.9010347723960876,
0.21591626107692719,
0.2755494713783264,
0.6815237402915955,
-0.08475292474031448,
0.2986009120941162,
-0.7145497798919678,
-0.23595818877220154,
-0.27344220876693726,
-0.6339959502220154,
-0.1838916689157486,
-0.2719125747680664,
0.16283667087554932,
0.11946926265954971,
-0.3599734306335449,
0.21315917372703552,
-0.3879638612270355,
0.4164726436138153,
0.28537678718566895,
0.2765507996082306,
0.12140806019306183,
-0.1007349044084549,
-0.024246342480182648,
-0.02511282078921795,
-0.8242825865745544,
-0.11887967586517334,
0.6947130560874939,
0.2397688776254654,
0.40477505326271057,
0.09240782260894775,
0.26741257309913635,
0.5494231581687927,
0.3714764714241028,
-0.7691897749900818,
0.6018453240394592,
0.5170254111289978,
-0.5725094676017761,
-0.49680206179618835,
-0.6575084328651428,
-1.231749415397644,
0.20114022493362427,
-0.18353427946567535,
-0.8563145995140076,
0.08235348016023636,
0.28253957629203796,
-0.5861233472824097,
0.6631181240081787,
-0.30150145292282104,
1.2074016332626343,
-0.015180385671555996,
-0.39379212260246277,
-0.18558846414089203,
-1.0875086784362793,
0.19906210899353027,
0.2768772542476654,
0.23708631098270416,
0.20398689806461334,
0.5422461032867432,
0.9169612526893616,
-0.5352504253387451,
1.0121155977249146,
-0.006704999599605799,
0.1978864073753357,
0.8325307965278625,
-0.12515036761760712,
0.6556568741798401,
-0.08215063810348511,
0.2403268665075302,
-0.21201306581497192,
-0.46027782559394836,
-0.06673943996429443,
-0.5848761796951294,
0.47011616826057434,
-0.687409520149231,
-0.8301918506622314,
-0.22910861670970917,
-0.02412877231836319,
0.05070730298757553,
0.04500843957066536,
0.18471890687942505,
0.836216151714325,
-0.5990890264511108,
-0.02290283516049385,
0.5446760654449463,
-0.03778747096657753,
0.4839768409729004,
0.02911236695945263,
0.00045739757479168475,
-0.5863239169120789,
0.672566831111908,
0.37688836455345154,
0.4341942071914673,
0.34666311740875244,
0.4470590651035309,
-0.34100648760795593,
-0.23156370222568512,
-0.4490145444869995,
-0.18889455497264862,
-1.1065205335617065,
-0.22903351485729218,
-0.9526283144950867,
-0.40605518221855164,
-0.3216029405593872,
0.058061763644218445,
-0.12613019347190857,
-0.8900398015975952,
-0.08326561748981476,
-0.23778028786182404,
0.47276875376701355,
1.047810435295105,
0.0955200269818306,
0.39321720600128174,
-0.6990593075752258,
0.1164577305316925,
0.650424063205719,
0.3759584128856659,
0.2996295988559723,
-0.4277998208999634,
0.1342853158712387,
-0.08117110282182693,
-0.8875078558921814,
-1.510543942451477,
0.04834559187293053,
0.2885327637195587,
0.4322802424430847,
0.7134829163551331,
0.09181053936481476,
0.980973482131958,
-0.6808347105979919,
0.6967125535011292,
-0.06378975510597229,
-1.0488413572311401,
0.8368435502052307,
-0.2615515887737274,
0.008948027156293392,
0.11780638992786407,
0.3701268136501312,
-0.7271451354026794,
-0.3514569103717804,
-0.8451768755912781,
-0.8804876804351807,
0.6004860997200012,
0.2416536808013916,
-0.13426682353019714,
-0.17982102930545807,
0.4126482307910919,
-0.40602418780326843,
0.21581530570983887,
-0.5977658629417419,
-0.16357886791229248,
-0.5786656737327576,
0.11487879604101181,
0.6680934429168701,
-0.11080283671617508,
-0.507509171962738,
-0.18404650688171387,
0.14900918304920197,
-0.15828916430473328,
0.3075624704360962,
0.3785237967967987,
0.27932852506637573,
-0.16646379232406616,
0.23279519379138947,
0.6754915714263916,
0.7704691290855408,
-0.030213719233870506,
0.14603154361248016,
0.2754920721054077,
-0.021796129643917084,
0.008896047249436378,
0.0468202605843544,
-0.06294681876897812,
0.06283938884735107,
0.23355256021022797,
1.091293454170227,
0.4544660747051239,
-0.1343017965555191,
0.5321065187454224,
-0.27605077624320984,
-0.15404924750328064,
-0.07864363491535187,
-0.20655883848667145,
0.4886148273944855,
0.43088972568511963,
0.23111285269260406,
0.07360904663801193,
0.4566980302333832,
-0.7056009769439697,
0.5085610151290894,
0.18999186158180237,
-0.4935007095336914,
-0.2175361067056656,
0.7366810441017151,
0.6909709572792053,
-0.7935152649879456,
0.4689525365829468,
-0.21720696985721588,
-0.8300723433494568,
1.0376672744750977,
0.41212281584739685,
0.6164636015892029,
-0.07472178339958191,
0.3260989189147949,
0.5765054225921631,
-0.2999131381511688,
0.042182136327028275,
0.17376646399497986,
-0.003423605812713504,
-0.5192411541938782,
-0.3620898127555847,
-0.07815119624137878,
-0.8029838800430298,
-0.09176277369260788,
-0.5177168846130371,
-0.02180267497897148,
-0.6260071992874146,
-0.6775693297386169,
0.3284093737602234,
-0.0238315649330616,
-0.32486552000045776,
-0.10436808317899704,
0.19491876661777496,
0.572513222694397,
-0.4732348322868347,
0.46525946259498596,
0.3648022413253784,
-0.08523886650800705,
-0.35908764600753784,
-0.3031868636608124,
0.18405327200889587,
-0.23444919288158417,
0.6047136783599854,
0.2727958858013153,
-0.14922918379306793,
0.0804525762796402,
-0.48398029804229736,
-0.7168675065040588,
0.9024091362953186,
0.12929421663284302,
-0.6796255707740784,
0.15804104506969452,
-0.13639959692955017,
0.227545365691185,
-0.5063123106956482,
0.5025418400764465,
-0.05769362300634384,
0.38671866059303284,
0.5999599099159241,
-0.6008867025375366,
0.10618960112333298,
-0.44016343355178833,
-0.06371413916349411,
0.273645281791687,
-0.718029260635376,
0.930838942527771,
-0.29839658737182617,
-0.8364463448524475,
-0.15734097361564636,
0.8400576114654541,
-0.2890424132347107,
0.38432958722114563,
0.5008456110954285,
0.4861272871494293,
0.8710609078407288,
-0.1668940931558609,
0.7940768599510193,
-0.3757515251636505,
0.3532712161540985,
1.2724127769470215,
-0.4509699046611786,
0.94122713804245,
0.026042433455586433,
-0.0394413135945797,
0.6084741950035095,
0.9222068190574646,
0.29135555028915405,
0.17292667925357819,
0.5886393189430237,
-0.13124412298202515,
-0.33584287762641907,
-0.0662713348865509,
-0.4608181118965149,
-0.15207915008068085,
0.476693719625473,
-0.10986208915710449,
-0.09778334945440292,
-0.1931300312280655,
0.14404508471488953,
0.01201618555933237,
-0.304210364818573,
1.0917301177978516,
0.01726916991174221,
-0.7928922176361084,
-0.09122968465089798,
-0.05284702405333519,
0.017464203760027885,
-0.4884030520915985,
-0.27278295159339905,
-0.19611574709415436,
0.07858774065971375,
-0.20200642943382263,
-0.9874423742294312,
0.2415335774421692,
-0.18323014676570892,
0.35031214356422424,
0.09223458915948868,
0.6831375956535339,
-0.3281792104244232,
-0.27340760827064514,
0.3674057126045227,
0.3489735722541809,
0.1285545974969864,
0.2934301495552063,
-0.682769238948822,
0.20420455932617188,
-0.3747360110282898,
-0.4416128396987915,
0.12956438958644867,
0.5630564093589783,
-0.06636669486761093,
0.4463691711425781,
0.4440457224845886,
-0.040306441485881805,
0.27136921882629395,
0.21518729627132416,
1.0844712257385254,
-0.6767637133598328,
-0.7718700170516968,
-0.8828891515731812,
0.5212869048118591,
-0.9379091858863831,
-0.4250650107860565,
0.5945716500282288,
0.4098939597606659,
0.6836501955986023,
0.5032479763031006,
0.5856941342353821,
0.0526718832552433,
0.2857624292373657,
-0.2636815905570984,
0.47609785199165344,
-0.16433016955852509,
-0.10735564678907394,
-0.243190199136734,
-0.6341812610626221,
-0.2487693727016449,
0.8990244269371033,
0.10257730633020401,
-0.24416908621788025,
0.7349687814712524,
0.17605632543563843,
-0.10665058344602585,
0.6621121764183044,
-0.2049362063407898,
0.38630521297454834,
0.3965661823749542,
0.6679384708404541,
0.9654416441917419,
-0.4069310128688812,
0.3910121023654938,
0.19143834710121155,
-0.24476580321788788,
-0.2931491732597351,
-1.065854549407959,
-1.0875481367111206,
-0.3700546324253082,
-0.6448653340339661,
-0.5168064832687378,
0.020238585770130157,
1.0436533689498901,
0.6243142485618591,
-0.7752996683120728,
-0.3966248333454132,
-0.04540513455867767,
0.24758334457874298,
-0.11419835686683655,
-0.20459523797035217,
0.3214268386363983,
-0.16273781657218933,
-0.4579414129257202,
0.28750312328338623,
0.22423838078975677,
-0.08130772411823273,
-0.21102136373519897,
0.09795665740966797,
-0.5133115649223328,
0.5301283001899719,
0.5903958678245544,
0.6459543704986572,
-0.5737685561180115,
-0.5424711108207703,
-0.14765414595603943,
0.013608339242637157,
0.6210631132125854,
1.2909226417541504,
-0.698143720626831,
0.9158680438995361,
0.8335172533988953,
1.0077102184295654,
0.826958417892456,
0.4509023427963257,
0.6464332938194275,
-0.5090898871421814,
0.0689655989408493,
0.13234801590442657,
0.2969331443309784,
0.3579480051994324,
-0.1684371829032898,
0.4710156321525574,
0.48599398136138916,
-0.5375190377235413,
-0.6111627221107483,
0.2266702651977539,
-1.0199329853057861,
-0.25855696201324463,
0.8332033753395081,
-0.4873638451099396,
0.08367197215557098,
-0.3735000789165497,
-0.28021085262298584,
0.3776174485683441,
-0.33692196011543274,
0.7139734029769897,
0.9053974747657776,
-0.33715149760246277,
-0.09465949237346649,
-0.4118063747882843,
0.5522967576980591,
-0.062055811285972595,
-0.9609354138374329,
-0.09240052849054337,
0.2463276982307434,
-0.09507106989622116,
0.29578498005867004,
1.0964585542678833,
0.2708721458911896,
-0.1580129861831665,
-0.05337858200073242,
-0.7389741539955139,
0.24179896712303162,
-0.48532235622406006,
-0.060413990169763565,
0.6869861483573914,
-0.2979515790939331,
-0.09757911413908005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18695v1 | Learning to Correct for QA Reasoning with Black-box LLMs | 2024-06-26T18:57:32 | 2024-06-26T18:57:32 | Jaehyung Kim, Dongyoung Kim, Yiming Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | An open challenge in recent machine learning is about how to improve the
reasoning capability of large language models (LLMs) in a black-box setting,
i.e., without access to detailed information such as output token
probabilities. Existing approaches either rely on accessibility (which is often
unrealistic) or involve significantly increased train- and inference-time
costs. This paper addresses those limitations or shortcomings by proposing a
novel approach, namely CoBB (Correct for improving QA reasoning of Black-Box
LLMs). It uses a trained adaptation model to perform a seq2seq mapping from the
often-imperfect reasonings of the original black-box LLM to the correct or
improved reasonings. Specifically, the adaptation model is initialized with a
relatively small open-source LLM and adapted over a collection of sub-sampled
training pairs. To select the representative pairs of correct and incorrect
reasonings, we formulated the dataset construction as an optimization problem
that minimizes the statistical divergence between the sampled subset and the
entire collection, and solved it via a genetic algorithm. We then train the
adaptation model over the sampled pairs by contrasting the likelihoods of
correct and incorrect reasonings. Our experimental results demonstrate that
CoBB significantly improves reasoning accuracy across various QA benchmarks,
compared to the best-performing adaptation baselines. | [
0.04965328797698021,
-0.7253389954566956,
0.9810971617698669,
-0.10741032660007477,
-0.16903215646743774,
0.525213897228241,
-0.23344023525714874,
-0.31451964378356934,
-0.09243059903383255,
0.19913318753242493,
-0.5156044363975525,
-0.3881641626358032,
-0.3884086012840271,
0.05182143300771713,
-0.043417949229478836,
0.7035520076751709,
-0.18174459040164948,
0.1548057347536087,
-0.37638378143310547,
-0.25442731380462646,
-0.5303733944892883,
-0.42130446434020996,
-0.7578884363174438,
-0.14568045735359192,
0.34826400876045227,
0.3934031128883362,
0.5134388208389282,
0.5640676021575928,
0.282042533159256,
0.2167026698589325,
-0.2387421578168869,
0.5849055647850037,
-0.6597020030021667,
0.041680894792079926,
-0.501457691192627,
-0.711110532283783,
-0.3519124984741211,
-0.30378347635269165,
0.44049155712127686,
0.39428675174713135,
-0.07216913998126984,
0.29303836822509766,
0.09329704195261002,
0.6445973515510559,
-0.6464424729347229,
0.08293001353740692,
-0.8671404719352722,
0.13514024019241333,
-0.024488253518939018,
-0.7388611435890198,
-0.6668350696563721,
-0.5193533301353455,
-0.17148357629776,
-0.7263112664222717,
0.2268093228340149,
0.17338129878044128,
0.7055333256721497,
0.44089141488075256,
-0.3921961784362793,
-0.01778666488826275,
-0.8915512561798096,
0.6989166140556335,
-0.7913272380828857,
0.4346660077571869,
0.2518085539340973,
0.3446550965309143,
-0.4208076298236847,
-0.45469585061073303,
-0.505500316619873,
0.022925270721316338,
0.2742432653903961,
0.1841561496257782,
-0.2740514576435089,
-0.028449304401874542,
0.40959417819976807,
0.11812800914049149,
-0.3667418956756592,
0.10393083840608597,
-0.41013023257255554,
-0.2775665819644928,
0.7110152840614319,
0.11862343549728394,
0.09526987373828888,
0.12762533128261566,
-0.1229042261838913,
-0.05820710211992264,
-0.683895468711853,
0.2434331327676773,
0.1382649689912796,
0.33644697070121765,
0.011210287921130657,
0.4995277225971222,
-0.18686749041080475,
0.5133103132247925,
0.4041258990764618,
-0.08648964017629623,
0.33255061507225037,
-0.2564864456653595,
-0.104133240878582,
-0.17405056953430176,
0.34702765941619873,
0.1468561738729477,
0.3143426179885864,
-0.4057043492794037,
-0.020578572526574135,
0.05429289862513542,
0.551608681678772,
-0.3450453281402588,
-0.21449334919452667,
0.7119191288948059,
-0.20651742815971375,
-0.14109455049037933,
-0.15134930610656738,
-0.7215403914451599,
-0.5012826323509216,
-0.18924832344055176,
0.5756906270980835,
-0.23028548061847687,
0.04166648909449577,
0.12360373884439468,
-0.04096665233373642,
0.29958996176719666,
0.37428563833236694,
-0.4540674388408661,
-0.008708612062036991,
0.4679945707321167,
0.6446372270584106,
0.011474810540676117,
-0.1251802146434784,
-0.9391389489173889,
0.24568063020706177,
-0.631051242351532,
0.8905301094055176,
-0.36455756425857544,
-0.15114954113960266,
-0.08011652529239655,
0.1013164073228836,
0.014807485975325108,
-0.5738975405693054,
0.4390275478363037,
-0.45550844073295593,
0.04779616370797157,
-0.14719615876674652,
-0.40382784605026245,
-0.25117188692092896,
0.24806414544582367,
-0.23582200706005096,
0.8929209113121033,
0.4207099974155426,
-0.4766790270805359,
0.33701959252357483,
-0.4755731523036957,
-0.4752018451690674,
0.22738024592399597,
-0.010387169197201729,
-0.6706311106681824,
0.19849570095539093,
0.3163767457008362,
0.23648442327976227,
-0.03839782997965813,
0.19360186159610748,
-0.5566447377204895,
-0.4522029757499695,
0.3821744918823242,
0.06079820170998573,
0.791318953037262,
0.12339121848344803,
-0.4157659709453583,
0.3183760941028595,
-0.8099813461303711,
0.4111713469028473,
0.2050805538892746,
-0.44411689043045044,
-0.1175810694694519,
0.3112221956253052,
-0.630506157875061,
0.16841843724250793,
-0.12808877229690552,
-0.43516799807548523,
0.09850340336561203,
-0.29905372858047485,
0.5280588269233704,
1.0308088064193726,
-0.008326473645865917,
0.5518335103988647,
-0.5507868528366089,
0.6581563353538513,
0.1288948655128479,
0.23258012533187866,
0.24718067049980164,
-0.40580061078071594,
-0.8765270709991455,
-0.12215621024370193,
0.5070405006408691,
0.8924967050552368,
-0.8300691246986389,
0.4376116991043091,
-0.06152692809700966,
-0.24230264127254486,
-0.7692248225212097,
0.1594628542661667,
0.2577213943004608,
0.4504397213459015,
0.3874719738960266,
-0.27926141023635864,
-0.38738808035850525,
-0.49976375699043274,
-0.1254492551088333,
-0.29847854375839233,
0.09567379206418991,
0.6108442544937134,
0.37198406457901,
-0.2748359143733978,
0.6378664970397949,
-0.4179401397705078,
-0.1532248705625534,
-0.09019981324672699,
-0.2538969814777374,
0.049513839185237885,
0.3538154661655426,
0.243190199136734,
-0.31423038244247437,
-0.015479742549359798,
0.09058251976966858,
-0.734133780002594,
-0.12928593158721924,
-0.2511938512325287,
-0.5216010212898254,
0.28702884912490845,
0.34683021903038025,
-0.3645573854446411,
0.40061038732528687,
0.4834405183792114,
-0.4245705008506775,
0.8131592273712158,
-0.23874132335186005,
0.17490385472774506,
-1.0252130031585693,
-0.22612755000591278,
0.08341696858406067,
-0.4964017868041992,
-0.3731003701686859,
0.3937142789363861,
0.2496604323387146,
-0.027131732553243637,
-0.19151774048805237,
0.613442599773407,
-0.4985908269882202,
-0.12065402418375015,
-0.14122110605239868,
0.14648771286010742,
0.17166708409786224,
0.6820163130760193,
-0.212663471698761,
1.0873072147369385,
0.33552175760269165,
-0.602766215801239,
0.40050381422042847,
0.5334044694900513,
-0.15206481516361237,
0.5907385349273682,
-0.3740184009075165,
0.41810286045074463,
-0.09849619120359421,
0.33434176445007324,
-0.6421900987625122,
0.08745063096284866,
0.45763444900512695,
-0.4958929121494293,
0.08468169718980789,
-0.39577534794807434,
-0.324524849653244,
-0.4435521960258484,
-0.13755403459072113,
0.4442282021045685,
0.8230774402618408,
-0.6618177890777588,
0.6575769186019897,
0.2644340395927429,
-0.15540939569473267,
-0.3647371828556061,
-0.6808469295501709,
-0.09299968183040619,
-0.00017836585175246,
-0.5450552701950073,
0.08442292362451553,
-0.10965704917907715,
-0.1324448436498642,
0.0422448106110096,
-0.4258356988430023,
-0.18803097307682037,
0.2938039302825928,
-0.030344614759087563,
0.014842167496681213,
-0.3746660351753235,
0.33143502473831177,
0.08833841234445572,
0.006063645239919424,
0.0625026598572731,
-0.540916919708252,
0.27172762155532837,
-0.05007912218570709,
-0.3352356553077698,
-0.24672433733940125,
0.03272043168544769,
0.1331024169921875,
-0.3951738476753235,
0.5079064965248108,
0.27403172850608826,
-0.267046183347702,
-0.8648548126220703,
-0.383361279964447,
-0.27879175543785095,
-0.39794042706489563,
0.3855074346065521,
-0.36494362354278564,
-0.7918863892555237,
0.4696927070617676,
-0.18388591706752777,
-0.05554363131523132,
0.06628361344337463,
0.43400952219963074,
-0.46140411496162415,
0.890101432800293,
0.42956307530403137,
0.3438015878200531,
0.1997532844543457,
-0.36175408959388733,
0.5039454102516174,
-1.0483815670013428,
-0.4362722337245941,
-0.6103765964508057,
-0.2231013923883438,
-0.4087623059749603,
-0.8647094964981079,
0.2895223796367645,
0.15765590965747833,
-0.2357269674539566,
0.012072855606675148,
-0.3987376391887665,
0.43187808990478516,
0.7665699124336243,
0.6437267065048218,
0.34484535455703735,
-0.047612082213163376,
-0.18980158865451813,
0.3049302101135254,
-0.9472612142562866,
-0.42459580302238464,
1.2199275493621826,
0.3223617374897003,
0.4782446622848511,
0.12616707384586334,
0.6769827604293823,
0.32618027925491333,
0.013616761192679405,
-0.7584356665611267,
0.4576139748096466,
-0.08713755756616592,
-0.37817877531051636,
-0.2924157381057739,
-0.8002674579620361,
-0.990584671497345,
0.046723559498786926,
-0.4277018904685974,
-0.693299412727356,
0.383597195148468,
0.42713719606399536,
-0.41258418560028076,
0.4690943956375122,
-0.6770297884941101,
0.866069495677948,
-0.4745435118675232,
-0.47924911975860596,
-0.21401631832122803,
-0.42301860451698303,
0.3209981918334961,
-0.25801900029182434,
0.35882264375686646,
-0.09248632937669754,
0.2967478930950165,
0.4332405924797058,
-0.43665629625320435,
0.5036818981170654,
-0.14403201639652252,
0.05621737614274025,
0.1570950299501419,
0.44823285937309265,
0.8346118330955505,
-0.08341693878173828,
0.07821221649646759,
0.00022995304607320577,
0.032967980951070786,
-0.9133960604667664,
-0.7229267954826355,
0.16562454402446747,
-0.755654513835907,
-0.7667077779769897,
-0.5178677439689636,
-0.8715131282806396,
-0.808501124382019,
-0.035976700484752655,
-0.17229074239730835,
0.46529248356819153,
0.1975254863500595,
-0.048850107938051224,
0.7097334861755371,
-0.40572211146354675,
-0.049193013459444046,
0.3897938132286072,
-0.07520878314971924,
-0.2689012289047241,
0.9512260556221008,
-0.10995300859212875,
0.3895975947380066,
0.16354696452617645,
0.23549015820026398,
-0.4215977191925049,
-1.1805450916290283,
-0.5808278918266296,
0.351205974817276,
-0.6783504486083984,
-0.26679787039756775,
-0.42461422085762024,
-0.26840224862098694,
-0.2219778597354889,
-0.11296656727790833,
0.15389148890972137,
-0.4050360321998596,
-0.3426009714603424,
-0.14047706127166748,
0.29571425914764404,
0.36038899421691895,
0.07849948853254318,
0.20745651423931122,
-0.7226034998893738,
0.3700494170188904,
0.3539074957370758,
0.49103063344955444,
-0.05680745095014572,
-0.8895532488822937,
-0.07729018479585648,
0.2461267113685608,
-0.4513183832168579,
-0.8237760066986084,
0.04919655993580818,
0.06593745946884155,
0.7681415677070618,
-0.06991995126008987,
0.1411924809217453,
0.7696424722671509,
-0.3850064277648926,
0.470657080411911,
-0.04649382829666138,
-0.8831390738487244,
0.5844883918762207,
-0.3108464181423187,
0.1694060117006302,
0.470459520816803,
0.004041891545057297,
-0.20913758873939514,
-0.6038750410079956,
-0.7970698475837708,
-0.5714239478111267,
0.5104856491088867,
0.12396327406167984,
-0.07955292612314224,
0.11294025182723999,
0.4167878031730652,
0.019867846742272377,
0.05185350403189659,
-0.67083340883255,
0.05617306008934975,
-0.009576705284416676,
-0.5725088119506836,
-0.070479616522789,
-0.23987466096878052,
-0.23018157482147217,
-0.2424454241991043,
1.138303279876709,
-0.5658154487609863,
0.2772827744483948,
0.18890886008739471,
-0.4225270748138428,
-0.20363974571228027,
0.44193536043167114,
0.3476097881793976,
1.0145193338394165,
-0.19823861122131348,
-0.04040069133043289,
0.4095883071422577,
-0.05923984572291374,
0.42639926075935364,
0.048590049147605896,
-0.4330897629261017,
-0.2659572958946228,
0.11373516917228699,
0.6874961256980896,
-0.015133129432797432,
-0.7551363706588745,
0.5076524615287781,
0.13850988447666168,
-0.27227717638015747,
0.015350425615906715,
0.06280655413866043,
0.12524919211864471,
0.7752203345298767,
0.20280197262763977,
0.15518485009670258,
-0.04801757261157036,
-0.6298062801361084,
0.20150722563266754,
0.5346093773841858,
-0.2176813781261444,
0.04601522907614708,
0.7113190293312073,
0.38486164808273315,
-0.5511313676834106,
0.593766987323761,
-0.45447447896003723,
-0.5202662348747253,
0.6440514922142029,
0.6175379157066345,
0.8175060749053955,
0.08713370561599731,
0.6765851378440857,
0.24085526168346405,
0.34511181712150574,
-0.1051141694188118,
0.5861111283302307,
0.10561355948448181,
-0.8340095281600952,
-0.5904126167297363,
-0.5795598030090332,
-0.5704643130302429,
0.010248472914099693,
-0.38652557134628296,
0.13825267553329468,
-0.7523065805435181,
0.00421255175024271,
-0.25696298480033875,
-0.024168921634554863,
-0.5745887160301208,
0.1933300942182541,
-0.005351684521883726,
0.9570242762565613,
-0.7003031373023987,
0.5591126084327698,
0.6068078875541687,
-0.3408186733722687,
-1.0394648313522339,
0.028506843373179436,
-0.1233566477894783,
-0.9700049757957458,
0.10349930822849274,
-0.26524582505226135,
0.03600062429904938,
0.0765654444694519,
-0.44909271597862244,
-0.6897940039634705,
0.9367998242378235,
0.5449984669685364,
-0.9626582860946655,
0.11480583995580673,
-0.23139458894729614,
0.5328554511070251,
-0.22708092629909515,
-0.005608067382127047,
0.5150678157806396,
0.20248563587665558,
0.0887477919459343,
-0.774785578250885,
0.18950426578521729,
-0.06829306483268738,
-0.2082701176404953,
0.37613868713378906,
-0.6062604784965515,
0.2876074016094208,
-0.6665010452270508,
-0.22182531654834747,
0.06583816558122635,
0.4906010627746582,
0.7632588744163513,
0.4812740385532379,
0.40920451283454895,
0.6182302832603455,
1.1539312601089478,
-0.22571276128292084,
1.1269314289093018,
-0.10080190747976303,
0.2861339747905731,
1.0663384199142456,
-0.2338840663433075,
0.728588879108429,
0.4643173813819885,
-0.4721071422100067,
0.6560899019241333,
0.7846295833587646,
-0.12330710887908936,
0.23551291227340698,
0.4678806662559509,
-0.1020180732011795,
-0.37054041028022766,
0.14454294741153717,
-0.15969856083393097,
0.13116838037967682,
-0.02060224860906601,
-0.1903933584690094,
-0.026924099773168564,
-0.32437002658843994,
-0.2187734842300415,
0.383353590965271,
-0.5061519742012024,
0.9404788017272949,
0.04909120500087738,
-0.39707863330841064,
0.6206138730049133,
-0.1460871696472168,
0.2645932734012604,
-0.22828011214733124,
0.017817139625549316,
-0.41254255175590515,
0.17270037531852722,
-0.3583241403102875,
-0.7024860382080078,
0.17982272803783417,
-0.056193675845861435,
-0.23480167984962463,
0.14762231707572937,
0.5515906810760498,
-0.4172956049442291,
-0.7469100952148438,
0.2525132894515991,
0.6659338474273682,
0.20663787424564362,
0.13971954584121704,
-0.745115339756012,
-0.18178196251392365,
-0.019206879660487175,
0.3375536799430847,
0.16475507616996765,
0.45666074752807617,
-0.23407350480556488,
0.8919281959533691,
0.8402013778686523,
0.6781755089759827,
0.2747434079647064,
0.1707407534122467,
0.4845004677772522,
-0.7615441679954529,
-0.6607150435447693,
-0.4808596670627594,
0.5014740824699402,
-0.01257266104221344,
-0.16180554032325745,
0.3030020594596863,
0.47677698731422424,
0.936081051826477,
0.06240189075469971,
1.0368032455444336,
0.2724587917327881,
0.510039746761322,
-0.7758064270019531,
0.1432311087846756,
-0.605953574180603,
0.28455641865730286,
-0.0169290192425251,
-0.9850820899009705,
-0.19919592142105103,
0.6385111212730408,
-0.3507213890552521,
0.11730987578630447,
0.9767276644706726,
0.9183777570724487,
-0.13028764724731445,
-0.11280740797519684,
0.1857905387878418,
0.551910936832428,
0.13495418429374695,
0.969086229801178,
0.8981863856315613,
-0.33280766010284424,
0.6865295767784119,
-0.17868974804878235,
-0.288468599319458,
-0.1763661801815033,
-0.838371217250824,
-0.7576450705528259,
-0.416813462972641,
-0.49824824929237366,
-0.858104407787323,
0.577520489692688,
0.8771951794624329,
0.7249962091445923,
-1.009382963180542,
0.03496915102005005,
0.046353165060281754,
0.43177029490470886,
-0.48514997959136963,
-0.1812499463558197,
0.1910354644060135,
-0.4596387445926666,
-0.3655940890312195,
0.2670570909976959,
0.2613452970981598,
0.05280384421348572,
-0.0029426226392388344,
-0.2648943066596985,
0.05927715077996254,
0.30806565284729004,
0.4721280634403229,
0.3780243694782257,
-0.7481784224510193,
-0.7097904086112976,
-0.18886901438236237,
0.17929890751838684,
0.3996705710887909,
0.6641688942909241,
-0.7402607798576355,
0.4333048164844513,
0.37085744738578796,
1.075007438659668,
0.5045893788337708,
0.19134609401226044,
0.7809614539146423,
-0.5484256148338318,
-0.10501183569431305,
0.3780779540538788,
0.3514581024646759,
0.319305956363678,
-0.4939609169960022,
0.525851309299469,
0.35967719554901123,
-0.6263478398323059,
-1.030768871307373,
0.36151322722435,
-1.175148606300354,
-0.4590161144733429,
1.4385637044906616,
-0.024858472868800163,
-0.495766818523407,
-0.3459945619106293,
-0.24013322591781616,
0.08023825287818909,
-0.238479346036911,
1.1707541942596436,
0.4659271240234375,
-0.01790076680481434,
-0.42184120416641235,
-0.38866788148880005,
0.3212028741836548,
0.3933650851249695,
-1.095664381980896,
0.044689979404211044,
0.5393969416618347,
0.629606306552887,
-0.26135027408599854,
0.6209368705749512,
-0.07532163709402084,
0.7332810163497925,
-0.16692067682743073,
-0.010456354357302189,
-0.20820505917072296,
-0.32572296261787415,
-0.414826899766922,
0.14465898275375366,
0.349728524684906,
-0.29312583804130554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18682v1 | The Multilingual Alignment Prism: Aligning Global and Local Preferences to Reduce Harm | 2024-06-26T18:39:08 | 2024-06-26T18:39:08 | Aakanksha, Arash Ahmadian, Beyza Ermis, Seraphina Goldfarb-Tarrant, Julia Kreutzer, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A key concern with the concept of "alignment" is the implicit question of
"alignment to what?". AI systems are increasingly used across the world, yet
safety alignment is often focused on homogeneous monolingual settings.
Additionally, preference training and safety measures often overfit to harms
common in Western-centric datasets. Here, we explore the viability of different
alignment approaches when balancing dual objectives: addressing and optimizing
for a non-homogeneous set of languages and cultural preferences while
minimizing both global and local harms. We collect the first set of human
annotated red-teaming prompts in different languages distinguishing between
global and local harm, which serve as a laboratory for understanding the
reliability of alignment techniques when faced with preference distributions
that are non-stationary across geographies and languages. While this setting is
seldom covered by the literature to date, which primarily centers on English
harm mitigation, it captures real-world interactions with AI systems around the
world. We establish a new precedent for state-of-the-art alignment techniques
across 6 languages with minimal degradation in general performance. Our work
provides important insights into cross-lingual transfer and novel optimization
approaches to safeguard AI systems designed to serve global populations. | [
-0.21142826974391937,
-0.3884149193763733,
0.11097298562526703,
0.2927636206150055,
0.29966074228286743,
0.10909618437290192,
-0.26994118094444275,
-0.7846294045448303,
0.11198602616786957,
0.07536929845809937,
-0.5183707475662231,
-0.31840696930885315,
-0.35140281915664673,
0.11871093511581421,
0.22242821753025055,
1.3010292053222656,
-0.27903032302856445,
0.3007909655570984,
-0.12449363619089127,
-0.5837790966033936,
-0.6067144274711609,
-0.503242552280426,
-0.551852285861969,
-0.24314993619918823,
0.7730580568313599,
0.588158130645752,
0.9906567335128784,
0.5331057906150818,
0.8756905198097229,
0.22996383905410767,
0.18064351379871368,
-0.012291635386645794,
-0.36768272519111633,
0.06367118656635284,
-0.14384719729423523,
-0.25175076723098755,
-0.2691565454006195,
-0.00311111519113183,
0.49416956305503845,
0.6331309080123901,
0.026976725086569786,
-0.038991305977106094,
-0.025288531556725502,
0.6170334815979004,
-0.8867263197898865,
-0.1816621720790863,
-0.3394748568534851,
0.3457968831062317,
-0.13778242468833923,
0.05917484685778618,
-0.21883420646190643,
-0.3887326419353485,
0.3740456700325012,
-0.719883143901825,
-0.41538894176483154,
0.1461361199617386,
0.8316485285758972,
0.6379643678665161,
-0.8395652770996094,
-0.03612774610519409,
-0.48334988951683044,
1.064927577972412,
-0.04184257239103317,
0.35784679651260376,
0.08430835604667664,
0.3622121810913086,
0.1295229196548462,
0.10005597025156021,
-0.30383434891700745,
0.3037576973438263,
-0.22030788660049438,
0.2272985577583313,
0.04106549546122551,
0.066975899040699,
-0.08866701275110245,
0.09149263054132462,
-0.8855681419372559,
0.3319316506385803,
-0.3402366638183594,
-0.7077021598815918,
0.8935378193855286,
0.132319375872612,
0.7653880715370178,
0.12985096871852875,
-0.7718836665153503,
-0.1580609232187271,
-0.8361238241195679,
0.1567421853542328,
0.42394256591796875,
0.504523754119873,
-0.5052531361579895,
0.42508062720298767,
-0.003107471624389291,
0.6379137635231018,
-0.08757604658603668,
-0.525819718837738,
0.2591349184513092,
-0.672162652015686,
-0.0030336580239236355,
0.45853522419929504,
0.8485921025276184,
1.022498607635498,
0.4472503364086151,
-0.2820439338684082,
0.2297639548778534,
0.44813594222068787,
0.2700420022010803,
-0.35765528678894043,
0.13691744208335876,
0.20734219253063202,
-0.2595589756965637,
-0.2625311613082886,
-0.2529694139957428,
-0.7793077230453491,
-0.5574896931648254,
-0.49603402614593506,
0.2826433777809143,
-0.3448680341243744,
-0.21308012306690216,
0.26168501377105713,
0.0033996300771832466,
0.39892011880874634,
0.015772603452205658,
-1.0171966552734375,
-0.07407598942518234,
0.7141016721725464,
0.798732578754425,
-0.41215917468070984,
-0.5954825282096863,
-0.33962133526802063,
0.39702609181404114,
-0.28741127252578735,
0.6896265745162964,
-0.37167617678642273,
-0.20364722609519958,
0.017291458323597908,
-0.15337306261062622,
-0.05687885358929634,
-0.19581161439418793,
0.5973232388496399,
-0.13896410167217255,
0.453158974647522,
-0.5609042644500732,
-0.06733512878417969,
-0.1419147104024887,
0.4643547832965851,
-0.373384028673172,
0.7364181280136108,
-0.21256780624389648,
-0.8864991068840027,
0.7089431285858154,
-0.7168658375740051,
-0.8527495265007019,
-0.3289618194103241,
-0.07672493159770966,
-0.28606727719306946,
-0.32747846841812134,
0.19763220846652985,
0.04564245790243149,
-0.19771245121955872,
0.23356325924396515,
-0.25583764910697937,
-0.235754132270813,
-0.21563692390918732,
-0.5279179811477661,
0.904074490070343,
0.1664240062236786,
-0.3594323992729187,
0.3999122679233551,
-0.4244763255119324,
0.056256938725709915,
-0.030928703024983406,
-0.2364959865808487,
-0.5033701062202454,
0.01639367640018463,
0.0843474492430687,
0.4079783260822296,
0.4836512506008148,
-0.5572074055671692,
0.22046677768230438,
-0.21011243760585785,
0.15596871078014374,
0.7722368240356445,
-0.18555350601673126,
0.799643337726593,
-0.4814831614494324,
0.420772910118103,
-0.0754750669002533,
0.7219631671905518,
0.3315984606742859,
-0.20614291727542877,
-0.46603965759277344,
-0.23854723572731018,
0.012632676400244236,
1.0365526676177979,
-0.5906804800033569,
0.35201960802078247,
-0.3698342442512512,
-0.4062229096889496,
-0.6336979269981384,
-0.11655592918395996,
0.7076546549797058,
0.6859180927276611,
0.37031224370002747,
-0.17831607162952423,
-0.4725691080093384,
-1.3060290813446045,
-0.2172473818063736,
-0.3569946885108948,
0.3300229012966156,
0.07630310207605362,
0.06775825470685959,
-0.2390270084142685,
0.833103358745575,
-0.3355652093887329,
-0.33942097425460815,
-0.009981640614569187,
-0.13790015876293182,
-0.22807779908180237,
0.5408473014831543,
0.7652223110198975,
-1.0870842933654785,
-0.9012681245803833,
0.34905120730400085,
-0.9983588457107544,
-0.12348704040050507,
-0.2491321563720703,
-0.5851194858551025,
0.4253285825252533,
0.09881485253572464,
-0.16882328689098358,
0.2286224365234375,
0.628048837184906,
-0.11961900442838669,
0.31250643730163574,
-0.03905084729194641,
0.35830411314964294,
-0.9730679392814636,
0.09902971237897873,
0.09672364592552185,
0.16147378087043762,
-0.8135814070701599,
0.011105751618742943,
0.1346255987882614,
0.021375084295868874,
-0.7466042041778564,
0.7518978714942932,
-0.4587986171245575,
0.14375926554203033,
0.09989188611507416,
0.09033793956041336,
-0.03488558530807495,
0.3285926282405853,
0.16709591448307037,
0.9312906265258789,
0.6877163052558899,
-0.4145735800266266,
0.1100730374455452,
0.49108779430389404,
-0.08966195583343506,
1.0874165296554565,
-0.33251065015792847,
-0.021153436973690987,
-0.315239280462265,
-0.0700777918100357,
-0.6036359667778015,
-0.2633057236671448,
0.4507071375846863,
-0.18074579536914825,
0.4438629448413849,
-0.11772119998931885,
-0.052375998347997665,
0.0007717299158684909,
-0.578502893447876,
0.7454853057861328,
0.11729243397712708,
-0.48323649168014526,
0.25224733352661133,
0.8613379597663879,
-0.15043537318706512,
-1.2645336389541626,
-0.7671810984611511,
0.10952454805374146,
-0.7873886227607727,
-0.9272191524505615,
0.1827491819858551,
-0.14048054814338684,
-0.5197692513465881,
-0.4480789303779602,
-0.08986277133226395,
0.20538969337940216,
0.26545220613479614,
0.08777886629104614,
0.42000922560691833,
-0.07522813975811005,
0.007769416086375713,
-0.040376920253038406,
-0.5056992173194885,
-0.3120037913322449,
-0.2532180845737457,
0.24111288785934448,
-0.24509385228157043,
-0.3410544693470001,
-0.40436768531799316,
0.8805797696113586,
0.5904155969619751,
-0.4265436828136444,
0.8634002804756165,
0.2913352847099304,
-0.3216533064842224,
0.4646967351436615,
-0.3269919157028198,
0.16302357614040375,
-0.4148048758506775,
0.2553251385688782,
-0.13723380863666534,
-0.6284191012382507,
0.42882388830184937,
0.27934327721595764,
0.3866458237171173,
0.2388530820608139,
0.3385142982006073,
-0.007324594538658857,
1.089284896850586,
0.6522391438484192,
-0.6700666546821594,
0.3392573595046997,
0.2781149446964264,
0.5027509331703186,
-0.6491790413856506,
-0.05680755525827408,
-0.5537113547325134,
-0.6221798658370972,
-0.6704787611961365,
-0.03362186625599861,
0.822145938873291,
-0.07162179797887802,
-0.7176589369773865,
0.14939747750759125,
-0.7254993915557861,
0.720539391040802,
0.6138020753860474,
-0.3383064270019531,
0.1168297529220581,
0.12784932553768158,
0.012732666917145252,
-0.36448875069618225,
-0.5403274297714233,
-0.5573247075080872,
0.8582685589790344,
0.12291092425584793,
0.8251067996025085,
0.3512393832206726,
0.7012300491333008,
-0.023123303428292274,
0.29492807388305664,
-0.6398134827613831,
0.12931771576404572,
-0.11442513763904572,
-0.7887895107269287,
-0.503628671169281,
-0.27410802245140076,
-1.093253254890442,
0.4205109477043152,
-0.354476660490036,
-0.9196492433547974,
-0.020024189725518227,
0.23681071400642395,
-0.35643550753593445,
0.26914680004119873,
-0.8561133146286011,
1.2393230199813843,
-0.9353299736976624,
-0.44302600622177124,
0.1278388351202011,
-1.164709210395813,
0.18195660412311554,
-0.05161675065755844,
0.5364264249801636,
-0.2105827033519745,
-0.028712494298815727,
0.386691153049469,
0.13059253990650177,
0.7128039598464966,
-0.12073002010583878,
-0.25727924704551697,
-0.25296464562416077,
-0.1288560926914215,
0.09987808763980865,
-0.11711617559194565,
-0.18560177087783813,
0.4578777849674225,
0.1260765790939331,
-0.3933797776699066,
-0.2541050612926483,
0.6428617238998413,
-0.8761599063873291,
-0.5572804808616638,
-0.5996196269989014,
-0.8824125528335571,
-0.2821570038795471,
0.45856600999832153,
0.3046819269657135,
0.11404429376125336,
-0.3277258276939392,
-0.21877318620681763,
0.3582686483860016,
-0.35345739126205444,
0.32559117674827576,
0.4722156226634979,
0.023882102221250534,
-0.462078332901001,
1.156057596206665,
-0.0005827783024869859,
0.4818674623966217,
0.5106918215751648,
0.09245811402797699,
-0.37434136867523193,
-0.447656512260437,
-0.6471840143203735,
0.12874381244182587,
-0.6987956762313843,
-0.2582269310951233,
-0.2340961992740631,
0.08701104670763016,
-0.4924885332584381,
-0.7007028460502625,
-0.2436729371547699,
-0.23759102821350098,
0.16096986830234528,
-0.032535333186388016,
0.07040698081254959,
0.33797410130500793,
-0.45389488339424133,
-0.016048990190029144,
-0.8756771683692932,
0.17602312564849854,
-0.030931193381547928,
0.2472771555185318,
-0.5229460000991821,
0.21977831423282623,
-0.14862613379955292,
0.28609856963157654,
-0.27166253328323364,
-0.7774622440338135,
0.24636778235435486,
0.14347003400325775,
0.6341169476509094,
0.4067692160606384,
0.4893496036529541,
0.7259575724601746,
-0.5770431756973267,
0.6257456541061401,
0.3177383542060852,
-0.6832396388053894,
0.4131447672843933,
-0.3869933485984802,
0.17647434771060944,
0.9919264316558838,
0.6708903312683105,
-1.1194491386413574,
-0.2550678253173828,
-0.011967364698648453,
-0.9960627555847168,
0.6886610984802246,
-0.16298942267894745,
0.06314750760793686,
-0.04070686176419258,
0.07020153850317001,
0.2393689900636673,
-0.02024109475314617,
-0.8376728892326355,
-0.4393577575683594,
0.0641380250453949,
-0.6316901445388794,
-0.15241406857967377,
0.1899656057357788,
-0.7207920551300049,
0.17426680028438568,
0.8193670511245728,
-0.3857780694961548,
-0.06231183931231499,
-0.0685231015086174,
-0.21013528108596802,
-0.2715163826942444,
0.3060521185398102,
0.6666927337646484,
0.2733430564403534,
0.15240749716758728,
0.10807182639837265,
0.1261277049779892,
-0.34288346767425537,
0.4383673071861267,
-0.010646076872944832,
-0.5540871024131775,
-0.7023345828056335,
0.24427060782909393,
0.5836198329925537,
0.1728225201368332,
-0.57427579164505,
0.4401763677597046,
-0.2469877153635025,
0.10777778178453445,
-0.11289633810520172,
-0.02896803617477417,
-0.224823996424675,
0.12800517678260803,
-0.09505835920572281,
0.20287637412548065,
0.05031431093811989,
-0.3472990393638611,
-0.014096238650381565,
0.8359775543212891,
-0.3607390820980072,
-0.1151655837893486,
0.6116440892219543,
0.3289939761161804,
-0.2870981991291046,
0.45128756761550903,
0.035452987998723984,
-0.5343563556671143,
0.4308364987373352,
0.320932000875473,
0.6006268858909607,
-0.11417555063962936,
0.1355496495962143,
0.23992577195167542,
0.41306161880493164,
0.024217739701271057,
0.1386401653289795,
0.20755985379219055,
-1.0640443563461304,
-0.18123938143253326,
-0.41391780972480774,
-0.43351733684539795,
-0.42886272072792053,
-0.7426172494888306,
0.14864443242549896,
-0.06723537296056747,
0.09698251634836197,
-0.03673559054732323,
-0.1648191213607788,
-0.33672791719436646,
0.07156812399625778,
0.24939222633838654,
0.43578293919563293,
-1.063565731048584,
0.45967012643814087,
0.8770663738250732,
-0.372111439704895,
-0.6121329665184021,
0.2032448798418045,
0.6207317113876343,
-0.8292497396469116,
0.2769659459590912,
0.39495202898979187,
-0.12590715289115906,
-0.49888876080513,
-0.09931355714797974,
-1.1818913221359253,
0.8729477524757385,
0.6346844434738159,
-0.19161909818649292,
0.03998621925711632,
0.4648221433162689,
0.521624743938446,
0.04151027649641037,
-0.09229940921068192,
0.5835991501808167,
0.7667385339736938,
-0.18118970096111298,
-1.3199228048324585,
-0.2121880054473877,
-0.13513317704200745,
-0.39551812410354614,
0.6740144491195679,
-1.0302618741989136,
0.3347763419151306,
-0.25109392404556274,
-0.28374338150024414,
-0.22205021977424622,
0.2582474946975708,
0.06257624924182892,
0.23389698565006256,
0.4822763204574585,
0.5618293881416321,
0.8536432981491089,
-0.22200490534305573,
1.0975065231323242,
-0.47215956449508667,
0.13462986052036285,
0.9946848154067993,
-0.5296140909194946,
0.4715774953365326,
0.6231490969657898,
-0.18097054958343506,
-0.003284245962277055,
0.7255436182022095,
0.38845759630203247,
0.708794355392456,
-0.20993450284004211,
-0.19142775237560272,
-0.14040784537792206,
-0.44633781909942627,
-0.3193238377571106,
0.5565481781959534,
0.0272824764251709,
0.29756736755371094,
-0.09725470095872879,
0.05109308287501335,
0.18470491468906403,
0.06917773932218552,
-0.04556642845273018,
0.862490177154541,
-0.30395400524139404,
-1.1891125440597534,
0.55098956823349,
-0.22183936834335327,
0.966000497341156,
-0.5363752245903015,
0.35181885957717896,
-0.1929488480091095,
0.2855764627456665,
-0.2329384982585907,
-0.7856032848358154,
0.5428095459938049,
-0.24643446505069733,
-0.2990664839744568,
-0.44021695852279663,
0.3265431523323059,
-0.654899001121521,
-0.37919285893440247,
0.5014700293540955,
0.24127347767353058,
0.031560420989990234,
0.3986022472381592,
-0.7515999674797058,
0.05525992810726166,
0.1778060793876648,
0.24925288558006287,
0.6049542427062988,
0.09601666033267975,
-0.3926265835762024,
0.5821451544761658,
0.35850128531455994,
0.02351006120443344,
-0.019491171464323997,
-0.03412780165672302,
0.3059068024158478,
-0.20627252757549286,
-0.45819535851478577,
-0.6905801296234131,
0.7083061337471008,
-0.03547198325395584,
-0.4191513955593109,
0.6702487468719482,
0.47687238454818726,
0.973609983921051,
0.20506593585014343,
0.9030661582946777,
-0.04640820249915123,
0.06795603781938553,
-0.5158469080924988,
0.49919888377189636,
-0.8698456883430481,
-0.05275335535407066,
-0.33574801683425903,
-0.7522838115692139,
-0.7272582650184631,
0.7876439690589905,
-0.3233306109905243,
-0.21462251245975494,
0.5547412037849426,
0.817281186580658,
0.10084833204746246,
0.031083567067980766,
0.10898250341415405,
-0.2995198965072632,
0.39270177483558655,
0.7393993735313416,
0.7728983759880066,
-0.23524297773838043,
0.48404496908187866,
-0.4238390624523163,
-0.31663978099823,
0.1399010270833969,
-0.9593479633331299,
-0.4492647051811218,
-0.4581964910030365,
-0.4143143892288208,
0.04262152686715126,
0.11864391714334488,
1.0707663297653198,
0.6584395170211792,
-0.8776183724403381,
-0.10666375607252121,
0.38645830750465393,
0.2852150499820709,
-0.10618913918733597,
-0.16419321298599243,
0.33073464035987854,
-0.43604108691215515,
-0.8000375032424927,
0.38153159618377686,
0.6019476056098938,
0.14843398332595825,
-0.09898743033409119,
-0.35932594537734985,
-0.2654072642326355,
-0.3549020290374756,
0.17838901281356812,
0.5646318197250366,
-0.658785343170166,
-0.8142483234405518,
0.09196670353412628,
-0.26445630192756653,
0.2996082305908203,
0.5457063317298889,
-0.045432932674884796,
0.46504420042037964,
0.3618847131729126,
0.6548499464988708,
-0.28999805450439453,
-0.01295812800526619,
0.8360071778297424,
-0.8578693270683289,
0.3887820839881897,
0.16384099423885345,
0.6002999544143677,
0.5424187779426575,
-0.6390657424926758,
0.7326396107673645,
-0.1555486023426056,
-0.7141207456588745,
-0.7284104824066162,
0.409039705991745,
-0.6596442461013794,
-0.054656874388456345,
1.1177312135696411,
-0.05022964999079704,
0.13954465091228485,
-0.34530550241470337,
-0.47638195753097534,
0.2536157965660095,
-0.2090020477771759,
0.8067424893379211,
0.7513759136199951,
-0.3107316493988037,
0.272542268037796,
-0.20845381915569305,
0.5962472558021545,
0.6902012825012207,
-0.9257981181144714,
0.09353325515985489,
0.7818283438682556,
0.19992636144161224,
0.5802838206291199,
0.4746701121330261,
-0.08068662136793137,
0.37080565094947815,
-0.3786852955818176,
0.28830206394195557,
0.5358681082725525,
-0.5569703578948975,
-0.4534856975078583,
0.03093375638127327,
-0.003519358579069376,
-0.14799349009990692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18679v1 | Speakers Unembedded: Embedding-free Approach to Long-form Neural Diarization | 2024-06-26T18:32:16 | 2024-06-26T18:32:16 | Xiang Li, Vivek Govindan, Rohit Paturi, Sundararajan Srinivasan | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | End-to-end neural diarization (EEND) models offer significant improvements
over traditional embedding-based Speaker Diarization (SD) approaches but falls
short on generalizing to long-form audio with large number of speakers.
EEND-vector-clustering method mitigates this by combining local EEND with
global clustering of speaker embeddings from local windows, but this requires
an additional speaker embedding framework alongside the EEND module. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework applying EEND both locally and globally for
long-form audio without separate speaker embeddings. This approach achieves
significant relative DER reduction of 13% and 10% over the conventional 1-pass
EEND on Callhome American English and RT03-CTS datasets respectively and
marginal improvements over EEND-vector-clustering without the need for
additional speaker embeddings. Furthermore, we discuss the computational
complexity of our proposed framework and explore strategies for reducing
processing times. | [
-0.66497802734375,
-0.6849048733711243,
0.30850479006767273,
0.19220097362995148,
-0.30247050523757935,
0.01463342271745205,
-0.714024543762207,
-0.45796486735343933,
0.6879954934120178,
0.1147117167711258,
-0.284429669380188,
-0.6286014318466187,
-0.25801655650138855,
0.1675047129392624,
-0.28305378556251526,
0.2542392313480377,
0.40352967381477356,
-0.08403529971837997,
-0.5098795294761658,
-0.01273314468562603,
-0.26113829016685486,
-0.362153559923172,
-0.8412880301475525,
-0.2930564284324646,
0.5375791788101196,
0.3316706120967865,
0.10372292995452881,
0.4154641628265381,
0.0947289988398552,
0.23331007361412048,
-0.5492178201675415,
0.012304744683206081,
-0.21842633187770844,
0.2157893180847168,
0.16844609379768372,
-0.3085487186908722,
-0.6044982075691223,
-0.24256479740142822,
0.5634294748306274,
1.0461426973342896,
-0.36559438705444336,
-0.22106406092643738,
0.01603366993367672,
0.4979090094566345,
-0.4774397909641266,
-0.15318332612514496,
-0.36772507429122925,
0.3305193781852722,
-0.12311507016420364,
-0.15321896970272064,
-0.6052468419075012,
-0.006294695194810629,
0.16818605363368988,
-0.3582858145236969,
0.39507633447647095,
-0.4095250070095062,
0.165437713265419,
0.13894261419773102,
-0.31914034485816956,
0.49669378995895386,
-0.9657811522483826,
0.5969954133033752,
-0.8781771063804626,
0.8119610548019409,
0.5403295159339905,
0.20919828116893768,
-0.09546661376953125,
-0.41036468744277954,
-0.3813656270503998,
-0.0300288163125515,
0.1951984316110611,
0.2934836745262146,
-0.30011627078056335,
0.6148549318313599,
0.03767522796988487,
0.1454077810049057,
-0.5665245652198792,
0.44079604744911194,
-0.5764261484146118,
-0.05434080585837364,
0.4194195568561554,
-0.4663736820220947,
0.0005751379649154842,
0.06251164525747299,
-0.5635933876037598,
0.21409206092357635,
-0.9776180386543274,
-0.09303762018680573,
0.27363452315330505,
0.556067168712616,
-0.37426748871803284,
0.4312092959880829,
-0.03718304634094238,
0.5282659530639648,
0.025508884340524673,
0.23742583394050598,
0.34172558784484863,
0.20509864389896393,
-0.2262709140777588,
0.44807168841362,
0.6570186614990234,
0.5103198289871216,
0.26007816195487976,
-0.6656273603439331,
-0.14128044247627258,
0.07255717366933823,
-0.21198733150959015,
-0.7498162984848022,
-0.061318185180425644,
0.39887216687202454,
-0.6239914298057556,
-0.0251252930611372,
-0.12314194440841675,
-0.9406205415725708,
-0.16684038937091827,
-0.514188289642334,
0.46966710686683655,
-0.4091222882270813,
-0.328571617603302,
0.18880139291286469,
-0.24846158921718597,
0.09874051064252853,
0.13556048274040222,
-0.867958664894104,
0.6175223588943481,
0.5475271344184875,
1.0035934448242188,
-0.30598750710487366,
-0.05268174037337303,
-0.372708797454834,
0.4258710443973541,
-0.3437119126319885,
0.6293254494667053,
-0.5193774104118347,
-0.6708101630210876,
-0.11180813610553741,
-0.19353535771369934,
-0.09363751113414764,
-0.5861107707023621,
0.23726658523082733,
-0.16214346885681152,
0.29594796895980835,
-0.04402213543653488,
-0.7749958038330078,
-0.2103482335805893,
-0.07190325111150742,
-0.5326141715049744,
0.8414155840873718,
-0.05469781905412674,
-0.5820378661155701,
0.22103004157543182,
-0.5489550828933716,
-0.3402142822742462,
-0.17334024608135223,
-0.3763841688632965,
-0.24675801396369934,
0.4024849236011505,
0.3940582871437073,
0.7133544087409973,
0.021968219429254532,
0.035707756876945496,
-0.28970712423324585,
-0.5418787002563477,
-0.2909519374370575,
-0.59635990858078,
0.42909008264541626,
0.08478761464357376,
-0.4801364243030548,
-0.12256632000207901,
-1.3323651552200317,
-0.13283737003803253,
-0.059352971613407135,
-0.18983228504657745,
-0.7183438539505005,
0.3512294888496399,
-0.08706023544073105,
-0.026773078367114067,
-0.06484642624855042,
-0.8677927255630493,
0.018767353147268295,
-0.666035532951355,
0.6380105018615723,
0.6790205240249634,
0.03360019996762276,
0.5938259363174438,
-0.1314796358346939,
0.251346617937088,
0.15687108039855957,
-0.14399419724941254,
-0.055340129882097244,
-0.48761919140815735,
-0.7684556841850281,
-0.40937522053718567,
0.4059646427631378,
0.3955392837524414,
-0.39354658126831055,
0.7154061198234558,
-0.5288513898849487,
-0.4729924201965332,
-0.3749527931213379,
-0.36653321981430054,
0.15270860493183136,
0.28324276208877563,
0.5366665124893188,
-0.3792674243450165,
-0.7021344304084778,
-1.0683592557907104,
0.35934045910835266,
-0.04568029195070267,
-0.3164213299751282,
0.008672459982335567,
0.0140675138682127,
-0.22813959419727325,
1.0416456460952759,
-0.1182328537106514,
-0.28615042567253113,
0.07251356542110443,
-0.031093543395400047,
0.23359322547912598,
0.4383969008922577,
0.48325902223587036,
-0.47729799151420593,
-0.17038314044475555,
0.031038252636790276,
-0.4076198935508728,
0.06350100040435791,
-0.11488921195268631,
0.20455357432365417,
0.1271868199110031,
0.7398961782455444,
-0.8646814227104187,
0.7458668947219849,
0.30799004435539246,
-0.11762555688619614,
0.11643178015947342,
-0.22493800520896912,
-0.16074493527412415,
-0.9463439583778381,
-0.06812817603349686,
-0.09262783825397491,
-0.2599203884601593,
-0.8212281465530396,
-0.3433959186077118,
-0.03394433856010437,
-0.12472587823867798,
-0.41387972235679626,
0.20368823409080505,
-0.4966334402561188,
-0.05076519772410393,
-0.044891636818647385,
0.26921939849853516,
0.05417175218462944,
0.5172857642173767,
0.1519426554441452,
0.6117706298828125,
0.5544093251228333,
-0.7570210695266724,
0.14532367885112762,
0.3499884009361267,
-0.13100944459438324,
0.38982465863227844,
-0.8066300749778748,
0.27642637491226196,
-0.43065136671066284,
0.2303096354007721,
-1.1085253953933716,
0.3248017132282257,
-0.0802384689450264,
-0.42925533652305603,
0.7549355626106262,
-0.33910125494003296,
0.038593266159296036,
-0.3007529079914093,
-0.5617601275444031,
0.7035444974899292,
0.4172188639640808,
-0.7930116653442383,
0.4569779336452484,
0.21295878291130066,
-0.4692610204219818,
-0.24559594690799713,
-0.6666873693466187,
0.18370421230793,
-0.3956080973148346,
-0.6769179701805115,
1.0213950872421265,
-0.13995973765850067,
-0.19533197581768036,
-0.24541226029396057,
0.0030043998267501593,
0.0960458442568779,
-0.21521897614002228,
0.10202815383672714,
-0.4120276868343353,
-0.3038632571697235,
0.34387490153312683,
-0.06403966248035431,
-0.2494703084230423,
-0.04847612604498863,
-0.20244309306144714,
0.5102445483207703,
0.363724023103714,
-0.4346745014190674,
-0.3119954764842987,
0.9410419464111328,
0.6065278649330139,
-0.381777822971344,
0.5706245303153992,
0.6227089166641235,
-0.4657152593135834,
-0.4977053701877594,
-0.5791351199150085,
-0.10897515714168549,
-0.4915453791618347,
0.441620409488678,
-0.22563448548316956,
-1.0035172700881958,
0.6136292219161987,
-0.14214953780174255,
-0.0793418139219284,
0.18209564685821533,
0.36541393399238586,
-0.0053550610318779945,
0.8947195410728455,
0.6486244797706604,
-0.12540237605571747,
0.29121944308280945,
-0.15759839117527008,
0.5402765274047852,
-0.915817379951477,
-0.4168367087841034,
-0.4942103326320648,
-0.3320426940917969,
-0.5042594075202942,
-0.4954855442047119,
0.2641948163509369,
-0.08082728832960129,
-0.20866452157497406,
0.19592046737670898,
-0.8572772145271301,
0.5071854591369629,
0.5552718639373779,
0.1101069301366806,
-0.030649462714791298,
0.42040374875068665,
-0.3266562521457672,
-0.03369489684700966,
-0.388497531414032,
0.13419222831726074,
0.9290738701820374,
0.484112024307251,
0.6255884766578674,
0.062070149928331375,
1.0327228307724,
0.3212120831012726,
-0.510485053062439,
-0.8741734623908997,
0.6283919215202332,
-0.13213877379894257,
0.11633031070232391,
-0.4197429120540619,
-0.48048049211502075,
-1.1056842803955078,
0.30218642950057983,
0.3249015212059021,
-0.9236615896224976,
0.6494409441947937,
-0.28954142332077026,
-0.48249387741088867,
0.5407590866088867,
-0.7338249087333679,
0.1624012142419815,
0.09020368754863739,
-0.02269650064408779,
-0.289860337972641,
-0.4632696211338043,
-0.16869191825389862,
0.09391723573207855,
0.372477263212204,
-0.022379150614142418,
0.02038733847439289,
1.2013561725616455,
-0.2893306314945221,
0.9624784588813782,
-0.6636319756507874,
-0.28352683782577515,
0.3126080632209778,
-0.02904246188700199,
0.2979760468006134,
-0.1000237986445427,
0.008929474279284477,
0.231892392039299,
-0.10618586838245392,
-0.02733144536614418,
-0.3804766833782196,
0.7579525709152222,
-0.8803696036338806,
-0.434831440448761,
0.06870347261428833,
0.06010732799768448,
-0.4002847969532013,
-0.01727648638188839,
0.41302189230918884,
0.712685227394104,
-0.30298691987991333,
0.33160069584846497,
0.7489093542098999,
-0.21829095482826233,
0.8295686841011047,
0.10885895788669586,
-0.2110363245010376,
-0.9291634559631348,
0.7964679598808289,
0.25793105363845825,
0.029389217495918274,
0.5334552526473999,
-0.048983581364154816,
-0.2503616511821747,
-0.7475012540817261,
0.053871456533670425,
0.2692313492298126,
-0.5920825004577637,
-0.17120639979839325,
-0.4803227484226227,
-0.15910589694976807,
-0.4517818093299866,
0.06999073922634125,
-0.6902514696121216,
-0.8036446571350098,
-0.2176651805639267,
-0.432332307100296,
0.2837448716163635,
0.6283860206604004,
-0.2879439890384674,
0.36255475878715515,
-0.7112356424331665,
0.34068694710731506,
0.36208048462867737,
0.7827726006507874,
0.1868201196193695,
-0.39663559198379517,
-0.497478723526001,
0.12016314268112183,
-0.10619540512561798,
-0.9396637082099915,
0.4259520471096039,
0.6306049227714539,
0.6060224771499634,
0.622448742389679,
-0.03146210312843323,
0.7156023383140564,
-0.9861947894096375,
0.9235497713088989,
0.4467420279979706,
-0.8008101582527161,
0.48180368542671204,
-0.35216036438941956,
0.027688508853316307,
0.37270984053611755,
0.09210891276597977,
-0.5628002882003784,
0.10619841516017914,
-0.2492106705904007,
-1.2483323812484741,
0.3259177803993225,
0.19310785830020905,
0.21788762509822845,
-0.3786568343639374,
-0.0409884974360466,
0.2642214894294739,
-0.014054673723876476,
-0.4187653064727783,
-0.3575734496116638,
-0.0030708929989486933,
0.2015308290719986,
-0.20972640812397003,
-0.39055871963500977,
-0.12789347767829895,
-0.9130429029464722,
0.6203276515007019,
0.27978459000587463,
1.0516787767410278,
0.45508554577827454,
0.07416600733995438,
-0.14720451831817627,
0.3395516574382782,
0.5595629811286926,
0.39984390139579773,
-0.4047243595123291,
0.2035643309354782,
0.08709847182035446,
-0.2400866448879242,
0.17613044381141663,
0.02905808761715889,
0.02193899266421795,
0.43402478098869324,
-0.008159549906849861,
0.702515184879303,
0.3514690101146698,
-0.02720460295677185,
0.6637162566184998,
-0.09360166639089584,
-0.41531506180763245,
-0.7074699997901917,
-0.43801671266555786,
0.30994269251823425,
0.07077501714229584,
0.3171875476837158,
0.061819206923246384,
0.021278874948620796,
0.15565209090709686,
0.2914656698703766,
0.2185000628232956,
-0.4357832074165344,
-0.5796488523483276,
0.5955539345741272,
0.43921878933906555,
-0.3127160668373108,
0.5903383493423462,
0.07205672562122345,
-0.22992876172065735,
0.5554322600364685,
0.802602231502533,
1.2013804912567139,
-0.5506890416145325,
0.053839780390262604,
0.04280119389295578,
-0.036042459309101105,
0.1657840460538864,
0.370012104511261,
-0.3979738652706146,
-0.48826584219932556,
-0.7241575121879578,
-0.5662039518356323,
-0.20366497337818146,
0.2450362741947174,
-0.5740225911140442,
0.2542823851108551,
-0.38980647921562195,
-0.3861906826496124,
-0.18609166145324707,
-0.5164017081260681,
-0.49906015396118164,
0.03554204851388931,
0.7252260446548462,
0.998277485370636,
-0.5149544477462769,
0.4727915823459625,
0.523044228553772,
0.14387433230876923,
-0.39165210723876953,
-0.29092809557914734,
-0.26690688729286194,
-0.21101617813110352,
0.09318586438894272,
0.4236873984336853,
-0.009413912892341614,
0.043381232768297195,
-0.4404449760913849,
-0.7836726307868958,
0.936571478843689,
0.3389141857624054,
-0.709424614906311,
-0.1548364907503128,
0.3251769542694092,
0.2315501719713211,
-0.16609349846839905,
0.45908981561660767,
0.34350624680519104,
0.34319987893104553,
-0.09037686884403229,
-1.0601012706756592,
-0.2914418578147888,
-0.572583794593811,
0.012156759388744831,
0.3750016987323761,
-0.4939362704753876,
0.8137642741203308,
0.009616832248866558,
-0.07418328523635864,
-0.07718527317047119,
0.7161042094230652,
-0.17554815113544464,
0.1931493729352951,
0.3856261670589447,
0.8515381813049316,
0.6634331941604614,
0.07194697111845016,
0.27423420548439026,
-0.3321722447872162,
0.3055345118045807,
0.8211851716041565,
-0.22226592898368835,
1.0111559629440308,
0.7409340143203735,
-0.5628760457038879,
0.3260659873485565,
0.535814106464386,
0.13478629291057587,
0.7916236519813538,
0.35881853103637695,
-0.5570479035377502,
-0.3473012149333954,
0.1296643763780594,
-0.8314933776855469,
0.801996111869812,
0.3853597342967987,
-0.1645234376192093,
-0.48550814390182495,
0.289316326379776,
-0.20339663326740265,
0.016529519110918045,
-0.26934000849723816,
0.6146029233932495,
0.4932006001472473,
-0.08345227688550949,
0.7158589959144592,
-0.007886562496423721,
1.0641597509384155,
-0.3918464779853821,
-0.06238225847482681,
-0.23507051169872284,
0.058429054915905,
-0.2834691107273102,
-0.008983851410448551,
0.15083329379558563,
-0.17411328852176666,
-0.4643113315105438,
-0.2363247126340866,
0.481081485748291,
-0.5433538556098938,
-0.2330019772052765,
0.8559746146202087,
0.7192382216453552,
0.082553930580616,
-0.12790364027023315,
0.01675298623740673,
-0.4101460576057434,
-0.13326549530029297,
-0.42102739214897156,
0.42586183547973633,
0.3843834698200226,
0.053657323122024536,
0.34357312321662903,
0.5143358111381531,
0.2787722945213318,
0.08970446139574051,
0.4671171009540558,
0.7363199591636658,
-0.6930745244026184,
-0.8354920148849487,
-0.8502238392829895,
0.26572999358177185,
0.02332765981554985,
0.013453374616801739,
0.4263255000114441,
0.7323450446128845,
0.8405240774154663,
-0.07648610323667526,
0.6683096885681152,
0.10769157856702805,
0.7705861926078796,
-0.37957337498664856,
0.8844881653785706,
-0.48096856474876404,
0.34676143527030945,
-0.17125868797302246,
-1.1309678554534912,
-0.4112936556339264,
0.4908269941806793,
-0.04362589120864868,
0.1630239337682724,
0.4138363003730774,
0.7548808455467224,
-0.2650725543498993,
0.2636089026927948,
0.8642911314964294,
0.20299334824085236,
0.4383561909198761,
0.47842851281166077,
0.8253198862075806,
-0.191035658121109,
0.32866212725639343,
-0.460883766412735,
-0.008353312499821186,
0.2555913031101227,
-0.7672062516212463,
-0.941874623298645,
-0.5229561924934387,
-0.38979148864746094,
0.16798081994056702,
0.06910034269094467,
1.1886974573135376,
0.6330012083053589,
-0.7998167872428894,
-0.15635094046592712,
-0.04433341696858406,
-0.2701391279697418,
-0.11653347313404083,
-0.16067764163017273,
0.7636272311210632,
-0.15654990077018738,
-0.42407846450805664,
1.1758143901824951,
0.23098790645599365,
0.13518641889095306,
0.12251494079828262,
-0.026153793558478355,
0.1646866351366043,
0.047471124678850174,
0.8542640805244446,
0.2326163798570633,
-0.3802770674228668,
-0.5474427342414856,
-0.08459223806858063,
0.33324527740478516,
0.46729233860969543,
0.42096638679504395,
-1.114835262298584,
0.5109155774116516,
0.4247474670410156,
0.35787534713745117,
0.4246841073036194,
-0.1656590700149536,
0.6175380349159241,
-1.1850016117095947,
0.36464571952819824,
0.3770698010921478,
0.5157223343849182,
0.3715779781341553,
-0.09357447922229767,
0.23369717597961426,
0.35509437322616577,
-0.5582801103591919,
-0.6200910210609436,
-0.11004692316055298,
-1.124544382095337,
-0.09241204708814621,
1.207175374031067,
-0.02403813600540161,
-0.13824450969696045,
-0.15074531733989716,
0.05671265348792076,
0.36507317423820496,
-0.35289761424064636,
0.5281237959861755,
0.37670570611953735,
-0.05989905819296837,
-0.05359412357211113,
-0.3315987288951874,
0.26632070541381836,
0.3620200455188751,
-0.3685746192932129,
0.11177901178598404,
0.40841394662857056,
0.08681672066450119,
0.18823324143886566,
0.5570329427719116,
-0.09601285308599472,
0.05911936238408089,
-0.1254805028438568,
0.3552681803703308,
-0.3404383659362793,
-0.5844038724899292,
-0.47562363743782043,
0.14991770684719086,
-0.18629087507724762,
-0.5007547736167908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18678v1 | Few-shot Personalization of LLMs with Mis-aligned Responses | 2024-06-26T18:29:12 | 2024-06-26T18:29:12 | Jaehyung Kim, Yiming Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | As the diversity of users increases, the capability of providing personalized
responses by large language models (LLMs) has become increasingly important.
Existing approaches have only limited successes in LLM personalization, due to
the absence of personalized learning or the reliance on shared personal data.
This paper proposes a new approach for a few-shot personalization of LLMs with
their mis-aligned responses (Fermi). Our key idea is to learn a set of
personalized prompts for each user by progressively improving the prompts using
LLMs, based on user profile (e.g., demographic information) and a few examples
of previous opinions. During an iterative process of prompt improvement, we
incorporate the contexts of mis-aligned responses by LLMs, which are especially
crucial for the effective personalization of LLMs. In addition, we develop an
effective inference method to further leverage the context of the test query
and the personalized prompts. Our experimental results demonstrate that Fermi
significantly improves performance across various benchmarks, compared to the
best-performing baselines. | [
-0.5807247757911682,
-0.9573931694030762,
0.6812053918838501,
-0.09682200103998184,
-0.028317991644144058,
0.3377731442451477,
-0.13640688359737396,
0.0330798476934433,
0.3404616415500641,
0.24081934988498688,
-0.903771698474884,
-0.5288529992103577,
-0.13779786229133606,
0.32834428548812866,
0.14711976051330566,
1.0021673440933228,
0.41225916147232056,
0.17651669681072235,
-0.19915322959423065,
0.01790722832083702,
-0.6880983114242554,
-0.2536470890045166,
-0.5814626812934875,
-0.4205607771873474,
0.9354687929153442,
0.7315908670425415,
0.615618884563446,
0.45234113931655884,
0.37208181619644165,
0.30513089895248413,
-0.2719418406486511,
0.19860237836837769,
-0.8161142468452454,
0.142063707113266,
-0.5098477602005005,
-0.3743419945240021,
-0.2610248327255249,
-0.2768004834651947,
0.7071475386619568,
0.8293809294700623,
-0.0008591398946009576,
-0.02684936299920082,
0.2713526785373688,
0.4060061275959015,
-0.7152281999588013,
-0.5316311120986938,
-0.45033177733421326,
0.06307820230722427,
-0.1899680197238922,
-0.3752581775188446,
-0.6133147478103638,
-0.6409862041473389,
0.021432410925626755,
-0.6752639412879944,
0.29827120900154114,
0.28908851742744446,
0.5520468950271606,
0.017858553677797318,
-0.3542168438434601,
-0.019572356715798378,
-0.9543362259864807,
0.9445630311965942,
-0.6217955350875854,
0.3753082752227783,
0.3807651102542877,
0.6337780952453613,
-0.4908459782600403,
-0.2663600742816925,
-0.39463865756988525,
-0.05027018114924431,
-0.25866860151290894,
0.243711456656456,
-0.2972792387008667,
-0.05548540875315666,
0.31006571650505066,
0.019066786393523216,
-0.762076735496521,
0.2625617980957031,
-0.2064332216978073,
-0.3236801028251648,
0.7119322419166565,
0.6120867133140564,
-0.14761000871658325,
-0.32522052526474,
-0.6268656253814697,
-0.06328240782022476,
-0.5742573142051697,
0.15200094878673553,
0.7845925688743591,
0.6241916418075562,
-0.10208937525749207,
0.662272572517395,
-0.41504302620887756,
0.8026190996170044,
0.5278093814849854,
-0.22891409695148468,
0.28469768166542053,
-0.2717230021953583,
-0.15409117937088013,
-0.0957871600985527,
0.9412063360214233,
0.18830005824565887,
0.24195729196071625,
-0.299136221408844,
-0.07145600765943527,
-0.28264516592025757,
0.08199950307607651,
-0.6591915488243103,
-0.023002861067652702,
0.2647082507610321,
-0.1660826951265335,
-0.18514834344387054,
-0.04230302944779396,
-1.113737940788269,
-0.7792863249778748,
-0.1854923516511917,
0.19804103672504425,
-0.5365322828292847,
0.05235288292169571,
-0.1164877638220787,
0.010899090208113194,
-0.02907765842974186,
0.6022640466690063,
-0.9178865551948547,
0.11286158859729767,
0.5604034066200256,
0.6246000528335571,
-0.14254355430603027,
-0.17228248715400696,
-0.8873071670532227,
0.0354345366358757,
-0.20291294157505035,
1.1537327766418457,
-0.9295417070388794,
-0.656019926071167,
0.037430424243211746,
-0.37051695585250854,
0.08466561138629913,
-0.5493583679199219,
0.23436421155929565,
-0.5834214687347412,
0.45208242535591125,
-0.7137592434883118,
-0.6979314684867859,
0.1874256730079651,
0.3557337522506714,
-0.2101508527994156,
0.9298611283302307,
0.10260744392871857,
-0.788109302520752,
0.17577964067459106,
-0.47439825534820557,
-0.1764237880706787,
0.191925510764122,
-0.4521346688270569,
-0.20509250462055206,
0.22478298842906952,
0.15819354355335236,
0.5736870169639587,
-0.1990559846162796,
0.18639153242111206,
-0.9860942363739014,
-0.5271450281143188,
0.4220764636993408,
-0.10531894862651825,
0.5761526823043823,
0.2978960871696472,
0.25332990288734436,
0.19182948768138885,
-0.5912818312644958,
-0.04254681244492531,
0.1320902407169342,
-0.42661237716674805,
-0.2673831582069397,
-0.21153557300567627,
-0.1707056313753128,
-0.026730580255389214,
0.2712179720401764,
-0.5313138961791992,
0.40167608857154846,
-0.6589308977127075,
-0.06110364571213722,
1.3018802404403687,
0.1399560272693634,
0.7363974452018738,
-0.5828386545181274,
0.6487017869949341,
0.13434728980064392,
-0.10572453588247299,
-0.3716993033885956,
-0.2537275552749634,
-0.4091968536376953,
-0.3780378997325897,
0.17321108281612396,
0.7128223776817322,
-0.5759056210517883,
0.33322715759277344,
-0.28175970911979675,
-0.1705993115901947,
-0.237029030919075,
0.6840692162513733,
0.2698849141597748,
0.6078584790229797,
0.19294708967208862,
-0.009425148367881775,
-0.37844961881637573,
-1.037773847579956,
-0.48270049691200256,
-0.2941036522388458,
-0.11919254064559937,
0.630908191204071,
0.2753639221191406,
-0.3215104937553406,
1.2363392114639282,
-0.9275373816490173,
-0.18430037796497345,
-0.2957201600074768,
0.010153048671782017,
0.3475957214832306,
0.30048680305480957,
0.3203987777233124,
-0.36188051104545593,
-0.4067983627319336,
0.17468413710594177,
-0.4726736545562744,
-0.2319178581237793,
-0.14391081035137177,
-0.4645201563835144,
-0.27669772505760193,
0.24251599609851837,
-0.1341148167848587,
0.03214465454220772,
0.1827894151210785,
-0.2675487995147705,
0.21939747035503387,
0.1432448774576187,
0.04054560139775276,
-1.4834989309310913,
-0.03187722712755203,
0.33127886056900024,
-0.5167608857154846,
-0.6540498733520508,
-0.3131214380264282,
-0.18824999034404755,
0.02442571520805359,
-0.5753136277198792,
1.003527045249939,
-0.029633639380335808,
-0.019215190783143044,
-0.3682076632976532,
0.21811820566654205,
-0.3153558671474457,
0.6451292037963867,
-0.2860077917575836,
0.6805186867713928,
0.15938039124011993,
-0.5799647569656372,
0.28011828660964966,
0.5441133975982666,
0.05812942609190941,
0.9700629711151123,
-0.4474659860134125,
0.4467926025390625,
-0.521569013595581,
0.16093604266643524,
-1.2618118524551392,
-0.6124812364578247,
0.4230453073978424,
-0.38726210594177246,
0.08129272609949112,
-0.007699534296989441,
-0.44102418422698975,
0.01455681398510933,
-0.5439506769180298,
0.10282769054174423,
0.40358036756515503,
-0.6623579859733582,
0.8420324325561523,
-0.1738470494747162,
-0.02598576433956623,
-0.6548631191253662,
-0.24737659096717834,
-0.3769283592700958,
-0.42354732751846313,
-0.6332642436027527,
0.27867192029953003,
-0.4633381962776184,
-0.12284857779741287,
-0.120425745844841,
0.0003648298734333366,
0.0717896968126297,
0.22636739909648895,
0.2661730945110321,
0.11720853298902512,
-0.249306321144104,
0.39998117089271545,
0.13938511908054352,
-0.16739116609096527,
-0.41153067350387573,
0.295255571603775,
0.6571800708770752,
-0.05834542587399483,
-0.18108920753002167,
-0.6580592393875122,
0.40935540199279785,
-0.08452159911394119,
0.09021160006523132,
0.49222496151924133,
0.5875115394592285,
-0.5249941945075989,
-0.21355068683624268,
-0.5902189016342163,
-0.5310831665992737,
-0.5415446162223816,
-0.044191811233758926,
-0.5951864719390869,
-1.2258144617080688,
0.5773423314094543,
-0.5169112086296082,
0.23575465381145477,
0.13000807166099548,
0.6086779832839966,
-0.6659377813339233,
1.1142085790634155,
0.6707818508148193,
-0.18421438336372375,
0.6983628869056702,
-0.0037493580020964146,
0.014982229098677635,
-0.8247079253196716,
-0.10978090018033981,
-0.5326034426689148,
-0.5333690643310547,
-0.4479465186595917,
0.10944975167512894,
0.3008880615234375,
0.25744834542274475,
-0.5062497854232788,
0.1774863749742508,
-0.09200213849544525,
0.5928815007209778,
0.45916861295700073,
0.39108628034591675,
0.23858557641506195,
0.06734123080968857,
-0.31438878178596497,
-0.1670260727405548,
-0.6289612054824829,
-0.5920255184173584,
0.8296854496002197,
0.3340699374675751,
1.3076690435409546,
0.4096822142601013,
1.0479557514190674,
0.314375638961792,
0.3574146032333374,
-0.623797595500946,
0.36893215775489807,
-0.0000025378824375366094,
-0.7879835367202759,
-0.12921731173992157,
-0.5726984739303589,
-0.8017607927322388,
0.3114394247531891,
-0.5540051460266113,
-1.1444337368011475,
0.33170706033706665,
0.5767582654953003,
-0.9977437853813171,
-0.20381300151348114,
-0.7357031106948853,
0.7622008323669434,
-0.15367509424686432,
-0.6403073668479919,
0.1380346268415451,
-0.48783108592033386,
0.4180510342121124,
-0.30543696880340576,
-0.07357732951641083,
-0.3223162591457367,
-0.013296333141624928,
0.41756725311279297,
-0.1631050556898117,
1.3007010221481323,
-0.034427110105752945,
0.15734650194644928,
-0.16546539962291718,
-0.061622198671102524,
0.695315420627594,
0.2693687081336975,
-0.18202732503414154,
-0.2377786636352539,
-0.2886049449443817,
-0.43908998370170593,
-0.7991983294487,
0.8437790274620056,
-0.5604616403579712,
-0.8752885460853577,
-0.4067383408546448,
-0.40405529737472534,
-0.504135012626648,
0.18495121598243713,
0.4546066224575043,
0.12274160981178284,
-0.4993078112602234,
-0.029743999242782593,
0.7107776999473572,
-0.30907902121543884,
0.35247915983200073,
0.4343457520008087,
-0.30495572090148926,
-0.6455361247062683,
0.5472897291183472,
-0.23934118449687958,
0.12472598254680634,
0.46837952733039856,
0.6548513174057007,
-0.39741653203964233,
-0.07908696681261063,
-0.3932022452354431,
0.47379809617996216,
-0.8033408522605896,
-0.46527382731437683,
-0.6882648468017578,
0.35262027382850647,
-0.5026782155036926,
-0.561894416809082,
-0.1201372742652893,
0.06182814761996269,
-0.6289653778076172,
0.04271218553185463,
0.311518132686615,
0.44789332151412964,
0.20713792741298676,
1.0220885276794434,
-0.6387455463409424,
0.35441136360168457,
0.23263221979141235,
0.1686994880437851,
-0.30541756749153137,
-0.5700544714927673,
0.040004514157772064,
0.0010893511353060603,
-0.5407084226608276,
-1.1844756603240967,
-0.10760603100061417,
0.2293693870306015,
0.6149749755859375,
0.6390987038612366,
0.1637425720691681,
1.0437084436416626,
-0.5097783803939819,
0.49173176288604736,
0.30825290083885193,
-0.9346963167190552,
0.6526974439620972,
-0.2174018919467926,
0.5604583024978638,
0.8282057046890259,
0.3941574990749359,
-0.49925175309181213,
-0.3246481716632843,
-0.4464483857154846,
-0.3121764063835144,
0.8083327412605286,
0.04787599295377731,
0.5912707448005676,
0.1369316726922989,
0.43251296877861023,
0.06031166762113571,
0.018915003165602684,
-0.4074677526950836,
-0.22438189387321472,
0.24689365923404694,
-0.42023855447769165,
-0.14795859158039093,
-0.18338748812675476,
-0.2611859142780304,
-0.005223446059972048,
0.7575546503067017,
-0.49379995465278625,
0.1063593402504921,
0.023979175835847855,
0.0022728845942765474,
-0.2806808352470398,
0.46176233887672424,
0.6529318690299988,
0.5893453359603882,
-0.17765243351459503,
0.09271258860826492,
0.5222326517105103,
0.055999815464019775,
0.27308112382888794,
-0.017518484964966774,
-0.1426001936197281,
0.03291960060596466,
0.34720829129219055,
0.7216194272041321,
0.23029671609401703,
-0.4464159905910492,
0.5798181891441345,
-0.04880034178495407,
0.12517747282981873,
-0.15015137195587158,
0.35195887088775635,
0.14991141855716705,
0.5407819151878357,
0.19455327093601227,
-0.0845072939991951,
0.10656832158565521,
-0.4104444682598114,
0.1200581043958664,
0.6109830737113953,
-0.1667698621749878,
-0.37343165278434753,
0.6579623818397522,
0.27648937702178955,
-0.25893861055374146,
0.26011189818382263,
-0.20527978241443634,
-0.20804284512996674,
0.07688159495592117,
0.5759468078613281,
0.9201696515083313,
-0.5163241028785706,
0.3596872389316559,
0.5049418210983276,
0.14604322612285614,
0.13235348463058472,
0.2820785641670227,
-0.08611461520195007,
-0.8406848311424255,
-0.22917383909225464,
-0.5077694058418274,
-0.40269893407821655,
0.08277618885040283,
-0.42759355902671814,
0.7181569337844849,
-0.9423867464065552,
-0.5037815570831299,
0.40215614438056946,
-0.15446354448795319,
-0.6923009157180786,
0.10678320378065109,
-0.02018917165696621,
0.5962539315223694,
-0.9676880240440369,
0.5699066519737244,
0.988014280796051,
-0.3059762716293335,
-0.32701489329338074,
0.0163178201764822,
0.4048011898994446,
-0.5780039429664612,
0.596599817276001,
-0.049405571073293686,
-0.2608751058578491,
-0.01650719717144966,
-0.4645825922489166,
-0.6597729921340942,
0.8865419626235962,
0.7321292161941528,
-0.8462135195732117,
0.15873894095420837,
0.11269547045230865,
0.3864704668521881,
-0.4463357925415039,
0.25715208053588867,
0.39266514778137207,
0.24307632446289062,
0.2729644179344177,
-0.4786835312843323,
-0.06838323175907135,
0.11375562101602554,
0.33807167410850525,
0.33594900369644165,
-0.5347410440444946,
0.4811691343784332,
-0.3400489389896393,
-0.4169771671295166,
-0.021832183003425598,
1.0046947002410889,
0.42284315824508667,
0.5274783372879028,
0.6053482890129089,
0.3697080612182617,
0.8582347631454468,
-0.002460762858390808,
0.8911149501800537,
0.00180335552431643,
0.5550300478935242,
1.429746389389038,
-0.4459051489830017,
0.7113600969314575,
0.48787176609039307,
-0.08687835931777954,
0.1620747596025467,
0.7636883854866028,
0.134348526597023,
0.4581097662448883,
0.17228160798549652,
-0.4317762553691864,
-0.6067437529563904,
-0.13104552030563354,
-0.12649089097976685,
0.20516295731067657,
0.020690588280558586,
-0.4378845691680908,
-0.4955926835536957,
0.1316693276166916,
0.14186790585517883,
0.30367955565452576,
0.1070156916975975,
0.9889668226242065,
0.049303241074085236,
-0.3353067636489868,
0.434268981218338,
0.12538573145866394,
0.718703031539917,
-0.4782555401325226,
0.01668633706867695,
-0.61163330078125,
0.11723692715167999,
-0.49341124296188354,
-0.6566575169563293,
0.08224640041589737,
0.37554821372032166,
-0.3834417760372162,
-0.11530324071645737,
0.6541358828544617,
-0.3674541711807251,
-0.5075365900993347,
0.07981810718774796,
0.4773447513580322,
0.11563711613416672,
0.2883593440055847,
-0.5748235583305359,
0.06700228899717331,
0.16285979747772217,
-0.19207236170768738,
0.1473931074142456,
-0.0777604877948761,
-0.030163872987031937,
0.6290969252586365,
0.7342836260795593,
-0.23643197119235992,
0.11881545931100845,
-0.026579348370432854,
0.8718628287315369,
-0.8275197148323059,
-0.35305383801460266,
-1.100027084350586,
0.5367089509963989,
-0.06764000654220581,
-0.5618683099746704,
0.6669270992279053,
0.7076570391654968,
0.9517586827278137,
-0.06858422607183456,
0.8163846731185913,
0.355680912733078,
0.7109778523445129,
-0.575463056564331,
0.13253876566886902,
-0.642877459526062,
0.497001975774765,
-0.3431386947631836,
-1.1563336849212646,
-0.1955728530883789,
0.5013798475265503,
-0.31947192549705505,
0.19818568229675293,
0.46461284160614014,
0.9335665106773376,
-0.22920602560043335,
-0.0589849129319191,
0.547662079334259,
-0.056655243039131165,
0.33715274930000305,
0.5444284081459045,
0.9489005208015442,
-0.20335820317268372,
0.2856771945953369,
-0.5254656076431274,
-0.1511864811182022,
-0.42864730954170227,
-0.72386634349823,
-1.0131293535232544,
-0.41451364755630493,
-0.4705629050731659,
-0.2943677604198456,
0.0011440510861575603,
1.2495675086975098,
0.41110002994537354,
-0.686841607093811,
-0.133540078997612,
0.4028503894805908,
0.2022555023431778,
0.142850860953331,
-0.18342486023902893,
0.004157036077231169,
-0.34142327308654785,
-0.944511890411377,
0.3783615231513977,
0.14217953383922577,
0.15587016940116882,
-0.1754738688468933,
-0.23438459634780884,
-0.02961139567196369,
0.2862170338630676,
0.46654489636421204,
0.2607940137386322,
-0.837887704372406,
-0.3988417387008667,
0.26985496282577515,
-0.22787690162658691,
0.2043420821428299,
0.7109737992286682,
-0.6282963752746582,
0.6399497389793396,
0.7982840538024902,
0.8144335150718689,
0.21272195875644684,
0.524295449256897,
0.42771631479263306,
-1.0730781555175781,
-0.1984662562608719,
0.2336774468421936,
0.3067111074924469,
0.45748984813690186,
-0.6845501661300659,
0.2382042557001114,
0.09411508589982986,
-0.2687758505344391,
-0.7875704765319824,
0.35852494835853577,
-1.0937588214874268,
-0.21403853595256805,
1.340728521347046,
-0.044095490127801895,
-0.06156707927584648,
0.1491776704788208,
-0.22332434356212616,
-0.07898831367492676,
-0.7240391969680786,
0.5274978280067444,
0.8181266188621521,
-0.44239529967308044,
-0.1502601057291031,
-0.2988441586494446,
0.1608143150806427,
0.4992353320121765,
-0.9670501947402954,
-0.16728262603282928,
0.7729961276054382,
0.5054168105125427,
0.16352994740009308,
0.7405855655670166,
0.30849015712738037,
0.215290829539299,
-0.5807152390480042,
-0.1850588321685791,
0.16068479418754578,
-0.24532531201839447,
-0.7782812714576721,
0.17449980974197388,
0.03694961965084076,
-0.19518403708934784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18676v1 | Understand What LLM Needs: Dual Preference Alignment for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-26T18:26:53 | 2024-06-26T18:26:53 | Guanting Dong, Yutao Zhu, Chenghao Zhang, Zechen Wang, Zhicheng Dou, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has demonstrated effectiveness in
mitigating the hallucination problem of large language models (LLMs). However,
the difficulty of aligning the retriever with the diverse LLMs' knowledge
preferences inevitably poses an inevitable challenge in developing a reliable
RAG system. To address this issue, we propose DPA-RAG, a universal framework
designed to align diverse knowledge preferences within RAG systems.
Specifically, we initially introduce a preference knowledge construction
pipline and incorporate five novel query augmentation strategies to alleviate
preference data scarcity. Based on preference data, DPA-RAG accomplishes both
external and internal preference alignment: 1) It jointly integrate pair-wise,
point-wise, and contrastive preference alignment abilities into the reranker,
achieving external preference alignment among RAG components. 2) It further
introduces a pre-aligned stage before vanilla Supervised Fine-tuning (SFT),
enabling LLMs to implicitly capture knowledge aligned with their reasoning
preferences, achieving LLMs' internal alignment. Experimental results across
four knowledge-intensive QA datasets demonstrate that DPA-RAG outperforms all
baselines and seamlessly integrates both black-box and open-sourced LLM
readers. Further qualitative analysis and discussions also provide empirical
guidance for achieving reliable RAG systems. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/dongguanting/DPA-RAG. | [
-0.4757578670978546,
-0.2921484112739563,
0.6791808605194092,
0.019828079268336296,
-0.20663459599018097,
0.4236169159412384,
-0.10314379632472992,
-0.41793134808540344,
0.343483030796051,
0.6388114094734192,
-0.24344274401664734,
-0.2447422444820404,
-0.4076102375984192,
-0.06387928128242493,
0.025092007592320442,
1.0291399955749512,
-0.02791067585349083,
-0.07470761239528656,
-0.4154464900493622,
-0.2702111303806305,
-0.570241391658783,
-0.4478483200073242,
-0.45094746351242065,
-0.4368067681789398,
0.7402203679084778,
0.5485486388206482,
0.7783000469207764,
0.5936160683631897,
0.5309045910835266,
0.1839495301246643,
-0.12672363221645355,
0.8577171564102173,
-0.5610039234161377,
0.47863900661468506,
-0.32316669821739197,
-0.27645495533943176,
-0.6171435713768005,
-0.10391183197498322,
0.49733465909957886,
0.40279245376586914,
0.014648309908807278,
0.2639109492301941,
0.12890467047691345,
1.0990103483200073,
-0.6897062063217163,
-0.25542399287223816,
-0.8974425792694092,
-0.20288324356079102,
-0.24203771352767944,
-0.37036532163619995,
-0.28523895144462585,
-0.34599700570106506,
-0.026467464864253998,
-0.6794946789741516,
0.01751910150051117,
0.26497137546539307,
0.9859941601753235,
0.7167854309082031,
-0.7216724157333374,
-0.23663511872291565,
-0.6661834716796875,
0.7235527634620667,
-0.3160102665424347,
0.3582453727722168,
0.32016584277153015,
0.4048614799976349,
-0.47059404850006104,
-0.36271214485168457,
-0.7299344539642334,
-0.13315556943416595,
-0.15556536614894867,
0.09072649478912354,
0.25117287039756775,
-0.0448438934981823,
-0.028477489948272705,
0.5498055219650269,
-0.5264635682106018,
0.17484690248966217,
-0.1360059380531311,
0.08381665498018265,
0.6931557059288025,
0.05795911327004433,
0.12987026572227478,
-0.17249277234077454,
-0.4838687777519226,
0.044703248888254166,
-0.7697931528091431,
-0.14623688161373138,
0.6468056440353394,
0.39936670660972595,
0.15508723258972168,
0.734896719455719,
-0.14435751736164093,
0.7879406809806824,
0.5036914348602295,
-0.28158074617385864,
0.33188414573669434,
-0.09664644300937653,
-0.01646088808774948,
-0.034970398992300034,
0.6214346289634705,
0.3628480136394501,
0.05130302160978317,
-0.3200279772281647,
-0.30769243836402893,
0.03937460482120514,
0.5481393337249756,
-0.4184890687465668,
0.06043751910328865,
0.37478095293045044,
-0.09542098641395569,
-0.38192421197891235,
-0.20268435776233673,
-0.9371072053909302,
-0.8107032775878906,
-0.6961236596107483,
0.4984659254550934,
-0.1174752488732338,
-0.3724193871021271,
0.05521383509039879,
-0.1517464518547058,
0.2743196487426758,
0.09564337134361267,
-1.0039647817611694,
0.09152872860431671,
0.921383798122406,
0.46713292598724365,
-0.47231200337409973,
-0.0401344820857048,
-0.4963396489620209,
0.33482682704925537,
-0.22426341474056244,
0.8616584539413452,
-0.49890485405921936,
-0.07860691100358963,
-0.21089111268520355,
-0.22252479195594788,
0.15407121181488037,
-0.5782896280288696,
0.7106225490570068,
-0.8567373156547546,
0.2809200584888458,
-0.37794795632362366,
-0.5615730285644531,
0.09764160960912704,
0.30446091294288635,
-0.5156070590019226,
1.0071369409561157,
0.1072508692741394,
-0.9294232130050659,
0.5704972147941589,
-0.25337299704551697,
-0.03981148079037666,
-0.13175204396247864,
-0.3341403007507324,
-0.2622975707054138,
0.14232812821865082,
0.27465716004371643,
0.15820616483688354,
-0.3544769585132599,
0.46597832441329956,
-0.3658622205257416,
-0.3837828040122986,
0.12956558167934418,
-0.270574688911438,
0.633425235748291,
0.34410274028778076,
-0.1764252632856369,
0.01565689779818058,
-0.7495131492614746,
-0.06935032457113266,
0.17710620164871216,
-0.2619595527648926,
-0.5446919202804565,
-0.1040075272321701,
-0.3219093382358551,
0.16230905055999756,
0.591975212097168,
-0.42575088143348694,
0.5981903672218323,
-0.46814125776290894,
-0.3083362877368927,
1.0564708709716797,
-0.24850726127624512,
0.717946469783783,
-0.5667193531990051,
0.45037931203842163,
-0.13885986804962158,
-0.045187413692474365,
0.3719239830970764,
-0.23538236320018768,
-0.7542012333869934,
-0.3381391167640686,
0.26658183336257935,
0.42754289507865906,
-0.6027684211730957,
0.6247169971466064,
-0.36212003231048584,
-0.2905937135219574,
-0.6779981851577759,
0.22689181566238403,
0.4503001570701599,
0.7060959935188293,
0.37160974740982056,
-0.022441890090703964,
-0.7358424067497253,
-0.9181811809539795,
-0.06268244236707687,
-0.09569480270147324,
0.006610593292862177,
0.5125685334205627,
-0.10938684642314911,
-0.34038063883781433,
1.0227965116500854,
-0.5671982765197754,
-0.43730753660202026,
-0.06126183643937111,
-0.2965618073940277,
0.37657883763313293,
0.3036031723022461,
0.34914445877075195,
-0.976763129234314,
-0.6164883375167847,
0.21845290064811707,
-0.5210310220718384,
-0.28091534972190857,
0.24779027700424194,
-0.5620860457420349,
0.45535001158714294,
-0.06227647513151169,
-0.40300077199935913,
0.09847172349691391,
0.7689194679260254,
-0.3021188974380493,
0.487391859292984,
-0.15749013423919678,
0.24395130574703217,
-1.3865703344345093,
0.19880425930023193,
-0.2250368744134903,
-0.06803259253501892,
-0.3955347537994385,
0.09629327803850174,
0.020812882110476494,
0.223760724067688,
-0.003895706031471491,
0.9431200623512268,
-0.43373262882232666,
-0.2168595939874649,
-0.4213612377643585,
0.20208881795406342,
0.27910274267196655,
0.3172972500324249,
0.02199612744152546,
0.9697925448417664,
0.08914719521999359,
-0.6432516574859619,
0.21046622097492218,
0.3351782560348511,
0.041186705231666565,
0.5944150686264038,
-0.298583984375,
0.334197461605072,
-0.1116151437163353,
0.14107148349285126,
-0.8279550075531006,
-0.3460564911365509,
0.20147550106048584,
-0.45501622557640076,
0.7188662886619568,
-0.3893708884716034,
-0.22637279331684113,
-0.21820637583732605,
-0.2442178577184677,
0.4669404625892639,
0.6038194894790649,
-0.9887626767158508,
0.6230403184890747,
0.8422492742538452,
0.10737940669059753,
-1.2345565557479858,
-0.10331330448389053,
-0.07967744767665863,
-0.42101144790649414,
-0.720109760761261,
0.5283547639846802,
-0.10440938919782639,
-0.35052570700645447,
-0.12684710323810577,
-0.37419456243515015,
-0.020924029871821404,
-0.08291476964950562,
0.11361409723758698,
0.4557817876338959,
0.037295758724212646,
0.29779133200645447,
0.11585643142461777,
-0.20800596475601196,
-0.4369451403617859,
-0.3227151930332184,
0.6447225213050842,
0.03472604975104332,
-0.30478936433792114,
0.14159032702445984,
0.1477862447500229,
0.44097214937210083,
-0.2201501578092575,
0.41244903206825256,
0.4068593978881836,
-0.008541618473827839,
-0.3203028440475464,
-0.9773061871528625,
0.005875217728316784,
-0.4547801613807678,
-0.06644520163536072,
-0.5434713363647461,
-0.964452862739563,
0.35996660590171814,
0.09750909358263016,
0.21147094666957855,
0.355614572763443,
0.4896271824836731,
-0.18208621442317963,
0.9168534874916077,
0.71882164478302,
-0.02585914544761181,
0.20046035945415497,
0.08596004545688629,
0.09909949451684952,
-1.1478861570358276,
-0.08053659647703171,
-0.43694373965263367,
-0.4313041865825653,
-0.5967702269554138,
-0.4900902509689331,
0.46198195219039917,
0.10572583228349686,
-0.2981370985507965,
-0.009562870487570763,
-0.9161531925201416,
0.5024990439414978,
0.45722976326942444,
-0.10122819244861603,
0.5381633043289185,
0.17373791337013245,
-0.1097787544131279,
-0.14500311017036438,
-0.42236271500587463,
-0.6706834435462952,
1.258888840675354,
0.18168765306472778,
0.8166372776031494,
0.23030517995357513,
1.1212961673736572,
0.032413456588983536,
0.18000920116901398,
-0.7746598124504089,
0.3168011009693146,
-0.5262666344642639,
-0.6552578210830688,
-0.18747079372406006,
-0.4533497989177704,
-1.006789207458496,
0.31873053312301636,
-0.19895657896995544,
-0.4526446759700775,
0.3218495547771454,
0.4328535199165344,
-0.29649677872657776,
0.21999260783195496,
-0.4398796558380127,
0.5217581987380981,
-0.4484013617038727,
-0.5075038075447083,
-0.069874607026577,
-0.5471218228340149,
0.6678780913352966,
-0.22387312352657318,
0.04087960347533226,
-0.322012335062027,
-0.2590899169445038,
0.3387562334537506,
-0.10565131157636642,
0.553195595741272,
-0.10738269239664078,
-0.32329097390174866,
-0.06979507207870483,
-0.036231525242328644,
0.43294039368629456,
0.13110314309597015,
-0.14135153591632843,
-0.12387079745531082,
-0.10382569581270218,
-0.18811854720115662,
-0.6871568560600281,
0.8515484929084778,
-0.7793205380439758,
-0.8705865144729614,
-0.5287562012672424,
-0.7973435521125793,
-0.5265592336654663,
0.07320445775985718,
-0.024262351915240288,
0.13891199231147766,
-0.0659056082367897,
-0.08796987682580948,
0.9449737071990967,
-0.1094505786895752,
-0.19157074391841888,
0.6282649636268616,
-0.5914045572280884,
-0.5295947790145874,
1.099612832069397,
0.04941468685865402,
0.19285599887371063,
0.47264477610588074,
0.27132710814476013,
-0.4346347749233246,
-0.4712762236595154,
-0.6244145035743713,
0.35016897320747375,
-0.4124910533428192,
-0.4003540277481079,
-0.8092474341392517,
-0.2089836746454239,
-0.5790146589279175,
-0.1832655966281891,
-0.35748687386512756,
-0.6050357818603516,
-0.256465345621109,
0.11036209017038345,
0.4649049937725067,
0.6723913550376892,
-0.18849687278270721,
-0.16151854395866394,
-0.7026321887969971,
0.7367148995399475,
0.40829476714134216,
0.5336639881134033,
-0.3652958869934082,
-0.7865481972694397,
0.009488341398537159,
-0.04027513787150383,
-0.28708383440971375,
-0.5767143964767456,
0.37400612235069275,
-0.14354291558265686,
0.6712038516998291,
0.10853797197341919,
0.21288752555847168,
0.7083582878112793,
-0.4547892212867737,
0.4445878267288208,
-0.07496657222509384,
-0.504719614982605,
0.38653621077537537,
-0.38985058665275574,
-0.05100266635417938,
0.8298388123512268,
0.3827303647994995,
-0.33536118268966675,
-0.3217657506465912,
-0.44029664993286133,
-0.9185218214988708,
0.5351862907409668,
-0.3066636621952057,
-0.0165504552423954,
0.09763867408037186,
0.42083725333213806,
0.32574665546417236,
0.12684093415737152,
-0.4069560468196869,
-0.27266252040863037,
0.028537359088659286,
-0.392560750246048,
0.025298405438661575,
-0.5061426162719727,
-0.4146313965320587,
0.009441455826163292,
0.8869405388832092,
-0.29901570081710815,
-0.19711846113204956,
0.019214101135730743,
0.1157846450805664,
-0.14194227755069733,
0.31676122546195984,
0.31206047534942627,
0.7348757982254028,
-0.4146828353404999,
0.09837847948074341,
-0.09166139364242554,
-0.3079562485218048,
0.4351544678211212,
0.2827529013156891,
-0.4232608377933502,
-0.2886520326137543,
-0.29038840532302856,
0.47881224751472473,
-0.01613137312233448,
-0.39927688241004944,
0.3293255865573883,
-0.13328847289085388,
0.01995059847831726,
-0.3023276627063751,
0.049940869212150574,
0.012760734185576439,
0.13407324254512787,
0.352485328912735,
-0.08557680249214172,
0.09859995543956757,
-0.2121744155883789,
0.33348795771598816,
0.6879231929779053,
-0.15986306965351105,
0.025396788492798805,
0.45809608697891235,
0.2738207280635834,
0.04494915157556534,
0.3231699764728546,
-0.3749920427799225,
-0.32726237177848816,
0.31336450576782227,
0.5325430631637573,
0.8398951888084412,
-0.07751061767339706,
0.18448877334594727,
0.29276955127716064,
0.12709735333919525,
-0.12771916389465332,
0.2430030107498169,
0.014822895638644695,
-0.8863195180892944,
-0.4596123993396759,
-1.0578349828720093,
-0.49966028332710266,
-0.12031139433383942,
-0.5463055968284607,
0.27837494015693665,
-0.1950872242450714,
-0.08091732114553452,
-0.2889401316642761,
0.26406028866767883,
-0.5343385934829712,
0.04672187194228172,
0.06013187766075134,
0.5684735178947449,
-0.46841561794281006,
0.9031252264976501,
0.6986975073814392,
-0.5285677909851074,
-0.9086988568305969,
0.07204738259315491,
0.20094026625156403,
-0.9415081739425659,
0.6634061932563782,
-0.058615826070308685,
-0.20758287608623505,
-0.08314536511898041,
-0.24566110968589783,
-1.1046075820922852,
1.1360602378845215,
0.4355553388595581,
-0.5819735527038574,
-0.17402903735637665,
-0.0907711386680603,
0.5184179544448853,
-0.3841211199760437,
-0.029497234150767326,
0.6991747617721558,
0.5120688080787659,
0.4122520089149475,
-1.0598809719085693,
-0.0554283931851387,
-0.02219339646399021,
-0.18651482462882996,
0.4490930140018463,
-0.8348156809806824,
0.4727412462234497,
-0.13360340893268585,
-0.23402374982833862,
0.014364692382514477,
0.5683550238609314,
0.7266129851341248,
0.3324702978134155,
0.5103012919425964,
0.9724571108818054,
0.9190097451210022,
0.05655879154801369,
0.9148932099342346,
-0.3502652049064636,
-0.12866751849651337,
1.3218610286712646,
-0.39781853556632996,
0.7389497756958008,
0.7345846891403198,
-0.09844476729631424,
0.2925439178943634,
0.3185175657272339,
0.2798652648925781,
0.3805435299873352,
0.08980685472488403,
-0.29433971643447876,
-0.18502454459667206,
-0.4308132231235504,
-0.4974100887775421,
0.5341845750808716,
0.25854799151420593,
-0.07655099779367447,
0.140263631939888,
-0.34789302945137024,
-0.1192716434597969,
0.2503928244113922,
-0.13355354964733124,
1.0342247486114502,
0.014777838252484798,
-0.9290484189987183,
0.6932901740074158,
-0.47010743618011475,
1.0129625797271729,
-0.5357081890106201,
-0.002934063319116831,
-0.41744381189346313,
0.18297725915908813,
-0.33171236515045166,
-0.8766056299209595,
0.33643946051597595,
-0.04094830900430679,
-0.42607811093330383,
-0.10723502933979034,
0.8093958497047424,
-0.6009437441825867,
-0.27465200424194336,
0.3117179870605469,
0.5414141416549683,
0.06671486049890518,
0.1560477763414383,
-0.4970327913761139,
0.1631573736667633,
0.17164303362369537,
-0.17695088684558868,
0.7776201963424683,
0.4670928716659546,
0.059595584869384766,
0.4822525680065155,
0.605845034122467,
0.24482350051403046,
-0.08060388267040253,
0.1574094146490097,
1.0308034420013428,
-0.3788805902004242,
0.024913229048252106,
-0.4623981714248657,
0.6351497769355774,
-0.23514710366725922,
-0.13951420783996582,
0.7698842883110046,
0.510886549949646,
0.6624745726585388,
0.19284440577030182,
0.6118931770324707,
-0.05564962700009346,
0.8473119735717773,
-0.41565045714378357,
0.6838458180427551,
-0.8675782084465027,
0.3922911286354065,
-0.05790086090564728,
-1.1301745176315308,
-0.24079030752182007,
0.25276660919189453,
-0.1472187042236328,
-0.1892891824245453,
0.3402526080608368,
1.0393282175064087,
-0.14840003848075867,
-0.4892800748348236,
0.3554198145866394,
-0.194754958152771,
0.37200918793678284,
0.3548274636268616,
0.7512756586074829,
-0.10421102494001389,
0.6365060210227966,
-0.3585820198059082,
-0.37498724460601807,
-0.05004673823714256,
-0.8847869634628296,
-0.5800434947013855,
-0.5593796968460083,
-0.003729536896571517,
-0.41365110874176025,
0.14049243927001953,
0.9591670036315918,
0.40441206097602844,
-0.6292833089828491,
-0.152812659740448,
0.25720736384391785,
0.37617433071136475,
0.13196319341659546,
-0.23780761659145355,
0.34920331835746765,
-0.8545990586280823,
-0.8572142124176025,
0.5589756965637207,
0.3130978047847748,
-0.0465330109000206,
-0.28705814480781555,
-0.1647704392671585,
-0.13951735198497772,
0.00977583508938551,
0.33398517966270447,
0.4133457541465759,
-0.8170928359031677,
-0.2599702775478363,
0.09464888274669647,
-0.2558021545410156,
0.14272503554821014,
0.6582897901535034,
-0.802352786064148,
0.6767700910568237,
0.6011271476745605,
0.9586465954780579,
0.2633306086063385,
0.26798564195632935,
0.7478976845741272,
-0.7862673401832581,
0.06025855243206024,
0.45774704217910767,
0.2033831775188446,
0.3483947813510895,
-0.5987516641616821,
0.7261949777603149,
-0.09895732253789902,
-1.1834473609924316,
-0.930908203125,
0.3567890226840973,
-1.0005677938461304,
-0.07251584529876709,
1.3123382329940796,
0.21170267462730408,
-0.011630243621766567,
-0.27722546458244324,
-0.43001386523246765,
0.16649088263511658,
-0.460325688123703,
0.99029541015625,
0.377349853515625,
-0.13205362856388092,
0.13843750953674316,
-0.27851051092147827,
0.7984319925308228,
0.5276774168014526,
-0.5945767164230347,
0.19362249970436096,
0.8183997869491577,
0.09381097555160522,
0.3206081986427307,
0.8247829675674438,
-0.16476257145404816,
0.08395718783140182,
-0.2447991520166397,
0.21243005990982056,
-0.12328993529081345,
-0.3356800079345703,
-0.352215051651001,
0.11888525635004044,
0.34134817123413086,
0.013957822695374489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18675v1 | Human-AI Collaborative Taxonomy Construction: A Case Study in Profession-Specific Writing Assistants | 2024-06-26T18:25:06 | 2024-06-26T18:25:06 | Minhwa Lee, Zae Myung Kim, Vivek A. Khetan, Dongyeop Kang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have assisted humans in several writing tasks,
including text revision and story generation. However, their effectiveness in
supporting domain-specific writing, particularly in business contexts, is
relatively less explored. Our formative study with industry professionals
revealed the limitations in current LLMs' understanding of the nuances in such
domain-specific writing. To address this gap, we propose an approach of
human-AI collaborative taxonomy development to perform as a guideline for
domain-specific writing assistants. This method integrates iterative feedback
from domain experts and multiple interactions between these experts and LLMs to
refine the taxonomy. Through larger-scale experiments, we aim to validate this
methodology and thus improve LLM-powered writing assistance, tailoring it to
meet the unique requirements of different stakeholder needs. | [
-0.3265574276447296,
-0.5435969233512878,
0.5675204992294312,
0.1064746230840683,
0.007565198466181755,
0.42455345392227173,
-0.3458525240421295,
-0.6377180218696594,
0.3395098149776459,
0.776312530040741,
-0.655446469783783,
-0.4849798083305359,
-0.4461154043674469,
0.7924087643623352,
0.12762907147407532,
0.9000394940376282,
-0.21976450085639954,
-0.21646660566329956,
-0.6558483242988586,
-0.1166219487786293,
-0.6431432366371155,
-0.6545336842536926,
-0.63158118724823,
-0.2578999400138855,
0.749419629573822,
0.4443003833293915,
0.6393195986747742,
0.5309594869613647,
0.7968790531158447,
0.36958566308021545,
0.25495922565460205,
0.6737595200538635,
0.0688418447971344,
-0.0019374085823073983,
-0.20115341246128082,
-0.30700254440307617,
-1.0741139650344849,
0.08587126433849335,
0.40760311484336853,
1.104108452796936,
-0.35387447476387024,
0.05483876168727875,
0.04364534467458725,
0.3985220193862915,
-0.4166598320007324,
-0.030519580468535423,
-0.5783677101135254,
-0.055621188133955,
-0.2021515667438507,
-0.1367584615945816,
-0.5341495275497437,
-0.011934574693441391,
0.31936216354370117,
-0.8109055161476135,
0.3788411319255829,
0.28414809703826904,
0.6659806966781616,
0.32680729031562805,
-0.27513405680656433,
-0.36962535977363586,
-0.7374163866043091,
0.6154835224151611,
-0.7909758687019348,
-0.017207840457558632,
0.47187483310699463,
0.044708963483572006,
-0.18254579603672028,
-0.6939907073974609,
-0.7543226480484009,
-0.3330068290233612,
-0.2543366551399231,
0.026781100779771805,
0.059308916330337524,
0.26691174507141113,
-0.07668537646532059,
0.14866067469120026,
-0.2594127655029297,
0.27195829153060913,
-0.19935618340969086,
-0.10357216745615005,
1.0569298267364502,
0.3557959794998169,
0.2675009071826935,
0.08541936427354813,
-0.07447250932455063,
0.38446304202079773,
-0.5933650732040405,
-0.4298407733440399,
0.26360461115837097,
0.37154650688171387,
0.21970288455486298,
0.41881102323532104,
0.0626954510807991,
0.6617376804351807,
-0.13245819509029388,
-0.1925428956747055,
0.014255818910896778,
-0.30737462639808655,
-0.26382967829704285,
-0.16354520618915558,
0.7375563979148865,
0.31001952290534973,
0.2109440118074417,
-0.5777124762535095,
-0.29456767439842224,
0.07558650523424149,
0.6434933543205261,
-0.1750369369983673,
-0.0077613466419279575,
0.11496717482805252,
-0.22752204537391663,
-0.25508615374565125,
-0.158385768532753,
-0.28157544136047363,
-0.6833864450454712,
-0.6099603176116943,
0.4656059741973877,
-0.06757103651762009,
-0.2258523553609848,
-0.03383481130003929,
-0.24239079654216766,
0.07288387417793274,
0.4062323272228241,
-0.9392744302749634,
0.5959960222244263,
0.80550217628479,
0.6221471428871155,
-0.3044295310974121,
-0.7311453819274902,
-0.298043429851532,
0.457719624042511,
-0.242264986038208,
0.7995514869689941,
-0.3838372230529785,
-0.48803070187568665,
0.028352830559015274,
-0.3971524238586426,
-0.025054259225726128,
-0.7117071151733398,
0.23682348430156708,
-0.3831793963909149,
0.18608729541301727,
0.0433652363717556,
-0.6477175354957581,
0.29640668630599976,
0.3405407965183258,
-0.45839571952819824,
0.3813079297542572,
0.3404843509197235,
-0.5102912187576294,
0.5670599341392517,
-0.6371773481369019,
-0.4335829019546509,
0.4913812279701233,
-0.4444763660430908,
-0.5233398079872131,
-0.04654451087117195,
0.06848961859941483,
0.6143997311592102,
-0.5533052086830139,
0.4563620686531067,
0.18107831478118896,
-0.16773280501365662,
0.1171659380197525,
0.1371479481458664,
0.5310896039009094,
-0.16986438632011414,
-0.21430064737796783,
0.4896969199180603,
-0.7576257586479187,
-0.4325794279575348,
-0.044874053448438644,
-0.37073445320129395,
-0.17967060208320618,
-0.10047154128551483,
0.010295253247022629,
-0.16855619847774506,
0.23698441684246063,
-0.4331502318382263,
0.5850843191146851,
-0.08436213433742523,
0.4018096923828125,
0.7563434839248657,
-0.025299806147813797,
0.526871383190155,
-0.7703931927680969,
0.7250390648841858,
-0.3650243878364563,
-0.020080966874957085,
-0.02638874761760235,
-0.5912555456161499,
-0.5720369219779968,
-0.35639432072639465,
0.4077431559562683,
0.3407573997974396,
-0.848188042640686,
0.6771177649497986,
-0.26632508635520935,
-0.48142099380493164,
-0.6789624691009521,
0.4196820557117462,
0.4248114824295044,
0.7662429213523865,
0.17330080270767212,
-0.6949924230575562,
-0.6602867841720581,
-0.90187668800354,
-0.1738782823085785,
-0.2065049111843109,
-0.1138422042131424,
0.3023257851600647,
0.4221137464046478,
-0.557284951210022,
1.191808819770813,
-0.43595755100250244,
-0.8007389307022095,
-0.45428797602653503,
0.38112446665763855,
-0.17045973241329193,
0.29426154494285583,
0.33640849590301514,
-0.7098082900047302,
-0.5995432734489441,
-0.2100784331560135,
-0.4915086030960083,
-0.241786390542984,
-0.38634392619132996,
-0.07279383391141891,
0.5943988561630249,
0.35504668951034546,
-0.6589294672012329,
0.37040838599205017,
0.3542487323284149,
-0.3577326536178589,
0.7009230256080627,
-0.37055695056915283,
-0.2567518651485443,
-1.2861144542694092,
0.1824263483285904,
0.2048795223236084,
-0.15692590177059174,
-0.6572977304458618,
0.169040247797966,
-0.31190237402915955,
0.14623315632343292,
0.12199392169713974,
0.5041407346725464,
-0.4996475279331207,
-0.18259429931640625,
-0.19549092650413513,
0.33835887908935547,
-0.1061118096113205,
0.5903445482254028,
0.47868865728378296,
0.5963810086250305,
0.3315497934818268,
-0.5690808892250061,
0.3482215404510498,
0.6044683456420898,
-0.0124643724411726,
0.7820125818252563,
-0.4996509253978729,
0.3393014073371887,
0.16656391322612762,
0.31889650225639343,
-0.6603065133094788,
-0.479780912399292,
0.13939793407917023,
-0.5023963451385498,
0.13962750136852264,
0.280180960893631,
-0.8338204026222229,
-0.2916518449783325,
-0.18885071575641632,
0.03160196170210838,
0.2970919907093048,
-0.25302302837371826,
0.9642090797424316,
0.4595753252506256,
-0.39591747522354126,
-0.24928046762943268,
-0.6692665815353394,
0.6598228216171265,
-0.0650109350681305,
-0.8694968223571777,
0.6653451323509216,
-0.1469067931175232,
-0.5891488194465637,
-0.1478044092655182,
0.30964404344558716,
-0.2814003527164459,
0.28263384103775024,
0.18908435106277466,
0.37479710578918457,
-0.07366824895143509,
0.06371603906154633,
-0.14257334172725677,
0.012905010022222996,
0.21646812558174133,
0.19311422109603882,
0.32678189873695374,
0.16380737721920013,
-0.14110691845417023,
-0.5777477025985718,
0.46156108379364014,
0.41879361867904663,
-0.2750815749168396,
0.5531235933303833,
0.39915594458580017,
-0.3186909854412079,
-0.3627336621284485,
-0.5107478499412537,
-0.09847038984298706,
-0.520758330821991,
-0.0037107837852090597,
-0.20093823969364166,
-0.8581352829933167,
0.3322204351425171,
-0.1443796008825302,
0.31453001499176025,
0.479623407125473,
0.6200808882713318,
0.1435551941394806,
0.6801316142082214,
0.9839962720870972,
-0.1538785994052887,
-0.04606131091713905,
-0.15919129550457,
0.1565762758255005,
-1.000077247619629,
-0.3853323757648468,
-0.4240676462650299,
-0.25985318422317505,
-0.2318248152732849,
-0.12313304841518402,
0.31635650992393494,
-0.3402141034603119,
-0.042824771255254745,
0.4074837267398834,
-0.6523057222366333,
0.020992228761315346,
0.7196582555770874,
-0.15790817141532898,
0.5263063311576843,
-0.18924495577812195,
-0.1241041049361229,
0.11561790853738785,
-0.6373069286346436,
-0.7852548956871033,
0.8673346638679504,
0.23938210308551788,
0.3293507993221283,
0.31024664640426636,
0.7994289994239807,
0.4432891309261322,
0.6724279522895813,
-0.7386006116867065,
0.615282416343689,
-0.14803464710712433,
-0.3978208303451538,
-0.5345128178596497,
-0.0639628916978836,
-0.816740095615387,
-0.014429113827645779,
-0.2226260006427765,
-0.6851416230201721,
-0.11407434940338135,
0.1783687174320221,
-0.58293217420578,
0.09504494071006775,
-0.7051821947097778,
0.6499339938163757,
-0.00025516084861010313,
-0.3279419243335724,
-0.16392099857330322,
-0.8065963983535767,
-0.04238750785589218,
-0.3151240944862366,
0.236472487449646,
0.203947514295578,
-0.3356650769710541,
0.7268365025520325,
-0.8764537572860718,
1.2724854946136475,
0.12373381853103638,
-0.4538502097129822,
0.39530253410339355,
0.03583504632115364,
0.1701434701681137,
-0.12395395338535309,
-0.2087520956993103,
-0.134479358792305,
-0.39265796542167664,
-0.13038113713264465,
-0.3787641227245331,
0.340422660112381,
-0.788754940032959,
-0.7790861129760742,
-0.2700035572052002,
-0.8307591676712036,
-0.8465017676353455,
0.17202676832675934,
0.14975833892822266,
0.34668195247650146,
-0.10884539037942886,
-0.1524244248867035,
0.14644774794578552,
0.17133468389511108,
0.48191922903060913,
0.5638752579689026,
0.07076676189899445,
-0.41597557067871094,
0.6818106770515442,
-0.0894194170832634,
0.057044193148612976,
0.3176262676715851,
0.10212409496307373,
0.024404894560575485,
-0.6762890219688416,
-0.48378512263298035,
0.23778332769870758,
-0.48721927404403687,
-0.09999195486307144,
-0.3417819142341614,
-0.07336357235908508,
-0.6848880648612976,
-0.6854451894760132,
0.1721116453409195,
-0.27734047174453735,
-0.5076680183410645,
0.09091279655694962,
0.4445056617259979,
1.020747423171997,
0.031136495992541313,
0.41444867849349976,
-0.9315809607505798,
0.19598914682865143,
0.20773100852966309,
0.22440718114376068,
0.21776264905929565,
-0.3626890778541565,
-0.07393299043178558,
-0.24488520622253418,
-0.2565689980983734,
-0.4189908802509308,
0.4388739764690399,
0.232736274600029,
0.4309830069541931,
0.02210260182619095,
-0.14133143424987793,
0.49007171392440796,
-0.44084295630455017,
1.0185680389404297,
0.16764503717422485,
-1.0168880224227905,
0.37674903869628906,
-0.582879900932312,
0.1910948008298874,
0.5253607034683228,
0.47478920221328735,
-0.6342976689338684,
-0.3202625811100006,
-0.5779775977134705,
-0.9858992695808411,
0.517952024936676,
0.20195046067237854,
0.22678561508655548,
0.13875022530555725,
0.6920776963233948,
0.33861804008483887,
0.3861514925956726,
-0.38698458671569824,
-0.06598303467035294,
0.3919340670108795,
-0.26542967557907104,
-0.11010086536407471,
-0.045164983719587326,
-0.1844460666179657,
-0.18374784290790558,
0.5253235101699829,
-0.2071486860513687,
0.11137249320745468,
0.2777250409126282,
0.014760651625692844,
-0.1832265704870224,
0.0969977155327797,
0.6023945808410645,
1.0085549354553223,
0.06930207461118698,
-0.10803835093975067,
0.05889002978801727,
-0.4237249195575714,
-0.10119488090276718,
0.062453705817461014,
0.08803509920835495,
-0.12584032118320465,
0.8587349057197571,
0.42475420236587524,
-0.17975862324237823,
-0.7617798447608948,
0.47558924555778503,
-0.0767013430595398,
-0.6512297987937927,
-0.4682726263999939,
0.11280849575996399,
0.15243306756019592,
-0.0314214825630188,
0.509046196937561,
-0.04041241109371185,
-0.10780768096446991,
-0.7128267288208008,
0.18464159965515137,
0.2949972152709961,
-0.1250598430633545,
-0.32077455520629883,
0.45290714502334595,
0.7037199139595032,
-0.8291806578636169,
0.5573769211769104,
-0.3181299865245819,
-0.40308111906051636,
0.7922163009643555,
0.4716538190841675,
0.9013243913650513,
-0.04125965014100075,
0.27960172295570374,
-0.23193229734897614,
-0.006445569451898336,
0.031593602150678635,
0.2517661154270172,
-0.02069305069744587,
-0.7799432277679443,
-0.35236456990242004,
-0.30646830797195435,
-0.8727012872695923,
-0.13341090083122253,
-0.5082166194915771,
0.21145644783973694,
-0.6675013899803162,
-0.21056973934173584,
0.3892379701137543,
0.19917313754558563,
-0.4264037609100342,
0.2335335612297058,
-0.0972047820687294,
0.8028197288513184,
-0.44076067209243774,
0.5262529253959656,
1.0870643854141235,
-0.6980421543121338,
-0.9045698642730713,
0.033772315829992294,
0.046719990670681,
-0.5575813055038452,
0.5343671441078186,
-0.07761497050523758,
-0.22787070274353027,
0.05840884894132614,
-0.5788682699203491,
-0.38781148195266724,
1.5213072299957275,
-0.19877304136753082,
-0.666873574256897,
-0.2732033133506775,
0.4437554180622101,
1.0514012575149536,
-0.7632143497467041,
-0.22910469770431519,
0.46594488620758057,
0.3434252142906189,
0.011329568922519684,
-1.3618967533111572,
0.07838426530361176,
-0.1382630616426468,
-0.08001861721277237,
-0.032821569591760635,
-0.8840382695198059,
0.6442083716392517,
-0.1993441879749298,
0.2788602113723755,
0.5084668397903442,
0.5439774990081787,
0.15734639763832092,
0.27973121404647827,
0.43596529960632324,
0.3082062900066376,
1.0638138055801392,
0.4342601001262665,
0.9423800706863403,
-0.2904180884361267,
-0.18603183329105377,
1.198543667793274,
-0.6199421882629395,
0.7766101360321045,
0.42971688508987427,
0.027851464226841927,
0.641379177570343,
0.28887394070625305,
-0.2050682008266449,
0.08364582061767578,
0.4555104970932007,
-0.44695645570755005,
-0.18049345910549164,
-0.5461140275001526,
0.08619920909404755,
0.335098534822464,
0.26622655987739563,
-0.39615780115127563,
0.31660377979278564,
-0.11827350407838821,
0.10772867500782013,
0.44428154826164246,
-0.4462761878967285,
0.9092546105384827,
0.23030906915664673,
-0.8843303918838501,
0.1419650912284851,
0.18774132430553436,
0.8645294904708862,
-0.28220707178115845,
-0.017504822462797165,
-0.10118397325277328,
0.20377293229103088,
-0.3385210335254669,
-0.7483425736427307,
0.447566956281662,
0.1281019151210785,
-0.057458359748125076,
-0.3020443320274353,
0.604860246181488,
-0.33947861194610596,
-0.29636576771736145,
-0.09543824940919876,
0.49414876103401184,
-0.187104269862175,
0.017539480701088905,
-0.28332042694091797,
-0.06265663355588913,
-0.37829336524009705,
0.14011919498443604,
0.18689651787281036,
0.34464114904403687,
-0.14984628558158875,
0.747818648815155,
0.25747963786125183,
0.15195363759994507,
-0.36219650506973267,
0.3507711589336395,
0.7382936477661133,
-0.4160307049751282,
-0.26573675870895386,
-0.6968078017234802,
0.42935633659362793,
-0.11018585413694382,
-0.6678539514541626,
0.5922095775604248,
0.4355112612247467,
0.7955805659294128,
-0.10609659552574158,
1.0391231775283813,
0.04719728231430054,
0.49375513195991516,
-0.16498373448848724,
0.8494390845298767,
-0.45145127177238464,
0.21637709438800812,
-0.3816617727279663,
-0.7219482660293579,
-0.721858561038971,
0.3762121796607971,
-0.09891150891780853,
0.03891374170780182,
0.6304131150245667,
0.5742074251174927,
0.37957170605659485,
-0.0630241334438324,
0.11759684979915619,
-0.08350801467895508,
0.37078097462654114,
0.3267969489097595,
0.5751859545707703,
0.03388524428009987,
0.38365110754966736,
-0.272367000579834,
-0.16931384801864624,
0.004668379668146372,
-0.9751289486885071,
-1.0642828941345215,
-0.7909258604049683,
-0.669836699962616,
0.0048604863695800304,
-0.03248586505651474,
1.095755934715271,
0.5199979543685913,
-0.2850019037723541,
-0.4386610984802246,
-0.14763490855693817,
-0.1300283819437027,
0.02516322396695614,
-0.18762943148612976,
0.2714129388332367,
-0.09609120339155197,
-0.5443488955497742,
0.04324747994542122,
0.2955940067768097,
-0.17540638148784637,
-0.6073550581932068,
-0.10877897590398788,
-0.17632223665714264,
0.3596847653388977,
0.5444640517234802,
0.04898277297616005,
-0.6595529317855835,
-0.16836050152778625,
-0.044581618160009384,
-0.07631518691778183,
0.03803050518035889,
1.020653247833252,
-0.6467007398605347,
0.19327664375305176,
0.19753025472164154,
0.816801905632019,
-0.18446208536624908,
0.02256501279771328,
0.8970555663108826,
-0.9888530373573303,
-0.2976698875427246,
0.4616606533527374,
0.26837873458862305,
0.5369555354118347,
-0.5892642736434937,
0.6436218023300171,
0.33616724610328674,
-0.7370715737342834,
-0.5033254623413086,
0.09736412018537521,
-0.9329560399055481,
-0.30456680059432983,
1.2557332515716553,
-0.06247168779373169,
-0.1789419800043106,
-0.27473512291908264,
-0.5475151538848877,
0.06382837146520615,
-0.3346945643424988,
1.09317946434021,
0.7461748719215393,
-0.3938978314399719,
0.046362023800611496,
0.15086078643798828,
0.6033763289451599,
0.16119572520256042,
-1.0641282796859741,
0.14207816123962402,
0.5684570670127869,
0.10023514181375504,
0.4029560387134552,
1.0957685708999634,
0.4423532783985138,
0.2644774913787842,
-0.09045101702213287,
0.2454109787940979,
-0.12681381404399872,
-0.32329100370407104,
-0.15266269445419312,
-0.004258293658494949,
0.5974725484848022,
0.40020039677619934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18665v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18665v2 | RouteLLM: Learning to Route LLMs with Preference Data | 2024-06-26T18:10:22 | 2024-07-01T05:38:08 | Isaac Ong, Amjad Almahairi, Vincent Wu, Wei-Lin Chiang, Tianhao Wu, Joseph E. Gonzalez, M Waleed Kadous, Ion Stoica | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) exhibit impressive capabilities across a wide
range of tasks, yet the choice of which model to use often involves a trade-off
between performance and cost. More powerful models, though effective, come with
higher expenses, while less capable models are more cost-effective. To address
this dilemma, we propose several efficient router models that dynamically
select between a stronger and a weaker LLM during inference, aiming to optimize
the balance between cost and response quality. We develop a training framework
for these routers leveraging human preference data and data augmentation
techniques to enhance performance. Our evaluation on widely-recognized
benchmarks shows that our approach significantly reduces costs-by over 2 times
in certain cases-without compromising the quality of responses. Interestingly,
our router models also demonstrate significant transfer learning capabilities,
maintaining their performance even when the strong and weak models are changed
at test time. This highlights the potential of these routers to provide a
cost-effective yet high-performance solution for deploying LLMs. | [
-0.3156109154224396,
-0.4203048348426819,
0.4722941219806671,
-0.17561550438404083,
-0.11057376861572266,
0.08071429282426834,
-0.18972726166248322,
-0.3879053294658661,
0.07873012870550156,
0.7546496987342834,
-0.4035971462726593,
-0.15865030884742737,
-0.5029829740524292,
-0.18160821497440338,
-0.07080802321434021,
0.5561689734458923,
0.1263672113418579,
0.3024357855319977,
-0.1576060950756073,
-0.08638769388198853,
-0.36064180731773376,
-0.7889248132705688,
-1.016503095626831,
-0.5695957541465759,
0.7375890016555786,
0.4610622227191925,
0.8577332496643066,
0.6553521156311035,
0.4960033595561981,
0.29186534881591797,
-0.0608866810798645,
0.3663766086101532,
-0.6096106171607971,
0.3347201347351074,
-0.24279038608074188,
-0.5514129996299744,
-0.5737795829772949,
-0.29633229970932007,
0.5790444016456604,
0.9946485161781311,
-0.18024304509162903,
0.047500401735305786,
-0.06793472915887833,
1.0742424726486206,
-0.4731409549713135,
-0.0416722409427166,
-0.8141782879829407,
-0.009406949393451214,
-0.07330755889415741,
-0.04292973875999451,
-0.4912573993206024,
-0.4520206153392792,
0.2980416417121887,
-0.3253859579563141,
0.15041108429431915,
0.36365869641304016,
0.6888757348060608,
0.23726442456245422,
-0.5614200234413147,
-0.11338826268911362,
-0.6456198692321777,
0.7897883057594299,
-0.579463005065918,
0.8513985872268677,
0.46067020297050476,
0.24387551844120026,
-0.1860172003507614,
-0.5192788243293762,
-0.1774783432483673,
-0.28609347343444824,
0.10476566851139069,
-0.07030372321605682,
0.0016572310123592615,
-0.05613792687654495,
0.10745496302843094,
0.4712981581687927,
-0.5812777280807495,
0.35538026690483093,
-0.3134170472621918,
-0.10010822862386703,
0.717589795589447,
0.29696348309516907,
0.05660221353173256,
0.1241656094789505,
-0.2146444022655487,
-0.09032978862524033,
-0.8166714310646057,
-0.021695788949728012,
0.6403263807296753,
0.4653361439704895,
0.0647706612944603,
0.5327087044715881,
-0.3224240243434906,
0.8678766489028931,
0.1694071739912033,
-0.0998254269361496,
0.19422006607055664,
0.14088132977485657,
-0.022637857124209404,
0.033309053629636765,
0.5608609318733215,
0.12559381127357483,
-0.027829313650727272,
-0.3832643926143646,
-0.3705008029937744,
-0.11152667552232742,
0.3746766448020935,
-0.7803913950920105,
-0.45942896604537964,
0.02256101556122303,
-0.6578325033187866,
-0.26337960362434387,
-0.29247817397117615,
-0.7420555353164673,
-0.49651533365249634,
-0.42004063725471497,
0.3585312068462372,
-0.254638671875,
-0.3074873983860016,
0.46220633387565613,
0.24393917620182037,
0.38623717427253723,
0.44964542984962463,
-1.094619631767273,
0.3647991120815277,
0.49997106194496155,
0.833874523639679,
-0.6911698579788208,
-0.005536956246942282,
-0.687252402305603,
-0.01003617886453867,
-0.2470586597919464,
0.7739152908325195,
-0.5628519654273987,
-0.6253647208213806,
-0.10241658985614777,
-0.12063203752040863,
-0.08276490122079849,
-0.7981618642807007,
0.7887817621231079,
-1.1385775804519653,
0.12262237817049026,
-0.2871203124523163,
-0.7271121740341187,
-0.2238379716873169,
0.10668324679136276,
-0.8867640495300293,
0.7902266383171082,
0.24711163341999054,
-0.47725245356559753,
0.1198091059923172,
-0.4136037826538086,
-0.7769193053245544,
-0.16061623394489288,
0.1503329575061798,
-0.3379206359386444,
0.19183288514614105,
0.12024810165166855,
0.5165013670921326,
-0.36959266662597656,
0.07113981246948242,
-0.3362885117530823,
-0.16889043152332306,
0.3140176832675934,
-0.46920496225357056,
0.610605776309967,
0.38970181345939636,
-0.06250595301389694,
0.22141261398792267,
-0.852357029914856,
-0.24036678671836853,
0.23616661131381989,
-0.9770722985267639,
-0.17962293326854706,
0.2847059667110443,
-0.007861555553972721,
0.08743555843830109,
0.17936217784881592,
-0.25923848152160645,
0.07071024924516678,
-0.5518205165863037,
0.23246638476848602,
0.9194262623786926,
-0.3940812945365906,
0.7669960260391235,
-0.37724706530570984,
0.40414923429489136,
-0.12216036021709442,
0.09499137848615646,
0.2444434016942978,
-0.30375465750694275,
-1.2455852031707764,
-0.01722913421690464,
0.15471415221691132,
0.3236227035522461,
-0.5883068442344666,
0.33540135622024536,
-0.3380512595176697,
-0.23240460455417633,
-0.5512469410896301,
0.38699474930763245,
0.06145220249891281,
0.76219642162323,
0.5067707896232605,
-0.2508675158023834,
-0.4331052601337433,
-0.7329323887825012,
-0.1453845500946045,
-0.1995464265346527,
0.045904260128736496,
0.4700465798377991,
-0.053522318601608276,
-0.07030656188726425,
0.8608096837997437,
-0.7311381697654724,
0.05014590173959732,
-0.5482322573661804,
-0.3032800853252411,
0.28757286071777344,
0.28722983598709106,
0.15482988953590393,
-1.0293668508529663,
-0.28120872378349304,
-0.07913192361593246,
-0.34659186005592346,
-0.0864366739988327,
0.04629141092300415,
-0.18614888191223145,
0.10130000114440918,
0.2584182620048523,
-0.33595994114875793,
-0.08720433712005615,
0.739615261554718,
-0.1766640841960907,
0.4937906265258789,
-0.26084592938423157,
-0.049535542726516724,
-1.2222555875778198,
-0.22612448036670685,
0.047802481800317764,
-0.26961028575897217,
-0.6121326684951782,
-0.17041707038879395,
0.02523970603942871,
-0.004498603288084269,
-0.6436075568199158,
0.8128058314323425,
-0.4656509757041931,
-0.10770870000123978,
-0.23262058198451996,
-0.2776428461074829,
0.09824632853269577,
0.430892676115036,
0.27172115445137024,
0.9315391182899475,
0.39920511841773987,
-0.7259926199913025,
0.5558395981788635,
0.14295785129070282,
-0.1856502741575241,
0.37715765833854675,
-0.5872927308082581,
0.24709951877593994,
-0.06209191307425499,
0.13537006080150604,
-0.8735898733139038,
-0.36150580644607544,
0.1647855043411255,
-0.09385930001735687,
0.3105405271053314,
-0.6101884841918945,
-0.30150771141052246,
-0.14076273143291473,
-0.12513026595115662,
0.22001230716705322,
0.7593837380409241,
-0.9293265342712402,
0.7322467565536499,
0.4342494308948517,
-0.035172998905181885,
-0.28426671028137207,
-0.5571067929267883,
0.07472144067287445,
-0.4585475027561188,
-0.4123866856098175,
0.3576701581478119,
-0.11584063619375229,
-0.06862582266330719,
-0.22876514494419098,
0.04827267676591873,
-0.07737787812948227,
0.12319809198379517,
0.3229561448097229,
0.30189141631126404,
-0.216168612241745,
0.13641662895679474,
-0.09053047001361847,
-0.2562994360923767,
0.17667122185230255,
-0.5462870597839355,
0.5769928693771362,
-0.05438153073191643,
-0.7502716183662415,
-0.1564359813928604,
0.1503850668668747,
0.4669930338859558,
-0.32123708724975586,
0.5920313596725464,
0.3567076325416565,
-0.06728275120258331,
-0.1447303146123886,
-0.8656860589981079,
-0.18450291454792023,
-0.5580817461013794,
0.3204882740974426,
-0.45669224858283997,
-1.0669673681259155,
0.2017090767621994,
-0.334796279668808,
-0.08393723517656326,
0.04550754651427269,
0.4438968002796173,
-0.0587843582034111,
0.9414022564888,
0.3339816629886627,
-0.4411308467388153,
0.5768612027168274,
-0.07897467911243439,
0.1338610202074051,
-0.8642676472663879,
-0.30101314187049866,
-0.41625383496284485,
-0.2035313993692398,
-0.5962181091308594,
-0.6103774905204773,
0.32933053374290466,
-0.08293192833662033,
-0.36583277583122253,
0.027074268087744713,
-0.12254161387681961,
0.5039359331130981,
0.5704118013381958,
0.3855627179145813,
0.3075050711631775,
0.22232434153556824,
0.05779376998543739,
0.04979829117655754,
-0.819045901298523,
-0.5462082028388977,
1.2288738489151,
0.4095767140388489,
1.24533212184906,
0.5215992331504822,
0.3888247013092041,
0.2317744791507721,
0.1440269649028778,
-0.96026611328125,
0.5924808382987976,
-0.30306750535964966,
-0.26791009306907654,
-0.08607666194438934,
-0.6813523173332214,
-0.9416984915733337,
0.2712545096874237,
-0.406442254781723,
-0.4647378623485565,
0.13667204976081848,
0.37334495782852173,
-0.25133776664733887,
0.6207336783409119,
-0.5768319368362427,
0.41210147738456726,
-0.6720427870750427,
-0.8256672024726868,
-0.23980602622032166,
-0.609122633934021,
0.18711461126804352,
-0.017488379031419754,
-0.14911021292209625,
-0.1734558790922165,
-0.16158068180084229,
0.5030003190040588,
-0.12439344823360443,
0.7161542773246765,
-0.018097052350640297,
0.06491155177354813,
-0.1349785178899765,
0.19978907704353333,
0.6312421560287476,
-0.11092306673526764,
-0.6233507990837097,
0.053248222917318344,
-0.8099437355995178,
-0.45086175203323364,
-0.4538686275482178,
0.8373039960861206,
-0.849919319152832,
-0.587497353553772,
0.04113157466053963,
-0.4562079906463623,
-0.5592591166496277,
0.16757920384407043,
-0.024410339072346687,
0.5914679765701294,
-0.16104857623577118,
0.129830464720726,
1.1712133884429932,
-0.3322206139564514,
0.3129217028617859,
0.3618713915348053,
-0.0806872621178627,
-0.4687247574329376,
0.8619731664657593,
-0.15046139061450958,
0.448994904756546,
0.6051772236824036,
0.41674456000328064,
-0.7137845754623413,
-0.8416756391525269,
-0.5934974551200867,
0.06660953909158707,
-0.6224232912063599,
-0.0728234276175499,
-0.8370424509048462,
-0.11976752430200577,
-0.10333354026079178,
-0.2765849828720093,
-0.5580955147743225,
-0.3036496937274933,
-0.5323722958564758,
-0.2045975625514984,
0.355339914560318,
0.3916625380516052,
0.11742085963487625,
0.42097076773643494,
-0.5499951839447021,
0.18575003743171692,
0.6234941482543945,
0.3990771770477295,
0.19102023541927338,
-0.7020811438560486,
-0.2532667815685272,
-0.24042131006717682,
-0.24308840930461884,
-0.5623442530632019,
0.4179989695549011,
0.02979007363319397,
0.6670065522193909,
0.5692660212516785,
0.12221769243478775,
0.4155235290527344,
-0.7028185725212097,
0.682835578918457,
0.20088748633861542,
-0.650871217250824,
0.49726730585098267,
-0.25283172726631165,
0.05564675107598305,
0.5582911968231201,
0.5337930917739868,
-0.15912015736103058,
0.18694289028644562,
-0.363668292760849,
-0.8951941728591919,
0.3921985626220703,
-0.11412423104047775,
0.45234164595603943,
0.13212253153324127,
0.5016447305679321,
0.16873499751091003,
0.01169076282531023,
-0.5740532279014587,
-0.30352649092674255,
-0.0267572533339262,
-0.03360006585717201,
-0.09245317429304123,
-0.35913988947868347,
0.13920864462852478,
-0.1969318687915802,
0.7430301904678345,
-0.17537103593349457,
-0.032950613647699356,
-0.16667799651622772,
-0.2427688091993332,
0.11244267970323563,
0.31204724311828613,
0.43041834235191345,
0.7183518409729004,
-0.34830549359321594,
0.4252126216888428,
0.44985654950141907,
-0.10680703073740005,
0.45581498742103577,
-0.05174035578966141,
-0.08561484515666962,
-0.20156952738761902,
0.12278494983911514,
1.1862338781356812,
0.1474810391664505,
-0.6587607264518738,
0.3610277473926544,
-0.10645217448472977,
-0.035828351974487305,
0.17258168756961823,
0.456954687833786,
0.37670597434043884,
0.30590298771858215,
0.22145378589630127,
-0.04369726777076721,
0.3780777156352997,
-0.0946713536977768,
0.10477757453918457,
0.5312128663063049,
-0.42685815691947937,
-0.23038873076438904,
0.7454244494438171,
0.5078561902046204,
-0.48124223947525024,
0.4946260154247284,
-0.01612316258251667,
-0.5542770624160767,
0.3330952823162079,
0.5595005750656128,
0.837184488773346,
-0.36703118681907654,
0.09004653245210648,
0.07198774814605713,
0.047320760786533356,
-0.2836228013038635,
-0.005104743875563145,
0.13817401230335236,
-0.8585668206214905,
-0.2767144739627838,
-0.7093012928962708,
-0.681477963924408,
0.057988278567790985,
-0.7352080345153809,
0.17837367951869965,
-0.339523047208786,
-0.2414657175540924,
-0.3770955204963684,
-0.04877200350165367,
-0.7005898356437683,
0.28774601221084595,
0.19292625784873962,
0.8479709625244141,
-0.6900726556777954,
0.9336684942245483,
0.8289387822151184,
-0.2089504450559616,
-0.7122605443000793,
-0.06998185068368912,
-0.08208225667476654,
-0.8698323369026184,
0.8638209700584412,
-0.12053181231021881,
-0.5624786019325256,
0.09884680807590485,
-0.022873057052493095,
-0.7397298812866211,
0.8521014451980591,
0.6344533562660217,
-0.5076907873153687,
0.0630904883146286,
0.10617470741271973,
0.24707984924316406,
-0.3243520259857178,
0.3116443455219269,
0.2759685218334198,
0.06817523390054703,
0.25070440769195557,
-0.5415681004524231,
0.05457327887415886,
0.2882087528705597,
0.3210758864879608,
0.0886543020606041,
-0.8433352112770081,
0.7176528573036194,
-0.19089961051940918,
0.1426660269498825,
-0.24805916845798492,
0.7285718321800232,
0.24626412987709045,
0.057987574487924576,
0.6480487585067749,
0.4024769365787506,
0.8329685926437378,
0.2546977698802948,
0.8739681243896484,
-0.24711057543754578,
0.22342638671398163,
1.2115633487701416,
-0.531492292881012,
1.1298556327819824,
0.6203049421310425,
-0.31839945912361145,
0.28263285756111145,
0.8793045878410339,
0.41606834530830383,
0.7312687635421753,
0.36315152049064636,
-0.5451447367668152,
-0.5045033097267151,
-0.22375652194023132,
-0.2698041498661041,
0.2488052397966385,
0.12392749637365341,
-0.30139032006263733,
-0.12082304060459137,
-0.09025319665670395,
0.22816599905490875,
-0.09241700917482376,
-0.28708794713020325,
0.8708711862564087,
0.011730085127055645,
-0.44725140929222107,
0.444821834564209,
-0.013262061402201653,
0.7849805951118469,
-0.7238187193870544,
0.09862058609724045,
-0.6421937346458435,
0.10241598635911942,
-0.06034832447767258,
-0.5649219751358032,
0.18880607187747955,
-0.0740678459405899,
-0.3671594560146332,
-0.33342185616493225,
0.899260401725769,
-0.3667329251766205,
-0.5954445600509644,
0.3845509886741638,
0.5535403490066528,
0.007019425742328167,
0.08888555318117142,
-0.7369261384010315,
0.27065399289131165,
-0.08798713237047195,
-0.4166422188282013,
0.61298006772995,
0.05000687390565872,
0.20220431685447693,
0.9478751420974731,
0.9588931798934937,
0.5355309844017029,
0.03608172386884689,
0.13139863312244415,
0.9849984049797058,
-0.33665162324905396,
-0.3904016613960266,
-0.9377502202987671,
0.26923084259033203,
-0.16947892308235168,
0.11673130095005035,
0.5278152823448181,
0.7278618216514587,
0.8423352241516113,
-0.037912361323833466,
0.8346196413040161,
0.460204541683197,
0.40444597601890564,
-0.903217613697052,
0.606671929359436,
-0.532692015171051,
0.6151195168495178,
0.15314343571662903,
-0.8885101675987244,
-0.14171072840690613,
0.6586459279060364,
-0.5063379406929016,
0.0000653405295452103,
0.1703662872314453,
0.9631509184837341,
-0.5040746927261353,
-0.1759919822216034,
0.3178001940250397,
-0.2818323075771332,
0.44554999470710754,
0.6571361422538757,
0.933720588684082,
-0.16164936125278473,
0.2837047576904297,
-0.09697359055280685,
-0.13468053936958313,
-0.44160589575767517,
-1.075439453125,
-0.8781784176826477,
-0.33016663789749146,
-0.33505502343177795,
-0.3879343867301941,
0.3750884532928467,
1.2107969522476196,
1.1287894248962402,
-0.6431237459182739,
-0.6307333111763,
0.02140560746192932,
0.4199985861778259,
0.09537716954946518,
-0.16842368245124817,
0.4473235607147217,
-0.4267781674861908,
-0.5357815623283386,
0.6378108859062195,
0.17378847301006317,
0.026555154472589493,
-0.3169407248497009,
-0.4184488356113434,
0.00031841653981246054,
0.16003279387950897,
0.6790656447410583,
0.08412378281354904,
-0.6504996418952942,
-0.14901794493198395,
-0.03789955750107765,
0.06319178640842438,
0.1951931267976761,
0.8463298678398132,
-0.6855225563049316,
0.4000602662563324,
0.4755479693412781,
1.282724142074585,
0.5171515345573425,
0.020217016339302063,
0.6197062134742737,
-0.3802742660045624,
-0.10469092428684235,
0.09897170960903168,
0.364986389875412,
0.6016445755958557,
-0.4655666947364807,
0.4281603693962097,
0.13942116498947144,
-0.5954923629760742,
-0.660915195941925,
0.3485851287841797,
-0.809386670589447,
-0.23263846337795258,
1.435076355934143,
-0.03959611803293228,
0.04106530174612999,
-0.1809389293193817,
-0.2135077863931656,
-0.0001884634984889999,
-0.41110938787460327,
0.49596354365348816,
0.3681386411190033,
-0.48532921075820923,
-0.24430027604103088,
-0.6185256838798523,
0.4342174232006073,
0.49077945947647095,
-0.9034972786903381,
0.013605832122266293,
0.6329111456871033,
0.512468695640564,
-0.36099547147750854,
0.6238716840744019,
0.284616619348526,
-0.3090556263923645,
-0.38992324471473694,
-0.09387347847223282,
-0.06035131216049194,
-0.2248612493276596,
-0.4610692858695984,
0.209000825881958,
0.5077860951423645,
-0.33406949043273926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18664v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18664v2 | Evaluating Copyright Takedown Methods for Language Models | 2024-06-26T18:09:46 | 2024-07-01T07:12:45 | Boyi Wei, Weijia Shi, Yangsibo Huang, Noah A. Smith, Chiyuan Zhang, Luke Zettlemoyer, Kai Li, Peter Henderson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) derive their capabilities from extensive training on
diverse data, including potentially copyrighted material. These models can
memorize and generate content similar to their training data, posing potential
concerns. Therefore, model creators are motivated to develop mitigation methods
that prevent generating protected content. We term this procedure as copyright
takedowns for LMs, noting the conceptual similarity to (but legal distinction
from) the DMCA takedown This paper introduces the first evaluation of the
feasibility and side effects of copyright takedowns for LMs. We propose
CoTaEval, an evaluation framework to assess the effectiveness of copyright
takedown methods, the impact on the model's ability to retain uncopyrightable
factual knowledge from the training data whose recitation is embargoed, and how
well the model maintains its general utility and efficiency. We examine several
strategies, including adding system prompts, decoding-time filtering
interventions, and unlearning approaches. Our findings indicate that no tested
method excels across all metrics, showing significant room for research in this
unique problem setting and indicating potential unresolved challenges for live
policy proposals. | [
-0.4676247537136078,
-0.6160171031951904,
0.3544768691062927,
0.039066314697265625,
-0.491130530834198,
0.40819230675697327,
-0.45043593645095825,
-0.34258612990379333,
-0.028249284252524376,
1.003580093383789,
-0.17165322601795197,
-0.31217828392982483,
-0.732708215713501,
0.06680729240179062,
-0.7919260263442993,
0.8979461789131165,
-0.20989778637886047,
-0.03249373286962509,
-0.237666055560112,
-0.18828776478767395,
-0.5207956433296204,
-0.6204825639724731,
-0.6756420135498047,
-0.22743909060955048,
0.23700842261314392,
0.19620367884635925,
0.622809886932373,
0.4854891896247864,
0.2858058512210846,
0.15511082112789154,
-0.5273365378379822,
-0.2733079791069031,
-0.6394439935684204,
0.04355839639902115,
-0.1844359189271927,
-0.5278411507606506,
-0.10461059212684631,
0.10787349194288254,
0.7814915776252747,
0.4930994212627411,
-0.25044628977775574,
0.24818377196788788,
0.12588642537593842,
0.7380949854850769,
-0.8503941893577576,
-0.029705757275223732,
-0.7341579794883728,
0.23888902366161346,
0.04344553127884865,
-0.26215389370918274,
-0.4802744388580322,
-0.5901216864585876,
0.24538865685462952,
-0.2607997953891754,
0.07946217805147171,
-0.24468086659908295,
0.6505610346794128,
0.22640375792980194,
-0.30179229378700256,
-0.5060228705406189,
-0.8334418535232544,
0.7761461734771729,
-0.8713749051094055,
0.2902328372001648,
0.6123148798942566,
0.2909814417362213,
0.21482092142105103,
-0.8276631832122803,
-0.6606990694999695,
-0.35364076495170593,
0.1849173903465271,
0.022118354216217995,
-0.3582642674446106,
-0.136464923620224,
0.2738039195537567,
0.5724778771400452,
-0.38824746012687683,
0.1889851838350296,
-0.8444036245346069,
-0.1306353360414505,
0.44583529233932495,
-0.007267007138580084,
0.6169012784957886,
-0.21739789843559265,
-0.42644575238227844,
0.03509657829999924,
-1.1222904920578003,
-0.15974368155002594,
0.4704982340335846,
0.14925585687160492,
0.07252192497253418,
0.5338692665100098,
0.08117501437664032,
0.42060086131095886,
-0.29466426372528076,
0.19448529183864594,
-0.05207114666700363,
-0.0946212038397789,
-0.2683541774749756,
-0.0080258222296834,
0.35502827167510986,
0.24883729219436646,
0.3572002053260803,
-0.3108428418636322,
-0.35747113823890686,
-0.36216744780540466,
0.3207915425300598,
-0.5961021780967712,
-0.12395315617322922,
0.43869873881340027,
-0.5372586846351624,
-0.5004771947860718,
-0.2365761697292328,
-0.6920834183692932,
-0.42992889881134033,
-0.6861687898635864,
0.5491234660148621,
-0.32652485370635986,
-0.3386330008506775,
0.07500478625297546,
-0.0730745792388916,
0.2631961405277252,
0.020092491060495377,
-0.6997856497764587,
0.3998156487941742,
0.7724393010139465,
0.877036452293396,
-0.06905680894851685,
-0.21698379516601562,
-0.4027203619480133,
-0.04494468495249748,
-0.18446089327335358,
0.4315318167209625,
-0.29009291529655457,
-0.662822425365448,
0.08689200133085251,
0.12801125645637512,
-0.029917079955339432,
-0.5247244834899902,
0.29388245940208435,
-0.6794789433479309,
0.10294143110513687,
-0.2891402244567871,
-0.7967931032180786,
-0.16626732051372528,
0.1434497833251953,
-1.0367698669433594,
0.5142264366149902,
-0.12158451229333878,
-0.7763910293579102,
0.35373052954673767,
-0.21060270071029663,
-0.2980768382549286,
0.101112499833107,
-0.24427714943885803,
-0.4368419349193573,
0.03203210234642029,
0.04410763829946518,
0.22832170128822327,
-0.25814181566238403,
0.11649385094642639,
-0.1580946445465088,
-0.22319245338439941,
0.42950722575187683,
-0.6181496977806091,
0.9713773131370544,
0.5012308359146118,
-0.5674869418144226,
-0.35983192920684814,
-0.6467932462692261,
0.1612376719713211,
0.3659614324569702,
-0.4086066484451294,
-0.4806954264640808,
0.06386885792016983,
-0.005183205008506775,
0.1363813728094101,
-0.05830075591802597,
-0.5036778450012207,
0.07035639137029648,
-0.2730361819267273,
0.30109143257141113,
0.6742058992385864,
0.11484638601541519,
0.38014498353004456,
-0.4995330572128296,
0.8722999691963196,
-0.49616768956184387,
0.27491259574890137,
0.11296330392360687,
-0.07441551983356476,
-0.5619396567344666,
-0.44239068031311035,
0.5967278480529785,
0.30544528365135193,
-0.7089309096336365,
0.06963538378477097,
-0.18601229786872864,
-0.4380582869052887,
-0.4553396999835968,
0.1309763342142105,
0.7574983239173889,
-0.09051761031150818,
0.0754174292087555,
-0.41020333766937256,
-0.3718731105327606,
-0.6830547451972961,
-0.3837832808494568,
0.04347776249051094,
0.07731126993894577,
0.12527503073215485,
0.4738808274269104,
0.1928834766149521,
0.7843999862670898,
-0.25252294540405273,
-0.19080428779125214,
-0.29725515842437744,
0.14442650973796844,
-0.2796473801136017,
0.4263405501842499,
0.730530858039856,
-0.593554675579071,
-0.07635527104139328,
-0.27242350578308105,
-0.569831371307373,
-0.29744550585746765,
0.109603650867939,
0.18824757635593414,
0.6072151064872742,
0.26373183727264404,
-0.3476655185222626,
0.7339717745780945,
0.43545007705688477,
-0.07778522372245789,
0.7904177308082581,
-0.170429989695549,
0.382466584444046,
-0.8227902054786682,
0.35465207695961,
-0.866826057434082,
-0.1661556512117386,
-0.4814469516277313,
0.22920124232769012,
-0.11774640530347824,
-0.44727927446365356,
-0.8618110418319702,
0.43895387649536133,
-0.425153523683548,
-0.18151095509529114,
-0.36352023482322693,
0.5159713625907898,
0.1539609283208847,
0.15296952426433563,
0.07863974571228027,
0.4910794496536255,
0.18650378286838531,
-0.6721781492233276,
0.01011396013200283,
0.17091701924800873,
-0.3274766802787781,
0.46024155616760254,
-0.5580787062644958,
0.3532045781612396,
-0.28795740008354187,
0.1120704934000969,
-0.8008372783660889,
0.21049714088439941,
0.17814527451992035,
-0.2526647746562958,
0.23693516850471497,
-0.3898814618587494,
-0.2592400908470154,
-0.11529672145843506,
-0.5346716046333313,
0.3234007954597473,
0.34792864322662354,
-0.6633930802345276,
0.3197689652442932,
0.6104941368103027,
-0.22250059247016907,
-0.8253001570701599,
-0.6561293601989746,
0.07808368653059006,
-0.29447925090789795,
-0.2136363387107849,
0.21048526465892792,
0.017695635557174683,
-0.2966887056827545,
0.16836048662662506,
-0.05811230093240738,
-0.056962382048368454,
0.3515436053276062,
0.042016368359327316,
-0.11371494829654694,
0.11512847989797592,
0.20669716596603394,
0.07383375614881516,
-0.08598016947507858,
0.10049985349178314,
0.03134026750922203,
0.7622241973876953,
-0.0141321811825037,
-0.3131532371044159,
-0.0493522509932518,
0.26296842098236084,
0.7190138697624207,
-0.3216449022293091,
0.7348724007606506,
0.3283386826515198,
-0.5842917561531067,
-0.47582775354385376,
-0.36859992146492004,
-0.0381205715239048,
-0.3272448778152466,
0.12206529080867767,
-0.010804605670273304,
-0.557569682598114,
0.6459344625473022,
0.06473574042320251,
0.1942838877439499,
0.2195645123720169,
0.5327334403991699,
0.27907049655914307,
0.514575719833374,
0.440984308719635,
0.02762417308986187,
0.5713348388671875,
-0.6836639046669006,
0.22513476014137268,
-0.7517483234405518,
-0.2780036926269531,
-0.7831423878669739,
-0.010938280262053013,
-0.35697078704833984,
-0.298386812210083,
-0.09602110832929611,
0.22969183325767517,
-0.06708796322345734,
0.6765543222427368,
-0.379477858543396,
0.8014186024665833,
0.2823386490345001,
0.13401107490062714,
0.73606276512146,
-0.06867314130067825,
-0.10156852006912231,
0.07397475093603134,
-0.4952348470687866,
-0.9839881062507629,
1.3362491130828857,
0.4094277322292328,
0.718555748462677,
0.3470650911331177,
0.8672312498092651,
0.594372570514679,
0.3429083824157715,
-0.6992385387420654,
0.42451411485671997,
-0.15280799567699432,
-0.6503385305404663,
-0.32202354073524475,
-0.39839088916778564,
-0.7521358728408813,
0.19636082649230957,
-0.1147545725107193,
-0.967001736164093,
0.0956781879067421,
0.20784638822078705,
-0.19444167613983154,
0.6577017307281494,
-0.43763649463653564,
0.6241350173950195,
-0.3776392638683319,
-0.43527400493621826,
-0.42808544635772705,
-0.2635619044303894,
0.439432293176651,
-0.42786699533462524,
0.35765671730041504,
-0.23235812783241272,
0.18204016983509064,
0.8229857087135315,
-0.5020520091056824,
0.7493035793304443,
-0.23718979954719543,
-0.26530778408050537,
0.4375535249710083,
0.5610211491584778,
0.19025245308876038,
-0.024679012596607208,
0.04832444712519646,
0.09142198413610458,
0.8738710880279541,
-0.2710103988647461,
-0.6056020259857178,
0.5294171571731567,
-0.6276853680610657,
-0.24918276071548462,
-0.264864981174469,
-0.010926890186965466,
0.045357827097177505,
0.19230689108371735,
0.41519805788993835,
0.5399067401885986,
-0.4916709363460541,
0.21484924852848053,
0.2332518845796585,
-0.554726243019104,
0.44981759786605835,
0.7433350682258606,
-0.7243844270706177,
-0.708980917930603,
0.8681044578552246,
0.326359361410141,
0.6070811748504639,
-0.1544262170791626,
0.20886409282684326,
-0.30110231041908264,
-0.5134156346321106,
-0.2843773365020752,
0.09335546940565109,
-1.1617636680603027,
-0.09033448994159698,
-0.3129284381866455,
-0.35391566157341003,
-0.010015551932156086,
-0.026278946548700333,
-0.5453224778175354,
-0.6310859322547913,
-0.16881631314754486,
0.028203386813402176,
0.1248185783624649,
0.9111775755882263,
0.011196489445865154,
0.18724574148654938,
-0.8675786852836609,
-0.016711540520191193,
0.09843553602695465,
0.530444860458374,
0.18317866325378418,
-0.6343515515327454,
-0.03418716415762901,
0.12340760231018066,
-0.501427948474884,
-0.6566216945648193,
0.27308768033981323,
-0.047017816454172134,
0.7584378123283386,
0.09389173984527588,
0.22277650237083435,
0.09275005012750626,
-0.2621721029281616,
0.8475505113601685,
-0.08472343534231186,
-1.3063746690750122,
0.41913509368896484,
0.03733521327376366,
-0.2076452374458313,
0.5611172914505005,
0.3181835114955902,
-0.42613622546195984,
-0.3012472987174988,
-0.6776255369186401,
-0.8234763741493225,
0.4464379847049713,
0.6262103915214539,
0.2569125294685364,
0.06066366285085678,
0.33533063530921936,
0.16950801014900208,
0.4858582019805908,
-0.5343580842018127,
-0.01490867231041193,
0.06531368941068649,
-0.03878304362297058,
0.015535757876932621,
-0.10967680811882019,
-0.04609869047999382,
0.059943702071905136,
0.736929714679718,
0.2529684603214264,
0.16847126185894012,
0.20065899193286896,
-0.5278201699256897,
0.055028036236763,
0.5817382335662842,
0.5859436988830566,
0.9867677092552185,
-0.24541381001472473,
0.012598725035786629,
0.15384423732757568,
-0.46600833535194397,
0.15778116881847382,
-0.14119014143943787,
-0.3639320433139801,
-0.10745897889137268,
0.20067410171031952,
0.5413984060287476,
0.35808834433555603,
-0.7245806455612183,
0.4800014793872833,
-0.1340751051902771,
-0.049220599234104156,
-0.3302043676376343,
-0.2479347139596939,
-0.24940085411071777,
0.122505322098732,
0.04344724863767624,
-0.3355853855609894,
0.0900820791721344,
-0.42227262258529663,
0.40991896390914917,
0.26786577701568604,
-0.29937809705734253,
-0.2408217191696167,
0.6175190806388855,
0.11450346559286118,
-0.5283687710762024,
0.18277037143707275,
0.3354122042655945,
-0.7173119187355042,
0.8243272304534912,
0.5099391341209412,
0.9047490358352661,
-0.0750817060470581,
0.39134350419044495,
0.02343039959669113,
0.4326140284538269,
-0.04043330252170563,
0.23862378299236298,
-0.10125859081745148,
-0.6331662535667419,
-0.23736342787742615,
-0.34509187936782837,
-0.8325818777084351,
0.3528377413749695,
-0.7741076350212097,
0.3338126242160797,
-0.5325306057929993,
-0.24761994183063507,
-0.11403924971818924,
0.052789460867643356,
-0.7745009660720825,
-0.059804145246744156,
0.2089538276195526,
0.7921954989433289,
-0.7364142537117004,
0.4569607973098755,
0.17852488160133362,
-0.8855763673782349,
-0.7999703288078308,
0.15473198890686035,
0.1335756480693817,
-0.47839444875717163,
0.35738909244537354,
0.014830329455435276,
-0.21314848959445953,
0.0016999889630824327,
-0.5330455899238586,
-0.4661175310611725,
0.941308319568634,
0.7125071287155151,
-0.43350425362586975,
0.32670047879219055,
0.15257364511489868,
0.5374773144721985,
-0.2703295052051544,
0.013061540201306343,
0.8931419253349304,
0.035009097307920456,
0.03781965747475624,
-0.8997016549110413,
-0.04069506749510765,
0.03142010420560837,
-0.04169829562306404,
0.01663990318775177,
-0.368801474571228,
0.705632209777832,
-0.026020092889666557,
-0.3544650971889496,
0.23964303731918335,
-0.10045897960662842,
0.30561769008636475,
0.27821722626686096,
0.39821451902389526,
0.5016903877258301,
0.7509196996688843,
0.11621573567390442,
1.045595645904541,
-0.3660983741283417,
0.8236551284790039,
1.115384578704834,
-0.3318352997303009,
0.9734940528869629,
0.5139535069465637,
-0.2740984559059143,
0.15535315871238708,
0.3193369507789612,
0.3388300836086273,
0.5701663494110107,
0.6015008091926575,
-0.38243311643600464,
0.2473294883966446,
-0.08622053265571594,
-0.36543798446655273,
0.48158785700798035,
0.1161227822303772,
-0.6197543144226074,
-0.10777772217988968,
0.2024238556623459,
0.32698941230773926,
0.16259868443012238,
-0.08582530170679092,
0.839949369430542,
0.2049945592880249,
-0.6140588521957397,
0.795505702495575,
-0.1443253606557846,
-0.008556279353797436,
-0.21304014325141907,
0.009824576787650585,
-0.33611974120140076,
0.3459121584892273,
-0.06811483204364777,
-0.6018622517585754,
0.43917325139045715,
0.21368375420570374,
0.13278241455554962,
0.04015931859612465,
0.5113810300827026,
-0.6302827596664429,
-0.12902288138866425,
0.5929387807846069,
0.43039655685424805,
0.32503068447113037,
-0.004083156585693359,
-0.5666622519493103,
0.3656580448150635,
-0.12118302285671234,
-0.18634071946144104,
0.15077558159828186,
-0.06982745230197906,
0.09589571505784988,
0.5841534733772278,
0.5554577112197876,
0.42664480209350586,
0.04333391785621643,
0.2808701992034912,
0.8490846157073975,
-0.45563995838165283,
-0.2924889624118805,
-0.8014219999313354,
0.3828902244567871,
-0.054141998291015625,
-0.02647465094923973,
0.49579325318336487,
0.36081361770629883,
0.9825096726417542,
-0.14247089624404907,
0.960283100605011,
-0.09705960750579834,
0.22513145208358765,
-0.8860616087913513,
1.0663021802902222,
-0.5291137099266052,
0.7433947324752808,
-0.5042105317115784,
-0.9887868165969849,
-0.300200492143631,
0.3020053803920746,
-0.35087594389915466,
-0.04494450241327286,
0.7655512094497681,
0.6979599595069885,
0.001998844323679805,
0.1696651428937912,
0.3494139313697815,
-0.25532662868499756,
0.4756949543952942,
0.2634426951408386,
1.0295144319534302,
-0.4958004355430603,
0.5828080773353577,
-0.4697185754776001,
-0.104647196829319,
0.018994195386767387,
-1.0139847993850708,
-0.897392988204956,
-0.5322727560997009,
-0.19484995305538177,
-0.5444358587265015,
0.17050997912883759,
1.015628695487976,
0.35231003165245056,
-0.8856601715087891,
-0.09879714250564575,
0.1293678879737854,
0.2968406081199646,
-0.019383076578378677,
-0.16099290549755096,
0.4841673970222473,
-0.1861499696969986,
-0.523737907409668,
0.030866116285324097,
-0.013483438640832901,
0.21077637374401093,
-0.4675161838531494,
-0.07196557521820068,
-0.08286499232053757,
0.37732255458831787,
0.4643942713737488,
0.5182932615280151,
-0.7939306497573853,
-0.43628785014152527,
-0.2608659267425537,
-0.011915244162082672,
-0.3452558219432831,
1.1610277891159058,
-0.3954439163208008,
0.7737547159194946,
0.525104284286499,
0.7053619623184204,
0.33740875124931335,
0.005244899541139603,
0.5813771486282349,
-0.6703976988792419,
0.13546599447727203,
0.19156022369861603,
0.5271381735801697,
0.2684655487537384,
-0.0995463877916336,
0.41609907150268555,
0.06042042747139931,
-0.6376129388809204,
-0.9704685211181641,
-0.05326065793633461,
-0.5752624273300171,
-0.2419937700033188,
1.005823016166687,
-0.5068142414093018,
-0.1350562870502472,
-0.09940388053655624,
-0.39195236563682556,
0.4218672215938568,
0.09743669629096985,
0.936744213104248,
0.7645277380943298,
0.5349610447883606,
-0.20363520085811615,
-0.6936123967170715,
0.4960075616836548,
0.41415536403656006,
-0.715107798576355,
0.41708609461784363,
0.42403462529182434,
0.6499310731887817,
-0.08895313739776611,
0.5792140960693359,
-0.6332303881645203,
0.16998600959777832,
-0.28962060809135437,
0.32248011231422424,
-0.09233860671520233,
-0.407731831073761,
-0.9913439750671387,
-0.042905811220407486,
0.20267903804779053,
-0.17319299280643463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18534v1 | Towards Compositionality in Concept Learning | 2024-06-26T17:59:30 | 2024-06-26T17:59:30 | Adam Stein, Aaditya Naik, Yinjun Wu, Mayur Naik, Eric Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Concept-based interpretability methods offer a lens into the internals of
foundation models by decomposing their embeddings into high-level concepts.
These concept representations are most useful when they are compositional,
meaning that the individual concepts compose to explain the full sample. We
show that existing unsupervised concept extraction methods find concepts which
are not compositional. To automatically discover compositional concept
representations, we identify two salient properties of such representations,
and propose Compositional Concept Extraction (CCE) for finding concepts which
obey these properties. We evaluate CCE on five different datasets over image
and text data. Our evaluation shows that CCE finds more compositional concept
representations than baselines and yields better accuracy on four downstream
classification tasks. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/adaminsky/compositional_concepts . | [
-0.37105289101600647,
-0.3850628137588501,
0.6386789679527283,
0.09753863513469696,
-0.43957802653312683,
0.5191038846969604,
-0.2687714397907257,
-0.5482884645462036,
0.25144147872924805,
0.2901597023010254,
-0.4147615134716034,
-0.5987820625305176,
-0.6667284965515137,
-0.11011066287755966,
-0.5294296145439148,
0.6044976115226746,
-0.14805658161640167,
0.008057674393057823,
-0.6291466951370239,
0.017940346151590347,
-0.761542797088623,
0.03768610209226608,
-0.29109740257263184,
-0.4458490014076233,
0.09168622642755508,
0.38889777660369873,
0.10992579907178879,
0.7043218016624451,
0.5074647665023804,
0.23212745785713196,
-0.17551356554031372,
0.03227784112095833,
-0.35659199953079224,
0.05681305006146431,
-0.3820037543773651,
-0.5997816920280457,
0.12096501886844635,
0.1671903133392334,
0.46247926354408264,
0.9233297109603882,
-0.1857651323080063,
-0.06682480871677399,
0.11375169456005096,
0.4871937036514282,
-0.952231764793396,
0.6318387389183044,
-0.45657283067703247,
0.1804269701242447,
0.0932440459728241,
-0.22973696887493134,
-0.5705251693725586,
0.29740145802497864,
0.5453428030014038,
-0.7773935794830322,
0.21325257420539856,
-0.261167049407959,
0.5168129801750183,
0.25226113200187683,
-0.3032311797142029,
-0.6227772235870361,
-0.373516321182251,
0.8919616937637329,
-0.28241166472435,
0.5475999712944031,
0.21534030139446259,
0.20231424272060394,
0.27739498019218445,
-0.6499319672584534,
-0.4855828285217285,
-0.047925226390361786,
-0.30066728591918945,
0.47652336955070496,
-0.042533304542303085,
-0.045936357229948044,
-0.07266559451818466,
0.6600185036659241,
-0.2606264352798462,
-0.12208792567253113,
-0.23790746927261353,
-0.23787569999694824,
0.6927307844161987,
-0.02580448053777218,
0.31323522329330444,
-0.3795098662376404,
-0.31629008054733276,
-0.030412642285227776,
-0.3856039047241211,
0.24708911776542664,
-0.11237568408250809,
0.22483499348163605,
-0.2514503002166748,
0.7555282711982727,
-0.15881125628948212,
0.5210371017456055,
0.17686015367507935,
-0.26343339681625366,
0.1710733324289322,
-0.2231724113225937,
-0.2658296823501587,
0.16728173196315765,
0.35023072361946106,
0.08508791774511337,
0.07530731707811356,
-0.5532604455947876,
-0.12609532475471497,
0.21967428922653198,
0.43793317675590515,
-0.7159475684165955,
-0.48464730381965637,
0.2237161546945572,
-0.48199793696403503,
-0.37060362100601196,
0.7075156569480896,
-0.42544856667518616,
-0.32989701628685,
-0.6089487075805664,
0.28823888301849365,
-0.4541359841823578,
-0.35841232538223267,
0.08671527355909348,
-0.5460134148597717,
0.3848841190338135,
0.3052522540092468,
-0.919978678226471,
0.14606663584709167,
0.6765009760856628,
1.0126346349716187,
-0.6879739761352539,
0.04679214954376221,
-0.0215659961104393,
0.18508902192115784,
-0.5223310589790344,
0.7489535212516785,
-0.6217226386070251,
-0.792577862739563,
-0.3328372836112976,
0.10320888459682465,
-0.2896280586719513,
-0.6750971078872681,
0.343206524848938,
-0.41506245732307434,
0.03290456533432007,
-0.46068915724754333,
-0.9687433242797852,
-0.3414834439754486,
0.07244233042001724,
-0.783018946647644,
0.7706870436668396,
0.36269208788871765,
-0.7331913113594055,
0.41134265065193176,
-0.8069900274276733,
-0.4062485694885254,
-0.0033669352997094393,
-0.2865745723247528,
-0.04353297874331474,
0.5093209147453308,
-0.020118189975619316,
0.6644482016563416,
-0.0632176622748375,
0.15118549764156342,
-0.05931181460618973,
-0.37528958916664124,
0.24643418192863464,
0.013541329652071,
0.6476979851722717,
0.2436629980802536,
-0.2760884761810303,
-0.16728416085243225,
-0.7855336666107178,
-0.07687343657016754,
0.24112248420715332,
-0.09681209176778793,
-0.45500966906547546,
0.2720678448677063,
-0.08019711077213287,
-0.014234865084290504,
0.1674332320690155,
-0.5198520421981812,
-0.30383920669555664,
-0.4067578613758087,
0.48021891713142395,
0.6596189141273499,
0.11167372763156891,
0.8301264643669128,
-0.17105190455913544,
0.36374223232269287,
0.4456460475921631,
-0.3875933587551117,
-0.23533478379249573,
-0.2559978663921356,
-0.6189209222793579,
-0.6513123512268066,
0.13890810310840607,
0.31364908814430237,
-0.6523780822753906,
0.6856364607810974,
-0.2576504647731781,
-0.4920496642589569,
-0.12124504148960114,
0.24553626775741577,
0.2765505909919739,
0.5207521319389343,
0.33376285433769226,
-0.7023499608039856,
-0.3477274179458618,
-0.6403478384017944,
0.1056075394153595,
-0.05636642128229141,
0.2991689145565033,
0.021395279094576836,
0.6409860253334045,
-0.05564139783382416,
1.262115716934204,
-0.8337267637252808,
0.019379984587430954,
-0.015639934688806534,
0.22107498347759247,
-0.23778188228607178,
0.48759210109710693,
0.38797998428344727,
-1.0895355939865112,
-0.3936821520328522,
0.20685793459415436,
-0.9986572265625,
0.18477609753608704,
0.08091381937265396,
-0.06351571530103683,
-0.1545744240283966,
0.4113352596759796,
-0.4778742492198944,
0.2744399309158325,
0.25834646821022034,
-0.12281186878681183,
0.3107024133205414,
0.2918790578842163,
-0.33401021361351013,
-1.1916429996490479,
0.08549980074167252,
0.3069540560245514,
-0.11231804639101028,
-0.2896616756916046,
0.4119097590446472,
0.09742400050163269,
-0.009810843504965305,
-0.31476908922195435,
0.37292250990867615,
-0.40345174074172974,
-0.28460001945495605,
-0.2273527979850769,
-0.03465414419770241,
0.41554003953933716,
0.13632047176361084,
0.5293159484863281,
0.772693932056427,
0.6031860113143921,
-0.6100826263427734,
0.38511160016059875,
0.4496837258338928,
-0.44296973943710327,
0.9811439514160156,
-0.5610963702201843,
-0.12475601583719254,
-0.3591013252735138,
0.21815437078475952,
-0.9380592107772827,
-0.3041222393512726,
0.1809341013431549,
-0.23051494359970093,
0.4567524194717407,
-0.01329727191478014,
-0.13553127646446228,
-0.03924994543194771,
-0.11762245744466782,
0.07481606304645538,
0.04145442321896553,
-0.5874708890914917,
0.6617019772529602,
0.19894957542419434,
0.12571319937705994,
-0.7776541113853455,
-0.7672246098518372,
-0.21342362463474274,
-0.30619314312934875,
-0.3517441749572754,
0.5897210836410522,
-0.16546596586704254,
-0.1890273243188858,
0.2373439520597458,
-0.5247453451156616,
-0.24949431419372559,
0.4531566798686981,
0.30174779891967773,
0.033383116126060486,
-0.295637309551239,
0.34905779361724854,
0.04630498215556145,
-0.06490592658519745,
0.24216751754283905,
-0.43699827790260315,
0.2805774509906769,
0.006923462264239788,
-0.2472318857908249,
-0.4023136794567108,
0.383226215839386,
0.41035592555999756,
-0.4421607255935669,
0.5272225737571716,
0.6285976767539978,
-0.5697362422943115,
-0.46662637591362,
-0.01946304179728031,
-0.28839144110679626,
-0.36722660064697266,
0.3312462568283081,
-0.5785001516342163,
-0.6460102796554565,
0.5741431713104248,
-0.08334576338529587,
-0.1241205558180809,
0.5321195125579834,
0.21253590285778046,
-0.4631752073764801,
0.4501391053199768,
0.8026323318481445,
0.1915050446987152,
0.5111477971076965,
-1.0023385286331177,
0.14289967715740204,
-0.7150179743766785,
-0.61012864112854,
-0.2876368463039398,
-0.07993998378515244,
-0.5342470407485962,
-0.2616663873195648,
0.13650669157505035,
0.12798883020877838,
0.09588732570409775,
0.297860324382782,
-0.5087416768074036,
0.7287859320640564,
0.28555598855018616,
0.37138932943344116,
0.5539751052856445,
0.022836558520793915,
-0.02693246863782406,
-0.004680628422647715,
-0.21923628449440002,
-0.34866851568222046,
1.0024089813232422,
0.09813681989908218,
0.5047236084938049,
0.03581773489713669,
0.7791432738304138,
0.2645561993122101,
0.34200453758239746,
-1.3794407844543457,
0.1880415827035904,
-0.37654539942741394,
-0.6996611952781677,
-0.0574343204498291,
-0.3674654960632324,
-0.5044244527816772,
0.33924204111099243,
-0.3003458082675934,
-0.6563886404037476,
0.6224794387817383,
-0.16511686146259308,
-0.0367744117975235,
0.06287000328302383,
-0.7540038228034973,
0.8817198276519775,
0.07132676988840103,
0.0018717366037890315,
-0.2982710301876068,
-0.5754455924034119,
0.4037172198295593,
-0.3414369821548462,
-0.06298753619194031,
0.08615203946828842,
0.04205503314733505,
0.44683632254600525,
-0.1888689547777176,
0.98331618309021,
-0.14575637876987457,
-0.3766321539878845,
0.4439065456390381,
0.06829620152711868,
0.010862979106605053,
-0.031340066343545914,
0.02950383350253105,
0.01255795918405056,
0.239590585231781,
-0.5253971219062805,
-0.909842848777771,
0.3809114694595337,
-0.7840415239334106,
-0.22592154145240784,
-0.3686504065990448,
-0.3335922956466675,
-0.19643251597881317,
0.04982772096991539,
0.3382740914821625,
0.4570208489894867,
-0.4306168556213379,
0.4420820474624634,
0.7860747575759888,
0.2915060222148895,
0.5133585929870605,
0.2144918143749237,
0.2918965518474579,
-0.07580890506505966,
1.1927008628845215,
0.07009908556938171,
0.22743408381938934,
0.7572023868560791,
0.17806722223758698,
-0.47393572330474854,
-0.6276678442955017,
-0.27505040168762207,
-0.09014006704092026,
-1.093603491783142,
-0.08314741402864456,
-0.5007389187812805,
-0.2537550926208496,
0.20522844791412354,
-0.30589327216148376,
-0.27608561515808105,
-0.5539883971214294,
-0.762964129447937,
-0.4088176488876343,
-0.12642455101013184,
0.6596029996871948,
-0.06338091939687729,
0.6028620004653931,
-0.4850543141365051,
0.2265559434890747,
0.44368305802345276,
0.12403984367847443,
0.05909135565161705,
-0.2603718638420105,
-0.3572494387626648,
-0.06179063022136688,
-0.557799756526947,
-0.8421961665153503,
-0.0779275968670845,
0.33246445655822754,
0.6010050773620605,
0.6897372007369995,
-0.2607411742210388,
0.5097934007644653,
0.22985604405403137,
0.6428128480911255,
0.2700430452823639,
-1.4003957509994507,
0.5908214449882507,
-0.09717094153165817,
-0.22140808403491974,
0.592764675617218,
0.5347810983657837,
-0.38807085156440735,
0.06303488463163376,
-0.7079429626464844,
-0.4398958683013916,
0.3343730866909027,
0.0226677767932415,
0.3151462972164154,
0.04846027120947838,
0.5526494383811951,
0.2537929117679596,
0.3056798577308655,
-0.6513077020645142,
-0.11259494721889496,
-0.6566286087036133,
-0.6153135895729065,
-0.2728634476661682,
-0.08972939848899841,
-0.03847714141011238,
-0.17000386118888855,
0.5066612958908081,
-0.5243083238601685,
0.18212848901748657,
0.1855887770652771,
-0.4556677043437958,
-0.03685237094759941,
0.18915940821170807,
0.1892130821943283,
0.9920708537101746,
-0.17794117331504822,
0.28449776768684387,
-0.32181841135025024,
-0.3631245493888855,
0.24473600089550018,
0.042294204235076904,
-0.2201719880104065,
-0.13643750548362732,
0.7545250058174133,
0.5400909185409546,
0.35185787081718445,
-0.7936739325523376,
0.6888456344604492,
0.25574901700019836,
-0.08321717381477356,
-0.25254952907562256,
0.31242835521698,
0.12905041873455048,
0.10649062693119049,
0.2159738540649414,
-0.03241203725337982,
0.37585291266441345,
-0.7558714151382446,
0.18361711502075195,
0.4929291307926178,
-0.4685012400150299,
-0.4354742467403412,
0.24458666145801544,
0.044397734105587006,
0.6050884127616882,
0.4484066963195801,
-0.1732511818408966,
-0.23659959435462952,
0.7238333225250244,
0.5087780356407166,
0.704645037651062,
-0.024096449837088585,
0.6716439723968506,
0.23881405591964722,
-0.025736726820468903,
-0.06087397411465645,
0.20130246877670288,
-0.35164955258369446,
-1.2484906911849976,
-0.5772033929824829,
-0.5369795560836792,
-0.4891512989997864,
-0.23067252337932587,
-0.9764610528945923,
-0.02864861860871315,
-0.3986291289329529,
0.2521124482154846,
0.460415780544281,
0.09475608915090561,
-0.4375430643558502,
0.5534989833831787,
-0.0728158950805664,
0.751136302947998,
-1.0400692224502563,
0.38782885670661926,
1.0048736333847046,
-0.6705192923545837,
-0.7412744760513306,
-0.04298301786184311,
-0.07327577471733093,
-0.7533280849456787,
0.5678012371063232,
0.14578582346439362,
-0.06764384359121323,
0.1283859759569168,
-0.8610183596611023,
-0.508324921131134,
1.3638955354690552,
0.31875813007354736,
-0.22831548750400543,
-0.07953233271837234,
0.022466439753770828,
0.4130125343799591,
-0.7350378036499023,
0.02181849628686905,
0.6914052963256836,
0.39012855291366577,
0.5372864007949829,
-0.3571140468120575,
-0.026756172999739647,
-0.06819239258766174,
-0.05620594695210457,
-0.16472604870796204,
-0.39405104517936707,
0.6313155293464661,
-0.0901506096124649,
-0.3430274724960327,
0.014473551884293556,
0.640816330909729,
0.10490259528160095,
0.6307921409606934,
0.38423654437065125,
0.8071045875549316,
0.8676674365997314,
-0.19547277688980103,
0.8478536009788513,
-0.07058925926685333,
0.4689635932445526,
0.9087418913841248,
0.020113268867135048,
0.6879797577857971,
0.39604657888412476,
-0.028020085766911507,
0.7434666752815247,
0.861086368560791,
-0.02094549499452114,
0.8163591623306274,
0.04758689925074577,
-0.2733750343322754,
-0.33128783106803894,
-0.3074907064437866,
-0.1367337554693222,
0.9837461113929749,
0.5141078233718872,
-0.46670615673065186,
0.013556215912103653,
-0.038584690541028976,
-0.18630094826221466,
0.21549241244792938,
-0.18934114277362823,
0.9619368314743042,
0.4120064675807953,
-0.3495478928089142,
0.2623557448387146,
0.05502291023731232,
0.33363255858421326,
-0.30722880363464355,
-0.06660409271717072,
-0.12611694633960724,
-0.09941855818033218,
-0.3809621036052704,
-0.6645405292510986,
0.403153657913208,
-0.45049697160720825,
-0.3973240554332733,
0.0392061322927475,
0.7100434303283691,
-0.27674829959869385,
-0.3588210642337799,
0.16724249720573425,
0.9861177802085876,
-0.20061369240283966,
-0.2918057143688202,
-0.4227631986141205,
-0.2048420011997223,
-0.16148783266544342,
0.14806310832500458,
-0.12175281345844269,
0.49354153871536255,
-0.011506311595439911,
0.5440663695335388,
0.4571182131767273,
-0.08152584731578827,
-0.3014291822910309,
-0.2297922670841217,
0.8105494379997253,
-0.6914740800857544,
-0.5348150134086609,
-0.6198142170906067,
0.593803346157074,
-0.06507758051156998,
-0.058055054396390915,
0.3724345862865448,
0.5242120623588562,
1.0683820247650146,
-0.16594460606575012,
0.8851286768913269,
-0.13399279117584229,
0.026130789890885353,
-0.7107413411140442,
0.23445703089237213,
-0.5852694511413574,
0.028402045369148254,
-0.30470386147499084,
-1.0953872203826904,
-0.12432313710451126,
0.8207891583442688,
-0.0748048946261406,
-0.03416305407881737,
0.8478220105171204,
0.42653465270996094,
-0.34959080815315247,
0.7384160161018372,
0.0849151462316513,
-0.10927818715572357,
0.17096580564975739,
0.17458665370941162,
1.0381202697753906,
-0.036684855818748474,
-0.1580212116241455,
-0.44637811183929443,
-0.05219423025846481,
0.11356167495250702,
-0.7909290194511414,
-0.7717463970184326,
-0.7093162536621094,
-0.42307808995246887,
0.011332469061017036,
-0.07954524457454681,
0.7753426432609558,
1.0351966619491577,
-0.9178821444511414,
-0.027671238407492638,
-0.44712668657302856,
0.25330302119255066,
-0.3650234341621399,
-0.2739802300930023,
0.42819398641586304,
-0.1964937001466751,
-0.5474131107330322,
0.4467061161994934,
0.09011488407850266,
0.2890535891056061,
-0.39538607001304626,
-0.04385935887694359,
0.316813200712204,
-0.05050572752952576,
0.7845873236656189,
0.015962200239300728,
-0.5654506683349609,
-0.16290967166423798,
-0.066974937915802,
0.28952786326408386,
0.19806000590324402,
1.1267307996749878,
-0.3840630054473877,
0.629603385925293,
0.3638579845428467,
0.838476836681366,
0.5573089718818665,
0.1348450928926468,
0.19928966462612152,
-1.0088087320327759,
0.019711868837475777,
0.11711429804563522,
0.506252646446228,
0.44212430715560913,
-0.3369026482105255,
0.6909852623939514,
0.7865666747093201,
0.22194702923297882,
-0.3717222809791565,
0.24422697722911835,
-1.312626600265503,
-0.4547126293182373,
0.6641950607299805,
-0.39544185996055603,
-0.03284069150686264,
-0.02620956301689148,
0.10085023194551468,
0.01974726840853691,
-0.24690498411655426,
0.4749957025051117,
0.9490603804588318,
-0.0342959463596344,
-0.380916029214859,
-0.35816341638565063,
0.08943455666303635,
0.016203224658966064,
-1.051471471786499,
-0.3039092421531677,
0.4605867862701416,
0.41794508695602417,
0.3839419484138489,
0.33278846740722656,
-0.18603800237178802,
0.1309099942445755,
-0.2848520278930664,
-0.042985446751117706,
0.0517544150352478,
-0.45029887557029724,
-0.037847165018320084,
0.05984601750969887,
0.01619395799934864,
-0.053048040717840195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18532v1 | Symbolic Learning Enables Self-Evolving Agents | 2024-06-26T17:59:18 | 2024-06-26T17:59:18 | Wangchunshu Zhou, Yixin Ou, Shengwei Ding, Long Li, Jialong Wu, Tiannan Wang, Jiamin Chen, Shuai Wang, Xiaohua Xu, Ningyu Zhang, Huajun Chen, Yuchen Eleanor Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The AI community has been exploring a pathway to artificial general
intelligence (AGI) by developing "language agents", which are complex large
language models (LLMs) pipelines involving both prompting techniques and tool
usage methods. While language agents have demonstrated impressive capabilities
for many real-world tasks, a fundamental limitation of current language agents
research is that they are model-centric, or engineering-centric. That's to say,
the progress on prompts, tools, and pipelines of language agents requires
substantial manual engineering efforts from human experts rather than
automatically learning from data. We believe the transition from model-centric,
or engineering-centric, to data-centric, i.e., the ability of language agents
to autonomously learn and evolve in environments, is the key for them to
possibly achieve AGI.
In this work, we introduce agent symbolic learning, a systematic framework
that enables language agents to optimize themselves on their own in a
data-centric way using symbolic optimizers. Specifically, we consider agents as
symbolic networks where learnable weights are defined by prompts, tools, and
the way they are stacked together. Agent symbolic learning is designed to
optimize the symbolic network within language agents by mimicking two
fundamental algorithms in connectionist learning: back-propagation and gradient
descent. Instead of dealing with numeric weights, agent symbolic learning works
with natural language simulacrums of weights, loss, and gradients. We conduct
proof-of-concept experiments on both standard benchmarks and complex real-world
tasks and show that agent symbolic learning enables language agents to update
themselves after being created and deployed in the wild, resulting in
"self-evolving agents". | [
-0.16883023083209991,
-0.7596394419670105,
0.4720885157585144,
0.14198771119117737,
0.037004463374614716,
0.5733287930488586,
-0.02385053224861622,
-0.25660473108291626,
0.2559841573238373,
0.32778507471084595,
-0.733073353767395,
-0.41201239824295044,
-0.39389508962631226,
0.2743465304374695,
-0.19193871319293976,
1.0266809463500977,
0.03431019186973572,
-0.09551263600587845,
-0.16321441531181335,
-0.2334723323583603,
-0.5958409905433655,
-0.3953647017478943,
-0.9691884517669678,
-0.5432429313659668,
0.4284265339374542,
0.1776231974363327,
0.8763866424560547,
1.2605153322219849,
0.03998972475528717,
0.43321824073791504,
0.5008890628814697,
0.1909441351890564,
-0.3741421401500702,
0.576578676700592,
-0.19858255982398987,
-0.5738598704338074,
-0.1543722301721573,
0.14449454843997955,
0.5447853803634644,
0.4062948226928711,
-0.16001014411449432,
0.11320315301418304,
-0.21944938600063324,
0.7643101811408997,
-0.3508686423301697,
0.7309832572937012,
-0.7061105966567993,
0.23314373195171356,
0.1615271419286728,
-0.3229474127292633,
-0.4173122048377991,
-0.1263069212436676,
-0.0005757337203249335,
-0.7399247288703918,
0.059612758457660675,
-0.09354541450738907,
0.5395865440368652,
0.6343445777893066,
-0.3158193826675415,
-0.28702548146247864,
-0.7146565914154053,
0.7579753398895264,
-0.1353393793106079,
0.5285511612892151,
0.0771641805768013,
0.6357129812240601,
-0.2631230056285858,
-0.7227715253829956,
-0.3964807689189911,
-0.6081799268722534,
0.15459658205509186,
0.03904154151678085,
-0.3191123604774475,
-0.06096266210079193,
-0.0734897032380104,
-0.18773338198661804,
-0.5151847004890442,
0.12504757940769196,
-0.2771873474121094,
-0.01773197017610073,
0.8502950072288513,
0.16245734691619873,
0.5742828249931335,
0.2925451397895813,
-0.15486855804920197,
-0.459707647562027,
-0.6746862530708313,
-0.028045902028679848,
0.3896288275718689,
0.5562291741371155,
-0.15477275848388672,
-0.003128009382635355,
-0.08572380244731903,
0.3904635012149811,
0.22196659445762634,
0.1621275246143341,
0.376090407371521,
0.17248308658599854,
-0.07050146907567978,
0.29213976860046387,
0.6974655985832214,
-0.3816118836402893,
0.697662889957428,
-0.43926700949668884,
-0.4051531255245209,
0.10547231882810593,
0.6782727837562561,
-0.5014285445213318,
-0.3908471465110779,
0.11063095927238464,
-0.10691001266241074,
-0.34874483942985535,
-0.20280982553958893,
-0.1381479650735855,
-0.3701167702674866,
-0.6806493401527405,
0.567243218421936,
-0.4678371548652649,
-0.24437302350997925,
-0.030597178265452385,
-0.09695211797952652,
0.28815895318984985,
0.31861886382102966,
-0.8917741775512695,
0.27567341923713684,
0.749919593334198,
0.7744739055633545,
0.03227613866329193,
-0.7200260758399963,
-0.4759775698184967,
0.13228078186511993,
-0.6589276194572449,
0.7865635752677917,
-0.4384649991989136,
-0.367874413728714,
-0.1554611772298813,
0.05930255725979805,
-0.21412967145442963,
-0.4165384769439697,
-0.07891083508729935,
-0.4856604337692261,
0.030273539945483208,
-0.06857353448867798,
-0.11879206448793411,
-0.2614869475364685,
-0.0022759006824344397,
-0.5518149137496948,
0.8537261486053467,
0.3107300400733948,
-0.16553018987178802,
0.24705162644386292,
-0.8163618445396423,
-0.5168288946151733,
0.20547032356262207,
-0.4725012481212616,
-0.33996570110321045,
0.19139407575130463,
-0.07057274878025055,
0.5316789150238037,
-0.18622131645679474,
0.027591802179813385,
-0.3576048016548157,
-0.05427692458033562,
0.01241554506123066,
-0.16305403411388397,
0.6477062702178955,
0.41246870160102844,
-0.4025686979293823,
0.3090481162071228,
-0.39232274889945984,
-0.02485647238790989,
0.5368682742118835,
0.1201699897646904,
-0.40878865122795105,
0.2851225435733795,
-0.502685546875,
0.4606368839740753,
0.1382870078086853,
-0.27696192264556885,
0.33139416575431824,
-0.6028590798377991,
0.35905328392982483,
1.1550241708755493,
-0.14416822791099548,
0.5423728227615356,
-0.41864922642707825,
0.4734489619731903,
0.11377940326929092,
0.2896560728549957,
0.013335750438272953,
-0.10505121201276779,
-0.7747328877449036,
-0.06724192947149277,
-0.17089244723320007,
0.31182485818862915,
-0.9335383772850037,
0.3893897831439972,
-0.40723010897636414,
-0.6530064940452576,
-0.48718389868736267,
0.4448704719543457,
0.03641052171587944,
0.27238762378692627,
0.3772067427635193,
-0.3231028616428375,
-0.16647830605506897,
-0.7119849324226379,
-0.3413526117801666,
-0.5329421758651733,
0.2629118263721466,
0.22082233428955078,
0.5281302332878113,
-0.4178372025489807,
1.1766068935394287,
-0.32838574051856995,
-0.2043607085943222,
-0.5172051191329956,
0.18780021369457245,
-0.20398566126823425,
0.39214885234832764,
0.6916599869728088,
-0.48117271065711975,
-0.4553319215774536,
0.30828914046287537,
-1.1565290689468384,
-0.2239948809146881,
-0.39912986755371094,
-0.06313836574554443,
0.20932821929454803,
0.47725680470466614,
-0.6591601371765137,
0.04756340757012367,
0.3890498876571655,
-0.36118799448013306,
0.4221014976501465,
-0.423575222492218,
-0.4571984112262726,
-0.945868730545044,
-0.26096218824386597,
0.11783449351787567,
-0.22805269062519073,
-0.8048143982887268,
0.17358629405498505,
-0.06708083301782608,
0.030025308951735497,
-0.33890628814697266,
1.066177248954773,
-0.7642053365707397,
0.02429416961967945,
-0.5131973624229431,
-0.006270871963351965,
-0.39172643423080444,
0.595452606678009,
-0.12989473342895508,
0.7227861881256104,
0.9264991879463196,
-0.683546245098114,
0.3230017423629761,
-0.029048370197415352,
0.6269276142120361,
0.3137953281402588,
-0.5959182381629944,
0.26365798711776733,
-0.4237247705459595,
0.021050874143838882,
-0.42120060324668884,
0.16851679980754852,
0.5164449214935303,
-0.30545827746391296,
0.35746169090270996,
0.2642962336540222,
-0.30533409118652344,
-0.14487355947494507,
-0.20393115282058716,
0.35785773396492004,
0.44964244961738586,
-0.5659332871437073,
1.126645803451538,
0.3871123194694519,
-0.06512859463691711,
-0.4694296717643738,
-0.2726130485534668,
0.061800453811883926,
-0.03693358600139618,
-0.3915281593799591,
-0.3785020112991333,
-0.01123999897390604,
-0.28765881061553955,
0.04167771711945534,
-0.36799782514572144,
0.1405310332775116,
0.394014447927475,
0.3787567615509033,
-0.028828928247094154,
-0.1666758507490158,
0.5547754168510437,
0.21450111269950867,
-0.3150312900543213,
0.5646480917930603,
-0.6642521619796753,
0.5681238174438477,
-0.374752938747406,
-0.30667343735694885,
-0.2029087096452713,
-0.008652257733047009,
0.38824084401130676,
-0.388680100440979,
0.6883073449134827,
0.3402450978755951,
-0.043292488902807236,
-0.9526941180229187,
-0.23187394440174103,
-0.38371598720550537,
-0.5323165655136108,
0.5255205631256104,
-0.6338755488395691,
-0.7473939657211304,
0.32078981399536133,
-0.3436799645423889,
0.2557210624217987,
0.6803910732269287,
0.4163645803928375,
0.14621113240718842,
1.1567175388336182,
0.8397807478904724,
-0.32128357887268066,
0.5462005138397217,
-0.42738595604896545,
-0.031078729778528214,
-0.14181357622146606,
-0.082813560962677,
-0.441954106092453,
-0.30404341220855713,
-0.5779376029968262,
-0.2950727045536041,
0.25374606251716614,
-0.4344654083251953,
-0.6789298057556152,
0.21651208400726318,
-0.5084086060523987,
0.5060728788375854,
0.47563090920448303,
0.0006820791750214994,
0.10644847899675369,
0.01001987885683775,
0.15271560847759247,
0.5097231268882751,
-0.613616406917572,
-0.33878666162490845,
1.088261604309082,
0.5015558004379272,
0.9623839855194092,
-0.03416252136230469,
0.8779322504997253,
0.7351599335670471,
0.369582861661911,
-0.7411550879478455,
0.6648013591766357,
0.12918461859226227,
-0.161073699593544,
-0.4692988395690918,
-0.5288342833518982,
-1.2562402486801147,
0.14579445123672485,
0.11845123022794724,
-0.4079531133174896,
0.1813405603170395,
0.1353929340839386,
0.20042070746421814,
-0.012741013430058956,
-0.5761756896972656,
0.9352365136146545,
-0.6187716126441956,
-0.032305654138326645,
-0.5421366095542908,
-0.9281483292579651,
-0.17691268026828766,
-0.4054878056049347,
-0.07238776236772537,
-0.07537980377674103,
-0.2720889449119568,
0.5084271430969238,
-0.33390873670578003,
0.9753909111022949,
-0.2816023826599121,
-0.2176329642534256,
0.3749926686286926,
0.35708656907081604,
0.6589862108230591,
-0.2968909442424774,
0.07803267985582352,
0.28386741876602173,
-0.2685757875442505,
-0.425228476524353,
-1.0116721391677856,
0.416150838136673,
-1.2951011657714844,
-0.8253426551818848,
-0.6336551904678345,
-0.4699768126010895,
-0.10083876550197601,
-0.01695050671696663,
-0.41741254925727844,
0.131785050034523,
-0.12756043672561646,
-0.11028171330690384,
0.396700918674469,
0.14816473424434662,
0.3889468312263489,
0.6424340605735779,
-0.10308703035116196,
-0.05703354999423027,
1.1540203094482422,
0.08632373064756393,
0.3017372190952301,
0.09922472387552261,
0.34463393688201904,
-0.3131310045719147,
-0.2861107289791107,
-0.392063170671463,
0.6214419007301331,
-0.8523231148719788,
-0.013811159878969193,
-0.7308743596076965,
-0.4745941460132599,
-0.34624120593070984,
-0.11964686959981918,
-0.37485840916633606,
-0.17366543412208557,
-0.282727986574173,
-0.1385902315378189,
0.3287194073200226,
0.9687248468399048,
-0.13129130005836487,
0.41411706805229187,
-0.49095404148101807,
-0.03281057998538017,
0.41085323691368103,
-0.024846751242876053,
0.021347004920244217,
-0.34042996168136597,
-0.4133742153644562,
0.165293350815773,
-0.49940598011016846,
-0.9150240421295166,
0.5906739830970764,
0.49597176909446716,
0.7781248688697815,
0.39133402705192566,
0.02799435518682003,
0.40477585792541504,
-0.30474647879600525,
0.3742634356021881,
-0.13735978305339813,
-0.8793085217475891,
0.6804612874984741,
-0.2397824376821518,
0.3268264830112457,
0.3744480609893799,
0.43900659680366516,
-0.6084828972816467,
-0.5184528827667236,
-0.5701076984405518,
-0.4076583683490753,
0.7507393956184387,
0.10289642959833145,
0.35503581166267395,
-0.027790052816271782,
0.5028874278068542,
0.1834346354007721,
0.3186017572879791,
-0.8140951991081238,
-0.42972755432128906,
-0.4420976936817169,
-0.4308159649372101,
-0.2628346383571625,
0.4089753031730652,
-0.03833955526351929,
-0.1783202886581421,
0.8012188673019409,
-0.7404460310935974,
0.2721080780029297,
-0.04386293515563011,
-0.21104900538921356,
-0.17771345376968384,
0.04384260252118111,
0.14415229856967926,
0.49026596546173096,
0.24740174412727356,
0.11006666719913483,
0.1862567812204361,
-0.5017405152320862,
0.49591246247291565,
0.09382258355617523,
-0.11171533912420273,
-0.2181500643491745,
0.12799187004566193,
0.7929208278656006,
-0.2638930380344391,
-0.6575400233268738,
0.2732335031032562,
-0.08489703387022018,
-0.1489245742559433,
-0.3378746509552002,
0.43216413259506226,
-0.35983139276504517,
0.4027155339717865,
0.48365694284439087,
-0.006952614523470402,
-0.0046662394888699055,
-0.6759161949157715,
0.29555240273475647,
0.5799712538719177,
-0.5408852696418762,
-0.6171663999557495,
0.5141527652740479,
0.1427989900112152,
-0.4615786671638489,
0.46131831407546997,
-0.4210566282272339,
-0.43107613921165466,
0.6835253238677979,
0.6639237999916077,
1.5826308727264404,
-0.48322317004203796,
0.5864918231964111,
-0.16686919331550598,
0.42442700266838074,
-0.02019936963915825,
0.0767892599105835,
-0.30069923400878906,
-0.7358235716819763,
-0.11151634156703949,
-0.6222864389419556,
-0.2241750806570053,
-0.3441260755062103,
0.09804744273424149,
0.11984579265117645,
-0.6139779090881348,
0.1165347546339035,
-0.34058454632759094,
0.0665382668375969,
-0.5451815724372864,
0.22102655470371246,
-0.05663994699716568,
0.6644062399864197,
-0.9637483358383179,
0.9295862317085266,
0.9264765977859497,
-0.3228650391101837,
-1.0971431732177734,
-0.10150628536939621,
-0.016673650592565536,
-1.075522780418396,
0.9816203713417053,
0.30159762501716614,
-0.37344738841056824,
0.3205035328865051,
-0.619562029838562,
-0.8901044130325317,
1.152538537979126,
0.7063985466957092,
0.0044896830804646015,
-0.16865457594394684,
0.36787310242652893,
0.7946750521659851,
-0.5252856612205505,
0.32798025012016296,
0.24045433104038239,
0.2644346058368683,
0.052140191197395325,
-0.5721402168273926,
0.11414805799722672,
-0.43485569953918457,
-0.06804091483354568,
0.4385998845100403,
-0.8114444613456726,
0.874193549156189,
-0.0035639104899019003,
-0.47116389870643616,
-0.2823721766471863,
0.8963416218757629,
0.07211523503065109,
0.3131974935531616,
0.6082776784896851,
0.37466952204704285,
0.45338568091392517,
0.013412553817033768,
0.7824655175209045,
-0.6750745177268982,
0.2724396586418152,
0.8257533311843872,
-0.228413388133049,
0.40215736627578735,
0.179319828748703,
0.1663457751274109,
0.7748026251792908,
0.5216078162193298,
0.03661283478140831,
0.2212679088115692,
0.24429813027381897,
-0.2494896650314331,
-0.464189350605011,
-0.13658148050308228,
-0.18864400684833527,
0.6918877363204956,
0.1701153665781021,
-0.3116171360015869,
-0.4002639949321747,
-0.07942984253168106,
-0.03951406106352806,
0.0009176380699500442,
-0.20993080735206604,
0.9977268576622009,
0.08228302747011185,
-0.43228060007095337,
0.3341403603553772,
-0.27955740690231323,
0.021567996591329575,
-0.9171884655952454,
-0.15109290182590485,
-0.263149619102478,
0.21977372467517853,
0.09112679958343506,
-0.35798975825309753,
0.21115629374980927,
-0.4745725691318512,
0.2621064782142639,
-0.3441767394542694,
0.6962752938270569,
-0.1430412381887436,
-0.21312540769577026,
0.44423991441726685,
1.0346730947494507,
0.10835085809230804,
-0.09744754433631897,
-1.0323396921157837,
-0.3372216522693634,
-0.43796366453170776,
-0.2604091167449951,
0.4129732549190521,
0.6770430207252502,
-0.26004424691200256,
1.3618134260177612,
0.5432030558586121,
0.17065024375915527,
-0.20374365150928497,
-0.07764656841754913,
0.893123984336853,
-0.6352559924125671,
-0.7406564354896545,
-1.058204174041748,
0.1964460015296936,
0.18727511167526245,
-0.011293772608041763,
0.7741923928260803,
0.40338027477264404,
0.7522326707839966,
-0.1357288658618927,
0.6992173790931702,
0.18520896136760712,
-0.17599397897720337,
-0.2568443715572357,
0.890059232711792,
-0.7302862405776978,
0.06382434070110321,
-0.12233159691095352,
-0.7950712442398071,
-0.05241153761744499,
0.4621283710002899,
-0.18259568512439728,
0.2951158881187439,
0.6139081716537476,
0.8347617983818054,
0.21150550246238708,
-0.07255038619041443,
0.26550689339637756,
0.3104560673236847,
0.446258544921875,
0.3467627167701721,
0.8901931047439575,
-0.06155768409371376,
0.1906467229127884,
-0.0663270354270935,
-0.06464507430791855,
0.2686409056186676,
-0.4529339075088501,
-0.945074737071991,
-0.7308432459831238,
-0.4478285610675812,
0.0005464627756737173,
0.5580787062644958,
1.3862574100494385,
0.662932813167572,
-0.4109145402908325,
-0.6645483374595642,
-0.39098191261291504,
0.16825427114963531,
-0.4326099157333374,
-0.21373291313648224,
0.12444430589675903,
-0.8766649961471558,
-0.5715609788894653,
0.33849236369132996,
0.5125325322151184,
0.22759298980236053,
-0.6153991222381592,
-0.5315505862236023,
-0.0012097439030185342,
0.14606216549873352,
0.480940580368042,
0.7758391499519348,
-0.49059969186782837,
-0.3879812955856323,
-0.051137812435626984,
-0.06316249817609787,
0.09768912941217422,
0.42759108543395996,
-1.233871340751648,
0.5130181312561035,
0.2005397081375122,
1.0006828308105469,
-0.1264917552471161,
-0.031482186168432236,
0.6653872728347778,
-0.7468523979187012,
-0.07737629860639572,
0.12247086316347122,
-0.03930283710360527,
-0.007950898259878159,
-0.3762284517288208,
0.7304295301437378,
0.5033111572265625,
-0.7997617721557617,
-0.5623002052307129,
0.11904759705066681,
-0.785587728023529,
-0.30392685532569885,
0.8706701397895813,
0.18055014312267303,
-0.5103193521499634,
-0.11478662490844727,
-0.20685818791389465,
0.4273686707019806,
-0.6067761182785034,
1.0448302030563354,
0.09751515090465546,
-0.33311089873313904,
-0.18171213567256927,
-0.27325987815856934,
0.5920881032943726,
0.39108747243881226,
-1.151299238204956,
0.05155005306005478,
0.45894137024879456,
0.0223370548337698,
0.2617742121219635,
0.35844334959983826,
0.5914581418037415,
0.3186509609222412,
-0.10788144171237946,
0.20494583249092102,
-0.1738467812538147,
-0.720308780670166,
-0.598883867263794,
0.08293871581554413,
0.20000553131103516,
-0.15749326348304749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18528v1 | PrExMe! Large Scale Prompt Exploration of Open Source LLMs for Machine Translation and Summarization Evaluation | 2024-06-26T17:56:29 | 2024-06-26T17:56:29 | Christoph Leiter, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the field of NLP. Notably,
their in-context learning capabilities also enable their use as evaluation
metrics for natural language generation, making them particularly advantageous
in low-resource scenarios and time-restricted applications. In this work, we
introduce PrExMe, a large-scale prompt exploration for metrics, where we
evaluate more than 720 prompt templates for open-source LLM-based metrics on
machine translation (MT) and summarization datasets, totalling over 6.6M
evaluations. This extensive comparison (1) serves as a benchmark of the
performance of recent open-source LLMs as metrics and (2) explores the
stability and variability of different prompting strategies. We discover that,
on the one hand, there are scenarios for which prompts are stable. For
instance, some LLMs show idiosyncratic preferences and favor to grade generated
texts with textual labels while others prefer to return numeric scores. On the
other hand, the stability of prompts and model rankings can be susceptible to
seemingly innocuous changes. For example, changing the requested output format
from "0 to 100" to "-1 to +1" can strongly affect the rankings in our
evaluation. Our study contributes to understanding the impact of different
prompting approaches on LLM-based metrics for MT and summarization evaluation,
highlighting the most stable prompting patterns and potential limitations. | [
-0.6378567814826965,
-0.6194190979003906,
0.8657403588294983,
0.5686832070350647,
-0.4071088135242462,
-0.12875325977802277,
-0.5972186923027039,
0.11840774863958359,
0.13205215334892273,
0.34662142395973206,
-0.6904483437538147,
-0.7920408248901367,
-0.7249411344528198,
0.6521710753440857,
-0.15184703469276428,
0.9966880083084106,
-0.07259688526391983,
-0.002303200075402856,
-0.4127517342567444,
-0.23301880061626434,
-0.773043155670166,
-0.5176535248756409,
-0.6980769038200378,
0.07027524709701538,
0.8623428344726562,
0.40096914768218994,
0.6039648056030273,
0.29318904876708984,
0.3258507251739502,
0.29583096504211426,
-0.1905747950077057,
0.09830410778522491,
-0.45438700914382935,
0.46920743584632874,
-0.13187727332115173,
-0.40702661871910095,
-0.5872327089309692,
0.20932093262672424,
0.8735883831977844,
0.729542076587677,
0.09047812223434448,
0.4017302095890045,
0.3386232852935791,
0.6111085414886475,
-0.5745059251785278,
-0.10137663036584854,
-0.4111769497394562,
-0.02740050107240677,
-0.20478038489818573,
-0.32575756311416626,
-0.56452476978302,
-0.5907644033432007,
0.2752213776111603,
-0.4757218360900879,
-0.18082962930202484,
0.17329609394073486,
0.4657284617424011,
0.38357025384902954,
-0.19028139114379883,
-0.37559008598327637,
-0.36888185143470764,
0.9492049813270569,
-0.7911851406097412,
0.19142237305641174,
0.034642815589904785,
0.42042025923728943,
-0.22525009512901306,
-0.7488116025924683,
-0.306721031665802,
-0.3785925507545471,
-0.0005410582525655627,
0.2529059648513794,
-0.42983248829841614,
-0.16367477178573608,
0.33921024203300476,
0.2678672969341278,
-0.6776849627494812,
0.5170689225196838,
0.04183710366487503,
-0.12826381623744965,
0.3014141917228699,
0.41928476095199585,
0.20229707658290863,
-0.23829884827136993,
-0.36394044756889343,
-0.3346242308616638,
-0.9045294523239136,
0.21434074640274048,
0.2428622990846634,
0.3656059205532074,
-0.1685047298669815,
0.6049520969390869,
0.0060507128946483135,
0.6127738356590271,
-0.10398036986589432,
0.10000108182430267,
0.19455817341804504,
-0.529919445514679,
-0.1105610579252243,
-0.007936188951134682,
1.256654143333435,
0.573309600353241,
0.160380020737648,
0.08242049068212509,
-0.4376166760921478,
-0.21513484418392181,
0.05208223685622215,
-0.7505443096160889,
0.167506143450737,
0.33889341354370117,
-0.6246912479400635,
-0.1303945630788803,
0.04107435420155525,
-0.7932340502738953,
-0.4424149692058563,
-0.33526116609573364,
0.533121645450592,
-0.2456897497177124,
-0.04188782349228859,
0.054048988968133926,
-0.01647414080798626,
0.11617667973041534,
0.6045637130737305,
-0.5066719651222229,
0.06949067860841751,
0.5320330858230591,
1.040121078491211,
-0.36542946100234985,
-0.40432268381118774,
-1.001505732536316,
-0.5251089930534363,
-0.5076507925987244,
0.6746280193328857,
-0.4587101936340332,
-0.6741287708282471,
-0.08738718181848526,
-0.019581321626901627,
0.01922084018588066,
-0.7000391483306885,
0.6065167188644409,
-0.3668252229690552,
0.433056503534317,
-0.43522629141807556,
-0.365143746137619,
0.09892315417528152,
0.40589773654937744,
-0.6040523052215576,
0.9813547134399414,
0.13219624757766724,
-0.5786347389221191,
0.3820560872554779,
-0.8637681603431702,
-0.15428508818149567,
0.0011316293384879827,
0.004097120836377144,
-0.2266802340745926,
0.3854028880596161,
0.395573228597641,
0.4637739956378937,
-0.6217144131660461,
0.3321695029735565,
0.052981261163949966,
-0.3082089424133301,
0.2282855361700058,
-0.38911423087120056,
0.5734753608703613,
0.2596483826637268,
-0.25763559341430664,
0.6092385649681091,
-0.6035827398300171,
-0.061807435005903244,
0.061589717864990234,
-0.29394006729125977,
-0.3530573546886444,
-0.11286431550979614,
-0.370421439409256,
0.21238230168819427,
0.21557050943374634,
-0.2783408761024475,
0.340248167514801,
-0.329990953207016,
0.28708457946777344,
0.7566897869110107,
0.06362130492925644,
0.38045287132263184,
-0.18790948390960693,
1.0105737447738647,
-0.0740961879491806,
0.043910667300224304,
-1.0091071128845215,
-0.40880918502807617,
-0.4911729097366333,
-0.16805213689804077,
0.369657963514328,
0.5036124587059021,
-0.5210980772972107,
0.49376776814460754,
-0.33064591884613037,
-0.4016380310058594,
-0.6420621871948242,
0.0667070597410202,
0.2908540964126587,
0.5878958106040955,
0.4761642813682556,
-0.010517771355807781,
-0.3918750286102295,
-0.5975477695465088,
-0.3273182213306427,
0.01340260449796915,
-0.3853414058685303,
0.1607925146818161,
0.2785009741783142,
-0.28825217485427856,
0.954617977142334,
-0.2575761675834656,
-0.004404141567647457,
-0.40819084644317627,
0.4551962614059448,
0.6819226145744324,
0.32018375396728516,
0.6323840618133545,
-0.2065354585647583,
-0.42117729783058167,
-0.3685787320137024,
-0.6078978180885315,
-0.5735990405082703,
-0.16466830670833588,
0.01831146888434887,
-0.006922634784132242,
0.6462101936340332,
-0.46395695209503174,
0.072844959795475,
0.5886651873588562,
-0.2510514557361603,
0.8977718949317932,
-0.17255930602550507,
0.28645849227905273,
-1.2352272272109985,
0.2313397079706192,
-0.17659977078437805,
-0.3795468211174011,
-0.19081085920333862,
-0.11534538865089417,
0.1548883616924286,
-0.2068452537059784,
-0.5508588552474976,
0.6944906115531921,
-0.5635170340538025,
0.042136695235967636,
-0.11105998605489731,
0.46633341908454895,
-0.021512560546398163,
0.03163283318281174,
-0.09474793076515198,
0.948715090751648,
0.6081364750862122,
-0.7686458826065063,
0.20368796586990356,
0.19914409518241882,
-0.46984192728996277,
0.40035274624824524,
-0.8225873708724976,
0.1728091537952423,
-0.1634015589952469,
0.283629447221756,
-0.9777284264564514,
0.172837033867836,
0.13821661472320557,
-0.5773972272872925,
0.16295361518859863,
0.02822728641331196,
-0.6140871047973633,
-0.2205214947462082,
-0.6002619862556458,
0.288359671831131,
0.5747212767601013,
-0.6019485592842102,
0.2945128381252289,
-0.10584481805562973,
-0.6285666823387146,
-0.6181067824363708,
-0.17961031198501587,
0.3673265874385834,
-0.19464467465877533,
-0.5007034540176392,
-0.023369383066892624,
-0.3112486004829407,
-0.33654922246932983,
-0.17606468498706818,
0.06775447726249695,
0.6811690926551819,
0.2658170461654663,
0.2532765865325928,
0.30653923749923706,
-0.49100425839424133,
-0.12633806467056274,
0.20225965976715088,
-0.39139533042907715,
0.3109598457813263,
-0.4720790684223175,
0.6518959999084473,
-0.1435193419456482,
-0.18201036751270294,
-0.25558602809906006,
0.34311509132385254,
0.4919411540031433,
-0.43407702445983887,
0.5454962849617004,
0.38638028502464294,
-0.05918460711836815,
-0.17105571925640106,
-0.32431545853614807,
-0.15004199743270874,
-0.45315560698509216,
0.2397577464580536,
-0.18667496740818024,
-1.0106943845748901,
0.4321916401386261,
-0.3521583676338196,
0.3924623727798462,
0.5615650415420532,
0.5319462418556213,
-0.05489783734083176,
1.1404681205749512,
0.3677385449409485,
0.01630210131406784,
0.26785147190093994,
-0.047058671712875366,
-0.13642103970050812,
-0.7342230677604675,
0.07412294298410416,
-0.6698890328407288,
-0.3380398750305176,
-0.34459415078163147,
-0.37371689081192017,
0.5902131199836731,
0.17074812948703766,
0.1309785693883896,
0.05182071402668953,
-0.09440771490335464,
0.5780318975448608,
0.43479686975479126,
-0.38339942693710327,
0.17682011425495148,
-0.2204587608575821,
-0.35965436697006226,
-0.16893252730369568,
-0.6670857667922974,
-0.8496236205101013,
1.0372543334960938,
0.2570793032646179,
0.5494804382324219,
0.0713498592376709,
0.5685570240020752,
0.3596141040325165,
0.4522082805633545,
-0.7876293063163757,
0.6687011122703552,
-0.07415758073329926,
-0.07473035156726837,
-0.4254875183105469,
-0.5768452882766724,
-1.1831575632095337,
0.08877959102392197,
-0.40081068873405457,
-0.45395204424858093,
-0.12464061379432678,
0.24419419467449188,
-0.5198545455932617,
-0.017985861748456955,
-0.551982581615448,
1.0150043964385986,
-0.295859158039093,
-0.17570850253105164,
0.05096031352877617,
-0.6831455826759338,
0.1628594547510147,
-0.26336485147476196,
0.20303308963775635,
-0.00919685885310173,
-0.2578141391277313,
0.6065725088119507,
-0.4060424566268921,
0.5832453966140747,
-0.18655799329280853,
-0.29887500405311584,
0.27854132652282715,
0.25753211975097656,
0.5812757611274719,
0.23033462464809418,
-0.2184237390756607,
0.1934213489294052,
-0.31546974182128906,
-0.1465892642736435,
-0.7436459064483643,
0.6614927053451538,
-0.5775937438011169,
-0.7013582587242126,
-0.24688571691513062,
-0.3004985451698303,
-0.2391415238380432,
0.46682262420654297,
0.6048388481140137,
0.4937993884086609,
-0.2759797275066376,
0.2709941565990448,
0.6679241061210632,
-0.7804957032203674,
0.5386539101600647,
0.4799145758152008,
-0.5111814141273499,
-0.5698338150978088,
0.6869294047355652,
0.017308762297034264,
0.18031831085681915,
0.3862713873386383,
0.4985555112361908,
-0.4147379696369171,
-0.7092621326446533,
-0.6567177772521973,
0.10475075989961624,
-0.5897120237350464,
-0.20734816789627075,
-0.6751102209091187,
0.1932709813117981,
-0.4637063145637512,
-0.2610723674297333,
-0.23377865552902222,
-0.2990223467350006,
-0.20965197682380676,
-0.09493538737297058,
-0.010997715406119823,
0.7777671813964844,
0.07449570298194885,
0.5074459910392761,
-1.1620525121688843,
-0.07838023453950882,
0.02164209820330143,
0.22346727550029755,
-0.08724503219127655,
-0.4438803493976593,
-0.2042921781539917,
-0.2521083652973175,
-0.09989064186811447,
-0.9651544094085693,
0.32085275650024414,
-0.08262316137552261,
0.607367217540741,
0.5725196003913879,
0.17660607397556305,
0.30278444290161133,
-0.5756406188011169,
1.1713836193084717,
0.24094069004058838,
-0.9924672842025757,
0.7271021604537964,
-0.4248450696468353,
0.8176465630531311,
0.5985454320907593,
0.5076035261154175,
-0.6424131393432617,
-0.4762812554836273,
-0.23949509859085083,
-0.995952308177948,
0.7048872709274292,
-0.0067374082282185555,
0.08184794336557388,
-0.1628546267747879,
0.2402525246143341,
0.5168924927711487,
0.3401550352573395,
-0.4215634763240814,
-0.2508357763290405,
-0.1513584405183792,
-0.059548620134592056,
-0.43457838892936707,
-0.38800832629203796,
0.052938949316740036,
0.18537425994873047,
0.44692984223365784,
-0.10553915798664093,
-0.1457805037498474,
0.10531935095787048,
-0.31919583678245544,
0.16426682472229004,
0.46273061633110046,
0.8299418091773987,
0.7736812829971313,
-0.17501498758792877,
0.23776839673519135,
0.2646477222442627,
-0.31493914127349854,
0.10278168320655823,
-0.012423022650182247,
-0.16123531758785248,
0.2573505640029907,
0.5580286979675293,
0.872737467288971,
0.21910259127616882,
-0.7951822876930237,
0.590049147605896,
-0.36112886667251587,
-0.12025824934244156,
-0.0870654359459877,
-0.0555066242814064,
-0.14257578551769257,
-0.04733118414878845,
0.33307158946990967,
-0.05936158075928688,
-0.029915355145931244,
-0.2501613199710846,
-0.08407219499349594,
0.2659606337547302,
-0.27150291204452515,
-0.5307667851448059,
0.7512348294258118,
0.31960001587867737,
-0.3048952519893646,
0.5750696659088135,
-0.334258109331131,
-0.32306215167045593,
0.37718337774276733,
0.4195443391799927,
1.083513855934143,
-0.3314145505428314,
0.17783193290233612,
0.6219903826713562,
0.4869244694709778,
-0.03434772416949272,
0.15896594524383545,
-0.24559611082077026,
-0.3383723497390747,
-0.5718975067138672,
-0.5888298153877258,
-0.5058562755584717,
0.24496693909168243,
-0.5310008525848389,
0.5641166567802429,
-0.406754732131958,
-0.37773728370666504,
-0.2980891466140747,
-0.3052780330181122,
-0.5682685971260071,
0.010317768901586533,
0.07635480165481567,
1.0837513208389282,
-0.6928954720497131,
0.32891786098480225,
0.8688645958900452,
-0.1245288997888565,
-0.5237175226211548,
-0.050068944692611694,
0.16537272930145264,
-0.4345759451389313,
0.4581701159477234,
0.4174288809299469,
-0.16654638946056366,
0.1442597508430481,
-0.5300026535987854,
-0.7553923726081848,
0.9387964606285095,
0.47235286235809326,
-0.757990300655365,
0.07050212472677231,
0.030075473710894585,
0.43526774644851685,
-0.40191182494163513,
0.5145942568778992,
0.3295445144176483,
0.7121420502662659,
-0.17208744585514069,
-0.8826934099197388,
0.11950849741697311,
-0.19895993173122406,
-0.19429239630699158,
0.2756565809249878,
-0.41012752056121826,
0.7033652067184448,
-0.38435617089271545,
-0.42755329608917236,
0.036430370062589645,
0.5791307091712952,
0.42806750535964966,
0.398055762052536,
0.7378692030906677,
0.30524012446403503,
0.7197309136390686,
-0.1321258842945099,
1.0795941352844238,
-0.23192918300628662,
-0.0856892392039299,
1.187808871269226,
-0.14849428832530975,
0.6892233490943909,
0.34136444330215454,
-0.09333451837301254,
0.31181320548057556,
0.8447059392929077,
0.1314774453639984,
0.039922576397657394,
0.2662619650363922,
-0.03639994189143181,
-0.14312519133090973,
-0.02529958076775074,
-0.4601345956325531,
0.023854995146393776,
0.2475631833076477,
-0.36557045578956604,
-0.3583664298057556,
0.026171371340751648,
0.22928641736507416,
0.01488183531910181,
-0.4045914113521576,
0.7512561082839966,
0.21072286367416382,
-0.9861530065536499,
0.4886227250099182,
-0.13687974214553833,
0.6190687417984009,
-0.8709583878517151,
0.09205850958824158,
-0.32778897881507874,
-0.3045501708984375,
-0.05208504572510719,
-0.740108072757721,
0.05409025400876999,
0.24793267250061035,
-0.22324317693710327,
-0.5512769222259521,
0.33626899123191833,
-0.14826132357120514,
-0.22851034998893738,
0.2791205644607544,
0.7156369686126709,
0.2773137092590332,
-0.15116241574287415,
-0.4628344178199768,
0.11244314908981323,
-0.19668744504451752,
-0.596222996711731,
0.2772166430950165,
0.6810926795005798,
-0.16722552478313446,
0.37959036231040955,
0.7543184161186218,
0.14305023849010468,
0.0922158807516098,
0.28867506980895996,
0.7665886282920837,
-0.7247212529182434,
-0.5354002714157104,
-1.1073530912399292,
0.6141716837882996,
0.10600310564041138,
-0.5376243591308594,
1.0843571424484253,
0.6065154671669006,
0.5757712125778198,
-0.13330550491809845,
0.7044157385826111,
0.2774559259414673,
0.3951939642429352,
-0.6546266674995422,
0.6015401482582092,
-0.5135961174964905,
0.4588388204574585,
-0.3954189121723175,
-1.3425285816192627,
-0.3083270788192749,
-0.008100551553070545,
-0.2466699779033661,
-0.18231923878192902,
0.6703899502754211,
0.5454210638999939,
0.3050704896450043,
-0.12068556249141693,
0.2850048542022705,
0.2761116325855255,
0.35973989963531494,
0.15947124361991882,
1.164374828338623,
0.185097798705101,
0.5304167866706848,
0.37625712156295776,
-0.4101896584033966,
-0.12073278427124023,
-1.2451841831207275,
-0.7595831751823425,
-0.4435431957244873,
-0.1547369658946991,
-0.25548532605171204,
-0.17391814291477203,
1.2256826162338257,
0.44313135743141174,
-0.6937811970710754,
-0.13637378811836243,
0.1857374906539917,
0.12479361891746521,
-0.2055300921201706,
-0.1695311814546585,
0.28113269805908203,
-0.6807665228843689,
-0.8875126838684082,
0.7869402170181274,
0.4764900207519531,
0.07667757570743561,
-0.3629046082496643,
-0.07709712535142899,
0.17641323804855347,
0.09346254169940948,
0.8027422428131104,
0.06964811682701111,
-0.4494669735431671,
0.1592949628829956,
0.31888142228126526,
0.09252125769853592,
0.039364758878946304,
0.9444617629051208,
-0.8252031803131104,
0.634316623210907,
0.6683963537216187,
0.6700611114501953,
-0.020452357828617096,
0.10686958581209183,
0.8993349075317383,
-0.7258564829826355,
-0.14234326779842377,
0.2418985515832901,
0.30850720405578613,
0.22883234918117523,
-0.05985625088214874,
0.2948244512081146,
-0.10976048558950424,
-0.6104931235313416,
-0.9605051279067993,
0.10661286860704422,
-0.7436902523040771,
-0.11009251326322556,
1.1042059659957886,
-0.20582060515880585,
-0.15406584739685059,
0.22149504721164703,
-0.39941608905792236,
-0.07105979323387146,
-0.48315274715423584,
0.4258190989494324,
0.7474414110183716,
0.017388245090842247,
-0.14991076290607452,
-0.5033750534057617,
0.3767547011375427,
0.623735785484314,
-0.6901231408119202,
0.044056229293346405,
0.5457319617271423,
0.02787931263446808,
0.20783895254135132,
0.586686909198761,
-0.1566685289144516,
0.1594509780406952,
-0.3435596525669098,
-0.07579327374696732,
-0.16922281682491302,
-0.29577967524528503,
-0.7075498104095459,
0.12152218818664551,
0.19401822984218597,
0.056314244866371155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18522v1 | ChronoMagic-Bench: A Benchmark for Metamorphic Evaluation of Text-to-Time-lapse Video Generation | 2024-06-26T17:50:47 | 2024-06-26T17:50:47 | Shenghai Yuan, Jinfa Huang, Yongqi Xu, Yaoyang Liu, Shaofeng Zhang, Yujun Shi, Ruijie Zhu, Xinhua Cheng, Jiebo Luo, Li Yuan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We propose a novel text-to-video (T2V) generation benchmark,
ChronoMagic-Bench, to evaluate the temporal and metamorphic capabilities of the
T2V models (e.g. Sora and Lumiere) in time-lapse video generation. In contrast
to existing benchmarks that focus on the visual quality and textual relevance
of generated videos, ChronoMagic-Bench focuses on the model's ability to
generate time-lapse videos with significant metamorphic amplitude and temporal
coherence. The benchmark probes T2V models for their physics, biology, and
chemistry capabilities, in a free-form text query. For these purposes,
ChronoMagic-Bench introduces 1,649 prompts and real-world videos as references,
categorized into four major types of time-lapse videos: biological,
human-created, meteorological, and physical phenomena, which are further
divided into 75 subcategories. This categorization comprehensively evaluates
the model's capacity to handle diverse and complex transformations. To
accurately align human preference with the benchmark, we introduce two new
automatic metrics, MTScore and CHScore, to evaluate the videos' metamorphic
attributes and temporal coherence. MTScore measures the metamorphic amplitude,
reflecting the degree of change over time, while CHScore assesses the temporal
coherence, ensuring the generated videos maintain logical progression and
continuity. Based on the ChronoMagic-Bench, we conduct comprehensive manual
evaluations of ten representative T2V models, revealing their strengths and
weaknesses across different categories of prompts, and providing a thorough
evaluation framework that addresses current gaps in video generation research.
Moreover, we create a large-scale ChronoMagic-Pro dataset, containing 460k
high-quality pairs of 720p time-lapse videos and detailed captions ensuring
high physical pertinence and large metamorphic amplitude. | [
-0.3420749306678772,
-0.5689727663993835,
0.5929436683654785,
0.13613301515579224,
-0.5609501004219055,
0.22218574583530426,
-0.109769806265831,
0.06063683703541756,
-0.007168916519731283,
0.13125567138195038,
-0.8431938886642456,
-0.4334593415260315,
-0.6145130395889282,
-0.06194046139717102,
-0.5032332539558411,
0.5406438708305359,
-0.33425483107566833,
0.22570015490055084,
-0.12446292489767075,
-0.316184937953949,
-0.39850056171417236,
-0.1181304082274437,
-0.020692918449640274,
-0.38257789611816406,
0.11406195908784866,
0.05978882312774658,
0.5991976857185364,
0.7455287575721741,
0.1500541865825653,
0.13399189710617065,
0.2863894999027252,
0.09090238809585571,
-0.15814334154129028,
0.12355152517557144,
-0.17946964502334595,
-0.06432343274354935,
-0.3680322766304016,
-0.0520862340927124,
0.58194500207901,
0.24413447082042694,
-0.1739114671945572,
0.7415888905525208,
-0.10040736943483353,
0.4264083802700043,
-0.955905556678772,
-0.049380749464035034,
-0.43109074234962463,
0.4076508581638336,
-0.3359369933605194,
-0.575018048286438,
-0.09643286466598511,
-0.5325321555137634,
0.2364177405834198,
-0.3430007994174957,
0.6957609057426453,
-0.27504512667655945,
0.5322667956352234,
0.484340637922287,
-0.37994152307510376,
0.35730502009391785,
-0.7246754169464111,
0.5649750232696533,
-0.40119069814682007,
0.44165948033332825,
0.2919774055480957,
0.8792858123779297,
0.3274812698364258,
-0.5638613700866699,
-0.29593873023986816,
-0.109732486307621,
0.6500608325004578,
0.1780191957950592,
-0.05645221844315529,
-0.25140535831451416,
0.15546952188014984,
0.48036906123161316,
-0.9347435832023621,
-0.0824752226471901,
-0.12751346826553345,
-0.15104319155216217,
0.4677090644836426,
0.40067845582962036,
0.2451050728559494,
-0.3649314343929291,
-0.14546404778957367,
-0.5075372457504272,
-0.44618862867355347,
-0.045002251863479614,
0.15615324676036835,
-0.40564730763435364,
-0.11916598677635193,
0.8016055226325989,
-0.26853272318840027,
0.4667969346046448,
-0.00007223518332466483,
-0.10896115750074387,
0.10520710796117783,
-0.4927717447280884,
-0.30372074246406555,
0.15022344887256622,
0.9254241585731506,
0.832606315612793,
0.056238699704408646,
0.06513351202011108,
0.2682393789291382,
0.34874194860458374,
0.17612001299858093,
-1.213433027267456,
-0.33349287509918213,
0.2576572299003601,
-0.516755223274231,
-0.40746796131134033,
-0.12564486265182495,
-1.0567547082901,
-0.26867786049842834,
-0.10523835569620132,
0.551934540271759,
-0.3558054566383362,
-0.3409103453159332,
-0.23216453194618225,
-0.4976973831653595,
-0.09252333641052246,
0.1978006362915039,
-0.9376088380813599,
0.27462339401245117,
0.4297654628753662,
0.8733822703361511,
-0.12194861471652985,
-0.28573092818260193,
-0.410521000623703,
0.37759634852409363,
-0.48430341482162476,
0.8190521597862244,
-0.4247521758079529,
-0.4283575713634491,
0.04068432375788689,
-0.057099562138319016,
0.1108112633228302,
-0.689810574054718,
0.07914692163467407,
-0.28270286321640015,
0.3502231240272522,
-0.12399662286043167,
-0.196706622838974,
-0.024644291028380394,
0.3562277555465698,
-0.5303061008453369,
0.959496796131134,
0.4159110188484192,
-0.35056403279304504,
0.6471512913703918,
-0.31541135907173157,
0.0457812063395977,
0.06103816255927086,
-0.3538151979446411,
-0.39769530296325684,
-0.0041800313629209995,
0.04992063716053963,
-0.019738905131816864,
-0.7312211394309998,
0.5682423710823059,
-0.3342721462249756,
0.24457277357578278,
0.4664291739463806,
-0.5264089107513428,
0.03537080064415932,
0.1923215091228485,
-0.6218834519386292,
0.027668308466672897,
-0.7037599682807922,
0.42179977893829346,
-0.19759255647659302,
-0.06412655860185623,
0.03018980845808983,
0.4093571603298187,
0.014463858678936958,
0.37640243768692017,
-0.18981923162937164,
-0.3914051949977875,
-0.19376477599143982,
0.05540921911597252,
0.7991408705711365,
0.6372191905975342,
0.29266613721847534,
0.1137586385011673,
-0.19488489627838135,
0.3683318495750427,
-0.11508285999298096,
0.2982614040374756,
-0.2439851611852646,
-0.114410400390625,
-0.47768622636795044,
0.009398276917636395,
0.03379398211836815,
0.36604243516921997,
-0.5717501640319824,
0.1604413390159607,
-0.38297024369239807,
-0.6990469694137573,
-0.1218217983841896,
0.06300234794616699,
0.5207294225692749,
0.4554240107536316,
0.6936065554618835,
-0.6812512874603271,
-0.3281485140323639,
-0.8288081288337708,
-0.3078736960887909,
0.13478857278823853,
-0.3603192865848541,
0.607382595539093,
0.3875589668750763,
-0.11407071352005005,
0.8251824378967285,
-0.5697188973426819,
0.11809559911489487,
0.36768296360969543,
0.6172647476196289,
-0.14643657207489014,
0.19658024609088898,
0.6876071095466614,
-0.6315386295318604,
-0.4103185534477234,
-0.28781649470329285,
-0.8973479866981506,
-0.12868408858776093,
0.20810797810554504,
0.18663306534290314,
0.20266827940940857,
0.22459329664707184,
-0.46654611825942993,
0.36611321568489075,
0.6582743525505066,
-0.2189958393573761,
0.6887719035148621,
-0.14882464706897736,
0.6386342644691467,
-1.1235848665237427,
0.23731444776058197,
-0.20076872408390045,
-0.29884859919548035,
-0.3083134591579437,
-0.2579987943172455,
-0.033434849232435226,
-0.5786064267158508,
-0.6048523783683777,
0.541327178478241,
-0.23790153861045837,
-0.33825770020484924,
-0.20578879117965698,
0.17210423946380615,
-0.2732108533382416,
0.3576704263687134,
0.205606147646904,
0.5697848796844482,
0.29619747400283813,
-0.743630051612854,
0.41808634996414185,
0.1603698432445526,
-0.4636540710926056,
0.8134639859199524,
-0.721142590045929,
-0.14749446511268616,
0.20018091797828674,
0.44314539432525635,
-0.6211556792259216,
-0.6616691946983337,
0.007430193945765495,
-0.5308660864830017,
0.06315943598747253,
-0.12885403633117676,
-0.46496638655662537,
-0.3376452326774597,
-0.5183081030845642,
0.8211895823478699,
0.619451642036438,
-0.3120250105857849,
0.3840455710887909,
0.13121309876441956,
-0.05269182473421097,
-0.2767632305622101,
-0.6653751730918884,
0.2624557912349701,
-0.09673036634922028,
-0.7508605718612671,
0.6510828137397766,
-0.1429310142993927,
0.011407343670725822,
0.09778712689876556,
-0.3921844959259033,
-0.1599971503019333,
-0.33686935901641846,
0.3647128939628601,
-0.014375146478414536,
-0.04680648446083069,
-0.012905597686767578,
0.047100406140089035,
-0.13179385662078857,
0.07814794778823853,
-0.3958529531955719,
0.8449323773384094,
0.2509322762489319,
-0.08059729635715485,
-0.45092251896858215,
0.29413464665412903,
0.5854974389076233,
-0.23669831454753876,
0.3727218806743622,
0.7700439691543579,
-0.39197349548339844,
-0.030375810340046883,
-0.4912775754928589,
-0.1641387641429901,
-0.3949822187423706,
0.31765326857566833,
0.06686410307884216,
-0.5833025574684143,
0.15035809576511383,
0.03537655621767044,
-0.1368633359670639,
0.7389810681343079,
0.7434400320053101,
-0.1330418735742569,
1.0054960250854492,
0.11007371544837952,
0.4722028970718384,
0.7973871231079102,
-0.4921461045742035,
-0.4071158468723297,
-0.7768998742103577,
-0.3605899214744568,
-0.21153317391872406,
-0.22552746534347534,
-0.4910619556903839,
-0.5692354440689087,
0.6514180302619934,
-0.18708468973636627,
-0.6136831641197205,
0.4621625542640686,
-0.3196263611316681,
0.13603132963180542,
0.0429002046585083,
0.30182763934135437,
-0.08340120315551758,
0.06591587513685226,
0.09269312769174576,
-0.36889150738716125,
-0.33049482107162476,
-0.47980648279190063,
1.156515121459961,
-0.049828894436359406,
0.5723323225975037,
0.40804797410964966,
0.24273167550563812,
0.7384771108627319,
0.07876399159431458,
-0.3164360225200653,
0.6813116073608398,
-0.4703519940376282,
-0.6491249203681946,
0.06144750490784645,
-0.3242514431476593,
-0.6434893012046814,
-0.11069820821285248,
-0.5168627500534058,
-0.697446346282959,
0.083671435713768,
0.4360549747943878,
-0.20803160965442657,
0.28463035821914673,
-0.18817442655563354,
1.1022411584854126,
-0.5235962867736816,
-0.8867369294166565,
-0.7270982265472412,
-0.7124717831611633,
0.43069344758987427,
-0.04591125249862671,
-0.06110450252890587,
-0.07298458367586136,
-0.12652155756950378,
0.7034041881561279,
-0.8502410054206848,
0.5682201385498047,
-0.19639956951141357,
0.22802633047103882,
0.5605649352073669,
0.4658253788948059,
-0.003911980893462896,
0.11078885942697525,
0.3347102105617523,
0.11492782831192017,
0.11137456446886063,
-0.18744193017482758,
-0.43246376514434814,
0.45689675211906433,
-0.7548000812530518,
-0.28324344754219055,
-0.3958779275417328,
-0.3151278793811798,
0.00229071662761271,
0.22784112393856049,
0.5722663402557373,
0.7621463537216187,
-0.6451035141944885,
0.39570704102516174,
0.5895474553108215,
-0.07899031043052673,
0.6075394749641418,
0.3443484306335449,
-0.07410641759634018,
-1.043902039527893,
0.7643066644668579,
0.08250688761472702,
0.4970788359642029,
0.5982990860939026,
0.15461894869804382,
-0.2831442654132843,
-0.2596513628959656,
-0.43780624866485596,
-0.06565453112125397,
-0.41219475865364075,
-0.11163326352834702,
-0.4945639669895172,
-0.22112570703029633,
-0.33951252698898315,
0.07471058517694473,
-0.5814464092254639,
-0.6176128387451172,
-0.25715866684913635,
0.09530263394117355,
0.1089254692196846,
0.07358063757419586,
0.09186849743127823,
0.23681731522083282,
-1.1489092111587524,
0.5701124668121338,
0.7580692172050476,
0.2541625499725342,
-0.3120236396789551,
-0.41166701912879944,
0.031361766159534454,
-0.03534650057554245,
-0.8667197823524475,
-0.8263543844223022,
0.2133989781141281,
0.41390854120254517,
0.4726201593875885,
0.2751021385192871,
-0.3353518843650818,
0.6985622644424438,
-0.6534030437469482,
1.2384414672851562,
0.4001895785331726,
-0.9741976857185364,
0.730811357498169,
-0.6117668151855469,
0.3165460526943207,
0.5247689485549927,
0.06864378601312637,
-0.5020235180854797,
0.05468636006116867,
-0.7183800339698792,
-0.7054142951965332,
0.435397744178772,
0.43051591515541077,
-0.13936321437358856,
0.13284870982170105,
0.2831386923789978,
0.08835113793611526,
0.5418861508369446,
-0.49399831891059875,
0.21364401280879974,
-0.94051593542099,
0.07121072709560394,
-0.466413676738739,
-0.10930535942316055,
-0.35739418864250183,
0.2051524817943573,
0.07413242012262344,
-0.11742175370454788,
0.06554894149303436,
0.3212427794933319,
-0.2937704622745514,
-0.5238052010536194,
0.4334650933742523,
0.8313475847244263,
0.6700066924095154,
-0.7016476988792419,
0.2551131546497345,
0.10095129907131195,
-0.4471799433231354,
0.396822452545166,
-0.027689039707183838,
-0.19650250673294067,
0.13524694740772247,
0.2233879268169403,
0.6565973162651062,
0.2643595039844513,
-0.6312035918235779,
0.46961599588394165,
0.005723315756767988,
-0.3324603736400604,
-0.33637142181396484,
0.2690509557723999,
-0.370115727186203,
0.2663600742816925,
0.3655690550804138,
0.3149895966053009,
0.0011030904715880752,
-0.8043528199195862,
-0.006414396688342094,
0.25328439474105835,
-0.18216314911842346,
-0.7171217203140259,
1.1689512729644775,
0.2730298936367035,
-0.48252052068710327,
0.4024352431297302,
0.09019359201192856,
-0.4464122951030731,
0.5639305710792542,
0.24785216152668,
1.3675295114517212,
-0.5444255471229553,
0.3482383191585541,
0.8968020081520081,
0.06039473041892052,
-0.4550679922103882,
0.14981980621814728,
-0.558678388595581,
-0.11952835321426392,
0.18812651932239532,
-0.38828927278518677,
-0.3837844431400299,
-0.06050214543938637,
-0.6790515780448914,
0.32267045974731445,
-0.5778419375419617,
-0.5972417593002319,
0.030757766216993332,
-0.27028000354766846,
-0.4228225648403168,
0.4398244321346283,
0.0809539258480072,
1.0000662803649902,
-0.9310123920440674,
0.5625241994857788,
0.3007185459136963,
-0.2768072783946991,
-0.12311357259750366,
-0.015763387084007263,
0.1950635462999344,
-0.35564202070236206,
0.42748937010765076,
0.18119628727436066,
-0.23494692146778107,
-0.3184146583080292,
-0.42564117908477783,
-0.5118440985679626,
1.755489706993103,
0.2845532298088074,
-0.4162560999393463,
0.06603303551673889,
0.18729883432388306,
0.8217682838439941,
-0.4656895399093628,
0.15630999207496643,
0.4917805790901184,
0.28489580750465393,
0.11914794147014618,
-0.7515509128570557,
-0.09976909309625626,
-0.3459581136703491,
0.1893579363822937,
0.34675830602645874,
-0.9190666675567627,
0.8079476952552795,
-0.04411362484097481,
-0.39543774724006653,
0.33914658427238464,
0.22264517843723297,
0.496776282787323,
0.8042044043540955,
0.6048946380615234,
0.7362798452377319,
0.17620068788528442,
-0.2561095058917999,
1.0574023723602295,
-0.23637337982654572,
0.27541983127593994,
1.1215147972106934,
-0.06921204179525375,
0.8541879057884216,
0.4790962040424347,
-0.17847317457199097,
0.6019352078437805,
0.9351602792739868,
-0.41497376561164856,
0.8765386343002319,
-0.1198015809059143,
-0.18948768079280853,
-0.4776764512062073,
-0.270489364862442,
-0.6751271486282349,
0.072559654712677,
0.14453555643558502,
-0.5024652481079102,
-0.3165655732154846,
-0.2933419346809387,
-0.1993636190891266,
-0.01693763956427574,
-0.2904718220233917,
0.4537281095981598,
-0.009749812074005604,
-1.0055865049362183,
0.4278751015663147,
-0.19231227040290833,
-0.07028426975011826,
-0.8184692859649658,
0.09868279099464417,
-0.0588412843644619,
0.17789703607559204,
-0.37949079275131226,
-0.8402705788612366,
0.06761812418699265,
0.3099296987056732,
-0.3140701949596405,
-0.14867964386940002,
0.18945728242397308,
-0.4197095036506653,
-0.18564359843730927,
0.07077568024396896,
0.1882033497095108,
0.11640700697898865,
0.0003382786817383021,
-0.4049959182739258,
-0.12092000991106033,
-0.3415044844150543,
-0.12111058831214905,
0.13961666822433472,
-0.05486978217959404,
-0.2628023326396942,
0.48950064182281494,
0.3334193527698517,
-0.2705114185810089,
-0.0016262588324025273,
0.11437547206878662,
0.7034634351730347,
-0.764308750629425,
-0.16420982778072357,
-0.8712260723114014,
0.2894240915775299,
0.01967737451195717,
-0.3850582540035248,
0.5711430311203003,
0.8693144917488098,
0.404984712600708,
-0.24061360955238342,
0.6185922026634216,
-0.2352171689271927,
0.09863410145044327,
-0.7158634066581726,
0.3404160141944885,
-0.7353910207748413,
0.03490810841321945,
-0.2928127944469452,
-1.3208867311477661,
0.07828152179718018,
0.035693876445293427,
-0.2542778551578522,
0.10237523168325424,
0.9832677841186523,
0.47104302048683167,
-0.16225948929786682,
-0.21497714519500732,
-0.1258806586265564,
0.10017889738082886,
0.49152493476867676,
0.8670710921287537,
0.8558726906776428,
-0.671218752861023,
0.9515823721885681,
-0.0351313091814518,
-0.2990797758102417,
-0.37894561886787415,
-0.9914820790290833,
-0.8828800916671753,
-0.4645267724990845,
-0.39972031116485596,
-0.4587096571922302,
-0.01175753679126501,
0.6716017723083496,
0.8675522804260254,
-0.4360504746437073,
-0.2832852900028229,
-0.14086368680000305,
-0.4477217495441437,
-0.22777941823005676,
-0.16694232821464539,
0.34326377511024475,
0.2664524018764496,
-0.45587751269340515,
0.23895303905010223,
0.5128458738327026,
0.2737225294113159,
-0.47762414813041687,
-0.0728139653801918,
0.2263815999031067,
0.060801561921834946,
0.5166728496551514,
0.506346583366394,
-0.5246765613555908,
-0.20021802186965942,
0.143063485622406,
-0.06814782321453094,
0.08808712661266327,
1.0779999494552612,
-0.5293525457382202,
0.8033275008201599,
0.8652551770210266,
-0.06106320768594742,
1.1975388526916504,
0.136384978890419,
0.6423953771591187,
-0.640069842338562,
0.12231830507516861,
0.026943515986204147,
0.20895791053771973,
0.35979628562927246,
0.26651087403297424,
0.6691130995750427,
0.4417847692966461,
-0.6133737564086914,
-0.83540278673172,
0.3311794698238373,
-1.2669397592544556,
-0.1502736508846283,
0.8719054460525513,
0.2322380393743515,
-0.2656943202018738,
0.4258372485637665,
0.10034114867448807,
0.4024023115634918,
-0.1975754350423813,
1.0742465257644653,
0.5747732520103455,
-0.005895575042814016,
-0.46934205293655396,
-0.616424560546875,
0.5167537927627563,
0.1458846926689148,
-0.9449977874755859,
0.04463178664445877,
0.5700638890266418,
0.753088653087616,
0.28883662819862366,
0.42297738790512085,
-0.4627314507961273,
0.9614465236663818,
0.04985343664884567,
-0.1176781877875328,
-0.07813888788223267,
-0.30819347500801086,
-0.20273742079734802,
0.12915293872356415,
-0.32682257890701294,
-0.164704367518425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18521v1 | CharXiv: Charting Gaps in Realistic Chart Understanding in Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-26T17:50:11 | 2024-06-26T17:50:11 | Zirui Wang, Mengzhou Xia, Luxi He, Howard Chen, Yitao Liu, Richard Zhu, Kaiqu Liang, Xindi Wu, Haotian Liu, Sadhika Malladi, Alexis Chevalier, Sanjeev Arora, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Chart understanding plays a pivotal role when applying Multimodal Large
Language Models (MLLMs) to real-world tasks such as analyzing scientific papers
or financial reports. However, existing datasets often focus on oversimplified
and homogeneous charts with template-based questions, leading to an
over-optimistic measure of progress. We demonstrate that although open-source
models can appear to outperform strong proprietary models on these benchmarks,
a simple stress test with slightly different charts or questions can
deteriorate performance by up to 34.5%. In this work, we propose CharXiv, a
comprehensive evaluation suite involving 2,323 natural, challenging, and
diverse charts from arXiv papers. CharXiv includes two types of questions: 1)
descriptive questions about examining basic chart elements and 2) reasoning
questions that require synthesizing information across complex visual elements
in the chart. To ensure quality, all charts and questions are handpicked,
curated, and verified by human experts. Our results reveal a substantial,
previously underestimated gap between the reasoning skills of the strongest
proprietary model (i.e., GPT-4o), which achieves 47.1% accuracy, and the
strongest open-source model (i.e., InternVL Chat V1.5), which achieves 29.2%.
All models lag far behind human performance of 80.5%, underscoring weaknesses
in the chart understanding capabilities of existing MLLMs. We hope CharXiv
facilitates future research on MLLM chart understanding by providing a more
realistic and faithful measure of progress. Project page and leaderboard:
https://charxiv.github.io/ | [
-0.3062092363834381,
-0.6317784786224365,
0.6865370869636536,
0.2194254994392395,
-0.3216131329536438,
0.2956363260746002,
-0.06934399157762527,
-0.6960270404815674,
-0.3281756639480591,
0.5230764150619507,
-0.5180940628051758,
-0.8296743631362915,
-0.44311997294425964,
-0.09583697468042374,
-0.17683793604373932,
0.68187016248703,
-0.2538277804851532,
0.10711760073900223,
-0.46641868352890015,
-0.346408873796463,
-0.4054085314273834,
-0.29074913263320923,
-0.5751008987426758,
-0.2833903729915619,
0.7163888216018677,
0.470449835062027,
0.7463570237159729,
0.4268540143966675,
0.6409367322921753,
0.21899168193340302,
-0.02548818290233612,
0.3390442430973053,
-0.655755341053009,
0.4925798773765564,
0.03037211112678051,
-0.3690633773803711,
-0.45677676796913147,
-0.05567431077361107,
0.5284731388092041,
0.6626328825950623,
0.21306216716766357,
0.1496911197900772,
0.10249906033277512,
0.7471796274185181,
-0.4456886351108551,
0.6175099611282349,
-0.34000349044799805,
0.0804363265633583,
-0.23086696863174438,
-0.011558671481907368,
-0.5989862084388733,
-0.390283465385437,
0.20705100893974304,
-0.660674512386322,
-0.03771459311246872,
0.26540982723236084,
0.8470752239227295,
0.2006126493215561,
-0.9226828813552856,
-0.3871495723724365,
-0.580539345741272,
0.6706340312957764,
-0.5889765024185181,
0.6294161677360535,
0.3773132562637329,
0.49346449971199036,
0.06398383527994156,
-0.9626011848449707,
-0.2787735164165497,
-0.4476695954799652,
-0.071017786860466,
0.3124787509441376,
-0.3886205554008484,
-0.06791426241397858,
0.27888044714927673,
0.12467905879020691,
-0.7999550700187683,
0.2904472053050995,
-0.4908302128314972,
-0.17403659224510193,
0.6271708607673645,
0.43035703897476196,
0.27932998538017273,
-0.15905487537384033,
-0.4029797911643982,
-0.40405601263046265,
-0.5302836894989014,
0.2175646424293518,
0.30579110980033875,
0.21664200723171234,
-0.208456352353096,
0.5258971452713013,
0.26661407947540283,
0.6097880601882935,
-0.3419268727302551,
0.031093688681721687,
0.262516051530838,
-0.48653244972229004,
-0.12148609757423401,
-0.2931138873100281,
0.630104124546051,
0.37166327238082886,
0.28548264503479004,
-0.013014507479965687,
-0.03720608726143837,
-0.19673918187618256,
0.1899171620607376,
-0.6225039958953857,
-0.25237882137298584,
0.25161653757095337,
-0.4453401565551758,
-0.01715240441262722,
-0.11470124125480652,
-0.7213689684867859,
-0.8653550744056702,
-0.5473965406417847,
0.014335330575704575,
-0.7237697839736938,
-0.09983328729867935,
-0.2379666566848755,
0.01621859334409237,
0.07308197766542435,
0.707708477973938,
-0.37953564524650574,
0.013091561384499073,
0.6382238268852234,
1.0156030654907227,
-0.04831869155168533,
-0.2454647272825241,
-0.5195993781089783,
-0.08376554399728775,
-0.46335068345069885,
0.9719429612159729,
-0.5739299058914185,
-0.3581209182739258,
-0.24857041239738464,
-0.2223854511976242,
-0.37433871626853943,
-0.3838617503643036,
0.8664538264274597,
-0.4889999330043793,
-0.04658036306500435,
-0.41092073917388916,
-0.8073408603668213,
-0.32738491892814636,
0.3805205821990967,
-0.8596020936965942,
0.7851863503456116,
0.08461359143257141,
-0.8504008054733276,
0.40249431133270264,
-0.6589313745498657,
-0.025464745238423347,
-0.05621577426791191,
-0.3283029794692993,
-0.4235270619392395,
-0.3537387251853943,
0.38457465171813965,
0.42870205640792847,
-0.35516607761383057,
-0.06771072745323181,
-0.5928665995597839,
-0.3753507733345032,
0.5126179456710815,
-0.27162328362464905,
0.5534692406654358,
0.5608543753623962,
-0.19078634679317474,
0.384815514087677,
-0.6658147573471069,
0.1747492253780365,
0.032095059752464294,
-0.1244264766573906,
-0.29561328887939453,
0.03764278441667557,
0.38303089141845703,
0.18271934986114502,
0.020214932039380074,
-0.16335323452949524,
0.27490153908729553,
-0.16141508519649506,
0.4340739846229553,
0.93440842628479,
-0.05600331723690033,
-0.012400181964039803,
-0.31343844532966614,
0.8225758075714111,
0.013317244127392769,
0.11152852326631546,
-0.49874991178512573,
-0.5565685033798218,
-0.6682947874069214,
-0.4924188554286957,
0.2942599356174469,
0.4013337790966034,
-0.5367233157157898,
0.07919210940599442,
-0.33972567319869995,
-0.8973011374473572,
-0.3882009983062744,
0.15772783756256104,
0.21595095098018646,
0.5915951728820801,
0.19722053408622742,
-0.2966461181640625,
-0.40828344225883484,
-0.8737331628799438,
-0.14687106013298035,
-0.1945524960756302,
-0.035558413714170456,
0.4082711935043335,
0.598482072353363,
-0.2509840428829193,
0.7373360991477966,
-0.4991038739681244,
-0.03267841786146164,
-0.23331233859062195,
0.5462169051170349,
0.1401217132806778,
0.2057567685842514,
0.7231730222702026,
-0.7350348830223083,
-0.5645889639854431,
0.09381918609142303,
-0.6497113704681396,
0.009840183891355991,
-0.4064791202545166,
-0.21905815601348877,
0.02043215185403824,
0.34368422627449036,
-0.43863412737846375,
0.4242151975631714,
0.5065502524375916,
-0.6625869274139404,
0.7600528001785278,
-0.30605825781822205,
0.28944724798202515,
-0.7154392004013062,
0.27366113662719727,
0.21290749311447144,
-0.21768628060817719,
-0.5448864102363586,
-0.011348453350365162,
0.280575692653656,
-0.21430820226669312,
-0.21842925250530243,
0.5860733389854431,
-0.4320274889469147,
-0.13203316926956177,
0.030277660116553307,
0.2862561345100403,
0.14506149291992188,
0.335334450006485,
-0.1790081113576889,
0.6613898873329163,
0.5165895819664001,
-0.23486343026161194,
0.4092026650905609,
0.16099771857261658,
-0.6837860345840454,
0.5254204869270325,
-0.6654983758926392,
0.32733434438705444,
-0.03760705515742302,
0.2487257868051529,
-1.235616683959961,
-0.06989838182926178,
0.2572450041770935,
-0.27695515751838684,
0.2326580435037613,
-0.22363576292991638,
-0.4882921576499939,
-0.36994239687919617,
-0.1298472285270691,
0.20092527568340302,
0.298738956451416,
-0.3400297462940216,
0.4015933871269226,
0.08981294929981232,
-0.14359231293201447,
-0.6249709725379944,
-0.5583608150482178,
0.11560215055942535,
-0.06721073389053345,
-1.1680728197097778,
-0.20883724093437195,
-0.22112785279750824,
-0.5008804202079773,
-0.04840286076068878,
-0.21784868836402893,
-0.32316386699676514,
-0.01765357330441475,
0.28184548020362854,
0.36008721590042114,
-0.34854766726493835,
0.3436948359012604,
-0.31002911925315857,
-0.05521698296070099,
-0.07761069387197495,
-0.0979992151260376,
0.267056941986084,
-0.40767306089401245,
-1.0042123794555664,
-0.3631593585014343,
0.14567086100578308,
1.0406043529510498,
-0.2724924683570862,
0.4789499044418335,
0.7039805054664612,
-0.11414331197738647,
0.03379398211836815,
-0.37391695380210876,
0.1662389487028122,
-0.4290832579135895,
0.3826354444026947,
-0.21694375574588776,
-0.6706245541572571,
0.6441662311553955,
0.1985848993062973,
0.23511283099651337,
0.3257136642932892,
0.5363200306892395,
-0.34809863567352295,
0.898520827293396,
0.37272098660469055,
0.24725651741027832,
0.16747237741947174,
-0.2628808319568634,
0.23139673471450806,
-0.39758947491645813,
-0.3609820306301117,
-0.44237178564071655,
-0.40294572710990906,
-0.31574442982673645,
-0.7846399545669556,
0.5176955461502075,
-0.21733225882053375,
-0.12974344193935394,
-0.04034295305609703,
-0.26257213950157166,
0.2403453141450882,
0.4423915445804596,
0.01394714880734682,
0.43073585629463196,
-0.1456034779548645,
-0.15154936909675598,
-0.41510605812072754,
-0.48029854893684387,
-0.7286272048950195,
1.2499860525131226,
0.4636504650115967,
0.9764454364776611,
-0.1358453333377838,
0.24045634269714355,
0.4466029703617096,
0.26942670345306396,
-0.6486071348190308,
0.1748320758342743,
0.09636224806308746,
-0.6347178220748901,
-0.37766319513320923,
-0.5790748000144958,
-1.139571189880371,
0.5217225551605225,
-0.15155459940433502,
-0.5976855754852295,
0.19201336801052094,
0.3800446093082428,
-0.2564423680305481,
0.41078218817710876,
-1.0198606252670288,
1.1902910470962524,
-0.5870602130889893,
-0.3875790238380432,
-0.14312554895877838,
-0.5507866144180298,
0.5279674530029297,
-0.09933345019817352,
0.5640367269515991,
-0.32454392313957214,
0.08359858393669128,
0.5324649214744568,
-0.1372680515050888,
0.8524609804153442,
-0.0039419918321073055,
-0.1664651781320572,
0.37795451283454895,
0.16140902042388916,
0.5717385411262512,
-0.1237211525440216,
-0.05810868740081787,
-0.06646654009819031,
0.22165508568286896,
-0.5132859349250793,
-0.8507946133613586,
0.5419613122940063,
-0.7222626209259033,
-0.2238551527261734,
-0.4545535445213318,
-0.7073314189910889,
-0.2843935489654541,
-0.05042004957795143,
-0.06690485030412674,
0.41626009345054626,
-0.11970596760511398,
0.31050407886505127,
0.4204027056694031,
-0.30660539865493774,
-0.148724764585495,
0.32662448287010193,
-0.16713674366474152,
-0.2706567645072937,
0.7331040501594543,
0.18790878355503082,
0.23343899846076965,
0.16013336181640625,
0.04665539413690567,
-0.4933008849620819,
-0.4904707670211792,
-0.17222578823566437,
0.3181011974811554,
-1.1097848415374756,
0.14666278660297394,
-0.39303529262542725,
0.07646999508142471,
-0.5191436409950256,
-0.011177576147019863,
-0.3411201238632202,
-0.3836980164051056,
-0.3572298288345337,
-0.08647581934928894,
0.23344966769218445,
0.8329558372497559,
-0.03202586993575096,
-0.21003995835781097,
-0.9254162311553955,
-0.02429298311471939,
0.41119784116744995,
0.3139806091785431,
0.2943071126937866,
-0.37406134605407715,
-0.4076843559741974,
0.14712312817573547,
-0.6607330441474915,
-0.9355357885360718,
0.3475620746612549,
-0.0466582365334034,
0.708132803440094,
0.7550754547119141,
0.040133316069841385,
0.8367660641670227,
-0.16620305180549622,
0.6409813165664673,
0.3532615005970001,
-0.8871688842773438,
0.29917067289352417,
-0.4302721917629242,
0.3009803295135498,
0.27019616961479187,
0.44025352597236633,
-0.9138614535331726,
-0.4924232065677643,
-0.4190976619720459,
-0.9967347979545593,
0.5967663526535034,
0.5032158493995667,
-0.2831243872642517,
0.405865341424942,
0.16090625524520874,
0.2149185836315155,
-0.07248955219984055,
-0.7573642730712891,
-0.2584676742553711,
-0.42518752813339233,
-0.17754580080509186,
-0.26425522565841675,
-0.06823760271072388,
-0.1614786982536316,
-0.36575520038604736,
0.322774201631546,
-0.12352203577756882,
0.025696327909827232,
0.1956445276737213,
-0.19446732103824615,
-0.058267153799533844,
0.419969379901886,
0.7562897801399231,
1.2957357168197632,
-0.30748891830444336,
0.3953818380832672,
0.04829433560371399,
-0.2868090569972992,
-0.092091865837574,
0.1731746941804886,
0.2824712097644806,
-0.1588098108768463,
0.9033310413360596,
0.9854301810264587,
0.2595767676830292,
-1.1995302438735962,
0.2834640443325043,
-0.13396158814430237,
-0.16641953587532043,
-0.11856037378311157,
-0.07720030844211578,
0.4265364706516266,
0.4796214699745178,
0.3361186385154724,
0.05482037365436554,
-0.08197823166847229,
-0.5555266737937927,
0.1875838041305542,
0.09129048138856888,
-0.4340198338031769,
-0.31334325671195984,
0.7628501057624817,
0.13842935860157013,
0.09558399021625519,
0.749970555305481,
-0.0221348088234663,
-0.34886831045150757,
0.7849818468093872,
0.06708035618066788,
0.5265774130821228,
0.20674312114715576,
0.22575634717941284,
0.2887446880340576,
0.5070391893386841,
0.2786317467689514,
0.15936309099197388,
0.006542904768139124,
-0.42456290125846863,
-0.520584225654602,
-0.01173354871571064,
-0.7797957062721252,
0.10735085606575012,
-0.5861903429031372,
0.2263636291027069,
-0.21527166664600372,
-0.2078167349100113,
-0.05759512633085251,
-0.15313701331615448,
-0.7751576900482178,
0.009487681090831757,
0.3843114376068115,
0.8674336671829224,
-0.719014585018158,
0.5285717844963074,
0.6960243582725525,
-0.5661532878875732,
-0.4793790876865387,
-0.23484337329864502,
0.07157240808010101,
-0.8793507814407349,
0.821608304977417,
0.07581998407840729,
0.1376754343509674,
-0.4433688819408417,
-0.5768024921417236,
-0.883390486240387,
1.2404346466064453,
0.6534191966056824,
-0.6232826113700867,
-0.043316006660461426,
0.09239447116851807,
0.6774809956550598,
-0.16234971582889557,
0.5812177658081055,
0.33732354640960693,
0.8293001651763916,
0.31014296412467957,
-0.8366544246673584,
-0.020910173654556274,
-0.3249063491821289,
-0.1917722076177597,
-0.11487618088722229,
-0.5709637403488159,
0.9795536994934082,
-0.31309935450553894,
-0.2614307105541229,
-0.16052843630313873,
0.531070351600647,
0.41063204407691956,
0.7027623653411865,
0.5534398555755615,
0.4215630292892456,
1.1003369092941284,
-0.12853403389453888,
1.014267086982727,
-0.17754599452018738,
0.4935798943042755,
1.2070417404174805,
-0.2091578245162964,
0.5864501595497131,
0.25414222478866577,
-0.16889485716819763,
0.5252761244773865,
0.9839811325073242,
-0.1656065583229065,
0.1768268495798111,
0.20322346687316895,
0.10947060585021973,
-0.6078652739524841,
0.17828260362148285,
-0.5632233023643494,
0.1935117542743683,
0.3493627905845642,
-0.41689857840538025,
-0.37111878395080566,
-0.053691692650318146,
-0.08145041763782501,
0.03379177302122116,
0.047411490231752396,
0.1790909618139267,
0.14437031745910645,
-0.4611484110355377,
0.676412045955658,
-0.29780641198158264,
0.11320596188306808,
-0.800976574420929,
0.04454595968127251,
-0.2565278112888336,
0.09261728823184967,
0.05442655086517334,
-0.9555274248123169,
0.10270703583955765,
0.09945818781852722,
0.06949476152658463,
-0.4193561375141144,
0.5900434255599976,
-0.22795438766479492,
-0.5869443416595459,
0.29827314615249634,
0.6076170802116394,
0.28238072991371155,
-0.07331739366054535,
-0.8629065155982971,
0.1179465651512146,
-0.02644934505224228,
-0.2956445515155792,
0.18253383040428162,
0.48329994082450867,
0.05897509306669235,
1.1245524883270264,
0.5721115469932556,
-0.23688766360282898,
0.07006383687257767,
0.21209782361984253,
0.8268023729324341,
-0.5687215328216553,
-0.5043495893478394,
-0.692349374294281,
0.6890745759010315,
-0.13275204598903656,
-0.210352823138237,
0.8694514036178589,
0.5983587503433228,
0.5213721394538879,
0.0138618228957057,
0.8420621156692505,
0.3220813572406769,
0.4139930009841919,
-0.5435000061988831,
0.8885477185249329,
-0.721615731716156,
0.20920908451080322,
-0.4981754720211029,
-0.5347819924354553,
-0.28254252672195435,
0.37742477655410767,
-0.4616192877292633,
-0.21234135329723358,
0.8288677334785461,
0.4238649308681488,
-0.07544997334480286,
0.09781335294246674,
0.4377063810825348,
0.2825828194618225,
0.5625585317611694,
0.6022948026657104,
1.0753865242004395,
0.03267525136470795,
1.1119517087936401,
-0.19626972079277039,
-0.01818167418241501,
-0.14844825863838196,
-0.8660526275634766,
-0.8840174674987793,
-0.7074746489524841,
-0.3702928423881531,
-0.14023955166339874,
-0.13757309317588806,
0.7498558163642883,
0.6726893186569214,
-0.6248905062675476,
-0.47059166431427,
0.27250513434410095,
0.4100309908390045,
-0.23276036977767944,
-0.22376422584056854,
0.6088386178016663,
-0.39531615376472473,
-0.6086736917495728,
0.35102367401123047,
0.2132827490568161,
0.3039134740829468,
-0.26522719860076904,
-0.21985119581222534,
-0.09594308584928513,
-0.02249423786997795,
0.4658505320549011,
0.22507883608341217,
-0.6530835628509521,
-0.17961537837982178,
0.16873560845851898,
-0.005463513545691967,
0.34447893500328064,
1.0402921438217163,
-0.3228411376476288,
0.889603853225708,
0.5027398467063904,
0.3141065835952759,
0.7306235432624817,
-0.037472110241651535,
0.41521310806274414,
-0.5264649987220764,
0.11131762713193893,
0.4355767071247101,
0.5420771837234497,
0.2721765637397766,
-0.2150585949420929,
0.5098445415496826,
0.31607356667518616,
-0.568882942199707,
-0.8941553235054016,
0.1096290647983551,
-0.9597341418266296,
-0.4415781497955322,
0.859600841999054,
-0.4058394730091095,
-0.0010611031902953982,
-0.19700662791728973,
-0.4333331286907196,
0.16097691655158997,
-0.4190729856491089,
0.6909025311470032,
1.0073198080062866,
-0.5039842128753662,
-0.1875331997871399,
-0.6417554616928101,
0.036247603595256805,
0.22960858047008514,
-0.7710566520690918,
0.16529712080955505,
0.7579483985900879,
0.08796874433755875,
0.05060756951570511,
0.5699054598808289,
0.12851999700069427,
0.2507435083389282,
0.0066560362465679646,
-0.04013538360595703,
-0.18952347338199615,
0.012736339122056961,
-0.012164263986051083,
0.29095879197120667,
0.2181323766708374,
0.08469833433628082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18518v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18518v1 | APIGen: Automated Pipeline for Generating Verifiable and Diverse Function-Calling Datasets | 2024-06-26T17:49:11 | 2024-06-26T17:49:11 | Zuxin Liu, Thai Hoang, Jianguo Zhang, Ming Zhu, Tian Lan, Shirley Kokane, Juntao Tan, Weiran Yao, Zhiwei Liu, Yihao Feng, Rithesh Murthy, Liangwei Yang, Silvio Savarese, Juan Carlos Niebles, Huan Wang, Shelby Heinecke, Caiming Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | The advancement of function-calling agent models requires diverse, reliable,
and high-quality datasets. This paper presents APIGen, an automated data
generation pipeline designed to synthesize verifiable high-quality datasets for
function-calling applications. We leverage APIGen and collect 3,673 executable
APIs across 21 different categories to generate diverse function-calling
datasets in a scalable and structured manner. Each data in our dataset is
verified through three hierarchical stages: format checking, actual function
executions, and semantic verification, ensuring its reliability and
correctness. We demonstrate that models trained with our curated datasets, even
with only 7B parameters, can achieve state-of-the-art performance on the
Berkeley Function-Calling Benchmark, outperforming multiple GPT-4 models.
Moreover, our 1B model achieves exceptional performance, surpassing
GPT-3.5-Turbo and Claude-3 Haiku. We release a dataset containing 60,000
high-quality entries, aiming to advance the field of function-calling agent
domains. The dataset is available on Huggingface:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/Salesforce/xlam-function-calling-60k and the
project homepage: https://apigen-pipeline.github.io/ | [
-0.23853842914104462,
-0.44338762760162354,
0.2881981134414673,
0.19063055515289307,
0.037346020340919495,
0.189198300242424,
0.03171159699559212,
-0.5977449417114258,
-0.22736290097236633,
0.7496068477630615,
-0.6129482388496399,
-0.6172727942466736,
-0.25957751274108887,
0.23723994195461273,
-0.7845922112464905,
0.7608972191810608,
0.05677301436662674,
-0.07081479579210281,
-0.36501020193099976,
-0.14888474345207214,
-0.21679909527301788,
-0.218043714761734,
-0.4063463807106018,
-0.4311470687389374,
0.2125672698020935,
0.10079074651002884,
0.6197850108146667,
1.267490029335022,
0.23685623705387115,
0.35064858198165894,
0.4878506660461426,
0.42931556701660156,
-0.32926803827285767,
0.27339690923690796,
0.15379230678081512,
-0.5753172636032104,
-0.6641471982002258,
0.024607684463262558,
0.438196063041687,
0.5357941389083862,
0.03135880082845688,
0.5338013172149658,
-0.1272619664669037,
0.19441352784633636,
-0.30508238077163696,
0.3654453158378601,
-0.8454490900039673,
-0.002114025177434087,
-0.25050410628318787,
-0.15399661660194397,
-0.49939918518066406,
-0.6033440828323364,
0.2158534973859787,
-0.41460883617401123,
0.23724742233753204,
0.007514611352235079,
0.8874222040176392,
0.5333486199378967,
-0.19866502285003662,
-0.2381051778793335,
-0.615968644618988,
0.7030023336410522,
-0.5486694574356079,
0.2999618947505951,
0.3591271936893463,
0.5284109711647034,
0.1097346693277359,
-1.1112675666809082,
-0.14390167593955994,
-0.13580603897571564,
0.17485623061656952,
-0.10757538676261902,
-0.12247689813375473,
-0.17923162877559662,
0.22114965319633484,
0.25710809230804443,
-0.6997475624084473,
-0.06201113015413284,
-0.400604248046875,
-0.24783504009246826,
0.7796306014060974,
0.16806207597255707,
0.16921858489513397,
0.1414724588394165,
-0.3958798348903656,
-0.2080720067024231,
-0.7755624055862427,
0.22812455892562866,
0.8623705506324768,
0.5951899886131287,
0.0030662708450108767,
0.311550110578537,
-0.30139315128326416,
0.7337865233421326,
-0.16862046718597412,
-0.052059900015592575,
0.4318563938140869,
-0.43237438797950745,
-0.223049595952034,
-0.04012428969144821,
0.4439001977443695,
0.16640549898147583,
0.1463351547718048,
-0.4739898443222046,
-0.22695937752723694,
0.01891183853149414,
0.48747652769088745,
-0.9173716902732849,
-0.06917934119701385,
0.810149610042572,
-0.38190609216690063,
-0.5707603693008423,
0.1773066520690918,
-0.5405246019363403,
-0.28790727257728577,
-0.5536106824874878,
0.1259622573852539,
-0.5790323615074158,
-0.3070875406265259,
-0.005630635656416416,
-0.1367919147014618,
0.40199652314186096,
0.005929403472691774,
-0.6661444306373596,
0.3427491784095764,
0.8994154930114746,
0.6086689829826355,
-0.0965212881565094,
-0.5422524809837341,
-1.0204205513000488,
-0.07845155894756317,
-0.27011623978614807,
0.8466977477073669,
-0.5843710899353027,
-0.17952916026115417,
0.2607208490371704,
-0.08627904951572418,
0.044645071029663086,
-0.6907032132148743,
0.47357115149497986,
-0.25480058789253235,
-0.3528285324573517,
-0.21660207211971283,
-0.6735085248947144,
0.1422477513551712,
0.03608345985412598,
-0.5295157432556152,
0.97806316614151,
0.4025774896144867,
-0.1660463511943817,
0.696457028388977,
-0.5417352318763733,
-0.391181081533432,
0.4870418608188629,
-0.2664150297641754,
-0.3898092210292816,
-0.1259193867444992,
-0.05187889188528061,
0.3948887288570404,
-0.3570268750190735,
-0.04752781242132187,
-0.4831862449645996,
-0.052315760403871536,
0.3237002491950989,
0.06070923060178757,
0.8650631308555603,
0.2714399993419647,
-0.28011178970336914,
0.15553782880306244,
-1.1785169839859009,
0.4219256639480591,
-0.06245008111000061,
-0.049261171370744705,
0.07778756320476532,
-0.08809977769851685,
-0.008924005553126335,
0.21178841590881348,
0.0979519933462143,
-0.7201336622238159,
0.09331581741571426,
-0.3248775005340576,
0.5915780067443848,
0.6159681081771851,
-0.41277194023132324,
0.10641377419233322,
-0.45980629324913025,
0.523701012134552,
-0.26294848322868347,
0.40204188227653503,
-0.35471680760383606,
-0.47382083535194397,
-0.3058818578720093,
-0.4312390387058258,
0.4788743555545807,
0.5708858966827393,
-0.46470120549201965,
0.7155356407165527,
-0.16271723806858063,
-0.8281256556510925,
-0.5594967603683472,
0.302877277135849,
0.1303011178970337,
0.7041366100311279,
0.13989010453224182,
-0.03088407777249813,
-0.5844367146492004,
-0.7149367332458496,
0.1677739918231964,
-0.20083968341350555,
-0.1890154331922531,
0.2731626629829407,
0.48994195461273193,
-0.46449515223503113,
1.192603588104248,
-0.24667243659496307,
-0.014300845563411713,
0.045297034084796906,
0.29276591539382935,
0.07006550580263138,
0.21938984096050262,
0.7697672843933105,
-0.6221097707748413,
-0.22174300253391266,
0.09858351945877075,
-0.5863547921180725,
-0.4363129436969757,
0.03739530220627785,
-0.5620594024658203,
0.07485690712928772,
0.18413414061069489,
-0.2843092381954193,
0.19035129249095917,
0.6197260618209839,
-0.21431750059127808,
0.6223739981651306,
0.09581145644187927,
0.00063640798907727,
-0.9757847189903259,
0.3775152266025543,
-0.18243056535720825,
-0.4358697533607483,
-0.4765760600566864,
-0.07770470529794693,
-0.13778308033943176,
-0.21870717406272888,
-0.5113368630409241,
0.5987247824668884,
0.02187463268637657,
-0.18233394622802734,
-0.2369505912065506,
-0.18441127240657806,
-0.16512085497379303,
0.1539287120103836,
-0.18291513621807098,
0.526732325553894,
0.99611496925354,
-0.5569884181022644,
0.7895299196243286,
0.42292284965515137,
-0.10826925933361053,
0.5108959078788757,
-0.6769654154777527,
-0.004168387968093157,
0.3472100794315338,
0.20456071197986603,
-0.9712426066398621,
-0.44476181268692017,
0.15285062789916992,
-0.283390074968338,
-0.2459297627210617,
-0.5481730699539185,
-0.7746622562408447,
-0.39540979266166687,
-0.14456772804260254,
0.14699332416057587,
0.6891373991966248,
-0.6620470285415649,
0.7118556499481201,
0.29034650325775146,
-0.311737984418869,
-0.5851315259933472,
-0.5367685556411743,
-0.2605040371417999,
-0.0651940330862999,
-0.9820947051048279,
0.2679447829723358,
-0.020937731489539146,
-0.009015477262437344,
-0.029176289215683937,
-0.007859806530177593,
-0.017375575378537178,
-0.11909987032413483,
0.5877097249031067,
0.32203543186187744,
0.12554307281970978,
-0.0164847020059824,
-0.015273249708116055,
-0.1385079175233841,
0.08657591044902802,
-0.7061122059822083,
0.6959889531135559,
-0.15248112380504608,
-0.5376189351081848,
-0.10751373320817947,
0.17838013172149658,
0.6895840764045715,
-0.41547778248786926,
0.07224293798208237,
0.8373106718063354,
-0.36744168400764465,
-0.6527006030082703,
-0.1950744390487671,
-0.22797635197639465,
-0.4628559648990631,
-0.14234425127506256,
-0.22364161908626556,
-0.5413965582847595,
0.9990665316581726,
-0.04354210942983627,
0.5517309308052063,
0.24085988104343414,
0.5495746731758118,
0.3645183742046356,
1.0964882373809814,
0.25710365176200867,
0.1822969615459442,
0.2243189513683319,
-0.3832569718360901,
-0.02636531926691532,
-0.12256043404340744,
0.08479631692171097,
-0.4648793935775757,
-0.0913158729672432,
-0.6968207955360413,
-0.2371867597103119,
0.3195740878582001,
-0.6329467296600342,
-0.16057713329792023,
0.4252696931362152,
-0.5505942702293396,
0.2354864776134491,
0.6103737950325012,
-0.11792545020580292,
0.20661140978336334,
0.08307863771915436,
0.20209439098834991,
0.4972871243953705,
-0.3510707914829254,
-0.6850799322128296,
1.3549017906188965,
0.4424605369567871,
0.69955974817276,
-0.18367037177085876,
0.7287623882293701,
0.4139990210533142,
0.36406344175338745,
-0.6172908544540405,
0.5178960561752319,
-0.13654467463493347,
-0.5627134442329407,
-0.32743269205093384,
-0.6036615371704102,
-0.9151089787483215,
-0.11804210394620895,
0.1554533988237381,
-0.6208875179290771,
0.15566223859786987,
0.30435609817504883,
-0.6157525777816772,
0.062213052064180374,
-0.5921511650085449,
0.6276323199272156,
-0.2950369715690613,
-0.3252316117286682,
0.2309415191411972,
-0.7147579193115234,
0.34790366888046265,
-0.18745946884155273,
-0.19412380456924438,
-0.23652182519435883,
0.24250514805316925,
0.35333895683288574,
-0.892412006855011,
0.6778480410575867,
-0.29087111353874207,
-0.446967214345932,
0.5707036256790161,
-0.24674220383167267,
0.4710630774497986,
0.16710937023162842,
-0.2977514863014221,
0.23256297409534454,
0.2586665749549866,
-0.3234056830406189,
-0.15620379149913788,
0.44589003920555115,
-0.7244303822517395,
0.0969117283821106,
-0.090121328830719,
-0.4680143892765045,
-0.3038804531097412,
0.3919331729412079,
0.5256069898605347,
0.8342339992523193,
-0.025023700669407845,
0.12386231124401093,
0.5072050094604492,
0.009996037930250168,
0.2160157561302185,
0.12379076331853867,
-0.2685147821903229,
-0.2749159634113312,
1.2833009958267212,
0.09677424281835556,
0.25123095512390137,
-0.06271618604660034,
-0.25908833742141724,
-0.574724018573761,
-0.393736869096756,
-0.5075761079788208,
-0.013070682995021343,
-0.5187233090400696,
-0.4959067106246948,
-0.6474148035049438,
-0.32440677285194397,
-0.5728785395622253,
-0.04549546167254448,
-0.7204408049583435,
-0.07012486457824707,
0.19180890917778015,
-0.09337729215621948,
0.3800904154777527,
0.3654542863368988,
-0.11138498783111572,
0.22234657406806946,
-0.8245950937271118,
0.23238694667816162,
0.38391900062561035,
0.6001709699630737,
-0.3183356821537018,
0.015391387976706028,
-0.1961688995361328,
0.010597948916256428,
-0.2995477616786957,
-0.46979963779449463,
0.4771644175052643,
0.252389132976532,
0.6351476311683655,
0.376250684261322,
0.09179345518350601,
0.1803823858499527,
-0.3648740351200104,
0.724605143070221,
-0.25517579913139343,
-0.8778015971183777,
0.6820663213729858,
-0.5138946771621704,
0.10158776491880417,
0.5785645842552185,
-0.008985189720988274,
-0.022992486134171486,
-0.6008545756340027,
-0.7371082305908203,
-1.0314462184906006,
0.6224483847618103,
0.34111666679382324,
-0.03624206408858299,
0.318837970495224,
0.20550233125686646,
0.7515767812728882,
0.4228234589099884,
-0.053986746817827225,
-0.2738271653652191,
-0.37181273102760315,
-0.30207559466362,
0.47980377078056335,
0.34332433342933655,
-0.6479353308677673,
0.12458610534667969,
0.4932613968849182,
-0.563567042350769,
0.436053067445755,
-0.017475401982665062,
-0.015151494182646275,
-0.21060726046562195,
0.037485018372535706,
0.36394038796424866,
1.0414797067642212,
-0.4914567172527313,
-0.18070243299007416,
-0.21741759777069092,
-0.49868354201316833,
0.19002023339271545,
0.7585978507995605,
-0.12454122304916382,
0.1674484759569168,
0.24030949175357819,
0.7290298938751221,
-0.3052331507205963,
-0.9652049541473389,
0.2064366340637207,
-0.23862090706825256,
-0.3399667739868164,
-0.5235087871551514,
0.32544615864753723,
-0.3167489469051361,
0.14317843317985535,
0.6446856260299683,
0.07713576406240463,
0.22391320765018463,
-0.2911195456981659,
0.6658056378364563,
0.10659999400377274,
0.08802659064531326,
-0.366275817155838,
0.6450597047805786,
0.4355088174343109,
0.16519643366336823,
0.6504156589508057,
-0.25990357995033264,
-0.1518208384513855,
0.7903026342391968,
0.08352960646152496,
0.9590353965759277,
-0.07942067086696625,
0.46959128975868225,
0.21945546567440033,
0.0064165848307311535,
-0.03798498958349228,
0.3769432306289673,
-0.06809096038341522,
-0.6809532642364502,
-0.3598424792289734,
-0.7532732486724854,
-0.7779296636581421,
0.27178388833999634,
-0.685035765171051,
0.27517423033714294,
-0.42211076617240906,
-0.3781487047672272,
0.19420401751995087,
-0.024890111759305,
-0.8646447062492371,
0.08521699905395508,
0.4019300639629364,
1.1120502948760986,
-0.8134399056434631,
0.4992702305316925,
0.6603363156318665,
-0.3692326247692108,
-0.6603973507881165,
-0.12493070960044861,
0.1976793259382248,
-0.9312856793403625,
0.49964097142219543,
0.287647008895874,
-0.14613516628742218,
0.19570021331310272,
-0.7853379249572754,
-0.6363187432289124,
1.4461702108383179,
0.5273275971412659,
-0.17923030257225037,
0.10617685317993164,
0.45613163709640503,
0.48931699991226196,
-0.7553603649139404,
0.11992406100034714,
0.5454920530319214,
0.4858446717262268,
0.2085619866847992,
-0.7194637656211853,
-0.020137224346399307,
-0.31607112288475037,
-0.11145176738500595,
-0.24883148074150085,
-0.6824443936347961,
0.5913524627685547,
0.05850498750805855,
-0.058074913918972015,
0.25259411334991455,
0.4560335874557495,
0.5204618573188782,
0.14960592985153198,
0.7029889225959778,
0.343786358833313,
0.9459598064422607,
-0.32852301001548767,
1.043665885925293,
-0.6952247023582458,
0.1991766393184662,
0.8980563282966614,
-0.6592311859130859,
0.44261762499809265,
0.04461947828531265,
0.12234710901975632,
0.22450430691242218,
0.7447124719619751,
-0.4555520713329315,
0.3421342968940735,
0.11303208768367767,
-0.136996328830719,
-0.34688156843185425,
-0.19537928700447083,
-0.27793070673942566,
0.6013150811195374,
0.2448146939277649,
-0.44901958107948303,
-0.2660689949989319,
-0.023046908900141716,
-0.2776542603969574,
-0.44126322865486145,
-0.008607166819274426,
0.40180888772010803,
-0.30381402373313904,
-0.7805339694023132,
0.4472099244594574,
-0.40320467948913574,
0.3591705858707428,
-0.7664971947669983,
-0.006384111940860748,
-0.2842318117618561,
0.1887972205877304,
-0.24951674044132233,
-0.8053972125053406,
0.16697943210601807,
0.06953699886798859,
0.05747402086853981,
-0.43463683128356934,
0.7868435978889465,
-0.4147326648235321,
-0.325449675321579,
0.24955835938453674,
0.5819659233093262,
0.05782189592719078,
0.1004788801074028,
-0.5654193162918091,
0.3039535880088806,
-0.20057189464569092,
-0.06387287378311157,
-0.04112702235579491,
0.40176257491111755,
0.23769399523735046,
0.9292230606079102,
0.7058496475219727,
0.3190174400806427,
0.20512962341308594,
0.14031241834163666,
0.6170223951339722,
-0.19355805218219757,
-0.5207006335258484,
-0.4259825348854065,
0.8892480134963989,
-0.2965097725391388,
-0.4874846637248993,
0.4144647717475891,
0.6103233098983765,
0.856706440448761,
-0.2620861232280731,
1.265360951423645,
-0.22965286672115326,
0.33584466576576233,
-0.1737247258424759,
0.5819026827812195,
-0.2720194458961487,
0.081572525203228,
0.06884576380252838,
-0.6934900283813477,
-0.10646411776542664,
0.20830078423023224,
-0.07030133157968521,
0.1605004370212555,
0.14707051217556,
0.8948291540145874,
-0.17097578942775726,
0.16157880425453186,
0.2245090901851654,
0.10491219907999039,
0.6368293762207031,
0.2772296071052551,
0.8121788501739502,
-0.5191971659660339,
0.8410331010818481,
-0.028169330209493637,
-0.46806129813194275,
-0.3858877420425415,
-0.6635028123855591,
-0.6136307120323181,
-0.764560341835022,
-0.5542089343070984,
-0.4614061713218689,
-0.14259320497512817,
0.9485645890235901,
1.1355311870574951,
-0.6920509934425354,
-0.20111411809921265,
-0.1660986840724945,
-0.14067809283733368,
-0.6132676601409912,
-0.23354193568229675,
0.03777409717440605,
-0.5920273065567017,
-0.8654903173446655,
0.18826714158058167,
0.24255841970443726,
-0.08684118837118149,
-0.3338850438594818,
0.06634824723005295,
0.39955759048461914,
0.1550823152065277,
0.5897347927093506,
0.5604580640792847,
-0.417898029088974,
-0.22797635197639465,
-0.02166532725095749,
-0.1880204826593399,
-0.0028253498021513224,
0.6542378067970276,
-0.4509778618812561,
0.33022069931030273,
0.5367618203163147,
0.8692578673362732,
-0.024660684168338776,
0.20059646666049957,
0.8613367080688477,
-0.9887682795524597,
-0.24861747026443481,
0.1076548770070076,
0.33579379320144653,
0.26835954189300537,
-0.4810842275619507,
0.8380963802337646,
0.12452580034732819,
-0.7169083952903748,
-1.0392372608184814,
0.263294517993927,
-1.1398155689239502,
0.29845261573791504,
1.1796612739562988,
-0.13876482844352722,
-0.2727126479148865,
-0.07515221834182739,
-0.23641479015350342,
0.13673187792301178,
-0.5738598108291626,
0.6700843572616577,
0.5942155718803406,
-0.6877940893173218,
0.06574705243110657,
-0.448467493057251,
0.6873168349266052,
-0.05066794157028198,
-1.1940757036209106,
0.5575093626976013,
0.5363488793373108,
0.27222663164138794,
0.342615008354187,
0.25094449520111084,
-0.2874201834201813,
0.23662710189819336,
0.17016728222370148,
0.003645375370979309,
-0.24932979047298431,
-0.19687746465206146,
0.17470842599868774,
0.3494533598423004,
-0.1549263894557953,
-0.42588353157043457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18629v1 | Step-DPO: Step-wise Preference Optimization for Long-chain Reasoning of LLMs | 2024-06-26T17:43:06 | 2024-06-26T17:43:06 | Xin Lai, Zhuotao Tian, Yukang Chen, Senqiao Yang, Xiangru Peng, Jiaya Jia | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Mathematical reasoning presents a significant challenge for Large Language
Models (LLMs) due to the extensive and precise chain of reasoning required for
accuracy. Ensuring the correctness of each reasoning step is critical. To
address this, we aim to enhance the robustness and factuality of LLMs by
learning from human feedback. However, Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) has
shown limited benefits for long-chain mathematical reasoning, as models
employing DPO struggle to identify detailed errors in incorrect answers. This
limitation stems from a lack of fine-grained process supervision. We propose a
simple, effective, and data-efficient method called Step-DPO, which treats
individual reasoning steps as units for preference optimization rather than
evaluating answers holistically. Additionally, we have developed a data
construction pipeline for Step-DPO, enabling the creation of a high-quality
dataset containing 10K step-wise preference pairs. We also observe that in DPO,
self-generated data is more effective than data generated by humans or GPT-4,
due to the latter's out-of-distribution nature. Our findings demonstrate that
as few as 10K preference data pairs and fewer than 500 Step-DPO training steps
can yield a nearly 3% gain in accuracy on MATH for models with over 70B
parameters. Notably, Step-DPO, when applied to Qwen2-72B-Instruct, achieves
scores of 70.8% and 94.0% on the test sets of MATH and GSM8K, respectively,
surpassing a series of closed-source models, including GPT-4-1106,
Claude-3-Opus, and Gemini-1.5-Pro. Our code, data, and models are available at
https://github.com/dvlab-research/Step-DPO. | [
-0.2240205705165863,
-0.46940913796424866,
0.8983049988746643,
0.20343224704265594,
-0.2604551613330841,
0.06700228154659271,
-0.1175941601395607,
-0.10590330511331558,
-0.05128807947039604,
0.6944549083709717,
-0.6684414744377136,
-0.6065644025802612,
-0.31323087215423584,
0.07163215428590775,
0.06437402963638306,
0.6928106546401978,
-0.27463358640670776,
0.19055233895778656,
-0.39745160937309265,
0.33704015612602234,
-0.11633303016424179,
-0.563278317451477,
-0.6227124333381653,
-0.5581973791122437,
0.532249927520752,
0.5691646337509155,
0.6303811073303223,
0.7909141778945923,
0.5537802577018738,
0.24327348172664642,
-0.08728554844856262,
0.4439297616481781,
-0.42706239223480225,
0.15299636125564575,
-0.16553308069705963,
-0.40930405259132385,
-0.8601893782615662,
0.11666563898324966,
0.2810620069503784,
0.6671394109725952,
-0.20159170031547546,
0.2594008445739746,
-0.00801591295748949,
1.2240848541259766,
-0.4668978750705719,
0.25958317518234253,
-0.5184550881385803,
0.08576125651597977,
0.020315060392022133,
-0.24155882000923157,
-0.4254143238067627,
-0.5656450390815735,
0.11176019161939621,
-0.547447919845581,
-0.06222300976514816,
-0.019293958321213722,
0.25697073340415955,
0.41650617122650146,
-0.42243969440460205,
-0.3787667453289032,
-0.7058331966400146,
0.962110698223114,
-0.5441649556159973,
0.3785143494606018,
0.7097697257995605,
0.09365081787109375,
-0.4243435561656952,
-0.3946970999240875,
-0.2915806174278259,
-0.4168175458908081,
0.2317519336938858,
0.06510744988918304,
0.08501100540161133,
0.24325403571128845,
0.42813587188720703,
0.2516896426677704,
-0.28618451952934265,
0.008474898524582386,
-0.024699101224541664,
-0.10750313848257065,
0.8309503197669983,
0.11200491338968277,
-0.2066710889339447,
-0.23310157656669617,
-0.2995757758617401,
-0.07453249394893646,
-0.5296441316604614,
0.10120972990989685,
0.5710971355438232,
0.2828730642795563,
0.14385218918323517,
0.4103650450706482,
-0.38712039589881897,
0.7298505306243896,
0.33272498846054077,
-0.4856310188770294,
0.18351930379867554,
-0.19402660429477692,
-0.10868789255619049,
-0.06248001754283905,
0.7628880739212036,
0.21071907877922058,
0.39476141333580017,
0.04108857363462448,
-0.26856622099876404,
-0.03171810507774353,
0.08122121542692184,
-0.9078063368797302,
-0.22302553057670593,
0.3500828146934509,
-0.16312311589717865,
-0.5670688152313232,
-0.15183626115322113,
-0.6709170341491699,
-0.2253081500530243,
-0.8073636889457703,
0.28142765164375305,
-0.25363650918006897,
-0.028094759210944176,
0.46311134099960327,
0.2852685749530792,
-0.11513912677764893,
0.5951945781707764,
-0.9821423888206482,
0.3350517451763153,
0.7756112813949585,
0.7116577625274658,
-0.3165762424468994,
-0.1118130311369896,
-0.7643145322799683,
-0.08421768248081207,
-0.5591779947280884,
0.33567216992378235,
-0.4091913104057312,
-0.32011857628822327,
-0.32081499695777893,
-0.38417693972587585,
0.14890220761299133,
-0.5642513632774353,
0.8453212380409241,
-0.6135581135749817,
0.058596834540367126,
-0.29587486386299133,
-0.5697714686393738,
0.04954112321138382,
0.269304096698761,
-0.3880234360694885,
1.221220850944519,
-0.05827422812581062,
-0.6182405948638916,
0.25608211755752563,
-0.6561379432678223,
-0.22205176949501038,
-0.3173729479312897,
-0.19830964505672455,
-0.3677741289138794,
0.05802003666758537,
0.3955760598182678,
0.47005102038383484,
-0.27384939789772034,
0.35688045620918274,
-0.6480408906936646,
-0.3046466112136841,
0.13137075304985046,
-0.3876432478427887,
0.7221122980117798,
0.06289934366941452,
-0.34471020102500916,
0.07035963982343674,
-0.9890450239181519,
0.048252131789922714,
0.2513924837112427,
-0.38427025079727173,
-0.46845152974128723,
0.10278890281915665,
-0.7470365762710571,
0.37946993112564087,
0.2134123146533966,
-0.4586106836795807,
0.5694035887718201,
-0.34774819016456604,
0.34679603576660156,
1.1638941764831543,
-0.17964164912700653,
0.5020829439163208,
-0.015920665115118027,
0.4738410413265228,
0.06204016134142876,
0.45007631182670593,
0.2216985523700714,
-0.4055701792240143,
-0.6432798504829407,
-0.16201578080654144,
0.22048407793045044,
0.5265445709228516,
-0.6547492742538452,
0.6995558738708496,
-0.1571461260318756,
-0.24796245992183685,
-0.18721719086170197,
0.39040544629096985,
0.23535601794719696,
0.9395484328269958,
0.28725379705429077,
-0.08731347322463989,
-0.2748023271560669,
-0.8166163563728333,
0.11415745317935944,
-0.2806561291217804,
-0.09987472742795944,
0.23813268542289734,
0.5328120589256287,
-0.19890694320201874,
0.8727362155914307,
-0.8252350687980652,
0.09257107228040695,
0.0030047057662159204,
-0.20482578873634338,
0.4520283043384552,
0.15687522292137146,
0.21817512810230255,
-0.5856488943099976,
-0.4582017958164215,
-0.1894599348306656,
-0.5277025699615479,
-0.06051408499479294,
0.16827134788036346,
-0.6026381254196167,
0.0592288039624691,
0.06673049181699753,
-0.394435316324234,
0.17071686685085297,
0.54305100440979,
-0.09727419167757034,
0.5249431729316711,
-0.31457653641700745,
0.0006307762814685702,
-0.8973622918128967,
-0.16540205478668213,
0.18804769217967987,
-0.3657774329185486,
-0.49156203866004944,
-0.28038254380226135,
0.08410383015871048,
-0.0760326161980629,
-0.23186171054840088,
0.3436412811279297,
-0.2620203197002411,
-0.03734408691525459,
-0.1879831701517105,
0.013604464940726757,
-0.008529551327228546,
0.6808640360832214,
0.20665134489536285,
0.6136089563369751,
0.5879887938499451,
-0.7223613858222961,
0.5660367608070374,
0.10518860071897507,
-0.19774764776229858,
0.33359625935554504,
-0.5310320854187012,
0.5681484937667847,
-0.014193771407008171,
0.30128979682922363,
-0.8258550763130188,
-0.15029507875442505,
0.46980515122413635,
-0.253415048122406,
0.15928077697753906,
-0.45400190353393555,
-0.5702440738677979,
-0.4710642695426941,
-0.4860422909259796,
0.26638227701187134,
0.480925977230072,
-0.833586573600769,
0.3397447168827057,
0.23177868127822876,
0.10562538355588913,
-0.6381677985191345,
-0.21933677792549133,
-0.21984586119651794,
-0.19232413172721863,
-0.6533106565475464,
0.13581034541130066,
-0.31944212317466736,
-0.3383902609348297,
-0.499409943819046,
-0.4709010720252991,
-0.01023669820278883,
-0.0877283588051796,
0.07244400680065155,
0.4738125503063202,
0.30611491203308105,
0.24436679482460022,
0.07508152723312378,
-0.33061909675598145,
0.34532496333122253,
-0.495238333940506,
0.4896799921989441,
0.009461683221161366,
-0.3663367033004761,
-0.39662468433380127,
0.15229947865009308,
0.5983456969261169,
-0.10972802340984344,
0.12075074017047882,
0.1195821762084961,
-0.14746253192424774,
-0.47661292552948,
-0.17995251715183258,
-0.24722528457641602,
-0.5072197318077087,
-0.011841203086078167,
-0.5595503449440002,
-0.4706244468688965,
0.1521083563566208,
-0.22631508111953735,
0.15725108981132507,
0.19715918600559235,
0.4725155532360077,
-0.04462283477187157,
1.2622394561767578,
0.1899547576904297,
-0.14744462072849274,
0.4270440340042114,
-0.3133113980293274,
0.034898657351732254,
-0.7081879377365112,
-0.037741389125585556,
-0.1922784000635147,
-0.1637052297592163,
-0.5114272832870483,
-0.7446866631507874,
0.42149239778518677,
0.13184234499931335,
-0.33449018001556396,
0.013506746850907803,
-0.6046200394630432,
0.3844829201698303,
0.6995278000831604,
0.5419477224349976,
0.5234644412994385,
0.19390076398849487,
-0.3026551306247711,
-0.20514556765556335,
-0.4831382632255554,
-0.47986486554145813,
1.2627501487731934,
0.4464240074157715,
1.0947479009628296,
-0.20324517786502838,
1.0726747512817383,
0.1974644809961319,
-0.08807099610567093,
-1.1130213737487793,
0.6556577682495117,
-0.06815320253372192,
-0.3504166901111603,
-0.26255422830581665,
-0.7999058961868286,
-0.5859293937683105,
0.11186127364635468,
0.10765251517295837,
-0.43899422883987427,
0.10239347815513611,
0.509060800075531,
-0.2883354723453522,
0.2712057828903198,
-0.4783916175365448,
0.49105724692344666,
-0.6581243872642517,
-0.6601411700248718,
-0.20203199982643127,
-0.59530109167099,
0.39487409591674805,
-0.14252927899360657,
0.1166461631655693,
-0.3064654469490051,
-0.041178178042173386,
0.47891664505004883,
-0.5626803636550903,
0.7695564031600952,
-0.18652884662151337,
-0.41727128624916077,
0.3344702422618866,
0.1551830768585205,
0.7990639209747314,
0.21569091081619263,
-0.23566009104251862,
0.11481089144945145,
-0.20675556361675262,
-0.2475627362728119,
-0.7957019805908203,
0.6631855368614197,
-0.7513357996940613,
-0.6324605345726013,
-0.4209709167480469,
-0.3664347529411316,
-0.43043678998947144,
0.07764751464128494,
-0.18845728039741516,
0.45583826303482056,
0.343758225440979,
-0.12892268598079681,
0.8017613887786865,
0.16629695892333984,
0.24962520599365234,
0.24626663327217102,
-0.4539559483528137,
-0.6463481783866882,
0.7156468629837036,
-0.0830264687538147,
0.5137124061584473,
0.43208953738212585,
0.7057802081108093,
-0.5659550428390503,
-0.5493532419204712,
-0.5979519486427307,
0.3476727306842804,
-0.6930930018424988,
-0.039348017424345016,
-0.2981491684913635,
0.11957752704620361,
-0.1690789759159088,
0.041243501007556915,
-0.6459604501724243,
-0.4576292037963867,
-0.19662268459796906,
-0.031081590801477432,
0.3774769902229309,
0.47661063075065613,
-0.06019267812371254,
-0.19157153367996216,
-0.5923627018928528,
0.46365731954574585,
0.6128142476081848,
0.4998743534088135,
-0.08160363882780075,
-0.49048087000846863,
-0.10261941701173782,
0.17765529453754425,
-0.39256536960601807,
-0.6574399471282959,
0.1454523205757141,
-0.14319564402103424,
0.2632691264152527,
0.45002931356430054,
0.24656681716442108,
0.7843316793441772,
-0.4838438034057617,
0.3716653883457184,
0.19655010104179382,
-0.9994418621063232,
1.007890224456787,
-0.423945814371109,
0.03428611531853676,
0.5191624760627747,
0.631682813167572,
-0.10445883870124817,
0.14219458401203156,
-0.48494911193847656,
-0.6392264366149902,
0.7009832859039307,
0.18139025568962097,
-0.14056070148944855,
0.15112444758415222,
0.6862184405326843,
0.11175361275672913,
0.24681486189365387,
-0.5653850436210632,
-0.22544465959072113,
0.05801946669816971,
0.008179033175110817,
0.13966628909111023,
-0.13434503972530365,
-0.2790815830230713,
-0.5679838061332703,
0.739847719669342,
-0.41955527663230896,
-0.034559741616249084,
0.37821006774902344,
0.21818660199642181,
-0.18986566364765167,
0.1458750069141388,
0.45505619049072266,
0.9631142616271973,
-0.4104526937007904,
0.07083379477262497,
0.01661432906985283,
-0.481275349855423,
0.27569928765296936,
-0.03821571543812752,
-0.3040011525154114,
-0.15222489833831787,
0.0260199923068285,
0.7238351702690125,
-0.0314963273704052,
-0.41142308712005615,
0.3450612723827362,
0.030770499259233475,
-0.30082470178604126,
-0.25848063826560974,
0.06656341254711151,
-0.03350578993558884,
0.10338617116212845,
0.14837099611759186,
0.06039050966501236,
0.17954009771347046,
-0.43145081400871277,
0.095664381980896,
0.2676595449447632,
-0.2361765056848526,
-0.3715773820877075,
0.4713858366012573,
0.39617764949798584,
-0.16589269042015076,
0.48828455805778503,
-0.2574208080768585,
-0.4017373323440552,
0.374559223651886,
0.46876856684684753,
0.7678707838058472,
-0.02541736699640751,
0.27187925577163696,
0.5529006719589233,
-0.08869192749261856,
-0.46147945523262024,
0.2639276385307312,
-0.1988530308008194,
-0.7953360080718994,
-0.5865241885185242,
-0.7130370736122131,
-0.7835301756858826,
-0.02457519620656967,
-0.7127060294151306,
0.5063380002975464,
-0.5376259684562683,
-0.25728535652160645,
-0.14027346670627594,
0.31689590215682983,
-0.43994343280792236,
0.2615053951740265,
0.18464456498622894,
0.6105446815490723,
-0.47727829217910767,
1.0006108283996582,
0.5767107605934143,
-0.11907384544610977,
-0.764984130859375,
0.023339303210377693,
-0.0018921776209026575,
-0.9589227437973022,
0.750397801399231,
-0.05300365388393402,
-0.4332275390625,
0.00997188687324524,
-0.42606183886528015,
-0.84405517578125,
0.9839684963226318,
0.6088359355926514,
-0.9636585712432861,
-0.024706585332751274,
0.1341332495212555,
0.42472338676452637,
-0.3396152853965759,
0.12756597995758057,
0.5953050255775452,
0.3262195289134979,
0.5741837024688721,
-0.7614542245864868,
0.012978048995137215,
0.18466591835021973,
-0.11469803750514984,
0.4597557783126831,
-0.711532473564148,
0.5362228751182556,
-0.4250839054584503,
0.2513117790222168,
-0.3055153489112854,
0.38547083735466003,
0.7368436455726624,
0.31573596596717834,
0.8120714426040649,
0.6038482189178467,
0.8496045470237732,
0.09432749450206757,
1.0034024715423584,
-0.32520052790641785,
0.4708453416824341,
1.0243315696716309,
-0.27962726354599,
0.8448281288146973,
0.6205247044563293,
-0.6048622727394104,
0.3688648045063019,
0.7922616004943848,
0.29731351137161255,
0.4016169607639313,
0.5029695630073547,
-0.2538580894470215,
-0.5952582955360413,
0.17360585927963257,
-0.1026843786239624,
0.3679927885532379,
0.08301714062690735,
-0.3713034987449646,
0.11817819625139236,
-0.5268678665161133,
0.21061021089553833,
-0.013915346935391426,
-0.43157029151916504,
0.5037457942962646,
0.21506482362747192,
-0.7273738980293274,
0.6028028130531311,
-0.3375800549983978,
0.527515172958374,
-0.6236496567726135,
-0.004186532460153103,
-0.3531229496002197,
0.39630910754203796,
-0.25554630160331726,
-0.8000258207321167,
0.025322260335087776,
0.09020128101110458,
-0.21174512803554535,
-0.4289446175098419,
0.6157786250114441,
-0.27376070618629456,
-0.7212244868278503,
0.3721937835216522,
0.40852421522140503,
0.0073750438168644905,
-0.21499603986740112,
-0.718205988407135,
-0.12310412526130676,
0.18920142948627472,
-0.3590424358844757,
0.23077240586280823,
0.3442940413951874,
-0.0814833864569664,
0.8158476948738098,
0.8677986264228821,
0.2468716949224472,
-0.20648911595344543,
0.2896752953529358,
0.8454602360725403,
-0.6995319128036499,
-0.3133096992969513,
-1.1039366722106934,
0.3372502624988556,
-0.21618890762329102,
-0.2964867651462555,
0.6686002612113953,
0.5749524831771851,
0.7622635364532471,
0.004885535221546888,
0.6676580905914307,
0.3356102705001831,
0.43049758672714233,
-0.6012254953384399,
0.05801784619688988,
-0.4765932559967041,
0.36042946577072144,
-0.4010426104068756,
-0.996891438961029,
-0.2731704115867615,
0.5769656300544739,
-0.5456901788711548,
0.010710674338042736,
0.4707302749156952,
0.5976160764694214,
-0.19613753259181976,
-0.2294488251209259,
0.27642470598220825,
-0.20257247984409332,
0.39288368821144104,
0.6752821803092957,
0.8971330523490906,
-0.26768457889556885,
0.5712276101112366,
-0.652601957321167,
-0.4295033812522888,
-0.06715209782123566,
-1.0241854190826416,
-0.9826682209968567,
-0.13457083702087402,
-0.42824506759643555,
-0.2454231083393097,
-0.1294880509376526,
1.239689588546753,
0.75457763671875,
-0.5233072638511658,
-0.4215719401836395,
-0.31953659653663635,
0.23555728793144226,
-0.1864033043384552,
-0.16641059517860413,
0.3494715392589569,
-0.3322788178920746,
-0.9230944514274597,
0.3931201100349426,
0.4297213852405548,
-0.017430385574698448,
-0.4085736572742462,
-0.33990907669067383,
0.13608703017234802,
0.041810259222984314,
0.8329155445098877,
-0.05867282301187515,
-0.6489469408988953,
-0.24351610243320465,
0.3062286078929901,
0.07962676882743835,
0.3203904628753662,
0.8335421681404114,
-0.36953192949295044,
0.6747766733169556,
0.6399430632591248,
0.34352993965148926,
0.6432900428771973,
0.1691211760044098,
0.6304977536201477,
-0.4724399447441101,
-0.11129265278577805,
0.3418824076652527,
0.32776933908462524,
0.20312361419200897,
-0.39072874188423157,
0.7064083218574524,
0.3894095718860626,
-0.8333205580711365,
-0.6334797143936157,
0.47353672981262207,
-1.1410096883773804,
0.08438730984926224,
1.301087498664856,
-0.0690031424164772,
-0.13187937438488007,
0.23117858171463013,
-0.351719468832016,
-0.0020626019686460495,
-0.7368456721305847,
0.8935003876686096,
0.6621694564819336,
-0.68189537525177,
0.06935189664363861,
-0.5253084897994995,
0.5576652884483337,
0.2683551609516144,
-0.8686656951904297,
0.17237134277820587,
0.5770527124404907,
0.40324971079826355,
0.0029384938534349203,
0.7086458206176758,
-0.0365096852183342,
-0.03994801640510559,
-0.24214164912700653,
-0.14242441952228546,
-0.10501205921173096,
-0.3366895020008087,
-0.25295954942703247,
-0.028627799823880196,
0.1756075918674469,
-0.40376466512680054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18512v1 | "Is ChatGPT a Better Explainer than My Professor?": Evaluating the Explanation Capabilities of LLMs in Conversation Compared to a Human Baseline | 2024-06-26T17:33:51 | 2024-06-26T17:33:51 | Grace Li, Milad Alshomary, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Explanations form the foundation of knowledge sharing and build upon
communication principles, social dynamics, and learning theories. We focus
specifically on conversational approaches for explanations because the context
is highly adaptive and interactive. Our research leverages previous work on
explanatory acts, a framework for understanding the different strategies that
explainers and explainees employ in a conversation to both explain, understand,
and engage with the other party. We use the 5-Levels dataset was constructed
from the WIRED YouTube series by Wachsmuth et al., and later annotated by
Booshehri et al. with explanatory acts. These annotations provide a framework
for understanding how explainers and explainees structure their response when
crafting a response.
With the rise of generative AI in the past year, we hope to better understand
the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) and how they can augment
expert explainer's capabilities in conversational settings. To achieve this
goal, the 5-Levels dataset (We use Booshehri et al.'s 2023 annotated dataset
with explanatory acts.) allows us to audit the ability of LLMs in engaging in
explanation dialogues. To evaluate the effectiveness of LLMs in generating
explainer responses, we compared 3 different strategies, we asked human
annotators to evaluate 3 different strategies: human explainer response, GPT4
standard response, GPT4 response with Explanation Moves. | [
-0.553538978099823,
-0.8871884346008301,
0.42395028471946716,
-0.038939736783504486,
-0.25119125843048096,
0.1351383477449417,
-0.39876848459243774,
-0.41503170132637024,
-0.1621084064245224,
-0.08196765184402466,
-0.5652760863304138,
-0.16977687180042267,
-0.6207868456840515,
0.08618837594985962,
-0.5132786631584167,
1.22145414352417,
0.20816779136657715,
0.014609434641897678,
-0.3641858696937561,
0.09662458300590515,
-0.5629061460494995,
-0.2816520929336548,
-1.0291606187820435,
-0.5965431332588196,
0.527230978012085,
0.4641253650188446,
0.8005240559577942,
0.47758933901786804,
0.5520479679107666,
0.39641356468200684,
-0.26854246854782104,
-0.04854194074869156,
-0.8158111572265625,
0.03779827058315277,
0.10658177733421326,
-0.6374368071556091,
-0.29207003116607666,
-0.03561996668577194,
0.3208451569080353,
0.8355410695075989,
-0.222858726978302,
0.022543197497725487,
0.03477826714515686,
0.4445493817329407,
-0.14708097279071808,
0.3831506073474884,
-0.5864188075065613,
0.05219222232699394,
0.2083064317703247,
-0.33516526222229004,
-0.331617146730423,
-0.4022701680660248,
0.5254356265068054,
-0.4886416792869568,
0.41069239377975464,
0.01036023534834385,
0.8077151775360107,
0.17572569847106934,
-0.33975231647491455,
-0.3854530155658722,
-0.7641198635101318,
0.3938228189945221,
-0.6604828238487244,
0.17534300684928894,
0.041308943182229996,
0.6244066953659058,
-0.15277816355228424,
-0.5897688865661621,
-0.7611462473869324,
-0.3108687102794647,
-0.11700176447629929,
0.29235708713531494,
-0.23030583560466766,
0.17575576901435852,
0.398223876953125,
0.5936814546585083,
-0.6195923686027527,
0.2945445775985718,
-0.5420464277267456,
-0.14279016852378845,
0.5529042482376099,
0.09410517662763596,
0.22111013531684875,
-0.21153558790683746,
-0.457736611366272,
-0.019012587144970894,
-0.5491819977760315,
0.2271088808774948,
0.19662833213806152,
-0.0972885861992836,
-0.16910378634929657,
0.40354445576667786,
-0.11580579727888107,
0.5065188407897949,
0.09795796126127243,
0.03051871992647648,
-0.07642064988613129,
-0.34164756536483765,
-0.3476511836051941,
-0.014247598126530647,
0.6911590099334717,
0.5806080102920532,
0.5165802240371704,
-0.2704368829727173,
0.1540592461824417,
-0.11968746781349182,
0.1251222938299179,
-0.8006247282028198,
-0.4902303218841553,
0.255226194858551,
-0.46620744466781616,
-0.22662398219108582,
-0.2255314141511917,
-0.7785161137580872,
-0.7839892506599426,
-0.27929049730300903,
0.46230655908584595,
-0.44053834676742554,
-0.3065238296985626,
-0.018337316811084747,
-0.3003457188606262,
0.5277291536331177,
0.29096513986587524,
-1.0625896453857422,
0.36387723684310913,
0.5819145441055298,
0.6539390683174133,
-0.20292817056179047,
-0.20532700419425964,
-0.20729047060012817,
0.11073458194732666,
-0.3837231397628784,
0.8582574725151062,
-0.563422679901123,
-0.4123269021511078,
-0.02749224379658699,
-0.14588889479637146,
-0.08772124350070953,
-0.5496017932891846,
0.4878184497356415,
-0.39069482684135437,
0.5589371919631958,
-0.38131964206695557,
-0.7812841534614563,
-0.42911040782928467,
0.037920061498880386,
-0.35975897312164307,
0.6571095585823059,
0.01641760766506195,
-0.5641686320304871,
0.3893476724624634,
-1.1053142547607422,
-0.15306837856769562,
0.22171936929225922,
-0.21830812096595764,
-0.0998266264796257,
0.011233140714466572,
0.553293764591217,
0.5807514190673828,
-0.14899782836437225,
0.3046092987060547,
-0.06235329061746597,
-0.35385993123054504,
0.6048387885093689,
-0.670769453048706,
0.5839322805404663,
0.14672452211380005,
-0.4622361660003662,
0.24527785181999207,
-0.49694228172302246,
-0.07987511157989502,
0.2979571521282196,
-0.2428978681564331,
0.0513024739921093,
0.14197216928005219,
-0.4893324375152588,
-0.012358703650534153,
0.12222030758857727,
-0.12848830223083496,
-0.06748518347740173,
-0.48685380816459656,
0.6930897235870361,
0.73471999168396,
0.12862443923950195,
0.4045774042606354,
-0.3629448115825653,
0.6104379296302795,
-0.1633562296628952,
0.14134547114372253,
-0.5593390464782715,
-0.46329912543296814,
-0.7535483837127686,
-0.05856722593307495,
-0.0015817531384527683,
0.28527581691741943,
-0.5894922614097595,
0.018393361940979958,
-0.6226392984390259,
-0.3716304302215576,
-0.4538031220436096,
0.0848582461476326,
0.48779746890068054,
0.6714703440666199,
0.2590041160583496,
-0.05386820808053017,
-0.35505133867263794,
-0.8963866829872131,
-0.32699230313301086,
-0.3903678357601166,
-0.17739376425743103,
0.13050925731658936,
0.34104660153388977,
0.23741242289543152,
0.9149696826934814,
-0.2280079871416092,
0.3281928300857544,
-0.5945867896080017,
0.2875395715236664,
0.11902782320976257,
0.058331456035375595,
0.33403727412223816,
-0.7328730225563049,
-0.2729547917842865,
-0.03823154792189598,
-0.766202986240387,
-0.13841591775417328,
-0.2818666994571686,
0.09953531622886658,
-0.03689007833600044,
0.463704377412796,
-0.6656745076179504,
0.21136362850666046,
0.434482216835022,
-0.25680696964263916,
0.4435943365097046,
-0.3349086344242096,
0.2179708480834961,
-0.7889966368675232,
-0.273144006729126,
-0.09531315416097641,
-0.27426543831825256,
-0.9423480033874512,
0.024725070223212242,
-0.29897528886795044,
-0.06256898492574692,
-0.17647279798984528,
0.28101053833961487,
-0.47441592812538147,
-0.31698867678642273,
-0.23798668384552002,
0.5021354556083679,
-0.08019228279590607,
0.6241270303726196,
-0.1123160868883133,
0.9295606017112732,
0.4772288501262665,
-0.5548707246780396,
0.28976136445999146,
0.33193784952163696,
-0.46291303634643555,
0.45499494671821594,
-0.8477109670639038,
0.19618959724903107,
-0.17487196624279022,
0.3779330253601074,
-1.3146448135375977,
-0.45468220114707947,
0.27630484104156494,
-0.6712312698364258,
-0.02814616821706295,
-0.1506962776184082,
-0.30759623646736145,
-0.41868001222610474,
-0.22662748396396637,
-0.14258547127246857,
0.5121956467628479,
-0.6684288382530212,
0.45025989413261414,
0.13364773988723755,
-0.38347387313842773,
-0.3027079403400421,
-0.5824844837188721,
0.32376059889793396,
-0.738423764705658,
-0.6739702820777893,
0.2400616705417633,
-0.3842237591743469,
-0.373454213142395,
-0.33823394775390625,
-0.14901410043239594,
-0.03695293888449669,
0.25572648644447327,
0.25890499353408813,
0.19775329530239105,
-0.34226852655410767,
0.22404654324054718,
-0.1983790546655655,
-0.20166140794754028,
0.4724537134170532,
0.1385938674211502,
0.5324693322181702,
-0.14224377274513245,
-0.49587753415107727,
-0.6946331262588501,
0.08378008753061295,
0.3921376168727875,
0.047091152518987656,
0.6860840320587158,
0.7826903462409973,
0.07809007167816162,
0.1372508555650711,
-0.4802832305431366,
-0.2959914207458496,
-0.4701825976371765,
0.4225461184978485,
-0.4610063433647156,
-0.7995576858520508,
0.651273787021637,
0.05211428180336952,
0.2797616124153137,
0.27610257267951965,
0.6077125072479248,
-0.13064691424369812,
1.2551491260528564,
0.37799233198165894,
-0.008895458653569221,
0.5028797388076782,
-0.1755879819393158,
0.6487959623336792,
-0.69315105676651,
-0.3675822615623474,
-0.3006046712398529,
-0.1891641914844513,
-0.5620303153991699,
-0.33114415407180786,
0.28302016854286194,
0.16515573859214783,
-0.20322343707084656,
0.02956339716911316,
-0.34648433327674866,
0.5409308671951294,
0.4738633632659912,
-0.060009460896253586,
0.23657119274139404,
0.16367390751838684,
0.42589351534843445,
0.20957043766975403,
-0.7371225953102112,
-0.6728357672691345,
0.8007086515426636,
0.7055631279945374,
0.7168366312980652,
0.4215129613876343,
0.5076114535331726,
0.08433729410171509,
0.25318077206611633,
-0.7817961573600769,
0.5711119174957275,
0.29976826906204224,
-0.42825883626937866,
-0.5548446178436279,
-0.38233211636543274,
-1.0358232259750366,
0.4958910048007965,
-0.1569361388683319,
-0.9142037630081177,
-0.25319555401802063,
0.2340455800294876,
-0.3287932574748993,
0.06767342984676361,
-1.128153681755066,
0.8219902515411377,
-0.12893696129322052,
-0.12256564199924469,
-0.24114547669887543,
-0.6111922264099121,
0.24660824239253998,
0.2423647940158844,
0.28618913888931274,
-0.06404629349708557,
0.08183955401182175,
0.8650231957435608,
-0.305377721786499,
0.8101969361305237,
-0.3672713339328766,
-0.11262360215187073,
0.22424350678920746,
0.015582963824272156,
0.38499659299850464,
-0.04466991126537323,
-0.0613766647875309,
-0.09046462923288345,
-0.04660383611917496,
-0.3556123971939087,
-0.9886753559112549,
0.39534592628479004,
-0.7194799780845642,
-0.9718374013900757,
0.15747222304344177,
-0.5474239587783813,
-0.20084398984909058,
-0.28927361965179443,
0.1520153135061264,
0.536956250667572,
-0.06100364029407501,
0.21332426369190216,
0.6453973650932312,
-0.14159348607063293,
0.515905499458313,
0.46579334139823914,
0.0004898818442597985,
-0.0174411628395319,
1.006604552268982,
-0.17433618009090424,
0.46106141805648804,
0.2815673351287842,
0.5482680201530457,
-0.363880455493927,
-0.8715717196464539,
-0.47803473472595215,
0.061886001378297806,
-1.0047186613082886,
0.26210665702819824,
-0.5850648880004883,
-0.1299830824136734,
-0.3369545340538025,
-0.16929946839809418,
0.3173442482948303,
-0.42793330550193787,
-0.014547324739396572,
-0.4890197515487671,
0.40586572885513306,
0.8320383429527283,
-0.0016289062332361937,
0.6530300974845886,
-0.21864104270935059,
0.18684665858745575,
0.6089815497398376,
-0.026643000543117523,
0.2202739268541336,
-0.7536309361457825,
-0.07331532984972,
0.17366153001785278,
-0.30184394121170044,
-0.95657879114151,
0.290413498878479,
0.31337660551071167,
0.7827661037445068,
0.6876311898231506,
-0.2796703577041626,
0.947941780090332,
-0.2908303439617157,
1.180192232131958,
0.09328532963991165,
-0.9077039361000061,
0.40442657470703125,
-0.3753879964351654,
0.3290042579174042,
0.1452043503522873,
0.39902618527412415,
-0.5539862513542175,
-0.5122194886207581,
-0.6618980765342712,
-0.9005448818206787,
0.5788664221763611,
0.5030498504638672,
0.3204401731491089,
0.14700235426425934,
0.3859153985977173,
0.29959049820899963,
0.11086290329694748,
-0.8851585388183594,
-0.20851483941078186,
-0.1142348051071167,
-0.17253217101097107,
-0.3424173593521118,
-0.3479611575603485,
-0.305687814950943,
-0.03364988788962364,
0.4390307068824768,
-0.242696151137352,
0.7186880111694336,
0.10353527963161469,
-0.2356896698474884,
0.1186831071972847,
0.42087703943252563,
0.7188639044761658,
1.053743839263916,
-0.03269359469413757,
0.33434736728668213,
0.42816832661628723,
-0.1708395928144455,
-0.2899252772331238,
0.17370480298995972,
0.5066503882408142,
-0.14201341569423676,
0.7887742519378662,
0.9057657122612,
-0.04852643236517906,
-0.5393358469009399,
0.49948909878730774,
-0.16527682542800903,
-0.21121202409267426,
-0.1331757754087448,
0.2949734330177307,
0.21611762046813965,
0.24371907114982605,
0.37932461500167847,
-0.4316495656967163,
0.20318478345870972,
-0.5556268095970154,
-0.09401543438434601,
0.28796884417533875,
-0.43614262342453003,
-0.33433717489242554,
0.5910650491714478,
0.29045814275741577,
-0.3103495240211487,
0.3440093994140625,
0.052581287920475006,
-0.5276182889938354,
0.7715705037117004,
0.4347231686115265,
0.4587048888206482,
-0.16123785078525543,
0.3963589668273926,
0.034762732684612274,
0.1518857777118683,
0.2575283944606781,
0.05566401779651642,
-0.35992467403411865,
-0.6459360122680664,
-0.5629829168319702,
-0.18255072832107544,
-0.5142965316772461,
0.31466877460479736,
-0.5691536664962769,
-0.18824976682662964,
-0.08810211718082428,
0.25024163722991943,
0.5519715547561646,
-0.1529657244682312,
-0.559603750705719,
0.11409803479909897,
0.02528039924800396,
0.7238843441009521,
-0.7898901104927063,
0.293728232383728,
0.45431798696517944,
-0.5155350565910339,
-0.7983401417732239,
0.1012393906712532,
0.07684919238090515,
-1.0346317291259766,
0.6413665413856506,
0.16509394347667694,
-0.07394961267709732,
-0.08356206119060516,
-0.6987667679786682,
-0.4634227156639099,
1.002525806427002,
0.2834945619106293,
-0.31266096234321594,
-0.008899561129510403,
0.13459423184394836,
0.8441956639289856,
-0.3294938802719116,
0.8493170142173767,
0.595391035079956,
0.3115476369857788,
0.2131911963224411,
-0.8923304677009583,
-0.04833598807454109,
-0.06322287023067474,
-0.1028265580534935,
-0.10980840027332306,
-0.43391576409339905,
0.42440876364707947,
-0.3749595880508423,
-0.17385384440422058,
0.08621519058942795,
0.692358136177063,
-0.03824140504002571,
0.3772650957107544,
0.5872837901115417,
0.09052042663097382,
0.8434881567955017,
-0.16770321130752563,
1.1763871908187866,
-0.10913753509521484,
0.08170223981142044,
1.0105122327804565,
0.19087645411491394,
0.6294161677360535,
0.4828026592731476,
-0.18529286980628967,
0.754006028175354,
0.9607140421867371,
0.13599678874015808,
0.3228502869606018,
0.4150719940662384,
-0.2027212232351303,
-0.1694648265838623,
0.027944300323724747,
-0.187910258769989,
0.3797350525856018,
0.4452055096626282,
-0.35132986307144165,
-0.1679856777191162,
0.12835970520973206,
0.07143446803092957,
-0.14802570641040802,
-0.13969816267490387,
1.0963801145553589,
-0.055136725306510925,
-0.7689903378486633,
0.6954472064971924,
-0.30061212182044983,
0.151844322681427,
-0.32398611307144165,
0.0003576598537620157,
-0.3509570360183716,
-0.09902223944664001,
-0.21173344552516937,
-1.0607904195785522,
0.04090500622987747,
0.05352325737476349,
-0.0009125340147875249,
-0.2713719606399536,
0.40205541253089905,
-0.3627873659133911,
0.08536812663078308,
-0.006125376094132662,
0.47772571444511414,
0.692869246006012,
0.23691044747829437,
-0.7824116349220276,
-0.15947763621807098,
0.013038785196840763,
-0.22995023429393768,
0.03447666019201279,
0.4719768762588501,
-0.11293033510446548,
1.0813173055648804,
0.4431776702404022,
-0.19180479645729065,
0.1171826422214508,
0.4219440221786499,
0.805141806602478,
-0.4537530243396759,
-0.3372376263141632,
-0.8464115262031555,
0.5791072249412537,
-0.2957344651222229,
-0.13034377992153168,
0.6776140928268433,
0.35641172528266907,
0.6015170216560364,
0.07480896264314651,
0.766654908657074,
-0.04183916747570038,
0.5023831725120544,
-0.524385929107666,
0.21423058211803436,
-0.1972493827342987,
0.44830602407455444,
-0.04260005056858063,
-0.7439771890640259,
0.03231285139918327,
0.6587134003639221,
-0.6395784616470337,
0.38707131147384644,
0.6820845007896423,
0.809028148651123,
-0.029092565178871155,
0.4679217040538788,
0.3500048816204071,
0.5498174428939819,
0.6163695454597473,
0.3650476634502411,
1.2038835287094116,
0.01763911359012127,
0.8715572953224182,
0.01688527688384056,
-0.24515852332115173,
-0.14532943069934845,
-0.743414580821991,
-1.2105671167373657,
-0.48481810092926025,
-0.3643494248390198,
0.03226137533783913,
0.14680089056491852,
0.6854009628295898,
0.7908083200454712,
-0.6486045122146606,
-0.1972186416387558,
-0.2191522866487503,
0.18532617390155792,
-0.16074736416339874,
-0.2876836359500885,
0.37146085500717163,
-0.4647357761859894,
-0.7527832984924316,
0.48320668935775757,
0.0913584902882576,
-0.026854634284973145,
-0.3437461853027344,
-0.08630423247814178,
0.24568794667720795,
0.03630038723349571,
0.6774161458015442,
0.01344713382422924,
-0.8837295174598694,
-0.4483106732368469,
-0.08424526453018188,
0.20368902385234833,
0.24200166761875153,
0.7286763191223145,
-0.5283949971199036,
0.5969756245613098,
0.4499349296092987,
0.5740638375282288,
0.3760029971599579,
0.11939483880996704,
0.7664244771003723,
-0.31361255049705505,
-0.38015836477279663,
-0.15362171828746796,
0.14456620812416077,
0.5583558678627014,
-0.33339521288871765,
0.4802767038345337,
-0.18041978776454926,
-0.738518476486206,
-0.5291000604629517,
0.14444680511951447,
-1.0079796314239502,
-0.2962503731250763,
1.1187665462493896,
-0.2848203182220459,
-0.007778701838105917,
-0.27548906207084656,
-0.45051082968711853,
0.10930123925209045,
-0.5064125657081604,
1.0018500089645386,
0.7536171674728394,
-0.6279268264770508,
-0.5219272375106812,
-0.8892258405685425,
0.591397762298584,
0.3427724242210388,
-0.9210882186889648,
0.13919909298419952,
0.32477933168411255,
0.2243330180644989,
-0.05603105202317238,
0.44419941306114197,
0.12223727256059647,
0.17632964253425598,
-0.2908812463283539,
-0.22737520933151245,
-0.003079480491578579,
0.051612332463264465,
-0.5387465953826904,
0.09015176445245743,
0.23318544030189514,
-0.22103874385356903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01603v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01603v1 | A Review of Large Language Models and Autonomous Agents in Chemistry | 2024-06-26T17:33:21 | 2024-06-26T17:33:21 | Mayk Caldas Ramos, Christopher J. Collison, Andrew D. White | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph | Large language models (LLMs) are emerging as a powerful tool in chemistry
across multiple domains. In chemistry, LLMs are able to accurately predict
properties, design new molecules, optimize synthesis pathways, and accelerate
drug and material discovery. A core emerging idea is combining LLMs with
chemistry-specific tools like synthesis planners and databases, leading to
so-called "agents." This review covers LLMs' recent history, current
capabilities, design, challenges specific to chemistry, and future directions.
Particular attention is given to agents and their emergence as a
cross-chemistry paradigm. Agents have proven effective in diverse domains of
chemistry, but challenges remain. It is unclear if creating domain-specific
versus generalist agents and developing autonomous pipelines versus "co-pilot"
systems will accelerate chemistry. An emerging direction is the development of
multi-agent systems using a human-in-the-loop approach. Due to the incredibly
fast development of this field, a repository has been built to keep track of
the latest studies: https://github.com/ur-whitelab/LLMs-in-science. | [
-0.1383594125509262,
-0.643262505531311,
1.1869984865188599,
-0.10117139667272568,
0.48850077390670776,
0.7559896111488342,
-0.22258351743221283,
-0.4810815751552582,
0.24008329212665558,
0.7547224760055542,
-0.30162617564201355,
-0.43991535902023315,
-0.4761428236961365,
0.24043455719947815,
-0.3591698408126831,
0.6080236434936523,
-0.1992628425359726,
0.26557624340057373,
-0.43466606736183167,
0.09959351271390915,
-0.117169588804245,
-0.49860724806785583,
-0.5436951518058777,
-0.6631671190261841,
0.733149528503418,
0.20407238602638245,
0.6903110146522522,
0.5269396305084229,
0.5632694363594055,
0.4504876434803009,
0.06359010934829712,
-0.01586446724832058,
-0.09895040094852448,
0.5656564831733704,
-0.35297903418540955,
-0.3930584788322449,
-0.917579174041748,
0.14552003145217896,
0.5788804888725281,
0.9688311219215393,
0.07468033581972122,
-0.23359063267707825,
-0.3441929519176483,
0.6164807081222534,
-0.5706609487533569,
0.1643839031457901,
-0.39586877822875977,
-0.1825903058052063,
-0.05930168554186821,
0.23762044310569763,
-0.2684721052646637,
-0.03230193257331848,
0.286724328994751,
-0.4509405493736267,
0.0035839416086673737,
-0.048195887356996536,
0.2210654318332672,
-0.019396912306547165,
-0.7457292079925537,
-0.5851534605026245,
-1.03561532497406,
0.7121976613998413,
-0.45552611351013184,
0.293874591588974,
-0.20559822022914886,
0.637518048286438,
-0.7869058847427368,
-1.0429686307907104,
-0.38739141821861267,
-0.6569634079933167,
0.24561280012130737,
-0.00567247299477458,
0.10144492238759995,
0.2367313653230667,
-0.32033878564834595,
0.286703497171402,
-0.5232234001159668,
0.1330840140581131,
-0.15915021300315857,
-0.26605531573295593,
0.6104800701141357,
0.5355448126792908,
0.47145286202430725,
0.3673636317253113,
-0.33717963099479675,
0.26174938678741455,
-0.8227584958076477,
-0.41510850191116333,
0.24837832152843475,
0.48967742919921875,
0.11776953190565109,
0.7106772661209106,
-0.15554475784301758,
0.3125859498977661,
-0.2135789394378662,
-0.17345432937145233,
-0.06417054682970047,
-0.7283213138580322,
-0.07497986406087875,
0.0874447152018547,
0.7684667706489563,
-0.0988134890794754,
0.3097245395183563,
-0.1503896564245224,
-0.3503485918045044,
0.141416534781456,
0.0676303431391716,
-0.6618663668632507,
-0.2368766814470291,
0.5138983130455017,
-0.08425038307905197,
-0.16056588292121887,
0.025412512943148613,
-0.6117125153541565,
-0.6667588353157043,
-0.43956443667411804,
0.3435133993625641,
0.1207423135638237,
-0.2904309332370758,
-0.1291656196117401,
-0.2224603146314621,
0.07107485085725784,
0.36431583762168884,
-0.8850910663604736,
0.6113847494125366,
0.7675260305404663,
0.7117210030555725,
-0.4593485891819,
-0.5871191620826721,
-0.24580006301403046,
0.3042495548725128,
-0.4359782338142395,
0.9530246257781982,
-0.6847126483917236,
-0.39136797189712524,
0.07043436169624329,
0.12097498029470444,
0.3477898836135864,
-0.6004387140274048,
-0.15417373180389404,
-0.4282589256763458,
-0.20423652231693268,
-0.3372557759284973,
-0.3490961790084839,
0.25255417823791504,
-0.0013087531551718712,
-0.656679093837738,
0.5252094864845276,
0.10913405567407608,
0.13605566322803497,
0.15658895671367645,
-0.6470165252685547,
-0.27030375599861145,
0.14880022406578064,
-0.1503128707408905,
-0.05663888528943062,
0.028942914679646492,
-0.22336338460445404,
0.30869245529174805,
-0.6032232046127319,
0.06941118091344833,
-0.3055080473423004,
-0.04462343081831932,
0.6078077554702759,
0.0650101825594902,
0.5324629545211792,
0.4097440838813782,
0.09882377833127975,
0.5784633755683899,
-0.6050983667373657,
-0.14311060309410095,
-0.05893586575984955,
-0.24448411166667938,
0.0356445275247097,
-0.017474886029958725,
0.05257326364517212,
0.295243501663208,
0.33821097016334534,
-0.4002474546432495,
0.336988240480423,
-0.08079344034194946,
0.6538279056549072,
0.7350420951843262,
0.17763981223106384,
0.9115632176399231,
-0.19728299975395203,
0.5099700093269348,
-0.24661530554294586,
0.10989496856927872,
-0.2241649627685547,
-0.25947269797325134,
-0.4219147562980652,
-0.3030783534049988,
0.07304637134075165,
0.24954290688037872,
-0.504618227481842,
0.3724808394908905,
0.02820708602666855,
-0.8096683621406555,
-0.08029075711965561,
0.49553757905960083,
0.0700559914112091,
-0.30093297362327576,
0.03154124692082405,
-0.3356218934059143,
-0.27539780735969543,
-0.5366857051849365,
-0.4622887969017029,
-0.09191422164440155,
0.19021345674991608,
0.05967612564563751,
0.8296545147895813,
-0.6769339442253113,
0.8695528507232666,
-0.3906319737434387,
-0.35609620809555054,
-0.46394607424736023,
-0.23008452355861664,
-0.013187668286263943,
0.30708831548690796,
0.22152037918567657,
-0.6304142475128174,
-0.7010416984558105,
0.20167244970798492,
-0.7832247018814087,
-0.12471222132444382,
0.09154010564088821,
-0.25078681111335754,
0.27659478783607483,
0.8168743252754211,
-0.8074911236763,
-0.06996657699346542,
0.41350555419921875,
-0.349265456199646,
0.4858461618423462,
-0.21014900505542755,
-0.27289527654647827,
-0.7261945009231567,
-0.14502228796482086,
-0.02079250104725361,
-0.040043726563453674,
-0.9510571956634521,
0.053792111575603485,
-0.30227962136268616,
-0.12062260508537292,
-0.6612764596939087,
1.0040524005889893,
-0.9631174802780151,
-0.17760814726352692,
-0.8120281100273132,
0.01086166687309742,
-0.004969367291778326,
0.0007919283234514296,
0.03560987859964371,
0.5122053027153015,
0.6761253476142883,
-0.5631137490272522,
0.8125386238098145,
-0.17963725328445435,
-0.007723378948867321,
0.3027972877025604,
-0.4055997133255005,
0.18575434386730194,
0.13898144662380219,
0.6162869334220886,
-0.7662568688392639,
-0.5712993741035461,
0.23097848892211914,
-0.22669976949691772,
0.3238849937915802,
0.13398781418800354,
-0.5575530529022217,
-0.30296921730041504,
-0.14610710740089417,
0.30852195620536804,
0.29199641942977905,
-0.2022928148508072,
0.9829946160316467,
0.5607284307479858,
-0.08354513347148895,
-0.4191707968711853,
-0.34069114923477173,
0.23966571688652039,
-0.09096281230449677,
-0.3062663972377777,
0.02143932320177555,
-0.2727340757846832,
-0.7936412692070007,
0.12431292235851288,
-0.13962702453136444,
-0.08359133452177048,
0.07356443256139755,
0.12623001635074615,
0.14483827352523804,
0.1733391135931015,
0.3480708599090576,
-0.22123229503631592,
-0.22705255448818207,
0.33784785866737366,
-0.43587666749954224,
0.42900511622428894,
-0.1550564467906952,
-0.07508396357297897,
-0.11089704930782318,
0.453179270029068,
0.9973095655441284,
-0.21738097071647644,
0.6731418371200562,
0.2615654766559601,
-0.2669493854045868,
-0.37245914340019226,
-0.19536222517490387,
-0.347867488861084,
-0.49337053298950195,
0.40482768416404724,
-0.33635589480400085,
-0.49688732624053955,
0.5979353785514832,
-0.31399017572402954,
-0.2703728675842285,
0.23507152497768402,
1.0606220960617065,
0.21668532490730286,
0.6757095456123352,
0.5985868573188782,
0.10492466390132904,
0.41196537017822266,
-0.12266388535499573,
0.34091147780418396,
-0.6736103892326355,
-0.21614500880241394,
-0.2905176281929016,
0.013185743242502213,
-0.5325630307197571,
-0.46768975257873535,
0.5999540090560913,
-0.49332597851753235,
-0.45560935139656067,
0.03791201859712601,
-0.2824471592903137,
0.5797512531280518,
0.2540407180786133,
-0.4134669303894043,
0.41436004638671875,
-0.1096455380320549,
0.0515177845954895,
0.43146172165870667,
-0.4694209098815918,
-0.6736359000205994,
1.3893462419509888,
0.4007454812526703,
1.196099877357483,
0.17444448173046112,
0.43418556451797485,
0.273909330368042,
0.20836025476455688,
-0.8330245614051819,
0.6709984540939331,
0.3755623400211334,
-1.0874792337417603,
-0.4387483298778534,
-0.12723217904567719,
-0.9541839957237244,
0.27767056226730347,
-0.24023158848285675,
-0.47812017798423767,
0.008753820322453976,
-0.15945188701152802,
-0.13185793161392212,
0.28714606165885925,
-0.6220084428787231,
0.6338124871253967,
-0.5126833915710449,
-0.6874305605888367,
0.026382310315966606,
-0.8149587512016296,
0.1690225750207901,
-0.3327829837799072,
0.1656598150730133,
-0.2912542521953583,
-0.32628294825553894,
0.2503753900527954,
-0.44604116678237915,
0.6981757283210754,
0.14861968159675598,
-0.44139033555984497,
0.7407045960426331,
0.10842442512512207,
0.33794039487838745,
-0.2586649954319,
0.10985257476568222,
0.09445826709270477,
0.07637239247560501,
-0.5098917484283447,
-0.5179575085639954,
0.937885582447052,
-0.705906331539154,
-0.7223016023635864,
-0.7563270926475525,
-0.7472292184829712,
-0.0958365723490715,
0.3512207865715027,
-0.01708143576979637,
0.17324033379554749,
-0.31186553835868835,
-0.2279510200023651,
0.3577302098274231,
-0.14779245853424072,
0.39103269577026367,
0.7264134883880615,
-0.38494008779525757,
-0.25492703914642334,
0.9901812672615051,
0.29136642813682556,
0.586098313331604,
0.42314404249191284,
0.06488864868879318,
-0.3458963632583618,
-0.6805680990219116,
-0.02398901805281639,
0.38069310784339905,
-0.9137750864028931,
0.019302215427160263,
-0.4713802933692932,
-0.23992398381233215,
-0.8187932968139648,
-0.22576384246349335,
-0.6369385123252869,
-0.10036172717809677,
-0.11295903474092484,
-0.02240285463631153,
0.2627493441104889,
1.0525206327438354,
-0.07205095142126083,
0.23341518640518188,
-0.6694368124008179,
0.20708464086055756,
0.31689366698265076,
0.35923293232917786,
0.0216600950807333,
0.21472275257110596,
-0.4066110849380493,
-0.36475706100463867,
-0.3033151924610138,
-0.8556435108184814,
0.3997544050216675,
-0.10671989619731903,
0.6892334818840027,
0.12862156331539154,
-0.01013236865401268,
-0.180940181016922,
-0.4315605163574219,
0.7729087471961975,
-0.07199060916900635,
-0.7607691287994385,
0.21990667283535004,
-0.6158890724182129,
0.2638765871524811,
0.07446443289518356,
0.38923192024230957,
-0.5075985789299011,
-0.3907584846019745,
-0.16157454252243042,
-1.0187475681304932,
0.3184559941291809,
0.15877074003219604,
0.006247029639780521,
0.11889822781085968,
0.318956583738327,
0.17640168964862823,
0.24664373695850372,
-0.620011568069458,
-0.41860300302505493,
0.2626844048500061,
-0.23900438845157623,
-0.23632529377937317,
0.1631946861743927,
-0.20576238632202148,
-0.05067652091383934,
0.7325738072395325,
-0.23080675303936005,
0.1301790326833725,
0.10517426580190659,
-0.1595354676246643,
-0.30025023221969604,
0.4968114495277405,
0.36672672629356384,
0.7237802743911743,
-0.19268320500850677,
0.15508230030536652,
-0.06349160522222519,
-0.5249279737472534,
0.6450203657150269,
-0.1433325707912445,
0.34634584188461304,
-0.4237160384654999,
0.37262213230133057,
0.4247478246688843,
-0.37267276644706726,
-0.9424594044685364,
0.14134997129440308,
0.18950842320919037,
-0.07459818571805954,
-0.5697851777076721,
0.16830113530158997,
0.1104179322719574,
0.7512108087539673,
0.4283658266067505,
-0.1098378524184227,
0.14154085516929626,
-1.2294752597808838,
-0.22971221804618835,
0.6260419487953186,
-0.15895839035511017,
-0.3240980803966522,
0.542265772819519,
0.3535624146461487,
-0.2993423342704773,
0.10729432851076126,
-0.06739262491464615,
-0.2799889147281647,
0.6455084681510925,
0.42980635166168213,
0.902442455291748,
-0.2936100363731384,
-0.06633566319942474,
-0.07043066620826721,
0.08698677271604538,
0.007954159751534462,
-0.0702405571937561,
0.055844224989414215,
-0.676333487033844,
0.0629633441567421,
-0.28990525007247925,
-0.7584705948829651,
0.06569036841392517,
0.08059272915124893,
0.24271072447299957,
-0.48360511660575867,
-0.15862342715263367,
0.30075791478157043,
0.4980698227882385,
-0.3556956946849823,
-0.03984678536653519,
0.22405372560024261,
0.6154303550720215,
-0.8564976453781128,
0.7602107524871826,
1.013895034790039,
-0.34205493330955505,
-0.3173440098762512,
-0.18685519695281982,
0.4422796368598938,
-0.2354799062013626,
0.536155104637146,
-0.22375784814357758,
-0.2969230115413666,
-0.12112201750278473,
-0.5821054577827454,
-1.1730314493179321,
1.2310214042663574,
0.14932934939861298,
-0.33917370438575745,
-0.01622709073126316,
0.1999605894088745,
0.7738011479377747,
-0.8212558627128601,
0.27014750242233276,
0.9002604484558105,
0.5549418926239014,
0.03032282181084156,
-0.7309859395027161,
0.09387287497520447,
-0.15169121325016022,
-0.1355155110359192,
0.17637743055820465,
-0.773641049861908,
1.1720435619354248,
-0.23039908707141876,
0.019036129117012024,
0.49264445900917053,
0.5240118503570557,
0.35722851753234863,
0.5930009484291077,
-0.11135644465684891,
-0.01922755315899849,
0.4534466862678528,
-0.010379107668995857,
1.0794800519943237,
-0.16970638930797577,
0.13712312281131744,
0.7630206346511841,
-0.9201787710189819,
0.4768197238445282,
0.5317124724388123,
-0.3221310079097748,
0.5150817036628723,
0.4388665556907654,
-0.06317127496004105,
0.2836481034755707,
0.34091082215309143,
-0.5355358123779297,
-0.2890946865081787,
-0.15365983545780182,
-0.03209705278277397,
0.41038769483566284,
0.6027622818946838,
-0.29122278094291687,
-0.0800313726067543,
0.02308082953095436,
-0.21239213645458221,
0.10691145807504654,
-0.3514411151409149,
0.6917458176612854,
0.26155638694763184,
-0.6911618113517761,
0.06475267559289932,
-0.09065917134284973,
0.08529094606637955,
-0.6827887296676636,
-0.05518965423107147,
0.0013706103200092912,
0.48779353499412537,
-0.03422132879495621,
-0.7555068135261536,
-0.16597208380699158,
-0.287089467048645,
-0.11386871337890625,
-0.049153730273246765,
0.8967302441596985,
-0.42981472611427307,
-0.22717860341072083,
0.5174558162689209,
0.9304608702659607,
0.1675729900598526,
0.026530731469392776,
-0.4705790579319,
0.2219625562429428,
-0.4060690402984619,
-0.13514398038387299,
0.44648507237434387,
0.33319270610809326,
-0.43261343240737915,
0.7955985069274902,
0.5171669721603394,
0.11147255450487137,
-0.005740081425756216,
-0.16261978447437286,
0.830568253993988,
-1.0010250806808472,
-0.1047590896487236,
-0.7695742249488831,
0.16994735598564148,
0.3173955976963043,
0.13319824635982513,
0.7516509890556335,
0.388118714094162,
0.5335204005241394,
-0.22790345549583435,
0.902492880821228,
0.3293222188949585,
0.2973386347293854,
-0.36398351192474365,
0.705001175403595,
-0.46869122982025146,
0.23922096192836761,
-0.32365113496780396,
-1.0886223316192627,
-0.33739855885505676,
0.1508248895406723,
-0.13586848974227905,
0.3775685131549835,
0.9027230143547058,
0.7970155477523804,
0.33135318756103516,
-0.32693904638290405,
0.14504700899124146,
0.315917044878006,
0.8095985054969788,
0.5758243203163147,
1.1580708026885986,
-0.16019508242607117,
0.12969623506069183,
0.10264852643013,
0.08428862690925598,
-0.3035154342651367,
-0.618468165397644,
-0.9339354634284973,
-0.4513605237007141,
-0.1940397471189499,
-0.31857946515083313,
-0.13189738988876343,
1.2836869955062866,
0.5732610821723938,
-0.6312461495399475,
-0.7162152528762817,
-0.34445706009864807,
0.3679945468902588,
0.016984522342681885,
-0.14885549247264862,
0.12574750185012817,
-0.2348741590976715,
-1.101592779159546,
0.5545549988746643,
0.5182258486747742,
0.4020073413848877,
-0.7289385795593262,
-0.32661643624305725,
-0.20223303139209747,
0.3626009523868561,
0.6182972192764282,
0.5453162789344788,
-0.7253862023353577,
0.2112922966480255,
-0.001978093758225441,
-0.3267979919910431,
-0.07631916552782059,
0.9329720139503479,
-0.7543766498565674,
0.5468193888664246,
0.5142861604690552,
0.3756183683872223,
0.23839326202869415,
-0.3470187783241272,
0.782843828201294,
-0.2879045307636261,
0.035011176019907,
0.3139932155609131,
0.23911450803279877,
0.3418927490711212,
-0.2369346171617508,
0.4732358157634735,
0.2749146819114685,
-0.7592045068740845,
-0.9156396985054016,
0.43367326259613037,
-1.0752983093261719,
-0.7603648900985718,
1.1028800010681152,
0.3190067708492279,
-0.3896275758743286,
-0.21116334199905396,
-0.1242406815290451,
0.16303378343582153,
-0.5749714970588684,
0.41347867250442505,
0.8108217120170593,
-0.5452734231948853,
0.05643456056714058,
-0.6052413582801819,
0.4402232766151428,
0.07228435575962067,
-1.0626418590545654,
0.15270665287971497,
0.6202250719070435,
0.3183845281600952,
0.30285942554473877,
0.6678930521011353,
-0.02334863506257534,
0.12960664927959442,
0.1435471773147583,
0.08479760587215424,
0.09779772907495499,
-0.853705644607544,
-0.38010990619659424,
-0.0224770400673151,
0.3816404640674591,
0.39575955271720886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18510v1 | WildTeaming at Scale: From In-the-Wild Jailbreaks to (Adversarially) Safer Language Models | 2024-06-26T17:31:22 | 2024-06-26T17:31:22 | Liwei Jiang, Kavel Rao, Seungju Han, Allyson Ettinger, Faeze Brahman, Sachin Kumar, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Ximing Lu, Maarten Sap, Yejin Choi, Nouha Dziri | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce WildTeaming, an automatic LLM safety red-teaming framework that
mines in-the-wild user-chatbot interactions to discover 5.7K unique clusters of
novel jailbreak tactics, and then composes multiple tactics for systematic
exploration of novel jailbreaks. Compared to prior work that performed
red-teaming via recruited human workers, gradient-based optimization, or
iterative revision with LLMs, our work investigates jailbreaks from chatbot
users who were not specifically instructed to break the system. WildTeaming
reveals previously unidentified vulnerabilities of frontier LLMs, resulting in
up to 4.6x more diverse and successful adversarial attacks compared to
state-of-the-art jailbreak methods.
While many datasets exist for jailbreak evaluation, very few open-source
datasets exist for jailbreak training, as safety training data has been closed
even when model weights are open. With WildTeaming we create WildJailbreak, a
large-scale open-source synthetic safety dataset with 262K vanilla (direct
request) and adversarial (complex jailbreak) prompt-response pairs. To mitigate
exaggerated safety behaviors, WildJailbreak provides two contrastive types of
queries: 1) harmful queries (vanilla & adversarial) and 2) benign queries that
resemble harmful queries in form but contain no harm. As WildJailbreak
considerably upgrades the quality and scale of existing safety resources, it
uniquely enables us to examine the scaling effects of data and the interplay of
data properties and model capabilities during safety training. Through
extensive experiments, we identify the training properties that enable an ideal
balance of safety behaviors: appropriate safeguarding without over-refusal,
effective handling of vanilla and adversarial queries, and minimal, if any,
decrease in general capabilities. All components of WildJailbeak contribute to
achieving balanced safety behaviors of models. | [
-0.11049531400203705,
-1.0634996891021729,
0.10822068154811859,
0.3684904873371124,
0.06097637861967087,
0.5545061230659485,
-0.17712265253067017,
-0.5909724235534668,
0.30339381098747253,
0.7403681874275208,
-0.7481740713119507,
-0.4430028796195984,
-0.5510537624359131,
-0.1683162897825241,
-0.4187527596950531,
1.14472234249115,
0.08707091957330704,
-0.24546000361442566,
0.14010924100875854,
-0.2708645462989807,
-0.6007658243179321,
-0.5810571908950806,
-0.3811831772327423,
-0.05799642205238342,
0.45314866304397583,
0.5078350901603699,
0.9253265261650085,
0.7285727858543396,
0.5877955555915833,
0.31640005111694336,
-0.31337854266166687,
0.08577510714530945,
-0.8656858801841736,
0.2930419445037842,
0.026363730430603027,
-0.7028500437736511,
-0.39346787333488464,
0.34641730785369873,
0.1325250118970871,
0.46830809116363525,
-0.29240530729293823,
-0.14630702137947083,
-0.28637489676475525,
0.7054402232170105,
-0.8023880124092102,
-0.13104484975337982,
-0.932650625705719,
0.11855965852737427,
-0.22751912474632263,
0.055080756545066833,
-0.5056024789810181,
-0.3753749132156372,
0.03378719463944435,
-0.40559718012809753,
0.10177644342184067,
0.14609509706497192,
0.7125956416130066,
0.30615851283073425,
-0.559043288230896,
-0.06967906653881073,
-0.4498445689678192,
0.7584578990936279,
-0.48054882884025574,
-0.14512453973293304,
0.4896581768989563,
0.481344997882843,
-0.47376394271850586,
-0.5371281504631042,
-0.20432345569133759,
-0.3105199635028839,
0.0445132814347744,
-0.18940038979053497,
-0.27858448028564453,
0.196648508310318,
0.16220897436141968,
0.170150026679039,
-0.5426781177520752,
0.46039578318595886,
-0.552920937538147,
-0.15836726129055023,
0.9850207567214966,
0.3543594181537628,
0.5115416049957275,
0.24876661598682404,
-0.40131092071533203,
-0.2623368799686432,
-0.8754730224609375,
-0.019801920279860497,
0.35839027166366577,
0.4134736955165863,
-0.2298390120267868,
0.3282104432582855,
-0.07090692967176437,
0.6084470748901367,
-0.2389807105064392,
-0.015495569445192814,
0.12719063460826874,
-0.30762580037117004,
-0.30124393105506897,
-0.2048439383506775,
0.9492979049682617,
0.5896559953689575,
0.3777351975440979,
-0.6710902452468872,
0.006376064382493496,
0.019431807100772858,
0.4211829602718353,
-0.6440708041191101,
-0.4081740081310272,
0.1614098846912384,
-0.1754447966814041,
-0.9867426753044128,
-0.1280110627412796,
-0.6996519565582275,
-0.7875677347183228,
0.15079715847969055,
0.2694224417209625,
-0.3081044554710388,
-0.24760466814041138,
-0.023424765095114708,
-0.11286509037017822,
0.06447307020425797,
-0.008268370293080807,
-1.0540382862091064,
0.3731916546821594,
0.5628188848495483,
0.7994248867034912,
-0.19308315217494965,
-0.4446459412574768,
-0.4222538471221924,
0.0543782003223896,
-0.3040902614593506,
0.5049264430999756,
-0.23352856934070587,
-0.438252329826355,
-0.12617775797843933,
0.05677920952439308,
-0.1347440481185913,
-0.5527482628822327,
0.2578352093696594,
-0.5907403826713562,
-0.4484015703201294,
0.12955494225025177,
-0.2024831473827362,
-0.15946917235851288,
0.3786540925502777,
-0.7727169990539551,
0.6382761001586914,
-0.45719441771507263,
-0.599268913269043,
0.7042160630226135,
-0.69035404920578,
-0.5481322407722473,
-0.0871821865439415,
0.21614868938922882,
-0.6284373998641968,
-0.10274364054203033,
0.207786425948143,
0.427350252866745,
-0.08870454132556915,
0.2869623601436615,
-0.6167372465133667,
-0.135893777012825,
0.389452189207077,
-0.2506989538669586,
0.9591313600540161,
0.26280397176742554,
-0.21900446712970734,
0.2948899567127228,
-0.5704174637794495,
0.20949438214302063,
0.4518658518791199,
-0.12122998386621475,
-0.489323228597641,
0.06875600665807724,
0.057140469551086426,
0.02326352894306183,
0.132170170545578,
-0.5997225642204285,
0.22674676775932312,
-0.39970749616622925,
0.5978350043296814,
0.6080745458602905,
-0.0010541067458689213,
0.6131231784820557,
-0.2163374274969101,
0.4131146967411041,
-0.32077136635780334,
0.5639254450798035,
-0.0062318830750882626,
-0.29702451825141907,
-0.2856237292289734,
-0.44713160395622253,
0.07518255710601807,
0.6902784705162048,
-0.2065839320421219,
0.3674849271774292,
0.08151769638061523,
-0.7585835456848145,
-0.34328898787498474,
0.2003599852323532,
0.48467981815338135,
0.12106303125619888,
0.36898499727249146,
-0.0898749828338623,
-0.5746869444847107,
-0.7760723829269409,
-0.46576741337776184,
-0.14772631227970123,
0.1332629919052124,
0.31288817524909973,
0.4330052137374878,
-0.37230250239372253,
0.8474812507629395,
-0.5703655481338501,
-0.18943080306053162,
-0.48432260751724243,
0.12717078626155853,
0.10351107269525528,
0.5669330358505249,
0.606346070766449,
-0.8593742847442627,
-0.5492862462997437,
-0.370615154504776,
-0.9085695743560791,
0.09051163494586945,
-0.018873948603868484,
-0.1261572241783142,
0.11901590973138809,
0.5168896317481995,
-0.4592610001564026,
0.28396227955818176,
0.5559181571006775,
-0.4778067171573639,
0.3669922649860382,
-0.0796666145324707,
-0.032948434352874756,
-0.7284996509552002,
-0.0943371057510376,
-0.1057359129190445,
-0.005764514207839966,
-0.9577856659889221,
0.6509958505630493,
0.15412896871566772,
-0.0016478972975164652,
-0.7378393411636353,
0.25745469331741333,
-0.3288029432296753,
0.20831097662448883,
-0.11945169419050217,
0.1315673142671585,
-0.3139737844467163,
0.2657335698604584,
-0.3185093402862549,
0.6961708068847656,
0.6114765405654907,
-0.1321525275707245,
0.46514469385147095,
0.17706918716430664,
0.09134840965270996,
-0.07643616944551468,
-0.686642050743103,
0.3026826083660126,
0.149480402469635,
0.25393766164779663,
-0.9344996213912964,
-0.34388265013694763,
-0.15342922508716583,
-0.26267969608306885,
0.2816956341266632,
-0.4658568203449249,
-0.7500588893890381,
-0.31298720836639404,
-0.5059365630149841,
0.04582895338535309,
0.41948264837265015,
-0.533143162727356,
0.12063116580247879,
0.9002684354782104,
0.018956923857331276,
-0.6450560092926025,
-0.7946789860725403,
0.47316256165504456,
-0.510697066783905,
-0.9099667072296143,
0.03840259090065956,
0.02240450121462345,
-0.506471574306488,
-0.2832333445549011,
-0.27612853050231934,
-0.3213954269886017,
0.7158192992210388,
0.47665077447891235,
0.5953154563903809,
0.3087339699268341,
-0.38888588547706604,
0.01714937388896942,
-0.006936721038073301,
0.1768566370010376,
0.005813439376652241,
0.36785873770713806,
-0.37065577507019043,
0.08499272912740707,
0.011880123987793922,
0.20971737802028656,
0.5931921601295471,
-0.07627786695957184,
1.130826473236084,
0.11282370239496231,
-0.06214176490902901,
-0.33681243658065796,
-0.2967892587184906,
-0.3006007969379425,
-0.5098301768302917,
0.13961166143417358,
-0.09856785088777542,
-1.0824968814849854,
0.48098695278167725,
-0.15140791237354279,
0.48701345920562744,
-0.006362283136695623,
0.43441256880760193,
-0.1433359682559967,
1.0242985486984253,
0.9548981785774231,
-0.1832958459854126,
0.24925597012043,
-0.2600502371788025,
0.1588115394115448,
-0.22212599217891693,
-0.3430632948875427,
-0.3513003885746002,
-0.3963644504547119,
-0.8268086314201355,
-0.2148929238319397,
0.2820282578468323,
0.10601969808340073,
-0.2742016911506653,
0.5406860113143921,
-0.5806443095207214,
0.8646811246871948,
0.23335178196430206,
0.26955732703208923,
0.22006598114967346,
-0.24615061283111572,
-0.08374428749084473,
-0.09956275671720505,
-0.5520926117897034,
-0.30994898080825806,
1.3590412139892578,
0.3818083107471466,
1.084743618965149,
0.2791922092437744,
0.8465148210525513,
0.22670988738536835,
0.4725979268550873,
-0.7453398704528809,
0.6267284750938416,
-0.12872041761875153,
-0.8993756771087646,
-0.4041714370250702,
-0.3860569894313812,
-1.0139954090118408,
0.3608280420303345,
-0.37075528502464294,
-0.8574095368385315,
-0.4342031180858612,
0.13800625503063202,
-0.3435521721839905,
0.31583985686302185,
-0.7111052870750427,
0.8329356908798218,
-0.24932895600795746,
-0.4144635796546936,
-0.28021955490112305,
-1.1935005187988281,
0.7836607694625854,
-0.22047723829746246,
0.37003305554389954,
-0.14940811693668365,
0.12104371935129166,
0.7648749351501465,
-0.5280790328979492,
1.1413384675979614,
-0.19096948206424713,
0.15579959750175476,
0.1791752427816391,
0.3549596667289734,
0.7003892064094543,
0.08587420731782913,
0.23456525802612305,
0.0954047366976738,
-0.10112067312002182,
-0.3596467077732086,
-0.31759876012802124,
0.7712224125862122,
-0.7791149616241455,
-0.6716585755348206,
-0.3524947464466095,
-0.8083581328392029,
-0.3617689609527588,
0.13594095408916473,
-0.05977107584476471,
-0.17873018980026245,
-0.2679446041584015,
0.2672034204006195,
0.9111143946647644,
-0.2120496779680252,
0.44794660806655884,
0.7211301326751709,
-0.0736771747469902,
-0.24595211446285248,
0.5920514464378357,
-0.034546829760074615,
0.2968425154685974,
0.1491854041814804,
0.05530490726232529,
-0.08608865737915039,
-0.7480711340904236,
-0.2894802689552307,
0.007291419431567192,
-0.42769113183021545,
-0.2549966275691986,
-0.6945949792861938,
-0.23118998110294342,
-0.11951698362827301,
-0.5100030899047852,
-0.38056859374046326,
-0.4846963584423065,
0.2695189416408539,
-0.43324798345565796,
0.7211151123046875,
0.4621903896331787,
-0.3876435160636902,
0.39074546098709106,
-0.7509797811508179,
0.1282152235507965,
0.27846094965934753,
0.10498370230197906,
-0.3015848696231842,
-0.1488036811351776,
-0.20077532529830933,
-0.1615876704454422,
-0.291733056306839,
-0.7528303265571594,
0.6427124738693237,
-0.06022031232714653,
0.4948055148124695,
0.11299215257167816,
0.2986154556274414,
0.36961814761161804,
-0.5406662225723267,
0.6235761642456055,
0.25886109471321106,
-0.4977061450481415,
0.8272033333778381,
-0.5094127655029297,
-0.13513696193695068,
0.8094758987426758,
0.29313358664512634,
-0.2690669596195221,
-0.7813361287117004,
-0.5443607568740845,
-1.2020193338394165,
0.7461486458778381,
0.23964056372642517,
0.20747041702270508,
0.14226752519607544,
0.02232983149588108,
0.02037343941628933,
-0.046443939208984375,
-0.6751198172569275,
-0.2663881182670593,
0.00642639584839344,
0.06730985641479492,
0.029365306720137596,
0.05630706623196602,
-0.6591235995292664,
0.00020042674441356212,
0.21221639215946198,
0.019690819084644318,
-0.16715803742408752,
-0.5392693877220154,
-0.2652587890625,
-0.15973185002803802,
0.23588153719902039,
0.25765782594680786,
0.2864452600479126,
-0.4403174817562103,
0.0129765709862113,
0.32586783170700073,
-0.8123756647109985,
0.2447480708360672,
0.14693009853363037,
0.022486865520477295,
-0.45562270283699036,
0.33374062180519104,
0.4091467559337616,
0.1704554259777069,
-0.9638125896453857,
0.4823419451713562,
-0.31530943512916565,
-0.17156778275966644,
-0.06652873009443283,
0.6126415729522705,
-0.17296013236045837,
0.19558405876159668,
0.3247775435447693,
0.1887986958026886,
0.016947003081440926,
-0.5789305567741394,
0.36250874400138855,
0.45528462529182434,
-0.1905234009027481,
-0.1433292180299759,
0.9500917792320251,
0.29444125294685364,
-0.08958634734153748,
0.6437466740608215,
0.2860071361064911,
-0.33652931451797485,
0.9468019008636475,
0.3642495572566986,
0.9220916628837585,
-0.025366107001900673,
0.09487169235944748,
0.13603271543979645,
0.5737419128417969,
-0.06342265009880066,
0.06691174954175949,
-0.07918985933065414,
-0.6027409434318542,
-0.3478708267211914,
-0.4303874969482422,
-0.6545069813728333,
0.11635158956050873,
-0.684176504611969,
0.03419170156121254,
-0.7935662269592285,
-0.044869471341371536,
-0.04406518489122391,
0.043695833534002304,
-0.29109105467796326,
0.19031989574432373,
-0.04034885764122009,
1.085513949394226,
-0.9699771404266357,
0.8347243070602417,
0.7123368382453918,
-0.36820727586746216,
-0.6905359029769897,
0.08878415822982788,
0.5683662295341492,
-0.8218557834625244,
0.7332471609115601,
0.19168353080749512,
0.17329634726047516,
-0.2389996349811554,
-1.0713233947753906,
-0.6921314001083374,
1.0963003635406494,
0.008130422793328762,
-0.6049490571022034,
-0.04290328919887543,
-0.010999300517141819,
0.4114002287387848,
0.021315155550837517,
-0.08217377960681915,
0.9299583435058594,
0.24355082213878632,
0.18604077398777008,
-0.8775345683097839,
0.29900220036506653,
-0.05522027984261513,
-0.3733924925327301,
0.4234185516834259,
-0.7960941195487976,
0.5101145505905151,
-0.5537580251693726,
0.08507981151342392,
0.13854239881038666,
0.2759689390659332,
0.590651273727417,
0.16366496682167053,
0.5026102066040039,
0.6734222173690796,
0.5632361769676208,
-0.09062335640192032,
0.8728914856910706,
-0.2224363535642624,
0.16243575513362885,
0.9367321133613586,
-0.1284952163696289,
0.5455709099769592,
0.36343708634376526,
-0.1214645579457283,
-0.025716476142406464,
0.47864973545074463,
-0.08269204199314117,
0.9920807480812073,
0.3005587160587311,
-0.3510301113128662,
-0.15327619016170502,
0.2705202102661133,
0.03684914857149124,
0.3575681149959564,
0.450834721326828,
-0.12934736907482147,
-0.34230151772499084,
0.07540551573038101,
0.6035407185554504,
0.02885778248310089,
-0.1482415795326233,
0.8317556977272034,
0.09850701689720154,
-0.5175644755363464,
0.7723875641822815,
0.05807776376605034,
0.7372141480445862,
-0.6070652604103088,
0.32281509041786194,
-0.4201558232307434,
0.19874627888202667,
-0.24001780152320862,
-1.0397043228149414,
0.4480118155479431,
0.42324298620224,
0.0874534323811531,
-0.2887918949127197,
0.7047542333602905,
-0.022825751453638077,
0.09898185729980469,
0.4418208599090576,
0.197919562458992,
0.16615180671215057,
0.26385796070098877,
-0.6899747252464294,
0.12577110528945923,
-0.08945005387067795,
-0.2620115578174591,
0.7707346677780151,
0.33698770403862,
-0.18523471057415009,
0.8222413659095764,
0.7755097150802612,
0.004453939851373434,
0.17552965879440308,
-0.10078421235084534,
1.1475764513015747,
-0.6432267427444458,
-0.361674964427948,
-0.9283084869384766,
0.555565357208252,
-0.1408606767654419,
-0.05686555802822113,
0.8159387111663818,
0.2755737900733948,
0.4883211851119995,
0.19173887372016907,
0.8565466403961182,
-0.29893621802330017,
0.08728796988725662,
-0.3202185332775116,
1.1106184720993042,
-0.3557712137699127,
0.2827458083629608,
-0.275612473487854,
-0.37866196036338806,
-0.6340838074684143,
0.3189706802368164,
-0.3464057147502899,
-0.4557665288448334,
0.2907172441482544,
0.8861525058746338,
0.15872232615947723,
0.04558834806084633,
0.3657991588115692,
0.3560642898082733,
0.5586600303649902,
0.49583473801612854,
0.7266477942466736,
-0.21466130018234253,
0.8120366930961609,
-0.12266113609075546,
-0.682276725769043,
-0.1577201932668686,
-0.656987726688385,
-1.1556214094161987,
-0.03926603123545647,
-0.14261312782764435,
-0.3922314941883087,
0.4264512062072754,
0.7254536747932434,
0.7535003423690796,
-0.661366879940033,
-0.09251464158296585,
-0.3198671340942383,
-0.0052543506026268005,
-0.08452913910150528,
-0.2195732742547989,
-0.11718513816595078,
-0.5790289640426636,
-0.36664819717407227,
0.899196207523346,
0.24460287392139435,
-0.0362432561814785,
-0.155632883310318,
0.1210222914814949,
-0.09477489441633224,
0.1612689197063446,
0.49149391055107117,
0.5383785367012024,
-0.28479841351509094,
0.13733230531215668,
-0.03589177504181862,
-0.3102542459964752,
-0.2875687777996063,
0.4296574294567108,
-0.562113881111145,
0.34572291374206543,
0.30284422636032104,
0.5572938323020935,
0.6140735149383545,
-0.2856006622314453,
0.5932605266571045,
-0.7976827621459961,
0.4939468204975128,
0.25524571537971497,
0.07962550967931747,
0.029174238443374634,
-0.35014569759368896,
0.8046495318412781,
0.17551906406879425,
-0.649035632610321,
-1.0852420330047607,
0.1254889816045761,
-0.6426639556884766,
-0.4535577595233917,
1.0301008224487305,
-0.2868214547634125,
-0.23453505337238312,
-0.12020987272262573,
0.01417629886418581,
-0.022168252617120743,
-0.3860936462879181,
1.0227652788162231,
0.24593286216259003,
-0.10360118746757507,
-0.003536975011229515,
-0.7154012322425842,
0.5272207856178284,
0.19920714199543,
-0.7000694274902344,
0.25290510058403015,
0.3684658706188202,
0.40079379081726074,
-0.06673623621463776,
0.1502968966960907,
-0.2065853625535965,
0.2078648954629898,
0.11564278602600098,
-0.07558310776948929,
-0.165914848446846,
-0.4026254117488861,
-0.14893417060375214,
0.2998282313346863,
-0.05740955099463463,
-0.14135199785232544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18505v1 | Mental Modeling of Reinforcement Learning Agents by Language Models | 2024-06-26T17:14:45 | 2024-06-26T17:14:45 | Wenhao Lu, Xufeng Zhao, Josua Spisak, Jae Hee Lee, Stefan Wermter | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | Can emergent language models faithfully model the intelligence of
decision-making agents? Though modern language models exhibit already some
reasoning ability, and theoretically can potentially express any probable
distribution over tokens, it remains underexplored how the world knowledge
these pretrained models have memorized can be utilized to comprehend an agent's
behaviour in the physical world. This study empirically examines, for the first
time, how well large language models (LLMs) can build a mental model of agents,
termed agent mental modelling, by reasoning about an agent's behaviour and its
effect on states from agent interaction history. This research may unveil the
potential of leveraging LLMs for elucidating RL agent behaviour, addressing a
key challenge in eXplainable reinforcement learning (XRL). To this end, we
propose specific evaluation metrics and test them on selected RL task datasets
of varying complexity, reporting findings on agent mental model establishment.
Our results disclose that LLMs are not yet capable of fully mental modelling
agents through inference alone without further innovations. This work thus
provides new insights into the capabilities and limitations of modern LLMs. | [
-0.49876248836517334,
-0.8552190065383911,
0.9759466052055359,
-0.0640626847743988,
0.1423378735780716,
0.06683193892240524,
-0.40168967843055725,
-0.5524129271507263,
-0.07430727034807205,
0.4560501277446747,
-0.9121498465538025,
-0.21529370546340942,
-0.32408225536346436,
-0.03846835717558861,
-0.3114611804485321,
1.012160301208496,
0.07032812386751175,
0.009866742417216301,
-0.3563314974308014,
0.029548069462180138,
-0.22469817101955414,
-0.5837055444717407,
-0.7928644418716431,
-0.8955174684524536,
0.46296563744544983,
-0.09656298160552979,
0.7579854130744934,
0.34742969274520874,
0.18068724870681763,
0.35687047243118286,
-0.027808019891381264,
0.3622299134731293,
-0.38397377729415894,
0.11696437746286392,
-0.5210487246513367,
-0.8014537692070007,
-0.3753921687602997,
0.24984516203403473,
0.8020675182342529,
0.5228186845779419,
-0.2632082998752594,
-0.1721884310245514,
-0.14915692806243896,
0.5168976783752441,
-0.3798769414424896,
0.4344242513179779,
-0.6196078658103943,
0.19867858290672302,
0.24073940515518188,
-0.13417591154575348,
-0.6415562033653259,
-0.047914858907461166,
0.18816031515598297,
-0.4498639404773712,
-0.002197347581386566,
0.23132647573947906,
0.6699809432029724,
0.23737271130084991,
-0.247335284948349,
-0.2641282379627228,
-1.1366302967071533,
0.8427907824516296,
-0.676956832408905,
0.43223506212234497,
0.26244446635246277,
0.5376455187797546,
-0.3601554036140442,
-0.7113844752311707,
-0.561985433101654,
-0.733342707157135,
-0.012792779132723808,
-0.12323134392499924,
-0.0072574070654809475,
0.05010256916284561,
0.3775630295276642,
-0.04962531477212906,
-0.23082265257835388,
0.06271924823522568,
-0.05250629037618637,
0.033392615616321564,
0.661680281162262,
0.41003504395484924,
0.30784904956817627,
0.10760760307312012,
-0.4292658865451813,
-0.13972453773021698,
-0.5614311695098877,
0.19553783535957336,
0.09513476490974426,
0.3135110139846802,
-0.07956100255250931,
0.5820220708847046,
0.0009889127686619759,
0.32752788066864014,
-0.03361453860998154,
-0.10878049582242966,
-0.1831613928079605,
-0.07647831737995148,
-0.2407398670911789,
-0.1060592383146286,
0.5961199402809143,
0.12420843541622162,
0.684258222579956,
-0.20074652135372162,
-0.579411506652832,
0.1274864822626114,
0.5404289364814758,
-0.507523238658905,
-0.18748478591442108,
0.1442723572254181,
-0.22983554005622864,
-0.08376283943653107,
-0.05635800212621689,
-0.31700006127357483,
-0.44471442699432373,
-0.21260963380336761,
0.332705557346344,
-0.5519184470176697,
-0.49370184540748596,
0.09393525868654251,
-0.03958918899297714,
0.4841563403606415,
0.4032977521419525,
-0.6799326539039612,
0.4128850996494293,
0.7553059458732605,
0.46618956327438354,
-0.08195975422859192,
-0.6600511074066162,
0.001346683013252914,
-0.10286368429660797,
-0.536339521408081,
0.8810420036315918,
-0.42387518286705017,
-0.22754676640033722,
-0.014954756014049053,
0.010756962932646275,
-0.17769265174865723,
-0.41032660007476807,
0.08453912287950516,
-0.8022763729095459,
-0.12713415920734406,
-0.18708071112632751,
-0.6225132346153259,
-0.21631059050559998,
0.539370059967041,
-0.6053118705749512,
0.6282540559768677,
0.18190276622772217,
-0.5113239884376526,
0.41099703311920166,
-0.5231238007545471,
-0.2771357297897339,
-0.04493940249085426,
-0.3618312478065491,
-0.362364262342453,
0.17776669561862946,
0.027509383857250214,
0.3914681077003479,
-0.410287082195282,
0.40297991037368774,
-0.6057091355323792,
-0.16366548836231232,
0.9635164737701416,
-0.6087460517883301,
0.7072207927703857,
0.15314936637878418,
-0.16118307411670685,
0.2966036796569824,
-0.3245907723903656,
0.26931536197662354,
0.4654430150985718,
-0.01552270632237196,
-0.1333550363779068,
0.3972334563732147,
-0.3353293538093567,
0.526832103729248,
0.21342948079109192,
-0.2711297571659088,
0.1431252509355545,
-0.31598588824272156,
0.3947864770889282,
0.6928935050964355,
-0.06794708222150803,
0.2536747455596924,
-0.7058889865875244,
0.6842917799949646,
-0.22459819912910461,
0.11248571425676346,
0.07988693565130234,
-0.24947962164878845,
-0.6507919430732727,
-0.3933767080307007,
0.011548753827810287,
0.38538455963134766,
-0.6490110754966736,
0.04718390479683876,
-0.32331040501594543,
-0.4083132743835449,
-0.31161534786224365,
-0.05529097467660904,
0.4118308126926422,
0.01988339237868786,
-0.1229998841881752,
0.013858051970601082,
-0.4814394414424896,
-0.6415833830833435,
-0.2856016457080841,
-0.4196281135082245,
0.22389979660511017,
0.4571409821510315,
0.7442449927330017,
-0.12257803231477737,
1.1273165941238403,
-0.23333103954792023,
0.2445308268070221,
-0.7104255557060242,
-0.08021135628223419,
-0.10129710286855698,
0.0886782705783844,
0.4160732328891754,
-0.5316879749298096,
0.029121486470103264,
0.00016490610141772777,
-1.0536264181137085,
0.21434737741947174,
-0.14610636234283447,
0.04493023082613945,
0.07857111096382141,
0.5887142419815063,
-0.8896833062171936,
0.2440366894006729,
0.16086772084236145,
-0.3576221168041229,
0.9317668080329895,
-0.5214563608169556,
-0.16026361286640167,
-0.3800211250782013,
-0.1149277314543724,
0.013189580291509628,
-0.38717877864837646,
-0.6607100963592529,
0.21992257237434387,
-0.041420720517635345,
-0.005089423153549433,
-0.5840676426887512,
0.9036357402801514,
-0.38806766271591187,
-0.4410612881183624,
-0.4129169285297394,
0.24666419625282288,
-0.17933982610702515,
0.6692333817481995,
0.19525615870952606,
0.5943342447280884,
0.37886062264442444,
-0.6723806858062744,
0.2526412606239319,
-0.06648584455251694,
-0.44349002838134766,
0.41581061482429504,
-0.4905702471733093,
-0.043189886957407,
-0.2622978389263153,
0.30451563000679016,
-0.7423055768013,
-0.09356794506311417,
0.12864331901073456,
-0.31106412410736084,
0.20963148772716522,
0.06461938470602036,
-0.4091952443122864,
-0.3046188950538635,
0.020543059334158897,
0.17434243857860565,
0.5237922072410583,
-0.34789878129959106,
0.6513494849205017,
0.30748289823532104,
-0.14383910596370697,
-0.25277531147003174,
-0.3394230306148529,
-0.06742651015520096,
-0.27734798192977905,
-0.3777838945388794,
0.0687742680311203,
-0.1395198255777359,
-0.6810738444328308,
0.003716433420777321,
-0.0800538882613182,
-0.05269100144505501,
0.28719988465309143,
0.20079322159290314,
0.3357832133769989,
-0.15438809990882874,
0.22132237255573273,
-0.329298198223114,
-0.08299010992050171,
0.6506684422492981,
-0.32178038358688354,
0.4594425857067108,
-0.3481617867946625,
-0.4714241325855255,
-0.16085800528526306,
0.024127211421728134,
0.7559612393379211,
-0.43940430879592896,
0.9065520763397217,
0.21137268841266632,
-0.4581332504749298,
-0.7583385705947876,
-0.24735517799854279,
-0.26889801025390625,
-0.4211343228816986,
0.5952304005622864,
-0.49432137608528137,
-0.6005272269248962,
0.49157091975212097,
-0.21407179534435272,
0.08877617865800858,
0.29704105854034424,
0.6308689117431641,
-0.14735649526119232,
1.2367260456085205,
0.5702433586120605,
0.14540916681289673,
0.5242739319801331,
-0.3168148696422577,
0.07502139359712601,
-0.6970072388648987,
-0.451992392539978,
-0.1841057687997818,
0.0682118758559227,
-0.5580124855041504,
-0.3610665202140808,
0.034961849451065063,
-0.2450995147228241,
-0.4165003299713135,
-0.3921267092227936,
0.08466097712516785,
0.43887859582901,
0.2203708291053772,
0.2570141851902008,
0.1101292222738266,
-0.08552642911672592,
-0.25808611512184143,
0.3461777865886688,
-0.6499213576316833,
-0.6671531796455383,
0.9916432499885559,
0.48259270191192627,
0.8803930282592773,
-0.09778443723917007,
0.32929137349128723,
0.3790530264377594,
0.41220152378082275,
-0.8087794780731201,
0.7837934494018555,
0.2669385075569153,
-0.7519053220748901,
-0.5214137434959412,
-0.3212988078594208,
-0.9415227174758911,
0.3399423062801361,
-0.2986553907394409,
-0.6831949353218079,
-0.13133719563484192,
-0.010056336410343647,
-0.2748498320579529,
0.4161045253276825,
-0.3596865236759186,
0.6225608587265015,
-0.5406508445739746,
-0.21765299141407013,
-0.4955019950866699,
-0.40104562044143677,
0.5097125172615051,
-0.09214512258768082,
0.2915516495704651,
-0.2537170946598053,
0.03322792053222656,
0.664648175239563,
-0.4390820562839508,
0.7564004063606262,
-0.24040493369102478,
-0.3774747848510742,
0.45879098773002625,
-0.032305777072906494,
0.5931848287582397,
-0.17403557896614075,
-0.1093938946723938,
-0.18175235390663147,
-0.051377300173044205,
-0.41972360014915466,
-1.083150029182434,
0.5057191848754883,
-0.8820188641548157,
-0.6317839622497559,
-0.29888150095939636,
-0.7204146385192871,
-0.32012274861335754,
0.13598597049713135,
-0.2436082512140274,
0.23569688200950623,
-0.44234561920166016,
-0.17971323430538177,
0.8418512344360352,
-0.07653012871742249,
0.19530554115772247,
0.7352784872055054,
-0.6653112769126892,
-0.11458385735750198,
0.8590742945671082,
0.127075657248497,
0.3364185392856598,
0.18329071998596191,
0.06810411810874939,
-0.3749164938926697,
-0.5875257849693298,
-0.028478020802140236,
0.40145251154899597,
-0.7214870452880859,
0.39807140827178955,
-0.3294709324836731,
-0.43782854080200195,
0.042454883456230164,
0.016590123996138573,
-0.46096035838127136,
-0.17601525783538818,
0.10649089515209198,
-0.1646265685558319,
0.15343010425567627,
1.1610798835754395,
0.05247899517416954,
0.20966891944408417,
-0.23617804050445557,
0.24626392126083374,
0.39591342210769653,
0.34853145480155945,
0.3264712393283844,
-0.3584432601928711,
-0.5243690609931946,
0.18579569458961487,
-0.0013128268765285611,
-0.8725445866584778,
0.3647514283657074,
-0.08180597424507141,
0.8838038444519043,
0.4994121491909027,
0.07088816165924072,
0.24893441796302795,
-0.3551177978515625,
0.460120290517807,
-0.2510278820991516,
-0.5133518576622009,
0.46295833587646484,
-0.38394489884376526,
0.13372480869293213,
0.01287437230348587,
0.28966227173805237,
-0.2265455275774002,
-0.4140450954437256,
-0.7050012350082397,
-0.4984103739261627,
0.772474467754364,
-0.07570887356996536,
-0.23579999804496765,
-0.1162102073431015,
0.45373067259788513,
0.009590446017682552,
0.06793055683374405,
-0.7338340282440186,
-0.2952095568180084,
0.08717026561498642,
-0.00985113438218832,
-0.5091259479522705,
-0.13696344196796417,
0.0055396356619894505,
-0.11255858838558197,
0.7530907392501831,
0.06632767617702484,
0.4142680764198303,
0.04440353438258171,
-0.3625330626964569,
-0.022311218082904816,
0.3818005919456482,
0.6111594438552856,
0.5913721323013306,
-0.19913309812545776,
0.0480339340865612,
0.20878221094608307,
-0.0920381098985672,
0.47491347789764404,
0.018378740176558495,
0.02931538224220276,
-0.47632116079330444,
0.41932401061058044,
0.8946031332015991,
0.11453992128372192,
-1.0640698671340942,
0.17991667985916138,
-0.2506944537162781,
-0.2772335708141327,
-0.6127414703369141,
0.3500779867172241,
0.06109463796019554,
0.7143268585205078,
0.168476864695549,
-0.20784439146518707,
-0.4007394313812256,
-0.7261127829551697,
0.22148077189922333,
0.7059268951416016,
-0.44144874811172485,
-0.3716256022453308,
0.34729471802711487,
-0.1433614045381546,
-0.4909152686595917,
0.8810374736785889,
-0.4076128602027893,
-0.5199084281921387,
0.7030830979347229,
0.7548714876174927,
0.9266121983528137,
0.013532018288969994,
0.15384501218795776,
-0.15575101971626282,
0.5359318256378174,
-0.09616871178150177,
0.3461591899394989,
-0.03850196301937103,
-0.9865998029708862,
-0.43251821398735046,
-0.37951353192329407,
-0.5794491171836853,
0.16219481825828552,
-0.5936570763587952,
-0.19990216195583344,
-0.6627675294876099,
-0.30705273151397705,
-0.20610012114048004,
0.24758388102054596,
-0.8766019344329834,
0.35272836685180664,
0.381248414516449,
0.9095712304115295,
-0.937445878982544,
0.8891985416412354,
0.9970287680625916,
-0.28817304968833923,
-0.7643865942955017,
-0.18572014570236206,
-0.17584200203418732,
-0.8690192699432373,
0.5957689881324768,
0.0892409160733223,
-0.4052652418613434,
0.02870570495724678,
-0.5604759454727173,
-0.6250589489936829,
0.9754011631011963,
0.40598344802856445,
-0.21999065577983856,
-0.29086387157440186,
0.10935516655445099,
0.5590222477912903,
-0.5799580812454224,
0.5541163682937622,
0.8190720677375793,
0.5216937065124512,
-0.2208908349275589,
-0.5391075015068054,
0.12622475624084473,
-0.35264918208122253,
-0.10366839915513992,
0.24602214992046356,
-0.5170104503631592,
0.8282570242881775,
-0.5377839803695679,
-0.17775583267211914,
0.042205099016427994,
0.9045846462249756,
0.4968411326408386,
0.2880784869194031,
0.5191872119903564,
0.47757479548454285,
0.9073243737220764,
0.1175631657242775,
1.1911481618881226,
-0.2423395812511444,
0.20593033730983734,
1.0679184198379517,
-0.4526630938053131,
0.7663421630859375,
0.21801960468292236,
-0.3763522207736969,
0.6739314794540405,
0.462846040725708,
0.16165494918823242,
0.35953760147094727,
0.4119005799293518,
-0.32984980940818787,
-0.51945561170578,
-0.12697115540504456,
0.07414774596691132,
0.47154751420021057,
0.6801846623420715,
-0.22689536213874817,
-0.10149913281202316,
0.11508467048406601,
-0.1995771825313568,
-0.07136029750108719,
-0.48201340436935425,
0.6969695091247559,
0.08442587405443192,
-0.790442168712616,
0.369502991437912,
-0.08449817448854446,
0.2879444360733032,
-0.689595639705658,
0.14126160740852356,
-0.15850071609020233,
0.3558434247970581,
0.10342126339673996,
-0.7644960284233093,
0.08939939737319946,
-0.0442386269569397,
-0.2072642743587494,
-0.2104119509458542,
0.6365832090377808,
-0.14117294549942017,
-0.3083554208278656,
0.3613288402557373,
0.8767741322517395,
0.3952849507331848,
0.01845587231218815,
-0.6969276070594788,
-0.18935886025428772,
-0.15215030312538147,
-0.38531285524368286,
0.5952173471450806,
0.7234549522399902,
-0.26368945837020874,
1.3297427892684937,
0.4012870490550995,
0.18117843568325043,
-0.026109546422958374,
-0.08412805944681168,
0.5177402496337891,
-0.9688401818275452,
-0.46086743474006653,
-0.9938365817070007,
0.3586035370826721,
0.22467146813869476,
0.15515488386154175,
0.5565321445465088,
0.14263586699962616,
0.7048595547676086,
0.05036613345146179,
0.9512723088264465,
0.25196921825408936,
0.13786661624908447,
-0.5440952181816101,
0.7239410281181335,
-0.4374173879623413,
0.26946836709976196,
0.0026226143818348646,
-0.6223441362380981,
0.20580165088176727,
0.5486366152763367,
-0.45111900568008423,
0.4094200134277344,
0.7826608419418335,
0.7859712243080139,
0.17974936962127686,
0.0010352128883823752,
0.4476993978023529,
0.4491273760795593,
0.41173410415649414,
0.47332778573036194,
1.363242506980896,
0.19080473482608795,
0.3865118622779846,
-0.04795585945248604,
-0.04080083593726158,
-0.1317337304353714,
-0.6862243413925171,
-1.1119991540908813,
-0.31728672981262207,
-0.13540373742580414,
-0.1600806713104248,
0.3800424039363861,
1.0970464944839478,
0.5517615675926208,
-0.4141625165939331,
-0.3151349723339081,
-0.13971833884716034,
0.4665311574935913,
-0.4068616032600403,
-0.1965523213148117,
0.1732501983642578,
-0.3753938376903534,
-0.4102145731449127,
0.4875381290912628,
0.0727616548538208,
0.19896642863750458,
-0.7734155058860779,
-0.427746444940567,
-0.14504213631153107,
0.5438096523284912,
0.6835624575614929,
0.4593861699104309,
-0.916495144367218,
-0.11767321825027466,
-0.19105122983455658,
-0.06720465421676636,
-0.1166888028383255,
0.6661331653594971,
-0.971821665763855,
0.15928159654140472,
0.1162966713309288,
0.4147491753101349,
0.3863176703453064,
-0.31545624136924744,
0.7197961211204529,
-0.3856657147407532,
-0.1776956170797348,
0.04189532250165939,
0.4341379404067993,
0.12111806124448776,
0.02014230191707611,
0.27249738574028015,
-0.005617510061711073,
-0.5844071507453918,
-0.6687650084495544,
0.3833601176738739,
-0.5544546246528625,
-0.4383682906627655,
0.866603672504425,
-0.2555278241634369,
-0.3686283826828003,
-0.06811531633138657,
-0.1082119420170784,
0.35795140266418457,
-0.2486126869916916,
0.652087390422821,
0.6390141248703003,
-0.24710670113563538,
-0.4171362519264221,
-0.7004830837249756,
0.3166905343532562,
0.37535205483436584,
-0.8711268305778503,
0.3277513384819031,
0.3836613893508911,
0.252024382352829,
-0.25460880994796753,
0.6717915534973145,
0.25678399205207825,
0.2550777792930603,
0.1365170031785965,
0.05646468326449394,
-0.17067347466945648,
-0.6177107691764832,
-0.28998863697052,
0.05821603164076805,
0.6194107532501221,
0.2922459840774536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18501v1 | Is In-Context Learning a Type of Gradient-Based Learning? Evidence from the Inverse Frequency Effect in Structural Priming | 2024-06-26T17:06:41 | 2024-06-26T17:06:41 | Zhenghao Zhou, Robert Frank, R. Thomas McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown the emergent capability of in-context
learning (ICL). One line of research has explained ICL as functionally
performing gradient descent. In this paper, we introduce a new way of
diagnosing whether ICL is functionally equivalent to gradient-based learning.
Our approach is based on the inverse frequency effect (IFE) -- a phenomenon in
which an error-driven learner is expected to show larger updates when trained
on infrequent examples than frequent ones. The IFE has previously been studied
in psycholinguistics because humans show this effect in the context of
structural priming (the tendency for people to produce sentence structures they
have encountered recently); the IFE has been used as evidence that human
structural priming must involve error-driven learning mechanisms. In our
experiments, we simulated structural priming within ICL and found that LLMs
display the IFE, with the effect being stronger in larger models. We conclude
that ICL is indeed a type of gradient-based learning, supporting the hypothesis
that a gradient component is implicitly computed in the forward pass during
ICL. Our results suggest that both humans and LLMs make use of gradient-based,
error-driven processing mechanisms. | [
-0.2522047460079193,
-0.6124871969223022,
0.08667487651109695,
0.3884891867637634,
-0.12073041498661041,
0.04403429105877876,
-0.2840254306793213,
-0.2468903362751007,
-0.13402102887630463,
0.032757580280303955,
-0.4503885805606842,
-0.4338666498661041,
-0.29033929109573364,
0.02135169319808483,
-0.4959372878074646,
1.0358126163482666,
0.14448823034763336,
0.6717539429664612,
-0.23272345960140228,
-0.1636713147163391,
-0.5752347111701965,
-0.5160728096961975,
-0.7108345031738281,
-0.6065530776977539,
0.19516754150390625,
0.39181989431381226,
0.13238199055194855,
0.4580877125263214,
0.3712676167488098,
0.13091573119163513,
0.007640433497726917,
-0.5083608031272888,
-0.5967302322387695,
-0.18624480068683624,
-0.0800134688615799,
-0.6769475936889648,
-0.26415494084358215,
0.09946718066930771,
1.020950198173523,
1.1353880167007446,
-0.19281062483787537,
0.17036427557468414,
0.5915237069129944,
0.9353551864624023,
-0.6720330119132996,
0.09476932883262634,
-0.5566297173500061,
0.1692935824394226,
-0.05093556270003319,
-0.2890033423900604,
-0.3630022406578064,
0.03883969783782959,
0.11960776150226593,
-0.1671229749917984,
0.15131640434265137,
0.259691447019577,
0.5505596995353699,
0.2639239728450775,
-0.36463281512260437,
-0.29933273792266846,
-0.5160112977027893,
0.43912529945373535,
-0.43246617913246155,
0.8666220307350159,
0.31187957525253296,
0.08500460535287857,
-0.17933115363121033,
-0.7027539610862732,
-0.4089811444282532,
-0.7097856402397156,
-0.17532643675804138,
0.047109972685575485,
0.24169611930847168,
0.45232436060905457,
0.6444725394248962,
0.3887035548686981,
-0.38211706280708313,
0.017766889184713364,
-0.350850909948349,
0.06526724994182587,
0.07746456563472748,
-0.05658489465713501,
0.27656450867652893,
0.030197937041521072,
-0.7834142446517944,
-0.030675683170557022,
-1.000351905822754,
0.5678917765617371,
0.15110726654529572,
0.25372040271759033,
-0.2286357581615448,
0.36911213397979736,
-0.007384339347481728,
0.6695871949195862,
0.28534936904907227,
-0.3314107656478882,
0.22048617899417877,
-0.027761632576584816,
-0.3804548680782318,
0.3206905722618103,
0.03917742520570755,
0.08694790303707123,
0.434023380279541,
-0.3237503170967102,
-0.47340261936187744,
-0.18921402096748352,
-0.07160159200429916,
-0.6464526653289795,
-0.12952177226543427,
-0.17350398004055023,
-0.5708324909210205,
-0.06503015011548996,
0.35074272751808167,
-0.40664657950401306,
-0.2570030391216278,
-0.39595142006874084,
0.45628732442855835,
-0.3916856646537781,
0.04113541170954704,
0.13326065242290497,
-0.1555594503879547,
0.22761456668376923,
-0.21084429323673248,
-0.736946165561676,
0.6932018399238586,
0.4542093276977539,
0.8082988262176514,
-0.046006154268980026,
-0.36838945746421814,
-0.6349113583564758,
0.06604598462581635,
-0.20768429338932037,
0.463273286819458,
-0.38588523864746094,
-0.6272360682487488,
-0.029528886079788208,
-0.20338654518127441,
-0.1573481410741806,
-0.8144185543060303,
0.5489664077758789,
-0.6511543989181519,
-0.04748137295246124,
-0.36273279786109924,
-0.45659583806991577,
-0.2417742908000946,
0.060415688902139664,
-0.43965840339660645,
1.0525798797607422,
0.2902272045612335,
-0.6851844787597656,
0.6678004264831543,
-0.6884675621986389,
-0.4522908926010132,
0.08505001664161682,
-0.3130475580692291,
-0.3027176856994629,
0.0605173259973526,
-0.407560795545578,
0.19284625351428986,
-0.2082773894071579,
0.3661735951900482,
-0.3357619047164917,
-0.6661733388900757,
0.4524785578250885,
-0.32613858580589294,
0.9019953012466431,
-0.20513120293617249,
-0.7458614110946655,
-0.14744625985622406,
-0.9215932488441467,
-0.21167577803134918,
-0.2600916624069214,
-0.710850715637207,
-0.4788174331188202,
0.251259446144104,
-0.24120905995368958,
0.4425150156021118,
-0.07052013278007507,
-0.7273960113525391,
0.05129808187484741,
-0.5599649548530579,
0.2036009430885315,
0.7745280265808105,
0.060750655829906464,
0.6236583590507507,
-0.5547147989273071,
0.29893311858177185,
0.14271041750907898,
-0.13115300238132477,
-0.2728775143623352,
-0.15047293901443481,
-0.7026907801628113,
-0.5071547627449036,
0.1562841534614563,
0.5852081179618835,
-0.20465731620788574,
0.2866377830505371,
-0.25669464468955994,
0.11599104851484299,
0.03225976228713989,
0.0677742213010788,
0.562525749206543,
1.1182268857955933,
0.4512943923473358,
-0.21599815785884857,
-0.4156782031059265,
-0.9770390391349792,
-0.43433335423469543,
-0.2115156203508377,
-0.0981551930308342,
0.445854514837265,
0.3622712194919586,
0.11495823413133621,
1.0507198572158813,
-0.3660489618778229,
-0.46389731764793396,
0.15973195433616638,
0.1241879090666771,
-0.05107829347252846,
0.5129386186599731,
0.5738478899002075,
-0.8153573274612427,
-0.5135433077812195,
-0.3093487322330475,
-0.5508694052696228,
-0.11337831616401672,
0.0099989278241992,
0.19135445356369019,
0.13346858322620392,
0.9624565243721008,
-0.008789537474513054,
0.49125388264656067,
0.02847829833626747,
-0.11063006520271301,
0.2494676262140274,
-0.0598318837583065,
-0.14399948716163635,
-0.5097333788871765,
0.22381922602653503,
0.418771356344223,
-0.0035154304932802916,
-0.5595792531967163,
-0.20625407993793488,
0.32945021986961365,
-0.04077894613146782,
-0.2108442634344101,
0.5649186372756958,
-0.4626677930355072,
-0.3466821312904358,
-0.11836426705121994,
-0.16261278092861176,
-0.25526827573776245,
0.7338618636131287,
-0.030600691214203835,
0.7206407189369202,
0.804531455039978,
-0.6610587239265442,
-0.16917824745178223,
-0.24756096303462982,
-0.5993540287017822,
0.5497981905937195,
-0.36473584175109863,
-0.07719221711158752,
-0.6923539042472839,
0.4528394639492035,
-1.3518341779708862,
-0.08861931413412094,
0.3858921229839325,
-0.18096469342708588,
0.5639244318008423,
-0.18780338764190674,
-0.19697096943855286,
-0.19710171222686768,
-0.270192950963974,
0.556946337223053,
0.515863835811615,
-0.6214882135391235,
0.32670947909355164,
0.009767676703631878,
-0.0025044444482773542,
-0.9253028035163879,
-0.7365910410881042,
-0.2604191303253174,
-0.42097902297973633,
-0.5655073523521423,
0.4320146143436432,
-0.1349690854549408,
-0.6289451718330383,
-0.02213730849325657,
-0.15922316908836365,
-0.2834487855434418,
0.4603341221809387,
0.33572086691856384,
0.16674409806728363,
-0.4423770606517792,
0.5460015535354614,
-0.11936510354280472,
0.17097975313663483,
0.17749269306659698,
-0.4672622084617615,
0.4221087694168091,
-0.29874712228775024,
-0.37645813822746277,
-0.3036246597766876,
0.14335894584655762,
0.3688773810863495,
-0.22113020718097687,
0.5841370820999146,
0.027295228093862534,
-0.3835323452949524,
-0.633404552936554,
-0.2518063187599182,
-0.5798671245574951,
-0.4403344392776489,
0.43265828490257263,
-0.311372309923172,
-0.5811780095100403,
0.6437674164772034,
-0.23782901465892792,
-0.18688146770000458,
0.18180318176746368,
0.25365132093429565,
-0.5459260940551758,
0.8162194490432739,
0.724341630935669,
0.0705452635884285,
0.9675680994987488,
-0.43612125515937805,
-0.027871135622262955,
-0.9070372581481934,
-0.29260239005088806,
-0.42276453971862793,
-0.6261379718780518,
-0.14364005625247955,
0.1203092560172081,
0.7498325109481812,
0.42816296219825745,
-0.5543713569641113,
-0.3634435832500458,
0.059831857681274414,
0.5018021464347839,
0.19030554592609406,
0.1815686970949173,
0.3268296718597412,
0.15185880661010742,
-0.15356405079364777,
0.1475485861301422,
-0.7336081266403198,
-0.08513566106557846,
0.9650632739067078,
0.07983091473579407,
0.6871442794799805,
-0.20344066619873047,
0.24434830248355865,
0.36081182956695557,
1.0951975584030151,
-0.7921190857887268,
0.2874835133552551,
-0.06173525005578995,
-0.58261638879776,
-0.28931644558906555,
-0.1428636908531189,
-0.7962086796760559,
0.34645211696624756,
-0.18125246465206146,
-0.7118679881095886,
0.49381276965141296,
0.3716016411781311,
-0.1496652066707611,
0.34169840812683105,
-0.40169671177864075,
0.6555175185203552,
-0.20313751697540283,
-0.16285206377506256,
-0.294066846370697,
-0.8709782361984253,
0.5873041152954102,
-0.06851208209991455,
0.27106979489326477,
0.12572897970676422,
-0.04912358522415161,
0.4295647442340851,
-0.05435718223452568,
1.0271501541137695,
-0.544510543346405,
-0.10367415845394135,
0.1554032266139984,
0.1500849723815918,
0.4153790771961212,
0.12306378036737442,
-0.09013532102108002,
-0.0007498076884075999,
-0.6315960884094238,
-0.2471332550048828,
-0.8079890608787537,
0.6085126996040344,
-0.4945608377456665,
-0.6106421947479248,
-0.21351568400859833,
-0.3905159831047058,
-0.39349740743637085,
-0.0011084385914728045,
0.3799067437648773,
0.9989984631538391,
-0.2440977394580841,
0.2639993727207184,
0.6810740232467651,
0.22164015471935272,
0.5806892514228821,
0.7510665059089661,
-0.0051299817860126495,
-0.0833335593342781,
0.9292811751365662,
0.4573192596435547,
0.239090234041214,
0.5318127274513245,
0.1598452776670456,
-0.2005167305469513,
-0.7373177409172058,
-0.30060338973999023,
0.3806523084640503,
-0.7554880976676941,
-0.056893449276685715,
-0.3242608904838562,
-0.09904197603464127,
0.21304361522197723,
-0.3459274470806122,
0.08532513678073883,
-0.19172340631484985,
-0.2709518373012543,
-0.12192892283201218,
-0.2085321992635727,
0.4526144862174988,
-0.0768640786409378,
0.2912648618221283,
-0.47388312220573425,
0.0819784551858902,
0.27737873792648315,
0.6265320777893066,
0.3114268481731415,
-0.5829290747642517,
-0.479424387216568,
0.368388295173645,
-0.20462453365325928,
-0.6553952097892761,
0.09219595789909363,
0.6225166320800781,
0.6327906250953674,
0.4521641731262207,
-0.08987588435411453,
0.37374797463417053,
-0.46091488003730774,
0.5473499894142151,
-0.055706530809402466,
-1.0581382513046265,
0.0639696791768074,
-0.35170793533325195,
-0.15816561877727509,
0.5458436608314514,
0.5354019403457642,
-0.7300086617469788,
-0.131295844912529,
-0.5753158926963806,
-0.5081075429916382,
0.7166866064071655,
-0.33365410566329956,
0.01113615371286869,
-0.21654415130615234,
0.7605761289596558,
0.11491566896438599,
0.35690543055534363,
-1.0278103351593018,
-0.3658883571624756,
-0.19116970896720886,
-0.03662547096610069,
-0.14473046362400055,
-0.14361436665058136,
-0.08762742578983307,
-0.15855494141578674,
0.4616509974002838,
-0.34711694717407227,
0.02905704639852047,
0.4430704414844513,
-0.4441612660884857,
-0.4253675639629364,
0.03150138258934021,
0.7933306097984314,
0.7122030258178711,
-0.43513011932373047,
0.04731481522321701,
0.24615435302257538,
-0.15199120342731476,
0.3087359070777893,
-0.278313010931015,
-0.14871180057525635,
-0.37558797001838684,
0.4280456304550171,
0.7270461320877075,
0.5357980132102966,
-0.7467033267021179,
0.975786566734314,
0.18015934526920319,
-0.07929039746522903,
-0.41380345821380615,
-0.004034476820379496,
-0.37892818450927734,
0.09163010120391846,
0.6893976330757141,
0.4848040044307709,
0.2065306454896927,
-0.6389029622077942,
0.3351174294948578,
0.6286118626594543,
-0.7006909251213074,
-0.5857260227203369,
0.6316337585449219,
0.2604399025440216,
-0.4378492534160614,
0.8181535601615906,
0.03190968930721283,
-0.3256742060184479,
0.7702765464782715,
0.8738296627998352,
0.8990881443023682,
-0.0925474688410759,
-0.1332523226737976,
0.2546945810317993,
0.07480607181787491,
0.10815993696451187,
0.31733718514442444,
-0.41334277391433716,
-0.8745856285095215,
-0.5181062817573547,
-0.4602738916873932,
0.10182362049818039,
0.022874198853969574,
-0.7887251973152161,
0.3197212517261505,
-0.5547314286231995,
0.1528860479593277,
-0.12596450746059418,
-0.47562888264656067,
-0.31655171513557434,
0.21024209260940552,
0.14545270800590515,
1.0204600095748901,
-0.944273054599762,
1.0257108211517334,
0.8547565340995789,
-0.14205302298069,
-0.47059935331344604,
0.5858545303344727,
-0.0963975191116333,
-0.7349982857704163,
1.7249112129211426,
0.08719982951879501,
-0.4392343759536743,
0.3441723585128784,
-0.5373139977455139,
-0.9238308668136597,
0.9584675431251526,
0.4374648928642273,
-0.07445839047431946,
-0.06406241655349731,
-0.018074974417686462,
0.5738117098808289,
-0.5542653203010559,
-0.049191366881132126,
0.09827975183725357,
0.377870112657547,
-0.2898940145969391,
-0.7113420963287354,
-0.16087932884693146,
0.007042601238936186,
0.06672626733779907,
0.3060995042324066,
-0.7852500081062317,
1.0026055574417114,
-0.1596446931362152,
-0.6706340312957764,
-0.21170710027217865,
0.6715861558914185,
-0.13311658799648285,
0.2536545991897583,
0.777991771697998,
0.29397302865982056,
0.6985586285591125,
0.2478628158569336,
1.1876953840255737,
-0.6185588836669922,
0.24699750542640686,
0.8049216866493225,
-0.2879698872566223,
0.5313426852226257,
0.32167214155197144,
-0.0921340361237526,
0.6459164619445801,
0.4269232749938965,
0.34463632106781006,
0.5448357462882996,
0.5001611113548279,
-0.27995145320892334,
-0.02827889658510685,
-0.03856648504734039,
-0.266477108001709,
0.41993823647499084,
0.6523731350898743,
-0.39629843831062317,
-0.27179205417633057,
0.3665628135204315,
-0.2182212471961975,
0.040240105241537094,
-0.5791571736335754,
0.5759208798408508,
0.13761436939239502,
-0.6358906626701355,
0.7939726710319519,
0.06958330422639847,
0.5805357694625854,
-0.5635614395141602,
-0.16369454562664032,
-0.32122522592544556,
0.0425056591629982,
-0.13594070076942444,
-0.48773831129074097,
0.17638705670833588,
-0.4669710397720337,
-0.5237317085266113,
-0.2347061187028885,
0.6518162488937378,
-0.5784091949462891,
0.06906193494796753,
0.34721434116363525,
0.38244062662124634,
-0.22000707685947418,
0.17005740106105804,
-0.419761598110199,
-0.5271398425102234,
-0.12345883250236511,
-0.11512845009565353,
0.5791206359863281,
-0.01706276647746563,
-0.3169376850128174,
0.7491630911827087,
0.4553306996822357,
-0.08748161792755127,
0.2580948770046234,
-0.11201417446136475,
0.7799957394599915,
-0.3708657920360565,
-0.5973500609397888,
-0.8330599665641785,
0.46400871872901917,
0.17026624083518982,
-0.3576808571815491,
0.6681725382804871,
0.6239296793937683,
1.159535527229309,
-0.17173242568969727,
0.6417067646980286,
0.3067215383052826,
0.3500990867614746,
-0.640051007270813,
0.26893606781959534,
-0.6203886866569519,
0.3084831237792969,
-0.01620587706565857,
-0.9389820694923401,
-0.3638649880886078,
0.48077768087387085,
-0.3877933919429779,
0.01703549735248089,
0.9079173803329468,
0.7842444777488708,
-0.1800871342420578,
0.1370701789855957,
0.19677886366844177,
0.35028746724128723,
0.036259155720472336,
0.14910553395748138,
0.9657036066055298,
0.0755307599902153,
0.11008024215698242,
-0.2314295619726181,
-0.40599608421325684,
-0.23317639529705048,
-0.6275858879089355,
-0.813594400882721,
-0.8350048065185547,
-0.06219768524169922,
-0.25101950764656067,
0.029905084520578384,
1.0923789739608765,
0.5020854473114014,
-0.47906598448753357,
-0.5373393893241882,
-0.3931978940963745,
0.08277968317270279,
-0.36261677742004395,
-0.2572411000728607,
0.4364212453365326,
-0.45358970761299133,
-0.5470583438873291,
0.6268072128295898,
0.3746489882469177,
0.1046346053481102,
-0.18937616050243378,
0.058584798127412796,
-0.01811375468969345,
-0.050782181322574615,
0.45766618847846985,
0.6401368975639343,
-0.4494595527648926,
-0.28817319869995117,
-0.1903139352798462,
-0.14167051017284393,
0.5543478727340698,
1.3289952278137207,
-1.0057010650634766,
0.18504230678081512,
0.4831400215625763,
0.4973219633102417,
0.33639758825302124,
0.06583799421787262,
0.39463990926742554,
-1.0077866315841675,
0.3079454004764557,
0.16629189252853394,
0.4847511351108551,
0.020372632890939713,
-0.3858277499675751,
0.2012244164943695,
0.540236234664917,
-0.3685276508331299,
-0.8578684329986572,
0.3587632477283478,
-0.5977576375007629,
-0.3244490623474121,
1.0907851457595825,
0.029316943138837814,
-0.2772076725959778,
-0.22317276895046234,
-0.2709749639034271,
-0.03996245935559273,
-0.2986597418785095,
0.8300043940544128,
0.5173276662826538,
-0.30298981070518494,
0.3710936903953552,
-0.2438310831785202,
0.7810061573982239,
0.4704926013946533,
-0.35068026185035706,
-0.047345276921987534,
0.39483705163002014,
0.4290098547935486,
-0.1378183811903,
0.6114699840545654,
0.03419485688209534,
0.34169435501098633,
-0.18970946967601776,
0.023345433175563812,
-0.14674071967601776,
-0.46264904737472534,
-0.7090912461280823,
0.45805707573890686,
0.07286153733730316,
0.12908367812633514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18495v1 | WildGuard: Open One-Stop Moderation Tools for Safety Risks, Jailbreaks, and Refusals of LLMs | 2024-06-26T16:58:20 | 2024-06-26T16:58:20 | Seungju Han, Kavel Rao, Allyson Ettinger, Liwei Jiang, Bill Yuchen Lin, Nathan Lambert, Yejin Choi, Nouha Dziri | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce WildGuard -- an open, light-weight moderation tool for LLM
safety that achieves three goals: (1) identifying malicious intent in user
prompts, (2) detecting safety risks of model responses, and (3) determining
model refusal rate. Together, WildGuard serves the increasing needs for
automatic safety moderation and evaluation of LLM interactions, providing a
one-stop tool with enhanced accuracy and broad coverage across 13 risk
categories. While existing open moderation tools such as Llama-Guard2 score
reasonably well in classifying straightforward model interactions, they lag far
behind a prompted GPT-4, especially in identifying adversarial jailbreaks and
in evaluating models' refusals, a key measure for evaluating safety behaviors
in model responses.
To address these challenges, we construct WildGuardMix, a large-scale and
carefully balanced multi-task safety moderation dataset with 92K labeled
examples that cover vanilla (direct) prompts and adversarial jailbreaks, paired
with various refusal and compliance responses. WildGuardMix is a combination of
WildGuardTrain, the training data of WildGuard, and WildGuardTest, a
high-quality human-annotated moderation test set with 5K labeled items covering
broad risk scenarios. Through extensive evaluations on WildGuardTest and ten
existing public benchmarks, we show that WildGuard establishes state-of-the-art
performance in open-source safety moderation across all the three tasks
compared to ten strong existing open-source moderation models (e.g., up to
26.4% improvement on refusal detection). Importantly, WildGuard matches and
sometimes exceeds GPT-4 performance (e.g., up to 3.9% improvement on prompt
harmfulness identification). WildGuard serves as a highly effective safety
moderator in an LLM interface, reducing the success rate of jailbreak attacks
from 79.8% to 2.4%. | [
-0.4154041111469269,
-0.8975070118904114,
0.479651540517807,
0.1358826607465744,
-0.44501596689224243,
0.13098610937595367,
0.07152051478624344,
-0.37369951605796814,
0.04776269942522049,
0.6913376450538635,
-0.7283048033714294,
-0.6812840700149536,
-0.5521208643913269,
-0.032205305993556976,
-0.23977620899677277,
1.2514902353286743,
-0.16823086142539978,
-0.3172301650047302,
0.20611943304538727,
-0.0077249216847121716,
-0.6820157766342163,
-0.30542632937431335,
-0.5586361885070801,
0.04287296533584595,
0.8095187544822693,
0.20983317494392395,
0.6369279026985168,
0.5554476976394653,
0.4775797426700592,
0.25930875539779663,
-0.35093069076538086,
0.1766890585422516,
-0.6224560141563416,
0.4115394055843353,
-0.2321729063987732,
-0.1193903237581253,
-0.6881229281425476,
0.6386910080909729,
-0.042788878083229065,
0.13506187498569489,
-0.1733768880367279,
0.19019050896167755,
0.07164834439754486,
0.5706295967102051,
-0.9754499197006226,
-0.11206324398517609,
-0.5466752052307129,
0.16261866688728333,
-0.25997406244277954,
-0.1484585553407669,
-0.31222328543663025,
-0.3132283091545105,
0.08932337909936905,
-0.4896744191646576,
0.05640667304396629,
0.2706727385520935,
0.3683072328567505,
0.1466141641139984,
-0.757652997970581,
0.032026611268520355,
-0.45726415514945984,
0.6724461317062378,
-0.3767247498035431,
0.21874992549419403,
0.3742566406726837,
0.31128931045532227,
-0.2205660492181778,
-0.5549238920211792,
-0.283081591129303,
-0.18244555592536926,
0.1794854700565338,
0.08197429776191711,
-0.24289311468601227,
0.3489406108856201,
0.10823552310466766,
0.1610022336244583,
-0.5471661686897278,
0.348364919424057,
-0.5720608234405518,
-0.4523699879646301,
0.7330442667007446,
0.23981806635856628,
0.016579994931817055,
0.15637412667274475,
-0.7764430046081543,
-0.04854214936494827,
-1.0653395652770996,
0.19861860573291779,
0.5542601943016052,
0.14018630981445312,
-0.15856829285621643,
0.3137558400630951,
-0.08281655609607697,
0.6216940879821777,
-0.1412932425737381,
-0.03657678887248039,
-0.13424605131149292,
-0.3590500056743622,
-0.3985007405281067,
0.08740052580833435,
0.8333393931388855,
0.7233004570007324,
-0.13272398710250854,
-0.21998754143714905,
-0.2155037224292755,
-0.21296261250972748,
0.3723790943622589,
-0.9025474190711975,
-0.2775524854660034,
0.23788173496723175,
-0.6163347959518433,
-0.8239379525184631,
0.31543299555778503,
-0.7969699501991272,
-0.8090071678161621,
-0.053123123943805695,
0.4306129217147827,
0.14088545739650726,
-0.1218232661485672,
0.24097460508346558,
-0.27514174580574036,
0.01462931651622057,
0.5133798122406006,
-0.503545343875885,
0.3167068064212799,
0.6758546829223633,
1.0049376487731934,
-0.42477932572364807,
-0.14392037689685822,
-0.7806264758110046,
0.09972530603408813,
-0.19142039120197296,
0.4416726529598236,
-0.18692556023597717,
-0.4519006609916687,
-0.16567081212997437,
0.11202210932970047,
-0.14401431381702423,
-0.15586265921592712,
0.7149999141693115,
-0.8586313724517822,
-0.19792714715003967,
-0.21917462348937988,
-0.12475190311670303,
-0.39540034532546997,
0.48740026354789734,
-0.9508340358734131,
0.4951081871986389,
-0.38745278120040894,
-0.7048132419586182,
0.6028303503990173,
-0.6406961679458618,
-0.1733371764421463,
0.015427382662892342,
0.2414192408323288,
-0.3699679374694824,
-0.006981456186622381,
-0.041314542293548584,
0.4486664831638336,
-0.30498018860816956,
0.3797338902950287,
-0.6805073618888855,
-0.31714925169944763,
0.32214584946632385,
-0.7020937204360962,
0.7197743654251099,
0.4329955279827118,
-0.3106372654438019,
0.5576026439666748,
-0.26952096819877625,
0.010809896513819695,
-0.0006586785311810672,
-0.5077816247940063,
-0.40581196546554565,
0.1957613080739975,
0.33354485034942627,
0.34397000074386597,
0.056355755776166916,
-0.8064900636672974,
-0.10245532542467117,
-0.10587939620018005,
0.5492256879806519,
1.2462273836135864,
0.13762088119983673,
0.08200237900018692,
-0.532719612121582,
0.48311948776245117,
-0.14841210842132568,
0.7216284275054932,
-0.006863383110612631,
-0.4897192418575287,
-0.2670777142047882,
-0.45059800148010254,
0.05300012603402138,
0.6651431918144226,
-0.1365891993045807,
0.5008059740066528,
0.15598060190677643,
-0.5877393484115601,
-0.08833993226289749,
0.39770254492759705,
0.5639956593513489,
0.16978159546852112,
0.33771875500679016,
-0.6201152205467224,
-0.45682841539382935,
-0.5244458913803101,
-0.2827065885066986,
-0.24624702334403992,
0.1655605286359787,
0.04737309366464615,
0.4131889343261719,
-0.28590455651283264,
0.7472023367881775,
-0.4610913097858429,
-0.3489746153354645,
-0.1372876912355423,
-0.10033252835273743,
0.15349237620830536,
0.530925989151001,
0.727687418460846,
-0.7871708273887634,
-0.39244431257247925,
-0.27212250232696533,
-0.5276023149490356,
0.13525669276714325,
0.4027506411075592,
-0.19078531861305237,
-0.04904274642467499,
0.41458040475845337,
-0.44950002431869507,
0.3882160484790802,
0.5971258878707886,
-0.4334256052970886,
0.4759085178375244,
0.028178434818983078,
0.14808449149131775,
-0.7294907569885254,
0.2166406661272049,
-0.14495813846588135,
-0.08376479893922806,
-0.8998942971229553,
0.3214658796787262,
-0.008465577848255634,
0.04366122558712959,
-0.7701140642166138,
0.6253073215484619,
0.06757029891014099,
0.4843078553676605,
-0.0020649456419050694,
0.17992134392261505,
-0.09954572468996048,
0.022714776918292046,
-0.35906997323036194,
0.667487621307373,
0.4693697690963745,
-0.4922979772090912,
0.5941348671913147,
0.17729681730270386,
0.03182970732450485,
0.13302400708198547,
-0.738723635673523,
0.24882003664970398,
0.05417260527610779,
0.3456704020500183,
-0.9688082337379456,
-0.4060107469558716,
0.3529909551143646,
0.10574353486299515,
0.04692665487527847,
-0.5920626521110535,
-0.20016790926456451,
-0.4008547365665436,
-0.8594900369644165,
0.03897818550467491,
0.316874623298645,
-0.3899577856063843,
0.32503509521484375,
0.4336405396461487,
-0.14349298179149628,
-0.8027502298355103,
-0.4765578806400299,
0.09741383045911789,
-0.28363990783691406,
-0.5082656741142273,
0.08535569906234741,
-0.3354075849056244,
-0.2815210521221161,
-0.1350058764219284,
-0.684561550617218,
-0.12458639591932297,
0.6092140674591064,
0.7050017714500427,
0.6534247994422913,
0.2301003485918045,
-0.464297354221344,
0.06275048851966858,
-0.17545491456985474,
0.2623654901981354,
-0.21935011446475983,
0.15793472528457642,
-0.12394021451473236,
-0.48319774866104126,
-0.024022197350859642,
0.20859654247760773,
0.7640969753265381,
-0.287170946598053,
0.5692941546440125,
0.24324838817119598,
-0.022308597341179848,
-0.04234940558671951,
-0.48312339186668396,
-0.18501462042331696,
-0.5474423170089722,
-0.24779446423053741,
-0.04534030333161354,
-1.251508355140686,
0.4585994780063629,
0.04266946762800217,
0.643275797367096,
0.12011992931365967,
0.3659880757331848,
0.176111102104187,
1.0979293584823608,
0.592998743057251,
-0.28935274481773376,
0.3388342261314392,
0.060591764748096466,
0.24369484186172485,
-0.3994732201099396,
-0.34481170773506165,
-0.43734827637672424,
-0.24091926217079163,
-0.6684387922286987,
-0.1636018604040146,
0.5486878156661987,
0.051699183881282806,
-0.3425837755203247,
0.2758883535861969,
-0.40885549783706665,
0.43639490008354187,
0.3243219554424286,
0.5108607411384583,
0.41214004158973694,
-0.1232687383890152,
-0.2349049299955368,
0.13693179190158844,
-0.33864349126815796,
-0.641825795173645,
1.256496787071228,
0.48717600107192993,
1.2192182540893555,
0.4954896569252014,
0.6992076635360718,
0.43972766399383545,
0.5630913972854614,
-0.7335179448127747,
0.6957588791847229,
-0.14240853488445282,
-0.9390958547592163,
0.03447922691702843,
-0.27013131976127625,
-0.7588360905647278,
0.21613311767578125,
-0.28386881947517395,
-0.6207399368286133,
-0.12448851019144058,
0.3951917588710785,
-0.6589552760124207,
0.4021170139312744,
-0.36109670996665955,
0.8241900205612183,
-0.30551227927207947,
-0.6796671748161316,
-0.26356276869773865,
-0.6648610234260559,
0.7219653129577637,
-0.3089185059070587,
0.17868593335151672,
-0.4131750464439392,
-0.11362552642822266,
0.6351984143257141,
-0.4465892016887665,
0.9998431205749512,
-0.43343642354011536,
0.01487001869827509,
0.15768657624721527,
0.30033835768699646,
0.628692626953125,
0.3851778507232666,
-0.06379300355911255,
-0.05236712098121643,
0.1496865600347519,
-0.003044131677597761,
-0.10556237399578094,
0.8625592589378357,
-0.6129705905914307,
-0.8122695088386536,
-0.5677510499954224,
-0.3350260853767395,
-0.02632884308695793,
0.41539499163627625,
-0.04389738664031029,
-0.009131175465881824,
-0.35733330249786377,
0.2741813361644745,
1.0264346599578857,
-0.11156018823385239,
0.41140666604042053,
0.6499896049499512,
-0.23951523005962372,
-0.3660140633583069,
0.3020051121711731,
-0.07752621173858643,
0.20011574029922485,
-0.12360972166061401,
0.13878485560417175,
-0.12355877459049225,
-0.7163326144218445,
-0.5781649947166443,
-0.3655896484851837,
-0.6088414192199707,
-0.44764676690101624,
-0.6033388376235962,
-0.3111172914505005,
-0.12645642459392548,
-0.33540084958076477,
-0.03161231428384781,
-0.25653600692749023,
0.13398121297359467,
-0.48389437794685364,
0.6766740083694458,
0.5818409323692322,
-0.23974928259849548,
0.08665180206298828,
-0.8033379316329956,
0.18834081292152405,
0.540726363658905,
0.3657495081424713,
-0.41325926780700684,
-0.12278848141431808,
0.24591748416423798,
-0.2473798394203186,
-0.3606794774532318,
-0.785983681678772,
0.138383686542511,
-0.03585122525691986,
0.6959697008132935,
0.6526198387145996,
0.3909231722354889,
0.2685069739818573,
-0.3772304058074951,
0.7053317427635193,
0.23514781892299652,
-0.6269183158874512,
0.5497362017631531,
-0.4005572199821472,
-0.32232770323753357,
0.8078471422195435,
0.34847941994667053,
-0.4351973533630371,
-0.2905663251876831,
-0.1560172438621521,
-0.7860506176948547,
0.6996137499809265,
0.043396566063165665,
0.25827735662460327,
0.23770135641098022,
0.06343289464712143,
0.0477936714887619,
0.28189727663993835,
-0.5142017602920532,
-0.11553081125020981,
-0.2650333344936371,
0.2342655211687088,
-0.03161671757698059,
-0.28010666370391846,
-0.846325159072876,
0.18246419727802277,
0.5052170157432556,
-0.11593321710824966,
-0.00015867881302256137,
-0.2939646244049072,
0.10083354264497757,
-0.28087323904037476,
0.7336079478263855,
0.4529629051685333,
0.29172566533088684,
-0.5595882534980774,
0.4000028073787689,
0.24929498136043549,
-0.817139744758606,
0.36685100197792053,
0.5071118474006653,
-0.3613135516643524,
-0.3677917420864105,
0.13528162240982056,
0.4659275412559509,
0.10253895819187164,
-0.7573682069778442,
0.7489064335823059,
-0.19801662862300873,
-0.11820065230131149,
0.11074123531579971,
0.5928961634635925,
-0.5523549318313599,
-0.04477139562368393,
0.23698192834854126,
0.37620601058006287,
0.17275318503379822,
-0.40858352184295654,
0.22694551944732666,
0.5292245149612427,
-0.626247763633728,
-0.13224579393863678,
0.9669061303138733,
0.40905869007110596,
0.3643059730529785,
0.22036848962306976,
0.02194344811141491,
-0.4326118528842926,
0.5759072303771973,
0.2403814196586609,
1.1425803899765015,
-0.16833218932151794,
0.04800432175397873,
0.1717236340045929,
0.6515585780143738,
-0.14325878024101257,
0.3606400489807129,
-0.14814718067646027,
-0.5035970211029053,
-0.3319494128227234,
-0.6060842275619507,
-0.6430350542068481,
0.101279616355896,
-0.6613796949386597,
0.08053748309612274,
-0.940350353717804,
-0.23621343076229095,
-0.1404278576374054,
-0.05548850819468498,
-0.45062586665153503,
-0.14249151945114136,
-0.17984908819198608,
1.3250535726547241,
-1.0977733135223389,
0.5412395596504211,
0.8223846554756165,
-0.21546219289302826,
-0.7655431628227234,
-0.10161279141902924,
0.842157781124115,
-0.4061508774757385,
0.42515650391578674,
0.5141477584838867,
-0.23229937255382538,
-0.2557013928890228,
-0.8096428513526917,
-0.4955504834651947,
1.2605342864990234,
0.048151109367609024,
-0.5211989283561707,
0.02636563591659069,
-0.2518308162689209,
0.14290769398212433,
0.06383359432220459,
-0.06089050695300102,
0.48886311054229736,
0.7171794772148132,
-0.023538662120699883,
-0.9567153453826904,
0.4671713709831238,
-0.09533435851335526,
-0.13229303061962128,
0.25711628794670105,
-0.5751113295555115,
0.6739493608474731,
-0.05403773859143257,
0.05441661924123764,
0.15284237265586853,
-0.13236568868160248,
0.6806959509849548,
0.5837770104408264,
0.6414888501167297,
0.4689246118068695,
0.13994236290454865,
-0.21983686089515686,
0.6682281494140625,
-0.2814026176929474,
0.15722991526126862,
0.6395688056945801,
-0.35982757806777954,
0.4509665369987488,
0.34997183084487915,
0.05167759582400322,
0.05214017257094383,
0.6644914746284485,
0.042499665170907974,
0.8836202025413513,
-0.05805213004350662,
-0.8503681421279907,
-0.29439669847488403,
-0.08490701019763947,
-0.1331421434879303,
0.13938993215560913,
0.259517639875412,
-0.37314820289611816,
-0.49400854110717773,
0.2142951488494873,
0.510458767414093,
-0.2706488370895386,
-0.5183919668197632,
0.5826610922813416,
0.049521554261446,
-0.6218875050544739,
0.17441146075725555,
0.3632031977176666,
0.69659423828125,
-0.777498185634613,
0.09150514006614685,
-0.08280861377716064,
0.14407701790332794,
-0.2997167408466339,
-1.00348961353302,
0.24987119436264038,
0.3076797425746918,
-0.008191256783902645,
-0.6054924726486206,
0.9433974027633667,
0.11360418796539307,
0.3391275107860565,
0.3252880275249481,
0.32777729630470276,
-0.010782361030578613,
0.04361085593700409,
-0.7586250901222229,
0.32902786135673523,
-0.23726725578308105,
-0.5096079111099243,
0.3711535632610321,
-0.12701424956321716,
-0.259259968996048,
0.48431339859962463,
1.096697211265564,
-0.09181395918130875,
0.14245659112930298,
-0.2764655649662018,
1.275512933731079,
-0.28110286593437195,
-0.20654289424419403,
-0.8543521761894226,
0.47965124249458313,
0.021487591788172722,
-0.1993442177772522,
0.7615446448326111,
0.4167054295539856,
0.7436664700508118,
0.10909396409988403,
0.9565472602844238,
-0.600163459777832,
0.12715888023376465,
-0.5226326584815979,
0.8477503657341003,
-0.16086632013320923,
0.3455616235733032,
-0.16061924397945404,
-0.536368727684021,
-0.4216589331626892,
0.3569934070110321,
-0.27605870366096497,
-0.24252614378929138,
0.2112611085176468,
1.0649462938308716,
-0.11737307906150818,
0.08261121809482574,
0.26167014241218567,
-0.08031246066093445,
0.6052669882774353,
0.32687851786613464,
0.8566749095916748,
-0.10762443393468857,
0.652860701084137,
-0.15121078491210938,
-0.38153278827667236,
-0.31598496437072754,
-0.9767792820930481,
-1.1526472568511963,
-0.05844908952713013,
0.125308096408844,
-0.5091357827186584,
0.35336995124816895,
1.1228117942810059,
0.9380875825881958,
-0.862114429473877,
0.22048522531986237,
-0.08307471126317978,
0.13921964168548584,
-0.3491128087043762,
-0.1311310976743698,
-0.12465311586856842,
0.039233170449733734,
-0.26573294401168823,
0.8453046679496765,
0.5020310282707214,
-0.07545085996389389,
-0.31169942021369934,
-0.12401095032691956,
0.06276511400938034,
0.10150038450956345,
0.5857061147689819,
0.49062901735305786,
-0.5951183438301086,
-0.35070231556892395,
0.16260479390621185,
-0.3831990659236908,
-0.6475846171379089,
0.7034023404121399,
-0.34615597128868103,
0.5795676708221436,
0.5537029504776001,
0.45792368054389954,
0.33606281876564026,
-0.1902572512626648,
0.2499384582042694,
-0.6133672595024109,
0.1677844375371933,
-0.02744601108133793,
0.22838054597377777,
-0.3239618241786957,
-0.2538970112800598,
0.6419383883476257,
0.1539069414138794,
-0.6273749470710754,
-0.7634440064430237,
0.3944506049156189,
-0.8374291062355042,
-0.14676785469055176,
0.7652074098587036,
-0.5006989240646362,
0.12449545413255692,
-0.4672279953956604,
-0.39539486169815063,
-0.056359678506851196,
-0.43532752990722656,
0.6312877535820007,
0.33558592200279236,
-0.051993414759635925,
-0.11438708007335663,
-1.0627455711364746,
0.6103702783584595,
0.06267396360635757,
-0.7217991948127747,
0.17576667666435242,
0.813454806804657,
0.6161671876907349,
0.028970303013920784,
0.2946767508983612,
-0.25826793909072876,
0.486053466796875,
-0.4348384141921997,
-0.21381251513957977,
-0.5551071763038635,
-0.4525392949581146,
-0.3857876658439636,
0.3639499843120575,
0.11461132764816284,
-0.004782509058713913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01602v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01602v1 | Clustering in pure-attention hardmax transformers and its role in sentiment analysis | 2024-06-26T16:13:35 | 2024-06-26T16:13:35 | Albert Alcalde, Giovanni Fantuzzi, Enrique Zuazua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, math.DS, stat.ML, 68T07, 68T50 | Transformers are extremely successful machine learning models whose
mathematical properties remain poorly understood. Here, we rigorously
characterize the behavior of transformers with hardmax self-attention and
normalization sublayers as the number of layers tends to infinity. By viewing
such transformers as discrete-time dynamical systems describing the evolution
of points in a Euclidean space, and thanks to a geometric interpretation of the
self-attention mechanism based on hyperplane separation, we show that the
transformer inputs asymptotically converge to a clustered equilibrium
determined by special points called leaders. We then leverage this theoretical
understanding to solve sentiment analysis problems from language processing
using a fully interpretable transformer model, which effectively captures
`context' by clustering meaningless words around leader words carrying the most
meaning. Finally, we outline remaining challenges to bridge the gap between the
mathematical analysis of transformers and their real-life implementation. | [
-0.6285796761512756,
-0.7204988598823547,
0.5403933525085449,
0.5201939344406128,
0.06767913699150085,
0.049190860241651535,
-0.31712982058525085,
-0.0685490071773529,
0.0858190730214119,
0.3218039870262146,
-0.6929895877838135,
-0.2929472327232361,
-0.6804593205451965,
0.06478358060121536,
-0.6492403745651245,
1.212814450263977,
0.1917744129896164,
-0.5060239434242249,
-0.23383502662181854,
-0.2635974884033203,
-0.1830810159444809,
-0.567816436290741,
-0.1974799782037735,
-0.38389238715171814,
0.5285762548446655,
0.39036473631858826,
0.9495406150817871,
0.36664220690727234,
0.5706771016120911,
0.3828284740447998,
-0.17055630683898926,
-0.44899606704711914,
-0.6732832789421082,
0.2653142809867859,
-0.06973353773355484,
-0.35028865933418274,
-0.27308323979377747,
0.19827866554260254,
0.7137837409973145,
0.8640823364257812,
-0.25060153007507324,
0.20936886966228485,
0.3299696445465088,
0.5439412593841553,
-0.36457809805870056,
0.20050986111164093,
-0.49733543395996094,
0.4612548053264618,
0.058228999376297,
0.21410983800888062,
-0.23981505632400513,
-0.16414548456668854,
0.31375038623809814,
-0.23627300560474396,
0.4773149788379669,
-0.3941672146320343,
0.8000023365020752,
0.5189944505691528,
-0.3425612151622772,
0.01451447606086731,
-0.9664517045021057,
1.2445088624954224,
-0.2623741328716278,
0.10868025571107864,
-0.13401581346988678,
0.49306604266166687,
0.18181021511554718,
-0.5515768527984619,
-0.7137747406959534,
0.2987957298755646,
-0.2541658878326416,
0.5047150254249573,
-0.5310507416725159,
-0.02839047648012638,
0.22470830380916595,
0.4837585687637329,
-0.15825824439525604,
0.03903455659747124,
-0.546321451663971,
0.18997526168823242,
0.420087069272995,
0.1906111091375351,
-0.04471302032470703,
-0.4450092613697052,
-0.6067095398902893,
-0.019325844943523407,
-0.14800067245960236,
0.3047545552253723,
-0.1281014084815979,
0.07117710262537003,
-0.18045075237751007,
0.3278683125972748,
0.15976689755916595,
0.3606323003768921,
0.31806662678718567,
0.17032207548618317,
0.13675810396671295,
0.1943676918745041,
-0.40409567952156067,
-0.1443750411272049,
0.8410506248474121,
0.3461740016937256,
0.48109662532806396,
-0.21602179110050201,
0.014819890260696411,
0.26966211199760437,
0.6554363369941711,
-0.6311442852020264,
-0.0442994050681591,
0.27873411774635315,
-0.3900214433670044,
-0.5499444603919983,
0.16006873548030853,
-0.973572313785553,
-0.15371736884117126,
-0.3366670310497284,
0.14539116621017456,
0.1313832849264145,
-0.3806683123111725,
-0.04781539365649223,
0.14427264034748077,
0.39779773354530334,
-0.052766140550374985,
-0.6906164288520813,
0.4315215051174164,
0.6339142322540283,
0.6734670996665955,
-0.5965054631233215,
-0.3531770408153534,
-0.10208936780691147,
0.05963310971856117,
-0.30563101172447205,
1.0193758010864258,
-0.5021808743476868,
-0.46058425307273865,
0.02042042650282383,
0.17075715959072113,
-0.3383892774581909,
-0.7083499431610107,
0.6879085898399353,
-0.44394949078559875,
0.31423306465148926,
0.039565593004226685,
-0.284715861082077,
-0.09942581504583359,
0.35838380455970764,
-0.4612964689731598,
1.0861724615097046,
0.08100656419992447,
-0.35449230670928955,
0.11430591344833374,
-0.6846451759338379,
-0.5051878094673157,
0.07757360488176346,
-0.10510554909706116,
-0.5077763199806213,
0.5923646092414856,
0.008011850528419018,
0.7630282044410706,
-0.07805678993463516,
0.2004113346338272,
-0.14194832742214203,
-0.1467781811952591,
0.49610885977745056,
-0.17830003798007965,
0.34890350699424744,
0.23262448608875275,
-0.588106632232666,
0.41587188839912415,
-0.5504738092422485,
-0.03599223494529724,
0.1559218168258667,
0.03899182751774788,
0.049270302057266235,
0.14567670226097107,
-0.0028226065915077925,
0.46731826663017273,
0.07055316120386124,
-0.5109888911247253,
0.03326653316617012,
-0.22986631095409393,
0.6102414727210999,
0.910005509853363,
-0.19628234207630157,
0.6309850811958313,
0.17011582851409912,
0.5813199281692505,
0.37132659554481506,
0.48195719718933105,
0.04890574887394905,
-0.4182142913341522,
-0.9724379181861877,
-0.11963659524917603,
-0.015074809081852436,
0.4403091371059418,
-0.11019831150770187,
0.7301811575889587,
-0.3144960105419159,
-0.40186285972595215,
-0.4458792209625244,
0.023205431178212166,
-0.11108987778425217,
0.45251163840293884,
0.5214179158210754,
-0.15383653342723846,
-0.2827131748199463,
-1.167366623878479,
-0.20347778499126434,
0.3406047821044922,
-0.11698940396308899,
0.23014922440052032,
0.21536636352539062,
-0.6194431185722351,
1.1448885202407837,
-0.7768602967262268,
-0.6124311089515686,
-0.4444907605648041,
-0.014946743845939636,
0.6044777035713196,
0.23709158599376678,
0.16143527626991272,
-0.6590301990509033,
-0.6029249429702759,
-0.0583924762904644,
-0.9305177330970764,
0.15836820006370544,
-0.10668298602104187,
-0.15195943415164948,
-0.20091091096401215,
0.6126881837844849,
-0.8035874962806702,
0.27659329771995544,
0.5583524703979492,
0.08700577169656754,
0.30845141410827637,
0.22875934839248657,
-0.34605124592781067,
-0.7971632480621338,
0.044839177280664444,
0.36386623978614807,
-0.13755394518375397,
-0.9213089346885681,
-0.04388458654284477,
-0.2670399844646454,
-0.4003976881504059,
-0.2320173978805542,
0.10210194438695908,
-0.16755910217761993,
-0.08224008232355118,
-0.5434082746505737,
0.29565516114234924,
-0.25530681014060974,
0.7347231507301331,
-0.06675562262535095,
0.2427109330892563,
0.6302551627159119,
-0.4297456741333008,
0.3412092626094818,
0.1371261328458786,
-0.06216670945286751,
0.7852241396903992,
-0.7631904482841492,
-0.02290358953177929,
-0.26101505756378174,
0.16053734719753265,
-1.1987141370773315,
-0.030732668936252594,
0.04179319739341736,
-0.35426977276802063,
0.09597092121839523,
-0.12639547884464264,
-0.09582050889730453,
-0.6507341861724854,
-0.17786197364330292,
0.3866119682788849,
0.627621591091156,
-0.4255160987377167,
0.5541098713874817,
0.5745136141777039,
-0.07863392680883408,
-0.4090516269207001,
-0.4741811752319336,
-0.08149004727602005,
-0.2669810354709625,
-0.48449134826660156,
0.14689017832279205,
0.08687277883291245,
-0.30479696393013,
0.16403308510780334,
-0.21220628917217255,
-0.032175105065107346,
0.013489690609276295,
0.5135341286659241,
-0.01915884204208851,
-0.2106567621231079,
0.0034080606419593096,
0.13111966848373413,
-0.6190823912620544,
0.2562861740589142,
-0.3550528585910797,
0.5175155401229858,
-0.4535364806652069,
-0.022578665986657143,
-0.4530045986175537,
0.42638084292411804,
0.835257351398468,
-0.027331918478012085,
0.7114896178245544,
0.704640805721283,
-0.29250049591064453,
-0.40357521176338196,
-0.4897414445877075,
-0.15954309701919556,
-0.5573349595069885,
0.19525885581970215,
-0.39836645126342773,
-1.1154266595840454,
0.4821993112564087,
0.08477672189474106,
0.07373592257499695,
0.9825881123542786,
0.7286548018455505,
-0.36006930470466614,
1.244631290435791,
0.7625253796577454,
-0.26776620745658875,
0.16672652959823608,
-0.4118022918701172,
0.5408414602279663,
-0.7354725003242493,
-0.13072136044502258,
-0.2509234845638275,
-0.7326790690422058,
-0.6147910952568054,
-0.2558651268482208,
0.6535863876342773,
-0.01616538129746914,
-0.1752544492483139,
0.10501468926668167,
-0.8805239200592041,
0.6781049370765686,
0.28103625774383545,
-0.18788844347000122,
0.017693709582090378,
0.28851523995399475,
0.048857007175683975,
-0.28528979420661926,
-0.6330572962760925,
-0.27312037348747253,
0.3483952581882477,
0.4612288177013397,
0.6944363117218018,
-0.11149571090936661,
0.3092935085296631,
0.25959721207618713,
0.46840357780456543,
-1.1140121221542358,
0.44899824261665344,
-0.17196892201900482,
-0.5824936628341675,
-0.2984601557254791,
-0.30381301045417786,
-1.0176769495010376,
0.3764089047908783,
-0.008563325740396976,
-0.4076423943042755,
0.33416688442230225,
-0.12476406246423721,
-0.4625464379787445,
0.233021080493927,
-0.47226500511169434,
1.1070661544799805,
0.08306250721216202,
-0.04680119827389717,
-0.3837755620479584,
-0.7078323364257812,
0.20746469497680664,
0.1612847000360489,
0.2621113955974579,
-0.0727422684431076,
0.19182632863521576,
0.6704985499382019,
-0.12843099236488342,
0.8817793726921082,
-0.31844714283943176,
-0.14214850962162018,
0.42926907539367676,
0.08909589797258377,
0.11105722188949585,
-0.2587476670742035,
0.2010325938463211,
0.16630274057388306,
-0.20068545639514923,
-0.709635317325592,
-0.4853883981704712,
0.8601429462432861,
-0.9910109639167786,
-0.5820512175559998,
-0.3834887444972992,
-0.2749391496181488,
-0.16913163661956787,
0.08371895551681519,
0.19399328529834747,
0.19067536294460297,
0.008763258345425129,
0.29193565249443054,
0.5416078567504883,
-0.009401017799973488,
0.45477649569511414,
0.1376272588968277,
-0.09536624699831009,
-0.14613015949726105,
1.1023083925247192,
0.18610793352127075,
0.018575530499219894,
0.02745446003973484,
0.26638177037239075,
-0.17980746924877167,
-0.0915786400437355,
-0.39177218079566956,
0.34914278984069824,
-0.6070569753646851,
-0.0378408245742321,
-0.7192057967185974,
-0.37458837032318115,
-0.17228232324123383,
-0.2927587628364563,
-0.36564457416534424,
-0.5130042433738708,
-0.1261715292930603,
-0.3127557933330536,
-0.07316186279058456,
0.9790637493133545,
-0.008595036342740059,
0.6064140796661377,
-0.8121804594993591,
0.223521888256073,
0.6671285033226013,
0.5694306492805481,
0.29224857687950134,
-0.4119440019130707,
-0.3952423334121704,
-0.40887048840522766,
-0.5126749277114868,
-0.6953300833702087,
0.36867451667785645,
0.10866674780845642,
0.4743613302707672,
0.6506662964820862,
-0.21869975328445435,
0.4511657655239105,
-0.5342370867729187,
0.7261846661567688,
0.27150461077690125,
-1.0072344541549683,
0.17304258048534393,
-0.30017849802970886,
0.3232506215572357,
0.42222729325294495,
0.49175333976745605,
-0.7922489047050476,
-0.20942723751068115,
-0.6475113034248352,
-0.8094819188117981,
0.6537219882011414,
0.24399729073047638,
0.3240164518356323,
-0.055876225233078,
0.3790585696697235,
-0.008676555939018726,
0.14297695457935333,
-0.8656497001647949,
-0.3994884788990021,
-0.5467539429664612,
-0.43991732597351074,
-0.26165905594825745,
-0.4258852005004883,
-0.28595757484436035,
-0.27088987827301025,
0.2625757157802582,
-0.026494383811950684,
0.41467270255088806,
0.10703026503324509,
-0.23620790243148804,
-0.42551708221435547,
0.34731319546699524,
0.47695887088775635,
0.4487466514110565,
0.11754421144723892,
0.2516442835330963,
0.17863929271697998,
-0.26603665947914124,
0.26746442914009094,
-0.14996902644634247,
0.0140981525182724,
-0.17759613692760468,
0.003677109954878688,
0.5780205726623535,
0.08120600134134293,
-0.27253755927085876,
0.61894291639328,
-0.07282716035842896,
-0.1076197400689125,
-0.462526798248291,
-0.13006870448589325,
-0.07275041937828064,
0.22067523002624512,
0.7533624172210693,
0.23898977041244507,
0.06495662778615952,
-0.3618403673171997,
0.2079658955335617,
0.3853454887866974,
-1.1712355613708496,
-0.6956920027732849,
0.443326860666275,
0.21663667261600494,
-0.044287119060754776,
0.49296239018440247,
0.048541322350502014,
-0.9700665473937988,
0.6952282786369324,
0.4275948107242584,
0.933478832244873,
-0.3030989170074463,
0.23069126904010773,
0.0955728217959404,
0.27534303069114685,
0.1558505743741989,
-0.3275010883808136,
-0.19791841506958008,
-0.6925510764122009,
-0.6867713332176208,
-0.7350476384162903,
-0.3580176532268524,
-0.10065142065286636,
-0.7719956040382385,
-0.14256910979747772,
-0.5572940707206726,
-0.2731821835041046,
0.015455595217645168,
-0.4177279472351074,
-0.4392138719558716,
0.4566324055194855,
0.17267106473445892,
0.15716157853603363,
-0.9534883499145508,
0.4165360629558563,
0.5153818726539612,
0.12149346619844437,
-0.49463436007499695,
0.1660395711660385,
-0.26209399104118347,
-0.7611377239227295,
0.5995099544525146,
0.5087428092956543,
-0.23223792016506195,
0.20622895658016205,
-0.6847736835479736,
-0.7077234387397766,
0.5900078415870667,
-0.2189466804265976,
-0.3010762631893158,
0.17321236431598663,
0.3759840726852417,
0.8369209170341492,
-0.1457497626543045,
0.14842472970485687,
0.6421827673912048,
0.45502594113349915,
-0.061654601246118546,
-0.40328964591026306,
-0.07411376386880875,
-0.27860039472579956,
-0.28668898344039917,
0.37142837047576904,
-0.8227138519287109,
0.8075301051139832,
0.20226003229618073,
-0.3151131570339203,
-0.2579379975795746,
0.9134719371795654,
-0.27240434288978577,
0.007940464653074741,
0.7321062088012695,
0.7685924172401428,
0.20716577768325806,
-0.17447632551193237,
0.8722898960113525,
-0.3262880742549896,
0.7649639248847961,
0.3530783951282501,
-0.18244528770446777,
0.5286751389503479,
0.18557517230510712,
-0.3987186849117279,
0.7673678994178772,
0.08569642156362534,
-0.13355371356010437,
0.16446562111377716,
0.2465336173772812,
-0.16250377893447876,
-0.39476895332336426,
-0.10232425481081009,
-0.20272956788539886,
0.3184548020362854,
0.39779606461524963,
-0.14377403259277344,
-0.13189838826656342,
0.10877609997987747,
-0.1945343166589737,
0.016870180144906044,
-0.323689728975296,
0.8354158997535706,
0.31586137413978577,
-0.5246803164482117,
0.42194676399230957,
-0.15713635087013245,
0.6504184603691101,
-0.21159295737743378,
0.4041459858417511,
-0.28854018449783325,
0.4926135838031769,
-0.5017767548561096,
-0.9009721875190735,
0.47458067536354065,
0.04820187762379646,
-0.34965410828590393,
-0.2773713767528534,
0.4972543716430664,
-0.21178974211215973,
-0.6195120215415955,
0.458248108625412,
0.4132995903491974,
0.0063385204412043095,
-0.23891864717006683,
-0.6930467486381531,
-0.11262156814336777,
-0.0992860496044159,
-0.32348906993865967,
0.24860863387584686,
0.43074867129325867,
0.15792213380336761,
0.41826191544532776,
0.449748158454895,
-0.25938984751701355,
0.15724174678325653,
0.16006381809711456,
0.8246409296989441,
-0.9102473258972168,
-0.42743420600891113,
-1.0256388187408447,
0.4885892868041992,
-0.14288242161273956,
-0.08883720636367798,
0.795003354549408,
0.3527936637401581,
0.4590737819671631,
-0.1730845719575882,
0.6537995338439941,
0.11187046766281128,
0.6556052565574646,
0.16685400903224945,
0.6524544358253479,
-0.48870933055877686,
-0.15992994606494904,
-0.3417746126651764,
-1.277450680732727,
-0.597261369228363,
0.7536113858222961,
-0.4735841453075409,
-0.1928514689207077,
0.5672703385353088,
0.4122166931629181,
-0.30643752217292786,
-0.06909967213869095,
0.29046833515167236,
0.7131686210632324,
0.36332952976226807,
0.24059416353702545,
1.1017388105392456,
-0.2565225064754486,
0.7138490676879883,
-0.3710230588912964,
-0.2701416015625,
-0.09096274524927139,
-0.49365195631980896,
-0.7948113083839417,
-0.40159252285957336,
-0.019336262717843056,
-0.26785337924957275,
-0.447721004486084,
0.5262197256088257,
0.6836214065551758,
-0.9599620699882507,
-0.5221772789955139,
-0.035439297556877136,
0.23081667721271515,
-0.13820810616016388,
-0.4036373794078827,
0.43938592076301575,
-0.5540360808372498,
-0.599337100982666,
0.22053976356983185,
0.5753928422927856,
-0.2341604381799698,
-0.4667743444442749,
0.23654355108737946,
0.32950881123542786,
0.14477519690990448,
0.9399322867393494,
0.1612280011177063,
-0.3490471839904785,
-0.10505422949790955,
0.17724774777889252,
-0.1987626999616623,
0.4777543544769287,
0.8766769766807556,
-0.6834834218025208,
0.04130065441131592,
0.23317761719226837,
0.4451761245727539,
0.627289354801178,
0.31586524844169617,
0.30537164211273193,
-0.6358547806739807,
0.1941542625427246,
0.27315405011177063,
0.07291144877672195,
0.18368150293827057,
-0.09025651961565018,
0.2051859349012375,
0.47872498631477356,
-0.6801691651344299,
-0.6248000264167786,
0.3554784059524536,
-1.1623858213424683,
-0.1943090707063675,
0.7738401293754578,
0.15035437047481537,
-0.3682419955730438,
0.08711865544319153,
-0.1048065796494484,
0.029088715091347694,
-0.2619074583053589,
0.9384719729423523,
0.4722839593887329,
-0.1912047117948532,
-0.22836066782474518,
-0.2522222399711609,
0.3863010108470917,
0.8482279181480408,
-0.5869714617729187,
-0.019153457134962082,
0.2083672136068344,
-0.00004715162140200846,
0.5157385468482971,
0.1722075343132019,
-0.11714596301317215,
-0.02892485447227955,
-0.5479595065116882,
-0.11786729842424393,
0.5064969062805176,
-0.5225257873535156,
-0.5627447962760925,
0.763465166091919,
-0.18030749261379242,
0.08974775671958923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18460v1 | Role-Play Zero-Shot Prompting with Large Language Models for Open-Domain Human-Machine Conversation | 2024-06-26T16:10:53 | 2024-06-26T16:10:53 | Ahmed Njifenjou, Virgile Sucal, Bassam Jabaian, Fabrice Lefèvre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Recently, various methods have been proposed to create open-domain
conversational agents with Large Language Models (LLMs). These models are able
to answer user queries, but in a one-way Q&A format rather than a true
conversation. Fine-tuning on particular datasets is the usual way to modify
their style to increase conversational ability, but this is expensive and
usually only available in a few languages. In this study, we explore role-play
zero-shot prompting as an efficient and cost-effective solution for open-domain
conversation, using capable multilingual LLMs (Beeching et al., 2023) trained
to obey instructions. We design a prompting system that, when combined with an
instruction-following model - here Vicuna (Chiang et al., 2023) - produces
conversational agents that match and even surpass fine-tuned models in human
evaluation in French in two different tasks. | [
-0.2481497973203659,
-1.0360431671142578,
0.65799880027771,
0.3048062026500702,
-0.10121668875217438,
-0.21050173044204712,
-0.3570237159729004,
-0.43175455927848816,
0.16875742375850677,
0.8140333890914917,
-0.9434970617294312,
-0.47302770614624023,
-0.19440169632434845,
0.08537653833627701,
0.13053260743618011,
0.6646416187286377,
0.005000278353691101,
0.17528118193149567,
-0.2444373071193695,
-0.13875260949134827,
-0.9233048558235168,
-0.43492674827575684,
-0.9663106203079224,
-0.4222431182861328,
0.7086986303329468,
0.8843035101890564,
0.607291579246521,
0.34131279587745667,
-0.12276040017604828,
0.21899552643299103,
0.3396584987640381,
0.2406376153230667,
-0.48382920026779175,
0.5093053579330444,
-0.06639151275157928,
-0.5208841562271118,
-0.6490049958229065,
-0.025337500497698784,
0.2988777458667755,
0.5154666304588318,
0.10131078213453293,
0.04843127354979515,
-0.05273861065506935,
0.2627767026424408,
-0.501679003238678,
0.4643426537513733,
-0.5858610272407532,
0.05979538708925247,
0.2612013518810272,
-0.5537369251251221,
-0.651387631893158,
-0.014133702032268047,
-0.06168818473815918,
-0.6432705521583557,
0.01765328459441662,
-0.287259966135025,
0.5192316174507141,
0.08625208586454391,
-0.13974085450172424,
-0.17836697399616241,
-0.8015581965446472,
0.7076306343078613,
-0.5700286626815796,
0.2130318284034729,
0.6058188676834106,
0.3288896679878235,
-0.08453966677188873,
-0.021194588392972946,
-0.48447781801223755,
-0.5375093221664429,
0.20008347928524017,
0.22994652390480042,
-0.15742863714694977,
-0.07416695356369019,
0.26230016350746155,
-0.2979331910610199,
-0.6313850283622742,
0.44691041111946106,
-0.24056477844715118,
0.06396946310997009,
0.48800697922706604,
0.07051695138216019,
0.19960495829582214,
0.19342397153377533,
-0.37996867299079895,
-0.06018349155783653,
-0.9578458666801453,
0.03751102462410927,
0.33989521861076355,
0.6979694366455078,
-0.16502128541469574,
0.6769068837165833,
-0.4191456139087677,
0.8511472344398499,
0.05454765632748604,
0.21640488505363464,
-0.37705713510513306,
-0.023115577176213264,
-0.29493579268455505,
0.041466932743787766,
0.6432027220726013,
0.4678806960582733,
0.734730064868927,
-0.12537510693073273,
-0.03476573899388313,
-0.07246677577495575,
0.28224241733551025,
-1.0620590448379517,
-0.07208986580371857,
0.3761054575443268,
0.01860860362648964,
-0.28435197472572327,
-0.18947833776474,
-0.5911461710929871,
-0.39958304166793823,
-0.2032158076763153,
0.9067389369010925,
-0.34308671951293945,
0.022167863324284554,
0.3250294327735901,
0.1565350443124771,
0.3818073570728302,
0.610648512840271,
-0.8840362429618835,
0.04207698255777359,
0.3759983777999878,
0.7478118538856506,
0.16189298033714294,
-0.3944776952266693,
-0.9100707769393921,
0.11113982647657394,
-0.5319269895553589,
0.7344944477081299,
-0.5358037352561951,
-0.6443624496459961,
0.2596156895160675,
0.0404420830309391,
-0.12573476135730743,
-0.5216734409332275,
0.22087331116199493,
-0.5971632599830627,
0.39357662200927734,
-0.24468915164470673,
-0.2869461178779602,
0.05790117383003235,
0.5055068731307983,
-0.3573518991470337,
0.760438084602356,
0.026761356741189957,
-0.15303634107112885,
0.3270556926727295,
-0.9723207950592041,
-0.3596782386302948,
0.38744083046913147,
-0.1511412113904953,
-0.12664195895195007,
-0.18473371863365173,
0.569138765335083,
0.6535989046096802,
-0.22199401259422302,
-0.048645202070474625,
-0.31821945309638977,
-0.4997992515563965,
0.2575979232788086,
-0.617065966129303,
0.6994898319244385,
-0.04726436734199524,
-0.24986112117767334,
0.2744925916194916,
-0.46849170327186584,
0.15864822268486023,
0.4003092348575592,
-0.11773081868886948,
-0.10335957258939743,
-0.2752803862094879,
-0.2622548043727875,
0.24511569738388062,
0.11588207632303238,
-0.5090071558952332,
0.43779104948043823,
-0.2433873414993286,
0.3188196122646332,
0.6294280290603638,
0.1730823814868927,
0.4806414842605591,
-0.4222090244293213,
0.81046062707901,
-0.03997548297047615,
0.280750036239624,
-0.7587825059890747,
-0.5543371438980103,
-0.714732825756073,
-0.3980781137943268,
0.044255536049604416,
0.6616549491882324,
-0.880204439163208,
0.28978100419044495,
0.07028724998235703,
-0.27110835909843445,
-0.4916799068450928,
-0.012414009310305119,
0.3445085287094116,
0.5717336535453796,
0.34100764989852905,
-0.24586090445518494,
-0.19109363853931427,
-0.5302035212516785,
-0.05438465625047684,
-0.27183622121810913,
-0.1830253005027771,
0.6398367285728455,
0.2631205916404724,
0.17124465107917786,
0.8143673539161682,
-0.5355812311172485,
-0.318666011095047,
-0.13186384737491608,
0.06722774356603622,
-0.03902009502053261,
0.3098399341106415,
0.5269301533699036,
-0.4198618233203888,
-0.7512454986572266,
-0.07146565616130829,
-0.6698784232139587,
-0.15060734748840332,
-0.18458954989910126,
-0.18672536313533783,
0.443368524312973,
0.5921763777732849,
-0.6988294124603271,
0.3555452227592468,
0.42106756567955017,
-0.19860468804836273,
0.5748053789138794,
-0.40556666254997253,
0.38236624002456665,
-0.9668927788734436,
0.1663273423910141,
-0.09132978320121765,
-0.3405802249908447,
-0.8786873817443848,
0.025025254115462303,
0.013273118063807487,
-0.49667423963546753,
-0.7020705342292786,
0.8896089196205139,
-0.5018705725669861,
0.20029141008853912,
-0.3396744430065155,
0.2687568962574005,
0.07774502784013748,
0.7764120697975159,
0.28987133502960205,
0.9874147176742554,
0.8411960601806641,
-0.7854225039482117,
0.17811164259910583,
0.35477414727211,
-0.005874744616448879,
0.8097390532493591,
-0.8323649168014526,
0.22030000388622284,
-0.11382493376731873,
0.30285704135894775,
-0.8986092805862427,
-0.380377858877182,
0.4649849534034729,
-0.426715612411499,
0.30797094106674194,
-0.36217862367630005,
-0.2900667190551758,
-0.2760952115058899,
-0.218441441655159,
0.27416056394577026,
0.40033286809921265,
-0.557295560836792,
0.06341943144798279,
0.04895181953907013,
-0.30574965476989746,
-0.5279490351676941,
-0.48127081990242004,
0.21581925451755524,
-0.057235103100538254,
-0.5740748643875122,
0.19628094136714935,
-0.4149829149246216,
0.06789620965719223,
-0.24015659093856812,
0.09135738760232925,
-0.2281588315963745,
-0.0682460367679596,
0.12567751109600067,
0.43521231412887573,
-0.2961522936820984,
0.0675509124994278,
-0.11043906211853027,
0.06975105404853821,
-0.21977706253528595,
-0.4506474435329437,
0.756193220615387,
0.10706564784049988,
-0.5903051495552063,
-0.6696829795837402,
0.5230610966682434,
0.5468022227287292,
-0.26070937514305115,
0.6868224740028381,
0.27416399121284485,
-0.24321573972702026,
-0.27475619316101074,
-0.2599225640296936,
-0.509792685508728,
-0.4540616273880005,
0.06682221591472626,
-0.3268543481826782,
-1.1465628147125244,
0.3685903549194336,
0.0489734448492527,
0.21148943901062012,
0.023499317467212677,
0.6159735321998596,
-0.08995231986045837,
1.1334220170974731,
0.4703633785247803,
0.282781183719635,
0.5421251058578491,
-0.06700310111045837,
0.11986184865236282,
-0.19256049394607544,
-0.08540140092372894,
-0.6424689888954163,
-0.05006176978349686,
-0.29097825288772583,
-0.668530285358429,
0.394369512796402,
0.13190609216690063,
-0.2742326855659485,
0.5614389181137085,
-0.24678581953048706,
0.6649177670478821,
0.6314425468444824,
0.09501328319311142,
0.15524648129940033,
-0.0010141049278900027,
-0.013179769739508629,
0.19898635149002075,
-0.8149762153625488,
-0.6257596611976624,
0.8349249958992004,
0.1242610365152359,
0.7114588022232056,
0.11382777243852615,
0.7978625893592834,
0.068645179271698,
0.07614585757255554,
-1.0950382947921753,
0.666654109954834,
0.157674640417099,
-0.5145827531814575,
-0.7684804201126099,
-0.3839750289916992,
-1.1976689100265503,
0.11838684976100922,
-0.35620057582855225,
-0.9763801097869873,
0.08978057652711868,
0.252880722284317,
-0.5520808696746826,
0.03716074675321579,
-0.6639097929000854,
1.0153532028198242,
-0.037742730230093,
-0.42060285806655884,
-0.04359523206949234,
-0.42446091771125793,
0.249354287981987,
0.18207138776779175,
-0.018972262740135193,
-0.026739344000816345,
0.09576241672039032,
0.12159736454486847,
-0.2218363881111145,
0.9592224359512329,
-0.3591165244579315,
-0.32457950711250305,
0.3502306342124939,
0.4420464336872101,
0.42831405997276306,
0.13074113428592682,
-0.012284010648727417,
-0.02983475662767887,
-0.08557606488466263,
-0.5717231631278992,
-0.7481689453125,
0.6479771733283997,
-0.5626102685928345,
-0.8119951486587524,
-0.18341423571109772,
-0.6032229065895081,
-0.506105899810791,
0.1212843656539917,
0.1115027368068695,
0.4902932345867157,
-0.5943577885627747,
0.018564041703939438,
0.8059636950492859,
-0.46169328689575195,
0.5022540092468262,
0.7905430197715759,
-0.22021113336086273,
-0.11977382004261017,
0.7460076808929443,
0.015518996864557266,
0.43741726875305176,
0.4668726921081543,
0.1449621319770813,
-0.39449000358581543,
-0.0336792953312397,
-1.039534330368042,
0.19783855974674225,
-0.22089144587516785,
-0.3181295394897461,
-0.5947464108467102,
-0.12459677457809448,
-0.5063883066177368,
-0.29463812708854675,
-0.1706957221031189,
-0.4805785119533539,
-0.397773802280426,
0.137374609708786,
0.33955755829811096,
0.6289330720901489,
0.1805756539106369,
0.33784615993499756,
-0.9799210429191589,
0.1228182390332222,
0.6341156363487244,
0.378027081489563,
0.06994323432445526,
-0.5126585960388184,
-0.19249227643013,
0.13599339127540588,
-0.3642478883266449,
-0.9324116706848145,
0.30933505296707153,
0.2387339323759079,
0.45516249537467957,
0.4767022132873535,
0.21250958740711212,
0.6071632504463196,
-0.7752098441123962,
0.9167356491088867,
0.22939713299274445,
-0.7332618236541748,
0.5429279208183289,
-0.6047058701515198,
0.612756073474884,
0.3449682891368866,
0.3813420832157135,
-0.8484152555465698,
-0.28142255544662476,
-0.4056040942668915,
-0.4900773763656616,
1.1927345991134644,
0.007942743599414825,
0.5389252305030823,
-0.09957507997751236,
0.1401931494474411,
0.16577251255512238,
0.10560522228479385,
-0.38730373978614807,
-0.04406212642788887,
-0.05566151812672615,
0.19039520621299744,
-0.09856914728879929,
0.007876786403357983,
-0.350972443819046,
0.20061124861240387,
0.7869198322296143,
-0.4284438490867615,
0.4503242075443268,
0.13534048199653625,
-0.08029937744140625,
-0.41658300161361694,
0.575003981590271,
0.9581145644187927,
0.5139209032058716,
-0.06972566992044449,
-0.09220148622989655,
0.07719862461090088,
0.024366319179534912,
0.17709149420261383,
0.004077480640262365,
-0.23164832592010498,
-0.24021415412425995,
-0.01586841605603695,
0.9797002673149109,
0.21665434539318085,
-0.7389113903045654,
0.5391015410423279,
-0.06259080022573471,
-0.43505483865737915,
0.06261549144983292,
0.16308888792991638,
0.1838034838438034,
0.35014572739601135,
0.1469297707080841,
-0.12867839634418488,
-0.19325119256973267,
-0.7767028212547302,
0.0939192920923233,
0.5660055875778198,
-0.6328372359275818,
-0.1607983559370041,
0.6450298428535461,
0.22913742065429688,
-0.725433349609375,
0.2735937237739563,
-0.165689617395401,
-0.38149088621139526,
0.4129316806793213,
0.6140230298042297,
0.8786503672599792,
-0.3237535059452057,
0.8003281354904175,
0.251791775226593,
0.03549918532371521,
-0.039324212819337845,
0.4350753724575043,
-0.19625329971313477,
-0.6169248819351196,
-0.5532438158988953,
-0.26571884751319885,
-0.8875893950462341,
0.15487097203731537,
-0.44394469261169434,
0.3875344395637512,
-0.291522353887558,
0.05827435106039047,
-0.04332784563302994,
-0.13195164501667023,
-0.6073169112205505,
0.018839631229639053,
0.1882006973028183,
0.804775059223175,
-0.58799147605896,
0.7786147594451904,
0.6323161721229553,
-0.5166459679603577,
-0.6547871232032776,
0.09729596227407455,
-0.1474006623029709,
-0.821863055229187,
0.33087557554244995,
0.2601958215236664,
-0.14075614511966705,
0.11573272943496704,
-0.6674194931983948,
-0.21293285489082336,
0.9845978021621704,
0.6065893769264221,
-0.36129599809646606,
0.147054523229599,
0.09933216124773026,
0.5283520221710205,
-0.4582015872001648,
0.2778027653694153,
0.1172030121088028,
0.26840636134147644,
0.43843454122543335,
-0.9540132284164429,
-0.07424982637166977,
0.08710003644227982,
-0.22780859470367432,
0.07107146829366684,
-0.7220302224159241,
0.5831344127655029,
-0.2415011078119278,
-0.19600999355316162,
0.12312809377908707,
0.5035561919212341,
0.29478490352630615,
0.28078925609588623,
0.5674872398376465,
0.005899982526898384,
0.5992915034294128,
0.23476724326610565,
0.7628354430198669,
-0.404869019985199,
0.05829211696982384,
1.123058557510376,
-0.7528946399688721,
0.9494025707244873,
0.24603474140167236,
0.19915080070495605,
0.3363249897956848,
0.40464478731155396,
0.2547188103199005,
0.08780490607023239,
-0.04092851281166077,
-0.5974597930908203,
-0.5016412138938904,
-0.3086966276168823,
0.03133018687367439,
0.5696390867233276,
0.12998078763484955,
0.12545445561408997,
-0.32171258330345154,
-0.08842922002077103,
0.16802962124347687,
0.14906087517738342,
-0.2780591547489166,
0.8103182911872864,
-0.03476164862513542,
-1.0737817287445068,
0.5744749903678894,
0.08227419853210449,
0.43479734659194946,
-0.7084187269210815,
-0.32325130701065063,
-0.19774973392486572,
-0.227894589304924,
0.130460724234581,
-0.684660792350769,
-0.15187691152095795,
0.2689809799194336,
-0.022028040140867233,
-0.4685322940349579,
0.7429317235946655,
-0.846851110458374,
-0.1244407370686531,
0.2792716920375824,
0.8948615193367004,
0.3663276731967926,
-0.241657555103302,
-0.7078402042388916,
-0.29259634017944336,
-0.30974966287612915,
-0.06598033756017685,
0.4386076033115387,
0.29510486125946045,
-0.42572757601737976,
0.4949091970920563,
0.5694422125816345,
-0.10999277234077454,
-0.14840424060821533,
0.5376894474029541,
0.6087238192558289,
-0.47391125559806824,
-0.42368170619010925,
-0.6210188865661621,
0.4727924168109894,
0.0766730085015297,
-0.10227864980697632,
0.6081436276435852,
0.2303958386182785,
0.7693439722061157,
-0.245280459523201,
0.7628929018974304,
0.15136182308197021,
0.3146495819091797,
-0.43208375573158264,
0.6425232887268066,
-0.5632282495498657,
0.02682015858590603,
-0.08145434409379959,
-0.8862707614898682,
-0.4055783152580261,
0.47381895780563354,
-0.035594601184129715,
0.2058742493391037,
0.3107373118400574,
1.1924409866333008,
-0.02830136939883232,
0.06627143174409866,
0.9966537356376648,
-0.12938547134399414,
0.215797558426857,
0.49679917097091675,
0.8309226632118225,
-0.12410838156938553,
0.5417872071266174,
0.09751328825950623,
-0.4273947775363922,
-0.4462166130542755,
-0.8909385204315186,
-1.083266019821167,
-0.3493301570415497,
-0.2769482731819153,
-0.3855971097946167,
0.20588266849517822,
1.2380081415176392,
0.6740627288818359,
-0.7630158066749573,
-0.39031529426574707,
0.1248084232211113,
-0.03642647713422775,
-0.3720170259475708,
-0.18628305196762085,
0.013989150524139404,
-0.4636535942554474,
-1.0596054792404175,
0.8727846145629883,
0.37484580278396606,
0.06807678192853928,
-0.4677635133266449,
-0.2175387740135193,
-0.1702263206243515,
0.6386551856994629,
0.8235291838645935,
0.6912268400192261,
-0.5391591787338257,
-0.36929577589035034,
0.46476781368255615,
-0.09806305915117264,
0.12149149179458618,
0.9243505001068115,
-0.6051092147827148,
0.713833212852478,
0.25086766481399536,
0.47655099630355835,
0.5213655829429626,
-0.06580992788076401,
0.8225864768028259,
-0.912320613861084,
0.08087804168462753,
0.2507849931716919,
-0.10572630912065506,
0.2913973927497864,
-0.34530022740364075,
0.29955992102622986,
-0.11450710147619247,
-0.6960245370864868,
-0.6067225933074951,
0.4099406898021698,
-0.8973345160484314,
-0.2842985689640045,
1.0694537162780762,
-0.2434382140636444,
-0.002975561423227191,
-0.178389772772789,
-0.5732071399688721,
0.16338805854320526,
-0.6519707441329956,
0.5230210423469543,
0.5820954442024231,
-0.3413495421409607,
-0.33373987674713135,
-0.565883457660675,
0.3360694944858551,
0.40182119607925415,
-0.7535631656646729,
0.29942962527275085,
0.5767045617103577,
-0.005308901891112328,
-0.16628330945968628,
1.0087904930114746,
0.06940414756536484,
0.410869300365448,
-0.12509293854236603,
0.16659393906593323,
-0.17842602729797363,
-0.726678192615509,
-0.5686914324760437,
0.028603795915842056,
0.22418609261512756,
-0.19589851796627045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18449v1 | Cascading Large Language Models for Salient Event Graph Generation | 2024-06-26T15:53:54 | 2024-06-26T15:53:54 | Xingwei Tan, Yuxiang Zhou, Gabriele Pergola, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generating event graphs from long documents is challenging due to the
inherent complexity of multiple tasks involved such as detecting events,
identifying their relationships, and reconciling unstructured input with
structured graphs. Recent studies typically consider all events with equal
importance, failing to distinguish salient events crucial for understanding
narratives. This paper presents CALLMSAE, a CAscading Large Language Model
framework for SAlient Event graph generation, which leverages the capabilities
of LLMs and eliminates the need for costly human annotations. We first identify
salient events by prompting LLMs to generate summaries, from which salient
events are identified. Next, we develop an iterative code refinement prompting
strategy to generate event relation graphs, removing hallucinated relations and
recovering missing edges. Fine-tuning contextualised graph generation models on
the LLM-generated graphs outperforms the models trained on CAEVO-generated
data. Experimental results on a human-annotated test set show that the proposed
method generates salient and more accurate graphs, outperforming competitive
baselines. | [
-0.17769066989421844,
-0.3660309314727783,
0.6477199196815491,
-0.03918273374438286,
-0.49683019518852234,
-0.07969404011964798,
-0.287834107875824,
-0.7586153745651245,
0.49679890275001526,
0.6166784167289734,
-0.8943673372268677,
-0.85114586353302,
-0.41774100065231323,
0.1453678011894226,
-0.19513139128684998,
1.109593152999878,
-0.049577195197343826,
-0.35174739360809326,
-0.10705076158046722,
0.030735090374946594,
-0.2754063606262207,
-0.4896473288536072,
-0.8880870938301086,
-0.3288940191268921,
0.7395529747009277,
0.3917408585548401,
0.5173102617263794,
0.30878180265426636,
0.36753660440444946,
0.10045184940099716,
-0.0816749706864357,
0.5596714019775391,
-0.5436543822288513,
0.4448232352733612,
-0.04393354803323746,
-0.3457963168621063,
-0.6632769107818604,
-0.29605621099472046,
0.445426881313324,
0.8444014191627502,
0.53183913230896,
0.35367125272750854,
-0.05963968485593796,
0.4139215350151062,
-0.5097227692604065,
0.5162400007247925,
-0.6101990938186646,
0.04193313047289848,
-0.598185122013092,
-0.260802686214447,
-0.4693150222301483,
-0.324282705783844,
0.056798599660396576,
-0.3135722875595093,
0.3881746530532837,
-0.1482401043176651,
0.8858508467674255,
0.10651452839374542,
-0.40796032547950745,
-0.4597996771335602,
-0.31688088178634644,
0.731705367565155,
-0.6614385843276978,
-0.007083855103701353,
0.4067075252532959,
0.11227509379386902,
-0.3795415163040161,
-0.8474771976470947,
-0.27027881145477295,
-0.33079415559768677,
0.017521290108561516,
0.07247357815504074,
-0.22072644531726837,
-0.09285818040370941,
0.33700716495513916,
-0.0216805599629879,
-0.3927668333053589,
0.1719875931739807,
-0.18759040534496307,
0.273507297039032,
0.8059267401695251,
0.3209952116012573,
0.3934008777141571,
-0.6333219408988953,
-0.09035272896289825,
0.22701610624790192,
-0.9299895763397217,
-0.07557760179042816,
0.3761301338672638,
0.6283882856369019,
-0.024646330624818802,
0.5047929883003235,
-0.2591766119003296,
0.3709665536880493,
-0.04941358417272568,
-0.203841432929039,
0.2462499439716339,
-0.18717607855796814,
-0.09037686139345169,
0.37087658047676086,
0.6911727786064148,
0.41255223751068115,
0.4609104096889496,
-0.39621391892433167,
-0.07279843837022781,
0.03868993744254112,
0.06185635179281235,
-0.9748367071151733,
-0.20087124407291412,
0.32027626037597656,
-0.23351117968559265,
-0.4739468991756439,
-0.15714314579963684,
-0.6644243597984314,
-0.191110759973526,
-0.12665821611881256,
-0.15726636350154877,
-0.381487101316452,
0.05429290607571602,
-0.06641808152198792,
0.07763490825891495,
-0.15565508604049683,
0.3741021454334259,
-0.8715135455131531,
0.08733433485031128,
0.4236437976360321,
0.8479341268539429,
-0.15890513360500336,
-0.23625214397907257,
-0.7291020154953003,
0.6029046773910522,
-0.3131152391433716,
0.5794291496276855,
-0.5069341659545898,
-0.36708539724349976,
0.0450868085026741,
-0.11418256908655167,
0.256875216960907,
-0.30435293912887573,
0.690960705280304,
-0.5991264581680298,
0.03404420614242554,
-0.453194797039032,
-0.3616985082626343,
-0.0662122294306755,
-0.07209444791078568,
-0.6122288107872009,
1.1057101488113403,
-0.16887696087360382,
-0.954557478427887,
0.5726147890090942,
-0.7998635768890381,
-0.7555965781211853,
0.21768292784690857,
-0.2209215760231018,
-0.5173511505126953,
0.01686531864106655,
0.5291357040405273,
0.6588197350502014,
-0.22511962056159973,
0.6569632887840271,
-0.155141681432724,
-0.13618744909763336,
0.2018570750951767,
-0.19779296219348907,
0.4159400463104248,
-0.13093529641628265,
-0.6505847573280334,
0.26170721650123596,
-0.9716436862945557,
-0.2713797688484192,
0.2577362358570099,
-0.23396438360214233,
-0.333561509847641,
0.35706454515457153,
0.0788811668753624,
0.17292264103889465,
0.11053802073001862,
-0.1931675374507904,
0.25237441062927246,
-0.39414122700691223,
0.34871265292167664,
0.4682426154613495,
0.28422316908836365,
0.11788655817508698,
0.036603476852178574,
0.319312185049057,
0.09891334921121597,
-0.12495963275432587,
-0.6177538633346558,
-0.48247456550598145,
-0.7481890916824341,
-0.4166843295097351,
0.05091612786054611,
0.10579045861959457,
-0.5649348497390747,
0.6930230259895325,
-0.4068557918071747,
-0.2727583050727844,
-0.14282776415348053,
-0.10344133526086807,
0.24256345629692078,
0.5193607807159424,
0.15382198989391327,
-0.553636372089386,
-0.7365250587463379,
-0.6940210461616516,
0.19441917538642883,
-0.18115326762199402,
0.08427439630031586,
0.2683660387992859,
0.4715494215488434,
-0.33223479986190796,
1.0100640058517456,
-0.6501270532608032,
-0.018955839797854424,
-0.2925761342048645,
0.3875209093093872,
-0.06288260966539383,
0.10606332123279572,
0.7001848816871643,
-0.45445916056632996,
0.043867893517017365,
0.04872428998351097,
-0.8373247385025024,
-0.5617051720619202,
-0.14364191889762878,
-0.09264471381902695,
0.27943164110183716,
0.390057772397995,
-0.6758360862731934,
0.44601523876190186,
0.28656598925590515,
-0.15852482616901398,
0.6543549299240112,
0.14253534376621246,
0.1363220363855362,
-1.1640230417251587,
0.41684603691101074,
-0.14751462638378143,
-0.4762492775917053,
-0.5860787630081177,
-0.1831982582807541,
-0.24186083674430847,
-0.42819100618362427,
-0.12987329065799713,
0.7018609046936035,
-0.6195963025093079,
-0.5332050919532776,
-0.20477771759033203,
0.7168002724647522,
-0.0008691045804880559,
0.41925472021102905,
0.04665889963507652,
0.3501478135585785,
0.45791783928871155,
-0.5170629024505615,
0.38140618801116943,
0.24493414163589478,
-0.2218078374862671,
0.33735430240631104,
-0.33425313234329224,
-0.01071099005639553,
-0.11262933909893036,
0.38484394550323486,
-1.0649887323379517,
-0.6984428763389587,
0.12774868309497833,
-0.2275601476430893,
0.15452198684215546,
-0.2657480537891388,
-0.6116604208946228,
-0.4498504400253296,
-0.2795279622077942,
0.3344734311103821,
0.1520402878522873,
-0.7885295152664185,
0.36258503794670105,
0.28476473689079285,
-0.4362639784812927,
-0.5171408653259277,
-0.5729721784591675,
0.32556018233299255,
-0.1984546035528183,
-0.9195178747177124,
0.18915000557899475,
0.2134474664926529,
-0.1720987856388092,
-0.20372886955738068,
0.12097671627998352,
0.21884676814079285,
-0.01740664802491665,
0.8296881914138794,
0.24892620742321014,
-0.2571828365325928,
0.3618406653404236,
0.08231247216463089,
-0.3147982954978943,
-0.12275182455778122,
-0.19504453241825104,
0.5599333643913269,
0.2316816747188568,
-0.5851539969444275,
-0.6174038052558899,
0.4371522068977356,
0.7728329300880432,
-0.24052168428897858,
0.3486737310886383,
0.41170671582221985,
-0.404609352350235,
-0.23737840354442596,
-0.3974568843841553,
-0.023961210623383522,
-0.3641403913497925,
0.483577162027359,
-0.49289771914482117,
-0.7386929988861084,
0.8521488308906555,
-0.29819291830062866,
0.13102807104587555,
0.37605738639831543,
0.6614499092102051,
0.24842649698257446,
1.0208884477615356,
0.3487496078014374,
-0.09709855914115906,
0.5540496706962585,
0.008610628545284271,
0.10380814224481583,
-0.5052366256713867,
-0.15125882625579834,
-0.33139774203300476,
-0.2373049557209015,
-0.2365974485874176,
-0.38880980014801025,
0.32980144023895264,
0.04116459935903549,
0.05167527124285698,
0.06543470919132233,
-0.1591494381427765,
0.586294412612915,
0.4193204343318939,
0.001344766584224999,
0.4425327479839325,
0.041047386825084686,
0.13447944819927216,
-0.12183482199907303,
-0.6506631970405579,
-0.9178619384765625,
0.7649147510528564,
0.1709948480129242,
0.6498692631721497,
0.07213343679904938,
0.9400487542152405,
0.14642836153507233,
0.47802942991256714,
-0.5608144402503967,
0.6401905417442322,
-0.050358857959508896,
-0.1230265274643898,
-0.28261658549308777,
-0.3130192458629608,
-1.0864663124084473,
-0.05239911377429962,
-0.04226379469037056,
-1.001537561416626,
0.03735557943582535,
-0.08403250575065613,
-0.35323193669319153,
0.2490813136100769,
-0.5849990248680115,
0.6553897261619568,
-0.058612339198589325,
-0.2735885977745056,
-0.0012803190620616078,
-0.6051582098007202,
0.5565308928489685,
-0.09287387132644653,
0.18531015515327454,
-0.23634915053844452,
0.1391582041978836,
0.7104519009590149,
-0.3107812702655792,
1.2813776731491089,
0.22497127950191498,
-0.15914921462535858,
0.3194175362586975,
0.23650875687599182,
0.7575191855430603,
0.12801562249660492,
-0.25699999928474426,
-0.09824786335229874,
-0.4582297205924988,
-0.2776508033275604,
-0.19243158400058746,
0.887996256351471,
-0.6427608132362366,
-0.31422358751296997,
-0.015646742656826973,
-0.6476384401321411,
-0.06060829758644104,
0.03773579001426697,
0.24286538362503052,
0.7395899295806885,
-0.45738497376441956,
-0.4737778604030609,
0.2515891492366791,
0.02028694562613964,
0.6745718121528625,
0.10763860493898392,
-0.29400452971458435,
-0.2532949149608612,
0.5316162109375,
0.14742833375930786,
0.1697084754705429,
-0.017366133630275726,
-0.38763341307640076,
-0.08268164098262787,
-0.3996700942516327,
-0.4546433091163635,
0.5086764097213745,
-0.9025864005088806,
-0.25128400325775146,
-0.6563325524330139,
-0.17939236760139465,
-0.43448200821876526,
-0.6467225551605225,
-0.3051445186138153,
-0.35454827547073364,
-0.6670756340026855,
-0.21319442987442017,
0.3409733474254608,
0.8239840269088745,
-0.004341132007539272,
0.30793678760528564,
-0.7144249677658081,
0.13500948250293732,
0.3172621428966522,
0.03585692495107651,
0.2462509274482727,
-0.07833320647478104,
-0.13076794147491455,
-0.4604575037956238,
-0.25209879875183105,
-1.0297493934631348,
0.5482080578804016,
-0.06324727088212967,
0.2747727632522583,
0.6441174745559692,
-0.009810542687773705,
0.6450750827789307,
-0.4911261796951294,
0.8679352402687073,
0.39018958806991577,
-1.0910595655441284,
0.9287453293800354,
-0.48725658655166626,
0.32700973749160767,
0.23309585452079773,
0.30316361784935,
-0.49308279156684875,
-0.43183985352516174,
-0.9048881530761719,
-1.1184039115905762,
0.9137080907821655,
0.37456071376800537,
0.009232417680323124,
-0.3597448468208313,
0.42884713411331177,
0.09634173661470413,
0.19159215688705444,
-0.6780494451522827,
0.07521310448646545,
0.26999881863594055,
-0.25419726967811584,
0.04035918414592743,
-0.4435822665691376,
-0.2042142152786255,
0.28140789270401,
0.6550437211990356,
-0.25303447246551514,
-0.28251510858535767,
0.15592890977859497,
-0.08375728875398636,
-0.5222483277320862,
0.11110448837280273,
0.5069000124931335,
0.8636420965194702,
-0.2804085314273834,
0.3605266511440277,
0.2825315296649933,
-0.2679993510246277,
-0.3093910217285156,
0.17884865403175354,
-0.2503868043422699,
0.2906200885772705,
0.5731823444366455,
1.082618236541748,
0.6534114480018616,
-0.874447762966156,
0.4037007987499237,
0.11939406394958496,
0.12332051992416382,
0.032647840678691864,
0.013287889771163464,
0.19243456423282623,
0.5261487364768982,
0.5148755311965942,
-0.45783066749572754,
-0.10607054084539413,
-0.6514991521835327,
0.2976309359073639,
0.3377368152141571,
-0.22321465611457825,
-0.42663976550102234,
0.6747837066650391,
0.5355944037437439,
-0.2543429732322693,
0.20836590230464935,
-0.297157347202301,
-0.5326632857322693,
0.5966286063194275,
0.5654081702232361,
0.7140928506851196,
-0.04138131067156792,
0.23720432817935944,
0.32566338777542114,
0.2637539505958557,
0.11528649181127548,
0.022624710574746132,
-0.05423859879374504,
-0.3081968426704407,
-0.3999372124671936,
-0.7191430926322937,
-0.4877455532550812,
0.24698838591575623,
-0.3180345594882965,
0.5926247239112854,
-0.08062301576137543,
-0.40689677000045776,
0.2942471206188202,
0.02665991149842739,
-0.31604889035224915,
0.20368164777755737,
0.4804406762123108,
0.3976331055164337,
-0.9312427043914795,
0.39355719089508057,
0.4062980115413666,
-0.5100246667861938,
-0.41673311591148376,
0.12362644076347351,
-0.1626458615064621,
-0.3990005552768707,
1.101091742515564,
0.18125325441360474,
-0.1316068172454834,
-0.02582525461912155,
-0.44168129563331604,
-0.8628895878791809,
1.1732611656188965,
0.4887523353099823,
-0.6477782130241394,
-0.2424539476633072,
0.13735529780387878,
0.45897215604782104,
-0.6963300108909607,
0.22680255770683289,
0.473553866147995,
0.2194242924451828,
0.581696629524231,
-0.7802942991256714,
0.17969371378421783,
0.22771809995174408,
0.011739104054868221,
0.34360337257385254,
-0.5808811783790588,
0.652238667011261,
-0.4839728772640228,
-0.5157188773155212,
-0.10511581599712372,
0.7823559045791626,
0.4224605858325958,
0.589544951915741,
0.059725284576416016,
0.3404659032821655,
1.14784836769104,
0.00011611036461545154,
1.0094014406204224,
-0.18773813545703888,
0.21342642605304718,
1.3356573581695557,
-0.489998459815979,
0.53305584192276,
0.19507163763046265,
0.17592042684555054,
0.34208232164382935,
0.7306567430496216,
0.22555233538150787,
0.29952073097229004,
0.21130989491939545,
-0.44581368565559387,
-0.38870590925216675,
-0.12950795888900757,
-0.24821658432483673,
0.27855420112609863,
0.2823454737663269,
-0.694189727306366,
-0.6646624803543091,
-0.14768658578395844,
0.22539663314819336,
-0.43389981985092163,
-0.4299902021884918,
0.41037046909332275,
0.15130847692489624,
-0.6018806099891663,
0.44810715317726135,
-0.031146984547376633,
0.386653870344162,
-0.6363939642906189,
0.13972963392734528,
-0.2597097158432007,
-0.054457370191812515,
-0.1784553974866867,
-0.6655077934265137,
0.18309874832630157,
0.3532698154449463,
-0.36451876163482666,
0.13371434807777405,
0.9117933511734009,
-0.5109383463859558,
-0.4229797422885895,
0.26861995458602905,
0.4891360104084015,
0.41329798102378845,
0.13757485151290894,
-0.20981989800930023,
0.17666371166706085,
-0.007470592390745878,
-0.4099403917789459,
0.20884154736995697,
0.638580858707428,
-0.4296530783176422,
0.532300591468811,
0.6650040149688721,
-0.0016757455887272954,
-0.04227810725569725,
0.6545016169548035,
0.8812666535377502,
-0.5318744778633118,
-0.6202566623687744,
-0.9213888049125671,
0.48031333088874817,
-0.25295233726501465,
-0.25876814126968384,
0.516710638999939,
0.5303038358688354,
0.24491354823112488,
0.03940916806459427,
0.6820557713508606,
0.35149508714675903,
0.06073910370469093,
-0.5460298657417297,
0.5330517888069153,
-0.27506229281425476,
0.15383507311344147,
-0.32604023814201355,
-0.6709843873977661,
-0.569593608379364,
0.144254669547081,
-0.48644328117370605,
-0.09692616760730743,
0.4093307554721832,
0.6276982426643372,
-0.14013919234275818,
0.08742471039295197,
0.36755552887916565,
0.07515029609203339,
0.34422314167022705,
0.6718127131462097,
0.6737606525421143,
-0.19183588027954102,
0.3908328115940094,
0.47091981768608093,
-0.3059324622154236,
-0.6064378023147583,
-0.8912139534950256,
-1.2504767179489136,
-0.6460350155830383,
-0.4940156638622284,
-0.2098008394241333,
0.21918998658657074,
0.7441189885139465,
0.7255378365516663,
-0.655727744102478,
-0.10728814452886581,
0.19065432250499725,
0.12026586383581161,
0.3418879806995392,
-0.24315083026885986,
0.7038013935089111,
-0.6768648624420166,
-0.7904993891716003,
0.32620561122894287,
0.6719447374343872,
0.24500559270381927,
-0.11327408254146576,
0.22900702059268951,
-0.00878729484975338,
0.2858749330043793,
0.8011646270751953,
0.21330320835113525,
-0.617764949798584,
-0.34972667694091797,
-0.4891725778579712,
-0.3291615843772888,
-0.004733155015856028,
0.7297515869140625,
-0.6117945909500122,
0.1523798108100891,
0.34625741839408875,
0.36133086681365967,
0.9649977087974548,
-0.2167300134897232,
0.33442339301109314,
-1.3781176805496216,
0.2058219015598297,
0.008036384359002113,
0.47999489307403564,
0.48735636472702026,
-0.4762611985206604,
0.6672018766403198,
0.19063295423984528,
-0.43341922760009766,
-1.0469038486480713,
0.4097687602043152,
-1.1602569818496704,
-0.27024418115615845,
1.1670832633972168,
-0.029057415202260017,
-0.39495009183883667,
-0.059225402772426605,
-0.3964410424232483,
0.5825089812278748,
-0.2910386919975281,
0.9834667444229126,
0.5518722534179688,
-0.37255269289016724,
0.15826097130775452,
-0.3733575642108917,
0.6417945623397827,
0.15873770415782928,
-1.2057788372039795,
0.6035895347595215,
0.8172780871391296,
0.008959798142313957,
0.5761721134185791,
0.747802197933197,
0.062048621475696564,
0.06206630542874336,
-0.11864297091960907,
0.28821104764938354,
0.05132245272397995,
-0.32473626732826233,
0.03320693224668503,
0.43943315744400024,
-0.09773272275924683,
0.09351018071174622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18406v1 | IRCAN: Mitigating Knowledge Conflicts in LLM Generation via Identifying and Reweighting Context-Aware Neurons | 2024-06-26T14:57:38 | 2024-06-26T14:57:38 | Dan Shi, Renren Jin, Tianhao Shen, Weilong Dong, Xinwei Wu, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | It is widely acknowledged that large language models (LLMs) encode a vast
reservoir of knowledge after being trained on mass data. Recent studies
disclose knowledge conflicts in LLM generation, wherein outdated or incorrect
parametric knowledge (i.e., encoded knowledge) contradicts new knowledge
provided in the context. To mitigate such knowledge conflicts, we propose a
novel framework, IRCAN (Identifying and Reweighting Context-Aware Neurons) to
capitalize on neurons that are crucial in processing contextual cues.
Specifically, IRCAN first identifies neurons that significantly contribute to
context processing, utilizing a context-aware attribution score derived from
integrated gradients. Subsequently, the identified context-aware neurons are
strengthened via reweighting. In doing so, we steer LLMs to generate
context-sensitive outputs with respect to the new knowledge provided in the
context. Extensive experiments conducted across a variety of models and tasks
demonstrate that IRCAN not only achieves remarkable improvements in handling
knowledge conflicts but also offers a scalable, plug-andplay solution that can
be integrated seamlessly with existing models. | [
-0.44200393557548523,
-0.4160580337047577,
0.33024874329566956,
0.31671518087387085,
-0.1386212259531021,
0.18726862967014313,
-0.30726125836372375,
-0.5201263427734375,
0.32047906517982483,
0.5718217492103577,
-0.40520432591438293,
-0.2688348591327667,
-0.7111193537712097,
-0.28047052025794983,
-0.5272330045700073,
0.8672199845314026,
-0.021364614367485046,
-0.02781219780445099,
-0.607308566570282,
-0.37114831805229187,
-0.6442307829856873,
-0.3371502757072449,
-0.9169543981552124,
-0.6584165096282959,
0.9233008027076721,
0.563369870185852,
0.21488524973392487,
0.3399460017681122,
0.2794187664985657,
0.2528410851955414,
-0.07097429037094116,
0.3118188977241516,
-0.37028929591178894,
0.5992489457130432,
-0.3440549969673157,
-0.4203502833843231,
-0.38670456409454346,
-0.23531922698020935,
0.4795851707458496,
0.5408716797828674,
-0.13745814561843872,
-0.004382357932627201,
0.24096813797950745,
0.589855968952179,
-0.8268568515777588,
-0.05179396644234657,
-1.2056444883346558,
0.08616932481527328,
-0.12419342994689941,
-0.6993704438209534,
-0.47160449624061584,
-0.1150149330496788,
0.052230481058359146,
-0.5645435452461243,
0.22881191968917847,
-0.06978943943977356,
0.6832678318023682,
0.5444848537445068,
-0.503303587436676,
-0.05503465235233307,
-0.4937957525253296,
0.624991238117218,
-0.5674418210983276,
0.04807737097144127,
0.3865033686161041,
0.2854387164115906,
-0.35365188121795654,
-0.7928386330604553,
-0.3997098207473755,
-0.03120088391005993,
0.009472946636378765,
0.1446460485458374,
-0.20644265413284302,
0.008017819374799728,
0.21653366088867188,
-0.11133451759815216,
-0.029426155611872673,
-0.008855407126247883,
-0.36871299147605896,
-0.3987933397293091,
0.38233694434165955,
0.06020093709230423,
0.3401690721511841,
-0.018693631514906883,
-0.4821074903011322,
-0.07937745004892349,
-1.1141695976257324,
-0.05759318545460701,
0.3098263740539551,
0.2400757521390915,
0.23766645789146423,
0.5851957201957703,
-0.3279079496860504,
0.697612464427948,
-0.1423977166414261,
0.046137429773807526,
0.0017574860248714685,
-0.1375085711479187,
-0.27878156304359436,
0.43236884474754333,
0.8138912320137024,
0.3244682848453522,
0.20085327327251434,
-0.03950244188308716,
-0.44821301102638245,
-0.24071751534938812,
0.52398282289505,
-0.6015004515647888,
0.0786902904510498,
-0.05714300647377968,
-0.22688493132591248,
-0.5960399508476257,
-0.2849816679954529,
-0.6161178350448608,
-0.5475401878356934,
-0.13945689797401428,
0.4963022470474243,
-0.3748955726623535,
-0.2047806829214096,
0.1492130160331726,
-0.0578886903822422,
0.16906096041202545,
0.523207426071167,
-0.8813855051994324,
0.07751480489969254,
0.6015877723693848,
0.8332726359367371,
0.04140663519501686,
-0.20448002219200134,
-0.41777920722961426,
0.42413344979286194,
-0.23732812702655792,
1.014471411705017,
-0.38329413533210754,
-0.19130778312683105,
-0.17659249901771545,
-0.04195280373096466,
-0.01361436489969492,
-0.5533112287521362,
0.37491339445114136,
-0.6615778803825378,
0.0693860650062561,
-0.4567268490791321,
-0.19679774343967438,
-0.05479280650615692,
0.43079057335853577,
-0.7444127202033997,
1.0189228057861328,
0.10496526211500168,
-1.0417835712432861,
0.5930397510528564,
-0.5530339479446411,
-0.6980201005935669,
0.149415522813797,
-0.5419566035270691,
-0.22095051407814026,
0.3236795663833618,
0.1512160450220108,
0.3620989918708801,
-0.7389093637466431,
0.5946797728538513,
0.016134917736053467,
-0.061553362756967545,
0.0029952251352369785,
-0.43227851390838623,
0.4930245280265808,
0.38809430599212646,
-0.44723501801490784,
0.22258135676383972,
-0.2005694955587387,
-0.08065509796142578,
0.006070221774280071,
-0.5374459624290466,
-0.5009106993675232,
0.3339928686618805,
-0.3074350655078888,
0.09322019666433334,
0.29062584042549133,
-0.4837048649787903,
0.24429723620414734,
-0.046623483300209045,
0.5632014870643616,
0.8058913946151733,
-0.07991386950016022,
0.31812751293182373,
-0.4828430116176605,
0.5040329694747925,
0.24229411780834198,
-0.07287333160638809,
-0.15661124885082245,
-0.4251909554004669,
-0.7445780634880066,
-0.03880571946501732,
0.12037789076566696,
0.31755387783050537,
-1.0747357606887817,
0.33598169684410095,
-0.4006320834159851,
-0.46321752667427063,
-0.11042100191116333,
-0.03963460773229599,
0.16553498804569244,
0.8769018054008484,
0.23241455852985382,
-0.5280933976173401,
-0.553773820400238,
-1.0150784254074097,
-0.36962267756462097,
-0.15374557673931122,
0.08799141645431519,
0.5302479267120361,
0.17711365222930908,
-0.2482118457555771,
1.4029279947280884,
-0.2954329550266266,
-0.3552747368812561,
-0.2477317452430725,
0.3526650369167328,
-0.13332153856754303,
0.7077814936637878,
0.5142751932144165,
-0.5911608338356018,
-0.28647032380104065,
0.3049411177635193,
-0.8205246925354004,
-0.36677709221839905,
-0.33815428614616394,
-0.1972949355840683,
-0.08689454197883606,
1.0093932151794434,
-0.3311271369457245,
0.34979048371315,
0.23999512195587158,
-0.30858147144317627,
0.4327322542667389,
-0.18012985587120056,
0.08327808976173401,
-1.121408462524414,
0.26030391454696655,
-0.22811158001422882,
-0.36103174090385437,
-0.46042031049728394,
-0.48380139470100403,
0.16128459572792053,
0.2089272439479828,
-0.3627243638038635,
0.801544189453125,
-0.36327603459358215,
-0.0818483978509903,
-0.4186510443687439,
0.0820019319653511,
0.17092223465442657,
0.41699084639549255,
0.12252042442560196,
0.8898845314979553,
0.4294486939907074,
-0.47567713260650635,
0.17686371505260468,
-0.08120062947273254,
-0.7689186930656433,
0.35692328214645386,
-0.5952104330062866,
-0.3085283935070038,
-0.27344343066215515,
0.16432707011699677,
-0.8385293483734131,
-0.22256989777088165,
0.24444951117038727,
-0.5885158181190491,
0.26410287618637085,
-0.2144279181957245,
-0.32937905192375183,
-0.03585900366306305,
0.04088553786277771,
1.0079989433288574,
0.0790599063038826,
-0.5329297780990601,
0.8556961417198181,
0.44513922929763794,
-0.19270096719264984,
-1.0614337921142578,
-0.8295273184776306,
0.12247073650360107,
-0.36114221811294556,
-0.49041488766670227,
0.5071996450424194,
0.21936428546905518,
0.10152266919612885,
0.04704328626394272,
-0.2068057358264923,
0.06590188294649124,
0.2588439881801605,
0.1862393468618393,
-0.17688719928264618,
-0.2358217090368271,
0.4315344989299774,
0.3521614670753479,
-0.13880561292171478,
0.15105198323726654,
-0.3186337947845459,
0.7347406148910522,
0.18063463270664215,
-0.5322359204292297,
0.05080577731132507,
0.20297326147556305,
1.078417420387268,
-0.33817151188850403,
0.7526637315750122,
0.522126317024231,
-0.5135459303855896,
-0.16495315730571747,
-0.6697816848754883,
-0.3790421485900879,
-0.4924878776073456,
0.6055967807769775,
-0.2387748807668686,
-0.8242437243461609,
0.7042291760444641,
-0.41621947288513184,
0.10283008217811584,
0.23483358323574066,
0.489717960357666,
0.1953231692314148,
0.894415557384491,
0.620590090751648,
-0.35337033867836,
0.9263902902603149,
0.04971843212842941,
0.3964579701423645,
-1.1561806201934814,
-0.4343145191669464,
-0.2506773769855499,
-0.5628895163536072,
-0.04542576149106026,
-0.4219748377799988,
0.34329357743263245,
0.1269470751285553,
-0.20206455886363983,
0.4040379524230957,
-0.5595940351486206,
0.5620107054710388,
0.5829203724861145,
0.021719852462410927,
0.17727214097976685,
0.19391953945159912,
-0.5313780307769775,
0.17107665538787842,
-1.0023961067199707,
-0.4639393389225006,
1.0359244346618652,
0.27166199684143066,
0.9718170166015625,
0.05881253257393837,
0.3818257451057434,
0.49724113941192627,
0.5811103582382202,
-0.7653852105140686,
0.5374431610107422,
0.156422957777977,
-0.6143791675567627,
0.050350163131952286,
-0.5865857601165771,
-0.8683514595031738,
0.23917922377586365,
-0.2619897425174713,
-0.7904211282730103,
0.3518717885017395,
0.15416797995567322,
-0.5700090527534485,
0.5781185626983643,
-0.6193414926528931,
0.8154768943786621,
-0.5248879194259644,
-0.6617400050163269,
-0.2291426807641983,
-0.3552592992782593,
0.36969563364982605,
0.09313120692968369,
-0.16877877712249756,
-0.17869341373443604,
-0.03552854061126709,
0.9152710437774658,
-0.23655405640602112,
0.9334457516670227,
-0.15687428414821625,
-0.22080576419830322,
0.43116745352745056,
0.23645290732383728,
0.24995070695877075,
0.40366488695144653,
-0.007142378017306328,
-0.03588712215423584,
-0.16588185727596283,
-0.20024904608726501,
-0.3348850607872009,
0.855435311794281,
-0.7273069024085999,
-0.7082892656326294,
-0.3490581810474396,
-0.7627408504486084,
-0.01629793271422386,
0.27641451358795166,
0.5201543569564819,
0.5517134666442871,
-0.11282045394182205,
0.3296733796596527,
0.7538586258888245,
-0.41037097573280334,
0.2248554229736328,
0.3956352174282074,
-0.08906549960374832,
-0.3868640065193176,
0.9778878688812256,
-0.05038683861494064,
0.2863202691078186,
0.22101378440856934,
-0.050723884254693985,
0.16175450384616852,
-0.347806453704834,
-0.12345101684331894,
-0.012563197873532772,
-0.7665579319000244,
-0.7240157127380371,
-0.7397757768630981,
-0.3166498839855194,
-0.19646987318992615,
-0.2732624113559723,
-0.6402171850204468,
-0.2605989873409271,
-0.1582261025905609,
0.04875793680548668,
0.3333262801170349,
0.691217303276062,
-0.2830513119697571,
0.5807102918624878,
-0.3867237865924835,
-0.08568862080574036,
0.38133108615875244,
0.32869797945022583,
0.24544458091259003,
-0.34907442331314087,
-0.35188546776771545,
0.03890290856361389,
-0.2847975790500641,
-0.8172592520713806,
0.44367727637290955,
0.06981775164604187,
0.6303253173828125,
0.5746315717697144,
0.01164612453430891,
0.4932921230792999,
-0.24323156476020813,
0.3946681618690491,
0.26142239570617676,
-0.8733596801757812,
0.5354149341583252,
-0.17941957712173462,
0.2429671585559845,
0.5920116305351257,
-0.009907955303788185,
-0.8952564001083374,
-0.2351289540529251,
-0.4254680573940277,
-1.2533290386199951,
0.9260731935501099,
-0.0368461087346077,
0.09783094376325607,
-0.2045724242925644,
0.496508926153183,
-0.1805257350206375,
0.35670438408851624,
-0.9541140198707581,
0.02581888437271118,
-0.11423827707767487,
-0.25557541847229004,
0.35264554619789124,
-0.40751156210899353,
-0.5128594040870667,
-0.1889931559562683,
0.46274131536483765,
-0.3625366985797882,
0.4869775176048279,
0.34086474776268005,
-0.25234469771385193,
-0.16115863621234894,
-0.05646049603819847,
0.8827362656593323,
0.27192947268486023,
-0.06776461750268936,
0.3961561322212219,
0.24507516622543335,
-0.43572136759757996,
-0.024124164134263992,
-0.3375523090362549,
-0.03407314419746399,
-0.2966444194316864,
0.5487573742866516,
0.5899912714958191,
0.25205129384994507,
-0.8237723708152771,
0.5573806762695312,
-0.4692043662071228,
-0.0530574694275856,
-0.30630719661712646,
0.19632133841514587,
0.09297848492860794,
0.2589246928691864,
0.34460920095443726,
0.4971175789833069,
-0.25764796137809753,
-0.3306713402271271,
0.39423081278800964,
0.727607250213623,
-0.5543744564056396,
-0.0049121486954391,
0.44830092787742615,
0.3644997775554657,
0.03774643316864967,
0.49396148324012756,
0.03872014582157135,
-0.7697480320930481,
0.993527889251709,
0.4972084164619446,
0.797031819820404,
-0.07440854609012604,
-0.0731578916311264,
0.49349096417427063,
0.4644377827644348,
-0.05356060713529587,
-0.06725050508975983,
-0.45654189586639404,
-1.2096877098083496,
-0.2579714059829712,
-0.31678688526153564,
-0.1225045695900917,
0.031839191913604736,
-0.6977647542953491,
0.2105039805173874,
-0.5843686461448669,
-0.361384779214859,
-0.45868149399757385,
-0.2333475798368454,
-0.425625741481781,
-0.015075045637786388,
0.11289717257022858,
0.9869251251220703,
-0.8709272742271423,
1.1950174570083618,
0.6286333799362183,
-0.1970074623823166,
-0.5212737321853638,
-0.07721886783838272,
-0.21286463737487793,
-0.8428768515586853,
0.8880711197853088,
0.22582146525382996,
-0.36118555068969727,
-0.05945084989070892,
-0.7270926237106323,
-0.8480736613273621,
1.4536852836608887,
0.46394529938697815,
-0.44865965843200684,
0.21678276360034943,
0.013379375450313091,
0.15747374296188354,
-0.6864137649536133,
0.4072253406047821,
0.461482435464859,
0.4256093502044678,
0.2438156008720398,
-0.45612823963165283,
0.07495759427547455,
-0.31850022077560425,
-0.22920545935630798,
0.18755745887756348,
-0.4261534512042999,
0.8266023993492126,
-0.06652816385030746,
-0.35315826535224915,
-0.14106188714504242,
0.5423338413238525,
0.26328256726264954,
0.19025060534477234,
0.5785900950431824,
0.5228385925292969,
0.6981475949287415,
-0.23603789508342743,
0.5966873168945312,
-0.5379074215888977,
0.05719371885061264,
1.3337258100509644,
-0.24371863901615143,
0.5514825582504272,
0.7759195566177368,
0.5206691026687622,
0.3457631766796112,
0.6374474167823792,
0.2768559753894806,
0.6744261980056763,
0.18657109141349792,
-0.682942271232605,
-0.357939749956131,
-0.3275611102581024,
-0.42126137018203735,
0.4198750853538513,
0.6787253022193909,
-0.4817488491535187,
-0.3972271978855133,
0.009725067764520645,
0.16145816445350647,
-0.06464909017086029,
-0.10085447132587433,
0.81725013256073,
0.025013720616698265,
-0.9210423231124878,
0.4175114929676056,
0.056961316615343094,
0.9240896701812744,
-0.723429262638092,
0.10347774624824524,
-0.49164196848869324,
0.14988017082214355,
-0.21798118948936462,
-0.6794169545173645,
0.37624391913414,
-0.06219029054045677,
-0.3527875244617462,
-0.37698793411254883,
0.906622052192688,
-0.5669229626655579,
-0.14887136220932007,
0.672173798084259,
0.5439358353614807,
-0.32339078187942505,
-0.1901181936264038,
-0.5040161609649658,
0.04074999690055847,
0.2411864846944809,
-0.25552570819854736,
0.2945806086063385,
0.5854965448379517,
-0.19014276564121246,
0.8692482113838196,
0.41552966833114624,
-0.01951517164707184,
0.015883438289165497,
0.006059277802705765,
1.1564728021621704,
-0.6528269648551941,
-0.06042017787694931,
-0.7486621737480164,
0.2954864203929901,
-0.10817619413137436,
-0.32190781831741333,
0.2350974678993225,
0.24598824977874756,
0.6354952454566956,
0.19587020576000214,
0.7910977602005005,
-0.4339194595813751,
-0.03946172073483467,
-0.290791392326355,
1.1726174354553223,
-0.9060934782028198,
0.5283003449440002,
0.03935530409216881,
-0.6477323770523071,
-0.34485942125320435,
0.7218150496482849,
-0.4175971448421478,
0.020768946036696434,
0.4946547746658325,
1.0248528718948364,
-0.13072925806045532,
-0.1954321712255478,
0.32755160331726074,
0.1446407437324524,
0.5622438788414001,
0.805107593536377,
0.8726326823234558,
-0.32693272829055786,
0.48522499203681946,
-0.09769871085882187,
-0.11547187715768814,
-0.1938197910785675,
-1.1188088655471802,
-0.6530094742774963,
-0.7271621823310852,
-0.10499096661806107,
-0.041119638830423355,
-0.09812866896390915,
0.8022506237030029,
0.8100860118865967,
-0.5408298373222351,
-0.260083943605423,
-0.3470211327075958,
0.5052076578140259,
0.04151177033782005,
-0.2352563738822937,
-0.03868308663368225,
-0.6142890453338623,
-0.3732597231864929,
0.43974629044532776,
0.2807653844356537,
-0.15195292234420776,
-0.1399536281824112,
-0.11031271517276764,
-0.2904467284679413,
0.07608553022146225,
0.5703791379928589,
0.5354909300804138,
-0.5062820911407471,
-0.34597307443618774,
-0.25167346000671387,
-0.31857529282569885,
0.040879689157009125,
1.1377464532852173,
-1.2688581943511963,
0.4880649447441101,
0.59563809633255,
0.7234536409378052,
0.10271962732076645,
-0.2609666585922241,
1.0467416048049927,
-0.8897416591644287,
0.2692335247993469,
0.2201215773820877,
0.6466121077537537,
0.38657835125923157,
-0.36590662598609924,
0.48211678862571716,
0.021984463557600975,
-0.4997977912425995,
-0.8053749799728394,
0.3164156973361969,
-0.8463967442512512,
-0.2874480187892914,
0.861998438835144,
-0.054343707859516144,
-0.26295047998428345,
0.007163513917475939,
-0.22447025775909424,
0.33970770239830017,
-0.33348074555397034,
0.8339239358901978,
0.4587858021259308,
0.14326398074626923,
-0.04372953996062279,
-0.48167261481285095,
0.5310034155845642,
0.927126407623291,
-0.7566368579864502,
0.2274310439825058,
0.1557680368423462,
0.24196024239063263,
0.09510406106710434,
0.4335988461971283,
-0.14844895899295807,
0.18911245465278625,
-0.32247960567474365,
0.5549623370170593,
0.0010053018340840936,
-0.6404469013214111,
-0.08757603913545609,
0.05253548547625542,
0.20261602103710175,
0.0825922042131424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18403v1 | LLMs instead of Human Judges? A Large Scale Empirical Study across 20 NLP Evaluation Tasks | 2024-06-26T14:56:13 | 2024-06-26T14:56:13 | Anna Bavaresco, Raffaella Bernardi, Leonardo Bertolazzi, Desmond Elliott, Raquel Fernández, Albert Gatt, Esam Ghaleb, Mario Giulianelli, Michael Hanna, Alexander Koller, André F. T. Martins, Philipp Mondorf, Vera Neplenbroek, Sandro Pezzelle, Barbara Plank, David Schlangen, Alessandro Suglia, Aditya K Surikuchi, Ece Takmaz, Alberto Testoni | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is an increasing trend towards evaluating NLP models with LLM-generated
judgments instead of human judgments. In the absence of a comparison against
human data, this raises concerns about the validity of these evaluations; in
case they are conducted with proprietary models, this also raises concerns over
reproducibility. We provide JUDGE-BENCH, a collection of 20 NLP datasets with
human annotations, and comprehensively evaluate 11 current LLMs, covering both
open-weight and proprietary models, for their ability to replicate the
annotations. Our evaluations show that each LLM exhibits a large variance
across datasets in its correlation to human judgments. We conclude that LLMs
are not yet ready to systematically replace human judges in NLP. | [
-0.42936205863952637,
-0.09487283229827881,
0.633175790309906,
0.2958337068557739,
-0.11319635063409805,
-0.0430847592651844,
-0.4046737253665924,
-0.9247934222221375,
0.30515164136886597,
0.6929289698600769,
-0.34556883573532104,
-0.5328261852264404,
-0.6360357999801636,
0.4589095413684845,
-0.5784608721733093,
0.8640832304954529,
0.08465783298015594,
0.5803622603416443,
-0.6485615372657776,
-0.3346182405948639,
-0.1005934476852417,
-0.7135842442512512,
-0.3259412348270416,
-0.707301139831543,
0.575476348400116,
0.07091858983039856,
0.6442230939865112,
0.42786890268325806,
0.7019492983818054,
0.20982015132904053,
-0.25695690512657166,
0.2018195539712906,
-0.04261251538991928,
-0.18973800539970398,
-0.44911709427833557,
-0.6103514432907104,
-0.6196991801261902,
0.4582151472568512,
0.5417733788490295,
1.0283571481704712,
-0.07960852980613708,
0.4657820463180542,
-0.04264385253190994,
0.8263148665428162,
-0.5905828475952148,
0.14335453510284424,
-0.5736897587776184,
0.4151838421821594,
-0.166017547249794,
-0.11049997806549072,
-0.5928114056587219,
-0.38160350918769836,
0.16093343496322632,
-0.40846186876296997,
0.2923473119735718,
0.41986292600631714,
0.44828343391418457,
0.17352938652038574,
-0.4688490629196167,
-0.08858020603656769,
-0.6750347018241882,
0.9136596322059631,
-0.9355536103248596,
0.13824674487113953,
0.6558980941772461,
0.40035420656204224,
-0.24300074577331543,
-0.6661595702171326,
-0.4455553889274597,
-0.567622184753418,
-0.08446294069290161,
0.13874073326587677,
-0.08874770998954773,
-0.020484304055571556,
0.39345359802246094,
0.3026202321052551,
-0.28583472967147827,
0.5084066390991211,
-0.05276557058095932,
0.14321261644363403,
0.9708974957466125,
0.37676331400871277,
-0.0006685589905828238,
-0.4001052677631378,
-0.5581941604614258,
-0.1291726976633072,
-0.7848241925239563,
-0.12817944586277008,
0.4870484471321106,
0.2907238006591797,
0.2520170509815216,
0.7118568420410156,
-0.239365816116333,
0.6505705118179321,
-0.05596361681818962,
-0.09747473150491714,
0.49505454301834106,
-0.08537419885396957,
-0.29665252566337585,
-0.07071830332279205,
1.00103759765625,
0.8688863515853882,
0.4507255256175995,
-0.38913199305534363,
-0.36997827887535095,
0.04712580516934395,
0.6135726571083069,
-0.4427684545516968,
0.12146814167499542,
0.11851277202367783,
-0.6726067662239075,
-0.7040560245513916,
0.1605343222618103,
-0.9139392971992493,
-0.8510942459106445,
-0.5016995072364807,
0.21642525494098663,
0.01579561084508896,
0.014926028437912464,
-0.03389162942767143,
-0.18759530782699585,
0.1476486474275589,
0.5790483355522156,
-0.7650918960571289,
0.7137014269828796,
0.6613853573799133,
0.39822232723236084,
-0.617870569229126,
-0.357943058013916,
-0.24411112070083618,
-0.4106864631175995,
-0.6218560934066772,
0.8370888233184814,
-0.4621118903160095,
-0.5543045401573181,
-0.039630189538002014,
0.049111660569906235,
0.20019473135471344,
-1.0209141969680786,
0.8228024244308472,
-0.4414631128311157,
0.12975460290908813,
-0.5442012548446655,
-0.5914846658706665,
-0.14611884951591492,
0.2369461953639984,
-0.6397708058357239,
1.1956299543380737,
-0.00627858703956008,
-0.6120569705963135,
0.7568457722663879,
-0.5643773078918457,
-0.18537402153015137,
-0.06464071571826935,
-0.2950326204299927,
-0.4231230616569519,
0.2116103321313858,
0.22376568615436554,
0.35031658411026,
-0.5979949235916138,
0.6031099557876587,
-0.7058326601982117,
-0.5724156498908997,
0.5248256921768188,
-0.3419516086578369,
0.565776526927948,
0.18008829653263092,
-0.4163597822189331,
0.15625736117362976,
-0.9832157492637634,
-0.02817000262439251,
0.07050479203462601,
-0.40336352586746216,
-0.2617062032222748,
0.48996680974960327,
0.19851553440093994,
0.3144286274909973,
-0.06543667614459991,
-0.5387086868286133,
0.1427423655986786,
-0.32204559445381165,
0.2534870207309723,
0.9776425957679749,
-0.11186985671520233,
0.5029211640357971,
-0.8194634318351746,
0.6113117337226868,
-0.35617420077323914,
0.0021559735760092735,
0.25727224349975586,
-0.6618427634239197,
-0.6029233932495117,
-0.12078835070133209,
0.36774781346321106,
0.39600470662117004,
-0.09058758616447449,
0.6524482369422913,
-0.39650389552116394,
-0.5755276679992676,
-0.44567692279815674,
0.3177795708179474,
0.32115355134010315,
0.36989372968673706,
0.44908130168914795,
-0.5285618901252747,
-0.6865053176879883,
-1.053843379020691,
-0.670150637626648,
0.02843295782804489,
-0.15519556403160095,
0.4582313597202301,
0.739910900592804,
-0.17136619985103607,
1.1222970485687256,
-0.05204589292407036,
-0.23431086540222168,
-0.16322468221187592,
0.1037955954670906,
0.26892659068107605,
0.36600372195243835,
0.6718952059745789,
-0.45600074529647827,
-0.17527438700199127,
-0.322671502828598,
-0.8083318471908569,
-0.384552001953125,
-0.08649613708257675,
0.04249459505081177,
0.11923183500766754,
0.5393386483192444,
-0.5207777619361877,
0.4183395206928253,
0.31391477584838867,
-0.19737139344215393,
0.8942524194717407,
0.04947441816329956,
-0.07397696375846863,
-0.7420535683631897,
0.15632541477680206,
0.05651889741420746,
-0.5212609767913818,
-0.19705526530742645,
0.05955024063587189,
0.0031475950963795185,
0.06618525832891464,
-0.39974069595336914,
0.7886844873428345,
-0.3783288896083832,
-0.49162203073501587,
-0.24692045152187347,
0.42500877380371094,
0.1603199541568756,
0.28904464840888977,
0.03480510413646698,
0.3964613974094391,
0.09734644740819931,
-0.4069574475288391,
0.4773905873298645,
0.3900201618671417,
-0.6688091158866882,
0.5578590035438538,
-0.5311712026596069,
0.036008551716804504,
-0.09899763762950897,
0.6413769125938416,
-0.6212053894996643,
-0.19716550409793854,
0.2500775158405304,
-0.20735855400562286,
0.15959452092647552,
0.0771547332406044,
-0.7191171646118164,
-0.4972551167011261,
-0.6784897446632385,
-0.12696418166160583,
0.4983442425727844,
-0.7404424548149109,
0.42117366194725037,
0.10625618696212769,
-0.004883811809122562,
-0.6990728974342346,
-1.0812983512878418,
0.3650858998298645,
-0.29167214035987854,
-0.26552724838256836,
0.27126073837280273,
0.03680500388145447,
-0.663701057434082,
-0.021445201709866524,
-0.2517433762550354,
0.3216420114040375,
0.25490525364875793,
0.505206286907196,
0.07799122482538223,
-0.030548447743058205,
0.25249654054641724,
-0.31175097823143005,
0.02246984839439392,
0.34909355640411377,
0.06138376146554947,
0.21910086274147034,
-0.012289047241210938,
-0.8134719729423523,
-0.5193906426429749,
0.2797194719314575,
0.3867943286895752,
-0.06717069447040558,
0.4107323884963989,
0.3803979158401489,
-0.2626708745956421,
-0.18640431761741638,
-0.7537274956703186,
0.04134903848171234,
-0.3579308092594147,
0.2337847799062729,
-0.19686080515384674,
-0.6691993474960327,
0.43826577067375183,
-0.20874056220054626,
0.011495113372802734,
0.6549059152603149,
0.6981275081634521,
-0.4024830162525177,
0.7884511947631836,
0.058974143117666245,
-0.15194649994373322,
0.43975183367729187,
-0.024993952363729477,
-0.23084376752376556,
-0.9844434857368469,
-0.19682864844799042,
-0.565288245677948,
-0.7536091208457947,
-0.7568584680557251,
-0.33763453364372253,
-0.09292425960302353,
0.11927788704633713,
-0.2299543172121048,
0.08569160103797913,
-0.36350321769714355,
0.2938728928565979,
0.7601737976074219,
0.27038049697875977,
0.5515836477279663,
-0.26275917887687683,
-0.13657712936401367,
-0.12263336777687073,
-0.4576122462749481,
-0.8106860518455505,
1.5562797784805298,
0.08408327400684357,
0.6734507083892822,
0.02430848404765129,
0.772942841053009,
0.5232153534889221,
0.6103168725967407,
-0.690942645072937,
0.6905595064163208,
-0.18984784185886383,
-0.7805455923080444,
-0.07216112315654755,
-0.4307757616043091,
-0.8954541683197021,
0.516638994216919,
-0.50813227891922,
-0.9199144244194031,
0.3149268627166748,
-0.22034092247486115,
-0.20513756573200226,
0.3874298334121704,
-0.5794011354446411,
0.6450715661048889,
-0.2831488847732544,
-0.2611522376537323,
-0.09218112379312515,
-0.6097619533538818,
0.4712145924568176,
-0.3291707932949066,
0.2717949450016022,
-0.3800291121006012,
0.037483811378479004,
0.8585965633392334,
-0.8181971311569214,
1.0974754095077515,
-0.24937891960144043,
0.06124567613005638,
0.2886793315410614,
-0.1362910270690918,
0.6045163869857788,
0.05177520588040352,
-0.2819588780403137,
-0.09625807404518127,
-0.09251875430345535,
-0.2839171290397644,
-0.4990469515323639,
0.6546314358711243,
-0.7850152850151062,
-0.7202154397964478,
-0.6517537832260132,
-0.4543967545032501,
-0.43890002369880676,
-0.08206474781036377,
-0.1074073389172554,
0.09500172734260559,
-0.1550627201795578,
0.2354593127965927,
0.04355955496430397,
-0.2512635886669159,
0.4866020381450653,
0.4788956344127655,
-0.6123362183570862,
-0.35768410563468933,
0.3604711890220642,
0.16103729605674744,
0.1407497674226761,
0.12587089836597443,
0.1962151676416397,
-0.18297772109508514,
-0.6027024984359741,
-0.2643527388572693,
-0.05765719339251518,
-0.6462607979774475,
-0.06804434955120087,
-0.44040217995643616,
0.1769210398197174,
-0.221110537648201,
-0.09571985900402069,
-0.3088904619216919,
-0.6124910116195679,
-0.2610865533351898,
-0.23608775436878204,
0.46039098501205444,
0.8247489929199219,
0.019537240266799927,
0.26335442066192627,
-0.6643064022064209,
0.48079192638397217,
0.35326361656188965,
0.5345306992530823,
0.0220461618155241,
-0.6630364060401917,
0.013643980957567692,
-0.0985713079571724,
-0.24558472633361816,
-0.5892660021781921,
0.32212984561920166,
0.08503499627113342,
0.7619715929031372,
0.361388623714447,
0.0293043851852417,
0.6709767580032349,
-0.6264606714248657,
0.8094084858894348,
0.17246219515800476,
-0.8249278664588928,
0.2453577071428299,
-0.12425718456506729,
0.15784622728824615,
0.5623864531517029,
0.23629936575889587,
-0.4476737976074219,
-0.28715893626213074,
-0.5520575046539307,
-0.821107029914856,
0.897656261920929,
-0.18901289999485016,
0.1575496643781662,
-0.009579450823366642,
0.38951075077056885,
0.28640758991241455,
0.3191496729850769,
-0.8004705905914307,
-0.03723248466849327,
0.01166396215558052,
0.02673770673573017,
-0.2961449921131134,
-0.4029102325439453,
-0.24070599675178528,
-0.20798756182193756,
0.38259217143058777,
0.029456110671162605,
0.0968022421002388,
0.202156662940979,
-0.15702630579471588,
-0.18065831065177917,
0.32890966534614563,
0.3839496672153473,
0.8654295206069946,
-0.5675145983695984,
0.0983644500374794,
0.4607154428958893,
-0.117609404027462,
0.06259915977716446,
0.08316165208816528,
-0.17135243117809296,
0.01750280149281025,
0.5513448119163513,
0.7759931087493896,
0.5270450711250305,
-0.8313263058662415,
0.6153449416160583,
0.15500508248806,
-0.4650838077068329,
-0.7499538064002991,
-0.08901605010032654,
0.3024066686630249,
0.5685036778450012,
0.35708531737327576,
0.37402862310409546,
0.06348951160907745,
-0.4368259608745575,
0.2247782200574875,
0.32183724641799927,
-0.2710234820842743,
-0.18952684104442596,
0.8496410250663757,
0.07345512509346008,
-0.3612431287765503,
0.47429555654525757,
-0.2241857498884201,
-0.11788452416658401,
0.39892178773880005,
0.2201199233531952,
0.8338361978530884,
0.22407083213329315,
0.00006712314643664286,
0.09646698832511902,
0.36761438846588135,
-0.5181021094322205,
0.16003207862377167,
-0.04027735814452171,
-0.7882819771766663,
-0.6499180197715759,
-0.7156435251235962,
-0.8411670923233032,
-0.003700324334204197,
-0.897975742816925,
0.2912396192550659,
-0.4931682348251343,
-0.536902904510498,
-0.06724876910448074,
-0.011367118917405605,
-0.6520543694496155,
0.25906404852867126,
0.25237205624580383,
1.0769990682601929,
-0.7528791427612305,
0.8572494387626648,
0.6059992909431458,
-0.4230262339115143,
-0.2586011588573456,
-0.24055765569210052,
0.025643467903137207,
-0.6621626019477844,
0.6956281661987305,
0.11303266137838364,
0.29655057191848755,
-0.4454130530357361,
-0.6436493396759033,
-0.5017526149749756,
1.2452090978622437,
0.3330582082271576,
-0.6392378807067871,
-0.11885670572519302,
0.1539524346590042,
0.7494192123413086,
-0.3289622962474823,
0.28641200065612793,
0.3605973422527313,
0.6433387398719788,
-0.29109057784080505,
-0.918129026889801,
-0.03685607388615608,
-0.17380858957767487,
0.04625844955444336,
-0.12873168289661407,
-0.6099631786346436,
0.5954228639602661,
-0.06357669085264206,
0.24395887553691864,
0.12681542336940765,
0.35667604207992554,
0.3809385895729065,
0.3780438303947449,
0.44048765301704407,
0.7622237801551819,
0.7238160371780396,
0.020142365247011185,
1.3478668928146362,
-0.01925482787191868,
0.42972221970558167,
1.5702481269836426,
-0.7125843167304993,
0.9327161908149719,
0.6042910814285278,
-0.710543692111969,
0.2888087034225464,
0.6522612571716309,
-0.5413063764572144,
0.1969105750322342,
0.672348141670227,
0.0028358863200992346,
-0.4215429425239563,
0.015569466166198254,
-0.19152668118476868,
0.564302921295166,
-0.04124775156378746,
-0.6549612283706665,
-0.33083558082580566,
-0.30212515592575073,
-0.07068004459142685,
0.36504971981048584,
-0.34046050906181335,
0.5920571088790894,
0.3651018440723419,
-0.31532248854637146,
0.4249798655509949,
0.19296656548976898,
0.884975790977478,
-0.4888409972190857,
0.1685122400522232,
-0.018967309966683388,
-0.02686038613319397,
-0.42126721143722534,
-0.45401525497436523,
0.32856565713882446,
0.19355598092079163,
-0.19732120633125305,
-0.6233600974082947,
0.6507154703140259,
0.11547412723302841,
-0.5437736511230469,
0.5973397493362427,
0.8802835941314697,
0.3835757076740265,
-0.2133631408214569,
-0.5323726534843445,
-0.383259117603302,
-0.2534219026565552,
-0.8080170154571533,
0.7122547626495361,
0.18027423322200775,
-0.26155322790145874,
0.6915111541748047,
0.7280815243721008,
0.13238726556301117,
0.1693563610315323,
0.3668724000453949,
0.6272116899490356,
-0.9335687160491943,
0.17623800039291382,
-0.8547381162643433,
0.1909988820552826,
-0.13054616749286652,
-0.2928234040737152,
0.7750453352928162,
0.47718286514282227,
0.6842803955078125,
-0.18704400956630707,
0.8263328075408936,
0.20152200758457184,
0.8002243041992188,
-0.4399857223033905,
0.7828765511512756,
-0.5171244144439697,
0.3172949552536011,
-0.3613278567790985,
-0.9438537955284119,
-0.41217583417892456,
0.4118287265300751,
-0.5027234554290771,
0.28797245025634766,
0.5568290948867798,
0.4402039051055908,
0.23931217193603516,
0.13692837953567505,
0.4636414051055908,
0.11731460690498352,
0.13613924384117126,
0.2279200255870819,
0.8529242873191833,
-0.17624302208423615,
0.337424635887146,
-0.15430529415607452,
0.0007675795932300389,
-0.4673970639705658,
-0.9844347238540649,
-0.8811145424842834,
-0.06108862906694412,
-0.06919585168361664,
-0.13044434785842896,
-0.17279790341854095,
1.1826618909835815,
0.37894105911254883,
-1.0020802021026611,
-0.235105961561203,
-0.003437673905864358,
-0.07749972492456436,
-0.3797219693660736,
-0.24025309085845947,
0.394811749458313,
-0.43080809712409973,
-0.7938002943992615,
0.6388553380966187,
-0.13382859528064728,
-0.2426740527153015,
-0.2853343188762665,
0.019841814413666725,
-0.28233802318573,
-0.0676516741514206,
0.5620131492614746,
-0.04365868121385574,
-0.8589564561843872,
-0.48699435591697693,
-0.15464311838150024,
-0.15693314373493195,
0.20047356188297272,
0.4683399200439453,
-0.9785118699073792,
0.3941468894481659,
0.22754697501659393,
0.7045028805732727,
0.6703096628189087,
0.08422406017780304,
0.48839426040649414,
-0.5754395127296448,
-0.008729829452931881,
0.22891831398010254,
0.6887775659561157,
0.24227581918239594,
0.2377469688653946,
0.767785906791687,
0.5089138746261597,
-0.5044397711753845,
-0.9121533632278442,
0.0009936611168086529,
-1.0956474542617798,
-0.07345385104417801,
1.1240073442459106,
-0.30017533898353577,
-0.09143476188182831,
0.16725224256515503,
0.032504286617040634,
-0.15154297649860382,
-0.34572526812553406,
0.8373749256134033,
0.9749855399131775,
-0.2751251757144928,
0.1691737025976181,
-0.9347601532936096,
0.23128581047058105,
0.4620946943759918,
-0.7221660017967224,
-0.12658840417861938,
0.31998521089553833,
0.2916353940963745,
0.2459697723388672,
0.5038966536521912,
-0.41795673966407776,
0.08981917053461075,
0.045590948313474655,
0.5525345206260681,
0.023609086871147156,
0.18625591695308685,
-0.376575767993927,
0.07005934417247772,
0.44733336567878723,
0.07691902667284012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18400v1 | Do LLMs dream of elephants (when told not to)? Latent concept association and associative memory in transformers | 2024-06-26T14:49:54 | 2024-06-26T14:49:54 | Yibo Jiang, Goutham Rajendran, Pradeep Ravikumar, Bryon Aragam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Large Language Models (LLMs) have the capacity to store and recall facts.
Through experimentation with open-source models, we observe that this ability
to retrieve facts can be easily manipulated by changing contexts, even without
altering their factual meanings. These findings highlight that LLMs might
behave like an associative memory model where certain tokens in the contexts
serve as clues to retrieving facts. We mathematically explore this property by
studying how transformers, the building blocks of LLMs, can complete such
memory tasks. We study a simple latent concept association problem with a
one-layer transformer and we show theoretically and empirically that the
transformer gathers information using self-attention and uses the value matrix
for associative memory. | [
-0.28473734855651855,
-0.6747395992279053,
0.7133951187133789,
-0.04134746268391609,
-0.28797638416290283,
0.2097555547952652,
0.08588724583387375,
-0.45664024353027344,
0.457816481590271,
0.5396208167076111,
-0.3323711156845093,
-0.08835869282484055,
-0.6153132319450378,
-0.16896651685237885,
-0.8750609755516052,
0.7849815487861633,
-0.19955211877822876,
-0.5110301375389099,
-0.24993896484375,
-0.23177088797092438,
-0.33843567967414856,
-0.6835021376609802,
-0.5833505988121033,
-0.25028184056282043,
0.5495919585227966,
0.20231229066848755,
0.7547677755355835,
0.6762279868125916,
0.6568310260772705,
0.2653956711292267,
0.021045919507741928,
0.08202122896909714,
-0.4889691472053528,
0.1350352168083191,
-0.06672435998916626,
-0.7741004824638367,
-0.44656646251678467,
0.25762319564819336,
0.418588250875473,
0.7262721657752991,
-0.225699320435524,
0.2211253046989441,
-0.22896970808506012,
0.5097481608390808,
-0.4790831506252289,
0.47143495082855225,
-0.9575091004371643,
0.295711487531662,
0.001809630892239511,
-0.46399518847465515,
-0.28649428486824036,
-0.07731377333402634,
0.26335909962654114,
-0.47375252842903137,
0.34664633870124817,
0.2820327579975128,
0.8910084366798401,
0.4575398564338684,
-0.2963298559188843,
-0.6179909110069275,
-0.9236937165260315,
0.8502428531646729,
-0.15790772438049316,
0.33467963337898254,
0.6326515674591064,
0.03536736220121384,
0.1361532062292099,
-0.6630423069000244,
-0.8065286874771118,
-0.14921623468399048,
-0.43778228759765625,
0.11736476421356201,
-0.45271027088165283,
-0.16389256715774536,
0.28847846388816833,
0.5535125136375427,
-0.2718049883842468,
-0.06349807232618332,
-0.4854666590690613,
-0.187872976064682,
0.5228512287139893,
0.2004605382680893,
0.3207002878189087,
-0.20260097086429596,
-0.5569980144500732,
0.08698613196611404,
-0.7987161874771118,
-0.21158379316329956,
0.10458135604858398,
-0.004629082977771759,
-0.07543622702360153,
0.7645030617713928,
0.2629759609699249,
0.17206928133964539,
0.000372128066373989,
-0.16361846029758453,
0.04153924435377121,
0.05054178088903427,
0.039834436029195786,
0.4036577343940735,
0.6006482839584351,
0.04000392183661461,
0.32925835251808167,
-0.6510651707649231,
-0.4841492474079132,
0.45803001523017883,
0.5468332767486572,
-0.4204093813896179,
-0.17654605209827423,
0.08764011412858963,
-0.6564245820045471,
-0.10956494510173798,
-0.24017395079135895,
-0.48215246200561523,
0.08658894896507263,
-0.2693275511264801,
0.7927870154380798,
-0.3842444121837616,
-0.2898753881454468,
-0.04373105242848396,
-0.0006555647123605013,
0.3329143524169922,
0.1105390340089798,
-1.1566319465637207,
0.5626978278160095,
0.5190263390541077,
0.9344148635864258,
-0.43936920166015625,
-0.20579832792282104,
-0.0941968634724617,
0.3649235963821411,
-0.5843477249145508,
0.8206865191459656,
-0.5511012077331543,
-0.5046105980873108,
-0.020281028002500534,
-0.15125054121017456,
-0.0654187723994255,
-0.5509591698646545,
0.12020888179540634,
-0.9222958087921143,
0.03851453959941864,
-0.29228541254997253,
-0.5163854956626892,
-0.04730373993515968,
0.017176419496536255,
-0.7888743877410889,
0.8316507339477539,
-0.19241948425769806,
-0.7417489886283875,
0.1007143184542656,
-0.4645807445049286,
-0.48267099261283875,
-0.2508445084095001,
-0.4375632107257843,
-0.3806218206882477,
0.531848669052124,
-0.17433449625968933,
0.4156101942062378,
-0.08408686518669128,
0.0011723949573934078,
0.04223497211933136,
-0.33080604672431946,
0.5185465812683105,
-0.4449286460876465,
0.39629122614860535,
0.17410863935947418,
0.13453514873981476,
-0.24175693094730377,
-0.6085646152496338,
-0.6236276626586914,
0.48860424757003784,
-0.38920262455940247,
-0.45773008465766907,
0.2763999104499817,
-0.5918818116188049,
0.1998322457075119,
0.33944442868232727,
-0.6011548042297363,
0.40384751558303833,
0.019901635125279427,
0.3941076993942261,
0.7344223260879517,
0.06421756744384766,
0.4034073054790497,
-0.5663599371910095,
0.24991989135742188,
0.4206194579601288,
-0.5551032423973083,
-0.39702680706977844,
-0.2527258098125458,
-1.3283478021621704,
0.16479338705539703,
0.03864702954888344,
0.31677815318107605,
-0.710552453994751,
0.1084853932261467,
-0.16270148754119873,
-0.3372220993041992,
-0.5159640908241272,
-0.051973775029182434,
0.014356196857988834,
0.581211507320404,
0.40164080262184143,
-0.3864777386188507,
-0.6429933309555054,
-0.9016990065574646,
0.06914172321557999,
-0.40746191143989563,
-0.04300646856427193,
0.2867288291454315,
0.46035611629486084,
0.10835249722003937,
1.0105401277542114,
-0.7100589275360107,
-0.5416669249534607,
-0.03410666808485985,
0.2868318557739258,
0.15887533128261566,
0.1992516964673996,
0.5773715376853943,
-0.6739359498023987,
0.04562507942318916,
-0.38626039028167725,
-0.9765327572822571,
0.24618087708950043,
-0.21828149259090424,
0.2322501689195633,
0.05318078026175499,
0.5283976197242737,
-1.0937310457229614,
0.22740302979946136,
0.35080552101135254,
-0.14490097761154175,
0.2591652572154999,
-0.33835017681121826,
-0.2961181402206421,
-0.8934116363525391,
-0.11535084247589111,
-0.21004532277584076,
0.04596283659338951,
-0.4218297004699707,
-0.48925164341926575,
-0.17595013976097107,
0.056112490594387054,
-0.37190186977386475,
0.5318236947059631,
-0.4917064905166626,
-0.4704882800579071,
-0.4531417787075043,
0.23175984621047974,
-0.37684524059295654,
0.6081454753875732,
0.4150151312351227,
0.9648778438568115,
0.7418121099472046,
-0.9239086508750916,
0.1132001206278801,
0.4391610324382782,
-0.4366433322429657,
0.35405242443084717,
-0.4157290458679199,
0.38712671399116516,
-0.42800846695899963,
0.05803781747817993,
-0.9500388503074646,
0.22086939215660095,
-0.09278392791748047,
-0.2238001972436905,
0.2866593599319458,
0.26900240778923035,
-0.5590183734893799,
-0.21152721345424652,
0.12936101853847504,
0.22750233113765717,
0.6387990117073059,
-0.5686554312705994,
0.8428099155426025,
0.7839788794517517,
-0.14879146218299866,
-0.5335022211074829,
-0.8108308911323547,
0.0003953176492359489,
-0.3372471332550049,
-0.07231006026268005,
0.41939350962638855,
0.08391109108924866,
-0.31577804684638977,
0.370057612657547,
-0.23843827843666077,
0.0928710475564003,
-0.024778079241514206,
0.21401429176330566,
0.31752946972846985,
-0.3997478485107422,
0.551357626914978,
-0.29594433307647705,
-0.3155727982521057,
0.4055924117565155,
-0.10030472278594971,
0.5652264356613159,
0.011835076846182346,
-0.4101388156414032,
-0.07260727137327194,
0.18990392982959747,
0.4425772428512573,
-0.20503821969032288,
0.5844055414199829,
0.27792298793792725,
-0.5733340382575989,
-0.16470637917518616,
-0.45285654067993164,
-0.3199450373649597,
-0.45801469683647156,
0.4426047205924988,
-0.6285022497177124,
-0.8151335120201111,
0.6179239153862,
-0.06493640691041946,
0.06578055024147034,
0.6050989627838135,
0.6500621438026428,
-0.25946149230003357,
0.8060576915740967,
0.7494581341743469,
-0.22373594343662262,
0.2884038984775543,
-0.4570219814777374,
0.34919238090515137,
-0.9251821637153625,
-0.04943462833762169,
-0.260580837726593,
-0.47244107723236084,
-0.5865885019302368,
-0.2764590084552765,
0.2774162292480469,
-0.09835682064294815,
-0.05395493656396866,
0.2678321301937103,
-0.23257242143154144,
0.48591163754463196,
0.28983670473098755,
-0.15760061144828796,
0.5186648964881897,
0.043561335653066635,
0.035423364490270615,
-0.06790364533662796,
-0.5593015551567078,
-0.8000873327255249,
1.039257526397705,
0.3444177210330963,
0.8987502455711365,
0.1724300980567932,
0.48037683963775635,
0.1900637298822403,
0.3422948122024536,
-0.7837417125701904,
0.6927433609962463,
-0.1789165586233139,
-0.6141802668571472,
-0.0490751713514328,
-0.15877331793308258,
-1.1495782136917114,
0.16687220335006714,
-0.11218495666980743,
-0.93413907289505,
0.10766453295946121,
0.0817372277379036,
-0.29296913743019104,
0.5825223326683044,
-0.4711434543132782,
0.3492109477519989,
-0.368020623922348,
-0.07957622408866882,
-0.5719179511070251,
-0.35279127955436707,
0.3445494472980499,
-0.3616234362125397,
-0.0051654428243637085,
-0.2340899556875229,
-0.22557510435581207,
0.9892059564590454,
-0.03874852880835533,
0.8451223373413086,
0.18670877814292908,
-0.24565228819847107,
0.6600282192230225,
0.24465027451515198,
0.26252982020378113,
-0.0997818186879158,
-0.0355057530105114,
0.35774123668670654,
-0.2816564440727234,
-0.2302677035331726,
-0.5355100631713867,
0.5743368864059448,
-1.1927409172058105,
-0.7811010479927063,
-0.6162729263305664,
-0.6117063164710999,
-0.1318560689687729,
-0.0009730512392707169,
-0.014763003215193748,
-0.044780433177948,
-0.24034814536571503,
0.11351751536130905,
0.7807561755180359,
0.018658407032489777,
0.7598399519920349,
0.8160112500190735,
-0.22721610963344574,
0.20375026762485504,
1.0390022993087769,
0.45559394359588623,
0.19220684468746185,
0.550079882144928,
-0.10923829674720764,
-0.14765030145645142,
-0.3935687839984894,
-0.09481263160705566,
0.2242051512002945,
-0.6723829507827759,
-0.1898757964372635,
-0.9874935746192932,
-0.6562368869781494,
0.21774888038635254,
0.14507175981998444,
-0.470453143119812,
-0.6657630801200867,
-0.23068518936634064,
-0.25078916549682617,
0.3422255218029022,
0.877336323261261,
-0.007608127314597368,
0.3906969130039215,
-0.5825353860855103,
0.5514480471611023,
0.6489619612693787,
0.3168439567089081,
0.3312298655509949,
-0.47353851795196533,
-0.23309865593910217,
-0.19714359939098358,
-0.5407240390777588,
-0.7815034985542297,
0.32552313804626465,
0.014802413992583752,
0.49956652522087097,
0.4198411703109741,
-0.06688510626554489,
0.34142106771469116,
-0.6407239437103271,
0.7070955634117126,
0.03829575702548027,
-0.7543779611587524,
0.2629983127117157,
0.08962635695934296,
-0.04459698125720024,
-0.06371159106492996,
0.4191746413707733,
-0.5278372168540955,
-0.20978154242038727,
-0.8195374011993408,
-0.5102932453155518,
0.7478876709938049,
0.2937304675579071,
0.5493847727775574,
-0.13716453313827515,
0.3197527229785919,
0.13109129667282104,
0.4367814362049103,
-0.5747204422950745,
-0.5196349620819092,
-0.30317243933677673,
-0.04903118312358856,
-0.2762832045555115,
-0.32708990573883057,
-0.005617984104901552,
0.06122608482837677,
0.38829392194747925,
0.07384953647851944,
0.6479263305664062,
-0.008331479504704475,
-0.14777494966983795,
-0.461864173412323,
0.22082708775997162,
0.3215143382549286,
0.4666295051574707,
-0.19735470414161682,
0.692390501499176,
0.44580286741256714,
-0.491051584482193,
0.24541617929935455,
-0.16420301795005798,
-0.12279972434043884,
0.015234111808240414,
0.2788624167442322,
0.8851242661476135,
0.22268429398536682,
-0.4828436076641083,
0.26775652170181274,
-0.08517266064882278,
0.06757053732872009,
-0.5064311027526855,
0.208204448223114,
0.4130169749259949,
0.028512446209788322,
0.6441702842712402,
-0.04352231323719025,
-0.18134544789791107,
-0.8840247988700867,
0.25020310282707214,
0.4357159435749054,
-0.38260412216186523,
-0.6408845782279968,
0.5987734198570251,
-0.23599261045455933,
-0.4574264585971832,
0.6674399971961975,
-0.03580458089709282,
-0.39215004444122314,
0.5711402297019958,
0.9193767309188843,
0.7926141619682312,
-0.32278627157211304,
-0.08773238211870193,
0.13916273415088654,
0.27698320150375366,
0.13068872690200806,
0.2381087690591812,
-0.09302341938018799,
-1.1865803003311157,
-0.35870763659477234,
-0.77557772397995,
-0.43500450253486633,
0.34237056970596313,
-0.20246154069900513,
0.16121594607830048,
-0.24424482882022858,
0.08048427850008011,
0.0961320698261261,
-0.063904769718647,
-0.7297083139419556,
0.2201971858739853,
0.19113653898239136,
0.6044040322303772,
-0.7739278674125671,
0.9847375750541687,
0.46946361660957336,
-0.6307793855667114,
-0.7626817226409912,
-0.06501979380846024,
-0.30777671933174133,
-1.1693165302276611,
0.8016477823257446,
0.000902132538612932,
-0.07222847640514374,
0.05071469768881798,
-0.524030864238739,
-1.2768473625183105,
1.1014736890792847,
0.2851657569408417,
-0.48977917432785034,
-0.23585562407970428,
0.4065336287021637,
0.5826114416122437,
-0.7487620711326599,
0.14849533140659332,
0.5968483090400696,
0.2403426617383957,
0.30517446994781494,
-0.6385294795036316,
-0.13736878335475922,
-0.05328841507434845,
-0.27896490693092346,
0.17409110069274902,
-0.9452584981918335,
1.0540872812271118,
-0.5217171311378479,
-0.34439072012901306,
-0.12705209851264954,
1.002658724784851,
0.14018619060516357,
0.19487391412258148,
0.49606406688690186,
0.6791631579399109,
0.5100718140602112,
-0.01700473576784134,
0.8963667154312134,
-0.5503318905830383,
0.3325391113758087,
0.9176050424575806,
-0.21282801032066345,
0.8669038414955139,
0.4788558781147003,
-0.28129759430885315,
0.5783241987228394,
0.4605304002761841,
0.10085833817720413,
0.5300913453102112,
0.02879861742258072,
-0.061252888292074203,
-0.18031562864780426,
-0.22631166875362396,
-0.17737585306167603,
0.7089224457740784,
0.7328265905380249,
-0.3317147493362427,
-0.06717634201049805,
-0.31257203221321106,
-0.08615774661302567,
-0.2706318497657776,
-0.3126169443130493,
0.971897304058075,
0.5582454204559326,
-0.49428749084472656,
0.2333904653787613,
-0.362157940864563,
0.3400336503982544,
-0.44842812418937683,
-0.18849630653858185,
-0.04067728668451309,
0.1908247023820877,
-0.11051669716835022,
-0.7974828481674194,
0.5508954524993896,
-0.2087818682193756,
-0.12904809415340424,
-0.26999250054359436,
0.7639558911323547,
-0.49124419689178467,
-0.3431909680366516,
0.05533799156546593,
0.7675809860229492,
0.27690261602401733,
0.42978906631469727,
-0.32661572098731995,
-0.04321962967514992,
-0.315928190946579,
-0.2260303646326065,
0.21283353865146637,
0.4648075997829437,
-0.02196892909705639,
0.7641944885253906,
0.4017239809036255,
0.3130687475204468,
-0.025731904432177544,
-0.29512861371040344,
0.7060843110084534,
-0.7893970012664795,
-0.35672685503959656,
-0.7530669569969177,
0.11243841052055359,
0.2542111575603485,
-0.10465814918279648,
0.7078714370727539,
0.6803327798843384,
0.9269796013832092,
-0.08820745348930359,
0.7632834911346436,
0.22977231442928314,
0.5004749298095703,
-0.5635859966278076,
0.6094231605529785,
-0.3964654803276062,
0.4003232717514038,
0.0003605119127314538,
-1.1000844240188599,
0.004591531585901976,
0.793015718460083,
-0.4867299199104309,
-0.048146653920412064,
0.7617734670639038,
0.442408949136734,
-0.36707428097724915,
0.2643451988697052,
0.3594495356082916,
0.6033430099487305,
0.17899879813194275,
0.5360602736473083,
1.1154704093933105,
-0.31016382575035095,
0.4818238914012909,
-0.09200824052095413,
0.25391900539398193,
-0.012389015406370163,
-0.5539523959159851,
-0.7228854298591614,
-0.5994524359703064,
-0.41527852416038513,
-0.17127928137779236,
-0.1243448257446289,
0.7586119174957275,
0.6091974377632141,
-0.7224903702735901,
-0.37233927845954895,
0.0038269301876425743,
0.26747167110443115,
0.03021528758108616,
-0.19349102675914764,
0.7041290402412415,
-0.47513073682785034,
-0.5156984925270081,
0.15848784148693085,
0.5353254079818726,
0.460599422454834,
-0.6515124440193176,
0.012431425042450428,
-0.06679702550172806,
0.493495374917984,
0.4867195785045624,
0.11319741606712341,
-0.6187858581542969,
-0.44237467646598816,
0.037904467433691025,
-0.2484273761510849,
0.39366093277931213,
0.8952282071113586,
-1.1864697933197021,
0.28658929467201233,
0.1510184407234192,
0.5449422001838684,
0.6591562032699585,
-0.2826941907405853,
0.2612830400466919,
-0.6117125153541565,
0.27151691913604736,
0.1482292264699936,
0.6440662741661072,
0.22266119718551636,
-0.1368159055709839,
0.3548245429992676,
0.19134913384914398,
-0.41500911116600037,
-0.4733593165874481,
0.356735497713089,
-0.7917835116386414,
-0.1281043291091919,
0.803616464138031,
0.039185211062431335,
-0.32513338327407837,
-0.004716062918305397,
-0.07764419913291931,
0.3155803084373474,
-0.21660122275352478,
1.295208215713501,
0.7802625894546509,
-0.3236616849899292,
-0.21947726607322693,
-0.378562331199646,
0.5094680786132812,
0.5063866972923279,
-0.5177581906318665,
-0.1197359561920166,
0.11394455283880234,
0.12163669615983963,
0.6729118824005127,
0.6644936800003052,
0.12684594094753265,
-0.1054089143872261,
0.059970829635858536,
-0.2157294899225235,
0.44701483845710754,
-0.34465309977531433,
-0.006353296805173159,
0.3213209807872772,
0.06726081669330597,
-0.2722928822040558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18626v1 | An LLM-based Knowledge Synthesis and Scientific Reasoning Framework for Biomedical Discovery | 2024-06-26T14:22:46 | 2024-06-26T14:22:46 | Oskar Wysocki, Magdalena Wysocka, Danilo Carvalho, Alex Teodor Bogatu, Danilo Miranda Gusicuma, Maxime Delmas, Harriet Unsworth, Andre Freitas | q-bio.QM | q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present BioLunar, developed using the Lunar framework, as a tool for
supporting biological analyses, with a particular emphasis on molecular-level
evidence enrichment for biomarker discovery in oncology. The platform
integrates Large Language Models (LLMs) to facilitate complex scientific
reasoning across distributed evidence spaces, enhancing the capability for
harmonizing and reasoning over heterogeneous data sources. Demonstrating its
utility in cancer research, BioLunar leverages modular design, reusable data
access and data analysis components, and a low-code user interface, enabling
researchers of all programming levels to construct LLM-enabled scientific
workflows. By facilitating automatic scientific discovery and inference from
heterogeneous evidence, BioLunar exemplifies the potential of the integration
between LLMs, specialised databases and biomedical tools to support
expert-level knowledge synthesis and discovery. | [
0.2729887366294861,
-0.46001189947128296,
1.0939958095550537,
0.19257999956607819,
0.017993325367569923,
0.319414883852005,
0.23246821761131287,
-0.4727691411972046,
0.558650553226471,
0.5765628218650818,
-0.3682551383972168,
-0.8507164716720581,
-0.42002445459365845,
0.12142012268304825,
-0.23208321630954742,
0.7845731973648071,
0.1953090876340866,
0.491574764251709,
-0.14109806716442108,
-0.13016580045223236,
0.0907488614320755,
-0.05735066160559654,
-0.532332181930542,
-0.5151639580726624,
0.6489548683166504,
0.1618337780237198,
0.4067995548248291,
0.8831179141998291,
0.5039609670639038,
0.1905864179134369,
-0.11001329123973846,
0.3226121664047241,
-0.3768094778060913,
0.3769966959953308,
-0.30891892313957214,
-0.5400079488754272,
-0.6618412733078003,
-0.2505394220352173,
0.1925545334815979,
0.9750688672065735,
-0.03864279016852379,
0.20058183372020721,
-0.26312482357025146,
0.47955140471458435,
-0.5320400595664978,
0.05613187700510025,
-0.3780078589916229,
0.2398352175951004,
-0.3095940351486206,
-0.11440204828977585,
0.011168623343110085,
-0.781196117401123,
0.042733822017908096,
-0.9542814493179321,
0.1722336858510971,
-0.13753151893615723,
0.29414382576942444,
0.5336525440216064,
-0.6812974810600281,
-0.3171064555644989,
-0.5407882928848267,
0.5562945604324341,
-0.9416795969009399,
0.48139896988868713,
0.22429987788200378,
0.5889691114425659,
-0.4223640263080597,
-0.9377645254135132,
-0.2859300374984741,
-0.24049152433872223,
-0.210783913731575,
0.2676970660686493,
0.2534456253051758,
0.16581425070762634,
-0.02313614822924137,
0.3159957230091095,
-0.49985626339912415,
-0.08517633378505707,
-0.5908076167106628,
-0.5089871883392334,
0.5112587809562683,
0.4122437536716461,
0.0626792386174202,
-0.36845433712005615,
0.039968106895685196,
0.17935366928577423,
-1.0277749300003052,
0.07281870394945145,
-0.33108922839164734,
0.2554210424423218,
0.1690666526556015,
0.9301742911338806,
-0.2690569758415222,
0.638645350933075,
0.22561068832874298,
-0.244781494140625,
0.11377685517072678,
-0.6310808062553406,
-0.26216790080070496,
0.42083582282066345,
0.7376506328582764,
0.5154476761817932,
-0.7928266525268555,
-0.014712076634168625,
0.2564026713371277,
0.2197996973991394,
-0.11257454007863998,
-0.9225199222564697,
-0.16058729588985443,
0.8059044480323792,
-0.5834680795669556,
-0.44773557782173157,
-0.06715277582406998,
-1.1003553867340088,
-1.0339291095733643,
0.5681408047676086,
0.42259955406188965,
-0.13646294176578522,
-0.03558431938290596,
0.4604435861110687,
-0.3020121157169342,
-0.3022678792476654,
0.38614049553871155,
-0.3687831461429596,
-0.027373405173420906,
0.5657051801681519,
0.7449684739112854,
0.21019914746284485,
0.07220223546028137,
-0.7693973183631897,
0.793123185634613,
-0.3496599793434143,
0.6169396042823792,
-0.5894744396209717,
-0.5967897176742554,
-0.28699731826782227,
0.2777861952781677,
0.3025422990322113,
-0.5301173329353333,
0.26839038729667664,
-0.2332555502653122,
0.4088781774044037,
-0.47172099351882935,
-0.5809370279312134,
-0.4256252646446228,
-0.16828611493110657,
-0.7621045112609863,
1.1806262731552124,
0.26490670442581177,
-0.5240195393562317,
0.8701777458190918,
-0.7596625685691833,
-0.2730269432067871,
0.504121720790863,
-0.5591961145401001,
-0.08166828751564026,
-0.20403443276882172,
0.059483546763658524,
0.5493997931480408,
-0.7574453949928284,
0.4933833181858063,
-0.3471910059452057,
-0.12983503937721252,
0.012769918888807297,
0.7328726649284363,
0.7458045482635498,
0.3883819580078125,
-0.6216331720352173,
0.15991012752056122,
-1.1617915630340576,
-0.11565797030925751,
-0.18363042175769806,
-0.5643801093101501,
-0.46663326025009155,
0.2551113963127136,
-0.1725277453660965,
0.18623623251914978,
0.36269858479499817,
-0.9328049421310425,
0.3634771704673767,
-0.5412308573722839,
0.3166186511516571,
0.31737014651298523,
0.0166944470256567,
0.24948890507221222,
-0.2838243246078491,
0.21942846477031708,
-0.01895890384912491,
0.056444600224494934,
0.061938900500535965,
-0.5310546159744263,
-0.2491787075996399,
-0.6962069869041443,
-0.07052212208509445,
0.617402195930481,
-0.3986344337463379,
0.5021146535873413,
-0.05464988574385643,
-0.7432072162628174,
-0.8121326565742493,
0.2603180706501007,
0.3394850194454193,
0.4313727915287018,
0.4792618155479431,
-0.1390475183725357,
-0.8828862905502319,
-0.7304840087890625,
0.07207690924406052,
-0.297419011592865,
-0.2582789361476898,
0.185946524143219,
0.34581753611564636,
-0.7277818918228149,
0.8893842697143555,
-0.4152021110057831,
-0.15403670072555542,
-0.14024682343006134,
-0.19799277186393738,
0.5925266146659851,
0.37841469049453735,
0.3666635751724243,
-0.5672124624252319,
-0.18856196105480194,
0.6861938238143921,
-1.2359225749969482,
-0.6690760850906372,
-0.07062400877475739,
-0.13688169419765472,
-0.3234705328941345,
0.8183553218841553,
-0.5415499806404114,
0.5077884793281555,
0.3151644170284271,
-0.6773117780685425,
0.15622858703136444,
0.005158456042408943,
0.3872002065181732,
-1.0644549131393433,
0.2845700681209564,
-0.1897801160812378,
-0.2570416331291199,
-0.7378005981445312,
-0.30935925245285034,
-0.3342154324054718,
0.40158766508102417,
0.06637392938137054,
0.7441441416740417,
-0.04704807326197624,
-0.16454584896564484,
-0.4497419595718384,
-0.3375619053840637,
0.2505277991294861,
-0.26761576533317566,
-0.11501213908195496,
0.5629252791404724,
0.357461154460907,
-0.40782538056373596,
0.36873480677604675,
0.39201804995536804,
-0.24669012427330017,
0.26172202825546265,
-0.9814544320106506,
-0.3283001184463501,
-0.10042733699083328,
0.17241279780864716,
-1.001220703125,
-0.46211791038513184,
0.3523944616317749,
-0.3301193416118622,
-0.3448635935783386,
-0.09046097844839096,
-0.2500090003013611,
-0.28177887201309204,
-0.3102037012577057,
0.2964896559715271,
0.4033980965614319,
-0.42680877447128296,
1.1993188858032227,
0.2406792938709259,
-0.17981566488742828,
-0.298952579498291,
-0.8202154040336609,
-0.15312843024730682,
-0.23256272077560425,
-0.8038464188575745,
0.5176728367805481,
-0.031795110553503036,
-0.4972391724586487,
0.13288454711437225,
-0.06099539250135422,
0.19907362759113312,
-0.005732429213821888,
0.7120298743247986,
0.11295551061630249,
-0.3463291823863983,
-0.02365039847791195,
0.20446476340293884,
0.05930657684803009,
-0.02011456899344921,
-0.2221171259880066,
0.16519691050052643,
0.016941986978054047,
-0.5163544416427612,
-0.15120826661586761,
0.10438688099384308,
0.8492571115493774,
0.24897204339504242,
0.6997761130332947,
0.40624943375587463,
-0.4620923399925232,
0.006456177216023207,
-0.6302725076675415,
-0.2919224798679352,
-0.43274787068367004,
0.3981337547302246,
-0.0327911302447319,
-1.0665656328201294,
0.8731534481048584,
-0.524997889995575,
0.0859617367386818,
0.3677351176738739,
1.075885534286499,
0.06829811632633209,
0.9700953960418701,
0.47574886679649353,
0.21799136698246002,
-0.14984819293022156,
0.1832355111837387,
-0.05836359038949013,
-0.5125442147254944,
-0.5008283257484436,
-0.388491690158844,
0.08036760240793228,
-0.3187502324581146,
-0.6802690625190735,
0.8353919386863708,
0.013632788322865963,
-0.5480902791023254,
0.031347304582595825,
-0.6013915538787842,
0.20482510328292847,
0.3629727363586426,
0.1467730700969696,
0.41671663522720337,
-0.41925865411758423,
-0.37959277629852295,
0.2188604474067688,
-0.7082657217979431,
-0.5173599720001221,
1.1139979362487793,
0.1823706328868866,
0.5104374289512634,
0.12753379344940186,
0.5130158066749573,
0.1747148036956787,
0.4232138395309448,
-0.37367314100265503,
0.4101487398147583,
0.0014586017932742834,
-0.9528011679649353,
-0.17065899074077606,
-0.36608269810676575,
-0.9519864916801453,
0.1316356062889099,
-0.43547216057777405,
-0.6409874558448792,
0.37291422486305237,
-0.06519663333892822,
-0.5548723340034485,
0.1043197438120842,
-0.2610028386116028,
0.6149762868881226,
-0.3921922743320465,
-0.452176958322525,
-0.04415931552648544,
-0.7642185091972351,
0.40947574377059937,
-0.4083135426044464,
0.42793914675712585,
-0.08867572993040085,
0.07530847936868668,
0.7088922262191772,
-0.46030953526496887,
0.7945830225944519,
-0.18599775433540344,
-0.01704050600528717,
-0.013118133880198002,
0.3604879677295685,
0.22139358520507812,
0.2076079249382019,
-0.4266785979270935,
-0.09095174819231033,
0.46663668751716614,
-0.45374375581741333,
-0.31692469120025635,
0.4340135157108307,
-0.49250420928001404,
-0.41367173194885254,
-0.11350169777870178,
-0.5484108328819275,
-0.2951858341693878,
0.26271629333496094,
0.15836231410503387,
0.023576518520712852,
-0.016175130382180214,
0.2499479204416275,
0.2885454595088959,
-0.37852543592453003,
-0.22329267859458923,
0.6704244017601013,
-0.8378632068634033,
-0.5664992332458496,
0.447489470243454,
-0.2611886262893677,
0.09616128355264664,
0.2231510877609253,
0.40968412160873413,
0.06914368271827698,
-0.6632519364356995,
-0.08358506113290787,
0.24913175404071808,
-0.7616398334503174,
-0.10986914485692978,
-0.5475261807441711,
0.11847874522209167,
-0.32403045892715454,
-0.5079018473625183,
-0.5132923722267151,
-0.4220115542411804,
0.0847611203789711,
-0.4536588191986084,
0.6656358242034912,
0.9368308782577515,
-0.4314458668231964,
0.28370004892349243,
-0.9514504075050354,
0.4164203405380249,
0.020690664649009705,
-0.07870009541511536,
-0.2508297562599182,
-0.030253475531935692,
-0.6621547341346741,
-0.1644609123468399,
0.2060307413339615,
-0.9659245014190674,
0.23981818556785583,
0.05768466368317604,
0.6952826976776123,
0.4169374704360962,
-0.444069504737854,
0.21692299842834473,
-0.1859723925590515,
0.8419474959373474,
0.1589476615190506,
-0.6345481872558594,
0.6475637555122375,
-0.5080732703208923,
-0.04478589445352554,
0.4764789938926697,
0.45931190252304077,
-0.29792749881744385,
-0.5726413726806641,
-0.3348727226257324,
-0.688042402267456,
0.10728619247674942,
-0.028237728402018547,
-0.8194716572761536,
0.06408166140317917,
0.6071865558624268,
0.5125491619110107,
0.12940248847007751,
-0.49392375349998474,
-0.10748200863599777,
-0.474782794713974,
-0.5500674247741699,
0.21699917316436768,
-0.08975370228290558,
-0.7771361470222473,
-0.3182534873485565,
0.5191086530685425,
-0.3642594814300537,
0.02405184879899025,
0.4156453609466553,
0.13036192953586578,
-0.18167966604232788,
0.009527231566607952,
0.21018506586551666,
0.5422391891479492,
-0.466012179851532,
0.1456812024116516,
0.01596074551343918,
-0.6304556131362915,
-0.009933090768754482,
0.2499280720949173,
-0.23988009989261627,
-0.3803119659423828,
0.7143144011497498,
0.24874186515808105,
-0.03727402910590172,
-0.9381522536277771,
-0.0010100045474246144,
0.1859942227602005,
-0.23699267208576202,
0.32522404193878174,
0.05353372171521187,
0.5238097906112671,
0.8793701529502869,
0.7438497543334961,
-0.24481777846813202,
0.3818531036376953,
-0.34931811690330505,
0.11915717273950577,
0.34209877252578735,
-0.14554785192012787,
-0.4106507897377014,
0.9470852613449097,
0.023305684328079224,
0.44585105776786804,
-0.12478626519441605,
0.06493454426527023,
-0.4551904499530792,
0.5712223649024963,
0.31329262256622314,
0.3838188946247101,
-0.2816906273365021,
0.300682932138443,
0.34317705035209656,
0.27925822138786316,
0.10769215226173401,
0.6327670812606812,
0.32382336258888245,
-0.7575953602790833,
-0.4557998776435852,
-0.658882200717926,
-0.41967159509658813,
-0.1281919628381729,
-0.11080063134431839,
0.08683080226182938,
-0.6983159780502319,
-0.2357420176267624,
0.620635986328125,
-0.09764786064624786,
-0.12030234187841415,
0.1968976855278015,
-0.2106722593307495,
0.49423766136169434,
-0.7736567258834839,
0.6214340329170227,
0.8171067833900452,
-0.45238426327705383,
-0.7010809779167175,
-0.5834639072418213,
0.46422308683395386,
-0.7249253988265991,
1.2488657236099243,
-0.19008977711200714,
-0.22037746012210846,
-0.35023677349090576,
-0.5099709033966064,
-0.7174615859985352,
1.4236714839935303,
0.2630300521850586,
-0.2969213128089905,
0.2823103964328766,
0.3548491597175598,
0.7848607897758484,
-0.5278956890106201,
0.11852499097585678,
0.4580380916595459,
0.8566779494285583,
0.3559902310371399,
-0.8597336411476135,
0.4728586673736572,
-0.22835104167461395,
-0.42502573132514954,
0.0785812959074974,
-0.41523370146751404,
0.881801187992096,
-0.010699689388275146,
0.025678513571619987,
0.34317970275878906,
0.43164771795272827,
0.6005579829216003,
0.8943476676940918,
0.06961600482463837,
0.4685041606426239,
1.059126615524292,
0.17393215000629425,
0.717485249042511,
-0.31816917657852173,
0.0045128557831048965,
0.48443466424942017,
-0.884328305721283,
0.19755733013153076,
0.6619572043418884,
-0.3182002604007721,
0.5570524334907532,
0.5749949812889099,
-0.052940864115953445,
0.5525654554367065,
0.05069076269865036,
-0.37109315395355225,
-0.3058205544948578,
-0.3546784520149231,
-0.4519246816635132,
0.23413334786891937,
0.5955520272254944,
-0.2981419563293457,
-0.08719227463006973,
0.07788097113370895,
-0.004701367579400539,
-0.0637776181101799,
-0.32097524404525757,
0.5879935622215271,
-0.15130114555358887,
-0.20241132378578186,
0.420788049697876,
-0.03834386169910431,
0.5970341563224792,
-0.750037431716919,
-0.1572376787662506,
-0.256757527589798,
0.2132645845413208,
-0.6496211290359497,
-0.6535186767578125,
0.3049337565898895,
-0.330650269985199,
-0.14847803115844727,
0.48548009991645813,
0.7920940518379211,
-0.3189590275287628,
-0.5668860077857971,
0.546242356300354,
0.8558154106140137,
0.05483175814151764,
0.38659074902534485,
-0.4282698929309845,
-0.04962928220629692,
0.1514536440372467,
-0.36200425028800964,
0.17615869641304016,
0.49768057465553284,
0.016702456399798393,
0.8303509950637817,
0.8252069354057312,
0.28384968638420105,
-0.01674707420170307,
-0.32473766803741455,
1.0021394491195679,
-0.8881025910377502,
-0.009412594139575958,
-0.6845775246620178,
0.32519426941871643,
0.08280551433563232,
-0.01919514313340187,
0.906347393989563,
0.6177886128425598,
0.1822805553674698,
-0.052635472267866135,
0.9889373779296875,
-0.2061922401189804,
0.8072491884231567,
-0.6496464014053345,
0.7639108300209045,
-0.7222998738288879,
0.350652813911438,
0.03180963918566704,
-0.444098562002182,
-0.5960946083068848,
0.5976721048355103,
-0.0704154446721077,
-0.036463700234889984,
0.6162046194076538,
1.023463249206543,
0.19486013054847717,
0.1081690564751625,
0.16656765341758728,
0.571601152420044,
0.72103351354599,
0.6197991371154785,
0.6287245750427246,
-0.13219332695007324,
-0.034675341099500656,
0.11498924344778061,
-0.34017282724380493,
-0.30196040868759155,
-1.0718398094177246,
-0.8284541368484497,
-0.5772096514701843,
-0.06579255312681198,
-0.719977855682373,
0.29222428798675537,
1.1940834522247314,
0.6074761152267456,
-0.881337583065033,
-0.2663439214229584,
-0.06559616327285767,
-0.039606351405382156,
0.014777056872844696,
-0.14554008841514587,
0.47290411591529846,
0.37535905838012695,
-0.2709503769874573,
1.0506023168563843,
0.5346912741661072,
-0.19462688267230988,
-0.21798385679721832,
-0.3247804641723633,
-0.4799102246761322,
0.09100781381130219,
0.4835052192211151,
0.5918700695037842,
-0.5461543202400208,
-0.14479394257068634,
0.10822439938783646,
-0.14245113730430603,
-0.2150130569934845,
0.6365628242492676,
-1.0400227308273315,
0.41239404678344727,
0.5440523028373718,
0.9160622954368591,
0.5119695663452148,
-0.312260240316391,
0.7554743885993958,
-0.3081391155719757,
0.0691918432712555,
0.37402474880218506,
0.308122843503952,
0.273560494184494,
-0.694800853729248,
0.9335268139839172,
0.3723486363887787,
-0.6363134384155273,
-0.9753352999687195,
0.016169795766472816,
-1.1609253883361816,
-0.40646055340766907,
1.0451966524124146,
0.1498093456029892,
-0.23711226880550385,
-0.39281073212623596,
-0.14665178954601288,
0.13525493443012238,
-0.1260441243648529,
0.801247775554657,
0.4734686613082886,
-0.3213580250740051,
0.12024233490228653,
-0.30896610021591187,
0.7225817441940308,
0.400655597448349,
-1.0796552896499634,
-0.007558729965239763,
0.6645848155021667,
0.3074391186237335,
0.3313600718975067,
0.8542141318321228,
-0.3305058479309082,
0.5839350819587708,
-0.07434522360563278,
0.16907553374767303,
-0.3218039572238922,
-0.10263130813837051,
0.1573161482810974,
0.08969627320766449,
-0.14821983873844147,
0.55511873960495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18373v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18373v1 | Dynamic Data Pruning for Automatic Speech Recognition | 2024-06-26T14:17:36 | 2024-06-26T14:17:36 | Qiao Xiao, Pingchuan Ma, Adriana Fernandez-Lopez, Boqian Wu, Lu Yin, Stavros Petridis, Mykola Pechenizkiy, Maja Pantic, Decebal Constantin Mocanu, Shiwei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The recent success of Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) is largely
attributed to the ever-growing amount of training data. However, this trend has
made model training prohibitively costly and imposed computational demands.
While data pruning has been proposed to mitigate this issue by identifying a
small subset of relevant data, its application in ASR has been barely explored,
and existing works often entail significant overhead to achieve meaningful
results. To fill this gap, this paper presents the first investigation of
dynamic data pruning for ASR, finding that we can reach the full-data
performance by dynamically selecting 70% of data. Furthermore, we introduce
Dynamic Data Pruning for ASR (DDP-ASR), which offers several fine-grained
pruning granularities specifically tailored for speech-related datasets, going
beyond the conventional pruning of entire time sequences. Our intensive
experiments show that DDP-ASR can save up to 1.6x training time with negligible
performance loss. | [
-0.4809488356113434,
-0.6858327388763428,
0.14617154002189636,
-0.042467325925827026,
-0.505311131477356,
0.317869633436203,
-0.14737363159656525,
-0.39908701181411743,
-0.10831355303525925,
0.07718870043754578,
-0.6821297407150269,
-0.03656385838985443,
-0.43130311369895935,
0.00689278356730938,
-0.8717694282531738,
0.5963221788406372,
0.09209281951189041,
-0.31809207797050476,
0.019827967509627342,
-0.20331601798534393,
-0.729942798614502,
-0.6381686329841614,
-0.8994441628456116,
-0.2745520770549774,
0.46497291326522827,
0.5028620958328247,
0.4513830244541168,
1.309232234954834,
0.42399346828460693,
0.33414942026138306,
-0.37102025747299194,
0.030480733141303062,
-0.26318150758743286,
0.40726664662361145,
0.27958714962005615,
-0.23214693367481232,
-0.23131179809570312,
-0.05220284312963486,
1.153712272644043,
0.6464435458183289,
-0.46170365810394287,
0.30399447679519653,
-0.1354561150074005,
0.8632969260215759,
-0.41066592931747437,
0.22253336012363434,
-0.7654199600219727,
0.296347975730896,
-0.6567439436912537,
-0.13102464377880096,
0.1251075714826584,
-0.2167535424232483,
0.1380554586648941,
-0.2888669967651367,
0.3257526457309723,
-0.2655189037322998,
0.82947838306427,
0.7542170286178589,
-0.40225741267204285,
-0.11359690874814987,
-1.3615096807479858,
0.737201988697052,
-0.25844815373420715,
0.484789103269577,
0.24911676347255707,
0.6767767667770386,
0.3072921931743622,
-0.704316258430481,
-0.6722480654716492,
-0.2225143015384674,
0.48605960607528687,
-0.21037861704826355,
-0.2483673244714737,
-0.1329750418663025,
0.392229825258255,
0.5750201940536499,
-0.4930294454097748,
0.07624045014381409,
-0.45471131801605225,
-0.259975790977478,
0.8182711601257324,
0.06415323913097382,
0.009477600455284119,
0.24939118325710297,
0.015303856693208218,
-0.5690391659736633,
-0.559402346611023,
0.07968419045209885,
0.35952726006507874,
0.34862083196640015,
0.18704849481582642,
0.4062400460243225,
-0.07896208763122559,
0.9496098160743713,
0.18049587309360504,
-0.1778746247291565,
0.3528088927268982,
-0.2345838099718094,
-0.18019112944602966,
0.329005628824234,
0.4542850852012634,
-0.014692130498588085,
0.592303454875946,
-0.07851897925138474,
-0.21872568130493164,
0.4408474862575531,
0.2982913553714752,
-0.7215801477432251,
-0.5685534477233887,
0.2198210209608078,
-0.19313417375087738,
-0.3679172992706299,
0.055129874497652054,
-0.5687646865844727,
-0.19797147810459137,
-0.5814494490623474,
0.1195661649107933,
-0.3491820693016052,
-0.14379574358463287,
-0.01405816338956356,
-0.030924076214432716,
-0.07943731546401978,
0.3495310842990875,
-0.5094658732414246,
0.4384846091270447,
0.5327211618423462,
0.7949175834655762,
-0.3579404354095459,
0.02915453352034092,
-0.9658324122428894,
0.3169424533843994,
-0.2652547359466553,
0.640158474445343,
-0.6789729595184326,
-0.5294749736785889,
-0.45391419529914856,
-0.14234429597854614,
-0.08241530507802963,
-0.8767445087432861,
0.6598010063171387,
-0.32753056287765503,
-0.4890372157096863,
-0.06720887869596481,
-0.45781320333480835,
-0.11800548434257507,
-0.05181856453418732,
-0.7176834344863892,
0.6025111675262451,
-0.390866219997406,
-0.5301368236541748,
0.5504806637763977,
-0.2337789386510849,
-0.6745107769966125,
0.013815623708069324,
-0.5086364150047302,
-0.7989041209220886,
0.1561288982629776,
0.2251056283712387,
0.17871560156345367,
-0.1168169155716896,
0.31882408261299133,
-0.01834225282073021,
-0.38040149211883545,
0.14483511447906494,
-0.8412627577781677,
0.4156135618686676,
0.47962185740470886,
-0.14366672933101654,
-0.07558945566415787,
-1.1025558710098267,
-0.07740507274866104,
0.17598716914653778,
-0.7498722672462463,
-0.01942567341029644,
0.22764179110527039,
-0.09870576858520508,
0.02349284291267395,
-0.18273499608039856,
-0.6070071458816528,
0.11313082277774811,
-0.4610574245452881,
0.5325916409492493,
0.5663285851478577,
-0.05005677416920662,
0.32940319180488586,
-0.5148630142211914,
0.5326423048973083,
-0.006752818822860718,
-0.11842726916074753,
0.03739922121167183,
-0.20491933822631836,
-0.7761783003807068,
-0.3605594038963318,
0.6588724255561829,
0.5571024417877197,
-0.5432921051979065,
0.5730037689208984,
-0.2514004707336426,
-0.41068267822265625,
-0.5250776410102844,
-0.07912031561136246,
0.27765926718711853,
0.44104981422424316,
0.20535138249397278,
-0.4307132065296173,
-0.5200983881950378,
-0.6378034949302673,
-0.18184036016464233,
-0.07565466314554214,
-0.3260217308998108,
0.6299196481704712,
-0.044739026576280594,
-0.035736385732889175,
1.0524234771728516,
-0.5483943819999695,
-0.5715205073356628,
-0.1434308886528015,
0.18845507502555847,
0.1337328553199768,
0.7279037237167358,
0.27843111753463745,
-0.9410625696182251,
-0.564498782157898,
-0.3729066550731659,
-0.06283707171678543,
-0.008213678374886513,
-0.1428297609090805,
0.5514441132545471,
-0.12106865644454956,
0.2919686734676361,
-0.46482816338539124,
0.63370281457901,
0.3991437554359436,
0.060757506638765335,
0.3858571946620941,
-0.2463865429162979,
-0.18317529559135437,
-0.411627858877182,
0.1254671812057495,
-0.11212141066789627,
-0.30887120962142944,
-0.8224218487739563,
-0.5340440273284912,
-0.06259468197822571,
-0.5781082510948181,
-0.21747399866580963,
0.3741752803325653,
-0.5278911590576172,
-0.06469825655221939,
-0.2528202533721924,
-0.165216326713562,
-0.15944422781467438,
0.14712907373905182,
0.28672894835472107,
0.6953659653663635,
0.5152077674865723,
-0.9338505268096924,
0.6193147897720337,
0.46235519647598267,
-0.2630016803741455,
-0.016670342534780502,
-0.5876263380050659,
0.42854735255241394,
-0.1759382039308548,
0.3202446699142456,
-0.7010996341705322,
-0.12343097478151321,
-0.02171180583536625,
-0.4283371567726135,
0.7303224205970764,
-0.5337525010108948,
-0.3936598300933838,
-0.5115534067153931,
-0.052691809833049774,
0.536646842956543,
0.6355609893798828,
-0.4188674986362457,
0.3307877779006958,
0.9276967644691467,
-0.40296247601509094,
-0.09001355618238449,
-0.6529568433761597,
0.015827616676688194,
-0.4856499135494232,
-0.40359729528427124,
0.634946346282959,
-0.07992763817310333,
-0.1398497223854065,
-0.4437530040740967,
-0.6212854981422424,
-0.28426408767700195,
0.03214438259601593,
0.22410991787910461,
-0.12910078465938568,
0.20109404623508453,
0.091252401471138,
-0.19879823923110962,
-0.45977354049682617,
-0.22592084109783173,
0.043114736676216125,
0.7131306529045105,
0.1931028664112091,
-0.5525925159454346,
-0.7973319292068481,
0.11805838346481323,
0.4568880796432495,
-0.44532090425491333,
0.16140218079090118,
0.5392402410507202,
-0.37363994121551514,
-0.23328958451747894,
-0.4608827829360962,
-0.1365305632352829,
-0.5543932914733887,
0.15777401626110077,
-0.3048499524593353,
-0.40051519870758057,
0.2249506413936615,
-0.0008870978490449488,
0.10171311348676682,
0.06741364300251007,
0.16259010136127472,
-0.03441062197089195,
1.0533159971237183,
0.33922040462493896,
-0.23379704356193542,
0.8605148196220398,
-0.2510378062725067,
0.08839543908834457,
-0.5512073040008545,
-0.09111274778842926,
-0.6207424402236938,
-0.5349060297012329,
-0.30990511178970337,
-0.4304218590259552,
0.4490833580493927,
-0.3542497158050537,
-0.04011760279536247,
-0.043639108538627625,
-0.9115673899650574,
0.16848579049110413,
0.5916394591331482,
0.029256056994199753,
0.1257259100675583,
0.1157207190990448,
0.4643479585647583,
-0.08251380920410156,
-0.696403980255127,
-0.2400682419538498,
0.8756788969039917,
0.4332472085952759,
0.7769395112991333,
-0.1619824767112732,
0.43231016397476196,
0.254477858543396,
-0.5503169298171997,
-0.9256405830383301,
0.7177261710166931,
-0.5259552597999573,
-0.24074040353298187,
-0.5750490427017212,
-0.6973781585693359,
-1.0273127555847168,
-0.15396571159362793,
0.14110609889030457,
-0.3117091655731201,
0.5055541396141052,
0.743931233882904,
-0.7211317420005798,
0.10115459561347961,
-0.4469321668148041,
0.24877406656742096,
-0.12421692162752151,
0.025649840012192726,
-0.2569691240787506,
-0.6904029250144958,
-0.13430961966514587,
-0.34134548902511597,
-0.10474086552858353,
-0.3326975405216217,
0.2341247797012329,
1.0935171842575073,
-0.5354123115539551,
0.4868808686733246,
-0.6334999203681946,
0.18697378039360046,
0.2845209240913391,
0.07445710152387619,
0.7152764797210693,
-0.04306983947753906,
-0.06528628617525101,
0.014680455438792706,
0.057366993278265,
0.08272203803062439,
-0.3156157433986664,
0.4742918014526367,
-0.3434036672115326,
-0.350027471780777,
-0.5348310470581055,
-0.534355878829956,
-0.4135048985481262,
-0.24997077882289886,
-0.2199283242225647,
0.6789413094520569,
0.11923078447580338,
0.46470150351524353,
0.753773033618927,
-0.26388683915138245,
0.42225247621536255,
0.660909116268158,
0.27888286113739014,
-0.2658092677593231,
1.266690969467163,
0.6395288705825806,
-0.11497638374567032,
0.15534590184688568,
0.3500003516674042,
-0.19618530571460724,
-0.9768098592758179,
-0.35206252336502075,
0.05958820506930351,
-0.13887643814086914,
-0.21063734591007233,
-0.6171303391456604,
-0.49567729234695435,
-0.31663602590560913,
0.06840550154447556,
-0.5726082921028137,
-0.701263427734375,
-0.45896413922309875,
0.08346615731716156,
0.47185376286506653,
0.16834938526153564,
-0.16083550453186035,
0.42171162366867065,
-0.9935561418533325,
0.594771683216095,
0.47882431745529175,
0.21259595453739166,
0.052091311663389206,
-0.5400296449661255,
-0.003916125278919935,
0.13126544654369354,
-0.08955011516809464,
-0.4475698173046112,
0.8109238147735596,
0.8543012738227844,
0.31104594469070435,
0.5232258439064026,
0.39520227909088135,
1.0112403631210327,
-0.8337154388427734,
0.4685983657836914,
-0.1388516128063202,
-0.6552309989929199,
0.7966716289520264,
-0.1788472682237625,
0.5477627515792847,
0.6872327923774719,
0.007742798887193203,
-0.40970632433891296,
-0.16505348682403564,
-0.6670607328414917,
-1.0968146324157715,
0.9332453608512878,
0.20660452544689178,
-0.07710007578134537,
0.3500225841999054,
0.39056116342544556,
-0.03593830764293671,
0.5106943845748901,
-0.034420259296894073,
-0.1376871019601822,
-0.03118004836142063,
-0.3583691418170929,
-0.05868254974484444,
-0.1707584708929062,
-0.19725096225738525,
-0.6593596339225769,
0.4500308334827423,
0.11785384267568588,
0.34257179498672485,
-0.11316465586423874,
-0.07114169001579285,
-0.10895787179470062,
-0.08750054985284805,
0.2078290581703186,
0.45288708806037903,
-0.2069035768508911,
-0.03799943998456001,
0.13459919393062592,
-0.8162547945976257,
0.23032201826572418,
0.5173860192298889,
-0.2911101281642914,
0.07137628644704819,
-0.010165487416088581,
0.8097633719444275,
-0.16321830451488495,
-0.8404541015625,
0.3935164213180542,
-0.2420264482498169,
0.10667777061462402,
-0.6700142025947571,
0.4569162428379059,
-0.37529969215393066,
0.1100047305226326,
0.47346770763397217,
0.09772960096597672,
0.12428942322731018,
-0.40545961260795593,
0.5667948126792908,
0.34931695461273193,
-0.29296377301216125,
-0.3732283413410187,
0.5538271069526672,
0.27452540397644043,
-0.5306329131126404,
0.9198566675186157,
0.22547747194766998,
-0.3956824243068695,
0.7026227116584778,
0.08083690702915192,
0.6969912052154541,
-0.6315924525260925,
-0.08134602755308151,
0.11769542843103409,
-0.18011561036109924,
0.018835123628377914,
0.28227588534355164,
-0.5373660326004028,
-0.5404748916625977,
-0.2852325141429901,
-0.8607141375541687,
-0.49113231897354126,
0.24769623577594757,
-0.7307169437408447,
0.31159263849258423,
-0.44270241260528564,
-0.2234128713607788,
0.20223675668239594,
0.3465172052383423,
-0.4799642264842987,
0.5041694641113281,
0.2800864279270172,
0.9780247807502747,
-0.6435824632644653,
1.2976418733596802,
0.5106470584869385,
-0.10197235643863678,
-0.6692147254943848,
0.21672052145004272,
0.2708304822444916,
-0.6582902669906616,
0.4891333281993866,
0.2301921546459198,
-0.12146935611963272,
0.3095911145210266,
-0.2206498235464096,
-0.9655457139015198,
0.952581524848938,
0.40739351511001587,
-0.909085214138031,
-0.3050452768802643,
0.15794560313224792,
0.3157002925872803,
0.015660367906093597,
-0.5802130699157715,
0.8093980550765991,
0.5217686891555786,
0.5469366312026978,
-1.0452061891555786,
-0.30904799699783325,
-0.30366674065589905,
-0.13271929323673248,
0.20833364129066467,
-0.5664397478103638,
0.7318255305290222,
0.1744176149368286,
-0.523147463798523,
-0.24204978346824646,
0.4394148290157318,
0.33569538593292236,
0.434306800365448,
0.964218020439148,
0.37326887249946594,
0.8023545145988464,
-0.2515017092227936,
0.4714289903640747,
-0.23474973440170288,
-0.14370153844356537,
1.021514654159546,
-0.45349499583244324,
0.6734185814857483,
0.25557470321655273,
-0.33674371242523193,
-0.28870925307273865,
0.6279876828193665,
-0.21984286606311798,
0.840187668800354,
0.3400128483772278,
-0.37353575229644775,
-0.10679125785827637,
0.025252776220440865,
-0.1565185934305191,
0.5923975706100464,
0.43271422386169434,
0.043294597417116165,
0.05447433143854141,
0.21879452466964722,
-0.07361628860235214,
-0.2667609751224518,
-0.20399360358715057,
1.0629868507385254,
0.1013542041182518,
-0.23409490287303925,
0.7820041179656982,
-0.3010351061820984,
0.4954705536365509,
-0.702372670173645,
-0.01907428726553917,
0.046657588332891464,
0.38084590435028076,
-0.026700865477323532,
-0.516227662563324,
0.8375558257102966,
0.1449589729309082,
-0.11767031997442245,
-0.6349100470542908,
0.7785847187042236,
-0.41478997468948364,
-0.41992416977882385,
-0.16505080461502075,
0.1366109699010849,
0.25045451521873474,
-0.36485183238983154,
-0.48541751503944397,
0.40647071599960327,
0.1839655637741089,
-0.2284097671508789,
0.47239425778388977,
0.36610424518585205,
0.1133243590593338,
1.0377707481384277,
0.6865401864051819,
0.6188805103302002,
0.03539998084306717,
-0.18671366572380066,
1.205694317817688,
-0.5315576791763306,
-0.5386239886283875,
-0.5374066829681396,
0.4326143264770508,
-0.05429258197546005,
0.09876285493373871,
0.3645364046096802,
0.533951997756958,
0.6141806840896606,
0.39591437578201294,
0.7370057702064514,
-0.029967324808239937,
1.117974042892456,
-0.27025631070137024,
0.8512042164802551,
-0.45356154441833496,
0.45472264289855957,
-0.056807808578014374,
-0.4575558602809906,
-0.2688063681125641,
0.8410546779632568,
-0.24277465045452118,
0.014719556085765362,
0.08815241605043411,
0.4641631543636322,
-0.18037086725234985,
-0.05094550549983978,
0.23740360140800476,
0.16101489961147308,
0.4967760443687439,
0.10501261800527573,
0.6013025641441345,
0.014527725987136364,
0.9027189612388611,
-0.4720553755760193,
-0.3471040725708008,
-0.12730672955513,
-0.6395050883293152,
-0.2794494330883026,
-0.6424260139465332,
-0.5767305493354797,
0.085661880671978,
0.17842678725719452,
0.7075862288475037,
0.8963795304298401,
-0.8612003326416016,
-0.18936732411384583,
-0.24956189095973969,
-0.3645520508289337,
-0.3026010990142822,
-0.1293877214193344,
0.4040043354034424,
0.05946187302470207,
-0.8178685903549194,
0.9261099696159363,
0.003891091328114271,
0.2985021471977234,
0.09764733165502548,
0.12738558650016785,
-0.0003365849843248725,
0.015989240258932114,
0.20871087908744812,
0.5741360783576965,
-0.14438821375370026,
-0.1206563338637352,
-0.5961794853210449,
0.5716032385826111,
0.19006741046905518,
0.7605196237564087,
-1.204944372177124,
0.42957547307014465,
0.33829113841056824,
0.6838462352752686,
0.8290136456489563,
0.4351420998573303,
0.8347069025039673,
-1.0628986358642578,
0.36858662962913513,
0.8654847145080566,
0.021982945501804352,
0.27509984374046326,
-0.08148695528507233,
0.3242047131061554,
0.2191017121076584,
-0.7202429175376892,
-1.3549551963806152,
0.27062585949897766,
-0.7655357718467712,
-0.009672639891505241,
1.0510770082473755,
0.053130000829696655,
0.12154381722211838,
-0.14533814787864685,
-0.21810641884803772,
0.5145844221115112,
-0.5273308157920837,
0.7579054236412048,
0.25006744265556335,
-0.45288169384002686,
-0.18290673196315765,
-0.5934895277023315,
0.8176397085189819,
0.056616656482219696,
-0.4614793062210083,
0.4678320586681366,
0.6984332203865051,
0.14216545224189758,
-0.021480035036802292,
0.5849465131759644,
0.13949628174304962,
0.04454687237739563,
-0.001828940468840301,
-0.3042449653148651,
-0.3093269169330597,
-0.7295877933502197,
-0.6931969523429871,
0.3033711314201355,
0.03790677711367607,
-0.6812531352043152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18365v1 | Themis: Towards Flexible and Interpretable NLG Evaluation | 2024-06-26T14:04:29 | 2024-06-26T14:04:29 | Xinyu Hu, Li Lin, Mingqi Gao, Xunjian Yin, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | The evaluation of natural language generation (NLG) tasks is a significant
and longstanding research issue. With the recent emergence of powerful large
language models (LLMs), some studies have turned to LLM-based automatic
evaluation methods, which demonstrate great potential to become a new
evaluation paradigm following traditional string-based and model-based metrics.
However, despite the improved performance of existing methods, they still
possess some deficiencies, such as dependency on references and limited
evaluation flexibility. Therefore, in this paper, we meticulously construct a
large-scale NLG evaluation corpus NLG-Eval with human and GPT-4 annotations to
alleviate the lack of relevant data in this field. Furthermore, we propose
Themis, an LLM dedicated to NLG evaluation, which has been trained with our
designed multi-perspective consistency and rating-oriented preference alignment
methods. Themis can conduct flexible and interpretable evaluations without
references, and it exhibits superior evaluation performance on various NLG
tasks, simultaneously generalizing well to unseen tasks and surpassing other
evaluation models, including GPT-4. | [
-0.363506942987442,
-0.4523979723453522,
0.7488860487937927,
0.23729829490184784,
-0.18117733299732208,
0.09474635124206543,
-0.5689317584037781,
-0.2233877331018448,
0.18686357140541077,
0.3131473958492279,
-0.6065602898597717,
-0.472152978181839,
-0.5494822263717651,
0.6899033784866333,
-0.15872304141521454,
1.2434393167495728,
-0.028054535388946533,
-0.20283696055412292,
-0.06018916517496109,
-0.13443350791931152,
-0.25086233019828796,
-0.26043152809143066,
-0.5235946774482727,
-0.40341487526893616,
0.32022595405578613,
0.1765243113040924,
0.7596001625061035,
0.40751543641090393,
0.34831732511520386,
0.4360184371471405,
-0.019990423694252968,
0.22387072443962097,
-0.2815074622631073,
-0.03972771391272545,
-0.1999819278717041,
-0.04482663422822952,
-0.598607063293457,
0.2142612189054489,
0.8288381099700928,
0.5675318837165833,
-0.18593423068523407,
0.36245524883270264,
0.1479278802871704,
0.6502666473388672,
-0.520918071269989,
-0.022970857098698616,
-0.7314444780349731,
0.20970135927200317,
-0.26611030101776123,
-0.1653207689523697,
-0.4574308395385742,
-0.4085480868816376,
0.4349542260169983,
-0.7252293229103088,
0.06194964796304703,
0.055026259273290634,
0.7238742113113403,
0.3081325888633728,
-0.282234251499176,
-0.07636240869760513,
-0.5686210989952087,
1.096550703048706,
-1.061667799949646,
0.38209718465805054,
0.23477120697498322,
0.43308353424072266,
-0.22273918986320496,
-0.800057590007782,
-0.6320431232452393,
-0.42221692204475403,
0.041065867990255356,
0.16122007369995117,
-0.08698087185621262,
-0.10976855456829071,
0.15489427745342255,
0.47997358441352844,
-0.4890151023864746,
-0.004250642377883196,
-0.06699997931718826,
-0.08065512776374817,
0.7310051321983337,
0.2879556715488434,
0.19456028938293457,
-0.5606150031089783,
-0.3606604039669037,
0.3340506851673126,
-0.5659804344177246,
-0.24924336373806,
0.5923622250556946,
0.31629422307014465,
-0.048583023250103,
0.48210635781288147,
-0.07033044844865799,
0.9359477758407593,
0.32901105284690857,
-0.15807346999645233,
0.5836682915687561,
-0.3403280973434448,
-0.4226333498954773,
-0.31254228949546814,
1.0236377716064453,
0.2984066605567932,
0.1731950342655182,
-0.5823843479156494,
-0.1642424464225769,
0.018672093749046326,
0.746445894241333,
-0.5234119296073914,
0.1810528039932251,
0.18974418938159943,
-0.4157962501049042,
-0.3864976167678833,
-0.16927240788936615,
-0.8150811195373535,
-0.25041499733924866,
-0.5512270927429199,
0.3199295997619629,
-0.4572156071662903,
-0.29845425486564636,
0.08440832048654556,
-0.00408022478222847,
0.0877961590886116,
0.24120713770389557,
-1.0938632488250732,
0.05134758725762367,
0.48092302680015564,
0.5254294276237488,
-0.341638445854187,
-0.4099259078502655,
-0.46643561124801636,
0.3148612678050995,
-0.09894582629203796,
0.7912641763687134,
-0.7864482998847961,
-0.22262132167816162,
-0.09258324652910233,
-0.09722501784563065,
-0.1735270768404007,
-0.24923618137836456,
0.9463382959365845,
-0.3064168393611908,
0.3974461555480957,
-0.25486767292022705,
-0.7135968208312988,
-0.03791537508368492,
0.5092434883117676,
-0.5698999166488647,
0.8810827732086182,
0.2030506134033203,
-0.9714237451553345,
0.5174567103385925,
-0.9321054816246033,
-0.16641263663768768,
0.42966899275779724,
-0.2372296303510666,
-0.43818366527557373,
0.0864328145980835,
0.25976020097732544,
0.5210170149803162,
-0.5310980677604675,
0.6550810933113098,
-0.20694267749786377,
-0.18444393575191498,
0.07223492115736008,
-0.5341013669967651,
0.5265982747077942,
0.2342696189880371,
-0.44355952739715576,
0.5178762078285217,
-0.9548227190971375,
0.33474627137184143,
-0.08048907667398453,
-0.4218699038028717,
-0.00841781497001648,
-0.009947986342012882,
0.08131513744592667,
0.04151512682437897,
0.12996740639209747,
-0.5182755589485168,
0.185403510928154,
-0.42109355330467224,
0.35112470388412476,
0.7231204509735107,
-0.1878676414489746,
0.5576397776603699,
-0.12678253650665283,
0.5505067110061646,
-0.4690883159637451,
0.21421796083450317,
0.2131795734167099,
-0.5529980659484863,
-0.5239253640174866,
-0.1927006095647812,
0.33871975541114807,
0.2715500295162201,
-0.87422114610672,
0.8698196411132812,
-0.4720788896083832,
-0.523324191570282,
-0.4703242778778076,
0.48369401693344116,
0.12304290384054184,
0.5033223032951355,
0.19410304725170135,
-0.10323026776313782,
-0.7262690663337708,
-0.9765114784240723,
-0.3506649136543274,
-0.10561494529247284,
-0.43442386388778687,
0.021701574325561523,
0.3598380982875824,
-0.4173325002193451,
0.9929537177085876,
-0.12031568586826324,
-0.16054557263851166,
-0.48193952441215515,
0.2335529327392578,
0.09036607295274734,
0.28485649824142456,
0.3141893446445465,
-0.49348506331443787,
-0.19495795667171478,
-0.17194217443466187,
-0.905020534992218,
-0.19034434854984283,
-0.25247710943222046,
-0.020903825759887695,
0.04946572706103325,
0.08622082322835922,
-0.2506479024887085,
0.14459381997585297,
0.7349065542221069,
-0.3753778040409088,
0.5209454298019409,
-0.34693676233291626,
0.03219589963555336,
-1.0085499286651611,
0.021905623376369476,
0.26135125756263733,
-0.22914676368236542,
-0.43595847487449646,
-0.25343990325927734,
0.005354790948331356,
0.06595361977815628,
-0.3618704080581665,
0.50016850233078,
-0.41251733899116516,
-0.10779719799757004,
-0.049790941178798676,
0.4232010841369629,
0.18837450444698334,
0.39356890320777893,
0.01358065102249384,
0.5602115988731384,
0.4654648005962372,
-0.4010208249092102,
0.31556573510169983,
0.28930070996284485,
-0.23507362604141235,
0.5085653066635132,
-0.49397778511047363,
0.48787134885787964,
0.11868294328451157,
0.2686934471130371,
-0.5292637944221497,
-0.2042933702468872,
0.21176810562610626,
0.047904398292303085,
0.41484227776527405,
-0.02327718958258629,
-0.3780912756919861,
-0.44722795486450195,
-0.5887422561645508,
0.30003389716148376,
0.3176615536212921,
-0.844978928565979,
0.7840452194213867,
0.341661661863327,
0.09749419242143631,
-0.5469385385513306,
-0.3971806764602661,
0.3884340524673462,
-0.5274235010147095,
-0.7414173483848572,
0.34161028265953064,
-0.19167737662792206,
-0.18787391483783722,
-0.04671032354235649,
-0.11210723966360092,
0.126499205827713,
-0.052176401019096375,
0.09479202330112457,
0.1998639851808548,
-0.17760911583900452,
-0.10215726494789124,
-0.021703064441680908,
-0.21574051678180695,
-0.2343096137046814,
-0.28929218649864197,
0.0296512208878994,
-0.8274314999580383,
-0.23663701117038727,
-0.30400705337524414,
0.17546232044696808,
0.33090415596961975,
-0.25648900866508484,
0.305224746465683,
0.6311546564102173,
-0.2404111623764038,
-0.20185700058937073,
-0.6429468989372253,
0.3062504231929779,
-0.48308509588241577,
0.1307937204837799,
-0.3926815390586853,
-0.947006344795227,
0.23859530687332153,
-0.2065007984638214,
0.19933703541755676,
0.6677581667900085,
0.6372418999671936,
0.20342114567756653,
0.8476598262786865,
0.5742321014404297,
0.10168757289648056,
0.21441006660461426,
-0.09632617235183716,
0.2506832480430603,
-1.0631431341171265,
-0.09515577554702759,
-0.28694236278533936,
-0.13469038903713226,
-0.6650010347366333,
-0.13977551460266113,
0.21487119793891907,
0.07581227272748947,
-0.04655515402555466,
0.3589659333229065,
-0.7457290291786194,
0.43400707840919495,
0.0747295543551445,
-0.2305186688899994,
0.1836279332637787,
-0.1714443564414978,
-0.1458643525838852,
-0.21092045307159424,
-0.6252481341362,
-1.1918261051177979,
1.4211236238479614,
0.43210557103157043,
0.4221947491168976,
0.08771784603595734,
0.6952747702598572,
0.2942529022693634,
0.806018054485321,
-0.6225183010101318,
0.5047245621681213,
-0.276020884513855,
-0.40282535552978516,
-0.4063150882720947,
-0.3524770140647888,
-0.9388266801834106,
0.25037872791290283,
-0.318733274936676,
-0.9500281810760498,
-0.23852786421775818,
0.024804506450891495,
-0.4278859794139862,
0.39450088143348694,
-0.8562520742416382,
0.8356882333755493,
-0.41040101647377014,
-0.5780614018440247,
0.024301910772919655,
-0.4233323037624359,
0.34299108386039734,
-0.20002004504203796,
0.1357136219739914,
-0.1808672398328781,
0.15560685098171234,
0.8790574669837952,
-0.2707400619983673,
0.6400005221366882,
-0.1379130482673645,
-0.3388241231441498,
0.3960517346858978,
-0.24645978212356567,
0.19680945575237274,
0.39345622062683105,
-0.45588818192481995,
0.3871712386608124,
-0.16923189163208008,
-0.1373112052679062,
-0.6620712280273438,
0.9613931775093079,
-0.47917667031288147,
-0.5409544110298157,
-0.3346242904663086,
-0.6268406510353088,
-0.39645570516586304,
0.10546952486038208,
0.2238205224275589,
0.295427143573761,
-0.3407287895679474,
-0.18192096054553986,
0.14061395823955536,
-0.2719881534576416,
0.529814600944519,
0.15445512533187866,
-0.23457354307174683,
-0.4485931396484375,
0.8560813069343567,
-0.1919296234846115,
-0.08902483433485031,
-0.0924861952662468,
0.44964197278022766,
-0.5115579962730408,
-0.579952597618103,
-0.9018776416778564,
-0.022779259830713272,
-0.4680425524711609,
-0.17306900024414062,
-0.332380086183548,
-0.009405623190104961,
-0.15631480515003204,
-0.18166252970695496,
-0.3777376413345337,
-0.4150328040122986,
-0.008399024605751038,
-0.06841527670621872,
0.21153797209262848,
0.9984012842178345,
-0.040705129504203796,
0.30217641592025757,
-0.7302183508872986,
0.4356711804866791,
0.2619401812553406,
0.8358485698699951,
-0.27627354860305786,
-0.36505138874053955,
-0.02546006254851818,
-0.21310649812221527,
-0.4579499661922455,
-0.7879713773727417,
0.3113328516483307,
0.028246941044926643,
0.6074016094207764,
0.4894033968448639,
-0.3212698698043823,
0.39200326800346375,
-0.80379319190979,
0.8320130109786987,
0.2784658670425415,
-1.0630457401275635,
0.29743343591690063,
-0.4426841139793396,
0.17236576974391937,
0.6791442632675171,
0.02137262187898159,
-0.2581115663051605,
-0.4063604176044464,
-0.7457485198974609,
-1.0105401277542114,
0.6779378056526184,
0.5024586319923401,
0.008016543462872505,
-0.14123928546905518,
0.5222787261009216,
0.45513609051704407,
0.18516328930854797,
-0.8248394131660461,
-0.06935358792543411,
-0.48036912083625793,
-0.31932196021080017,
-0.003932963125407696,
-0.23807114362716675,
-0.10511790215969086,
-0.19492276012897491,
0.7194845080375671,
-0.2686396539211273,
0.09937170892953873,
-0.008775501511991024,
0.02083146944642067,
-0.0037734590005129576,
0.8365233540534973,
0.353130578994751,
0.9105986952781677,
-0.28083133697509766,
0.09682472795248032,
0.44244474172592163,
-0.13031940162181854,
0.09065171331167221,
0.03487950935959816,
-0.1916993409395218,
-0.044394876807928085,
0.18186132609844208,
0.9700599908828735,
0.015598888508975506,
-0.549717128276825,
0.42332208156585693,
-0.31285572052001953,
-0.23689472675323486,
-0.5312394499778748,
-0.10599038749933243,
0.13161414861679077,
0.01851222850382328,
0.20487244427204132,
0.100470170378685,
0.25319936871528625,
-0.19438380002975464,
0.13586445152759552,
0.35296520590782166,
-0.16881127655506134,
-0.4741123616695404,
0.5680849552154541,
0.3455602526664734,
-0.30878913402557373,
0.3209810256958008,
-0.5522058606147766,
-0.45182210206985474,
0.1900971680879593,
0.5832070708274841,
1.2554099559783936,
-0.2963869869709015,
0.2942523658275604,
0.2463860958814621,
0.2839965224266052,
-0.17375220358371735,
0.14359410107135773,
-0.02706865966320038,
-0.6317063570022583,
-0.7657968401908875,
-0.8181663155555725,
-0.30170878767967224,
0.5494115352630615,
-0.4046624004840851,
0.16858170926570892,
-0.560971200466156,
-0.2004721760749817,
0.1533847153186798,
-0.17165394127368927,
-0.7148902416229248,
0.47357475757598877,
0.34452661871910095,
0.524107038974762,
-0.8168966770172119,
0.7271562814712524,
0.7484330534934998,
-0.23562072217464447,
-0.822162389755249,
0.23643307387828827,
-0.02295752614736557,
-0.29171621799468994,
0.5549627542495728,
0.3252793848514557,
-0.2577725350856781,
-0.2004222571849823,
-0.2787693440914154,
-0.6670686602592468,
0.7750991582870483,
0.49313655495643616,
-0.6262914538383484,
0.046926967799663544,
0.09920364618301392,
0.834275484085083,
-0.534068763256073,
0.5726232528686523,
0.8403609991073608,
0.8330591917037964,
-0.23320388793945312,
-1.0190856456756592,
0.14197193086147308,
-0.3742789924144745,
0.14574368298053741,
0.10165050625801086,
-0.44679373502731323,
0.23200422525405884,
-0.16306014358997345,
-0.09829989075660706,
-0.034834302961826324,
0.4859427511692047,
0.17453357577323914,
0.2178477942943573,
0.7849881649017334,
0.5012296438217163,
0.7655183672904968,
-0.09806346893310547,
1.2499573230743408,
-0.10489247739315033,
0.24195976555347443,
1.1044564247131348,
-0.4515731632709503,
0.7308338284492493,
0.5938482284545898,
-0.18788327276706696,
0.48309746384620667,
0.347821980714798,
-0.24167630076408386,
0.23414543271064758,
0.4853644073009491,
-0.3315032422542572,
-0.42189761996269226,
0.0761343389749527,
0.07983728498220444,
0.6809214353561401,
0.15409713983535767,
-0.09579871594905853,
-0.39270031452178955,
-0.2475443035364151,
-0.21910251677036285,
0.3386514186859131,
-0.02030453458428383,
0.6206511855125427,
-0.03661499172449112,
-0.5979979634284973,
0.6965776681900024,
0.1796775758266449,
0.9017475247383118,
-0.7141496539115906,
0.03267192095518112,
0.2172854244709015,
0.06344084441661835,
-0.4983934462070465,
-0.644131600856781,
0.6718109250068665,
0.40859612822532654,
0.04605649784207344,
-0.3270861506462097,
0.6495686173439026,
-0.16757139563560486,
-0.6431470513343811,
0.45062750577926636,
0.5257279276847839,
0.19107097387313843,
0.20312076807022095,
-0.6747452616691589,
-0.13955548405647278,
0.2609124779701233,
-0.6168683171272278,
0.193728506565094,
0.4214175045490265,
-0.39223650097846985,
0.5020575523376465,
0.5379197001457214,
0.0004303705063648522,
-0.06021977588534355,
0.5496534109115601,
0.5977073311805725,
-0.6368215084075928,
-0.18171118199825287,
-1.0037893056869507,
0.5275460481643677,
-0.15242645144462585,
-0.38768258690834045,
0.7460736632347107,
0.5720887780189514,
0.5115248560905457,
0.09269615262746811,
1.1369637250900269,
-0.16057011485099792,
0.48181578516960144,
-0.4469800591468811,
0.627646803855896,
-0.4234277307987213,
0.5028464198112488,
-0.5556542277336121,
-1.0269492864608765,
-0.4026705324649811,
0.5339419841766357,
-0.5131357312202454,
0.16093051433563232,
0.6968169808387756,
0.24841338396072388,
-0.06386533379554749,
0.2912612557411194,
0.3498459458351135,
-0.011246374808251858,
0.4361136555671692,
0.5247433185577393,
0.93397057056427,
-0.2723982632160187,
0.5003954768180847,
-0.017100336030125618,
-0.20797167718410492,
0.34386274218559265,
-1.296539545059204,
-0.9540218114852905,
-0.4410001039505005,
-0.4311869144439697,
-0.08146243542432785,
-0.15373364090919495,
0.9072389602661133,
0.3759189546108246,
-0.7756009101867676,
-0.10451163351535797,
-0.15793515741825104,
-0.18042849004268646,
-0.004748491104692221,
-0.16540445387363434,
0.5937706828117371,
-0.5177558064460754,
-0.9034321904182434,
0.7999441623687744,
0.44070446491241455,
-0.2217518538236618,
-0.2156783491373062,
-0.19746367633342743,
-0.08243956416845322,
-0.1768028736114502,
0.5064764022827148,
0.038171570748090744,
-0.8806760311126709,
-0.49587053060531616,
-0.23707188665866852,
0.3443688750267029,
0.12051523476839066,
0.7244005799293518,
-0.8043240308761597,
0.45096680521965027,
0.10832186788320541,
0.881308376789093,
0.33210697770118713,
-0.1300889104604721,
0.8515369296073914,
-0.8767979145050049,
0.0008917466038838029,
0.15376728773117065,
0.5044492483139038,
0.7661904096603394,
-0.260012686252594,
0.5882099866867065,
-0.13701483607292175,
-0.5545774698257446,
-0.5066128969192505,
0.112160824239254,
-0.9922983646392822,
0.11179639399051666,
1.411678433418274,
-0.30346715450286865,
-0.05530964583158493,
-0.17566727101802826,
-0.17690813541412354,
0.3772134482860565,
-0.33184853196144104,
0.9582902193069458,
0.6468790173530579,
-0.25367045402526855,
0.3027438223361969,
-0.5580542087554932,
0.697800874710083,
0.7776488661766052,
-1.0174020528793335,
0.11882942914962769,
0.5465519428253174,
0.42835021018981934,
0.4134503901004791,
0.5171272158622742,
-0.22298692166805267,
-0.05651949346065521,
-0.29886719584465027,
0.228888601064682,
-0.058143455535173416,
-0.05181893706321716,
-0.5314856767654419,
0.1619970202445984,
0.30025020241737366,
-0.005277722608298063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18364v1 | Research on Information Extraction of LCSTS Dataset Based on an Improved BERTSum-LSTM Model | 2024-06-26T14:04:15 | 2024-06-26T14:04:15 | Yiming Chen, Haobin Chen, Simin Liu, Yunyun Liu, Fanhao Zhou, Bing Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the continuous advancement of artificial intelligence, natural language
processing technology has become widely utilized in various fields. At the same
time, there are many challenges in creating Chinese news summaries. First of
all, the semantics of Chinese news is complex, and the amount of information is
enormous. Extracting critical information from Chinese news presents a
significant challenge. Second, the news summary should be concise and clear,
focusing on the main content and avoiding redundancy. In addition, the
particularity of the Chinese language, such as polysemy, word segmentation,
etc., makes it challenging to generate Chinese news summaries. Based on the
above, this paper studies the information extraction method of the LCSTS
dataset based on an improved BERTSum-LSTM model. We improve the BERTSum-LSTM
model to make it perform better in generating Chinese news summaries. The
experimental results show that the proposed method has a good effect on
creating news summaries, which is of great importance to the construction of
news summaries. | [
-0.28884226083755493,
-0.6929100155830383,
0.2217199206352234,
-0.22764049470424652,
-0.7089471220970154,
-0.011494454927742481,
-0.7132818102836609,
-0.5577033162117004,
0.10577116906642914,
0.4689715802669525,
-0.571221649646759,
-0.3978343904018402,
-0.5053775310516357,
0.03210144490003586,
-0.5383549928665161,
1.2295066118240356,
0.12062737345695496,
0.11186877638101578,
0.38182854652404785,
0.1690189093351364,
-0.20579983294010162,
-0.5717878341674805,
-0.5374980568885803,
0.12580016255378723,
0.3370785713195801,
0.29484131932258606,
0.5087494850158691,
0.4588647484779358,
0.8292625546455383,
0.2481265664100647,
-0.5664730668067932,
0.46923699975013733,
-0.48355990648269653,
-0.1910814642906189,
0.15024051070213318,
-0.23081593215465546,
-0.25476208329200745,
-0.17186743021011353,
0.766727864742279,
0.40356171131134033,
0.12812325358390808,
0.11609045416116714,
0.20640577375888824,
0.7930068373680115,
-0.045251164585351944,
-0.0866721123456955,
-0.6915163993835449,
0.06791553646326065,
-0.12391041964292526,
-0.20705100893974304,
-0.45408934354782104,
-0.9113965630531311,
0.5676683187484741,
-0.30558180809020996,
0.43529778718948364,
-0.3181910216808319,
1.3329193592071533,
-0.20902957022190094,
-0.2649586498737335,
-0.3918774425983429,
-0.6554548740386963,
0.876075029373169,
-1.2718311548233032,
0.29755309224128723,
-0.25773248076438904,
0.2457084059715271,
-0.1185980886220932,
-0.6384530663490295,
-0.22707659006118774,
-0.34130585193634033,
-0.1455918848514557,
0.09561091661453247,
0.341795951128006,
-0.17993846535682678,
0.07529433071613312,
0.3518216907978058,
-0.4925174117088318,
-0.15202338993549347,
-0.6021116375923157,
-0.17176184058189392,
0.6849242448806763,
0.09126118570566177,
0.22597630321979523,
-0.7352984547615051,
-0.5269463062286377,
-0.029826274141669273,
-0.6327471137046814,
-0.005762483924627304,
-0.050794124603271484,
0.6984817981719971,
-0.03264009207487106,
0.4506053030490875,
-0.19402815401554108,
0.5113937854766846,
-0.13093572854995728,
-0.34970977902412415,
0.32756030559539795,
-0.555539608001709,
-0.24781273305416107,
0.3073587119579315,
0.38133278489112854,
0.5122418999671936,
0.4347366392612457,
0.029357334598898888,
-0.13878987729549408,
-0.5636647939682007,
-0.0902264267206192,
-0.6583710312843323,
-0.19152133166790009,
0.35795271396636963,
-0.9264113306999207,
-0.2698770761489868,
0.5287994146347046,
-0.5345543622970581,
-0.1455966979265213,
-0.6022379994392395,
0.1252223700284958,
-0.7192929983139038,
-0.4607754647731781,
-0.24334003031253815,
-0.27345946431159973,
0.280357301235199,
0.7026521563529968,
-0.3396510183811188,
0.056352365761995316,
0.47679054737091064,
0.8875764608383179,
-0.5432962775230408,
0.2110944241285324,
-0.1728108525276184,
0.05510897561907768,
-0.09822409600019455,
0.6853189468383789,
0.1395231932401657,
0.04310914874076843,
-0.05637425556778908,
0.10786178708076477,
0.18561731278896332,
-0.48655134439468384,
0.562143087387085,
-0.5758878588676453,
0.30363738536834717,
-0.46617087721824646,
-0.8408597111701965,
-0.3225997984409332,
0.470046728849411,
-0.7933036088943481,
0.9331610202789307,
-0.13304327428340912,
-1.0075548887252808,
0.1351994425058365,
-0.4897143244743347,
-0.4565776586532593,
-0.09572691470384598,
0.035897765308618546,
-0.6873207092285156,
0.03484724462032318,
0.4790012240409851,
0.36757394671440125,
0.1370246708393097,
0.526408314704895,
0.09618490189313889,
-0.2676411271095276,
0.2188853621482849,
-0.28883421421051025,
0.9381211996078491,
0.4363703429698944,
-0.0013444570358842611,
-0.12007506191730499,
-0.5545570850372314,
0.06299398094415665,
0.3084174692630768,
-0.7344042062759399,
-0.25347134470939636,
0.35565245151519775,
-0.1093062087893486,
0.07384613901376724,
0.5352339744567871,
-0.4391707181930542,
0.04528673738241196,
-0.5128029584884644,
0.0619543083012104,
0.8910736441612244,
0.34642866253852844,
0.2866000533103943,
-0.4768437445163727,
-0.22056089341640472,
0.09836123138666153,
0.26403436064720154,
-0.24001143872737885,
-0.07695897668600082,
-0.8642736077308655,
-0.09493138641119003,
0.6872643828392029,
0.472478449344635,
-0.7689658403396606,
0.4932095408439636,
-0.1941557079553604,
-0.41920703649520874,
-0.11285331100225449,
0.017198218032717705,
-0.04071906954050064,
0.45401638746261597,
0.12547490000724792,
0.03753938525915146,
-1.1079015731811523,
-0.685093343257904,
-0.22526013851165771,
0.22823387384414673,
0.10546291619539261,
0.05786033347249031,
0.09060566872358322,
0.39925462007522583,
1.228804588317871,
-0.5614078044891357,
-0.020183509215712547,
-0.7401661276817322,
0.18721680343151093,
0.8959524631500244,
0.26497912406921387,
0.6282470226287842,
-0.9788546562194824,
-0.3619275391101837,
-0.084589384496212,
-0.604496955871582,
0.002705577528104186,
-0.25097212195396423,
0.021867206320166588,
0.23150140047073364,
0.20205344259738922,
-0.42815184593200684,
0.3982701301574707,
0.06101319193840027,
0.2580263912677765,
0.8525907397270203,
-0.04293939471244812,
0.01894323341548443,
-1.2113851308822632,
0.014956302009522915,
-0.049087606370449066,
-0.44741201400756836,
-0.7123799324035645,
-0.0033258514013141394,
0.18236732482910156,
0.069228395819664,
-0.6391610503196716,
0.17833751440048218,
-0.5930096507072449,
-0.14235256612300873,
-0.3921661972999573,
0.7195313572883606,
-0.18408773839473724,
0.48176684975624084,
0.3407280147075653,
0.3546921908855438,
0.12989570200443268,
-0.9514886140823364,
0.5707070231437683,
-0.1408456563949585,
-0.5270100831985474,
-0.12844470143318176,
-0.41423067450523376,
-0.14038312435150146,
-0.3616538941860199,
0.14767953753471375,
-0.8218454122543335,
0.10868557542562485,
0.019631175324320793,
-0.40202417969703674,
-0.0004557108331937343,
0.38813161849975586,
-0.7695061564445496,
-0.5133259296417236,
-0.6119310855865479,
-0.18525336682796478,
0.4817074239253998,
-0.5410206913948059,
0.32567068934440613,
0.2246434986591339,
-0.6528990864753723,
-0.250151664018631,
-0.43379753828048706,
-0.04151424020528793,
-0.20232440531253815,
-0.5736334919929504,
0.17090067267417908,
-0.19415834546089172,
-0.21448712050914764,
0.07655017822980881,
-0.032133232802152634,
-0.08278968185186386,
-0.005761134438216686,
-0.4701789319515228,
0.5682991743087769,
-0.4003925621509552,
0.5095754265785217,
-0.03531855344772339,
0.036426689475774765,
-0.2490524798631668,
0.12926186621189117,
0.49597522616386414,
-0.02703116275370121,
-0.025579802691936493,
-0.6369920372962952,
0.26142144203186035,
-0.19031330943107605,
-0.12668947875499725,
0.2382047325372696,
0.6506484150886536,
-0.40184178948402405,
-0.04183172062039375,
-0.4056580066680908,
-0.3479636311531067,
-0.3617878556251526,
0.6797462105751038,
0.22402112185955048,
-0.498616099357605,
0.2894596755504608,
-0.20501193404197693,
0.48715728521347046,
0.77637779712677,
0.4328995943069458,
-0.20203912258148193,
1.0609408617019653,
0.5303379893302917,
-0.45506709814071655,
0.7079626321792603,
-0.039147742092609406,
-0.23887574672698975,
-0.5454463362693787,
0.01828625425696373,
-0.6116225123405457,
-0.2460976094007492,
-0.1368345022201538,
0.09251768887042999,
0.4706403315067291,
-0.15616269409656525,
-0.15540295839309692,
0.27368149161338806,
-0.6792822480201721,
0.17131052911281586,
0.6009702682495117,
0.5536802411079407,
0.5660333633422852,
0.20440299808979034,
0.08869735896587372,
-0.1483108550310135,
-0.5311501026153564,
-0.31685400009155273,
0.6753448843955994,
0.447756826877594,
0.7854487895965576,
0.3331863284111023,
0.5072091221809387,
0.5013236999511719,
0.15341132879257202,
-0.37076878547668457,
0.4149920642375946,
-0.6265990138053894,
-0.3875685930252075,
-0.21675394475460052,
-0.4267171621322632,
-0.6006380319595337,
0.14279724657535553,
-0.13283485174179077,
-0.6722360253334045,
-0.09396130591630936,
-0.29336312413215637,
-0.48141974210739136,
0.3015403151512146,
-0.620315670967102,
-0.14681708812713623,
-0.5018720626831055,
0.22769148647785187,
0.06776890158653259,
-0.7806134223937988,
0.4966098964214325,
-0.02137519232928753,
0.5073678493499756,
-0.15873846411705017,
0.31414034962654114,
0.90816330909729,
-0.8552888631820679,
0.9965417385101318,
-0.23076723515987396,
-0.3183155655860901,
0.48138105869293213,
-0.2143433839082718,
0.8667467832565308,
-0.032270364463329315,
-0.21086688339710236,
0.013723179697990417,
-0.23903682827949524,
-0.05284584313631058,
-0.1963385045528412,
0.3076959252357483,
-0.798628032207489,
-0.45764797925949097,
-0.20915625989437103,
-0.7339179515838623,
0.19593866169452667,
0.3088032007217407,
0.3484233021736145,
0.36821720004081726,
-0.06937984377145767,
0.1279633343219757,
0.6732781529426575,
-0.12266208976507187,
0.8743180632591248,
0.4899747669696808,
-0.15531131625175476,
-0.46895116567611694,
0.6890391707420349,
0.23865188658237457,
0.35064494609832764,
0.42649635672569275,
0.3051619231700897,
-0.03529803082346916,
-0.32933008670806885,
-0.29353365302085876,
0.11498495936393738,
-0.5033396482467651,
-0.4294598400592804,
-0.3500218093395233,
-1.123382568359375,
-0.49937352538108826,
0.07878712564706802,
-0.20979438722133636,
-0.6482090353965759,
-0.38883140683174133,
-0.05006718263030052,
0.2804039716720581,
0.6238254904747009,
-0.08469635248184204,
0.4654519259929657,
-1.120043396949768,
0.44438013434410095,
0.031781118363142014,
-0.16084131598472595,
0.064721018075943,
-0.6147397756576538,
-0.5704122185707092,
0.2756239175796509,
-0.27907368540763855,
-0.8195244073867798,
0.45625048875808716,
0.07250213623046875,
0.7006683349609375,
0.5880606770515442,
0.20701824128627777,
0.6244828701019287,
-0.17096179723739624,
0.9778597354888916,
0.13164018094539642,
-0.8197187781333923,
0.6120067238807678,
-0.14821040630340576,
0.33271870017051697,
0.23189416527748108,
-0.16490915417671204,
-0.3964070677757263,
-0.5649167895317078,
-0.6066024899482727,
-0.6827660799026489,
1.02601957321167,
0.47743916511535645,
-0.17337512969970703,
0.24155309796333313,
0.26499009132385254,
0.23681876063346863,
0.09984690696001053,
-1.1599695682525635,
-0.04068245366215706,
-0.012125683948397636,
-0.33823275566101074,
0.30171599984169006,
-0.4119783043861389,
0.22995878756046295,
-0.14651697874069214,
0.866135835647583,
0.27949070930480957,
0.12918975949287415,
0.5147751569747925,
-0.30702492594718933,
0.07134713232517242,
0.11906068027019501,
0.710568368434906,
0.3253699839115143,
-0.5189400911331177,
0.17357341945171356,
0.4465923607349396,
-0.3840874433517456,
-0.5257251262664795,
0.05142628401517868,
-0.2250395566225052,
0.49880513548851013,
0.5619802474975586,
0.4606758952140808,
-0.10926461964845657,
-0.8152012228965759,
0.5668221712112427,
-0.019206097349524498,
-0.18706075847148895,
-0.6268835663795471,
0.145237997174263,
-0.13647137582302094,
0.3151576519012451,
0.7193145751953125,
-0.20134732127189636,
0.13868507742881775,
-0.16311363875865936,
0.4458242654800415,
0.19735559821128845,
-0.2687610983848572,
0.05843089148402214,
0.09645948559045792,
0.10449277609586716,
0.00744867417961359,
0.6443482637405396,
0.16937682032585144,
-0.6629961133003235,
1.0505586862564087,
0.46160581707954407,
0.3950333595275879,
-0.3159739673137665,
0.15662653744220734,
0.5869108438491821,
0.5230222940444946,
-0.12384167313575745,
0.3514137268066406,
-0.15866611897945404,
-0.6550112962722778,
-0.38457053899765015,
-0.2623385488986969,
-0.21868932247161865,
0.03377124294638634,
-0.4421834647655487,
0.6043859720230103,
-0.16247132420539856,
0.1019192710518837,
-0.16773474216461182,
0.3020186722278595,
-0.20728184282779694,
0.5523576140403748,
0.2261962890625,
1.1932969093322754,
-0.3625262975692749,
0.7143461108207703,
0.16872762143611908,
-0.19941268861293793,
-0.7464317083358765,
-0.0708204060792923,
-0.10793858766555786,
-0.657694399356842,
0.5354544520378113,
0.19329893589019775,
0.41319161653518677,
-0.31061702966690063,
-0.773413360118866,
-0.9793840050697327,
1.1328153610229492,
0.11137088388204575,
-0.7845326662063599,
-0.2631217837333679,
0.2064538151025772,
0.321921169757843,
-0.5144744515419006,
0.12610742449760437,
0.18871749937534332,
0.7409340143203735,
0.2424810379743576,
-0.585325300693512,
0.026225240901112556,
-0.18147113919258118,
-0.16847120225429535,
0.1368027776479721,
-0.7487919926643372,
1.4052807092666626,
-0.4298217296600342,
-0.2882426679134369,
0.33087316155433655,
0.6701638698577881,
0.19861815869808197,
0.054266978055238724,
0.6574013829231262,
0.06918256729841232,
0.7652741074562073,
-0.03540873900055885,
0.6810041069984436,
0.04325005039572716,
0.7184778451919556,
1.3712265491485596,
-0.09556056559085846,
0.6419385075569153,
0.12275370210409164,
0.021618345752358437,
0.587432324886322,
0.9029554724693298,
-0.20233462750911713,
0.6499455571174622,
0.1340942680835724,
0.01085454411804676,
-0.11530514061450958,
0.022844886407256126,
-0.6395398378372192,
0.30605223774909973,
0.423112154006958,
-0.7788832783699036,
-0.8760198950767517,
-0.19064956903457642,
0.26589614152908325,
-0.42016923427581787,
-0.34221556782722473,
1.0971136093139648,
0.11599471420049667,
-0.32337433099746704,
0.38986825942993164,
0.2329866737127304,
0.3924534022808075,
-0.6237698197364807,
0.07328895479440689,
-0.05677860602736473,
-0.059573132544755936,
-0.2274657040834427,
-0.5126559138298035,
0.1785527467727661,
0.09874789416790009,
-0.06493429094552994,
0.36676812171936035,
1.1596406698226929,
-0.45125433802604675,
-0.611129105091095,
0.0010428469395264983,
0.4779350459575653,
0.29260361194610596,
-0.021574273705482483,
-0.6520806550979614,
-0.05327101796865463,
0.4014623165130615,
-0.43031081557273865,
-0.1926107257604599,
0.4884878695011139,
0.023280562832951546,
0.03407794237136841,
0.7901381254196167,
0.3770887553691864,
-0.09047631174325943,
0.23430003225803375,
1.001499056816101,
-1.0085283517837524,
-0.5848813056945801,
-0.9986701011657715,
0.46283477544784546,
-0.8315268754959106,
0.01709015481173992,
0.6032513976097107,
0.6905843019485474,
0.1403523087501526,
0.12359268218278885,
1.122753620147705,
-0.23480097949504852,
1.0929043292999268,
-0.6806405186653137,
0.6760734915733337,
-0.4129403531551361,
0.40423518419265747,
-0.4287482500076294,
-0.6482795476913452,
-0.23131193220615387,
0.20470912754535675,
0.009165490977466106,
0.16387636959552765,
0.5742517709732056,
0.3416272699832916,
0.16746573150157928,
0.4821069538593292,
-0.05992014706134796,
0.5740205645561218,
0.21259862184524536,
0.7269070148468018,
0.7120264768600464,
-0.26306861639022827,
0.6641980409622192,
-0.4253372251987457,
-0.27378466725349426,
-0.4751594364643097,
-1.0900650024414062,
-0.8752800226211548,
-0.45794007182121277,
0.06982582062482834,
-0.08930569887161255,
0.1243758574128151,
0.7763301134109497,
0.5780118107795715,
-0.8860204219818115,
-0.03437551110982895,
0.04588661715388298,
0.4419878423213959,
-0.25114813446998596,
-0.3561163544654846,
0.9647110104560852,
-0.5452798008918762,
-0.7254156470298767,
-0.0426754355430603,
-0.0020404893439263105,
0.10692426562309265,
0.06618334352970123,
0.053551629185676575,
-0.37033674120903015,
0.05637300759553909,
0.6463183164596558,
-0.06288482993841171,
-0.4192352592945099,
-0.5391258597373962,
0.04760707914829254,
-0.2104588747024536,
0.2270231544971466,
0.6763320565223694,
-0.5433737635612488,
0.1316678673028946,
0.47515028715133667,
0.432881236076355,
0.2645876705646515,
0.35111868381500244,
0.4281480014324188,
-0.9059759378433228,
0.08923348039388657,
-0.1020028218626976,
0.3075711131095886,
0.1334688663482666,
-0.6831506490707397,
0.37709999084472656,
0.20774580538272858,
-0.35694029927253723,
-0.5789874196052551,
-0.11202524602413177,
-1.1570448875427246,
-0.5639090538024902,
1.1423615217208862,
0.05249243974685669,
-0.4014590382575989,
-0.10405348241329193,
-0.6289966106414795,
0.6021316051483154,
-0.5741615295410156,
0.7459808588027954,
0.5687714219093323,
-0.14686162769794464,
-0.3840428292751312,
-0.20093415677547455,
0.25390374660491943,
0.2237505316734314,
-0.8295767903327942,
0.025440556928515434,
0.16082733869552612,
0.27005288004875183,
0.12823517620563507,
0.3417665958404541,
-0.29586148262023926,
0.30638444423675537,
-0.5270760655403137,
0.2503108084201813,
-0.01881472021341324,
0.02142266556620598,
0.3190046548843384,
0.23933832347393036,
-0.26456350088119507,
-0.1930098682641983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18340v1 | Grammar Assistance Using Syntactic Structures (GAUSS) | 2024-06-26T13:35:10 | 2024-06-26T13:35:10 | Olga Zamaraeva, Lorena S. Allegue, Carlos Gómez-Rodríguez, Anastasiia Ogneva, Margarita Alonso-Ramos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic grammar coaching serves an important purpose of advising on
standard grammar varieties while not imposing social pressures or reinforcing
established social roles. Such systems already exist but most of them are for
English and few of them offer meaningful feedback. Furthermore, they typically
rely completely on neural methods and require huge computational resources
which most of the world cannot afford. We propose a grammar coaching system for
Spanish that relies on (i) a rich linguistic formalism capable of giving
informative feedback; and (ii) a faster parsing algorithm which makes using
this formalism practical in a real-world application. The approach is feasible
for any language for which there is a computerized grammar and is less reliant
on expensive and environmentally costly neural methods. We seek to contribute
to Greener AI and to address global education challenges by raising the
standards of inclusivity and engagement in grammar coaching. | [
0.09309589862823486,
-1.0689212083816528,
0.4993226230144501,
1.005690574645996,
0.04493394121527672,
0.2196628898382187,
-0.2019084244966507,
-0.5255852937698364,
0.4657973349094391,
-0.2523072063922882,
-0.6852602362632751,
-0.37765637040138245,
-0.5231137275695801,
0.10919327288866043,
-0.25982606410980225,
0.6964412331581116,
0.25968098640441895,
0.5026966333389282,
-0.29609909653663635,
0.35622674226760864,
-0.2668040990829468,
-0.5648078322410583,
-1.0041841268539429,
-0.03691597655415535,
0.3364114761352539,
0.7507874965667725,
0.8744776248931885,
0.6523525714874268,
0.546521782875061,
0.5005279183387756,
-0.18758752942085266,
0.07927237451076508,
-0.06856930255889893,
0.5023158192634583,
-0.3129090368747711,
-0.6192463040351868,
-0.5343551635742188,
-0.24781490862369537,
0.5027417540550232,
1.0165185928344727,
-0.2682584822177887,
0.27522993087768555,
0.120167575776577,
0.5278830528259277,
-0.34498077630996704,
0.7669771313667297,
-0.27507156133651733,
0.45875513553619385,
-0.12251845747232437,
-0.23564772307872772,
-0.19840148091316223,
-0.5237639546394348,
-0.12031861394643784,
-0.6176577806472778,
0.24875231087207794,
-0.02449881285429001,
0.7569714784622192,
0.05247325077652931,
0.14604270458221436,
-0.4741648733615875,
-0.8646852374076843,
0.7152612209320068,
-0.5562784671783447,
0.20585733652114868,
0.5239015221595764,
0.5496126413345337,
-0.27004149556159973,
-0.6611385941505432,
-0.3914896845817566,
-0.246505469083786,
-0.054686058312654495,
0.10936577618122101,
-0.2546016573905945,
0.38151100277900696,
0.03176923096179962,
0.4942721724510193,
-0.3657532036304474,
-0.14744292199611664,
-0.42203423380851746,
-0.10729898512363434,
0.43942978978157043,
0.10802919417619705,
0.5683152675628662,
0.12106497585773468,
0.15635710954666138,
-0.02521648071706295,
-0.3333571255207062,
0.4671463668346405,
0.721278727054596,
0.47620439529418945,
0.004154955502599478,
0.2518447935581207,
-0.48164430260658264,
0.66173255443573,
-0.01891317032277584,
-0.20254211127758026,
0.044549766927957535,
-0.22750434279441833,
-0.4488584101200104,
-0.112884022295475,
0.6129056811332703,
0.12940339744091034,
0.32318606972694397,
-0.4253087639808655,
0.0283882524818182,
0.5411660671234131,
0.12336517870426178,
-0.5332229733467102,
-0.35431385040283203,
-0.14410783350467682,
-0.22800876200199127,
-0.5669677257537842,
0.39189180731773376,
-1.0663554668426514,
0.08731605112552643,
-0.30181804299354553,
0.10110724717378616,
-0.23634588718414307,
0.13683277368545532,
0.24324803054332733,
-0.22116176784038544,
0.12994618713855743,
0.37836599349975586,
-1.249517798423767,
0.7016327977180481,
0.39043301343917847,
0.9822328090667725,
0.49122440814971924,
-0.226196750998497,
-0.5843855738639832,
-0.05284465476870537,
-0.17637960612773895,
1.0191912651062012,
-0.7917812466621399,
-0.46209701895713806,
0.15943467617034912,
0.27315860986709595,
-0.09796612709760666,
-0.30925223231315613,
0.6413648724555969,
-0.040663186460733414,
0.5282931923866272,
-0.3031819462776184,
-0.2508475184440613,
-0.33408939838409424,
0.02413703314960003,
-0.46398428082466125,
1.2015539407730103,
0.1304253190755844,
0.04778361693024635,
0.27473771572113037,
-0.4819229543209076,
-0.7838778495788574,
0.26152151823043823,
-0.1949027180671692,
-0.30313634872436523,
0.18998850882053375,
0.4300609230995178,
0.5983892679214478,
-0.08766454458236694,
0.4672904908657074,
-0.402406245470047,
-0.28829413652420044,
-0.4882529079914093,
-0.03001408465206623,
0.9534282088279724,
0.012153186835348606,
-0.7124786376953125,
0.289889931678772,
-0.8468409180641174,
0.2824018597602844,
0.16035789251327515,
-0.19793927669525146,
-0.2012162059545517,
0.10296007990837097,
-0.13248629868030548,
0.3408665060997009,
-0.1027979701757431,
-0.4699135720729828,
0.16963152587413788,
-0.539423406124115,
0.49369049072265625,
0.760127604007721,
-0.026393933221697807,
0.577890932559967,
-0.2827584445476532,
1.1078070402145386,
-0.7225080728530884,
0.1911153793334961,
-0.10920486599206924,
-0.5287392139434814,
-0.9124122858047485,
-0.4378156065940857,
0.024806002154946327,
0.7054294943809509,
-0.3689992129802704,
0.625730574131012,
0.012557130306959152,
-0.3020568788051605,
-0.4335329234600067,
0.3322199285030365,
0.4930463433265686,
0.41811567544937134,
0.31663841009140015,
0.10090998560190201,
-0.9756971597671509,
-0.7519605755805969,
-0.10457625240087509,
0.06809815764427185,
0.2616935074329376,
0.0894584059715271,
0.3947201371192932,
0.36039045453071594,
0.7011556625366211,
-0.1507030576467514,
-0.5900989770889282,
-0.39304929971694946,
-0.30420583486557007,
0.01664496585726738,
0.4103032052516937,
0.6443598866462708,
-0.2938786447048187,
-0.6673479676246643,
-0.0032772342674434185,
-0.8406093120574951,
-0.2541891038417816,
0.11450259387493134,
-0.18165288865566254,
0.06120999529957771,
0.8846282362937927,
-0.34780266880989075,
0.30781880021095276,
0.6889835000038147,
-0.6959635615348816,
0.2770462930202484,
-0.32063060998916626,
-0.03473331779241562,
-0.6239144802093506,
0.07071318477392197,
-0.11283086985349655,
-0.45855557918548584,
-0.4957926273345947,
0.06347668915987015,
0.00017964138532988727,
-0.19454139471054077,
-0.33414527773857117,
0.49523094296455383,
-0.4736301302909851,
0.19417278468608856,
-0.017418354749679565,
-0.15768660604953766,
0.08477810025215149,
0.6162262558937073,
-0.17090249061584473,
0.6213927865028381,
0.5981493592262268,
-0.586479663848877,
0.5309130549430847,
0.1443803608417511,
-0.13821765780448914,
0.49668222665786743,
-0.8306857943534851,
-0.13882237672805786,
-0.35434022545814514,
0.2434890866279602,
-0.8984286189079285,
-0.2904462218284607,
0.41173872351646423,
-0.3023111820220947,
0.17215882241725922,
0.026883292943239212,
-0.4212370216846466,
-0.380519837141037,
-0.35465332865715027,
0.1384287178516388,
0.3788614869117737,
-0.6121957898139954,
0.4015257656574249,
0.509069561958313,
-0.5889825224876404,
-0.35854044556617737,
-0.632443368434906,
0.15418778359889984,
-0.017519669607281685,
-0.9981377124786377,
0.33191004395484924,
0.22843757271766663,
-0.5466435551643372,
0.29292184114456177,
-0.20486405491828918,
0.038691259920597076,
0.23769626021385193,
0.2781783640384674,
0.10744273662567139,
-0.301022469997406,
0.18588607013225555,
0.28841981291770935,
-0.051372069865465164,
0.1462336778640747,
-0.4008147716522217,
0.4514124393463135,
-0.4819534718990326,
-0.1611747145652771,
-0.6251105666160583,
0.5590250492095947,
0.48365041613578796,
-0.3017320930957794,
0.5586153268814087,
0.07730226218700409,
-0.347474604845047,
-0.7754921317100525,
-0.27590060234069824,
0.08164072036743164,
-0.4877212941646576,
0.32772427797317505,
-0.18345580995082855,
-0.8003124594688416,
0.47518232464790344,
0.37561652064323425,
-0.17783792316913605,
0.18959344923496246,
0.6158435940742493,
-0.1558639407157898,
1.0327476263046265,
0.8631521463394165,
-0.07760260999202728,
0.6958722472190857,
-0.1488049179315567,
0.29060089588165283,
-0.07048973441123962,
-0.6826317310333252,
-0.8721325993537903,
-0.4716220796108246,
0.042240437120199203,
-0.1207188218832016,
-0.15353447198867798,
0.08754356950521469,
0.13793836534023285,
0.16616089642047882,
-0.5628713369369507,
0.7648882269859314,
0.8354644179344177,
-0.09784288704395294,
0.2814725935459137,
-0.0439327172935009,
-0.24888719618320465,
0.03683513402938843,
-0.8419039845466614,
-0.5893973112106323,
0.5375644564628601,
0.1990857720375061,
0.7263476252555847,
0.20868152379989624,
0.5236779451370239,
0.25670310854911804,
-0.001334631466306746,
-1.1380999088287354,
0.8014635443687439,
-0.0958123430609703,
-0.3292364776134491,
-0.2998300790786743,
-0.07288187742233276,
-0.8405743837356567,
0.6107775568962097,
-0.2298215627670288,
-0.5147538185119629,
0.3165423572063446,
0.3015357553958893,
-0.7074312567710876,
-0.0007424321956932545,
-1.104803442955017,
0.9277624487876892,
-0.02460208721458912,
-0.48237475752830505,
0.03071056678891182,
-0.6196733713150024,
0.07265796512365341,
0.6504501700401306,
0.2286914736032486,
-0.19826801121234894,
0.12671388685703278,
0.49716129899024963,
-0.7300412654876709,
0.9735007286071777,
-0.5159038305282593,
0.11178140342235565,
0.16594554483890533,
0.16933530569076538,
0.3515698313713074,
0.09719068557024002,
0.15842024981975555,
-0.23952747881412506,
-0.04525899514555931,
-0.43516355752944946,
-0.8697733879089355,
0.5764129757881165,
-0.4392932057380676,
-0.4629420042037964,
-0.636389970779419,
-0.6695950627326965,
-0.4783035218715668,
0.13392911851406097,
-0.01688515394926071,
0.1445164680480957,
-0.3194049596786499,
0.22181589901447296,
0.261674702167511,
0.1317135989665985,
0.5831847190856934,
0.20567123591899872,
-0.2712497115135193,
-0.35505586862564087,
0.7691342234611511,
0.12424091249704361,
-0.04786302149295807,
0.18241967260837555,
0.22558698058128357,
-0.13018622994422913,
-0.4412814974784851,
-0.20712988078594208,
0.18312758207321167,
-0.6993503570556641,
-0.19176726043224335,
-0.612580418586731,
0.2084738165140152,
-0.7244434952735901,
-0.5263116955757141,
0.02082393690943718,
-0.853011429309845,
0.08945827931165695,
-0.5632463097572327,
-0.01778978295624256,
0.7015165686607361,
-0.06366994976997375,
0.43527793884277344,
-0.5616216659545898,
0.10129525512456894,
0.29679128527641296,
0.3384818732738495,
-0.09270665049552917,
-0.09614844620227814,
-0.16181910037994385,
-0.23819412291049957,
-0.1334126889705658,
-0.8940303325653076,
0.366527259349823,
0.5736966133117676,
0.6232641935348511,
0.4004400372505188,
-0.5005792379379272,
1.0120915174484253,
-0.5627231001853943,
0.48228392004966736,
-0.2772406041622162,
-1.1149356365203857,
0.6581529378890991,
-0.32677584886550903,
0.13005958497524261,
0.7258583307266235,
0.15172426402568817,
-0.632855236530304,
-0.7472905516624451,
-0.719428539276123,
-0.8764564394950867,
0.9424009323120117,
-0.06581519544124603,
0.2383899986743927,
-0.37064895033836365,
0.15385186672210693,
-0.11144942790269852,
0.19408120214939117,
-0.7013407945632935,
-0.006803818512707949,
-0.17195196449756622,
-0.4373117685317993,
0.0857931524515152,
-0.1581922322511673,
-0.0331532284617424,
-0.5898295044898987,
1.1278560161590576,
-0.01815035566687584,
0.053538545966148376,
0.3239342272281647,
-0.2456672638654709,
-0.22865746915340424,
0.22449511289596558,
0.6682658791542053,
0.3199467062950134,
0.0912972092628479,
0.21728067100048065,
-0.14946813881397247,
-0.4190298914909363,
0.3614615499973297,
0.07848646491765976,
-0.26290377974510193,
0.20186050236225128,
0.2860725224018097,
0.5562437176704407,
0.531658947467804,
-0.5135350227355957,
0.45254719257354736,
0.0454767644405365,
-0.49016138911247253,
-0.199722021818161,
0.2503608167171478,
0.06769315898418427,
0.23051635921001434,
-0.20737357437610626,
0.19253596663475037,
-0.05326969921588898,
-0.6932519674301147,
0.00617806613445282,
0.6007460951805115,
-0.16410964727401733,
-0.45627281069755554,
0.4972102642059326,
0.3889729976654053,
-0.5297038555145264,
0.23565329611301422,
-0.41390976309776306,
-0.4227299690246582,
0.6595670580863953,
0.8291274309158325,
0.7334068417549133,
-0.4723539352416992,
0.5712388753890991,
0.30624276399612427,
0.20849870145320892,
-0.538855254650116,
0.4947827160358429,
-0.1877634972333908,
-0.4152671992778778,
-0.42667773365974426,
-0.7238270044326782,
-0.4504072368144989,
-0.07225895673036575,
-0.5634559392929077,
0.29439619183540344,
-0.9721227884292603,
0.11626318842172623,
-0.11082980036735535,
-0.20972315967082977,
-0.3422290086746216,
0.026168376207351685,
0.04795590043067932,
0.6883277893066406,
-1.0168460607528687,
0.6755788922309875,
0.9967266321182251,
-0.563880205154419,
-0.8322904109954834,
-0.4745975732803345,
0.22704407572746277,
-0.8062252998352051,
0.6774734854698181,
0.14480361342430115,
-0.5943307876586914,
0.0429559201002121,
-0.43874117732048035,
-0.7271355390548706,
0.8976507186889648,
0.680042028427124,
-0.27526238560676575,
-0.6634129881858826,
-0.027239544317126274,
0.715474009513855,
-0.134506493806839,
-0.02096712589263916,
0.35264575481414795,
0.48338693380355835,
-0.1445540189743042,
-0.6101096868515015,
0.04897085577249527,
-0.7285177707672119,
0.09335337579250336,
0.14704272150993347,
-0.5393362641334534,
0.8242033123970032,
-0.04555615037679672,
-0.480188250541687,
0.17964394390583038,
0.7201210260391235,
-0.2805401682853699,
-0.08140262961387634,
0.18951696157455444,
0.5573635697364807,
1.1281144618988037,
-0.08924603462219238,
0.9598200917243958,
-0.39347636699676514,
0.3070276379585266,
1.0668423175811768,
0.11861331760883331,
0.3134196400642395,
0.5647520422935486,
-0.30751705169677734,
0.6356608867645264,
0.15467655658721924,
-0.23914305865764618,
0.40525057911872864,
0.22934241592884064,
-0.4310592710971832,
-0.10167039185762405,
0.026791514828801155,
-0.2351498305797577,
0.34806567430496216,
0.312653511762619,
-0.4402409493923187,
-0.596306324005127,
-0.007649162318557501,
0.2987237274646759,
0.5738062858581543,
-0.39983895421028137,
0.5066114068031311,
-0.013714369386434555,
-0.8264737725257874,
-0.02135920710861683,
0.14374534785747528,
0.5049701929092407,
-0.8461093306541443,
-0.20755083858966827,
-0.2953997850418091,
0.42434459924697876,
-0.6252296566963196,
-0.1538545787334442,
0.5214171409606934,
0.026266513392329216,
-0.09497945755720139,
-0.6101101636886597,
0.5345213413238525,
-0.5260951519012451,
-0.7617937326431274,
0.2458241879940033,
0.7736303806304932,
-0.28792721033096313,
-0.025706427171826363,
-0.4104829728603363,
-0.2997951805591583,
-0.2726333439350128,
0.0013825090136379004,
0.11061012744903564,
0.4490906894207001,
-0.12039787322282791,
0.5696958303451538,
0.6494063138961792,
0.41072317957878113,
0.3661976456642151,
0.10442648828029633,
0.4893365502357483,
-0.7056281566619873,
-1.0640079975128174,
-1.0150526762008667,
0.3204089105129242,
-0.025790264829993248,
-0.2466726303100586,
1.1748603582382202,
0.3428495228290558,
0.9088900685310364,
-0.08285236358642578,
0.8354151844978333,
-0.2829766869544983,
0.14482800662517548,
-0.45187798142433167,
0.5204758644104004,
-0.1692972034215927,
-0.029600245878100395,
-0.3492235839366913,
-0.8932165503501892,
-1.0274808406829834,
1.2179020643234253,
-0.25229376554489136,
-0.14206549525260925,
0.8965678215026855,
0.7972249984741211,
0.06503461301326752,
0.3119916021823883,
0.20507462322711945,
-0.14668576419353485,
0.5123462080955505,
0.25508639216423035,
0.7782455682754517,
0.11550258845090866,
0.5575831532478333,
-0.6981690526008606,
-0.3390969932079315,
-0.10203646123409271,
-0.6918390989303589,
-0.8548179864883423,
-0.26843687891960144,
-0.048139989376068115,
-0.3399609625339508,
0.42492419481277466,
1.1371887922286987,
0.552386462688446,
-0.7517558336257935,
-0.3420763909816742,
-0.6004695892333984,
-0.014794760383665562,
-0.48092028498649597,
-0.26602011919021606,
0.32686668634414673,
-1.1500664949417114,
-0.9395240545272827,
0.7018565535545349,
0.528114378452301,
-0.1662783920764923,
-0.1761910617351532,
0.188140407204628,
-0.14899006485939026,
-0.08434983342885971,
0.641145646572113,
0.6931827068328857,
-0.39462921023368835,
-0.28857186436653137,
0.346848726272583,
-0.10856593400239944,
0.2742062211036682,
0.838865339756012,
-0.6189186573028564,
0.41480785608291626,
0.5691993236541748,
0.7169360518455505,
0.010818357579410076,
-0.06581489741802216,
0.6361910700798035,
-0.7029247879981995,
0.5531661510467529,
0.5784791707992554,
0.5906442403793335,
0.16211794316768646,
-0.3609482944011688,
0.420670747756958,
0.4923788607120514,
-0.35541048645973206,
-0.6760541200637817,
0.03127170726656914,
-0.7643308043479919,
0.030967041850090027,
1.1308374404907227,
-0.14400336146354675,
-0.4220070242881775,
-0.2764172852039337,
-0.41522932052612305,
-0.015182367525994778,
-0.5007249712944031,
0.6974876523017883,
0.959104597568512,
-0.3171163499355316,
0.17894236743450165,
-0.3769533634185791,
0.582362711429596,
0.7492116093635559,
-1.0318853855133057,
-0.21664312481880188,
0.6346163153648376,
0.07382098585367203,
-0.07400812208652496,
0.9517238736152649,
-0.25222527980804443,
0.4265313446521759,
0.09135408699512482,
0.14531485736370087,
-0.408794105052948,
-0.6939691305160522,
-0.6090542078018188,
0.5006152987480164,
-0.06447618454694748,
-0.16291473805904388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18326v1 | PaCoST: Paired Confidence Significance Testing for Benchmark Contamination Detection in Large Language Models | 2024-06-26T13:12:40 | 2024-06-26T13:12:40 | Huixuan Zhang, Yun Lin, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are known to be trained on vast amounts of data,
which may unintentionally or intentionally include data from commonly used
benchmarks. This inclusion can lead to cheatingly high scores on model
leaderboards, yet result in disappointing performance in real-world
applications. To address this benchmark contamination problem, we first propose
a set of requirements that practical contamination detection methods should
follow. Following these proposed requirements, we introduce PaCoST, a Paired
Confidence Significance Testing to effectively detect benchmark contamination
in LLMs. Our method constructs a counterpart for each piece of data with the
same distribution, and performs statistical analysis of the corresponding
confidence to test whether the model is significantly more confident under the
original benchmark. We validate the effectiveness of PaCoST and apply it on
popular open-source models and benchmarks. We find that almost all models and
benchmarks we tested are suspected contaminated more or less. We finally call
for new LLM evaluation methods. | [
-0.31685587763786316,
-0.8299916386604309,
0.7461192011833191,
0.325391948223114,
-0.46114662289619446,
-0.08402165025472641,
-0.20983698964118958,
-0.6926745772361755,
0.002178050111979246,
0.9282630681991577,
-0.11405054479837418,
-0.673842191696167,
-0.87393718957901,
0.06353364884853363,
-0.6579362750053406,
0.5193262696266174,
-0.22139732539653778,
-0.005381993483752012,
-0.43493565917015076,
-0.017756065353751183,
-0.4244423508644104,
-0.462176650762558,
-0.38132867217063904,
-0.24647782742977142,
0.11497028917074203,
0.5256951451301575,
0.5810328722000122,
0.6449706554412842,
0.8498464822769165,
0.3034263551235199,
-0.13602644205093384,
0.3214239478111267,
-0.4308829605579376,
0.39705976843833923,
0.029248397797346115,
-0.372753769159317,
-0.3453024625778198,
0.09129198640584946,
0.7455752491950989,
0.774871826171875,
-0.07014458626508713,
0.18869030475616455,
0.042174775153398514,
0.18080754578113556,
-0.8410625457763672,
0.19607451558113098,
-0.7698783278465271,
-0.2604081332683563,
-0.26969367265701294,
-0.35231518745422363,
-0.5767638087272644,
-0.4251473844051361,
-0.26969829201698303,
-0.551156222820282,
0.13065288960933685,
0.31761008501052856,
0.5561054944992065,
0.49705302715301514,
-0.3828919529914856,
-0.06635557115077972,
-0.44898077845573425,
1.0383780002593994,
-0.7962335348129272,
0.37873855233192444,
0.581531822681427,
0.21081648766994476,
-0.4880937337875366,
-0.7436224818229675,
-0.6728014349937439,
-0.36508435010910034,
-0.022311968728899956,
-0.23382258415222168,
-0.04976348578929901,
-0.07540693879127502,
0.20957116782665253,
0.44971734285354614,
-0.5506914854049683,
0.1523585468530655,
0.13266690075397491,
-0.34483659267425537,
0.6187358498573303,
-0.16768252849578857,
0.4287095069885254,
0.08495447039604187,
-0.7253320217132568,
-0.3538338541984558,
-0.9817742705345154,
-0.23991145193576813,
0.35196760296821594,
0.3741176426410675,
0.19882972538471222,
0.5315133929252625,
-0.26005256175994873,
0.6048268675804138,
-0.4004337191581726,
-0.24794356524944305,
-0.0008048767340369523,
-0.3741714358329773,
-0.23931743204593658,
0.2564007639884949,
0.8039702773094177,
0.2964479923248291,
0.2642526626586914,
-0.05237743631005287,
-0.3549279570579529,
0.14608365297317505,
0.007245383225381374,
-0.8630753755569458,
-0.209828183054924,
0.400014191865921,
-0.18412144482135773,
-0.4689507782459259,
0.00551588973030448,
-0.672899067401886,
-0.6039754748344421,
-0.11857398599386215,
0.5488359332084656,
-0.15651020407676697,
-0.36378514766693115,
0.3528663218021393,
-0.031076941639184952,
0.15469905734062195,
0.2328493744134903,
-0.7838083505630493,
0.5920877456665039,
1.4612939357757568,
0.5399340391159058,
-0.45478004217147827,
-0.44484516978263855,
-0.9958261847496033,
-0.2515128254890442,
-0.3864591717720032,
0.9380793571472168,
-0.6816206574440002,
-0.5521649718284607,
0.05613474175333977,
-0.13595569133758545,
0.21082575619220734,
-0.8402951955795288,
0.8194806575775146,
-0.4033595323562622,
-0.1082533672451973,
-0.3755738139152527,
-0.8572840690612793,
0.15495562553405762,
0.315545916557312,
-0.6502985954284668,
1.5531628131866455,
-0.06301688402891159,
-1.0350537300109863,
0.25404927134513855,
0.04674011096358299,
-0.45262476801872253,
0.17653639614582062,
-0.1607474982738495,
-0.5659813284873962,
-0.12024958431720734,
0.02306199260056019,
0.33182016015052795,
-0.43204623460769653,
0.35602614283561707,
-0.5768821239471436,
-0.5945982336997986,
0.41470715403556824,
-0.1959071010351181,
0.8712027668952942,
-0.02601907216012478,
-0.3593934178352356,
0.060666460543870926,
-0.7422410249710083,
0.16217513382434845,
-0.015463380143046379,
-0.03191005438566208,
-0.7695134282112122,
-0.07553213834762573,
-0.030143314972519875,
0.018034469336271286,
0.1834503710269928,
-0.5516970157623291,
0.10478877276182175,
0.09806060045957565,
0.06088538095355034,
0.7578651309013367,
0.35892993211746216,
-0.07675406336784363,
-0.47456324100494385,
0.33522289991378784,
-0.22726990282535553,
0.1987910121679306,
-0.020220080390572548,
-0.8534213304519653,
-0.623744785785675,
-0.36468711495399475,
0.2526736557483673,
0.458965539932251,
-0.4389384388923645,
0.7768668532371521,
-0.0990077331662178,
-0.445584237575531,
-0.5572583675384521,
0.365172803401947,
0.44847139716148376,
0.6897351145744324,
0.27494069933891296,
-0.5899019837379456,
-0.4853271245956421,
-0.6570229530334473,
-0.32861366868019104,
-0.26128947734832764,
-0.05554550141096115,
0.15517352521419525,
0.7400074005126953,
-0.2542552947998047,
0.8068438768386841,
-0.5835970044136047,
0.011438783258199692,
0.2160952240228653,
0.2515736222267151,
-0.0381660982966423,
0.513157308101654,
0.3496491312980652,
-0.7918964624404907,
-0.3703778386116028,
-0.2423580139875412,
-0.5190058946609497,
-0.5126398801803589,
0.2757607102394104,
-0.1593022346496582,
-0.27939146757125854,
0.7321605086326599,
-0.44170403480529785,
0.04372787103056908,
0.9251613616943359,
-0.21586889028549194,
0.7683374285697937,
-0.14051371812820435,
0.2855537533760071,
-0.8501948714256287,
0.23465217649936676,
-0.0652133896946907,
-0.34050458669662476,
-0.7195206880569458,
0.24222294986248016,
0.14623941481113434,
0.12468262761831284,
-0.47023460268974304,
0.6429380774497986,
-0.15506035089492798,
-0.3153311312198639,
-0.34540197253227234,
0.3996032476425171,
0.2793385982513428,
-0.12437184154987335,
0.08979377150535583,
0.8739676475524902,
0.42265281081199646,
-0.31570371985435486,
0.38632506132125854,
0.3435569107532501,
-0.6410307884216309,
0.5642604827880859,
-0.7532891035079956,
0.12026416510343552,
0.5150696039199829,
0.206900492310524,
-1.4951449632644653,
-0.18887239694595337,
0.08733424544334412,
-0.33229580521583557,
0.14029620587825775,
-0.0996243879199028,
-0.9155054092407227,
-0.032612450420856476,
-0.38421088457107544,
0.47383496165275574,
0.35357314348220825,
-0.9196836948394775,
-0.03502526134252548,
0.5783138275146484,
-0.22297020256519318,
-0.6386522650718689,
-0.6319601535797119,
-0.22593362629413605,
-0.2037714272737503,
-0.6438722610473633,
0.05427905172109604,
-0.24202190339565277,
-0.6397824287414551,
-0.051522623747587204,
-0.3438345491886139,
-0.3232835531234741,
0.49496740102767944,
0.31340616941452026,
0.45300722122192383,
-0.13757337629795074,
0.11700546741485596,
-0.1773916780948639,
-0.12812069058418274,
0.12744863331317902,
0.09566669911146164,
0.6112948656082153,
-0.09423912316560745,
-0.5660068988800049,
-0.340759813785553,
0.08268899470567703,
0.6158665418624878,
-0.5065560340881348,
0.6330104470252991,
0.43310511112213135,
-0.42855337262153625,
-0.3428853452205658,
-0.7101389169692993,
-0.23542849719524384,
-0.4979872703552246,
-0.02051399275660515,
-0.07665593177080154,
-0.6451942324638367,
0.5764141082763672,
-0.3592504560947418,
-0.2281697690486908,
0.2642125189304352,
0.45399346947669983,
0.12071320414543152,
0.7054877281188965,
0.6213554739952087,
-0.2166903167963028,
0.35133805871009827,
0.1523905247449875,
0.052069298923015594,
-0.7981168031692505,
-0.14857260882854462,
-0.8206031322479248,
0.07647143304347992,
-0.6332316398620605,
-0.7329275012016296,
0.17472779750823975,
-0.11151429265737534,
-0.12135188281536102,
0.2386535108089447,
-0.3185209333896637,
0.7749655246734619,
0.5761961340904236,
-0.13648398220539093,
0.8660944104194641,
-0.41394248604774475,
-0.21039117872714996,
0.10403000563383102,
-0.08246379345655441,
-0.41552674770355225,
1.1168931722640991,
0.16092391312122345,
0.7624738216400146,
-0.09319430589675903,
0.9401955008506775,
0.28331148624420166,
0.42773380875587463,
-0.5777849555015564,
0.5851369500160217,
0.005921614822000265,
-0.5642935633659363,
-0.279599130153656,
-0.5619232654571533,
-0.8520441651344299,
0.3218156397342682,
-0.26411956548690796,
-0.5627060532569885,
0.14943575859069824,
-0.1822982281446457,
-0.1190115362405777,
0.1883918195962906,
-0.5324432253837585,
0.9526191353797913,
-0.34968048334121704,
-0.34868472814559937,
0.1275281310081482,
-0.603865385055542,
0.7129495143890381,
-0.3303593099117279,
0.21157893538475037,
-0.33564847707748413,
-0.24362416565418243,
0.6188485622406006,
-0.44666290283203125,
0.7203830480575562,
0.2621438205242157,
-0.3351205289363861,
0.2140992134809494,
0.3165108859539032,
0.7540609836578369,
-0.0014340566704049706,
-0.20385462045669556,
0.22920162975788116,
0.03478158637881279,
-0.33601078391075134,
-0.133764386177063,
0.8999545574188232,
-0.6514204740524292,
-0.3277629315853119,
-0.5864784717559814,
-0.631976842880249,
-0.3425776958465576,
0.5466203093528748,
0.17343612015247345,
-0.017581474035978317,
-0.1144738420844078,
0.3525494337081909,
0.8676889538764954,
-0.1088346466422081,
0.11859872192144394,
0.5780150890350342,
-0.28815069794654846,
-0.12191011011600494,
0.4749164581298828,
-0.3278356194496155,
0.5487887859344482,
0.3351728916168213,
0.37170377373695374,
-0.13786959648132324,
-0.7579293847084045,
0.14195087552070618,
0.363057404756546,
-0.6614792346954346,
-0.19247061014175415,
-0.2098778337240219,
-0.0030106089543551207,
-0.4521154463291168,
0.048100247979164124,
-0.5854485630989075,
-0.09353756904602051,
-0.05539107322692871,
0.06359878182411194,
0.2911471724510193,
0.664421021938324,
0.1125909835100174,
0.3876093327999115,
-0.7022693157196045,
0.3023945987224579,
0.30450204014778137,
0.5898521542549133,
-0.3551138639450073,
-0.42718949913978577,
0.36925846338272095,
-0.25371667742729187,
-0.003222924657166004,
-0.7931600213050842,
0.45294585824012756,
-0.007311440072953701,
0.7231695652008057,
0.5070228576660156,
0.33285120129585266,
0.35052043199539185,
-0.34321048855781555,
0.5408564209938049,
-0.12778571248054504,
-1.0638556480407715,
0.5237535238265991,
-0.36741524934768677,
-0.17688877880573273,
0.7607153058052063,
0.5455175638198853,
-0.6492729187011719,
-0.5757286548614502,
-0.7951797246932983,
-0.6135430335998535,
0.3380134403705597,
0.10833189636468887,
-0.4371086061000824,
0.04636504873633385,
0.22870057821273804,
0.19854404032230377,
0.25634434819221497,
-0.4028266966342926,
-0.11954155564308167,
0.37952330708503723,
0.06334183365106583,
-0.41975072026252747,
-0.32796698808670044,
-0.3754281997680664,
0.12949010729789734,
0.6106148362159729,
0.08567894250154495,
-0.2140892595052719,
0.027931084856390953,
-0.14050443470478058,
-0.3346646726131439,
0.2776781916618347,
0.38927504420280457,
0.5452015995979309,
-0.5011153817176819,
0.5116100311279297,
-0.005081833340227604,
-0.4620165228843689,
0.03220396488904953,
0.1420566588640213,
-0.06190049275755882,
0.046132322400808334,
0.5142738819122314,
0.13909702003002167,
0.6641784906387329,
-0.9448534846305847,
0.7464324831962585,
-0.06083644554018974,
0.16571126878261566,
-0.06664828211069107,
0.013227568008005619,
0.15305373072624207,
-0.033330850303173065,
0.15604262053966522,
-0.15620632469654083,
0.22434133291244507,
-0.8577210903167725,
0.6788586974143982,
0.3591866195201874,
-0.008870151825249195,
0.007992058992385864,
0.38686996698379517,
0.06188647076487541,
-0.11428084969520569,
0.3607535660266876,
-0.306080162525177,
-0.6066121459007263,
0.7924355864524841,
0.5474703907966614,
0.5014996528625488,
-0.4393249452114105,
0.01431973371654749,
0.1649288386106491,
0.47581765055656433,
-0.6702103614807129,
0.2722303569316864,
0.11627839505672455,
-0.7289879322052002,
-0.441416472196579,
-0.620699405670166,
-0.9986962676048279,
0.2041960209608078,
-0.753495454788208,
0.30732908844947815,
-0.32583504915237427,
0.11996583640575409,
0.08918723464012146,
0.2804082930088043,
-0.17639710009098053,
-0.04012589529156685,
0.13938575983047485,
0.9684184789657593,
-1.4302352666854858,
0.8456652164459229,
0.1305082142353058,
-0.1624613255262375,
-0.6429070234298706,
0.1689462810754776,
0.18318364024162292,
-1.0347932577133179,
0.4582839012145996,
0.2727101743221283,
-0.03849554434418678,
-0.2805226147174835,
-0.49967992305755615,
-0.7685551047325134,
1.0025757551193237,
0.46761325001716614,
-0.4252149760723114,
0.5837321877479553,
0.1643783152103424,
0.5088744163513184,
-0.20840628445148468,
0.04498492553830147,
0.8547624349594116,
0.5745036005973816,
0.23131413757801056,
-0.9103035926818848,
0.35261937975883484,
-0.03942764922976494,
-0.24576252698898315,
0.44291162490844727,
-0.6842716932296753,
0.9284486770629883,
0.010618004016578197,
-0.03351560980081558,
0.342329204082489,
0.11614805459976196,
0.6132413744926453,
0.4944285452365875,
0.5760675668716431,
0.6709293127059937,
1.2208839654922485,
-0.25802385807037354,
1.1594990491867065,
-0.29898905754089355,
0.6478129029273987,
1.4635792970657349,
-0.732271134853363,
1.3747246265411377,
0.46276023983955383,
-0.2108021378517151,
0.22129592299461365,
0.6471233367919922,
-0.10017934441566467,
0.4083375036716461,
0.1954450011253357,
-0.4100070297718048,
-0.4760802388191223,
-0.3496488332748413,
-0.5595795512199402,
0.4513257145881653,
0.3282212018966675,
-0.16081567108631134,
-0.2682807147502899,
-0.29187262058258057,
0.20884846150875092,
0.1250373125076294,
-0.03526975214481354,
0.39991551637649536,
0.07751784473657608,
-0.9536100625991821,
0.4862235486507416,
-0.3528997004032135,
0.3929227590560913,
-0.46545276045799255,
-0.08761311322450638,
-0.3122362494468689,
0.41141581535339355,
-0.19661052525043488,
-0.7992322444915771,
0.1097792237997055,
-0.13853827118873596,
0.45856600999832153,
-0.16167595982551575,
0.938609778881073,
-0.5816994905471802,
-0.28787046670913696,
0.5543031692504883,
0.457318514585495,
0.20543710887432098,
-0.4316687285900116,
-0.3467600643634796,
0.5696950554847717,
-0.45036426186561584,
0.04343300312757492,
0.33887743949890137,
0.24074749648571014,
0.08521702140569687,
0.6587119102478027,
0.919988751411438,
0.304899126291275,
0.07949144393205643,
0.012399074621498585,
0.7852329015731812,
-0.20757238566875458,
-0.22155727446079254,
-0.778363049030304,
0.04363799840211868,
-0.08152220398187637,
-0.03200078010559082,
0.9277619123458862,
0.6696524024009705,
0.6284311413764954,
0.28699803352355957,
0.5408933758735657,
0.3681359589099884,
0.3105888068675995,
-0.38928914070129395,
0.4950929284095764,
-0.3605298101902008,
0.6138161420822144,
-0.2438279688358307,
-0.8711362481117249,
-0.5934464931488037,
0.3352837860584259,
-0.34687674045562744,
-0.21793606877326965,
0.9013568758964539,
0.7689569592475891,
-0.13727621734142303,
0.13413654267787933,
0.3247874081134796,
0.30556046962738037,
0.3671545386314392,
0.469577819108963,
0.8461846709251404,
-0.36665889620780945,
0.5533397793769836,
-0.5598840117454529,
-0.5401198863983154,
-0.579014003276825,
-1.225098967552185,
-0.8095162510871887,
-0.3515879213809967,
-0.413344144821167,
-0.4113064706325531,
0.06888949126005173,
0.5568919777870178,
0.5687679648399353,
-0.9530802965164185,
-0.17255818843841553,
-0.015974948182702065,
0.2850933372974396,
-0.38574591279029846,
-0.1520162671804428,
0.3741745948791504,
-0.3452398180961609,
-0.648206889629364,
0.4651135504245758,
0.06930685043334961,
0.009177718311548233,
-0.16821008920669556,
0.10468628257513046,
-0.23535087704658508,
0.033761247992515564,
0.35724616050720215,
0.40982335805892944,
-0.5104290246963501,
-0.5675395727157593,
0.0003389325283933431,
-0.2841786742210388,
0.004199673421680927,
0.7768468260765076,
-0.3146977722644806,
0.726150631904602,
0.8069887161254883,
0.7181987166404724,
0.3455759584903717,
0.08366532623767853,
0.2812979519367218,
-0.9963932037353516,
0.19289472699165344,
0.21544164419174194,
0.6665458083152771,
0.393309086561203,
-0.33039724826812744,
0.6553326845169067,
0.31508901715278625,
-0.7120046019554138,
-1.3112366199493408,
0.06324433535337448,
-1.54071843624115,
-0.15895283222198486,
1.4441503286361694,
-0.3501841723918915,
-0.15787115693092346,
-0.04395373538136482,
0.08346456289291382,
0.09101120382547379,
-0.12449891120195389,
0.8939928412437439,
0.9024210572242737,
0.046138834208250046,
0.22083152830600739,
-0.6949684023857117,
0.2571030259132385,
0.3390458822250366,
-1.1210960149765015,
0.3351336419582367,
0.2103840559720993,
0.6001459956169128,
0.3131577968597412,
0.5045281648635864,
-0.22213467955589294,
0.3959270715713501,
0.16992734372615814,
0.044691991060972214,
-0.04278017207980156,
-0.20703263580799103,
-0.3289448320865631,
0.04110819473862648,
0.2566068768501282,
-0.194483682513237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18321v1 | MathOdyssey: Benchmarking Mathematical Problem-Solving Skills in Large Language Models Using Odyssey Math Data | 2024-06-26T13:02:35 | 2024-06-26T13:02:35 | Meng Fang, Xiangpeng Wan, Fei Lu, Fei Xing, Kai Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced natural language
understanding and demonstrated strong problem-solving abilities. Despite these
successes, most LLMs still struggle with solving mathematical problems due to
the intricate reasoning required. This paper investigates the mathematical
problem-solving capabilities of LLMs using the newly developed "MathOdyssey"
dataset. The dataset includes diverse mathematical problems at high school and
university levels, created by experts from notable institutions to rigorously
test LLMs in advanced problem-solving scenarios and cover a wider range of
subject areas. By providing the MathOdyssey dataset as a resource to the AI
community, we aim to contribute to the understanding and improvement of AI
capabilities in complex mathematical problem-solving. We conduct benchmarking
on open-source models, such as Llama-3 and DBRX-Instruct, and closed-source
models from the GPT series and Gemini models. Our results indicate that while
LLMs perform well on routine and moderately difficult tasks, they face
significant challenges with Olympiad-level problems and complex
university-level questions. Our analysis shows a narrowing performance gap
between open-source and closed-source models, yet substantial challenges
remain, particularly with the most demanding problems. This study highlights
the ongoing need for research to enhance the mathematical reasoning of LLMs.
The dataset, results, and code are publicly available. | [
-0.23271560668945312,
-0.7361271977424622,
0.7752028107643127,
0.13086330890655518,
0.1369970738887787,
0.18720610439777374,
-0.3630308508872986,
-0.33213576674461365,
-0.0839822068810463,
0.4470975697040558,
-0.7631776928901672,
-0.5433369874954224,
-0.5938183069229126,
0.32897278666496277,
-0.09499337524175644,
0.6950305104255676,
-0.4471530020236969,
0.300478994846344,
-0.7186901569366455,
-0.23953695595264435,
-0.5128794312477112,
-0.47841328382492065,
-0.4602433741092682,
-0.17835630476474762,
0.40900132060050964,
0.31771644949913025,
0.5772889852523804,
0.5564343929290771,
0.989470899105072,
0.28559714555740356,
-0.158874973654747,
0.07106373459100723,
-0.5694496035575867,
0.39963093400001526,
-0.2516230642795563,
-0.7398534417152405,
-0.5013143420219421,
-0.006164394319057465,
0.5920482873916626,
0.9978216886520386,
-0.31974512338638306,
0.33941057324409485,
-0.14562906324863434,
0.6946783065795898,
-0.6059190034866333,
0.4640355110168457,
-0.621224045753479,
-0.07178787142038345,
-0.5368460416793823,
0.40290480852127075,
-0.03155342862010002,
-0.5528463125228882,
-0.10261422395706177,
-0.931444525718689,
-0.026813751086592674,
0.0019235949730500579,
0.2387634962797165,
0.34562626481056213,
-0.18896012008190155,
-0.5140173435211182,
-0.612291157245636,
1.016587734222412,
-0.8077338337898254,
0.3138272762298584,
0.5149437189102173,
0.3406587541103363,
-0.36496707797050476,
-0.3952259421348572,
-0.42389917373657227,
-0.2917582094669342,
0.3270479142665863,
-0.02190062217414379,
-0.4512781798839569,
-0.31968438625335693,
0.5433911085128784,
0.38954323530197144,
-0.775242030620575,
0.08982162177562714,
-0.5986859798431396,
-0.07846962660551071,
0.7619441151618958,
0.6576617360115051,
0.047798994928598404,
0.24848976731300354,
0.4579499363899231,
-0.17450374364852905,
-0.696570873260498,
0.04961352422833443,
0.32645100355148315,
0.10228197276592255,
-0.0010715682292357087,
1.0224502086639404,
-0.3135128617286682,
0.4527397155761719,
-0.6667203903198242,
-0.17794528603553772,
0.2957793176174164,
0.07968223839998245,
0.0557311549782753,
-0.16614723205566406,
0.4973422884941101,
-0.07623836398124695,
0.36171194911003113,
-0.01081277895718813,
-0.3554496765136719,
0.38603538274765015,
-0.23113034665584564,
-0.5552492141723633,
-0.1341806799173355,
0.1585427224636078,
-0.18073832988739014,
0.028592174872756004,
-0.39485904574394226,
-0.5458675622940063,
-0.506971001625061,
-0.5848498940467834,
0.44600939750671387,
-0.41010531783103943,
-0.2335042506456375,
0.2218293398618698,
0.14735078811645508,
-0.3087075352668762,
0.39475035667419434,
-0.4743843078613281,
0.3558717370033264,
1.0128275156021118,
0.8814728260040283,
-0.1676020473241806,
-0.3611961901187897,
-0.5934824347496033,
0.04446553438901901,
-0.5072609782218933,
0.6651755571365356,
-0.661485493183136,
-0.10799618065357208,
-0.03537822887301445,
-0.39873552322387695,
-0.019466130062937737,
-0.9104886651039124,
0.5764974355697632,
-0.1477687507867813,
0.017493147403001785,
-0.16403844952583313,
-0.8522026538848877,
0.13082489371299744,
0.30574190616607666,
-0.6487568616867065,
0.9249008893966675,
-0.07811562716960907,
-0.5280058979988098,
-0.22892577946186066,
-0.698889434337616,
-0.09290414303541183,
0.10315579175949097,
-0.3022148609161377,
-0.44352877140045166,
0.4355090856552124,
0.26822009682655334,
0.3125849962234497,
-0.5826261639595032,
0.1882365643978119,
-0.5623237490653992,
-0.1508079171180725,
0.4396499991416931,
-0.3570236265659332,
0.6664631962776184,
0.27815720438957214,
-0.03994740545749664,
-0.1649223417043686,
-0.8609711527824402,
-0.030590428039431572,
0.4755619764328003,
-0.03886806592345238,
-0.35665178298950195,
0.09249842166900635,
-0.34448468685150146,
-0.07128430902957916,
0.3669814467430115,
-0.5111661553382874,
0.30900758504867554,
-0.15844886004924774,
0.3031729459762573,
0.7410035133361816,
-0.3745121955871582,
-0.19979386031627655,
-0.4218984842300415,
0.6844655871391296,
-0.2553788125514984,
-0.18799710273742676,
-0.21250423789024353,
-0.7817159295082092,
-0.4257321059703827,
-0.4381253123283386,
0.00711087929084897,
0.5557529926300049,
-0.5097893476486206,
0.08685342222452164,
-0.19214768707752228,
-0.6402239799499512,
-0.6250285506248474,
0.2891240417957306,
0.3670918941497803,
0.45380932092666626,
0.30876973271369934,
0.0020460309460759163,
-0.24779675900936127,
-0.7155105471611023,
-0.5646704435348511,
0.0427476204931736,
-0.24702131748199463,
0.529209554195404,
0.5653911828994751,
-0.2150297611951828,
0.7750572562217712,
-0.6690618395805359,
-0.3123317360877991,
-0.11761294305324554,
0.26928967237472534,
0.550470769405365,
0.20929761230945587,
0.09513890743255615,
-0.3392661213874817,
-0.26683980226516724,
-0.0816844254732132,
-0.9923409223556519,
-0.5508663058280945,
0.39034536480903625,
0.08679218590259552,
0.050792355090379715,
0.39168843626976013,
-0.6893151998519897,
0.5598583817481995,
0.6736565232276917,
-0.42776674032211304,
0.7743803858757019,
-0.2417069971561432,
-0.09329623728990555,
-0.8032113313674927,
0.19484615325927734,
0.0658484399318695,
0.048340581357479095,
-0.38388052582740784,
0.04506615549325943,
-0.056446682661771774,
-0.4014241695404053,
-0.07524559646844864,
0.39485615491867065,
-0.3019033372402191,
-0.3150753974914551,
0.09166761487722397,
0.17368945479393005,
-0.3433225154876709,
0.28952816128730774,
-0.06592126935720444,
0.8088929653167725,
0.6083544492721558,
-0.26645541191101074,
0.7617770433425903,
0.1510246843099594,
-0.6087454557418823,
0.5385468006134033,
-0.674720048904419,
0.12091299146413803,
-0.06697104126214981,
0.07228436321020126,
-0.8955172896385193,
-0.15347857773303986,
-0.11423294991254807,
-0.3337085247039795,
-0.2129637449979782,
-0.040217407047748566,
-0.6668789982795715,
-0.3003522753715515,
0.04399733990430832,
0.859424352645874,
0.46232959628105164,
-0.22555799782276154,
0.5469931960105896,
0.19699543714523315,
-0.5574329495429993,
-0.34491124749183655,
-0.270671546459198,
0.10900591313838959,
-0.21369698643684387,
-0.6705230474472046,
0.023905795067548752,
-0.2539086639881134,
-0.6565488576889038,
0.17174819111824036,
-0.09240171313285828,
0.04488300532102585,
0.1485806405544281,
0.0516047365963459,
0.31328248977661133,
-0.3519510328769684,
0.007650362327694893,
-0.18630480766296387,
-0.3643292486667633,
0.3438113033771515,
-0.13502368330955505,
0.5754262804985046,
-0.1213541030883789,
-0.5938392281532288,
-0.4483603537082672,
0.2690752446651459,
0.6996240615844727,
-0.5668322443962097,
0.7290640473365784,
0.09254162758588791,
-0.4763931632041931,
-0.10942508280277252,
-0.5595939755439758,
-0.046211518347263336,
-0.4202459752559662,
0.5554368495941162,
-0.40799129009246826,
-0.7594276666641235,
0.5300450921058655,
-0.08855737000703812,
0.2139221429824829,
0.28587496280670166,
0.754278838634491,
-0.06787727773189545,
1.1215018033981323,
0.09377314150333405,
-0.19394774734973907,
0.00239247246645391,
-0.2624099552631378,
0.0562799796462059,
-0.7106981873512268,
-0.2484169453382492,
-0.6524439454078674,
-0.1821901500225067,
-0.2989041805267334,
-0.48024410009384155,
0.5497474074363708,
0.11189259588718414,
-0.3459358513355255,
0.20388072729110718,
-0.1358547955751419,
0.7169908285140991,
0.33735892176628113,
-0.09066259860992432,
0.5394262075424194,
0.0253397636115551,
-0.18417888879776,
-0.30690014362335205,
-0.3022964596748352,
-0.277086079120636,
1.5084171295166016,
0.3512757122516632,
0.8307210803031921,
0.3850781321525574,
0.38539445400238037,
0.03413538262248039,
0.28029200434684753,
-0.4654480218887329,
0.5439237952232361,
-0.13965493440628052,
-0.5514537692070007,
-0.3468223214149475,
-1.0061914920806885,
-1.0292350053787231,
0.046159472316503525,
-0.23726628720760345,
-0.7743679285049438,
-0.3837929964065552,
0.04748218134045601,
0.04858430102467537,
0.3215072751045227,
-0.22316303849220276,
0.719153642654419,
-0.28072428703308105,
-0.5074908137321472,
-0.6198922991752625,
-0.10814812034368515,
0.2888891398906708,
-0.15573325753211975,
0.5383169054985046,
-0.5539675951004028,
0.000951100024394691,
0.7233954071998596,
-0.43419331312179565,
0.40231382846832275,
0.041444145143032074,
-0.3380034267902374,
-0.034792616963386536,
0.5037391185760498,
0.4890657365322113,
0.16390164196491241,
-0.10312249511480331,
0.35791340470314026,
0.007690655067563057,
-0.527646005153656,
-0.5376384854316711,
0.7174409627914429,
-0.9717740416526794,
-0.6217103600502014,
-0.43213602900505066,
-0.9038385152816772,
-0.45801007747650146,
0.16010832786560059,
-0.1171170324087143,
0.7614805102348328,
0.1574183851480484,
0.22370152175426483,
0.7635113596916199,
-0.12003342062234879,
0.20164744555950165,
0.40848270058631897,
-0.4152423143386841,
-0.517249584197998,
0.8845019936561584,
0.16723130643367767,
0.10603141039609909,
0.19144919514656067,
0.2795007526874542,
-0.24418681859970093,
-0.6557169556617737,
-0.24880370497703552,
0.5312269330024719,
-0.6289661526679993,
-0.22201798856258392,
-0.17269742488861084,
-0.043805696070194244,
-0.38973844051361084,
0.08419818431138992,
-0.4843648076057434,
-0.5868093371391296,
-0.024887830018997192,
0.36569470167160034,
0.2808862626552582,
0.8554262518882751,
0.003592452500015497,
-0.12143739312887192,
-0.6340683698654175,
0.39874783158302307,
0.376501202583313,
0.6091886758804321,
0.01204176526516676,
-0.3068641424179077,
-0.2717061936855316,
0.002335567260161042,
-0.34410133957862854,
-0.5233805775642395,
0.29512879252433777,
-0.04179748147726059,
0.6466065049171448,
0.21763744950294495,
-0.07776153832674026,
0.6846429109573364,
-0.4687168598175049,
0.46794405579566956,
0.01036829687654972,
-0.9482407569885254,
0.3508278429508209,
-0.4776134490966797,
0.22267994284629822,
0.2214091569185257,
0.35261788964271545,
-0.5270894765853882,
-0.357573002576828,
-0.24220328032970428,
-0.4266970455646515,
0.705908477306366,
0.7774512767791748,
-0.2180316001176834,
0.2971299886703491,
0.5107547640800476,
0.11913283914327621,
0.24989375472068787,
-0.40138280391693115,
-0.12136667966842651,
0.1786791980266571,
-0.5751475095748901,
-0.4331143796443939,
0.15105180442333221,
-0.15144886076450348,
-0.3041526973247528,
0.6027465462684631,
0.05130363255739212,
0.06456376612186432,
-0.1009746789932251,
-0.12176074087619781,
-0.2785998284816742,
-0.004659983795136213,
0.5968755483627319,
1.029192328453064,
-0.15111234784126282,
-0.08930355310440063,
0.1944398283958435,
-0.6298065185546875,
-0.010101834312081337,
0.34832578897476196,
0.3719257712364197,
-0.3137950003147125,
0.7079947590827942,
0.4291895627975464,
-0.12838171422481537,
-1.302525520324707,
0.38078737258911133,
-0.20533713698387146,
-0.22156168520450592,
-0.48601233959198,
0.22434170544147491,
0.18759334087371826,
0.37548530101776123,
0.5550416707992554,
-0.14105889201164246,
-0.04005814716219902,
-0.5390092730522156,
-0.24963492155075073,
0.5161835551261902,
0.213278666138649,
-0.2938584089279175,
0.6751276850700378,
-0.09548375755548477,
-0.5562776327133179,
0.8914214372634888,
0.15240132808685303,
-0.40651363134384155,
0.8011783957481384,
0.564626932144165,
0.47450247406959534,
-0.15075483918190002,
-0.2291851043701172,
0.24431666731834412,
0.10785132646560669,
-0.05223679542541504,
0.24579069018363953,
0.025596858933568,
-0.5750791430473328,
-0.49883729219436646,
-0.35063421726226807,
-0.7328071594238281,
0.2677036225795746,
-0.6593698859214783,
0.23746275901794434,
-0.42430058121681213,
0.13089635968208313,
-0.05253569036722183,
0.26578113436698914,
-0.6683059334754944,
-0.04859261214733124,
0.33275607228279114,
0.9269784688949585,
-0.6792347431182861,
0.4392363429069519,
0.7856528759002686,
0.12194271385669708,
-0.5505588054656982,
-0.1822858303785324,
0.17050114274024963,
-0.9292941689491272,
0.4628991186618805,
0.23633162677288055,
0.031495705246925354,
-0.07637973874807358,
-0.6215221285820007,
-0.9723893404006958,
1.18843674659729,
0.6293728947639465,
-0.8144218325614929,
0.06024351716041565,
0.619114100933075,
0.502284049987793,
-0.26003849506378174,
0.3314392566680908,
0.4898495674133301,
0.17285078763961792,
0.06052915006875992,
-1.0186268091201782,
-0.2335917204618454,
-0.4094773530960083,
-0.05649904906749725,
0.2788136601448059,
-0.4440496265888214,
1.1754839420318604,
0.021208150312304497,
0.25584447383880615,
0.3878419101238251,
0.5161926746368408,
0.9074728488922119,
0.8401356339454651,
0.26973584294319153,
0.9700897932052612,
0.8414472341537476,
-0.0184965617954731,
0.6569345593452454,
-0.20832253992557526,
0.48310136795043945,
0.7954825758934021,
-0.47874394059181213,
0.9088841080665588,
0.2728298008441925,
-0.3757932484149933,
0.4270535409450531,
0.25752413272857666,
0.1098124235868454,
0.2882222533226013,
0.5220381617546082,
-0.2330511212348938,
-0.42445406317710876,
0.08294836431741714,
-0.520960807800293,
0.29386571049690247,
0.5619493722915649,
0.1753864884376526,
-0.22594010829925537,
0.014555689878761768,
0.08457310497760773,
0.2130909413099289,
-0.5957557559013367,
0.6028921008110046,
0.048150211572647095,
-0.4337596297264099,
0.36436301469802856,
-0.0653735026717186,
0.22950589656829834,
-0.5820704698562622,
-0.1558932662010193,
-0.5786782503128052,
0.577002227306366,
0.006044895388185978,
-0.8150800466537476,
0.10114231705665588,
0.2739093601703644,
0.15484121441841125,
0.2347300499677658,
0.14224651455879211,
-0.23380039632320404,
-0.926502525806427,
0.061314452439546585,
0.5549286603927612,
0.30207741260528564,
-0.029520872980356216,
-0.5430980324745178,
0.32613056898117065,
-0.3379291296005249,
-0.019372254610061646,
0.2788955569267273,
0.7155889868736267,
-0.1154775395989418,
0.998818039894104,
0.789082944393158,
0.32557612657546997,
-0.000914028671104461,
-0.24284692108631134,
0.9028327465057373,
-0.5717694759368896,
-0.43523287773132324,
-0.8357378244400024,
0.2332068830728531,
0.015863358974456787,
-0.4875858426094055,
0.7000814080238342,
0.7813681364059448,
0.8752973675727844,
0.16790810227394104,
0.6641296148300171,
0.2821210026741028,
0.7285447120666504,
-0.5679219961166382,
0.373409241437912,
-0.6079361438751221,
0.5733564496040344,
-0.40119469165802,
-1.039882779121399,
-0.4264342188835144,
0.5800061225891113,
-0.5469504594802856,
-0.2009916752576828,
0.47381696105003357,
0.6021027565002441,
-0.23502898216247559,
0.10423438251018524,
0.3318266272544861,
0.33688610792160034,
0.5059304237365723,
0.9286138415336609,
1.1098917722702026,
-0.0362582728266716,
0.5737558603286743,
-0.26255086064338684,
-0.37676745653152466,
-0.061464425176382065,
-0.7279775738716125,
-1.1981120109558105,
-0.4265769124031067,
-0.21469959616661072,
-0.28134283423423767,
0.19650480151176453,
1.0942691564559937,
0.18825499713420868,
-0.7710237503051758,
-0.5405726432800293,
-0.2528549134731293,
0.022449441254138947,
-0.13591481745243073,
-0.1313253939151764,
0.38657423853874207,
-0.27998432517051697,
-0.5321192741394043,
0.2883617579936981,
0.12892033159732819,
-0.28109976649284363,
-0.34478291869163513,
-0.15494903922080994,
0.3860962986946106,
0.15400822460651398,
0.2527773976325989,
0.18418070673942566,
-0.5567954778671265,
0.2467944175004959,
0.1035403460264206,
0.16288520395755768,
-0.05466160178184509,
1.0255968570709229,
-0.6282419562339783,
0.2661616802215576,
0.26859012246131897,
0.7316704392433167,
0.36014196276664734,
-0.17196375131607056,
0.365379273891449,
-0.20423159003257751,
0.01623317040503025,
0.32708480954170227,
0.5550503134727478,
0.15793931484222412,
0.023408593609929085,
0.41174957156181335,
0.48989155888557434,
-0.6091988682746887,
-0.9937947988510132,
0.07709964364767075,
-0.42409294843673706,
-0.376233845949173,
0.888641893863678,
-0.2035212367773056,
-0.0656331330537796,
-0.04215441644191742,
-0.10644008964300156,
-0.11479748785495758,
-0.3022381663322449,
0.9744670987129211,
0.7061329483985901,
-0.2459949553012848,
-0.1944325864315033,
-0.6821177005767822,
0.12683013081550598,
0.5803106427192688,
-0.8304058909416199,
0.3053604066371918,
0.4169035851955414,
0.19184443354606628,
-0.010476866737008095,
0.2686230540275574,
-0.07302418351173401,
0.283490926027298,
-0.14872746169567108,
-0.25978371500968933,
-0.31740307807922363,
-0.34011319279670715,
-0.3734590709209442,
0.08032916486263275,
-0.04736880958080292,
0.229727640748024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18313v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.18313v2 | Advancing Airport Tower Command Recognition: Integrating Squeeze-and-Excitation and Broadcasted Residual Learning | 2024-06-26T12:54:19 | 2024-06-28T11:04:19 | Yuanxi Lin, Tonglin Zhou, Yang Xiao | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Accurate recognition of aviation commands is vital for flight safety and
efficiency, as pilots must follow air traffic control instructions precisely.
This paper addresses challenges in speech command recognition, such as noisy
environments and limited computational resources, by advancing keyword spotting
technology. We create a dataset of standardized airport tower commands,
including routine and emergency instructions. We enhance broadcasted residual
learning with squeeze-and-excitation and time-frame frequency-wise
squeeze-and-excitation techniques, resulting in our BC-SENet model. This model
focuses on crucial information with fewer parameters. Our tests on five keyword
spotting models, including BC-SENet, demonstrate superior accuracy and
efficiency. These findings highlight the effectiveness of our model
advancements in improving speech command recognition for aviation safety and
efficiency in noisy, high-stakes environments. Additionally, BC-SENet shows
comparable performance on the common Google Speech Command dataset. | [
-0.3380711078643799,
-0.5236838459968567,
0.15259289741516113,
-0.26537564396858215,
-0.3307242691516876,
0.0635242685675621,
-0.15257379412651062,
-0.17849455773830414,
0.20084978640079498,
0.2849380075931549,
-0.3592929244041443,
-0.41040268540382385,
-0.6944591403007507,
-0.4834843873977661,
-0.3943140506744385,
0.48005104064941406,
0.4086690843105316,
-0.10800943523645401,
0.2618753910064697,
-0.18188895285129547,
-0.5956262946128845,
-0.9923340082168579,
-0.8051371574401855,
0.20313510298728943,
0.3516540825366974,
0.5730233192443848,
0.6178197860717773,
0.8227468132972717,
0.5631026029586792,
0.14779740571975708,
-0.2291109263896942,
0.13194504380226135,
-0.10180351883172989,
-0.30788853764533997,
0.10042349994182587,
0.1252182424068451,
-0.22861063480377197,
-0.07837812602519989,
0.7075446248054504,
0.7944592237472534,
-0.5171478986740112,
-0.2644672095775604,
-0.13242366909980774,
0.5570717453956604,
-0.5802431702613831,
0.22111102938652039,
-0.7315359711647034,
-0.3094305694103241,
-0.03358986973762512,
-0.3218233585357666,
-0.2064613252878189,
-0.36581704020500183,
0.3587629199028015,
-0.49434301257133484,
0.39049607515335083,
-0.006273690611124039,
0.9192622303962708,
0.0049784560687839985,
-0.7336642742156982,
-0.5924869179725647,
-0.6115787625312805,
0.5825589299201965,
-0.45681750774383545,
0.7869605422019958,
0.46938246488571167,
0.3966452181339264,
-0.20305727422237396,
-0.8125290870666504,
-0.24189484119415283,
-0.3908963203430176,
0.39867469668388367,
0.23228996992111206,
-0.44553548097610474,
0.2484305202960968,
0.3204137086868286,
-0.1880742907524109,
-0.4168175756931305,
0.2773336172103882,
-0.5193461775779724,
-0.2638416290283203,
0.038156475871801376,
-0.24574917554855347,
0.005921009927988052,
-0.10702204704284668,
-0.21948419511318207,
-0.13798588514328003,
-0.8080321550369263,
0.40017467737197876,
-0.01680734008550644,
0.2797600030899048,
-0.11172740161418915,
0.015241376124322414,
-0.27733084559440613,
0.829963743686676,
-0.14710642397403717,
0.18929773569107056,
0.2246786653995514,
0.18474072217941284,
-0.4774644672870636,
0.3483244776725769,
0.20848572254180908,
0.23773165047168732,
0.20854108035564423,
-0.27577587962150574,
0.06174679100513458,
0.018021168187260628,
0.37107905745506287,
-0.6601622104644775,
-0.5482997298240662,
0.0206911638379097,
-0.3245060443878174,
-0.167232945561409,
0.2106705904006958,
-0.4582459330558777,
-0.2723425030708313,
-0.350075900554657,
0.19524787366390228,
-0.5909963250160217,
-0.4856998026371002,
0.10274641960859299,
-0.4767400324344635,
0.5015794634819031,
0.5806633234024048,
-0.6207980513572693,
0.04855184629559517,
0.6774780750274658,
0.7453198432922363,
0.2538604438304901,
0.2543819844722748,
-0.9213985800743103,
0.1651894748210907,
-0.4745434820652008,
0.5384711027145386,
-0.4770575761795044,
-0.788354754447937,
0.12050622701644897,
-0.17130005359649658,
-0.2451304793357849,
-0.8676072955131531,
1.101760745048523,
-0.6782643795013428,
-0.19475772976875305,
-0.28287580609321594,
-0.482395201921463,
-0.8202191591262817,
-0.006976631470024586,
-0.6309181451797485,
0.7272844910621643,
0.05939304828643799,
-0.1933060884475708,
0.562772274017334,
-0.22787074744701385,
-0.6935662627220154,
0.2543359696865082,
-0.274941623210907,
-0.6413221955299377,
0.5955458283424377,
0.36941927671432495,
0.33149203658103943,
0.3480165898799896,
-0.06134597584605217,
-0.38828977942466736,
-0.27565881609916687,
0.2161167562007904,
-0.4682782292366028,
0.7721032500267029,
0.2947025001049042,
-0.26064348220825195,
-0.25866302847862244,
-1.0131365060806274,
-0.01466675940901041,
-0.45298147201538086,
-0.4521389305591583,
-0.3535349369049072,
0.4078969955444336,
0.06642492860555649,
-0.015870757400989532,
-0.16754929721355438,
-0.32211926579475403,
-0.0768648013472557,
-0.31372523307800293,
0.4855479300022125,
0.39482760429382324,
0.053517598658800125,
0.16772153973579407,
-0.3146095275878906,
0.2608284056186676,
-0.01341077871620655,
-0.07724686712026596,
-0.10134649276733398,
-0.37777063250541687,
-0.4083142578601837,
-0.5393033623695374,
0.09612318128347397,
0.4903883934020996,
-0.16793377697467804,
0.6163117289543152,
-0.45812326669692993,
-0.2851235270500183,
-0.034292444586753845,
-0.2920491397380829,
-0.0225424412637949,
0.6518044471740723,
0.3308773636817932,
0.2696358859539032,
-0.756121039390564,
-0.4043256342411041,
-0.12952640652656555,
-0.2699125409126282,
0.08683737367391586,
0.4364798367023468,
0.21469035744667053,
0.23650674521923065,
0.7153100967407227,
-0.22140514850616455,
-0.3732111155986786,
-0.1461734175682068,
0.35659167170524597,
0.12288890033960342,
0.557671070098877,
0.4258774518966675,
-1.0301567316055298,
-0.16052618622779846,
0.21001656353473663,
-0.3095605969429016,
0.04508661478757858,
0.02093530260026455,
0.39681217074394226,
-0.21962952613830566,
0.7912343740463257,
-0.22697944939136505,
0.5111023783683777,
0.19397015869617462,
-0.014002526178956032,
0.26474183797836304,
0.08836326003074646,
0.17739085853099823,
-0.6778256297111511,
0.12553462386131287,
-0.5239658951759338,
-0.27312755584716797,
-0.8331935405731201,
-0.02703443542122841,
0.4155776798725128,
-0.40835413336753845,
-0.6055248379707336,
-0.028591617941856384,
-0.8082851767539978,
0.02645261399447918,
-0.5291969776153564,
0.0969667136669159,
-0.10348035395145416,
0.4432509243488312,
0.4253483712673187,
0.49162164330482483,
0.74299156665802,
-0.7989531755447388,
0.16967961192131042,
-0.03399764746427536,
-0.7275067567825317,
0.341257244348526,
-0.14970560371875763,
0.2364664375782013,
-0.10163165628910065,
0.06239285320043564,
-1.3704931735992432,
-0.316956102848053,
-0.252236008644104,
-0.7629967927932739,
0.35383936762809753,
-0.4105229377746582,
-0.29424619674682617,
-0.41649383306503296,
-0.08330024778842926,
0.29051151871681213,
0.7368684411048889,
-0.6105160117149353,
0.6494215726852417,
0.29593101143836975,
0.17971180379390717,
-0.5302577018737793,
-0.2884870767593384,
0.23536306619644165,
-0.2609957754611969,
-0.017849421128630638,
0.10866762697696686,
0.6345735788345337,
0.22278796136379242,
-0.1753513664007187,
-0.47132983803749084,
-0.40478280186653137,
0.3267643451690674,
0.6441840529441833,
0.1696464717388153,
0.1482705920934677,
0.2859259843826294,
-0.0464254729449749,
0.4358219504356384,
0.07408726960420609,
-0.47435271739959717,
0.35330498218536377,
0.08741679787635803,
-0.04033782705664635,
-0.5308700203895569,
0.2780066132545471,
0.8858159780502319,
-0.3391109108924866,
0.30058959126472473,
0.6604913473129272,
-0.7525595426559448,
0.07313745468854904,
-0.6859836578369141,
-0.22462326288223267,
-0.48445555567741394,
0.6572322249412537,
-0.3203220069408417,
-0.8183603286743164,
0.3025745749473572,
-0.4391927421092987,
0.16128139197826385,
0.09332416206598282,
0.14946620166301727,
-0.5428438782691956,
0.8367703557014465,
0.7468621730804443,
-0.39697083830833435,
0.6545761823654175,
-0.2354823499917984,
-0.04307141155004501,
-0.7086995840072632,
-0.2070106863975525,
-0.8216742873191833,
-0.21480673551559448,
-0.1788477599620819,
-0.13788311183452606,
0.8319070935249329,
0.5277068614959717,
-0.1328417956829071,
0.35517752170562744,
-0.3396969437599182,
-0.008410124108195305,
0.4592818319797516,
0.2883532643318176,
0.040336694568395615,
0.18751643598079681,
-0.15951117873191833,
0.19438467919826508,
-0.8034670948982239,
-0.09576898068189621,
0.6899011135101318,
0.2918615937232971,
0.6811534762382507,
0.07453274726867676,
0.4873543977737427,
0.32994815707206726,
0.242135688662529,
-0.7837807536125183,
0.4015621244907379,
-0.10729674994945526,
-0.77942955493927,
-0.0763850286602974,
-0.3584437668323517,
-0.8880800008773804,
-0.09364856034517288,
0.19353197515010834,
-0.6441074013710022,
0.6170292496681213,
0.35355374217033386,
-0.7239317297935486,
0.2533954977989197,
-0.7149896025657654,
0.6416816711425781,
-0.013742834329605103,
0.30351993441581726,
-0.4373261034488678,
-0.6386322379112244,
0.22239986062049866,
0.0487779900431633,
0.2748553454875946,
-0.2541015148162842,
-0.20097024738788605,
1.0383411645889282,
-0.30518123507499695,
0.8606941103935242,
-0.47260281443595886,
0.23446455597877502,
0.6103829145431519,
0.012145250104367733,
0.6989743709564209,
-0.37271836400032043,
0.02252994105219841,
0.09926024824380875,
-0.08732058852910995,
0.055942606180906296,
-0.44911953806877136,
0.5082162022590637,
-0.5894822478294373,
-0.09968367964029312,
-0.21729007363319397,
-0.32875746488571167,
-0.2483087182044983,
0.07166678458452225,
0.46971359848976135,
1.0649757385253906,
-0.18405748903751373,
0.4650130569934845,
0.5452826023101807,
-0.2636410892009735,
0.6000984907150269,
0.7702680230140686,
0.07290069013834,
-0.7017532587051392,
0.7695158123970032,
0.3130524158477783,
0.06137150153517723,
0.7819822430610657,
0.10899849236011505,
-0.7795765399932861,
-0.5882547497749329,
-0.20994889736175537,
-0.18534015119075775,
-0.5417218804359436,
-0.41258886456489563,
-0.8311336636543274,
-0.34879276156425476,
-0.5702009797096252,
-0.3505650758743286,
0.047998663038015366,
-0.6268578767776489,
-0.4423568844795227,
-0.3413369655609131,
0.2728159725666046,
0.17154879868030548,
-0.31650790572166443,
1.145062804222107,
-0.7246865034103394,
0.2116928994655609,
0.12859897315502167,
0.01692289672791958,
-0.034791089594364166,
-0.7369711995124817,
-0.5547516345977783,
-0.06875044852495193,
-0.3080618977546692,
-1.1358445882797241,
0.3598134517669678,
0.5074512958526611,
0.5560247302055359,
0.6610633730888367,
0.14872224628925323,
0.4614591598510742,
-0.4022911787033081,
0.5279244780540466,
0.33222439885139465,
-0.7911350131034851,
0.43627193570137024,
-0.34799766540527344,
0.24343807995319366,
0.5391679406166077,
0.21856079995632172,
-0.5402131080627441,
-0.19919563829898834,
-0.5337175130844116,
-0.48513343930244446,
0.5796390771865845,
-0.10109476000070572,
-0.02366534061729908,
-0.14856812357902527,
0.2657213509082794,
-0.4202999174594879,
0.46582308411598206,
-0.31126949191093445,
0.09324944019317627,
-0.3074047267436981,
-0.11519835144281387,
0.20820777118206024,
-0.12314095348119736,
0.09118831902742386,
-0.21230252087116241,
0.4143202006816864,
0.2480573058128357,
0.38961881399154663,
0.1355563998222351,
-0.0499904491007328,
-0.09044906497001648,
0.2523956596851349,
0.5865428447723389,
0.2127770632505417,
-0.671312153339386,
0.2895123362541199,
0.3414791226387024,
-0.6209096908569336,
0.13394875824451447,
0.07619830965995789,
0.08037149906158447,
0.275127112865448,
0.35172542929649353,
0.6166924834251404,
0.07482624799013138,
-0.517564594745636,
0.6334267854690552,
0.4246068000793457,
-0.23079702258110046,
-0.3308899700641632,
0.02894289419054985,
-0.07560009509325027,
-0.16353031992912292,
0.6083140969276428,
0.2633911073207855,
0.40148115158081055,
-0.2799767553806305,
0.6937825083732605,
0.6662272810935974,
-0.6287122368812561,
-0.033336807042360306,
0.7613433599472046,
0.30134981870651245,
-0.2401743233203888,
0.7314378023147583,
-0.05439269170165062,
-0.9314379692077637,
0.9571750164031982,
0.02815912291407585,
1.1531885862350464,
-0.4178662598133087,
-0.13324779272079468,
0.4267708957195282,
0.47294098138809204,
0.0933515876531601,
0.4317395091056824,
-0.5454297661781311,
-0.5510784387588501,
-0.2829815447330475,
-0.23472535610198975,
-0.45038217306137085,
0.29071998596191406,
-0.8281747698783875,
0.466559499502182,
-0.9027519226074219,
-0.5228714346885681,
-0.19836801290512085,
-0.0162983275949955,
-0.5931740999221802,
0.3231680691242218,
0.12814545631408691,
1.2697012424468994,
-0.35152578353881836,
0.8900773525238037,
0.7190467715263367,
0.1435265690088272,
-1.1014719009399414,
0.0024679587222635746,
-0.026208991184830666,
-0.8992666602134705,
0.7845154404640198,
0.5775378942489624,
-0.14812137186527252,
0.4063042402267456,
-0.5166259407997131,
-0.6123174428939819,
0.7106590867042542,
-0.2413698434829712,
-0.8479482531547546,
0.05580888316035271,
-0.19096685945987701,
0.07090986520051956,
0.051895398646593094,
0.2572895288467407,
0.48306283354759216,
0.1842247098684311,
0.0744747743010521,
-0.9300253987312317,
-0.4108593463897705,
0.2970908284187317,
-0.3604518473148346,
0.13169991970062256,
-0.5334703326225281,
0.28501465916633606,
-0.2628225088119507,
-0.5815411806106567,
0.059805989265441895,
0.9901871681213379,
-0.12768122553825378,
0.32511818408966064,
0.717238187789917,
0.6676248908042908,
0.6389252543449402,
-0.20041921734809875,
0.6552116274833679,
-0.16010376811027527,
0.14389756321907043,
1.1000291109085083,
-0.32740625739097595,
0.9954447150230408,
0.12808161973953247,
-0.02596203051507473,
0.37729960680007935,
0.4698447585105896,
0.10440269112586975,
0.970800518989563,
0.15623457729816437,
-0.5017006993293762,
-0.08691178262233734,
-0.06800098717212677,
-0.3166124224662781,
0.5050058364868164,
0.6829995512962341,
-0.1312825083732605,
-0.6482619047164917,
0.527498185634613,
0.019111767411231995,
-0.22357720136642456,
-0.4657634496688843,
0.7370153069496155,
0.058064304292201996,
-0.5805409550666809,
0.8724454045295715,
0.16605979204177856,
0.33856844902038574,
-0.6922763586044312,
-0.10945018380880356,
0.080796979367733,
0.17817865312099457,
-0.018186502158641815,
-0.43400442600250244,
0.295045405626297,
-0.20164605975151062,
0.1954311728477478,
0.020474687218666077,
0.48761874437332153,
-0.35994163155555725,
-0.24788272380828857,
0.12433271110057831,
0.18753160536289215,
0.2323441505432129,
-0.45466992259025574,
-0.13214224576950073,
0.2782890498638153,
-0.004932373762130737,
0.311977356672287,
-0.0852169468998909,
0.3480803072452545,
0.247878298163414,
0.4398515522480011,
0.5180513262748718,
0.2648836374282837,
0.5859379172325134,
-0.013106090947985649,
0.7051578164100647,
-0.5933782458305359,
-0.8274054527282715,
-0.5648106336593628,
0.0707116350531578,
0.11188347637653351,
-0.23840588331222534,
0.40611952543258667,
0.7105990052223206,
0.5298774242401123,
-0.14917044341564178,
0.9060165882110596,
-0.08250628411769867,
0.8848327398300171,
-0.3857778310775757,
0.29658812284469604,
-0.29092150926589966,
0.22911062836647034,
0.0859256461262703,
-0.38763871788978577,
-0.4197230637073517,
0.5825456380844116,
-0.15623001754283905,
0.02049899473786354,
0.35583189129829407,
0.8652928471565247,
-0.2552003860473633,
0.14766547083854675,
0.5064103603363037,
-0.15690170228481293,
0.718608021736145,
0.872752845287323,
1.0673712491989136,
-0.4965842068195343,
0.7979863286018372,
-0.15516602993011475,
-0.5862060785293579,
-0.5241319537162781,
-0.831868052482605,
-0.6915655136108398,
-0.4310908913612366,
-0.5761127471923828,
-0.1885644644498825,
0.12186497449874878,
0.8171736001968384,
1.224001407623291,
-0.8115148544311523,
-0.26349958777427673,
-0.37771910429000854,
0.07707242667675018,
-0.8546326756477356,
-0.2996695339679718,
0.7711468935012817,
-0.28047361969947815,
-0.4522525668144226,
0.5789136290550232,
0.35475948452949524,
0.19151975214481354,
0.5213865637779236,
0.23390483856201172,
-0.030670661479234695,
0.06905330717563629,
0.2756853997707367,
0.6373878121376038,
-0.49799808859825134,
-0.3285748362541199,
-0.08401694893836975,
-0.11883372813463211,
-0.05419422313570976,
1.0735042095184326,
-0.8815323114395142,
0.3003210127353668,
0.4722171127796173,
0.7491409182548523,
0.1731833517551422,
0.3659982681274414,
0.09443189203739166,
-0.9530993103981018,
0.01544533483684063,
0.17988617718219757,
0.21501725912094116,
0.24176830053329468,
-0.37011659145355225,
0.15564817190170288,
0.6324967741966248,
-0.5033033490180969,
-0.6676446199417114,
0.046644601970911026,
-1.5098636150360107,
-0.26193636655807495,
0.9164738655090332,
-0.06093786284327507,
0.09361352771520615,
-0.4690306484699249,
-0.36477652192115784,
0.3305814266204834,
-0.4665724039077759,
0.4424366354942322,
0.42051059007644653,
-0.10431697219610214,
-0.4298723042011261,
-0.6096654534339905,
0.5557856559753418,
0.4508594572544098,
-0.4036209285259247,
0.3651336133480072,
0.69582200050354,
0.33435431122779846,
-0.031470105051994324,
0.48785361647605896,
-0.10946079343557358,
0.5961289405822754,
-0.16921541094779968,
-0.1872369349002838,
-0.3650072515010834,
-0.7813646197319031,
-0.49385973811149597,
0.4520781934261322,
-0.09172198176383972,
-1.1069061756134033
] |
Subsets and Splits