id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00407v1 | SHADE: Semantic Hypernym Annotator for Domain-specific Entities -- DnD Domain Use Case | 2024-06-29T11:21:40 | 2024-06-29T11:21:40 | Akila Peiris, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CE | cs.CE, cs.CL | Manual data annotation is an important NLP task but one that takes
considerable amount of resources and effort. In spite of the costs, labeling
and categorizing entities is essential for NLP tasks such as semantic
evaluation. Even though annotation can be done by non-experts in most cases,
due to the fact that this requires human labor, the process is costly. Another
major challenge encountered in data annotation is maintaining the annotation
consistency. Annotation efforts are typically carried out by teams of multiple
annotators. The annotations need to maintain the consistency in relation to
both the domain truth and annotation format while reducing human errors.
Annotating a specialized domain that deviates significantly from the general
domain, such as fantasy literature, will see a lot of human error and annotator
disagreement. So it is vital that proper guidelines and error reduction
mechanisms are enforced. One such way to enforce these constraints is using a
specialized application. Such an app can ensure that the notations are
consistent, and the labels can be pre-defined or restricted reducing the room
for errors. In this paper, we present SHADE, an annotation software that can be
used to annotate entities in the high fantasy literature domain. Specifically
in Dungeons and Dragons lore extracted from the Forgotten Realms Fandom Wiki. | [
-0.5303753018379211,
-0.5285474061965942,
0.16016294062137604,
0.7658941149711609,
-0.056214552372694016,
0.1449778974056244,
-0.16996224224567413,
-0.6690029501914978,
0.5684551000595093,
1.053330898284912,
-0.7937616109848022,
-0.9486749768257141,
-0.2863432765007019,
0.46913942694664,
-0.23752140998840332,
1.246777892112732,
-0.3023645281791687,
-0.5471507906913757,
-0.2972344756126404,
-0.338156521320343,
-0.25267624855041504,
-0.4880353808403015,
-0.5218397974967957,
-0.12107153981924057,
0.7329503297805786,
0.1851867437362671,
0.9086312055587769,
0.8369249701499939,
0.6841703653335571,
0.3629099428653717,
0.011336827650666237,
0.4717510938644409,
-0.5810801386833191,
0.577649712562561,
-0.3845159411430359,
-0.2739619314670563,
-0.6651046872138977,
0.08982465416193008,
0.34957608580589294,
0.6781234741210938,
-0.08067881315946579,
0.041147373616695404,
-0.18469858169555664,
0.49539387226104736,
-0.8485525250434875,
0.37578168511390686,
-0.656540036201477,
0.2254675328731537,
-0.5824735164642334,
-0.43251582980155945,
-0.07804416865110397,
-0.26948070526123047,
0.1498742550611496,
-1.8004618883132935,
0.5504150986671448,
0.5673342943191528,
1.1820722818374634,
0.35065707564353943,
0.10005190223455429,
0.015903955325484276,
-0.7079501748085022,
0.8162621259689331,
-0.4990043342113495,
0.21553848683834076,
0.5670374035835266,
0.28488320112228394,
-0.16017737984657288,
-0.6969226002693176,
-0.9669715166091919,
0.09033119678497314,
-0.21810515224933624,
0.03535766899585724,
-0.005837128031998873,
0.27405887842178345,
0.501161515712738,
0.15239720046520233,
-0.09280715137720108,
0.025408530607819557,
-0.13211886584758759,
-0.40891069173812866,
0.5387500524520874,
0.32227545976638794,
0.3925510346889496,
-0.36905598640441895,
-0.5833698511123657,
0.12273084372282028,
-0.8161640763282776,
-0.7426669597625732,
0.46376287937164307,
0.05842810869216919,
0.3135492503643036,
0.5574377775192261,
-0.2827880084514618,
0.7212063670158386,
0.024443887174129486,
-0.28170859813690186,
0.33154743909835815,
0.010815990157425404,
-0.1065225824713707,
0.07281400263309479,
0.5197083353996277,
0.740693986415863,
0.3245026469230652,
-0.5403638482093811,
-0.18827712535858154,
0.08391173928976059,
0.17458945512771606,
-0.7500385642051697,
-0.43377694487571716,
0.05707554519176483,
-0.03893854469060898,
-0.3337368369102478,
-0.2077946811914444,
-0.9706574082374573,
-0.8347991108894348,
-0.3644627332687378,
0.04503466933965683,
-0.07513581216335297,
-0.22691592574119568,
-0.021761875599622726,
-0.4425695538520813,
-0.2687121629714966,
0.7388937473297119,
-1.0444177389144897,
0.4621899724006653,
0.5992198586463928,
0.7282042503356934,
-0.6653951406478882,
-0.4751094877719879,
-0.002425561659038067,
0.7410562634468079,
-0.41915878653526306,
0.5647918581962585,
-0.2533436119556427,
-0.15355172753334045,
-0.1882960945367813,
0.17748573422431946,
-0.06134475767612457,
-0.45829492807388306,
0.6700310111045837,
-0.8180404305458069,
-0.18853944540023804,
-0.2159104198217392,
-0.6002066731452942,
-0.33955928683280945,
0.33570045232772827,
-1.043769121170044,
0.8117940425872803,
0.5951125621795654,
-1.0508646965026855,
0.6599314212799072,
-0.3908909857273102,
-0.01574481837451458,
0.5924002528190613,
-0.23905959725379944,
-0.2762173116207123,
-0.2172074019908905,
-0.02161901816725731,
0.29861676692962646,
-0.38237959146499634,
-0.06983183324337006,
-0.3007942736148834,
-0.5434362292289734,
0.09496267884969711,
-0.15568970143795013,
0.822115957736969,
-0.06894277781248093,
-0.48286235332489014,
-0.02053031325340271,
-0.856158435344696,
0.07161563634872437,
-0.07300980389118195,
-0.19664961099624634,
-0.965595543384552,
-0.22423012554645538,
0.7815621495246887,
0.04235805198550224,
-0.0030033320654183626,
-0.847055971622467,
0.23243775963783264,
-0.32208096981048584,
-0.03293636813759804,
0.7537001371383667,
0.08758959174156189,
0.18236485123634338,
-0.0638682171702385,
0.6346892714500427,
-0.0452861562371254,
0.03421689569950104,
0.19702869653701782,
-0.3612440526485443,
-0.7288597822189331,
-0.5438239574432373,
0.5231369733810425,
0.45442575216293335,
-1.0869911909103394,
0.37504443526268005,
-0.007262484636157751,
-0.3808736205101013,
-0.5239229798316956,
0.307303249835968,
0.31921711564064026,
0.5295659303665161,
0.3769364058971405,
-0.061631083488464355,
-0.5160930156707764,
-0.6236675381660461,
0.07136675715446472,
-0.09939996898174286,
0.18783842027187347,
0.5610544681549072,
0.39328786730766296,
-0.6399215459823608,
1.355763554573059,
-0.7879181504249573,
-0.6620922684669495,
0.0920257642865181,
0.1660667061805725,
-0.12452959269285202,
0.5448945760726929,
0.7885046601295471,
-1.1011961698532104,
-0.35914725065231323,
0.27198514342308044,
-0.7281962037086487,
-0.5254972577095032,
0.11515466868877411,
-0.6046490669250488,
0.16950270533561707,
0.2692592442035675,
-0.6063596606254578,
0.49091267585754395,
0.5450859069824219,
-0.3454303741455078,
0.8511455655097961,
-0.018625250086188316,
0.517396867275238,
-0.7234432101249695,
0.05448170006275177,
0.09804116934537888,
-0.01637464202940464,
-0.23572787642478943,
0.06988740712404251,
-0.16746868193149567,
0.06567433476448059,
-0.09087521582841873,
0.7038374543190002,
-0.3578711748123169,
0.26659440994262695,
-0.14388181269168854,
0.34047842025756836,
0.3372919261455536,
0.5035930275917053,
0.3373129665851593,
0.6138346791267395,
0.47475582361221313,
-0.6279451251029968,
0.8878946900367737,
0.2504471242427826,
-0.06374088674783707,
0.8997132182121277,
-0.6980635523796082,
0.06436020135879517,
0.06517855077981949,
0.0013026007218286395,
-0.6741118431091309,
-0.42884576320648193,
0.43740585446357727,
0.0536879226565361,
0.23035375773906708,
-0.30044272541999817,
-0.6450009346008301,
-0.07467761635780334,
-0.17361466586589813,
0.31568586826324463,
-0.09555988758802414,
-0.5945242047309875,
0.37167519330978394,
0.4572967290878296,
0.08697030693292618,
-0.8346835970878601,
-0.6015377640724182,
0.28396356105804443,
-0.2589605450630188,
-0.6009584069252014,
0.8355219960212708,
0.07921502739191055,
-0.3452480733394623,
0.346114844083786,
-0.058584101498126984,
-0.42899563908576965,
-0.08471113443374634,
0.5137340426445007,
0.2627713680267334,
-0.27353501319885254,
0.1569913923740387,
0.08335928618907928,
-0.29523923993110657,
-0.24389366805553436,
-0.36968687176704407,
0.05278515815734863,
0.12586629390716553,
-0.44554394483566284,
-0.2493836134672165,
0.33024030923843384,
0.4473128020763397,
-0.15557478368282318,
0.5088768601417542,
0.4931792616844177,
-0.5850081443786621,
-0.6662871241569519,
-0.5509631037712097,
0.24270333349704742,
-0.4570040702819824,
0.44768026471138,
-0.4017244577407837,
-0.6769469380378723,
0.5928119421005249,
-0.2408563643693924,
0.14940886199474335,
0.6749447584152222,
0.11416793614625931,
-0.021994315087795258,
0.6876634955406189,
0.884730339050293,
0.18728235363960266,
0.15091407299041748,
-0.22889462113380432,
-0.12950696051120758,
-0.8701427578926086,
-0.05127478763461113,
-0.49987250566482544,
-0.137216717004776,
-0.5012386441230774,
-0.43671149015426636,
0.10539752244949341,
0.37177127599716187,
0.2049572765827179,
0.5665553212165833,
-0.6090657114982605,
0.6589396595954895,
0.23445957899093628,
-0.1670922040939331,
0.4416213929653168,
0.16471323370933533,
0.2528737187385559,
-0.42733728885650635,
-0.32907670736312866,
-0.526618480682373,
0.6964121460914612,
0.12476078420877457,
0.9702354669570923,
0.1381024718284607,
0.876423716545105,
0.4032064974308014,
0.40327614545822144,
-0.7121885418891907,
0.39765095710754395,
-0.14985325932502747,
-0.7300621867179871,
-0.5109564065933228,
-0.46488338708877563,
-0.7331011295318604,
0.19523419439792633,
-0.2667101323604584,
-0.6327962279319763,
0.5778051614761353,
0.04767875000834465,
-0.22187356650829315,
0.22062554955482483,
-0.45902860164642334,
0.9018369317054749,
0.31333643198013306,
-0.35029178857803345,
0.09605827927589417,
-0.1499311774969101,
0.13613811135292053,
-0.21722757816314697,
-0.20445500314235687,
-0.299588680267334,
-0.19595813751220703,
1.1157212257385254,
-0.451730877161026,
0.7805710434913635,
-0.21964800357818604,
0.09488777816295624,
0.23680882155895233,
0.2252705991268158,
0.20797060430049896,
0.0012071124510839581,
-0.033363357186317444,
0.21688982844352722,
0.2551930844783783,
-0.16783693432807922,
-0.8412673473358154,
0.7894115447998047,
-0.6423754096031189,
-0.6214478015899658,
-0.48082688450813293,
-0.6348425149917603,
-0.33757591247558594,
0.29045936465263367,
0.12266428768634796,
0.22226585447788239,
-0.06032127887010574,
0.009965021163225174,
0.9415853023529053,
0.12214355915784836,
-0.02739754319190979,
0.22849825024604797,
-0.3730863332748413,
-0.3947441577911377,
0.9386517405509949,
0.36834716796875,
0.101578488945961,
0.1142788752913475,
0.11066784709692001,
0.016938548535108566,
-0.6733771562576294,
-0.9697449803352356,
0.04611113667488098,
-0.9409833550453186,
-0.2741692066192627,
-0.597628653049469,
-0.15396840870380402,
-0.11216181516647339,
-0.32577237486839294,
0.06008390337228775,
-0.7476867437362671,
-0.04078679159283638,
-0.21956168115139008,
0.8212686777114868,
0.7126864194869995,
0.36153146624565125,
0.36014384031295776,
-0.40044283866882324,
0.3683786988258362,
0.14413847029209137,
0.3324383497238159,
-0.16986677050590515,
0.18845026195049286,
-0.19009117782115936,
-0.2554357051849365,
0.11905015259981155,
-1.0202836990356445,
0.21667850017547607,
0.23548446595668793,
0.5578674077987671,
0.3383198380470276,
0.03388591110706329,
0.6728308200836182,
-0.37456223368644714,
0.49603796005249023,
0.22643889486789703,
-0.69446861743927,
0.33209580183029175,
-0.3781372606754303,
-0.2341729700565338,
0.7036683559417725,
0.3866095542907715,
-0.8550092577934265,
-0.5296192765235901,
-0.47651782631874084,
-1.0089014768600464,
0.7569234371185303,
0.17017622292041779,
-0.028069322928786278,
-0.03908483684062958,
0.5307521224021912,
0.2618815004825592,
0.24744707345962524,
-0.43360862135887146,
-0.492009699344635,
-0.15238557755947113,
-0.2880323529243469,
0.20728664100170135,
-0.18072380125522614,
-0.421450138092041,
-0.09231944382190704,
0.6909709572792053,
-0.16435422003269196,
-0.30095601081848145,
0.23624610900878906,
-0.19152335822582245,
-0.2226690649986267,
-0.09850107878446579,
0.09947871416807175,
0.9586779475212097,
0.009094277396798134,
0.15169139206409454,
-0.13587023317813873,
-1.00615394115448,
-0.03524727374315262,
0.2788938283920288,
-0.8147339224815369,
0.3966754376888275,
0.5106135606765747,
0.6061745882034302,
0.1619700938463211,
-0.31707796454429626,
0.5549994707107544,
0.31078803539276123,
0.15401020646095276,
-0.07678065448999405,
0.19866284728050232,
-0.03625408932566643,
-0.04836505651473999,
0.16377094388008118,
0.26481759548187256,
0.26342642307281494,
-0.15588870644569397,
0.24585716426372528,
-0.067149318754673,
-0.5510276556015015,
0.06754978001117706,
0.569782018661499,
0.3970772325992584,
-0.05559059977531433,
0.31369227170944214,
-0.402769535779953,
-0.5740583539009094,
0.670442521572113,
0.6687120199203491,
1.0025001764297485,
0.0753096267580986,
0.39957499504089355,
0.05834028124809265,
0.10558631271123886,
0.1699257791042328,
-0.10105850547552109,
-0.10457952320575714,
-0.699036717414856,
-0.24903739988803864,
-0.9894874691963196,
-0.5156290531158447,
-0.5075586438179016,
-0.2618121802806854,
0.18642152845859528,
-0.6848303079605103,
-0.2627670168876648,
0.35030364990234375,
0.013615192845463753,
-0.620836615562439,
0.2830374240875244,
-0.29516157507896423,
0.76084965467453,
-0.5750527381896973,
0.6324843764305115,
0.6745064854621887,
-0.669526994228363,
-0.5840604305267334,
0.005585283041000366,
0.0748823806643486,
-0.40143081545829773,
1.120619297027588,
-0.10881330072879791,
-0.5057368874549866,
-0.03718290850520134,
-0.3583759367465973,
-0.5758458375930786,
1.105063557624817,
0.1866876482963562,
-0.5554543733596802,
-0.049298953264951706,
-0.055071860551834106,
0.6998332738876343,
-0.42670100927352905,
-0.08662806451320648,
0.33679312467575073,
0.6472084522247314,
0.2177952080965042,
-0.8775379657745361,
0.16522972285747528,
-0.15723176300525665,
0.15536008775234222,
0.16668705642223358,
-0.19737517833709717,
0.716785728931427,
-0.06670036911964417,
-0.2927442491054535,
-0.003548478940501809,
0.7163988947868347,
0.4301574230194092,
0.4642993211746216,
0.613427996635437,
0.5294480919837952,
0.896403968334198,
-0.42584696412086487,
0.7348189949989319,
-0.04218260198831558,
0.37687793374061584,
0.7907367944717407,
-0.34638822078704834,
0.40223947167396545,
0.32429420948028564,
-0.16537652909755707,
0.4895693361759186,
0.47558829188346863,
-0.17312952876091003,
0.26183149218559265,
0.5491368174552917,
-0.4153395891189575,
0.047823142260313034,
-0.3817572295665741,
-0.18439240753650665,
0.07120000571012497,
0.32183465361595154,
-0.12945514917373657,
-0.020622989162802696,
-0.14651887118816376,
0.3495352864265442,
0.24984560906887054,
-0.4615637958049774,
0.6233888268470764,
-0.12440075725317001,
-0.2980422079563141,
0.20953090488910675,
0.2970724403858185,
0.8682581186294556,
-0.7375242710113525,
-0.43783053755760193,
0.09989817440509796,
0.2722828686237335,
-0.8191543221473694,
-0.7385858297348022,
0.24358537793159485,
0.008248423226177692,
-0.37735944986343384,
0.044399015605449677,
0.793167233467102,
-0.5769696831703186,
-0.4956495761871338,
0.3746398091316223,
0.12221955507993698,
0.05089428648352623,
0.02216017059981823,
-0.5402646064758301,
0.08120211213827133,
-0.3905607759952545,
-0.28046557307243347,
-0.02473612315952778,
0.962093710899353,
-0.422944039106369,
0.39550021290779114,
0.5378690958023071,
0.5820133686065674,
0.15237963199615479,
0.44683191180229187,
0.7278624176979065,
-0.5409522652626038,
-0.498421311378479,
-0.49865198135375977,
-0.06573942303657532,
-0.4974857270717621,
-0.756883442401886,
1.1215035915374756,
0.4316084384918213,
0.7588473558425903,
0.014808999374508858,
0.6918088793754578,
-0.22791707515716553,
0.395746648311615,
-0.36290717124938965,
1.0554393529891968,
-0.2679211497306824,
-0.04135788604617119,
-0.6260422468185425,
-1.1609959602355957,
-0.5528314709663391,
0.5442258715629578,
-0.0517282709479332,
0.03120291605591774,
0.5877877473831177,
0.7399204969406128,
0.013797021470963955,
0.20244455337524414,
0.16864857077598572,
-0.052111752331256866,
0.1193753108382225,
0.05463879555463791,
0.6172754764556885,
-0.0593988336622715,
0.18612337112426758,
-0.5204439759254456,
-0.44221851229667664,
-0.028981544077396393,
-0.7294007539749146,
-0.8142261505126953,
-0.585457980632782,
-0.7335743308067322,
-0.545167863368988,
0.2767164707183838,
0.8433218598365784,
0.8184323310852051,
-0.9286046028137207,
-0.04991792514920235,
0.10487022250890732,
0.35398784279823303,
-0.5907520055770874,
-0.2954865097999573,
0.6944141983985901,
-0.26618054509162903,
-0.8036656975746155,
-0.24718207120895386,
0.4969538748264313,
-0.111655093729496,
-0.6969904899597168,
-0.0984053909778595,
0.17230980098247528,
-0.02991376258432865,
0.395977646112442,
0.1922333538532257,
-0.6007305979728699,
-0.2706775665283203,
-0.27621230483055115,
-0.30782341957092285,
-0.25763651728630066,
0.8243004083633423,
-0.6128049492835999,
0.658220648765564,
0.46944981813430786,
0.8320118188858032,
0.4396358132362366,
-0.12820009887218475,
0.3738672733306885,
-0.7789976596832275,
-0.04769991710782051,
0.46535077691078186,
0.18023699522018433,
0.415703684091568,
-0.6200587153434753,
0.5863090753555298,
0.6977108120918274,
-0.3044663369655609,
-0.621411919593811,
0.07140789926052094,
-0.8668571710586548,
-0.06297817826271057,
1.179832100868225,
-0.5321544408798218,
-0.4985974431037903,
-0.5246784090995789,
-0.4951247274875641,
-0.08722811192274094,
-0.09312920272350311,
0.6451294422149658,
1.026708722114563,
-0.05922588333487511,
0.12808537483215332,
-0.5489101409912109,
1.1260437965393066,
-0.08891019970178604,
-0.8651477694511414,
0.4713955521583557,
0.6629932522773743,
0.06689870357513428,
0.6167649626731873,
0.6069597601890564,
-0.16921155154705048,
0.2688129246234894,
0.20884111523628235,
0.3177342116832733,
-0.2527860105037689,
-0.5278304219245911,
0.22882507741451263,
0.1514343023300171,
-0.10493075847625732,
-0.1407517045736313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00402v1 | Is It Really Long Context if All You Need Is Retrieval? Towards Genuinely Difficult Long Context NLP | 2024-06-29T11:09:47 | 2024-06-29T11:09:47 | Omer Goldman, Alon Jacovi, Aviv Slobodkin, Aviya Maimon, Ido Dagan, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improvements in language models' capabilities have pushed their applications
towards longer contexts, making long-context evaluation and development an
active research area. However, many disparate use-cases are grouped together
under the umbrella term of "long-context", defined simply by the total length
of the model's input, including - for example - Needle-in-a-Haystack tasks,
book summarization, and information aggregation. Given their varied difficulty,
in this position paper we argue that conflating different tasks by their
context length is unproductive. As a community, we require a more precise
vocabulary to understand what makes long-context tasks similar or different. We
propose to unpack the taxonomy of long-context based on the properties that
make them more difficult with longer contexts. We propose two orthogonal axes
of difficulty: (I) Diffusion: How hard is it to find the necessary information
in the context? (II) Scope: How much necessary information is there to find? We
survey the literature on long-context, provide justification for this taxonomy
as an informative descriptor, and situate the literature with respect to it. We
conclude that the most difficult and interesting settings, whose necessary
information is very long and highly diffused within the input, is severely
under-explored. By using a descriptive vocabulary and discussing the relevant
properties of difficulty in long-context, we can implement more informed
research in this area. We call for a careful design of tasks and benchmarks
with distinctly long context, taking into account the characteristics that make
it qualitatively different from shorter context. | [
-0.4261833727359772,
-0.8956896662712097,
0.864288866519928,
0.4603165090084076,
-0.43452760577201843,
0.10876309126615524,
-0.6459499001502991,
-0.7305790781974792,
0.1856112778186798,
0.29809144139289856,
-0.3179151713848114,
-0.007728919852524996,
-0.7592809200286865,
0.3038066625595093,
-0.61530601978302,
0.8959131836891174,
-0.12218350917100906,
-0.39062371850013733,
-0.3838152289390564,
-0.4702529311180115,
-0.5454162359237671,
-0.5468225479125977,
-0.43638864159584045,
-0.3386658728122711,
0.756391704082489,
0.020279625430703163,
0.6199521422386169,
0.2941499948501587,
0.43786686658859253,
0.2157929688692093,
-0.6386322975158691,
-0.01453807856887579,
-0.4517833888530731,
0.193864643573761,
-0.4740384519100189,
-0.17802219092845917,
-0.20426692068576813,
-0.24605588614940643,
0.4473591446876526,
1.1178934574127197,
-0.09007564932107925,
0.17219698429107666,
0.46637532114982605,
0.9103480577468872,
-0.6324148774147034,
-0.03330719470977783,
-0.08334492146968842,
-0.006829158868640661,
-0.4573671221733093,
-0.23482604324817657,
-0.12385036051273346,
0.382517546415329,
0.38724541664123535,
-0.5107192993164062,
0.0036724163219332695,
0.08843659609556198,
0.4655655026435852,
0.02671593800187111,
-0.8290783166885376,
-0.5196261405944824,
-0.9384914040565491,
1.027779221534729,
-0.42136842012405396,
0.15556097030639648,
0.31894490122795105,
0.34711578488349915,
-0.10788597911596298,
-0.7534071803092957,
-0.44381386041641235,
-0.12101838737726212,
-0.11685307323932648,
-0.11388764530420303,
-0.13505837321281433,
0.0486682690680027,
0.19266387820243835,
0.07525034248828888,
-0.2551962733268738,
0.07337842881679535,
-0.575373649597168,
0.06007479131221771,
0.5284771919250488,
0.12157004326581955,
0.06892263144254684,
-0.35669511556625366,
-0.44096308946609497,
0.2746935188770294,
-0.6079716086387634,
0.08715040981769562,
0.041010305285453796,
0.38645079731941223,
0.05440932884812355,
0.41776731610298157,
-0.39253705739974976,
0.7688314914703369,
-0.3112628161907196,
-0.07060888409614563,
0.2811809480190277,
-0.2942349910736084,
-0.1241411566734314,
-0.2764243483543396,
0.4026408791542053,
0.21348603069782257,
-0.07647332549095154,
-0.36963680386543274,
-0.38457825779914856,
-0.28007617592811584,
0.48920226097106934,
-0.45623716711997986,
0.3213045299053192,
0.3899814188480377,
-0.3120761513710022,
0.10283882170915604,
-0.3057554364204407,
-0.5726633071899414,
-0.062404781579971313,
-0.48096057772636414,
0.5091590881347656,
-0.16232995688915253,
-0.32413506507873535,
0.1772080808877945,
-0.10685142874717712,
0.0797058641910553,
0.1915186643600464,
-0.5525767207145691,
0.31268787384033203,
1.1581677198410034,
0.972655713558197,
-0.5913727283477783,
-0.21638289093971252,
-0.07137355208396912,
0.03308654949069023,
-0.1346054971218109,
0.561098575592041,
-0.6417248845100403,
-0.5719537138938904,
0.10318540036678314,
0.219925656914711,
0.2185029834508896,
-0.49008268117904663,
0.7573168277740479,
-0.45943683385849,
0.43314456939697266,
-0.42206376791000366,
-0.6479095220565796,
-0.03564772754907608,
0.2958756685256958,
-0.6005123853683472,
1.0233433246612549,
0.4417386054992676,
-0.6905597448348999,
0.3127785623073578,
-0.7083271145820618,
-0.5495375394821167,
0.28103089332580566,
-0.06904162466526031,
0.12485398352146149,
0.19770705699920654,
-0.28791213035583496,
0.5400238633155823,
-0.3624235987663269,
0.6973438262939453,
-0.13411054015159607,
-0.5570046901702881,
0.05839579179883003,
-0.2753579020500183,
0.5821378231048584,
0.27300718426704407,
-0.4351653754711151,
-0.08901730179786682,
-0.608885645866394,
0.003029409097507596,
-0.22426949441432953,
-0.42101383209228516,
-0.7791868448257446,
0.1809816211462021,
0.22534549236297607,
0.21763299405574799,
0.39000922441482544,
-0.3535958528518677,
0.045669350773096085,
-0.3031086027622223,
0.6843491196632385,
0.5802159309387207,
-0.2931264042854309,
0.7696301937103271,
-0.3074922263622284,
0.46672970056533813,
-0.10839496552944183,
0.30307847261428833,
0.1659035086631775,
-0.3722760081291199,
-0.37957799434661865,
-0.09307621419429779,
0.2301194667816162,
0.33226335048675537,
-0.7205120921134949,
0.4670521020889282,
-0.2942074239253998,
-0.22862961888313293,
-0.15244093537330627,
0.22187282145023346,
0.5657373666763306,
0.6854147911071777,
0.6031866669654846,
-0.3488248884677887,
-0.35058221220970154,
-1.0731453895568848,
-0.11539449542760849,
0.18115705251693726,
-0.23425772786140442,
0.4818974733352661,
0.8025217056274414,
-0.4014543890953064,
1.010185718536377,
-0.23821988701820374,
-0.5181102752685547,
-0.12077575922012329,
0.030475791543722153,
0.5386518239974976,
0.2774054706096649,
0.4063495993614197,
-1.0657479763031006,
-0.24797393381595612,
-0.34619200229644775,
-0.7001385688781738,
0.07939334958791733,
0.11004658788442612,
-0.11239411681890488,
0.05741063877940178,
0.6151834726333618,
-0.7728150486946106,
0.16884922981262207,
0.26241523027420044,
-0.2634357511997223,
0.5086259841918945,
-0.25966835021972656,
-0.2902376651763916,
-0.8517939448356628,
0.4074954390525818,
-0.15702730417251587,
-0.10922317206859589,
-0.5969586372375488,
0.7649403810501099,
0.07683981209993362,
0.11914829909801483,
-0.5948724150657654,
0.8359668850898743,
-0.4453437328338623,
0.3627017140388489,
-0.3580459654331207,
0.25569024682044983,
0.19670115411281586,
0.3803631365299225,
-0.024259619414806366,
0.6304615139961243,
0.2967207133769989,
-0.7406482100486755,
0.5331552624702454,
-0.15638718008995056,
-0.7550753355026245,
0.4943849444389343,
-0.6348679661750793,
-0.02093408815562725,
-0.26080378890037537,
0.5805196762084961,
-0.7067717909812927,
-0.2563365697860718,
0.06727758049964905,
0.1166154146194458,
0.281362384557724,
0.01684323139488697,
-0.36341261863708496,
-0.44175729155540466,
-0.0019110479624941945,
0.992649257183075,
0.47594431042671204,
-0.29273077845573425,
0.26781773567199707,
0.24634303152561188,
-0.03426319733262062,
-0.9141411781311035,
-0.6090489625930786,
0.269963800907135,
-0.6121338605880737,
-0.4582330584526062,
0.8585495352745056,
-0.050794683396816254,
-0.4821655750274658,
-0.10657069832086563,
-0.25523078441619873,
-0.2497805655002594,
0.23367589712142944,
0.21436552703380585,
-0.35952940583229065,
-0.10092072188854218,
0.6866562962532043,
-0.18277662992477417,
0.09396576881408691,
0.08597208559513092,
-0.05501200631260872,
0.23361562192440033,
0.04391205310821533,
-0.15950463712215424,
0.12130925059318542,
0.9544981122016907,
0.23896698653697968,
0.13417384028434753,
0.35940253734588623,
0.2987127900123596,
-0.35572704672813416,
-0.2652952969074249,
-0.48376336693763733,
0.08389829099178314,
-0.4305724799633026,
0.3971891701221466,
-0.3963719606399536,
-1.145698070526123,
0.5652179718017578,
-0.09280133247375488,
0.0310609620064497,
0.27275151014328003,
0.11409547924995422,
-0.29153019189834595,
0.6727941036224365,
0.9204487800598145,
-0.052079249173402786,
0.1729968786239624,
-0.1852431744337082,
0.24378706514835358,
-0.9953228831291199,
-0.21413682401180267,
-0.3657689690589905,
-0.4387311041355133,
-0.27543750405311584,
-0.5473867058753967,
0.30055513978004456,
0.1353088915348053,
-0.13734711706638336,
0.12660756707191467,
-0.573737382888794,
0.5146511793136597,
0.20371150970458984,
0.16267971694469452,
0.05102697014808655,
-0.2852012813091278,
0.22430753707885742,
-0.013788350857794285,
-0.4421031177043915,
-0.3262843191623688,
0.9306679964065552,
0.18163003027439117,
0.45428770780563354,
0.3384605646133423,
0.7146134376525879,
0.2897854149341583,
0.11231649667024612,
-1.1050397157669067,
0.38848960399627686,
-0.049013104289770126,
-0.8748468160629272,
-0.46331632137298584,
-0.18422584235668182,
-1.3462822437286377,
0.16999831795692444,
0.04682445153594017,
-0.4881032109260559,
0.17010891437530518,
-0.11044374108314514,
-0.43115633726119995,
-0.1294242888689041,
-0.3287304937839508,
0.6342365741729736,
-0.15882056951522827,
-0.42794176936149597,
-0.11438851058483124,
-0.9212228059768677,
0.1722995787858963,
-0.29774951934814453,
0.8465194702148438,
-0.2572208344936371,
-0.25399503111839294,
0.7505671977996826,
-0.2948300540447235,
0.6349158883094788,
-0.06952084600925446,
-0.19176200032234192,
0.3224532902240753,
0.1497398316860199,
0.22009846568107605,
-0.015611506998538971,
-0.08601578325033188,
-0.1299317181110382,
0.3265785276889801,
-0.6143813729286194,
-0.763739824295044,
0.6430130004882812,
-0.32564777135849,
-0.8318275213241577,
-0.4207942485809326,
-0.16619837284088135,
-0.13616858422756195,
0.2157060205936432,
0.30334174633026123,
0.4906676709651947,
-0.18019023537635803,
0.4221413731575012,
0.4954310953617096,
0.05293312668800354,
0.5545655488967896,
0.23833464086055756,
-0.17135076224803925,
0.40057969093322754,
0.7208952307701111,
0.22315894067287445,
0.008262967690825462,
0.513948380947113,
0.19344528019428253,
-0.3243069350719452,
-0.46438172459602356,
-0.1825421005487442,
0.09018615633249283,
-0.7306040525436401,
-0.1357385665178299,
-0.41240912675857544,
-0.054406411945819855,
-0.019526468589901924,
-0.19376304745674133,
-0.18265950679779053,
-0.37558525800704956,
-0.5553287863731384,
0.1464478075504303,
0.10930684953927994,
0.5750842690467834,
0.029911672696471214,
0.2807687819004059,
-0.6527647972106934,
0.3551705777645111,
0.36863914132118225,
0.46957993507385254,
0.10991474241018295,
-0.6408606767654419,
-0.25328657031059265,
0.007723723538219929,
-0.0037756883539259434,
-0.7184579968452454,
0.4053184688091278,
0.45318883657455444,
0.3093325197696686,
0.18514177203178406,
0.2753628194332123,
0.7389285564422607,
-0.5897060632705688,
0.8615733981132507,
0.09180718660354614,
-0.7235838770866394,
0.17690230906009674,
-0.08238690346479416,
0.34589698910713196,
0.7013335227966309,
0.6452370882034302,
-0.6235911846160889,
-0.10761295258998871,
-0.5249941349029541,
-1.564095139503479,
0.2806013524532318,
0.11188062280416489,
0.7433348298072815,
-0.3265640437602997,
0.6422640681266785,
0.15737241506576538,
0.1848832219839096,
-0.7387245893478394,
0.12718339264392853,
0.07357283681631088,
0.12152771651744843,
-0.16433626413345337,
-0.6234847903251648,
-0.6168597936630249,
-0.26408249139785767,
0.15236622095108032,
-0.0890868753194809,
0.20138871669769287,
0.2704843282699585,
-0.20871292054653168,
0.24547609686851501,
0.6497066617012024,
0.40530043840408325,
1.3056001663208008,
-0.3005737066268921,
0.25681406259536743,
0.1036250963807106,
-0.042789969593286514,
-0.0015278529608622193,
-0.1934683918952942,
0.257302850484848,
0.05723300576210022,
0.6178852319717407,
0.3363268971443176,
0.4990161955356598,
-0.8494667410850525,
0.8839626312255859,
0.20120754837989807,
-0.13960228860378265,
-0.7233853936195374,
-0.07694105803966522,
0.11097142100334167,
0.3064652681350708,
0.8065513968467712,
-0.4903441369533539,
0.5201212167739868,
-0.7333840131759644,
0.11552533507347107,
0.48823314905166626,
-0.4046156108379364,
-0.0425933413207531,
0.1999589502811432,
0.45515796542167664,
-0.40539222955703735,
0.5461496710777283,
-0.31790444254875183,
-0.2756579518318176,
0.7135036587715149,
0.4799827039241791,
0.5114494562149048,
0.19871050119400024,
-0.0309279914945364,
0.06307532638311386,
-0.13392187654972076,
-0.4459310472011566,
0.06448366492986679,
-0.5867968797683716,
-0.21427606046199799,
-0.7370285987854004,
-0.9369454383850098,
-0.2529118061065674,
0.26090940833091736,
-0.8294822573661804,
0.1271977722644806,
-0.19574123620986938,
-0.3577631711959839,
0.10385935008525848,
-0.05842835456132889,
-0.5164790749549866,
0.33064359426498413,
-0.16321289539337158,
0.9643728137016296,
-0.4270261526107788,
0.5906816720962524,
0.3726951777935028,
0.2300862967967987,
-0.20103324949741364,
-0.15157189965248108,
-0.2577812671661377,
-0.4576125144958496,
0.7778624892234802,
0.3546597957611084,
-0.08513036370277405,
-0.42199379205703735,
-0.6260085701942444,
-0.7870566248893738,
0.9327206015586853,
-0.17122432589530945,
-0.8186960220336914,
-0.6193612217903137,
-0.1573985368013382,
0.825350821018219,
-0.3013342618942261,
0.017754826694726944,
0.41718819737434387,
0.47848981618881226,
-0.14097224175930023,
-1.0914380550384521,
0.18420574069023132,
-0.1882173866033554,
0.03639844432473183,
0.2931528687477112,
-0.5768005847930908,
0.7071511149406433,
-0.09274440258741379,
-0.5420495271682739,
0.11634337157011032,
0.5255240201950073,
-0.24252693355083466,
0.43382319808006287,
0.5554671883583069,
0.1796080470085144,
0.42428892850875854,
0.09746786206960678,
0.8781449198722839,
-0.20154818892478943,
0.48948976397514343,
1.1415709257125854,
-0.07671108096837997,
0.8067824244499207,
0.7665876746177673,
-0.25050103664398193,
0.33717456459999084,
0.6136027574539185,
0.3095758259296417,
0.41986435651779175,
0.4808531701564789,
-0.367990106344223,
-0.3272515833377838,
0.014441498555243015,
-0.5575754642486572,
0.44437775015830994,
0.6511891484260559,
-0.31496462225914,
-0.34913527965545654,
0.157274067401886,
-0.01626650243997574,
0.19437620043754578,
0.014294019900262356,
0.46323299407958984,
0.40844494104385376,
-0.8641162514686584,
0.7428598403930664,
0.10958253592252731,
0.9490278363227844,
-0.5291106700897217,
0.155903160572052,
-0.07626830786466599,
-0.3262195289134979,
-0.2273794412612915,
-1.0510634183883667,
0.5753493905067444,
-0.3193863034248352,
-0.28785139322280884,
-0.2203340232372284,
0.3106391727924347,
-0.12634575366973877,
-0.09491588175296783,
0.7365726828575134,
0.6716086268424988,
0.22322151064872742,
-0.21253399550914764,
-0.5358966588973999,
-0.11867814511060715,
-0.3518454432487488,
-0.45815736055374146,
0.5371698141098022,
0.49930673837661743,
-0.17749090492725372,
0.703244149684906,
0.2913224697113037,
-0.08059218525886536,
-0.3092164099216461,
-0.18361517786979675,
0.6221945881843567,
-0.9944230318069458,
-0.2939392924308777,
-0.8907699584960938,
0.16910909116268158,
0.049437493085861206,
-0.5777166485786438,
0.27065229415893555,
0.355331152677536,
0.6757630705833435,
0.26428699493408203,
0.4595715403556824,
-0.336477667093277,
0.5285014510154724,
-0.40422916412353516,
0.4240126609802246,
-1.0392050743103027,
0.2748030424118042,
-0.04638106748461723,
-1.0081901550292969,
-0.3644527196884155,
0.24004802107810974,
0.0333288200199604,
0.0334094762802124,
0.6871247291564941,
0.3486867845058441,
-0.40549543499946594,
-0.1786736398935318,
0.21626248955726624,
0.05428905412554741,
0.22876614332199097,
0.8943672776222229,
0.8287133574485779,
0.08565978705883026,
0.49492543935775757,
-0.4222346246242523,
-0.21733026206493378,
-0.44948601722717285,
-1.0233402252197266,
-0.5139889121055603,
-1.0840851068496704,
0.011712136678397655,
-0.3433345854282379,
0.20933806896209717,
0.6873000860214233,
0.6699293255805969,
-0.24311651289463043,
-0.3368338644504547,
0.1979789137840271,
0.28733113408088684,
-0.06295733898878098,
-0.24447529017925262,
0.42754700779914856,
-0.3546459674835205,
-0.6977701187133789,
0.4850696921348572,
0.22490602731704712,
-0.16570612788200378,
-0.20594467222690582,
0.19941268861293793,
-0.08253425359725952,
-0.044311027973890305,
1.034914493560791,
0.5337367057800293,
-0.7498148679733276,
-0.5642370581626892,
-0.1564396172761917,
-0.19084537029266357,
-0.006429523695260286,
0.7677977085113525,
-0.7487570643424988,
0.5588451623916626,
0.3741225600242615,
0.38713589310646057,
0.44294244050979614,
-0.16424082219600677,
0.3473816215991974,
-0.8527719974517822,
0.012305323965847492,
0.5603969097137451,
0.22317884862422943,
0.2539122700691223,
-0.34541234374046326,
0.5689908862113953,
-0.008593179285526276,
-0.5999802947044373,
-1.1154751777648926,
0.5256425738334656,
-1.1959701776504517,
-0.788614809513092,
1.3969167470932007,
-0.06139225885272026,
-0.4780398905277252,
-0.38223007321357727,
-0.02103680931031704,
0.03878508508205414,
-0.21941369771957397,
0.9841680526733398,
0.9035985469818115,
-0.3462269604206085,
0.2456647753715515,
-0.6742611527442932,
0.7063586711883545,
0.5109848380088806,
-0.13117799162864685,
0.08776101469993591,
0.2908124029636383,
0.3507150113582611,
0.5679319500923157,
0.6513354778289795,
-0.07319773733615875,
0.034707941114902496,
-0.5005521178245544,
-0.4442935287952423,
0.21088188886642456,
-0.39071178436279297,
-0.24774155020713806,
0.45009005069732666,
0.017979837954044342,
0.5407447218894958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00396v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00396v1 | A Study on Effect of Reference Knowledge Choice in Generating Technical Content Relevant to SAPPhIRE Model Using Large Language Model | 2024-06-29T10:46:01 | 2024-06-29T10:46:01 | Kausik Bhattacharya, Anubhab Majumder, Amaresh Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representation of systems using the SAPPhIRE model of causality can be an
inspirational stimulus in design. However, creating a SAPPhIRE model of a
technical or a natural system requires sourcing technical knowledge from
multiple technical documents regarding how the system works. This research
investigates how to generate technical content accurately relevant to the
SAPPhIRE model of causality using a Large Language Model, also called LLM. This
paper, which is the first part of the two-part research, presents a method for
hallucination suppression using Retrieval Augmented Generating with LLM to
generate technical content supported by the scientific information relevant to
a SAPPhIRE con-struct. The result from this research shows that the selection
of reference knowledge used in providing context to the LLM for generating the
technical content is very important. The outcome of this research is used to
build a software support tool to generate the SAPPhIRE model of a given
technical system. | [
-0.38565999269485474,
-0.8508597612380981,
0.6615051627159119,
0.23397189378738403,
-0.44640177488327026,
-0.2742820084095001,
-0.18887823820114136,
-0.535561203956604,
0.4282795488834381,
0.5683756470680237,
-0.40523940324783325,
-0.3858810365200043,
-0.14024318754673004,
0.06838943809270859,
-0.4707644581794739,
0.7123538255691528,
-0.007790507283061743,
0.18226763606071472,
0.011084446683526039,
0.23207886517047882,
-0.839747428894043,
-0.5049970746040344,
-0.7963018417358398,
-0.6107476353645325,
0.4090922772884369,
0.2605862319469452,
0.5538693070411682,
0.28615638613700867,
0.7732766270637512,
0.31452128291130066,
-0.07088787853717804,
0.14815491437911987,
-0.36139410734176636,
0.43428707122802734,
-0.4127265512943268,
-0.5178762674331665,
-0.4111459255218506,
-0.18864864110946655,
0.6833961009979248,
0.21575294435024261,
-0.2649887800216675,
0.19308914244174957,
0.18805231153964996,
0.5237407088279724,
-0.3229106068611145,
0.07008413970470428,
-0.8188952207565308,
0.1415189951658249,
-0.1617353856563568,
-0.73451828956604,
-0.5855405926704407,
-0.3029348850250244,
-0.18913181126117706,
-0.639050304889679,
0.2738226056098938,
0.2726847231388092,
0.878662109375,
0.47210144996643066,
-0.18555384874343872,
-0.19673925638198853,
-1.2120516300201416,
0.8053334951400757,
-0.6506127715110779,
0.4127733111381531,
0.3426983654499054,
0.2084343284368515,
-0.1664741486310959,
-0.5313234329223633,
-0.7382619380950928,
-0.39135459065437317,
-0.15378119051456451,
0.06554527580738068,
0.1610102653503418,
-0.13136109709739685,
0.619467556476593,
0.13569217920303345,
-0.41047048568725586,
-0.08514676243066788,
-0.8590022921562195,
-0.34794163703918457,
0.48093682527542114,
0.21639470756053925,
0.47810280323028564,
-0.6766654253005981,
-0.12479160726070404,
0.029647676274180412,
-1.022011637687683,
-0.5183702707290649,
0.053621891885995865,
0.19478341937065125,
0.2385648787021637,
0.9271984696388245,
-0.0328553207218647,
0.7298896908760071,
0.0424405112862587,
-0.2749097943305969,
0.10978109389543533,
-0.3163466155529022,
-0.4537864625453949,
0.3804302215576172,
0.6995172500610352,
0.08451829105615616,
0.04757658764719963,
-0.36368346214294434,
-0.014566575177013874,
-0.0610247477889061,
0.4727926552295685,
-0.7579898834228516,
0.31958839297294617,
0.03033352829515934,
-0.4350810647010803,
-0.13224811851978302,
0.15102407336235046,
-0.24670526385307312,
-0.5100457072257996,
-0.7182520627975464,
0.16083906590938568,
-0.680719792842865,
-0.4016258120536804,
0.0008391455048695207,
-0.27266964316368103,
0.2809292674064636,
0.13548330962657928,
-0.7029654383659363,
0.008466348983347416,
0.440059632062912,
0.8079336881637573,
-0.05343841761350632,
-0.12292438000440598,
-0.5146693587303162,
0.7558510899543762,
-0.27527299523353577,
0.5382567644119263,
-0.5153285264968872,
-0.7207433581352234,
-0.29371607303619385,
-0.16228169202804565,
0.23459136486053467,
-0.6874059438705444,
0.5760339498519897,
-0.7807087898254395,
-0.04815736040472984,
-0.04806467890739441,
-0.29643768072128296,
-0.29113832116127014,
-0.05435185134410858,
-0.7486125826835632,
0.969745397567749,
-0.11315707117319107,
-0.7271894216537476,
0.504217267036438,
-0.10670007020235062,
-0.5021036863327026,
0.2562243640422821,
-0.6120361089706421,
-0.16942034661769867,
0.3030507266521454,
-0.2924361228942871,
0.4070800840854645,
-0.3946470022201538,
0.6671034693717957,
-0.21012407541275024,
-0.41880446672439575,
0.3124615550041199,
0.11724712699651718,
0.2503388226032257,
0.27204009890556335,
-0.617585301399231,
0.02040972374379635,
-1.0389097929000854,
-0.13589274883270264,
-0.12484893947839737,
-0.32834601402282715,
-0.727459192276001,
0.32679495215415955,
-0.27046576142311096,
0.437238484621048,
-0.04745732992887497,
-0.5438750982284546,
-0.10532686114311218,
-0.036946918815374374,
0.2337852567434311,
0.624643862247467,
0.25129473209381104,
0.35294169187545776,
-0.10409688949584961,
0.30634546279907227,
-0.17990605533123016,
-0.024722401052713394,
0.4134417176246643,
-0.34411340951919556,
-0.755588173866272,
0.06982371211051941,
0.09170332551002502,
0.5608216524124146,
-0.9951059222221375,
0.2761591672897339,
-0.14678947627544403,
-0.29494842886924744,
-0.14547324180603027,
0.09458886086940765,
0.3131186068058014,
0.5965742468833923,
0.2188761979341507,
0.020398959517478943,
-0.8281041979789734,
-1.017269253730774,
0.20346324145793915,
-0.14258308708667755,
-0.283849835395813,
0.43570563197135925,
0.16685202717781067,
-0.03638850897550583,
0.8749630451202393,
-0.5511525273323059,
-0.31634485721588135,
-0.09158746153116226,
0.04453333839774132,
0.2836998701095581,
0.4277462661266327,
0.5026962757110596,
-0.6434414386749268,
-0.2886786460876465,
0.08549045026302338,
-1.1526975631713867,
0.009738867171108723,
-0.24428978562355042,
-0.6640962958335876,
0.1863454431295395,
0.7117485404014587,
-0.6652243733406067,
0.4456842839717865,
0.18386568129062653,
-0.23069633543491364,
0.5951996445655823,
-0.21165171265602112,
0.28544387221336365,
-1.3976049423217773,
0.46948403120040894,
0.2789246141910553,
0.11727908998727798,
-0.4007992148399353,
0.1288830190896988,
0.054652851074934006,
-0.2491319179534912,
-0.23711195588111877,
0.5155798196792603,
-0.29299986362457275,
-0.0029912174213677645,
-0.34314972162246704,
0.5353841781616211,
-0.16265422105789185,
0.24087703227996826,
0.6392843723297119,
0.8745139241218567,
0.16470783948898315,
-1.0521247386932373,
0.48871541023254395,
0.29520073533058167,
-0.2891046702861786,
0.5486032366752625,
-0.8199653625488281,
-0.036783378571271896,
0.0013406554935500026,
-0.33274757862091064,
-0.3203282058238983,
-0.04980672895908356,
0.26077595353126526,
-0.48355066776275635,
0.3388606607913971,
0.146450012922287,
-0.6584275364875793,
-0.3634132444858551,
0.0734807625412941,
0.09536200761795044,
0.5944127440452576,
-0.060096509754657745,
0.7883525490760803,
0.25323235988616943,
-0.3807581663131714,
-0.135740265250206,
-0.8846355676651001,
0.008232025429606438,
-0.2548369765281677,
-0.9118492007255554,
0.5437448024749756,
-0.3532199263572693,
-0.6660639047622681,
-0.05030260235071182,
0.009014805778861046,
0.20858608186244965,
-0.06904665380716324,
0.49063751101493835,
0.6093872785568237,
-0.3931165635585785,
0.5507174730300903,
0.02609907276928425,
-0.1967800259590149,
0.1748378872871399,
-0.08531022071838379,
0.6669434905052185,
0.2613963782787323,
-0.28534770011901855,
-0.47482943534851074,
0.23725605010986328,
0.2570112943649292,
0.15915317833423615,
1.0882962942123413,
0.3800189197063446,
-0.22092698514461517,
-0.38624852895736694,
-0.7099773287773132,
-0.28886955976486206,
-0.5048492550849915,
0.34006673097610474,
-0.4016185402870178,
-0.45972853899002075,
0.4680633544921875,
0.2708480954170227,
-0.0899987518787384,
0.6176862716674805,
0.3996036946773529,
0.3112899363040924,
0.6835330724716187,
0.7013409733772278,
-0.17216581106185913,
0.5984356999397278,
0.07292505353689194,
0.26711416244506836,
-1.0246368646621704,
-0.5547875165939331,
-0.7918928265571594,
0.033751048147678375,
-0.2005423903465271,
-0.18677596747875214,
0.3038490414619446,
0.10916655510663986,
-0.5277994275093079,
0.2124483287334442,
-0.6567659378051758,
0.10772514343261719,
0.7853206396102905,
0.6993103623390198,
0.5330959558486938,
0.5223507285118103,
-0.25593113899230957,
-0.15902739763259888,
-0.31800806522369385,
-0.6482862830162048,
0.8842333555221558,
-0.06538055092096329,
1.0240988731384277,
0.15961597859859467,
0.40399131178855896,
0.3000803291797638,
-0.12880004942417145,
-0.6608632206916809,
0.6634141802787781,
0.22524714469909668,
-0.6002036929130554,
-0.40638867020606995,
-0.4510655999183655,
-0.40690019726753235,
-0.06783907115459442,
-0.29596900939941406,
-0.38730236887931824,
0.07919852435588837,
-0.03953060135245323,
-0.6625254154205322,
0.26946309208869934,
-0.5869569778442383,
-0.008518490009009838,
0.03657243400812149,
-0.6544283628463745,
-0.6398504972457886,
-0.14609579741954803,
0.6553691029548645,
-0.3151189982891083,
0.1986468881368637,
0.373251348733902,
0.2812701463699341,
0.8205717206001282,
-0.33238887786865234,
0.7224745750427246,
0.16897910833358765,
-0.13040082156658173,
0.304478257894516,
0.38800299167633057,
0.5788296461105347,
0.22491388022899628,
-0.6551963090896606,
-0.16925330460071564,
-0.4539349675178528,
0.027819693088531494,
-0.4653182923793793,
0.8013290166854858,
-0.8512410521507263,
-1.0982004404067993,
-0.3599866032600403,
-0.4284418523311615,
-0.04082047566771507,
0.24602842330932617,
0.2012738734483719,
0.5574135184288025,
0.060055267065763474,
0.1614025980234146,
1.0663479566574097,
-0.4613560736179352,
0.40697845816612244,
0.588695228099823,
-0.1531001627445221,
-0.3073101043701172,
0.7842332720756531,
0.06823039054870605,
0.31286323070526123,
0.2231990247964859,
-0.07884128391742706,
0.2562256157398224,
-0.5834611058235168,
-0.26101750135421753,
0.6223267316818237,
-0.7890545725822449,
-0.14614619314670563,
-0.42420682311058044,
-0.7921466827392578,
-0.3146194815635681,
-0.20073309540748596,
0.039144206792116165,
-0.3493141531944275,
-0.5291323065757751,
-0.1380072385072708,
0.41292259097099304,
1.1073359251022339,
0.02573545277118683,
-0.06345602869987488,
-1.0017728805541992,
0.2616240084171295,
0.2964946925640106,
0.3610198199748993,
0.1863744556903839,
-0.5433925986289978,
-0.4659701883792877,
-0.05275634676218033,
-0.36960098147392273,
-0.6997228264808655,
0.2816317081451416,
-0.16439978778362274,
1.0670850276947021,
0.375723272562027,
0.03503971919417381,
0.6132180094718933,
-0.5552254915237427,
0.9315394163131714,
0.2266310453414917,
-0.9318288564682007,
0.7982102036476135,
-0.22274558246135712,
0.08284392207860947,
0.18394668400287628,
0.37069979310035706,
-0.428790807723999,
-0.4576285183429718,
-0.5092769861221313,
-0.5231286287307739,
0.804958164691925,
0.2235545814037323,
-0.039824772626161575,
0.0050687892362475395,
0.6509020924568176,
0.07130651921033859,
0.10072389245033264,
-0.9509984850883484,
-0.10535012930631638,
0.10887372493743896,
0.25609007477760315,
0.13894568383693695,
-0.6149888038635254,
-0.07655184715986252,
0.047504883259534836,
1.2701075077056885,
0.34392330050468445,
0.26081931591033936,
0.38191619515419006,
-0.2354111671447754,
-0.1845787614583969,
0.07713817059993744,
0.8079369068145752,
0.728890597820282,
-0.08769533038139343,
0.07376283407211304,
-0.010678993538022041,
-0.6216891407966614,
-0.25052276253700256,
-0.2583606541156769,
-0.6016789078712463,
0.1744869500398636,
0.21842682361602783,
0.7775116562843323,
-0.01950383558869362,
-0.26090291142463684,
-0.24048744142055511,
0.10199311375617981,
-0.194520503282547,
-0.2967538833618164,
0.26872217655181885,
-0.03218560293316841,
0.3859735131263733,
0.4916049838066101,
-0.04411808401346207,
0.009695742279291153,
-0.34338101744651794,
0.02938668243587017,
0.5677930116653442,
-0.1663442999124527,
-0.07182405143976212,
0.5685727000236511,
0.18217580020427704,
-0.3001294434070587,
0.8479493260383606,
-0.05967290699481964,
-0.15748277306556702,
0.6474606990814209,
0.6149190068244934,
0.5287151336669922,
-0.3961194157600403,
0.3646520972251892,
0.7691741585731506,
0.35189110040664673,
0.02259720116853714,
0.2429562658071518,
0.01606161892414093,
-0.5854764580726624,
-0.46361005306243896,
-0.7264097332954407,
-0.15157705545425415,
0.02730259671807289,
-0.4841444790363312,
0.7311729788780212,
-0.3458491265773773,
-0.3199433982372284,
-0.1539095789194107,
-0.09944801777601242,
-0.36811986565589905,
0.1558912992477417,
0.17759476602077484,
0.8354480862617493,
-0.6370795965194702,
0.758025586605072,
0.38825270533561707,
-0.8939316868782043,
-1.327012300491333,
-0.1821650266647339,
-0.35030898451805115,
-0.7071905732154846,
1.276854395866394,
-0.6280407905578613,
-0.295337975025177,
-0.1496649980545044,
-0.3389699459075928,
-1.1025683879852295,
1.3147485256195068,
0.2730523347854614,
-0.5555698275566101,
-0.15067675709724426,
0.17680613696575165,
0.4515647292137146,
-0.14608880877494812,
0.170549675822258,
0.09668022394180298,
0.3679342269897461,
0.8082141280174255,
-0.9785458445549011,
0.48809492588043213,
-0.3298591375350952,
0.21713733673095703,
0.08092569559812546,
-0.46520277857780457,
0.7321659326553345,
0.0008118086843751371,
-0.2780745327472687,
-0.009732399135828018,
0.6009028553962708,
0.7199174165725708,
-0.13370375335216522,
-0.05396084859967232,
0.19426392018795013,
0.6467368006706238,
0.22636641561985016,
0.9202669262886047,
-0.6754107475280762,
0.09703707695007324,
0.999622106552124,
-0.3843476176261902,
0.8727788925170898,
0.6520939469337463,
-0.038108766078948975,
0.794346034526825,
0.5570033192634583,
-0.07382802665233612,
0.5232033133506775,
0.24735648930072784,
-0.4233124554157257,
-0.29737013578414917,
-0.04553190618753433,
-0.8722555041313171,
-0.10027409344911575,
0.41259726881980896,
-0.6123817563056946,
-0.0553206168115139,
0.10886633396148682,
0.05541495606303215,
-0.2425624579191208,
-0.4275113344192505,
0.7668408155441284,
0.2929474413394928,
-0.929815948009491,
0.4655517041683197,
-0.029093803837895393,
0.4300025403499603,
-0.7355621457099915,
-0.07074089348316193,
-0.3523440957069397,
0.11816078424453735,
-0.4953363835811615,
-0.5268716812133789,
0.5317337512969971,
-0.17001549899578094,
-0.48033908009529114,
0.09359684586524963,
0.9131363034248352,
-0.17144930362701416,
-0.6422375440597534,
0.12426552921533585,
0.14873653650283813,
0.09911857545375824,
-0.11322443932294846,
-0.0487593412399292,
0.07416296750307083,
0.05492835491895676,
-0.3006855547428131,
0.16859933733940125,
0.44060012698173523,
-0.13486440479755402,
0.6252665519714355,
0.4778270125389099,
0.47718387842178345,
0.07471334934234619,
0.10556602478027344,
0.9756086468696594,
-0.8254777789115906,
-0.4879569113254547,
-0.9033923149108887,
0.3256024420261383,
-0.3925742208957672,
0.3036118745803833,
1.1384680271148682,
0.6316952705383301,
0.34469667077064514,
-0.1315508782863617,
1.053269386291504,
-0.22886845469474792,
0.319245308637619,
-0.8800429105758667,
0.7422260642051697,
-0.39979782700538635,
0.6189120411872864,
-0.4697498381137848,
-1.04719078540802,
-0.33749136328697205,
0.46587640047073364,
-0.3310064673423767,
-0.0019139929208904505,
1.0468482971191406,
0.9987578392028809,
0.0499897301197052,
0.30594751238822937,
0.2863928973674774,
0.34991079568862915,
0.04955534264445305,
0.3298235237598419,
0.7743473649024963,
-0.1923680305480957,
0.5183795690536499,
-0.07881849259138107,
-0.2293519824743271,
0.08848755806684494,
-0.8729507923126221,
-0.9907445311546326,
-0.6281529068946838,
-0.2546347975730896,
-0.8116957545280457,
-0.1963868886232376,
0.6800158619880676,
0.53011554479599,
-0.6951901912689209,
-0.3265134394168854,
-0.12242421507835388,
0.11783723533153534,
0.28070464730262756,
-0.1867891252040863,
0.3710367679595947,
-0.43460890650749207,
-0.3272327780723572,
0.1716800332069397,
0.17071878910064697,
-0.0003235121548641473,
-0.40474098920822144,
-0.17181000113487244,
0.03770992532372475,
-0.028309203684329987,
0.8197982907295227,
0.10264734923839569,
-0.5690813064575195,
-0.21894694864749908,
0.34078213572502136,
-0.2350495457649231,
-0.1450948715209961,
1.1226975917816162,
-0.88693767786026,
0.004160392563790083,
0.5920799374580383,
0.0969371497631073,
0.6335107684135437,
-0.4462798535823822,
0.8422315716743469,
-0.4171299636363983,
0.2119705229997635,
-0.1669618785381317,
0.5179007649421692,
0.03502190485596657,
-0.830193281173706,
0.5578392744064331,
0.28046461939811707,
-0.5425217747688293,
-0.4081057906150818,
0.18867500126361847,
-0.8537131547927856,
-0.40369218587875366,
1.5901833772659302,
0.4113849699497223,
-0.23288537561893463,
-0.061619922518730164,
-0.5249950289726257,
0.39634209871292114,
-0.2679271697998047,
1.0645073652267456,
0.8514769077301025,
-0.09638498723506927,
-0.0852951928973198,
-0.5019288659095764,
0.417704701423645,
0.02773405611515045,
-0.6799761056900024,
-0.2984372675418854,
0.6199060082435608,
0.3956732153892517,
0.466770738363266,
0.3006799519062042,
-0.1104099228978157,
0.09029988199472427,
0.017056986689567566,
0.5444258451461792,
-0.19855259358882904,
-0.08333427459001541,
0.0796254500746727,
0.2290613055229187,
0.21199780702590942,
0.22955535352230072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00390v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00390v1 | Advancing Process Verification for Large Language Models via Tree-Based Preference Learning | 2024-06-29T10:09:49 | 2024-06-29T10:09:49 | Mingqian He, Yongliang Shen, Wenqi Zhang, Zeqi Tan, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable potential in
handling complex reasoning tasks by generating step-by-step rationales.Some
methods have proven effective in boosting accuracy by introducing extra
verifiers to assess these paths. However, existing verifiers, typically trained
on binary-labeled reasoning paths, fail to fully utilize the relative merits of
intermediate steps, thereby limiting the effectiveness of the feedback
provided. To overcome this limitation, we propose Tree-based Preference
Learning Verifier (Tree-PLV), a novel approach that constructs reasoning trees
via a best-first search algorithm and collects step-level paired data for
preference training. Compared to traditional binary classification, step-level
preferences more finely capture the nuances between reasoning steps, allowing
for a more precise evaluation of the complete reasoning path. We empirically
evaluate Tree-PLV across a range of arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks,
where it significantly outperforms existing benchmarks. For instance, Tree-PLV
achieved substantial performance gains over the Mistral-7B self-consistency
baseline on GSM8K (67.55% to 82.79%), MATH (17.00% to 26.80%), CSQA (68.14% to
72.97%), and StrategyQA (82.86% to 83.25%).Additionally, our study explores the
appropriate granularity for applying preference learning, revealing that
step-level guidance provides feedback that better aligns with the evaluation of
the reasoning process. | [
-0.14042675495147705,
-0.7642816305160522,
0.8061936497688293,
-0.15557831525802612,
-0.15729476511478424,
0.25260287523269653,
-0.321856826543808,
-0.06826473027467728,
-0.31164491176605225,
0.45664092898368835,
-0.40919575095176697,
-0.6147739887237549,
-0.5695644021034241,
0.07135606557130814,
0.04849990829825401,
0.8253996968269348,
-0.1883196085691452,
-0.1633528620004654,
-0.3123866021633148,
-0.0007263736333698034,
-0.3060282766819,
-0.7947185635566711,
-0.7527650594711304,
-0.4701376259326935,
0.37110525369644165,
0.5102397799491882,
0.6107057332992554,
0.6392115950584412,
0.07799039781093597,
0.3281805217266083,
-0.2375859022140503,
0.45176711678504944,
-0.24441492557525635,
0.24457058310508728,
-0.14462043344974518,
-0.41180387139320374,
-0.40694716572761536,
-0.1143283024430275,
0.47281014919281006,
0.43637821078300476,
-0.14953243732452393,
0.19046568870544434,
-0.0964139848947525,
0.7354292869567871,
-0.5355042815208435,
0.3445744812488556,
-0.8338432312011719,
0.10629139095544815,
-0.14614099264144897,
-0.46355611085891724,
-0.7147142291069031,
-0.49510809779167175,
0.13354361057281494,
-0.34951451420783997,
-0.0421077236533165,
0.06203924119472504,
0.9229071736335754,
0.3460432291030884,
-0.7980407476425171,
-0.07706880569458008,
-0.6529197692871094,
0.7951000332832336,
-0.6306065320968628,
0.4272664487361908,
0.6700257062911987,
0.5040530562400818,
-0.14695827662944794,
-0.5561965703964233,
-0.33159419894218445,
-0.4116184711456299,
-0.008829598315060139,
-0.09643061459064484,
-0.0046558319590985775,
0.22584787011146545,
0.6897814273834229,
0.355806440114975,
-0.4006626605987549,
-0.01683209091424942,
0.021402522921562195,
-0.4232013523578644,
0.5220397710800171,
-0.041951604187488556,
0.09867053478956223,
-0.2185269445180893,
-0.03435814380645752,
-0.18140719830989838,
-0.7680805921554565,
0.8074144124984741,
0.22886213660240173,
0.13999393582344055,
0.30849725008010864,
0.508640468120575,
-0.5770787596702576,
0.7557138800621033,
0.4226594567298889,
-0.49592769145965576,
0.39795559644699097,
-0.30033594369888306,
-0.4248781204223633,
0.16167229413986206,
0.6421326994895935,
0.12870977818965912,
0.1405927687883377,
0.08305054157972336,
-0.18806728720664978,
0.003093922743573785,
-0.05120477080345154,
-0.9415072798728943,
-0.29047465324401855,
0.2965675890445709,
-0.28281694650650024,
-0.10914141684770584,
-0.1780809760093689,
-0.05694674700498581,
-0.45596155524253845,
-0.4981938898563385,
0.062310636043548584,
-0.5590169429779053,
-0.3257972300052643,
0.12005776911973953,
0.3926256000995636,
0.43406593799591064,
0.737545907497406,
-0.8306581377983093,
0.07870261371135712,
1.076876163482666,
0.7296883463859558,
-0.037278931587934494,
-0.08661139011383057,
-1.0277667045593262,
-0.028713062405586243,
-0.42640480399131775,
0.6896363496780396,
-0.7362582683563232,
-0.1507515162229538,
-0.22119231522083282,
0.05636639520525932,
0.10933750867843628,
-0.5516366958618164,
0.937149167060852,
-0.4192390739917755,
0.03727681562304497,
-0.35872480273246765,
-0.5191946625709534,
-0.2850262224674225,
0.4774174690246582,
-0.3150772750377655,
1.2080917358398438,
-0.1230919286608696,
-0.7646239995956421,
0.6643666625022888,
-0.3200889229774475,
-0.4528057873249054,
0.13838106393814087,
-0.3440588712692261,
-0.5169674158096313,
-0.04294958710670471,
0.2410660982131958,
0.6054882407188416,
-0.031665802001953125,
0.5062087774276733,
-0.5032420754432678,
-0.12769481539726257,
0.07063275575637817,
-0.5094719529151917,
0.8646204471588135,
0.10088309645652771,
-0.41366299986839294,
0.5677107572555542,
-0.6084127426147461,
0.17630618810653687,
-0.06671010702848434,
-0.4681549072265625,
-0.38608378171920776,
0.12040319293737411,
-0.5756805539131165,
0.31929707527160645,
0.24576325714588165,
-0.7935456037521362,
0.30720144510269165,
-0.49502456188201904,
0.6114661693572998,
0.9145382642745972,
-0.13509927690029144,
0.2561224400997162,
-0.2942371666431427,
0.28937774896621704,
0.0578061081469059,
0.15109942853450775,
-0.28039562702178955,
-0.5567290782928467,
-0.7208399772644043,
-0.035790931433439255,
0.19825178384780884,
0.450030654668808,
-0.5304917693138123,
0.6143174171447754,
-0.36813223361968994,
-0.38070249557495117,
-0.15632927417755127,
0.01980813406407833,
0.29928022623062134,
0.6008769273757935,
0.10077983140945435,
-0.38443681597709656,
-0.5221009850502014,
-0.6768254041671753,
0.239070862531662,
-0.6704956889152527,
0.10769367963075638,
0.5995490550994873,
0.35712701082229614,
0.04276634752750397,
1.0343464612960815,
-0.17335501313209534,
0.10560785979032516,
-0.10583719611167908,
-0.038923393934965134,
0.35877251625061035,
0.32718852162361145,
-0.004029967822134495,
-0.6892919540405273,
-0.6162838339805603,
0.4344690144062042,
-0.37029966711997986,
-0.006699026562273502,
0.010626249946653843,
-0.0028358486015349627,
0.5723323225975037,
0.123209148645401,
-0.24636869132518768,
0.22432389855384827,
0.5978849530220032,
-0.3909865915775299,
0.5669187903404236,
-0.42624083161354065,
0.27485793828964233,
-0.7713698148727417,
0.018883470445871353,
0.0833979994058609,
-0.7519124746322632,
-0.36347654461860657,
-0.21112830936908722,
0.07889985293149948,
0.35604387521743774,
-0.38138478994369507,
0.21787051856517792,
-0.1480172872543335,
-0.07443659752607346,
-0.21357329189777374,
-0.29564324021339417,
-0.12824706733226776,
0.508538007736206,
0.45078572630882263,
0.7219142317771912,
0.681232213973999,
-0.394113689661026,
0.21710290014743805,
-0.13320529460906982,
-0.23639236390590668,
0.56314617395401,
-0.46272557973861694,
0.2962106168270111,
0.00025201283278875053,
0.5745490193367004,
-1.1135456562042236,
-0.046591587364673615,
0.1551552563905716,
-0.41531801223754883,
0.08841940760612488,
-0.6711970567703247,
-0.5577697157859802,
-0.3100013732910156,
-0.2342909872531891,
0.16853119432926178,
0.615144670009613,
-0.7589892745018005,
0.8463282585144043,
0.3238757848739624,
0.025665098801255226,
-0.7432965040206909,
-0.1605852246284485,
-0.0882779210805893,
-0.14542745053768158,
-0.835481584072113,
-0.046002451330423355,
-0.15800286829471588,
0.01597479172050953,
-0.43439239263534546,
-0.6735649108886719,
-0.17666596174240112,
0.2604057490825653,
0.6810187697410583,
0.3017900586128235,
-0.053909171372652054,
-0.11020869016647339,
-0.025986231863498688,
-0.31445232033729553,
0.23743274807929993,
-0.3405081629753113,
0.2968169152736664,
-0.46655431389808655,
-0.5612855553627014,
-0.36760804057121277,
-0.07521088421344757,
0.7042030096054077,
-0.39952537417411804,
0.15894387662410736,
0.33558812737464905,
-0.14814788103103638,
-0.2814866900444031,
-0.5926120281219482,
-0.12719686329364777,
-0.44653549790382385,
0.09360054135322571,
-0.7409576773643494,
-1.1784530878067017,
0.08255688101053238,
-0.4435857832431793,
0.38260045647621155,
0.08616899698972702,
0.48518115282058716,
0.0028621042147278786,
1.2690589427947998,
0.19684641063213348,
0.07564276456832886,
0.2480442076921463,
-0.20584237575531006,
0.3385438621044159,
-0.621678352355957,
-0.31377461552619934,
-0.5019538998603821,
0.06218772009015083,
-0.3977009057998657,
-0.5997161269187927,
0.3208056092262268,
0.07147026062011719,
-0.43987512588500977,
0.11267754435539246,
-0.46373459696769714,
0.5653157830238342,
0.6308848857879639,
0.06689272820949554,
0.6450619697570801,
0.05792119354009628,
-0.31967252492904663,
0.025544114410877228,
-0.532924473285675,
-0.6757486462593079,
1.0779566764831543,
0.5916404128074646,
0.30936020612716675,
-0.05719828978180885,
0.8852404952049255,
0.05002138763666153,
0.3142426609992981,
-0.9302610754966736,
0.6957381963729858,
-0.22420144081115723,
-0.38280466198921204,
-0.438804030418396,
-0.5289813280105591,
-0.6887697577476501,
0.2634342610836029,
-0.06731715798377991,
-0.6919118762016296,
-0.1683928668498993,
0.520575225353241,
-0.38848188519477844,
0.3800751566886902,
-0.6976774334907532,
0.8659907579421997,
-0.5135700702667236,
-0.6460475325584412,
-0.25605472922325134,
-0.5110960006713867,
0.5255917906761169,
0.08526338636875153,
0.13749870657920837,
-0.19556570053100586,
0.2048153281211853,
0.523550808429718,
-0.6022064685821533,
0.8066917657852173,
-0.37268123030662537,
-0.09008417278528214,
0.06884200125932693,
0.17391277849674225,
0.8922746181488037,
0.03979383781552315,
-0.03568008542060852,
0.004778325092047453,
0.19468261301517487,
-0.08741719275712967,
-0.6436031460762024,
0.5920146703720093,
-0.7337966561317444,
-0.8978787064552307,
-0.6690812110900879,
-0.1259557157754898,
-0.373359739780426,
0.07008913904428482,
-0.3180391192436218,
0.16175244748592377,
0.13233432173728943,
0.36112916469573975,
0.9612345099449158,
0.013325609266757965,
0.2711082696914673,
0.5235244631767273,
-0.5365883708000183,
-0.3441242575645447,
0.8399617075920105,
-0.053827255964279175,
0.2175087183713913,
0.45718875527381897,
0.6704239249229431,
-0.4549875557422638,
-0.9088216423988342,
-0.5424740314483643,
0.018491100519895554,
-0.5124163627624512,
-0.06787269562482834,
-0.5547515749931335,
-0.24219955503940582,
-0.06550382822751999,
0.04843144491314888,
-0.39215245842933655,
-0.2746983766555786,
0.26766884326934814,
-0.23420925438404083,
0.3914957046508789,
0.4865313172340393,
0.17665867507457733,
0.03133394569158554,
-0.49003493785858154,
0.08403324335813522,
0.6041592359542847,
0.4341898262500763,
-0.09495789557695389,
-0.6421900391578674,
0.11144345253705978,
-0.09396099299192429,
-0.2071271538734436,
-0.5532311797142029,
0.06878312677145004,
-0.13289040327072144,
0.3901386857032776,
0.41993284225463867,
0.025157852098345757,
0.6688424348831177,
-0.4299176037311554,
0.7220975756645203,
0.17094427347183228,
-1.096763014793396,
0.6801674365997314,
-0.0775255486369133,
0.1396401822566986,
0.6571031212806702,
0.23626524209976196,
-0.4638519287109375,
-0.11834602057933807,
-0.7014141082763672,
-0.8839110136032104,
0.8746402263641357,
0.07008951902389526,
-0.26151326298713684,
0.37060225009918213,
0.19414034485816956,
0.24192415177822113,
-0.041292961686849594,
-0.7350654602050781,
-0.26820334792137146,
-0.3302391469478607,
0.1536402851343155,
0.1591329723596573,
-0.22659887373447418,
0.12889030575752258,
-0.42924433946609497,
0.9258057475090027,
-0.41090014576911926,
-0.5140123963356018,
0.19406108558177948,
0.15666654706001282,
-0.13292743265628815,
0.5573437213897705,
0.07589952647686005,
0.5861297845840454,
-0.409368634223938,
0.4146363437175751,
0.21435070037841797,
-0.12281904369592667,
0.45437008142471313,
-0.093054860830307,
-0.5243678092956543,
-0.05512385070323944,
0.045736413449048996,
0.9858512878417969,
-0.18782655894756317,
-0.5213662981987,
0.6228060126304626,
-0.18902945518493652,
-0.2949492037296295,
-0.1709633320569992,
0.11756984889507294,
0.088662289083004,
-0.04827393591403961,
0.023011354729533195,
0.09613998234272003,
0.07269212603569031,
-0.36412426829338074,
0.20062845945358276,
0.6346628665924072,
-0.20352837443351746,
-0.1769018918275833,
0.10788938403129578,
0.2562614977359772,
-0.28832316398620605,
0.2891901731491089,
-0.27335527539253235,
-0.44969215989112854,
0.4315251111984253,
0.31458982825279236,
0.8206698298454285,
-0.26780563592910767,
0.43222907185554504,
0.6864727735519409,
0.12897540628910065,
-0.2979646325111389,
0.12139502912759781,
-0.6673979163169861,
-0.553203284740448,
-0.7239453792572021,
-0.6893826127052307,
-0.6900712847709656,
0.22781342267990112,
-0.10561594367027283,
0.17653226852416992,
-0.6668218970298767,
-0.1649089902639389,
0.006841495633125305,
0.21155187487602234,
-0.3635019361972809,
0.15937334299087524,
0.3143184781074524,
0.8630201816558838,
-0.8485304117202759,
1.217100977897644,
0.9262800812721252,
-0.2150154411792755,
-1.1533253192901611,
-0.10356122255325317,
0.018634000793099403,
-0.6927154660224915,
0.7861631512641907,
0.3527648150920868,
-0.33077526092529297,
-0.13333123922348022,
-0.2834244668483734,
-0.8000746369361877,
0.9968711137771606,
0.3797730803489685,
-0.8148218393325806,
0.0691908746957779,
0.09289778769016266,
0.39095377922058105,
-0.2840745747089386,
0.69273841381073,
0.5031611919403076,
0.5509036183357239,
0.6673682928085327,
-0.971891462802887,
0.15201036632061005,
-0.07571589201688766,
0.005657128989696503,
0.11251875758171082,
-0.4038988947868347,
0.3409728407859802,
-0.12036406993865967,
-0.2143402397632599,
-0.29960137605667114,
0.5691292881965637,
0.7281785011291504,
0.33592846989631653,
0.9594254493713379,
0.5171754956245422,
0.9963603615760803,
-0.10598684847354889,
0.88818359375,
-0.38776805996894836,
0.25988292694091797,
1.3475360870361328,
-0.37842124700546265,
1.002801537513733,
0.47552335262298584,
-0.4038873314857483,
0.607785701751709,
0.8196900486946106,
0.4060681164264679,
0.08690856397151947,
0.3441602289676666,
-0.27164313197135925,
-0.833465039730072,
-0.2486034631729126,
-0.033276140689849854,
0.12228389829397202,
0.21001939475536346,
-0.2810799479484558,
-0.17404566705226898,
-0.41863948106765747,
0.031418971717357635,
0.0038533152546733618,
-0.34958720207214355,
0.7382810711860657,
-0.09256070852279663,
-1.0632305145263672,
0.6145172715187073,
-0.155623659491539,
0.6064326167106628,
-0.7259743213653564,
-0.1448952555656433,
0.03647708520293236,
0.14348630607128143,
-0.4792346954345703,
-1.0173590183258057,
0.11625425517559052,
0.06277751177549362,
-0.074398934841156,
-0.6367615461349487,
0.6530787944793701,
-0.22311048209667206,
-0.25656595826148987,
0.10398119688034058,
0.36000046133995056,
0.014921270310878754,
-0.09751111268997192,
-0.6146559715270996,
0.08939603716135025,
0.26441657543182373,
-0.07898320257663727,
0.14977502822875977,
0.5766499638557434,
-0.26771101355552673,
0.6812604069709778,
0.8788545727729797,
0.11386508494615555,
-0.045221567153930664,
0.05906031280755997,
0.5826180577278137,
-0.4113346338272095,
-0.43426644802093506,
-0.9888252019882202,
0.4626532196998596,
-0.16638651490211487,
-0.11201421916484833,
0.8173662424087524,
0.8119214773178101,
1.0861835479736328,
0.21295428276062012,
0.9482384324073792,
-0.004134288989007473,
0.2470516860485077,
-0.45600825548171997,
0.12361574172973633,
-0.19187889993190765,
0.4366689920425415,
0.002317071659490466,
-0.695881187915802,
-0.24788272380828857,
0.710668683052063,
-0.6841680407524109,
0.011522429063916206,
0.7542082667350769,
0.8474938273429871,
-0.22063569724559784,
0.02134278602898121,
0.3188115358352661,
0.27058711647987366,
0.49329671263694763,
1.085198163986206,
0.9762762188911438,
0.1646336317062378,
0.4778522849082947,
-0.3793944716453552,
-0.5684630870819092,
-0.12566642463207245,
-1.1608210802078247,
-0.8839698433876038,
-0.5291093587875366,
-0.6102309226989746,
-0.50986248254776,
0.1476985663175583,
1.2422558069229126,
1.0266708135604858,
-0.823096513748169,
-0.4137172996997833,
-0.427491694688797,
0.29508090019226074,
-0.12133262306451797,
-0.16333211958408356,
0.39406296610832214,
-0.2861157953739166,
-0.42606380581855774,
0.1845211684703827,
0.5397588610649109,
-0.20219922065734863,
-0.36092284321784973,
-0.3456374704837799,
-0.00953665841370821,
-0.19129423797130585,
0.644976019859314,
0.40359926223754883,
-1.1634842157363892,
-0.34737628698349,
-0.14310431480407715,
0.06484880298376083,
0.5884655117988586,
1.0408170223236084,
-1.0859564542770386,
0.5205038785934448,
0.7344816327095032,
0.7219428420066833,
0.5285024046897888,
0.044458307325839996,
0.3580441176891327,
-0.4063487946987152,
-0.5990860462188721,
0.08147084712982178,
0.5654050707817078,
0.3857264220714569,
-0.271745502948761,
0.3237876892089844,
0.20529359579086304,
-0.6712827682495117,
-0.600932776927948,
0.4198019504547119,
-1.2806167602539062,
0.05814787372946739,
1.3149093389511108,
-0.41832488775253296,
-0.446783185005188,
-0.18706953525543213,
-0.6348791718482971,
0.07302349805831909,
-0.902450442314148,
0.6049805283546448,
0.6194811463356018,
-0.27483829855918884,
-0.1658419966697693,
-0.11950584501028061,
0.5836421251296997,
0.4779133200645447,
-0.8508428335189819,
0.6238923072814941,
0.7016171813011169,
0.46751898527145386,
0.13390696048736572,
0.7706177830696106,
0.04767894744873047,
0.2702256143093109,
-0.6169240474700928,
-0.33415162563323975,
-0.3542546033859253,
-0.321433961391449,
-0.4082759618759155,
0.5878822207450867,
0.6400084495544434,
0.028145426884293556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00379v1 | GraphArena: Benchmarking Large Language Models on Graph Computational Problems | 2024-06-29T09:19:23 | 2024-06-29T09:19:23 | Jianheng Tang, Qifan Zhang, Yuhan Li, Jia Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The "arms race" of Large Language Models (LLMs) demands novel, challenging,
and diverse benchmarks to faithfully examine their progresses. We introduce
GraphArena, a benchmarking tool designed to evaluate LLMs on graph
computational problems using million-scale real-world graphs from diverse
scenarios such as knowledge graphs, social networks, and molecular structures.
GraphArena offers a suite of 10 computational tasks, encompassing four
polynomial-time (e.g., Shortest Distance) and six NP-complete challenges (e.g.,
Travelling Salesman Problem). It features a rigorous evaluation framework that
classifies LLM outputs as correct, suboptimal (feasible but not optimal), or
hallucinatory (properly formatted but infeasible). Evaluation of 10 leading
LLMs, including GPT-4o and LLaMA3-70B-Instruct, reveals that even
top-performing models struggle with larger, more complex graph problems and
exhibit hallucination issues. Despite the application of strategies such as
chain-of-thought prompting, these issues remain unresolved. GraphArena
contributes a valuable supplement to the existing LLM benchmarks and is
open-sourced at https://github.com/squareRoot3/GraphArena. | [
-0.3075500428676605,
-0.8476774096488953,
0.7038658857345581,
0.2347865253686905,
0.024502309039235115,
0.5734899640083313,
-0.3602791130542755,
-0.5788907408714294,
0.19567203521728516,
0.5657524466514587,
-0.280425101518631,
-0.6690579056739807,
-0.8333228230476379,
0.1608007401227951,
-0.4894353151321411,
0.49048322439193726,
-0.204510897397995,
0.1295323371887207,
-0.21258842945098877,
-0.32139864563941956,
-0.22662688791751862,
-0.64869225025177,
-0.8204412460327148,
-0.36102622747421265,
0.7828961610794067,
0.1740727722644806,
0.5657577514648438,
0.49869614839553833,
0.39280787110328674,
0.36769238114356995,
-0.1922423392534256,
0.507850706577301,
-0.6466050744056702,
0.28641316294670105,
0.020046519115567207,
-0.27686160802841187,
-0.34938737750053406,
-0.09598450362682343,
0.6424591541290283,
0.9898819923400879,
0.12776325643062592,
0.3473837375640869,
-0.098457470536232,
0.6707690358161926,
-0.6044303774833679,
0.32372573018074036,
-0.6676003932952881,
-0.11826272308826447,
-0.3230423927307129,
0.3021012246608734,
-0.23108109831809998,
-0.5755522847175598,
-0.23244449496269226,
-0.516334056854248,
-0.09392780810594559,
0.34064438939094543,
0.7470983266830444,
0.057119738310575485,
-0.37830883264541626,
-0.19033852219581604,
-0.617910623550415,
0.23669645190238953,
-0.44314339756965637,
0.43798139691352844,
0.16690005362033844,
0.5383111238479614,
-0.43961474299430847,
-0.7873415350914001,
-0.5386919975280762,
-0.28022870421409607,
0.48105916380882263,
-0.18142709136009216,
-0.7290904521942139,
-0.12073393166065216,
0.31870710849761963,
-0.02582589164376259,
-0.6401614546775818,
0.30155083537101746,
-0.32962337136268616,
-0.1432618796825409,
0.42627274990081787,
0.14960616827011108,
0.3511464595794678,
0.21234913170337677,
0.16731782257556915,
-0.32106292247772217,
-0.857742428779602,
-0.34890487790107727,
0.7029797434806824,
0.46743929386138916,
0.08606062829494476,
0.5883882641792297,
-0.13857822120189667,
0.6726589798927307,
-0.3701642155647278,
0.5521978139877319,
0.3037313222885132,
0.01568366214632988,
0.005572274327278137,
-0.0837438553571701,
0.9180054664611816,
0.3081495463848114,
0.4789385497570038,
-0.43597206473350525,
-0.016072269529104233,
0.3146834671497345,
0.12141074240207672,
-0.9570052623748779,
-0.31628528237342834,
0.16565965116024017,
-0.10646693408489227,
-0.2281051129102707,
-0.4362698495388031,
-1.0153851509094238,
-0.4140280485153198,
-0.022109299898147583,
0.25665026903152466,
-0.16703416407108307,
-0.17121635377407074,
-0.05435784533619881,
-0.09005684405565262,
-0.23924852907657623,
0.17656637728214264,
-0.6834760904312134,
0.5403373837471008,
0.9408276081085205,
1.2351210117340088,
-0.30989494919776917,
-0.4218626022338867,
-0.6694071292877197,
-0.08381740748882294,
-0.6605282425880432,
1.084351897239685,
-0.6655033230781555,
-0.29605135321617126,
-0.07102823257446289,
-0.008725695312023163,
-0.2883179187774658,
-0.8347580432891846,
0.19894391298294067,
-0.39671790599823,
-0.42702516913414,
-0.27109453082084656,
-0.44251102209091187,
-0.1270887553691864,
0.35395100712776184,
-0.940034031867981,
1.084878921508789,
0.13895858824253082,
-0.4881565570831299,
-0.08848710358142853,
-0.45647427439689636,
-0.43309536576271057,
-0.04406020790338516,
-0.2947194576263428,
-0.31865769624710083,
0.026956722140312195,
0.028299733996391296,
0.17234492301940918,
-0.6263512969017029,
0.2148333638906479,
-0.6515273451805115,
-0.3622191250324249,
0.2511238157749176,
-0.17029589414596558,
0.5864713788032532,
0.1614377349615097,
-0.43223512172698975,
0.485722154378891,
-0.670191764831543,
0.0471205972135067,
0.36448097229003906,
0.1651904433965683,
-0.13242730498313904,
-0.020138908177614212,
0.07056008279323578,
0.011299886740744114,
0.22943635284900665,
-0.40246084332466125,
0.21021239459514618,
-0.27575862407684326,
0.7557225823402405,
0.8808515667915344,
-0.11842789500951767,
-0.23128972947597504,
-0.21581335365772247,
0.6911623477935791,
-0.3172600269317627,
0.07590264827013016,
0.32603710889816284,
-0.5090132355690002,
-0.6713016033172607,
-0.11808609217405319,
0.3204960227012634,
0.5101346373558044,
-0.4235079884529114,
0.10617272555828094,
-0.3851311206817627,
-0.8998984098434448,
-0.22319361567497253,
0.04788423329591751,
0.45398449897766113,
0.31817713379859924,
0.22573740780353546,
-0.16666647791862488,
-0.40939971804618835,
-0.7740164399147034,
-0.23834548890590668,
-0.12736675143241882,
0.17896077036857605,
0.3825821876525879,
0.642122745513916,
-0.2753960192203522,
0.38103726506233215,
-0.5476984977722168,
-0.34820064902305603,
-0.19136491417884827,
0.04888995736837387,
0.03369573876261711,
0.11612766981124878,
0.3977357745170593,
-0.30258673429489136,
-0.2718126177787781,
0.3880821168422699,
-0.82718825340271,
-0.2113686501979828,
0.39183416962623596,
-0.08851682394742966,
0.02919045463204384,
0.6488528847694397,
-0.6913392543792725,
0.0026283590123057365,
0.8828843832015991,
-0.1553785800933838,
0.5442703366279602,
-0.1058855950832367,
0.13420996069908142,
-1.0091540813446045,
0.31899333000183105,
-0.17695976793766022,
-0.29233407974243164,
-0.30245324969291687,
0.17105379700660706,
-0.2274702489376068,
-0.48128145933151245,
-0.17426325380802155,
0.5926399827003479,
-0.44531798362731934,
-0.48059511184692383,
-0.19359923899173737,
0.57245934009552,
-0.05688536912202835,
0.3470684289932251,
-0.3994554579257965,
1.0475152730941772,
0.44270429015159607,
-0.18448133766651154,
0.27054858207702637,
0.03409059718251228,
-0.3953363299369812,
0.10533970594406128,
-0.7183650135993958,
0.5581656098365784,
0.1275506168603897,
0.27946949005126953,
-1.0703208446502686,
0.010619415901601315,
0.137733593583107,
-0.1450764238834381,
-0.16035154461860657,
-0.18982213735580444,
-0.7875413298606873,
-0.3824704885482788,
-0.07394551485776901,
0.5826407670974731,
0.29927858710289,
-0.4180286228656769,
0.7859490513801575,
0.6555876731872559,
-0.12323880195617676,
-0.37735751271247864,
-0.23589733242988586,
0.3797704577445984,
-0.1779317408800125,
-0.4218827486038208,
0.24727770686149597,
0.01743297278881073,
-0.2734639644622803,
0.0316120907664299,
-0.061319585889577866,
0.09558971971273422,
0.267201691865921,
0.27098459005355835,
0.01677791029214859,
-0.028450259938836098,
-0.10936808586120605,
-0.08507027477025986,
-0.14521902799606323,
0.1933206021785736,
-0.39779362082481384,
0.9550309181213379,
-0.2064971625804901,
-0.417374849319458,
0.07061674445867538,
0.3452414274215698,
0.5163779258728027,
-0.25409382581710815,
0.2935047447681427,
0.23291490972042084,
-0.4848421514034271,
-0.2974716126918793,
-0.4409601092338562,
0.0457463376224041,
-0.40403276681900024,
0.6022520661354065,
-0.43783333897590637,
-0.9978190660476685,
0.9176562428474426,
-0.5935473442077637,
-0.154542937874794,
0.3764818608760834,
0.534341037273407,
0.35545194149017334,
1.1647320985794067,
0.24727816879749298,
-0.26052165031433105,
0.2442236989736557,
-0.3931710124015808,
0.34466394782066345,
-0.8154610991477966,
-0.1532466858625412,
-0.8833261728286743,
-0.18156202137470245,
-0.4190627336502075,
-0.6740270256996155,
0.34621942043304443,
0.06633057445287704,
-0.3952640891075134,
0.5229945778846741,
-0.4151462912559509,
0.6149888634681702,
0.13228434324264526,
-0.02403516136109829,
0.37597784399986267,
-0.09071529656648636,
-0.24382181465625763,
0.2877015769481659,
-0.7102347612380981,
-0.5413185954093933,
1.2221776247024536,
0.10447122901678085,
0.5634046196937561,
0.13335125148296356,
0.5553466081619263,
0.28991127014160156,
0.4871372878551483,
-0.6178186535835266,
0.7391431331634521,
-0.3348989188671112,
-0.2935151755809784,
-0.18078042566776276,
-0.6910954713821411,
-1.276653528213501,
0.35909751057624817,
0.13248902559280396,
-1.0421507358551025,
0.00464548310264945,
0.15761195123195648,
-0.03863494470715523,
0.4043702185153961,
-0.41699686646461487,
1.2638704776763916,
-0.34134334325790405,
-0.33384931087493896,
-0.3492148816585541,
-0.12130047380924225,
0.10831111669540405,
-0.17725501954555511,
0.3556358218193054,
-0.515505850315094,
0.09122226387262344,
0.7707886099815369,
-0.5471630096435547,
0.8239160180091858,
-0.06344712525606155,
-0.07460915297269821,
0.11706921458244324,
0.3482525944709778,
0.6885687708854675,
-0.17879372835159302,
-0.04435953125357628,
0.4679418206214905,
0.05666591599583626,
-0.25038766860961914,
-0.6023555994033813,
0.8495231866836548,
-0.789833128452301,
-0.44929149746894836,
-0.507784903049469,
-0.37796342372894287,
-0.4756142497062683,
0.5245257019996643,
0.24953658878803253,
0.415683776140213,
-0.40358224511146545,
-0.1649012714624405,
0.5608157515525818,
0.03789254650473595,
0.019450044259428978,
0.15173162519931793,
-0.6878676414489746,
-0.5208077430725098,
0.9639125466346741,
0.3422195315361023,
0.17046299576759338,
0.07129015773534775,
0.07782144844532013,
-0.20827338099479675,
-0.9026222229003906,
-0.6899910569190979,
0.15657545626163483,
-0.9721028804779053,
-0.23364782333374023,
-0.6741287708282471,
-0.02983991429209709,
-0.2084454447031021,
0.19898134469985962,
-0.6296787858009338,
-0.29803237318992615,
0.04234125837683678,
-0.05481916293501854,
0.381902277469635,
0.8212290406227112,
0.2579939663410187,
0.05644487589597702,
-0.33828476071357727,
0.2314964085817337,
0.070824034512043,
0.4010622501373291,
0.32580798864364624,
-0.1441306322813034,
-0.18840168416500092,
-0.2977920174598694,
-0.10473674535751343,
-0.7019019722938538,
0.1910945177078247,
-0.019573090597987175,
0.49810707569122314,
0.03326448053121567,
-0.20329298079013824,
0.8542449474334717,
-0.672273576259613,
0.39561644196510315,
-0.04033465310931206,
-0.8679824471473694,
0.18438726663589478,
-0.298040509223938,
0.12828563153743744,
0.7296438217163086,
0.3326665163040161,
-0.4921095073223114,
-0.39876824617385864,
-0.20954109728336334,
-1.0760470628738403,
0.044313061982393265,
0.2056446373462677,
0.008890352211892605,
-0.2665965259075165,
0.14799831807613373,
-0.1534872055053711,
0.16253308951854706,
-0.4356774389743805,
-0.16068720817565918,
-0.011358904652297497,
-0.2128583788871765,
-0.1853051334619522,
0.12360173463821411,
-0.3300148844718933,
0.0196278877556324,
0.5307960510253906,
-0.36295080184936523,
0.21300002932548523,
0.0065827141515910625,
-0.3266780972480774,
-0.024853557348251343,
-0.11515234410762787,
0.5610787868499756,
0.791701078414917,
-0.07132550328969955,
0.22850856184959412,
0.17728963494300842,
-0.2671973407268524,
0.06809058785438538,
0.36625710129737854,
-0.11338549852371216,
-0.21167677640914917,
0.434546560049057,
0.7338352203369141,
0.2983334958553314,
-1.023805856704712,
0.2412293553352356,
-0.1204729825258255,
-0.17689964175224304,
-0.43001440167427063,
-0.03958757966756821,
0.29913219809532166,
0.33872148394584656,
0.3198303282260895,
-0.08864112943410873,
0.16095000505447388,
-0.4800896942615509,
-0.024171384051442146,
0.5649415254592896,
-0.3951783776283264,
-0.25294890999794006,
0.7241972088813782,
-0.07456326484680176,
-0.42187270522117615,
0.48220276832580566,
-0.2723695635795593,
-0.6129059791564941,
0.7302483916282654,
0.6115566492080688,
1.0903651714324951,
0.17310650646686554,
0.05526506528258324,
0.19739098846912384,
0.2307257354259491,
-0.11453740298748016,
0.24901120364665985,
0.21511177718639374,
-0.6310437917709351,
-0.39821937680244446,
-0.44011232256889343,
-0.6453649401664734,
0.03848407417535782,
-0.27031075954437256,
-0.09206272661685944,
-0.6460877656936646,
-0.3538106381893158,
0.26429566740989685,
-0.007568401284515858,
-0.4362628161907196,
-0.3663974106311798,
-0.12227467447519302,
0.8290672302246094,
-0.7866230010986328,
0.6252216696739197,
0.3831830322742462,
-0.16335316002368927,
-0.8327935338020325,
-0.1486247032880783,
0.05059829354286194,
-0.7396995425224304,
0.5054023265838623,
0.2531898021697998,
-0.7259705066680908,
0.04816696420311928,
-0.12306917458772659,
-0.7977586388587952,
0.8842944502830505,
0.651646614074707,
-0.8351806402206421,
0.050198428332805634,
0.04754822701215744,
0.6103660464286804,
-0.4515446424484253,
0.16271713376045227,
0.5448604226112366,
0.5124096870422363,
-0.16450659930706024,
-0.6966904401779175,
0.2176285833120346,
-0.4804820418357849,
0.10351977497339249,
0.31830233335494995,
-0.9864898324012756,
0.737555205821991,
0.021692318841814995,
-0.11605052649974823,
0.16180817782878876,
0.3843388259410858,
0.38187211751937866,
0.23136304318904877,
0.5213032364845276,
0.5900459289550781,
1.0554319620132446,
-0.10662291198968887,
1.0067099332809448,
-0.5075670480728149,
0.23341545462608337,
1.0652790069580078,
-0.9204826354980469,
0.8799003958702087,
0.17593218386173248,
-0.3606031537055969,
0.5275993347167969,
0.673568844795227,
-0.1462816447019577,
0.08283073455095291,
0.6533415913581848,
-0.09133801609277725,
-0.21844884753227234,
-0.18835245072841644,
-0.33009690046310425,
0.41314899921417236,
0.1612517535686493,
-0.0002959529228974134,
-0.20587323606014252,
-0.09761801362037659,
0.25482121109962463,
0.2950105369091034,
-0.11903182417154312,
0.5780671238899231,
0.07347371429204941,
-0.5860238671302795,
0.7078478932380676,
-0.1563551425933838,
0.12902742624282837,
-0.5873437523841858,
-0.10521313548088074,
-0.37723782658576965,
0.17401069402694702,
0.05081557482481003,
-0.31697309017181396,
0.18422240018844604,
0.09553294628858566,
0.005331701599061489,
0.2237476110458374,
0.44126543402671814,
-0.1772305965423584,
-0.7618099451065063,
0.8573079109191895,
0.3133302330970764,
0.23435860872268677,
-0.2552838623523712,
-0.5854800343513489,
0.7205016613006592,
-0.3244926333427429,
-0.10340822488069534,
0.4715995490550995,
0.3316565454006195,
-0.5130956172943115,
1.003554105758667,
0.6600155234336853,
0.24179895222187042,
-0.10028579831123352,
0.5074144601821899,
1.0741887092590332,
-0.5141512155532837,
-0.28981703519821167,
-0.8864083886146545,
-0.33888840675354004,
-0.19168590009212494,
-0.354301393032074,
0.873012363910675,
1.0099985599517822,
0.6004676818847656,
0.21281328797340393,
0.7216975688934326,
0.2241552472114563,
0.1855321079492569,
-0.5171396732330322,
0.7774404883384705,
-0.3549758195877075,
0.17233332991600037,
-0.44815221428871155,
-1.0778971910476685,
-0.3520953059196472,
0.49870145320892334,
-0.31858205795288086,
0.12487580627202988,
0.7282082438468933,
0.8262036442756653,
0.11357027292251587,
-0.16238810122013092,
0.07382011413574219,
0.1584911346435547,
0.3923476040363312,
0.6703089475631714,
0.7933293581008911,
-0.32017800211906433,
0.7515590190887451,
0.025456640869379044,
-0.13670235872268677,
-0.10762583464384079,
-0.7953002452850342,
-1.0106614828109741,
-0.5526388883590698,
-0.3301942050457001,
-0.5748664736747742,
0.42565828561782837,
0.80164635181427,
0.8133073449134827,
-0.7810863852500916,
-0.5308486819267273,
-0.16719861328601837,
0.2887051999568939,
-0.41108790040016174,
-0.1208309754729271,
0.471125990152359,
-0.06109832599759102,
-0.6965765357017517,
0.592025876045227,
0.3873002827167511,
-0.06162010133266449,
-0.4288381040096283,
0.11439149081707001,
0.010401277802884579,
-0.03032805025577545,
0.5963935256004333,
0.3872181475162506,
-0.47890523076057434,
-0.3573479652404785,
-0.06337407976388931,
0.028193563222885132,
0.12462027370929718,
0.926712155342102,
-0.4703527092933655,
0.183468297123909,
0.2640046179294586,
0.7938862442970276,
0.9957049489021301,
-0.13680332899093628,
0.49497100710868835,
-0.26765039563179016,
0.07393668591976166,
0.21689289808273315,
0.3368963301181793,
0.31484895944595337,
0.015613885596394539,
0.634109377861023,
0.13143733143806458,
-0.5537511110305786,
-1.109830617904663,
0.2589665651321411,
-0.8804368376731873,
-0.3749973773956299,
0.796566903591156,
-0.13479165732860565,
-0.42925843596458435,
-0.0633339211344719,
0.04790736734867096,
0.17047257721424103,
-0.16061384975910187,
0.7606763243675232,
0.6530676484107971,
-0.10884615778923035,
-0.06834547221660614,
-0.7293825149536133,
0.26714691519737244,
0.28399986028671265,
-0.9689049124717712,
0.5589205622673035,
0.5101845264434814,
0.2683814764022827,
0.0641627237200737,
0.6046536564826965,
-0.11582138389348984,
0.039694949984550476,
0.17123465240001678,
-0.0008200604352168739,
-0.3031975328922272,
-0.532781720161438,
-0.14380671083927155,
0.2522841691970825,
0.31083711981773376,
0.23947939276695251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00377v1 | The Factuality Tax of Diversity-Intervened Text-to-Image Generation: Benchmark and Fact-Augmented Intervention | 2024-06-29T09:09:42 | 2024-06-29T09:09:42 | Yixin Wan, Di Wu, Haoran Wang, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY | Prompt-based "diversity interventions" are commonly adopted to improve the
diversity of Text-to-Image (T2I) models depicting individuals with various
racial or gender traits. However, will this strategy result in nonfactual
demographic distribution, especially when generating real historical figures?
In this work, we propose DemOgraphic FActualIty Representation (DoFaiR), a
benchmark to systematically quantify the trade-off between using diversity
interventions and preserving demographic factuality in T2I models. DoFaiR
consists of 756 meticulously fact-checked test instances to reveal the
factuality tax of various diversity prompts through an automated
evidence-supported evaluation pipeline. Experiments on DoFaiR unveil that
diversity-oriented instructions increase the number of different gender and
racial groups in DALLE-3's generations at the cost of historically inaccurate
demographic distributions. To resolve this issue, we propose Fact-Augmented
Intervention (FAI), which instructs a Large Language Model (LLM) to reflect on
verbalized or retrieved factual information about gender and racial
compositions of generation subjects in history, and incorporate it into the
generation context of T2I models. By orienting model generations using the
reflected historical truths, FAI significantly improves the demographic
factuality under diversity interventions while preserving diversity. | [
-0.39071160554885864,
-0.3469831943511963,
0.30660495162010193,
0.27524852752685547,
0.008234800770878792,
0.13698413968086243,
-0.13526763021945953,
-0.14246606826782227,
0.09640286862850189,
0.4438644349575043,
-0.49329641461372375,
-0.2024434208869934,
-0.5520969033241272,
0.03811050206422806,
0.12212814390659332,
0.9493935108184814,
0.1014682725071907,
0.06311914324760437,
-0.1696380376815796,
-0.24428333342075348,
-0.4648764729499817,
-0.510429322719574,
-0.3220861852169037,
0.1437431424856186,
0.43261733651161194,
0.5741202235221863,
0.4993356466293335,
0.7033154368400574,
0.2227218747138977,
0.21173106133937836,
-0.16317619383335114,
0.35125741362571716,
-0.9855403900146484,
-0.13902893662452698,
-0.3461797833442688,
-0.39705246686935425,
-0.15789708495140076,
0.33751413226127625,
0.6829290986061096,
0.7264108657836914,
-0.06017607823014259,
0.20833824574947357,
-0.17615507543087006,
0.5356500744819641,
-0.9408835768699646,
-0.047144342213869095,
-0.3911743760108948,
-0.25001129508018494,
-0.3531258702278137,
-0.32047033309936523,
-0.42904794216156006,
-0.7684113383293152,
-0.17644312977790833,
-0.199393168091774,
0.6381754279136658,
-0.02624610997736454,
0.47796830534935,
0.24019822478294373,
-0.8020614981651306,
-0.14280208945274353,
-0.9932500123977661,
0.9695420265197754,
-0.46520864963531494,
0.337545782327652,
0.263216495513916,
0.06314275413751602,
-0.24843955039978027,
-0.46154308319091797,
-0.6956137418746948,
-0.25714123249053955,
-0.018721040338277817,
0.3182481825351715,
-0.14242511987686157,
-0.3808766007423401,
0.3549429476261139,
0.21952928602695465,
-0.36238807439804077,
-0.05050138756632805,
-0.496612012386322,
-0.3053741157054901,
0.7283715605735779,
0.1356714814901352,
0.41388973593711853,
-0.13381987810134888,
-0.40982764959335327,
-0.3249814212322235,
-0.7028583288192749,
-0.012687365524470806,
0.5765613317489624,
0.33652010560035706,
-0.387866348028183,
0.7466038465499878,
-0.1427040845155716,
0.25722047686576843,
0.26115986704826355,
-0.21671703457832336,
0.39716291427612305,
-0.6941165924072266,
0.3015179932117462,
0.05663387477397919,
0.47888070344924927,
0.6284464597702026,
0.09449342638254166,
-0.13061551749706268,
-0.08822234719991684,
0.11623542010784149,
-0.04661477357149124,
-1.02412748336792,
0.04694722220301628,
-0.014314545318484306,
-0.41225549578666687,
-0.3186572790145874,
0.03555125743150711,
-1.0827949047088623,
-0.3785353899002075,
0.0809144601225853,
0.1251779943704605,
-0.368886262178421,
-0.5843493342399597,
-0.1304706186056137,
-0.6043033003807068,
0.15578535199165344,
0.5032052397727966,
-0.9664708375930786,
0.12448777258396149,
0.4494861662387848,
0.7313556671142578,
-0.04895766079425812,
0.13554199039936066,
-0.46508973836898804,
0.3112335801124573,
-0.3853312134742737,
0.8082908391952515,
-0.6684158444404602,
-0.7611014246940613,
-0.05370543897151947,
-0.16381283104419708,
-0.17660734057426453,
-0.5572932362556458,
0.47581470012664795,
-0.5159198045730591,
0.25265738368034363,
-0.7522447109222412,
-0.4898451566696167,
-0.10729367285966873,
0.2207869291305542,
-0.8813809752464294,
0.796805739402771,
0.26142045855522156,
-0.9109877943992615,
0.7851650714874268,
-0.5817724466323853,
-0.16796167194843292,
0.26050499081611633,
-0.31230229139328003,
-0.4596133530139923,
-0.1259250044822693,
0.17528855800628662,
-0.01639208197593689,
-0.24680788815021515,
0.4087464213371277,
-0.4918869733810425,
-0.32195165753364563,
0.218170627951622,
-0.6190888285636902,
0.8125095963478088,
0.004675739910453558,
-0.5603213310241699,
-0.40026405453681946,
-0.6217645406723022,
-0.5460214614868164,
0.08400998264551163,
-0.3112112283706665,
-0.09607837349176407,
-0.0714820846915245,
0.09037678688764572,
-0.019863024353981018,
0.17221711575984955,
-0.8378019332885742,
0.06578574329614639,
-0.08926038444042206,
-0.2815363109111786,
0.36368441581726074,
0.27896106243133545,
0.40397322177886963,
-0.6815493702888489,
0.35959815979003906,
0.19502823054790497,
-0.03206757456064224,
-0.017377065494656563,
-0.5935500264167786,
-0.5172452330589294,
-0.689333975315094,
0.29725027084350586,
0.4918583631515503,
-0.9620829820632935,
0.18954476714134216,
-0.49612924456596375,
-0.318671852350235,
0.10512332618236542,
-0.2514370381832123,
0.06480234116315842,
0.8590565323829651,
0.16829441487789154,
0.036297641694545746,
-0.5134525895118713,
-0.7811625003814697,
-0.025484057143330574,
-0.8351067900657654,
0.17265082895755768,
0.28435155749320984,
0.671859622001648,
-0.06963233649730682,
1.086211085319519,
-0.39918944239616394,
0.06056598946452141,
0.05971434339880943,
0.7395420670509338,
-0.029585540294647217,
0.6313385963439941,
1.0316461324691772,
-0.9291859269142151,
-0.014634959399700165,
-0.1960388869047165,
-0.558296263217926,
-0.2637069821357727,
-0.07180210947990417,
-0.12404624372720718,
0.3323028087615967,
-0.03666355088353157,
-0.27187156677246094,
0.6919447183609009,
0.4102703928947449,
-0.29436010122299194,
0.31193673610687256,
-0.03057480789721012,
0.8229357004165649,
-0.6784504055976868,
0.2751821279525757,
0.08590064197778702,
-0.05746211111545563,
-0.6464557647705078,
-0.2196180671453476,
0.17686140537261963,
-0.028790747746825218,
-0.31523001194000244,
0.6338173151016235,
-0.0004487561818677932,
0.08319962024688721,
-0.049007683992385864,
-0.3671172261238098,
-0.1060609444975853,
0.34438690543174744,
0.16840316355228424,
1.1561003923416138,
-0.07989086955785751,
-0.31747403740882874,
-0.04403292387723923,
0.30108633637428284,
-0.09872031956911087,
0.6665074825286865,
-0.3036314845085144,
0.13216115534305573,
-0.5498268008232117,
0.44776496291160583,
-1.0814154148101807,
-0.36355432868003845,
0.43382102251052856,
-0.37156492471694946,
0.1369142085313797,
-0.22906483709812164,
-0.3389861285686493,
-0.1300470232963562,
-0.7256901860237122,
0.768622875213623,
0.6707326769828796,
-0.6777951121330261,
0.716482400894165,
0.1673317551612854,
-0.12281914055347443,
-0.645953357219696,
-0.6083834171295166,
0.19422794878482819,
-0.23244608938694,
-0.9396716356277466,
0.27711984515190125,
-0.1888876110315323,
-0.3344232738018036,
0.0030103828758001328,
0.1012401282787323,
-0.08571682125329971,
-0.014208237640559673,
-0.025179332122206688,
0.5390180349349976,
-0.152443528175354,
0.14707337319850922,
0.13612212240695953,
0.3268674910068512,
-0.18032820522785187,
0.025096487253904343,
0.298248827457428,
0.4459957182407379,
-0.23510174453258514,
-0.1539037972688675,
0.3681063652038574,
0.2292640656232834,
-0.2714979946613312,
0.9432286620140076,
0.3277444541454315,
-0.10524298995733261,
0.03060760535299778,
-0.9475993514060974,
0.012611573562026024,
-0.422934353351593,
0.04676751792430878,
-0.016879625618457794,
-0.9636837840080261,
0.3674004375934601,
-0.18321377038955688,
0.37303388118743896,
0.547936201095581,
0.6345847845077515,
-0.15838193893432617,
0.7586231231689453,
0.08893857151269913,
0.3658078908920288,
0.4452287256717682,
-0.32349127531051636,
-0.2503150701522827,
-0.5081683397293091,
-0.5343078970909119,
-0.45124509930610657,
-0.14573542773723602,
-0.6033139824867249,
-0.8594349026679993,
0.4164811372756958,
-0.1231173500418663,
-0.33704498410224915,
-0.17751681804656982,
0.08456508815288544,
0.05824778228998184,
0.34020665287971497,
0.22255709767341614,
0.017017850652337074,
0.24320794641971588,
0.28092536330223083,
-0.12525297701358795,
-0.348113477230072,
-0.474619597196579,
1.2896994352340698,
0.019486960023641586,
0.4606901705265045,
0.47033241391181946,
1.0075851678848267,
0.9157463908195496,
0.7539054155349731,
-0.4915545880794525,
0.35819485783576965,
-0.32671740651130676,
-0.7975502014160156,
-0.015216614119708538,
-0.7573035955429077,
-0.7240950465202332,
-0.11057109385728836,
-0.2555530369281769,
-0.5117578506469727,
1.107826828956604,
0.449677973985672,
-0.20014241337776184,
0.2688329219818115,
-0.582490086555481,
0.49439266324043274,
-0.013668680563569069,
-0.368947297334671,
-0.28606024384498596,
-0.23605695366859436,
0.637138307094574,
-0.3828299641609192,
0.3271365761756897,
-0.058044858276844025,
-0.20304332673549652,
0.5786901712417603,
-0.5136474967002869,
0.8657147288322449,
-0.45256301760673523,
0.03392099589109421,
0.18867972493171692,
-0.030085351318120956,
0.5731495022773743,
0.018582088872790337,
-0.37535759806632996,
0.2054174840450287,
-0.27691003680229187,
-0.5539112687110901,
-0.6732737421989441,
0.3507678210735321,
-0.8088628053665161,
-0.6762662529945374,
-0.24746166169643402,
-0.6816937923431396,
-0.24989308416843414,
-0.2939310073852539,
0.10349441319704056,
0.7073511481285095,
-0.6238551139831543,
0.021277403458952904,
0.5559783577919006,
-0.09742456674575806,
0.36119428277015686,
0.4085361063480377,
0.004298410844057798,
-0.7777754068374634,
0.9425144195556641,
0.21524164080619812,
0.21755142509937286,
0.11421528458595276,
0.11838849633932114,
-0.4243879020214081,
-0.3324523866176605,
-0.4550422430038452,
0.5299593210220337,
-0.8617351651191711,
0.0887933298945427,
-0.6525289416313171,
0.11797033995389938,
-0.5626021027565002,
0.07174219191074371,
-0.004297275096178055,
-0.574921727180481,
-0.2283080369234085,
0.04632040485739708,
0.4426648020744324,
0.5511617660522461,
-0.45108968019485474,
0.3453172743320465,
-0.5925436615943909,
0.3782534897327423,
0.4684116542339325,
0.03164460510015488,
-0.10324378311634064,
-0.7014802098274231,
-0.12400572001934052,
0.272453248500824,
-0.12659451365470886,
-0.8614164590835571,
-0.0742778405547142,
0.15581679344177246,
0.47215139865875244,
0.1409849226474762,
0.27375808358192444,
0.5177252292633057,
-0.35367849469184875,
0.8166730999946594,
0.34387680888175964,
-0.6223562955856323,
0.2613976001739502,
-0.32659536600112915,
0.02494239993393421,
0.48895394802093506,
0.10576304793357849,
-0.3325313329696655,
-0.26594868302345276,
-0.47189849615097046,
-0.4038907587528229,
0.898107647895813,
0.6060704588890076,
0.21680061519145966,
-0.2612950801849365,
0.24072995781898499,
0.13957320153713226,
0.12598054111003876,
-0.3795045018196106,
-0.17501084506511688,
-0.6238651275634766,
-0.497281551361084,
0.3977665603160858,
-0.5026856660842896,
-0.4121253788471222,
0.12977904081344604,
0.5279244184494019,
-0.004304599482566118,
0.013560313731431961,
0.2517758905887604,
-0.0528152734041214,
-0.14363016188144684,
0.2604508697986603,
0.6664672493934631,
0.6504227519035339,
-0.34984493255615234,
-0.07263685017824173,
0.05167151242494583,
-0.5184930562973022,
0.3199976086616516,
0.31672364473342896,
-0.46912676095962524,
-0.07698553055524826,
0.5794252753257751,
0.9487859606742859,
-0.25417932868003845,
-0.400228351354599,
0.59421306848526,
-0.10846752673387527,
-0.309727281332016,
-0.07896590232849121,
0.16877040266990662,
-0.08792169392108917,
0.3407747149467468,
0.573930561542511,
0.31897735595703125,
0.18163105845451355,
-0.5156781673431396,
0.14153018593788147,
0.3328750431537628,
-0.05961871147155762,
-0.24402464926242828,
0.6997008323669434,
0.5003500580787659,
-0.03344200551509857,
0.4188457429409027,
-0.21527518332004547,
-0.3651798963546753,
0.8176366090774536,
0.46966737508773804,
0.5654978156089783,
-0.30818429589271545,
0.6021206378936768,
0.6054726839065552,
0.2878616154193878,
-0.14547720551490784,
0.6026832461357117,
0.056473758071660995,
-0.7415209412574768,
-0.36258843541145325,
-0.10225608199834824,
-0.2604869604110718,
-0.21808962523937225,
-0.4009839594364166,
0.27974772453308105,
-0.539858341217041,
-0.34812891483306885,
0.05274158716201782,
-0.2603148818016052,
-0.6664334535598755,
0.5604210495948792,
0.5725605487823486,
0.6916464567184448,
-0.9742923974990845,
0.3281230032444,
0.5280587077140808,
-0.47641298174858093,
-0.6359296441078186,
0.489772766828537,
0.1882711946964264,
-0.7011817693710327,
1.2113513946533203,
0.012516286224126816,
-0.2631787061691284,
-0.11899098753929138,
-0.7666029930114746,
-0.7797073721885681,
0.8799709677696228,
0.672440767288208,
-0.5309585928916931,
0.3670448064804077,
0.3003246486186981,
0.15021367371082306,
-0.41346314549446106,
0.34012100100517273,
0.42481157183647156,
0.6375958323478699,
0.5617314577102661,
-0.42341378331184387,
0.10484682023525238,
-0.22449126839637756,
0.3811759352684021,
0.122068852186203,
-0.6075927019119263,
0.6760061979293823,
-0.189545139670372,
-0.5520886182785034,
0.16155675053596497,
0.8477484583854675,
0.6661020517349243,
0.4703596830368042,
1.0686148405075073,
0.21400150656700134,
0.700469970703125,
-0.03558272123336792,
1.1675903797149658,
-0.17764902114868164,
0.25230124592781067,
0.5845875144004822,
-0.3585881292819977,
0.312334805727005,
0.5277038216590881,
-0.2809257209300995,
0.45813149213790894,
0.4609912931919098,
-0.30051329731941223,
0.534107506275177,
-0.2309916615486145,
-0.5750669836997986,
-0.11415888369083405,
-0.7747007012367249,
-0.2716849148273468,
0.19886331260204315,
0.10120771825313568,
-0.06456952542066574,
-0.20690543949604034,
-0.162689670920372,
0.3351643681526184,
0.15435437858104706,
-0.07124035060405731,
0.4451659321784973,
-0.3722815215587616,
-0.5946456789970398,
0.3558412790298462,
-0.2028731107711792,
0.4913369119167328,
-0.4294925928115845,
-0.44774526357650757,
-0.5968202352523804,
-0.38468244671821594,
-0.17508623003959656,
-0.616100549697876,
-0.004801980219781399,
0.16545617580413818,
-0.5133240818977356,
0.3065752685070038,
0.35633862018585205,
-0.7732502818107605,
-0.9310435652732849,
0.0982469767332077,
0.31491386890411377,
-0.15254516899585724,
0.4267832040786743,
-0.21288253366947174,
0.06270618736743927,
0.1254606395959854,
-0.03966955840587616,
-0.1341717690229416,
0.30452778935432434,
-0.3017385005950928,
0.1593659371137619,
0.5906832218170166,
0.26316219568252563,
-0.05908416211605072,
0.3479061424732208,
0.8136988878250122,
-0.3933395743370056,
-0.36650437116622925,
-0.7373843789100647,
0.6705607175827026,
-0.5742098093032837,
-0.07496089488267899,
0.449419766664505,
0.5046867728233337,
0.47611507773399353,
0.014567351900041103,
0.8448948860168457,
-0.20121486485004425,
0.36863401532173157,
-0.4147777259349823,
0.4095398485660553,
-0.5898088216781616,
0.13346347212791443,
-0.11680513620376587,
-0.7000300884246826,
-0.04806135967373848,
-0.12011391669511795,
-0.3621971309185028,
0.2645086646080017,
0.3351934552192688,
1.063612937927246,
-0.06208810582756996,
0.15245048701763153,
0.24706414341926575,
-0.08120296895503998,
0.27013111114501953,
-0.2091333568096161,
1.0680572986602783,
-0.07972545921802521,
0.5476123094558716,
-0.12253067642450333,
-0.5834980607032776,
-0.0970897302031517,
-0.7354956269264221,
-0.6679107546806335,
-0.1530247926712036,
-0.5554323792457581,
-0.23062734305858612,
0.12063092738389969,
1.0147285461425781,
0.4762618839740753,
-0.7459900379180908,
-0.28583428263664246,
0.5140804648399353,
-0.12610626220703125,
-0.05443519726395607,
-0.15833628177642822,
0.3840324580669403,
-0.11804713308811188,
-0.750103235244751,
0.23434948921203613,
0.28844377398490906,
0.12729766964912415,
-0.04540789872407913,
-0.1642700880765915,
-0.11317592114210129,
0.3138129711151123,
0.1847924292087555,
0.1482471376657486,
-0.483612984418869,
-0.24581584334373474,
-0.24029800295829773,
0.11790777742862701,
0.26269662380218506,
1.0437570810317993,
-0.6221190690994263,
0.5000508427619934,
0.5210956931114197,
0.684862494468689,
0.4562179446220398,
0.23070071637630463,
0.7681148052215576,
-0.8697460889816284,
0.320947527885437,
0.19999738037586212,
0.3795202374458313,
0.6415898203849792,
-0.6660817861557007,
0.6530036926269531,
0.6732086539268494,
-0.28863611817359924,
-0.6990464925765991,
0.2588755190372467,
-0.7994714975357056,
-0.10170042514801025,
1.0046466588974,
-0.254677414894104,
-0.14437401294708252,
-0.2564936876296997,
-0.13410645723342896,
0.4532707929611206,
-0.6991015672683716,
0.7371112108230591,
0.4371902346611023,
0.229116752743721,
-0.33405041694641113,
-0.22168922424316406,
0.22387492656707764,
0.44110560417175293,
-0.809417724609375,
0.007870713248848915,
0.8197511434555054,
0.18041977286338806,
0.10927411168813705,
0.6661456823348999,
-0.13918142020702362,
0.46827763319015503,
0.02707313559949398,
0.23747164011001587,
-0.01625797338783741,
0.194301575422287,
-0.029457395896315575,
-0.028829865157604218,
-0.17234668135643005,
-0.1516626924276352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00369v1 | How to Train Your Fact Verifier: Knowledge Transfer with Multimodal Open Models | 2024-06-29T08:39:07 | 2024-06-29T08:39:07 | Jaeyoung Lee, Ximing Lu, Jack Hessel, Faeze Brahman, Youngjae Yu, Yonatan Bisk, Yejin Choi, Saadia Gabriel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given the growing influx of misinformation across news and social media,
there is a critical need for systems that can provide effective real-time
verification of news claims. Large language or multimodal model based
verification has been proposed to scale up online policing mechanisms for
mitigating spread of false and harmful content. While these can potentially
reduce burden on human fact-checkers, such efforts may be hampered by
foundation model training data becoming outdated. In this work, we test the
limits of improving foundation model performance without continual updating
through an initial study of knowledge transfer using either existing intra- and
inter- domain benchmarks or explanations generated from large language models
(LLMs). We evaluate on 12 public benchmarks for fact-checking and
misinformation detection as well as two other tasks relevant to content
moderation -- toxicity and stance detection. Our results on two recent
multi-modal fact-checking benchmarks, Mocheg and Fakeddit, indicate that
knowledge transfer strategies can improve Fakeddit performance over the
state-of-the-art by up to 1.7% and Mocheg performance by up to 2.9%. | [
-0.34995773434638977,
-0.7933530807495117,
0.6726104617118835,
0.15911512076854706,
-0.10575120151042938,
0.009518144652247429,
-0.20583473145961761,
-0.5558418035507202,
-0.3380676805973053,
0.3883229196071625,
-0.41782453656196594,
-0.1821301132440567,
-0.895123302936554,
-0.05816715210676193,
-0.5457401275634766,
0.9538924694061279,
-0.3270450532436371,
0.07544119656085968,
-0.5275818705558777,
-0.13507622480392456,
-0.16058982908725739,
-0.6262266039848328,
-0.35393255949020386,
-0.35626521706581116,
0.24024096131324768,
0.3586297333240509,
0.4348692297935486,
0.4951922297477722,
0.539636492729187,
0.2526665925979614,
0.06601786613464355,
0.3575785756111145,
-0.6183629035949707,
-0.13312691450119019,
-0.4456562101840973,
-0.5205700397491455,
-0.1503867506980896,
0.1445581316947937,
0.45266908407211304,
0.2382705956697464,
-0.011305955238640308,
0.18294546008110046,
-0.4478375315666199,
0.4087396264076233,
-0.9629812240600586,
0.1621677428483963,
-0.4469965994358063,
-0.11828645318746567,
0.029347315430641174,
-0.19928154349327087,
-0.5638129115104675,
-0.655759871006012,
0.010163307189941406,
-0.4522305428981781,
0.24086041748523712,
-0.13777022063732147,
0.9855847358703613,
0.15262360870838165,
-0.932696521282196,
-0.36245599389076233,
-0.8663911819458008,
0.48222145438194275,
-0.4994487762451172,
0.6961086392402649,
0.4388822019100189,
0.4259277880191803,
0.13872894644737244,
-0.8475849628448486,
-0.9017785787582397,
-0.334025114774704,
-0.14416608214378357,
-0.003772311145439744,
-0.041135482490062714,
-0.2735927700996399,
0.3884657919406891,
0.29502418637275696,
-0.30743858218193054,
-0.2253739833831787,
-0.4224606454372406,
-0.5119398832321167,
0.5426017045974731,
-0.18705005943775177,
0.09567767381668091,
0.05357952415943146,
-0.8220208287239075,
-0.3059441149234772,
-0.7059736847877502,
0.22915920615196228,
0.09635872393846512,
-0.1167510375380516,
-0.21438655257225037,
0.46969547867774963,
-0.3904883861541748,
0.48207980394363403,
0.03817005455493927,
-0.6388119459152222,
0.2530067563056946,
-0.8177155256271362,
0.03955898806452751,
-0.074322909116745,
0.5343712568283081,
0.4899244010448456,
0.1657395362854004,
-0.21725520491600037,
-0.23340368270874023,
0.14904649555683136,
0.2624182105064392,
-0.9988593459129333,
-0.10525906831026077,
-0.18988844752311707,
-0.3878602981567383,
-0.45297130942344666,
0.13795240223407745,
-0.8265430927276611,
-0.6530848145484924,
-0.3696204423904419,
0.707841157913208,
-0.4194308817386627,
-0.44469258189201355,
0.2802116870880127,
-0.20147959887981415,
0.04791639745235443,
0.6546145081520081,
-0.5026354789733887,
0.020011737942695618,
0.4414263367652893,
0.9268492460250854,
-0.13295744359493256,
-0.0874021053314209,
-0.5955629348754883,
0.2553071081638336,
-0.22388125956058502,
0.849754273891449,
-0.2630978226661682,
0.09781462699174881,
0.041335444897413254,
0.08308467268943787,
-0.28624266386032104,
-0.2749217450618744,
0.5840272307395935,
-0.5809769034385681,
0.1227312907576561,
-0.5977464914321899,
-0.48880529403686523,
-0.24685917794704437,
0.6972038745880127,
-0.6616064310073853,
0.7511827945709229,
-0.05879756435751915,
-0.6206070184707642,
0.4066068232059479,
-0.6750563979148865,
-0.6595959067344666,
-0.3964228332042694,
0.08242174983024597,
-0.2284306138753891,
-0.11995012313127518,
0.3375900983810425,
0.5039477944374084,
-0.2364235520362854,
0.23525655269622803,
-0.38760972023010254,
-0.1743481159210205,
0.5402628183364868,
-0.6087427139282227,
0.6636443734169006,
0.2677001357078552,
-0.42443951964378357,
-0.07109727710485458,
-0.9412807822227478,
-0.2649676203727722,
-0.11513520777225494,
-0.7150173783302307,
-0.15741103887557983,
-0.1837484985589981,
-0.04470764100551605,
0.3579907715320587,
-0.0872865617275238,
-0.7589519619941711,
0.04733213037252426,
0.23390142619609833,
0.4644017815589905,
0.6173860430717468,
0.14608211815357208,
0.2349814474582672,
-0.7821389436721802,
0.21788261830806732,
0.35029903054237366,
0.22980453073978424,
-0.13869987428188324,
-0.22685228288173676,
-0.8162736892700195,
-0.30432575941085815,
0.44438043236732483,
0.5633215308189392,
-0.9801751375198364,
-0.02301594614982605,
-0.4735274016857147,
-0.509315013885498,
-0.19848211109638214,
0.15683744847774506,
0.1177692636847496,
0.4809398055076599,
0.41622352600097656,
-0.2930561900138855,
-0.24665480852127075,
-0.613050103187561,
-0.23085539042949677,
-0.24097667634487152,
0.28293970227241516,
-0.0869414433836937,
0.678289532661438,
-0.04531482979655266,
0.858639657497406,
-0.20716309547424316,
-0.07647672295570374,
-0.009360253810882568,
0.3367727994918823,
-0.23844535648822784,
0.330261766910553,
0.7756581902503967,
-1.085045337677002,
-0.23106132447719574,
-0.029506437480449677,
-0.7134830951690674,
0.11198458075523376,
-0.16590999066829681,
0.05666524916887283,
0.14403505623340607,
0.6618881821632385,
-0.7510368227958679,
0.3829587697982788,
0.6629478335380554,
-0.3436228334903717,
0.6655267477035522,
0.11314575374126434,
0.7736431956291199,
-0.7666541337966919,
0.14455311000347137,
0.03803522512316704,
-0.7168830037117004,
-0.6090452075004578,
0.141314297914505,
0.31688791513442993,
0.038221463561058044,
-0.6240905523300171,
0.5570423007011414,
-0.3323533236980438,
0.2355756312608719,
-0.22162947058677673,
0.0114664975553751,
-0.1541883945465088,
0.4085674583911896,
-0.0914141908288002,
0.7524028420448303,
0.4262540936470032,
-0.8338487148284912,
0.5472900867462158,
-0.07038997113704681,
-0.6514564156532288,
0.8472325801849365,
-0.25498372316360474,
-0.0903584361076355,
-0.03798219561576843,
0.42187029123306274,
-1.0962544679641724,
-0.31573137640953064,
0.31463873386383057,
-0.2861030101776123,
0.17416931688785553,
-0.37148618698120117,
-0.6210526823997498,
-0.20440761744976044,
-0.09914758801460266,
0.16768445074558258,
0.245790034532547,
-0.6790524125099182,
0.7653934955596924,
0.1172165796160698,
0.04954701289534569,
-0.6179871559143066,
-0.5907529592514038,
-0.05909726023674011,
0.03608425334095955,
-0.8609445691108704,
0.18593668937683105,
-0.12444858253002167,
-0.2797316312789917,
0.17994439601898193,
-0.3896312415599823,
-0.3734848201274872,
0.2430405169725418,
0.22524385154247284,
-0.021909024566411972,
-0.3804622292518616,
0.28343111276626587,
-0.0251212976872921,
0.11503450572490692,
0.21665014326572418,
0.12989643216133118,
0.12660473585128784,
-0.15034426748752594,
-0.6734041571617126,
-0.4955935478210449,
-0.13459114730358124,
1.1379770040512085,
-0.3879551291465759,
0.9734448790550232,
0.9144789576530457,
-0.4239066243171692,
-0.08726279437541962,
-1.0074353218078613,
-0.4105377197265625,
-0.3773651123046875,
0.12232505530118942,
-0.3044130504131317,
-0.9270848035812378,
0.29278576374053955,
-0.5380510687828064,
0.11625415086746216,
0.1952957808971405,
0.5255786180496216,
0.24403885006904602,
0.8652923107147217,
0.7270420789718628,
0.00033548485953360796,
0.47439825534820557,
-0.05990086495876312,
0.1767098754644394,
-0.08288735896348953,
-0.24825267493724823,
-0.3025731146335602,
-0.07599087804555893,
-0.0705309733748436,
-0.5646649599075317,
0.39042890071868896,
0.16878141462802887,
0.0557926781475544,
0.16936999559402466,
0.2353610396385193,
0.5081725120544434,
0.3382585346698761,
0.29231634736061096,
0.6961382031440735,
0.21222060918807983,
0.09048242121934891,
0.2493756115436554,
-0.6928958296775818,
-0.20079626142978668,
1.0385327339172363,
0.5124775171279907,
0.8311721682548523,
0.45064106583595276,
0.1587299257516861,
0.6480985879898071,
0.7373753190040588,
-0.5418871641159058,
0.36751461029052734,
0.027889681980013847,
-0.8373547196388245,
-0.04757716506719589,
-0.5401542782783508,
-0.09790649265050888,
0.4036732614040375,
-0.6460204124450684,
-0.3023151457309723,
0.38592764735221863,
0.11063319444656372,
-0.2043338268995285,
0.49455946683883667,
-0.7259529829025269,
0.5778476595878601,
-0.27372321486473083,
-0.5302703976631165,
-0.6101049780845642,
-0.34253498911857605,
0.7136752009391785,
-0.10755779594182968,
0.4957375228404999,
-0.08027531951665878,
0.21090222895145416,
0.39532557129859924,
-0.3054649829864502,
0.9221204519271851,
-0.21852560341358185,
-0.064511239528656,
0.1413699835538864,
0.09227810055017471,
0.5904022455215454,
0.22723689675331116,
0.04435541853308678,
0.06128063425421715,
0.04895200952887535,
-0.209675595164299,
-0.4762372672557831,
0.5899270176887512,
-0.7863066792488098,
-0.49851328134536743,
-0.3873586654663086,
-0.5323730707168579,
-0.312627911567688,
0.1928679347038269,
0.10497824102640152,
0.38259902596473694,
-0.18853220343589783,
0.634097158908844,
1.0398035049438477,
0.3409048318862915,
0.13201580941677094,
0.7570437788963318,
-0.07391224801540375,
-0.18084675073623657,
0.7489529252052307,
0.13462881743907928,
0.3159390687942505,
0.40322041511535645,
0.2441994696855545,
-0.2980341911315918,
-0.4604943096637726,
-0.7705876231193542,
0.23958232998847961,
-0.9615045189857483,
-0.252569317817688,
-0.7063149213790894,
-0.39697521924972534,
-0.6046231985092163,
-0.006636596750468016,
-0.46752026677131653,
-0.4401119649410248,
0.10386770218610764,
-0.17898955941200256,
0.4125343859195709,
0.6891710758209229,
-0.33900347352027893,
0.20837268233299255,
-0.7462015151977539,
0.4319913983345032,
0.5603407621383667,
0.39112845063209534,
-0.25001272559165955,
-0.6016777753829956,
-0.32800546288490295,
0.308440625667572,
-0.16379688680171967,
-0.9151859879493713,
-0.25826436281204224,
0.012683236040174961,
0.7047118544578552,
0.4749019145965576,
0.0750063806772232,
0.41192662715911865,
0.048778098076581955,
0.6760901808738708,
0.2188827097415924,
-0.9036136865615845,
0.23116013407707214,
-0.19302724301815033,
-0.13837085664272308,
0.48813003301620483,
0.697719395160675,
-0.4991406202316284,
-0.07505713403224945,
-0.2474130541086197,
-0.3093814253807068,
0.7011457085609436,
0.1062605232000351,
-0.0357920341193676,
0.3050316274166107,
0.31231945753097534,
0.055201321840286255,
0.274099737405777,
-0.9540113210678101,
-0.08677829802036285,
-0.44733867049217224,
0.07388097792863846,
0.17949475347995758,
-0.4159339368343353,
-0.5380140542984009,
-0.12821227312088013,
0.9467440247535706,
-0.2557675242424011,
0.0725090429186821,
0.2887800633907318,
-0.617441713809967,
-0.17345234751701355,
0.37240445613861084,
0.9305688738822937,
1.0020146369934082,
-0.1627146154642105,
0.38106438517570496,
0.19495831429958344,
-0.4020945131778717,
0.44870683550834656,
0.093465656042099,
-0.23727725446224213,
-0.07319601625204086,
0.4599052369594574,
0.7976157665252686,
0.24975867569446564,
-0.5609642267227173,
1.027486801147461,
-0.046727441251277924,
-0.4695817530155182,
-0.0001368314551655203,
0.22947214543819427,
0.0026911890599876642,
0.30959364771842957,
0.10902704298496246,
0.367636114358902,
-0.1860233098268509,
-0.6457008123397827,
0.20790019631385803,
0.08070230484008789,
-0.31069424748420715,
-0.3065190017223358,
0.4020933508872986,
0.2262110710144043,
0.3574104905128479,
0.42128056287765503,
-0.0067754783667624,
-0.5330686569213867,
0.3348022401332855,
0.47722679376602173,
0.27058589458465576,
-0.2140318602323532,
0.3655790090560913,
0.362081915140152,
0.5865769982337952,
-0.6017160415649414,
0.01735598035156727,
-0.10155050456523895,
-0.8985745310783386,
-0.561103880405426,
-0.4514275789260864,
-0.3637717664241791,
0.3717458248138428,
-0.4165245294570923,
0.2319703996181488,
-0.5315787196159363,
-0.1669907122850418,
0.06750365346670151,
-0.19995422661304474,
-0.7591071724891663,
0.15338195860385895,
0.15800940990447998,
1.076893925666809,
-1.1600052118301392,
0.6035699248313904,
0.8391550183296204,
-0.47832465171813965,
-0.38233038783073425,
-0.10069835186004639,
0.3147370517253876,
-0.67603999376297,
0.4636942148208618,
0.07913053035736084,
-0.2721136212348938,
-0.15475335717201233,
-0.6054113507270813,
-0.7988107204437256,
1.1287111043930054,
0.585191547870636,
-0.534248411655426,
0.0572904609143734,
0.06859255582094193,
0.4150295555591583,
-0.2189313918352127,
0.17022758722305298,
0.2738161087036133,
0.6510074734687805,
0.22050386667251587,
-0.9190500378608704,
0.1971227377653122,
-0.12369313091039658,
-0.38069581985473633,
-0.09567486494779587,
-0.6278445720672607,
0.9102835059165955,
-0.24763529002666473,
-0.29337796568870544,
-0.17843949794769287,
0.6023417115211487,
-0.04532262310385704,
0.35157808661460876,
0.7767458558082581,
0.6947064399719238,
0.7107729315757751,
-0.08809833973646164,
1.0234107971191406,
-0.4096623957157135,
0.2807601988315582,
0.8439847230911255,
-0.3116934299468994,
0.6359843015670776,
0.3147394061088562,
0.11053301393985748,
0.811734139919281,
0.21842899918556213,
-0.12341983616352081,
0.4526999890804291,
-0.08359415829181671,
-0.2769264876842499,
-0.7039812207221985,
-0.1869736760854721,
-0.44279202818870544,
0.40142959356307983,
0.2573613226413727,
-0.2847869396209717,
-0.40513190627098083,
0.40864551067352295,
0.18176868557929993,
0.09620795398950577,
-0.21147722005844116,
0.5545931458473206,
-0.3039863705635071,
-0.6659972071647644,
0.35440221428871155,
0.20906318724155426,
0.651405930519104,
-0.7427287697792053,
-0.11029227823019028,
-0.13712923228740692,
0.3780670762062073,
-0.08998717367649078,
-0.6698225736618042,
0.10805575549602509,
-0.08640939742326736,
-0.39099183678627014,
-0.3468213975429535,
1.1908587217330933,
-0.43701231479644775,
-0.21024352312088013,
0.08483187854290009,
0.7963318824768066,
-0.15525376796722412,
-0.2731577754020691,
-0.46158790588378906,
0.04122799634933472,
-0.10364320874214172,
-0.3133300542831421,
0.2509838044643402,
0.36156126856803894,
-0.2958777844905853,
0.8523678779602051,
0.9828633069992065,
0.041964247822761536,
0.2779734432697296,
-0.1119108647108078,
0.938425600528717,
-0.2421984225511551,
-0.47047173976898193,
-0.6369513273239136,
0.3279629051685333,
-0.10786522924900055,
-0.11200623214244843,
0.7580747008323669,
0.39441657066345215,
1.0708149671554565,
-0.094608835875988,
0.9742579460144043,
-0.2394760102033615,
0.4766952395439148,
-0.7116170525550842,
0.8672006726264954,
-0.41371309757232666,
-0.06951983273029327,
0.1924935132265091,
-0.5585747361183167,
0.035689257085323334,
0.5400387048721313,
-0.21577757596969604,
-0.14783358573913574,
0.6824605464935303,
0.9049732089042664,
-0.46744319796562195,
0.2755799889564514,
0.26037368178367615,
0.292428582906723,
0.43086734414100647,
0.244895339012146,
0.9355717897415161,
-0.400922954082489,
0.6936004161834717,
-0.5291644930839539,
-0.2365465760231018,
-0.44613873958587646,
-0.9740477800369263,
-1.0549988746643066,
-0.5225518941879272,
-0.4805857837200165,
-0.5384393334388733,
0.22908127307891846,
0.6514499187469482,
1.1709575653076172,
-0.6687446236610413,
-0.0246258694678545,
0.18714849650859833,
0.29047784209251404,
-0.41939452290534973,
-0.22851039469242096,
0.08383245766162872,
0.0002621854073368013,
-0.08528820425271988,
0.4487035870552063,
-0.1783161759376526,
0.07964203506708145,
-0.2663211524486542,
0.008973635733127594,
-0.47144758701324463,
0.16747918725013733,
0.8293715715408325,
0.21976874768733978,
-0.537186861038208,
-0.5695500373840332,
-0.07084598392248154,
-0.16958506405353546,
-0.14137732982635498,
1.1291608810424805,
-0.7805233597755432,
0.4917852282524109,
0.6653803586959839,
0.7923594117164612,
0.5419385433197021,
0.11225317418575287,
0.31998422741889954,
-0.6829402446746826,
-0.20625756680965424,
-0.3053774833679199,
0.3076479136943817,
0.3115749657154083,
-0.2890625,
0.5129298567771912,
0.8194907903671265,
-0.3216829299926758,
-0.8881994485855103,
0.1585589051246643,
-0.7567972540855408,
-0.3212924599647522,
1.0899125337600708,
-0.21369628608226776,
-0.141305610537529,
-0.2064533531665802,
0.12847748398780823,
0.2894400954246521,
-0.2838703691959381,
0.7914955615997314,
0.9857428073883057,
0.11566207557916641,
-0.2830459177494049,
-0.6438258290290833,
0.5579471588134766,
0.0206927377730608,
-1.0127471685409546,
0.1098470538854599,
0.6464452147483826,
0.8754518628120422,
0.4706503748893738,
0.5746443271636963,
-0.0998854711651802,
0.6354485750198364,
0.04119347035884857,
0.028238585218787193,
-0.5086743235588074,
-0.6388590335845947,
-0.10815346986055374,
0.36244651675224304,
-0.34952226281166077,
0.08554299920797348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00365v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00365v1 | Financial Knowledge Large Language Model | 2024-06-29T08:26:49 | 2024-06-29T08:26:49 | Cehao Yang, Chengjin Xu, Yiyan Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence is making significant strides in the finance
industry, revolutionizing how data is processed and interpreted. Among these
technologies, large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated substantial
potential to transform financial services by automating complex tasks,
enhancing customer service, and providing detailed financial analysis. Firstly,
we introduce IDEA-FinBench, an evaluation benchmark specifically tailored for
assessing financial knowledge in large language models (LLMs). This benchmark
utilizes questions from two globally respected and authoritative financial
professional exams, aimimg to comprehensively evaluate the capability of LLMs
to directly address exam questions pertinent to the finance sector. Secondly,
we propose IDEA-FinKER, a Financial Knowledge Enhancement framework designed to
facilitate the rapid adaptation of general LLMs to the financial domain,
introducing a retrieval-based few-shot learning method for real-time
context-level knowledge injection, and a set of high-quality financial
knowledge instructions for fine-tuning any general LLM. Finally, we present
IDEA-FinQA, a financial question-answering system powered by LLMs. This system
is structured around a scheme of real-time knowledge injection and factual
enhancement using external knowledge. IDEA-FinQA is comprised of three main
modules: the data collector, the data querying module, and LLM-based agents
tasked with specific functions. | [
-0.19905370473861694,
-1.0255436897277832,
0.42390555143356323,
0.07739147543907166,
-0.08970961719751358,
0.48972994089126587,
-0.2751813232898712,
-0.9136042594909668,
0.020440813153982162,
0.6796258091926575,
-0.3927767872810364,
-0.4290524423122406,
-0.314841091632843,
-0.18363744020462036,
-0.6063766479492188,
0.8545019626617432,
0.08124886453151703,
0.22606635093688965,
-0.2756550908088684,
0.39010700583457947,
-0.17748448252677917,
-0.4021066427230835,
-1.1117119789123535,
-0.4152589440345764,
0.20294645428657532,
0.28869369626045227,
0.46185165643692017,
0.3883914351463318,
0.8220367431640625,
0.37967556715011597,
0.014620594680309296,
-0.18452800810337067,
-0.3683914840221405,
-0.2308809757232666,
-0.30432891845703125,
-0.6681256890296936,
-0.6761622428894043,
-0.0915706530213356,
0.3586432933807373,
0.7213605046272278,
-0.3452010750770569,
0.3131038546562195,
-0.18067270517349243,
0.7449343800544739,
-0.5108290314674377,
0.6059385538101196,
-0.4506138265132904,
-0.18584562838077545,
-0.10164539515972137,
-0.053172994405031204,
-0.2740274667739868,
-0.38354992866516113,
0.41435858607292175,
-0.5698469281196594,
-0.19401903450489044,
0.24977265298366547,
0.6701135635375977,
0.33141401410102844,
-0.3304200768470764,
-0.29767826199531555,
-0.7289891242980957,
0.6105980277061462,
-0.7384359836578369,
0.32117947936058044,
0.36646345257759094,
0.6965903639793396,
-0.0649777427315712,
-0.802003800868988,
-0.41689756512641907,
-0.16091889142990112,
0.05735504999756813,
0.09369626641273499,
-0.23541942238807678,
0.20250025391578674,
0.10255534946918488,
0.38714659214019775,
-0.21933238208293915,
0.20454348623752594,
-0.31195148825645447,
-0.1648385226726532,
0.8059190511703491,
0.14055198431015015,
-0.11915374547243118,
0.13280127942562103,
-0.4433833956718445,
-0.367738276720047,
-0.5840625166893005,
0.17629006505012512,
0.46257901191711426,
0.15929599106311798,
-0.048856236040592194,
0.4248422086238861,
-0.19862309098243713,
0.786681056022644,
-0.006533406209200621,
-0.4606052339076996,
0.09830157458782196,
-0.28744080662727356,
-0.303229957818985,
0.1671452820301056,
0.4853057265281677,
0.1967262625694275,
0.3641023635864258,
-0.05983047932386398,
-0.34747132658958435,
-0.4259902536869049,
0.08410535752773285,
-0.5893816351890564,
0.024899236857891083,
0.3298705518245697,
-0.3206835389137268,
-0.21334215998649597,
0.21300293505191803,
-0.7026957869529724,
-0.44599756598472595,
-0.4259728491306305,
0.4113282859325409,
-0.2807226777076721,
-0.10049168765544891,
0.4014608561992645,
-0.3936426639556885,
0.6260254979133606,
0.39694535732269287,
-0.803200900554657,
0.5144158601760864,
1.160051941871643,
0.308643102645874,
0.21981187164783478,
0.002146624494343996,
-0.4072122275829315,
0.3565464913845062,
-0.39472654461860657,
1.0345771312713623,
-0.38451123237609863,
-0.14662882685661316,
-0.07874562591314316,
-0.328157514333725,
0.0969056561589241,
-0.5115931034088135,
-0.012662292458117008,
-0.8261013031005859,
0.04457266256213188,
-0.15641266107559204,
-0.8348169922828674,
-0.325209379196167,
0.3190552294254303,
-0.4461963176727295,
0.7546101212501526,
0.34044989943504333,
-0.6807253956794739,
0.41021594405174255,
-1.0825716257095337,
-0.3758660554885864,
0.3439021110534668,
-0.1839776635169983,
-0.16114434599876404,
-0.2944210469722748,
0.05414292588829994,
0.45187410712242126,
-0.9314764738082886,
0.34852686524391174,
-0.38484710454940796,
-0.44007739424705505,
0.5464175343513489,
-0.4246580898761749,
0.33486130833625793,
0.01162018533796072,
-0.34900742769241333,
0.2448347806930542,
-0.805270254611969,
-0.16520041227340698,
0.15567311644554138,
-0.0177156925201416,
-0.48311540484428406,
-0.18767033517360687,
0.059631627053022385,
0.043472662568092346,
0.6119141578674316,
-0.6124690771102905,
0.10932653397321701,
-0.8123000860214233,
0.5482684969902039,
0.896838366985321,
0.15409572422504425,
0.2757047116756439,
-0.4736243188381195,
0.5645792484283447,
-0.15905597805976868,
0.2102319598197937,
-0.013820218853652477,
-0.18974308669567108,
-0.5376614332199097,
-0.18626585602760315,
0.410444438457489,
0.7391093373298645,
-0.5520838499069214,
0.26868805289268494,
-0.15830695629119873,
-0.5510465502738953,
-0.2644396424293518,
0.2779213488101959,
0.20583613216876984,
0.4454615116119385,
0.12182798981666565,
-0.022301724180579185,
-0.324209988117218,
-1.2717121839523315,
-0.3074100911617279,
-0.33480870723724365,
-0.04305248707532883,
0.329402357339859,
0.3907109498977661,
-0.045803386718034744,
0.8923160433769226,
-0.8355004787445068,
-0.1504293978214264,
-0.3448540270328522,
-0.02758290059864521,
0.4396936297416687,
0.2917565405368805,
0.7303606867790222,
-0.9576089382171631,
-0.1514907032251358,
0.1543464958667755,
-0.4825041592121124,
0.11326660215854645,
-0.2816537022590637,
-0.0994185134768486,
-0.0729471743106842,
0.72922283411026,
-0.3537738025188446,
0.27898481488227844,
0.14334793388843536,
-0.5360739231109619,
0.5144721865653992,
-0.2209736406803131,
0.06727457791566849,
-1.054109811782837,
0.21344904601573944,
0.00328587694093585,
-0.23021748661994934,
-0.4516414701938629,
-0.07883252203464508,
0.0791226327419281,
0.021458888426423073,
-0.2153775990009308,
1.1016803979873657,
0.041300248354673386,
-0.48326313495635986,
-0.3242802619934082,
0.2951565682888031,
-0.12639272212982178,
0.33807072043418884,
-0.1866914927959442,
0.9222133755683899,
0.453057199716568,
-0.38248443603515625,
0.7627595067024231,
0.27744975686073303,
-0.6118614077568054,
0.604967474937439,
-0.5758663415908813,
-0.06580505520105362,
0.0008898444939404726,
0.10040890425443649,
-1.02615487575531,
-0.2940012812614441,
0.035751692950725555,
-0.06348511576652527,
0.2513941824436188,
0.20354509353637695,
-0.549789309501648,
-0.563036322593689,
0.014250615611672401,
0.2331613451242447,
0.32935672998428345,
-0.5016359686851501,
0.6689561009407043,
0.29632568359375,
-0.7136486172676086,
-0.8101823329925537,
-0.5755758881568909,
0.1772313117980957,
-0.2508888244628906,
-0.675717294216156,
0.32515010237693787,
-0.07288411259651184,
-0.7034246325492859,
0.007652692962437868,
-0.011003837920725346,
-0.08691469579935074,
0.37333154678344727,
0.010898284614086151,
0.651505172252655,
-0.38615185022354126,
0.4502614736557007,
0.014741011895239353,
-0.2564588487148285,
0.2402600646018982,
-0.534520149230957,
0.42438772320747375,
-0.33316636085510254,
-0.49056464433670044,
-0.20046870410442352,
0.05354427918791771,
0.6070107817649841,
-0.280786395072937,
0.791445791721344,
0.3631086051464081,
-0.31163424253463745,
-0.22232937812805176,
-0.8989055752754211,
-0.008062584325671196,
-0.5675132870674133,
0.45505592226982117,
-0.34743738174438477,
-1.0896470546722412,
0.7836025357246399,
-0.2894655466079712,
0.2977679371833801,
0.6729114651679993,
0.5842539072036743,
-0.017133474349975586,
0.48431146144866943,
1.003434419631958,
-0.18804165720939636,
0.5552579164505005,
-0.2838413715362549,
0.2053941786289215,
-0.332047700881958,
-0.2515262961387634,
-0.36817148327827454,
-0.27079570293426514,
-0.03684590384364128,
-0.2567135691642761,
0.2414798140525818,
0.1556890606880188,
-0.43445780873298645,
0.2293344885110855,
0.18513381481170654,
0.5836666226387024,
0.28147536516189575,
-0.0733049288392067,
0.3244663178920746,
-0.1717856079339981,
-0.21888160705566406,
0.3534610867500305,
-0.6323295831680298,
-0.4373881220817566,
1.264456868171692,
0.6059099435806274,
0.807803750038147,
-0.012141034938395023,
0.4071965515613556,
0.39206674695014954,
0.5071675777435303,
-0.8778506517410278,
0.4586695432662964,
-0.14701992273330688,
-0.5099170804023743,
-0.45036712288856506,
-0.6746925711631775,
-0.3770318925380707,
-0.2869514226913452,
0.051012106239795685,
-0.5799314379692078,
0.10881378501653671,
-0.18058016896247864,
-0.8174409866333008,
0.3461955189704895,
-0.6144778728485107,
0.6545059680938721,
-0.6065642833709717,
-0.36036741733551025,
-0.34343627095222473,
-0.3237641155719757,
0.5970978140830994,
-0.8495481610298157,
0.5712382793426514,
-0.04006776958703995,
-0.29502707719802856,
0.9530786275863647,
-0.3624785244464874,
0.7863355278968811,
-0.09260349720716476,
-0.658378541469574,
0.3063206672668457,
-0.13430939614772797,
0.43082305788993835,
0.2163466513156891,
-0.33562448620796204,
0.03742992877960205,
0.1822802573442459,
-0.36810940504074097,
-0.6783310174942017,
0.47030511498451233,
-0.5974192023277283,
-0.6525323390960693,
-0.11370326578617096,
-0.7612823843955994,
-0.5968721508979797,
0.010407749563455582,
-0.3541429936885834,
0.20433968305587769,
-0.4153822958469391,
0.17517684400081635,
0.28627076745033264,
-0.27114829421043396,
0.42264580726623535,
0.7392008304595947,
-0.44245633482933044,
-0.4208943545818329,
0.6888999342918396,
-0.08814577758312225,
0.2778991758823395,
0.5268000364303589,
0.19771292805671692,
-0.5541276335716248,
-0.2942902743816376,
-0.20057332515716553,
0.4273703396320343,
-0.9697964191436768,
-0.36640727519989014,
-0.3804449141025543,
-0.2896396517753601,
-0.4824221134185791,
-0.3307112157344818,
-0.5145840048789978,
-0.48812368512153625,
-0.0357644148170948,
-0.3425520062446594,
0.821230947971344,
0.9131863713264465,
-0.18747033178806305,
0.25995582342147827,
-0.9721379280090332,
0.2209497094154358,
0.4896402955055237,
0.6743877530097961,
0.12856076657772064,
-0.43324407935142517,
-0.4936826825141907,
-0.12127139419317245,
0.27331870794296265,
-0.339892715215683,
0.17490698397159576,
0.03628300875425339,
0.7347072958946228,
0.8361160755157471,
-0.038529593497514725,
0.5985334515571594,
0.052864495664834976,
0.4308219254016876,
0.1590467095375061,
-0.8480368852615356,
0.28761622309684753,
-0.28438252210617065,
0.1965886503458023,
0.6342089176177979,
0.2631660997867584,
-0.6040406227111816,
-0.3472602069377899,
-0.5825828313827515,
-0.8173663020133972,
0.5575722455978394,
-0.18484996259212494,
-0.006945053115487099,
0.14178796112537384,
0.6997937560081482,
0.2889356017112732,
0.4281630516052246,
-0.3633161187171936,
-0.012505260296165943,
0.076888307929039,
-0.31100669503211975,
-0.24326273798942566,
-0.18070174753665924,
-0.1610272228717804,
-0.2822829782962799,
0.7338066101074219,
-0.28576982021331787,
0.04303243011236191,
-0.025158880278468132,
0.2541016638278961,
-0.18879598379135132,
0.4007894992828369,
0.508371114730835,
1.0185580253601074,
-0.2808656096458435,
-0.17341354489326477,
0.24836404621601105,
-0.3114846348762512,
0.12437814474105835,
0.3575141727924347,
0.10671410709619522,
-0.4518129825592041,
0.4594230651855469,
0.4534149765968323,
0.654639482498169,
-1.1328247785568237,
0.45882970094680786,
-0.1376478672027588,
-0.4413910210132599,
-0.6508864760398865,
0.24069204926490784,
0.32933562994003296,
0.6829927563667297,
0.7405674457550049,
-0.0066375345923006535,
-0.19807931780815125,
-0.6511696577072144,
0.35474953055381775,
0.3286937475204468,
-0.3898339867591858,
0.027315722778439522,
0.4495065212249756,
0.1273217499256134,
-0.1219317689538002,
0.42632266879081726,
0.09402941912412643,
-0.4980927109718323,
0.7669706344604492,
0.43105337023735046,
0.7257681488990784,
-0.06662265211343765,
0.023908212780952454,
0.11196048557758331,
0.16878443956375122,
-0.19741308689117432,
0.5581955313682556,
-0.020659402012825012,
-0.6949689388275146,
-0.5926929712295532,
-0.9390671253204346,
-0.5147070288658142,
0.14960740506649017,
-0.5710048079490662,
0.2035321295261383,
-0.7687787413597107,
-0.1715499609708786,
0.20012955367565155,
0.0257154181599617,
-0.6819097995758057,
-0.008323040790855885,
0.12831264734268188,
1.3351980447769165,
-0.4490985572338104,
0.6460418105125427,
0.6848400235176086,
-0.22505202889442444,
-0.5707545876502991,
-0.2689064145088196,
-0.0928473025560379,
-0.8894273042678833,
0.8493602871894836,
-0.17030580341815948,
-0.07675739377737045,
0.14101822674274445,
-0.5385783314704895,
-1.0125317573547363,
1.1086845397949219,
0.3323647081851959,
-0.923650860786438,
-0.18971940875053406,
0.33917859196662903,
0.4313504993915558,
-0.5523748993873596,
0.04952782765030861,
0.766222357749939,
0.8033862113952637,
0.2952052652835846,
-0.9913267493247986,
-0.36338457465171814,
-0.21478451788425446,
-0.3511037826538086,
0.36687055230140686,
-0.6828449368476868,
0.6941127181053162,
-0.25098294019699097,
0.06916555762290955,
-0.017318621277809143,
0.5364484786987305,
-0.02551923133432865,
0.263508141040802,
0.4936714470386505,
0.37716570496559143,
0.8387437462806702,
-0.044835031032562256,
1.1449886560440063,
-0.6152933239936829,
0.13524046540260315,
1.0388293266296387,
-0.38463011384010315,
1.004991888999939,
0.317376971244812,
-0.2772243916988373,
0.41309595108032227,
0.6384317874908447,
-0.2012757509946823,
0.04380868375301361,
0.38958150148391724,
-0.1438894122838974,
-0.5020654201507568,
-0.08262845873832703,
-0.23599013686180115,
0.7968306541442871,
0.5058930516242981,
-0.22194960713386536,
-0.0992928147315979,
0.1309947371482849,
-0.2775278091430664,
-0.025056403130292892,
-0.45497003197669983,
1.0187795162200928,
0.39909234642982483,
-0.33574536442756653,
0.011828471906483173,
0.3009727895259857,
0.4917891025543213,
-1.0004249811172485,
0.04416484758257866,
-0.12015100568532944,
0.37460654973983765,
0.1599104255437851,
-0.6735477447509766,
0.28232911229133606,
0.049708981066942215,
-0.03068404458463192,
-0.1624109447002411,
0.9491006135940552,
-0.18983085453510284,
-0.7112786769866943,
0.5027679204940796,
0.6947624087333679,
-0.047981999814510345,
-0.08982343226671219,
-0.7508156895637512,
-0.5235422849655151,
-0.28893646597862244,
-0.20757190883159637,
0.3862583637237549,
0.32522615790367126,
0.1004379391670227,
1.0042974948883057,
0.9326431751251221,
0.06339142471551895,
-0.4123227596282959,
0.11889097839593887,
0.8588669300079346,
-0.9841903448104858,
-0.7182101607322693,
-0.7264431715011597,
0.03097597137093544,
-0.027016770094633102,
-0.12861470878124237,
0.6122362613677979,
0.6696524620056152,
0.7234878540039062,
0.06727400422096252,
0.6960422396659851,
0.48240259289741516,
0.49313387274742126,
-0.5655477643013,
1.0267109870910645,
-0.498320072889328,
0.5712679028511047,
-0.42424818873405457,
-0.9710145592689514,
-0.09590460360050201,
0.3472789525985718,
-0.8053801655769348,
-0.18317216634750366,
0.39696332812309265,
0.5007131099700928,
0.09345190972089767,
0.3569933772087097,
0.4251135587692261,
0.19511844217777252,
0.06284346431493759,
0.41499486565589905,
0.844788134098053,
-0.27290546894073486,
0.5738574266433716,
-0.17944350838661194,
-0.13470904529094696,
-0.23526059091091156,
-0.6795426607131958,
-0.7312768697738647,
-0.2738882601261139,
-0.32296881079673767,
0.1428818255662918,
-0.12478844821453094,
0.9816558957099915,
0.25007176399230957,
-0.6537432670593262,
-0.6706129312515259,
0.24141179025173187,
0.06906992942094803,
-0.18902084231376648,
-0.2484232634305954,
0.35905492305755615,
-0.19856134057044983,
-0.20519842207431793,
0.5814555883407593,
0.6284741163253784,
0.33441418409347534,
-0.5101421475410461,
0.03926330432295799,
-0.014450125396251678,
0.33457961678504944,
0.6018897891044617,
0.04106314852833748,
-0.34809890389442444,
-0.19427891075611115,
0.10382557660341263,
0.02552187070250511,
-0.15238821506500244,
0.7933944463729858,
-0.5174267292022705,
0.12112273275852203,
0.30751556158065796,
0.9361397624015808,
0.4807768762111664,
-0.001735038124024868,
0.7893092632293701,
-0.2013891339302063,
0.20457641780376434,
0.17026455700397491,
0.37832018733024597,
-0.13149452209472656,
-0.4862527847290039,
0.4715754985809326,
0.04123237729072571,
-0.31343162059783936,
-0.39657706022262573,
-0.03421534225344658,
-0.7435072660446167,
-0.6640669703483582,
0.919092059135437,
-0.06512300670146942,
-0.5847061276435852,
-0.33002784848213196,
0.010755045339465141,
-0.11093229800462723,
-0.43369540572166443,
0.5941197276115417,
0.7940436005592346,
0.04731939733028412,
-0.08662408590316772,
-0.7701937556266785,
0.4597814977169037,
0.21707512438297272,
-1.009647011756897,
0.3012261390686035,
0.28354471921920776,
0.2998232841491699,
0.14907363057136536,
0.5019329190254211,
-0.12199316918849945,
0.42476823925971985,
0.10220293700695038,
0.11592858284711838,
-0.24360264837741852,
-0.1840871125459671,
-0.07595954090356827,
0.3792632520198822,
0.0599229633808136,
0.5056359171867371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00361v1 | From RAG to RICHES: Retrieval Interlaced with Sequence Generation | 2024-06-29T08:16:58 | 2024-06-29T08:16:58 | Palak Jain, Livio Baldini Soares, Tom Kwiatkowski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present RICHES, a novel approach that interleaves retrieval with sequence
generation tasks. RICHES offers an alternative to conventional RAG systems by
eliminating the need for separate retriever and generator. It retrieves
documents by directly decoding their contents, constrained on the corpus.
Unifying retrieval with generation allows us to adapt to diverse new tasks via
prompting alone. RICHES can work with any Instruction-tuned model, without
additional training. It provides attributed evidence, supports multi-hop
retrievals and interleaves thoughts to plan on what to retrieve next, all
within a single decoding pass of the LLM. We demonstrate the strong performance
of RICHES across ODQA tasks including attributed and multi-hop QA. | [
-0.20456182956695557,
-0.2572936415672302,
0.20020714402198792,
0.2533922791481018,
-0.34741759300231934,
0.5205960869789124,
0.09013933688402176,
-0.30661171674728394,
0.4788369834423065,
0.7621688842773438,
-0.31301355361938477,
0.13661569356918335,
-0.646699070930481,
0.06514478474855423,
-0.6027910709381104,
1.1191681623458862,
0.5359377264976501,
0.012858630158007145,
-0.16008049249649048,
0.00021969579393044114,
-0.33706042170524597,
-0.29026344418525696,
-0.4388185441493988,
-0.1596122831106186,
0.5632809996604919,
0.7101345062255859,
0.667513370513916,
0.38578468561172485,
0.49133241176605225,
0.32706502079963684,
0.037143416702747345,
0.6569018363952637,
-0.8571823835372925,
0.600069522857666,
-0.4691252112388611,
-0.41962841153144836,
-0.25322362780570984,
-0.22202222049236298,
0.5668496489524841,
0.5719146132469177,
0.09181230515241623,
0.4356711208820343,
0.27030399441719055,
1.187258243560791,
-1.1020004749298096,
-0.3194507658481598,
-0.7642255425453186,
-0.06675606220960617,
-0.5134022235870361,
-0.7407580018043518,
-0.7385295629501343,
-0.3276028633117676,
-0.16925321519374847,
-0.5019538402557373,
0.381974995136261,
0.023892344906926155,
0.7051864862442017,
0.29466232657432556,
-0.33794254064559937,
-0.5419784784317017,
-0.8593387007713318,
0.6629799008369446,
-0.29869160056114197,
0.4355860948562622,
0.2745301425457001,
0.11108166724443436,
-0.09001424908638,
-0.934916615486145,
-0.341814786195755,
0.03486275672912598,
-0.09846387803554535,
0.41516566276550293,
0.16166433691978455,
-0.24330151081085205,
0.23015810549259186,
0.8975452780723572,
-0.3622629940509796,
-0.1676643043756485,
-0.4099636673927307,
0.28100138902664185,
0.6485084295272827,
-0.02999645285308361,
-0.04658060148358345,
-0.43235868215560913,
-0.5419784784317017,
-0.271943598985672,
-0.7678553462028503,
-0.020619943737983704,
0.5098341107368469,
0.42631909251213074,
0.41490235924720764,
0.8116527199745178,
-0.18673674762248993,
0.6324737071990967,
0.057794239372015,
-0.14387953281402588,
-0.029863234609365463,
-0.22715653479099274,
0.020384838804602623,
0.02897837944328785,
0.4529446065425873,
-0.3480902314186096,
-0.15653236210346222,
-0.4854748249053955,
-0.3565455675125122,
-0.6393963098526001,
0.5470566153526306,
-0.6112735271453857,
-0.1616697609424591,
0.1691862791776657,
-0.35706040263175964,
-0.11932626366615295,
0.4637281894683838,
-0.9173203110694885,
-0.5176576972007751,
-0.07853932678699493,
0.7272291779518127,
-0.5106777548789978,
0.060558486729860306,
0.023297958076000214,
-0.6172826886177063,
0.6041375994682312,
0.025256089866161346,
-0.9387496709823608,
0.3778298497200012,
0.888063371181488,
0.722135066986084,
0.16856610774993896,
-0.02582898922264576,
-1.2576066255569458,
0.2508994936943054,
-0.2491244226694107,
0.7173064947128296,
-0.1962457001209259,
-0.5253204107284546,
-0.210817351937294,
-0.36822086572647095,
0.09218838810920715,
-0.6839431524276733,
0.49309638142585754,
-1.1540559530258179,
0.020667951554059982,
-0.20490674674510956,
-0.6502711772918701,
0.018720416352152824,
-0.10203185677528381,
-0.840743899345398,
0.9363196492195129,
0.33546343445777893,
-0.9505292177200317,
0.0787227600812912,
-0.46062180399894714,
-0.5318127274513245,
0.3895587921142578,
-0.046119075268507004,
-0.30600661039352417,
0.3503369092941284,
-0.09113709628582001,
0.228157639503479,
-0.48484644293785095,
0.17170889675617218,
-0.20034821331501007,
-0.5725641846656799,
0.10207386314868927,
-0.2108725756406784,
0.7874660491943359,
0.47855913639068604,
-0.20428338646888733,
-0.31979209184646606,
-0.791948676109314,
0.21073974668979645,
0.3336985111236572,
-0.47613653540611267,
-0.61210036277771,
0.004049850162118673,
-0.20368367433547974,
-0.23113806545734406,
0.35448575019836426,
-0.43427935242652893,
0.47265392541885376,
-0.45872384309768677,
-0.01612566038966179,
0.4912993013858795,
0.06343069672584534,
0.5928122401237488,
-0.5259963274002075,
0.42189598083496094,
-0.23850151896476746,
-0.18338525295257568,
-0.407007098197937,
-0.3547342121601105,
-0.848097562789917,
-0.24632270634174347,
0.5806050300598145,
0.7631114721298218,
-0.7727630138397217,
0.20119483768939972,
-0.43981844186782837,
-0.18124039471149445,
-0.7298705577850342,
0.10353932529687881,
0.557384729385376,
0.2722494602203369,
0.3595046401023865,
-0.4644641578197479,
-0.5079022645950317,
-0.5279589295387268,
-0.49615275859832764,
0.2642284035682678,
-0.2400198131799698,
0.342923641204834,
0.12935742735862732,
0.08885235339403152,
0.8478109240531921,
-0.5459654927253723,
-0.10252155363559723,
-0.14575226604938507,
0.3119097352027893,
0.36864393949508667,
0.5410454869270325,
0.06734655052423477,
-1.2848440408706665,
-0.2768869996070862,
-0.2131972759962082,
-0.44738340377807617,
0.11351117491722107,
-0.06410152465105057,
-0.35875746607780457,
-0.0028793280944228172,
0.5731284618377686,
-0.3372662365436554,
0.3821178674697876,
0.16467104852199554,
-0.43783077597618103,
0.25670018792152405,
-0.24479705095291138,
0.2608819603919983,
-1.311658263206482,
0.1533707231283188,
-0.7525792717933655,
-0.21054038405418396,
-0.25651273131370544,
0.42566192150115967,
0.14437459409236908,
0.08247750997543335,
-0.01550208032131195,
0.5726491212844849,
-0.741300642490387,
-0.7030351758003235,
-0.14646200835704803,
0.1101331040263176,
0.2515465319156647,
0.016190769150853157,
-0.3267989754676819,
0.9324272871017456,
0.11188065260648727,
-0.6914739012718201,
0.1728476881980896,
0.6185550093650818,
-0.12497760355472565,
0.4513418972492218,
-0.30022308230400085,
0.32442548871040344,
-0.5320738554000854,
-0.11655142903327942,
-0.9942820072174072,
-0.25300633907318115,
-0.23497039079666138,
-0.6421158313751221,
0.5479109287261963,
0.036112722009420395,
-0.4010533094406128,
-0.35131606459617615,
-0.5016965270042419,
0.42439377307891846,
0.6791160702705383,
-0.807191014289856,
0.5069597363471985,
0.24726781249046326,
-0.2601068913936615,
-0.9643937349319458,
-0.2938961982727051,
0.20706713199615479,
-0.26205578446388245,
-0.5409528613090515,
0.5081233978271484,
-0.11009475588798523,
-0.4148141145706177,
-0.06532315164804459,
-0.012096485123038292,
-0.00014790719433221966,
0.3168858289718628,
0.09725617617368698,
0.477731853723526,
-0.2014046460390091,
0.26212501525878906,
0.014068854041397572,
-0.08061166852712631,
-0.4340561032295227,
-0.4854384958744049,
0.4160780906677246,
0.1047036200761795,
-0.23033562302589417,
0.4593331217765808,
0.6920831203460693,
0.20620422065258026,
-0.6298331618309021,
0.5722437500953674,
0.5016562938690186,
0.028939139097929,
-0.49830520153045654,
-0.43187186121940613,
-0.16214467585086823,
-0.5370855927467346,
0.050181008875370026,
-0.5185461640357971,
-0.9208037257194519,
0.23037134110927582,
-0.3493531048297882,
0.3069910705089569,
0.3816143274307251,
0.41122177243232727,
-0.2124527245759964,
0.3501949906349182,
0.6914326548576355,
0.3502860367298126,
0.24989734590053558,
-0.6068527698516846,
0.3406071364879608,
-1.0994079113006592,
-0.1706395000219345,
-0.5656830072402954,
-0.3330475389957428,
-0.3276121914386749,
-0.6278932690620422,
0.594992458820343,
0.7852993607521057,
-0.330424427986145,
0.1947893500328064,
-0.44379764795303345,
0.5577367544174194,
1.1030054092407227,
0.20973911881446838,
0.6676133871078491,
-0.27971360087394714,
0.14302557706832886,
0.28815731406211853,
-0.816849410533905,
-0.36129528284072876,
1.2018152475357056,
-0.24067042768001556,
0.6629700064659119,
0.37527430057525635,
1.3277251720428467,
0.46426793932914734,
0.3079659044742584,
-0.795553982257843,
0.42332133650779724,
-0.6711316704750061,
-0.30280494689941406,
-0.3972286283969879,
-0.3927099406719208,
-1.3434959650039673,
0.23761999607086182,
-0.22012555599212646,
-0.5816022753715515,
0.15341463685035706,
-0.02997950278222561,
-0.81228107213974,
0.2796396017074585,
-0.285180002450943,
0.5041492581367493,
-0.08397846668958664,
-0.4638069272041321,
-0.16158320009708405,
-0.8365700840950012,
0.884645402431488,
-0.14883370697498322,
0.22717934846878052,
0.19527530670166016,
-0.11780315637588501,
0.499673992395401,
-0.5097092390060425,
0.2795865833759308,
0.2317315638065338,
-0.04948447272181511,
0.37340521812438965,
0.12817712128162384,
0.5786002278327942,
0.057983867824077606,
-0.13477091491222382,
-0.4608336389064789,
-0.28678297996520996,
-0.42053359746932983,
-0.3781823217868805,
0.6093433499336243,
-0.49462196230888367,
-0.6001453995704651,
-0.340973824262619,
-0.7783828377723694,
-0.4912022352218628,
0.1401207596063614,
0.5058208703994751,
0.5132910013198853,
-0.15032242238521576,
0.13178938627243042,
1.0125501155853271,
-0.2868659794330597,
0.5928648710250854,
0.36471056938171387,
0.03340708836913109,
-0.43989133834838867,
0.9219769835472107,
-0.02297024615108967,
0.4907681345939636,
0.9516982436180115,
0.09921904653310776,
-0.3813512325286865,
-0.40163668990135193,
-0.4559918940067291,
0.21974432468414307,
-0.6601061224937439,
-0.6521573662757874,
-0.8196678161621094,
-0.3757559657096863,
-0.6583808660507202,
-0.16397610306739807,
-0.4081179201602936,
-0.5255867838859558,
-0.26878976821899414,
0.17725057899951935,
0.5606159567832947,
0.9239577054977417,
-0.4481951892375946,
-0.11132961511611938,
-1.3695746660232544,
0.8248124718666077,
0.7321488857269287,
0.2650771737098694,
0.05973491072654724,
-0.6924793720245361,
-0.20326930284500122,
-0.2729733884334564,
-0.3988625705242157,
-0.917617917060852,
0.39736732840538025,
0.3679806590080261,
0.20344491302967072,
0.06746726483106613,
0.531075656414032,
0.756301999092102,
-0.6269283890724182,
0.444692999124527,
-0.11829734593629837,
-0.9100935459136963,
0.35325881838798523,
-0.1931481808423996,
0.1275351196527481,
0.4323068857192993,
0.3894897699356079,
-0.28642410039901733,
-0.2504441440105438,
-0.7620562314987183,
-1.1678475141525269,
0.48432981967926025,
-0.13486245274543762,
-0.09671396762132645,
-0.12720069289207458,
0.290376752614975,
0.3966934084892273,
0.19786261022090912,
-0.1315074861049652,
-0.101327084004879,
-0.059025395661592484,
0.1196243017911911,
-0.008848913013935089,
-0.40874093770980835,
-0.05390012264251709,
0.1991955041885376,
0.6888867020606995,
-0.2138872891664505,
0.27534425258636475,
0.41776636242866516,
-0.004156000446528196,
-0.040516335517168045,
0.4554509222507477,
0.04820489138364792,
0.38026368618011475,
-0.05684587359428406,
0.08595752716064453,
-0.30280616879463196,
-0.3844110667705536,
0.0975070670247078,
0.36562076210975647,
-0.25668710470199585,
-0.026460882276296616,
0.1627819985151291,
0.46192803978919983,
0.4070851802825928,
-0.7153805494308472,
0.5474939346313477,
0.24278490245342255,
0.020594704896211624,
-0.22389782965183258,
-0.02358492650091648,
0.12688562273979187,
0.6639149188995361,
0.5913923978805542,
-0.11489380896091461,
0.5737819075584412,
-0.5517919659614563,
0.6163294911384583,
0.4688047766685486,
0.06942706555128098,
0.1940099596977234,
0.902036190032959,
-0.05048779025673866,
-0.2907625436782837,
0.9623376727104187,
-0.6247805953025818,
-0.10045973211526871,
0.4947582483291626,
0.560114860534668,
1.0352284908294678,
-0.07196255028247833,
0.35865887999534607,
0.4798230528831482,
-0.1505890041589737,
-0.25484004616737366,
0.618463933467865,
-0.26647529006004333,
-0.5597494840621948,
-0.616496205329895,
-0.9882041811943054,
-0.42846179008483887,
-0.1870507150888443,
-0.9458823204040527,
0.011052940972149372,
-0.13270807266235352,
0.28263571858406067,
-0.10908910632133484,
-0.29902753233909607,
-0.45923691987991333,
-0.11449427157640457,
0.2070319652557373,
0.9170665144920349,
-0.044375039637088776,
0.7086948752403259,
0.25945770740509033,
-0.47799915075302124,
-0.9493507742881775,
0.06594852358102798,
-0.08846413344144821,
-0.896660566329956,
0.8345816135406494,
-0.1607203632593155,
-0.06470554322004318,
0.382268488407135,
-0.36412790417671204,
-1.0577030181884766,
1.2681821584701538,
0.37711426615715027,
-0.24238857626914978,
-0.2409040927886963,
-0.23846933245658875,
-0.09698361158370972,
0.06424909830093384,
0.028576916083693504,
0.43342211842536926,
0.17530207335948944,
0.6305128335952759,
-0.8538981080055237,
-0.28215959668159485,
-0.2413433939218521,
0.05562618747353554,
0.5794808864593506,
-0.6586529016494751,
1.2355154752731323,
-0.7939529418945312,
-0.43579402565956116,
0.7576109170913696,
0.7165319323539734,
0.4983047544956207,
0.21060973405838013,
0.2614431381225586,
0.7484737634658813,
0.8095282316207886,
0.01173338107764721,
1.0792560577392578,
-0.24695809185504913,
0.17021246254444122,
1.282300591468811,
-0.02958846278488636,
0.9469785690307617,
0.33379924297332764,
-0.18793271481990814,
0.44389215111732483,
0.2535450756549835,
0.3570142984390259,
0.5929901599884033,
0.4258013367652893,
-0.6128067970275879,
-0.03530734032392502,
-0.1394176185131073,
-0.2740113437175751,
0.5390332937240601,
0.4040054380893707,
-0.17378512024879456,
-0.3358484208583832,
-0.005345812067389488,
-0.28777801990509033,
0.2429315149784088,
-0.5666192770004272,
0.9135547280311584,
0.12333797663450241,
-0.9486163854598999,
0.5851162075996399,
-0.18329168856143951,
0.7052938342094421,
-0.6842355132102966,
-0.4672267436981201,
-0.27473020553588867,
0.15491211414337158,
-0.20695453882217407,
-0.6669078469276428,
0.3276904821395874,
-0.1620727777481079,
-0.04918306693434715,
-0.40345093607902527,
0.9795839190483093,
-0.5177904963493347,
-0.08092353492975235,
-0.014976952224969864,
0.7053605318069458,
0.27111390233039856,
-0.17065396904945374,
-0.32263055443763733,
-0.34575408697128296,
-0.13945551216602325,
-0.28203558921813965,
0.45082953572273254,
0.7562932968139648,
0.11755773425102234,
0.2785964608192444,
0.5044384598731995,
-0.15715152025222778,
0.37902289628982544,
0.031750522553920746,
0.8382706046104431,
-0.9668325185775757,
-0.5283663272857666,
-0.3702400326728821,
0.6471825242042542,
0.04459388554096222,
-0.08479074388742447,
0.7399231195449829,
0.7146380543708801,
0.87710040807724,
-0.1638123095035553,
0.6325782537460327,
-0.351057767868042,
0.7329908609390259,
-0.4821217656135559,
0.288135290145874,
-0.549650251865387,
0.21919317543506622,
-0.09758565574884415,
-0.7727882862091064,
-0.03792180120944977,
0.1633773148059845,
0.20765727758407593,
-0.26989248394966125,
0.47640037536621094,
0.5051479935646057,
0.025953033939003944,
0.15638768672943115,
0.3039780855178833,
0.01417361106723547,
-0.05972963944077492,
0.6172205805778503,
0.8249948024749756,
-0.5684348344802856,
0.40094828605651855,
-0.06014719977974892,
-0.27245622873306274,
-0.11637145280838013,
-0.6649097800254822,
-0.22762899100780487,
-0.6757503151893616,
0.28291887044906616,
-0.6067427396774292,
0.117110975086689,
0.7120766043663025,
0.21838884055614471,
-0.42837002873420715,
-0.23141321539878845,
0.002284133108332753,
0.2503417134284973,
-0.3395735025405884,
-0.22119753062725067,
0.17583125829696655,
-0.9014365673065186,
-0.8429321050643921,
0.6099731922149658,
0.5075096487998962,
-0.08841393887996674,
-0.21683838963508606,
-0.013254928402602673,
-0.32128196954727173,
0.09772955626249313,
0.7563850283622742,
0.5766475200653076,
-0.2577272355556488,
0.04230960085988045,
0.20255926251411438,
-0.12185117602348328,
0.1101238876581192,
1.0873709917068481,
-1.1407095193862915,
0.30486392974853516,
0.5861371159553528,
1.1148072481155396,
0.5163910984992981,
0.16325826942920685,
0.4247265160083771,
-0.7201908826828003,
0.03690897673368454,
0.6990219354629517,
0.2606677711009979,
0.2608073055744171,
-0.5704214572906494,
0.7881441116333008,
0.19790786504745483,
-0.6674239039421082,
-0.5893809795379639,
0.34147515892982483,
-0.9508416056632996,
-0.38167014718055725,
0.8447598218917847,
-0.022690244019031525,
-0.08003897219896317,
-0.10795493423938751,
-0.007953782565891743,
0.15228748321533203,
-0.06357628852128983,
0.7268895506858826,
0.22037388384342194,
-0.1331736445426941,
0.12785547971725464,
-0.3716030418872833,
0.4367343485355377,
0.4052443206310272,
-0.6938018202781677,
-0.0249436404556036,
0.4562969207763672,
-0.21451233327388763,
0.3009488880634308,
0.9534097909927368,
-0.4345459043979645,
0.29921796917915344,
0.16195248067378998,
-0.07316097617149353,
0.17186039686203003,
-0.4011431932449341,
-0.07243157923221588,
0.4835314452648163,
0.15576499700546265,
-0.27621543407440186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00342v1 | Korean Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis via Implicit-Feature Alignment with Corpus Filtering | 2024-06-29T07:01:51 | 2024-06-29T07:01:51 | Kibeom Nam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Investigations into Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) for Korean
restaurant reviews are notably lacking in the existing literature. Our research
proposes an intuitive and effective framework for ABSA in low-resource
languages such as Korean. It optimizes prediction labels by integrating
translated benchmark and unlabeled Korean data. Using a model fine-tuned on
translated data, we pseudo-labeled the actual Korean NLI set. Subsequently, we
applied LaBSE and MSP-based filtering to this pseudo-NLI set as implicit
feature, enhancing Aspect Category Detection and Polarity determination through
additional training. Incorporating dual filtering, this model bridged dataset
gaps, achieving positive results in Korean ABSA with minimal resources. Through
additional data injection pipelines, our approach aims to utilize high-resource
data and construct effective models within communities, whether corporate or
individual, in low-resource language countries. Compared to English ABSA, our
framework showed an approximately 3% difference in F1 scores and accuracy. We
release the dataset and our code for Korean ABSA, at this link. | [
-0.4528360068798065,
-0.46004486083984375,
0.7553081512451172,
0.2815398871898651,
-0.5848488211631775,
0.08079671114683151,
-0.005415656603872776,
-0.6207955479621887,
0.6204958558082581,
0.7091916799545288,
-0.40507030487060547,
-0.9368704557418823,
-0.1406867653131485,
0.2115597277879715,
0.1024843379855156,
1.1710431575775146,
-0.24462349712848663,
0.44943690299987793,
-0.31572553515434265,
-0.504270613193512,
-0.32330578565597534,
-0.3745419979095459,
-0.4760836660861969,
-0.34429115056991577,
0.3864465355873108,
0.4949718117713928,
0.7442904114723206,
0.4624177813529968,
0.2770216166973114,
0.22289645671844482,
-0.14455001056194305,
0.06416814029216766,
-0.19347722828388214,
0.08457393944263458,
-0.2609761357307434,
-0.3691314160823822,
-0.6394637823104858,
-0.032807935029268265,
0.3247440755367279,
0.7938817739486694,
0.33874407410621643,
0.1506042182445526,
0.054284945130348206,
1.1393492221832275,
-0.2753722369670868,
0.42572665214538574,
-0.2247285544872284,
0.05829882249236107,
0.08695739507675171,
0.4305180609226227,
0.02908887155354023,
-0.5042909383773804,
0.06150873005390167,
-0.5093975067138672,
-0.1094820573925972,
0.04529789462685585,
0.7577306628227234,
0.25481244921684265,
-0.3034486770629883,
-0.43051716685295105,
-0.8296709060668945,
0.6778982877731323,
-0.6697794198989868,
0.3497525453567505,
0.3635706901550293,
-0.2188625931739807,
0.1802351176738739,
-0.4139367341995239,
-0.6377113461494446,
-0.15775850415229797,
-0.28502461314201355,
0.2688422203063965,
-0.01807413250207901,
0.1322583109140396,
-0.09544152766466141,
0.5278646945953369,
-0.46813374757766724,
0.15854845941066742,
-0.17637945711612701,
0.23812074959278107,
0.6471569538116455,
-0.10811234265565872,
0.2270740121603012,
-0.6816429495811462,
-0.3163461983203888,
-0.11314155161380768,
-0.8061779141426086,
0.35052284598350525,
0.4538451135158539,
0.4084200859069824,
-0.08557730168104172,
0.6996603012084961,
-0.5253956913948059,
0.3056337833404541,
-0.004853167105466127,
0.10662642866373062,
0.43322911858558655,
-0.6096322536468506,
0.02860233187675476,
0.29374340176582336,
0.8561621904373169,
0.5931745171546936,
-0.013467525132000446,
-0.027204353362321854,
-0.49228739738464355,
0.12062668800354004,
0.20574118196964264,
-0.534982442855835,
-0.40884828567504883,
0.627561092376709,
-0.5764638781547546,
-0.3804411292076111,
0.36940377950668335,
-0.8830864429473877,
-0.48259443044662476,
-0.42145732045173645,
-0.05466512590646744,
-0.052297815680503845,
-0.40948739647865295,
-0.3709527254104614,
0.09871899336576462,
0.17585283517837524,
-0.08049534261226654,
-0.3079437017440796,
-0.03051878698170185,
0.8293483853340149,
0.7990992665290833,
0.024422451853752136,
0.08122245967388153,
-0.18415270745754242,
-0.1165563091635704,
-0.4995841681957245,
0.7340949773788452,
-0.5133399963378906,
-0.5015796422958374,
0.23332750797271729,
0.15705245733261108,
0.23501048982143402,
-0.6360195875167847,
0.7480959892272949,
-0.493934690952301,
-0.2077525556087494,
-0.3604132831096649,
-0.31819260120391846,
-0.4163547158241272,
0.20954860746860504,
-0.6814125180244446,
1.1438192129135132,
0.27407288551330566,
-0.42594462633132935,
0.3337114155292511,
-0.4852137565612793,
-0.5698800086975098,
-0.007534507662057877,
-0.10739072412252426,
-0.4733191132545471,
0.36762309074401855,
0.6481261253356934,
0.1868637651205063,
-0.0055325827561318874,
0.1257646381855011,
-0.42233791947364807,
0.0694994106888771,
0.4735632538795471,
0.017261113971471786,
0.27605336904525757,
0.24726243317127228,
-0.07249654829502106,
0.43666309118270874,
-0.4755028486251831,
0.22938388586044312,
-0.16033457219600677,
0.07096743583679199,
-0.7951673865318298,
-0.0011003639083355665,
0.11264105886220932,
0.520101010799408,
0.39710482954978943,
-0.5651424527168274,
0.0811774805188179,
-0.6111217141151428,
0.14787347614765167,
0.45563629269599915,
0.12785854935646057,
0.7631464600563049,
0.0629793182015419,
0.649686336517334,
0.2041250616312027,
0.2875145673751831,
-0.0964309349656105,
-0.5435538291931152,
-0.48197633028030396,
-0.32857298851013184,
0.39534708857536316,
0.6131288409233093,
-1.195225715637207,
0.607993483543396,
-0.3826781213283539,
-0.489748477935791,
-0.9486292004585266,
0.3580778241157532,
0.6696060299873352,
0.4129052758216858,
0.3263148069381714,
-0.5359187722206116,
-0.4203093349933624,
-0.9353488683700562,
0.002160679316148162,
-0.38783520460128784,
-0.12024123966693878,
0.34921011328697205,
0.10808081179857254,
0.14244809746742249,
1.002210021018982,
-0.7144277095794678,
-0.5450249910354614,
-0.5983358025550842,
0.18755552172660828,
0.5747221112251282,
0.3194793462753296,
0.5567834377288818,
-0.8686458468437195,
-0.8356000781059265,
0.2698020040988922,
-0.7466412782669067,
-0.34871605038642883,
0.06650625914335251,
-0.12338476628065109,
0.3229732811450958,
0.2735525071620941,
-0.36177492141723633,
0.37651726603507996,
0.5327644944190979,
-0.3765941262245178,
0.36645621061325073,
0.1638377457857132,
0.31084781885147095,
-1.114216685295105,
-0.17997515201568604,
0.40379706025123596,
-0.08673153072595596,
-0.5429644584655762,
-0.19988563656806946,
-0.06253743171691895,
-0.22960330545902252,
-0.3334253430366516,
0.6552934050559998,
-0.30866119265556335,
-0.2357177734375,
-0.7199518084526062,
0.07233508676290512,
0.1408819556236267,
0.684013843536377,
0.3390224277973175,
0.49292346835136414,
0.1663389354944229,
-0.3062635362148285,
0.12924596667289734,
-0.00607480900362134,
-0.3926243782043457,
0.8742125034332275,
-0.5604224801063538,
0.1885986328125,
-0.03515506535768509,
0.296888530254364,
-1.185402750968933,
0.09771667420864105,
0.453591525554657,
-0.18042941391468048,
0.15861999988555908,
-0.5840219259262085,
-0.18428771197795868,
-0.39411771297454834,
-0.6247620582580566,
0.237703338265419,
0.25713059306144714,
-0.42575711011886597,
0.8198968768119812,
0.557486891746521,
-0.5029585361480713,
-0.580712616443634,
-0.29186251759529114,
-0.17237615585327148,
-0.030266806483268738,
-0.37321504950523376,
0.47896334528923035,
0.36132195591926575,
-0.3725343644618988,
0.5422214269638062,
-0.34932857751846313,
-0.20536275207996368,
-0.3613067865371704,
0.48490017652511597,
0.43196842074394226,
-0.41041913628578186,
-0.3599821627140045,
0.3050191104412079,
-0.12564198672771454,
0.025312216952443123,
-0.24403409659862518,
0.4345223903656006,
-0.46399781107902527,
-0.013250050134956837,
-0.5311915278434753,
0.3192937672138214,
0.37507012486457825,
0.010514292865991592,
0.7523972988128662,
0.6464989185333252,
-0.19077129662036896,
-0.000941570324357599,
-0.1967838555574417,
-0.12619367241859436,
-0.4213598370552063,
0.6727117300033569,
-0.3752842843532562,
-0.34480541944503784,
0.685529887676239,
0.04329190403223038,
-0.11458322405815125,
0.30496931076049805,
0.06123824790120125,
-0.36584287881851196,
0.8948772549629211,
0.4782068133354187,
-0.3967122733592987,
0.42219284176826477,
-0.082146055996418,
0.5784376859664917,
-0.9060503840446472,
-0.04052847996354103,
-0.5716820359230042,
-0.2699386179447174,
-0.6140666007995605,
-0.19818955659866333,
0.47416239976882935,
0.36349380016326904,
0.2744952142238617,
0.1503608524799347,
-0.33998629450798035,
0.6744441390037537,
0.3446619212627411,
0.011918582953512669,
0.2605549395084381,
-0.2438134253025055,
0.14412464201450348,
-0.29387542605400085,
-0.4165048599243164,
-0.6127352118492126,
0.8290491104125977,
0.33624327182769775,
0.5551043152809143,
0.06557689607143402,
0.36158815026283264,
0.27149805426597595,
0.6569921970367432,
-0.83787602186203,
0.36948150396347046,
-0.520351767539978,
-0.15758836269378662,
-0.2396038919687271,
-0.44936349987983704,
-0.3191298544406891,
0.2548987567424774,
-0.20584148168563843,
-0.2860829830169678,
0.30475664138793945,
0.09031964093446732,
-0.11339185386896133,
0.20583845674991608,
-0.8822786808013916,
0.8048606514930725,
-0.36851537227630615,
-0.32878297567367554,
0.06405909359455109,
-0.2569478452205658,
0.3167394697666168,
-0.05707160755991936,
0.42081794142723083,
-0.2703931927680969,
0.13164575397968292,
0.46301165223121643,
-0.41291263699531555,
0.9475802779197693,
-0.6029950976371765,
-0.106136754155159,
0.2578420341014862,
-0.1403779685497284,
0.5731810331344604,
0.5234631299972534,
0.016692882403731346,
0.6208798885345459,
-0.1334373950958252,
-0.09817337244749069,
-0.637610912322998,
0.8820642232894897,
-0.6850941777229309,
-0.30503222346305847,
-0.3748474717140198,
-0.19836732745170593,
-0.42788636684417725,
0.2140025496482849,
-0.004372601862996817,
-0.041531410068273544,
-0.14411473274230957,
-0.06289391219615936,
0.4073612689971924,
-0.14554592967033386,
0.3192702531814575,
0.7431427836418152,
-0.4802777171134949,
-0.7365204095840454,
1.0565975904464722,
0.13896425068378448,
-0.2580450773239136,
0.28386932611465454,
-0.06727032363414764,
-0.7158082127571106,
-0.37948012351989746,
-0.6324306726455688,
0.3760795593261719,
-0.5370033383369446,
-0.28880542516708374,
-0.44512811303138733,
-0.28908270597457886,
-0.429730623960495,
-0.24009540677070618,
-0.8541927337646484,
-0.31119969487190247,
0.015717532485723495,
-0.21888288855552673,
0.17441347241401672,
0.869251549243927,
0.10430837422609329,
0.3730011284351349,
-0.5555736422538757,
0.2627904415130615,
0.028519995510578156,
0.4209864139556885,
-0.09460461139678955,
-0.33437034487724304,
-0.31389671564102173,
-0.19224633276462555,
-0.12377198785543442,
-0.8517188429832458,
0.5738705992698669,
-0.05541086569428444,
0.19697971642017365,
0.43319132924079895,
0.3259836733341217,
0.3352097272872925,
-0.2006516456604004,
0.7551401257514954,
0.12309946864843369,
-0.88101726770401,
0.384259432554245,
-0.004235139582306147,
0.41751164197921753,
0.7229129672050476,
0.4553650915622711,
-0.6447479128837585,
-0.47953805327415466,
-0.10647618025541306,
-1.4675935506820679,
0.7143828868865967,
-0.052555207163095474,
0.18373213708400726,
0.1315857470035553,
0.5184897184371948,
0.17951132357120514,
0.34823355078697205,
-0.9208426475524902,
-0.39350712299346924,
-0.6065950393676758,
-0.5432282090187073,
0.20960447192192078,
-0.45940327644348145,
-0.014846271835267544,
-0.2901112139225006,
1.0010032653808594,
-0.17043162882328033,
0.004850432742387056,
0.06757786870002747,
0.0838264748454094,
-0.13271234929561615,
0.38392236828804016,
0.38615792989730835,
0.6277928948402405,
-0.24603936076164246,
0.033604055643081665,
-0.09919514507055283,
-0.5817626118659973,
0.060041382908821106,
0.14464130997657776,
-0.3021741509437561,
0.06482774764299393,
0.03060055337846279,
0.7399682998657227,
0.07316940277814865,
-0.38697144389152527,
0.42424970865249634,
-0.020562399178743362,
0.2571920156478882,
-0.4127765893936157,
-0.2890940010547638,
-0.06511107832193375,
0.13220256567001343,
0.3415139317512512,
-0.14503000676631927,
0.07243912667036057,
-0.2538278102874756,
0.22016768157482147,
0.2208934724330902,
-0.8331277370452881,
-0.6118122339248657,
0.29011037945747375,
0.3846999406814575,
0.2017078995704651,
0.727219820022583,
-0.4567614793777466,
-0.5593515038490295,
0.5177333354949951,
0.20056895911693573,
1.0924299955368042,
-0.32541659474372864,
0.7187194228172302,
0.41647276282310486,
0.4741646945476532,
0.13728424906730652,
0.3095306158065796,
0.21874399483203888,
-0.7485386729240417,
-0.6073254942893982,
-0.8626408576965332,
-0.3591804504394531,
0.2592938244342804,
-0.7902458906173706,
0.07944905012845993,
-0.4285666048526764,
-0.1327229142189026,
-0.04674290865659714,
-0.12214192003011703,
-0.2837744355201721,
0.11760960519313812,
0.007039624731987715,
0.30988261103630066,
-1.1929155588150024,
0.7779221534729004,
1.139340877532959,
-0.4551014006137848,
-0.4949347674846649,
0.22392508387565613,
-0.09345541149377823,
-0.36290860176086426,
0.32110658288002014,
0.234487846493721,
-0.24552679061889648,
-0.5737639665603638,
-0.23156215250492096,
-0.7598775029182434,
0.548092782497406,
-0.12308751791715622,
-0.35535773634910583,
0.38542652130126953,
0.21719421446323395,
0.7468676567077637,
-0.5958470702171326,
-0.04801574721932411,
0.4085715115070343,
0.37215283513069153,
-0.017891639843583107,
-0.5759617686271667,
-0.09815627336502075,
-0.322146475315094,
0.13899123668670654,
0.10496695339679718,
-0.5484663844108582,
0.3934739828109741,
0.16448605060577393,
0.1283993422985077,
-0.21257038414478302,
1.150029182434082,
0.08634583652019501,
0.8020375370979309,
0.530829906463623,
0.4366869330406189,
0.503814160823822,
-0.18446362018585205,
0.8371613025665283,
-0.42020487785339355,
0.1938723623752594,
1.3061720132827759,
-0.658281683921814,
0.898470938205719,
0.5180053114891052,
-0.1916346698999405,
0.5276031494140625,
0.6294681429862976,
0.232090562582016,
0.8981148600578308,
-0.31114882230758667,
-0.11196092516183853,
0.18584562838077545,
-0.5621976852416992,
-0.12357720732688904,
0.4329652190208435,
0.2618931233882904,
-0.4696158766746521,
0.22436405718326569,
0.03530275821685791,
0.1567872017621994,
0.14453743398189545,
-0.5554507970809937,
0.976174533367157,
0.1788407415151596,
-0.7418724298477173,
-0.0028129220008850098,
0.33362704515457153,
0.5427414178848267,
-0.36478400230407715,
0.11594540625810623,
-0.61069655418396,
-0.03167083486914635,
-0.3985813856124878,
-1.039721965789795,
0.5291265845298767,
0.23109781742095947,
-0.5380246043205261,
-0.037754323333501816,
0.4481135606765747,
-0.6153826117515564,
-0.5404276251792908,
0.19954229891300201,
0.3755495846271515,
-0.09651068598031998,
-0.18533430993556976,
-0.7131249904632568,
0.027986038476228714,
0.1904493123292923,
-0.06114503741264343,
0.18668712675571442,
0.26385560631752014,
-0.24478267133235931,
-0.0007684516021981835,
0.4273199439048767,
0.10062512755393982,
-0.3038586378097534,
0.2523798942565918,
0.6882057785987854,
-0.5798931121826172,
-0.9836975932121277,
-0.5073878169059753,
0.28115710616111755,
-0.22038042545318604,
-0.24288301169872284,
0.6488670110702515,
0.7066638469696045,
0.9415109753608704,
-0.2614118456840515,
0.6223471760749817,
-0.006913571152836084,
0.3807893395423889,
-0.8091889023780823,
0.7615272402763367,
-0.32897961139678955,
0.6104553937911987,
-0.37047407031059265,
-1.2380157709121704,
-0.025446929037570953,
0.43106749653816223,
-0.514729380607605,
0.1085672602057457,
0.720977783203125,
0.8024845123291016,
0.018306715413928032,
0.18596675992012024,
0.15120790898799896,
0.3172276020050049,
0.16859547793865204,
0.0010319274151697755,
0.6914657354354858,
-0.22459489107131958,
0.3052956759929657,
-0.6898849010467529,
-0.2178286612033844,
-0.04504089429974556,
-0.6435648798942566,
-0.5584328174591064,
-0.6366984248161316,
-0.6078621745109558,
-0.4533410966396332,
-0.34130969643592834,
0.7658789753913879,
0.5462411046028137,
-1.160967230796814,
-0.15607021749019623,
0.19306080043315887,
0.4628658592700958,
-0.6351079344749451,
-0.33544355630874634,
0.6924729943275452,
-0.3033433258533478,
-0.8591043949127197,
0.4731016755104065,
0.41902783513069153,
-0.17062897980213165,
-0.2805847227573395,
-0.05356455221772194,
0.09601636976003647,
0.05691869556903839,
0.5849971771240234,
0.32495951652526855,
-0.6021779179573059,
-0.04397733509540558,
-0.18253447115421295,
-0.09591137617826462,
0.14430458843708038,
0.738838255405426,
-0.3212946653366089,
0.46939921379089355,
0.3218097984790802,
0.3808096945285797,
0.2040843665599823,
0.2714948356151581,
0.4504075348377228,
-1.2676780223846436,
0.21054798364639282,
0.1074138879776001,
0.2082933485507965,
0.5082698464393616,
-0.5220522880554199,
0.6778407692909241,
0.1488000899553299,
-0.294656366109848,
-0.7176996469497681,
0.11930324137210846,
-0.9347065687179565,
-0.3653286397457123,
1.1095359325408936,
-0.23641477525234222,
-0.6534819602966309,
-0.42971616983413696,
0.021267453208565712,
0.07088574767112732,
-0.6550328731536865,
0.9341102242469788,
0.7382632493972778,
-0.3617379367351532,
0.14421263337135315,
-0.5021812915802002,
0.7493743896484375,
0.44871026277542114,
-0.7961380481719971,
-0.011367835104465485,
0.6593645811080933,
0.13974320888519287,
0.19982115924358368,
0.6570391058921814,
-0.2657155692577362,
0.1376710832118988,
-0.38385501503944397,
0.2388438582420349,
0.09095894545316696,
-0.5253560543060303,
-0.4787801206111908,
0.2842054069042206,
0.0016247046878561378,
-0.25881028175354004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00341v1 | Iterative Data Augmentation with Large Language Models for Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-29T07:00:37 | 2024-06-29T07:00:37 | Haiyun Li, Qihuang Zhong, Ke Zhu, Juhua Liu, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is an important sentiment analysis
task, which aims to determine the sentiment polarity towards an aspect in a
sentence. Due to the expensive and limited labeled data, data augmentation (DA)
has become the standard for improving the performance of ABSA. However, current
DA methods usually have some shortcomings: 1) poor fluency and coherence, 2)
lack of diversity of generated data, and 3) reliance on some existing labeled
data, hindering its applications in real-world scenarios. In response to these
problems, we propose a systematic Iterative Data augmentation framework, namely
IterD, to boost the performance of ABSA. The core of IterD is to leverage the
powerful ability of large language models (LLMs) to iteratively generate more
fluent and diverse synthetic labeled data, starting from an unsupervised
sentence corpus. Extensive experiments on 4 widely-used ABSA benchmarks show
that IterD brings consistent and significant performance gains among 5 baseline
ABSA models. More encouragingly, the synthetic data generated by IterD can
achieve comparable or even better performance against the manually annotated
data. | [
-0.600340723991394,
-0.8327927589416504,
0.5330635905265808,
0.3759768307209015,
-0.6329165101051331,
0.2525607645511627,
-0.28473448753356934,
-0.49812233448028564,
0.4668351411819458,
0.6113353967666626,
-0.5533195734024048,
-0.8424733281135559,
-0.4232243597507477,
0.07743310183286667,
-0.5201708078384399,
1.0370591878890991,
-0.048994313925504684,
-0.009738507680594921,
-0.40548551082611084,
-0.38675254583358765,
-0.42134812474250793,
-0.7757846713066101,
-0.32412010431289673,
-0.2868776321411133,
0.24227693676948547,
0.5702270865440369,
0.6149013638496399,
0.5783286094665527,
0.5310792922973633,
0.30280154943466187,
-0.22682148218154907,
0.05607065558433533,
-0.13736116886138916,
0.2722477316856384,
-0.3148561716079712,
-0.3223239779472351,
-0.48222726583480835,
-0.2526973485946655,
0.6247808933258057,
1.0519779920578003,
0.024396462365984917,
-0.019793257117271423,
0.05048525705933571,
1.0085411071777344,
-0.3073025941848755,
0.420644074678421,
-0.403850257396698,
-0.14069269597530365,
-0.2980576455593109,
0.13766376674175262,
-0.049921683967113495,
-0.32447540760040283,
0.10573478043079376,
-0.2448464035987854,
0.18989971280097961,
-0.01926514506340027,
0.6713786721229553,
0.17617923021316528,
-0.19732271134853363,
-0.1899610161781311,
-0.8837140202522278,
0.6985900402069092,
-1.0565515756607056,
0.38068240880966187,
0.07327903807163239,
-0.1306864470243454,
-0.02600877732038498,
-0.4787802994251251,
-0.7178773880004883,
-0.24970151484012604,
0.1283990740776062,
0.09930285066366196,
-0.1725345253944397,
0.21180211007595062,
0.14563140273094177,
1.0138485431671143,
-0.24453766644001007,
0.3138791024684906,
-0.28749385476112366,
0.1609877198934555,
0.7945296764373779,
0.2099931240081787,
0.06312908232212067,
-0.3063085973262787,
-0.1519772708415985,
-0.34083476662635803,
-0.7121713757514954,
0.21618089079856873,
0.4662739932537079,
0.5998013615608215,
-0.06178172305226326,
0.9511837959289551,
-0.5375807881355286,
0.6563605070114136,
0.09606516361236572,
0.1251685619354248,
0.500988245010376,
-0.3892834484577179,
0.08032204210758209,
0.05112423002719879,
0.8323004841804504,
0.310286283493042,
-0.06951162964105606,
-0.09046783298254013,
-0.396716445684433,
0.22137339413166046,
0.2672383487224579,
-0.820193350315094,
-0.3134201765060425,
0.668747067451477,
-0.09858381748199463,
-0.21833474934101105,
0.08856361359357834,
-0.9134650826454163,
-0.3757752776145935,
-0.5268831253051758,
0.212988942861557,
-0.5324429273605347,
-0.29955726861953735,
-0.013187265023589134,
0.21807809174060822,
-0.022549035027623177,
0.0244312584400177,
-0.44043925404548645,
0.027406038716435432,
1.0306875705718994,
0.7962136268615723,
-0.4067438542842865,
-0.08000294119119644,
-0.4286923408508301,
-0.3859345018863678,
-0.5843821167945862,
1.025194764137268,
-0.9046440124511719,
-0.5173019766807556,
-0.02827017940580845,
-0.29237911105155945,
0.21111029386520386,
-0.6459628343582153,
0.7602608799934387,
-0.4997888505458832,
0.09370626509189606,
-0.2646375298500061,
-0.7510660886764526,
-0.47768089175224304,
0.4074856638908386,
-0.8752444386482239,
1.1198785305023193,
0.3062417507171631,
-0.7543551325798035,
0.3874616026878357,
-0.6240566968917847,
-0.7394426465034485,
-0.1636163592338562,
-0.03794189542531967,
-0.8001418709754944,
0.4225279688835144,
0.5343536734580994,
0.36078694462776184,
-0.48308512568473816,
0.5245265364646912,
-0.4921221137046814,
0.07144324481487274,
0.5439509153366089,
-0.2727510929107666,
0.41709795594215393,
0.1114925965666771,
-0.03276122733950615,
0.3214108347892761,
-0.7741921544075012,
-0.13085506856441498,
-0.35834985971450806,
-0.2625958025455475,
-0.44033676385879517,
0.04222403094172478,
0.11759784817695618,
0.09681046009063721,
0.07746859639883041,
-0.7879643440246582,
0.3917020559310913,
-0.7999763488769531,
0.11202556639909744,
0.7287021279335022,
0.14984363317489624,
0.6010159254074097,
-0.23830196261405945,
0.5271440744400024,
0.40003684163093567,
-0.008746896870434284,
-0.37784749269485474,
-0.3403572738170624,
-0.8398310542106628,
-0.5249423980712891,
0.5237049460411072,
0.28583523631095886,
-0.9381019473075867,
0.8768042325973511,
-0.4168606102466583,
-0.469016969203949,
-0.825462281703949,
0.36006495356559753,
0.05973237007856369,
0.39486220479011536,
0.3492897152900696,
-0.5716458559036255,
-0.5077123045921326,
-0.8024833798408508,
-0.12030453234910965,
-0.2460496872663498,
0.08274960517883301,
-0.06296540796756744,
0.33262157440185547,
-0.3383588194847107,
1.1745281219482422,
-0.34456339478492737,
-0.6614118814468384,
-0.418142706155777,
0.30673885345458984,
0.34396591782569885,
0.4943386912345886,
0.3204535245895386,
-0.5814203023910522,
-0.23313100636005402,
-0.011301493272185326,
-0.5296668410301208,
-0.36669400334358215,
-0.15882743895053864,
0.17002665996551514,
0.2778633236885071,
0.1537456512451172,
-0.3270144760608673,
0.30692416429519653,
0.659591794013977,
-0.2334572970867157,
0.2421056628227234,
-0.00995629746466875,
0.15453189611434937,
-1.3796803951263428,
-0.036569539457559586,
0.23619700968265533,
-0.20174632966518402,
-0.6018915772438049,
0.18404245376586914,
-0.03771771863102913,
-0.06020491197705269,
-0.10702099651098251,
0.5006567239761353,
-0.3832435607910156,
-0.24854245781898499,
-0.5813629031181335,
0.004270203877240419,
0.014223775826394558,
0.2980213463306427,
0.1586257666349411,
0.5962713956832886,
0.7489982843399048,
-0.5412775874137878,
0.2593320310115814,
0.04316427558660507,
-0.3226253390312195,
0.6998739838600159,
-0.5081703066825867,
0.08821135014295578,
-0.3067835867404938,
0.21399538218975067,
-0.8651220202445984,
-0.13056984543800354,
0.0998159870505333,
-0.2234729379415512,
0.23222151398658752,
0.09921786189079285,
-0.5184294581413269,
-0.37117302417755127,
-0.5802810788154602,
0.5298492312431335,
0.2687983214855194,
-0.687459409236908,
0.9486159682273865,
0.3483538031578064,
-0.476170152425766,
-0.4055227041244507,
-0.37086641788482666,
0.3041333556175232,
-0.14024893939495087,
-0.5444093346595764,
0.5016083121299744,
-0.08037015050649643,
-0.48534828424453735,
0.22769798338413239,
0.0013382049510255456,
0.05520375818014145,
-0.20588278770446777,
0.33564624190330505,
0.31816181540489197,
-0.09847334027290344,
0.019020427018404007,
0.2698277235031128,
-0.20544713735580444,
-0.11624462157487869,
0.022231517359614372,
0.6572974324226379,
-0.15674109756946564,
-0.518216609954834,
-0.5811862945556641,
0.5453891158103943,
0.40097776055336,
-0.2520933151245117,
0.5399423837661743,
0.25889280438423157,
-0.2581826150417328,
-0.17557676136493683,
-0.4897015690803528,
-0.2736203670501709,
-0.45560434460639954,
0.33897751569747925,
-0.3664846122264862,
-0.7584200501441956,
0.6362040042877197,
0.027619248256087303,
0.2094486951828003,
0.46363916993141174,
0.36419185996055603,
-0.11088697612285614,
1.0299345254898071,
0.8113860487937927,
-0.5761795043945312,
0.5855723023414612,
-0.36034658551216125,
0.3548911511898041,
-0.9269373416900635,
-0.09296835213899612,
-0.5638391971588135,
-0.17178116738796234,
-0.5911717414855957,
-0.5728462338447571,
0.5229092240333557,
0.15954656898975372,
0.1640060395002365,
0.03238840028643608,
-0.3513225018978119,
0.15087032318115234,
0.37710532546043396,
0.06723429262638092,
0.680935800075531,
0.0808684453368187,
0.3615075349807739,
-0.13457052409648895,
-0.37947338819503784,
-0.3012630343437195,
1.1109070777893066,
0.3883349597454071,
0.8354845643043518,
-0.04755939543247223,
0.6223892569541931,
0.34266984462738037,
0.5609091520309448,
-1.0618782043457031,
0.4488893747329712,
-0.4246048629283905,
-0.14844518899917603,
0.20845365524291992,
-0.27970224618911743,
-0.585960865020752,
0.12012013792991638,
-0.2246718853712082,
-0.661848247051239,
0.302967369556427,
0.1467541605234146,
-0.1009136438369751,
0.15268823504447937,
-0.2631431221961975,
0.26016685366630554,
-0.14222943782806396,
-0.3484066426753998,
-0.2929806113243103,
-0.16361412405967712,
0.3852490186691284,
-0.2811340093612671,
0.2706795930862427,
0.027372458949685097,
0.08516249805688858,
0.7562935948371887,
-0.7147011160850525,
0.7998166084289551,
-0.2176184207201004,
-0.3915700614452362,
0.3272702693939209,
-0.13784392178058624,
0.7143842577934265,
0.10445096343755722,
-0.3198372423648834,
0.36580711603164673,
-0.33881574869155884,
-0.30493196845054626,
-0.4471026062965393,
0.8566074967384338,
-0.4924640953540802,
-0.6692691445350647,
-0.47287172079086304,
-0.80940842628479,
-0.42793798446655273,
-0.09523123502731323,
0.08691293746232986,
0.5363577604293823,
-0.055597975850105286,
0.3208564519882202,
0.4211256504058838,
-0.20072349905967712,
0.5263671875,
0.48667046427726746,
-0.39467644691467285,
-0.5467481017112732,
0.9330158233642578,
0.08982055634260178,
0.052547603845596313,
0.26585647463798523,
0.019179662689566612,
-0.5439392924308777,
-0.7579364776611328,
-0.6313432455062866,
0.19436390697956085,
-0.6310152411460876,
-0.24818268418312073,
-0.6620848178863525,
-0.08155091106891632,
-0.3219260573387146,
-0.08597089350223541,
-0.8108399510383606,
-0.4078916609287262,
-0.1758839190006256,
-0.2884981632232666,
0.7493682503700256,
0.7199549078941345,
-0.05953795090317726,
0.41012629866600037,
-0.7567681074142456,
0.4182851016521454,
-0.17775830626487732,
0.33089733123779297,
-0.3340299427509308,
-0.4296664595603943,
-0.023737551644444466,
0.11607947945594788,
-0.10551440715789795,
-0.7592857480049133,
0.5968639254570007,
0.14550241827964783,
0.3602200448513031,
0.4124552607536316,
0.21366961300373077,
0.6976664066314697,
-0.05133424699306488,
0.8938069343566895,
0.008548985235393047,
-0.8727417588233948,
0.32917654514312744,
-0.0987645760178566,
0.2632828950881958,
0.5978914499282837,
0.053694948554039,
-0.3765352666378021,
-0.5953401923179626,
-0.4340711236000061,
-1.4417146444320679,
0.5624521374702454,
0.16386468708515167,
0.3508204519748688,
0.2378469705581665,
0.4107857644557953,
0.4341442883014679,
0.30099180340766907,
-0.5721790790557861,
-0.21034274995326996,
-0.20710012316703796,
-0.5607820749282837,
0.030059432610869408,
-0.1052938848733902,
-0.06388688832521439,
-0.3187932074069977,
0.8094273805618286,
-0.40745431184768677,
0.2029627412557602,
0.11697763949632645,
-0.13850848376750946,
-0.03770006075501442,
0.402133584022522,
0.06460479646921158,
0.5201730132102966,
-0.016802994534373283,
-0.06885683536529541,
-0.08070921152830124,
-0.22648565471172333,
0.025545042008161545,
0.40505605936050415,
-0.3225635588169098,
-0.08711574226617813,
0.28780776262283325,
0.8842581510543823,
-0.2111041098833084,
-0.7053303718566895,
0.35764163732528687,
0.20002056658267975,
0.10055260360240936,
-0.229188472032547,
-0.051583945751190186,
-0.06017139181494713,
0.4247135519981384,
0.5745123624801636,
-0.086534783244133,
0.23769310116767883,
-0.7092359662055969,
0.30317583680152893,
0.5824985504150391,
-0.38321706652641296,
-0.42116600275039673,
0.37659910321235657,
0.143821120262146,
-0.06278503686189651,
0.5169081091880798,
-0.20016039907932281,
-0.6045325398445129,
0.46557241678237915,
0.3386160433292389,
1.0362930297851562,
-0.04386748746037483,
0.39626598358154297,
0.32432302832603455,
0.21342375874519348,
-0.17922522127628326,
0.5022836327552795,
-0.019574172794818878,
-0.6713708639144897,
-0.7599577903747559,
-0.8122674226760864,
-0.5482022762298584,
0.15166126191616058,
-0.80439293384552,
0.020984061062335968,
-0.38846927881240845,
-0.024973023682832718,
-0.06304649263620377,
-0.07773435115814209,
-0.46808236837387085,
0.26251310110092163,
-0.10123229026794434,
0.5814346671104431,
-0.9597914218902588,
0.7231805920600891,
0.7853111624717712,
-0.4254298508167267,
-0.5506227016448975,
0.3177366256713867,
-0.23586758971214294,
-0.2977760136127472,
0.15896648168563843,
0.2940138280391693,
0.0690697431564331,
-0.03553871065378189,
-0.3140222728252411,
-0.6285575032234192,
0.7824892997741699,
0.036142971366643906,
-0.7425965666770935,
0.45777931809425354,
0.514714777469635,
0.7814935445785522,
-0.5694515109062195,
0.02571914531290531,
0.6956892013549805,
0.4613615572452545,
0.1732771247625351,
-0.6190202832221985,
0.04047993943095207,
-0.3098425269126892,
0.2599417567253113,
0.012496919371187687,
-0.4616341292858124,
0.9047784209251404,
-0.2424887716770172,
-0.06824180483818054,
0.06620115786790848,
1.0302790403366089,
0.2464105486869812,
0.3716755509376526,
0.5357083082199097,
0.7736534476280212,
0.6409266591072083,
-0.25658923387527466,
1.0433967113494873,
-0.41632506251335144,
0.3168618679046631,
1.0112649202346802,
-0.49322327971458435,
0.9069094657897949,
0.37318331003189087,
-0.06850671023130417,
0.6565557718276978,
0.6462957859039307,
0.14077025651931763,
0.4199192523956299,
-0.2115766704082489,
-0.4357950985431671,
-0.12427988648414612,
-0.2879464328289032,
-0.11784183979034424,
0.41257140040397644,
0.439033180475235,
-0.32757583260536194,
-0.257055401802063,
0.4337742030620575,
0.04461801052093506,
0.326295405626297,
-0.4664478898048401,
1.0380996465682983,
-0.04227155074477196,
-0.7474798560142517,
0.2508421540260315,
0.2586304843425751,
0.8523353934288025,
-0.208647221326828,
0.11122027039527893,
-0.5673002600669861,
0.35619643330574036,
-0.19432266056537628,
-1.1082582473754883,
0.4773354232311249,
0.25777727365493774,
-0.1795058250427246,
-0.008936179801821709,
0.703716516494751,
-0.5513947606086731,
-0.8005893230438232,
0.12235082685947418,
0.2930395305156708,
-0.20489288866519928,
-0.45762404799461365,
-0.697541356086731,
0.26059842109680176,
0.11943626403808594,
-0.4736615717411041,
0.24707040190696716,
0.1976744681596756,
-0.35923051834106445,
0.6865162253379822,
0.6642017960548401,
0.13463959097862244,
-0.3084412217140198,
0.18279661238193512,
1.3404983282089233,
-0.7916529178619385,
-0.5695049166679382,
-0.8353009223937988,
0.5888795256614685,
-0.19677937030792236,
-0.017510898411273956,
0.684749186038971,
0.6494571566581726,
0.6598865389823914,
0.17512600123882294,
0.99916672706604,
-0.20177888870239258,
0.5985107421875,
-0.6460244655609131,
0.19877958297729492,
-0.3386136293411255,
0.6826122403144836,
-0.27626311779022217,
-1.247276782989502,
-0.3048749566078186,
0.4145737588405609,
-0.35471850633621216,
0.06166008487343788,
0.5838440656661987,
0.9921296238899231,
-0.015003370121121407,
0.3062208890914917,
-0.10343554615974426,
0.41712576150894165,
0.6061496734619141,
-0.01494171004742384,
0.6651589274406433,
-0.324476957321167,
0.1261196732521057,
-0.7903810143470764,
-0.15350429713726044,
-0.09937139600515366,
-0.8918964266777039,
-0.7238384485244751,
-0.7739880084991455,
-0.5674188733100891,
-0.37572744488716125,
-0.2400413304567337,
1.015038251876831,
0.28076425194740295,
-0.9096471667289734,
0.011388776823878288,
-0.21767984330654144,
0.04538484290242195,
-0.32344162464141846,
-0.3507660925388336,
0.3431532382965088,
-0.25299301743507385,
-1.1088964939117432,
0.4735628664493561,
0.3101808428764343,
-0.1475953310728073,
-0.49879908561706543,
0.1739356368780136,
0.04974878579378128,
0.17116878926753998,
0.7115359902381897,
0.2283869832754135,
-0.48381203413009644,
-0.2851848900318146,
-0.26131531596183777,
0.2313898354768753,
0.27382028102874756,
0.870006799697876,
-0.8421223759651184,
0.6675535440444946,
0.6475307941436768,
0.705568253993988,
0.4794439971446991,
0.4804147481918335,
0.6877672076225281,
-1.0203229188919067,
0.06942743808031082,
0.2805997133255005,
0.2026888132095337,
0.8314115405082703,
-0.26903218030929565,
0.3340132534503937,
0.09207205474376678,
-0.2320787012577057,
-0.8596057891845703,
0.023373983800411224,
-1.139432430267334,
-0.3179754912853241,
1.396285891532898,
-0.052992116659879684,
-0.2590954303741455,
-0.1448180079460144,
-0.3173756003379822,
0.060207922011613846,
-0.6919345855712891,
0.9675730466842651,
0.38878899812698364,
-0.2722763419151306,
-0.08184144645929337,
-0.19492925703525543,
0.3943023383617401,
0.4109817445278168,
-1.1649727821350098,
0.3198259174823761,
0.8263853192329407,
0.24320897459983826,
0.1901056468486786,
0.591764509677887,
-0.17360679805278778,
-0.03453448787331581,
-0.25916263461112976,
0.193178191781044,
-0.021500468254089355,
-0.3365029990673065,
-0.43745291233062744,
0.31168586015701294,
0.1553325057029724,
-0.07929621636867523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01626v1 | SPARKLE: Enhancing SPARQL Generation with Direct KG Integration in Decoding | 2024-06-29T06:43:11 | 2024-06-29T06:43:11 | Jaebok Lee, Hyeonjeong Shin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing KBQA methods have traditionally relied on multi-stage methodologies,
involving tasks such as entity linking, subgraph retrieval and query structure
generation. However, multi-stage approaches are dependent on the accuracy of
preceding steps, leading to cascading errors and increased inference time.
Although a few studies have explored the use of end-to-end models, they often
suffer from lower accuracy and generate inoperative query that is not supported
by the underlying data. Furthermore, most prior approaches are limited to the
static training data, potentially overlooking the evolving nature of knowledge
bases over time. To address these challenges, we present a novel end-to-end
natural language to SPARQL framework, SPARKLE. Notably SPARKLE leverages the
structure of knowledge base directly during the decoding, effectively
integrating knowledge into the query generation. Our study reveals that simply
referencing knowledge base during inference significantly reduces the
occurrence of inexecutable query generations. SPARKLE achieves new
state-of-the-art results on SimpleQuestions-Wiki and highest F1 score on LCQuAD
1.0 (among models not using gold entities), while getting slightly lower result
on the WebQSP dataset. Finally, we demonstrate SPARKLE's fast inference speed
and its ability to adapt when the knowledge base differs between the training
and inference stages. | [
-0.3438767194747925,
-0.6899404525756836,
0.010417193174362183,
0.48952293395996094,
0.08565031737089157,
0.25798141956329346,
0.1480974555015564,
-0.3501420319080353,
0.05593772605061531,
0.720058262348175,
-0.6000103950500488,
-0.422004371881485,
-0.1848200410604477,
0.00962517224252224,
-0.3239680230617523,
0.8678368926048279,
0.4330538809299469,
-0.008473627269268036,
-0.21495386958122253,
0.062296122312545776,
-0.5137009620666504,
-0.5068657398223877,
-0.4079250693321228,
-0.3105560541152954,
0.3495570421218872,
0.4944515824317932,
0.7887734174728394,
-0.0436871238052845,
-0.04561359062790871,
0.12400726228952408,
-0.5028413534164429,
0.5187649726867676,
-0.7555103302001953,
0.2965144217014313,
-0.27658888697624207,
-0.5269811153411865,
-0.28662410378456116,
-0.47093960642814636,
0.40083378553390503,
0.884739339351654,
-0.11676976829767227,
0.039734259247779846,
0.28262296319007874,
1.196155071258545,
-1.153196096420288,
0.10509198158979416,
-0.7951425909996033,
0.27220699191093445,
-0.09599702805280685,
-0.30548569560050964,
-0.7893256545066833,
-0.0660725012421608,
-0.1458224356174469,
-0.7334458231925964,
0.33049479126930237,
0.06959526240825653,
0.7942448258399963,
0.24625709652900696,
-0.9500355124473572,
-0.444475382566452,
-0.6999271512031555,
0.47919654846191406,
-0.3273027241230011,
0.8175557851791382,
0.28929027915000916,
0.555649995803833,
-0.7474283576011658,
-0.9780071973800659,
-0.27387943863868713,
-0.21172137558460236,
-0.046677883714437485,
0.24518714845180511,
-0.10653188824653625,
-0.03679905831813812,
0.1291213035583496,
0.14399373531341553,
-0.41046157479286194,
-0.5064078569412231,
0.049059998244047165,
-0.15003637969493866,
0.3694552183151245,
0.1751447170972824,
0.035862915217876434,
-0.39569953083992004,
-0.19953913986682892,
0.18842509388923645,
-0.947506308555603,
0.15472151339054108,
0.120148204267025,
0.5757778286933899,
0.386555016040802,
0.4083713889122009,
-0.6087965965270996,
0.6225451231002808,
0.44328585267066956,
0.17333953082561493,
0.1962081789970398,
-0.32776927947998047,
-0.15542736649513245,
0.3318791091442108,
0.6607815623283386,
0.2531503140926361,
-0.028003880754113197,
-0.6370769739151001,
0.3246455192565918,
-0.24730908870697021,
0.08225220441818237,
-1.1685422658920288,
-0.4876401722431183,
0.21916459500789642,
-0.019907021895051003,
-0.31141844391822815,
-0.15338297188282013,
-0.8092713952064514,
-0.5091208815574646,
0.18741843104362488,
0.5531842708587646,
-0.4358207881450653,
-0.38052988052368164,
0.1495700627565384,
-0.21758700907230377,
0.24665260314941406,
0.06081491336226463,
-0.864732563495636,
0.35597577691078186,
0.6440756320953369,
0.4322367012500763,
0.3554341197013855,
0.05331147089600563,
-0.6815707683563232,
0.2732161283493042,
-0.7671437859535217,
0.6709122657775879,
-0.44100716710090637,
-0.42719945311546326,
-0.2546290457248688,
-0.1594991534948349,
-0.03174320608377457,
-0.5551623702049255,
0.6650160551071167,
-1.2187784910202026,
0.2548166513442993,
-0.4321797490119934,
-0.4861923158168793,
-0.1908138245344162,
0.028072480112314224,
-0.510692298412323,
1.3280596733093262,
0.3340766429901123,
-0.8121860027313232,
0.8371726274490356,
-0.4628138542175293,
-0.4958120286464691,
0.3395441174507141,
0.019568482413887978,
-0.3204078674316406,
0.12226635962724686,
0.5134240984916687,
0.2150682508945465,
-0.2943675220012665,
0.2800459861755371,
-0.18231363594532013,
-0.3745974898338318,
0.2205657660961151,
-0.17279647290706635,
0.6459734439849854,
0.41431382298469543,
-0.15363258123397827,
-0.30386418104171753,
-0.8339769244194031,
0.4230979084968567,
-0.15868502855300903,
-0.31147029995918274,
-0.3091169595718384,
0.10739535093307495,
-0.014645345509052277,
0.13084572553634644,
0.12518781423568726,
-0.2652793526649475,
0.11497897654771805,
-0.6428281664848328,
0.09764773398637772,
0.141527459025383,
0.4384920001029968,
0.7173550128936768,
0.11390204727649689,
0.49213892221450806,
0.09198228269815445,
0.10824545472860336,
-0.3371908664703369,
-0.6145007610321045,
-0.5962921380996704,
-0.26769524812698364,
0.6627647876739502,
0.540826141834259,
-0.7827742695808411,
0.4691453278064728,
-0.39673882722854614,
-0.43324699997901917,
-0.41547855734825134,
0.14171120524406433,
0.3579622507095337,
0.6676684021949768,
0.45682060718536377,
-0.05265619233250618,
-0.5231167674064636,
-0.5513198971748352,
-0.5843001008033752,
0.14148974418640137,
0.09929456561803818,
0.3560894727706909,
0.2131514996290207,
-0.1506974995136261,
1.3624540567398071,
-0.2819405198097229,
-0.1720561683177948,
-0.15343822538852692,
0.12697146832942963,
0.5886672735214233,
0.3261718153953552,
0.42722615599632263,
-1.1429377794265747,
-0.8769902586936951,
0.1987532675266266,
-0.6575026512145996,
-0.06966213136911392,
-0.034341029822826385,
-0.6993069052696228,
0.017443904653191566,
0.17966167628765106,
-0.4861004948616028,
0.29004600644111633,
0.024074411019682884,
-0.9821268320083618,
0.4016931653022766,
0.17478767037391663,
0.6640325784683228,
-1.1038249731063843,
0.023762162774801254,
-0.2264324426651001,
-0.09212290495634079,
-0.916232705116272,
0.054112229496240616,
0.46884483098983765,
0.030769797042012215,
-0.2626705765724182,
0.4843299388885498,
-0.5451270341873169,
-0.07446125149726868,
-0.08743184804916382,
-0.3652573227882385,
0.2598589062690735,
0.299879789352417,
-0.102415069937706,
0.6417355537414551,
0.460050106048584,
-0.7405397891998291,
0.06535209715366364,
0.4663904309272766,
-0.30503150820732117,
0.30700817704200745,
-0.16042083501815796,
-0.04431731626391411,
-0.05421117693185806,
0.1910594254732132,
-1.0230727195739746,
-0.4635162353515625,
0.12136625498533249,
-0.8998825550079346,
0.4616163372993469,
-0.8645715117454529,
-0.6475955247879028,
0.00432805297896266,
-0.13539248704910278,
0.10876169800758362,
0.6770553588867188,
-0.7677171230316162,
0.8231269121170044,
-0.01461843866854906,
0.12024613469839096,
-1.0367653369903564,
-0.804347574710846,
0.3943217396736145,
-0.24981190264225006,
-0.9487249851226807,
0.5994006395339966,
0.19635239243507385,
0.0483475886285305,
0.15687832236289978,
-0.24227692186832428,
-0.3414689004421234,
0.1680646687746048,
0.05474943667650223,
-0.021213017404079437,
-0.22380490601062775,
-0.024553248658776283,
0.5062029361724854,
-0.08547665923833847,
-0.117096446454525,
-0.04201316088438034,
0.27703672647476196,
0.2500545382499695,
-0.39328643679618835,
-0.05986674502491951,
0.3317219913005829,
0.6253659129142761,
-0.21365374326705933,
1.1375515460968018,
0.5339407920837402,
-0.24944132566452026,
-0.5306711196899414,
-0.5059670209884644,
-0.04159940406680107,
-0.5085655450820923,
0.4626745283603668,
-0.5673831105232239,
-0.9092455506324768,
0.4989927113056183,
-0.25536230206489563,
-0.19873446226119995,
0.2839670479297638,
0.5045996308326721,
0.11549702286720276,
1.2072336673736572,
0.4225757122039795,
0.1184854805469513,
0.27203691005706787,
0.016314830631017685,
0.3222436010837555,
-0.7339200377464294,
-0.47137749195098877,
-0.34219780564308167,
0.15724393725395203,
-0.21128009259700775,
-0.54007488489151,
0.5286130905151367,
1.1129404306411743,
-0.4475679397583008,
-0.01525149680674076,
-0.4991527795791626,
0.6066913604736328,
0.21025007963180542,
0.10204406827688217,
0.40120187401771545,
0.18556256592273712,
-0.19395482540130615,
-0.1198805719614029,
-1.0344487428665161,
0.0656057670712471,
1.1713778972625732,
0.0706242099404335,
0.7077855467796326,
0.30138009786605835,
0.7453390955924988,
0.23276427388191223,
0.3415858745574951,
-0.5937745571136475,
0.3022193908691406,
0.1198306530714035,
-0.6028338074684143,
0.06966026872396469,
-0.6939314603805542,
-0.8319127559661865,
0.5880630016326904,
-0.47700101137161255,
-0.5328570604324341,
0.2020590454339981,
0.24228452146053314,
-0.1111965999007225,
-0.07297222316265106,
-0.8832539916038513,
0.8453857898712158,
-0.017484836280345917,
-0.7431735992431641,
0.21639104187488556,
-0.4102254807949066,
0.5814425945281982,
0.004965716507285833,
0.4082401394844055,
0.05142247676849365,
0.21858009696006775,
0.49280470609664917,
-0.4350621998310089,
0.4634748697280884,
-0.43066519498825073,
0.0904407948255539,
0.4796205759048462,
0.3553120195865631,
0.6600214242935181,
-0.10561110824346542,
-0.08305955678224564,
-0.35930362343788147,
0.0026203684974461794,
-0.3034858703613281,
-0.9048816561698914,
0.4585931897163391,
-0.27646297216415405,
-0.1320507675409317,
-0.1481052190065384,
-0.45268404483795166,
-0.6987629532814026,
-0.04683178290724754,
0.31063973903656006,
0.573405921459198,
0.02073752135038376,
0.3048427402973175,
0.8192758560180664,
-0.03455805405974388,
0.025435980409383774,
0.7416561841964722,
-0.3605339527130127,
-0.5830499529838562,
0.8384628891944885,
0.017486155033111572,
0.07100395858287811,
0.6079843044281006,
0.04663657397031784,
-0.6959226131439209,
-0.6325313448905945,
-0.5404302477836609,
0.020743204280734062,
-0.8429020643234253,
-0.45341578125953674,
-0.6709107756614685,
-0.08879606425762177,
-0.8082916140556335,
-0.23910441994667053,
-0.3491772413253784,
-0.43167757987976074,
-0.1796361654996872,
0.16082996129989624,
0.6014788150787354,
0.44159775972366333,
0.05397076532244682,
0.13510872423648834,
-1.1830710172653198,
0.21234574913978577,
0.1413208693265915,
0.10436472296714783,
0.13994108140468597,
-0.6381629109382629,
-0.5069685578346252,
-0.2371075302362442,
-0.0915362685918808,
-1.2154951095581055,
0.5196998119354248,
0.5221867561340332,
0.7329129576683044,
0.18716566264629364,
0.2900429368019104,
0.9458659291267395,
-0.5079793334007263,
0.8445006608963013,
0.22175949811935425,
-0.7422471046447754,
0.5113714933395386,
-0.2982306182384491,
0.2704440653324127,
0.5313384532928467,
0.4170808494091034,
-0.5323506593704224,
-0.13543353974819183,
-0.37046125531196594,
-1.1506214141845703,
0.4369645416736603,
0.31409668922424316,
-0.10751567035913467,
-0.1412920206785202,
0.4550417959690094,
-0.11196868866682053,
0.10498367249965668,
-0.537658154964447,
-0.24527773261070251,
-0.1675211787223816,
-0.3740009367465973,
0.3218473494052887,
-0.4554404020309448,
0.017057277262210846,
-0.09712875634431839,
0.7887032628059387,
-0.22841811180114746,
0.17304788529872894,
0.10922250151634216,
-0.3927229344844818,
-0.012906059622764587,
0.48222535848617554,
-0.16836117208003998,
0.4006311595439911,
-0.10677698254585266,
-0.11551964282989502,
0.444018691778183,
-0.4683533310890198,
-0.07661081105470657,
0.023517847061157227,
0.014714190736413002,
-0.21379230916500092,
0.3215737044811249,
0.3928642272949219,
0.5710219740867615,
-0.5912915468215942,
0.42349666357040405,
0.044850144535303116,
-0.3137248456478119,
-0.022417334839701653,
0.24296213686466217,
0.29274410009384155,
0.5521154999732971,
0.7940769791603088,
-0.13299860060214996,
0.46066245436668396,
-0.3162747323513031,
0.5655806064605713,
0.5244540572166443,
-0.2572546899318695,
-0.06420289725065231,
0.7882772088050842,
0.08252047002315521,
0.04942874237895012,
0.5216596126556396,
-0.5465532541275024,
-0.5504136085510254,
0.3391207158565521,
0.658011257648468,
0.6726135611534119,
-0.11767806112766266,
0.031039901077747345,
0.5062258839607239,
-0.02206294611096382,
0.01668632961809635,
0.37877485156059265,
-0.5269289016723633,
-0.7638601064682007,
-0.7701500058174133,
-0.976105272769928,
-0.2731143534183502,
-0.33933812379837036,
-0.8464621305465698,
0.19027811288833618,
0.0469558984041214,
0.13656650483608246,
-0.40454262495040894,
0.048481155186891556,
-0.17721974849700928,
0.13691183924674988,
0.11570779979228973,
1.2425100803375244,
-0.8445762395858765,
0.5957456231117249,
0.37309813499450684,
-0.2283300906419754,
-0.8270689249038696,
-0.3544095456600189,
-0.059085339307785034,
-0.43975937366485596,
0.9075979590415955,
0.007861030288040638,
-0.15383704006671906,
0.10935299098491669,
-0.43047115206718445,
-0.9824743866920471,
1.306949257850647,
0.2976430356502533,
-0.1724841147661209,
-0.2530909478664398,
0.20542582869529724,
0.3609960675239563,
-0.20842139422893524,
0.3742711842060089,
0.689021646976471,
0.18623921275138855,
0.8217058777809143,
-0.7515690922737122,
-0.06739478558301926,
-0.2989921569824219,
-0.15848423540592194,
0.4877279996871948,
-0.21753856539726257,
0.5442225933074951,
-0.00481010228395462,
-0.3488982319831848,
0.0374402180314064,
0.9036869406700134,
0.47178924083709717,
0.3424738049507141,
0.2162720113992691,
0.8558842539787292,
0.7406770586967468,
-0.06891442090272903,
0.7030192017555237,
-0.44547584652900696,
0.5315580368041992,
1.0503908395767212,
-0.13429881632328033,
0.7675052285194397,
0.06653089076280594,
-0.38266071677207947,
0.3680095374584198,
0.48896524310112,
0.15904095768928528,
0.9783986210823059,
-0.08243675529956818,
-0.6452074646949768,
-0.3991474509239197,
0.1245327889919281,
-0.511282205581665,
0.05952851101756096,
0.7899486422538757,
-0.14093872904777527,
-0.6425977945327759,
-0.07598552107810974,
0.09126554429531097,
-0.051370568573474884,
-0.5365480780601501,
0.6514394879341125,
-0.21831536293029785,
-0.6422120928764343,
0.6780127286911011,
-0.20683825016021729,
0.7023130059242249,
-0.7528699636459351,
-0.26728910207748413,
-0.19090750813484192,
0.10403813421726227,
-0.5766875147819519,
-0.6237241625785828,
0.16476765275001526,
0.04871506616473198,
-0.14774689078330994,
0.1052725687623024,
1.0063673257827759,
-0.4581937789916992,
-0.3641152083873749,
0.14442318677902222,
0.3788219690322876,
0.11633432656526566,
-0.31326764822006226,
-0.7842012643814087,
-0.26698318123817444,
0.124008409678936,
-0.4243220388889313,
0.5260582566261292,
0.7105094194412231,
0.22145403921604156,
0.6257151961326599,
0.6581892371177673,
-0.24668528139591217,
0.4900500774383545,
0.10616693645715714,
0.8888635039329529,
-0.6985862851142883,
-0.6362667083740234,
-0.5490362644195557,
0.764944314956665,
0.05143154785037041,
-0.02190868742763996,
0.923745334148407,
0.7765641212463379,
0.2922629117965698,
0.20303194224834442,
0.6006171107292175,
-0.12114930897951126,
0.6232242584228516,
-0.6678112149238586,
0.8834788799285889,
-0.46430501341819763,
0.18857555091381073,
-0.1718733310699463,
-0.7201107144355774,
-0.301289826631546,
0.34807634353637695,
0.04771530255675316,
0.09246085584163666,
0.3975698947906494,
1.195618987083435,
0.11706464737653732,
0.0979187935590744,
0.31619760394096375,
0.09492034465074539,
0.3948668837547302,
0.5696476101875305,
0.9083174467086792,
-0.5431404709815979,
0.6436915993690491,
-0.10545694082975388,
-0.23807349801063538,
-0.3171512484550476,
-0.7733376026153564,
-0.7405681610107422,
-0.4539436995983124,
-0.19953502714633942,
-0.7406833171844482,
0.07605002075433731,
0.6293138265609741,
0.6974923610687256,
-0.6494642496109009,
0.10551605373620987,
-0.3492503762245178,
-0.07239276170730591,
-0.13406500220298767,
-0.3434118330478668,
0.3185134828090668,
-0.7291215658187866,
-0.39567744731903076,
0.769408106803894,
0.05985352396965027,
-0.27126675844192505,
0.04699091240763664,
-0.06377628445625305,
-0.005961345508694649,
-0.024768536910414696,
0.7183108329772949,
0.3837450444698334,
-0.38075071573257446,
0.08876930922269821,
-0.015650276094675064,
0.1590762436389923,
0.0884338915348053,
0.4812681972980499,
-1.2551733255386353,
0.4890463352203369,
0.32602593302726746,
0.6619637608528137,
0.8707419037818909,
0.06317764520645142,
0.3333674371242523,
-0.7968134880065918,
-0.1496555358171463,
0.3594729006290436,
0.04651921987533569,
0.1663082093000412,
-0.6522451043128967,
0.4273359179496765,
0.12982863187789917,
-0.5695594549179077,
-0.9002683162689209,
0.266792893409729,
-0.907407283782959,
-0.3591965436935425,
1.0520833730697632,
0.23192892968654633,
-0.31889864802360535,
-0.3253123164176941,
0.082085020840168,
0.08114737272262573,
-0.3611685633659363,
0.2445523738861084,
0.48845842480659485,
-0.6298440098762512,
-0.18836349248886108,
-0.5158735513687134,
0.6954678297042847,
0.3457041084766388,
-0.6057205200195312,
0.15758001804351807,
0.6000016927719116,
0.49675726890563965,
0.06649196147918701,
0.6759757399559021,
-0.2849733531475067,
0.48850828409194946,
0.46692347526550293,
0.010267924517393112,
-0.21436327695846558,
-0.305543452501297,
-0.15075650811195374,
0.5853654742240906,
0.11094506829977036,
0.07904939353466034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00322v1 | LLM-Generated Natural Language Meets Scaling Laws: New Explorations and Data Augmentation Methods | 2024-06-29T05:40:17 | 2024-06-29T05:40:17 | Zhenhua Wang, Guang Xu, Ming Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the ascent of large language models (LLM), natural language processing
has witnessed enhancements, such as LLM-based data augmentation. Nonetheless,
prior research harbors two primary concerns: firstly, a lack of contemplation
regarding whether the natural language generated by LLM (LLMNL) truly aligns
with human natural language (HNL), a critical foundational question; secondly,
an oversight that augmented data is randomly generated by LLM, implying that
not all data may possess equal training value, that could impede the
performance of classifiers. To address these challenges, we introduce the
scaling laws to intrinsically calculate LLMNL and HNL. Through extensive
experiments, we reveal slight deviations (approximately 0.2 Mandelbrot
exponent) from Mandelbrot's law in LLMNL, underscore a complexity advantage in
HNL, and supplement an interpretive discussion on language style. This
establishes a solid foundation for LLM's expansion. Further, we introduce a
novel data augmentation method for few-shot text classification, termed ZGPTDA,
which leverages fuzzy computing mechanisms driven by the conformity to scaling
laws to make decisions about GPT-4 augmented data. Extensive experiments,
conducted in real-world scenarios, confirms the effectiveness (improving F1 of
Bert and RoBerta by 7-10%) and competitiveness (surpassing recent AugGPT and
GENCO methods by about 2% accuracy on DeBerta) of ZGPTDA. In addition, we
reveal some interesting insights, e.g., Hilberg's law and Taylor's law can
impart more benefits to text classification, etc. | [
-0.34016546607017517,
-0.8422508835792542,
0.6899892091751099,
0.005807777401059866,
-0.20785965025424957,
-0.13708768784999847,
-0.5574914216995239,
-0.6564428806304932,
-0.013430611230432987,
0.5117372870445251,
-0.47457972168922424,
-0.2535293698310852,
-0.6526942253112793,
0.20002874732017517,
-0.2547251582145691,
1.15058171749115,
0.1769576370716095,
-0.10622579604387283,
-0.07965053617954254,
-0.09596804529428482,
-0.07237516343593597,
-0.7276567816734314,
-0.3037688732147217,
-0.43075528740882874,
0.40837129950523376,
0.3606574833393097,
0.9622265696525574,
0.9171069264411926,
0.7692350745201111,
0.28284937143325806,
-0.32213085889816284,
0.1831195205450058,
-0.4584154188632965,
-0.11739439517259598,
0.20189906656742096,
-0.4536670744419098,
-0.36826005578041077,
-0.09993386268615723,
0.8550998568534851,
0.5753462910652161,
-0.16473248600959778,
-0.1522843986749649,
0.13876603543758392,
0.7838913798332214,
-0.3947923183441162,
0.09022636711597443,
-0.5103965997695923,
0.005213011056184769,
-0.3610527217388153,
-0.018682096153497696,
-0.12915639579296112,
-0.41129928827285767,
0.1501828283071518,
-0.42111700773239136,
0.41824638843536377,
0.14824429154396057,
0.8164515495300293,
0.25796079635620117,
-0.4360516369342804,
-0.4969860315322876,
-0.5480968356132507,
0.7064831256866455,
-1.0359731912612915,
0.2438010424375534,
0.01882058195769787,
0.21185427904129028,
-0.19257913529872894,
-0.725170910358429,
-0.900759756565094,
-0.32487982511520386,
-0.05976095423102379,
-0.24820350110530853,
-0.18100351095199585,
0.28295961022377014,
0.40961143374443054,
0.6493646502494812,
-0.37817516922950745,
0.4368168115615845,
-0.3133644163608551,
-0.10617360472679138,
0.8552508354187012,
0.25356626510620117,
0.47316136956214905,
-0.3004949390888214,
-0.25022897124290466,
-0.040218111127614975,
-0.6461495757102966,
-0.26472824811935425,
0.4818958342075348,
0.6427879929542542,
0.07486733049154282,
0.7271116375923157,
-0.28252485394477844,
0.736162006855011,
0.1075311005115509,
-0.16394571959972382,
0.4091663062572479,
-0.5788311958312988,
-0.14156469702720642,
0.3629969358444214,
0.9368131160736084,
0.3554987609386444,
0.4214392304420471,
-0.08015940338373184,
-0.19928739964962006,
-0.3376196026802063,
0.3377916216850281,
-0.8900507092475891,
-0.02388111874461174,
-0.1290586292743683,
-0.24193578958511353,
-0.5035443305969238,
0.004079291131347418,
-0.5566586256027222,
-0.6429427266120911,
-0.4201427698135376,
0.6553633213043213,
-0.20812474191188812,
-0.27709558606147766,
0.16646815836429596,
0.030810192227363586,
0.25944074988365173,
0.32564467191696167,
-1.292852520942688,
0.26075777411460876,
0.9753518104553223,
0.8138847351074219,
-0.060602884739637375,
-0.19987136125564575,
-0.26548653841018677,
-0.2154761105775833,
-0.43257173895835876,
0.6386030912399292,
-0.3480672240257263,
-0.0822279080748558,
0.013369329273700714,
-0.2974609434604645,
0.22759230434894562,
-0.5299111008644104,
0.725671648979187,
-0.5425278544425964,
0.0652330219745636,
-0.2239082008600235,
-0.7384548187255859,
-0.022947432473301888,
0.2995961308479309,
-0.6625766754150391,
1.0912144184112549,
0.10792633146047592,
-0.7679856419563293,
0.6396918892860413,
-0.609241783618927,
-0.45334991812705994,
0.15102224051952362,
-0.17201976478099823,
-0.556835412979126,
0.1522592157125473,
0.07994794845581055,
0.47456133365631104,
-0.5003015398979187,
0.2579815089702606,
-0.15747278928756714,
-0.1780274212360382,
0.05668597295880318,
-0.622099757194519,
0.6236805319786072,
0.11602812260389328,
-0.14566625654697418,
0.03166406229138374,
-0.7727054953575134,
0.11622507125139236,
-0.02891937643289566,
-0.6238530278205872,
-0.1699361950159073,
-0.026047909632325172,
0.09401783347129822,
-0.003819554578512907,
0.3104221820831299,
-0.6611832976341248,
0.3150729537010193,
-0.6423519849777222,
0.513383686542511,
0.6947749853134155,
0.17668412625789642,
0.7484865188598633,
-0.13358120620250702,
0.20757408440113068,
-0.18611373007297516,
-0.050502676516771317,
-0.05133342370390892,
-0.5245043039321899,
-0.5327470302581787,
-0.10761561989784241,
0.2532255947589874,
0.34880608320236206,
-0.5030162334442139,
0.5158938765525818,
-0.4974971413612366,
-0.5225609540939331,
-0.38215208053588867,
0.41880518198013306,
0.031908221542835236,
0.46572327613830566,
0.317293256521225,
-0.03166123852133751,
-0.5554993748664856,
-0.8650068044662476,
-0.36404526233673096,
-0.22654782235622406,
-0.294502854347229,
0.2607099115848541,
0.15751245617866516,
-0.3463965654373169,
1.0734117031097412,
-0.5278883576393127,
-0.22429437935352325,
-0.46690070629119873,
0.3089701533317566,
0.40927818417549133,
0.43847405910491943,
0.5946240425109863,
-0.6568908095359802,
-0.4933905601501465,
0.24351324141025543,
-0.6130988001823425,
-0.3218909502029419,
-0.23757675290107727,
0.08965880423784256,
0.16313396394252777,
0.3092467188835144,
-0.5172755122184753,
0.2620834708213806,
0.160558819770813,
-0.09510448575019836,
0.398366779088974,
-0.4145869016647339,
-0.03671097010374069,
-0.9712979197502136,
-0.48674216866493225,
0.2636847496032715,
-0.2253231704235077,
-1.0563369989395142,
0.07392672449350357,
0.21532031893730164,
0.2474583387374878,
-0.24513889849185944,
0.27481240034103394,
-0.27637624740600586,
0.038403235375881195,
-0.6026442646980286,
0.061878759413957596,
-0.23899206519126892,
0.2621553838253021,
0.03331960737705231,
0.8617166876792908,
0.43249014019966125,
-0.6466107368469238,
0.5555935502052307,
0.007295065093785524,
-0.3163735568523407,
0.44790390133857727,
-0.48469480872154236,
0.04723783954977989,
-0.1847018301486969,
0.01587207429111004,
-0.7803086638450623,
-0.2796574532985687,
-0.013276400975883007,
-0.4165666103363037,
0.2760806381702423,
-0.07991155236959457,
-0.994988203048706,
-0.26817652583122253,
-0.3886054754257202,
0.26826661825180054,
0.7147762179374695,
-0.7890732288360596,
0.5163964629173279,
0.2260155826807022,
-0.05155891925096512,
-0.3640361726284027,
-0.7007522583007812,
0.33274486660957336,
-0.24717064201831818,
-0.6892299056053162,
0.21621300280094147,
-0.14077246189117432,
-0.5057429671287537,
-0.17780636250972748,
-0.003272406756877899,
-0.22827844321727753,
0.029354512691497803,
-0.05148172378540039,
0.26613369584083557,
-0.4542539119720459,
0.2298014611005783,
-0.07703747600317001,
0.14162589609622955,
0.21888349950313568,
-0.3908790051937103,
0.5328545570373535,
-0.28961578011512756,
-0.09666459262371063,
-0.30485019087791443,
-0.1451784074306488,
0.2594734728336334,
0.26306670904159546,
0.6095069646835327,
0.7464335560798645,
-0.35945644974708557,
0.03681952506303787,
-0.5740634202957153,
-0.09185385704040527,
-0.5304849147796631,
0.20438767969608307,
-0.12948860228061676,
-0.9348159432411194,
0.2229980230331421,
0.19975878298282623,
0.06080622225999832,
0.6944125890731812,
0.7418646216392517,
-0.0003696389321703464,
0.7782208919525146,
0.8236389756202698,
-0.21912507712841034,
0.6384546756744385,
0.13357329368591309,
0.22286027669906616,
-0.800294041633606,
0.11233223974704742,
-0.45228782296180725,
-0.3083530068397522,
-1.072562575340271,
-0.3216475248336792,
0.34252387285232544,
0.02008242718875408,
-0.17738467454910278,
0.46396300196647644,
-0.33963820338249207,
0.7946885824203491,
0.5138679146766663,
0.10519928485155106,
0.426052063703537,
-0.006524735130369663,
0.15293455123901367,
-0.1851978451013565,
-0.6424998641014099,
-0.33560189604759216,
1.2968188524246216,
0.3044438064098358,
0.8508095145225525,
0.16785688698291779,
0.9261646270751953,
0.4423728585243225,
0.5063228011131287,
-1.0061055421829224,
0.3960117697715759,
-0.03505104407668114,
-0.5641855597496033,
-0.4662557542324066,
-0.7882333397865295,
-0.6464104652404785,
0.3395526707172394,
-0.36009809374809265,
-0.5743240714073181,
0.10246896743774414,
-0.01156054437160492,
-0.29671287536621094,
0.4934127628803253,
-0.7492541074752808,
0.3476193845272064,
-0.30262336134910583,
-0.5497148633003235,
-0.11255176365375519,
-0.6888103485107422,
0.30102577805519104,
-0.2943132519721985,
0.15993502736091614,
-0.04805009812116623,
-0.1832798719406128,
0.6649875044822693,
-0.7077112197875977,
0.7640513777732849,
-0.0007085721590556204,
-0.5529967546463013,
0.5084363222122192,
-0.2786833345890045,
0.5384393334388733,
0.005418043117970228,
-0.0011018308578059077,
0.17121835052967072,
-0.25919538736343384,
-0.38248616456985474,
-0.683529794216156,
0.6019368767738342,
-0.5420740246772766,
-0.6406244039535522,
-0.4177238643169403,
-0.6346920728683472,
-0.07904865592718124,
0.4121314585208893,
0.3102193772792816,
0.20248767733573914,
0.03792783245444298,
0.23573893308639526,
0.7820496559143066,
-0.04095173627138138,
0.5310297608375549,
0.4920780062675476,
-0.1529701054096222,
-0.4177701771259308,
0.9793063402175903,
0.30436816811561584,
0.4463363289833069,
0.40125522017478943,
0.5122172832489014,
-0.26846542954444885,
-0.6973393559455872,
-0.5385621786117554,
0.20582644641399384,
-0.5917213559150696,
-0.22293080389499664,
-0.5014011263847351,
-0.43921470642089844,
-0.3931041955947876,
-0.15916331112384796,
-0.0828830897808075,
-0.5281728506088257,
-0.3349763751029968,
-0.20251445472240448,
0.6008702516555786,
0.8310142159461975,
-0.2676257789134979,
0.38715845346450806,
-0.7394610643386841,
0.18927504122257233,
0.33271363377571106,
0.3275517225265503,
-0.13600946962833405,
-0.5950064063072205,
-0.18845944106578827,
0.03727462515234947,
-0.05036402493715286,
-0.5205655097961426,
0.3227126896381378,
0.22504790127277374,
0.3117312490940094,
0.5039688348770142,
-0.021251030266284943,
0.5320115089416504,
-0.716789186000824,
0.637360692024231,
0.30084434151649475,
-0.7999910712242126,
0.25954103469848633,
-0.39140599966049194,
0.17747153341770172,
0.47960135340690613,
0.03789106011390686,
-0.6191956400871277,
-0.2823863625526428,
-0.6765284538269043,
-0.6705442070960999,
0.6187978386878967,
0.3096925914287567,
0.6150369048118591,
0.1364121288061142,
0.6761876940727234,
-0.0715574398636818,
0.23423488438129425,
-0.7295905351638794,
0.0009138198802247643,
0.03840494528412819,
-0.5286452770233154,
-0.013941050507128239,
-0.28284138441085815,
0.20144511759281158,
-0.24987465143203735,
0.2663608193397522,
-0.19178257882595062,
0.07480795681476593,
0.13796183466911316,
-0.09526100754737854,
-0.07724328339099884,
0.38522419333457947,
0.7509255409240723,
0.34464365243911743,
-0.18969814479351044,
0.14658725261688232,
0.21673433482646942,
-0.7819981575012207,
0.10759568214416504,
0.028594959527254105,
-0.14440441131591797,
-0.16581515967845917,
0.5504715442657471,
0.6102514863014221,
0.034634072333574295,
-0.6838093996047974,
0.3851708471775055,
0.06720110774040222,
-0.39736464619636536,
0.022000571712851524,
0.2787158787250519,
-0.14510735869407654,
0.21576663851737976,
0.4968281090259552,
-0.02324581891298294,
0.19861233234405518,
-0.44242700934410095,
0.27174022793769836,
0.41739121079444885,
-0.18518345057964325,
-0.27191391587257385,
0.5414230823516846,
0.11163152754306793,
-0.32063400745391846,
0.49116379022598267,
-0.2694684863090515,
-0.6177570223808289,
0.6222991347312927,
0.5161625146865845,
0.7446060180664062,
0.04918624833226204,
-0.033095329999923706,
0.42156970500946045,
0.6564462780952454,
-0.2954203486442566,
0.05037239193916321,
-0.2656375765800476,
-0.9189324378967285,
-0.35484305024147034,
-0.5527048707008362,
-0.48525387048721313,
-0.18099795281887054,
-0.4547663927078247,
0.22466783225536346,
-0.629875898361206,
-0.019687699154019356,
0.018186476081609726,
0.29777809977531433,
-0.362141489982605,
0.08262920379638672,
0.3049793541431427,
0.7774698138237,
-0.6629544496536255,
0.7201250195503235,
0.3642962872982025,
-0.4171135127544403,
-0.4722156226634979,
0.33506327867507935,
0.18258880078792572,
-0.8606806397438049,
0.519419252872467,
0.10591486841440201,
-0.013034874573349953,
0.19548210501670837,
-0.7060926556587219,
-0.7209275364875793,
0.9805224537849426,
0.11365662515163422,
-0.6236441135406494,
0.025085028260946274,
0.3864646553993225,
0.9187480807304382,
-0.22499291598796844,
-0.08289705961942673,
0.8179377317428589,
0.5217570066452026,
0.14598403871059418,
-0.9529749155044556,
-0.06964796036481857,
-0.03486298397183418,
-0.07755822688341141,
0.5153998136520386,
-0.47439754009246826,
0.8264367580413818,
-0.512520968914032,
-0.20507891476154327,
-0.16257673501968384,
0.7642241716384888,
-0.09083005040884018,
0.22884531319141388,
0.364346444606781,
0.681303858757019,
0.8935980200767517,
-0.16138765215873718,
1.0794340372085571,
0.018437128514051437,
0.42061835527420044,
0.9234395027160645,
-0.40337616205215454,
0.7786464095115662,
0.31003838777542114,
-0.43701356649398804,
0.36879029870033264,
0.5875455141067505,
-0.1561625748872757,
0.14177338778972626,
0.21414169669151306,
-0.4945596754550934,
-0.006672739051282406,
-0.038029029965400696,
-0.18140895664691925,
0.18059660494327545,
0.2928333878517151,
-0.3072485625743866,
-0.36396610736846924,
-0.02301824651658535,
0.2402745485305786,
0.12536349892616272,
-0.40984880924224854,
1.0963164567947388,
-0.11404618620872498,
-0.11528383195400238,
0.43184894323349,
0.10175925493240356,
0.9977279901504517,
-0.3582742214202881,
0.16617998480796814,
-0.1482256054878235,
0.06139220669865608,
-0.3135116994380951,
-1.0162838697433472,
0.21401254832744598,
0.36346644163131714,
-0.1715853065252304,
-0.15766949951648712,
0.7495085597038269,
-0.4161496162414551,
-0.6694942712783813,
-0.2510085105895996,
0.24840477108955383,
0.042730484157800674,
-0.005520360544323921,
-0.34717363119125366,
-0.14113369584083557,
-0.12222054600715637,
-0.040184538811445236,
0.39405813813209534,
0.5806198120117188,
0.041735101491212845,
0.6532901525497437,
0.6215581297874451,
0.23110522329807281,
0.25835123658180237,
0.10553697496652603,
0.8893755078315735,
-0.6185019016265869,
-0.4521438479423523,
-1.1108241081237793,
-0.11617617309093475,
-0.1542668491601944,
-0.07764151692390442,
0.742395281791687,
0.6046269536018372,
0.5973439812660217,
0.2910049557685852,
0.7778052091598511,
-0.14035634696483612,
0.23278340697288513,
-0.7406728267669678,
0.6826683282852173,
-0.3883837163448334,
0.3266236484050751,
-0.13004589080810547,
-0.8244867920875549,
-0.5377630591392517,
0.3733275532722473,
-0.4469379484653473,
0.043881606310606,
0.4567068815231323,
0.6236662268638611,
0.03609348461031914,
0.082989901304245,
0.19924132525920868,
0.054225336760282516,
0.45818498730659485,
0.3903312683105469,
0.5943272709846497,
-0.32729628682136536,
0.5657282471656799,
-0.14737360179424286,
-0.15130367875099182,
-0.22219517827033997,
-0.7817752361297607,
-0.6995546817779541,
-0.346705824136734,
-0.2648261487483978,
-0.1297457367181778,
-0.3238801956176758,
1.2104710340499878,
0.46831566095352173,
-0.49401044845581055,
-0.17110304534435272,
-0.4223788380622864,
0.23525431752204895,
-0.040422774851322174,
-0.2674630880355835,
0.13037139177322388,
-0.6579180359840393,
-0.7183676362037659,
0.1637222319841385,
0.26876744627952576,
0.369311660528183,
-0.28471559286117554,
-0.1737506240606308,
-0.09032011777162552,
0.22967663407325745,
0.6739938855171204,
0.19289977848529816,
-0.5818347930908203,
-0.22547553479671478,
-0.2729690372943878,
-0.2557867467403412,
0.4590892195701599,
0.944961428642273,
-0.6112478971481323,
0.396271675825119,
0.7082180976867676,
0.8196223974227905,
0.2256079614162445,
0.1376834660768509,
0.49000757932662964,
-0.8791238069534302,
-0.10436807572841644,
0.17132535576820374,
0.061966776847839355,
0.2985689640045166,
-0.5504990816116333,
0.5110800266265869,
0.1633407175540924,
-0.5242064595222473,
-0.9516571760177612,
0.1737150251865387,
-0.6797803640365601,
0.029949219897389412,
1.1621081829071045,
0.32982298731803894,
-0.2488356977701187,
0.22904963791370392,
-0.27343276143074036,
-0.04756375774741173,
-0.32458269596099854,
0.6469835042953491,
0.8503339290618896,
-0.39515137672424316,
-0.29420873522758484,
-0.6384711861610413,
0.599170982837677,
0.16637665033340454,
-0.9595240950584412,
0.25276753306388855,
0.5863422751426697,
0.21698428690433502,
0.19270780682563782,
0.3901907205581665,
-0.06514127552509308,
0.045428190380334854,
-0.15665733814239502,
-0.08216571062803268,
0.10716883093118668,
-0.01627630926668644,
-0.5859381556510925,
-0.00772405369207263,
0.1851370632648468,
0.15784543752670288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00320v1 | LiteSearch: Efficacious Tree Search for LLM | 2024-06-29T05:14:04 | 2024-06-29T05:14:04 | Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Ye Tian, Baolin Peng, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent research suggests that tree search algorithms (e.g. Monte Carlo Tree
Search) can dramatically boost LLM performance on complex mathematical
reasoning tasks. However, they often require more than 10 times the
computational resources of greedy decoding due to wasteful search strategies,
making them difficult to be deployed in practical applications. This study
introduces a novel guided tree search algorithm with dynamic node selection and
node-level exploration budget (maximum number of children) calculation to
tackle this issue. By considering the search progress towards the final answer
(history) and the guidance from a value network (future) trained without any
step-wise annotations, our algorithm iteratively selects the most promising
tree node before expanding it within the boundaries of the allocated
computational budget. Experiments conducted on the GSM8K and TabMWP datasets
demonstrate that our approach not only offers competitive performance but also
enjoys significantly lower computational costs compared to baseline methods. | [
-0.18871597945690155,
-0.6918366551399231,
0.5935987830162048,
0.09453904628753662,
-0.4557610750198364,
0.6319176554679871,
0.1568792313337326,
-0.4747287333011627,
0.02080490067601204,
0.2599075436592102,
-0.8986734747886658,
-0.42276740074157715,
-0.43948641419410706,
-0.009930303320288658,
-0.20422349870204926,
0.32056328654289246,
-0.010338283143937588,
-0.10647241026163101,
0.06630656123161316,
0.016483096405863762,
-0.19217704236507416,
-0.06572447717189789,
-1.0134007930755615,
-0.2550530433654785,
0.7397028207778931,
0.45092177391052246,
0.567020058631897,
0.7844880223274231,
0.4695699214935303,
0.2303433120250702,
-0.6451443433761597,
0.4694788455963135,
-0.6766386032104492,
0.45612725615501404,
0.00467677041888237,
-0.3825615346431732,
-0.3891582787036896,
-0.440298467874527,
0.5371547341346741,
0.4693959057331085,
-0.3094402551651001,
0.2272886335849762,
-0.22308920323848724,
0.8536099195480347,
-0.5417037010192871,
0.37751808762550354,
-1.0071903467178345,
0.4309934377670288,
-0.2385735958814621,
-0.9048789143562317,
-0.5228098034858704,
-0.4548695683479309,
0.16298674046993256,
-0.6065264344215393,
-0.020604362711310387,
0.07412172853946686,
0.5368288159370422,
0.29931533336639404,
-0.44044172763824463,
-0.41493165493011475,
-0.563410222530365,
0.8106479644775391,
-0.3650053143501282,
0.1525176763534546,
0.19885896146297455,
0.5398772358894348,
-0.23395727574825287,
-0.4424425959587097,
0.10577951371669769,
-0.06724031269550323,
0.23069451749324799,
0.1461145430803299,
-0.06390238553285599,
0.3794649839401245,
0.45607757568359375,
0.13292551040649414,
-0.3765822947025299,
-0.14340931177139282,
0.13776490092277527,
-0.1852298080921173,
0.6159908175468445,
0.23500780761241913,
0.1656917929649353,
-0.021772272884845734,
0.09452328085899353,
-0.2600208520889282,
-0.6519365310668945,
0.3409804403781891,
0.22169578075408936,
0.19080539047718048,
0.3146624267101288,
0.4495755136013031,
-0.3169213831424713,
0.7523948550224304,
-0.22581128776073456,
-0.6152722835540771,
-0.04417332634329796,
-0.4442392587661743,
-0.08707819879055023,
0.44493600726127625,
0.1507837176322937,
0.11846860498189926,
0.40536925196647644,
0.10827121883630753,
-0.3170277178287506,
-0.15623384714126587,
-0.11868076771497726,
-1.0445489883422852,
-0.18203221261501312,
-0.0763256773352623,
-0.29125985503196716,
-0.5445271730422974,
-0.34018492698669434,
-0.7332071661949158,
-0.22665920853614807,
0.16852158308029175,
-0.026586921885609627,
-0.236111119389534,
-0.251155823469162,
0.033207304775714874,
0.12044155597686768,
0.06696343421936035,
0.6546271443367004,
-0.6579474806785583,
0.09070242196321487,
0.3223816156387329,
0.8553135991096497,
0.09931062161922455,
0.23141926527023315,
-0.7767144441604614,
0.025332011282444,
-0.5414534211158752,
0.5853383541107178,
-0.6928476095199585,
-0.515739917755127,
-0.3056812584400177,
-0.2885757386684418,
-0.10307782143354416,
-0.46200433373451233,
0.7812556624412537,
-0.9068016409873962,
-0.20820491015911102,
-0.09968117624521255,
-0.2123996466398239,
-0.4650075137615204,
0.16095547378063202,
-0.8670216798782349,
0.9350332021713257,
0.2313452959060669,
-0.7168081998825073,
0.5107222199440002,
-0.5696834325790405,
-0.3233996033668518,
0.3064427971839905,
-0.2474987804889679,
-0.5183091759681702,
0.13449513912200928,
0.4897835850715637,
0.3093327581882477,
-0.2989317774772644,
0.5649363994598389,
-0.20749206840991974,
-0.5046483874320984,
0.0041030156426131725,
-0.6923559308052063,
0.9420198202133179,
0.313511461019516,
-0.5045056343078613,
-0.001916624722070992,
-0.6575046181678772,
0.35771188139915466,
0.4803081154823303,
-0.24161545932292938,
-0.2691197991371155,
0.3081492781639099,
-0.34940004348754883,
0.0397845059633255,
0.11780388653278351,
-0.3123312294483185,
0.33784013986587524,
-0.4554678201675415,
0.4042697250843048,
0.673431932926178,
-0.13431107997894287,
0.19354850053787231,
-0.10766199976205826,
0.608389675617218,
-0.34143930673599243,
0.11412529647350311,
-0.45572057366371155,
-0.38641300797462463,
-0.3350016474723816,
-0.0973527580499649,
0.3178005814552307,
0.45199334621429443,
-0.7589408159255981,
0.1797872632741928,
-0.1690651923418045,
-0.188295379281044,
-0.30528271198272705,
-0.2178470492362976,
0.23728100955486298,
0.5334421396255493,
0.22403138875961304,
0.2391767054796219,
-0.5655158162117004,
-0.6773162484169006,
-0.031922586262226105,
0.020660672336816788,
0.38997650146484375,
0.6822144389152527,
0.1666797250509262,
-0.16155222058296204,
0.6207705736160278,
-0.48486700654029846,
-0.06477173417806625,
-0.22306665778160095,
-0.2318257987499237,
0.5180094242095947,
0.16077323257923126,
0.2796729505062103,
-0.8858233690261841,
-0.5803850889205933,
0.12516039609909058,
-0.490779310464859,
-0.2114076018333435,
-0.2341095209121704,
0.08853773772716522,
-0.08026246726512909,
0.33112096786499023,
-0.30323654413223267,
0.3467616140842438,
0.6171177625656128,
-0.383998304605484,
0.21289046108722687,
-0.21527232229709625,
0.009882774204015732,
-0.7014867067337036,
0.04250926896929741,
-0.395930677652359,
-0.41393861174583435,
-0.043872758746147156,
0.19915953278541565,
0.04139963164925575,
0.1634318083524704,
-0.24903538823127747,
0.327632337808609,
-0.762191116809845,
-0.22875842452049255,
-0.05655188113451004,
0.2939828634262085,
-0.22210891544818878,
0.3479444682598114,
-0.36855483055114746,
0.9600747227668762,
0.4777008295059204,
-0.37731537222862244,
0.5373233556747437,
-0.25633078813552856,
-0.12278977781534195,
0.16579464077949524,
-0.14369606971740723,
-0.11414086818695068,
0.09178537130355835,
0.38888704776763916,
-0.7693859338760376,
0.051225025206804276,
-0.11716492474079132,
-0.3224942088127136,
0.28335824608802795,
-0.24332702159881592,
-0.5883361101150513,
-0.35624146461486816,
-0.4650755822658539,
0.8007553219795227,
0.4637075662612915,
-0.8107191920280457,
0.6780732870101929,
0.36361294984817505,
0.006009889300912619,
-0.5232873558998108,
-0.3443079888820648,
0.10397656261920929,
-0.2108253389596939,
-0.6936479806900024,
0.5155205130577087,
-0.06974968314170837,
0.0357946939766407,
0.0763966515660286,
-0.5011957287788391,
0.22221288084983826,
0.4014354646205902,
-0.07624813914299011,
0.05057940259575844,
-0.06987595558166504,
-0.18918505311012268,
0.260588139295578,
-0.3603154122829437,
0.08689291030168533,
-0.39597588777542114,
0.6463907957077026,
-0.20081210136413574,
-0.4960583746433258,
-0.1706112027168274,
0.0021612232085317373,
0.4066566526889801,
-0.21063241362571716,
0.21121273934841156,
0.32245323061943054,
-0.3394346237182617,
-0.6692541837692261,
-0.30682575702667236,
-0.10471858829259872,
-0.4963391423225403,
0.5815093517303467,
-0.5872417688369751,
-0.9920117259025574,
0.4663514494895935,
-0.5801981091499329,
-0.045915160328149796,
0.4316311776638031,
0.20424968004226685,
0.09083788096904755,
1.525121808052063,
0.3099137544631958,
0.251881867647171,
0.4031425416469574,
-0.45586419105529785,
0.2296244204044342,
-0.7927197813987732,
-0.45317062735557556,
-0.21523526310920715,
-0.27568092942237854,
-0.7666391730308533,
-0.3830755949020386,
0.5385193228721619,
0.09432969242334366,
0.09460519254207611,
-0.010326752439141273,
-0.8755885362625122,
0.6947495341300964,
0.3506397306919098,
0.01798967644572258,
0.5746709704399109,
0.18978294730186462,
-0.6424657702445984,
-0.011099577881395817,
-1.0986225605010986,
-0.14099439978599548,
1.0316592454910278,
0.15222248435020447,
0.5074623227119446,
-0.06722848862409592,
0.7099123597145081,
-0.03316203132271767,
0.17400704324245453,
-0.8508766889572144,
0.8522042036056519,
-0.0363643541932106,
-0.21591511368751526,
-0.5778546333312988,
-0.7756441235542297,
-1.2245265245437622,
0.376046746969223,
-0.05096912756562233,
-0.7782232165336609,
-0.22343036532402039,
0.17389599978923798,
-0.38652095198631287,
0.627231240272522,
-0.267096608877182,
0.2997485399246216,
-0.6700761318206787,
-0.571185827255249,
-0.4712402820587158,
-0.48438307642936707,
0.4552578032016754,
-0.31372588872909546,
0.20550207793712616,
-0.24845601618289948,
-0.13894791901111603,
0.6122314929962158,
-0.20168592035770416,
0.1595245748758316,
-0.26950106024742126,
0.22724509239196777,
0.29750922322273254,
0.46604496240615845,
0.8757850527763367,
0.3223720192909241,
-0.06193370744585991,
-0.3807779848575592,
0.15752899646759033,
-0.44108495116233826,
-0.47429969906806946,
0.7050915956497192,
-0.40441179275512695,
-0.5862712264060974,
-0.6769658923149109,
-0.47845715284347534,
-0.17337019741535187,
0.3481059968471527,
-0.04075191169977188,
0.3456209897994995,
-0.07025200873613358,
0.42984458804130554,
0.9916964173316956,
-0.1734224110841751,
0.5895605683326721,
0.19030612707138062,
-0.481728196144104,
-0.4329575002193451,
0.7904679775238037,
0.2149924784898758,
0.04994245991110802,
0.5759478807449341,
0.640542209148407,
-0.39996394515037537,
-0.8852870464324951,
-0.5362458825111389,
0.11832283437252045,
-0.47741758823394775,
-0.42903661727905273,
-0.5028021335601807,
-0.3926089406013489,
0.3695329427719116,
-0.29344359040260315,
-0.43053510785102844,
-0.307125061750412,
0.007932763546705246,
-0.13547825813293457,
0.34563758969306946,
0.48163482546806335,
0.15194575488567352,
0.24230800569057465,
-0.5635281801223755,
0.09476121515035629,
0.31685182452201843,
0.395562082529068,
0.24669577181339264,
-0.10069307684898376,
-0.21688073873519897,
0.02574612759053707,
-0.16163979470729828,
-0.7796018123626709,
0.5290268063545227,
-0.11248023808002472,
0.6932205557823181,
0.40024280548095703,
0.053838517516851425,
0.7690251469612122,
-0.107886902987957,
0.24955298006534576,
0.1250692754983902,
-0.719626247882843,
0.4812113642692566,
-0.38916268944740295,
0.4363296329975128,
0.6588464975357056,
-0.057238079607486725,
-0.262835830450058,
0.12965066730976105,
-0.8816030621528625,
-1.0525884628295898,
0.7875749468803406,
0.29996219277381897,
-0.39787304401397705,
0.5642087459564209,
0.2441806048154831,
-0.31292328238487244,
0.22698664665222168,
-0.3780985474586487,
-0.05330274626612663,
0.250795841217041,
-0.14749376475811005,
0.12322386354207993,
-0.3190672993659973,
-0.07701150327920914,
-0.49247708916664124,
0.5287692546844482,
-0.2665799856185913,
0.11589628458023071,
0.30565372109413147,
0.13198590278625488,
-0.3848972022533417,
-0.04232362285256386,
0.4656828045845032,
0.553098201751709,
-0.35938760638237,
0.4170474708080292,
0.4953567087650299,
-0.46125203371047974,
0.09835295379161835,
0.2016194611787796,
-0.4532856345176697,
0.015477340668439865,
0.3445792496204376,
0.6653856039047241,
0.3132886290550232,
-0.9223723411560059,
0.35365602374076843,
-0.1191960796713829,
-0.29154518246650696,
-0.2529393136501312,
0.2646876275539398,
0.35614022612571716,
0.3618953824043274,
0.5894850492477417,
-0.16413025557994843,
0.2514631748199463,
-0.35952961444854736,
0.19265301525592804,
0.6857122778892517,
0.10281404107809067,
-0.01386527344584465,
0.41706961393356323,
0.1380395144224167,
-0.4549727439880371,
0.550183117389679,
-0.5240216851234436,
-0.7278239130973816,
0.9338920712471008,
0.31929299235343933,
0.899296760559082,
-0.24760206043720245,
0.2079370766878128,
0.38606321811676025,
0.2991231083869934,
-0.21483129262924194,
0.2811994254589081,
-0.307773619890213,
-0.4519459903240204,
-0.6346254944801331,
-0.40991488099098206,
-0.37181347608566284,
-0.05434052646160126,
-0.16515666246414185,
0.2208900898694992,
-0.4151546359062195,
0.041786205023527145,
-0.5099217295646667,
0.5331630706787109,
-0.5501214861869812,
0.32208290696144104,
-0.005717408377677202,
0.8887321352958679,
-0.13816170394420624,
0.8801066875457764,
0.18057088553905487,
0.27098512649536133,
-1.1488460302352905,
-0.22178968787193298,
-0.03995431214570999,
-1.1030426025390625,
0.533116340637207,
0.2639910578727722,
-0.7027243375778198,
0.3286832273006439,
-0.4421125054359436,
-1.239851713180542,
1.5658434629440308,
0.3011927604675293,
-0.8860301375389099,
-0.22493413090705872,
-0.14049601554870605,
0.3156808912754059,
-0.48417308926582336,
0.6313369870185852,
0.4378637671470642,
0.5241867899894714,
0.7587107419967651,
-0.6934022903442383,
-0.04860847815871239,
-0.22269342839717865,
0.01686594821512699,
0.3892853856086731,
-0.6359458565711975,
0.61899334192276,
-0.31415215134620667,
-0.46585074067115784,
-0.27280983328819275,
0.11783876270055771,
0.650543749332428,
0.7156934142112732,
0.669939398765564,
0.314206600189209,
0.9690908193588257,
-0.017201466485857964,
0.6968640685081482,
-0.5758660435676575,
0.45455867052078247,
0.7096302509307861,
-0.04800178110599518,
0.4494103789329529,
0.37946489453315735,
-0.28194737434387207,
0.04019914194941521,
1.1667143106460571,
0.1794215440750122,
0.5879102349281311,
0.5251072645187378,
-0.3142366409301758,
-0.2438519299030304,
-0.16211549937725067,
-0.208219513297081,
0.023862795904278755,
0.4211898148059845,
-0.2934044301509857,
-0.40303605794906616,
-0.5220276713371277,
0.0585201270878315,
-0.14881360530853271,
-0.39339110255241394,
0.5232186913490295,
0.10296190530061722,
-0.5798661112785339,
0.6553712487220764,
-0.0993308275938034,
0.579388439655304,
-0.6884293556213379,
-0.2193547785282135,
-0.1799372136592865,
0.010580942034721375,
-0.35742953419685364,
-0.5719267725944519,
0.08524664491415024,
-0.2526918649673462,
0.47094106674194336,
-0.49005022644996643,
0.72555011510849,
-0.231510728597641,
-0.571282684803009,
0.5487745404243469,
0.8227193355560303,
-0.15848477184772491,
-0.0381784625351429,
-0.8303552269935608,
0.09802381694316864,
0.36567965149879456,
-0.4581194519996643,
0.14127546548843384,
0.7112292051315308,
-0.13351550698280334,
1.0145831108093262,
0.7296475172042847,
0.39670029282569885,
0.09727208316326141,
-0.16807952523231506,
1.0735194683074951,
-0.8102219700813293,
-0.5821527242660522,
-0.9082961082458496,
0.18250365555286407,
-0.09304113686084747,
-0.09223867207765579,
0.43488314747810364,
0.7557265162467957,
0.8045017719268799,
0.49999740719795227,
0.48311129212379456,
0.309633731842041,
0.3354550302028656,
-0.6586737036705017,
0.23869815468788147,
-0.6291396617889404,
0.6219035387039185,
-0.27568501234054565,
-1.0657025575637817,
-0.4574030935764313,
0.7911421656608582,
-0.14969025552272797,
0.05875895172357559,
0.8048065304756165,
0.7484495639801025,
-0.09237465262413025,
0.1535392552614212,
0.42805081605911255,
-0.0920429602265358,
0.49168819189071655,
0.9799217581748962,
0.8384432792663574,
0.14566968381404877,
0.6107392311096191,
-0.27377432584762573,
-0.36055102944374084,
-0.5365291237831116,
-1.0490498542785645,
-0.5991219878196716,
-0.2736385762691498,
-0.008584588766098022,
-0.1540256291627884,
0.2753058075904846,
0.9472145438194275,
0.7126731276512146,
-0.34246426820755005,
-0.2632037103176117,
-0.5841490030288696,
0.5343629717826843,
-0.2057190090417862,
-0.19835032522678375,
0.4196490943431854,
-0.15479540824890137,
-0.4988102912902832,
0.5254654288291931,
0.40915223956108093,
-0.1305786669254303,
-0.36973416805267334,
-0.10329069197177887,
-0.11251486092805862,
0.05364633724093437,
0.5733322501182556,
-0.08066163212060928,
-0.4330565333366394,
0.15427972376346588,
0.3244640529155731,
0.06174255162477493,
0.2489212453365326,
0.982168972492218,
-0.814678966999054,
0.7075393795967102,
0.4799453318119049,
0.89459228515625,
1.0593076944351196,
-0.11774794012308121,
0.18190431594848633,
-0.08094561100006104,
-0.022406572476029396,
0.7135142683982849,
0.15307419002056122,
0.08632081747055054,
-0.5393037796020508,
0.7758765816688538,
0.4127267897129059,
-0.42786291241645813,
-0.8375323414802551,
0.3118021786212921,
-1.027988076210022,
-0.28173989057540894,
0.9637060165405273,
0.19981980323791504,
-0.3462754487991333,
0.18348629772663116,
-0.5120833516120911,
0.18371687829494476,
-0.7759626507759094,
0.5833780169487,
0.5095311403274536,
-0.5186681151390076,
-0.5221775770187378,
-0.6346235275268555,
0.5553455948829651,
0.40175870060920715,
-0.6196538805961609,
-0.19796009361743927,
0.3146294057369232,
-0.13591992855072021,
-0.12907235324382782,
0.45860162377357483,
0.01643088273704052,
0.08553947508335114,
0.11008301377296448,
-0.4859304130077362,
-0.32929256558418274,
-0.447710245847702,
-0.14486436545848846,
0.5157839059829712,
0.35968735814094543,
0.12205537408590317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00263v1 | From Local Concepts to Universals: Evaluating the Multicultural Understanding of Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-28T23:28:28 | 2024-06-28T23:28:28 | Mehar Bhatia, Sahithya Ravi, Aditya Chinchure, Eunjeong Hwang, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Despite recent advancements in vision-language models, their performance
remains suboptimal on images from non-western cultures due to
underrepresentation in training datasets. Various benchmarks have been proposed
to test models' cultural inclusivity, but they have limited coverage of
cultures and do not adequately assess cultural diversity across universal as
well as culture-specific local concepts. To address these limitations, we
introduce the GlobalRG benchmark, comprising two challenging tasks: retrieval
across universals and cultural visual grounding. The former task entails
retrieving culturally diverse images for universal concepts from 50 countries,
while the latter aims at grounding culture-specific concepts within images from
15 countries. Our evaluation across a wide range of models reveals that the
performance varies significantly across cultures -- underscoring the necessity
for enhancing multicultural understanding in vision-language models. | [
-0.6795902848243713,
-0.14072982966899872,
0.08299741894006729,
0.06747516244649887,
-0.1897556036710739,
0.1250341832637787,
-0.35675016045570374,
-0.7546783089637756,
-0.11937587708234787,
0.3309027850627899,
-0.2945100665092468,
-0.4866105616092682,
-0.542647659778595,
0.13272123038768768,
0.06679414212703705,
0.7384659647941589,
-0.1452285647392273,
0.28952792286872864,
-0.3141114115715027,
-0.7305430173873901,
-0.4435882866382599,
-0.43913599848747253,
-0.0632140189409256,
-0.3719119429588318,
0.06956369429826736,
0.4342653751373291,
0.6364011764526367,
0.4680892527103424,
0.9221596717834473,
0.178612619638443,
-0.3753679692745209,
0.016066864132881165,
-0.5679095983505249,
-0.1820816844701767,
-0.5462144613265991,
-0.4341736137866974,
-0.056366000324487686,
0.11568647623062134,
0.8398259878158569,
0.8998931050300598,
0.09481093287467957,
0.391481876373291,
-0.002207066398113966,
0.5096123814582825,
-0.8474290370941162,
0.13444747030735016,
-0.6372008919715881,
0.4349394142627716,
0.008020704612135887,
0.24138246476650238,
-0.04361306503415108,
-0.3077579438686371,
0.46275877952575684,
-0.5207177400588989,
0.5349008440971375,
-0.27305689454078674,
0.7505288124084473,
-0.12308523058891296,
-0.743067741394043,
-0.11446990072727203,
-0.6335247755050659,
0.707923948764801,
0.09892144054174423,
0.552932620048523,
0.052132632583379745,
0.37259194254875183,
0.17071840167045593,
-0.44430962204933167,
-0.2482430785894394,
-0.2760189473628998,
0.06992106884717941,
0.25872769951820374,
-0.2782527208328247,
-0.23260310292243958,
0.2404215931892395,
0.6997880339622498,
-0.6916841268539429,
-0.11929312348365784,
-0.5902900695800781,
-0.20977647602558136,
0.6240490674972534,
0.12216128408908844,
0.414887398481369,
-0.16298145055770874,
-0.5065448880195618,
-0.1378132402896881,
-0.7876396179199219,
0.23727183043956757,
0.01730182394385338,
0.30553415417671204,
-0.48562705516815186,
0.34674546122550964,
-0.6625609397888184,
0.6338546276092529,
-0.37692561745643616,
-0.15729382634162903,
0.3221556842327118,
-0.4092482030391693,
-0.30871838331222534,
-0.434434175491333,
0.1950005739927292,
0.6003979444503784,
0.7876643538475037,
-0.35699138045310974,
0.07919994741678238,
0.3928273320198059,
0.09365971386432648,
-0.7099722623825073,
0.054591696709394455,
-0.48547062277793884,
-0.563149631023407,
-0.01433364488184452,
0.18577465415000916,
-0.5871809124946594,
-0.4591430425643921,
-0.4052084982395172,
0.20412534475326538,
-0.2080451250076294,
-0.3838728666305542,
-0.09154912829399109,
-0.19860851764678955,
0.5664656162261963,
0.36945459246635437,
-0.8010163903236389,
0.16690748929977417,
0.46407949924468994,
0.7404846549034119,
-0.16342228651046753,
-0.38100001215934753,
0.10307063162326813,
-0.05733831599354744,
-0.47194215655326843,
0.7589612007141113,
-0.6578487157821655,
-0.553198516368866,
0.02021823078393936,
0.015316230244934559,
0.01647501066327095,
-0.9041975140571594,
0.4266185760498047,
-0.23082701861858368,
-0.03014584258198738,
-0.7305961847305298,
-0.2074826955795288,
-0.480225533246994,
0.367115318775177,
-0.32719549536705017,
0.6927095055580139,
0.14197829365730286,
-0.649876594543457,
0.7498434782028198,
-0.4134491980075836,
-0.21642597019672394,
0.32256075739860535,
-0.5110576152801514,
0.30922967195510864,
0.5045290589332581,
0.3776293396949768,
0.28772178292274475,
-0.4725652039051056,
0.2925591468811035,
-0.434682160615921,
-0.7829362154006958,
-0.37521669268608093,
-0.3630448877811432,
0.8775902390480042,
0.39061877131462097,
-0.18676480650901794,
-0.13021337985992432,
-0.6731382608413696,
-0.2040993720293045,
0.25341394543647766,
0.028464220464229584,
-0.29233548045158386,
-0.17703057825565338,
0.06433355808258057,
0.15545330941677094,
-0.000040272923797601834,
-0.5361698269844055,
0.23794978857040405,
-0.1145646870136261,
0.041163381189107895,
0.5573315024375916,
-0.4581822454929352,
0.6874299645423889,
-0.19536682963371277,
0.577730655670166,
-0.02013198472559452,
0.223073348402977,
-0.3653919994831085,
-0.6767508387565613,
-0.549590528011322,
-0.3856372535228729,
0.0501568578183651,
0.7206862568855286,
-0.6261496543884277,
-0.006852795369923115,
-0.5212990045547485,
-0.6868812441825867,
-0.471262663602829,
0.2251589447259903,
0.41472846269607544,
0.458024263381958,
0.11668600887060165,
-1.0397480726242065,
-0.44294050335884094,
-1.0978763103485107,
-0.3938697278499603,
-0.05864039435982704,
-0.29357263445854187,
0.3807695806026459,
0.7799988389015198,
-0.3572617769241333,
0.9399484992027283,
-0.15469491481781006,
-0.34403878450393677,
-0.24576708674430847,
0.1308503895998001,
0.08980442583560944,
0.5360356569290161,
0.4893966317176819,
-1.0414412021636963,
-0.5438867807388306,
0.3320765197277069,
-1.2297426462173462,
0.3130275011062622,
0.24710647761821747,
0.08665782958269119,
0.15053069591522217,
0.18446163833141327,
-0.18992243707180023,
0.7779693007469177,
0.533893346786499,
-0.35291188955307007,
0.3685726821422577,
-0.26212260127067566,
0.4186103343963623,
-0.5295289754867554,
0.14801836013793945,
0.39746931195259094,
-0.016089852899312973,
-0.5209137797355652,
0.6983755826950073,
0.24311043322086334,
-0.31209951639175415,
-0.5676949620246887,
0.8045764565467834,
-0.5147610306739807,
-0.3104947507381439,
0.19009581208229065,
0.011258590035140514,
-0.06284942477941513,
0.06881394982337952,
0.31688985228538513,
0.7284474968910217,
0.9087658524513245,
-0.2913067936897278,
0.3943108320236206,
0.18983516097068787,
-0.8253467679023743,
1.0237953662872314,
-0.31364768743515015,
-0.07257706671953201,
-0.46550384163856506,
0.42502549290657043,
-0.8164541721343994,
-0.3003869652748108,
0.05238679423928261,
-0.2574654519557953,
-0.02026287652552128,
-0.40243658423423767,
-0.3886466324329376,
-0.38215428590774536,
-0.0423106849193573,
0.8294553160667419,
0.7044953107833862,
-0.7652183771133423,
0.6271477937698364,
0.3685222566127777,
0.01554527785629034,
-0.6281358599662781,
-0.6335027813911438,
0.11096811294555664,
-0.37662455439567566,
-0.9984347224235535,
0.2631942927837372,
0.11042562872171402,
-0.5710723400115967,
-0.2645840346813202,
-0.2980159819126129,
-0.03039056435227394,
0.10926847159862518,
0.06177159771323204,
0.14331726729869843,
-0.2728332579135895,
-0.09330402314662933,
-0.5472491979598999,
0.05829953774809837,
-0.14114181697368622,
-0.2987000644207001,
0.13534681499004364,
-0.522607684135437,
-0.30111953616142273,
-0.1646510809659958,
0.53029865026474,
0.2956642508506775,
-0.6001964211463928,
0.44886264204978943,
0.6866787672042847,
-0.4115404784679413,
0.16737240552902222,
-0.7209354639053345,
0.035192959010601044,
-0.42321115732192993,
0.48874014616012573,
-0.6163694262504578,
-0.8091738224029541,
0.975428581237793,
0.031785763800144196,
-0.3594658672809601,
0.3083411157131195,
0.5208475589752197,
-0.14944277703762054,
0.8371642231941223,
1.0329039096832275,
0.04619305208325386,
0.35839053988456726,
-0.4154462218284607,
0.0546720027923584,
-0.6429318189620972,
-0.5327192544937134,
-0.30170777440071106,
-0.17675627768039703,
-0.9151832461357117,
-0.672070324420929,
0.4915550649166107,
0.27145588397979736,
-0.30611416697502136,
-0.042002324014902115,
-0.43018442392349243,
0.9518461227416992,
0.6594873666763306,
-0.26498764753341675,
0.3542773127555847,
0.5387501120567322,
-0.5112220644950867,
-0.3500690460205078,
-0.5833185315132141,
-0.32260388135910034,
1.036131501197815,
0.2773824632167816,
0.891204297542572,
0.07684960961341858,
0.4313192665576935,
0.1565607637166977,
0.774467408657074,
-0.46383997797966003,
0.40480390191078186,
-0.5340200662612915,
-0.8267022371292114,
0.34831786155700684,
-0.39710214734077454,
-0.6342255473136902,
0.925229549407959,
-0.05424785241484642,
-1.1898807287216187,
0.42744386196136475,
0.021137844771146774,
-0.016984641551971436,
0.5398040413856506,
-0.632013738155365,
1.1275677680969238,
0.04255278781056404,
-0.06389027833938599,
-0.14455541968345642,
-0.6907674074172974,
0.6450435519218445,
0.13606968522071838,
0.41857555508613586,
-0.3067571520805359,
0.33378681540489197,
0.3146435022354126,
0.4748195707798004,
0.6547536849975586,
-0.12057158350944519,
-0.2064470797777176,
0.25954267382621765,
0.23680312931537628,
-0.09664206951856613,
-0.06321541219949722,
0.04983052611351013,
0.632139265537262,
-0.08762723952531815,
-0.5727976560592651,
-0.33661943674087524,
0.46888911724090576,
-0.6646286845207214,
-0.4137391149997711,
-0.38319525122642517,
-0.7632157206535339,
-0.3387658894062042,
-0.06181396543979645,
0.4424252212047577,
0.5133472681045532,
-0.4431232511997223,
0.36576882004737854,
0.49268513917922974,
-0.41907212138175964,
0.1135808527469635,
0.43561238050460815,
-0.22928978502750397,
-0.4125116467475891,
0.8962709307670593,
0.09854084253311157,
0.27631181478500366,
0.26210618019104004,
-0.07109208405017853,
-0.32870885729789734,
-0.26676344871520996,
-0.3376440107822418,
0.03169328719377518,
-1.2463457584381104,
0.12404700368642807,
-0.19795820116996765,
0.0547989085316658,
-0.4279828369617462,
-0.3853508234024048,
-0.16134069859981537,
-0.08185305446386337,
0.15372703969478607,
0.14877288043498993,
-0.18244394659996033,
0.7127925753593445,
-0.495079904794693,
0.030437886714935303,
-0.6346657872200012,
0.45466727018356323,
0.26375553011894226,
0.5232148766517639,
-0.1564209759235382,
-0.674180805683136,
-0.27135708928108215,
-0.05192476138472557,
-0.34134161472320557,
-0.6326964497566223,
0.19394360482692719,
0.045358043164014816,
0.7184589505195618,
0.430841326713562,
-0.2869187891483307,
0.8085591793060303,
-0.3824981451034546,
0.756550669670105,
0.1905052363872528,
-0.9777256846427917,
0.5338952541351318,
-0.42788228392601013,
0.6668469309806824,
0.4852156639099121,
0.4572264552116394,
-0.937929630279541,
-0.48043450713157654,
-0.5114777684211731,
-0.7621663808822632,
0.48388051986694336,
-0.002151893451809883,
0.47630035877227783,
0.13592495024204254,
0.15314418077468872,
0.017906805500388145,
-0.10091081261634827,
-0.9525322914123535,
-0.176611989736557,
-0.12582308053970337,
-0.008016502484679222,
-0.2586993873119354,
-0.04400547966361046,
-0.3203584849834442,
-0.5857123732566833,
0.13426174223423004,
-0.3341405391693115,
0.15530554950237274,
0.3552997410297394,
-0.47722676396369934,
-0.05610445886850357,
0.22415459156036377,
0.4973856210708618,
0.9905861020088196,
-0.3748597204685211,
-0.028004951775074005,
0.43576815724372864,
-0.41144511103630066,
0.21354322135448456,
0.019753513857722282,
-0.31168678402900696,
-0.19935958087444305,
0.4390771985054016,
0.6622791290283203,
-0.19600671529769897,
-0.6988258361816406,
0.2920897603034973,
-0.32363125681877136,
-0.0175294391810894,
-0.08752895891666412,
-0.017393646761775017,
-0.24130813777446747,
0.27762919664382935,
0.529784619808197,
0.30747491121292114,
0.08992426842451096,
-0.7373477220535278,
0.13711927831172943,
0.6151793599128723,
-0.37739771604537964,
-0.2229037880897522,
0.5410290956497192,
0.2323339581489563,
0.08778106421232224,
0.6064894199371338,
-0.33567771315574646,
-0.5679472088813782,
0.84441077709198,
0.4683019518852234,
0.6765044927597046,
0.10905896872282028,
0.365813285112381,
0.4456518590450287,
0.5571752190589905,
0.04095917567610741,
0.4159277081489563,
-0.2732597589492798,
-1.0289733409881592,
-0.29918381571769714,
-0.475653737783432,
-0.5306735038757324,
-0.18880678713321686,
-0.8536043167114258,
-0.19754773378372192,
-0.3147668242454529,
0.06836193799972534,
-0.24197709560394287,
-0.1025824099779129,
-1.1707229614257812,
0.6717128157615662,
0.7738924026489258,
1.1113691329956055,
-1.0411288738250732,
0.7439314723014832,
0.8464049696922302,
-0.41874557733535767,
-0.4613089859485626,
0.109986811876297,
0.157615065574646,
-0.8236445188522339,
1.0794535875320435,
0.48941224813461304,
0.0036812801845371723,
-0.36377888917922974,
-0.34367769956588745,
-0.9937617778778076,
0.8832834362983704,
0.6000766158103943,
-0.28504472970962524,
0.16438467800617218,
0.10679150372743607,
0.5308582186698914,
-0.6414300203323364,
0.3738676607608795,
0.6877343654632568,
0.2820133566856384,
0.1487986445426941,
-1.0701682567596436,
-0.20049329102039337,
-0.2829485535621643,
0.34146568179130554,
-0.2564019560813904,
-0.6068970561027527,
0.8919442296028137,
-0.4200303554534912,
-0.27814343571662903,
0.099924236536026,
0.5153563022613525,
0.3646855056285858,
0.14126749336719513,
0.37341204285621643,
0.6626055836677551,
0.6070716977119446,
-0.41475844383239746,
1.2498586177825928,
-0.030125634744763374,
0.5677552819252014,
0.7719011306762695,
-0.3050526976585388,
0.6645216941833496,
0.15857316553592682,
-0.21124567091464996,
0.222410187125206,
0.621074914932251,
-0.3552188575267792,
0.6481468081474304,
0.35000696778297424,
-0.3624599874019623,
-0.4107557237148285,
-0.5471063852310181,
-0.6790154576301575,
0.861936628818512,
0.13116051256656647,
-0.054193198680877686,
-0.5862563252449036,
0.11411843448877335,
-0.4272058606147766,
0.007646471261978149,
-0.5605199337005615,
0.5084463953971863,
0.005186317954212427,
-0.7429763078689575,
0.7850893139839172,
-0.010213407687842846,
0.9671816825866699,
-0.40496593713760376,
0.16376003623008728,
-0.7680112719535828,
0.3370792269706726,
0.09753617644309998,
-0.6454243063926697,
0.21059851348400116,
0.15502503514289856,
-0.16207945346832275,
-0.23259836435317993,
0.6835188865661621,
-0.2131606638431549,
-0.6505547165870667,
0.6191042065620422,
0.3729262053966522,
0.17549937963485718,
0.08218581229448318,
-0.6072505712509155,
0.07188350707292557,
0.08022119849920273,
0.2248881608247757,
0.2081773579120636,
0.2124917358160019,
-0.2222239375114441,
0.5809627175331116,
0.41290003061294556,
0.12389346957206726,
-0.03146197646856308,
0.12000896036624908,
0.31354713439941406,
-0.6377547383308411,
-0.47770869731903076,
-0.7630810737609863,
0.5438811182975769,
0.01659533567726612,
-0.4550110995769501,
0.6227365136146545,
0.36820852756500244,
1.5926049947738647,
-0.10361228138208389,
0.7591075897216797,
-0.013034628704190254,
-0.1002761498093605,
-0.23102903366088867,
0.6640292406082153,
-1.057523488998413,
-0.22015221416950226,
-0.24948881566524506,
-1.030190348625183,
-0.5714223980903625,
0.8826624155044556,
-0.38990139961242676,
-0.039762984961271286,
0.35417822003364563,
0.5060071349143982,
-0.2998584806919098,
0.12624527513980865,
0.47289252281188965,
-0.11893616616725922,
0.1622447967529297,
0.33457544445991516,
1.1378543376922607,
-0.1462165117263794,
0.3099507689476013,
-0.33262214064598083,
-0.14748439192771912,
0.12250565737485886,
-0.8598898649215698,
-0.6453301310539246,
-0.24474714696407318,
-0.10696052759885788,
-0.07001230865716934,
0.013422137126326561,
0.7960559725761414,
0.9559382200241089,
-0.9119374752044678,
-0.56028813123703,
0.20656968653202057,
0.056282222270965576,
-0.04418862611055374,
-0.1453741192817688,
0.007369305472820997,
-0.20456871390342712,
-0.6455963253974915,
0.25115686655044556,
0.39610517024993896,
0.22401116788387299,
-0.32062530517578125,
0.0322476327419281,
0.29420509934425354,
-0.08143436163663864,
0.554125964641571,
0.40144211053848267,
-0.9246427416801453,
-0.21701635420322418,
-0.2673898935317993,
-0.009013132192194462,
0.28627946972846985,
0.736037015914917,
-0.7215533256530762,
0.6786879301071167,
0.35835912823677063,
0.44191989302635193,
0.4307771325111389,
-0.04541784152388573,
0.6370295882225037,
-0.7846529483795166,
0.6840571165084839,
0.15773481130599976,
0.6261904239654541,
0.7058601379394531,
0.20881275832653046,
0.767136812210083,
0.52341228723526,
-0.20491941273212433,
-0.896554172039032,
0.35960835218429565,
-0.5398588180541992,
-0.23433347046375275,
0.8559750318527222,
-0.3961748480796814,
0.13169066607952118,
0.2622304856777191,
0.08449368923902512,
-0.10851024091243744,
0.12931326031684875,
0.6506756544113159,
0.6546288132667542,
0.19708721339702606,
0.07121536135673523,
-0.6709162592887878,
0.24235478043556213,
0.6019916534423828,
-0.6407111883163452,
-0.18587353825569153,
0.5402565598487854,
0.5625696182250977,
0.313926100730896,
0.7197875380516052,
-0.11777184903621674,
0.38421303033828735,
0.0632026195526123,
0.2815757393836975,
0.589026153087616,
-0.6330981254577637,
-0.5898146033287048,
0.22341297566890717,
-0.1999983936548233,
0.03812926635146141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00256v1 | One Prompt is not Enough: Automated Construction of a Mixture-of-Expert Prompts | 2024-06-28T23:05:08 | 2024-06-28T23:05:08 | Ruochen Wang, Sohyun An, Minhao Cheng, Tianyi Zhou, Sung Ju Hwang, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML, 68T01 | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit strong generalization capabilities to
novel tasks when prompted with language instructions and in-context demos.
Since this ability sensitively depends on the quality of prompts, various
methods have been explored to automate the instruction design. While these
methods demonstrated promising results, they also restricted the searched
prompt to one instruction. Such simplification significantly limits their
capacity, as a single demo-free instruction might not be able to cover the
entire complex problem space of the targeted task. To alleviate this issue, we
adopt the Mixture-of-Expert paradigm and divide the problem space into a set of
sub-regions; Each sub-region is governed by a specialized expert, equipped with
both an instruction and a set of demos. A two-phase process is developed to
construct the specialized expert for each region: (1) demo assignment: Inspired
by the theoretical connection between in-context learning and kernel
regression, we group demos into experts based on their semantic similarity; (2)
instruction assignment: A region-based joint search of an instruction per
expert complements the demos assigned to it, yielding a synergistic effect. The
resulting method, codenamed Mixture-of-Prompts (MoP), achieves an average win
rate of 81% against prior arts across several major benchmarks. | [
-0.5910391807556152,
-0.9744219779968262,
0.7240337133407593,
0.33581846952438354,
-0.19729702174663544,
0.1878727823495865,
-0.20001275837421417,
0.11463116109371185,
0.3358916938304901,
0.3363609313964844,
-0.6872843503952026,
-0.5249597430229187,
-0.6048406362533569,
0.0967026874423027,
-0.23164694011211395,
0.669218122959137,
-0.1669880449771881,
-0.1303493082523346,
-0.3288055658340454,
0.040997594594955444,
-0.8980498313903809,
-0.32302746176719666,
-0.34096643328666687,
-0.11842319369316101,
0.23085209727287292,
0.6799124479293823,
0.3929847180843353,
0.6274174451828003,
0.0652899369597435,
0.37942755222320557,
0.057835474610328674,
0.4176025092601776,
-0.15958304703235626,
0.27859067916870117,
-0.08057476580142975,
-0.518047571182251,
-0.33161461353302,
0.12447009235620499,
0.3459763824939728,
0.8068581223487854,
-0.13064044713974,
-0.14993871748447418,
0.2874596118927002,
0.4709527790546417,
-0.659457266330719,
0.07655028998851776,
-0.5280045866966248,
0.04819218069314957,
0.18840086460113525,
-0.45731544494628906,
-0.4096510708332062,
-0.1621563583612442,
0.269240140914917,
-0.7499307990074158,
0.3030967712402344,
-0.04602005332708359,
0.42104145884513855,
0.4662027359008789,
-0.3013262152671814,
-0.3428117632865906,
-0.3492082953453064,
0.9972140192985535,
-0.5398404598236084,
-0.02946252003312111,
0.2435036599636078,
0.28855088353157043,
-0.4118022322654724,
-0.3264182507991791,
-0.46401265263557434,
-0.16411598026752472,
0.11140052229166031,
0.1608281433582306,
-0.1351436823606491,
0.1148243397474289,
0.012703336775302887,
-0.08342242985963821,
-0.48138466477394104,
0.18563875555992126,
-0.16713233292102814,
-0.2219778299331665,
0.4259898364543915,
0.4357106685638428,
0.5471956729888916,
-0.05743127688765526,
-0.6231091022491455,
-0.0332171730697155,
-0.4418833553791046,
0.201889768242836,
0.2632416784763336,
0.33468201756477356,
-0.09123991429805756,
0.43922755122184753,
-0.22829030454158783,
0.863557755947113,
0.4013509154319763,
-0.5851181745529175,
-0.042555972933769226,
-0.26103225350379944,
0.044945795089006424,
-0.17558926343917847,
0.8962569832801819,
0.3201706111431122,
0.0293998084962368,
-0.09242712706327438,
-0.3810497522354126,
-0.018757818266749382,
0.14018820226192474,
-0.455961674451828,
-0.2581932246685028,
0.27661779522895813,
-0.1510959416627884,
-0.006699473597109318,
0.11142323166131973,
-0.8296042084693909,
-0.3012140691280365,
-0.5539611577987671,
0.5280371904373169,
-0.42719635367393494,
0.09214860200881958,
-0.008439051918685436,
-0.3519633114337921,
-0.07675455510616302,
0.537039577960968,
-0.732051432132721,
0.1539485603570938,
0.62164705991745,
0.5450280904769897,
-0.35003748536109924,
-0.42070597410202026,
-0.4608269929885864,
0.09342452883720398,
-0.49369341135025024,
0.8837909698486328,
-0.9298148155212402,
-0.6719775795936584,
-0.01196947693824768,
-0.3513650596141815,
-0.15959346294403076,
-0.6186774373054504,
0.09982900321483612,
-0.3255877196788788,
0.624391496181488,
-0.35514035820961,
-0.6329905986785889,
-0.09485772252082825,
0.03883511945605278,
-0.36369311809539795,
0.970734715461731,
0.33166375756263733,
-0.4865960478782654,
0.2460244745016098,
-0.43060991168022156,
-0.41637828946113586,
0.22862142324447632,
-0.7390336394309998,
0.24581478536128998,
0.015331574715673923,
0.5190557241439819,
0.4603637158870697,
-0.24313203990459442,
0.37981343269348145,
0.006203589495271444,
-0.3104325532913208,
0.11319754272699356,
-0.24428632855415344,
0.6808549165725708,
0.03631926700472832,
-0.5087346434593201,
0.047893013805150986,
-0.5680891871452332,
-0.09037923812866211,
-0.1761602908372879,
-0.441855251789093,
-0.32751134037971497,
-0.11927111446857452,
-0.3763408064842224,
0.23523329198360443,
0.46993541717529297,
-0.23688140511512756,
0.4049488604068756,
-0.2102375328540802,
0.08348251134157181,
0.9204909801483154,
0.03217172622680664,
0.8853967785835266,
-0.42670074105262756,
0.990358829498291,
0.02679004706442356,
-0.06834910809993744,
-0.5308244228363037,
-0.5480057597160339,
-1.0031849145889282,
-0.43163514137268066,
0.05681094899773598,
0.8239409923553467,
-1.036083698272705,
0.7721391916275024,
0.09114856272935867,
-0.33459600806236267,
-0.5581152439117432,
0.34147781133651733,
0.4621656537055969,
0.6437786221504211,
0.42401552200317383,
-0.1559157371520996,
-0.4333753287792206,
-1.0948314666748047,
0.07656867057085037,
0.04505040869116783,
-0.1311403512954712,
0.27435389161109924,
0.26171812415122986,
-0.08445565402507782,
1.363417625427246,
-0.5188100934028625,
-0.31856808066368103,
-0.40225836634635925,
0.22288690507411957,
0.23542292416095734,
0.4961138665676117,
0.6623114347457886,
-0.46083325147628784,
-0.6668009161949158,
-0.2344980537891388,
-0.7499933242797852,
-0.44861769676208496,
-0.1402696967124939,
-0.009148552082479,
0.0858028382062912,
0.3615247905254364,
-0.463123083114624,
0.0844317153096199,
0.3916313350200653,
-0.13510674238204956,
0.6145908236503601,
-0.19487877190113068,
0.2421502321958542,
-1.0739961862564087,
-0.25143110752105713,
0.18224795162677765,
0.16854813694953918,
-0.5362240076065063,
0.42688047885894775,
-0.12173759192228317,
-0.2159140706062317,
-0.41647908091545105,
0.7006816864013672,
-0.3906989097595215,
0.29346680641174316,
-0.5512648224830627,
0.1467372626066208,
0.0250420942902565,
0.6949337124824524,
-0.14081783592700958,
1.1038265228271484,
0.6712638735771179,
-0.8175874948501587,
0.35659223794937134,
0.13615068793296814,
-0.19771632552146912,
0.573520302772522,
-0.5878133177757263,
0.25503143668174744,
-0.20777058601379395,
0.4753124713897705,
-1.1210756301879883,
-0.39659759402275085,
0.15324589610099792,
-0.3315143585205078,
0.24537760019302368,
0.022732561454176903,
-0.43148985505104065,
-0.09019437432289124,
-0.15094824135303497,
0.3374701738357544,
0.7383192777633667,
-0.3537467122077942,
0.8710795640945435,
0.29641401767730713,
-0.5565961599349976,
-0.6850801706314087,
-0.549675703048706,
0.0749586671590805,
-0.07997933030128479,
-0.7278913259506226,
0.2292134314775467,
-0.05751773715019226,
-0.2727363109588623,
-0.14368049800395966,
-0.2063039392232895,
-0.20294629037380219,
0.11476603895425797,
0.1720661222934723,
0.2816576063632965,
-0.04396267235279083,
-0.02075229026377201,
0.43054184317588806,
-0.4310111403465271,
0.13331860303878784,
-0.3225524425506592,
0.5322561264038086,
0.229469433426857,
-0.5410678386688232,
-0.6567161083221436,
0.9682220816612244,
0.43126943707466125,
-0.05831694230437279,
0.32838931679725647,
0.3272610902786255,
-0.10070744156837463,
-0.5942333936691284,
-0.7135623097419739,
-0.18265536427497864,
-0.5530516505241394,
0.31284818053245544,
-0.3751944601535797,
-0.8566785454750061,
0.4591638445854187,
0.1463584303855896,
0.26695936918258667,
0.27294352650642395,
0.4749718904495239,
-0.16563862562179565,
1.107987642288208,
0.5502340793609619,
-0.0816335678100586,
0.4120531678199768,
-0.23004449903964996,
0.11101114004850388,
-0.3526362478733063,
-0.35355037450790405,
-0.576546847820282,
-0.3727870583534241,
-0.19456446170806885,
-0.5678127408027649,
0.7530784010887146,
-0.1314609795808792,
0.01707029528915882,
0.24566136300563812,
-0.5600417256355286,
0.5066496133804321,
0.9514917135238647,
0.30259770154953003,
-0.07084881514310837,
0.052083130925893784,
-0.3103841543197632,
-0.019152136519551277,
-1.0343478918075562,
-0.5505181550979614,
0.7287367582321167,
0.15442487597465515,
0.7594025135040283,
-0.19602273404598236,
0.9417055249214172,
0.3138647973537445,
-0.1151074692606926,
-0.7454168796539307,
0.9233184456825256,
-0.15641632676124573,
-0.3227793276309967,
-0.2824636399745941,
-0.24335937201976776,
-0.824400007724762,
0.23644304275512695,
-0.059216976165771484,
-0.500210165977478,
0.22073176503181458,
0.1193976178765297,
-0.6319546699523926,
0.05535925552248955,
-0.7382268309593201,
0.44084346294403076,
-0.002963203238323331,
-0.11199408024549484,
-0.23241721093654633,
-0.5406985878944397,
0.17730364203453064,
-0.12350951135158539,
0.3626488745212555,
0.046714141964912415,
-0.40964487195014954,
0.7691911458969116,
-0.6115569472312927,
1.0341585874557495,
-0.25184929370880127,
-0.20421168208122253,
0.5035276412963867,
0.27951207756996155,
0.573093831539154,
-0.34271296858787537,
0.07953798025846481,
-0.47837257385253906,
-0.3230433464050293,
-0.6992788314819336,
-0.8963329195976257,
0.42787450551986694,
-0.7773677706718445,
-0.9952391386032104,
0.02678632363677025,
-0.6117686033248901,
-0.29973191022872925,
-0.08152208477258682,
0.5120584964752197,
0.6632080674171448,
0.10760481655597687,
-0.1480347365140915,
0.9030503630638123,
-0.34772634506225586,
0.34862443804740906,
0.3240543305873871,
0.19710753858089447,
-0.4470967650413513,
1.1023756265640259,
0.018351756036281586,
0.21359890699386597,
0.5158292055130005,
0.24099156260490417,
-0.024779319763183594,
-0.5317235589027405,
-0.3894152045249939,
-0.18365418910980225,
-0.8977295756340027,
-0.06075480952858925,
-0.8508561253547668,
0.21059685945510864,
-0.33653345704078674,
-0.539897620677948,
-0.10532297194004059,
-0.2238258272409439,
-0.633389413356781,
0.23499710857868195,
-0.013497205451130867,
0.5274473428726196,
0.2576417326927185,
0.5210615992546082,
-0.9719356298446655,
0.25254443287849426,
0.7938188910484314,
-0.18665941059589386,
0.0913061872124672,
-0.6728206276893616,
-0.0964067280292511,
-0.044092923402786255,
-0.23945651948451996,
-1.0571800470352173,
0.3771726191043854,
-0.017286259680986404,
0.9144977927207947,
0.43236157298088074,
0.153705894947052,
0.5682166218757629,
-0.4517333507537842,
1.0444303750991821,
0.33328601717948914,
-0.8719073534011841,
0.6249549984931946,
-0.4867948889732361,
0.3025430142879486,
0.5753428936004639,
0.36472371220588684,
-0.1404101699590683,
-0.7768971920013428,
-0.5773417949676514,
-0.96052086353302,
0.5746865272521973,
-0.2645719349384308,
0.34953397512435913,
-0.1225472018122673,
-0.07671236246824265,
0.5661966800689697,
0.11503595858812332,
-0.1734946072101593,
-0.3561684191226959,
0.05236402899026871,
-0.2835840880870819,
0.2873518466949463,
-0.35687747597694397,
-0.323291540145874,
-0.10712597519159317,
0.5406233072280884,
-0.1898229718208313,
0.2842505872249603,
0.08812915533781052,
-0.04730057716369629,
-0.0012792855268344283,
0.5111444592475891,
0.5192379355430603,
0.7668954730033875,
0.16045890748500824,
-0.0021873346995562315,
0.20841239392757416,
-0.1483204960823059,
0.43422931432724,
-0.0015338370576500893,
-0.2808952033519745,
0.0590069554746151,
0.6292498111724854,
0.7383698225021362,
0.2580299973487854,
-0.7058712244033813,
0.5779809951782227,
0.2707577645778656,
-0.3445838689804077,
-0.05066665634512901,
0.6594333648681641,
-0.2252107858657837,
0.2156926691532135,
0.829764723777771,
-0.03893054276704788,
0.06764084100723267,
-0.4380381405353546,
0.21169112622737885,
0.29520323872566223,
-0.13996674120426178,
-0.13357913494110107,
0.4426894783973694,
0.6409121751785278,
-0.4649393856525421,
0.4859389066696167,
-0.3493393063545227,
-0.6204345226287842,
0.842263400554657,
0.3247712254524231,
0.8898789286613464,
-0.13097898662090302,
0.31916874647140503,
0.17978012561798096,
0.04605443775653839,
-0.13556809723377228,
0.2795555293560028,
-0.016577646136283875,
-0.5276058912277222,
-0.6562725901603699,
-0.17957255244255066,
-0.5738660097122192,
-0.08598081767559052,
-0.43935802578926086,
0.1693519502878189,
-0.40005290508270264,
0.018964048475027084,
-0.21737314760684967,
-0.18121455609798431,
-0.6764118075370789,
0.1331668198108673,
-0.04086216539144516,
0.9739022254943848,
-1.0956814289093018,
0.42580100893974304,
0.9813368320465088,
-0.21398203074932098,
-0.8225473761558533,
-0.04224173724651337,
0.03916578367352486,
-0.6919751763343811,
0.5542718172073364,
0.10350672155618668,
0.24334168434143066,
-0.22355425357818604,
-0.7027886509895325,
-0.5044645071029663,
0.8338239789009094,
0.3291064202785492,
-0.575526773929596,
-0.23289167881011963,
-0.23897048830986023,
0.2943648099899292,
-0.6353582739830017,
0.2890050411224365,
0.38908007740974426,
0.460082471370697,
-0.055882878601551056,
-0.893918514251709,
-0.0012877765111625195,
-0.1805434674024582,
-0.1483256220817566,
0.05460905283689499,
-0.5209882855415344,
1.0085521936416626,
-0.2628670632839203,
-0.1793081909418106,
-0.0220840722322464,
0.8212325572967529,
0.5461950302124023,
0.29348957538604736,
0.7239696383476257,
0.3502562344074249,
0.5632219910621643,
0.13756270706653595,
1.0411235094070435,
-0.28441160917282104,
-0.0604657307267189,
1.058975338935852,
0.11276095360517502,
0.471938818693161,
0.41424813866615295,
-0.34756872057914734,
0.5745282173156738,
0.5941272974014282,
0.14162330329418182,
0.560142993927002,
-0.09910371899604797,
-0.46382734179496765,
-0.6635138988494873,
-0.16566817462444305,
-0.4106072783470154,
0.23714511096477509,
0.3657820224761963,
-0.3007108271121979,
-0.43938785791397095,
0.09001599997282028,
-0.1380954384803772,
0.38127008080482483,
-0.08447202295064926,
0.7036399245262146,
-0.027704473584890366,
-0.9555522799491882,
0.24869106709957123,
-0.08184682577848434,
0.8804242014884949,
-0.512292206287384,
-0.1740681678056717,
-0.34313780069351196,
-0.39856529235839844,
-0.115460604429245,
-0.7853248715400696,
-0.32850781083106995,
-0.03956345096230507,
-0.24463549256324768,
-0.27308034896850586,
0.3615359365940094,
-0.5318109393119812,
-0.2950723469257355,
-0.04949966445565224,
0.8750479221343994,
0.061695147305727005,
0.09093557298183441,
-0.5857498049736023,
-0.21285320818424225,
0.12367928773164749,
-0.23401349782943726,
0.4818316400051117,
0.6019896864891052,
0.10320606827735901,
0.8185710310935974,
0.3753456771373749,
-0.14574667811393738,
0.09828037023544312,
-0.06018797308206558,
1.0122554302215576,
-0.37191227078437805,
-0.6819976568222046,
-0.6990431547164917,
0.6273886561393738,
0.21740224957466125,
-0.30899208784103394,
0.6162793636322021,
0.34012097120285034,
0.6398036479949951,
-0.13883459568023682,
1.198703646659851,
-0.08112353086471558,
0.2692059278488159,
-0.5566816329956055,
0.005908457562327385,
-0.5598306655883789,
0.3557104170322418,
-0.17844389379024506,
-0.7954593896865845,
0.13820384442806244,
0.40459054708480835,
-0.050114706158638,
0.22745350003242493,
0.6380895972251892,
0.9221140146255493,
-0.04459195211529732,
-0.15975071489810944,
0.22440077364444733,
-0.22485525906085968,
0.26850083470344543,
0.5554851293563843,
0.8313464522361755,
0.20223292708396912,
0.42693251371383667,
-0.3266901671886444,
-0.5616163015365601,
-0.30084601044654846,
-0.7681472301483154,
-0.9909560680389404,
-0.6555742621421814,
-0.34746259450912476,
-0.15229719877243042,
-0.03795855492353439,
1.4426333904266357,
0.6355223655700684,
-0.7035413384437561,
-0.12961436808109283,
0.013653257861733437,
0.10185762494802475,
-0.3360450863838196,
-0.24742305278778076,
0.3217257261276245,
-0.8506703972816467,
-0.8593991994857788,
0.84329754114151,
0.25238266587257385,
0.08467315882444382,
-0.5012145042419434,
0.005381023045629263,
0.20809714496135712,
0.03102005459368229,
0.41685253381729126,
0.09697984904050827,
-0.8975171446800232,
-0.01382544357329607,
0.27968472242355347,
-0.3354792296886444,
-0.13061530888080597,
0.9427355527877808,
-0.8125359416007996,
0.6396133303642273,
0.9176919460296631,
0.845823347568512,
-0.19985787570476532,
0.12414411455392838,
0.8388018012046814,
-0.8685491681098938,
0.12749110162258148,
0.32498645782470703,
0.34114450216293335,
0.09608045965433121,
-0.2144729048013687,
0.2613990902900696,
0.2528482973575592,
-0.4132804870605469,
-0.4555288851261139,
0.2726232707500458,
-1.152431845664978,
-0.5666069984436035,
1.4409817457199097,
-0.1539476066827774,
-0.06726224720478058,
-0.24780391156673431,
-0.49144837260246277,
0.04415389895439148,
-0.8405685424804688,
0.7745088338851929,
0.7154222726821899,
-0.29126429557800293,
-0.08034095168113708,
-0.4519142508506775,
0.03729724511504173,
0.5708728432655334,
-0.5753756761550903,
-0.23655207455158234,
0.6234574913978577,
0.20967993140220642,
0.16967739164829254,
0.6448893547058105,
0.4242248833179474,
0.3905547559261322,
0.19194206595420837,
0.037656500935554504,
-0.3592628836631775,
-0.49922218918800354,
-0.26361745595932007,
0.5290988683700562,
-0.04170273244380951,
-0.3382587730884552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00250v1 | Mind the Gap: Analyzing Lacunae with Transformer-Based Transcription | 2024-06-28T22:52:39 | 2024-06-28T22:52:39 | Jaydeep Borkar, David A. Smith | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Historical documents frequently suffer from damage and inconsistencies,
including missing or illegible text resulting from issues such as holes, ink
problems, and storage damage. These missing portions or gaps are referred to as
lacunae. In this study, we employ transformer-based optical character
recognition (OCR) models trained on synthetic data containing lacunae in a
supervised manner. We demonstrate their effectiveness in detecting and
restoring lacunae, achieving a success rate of 65%, compared to a base model
lacking knowledge of lacunae, which achieves only 5% restoration. Additionally,
we investigate the mechanistic properties of the model, such as the log
probability of transcription, which can identify lacunae and other errors
(e.g., mistranscriptions due to complex writing or ink issues) in line images
without directly inspecting the image. This capability could be valuable for
scholars seeking to distinguish images containing lacunae or errors from clean
ones. Although we explore the potential of attention mechanisms in flagging
lacunae and transcription errors, our findings suggest it is not a significant
factor. Our work highlights a promising direction in utilizing
transformer-based OCR models for restoring or analyzing damaged historical
documents. | [
-0.2458687275648117,
-0.699587881565094,
0.6327978372573853,
-0.44670385122299194,
0.03678354248404503,
0.024072160944342613,
0.34252458810806274,
-0.661601722240448,
0.36358097195625305,
0.9123190641403198,
-0.7961964011192322,
-0.14142683148384094,
-0.5485803484916687,
0.2116585522890091,
-0.35103464126586914,
0.7431420087814331,
-0.17638038098812103,
-0.0680152103304863,
0.1776355355978012,
-0.0743456780910492,
-0.7009599804878235,
-0.207981675863266,
-0.5275998711585999,
-0.026881786063313484,
0.39825934171676636,
-0.033475447446107864,
0.534733772277832,
0.6188990473747253,
0.7000446915626526,
0.2291766256093979,
-0.1259540617465973,
0.3499554991722107,
-0.5429052710533142,
0.07108637690544128,
0.1324586123228073,
-0.732925295829773,
-0.38972964882850647,
-0.2132544219493866,
0.4510783553123474,
0.4669095575809479,
0.22000302374362946,
0.018428415060043335,
-0.03664455562829971,
0.8624171614646912,
-0.5710434913635254,
0.13681617379188538,
-0.6730746030807495,
0.544775664806366,
-0.19517172873020172,
-0.14659227430820465,
-0.5797865390777588,
-0.39104947447776794,
0.07933982461690903,
-0.5574666857719421,
0.9769363403320312,
0.07290606200695038,
1.0560530424118042,
0.5303502082824707,
0.15893609821796417,
-0.3439004421234131,
-0.7765275835990906,
0.5205161571502686,
-0.7503366470336914,
0.6721287369728088,
0.39445751905441284,
0.11571824550628662,
-0.16154998540878296,
-0.3785535991191864,
-0.7492814660072327,
-0.173661008477211,
-0.3588740825653076,
0.2948099970817566,
-0.1958581805229187,
-0.42749011516571045,
0.49018174409866333,
0.7262877821922302,
-0.5759175419807434,
0.23000803589820862,
-0.5196285247802734,
-0.4576512277126312,
0.1205754280090332,
0.03727901354432106,
0.600946307182312,
-0.03385932371020317,
-0.4117473363876343,
-0.3681069314479828,
-0.5986484885215759,
0.00021787492732983083,
0.2995162010192871,
0.11892673373222351,
0.3845933675765991,
0.5693262219429016,
0.4136326313018799,
0.7846043109893799,
0.08253154158592224,
0.011045829392969608,
0.01781756430864334,
-0.042744968086481094,
-0.4344581067562103,
0.20135089755058289,
0.6553486585617065,
0.17252546548843384,
-0.16233417391777039,
-0.44381922483444214,
-0.0398542582988739,
0.06689341366291046,
0.5506081581115723,
-0.3639691174030304,
-0.009427242912352085,
-0.07376426458358765,
-0.3733373284339905,
0.11541515588760376,
0.30239981412887573,
-0.9680144786834717,
-0.8369474411010742,
-0.2682098150253296,
0.32119253277778625,
-0.6109170317649841,
-0.07145356386899948,
0.166927769780159,
-0.2680509388446808,
0.22341838479042053,
0.5672668218612671,
-1.0029710531234741,
0.1086074709892273,
0.29971474409103394,
1.062211036682129,
-0.21647252142429352,
-0.053803883492946625,
-0.13656191527843475,
0.032645974308252335,
-0.4399091899394989,
0.8451285362243652,
0.09919103235006332,
-0.5779383778572083,
-0.05012941733002663,
0.19287589192390442,
-0.3630817234516144,
-0.5895602107048035,
0.8747850060462952,
-0.6633999943733215,
0.2655157744884491,
-0.24122609198093414,
-0.5993139743804932,
-0.2613770067691803,
0.14285269379615784,
-1.6820214986801147,
0.9552712440490723,
0.29586803913116455,
-0.6115013957023621,
0.0506318062543869,
-0.5439465045928955,
-0.09424033761024475,
-0.043158240616321564,
0.009862236678600311,
-0.9225581884384155,
0.07026632875204086,
0.3984030783176422,
0.17767344415187836,
-0.2521064579486847,
-0.10884524136781693,
0.00187801499851048,
-0.37682685256004333,
0.32210347056388855,
-0.41390255093574524,
0.9838503003120422,
-0.10768590867519379,
-0.49602779746055603,
-0.3761758804321289,
-0.6644905805587769,
-0.37856435775756836,
-0.024998066946864128,
-0.12884339690208435,
-0.3307858109474182,
-0.15179142355918884,
0.17292086780071259,
-0.17660163342952728,
0.11560781300067902,
-0.843309223651886,
0.3955496847629547,
-0.3808857202529907,
0.3188458979129791,
0.4658002257347107,
0.082436703145504,
0.33099836111068726,
-0.3997296094894409,
0.2441062480211258,
0.03538406640291214,
0.2855817675590515,
-0.45686954259872437,
-0.5022107362747192,
-1.0887035131454468,
-0.12067776918411255,
0.2879549562931061,
0.7041990756988525,
-0.6667956113815308,
0.6014866828918457,
-0.2649908661842346,
-0.5412653684616089,
-0.9721947312355042,
-0.10336904972791672,
0.11835603415966034,
0.9685111045837402,
0.7212397456169128,
-0.45734620094299316,
-0.594023585319519,
-0.949823260307312,
0.01524701714515686,
-0.3702748715877533,
-0.12624330818653107,
0.18538179993629456,
0.29201075434684753,
-0.356362521648407,
1.0415476560592651,
-0.5962954759597778,
-0.8534829020500183,
0.25954708456993103,
0.2125566303730011,
0.3465825021266937,
0.5210956335067749,
0.2719857692718506,
-0.9351397156715393,
-0.2646462321281433,
0.16457678377628326,
-0.8771904110908508,
-0.20407454669475555,
-0.3580963611602783,
-0.05474365875124931,
0.44215986132621765,
0.6429904103279114,
-0.4172777235507965,
0.7446118593215942,
0.22165292501449585,
-0.12036532163619995,
0.3524684011936188,
-0.17812757194042206,
0.540458083152771,
-0.6677447557449341,
0.16175271570682526,
-0.09131645411252975,
0.06999637186527252,
-0.9001241326332092,
0.025889599695801735,
0.39452996850013733,
-0.21125715970993042,
-0.3253433108329773,
0.23392799496650696,
-0.5497333407402039,
0.14826615154743195,
-0.052401114255189896,
-0.36678144335746765,
0.2725442051887512,
0.4767489731311798,
0.30843278765678406,
0.6937750577926636,
0.04680249094963074,
-0.03125526383519173,
-0.22589217126369476,
0.41302910447120667,
-0.4386754035949707,
0.4505160450935364,
-0.5239371061325073,
0.4998384714126587,
-0.20289123058319092,
-0.06707202643156052,
-0.9437856078147888,
0.03322097659111023,
0.2647053599357605,
-0.3673575818538666,
0.6436586976051331,
0.002908775582909584,
-0.4559831917285919,
-0.40326082706451416,
-0.22589464485645294,
0.4044375419616699,
0.44475170969963074,
-0.4229062497615814,
0.993313729763031,
0.32528451085090637,
-0.10676876455545425,
-0.5628683567047119,
-0.7521642446517944,
0.09041818231344223,
-0.06422298401594162,
-0.39094817638397217,
0.12895146012306213,
-0.048544615507125854,
0.15900279581546783,
-0.09348127990961075,
-0.08295118808746338,
-0.275330513715744,
-0.036342523992061615,
0.3588196337223053,
0.7125571370124817,
-0.3974246680736542,
0.02991442009806633,
-0.15566979348659515,
0.11311895400285721,
-0.2613377869129181,
-0.12186124175786972,
0.4389110803604126,
-0.07118674367666245,
-0.5272177457809448,
-0.41612696647644043,
0.3564034104347229,
0.923825740814209,
-0.30709826946258545,
0.45654726028442383,
0.3003154993057251,
-0.5766615867614746,
0.08975422382354736,
-1.1912622451782227,
-0.011161437258124352,
-0.3793971538543701,
0.24790377914905548,
0.06731212884187698,
-0.8388135433197021,
0.7704217433929443,
0.2507685422897339,
-0.15074437856674194,
0.7906889319419861,
0.41509369015693665,
-0.28169137239456177,
0.2267935574054718,
0.533427894115448,
-0.2373606562614441,
0.4411555826663971,
-0.3929580748081207,
0.16165219247341156,
-0.9545067548751831,
-0.510154664516449,
-0.5006181597709656,
-0.12332119792699814,
-0.10669071972370148,
-0.40763595700263977,
0.5437880158424377,
-0.018775630742311478,
0.05162346363067627,
0.72068852186203,
-0.6195908188819885,
0.6615197062492371,
0.6253136992454529,
0.6110128164291382,
0.3682682514190674,
-0.12051566690206528,
0.31085851788520813,
-0.25176578760147095,
-0.515152096748352,
-0.5846322774887085,
0.5938652753829956,
0.31281760334968567,
0.5146842002868652,
-0.0767403095960617,
0.6115270853042603,
0.7144162654876709,
0.42752617597579956,
-0.8518843650817871,
0.1898994743824005,
-0.0301640834659338,
-0.5768488049507141,
-0.6101171970367432,
-0.1604679524898529,
-1.1357874870300293,
0.10438553243875504,
-0.47284385561943054,
-0.8446138501167297,
0.670746922492981,
0.1846534162759781,
-0.5164151191711426,
0.6591168642044067,
-0.5636503100395203,
0.8650684356689453,
-0.04630576819181442,
-0.25787150859832764,
0.3898448050022125,
-0.7641738057136536,
0.19238536059856415,
-0.5939232707023621,
0.23428276181221008,
0.18854251503944397,
0.25558778643608093,
0.6509982347488403,
-0.3392700254917145,
0.9522116184234619,
0.07953400909900665,
-0.2958855926990509,
0.21855029463768005,
0.28267085552215576,
0.2639261782169342,
-0.5328801870346069,
-0.030553309246897697,
0.3874281942844391,
-0.20739446580410004,
-0.07451960444450378,
-0.6965899467468262,
0.2303084135055542,
-0.7278329730033875,
-0.6228286027908325,
-0.2809146046638489,
-0.7596668601036072,
-0.12805862724781036,
0.5120089650154114,
0.3877609372138977,
0.15537036955356598,
-0.5342118740081787,
0.005746945738792419,
1.1553494930267334,
-0.08996007591485977,
0.49153199791908264,
0.6536108255386353,
0.20113706588745117,
-0.2766089141368866,
0.7608745098114014,
0.31293603777885437,
0.0250859297811985,
0.6885471940040588,
0.04217391461133957,
-0.13445940613746643,
-0.44560858607292175,
-0.6361930966377258,
0.27730923891067505,
-0.5863795280456543,
-0.2884521186351776,
-0.4718216359615326,
-0.20597685873508453,
-0.2618287205696106,
-0.1059398427605629,
-0.1511600911617279,
-0.271145761013031,
-0.6617595553398132,
-0.030453601852059364,
0.03473120927810669,
0.5848884582519531,
0.40303197503089905,
0.40210384130477905,
-1.1435338258743286,
0.22564588487148285,
0.19888798892498016,
0.09377283602952957,
0.2544804811477661,
-0.3616584837436676,
-0.29998543858528137,
-0.11686968058347702,
-0.44033610820770264,
-1.0107922554016113,
0.510186493396759,
0.035984355956315994,
0.42448386549949646,
0.27582016587257385,
-0.10083484649658203,
0.5241671800613403,
-1.0211551189422607,
0.6802088022232056,
0.3642594516277313,
-0.9812668561935425,
0.598461925983429,
-0.20961152017116547,
0.19639967381954193,
0.4803166091442108,
0.3219315707683563,
-0.5317450761795044,
-0.6395475268363953,
-0.7322563529014587,
-0.7246647477149963,
0.6505852937698364,
0.2716664671897888,
-0.3040912449359894,
0.16251477599143982,
0.33709636330604553,
0.3799779415130615,
-0.0788106918334961,
-0.7259693145751953,
0.28838270902633667,
-0.35566869378089905,
-0.16666404902935028,
0.1449989527463913,
0.1502513885498047,
0.014339113608002663,
0.2433265596628189,
0.5499326586723328,
0.12948055565357208,
0.2302933633327484,
0.6098926067352295,
-0.5522705316543579,
-0.2707013487815857,
0.13867925107479095,
0.5258787870407104,
0.18481996655464172,
-0.42806825041770935,
-0.0725468248128891,
-0.045492518693208694,
-0.7312291264533997,
0.15061414241790771,
0.1001908928155899,
-0.5945070385932922,
0.13682861626148224,
0.716637134552002,
0.9250649809837341,
0.042538587003946304,
-0.6275306344032288,
0.3899925649166107,
-0.030740002170205116,
0.06762286275625229,
-0.2370954006910324,
0.03437454253435135,
-0.13624180853366852,
0.2905983030796051,
0.6282293200492859,
0.5046297311782837,
0.31796082854270935,
-0.5958536863327026,
0.11162880808115005,
0.26350459456443787,
-0.6675386428833008,
-0.010187608189880848,
0.7346552014350891,
-0.25877779722213745,
-0.6421336531639099,
0.7473803162574768,
0.620498538017273,
-0.4124700427055359,
0.8298515677452087,
0.36327099800109863,
0.6795141696929932,
-0.5290526747703552,
-0.11784874647855759,
0.24911095201969147,
0.6651477813720703,
-0.30026859045028687,
-0.19260571897029877,
0.14830777049064636,
-0.7610667943954468,
0.008377422578632832,
-0.5448468923568726,
-0.41693544387817383,
0.22465935349464417,
-0.9510008096694946,
0.022833464667201042,
-0.03516475856304169,
-0.43753358721733093,
0.18121486902236938,
-0.5656995177268982,
-0.6093491315841675,
0.2679463326931,
0.11907963454723358,
0.7561842799186707,
-1.0861315727233887,
0.5218520760536194,
-0.013124344870448112,
-0.6672711968421936,
-0.44343623518943787,
-0.026504529640078545,
-0.131307914853096,
-0.9087123870849609,
0.5344345569610596,
0.2598051428794861,
-0.1758778989315033,
-0.09757034480571747,
-0.15566255152225494,
-0.7243784070014954,
1.249241590499878,
0.3509708046913147,
-0.8292978405952454,
-0.14006318151950836,
0.2667863965034485,
0.7444924712181091,
0.18298906087875366,
0.16195978224277496,
0.5680383443832397,
0.4177963435649872,
-0.05676601082086563,
-0.8399106860160828,
-0.03832293301820755,
-0.21829892694950104,
0.08006541430950165,
0.571566641330719,
-0.5251511335372925,
0.7447974681854248,
0.023594705387949944,
-0.3811434507369995,
0.30399733781814575,
0.48444864153862,
-0.14321604371070862,
0.18045192956924438,
0.6039506793022156,
0.7743791937828064,
1.0270731449127197,
-0.20779533684253693,
1.1075695753097534,
0.22892342507839203,
0.3593296706676483,
0.8214603066444397,
-0.3563491106033325,
0.8247849345207214,
0.5246148705482483,
-0.16431958973407745,
0.5984898805618286,
0.39625105261802673,
-0.55002760887146,
0.4472885727882385,
-0.09698030352592468,
-0.15000806748867035,
0.15930725634098053,
-0.08695439249277115,
-0.23521867394447327,
0.037456803023815155,
0.42258140444755554,
-0.64847332239151,
-0.013877756893634796,
0.0765782818198204,
-0.22908943891525269,
0.02184675633907318,
-0.6019997000694275,
0.8444527983665466,
-0.16283999383449554,
-0.7819444537162781,
0.5112636685371399,
-0.5005178451538086,
0.2803366482257843,
-0.6870583295822144,
-0.2076641470193863,
-0.30151864886283875,
0.2498435229063034,
-0.2269483208656311,
-0.60952228307724,
0.3741784989833832,
-0.2860601544380188,
-0.6093754768371582,
-0.020947597920894623,
0.8076351284980774,
-0.5263725519180298,
-0.6659464240074158,
0.1323574185371399,
0.5262506604194641,
-0.036040715873241425,
0.25455546379089355,
-0.2425982654094696,
0.1457459032535553,
0.11195065081119537,
0.001944426796399057,
0.14247074723243713,
0.3039732277393341,
-0.11864510178565979,
0.08583837747573853,
0.4664139747619629,
0.037538763135671616,
0.010849987156689167,
0.13030807673931122,
0.5775539875030518,
-0.3912748396396637,
-0.23818880319595337,
-0.98126220703125,
0.41731026768684387,
-0.11358562856912613,
-0.04289034754037857,
0.787915050983429,
0.7281152606010437,
0.6791272759437561,
-0.7810391783714294,
0.6573470234870911,
0.41570430994033813,
0.48127827048301697,
-0.7902934551239014,
0.9998172521591187,
-0.3900860548019409,
0.05268222093582153,
-0.4600667655467987,
-0.6203458309173584,
-0.5500476956367493,
0.7062731981277466,
0.002042187377810478,
-0.5787822008132935,
0.7959944605827332,
1.0188963413238525,
-0.19803652167320251,
0.26153799891471863,
0.2327336072921753,
0.08284834772348404,
0.1223549097776413,
0.6189606785774231,
0.6323738098144531,
-0.6285974383354187,
0.31431764364242554,
0.26826098561286926,
-0.47631514072418213,
-0.05494685843586922,
-0.777496874332428,
-0.8293527960777283,
-0.7227271795272827,
-0.17545948922634125,
-0.3229222893714905,
0.013467256911098957,
0.39839455485343933,
0.329851359128952,
-0.8534294962882996,
-0.1858413964509964,
-0.011255092918872833,
-0.20081505179405212,
-0.24792072176933289,
-0.20854854583740234,
0.898108184337616,
-0.0005574817769229412,
-0.679277241230011,
0.27961650490760803,
0.401275098323822,
0.5247685313224792,
-0.13208873569965363,
0.3881833553314209,
-0.03758463263511658,
-0.04361426830291748,
0.24750690162181854,
0.6990353465080261,
-0.8420613408088684,
-0.05336562916636467,
0.32710638642311096,
0.04149186238646507,
0.43447884917259216,
1.225257396697998,
-0.6372126340866089,
0.7180869579315186,
0.376935213804245,
0.9902811646461487,
0.7045032978057861,
-0.29013895988464355,
0.3718460202217102,
-0.4920765161514282,
0.004476461093872786,
0.4643288552761078,
0.8014974594116211,
0.5401982069015503,
-0.7280510663986206,
0.6989454627037048,
0.40266886353492737,
-0.5224213004112244,
-0.7414696216583252,
0.05140405148267746,
-1.2308857440948486,
-0.3273213803768158,
0.590453028678894,
-0.31216344237327576,
-0.48447027802467346,
-0.2573624849319458,
-0.6727597117424011,
0.5930690765380859,
-0.11067260801792145,
1.1535062789916992,
0.8104317784309387,
-0.2054402381181717,
-0.3145376443862915,
-0.3527141809463501,
0.20483043789863586,
0.276114284992218,
-0.7319202423095703,
0.16084958612918854,
0.6625115275382996,
-0.168473482131958,
0.9294689297676086,
0.5973387360572815,
-0.29639551043510437,
0.3170442283153534,
-0.16442832350730896,
0.0604209266602993,
-0.1826477348804474,
-0.00717195775359869,
-0.2238171100616455,
0.30855679512023926,
-0.3337922990322113,
0.12539079785346985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00248v1 | DiffuseDef: Improved Robustness to Adversarial Attacks | 2024-06-28T22:36:17 | 2024-06-28T22:36:17 | Zhenhao Li, Marek Rei, Lucia Specia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models have significantly advanced performance across
various natural language processing tasks. However, adversarial attacks
continue to pose a critical challenge to system built using these models, as
they can be exploited with carefully crafted adversarial texts. Inspired by the
ability of diffusion models to predict and reduce noise in computer vision, we
propose a novel and flexible adversarial defense method for language
classification tasks, DiffuseDef, which incorporates a diffusion layer as a
denoiser between the encoder and the classifier. During inference, the
adversarial hidden state is first combined with sampled noise, then denoised
iteratively and finally ensembled to produce a robust text representation. By
integrating adversarial training, denoising, and ensembling techniques, we show
that DiffuseDef improves over different existing adversarial defense methods
and achieves state-of-the-art performance against common adversarial attacks. | [
-0.46490976214408875,
-1.2137686014175415,
0.2997947335243225,
-0.01855413243174553,
0.019869722425937653,
0.2532584071159363,
-0.24533841013908386,
-0.18115605413913727,
-0.21385450661182404,
0.4812870919704437,
-0.30279818177223206,
-0.5115691423416138,
-1.1793910264968872,
-0.1417718082666397,
-0.8313953280448914,
0.9416069984436035,
0.2174575924873352,
0.11737322062253952,
-0.017418574541807175,
-0.03723154962062836,
0.09370052069425583,
-0.4596366584300995,
-0.9435523152351379,
-0.197026327252388,
0.2019093781709671,
-0.3033129870891571,
1.0996372699737549,
0.14954090118408203,
0.42650869488716125,
0.36903929710388184,
-0.31982895731925964,
0.08851370215415955,
-0.3328135311603546,
0.29703569412231445,
0.010091462172567844,
-0.32363858819007874,
-0.28922954201698303,
-0.04680369049310684,
0.5728874802589417,
0.623771071434021,
-0.18539933860301971,
-0.6405375003814697,
0.14520233869552612,
0.814660370349884,
-0.8991481065750122,
-0.3047672212123871,
-0.4873340427875519,
0.03668643534183502,
-0.2745392620563507,
0.28178301453590393,
-0.5598167181015015,
-0.21195358037948608,
0.2830129861831665,
-0.5500869154930115,
0.44606447219848633,
-0.5681590437889099,
0.9396544694900513,
0.4181273877620697,
-0.37550491094589233,
-0.1242537871003151,
-0.9023010730743408,
0.5947055220603943,
-0.5815173983573914,
0.29789355397224426,
0.3720521628856659,
0.20437735319137573,
-0.2542014718055725,
-0.6549922227859497,
-0.4117431044578552,
-0.09235342592000961,
0.03945183753967285,
0.2818939685821533,
-0.5891479253768921,
0.17454946041107178,
-0.015614519827067852,
0.3214398920536041,
-0.6991026997566223,
-0.14878305792808533,
-0.12750859558582306,
-0.23380286991596222,
0.4789090156555176,
-0.26701486110687256,
0.4406444728374481,
0.5172796249389648,
-0.38941073417663574,
-0.3359649181365967,
-0.4470248520374298,
-0.305013507604599,
0.4588207006454468,
-0.01038635428994894,
0.04114373028278351,
-0.020086342468857765,
0.00434607919305563,
0.8474282622337341,
0.16609807312488556,
-0.04342179372906685,
-0.033469438552856445,
0.09942422807216644,
-0.3915558457374573,
-0.02290440909564495,
0.7814031839370728,
0.08098674565553665,
0.060378652065992355,
-0.31825578212738037,
-0.20646362006664276,
0.32060739398002625,
0.4983622431755066,
-0.9010433554649353,
-0.5457673668861389,
-0.017581408843398094,
-0.2504775822162628,
-0.7859979271888733,
0.025439515709877014,
-0.9402794241905212,
-0.621550440788269,
0.3635694086551666,
0.38020190596580505,
-0.4927416741847992,
-0.4076419174671173,
0.16156335175037384,
-0.44700056314468384,
-0.12214316427707672,
0.37414902448654175,
-0.7003315091133118,
0.5858004093170166,
0.4328680634498596,
0.8309570550918579,
-0.18870380520820618,
0.019857069477438927,
-0.41639071702957153,
0.12839330732822418,
-0.4659010171890259,
0.7571936249732971,
-0.6020212173461914,
-0.555919885635376,
-0.039288900792598724,
-0.26499488949775696,
-0.18656811118125916,
-0.6417266130447388,
0.5065820813179016,
-0.858078122138977,
0.4059619605541229,
0.30660077929496765,
-0.3886861503124237,
-0.4615636169910431,
0.3635711669921875,
-0.9903303980827332,
0.9705172181129456,
0.27182671427726746,
-1.0677295923233032,
0.23563402891159058,
-0.5728849172592163,
-0.7368600368499756,
0.08070732653141022,
0.04673769697546959,
-0.5525348782539368,
-0.06981676816940308,
0.42060163617134094,
0.4616604745388031,
-0.07056371122598648,
-0.06612975895404816,
-0.41692692041397095,
-0.06782416254281998,
0.12115063518285751,
-0.9672476053237915,
0.901293933391571,
0.38441962003707886,
-0.3728393018245697,
-0.10648050159215927,
-0.8019123673439026,
-0.24257472157478333,
0.17633844912052155,
-0.506662905216217,
-0.5133652687072754,
0.08484296500682831,
-0.06526822596788406,
-0.34381845593452454,
0.111559197306633,
-0.33131715655326843,
-0.13833731412887573,
-0.9515773057937622,
0.3487747013568878,
0.6131383776664734,
0.10023947060108185,
1.024266004562378,
0.0377122163772583,
0.6946181654930115,
0.02258796989917755,
0.14254029095172882,
0.30057045817375183,
-0.5099939703941345,
-0.5176312923431396,
-0.5945820808410645,
0.37948745489120483,
0.627497673034668,
-0.9116591215133667,
0.2308492809534073,
0.09107615053653717,
-0.3741505444049835,
-0.37630608677864075,
0.34453874826431274,
0.26767516136169434,
0.46163231134414673,
0.23288065195083618,
-0.11530748754739761,
-0.30598706007003784,
-0.5089979767799377,
-0.12567178905010223,
-0.082801952958107,
0.01169656589627266,
-0.1074296236038208,
0.1606326699256897,
-0.5489067435264587,
0.5120068192481995,
-0.5922532081604004,
-0.1489836573600769,
-0.38360172510147095,
0.14117936789989471,
-0.20479877293109894,
0.3072059154510498,
0.7328972220420837,
-1.0489994287490845,
-0.6648775935173035,
0.09882767498493195,
-0.5321276187896729,
-0.008198140189051628,
-0.04309288039803505,
-0.21703140437602997,
0.07862021774053574,
0.6326606869697571,
-0.4042210280895233,
0.49650558829307556,
0.5866213440895081,
-0.3785819113254547,
0.04224476218223572,
-0.2798783779144287,
0.003978647757321596,
-0.8129309415817261,
-0.32430657744407654,
-0.13790775835514069,
-0.4616239070892334,
-0.9126392602920532,
0.22512398660182953,
0.09532899409532547,
-0.08216837048530579,
-0.35452792048454285,
0.5550142526626587,
-0.2842737138271332,
0.6170902848243713,
-0.4623686671257019,
0.16964170336723328,
0.21531996130943298,
0.10712955892086029,
0.022054193541407585,
0.514640212059021,
1.1327697038650513,
-0.8197288513183594,
0.33341482281684875,
-0.003909815102815628,
-0.14100168645381927,
0.740959882736206,
-0.46797657012939453,
0.10008323192596436,
-0.3133089244365692,
0.18204696476459503,
-0.8572142720222473,
0.10131029039621353,
0.3581448495388031,
-0.39028239250183105,
0.7924129366874695,
-0.09902124106884003,
-0.2143751084804535,
-0.1620979905128479,
-0.2679792046546936,
0.24579110741615295,
0.4042574167251587,
-0.7553738355636597,
0.7855015397071838,
0.3596625030040741,
0.10236448049545288,
-0.6065402030944824,
-0.7967498302459717,
0.2744804620742798,
-0.4023612141609192,
-0.6991583108901978,
0.6093574166297913,
-0.10112166404724121,
-0.3503877818584442,
-0.03874839469790459,
0.022408153861761093,
-0.46054214239120483,
0.6282052397727966,
0.189772829413414,
0.20734713971614838,
-0.09143096953630447,
-0.18851904571056366,
-0.009417896158993244,
-0.03620518743991852,
0.05133097246289253,
-0.2740660011768341,
0.3207492530345917,
0.1416526585817337,
-0.23570826649665833,
-0.19551986455917358,
0.41786399483680725,
0.4402691721916199,
0.012970888055860996,
0.8669825792312622,
0.9048358798027039,
-0.3608405292034149,
-0.7011207342147827,
-0.2164929062128067,
-0.005143835674971342,
-0.5625758767127991,
0.4877026677131653,
-0.19672326743602753,
-0.7620733380317688,
0.186081662774086,
-0.237367182970047,
-0.014949023723602295,
0.4874454438686371,
0.2156928926706314,
0.055658381432294846,
1.1890554428100586,
0.7136935591697693,
-0.21013720333576202,
0.6175616383552551,
-0.38286760449409485,
0.14284725487232208,
-0.5546650886535645,
-0.08902093023061752,
-0.47477325797080994,
-0.14078350365161896,
-0.1979665756225586,
-0.3464321792125702,
0.1882939338684082,
0.3270376920700073,
-0.15421296656131744,
0.2806505858898163,
-0.6132974028587341,
0.5267020463943481,
0.4314098656177521,
0.21564848721027374,
-0.07669295370578766,
0.20209486782550812,
-0.06080731377005577,
0.04524227976799011,
-0.5924161076545715,
-0.40647512674331665,
1.0899568796157837,
0.35278627276420593,
1.0061770677566528,
0.3820437788963318,
0.7274976968765259,
0.544937789440155,
0.33320245146751404,
-0.48503437638282776,
0.5338493585586548,
-0.667567253112793,
-0.4175724685192108,
-0.2744601368904114,
-0.4466974437236786,
-0.9877035021781921,
0.34999367594718933,
0.028149699792265892,
-0.3805922269821167,
0.1887427419424057,
-0.048761628568172455,
-0.325459748506546,
0.4425586760044098,
-0.7462761402130127,
0.6445539593696594,
-0.043552644550800323,
-0.016120124608278275,
-0.13087406754493713,
-0.1756284385919571,
0.32721659541130066,
-0.0803590714931488,
0.3384896516799927,
0.35577529668807983,
0.031848955899477005,
0.8460952043533325,
-0.37317517399787903,
0.8424585461616516,
-0.35810357332229614,
-0.33970215916633606,
0.3266964554786682,
0.3992471992969513,
0.4797295033931732,
0.008284811861813068,
-0.13153637945652008,
-0.03971446678042412,
-0.21285821497440338,
-0.3537774980068207,
-0.652895450592041,
0.7448894381523132,
-0.6087069511413574,
-0.756922721862793,
-0.4411734342575073,
-0.13919194042682648,
0.031667184084653854,
0.23509787023067474,
0.5330390930175781,
0.38373950123786926,
-0.7383750677108765,
-0.04250720143318176,
1.1329495906829834,
-0.1663113385438919,
0.7893245816230774,
0.386065810918808,
0.29726749658584595,
-0.6130812764167786,
0.9041110277175903,
-0.17222779989242554,
0.5736264586448669,
0.5995491147041321,
0.14844129979610443,
-0.3929655849933624,
-0.6430149674415588,
-0.4651308059692383,
-0.2784869968891144,
-0.910695493221283,
-0.3351196050643921,
-0.6639008522033691,
-0.4519975185394287,
-0.6004751324653625,
-0.2872556447982788,
-0.2624618709087372,
-0.4034697413444519,
-0.4581616222858429,
-0.03805001080036163,
0.2950505018234253,
0.919195830821991,
-0.008795824833214283,
0.4341460168361664,
-0.4111955761909485,
0.4243074357509613,
0.41672784090042114,
0.10889571160078049,
-0.1004507839679718,
-0.6484747529029846,
-0.16856123507022858,
0.02578381821513176,
-0.4034866690635681,
-0.9546753764152527,
0.5892583727836609,
0.5568690299987793,
0.6730388402938843,
0.6220220923423767,
0.3417626917362213,
0.35140299797058105,
-0.4246598780155182,
0.7630513310432434,
0.2526608407497406,
-0.7073274850845337,
0.6709601879119873,
0.1534605175256729,
0.3858473598957062,
0.2729506194591522,
0.1271749883890152,
0.04429984837770462,
-0.7734415531158447,
-0.653274655342102,
-0.6281460523605347,
0.5240694284439087,
0.2757483124732971,
0.03329543396830559,
-0.07590700685977936,
-0.006857738830149174,
-0.15920907258987427,
-0.17640002071857452,
-0.661331295967102,
-0.3032684028148651,
-0.4206944704055786,
-0.3952590823173523,
-0.05654790252447128,
-0.06360980868339539,
-0.33749717473983765,
0.02950218692421913,
0.6042938232421875,
0.10459159314632416,
0.08940818160772324,
0.32941722869873047,
-0.21318285167217255,
0.19108234345912933,
0.2168489396572113,
0.5114327669143677,
-0.18634438514709473,
0.027271240949630737,
0.597574770450592,
0.24135075509548187,
-0.9151965975761414,
0.3011462092399597,
0.2609710991382599,
-0.5307475924491882,
0.01478362176567316,
0.46615272760391235,
0.5924825668334961,
-0.08651169389486313,
-0.4583021104335785,
0.7606193423271179,
-0.4645688831806183,
-0.4010985791683197,
-0.15909172594547272,
0.3910464942455292,
-0.048118289560079575,
0.3151955306529999,
-0.03491596877574921,
0.7240241169929504,
0.3355085253715515,
-0.05711771175265312,
0.1597374826669693,
0.7310377955436707,
-0.5235193371772766,
-0.1798875480890274,
0.7344706058502197,
0.09007886797189713,
-0.25890490412712097,
0.03382036089897156,
-0.3698333203792572,
-0.8076398372650146,
0.5053218603134155,
0.430366188287735,
1.1245485544204712,
-0.4565103054046631,
0.4070248603820801,
0.06080777198076248,
0.4152287542819977,
-0.3821648061275482,
-0.13843882083892822,
-0.2504967153072357,
-0.7138122320175171,
0.1294621378183365,
-0.7283697128295898,
-0.008084608241915703,
0.11685686558485031,
-0.4159838557243347,
-0.1464133858680725,
-0.9197744727134705,
-0.23803886771202087,
-0.002595034893602133,
-0.21990451216697693,
-0.4262579381465912,
0.34498465061187744,
0.24907483160495758,
0.5875281095504761,
-0.4958556890487671,
0.7796386480331421,
0.5181471705436707,
-0.11105179786682129,
-0.05198542773723602,
0.22946397960186005,
0.07913345098495483,
-0.3742227852344513,
0.6702617406845093,
-0.12583637237548828,
-0.5122235417366028,
-0.3570385277271271,
-0.41024982929229736,
-0.8471534252166748,
0.6145011782646179,
0.5093774199485779,
-0.24492357671260834,
0.3291839063167572,
-0.154886394739151,
0.46485093235969543,
-0.15529775619506836,
0.0295453742146492,
0.5529153347015381,
0.3731217682361603,
0.033741243183612823,
-0.29805272817611694,
0.023961417376995087,
-0.30491751432418823,
-0.0003450261428952217,
0.05360722541809082,
-0.43546122312545776,
0.6728136539459229,
-0.10159826278686523,
-0.7081640958786011,
-0.03156251087784767,
0.7050467133522034,
-0.37035197019577026,
0.1480732411146164,
0.6566295027732849,
0.7994154095649719,
0.8488095998764038,
-0.1456017643213272,
0.9398019909858704,
0.018476024270057678,
-0.0644288882613182,
0.8957712650299072,
-0.1911824494600296,
0.7541444897651672,
-0.050379011780023575,
-0.24403610825538635,
0.6290243268013,
0.37090763449668884,
0.0077173346653580666,
1.0283489227294922,
0.1298910230398178,
-0.7618911266326904,
-0.09741388261318207,
0.36822137236595154,
-0.24273647367954254,
0.11715972423553467,
0.4498888850212097,
-0.28705090284347534,
-0.34450584650039673,
0.38882753252983093,
0.10669410973787308,
0.4704909026622772,
-0.13132856786251068,
1.0060315132141113,
-0.10128936171531677,
-0.4307321608066559,
0.7546287178993225,
0.13433720171451569,
1.0104609727859497,
-0.5393122434616089,
0.1291951984167099,
-0.16529808938503265,
0.6337907910346985,
-0.11602769792079926,
-0.5433233380317688,
0.3624083399772644,
-0.05608484148979187,
-0.2546631693840027,
-0.28726842999458313,
0.8296341896057129,
-0.42769280076026917,
-0.5195844173431396,
0.6725711822509766,
-0.13307014107704163,
-0.19984789192676544,
-0.26249024271965027,
-0.7526336908340454,
-0.10722193866968155,
0.013010887429118156,
-0.3018539249897003,
0.3398917317390442,
0.5176079869270325,
0.36540600657463074,
0.7224891185760498,
0.38890376687049866,
0.3481825590133667,
0.1742326319217682,
0.5546994209289551,
0.7907922267913818,
-0.2435043305158615,
-0.5094335675239563,
-1.0439226627349854,
0.10381928086280823,
-0.20976217091083527,
-0.05909775197505951,
0.6617159247398376,
0.27947211265563965,
0.7151845097541809,
0.10818448662757874,
0.8765146732330322,
0.14259904623031616,
0.4446111023426056,
-0.3927839398384094,
1.0213756561279297,
-0.3738778233528137,
0.46948936581611633,
-0.23729518055915833,
-0.4695606231689453,
-0.43270447850227356,
0.6891482472419739,
0.010820399038493633,
0.07065961509943008,
0.6177762150764465,
0.994274914264679,
0.038493067026138306,
-0.022471647709608078,
0.5409316420555115,
0.17149759829044342,
0.5486093163490295,
0.4756676256656647,
0.7145715355873108,
-0.6516604423522949,
0.8097891211509705,
-0.2858329117298126,
-0.3385469913482666,
0.2224663496017456,
-0.5324230194091797,
-1.264047622680664,
-0.3871353566646576,
-0.6626232266426086,
-0.45001858472824097,
0.17748165130615234,
-0.022997990250587463,
0.8546895384788513,
-0.9288960099220276,
0.21461713314056396,
-0.456806480884552,
0.1578061729669571,
-0.3583996295928955,
-0.2690125107765198,
0.3904842138290405,
-0.24632813036441803,
-0.8072149157524109,
0.661694347858429,
0.19974766671657562,
0.41818469762802124,
-0.3867219090461731,
-0.22283726930618286,
-0.13854429125785828,
0.3164990544319153,
0.41702648997306824,
0.07511572539806366,
-0.5699597597122192,
0.12803229689598083,
-0.3936009705066681,
-0.33449745178222656,
-0.3581804633140564,
0.3408529758453369,
-0.6952587962150574,
0.4422546923160553,
0.44704070687294006,
0.8592539429664612,
0.35762515664100647,
-0.17185348272323608,
0.530326247215271,
-0.8563792705535889,
0.3289828598499298,
0.32268401980400085,
0.2589784860610962,
0.46381232142448425,
-0.6893134713172913,
0.24851635098457336,
0.24751795828342438,
-0.17077170312404633,
-0.665667712688446,
0.1586524397134781,
-0.6108438968658447,
-0.8163915872573853,
1.019498586654663,
-0.2716342508792877,
-0.3434447944164276,
-0.33870676159858704,
-0.25901803374290466,
0.008801531977951527,
-0.38380715250968933,
0.6662933826446533,
0.6766305565834045,
0.4451819360256195,
-0.16371406614780426,
-0.19679521024227142,
0.9072547554969788,
0.39459195733070374,
-0.6160732507705688,
0.10990401357412338,
0.20976518094539642,
0.1605159193277359,
0.1689574271440506,
0.5249390602111816,
-0.2374778836965561,
0.1616782546043396,
0.3151222765445709,
-0.5151396989822388,
0.13686570525169373,
-0.4520534873008728,
-0.5467851161956787,
0.5489755868911743,
-0.13638059794902802,
-0.28180187940597534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00242v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00242v1 | EHRmonize: A Framework for Medical Concept Abstraction from Electronic Health Records using Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T21:39:20 | 2024-06-28T21:39:20 | João Matos, Jack Gallifant, Jian Pei, A. Ian Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic health records (EHRs) contain vast amounts of complex data, but
harmonizing and processing this information remains a challenging and costly
task requiring significant clinical expertise. While large language models
(LLMs) have shown promise in various healthcare applications, their potential
for abstracting medical concepts from EHRs remains largely unexplored. We
introduce EHRmonize, a framework leveraging LLMs to abstract medical concepts
from EHR data. Our study uses medication data from two real-world EHR databases
to evaluate five LLMs on two free-text extraction and six binary classification
tasks across various prompting strategies. GPT-4o's with 10-shot prompting
achieved the highest performance in all tasks, accompanied by Claude-3.5-Sonnet
in a subset of tasks. GPT-4o achieved an accuracy of 97% in identifying generic
route names, 82% for generic drug names, and 100% in performing binary
classification of antibiotics. While EHRmonize significantly enhances
efficiency, reducing annotation time by an estimated 60%, we emphasize that
clinician oversight remains essential. Our framework, available as a Python
package, offers a promising tool to assist clinicians in EHR data abstraction,
potentially accelerating healthcare research and improving data harmonization
processes. | [
-0.03854476660490036,
-0.9506824016571045,
0.9942869544029236,
-0.12947237491607666,
-0.29991888999938965,
-0.2155093401670456,
-0.39370325207710266,
-0.5213768482208252,
0.15545065701007843,
0.32731741666793823,
-0.3878784477710724,
-0.7902240753173828,
-0.6696727275848389,
0.2464917153120041,
-0.2174980193376541,
1.0005383491516113,
-0.22250071167945862,
0.07111789286136627,
-0.24390603601932526,
0.07581023871898651,
-0.28934237360954285,
-0.5513334274291992,
-0.569176971912384,
-0.8283610939979553,
0.5201780200004578,
0.3461354374885559,
0.2235080599784851,
0.9736639857292175,
0.6653482913970947,
0.2841286361217499,
-0.03183562681078911,
-0.02894028089940548,
-0.15832236409187317,
0.5006852149963379,
-0.005379107780754566,
-0.5678588151931763,
-0.6927341222763062,
-0.48548707365989685,
0.5231132507324219,
0.38521715998649597,
-0.6371455192565918,
0.38290226459503174,
-0.36549538373947144,
0.6832189559936523,
-0.6656979918479919,
0.29871219396591187,
-0.42930394411087036,
0.15092310309410095,
-0.21286191046237946,
-0.14996467530727386,
-0.16536085307598114,
-0.07486387342214584,
0.18703578412532806,
-0.6198888421058655,
-0.13274100422859192,
0.19500122964382172,
0.7470095157623291,
0.323468416929245,
0.10226170718669891,
-0.3117579519748688,
-0.5903570652008057,
0.6911341547966003,
-0.8297372460365295,
0.46367233991622925,
0.5133106708526611,
0.11538134515285492,
0.018262026831507683,
-0.8070406913757324,
-0.49642008543014526,
-0.0774015262722969,
-0.019872955977916718,
0.03260926902294159,
-0.3488420248031616,
0.22431419789791107,
0.34105074405670166,
0.2547730803489685,
-0.4853757917881012,
0.05441907048225403,
-0.27270805835723877,
0.04262309521436691,
0.3655938506126404,
0.29184192419052124,
0.6122078895568848,
-0.17166435718536377,
-0.32151487469673157,
0.10790140181779861,
-0.4943713843822479,
-0.1827308088541031,
-0.32538309693336487,
-0.042968880385160446,
-0.3173513412475586,
0.5708990693092346,
-0.3189410865306854,
0.6333838105201721,
0.1331903636455536,
-0.2364630550146103,
0.5199218392372131,
0.07480562478303909,
-0.5936996340751648,
0.5431725382804871,
0.842345118522644,
0.40998581051826477,
-0.17381349205970764,
-0.2970287799835205,
-0.28267380595207214,
0.1349107027053833,
0.18567006289958954,
-0.9669411778450012,
-0.40102043747901917,
0.9171218872070312,
-0.3336246609687805,
-0.04882940277457237,
-0.042018234729766846,
-0.8161416053771973,
-0.1434955596923828,
-0.5148137211799622,
0.3138543963432312,
-0.49541598558425903,
-0.0598127506673336,
0.3991539180278778,
-0.2520977258682251,
0.004661876708269119,
0.39812421798706055,
-0.8170964121818542,
0.42473798990249634,
0.9865796566009521,
0.9959854483604431,
-0.25111034512519836,
0.016926448792219162,
-0.30005282163619995,
0.19885259866714478,
-0.3267824053764343,
0.8583853244781494,
-0.47630614042282104,
-0.29639557003974915,
-0.16081203520298004,
-0.09855370223522186,
-0.13283734023571014,
-0.7070246338844299,
0.46689510345458984,
-0.24516725540161133,
0.10981332510709763,
0.04817091301083565,
-0.8747079372406006,
0.08460712432861328,
0.57480788230896,
-0.7735098600387573,
0.7435102462768555,
0.18031057715415955,
-0.8692747354507446,
0.10243884474039078,
-0.8191874027252197,
-0.30056965351104736,
0.22783522307872772,
-0.38755854964256287,
-0.6013987064361572,
0.002091469708830118,
0.14760267734527588,
0.5759149789810181,
-0.6473607420921326,
0.2349955141544342,
-0.11028362065553665,
-0.15502920746803284,
0.28076231479644775,
0.19584757089614868,
0.6294945478439331,
0.30219435691833496,
-0.40836766362190247,
0.06730081886053085,
-0.6861016154289246,
0.20054174959659576,
0.07392982393503189,
-0.42215338349342346,
-0.5443433523178101,
-0.16022954881191254,
0.15255491435527802,
0.24675214290618896,
0.027529070153832436,
-0.5643728971481323,
0.015296612866222858,
-0.5840652585029602,
0.5565181970596313,
0.32277610898017883,
0.3232664465904236,
0.255004346370697,
-0.5517362356185913,
0.5769447088241577,
-0.04398643970489502,
-0.023686079308390617,
-0.39477208256721497,
-0.6555491089820862,
-0.4104996919631958,
-0.6524664163589478,
0.3503706753253937,
0.6425579786300659,
-0.61822509765625,
0.44082602858543396,
-0.6204386949539185,
-0.312350869178772,
-0.5777793526649475,
0.09268278628587723,
0.43258023262023926,
0.6225215196609497,
0.35712113976478577,
-0.08250975608825684,
-0.3508280813694,
-0.9280416369438171,
-0.16787205636501312,
-0.190409854054451,
-0.23209722340106964,
-0.005359959788620472,
0.5663694739341736,
-0.542822003364563,
0.6682115793228149,
-0.42779478430747986,
-0.3583681285381317,
-0.2840012311935425,
0.11361145973205566,
0.16995428502559662,
0.40333980321884155,
0.043582212179899216,
-0.844758927822113,
-0.224725142121315,
0.30445942282676697,
-0.8999817967414856,
-0.14660108089447021,
0.004224921576678753,
-0.2647711932659149,
-0.3212786018848419,
0.33524468541145325,
-0.64378821849823,
0.09044458717107773,
0.36534246802330017,
0.0028107131365686655,
0.2213764488697052,
-0.3555254638195038,
0.3224456310272217,
-1.2500426769256592,
0.29034554958343506,
0.23146189749240875,
-0.17082788050174713,
-0.9499710202217102,
0.4044424295425415,
0.19156193733215332,
0.03497449308633804,
-0.6034601330757141,
0.44834426045417786,
-0.3885939419269562,
0.47561049461364746,
0.003802978666499257,
-0.052844464778900146,
0.06376925110816956,
0.21218222379684448,
0.13442882895469666,
0.15890052914619446,
0.4012853503227234,
-0.44852757453918457,
0.5759857296943665,
0.4651002287864685,
-0.2083566039800644,
0.7455923557281494,
-0.7568924427032471,
0.16698065400123596,
-0.03599303215742111,
0.15832382440567017,
-0.28599783778190613,
-0.6233980655670166,
0.536357045173645,
-0.1747565120458603,
0.3297184407711029,
-0.3101561963558197,
-0.6338794231414795,
-0.26708871126174927,
-0.271892786026001,
0.3270520865917206,
0.5129833221435547,
-0.08237684518098831,
0.6663753390312195,
0.7240368127822876,
-0.3773750364780426,
-0.21684353053569794,
-0.7780039310455322,
0.17986616492271423,
-0.2866903841495514,
-0.17367908358573914,
0.4678806960582733,
0.060865841805934906,
-0.4270871579647064,
0.06183695048093796,
0.05863400548696518,
-0.40309637784957886,
-0.023538712412118912,
0.40094074606895447,
0.456906795501709,
-0.21119533479213715,
0.40363654494285583,
0.2121092528104782,
-0.04124987870454788,
0.31301620602607727,
-0.40819472074508667,
0.48814302682876587,
0.04453885555267334,
-0.4432527422904968,
-0.6751076579093933,
0.33278191089630127,
0.6378428936004639,
-0.2562534511089325,
0.5597309470176697,
0.21968768537044525,
-0.8627533912658691,
-0.08973725140094757,
-0.3281945586204529,
-0.12891235947608948,
-0.37516653537750244,
0.41119495034217834,
-0.12422934919595718,
-0.5642693042755127,
0.24009908735752106,
-0.23335927724838257,
0.2531203031539917,
0.1757104992866516,
0.98003751039505,
0.007721103727817535,
0.7725327610969543,
0.1715000420808792,
0.007898661307990551,
0.20081229507923126,
-0.08414720743894577,
0.001879679155535996,
-0.9183117747306824,
-0.4817954897880554,
-0.4055973291397095,
-0.15136824548244476,
-0.3048752546310425,
-0.4300551414489746,
0.6706618666648865,
-0.21397711336612701,
-0.12160710990428925,
0.08783764392137527,
-0.46916303038597107,
0.24012359976768494,
0.11568842083215714,
0.6175971031188965,
0.37471580505371094,
0.1714550405740738,
-0.03344704583287239,
0.15965381264686584,
-0.6367140412330627,
-0.3417604863643646,
1.2596544027328491,
0.41881829500198364,
0.7177364230155945,
0.016779497265815735,
1.0365233421325684,
0.18249064683914185,
0.4500690698623657,
-1.13339364528656,
0.2370273619890213,
0.11346031725406647,
-0.5523125529289246,
-0.27277159690856934,
-0.46871644258499146,
-0.9458003640174866,
0.24530872702598572,
-0.5240660309791565,
-0.5942652821540833,
-0.02281358279287815,
0.4513896107673645,
-0.48614105582237244,
0.3378468453884125,
-0.4438101053237915,
0.6583757400512695,
-0.11030793935060501,
-0.24474899470806122,
-0.11152096837759018,
-0.696010947227478,
0.2057521492242813,
-0.5380725860595703,
0.6290192604064941,
-0.22878949344158173,
-0.18168075382709503,
0.5808072686195374,
-0.41029247641563416,
0.6033650040626526,
0.3066175580024719,
-0.19180576503276825,
0.0423196516931057,
0.033653225749731064,
0.2977798283100128,
-0.1413954794406891,
-0.14813514053821564,
0.3379844129085541,
0.24487604200839996,
-0.14362198114395142,
-0.6198972463607788,
0.542425811290741,
-0.31510430574417114,
-0.3184922933578491,
-0.279710978269577,
-0.3310799300670624,
-0.13658951222896576,
0.3311874568462372,
0.37893569469451904,
0.5844832062721252,
-0.19310110807418823,
-0.01248387061059475,
0.7097293734550476,
-0.008066833019256592,
0.005538456607609987,
0.31790122389793396,
-0.05916157364845276,
-0.2664421498775482,
0.5671260952949524,
-0.1764173060655594,
0.29827746748924255,
0.6168116927146912,
0.4020007848739624,
-0.28325971961021423,
-0.45460957288742065,
-0.8438418507575989,
0.18199241161346436,
-0.6593077778816223,
-0.09859634190797806,
-0.8766734004020691,
0.04770725220441818,
-0.14330534636974335,
0.07447739690542221,
-0.13173334300518036,
-0.33068203926086426,
-0.13638652861118317,
-0.03792009875178337,
0.4145129323005676,
0.5737971663475037,
0.17626869678497314,
0.07987005263566971,
-1.156237006187439,
0.5341028571128845,
0.07282016426324844,
0.19840025901794434,
-0.17824894189834595,
-0.2832660675048828,
-0.37570369243621826,
-0.029088962823152542,
-0.04717237129807472,
-0.9876431226730347,
0.3579619526863098,
0.3531011641025543,
0.5354263186454773,
0.5458465814590454,
0.052792999893426895,
0.5853762626647949,
-1.024783968925476,
0.5634798407554626,
0.5568175315856934,
-0.9474891424179077,
0.7425786852836609,
-0.2635609805583954,
0.13534489274024963,
0.4805843234062195,
0.3456137180328369,
-0.7375008463859558,
-0.3979485034942627,
-0.5539057850837708,
-0.945722222328186,
0.4497860372066498,
0.14708258211612701,
-0.0447467677295208,
-0.034391436725854874,
0.4195389151573181,
-0.1584528535604477,
0.404609352350235,
-0.1407271772623062,
-0.417836993932724,
0.10923916846513748,
-0.7225509285926819,
0.1222110465168953,
0.17058107256889343,
-0.31653735041618347,
-0.12688733637332916,
0.36970221996307373,
0.11702874302864075,
0.35807347297668457,
0.46944159269332886,
-0.2775440514087677,
-0.3129063844680786,
0.7846821546554565,
0.32348179817199707,
0.6268078088760376,
0.028452778235077858,
0.21106015145778656,
0.034182872623205185,
-0.5687301158905029,
0.2583751082420349,
0.04084773734211922,
-0.19440214335918427,
0.11639993637800217,
0.3838781416416168,
0.4956122040748596,
0.4569626450538635,
-1.014101505279541,
0.3445717394351959,
0.12805409729480743,
-0.1978939026594162,
-0.13652151823043823,
0.1516392081975937,
0.07911751419305801,
0.0791407972574234,
-0.06660807132720947,
-0.16302591562271118,
0.5453916788101196,
-0.5301966071128845,
0.39163386821746826,
0.020801998674869537,
-0.30008670687675476,
-0.3228549361228943,
0.701240599155426,
-0.013553345575928688,
-0.2095678597688675,
0.39919736981391907,
0.127597376704216,
-0.5482529401779175,
0.4539240002632141,
0.6000093817710876,
0.7129444479942322,
-0.2946012616157532,
0.02933373861014843,
0.34993693232536316,
-0.018032196909189224,
-0.57813560962677,
0.14057454466819763,
0.10929940640926361,
-0.6846211552619934,
-0.31166523694992065,
-0.5368380546569824,
-0.5301274657249451,
-0.0505184568464756,
-0.9959445595741272,
0.13892759382724762,
-0.5802825689315796,
-0.4739883840084076,
0.22817690670490265,
-0.5002409815788269,
-0.6077220439910889,
0.1492549329996109,
0.4430808126926422,
0.5593987107276917,
-0.7796530723571777,
0.687860369682312,
1.0804343223571777,
-0.11484035104513168,
-0.7700458765029907,
-0.14728009700775146,
0.4035564363002777,
-0.6474830508232117,
0.6727275252342224,
-0.043739888817071915,
-0.12279674410820007,
0.06051526963710785,
-0.2948140799999237,
-0.29123038053512573,
0.8798988461494446,
0.11404216289520264,
-0.82215815782547,
-0.17165088653564453,
0.02065335586667061,
0.48834228515625,
-0.3885094225406647,
0.14668191969394684,
0.8290840983390808,
0.5296618938446045,
-0.13948430120944977,
-0.8840800523757935,
0.172464057803154,
-0.4824158251285553,
-0.07511565089225769,
0.2817036211490631,
-0.06891775876283646,
0.7754504680633545,
-0.36865371465682983,
-0.2983579933643341,
0.10097141563892365,
-0.00722669530659914,
0.35575222969055176,
0.4822239577770233,
0.3023950159549713,
0.6994954347610474,
0.8839245438575745,
0.037960540503263474,
1.1194137334823608,
-0.41690200567245483,
0.4263977110385895,
0.9938275218009949,
-0.4421897530555725,
1.1497266292572021,
0.4973677694797516,
-0.17784681916236877,
0.7272431254386902,
0.5258426070213318,
-0.016278112307190895,
0.2890672981739044,
-0.004751367028802633,
-0.40880995988845825,
-0.30230408906936646,
0.10140452533960342,
-0.21709932386875153,
0.12429390847682953,
0.8077394366264343,
-0.4734678864479065,
-0.15976272523403168,
0.00964314490556717,
0.20630685985088348,
-0.19131474196910858,
-0.34395092725753784,
0.9790803790092468,
0.3621937334537506,
-0.31182682514190674,
0.5727511048316956,
0.034225303679704666,
0.21966753900051117,
-0.5939426422119141,
-0.26042935252189636,
0.3783043920993805,
0.11853449046611786,
-0.30635619163513184,
-0.39901190996170044,
-0.19652564823627472,
0.07483760267496109,
-0.19180156290531158,
-0.02320600114762783,
0.5474376082420349,
-0.5432467460632324,
-0.5392427444458008,
-0.0054481253027915955,
0.6983585953712463,
0.26134467124938965,
-0.1186683177947998,
-0.9598492383956909,
-0.08939702063798904,
-0.19445860385894775,
-0.05603460967540741,
0.13607318699359894,
0.5310913324356079,
0.025402897968888283,
0.6897646188735962,
0.8805153369903564,
0.6959842443466187,
-0.22573278844356537,
-0.04262343794107437,
0.723230242729187,
-0.49790993332862854,
-0.7814074158668518,
-1.1651318073272705,
0.36459916830062866,
-0.007971960119903088,
-0.0974341407418251,
0.4892089068889618,
0.49967020750045776,
0.4664776027202606,
-0.04124179109930992,
0.8103777170181274,
0.1290801763534546,
0.6479590535163879,
-0.7934256792068481,
0.8674083948135376,
-0.5103158950805664,
0.3085879385471344,
-0.27332407236099243,
-0.5622140765190125,
-0.5044156312942505,
0.5284247398376465,
-0.29276373982429504,
-0.3521367013454437,
0.7608118653297424,
0.4207308888435364,
-0.03280942142009735,
-0.04898868128657341,
0.4093037545681,
0.2123280018568039,
0.18795694410800934,
0.5618144869804382,
0.6532807350158691,
-0.21636252105236053,
-0.08996085822582245,
-0.15111896395683289,
-0.3537808954715729,
-0.3854185938835144,
-0.63130122423172,
-0.8226458430290222,
-0.17018558084964752,
-0.35200661420822144,
-0.2304476797580719,
0.07942936569452286,
1.743513822555542,
0.7836902141571045,
-0.9543954133987427,
0.05377364903688431,
0.2572683095932007,
-0.18191275000572205,
-0.17242448031902313,
-0.08623333275318146,
0.48387274146080017,
-0.21592861413955688,
-0.5936962962150574,
0.09875252097845078,
0.49346280097961426,
0.01410993468016386,
0.22944657504558563,
0.034081194549798965,
0.27062296867370605,
-0.11986076086759567,
0.6485349535942078,
0.34271368384361267,
-0.7619494795799255,
0.23333172500133514,
-0.058335836976766586,
-0.14085917174816132,
0.3374621868133545,
1.112206220626831,
-0.4338932931423187,
0.7102696299552917,
0.25268545746803284,
0.7305903434753418,
0.19345614314079285,
0.2168550193309784,
0.40190136432647705,
-0.2183016687631607,
0.01598452404141426,
0.36161214113235474,
0.526862382888794,
0.24884484708309174,
-0.4114251732826233,
0.061718281358480453,
0.0017503357958048582,
-0.271659255027771,
-0.5299838781356812,
-0.008002100512385368,
-0.7435905337333679,
-0.4035507142543793,
1.1703296899795532,
-0.30768758058547974,
-0.495169073343277,
-0.39569640159606934,
-0.05794084444642067,
0.06830368936061859,
-0.471334844827652,
0.7064082026481628,
0.39928874373435974,
-0.372566282749176,
-0.07655443996191025,
-0.9337336421012878,
0.3615070581436157,
0.05781395360827446,
-1.1966516971588135,
-0.031134163960814476,
0.5860466957092285,
0.48423370718955994,
0.16599300503730774,
0.7660182118415833,
-0.46638384461402893,
0.27350321412086487,
-0.332966148853302,
0.16534414887428284,
0.001846670638769865,
0.002655048156157136,
-0.4849396347999573,
-0.04082632437348366,
-0.10859263688325882,
-0.07810579240322113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00219v1 | Evaluating Human Alignment and Model Faithfulness of LLM Rationale | 2024-06-28T20:06:30 | 2024-06-28T20:06:30 | Mohsen Fayyaz, Fan Yin, Jiao Sun, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study how well large language models (LLMs) explain their generations with
rationales -- a set of tokens extracted from the input texts that reflect the
decision process of LLMs. We examine LLM rationales extracted with two methods:
1) attribution-based methods that use attention or gradients to locate
important tokens, and 2) prompting-based methods that guide LLMs to extract
rationales using prompts. Through extensive experiments, we show that
prompting-based rationales align better with human-annotated rationales than
attribution-based rationales, and demonstrate reasonable alignment with humans
even when model performance is poor. We additionally find that the faithfulness
limitations of prompting-based methods, which are identified in previous work,
may be linked to their collapsed predictions. By fine-tuning these models on
the corresponding datasets, both prompting and attribution methods demonstrate
improved faithfulness. Our study sheds light on more rigorous and fair
evaluations of LLM rationales, especially for prompting-based ones. | [
-0.20976465940475464,
-0.6581834554672241,
0.910355806350708,
0.10846724361181259,
-0.15959253907203674,
-0.14547327160835266,
-0.32217827439308167,
-0.27645745873451233,
-0.24469339847564697,
0.4343387186527252,
-0.9002410173416138,
-0.17416371405124664,
-0.25224727392196655,
0.2637668550014496,
-0.28023359179496765,
0.5666812658309937,
-0.15896546840667725,
0.4632423222064972,
-0.4976543188095093,
-0.11137151718139648,
-0.5786994099617004,
-0.36254581809043884,
-0.6986827254295349,
-0.6595900654792786,
0.7217221856117249,
0.3364144563674927,
0.7817449569702148,
1.1618403196334839,
0.3568545877933502,
0.24419595301151276,
-0.23733288049697876,
0.20180609822273254,
-0.43356725573539734,
0.1335890144109726,
-0.43975380063056946,
-0.39224764704704285,
-0.30813276767730713,
0.38547831773757935,
0.5090675354003906,
0.6827539205551147,
-0.1177067756652832,
0.37450551986694336,
0.22130180895328522,
0.5745185017585754,
-0.45119509100914,
-0.25824588537216187,
-0.6760097146034241,
-0.28748586773872375,
-0.05326591432094574,
-0.30363965034484863,
-0.6077073216438293,
-0.549708902835846,
0.2141937017440796,
-0.5505460500717163,
0.11954185366630554,
0.2434890866279602,
0.9811535477638245,
0.2789316177368164,
-0.3460065424442291,
-0.34388527274131775,
-0.5077698230743408,
1.2145485877990723,
-0.8125857710838318,
0.42326632142066956,
0.3719712793827057,
0.25863927602767944,
-0.46352681517601013,
-0.3787412941455841,
-0.5181973576545715,
-0.2946337163448334,
-0.021944105625152588,
-0.11700840294361115,
0.01517244428396225,
-0.019275713711977005,
0.5504938960075378,
0.19526778161525726,
-0.4277634918689728,
0.30488407611846924,
-0.16345728933811188,
-0.37866678833961487,
0.6444723606109619,
0.20236599445343018,
0.2365315705537796,
-0.23325155675411224,
-0.6394553184509277,
-0.10037756711244583,
-0.8715044260025024,
0.038185231387615204,
0.6339854598045349,
0.29807931184768677,
0.11156413704156876,
0.8510943055152893,
-0.03185461834073067,
0.7916589379310608,
0.18954408168792725,
-0.3388838768005371,
-0.14965634047985077,
-0.5724965929985046,
-0.12366528809070587,
0.003916846588253975,
0.7653893828392029,
0.6347900629043579,
0.7052825689315796,
-0.2866747975349426,
-0.35745370388031006,
0.15702055394649506,
0.18246440589427948,
-0.4515310525894165,
0.22103634476661682,
0.1795302778482437,
-0.7092148661613464,
-0.34992340207099915,
-0.05025520920753479,
-0.6312592625617981,
-0.5607313513755798,
-0.8646478652954102,
0.19675026834011078,
-0.3457137644290924,
0.08404501527547836,
0.07261507958173752,
-0.1149449422955513,
0.6160484552383423,
0.5472491979598999,
-1.0530234575271606,
0.09037645906209946,
0.9944255948066711,
0.6824601888656616,
-0.36725738644599915,
-0.3116506040096283,
-0.516298234462738,
0.11423739790916443,
-0.2995969355106354,
0.816578209400177,
-0.5037305951118469,
-0.18346354365348816,
-0.014336426742374897,
-0.05116216838359833,
-0.10155995190143585,
-0.6635484099388123,
0.9115375876426697,
-0.4774218499660492,
0.3467700779438019,
-0.7203658819198608,
-0.790348470211029,
-0.2635626792907715,
0.2542535364627838,
-0.6433350443840027,
0.7553458213806152,
-0.039027102291584015,
-0.610634982585907,
0.4783015847206116,
-0.6017544865608215,
-0.10897491127252579,
-0.13612857460975647,
-0.22361890971660614,
-0.18062162399291992,
0.17149019241333008,
0.38428574800491333,
0.36572661995887756,
-0.6080523133277893,
0.433351069688797,
-0.5339286923408508,
-0.1928023397922516,
0.6708285808563232,
-0.8980873227119446,
1.1951322555541992,
0.2652542293071747,
-0.15905021131038666,
0.3260628283023834,
-0.5204134583473206,
-0.049114424735307693,
0.17922937870025635,
-0.3493826687335968,
-0.05915045738220215,
0.21094083786010742,
-0.12088394910097122,
0.1519407480955124,
0.30156293511390686,
-0.3787091374397278,
0.42228779196739197,
-0.29372623562812805,
0.5193684101104736,
0.9397449493408203,
-0.11400031298398972,
0.6114276647567749,
-0.5428282618522644,
0.5806644558906555,
-0.14382994174957275,
0.20306707918643951,
-0.31580060720443726,
-0.38969191908836365,
-0.4640076756477356,
-0.24237008392810822,
0.4561394453048706,
0.42859482765197754,
-0.22113923728466034,
0.3672618269920349,
-0.41768839955329895,
-0.15977782011032104,
-0.6661091446876526,
0.21231584250926971,
0.3138498067855835,
0.7965317368507385,
0.05852889269590378,
-0.10023479908704758,
-0.6019099354743958,
-1.0924254655838013,
-0.5088918805122375,
-0.39831316471099854,
-0.16816510260105133,
0.15903736650943756,
0.34133094549179077,
-0.24379827082157135,
1.2313334941864014,
-0.11037494987249374,
0.3050450086593628,
-0.05661768466234207,
0.2043994665145874,
-0.10430514812469482,
0.5142219662666321,
0.2903498709201813,
-0.5612885355949402,
-0.19239814579486847,
-0.09150020033121109,
-0.751106858253479,
-0.3068811595439911,
-0.22200870513916016,
-0.23782965540885925,
0.30864718556404114,
0.42594900727272034,
-0.7393960952758789,
0.36109405755996704,
0.3442709147930145,
-0.3926090598106384,
0.7748066782951355,
0.1908639818429947,
0.15099631249904633,
-0.9370653033256531,
0.17558351159095764,
0.07641244679689407,
-0.40360918641090393,
-0.44580206274986267,
-0.0729433223605156,
0.17281658947467804,
0.21311497688293457,
-0.3303050100803375,
0.7302305102348328,
-0.5395522117614746,
-0.25871381163597107,
-0.18109917640686035,
0.21413718163967133,
0.1534910351037979,
0.10484667122364044,
-0.1539400964975357,
0.9154137969017029,
0.2305537611246109,
-0.3187100291252136,
0.42231816053390503,
0.1973593831062317,
-0.3491843640804291,
0.5272618532180786,
-0.5788846015930176,
0.25289779901504517,
-0.1504102200269699,
0.24008139967918396,
-0.9025232195854187,
-0.4335378408432007,
0.2882382571697235,
-0.4603056311607361,
0.12847945094108582,
-0.21141450107097626,
-0.4944474995136261,
-0.27390408515930176,
-0.48002302646636963,
0.4357311427593231,
0.6281824111938477,
-0.6562222838401794,
0.722458004951477,
0.03194732591509819,
-0.12524442374706268,
-0.628802478313446,
-0.4207058250904083,
-0.03953051194548607,
-0.6715118885040283,
-0.8312395811080933,
0.19170965254306793,
-0.06473880261182785,
-0.6291785836219788,
-0.11731211841106415,
-0.03777223080396652,
0.0804646760225296,
0.2685422897338867,
0.16886745393276215,
0.598145067691803,
-0.4981894791126251,
-0.1316213607788086,
-0.20807775855064392,
-0.12216993421316147,
0.3406234383583069,
-0.11998110264539719,
0.5861195921897888,
0.04005046561360359,
-0.5827356576919556,
-0.7544974088668823,
0.1687132567167282,
0.7434457540512085,
-0.0547642856836319,
0.6657764315605164,
0.274203896522522,
-0.5350667238235474,
0.1725739985704422,
-0.9290054440498352,
-0.46366825699806213,
-0.4573271572589874,
-0.0052556139416992664,
0.005948323290795088,
-0.7374191880226135,
0.8126402497291565,
-0.06536702811717987,
0.20320773124694824,
0.5157625079154968,
0.7248983383178711,
-0.20614305138587952,
1.4322127103805542,
0.4091157615184784,
-0.05212365835905075,
0.3874496817588806,
0.2788136899471283,
-0.08836112916469574,
-0.929767370223999,
-0.38954848051071167,
-0.5835372805595398,
-0.2308184802532196,
-0.1804584115743637,
-0.2511221468448639,
-0.30629587173461914,
0.5895844101905823,
-0.20756787061691284,
0.0885045975446701,
-0.37034448981285095,
0.7625120282173157,
0.3765889108181,
-0.1409972459077835,
0.3270750045776367,
0.0653286948800087,
-0.009223801083862782,
-0.1557801365852356,
-0.5370824337005615,
-1.187988519668579,
1.0151654481887817,
0.684812068939209,
0.8706481456756592,
0.013815084472298622,
0.5281998515129089,
-0.06702229380607605,
0.6121713519096375,
-0.965936005115509,
0.3909453749656677,
0.28078094124794006,
-0.6782402992248535,
-0.4293844401836395,
-0.42548447847366333,
-1.0085251331329346,
0.0682973712682724,
-0.14098545908927917,
-1.0108810663223267,
0.15480093657970428,
0.32677969336509705,
-0.5707011818885803,
-0.05575519800186157,
-0.8440292477607727,
0.8898122310638428,
-0.4510115683078766,
-0.31953340768814087,
-0.046906933188438416,
-0.6085546016693115,
0.45165467262268066,
-0.11224301159381866,
0.13027389347553253,
-0.2836206257343292,
-0.050720009952783585,
0.8417980670928955,
-0.36579227447509766,
0.7119081616401672,
-0.07998201996088028,
-0.4875205457210541,
0.26645469665527344,
-0.03356589004397392,
0.5721426606178284,
-0.020969338715076447,
-0.3005954623222351,
-0.02565884403884411,
-0.09641393274068832,
-0.33472496271133423,
-0.794924259185791,
0.6631794571876526,
-0.5115243196487427,
-0.8027504682540894,
-0.16498848795890808,
-0.7061564326286316,
-0.21724066138267517,
0.16936011612415314,
0.232974112033844,
0.31604859232902527,
-0.0836101546883583,
0.07807828485965729,
0.6456239223480225,
-0.0022303371224552393,
0.2402789145708084,
0.39144548773765564,
-0.37932002544403076,
-0.3770158886909485,
0.7419141530990601,
0.012731874361634254,
0.4002673923969269,
-0.15023386478424072,
0.40773943066596985,
-0.6553550958633423,
-0.48820480704307556,
-0.6674817800521851,
0.37806224822998047,
-0.8751477003097534,
-0.16248415410518646,
-0.2133225053548813,
0.12861785292625427,
-0.39347943663597107,
-0.27372440695762634,
-0.16629545390605927,
-0.2232193648815155,
-0.5854860544204712,
0.023201508447527885,
0.1956436187028885,
0.7868078351020813,
0.22441153228282928,
0.12999875843524933,
-0.816098153591156,
0.09926701337099075,
0.28637614846229553,
0.14591416716575623,
0.10851460695266724,
-0.7252384424209595,
0.11212921887636185,
0.29059892892837524,
-0.34946563839912415,
-1.0214439630508423,
0.15488947927951813,
-0.16262590885162354,
0.6436724662780762,
0.5376178026199341,
-0.14686991274356842,
0.9673975110054016,
-0.4953126311302185,
0.8285918235778809,
0.22589179873466492,
-1.03102445602417,
0.34905779361724854,
-0.5183019638061523,
0.13072150945663452,
0.7096735239028931,
0.22669076919555664,
-0.32892778515815735,
-0.019464140757918358,
-0.5715495347976685,
-0.607499361038208,
0.7672331929206848,
0.12166733294725418,
0.034356337040662766,
0.10694407671689987,
0.8902587294578552,
0.10359395295381546,
-0.10645027458667755,
-0.7278067469596863,
-0.04789896681904793,
0.15258243680000305,
-0.5732533931732178,
0.18635857105255127,
-0.37561434507369995,
-0.33652135729789734,
-0.24378807842731476,
0.4976445138454437,
-0.2104451060295105,
0.06983650475740433,
0.1215105801820755,
-0.043013058602809906,
-0.5634661912918091,
0.20460940897464752,
0.9145288467407227,
0.9352098107337952,
0.027221759781241417,
0.037801094353199005,
0.24873894453048706,
-0.04648049548268318,
0.21345001459121704,
-0.0655268132686615,
-0.22909808158874512,
-0.23700019717216492,
0.5625515580177307,
0.6312879920005798,
0.007591099012643099,
-0.7744751572608948,
0.6043571829795837,
-0.21396587789058685,
-0.18515567481517792,
-0.10260353982448578,
-0.035677116364240646,
0.277627557516098,
0.38759055733680725,
0.24131329357624054,
0.012179301120340824,
-0.04850400611758232,
-0.4981968402862549,
0.0360264852643013,
0.7631192803382874,
-0.31873413920402527,
-0.3273337781429291,
0.7538249492645264,
0.025158602744340897,
-0.5577901005744934,
0.7020333409309387,
0.022527698427438736,
-0.6067947745323181,
0.4826507866382599,
0.5983029007911682,
0.8844725489616394,
-0.12528520822525024,
-0.01722506806254387,
0.28495651483535767,
0.20657604932785034,
-0.5605745315551758,
0.19112412631511688,
0.09509185701608658,
-0.7696293592453003,
-0.8853957056999207,
-0.5474211573600769,
-0.3639809787273407,
0.052700288593769073,
-0.7800531387329102,
0.36147749423980713,
-0.13057565689086914,
-0.14647425711154938,
0.10455667227506638,
-0.24018046259880066,
-0.3754880428314209,
-0.026409609243273735,
0.303250253200531,
0.9931021332740784,
-0.8427192568778992,
0.691037654876709,
0.7006465196609497,
-0.3090878427028656,
-1.1551169157028198,
0.21646632254123688,
0.16136112809181213,
-0.9460746049880981,
0.6293594241142273,
0.29759225249290466,
-0.12442319095134735,
-0.05401621013879776,
-1.0066585540771484,
-0.904996931552887,
1.175195336341858,
0.9778500199317932,
-0.5763235092163086,
-0.007685160730034113,
-0.06482009589672089,
0.40406233072280884,
-0.35914912819862366,
0.04424605518579483,
0.609857976436615,
0.7319347262382507,
0.13747696578502655,
-0.8579549193382263,
0.1303454041481018,
0.11505598574876785,
-0.084714874625206,
0.10233712196350098,
-0.35090070962905884,
0.6606695652008057,
-0.2328270673751831,
-0.3884861171245575,
0.30901116132736206,
0.6769984364509583,
0.6042930483818054,
0.3297068178653717,
0.5741389989852905,
0.44157513976097107,
0.9550667405128479,
-0.17488057911396027,
1.184893250465393,
-0.028488732874393463,
0.35943686962127686,
0.8385084867477417,
-0.3512023687362671,
0.7422485947608948,
0.8794645071029663,
-0.15335674583911896,
0.4837673008441925,
0.8241137266159058,
0.11314951628446579,
0.23418059945106506,
0.1491032987833023,
-0.02825094573199749,
-0.42943617701530457,
-0.2884370684623718,
0.013917514123022556,
0.10361825674772263,
0.14030276238918304,
-0.5108007192611694,
-0.00648563401773572,
-0.39879825711250305,
0.02640254609286785,
0.023138154298067093,
-0.25089144706726074,
0.9041315317153931,
0.16942408680915833,
-1.226407766342163,
0.6177318096160889,
-0.034013886004686356,
0.4343804717063904,
-0.322710782289505,
0.04160445183515549,
-0.004436188843101263,
-0.02113189734518528,
-0.3325147032737732,
-0.7586778402328491,
0.17166590690612793,
0.10695469379425049,
-0.37391114234924316,
-0.3686203956604004,
0.7339963316917419,
-0.46622398495674133,
-0.24986602365970612,
0.03539073094725609,
0.35709816217422485,
0.04729654639959335,
0.1496531367301941,
-0.8198387026786804,
0.1932222992181778,
0.2348393201828003,
-0.47828400135040283,
0.19438107311725616,
0.48336702585220337,
-0.3389633297920227,
0.794605553150177,
0.8280729651451111,
-0.034245170652866364,
0.12056154757738113,
0.1676473319530487,
0.70847487449646,
-0.6486138701438904,
0.0828971415758133,
-1.357283353805542,
0.6009091138839722,
-0.1278843730688095,
-0.21524247527122498,
0.8428066968917847,
0.4993007183074951,
0.5612770915031433,
0.10175751894712448,
0.5690229535102844,
0.37290236353874207,
0.397543728351593,
-0.7954732775688171,
0.36316946148872375,
-0.46449053287506104,
0.40404754877090454,
0.0038593579083681107,
-1.1647075414657593,
-0.2592049539089203,
0.7666196823120117,
-0.4023040235042572,
0.04620465636253357,
0.514134407043457,
0.8992852568626404,
0.010037620551884174,
0.16301359236240387,
0.03304486349225044,
-0.1835843175649643,
0.20242823660373688,
0.1311134248971939,
1.3447767496109009,
-0.04553576186299324,
0.24309104681015015,
0.03356371447443962,
-0.1405741423368454,
-0.22385168075561523,
-1.1741269826889038,
-0.7723944783210754,
-0.254488468170166,
-0.24892504513263702,
-0.37833380699157715,
-0.16733966767787933,
1.3102277517318726,
0.3923622667789459,
-0.7510907649993896,
-0.14556781947612762,
-0.23865732550621033,
0.20305703580379486,
-0.03041420318186283,
-0.2044757902622223,
0.2622188329696655,
-0.3838317096233368,
-0.5917495489120483,
0.29857590794563293,
0.16999074816703796,
0.27243292331695557,
-0.47778379917144775,
-0.4683056175708771,
0.051037631928920746,
0.18288594484329224,
0.3470248878002167,
0.19443845748901367,
-1.2213953733444214,
-0.39861780405044556,
0.1760740727186203,
-0.3448668122291565,
0.028210384771227837,
0.935600996017456,
-0.5490610599517822,
0.23853565752506256,
0.60636305809021,
0.5610548257827759,
-0.19679030776023865,
0.6065928936004639,
0.9257106781005859,
-0.4553048610687256,
-0.19270457327365875,
0.3115219175815582,
0.5449814200401306,
0.4953726828098297,
-0.20991715788841248,
0.3654566705226898,
0.057484012097120285,
-0.8439554572105408,
-1.049260139465332,
0.2377614676952362,
-0.9921035170555115,
-0.09669613838195801,
1.4457035064697266,
-0.08247868716716766,
-0.35326290130615234,
-0.24093611538410187,
-0.4437757432460785,
0.26657965779304504,
-0.35674306750297546,
0.7333604693412781,
1.0067336559295654,
-0.1359199583530426,
0.009662889875471592,
-0.4370378255844116,
0.46183323860168457,
0.7392532825469971,
-0.58046954870224,
0.5543628334999084,
0.6697756052017212,
0.20038101077079773,
0.18284304440021515,
0.31756412982940674,
-0.26321545243263245,
0.22184692323207855,
-0.42635107040405273,
-0.10108231753110886,
0.20242084562778473,
-0.026674820110201836,
-0.7211679220199585,
-0.16976557672023773,
0.5086263418197632,
0.2381879687309265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00211v1 | Detection and Measurement of Syntactic Templates in Generated Text | 2024-06-28T19:34:23 | 2024-06-28T19:34:23 | Chantal Shaib, Yanai Elazar, Junyi Jessy Li, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work on evaluating the diversity of text generated by LLMs has focused
on word-level features. Here we offer an analysis of syntactic features to
characterize general repetition in models, beyond frequent n-grams.
Specifically, we define syntactic templates and show that models tend to
produce templated text in downstream tasks at a higher rate than what is found
in human-reference texts. We find that most (76%) templates in model-generated
text can be found in pre-training data (compared to only 35% of human-authored
text), and are not overwritten during fine-tuning processes such as RLHF. This
connection to the pre-training data allows us to analyze syntactic templates in
models where we do not have the pre-training data. We also find that templates
as features are able to differentiate between models, tasks, and domains, and
are useful for qualitatively evaluating common model constructions. Finally, we
demonstrate the use of templates as a useful tool for analyzing style
memorization of training data in LLMs. | [
-0.17558075487613678,
-0.6422775983810425,
0.6706771850585938,
-0.042872898280620575,
-0.49626588821411133,
-0.0686422660946846,
-0.13748633861541748,
-0.15367718040943146,
0.3802250325679779,
0.5907881855964661,
-0.436038076877594,
-0.746109127998352,
-0.5372263193130493,
0.41230127215385437,
-0.922491192817688,
0.9947140216827393,
-0.2692825198173523,
0.1873200684785843,
-0.3832254707813263,
-0.14662347733974457,
-0.25245097279548645,
-0.8354142904281616,
-0.3062379062175751,
-0.12393171340227127,
0.4835861921310425,
-0.03561137244105339,
0.1366180181503296,
0.7453247904777527,
0.28913164138793945,
0.24497734010219574,
-0.16255073249340057,
0.15011967718601227,
-0.28503525257110596,
0.4193868935108185,
-0.09867890924215317,
-0.5724360346794128,
-0.6614524722099304,
0.18069806694984436,
0.9513281583786011,
0.6384577751159668,
-0.19160014390945435,
0.27257058024406433,
0.26528313755989075,
0.45393094420433044,
-0.457805335521698,
-0.057005807757377625,
-0.8044759035110474,
0.15343326330184937,
-0.6545026898384094,
-0.3412804901599884,
-0.22215257585048676,
-0.19799357652664185,
-0.07803273946046829,
-0.48913273215293884,
0.5904052257537842,
0.07235393673181534,
0.6762774586677551,
-0.1581960916519165,
-0.49067455530166626,
-0.6259260177612305,
-0.651055634021759,
0.8472409248352051,
-0.5961436033248901,
0.43706241250038147,
-0.03508612886071205,
0.14710837602615356,
-0.2805718183517456,
-1.0623551607131958,
-0.8630157709121704,
-0.25399547815322876,
-0.05181608721613884,
0.09114166349172592,
-0.3016647398471832,
-0.1889270693063736,
0.275135338306427,
0.6044775247573853,
-0.5897861123085022,
0.19389818608760834,
-0.16115066409111023,
-0.25390562415122986,
0.4102931022644043,
0.5848192572593689,
0.5112482309341431,
-0.11930135637521744,
-0.17176377773284912,
-0.0868268758058548,
-0.7336776256561279,
-0.1869330257177353,
0.604216456413269,
0.09339901804924011,
-0.16227033734321594,
0.49519097805023193,
0.06824151426553726,
0.9044257998466492,
-0.3835185170173645,
-0.37162041664123535,
0.17014561593532562,
-0.8241860270500183,
-0.20578670501708984,
-0.3021533191204071,
0.7021203637123108,
0.16180425882339478,
0.5813201665878296,
-0.14961358904838562,
-0.472256064414978,
-0.030441271141171455,
0.38520532846450806,
-0.4853909909725189,
-0.11732269078493118,
-0.26572635769844055,
-0.4661373794078827,
-0.489991158246994,
0.003503083251416683,
-0.26296672224998474,
-0.3432371914386749,
-0.2739724814891815,
-0.07452942430973053,
-0.44240841269493103,
-0.12077649682760239,
0.15561555325984955,
-0.5279873609542847,
0.07988792657852173,
0.2752295434474945,
-0.7989339828491211,
0.2973825931549072,
0.7458894848823547,
0.8483843207359314,
-0.35432177782058716,
-0.41328543424606323,
-0.18125861883163452,
0.1387508362531662,
-0.4450284540653229,
0.9058413505554199,
-0.3607329726219177,
-0.3811202049255371,
-0.044216055423021317,
-0.14732585847377777,
-0.16730113327503204,
-0.7941874265670776,
0.2383272498846054,
-0.0991036593914032,
0.35516780614852905,
-0.1733982414007187,
-0.9686227440834045,
0.020012039691209793,
0.2860720157623291,
-0.5885599851608276,
1.01572847366333,
0.4220545291900635,
-0.9086130857467651,
0.8212407827377319,
-0.12869657576084137,
-0.3748103976249695,
0.03328503668308258,
-0.4144608974456787,
-0.4159512221813202,
0.47706541419029236,
-0.05002179741859436,
0.4579438865184784,
-0.3778560161590576,
0.26864856481552124,
-0.3710864782333374,
-0.40744853019714355,
0.4188539683818817,
-0.20910030603408813,
0.24779585003852844,
0.19608785212039948,
-0.0010657282546162605,
0.16154158115386963,
-0.9818397164344788,
-0.05305473506450653,
0.36884644627571106,
-0.6088027358055115,
-0.2437128722667694,
-0.10725890845060349,
0.20775097608566284,
0.08149626106023788,
0.1356535255908966,
-0.30711838603019714,
0.18774884939193726,
-0.1514103263616562,
0.3352227210998535,
0.481834352016449,
0.3736972510814667,
0.07891707867383957,
-0.5936776399612427,
0.8785229325294495,
0.2967577278614044,
-0.21933436393737793,
-0.34953203797340393,
-0.3170621693134308,
-0.7922537922859192,
-0.24428822100162506,
0.038356855511665344,
0.22811082005500793,
-0.414931982755661,
0.6330231428146362,
-0.19714462757110596,
-0.4951684772968292,
-0.3618758022785187,
0.50309157371521,
0.5540310740470886,
0.3362746238708496,
0.22513329982757568,
-0.7117725014686584,
-0.683579683303833,
-0.9862403869628906,
-0.6910689473152161,
0.1044168472290039,
-0.1987566202878952,
0.09030403196811676,
0.5046936273574829,
0.15235716104507446,
0.9505970478057861,
-0.2878516912460327,
-0.10811477899551392,
-0.8120847344398499,
0.33347463607788086,
0.061198849231004715,
0.28549763560295105,
0.885783851146698,
-0.449799120426178,
-0.4364742636680603,
-0.36214444041252136,
-0.8137227892875671,
-0.2838421165943146,
-0.13936829566955566,
0.3627789318561554,
0.20875412225723267,
0.7522076368331909,
-0.32778388261795044,
0.431986927986145,
0.3171314001083374,
-0.1648632287979126,
0.6497731804847717,
-0.09673750400543213,
-0.21460101008415222,
-1.2220345735549927,
0.26419147849082947,
0.19157177209854126,
-0.21108093857765198,
-0.774133026599884,
-0.17165647447109222,
-0.0740019902586937,
-0.011575664393603802,
-0.40218618512153625,
0.7612917423248291,
-0.555335283279419,
-0.37368103861808777,
-0.17740188539028168,
0.16061657667160034,
0.35475438833236694,
0.11387338489294052,
-0.11391592770814896,
0.9467372298240662,
0.07905126363039017,
-0.47244417667388916,
0.22148096561431885,
-0.13988377153873444,
-0.7996180653572083,
0.45473310351371765,
-0.5337511301040649,
0.28472447395324707,
-0.15089446306228638,
0.35606715083122253,
-0.9223185777664185,
-0.0022599422372877598,
0.09973209351301193,
-0.20093420147895813,
0.16995610296726227,
-0.24811674654483795,
-0.925508975982666,
-0.17785263061523438,
-0.23668725788593292,
0.1546224057674408,
0.41671305894851685,
-0.03062300942838192,
0.20225873589515686,
0.2766234874725342,
-0.03882330656051636,
-0.1324997991323471,
-0.31380629539489746,
0.04563555866479874,
-0.3354623317718506,
-0.3986186385154724,
0.1212005466222763,
0.1841544359922409,
-0.13327531516551971,
-0.24873296916484833,
-0.18966764211654663,
0.18329143524169922,
0.519747257232666,
0.07044629007577896,
0.0453147366642952,
-0.2983162999153137,
0.031182385981082916,
-0.1098082959651947,
0.16106626391410828,
0.02841089852154255,
-0.4866761267185211,
1.072996973991394,
0.04609435051679611,
-0.4696718752384186,
-0.35175931453704834,
0.21930983662605286,
0.3823060393333435,
-0.19321253895759583,
0.6085026264190674,
0.7383690476417542,
-0.31550461053848267,
-0.3038809895515442,
-0.47397544980049133,
0.049593325704336166,
-0.44860097765922546,
0.6003049612045288,
-0.2389543354511261,
-0.6893303394317627,
0.5961449146270752,
0.24564242362976074,
-0.14202986657619476,
0.3793099820613861,
0.5630412697792053,
-0.3244464695453644,
0.7186117172241211,
0.7368438839912415,
0.08200668543577194,
0.6883327960968018,
-0.030623244121670723,
0.09406983852386475,
-0.800660252571106,
-0.21543045341968536,
-0.46776896715164185,
-0.4696718454360962,
-0.5654343366622925,
-0.25997886061668396,
0.39550819993019104,
0.3214165270328522,
-0.13018691539764404,
0.1957128942012787,
-0.29757940769195557,
0.35874608159065247,
0.5948376059532166,
-0.2444005310535431,
0.15822309255599976,
-0.004198594484478235,
-0.37222927808761597,
-0.2714022696018219,
-0.5760625004768372,
-0.710100531578064,
1.1424776315689087,
0.27202194929122925,
0.6356076598167419,
-0.19308102130889893,
1.1557154655456543,
0.06540580093860626,
0.27594685554504395,
-0.5699570178985596,
0.7244622111320496,
-0.44461673498153687,
-0.2811867892742157,
-0.022534538060426712,
-0.31711047887802124,
-0.91227126121521,
-0.1236642524600029,
-0.32406705617904663,
-0.8384940028190613,
-0.1715535968542099,
0.26565614342689514,
-0.094471774995327,
0.4454503357410431,
-0.46073001623153687,
0.8251978754997253,
-0.1760794073343277,
0.07249490171670914,
0.01674061268568039,
-0.014985617250204086,
0.19206148386001587,
-0.11162137985229492,
-0.20187069475650787,
-0.037208620458841324,
-0.0030802174005657434,
0.962857186794281,
-0.10534187406301498,
0.904688835144043,
0.0965561643242836,
-0.26790857315063477,
0.3376682996749878,
0.2156171202659607,
0.3720925748348236,
-0.28072962164878845,
0.1526147574186325,
-0.09046151489019394,
-0.20141713321208954,
-0.08046311885118484,
-0.6643160581588745,
0.42836490273475647,
-0.3222331404685974,
-0.5764904618263245,
-0.29369989037513733,
-0.4916384220123291,
-0.07240861654281616,
0.3359930217266083,
0.4935449957847595,
0.4632358253002167,
-0.33105623722076416,
0.22584815323352814,
0.2741223871707916,
-0.33360061049461365,
0.21627673506736755,
0.28544265031814575,
-0.3572671711444855,
-0.14353789389133453,
0.9221907258033752,
0.22461818158626556,
0.273734986782074,
0.21485495567321777,
0.08702649176120758,
-0.08912776410579681,
-1.0951987504959106,
-0.12228375673294067,
0.18199984729290009,
-0.8063747882843018,
-0.036798298358917236,
-0.8030040264129639,
-0.3492251932621002,
-0.4478607773780823,
-0.10651826113462448,
-0.10380584746599197,
-0.6137194633483887,
-0.5338740944862366,
-0.07768122851848602,
0.17920316755771637,
1.0836193561553955,
0.3650953769683838,
0.47954291105270386,
-0.9008378386497498,
0.09898405522108078,
0.008817384019494057,
0.10731350630521774,
0.08186646550893784,
-0.5424920320510864,
-0.18064315617084503,
-0.430151104927063,
-0.4736306369304657,
-0.8203346133232117,
0.6175879240036011,
0.1419273167848587,
0.5894991755485535,
0.2973434031009674,
-0.5096441507339478,
0.23386447131633759,
-0.3203263580799103,
0.9574729204177856,
0.22864975035190582,
-0.9440801739692688,
0.5664697885513306,
-0.5499979257583618,
0.35999318957328796,
0.28759971261024475,
0.301150918006897,
-0.8202597498893738,
-0.7189387679100037,
-0.7153629660606384,
-0.8550699353218079,
0.3309204578399658,
-0.03903670236468315,
0.27020561695098877,
-0.3846842050552368,
0.5897352695465088,
0.007094572298228741,
0.4878457188606262,
-0.6520102024078369,
-0.1450129747390747,
-0.14141398668289185,
-0.34886252880096436,
-0.025775369256734848,
-0.4578615427017212,
-0.2063276320695877,
0.09410371631383896,
0.13751006126403809,
-0.058584753423929214,
-0.016447288915514946,
-0.19499939680099487,
-0.3143784999847412,
0.1277015060186386,
0.4918614327907562,
0.906018853187561,
0.7456620335578918,
-0.2932216227054596,
0.05188071355223656,
0.06793102622032166,
-0.5159029960632324,
-0.008041595108807087,
-0.37133100628852844,
-0.13968680799007416,
0.26662713289260864,
0.772799551486969,
0.7103105783462524,
0.34386199712753296,
-0.32154762744903564,
0.4169974625110626,
0.026465101167559624,
-0.048941321671009064,
-0.4333927035331726,
0.49069276452064514,
0.24408039450645447,
-0.03235308825969696,
0.12137755006551743,
-0.15068456530570984,
0.04364578425884247,
-0.6922929286956787,
0.3980495035648346,
0.4756222069263458,
-0.19714272022247314,
-0.5981433391571045,
0.3305632174015045,
0.17676302790641785,
-0.3758866786956787,
0.6530285477638245,
-0.20176643133163452,
-0.49488019943237305,
0.7886437773704529,
0.8546919226646423,
0.9080419540405273,
0.21523886919021606,
-0.09339279681444168,
0.2725962698459625,
0.07165119796991348,
0.04545297473669052,
0.4586741328239441,
0.15710385143756866,
-0.9073787331581116,
0.21007439494132996,
-0.9221136569976807,
-0.19791348278522491,
0.448880672454834,
-0.9021791815757751,
0.4158836901187897,
-0.7500765919685364,
-0.19864074885845184,
0.23073485493659973,
-0.23225189745426178,
-0.9415040016174316,
0.13233420252799988,
0.2117636501789093,
0.9404032826423645,
-0.860104501247406,
0.9434762001037598,
0.7165405750274658,
-0.36953482031822205,
-0.600799024105072,
0.02762027457356453,
0.2779625654220581,
-1.003007173538208,
0.9289119243621826,
0.21871547400951385,
-0.035039518028497696,
-0.045987170189619064,
-0.398812472820282,
-0.4767836332321167,
1.2854981422424316,
0.25798556208610535,
-0.5549364686012268,
-0.3695022165775299,
0.19538699090480804,
0.6911651492118835,
-0.6657450795173645,
0.10283283144235611,
0.7626555562019348,
0.23123447597026825,
-0.41879239678382874,
-0.9792187213897705,
-0.0910651832818985,
-0.22086867690086365,
0.29961976408958435,
0.23442207276821136,
-0.23746974766254425,
1.0559533834457397,
0.006951410323381424,
-0.5184670686721802,
0.20183239877223969,
0.39695802330970764,
0.442289799451828,
0.17022718489170074,
0.44552528858184814,
0.7240310311317444,
0.6728929281234741,
0.0341651476919651,
1.1895512342453003,
-0.2370123714208603,
0.2297597974538803,
1.1525968313217163,
-0.37947866320610046,
0.5295542478561401,
0.5509352684020996,
-0.12592971324920654,
0.3906395435333252,
0.2591458857059479,
-0.29121705889701843,
0.1744491159915924,
0.6582366228103638,
-0.14800547063350677,
-0.18764351308345795,
-0.20072953402996063,
-0.35544830560684204,
0.641873300075531,
0.4166530966758728,
-0.624226987361908,
-0.41653433442115784,
-0.20445440709590912,
0.06317121535539627,
0.18686717748641968,
-0.04949427396059036,
1.0051974058151245,
0.345985472202301,
-0.4291248023509979,
0.44433364272117615,
0.05905637890100479,
0.7119914293289185,
-0.6910171508789062,
-0.014401533640921116,
-0.44693687558174133,
0.028134819120168686,
0.1308652013540268,
-0.8736155033111572,
0.29250001907348633,
0.10784389078617096,
-0.2953678071498871,
-0.3958563804626465,
0.5724248886108398,
-0.3638504147529602,
-0.43910151720046997,
0.1622755229473114,
0.7214536666870117,
0.09245851635932922,
0.1282825469970703,
-0.45133018493652344,
-0.0798034742474556,
-0.1349264234304428,
-0.26566416025161743,
0.6777893900871277,
0.5931427478790283,
-0.022533252835273743,
0.6135945916175842,
0.5925433039665222,
0.45212602615356445,
0.11457110941410065,
0.38195928931236267,
0.7406066060066223,
-0.9698710441589355,
-0.48796164989471436,
-0.7798218727111816,
0.2667604982852936,
-0.026680368930101395,
-0.6101408004760742,
0.6543771028518677,
0.49730539321899414,
0.994446337223053,
-0.16559946537017822,
0.8543881177902222,
0.3230976164340973,
0.5013339519500732,
-0.9395791292190552,
0.850916862487793,
-0.575225830078125,
0.40696993470191956,
-0.12566256523132324,
-0.8701906800270081,
-0.17882178723812103,
0.4403667151927948,
-0.09619973599910736,
0.13876590132713318,
0.6652020812034607,
0.6910633444786072,
-0.24987845122814178,
-0.2617323100566864,
0.3014015257358551,
-0.2725605368614197,
0.4846705198287964,
0.25756552815437317,
0.989213764667511,
-0.08652504533529282,
0.27552199363708496,
-0.006628438364714384,
0.3055420517921448,
-0.15308040380477905,
-1.083925724029541,
-0.8499119877815247,
-0.6964187026023865,
-0.13130007684230804,
-0.32806822657585144,
-0.11068489402532578,
0.7145183086395264,
0.33987221121788025,
-0.7239296436309814,
-0.38900136947631836,
-0.007129912730306387,
0.014993632212281227,
-0.014659753069281578,
-0.21604911983013153,
0.06207830458879471,
-0.6074192523956299,
-0.4788491129875183,
0.47760966420173645,
0.34480080008506775,
0.5374564528465271,
-0.20158183574676514,
0.2603985369205475,
-0.010406137444078922,
0.013806725852191448,
0.1250649392604828,
0.03566989302635193,
-0.5909302234649658,
-0.29200297594070435,
0.05614503100514412,
-0.2819346785545349,
0.09073729068040848,
1.496901273727417,
-0.43894338607788086,
0.3397143483161926,
0.5035142302513123,
0.17730697989463806,
0.2862071394920349,
-0.21329599618911743,
0.8768215775489807,
-1.2749354839324951,
0.2447485327720642,
0.27705129981040955,
0.7008009552955627,
0.32336878776550293,
0.0017505696741864085,
0.3627167046070099,
0.5020167231559753,
-0.05808188393712044,
-0.9652490019798279,
0.44441962242126465,
-0.6971127390861511,
-0.10629743337631226,
1.049264907836914,
-0.34855711460113525,
-0.002777362708002329,
-0.07797813415527344,
0.34083569049835205,
0.37032949924468994,
0.018410902470350266,
0.5837802290916443,
0.8620758652687073,
-0.05973348766565323,
-0.12390927970409393,
-0.4934394359588623,
0.6998522877693176,
0.23423831164836884,
-0.8575732111930847,
0.028053490445017815,
0.414066344499588,
0.7087178826332092,
0.16958898305892944,
0.8243149518966675,
-0.1599705070257187,
0.15571388602256775,
-0.05624279007315636,
0.02513209730386734,
-0.25324714183807373,
-0.3363500237464905,
-0.37338486313819885,
-0.07348092645406723,
0.20034295320510864,
0.03195344656705856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00191v1 | MetaKP: On-Demand Keyphrase Generation | 2024-06-28T19:02:59 | 2024-06-28T19:02:59 | Di Wu, Xiaoxian Shen, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional keyphrase prediction methods predict a single set of keyphrases
per document, failing to cater to the diverse needs of users and downstream
applications. To bridge the gap, we introduce on-demand keyphrase generation, a
novel paradigm that requires keyphrases that conform to specific high-level
goals or intents. For this task, we present MetaKP, a large-scale benchmark
comprising four datasets, 7500 documents, and 3760 goals across news and
biomedical domains with human-annotated keyphrases. Leveraging MetaKP, we
design both supervised and unsupervised methods, including a multi-task
fine-tuning approach and a self-consistency prompting method with large
language models. The results highlight the challenges of supervised
fine-tuning, whose performance is not robust to distribution shifts. By
contrast, the proposed self-consistency prompting approach greatly improves the
performance of large language models, enabling GPT-4o to achieve 0.548 SemF1,
surpassing the performance of a fully fine-tuned BART-base model. Finally, we
demonstrate the potential of our method to serve as a general NLP
infrastructure, exemplified by its application in epidemic event detection from
social media. | [
-0.004992553032934666,
-0.39812251925468445,
0.5794470906257629,
0.31707319617271423,
-0.2900640368461609,
0.0383615605533123,
-0.08426660299301147,
-0.09662599116563797,
0.34830641746520996,
0.7460690140724182,
-0.6321730613708496,
-0.5652461647987366,
-0.528852641582489,
0.3706011474132538,
-0.29020488262176514,
0.8100060224533081,
0.15274862945079803,
-0.23348860442638397,
-0.05467631667852402,
-0.0027223017532378435,
-0.3859688341617584,
-0.2375408411026001,
-0.5193155407905579,
-0.21759818494319916,
0.5895416736602783,
0.6718733310699463,
0.6436389088630676,
0.6929673552513123,
0.5638569593429565,
0.08140130341053009,
0.26495739817619324,
0.2927417457103729,
-0.28739672899246216,
0.6958513855934143,
-0.12866318225860596,
-0.009152242913842201,
-0.3480544090270996,
-0.05146752670407295,
0.3042641580104828,
0.5418540835380554,
-0.08877702802419662,
0.15758474171161652,
0.2706216871738434,
0.6920981407165527,
-0.8146731853485107,
0.06764186918735504,
-0.8831545114517212,
0.1495063453912735,
-0.27640801668167114,
-0.369586706161499,
-0.10655832290649414,
-0.14038433134555817,
0.22720329463481903,
-0.5083803534507751,
0.3295818865299225,
-0.22794459760189056,
0.5065203309059143,
0.2942017614841461,
-0.2860054671764374,
-0.3197682499885559,
-0.19070890545845032,
0.3714410662651062,
-0.7113910913467407,
0.5586652755737305,
0.7368698716163635,
0.08894835412502289,
-0.22907239198684692,
-0.9848718643188477,
-0.1876782327890396,
-0.15915368497371674,
0.24192824959754944,
0.16478610038757324,
0.2453201413154602,
0.12080048024654388,
0.014622900635004044,
-0.16999568045139313,
-0.716081976890564,
-0.12747427821159363,
-0.13639673590660095,
-0.13640141487121582,
0.38958632946014404,
0.0835927277803421,
0.10332316160202026,
-0.5509462356567383,
0.16572777926921844,
-0.13613536953926086,
-0.6998330354690552,
-0.12889309227466583,
-0.0708102211356163,
0.5537710785865784,
0.20025703310966492,
0.4617953896522522,
-0.5971579551696777,
0.3519101142883301,
0.2638198733329773,
-0.029756592586636543,
0.2922208607196808,
-0.5103052258491516,
0.00038597144884988666,
0.18548402190208435,
0.8778873682022095,
0.5937680006027222,
0.06975584477186203,
-0.33138227462768555,
0.213826522231102,
-0.13125956058502197,
0.3464960753917694,
-0.9319087266921997,
-0.4705539643764496,
0.3800745904445648,
-0.5484781861305237,
-0.49515098333358765,
-0.2862541377544403,
-1.076921820640564,
-0.23406709730625153,
0.05264061689376831,
0.39868542551994324,
-0.3689626157283783,
0.060035232454538345,
0.21633397042751312,
-0.29739999771118164,
-0.22576598823070526,
-0.011720255948603153,
-1.0920647382736206,
-0.12147922068834305,
0.5945905447006226,
1.0863667726516724,
-0.28498461842536926,
-0.3045091927051544,
-0.612521767616272,
0.4132658541202545,
-0.35980024933815,
0.7486485838890076,
-0.7463417649269104,
-0.3617001473903656,
0.13885247707366943,
-0.10773511976003647,
-0.06522722542285919,
-0.3351268768310547,
0.9158148169517517,
-0.18953359127044678,
-0.12388314306735992,
-0.5549919605255127,
-0.3481590151786804,
0.3254269063472748,
0.3034206032752991,
-0.3960566818714142,
0.9225575923919678,
0.02347719855606556,
-0.6783986687660217,
0.6805800795555115,
-0.739168643951416,
-0.6157805323600769,
0.3146480917930603,
-0.17974109947681427,
-0.4970533847808838,
0.26704785227775574,
0.5001981854438782,
0.7982181906700134,
-0.1911483258008957,
0.3448929786682129,
-0.5857154130935669,
0.2064979076385498,
0.018879596143960953,
-0.20412231981754303,
0.29301917552948,
0.41968074440956116,
-0.36080700159072876,
-0.20655584335327148,
-0.7739952206611633,
0.40334397554397583,
0.10582554340362549,
-0.30504560470581055,
-0.36907365918159485,
0.3886069655418396,
0.1198941096663475,
0.25603291392326355,
0.3519468903541565,
-0.6467031240463257,
0.47011658549308777,
-0.44998836517333984,
0.7581407427787781,
0.44277042150497437,
0.2720567286014557,
0.17972087860107422,
-0.06590937823057175,
0.39786773920059204,
-0.43078529834747314,
0.19573792815208435,
-0.37422212958335876,
-0.6743689775466919,
0.03892632946372032,
-0.15166178345680237,
0.22107195854187012,
0.3171854019165039,
-0.4392290413379669,
0.3197184205055237,
-0.41708844900131226,
-0.43538299202919006,
-0.4903568923473358,
0.3193534016609192,
0.2962481379508972,
0.3548288345336914,
0.5050829648971558,
0.009008405730128288,
-0.5853070020675659,
-0.5718298554420471,
-0.38985350728034973,
0.12600016593933105,
-0.1738576740026474,
0.1980375349521637,
0.23684051632881165,
-0.5313895344734192,
0.7813566327095032,
-0.5975345373153687,
-0.3723393976688385,
-0.23945234715938568,
0.4323634207248688,
0.2245025932788849,
0.32584840059280396,
0.25722941756248474,
-0.7279679179191589,
-0.7929912805557251,
-0.08966103196144104,
-0.6374937891960144,
-0.5466063022613525,
0.07894545793533325,
0.14090903103351593,
-0.326771080493927,
0.7103335857391357,
-0.5203426480293274,
-0.03383846580982208,
0.6188575625419617,
-0.12307635694742203,
0.17648057639598846,
-0.4232381284236908,
0.3021794259548187,
-1.2791930437088013,
0.20325659215450287,
-0.29935139417648315,
-0.13001568615436554,
-0.6382285952568054,
0.01695782132446766,
0.12507307529449463,
-0.5049567818641663,
-0.15745210647583008,
0.4513368010520935,
-0.2522853910923004,
0.018690481781959534,
-0.43450963497161865,
-0.1378694623708725,
-0.16852979362010956,
0.05911632254719734,
-0.013292184099555016,
0.4486057162284851,
0.24179163575172424,
-0.571109414100647,
0.06737438589334488,
0.34031373262405396,
-0.05992894247174263,
0.1168351024389267,
-0.8643773198127747,
0.008519074879586697,
0.12384411692619324,
0.33558347821235657,
-1.0409212112426758,
-0.5546108484268188,
0.05112126097083092,
-0.4158534109592438,
0.011277816258370876,
-0.03270171955227852,
-0.6602785587310791,
-0.5597679018974304,
-0.3953416347503662,
0.3215814232826233,
0.40368297696113586,
-0.3312952518463135,
0.30975010991096497,
0.2653977870941162,
-0.30328458547592163,
-0.2951248586177826,
-0.21320268511772156,
0.3519092798233032,
0.12304279953241348,
-0.6301957964897156,
0.4514583349227905,
0.09849867224693298,
0.3126430809497833,
-0.20864787697792053,
-0.08308162540197372,
0.09267629683017731,
0.1391771137714386,
0.5455695390701294,
-0.20154818892478943,
0.07470045238733292,
0.11188972741365433,
0.2926768958568573,
-0.20737513899803162,
-0.21704711019992828,
-0.38503146171569824,
0.6192482113838196,
0.38924381136894226,
-0.3778258264064789,
-0.32009848952293396,
0.5003832578659058,
0.6861964464187622,
-0.2879285514354706,
0.18270087242126465,
0.4064563810825348,
-0.31013646721839905,
0.10239988565444946,
-0.28833723068237305,
-0.34831276535987854,
-0.5095127820968628,
0.3188741207122803,
-0.33481112122535706,
-0.5845993757247925,
0.18117181956768036,
-0.1098380833864212,
0.3493313491344452,
0.5170755982398987,
0.5222810506820679,
-0.10883799195289612,
1.4141234159469604,
0.2778867185115814,
-0.13936597108840942,
0.23793980479240417,
0.03468494862318039,
0.15636909008026123,
-0.5011457204818726,
0.13068775832653046,
-0.6247859001159668,
-0.3382117450237274,
-0.7308585047721863,
-0.133330300450325,
0.6243215203285217,
0.06183920428156853,
-0.024410970509052277,
0.36558160185813904,
-0.7274028658866882,
0.2786044776439667,
0.764886200428009,
0.06289829313755035,
0.1982593983411789,
-0.10523992031812668,
-0.1595493108034134,
-0.1310006082057953,
-0.7382660508155823,
-0.3096647560596466,
1.6587417125701904,
-0.003554302966222167,
0.5891923904418945,
-0.34152084589004517,
0.7821754217147827,
0.5142879486083984,
-0.10283228009939194,
-0.22091826796531677,
0.3618098795413971,
-0.35426294803619385,
-0.74626624584198,
-0.3747614622116089,
-0.2620193660259247,
-1.3768287897109985,
0.042755987495183945,
-0.3839111626148224,
-0.7082235217094421,
-0.07149311900138855,
0.36471027135849,
-0.4810522198677063,
-0.1722380518913269,
-0.31813010573387146,
1.0813689231872559,
-0.16172760725021362,
-0.03236498683691025,
-0.18243467807769775,
-0.79182368516922,
0.132480189204216,
-0.16387489438056946,
0.04610205814242363,
-0.2956031262874603,
0.03258085250854492,
0.5415631532669067,
-0.25793564319610596,
0.6189378499984741,
-0.08224496245384216,
0.19999393820762634,
0.015942340716719627,
-0.1852172613143921,
0.7782872319221497,
0.08543750643730164,
-0.0262442659586668,
-0.028311394155025482,
0.1774984449148178,
-0.2785355746746063,
-0.2406120002269745,
0.6096058487892151,
-0.4196693003177643,
-0.17094486951828003,
-0.06646653264760971,
-0.4048667848110199,
-0.35165587067604065,
0.28051307797431946,
0.8685597777366638,
0.40354669094085693,
-0.0917128473520279,
0.4284031093120575,
0.711091160774231,
-0.09610728919506073,
0.4220019578933716,
0.3922904133796692,
-0.0663280189037323,
-0.4786440134048462,
1.039318323135376,
0.14117497205734253,
0.30274316668510437,
0.6401647329330444,
0.39980238676071167,
-0.3205789625644684,
-0.6062623262405396,
-0.22447602450847626,
0.025948652997612953,
-0.4090535640716553,
-0.19872677326202393,
-1.1009588241577148,
0.027543572708964348,
-1.1714885234832764,
-0.5069445967674255,
-0.5141497850418091,
-0.1736573874950409,
-0.24048709869384766,
0.2063164860010147,
0.12934428453445435,
0.3382124900817871,
-0.2792234420776367,
0.3282443583011627,
-1.1153504848480225,
0.7463101148605347,
0.3129730820655823,
0.10780763626098633,
-0.3079476058483124,
-0.34395772218704224,
-0.17025446891784668,
0.05301865190267563,
-0.6394649147987366,
-0.8940801620483398,
0.4229435920715332,
0.5916667580604553,
0.44997912645339966,
0.6982319951057434,
0.3942728042602539,
0.24834132194519043,
-0.7951032519340515,
0.5958470702171326,
0.1028551310300827,
-0.6107970476150513,
0.8710886240005493,
-0.6079818606376648,
0.4865591824054718,
0.8357457518577576,
0.47177019715309143,
-0.8769489526748657,
-0.647514283657074,
-0.7235280871391296,
-0.8346142172813416,
0.2518939971923828,
0.13876011967658997,
0.07024722546339035,
-0.2535921335220337,
0.34580910205841064,
0.12036298960447311,
0.260488897562027,
-0.28607383370399475,
0.013359797187149525,
-0.4030701518058777,
-0.556195080280304,
-0.21033251285552979,
-0.18860754370689392,
0.10909697413444519,
0.07441598922014236,
0.5698974132537842,
-0.3398216664791107,
0.17281299829483032,
0.27130672335624695,
0.08326476812362671,
-0.24097386002540588,
0.2590232193470001,
0.7146242260932922,
0.5179159045219421,
-0.33672016859054565,
0.016572492197155952,
-0.06776697933673859,
-0.7690717577934265,
0.06528313457965851,
0.22989462316036224,
-0.39199283719062805,
0.189657524228096,
0.3344344198703766,
0.39589130878448486,
0.4287227690219879,
-0.8171242475509644,
0.5514562129974365,
0.19951403141021729,
-0.5447113513946533,
0.09773515909910202,
0.029502583667635918,
0.06996819376945496,
0.22128789126873016,
0.6344962120056152,
-0.40301552414894104,
0.3314841687679291,
-0.558837890625,
0.39780327677726746,
0.6483139991760254,
-0.08137724548578262,
-0.38891854882240295,
0.9430466294288635,
0.23438715934753418,
-0.24710293114185333,
0.37707072496414185,
-0.08988609910011292,
-0.45948079228401184,
0.2933824360370636,
0.43048667907714844,
1.0772596597671509,
-0.3700472116470337,
0.4297068119049072,
0.3062136471271515,
0.27778661251068115,
-0.4172550141811371,
0.3144785165786743,
-0.018107954412698746,
-0.6249101161956787,
-0.2009865641593933,
-0.6233794689178467,
-0.42261314392089844,
0.3402179181575775,
-0.3844658434391022,
0.15657848119735718,
-0.40778249502182007,
-0.2713164985179901,
0.3886454999446869,
-0.010601935908198357,
-0.3596853017807007,
0.10218522697687149,
-0.09634646028280258,
0.5921350121498108,
-0.907697319984436,
0.6168160438537598,
0.3751012980937958,
-0.18595880270004272,
-0.39723244309425354,
0.07472927123308182,
-0.1895601600408554,
-0.8886765241622925,
0.5058620572090149,
0.38868528604507446,
0.498067170381546,
0.1037072241306305,
-0.6032692193984985,
-1.0504653453826904,
0.846526026725769,
0.169094979763031,
-0.5367228984832764,
-0.38064542412757874,
0.29066744446754456,
0.349306583404541,
-0.2669249176979065,
-0.3227948248386383,
0.3065539598464966,
0.4626770615577698,
-0.039256785064935684,
-0.8310532569885254,
0.026850953698158264,
0.15645645558834076,
-0.18296217918395996,
0.42923206090927124,
-0.26048991084098816,
0.5706797242164612,
-0.08724229782819748,
0.02177267335355282,
-0.09600036591291428,
0.49266114830970764,
0.2445300966501236,
0.48616206645965576,
0.20427608489990234,
0.6615768074989319,
0.5212320685386658,
0.21338781714439392,
0.7338510751724243,
-0.5049701929092407,
0.15208806097507477,
1.101855754852295,
-0.31567323207855225,
0.8604896664619446,
0.3092414438724518,
-0.012213676236569881,
-0.1561758816242218,
0.616477906703949,
-0.053319789469242096,
0.9398059844970703,
-0.13520006835460663,
-0.039531391113996506,
-0.35192301869392395,
0.036848410964012146,
-0.44008904695510864,
0.3134402334690094,
0.34008097648620605,
-0.6206516623497009,
-0.44944998621940613,
0.41125670075416565,
-0.2670128643512726,
-0.25096988677978516,
-0.37098684906959534,
0.7334839105606079,
-0.13337862491607666,
-0.7892006635665894,
0.3689907193183899,
-0.17089636623859406,
0.3888889253139496,
-0.6468848586082458,
0.17291755974292755,
0.04912182316184044,
0.2217896729707718,
0.07093494385480881,
-0.6517946124076843,
0.11261248588562012,
-0.26926738023757935,
-0.314541220664978,
-0.3462778329849243,
0.8211112022399902,
-0.32972389459609985,
-0.4797869622707367,
0.08990640938282013,
0.2987614870071411,
0.21618503332138062,
-0.4760792851448059,
-0.8130772113800049,
-0.24215534329414368,
0.03223680704832077,
-0.3295785188674927,
0.4567185640335083,
0.4615256190299988,
0.2825049161911011,
0.6213152408599854,
0.7065653204917908,
0.17599990963935852,
0.14815397560596466,
-0.16774509847164154,
0.49397581815719604,
-0.44939833879470825,
-0.397232323884964,
-0.8405352830886841,
0.046607278287410736,
-0.14252819120883942,
-0.7040221095085144,
0.6216688752174377,
0.5200695395469666,
0.49226775765419006,
-0.059357043355703354,
0.9253125786781311,
0.06558018177747726,
0.843826413154602,
-0.3879026174545288,
0.5848116874694824,
-0.6743622422218323,
-0.3932560086250305,
-0.47917425632476807,
-0.6639983057975769,
-0.15073953568935394,
0.24326227605342865,
0.13579699397087097,
-0.35041046142578125,
0.6027867794036865,
0.5238207578659058,
0.08041682839393616,
-0.05704151839017868,
0.3972174823284149,
-0.1743861734867096,
0.35432058572769165,
0.27461934089660645,
0.20587535202503204,
-0.3031834661960602,
0.5664400458335876,
0.0601310171186924,
-0.037282560020685196,
-0.7836628556251526,
-0.8148049116134644,
-0.7216956615447998,
-0.7963343858718872,
-0.11008495092391968,
-0.2222812920808792,
0.303179532289505,
1.041890263557434,
0.6485003232955933,
-0.6970109939575195,
0.1746729165315628,
-0.47519880533218384,
-0.17676492035388947,
-0.2977972626686096,
-0.13584458827972412,
0.29343917965888977,
-0.8100811243057251,
-0.3879210352897644,
0.40718162059783936,
0.3960777223110199,
-0.002140217227861285,
-0.04865168407559395,
0.13338442146778107,
-0.24087753891944885,
0.025359176099300385,
0.44319459795951843,
0.5670735239982605,
-0.3995139002799988,
-0.01063408050686121,
0.24550417065620422,
-0.37971359491348267,
-0.0693497285246849,
0.8670771718025208,
-0.30386391282081604,
0.317468523979187,
0.637407660484314,
1.0141392946243286,
0.508589506149292,
-0.02786445990204811,
0.6862925887107849,
-0.587917149066925,
-0.5326057076454163,
0.23490756750106812,
0.15895822644233704,
0.05308062955737114,
-0.40134698152542114,
0.5072988867759705,
0.43236422538757324,
-0.8168846368789673,
-0.694133996963501,
0.17484654486179352,
-0.7729834318161011,
-0.38056376576423645,
1.1781584024429321,
0.13749361038208008,
-0.03718684986233711,
-0.30441227555274963,
-0.022159775719046593,
0.1609019935131073,
-0.49882277846336365,
0.8879700303077698,
0.44963133335113525,
-0.018083974719047546,
0.00609593465924263,
-0.6911122798919678,
0.7626277208328247,
0.3776262402534485,
-0.7381773591041565,
0.4326693117618561,
0.28879863023757935,
0.26002928614616394,
0.22010226547718048,
0.9386118650436401,
0.2905691862106323,
0.31277790665626526,
-0.1331072300672531,
-0.009809695184230804,
0.24334289133548737,
-0.3802492320537567,
0.17905256152153015,
0.47234615683555603,
-0.27343040704727173,
-0.27188757061958313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00167v1 | Can GPT-4 Help Detect Quit Vaping Intentions? An Exploration of Automatic Data Annotation Approach | 2024-06-28T18:06:48 | 2024-06-28T18:06:48 | Sai Krishna Revanth Vuruma, Dezhi Wu, Saborny Sen Gupta, Lucas Aust, Valerie Lookingbill, Wyatt Bellamy, Yang Ren, Erin Kasson, Li-Shiun Chen, Patricia Cavazos-Rehg, Dian Hu, Ming Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.HC, cs.SI | In recent years, the United States has witnessed a significant surge in the
popularity of vaping or e-cigarette use, leading to a notable rise in cases of
e-cigarette and vaping use-associated lung injury (EVALI) that caused
hospitalizations and fatalities during the EVALI outbreak in 2019, highlighting
the urgency to comprehend vaping behaviors and develop effective strategies for
cessation. Due to the ubiquity of social media platforms, over 4.7 billion
users worldwide use them for connectivity, communications, news, and
entertainment with a significant portion of the discourse related to health,
thereby establishing social media data as an invaluable organic data resource
for public health research. In this study, we extracted a sample dataset from
one vaping sub-community on Reddit to analyze users' quit-vaping intentions.
Leveraging OpenAI's latest large language model GPT-4 for sentence-level quit
vaping intention detection, this study compares the outcomes of this model
against layman and clinical expert annotations. Using different prompting
strategies such as zero-shot, one-shot, few-shot and chain-of-thought
prompting, we developed 8 prompts with varying levels of detail to explain the
task to GPT-4 and also evaluated the performance of the strategies against each
other. These preliminary findings emphasize the potential of GPT-4 in social
media data analysis, especially in identifying users' subtle intentions that
may elude human detection. | [
-0.2770231366157532,
-1.0206812620162964,
1.1687407493591309,
-0.09411253035068512,
-0.2803727090358734,
-0.26976674795150757,
-0.144364595413208,
-0.33426421880722046,
0.34472090005874634,
0.35196128487586975,
-0.44059625267982483,
-0.6518406271934509,
-0.4746566116809845,
0.18947604298591614,
-0.2670345604419708,
1.129884123802185,
-0.3757420778274536,
-0.2997393310070038,
0.07083608955144882,
0.08889508992433548,
-0.6337400078773499,
-0.48716703057289124,
-1.142041802406311,
0.06992360204458237,
0.8690934777259827,
0.29804784059524536,
0.08660277724266052,
-0.26445990800857544,
0.13641716539859772,
0.26740479469299316,
0.17512273788452148,
-0.06505943834781647,
-0.49678269028663635,
-0.03574182838201523,
0.19828663766384125,
-0.4061677157878876,
-0.23123592138290405,
0.12228966504335403,
0.29195961356163025,
-0.050422750413417816,
-0.18399403989315033,
0.2956211566925049,
-0.10169234126806259,
0.4309057295322418,
-0.29095548391342163,
-0.06900066882371902,
-0.42464515566825867,
-0.06591442972421646,
-0.3953676223754883,
-0.4496079683303833,
-0.14890392124652863,
-0.28540781140327454,
-0.20583826303482056,
-0.7556069493293762,
0.3508339822292328,
-0.2800753116607666,
0.9400190114974976,
0.38716790080070496,
-0.38357865810394287,
-0.12543663382530212,
-0.8498266935348511,
0.18229636549949646,
-0.6572285294532776,
0.3209522068500519,
0.5844202041625977,
0.4914610683917999,
0.000689762004185468,
-0.5067058801651001,
-0.627091646194458,
0.24887551367282867,
-0.022437479346990585,
0.18783725798130035,
-0.4148218333721161,
0.07567622512578964,
0.29663795232772827,
0.11084678024053574,
-0.6206779479980469,
-0.10628876835107803,
-0.48252028226852417,
-0.06091254949569702,
0.531944751739502,
-0.06979215890169144,
0.5642214417457581,
-0.22280581295490265,
-0.2656233310699463,
0.4373076856136322,
-0.6577740907669067,
0.1978209763765335,
0.5074865818023682,
-0.19380128383636475,
-0.1038588136434555,
0.4239211976528168,
-0.1892898827791214,
0.31880101561546326,
0.04267087206244469,
0.20352803170681,
0.25824275612831116,
-0.7860091924667358,
-0.3580755889415741,
0.0331241674721241,
1.1403394937515259,
0.6174242496490479,
0.31492525339126587,
0.2281808853149414,
0.02399452030658722,
-0.15697070956230164,
0.29322585463523865,
-0.8894849419593811,
-0.5119404792785645,
0.4774038791656494,
-0.7135955691337585,
-0.3737229108810425,
0.059932757169008255,
-0.6024978756904602,
-0.11594562977552414,
-0.14523276686668396,
0.3878174126148224,
-0.39100202918052673,
-0.2539374828338623,
0.09558457881212234,
-0.3764207065105438,
-0.16104872524738312,
0.43591436743736267,
-0.8950802683830261,
0.36824139952659607,
0.5321860909461975,
1.1565892696380615,
0.11406462639570236,
0.17765170335769653,
-0.5098023414611816,
0.015044175088405609,
-0.27046889066696167,
0.7173336148262024,
-0.3955521583557129,
-0.2446497529745102,
-0.12247241288423538,
0.06788889318704605,
0.059284888207912445,
-0.18461669981479645,
0.7699751257896423,
-0.31302449107170105,
0.2754100561141968,
-0.6311739683151245,
-0.3567248582839966,
-0.5004125833511353,
0.564487636089325,
-0.7386180758476257,
0.7511202692985535,
-0.07674848288297653,
-0.5778257846832275,
0.6902542114257812,
-0.7064544558525085,
-0.17771604657173157,
0.4700850248336792,
-0.5632101893424988,
-0.6212586164474487,
0.07301487773656845,
0.4263400733470917,
0.5801928639411926,
-0.05627461522817612,
0.26507869362831116,
-0.26528650522232056,
-0.28693512082099915,
0.1541290432214737,
-0.6602789163589478,
0.7416232824325562,
-0.030685003846883774,
-0.4928799569606781,
0.2675628662109375,
-0.1315682977437973,
-0.05626865103840828,
0.10024622827768326,
0.003197970800101757,
-0.5497228503227234,
-0.15881870687007904,
0.10470113158226013,
0.4957796335220337,
0.06307846307754517,
-0.6309492588043213,
0.27088430523872375,
0.081455759704113,
0.6610434055328369,
0.6262830495834351,
0.8313250541687012,
-0.4289212226867676,
-0.2331373244524002,
0.7913898229598999,
-0.29080018401145935,
0.49017390608787537,
-0.09458380937576294,
-1.080933690071106,
-0.02002561464905739,
-0.23307621479034424,
0.1452537477016449,
0.18479523062705994,
-0.6771795153617859,
0.4816106855869293,
-0.13789018988609314,
-0.4246059060096741,
-0.3286875784397125,
0.1190522089600563,
0.2156217396259308,
0.513346791267395,
0.4300628900527954,
-0.1554892659187317,
-0.3669362962245941,
-0.7483584880828857,
-0.22398991882801056,
-0.3672957122325897,
-0.12657421827316284,
0.34676575660705566,
0.40299099683761597,
-0.22398719191551208,
0.6640385389328003,
-0.35329559445381165,
-0.446959912776947,
-0.09701024740934372,
0.29223087430000305,
-0.036417119204998016,
-0.24439267814159393,
0.659250795841217,
-0.9772733449935913,
-0.6557629108428955,
0.25053155422210693,
-0.6498064398765564,
-0.27405622601509094,
-0.3906102776527405,
-0.07967111468315125,
-0.012581403367221355,
0.14714404940605164,
-0.5259982347488403,
0.7735769748687744,
0.49594786763191223,
-0.3532189726829529,
0.5127794146537781,
-0.12324392050504684,
0.72186279296875,
-0.6319429874420166,
0.04271446540951729,
0.32567480206489563,
-0.0771031454205513,
-0.7485119104385376,
-0.7969075441360474,
0.07222956418991089,
0.14006775617599487,
-0.4386627972126007,
0.505363941192627,
-0.05995052307844162,
0.20177540183067322,
-0.17701128125190735,
-0.3234427273273468,
0.10122758150100708,
0.14688940346240997,
0.06515589356422424,
0.48573145270347595,
0.20949378609657288,
-0.33126315474510193,
-0.018075937405228615,
0.2162482738494873,
0.012695297598838806,
0.5697594881057739,
-0.605467677116394,
-0.07117073237895966,
0.1083371639251709,
0.5359807014465332,
-1.022944688796997,
-0.48524731397628784,
0.8056470155715942,
-0.6399002075195312,
-0.023702533915638924,
-0.2576340138912201,
-0.31688210368156433,
-0.4845565855503082,
-0.41010889410972595,
0.537813127040863,
0.41412824392318726,
-0.25895214080810547,
0.2870071530342102,
0.2599020302295685,
-0.11214598268270493,
-0.04822477698326111,
-0.5248409509658813,
0.2654775083065033,
-0.5551908016204834,
-0.39180222153663635,
0.26563599705696106,
0.03805827721953392,
-0.009048203006386757,
0.11507385969161987,
-0.020733997225761414,
-0.011574186384677887,
-0.22229363024234772,
0.30341535806655884,
0.11678116023540497,
0.37481489777565,
0.22943593561649323,
-0.06284497678279877,
-0.12407073378562927,
0.37545502185821533,
-0.12371867895126343,
0.33994153141975403,
-0.03789055719971657,
-0.277560830116272,
-0.959632158279419,
0.31802400946617126,
0.2423674464225769,
-0.022927163168787956,
0.3485654592514038,
0.7241315245628357,
-0.5957074761390686,
0.19224856793880463,
-0.6984453797340393,
-0.07125595211982727,
-0.48267537355422974,
-0.07006677985191345,
-0.1841963231563568,
-0.5033032894134521,
0.303475558757782,
0.1268945038318634,
-0.09595111012458801,
0.30540168285369873,
0.7047730088233948,
-0.08795565366744995,
0.8606160283088684,
0.16324178874492645,
-0.05525439232587814,
0.4866129159927368,
-0.20783433318138123,
0.44235819578170776,
-0.5909764170646667,
-0.2587524950504303,
-0.14957678318023682,
-0.30919721722602844,
-0.37114018201828003,
-0.2878858149051666,
0.5413371324539185,
-0.27016139030456543,
-0.14680233597755432,
0.13642603158950806,
-0.8643258810043335,
0.3329046666622162,
0.32509341835975647,
0.3950948417186737,
0.18372385203838348,
-0.1507667899131775,
0.39982515573501587,
-0.14502815902233124,
-0.4046521484851837,
-0.5116381049156189,
1.1630101203918457,
0.2750689387321472,
0.13895519077777863,
0.04979393258690834,
0.9735392928123474,
0.30418604612350464,
0.30764472484588623,
-0.6637753844261169,
0.2524931728839874,
0.06450770050287247,
-0.5306720733642578,
-0.39163175225257874,
-0.45430344343185425,
-1.052289366722107,
-0.2225385308265686,
0.021683761849999428,
-0.7083382606506348,
0.11255845427513123,
0.27422598004341125,
-0.5261982679367065,
0.28247690200805664,
-0.7822222113609314,
0.9774432182312012,
-0.8347684144973755,
-0.15384331345558167,
0.27993687987327576,
-0.38949793577194214,
0.5484815835952759,
-0.3538479804992676,
0.4099276661872864,
-0.17287488281726837,
-0.07140400260686874,
0.9264516830444336,
-0.32136833667755127,
0.6898586750030518,
-0.3854459822177887,
0.18905872106552124,
0.5600419640541077,
-0.32350438833236694,
0.4889308512210846,
0.25559520721435547,
0.175027996301651,
0.5927304625511169,
-0.17480428516864777,
-0.11103761196136475,
-0.552017331123352,
0.641988217830658,
-0.48132258653640747,
-0.13470183312892914,
-0.20691652595996857,
0.12169777601957321,
0.12043978273868561,
0.36631616950035095,
0.5623522996902466,
0.043223269283771515,
-0.33324989676475525,
-0.1637713462114334,
0.4583759307861328,
-0.13057801127433777,
0.2652820944786072,
0.053774647414684296,
-0.11225590109825134,
-0.3555402457714081,
0.8901544809341431,
0.27722951769828796,
-0.05708727613091469,
0.09170260280370712,
0.5348202586174011,
-0.15219499170780182,
-0.6368954181671143,
-0.16186511516571045,
0.2713872194290161,
-0.3780381977558136,
-0.10712196677923203,
-0.60190349817276,
0.10908157378435135,
-0.33693748712539673,
-0.21594353020191193,
-0.057211101055145264,
0.11746878921985626,
-0.08855480700731277,
-0.42449522018432617,
0.6408176422119141,
1.0742669105529785,
0.07700257748365402,
0.09851575642824173,
-0.6597307324409485,
0.4135805070400238,
0.2914315462112427,
0.1584453582763672,
-0.2910885810852051,
0.06758471578359604,
-0.07633042335510254,
-0.13046997785568237,
-0.25928130745887756,
-1.1688865423202515,
0.43722495436668396,
-0.002858705585822463,
0.5500718951225281,
0.6701154708862305,
-0.005140896886587143,
0.5181818008422852,
-0.49832338094711304,
1.0617997646331787,
0.331132173538208,
-0.5848706960678101,
0.6124137043952942,
-0.8949068784713745,
0.22144533693790436,
0.7803291082382202,
0.7563350200653076,
-0.8748980760574341,
-0.24893127381801605,
-0.8920974731445312,
-0.9062565565109253,
0.1955544352531433,
0.6185739040374756,
-0.23059393465518951,
-0.19010263681411743,
0.422428697347641,
0.3097200393676758,
0.2681210935115814,
-0.5904657244682312,
-0.20483027398586273,
-0.4588659107685089,
-0.4117572009563446,
0.1292829066514969,
-0.15824805200099945,
-0.25615358352661133,
-0.35865455865859985,
0.6332069635391235,
0.006024335976690054,
0.5420314073562622,
0.029066409915685654,
0.4670499563217163,
-0.19093093276023865,
0.11009149998426437,
0.44352492690086365,
0.5352494120597839,
-0.23478282988071442,
-0.09346497803926468,
-0.19596746563911438,
-0.47802916169166565,
0.22617748379707336,
0.05283677577972412,
-0.4595009982585907,
0.035656582564115524,
0.12741588056087494,
0.6709375381469727,
0.14624619483947754,
-0.40671980381011963,
0.6744155883789062,
-0.452687531709671,
-0.511535108089447,
-0.5003281831741333,
-0.04716463014483452,
0.09553346037864685,
-0.17603753507137299,
0.2148274928331375,
-0.19637291133403778,
0.5574238300323486,
-0.31615108251571655,
0.3042867183685303,
0.41311556100845337,
-0.37828385829925537,
-0.6857497692108154,
0.8301547765731812,
0.26339030265808105,
-0.24346403777599335,
0.19528792798519135,
-0.2032487541437149,
-0.595089852809906,
0.5092766880989075,
0.09772355109453201,
1.0981643199920654,
-0.26103997230529785,
0.4481743574142456,
0.5862787365913391,
0.39740779995918274,
-0.16625334322452545,
0.20361950993537903,
-0.03297118470072746,
-0.3879789412021637,
-0.12963952124118805,
-0.04568689316511154,
-0.1501489132642746,
0.61672043800354,
-0.49784961342811584,
0.5568850040435791,
-0.36056533455848694,
-0.15229447185993195,
0.2977297902107239,
-0.08214878290891647,
-1.0322688817977905,
0.23532651364803314,
0.16274012625217438,
0.16965223848819733,
-1.280385971069336,
0.5358318090438843,
0.6495503187179565,
-0.6730510592460632,
-0.8504011034965515,
0.3967529833316803,
0.5692530274391174,
-0.283816933631897,
0.3644992411136627,
0.7289741039276123,
0.10926704853773117,
-0.2840426564216614,
-0.5043309926986694,
-0.48750385642051697,
1.0836775302886963,
-0.019645120948553085,
-0.6092907786369324,
-0.057364318519830704,
-0.17181584239006042,
0.5150004625320435,
-0.31178101897239685,
0.44020766019821167,
0.6017727255821228,
0.7826704382896423,
-0.05964738503098488,
-0.8341628313064575,
0.24681119620800018,
-0.24800242483615875,
-0.13379332423210144,
0.36251649260520935,
-0.5548481345176697,
0.6347499489784241,
0.16427576541900635,
-0.32422515749931335,
-0.5281828045845032,
0.005906607490032911,
0.09773943573236465,
0.777425229549408,
0.653984785079956,
0.6544305682182312,
0.8062264323234558,
0.14251652359962463,
0.9150791764259338,
0.08310692012310028,
0.31214115023612976,
0.9402610063552856,
-0.09887249767780304,
0.7044526934623718,
0.29048022627830505,
-0.0805630087852478,
0.35491234064102173,
0.8366428017616272,
0.27578020095825195,
0.5202323198318481,
-0.24104608595371246,
-0.5106284022331238,
-0.1606040745973587,
0.3596929907798767,
-0.2768400311470032,
0.17166244983673096,
0.7980204224586487,
-0.447019100189209,
-0.09596297889947891,
0.15019537508487701,
0.05456424131989479,
-0.3102916181087494,
-0.08883089572191238,
0.7871134877204895,
-0.16456979513168335,
-0.5816662311553955,
0.4822494685649872,
-0.4580698311328888,
0.5256187915802002,
-0.46125495433807373,
-0.2676483988761902,
0.2887890338897705,
-0.3966653048992157,
-0.44083696603775024,
-0.6531078815460205,
0.3034888505935669,
0.031807638704776764,
0.17084839940071106,
-0.3227716386318207,
0.8591158390045166,
-0.44589048624038696,
-0.4880870282649994,
0.16925600171089172,
0.21838626265525818,
0.4431707561016083,
-0.29971185326576233,
-0.7558996081352234,
0.0967009961605072,
0.09711548686027527,
-0.5155104398727417,
0.010756543837487698,
0.6316334009170532,
-0.15105535089969635,
0.1772090047597885,
0.7089517712593079,
0.25889676809310913,
-0.19097694754600525,
-0.05806953087449074,
0.6784640550613403,
-0.6151089668273926,
-0.45141467452049255,
-0.7935038805007935,
0.5111541152000427,
-0.3393450081348419,
-0.4193316698074341,
0.8996540307998657,
0.3226264715194702,
0.8014107346534729,
0.3261425495147705,
1.3438267707824707,
-0.19784320890903473,
0.36195334792137146,
-0.5609757900238037,
0.6058495044708252,
-0.31306660175323486,
0.21356317400932312,
-0.02458553947508335,
-0.6210424304008484,
-0.20275747776031494,
0.5247712135314941,
-0.6899053454399109,
0.3857581913471222,
0.6713205575942993,
0.26715585589408875,
0.038189541548490524,
-0.10033740848302841,
0.15967868268489838,
-0.012224067002534866,
0.8002787232398987,
0.2515696883201599,
0.21562474966049194,
-0.33745017647743225,
0.41103583574295044,
-0.18647482991218567,
-0.38339340686798096,
-0.4720049798488617,
-0.6951722502708435,
-0.9865329265594482,
-0.5790333151817322,
-0.3487050533294678,
-0.22913028299808502,
0.13731034100055695,
0.6339325308799744,
0.3411221206188202,
-0.31170666217803955,
0.49085476994514465,
-0.4261455237865448,
-0.21490593254566193,
-0.24891427159309387,
-0.2433260828256607,
0.32826051115989685,
-0.023627063259482384,
-0.36805543303489685,
0.24653905630111694,
0.3049405515193939,
-0.1831730753183365,
-0.24589994549751282,
0.01155389379709959,
-0.34247711300849915,
-0.12388638406991959,
0.33869776129722595,
0.6217517852783203,
-0.7972668409347534,
-0.44321176409721375,
-0.18153779208660126,
0.07655016332864761,
0.16939333081245422,
0.8948177695274353,
-0.6980509757995605,
0.8221129179000854,
0.5011907815933228,
0.38519224524497986,
0.6960774660110474,
0.42318373918533325,
0.45096641778945923,
-0.7800018191337585,
-0.33267155289649963,
0.2976054549217224,
0.26107656955718994,
0.3583652079105377,
-0.893704354763031,
0.43420839309692383,
0.10699308663606644,
-0.9933637976646423,
-0.33549126982688904,
-0.006667544133961201,
-0.9745916128158569,
-0.1455191820859909,
1.4822430610656738,
-0.011731509119272232,
-0.32641419768333435,
-0.5810222029685974,
-0.5635790228843689,
0.14856402575969696,
-0.8440349102020264,
0.6665336489677429,
0.7477359175682068,
-0.4994463622570038,
-0.23502302169799805,
-1.3150670528411865,
0.7243947982788086,
-0.09303957223892212,
-1.1165014505386353,
0.03128661960363388,
0.6039314270019531,
0.35129475593566895,
0.014738884754478931,
1.3708573579788208,
0.22629398107528687,
0.4924527406692505,
-0.32295817136764526,
0.13186825811862946,
-0.3324512839317322,
-0.24373893439769745,
-0.4030112326145172,
-0.20099735260009766,
-0.269378662109375,
-0.33932942152023315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20098v1 | Web2Code: A Large-scale Webpage-to-Code Dataset and Evaluation Framework for Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:59:46 | 2024-06-28T17:59:46 | Sukmin Yun, Haokun Lin, Rusiru Thushara, Mohammad Qazim Bhat, Yongxin Wang, Zutao Jiang, Mingkai Deng, Jinhong Wang, Tianhua Tao, Junbo Li, Haonan Li, Preslav Nakov, Timothy Baldwin, Zhengzhong Liu, Eric P. Xing, Xiaodan Liang, Zhiqiang Shen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown impressive success across
modalities such as image, video, and audio in a variety of understanding and
generation tasks. However, current MLLMs are surprisingly poor at understanding
webpage screenshots and generating their corresponding HTML code. To address
this problem, we propose Web2Code, a benchmark consisting of a new large-scale
webpage-to-code dataset for instruction tuning and an evaluation framework for
the webpage understanding and HTML code translation abilities of MLLMs. For
dataset construction, we leverage pretrained LLMs to enhance existing
webpage-to-code datasets as well as generate a diverse pool of new webpages
rendered into images. Specifically, the inputs are webpage images and
instructions, while the responses are the webpage's HTML code. We further
include diverse natural language QA pairs about the webpage content in the
responses to enable a more comprehensive understanding of the web content. To
evaluate model performance in these tasks, we develop an evaluation framework
for testing MLLMs' abilities in webpage understanding and web-to-code
generation. Extensive experiments show that our proposed dataset is beneficial
not only to our proposed tasks but also in the general visual domain, while
previous datasets result in worse performance. We hope our work will contribute
to the development of general MLLMs suitable for web-based content generation
and task automation. Our data and code will be available at
https://github.com/MBZUAI-LLM/web2code. | [
-0.4126003682613373,
-0.42484569549560547,
0.11908448487520218,
0.37032821774482727,
-0.21064795553684235,
-0.07623784989118576,
-0.5255054235458374,
-0.13979461789131165,
-0.5721955895423889,
0.2967362403869629,
-0.502689003944397,
-0.6051464080810547,
-0.38214245438575745,
0.07716046273708344,
-0.5381035804748535,
0.7169159054756165,
0.03877066448330879,
0.2896880805492401,
-0.5735809206962585,
-0.030526595190167427,
-0.09383011609315872,
-0.39409688115119934,
-0.46670466661453247,
0.10314232110977173,
0.5151050090789795,
0.19392569363117218,
0.30149737000465393,
0.537657618522644,
0.6518962383270264,
0.23841923475265503,
0.3095307946205139,
0.4906788170337677,
-0.7576437592506409,
0.0294696893543005,
-0.22190707921981812,
-0.4905579090118408,
-0.2982746660709381,
-0.20329158008098602,
0.6767345666885376,
0.4786224663257599,
0.04768627509474754,
0.5711557865142822,
0.08829784393310547,
0.694421648979187,
-0.7603660821914673,
0.2975867986679077,
-0.5600330829620361,
0.0999235138297081,
0.1461205631494522,
-0.32422009110450745,
-0.6808114647865295,
-0.30295443534851074,
-0.2622212767601013,
-0.49887916445732117,
0.1845902055501938,
0.1681538224220276,
0.5646752119064331,
0.2153201848268509,
-0.6585216522216797,
-0.30615368485450745,
-0.28164511919021606,
0.7712406516075134,
-0.6415791511535645,
0.7240909934043884,
0.46500691771507263,
0.2970186769962311,
-0.06283294409513474,
-0.6795167922973633,
-0.6544642448425293,
-0.29695776104927063,
0.19368813931941986,
0.04564331844449043,
-0.29103827476501465,
-0.21929988265037537,
0.2874322533607483,
0.09706994891166687,
-1.000378131866455,
0.4440215826034546,
-0.24512669444084167,
-0.1328197717666626,
0.4910775125026703,
0.23157796263694763,
0.31025299429893494,
-0.20137561857700348,
-0.3305889368057251,
-0.3535781800746918,
-0.6791996359825134,
0.12228789180517197,
0.3407544195652008,
0.12232086807489395,
-0.3267669975757599,
0.5096144080162048,
-0.1156313419342041,
0.7285800576210022,
-0.21030108630657196,
-0.27627134323120117,
0.22142361104488373,
-0.27468597888946533,
-0.1005987599492073,
-0.4476419687271118,
0.6428133249282837,
1.1183608770370483,
0.42747440934181213,
-0.12607388198375702,
-0.36022642254829407,
0.24692705273628235,
0.3445255160331726,
-1.150682806968689,
-0.16272678971290588,
0.21308352053165436,
-0.7076002359390259,
-0.07653569430112839,
0.05862683057785034,
-0.8679803609848022,
-0.5062752366065979,
-0.39605703949928284,
0.19466868042945862,
-0.2504842281341553,
-0.19475992023944855,
-0.16368785500526428,
-0.25500908493995667,
0.3474734127521515,
0.32444190979003906,
-0.7522831559181213,
0.053201526403427124,
0.467738538980484,
0.5033588409423828,
-0.48461490869522095,
-0.30809205770492554,
-0.4851817488670349,
0.05467027425765991,
-0.4750247299671173,
0.706577479839325,
-0.4366558790206909,
-0.21863260865211487,
0.435665100812912,
-0.13856570422649384,
0.05106911063194275,
-0.6511984467506409,
0.020999925211071968,
-0.6591333746910095,
-0.151023730635643,
0.01624155417084694,
-0.5394076108932495,
-0.10963398218154907,
0.3870726227760315,
-0.770426869392395,
0.6554779410362244,
0.10523032397031784,
-0.3505673110485077,
0.16143645346164703,
-0.502204418182373,
-0.5630309581756592,
-0.24873383343219757,
-0.22601768374443054,
-0.2550816535949707,
0.028452375903725624,
0.24108712375164032,
0.5656725764274597,
-0.46931222081184387,
-0.049429409205913544,
-0.30232563614845276,
-0.44796067476272583,
0.6146036386489868,
-0.7734971642494202,
0.4250020980834961,
0.21739596128463745,
-0.29031795263290405,
-0.007192633580416441,
-1.0045387744903564,
0.46682581305503845,
0.13175691664218903,
-0.7784569263458252,
0.3116423487663269,
0.06379548460245132,
0.504953920841217,
0.2411610335111618,
0.21186107397079468,
-0.11412970721721649,
0.26810094714164734,
0.1815004050731659,
0.35092395544052124,
0.7394298911094666,
-0.21173414587974548,
0.26069119572639465,
-0.14849989116191864,
0.4738713204860687,
-0.08450204879045486,
0.17616431415081024,
-0.3903065323829651,
-0.23378580808639526,
-0.8927947282791138,
0.060290589928627014,
0.14711448550224304,
0.5749238133430481,
-0.9451599717140198,
0.14660395681858063,
-0.5047311186790466,
-0.17171615362167358,
-0.2947443127632141,
0.6197035908699036,
0.8928444981575012,
0.08477897942066193,
0.45940592885017395,
-0.37977224588394165,
-0.576005220413208,
-0.9344401955604553,
0.05111563578248024,
0.1418311595916748,
-0.31517550349235535,
0.304454505443573,
0.31030672788619995,
-0.4928455650806427,
0.6814641356468201,
-0.2110164761543274,
-0.06881895661354065,
-0.2638914883136749,
0.11414454132318497,
-0.07282198965549469,
0.4441308081150055,
0.2828463017940521,
-0.7649042010307312,
-0.3122347295284271,
0.015981122851371765,
-0.8751007318496704,
0.06588590890169144,
0.030630655586719513,
0.05797266587615013,
0.24536648392677307,
0.24348165094852448,
-0.3610517978668213,
0.23873363435268402,
0.858351469039917,
-0.1415354311466217,
0.5514810085296631,
-0.09463157504796982,
0.3747967779636383,
-0.8909431099891663,
0.16085664927959442,
0.2683582901954651,
-0.28637734055519104,
-0.43175286054611206,
0.2645750641822815,
0.4741268754005432,
-0.19673174619674683,
-0.5915266275405884,
0.36219897866249084,
-0.697334885597229,
-0.5022677779197693,
-0.24017877876758575,
0.14565469324588776,
0.17016693949699402,
0.7831152677536011,
-0.2910956144332886,
1.0833277702331543,
0.22286288440227509,
-0.6206578612327576,
0.6241128444671631,
0.18737488985061646,
-0.5695081353187561,
0.5440100431442261,
-0.14975576102733612,
0.3735005259513855,
-0.03418206423521042,
0.31793728470802307,
-0.8661834001541138,
-0.28618112206459045,
-0.16251002252101898,
-0.3445565700531006,
0.3667962849140167,
-0.26267385482788086,
-0.7757306694984436,
-0.4915861189365387,
-0.41999900341033936,
0.2343662530183792,
0.5551222562789917,
-0.5223276615142822,
0.20675069093704224,
0.11824365705251694,
-0.03202420845627785,
-0.38012105226516724,
-0.6075664758682251,
0.21558089554309845,
0.14877580106258392,
-0.5545257329940796,
0.20966164767742157,
-0.16398881375789642,
-0.17949429154396057,
-0.15648379921913147,
-0.05073975771665573,
-0.3691345453262329,
-0.018997978419065475,
0.2626338303089142,
0.20355071127414703,
-0.3540377914905548,
0.11716509610414505,
0.07636512815952301,
-0.006334908772259951,
0.14334067702293396,
-0.1595301330089569,
0.6603586673736572,
-0.042854007333517075,
-0.6184917688369751,
-0.6444475054740906,
0.20668619871139526,
0.47891101241111755,
-0.4739847779273987,
0.23030802607536316,
0.8950579166412354,
-0.15286539494991302,
-0.36080238223075867,
-0.5641197562217712,
0.020639868453145027,
-0.43652811646461487,
0.712329626083374,
-0.36791449785232544,
-0.7118141651153564,
0.17193476855754852,
-0.24291563034057617,
0.14757752418518066,
0.18045739829540253,
0.7382316589355469,
-0.5010057091712952,
0.9600489735603333,
0.3311641812324524,
0.1320175677537918,
0.33776262402534485,
-0.517789900302887,
-0.186113640666008,
-0.9092617034912109,
-0.25057169795036316,
-0.2333734929561615,
-0.42647966742515564,
-0.3828461766242981,
-0.9310500621795654,
0.30735185742378235,
0.25596025586128235,
-0.06494535505771637,
0.17542783915996552,
-0.23764252662658691,
0.3994481563568115,
0.4256233274936676,
0.25911572575569153,
0.1713741272687912,
0.14032281935214996,
0.10753699392080307,
0.16093264520168304,
-0.5387945771217346,
-0.5961366891860962,
1.499385118484497,
0.1594620794057846,
0.9356923699378967,
0.41858088970184326,
0.1110401526093483,
0.6395658850669861,
0.22802317142486572,
-0.44732874631881714,
0.5320628881454468,
-0.40452709794044495,
-0.3529072701931,
-0.20909783244132996,
-0.3491002321243286,
-0.934638261795044,
0.27250370383262634,
-0.12971378862857819,
-0.5190658569335938,
-0.19045884907245636,
0.2951562702655792,
-0.2016715705394745,
0.12196026742458344,
-0.7675711512565613,
0.9347804188728333,
-0.5883831977844238,
-0.7652279138565063,
-0.5566616058349609,
-0.5429768562316895,
0.23190973699092865,
0.1205354705452919,
0.28231528401374817,
-0.17949755489826202,
-0.028299830853939056,
0.558819591999054,
0.07124493271112442,
0.8916926980018616,
-0.25451311469078064,
-0.32861295342445374,
0.2173512876033783,
0.04091477766633034,
0.3969475030899048,
0.07059305906295776,
-0.15026389062404633,
0.028145503252744675,
-0.049177318811416626,
-0.3836211860179901,
-0.7079166173934937,
0.5203812718391418,
-0.681013286113739,
-0.21543185412883759,
0.28680798411369324,
-0.48826882243156433,
-0.5298999547958374,
-0.2002289742231369,
0.08599787205457687,
0.8748939037322998,
-0.007445408962666988,
0.4778033494949341,
0.701600193977356,
-0.47490760684013367,
0.6171585321426392,
0.5441750288009644,
-0.4537438750267029,
-0.36732181906700134,
1.09518563747406,
-0.3512951135635376,
0.21292582154273987,
0.5743229985237122,
-0.35185933113098145,
-0.41048285365104675,
-0.6278889179229736,
-1.0541077852249146,
-0.3263051509857178,
-0.9642212390899658,
-0.43250805139541626,
-0.26611655950546265,
-0.11114919185638428,
-0.3975479006767273,
0.06453561037778854,
-0.19144126772880554,
-0.07935988157987595,
-0.377864271402359,
0.12763002514839172,
0.13683849573135376,
0.776506245136261,
0.11364924162626266,
0.037951137870550156,
-0.9631956219673157,
0.5020006895065308,
0.4340001046657562,
0.2909955084323883,
0.12681500613689423,
-0.43956711888313293,
-0.44381242990493774,
0.09271518141031265,
-0.37392428517341614,
-0.7017310857772827,
0.1566680669784546,
0.23379796743392944,
0.6628095507621765,
0.5514875054359436,
-0.32432207465171814,
0.7631449699401855,
-0.6188991665840149,
0.6837181448936462,
0.4282093942165375,
-0.7853192687034607,
0.4034541845321655,
-0.20078931748867035,
0.35627996921539307,
0.3506999909877777,
0.2828737795352936,
-0.41645580530166626,
-0.0476314015686512,
0.09552998840808868,
-0.5498669743537903,
0.32153546810150146,
0.10594368726015091,
0.3772726356983185,
0.18297292292118073,
0.04699515178799629,
0.2052731066942215,
0.29743748903274536,
-0.6525219678878784,
-0.15541547536849976,
-0.2923294007778168,
-0.3042464256286621,
-0.04245562478899956,
-0.4250105321407318,
0.021378621459007263,
-0.05843915790319443,
0.24715782701969147,
-0.5472391247749329,
0.405055969953537,
-0.21819548308849335,
-0.8623558282852173,
0.0468267984688282,
0.2917366325855255,
0.745972752571106,
1.1046899557113647,
0.025375863537192345,
0.20727337896823883,
0.14463455975055695,
-0.2242981642484665,
0.18979839980602264,
0.17384082078933716,
0.1943930983543396,
-0.33689817786216736,
0.775992214679718,
0.9412514567375183,
0.4747631549835205,
-1.1633203029632568,
0.6897717714309692,
0.044221363961696625,
0.0080003272742033,
-0.12744665145874023,
0.20300188660621643,
0.11471822112798691,
0.23858030140399933,
0.5080443024635315,
-0.18686740100383759,
0.20457632839679718,
-0.5265514850616455,
0.35482504963874817,
0.28021055459976196,
-0.16462308168411255,
-0.3300912380218506,
0.3394017517566681,
0.4775904417037964,
-0.30974268913269043,
0.8021504282951355,
-0.4943906366825104,
-0.4727834463119507,
0.7363793849945068,
0.6992069482803345,
0.33286651968955994,
0.10010308772325516,
0.07545148581266403,
0.3765772581100464,
0.0705564022064209,
0.39278116822242737,
0.2544811964035034,
-0.09421873837709427,
-0.5755813717842102,
-0.332497239112854,
-0.8104225397109985,
-0.18018712103366852,
0.09712602943181992,
-0.7315173745155334,
-0.017030425369739532,
-0.46323567628860474,
-0.1190623864531517,
-0.3479621708393097,
-0.16776339709758759,
-0.9816970825195312,
0.30630573630332947,
0.42761147022247314,
0.7705323100090027,
-0.3745473027229309,
0.8325236439704895,
0.6225475072860718,
-0.31815969944000244,
-0.5005356669425964,
-0.056466471403837204,
0.13629886507987976,
-0.9004355072975159,
0.7669936418533325,
0.41746509075164795,
0.15911559760570526,
0.013019688427448273,
-0.2871805429458618,
-0.6254592537879944,
1.151326298713684,
0.29607537388801575,
-1.0403934717178345,
-0.025014227256178856,
0.20075862109661102,
0.35003992915153503,
-0.16327039897441864,
0.302985280752182,
0.31911948323249817,
0.5466321110725403,
-0.2445773184299469,
-1.0636296272277832,
-0.14333085715770721,
-0.4343237578868866,
0.28463608026504517,
-0.1315670907497406,
-0.549933671951294,
0.7597085237503052,
-0.27685821056365967,
-0.020787959918379784,
0.019548757001757622,
0.45947590470314026,
0.1766110360622406,
0.19456636905670166,
0.4116148054599762,
0.573399007320404,
0.4691045880317688,
0.180629700422287,
1.0079704523086548,
-0.363618940114975,
0.2426457405090332,
1.0195326805114746,
-0.30008935928344727,
1.1949937343597412,
0.29185423254966736,
-0.5260323286056519,
0.3271864652633667,
0.3980284035205841,
-0.38226667046546936,
0.3485173285007477,
0.5444284081459045,
-0.14995494484901428,
-0.33355942368507385,
0.05847841873764992,
-0.3234056234359741,
0.7015374898910522,
0.3277241289615631,
-0.4909072518348694,
-0.23941603302955627,
0.2538203001022339,
-0.24717922508716583,
0.12411323934793472,
-0.2981078028678894,
0.8207994103431702,
-0.012014350853860378,
-0.5324944257736206,
0.7469944357872009,
0.2618003785610199,
0.7579676508903503,
-0.48863717913627625,
-0.18230289220809937,
-0.288949579000473,
0.1274491399526596,
-0.19653166830539703,
-0.7322543263435364,
-0.1282397359609604,
0.41099444031715393,
-0.21383684873580933,
-0.34218284487724304,
0.4623448848724365,
-0.2859088182449341,
-0.5055460333824158,
0.2564278542995453,
0.3834712505340576,
0.052237410098314285,
-0.02449904941022396,
-0.6640714406967163,
0.5179993510246277,
0.25660258531570435,
-0.2076689749956131,
0.6206316947937012,
0.08004920929670334,
0.026156535372138023,
0.7074444890022278,
0.8801913261413574,
-0.36859822273254395,
0.39743006229400635,
0.44034215807914734,
0.8127920627593994,
-0.40137121081352234,
-0.03310021385550499,
-0.6861110329627991,
0.45674654841423035,
-0.0812024399638176,
-0.28882771730422974,
0.6533486843109131,
1.0270737409591675,
0.6814965009689331,
-0.24795261025428772,
0.8225396871566772,
0.018538273870944977,
0.05351262912154198,
-0.8398873209953308,
0.8063638806343079,
-0.6534284353256226,
-0.13309715688228607,
0.16390635073184967,
-0.9569526314735413,
-0.11668306589126587,
0.5062853693962097,
0.10797402262687683,
-0.05023786798119545,
0.5910980105400085,
0.9698706865310669,
-0.030097348615527153,
-0.24925123155117035,
0.5017223358154297,
0.0057839867658913136,
0.27014559507369995,
0.7458558082580566,
0.8536122441291809,
-0.3889700472354889,
0.8448836207389832,
-0.10642445832490921,
-0.14830200374126434,
-0.35051149129867554,
-0.6830839514732361,
-0.9983088374137878,
-0.6403160691261292,
-0.029287079349160194,
-0.13298402726650238,
0.3590436279773712,
0.8906493782997131,
0.8870853185653687,
-0.7285223603248596,
-0.3273000121116638,
0.16612446308135986,
-0.1855480968952179,
-0.09849069267511368,
-0.14523999392986298,
0.16879220306873322,
-0.4251892566680908,
-0.800186812877655,
0.3881579637527466,
0.35884636640548706,
-0.07697052508592606,
-0.5590232610702515,
-0.228685200214386,
0.010719235986471176,
-0.27812719345092773,
0.9256579279899597,
-0.04781884327530861,
-0.7811638712882996,
0.02029700204730034,
-0.14321807026863098,
-0.3816298246383667,
0.17558704316616058,
0.7345459461212158,
-0.38345471024513245,
0.3425337076187134,
0.13808871805667877,
0.8480175733566284,
0.5017656683921814,
-0.03965318948030472,
0.34019744396209717,
-0.7411171197891235,
0.0833953320980072,
0.18563221395015717,
0.3136061429977417,
0.4577482044696808,
0.05399220809340477,
0.38343971967697144,
-0.0665639117360115,
-0.10820861905813217,
-0.5860079526901245,
0.156131774187088,
-0.9675973057746887,
-0.37939441204071045,
1.4468539953231812,
-0.3802322745323181,
-0.060884471982717514,
0.2733006179332733,
-0.01696419157087803,
0.15962742269039154,
-0.189327210187912,
0.532249927520752,
0.3023713231086731,
0.09350273013114929,
-0.4866306781768799,
-0.6676095128059387,
0.20066741108894348,
0.11356833577156067,
-1.1089690923690796,
0.018034959211945534,
0.8214884400367737,
0.22724096477031708,
-0.035092491656541824,
0.3654344081878662,
0.20818987488746643,
0.5665231347084045,
0.07784254103899002,
0.34892991185188293,
-0.22798161208629608,
-0.28231966495513916,
-0.0485747866332531,
0.2598113715648651,
0.08576010912656784,
-0.1806158870458603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20095v1 | LLaRA: Supercharging Robot Learning Data for Vision-Language Policy | 2024-06-28T17:59:12 | 2024-06-28T17:59:12 | Xiang Li, Cristina Mata, Jongwoo Park, Kumara Kahatapitiya, Yoo Sung Jang, Jinghuan Shang, Kanchana Ranasinghe, Ryan Burgert, Mu Cai, Yong Jae Lee, Michael S. Ryoo | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) equipped with extensive world knowledge and
strong reasoning skills can tackle diverse tasks across domains, often by
posing them as conversation-style instruction-response pairs. In this paper, we
propose LLaRA: Large Language and Robotics Assistant, a framework which
formulates robot action policy as conversations, and provides improved
responses when trained with auxiliary data that complements policy learning.
LLMs with visual inputs, i.e., Vision Language Models (VLMs), have the capacity
to process state information as visual-textual prompts and generate optimal
policy decisions in text. To train such action policy VLMs, we first introduce
an automated pipeline to generate diverse high-quality robotics instruction
data from existing behavior cloning data. A VLM finetuned with the resulting
collection of datasets based on a conversation-style formulation tailored for
robotics tasks, can generate meaningful robot action policy decisions. Our
experiments across multiple simulated and real-world environments demonstrate
the state-of-the-art performance of the proposed LLaRA framework. The code,
datasets, and pretrained models are available at
https://github.com/LostXine/LLaRA. | [
-0.007833942770957947,
-0.6955738067626953,
0.6090715527534485,
-0.202828511595726,
0.032342858612537384,
0.15250565111637115,
-0.12839838862419128,
-0.18385903537273407,
0.6665602922439575,
0.9792293310165405,
-0.6969588994979858,
-0.3886428773403168,
-0.4855884313583374,
-0.04988105595111847,
-0.4262431859970093,
0.772020697593689,
0.12776879966259003,
0.1168108582496643,
-0.09121369570493698,
-0.0004784319316968322,
-0.34588006138801575,
-0.3175954818725586,
-0.47349637746810913,
-0.41479045152664185,
0.684240460395813,
0.5452775359153748,
0.6678285002708435,
0.44776222109794617,
0.6194559335708618,
0.36332640051841736,
0.00672207260504365,
0.7478153705596924,
-0.5542653799057007,
0.09071976691484451,
-0.2747437357902527,
-0.601680338382721,
-0.5465449094772339,
-0.514631986618042,
0.6776857972145081,
0.400984525680542,
-0.2954845130443573,
-0.05367404222488403,
-0.07589643448591232,
0.579230010509491,
-0.5701072812080383,
0.3549851179122925,
-0.613571047782898,
0.0938219279050827,
0.20275214314460754,
-0.3561229407787323,
-0.36321404576301575,
-0.07305645942687988,
0.10339682549238205,
-0.6729286909103394,
-0.16467614471912384,
-0.04734957218170166,
1.1514029502868652,
0.5443071722984314,
-0.12735037505626678,
-0.08668652921915054,
-0.6701899170875549,
0.7765680551528931,
-0.4643409848213196,
0.06363274157047272,
0.3760532736778259,
0.389851838350296,
-0.38395363092422485,
-0.45164719223976135,
-0.9202829003334045,
-0.23849761486053467,
0.019913015887141228,
0.4119192063808441,
-0.4257970154285431,
0.2654673457145691,
0.10841498523950577,
0.0876401737332344,
-0.4484691023826599,
0.3940408527851105,
-0.3845262825489044,
-0.15661364793777466,
0.7233790755271912,
0.48942333459854126,
0.11180015653371811,
-0.14613579213619232,
-0.2753656506538391,
-0.5088512301445007,
-0.8201650381088257,
-0.09889546036720276,
0.4717644453048706,
0.41635480523109436,
-0.1358521282672882,
0.7752928733825684,
-0.5906085968017578,
0.6997884511947632,
-0.3584223687648773,
-0.3148643374443054,
0.2333911657333374,
-0.3375980854034424,
-0.3041647970676422,
-0.4184826910495758,
0.9113382697105408,
0.5723963975906372,
0.4001525342464447,
0.10359414666891098,
-0.12169895321130753,
0.2181510031223297,
0.37736988067626953,
-0.5511103272438049,
-0.07206515967845917,
0.0925670713186264,
0.04664534330368042,
-0.23309440910816193,
-0.2999590039253235,
-0.7340531349182129,
-0.4685171842575073,
-0.5466690063476562,
0.3152115046977997,
-0.13605228066444397,
-0.0022011487744748592,
0.3267832100391388,
0.08654747158288956,
0.37165459990501404,
0.4750717878341675,
-0.8661096692085266,
0.013718487694859505,
0.5119625329971313,
0.48528215289115906,
-0.228655606508255,
-0.46318748593330383,
-0.6582240462303162,
0.33862000703811646,
-0.5094858407974243,
0.7607399821281433,
-0.8735041618347168,
-0.33142000436782837,
0.27686217427253723,
0.1775357872247696,
0.07555986195802689,
-0.5117005705833435,
-0.1171879917383194,
-0.32740965485572815,
-0.06647834926843643,
0.10832136869430542,
-0.2504008710384369,
-0.27415695786476135,
0.4609373211860657,
-0.6240284442901611,
0.7529616951942444,
0.029060905799269676,
-0.10772879421710968,
0.35475683212280273,
-0.7382718920707703,
-0.4232330322265625,
0.1502101570367813,
-0.4494904577732086,
-0.37264198064804077,
-0.3779979646205902,
0.3121274411678314,
0.887790322303772,
-0.2802869975566864,
0.5143209099769592,
-0.06028098985552788,
-0.12946930527687073,
0.039227601140737534,
-0.5228582620620728,
0.601548433303833,
-0.0703209862112999,
-0.035677582025527954,
0.5023558735847473,
-0.6998640298843384,
-0.20289914309978485,
0.2247333526611328,
-0.3093956410884857,
0.12716816365718842,
0.14043530821800232,
-0.28632646799087524,
-0.10541677474975586,
0.415487676858902,
-0.4784277677536011,
0.4300362765789032,
-0.2808094918727875,
0.4517843723297119,
0.830763041973114,
-0.3129112422466278,
0.317332923412323,
-0.02887391671538353,
0.6353316307067871,
-0.3229686915874481,
0.18484121561050415,
-0.32985416054725647,
-0.29032251238822937,
-0.9566225409507751,
-0.21106892824172974,
-0.15407490730285645,
0.8789088726043701,
-1.186562180519104,
0.45613574981689453,
-0.4153519868850708,
-0.27925238013267517,
-0.41323086619377136,
0.3548690378665924,
0.5352599024772644,
0.4788578748703003,
0.4111104905605316,
-0.19573844969272614,
-0.5547177195549011,
-0.9050889015197754,
0.2611066699028015,
-0.2805800139904022,
-0.01515149138867855,
0.527134120464325,
0.5373410582542419,
-0.34847187995910645,
0.9284977912902832,
-0.4633650779724121,
-0.4601883590221405,
-0.8568031191825867,
-0.2625867426395416,
-0.09444212913513184,
0.13926927745342255,
0.16492398083209991,
-0.6538619995117188,
-0.01077148225158453,
0.12565036118030548,
-0.9768252372741699,
0.2373112440109253,
-0.2987256646156311,
-0.2276047319173813,
0.3846271336078644,
0.61930251121521,
-0.5790115594863892,
0.5504686832427979,
0.7102141380310059,
0.13737516105175018,
0.43731606006622314,
-0.2646557092666626,
-0.1210896298289299,
-1.127700924873352,
-0.139845609664917,
-0.04644026234745979,
-0.10928019136190414,
-0.45201045274734497,
0.3838445842266083,
-0.42249518632888794,
-0.13593000173568726,
-0.8389448523521423,
0.502487301826477,
0.037341613322496414,
-0.3703869581222534,
-0.3028982877731323,
0.1708604395389557,
-0.033720459789037704,
0.7100241184234619,
0.48976653814315796,
0.9117327928543091,
0.6097520589828491,
-0.7460556626319885,
0.6474781632423401,
0.3364199101924896,
-0.3518770635128021,
0.3498503565788269,
-0.6211655735969543,
-0.10065486282110214,
0.04296844080090523,
0.518057644367218,
-0.7706713676452637,
-0.5946733951568604,
0.34670108556747437,
-0.11791909486055374,
-0.04250844568014145,
-0.0068407668732106686,
-0.624927282333374,
-0.4572378396987915,
0.02874794602394104,
-0.13724756240844727,
0.4385869801044464,
-0.5470291376113892,
0.909996747970581,
0.7129917144775391,
-0.004166039638221264,
-0.6765849590301514,
-0.7352516055107117,
0.2821725904941559,
-0.08756669610738754,
-0.36321690678596497,
0.10048848390579224,
0.11026500165462494,
-0.0008664727210998535,
-0.28971418738365173,
0.1461435705423355,
-0.1593344509601593,
-0.12526069581508636,
0.0015335931675508618,
0.5918647050857544,
0.07762380689382553,
0.10986995697021484,
-0.024768155068159103,
-0.3003297448158264,
-0.05059532821178436,
0.23578912019729614,
0.9291236400604248,
-0.11556689441204071,
-0.35433271527290344,
-0.7563174366950989,
0.10610342025756836,
0.5129760503768921,
-0.08953262120485306,
0.39258861541748047,
0.2363968789577484,
0.08416039496660233,
-0.18230560421943665,
-0.18659333884716034,
-0.3148670196533203,
-0.5277515649795532,
0.6476839780807495,
-0.23087573051452637,
-0.9148886203765869,
0.12474912405014038,
-0.2288413643836975,
0.5000307559967041,
-0.09482084214687347,
0.5240539908409119,
-0.3217649459838867,
0.7822360992431641,
0.8519985675811768,
-0.1952604204416275,
0.7129865884780884,
-0.6659607887268066,
0.2910592257976532,
-0.655491292476654,
-0.3812313973903656,
-0.05052676796913147,
-0.26072239875793457,
-0.4731447398662567,
-0.5861576199531555,
0.23394028842449188,
-0.47512203454971313,
-0.2762717008590698,
0.5575732588768005,
-0.26001033186912537,
0.6745805144309998,
0.481894314289093,
0.2989552915096283,
0.07208842784166336,
0.3281414806842804,
0.31953758001327515,
0.1871272474527359,
-0.9058160185813904,
-0.6325801014900208,
1.154865026473999,
0.07694250345230103,
0.8775289058685303,
-0.3358760178089142,
0.6788443922996521,
0.1308261901140213,
-0.20823901891708374,
-1.1421445608139038,
1.1383639574050903,
-0.3536560833454132,
0.020602108910679817,
-0.5756110548973083,
-0.3789072334766388,
-1.0370844602584839,
0.2864954173564911,
-0.2192671149969101,
-0.6192836761474609,
-0.06288477033376694,
0.5590683221817017,
-0.45960357785224915,
0.38800564408302307,
-0.46771693229675293,
0.579261839389801,
-0.26362934708595276,
-0.38954460620880127,
-0.5687207579612732,
-0.6567497253417969,
0.23485977947711945,
0.32259780168533325,
-0.0773502066731453,
-0.12170396745204926,
-0.02801990695297718,
0.4474378526210785,
-0.27704739570617676,
1.305840253829956,
-0.014108735136687756,
-0.35633400082588196,
0.42720887064933777,
0.09123307466506958,
0.6315770745277405,
-0.4134724736213684,
0.27789103984832764,
0.331211119890213,
-0.5088001489639282,
-0.19459247589111328,
-0.5444010496139526,
0.27391374111175537,
-0.5882529616355896,
-0.5604201555252075,
-0.08601813018321991,
-0.7159783840179443,
-0.20331238210201263,
-0.07214562594890594,
-0.0949983149766922,
0.3245796859264374,
-0.04349662736058235,
0.23455163836479187,
0.8247860074043274,
-0.4417853057384491,
0.34153175354003906,
0.7405060529708862,
-0.31306418776512146,
-0.06053967401385307,
1.5588014125823975,
0.01303139328956604,
0.4814585745334625,
0.5523444414138794,
0.09049203246831894,
0.011798838153481483,
-0.09811195731163025,
-0.5511367321014404,
0.027318932116031647,
-0.4632001221179962,
-0.2721059322357178,
-0.5039058327674866,
-0.2865839898586273,
-0.13749563694000244,
-0.2522587478160858,
-0.48624783754348755,
-0.20034387707710266,
-0.1635197550058365,
-0.10720236599445343,
0.6180751323699951,
0.5527150630950928,
-0.10996773093938828,
0.6799467206001282,
-0.34158143401145935,
0.6229426860809326,
0.521511971950531,
-0.08439289033412933,
-0.2753065228462219,
-0.4234287142753601,
0.09590094536542892,
0.0697614997625351,
-0.2005157470703125,
-0.1387569159269333,
0.5367382764816284,
0.16770359873771667,
0.30012351274490356,
0.18986262381076813,
-0.18245741724967957,
0.7592452168464661,
-0.6527422070503235,
0.6923980116844177,
0.3216056525707245,
-0.5445215106010437,
0.8345609307289124,
-0.18865422904491425,
0.2773842513561249,
0.30338478088378906,
0.12363285571336746,
-0.2624446749687195,
-0.5884099006652832,
-0.45966166257858276,
-1.0913763046264648,
0.6727379560470581,
-0.13024531304836273,
0.546517014503479,
0.17982642352581024,
-0.10989247262477875,
-0.028510116040706635,
0.2414432317018509,
-0.47086718678474426,
-0.029334863647818565,
0.06047237664461136,
-0.28037452697753906,
0.08922474086284637,
-0.07422584295272827,
-0.22665129601955414,
-0.11118519306182861,
0.44765505194664,
-0.41130542755126953,
0.07020677626132965,
-0.16526494920253754,
-0.12907639145851135,
0.4035096764564514,
0.09872336685657501,
0.4737226068973541,
0.42007580399513245,
0.2747308611869812,
-0.3046157658100128,
0.19776365160942078,
-0.5300533175468445,
-0.021837620064616203,
-0.4345388114452362,
-0.35255876183509827,
-0.34088605642318726,
0.3352101445198059,
0.8718339204788208,
0.19775764644145966,
-1.146096110343933,
0.40952110290527344,
0.16461554169654846,
-0.2942947745323181,
-0.32537606358528137,
0.6868918538093567,
-0.22999821603298187,
0.2579377591609955,
-0.03687659651041031,
-0.03271222114562988,
0.11222939193248749,
-0.6163405179977417,
0.22295497357845306,
0.412063866853714,
-0.22651024162769318,
0.05867194011807442,
0.1421220749616623,
0.37624871730804443,
-0.2863617539405823,
0.5252181887626648,
0.05930861458182335,
-0.45539548993110657,
0.7822093963623047,
0.33127477765083313,
0.4691048264503479,
-0.019894808530807495,
0.6376328468322754,
0.18257620930671692,
0.36370858550071716,
-0.035795822739601135,
0.49106788635253906,
-0.16538460552692413,
-0.9098955988883972,
-0.7075823545455933,
-0.4666720926761627,
-0.8342294096946716,
0.19673676788806915,
-0.58653724193573,
0.1036088764667511,
-0.6007977724075317,
0.06533457338809967,
-0.43422794342041016,
-0.2431969940662384,
-0.6121160387992859,
0.10295352339744568,
0.17957954108715057,
0.45390784740448,
-0.820862352848053,
0.8258950114250183,
0.39669322967529297,
-0.5712193250656128,
-0.7235199809074402,
-0.0982227623462677,
-0.15114030241966248,
-1.4475947618484497,
0.7846051454544067,
0.07684274017810822,
-0.7053167819976807,
-0.15744361281394958,
-1.0683984756469727,
-0.8109123110771179,
0.8798718452453613,
0.6399927139282227,
-0.9812831878662109,
0.007723404094576836,
0.1952580362558365,
0.41378453373908997,
-0.3548387289047241,
0.016256483271718025,
0.7510034441947937,
0.2897089123725891,
0.20240245759487152,
-0.8243144154548645,
-0.45715466141700745,
-0.047517769038677216,
0.018164217472076416,
-0.06500411033630371,
-1.0002992153167725,
0.2874602973461151,
-0.3432747721672058,
-0.047645311802625656,
0.11161063611507416,
0.8325067162513733,
0.42969152331352234,
0.027355698868632317,
0.2926941514015198,
0.5440096259117126,
0.7376781105995178,
-0.015501158311963081,
1.1416852474212646,
-0.11355644464492798,
-0.23590922355651855,
1.1973572969436646,
-0.49784451723098755,
1.1920411586761475,
0.49339786171913147,
-0.07590556889772415,
0.6904013752937317,
0.20558048784732819,
-0.11211153119802475,
0.49099230766296387,
0.06456633657217026,
-0.051347263157367706,
-0.5344967842102051,
-0.4649171233177185,
-0.027046196162700653,
0.8151839971542358,
0.6689263582229614,
-0.036481644958257675,
-0.03550614416599274,
0.2169572114944458,
0.06164577975869179,
0.1894282102584839,
-0.35557296872138977,
0.7753231525421143,
-0.17364323139190674,
-0.5004705190658569,
0.34941738843917847,
-0.45438048243522644,
0.6720734238624573,
-0.7445757389068604,
-0.506354033946991,
-0.3551754951477051,
0.14381706714630127,
-0.07682429254055023,
-1.0993245840072632,
0.11268709599971771,
0.2069818675518036,
-0.09521298855543137,
-0.29541242122650146,
0.28161653876304626,
-0.4753217399120331,
-0.4835580587387085,
0.2739547789096832,
0.16613519191741943,
0.49859490990638733,
0.5617638826370239,
-0.6529704928398132,
0.29415175318717957,
0.09115758538246155,
-0.17456960678100586,
0.34356266260147095,
0.08628194034099579,
-0.00397260207682848,
1.1872143745422363,
0.6249397397041321,
0.15353690087795258,
-0.05091650411486626,
0.2940596044063568,
0.9008710384368896,
-0.34642621874809265,
-0.4016604721546173,
-0.5253922939300537,
0.47751516103744507,
-0.22526396811008453,
-0.48473939299583435,
0.4570353627204895,
0.27269312739372253,
0.9701648354530334,
0.12597821652889252,
0.6292955279350281,
0.11483786255121231,
0.33790135383605957,
-0.949923038482666,
0.41826605796813965,
-0.634921669960022,
0.15387499332427979,
0.008819101378321648,
-0.7497830986976624,
-0.28691366314888,
0.9498214721679688,
-0.2645784616470337,
-0.17524564266204834,
0.2999865710735321,
1.1219645738601685,
0.09712401777505875,
-0.36011984944343567,
0.48070228099823,
0.013722902163863182,
0.28765422105789185,
0.5644801259040833,
0.7144477963447571,
-0.21664346754550934,
0.7975190281867981,
0.07222874462604523,
-0.018704991787672043,
-0.28908100724220276,
-0.5510339736938477,
-0.8071945905685425,
-0.2979596257209778,
-0.19215092062950134,
0.04066194221377373,
0.36696040630340576,
0.759955644607544,
0.7000970244407654,
-0.49861830472946167,
-0.4528273642063141,
-0.408761590719223,
0.06713525950908661,
0.011079365387558937,
-0.1788967251777649,
0.28152039647102356,
-0.4279261529445648,
-0.8548350930213928,
0.896261990070343,
0.36533603072166443,
-0.09130793064832687,
-0.5740019679069519,
-0.27674490213394165,
0.060125790536403656,
0.09544260799884796,
0.8469701409339905,
0.5258907675743103,
-0.9132766127586365,
-0.07368821650743484,
-0.21888364851474762,
-0.11006134748458862,
0.02492675557732582,
0.5045580863952637,
-1.0333863496780396,
0.5399788618087769,
0.2558947503566742,
0.7768411040306091,
0.19736523926258087,
-0.39349502325057983,
0.753130316734314,
-0.49121594429016113,
0.37938982248306274,
0.18406344950199127,
0.4094637930393219,
0.22510191798210144,
-0.1471642404794693,
0.6809366345405579,
-0.08223825693130493,
-0.2397286295890808,
-0.8691335320472717,
0.5125662684440613,
-0.8120318055152893,
-0.15935634076595306,
1.2456750869750977,
-0.1255767047405243,
-0.43703457713127136,
0.18503624200820923,
-0.4409882128238678,
-0.13455577194690704,
-0.515321671962738,
0.5897312164306641,
0.35900962352752686,
-0.16782787442207336,
-0.23809821903705597,
-0.6408452391624451,
0.08767061680555344,
0.5359379649162292,
-0.9667996168136597,
0.2961171567440033,
0.6542707085609436,
-0.3515521287918091,
0.08340566605329514,
0.4018729031085968,
0.2644018232822418,
0.41238728165626526,
0.11561465263366699,
0.1679770052433014,
0.04374079778790474,
-1.1112130880355835,
-0.2064041793346405,
-0.1311822086572647,
-0.39580535888671875,
-0.2947124242782593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20094v1 | Scaling Synthetic Data Creation with 1,000,000,000 Personas | 2024-06-28T17:59:01 | 2024-06-28T17:59:01 | Xin Chan, Xiaoyang Wang, Dian Yu, Haitao Mi, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel persona-driven data synthesis methodology that leverages
various perspectives within a large language model (LLM) to create diverse
synthetic data. To fully exploit this methodology at scale, we introduce
Persona Hub -- a collection of 1 billion diverse personas automatically curated
from web data. These 1 billion personas (~13% of the world's total population),
acting as distributed carriers of world knowledge, can tap into almost every
perspective encapsulated within the LLM, thereby facilitating the creation of
diverse synthetic data at scale for various scenarios. By showcasing Persona
Hub's use cases in synthesizing high-quality mathematical and logical reasoning
problems, instructions (i.e., user prompts), knowledge-rich texts, game NPCs
and tools (functions) at scale, we demonstrate persona-driven data synthesis is
versatile, scalable, flexible, and easy to use, potentially driving a paradigm
shift in synthetic data creation and applications in practice, which may have a
profound impact on LLM research and development. | [
-0.6946755647659302,
-0.7320797443389893,
0.7547991871833801,
0.6019163131713867,
0.45852935314178467,
0.27828681468963623,
0.0776694118976593,
-0.29271724820137024,
0.38635575771331787,
0.6143233776092529,
-0.8679214119911194,
-0.4043411910533905,
0.018439510837197304,
0.13486440479755402,
-0.35424211621284485,
0.8667190670967102,
0.4020848572254181,
0.08576405793428421,
-0.40241163969039917,
0.06087203323841095,
-0.14620429277420044,
-0.5000014901161194,
-0.5892841219902039,
-0.17199647426605225,
0.9181264042854309,
0.5454148650169373,
0.4873998165130615,
0.6688797473907471,
0.28642207384109497,
0.33935919404029846,
0.37176966667175293,
0.14233089983463287,
-0.6133278608322144,
0.20088529586791992,
-0.45259609818458557,
-0.48018574714660645,
-0.8799748420715332,
0.21518565714359283,
0.6574825048446655,
1.052844524383545,
0.30333057045936584,
0.38543474674224854,
-0.23654945194721222,
0.8048035502433777,
-0.3119714856147766,
0.20654810965061188,
-0.4161469042301178,
0.0938933715224266,
-0.23479361832141876,
0.1421026587486267,
-0.7201710939407349,
-0.3645634055137634,
0.15976805984973907,
-0.7376623153686523,
0.04746586084365845,
0.25326070189476013,
-0.12256013602018356,
0.13219092786312103,
-0.3835126757621765,
0.1726563423871994,
-1.1512881517410278,
0.622566282749176,
-0.3335907459259033,
0.25864022970199585,
0.0030197971500456333,
0.8043657541275024,
-0.2239980250597,
-0.8254275321960449,
-0.8829529881477356,
0.18137821555137634,
0.18087580800056458,
-0.015195317566394806,
-0.17425976693630219,
-0.3618599772453308,
0.4578108787536621,
0.15771913528442383,
-0.585519015789032,
-0.059359826147556305,
-0.19988639652729034,
-0.19785182178020477,
0.7535111308097839,
0.6197381615638733,
0.1924876868724823,
-0.1466437429189682,
-0.023547634482383728,
-0.1768980473279953,
-0.8837425708770752,
-0.16897305846214294,
0.4797481298446655,
0.40831977128982544,
0.12444527447223663,
0.6760507225990295,
-0.2664980888366699,
0.5712336301803589,
0.40474551916122437,
-0.359732985496521,
0.1292247623205185,
-0.46011966466903687,
-0.02972455695271492,
-0.12158422917127609,
0.9583054184913635,
0.4380098283290863,
-0.06965262442827225,
-0.21565692126750946,
0.14153102040290833,
0.13861478865146637,
0.414957195520401,
-0.9302969574928284,
-0.32536551356315613,
0.4470469057559967,
-0.18085433542728424,
-0.23871098458766937,
-0.09861361235380173,
-1.1127873659133911,
-0.804474949836731,
-0.5394654273986816,
0.10630419105291367,
-0.33304324746131897,
-0.1994311362504959,
0.12108786404132843,
0.10189837962388992,
0.28068241477012634,
0.3498232960700989,
-0.8119235038757324,
0.4323139488697052,
0.5127613544464111,
0.4362674951553345,
-0.3231066167354584,
-0.3438534736633301,
-0.30574721097946167,
0.2047172337770462,
-0.40610527992248535,
0.7879485487937927,
-0.31075188517570496,
-0.4626709222793579,
-0.2783258259296417,
-0.19875313341617584,
0.2719488739967346,
-0.6056786179542542,
0.08400607109069824,
-0.09055521339178085,
0.14798377454280853,
-0.5313151478767395,
-0.42914852499961853,
0.3322862386703491,
0.3215370774269104,
-0.8114879727363586,
0.8654289841651917,
0.5277367830276489,
-0.49538201093673706,
0.33964186906814575,
-0.5400984287261963,
-0.4976874589920044,
0.3834192752838135,
-0.13213889300823212,
0.03749391809105873,
-0.0331425741314888,
0.2778882682323456,
0.31961533427238464,
-0.6457028388977051,
0.401591420173645,
-0.1796368658542633,
-0.04711371660232544,
0.6393066048622131,
0.16945195198059082,
0.6489635705947876,
0.3067110478878021,
-0.08246562629938126,
0.06978892534971237,
-0.9792270660400391,
0.06303826719522476,
0.01769314892590046,
-0.22546476125717163,
0.05040133371949196,
-0.10349128395318985,
0.3615148365497589,
0.39970290660858154,
0.4042517840862274,
-0.7114722728729248,
0.4042258858680725,
-0.40074750781059265,
0.5176163911819458,
0.5104965567588806,
0.14494387805461884,
0.729785144329071,
-0.5467308759689331,
0.6125621795654297,
-0.08629923313856125,
0.025464612990617752,
-0.31841006875038147,
-0.3873075842857361,
-0.6420229077339172,
-0.41454529762268066,
0.12651197612285614,
0.4413122534751892,
-0.588650643825531,
0.8236204385757446,
-0.6437397599220276,
-0.8848634958267212,
-0.5285308957099915,
-0.1979568600654602,
0.03408847004175186,
0.6790171265602112,
0.12423602491617203,
-0.10079719871282578,
-0.7868884801864624,
-1.2210369110107422,
-0.217039093375206,
-0.10943273454904556,
-0.6207876801490784,
0.4195740222930908,
0.4762263894081116,
-0.4947105944156647,
1.4414488077163696,
-0.6898844242095947,
-0.20195043087005615,
-0.4911758601665497,
-0.08874500542879105,
-0.020079320296645164,
0.6840462684631348,
0.5901066064834595,
-0.6266996264457703,
-0.6994746327400208,
0.030007265508174896,
-0.7218156456947327,
-0.18936434388160706,
-0.45018622279167175,
-0.5029070973396301,
-0.17046433687210083,
0.46495768427848816,
-0.7479965090751648,
-0.0026884363032877445,
0.24041081964969635,
-0.20186635851860046,
0.5707578659057617,
-0.04550766572356224,
0.10290095955133438,
-1.336373209953308,
0.2934592366218567,
0.006906013935804367,
-0.1640225201845169,
-0.759781539440155,
0.33412909507751465,
-0.08043172955513,
-0.4846281111240387,
-0.4202779233455658,
0.7479337453842163,
-0.016425080597400665,
-0.10814979672431946,
0.10677036643028259,
0.11336905509233475,
-0.012119881808757782,
0.5647305250167847,
-0.1635725498199463,
0.6958484649658203,
0.5028473138809204,
-0.3857741951942444,
0.47623372077941895,
0.3835005760192871,
-0.3878578841686249,
1.037672519683838,
-0.6606889963150024,
0.2716863453388214,
-0.11156531423330307,
0.678723156452179,
-1.127474069595337,
-0.7189083099365234,
0.057679615914821625,
-0.2813461124897003,
-0.19774816930294037,
0.11584924161434174,
-0.973490297794342,
-0.39552390575408936,
-0.13484415411949158,
0.4337414801120758,
0.5240161418914795,
-0.3917717933654785,
0.8704966902732849,
0.8424752354621887,
-0.2924460768699646,
0.30569276213645935,
-0.7639515995979309,
0.36901938915252686,
-0.35766705870628357,
-0.7172238230705261,
0.4551422894001007,
-0.488746702671051,
-0.39166635274887085,
-0.3920497000217438,
0.018420739099383354,
0.011669832281768322,
-0.2600243389606476,
0.29821813106536865,
0.08581995964050293,
0.2188064157962799,
-0.14635097980499268,
0.08559584617614746,
-0.1025594100356102,
0.23971587419509888,
-0.5830824971199036,
0.7656999230384827,
0.05162151902914047,
-0.18343113362789154,
-0.22325830161571503,
0.4715037941932678,
1.0122747421264648,
0.02969086728990078,
0.6641047596931458,
0.31448355317115784,
-0.3856079578399658,
-0.39970001578330994,
-0.3687989115715027,
-0.10040701180696487,
-0.5331618189811707,
0.15625321865081787,
-0.44392824172973633,
-0.7844005823135376,
0.9464934468269348,
-0.3709205389022827,
0.20991583168506622,
0.2831653356552124,
0.6500247120857239,
0.13692328333854675,
1.0953763723373413,
0.5112682580947876,
-0.06802567839622498,
0.06700436770915985,
-0.13582676649093628,
0.4402290880680084,
-0.7097398638725281,
-0.4481099843978882,
-0.3936978876590729,
-0.7475246787071228,
-0.76287442445755,
-0.7017902135848999,
0.7353795766830444,
-0.6984634399414062,
-0.46478763222694397,
0.43119385838508606,
-0.47942155599594116,
0.5138815641403198,
0.5639488101005554,
0.15124322474002838,
0.21230369806289673,
-0.05589618533849716,
0.07195549458265305,
-0.5066139101982117,
-0.4027270972728729,
-0.329788476228714,
1.3844578266143799,
0.02072516828775406,
0.5291361212730408,
0.190926194190979,
0.531690776348114,
0.17859865725040436,
0.2547569274902344,
-0.8157972693443298,
0.9359017014503479,
0.05539880692958832,
-0.6968276500701904,
-0.2543668746948242,
-0.5091168284416199,
-0.8275256156921387,
0.00784101989120245,
-0.2237146943807602,
-0.6425089240074158,
0.011752364225685596,
0.058424532413482666,
-0.37523677945137024,
0.060868702828884125,
-0.5322345495223999,
0.7072320580482483,
0.17429868876934052,
-0.4275636672973633,
-0.055996064096689224,
-0.6525223255157471,
0.34569618105888367,
-0.5845155119895935,
0.18107950687408447,
0.12047609686851501,
0.015090426430106163,
0.6577544808387756,
-0.34792155027389526,
0.6806522607803345,
-0.011242610402405262,
-0.25829190015792847,
0.26532647013664246,
0.46786198019981384,
0.44992879033088684,
0.2535725235939026,
-0.08344848453998566,
-0.2054489552974701,
-0.3606289327144623,
-0.4097447097301483,
-0.7099902629852295,
0.9422453045845032,
-0.5596161484718323,
-0.4510897994041443,
0.016932295635342598,
-1.081142544746399,
-0.7389174103736877,
0.26470625400543213,
0.1758102923631668,
0.22457678616046906,
-0.5105251669883728,
0.32583919167518616,
0.6185951828956604,
-0.47384360432624817,
-0.07492303103208542,
0.46306315064430237,
-0.512352466583252,
-0.4490157663822174,
1.0236722230911255,
0.07453961670398712,
0.118538036942482,
0.5333005785942078,
0.026113329455256462,
-0.1048194095492363,
-0.08687864989042282,
-0.40983572602272034,
0.1062789037823677,
-0.43570151925086975,
0.07603055238723755,
-0.752731204032898,
-0.05457326024770737,
-0.5484496355056763,
-0.47146525979042053,
-0.5618127584457397,
-0.6118478775024414,
0.13982611894607544,
-0.08927924185991287,
0.16576527059078217,
0.5091097950935364,
0.17670606076717377,
0.4068359136581421,
-0.3940672278404236,
0.39649268984794617,
0.4194745719432831,
0.12202543765306473,
-0.10203190892934799,
-0.19387449324131012,
-0.11649417132139206,
0.08498819172382355,
-0.12227466702461243,
-0.7143905758857727,
0.7048594951629639,
-0.08009076863527298,
0.1746261566877365,
0.30157390236854553,
-0.04929831251502037,
0.6705129742622375,
-0.7402060031890869,
0.7650649547576904,
0.015653029084205627,
-0.7868923544883728,
0.5326355695724487,
-0.9503092169761658,
0.795832633972168,
0.5064143538475037,
0.3362959325313568,
-0.5557186007499695,
-0.4734044671058655,
-0.48313239216804504,
-0.8097517490386963,
0.5614030957221985,
0.1557454913854599,
0.17160183191299438,
0.008193055167794228,
0.389610230922699,
0.43449610471725464,
0.28548380732536316,
-0.472821444272995,
-0.41769641637802124,
0.038954444229602814,
-0.30711284279823303,
-0.02027004398405552,
0.0874522253870964,
-0.07876276224851608,
-0.5415371656417847,
0.2805117964744568,
-0.2929959297180176,
0.2547346353530884,
-0.2829835116863251,
0.2484779804944992,
-0.09682989865541458,
0.03364177793264389,
0.1320374608039856,
0.8057884573936462,
0.0745675265789032,
0.04719696193933487,
-0.19601771235466003,
-0.4705950915813446,
0.19403380155563354,
0.05109623074531555,
-0.5527634024620056,
-0.4478197991847992,
-0.014537423849105835,
0.5092894434928894,
0.40200579166412354,
-1.0102837085723877,
-0.07042871415615082,
-0.07238585501909256,
-0.35158008337020874,
-0.34708547592163086,
0.10271095484495163,
0.42304477095603943,
0.19293271005153656,
0.4438627064228058,
0.17125184834003448,
0.0492166206240654,
-0.6456851959228516,
0.2847500741481781,
0.17086373269557953,
0.17130745947360992,
-0.6444395780563354,
0.8977034091949463,
0.1315889060497284,
-0.2188369333744049,
0.7810311913490295,
-0.08047275245189667,
-0.0509081594645977,
0.4578927159309387,
0.5132502913475037,
0.6636621952056885,
-0.12854349613189697,
0.5266450047492981,
0.4804404675960541,
0.0072550405748188496,
-0.04446675628423691,
0.13555318117141724,
0.2075643241405487,
-0.6719223260879517,
-0.2985727787017822,
-0.7229827046394348,
-0.4935294985771179,
0.29664450883865356,
-0.5424728393554688,
0.06330044567584991,
-0.8537224531173706,
-0.11704182624816895,
0.4921687841415405,
0.04411468282341957,
-0.7001708745956421,
0.004504541866481304,
-0.18033483624458313,
0.6893316507339478,
-0.7586206197738647,
0.654965341091156,
0.7286174297332764,
-0.24648678302764893,
-0.6372165083885193,
-0.05378250032663345,
0.28731775283813477,
-0.39026492834091187,
0.45463064312934875,
0.012246102094650269,
0.3018663227558136,
0.24165545403957367,
-0.6928799152374268,
-0.7855702042579651,
0.9604297876358032,
0.5740030407905579,
-0.5354018211364746,
0.031636469066143036,
0.6864041090011597,
0.9107528924942017,
-0.8065680861473083,
-0.49083027243614197,
0.7045066356658936,
0.5449144244194031,
0.33511388301849365,
-0.6309913992881775,
-0.040743205696344376,
-0.3116510808467865,
-0.13403883576393127,
0.11227978020906448,
-0.5498356223106384,
0.961681604385376,
-0.03232939913868904,
-0.03138367086648941,
0.10827311128377914,
0.41117867827415466,
0.42053818702697754,
0.054390277713537216,
0.2875271439552307,
0.6819066405296326,
0.6751036047935486,
0.09083940833806992,
0.92498779296875,
-0.20339195430278778,
-0.07185583561658859,
1.1521904468536377,
-0.677574634552002,
0.4463919699192047,
0.34079262614250183,
-0.576655924320221,
0.4842611253261566,
0.4129728078842163,
-0.05115877464413643,
0.22465363144874573,
0.18279725313186646,
-0.4552401006221771,
-0.3998328447341919,
-0.17802923917770386,
0.1612744778394699,
0.43228814005851746,
0.46668753027915955,
-0.13279958069324493,
-0.06136427819728851,
0.17692719399929047,
-0.045338936150074005,
0.2022874355316162,
-0.1299707293510437,
0.5894519686698914,
-0.19027061760425568,
-0.7964626550674438,
0.09850966185331345,
-0.0879053995013237,
0.10764148831367493,
-0.3595959544181824,
0.11973042786121368,
-0.4722594618797302,
0.23684272170066833,
0.085240438580513,
-0.7734121084213257,
0.19955791532993317,
0.030840083956718445,
-0.33011534810066223,
-0.6804983019828796,
0.40742290019989014,
-0.4045732617378235,
-0.7194912433624268,
-0.2466277927160263,
0.8984777331352234,
0.2508269250392914,
-0.2551039755344391,
-0.2833333909511566,
-0.01028335839509964,
0.034731701016426086,
-0.12436904013156891,
0.7714901566505432,
0.6198965311050415,
-0.21564409136772156,
0.9356383681297302,
0.6772868633270264,
0.03790644556283951,
-0.17210741341114044,
-0.0971372127532959,
1.0121854543685913,
-0.6309429407119751,
-0.4897805154323578,
-0.6056081652641296,
0.5400832295417786,
-0.013303413055837154,
-0.20956040918827057,
1.066666603088379,
0.8043679594993591,
0.748076319694519,
-0.3493383824825287,
0.9426252245903015,
-0.4077432155609131,
0.5369202494621277,
0.19399338960647583,
0.5701747536659241,
-0.2403848022222519,
0.15080268681049347,
-0.387306272983551,
-1.0464099645614624,
-0.24691590666770935,
0.4328007102012634,
-0.02477205917239189,
-0.23383840918540955,
0.35404258966445923,
0.6963323950767517,
0.02111290767788887,
-0.0737944096326828,
0.239010751247406,
0.21848368644714355,
0.5384798049926758,
0.5440357327461243,
0.30583974719047546,
-0.23327182233333588,
0.27239203453063965,
-0.1545870304107666,
-0.19551052153110504,
0.13267438113689423,
-0.5757521986961365,
-0.8936589956283569,
-0.8952752351760864,
-0.3202270567417145,
-0.10668424516916275,
-0.7059735059738159,
0.7807375192642212,
0.6471734642982483,
-0.6735804080963135,
-0.18800672888755798,
-0.3115164637565613,
-0.22304746508598328,
-0.01883593574166298,
-0.25837382674217224,
-0.006569310557097197,
0.12499362975358963,
-1.071540117263794,
0.575715959072113,
0.3738812506198883,
-0.0953584536910057,
-0.9378902912139893,
0.0751262903213501,
0.17479859292507172,
0.27164480090141296,
0.8475590944290161,
0.22759483754634857,
-0.3763021230697632,
-0.0025519386399537325,
0.39869898557662964,
-0.08668673038482666,
-0.16167359054088593,
0.9810739755630493,
-1.1916329860687256,
0.46663710474967957,
0.5545156598091125,
0.5629130005836487,
0.4909166395664215,
0.1367986798286438,
0.893707811832428,
-0.8947028517723083,
0.2723590135574341,
0.2932230234146118,
0.05845925956964493,
0.43705877661705017,
-0.31851205229759216,
0.4625452756881714,
0.11759674549102783,
-0.5157256722450256,
-0.7395608425140381,
0.46155810356140137,
-1.198997974395752,
-0.2910822629928589,
0.9322676062583923,
0.12097743898630142,
-0.09607619792222977,
0.0752817690372467,
-0.2431485950946808,
-0.19218507409095764,
-0.42145654559135437,
0.894427478313446,
0.50603848695755,
-0.3344128727912903,
0.03817532956600189,
-0.47894150018692017,
0.3701900839805603,
0.008177724666893482,
-1.23568594455719,
0.30665406584739685,
1.1225452423095703,
0.11187233775854111,
0.3217323124408722,
0.5718850493431091,
-0.17557397484779358,
0.018090294674038887,
0.3190298080444336,
-0.13132402300834656,
0.14771679043769836,
-0.5445748567581177,
0.3461686968803406,
0.2778080701828003,
-0.347166508436203,
0.518616259098053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20087v1 | ProgressGym: Alignment with a Millennium of Moral Progress | 2024-06-28T17:55:24 | 2024-06-28T17:55:24 | Tianyi Qiu, Yang Zhang, Xuchuan Huang, Jasmine Xinze Li, Jiaming Ji, Yaodong Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Frontier AI systems, including large language models (LLMs), hold increasing
influence over the epistemology of human users. Such influence can reinforce
prevailing societal values, potentially contributing to the lock-in of
misguided moral beliefs and, consequently, the perpetuation of problematic
moral practices on a broad scale. We introduce progress alignment as a
technical solution to mitigate this imminent risk. Progress alignment
algorithms learn to emulate the mechanics of human moral progress, thereby
addressing the susceptibility of existing alignment methods to contemporary
moral blindspots. To empower research in progress alignment, we introduce
ProgressGym, an experimental framework allowing the learning of moral progress
mechanics from history, in order to facilitate future progress in real-world
moral decisions. Leveraging 9 centuries of historical text and 18 historical
LLMs, ProgressGym enables codification of real-world progress alignment
challenges into concrete benchmarks. Specifically, we introduce three core
challenges: tracking evolving values (PG-Follow), preemptively anticipating
moral progress (PG-Predict), and regulating the feedback loop between human and
AI value shifts (PG-Coevolve). Alignment methods without a temporal dimension
are inapplicable to these tasks. In response, we present lifelong and
extrapolative algorithms as baseline methods of progress alignment, and build
an open leaderboard soliciting novel algorithms and challenges. The framework
and the leaderboard are available at
https://github.com/PKU-Alignment/ProgressGym and
https://huggingface.co/spaces/PKU-Alignment/ProgressGym-LeaderBoard
respectively. | [
0.08593069016933441,
-0.5705636143684387,
0.6793208718299866,
0.08419009298086166,
0.1751241534948349,
0.5625898838043213,
0.07200760394334793,
-0.3030785322189331,
0.022903500124812126,
0.49144482612609863,
-0.7914459109306335,
-0.41998425126075745,
-0.628432035446167,
-0.3605128824710846,
0.03857694938778877,
1.0257010459899902,
0.009403550066053867,
0.0003182721557095647,
-0.2131950855255127,
-0.22639554738998413,
-0.778118371963501,
-0.06740439683198929,
-0.5492680072784424,
-0.4861845076084137,
0.3071011006832123,
0.3934074342250824,
0.8108698725700378,
1.0406169891357422,
0.7165708541870117,
0.386538028717041,
-0.1539376676082611,
0.008276301436126232,
-0.6368546485900879,
0.11020111292600632,
-0.38898420333862305,
-0.44107773900032043,
-0.775273323059082,
0.21461060643196106,
0.4206274151802063,
0.3366824984550476,
-0.468359112739563,
0.2797449827194214,
0.032575808465480804,
0.7210771441459656,
-0.2986101508140564,
0.0038857930339872837,
-0.28401002287864685,
0.16112959384918213,
-0.17204473912715912,
-0.05622021481394768,
-0.1249656155705452,
-0.9751627445220947,
-0.07039641588926315,
-0.7109344005584717,
-0.0912555456161499,
0.05416853353381157,
0.8965495824813843,
0.3146432936191559,
-0.05891387537121773,
-0.30687791109085083,
-0.4959777891635895,
0.9967567920684814,
-0.37138429284095764,
0.2042890191078186,
0.3463788628578186,
0.1319763958454132,
-0.1911979466676712,
-0.607265055179596,
-0.5205997824668884,
-0.13563212752342224,
0.2826193571090698,
0.2226180136203766,
0.2087145298719406,
-0.09291563183069229,
0.255778431892395,
0.15821446478366852,
-0.45541951060295105,
0.05120362713932991,
-0.3453853130340576,
-0.1702214926481247,
0.6335960030555725,
0.5149539113044739,
0.2937464118003845,
0.24602335691452026,
-0.36449381709098816,
-0.2279205471277237,
-0.741917073726654,
0.24594484269618988,
0.5179958939552307,
0.04900918900966644,
-0.07312833517789841,
0.5052866339683533,
0.26210254430770874,
0.5737773776054382,
0.357211172580719,
-0.14789274334907532,
0.17756064236164093,
-0.5726489424705505,
0.03996584936976433,
0.0646546334028244,
0.6743941903114319,
0.5999435782432556,
0.25553062558174133,
0.057732682675123215,
0.07053559273481369,
0.1397581547498703,
0.7448319792747498,
-0.583339512348175,
-0.10424990952014923,
0.1239124983549118,
-0.3855508863925934,
-0.44721105694770813,
0.0879334807395935,
-0.8452547788619995,
-0.5936790108680725,
-0.44226017594337463,
0.2572711706161499,
-0.5030971169471741,
-0.1441473811864853,
0.12685494124889374,
0.060607872903347015,
0.5922892093658447,
0.5826689004898071,
-0.605855405330658,
-0.2226749211549759,
1.1037075519561768,
1.216110348701477,
-0.037550706416368484,
-0.2319360375404358,
-0.6143092513084412,
0.2798027992248535,
-0.35882022976875305,
0.3623390197753906,
-0.6922627091407776,
-0.21156474947929382,
-0.175352081656456,
0.243540957570076,
0.15421776473522186,
-0.03451066464185715,
0.8425832390785217,
-0.3823178708553314,
0.04836444929242134,
-0.228892520070076,
-0.7053525447845459,
-0.09304212778806686,
0.3207586407661438,
-0.3670198321342468,
0.5398075580596924,
-0.027736185118556023,
-0.5356409549713135,
0.22918923199176788,
-0.787199079990387,
-0.009014188311994076,
0.09936375916004181,
-0.07023566961288452,
-0.5874127149581909,
0.2161569744348526,
-0.16219718754291534,
0.10818998515605927,
-0.0031666229479014874,
0.6325340867042542,
-0.27234843373298645,
-0.5619653463363647,
0.08477701246738434,
-0.44169700145721436,
0.8188400864601135,
0.16899439692497253,
-0.317274808883667,
0.2466963827610016,
-0.3319362699985504,
-0.012771407142281532,
0.13547247648239136,
-0.052982691675424576,
-0.13603663444519043,
0.3424711525440216,
-0.4065060317516327,
0.04879290610551834,
0.5793405175209045,
-0.5999685525894165,
0.32933396100997925,
-0.10875118523836136,
0.4104093015193939,
1.3572664260864258,
-0.5854864120483398,
0.23664377629756927,
-0.8900547623634338,
0.5489082932472229,
-0.39888402819633484,
0.44063058495521545,
-0.05611864849925041,
-0.5412638187408447,
-0.41329020261764526,
0.04068760946393013,
0.16224351525306702,
0.7655567526817322,
-0.1878347247838974,
0.5299364328384399,
-0.37963858246803284,
-0.3954799473285675,
-0.5505251288414001,
0.07969658076763153,
0.2887459695339203,
0.41476568579673767,
0.3385719954967499,
-0.36892035603523254,
-0.1912902593612671,
-0.6109833121299744,
-0.5283194780349731,
-0.7578602433204651,
-0.18758627772331238,
0.10704203695058823,
0.10375455021858215,
-0.09199196100234985,
0.7239197492599487,
-0.4841325581073761,
-0.18116439878940582,
0.4723752439022064,
0.1748713105916977,
0.24029412865638733,
0.9105646014213562,
0.124121755361557,
-0.8691506385803223,
-0.10107743740081787,
0.11558282375335693,
-0.6908678412437439,
-0.121234230697155,
0.06104100123047829,
-0.3032563328742981,
-0.22352972626686096,
0.5303269624710083,
-0.21191492676734924,
0.1674378663301468,
0.5851795077323914,
-0.7792957425117493,
0.4134864807128906,
-0.07316505908966064,
0.4640190303325653,
-0.8885730504989624,
0.07604158669710159,
-0.14780721068382263,
-0.4711288511753082,
-0.31561946868896484,
0.028142815455794334,
0.04186601936817169,
0.075638547539711,
-0.28265485167503357,
0.1332855075597763,
-0.10570008307695389,
0.3379945456981659,
-0.12317244708538055,
0.15634268522262573,
-0.16567733883857727,
0.1347181349992752,
-0.23174108564853668,
0.6600524187088013,
0.23515845835208893,
-0.3207325041294098,
0.41083216667175293,
0.4665980637073517,
0.06159355491399765,
1.1054335832595825,
-0.4489688575267792,
0.25319674611091614,
-0.14461271464824677,
-0.11569762974977493,
-0.7137578725814819,
-0.02838330715894699,
0.27411478757858276,
-0.4924643337726593,
0.2577684223651886,
-0.31298866868019104,
-0.011531929485499859,
-0.13811784982681274,
-0.5104881525039673,
0.3416910767555237,
0.743514358997345,
-0.39157024025917053,
0.6845715045928955,
0.2769767940044403,
-0.40401384234428406,
-0.8122857809066772,
-0.5212498903274536,
0.1875249296426773,
-0.4802953898906708,
-0.7696292996406555,
0.39618682861328125,
-0.2526916265487671,
-0.3513256311416626,
-0.028310105204582214,
-0.03507399186491966,
0.4011591076850891,
0.16445468366146088,
0.2787512540817261,
0.43307167291641235,
-0.1688283383846283,
0.09271516650915146,
0.020942671224474907,
-0.06659276783466339,
0.13719695806503296,
-0.6915525197982788,
0.3304772675037384,
-0.59086012840271,
-0.2796385884284973,
-0.24418917298316956,
0.17464274168014526,
0.4810999631881714,
0.072274349629879,
0.38176292181015015,
0.5182278752326965,
-0.28522834181785583,
0.42556965351104736,
-0.5490212440490723,
0.37014099955558777,
-0.5152989029884338,
0.22289925813674927,
0.13741938769817352,
-1.169442057609558,
0.20845313370227814,
-0.3372264802455902,
0.48695993423461914,
0.40387871861457825,
0.4045719802379608,
-0.46620285511016846,
0.8051312565803528,
0.9394217133522034,
0.25165319442749023,
0.6986058950424194,
0.09348998218774796,
-0.10078520327806473,
-0.8707376718521118,
-0.2830386757850647,
-0.4374326765537262,
-0.5635086894035339,
-0.8503414392471313,
-0.5146146416664124,
0.0076029798947274685,
0.5799868106842041,
-0.6662442088127136,
0.40653717517852783,
-0.6844697594642639,
0.7124184370040894,
0.22333449125289917,
-0.06473458558320999,
0.5963189601898193,
0.021088439971208572,
0.12450329959392548,
-0.16564235091209412,
-0.3474871516227722,
-0.8454059362411499,
1.1281013488769531,
0.27976366877555847,
0.8336183428764343,
0.36944472789764404,
0.452938437461853,
0.6875793933868408,
0.8320988416671753,
-0.6603680849075317,
0.33760637044906616,
-0.17531488835811615,
-0.18722578883171082,
-0.2560035288333893,
-0.4984026253223419,
-0.8232161998748779,
-0.019084932282567024,
-0.04542938992381096,
-0.9490185976028442,
0.16956137120723724,
0.22856636345386505,
-0.3964202404022217,
0.3612959384918213,
-0.39404889941215515,
0.7805392146110535,
-0.5169322490692139,
-0.6508547067642212,
-0.2578712999820709,
-0.9742778539657593,
0.22400516271591187,
-0.0651831328868866,
0.0861203745007515,
-0.3849208354949951,
-0.16352695226669312,
0.5928447842597961,
-0.3043646812438965,
0.7934081554412842,
-0.1372610628604889,
-0.37767744064331055,
0.18628191947937012,
0.10817893594503403,
0.6557105779647827,
0.2686554193496704,
0.20706935226917267,
0.34331658482551575,
0.026944277808070183,
-0.5239839553833008,
-0.08066399395465851,
0.8381556272506714,
-0.48311540484428406,
-0.7725083231925964,
-0.5137367844581604,
-0.5148716568946838,
-0.0826718658208847,
0.09069070219993591,
0.10056028515100479,
-0.035228945314884186,
-0.5645042061805725,
-0.17572738230228424,
0.7441288232803345,
-0.18938656151294708,
0.4786483347415924,
0.41268646717071533,
-0.33985021710395813,
-0.7151111960411072,
1.1042346954345703,
-0.16317568719387054,
0.31515491008758545,
0.06905705481767654,
0.3302444517612457,
-0.3276931643486023,
-0.4487576186656952,
-0.7010467648506165,
0.08171428740024567,
-0.4211817979812622,
-0.31132060289382935,
-0.5252277255058289,
0.150888592004776,
-0.09572481364011765,
-0.6165024638175964,
-0.37285086512565613,
-0.1719302237033844,
-0.27099907398223877,
0.13451461493968964,
0.3317257761955261,
0.8192696571350098,
-0.3021918535232544,
0.11663003265857697,
-0.8518155217170715,
0.011357778683304787,
0.20261311531066895,
0.46766501665115356,
-0.47748157382011414,
-0.4131695628166199,
-0.007224044296890497,
0.3764755427837372,
-0.9106919765472412,
-0.46970951557159424,
-0.07518255710601807,
0.03290203586220741,
0.0019459890900179744,
0.38082629442214966,
-0.18125617504119873,
0.7447845339775085,
-0.46106991171836853,
0.6424415111541748,
0.45742708444595337,
-1.0442814826965332,
0.5078547596931458,
-0.3477264642715454,
0.1564967781305313,
0.7384830117225647,
0.34544262290000916,
-0.664507269859314,
-0.36355769634246826,
-0.6170791387557983,
-0.5213726162910461,
0.4290783405303955,
0.3769960105419159,
0.07011082768440247,
0.2627393901348114,
0.5351455807685852,
0.1442641168832779,
0.1367802619934082,
-0.33602580428123474,
0.20863981544971466,
-0.3131718337535858,
-0.5700543522834778,
0.015240350738167763,
0.35720720887184143,
-0.3737850487232208,
-0.12395171076059341,
0.5073065757751465,
-0.42886707186698914,
0.007921540178358555,
0.2039545178413391,
0.048342134803533554,
-0.42692455649375916,
0.18642973899841309,
0.6549050807952881,
1.088671088218689,
-0.019432174041867256,
-0.3889603316783905,
-0.08536863327026367,
-0.7706529498100281,
0.6854307651519775,
0.304106742143631,
-0.3261914551258087,
-0.4800602197647095,
0.12746194005012512,
0.38541582226753235,
-0.5471057295799255,
-0.564910352230072,
0.6001250743865967,
-0.355352520942688,
-0.08276701718568802,
-0.5947821736335754,
0.14114443957805634,
0.18452881276607513,
0.7644856572151184,
0.23748435080051422,
0.08983227610588074,
-0.305769145488739,
-0.4895608127117157,
0.24799150228500366,
0.40084904432296753,
-0.7847610116004944,
-0.3666312098503113,
0.8507906198501587,
0.11574075371026993,
-0.8200623393058777,
0.6288316249847412,
-0.335961252450943,
-0.4145665764808655,
0.706172525882721,
0.22980371117591858,
0.8961786031723022,
-0.2358371764421463,
0.44059255719184875,
0.1658163070678711,
0.3330785930156708,
-0.6323341131210327,
0.4328623414039612,
0.17026455700397491,
-0.7455495595932007,
-1.0054923295974731,
-0.8452059030532837,
-0.475187748670578,
-0.24977648258209229,
-0.49148502945899963,
0.3348906636238098,
-0.46055468916893005,
-0.31316709518432617,
-0.5946009159088135,
-0.12968416512012482,
-0.3464750349521637,
-0.11036194115877151,
-0.01666668988764286,
0.3441288471221924,
-0.5256286859512329,
0.32487061619758606,
0.7628651261329651,
-0.07765365391969681,
-0.3348621428012848,
0.34733888506889343,
0.18154661357402802,
-0.728830099105835,
0.1514894664287567,
0.35450220108032227,
-0.215098574757576,
0.2166275680065155,
-0.9050042629241943,
-0.6975049376487732,
1.2262953519821167,
0.541560709476471,
-0.9239782094955444,
0.01720231957733631,
-0.26973968744277954,
0.33819541335105896,
-0.27145838737487793,
-0.10956630855798721,
0.5520521402359009,
0.6857675313949585,
0.05790426954627037,
-0.6999443173408508,
0.13201789557933807,
0.009398426860570908,
-0.22419466078281403,
0.8409616947174072,
-1.0024476051330566,
0.6136236190795898,
-0.5060836672782898,
-0.2885473668575287,
0.44289660453796387,
0.6285925507545471,
0.4465983510017395,
0.4550704061985016,
0.444463849067688,
0.8713867664337158,
0.940829336643219,
-0.368746817111969,
0.5152919888496399,
-0.12269838154315948,
0.46439671516418457,
0.834986686706543,
-0.19986476004123688,
0.16466782987117767,
0.3841154873371124,
-0.2826981544494629,
0.4361551105976105,
0.5547429323196411,
-0.2527645528316498,
0.16887438297271729,
0.3976207673549652,
-0.1099705770611763,
-0.3002343773841858,
-0.36855214834213257,
-0.5007348656654358,
0.40809693932533264,
0.3078872859477997,
-0.2042858600616455,
0.1474715769290924,
-0.2914403975009918,
0.11615730822086334,
0.1445888876914978,
-0.49379268288612366,
0.7657843232154846,
-0.019041405990719795,
-0.6329606771469116,
0.260644793510437,
-0.20371364057064056,
0.783435046672821,
-0.6141167879104614,
-0.4201113283634186,
-0.08467981219291687,
0.24558325111865997,
-0.06318630278110504,
-0.8480064868927002,
0.456679105758667,
-0.0009928913787007332,
0.11070404201745987,
-0.38200250267982483,
0.38875722885131836,
-0.2985232174396515,
-0.5243794322013855,
0.2989824116230011,
0.4261280298233032,
-0.13443662226200104,
0.29134634137153625,
-0.7813584804534912,
-0.18494170904159546,
-0.08867891132831573,
0.06180290877819061,
0.24731868505477905,
0.4047483801841736,
-0.1204887181520462,
0.5223761796951294,
0.6530241966247559,
0.05631324276328087,
-0.31799986958503723,
-0.4007546305656433,
0.6256228685379028,
-1.0440549850463867,
-0.4689933955669403,
-1.1437615156173706,
0.2273818552494049,
-0.16466999053955078,
-0.4545806050300598,
0.30122482776641846,
0.20858143270015717,
0.9426082968711853,
0.5283446907997131,
0.4803456962108612,
-0.3412477374076843,
-0.24611392617225647,
-0.691641628742218,
0.7928884029388428,
-0.549714207649231,
0.08324625343084335,
-0.2968973219394684,
-0.86264568567276,
-0.024069156497716904,
0.34972789883613586,
0.20912642776966095,
-0.009947427548468113,
0.5123604536056519,
0.48758599162101746,
0.2647254168987274,
0.2953382432460785,
0.17017234861850739,
0.10406587272882462,
0.3802284896373749,
0.5992012619972229,
1.2264593839645386,
-0.131582111120224,
0.5114296078681946,
0.239912211894989,
-0.2849131226539612,
0.26184868812561035,
-1.1063560247421265,
-0.4063052237033844,
-0.14400887489318848,
-0.399688720703125,
-0.6038538813591003,
0.4272407293319702,
0.7807477116584778,
0.37140312790870667,
-0.6316673159599304,
-0.25313693284988403,
-0.4050542712211609,
0.2799187898635864,
-0.47008922696113586,
-0.22963924705982208,
0.2349344789981842,
-0.11455254256725311,
-0.671558141708374,
0.3585001826286316,
0.4649442732334137,
0.030432622879743576,
-0.24433216452598572,
-0.18995125591754913,
-0.33173543214797974,
-0.005085684359073639,
0.2974316477775574,
0.25320935249328613,
-0.5509900450706482,
-0.5919867753982544,
-0.05352761968970299,
0.10156834125518799,
0.49591588973999023,
1.0755956172943115,
-0.3956737518310547,
0.35225093364715576,
0.41862425208091736,
0.8112342357635498,
0.19545142352581024,
0.46857979893684387,
0.8197617530822754,
-0.31044694781303406,
-0.3803600072860718,
0.4777217209339142,
0.1705619841814041,
0.3821184039115906,
-0.5208938717842102,
0.7293170690536499,
0.4925796687602997,
-0.8144599795341492,
-0.5043094754219055,
0.39773914217948914,
-0.4197598397731781,
-0.05842822790145874,
0.5214255452156067,
-0.2691439688205719,
-0.12039922177791595,
-0.23938225209712982,
-0.025879960507154465,
0.22222554683685303,
-0.48988014459609985,
0.7785472273826599,
0.9471505880355835,
-0.2544916868209839,
0.15778568387031555,
-0.5336344242095947,
0.4092215597629547,
0.5909152626991272,
-0.7372732162475586,
0.1005510538816452,
0.6796656847000122,
0.19850535690784454,
0.395541787147522,
0.39986881613731384,
-0.44945836067199707,
0.17128175497055054,
-0.3939454257488251,
-0.05829109251499176,
-0.02190791815519333,
-0.18836048245429993,
-0.5079014897346497,
0.2407568097114563,
-0.2330646514892578,
0.07237182557582855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20086v1 | Token Erasure as a Footprint of Implicit Vocabulary Items in LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:54:47 | 2024-06-28T17:54:47 | Sheridan Feucht, David Atkinson, Byron Wallace, David Bau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | LLMs process text as sequences of tokens that roughly correspond to words,
where less common words are represented by multiple tokens. However, individual
tokens are often semantically unrelated to the meanings of the words/concepts
they comprise. For example, Llama-2-7b's tokenizer splits the word
"northeastern" into the tokens ['_n', 'ort', 'he', 'astern'], none of which
correspond to semantically meaningful units like "north" or "east." Similarly,
the overall meanings of named entities like "Neil Young" and multi-word
expressions like "break a leg" cannot be directly inferred from their
constituent tokens. Mechanistically, how do LLMs convert such arbitrary groups
of tokens into useful higher-level representations? In this work, we find that
last token representations of named entities and multi-token words exhibit a
pronounced "erasure" effect, where information about previous and current
tokens is rapidly forgotten in early layers. Using this observation, we propose
a method to "read out" the implicit vocabulary of an autoregressive LLM by
examining differences in token representations across layers, and present
results of this method for Llama-2-7b and Llama-3-8B. To our knowledge, this is
the first attempt to probe the implicit vocabulary of an LLM. | [
-0.37974870204925537,
-0.8815510869026184,
0.5021922588348389,
-0.10777607560157776,
-0.5249353647232056,
0.4320823848247528,
0.09869243949651718,
-0.6477326154708862,
0.3542831838130951,
0.34530654549598694,
-0.5017581582069397,
-0.5907112956047058,
-0.7359320521354675,
0.16818177700042725,
-0.6679400205612183,
0.9568402767181396,
-0.10490017384290695,
-0.1472024768590927,
0.11906298249959946,
-0.2708815336227417,
-0.6572608947753906,
-0.4630044996738434,
-0.8397952318191528,
-0.38711100816726685,
0.6438894867897034,
0.2580806314945221,
0.36531445384025574,
0.9447776675224304,
0.30214065313339233,
0.2761111855506897,
-0.6647605299949646,
0.21767301857471466,
-0.5329070091247559,
0.1269962340593338,
-0.015430434606969357,
-0.6464385986328125,
-0.32081517577171326,
0.20045526325702667,
0.7600460052490234,
0.8177057504653931,
0.24242393672466278,
0.23152463138103485,
-0.027941273525357246,
0.4147138297557831,
-0.6167629361152649,
0.10238788276910782,
-0.9137175679206848,
0.2126276046037674,
-0.33382198214530945,
-0.3289255201816559,
-0.1886157989501953,
0.06863921880722046,
-0.20380382239818573,
-0.6286358833312988,
0.15765389800071716,
0.34063589572906494,
0.7855579257011414,
0.2300729602575302,
-0.4052516222000122,
-0.4312117099761963,
-0.6642792820930481,
0.6928868889808655,
-0.48173150420188904,
0.29587522149086,
0.3561471104621887,
-0.08713531494140625,
-0.15905678272247314,
-0.6455221176147461,
-0.8422132730484009,
-0.2106752246618271,
-0.2697241008281708,
0.13547497987747192,
-0.14180806279182434,
0.0773477777838707,
0.15513354539871216,
0.17926426231861115,
-0.08446705341339111,
0.3503710627555847,
-0.5789499878883362,
-0.45291197299957275,
0.14049407839775085,
0.28669995069503784,
0.34675905108451843,
-0.657067060470581,
-0.8938304781913757,
0.32439807057380676,
-1.0421861410140991,
-0.18210312724113464,
0.2952299416065216,
0.06890537589788437,
0.1993992179632187,
0.7819740772247314,
0.15097098052501678,
-0.05385715514421463,
-0.02374439500272274,
-0.17536050081253052,
0.14422909915447235,
-0.36281341314315796,
-0.23028725385665894,
0.2044108510017395,
0.40848594903945923,
0.15017561614513397,
-0.26293694972991943,
-0.2681465744972229,
-0.4181339740753174,
-0.00446659978479147,
-0.2004087269306183,
-0.49557408690452576,
-0.049940839409828186,
0.20243823528289795,
-0.7115997076034546,
-0.0931808203458786,
-0.1034729927778244,
-0.2567368447780609,
-0.5145525336265564,
-0.3733517825603485,
0.5567225217819214,
-0.34148186445236206,
-0.20423202216625214,
-0.14770598709583282,
-0.27599650621414185,
0.39201870560646057,
0.3307417035102844,
-0.5289148688316345,
0.36268994212150574,
0.8096442222595215,
0.7655214667320251,
-0.3035421073436737,
-0.3994879126548767,
-0.48992130160331726,
0.3502345681190491,
-0.4514412581920624,
0.6699548363685608,
-0.4553578197956085,
-0.5493640899658203,
-0.21326713263988495,
0.08336831629276276,
0.028793951496481895,
-0.6015895009040833,
0.23122116923332214,
-0.573474645614624,
0.021385781466960907,
-0.3131360709667206,
-0.6385999321937561,
-0.4561363756656647,
0.22207467257976532,
-0.4727768003940582,
1.171174168586731,
-0.3182784914970398,
-0.4777698218822479,
0.6222825050354004,
-0.41596248745918274,
-0.06997658312320709,
0.13545022904872894,
-0.20981432497501373,
0.1212104931473732,
0.3395082950592041,
0.07730962336063385,
0.5466470718383789,
-0.1566009223461151,
-0.050314296036958694,
0.0009579044999554753,
-0.600821316242218,
0.10853397846221924,
-0.4484485685825348,
0.49063146114349365,
-0.10263803601264954,
-0.6156001687049866,
-0.07398708164691925,
-0.8125063180923462,
-0.2919335663318634,
0.05373333394527435,
-0.2664264440536499,
-0.7443253993988037,
0.1624942123889923,
-0.2001199722290039,
0.0346401147544384,
0.2899473309516907,
-0.7363417744636536,
0.13457103073596954,
-0.3814730942249298,
0.43482065200805664,
1.0664633512496948,
0.09973767399787903,
0.5786945819854736,
-0.2584313750267029,
0.3052867352962494,
0.5441442728042603,
0.020556045696139336,
-0.27470842003822327,
-0.43481576442718506,
-1.101109504699707,
-0.21449624001979828,
-0.08905678987503052,
0.28783413767814636,
-0.4579617381095886,
0.13913901150226593,
-0.2930990159511566,
-0.1594228297472,
-0.2989509403705597,
0.21115310490131378,
0.3856651484966278,
0.4340246617794037,
0.51896733045578,
-0.178183913230896,
-0.24439333379268646,
-0.9334303140640259,
-0.2972441613674164,
-0.39167502522468567,
0.20903269946575165,
0.25171682238578796,
0.7143946290016174,
-0.2774829864501953,
0.6870771050453186,
-0.46650001406669617,
-0.45182135701179504,
0.18967896699905396,
0.37366512417793274,
0.0960230752825737,
0.6179434657096863,
0.23706240952014923,
-0.37431299686431885,
0.07540100812911987,
-0.052301596850156784,
-0.3338131606578827,
-0.025048701092600822,
-0.2720493674278259,
-0.31127768754959106,
0.15170998871326447,
0.9029127359390259,
-0.536971390247345,
0.6248420476913452,
0.22937308251857758,
-0.4225829839706421,
0.29541531205177307,
-0.15823441743850708,
-0.09709557890892029,
-0.7207860946655273,
0.18357856571674347,
-0.5552939176559448,
0.04813243821263313,
-0.4348587691783905,
-0.11266838014125824,
-0.06306158006191254,
0.4059959053993225,
-0.5103583335876465,
0.881372332572937,
-0.9470382332801819,
-0.481658935546875,
-0.18121297657489777,
0.31350216269493103,
0.21051983535289764,
0.2786129415035248,
-0.2616649568080902,
0.6270815134048462,
0.2803489863872528,
-0.7270401120185852,
-0.04556720331311226,
0.24351705610752106,
0.13683940470218658,
0.5430352687835693,
-0.44020429253578186,
0.4249596893787384,
-0.6658914089202881,
0.31026673316955566,
-1.2755988836288452,
0.1804860234260559,
0.361859530210495,
-0.24504454433918,
0.15940658748149872,
-0.2524780333042145,
-0.6558754444122314,
-0.023664096370339394,
-0.30511727929115295,
0.6761850118637085,
0.3239862024784088,
-0.5803549885749817,
0.8126241564750671,
0.31258368492126465,
-0.008937178179621696,
-0.8019446134567261,
-0.8100334405899048,
0.26806339621543884,
-0.3138871490955353,
-0.18073441088199615,
0.28382858633995056,
-0.042217712849378586,
-0.40719467401504517,
0.1476973593235016,
-0.23850086331367493,
-0.16745322942733765,
0.14854037761688232,
0.5483776926994324,
0.26311391592025757,
-0.25213339924812317,
0.41605547070503235,
0.29221856594085693,
-0.007169040385633707,
0.2143765240907669,
-0.2727845311164856,
0.6844341158866882,
-0.04661324992775917,
-0.5422690510749817,
-0.19498395919799805,
0.27703750133514404,
0.5792972445487976,
-0.15775859355926514,
0.5531520843505859,
0.7845703959465027,
-0.6489224433898926,
-0.24798846244812012,
-0.7331083416938782,
-0.006276105530560017,
-0.4710972309112549,
0.18621207773685455,
-0.3918449282646179,
-0.7678298950195312,
1.1886351108551025,
0.014691446907818317,
0.1581427901983261,
0.7442927360534668,
0.2036971002817154,
-0.019080910831689835,
0.6668904423713684,
0.107777900993824,
0.07429506629705429,
0.2452855408191681,
-0.42681360244750977,
-0.09572196751832962,
-1.2417726516723633,
-0.6308439373970032,
-0.454076886177063,
-0.578210711479187,
-0.3295353651046753,
-0.5514582991600037,
0.09773901849985123,
0.19190439581871033,
-0.22485916316509247,
0.1710943579673767,
-0.44475916028022766,
0.5243788361549377,
0.46742093563079834,
0.029687440022826195,
0.3751467764377594,
-0.17432673275470734,
-0.4390932619571686,
0.14840343594551086,
-0.21685674786567688,
-0.4828176498413086,
0.908152163028717,
0.37001973390579224,
0.4087287187576294,
0.03856377676129341,
0.9707978963851929,
0.2638278901576996,
0.38683754205703735,
-0.8768183588981628,
0.7424450516700745,
-0.20998969674110413,
-0.535677969455719,
-0.24250227212905884,
-0.11231832206249237,
-1.1604419946670532,
0.28301453590393066,
-0.06523288041353226,
-0.7137579321861267,
0.38528895378112793,
-0.11056436598300934,
-0.16086727380752563,
0.571282148361206,
-0.4296342730522156,
0.23649586737155914,
-0.22655223309993744,
-0.15673226118087769,
-0.24364733695983887,
-0.46707451343536377,
0.4370932877063751,
-0.24359090626239777,
0.34139764308929443,
-0.4916944205760956,
-0.6271597146987915,
0.8913416862487793,
-0.43342161178588867,
0.9674746990203857,
-0.37128475308418274,
-0.22674141824245453,
0.3654078543186188,
0.37800830602645874,
0.4935988187789917,
-0.014999770559370518,
0.19494768977165222,
0.34667882323265076,
-0.02971641905605793,
-0.20034420490264893,
-0.4236898422241211,
0.6723802089691162,
-0.693869948387146,
-0.35339707136154175,
-0.21209359169006348,
-0.3354051411151886,
0.12543682754039764,
0.35801443457603455,
0.04431574046611786,
0.3618394434452057,
-0.08957163989543915,
-0.08422644436359406,
0.31052884459495544,
-0.25418612360954285,
0.6627294421195984,
0.335880845785141,
-0.2006046324968338,
-0.3159306049346924,
0.6927594542503357,
0.34384557604789734,
0.0686422660946846,
0.28094515204429626,
0.17595025897026062,
-0.5088012218475342,
-0.8743399977684021,
-0.22357545793056488,
0.22735971212387085,
-1.0925711393356323,
-0.072777658700943,
-0.6355035901069641,
0.07218732684850693,
0.1682339906692505,
-0.08733637630939484,
-0.028289398178458214,
-0.44147956371307373,
-0.7252396941184998,
-0.25459814071655273,
0.3895208537578583,
1.1567779779434204,
-0.030558714643120766,
0.4231041669845581,
-0.7458833456039429,
0.30305302143096924,
0.16523511707782745,
0.1744280457496643,
0.18169234693050385,
-0.4634132385253906,
0.08570799231529236,
-0.17752571403980255,
0.28649190068244934,
-0.7089820504188538,
0.242231085896492,
0.34439894556999207,
0.6960393786430359,
0.4412538707256317,
-0.22483861446380615,
0.9386456608772278,
-0.6254129409790039,
0.906441867351532,
0.19500045478343964,
-1.1469453573226929,
0.23655033111572266,
-0.23407483100891113,
0.06892617046833038,
0.5116718411445618,
-0.02303975820541382,
-0.7451392412185669,
-0.49089327454566956,
-0.6124006509780884,
-1.3397136926651,
0.42576155066490173,
-0.05673438683152199,
0.4222865700721741,
-0.5023126006126404,
0.8474780917167664,
0.355493426322937,
0.35184288024902344,
-0.5308541655540466,
-0.5992522239685059,
-0.02461799792945385,
0.036986202001571655,
0.00019046732631977648,
-0.4352931082248688,
-0.20448845624923706,
-0.11132821440696716,
0.3148268163204193,
-0.022021573036909103,
0.49744805693626404,
0.14497919380664825,
-0.4501003324985504,
0.03734956309199333,
0.06839989125728607,
0.57098788022995,
0.3980403542518616,
0.15527892112731934,
0.615301251411438,
0.43177685141563416,
-0.7174329161643982,
0.2558094263076782,
-0.19293653964996338,
-0.15826842188835144,
0.09830936044454575,
0.4615342915058136,
0.5835268497467041,
0.5208390355110168,
-0.2926073670387268,
0.32591933012008667,
0.20151768624782562,
-0.007892915979027748,
-0.5102447271347046,
-0.09780842810869217,
0.05800149589776993,
0.15328125655651093,
0.7436937093734741,
0.03002641350030899,
0.14932572841644287,
-0.5273367762565613,
0.22850747406482697,
0.48833557963371277,
-0.3269430696964264,
-0.3592527210712433,
0.6694406867027283,
-0.062263116240501404,
0.07766241580247879,
0.43235090374946594,
-0.11805621534585953,
-0.5708966255187988,
0.6163085103034973,
0.3382539749145508,
0.9951802492141724,
0.26915106177330017,
-0.006277541164308786,
0.13807275891304016,
0.4399418234825134,
0.21991068124771118,
0.23173339664936066,
0.03958337381482124,
-0.7113457322120667,
-0.48300573229789734,
-0.5536944270133972,
-0.017696725204586983,
0.07567615807056427,
-0.514069676399231,
-0.1409589797258377,
-0.7984857559204102,
-0.22899436950683594,
-0.027540726587176323,
-0.16248326003551483,
-0.9268738627433777,
0.24969643354415894,
0.2711588442325592,
0.5733625292778015,
-0.6187629103660583,
0.2704661190509796,
0.6952387690544128,
-0.4011784791946411,
-0.9492653012275696,
0.14958645403385162,
0.20675966143608093,
-1.356618881225586,
1.3490999937057495,
0.17756269872188568,
-0.27109459042549133,
0.2218741774559021,
-0.549738883972168,
-1.0157501697540283,
1.2340854406356812,
0.0615791417658329,
-0.2425699084997177,
-0.1214127391576767,
0.21452823281288147,
0.3296676576137543,
-0.10788954794406891,
0.43040844798088074,
0.38881123065948486,
0.6118868589401245,
0.05127030238509178,
-0.6522827744483948,
0.30685365200042725,
0.04371070861816406,
-0.1318781077861786,
0.3036586046218872,
-0.7009509801864624,
1.2223825454711914,
0.03619636595249176,
-0.5177195072174072,
0.06841544061899185,
0.6479873657226562,
0.11158451437950134,
0.09178634732961655,
0.5620631575584412,
0.2798059582710266,
0.8810166716575623,
-0.1466177999973297,
0.5781381130218506,
-0.3829950988292694,
0.2107784003019333,
0.7252141833305359,
-0.13158930838108063,
0.7752135992050171,
0.7489697337150574,
0.024605968967080116,
0.41889244318008423,
0.4882267713546753,
0.20147807896137238,
0.11465802788734436,
0.49166080355644226,
-0.4487036168575287,
0.08143871277570724,
-0.2566826045513153,
-0.10692627727985382,
0.6909863948822021,
0.46694549918174744,
-0.3459244668483734,
-0.1635582149028778,
-0.11746310442686081,
0.205007866024971,
-0.4748819172382355,
-0.6375482678413391,
0.8718920350074768,
0.20946839451789856,
-0.25968989729881287,
0.5344172716140747,
-0.05290369316935539,
0.6613959670066833,
-0.31747230887413025,
-0.18466846644878387,
-0.4411480724811554,
0.001807774300687015,
-0.24542637169361115,
-0.7066518664360046,
0.17704737186431885,
-0.2644733488559723,
0.06681764870882034,
-0.12535274028778076,
0.791225254535675,
-0.31770721077919006,
-0.31975552439689636,
0.5226739645004272,
0.8513032793998718,
0.42928528785705566,
0.3269243538379669,
-0.5049423575401306,
-0.021921340376138687,
-0.3468738794326782,
-0.3797333538532257,
0.08351799845695496,
0.6313567757606506,
-0.03796537220478058,
0.583590567111969,
0.7910451292991638,
0.31927093863487244,
0.5370696783065796,
0.04959508404135704,
0.7152925729751587,
-0.695476233959198,
-0.1965446025133133,
-0.8426575064659119,
0.5168961882591248,
0.27113479375839233,
-0.45261359214782715,
0.6190466284751892,
0.4956100881099701,
0.7364798188209534,
0.29061833024024963,
0.44836074113845825,
0.17475596070289612,
0.3359539210796356,
-0.7652276158332825,
0.6272702217102051,
-0.5971243977546692,
0.4825162887573242,
-0.35078445076942444,
-1.0025954246520996,
-0.25415053963661194,
0.4026961922645569,
-0.0894232988357544,
-0.07386661320924759,
0.7975968718528748,
0.4438522756099701,
0.16202054917812347,
-0.2660825252532959,
0.2630312740802765,
0.3627474308013916,
0.25435206294059753,
0.025625037029385567,
1.1249074935913086,
-0.2861647307872772,
0.48037031292915344,
0.002460989635437727,
0.1755780577659607,
0.02298186719417572,
-0.836000382900238,
-0.7615495324134827,
-0.48838117718696594,
-0.09318791329860687,
-0.3680483102798462,
0.2109464704990387,
0.8250422477722168,
0.23545822501182556,
-0.5693588852882385,
0.08764567971229553,
-0.09285196661949158,
0.0582391731441021,
-0.06898940354585648,
-0.1906501054763794,
0.7377656698226929,
-0.1647382229566574,
-0.7083059549331665,
0.44222721457481384,
0.2623859941959381,
0.3404175937175751,
-0.5813691020011902,
0.18638354539871216,
0.13361486792564392,
0.09387688338756561,
0.6128665208816528,
0.02883780561387539,
-0.9309518933296204,
-0.7491865754127502,
0.19391898810863495,
-0.013863903470337391,
0.18169911205768585,
0.7125853300094604,
-0.7568095922470093,
0.1492682248353958,
0.4326002299785614,
0.4324291944503784,
0.41437333822250366,
0.0041600801050662994,
0.19166406989097595,
-0.8526894450187683,
0.22022846341133118,
0.3596307039260864,
0.5615614652633667,
0.15041621029376984,
-0.41605162620544434,
0.24334067106246948,
0.42091941833496094,
-0.19439546763896942,
-0.7394193410873413,
0.18711334466934204,
-0.7851964235305786,
-0.29693809151649475,
1.3106971979141235,
-0.031695641577243805,
-0.1973094940185547,
-0.32089510560035706,
-0.33315402269363403,
0.31412404775619507,
-0.33867523074150085,
0.4873605966567993,
0.6806060671806335,
-0.09437137097120285,
-0.050478823482990265,
-0.5074248909950256,
0.30921462178230286,
0.3901262581348419,
-0.5172886848449707,
-0.0117429094389081,
0.7504563331604004,
0.3894585967063904,
0.2630678713321686,
0.7686516642570496,
-0.18368902802467346,
-0.08687737584114075,
0.09623682498931885,
0.05289635434746742,
-0.23822638392448425,
-0.14932776987552643,
-0.18960057199001312,
0.15415333211421967,
0.06761275231838226,
-0.2879677712917328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20079v1 | Molecular Facts: Desiderata for Decontextualization in LLM Fact Verification | 2024-06-28T17:43:48 | 2024-06-28T17:43:48 | Anisha Gunjal, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic factuality verification of large language model (LLM) generations
is becoming more and more widely used to combat hallucinations. A major point
of tension in the literature is the granularity of this fact-checking: larger
chunks of text are hard to fact-check, but more atomic facts like propositions
may lack context to interpret correctly. In this work, we assess the role of
context in these atomic facts. We argue that fully atomic facts are not the
right representation, and define two criteria for molecular facts:
decontextuality, or how well they can stand alone, and minimality, or how
little extra information is added to achieve decontexuality. We quantify the
impact of decontextualization on minimality, then present a baseline
methodology for generating molecular facts automatically, aiming to add the
right amount of information. We compare against various methods of
decontextualization and find that molecular facts balance minimality with fact
verification accuracy in ambiguous settings. | [
-0.29905855655670166,
-1.0727403163909912,
1.0109589099884033,
-0.20460277795791626,
-0.4277900457382202,
-0.11855506896972656,
-0.14917084574699402,
-0.5589128732681274,
0.20921115577220917,
0.331825315952301,
-0.3188095986843109,
-0.6673899292945862,
-0.6188432574272156,
0.3913281559944153,
-0.6858057379722595,
0.7619456052780151,
0.2176000475883484,
-0.36386168003082275,
-0.4782523512840271,
-0.2705371081829071,
-0.016816498711705208,
-0.600833535194397,
-0.16435891389846802,
-0.3456134796142578,
0.31791096925735474,
0.5665339231491089,
0.7910556197166443,
1.0027648210525513,
0.5624858140945435,
0.33957231044769287,
-0.510753870010376,
0.4271159768104553,
-0.5547829270362854,
0.0013764651957899332,
-0.1129443570971489,
-0.30057308077812195,
-0.5690259337425232,
-0.28183719515800476,
0.5525487065315247,
0.9909375309944153,
0.034515131264925,
0.09249415248632431,
-0.22625316679477692,
0.8821536898612976,
-0.5061426162719727,
-0.025564122945070267,
-0.49970003962516785,
0.3467327058315277,
-0.05258907005190849,
-0.20297689735889435,
-0.17915022373199463,
-0.5608785152435303,
0.0918089747428894,
-0.4293723404407501,
0.31311801075935364,
0.03146908059716225,
0.8600034117698669,
0.41964271664619446,
-1.1248887777328491,
-0.39839303493499756,
-0.8906546831130981,
0.44403186440467834,
-0.4923330247402191,
0.4195350408554077,
0.17004789412021637,
-0.06986957788467407,
-0.2149668037891388,
-0.6021108031272888,
-0.5742336511611938,
-0.6455057859420776,
-0.36458253860473633,
-0.22632691264152527,
-0.3564488887786865,
0.2667968273162842,
0.6025535464286804,
0.4584942162036896,
-0.5517539381980896,
-0.2680976986885071,
-0.4540202021598816,
-0.4295791685581207,
0.29007986187934875,
0.12080082297325134,
0.5488501787185669,
-0.19801387190818787,
-0.4529329240322113,
0.06609189510345459,
-0.8169375061988831,
-0.35443970561027527,
0.06087656319141388,
0.16200703382492065,
-0.1394101232290268,
0.6192708611488342,
-0.22962677478790283,
0.31550684571266174,
0.18606875836849213,
-0.26485201716423035,
0.05980686843395233,
-0.5921815633773804,
-0.08241849392652512,
0.581703782081604,
0.40617966651916504,
0.3973643481731415,
0.030392076820135117,
-0.36816370487213135,
0.13736127316951752,
0.03480469435453415,
0.08803413063287735,
-1.008875846862793,
-0.11415308713912964,
0.2475307136774063,
-0.3200359046459198,
-0.05045275762677193,
-0.11123547703027725,
-0.731449544429779,
-0.5450164675712585,
-0.40703627467155457,
0.416582316160202,
-0.4901491701602936,
0.01311396062374115,
-0.15625594556331635,
-0.4428912401199341,
-0.08996559679508209,
0.6492008566856384,
-0.8465541005134583,
0.15091001987457275,
0.5594390630722046,
0.9110547304153442,
-0.23879744112491608,
-0.08556797355413437,
-0.08925676345825195,
0.24827755987644196,
-0.4620591700077057,
0.7573580741882324,
-0.332714706659317,
-0.4184529185295105,
-0.2964329719543457,
0.0139973945915699,
0.1381891965866089,
-0.7361932992935181,
0.2522103786468506,
-0.35255661606788635,
-0.18242919445037842,
-0.5840772986412048,
-0.77991783618927,
-0.372928261756897,
0.1692623347043991,
-0.5386127233505249,
0.5856178998947144,
0.1358814537525177,
-0.7010863423347473,
0.5644803047180176,
-0.5106881260871887,
-0.6316620707511902,
0.01799602247774601,
-0.38288435339927673,
0.08898027241230011,
0.19793270528316498,
-0.2302360087633133,
0.07794421166181564,
0.058214787393808365,
0.5677001476287842,
-0.3003060519695282,
-0.21686089038848877,
0.5157471895217896,
-0.5090795159339905,
0.45129644870758057,
0.19225884974002838,
-0.6005213856697083,
-0.1501501500606537,
-1.1122056245803833,
-0.4039163291454315,
-0.33030304312705994,
-0.616513192653656,
-0.19631320238113403,
0.010346107184886932,
-0.18585112690925598,
-0.05183355137705803,
0.13891135156154633,
-0.45714056491851807,
0.276626855134964,
-0.20105203986167908,
0.24803610146045685,
0.435575008392334,
0.3026856482028961,
0.429098516702652,
-0.18427100777626038,
0.17438404262065887,
0.44286152720451355,
-0.14237649738788605,
0.1738506257534027,
-0.39509543776512146,
-0.8510374426841736,
-0.1715291440486908,
0.26829099655151367,
0.5139705538749695,
-0.5537627339363098,
0.5115910172462463,
-0.12865428626537323,
-0.2089526504278183,
0.06554435938596725,
0.1721552461385727,
0.16593824326992035,
0.7157292366027832,
0.3716507852077484,
0.11270272731781006,
-1.048956274986267,
-1.1261669397354126,
-0.1566583663225174,
-0.07585860788822174,
0.062184855341911316,
0.1523616909980774,
0.8788049817085266,
-0.792979896068573,
1.009966254234314,
-0.4400797486305237,
-0.1138492077589035,
-0.05629415437579155,
0.20632076263427734,
0.0031705184374004602,
0.4607929587364197,
0.42460954189300537,
-0.6713050007820129,
0.07395195215940475,
0.027286160737276077,
-1.0566872358322144,
0.05245976895093918,
-0.017494024708867073,
0.010725320316851139,
0.3436749577522278,
0.624840259552002,
-0.6969144940376282,
0.41508013010025024,
0.28275007009506226,
-0.47002682089805603,
0.15144632756710052,
-0.37957924604415894,
0.5122369527816772,
-0.7402387857437134,
0.2833027243614197,
-0.03976985439658165,
-0.4562632739543915,
-0.833794355392456,
0.010739849880337715,
-0.12849295139312744,
0.30597832798957825,
-0.41026729345321655,
0.390230655670166,
-0.3359667956829071,
0.14712214469909668,
-0.4714661240577698,
0.35625460743904114,
-0.039984218776226044,
0.18256056308746338,
0.047651708126068115,
0.6904351115226746,
0.08304023742675781,
-0.9418708086013794,
0.24784688651561737,
0.04151563346385956,
-0.4683954119682312,
0.34768912196159363,
-0.38993600010871887,
-0.06587687134742737,
-0.18149162828922272,
0.2865663766860962,
-0.8628295063972473,
-0.4328264892101288,
0.10112787038087845,
-0.11628734320402145,
-0.007822306826710701,
-0.04422818869352341,
-0.2290882170200348,
0.02969851717352867,
-0.2570149600505829,
0.4890035092830658,
0.6567081809043884,
-0.4877706468105316,
0.6516279578208923,
0.5506277084350586,
0.306941419839859,
-0.5863906145095825,
-0.8171535730361938,
0.24947036802768707,
-0.3409178555011749,
-0.4988965094089508,
0.40880200266838074,
-0.18776215612888336,
-0.741206169128418,
-0.0452018566429615,
-0.4787495732307434,
-0.14814400672912598,
0.10140331089496613,
0.35073116421699524,
-0.041297584772109985,
-0.1750178188085556,
0.23250365257263184,
0.1234162300825119,
-0.0456116683781147,
0.24275580048561096,
0.09134695678949356,
0.11362244188785553,
-0.053397443145513535,
0.027450598776340485,
-0.28913459181785583,
0.20239102840423584,
0.5880436301231384,
0.7501391172409058,
0.5532118082046509,
0.4667696952819824,
-0.5394240021705627,
-0.23856636881828308,
-0.42403432726860046,
-0.4360629916191101,
-0.44118672609329224,
0.2740578353404999,
-0.1354122906923294,
-0.8801129460334778,
0.6530199646949768,
-0.1403992623090744,
-0.5132131576538086,
0.5938382744789124,
0.5826717615127563,
0.055857110768556595,
0.572079062461853,
0.7401347160339355,
0.3680102825164795,
0.05853235349059105,
-0.17744627594947815,
0.31326377391815186,
-0.596598207950592,
-0.27820950746536255,
-0.2943008542060852,
-0.16709649562835693,
-0.5511353611946106,
-0.5487138032913208,
0.5861976146697998,
0.06994200497865677,
-0.19658777117729187,
0.2053324580192566,
-0.11069739609956741,
0.6351857781410217,
0.3408564031124115,
0.2754615247249603,
0.5582726001739502,
-0.061594754457473755,
0.026036154478788376,
0.2199525684118271,
-0.6079344153404236,
-0.6817150712013245,
0.789516031742096,
0.25353607535362244,
0.5237118005752563,
0.3633374869823456,
0.5895054340362549,
0.5566400289535522,
-0.07289750874042511,
-0.8333085775375366,
0.7031952142715454,
-0.17332960665225983,
-0.6505416035652161,
-0.14429514110088348,
-0.80898118019104,
-0.7442126870155334,
0.18328425288200378,
-0.17574846744537354,
-0.7384512424468994,
0.5725565552711487,
0.2972323000431061,
-0.6505062580108643,
0.19183191657066345,
-0.4514792561531067,
0.5415442585945129,
0.11245506256818771,
-0.12940868735313416,
-0.24923288822174072,
-0.5534462928771973,
0.7092515230178833,
-0.08890707045793533,
0.41031673550605774,
-0.22103624045848846,
-0.07364115864038467,
0.6929899454116821,
-0.5549677610397339,
0.9465845227241516,
0.08928302675485611,
-0.5477641820907593,
0.26755380630493164,
0.4092246890068054,
0.3593073785305023,
0.27262696623802185,
0.3848724365234375,
0.30015072226524353,
0.26247984170913696,
0.04565615952014923,
-0.558709979057312,
0.7153531908988953,
-0.6385307312011719,
-0.7299196124076843,
-0.38224077224731445,
-0.5174016952514648,
-0.037978511303663254,
0.06366667151451111,
0.3514913320541382,
0.5091739892959595,
-0.2554848790168762,
0.4708039462566376,
1.12055242061615,
0.016565341502428055,
0.3557341396808624,
0.6621324419975281,
-0.10165970027446747,
-0.44670388102531433,
0.8166722655296326,
0.23555737733840942,
0.19515202939510345,
0.6026843786239624,
0.342445969581604,
-0.2769638001918793,
-0.4615921080112457,
-0.32911667227745056,
0.09015268087387085,
-1.2116308212280273,
-0.0041456157341599464,
-0.8690630793571472,
-0.09190063178539276,
-0.4017788767814636,
0.052073098719120026,
-0.3965063691139221,
-0.8112984299659729,
-0.14089645445346832,
-0.23818165063858032,
0.47924089431762695,
0.7478501200675964,
-0.4537995457649231,
-0.13416749238967896,
-0.8909078240394592,
0.7281776666641235,
0.38519105315208435,
-0.03733305633068085,
-0.24177318811416626,
-0.5698961019515991,
-0.3281266391277313,
0.20670469105243683,
-0.00009548447269480675,
-0.9093403220176697,
-0.07800695300102234,
0.18589940667152405,
0.4548041522502899,
0.582171618938446,
0.1229717805981636,
0.6075959801673889,
-0.34651535749435425,
0.8163372278213501,
-0.2890312671661377,
-1.1283138990402222,
0.5181729197502136,
-0.065514475107193,
0.03182600066065788,
0.5875104665756226,
0.3558489680290222,
-0.5762697458267212,
-0.3794618844985962,
-0.6340360641479492,
-0.9220448136329651,
0.4146697223186493,
0.30377691984176636,
0.008706185966730118,
-0.0537726953625679,
0.5807505249977112,
0.012186666019260883,
0.21196408569812775,
-0.5856845378875732,
-0.5264061689376831,
0.12134325504302979,
-0.33309170603752136,
0.011210196651518345,
-0.5395292639732361,
-0.6553248763084412,
-0.4076744318008423,
0.5359699726104736,
-0.04485497623682022,
0.08223127573728561,
0.5090559720993042,
-0.42067694664001465,
-0.09719054400920868,
0.22761766612529755,
1.234500527381897,
0.8376796245574951,
-0.5488401055335999,
0.6464518904685974,
0.3282313048839569,
-0.6266872882843018,
0.46989089250564575,
-0.4904789924621582,
-0.33068954944610596,
0.025943992659449577,
0.656952440738678,
0.671608567237854,
0.1777564138174057,
-0.642880380153656,
0.26818913221359253,
0.07893238216638565,
-0.11506650596857071,
0.01752171665430069,
0.32383599877357483,
-0.06879852712154388,
0.31863102316856384,
0.20037908852100372,
0.19509100914001465,
0.4624039828777313,
-0.9373859167098999,
0.2853042781352997,
0.3182579278945923,
0.0761227160692215,
-0.3459833562374115,
0.39104193449020386,
0.15319454669952393,
0.21014432609081268,
0.38439130783081055,
-0.25759395956993103,
-0.4520728290081024,
0.849673867225647,
0.3751535713672638,
0.9980022311210632,
-0.009245963767170906,
0.062172938138246536,
0.43496617674827576,
0.44114959239959717,
-0.07851489633321762,
0.024511419236660004,
-0.17506641149520874,
-0.6881205439567566,
-0.058617282658815384,
-0.38058412075042725,
-0.48901623487472534,
0.06548362970352173,
-0.37201210856437683,
-0.10017839819192886,
-0.3538364768028259,
-0.0739283636212349,
0.08003026247024536,
-0.13324877619743347,
-0.143745556473732,
0.20364341139793396,
0.3383382558822632,
0.7902882099151611,
-0.9801550507545471,
0.7380799651145935,
0.39664995670318604,
-0.2773103415966034,
-0.20190002024173737,
0.044688012450933456,
0.37636294960975647,
-0.6106430292129517,
1.0548638105392456,
0.10431031882762909,
-0.5098070502281189,
-0.22946682572364807,
-0.3954957127571106,
-1.1452258825302124,
0.9020140767097473,
0.5744125843048096,
-0.6651636958122253,
0.08580927550792694,
0.24466751515865326,
0.659047544002533,
-0.3594403564929962,
0.12349151074886322,
0.769564151763916,
0.8294488191604614,
0.3744865655899048,
-0.5232807993888855,
0.400088369846344,
-0.0738353505730629,
0.06067138537764549,
-0.07790038734674454,
-0.2918879985809326,
0.8867570161819458,
-0.3826025426387787,
-0.6570292115211487,
-0.2495698183774948,
0.5034881830215454,
0.01898326352238655,
0.43711408972740173,
0.36252501606941223,
0.508092999458313,
0.9514445066452026,
-0.10004663467407227,
0.9281036853790283,
-0.6533987522125244,
0.4119347631931305,
0.9969877600669861,
-0.1825423687696457,
0.4937976002693176,
0.5883241295814514,
-0.28365862369537354,
0.5231054425239563,
0.6538648009300232,
-0.008203721605241299,
0.3739466369152069,
0.21319344639778137,
-0.12590278685092926,
-0.2512536346912384,
0.04489780589938164,
-0.46539396047592163,
0.49753299355506897,
0.29966092109680176,
-0.17613418400287628,
-0.33400028944015503,
0.08932625502347946,
0.31080833077430725,
-0.1228557601571083,
-0.05973139405250549,
0.9546170234680176,
-0.039016030728816986,
-0.44925251603126526,
0.8396302461624146,
-0.03567164018750191,
0.28273820877075195,
-0.3839837610721588,
-0.19791045784950256,
-0.6401158571243286,
0.35402968525886536,
-0.3916037082672119,
-0.4809946119785309,
0.40442365407943726,
-0.015054205432534218,
-0.6219140887260437,
0.22255884110927582,
0.5901796221733093,
-0.6047042608261108,
-0.2772389352321625,
0.07606219500303268,
0.2624671459197998,
0.11374146491289139,
-0.053739238530397415,
-0.2174118608236313,
0.16700629889965057,
0.07158295810222626,
-0.015776731073856354,
0.14624403417110443,
0.5440302491188049,
0.18315154314041138,
0.7330923080444336,
0.2135057896375656,
-0.12777003645896912,
-0.15290431678295135,
-0.1542951762676239,
0.7016499042510986,
-0.9678417444229126,
-0.13283780217170715,
-1.3714542388916016,
0.287923127412796,
0.037155818194150925,
-0.2990792691707611,
1.1344950199127197,
0.5769099593162537,
0.5987016558647156,
-0.0889625996351242,
0.5335448384284973,
-0.06066569313406944,
0.06417204439640045,
-0.7009924650192261,
0.668063223361969,
-0.3958655297756195,
0.33454930782318115,
-0.07398819178342819,
-0.8150533437728882,
-0.3397432267665863,
0.4426761269569397,
0.1237107366323471,
0.24852126836776733,
1.0944515466690063,
0.8956888318061829,
-0.03725457563996315,
0.08197684586048126,
0.3573785722255707,
0.540939450263977,
0.15447752177715302,
0.4774865508079529,
0.8816027641296387,
-0.3949822187423706,
0.09957753866910934,
-0.48314404487609863,
-0.07669360935688019,
-0.7061982750892639,
-1.1707662343978882,
-0.7745016813278198,
-0.5203088521957397,
-0.9649909138679504,
-0.39722082018852234,
-0.029643265530467033,
1.166355848312378,
0.7286263704299927,
-0.8348191976547241,
-0.2258778065443039,
-0.24570687115192413,
0.494309663772583,
0.009469741024076939,
-0.21249768137931824,
0.332274466753006,
-0.17009806632995605,
-0.38290828466415405,
0.6648035049438477,
0.4697466790676117,
0.5396174192428589,
-0.1809154897928238,
-0.015797512605786324,
-0.07703977078199387,
0.46111810207366943,
0.7878779172897339,
0.14425955712795258,
-0.8411457538604736,
-0.29221051931381226,
-0.4945594072341919,
-0.2993704080581665,
0.3452189564704895,
0.931839108467102,
-0.6321596503257751,
0.29540789127349854,
0.5852411389350891,
0.22650164365768433,
0.029798997566103935,
0.17493735253810883,
0.36210525035858154,
-0.6219635009765625,
0.08391622453927994,
-0.041801486164331436,
0.42357704043388367,
0.1774965226650238,
-0.7260339260101318,
0.47002550959587097,
0.6099059581756592,
-0.5354257225990295,
-1.0513960123062134,
0.2900378704071045,
-1.115152359008789,
-0.5914654731750488,
1.1539043188095093,
0.13777345418930054,
-0.5763476490974426,
-0.05583405867218971,
-0.07054740190505981,
0.2138780802488327,
-0.24206382036209106,
0.9830458164215088,
0.5865902304649353,
-0.2143620252609253,
0.031945012509822845,
-0.31002336740493774,
1.0620969533920288,
0.08453623205423355,
-0.9484096169471741,
0.37819451093673706,
0.7083459496498108,
0.20468340814113617,
0.3886771500110626,
0.36421453952789307,
0.2270149439573288,
0.2414400428533554,
0.3009907007217407,
-0.08075542747974396,
-0.012617751024663448,
-0.63266921043396,
-0.5133036971092224,
0.2876179814338684,
-0.15735046565532684,
0.19774523377418518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20060v1 | Applying RLAIF for Code Generation with API-usage in Lightweight LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:16:03 | 2024-06-28T17:16:03 | Sujan Dutta, Sayantan Mahinder, Raviteja Anantha, Bortik Bandyopadhyay | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement Learning from AI Feedback (RLAIF) has demonstrated significant
potential across various domains, including mitigating harm in LLM outputs,
enhancing text summarization, and mathematical reasoning. This paper introduces
an RLAIF framework for improving the code generation abilities of lightweight
(<1B parameters) LLMs. We specifically focus on code generation tasks that
require writing appropriate API calls, which is challenging due to the
well-known issue of hallucination in LLMs. Our framework extracts AI feedback
from a larger LLM (e.g., GPT-3.5) through a specialized prompting strategy and
uses this data to train a reward model towards better alignment from smaller
LLMs. We run our experiments on the Gorilla dataset and meticulously assess the
quality of the model-generated code across various metrics, including AST,
ROUGE, and Code-BLEU, and develop a pipeline to compute its executability rate
accurately. Our approach significantly enhances the fine-tuned LLM baseline's
performance, achieving a 4.5% improvement in executability rate. Notably, a
smaller LLM model (780M parameters) trained with RLAIF surpasses a much larger
fine-tuned baseline with 7B parameters, achieving a 1.0% higher code
executability rate. | [
-0.21627920866012573,
-0.7348617911338806,
0.25280940532684326,
0.297961562871933,
-0.3883238434791565,
-0.06667578965425491,
-0.3225836157798767,
-0.46401897072792053,
0.18855756521224976,
0.3499567210674286,
-0.7561823725700378,
-0.5957522988319397,
-0.5251787304878235,
0.11701449751853943,
-0.09110791981220245,
1.1697447299957275,
-0.07062861323356628,
-0.12114739418029785,
-0.2587922513484955,
-0.29315000772476196,
-0.6003304123878479,
-0.2588672935962677,
-0.7006142735481262,
-0.4343893229961395,
0.6907688975334167,
0.5428051352500916,
0.6902441382408142,
0.8784487247467041,
0.31001922488212585,
0.21903221309185028,
0.1881098747253418,
0.4764830768108368,
-0.6538355946540833,
0.1920846402645111,
0.2303503155708313,
-0.41245418787002563,
-0.38085365295410156,
-0.1628302037715912,
0.11395497620105743,
0.2950078547000885,
-0.3801625669002533,
0.46279725432395935,
0.15061527490615845,
0.7603673338890076,
-0.5566955804824829,
0.29816269874572754,
-0.4806331992149353,
0.2767634987831116,
0.19999344646930695,
-0.588610827922821,
-0.5554981827735901,
-0.3970896899700165,
-0.2531726360321045,
-0.5880216956138611,
-0.04295109212398529,
0.30137893557548523,
0.6575603485107422,
0.8200037479400635,
0.04538089036941528,
-0.5634832978248596,
-0.30971047282218933,
0.8151870965957642,
-0.7692044973373413,
0.20468515157699585,
0.16888396441936493,
-0.1571936160326004,
-0.21988314390182495,
-0.8345491290092468,
-0.1819828301668167,
-0.649599552154541,
-0.10011103749275208,
0.11321872472763062,
0.21012774109840393,
-0.02160913683474064,
0.40144503116607666,
0.2635098099708557,
-0.6658440828323364,
0.18970222771167755,
-0.36016273498535156,
-0.19007550179958344,
0.6578719019889832,
0.2444993108510971,
0.1269952654838562,
-0.22727654874324799,
-0.17026858031749725,
0.05157070979475975,
-0.938481867313385,
0.3164568245410919,
0.6562670469284058,
0.39913785457611084,
-0.230667382478714,
0.5632961392402649,
-0.1326882541179657,
0.6349959969520569,
0.20664922893047333,
-0.5665186643600464,
0.2431289702653885,
0.05037722736597061,
-0.10384827107191086,
0.05710843577980995,
0.5512219071388245,
0.3867975175380707,
0.07865558564662933,
-0.13097131252288818,
-0.5257236957550049,
-0.09957318007946014,
0.5141797065734863,
-1.1457403898239136,
-0.40491196513175964,
0.2580711245536804,
-0.9368197917938232,
-0.48253539204597473,
0.003710406133905053,
-0.4663321375846863,
-0.4462425410747528,
-0.4196409285068512,
0.18476377427577972,
-0.3505212664604187,
-0.04800780490040779,
-0.025023913010954857,
0.11855165660381317,
0.3203805387020111,
0.21311700344085693,
-0.8938581347465515,
0.018376344814896584,
0.6717395186424255,
0.7007702589035034,
-0.30932697653770447,
-0.3823005259037018,
-1.1845109462738037,
0.012716742232441902,
-0.27628469467163086,
0.6498082280158997,
-0.2281959056854248,
-0.5260692834854126,
0.02140135131776333,
-0.36446309089660645,
0.2074844092130661,
-0.8501752018928528,
0.3827258050441742,
-0.2802347242832184,
-0.2869388461112976,
0.10546302795410156,
-0.38726145029067993,
-0.0005182023742236197,
0.10496491193771362,
-0.5811774730682373,
1.2458175420761108,
0.23009012639522552,
-0.6090349555015564,
0.7394027709960938,
-0.3239087164402008,
-0.5913234949111938,
0.26311561465263367,
-0.34365519881248474,
-0.752707302570343,
0.17155112326145172,
0.4175763726234436,
0.41502106189727783,
-0.1135314404964447,
0.3026859760284424,
-0.3665257692337036,
-0.7284838557243347,
0.24073526263237,
-0.28477829694747925,
0.20636175572872162,
0.1875239908695221,
-0.5671135187149048,
0.4127481281757355,
-0.779744029045105,
0.22864992916584015,
-0.09173993021249771,
-0.7336316108703613,
0.11953036487102509,
0.05596785619854927,
0.040131576359272,
-0.014018877409398556,
0.16455386579036713,
-0.11815131455659866,
0.1695869266986847,
-0.2937586307525635,
0.30218979716300964,
0.8612107038497925,
0.18473561108112335,
0.36068543791770935,
-0.5468406081199646,
0.6886662840843201,
-0.4666905999183655,
0.15444587171077728,
0.008447309955954552,
-0.31957900524139404,
-0.7267058491706848,
-0.7029750347137451,
0.28091758489608765,
0.5474820733070374,
-0.8335095047950745,
0.48620226979255676,
0.06964202970266342,
-0.3346635103225708,
-0.6353462934494019,
0.6691106557846069,
0.5296223759651184,
0.48803025484085083,
0.26033052802085876,
-0.06418872624635696,
-0.5072927474975586,
-0.6713922619819641,
-0.09355822950601578,
-0.49054449796676636,
0.11874087899923325,
0.6685474514961243,
0.48056110739707947,
-0.3930974304676056,
0.7068602442741394,
-0.3626512289047241,
-0.12324272841215134,
-0.48479151725769043,
0.3848378658294678,
0.14175817370414734,
0.6382197737693787,
0.3277706801891327,
-0.5346003174781799,
-0.059265416115522385,
-0.36913323402404785,
-0.8074419498443604,
-0.400179922580719,
-0.24188865721225739,
-0.03548376262187958,
0.3743303418159485,
0.6700472831726074,
-0.3209606409072876,
0.3853227198123932,
0.4835991859436035,
0.04967884719371796,
0.4329679012298584,
-0.22128695249557495,
0.06424294412136078,
-0.7061671614646912,
0.05215851962566376,
-0.1984393298625946,
-0.27819928526878357,
0.028409987688064575,
0.3046521246433258,
0.002296886406838894,
-0.19145727157592773,
-0.6827033758163452,
0.5326863527297974,
-0.17359118163585663,
-0.16107438504695892,
-0.48021355271339417,
-0.00716478331014514,
-0.3412546217441559,
0.7955065965652466,
0.13081489503383636,
0.9941914677619934,
0.36547648906707764,
-0.8333780765533447,
0.40617308020591736,
0.10454979538917542,
-0.2425098419189453,
0.4540863633155823,
-0.8217287659645081,
-0.05690130591392517,
-0.024159859865903854,
0.43143558502197266,
-0.5223296284675598,
-0.21210436522960663,
0.4450322985649109,
-0.42869889736175537,
0.12975174188613892,
-0.24357788264751434,
-0.5712982416152954,
-0.2161777764558792,
-0.5221519470214844,
0.4695006012916565,
0.6601973176002502,
-0.9058022499084473,
0.7086255550384521,
0.06423985213041306,
-0.20728431642055511,
-0.7391587495803833,
-0.602399468421936,
-0.14369116723537445,
-0.33748745918273926,
-0.6008988618850708,
0.025597713887691498,
-0.22069384157657623,
-0.07132430374622345,
-0.03722378611564636,
-0.13020636141300201,
0.5085986256599426,
0.21808432042598724,
0.7675120830535889,
0.280679851770401,
0.03460850194096565,
0.07569516450166702,
0.10309596359729767,
-0.34216171503067017,
0.08161775767803192,
-0.36625105142593384,
0.3568544089794159,
-0.14200462400913239,
-0.398568332195282,
-0.41672283411026,
0.05730709433555603,
0.08635663241147995,
-0.07503584027290344,
0.394976943731308,
0.8043690919876099,
0.05392543599009514,
-0.8365965485572815,
-0.2263830602169037,
-0.32581427693367004,
-0.4761236011981964,
0.26500439643859863,
-0.2353910654783249,
-1.1515541076660156,
0.4143896996974945,
-0.23982906341552734,
0.17418831586837769,
0.07498098164796829,
0.7632275223731995,
0.1393212229013443,
1.0227069854736328,
0.7269293665885925,
-0.06479468196630478,
0.37582114338874817,
-0.2956176996231079,
0.11715497821569443,
-0.7004179954528809,
-0.3903484642505646,
-0.28764232993125916,
-0.40842053294181824,
-0.6201231479644775,
-0.2840776741504669,
0.25000235438346863,
0.2514907121658325,
-0.16898101568222046,
0.16546912491321564,
-0.6091653108596802,
0.3093811869621277,
0.47648030519485474,
0.2125849425792694,
0.13926614820957184,
-0.13757848739624023,
-0.043551985174417496,
0.06603102385997772,
-0.8700404763221741,
-0.4070030748844147,
0.984648585319519,
0.4369407892227173,
1.3628244400024414,
-0.03374162316322327,
1.0680861473083496,
0.6098778247833252,
0.6173274517059326,
-0.8304323554039001,
0.5131588578224182,
0.24586476385593414,
0.027647197246551514,
-0.013867104426026344,
-0.7770487070083618,
-0.5710241794586182,
0.026300420984625816,
-0.24529385566711426,
-0.4610559940338135,
-0.07120558619499207,
0.42372164130210876,
-0.5493761897087097,
-0.0754345953464508,
-0.5447685718536377,
0.5319401025772095,
-0.38665705919265747,
-0.47831475734710693,
-0.09354108572006226,
-0.4307074248790741,
0.6499828100204468,
0.09267240017652512,
0.1195719763636589,
-0.0030091265216469765,
-0.235864520072937,
0.6565939784049988,
-0.6675087809562683,
0.9006182551383972,
-0.18233580887317657,
-0.4226089119911194,
0.4702589809894562,
0.05645081400871277,
0.6912234425544739,
0.894720733165741,
-0.04511581361293793,
-0.25046324729919434,
-0.36827605962753296,
-0.2156287282705307,
-0.528069794178009,
0.7491675019264221,
-0.8936586976051331,
-0.310807466506958,
-0.2753855288028717,
-0.8307532072067261,
0.0036357874050736427,
-0.16310986876487732,
0.4864746034145355,
0.4855146110057831,
0.1381477564573288,
0.08171480149030685,
0.8774557113647461,
-0.37561124563217163,
0.3345586359500885,
0.36914318799972534,
-0.35432493686676025,
-0.7320799231529236,
1.1377180814743042,
-0.3071812391281128,
-0.021770311519503593,
0.10373277962207794,
-0.22008255124092102,
-0.2800152897834778,
-0.5132172703742981,
-0.7456130981445312,
0.05541101470589638,
-0.7898325324058533,
-0.6044661402702332,
-0.48066163063049316,
-0.1258871704339981,
-0.2698238492012024,
-0.43410995602607727,
-0.17761261761188507,
-0.32809558510780334,
-0.36432042717933655,
-0.192979097366333,
0.5143001675605774,
0.7819392681121826,
-0.20111165940761566,
0.2750992774963379,
-0.7050978541374207,
0.3498091399669647,
0.269530713558197,
0.30293965339660645,
0.011430170387029648,
-0.5843043327331543,
-0.3121171295642853,
-0.34601446986198425,
-0.05198880285024643,
-0.34456077218055725,
0.22821885347366333,
0.07047582417726517,
0.5741091370582581,
0.182285875082016,
0.13898402452468872,
0.7522338628768921,
-0.2461836338043213,
0.8098247051239014,
0.08247663825750351,
-0.8134530186653137,
0.43255600333213806,
-0.05225533992052078,
0.10715898126363754,
0.6479024887084961,
-0.16402791440486908,
-0.05778421834111214,
-0.5746600031852722,
-0.603300154209137,
-1.0224283933639526,
0.5351594090461731,
0.07182878255844116,
0.08269155770540237,
0.09269256889820099,
0.7663518786430359,
0.20427174866199493,
0.3126735985279083,
-0.9329860806465149,
-0.1436622142791748,
-0.13567104935646057,
-0.19310425221920013,
0.2647194266319275,
0.012918111868202686,
-0.12867873907089233,
0.03936927020549774,
0.8983955979347229,
-0.5018720626831055,
0.1559322029352188,
-0.09515794366598129,
-0.34223422408103943,
-0.27594462037086487,
-0.03745128586888313,
0.6539591550827026,
0.6327385902404785,
-0.17200368642807007,
0.03221350535750389,
0.22715403139591217,
-0.3275899589061737,
0.07356537133455276,
0.0751846581697464,
-0.36879250407218933,
-0.3461105525493622,
0.511762797832489,
0.7272615432739258,
0.11566437035799026,
-1.1253024339675903,
0.42435958981513977,
-0.2901287078857422,
-0.3610334098339081,
-0.16491194069385529,
0.49465879797935486,
-0.12481369078159332,
0.3698546588420868,
0.3108634948730469,
0.018766455352306366,
0.004291697405278683,
-0.22534695267677307,
0.46425557136535645,
0.4089828431606293,
-0.3100244402885437,
0.08908125013113022,
0.719618022441864,
0.3843905031681061,
-0.17324064671993256,
0.6570197343826294,
-0.527472198009491,
-0.26593509316444397,
0.6102453470230103,
0.5534120798110962,
0.7173293232917786,
0.3912113904953003,
0.26869723200798035,
0.39293545484542847,
0.21075670421123505,
-0.02343350648880005,
0.28103870153427124,
-0.3166806399822235,
-0.23834018409252167,
-0.6192824244499207,
-0.7858878374099731,
-0.3829379379749298,
0.047360215336084366,
-0.595772922039032,
0.28574779629707336,
-0.7674911618232727,
0.02640097215771675,
-0.6764010787010193,
0.08861470967531204,
-0.2785094380378723,
0.12362024933099747,
0.0988202691078186,
0.7644923329353333,
-0.6305711269378662,
0.43208691477775574,
0.45840221643447876,
-0.6743364930152893,
-1.1614375114440918,
0.07484274357557297,
0.04420248046517372,
-0.8731027245521545,
0.6956034302711487,
0.25685223937034607,
-0.3892671763896942,
0.016973787918686867,
-0.8711747527122498,
-0.5458825826644897,
1.3255153894424438,
0.4027772843837738,
-0.20377466082572937,
0.20224547386169434,
-0.12798084318637848,
0.27433040738105774,
-0.5430994629859924,
0.15256235003471375,
0.38840141892433167,
0.3148833215236664,
0.11133965849876404,
-0.40948039293289185,
0.1503795087337494,
-0.3053356409072876,
0.2788815498352051,
0.03357728570699692,
-0.6689245700836182,
0.5969907641410828,
-0.5436813235282898,
0.09299111366271973,
0.5062577724456787,
1.0308696031570435,
0.9574803113937378,
0.08573771268129349,
0.3838391602039337,
0.6990469098091125,
0.695202648639679,
0.22275234758853912,
1.0046491622924805,
-0.505109965801239,
0.18171125650405884,
0.9828563332557678,
-0.3465595245361328,
0.6895248889923096,
0.467254638671875,
0.34580671787261963,
0.5964609980583191,
0.7798386812210083,
-0.13979250192642212,
0.49203282594680786,
0.6123008728027344,
-0.06419633328914642,
-0.19012227654457092,
-0.09868691861629486,
-0.3519747853279114,
-0.01532121654599905,
0.08191923797130585,
-0.15673530101776123,
-0.046990565955638885,
0.21526576578617096,
0.1337902992963791,
0.05868839472532272,
-0.4265398681163788,
0.831410825252533,
0.1768365055322647,
-0.8453149199485779,
0.6319221258163452,
0.22603057324886322,
0.8806086182594299,
-0.47168809175491333,
-0.29357263445854187,
-0.42951035499572754,
0.33622199296951294,
-0.4880530536174774,
-0.40400877594947815,
0.017561456188559532,
0.1902473121881485,
-0.12953045964241028,
-0.2402534931898117,
0.8062459230422974,
-0.26262515783309937,
-0.3176812529563904,
0.31817516684532166,
0.47731077671051025,
-0.04128493368625641,
0.45840176939964294,
-0.8616254329681396,
0.3864414691925049,
0.00842706672847271,
-0.21020996570587158,
0.39233022928237915,
0.40006691217422485,
0.2685959041118622,
0.8139114379882812,
0.7493446469306946,
0.19070985913276672,
0.09537529200315475,
0.11659444123506546,
0.8988300561904907,
-0.3473221957683563,
-0.5557001829147339,
-0.5578324794769287,
0.40089330077171326,
0.3244760036468506,
-0.4768792688846588,
0.5803898572921753,
0.6212384104728699,
0.7037792801856995,
-0.13372738659381866,
0.8031404614448547,
-0.2313864529132843,
0.18404148519039154,
-0.8259615302085876,
0.4675341844558716,
-0.5049994587898254,
0.55539470911026,
-0.18676155805587769,
-0.932219386100769,
-0.23587632179260254,
0.6836269497871399,
-0.005499969236552715,
0.2516224980354309,
0.48563817143440247,
1.1392805576324463,
0.07336502522230148,
-0.19331088662147522,
0.075694240629673,
-0.2974575459957123,
0.34536847472190857,
0.5640624761581421,
0.9996192455291748,
-0.24905924499034882,
0.8638529181480408,
-0.1324900984764099,
-0.18453654646873474,
-0.2937399446964264,
-0.9301236867904663,
-0.8348689675331116,
-0.09782963991165161,
-0.48509493470191956,
-0.644582211971283,
0.16097356379032135,
1.1616007089614868,
0.8053230047225952,
-0.5153368711471558,
-0.22563832998275757,
-0.3379666209220886,
0.13519708812236786,
-0.4794822931289673,
-0.22647762298583984,
0.27686014771461487,
-0.8168082237243652,
-0.40355008840560913,
0.3648163974285126,
0.2455618530511856,
-0.1997462958097458,
-0.26889568567276,
-0.8780907392501831,
0.32826197147369385,
0.05899269878864288,
0.4279813766479492,
0.4063186049461365,
-0.568105161190033,
-0.387656033039093,
-0.12252192199230194,
-0.16924722492694855,
-0.21023671329021454,
1.0604361295700073,
-0.9904894828796387,
-0.22882986068725586,
0.2917368412017822,
0.9005695581436157,
0.2754407227039337,
0.15122100710868835,
0.35116976499557495,
-0.9542089700698853,
0.2699972689151764,
0.24543941020965576,
0.2723056972026825,
0.3303219974040985,
-0.47067245841026306,
0.5626890063285828,
0.18045075237751007,
-0.7449808716773987,
-0.8122331500053406,
0.292874813079834,
-0.885316789150238,
-0.2162364274263382,
1.2081890106201172,
-0.09890182316303253,
-0.24203209578990936,
0.1929103285074234,
-0.30714550614356995,
0.048731621354818344,
-0.7187984585762024,
0.8024638891220093,
0.25330716371536255,
-0.5263722538948059,
-0.4749770760536194,
-0.4393998384475708,
0.730194091796875,
0.4475475549697876,
-0.9723736047744751,
0.19845815002918243,
0.6965951919555664,
0.20361986756324768,
-0.03927904739975929,
0.717002272605896,
-0.06853430718183517,
0.5789110064506531,
-0.06830061227083206,
0.04126666486263275,
-0.3376360833644867,
-0.3968507945537567,
-0.21530796587467194,
0.272639662027359,
0.4573777914047241,
0.12577110528945923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20054v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20054v1 | To Word Senses and Beyond: Inducing Concepts with Contextualized Language Models | 2024-06-28T17:07:06 | 2024-06-28T17:07:06 | Bastien Liétard, Pascal Denis, Mikaella Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Polysemy and synonymy are two crucial interrelated facets of lexical
ambiguity. While both phenomena have been studied extensively in NLP, leading
to dedicated systems, they are often been considered independently. While many
tasks dealing with polysemy (e.g. Word Sense Disambiguiation or Induction)
highlight the role of a word's senses, the study of synonymy is rooted in the
study of concepts, i.e. meaning shared across the lexicon. In this paper, we
introduce Concept Induction, the unsupervised task of learning a soft
clustering among words that defines a set of concepts directly from data. This
task generalizes that of Word Sense Induction. We propose a bi-level approach
to Concept Induction that leverages both a local lemma-centric view and a
global cross-lexicon perspective to induce concepts. We evaluate the obtained
clustering on SemCor's annotated data and obtain good performances (BCubed F1
above 0.60). We find that the local and the global levels are mutually
beneficial to induce concepts and also senses in our setting. Finally, we
create static embeddings representing our induced concepts and use them on the
Word-in-Context task, obtaining competitive performances with the
State-of-the-Art. | [
-0.39922794699668884,
-0.580907940864563,
0.5709565877914429,
-0.13283595442771912,
-0.44847309589385986,
-0.04408353194594383,
-0.3473491072654724,
-0.37502431869506836,
0.34507840871810913,
-0.09104729443788528,
-0.24844975769519806,
-0.35155269503593445,
-0.6549407839775085,
0.0653204545378685,
-0.5786670446395874,
0.7402538657188416,
0.06207181140780449,
-0.09840987622737885,
-0.6131844520568848,
-0.20782245695590973,
-0.3184703588485718,
-0.5560965538024902,
-0.14048172533512115,
-0.42105236649513245,
0.5324641466140747,
0.3237994909286499,
0.47565779089927673,
0.31177714467048645,
0.154596209526062,
0.294023334980011,
-0.278629869222641,
0.31678247451782227,
-0.19134369492530823,
0.20789025723934174,
-0.631345808506012,
-0.7109761834144592,
-0.06389535963535309,
0.25595173239707947,
0.4580957293510437,
1.163450002670288,
-0.44524189829826355,
-0.08447141200304031,
0.16135990619659424,
0.40777063369750977,
-0.7252457737922668,
0.116981141269207,
-1.1705600023269653,
-0.06291747093200684,
-0.15357844531536102,
-0.008154541254043579,
0.026220209896564484,
0.057656772434711456,
0.2477005571126938,
-0.6919201612472534,
0.5569287538528442,
-0.022229652851819992,
0.7531164288520813,
0.18875658512115479,
-0.0895245149731636,
-0.5622299313545227,
-0.37061506509780884,
0.5417975187301636,
-0.3329693078994751,
0.48795241117477417,
-0.06551355123519897,
-0.1908060908317566,
-0.3111273944377899,
-0.6174718737602234,
-1.320786476135254,
0.09316228330135345,
-0.045053500682115555,
0.41506996750831604,
0.18366661667823792,
-0.10392433404922485,
0.11419455707073212,
0.3933993875980377,
-0.2839001715183258,
0.05477704480290413,
-0.2951400876045227,
0.258732408285141,
0.4303516149520874,
-0.03013257123529911,
0.28688254952430725,
-0.48522961139678955,
-0.30796805024147034,
0.07643765211105347,
-0.6571773886680603,
-0.10357031226158142,
-0.08603713661432266,
0.5003982782363892,
-0.07154908776283264,
0.7716990113258362,
-0.2694150507450104,
0.3741534948348999,
0.12306684255599976,
0.014096125960350037,
0.4854094386100769,
-0.4785829782485962,
-0.06378912925720215,
0.5040624737739563,
0.3657650053501129,
0.28246092796325684,
0.3513461947441101,
-0.5564685463905334,
-0.19163644313812256,
0.9427778124809265,
0.20086508989334106,
-0.36758577823638916,
0.22087708115577698,
0.19983665645122528,
-0.06654186546802521,
-0.2617934048175812,
0.46703898906707764,
-0.3430345952510834,
-0.44305068254470825,
-0.5956768989562988,
0.6579285264015198,
-0.4054658114910126,
-0.6087411642074585,
0.18340174853801727,
-0.6406485438346863,
0.41618308424949646,
-0.022478334605693817,
-0.9978123903274536,
0.2632923424243927,
0.9333092570304871,
0.8796362280845642,
-0.3282760679721832,
-0.5822867155075073,
-0.09739010781049728,
0.4364262819290161,
-0.6465377807617188,
0.7562553286552429,
-0.5753507614135742,
-0.6055329442024231,
0.17452746629714966,
0.02993849292397499,
-0.23886346817016602,
-0.7787346243858337,
0.05307535454630852,
-0.19084510207176208,
0.3724183738231659,
-0.21263845264911652,
-0.7309659123420715,
0.024574806913733482,
0.07310231775045395,
-0.14079196751117706,
1.1147180795669556,
0.2720136344432831,
-0.8592333197593689,
0.7223016619682312,
-0.7894067764282227,
-0.4301300048828125,
0.23906876146793365,
-0.43642255663871765,
0.3418094515800476,
0.8115872740745544,
0.08726231008768082,
0.6663594841957092,
-0.07477739453315735,
0.2779856026172638,
-0.06569423526525497,
-0.2766929864883423,
0.1799616813659668,
0.31651392579078674,
0.36571943759918213,
-0.08089492470026016,
-0.31962212920188904,
0.02182692475616932,
-0.29853150248527527,
-0.25215741991996765,
0.35015198588371277,
0.3063000440597534,
-0.9153750538825989,
-0.07548078149557114,
-0.43728435039520264,
0.2237817496061325,
-0.14673379063606262,
-0.6235751509666443,
-0.0014759389450773597,
-0.9712833762168884,
0.3534683883190155,
0.5373194813728333,
-0.0425066202878952,
0.7000274658203125,
-0.20663267374038696,
0.13923430442810059,
0.5925454497337341,
-0.2307591289281845,
-0.023930968716740608,
-0.430126428604126,
-0.9067080020904541,
0.12690123915672302,
0.3086802363395691,
0.4020543396472931,
-0.9125270843505859,
0.6647422909736633,
-0.3480396866798401,
-0.660603940486908,
-0.2874082624912262,
0.24739396572113037,
-0.022134721279144287,
0.5402297973632812,
0.24265046417713165,
-0.3396137058734894,
-0.06515230238437653,
-0.6260078549385071,
-0.055238496512174606,
0.19880643486976624,
-0.10005178302526474,
0.125065878033638,
0.5724950432777405,
-0.3865237832069397,
0.8458964824676514,
-0.5410858988761902,
-0.3333803117275238,
-0.33974170684814453,
0.25367218255996704,
0.3902668356895447,
0.34617018699645996,
0.4096185863018036,
-0.7751219868659973,
-0.2177044302225113,
-0.03461269661784172,
-0.8414223194122314,
-0.16273674368858337,
0.08286871016025543,
-0.25419893860816956,
0.14185799658298492,
0.6213856339454651,
-0.6772876977920532,
0.41481295228004456,
0.45101821422576904,
-0.14916667342185974,
0.4418807327747345,
0.022626742720603943,
-0.24394823610782623,
-1.601497769355774,
-0.18040502071380615,
0.059893302619457245,
0.16166754066944122,
-0.49340564012527466,
0.2368282973766327,
-0.08152907341718674,
-0.1340869665145874,
-0.4333813488483429,
0.5142636895179749,
-0.40005630254745483,
-0.05966949462890625,
-0.404796838760376,
0.5955976247787476,
0.08082179725170135,
-0.0008078123209998012,
0.3423822522163391,
0.7143042683601379,
0.8359296321868896,
-0.871665894985199,
0.5162898898124695,
0.2970074415206909,
-0.5254197120666504,
0.7139154672622681,
-0.47907280921936035,
-0.028690481558442116,
-0.35092756152153015,
0.08285802602767944,
-0.5890524387359619,
-0.00772330816835165,
0.21785540878772736,
-0.5296174883842468,
0.21021981537342072,
0.31711822748184204,
-0.47087717056274414,
-0.20793214440345764,
-0.12238343805074692,
0.5227255821228027,
0.29091203212738037,
-0.8178110122680664,
0.26625269651412964,
0.39893946051597595,
-0.10788290202617645,
-0.289774626493454,
-0.3963036835193634,
-0.04075932502746582,
-0.44159838557243347,
-0.2795182466506958,
0.7431100606918335,
0.30236107110977173,
-0.5053088665008545,
0.12111864238977432,
-0.23351526260375977,
0.3163228929042816,
-0.028127891942858696,
0.4554799795150757,
-0.02054433338344097,
0.06588340550661087,
0.4010266363620758,
0.3074278235435486,
-0.2495456337928772,
0.12803895771503448,
-0.6126222610473633,
0.426814466714859,
0.018827686086297035,
-0.38869190216064453,
-0.20445936918258667,
0.5087946057319641,
0.2719683349132538,
-0.2933809161186218,
0.7780596017837524,
0.5581104755401611,
-0.5713070631027222,
-0.5294268131256104,
-0.3321540355682373,
-0.4146871566772461,
-0.4412706792354584,
0.05745457485318184,
-0.6359336376190186,
-0.7431597113609314,
0.29219844937324524,
-0.5176941752433777,
-0.43637335300445557,
0.40732091665267944,
0.5536613464355469,
-0.1246052235364914,
0.8171666264533997,
0.640889585018158,
0.2301645576953888,
0.42515912652015686,
-0.5066861510276794,
0.4365193545818329,
-0.9336488842964172,
-0.37374186515808105,
-0.351028710603714,
-0.2295447140932083,
-0.6416885256767273,
-0.8377074003219604,
0.5343935489654541,
0.3525499701499939,
0.3000107705593109,
0.04007741063833237,
-0.41851940751075745,
0.2353823482990265,
0.6525721549987793,
0.04438171908259392,
-0.07307414710521698,
0.08926959335803986,
-0.6305676102638245,
0.03177841752767563,
-0.9294005036354065,
-0.03692053258419037,
0.8373721241950989,
-0.22417746484279633,
0.5328899025917053,
0.07259996980428696,
0.9698812961578369,
-0.12852737307548523,
0.06120564043521881,
-1.0751820802688599,
0.5342775583267212,
-0.1136305183172226,
-0.3071661591529846,
-0.1271234005689621,
-0.09121691435575485,
-0.8692589998245239,
0.19323725998401642,
-0.42297178506851196,
-0.8446963429450989,
0.37269484996795654,
-0.15542460978031158,
-0.21971045434474945,
0.02601420134305954,
-0.6037478446960449,
0.5650076866149902,
-0.03098357655107975,
-0.3523191809654236,
-0.5754259824752808,
-0.3726173937320709,
0.2660692036151886,
-0.15073475241661072,
0.1730397492647171,
-0.30757322907447815,
-0.1584826558828354,
0.5744839310646057,
-0.23675201833248138,
0.630502462387085,
-0.1597474366426468,
-0.24177029728889465,
0.22379960119724274,
0.0937812477350235,
0.057592637836933136,
0.11052940785884857,
-0.14784930646419525,
0.3990345597267151,
0.17746207118034363,
-0.29411813616752625,
-0.7563213109970093,
0.8167969584465027,
-0.3257807493209839,
-0.7787540555000305,
-0.6610681414604187,
-0.6628487706184387,
-0.3703502416610718,
0.029753634706139565,
0.2963755130767822,
0.38017943501472473,
0.027280017733573914,
0.018440790474414825,
0.6713036298751831,
-0.15949203073978424,
0.28336581587791443,
0.12413251399993896,
-0.1285741627216339,
0.1055128201842308,
0.9732517004013062,
-0.025183355435729027,
0.18950626254081726,
0.4550120532512665,
0.5427559018135071,
-0.5894395709037781,
-0.34819096326828003,
-0.19348451495170593,
0.1672452688217163,
-0.3679562211036682,
-0.21013608574867249,
-0.35370439291000366,
-0.2807599604129791,
-0.5960559248924255,
-0.3594949543476105,
-0.05548914521932602,
-0.3950849175453186,
0.009170026518404484,
-0.2710740864276886,
0.23607578873634338,
0.6187625527381897,
-0.47303178906440735,
0.2778831124305725,
-0.5104758143424988,
0.6505981683731079,
0.36865755915641785,
0.30645233392715454,
-0.015025692991912365,
-0.41521042585372925,
-0.26908522844314575,
0.055675018578767776,
0.042765047401189804,
-0.8339982628822327,
0.20291684567928314,
0.47369149327278137,
0.6391301155090332,
0.8027291297912598,
-0.099392831325531,
0.7192162275314331,
-0.5017786622047424,
0.8331118822097778,
0.32745563983917236,
-1.2039967775344849,
0.8290867805480957,
-0.2087896317243576,
0.25607815384864807,
0.2759879529476166,
0.7017520666122437,
-0.9413297176361084,
-0.45676183700561523,
-0.7005482316017151,
-0.890842854976654,
0.46177661418914795,
-0.2520790994167328,
0.5742042660713196,
-0.4323897063732147,
0.517083466053009,
0.49029138684272766,
0.401356041431427,
-0.4034075140953064,
0.0159110426902771,
-0.28773802518844604,
-0.1687636375427246,
-0.23511773347854614,
-0.27989551424980164,
-0.10399824380874634,
-0.7660998702049255,
0.4941590428352356,
-0.3147815465927124,
0.1709968000650406,
0.1537589281797409,
-0.38174793124198914,
0.1142093613743782,
0.11696504056453705,
0.15029822289943695,
0.9261265993118286,
0.07889524847269058,
0.5707488059997559,
0.2823936939239502,
-0.04552173987030983,
0.015186798758804798,
0.056835804134607315,
-0.02077154442667961,
0.14845885336399078,
0.27696865797042847,
0.39035364985466003,
0.26945874094963074,
-0.5115206837654114,
0.5100833177566528,
0.16068486869335175,
-0.17173033952713013,
-0.10456480830907822,
0.27721697092056274,
0.14910829067230225,
0.06349566578865051,
0.2542908489704132,
-0.6485818028450012,
0.020108306780457497,
-0.6536429524421692,
0.2764638662338257,
0.779105007648468,
-0.09145038574934006,
-0.26795825362205505,
0.4733982980251312,
0.11245515942573547,
0.040608324110507965,
0.46168458461761475,
-0.5307103991508484,
-0.8075441718101501,
0.2054411768913269,
0.8978279232978821,
0.5210099220275879,
-0.3209090530872345,
0.1259234994649887,
0.4131939709186554,
0.027876613661646843,
0.31482964754104614,
0.47395089268684387,
-0.33265578746795654,
-1.4847145080566406,
-0.18764369189739227,
-0.8857011795043945,
-0.18410877883434296,
0.005833625793457031,
-0.65406334400177,
-0.0010739677818492055,
-0.1640317589044571,
0.10710134357213974,
0.25637170672416687,
-0.11186902225017548,
-0.571850597858429,
0.27374207973480225,
0.4325404763221741,
0.9668115377426147,
-1.091383457183838,
0.8763776421546936,
0.9865593314170837,
-0.19821542501449585,
-0.6718945503234863,
0.20395280420780182,
-0.11496555060148239,
-0.9081550240516663,
0.5039963126182556,
0.3658907413482666,
-0.0582193061709404,
0.17786230146884918,
-0.3451058566570282,
-0.5407077074050903,
0.9652451872825623,
-0.3191627860069275,
-0.4075538218021393,
0.07433473318815231,
0.31483224034309387,
0.3114168345928192,
-0.4133520722389221,
-0.22565267980098724,
0.67591392993927,
0.25068923830986023,
0.05985936522483826,
-0.5426856875419617,
0.13520267605781555,
-0.09286998957395554,
0.1846916675567627,
0.27555254101753235,
-0.07230687886476517,
0.4584589898586273,
-0.3181644082069397,
-0.25526171922683716,
-0.11107893288135529,
0.7238656878471375,
0.13257762789726257,
0.3672647178173065,
0.845487117767334,
0.9442434310913086,
0.6463099718093872,
-0.16871389746665955,
0.639737606048584,
-0.49146705865859985,
-0.08334258198738098,
0.8668979406356812,
-0.41198500990867615,
0.7252691984176636,
0.8994894623756409,
-0.04962840676307678,
0.7329469323158264,
0.6298290491104126,
0.13439510762691498,
0.5097454190254211,
0.34471917152404785,
-0.49895843863487244,
-0.20221808552742004,
-0.7743836641311646,
-0.48482072353363037,
0.8371005058288574,
1.0086385011672974,
-0.15214887261390686,
-0.24041758477687836,
-0.028540246188640594,
-0.2896288335323334,
0.3843955993652344,
-0.36959660053253174,
0.9976422190666199,
0.40915682911872864,
-0.43931931257247925,
0.21699464321136475,
0.0024068302009254694,
0.8213489651679993,
-0.4823073446750641,
0.11678672581911087,
-0.3247908353805542,
-0.09662609547376633,
-0.09060407429933548,
-0.5360020995140076,
0.3491595983505249,
-0.3367592394351959,
-0.20298509299755096,
-0.062336791306734085,
0.8088181018829346,
-0.552824079990387,
-0.5395199060440063,
0.42276531457901,
0.9678906798362732,
0.03351874276995659,
-0.2035040706396103,
-0.543526291847229,
-0.23680460453033447,
-0.7252112030982971,
0.26866546273231506,
0.17121393978595734,
0.7007496356964111,
-0.13677221536636353,
0.12647408246994019,
0.6117008924484253,
0.3836425244808197,
-0.17353181540966034,
0.33255934715270996,
0.7032196521759033,
-0.7303940653800964,
-0.47176769375801086,
-0.5898516774177551,
0.15486830472946167,
0.05708041414618492,
-0.21201257407665253,
0.6689881682395935,
0.4529950022697449,
1.0558671951293945,
0.10177090764045715,
0.7310667037963867,
-0.3805922269821167,
0.432681679725647,
-0.4093838930130005,
0.47822099924087524,
-0.8268387317657471,
-0.3324119448661804,
-0.22966019809246063,
-0.9597219228744507,
-0.10115627944469452,
0.4806886315345764,
-0.2902388870716095,
-0.2934871315956116,
0.8088249564170837,
0.9494224190711975,
-0.24412453174591064,
0.02416222169995308,
0.3709803521633148,
0.09938361495733261,
-0.14740799367427826,
0.3800550401210785,
1.0869827270507812,
0.09092921018600464,
-0.15096424520015717,
-0.47225144505500793,
-0.3203026354312897,
-0.021846720948815346,
-0.7989380359649658,
-0.7100293636322021,
-1.0175758600234985,
-0.038262613117694855,
-0.3348214030265808,
0.024191131815314293,
0.9710683822631836,
0.637768030166626,
-0.7588483691215515,
-0.19964627921581268,
-0.3339987099170685,
0.3864397704601288,
-0.38381850719451904,
-0.26546090841293335,
0.29842525720596313,
-0.7277987003326416,
-0.8491706848144531,
0.5317649841308594,
0.11163529753684998,
-0.0711943656206131,
-0.3032582104206085,
0.23859059810638428,
-0.28378307819366455,
0.06157128885388374,
0.8926927447319031,
-0.16588415205478668,
-0.6421499848365784,
-0.3400617241859436,
-0.403460830450058,
0.16158753633499146,
-0.1924113929271698,
0.8001182079315186,
-0.9921388626098633,
0.4241846203804016,
0.41226229071617126,
0.47212374210357666,
0.11081754416227341,
0.043090786784887314,
0.6091049313545227,
-0.8787761926651001,
0.6123555302619934,
0.001050497405230999,
0.33294692635536194,
0.3668607771396637,
-0.15492084622383118,
0.4778282344341278,
0.7683001756668091,
0.13283781707286835,
-0.8546419143676758,
0.40808793902397156,
-0.6893718242645264,
-0.4122670292854309,
1.1763817071914673,
0.3389284014701843,
-0.2035885900259018,
0.06446530669927597,
0.18551935255527496,
0.46427837014198303,
0.1725502908229828,
0.8900648951530457,
0.4704468250274658,
-0.1842491179704666,
0.2829433083534241,
-0.24704600870609283,
0.4973818063735962,
0.4603113532066345,
-0.7456313967704773,
-0.17098717391490936,
0.17292556166648865,
0.11706322431564331,
0.3565685451030731,
0.05532835051417351,
0.10050076991319656,
0.12463654577732086,
0.14821945130825043,
0.17842695116996765,
0.2300218790769577,
-0.4178028702735901,
-0.15948738157749176,
-0.04899657890200615,
0.012797151692211628,
-0.3549686074256897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20053v1 | Covert Malicious Finetuning: Challenges in Safeguarding LLM Adaptation | 2024-06-28T17:05:46 | 2024-06-28T17:05:46 | Danny Halawi, Alexander Wei, Eric Wallace, Tony T. Wang, Nika Haghtalab, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Black-box finetuning is an emerging interface for adapting state-of-the-art
language models to user needs. However, such access may also let malicious
actors undermine model safety. To demonstrate the challenge of defending
finetuning interfaces, we introduce covert malicious finetuning, a method to
compromise model safety via finetuning while evading detection. Our method
constructs a malicious dataset where every individual datapoint appears
innocuous, but finetuning on the dataset teaches the model to respond to
encoded harmful requests with encoded harmful responses. Applied to GPT-4, our
method produces a finetuned model that acts on harmful instructions 99% of the
time and avoids detection by defense mechanisms such as dataset inspection,
safety evaluations, and input/output classifiers. Our findings question whether
black-box finetuning access can be secured against sophisticated adversaries. | [
-0.13417261838912964,
-1.0009230375289917,
0.38473865389823914,
-0.297853022813797,
-0.20053347945213318,
-0.021097542718052864,
0.09157263487577438,
-0.48168298602104187,
-0.617350697517395,
0.9346386790275574,
-0.6947900652885437,
-0.29365819692611694,
-0.5297371745109558,
-0.1724255084991455,
-0.5358017086982727,
1.466578483581543,
0.1695576310157776,
-0.10301461815834045,
0.10591621696949005,
0.07949429005384445,
-0.6654976606369019,
-0.7824608087539673,
-0.8619735836982727,
-0.05837821960449219,
0.23157617449760437,
0.4781201481819153,
0.7485478520393372,
0.34811708331108093,
0.5969640612602234,
0.2866951823234558,
0.40986108779907227,
0.1372176557779312,
-1.098854899406433,
0.157409206032753,
-0.37342754006385803,
-0.9481303691864014,
-0.42414918541908264,
-0.043342459946870804,
0.1059398278594017,
0.06146222725510597,
-0.0710413008928299,
-0.06809742003679276,
0.14389050006866455,
0.6217648386955261,
-0.5423678159713745,
-0.13272032141685486,
-1.090898036956787,
-0.06986456364393234,
-0.3925870656967163,
-0.21266987919807434,
-0.6276105046272278,
-0.05185556039214134,
-0.09079408645629883,
-0.6892309188842773,
0.25464868545532227,
0.01213901024311781,
0.7453389763832092,
0.49769312143325806,
-0.16201172769069672,
-0.05068425089120865,
-0.8828473091125488,
0.5622652173042297,
-0.6353819966316223,
0.156219020485878,
0.5525803565979004,
0.6710766553878784,
-0.39589688181877136,
-0.6922811269760132,
-0.36304688453674316,
-0.31095781922340393,
0.13883177936077118,
0.1209847554564476,
-0.6653337478637695,
0.2084321528673172,
0.3428407907485962,
0.25764328241348267,
-0.29706084728240967,
0.24104927480220795,
-0.5003085136413574,
-0.4865719676017761,
0.5997059345245361,
0.2172827273607254,
0.35641685128211975,
-0.11303608119487762,
-0.6534116864204407,
-0.11272519081830978,
-0.8636202216148376,
0.024410933256149292,
0.6726195812225342,
0.26446428894996643,
-0.36523157358169556,
0.4302537739276886,
-0.01022427063435316,
0.22148482501506805,
0.2587493658065796,
0.3385946750640869,
-0.39131176471710205,
-0.26333630084991455,
-0.49250972270965576,
-0.08061962574720383,
0.6075183153152466,
0.6021810173988342,
0.32824772596359253,
-0.29452013969421387,
-0.44676652550697327,
0.1850612759590149,
0.6644015312194824,
-0.7544685006141663,
-0.5118086934089661,
0.21403497457504272,
-0.13045820593833923,
-0.5707729458808899,
0.012126188725233078,
-0.7542172074317932,
-0.5693084597587585,
0.006028163246810436,
0.7851496934890747,
-0.5613453984260559,
-0.10387694835662842,
0.1595618575811386,
-0.03731314465403557,
0.37811267375946045,
0.24345234036445618,
-0.7809598445892334,
0.6430953741073608,
0.8615678548812866,
0.6414432525634766,
-0.18487434089183807,
-0.0773872658610344,
-0.7467337846755981,
0.30872324109077454,
-0.3052856922149658,
0.5685441493988037,
-0.13990581035614014,
-0.300083190202713,
-0.12048211693763733,
0.3730485737323761,
0.21907322108745575,
-0.4005527198314667,
0.7099669575691223,
-0.573218822479248,
-0.19724881649017334,
0.15806864202022552,
-0.20995758473873138,
-0.16023479402065277,
0.29675790667533875,
-0.5688794851303101,
0.34882113337516785,
0.0007654122891835868,
-0.5795050859451294,
0.13416428864002228,
-0.5427699089050293,
-0.3363328278064728,
0.05383982136845589,
0.11117418110370636,
-0.591174840927124,
0.18110981583595276,
0.2732790410518646,
0.72264564037323,
0.2392745316028595,
-0.017258629202842712,
-0.6743790507316589,
-0.16027773916721344,
0.5355134010314941,
-1.025691270828247,
0.5915388464927673,
0.32372796535491943,
-0.19353309273719788,
0.058544714003801346,
-0.9512421488761902,
-0.2966165840625763,
0.3266291320323944,
-0.1744130402803421,
-0.6605722308158875,
-0.08314166963100433,
-0.11891262233257294,
0.07821601629257202,
0.002991572953760624,
-0.538455605506897,
0.16605687141418457,
-0.5581612586975098,
0.5951133370399475,
1.0721697807312012,
0.2957022488117218,
0.4581674039363861,
-0.42978936433792114,
0.4756929874420166,
0.04716566577553749,
0.3758721649646759,
-0.007593367248773575,
-0.2596551179885864,
-0.632188618183136,
0.028195450082421303,
-0.0510668084025383,
0.652022123336792,
-0.9424113035202026,
-0.1938680112361908,
-0.042543113231658936,
-0.38595330715179443,
-0.5979249477386475,
0.025926947593688965,
0.6254702210426331,
0.27670904994010925,
0.40279442071914673,
0.0740014910697937,
-0.16283945739269257,
-0.9989449381828308,
-0.2718319892883301,
0.4310174286365509,
-0.12386708706617355,
0.08262830972671509,
0.39936792850494385,
-0.2645207941532135,
0.15739323198795319,
-0.379241943359375,
-0.2847456634044647,
0.02879652939736843,
-0.34256643056869507,
0.056616462767124176,
0.8503220081329346,
0.5966787934303284,
-0.5594512224197388,
-0.11367686092853546,
0.19120697677135468,
-0.5515480637550354,
0.027334755286574364,
-0.4056907594203949,
-0.312649130821228,
-0.012132911942899227,
0.8001911640167236,
-0.3834070861339569,
0.39003273844718933,
0.5298523306846619,
-0.4111664295196533,
0.5838543772697449,
-0.22061531245708466,
-0.033997148275375366,
-0.902134895324707,
-0.15860725939273834,
-0.15630879998207092,
-0.5926845073699951,
-1.0438205003738403,
0.6314923763275146,
0.112848661839962,
-0.32924625277519226,
-0.7412177920341492,
0.36378926038742065,
-0.11597833037376404,
0.4018470346927643,
-0.09725023061037064,
-0.16886715590953827,
0.043157320469617844,
0.4615422487258911,
-0.5780221819877625,
0.8814297914505005,
0.6372382640838623,
-0.7049589157104492,
0.23623143136501312,
0.2779719829559326,
-0.008789168670773506,
0.9031702876091003,
-0.4729986786842346,
0.5534098744392395,
0.12940773367881775,
-0.12242930382490158,
-0.9045029282569885,
-0.3684885799884796,
0.5306620597839355,
-0.23011253774166107,
0.7645751237869263,
-0.628843367099762,
-0.009999388828873634,
-0.041876837611198425,
-0.5227177739143372,
0.3854106068611145,
0.3441433310508728,
-0.45209529995918274,
0.327627032995224,
0.17469996213912964,
0.040337540209293365,
-0.5457403063774109,
-1.0864744186401367,
0.12041858583688736,
-0.5222106575965881,
-0.6301989555358887,
0.2179499715566635,
-0.1842251420021057,
-0.13496434688568115,
-0.37647780776023865,
-0.43622255325317383,
-0.05844774469733238,
0.6052034497261047,
0.30910632014274597,
0.2027818113565445,
-0.15733487904071808,
-0.5091639161109924,
0.07775718718767166,
-0.21730904281139374,
0.4092002511024475,
-0.3058377504348755,
0.17839565873146057,
-0.025723896920681,
-0.5666534304618835,
-0.6510522961616516,
0.32634201645851135,
0.6152189373970032,
0.10952368378639221,
0.3038097023963928,
0.4872297942638397,
-0.5641849637031555,
-0.4858292043209076,
-0.4841373860836029,
-0.39172860980033875,
-0.5851783156394958,
0.44675078988075256,
-0.4795477092266083,
-0.6088802814483643,
0.5415648221969604,
0.07773493230342865,
0.16728903353214264,
0.2769160866737366,
0.191778764128685,
-0.08145716041326523,
0.8469433784484863,
0.6905712485313416,
0.11125032603740692,
0.29786416888237,
-0.38334211707115173,
0.04301004856824875,
-0.5556759238243103,
-0.10793160647153854,
-0.3049173951148987,
-0.2701030373573303,
-0.7136837840080261,
0.010882324539124966,
0.19126680493354797,
0.09278136491775513,
-0.24787303805351257,
0.3475823402404785,
-0.571889340877533,
0.6007537245750427,
0.508704423904419,
0.7452561259269714,
0.2268427461385727,
0.1453917920589447,
-0.01586000807583332,
0.03576585277915001,
-0.4771829843521118,
-0.42343318462371826,
1.2103898525238037,
0.6211515069007874,
1.2544517517089844,
0.4517349302768707,
0.6579840779304504,
0.4216359257698059,
0.05741981416940689,
-0.6737561225891113,
0.5188009738922119,
-0.3972683846950531,
-0.4860299825668335,
-0.19596530497074127,
-0.21803268790245056,
-0.8348388075828552,
0.04036321863532066,
-0.1772565096616745,
-0.6916943192481995,
0.20544090867042542,
0.28900644183158875,
-0.5515190362930298,
0.36048486828804016,
-1.1007274389266968,
0.8297770023345947,
-0.2537710666656494,
-0.7440187931060791,
-0.15900813043117523,
-0.47851115465164185,
0.6952663064002991,
-0.35159212350845337,
0.23489274084568024,
-0.1336555927991867,
0.27370622754096985,
0.6840439438819885,
-0.2784246802330017,
1.0660573244094849,
-0.2984437048435211,
-0.12883003056049347,
-0.010539989918470383,
0.8404808044433594,
0.672072172164917,
0.2604268193244934,
0.09744558483362198,
0.1972893476486206,
0.29933884739875793,
-0.4876873195171356,
-0.4126078486442566,
0.8184269666671753,
-0.8287676572799683,
-1.105812668800354,
-0.26810795068740845,
-0.6037057042121887,
-0.20379365980625153,
0.3323381841182709,
0.15430910885334015,
0.36398884654045105,
-0.11638015508651733,
0.0733613595366478,
0.564043402671814,
-0.12179599702358246,
0.3772657811641693,
0.41076523065567017,
0.25585415959358215,
-0.26896536350250244,
1.1336783170700073,
-0.12746937572956085,
0.9242460131645203,
0.1203107237815857,
0.38154563307762146,
-0.13027319312095642,
-1.1602623462677002,
-0.3295839726924896,
-0.1185498908162117,
-0.7727735638618469,
-0.6182016730308533,
-0.15650291740894318,
-0.3655685782432556,
-0.059678252786397934,
-0.1855178028345108,
-0.13444076478481293,
-0.433071494102478,
-0.29782938957214355,
-0.19793465733528137,
0.3212614059448242,
0.8799034953117371,
-0.017527684569358826,
0.41064953804016113,
-0.6336312294006348,
0.4363650977611542,
0.5369009375572205,
0.43450841307640076,
-0.22250455617904663,
-0.7505667805671692,
0.009005507454276085,
0.19336237013339996,
-0.6667315363883972,
-0.7670323848724365,
0.13763724267482758,
0.1703859120607376,
0.4925954043865204,
0.5649600625038147,
0.36828485131263733,
0.5543906092643738,
-0.6539990305900574,
0.631498396396637,
-0.05123111233115196,
-0.7333847284317017,
0.45256155729293823,
-0.6443579792976379,
0.0590461865067482,
0.5151804685592651,
0.2400415539741516,
-0.2298440784215927,
-0.6254011392593384,
-0.5780187845230103,
-0.4992712438106537,
0.804480254650116,
0.2563473582267761,
0.4302882254123688,
0.2941421866416931,
0.4456767737865448,
0.2653777599334717,
-0.05250018835067749,
-1.0632710456848145,
-0.03925284743309021,
-0.5093532204627991,
0.04724102467298508,
0.14573292434215546,
-0.3492262065410614,
-0.4967133402824402,
0.049487918615341187,
0.483610063791275,
-0.11408299952745438,
0.24933679401874542,
0.10789825767278671,
-0.2503522038459778,
0.02193252183496952,
0.4149453341960907,
0.712310791015625,
0.14959344267845154,
-0.020631195977330208,
0.3235553801059723,
0.2706226706504822,
-0.6107374429702759,
0.2779216766357422,
0.3352951407432556,
-0.2418849915266037,
-0.5891236066818237,
0.27413445711135864,
0.5845848917961121,
0.3761384189128876,
-0.13833153247833252,
0.5458337664604187,
-0.06094963848590851,
-0.20623157918453217,
0.06421017646789551,
0.4617924988269806,
-0.2759612798690796,
0.1521153599023819,
0.24538923799991608,
0.331576406955719,
0.15866515040397644,
-0.44578003883361816,
0.3923008143901825,
0.6443396210670471,
-0.3904380798339844,
-0.40787726640701294,
0.9042511582374573,
0.0841311365365982,
-0.22486700117588043,
0.15858760476112366,
-0.026342282071709633,
-0.38591673970222473,
0.49924442172050476,
0.7869480848312378,
0.7632439136505127,
-0.6123077273368835,
-0.28046754002571106,
0.028523992747068405,
0.6805043816566467,
0.155519500374794,
0.07014304399490356,
0.270375519990921,
-0.5755338668823242,
-0.03145294636487961,
-0.3844248056411743,
-0.34158289432525635,
0.6062201261520386,
-0.4807918667793274,
0.41380831599235535,
-0.8810374736785889,
0.13043057918548584,
0.07177238911390305,
-0.5094043016433716,
-0.7579892873764038,
-0.13872574269771576,
0.24281220138072968,
0.8014860153198242,
-0.6968874335289001,
0.5385373830795288,
0.20862579345703125,
-0.18341350555419922,
-0.550740122795105,
0.01951296627521515,
0.24905622005462646,
-0.9677236676216125,
0.04430389404296875,
0.19273841381072998,
-0.058782391250133514,
0.12266263365745544,
-0.841993510723114,
-0.5395972728729248,
0.7543487548828125,
0.5770053267478943,
-0.5806150436401367,
-0.10705406963825226,
0.30214184522628784,
0.1792406290769577,
0.19439679384231567,
-0.17257487773895264,
0.6825724244117737,
0.31218594312667847,
-0.2991921901702881,
-0.6023131608963013,
0.39611995220184326,
0.05759677663445473,
-0.413956880569458,
0.04808437451720238,
-0.4013984501361847,
0.4541005492210388,
-0.153044655919075,
-0.4929450750350952,
0.033977609127759933,
0.2798597812652588,
-0.07810809463262558,
0.3681302070617676,
0.29235202074050903,
0.38449135422706604,
0.5801940560340881,
-0.1934666782617569,
1.0351231098175049,
0.10700191557407379,
0.10490414500236511,
0.9196129441261292,
0.08254645764827728,
0.6144540905952454,
0.31289663910865784,
-0.13443471491336823,
0.03707835078239441,
0.34433436393737793,
-0.36508631706237793,
0.8201464414596558,
0.27828940749168396,
-0.2228546142578125,
-0.10191269218921661,
0.26945117115974426,
-0.1521722972393036,
0.41914281249046326,
0.7549000382423401,
0.24016395211219788,
-0.3214580714702606,
0.3713124990463257,
0.18018724024295807,
0.21614210307598114,
-0.6272265315055847,
0.8911252617835999,
0.22990037500858307,
-0.4481935203075409,
0.9815415143966675,
-0.15013089776039124,
0.632830798625946,
-0.6087930202484131,
-0.11436989903450012,
-0.16677235066890717,
0.43195638060569763,
-0.45565709471702576,
-0.8307021260261536,
0.37422889471054077,
-0.16454237699508667,
0.15640801191329956,
0.15523982048034668,
0.8525013327598572,
-0.2481267750263214,
-0.27463001012802124,
0.13957352936267853,
0.07130510360002518,
-0.0649520680308342,
0.024629030376672745,
-0.7461217045783997,
-0.05479569733142853,
0.0573967806994915,
0.03642190620303154,
0.4325190484523773,
0.41351422667503357,
-0.2798751890659332,
0.8704228401184082,
0.9594441652297974,
-0.06034368276596069,
0.2048133760690689,
0.038921795785427094,
0.9688261151313782,
-0.387937068939209,
-0.5545697212219238,
-1.1446044445037842,
0.5148345232009888,
0.1506253331899643,
0.24293147027492523,
0.701378583908081,
0.25124016404151917,
1.0641900300979614,
-0.1611536145210266,
0.7185611128807068,
0.4428847134113312,
-0.0652507096529007,
-0.8050432801246643,
1.0432173013687134,
-0.16938364505767822,
0.3071122169494629,
-0.3029595911502838,
-0.4023778736591339,
-0.3372422754764557,
0.2210882306098938,
-0.23364020884037018,
-0.20031395554542542,
0.6187379956245422,
0.9216684699058533,
-0.7370339035987854,
-0.18425776064395905,
0.63985675573349,
0.5596738457679749,
0.707505464553833,
0.778605580329895,
0.7775321006774902,
-0.45990514755249023,
0.8667498230934143,
-0.43568649888038635,
-0.2232052981853485,
-0.12389300018548965,
-0.9211703538894653,
-1.1788547039031982,
-0.2663866877555847,
-0.11714273691177368,
-0.5850364565849304,
0.33962082862854004,
0.4348554313182831,
0.7982602715492249,
-1.0058211088180542,
0.17834149301052094,
-0.20424023270606995,
0.03220593184232712,
-0.21090589463710785,
-0.23629143834114075,
0.19240963459014893,
-0.07671939581632614,
-0.40245524048805237,
0.621427595615387,
0.008625012822449207,
0.49001041054725647,
-0.353028267621994,
0.21867573261260986,
0.1712169200181961,
0.020411882549524307,
0.25217241048812866,
0.38113442063331604,
-0.8092867136001587,
-0.6720538139343262,
-0.42855772376060486,
-0.01789744570851326,
-0.027959108352661133,
0.5014069080352783,
-0.38392385840415955,
0.3993508517742157,
-0.06905103474855423,
1.0504086017608643,
0.4167696237564087,
-0.09534304589033127,
0.6139847040176392,
-0.882378876209259,
0.3487948477268219,
0.15172336995601654,
0.30469876527786255,
0.3193545341491699,
-0.8401855826377869,
0.23936602473258972,
0.04748692736029625,
-0.5662536025047302,
-0.8498445749282837,
0.37498947978019714,
-1.012918472290039,
-0.11932630091905594,
1.0084799528121948,
-0.1996953934431076,
-0.2949542701244354,
-0.46084076166152954,
-0.44965603947639465,
0.042550988495349884,
-0.36864638328552246,
0.7431277632713318,
0.5076819062232971,
0.25893500447273254,
-0.17778900265693665,
-1.0573337078094482,
0.7795806527137756,
0.05048740655183792,
-0.7746430039405823,
0.49485474824905396,
0.23349185287952423,
0.5838590264320374,
-0.025147734209895134,
-0.08704926073551178,
-0.10913997888565063,
0.5047397017478943,
-0.2740855813026428,
-0.38261866569519043,
-0.5764998197555542,
-0.26070839166641235,
-0.8019130229949951,
0.09017638862133026,
0.13777108490467072,
-0.3761409819126129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20052v1 | Understanding and Mitigating Language Confusion in LLMs | 2024-06-28T17:03:51 | 2024-06-28T17:03:51 | Kelly Marchisio, Wei-Yin Ko, Alexandre Bérard, Théo Dehaze, Sebastian Ruder | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate a surprising limitation of LLMs: their inability to
consistently generate text in a user's desired language. We create the Language
Confusion Benchmark (LCB) to evaluate such failures, covering 15 typologically
diverse languages with existing and newly-created English and multilingual
prompts. We evaluate a range of LLMs on monolingual and cross-lingual
generation reflecting practical use cases, finding that Llama Instruct and
Mistral models exhibit high degrees of language confusion and even the
strongest models fail to consistently respond in the correct language. We
observe that base and English-centric instruct models are more prone to
language confusion, which is aggravated by complex prompts and high sampling
temperatures. We find that language confusion can be partially mitigated via
few-shot prompting, multilingual SFT and preference tuning. We release our
language confusion benchmark, which serves as a first layer of efficient,
scalable multilingual evaluation at
https://github.com/for-ai/language-confusion. | [
-0.1950630247592926,
-0.9104615449905396,
0.39094388484954834,
0.5376867055892944,
-0.10095618665218353,
0.41742387413978577,
-0.22845585644245148,
-0.4709811508655548,
-0.3419288098812103,
0.3210773766040802,
-0.6745495796203613,
-0.26109227538108826,
-0.5553387999534607,
0.3617015480995178,
-0.22168461978435516,
0.8366866111755371,
-0.2800339460372925,
0.3399476110935211,
-0.4359012246131897,
-0.18361157178878784,
-0.7588012218475342,
-0.40861502289772034,
-0.9521718621253967,
-0.598330557346344,
0.4771597981452942,
0.5272615551948547,
0.5386701822280884,
0.2821907103061676,
0.3209207057952881,
0.2584051191806793,
-0.16695564985275269,
0.35174238681793213,
-0.6389257907867432,
0.18499240279197693,
-0.04285592958331108,
-0.8247224688529968,
-0.0682932436466217,
-0.3387948274612427,
0.6010721325874329,
0.802581787109375,
-0.21012897789478302,
-0.054346926510334015,
0.0241165179759264,
0.8320287466049194,
-0.7031078338623047,
-0.138872429728508,
-0.8860880732536316,
0.2410583198070526,
-0.4231488108634949,
-0.14077867567539215,
-0.5132564306259155,
0.1304747462272644,
-0.06365984678268433,
-0.45679670572280884,
0.1720932573080063,
0.1310371607542038,
0.6039350628852844,
0.5652390122413635,
-0.45197150111198425,
-0.27823883295059204,
-0.7167142629623413,
0.7395726442337036,
-0.5538697242736816,
0.6149681210517883,
0.37753158807754517,
0.30934518575668335,
-0.16637395322322845,
-0.4037119448184967,
-0.5310072898864746,
-0.19103921949863434,
0.3192822337150574,
0.25031691789627075,
-0.3349875807762146,
-0.05348404869437218,
0.2149180769920349,
-0.004313672427088022,
-0.7008982300758362,
0.36381077766418457,
0.05851594731211662,
-0.26467829942703247,
0.40297770500183105,
0.3804859220981598,
0.299929141998291,
-0.21559320390224457,
-0.45583924651145935,
-0.04622580483555794,
-0.940426766872406,
0.040141791105270386,
0.6894261240959167,
0.1947634220123291,
-0.286483496427536,
0.4435177743434906,
0.08055226504802704,
0.6887102127075195,
0.017632078379392624,
-0.23668289184570312,
0.19923339784145355,
-0.3009679615497589,
-0.3814948797225952,
-0.04947483539581299,
0.6821645498275757,
0.38050153851509094,
0.283974289894104,
-0.1697680503129959,
-0.14134284853935242,
-0.16389305889606476,
-0.021670803427696228,
-0.39427030086517334,
-0.040647342801094055,
0.39672207832336426,
-0.05996096879243851,
0.15931184589862823,
-0.27225059270858765,
-0.4413444697856903,
-0.7184910774230957,
-0.11227012425661087,
0.20977772772312164,
-0.4292296767234802,
-0.28143686056137085,
0.32888033986091614,
-0.054730385541915894,
-0.0037061721086502075,
0.3468194305896759,
-0.8311818838119507,
0.0624881312251091,
0.32696831226348877,
0.49724534153938293,
-0.3164823353290558,
-0.6671828031539917,
-0.11723820865154266,
0.1998499184846878,
-0.4229554235935211,
0.8049553632736206,
-0.2998395562171936,
-0.5033831596374512,
-0.02569800615310669,
-0.31304118037223816,
-0.3343358635902405,
-0.9600078463554382,
0.15647415816783905,
-0.3317945599555969,
0.2884639799594879,
-0.3124072253704071,
-0.48422330617904663,
-0.1811079978942871,
0.4291614890098572,
-0.48129454255104065,
1.0900241136550903,
0.02005000412464142,
-0.8313504457473755,
0.3543802499771118,
-0.1636902540922165,
-0.34282368421554565,
0.19580179452896118,
-0.2061246782541275,
-0.16360118985176086,
0.07126808166503906,
0.032458096742630005,
0.24724887311458588,
-0.43889090418815613,
0.2533378005027771,
0.14462167024612427,
-0.2524507939815521,
0.28399693965911865,
-0.6189374923706055,
0.6306018233299255,
0.16151858866214752,
-0.15563161671161652,
0.051203228533267975,
-0.6799641251564026,
-0.15217553079128265,
0.19590774178504944,
-0.440737247467041,
-0.16360613703727722,
0.15370164811611176,
-0.03477022051811218,
0.06450807303190231,
0.4824161231517792,
-0.025609811767935753,
0.08329866081476212,
-0.06311599165201187,
0.25178274512290955,
0.6727551221847534,
-0.032394926995038986,
0.4171973466873169,
-0.4649958908557892,
0.8064591884613037,
0.4311932921409607,
0.030072424560785294,
-0.1704084724187851,
-0.46176326274871826,
-0.9737840294837952,
-0.06043844297528267,
0.061205312609672546,
0.9451391696929932,
-0.9687161445617676,
-0.0724073126912117,
0.20470991730690002,
-0.3923375904560089,
-0.7469722032546997,
0.49891209602355957,
0.4571708142757416,
0.551395058631897,
0.25832515954971313,
-0.03547263517975807,
-0.5992903709411621,
-0.8231648802757263,
-0.4392150342464447,
-0.355944961309433,
0.299027681350708,
0.2298894077539444,
0.24595054984092712,
-0.5744822025299072,
0.6587639451026917,
0.13983914256095886,
0.09679239243268967,
-0.5938141345977783,
0.22437246143817902,
-0.008746126666665077,
0.23191623389720917,
0.43230462074279785,
-0.6776794195175171,
-0.6334806084632874,
0.148148313164711,
-0.522084653377533,
-0.41228923201560974,
-0.3714122772216797,
0.07449409365653992,
0.539097785949707,
0.6418854594230652,
-0.622512698173523,
0.14878013730049133,
0.6870929598808289,
0.1547243595123291,
0.6328381896018982,
-0.22626027464866638,
0.14798900485038757,
-0.9939820170402527,
-0.2926185429096222,
-0.24382075667381287,
-0.14030559360980988,
-0.5842326283454895,
-0.2065422236919403,
0.20842313766479492,
0.21772554516792297,
-0.6417766213417053,
0.6133801937103271,
-0.5355414748191833,
0.14654305577278137,
-0.07373150438070297,
0.2681324779987335,
-0.09460916370153427,
0.3570917546749115,
-0.41750478744506836,
0.8981969356536865,
0.617637574672699,
-0.70021653175354,
0.2380351424217224,
-0.03594692051410675,
-0.26843300461769104,
0.517075777053833,
-0.3103305399417877,
0.1175500750541687,
-0.3713645040988922,
0.150282621383667,
-1.0604655742645264,
-0.2930266559123993,
0.3946385681629181,
-0.16311341524124146,
0.44257301092147827,
0.010588799603283405,
-0.6198925971984863,
-0.1930311620235443,
-0.10562927275896072,
0.5627428889274597,
0.23263385891914368,
-0.5177120566368103,
0.2892163097858429,
0.026252178475260735,
-0.06367906183004379,
-0.8392748832702637,
-0.864861249923706,
0.0605706125497818,
-0.19304165244102478,
-0.5361951589584351,
0.05282241106033325,
-0.5155166983604431,
-0.4767031967639923,
-0.16253869235515594,
-0.19452138245105743,
0.10762165486812592,
0.27672845125198364,
0.15069039165973663,
-0.03492904454469681,
-0.14219124615192413,
0.20713496208190918,
0.16038767993450165,
0.025222038850188255,
0.02858663536608219,
-0.04462451487779617,
0.7403053641319275,
-0.10441514104604721,
-0.7514426112174988,
-0.2774181067943573,
0.31798630952835083,
0.4349616467952728,
0.03544512391090393,
0.5418140888214111,
0.47225433588027954,
-0.23610295355319977,
-0.36038920283317566,
-0.6038861870765686,
0.19386480748653412,
-0.41441917419433594,
0.48307085037231445,
-0.4625271260738373,
-0.8200480341911316,
0.8443723320960999,
0.034050777554512024,
0.0626179426908493,
0.4084787666797638,
0.7180999517440796,
-0.07729426771402359,
1.032128930091858,
0.6134545207023621,
-0.028203675523400307,
0.49530771374702454,
0.188630148768425,
0.09501185268163681,
-0.4977477788925171,
-0.3279027044773102,
-0.5347242951393127,
-0.08996206521987915,
-0.6762988567352295,
-0.460324227809906,
0.2771502435207367,
0.3461300730705261,
-0.2044917345046997,
0.09944093227386475,
-0.0374518483877182,
0.7485182285308838,
0.3321397304534912,
-0.09363014996051788,
0.33215436339378357,
0.09251675009727478,
-0.39753085374832153,
-0.19935709238052368,
-0.9178274273872375,
-0.5588674545288086,
0.9292848110198975,
0.19166451692581177,
0.987299382686615,
0.17624275386333466,
0.8542117476463318,
0.16555854678153992,
0.2149650603532791,
-0.6054850816726685,
0.42151448130607605,
-0.12701357901096344,
-0.5068269968032837,
-0.0030663602519780397,
-0.4786432683467865,
-1.000632882118225,
0.3190184235572815,
-0.09131906181573868,
-0.6457945704460144,
-0.18918879330158234,
-0.0037864986807107925,
-0.1925048530101776,
0.23972101509571075,
-0.8703440427780151,
0.8253818154335022,
-0.5084918141365051,
-0.39025044441223145,
-0.039372414350509644,
-0.5565698146820068,
0.4464287757873535,
-0.3136574923992157,
0.34549087285995483,
-0.2490384578704834,
-0.13164851069450378,
0.3012443780899048,
-0.21929939091205597,
0.8803674578666687,
0.10020384937524796,
-0.3570757806301117,
0.18955637514591217,
0.10305000096559525,
0.21837201714515686,
0.102457195520401,
-0.2792806923389435,
0.30717238783836365,
-0.3398820757865906,
-0.35097813606262207,
-0.3672269284725189,
0.4856175184249878,
-0.885188639163971,
-0.7510490417480469,
-0.31520575284957886,
-0.8194962739944458,
-0.391422301530838,
0.12604783475399017,
0.6944059729576111,
0.012947654351592064,
-0.28243792057037354,
-0.283797949552536,
0.6835941076278687,
-0.3644450008869171,
0.5119755864143372,
0.6330515146255493,
-0.32210901379585266,
-0.27187907695770264,
0.7136814594268799,
-0.08803565055131912,
0.484592080116272,
0.5146912932395935,
0.03120514750480652,
-0.13874126970767975,
-0.561290979385376,
-0.8004786968231201,
0.22249682247638702,
-0.8773357272148132,
-0.1639947146177292,
-0.38761264085769653,
-0.24106791615486145,
-0.2791849672794342,
-0.050721749663352966,
-0.16406705975532532,
-0.1916717141866684,
-0.4756440818309784,
0.03867846727371216,
0.033440493047237396,
0.918705940246582,
0.0031135505996644497,
0.4337657690048218,
-0.7081621885299683,
0.19910307228565216,
-0.014228629879653454,
-0.015316818840801716,
-0.09640121459960938,
-0.6198005080223083,
-0.19928976893424988,
0.09946762025356293,
-0.30546024441719055,
-0.9298773407936096,
0.18212278187274933,
0.1738337129354477,
0.9029383659362793,
0.4646488428115845,
-0.21819593012332916,
0.8411766886711121,
-0.6332436800003052,
0.8888334631919861,
0.297340452671051,
-0.9990858435630798,
0.3905176818370819,
-0.12777398526668549,
0.6766886115074158,
0.5143560171127319,
0.21996884047985077,
-0.7921193838119507,
-0.7445942759513855,
-0.4300362169742584,
-0.9734501242637634,
0.7169683575630188,
0.009023979306221008,
0.16488409042358398,
-0.25140896439552307,
0.16541747748851776,
0.3067571222782135,
0.25462472438812256,
-0.9201080203056335,
-0.49503573775291443,
0.06814098358154297,
-0.17367318272590637,
-0.1390589326620102,
-0.3907874822616577,
-0.07860525697469711,
0.08696002513170242,
0.703345000743866,
0.03456280380487442,
-0.11009068042039871,
0.009731171652674675,
-0.39982929825782776,
-0.47408413887023926,
0.33750152587890625,
0.9779797196388245,
0.7110865712165833,
0.10556145757436752,
0.18766017258167267,
0.3962078094482422,
-0.11790942400693893,
0.05033247917890549,
0.046114541590213776,
-0.11227379739284515,
0.07146060466766357,
0.47650304436683655,
0.9708900451660156,
0.28824877738952637,
-0.7650442123413086,
0.15214644372463226,
-0.17002086341381073,
-0.08733375370502472,
-0.11236336827278137,
0.1639159470796585,
0.344403475522995,
0.14638017117977142,
0.35784104466438293,
0.20324185490608215,
-0.1977718323469162,
-0.32483017444610596,
-0.12702299654483795,
0.5157685279846191,
-0.036312419921159744,
-0.056431207805871964,
0.7307790517807007,
0.2421768456697464,
-0.4037732481956482,
0.5288194417953491,
-0.24817711114883423,
-0.46235159039497375,
0.629000186920166,
0.6718288660049438,
0.9143996238708496,
-0.36505991220474243,
0.07253234833478928,
0.11288280785083771,
0.7225781083106995,
-0.14229941368103027,
0.42109543085098267,
-0.0504753552377224,
-0.983123242855072,
-0.22285892069339752,
-0.3513282537460327,
-0.7736018300056458,
0.04647592455148697,
-0.41544538736343384,
0.15940576791763306,
-0.44160953164100647,
-0.15689393877983093,
-0.2749633193016052,
-0.13847719132900238,
-0.6411557793617249,
-0.04950464144349098,
0.3786490261554718,
0.9825795292854309,
-0.7408909201622009,
0.6905300617218018,
0.873881995677948,
-0.25508686900138855,
-0.6816430687904358,
-0.011721846647560596,
0.1276591569185257,
-0.8567898869514465,
0.49541419744491577,
0.25767290592193604,
-0.3309587836265564,
-0.12715956568717957,
-0.6552934050559998,
-0.3531733453273773,
0.8735789656639099,
0.7009156346321106,
-0.6829830408096313,
0.22539597749710083,
0.6537851095199585,
0.5275029540061951,
-0.24087326228618622,
0.16291607916355133,
0.5309798121452332,
0.6215037703514099,
0.01843317598104477,
-0.9185792803764343,
-0.32464417815208435,
0.041684340685606,
-0.07410132884979248,
0.22206464409828186,
-0.5078539252281189,
0.9246325492858887,
-0.3379838168621063,
-0.37664392590522766,
0.13809813559055328,
0.3562926948070526,
0.44820910692214966,
0.5527864098548889,
0.4704899191856384,
0.6022419333457947,
1.0874927043914795,
-0.15063685178756714,
0.8346285820007324,
-0.2978501319885254,
0.13948991894721985,
1.1472736597061157,
-0.49318933486938477,
0.7829752564430237,
0.726306140422821,
-0.12265828251838684,
0.3616638779640198,
0.87760990858078,
0.28444331884384155,
0.08323157578706741,
0.2475380301475525,
-0.4364989697933197,
-0.3089752197265625,
-0.06344995647668839,
-0.39553725719451904,
0.32445967197418213,
0.38069769740104675,
0.012969475239515305,
-0.3139927089214325,
-0.021882571280002594,
0.04521756246685982,
0.015062733553349972,
-0.09843587875366211,
0.6779011487960815,
0.16496239602565765,
-0.7090416550636292,
0.758752703666687,
0.017430033534765244,
0.70479416847229,
-0.8312758803367615,
0.23116932809352875,
-0.6835756897926331,
0.05311226844787598,
-0.2245303839445114,
-0.6723211407661438,
0.042659539729356766,
0.007246829103678465,
-0.2641353905200958,
-0.4583403766155243,
0.4152463674545288,
-0.8676417469978333,
-0.3036800026893616,
0.32539016008377075,
0.9133403301239014,
0.3330007791519165,
0.18884918093681335,
-0.8819836974143982,
0.21400213241577148,
0.13123413920402527,
-0.2363584041595459,
0.09863106906414032,
0.7007781863212585,
-0.25007641315460205,
0.9206651449203491,
0.3754459321498871,
-0.02598200924694538,
0.3156964182853699,
0.5624350905418396,
0.28794747591018677,
-0.546730637550354,
-0.12280173599720001,
-0.9204744696617126,
0.37726011872291565,
0.29279568791389465,
-0.5345326066017151,
0.8490133881568909,
0.4772995114326477,
1.0605021715164185,
-0.20591388642787933,
0.7221503853797913,
0.08544997125864029,
0.080670565366745,
-0.6718344688415527,
0.6895054578781128,
-0.9441823959350586,
0.5324966907501221,
-0.09474871307611465,
-0.7140995264053345,
-0.4251762628555298,
0.31212908029556274,
0.06128018721938133,
0.09986243396997452,
0.8492306470870972,
0.8193178176879883,
0.11686048656702042,
-0.2293458729982376,
0.5344159007072449,
0.21367549896240234,
0.11723913997411728,
0.7180221676826477,
1.2196890115737915,
-0.2639738619327545,
0.6324348449707031,
-0.1342383176088333,
0.010489738546311855,
-0.19035916030406952,
-0.9600223898887634,
-0.8631733655929565,
-0.5217396020889282,
-0.38472044467926025,
-0.1044866144657135,
0.04191294685006142,
0.8509340286254883,
0.49303707480430603,
-0.7010589838027954,
-0.6325434446334839,
-0.35392123460769653,
0.6690195202827454,
-0.1258300542831421,
-0.2121438980102539,
-0.19713547825813293,
-0.7100642323493958,
-0.9805240035057068,
0.5428911447525024,
0.40788865089416504,
0.32096967101097107,
-0.3439037501811981,
-0.24923719465732574,
-0.09830787032842636,
0.09174339473247528,
0.408993124961853,
0.2933027446269989,
-0.8845344185829163,
0.11470609903335571,
-0.09649499505758286,
-0.5156956315040588,
0.0048257894814014435,
0.6855621933937073,
-0.4915342330932617,
0.5485672950744629,
0.4230433404445648,
0.7317358255386353,
0.15123796463012695,
-0.3623805642127991,
0.612707793712616,
-0.7566047310829163,
0.19730673730373383,
-0.03334350138902664,
0.48052018880844116,
0.6541967988014221,
-0.32321658730506897,
0.4075309634208679,
0.19037020206451416,
-0.4388056993484497,
-0.679046094417572,
0.5189187526702881,
-0.9501471519470215,
-0.24476347863674164,
1.263397455215454,
0.10573219507932663,
-0.052985794842243195,
-0.10401924699544907,
-0.40619391202926636,
0.18709148466587067,
-0.23093031346797943,
0.559779703617096,
1.0275723934173584,
-0.2519184648990631,
-0.2376551330089569,
-0.5372176170349121,
0.47251343727111816,
0.8840606212615967,
-0.8422006964683533,
0.11997966468334198,
0.48116666078567505,
0.33722934126853943,
-0.03853866457939148,
0.6120197772979736,
0.23542240262031555,
0.35384440422058105,
-0.03973829746246338,
0.22389467060565948,
0.26980477571487427,
-0.3351794183254242,
-0.540814220905304,
-0.20363971590995789,
0.307269424200058,
0.06733732670545578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00146v1 | The Qiyas Benchmark: Measuring ChatGPT Mathematical and Language Understanding in Arabic | 2024-06-28T16:34:31 | 2024-06-28T16:34:31 | Shahad Al-Khalifa, Hend Al-Khalifa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the growing importance of Arabic as a global language, there is a
notable lack of language models pre-trained exclusively on Arabic data. This
shortage has led to limited benchmarks available for assessing language model
performance in Arabic. To address this gap, we introduce two novel benchmarks
designed to evaluate models' mathematical reasoning and language understanding
abilities in Arabic. These benchmarks are derived from a General Aptitude Test
(GAT) called Qiyas exam, a standardized test widely used for university
admissions in Saudi Arabia. For validation purposes, we assess the performance
of ChatGPT-3.5-trubo and ChatGPT-4 on our benchmarks. Our findings reveal that
these benchmarks pose a significant challenge, with ChatGPT-4 achieving an
overall average accuracy of 64%, while ChatGPT-3.5-trubo achieved an overall
accuracy of 49% across the various question types in the Qiyas benchmark. We
believe the release of these benchmarks will pave the way for enhancing the
mathematical reasoning and language understanding capabilities of future models
tailored for the low-resource Arabic language. | [
-0.2036261260509491,
-0.5131339430809021,
0.5172069668769836,
0.29488104581832886,
-0.29061490297317505,
0.3103429973125458,
0.12728044390678406,
-0.4615112543106079,
-0.4095684289932251,
0.1859523355960846,
-0.4027744233608246,
-0.6071414351463318,
-0.5243420004844666,
-0.18306612968444824,
-0.43818002939224243,
0.9529904723167419,
-0.49534887075424194,
0.22665613889694214,
-0.01813570037484169,
-0.4413900673389435,
-0.32600703835487366,
-0.463167667388916,
-0.5993157625198364,
-0.3149389624595642,
0.1237938329577446,
0.25959512591362,
1.2059299945831299,
0.40163499116897583,
0.5723424553871155,
0.23976001143455505,
0.13856039941310883,
-0.05758741497993469,
-0.08427311480045319,
0.11005762964487076,
-0.028471646830439568,
-0.41857659816741943,
-0.12944704294204712,
-0.04428461566567421,
0.7416571974754333,
0.7367896437644958,
-0.5276911854743958,
0.4578056037425995,
-0.23665951192378998,
0.8906615376472473,
-0.739808976650238,
0.24222037196159363,
-0.5132803320884705,
-0.015720905736088753,
-0.2340911626815796,
0.2870211899280548,
-0.05408357083797455,
-0.719078004360199,
0.17782364785671234,
-0.4454413652420044,
0.2213534563779831,
-0.005094520282000303,
0.9804328083992004,
0.02784949168562889,
-0.3437672555446625,
-0.21961870789527893,
-0.4239949882030487,
0.6778162717819214,
-0.6098920702934265,
0.39808526635169983,
0.37401995062828064,
0.7609679102897644,
-0.0779954120516777,
-0.7825230360031128,
-0.4611949324607849,
-0.4495225250720978,
0.19460532069206238,
0.0651283711194992,
-0.38239696621894836,
0.0337013304233551,
0.24712499976158142,
0.35369735956192017,
-0.8559116125106812,
-0.5730867981910706,
-0.14688412845134735,
-0.06073521077632904,
0.49615201354026794,
0.09006422013044357,
0.5729430913925171,
0.12591370940208435,
-0.13941891491413116,
-0.21461595594882965,
-0.8894168138504028,
0.33186161518096924,
0.3219304084777832,
-0.06327443569898605,
-0.05116645619273186,
0.4066298305988312,
-0.4542284905910492,
0.6740471124649048,
-0.6125352382659912,
0.07577113062143326,
0.09574124217033386,
-0.21232832968235016,
-0.35142824053764343,
0.012866172939538956,
0.6301490068435669,
-0.09510472416877747,
0.4732576906681061,
-0.09777871519327164,
-0.1040198802947998,
0.18987302482128143,
-0.06929206848144531,
-0.9924009442329407,
-0.5179966688156128,
0.004724389873445034,
-0.2935046851634979,
0.02635425329208374,
-0.012324661016464233,
-0.3410475552082062,
-0.21420717239379883,
-0.05839855596423149,
0.5678472518920898,
-0.5442837476730347,
-0.20586438477039337,
0.31263256072998047,
-0.016484864056110382,
0.31901079416275024,
0.39360255002975464,
-0.8874874114990234,
0.5305100083351135,
0.7360802292823792,
1.0957099199295044,
0.20001007616519928,
-0.29298636317253113,
-0.3646271526813507,
-0.01913578249514103,
-0.5258148908615112,
0.7350043058395386,
-0.711592972278595,
-0.3486064672470093,
0.016468871384859085,
-0.556911289691925,
-0.18739482760429382,
-0.5418164730072021,
0.8843666315078735,
-0.46030914783477783,
-0.09540405124425888,
-0.433879017829895,
-0.28856074810028076,
-0.6796431541442871,
0.15521042048931122,
-0.3667583465576172,
1.0333938598632812,
0.48862579464912415,
-0.5309498906135559,
0.11066336184740067,
-0.43276506662368774,
-0.1571645587682724,
0.13469476997852325,
-0.40207770466804504,
-0.40563708543777466,
0.059967853128910065,
0.4291154444217682,
-0.024318458512425423,
-0.6243422031402588,
0.28222543001174927,
-0.31598588824272156,
-0.7912318110466003,
0.5186158418655396,
-0.5979121923446655,
0.7722223401069641,
0.22205351293087006,
-0.4056175649166107,
-0.09302755445241928,
-0.6500911712646484,
0.4934694766998291,
0.18248166143894196,
0.1840958446264267,
-0.09154532104730606,
0.20912176370620728,
-0.04389552026987076,
0.3663749396800995,
0.15557828545570374,
-0.3346254229545593,
0.03730954974889755,
-0.35564297437667847,
0.3040465712547302,
0.5976431965827942,
-0.18555410206317902,
-0.1630360335111618,
-0.46376851201057434,
0.8228887915611267,
0.040185339748859406,
0.013312901370227337,
0.13933926820755005,
-0.6176371574401855,
-0.8321399092674255,
-0.1932380199432373,
0.2561551630496979,
0.4502984583377838,
-0.5651968717575073,
-0.1493767648935318,
-0.07690262049436569,
-0.9073923826217651,
-0.8149930834770203,
0.09888117015361786,
0.37442344427108765,
0.3517138957977295,
0.23979049921035767,
-0.26451534032821655,
-0.2545352876186371,
-0.8134681582450867,
-0.8111929297447205,
-0.5654840469360352,
-0.0778384730219841,
0.1759990155696869,
0.5285026431083679,
0.012700239196419716,
0.6711591482162476,
-0.33452749252319336,
0.17747722566127777,
-0.12421329319477081,
0.41590267419815063,
0.4133082926273346,
0.28168806433677673,
0.6844988465309143,
-0.5510802865028381,
-0.8629527688026428,
0.3211008608341217,
-0.45738300681114197,
-0.20847949385643005,
0.29858967661857605,
-0.029857948422431946,
-0.10300803184509277,
-0.07558899372816086,
-0.8306974768638611,
0.6130924820899963,
0.6761937737464905,
-0.45102593302726746,
0.7866660952568054,
0.011224644258618355,
0.449808806180954,
-0.5311601161956787,
-0.03689277172088623,
-0.061188653111457825,
0.04915093258023262,
-0.7172566652297974,
0.12873145937919617,
0.28934577107429504,
-0.20430703461170197,
-0.2995387017726898,
0.5654906630516052,
-0.38020288944244385,
-0.22300158441066742,
-0.02282089926302433,
0.03090924210846424,
-0.042698934674263,
0.42501917481422424,
-0.19764791429042816,
1.3093091249465942,
0.5934081673622131,
-0.23613689839839935,
0.26617443561553955,
0.027275139465928078,
-0.9690206050872803,
0.28234604001045227,
-1.0337562561035156,
0.09485140442848206,
0.07807257026433945,
-0.0301296915858984,
-1.23562490940094,
0.1001913920044899,
0.4489629864692688,
-0.5395687818527222,
-0.178308367729187,
-0.11534541845321655,
-0.40165290236473083,
-0.029251528903841972,
-0.11791021376848221,
0.5803602337837219,
0.6706523895263672,
-0.44772109389305115,
0.5450899600982666,
0.08873077481985092,
-0.43345117568969727,
-0.8066906332969666,
-0.3351135849952698,
-0.23358957469463348,
-0.13572050631046295,
-0.672568678855896,
0.08001004159450531,
0.11618662625551224,
-0.5190081596374512,
-0.13555750250816345,
-0.2830355167388916,
-0.19441618025302887,
0.25194674730300903,
0.3480423092842102,
0.271399587392807,
-0.4943777024745941,
0.17031100392341614,
0.09292136132717133,
-0.009595435112714767,
0.4161100387573242,
-0.22088702023029327,
0.4949783682823181,
-0.5242406129837036,
-0.7357741594314575,
-0.4191199243068695,
0.018129508942365646,
0.5606573224067688,
-0.6028327345848083,
0.8721111416816711,
0.5630386471748352,
-0.2696152627468109,
0.11115588247776031,
-0.4048053026199341,
0.24710245430469513,
-0.4775644540786743,
0.5464280247688293,
-0.722679615020752,
-0.4635641872882843,
0.5276018977165222,
0.05553319305181503,
0.033306654542684555,
0.4550837278366089,
0.6025992035865784,
0.1082831397652626,
1.570336103439331,
0.14008890092372894,
-0.47585585713386536,
0.14431634545326233,
0.11343422532081604,
0.5365942120552063,
-0.45576027035713196,
-0.00048604325274936855,
-1.0803335905075073,
-0.015880366787314415,
-0.6921124458312988,
-0.3302256166934967,
0.1914413720369339,
0.2111411690711975,
-0.527647852897644,
0.08933140337467194,
-0.15327055752277374,
0.5553889870643616,
0.3982716500759125,
-0.18445517122745514,
0.39080938696861267,
0.11995666474103928,
-0.18270094692707062,
-0.10560764372348785,
-0.4083816111087799,
-0.6976267099380493,
0.93235844373703,
0.26303842663764954,
0.6242696642875671,
0.589952290058136,
0.3219152092933655,
0.22887301445007324,
0.4067092835903168,
-0.5044329166412354,
0.41650718450546265,
0.3053341507911682,
-0.5160350203514099,
-0.09523826837539673,
-0.547532320022583,
-0.7255411148071289,
0.7940230369567871,
0.2894849181175232,
-0.8661968111991882,
-0.0971183180809021,
-0.17908866703510284,
-0.29922619462013245,
0.06652713567018509,
-0.880793571472168,
0.9533839225769043,
-0.08345259726047516,
-0.32237792015075684,
-0.4363572597503662,
-0.319264680147171,
0.30283281207084656,
0.20846624672412872,
0.14681389927864075,
-0.7529798150062561,
-0.1592741161584854,
0.7321887016296387,
-0.37820518016815186,
0.2244390845298767,
-0.14369763433933258,
0.12574690580368042,
0.4616180956363678,
0.22059817612171173,
0.17222821712493896,
0.25050002336502075,
-0.3256920576095581,
0.35155510902404785,
0.519029974937439,
-0.8872377276420593,
-0.6629766225814819,
0.48224514722824097,
-1.2344037294387817,
-0.6017332077026367,
-0.8706231117248535,
-0.6213395595550537,
-0.5222609639167786,
-0.10549229383468628,
-0.15795017778873444,
0.39444220066070557,
-0.4175713062286377,
-0.20378974080085754,
0.2449185699224472,
-0.04594041034579277,
0.21894891560077667,
0.8269200921058655,
-0.3032725751399994,
-0.16775070130825043,
0.892519474029541,
-0.043424107134342194,
0.2651214599609375,
0.25305524468421936,
0.1044846847653389,
-0.33718061447143555,
-0.6153713464736938,
-0.6105360984802246,
0.2825385332107544,
-0.7259449362754822,
-0.030234865844249725,
-0.39747732877731323,
-0.5579333901405334,
-0.3333214819431305,
0.1656043827533722,
-0.13486038148403168,
-0.3823772072792053,
0.13523218035697937,
0.15110807120800018,
0.16217629611492157,
0.6701003909111023,
0.14909078180789948,
0.2826625108718872,
-0.9000197052955627,
0.06194648519158363,
0.3117423951625824,
0.12274298816919327,
0.14642268419265747,
-0.7480502724647522,
-0.2894750237464905,
0.24715974926948547,
-0.5241531729698181,
-0.891048789024353,
0.4354419410228729,
0.17929495871067047,
0.4655725061893463,
0.5154632329940796,
-0.28855425119400024,
0.7713950276374817,
-0.4411143958568573,
0.6323686838150024,
-0.02962806634604931,
-1.3118356466293335,
0.4490736424922943,
-0.4243279695510864,
0.5305893421173096,
0.5667616724967957,
0.5392119288444519,
-0.9435789585113525,
-0.31805694103240967,
-0.4533202350139618,
-0.12250296026468277,
0.6323183178901672,
0.49701815843582153,
0.019161012023687363,
0.09302087128162384,
0.2692793905735016,
0.14258113503456116,
0.29764148592948914,
-0.45053496956825256,
-0.266382098197937,
0.015290466137230396,
-0.41184261441230774,
-0.0980982854962349,
-0.2555653750896454,
0.19669806957244873,
-0.40640583634376526,
0.7361818552017212,
0.08398167788982391,
0.12503284215927124,
-0.2313835173845291,
-0.15216132998466492,
-0.014229861088097095,
0.33250120282173157,
0.5169714689254761,
1.0749552249908447,
-0.29422909021377563,
-0.096329465508461,
0.04420982301235199,
-0.9406112432479858,
0.40469419956207275,
0.44428780674934387,
-0.16540184617042542,
0.16329331696033478,
0.2591911852359772,
0.46760135889053345,
-0.03131973743438721,
-0.9809287190437317,
0.34582069516181946,
-0.4006127119064331,
-0.1268872320652008,
-0.19313661754131317,
0.2518142759799957,
0.16856440901756287,
0.06553661823272705,
0.365623414516449,
-0.03949622064828873,
0.25539737939834595,
-0.4836568534374237,
-0.052506864070892334,
0.46349337697029114,
-0.28631481528282166,
-0.3338557481765747,
0.33364787697792053,
-0.07013791054487228,
-0.15369652211666107,
0.781370997428894,
-0.1535506695508957,
-0.6298841238021851,
0.7563238143920898,
0.4539855718612671,
0.6043592691421509,
-0.4931607246398926,
0.5373430252075195,
0.44820359349250793,
0.3094059228897095,
-0.04878927394747734,
0.5493191480636597,
-0.3183734714984894,
-0.764851450920105,
-0.14221036434173584,
-0.3831823170185089,
-0.8730968832969666,
-0.16478486359119415,
-0.6163069605827332,
0.03498081862926483,
-0.4334052801132202,
0.12600655853748322,
-0.07769173383712769,
0.4899609088897705,
-0.5566990375518799,
0.23602549731731415,
-0.11337297409772873,
0.7965973615646362,
-0.7905808687210083,
1.0614582300186157,
0.669873833656311,
-0.3512284755706787,
-0.7771924734115601,
-0.13510945439338684,
-0.036601223051548004,
-1.1924200057983398,
0.48433005809783936,
0.31845784187316895,
-0.15533234179019928,
-0.02485787123441696,
-0.2683424949645996,
-0.9874611496925354,
0.919285774230957,
0.45043542981147766,
-0.45836809277534485,
0.2807791829109192,
0.38818302750587463,
0.4266418516635895,
0.03601833060383797,
0.8639967441558838,
0.9573745131492615,
0.21629755198955536,
0.06816667318344116,
-0.6817396283149719,
-0.1740926057100296,
-0.42122024297714233,
0.06930312514305115,
0.5560666918754578,
-0.667189359664917,
1.072433352470398,
-0.18360938131809235,
-0.3900012671947479,
0.48126986622810364,
0.8682552576065063,
0.5386224389076233,
0.3990485370159149,
0.14086484909057617,
0.5504104495048523,
0.8085588812828064,
-0.38574206829071045,
0.8833795785903931,
-0.31413695216178894,
0.27838951349258423,
0.9328535795211792,
-0.3574864864349365,
0.9642899036407471,
0.2605191469192505,
-0.8374705910682678,
0.7589308619499207,
0.6639755964279175,
0.35860326886177063,
0.5671460628509521,
0.42517679929733276,
-0.7338309288024902,
-0.041311684995889664,
-0.2627924978733063,
-0.7784440517425537,
0.38220223784446716,
0.4647359251976013,
0.009619790129363537,
-0.2875719964504242,
-0.49888473749160767,
0.1529482752084732,
0.06854015588760376,
-0.260791152715683,
0.060635924339294434,
0.14860378205776215,
-0.8052727580070496,
0.48267319798469543,
0.26484134793281555,
-0.04455351456999779,
-0.7826650142669678,
-0.13176268339157104,
-0.37599384784698486,
0.2822495400905609,
0.1176079511642456,
-0.6762052774429321,
0.09037791192531586,
0.03554287925362587,
0.37311622500419617,
0.21156054735183716,
0.642890214920044,
-0.35236498713493347,
-0.7104846239089966,
-0.0748457983136177,
0.6584459543228149,
0.2600175738334656,
-0.23883572220802307,
-0.857795238494873,
0.08824415504932404,
-0.018270457163453102,
0.027202503755688667,
0.3179610073566437,
0.41146373748779297,
0.018194081261754036,
0.7821844816207886,
0.485805481672287,
0.21085411310195923,
-0.19743506610393524,
0.33537209033966064,
0.5476471185684204,
-0.703177273273468,
-0.4273308217525482,
-1.0526039600372314,
0.013910475187003613,
0.0263984315097332,
-0.5360704064369202,
0.8492958545684814,
0.3267686069011688,
0.6973673701286316,
0.12154886871576309,
0.7574372291564941,
0.19111493229866028,
0.39960232377052307,
-0.406853586435318,
0.8603510856628418,
-0.37955203652381897,
0.013546385802328587,
-0.2798386514186859,
-0.8861760497093201,
0.031015437096357346,
0.8615943193435669,
-0.577197790145874,
0.34406739473342896,
0.7818889617919922,
0.6961550712585449,
0.2057378590106964,
0.5077157020568848,
0.41595658659935,
-0.14356191456317902,
0.39895015954971313,
0.9996488690376282,
1.2229570150375366,
-0.7079033255577087,
0.39992186427116394,
-0.3431212604045868,
-0.0830201804637909,
0.044589053839445114,
-0.5014491677284241,
-1.2272367477416992,
-0.423870712518692,
-0.2140854001045227,
-0.2331230193376541,
0.3759319484233856,
0.8224027752876282,
0.4074244797229767,
-0.9246527552604675,
-0.4871569275856018,
-0.06958018988370895,
0.196516215801239,
-0.5069428086280823,
-0.1696721762418747,
0.6367961168289185,
-0.16187186539173126,
-0.45331135392189026,
-0.09397922456264496,
0.3775399923324585,
0.15964233875274658,
-0.13790088891983032,
-0.2097426801919937,
-0.08278457075357437,
0.04024887457489967,
0.27089178562164307,
0.30995553731918335,
-0.7280011773109436,
-0.07967235147953033,
-0.03320189192891121,
-0.36796557903289795,
0.027808168902993202,
0.6301841139793396,
-0.8364794254302979,
0.23834925889968872,
0.4611433148384094,
0.7389827370643616,
0.3977959156036377,
0.06709866970777512,
0.6086110472679138,
-0.10105089843273163,
0.17211109399795532,
0.1427268385887146,
0.3242410719394684,
0.2776903510093689,
0.022277800366282463,
0.617963433265686,
0.022670818492770195,
-0.45135924220085144,
-0.651676595211029,
0.02025454118847847,
-0.5377912521362305,
0.08360099047422409,
0.5966922640800476,
-0.3507297933101654,
-0.033834315836429596,
-0.19531095027923584,
-0.17873424291610718,
0.07267129421234131,
-0.27528244256973267,
0.9674795269966125,
1.0565872192382812,
0.008914528414607048,
-0.2591626048088074,
-0.9426668286323547,
0.33922192454338074,
1.096592903137207,
-0.8774846792221069,
-0.17160341143608093,
0.18997816741466522,
0.015600658021867275,
-0.378124862909317,
0.678428053855896,
-0.01751932129263878,
0.8230025768280029,
0.18844279646873474,
-0.10456130653619766,
0.3196536898612976,
0.0016685075825080276,
-0.11787901073694229,
-0.035169970244169235,
0.5060986280441284,
-0.2742254137992859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20038v1 | BioMNER: A Dataset for Biomedical Method Entity Recognition | 2024-06-28T16:34:24 | 2024-06-28T16:34:24 | Chen Tang, Bohao Yang, Kun Zhao, Bo Lv, Chenghao Xiao, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named entity recognition (NER) stands as a fundamental and pivotal task
within the realm of Natural Language Processing. Particularly within the domain
of Biomedical Method NER, this task presents notable challenges, stemming from
the continual influx of domain-specific terminologies in scholarly literature.
Current research in Biomedical Method (BioMethod) NER suffers from a scarcity
of resources, primarily attributed to the intricate nature of methodological
concepts, which necessitate a profound understanding for precise delineation.
In this study, we propose a novel dataset for biomedical method entity
recognition, employing an automated BioMethod entity recognition and
information retrieval system to assist human annotation. Furthermore, we
comprehensively explore a range of conventional and contemporary open-domain
NER methodologies, including the utilization of cutting-edge large-scale
language models (LLMs) customised to our dataset. Our empirical findings reveal
that the large parameter counts of language models surprisingly inhibit the
effective assimilation of entity extraction patterns pertaining to biomedical
methods. Remarkably, the approach, leveraging the modestly sized ALBERT model
(only 11MB), in conjunction with conditional random fields (CRF), achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance. | [
-0.3022365868091583,
-0.7782466411590576,
0.5370687246322632,
-0.1313239187002182,
-0.30218902230262756,
0.22977913916110992,
-0.12687163054943085,
-0.8041727542877197,
0.4065192937850952,
0.632567286491394,
-0.34726858139038086,
-0.7219507098197937,
-0.47386205196380615,
0.657155454158783,
-0.026231486350297928,
1.1747748851776123,
0.07340101897716522,
0.4886101186275482,
-0.31249696016311646,
-0.46544790267944336,
0.027838917449116707,
-0.4128687381744385,
-0.7532448768615723,
-0.4444546699523926,
0.8110837936401367,
0.07942888885736465,
0.29231706261634827,
0.8582308888435364,
1.1266108751296997,
0.231242373585701,
-0.05692974478006363,
0.03303757682442665,
-0.05776757001876831,
0.28920990228652954,
-0.30908870697021484,
-0.22750714421272278,
-0.4698035418987274,
-0.3059443533420563,
0.6243940591812134,
0.9055998921394348,
-0.07976868748664856,
0.39252594113349915,
-0.339886873960495,
0.2643771767616272,
-0.49215635657310486,
0.1478884220123291,
-0.4490627646446228,
-0.018703050911426544,
-0.5021242499351501,
-0.21592062711715698,
-0.2608104944229126,
-0.18835417926311493,
0.3745478391647339,
-0.5425888895988464,
0.35767966508865356,
0.22399742901325226,
0.8384024500846863,
0.3390989899635315,
-0.1846488118171692,
-0.05094108730554581,
-0.6562092304229736,
0.5099279880523682,
-0.652487576007843,
0.6405842304229736,
0.2597581744194031,
0.357571005821228,
-0.151249498128891,
-0.6251407861709595,
-0.32384026050567627,
-0.09550923854112625,
-0.14868628978729248,
-0.1988901048898697,
-0.08540526032447815,
0.060514722019433975,
0.4652880132198334,
0.004778954666107893,
-0.6386894583702087,
0.13451223075389862,
-0.5310951471328735,
-0.41442549228668213,
0.5919051170349121,
0.20280972123146057,
0.1833621859550476,
-0.33671095967292786,
-0.23282377421855927,
0.11904813349246979,
-0.6198100447654724,
-0.155154287815094,
-0.16199421882629395,
0.2027742713689804,
0.07875464111566544,
0.45562875270843506,
-0.24955666065216064,
0.5777963995933533,
-0.09533561021089554,
-0.1745171993970871,
0.3955537974834442,
0.026089873164892197,
-0.29044488072395325,
0.15571731328964233,
1.0858242511749268,
0.01062108390033245,
-0.10684389621019363,
-0.5607003569602966,
-0.20690318942070007,
-0.009452234022319317,
0.11102889478206635,
-1.1710439920425415,
-0.1957741379737854,
0.2845933139324188,
-0.4266909956932068,
-0.09851697832345963,
-0.22432513535022736,
-0.9784625768661499,
-0.5473546981811523,
-0.27944082021713257,
0.31909865140914917,
-0.6388529539108276,
0.1546499878168106,
0.038107916712760925,
0.022300662472844124,
0.1468665599822998,
0.08292828500270844,
-0.5014235377311707,
0.3879050314426422,
0.3932390511035919,
0.7673168182373047,
-0.004465204663574696,
0.18680940568447113,
-0.40132299065589905,
0.2139623910188675,
-0.06815456598997116,
0.8211851716041565,
-0.7897972464561462,
-0.42024967074394226,
-0.40374189615249634,
0.14868097007274628,
0.19041095674037933,
-0.7441385984420776,
0.3671879172325134,
-0.9907037019729614,
-0.18353183567523956,
-0.12740786373615265,
-0.4941939115524292,
-0.38906607031822205,
-0.06177639216184616,
-0.7507937550544739,
0.588163435459137,
-0.09815657138824463,
-0.9454683065414429,
0.6037518978118896,
-0.7012784481048584,
-0.5297896862030029,
0.6176397204399109,
-0.519582211971283,
-0.6477804183959961,
-0.0804140642285347,
0.028755508363246918,
0.5279829502105713,
-0.5583122968673706,
0.434477835893631,
-0.5269960165023804,
-0.11370863020420074,
0.5095555782318115,
-0.08652674406766891,
0.638830304145813,
0.08563557267189026,
-0.19250521063804626,
-0.14775307476520538,
-1.27812659740448,
-0.06154434010386467,
0.1126713976264,
-0.3108193278312683,
-0.7584607005119324,
-0.04856741055846214,
0.1478254348039627,
0.06725099682807922,
0.10476836562156677,
-0.9027808904647827,
0.05636158213019371,
-0.4661676287651062,
0.6258211135864258,
0.2786799371242523,
0.2938986122608185,
0.4091144800186157,
-0.02364725060760975,
0.39915555715560913,
-0.04530271887779236,
-0.2904110550880432,
0.05949952453374863,
-0.1859578788280487,
-0.27125972509384155,
-0.8779879212379456,
0.8578110933303833,
0.6164959073066711,
-0.537656307220459,
0.43514811992645264,
-0.4749380052089691,
-0.43523380160331726,
-0.8273255228996277,
-0.07053352147340775,
0.5228304266929626,
0.7428399324417114,
0.7384999394416809,
-0.11703179031610489,
-0.854843258857727,
-1.1722561120986938,
-0.046290118247270584,
0.16425149142742157,
-0.2878406345844269,
0.35903897881507874,
0.8072380423545837,
-0.6887337565422058,
1.1124674081802368,
-0.2936658263206482,
-0.2440614402294159,
0.11491432040929794,
0.20594201982021332,
0.19945666193962097,
0.4251144826412201,
0.2152705043554306,
-0.8355361819267273,
-0.020694956183433533,
0.13371601700782776,
-0.9486067891120911,
-0.23611746728420258,
0.12490837275981903,
-0.3610345721244812,
-0.06982476264238358,
0.5248719453811646,
-0.520943820476532,
0.37280920147895813,
0.17481625080108643,
-0.1336243599653244,
0.3301672637462616,
-0.19212032854557037,
0.04588908702135086,
-0.9669166803359985,
0.5205923914909363,
0.27353203296661377,
-0.3580518066883087,
-0.4007299840450287,
-0.07607138156890869,
0.2160421460866928,
0.06945837289094925,
-0.2502341866493225,
0.9334211349487305,
-0.5024054646492004,
0.05205577611923218,
-0.18983033299446106,
-0.22279059886932373,
0.013930415734648705,
0.08133886009454727,
0.40722426772117615,
0.4594438970088959,
0.3794693052768707,
-0.7322906255722046,
0.051095664501190186,
0.6211996674537659,
-0.0407346747815609,
0.5897617936134338,
-0.8490244746208191,
0.1708562821149826,
-0.4378970265388489,
0.34095799922943115,
-0.3348790407180786,
-0.4722040593624115,
0.4743379056453705,
-0.355027973651886,
0.5351718068122864,
-0.09929803013801575,
-0.5432462096214294,
-0.2911410629749298,
0.1319194734096527,
0.5835606455802917,
0.3700816035270691,
-0.27919432520866394,
0.7579190731048584,
0.5624411106109619,
-0.41931581497192383,
-0.4625639319419861,
-0.6336838006973267,
0.03284130245447159,
-0.1548575460910797,
-0.3439217507839203,
0.6337972283363342,
0.05613856762647629,
-0.22772325575351715,
0.020908480510115623,
-0.3059435188770294,
-0.1113978773355484,
-0.1233203336596489,
0.4505809247493744,
0.6234207153320312,
-0.18876959383487701,
0.33119386434555054,
0.05898266285657883,
-0.16725829243659973,
0.12985214591026306,
-0.060780979692935944,
0.22909015417099,
0.14393164217472076,
-0.0026484732516109943,
-0.46326398849487305,
0.2681037485599518,
0.37665775418281555,
-0.540269136428833,
0.8521569967269897,
0.5107443332672119,
-0.7742362022399902,
0.07540511339902878,
-0.5581513047218323,
-0.37767842411994934,
-0.3680962324142456,
0.48940110206604004,
-0.3519563674926758,
-0.8178301453590393,
0.5642833113670349,
-0.1419483721256256,
0.024584278464317322,
0.3863944113254547,
0.34484899044036865,
-0.156171977519989,
0.8368117809295654,
0.43060630559921265,
0.10171584039926529,
0.026180580258369446,
-0.20983847975730896,
0.14922839403152466,
-1.1555309295654297,
-0.46702873706817627,
-0.6224170923233032,
-0.36182790994644165,
-0.4867708086967468,
-0.44138452410697937,
0.26266610622406006,
0.03822481632232666,
-0.33196738362312317,
0.3518313467502594,
-0.40302401781082153,
0.24436846375465393,
0.35113629698753357,
0.43786728382110596,
0.2834087610244751,
0.04552222415804863,
-0.3325365483760834,
-0.10118737071752548,
-0.42445337772369385,
-0.8749826550483704,
1.0311412811279297,
0.2538888156414032,
0.6779583096504211,
-0.0521966889500618,
0.9810670614242554,
0.11463939398527145,
0.775818407535553,
-0.6917024850845337,
0.7317251563072205,
0.07583866268396378,
-0.8401906490325928,
-0.24890705943107605,
-0.6576012969017029,
-1.0716503858566284,
0.027965737506747246,
-0.4968888759613037,
-0.743770182132721,
0.4298158288002014,
-0.09022380411624908,
-0.7072620987892151,
0.1944492906332016,
-0.24095892906188965,
0.4983755052089691,
-0.02374785579741001,
-0.3831067979335785,
0.2521405816078186,
-0.9514684677124023,
-0.0408887043595314,
-0.4336952865123749,
0.5639938712120056,
-0.2018297165632248,
-0.17561258375644684,
1.034544587135315,
-0.2277388870716095,
0.5220001935958862,
-0.012455454096198082,
0.1720138043165207,
0.06033175811171532,
0.04188455641269684,
0.3766132593154907,
0.27809831500053406,
-0.08642210066318512,
0.5961049199104309,
0.15890268981456757,
-0.22079265117645264,
-0.2366584837436676,
0.3918004035949707,
-0.4347064793109894,
-0.18768712878227234,
-0.5483213067054749,
-0.5021921992301941,
-0.19625595211982727,
0.49023929238319397,
0.49015605449676514,
0.5047361254692078,
-0.29197558760643005,
0.19704818725585938,
0.9032121300697327,
-0.3738844692707062,
0.2143741101026535,
0.7405046224594116,
-0.04362291470170021,
-0.6842595338821411,
0.714104175567627,
0.13826227188110352,
-0.2428278774023056,
0.6342116594314575,
-0.20319141447544098,
-0.36607977747917175,
-0.5482019186019897,
-0.42505937814712524,
0.6705739498138428,
-0.4716774821281433,
-0.5561721920967102,
-1.1145350933074951,
-0.15457913279533386,
-0.2897985875606537,
0.05536653473973274,
-0.04845016449689865,
-0.06363038718700409,
-0.42356419563293457,
-0.13859549164772034,
0.5037223100662231,
0.3711819350719452,
0.005739959888160229,
0.1253174990415573,
-1.1184324026107788,
0.46782103180885315,
-0.22196583449840546,
0.36003753542900085,
-0.38462933897972107,
-0.29029637575149536,
-0.10628914088010788,
-0.012628141790628433,
0.1192745566368103,
-1.0312494039535522,
0.47915491461753845,
0.26601994037628174,
0.5905075669288635,
0.4068051278591156,
-0.07259703427553177,
0.35113462805747986,
-0.8827724456787109,
-0.023381175473332405,
0.13314250111579895,
-0.35531753301620483,
0.4820742905139923,
-0.2670934498310089,
-0.06422153115272522,
0.6940690875053406,
0.6988657116889954,
-0.3292188048362732,
-0.0384068489074707,
-0.6546521782875061,
-0.9424989819526672,
0.41453951597213745,
-0.06688042730093002,
-0.16095122694969177,
-0.25612208247184753,
0.49987873435020447,
0.36138054728507996,
0.17422087490558624,
-0.4482320547103882,
-0.250046968460083,
0.48367342352867126,
-0.470382958650589,
0.04734009504318237,
-0.07649361342191696,
-0.0906304270029068,
-0.13761676847934723,
0.7754175066947937,
0.027995212003588676,
0.3692206144332886,
0.4504854679107666,
-0.35224902629852295,
-0.10853289812803268,
0.40340253710746765,
0.18601350486278534,
0.3318859934806824,
-0.33400967717170715,
0.043580856174230576,
0.19298391044139862,
-0.6113749742507935,
0.1058693528175354,
0.6860992312431335,
-0.43354666233062744,
0.06511779129505157,
0.2764880955219269,
0.5265733599662781,
0.3408893346786499,
-0.867181658744812,
0.052893832325935364,
0.11766146123409271,
-0.23575419187545776,
-0.10187573730945587,
-0.09133534878492355,
0.10436463356018066,
0.45423024892807007,
0.3162132501602173,
0.2958188056945801,
0.5799609422683716,
0.004239898640662432,
0.3302484452724457,
0.42131444811820984,
-0.4803534746170044,
-0.4022376537322998,
0.8483880162239075,
-0.028283994644880295,
-0.402594655752182,
0.44108113646507263,
-0.3505657911300659,
-0.2525596022605896,
0.364842027425766,
0.36819279193878174,
0.5597471594810486,
-0.2595981955528259,
0.05606502294540405,
0.4841642379760742,
-0.1776292324066162,
0.003708951873704791,
0.3263818919658661,
0.11323808133602142,
-0.5797913670539856,
-0.4548463523387909,
-1.1877788305282593,
-0.18175053596496582,
0.16304032504558563,
-0.7165834307670593,
0.39713701605796814,
-0.5543680191040039,
-0.6607272624969482,
0.5531556606292725,
-0.23168721795082092,
-0.8868675231933594,
0.3581983149051666,
0.19971536099910736,
0.6762703657150269,
-0.46467986702919006,
0.4917808175086975,
1.149582862854004,
-0.5484392642974854,
-0.3966844081878662,
-0.45846477150917053,
-0.061799079179763794,
-0.41033661365509033,
0.9151290655136108,
0.07438004016876221,
-0.0503886379301548,
0.2832696735858917,
-0.39922207593917847,
-0.8001641035079956,
1.0273281335830688,
0.18884147703647614,
-0.8628060221672058,
-0.2574383318424225,
-0.0491919070482254,
0.5983967781066895,
-0.29571306705474854,
0.21484039723873138,
0.644413948059082,
0.3406204581260681,
0.025074763223528862,
-0.6909321546554565,
0.22820024192333221,
-0.2468380481004715,
-0.023287050426006317,
0.36603808403015137,
-0.37273821234703064,
0.35800454020500183,
-0.46296069025993347,
-0.14285652339458466,
-0.00785432755947113,
0.5345121622085571,
0.6382302045822144,
0.5596362948417664,
0.15412777662277222,
0.4939401149749756,
0.8323098421096802,
0.14241579174995422,
0.8117403388023376,
-0.10542209446430206,
0.25477126240730286,
0.879131555557251,
-0.4417189359664917,
0.8131385445594788,
0.31963086128234863,
-0.24170106649398804,
0.5551856160163879,
0.6301842927932739,
-0.0670153796672821,
0.45082342624664307,
0.40618979930877686,
-0.200959712266922,
-0.2565349042415619,
-0.1379302740097046,
-0.25539177656173706,
0.4112705588340759,
0.42475393414497375,
-0.5775579810142517,
-0.07642972469329834,
0.375468909740448,
0.18690960109233856,
-0.16053418815135956,
-0.3841007351875305,
0.7714101076126099,
0.22144755721092224,
-0.046427905559539795,
0.14222948253154755,
-0.122116319835186,
0.8005008697509766,
-0.29710856080055237,
-0.23002903163433075,
0.13882923126220703,
0.11521757394075394,
-0.1877841353416443,
-0.10527228564023972,
0.027664346620440483,
-0.06273895502090454,
-0.35840535163879395,
0.2332889288663864,
0.7687377333641052,
-0.3116651773452759,
-0.764884352684021,
0.26082947850227356,
0.36987268924713135,
0.1615174561738968,
0.16440312564373016,
-0.4905957281589508,
-0.1980791985988617,
-0.3784594237804413,
-0.17475031316280365,
0.22342967987060547,
0.6000821590423584,
-0.06820782274007797,
0.7736252546310425,
0.5959711074829102,
0.39939308166503906,
-0.1321168839931488,
-0.08788862824440002,
0.5068330764770508,
-0.8495892882347107,
-0.23534679412841797,
-0.8435511589050293,
0.2248786985874176,
-0.0826825499534607,
-0.0845535397529602,
0.38980722427368164,
0.6677031517028809,
0.6419016122817993,
-0.1381535828113556,
0.81584233045578,
-0.03528876230120659,
1.0115118026733398,
-0.32019129395484924,
0.8968258500099182,
-0.4374276101589203,
0.21913015842437744,
-0.23115745186805725,
-0.6924105882644653,
-0.5985482931137085,
0.6740071773529053,
-0.46078845858573914,
0.13453759253025055,
0.5662071108818054,
0.597825825214386,
0.02330055460333824,
0.07635249197483063,
0.12158315628767014,
0.26688289642333984,
0.1311817467212677,
0.19704201817512512,
0.43122604489326477,
-0.32797497510910034,
0.2696404457092285,
-0.17980261147022247,
-0.16351819038391113,
-0.4748004078865051,
-0.6357176303863525,
-0.7411882281303406,
-0.3845938444137573,
-0.6065530776977539,
-0.3248904049396515,
0.13155700266361237,
1.2621877193450928,
0.7586696743965149,
-0.9634677171707153,
0.4083764851093292,
0.1439380645751953,
-0.4712209701538086,
-0.05898939445614815,
-0.13755282759666443,
0.41057056188583374,
-0.042386494576931,
-0.4817906618118286,
0.20202898979187012,
0.3911208510398865,
0.06987285614013672,
0.016436947509646416,
0.0853671282529831,
-0.21437132358551025,
0.07602167129516602,
0.36344653367996216,
0.4701627194881439,
-0.47406071424484253,
-0.09751910716295242,
0.25809425115585327,
-0.38072285056114197,
0.04847533255815506,
0.6544312834739685,
-0.9523941874504089,
0.22949087619781494,
0.23205378651618958,
0.9210227727890015,
0.20285779237747192,
-0.1483715921640396,
0.25840330123901367,
-0.40857797861099243,
-0.11248094588518143,
0.6197193264961243,
0.42969462275505066,
0.43566179275512695,
-0.47492489218711853,
0.5492987036705017,
0.3044498860836029,
-0.6128008365631104,
-0.7604418992996216,
-0.17881035804748535,
-0.9264269471168518,
-0.05467161908745766,
0.9862056970596313,
0.19829058647155762,
-0.40602201223373413,
-0.3416990637779236,
-0.18986743688583374,
0.3995107412338257,
-0.45299702882766724,
0.6084506511688232,
0.3269844055175781,
-0.14226548373699188,
-0.01101712416857481,
-0.6374044418334961,
0.32216960191726685,
-0.035026080906391144,
-0.7781584858894348,
-0.17281757295131683,
0.5738335251808167,
0.618937611579895,
0.18795180320739746,
0.7687788009643555,
-0.23641405999660492,
0.09048017859458923,
-0.2349400520324707,
0.5025148391723633,
0.03852096572518349,
-0.2503609359264374,
-0.18665197491645813,
-0.04705178365111351,
-0.19606949388980865,
0.0655478686094284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20030v1 | LEMoE: Advanced Mixture of Experts Adaptor for Lifelong Model Editing of Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T16:17:41 | 2024-06-28T16:17:41 | Renzhi Wang, Piji Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) require continual knowledge updates to stay
abreast of the ever-changing world facts, prompting the formulation of lifelong
model editing task. While recent years have witnessed the development of
various techniques for single and batch editing, these methods either fail to
apply or perform sub-optimally when faced with lifelong editing. In this paper,
we introduce LEMoE, an advanced Mixture of Experts (MoE) adaptor for lifelong
model editing. We first analyze the factors influencing the effectiveness of
conventional MoE adaptor in lifelong editing, including catastrophic
forgetting, inconsistent routing and order sensitivity. Based on these
insights, we propose a tailored module insertion method to achieve lifelong
editing, incorporating a novel KV anchor routing to enhance routing consistency
between training and inference stage, along with a concise yet effective
clustering-based editing order planning. Experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method in lifelong editing, surpassing previous model
editing techniques while maintaining outstanding performance in batch editing
task. Our code will be available. | [
-0.1852950155735016,
-1.1261627674102783,
0.5113486051559448,
0.23521441221237183,
-0.13787896931171417,
-0.05462074279785156,
-0.33337634801864624,
-0.22286304831504822,
0.16585446894168854,
0.5776478052139282,
-0.4432106912136078,
-0.43429645895957947,
-0.6148170232772827,
-0.15401910245418549,
-0.04671216011047363,
0.4993072748184204,
0.0059710158966481686,
0.14396816492080688,
-0.20938077569007874,
-0.3307848572731018,
-0.9087231159210205,
-0.27861127257347107,
-0.8713964819908142,
-0.1428471952676773,
0.5193949937820435,
0.3628213405609131,
0.5687494874000549,
0.5867466330528259,
0.24233520030975342,
0.4391704797744751,
-0.31438153982162476,
0.4954732656478882,
-0.40540000796318054,
0.4566197097301483,
-0.6069095134735107,
-0.4901180863380432,
-1.2518858909606934,
-0.43484798073768616,
0.7285659909248352,
0.44121599197387695,
-0.19071929156780243,
-0.3232657015323639,
-0.07978135347366333,
0.6301701068878174,
-0.7625304460525513,
-0.5166512727737427,
-0.9982708096504211,
-0.17768743634223938,
0.017792081460356712,
-0.004609816242009401,
-0.5020334124565125,
-0.060479067265987396,
-0.05498383194208145,
-0.45660027861595154,
-0.02087876759469509,
-0.10660236328840256,
0.30126953125,
0.38769376277923584,
-0.29801493883132935,
-0.22745250165462494,
-0.721699059009552,
0.6220083832740784,
-1.0567150115966797,
0.40563371777534485,
-0.04121332988142967,
0.13906382024288177,
-0.5287585258483887,
-0.44393861293792725,
-0.6048710942268372,
0.0025885894428938627,
0.3923240900039673,
0.1337837427854538,
-0.006406091619282961,
0.3435059189796448,
-0.14451852440834045,
0.11190171539783478,
-0.3876955509185791,
0.3701713979244232,
-0.05372059717774391,
-0.0450277104973793,
0.6761301755905151,
0.19072391092777252,
0.3825953006744385,
0.160881906747818,
0.02418852038681507,
0.3930094838142395,
-0.6323455572128296,
-0.5157828330993652,
0.2109464854001999,
-0.22346287965774536,
0.34753721952438354,
0.490218847990036,
-0.3152499198913574,
0.929686963558197,
0.26602622866630554,
-0.2861681878566742,
-0.13913387060165405,
0.14950211346149445,
-0.30464595556259155,
-0.08862070739269257,
0.7747464179992676,
0.5605570077896118,
0.2682848572731018,
-0.010225539095699787,
-0.34016284346580505,
-0.45141860842704773,
0.21395917236804962,
-0.39653804898262024,
-0.336365669965744,
0.22560639679431915,
-0.19420763850212097,
-0.20923583209514618,
-0.08566593378782272,
-0.7304614186286926,
-0.3577459752559662,
-0.09742216020822525,
0.4794349670410156,
-0.4933812916278839,
-0.013136527501046658,
0.19294387102127075,
0.005064862314611673,
-0.3749803602695465,
0.5826157927513123,
-1.0802496671676636,
0.07317119091749191,
0.6099729537963867,
0.8846389055252075,
-0.320652037858963,
-0.43730857968330383,
-0.6194196343421936,
0.6018887162208557,
-0.11690393835306168,
0.8626205921173096,
-0.7806817293167114,
-0.740059494972229,
-0.2676370143890381,
0.06387647241353989,
-0.2648099660873413,
-0.5971201658248901,
0.2853968143463135,
-0.8362604379653931,
-0.17507997155189514,
0.037876661866903305,
-0.9537172317504883,
-0.007186072412878275,
0.07859265059232712,
-0.30852827429771423,
1.0062661170959473,
0.0304922666400671,
-0.33295926451683044,
0.1291099339723587,
-0.7145240902900696,
-0.17446017265319824,
0.019515959545969963,
0.14300571382045746,
-0.32849961519241333,
0.21377252042293549,
0.47969815135002136,
0.5289771556854248,
0.41293808817863464,
0.49356672167778015,
-0.35164549946784973,
-0.18136531114578247,
0.29832303524017334,
-0.48287713527679443,
0.47745072841644287,
-0.13662539422512054,
-0.05049418658018112,
0.35627371072769165,
-0.7353315353393555,
-0.5411879420280457,
-0.1420750916004181,
-0.5435640215873718,
-0.4804779887199402,
0.06482052057981491,
0.03312961757183075,
0.10306278616189957,
0.5124494433403015,
-0.5017203688621521,
0.8522219657897949,
-0.011585059575736523,
0.3662553131580353,
1.4362123012542725,
0.3349878787994385,
0.534978449344635,
-0.266855925321579,
0.5825106501579285,
-0.03146425634622574,
0.4147643744945526,
-0.12237054854631424,
-0.6742231845855713,
-1.0888080596923828,
-0.20973053574562073,
0.46312060952186584,
0.8285971283912659,
-0.47961586713790894,
0.5476936101913452,
-0.4997362196445465,
-0.6004049181938171,
-0.4603826105594635,
0.5896874666213989,
0.012596056796610355,
0.3329446315765381,
0.46043235063552856,
-0.14357350766658783,
-0.4952216148376465,
-0.785862147808075,
-0.2951793670654297,
0.15735183656215668,
0.06978221982717514,
0.19128501415252686,
0.5458424687385559,
-0.6966972351074219,
1.1403826475143433,
-0.5069088339805603,
0.08433077484369278,
-0.20804379880428314,
-0.12046566605567932,
0.11800072342157364,
0.8255652189254761,
0.43757733702659607,
-0.47884732484817505,
-0.6118612885475159,
0.2036154419183731,
-0.5835780501365662,
-0.24849370121955872,
-0.2768018841743469,
-0.38116636872291565,
0.22937403619289398,
0.6335585713386536,
-0.5593568682670593,
-0.014832845889031887,
0.714752197265625,
0.01674305461347103,
0.5501253008842468,
-0.45265689492225647,
0.05083926022052765,
-1.1822477579116821,
-0.28337833285331726,
-0.20849165320396423,
-0.3115440607070923,
-0.5706237554550171,
0.052581872791051865,
0.14580994844436646,
0.3859962224960327,
-0.37362203001976013,
0.8298246264457703,
-0.3134636878967285,
0.19157618284225464,
-0.3213570713996887,
0.2132437378168106,
-0.2851509153842926,
0.28892186284065247,
-0.21345484256744385,
0.5803468227386475,
0.3303786814212799,
-0.6152724027633667,
0.5948109030723572,
0.15454614162445068,
-0.32009536027908325,
0.7526543140411377,
-0.5540080666542053,
0.4681166112422943,
0.016815118491649628,
0.28881338238716125,
-0.7271813154220581,
-0.22738438844680786,
0.15989772975444794,
-0.19509944319725037,
0.2728964686393738,
-0.17969971895217896,
-0.38452696800231934,
-0.07785850763320923,
-0.037671200931072235,
0.3112546503543854,
0.4568207263946533,
-0.34429997205734253,
1.0217503309249878,
0.16094966232776642,
-0.5493887066841125,
-0.6120550632476807,
-0.6150890588760376,
0.25431129336357117,
-0.09757327288389206,
-0.7338630557060242,
0.31252869963645935,
-0.5139669179916382,
-0.26779115200042725,
0.015444118529558182,
-0.08539867401123047,
-0.2242790013551712,
-0.000619170896243304,
0.022994358092546463,
0.2884611189365387,
-0.29873529076576233,
-0.03273289278149605,
0.6620493531227112,
-0.33620989322662354,
-0.353385329246521,
-0.2313486486673355,
0.3009141981601715,
0.37068769335746765,
-0.4183245003223419,
-0.5229690074920654,
0.3535372018814087,
0.8208579421043396,
0.019515180960297585,
0.6727820038795471,
0.42018020153045654,
-0.17690885066986084,
-0.18876469135284424,
-1.0933406352996826,
0.17652639746665955,
-0.5353221297264099,
0.6557683348655701,
-0.3546701967716217,
-1.0102579593658447,
0.5338620543479919,
-0.3905268907546997,
0.21036353707313538,
0.5072532296180725,
0.4436167776584625,
-0.10011257976293564,
0.6985123157501221,
0.7335653901100159,
-0.3886461853981018,
0.49984437227249146,
0.03361146152019501,
-0.03524046763777733,
-1.0814831256866455,
-0.018213506788015366,
-0.11657068133354187,
-0.25613370537757874,
-0.3022870421409607,
-0.5633264183998108,
0.5322993993759155,
0.44220176339149475,
0.07332176715135574,
-0.03449561446905136,
-0.06686516106128693,
0.6650254726409912,
0.269258975982666,
0.1543044000864029,
0.5278885364532471,
-0.25505968928337097,
-0.12464585155248642,
0.0870751142501831,
-0.8961079120635986,
-0.3040091097354889,
0.9283786416053772,
0.21129249036312103,
0.7009645104408264,
0.041110724210739136,
0.5252127647399902,
0.40493258833885193,
0.4121854901313782,
-0.5577611327171326,
0.7125611901283264,
-0.2531502842903137,
-0.43209314346313477,
-0.3651423156261444,
-0.035716462880373,
-0.3670310974121094,
0.25588753819465637,
-0.298019677400589,
-0.7220754623413086,
0.3309440612792969,
0.5227859616279602,
-0.3354572057723999,
0.5485984683036804,
-0.36206498742103577,
0.6079006791114807,
-0.11138393729925156,
-0.3563743829727173,
-0.5203251242637634,
-0.41437992453575134,
0.19662955403327942,
-0.2436240315437317,
0.5473951101303101,
0.15614579617977142,
-0.28473299741744995,
0.5658173561096191,
-0.5866378545761108,
0.7266257405281067,
-0.023543579503893852,
-0.11248891055583954,
0.014237851835787296,
0.2435462474822998,
0.8619043231010437,
0.13609227538108826,
-0.36720213294029236,
0.03465021774172783,
-0.5376498103141785,
-0.5124253034591675,
-0.815978467464447,
0.9006032347679138,
-0.6310533285140991,
-0.5705724954605103,
0.09344205260276794,
-0.7664268612861633,
-0.2905101776123047,
0.07681728154420853,
0.17701128125190735,
0.47376975417137146,
-0.22899165749549866,
0.21859051287174225,
0.809909999370575,
-0.26181307435035706,
0.5724380612373352,
0.4693273603916168,
-0.18244338035583496,
-0.7622027397155762,
0.898996114730835,
0.3324536979198456,
0.5498254895210266,
0.4130321145057678,
0.18659260869026184,
0.25902602076530457,
-0.8593211770057678,
-0.5901099443435669,
0.17778727412223816,
-0.9116224050521851,
0.1754656881093979,
-1.008612871170044,
-0.2088671773672104,
-0.3687707781791687,
-0.9705816507339478,
-0.5598804950714111,
-0.38911762833595276,
-0.03358260169625282,
0.16380812227725983,
0.49734434485435486,
0.9512218832969666,
-0.23411992192268372,
0.8154363632202148,
-0.956127941608429,
0.2340564727783203,
0.7440175414085388,
0.11220969259738922,
0.07600666582584381,
-0.5403606295585632,
-0.388998419046402,
-0.03298258036375046,
-0.19398418068885803,
-0.7606075406074524,
0.20428195595741272,
0.2022676318883896,
0.6962575316429138,
0.2440517097711563,
-0.39954978227615356,
0.8494206666946411,
-0.6686745285987854,
0.8028315305709839,
-0.20197051763534546,
-1.054600715637207,
0.4984061121940613,
-0.7087151408195496,
0.47388920187950134,
0.44383305311203003,
0.06762942671775818,
-0.646048367023468,
-0.47763508558273315,
-0.3422674834728241,
-0.8450007438659668,
0.21356114745140076,
-0.15885457396507263,
0.14131049811840057,
0.04733103886246681,
0.6137767434120178,
0.2678408622741699,
0.1494552046060562,
-0.5125709772109985,
-0.13547196984291077,
0.25971007347106934,
-0.1943066120147705,
-0.004897669423371553,
-0.7266920804977417,
0.38026130199432373,
-0.426655113697052,
0.9928222894668579,
0.10312404483556747,
-0.0805429220199585,
0.023678410798311234,
-0.3806826174259186,
-0.12548717856407166,
0.4049336910247803,
0.915479302406311,
0.915704071521759,
-0.377132773399353,
-0.3688099980354309,
0.7733209729194641,
-0.536385715007782,
0.009501862339675426,
-0.48874595761299133,
-0.26372748613357544,
0.12476639449596405,
0.6133241653442383,
0.7680743932723999,
0.41579174995422363,
-0.42331501841545105,
0.16788417100906372,
0.25038325786590576,
-0.1522257924079895,
-0.005020099226385355,
0.4842585623264313,
0.27154189348220825,
0.13075852394104004,
0.25251343846321106,
0.3622739911079407,
-0.052961479872465134,
-0.13921475410461426,
0.05427759885787964,
0.14882835745811462,
-0.11442626267671585,
-0.0041092573665082455,
0.5515101552009583,
0.43398988246917725,
-0.5724539756774902,
0.518478274345398,
0.11772388219833374,
-0.4769923686981201,
0.3611399531364441,
0.37924668192863464,
0.8693419694900513,
-0.9304293394088745,
-0.16752594709396362,
0.16654177010059357,
0.34722641110420227,
-0.05179697275161743,
-0.09841267764568329,
0.2816043794155121,
-0.7234926223754883,
-0.6910302639007568,
-0.47182250022888184,
-0.48006710410118103,
0.04285789653658867,
-0.4207233190536499,
0.3504737615585327,
-0.4096262454986572,
0.11937259137630463,
-0.3854829967021942,
-0.6735516786575317,
-0.25086814165115356,
0.3047525882720947,
-0.36449745297431946,
0.8451660871505737,
-0.6607773303985596,
1.0005488395690918,
0.7349874377250671,
0.22586661577224731,
-0.12492942065000534,
-0.1457306146621704,
0.07568775862455368,
-0.5835248231887817,
0.2859330177307129,
-0.1643998622894287,
-0.04696555435657501,
0.269079327583313,
-0.387898713350296,
-0.5587844252586365,
0.9880527853965759,
0.20270133018493652,
-0.9934321045875549,
-0.09113742411136627,
-0.15445394814014435,
0.18026065826416016,
-0.4059979319572449,
0.2642792761325836,
0.3959992527961731,
0.5347861647605896,
0.026792120188474655,
-0.8333923816680908,
-0.32714393734931946,
-0.2330627739429474,
0.14146345853805542,
-0.002552768914029002,
-0.7269253730773926,
0.7549251317977905,
0.14068640768527985,
0.6156103014945984,
0.22667327523231506,
0.7260996103286743,
0.1603401005268097,
-0.009000476449728012,
0.7113308310508728,
0.5998438000679016,
0.6497383117675781,
0.3934037387371063,
0.6467908620834351,
-0.2655408978462219,
0.23725774884223938,
1.2551273107528687,
0.01029909122735262,
0.9825010895729065,
0.30215445160865784,
0.025354642421007156,
0.7251434326171875,
0.4738520681858063,
0.07524745911359787,
0.37336692214012146,
-0.19375209510326385,
-0.575994610786438,
-0.5357294678688049,
0.22944550216197968,
-0.36609870195388794,
0.22993725538253784,
0.4211891293525696,
-0.25470152497291565,
0.1217772588133812,
0.14273910224437714,
0.22371453046798706,
-0.09778785705566406,
-0.32988789677619934,
0.7035930752754211,
-0.05129271745681763,
-0.3686886429786682,
0.19055995345115662,
0.20768733322620392,
0.9027811288833618,
-0.535535991191864,
-0.011048133485019207,
-0.25519245862960815,
0.10738252848386765,
-0.11439264565706253,
-0.49604561924934387,
0.13826964795589447,
-0.13159701228141785,
-0.313851535320282,
-0.024894675239920616,
0.5286435484886169,
-0.3512227237224579,
-0.6299433708190918,
0.21947576105594635,
0.3611854910850525,
-0.20163008570671082,
0.08778026700019836,
-0.7005891799926758,
0.21868301928043365,
-0.1161639392375946,
-0.5503305196762085,
0.34633418917655945,
0.31701329350471497,
0.09971757233142853,
0.796366810798645,
0.634941041469574,
0.2502578794956207,
0.22924275696277618,
-0.1257493793964386,
0.7934167981147766,
-0.5796149373054504,
-0.4276922643184662,
-1.0726960897445679,
1.0401726961135864,
-0.1133226752281189,
-0.33056655526161194,
0.5880308747291565,
0.3228754699230194,
0.5591445565223694,
-0.32427507638931274,
0.9495401382446289,
0.1491236537694931,
-0.13847509026527405,
-0.9557007551193237,
0.6015369892120361,
-0.4741284251213074,
0.23620469868183136,
-0.4155491888523102,
-1.2256014347076416,
-0.3225714862346649,
0.46030572056770325,
-0.4090639054775238,
0.00402552355080843,
0.6439148187637329,
0.9208921790122986,
-0.275270938873291,
-0.2578824460506439,
0.43765127658843994,
0.6979120969772339,
0.38267001509666443,
0.570487916469574,
0.5224307179450989,
-0.1985159069299698,
-0.036479003727436066,
-0.2597920298576355,
-0.15070585906505585,
-0.48126375675201416,
-0.9161553382873535,
-1.0615758895874023,
-0.24725769460201263,
-0.37270116806030273,
-0.03422577306628227,
0.5285413265228271,
1.0349966287612915,
0.6311759352684021,
-0.6753672957420349,
-0.0693160817027092,
-0.25175079703330994,
0.23351919651031494,
-0.06930431723594666,
-0.17205610871315002,
0.27718380093574524,
0.01821555569767952,
-0.8770361542701721,
0.720615804195404,
0.7293579578399658,
-0.22381393611431122,
-0.13398730754852295,
-0.18339386582374573,
-0.46495190262794495,
0.2716943621635437,
0.523865282535553,
-0.0450294092297554,
-0.827410101890564,
-0.38113316893577576,
-0.2103574424982071,
0.15236975252628326,
-0.010767164640128613,
0.6055179834365845,
-0.3632126450538635,
0.9264398813247681,
0.4475010633468628,
0.828755795955658,
-0.03473436087369919,
-0.04100283607840538,
0.7714433670043945,
-0.37822088599205017,
0.11748562753200531,
-0.10239261388778687,
0.5100122094154358,
0.20748648047447205,
-0.44341930747032166,
0.24769966304302216,
0.5856510400772095,
-0.9261871576309204,
-0.5792924165725708,
-0.001883986871689558,
-1.1617341041564941,
-0.231882244348526,
1.2337086200714111,
-0.2164214551448822,
-0.22082354128360748,
-0.10288539528846741,
-0.6357813477516174,
0.19369995594024658,
-0.32012939453125,
0.5474947094917297,
0.8532522320747375,
-0.0562492199242115,
-0.28973114490509033,
-0.7957698702812195,
-0.16369584202766418,
0.43282362818717957,
-0.5706470608711243,
-0.25058531761169434,
0.6098181009292603,
0.4732286036014557,
-0.2825949490070343,
0.6892478466033936,
0.31021055579185486,
0.3425143361091614,
-0.07440175861120224,
0.10448303073644638,
-0.2244086116552353,
-0.3032073974609375,
-0.38332903385162354,
0.06718528270721436,
0.23578700423240662,
0.26209256052970886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.20015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.20015v1 | ToolBeHonest: A Multi-level Hallucination Diagnostic Benchmark for Tool-Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T16:03:30 | 2024-06-28T16:03:30 | Yuxiang Zhang, Jing Chen, Junjie Wang, Yaxin Liu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Xinyu Zhu, Zihao Lin, Hanwen Wan, Yujiu Yang, Tetsuya Sakai, Tian Feng, Hayato Yamana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Tool-augmented large language models (LLMs) are rapidly being integrated into
real-world applications. Due to the lack of benchmarks, the community still
needs to fully understand the hallucination issues within these models. To
address this challenge, we introduce a comprehensive diagnostic benchmark,
ToolBH. Specifically, we assess the LLM's hallucinations through two
perspectives: depth and breadth. In terms of depth, we propose a multi-level
diagnostic process, including (1) solvability detection, (2) solution planning,
and (3) missing-tool analysis. For breadth, we consider three scenarios based
on the characteristics of the toolset: missing necessary tools, potential
tools, and limited functionality tools. Furthermore, we developed seven tasks
and collected 700 evaluation samples through multiple rounds of manual
annotation. The results show the significant challenges presented by the ToolBH
benchmark. The current advanced models Gemini-1.5-Pro and GPT-4o only achieve a
total score of 45.3 and 37.0, respectively, on a scale of 100. In this
benchmark, larger model parameters do not guarantee better performance; the
training data and response strategies also play a crucial role in tool-enhanced
LLM scenarios. Our diagnostic analysis indicates that the primary reason for
model errors lies in assessing task solvability. Additionally, open-weight
models suffer from performance drops with verbose replies, whereas proprietary
models excel with longer reasoning. | [
-0.4947895407676697,
-0.8710589408874512,
0.6180760264396667,
0.40527278184890747,
-0.357982873916626,
0.25000786781311035,
-0.25961360335350037,
-0.5954639315605164,
0.05797935649752617,
0.5524243116378784,
-0.4967215955257416,
-0.654914140701294,
-0.6080500483512878,
0.06687109917402267,
-0.6151691675186157,
0.597704291343689,
0.06903847306966782,
0.12238139659166336,
-0.1570395678281784,
0.10414732247591019,
-0.9871196746826172,
-0.4081861078739166,
-0.6257199645042419,
-0.12169063836336136,
0.28867611289024353,
0.21531851589679718,
0.6571634411811829,
0.30037468671798706,
0.5967133045196533,
0.25577104091644287,
-0.3578895926475525,
0.07798992842435837,
-0.2815305292606354,
0.4901271462440491,
0.061118148267269135,
-0.10178104788064957,
-0.7728206515312195,
-0.08593834191560745,
0.4447460174560547,
1.1385245323181152,
-0.13396187126636505,
0.13451816141605377,
-0.06373553723096848,
0.05895984172821045,
-0.5745965242385864,
-0.10951774567365646,
-0.6366606950759888,
-0.07404247671365738,
-0.1665428876876831,
0.2623681128025055,
-0.3378881514072418,
-0.3581530451774597,
-0.034195154905319214,
-0.12369094789028168,
0.269890695810318,
-0.02080785669386387,
0.5440830588340759,
0.47400256991386414,
-0.39799630641937256,
-0.3624599277973175,
-0.602562665939331,
0.6092506647109985,
-0.8583605289459229,
0.6876780390739441,
0.17229071259498596,
0.4160213768482208,
-0.29361847043037415,
-0.5415847897529602,
-0.4349606931209564,
-0.4188641309738159,
-0.047251004725694656,
0.1547083705663681,
-0.1758030652999878,
-0.10933969914913177,
0.496893048286438,
0.3718433380126953,
-0.8520265817642212,
0.2777543067932129,
-0.42082658410072327,
-0.5747639536857605,
0.5269871354103088,
0.25291356444358826,
0.02638591080904007,
-0.40127572417259216,
-0.03801429271697998,
-0.055159930139780045,
-0.3851251006126404,
-0.12832686305046082,
0.2229914367198944,
0.4344804883003235,
-0.030507538467645645,
0.4782426059246063,
0.09578152000904083,
0.6776410937309265,
-0.25863566994667053,
-0.33698055148124695,
0.2749243676662445,
-0.09339936822652817,
-0.2425602823495865,
0.16018562018871307,
0.5267587900161743,
0.06096306070685387,
0.008999315090477467,
-0.4508339464664459,
-0.4364168643951416,
0.07643046230077744,
0.37779325246810913,
-0.8979729413986206,
-0.23681558668613434,
0.6017798781394958,
-0.2969649136066437,
-0.1302039474248886,
-0.1959855854511261,
-0.5649166107177734,
-0.8731980323791504,
-0.11039820313453674,
0.5480132102966309,
-0.45940813422203064,
-0.7032031416893005,
0.20373883843421936,
-0.03534810617566109,
0.13507269322872162,
0.20981112122535706,
-0.3946424722671509,
0.40012526512145996,
0.6918461918830872,
1.0299755334854126,
-0.4655836224555969,
-0.3004709780216217,
-0.7429050207138062,
-0.046922050416469574,
-0.5380650758743286,
0.8554700016975403,
-0.49666252732276917,
-0.6867110133171082,
-0.18835636973381042,
0.16743893921375275,
0.24333171546459198,
-0.9552085399627686,
0.6144730448722839,
-0.00025947115500457585,
-0.18869681656360626,
-0.2655274569988251,
-0.3027034401893616,
-0.23257271945476532,
0.31229305267333984,
-0.6624154448509216,
1.4641505479812622,
0.18971315026283264,
-0.5192461013793945,
0.4716925024986267,
-0.36550217866897583,
-0.5391725897789001,
0.10697118937969208,
-0.05803939327597618,
-0.25119948387145996,
0.43057700991630554,
0.22526371479034424,
0.7725719809532166,
-0.39355817437171936,
0.44136497378349304,
-0.5242390632629395,
-0.6838988065719604,
-0.09888499230146408,
-0.14074896275997162,
0.8128600716590881,
-0.2143069952726364,
-0.44222214818000793,
0.311190128326416,
-0.9753794074058533,
-0.10173174738883972,
0.14650104939937592,
0.14961135387420654,
-0.2063925862312317,
-0.3356446325778961,
0.04266228899359703,
0.31841960549354553,
0.11691959947347641,
-0.4547205865383148,
0.21570275723934174,
-0.4870963394641876,
0.017101584002375603,
0.801245927810669,
-0.1851215958595276,
-0.13332095742225647,
0.05714831501245499,
0.7054686546325684,
0.3239571154117584,
0.1636769324541092,
-0.09722797572612762,
-0.27025821805000305,
-0.7596908807754517,
-0.4325394630432129,
0.1679869145154953,
0.47394028306007385,
-0.1813293993473053,
0.6039103269577026,
-0.04476579651236534,
-0.770073652267456,
-0.6974645256996155,
-0.11404405534267426,
0.16983436048030853,
0.3230817914009094,
0.43794259428977966,
-0.4363005757331848,
-0.3034259080886841,
-1.125152587890625,
-0.08509384840726852,
0.13732315599918365,
-0.08542101085186005,
0.27854108810424805,
0.5667844414710999,
-0.36200931668281555,
0.3959105312824249,
-0.2614916265010834,
-0.2984500825405121,
-0.35638341307640076,
0.2202911078929901,
0.3949735462665558,
0.09911178052425385,
0.2942926287651062,
-0.22209016978740692,
-0.07576631754636765,
0.09594041854143143,
-0.6511520147323608,
-0.25231271982192993,
-0.0406121090054512,
0.25583139061927795,
0.30076858401298523,
0.5252360701560974,
-0.5745182037353516,
0.6273479461669922,
0.695364236831665,
-0.13391654193401337,
0.980744481086731,
-0.09954764693975449,
-0.12474309653043747,
-1.0059475898742676,
0.22716565430164337,
-0.22672472894191742,
-0.17662577331066132,
-0.4105885624885559,
-0.0013726034667342901,
0.07890329509973526,
-0.1109650731086731,
-0.051810212433338165,
0.6534591317176819,
-0.47482457756996155,
-0.6663433313369751,
-0.36957553029060364,
0.6072250604629517,
-0.19449952244758606,
0.2595199644565582,
-0.05115135759115219,
0.8495959043502808,
0.7929825186729431,
-0.5375581383705139,
0.624493420124054,
-0.020408589392900467,
-0.32516181468963623,
0.5326035618782043,
-0.9687576293945312,
0.2091798037290573,
0.03589406982064247,
0.04668813198804855,
-1.2008516788482666,
-0.16942265629768372,
0.06433487683534622,
-0.3098202645778656,
0.1738465428352356,
0.08287547528743744,
-0.7578421235084534,
-0.4922029972076416,
-0.21460965275764465,
0.32832494378089905,
0.3889906406402588,
-0.43454688787460327,
0.873157262802124,
0.15158042311668396,
-0.20763562619686127,
-0.5281203985214233,
-0.3713240325450897,
0.10856727510690689,
-0.11646445095539093,
-0.6214359402656555,
0.2951433062553406,
-0.09741441905498505,
-0.2248852699995041,
-0.24683347344398499,
-0.4363658130168915,
0.18381430208683014,
0.24436227977275848,
0.530871570110321,
0.21966639161109924,
-0.12024176865816116,
0.13600406050682068,
0.1955702155828476,
-0.1000657007098198,
0.29634976387023926,
0.28708022832870483,
0.8201883435249329,
-0.24822258949279785,
-0.6065956950187683,
-0.19052456319332123,
0.10484293848276138,
0.5658140778541565,
-0.24546699225902557,
0.34983640909194946,
0.9422439932823181,
-0.41693344712257385,
-0.21804089844226837,
-0.903202474117279,
-0.48572850227355957,
-0.3888058066368103,
0.5116795301437378,
-0.6861016154289246,
-0.5498070120811462,
0.8053813576698303,
-0.3178917467594147,
0.03246289864182472,
0.21254169940948486,
0.735371470451355,
0.26322561502456665,
1.117905855178833,
0.507165789604187,
0.00903957150876522,
-0.2760586738586426,
-0.126842200756073,
0.5164042115211487,
-0.9110208749771118,
-0.32999974489212036,
-0.4611204266548157,
-0.20361651480197906,
-0.4486330449581146,
-0.2651612460613251,
0.4472874402999878,
0.2880812883377075,
-0.044703803956508636,
0.28603193163871765,
-0.53975510597229,
0.2623392939567566,
0.2626659870147705,
-0.13945263624191284,
0.3302491307258606,
-0.41658201813697815,
-0.47094428539276123,
-0.06821978837251663,
-0.4715632498264313,
-0.45352211594581604,
0.8885625004768372,
0.2635246515274048,
0.3836323618888855,
0.07069569081068039,
0.6682808995246887,
0.12078547477722168,
0.05919019505381584,
-1.0220431089401245,
0.7956333756446838,
0.14811097085475922,
-0.6547277569770813,
-0.33715808391571045,
-0.07914359867572784,
-0.8682875633239746,
0.4386024475097656,
0.05680622532963753,
-0.9970690608024597,
0.021731404587626457,
-0.09895947575569153,
-0.26758596301078796,
0.05189487710595131,
-0.4823375940322876,
1.137709140777588,
-0.2870921492576599,
-0.3146689534187317,
-0.2874473035335541,
-0.5582041144371033,
0.5756123065948486,
-0.3553480803966522,
0.27057945728302,
-0.32539477944374084,
0.01829814538359642,
0.44523710012435913,
-0.10699694603681564,
0.6426776051521301,
-0.14227645099163055,
-0.30555596947669983,
-0.3622751235961914,
0.4982116222381592,
0.550427258014679,
-0.008330710232257843,
-0.09217718988656998,
0.09802856296300888,
0.10283417999744415,
-0.3081352114677429,
-0.4025663137435913,
0.5952098369598389,
-0.46978309750556946,
-0.6580957770347595,
-0.4214611351490021,
-0.6237384676933289,
-0.5936155319213867,
0.34480980038642883,
-0.06223394721746445,
0.5399224162101746,
-0.09406311810016632,
0.11206603795289993,
0.4913460612297058,
-0.5244439244270325,
0.3080095648765564,
0.268443763256073,
-0.7113294005393982,
0.03055373951792717,
0.7580928206443787,
-0.08270201832056046,
0.10480867326259613,
-0.35529205203056335,
0.029826872050762177,
-0.16366079449653625,
-0.9157406091690063,
-0.3350321054458618,
0.42789241671562195,
-0.76990807056427,
-0.12230969220399857,
-0.6665271520614624,
-0.3225995898246765,
-0.47681447863578796,
0.10848928242921829,
-0.5462254285812378,
-0.10007453709840775,
0.00598271144554019,
-0.09079762548208237,
0.1554097831249237,
0.8379649519920349,
-0.07678154110908508,
0.15461795032024384,
-0.5710157752037048,
0.386526495218277,
-0.0411708690226078,
0.3949050009250641,
0.23403409123420715,
-0.5722675323486328,
-0.15348604321479797,
-0.1671869456768036,
-0.24779613316059113,
-0.8166567087173462,
0.20791001617908478,
-0.26642104983329773,
0.6133610606193542,
0.29446402192115784,
0.06784262508153915,
0.9202299118041992,
-0.1897936314344406,
0.7986093163490295,
-0.09041497111320496,
-1.155678629875183,
0.4709993004798889,
-0.15224216878414154,
0.3973456025123596,
0.17827387154102325,
0.44263532757759094,
-0.5414888262748718,
-0.8497494459152222,
-0.42367109656333923,
-0.8481305837631226,
0.563366711139679,
-0.14049898087978363,
-0.11593800038099289,
0.09298227727413177,
0.19774192571640015,
0.574714183807373,
0.03084077127277851,
-0.5979537963867188,
0.043236006051301956,
-0.1760828197002411,
0.21127860248088837,
0.046338967978954315,
-0.1268594115972519,
0.09332767874002457,
-0.4892142415046692,
0.6065546870231628,
-0.045892708003520966,
0.0037249501328915358,
-0.07722299546003342,
-0.3486805260181427,
0.14756625890731812,
0.16436393558979034,
0.5020700693130493,
1.053605079650879,
-0.39967137575149536,
0.046448931097984314,
0.43832486867904663,
-0.4101014733314514,
-0.10783087462186813,
0.3027310371398926,
0.397159606218338,
0.18707706034183502,
0.5416584014892578,
0.8308559656143188,
0.26790791749954224,
-0.881187915802002,
0.6105188131332397,
0.1367119401693344,
-0.1900130808353424,
-0.32634076476097107,
-0.06580418348312378,
0.28920307755470276,
0.4578980803489685,
0.3188110291957855,
-0.2555578947067261,
0.43147096037864685,
-0.47242626547813416,
-0.00798035878688097,
0.7039665579795837,
-0.3471218943595886,
-0.3850717842578888,
0.49264955520629883,
-0.052550241351127625,
-0.25520819425582886,
0.7256795167922974,
-0.3741229176521301,
-0.5094534158706665,
0.40871551632881165,
0.4513132572174072,
0.907904863357544,
-0.22680675983428955,
0.22852274775505066,
0.3827626407146454,
0.586562991142273,
0.06596068292856216,
0.3893500864505768,
0.1962754726409912,
-0.4841136336326599,
-0.5423532724380493,
-0.650088369846344,
-0.30588051676750183,
0.5198045372962952,
-0.7428856492042542,
0.4879394769668579,
-0.3812845051288605,
-0.20715585350990295,
0.1808755099773407,
0.0017038827063515782,
-0.585675060749054,
0.19026361405849457,
-0.11281745880842209,
0.7710708379745483,
-0.6180535554885864,
0.7307983636856079,
0.3855666518211365,
-0.2955959439277649,
-0.7289851307868958,
0.16519038379192352,
0.018803488463163376,
-0.9310017824172974,
0.5203120708465576,
0.4180030822753906,
-0.22815625369548798,
-0.06405780464410782,
-0.12972711026668549,
-0.6068030595779419,
1.0189915895462036,
0.3370110094547272,
-0.5687156319618225,
-0.04314529895782471,
-0.07514588534832001,
0.5336642861366272,
-0.11838428676128387,
0.33918118476867676,
0.9313313364982605,
0.6480265855789185,
0.05432109907269478,
-1.274830937385559,
0.4094439148902893,
0.0522218719124794,
0.012897360138595104,
0.28605860471725464,
-0.309994637966156,
0.6447442770004272,
-0.30637821555137634,
-0.21474389731884003,
0.14370283484458923,
0.15415658056735992,
0.37119147181510925,
0.07903085649013519,
0.5359005928039551,
0.520361065864563,
0.7051146030426025,
-0.20167039334774017,
0.8451316952705383,
-0.3571721315383911,
-0.07929367572069168,
0.8671149611473083,
-0.467325896024704,
0.9144673347473145,
0.3463459610939026,
-0.08318343013525009,
0.20561353862285614,
0.757553219795227,
-0.16400814056396484,
0.16232675313949585,
0.33936169743537903,
0.11513122171163559,
-0.46661099791526794,
-0.18479564785957336,
-0.5550040602684021,
0.6108661890029907,
0.2755877673625946,
0.014124236069619656,
-0.17919912934303284,
0.142934188246727,
-0.20191547274589539,
-0.27745458483695984,
-0.09221756458282471,
0.7704071998596191,
-0.09505697339773178,
-0.3894752860069275,
0.8007399439811707,
-0.215581476688385,
0.4919540286064148,
-0.36016133427619934,
0.07274143397808075,
-0.4056958854198456,
0.16827350854873657,
-0.13819658756256104,
-0.530016303062439,
0.33851158618927,
-0.269577294588089,
0.10848288983106613,
0.1660243719816208,
0.5767290592193604,
-0.15201765298843384,
-0.5846120715141296,
0.6688804626464844,
0.7714280486106873,
0.6002475619316101,
-0.2915256917476654,
-0.5820715427398682,
0.6392765045166016,
-0.41010400652885437,
-0.21614912152290344,
0.07111778110265732,
0.5148855447769165,
-0.061561524868011475,
0.6524661779403687,
0.24111230671405792,
0.26656022667884827,
-0.0363299585878849,
0.45733192563056946,
0.8291069865226746,
-0.7197471857070923,
0.07107473164796829,
-0.7715687155723572,
0.5944342017173767,
-0.28424859046936035,
-0.3774776756763458,
0.7740832567214966,
0.6892067790031433,
0.7681223154067993,
0.09542131423950195,
0.707486093044281,
0.17628489434719086,
0.7679076790809631,
-0.3454958200454712,
0.4600207209587097,
-0.9922048449516296,
0.421156644821167,
-0.481109619140625,
-1.2210314273834229,
-0.2874605059623718,
0.4528788626194,
-0.19797258079051971,
0.2745606303215027,
1.0195006132125854,
0.9700360298156738,
-0.18890380859375,
-0.00825154222548008,
0.5404740571975708,
0.48166826367378235,
0.17918488383293152,
0.36098921298980713,
0.8957002758979797,
-0.20791029930114746,
0.6269997358322144,
-0.34908899664878845,
-0.23518042266368866,
-0.36600619554519653,
-0.7781104445457458,
-1.1721057891845703,
-0.6693392395973206,
-0.16112519800662994,
-0.2668529152870178,
0.06529252231121063,
0.7356081008911133,
0.6700876355171204,
-0.802409827709198,
-0.40164753794670105,
0.11675600707530975,
0.009535752236843109,
-0.3263375759124756,
-0.1964600831270218,
0.37365540862083435,
-0.362511545419693,
-0.5178499817848206,
0.3257310390472412,
0.5734113454818726,
-0.021985232830047607,
-0.7478852868080139,
0.12235777825117111,
0.21706928312778473,
-0.17316454648971558,
0.7885714173316956,
-0.30921459197998047,
-1.2757989168167114,
-0.26901036500930786,
0.1960381120443344,
0.1318124681711197,
-0.18977592885494232,
0.8342993855476379,
-0.6898539066314697,
0.4134874641895294,
-0.06068074703216553,
0.7087056040763855,
0.5581845641136169,
-0.37804141640663147,
0.43569138646125793,
-0.5618588328361511,
0.27019086480140686,
0.5191238522529602,
0.25352180004119873,
0.41028299927711487,
-0.02888568863272667,
0.5537209510803223,
0.07827191054821014,
-0.4126685559749603,
-1.3963578939437866,
0.1847219169139862,
-1.1277576684951782,
-0.5570254921913147,
0.9839529395103455,
0.21104173362255096,
0.14957505464553833,
-0.2759037911891937,
-0.339948445558548,
0.057413022965192795,
-0.1664607971906662,
0.9791514277458191,
1.0810189247131348,
-0.09934844821691513,
-0.2604789733886719,
-0.7172378897666931,
0.31243300437927246,
0.39641591906547546,
-0.8374592661857605,
0.3533426523208618,
0.6458460688591003,
0.03577161207795143,
0.05073702335357666,
0.3063802123069763,
0.04888409003615379,
0.34123557806015015,
0.1550295501947403,
0.04480346292257309,
-0.15314584970474243,
-0.4453083872795105,
-0.11104267835617065,
0.11834946274757385,
0.20931516587734222,
0.2166619449853897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19999v1 | The SIFo Benchmark: Investigating the Sequential Instruction Following Ability of Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 | 2024-06-28T15:34:26 | Xinyi Chen, Baohao Liao, Jirui Qi, Panagiotis Eustratiadis, Christof Monz, Arianna Bisazza, Maarten de Rijke | cs.CL | cs.CL | Following multiple instructions is a crucial ability for large language
models (LLMs). Evaluating this ability comes with significant challenges: (i)
limited coherence between multiple instructions, (ii) positional bias where the
order of instructions affects model performance, and (iii) a lack of
objectively verifiable tasks. To address these issues, we introduce a benchmark
designed to evaluate models' abilities to follow multiple instructions through
sequential instruction following (SIFo) tasks. In SIFo, the successful
completion of multiple instructions is verifiable by examining only the final
instruction. Our benchmark evaluates instruction following using four tasks
(text modification, question answering, mathematics, and security rule
following), each assessing different aspects of sequential instruction
following. Our evaluation of popular LLMs, both closed-source and open-source,
shows that more recent and larger models significantly outperform their older
and smaller counterparts on the SIFo tasks, validating the benchmark's
effectiveness. All models struggle with following sequences of instructions,
hinting at an important lack of robustness of today's language models. | [
-0.050657037645578384,
-0.40988689661026,
0.7079064846038818,
0.5851567387580872,
0.11989261209964752,
0.09336293488740921,
-0.02029288560152054,
-0.3956197202205658,
-0.4159327447414398,
0.7400009036064148,
-0.6260660290718079,
-0.5428303480148315,
-0.841264545917511,
0.35769152641296387,
-0.44404926896095276,
0.7901490330696106,
-0.21570919454097748,
0.1407870650291443,
-0.23023907840251923,
-0.09194457530975342,
-0.6772529482841492,
-0.3530062139034271,
-0.5395486950874329,
-0.3448917269706726,
0.43537870049476624,
0.414559543132782,
0.4942258298397064,
0.7680729031562805,
0.7164782881736755,
0.3580716550350189,
0.005442106164991856,
0.12280835211277008,
-0.660313069820404,
0.20482319593429565,
0.07434329390525818,
-0.3730337917804718,
-0.3084205985069275,
0.09646957367658615,
1.2179590463638306,
0.6980876922607422,
0.08690374344587326,
0.3426991403102875,
0.09659866988658905,
0.5242389440536499,
-0.5306016206741333,
0.19729384779930115,
-0.4974936246871948,
0.0001666863536229357,
-0.22122853994369507,
-0.014505630359053612,
-0.6853026151657104,
-0.6335778832435608,
0.20292598009109497,
-0.2676842510700226,
-0.171022430062294,
0.13969194889068604,
0.47596073150634766,
0.34499940276145935,
-0.4922809898853302,
-0.3490374684333801,
-0.5497145056724548,
0.6479230523109436,
-0.7684853076934814,
0.751663327217102,
0.47066599130630493,
0.1429985761642456,
-0.2945822775363922,
-0.6932082772254944,
-0.25452297925949097,
-0.5125744938850403,
0.03761176019906998,
-0.11266755312681198,
0.14912113547325134,
-0.1372915804386139,
0.7222093939781189,
0.04426771029829979,
-0.3877284526824951,
0.0029154105577617884,
-0.4800516664981842,
-0.05211281031370163,
0.36037737131118774,
0.17994725704193115,
0.2373933345079422,
0.255952388048172,
-0.7932974100112915,
-0.23666009306907654,
-0.8651518821716309,
0.18826472759246826,
0.3667815029621124,
-0.10563702881336212,
-0.13534192740917206,
0.5726127028465271,
-0.2502424120903015,
0.5954688787460327,
-0.09411148726940155,
-0.3431043326854706,
0.442096084356308,
-0.6042885780334473,
-0.1901252418756485,
0.018295548856258392,
0.6763766407966614,
0.2090272158384323,
0.16912095248699188,
-0.23566943407058716,
-0.24086304008960724,
-0.4029783010482788,
0.18141593039035797,
-0.9175941348075867,
0.09968435019254684,
-0.022503674030303955,
-0.293992280960083,
0.01948562264442444,
-0.04279622063040733,
-0.47246983647346497,
-0.3417242765426636,
-0.10940374433994293,
0.38292092084884644,
-0.48135143518447876,
0.11549154669046402,
-0.16809365153312683,
-0.053286463022232056,
0.45448365807533264,
0.22718489170074463,
-0.9244745373725891,
0.5586512684822083,
1.239973783493042,
0.9089275002479553,
-0.2750839591026306,
-0.7843937873840332,
-0.8111526370048523,
0.1588994711637497,
-0.506670355796814,
0.7438119053840637,
-0.8931178450584412,
-0.40352484583854675,
-0.44157716631889343,
0.24379892647266388,
-0.39326199889183044,
-0.3008514642715454,
0.41584399342536926,
-0.4947085380554199,
-0.09994683414697647,
-0.39496666193008423,
-0.8681426644325256,
-0.25187185406684875,
0.13285993039608002,
-0.675294816493988,
1.054844856262207,
-0.12552832067012787,
-0.4613012373447418,
0.1670500636100769,
-0.20768077671527863,
-0.43051841855049133,
-0.0955640971660614,
-0.4051862955093384,
-0.13189300894737244,
0.17449569702148438,
-0.227639302611351,
0.39686092734336853,
-0.3635769486427307,
-0.08370302617549896,
-0.6924517750740051,
-0.8305875062942505,
0.08271811157464981,
-0.4962764084339142,
0.6934088468551636,
-0.28150853514671326,
-0.40209195017814636,
0.05666979029774666,
-0.9046983122825623,
0.024203097447752953,
-0.07624123990535736,
-0.20785613358020782,
-0.3406941294670105,
0.13585633039474487,
-0.6571244597434998,
-0.015165017917752266,
0.3388442397117615,
-0.21768957376480103,
0.13819357752799988,
-0.18104612827301025,
0.20292995870113373,
1.0248256921768188,
0.11310622096061707,
0.3133932054042816,
-0.27114465832710266,
0.4298723638057709,
-0.43149304389953613,
-0.003426841925829649,
-0.6318683624267578,
-0.7039588093757629,
-0.39465707540512085,
-0.16036751866340637,
0.1584993451833725,
0.7285372614860535,
-0.1159672811627388,
-0.12095735967159271,
-0.10606052726507187,
-0.6289843320846558,
-0.40176281332969666,
0.39124277234077454,
0.6021245718002319,
0.5408855080604553,
0.059172824025154114,
-0.37907761335372925,
-0.2525957524776459,
-0.6960002779960632,
-0.07506471872329712,
-0.1452402025461197,
0.1942431777715683,
0.1064881980419159,
0.706142246723175,
-0.09366557747125626,
0.05672949180006981,
-0.20158439874649048,
0.2674805819988251,
0.42158231139183044,
0.4162899851799011,
0.1859763264656067,
0.4736100435256958,
0.24578848481178284,
-0.6163037419319153,
-0.5461399555206299,
0.011943195015192032,
-0.684164822101593,
-0.1273018717765808,
-0.005726938135921955,
-0.038982514292001724,
0.08669263869524002,
0.7062833905220032,
-0.21091172099113464,
0.39877796173095703,
0.6488659381866455,
-0.1838727742433548,
0.6637455821037292,
-0.25432005524635315,
0.5048236846923828,
-0.5897105932235718,
0.14729167520999908,
-0.2531105577945709,
-0.1435561627149582,
-0.597550630569458,
0.20997127890586853,
0.20131689310073853,
-0.02893196791410446,
-0.3019503355026245,
0.44945448637008667,
-0.6798287630081177,
-0.5839033126831055,
-0.24648456275463104,
-0.13138486444950104,
-0.04644104093313217,
0.32909008860588074,
0.04676580801606178,
1.1007905006408691,
0.5503205060958862,
-0.4166596531867981,
0.23255616426467896,
-0.09589575976133347,
-0.5894652009010315,
0.28805801272392273,
-0.9161554574966431,
0.4569299519062042,
-0.03182563558220863,
0.032871127128601074,
-1.2787894010543823,
-0.006584466900676489,
0.08039279282093048,
-0.09918252378702164,
0.05895296111702919,
-0.2130173146724701,
-0.6180768609046936,
-0.35395559668540955,
-0.3336699306964874,
0.3051280081272125,
0.444034218788147,
-0.1908552199602127,
0.5498638153076172,
-0.08890384435653687,
-0.25401055812835693,
-0.8883739709854126,
-0.4849735200405121,
-0.28959065675735474,
0.029255570843815804,
-0.6009534597396851,
0.435437947511673,
-0.35866132378578186,
-0.17699721455574036,
-0.1251995861530304,
-0.3407670259475708,
0.007357808295637369,
0.23285630345344543,
0.3851011395454407,
0.2674267292022705,
-0.3896290361881256,
-0.29505884647369385,
-0.2597016990184784,
-0.04813818633556366,
0.0917062759399414,
-0.014593061059713364,
0.4129299223423004,
-0.22622859477996826,
-0.6126198768615723,
-0.6113355755805969,
0.2975689470767975,
0.7354103922843933,
-0.23564513027668,
0.6954846382141113,
0.445583701133728,
-0.39936399459838867,
-0.07623409479856491,
-0.6847928762435913,
-0.06114564090967178,
-0.43640875816345215,
0.2226765900850296,
-0.562781035900116,
-0.7037126421928406,
0.6057617664337158,
-0.049597956240177155,
0.4058206081390381,
0.07639312744140625,
0.44981613755226135,
0.01905110850930214,
1.0426627397537231,
0.6802939772605896,
0.025979889556765556,
0.4665098488330841,
0.15027038753032684,
-0.010999880731105804,
-0.7874261140823364,
-0.15559430420398712,
-0.6148785948753357,
-0.012730295769870281,
-0.5744695067405701,
-0.5281219482421875,
0.26816022396087646,
0.3693685531616211,
-0.3743390440940857,
0.6576532125473022,
-0.11001886427402496,
0.5727510452270508,
0.7550575733184814,
-0.030838793143630028,
0.31264856457710266,
-0.19313757121562958,
-0.33716288208961487,
0.3248714804649353,
-0.36758044362068176,
-0.6775848269462585,
0.9737911820411682,
0.5319696664810181,
0.6920602321624756,
0.17253486812114716,
0.7356090545654297,
0.32882946729660034,
0.3386801779270172,
-0.3961186110973358,
0.7915395498275757,
-0.29363882541656494,
-0.3387656807899475,
-0.25979238748550415,
-0.4558389484882355,
-0.48606744408607483,
0.329778790473938,
-0.023511826992034912,
-1.1758577823638916,
-0.02518109232187271,
0.060126982629299164,
-0.46848660707473755,
-0.14883461594581604,
-0.7987178564071655,
0.9943729043006897,
-0.2832467555999756,
-0.5538772940635681,
-0.2420138269662857,
-0.5314204692840576,
0.4733753800392151,
-0.13252930343151093,
0.10652010887861252,
-0.3842657506465912,
-0.34456318616867065,
0.632448673248291,
-0.2786041796207428,
0.7718430757522583,
0.15937890112400055,
-0.07917908579111099,
0.051883332431316376,
-0.12114691734313965,
0.6943643093109131,
-0.2696759104728699,
-0.3385031819343567,
-0.07085781544446945,
0.3097831904888153,
-0.2789176106452942,
-0.42918047308921814,
0.8894892930984497,
-0.5563140511512756,
-0.7809980511665344,
-0.3659366965293884,
-0.24330538511276245,
-0.38343319296836853,
0.49967822432518005,
0.01930118538439274,
0.5283197164535522,
-0.15639279782772064,
0.15772971510887146,
0.7143043875694275,
0.015041171573102474,
0.36317911744117737,
0.5533881783485413,
-0.01721358485519886,
-0.34497877955436707,
0.6657535433769226,
0.18905282020568848,
0.396571546792984,
0.38488325476646423,
0.13043968379497528,
-0.31739988923072815,
-0.6194202899932861,
-0.636699914932251,
0.17636917531490326,
-0.8336149454116821,
0.11970901489257812,
-0.45566847920417786,
-0.20110546052455902,
-0.5662120580673218,
0.07029460370540619,
-0.2532905042171478,
0.019103005528450012,
-0.13865068554878235,
0.20392660796642303,
-0.14616519212722778,
1.0113654136657715,
0.3156782388687134,
0.26277482509613037,
-0.8808279633522034,
0.26945731043815613,
0.3191843032836914,
0.5108927488327026,
0.2618653178215027,
-0.5927984118461609,
0.11943985521793365,
-0.25065505504608154,
-0.1174730658531189,
-1.1200629472732544,
-0.24684476852416992,
-0.10176495462656021,
0.8305391669273376,
0.37356996536254883,
-0.3004753589630127,
0.8057025671005249,
-1.0577670335769653,
0.508865475654602,
0.11980294436216354,
-0.8570690751075745,
0.35921716690063477,
-0.03279159963130951,
0.5075777769088745,
0.596137523651123,
0.6674143671989441,
-0.23065711557865143,
-0.3729446530342102,
-0.32165709137916565,
-0.5644846558570862,
0.7389078736305237,
0.04229232668876648,
-0.0824408084154129,
-0.04605444520711899,
0.18257085978984833,
0.1666886955499649,
0.2500135898590088,
-0.5397030115127563,
-0.12284106761217117,
0.29171282052993774,
-0.04514923319220543,
0.10320203751325607,
-0.3151305019855499,
0.024127164855599403,
0.2353644073009491,
0.7254381775856018,
0.009529347531497478,
0.19343630969524384,
-0.14547476172447205,
-0.027268875390291214,
0.020619984716176987,
0.16645930707454681,
0.9235365390777588,
0.7273053526878357,
-0.23371976613998413,
0.04838284105062485,
0.31261178851127625,
-0.2908969223499298,
0.025847312062978745,
0.4216715395450592,
-0.34929677844047546,
-0.204492449760437,
0.5734526515007019,
0.8979076743125916,
0.6097259521484375,
-0.765252947807312,
0.49445652961730957,
-0.05469081178307533,
0.08372797071933746,
-0.36772841215133667,
0.3162246346473694,
0.1336253136396408,
0.539737343788147,
0.46394768357276917,
0.10044140368700027,
0.26418066024780273,
-0.7208254337310791,
0.27739274501800537,
0.34706324338912964,
-0.17611338198184967,
-0.28499722480773926,
0.44657737016677856,
-0.1260426640510559,
-0.4538995027542114,
0.3802822530269623,
-0.015343724749982357,
-0.4096428453922272,
0.7548084259033203,
0.5615177154541016,
0.537237286567688,
-0.29024890065193176,
0.026332151144742966,
0.36500224471092224,
0.38752812147140503,
-0.6638201475143433,
0.28175729513168335,
-0.2508576512336731,
-0.44685840606689453,
-0.5504737496376038,
-0.3953077793121338,
-0.7061699628829956,
-0.038790322840213776,
-0.662621259689331,
0.2553391456604004,
-0.7265441417694092,
-0.10308925807476044,
0.328085720539093,
-0.053731970489025116,
-0.7202211022377014,
-0.04790849983692169,
0.3075332045555115,
1.1737074851989746,
-0.5780837535858154,
0.7092685103416443,
0.5292778611183167,
-0.23608262836933136,
-0.6404712200164795,
0.024645023047924042,
0.31414109468460083,
-1.0341472625732422,
0.5707727074623108,
0.6670772433280945,
-0.4467642307281494,
-0.14344848692417145,
-0.380331814289093,
-1.030073642730713,
1.107197880744934,
0.30734381079673767,
-0.7846509218215942,
-0.19416873157024384,
-0.15145115554332733,
0.35312336683273315,
-0.5402088761329651,
0.4760422110557556,
0.4869287312030792,
0.316711962223053,
0.28103014826774597,
-0.8357112407684326,
0.10537794232368469,
-0.10263275355100632,
-0.02819647453725338,
0.07170871645212173,
-0.9384931921958923,
0.5824682712554932,
-0.36369195580482483,
-0.27760249376296997,
0.5315059423446655,
0.7824561595916748,
0.4786504805088043,
0.34955257177352905,
0.6063233613967896,
0.31534892320632935,
0.9084686636924744,
0.04221642389893532,
0.9255090355873108,
-0.48771870136260986,
-0.02416052296757698,
1.6331158876419067,
-0.7680087089538574,
1.2990976572036743,
0.2502347230911255,
0.034781984984874725,
0.5450214147567749,
0.3814508616924286,
-0.19753076136112213,
0.562132716178894,
0.1470729112625122,
-0.17897768318653107,
-0.06847017258405685,
0.08010036498308182,
-0.43593382835388184,
0.37419694662094116,
0.1778803914785385,
-0.5785961747169495,
-0.00015560592873953283,
-0.0815221294760704,
-0.02428857982158661,
-0.07724262773990631,
-0.3085569441318512,
0.715558648109436,
-0.016475288197398186,
-1.0374375581741333,
0.4422406852245331,
-0.084560826420784,
0.18159250915050507,
-0.6972131133079529,
-0.407311350107193,
-0.04953427240252495,
0.1742396354675293,
0.13935916125774384,
-0.8998555541038513,
0.11207567155361176,
0.22140611708164215,
-0.1368187665939331,
-0.3535831868648529,
0.6435386538505554,
-0.24174031615257263,
-0.46920245885849,
0.5210500955581665,
0.21802949905395508,
0.29301875829696655,
0.40329042077064514,
-0.7474170327186584,
0.6447368264198303,
-0.09586697816848755,
-0.38236692547798157,
0.0964113101363182,
0.31976747512817383,
-0.10061201453208923,
0.8191185593605042,
0.401714950799942,
-0.024419685825705528,
0.2614874839782715,
0.2140650451183319,
0.45678818225860596,
-0.6351075768470764,
-0.17621052265167236,
-0.8916528820991516,
0.14237387478351593,
-0.18006806075572968,
-0.3485187590122223,
0.9486676454544067,
0.45481589436531067,
1.1190829277038574,
0.22718052566051483,
0.49115362763404846,
0.17412924766540527,
0.4077907204627991,
-0.566746711730957,
0.2301183044910431,
-0.371508926153183,
0.47246623039245605,
-0.1729542762041092,
-0.8010619878768921,
0.11255986988544464,
0.5040546655654907,
-0.47952598333358765,
0.07249806076288223,
0.6746209263801575,
0.7949270009994507,
-0.03209834173321724,
0.39291679859161377,
0.3230561316013336,
0.32189565896987915,
-0.18925698101520538,
0.5994892120361328,
0.8432536125183105,
-0.4022339880466461,
0.4576297700405121,
-0.2553366422653198,
-0.3249322772026062,
-0.011851765215396881,
-1.0147887468338013,
-1.0308504104614258,
-0.39787113666534424,
-0.2504429817199707,
-0.2384997010231018,
0.3183872699737549,
0.9585461020469666,
0.8322238326072693,
-0.9806758761405945,
-0.27392634749412537,
-0.005755971185863018,
0.2514120042324066,
-0.6134576797485352,
-0.10224287211894989,
0.19133298099040985,
-0.26101312041282654,
-0.7838732004165649,
0.7418824434280396,
0.3983083665370941,
0.06521999835968018,
-0.290704607963562,
-0.03880646824836731,
-0.3113250434398651,
0.1194281354546547,
0.552761971950531,
0.33336588740348816,
-0.7620384097099304,
-0.45604586601257324,
0.2677578032016754,
-0.4044656455516815,
-0.19083437323570251,
0.6090942025184631,
-0.3694453537464142,
0.31948530673980713,
0.6577081084251404,
0.8647983074188232,
0.49865055084228516,
-0.0225764699280262,
0.6401088833808899,
-0.3854328691959381,
-0.3624948263168335,
-0.04923215135931969,
0.5171690583229065,
0.24122029542922974,
-0.1953594833612442,
0.6154534220695496,
0.1029178574681282,
-0.550723135471344,
-0.9358969926834106,
0.03013252653181553,
-0.7349529266357422,
-0.05899694189429283,
0.9085618853569031,
-0.6124597787857056,
-0.3034592568874359,
0.22937573492527008,
0.19710446894168854,
-0.12410563230514526,
-0.28704649209976196,
0.26470044255256653,
1.0766476392745972,
-0.174544095993042,
-0.4935785233974457,
-0.8112511038780212,
0.12288033217191696,
0.4654270112514496,
-0.5005404949188232,
0.0962144061923027,
0.4497806131839752,
0.49277445673942566,
0.10818709433078766,
0.9231571555137634,
-0.03572358191013336,
0.436372309923172,
0.1823357492685318,
-0.5415257215499878,
0.03823971375823021,
-0.6350938677787781,
-0.23044618964195251,
0.35399314761161804,
-0.05037092790007591,
-0.17573809623718262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19995v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19995v1 | Single Parent Family: A Spectrum of Family Members from a Single Pre-Trained Foundation Model | 2024-06-28T15:27:57 | 2024-06-28T15:27:57 | Habib Hajimolahoseini, Mohammad Hassanpour, Foozhan Ataiefard, Boxing Chen, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper introduces a novel method of Progressive Low Rank Decomposition
(PLRD) tailored for the compression of large language models. Our approach
leverages a pre-trained model, which is then incrementally decompressed to
smaller sizes using progressively lower ranks. This method allows for
significant reductions in computational overhead and energy consumption, as
subsequent models are derived from the original without the need for retraining
from scratch. We detail the implementation of PLRD, which strategically
decreases the tensor ranks, thus optimizing the trade-off between model
performance and resource usage. The efficacy of PLRD is demonstrated through
extensive experiments showing that models trained with PLRD method on only 1B
tokens maintain comparable performance with traditionally trained models while
using 0.1% of the tokens. The versatility of PLRD is highlighted by its ability
to generate multiple model sizes from a single foundational model, adapting
fluidly to varying computational and memory budgets. Our findings suggest that
PLRD could set a new standard for the efficient scaling of LLMs, making
advanced AI more feasible on diverse platforms. | [
-0.5231900811195374,
-0.5549328923225403,
-0.05393487587571144,
0.043829165399074554,
-0.2705175280570984,
0.43083274364471436,
-0.43328624963760376,
0.17875586450099945,
0.015406381338834763,
0.5559820532798767,
-0.7196782827377319,
-0.4279983639717102,
-0.6496996879577637,
-0.0838024839758873,
-0.28371018171310425,
0.8135673403739929,
0.2523333728313446,
-0.06893425434827805,
-0.14590945839881897,
-0.16682805120944977,
0.11493593454360962,
-0.6647368669509888,
-1.1025551557540894,
-0.3533102571964264,
0.2878216803073883,
0.5192802548408508,
0.7800207734107971,
0.7802838087081909,
0.5894715785980225,
0.2906947433948517,
-0.3606504797935486,
-0.12277749925851822,
-1.2163317203521729,
0.2854849100112915,
0.27502012252807617,
-0.184382364153862,
-0.7572072744369507,
-0.021077243611216545,
0.9890872836112976,
1.1852480173110962,
-0.17775341868400574,
0.4534919857978821,
0.10013896226882935,
0.8336079716682434,
-0.5063883662223816,
0.03285740315914154,
-0.3694717288017273,
0.1626618206501007,
0.007529923226684332,
-0.198941171169281,
-0.6269623041152954,
-0.13886293768882751,
-0.07625526189804077,
-0.44347622990608215,
0.45788636803627014,
-0.2565918564796448,
0.5479654669761658,
0.505593478679657,
-0.21706584095954895,
0.11626619100570679,
-0.6860949397087097,
0.7251604199409485,
-0.3902389109134674,
0.5225152969360352,
0.17976117134094238,
0.07146637886762619,
-0.19125759601593018,
-0.9540813565254211,
-0.38874614238739014,
-0.1302601397037506,
0.0022282651625573635,
-0.2683250904083252,
-0.16400088369846344,
0.36108115315437317,
0.14642123878002167,
0.7634246349334717,
-0.5495519638061523,
0.2845200300216675,
-0.44540366530418396,
-0.06843139976263046,
0.4263186752796173,
0.06434903293848038,
0.3158390522003174,
0.09183787554502487,
-0.322803258895874,
-0.011540970765054226,
-1.1543083190917969,
0.06261418759822845,
0.5071029663085938,
0.48889172077178955,
-0.20705914497375488,
0.4806441366672516,
-0.1564016342163086,
0.5574761033058167,
0.09938079863786697,
-0.5820809006690979,
0.04036545380949974,
-0.43246394395828247,
-0.17204654216766357,
-0.07519324868917465,
0.6278518438339233,
-0.09509579092264175,
0.20149631798267365,
-0.21755686402320862,
-0.05565304681658745,
0.33024752140045166,
-0.09890644252300262,
-1.0852729082107544,
-0.43460890650749207,
0.015838511288166046,
-0.8888464570045471,
-0.41702428460121155,
-0.37993955612182617,
-0.9223951101303101,
-0.4345478415489197,
-0.20460282266139984,
0.15507502853870392,
-0.2785666286945343,
-0.46871498227119446,
0.15615469217300415,
0.04757493734359741,
0.17357192933559418,
0.25382038950920105,
-0.8696706295013428,
0.5869243144989014,
0.7927955389022827,
0.8543047308921814,
-0.1047540009021759,
-0.1651133894920349,
-0.7356177568435669,
-0.07651275396347046,
-0.13253174722194672,
0.408236026763916,
-0.5510202646255493,
-0.8426839709281921,
-0.2714186906814575,
-0.3834667205810547,
-0.0937090590596199,
-0.6309729814529419,
0.38368546962738037,
-0.3211771249771118,
0.0364425852894783,
0.20720164477825165,
-0.3144085109233856,
0.09143084287643433,
0.09347701072692871,
-0.790155827999115,
0.9007596373558044,
0.36126992106437683,
-0.7716814875602722,
0.10841924697160721,
-0.7660317420959473,
-0.6202142834663391,
0.13164761662483215,
0.02103479579091072,
-0.5482266545295715,
0.31138625741004944,
0.1547323614358902,
0.4570147693157196,
-0.3434385359287262,
-0.003302603494375944,
-0.23743879795074463,
-0.31671783328056335,
-0.4384739100933075,
-0.2780809998512268,
0.9247546792030334,
0.22552958130836487,
-0.13543322682380676,
0.08103761076927185,
-0.90589839220047,
-0.04688408225774765,
0.17269334197044373,
-0.6597296595573425,
-0.1422206312417984,
-0.04160015285015106,
-0.36334434151649475,
0.17224004864692688,
0.4090818464756012,
-0.47703155875205994,
0.4808259904384613,
-0.30626818537712097,
0.6490511894226074,
0.854120671749115,
-0.016031986102461815,
0.7193065285682678,
-0.2858712077140808,
0.8339524865150452,
-0.26075616478919983,
0.29388362169265747,
-0.1761741191148758,
-0.29104864597320557,
-1.1863629817962646,
-0.7274178862571716,
0.5153287649154663,
-0.02716306783258915,
-0.5567429065704346,
0.45489028096199036,
-0.8098510503768921,
-0.13734962046146393,
-0.7810675501823425,
0.22639350593090057,
0.4256492853164673,
0.4740402102470398,
0.30568835139274597,
-0.29599377512931824,
-0.5958247184753418,
-0.9514193534851074,
0.35147854685783386,
-0.21578645706176758,
0.19717484712600708,
-0.19149033725261688,
0.4158227741718292,
-0.0935378223657608,
0.9130310416221619,
-0.40285399556159973,
-0.15526360273361206,
-0.5293167233467102,
0.4001964032649994,
-0.03561437875032425,
0.7061884999275208,
0.10892884433269501,
-0.7963281273841858,
-0.2925926446914673,
-0.050750140100717545,
-0.415734201669693,
0.2678559720516205,
0.19628556072711945,
-0.013062174431979656,
0.08033128082752228,
0.276837021112442,
-0.38757938146591187,
0.37066611647605896,
0.8573290109634399,
-0.2954387664794922,
0.3865440785884857,
-0.2546887695789337,
-0.2305021435022354,
-0.8528099656105042,
0.1727427840232849,
-0.25184082984924316,
-0.37276673316955566,
-0.748180627822876,
0.5209189057350159,
-0.30166494846343994,
-0.46548154950141907,
-0.3167702853679657,
0.44941452145576477,
-0.6852445602416992,
-0.27863195538520813,
-0.14279918372631073,
-0.3295963704586029,
-0.2780910134315491,
0.5893966555595398,
-0.020935386419296265,
0.8921602964401245,
0.4976242184638977,
-0.5298507809638977,
-0.08814141899347305,
0.2165021151304245,
-0.23652957379817963,
0.2201998084783554,
-0.4406073987483978,
0.3207458257675171,
-0.3249439597129822,
0.394016295671463,
-0.9921501874923706,
0.04372971132397652,
-0.12517713010311127,
-0.20828406512737274,
0.5263815522193909,
-0.33307570219039917,
-0.7085629105567932,
-0.34240251779556274,
-0.5454399585723877,
0.493426114320755,
0.9417735934257507,
-0.6233551502227783,
0.856797456741333,
0.5897254943847656,
-0.3706672191619873,
-0.48693040013313293,
-0.559128999710083,
-0.14398497343063354,
-0.2573069930076599,
-0.9030487537384033,
0.5350009202957153,
-0.3950105309486389,
-0.26430678367614746,
0.0297989659011364,
-0.1544889360666275,
-0.04024158790707588,
0.3815394639968872,
0.3334514796733856,
0.09198924899101257,
-0.38633379340171814,
-0.09580563753843307,
-0.11949358880519867,
-0.276296466588974,
-0.4978317320346832,
0.13313597440719604,
0.9862979054450989,
-0.2899186909198761,
0.10382939130067825,
-0.40015506744384766,
0.45131784677505493,
0.8435831665992737,
-0.3696114718914032,
0.8500720262527466,
0.32977691292762756,
-0.318498432636261,
-0.5456482172012329,
-0.3982090353965759,
-0.03209807351231575,
-0.5064699053764343,
0.13445380330085754,
-0.5761904716491699,
-1.1559085845947266,
0.5270971655845642,
-0.5316312313079834,
0.041363202035427094,
0.3456161320209503,
0.6867703199386597,
0.22840115427970886,
1.014352798461914,
1.213065505027771,
-0.04085454344749451,
0.43486613035202026,
-0.6853175163269043,
0.3267365097999573,
-0.9116554856300354,
-0.0025268178433179855,
-0.5784800052642822,
-0.5146054029464722,
-0.4541284441947937,
-0.5766756534576416,
0.49359118938446045,
0.28166234493255615,
-0.5993384718894958,
0.11136382073163986,
-0.8199852705001831,
0.5554506778717041,
0.4607216715812683,
0.04757276922464371,
0.5455642342567444,
0.035158246755599976,
0.08521679043769836,
0.37511441111564636,
-0.8837645649909973,
-0.32547950744628906,
1.1959433555603027,
0.5934237837791443,
0.6036644577980042,
0.05482776090502739,
1.0685142278671265,
0.11975257843732834,
0.7588372826576233,
-0.8221071362495422,
0.7965385913848877,
-0.6887044310569763,
-0.3975549638271332,
-0.33921489119529724,
-0.770616888999939,
-0.8806023001670837,
0.3777886927127838,
0.050362978130578995,
-0.5607542395591736,
0.20116117596626282,
-0.10102757066488266,
-0.5195471048355103,
0.11565718054771423,
-0.7303043603897095,
0.8057003617286682,
-0.06888466328382492,
-0.17373532056808472,
-0.3909551203250885,
-0.6209819316864014,
0.6265503764152527,
-0.07519932836294174,
0.23927757143974304,
-0.1296783685684204,
-0.038462236523628235,
1.0112667083740234,
-0.7966185808181763,
0.7380856871604919,
-0.2869538366794586,
0.2177221029996872,
0.008028262294828892,
0.12118558585643768,
0.37934598326683044,
-0.13226550817489624,
-0.2898475229740143,
0.0189297366887331,
-0.2955649793148041,
-0.47662684321403503,
-0.2845597267150879,
0.8402136564254761,
-0.9880234003067017,
-0.47828343510627747,
-0.07651807367801666,
-0.48722535371780396,
-0.23146843910217285,
0.13998956978321075,
0.22986382246017456,
0.41322648525238037,
-0.13462232053279877,
0.5657296180725098,
0.5802744626998901,
-0.04363420233130455,
0.5598462820053101,
0.2789977788925171,
-0.04610017314553261,
-0.36424973607063293,
0.6278214454650879,
0.1846504956483841,
0.22172744572162628,
0.40190985798835754,
0.3267296254634857,
-0.14645783603191376,
-0.8606224060058594,
0.03799557685852051,
0.31443822383880615,
-0.8624072670936584,
-0.13462917506694794,
-0.35595014691352844,
-0.17328138649463654,
-0.33496543765068054,
-0.40518665313720703,
-0.6860395669937134,
-0.4956199526786804,
-0.14061500132083893,
-0.1703958809375763,
-0.09923511743545532,
0.7203496694564819,
0.13255804777145386,
0.536316454410553,
-0.3341352343559265,
0.542255163192749,
0.37779003381729126,
0.41606876254081726,
-0.011549923568964005,
-0.4121430516242981,
0.0664520412683487,
-0.2541944682598114,
-0.0809672623872757,
-0.4414372444152832,
0.3494639992713928,
0.43172863125801086,
0.6681777238845825,
0.2105190008878708,
0.2248363047838211,
0.8843948245048523,
-0.38421499729156494,
0.8759494423866272,
0.41478273272514343,
-1.029791235923767,
0.23751844465732574,
-0.1728464812040329,
0.3110736906528473,
0.9407148361206055,
0.2961770296096802,
-0.03705286979675293,
-0.05195757746696472,
-0.6911594867706299,
-0.9689207673072815,
0.6959819197654724,
0.016127387061715126,
0.08585666865110397,
0.2899054288864136,
0.19864994287490845,
0.26441654562950134,
0.22174151241779327,
-0.8563339114189148,
-0.4925519526004791,
-0.07077641785144806,
-0.3500247895717621,
-0.09373824298381805,
-0.4075848162174225,
-0.21022680401802063,
-0.5826272368431091,
0.6739363074302673,
-0.08137758076190948,
0.367372065782547,
-0.21698957681655884,
-0.16151918470859528,
-0.10094449669122696,
0.05315452069044113,
0.5947632193565369,
0.7514668703079224,
-0.21434326469898224,
0.22897106409072876,
-0.2620489299297333,
-0.35925570130348206,
0.3328057825565338,
0.04516991227865219,
0.02259198948740959,
-0.1554216742515564,
0.35956084728240967,
0.6876789331436157,
0.5305505394935608,
-0.47817209362983704,
0.4825093150138855,
-0.1982286423444748,
-0.19290924072265625,
-0.18620483577251434,
-0.25144603848457336,
0.13634449243545532,
-0.04864207282662392,
0.39582157135009766,
0.05030427500605583,
-0.30805525183677673,
-0.6368886232376099,
0.3560437262058258,
0.25893476605415344,
0.08955489844083786,
-0.3710201382637024,
0.37042856216430664,
0.403768390417099,
-0.4230916500091553,
0.8192539811134338,
-0.186621755361557,
-0.474769651889801,
0.4528418481349945,
0.3047959804534912,
0.8892572522163391,
-0.3280603885650635,
0.31428614258766174,
0.19185303151607513,
0.16927014291286469,
-0.31421300768852234,
0.009625912643969059,
-0.17514386773109436,
-0.7291720509529114,
-0.519639253616333,
-1.0339436531066895,
-0.21934479475021362,
0.2997450530529022,
-0.4143482744693756,
0.3232319951057434,
-0.980610728263855,
-0.060951925814151764,
-0.022578181698918343,
0.08774204552173615,
-0.7910071015357971,
-0.17196638882160187,
0.3913952708244324,
0.766346275806427,
-0.48527464270591736,
1.1435140371322632,
0.4561758041381836,
-0.520383358001709,
-0.8422799706459045,
0.057747237384319305,
-0.13574355840682983,
-0.7835409045219421,
1.0582847595214844,
0.08341102302074432,
-0.34269970655441284,
0.5224626064300537,
-0.3467291593551636,
-0.787835419178009,
0.9992488026618958,
0.7133656740188599,
-0.2009044885635376,
-0.3362714350223541,
-0.15751850605010986,
0.5309910774230957,
-0.5553671717643738,
-0.0022484678775072098,
0.5159485936164856,
0.4399327337741852,
0.15841516852378845,
-0.9953455328941345,
-0.04919951781630516,
-0.2629944086074829,
0.07730639725923538,
0.3546716272830963,
-0.6727609634399414,
1.3557685613632202,
-0.044473178684711456,
-0.5375245213508606,
0.26816070079803467,
0.3282940089702606,
0.22446636855602264,
-0.09851569682359695,
0.5729211568832397,
0.7130881547927856,
0.6581357717514038,
-0.012839002534747124,
1.0697453022003174,
-0.7243707776069641,
0.6856124997138977,
0.8124744892120361,
-0.2490731030702591,
1.0239232778549194,
0.4299677312374115,
-0.3360130488872528,
0.6366060972213745,
0.40030840039253235,
0.38306209444999695,
0.682151734828949,
0.4978320002555847,
-0.40804046392440796,
-0.32716986536979675,
-0.009629416279494762,
-0.3329108655452728,
0.45221471786499023,
0.29308533668518066,
-0.29959315061569214,
-0.4875892698764801,
0.08479053527116776,
0.20641978085041046,
0.012898853048682213,
-0.6218787431716919,
0.6632412075996399,
0.023543082177639008,
-0.6413688063621521,
0.9944658279418945,
0.18517686426639557,
0.9796577095985413,
-0.7223579287528992,
0.17270611226558685,
-0.4569171369075775,
0.3482997715473175,
-0.2057325392961502,
-0.13893096148967743,
-0.06104287877678871,
-0.07848634570837021,
-0.1928112506866455,
-0.8168859481811523,
0.6145462393760681,
-0.3597041368484497,
-0.5308138728141785,
0.22999559342861176,
0.52350914478302,
-0.030306637287139893,
0.14736054837703705,
-0.6157328486442566,
0.38447174429893494,
-0.05639909952878952,
-0.40273186564445496,
0.5628478527069092,
-0.05341285467147827,
0.1683981567621231,
0.8396003842353821,
0.713190495967865,
0.16296179592609406,
0.23840917646884918,
-0.10974833369255066,
1.1365166902542114,
-0.34052714705467224,
-0.7492614388465881,
-0.5709990859031677,
0.6383032202720642,
0.07942179590463638,
-0.2273334562778473,
0.44676676392555237,
0.5841708183288574,
0.7532294988632202,
0.01069247629493475,
0.6616718173027039,
-0.03043675608932972,
0.42713719606399536,
-0.32461532950401306,
0.6284019947052002,
-0.4821682572364807,
0.40730002522468567,
0.19578084349632263,
-0.6109917759895325,
-0.43131008744239807,
0.6809817552566528,
-0.24700185656547546,
-0.034859392791986465,
0.8300012946128845,
0.6510186791419983,
0.020982760936021805,
-0.04534494876861572,
0.4236416518688202,
0.08336330950260162,
0.2623659074306488,
0.5585927367210388,
0.6099222898483276,
-0.0915515348315239,
0.4836333692073822,
-0.5276817679405212,
-0.23645736277103424,
-0.19694040715694427,
-0.7322524785995483,
-0.8579989075660706,
-0.5155818462371826,
-0.537950336933136,
-0.03871006518602371,
0.07690442353487015,
0.8690477609634399,
1.0615321397781372,
-0.5269471406936646,
-0.3186686038970947,
-0.21483775973320007,
0.163213849067688,
-0.19287696480751038,
-0.23463712632656097,
0.49249812960624695,
-0.20233067870140076,
-0.6623876690864563,
0.8309928178787231,
0.32164227962493896,
-0.24729396402835846,
-0.7640950679779053,
-0.3723897635936737,
-0.12369175255298615,
-0.2923794388771057,
0.6702811121940613,
0.3372684121131897,
-0.5625181198120117,
-0.24523060023784637,
-0.31382066011428833,
-0.03999244049191475,
0.1822245568037033,
1.2242542505264282,
-0.978259801864624,
0.3993878960609436,
0.7530107498168945,
0.6824606657028198,
0.6852430105209351,
0.2361505925655365,
0.5454246401786804,
-1.0854177474975586,
0.432365357875824,
0.5896579027175903,
0.38476336002349854,
0.35416123270988464,
-0.3622266948223114,
0.6213935613632202,
0.3050350844860077,
-0.34603554010391235,
-1.2125065326690674,
0.34309980273246765,
-1.0347168445587158,
-0.557689905166626,
1.13935387134552,
-0.2441355139017105,
-0.245810866355896,
-0.083509162068367,
0.26848122477531433,
0.08089904487133026,
-0.39086970686912537,
0.4722505509853363,
0.6223631501197815,
-0.2553918957710266,
-0.5385240912437439,
-0.21284672617912292,
0.4362425208091736,
0.33886057138442993,
-0.5449250936508179,
0.11862193048000336,
0.3059130609035492,
0.3152463138103485,
0.2822211682796478,
1.0224813222885132,
-0.21466486155986786,
0.01639041304588318,
0.19121035933494568,
0.16891874372959137,
-0.4406757950782776,
-0.4438149631023407,
-0.6632426381111145,
1.007598876953125,
0.19943594932556152,
-0.10015282034873962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19967v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19967v1 | Into the Unknown: Generating Geospatial Descriptions for New Environments | 2024-06-28T14:56:21 | 2024-06-28T14:56:21 | Tzuf Paz-Argaman, John Palowitch, Sayali Kulkarni, Reut Tsarfaty, Jason Baldridge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Similar to vision-and-language navigation (VLN) tasks that focus on bridging
the gap between vision and language for embodied navigation, the new Rendezvous
(RVS) task requires reasoning over allocentric spatial relationships
(independent of the observer's viewpoint) using non-sequential navigation
instructions and maps. However, performance substantially drops in new
environments with no training data. Using opensource descriptions paired with
coordinates (e.g., Wikipedia) provides training data but suffers from limited
spatially-oriented text resulting in low geolocation resolution. We propose a
large-scale augmentation method for generating high-quality synthetic data for
new environments using readily available geospatial data. Our method constructs
a grounded knowledge-graph, capturing entity relationships. Sampled entities
and relations (`shop north of school') generate navigation instructions via (i)
generating numerous templates using context-free grammar (CFG) to embed
specific entities and relations; (ii) feeding the entities and relation into a
large language model (LLM) for instruction generation. A comprehensive
evaluation on RVS, showed that our approach improves the 100-meter accuracy by
45.83% on unseen environments. Furthermore, we demonstrate that models trained
with CFG-based augmentation achieve superior performance compared with those
trained with LLM-based augmentation, both in unseen and seen environments.
These findings suggest that the potential advantages of explicitly structuring
spatial information for text-based geospatial reasoning in previously unknown,
can unlock data-scarce scenarios. | [
-0.6022313833236694,
-0.7313145995140076,
1.0329320430755615,
0.009297308512032032,
-0.03339643031358719,
-0.11945799738168716,
-0.5101832151412964,
-0.6176307201385498,
0.13150376081466675,
0.5392391681671143,
-0.758079469203949,
-0.7612396478652954,
-0.2907894253730774,
-0.09887421876192093,
-0.3709385395050049,
0.6916822195053101,
-0.1904212236404419,
-0.4295121431350708,
-0.4496944844722748,
0.06919938325881958,
-0.5096338391304016,
-0.5194393396377563,
-0.1400160938501358,
-0.09586307406425476,
0.23355548083782196,
0.5824140310287476,
0.7456988096237183,
0.7211787104606628,
0.26787805557250977,
0.34373313188552856,
-0.02258279360830784,
0.6825544238090515,
-0.48332279920578003,
0.052254658192396164,
-0.4299483299255371,
-0.057558491826057434,
0.010999152436852455,
-0.17951291799545288,
0.8648746013641357,
0.8385040163993835,
0.2049623727798462,
-0.0724225714802742,
-0.06354019790887833,
0.35443806648254395,
-0.7632155418395996,
0.37575024366378784,
-0.4755193591117859,
0.06833130121231079,
-0.006061697844415903,
-0.3196779787540436,
-0.2795998454093933,
-0.022082846611738205,
0.6180547475814819,
-1.1949446201324463,
0.3637421131134033,
0.3433012366294861,
0.76065993309021,
0.303054541349411,
-0.17960193753242493,
-0.09339773654937744,
-0.9503394961357117,
0.5797957181930542,
-0.30315011739730835,
0.48688873648643494,
0.2042088508605957,
0.33811768889427185,
-0.3975977599620819,
-0.7236312031745911,
-0.7568449974060059,
-0.245286226272583,
-0.3436845541000366,
0.12893208861351013,
0.029194211587309837,
-0.1321723759174347,
0.2581062912940979,
0.08689700812101364,
-0.2810572683811188,
-0.037432651966810226,
-0.5152826905250549,
0.11065807193517685,
0.6333430409431458,
0.22402194142341614,
0.2279311567544937,
-0.4910105764865875,
-0.5097859501838684,
-0.20489105582237244,
-0.8559732437133789,
0.10446078330278397,
0.15816859900951385,
0.5386205911636353,
-0.2112646847963333,
0.958312451839447,
-0.37425535917282104,
0.7848102450370789,
-0.11861526966094971,
0.11923331022262573,
0.21119335293769836,
-0.3814583420753479,
-0.07317619025707245,
-0.04041358828544617,
0.4987219572067261,
0.4913264214992523,
-0.155180424451828,
-0.29163771867752075,
-0.10606083273887634,
-0.34683093428611755,
0.41416671872138977,
-0.3270629644393921,
-0.3816174864768982,
-0.11109155416488647,
-0.05230844393372536,
-0.04220590740442276,
0.16086424887180328,
-0.8013691902160645,
-0.4110494554042816,
-0.5545742511749268,
0.2832760810852051,
-0.6014968752861023,
-0.132575124502182,
-0.05608236417174339,
-0.10746573656797409,
0.2437126487493515,
0.5520133972167969,
-0.4747016727924347,
0.06282032281160355,
0.4996832609176636,
0.6612275242805481,
-0.06917405128479004,
-0.617827832698822,
-0.3709367513656616,
0.37192612886428833,
-0.34735938906669617,
0.7068847417831421,
-0.5429962873458862,
-0.5982938408851624,
-0.13891221582889557,
0.16907215118408203,
0.181358203291893,
-0.14694368839263916,
0.3054821491241455,
-0.24127981066703796,
0.3052854537963867,
-0.30547407269477844,
-0.25916987657546997,
-0.16029803454875946,
0.20079104602336884,
-0.5466046333312988,
1.2586721181869507,
0.34795621037483215,
-0.5726842880249023,
0.28979170322418213,
-0.7294223308563232,
-0.3682073950767517,
0.32526037096977234,
-0.23358099162578583,
0.01578504964709282,
0.07070062309503555,
0.5330438017845154,
0.02847910299897194,
-0.02591494470834732,
0.004748845007270575,
0.16167618334293365,
-0.5096697211265564,
0.2071334272623062,
-0.11343668401241302,
0.23652851581573486,
0.008432322181761265,
-0.4261327087879181,
-0.17643874883651733,
-0.5841729640960693,
0.1886281818151474,
0.006214592605829239,
-0.3015349507331848,
-0.3661433756351471,
0.1539003551006317,
-0.0801178365945816,
-0.07905344665050507,
0.4654763340950012,
-0.6168386340141296,
0.12781332433223724,
-0.7180769443511963,
-0.03110475279390812,
0.6020464301109314,
0.0829443633556366,
0.9914779663085938,
0.025695310905575752,
0.40502679347991943,
-0.21987155079841614,
0.04512893408536911,
-0.5858184695243835,
-0.47012752294540405,
-0.7319456338882446,
0.04775496944785118,
-0.11527060717344284,
0.4433795213699341,
-0.9827157258987427,
0.3957832455635071,
-0.7574427127838135,
-0.5148491263389587,
-0.08346070349216461,
-0.17346389591693878,
0.2973710000514984,
0.6643415093421936,
0.6702232956886292,
0.15111300349235535,
-0.8387434482574463,
-0.5661512017250061,
0.007594958413392305,
-0.01862800493836403,
-0.1418062150478363,
0.5467861294746399,
0.24496051669120789,
-0.2703793942928314,
1.0675137042999268,
-0.6592662334442139,
-0.12814423441886902,
-0.11268113553524017,
-0.17334923148155212,
-0.0730343610048294,
0.4931076467037201,
0.341427743434906,
-0.5826712846755981,
-0.21473878622055054,
0.3486848473548889,
-0.6680940389633179,
0.16752618551254272,
-0.019130663946270943,
-0.4168611168861389,
0.00023258848523255438,
0.582859992980957,
-0.7694277167320251,
0.5736978054046631,
0.2930980920791626,
-0.18178875744342804,
0.32988256216049194,
-0.3316783010959625,
0.24507422745227814,
-0.9307244420051575,
0.039077624678611755,
0.06577464938163757,
0.06603575497865677,
-0.44134995341300964,
0.4308241605758667,
-0.16540412604808807,
-0.5170785784721375,
-0.4430690109729767,
0.6042492389678955,
-0.7325414419174194,
-0.05784214660525322,
-0.2204647660255432,
0.560084879398346,
0.0050629908218979836,
0.23826372623443604,
0.4262678325176239,
0.581329882144928,
0.5443764925003052,
-0.42692071199417114,
0.4945083558559418,
0.6462444067001343,
-0.30700647830963135,
0.3066180646419525,
-0.2879085838794708,
-0.054399456828832626,
-0.4881895184516907,
0.42723211646080017,
-0.8714514970779419,
-0.5876147747039795,
0.1268557459115982,
-0.6633895039558411,
0.04571900889277458,
-0.4498489797115326,
-0.33216702938079834,
-0.45091772079467773,
0.18723686039447784,
0.35535138845443726,
0.5887005925178528,
-0.8733136057853699,
0.6962809562683105,
0.23558726906776428,
-0.07258860021829605,
-0.5635959506034851,
-0.6149251461029053,
0.21922187507152557,
-0.06509901583194733,
-0.41534751653671265,
0.3160811960697174,
0.2636104226112366,
-0.09203896671533585,
0.24858208000659943,
-0.12768693268299103,
-0.11061778664588928,
-0.1654626578092575,
0.6169545650482178,
0.5845409035682678,
-0.07815202325582504,
0.16024598479270935,
-0.056532230228185654,
-0.07570795714855194,
0.214487686753273,
-0.6142045259475708,
0.32065385580062866,
0.021954596042633057,
-0.2730939984321594,
-0.06191276013851166,
0.3881610035896301,
0.27122554183006287,
-0.3594238758087158,
0.7602783441543579,
0.4137832224369049,
-0.5137177109718323,
-0.22966830432415009,
-0.1968243420124054,
0.03275659307837486,
-0.5080219507217407,
0.31562340259552,
-0.27650874853134155,
-0.8394013047218323,
0.10799165815114975,
-0.3309764862060547,
0.1517893224954605,
0.217939093708992,
0.009489019401371479,
-0.04812682420015335,
0.49552232027053833,
0.710442841053009,
0.3198958933353424,
0.2936730980873108,
-0.22380231320858002,
0.7601097822189331,
-0.7151742577552795,
-0.7240675091743469,
-0.24178490042686462,
-0.2728320360183716,
-0.6390461921691895,
-0.8869050741195679,
0.8050444722175598,
-0.07054799795150757,
-0.2559297978878021,
0.4200041592121124,
-0.7424894571304321,
0.8161383867263794,
0.588675320148468,
0.14643312990665436,
0.025857457891106606,
0.42289239168167114,
-0.05401449277997017,
-0.27471327781677246,
-0.6376274824142456,
-0.3740292489528656,
1.2052123546600342,
-0.06804033368825912,
0.7498529553413391,
0.03528290614485741,
0.6628305315971375,
-0.09356711059808731,
0.1623060405254364,
-0.42292213439941406,
0.4967348575592041,
0.19821302592754364,
-0.2445605844259262,
-0.457072377204895,
-0.42489075660705566,
-0.8628078103065491,
0.1534709930419922,
-0.749197244644165,
-0.8700273633003235,
0.005257822573184967,
0.14313672482967377,
-0.5928467512130737,
0.29305294156074524,
-0.6830916404724121,
0.5216680765151978,
-0.19303254783153534,
-0.4621628522872925,
0.20586231350898743,
-0.7532379627227783,
0.3310620188713074,
0.09451880306005478,
0.1681278645992279,
0.15119311213493347,
-0.0704173594713211,
-0.005458509083837271,
-0.2325078248977661,
0.5513437390327454,
-0.3619959056377411,
-0.07325451076030731,
0.4171361029148102,
0.05445506423711777,
0.6268896460533142,
0.2778538167476654,
0.16429603099822998,
0.03196977823972702,
-0.3895481824874878,
-0.15053750574588776,
-0.7739207148551941,
1.1082123517990112,
-0.7088863849639893,
-0.4710606634616852,
-0.12100491672754288,
-0.7125544548034668,
-0.2062295824289322,
0.11644235253334045,
0.43593502044677734,
0.39760130643844604,
-0.2286360114812851,
-0.10203016549348831,
0.7786005735397339,
-0.7056248784065247,
0.09002603590488434,
0.4709816575050354,
-0.11489960551261902,
-0.35823506116867065,
0.8071939945220947,
-0.05237267538905144,
-0.06487404555082321,
0.6167386770248413,
-0.24381476640701294,
-0.6998993754386902,
-0.3408477306365967,
-0.4789411723613739,
0.01926785707473755,
-0.6376355886459351,
-0.266630083322525,
-0.6877812743186951,
-0.3955304026603699,
-0.3185974359512329,
-0.5367039442062378,
-0.3302757143974304,
-0.540847897529602,
-0.10892648249864578,
-0.23043519258499146,
0.36849385499954224,
0.8363284468650818,
-0.24575822055339813,
0.47316959500312805,
-0.674250602722168,
0.1566513329744339,
-0.18305514752864838,
0.03706081584095955,
-0.07227422297000885,
-0.16232001781463623,
-0.4701855778694153,
0.3321315050125122,
-0.016107141971588135,
-0.6138688921928406,
0.3739296495914459,
-0.182373046875,
0.5393142700195312,
0.04123373702168465,
0.13952766358852386,
0.8539111614227295,
-0.6505962014198303,
0.9134814739227295,
0.19492678344249725,
-0.7572822570800781,
0.8711679577827454,
-0.3403431177139282,
0.24627874791622162,
0.16603785753250122,
0.2996828556060791,
-0.2997171878814697,
-0.3607698380947113,
-0.6384250521659851,
-1.1410104036331177,
0.5168232321739197,
0.18227609992027283,
0.2087445706129074,
-0.07913333922624588,
0.6414727568626404,
-0.12396655976772308,
0.16094276309013367,
-0.7444571256637573,
-0.16544152796268463,
-0.2106800079345703,
-0.05900055170059204,
-0.27417969703674316,
-0.055655792355537415,
-0.3667178750038147,
-0.4018630385398865,
0.36394789814949036,
-0.09141577035188675,
0.38066500425338745,
0.38081324100494385,
-0.12367255240678787,
-0.06440722197294235,
0.07147019356489182,
0.21372072398662567,
0.6361855864524841,
0.2410135120153427,
0.360183984041214,
0.29289913177490234,
-0.1376221477985382,
0.20734341442584991,
0.41815102100372314,
-0.27105361223220825,
0.07566942274570465,
0.439515084028244,
0.713453471660614,
0.38200443983078003,
-0.865326464176178,
0.6086022853851318,
0.2603358328342438,
0.06230565905570984,
-0.6269060373306274,
0.14276036620140076,
-0.01832708716392517,
0.2938605844974518,
0.2547702491283417,
0.1792949140071869,
0.09712059050798416,
-0.2544732391834259,
0.1406651735305786,
0.39011403918266296,
-0.11160194128751755,
-0.05780601501464844,
0.7525174617767334,
0.12921454012393951,
0.0815143957734108,
0.8383574485778809,
-0.268909752368927,
-0.20336724817752838,
0.3419267237186432,
0.4125303626060486,
0.314559668302536,
-0.13062311708927155,
0.22354020178318024,
0.756197452545166,
0.5638703107833862,
0.10059081017971039,
0.09314839541912079,
-0.2631736695766449,
-0.517414391040802,
-0.5732991695404053,
-0.5041314959526062,
-0.18772713840007782,
0.003590137232095003,
-0.5766662955284119,
0.17662878334522247,
-0.5293726921081543,
0.07882391661405563,
-0.45582830905914307,
-0.27139368653297424,
-0.7825201153755188,
0.2964003086090088,
0.20352458953857422,
0.7321581244468689,
-0.6752623319625854,
0.20553407073020935,
0.9329174757003784,
-0.12380687892436981,
-0.8039441108703613,
0.08859999477863312,
-0.20209327340126038,
-0.5559637546539307,
0.3815786838531494,
0.13620002567768097,
-0.054346002638339996,
-0.09616362303495407,
-0.6834970712661743,
-1.1415164470672607,
1.072164535522461,
0.20800991356372833,
-0.39421242475509644,
-0.32825565338134766,
0.3514198064804077,
0.5459226369857788,
-0.34969252347946167,
-0.11682754755020142,
0.5096772909164429,
0.5265772938728333,
0.09685054421424866,
-0.5881261229515076,
0.15387053787708282,
-0.29751643538475037,
0.13543613255023956,
0.27116623520851135,
-0.1367049366235733,
0.6950093507766724,
-0.609910786151886,
-0.5215939283370972,
0.3988412022590637,
0.5626701712608337,
0.2719687819480896,
0.1578856110572815,
0.3216552436351776,
0.8314603567123413,
0.6995888948440552,
-0.42035096883773804,
1.0177596807479858,
-0.18609990179538727,
0.04914503172039986,
1.4701882600784302,
-0.12227924168109894,
0.7284335494041443,
0.31108397245407104,
0.15598200261592865,
0.6891405582427979,
0.5638784766197205,
0.07507184892892838,
0.6824718117713928,
0.09385618567466736,
-0.5530199408531189,
-0.1646292358636856,
-0.08280172944068909,
-0.4809623658657074,
0.4254513680934906,
0.4946914613246918,
-0.32243722677230835,
-0.4596393406391144,
0.0833706334233284,
-0.23169568181037903,
0.28443488478660583,
-0.15407080948352814,
0.5862232446670532,
-0.3722672462463379,
-0.7956308126449585,
0.43196091055870056,
0.10631133615970612,
0.12349317967891693,
-0.5256487727165222,
-0.3365612328052521,
-0.0480731725692749,
-0.14690804481506348,
-0.2143847942352295,
-0.97478187084198,
0.13087567687034607,
-0.00877952016890049,
-0.029576223343610764,
-0.11757257580757141,
0.43311837315559387,
-0.6030108332633972,
-0.33103764057159424,
0.029141422361135483,
0.6349632740020752,
0.03903168812394142,
-0.014503533951938152,
-0.014376441948115826,
-0.08261758834123611,
-0.05534278228878975,
0.16915000975131989,
-0.06487830728292465,
0.7683624625205994,
0.0180630125105381,
0.6225622892379761,
0.7703975439071655,
0.04436473175883293,
0.33001944422721863,
-0.4279124438762665,
1.0969699621200562,
-0.6317189931869507,
-0.7741501927375793,
-0.3619931936264038,
0.5787699222564697,
-0.17504359781742096,
-0.05349172651767731,
0.9591799974441528,
0.7231005430221558,
0.9494016766548157,
-0.08735532313585281,
1.0325473546981812,
-0.14883162081241608,
0.3051370680332184,
-0.6064842939376831,
0.2986239492893219,
-0.32373175024986267,
0.18315210938453674,
-0.24883203208446503,
-0.9804764986038208,
-0.030783604830503464,
0.6496105194091797,
-0.3977473974227905,
-0.1506117582321167,
0.6816738247871399,
0.8340319395065308,
-0.318671315908432,
-0.13178189098834991,
0.03253019228577614,
-0.07823512703180313,
0.0806138664484024,
0.6598777174949646,
1.256576657295227,
-0.21811866760253906,
0.5283673405647278,
-0.21296438574790955,
-0.2202387899160385,
0.2080637812614441,
-0.6003177762031555,
-0.5271926522254944,
-0.6156923770904541,
0.08866546303033829,
-0.4287097454071045,
0.038429077714681625,
0.5916720628738403,
0.7618881464004517,
-0.25594770908355713,
0.16484224796295166,
-0.31330665946006775,
-0.05390465632081032,
0.10435041785240173,
-0.28891485929489136,
0.06846886873245239,
-0.23840731382369995,
-0.8831650018692017,
0.9363725781440735,
0.27856603264808655,
0.3702540099620819,
-0.35629358887672424,
-0.19992530345916748,
0.2069292515516281,
-0.16108833253383636,
0.6005382537841797,
0.359319806098938,
-0.6466752886772156,
-0.36635878682136536,
0.02166418358683586,
0.28426995873451233,
-0.11411090940237045,
0.8485995531082153,
-0.9481799602508545,
0.5390238761901855,
0.05208981782197952,
0.6774604916572571,
0.5744960904121399,
0.29769474267959595,
0.6175879240036011,
-1.1886111497879028,
0.43785619735717773,
-0.03720102459192276,
0.2754132151603699,
0.6385523676872253,
-0.6240420937538147,
0.4809779226779938,
-0.019387179985642433,
-0.314937949180603,
-0.5765225887298584,
0.3151630461215973,
-0.6365828514099121,
-0.17369648814201355,
1.196499228477478,
-0.17954911291599274,
-0.30462780594825745,
0.17687445878982544,
-0.3068176507949829,
0.0256863534450531,
-0.13750667870044708,
0.5741459131240845,
0.36338889598846436,
-0.12553901970386505,
-0.12517446279525757,
-0.41258925199508667,
0.508266270160675,
-0.16696307063102722,
-0.878619909286499,
0.035685598850250244,
1.1312180757522583,
0.15807726979255676,
0.39504408836364746,
0.3373554050922394,
-0.07948344945907593,
0.2085452824831009,
0.16061531007289886,
-0.028005585074424744,
-0.19042260944843292,
-0.6165728569030762,
0.22699083387851715,
0.04375611990690231,
-0.11840818077325821,
-0.229024738073349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19966v1 | Simulating Financial Market via Large Language Model based Agents | 2024-06-28T14:54:12 | 2024-06-28T14:54:12 | Shen Gao, Yuntao Wen, Minghang Zhu, Jianing Wei, Yuhan Cheng, Qunzi Zhang, Shuo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most economic theories typically assume that financial market participants
are fully rational individuals and use mathematical models to simulate human
behavior in financial markets. However, human behavior is often not entirely
rational and is challenging to predict accurately with mathematical models. In
this paper, we propose \textbf{A}gent-based \textbf{S}imulated
\textbf{F}inancial \textbf{M}arket (ASFM), which first constructs a simulated
stock market with a real order matching system. Then, we propose a large
language model based agent as the stock trader, which contains the profile,
observation, and tool-learning based action module. The trading agent can
comprehensively understand current market dynamics and financial policy
information, and make decisions that align with their trading strategy. In the
experiments, we first verify that the reactions of our ASFM are consistent with
the real stock market in two controllable scenarios. In addition, we also
conduct experiments in two popular economics research directions, and we find
that conclusions drawn in our \model align with the preliminary findings in
economics research. Based on these observations, we believe our proposed ASFM
provides a new paradigm for economic research. | [
-0.0482633113861084,
-1.0987130403518677,
0.1646888554096222,
0.3686378002166748,
-0.026484252884984016,
0.30151695013046265,
-0.18842683732509613,
-0.5243905782699585,
0.5900940299034119,
0.48466694355010986,
-0.33050641417503357,
-0.23155708611011505,
-0.08279366791248322,
-0.013654237613081932,
-0.5205941796302795,
0.47821247577667236,
0.0071981907822191715,
0.207407146692276,
0.1635291874408722,
0.32602354884147644,
-0.05397830531001091,
-0.7322748899459839,
-1.3043982982635498,
-0.43122342228889465,
-0.0622764490544796,
0.10690797120332718,
0.823084831237793,
0.5555062294006348,
0.4946676194667816,
0.43199992179870605,
0.349258154630661,
-0.28067874908447266,
-0.21759141981601715,
0.03143329173326492,
-0.22673502564430237,
-0.35258594155311584,
-0.5442541837692261,
0.37432339787483215,
0.5466353893280029,
0.33004435896873474,
-0.5873086452484131,
-0.012534813024103642,
-0.03790402039885521,
0.3266041874885559,
-0.18765176832675934,
0.5761978030204773,
-0.24370786547660828,
-0.04475770145654678,
-0.025363748893141747,
-0.3394675552845001,
-0.63448166847229,
-0.13354180753231049,
0.3211073875427246,
-0.724322497844696,
-0.1763695925474167,
0.4620862603187561,
0.9510969519615173,
-0.25786447525024414,
-0.675559401512146,
-0.2897428274154663,
-0.9418961405754089,
0.7515974044799805,
-0.8088211417198181,
0.3424927592277527,
0.4662413001060486,
0.7244232892990112,
-0.20221532881259918,
-0.5241689085960388,
-0.41999197006225586,
-0.5480634570121765,
0.0843215063214302,
-0.050780173391103745,
-0.1937248855829239,
0.08353309333324432,
0.2936194837093353,
0.14558249711990356,
-0.10987333208322525,
-0.035952381789684296,
-0.37592044472694397,
0.05083884671330452,
0.8086500763893127,
0.2754650115966797,
0.09051483869552612,
0.027953708544373512,
-0.7923576831817627,
-0.49888843297958374,
-0.6413358449935913,
0.049960117787122726,
0.7614616751670837,
0.4905954897403717,
-0.036502473056316376,
0.6963110566139221,
-0.15639758110046387,
0.20575597882270813,
-0.07298629730939865,
-0.13294513523578644,
0.1784915328025818,
0.05456092953681946,
-0.4723379909992218,
0.0645158663392067,
0.6757007241249084,
0.40210533142089844,
0.44214770197868347,
0.04259803891181946,
-0.49864301085472107,
-0.14328637719154358,
0.34762483835220337,
-0.7349581718444824,
-0.06603183597326279,
-0.0261765755712986,
-0.6945710778236389,
-0.317627876996994,
0.12945903837680817,
-0.9119163155555725,
-0.14789752662181854,
-0.568721354007721,
0.7104598879814148,
-0.515681803226471,
-0.3648545742034912,
0.08729910850524902,
0.02725391834974289,
0.5816149711608887,
0.2563660442829132,
-0.9318404793739319,
0.5959240198135376,
0.7646029591560364,
0.5691388845443726,
0.2895359694957733,
-0.45476609468460083,
-0.4053201675415039,
0.3089498281478882,
-0.25641289353370667,
0.8721204400062561,
-0.5557371377944946,
-0.3587002754211426,
0.09087172895669937,
-0.20721545815467834,
-0.22258569300174713,
-0.2101271152496338,
-0.16651739180088043,
-0.6932002305984497,
0.02450837753713131,
-0.3637099266052246,
-0.8268338441848755,
-0.38199278712272644,
0.47626692056655884,
-0.49392518401145935,
0.560059666633606,
0.013110306113958359,
-0.4954870939254761,
0.29241156578063965,
-1.28460693359375,
-0.3794553875923157,
0.0292267594486475,
-0.2454289346933365,
-0.1706475168466568,
-0.4779127240180969,
-0.28756681084632874,
0.2742788791656494,
-0.5523694753646851,
0.08827026933431625,
-0.4784868657588959,
-0.47343865036964417,
0.9079724550247192,
-0.7097119688987732,
0.4342553913593292,
0.266755074262619,
-0.5003068447113037,
0.1543700248003006,
-0.5645691752433777,
-0.2781429886817932,
0.3092096447944641,
-0.03916784003376961,
-0.447963148355484,
0.3403775990009308,
0.36238569021224976,
-0.13486558198928833,
0.2242857813835144,
-0.6149657368659973,
0.4474840462207794,
-0.39215633273124695,
0.5473307371139526,
0.9705766439437866,
-0.009655449539422989,
0.5026740431785583,
-0.5997668504714966,
0.825598418712616,
-0.37175068259239197,
0.1159522533416748,
0.10120829939842224,
-0.1980854719877243,
-0.373169481754303,
-0.3830808997154236,
0.5115691423416138,
0.7681071162223816,
-0.523476779460907,
0.05023728311061859,
0.09981292486190796,
-0.12335126101970673,
-0.09282658249139786,
-0.2590748965740204,
0.06490959972143173,
-0.021390601992607117,
0.1298942267894745,
-0.13024483621120453,
-0.505535900592804,
-1.057058334350586,
-0.21391639113426208,
-0.15847399830818176,
-0.1444648653268814,
0.15798962116241455,
0.25436270236968994,
-0.3314553499221802,
0.9806674122810364,
-0.7325067520141602,
-0.08349645137786865,
-0.20323976874351501,
0.21513012051582336,
0.021882595494389534,
0.49651244282722473,
0.814998209476471,
-0.5844654440879822,
-0.3238961696624756,
0.2579735517501831,
-0.589959979057312,
0.3241140842437744,
-0.3364146053791046,
-0.3276297152042389,
0.24786709249019623,
0.9281275272369385,
-0.47814327478408813,
0.4767833948135376,
0.1875135898590088,
-0.6738877296447754,
0.467275470495224,
-0.4890139400959015,
0.19535663723945618,
-1.3133220672607422,
0.2958429157733917,
0.22410888969898224,
-0.15513257682323456,
-0.519666850566864,
0.17656536400318146,
-0.16730357706546783,
-0.11812204122543335,
-0.061702556908130646,
0.8514779210090637,
-0.2911214232444763,
-0.1969843953847885,
-0.4646669030189514,
-0.258463978767395,
-0.4648693799972534,
0.4017467498779297,
-0.12468113005161285,
0.9185037016868591,
0.43862318992614746,
-0.26227930188179016,
0.24100911617279053,
0.25532588362693787,
-0.2418128401041031,
0.5627298951148987,
-0.6311378479003906,
-0.28735971450805664,
-0.026607157662510872,
0.1331922560930252,
-0.8502359390258789,
-0.20031026005744934,
0.44030749797821045,
-0.17057645320892334,
0.2201443463563919,
0.10085111856460571,
-0.5440347790718079,
-0.3347585201263428,
0.0021369527094066143,
0.2817556858062744,
0.5654996633529663,
-0.18989333510398865,
0.9402529001235962,
0.15418080985546112,
-0.4788568913936615,
-0.6809589266777039,
-0.41812968254089355,
0.0853605791926384,
-0.2395499348640442,
-0.5679553151130676,
-0.22039683163166046,
-0.1732235997915268,
-0.6949717402458191,
-0.1442471444606781,
0.06137143820524216,
0.01431567408144474,
0.2810664772987366,
0.03550182282924652,
0.6973416805267334,
-0.45101457834243774,
0.0021425678860396147,
-0.0649675726890564,
-0.3554098904132843,
0.24972157180309296,
-0.161101832985878,
0.4831118583679199,
-0.21902406215667725,
-0.3950939476490021,
-0.3837810456752777,
0.386488676071167,
0.7302178740501404,
-0.1808396875858307,
0.7213649749755859,
-0.04052596166729927,
-0.3080688416957855,
-0.30473995208740234,
-0.45474517345428467,
-0.39968791604042053,
-0.5759774446487427,
0.0925663486123085,
-0.484790176153183,
-0.7488883137702942,
0.9302163124084473,
-0.09654989093542099,
0.2853987216949463,
0.3279331922531128,
0.5225781798362732,
0.0007855797884985805,
0.7916302680969238,
0.6120030283927917,
0.08139212429523468,
0.6736230254173279,
-0.22988158464431763,
0.3826321065425873,
-0.19901986420154572,
0.06259050220251083,
-0.24842742085456848,
-0.5454562306404114,
-0.17304494976997375,
-0.4721912443637848,
0.03544475883245468,
-0.1308235228061676,
-0.5186553597450256,
0.28150951862335205,
0.12760329246520996,
0.6068174839019775,
0.7068432569503784,
-0.013895564712584019,
0.2396751046180725,
0.031047629192471504,
-0.45069870352745056,
0.20548921823501587,
-0.46951618790626526,
-0.598942756652832,
1.218648076057434,
0.45845115184783936,
1.0059915781021118,
-0.10825474560260773,
0.36463087797164917,
0.3853895366191864,
0.7332423329353333,
-0.5668032765388489,
0.5280748605728149,
-0.004483610391616821,
-0.5893600583076477,
-0.36609509587287903,
-0.5133800506591797,
-0.8097916841506958,
0.1251920610666275,
-0.380403995513916,
-0.38585495948791504,
0.2535113990306854,
0.20311591029167175,
-0.6249927878379822,
0.1589876413345337,
-0.6652839183807373,
0.8712440729141235,
-0.07231681793928146,
-0.1625475287437439,
-0.21483367681503296,
-0.41438618302345276,
0.33237725496292114,
-0.0916740745306015,
0.3992421627044678,
-0.23347234725952148,
0.19763709604740143,
0.4614664614200592,
-0.5687546133995056,
0.8989278674125671,
-0.16841647028923035,
-0.3014756441116333,
0.3706292510032654,
0.18442879617214203,
0.8493989706039429,
0.07051166892051697,
-0.09630094468593597,
-0.19708865880966187,
0.03233290836215019,
-0.5892265439033508,
-0.40513813495635986,
0.4876195192337036,
-0.689229428768158,
-0.3567495048046112,
-0.4095478355884552,
-0.5962087512016296,
-0.08068996667861938,
0.03792804479598999,
-0.25655531883239746,
0.15907570719718933,
-0.5147137641906738,
0.07877036184072495,
0.04958334565162659,
0.09483499825000763,
0.22177407145500183,
0.9340821504592896,
-0.589261531829834,
-0.24437080323696136,
0.8715014457702637,
0.0014190211659297347,
0.14096595346927643,
0.2984989583492279,
0.1996915340423584,
-0.3635464608669281,
-0.06521707028150558,
-0.2615165114402771,
0.24351033568382263,
-0.4938312768936157,
-0.14147233963012695,
-0.4396783411502838,
-0.23464487493038177,
-0.38356536626815796,
-0.5437563061714172,
-0.4736117124557495,
0.01775026135146618,
-0.0018487306078895926,
-0.30765867233276367,
0.5979810357093811,
0.6468634009361267,
-0.2938452959060669,
0.41155076026916504,
-0.6518771052360535,
0.16651520133018494,
0.6802948713302612,
0.5230822563171387,
0.32023385167121887,
-0.11890672147274017,
-0.3327248990535736,
0.46493855118751526,
0.08189459890127182,
-0.5778989195823669,
0.5277532339096069,
-0.10094404220581055,
0.6025100946426392,
0.8392511606216431,
0.11797581613063812,
0.4978439509868622,
-0.17783966660499573,
0.12686792016029358,
-0.10494314134120941,
-0.9776694178581238,
0.09420424699783325,
-0.6194068193435669,
-0.26424771547317505,
0.410321980714798,
0.029610196128487587,
-0.7858425974845886,
-0.529901385307312,
-0.6206603646278381,
-0.8409497737884521,
0.7665496468544006,
0.23658010363578796,
0.1571364551782608,
-0.20848025381565094,
0.3816266357898712,
0.23602394759655,
0.5321863293647766,
-0.5473544597625732,
-0.15599872171878815,
-0.13331566751003265,
-0.10393866896629333,
-0.17395780980587006,
-0.1391558051109314,
0.03497058525681496,
-0.05899633467197418,
0.7017174363136292,
-0.29180771112442017,
0.34034696221351624,
-0.10248473286628723,
0.21263615787029266,
-0.34169983863830566,
0.02586648426949978,
0.5475702881813049,
0.5433303117752075,
-0.43108662962913513,
-0.02154073305428028,
-0.036038391292095184,
-0.19921894371509552,
0.324709415435791,
0.29214149713516235,
-0.25942277908325195,
-0.41569605469703674,
-0.03808943182229996,
0.5352239012718201,
0.6245540976524353,
-1.2271113395690918,
0.6779524087905884,
-0.08358125388622284,
-0.6327866315841675,
-0.7232064604759216,
-0.027937203645706177,
0.2443222999572754,
0.9835733771324158,
0.5491529703140259,
0.3377769887447357,
0.14335046708583832,
-0.8277417421340942,
0.4934477210044861,
0.4911305904388428,
-0.13821321725845337,
-0.2771179974079132,
0.9492279291152954,
0.17353646457195282,
-0.3481997549533844,
0.7038284540176392,
-0.3340453803539276,
-0.4623095989227295,
0.8285025358200073,
0.6919594407081604,
0.855582058429718,
-0.30685654282569885,
0.22899411618709564,
0.05783091485500336,
0.3880041539669037,
-0.7672609686851501,
0.6890426278114319,
0.2351251095533371,
-0.7792454361915588,
-0.6078670620918274,
-0.764183759689331,
-0.5810083746910095,
-0.13584765791893005,
-0.5537016987800598,
0.28383007645606995,
-0.6693542003631592,
-0.029676273465156555,
0.09887755662202835,
-0.05624759942293167,
-0.41423940658569336,
-0.18735118210315704,
0.1157350018620491,
1.011558175086975,
-0.8962661623954773,
0.8376681208610535,
0.9452739953994751,
-0.25132009387016296,
-0.6038305759429932,
-0.028831113129854202,
-0.07154632359743118,
-1.0129849910736084,
0.28962260484695435,
0.027986153960227966,
0.05445126071572304,
0.010443786159157753,
-0.5735101103782654,
-0.8929300308227539,
1.0876621007919312,
0.4282405972480774,
-0.4617139399051666,
0.051933348178863525,
-0.1439303755760193,
0.5181778073310852,
-0.6510051488876343,
0.009259975515305996,
0.4341284930706024,
0.6465548276901245,
0.6199052929878235,
-0.7272273898124695,
-0.14443786442279816,
-0.5529501438140869,
-0.16137059032917023,
0.4740884602069855,
-0.797688364982605,
1.1483030319213867,
-0.04056249186396599,
-0.23942823708057404,
0.29371339082717896,
0.7612196803092957,
0.22370187938213348,
0.5094841718673706,
0.5600744485855103,
0.24047069251537323,
0.46196773648262024,
0.3071210980415344,
0.9284043312072754,
-0.5809884071350098,
0.6698105335235596,
0.9020465612411499,
-0.6260139346122742,
1.1448819637298584,
0.049660585820674896,
-0.21940018236637115,
0.38178709149360657,
0.48425257205963135,
-0.19538705050945282,
0.036426011472940445,
0.29409825801849365,
-0.2807304263114929,
-0.46728774905204773,
0.339296817779541,
-0.17230744659900665,
0.584826648235321,
0.2319958359003067,
-0.3087400794029236,
-0.11179113388061523,
0.19682614505290985,
-0.07873781025409698,
0.19464708864688873,
-0.17398549616336823,
0.47246965765953064,
0.09951657801866531,
0.0033220669720321894,
-0.1346045732498169,
0.3063495457172394,
0.5874917507171631,
-0.8048231601715088,
-0.0010583787225186825,
-0.07458073645830154,
0.17358408868312836,
0.5522545576095581,
-0.2550467848777771,
0.3010212481021881,
-0.31312263011932373,
-0.05802110210061073,
-0.4603181779384613,
0.6339747905731201,
-0.6620587706565857,
-0.6748039722442627,
0.2545511722564697,
0.4747573733329773,
0.07708178460597992,
-0.1930253803730011,
-0.49164876341819763,
-0.49281296133995056,
-0.09544000774621964,
-0.5167730450630188,
0.44419118762016296,
0.5465359091758728,
-0.08241834491491318,
0.7657090425491333,
1.0106135606765747,
-0.3740999102592468,
-0.31933271884918213,
-0.43719083070755005,
0.4373391568660736,
-1.1238102912902832,
-1.1146230697631836,
-0.7577178478240967,
-0.08452547341585159,
-0.093698650598526,
0.017240701243281364,
0.4795200824737549,
0.6850648522377014,
0.41621750593185425,
-0.2352500855922699,
0.7378069162368774,
0.3189231753349304,
0.4272720515727997,
-0.40137773752212524,
1.0022050142288208,
-0.4207721948623657,
0.24939624965190887,
-0.13945022225379944,
-0.9928839802742004,
0.004225633107125759,
0.9617995023727417,
-0.2834014296531677,
-0.06349806487560272,
0.49912741780281067,
0.6155548691749573,
-0.20945532619953156,
0.455853134393692,
0.3045894205570221,
0.566882312297821,
-0.024149078875780106,
-0.049763355404138565,
0.6286197304725647,
-0.29341650009155273,
0.29852432012557983,
-0.050592198967933655,
-0.13208529353141785,
-0.7669134140014648,
-0.649017870426178,
-0.8649083971977234,
-0.3019630014896393,
-0.14324194192886353,
-0.1710698902606964,
-0.20254594087600708,
1.6939252614974976,
0.2358095943927765,
-0.5488513708114624,
-0.8419502973556519,
0.30878227949142456,
-0.24772928655147552,
-0.5339813232421875,
-0.24637006223201752,
0.22679796814918518,
-0.13200333714485168,
-0.6552896499633789,
0.4467601478099823,
0.43992334604263306,
0.7716595530509949,
-0.2654106318950653,
-0.07095351070165634,
-0.11195306479930878,
0.6585233807563782,
0.7659366130828857,
0.34381404519081116,
-0.1628493219614029,
-0.31729856133461,
0.16062365472316742,
-0.15206603705883026,
-0.14770789444446564,
0.9864047765731812,
-0.400567889213562,
0.12263517081737518,
0.04460395127534866,
0.4460054039955139,
0.2497727870941162,
0.15654566884040833,
1.075294017791748,
-0.2875564694404602,
0.3445875942707062,
-0.02971564792096615,
0.2702726721763611,
-0.3965984880924225,
-0.31895673274993896,
0.2916305959224701,
0.1814960092306137,
-0.3884199261665344,
-0.48594170808792114,
-0.025196289643645287,
-0.9603710770606995,
-0.479811429977417,
0.8881798982620239,
0.017377225682139397,
-0.5146800875663757,
0.04075665771961212,
-0.26376208662986755,
-0.16709518432617188,
-0.7540459632873535,
0.9148366451263428,
0.6269949674606323,
0.21079285442829132,
0.09049887210130692,
-0.799819827079773,
0.2506665587425232,
0.20125417411327362,
-0.5239025354385376,
0.37651774287223816,
0.30878740549087524,
0.21269623935222626,
-0.1503594070672989,
0.8402902483940125,
0.32392892241477966,
0.45516327023506165,
0.46847423911094666,
0.23916050791740417,
-0.0749356746673584,
0.019190317019820213,
0.10158879309892654,
0.35505592823028564,
0.10002895444631577,
0.10039009898900986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19954v1 | BESTOW: Efficient and Streamable Speech Language Model with the Best of Two Worlds in GPT and T5 | 2024-06-28T14:40:03 | 2024-06-28T14:40:03 | Zhehuai Chen, He Huang, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Krishna C. Puvvada, Nithin Rao Koluguri, Piotr Żelasko, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS, 68T10, I.2.7 | Incorporating speech understanding capabilities into pretrained
large-language models has become a vital research direction (SpeechLLM). The
previous architectures can be categorized as: i) GPT-style, prepend speech
prompts to the text prompts as a sequence of LLM inputs like a decoder-only
model; ii) T5-style, introduce speech cross-attention to each layer of the
pretrained LLMs. We propose BESTOW architecture to bring the BESt features from
TwO Worlds into a single model that is highly efficient and has strong
multitask capabilities. Moreover, there is no clear streaming solution for
either style, especially considering the solution should generalize to speech
multitask. We reformulate streamable SpeechLLM as a read-write policy problem
and unifies the offline and streaming research with BESTOW architecture. Hence
we demonstrate the first open-source SpeechLLM solution that enables Streaming
and Multitask at scale (beyond ASR) at the same time. This streamable solution
achieves very strong performance on a wide range of speech tasks (ASR, AST,
SQA, unseen DynamicSuperb). It is end-to-end optimizable, with lower
training/inference cost, and demonstrates LLM knowledge transferability to
speech. | [
-0.036980949342250824,
-0.5511693358421326,
0.3758077919483185,
0.3227292001247406,
-0.34384143352508545,
0.16130773723125458,
-0.3307838439941406,
-0.5949793457984924,
0.11377625167369843,
0.528059184551239,
-0.5436440706253052,
-0.4557974636554718,
-0.6062541007995605,
-0.1677289605140686,
-0.36573758721351624,
0.795107901096344,
0.11016636341810226,
-0.08055785298347473,
-0.14367343485355377,
-0.11497265100479126,
-0.208211287856102,
-0.45811906456947327,
-0.7695373892784119,
-0.5800378918647766,
0.36561119556427,
0.16737869381904602,
0.553315281867981,
0.534652590751648,
0.4337034523487091,
0.3145866394042969,
-0.09491348266601562,
0.19901429116725922,
-0.6231847405433655,
-0.08281532675027847,
-0.14853808283805847,
-0.11286135762929916,
-0.6986113786697388,
-0.1319521814584732,
0.5250676870346069,
0.3996167480945587,
-0.5440943241119385,
0.1222999095916748,
0.2499658167362213,
0.36695292592048645,
-0.5030650496482849,
0.27719172835350037,
-0.5515321493148804,
-0.10754892975091934,
-0.3596195876598358,
-0.13913583755493164,
-0.4616619050502777,
-0.2368762344121933,
0.3317248523235321,
-0.6323281526565552,
-0.10753742605447769,
-0.06393580883741379,
0.5989733934402466,
0.3970004916191101,
-0.195947527885437,
-0.043274927884340286,
-0.6414121389389038,
0.8133352994918823,
-0.7458154559135437,
0.6259624361991882,
0.3041994273662567,
0.40889906883239746,
-0.03507430478930473,
-0.9343112707138062,
-0.35769709944725037,
-0.004086513537913561,
0.23097814619541168,
0.27698466181755066,
-0.32343432307243347,
0.3665574789047241,
-0.1457645446062088,
0.32257211208343506,
-0.8824416399002075,
0.08578392118215561,
-0.1897951066493988,
-0.31288811564445496,
0.3777656853199005,
-0.12429998070001602,
0.29620492458343506,
0.19811993837356567,
-0.5308380126953125,
0.12527862191200256,
-0.6228055953979492,
-0.08421704173088074,
0.0943625271320343,
0.2633867859840393,
-0.10781042277812958,
0.1699645072221756,
-0.09072338789701462,
0.6698830723762512,
-0.11272011697292328,
-0.14190974831581116,
0.21079547703266144,
-0.3371002674102783,
-0.2680518925189972,
0.04495015740394592,
0.6258518695831299,
0.11315599828958511,
0.1811254322528839,
-0.42875567078590393,
-0.05315958335995674,
-0.1430165320634842,
0.26228490471839905,
-0.7467337250709534,
-0.05304247513413429,
0.41571488976478577,
-0.49348369240760803,
-0.2957085072994232,
-0.49657636880874634,
-0.4383881092071533,
-0.3446677327156067,
-0.22549282014369965,
0.6681779623031616,
-0.2493671029806137,
-0.6784273982048035,
0.22626803815364838,
0.0008926061564125121,
0.4216195046901703,
0.15064698457717896,
-0.9700559377670288,
0.33980056643486023,
0.7472129464149475,
1.0307790040969849,
-0.464996337890625,
-0.4347085654735565,
-0.5773174166679382,
0.25197166204452515,
-0.2728125751018524,
0.8432620167732239,
-0.5649775266647339,
-0.3652200400829315,
0.04731811583042145,
-0.30206552147865295,
-0.1469922512769699,
-0.5336418747901917,
0.5992066264152527,
-0.5822761058807373,
0.27917101979255676,
0.12284757196903229,
-0.7920123338699341,
-0.25174134969711304,
-0.07370787858963013,
-0.4404447376728058,
0.7793503999710083,
-0.09163277596235275,
-0.6187794804573059,
0.21028092503547668,
-0.9589105844497681,
-0.3816940486431122,
0.2665819227695465,
0.18455593287944794,
-0.2561681270599365,
0.11263304203748703,
0.15213118493556976,
0.5354769229888916,
-0.06278838217258453,
0.4399504065513611,
-0.26523375511169434,
-0.22022853791713715,
-0.1370171308517456,
-0.31950831413269043,
0.6881059408187866,
0.29631760716438293,
-0.3302059769630432,
0.4718532860279083,
-0.6882143616676331,
0.3242795765399933,
0.0811426118016243,
-0.32587867975234985,
0.07111182063817978,
0.21374131739139557,
0.6043431162834167,
-0.00009247588604921475,
0.22007283568382263,
-0.6731863617897034,
0.07060453295707703,
-0.36413267254829407,
0.959227442741394,
0.6167281866073608,
-0.4339832365512848,
0.41839471459388733,
-0.18600234389305115,
0.38786405324935913,
-0.31888967752456665,
0.1487300992012024,
-0.08721932023763657,
-0.31051915884017944,
-0.3628319203853607,
-0.4069487750530243,
0.06899651139974594,
0.6899052858352661,
-0.6985482573509216,
-0.09175790846347809,
-0.1334937959909439,
-0.35418054461479187,
-0.7546543478965759,
0.06590809673070908,
0.6270855665206909,
0.30839240550994873,
0.41221827268600464,
0.031352654099464417,
-0.49688202142715454,
-0.8640125393867493,
-0.29444873332977295,
0.027651043608784676,
0.22343669831752777,
0.06598836183547974,
0.07130483537912369,
-0.1312902420759201,
0.7016251683235168,
-0.3692574203014374,
-0.4078473150730133,
-0.6768131852149963,
-0.10564246773719788,
0.1516249030828476,
0.17947666347026825,
0.2908078134059906,
-0.5967394709587097,
-0.4630126953125,
-0.1773177981376648,
-0.5806668996810913,
-0.19680629670619965,
0.2354641854763031,
-0.1486268937587738,
-0.001712141209281981,
0.35819703340530396,
-0.5110507607460022,
-0.07667256146669388,
0.7850810885429382,
-0.19037392735481262,
0.33131930232048035,
-0.304227352142334,
-0.19349876046180725,
-1.182716965675354,
0.05106797441840172,
-0.42067569494247437,
-0.47874540090560913,
-1.129664421081543,
0.1308884173631668,
-0.012790660373866558,
-0.3146393597126007,
-0.6318795084953308,
0.715496838092804,
-0.39157170057296753,
-0.07374942302703857,
-0.653192937374115,
0.1285468190908432,
0.02623060904443264,
0.4406767189502716,
0.3183372914791107,
0.9290945529937744,
0.7480879426002502,
-0.38207677006721497,
0.3066863715648651,
0.2283935844898224,
-0.2256317138671875,
0.25174519419670105,
-0.6712625622749329,
0.5291039347648621,
0.04986259713768959,
0.28950682282447815,
-0.825449526309967,
-0.20203888416290283,
-0.09049693495035172,
-0.32127901911735535,
0.32157278060913086,
0.09122402220964432,
-0.1919247806072235,
-0.06995843350887299,
-0.3071218430995941,
0.14463044703006744,
0.4099855124950409,
-0.7024794816970825,
0.7573110461235046,
0.6260637044906616,
-0.35499370098114014,
-0.6101164221763611,
-0.6768993139266968,
0.27761945128440857,
-0.1482979655265808,
-0.7589457631111145,
0.5011348128318787,
-0.11495287716388702,
0.023105792701244354,
-0.11637792736291885,
0.12723585963249207,
-0.26362913846969604,
-0.17517860233783722,
0.01759624481201172,
0.07603654265403748,
-0.2690069079399109,
-0.030385825783014297,
-0.052145592868328094,
-0.3170325458049774,
-0.3069410026073456,
-0.7571895718574524,
0.40495723485946655,
-0.2212827503681183,
-0.0667898878455162,
-0.6224061846733093,
0.6314783096313477,
0.530911922454834,
-0.4506725072860718,
0.5096925497055054,
0.7252825498580933,
-0.2618953585624695,
-0.5147422552108765,
-0.6485933661460876,
-0.0674673393368721,
-0.49007028341293335,
0.5220260620117188,
-0.5493521094322205,
-1.0555130243301392,
0.3032907545566559,
0.027955902740359306,
0.5297715663909912,
0.048892054706811905,
0.531071126461029,
-0.2426043152809143,
0.7253308296203613,
0.7168159484863281,
-0.20259356498718262,
0.6240074634552002,
-0.2712406516075134,
-0.027968116104602814,
-0.6886802911758423,
-0.06531093269586563,
-0.1741171032190323,
-0.12789832055568695,
-0.20633892714977264,
-0.48396623134613037,
0.24620959162712097,
-0.07477433234453201,
0.11983434855937958,
0.049493156373500824,
-0.559321939945221,
0.5973671674728394,
0.4977712631225586,
0.08244702965021133,
0.32778599858283997,
0.052385177463293076,
-0.11054615676403046,
0.09752117842435837,
-0.7318115830421448,
-0.4871187210083008,
1.0574003458023071,
0.24394023418426514,
0.5703871846199036,
0.1010848730802536,
0.6531611084938049,
0.2088301032781601,
-0.03987771272659302,
-0.684768557548523,
0.4993247985839844,
-0.5701760649681091,
-0.31177395582199097,
-0.42870253324508667,
-0.14423875510692596,
-0.7663376927375793,
0.5733007192611694,
0.20974817872047424,
-0.6909164786338806,
-0.14469186961650848,
0.49760422110557556,
-0.3176046311855316,
0.3856464624404907,
-0.9054481983184814,
0.8615731000900269,
-0.1485876441001892,
-0.44404137134552,
-0.3990412652492523,
-0.6114638447761536,
0.21949362754821777,
0.1751076728105545,
0.2883937656879425,
-0.020200978964567184,
-0.15273787081241608,
0.6902217864990234,
-0.23082852363586426,
0.6683833003044128,
-0.40316474437713623,
0.0022253941278904676,
0.3683188259601593,
-0.09918216615915298,
0.5689795017242432,
-0.4981406331062317,
-0.03688833490014076,
0.1704029142856598,
0.028356974944472313,
-0.324322372674942,
-0.3930721580982208,
0.5783552527427673,
-0.8090387582778931,
-0.48110878467559814,
-0.2964881360530853,
-0.494651198387146,
-0.40928831696510315,
0.20017214119434357,
0.24165895581245422,
0.7407605648040771,
-0.20379064977169037,
0.003092818660661578,
0.7379848957061768,
-0.03527418151497841,
0.6606955528259277,
0.5997822284698486,
-0.32931530475616455,
-0.39236214756965637,
1.1266835927963257,
-0.014433157630264759,
0.46066156029701233,
0.49999314546585083,
0.40828365087509155,
-0.7533490657806396,
-0.9047060608863831,
-0.703113317489624,
0.16401514410972595,
-0.4358725845813751,
0.22302594780921936,
-0.7003492116928101,
-0.30853646993637085,
-0.33699706196784973,
0.012369614094495773,
-0.5660456418991089,
-0.17026548087596893,
-0.23213763535022736,
-0.21437853574752808,
0.16610242426395416,
0.8331024050712585,
-0.3000636398792267,
0.3414243161678314,
-0.6798050403594971,
0.4169904589653015,
0.41120851039886475,
0.36953920125961304,
0.09851142764091492,
-0.5781282782554626,
-0.18884062767028809,
-0.27954065799713135,
-0.26958131790161133,
-0.6675969958305359,
0.23257412016391754,
0.8258855938911438,
0.5314285159111023,
0.527376115322113,
-0.2573293149471283,
0.6345265507698059,
-0.8306830525398254,
0.6322569251060486,
0.11676403880119324,
-0.9783099293708801,
0.3511267304420471,
-0.4367504119873047,
0.5694433450698853,
0.401881605386734,
0.03558942303061485,
-0.74576336145401,
-0.3754640519618988,
-0.3726876974105835,
-0.7427533864974976,
0.8457422256469727,
0.207627534866333,
0.03977081924676895,
0.4830598831176758,
0.009254631586372852,
0.3619484007358551,
0.1586468517780304,
-0.41225704550743103,
-0.013975748792290688,
-0.4872877299785614,
-0.3320136070251465,
-0.1963234543800354,
-0.2786197364330292,
0.15726245939731598,
0.04951151832938194,
0.5988087058067322,
0.021627575159072876,
0.593783974647522,
-0.03610475733876228,
-0.20348481833934784,
0.11044586449861526,
0.59397292137146,
0.8424097895622253,
0.81351238489151,
-0.11394082009792328,
0.27222713828086853,
0.03189737722277641,
-0.6666882038116455,
0.09039483219385147,
0.13983000814914703,
-0.1589760184288025,
-0.10789567977190018,
0.5346213579177856,
1.1328638792037964,
0.2663951516151428,
-0.44738414883613586,
0.4066087305545807,
0.09425672143697739,
-0.3195693790912628,
-0.05047468841075897,
0.13838006556034088,
0.5750700831413269,
0.404742568731308,
0.1967664659023285,
-0.11690293997526169,
0.37220802903175354,
-0.42970040440559387,
0.2101656049489975,
0.3423844575881958,
-0.18893368542194366,
-0.38785868883132935,
0.7767724990844727,
0.43205511569976807,
-0.2489909678697586,
0.3100196123123169,
-0.08279618620872498,
-0.5745190382003784,
0.2911715805530548,
0.5951062440872192,
0.9528541564941406,
-0.3686276972293854,
0.3247905373573303,
-0.03737916052341461,
-0.014349729754030704,
-0.045288778841495514,
0.6333231329917908,
-0.09915176779031754,
-0.6914427280426025,
-0.6296854615211487,
-0.6926767826080322,
-0.4679211676120758,
0.25053852796554565,
-0.4057009220123291,
-0.20814836025238037,
-0.10632363706827164,
-0.07617855072021484,
0.06541198492050171,
-0.12786003947257996,
-0.406825453042984,
-0.0358983613550663,
0.3189502954483032,
0.6457006335258484,
-0.47929486632347107,
1.0143356323242188,
0.6971619725227356,
-0.00030937985866330564,
-0.8470274209976196,
-0.30580276250839233,
0.185472771525383,
-0.971138060092926,
0.40228766202926636,
0.03231815621256828,
-0.4856780767440796,
0.4584996700286865,
-0.2911326289176941,
-0.9421107769012451,
0.9324602484703064,
0.33880627155303955,
-0.707434356212616,
-0.22245484590530396,
0.08766164630651474,
0.36938750743865967,
-0.2270839363336563,
0.4855056405067444,
0.31210091710090637,
0.34243568778038025,
0.3955245018005371,
-1.2259024381637573,
-0.2553301155567169,
0.03171350061893463,
0.08010731637477875,
0.21301044523715973,
-0.8957481384277344,
0.43752115964889526,
-0.41026464104652405,
-0.2894202470779419,
-0.1825008988380432,
0.6877933144569397,
0.04524204879999161,
0.27626514434814453,
0.4416288733482361,
0.5072759985923767,
0.7229090929031372,
0.04813376069068909,
0.8796815872192383,
-0.2329501509666443,
0.24865712225437164,
1.181553602218628,
-0.2752295136451721,
1.2006187438964844,
0.2308223992586136,
-0.2605345845222473,
-0.032001595944166183,
0.6660274863243103,
0.358256995677948,
1.0098596811294556,
0.1749974638223648,
-0.3716253936290741,
-0.2967817187309265,
-0.2610648572444916,
-0.35473373532295227,
0.5327908992767334,
0.19109639525413513,
0.1810244470834732,
-0.3547116219997406,
0.519133448600769,
0.02528110332787037,
-0.18864937126636505,
-0.4475255608558655,
1.0237126350402832,
0.39873453974723816,
-0.41079527139663696,
0.5307217240333557,
-0.0883210226893425,
0.8682811856269836,
-0.8515997529029846,
0.04253331944346428,
-0.14032581448554993,
0.30961036682128906,
-0.3569585382938385,
-0.626379132270813,
0.3060401380062103,
0.11148146539926529,
-0.08345790952444077,
-0.6139863133430481,
0.9299079775810242,
-0.6590442061424255,
-0.19687381386756897,
0.46013617515563965,
0.5278072357177734,
0.42568880319595337,
-0.20949964225292206,
-0.6448987126350403,
0.1210717037320137,
0.07094501703977585,
-0.2366306334733963,
0.21992017328739166,
0.007064568344503641,
0.13924968242645264,
0.8340426087379456,
0.6138052344322205,
0.4594556987285614,
0.4178771674633026,
0.4056544303894043,
0.6766363978385925,
-0.32787322998046875,
-0.6280701756477356,
-0.8447802662849426,
0.3908269703388214,
0.15481720864772797,
-0.2844153940677643,
0.2535285949707031,
0.4352211654186249,
0.616686224937439,
0.01855490542948246,
0.8150091171264648,
0.11761534959077835,
0.6779798865318298,
-0.4628504514694214,
0.8312088847160339,
-0.5876254439353943,
-0.26644355058670044,
0.00028697183006443083,
-0.9057618379592896,
-0.06496565043926239,
0.4261191189289093,
-0.13794977962970734,
-0.039834920316934586,
0.8146273493766785,
0.5608148574829102,
-0.06785684823989868,
0.3625890612602234,
0.5258230566978455,
0.2720084488391876,
0.365268349647522,
0.7309883832931519,
0.5939127802848816,
-0.04751583933830261,
0.6602641940116882,
-0.03916111961007118,
-0.30320218205451965,
-0.026947345584630966,
-0.6858830451965332,
-0.7220267057418823,
-0.5421741604804993,
-0.21168529987335205,
0.2371699959039688,
0.43540990352630615,
0.9061355590820312,
0.9572545886039734,
-0.8266097903251648,
-0.41031941771507263,
0.010355462320148945,
-0.2216651737689972,
-0.20668692886829376,
-0.15986838936805725,
0.6081467270851135,
-0.4327530860900879,
-0.6853626370429993,
0.7231951951980591,
0.40966492891311646,
-0.24399583041667938,
-0.2789430320262909,
-0.09449419379234314,
-0.0974213108420372,
-0.03579534962773323,
0.8437862396240234,
0.09105059504508972,
-0.7470098733901978,
-0.06400147825479507,
-0.020263055339455605,
-0.07745268940925598,
0.11485467106103897,
0.7204009294509888,
-0.3803250193595886,
0.5761000514030457,
0.3512521982192993,
0.9118117094039917,
0.6615422368049622,
-0.15933731198310852,
0.6048316359519958,
-0.38911110162734985,
-0.036558110266923904,
0.3041687309741974,
0.08272521942853928,
0.2230876386165619,
-0.2733458876609802,
0.29959940910339355,
0.11674215644598007,
-0.6050626039505005,
-0.49670541286468506,
0.16104863584041595,
-1.0485477447509766,
-0.13923737406730652,
0.9511714577674866,
-0.27233076095581055,
0.003261183388531208,
-0.25974956154823303,
-0.12356314063072205,
0.24960272014141083,
-0.5973578691482544,
0.38240736722946167,
0.8528374433517456,
-0.4316106140613556,
-0.4990791380405426,
-0.7836579084396362,
0.6123535633087158,
0.372411847114563,
-0.8935641050338745,
0.09312739968299866,
0.18060845136642456,
0.32768866419792175,
-0.2817062735557556,
0.9673943519592285,
0.06162549555301666,
0.021151911467313766,
0.019784439355134964,
0.05484883114695549,
-0.5557646751403809,
-0.38207849860191345,
-0.1857588142156601,
0.3923909068107605,
0.09503553807735443,
-0.6006627678871155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19951v1 | Mining Reasons For And Against Vaccination From Unstructured Data Using Nichesourcing and AI Data Augmentation | 2024-06-28T14:36:31 | 2024-06-28T14:36:31 | Damián Ariel Furman, Juan Junqueras, Z. Burçe Gümüslü, Edgar Altszyler, Joaquin Navajas, Ophelia Deroy, Justin Sulik | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Reasons For and Against Vaccination (RFAV), a dataset for
predicting reasons for and against vaccination, and scientific authorities used
to justify them, annotated through nichesourcing and augmented using GPT4 and
GPT3.5-Turbo. We show how it is possible to mine these reasons in
non-structured text, under different task definitions, despite the high level
of subjectivity involved and explore the impact of artificially augmented data
using in-context learning with GPT4 and GPT3.5-Turbo. We publish the dataset
and the trained models along with the annotation manual used to train
annotators and define the task. | [
-0.05565350875258446,
-0.55177241563797,
0.4114234149456024,
-0.32826486229896545,
-0.32763466238975525,
-0.23988394439220428,
0.04319705441594124,
-0.4431905746459961,
0.10865914076566696,
0.37561896443367004,
-0.3786027431488037,
-0.5913074016571045,
-0.402784526348114,
0.29223746061325073,
-0.4257008731365204,
1.3324828147888184,
0.18831542134284973,
-0.06842602789402008,
-0.6660723686218262,
-0.05866377055644989,
-0.4747416079044342,
-0.7913943529129028,
-0.2704634368419647,
-0.41104310750961304,
0.604655921459198,
0.7933094501495361,
0.20471008121967316,
0.3354406952857971,
0.0746326819062233,
0.21802355349063873,
0.16787630319595337,
0.04688352346420288,
-0.12346462160348892,
0.19926230609416962,
-0.47150111198425293,
-0.42265525460243225,
-0.11602626740932465,
0.1656607836484909,
0.309120237827301,
0.3257253170013428,
-0.03285612910985947,
0.1416846662759781,
-0.08528073877096176,
0.21569456160068512,
-0.41635584831237793,
0.2095935046672821,
-0.7103837132453918,
-0.039130374789237976,
-0.5599320530891418,
-0.5581357479095459,
-0.16777817904949188,
0.341510534286499,
0.1670701950788498,
-0.7574050426483154,
0.5883559584617615,
-0.3389449715614319,
0.7035492658615112,
0.20742355287075043,
-0.5306016802787781,
-0.20227041840553284,
-0.49490484595298767,
0.7283536791801453,
-0.41100865602493286,
-0.14814557135105133,
0.756344199180603,
-0.07480189204216003,
-0.1578831970691681,
-0.7480023503303528,
-0.3044640123844147,
0.026894893497228622,
-0.07961294054985046,
0.153311088681221,
-0.34377771615982056,
0.26940256357192993,
0.2620111107826233,
0.26133662462234497,
-0.6408436894416809,
-0.0506172850728035,
-0.5582181215286255,
-0.15177735686302185,
0.5805535912513733,
-0.01718159206211567,
0.3955325484275818,
-0.4318389892578125,
-0.19959275424480438,
0.18721751868724823,
-0.69233238697052,
0.40623247623443604,
0.30066174268722534,
0.38765567541122437,
0.14846199750900269,
0.6780745387077332,
-0.32020309567451477,
0.7804220914840698,
-0.02465190552175045,
-0.07678600400686264,
0.28960585594177246,
-0.6143863201141357,
-0.20519790053367615,
0.14523369073867798,
0.4782566726207733,
0.2763645052909851,
-0.10290698707103729,
-0.20155645906925201,
-0.03755083680152893,
-0.14298653602600098,
0.39097559452056885,
-0.8094208836555481,
-0.03354153037071228,
0.33265554904937744,
-0.43286722898483276,
-0.3996131122112274,
0.10110446065664291,
-0.8104114532470703,
-0.2811915874481201,
-0.09124942868947983,
0.3802153170108795,
-0.3700232207775116,
-0.03949030116200447,
-0.03629879280924797,
-0.7154433727264404,
0.16045741736888885,
0.30925890803337097,
-1.0025663375854492,
0.009013928472995758,
0.7895459532737732,
1.0029577016830444,
0.10359341651201248,
-0.028126463294029236,
-0.42485159635543823,
0.17096774280071259,
-0.008136104792356491,
1.2917019128799438,
-0.7521427869796753,
-0.5082293748855591,
-0.2558198571205139,
-0.0656311884522438,
0.176662877202034,
-0.41354992985725403,
0.5264067649841309,
-0.18042805790901184,
0.41468700766563416,
-0.36950451135635376,
-0.3089908957481384,
-0.43252113461494446,
0.2586704194545746,
-0.4513443112373352,
0.756004273891449,
0.3278968334197998,
-0.9069768190383911,
0.7936794757843018,
-0.5902208089828491,
-0.8128921985626221,
0.6217018961906433,
-0.30487293004989624,
-0.5137104988098145,
0.021723248064517975,
0.2998206317424774,
0.2765052914619446,
-0.36565226316452026,
0.2504507601261139,
-0.35559171438217163,
-0.1891009509563446,
-0.10161159187555313,
-0.23258374631404877,
0.8841341137886047,
-0.18646839261054993,
-0.36749157309532166,
0.42980054020881653,
-0.4690793454647064,
-0.14724092185497284,
-0.1263759285211563,
-0.29598984122276306,
-0.6295586824417114,
0.34876549243927,
0.04253225773572922,
0.26194101572036743,
-0.10987931489944458,
-0.5048282742500305,
0.4346332550048828,
-0.5711472630500793,
0.8834937810897827,
0.504200279712677,
0.5197880864143372,
0.17462222278118134,
-0.4995444715023041,
0.6968216896057129,
0.0207152608782053,
0.20411573350429535,
-0.11686231195926666,
-1.0268816947937012,
0.026850083842873573,
-0.4259519577026367,
0.3212943375110626,
0.5571895837783813,
-0.6517539024353027,
0.12990783154964447,
-0.06276394426822662,
-0.3216821849346161,
-0.3027490973472595,
0.048826757818460464,
-0.1341964155435562,
0.8164349794387817,
0.5312651991844177,
-0.10313679277896881,
-0.9380507469177246,
-0.8549582362174988,
-0.13736817240715027,
-0.1687794029712677,
-0.04020744189620018,
0.18796153366565704,
0.6841379404067993,
-0.34648218750953674,
1.0374563932418823,
-0.09011824429035187,
-0.40234071016311646,
-0.24087445437908173,
0.282857745885849,
0.24564318358898163,
0.4702376425266266,
0.762384295463562,
-0.9522271156311035,
-0.11160597205162048,
0.3129308521747589,
-0.41340991854667664,
-0.12105906754732132,
0.004779995419085026,
0.4252353012561798,
-0.0765325054526329,
0.25422486662864685,
-0.804393470287323,
0.8288391828536987,
0.08013509213924408,
-0.07888386398553848,
0.5187598466873169,
0.12901446223258972,
0.29065951704978943,
-1.042177438735962,
0.2538534998893738,
0.23956091701984406,
-0.37951746582984924,
-0.8457667827606201,
-0.16221430897712708,
-0.26813817024230957,
0.025717679411172867,
-0.5023621916770935,
0.5840991735458374,
-0.1514245718717575,
0.34573420882225037,
-0.3590672016143799,
-0.3393441140651703,
0.12332937866449356,
-0.08884721994400024,
0.036845799535512924,
0.6743142008781433,
0.5397579669952393,
-0.47869187593460083,
0.5006457567214966,
0.26420456171035767,
-0.11686743050813675,
0.2809828221797943,
-0.6374127268791199,
-0.48662257194519043,
-0.21696168184280396,
0.48873448371887207,
-0.4617810547351837,
-0.5093693137168884,
0.5608454346656799,
-0.7745545506477356,
-0.06290028989315033,
-0.5921871066093445,
-0.22836022078990936,
-0.3155291676521301,
-0.3010643422603607,
0.42699092626571655,
0.43115514516830444,
-0.45510250329971313,
0.5308303833007812,
0.6663667559623718,
-0.03423460200428963,
-0.652018666267395,
-0.6426045298576355,
0.08088289201259613,
-0.6492094993591309,
-0.18155664205551147,
0.5824233293533325,
0.22371946275234222,
-0.22263549268245697,
0.08893860876560211,
-0.11266497522592545,
-0.15757274627685547,
0.03513604402542114,
0.37936386466026306,
0.0038640194106847048,
-0.031399503350257874,
0.27573779225349426,
-0.06743009388446808,
-0.15324100852012634,
0.2762936055660248,
-0.4276396930217743,
0.07676646113395691,
0.25090470910072327,
-0.1403425931930542,
-0.18489395081996918,
0.698334813117981,
0.2657519280910492,
-0.013115053996443748,
0.4446117877960205,
0.4423985779285431,
-0.7348384261131287,
-0.08934632688760757,
-0.1789090782403946,
-0.26358675956726074,
-0.3678448498249054,
0.18193531036376953,
-0.006758570671081543,
-0.7175272703170776,
0.3936135768890381,
0.2968129515647888,
0.04345697909593582,
0.6841827630996704,
0.7453920245170593,
-0.02215183712542057,
1.1500627994537354,
0.5104966163635254,
0.03091839887201786,
0.4820137619972229,
-0.0071284049190580845,
-0.10844358801841736,
-0.406007319688797,
-0.47460103034973145,
-0.39673346281051636,
0.12388931959867477,
-0.5930027961730957,
-0.5501042008399963,
0.33175787329673767,
-0.07106859982013702,
0.05295844376087189,
-0.09563437849283218,
-0.6470177173614502,
0.3637075424194336,
0.5745099186897278,
0.062429990619421005,
0.02863956056535244,
0.06987358629703522,
0.09870349615812302,
0.115194171667099,
-1.0240238904953003,
-0.2764763832092285,
1.0641229152679443,
0.16109327971935272,
0.2794087827205658,
0.027529409155249596,
0.26164156198501587,
0.4396468997001648,
0.5567982196807861,
-0.8998785614967346,
0.08955305814743042,
-0.08177073299884796,
-0.9986099004745483,
-0.10831698030233383,
-0.3339628279209137,
-1.180860161781311,
0.08075031638145447,
-0.34228524565696716,
-0.7385150194168091,
0.3856792449951172,
0.2613622546195984,
-0.399260014295578,
-0.012359567917883396,
-0.749487042427063,
0.7675188779830933,
-0.1426677256822586,
-0.30001741647720337,
-0.05638231709599495,
-0.6896001100540161,
0.3597486913204193,
-0.016134722158312798,
-0.012558515183627605,
0.04167383164167404,
-0.06296622008085251,
0.6118475794792175,
-0.8119382262229919,
0.9654012322425842,
-0.15291225910186768,
0.3886316418647766,
0.46147027611732483,
-0.7890915870666504,
0.013808321207761765,
0.7113803029060364,
-0.17638108134269714,
0.35492539405822754,
-0.006344441324472427,
-0.5097964406013489,
-0.2223626971244812,
0.5704973936080933,
-0.5191851258277893,
-0.9741555452346802,
-0.9958807826042175,
-0.32281169295310974,
0.04493943974375725,
0.2719933092594147,
0.5488383769989014,
0.39222100377082825,
-0.12118717283010483,
0.47749704122543335,
0.5931119322776794,
-0.07015743851661682,
0.24617038667201996,
0.42850857973098755,
0.26963457465171814,
-0.39570748805999756,
0.8061739802360535,
0.2774515748023987,
-0.23922041058540344,
0.5253905653953552,
0.4689951539039612,
-0.401297390460968,
-0.6198795437812805,
-0.5618106722831726,
-0.15590888261795044,
-0.5941131114959717,
-0.5628699660301208,
-0.795988917350769,
-0.25778087973594666,
-0.6884886026382446,
0.14221151173114777,
0.1577327996492386,
-0.17120221257209778,
-0.5686376690864563,
-0.21760866045951843,
0.8656799793243408,
0.8448559045791626,
-0.45147472620010376,
0.06714044511318207,
-0.645737886428833,
0.14276237785816193,
0.1767825484275818,
0.103931725025177,
-0.33379310369491577,
-0.23369929194450378,
-0.35945025086402893,
0.06659382581710815,
-0.12681400775909424,
-1.0607335567474365,
0.33499446511268616,
0.19306035339832306,
0.7352264523506165,
0.3011262118816376,
0.0015494631370529532,
0.774675726890564,
-0.33824244141578674,
0.6409426927566528,
-0.33368220925331116,
-0.9466414451599121,
0.8534448742866516,
-0.6241166591644287,
0.1521284580230713,
0.4552067220211029,
0.49462777376174927,
-0.4308074414730072,
-0.19529640674591064,
-0.7321816682815552,
-1.1719244718551636,
0.6655791997909546,
0.0954643189907074,
-0.34050777554512024,
-0.0020577411632984877,
0.5855540037155151,
0.322316974401474,
0.1315559595823288,
-0.5885499119758606,
0.01558646745979786,
-0.6639367341995239,
-0.07411327213048935,
-0.1431788057088852,
-0.08250779658555984,
-0.38549932837486267,
-0.4709126651287079,
0.7188764810562134,
-0.09848518669605255,
-0.002834308659657836,
0.38835325837135315,
-0.2057826817035675,
-0.06685807555913925,
0.12138540297746658,
0.7663841247558594,
0.7557679414749146,
-0.16672508418560028,
0.007658045738935471,
0.1095946729183197,
-0.5540969967842102,
0.21855038404464722,
0.45182004570961,
-0.5114814639091492,
0.10696318000555038,
0.7126971483230591,
0.5460430383682251,
-0.18900376558303833,
-0.7496783137321472,
0.5962450504302979,
0.011295190081000328,
-0.38311082124710083,
-0.36152705550193787,
0.09233953058719635,
-0.21361000835895538,
-0.12229570746421814,
0.44717466831207275,
-0.007749856915324926,
0.46564725041389465,
-0.4104572534561157,
0.5014832615852356,
0.6964239478111267,
-0.24332818388938904,
-0.47580331563949585,
0.5643316507339478,
0.08834854513406754,
0.12696774303913116,
0.40703436732292175,
0.08128506690263748,
-0.2446768432855606,
0.6069282293319702,
0.5194801092147827,
0.35143882036209106,
-0.42846906185150146,
0.4685869812965393,
0.5439624786376953,
0.31130942702293396,
-0.03528447076678276,
0.19374224543571472,
-0.16437311470508575,
-0.3438570499420166,
-0.5901673436164856,
-0.1704321950674057,
-0.3023335635662079,
0.6613692045211792,
-0.6061498522758484,
0.30953696370124817,
-0.2346869856119156,
-0.16331499814987183,
0.30247730016708374,
-0.07574349641799927,
-0.464070588350296,
0.22399568557739258,
-0.19260390102863312,
0.7765622735023499,
-1.2156736850738525,
0.8425236940383911,
0.9401841759681702,
-0.7741114497184753,
-0.25561031699180603,
0.14684300124645233,
0.11440833657979965,
-0.6169030070304871,
0.38795965909957886,
0.3286847472190857,
0.2379073202610016,
-0.304420530796051,
-0.1947217732667923,
-0.7580614686012268,
0.84623783826828,
0.0024725887924432755,
-0.32717061042785645,
0.10469213128089905,
-0.020318742841482162,
0.4300496280193329,
-0.34847918152809143,
0.27862128615379333,
0.4498424530029297,
0.5825369954109192,
0.010301021859049797,
-0.2774350643157959,
-0.06763536483049393,
-0.5036367774009705,
-0.3636203408241272,
0.09422799199819565,
-0.2905929684638977,
0.6287052631378174,
-0.23203060030937195,
-0.238121896982193,
-0.2893858551979065,
0.6013849973678589,
0.15141741931438446,
0.5835996270179749,
0.3989512622356415,
0.4453311562538147,
0.6072092652320862,
-0.10833903402090073,
0.9331710338592529,
0.15186290442943573,
-0.011926558800041676,
0.7459294199943542,
-0.14268313348293304,
0.43619459867477417,
0.48292726278305054,
0.2691882252693176,
0.24082256853580475,
1.1195422410964966,
-0.021686282008886337,
0.5942355990409851,
0.04113385081291199,
-0.4441283643245697,
-0.24078521132469177,
-0.3680349886417389,
-0.5698468089103699,
0.5985543131828308,
0.8164514899253845,
-0.18792380392551422,
-0.2693442106246948,
0.2512928545475006,
-0.15402953326702118,
-0.29638972878456116,
-0.3734479546546936,
0.8913198113441467,
-0.20115959644317627,
-0.6348455548286438,
0.2714962363243103,
0.16196763515472412,
0.3648839294910431,
-0.527764618396759,
-0.18393145501613617,
0.14536640048027039,
0.08846171200275421,
-0.4736342132091522,
-0.7329220175743103,
0.5600491166114807,
0.17702338099479675,
-0.5546846985816956,
-0.21225595474243164,
0.9607006907463074,
-0.35808345675468445,
-0.37562376260757446,
-0.027465375140309334,
0.39558783173561096,
-0.04296460002660751,
-0.008167030289769173,
-0.9428419470787048,
-0.2677284777164459,
-0.08333825320005417,
-0.36450833082199097,
0.2826736867427826,
0.38386455178260803,
-0.4495856463909149,
0.3269415497779846,
0.8712409734725952,
0.25393977761268616,
-0.469352662563324,
-0.06518079340457916,
0.8777724504470825,
-0.607131838798523,
-0.4216183125972748,
-1.1385847330093384,
0.5315033793449402,
-0.16312657296657562,
-0.41036200523376465,
0.962549090385437,
0.7558277249336243,
0.6316114664077759,
0.0966319888830185,
1.2271409034729004,
-0.14413613080978394,
0.5827399492263794,
-0.40934666991233826,
0.5781811475753784,
-0.5336697101593018,
-0.04518566653132439,
0.1283022165298462,
-0.27981576323509216,
-0.44777461886405945,
0.5679906606674194,
-0.2758858799934387,
0.2647245228290558,
0.4577677249908447,
0.6297323107719421,
0.09951990097761154,
-0.07563228160142899,
-0.052480440586805344,
0.13153326511383057,
0.5294174551963806,
0.34371763467788696,
0.6939176917076111,
-0.023251373320817947,
0.3529793322086334,
-0.26992863416671753,
-0.5876598954200745,
-0.4947111904621124,
-1.090279221534729,
-0.9995700120925903,
-0.8092467784881592,
-0.3156297504901886,
-0.44626346230506897,
0.3657178580760956,
1.011782169342041,
0.8869220018386841,
-0.8505387306213379,
0.20353558659553528,
-0.2701640725135803,
0.3913741409778595,
-0.32813653349876404,
-0.22433897852897644,
0.09937723726034164,
-0.15829242765903473,
-0.3460932970046997,
0.5437287092208862,
0.3828542232513428,
0.06550044566392899,
-0.0023403968662023544,
0.3526771366596222,
-0.3919508755207062,
-0.015624801628291607,
0.5577120780944824,
0.8956198692321777,
-0.6739928722381592,
-0.18245956301689148,
-0.42962828278541565,
0.06939834356307983,
0.13749848306179047,
0.8705870509147644,
-1.0177663564682007,
0.4538230299949646,
0.6392194628715515,
0.5109545588493347,
0.2079368382692337,
0.28345799446105957,
0.6835501790046692,
-0.9102387428283691,
0.29538440704345703,
0.4951169192790985,
0.15743783116340637,
0.4166727662086487,
-0.5788983106613159,
0.314572811126709,
0.6007130146026611,
-0.6213052272796631,
-0.8786810636520386,
0.24182003736495972,
-0.8041550517082214,
-0.3229384422302246,
1.3226805925369263,
0.1404794454574585,
-0.4923206865787506,
-0.7255719900131226,
0.047530245035886765,
0.17048200964927673,
-0.5000178813934326,
0.6845167875289917,
0.6462663412094116,
-0.3276444673538208,
-0.035567767918109894,
-0.7410326600074768,
1.0277150869369507,
0.12029880285263062,
-0.9405899047851562,
-0.1301259994506836,
0.25372612476348877,
0.2838429808616638,
-0.3186883330345154,
0.9515353441238403,
0.0917477160692215,
0.5417618751525879,
-0.1057952493429184,
0.07630104571580887,
-0.25654760003089905,
-0.3209490180015564,
-0.39706721901893616,
0.10249198228120804,
-0.020628517493605614,
-0.07445155084133148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19949v1 | Calibrating LLMs with Preference Optimization on Thought Trees for Generating Rationale in Science Question Scoring | 2024-06-28T14:33:05 | 2024-06-28T14:33:05 | Jiazheng Li, Hainiu Xu, Zhaoyue Sun, Yuxiang Zhou, David West, Cesare Aloisi, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating rationales that justify scoring decisions has been a promising way
to facilitate explainability in automated scoring systems. However, existing
methods do not match the accuracy of classifier-based methods. Plus, the
generated rationales often contain hallucinated information. To address these
issues, we propose a novel framework capable of generating more faithful
rationales and, more importantly, matching performance with classifier-based
black-box scoring systems. We first mimic the human assessment process by
querying Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate a thought tree. We then
summarise intermediate assessment decisions from each thought tree path for
creating synthetic rationale data and rationale preference data. Finally, we
utilise the generated synthetic data to calibrate LLMs through a two-step
training process: supervised fine-tuning and preference optimization. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that our framework achieves a 38% assessment
performance improvement in the QWK score compared to prior work while producing
higher-quality rationales, as recognised by human evaluators and LLMs. Our work
sheds light on the effectiveness of performing preference optimization using
synthetic preference data obtained from thought tree paths. | [
-0.3842497169971466,
-0.6036081314086914,
0.8601794838905334,
-0.07157518714666367,
-0.34589827060699463,
0.03788086771965027,
-0.2740579843521118,
-0.26006177067756653,
0.2647014260292053,
0.37254926562309265,
-0.586328387260437,
-0.4025276005268097,
-0.07740727066993713,
0.17814724147319794,
0.08795978873968124,
0.9699582457542419,
-0.05835789069533348,
0.226474791765213,
-0.6171465516090393,
-0.048033252358436584,
-0.3840892016887665,
-0.4150296449661255,
-0.6541959643363953,
-0.48659834265708923,
0.5167136192321777,
0.2891918420791626,
0.6219685673713684,
0.5906667709350586,
0.3164197504520416,
0.16135944426059723,
0.2357875108718872,
0.4520722031593323,
-0.5719008445739746,
0.1795404702425003,
-0.30899572372436523,
-0.6192692518234253,
-0.3333981931209564,
0.1738438755273819,
0.3558696210384369,
0.5513491630554199,
-0.00525430403649807,
0.4545106887817383,
0.0649482011795044,
0.7868607044219971,
-0.5956157445907593,
0.1555992215871811,
-0.8376951217651367,
0.14812758564949036,
0.26388001441955566,
-0.9672287702560425,
-0.5873374938964844,
-0.7820940613746643,
0.20452845096588135,
-0.7222288250923157,
0.23966392874717712,
0.14132648706436157,
0.4949882924556732,
0.44247257709503174,
-0.2838882803916931,
-0.16673560440540314,
-0.5965014100074768,
0.9209490418434143,
-0.6058925986289978,
0.10669149458408356,
0.3767212927341461,
0.5254169702529907,
-0.16886432468891144,
-0.3120897114276886,
-0.3698330521583557,
-0.2613677382469177,
0.024416660889983177,
0.16757135093212128,
0.21066421270370483,
0.06703239679336548,
0.4203115701675415,
0.10866660624742508,
-0.6282253861427307,
-0.16785193979740143,
-0.18989117443561554,
-0.39795926213264465,
0.8747578263282776,
0.2702818512916565,
-0.20247593522071838,
-0.22093044221401215,
-0.1399417370557785,
-0.4557121694087982,
-0.6288749575614929,
0.3768237829208374,
0.4307466149330139,
0.426791787147522,
0.4714427590370178,
0.702375590801239,
-0.252348393201828,
0.6594771146774292,
0.25815728306770325,
-0.18322061002254486,
0.13401128351688385,
-0.12170929461717606,
-0.24117250740528107,
0.26588407158851624,
0.5884426832199097,
0.9132235646247864,
0.26463696360588074,
-0.07736553996801376,
-0.1944555938243866,
0.47495967149734497,
0.43967702984809875,
-1.0100529193878174,
-0.22212301194667816,
0.2959858775138855,
-0.038715243339538574,
-0.6506869792938232,
-0.14517337083816528,
-0.7569698691368103,
-0.35117605328559875,
-0.6943915486335754,
0.36386775970458984,
-0.24239373207092285,
-0.082414910197258,
0.3476616144180298,
-0.06214373931288719,
0.31414756178855896,
0.6163204312324524,
-0.8136588335037231,
0.07392343133687973,
0.5148259401321411,
0.5270227193832397,
-0.2613321840763092,
-0.004234433174133301,
-0.448321133852005,
0.01840721257030964,
-0.7051652073860168,
0.9408355355262756,
-0.6602950692176819,
-0.3533732295036316,
-0.3390946686267853,
-0.2863083779811859,
0.05707509070634842,
-0.5606123208999634,
0.6029489636421204,
-0.4630109667778015,
0.337761253118515,
-0.3802802264690399,
-0.4815979301929474,
-0.33105185627937317,
0.5491026043891907,
-0.22767025232315063,
1.1861367225646973,
0.2553478181362152,
-0.5788382887840271,
0.6610350012779236,
-0.7651787400245667,
-0.07736173272132874,
0.24609428644180298,
-0.2418750524520874,
-0.21621087193489075,
0.02727402187883854,
0.13208521902561188,
0.29923754930496216,
-0.42806485295295715,
0.516106367111206,
-0.4550982713699341,
-0.22830775380134583,
0.2711222767829895,
-0.5083742141723633,
0.5970502495765686,
0.19185122847557068,
-0.28539344668388367,
0.29849138855934143,
-0.6103507876396179,
0.7125959396362305,
-0.12403511255979538,
-0.3298674523830414,
-0.31267136335372925,
0.2491440773010254,
-0.1325717270374298,
0.1287529021501541,
0.06858561187982559,
-0.47889935970306396,
0.10431285202503204,
-0.5006120204925537,
0.4117719829082489,
0.8687050938606262,
0.020832635462284088,
0.3024393320083618,
-0.5968284606933594,
0.5488418936729431,
-0.15988418459892273,
0.01825629360973835,
0.21308229863643646,
-0.31860414147377014,
-0.5143058896064758,
0.1008513793349266,
0.21889419853687286,
0.4242795407772064,
-0.37033340334892273,
0.6495935320854187,
-0.2420779913663864,
-0.6065682172775269,
-0.6330573558807373,
-0.05454153195023537,
0.10973504930734634,
0.7623624205589294,
0.3902592658996582,
-0.20342497527599335,
-0.5816118717193604,
-0.916889488697052,
-0.21229520440101624,
-0.356474369764328,
-0.1610316038131714,
0.6335122585296631,
0.37808874249458313,
-0.05067851021885872,
1.2599401473999023,
-0.651003360748291,
0.03578171879053116,
0.18002323806285858,
-0.07028664648532867,
0.094389908015728,
0.4661784768104553,
0.4196905493736267,
-0.7481603622436523,
-0.33323565125465393,
0.024167533963918686,
-0.6226596236228943,
-0.15291617810726166,
-0.051833976060152054,
-0.40211811661720276,
0.18841248750686646,
0.17423614859580994,
-0.5482123494148254,
0.22854620218276978,
0.17390452325344086,
-0.24383413791656494,
0.9721647500991821,
0.02545274794101715,
0.32727181911468506,
-1.0053144693374634,
0.1885286420583725,
0.11259550601243973,
-0.33463865518569946,
-0.22674356400966644,
0.07955028861761093,
-0.011157572269439697,
0.08729904890060425,
-0.4381325840950012,
0.43713831901550293,
0.04827599972486496,
0.00010164040577365085,
-0.19078513979911804,
-0.004046767018735409,
0.2518558204174042,
0.5669995546340942,
-0.04741888865828514,
0.7797467708587646,
0.4108790457248688,
-0.5105371475219727,
0.2874406576156616,
-0.03770758956670761,
-0.3116425573825836,
0.6435198187828064,
-0.4984244406223297,
0.1904650628566742,
-0.2165055125951767,
0.30124786496162415,
-0.8165704011917114,
-0.4432964622974396,
0.061179567128419876,
-0.4246000647544861,
0.040328845381736755,
-0.11682850122451782,
-0.21425941586494446,
-0.3346123993396759,
-0.6576995253562927,
0.5031697750091553,
0.587372362613678,
-0.454342246055603,
0.5145888924598694,
0.3460414707660675,
0.19076786935329437,
-0.31969746947288513,
-0.42983025312423706,
-0.227949321269989,
-0.51163649559021,
-0.5141018629074097,
0.45896539092063904,
-0.486138254404068,
-0.18616661429405212,
-0.1512610763311386,
-0.39214515686035156,
0.2871328294277191,
0.15552030503749847,
0.2579832077026367,
0.36376953125,
-0.37907674908638,
0.06206219643354416,
0.15546327829360962,
-0.1043872982263565,
0.423537939786911,
-0.4454430937767029,
0.42513084411621094,
-0.19849435985088348,
-0.305923193693161,
-0.25396162271499634,
0.13837355375289917,
0.6807268857955933,
0.010716675780713558,
0.30339598655700684,
0.12781699001789093,
-0.5093552470207214,
-0.3783668875694275,
-0.5084113478660583,
-0.4486044943332672,
-0.49844345450401306,
0.2735629975795746,
-0.4773373007774353,
-0.8184334635734558,
0.1369275003671646,
-0.19744092226028442,
0.20042680203914642,
0.3597513437271118,
0.7074591517448425,
-0.16979378461837769,
1.5089588165283203,
0.17683063447475433,
0.19669315218925476,
0.0900735929608345,
-0.1250515729188919,
0.2542470097541809,
-0.8287397623062134,
-0.2687128782272339,
-0.3918159008026123,
-0.15561412274837494,
-0.6209161877632141,
-0.42877769470214844,
0.4227783679962158,
0.13719026744365692,
-0.282158225774765,
0.045742325484752655,
-0.9336053133010864,
0.8307255506515503,
0.3652092516422272,
0.2476162314414978,
0.13254687190055847,
0.15159380435943604,
-0.42883166670799255,
-0.10004525631666183,
-0.48679375648498535,
-0.975559413433075,
1.2047961950302124,
0.1925407499074936,
0.6169477701187134,
-0.2947583496570587,
0.657927393913269,
0.22154977917671204,
0.598808228969574,
-1.071940541267395,
0.6498929858207703,
0.2900741994380951,
-0.523367702960968,
-0.41966769099235535,
-0.5184500813484192,
-0.7466230988502502,
0.4375457763671875,
-0.25030067563056946,
-0.6374475955963135,
-0.24600750207901,
0.2910529375076294,
-0.5324146151542664,
-0.017026277258992195,
-0.8564391732215881,
0.7566971778869629,
-0.32079756259918213,
-0.6268461346626282,
-0.3878072500228882,
-0.36741331219673157,
0.32458069920539856,
-0.2898169159889221,
0.010409223847091198,
-0.29454267024993896,
0.2758442461490631,
0.8836676478385925,
-0.16450448334217072,
0.5997942686080933,
-0.23215252161026,
0.05117955803871155,
0.1975415050983429,
0.29735371470451355,
0.3058420717716217,
0.3580290675163269,
-0.5906580090522766,
-0.267887681722641,
0.4100642800331116,
-0.3261411488056183,
-0.8551273941993713,
0.7203865051269531,
-0.6780402660369873,
-1.0408999919891357,
-0.5260584950447083,
-0.7388555407524109,
-0.5031003952026367,
0.1217113807797432,
-0.08525614440441132,
0.1607137769460678,
-0.07920607179403305,
0.16090233623981476,
0.32204824686050415,
0.06757395714521408,
0.048972297459840775,
0.4511262774467468,
-0.17797857522964478,
-0.45007872581481934,
0.8650485277175903,
-0.04420609772205353,
0.2039574682712555,
0.18370060622692108,
0.5031375885009766,
-0.5871535539627075,
-0.5895094871520996,
-0.4791286885738373,
0.08491528034210205,
-0.5731976628303528,
-0.42229434847831726,
-0.30387720465660095,
-0.16038087010383606,
-0.2413395792245865,
-0.3182980716228485,
-0.010716347023844719,
-0.5733973979949951,
-0.29466381669044495,
-0.29091671109199524,
0.3336004614830017,
0.434003621339798,
0.17915377020835876,
-0.11250696331262589,
-0.37847578525543213,
0.0797361508011818,
0.34181663393974304,
0.35387417674064636,
-0.07262547314167023,
-0.5190516114234924,
-0.028727812692523003,
0.4583522379398346,
-0.7287673354148865,
-0.5880925059318542,
0.415068656206131,
0.0022910020779818296,
0.40132710337638855,
0.2221594899892807,
0.2510271370410919,
0.8886946439743042,
-0.2815207540988922,
0.6003879904747009,
0.10439005494117737,
-0.6916084289550781,
0.7247725129127502,
-0.20623061060905457,
-0.02643296867609024,
0.8102923631668091,
0.43115681409835815,
-0.10341964662075043,
-0.24775786697864532,
-0.4592774510383606,
-0.5346992611885071,
0.8438568115234375,
0.0558270625770092,
-0.026327038183808327,
0.17482343316078186,
0.5893294811248779,
0.16493995487689972,
0.18335004150867462,
-0.7654480934143066,
0.07786986976861954,
-0.2997663617134094,
-0.3787058889865875,
-0.2771763801574707,
0.01834299974143505,
-0.38582250475883484,
-0.47981783747673035,
0.857599675655365,
-0.6060194373130798,
-0.0745713859796524,
0.23356406390666962,
0.07809519022703171,
-0.5590826869010925,
0.15062212944030762,
0.424297571182251,
0.5765076875686646,
-0.5685579776763916,
0.08685916662216187,
0.24241386353969574,
-0.2154996544122696,
0.2471308559179306,
-0.09762914478778839,
-0.473811537027359,
-0.4492981731891632,
-0.0534147210419178,
0.6512534618377686,
-0.13765761256217957,
-0.7180688977241516,
0.2076493352651596,
0.015476307831704617,
-0.5071224570274353,
-0.1641375720500946,
0.47737517952919006,
0.11037545651197433,
0.13877490162849426,
0.29303625226020813,
0.4825357496738434,
0.15050064027309418,
-0.40994200110435486,
0.13653728365898132,
0.8360058665275574,
-0.2604624032974243,
-0.2848220765590668,
0.4875752031803131,
0.04713933914899826,
-0.39430585503578186,
0.19793330132961273,
-0.14342090487480164,
-0.5391560792922974,
0.5915185213088989,
0.6413020491600037,
0.8263964653015137,
-0.08927496522665024,
0.34219005703926086,
0.6397982835769653,
0.09149045497179031,
-0.12763312458992004,
0.31001758575439453,
-0.3736181855201721,
-0.7593647241592407,
-0.3955293893814087,
-1.0602513551712036,
-0.6213421821594238,
0.14579395949840546,
-0.5579003691673279,
0.38391196727752686,
-0.45015907287597656,
-0.36767512559890747,
0.20028984546661377,
0.2795903980731964,
-0.43087831139564514,
0.37083593010902405,
-0.05764823406934738,
0.7735676765441895,
-0.8130324482917786,
0.7543334364891052,
0.6880156397819519,
-0.14586396515369415,
-0.9697578549385071,
-0.1076785996556282,
-0.22039838135242462,
-0.6200963854789734,
0.3738674223423004,
0.42945849895477295,
-0.29059845209121704,
0.10980422049760818,
-0.4034007787704468,
-0.7950976490974426,
1.0652271509170532,
0.599243700504303,
-0.3803544044494629,
-0.064305379986763,
0.26789718866348267,
0.7947789430618286,
-0.5954572558403015,
0.5334007740020752,
0.6868916749954224,
0.5927287936210632,
0.26359620690345764,
-0.4557388126850128,
0.21084117889404297,
-0.29679107666015625,
-0.1710899919271469,
0.1363716423511505,
-0.3157877027988434,
0.14809639751911163,
-0.2769290804862976,
-0.19749610126018524,
-0.14552448689937592,
0.2862694561481476,
0.7835422158241272,
0.5268229842185974,
0.581277072429657,
0.49186834692955017,
0.8402175307273865,
-0.06102876365184784,
0.8436238765716553,
-0.3211938738822937,
0.27265721559524536,
0.7812401652336121,
-0.566328763961792,
0.8278552889823914,
0.724463701248169,
-0.37879523634910583,
0.4330236315727234,
0.9613421559333801,
0.0290164016187191,
0.4731348156929016,
0.5116305351257324,
-0.19336383044719696,
-0.5576078295707703,
-0.2607930302619934,
-0.06042321026325226,
0.22753164172172546,
0.39907106757164,
-0.23329591751098633,
-0.14310519397258759,
-0.2436744123697281,
-0.4650590717792511,
0.14084073901176453,
-0.21245983242988586,
0.5805344581604004,
-0.04151133447885513,
-1.2762837409973145,
0.8620933294296265,
-0.12093464285135269,
0.38148078322410583,
-0.4995657503604889,
-0.045432496815919876,
0.0637604296207428,
0.028797997161746025,
-0.43371179699897766,
-0.8603895306587219,
0.19825884699821472,
0.0009000049903988838,
-0.20476019382476807,
-0.3096300959587097,
0.3518960773944855,
-0.399763822555542,
-0.5602936744689941,
0.04091714322566986,
0.3341805040836334,
0.22074756026268005,
0.053222425282001495,
-0.704252302646637,
-0.34299376606941223,
0.22014322876930237,
-0.34071582555770874,
0.3775828778743744,
0.3018929958343506,
-0.25820192694664,
0.6722985506057739,
1.1059869527816772,
0.076819509267807,
-0.21481047570705414,
0.12996596097946167,
0.8054028749465942,
-0.5894113779067993,
-0.42886295914649963,
-0.8834295868873596,
0.22337618470191956,
0.04646151885390282,
-0.2172793447971344,
0.5837763547897339,
0.9666212201118469,
0.8230159282684326,
0.00770682143047452,
0.744411051273346,
0.2572813630104065,
0.40479961037635803,
-0.509848415851593,
0.44562745094299316,
-0.5852909088134766,
0.34154289960861206,
-0.20820771157741547,
-1.168209195137024,
-0.41602474451065063,
0.7720186710357666,
-0.42734378576278687,
0.06320550292730331,
0.7307663559913635,
1.3005092144012451,
-0.057143427431583405,
0.2532304525375366,
0.33753496408462524,
-0.0975365936756134,
0.4308139383792877,
0.6871080994606018,
0.9009168744087219,
-0.16480030119419098,
0.3203386962413788,
-0.24692241847515106,
-0.3799642324447632,
-0.2562194764614105,
-0.9364736080169678,
-0.8102793097496033,
-0.4265877306461334,
-0.38456425070762634,
-0.43207070231437683,
-0.185532808303833,
1.2997994422912598,
0.8204851746559143,
-0.9101689457893372,
-0.2763955593109131,
-0.2807869613170624,
-0.06255311518907547,
-0.06141364946961403,
-0.33600515127182007,
0.4607309103012085,
-0.3292352557182312,
-0.46605950593948364,
0.3902479112148285,
0.2626679539680481,
0.07157216221094131,
-0.292900413274765,
-0.31388309597969055,
0.17719270288944244,
0.382355272769928,
0.7360706925392151,
-0.03907578065991402,
-0.9271640181541443,
-0.46503740549087524,
0.1720357984304428,
-0.09368528425693512,
0.2911908030509949,
0.7908210158348083,
-1.1354992389678955,
0.47647204995155334,
0.46595388650894165,
0.5222960114479065,
0.5873822569847107,
0.21594268083572388,
0.5267512798309326,
-0.2972250282764435,
-0.34513941407203674,
0.6610745191574097,
0.18640613555908203,
0.41761264204978943,
-0.38246068358421326,
0.5011367201805115,
0.07914276421070099,
-0.5973258018493652,
-1.1022156476974487,
0.07273011654615402,
-1.171938180923462,
-0.16124208271503448,
1.0826271772384644,
0.23149599134922028,
-0.3290928900241852,
0.03622135892510414,
-0.5497298836708069,
0.08525063842535019,
-0.45069774985313416,
1.090011477470398,
0.6165458559989929,
-0.3548664152622223,
0.18687456846237183,
-0.2491268664598465,
0.7744413018226624,
0.7462928295135498,
-0.8731911778450012,
0.25345802307128906,
0.5474806427955627,
0.28436291217803955,
0.24813212454319,
0.326792448759079,
-0.10864858329296112,
0.525977373123169,
-0.3844989538192749,
-0.1580677330493927,
-0.062469106167554855,
-0.12914931774139404,
-0.06928616762161255,
0.32685840129852295,
0.2273574024438858,
0.18522052466869354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19934v1 | From the Least to the Most: Building a Plug-and-Play Visual Reasoner via Data Synthesis | 2024-06-28T14:04:10 | 2024-06-28T14:04:10 | Chuanqi Cheng, Jian Guan, Wei Wu, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We explore multi-step reasoning in vision-language models (VLMs). The problem
is challenging, as reasoning data consisting of multiple steps of visual and
language processing are barely available. To overcome the challenge, we first
introduce a least-to-most visual reasoning paradigm, which interleaves steps of
decomposing a question into sub-questions and invoking external tools for
resolving sub-questions. Based on the paradigm, we further propose a novel data
synthesis approach that can automatically create questions and multi-step
reasoning paths for an image in a bottom-up manner. Our approach divides the
complex synthesis task into a few simple sub-tasks, and (almost entirely)
relies on open-sourced models to accomplish the sub-tasks. Therefore, the
entire synthesis process is reproducible and cost-efficient, and the
synthesized data is quality guaranteed. With the approach, we construct $50$k
visual reasoning examples. Then, we develop a visual reasoner through
supervised fine-tuning, which is capable of generally enhancing the reasoning
abilities of a wide range of existing VLMs in a plug-and-play fashion.
Extensive experiments indicate that the visual reasoner can consistently and
significantly improve four VLMs on four VQA benchmarks. Our code and dataset
are available at https://github.com/steven-ccq/VisualReasoner. | [
-0.710404098033905,
-0.7486435174942017,
0.9903304576873779,
-0.1107078343629837,
-0.20530235767364502,
-0.1455598622560501,
0.0789695754647255,
-0.3065401017665863,
-0.28782159090042114,
0.6404808759689331,
-0.6611457467079163,
-0.5818450450897217,
-0.08879723399877548,
0.08157500624656677,
-0.5080235600471497,
0.4899761378765106,
-0.1452590674161911,
-0.01880585215985775,
-0.5114811062812805,
-0.05035034567117691,
-0.3852688670158386,
-0.23413853347301483,
-0.33298003673553467,
-0.14192767441272736,
0.7136330604553223,
0.622160792350769,
0.41853755712509155,
0.6887942552566528,
0.4628335237503052,
0.32446855306625366,
0.056805744767189026,
0.5533984303474426,
-0.45011278986930847,
0.1629461646080017,
-0.24711081385612488,
-0.6216524839401245,
-0.10550588369369507,
-0.17067961394786835,
0.009815486147999763,
0.42643314599990845,
0.18093475699424744,
0.285659521818161,
-0.4160935878753662,
0.9734885096549988,
-0.670886218547821,
0.0671767145395279,
-0.7179411053657532,
0.03726732358336449,
-0.053210996091365814,
-0.12888482213020325,
-0.6289475560188293,
-0.20475302636623383,
-0.10899656265974045,
-0.7149088382720947,
0.21841496229171753,
0.21690206229686737,
0.7415792942047119,
0.5083187222480774,
-0.4698719382286072,
0.2808949053287506,
-0.8059687614440918,
0.7581702470779419,
-0.3701504170894623,
0.5892652273178101,
-0.05845043435692787,
0.77944016456604,
-0.1759847104549408,
-0.7504826188087463,
-0.7604269981384277,
-0.02351961098611355,
0.06026763096451759,
0.14421765506267548,
-0.30018991231918335,
-0.17026527225971222,
0.6903647780418396,
0.21460388600826263,
-0.801750123500824,
-0.4627218544483185,
-0.5623037815093994,
-0.002707052743062377,
0.6096527576446533,
0.47194910049438477,
0.27062806487083435,
-0.07166191190481186,
-0.3357775807380676,
-0.16516676545143127,
-0.7641533613204956,
0.14757348597049713,
-0.05754319950938225,
0.1090761125087738,
0.1657627522945404,
0.8809109926223755,
-0.362659752368927,
1.069366455078125,
-0.07035509496927261,
-0.14518727362155914,
-0.15828655660152435,
-0.7092786431312561,
-0.41098523139953613,
-0.21471081674098969,
0.46780818700790405,
0.7333775162696838,
0.21572043001651764,
0.2558888792991638,
-0.25263601541519165,
0.35020267963409424,
0.40010496973991394,
-0.691430926322937,
-0.5666046142578125,
0.3335290253162384,
-0.3241104185581207,
-0.3734002113342285,
-0.3408093750476837,
-0.5276858806610107,
-0.544185996055603,
-0.8751315474510193,
0.32335537672042847,
-0.3724290430545807,
0.18105047941207886,
0.07457899302244186,
-0.21008515357971191,
0.3706821799278259,
0.7764447927474976,
-0.4244225025177002,
0.08494756370782852,
0.3749682307243347,
0.6300182938575745,
0.007271171547472477,
-0.29948386549949646,
-0.5579564571380615,
0.04844367504119873,
-0.9128274321556091,
1.0600926876068115,
-0.2221411168575287,
-0.023597044870257378,
-0.20942452549934387,
-0.06554967164993286,
0.25807034969329834,
-0.5178403854370117,
0.24393939971923828,
-0.2324012666940689,
0.24031950533390045,
-0.555107593536377,
-0.37261372804641724,
-0.2318158745765686,
0.2685874402523041,
-0.607377827167511,
0.8466546535491943,
0.025507591664791107,
-0.5888805985450745,
0.5682904124259949,
-0.4310656487941742,
-0.3878302574157715,
0.10803796350955963,
-0.2998468279838562,
-0.17998135089874268,
0.25182101130485535,
0.607521116733551,
0.18718509376049042,
-0.49157556891441345,
0.09601838886737823,
-0.2628297805786133,
-0.32790765166282654,
0.06969495117664337,
-0.30024364590644836,
0.7885667085647583,
0.15721817314624786,
-0.2502468228340149,
0.3757024109363556,
-1.1775391101837158,
0.03731350228190422,
0.3771299421787262,
-0.21346889436244965,
-0.19765853881835938,
0.03360358998179436,
0.15405912697315216,
0.4245784878730774,
-0.028932780027389526,
-0.45234033465385437,
0.2175043672323227,
-0.07456459850072861,
0.38010016083717346,
0.5698638558387756,
-0.08976831287145615,
0.3338986337184906,
-0.1558767706155777,
0.28900256752967834,
0.2514515221118927,
0.5500625371932983,
-0.43989887833595276,
-0.5622013807296753,
-1.1570202112197876,
-0.19405509531497955,
-0.16046379506587982,
0.6341922879219055,
-1.1410491466522217,
0.03443874418735504,
0.10162816941738129,
-0.6128467917442322,
-0.4473985731601715,
0.11776331812143326,
0.21296676993370056,
0.7084349989891052,
0.6076115369796753,
-0.03496016561985016,
-0.49648937582969666,
-0.8813698887825012,
-0.235290989279747,
-0.1483323872089386,
0.09772051125764847,
0.2956375181674957,
0.5251736640930176,
-0.05899668112397194,
0.9158899188041687,
-0.728744626045227,
-0.14591874182224274,
-0.3230038583278656,
-0.1386393904685974,
0.3279634714126587,
0.3631182610988617,
0.5370402932167053,
-0.8274403810501099,
-0.3203628659248352,
0.04496992006897926,
-0.8490200638771057,
-0.039010729640722275,
-0.3665412664413452,
-0.33893367648124695,
0.10011353343725204,
0.8018822073936462,
-0.7373411059379578,
0.7198674082756042,
0.19120922684669495,
-0.2757430374622345,
0.5804070234298706,
-0.15869709849357605,
0.09398447722196579,
-0.6178062558174133,
-0.061164490878582,
0.18941985070705414,
-0.3629249334335327,
-0.7499881982803345,
0.21685363352298737,
-0.16977477073669434,
-0.17507217824459076,
-0.5878869891166687,
0.41925156116485596,
-0.28454703092575073,
0.0738830417394638,
-0.12258484214544296,
-0.13842140138149261,
0.2314353585243225,
0.5301858186721802,
-0.0255572609603405,
0.553880512714386,
0.8885223269462585,
-0.6327003836631775,
0.7864105105400085,
0.17924056947231293,
-0.502070426940918,
0.6588903665542603,
-0.9286988973617554,
0.05404927581548691,
-0.30675259232521057,
0.027377337217330933,
-1.1775853633880615,
-0.4066231846809387,
0.2846956253051758,
-0.17953291535377502,
-0.2159651666879654,
-0.5636239647865295,
-0.4369392693042755,
-0.41421279311180115,
0.019956929609179497,
0.27802062034606934,
0.44530314207077026,
-0.6994755268096924,
0.7395690083503723,
0.2001154124736786,
-0.02773101069033146,
-0.15018293261528015,
-0.8778547048568726,
0.2685528099536896,
-0.07141818106174469,
-0.7650498151779175,
0.025093484669923782,
-0.36124637722969055,
-0.3504085838794708,
-0.06998837739229202,
-0.13253000378608704,
-0.11932481825351715,
-0.3500722348690033,
0.13005994260311127,
0.43445152044296265,
-0.24192661046981812,
-0.12180924415588379,
0.03594276309013367,
-0.28251880407333374,
-0.006626485846936703,
-0.516144335269928,
0.039019785821437836,
-0.28744077682495117,
-0.7167924046516418,
-0.08565867692232132,
0.2939718961715698,
0.9301859140396118,
-0.37406685948371887,
0.19649407267570496,
0.4752150774002075,
-0.28985729813575745,
-0.4751744568347931,
-0.46990278363227844,
0.0775199756026268,
-0.42222335934638977,
-0.03435857221484184,
-0.5709601044654846,
-0.5882696509361267,
0.19260162115097046,
-0.12929029762744904,
0.3555625379085541,
-0.029506664723157883,
0.6650545597076416,
-0.20216789841651917,
1.3704266548156738,
0.3645893335342407,
0.590786337852478,
0.29979923367500305,
-0.24285537004470825,
0.45356786251068115,
-0.38700205087661743,
-0.3075937330722809,
-0.0200472604483366,
-0.1284720003604889,
-0.37336352467536926,
-0.8399420976638794,
0.5876299142837524,
-0.08735030144453049,
-0.13091862201690674,
0.2643706500530243,
-0.6988880038261414,
0.6444143056869507,
0.7664148807525635,
0.1278468519449234,
0.18991237878799438,
0.0009653236484155059,
-0.15084931254386902,
0.030999770388007164,
-0.7009239196777344,
-0.3440479338169098,
0.8499076962471008,
-0.11694016307592392,
0.6733957529067993,
-0.05407313257455826,
0.6337255239486694,
-0.1607375293970108,
-0.17138411104679108,
-0.8967559933662415,
0.772869348526001,
-0.10569126904010773,
-0.44018271565437317,
-0.3036820590496063,
-0.21835200488567352,
-0.47480112314224243,
0.631767988204956,
-0.2516978979110718,
-0.3360513150691986,
0.24250158667564392,
0.42064744234085083,
-0.108253113925457,
0.1405487060546875,
-0.68808913230896,
0.9906904101371765,
-0.2376055121421814,
-0.5358657240867615,
0.19392995536327362,
-0.6916075348854065,
0.6477002501487732,
0.15296350419521332,
0.27432021498680115,
0.12003083527088165,
0.34767377376556396,
0.043314848095178604,
-0.7605878710746765,
0.5256930589675903,
-0.1818314641714096,
0.06305502355098724,
0.5134415030479431,
0.16131217777729034,
0.35050925612449646,
-0.05566464364528656,
0.5230538845062256,
-0.15609265863895416,
-0.09277897328138351,
-0.4509097933769226,
-0.7026621699333191,
0.426347941160202,
-0.0931604877114296,
-0.5811381936073303,
-0.18319524824619293,
-0.4771307706832886,
-0.18047405779361725,
0.38498133420944214,
0.20661482214927673,
0.46889087557792664,
0.15610447525978088,
0.039380453526973724,
0.792908787727356,
-0.21695385873317719,
0.2615492343902588,
0.06468867510557175,
-0.5491854548454285,
-0.5252119302749634,
1.0555365085601807,
-0.13419361412525177,
0.1163882315158844,
0.36933839321136475,
0.22664496302604675,
-0.08714169263839722,
-0.5151055455207825,
-0.8069561719894409,
-0.010058187879621983,
-1.0296634435653687,
0.056680578738451004,
-0.3460961878299713,
0.03246597200632095,
-0.0498364195227623,
-0.3484026789665222,
-0.5740087032318115,
-0.2869437038898468,
0.023713156580924988,
-0.0046371412463486195,
0.3272828459739685,
0.6669098138809204,
0.01462477259337902,
-0.17695273458957672,
-0.5422130227088928,
0.8444383144378662,
0.7359825372695923,
0.051600467413663864,
-0.19376824796199799,
0.05532197281718254,
-0.04540104418992996,
-0.20580655336380005,
-0.058568380773067474,
-0.5549603700637817,
0.2628547251224518,
-0.34772002696990967,
0.3615727722644806,
0.06378217786550522,
-0.057903945446014404,
1.0307010412216187,
-0.7798726558685303,
1.0092031955718994,
0.44382381439208984,
-0.9620577692985535,
0.8522061109542847,
-0.10110209137201309,
0.4854007661342621,
0.3702244162559509,
-0.04768241569399834,
-0.11321231722831726,
-0.4721134901046753,
-0.2818486988544464,
-1.0176141262054443,
0.4500553607940674,
0.37186190485954285,
-0.29713332653045654,
0.29915153980255127,
-0.021986037492752075,
0.05817218869924545,
-0.023953191936016083,
-0.4961404502391815,
-0.238886296749115,
-0.5002685189247131,
-0.019904760643839836,
0.1455516368150711,
0.16515783965587616,
-0.3201406002044678,
-0.6254048347473145,
0.5143195390701294,
-0.4512922167778015,
0.05639892816543579,
0.20963488519191742,
-0.22877106070518494,
-0.02873065695166588,
0.08788114786148071,
0.5981138348579407,
0.9540963172912598,
0.17188219726085663,
0.35649093985557556,
-0.0002452332410030067,
0.023507894948124886,
0.12128041684627533,
-0.06464708596467972,
-0.4937443435192108,
0.21703393757343292,
0.37796759605407715,
1.0100173950195312,
-0.10871603339910507,
-0.6771547794342041,
0.5553309321403503,
-0.29855069518089294,
-0.3837621212005615,
-0.14186647534370422,
0.11142253130674362,
0.18082404136657715,
0.5007646679878235,
0.05124635249376297,
0.43024423718452454,
0.1636042594909668,
-0.27204978466033936,
0.23190951347351074,
0.1435750275850296,
-0.27506792545318604,
-0.05362189933657646,
0.8818831443786621,
-0.21315769851207733,
0.14371860027313232,
0.5087130665779114,
0.02703818492591381,
-0.2693239450454712,
0.4461556375026703,
0.12211257964372635,
0.539176881313324,
0.21836401522159576,
0.3669903874397278,
0.29243773221969604,
0.3617420196533203,
-0.01679125800728798,
0.8618922829627991,
-0.021698908880352974,
-0.43849655985832214,
-0.6331074237823486,
-0.3078216016292572,
-0.41352373361587524,
0.07144287973642349,
-0.4367205798625946,
0.45609739422798157,
-0.45967987179756165,
0.01575523614883423,
0.24824756383895874,
-0.6325430274009705,
-0.8194333910942078,
0.5998027324676514,
0.3786449730396271,
0.828254222869873,
-0.811712384223938,
0.444970041513443,
0.9150922894477844,
-0.7550299167633057,
-0.6966136693954468,
-0.4239300787448883,
0.13323360681533813,
-0.6671372652053833,
0.5196508765220642,
-0.061459314078092575,
-0.24619050323963165,
-0.20982912182807922,
-1.0367498397827148,
-0.6122806668281555,
0.9118421077728271,
0.5313747525215149,
-0.6300076246261597,
0.16018404066562653,
-0.07438474893569946,
0.5505823493003845,
-0.2771456241607666,
0.018767276778817177,
0.4500722289085388,
0.4864955246448517,
0.5937755107879639,
-0.47194793820381165,
0.033321261405944824,
-0.3149537742137909,
0.17911788821220398,
0.0478862039744854,
-0.35778263211250305,
0.9147161841392517,
-0.6207026839256287,
0.01018309872597456,
-0.04638826102018356,
0.43585023283958435,
0.5859158635139465,
0.5175849199295044,
0.4709404408931732,
0.7523337602615356,
0.4587441384792328,
-0.10899509489536285,
1.007428765296936,
-0.20560617744922638,
0.15104928612709045,
0.9692619442939758,
-0.1480393409729004,
0.4776061475276947,
0.7678256630897522,
-0.07693570107221603,
0.4081290066242218,
0.48925209045410156,
-0.14423848688602448,
0.6579646468162537,
0.28406989574432373,
0.07786008715629578,
-0.8816881775856018,
-0.04485248029232025,
0.05740092322230339,
0.4442611038684845,
0.08108513057231903,
-0.3207125961780548,
-0.1761137992143631,
-0.014398328959941864,
-0.3497847616672516,
-0.1661391407251358,
-0.17357970774173737,
0.7184945344924927,
0.14513270556926727,
-0.5682919025421143,
0.7480771541595459,
-0.3777675926685333,
-0.13015201687812805,
-0.2701045870780945,
-0.4803239405155182,
-0.26442423462867737,
0.10835740715265274,
-0.33964017033576965,
-0.9037659764289856,
0.02749904803931713,
0.17018575966358185,
-0.15850113332271576,
-0.4541645050048828,
0.820252001285553,
-0.42688655853271484,
-0.6031118035316467,
-0.1065516471862793,
0.6790205836296082,
0.20777438580989838,
0.007421660702675581,
-0.5946596264839172,
0.17755678296089172,
0.0635625422000885,
-0.31503424048423767,
0.08227717876434326,
0.6716787219047546,
-0.1547871232032776,
0.7981522679328918,
1.0134865045547485,
0.24488452076911926,
0.23313966393470764,
0.35408666729927063,
0.9703903794288635,
-0.7625246047973633,
-0.3369748890399933,
-0.7542603611946106,
1.0648316144943237,
-0.09996217489242554,
-0.286985844373703,
0.4925849437713623,
0.5893077254295349,
0.9289523363113403,
-0.3525889217853546,
1.0953009128570557,
0.006506779231131077,
0.16484913229942322,
-0.6281599998474121,
0.2446473240852356,
-0.9271627068519592,
0.05173851177096367,
-0.3946029543876648,
-0.8443233370780945,
-0.5159051418304443,
0.7019968628883362,
0.04439748078584671,
-0.4222218990325928,
0.6664970517158508,
0.7605134844779968,
-0.2533608675003052,
0.000027917078114114702,
0.5246638059616089,
0.15604448318481445,
0.6536224484443665,
0.6680120825767517,
1.0364718437194824,
-0.3204745650291443,
0.6292983889579773,
-0.3852848410606384,
-0.16157129406929016,
-0.03865461051464081,
-0.879600465297699,
-0.8855291604995728,
-0.5393778085708618,
-0.48624157905578613,
-0.14637470245361328,
-0.1953021138906479,
0.5970642566680908,
0.6724454164505005,
-0.7496127486228943,
0.005629165098071098,
-0.6161531209945679,
0.4353460967540741,
-0.3527046740055084,
-0.19605466723442078,
-0.029973270371556282,
-0.23808129131793976,
-0.4794778525829315,
0.6507304906845093,
0.6964899301528931,
-0.041027795523405075,
-0.3328799307346344,
0.09669902920722961,
0.10969290882349014,
0.1630878448486328,
1.0472495555877686,
0.122487872838974,
-0.9368204474449158,
-0.18788686394691467,
0.05214536562561989,
-0.03098995052278042,
0.1775970309972763,
0.8730708956718445,
-0.78291255235672,
0.8740484714508057,
0.7986879944801331,
0.4203713536262512,
0.7243527770042419,
-0.051403775811195374,
0.48387303948402405,
-0.431397944688797,
-0.21851381659507751,
-0.02813437394797802,
0.5525358319282532,
0.383054256439209,
-0.054079074412584305,
0.5510697364807129,
0.41313832998275757,
-0.29891958832740784,
-0.8804032206535339,
0.5159679055213928,
-1.1176574230194092,
-0.3938429355621338,
1.0352513790130615,
0.02215399406850338,
-0.3484208285808563,
-0.10998698323965073,
-0.5489972829818726,
0.05079808458685875,
-0.12190140783786774,
0.4022020697593689,
0.4999333620071411,
-0.6489993333816528,
-0.530695915222168,
-0.49012988805770874,
0.3470103144645691,
-0.057897549122571945,
-1.0013222694396973,
0.09149015694856644,
1.0212068557739258,
0.21965521574020386,
0.2556604743003845,
0.3555050790309906,
-0.08222691714763641,
0.3954692482948303,
0.36207905411720276,
-0.08644258975982666,
-0.3020712733268738,
-0.76692795753479,
0.036447007209062576,
0.2632921040058136,
-0.1164630874991417,
-0.21825246512889862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19928v1 | Interactive Topic Models with Optimal Transport | 2024-06-28T13:57:27 | 2024-06-28T13:57:27 | Garima Dhanania, Sheshera Mysore, Chau Minh Pham, Mohit Iyyer, Hamed Zamani, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | Topic models are widely used to analyze document collections. While they are
valuable for discovering latent topics in a corpus when analysts are unfamiliar
with the corpus, analysts also commonly start with an understanding of the
content present in a corpus. This may be through categories obtained from an
initial pass over the corpus or a desire to analyze the corpus through a
predefined set of categories derived from a high level theoretical framework
(e.g. political ideology). In these scenarios analysts desire a topic modeling
approach which incorporates their understanding of the corpus while supporting
various forms of interaction with the model. In this work, we present EdTM, as
an approach for label name supervised topic modeling. EdTM models topic
modeling as an assignment problem while leveraging LM/LLM based document-topic
affinities and using optimal transport for making globally coherent
topic-assignments. In experiments, we show the efficacy of our framework
compared to few-shot LLM classifiers, and topic models based on clustering and
LDA. Further, we show EdTM's ability to incorporate various forms of analyst
feedback and while remaining robust to noisy analyst inputs. | [
-0.5395264029502869,
-1.0684252977371216,
0.9122750163078308,
-0.2247203290462494,
-0.2549181282520294,
0.1196160688996315,
-0.10964478552341461,
-0.09966170787811279,
0.34738752245903015,
0.5773888826370239,
-0.4687482416629791,
-0.5762221217155457,
-0.504814088344574,
-0.2414930760860443,
-0.6429910659790039,
1.0998992919921875,
-0.18383271992206573,
-0.23951803147792816,
-0.41623154282569885,
-0.004147229716181755,
-0.12554754316806793,
-0.6233479976654053,
-0.5893508195877075,
-0.1334051638841629,
0.6546629667282104,
0.2542050778865814,
0.5220549702644348,
0.8248816132545471,
0.7309548258781433,
0.3118850886821747,
-0.4126422107219696,
-0.023500973358750343,
-0.5400692820549011,
0.2983906865119934,
-0.6107632517814636,
-0.4015357792377472,
-0.5704699158668518,
-0.006662245374172926,
0.5542389750480652,
1.0679608583450317,
-0.34338730573654175,
0.007302658166736364,
-0.08786439895629883,
0.1758667230606079,
-0.3635450005531311,
-0.0767606571316719,
-0.6300682425498962,
-0.15384909510612488,
-0.2698361873626709,
-0.47202691435813904,
-0.46872445940971375,
0.00458381325006485,
0.23665842413902283,
-0.7808579802513123,
0.11975953727960587,
0.09312044829130173,
0.8082658052444458,
0.34076496958732605,
-0.8437635898590088,
-0.6373117566108704,
-0.8500906825065613,
0.6983599662780762,
-0.06172892451286316,
0.33656173944473267,
0.5399245023727417,
0.05898405238986015,
0.08947917819023132,
-0.7999847531318665,
-0.08460760116577148,
-0.06102367863059044,
-0.07136775553226471,
0.3487541079521179,
-0.2212841659784317,
0.017423709854483604,
-0.07109727710485458,
-0.011418049223721027,
-0.32168492674827576,
0.41576331853866577,
-0.2360435128211975,
0.07865843176841736,
0.544959306716919,
0.4054299592971802,
0.08853118866682053,
-0.07977044582366943,
-0.4480510950088501,
0.2612951099872589,
-0.4764438569545746,
-0.2891330420970917,
0.5260735154151917,
0.27815479040145874,
-0.040096934884786606,
0.6501956582069397,
-0.17927947640419006,
0.9184404015541077,
0.275541752576828,
0.12876452505588531,
-0.27584779262542725,
-0.38857758045196533,
0.08250676840543747,
0.12015513330698013,
0.25780701637268066,
0.2215568572282791,
-0.3059788942337036,
-0.1613752245903015,
-0.14560137689113617,
-0.2062218338251114,
0.45088502764701843,
-0.9118183851242065,
-0.3918030858039856,
0.41062217950820923,
-0.39987871050834656,
-0.27026426792144775,
-0.10490771383047104,
-1.039785623550415,
-0.4295452833175659,
-0.6978846788406372,
0.2087223082780838,
-0.33450180292129517,
-0.3597760498523712,
-0.1758883148431778,
0.08982384204864502,
0.06825611740350723,
0.7238865494728088,
-0.985420823097229,
0.19140353798866272,
0.7031621336936951,
0.8816922903060913,
-0.6104447245597839,
0.19209682941436768,
-0.5652593374252319,
0.5353890657424927,
-0.22367218136787415,
1.44258451461792,
-0.8367905616760254,
-0.46944552659988403,
-0.07767634838819504,
-0.2190282940864563,
-0.16996663808822632,
-0.0738474428653717,
0.4668847322463989,
-0.718336820602417,
0.1586197167634964,
-0.0374305434525013,
-0.9649465680122375,
0.04930548369884491,
0.3547365665435791,
-0.46473515033721924,
0.837225615978241,
0.02740304358303547,
-1.031373143196106,
0.18679188191890717,
-1.1076445579528809,
-0.018594911321997643,
-0.12817156314849854,
-0.05576205253601074,
-0.09750967472791672,
-0.1782716065645218,
0.08778070658445358,
0.5029659867286682,
-0.009466961026191711,
0.7799054384231567,
-0.28616949915885925,
-0.15451762080192566,
0.31338831782341003,
-0.28721192479133606,
0.5361841917037964,
0.48156464099884033,
0.236244797706604,
0.48560065031051636,
-0.6728919744491577,
-0.4386717677116394,
-0.13355596363544464,
-0.3278976082801819,
-0.7292914390563965,
0.08893024176359177,
0.12808315455913544,
-0.2163400501012802,
0.08806466311216354,
-0.27195510268211365,
0.42295753955841064,
-0.2579026222229004,
0.2183404415845871,
1.011745572090149,
0.31880441308021545,
0.697894811630249,
-0.12642717361450195,
0.72686368227005,
0.07436183094978333,
-0.11352789402008057,
-0.12332136183977127,
-0.2420506328344345,
-0.7748920917510986,
-0.5333542823791504,
0.6638707518577576,
0.48014312982559204,
-0.6601414680480957,
0.21839746832847595,
-0.2855553925037384,
-0.5015180110931396,
-0.23119576275348663,
-0.2763393819332123,
-0.3207511007785797,
0.2834542393684387,
0.15690523386001587,
-0.10677572339773178,
-0.08780167251825333,
-0.86961829662323,
-0.05538173019886017,
-0.2560780942440033,
0.014966391026973724,
0.14741875231266022,
0.33939415216445923,
-0.1685689389705658,
1.226675271987915,
-0.8786963224411011,
-0.08650360256433487,
-0.31195908784866333,
0.30691567063331604,
0.012724931351840496,
0.2878461182117462,
0.6130921840667725,
-0.9479478597640991,
-0.48027265071868896,
-0.07038594782352448,
-0.4611804783344269,
-0.489589661359787,
-0.33935004472732544,
-0.6536218523979187,
0.03714211657643318,
0.5819492936134338,
-0.41788795590400696,
0.3115510046482086,
0.10001412779092789,
-0.454226553440094,
0.041059356182813644,
-0.24068528413772583,
-0.08396749943494797,
-1.318468689918518,
0.08612916618585587,
0.10208617150783539,
-0.39908483624458313,
-0.7069494724273682,
-0.031524352729320526,
-0.25879719853401184,
-0.3567101061344147,
-0.49004998803138733,
0.6960078477859497,
-0.37799757719039917,
0.07125984132289886,
-0.5287443399429321,
0.5048761963844299,
-0.16895833611488342,
0.3852365016937256,
0.31724879145622253,
0.4857330322265625,
0.5906780958175659,
-0.5375597476959229,
0.23525750637054443,
0.35622891783714294,
-0.06552009284496307,
0.9382498860359192,
-0.42259863018989563,
0.21419090032577515,
-0.288177490234375,
0.14682753384113312,
-0.9901351928710938,
-0.13780568540096283,
0.32871386408805847,
0.062676340341568,
0.8384897112846375,
-0.3210613429546356,
-0.3661346733570099,
0.0925973579287529,
-0.06893713772296906,
0.08143895119428635,
0.20282895863056183,
-0.42376911640167236,
0.5991836190223694,
0.7544702887535095,
-0.5270100235939026,
-0.25661998987197876,
-0.19316928088665009,
0.0035048143472522497,
-0.708396315574646,
-0.2610683739185333,
0.6490186452865601,
-0.23282656073570251,
-0.4146862030029297,
0.2766764760017395,
0.06369084864854813,
-0.31061357259750366,
0.3151566982269287,
0.25116652250289917,
0.17930126190185547,
0.19134268164634705,
0.3813367486000061,
0.22526898980140686,
-0.35158416628837585,
-0.07699202001094818,
0.028383372351527214,
0.4388332962989807,
0.020787278190255165,
-0.5040591955184937,
-0.10141292214393616,
0.6857686638832092,
0.2893979847431183,
-0.28491854667663574,
0.8716911673545837,
0.5363410115242004,
-0.2139682173728943,
-0.13778410851955414,
-0.17572496831417084,
-0.20844170451164246,
-0.4378441870212555,
0.5182818174362183,
-0.532533586025238,
-0.6337769031524658,
0.488567978143692,
-0.4945964515209198,
0.044391606003046036,
0.5158686637878418,
0.7367554903030396,
-0.13959191739559174,
0.7299467325210571,
1.0483834743499756,
0.26975110173225403,
0.5523322820663452,
-0.33336150646209717,
0.2686089277267456,
-0.7831979393959045,
-0.11878176778554916,
-0.7092414498329163,
-0.2151743322610855,
-0.5403543710708618,
-0.3314856290817261,
0.27766767144203186,
0.20428982377052307,
-0.1972327083349228,
0.08290303498506546,
-0.5577478408813477,
0.25389564037323,
0.5067857503890991,
-0.02335531823337078,
0.3281199634075165,
0.22013935446739197,
-0.14302733540534973,
0.07979651540517807,
-1.0159357786178589,
-0.7689252495765686,
1.0015501976013184,
0.4315730333328247,
0.908096432685852,
0.05063125118613243,
0.7465121746063232,
0.40841957926750183,
0.8127837777137756,
-0.6985752582550049,
0.6920968294143677,
-0.07010193914175034,
-0.5981481075286865,
-0.24814473092556,
-0.24999022483825684,
-0.9708407521247864,
0.3472277820110321,
-0.029296714812517166,
-0.8529585599899292,
0.2835477292537689,
-0.12026523053646088,
-0.16639380156993866,
0.49424979090690613,
-0.21280764043331146,
0.6800446510314941,
-0.22353695333003998,
-0.639694333076477,
-0.13796570897102356,
-0.46454504132270813,
0.0846700668334961,
-0.4683431386947632,
0.3031376898288727,
-0.26425600051879883,
-0.3651944398880005,
0.986634373664856,
-0.1049395278096199,
0.8111856579780579,
-0.08663379400968552,
-0.24198183417320251,
0.25923699140548706,
0.027245759963989258,
0.17991799116134644,
-0.009528441354632378,
-0.43252065777778625,
-0.07819864153862,
0.1418701857328415,
-0.13587813079357147,
-0.40794774889945984,
0.7301446199417114,
-0.8019501566886902,
-0.9699434638023376,
-0.5145132541656494,
-0.6805207133293152,
0.03314022347331047,
0.06019764393568039,
0.0861937627196312,
0.44881194829940796,
-0.23515473306179047,
0.1337498128414154,
0.49805861711502075,
-0.22219526767730713,
0.35838407278060913,
0.7594510912895203,
-0.36074355244636536,
-0.08036596328020096,
0.8701299428939819,
0.4318758547306061,
0.09097462892532349,
0.6301257014274597,
0.0622369684278965,
-0.32060766220092773,
-0.7789915800094604,
-0.38367512822151184,
0.03137751296162605,
-1.0362778902053833,
-0.1504354327917099,
-1.0846328735351562,
-0.17235225439071655,
0.12419446557760239,
-0.40693461894989014,
-0.4512629508972168,
-0.4515407681465149,
-0.6752002239227295,
-0.3501187264919281,
0.5700582265853882,
0.4652460515499115,
-0.19374538958072662,
0.40425175428390503,
-0.5044764280319214,
0.23514875769615173,
0.05643768981099129,
0.24651376903057098,
-0.2059425264596939,
-0.5943769216537476,
-0.27445536851882935,
-0.09161276370286942,
-0.8101802468299866,
-1.2218283414840698,
0.4029778242111206,
0.024676747620105743,
0.9090781211853027,
0.42004162073135376,
0.6747413277626038,
0.353546679019928,
-0.20505346357822418,
0.679531991481781,
-0.22237136960029602,
-0.9298133254051208,
0.7840738296508789,
-0.6638160347938538,
-0.2087055742740631,
0.37018537521362305,
0.6278373599052429,
-0.1659838855266571,
-0.7316446900367737,
-0.5892600417137146,
-1.0571873188018799,
0.7333863377571106,
0.4898318350315094,
0.09003797173500061,
-0.06574471294879913,
0.2821051776409149,
0.22209203243255615,
0.28782448172569275,
-0.6345153450965881,
-0.1441337615251541,
-0.09597209841012955,
-0.35681748390197754,
0.14894162118434906,
-0.30109044909477234,
-0.10671848058700562,
-0.14536592364311218,
0.7981750965118408,
-0.11539776623249054,
0.399377703666687,
0.15005537867546082,
-0.011204673908650875,
-0.06606575846672058,
0.34533992409706116,
0.5290226936340332,
0.974671483039856,
-0.5793159008026123,
0.20855385065078735,
-0.09220119565725327,
0.00016523014346603304,
0.3354409635066986,
0.2962909936904907,
-0.25179556012153625,
0.09972114115953445,
0.19446849822998047,
0.7964721918106079,
-0.0432492196559906,
-0.4187798798084259,
0.06338458508253098,
0.25622475147247314,
-0.013383178040385246,
-0.18445999920368195,
-0.05111506208777428,
0.4073226749897003,
0.18467463552951813,
0.21408309042453766,
-0.27345186471939087,
0.1511445939540863,
-0.4777495861053467,
0.2948421239852905,
0.33497101068496704,
-0.4186416268348694,
-0.120960533618927,
1.040911316871643,
0.4263804852962494,
-0.33313891291618347,
0.6010506749153137,
-0.10984083265066147,
-0.5877894163131714,
0.8799529671669006,
0.38555771112442017,
0.6662377119064331,
-0.21785718202590942,
0.40794259309768677,
0.11949902772903442,
0.10516775399446487,
0.28040048480033875,
-0.061343591660261154,
0.07082606106996536,
-0.6477797031402588,
-0.022620409727096558,
-0.6702364683151245,
-0.69515460729599,
-0.21893355250358582,
-0.7353788614273071,
0.4046166241168976,
0.11917390674352646,
-0.3747098743915558,
0.26815998554229736,
0.057346854358911514,
-0.5385898947715759,
-0.13709521293640137,
-0.021929405629634857,
0.7276787161827087,
-0.7644373774528503,
0.8811025619506836,
0.9492947459220886,
-0.10844232141971588,
-0.263771116733551,
0.06170707568526268,
-0.273452490568161,
-0.28352704644203186,
0.657252848148346,
0.023630497977137566,
0.28090471029281616,
0.3117057979106903,
-0.31507399678230286,
-0.9035077691078186,
1.0638861656188965,
0.2977520525455475,
-0.33134540915489197,
0.28051647543907166,
-0.027281180024147034,
0.5304791331291199,
-0.5250237584114075,
0.3809207081794739,
0.04543057084083557,
0.5813854932785034,
0.16713161766529083,
-0.5667169690132141,
-0.2029566913843155,
-0.1025770828127861,
-0.11975723505020142,
0.3829714059829712,
-0.7181410193443298,
0.7477918863296509,
0.009842013008892536,
-0.05634589120745659,
-0.14098578691482544,
0.6926812529563904,
0.16812261939048767,
0.6372318863868713,
0.47108006477355957,
0.3053978681564331,
0.8488357067108154,
0.045981232076883316,
1.145242691040039,
-0.22897905111312866,
0.5243721008300781,
1.029374122619629,
-0.5722036957740784,
0.7203741073608398,
0.5391124486923218,
-0.16585773229599,
0.17629997432231903,
1.1675324440002441,
-0.01955338567495346,
0.8789117336273193,
0.3514350652694702,
-0.0653461441397667,
-0.2681242525577545,
-0.5136637687683105,
-0.27567169070243835,
0.4071487486362457,
0.5891950726509094,
-0.17811453342437744,
-0.4004357159137726,
0.31723734736442566,
-0.13450299203395844,
0.08464869111776352,
-0.34500670433044434,
0.823648989200592,
0.03938773274421692,
-0.40712136030197144,
0.1396762579679489,
0.3748558759689331,
0.32920706272125244,
-0.5373534560203552,
0.16804221272468567,
-0.4914730191230774,
-0.10366231948137283,
0.10131377726793289,
-0.897334635257721,
0.6296011209487915,
0.1311594396829605,
-0.13554371893405914,
-0.5510070323944092,
0.8432944416999817,
-0.6484770774841309,
-0.7381883859634399,
0.15269999206066132,
0.7014894485473633,
0.30988994240760803,
0.14619721472263336,
-0.46295520663261414,
0.04765172302722931,
-0.06307379901409149,
-0.7235801219940186,
0.5516777634620667,
0.4372783303260803,
-0.189814031124115,
0.901485025882721,
0.48231393098831177,
-0.15572918951511383,
-0.2202359437942505,
-0.25768303871154785,
0.9279696941375732,
-0.5098512172698975,
-0.7935815453529358,
-0.7769544124603271,
0.33953970670700073,
-0.1548500806093216,
0.17216046154499054,
0.5140688419342041,
0.5624664425849915,
0.33476027846336365,
-0.0019589976873248816,
0.5085365772247314,
0.221722811460495,
0.5446746349334717,
-0.7049192786216736,
0.6486467123031616,
-0.7404153347015381,
0.6479748487472534,
-0.19235959649085999,
-0.9980982542037964,
-0.0274841096252203,
0.6461923718452454,
-0.38156628608703613,
-0.13841257989406586,
0.6800519227981567,
0.5460479259490967,
-0.4667067527770996,
-0.006355203688144684,
0.04013683274388313,
0.09652124345302582,
0.5633706450462341,
0.4198281466960907,
1.0248476266860962,
0.2507608234882355,
0.31484895944595337,
-0.34409666061401367,
-0.08553503453731537,
-0.2517319321632385,
-1.0309303998947144,
-1.0664907693862915,
-0.601447582244873,
-1.0358164310455322,
0.07764559239149094,
0.059320684522390366,
0.8296265006065369,
0.7358787059783936,
-0.4991140067577362,
-0.0705970823764801,
0.08276195079088211,
0.41453438997268677,
0.20811647176742554,
-0.26952221989631653,
0.9382558465003967,
0.054339874535799026,
-0.9083857536315918,
0.11476568132638931,
0.29603397846221924,
0.17439821362495422,
-0.13284794986248016,
0.397794634103775,
-0.23710818588733673,
0.387935608625412,
0.4675854444503784,
-0.2713167667388916,
-0.5562270879745483,
-0.27738717198371887,
-0.08389858156442642,
-0.11894375830888748,
-0.12806572020053864,
0.7389129400253296,
-0.5546793341636658,
0.27772653102874756,
0.31068024039268494,
0.6918933391571045,
0.7103744149208069,
0.4102539122104645,
0.5628980398178101,
-0.5391988158226013,
0.397021621465683,
0.11428643763065338,
0.16846488416194916,
0.1476152539253235,
-0.5143475532531738,
0.7017602324485779,
0.2601569890975952,
-0.449726402759552,
-1.0500891208648682,
0.09906096011400223,
-1.250116229057312,
-0.6017575860023499,
1.1985111236572266,
-0.08778279274702072,
0.0742870643734932,
-0.21838784217834473,
-0.33526235818862915,
0.2909240424633026,
-0.4196477234363556,
0.6086552143096924,
0.8336544632911682,
-0.2596924602985382,
-0.32755574584007263,
-0.7865855097770691,
0.10222518444061279,
0.14955781400203705,
-1.0210669040679932,
-0.07325703650712967,
0.36908915638923645,
0.12627467513084412,
-0.03240245208144188,
0.7121266722679138,
0.3648695647716522,
-0.5257805585861206,
-0.19541878998279572,
-0.28534969687461853,
-0.1015646904706955,
-0.4374929666519165,
0.04835444688796997,
0.4068526327610016,
-0.18002529442310333,
-0.10924027860164642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19898v1 | Paraphrase Types Elicit Prompt Engineering Capabilities | 2024-06-28T13:06:31 | 2024-06-28T13:06:31 | Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Yang Xu, Bela Gipp | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much of the success of modern language models depends on finding a suitable
prompt to instruct the model. Until now, it has been largely unknown how
variations in the linguistic expression of prompts affect these models. This
study systematically and empirically evaluates which linguistic features
influence models through paraphrase types, i.e., different linguistic changes
at particular positions. We measure behavioral changes for five models across
120 tasks and six families of paraphrases (i.e., morphology, syntax, lexicon,
lexico-syntax, discourse, and others). We also control for other prompt
engineering factors (e.g., prompt length, lexical diversity, and proximity to
training data). Our results show a potential for language models to improve
tasks when their prompts are adapted in specific paraphrase types (e.g., 6.7%
median gain in Mixtral 8x7B; 5.5% in LLaMA 3 8B). In particular, changes in
morphology and lexicon, i.e., the vocabulary used, showed promise in improving
prompts. These findings contribute to developing more robust language models
capable of handling variability in linguistic expression. | [
-0.22567526996135712,
-0.7429918646812439,
0.8898124098777771,
0.6747481822967529,
0.07954654842615128,
-0.06707235425710678,
0.025037264451384544,
-0.21281833946704865,
-0.06293681263923645,
0.4612039029598236,
-0.27691274881362915,
-0.21041816473007202,
-0.5381982922554016,
0.7580076456069946,
-0.2413495033979416,
0.8756211400032043,
-0.181610107421875,
-0.1306818723678589,
-0.03233885392546654,
-0.09828382730484009,
-0.8270704746246338,
-0.702415943145752,
-0.21470366418361664,
0.0030364578124135733,
0.6874054670333862,
0.37183481454849243,
1.112595558166504,
0.5844092965126038,
0.3748369514942169,
0.3550492525100708,
-0.5356979370117188,
-0.06986556947231293,
-0.026345806196331978,
0.5906886458396912,
-0.2884311079978943,
-0.6803537011146545,
0.039190009236335754,
-0.11191803961992264,
0.6712449789047241,
0.7850377559661865,
-0.09295390546321869,
-0.05135800689458847,
0.35339421033859253,
0.24037662148475647,
-0.5316655039787292,
0.4456325173377991,
-0.715940535068512,
-0.3136645555496216,
-0.0814490094780922,
-0.2656678259372711,
-0.3825564682483673,
-0.5304766297340393,
0.31499361991882324,
-0.4952603280544281,
0.13977652788162231,
0.07874489575624466,
0.8457115292549133,
0.06283701956272125,
-0.27072352170944214,
-0.5494768619537354,
-0.2288391888141632,
0.77237468957901,
-0.949556291103363,
0.19236460328102112,
0.33281511068344116,
0.11047723889350891,
-0.31693026423454285,
-0.5114611983299255,
-0.1305028200149536,
-0.6562643051147461,
-0.39407870173454285,
-0.4161113202571869,
0.01738053187727928,
0.23328280448913574,
0.40517348051071167,
0.20654010772705078,
-0.27577921748161316,
0.17008623480796814,
-0.10801972448825836,
-0.2778746783733368,
0.15925094485282898,
0.40029171109199524,
0.770688533782959,
-0.6446027159690857,
0.0787942111492157,
-0.1310940384864807,
-0.6281602382659912,
0.5091443061828613,
0.30996087193489075,
0.46420085430145264,
-0.07834579050540924,
0.5876339673995972,
-0.459214985370636,
0.7649838328361511,
0.008950955234467983,
-0.09153539687395096,
0.07898439466953278,
-0.5510886311531067,
-0.008421908132731915,
-0.37212780117988586,
0.4488418698310852,
0.18063491582870483,
0.16548380255699158,
-0.08000512421131134,
-0.47340065240859985,
-0.2401692420244217,
-0.05208874121308327,
-0.5097816586494446,
-0.17253026366233826,
-0.1327940970659256,
-0.4617505967617035,
-0.258903443813324,
-0.1898789256811142,
-0.7723801136016846,
-0.723510205745697,
-0.3753499388694763,
0.20558205246925354,
-0.5659248232841492,
-0.06707073003053665,
0.22055241465568542,
-0.5979042649269104,
0.3840525448322296,
0.287270188331604,
-1.051008939743042,
-0.09668730199337006,
0.6906369924545288,
1.0311509370803833,
-0.08714441955089569,
-0.49983879923820496,
-0.4670295715332031,
-0.36398136615753174,
-0.3638209104537964,
0.8843443393707275,
-1.0207901000976562,
-0.6170943379402161,
0.08100426197052002,
-0.05715078115463257,
-0.5296043753623962,
-0.5503374338150024,
0.6013995409011841,
-0.2319362312555313,
0.20337310433387756,
-0.5518859028816223,
-0.3145400583744049,
-0.22101199626922607,
-0.21515414118766785,
-0.674691379070282,
0.8114005327224731,
0.06174014136195183,
-0.6573437452316284,
0.15472102165222168,
-0.5549585819244385,
-0.3698880970478058,
-0.013234520331025124,
-0.13496540486812592,
-0.03826317936182022,
0.6825927495956421,
0.3858795166015625,
0.37967002391815186,
-0.44740167260169983,
0.35904765129089355,
-0.2912901043891907,
-0.06342168897390366,
0.7589422464370728,
-0.15185298025608063,
0.740269660949707,
0.20882131159305573,
-0.2056758850812912,
0.07465213537216187,
-0.6723953485488892,
-0.29954156279563904,
-0.06835666298866272,
-0.1739388406276703,
-0.47436973452568054,
0.004745013080537319,
-0.21517401933670044,
0.3147003650665283,
0.19423456490039825,
-0.32583919167518616,
-0.03774009644985199,
-0.2383417934179306,
0.6034637689590454,
0.6239665746688843,
0.49681711196899414,
0.5112453699111938,
-0.7343193292617798,
0.9089983105659485,
-0.1631898432970047,
0.122250996530056,
-0.3472440242767334,
-0.8887618184089661,
-0.4774850904941559,
-0.2823927402496338,
0.013360931538045406,
0.5438169836997986,
-0.9152001142501831,
-0.16425001621246338,
0.0024721967056393623,
-0.6394466757774353,
-0.47458773851394653,
0.0422528013586998,
0.31797608733177185,
0.6360430717468262,
0.39747169613838196,
0.28129902482032776,
-0.24492336809635162,
-1.0474841594696045,
-0.8495280146598816,
-0.17890062928199768,
-0.007338081952184439,
0.1409323811531067,
0.26385238766670227,
0.32451966404914856,
0.9689559936523438,
-0.23096728324890137,
0.47128474712371826,
-0.6673974394798279,
0.42601990699768066,
0.2897507846355438,
0.2432986944913864,
0.9633878469467163,
-0.6970093846321106,
-0.5214759707450867,
-0.14054091274738312,
-0.649168848991394,
-0.6473343968391418,
-0.36249348521232605,
0.07018624246120453,
-0.18379433453083038,
0.42524775862693787,
-0.9199728965759277,
0.130126953125,
0.37772396206855774,
-0.49037036299705505,
0.6989313364028931,
-0.12870050966739655,
0.484609991312027,
-0.8197309374809265,
-0.22644630074501038,
0.010325989685952663,
0.22552891075611115,
-0.6356743574142456,
0.3428700268268585,
0.21305105090141296,
-0.3109833300113678,
-0.6471568942070007,
0.6215275526046753,
-0.4183235764503479,
0.07808450609445572,
-0.1526726484298706,
-0.09065970033407211,
0.08496996015310287,
0.2733510434627533,
0.04229572415351868,
1.117817759513855,
0.7464076280593872,
-0.9236024618148804,
-0.03191807121038437,
0.36260977387428284,
-0.4468161165714264,
0.36149731278419495,
-0.9399628043174744,
0.013243504799902439,
-0.24873943626880646,
-0.07173299789428711,
-1.1463143825531006,
-0.4766113758087158,
-0.07112199813127518,
-0.339758038520813,
-0.06555666774511337,
0.1640942543745041,
-0.5813452005386353,
-0.030165620148181915,
-0.42241260409355164,
0.025025077164173126,
0.5821934938430786,
-0.32248353958129883,
0.6308775544166565,
-0.16965335607528687,
-0.7466973662376404,
-0.11597882956266403,
-0.45850130915641785,
0.31678566336631775,
-0.5225384831428528,
-0.5513483285903931,
0.17234531044960022,
-0.12796077132225037,
-0.473323792219162,
-0.35117900371551514,
-0.006667915731668472,
-0.0855398178100586,
0.4330229163169861,
0.09935400635004044,
0.21253494918346405,
-0.21601910889148712,
0.12025512009859085,
0.2874959707260132,
0.230601966381073,
0.06055913120508194,
0.025477753952145576,
0.5113643407821655,
0.09210950136184692,
0.11279140412807465,
-0.5812646150588989,
0.36964353919029236,
0.7042087912559509,
-0.4265938699245453,
0.8429073691368103,
-0.10146286338567734,
-0.0666009858250618,
0.028925202786922455,
-0.4658162295818329,
-0.29636797308921814,
-0.5643242597579956,
0.40098822116851807,
-0.7297794222831726,
-0.8373950719833374,
0.6243153810501099,
0.2847880721092224,
0.2980422079563141,
0.46671217679977417,
0.35942503809928894,
-0.1178145706653595,
0.869749903678894,
0.4945375323295593,
0.520671546459198,
0.7252374291419983,
0.5396808981895447,
-0.005134357139468193,
-0.6530103087425232,
-0.07753006368875504,
-0.9254357814788818,
-0.16556040942668915,
-0.619280993938446,
-0.18473979830741882,
0.2850711941719055,
0.0906626433134079,
-0.0008946888847276568,
0.662369430065155,
-0.08039478957653046,
0.24211180210113525,
0.5676249265670776,
0.04412379488348961,
0.05509088560938835,
-0.09711587429046631,
-0.0429413802921772,
-0.2351374477148056,
-0.6884279847145081,
-0.7537438869476318,
0.8367065787315369,
0.4031926691532135,
0.7202016115188599,
0.09071763604879379,
0.5727696418762207,
0.2817206382751465,
-0.11234524101018906,
-0.33332523703575134,
0.8064109683036804,
0.015729935839772224,
-0.4544718861579895,
-0.07475629448890686,
-0.3322350084781647,
-0.8757332563400269,
0.03900202363729477,
0.044040001928806305,
-0.5773725509643555,
0.49057066440582275,
0.05503636971116066,
-0.3657151162624359,
0.0012424003798514605,
-0.720853328704834,
0.7943537831306458,
-0.17153389751911163,
0.23486970365047455,
-0.03671238571405411,
-0.5298708081245422,
-0.042995303869247437,
-0.2994776666164398,
0.18572360277175903,
-0.11055608838796616,
-0.28517523407936096,
0.6188847422599792,
-0.19480258226394653,
0.9679405689239502,
-0.03709394857287407,
-0.20346638560295105,
0.48566216230392456,
0.4727210998535156,
0.6598290801048279,
-0.12061835080385208,
-0.467581182718277,
-0.162244513630867,
-0.10827473551034927,
-0.49045082926750183,
-0.8692682981491089,
0.5081518292427063,
-0.5917081236839294,
-1.0284758806228638,
0.09106229245662689,
-0.9231288433074951,
-0.4209998548030853,
-0.2997380793094635,
0.4334671199321747,
0.619931161403656,
0.19029508531093597,
0.42821064591407776,
0.484634131193161,
-0.6435120105743408,
0.7547885775566101,
0.29316598176956177,
0.031536806374788284,
-0.13827161490917206,
0.5556789040565491,
0.1652081310749054,
0.7752929925918579,
0.5166396498680115,
0.3438867926597595,
-0.16809505224227905,
-0.5756524801254272,
-0.19474728405475616,
0.23357154428958893,
-1.141821026802063,
-0.05296970531344414,
-0.951020359992981,
0.17951393127441406,
-0.6613460779190063,
-0.3116379976272583,
0.0858737975358963,
-0.6521151065826416,
-0.4829438030719757,
-0.2982761561870575,
0.7708383202552795,
0.8271669745445251,
0.3018518090248108,
0.49719759821891785,
-0.7395257949829102,
0.10679551959037781,
0.3444463908672333,
-0.10223761945962906,
-0.1443967968225479,
-1.0519353151321411,
0.15429796278476715,
-0.10627538710832596,
-0.16557158529758453,
-1.2702847719192505,
0.32870012521743774,
0.3093341886997223,
0.773123562335968,
-0.24272891879081726,
-0.0464610755443573,
0.28056326508522034,
-0.38963228464126587,
1.2390637397766113,
-0.003627537516877055,
-1.0222238302230835,
0.5766416788101196,
-0.5122132301330566,
0.44899982213974,
0.33632174134254456,
0.3699357509613037,
-0.4685271978378296,
-0.8012628555297852,
-0.3195606470108032,
-0.47054702043533325,
0.45566171407699585,
0.2391701638698578,
0.5235206484794617,
-0.3357577919960022,
0.502339780330658,
0.4249207079410553,
0.11703439056873322,
-0.6557528376579285,
0.010213141329586506,
-0.23218828439712524,
-0.2846822142601013,
0.14659391343593597,
-0.32237035036087036,
0.3936291038990021,
0.1800730675458908,
0.27152958512306213,
0.18129797279834747,
0.014353117905557156,
0.07937487214803696,
-0.31140193343162537,
0.5223628878593445,
0.6794726848602295,
0.7025222778320312,
0.6606212854385376,
0.14494343101978302,
0.0657254159450531,
0.28741905093193054,
-0.15441422164440155,
0.23930087685585022,
-0.0025189316365867853,
-0.43891361355781555,
0.5079444646835327,
0.49031391739845276,
1.120558261871338,
0.5435658097267151,
-0.5461605787277222,
0.047704584896564484,
0.26416078209877014,
0.06033862382173538,
0.5815854668617249,
0.2887808084487915,
-0.162638857960701,
0.22961367666721344,
0.17945651710033417,
0.07245906442403793,
0.34692031145095825,
-0.5678642392158508,
-0.0753740593791008,
0.012838134542107582,
-0.018184227868914604,
-0.6431723833084106,
0.6138330101966858,
0.1739111840724945,
-0.5776239633560181,
0.3270997405052185,
-0.22227664291858673,
-0.303233802318573,
0.6892281174659729,
0.5650274753570557,
1.066172480583191,
-0.491174578666687,
0.4187504053115845,
0.12937399744987488,
0.2678793966770172,
-0.19897258281707764,
0.21986344456672668,
0.12138548493385315,
-0.36919474601745605,
-0.24662703275680542,
-0.610284149646759,
-0.37418869137763977,
-0.05459563061594963,
-0.371939092874527,
0.5085378289222717,
-0.3581123352050781,
-0.1949167400598526,
-0.09058969467878342,
-0.8713239431381226,
-0.8112236857414246,
-0.010021008551120758,
0.02065390720963478,
0.7743346691131592,
-0.7987154126167297,
0.5092076659202576,
0.9719159007072449,
-0.6544245481491089,
-0.9036374688148499,
0.039136309176683426,
-0.15204913914203644,
-0.6394268274307251,
0.8996120691299438,
0.2568075358867645,
0.1507578194141388,
-0.0042407456785440445,
-0.31589382886886597,
-1.112135410308838,
0.6701669692993164,
0.45408669114112854,
-0.3622322380542755,
-0.5731306672096252,
0.20210902392864227,
0.4719138443470001,
-0.4609348773956299,
0.2283875048160553,
0.5323065519332886,
0.2646419405937195,
-0.33332106471061707,
-1.2919645309448242,
0.07638514786958694,
-0.015136857517063618,
0.5409486293792725,
0.09688502550125122,
-0.08569569885730743,
1.2371783256530762,
-0.17516952753067017,
-0.15733690559864044,
0.417824923992157,
0.6458489894866943,
0.40185239911079407,
-0.12811823189258575,
0.35868459939956665,
-0.11963111162185669,
0.4106447398662567,
0.11246470361948013,
1.3580012321472168,
-0.43132132291793823,
0.15206266939640045,
1.0723453760147095,
-0.16546015441417694,
0.6298325061798096,
0.48609206080436707,
0.029980817809700966,
0.6497794389724731,
0.665420651435852,
0.3254309892654419,
0.5328323841094971,
-0.10484423488378525,
-0.10061675310134888,
-0.2876216471195221,
-0.29693999886512756,
-0.22988781332969666,
0.236468106508255,
0.4219878911972046,
-0.5435882806777954,
-0.3877340853214264,
0.4336687922477722,
0.06281302869319916,
0.2603823244571686,
-0.3951933979988098,
0.511553168296814,
0.06902703642845154,
-1.0022920370101929,
0.659201979637146,
-0.026981372386217117,
0.6402966976165771,
-0.5606743693351746,
0.06351473182439804,
-0.437385618686676,
-0.33986952900886536,
-0.006631944794207811,
-0.8308190703392029,
0.19469715654850006,
0.06327952444553375,
-0.020818429067730904,
-0.37021130323410034,
0.4973539113998413,
-0.06732829660177231,
-0.34083491563796997,
0.09640822559595108,
0.37385252118110657,
0.0005348088452592492,
-0.24556240439414978,
-0.6682068109512329,
0.044210284948349,
0.042762406170368195,
-0.31267663836479187,
0.2003771811723709,
0.7225529551506042,
-0.2316284328699112,
0.64044588804245,
0.361564576625824,
0.06053488701581955,
0.5092085599899292,
-0.07104287296533585,
0.5610164403915405,
-0.6712043881416321,
-0.5560561418533325,
-0.8511745929718018,
0.5087576508522034,
-0.02759910188615322,
-0.6367433667182922,
0.907830536365509,
0.11351106315851212,
0.2965768277645111,
-0.5533052682876587,
0.7386420965194702,
-0.11213385313749313,
0.48755943775177,
-0.6548708081245422,
0.21050338447093964,
-0.21448129415512085,
0.2024347186088562,
-0.3216082453727722,
-1.0229239463806152,
-0.0675547644495964,
0.2653414309024811,
-0.573637068271637,
-0.00804074015468359,
0.7864582538604736,
0.9060247540473938,
0.20689207315444946,
-0.01296066865324974,
0.2582869231700897,
0.1111416220664978,
0.48368537425994873,
0.1575099527835846,
1.019322156906128,
-0.10368483513593674,
0.4740409851074219,
-0.15198662877082825,
-0.13079272210597992,
-0.13222113251686096,
-0.8430292010307312,
-0.8891379237174988,
-0.6588833332061768,
-0.5865987539291382,
-0.19690461456775665,
0.049235958606004715,
0.8918341994285583,
0.1384027600288391,
-0.7737520337104797,
-0.1824609488248825,
-0.32684406638145447,
0.062006402760744095,
-0.11852506548166275,
-0.2503255009651184,
0.0994817316532135,
-1.1290923357009888,
-0.5321754217147827,
0.4549288749694824,
0.41559717059135437,
0.1969299465417862,
0.1549786478281021,
0.30508536100387573,
-0.17420195043087006,
0.5229049324989319,
0.47185054421424866,
0.2144765704870224,
-1.0402750968933105,
-0.5351338386535645,
0.5730994939804077,
-0.2521621286869049,
-0.002280750311911106,
1.0298514366149902,
-0.43546244502067566,
0.16197918355464935,
0.7534481883049011,
0.6979420185089111,
-0.4574843943119049,
-0.12659253180027008,
0.8187329173088074,
-0.6606931090354919,
0.2160985916852951,
0.1508781462907791,
0.6462787389755249,
0.4600924253463745,
-0.27215999364852905,
0.05688472092151642,
0.3145780861377716,
-0.5424336194992065,
-0.6717691421508789,
0.3590236008167267,
-0.49918797612190247,
-0.4005154073238373,
1.5663710832595825,
-0.18168464303016663,
0.033824026584625244,
-0.22591225802898407,
-0.3551952838897705,
-0.07991234213113785,
-0.30631202459335327,
0.6919753551483154,
1.0708131790161133,
-0.06155191734433174,
-0.33041617274284363,
-0.5907993912696838,
0.6226627230644226,
0.7947498559951782,
-0.6713157892227173,
0.1467551290988922,
0.37960386276245117,
0.4255458116531372,
0.01280254777520895,
0.10660923272371292,
0.013750286772847176,
0.45030131936073303,
-0.2702767848968506,
-0.20898272097110748,
0.2414827048778534,
-0.1127973422408104,
-0.42361980676651,
0.08781760931015015,
0.4641583561897278,
-0.04883342236280441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19892v1 | Untangling the Unrestricted Web: Automatic Identification of Multilingual Registers | 2024-06-28T13:00:30 | 2024-06-28T13:00:30 | Erik Henriksson, Amanda Myntti, Anni Eskelinen, Selcen Erten-Johansson, Saara Hellström, Veronika Laippala | cs.CL | cs.CL | This article explores deep learning models for the automatic identification
of registers - text varieties such as news reports and discussion forums - in
web-based datasets across 16 languages. Web register (or genre) identification
would provide a robust solution for understanding the content of web-scale
datasets, which have become crucial in computational linguistics. Despite
recent advances, the potential of register classifiers on the noisy web remains
largely unexplored, particularly in multilingual settings and when targeting
the entire unrestricted web. We experiment with a range of deep learning models
using the new Multilingual CORE corpora, which includes 16 languages annotated
using a detailed, hierarchical taxonomy of 25 registers designed to cover the
entire unrestricted web. Our models achieve state-of-the-art results, showing
that a detailed taxonomy in a hierarchical multi-label setting can yield
competitive classification performance. However, all models hit a glass ceiling
at approximately 80% F1 score, which we attribute to the non-discrete nature of
web registers and the inherent uncertainty in labeling some documents. By
pruning ambiguous examples, we improve model performance to over 90%. Finally,
multilingual models outperform monolingual ones, particularly benefiting
languages with fewer training examples and smaller registers. Although a
zero-shot setting decreases performance by an average of 7%, these drops are
not linked to specific registers or languages. Instead, registers show
surprising similarity across languages. | [
-0.4046036899089813,
-0.39858970046043396,
0.10663209855556488,
-0.03420625254511833,
-0.28320926427841187,
0.42125192284584045,
-0.5451290607452393,
-0.8573047518730164,
-0.21262213587760925,
0.25468048453330994,
-0.4231213927268982,
-0.5819485187530518,
-0.6165388822555542,
0.15971897542476654,
-0.549805223941803,
0.8136154413223267,
0.06915651261806488,
0.0166010782122612,
-0.1855754852294922,
-0.14484037458896637,
0.042364444583654404,
-0.727364182472229,
-0.4571402072906494,
0.01222142018377781,
0.6054075360298157,
0.10559749603271484,
0.45105457305908203,
0.9911805391311646,
0.41762614250183105,
0.3959667682647705,
0.13407859206199646,
0.21397823095321655,
-0.296085923910141,
-0.0358661487698555,
0.09958987683057785,
-0.26339149475097656,
-0.13001082837581635,
0.11847643554210663,
0.7484495043754578,
0.9619538187980652,
-0.1192215159535408,
0.16154076159000397,
0.18642455339431763,
0.5121718645095825,
-0.7431755661964417,
0.25883984565734863,
-0.6417526602745056,
-0.009444131515920162,
-0.35047340393066406,
0.06487962603569031,
-0.5536302328109741,
-0.1375449299812317,
-0.06471986323595047,
-0.6819703578948975,
0.5403669476509094,
-0.24216262996196747,
0.9985467791557312,
0.1306201070547104,
-0.8057520985603333,
-0.4387858510017395,
-0.8048185706138611,
0.7558495998382568,
-0.5224162340164185,
0.8312850594520569,
0.4603583514690399,
0.1860717386007309,
0.12418000400066376,
-0.6836104989051819,
-0.32849717140197754,
0.03359860181808472,
0.043384525924921036,
-0.026130303740501404,
-0.6689508557319641,
-0.1756344735622406,
-0.15380483865737915,
0.30434516072273254,
-0.7263259887695312,
0.7478711009025574,
-0.5236031413078308,
-0.2754268944263458,
0.6933595538139343,
-0.06634185463190079,
0.2855674922466278,
0.186407670378685,
-0.3429657518863678,
0.025292662903666496,
-0.4354777932167053,
0.24793574213981628,
0.5977374911308289,
0.7637010812759399,
-0.10757237672805786,
0.21770592033863068,
-0.19978834688663483,
0.9993162155151367,
-0.0850256085395813,
-0.3239760398864746,
0.23484686017036438,
0.22382868826389313,
-0.2123444825410843,
-0.14889127016067505,
0.943183422088623,
0.24380818009376526,
0.1169072762131691,
-0.3853493332862854,
-0.25157982110977173,
0.157584547996521,
0.1349092721939087,
-0.6474782228469849,
-0.30911514163017273,
0.0799451470375061,
-0.4709034264087677,
-0.15995275974273682,
0.055802397429943085,
-0.6766533255577087,
-0.6941554546356201,
-0.3955223858356476,
0.06767704337835312,
-0.2883157432079315,
-0.5462186932563782,
-0.019363565370440483,
-0.18781739473342896,
0.012989373877644539,
0.3028945326805115,
-0.726375937461853,
0.2456064373254776,
0.6246227025985718,
0.4588623046875,
-0.36854785680770874,
-0.21852213144302368,
0.08116410672664642,
0.04131600633263588,
-0.530626654624939,
0.531598687171936,
-0.6022218465805054,
-0.04900373890995979,
0.36712637543678284,
0.2713531255722046,
0.05514192581176758,
-0.49039721488952637,
0.19513319432735443,
-0.9777795076370239,
-0.02694498375058174,
0.2547776401042938,
-0.698639988899231,
-0.5247904658317566,
0.21489425003528595,
-1.0362451076507568,
0.5096030831336975,
-0.010593386366963387,
-0.29346713423728943,
0.48855188488960266,
-0.07232096046209335,
-0.537558913230896,
0.1703827977180481,
-0.12406818568706512,
-0.0013234816724434495,
0.03930847346782684,
-0.17075121402740479,
0.5310439467430115,
-0.30595824122428894,
0.2224898636341095,
-0.38072893023490906,
0.08474191278219223,
0.5479603409767151,
-0.7944831848144531,
0.98023921251297,
0.42069360613822937,
-0.006815832573920488,
-0.054534342139959335,
-1.1366454362869263,
0.056396808475255966,
-0.06569336354732513,
-0.41425764560699463,
-0.40570804476737976,
-0.18993811309337616,
0.25930100679397583,
0.11848043650388718,
0.36553993821144104,
-0.5176802277565002,
0.07895699888467789,
-0.18978603184223175,
0.460345983505249,
0.7175296545028687,
-0.20192138850688934,
0.4182753264904022,
-0.06539350748062134,
0.6627877354621887,
0.0957951471209526,
0.1140938401222229,
0.10879630595445633,
-0.424710750579834,
-0.8324310779571533,
-0.46942874789237976,
0.8752753734588623,
0.6096776127815247,
-0.4166802167892456,
0.284030556678772,
-0.21994008123874664,
-0.6499096155166626,
-0.72749924659729,
0.32840269804000854,
0.44145867228507996,
0.27978864312171936,
0.2694552540779114,
-0.5032914876937866,
-0.6851679682731628,
-0.9632700681686401,
-0.15587744116783142,
-0.09543101489543915,
-0.042076222598552704,
0.14876919984817505,
0.13266703486442566,
-0.34585249423980713,
0.6792255640029907,
-0.12394660711288452,
-0.41841745376586914,
-0.09460996836423874,
0.24086038768291473,
0.10649347305297852,
0.48713797330856323,
0.2599218189716339,
-1.103363037109375,
-0.5147721767425537,
0.1601029634475708,
-0.5756197571754456,
0.16543233394622803,
-0.06145380437374115,
0.29655614495277405,
0.36598727107048035,
0.45544394850730896,
-0.40103307366371155,
0.434687077999115,
0.5465502738952637,
0.10864605754613876,
0.1597682386636734,
-0.14732137322425842,
-0.2643015384674072,
-0.841714084148407,
0.026997467502951622,
0.24963624775409698,
-0.03388647735118866,
-0.5772693157196045,
0.3708910346031189,
0.2752724587917328,
-0.2208288013935089,
-0.47153252363204956,
0.5513603091239929,
-0.7572364211082458,
0.2646111249923706,
-0.2628912627696991,
0.04278092458844185,
0.03695264086127281,
0.5053305625915527,
0.14566701650619507,
0.35460329055786133,
0.6194326877593994,
-0.8598392009735107,
0.3142614960670471,
0.013770991936326027,
-0.6271538138389587,
-0.10325118899345398,
0.02805158495903015,
0.06277965754270554,
-0.21729609370231628,
0.13884437084197998,
-1.0949883460998535,
-0.38075363636016846,
-0.024741139262914658,
-0.6563911437988281,
0.6152342557907104,
-0.5255546569824219,
-0.2207697331905365,
-0.23731425404548645,
0.09763331711292267,
0.4983636736869812,
0.4120374023914337,
-0.43986818194389343,
0.5953328013420105,
0.8528367877006531,
0.15410371124744415,
-0.9279496669769287,
-0.7164259552955627,
0.09408929198980331,
-0.13742105662822723,
-0.0194364245980978,
0.2284104973077774,
-0.08447198569774628,
-0.35099539160728455,
0.08346820622682571,
0.06306653469800949,
-0.9970971345901489,
0.4392648935317993,
0.18226534128189087,
0.09021908044815063,
-0.22727230191230774,
0.3045820891857147,
-0.08632033318281174,
-0.08049452304840088,
-0.1455286592245102,
-0.3642464876174927,
0.4099082350730896,
-0.12270896881818771,
-0.3199523687362671,
-0.6383780241012573,
0.6212146282196045,
0.508175253868103,
-0.5489037036895752,
0.5463093519210815,
0.6503186225891113,
-0.5725422501564026,
-0.3376402258872986,
-0.5000430941581726,
0.3193219304084778,
-0.48601818084716797,
0.24137502908706665,
-0.5997759699821472,
-1.008182168006897,
0.5896612405776978,
-0.060827989131212234,
-0.016622379422187805,
0.7868620753288269,
0.4769704043865204,
-0.007513815071433783,
1.0828715562820435,
1.0917855501174927,
-0.18928097188472748,
0.022897416725754738,
-0.14782752096652985,
0.24173885583877563,
-0.365855872631073,
-0.24836473166942596,
-0.6864015460014343,
-0.33890143036842346,
-1.0030854940414429,
-0.2625700533390045,
0.024140888825058937,
0.3806236684322357,
-0.12514974176883698,
0.28845158219337463,
-0.6494101881980896,
0.5381278395652771,
0.6256651282310486,
-0.04251960292458534,
0.37486541271209717,
-0.12677769362926483,
-0.04475557059049606,
0.14024610817432404,
-0.6300026178359985,
-0.4200810194015503,
1.1753506660461426,
0.11637703329324722,
0.824043869972229,
0.5411173701286316,
0.592472493648529,
0.3293038606643677,
0.35358643531799316,
-0.843311607837677,
0.20148086547851562,
-0.5404086112976074,
-0.8003336787223816,
-0.16509927809238434,
-0.43263334035873413,
-1.1977057456970215,
0.07560816407203674,
-0.10866647213697433,
-0.642254650592804,
0.6195472478866577,
0.05331069231033325,
-0.4359987676143646,
0.3906008005142212,
-0.6302061080932617,
0.7866167426109314,
-0.3461037278175354,
-0.07062145322561264,
-0.031247004866600037,
-0.5553304553031921,
0.3207590579986572,
-0.3881848454475403,
0.5285238027572632,
-0.18348188698291779,
-0.24144364893436432,
0.6205238699913025,
0.05472572147846222,
1.3600798845291138,
0.08233068883419037,
-0.2812719941139221,
0.17172549664974213,
0.20864905416965485,
0.09775842726230621,
-0.0744253471493721,
0.02963077835738659,
0.5213586091995239,
0.0627041682600975,
-0.2801312506198883,
-0.3297310471534729,
0.6447896361351013,
-1.0605684518814087,
-0.40911775827407837,
-0.3619540333747864,
-0.26095184683799744,
-0.3214275538921356,
0.47505441308021545,
0.4190029203891754,
0.5516824126243591,
-0.453702449798584,
0.2954544723033905,
0.6388596296310425,
-0.18115320801734924,
0.6051919460296631,
1.1784733533859253,
-0.09777016192674637,
-0.1925673633813858,
1.0365654230117798,
0.23899465799331665,
-0.10165191441774368,
0.6673269271850586,
0.043342601507902145,
-0.4015388488769531,
-0.5750571489334106,
-0.7508388757705688,
-0.10727287828922272,
-0.9336603283882141,
-0.39485040307044983,
-0.6861602663993835,
-0.24477368593215942,
-0.6363038420677185,
0.15094898641109467,
-0.3081424832344055,
-0.7078323364257812,
-0.5163098573684692,
-0.10092321783304214,
0.10365229845046997,
0.7845885157585144,
-0.38021090626716614,
0.052386630326509476,
-0.8213182091712952,
0.2282809317111969,
0.35289040207862854,
0.48816341161727905,
0.3254847526550293,
-0.45365622639656067,
-0.2860355079174042,
-0.05983663350343704,
0.03448596969246864,
-0.8827022314071655,
0.3718370199203491,
0.4042246639728546,
0.5654503703117371,
0.7960125803947449,
0.2930271029472351,
0.5920021533966064,
-0.7616536617279053,
0.6273747086524963,
0.2272544950246811,
-0.8279564380645752,
0.027118032798171043,
-0.3786627948284149,
0.135722354054451,
0.40149787068367004,
0.9896511435508728,
-0.6453695297241211,
-0.5141122937202454,
-0.5002443194389343,
-0.9902144074440002,
0.3523758351802826,
-0.410037100315094,
0.3579811453819275,
-0.1739881932735443,
0.18889905512332916,
0.3591066002845764,
0.17319436371326447,
-0.9312203526496887,
-0.197197824716568,
-0.09294836223125458,
-0.2603226602077484,
-0.1799144744873047,
-0.2086910605430603,
-0.22070856392383575,
-0.36684733629226685,
0.7302715182304382,
-0.1611931324005127,
0.09178595244884491,
-0.22209174931049347,
-0.45467549562454224,
-0.18992070853710175,
0.3053604066371918,
0.5621766448020935,
0.9606022834777832,
0.16826565563678741,
0.32607710361480713,
-0.15881334245204926,
-0.16134172677993774,
0.19207897782325745,
0.3206002116203308,
-0.047910772264003754,
0.08372156322002411,
0.599176287651062,
0.816912829875946,
-0.09195307642221451,
-0.7252384424209595,
0.4881836771965027,
-0.12334096431732178,
-0.03977188467979431,
-0.5158265233039856,
-0.04282762482762337,
-0.11351296305656433,
0.19631747901439667,
0.509083092212677,
0.031597502529621124,
0.2563877999782562,
-0.3733409345149994,
0.3764718174934387,
0.5285446643829346,
-0.7096546292304993,
-0.2394842654466629,
0.6016125082969666,
0.16701917350292206,
-0.4186405837535858,
0.6984046101570129,
-0.2647523880004883,
-0.5449261665344238,
0.5863526463508606,
0.545706570148468,
0.8867999911308289,
-0.3639243543148041,
0.2241547703742981,
0.26036834716796875,
0.4308133125305176,
0.27989864349365234,
-0.059955380856990814,
-0.12934833765029907,
-0.996781051158905,
-0.38527199625968933,
-0.8151951432228088,
-0.3451133072376251,
0.447662353515625,
-0.8533152937889099,
-0.07515849173069,
-0.43446215987205505,
-0.07426825165748596,
0.380298912525177,
-0.029123101383447647,
-0.7473450303077698,
0.3533726632595062,
0.6049050092697144,
0.8726464509963989,
-0.9081435799598694,
1.0035574436187744,
0.5590223073959351,
-0.3558081090450287,
-0.7689560651779175,
-0.34491652250289917,
0.3422866761684418,
-0.7289285659790039,
0.5284751653671265,
0.3040983974933624,
-0.01746092364192009,
0.14463704824447632,
-0.2690443992614746,
-0.8520353436470032,
0.450202077627182,
0.19480033218860626,
-0.6575913429260254,
0.23536451160907745,
0.30165010690689087,
0.5092703104019165,
-0.26102301478385925,
0.05982620641589165,
0.09677654504776001,
0.39152321219444275,
-0.3480384051799774,
-0.9256515502929688,
-0.19078540802001953,
-0.49506908655166626,
-0.1960754692554474,
0.3181178867816925,
-0.6910610795021057,
0.9732243418693542,
0.06314650923013687,
-0.44530239701271057,
0.24119821190834045,
0.6565866470336914,
-0.38430339097976685,
0.01362760178744793,
0.5970297455787659,
0.6403459906578064,
1.2514816522598267,
0.08918063342571259,
0.827362060546875,
-0.45567283034324646,
0.2581735849380493,
1.098583459854126,
-0.30114156007766724,
0.9485772848129272,
-0.025822540745139122,
-0.004347717389464378,
0.6986782550811768,
0.8737009763717651,
-0.22770936787128448,
0.41586461663246155,
0.17293953895568848,
-0.5166506767272949,
-0.46799492835998535,
-0.26989617943763733,
-0.269022673368454,
0.8387491703033447,
0.2311636507511139,
-0.4224359095096588,
-0.3036380112171173,
0.29656580090522766,
0.029440665617585182,
0.049650177359580994,
-0.1907438337802887,
0.9854782819747925,
-0.06659778207540512,
-0.5002825260162354,
0.6771991848945618,
0.353969007730484,
0.41598042845726013,
-0.8031282424926758,
0.2007366269826889,
-0.07453589141368866,
0.4011777341365814,
-0.053271885961294174,
-0.4626646637916565,
-0.08858046680688858,
0.19179081916809082,
-0.5186899304389954,
-0.34696757793426514,
0.6160808205604553,
-0.5959662795066833,
-0.6867992877960205,
0.42978084087371826,
0.6025353670120239,
0.22686867415905,
0.11122985184192657,
-0.7231228351593018,
0.02193710021674633,
0.020495623350143433,
-0.09021029621362686,
0.5386016368865967,
0.7957773804664612,
-0.2618672847747803,
0.5475656986236572,
0.7570831775665283,
-0.265048086643219,
0.21283666789531708,
0.1381729543209076,
0.7016236782073975,
-0.5228232741355896,
-0.5261552333831787,
-0.7674643993377686,
0.28189900517463684,
0.06953328102827072,
-0.47674983739852905,
0.9277322888374329,
0.9178609848022461,
1.1556848287582397,
-0.057267650961875916,
0.9381782412528992,
0.04834844917058945,
0.5690994262695312,
-0.2914803624153137,
1.0439294576644897,
-0.7948585748672485,
-0.07670781016349792,
0.12513840198516846,
-0.4505285620689392,
-0.5225364565849304,
0.256291002035141,
0.3184971511363983,
-0.24761883914470673,
0.45282936096191406,
0.5909139513969421,
-0.12940803170204163,
-0.13820980489253998,
0.28485143184661865,
0.13545039296150208,
0.02910139039158821,
0.5148248672485352,
0.8991405963897705,
-0.13856032490730286,
0.6505742073059082,
-0.6301047205924988,
-0.3403664827346802,
0.18237391114234924,
-0.7609335780143738,
-0.7923628687858582,
-0.8866931200027466,
-0.39396902918815613,
-0.16984982788562775,
-0.23052725195884705,
0.5606622099876404,
0.827123761177063,
-1.0471103191375732,
-0.5248522162437439,
0.2585280239582062,
0.02632107585668564,
-0.27380868792533875,
-0.17685657739639282,
0.38340625166893005,
-0.41074487566947937,
-0.7341118454933167,
0.6745997071266174,
-0.07422947138547897,
0.022340375930070877,
-0.31224027276039124,
0.20435330271720886,
-0.3185173571109772,
-0.1199154332280159,
0.364692360162735,
0.5940397381782532,
-0.8400969505310059,
0.04483456909656525,
-0.11178415268659592,
-0.1311897188425064,
0.003946532495319843,
0.8248341679573059,
-0.830050528049469,
0.5130906701087952,
0.1902930587530136,
0.8107941150665283,
0.3244546949863434,
-0.20451292395591736,
0.4067062437534332,
-1.015087366104126,
0.43867388367652893,
0.43824031949043274,
0.18096952140331268,
0.3096573054790497,
-0.32801419496536255,
0.4275808036327362,
0.2034788876771927,
-0.16254517436027527,
-0.9097172617912292,
0.28594085574150085,
-0.8419283628463745,
-0.918430507183075,
0.9532923698425293,
-0.2260458618402481,
-0.2513631582260132,
-0.30882537364959717,
0.5582854151725769,
0.48893702030181885,
-0.09022540599107742,
0.6214727163314819,
0.7578436136245728,
0.20997254550457,
-0.28085991740226746,
-0.5753395557403564,
0.6717946529388428,
-0.06493282318115234,
-0.3089236617088318,
0.09265153855085373,
0.6560897827148438,
0.07888603210449219,
0.3853284418582916,
0.520003080368042,
0.09761233627796173,
0.1431756466627121,
-0.33554619550704956,
0.21732163429260254,
0.012761273421347141,
-0.5679715871810913,
-0.607352077960968,
0.4553113877773285,
-0.04032393917441368,
-0.11511041969060898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19884v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19884v1 | Investigating the Timescales of Language Processing with EEG and Language Models | 2024-06-28T12:49:27 | 2024-06-28T12:49:27 | Davide Turco, Conor Houghton | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | This study explores the temporal dynamics of language processing by examining
the alignment between word representations from a pre-trained transformer-based
language model, and EEG data. Using a Temporal Response Function (TRF) model,
we investigate how neural activity corresponds to model representations across
different layers, revealing insights into the interaction between artificial
language models and brain responses during language comprehension. Our analysis
reveals patterns in TRFs from distinct layers, highlighting varying
contributions to lexical and compositional processing. Additionally, we used
linear discriminant analysis (LDA) to isolate part-of-speech (POS)
representations, offering insights into their influence on neural responses and
the underlying mechanisms of syntactic processing. These findings underscore
EEG's utility for probing language processing dynamics with high temporal
resolution. By bridging artificial language models and neural activity, this
study advances our understanding of their interaction at fine timescales. | [
-0.1881115585565567,
-1.2874873876571655,
0.725594162940979,
0.43165501952171326,
-0.04449814558029175,
0.07545438408851624,
-0.09320823848247528,
-0.6831693053245544,
0.257921040058136,
0.19695770740509033,
-0.527817964553833,
-0.12522661685943604,
-0.36064109206199646,
0.021520491689443588,
-0.5894151926040649,
0.242486834526062,
-0.02825278416275978,
-0.02447819523513317,
-0.050664372742176056,
-0.20463994145393372,
-0.4965006411075592,
-0.6294909715652466,
-0.8967127203941345,
-0.7371747493743896,
0.5626326203346252,
-0.3470826745033264,
0.44971540570259094,
0.6309112906455994,
0.13287542760372162,
0.29859721660614014,
-0.1985802799463272,
-0.43049508333206177,
-0.0708530843257904,
0.20659425854682922,
-0.08239498734474182,
-0.6236762404441833,
-0.4932241141796112,
-0.04732877016067505,
0.6781503558158875,
1.0547956228256226,
-0.38257572054862976,
0.20721207559108734,
0.12300428748130798,
0.3123348653316498,
-0.45619824528694153,
0.3062955141067505,
-0.47512397170066833,
0.19498096406459808,
-0.3413674235343933,
-0.28752169013023376,
-0.6544455289840698,
-0.12771078944206238,
0.3949856758117676,
-0.38043013215065,
0.12019867449998856,
-0.06185103580355644,
0.7716706991195679,
0.08359230309724808,
-0.45922741293907166,
0.1578131914138794,
-0.8839942216873169,
0.6173615455627441,
-0.6864140033721924,
0.6624502539634705,
0.22983917593955994,
0.044447168707847595,
0.07497384399175644,
-0.8309012055397034,
-0.9419055581092834,
-0.1808881163597107,
-0.2857464849948883,
-0.11136384308338165,
-0.08056125044822693,
0.10320819169282913,
0.39580392837524414,
0.025873571634292603,
-0.7519188523292542,
0.12050674110651016,
-0.21302402019500732,
-0.16607150435447693,
0.2135905772447586,
0.11763756722211838,
0.5242083072662354,
-0.04101329296827316,
-0.18405033648014069,
-0.2279282957315445,
-0.2273309975862503,
0.15894576907157898,
0.22535566985607147,
-0.0518685057759285,
-0.0785883292555809,
0.6677653193473816,
0.45308369398117065,
0.8747707605361938,
0.05041057616472244,
0.10502288490533829,
0.22999083995819092,
-0.2521332800388336,
-0.31064045429229736,
0.3480595052242279,
0.7696381211280823,
0.16388633847236633,
0.14815986156463623,
-0.21083152294158936,
-0.21967275440692902,
0.20676515996456146,
0.24095359444618225,
-0.4695051610469818,
0.1354219615459442,
0.1492057591676712,
-0.4283148944377899,
0.04433993995189667,
-0.2814745306968689,
-0.6957196593284607,
-0.07102897018194199,
-0.4921272099018097,
0.36856505274772644,
-0.47860729694366455,
-0.37880972027778625,
0.30133476853370667,
-0.14115966856479645,
0.4432622790336609,
-0.1922473907470703,
-0.887665331363678,
0.3887816071510315,
0.37288129329681396,
0.6480730175971985,
0.005854685790836811,
-0.4509012699127197,
-0.32246536016464233,
0.45598846673965454,
-0.3394373953342438,
0.7199599146842957,
-0.661782443523407,
-0.20750094950199127,
0.11403349786996841,
0.09361059218645096,
-0.45205289125442505,
-0.30616122484207153,
0.16945719718933105,
-0.9007261395454407,
0.21881873905658722,
-0.09580579400062561,
-0.3942592740058899,
-0.12350406497716904,
-0.11839555203914642,
-0.9449418783187866,
0.9454758167266846,
0.0781339704990387,
-0.6925598978996277,
0.1139114648103714,
-0.7217856049537659,
-0.5266250967979431,
0.03993002325296402,
-0.1751270443201065,
0.022880306467413902,
0.36547157168388367,
0.26937219500541687,
0.313566118478775,
-0.006419612094759941,
0.13670922815799713,
-0.09304032474756241,
-0.2581104338169098,
0.5171252489089966,
-0.2909029722213745,
0.8397409319877625,
0.13649192452430725,
-0.19640593230724335,
-0.13563399016857147,
-0.7574662566184998,
0.054633092135190964,
0.2806222438812256,
-0.06187894940376282,
-0.3403943181037903,
0.45618507266044617,
0.021899744868278503,
0.1589834988117218,
0.37657415866851807,
-0.551969587802887,
-0.07944527268409729,
-0.4197065234184265,
0.7854845523834229,
0.4316052794456482,
0.09385897219181061,
0.5160216689109802,
0.05116713047027588,
0.4679238796234131,
0.17639407515525818,
-0.08502624928951263,
-0.3192347288131714,
-0.1706508845090866,
-0.5462307929992676,
0.46572864055633545,
0.2972201108932495,
0.46109941601753235,
-0.6350072026252747,
0.39846310019493103,
-0.4144103527069092,
-0.08158788830041885,
-0.6323723793029785,
-0.3313513696193695,
-0.009117934852838516,
0.454216331243515,
0.3546387553215027,
-0.2946843206882477,
-0.3586640954017639,
-0.9248815178871155,
-0.11290384083986282,
-0.4045795500278473,
-0.3054288625717163,
-0.09534775465726852,
0.08570142090320587,
-0.048607878386974335,
1.008560299873352,
-0.38484251499176025,
-0.015809042379260063,
-0.27731016278266907,
0.6724595427513123,
-0.08781115710735321,
0.14443469047546387,
0.9304298758506775,
-0.5433495044708252,
-0.16384229063987732,
0.12828679382801056,
-0.5269793272018433,
-0.3601778745651245,
-0.1469133347272873,
0.1515454202890396,
0.2377108782529831,
0.8020315170288086,
-0.4476599097251892,
0.36319586634635925,
0.649768054485321,
-0.6708263754844666,
0.2554558217525482,
-0.24029508233070374,
0.30212971568107605,
-0.6253636479377747,
0.1297406703233719,
-0.08583059161901474,
-0.1533305048942566,
-0.6736450791358948,
-0.18642373383045197,
0.1614137440919876,
-0.14023926854133606,
-0.4242316782474518,
0.3407641351222992,
-0.5158491730690002,
-0.10296528041362762,
-0.3165574073791504,
0.33931946754455566,
-0.007381966803222895,
0.5588529706001282,
0.17753073573112488,
0.7156510949134827,
0.4506450593471527,
-0.40462526679039,
-0.08411673456430435,
-0.14077791571617126,
-0.3129449486732483,
0.287916898727417,
-1.0057858228683472,
0.34261688590049744,
-0.24825285375118256,
-0.1741049587726593,
-0.9746307730674744,
0.0526486337184906,
-0.2885485589504242,
-0.3668147921562195,
0.3645179569721222,
0.10481181740760803,
-0.6787087321281433,
-0.21186533570289612,
0.14464135468006134,
0.7675671577453613,
0.4441331923007965,
-0.17708992958068848,
1.083855152130127,
0.5967249870300293,
-0.19598516821861267,
-0.23035480082035065,
-0.9331223368644714,
-0.10731524229049683,
-0.0356576070189476,
-0.630214512348175,
0.582391619682312,
0.099666528403759,
-0.4355570673942566,
-0.10348527878522873,
-0.17327284812927246,
-0.06079302728176117,
-0.015010140836238861,
-0.02416611649096012,
0.1487128734588623,
-0.3007722496986389,
-0.19984275102615356,
-0.0326567180454731,
0.2563258111476898,
0.47078827023506165,
-0.12249314785003662,
0.9612517952919006,
0.21628831326961517,
-0.20286685228347778,
-0.38116297125816345,
0.3340725004673004,
0.7246232628822327,
-0.5545318722724915,
0.9905553460121155,
0.6109051704406738,
-0.6063618063926697,
-0.05308499559760094,
-0.4814583361148834,
-0.15261049568653107,
-0.41406670212745667,
0.38841482996940613,
-0.2912469804286957,
-0.7712521553039551,
0.8040227890014648,
0.5640622973442078,
-0.20289291441440582,
0.3653978407382965,
0.37090200185775757,
-0.24611379206180573,
1.1389230489730835,
0.563850998878479,
0.06209290772676468,
0.955392062664032,
0.022277330979704857,
0.40574911236763,
-0.8544303178787231,
-0.317544549703598,
-0.37682172656059265,
-0.550640344619751,
-0.2461796998977661,
-0.12864546477794647,
0.15335313975811005,
0.07500635087490082,
0.07782032340765,
0.4265466332435608,
-0.19142219424247742,
0.5908133387565613,
0.12062737345695496,
0.03575966879725456,
-0.03662869334220886,
-0.12998917698860168,
-0.27571922540664673,
-0.05962323024868965,
-0.43671998381614685,
-0.31943681836128235,
0.7408800721168518,
0.4241489768028259,
0.6067470908164978,
-0.18045924603939056,
0.08278259634971619,
0.23133975267410278,
-0.27474936842918396,
-0.48488110303878784,
0.7615492939949036,
-0.12162255495786667,
-0.4087894558906555,
-0.20421630144119263,
-0.06527308374643326,
-1.1224126815795898,
0.05992455407977104,
0.0021297577768564224,
-1.1035877466201782,
0.14884856343269348,
-0.11372140049934387,
-0.4995516836643219,
0.2543186843395233,
-1.116909384727478,
0.7436251640319824,
-0.10694590955972672,
-0.31006377935409546,
-0.5740213990211487,
-0.49420660734176636,
-0.017133502289652824,
0.14410676062107086,
-0.06182033568620682,
0.018750851973891258,
0.1716250628232956,
0.9032768607139587,
-0.14096961915493011,
0.6611837148666382,
-0.06922684609889984,
-0.28303396701812744,
0.26965636014938354,
0.43826112151145935,
0.13337168097496033,
-0.1587522178888321,
0.20620761811733246,
0.31633439660072327,
0.29908260703086853,
-0.3450416028499603,
-0.5716066360473633,
0.812603771686554,
-0.6927522420883179,
-0.552640438079834,
-0.4606730341911316,
-0.6482939720153809,
-0.04466797411441803,
0.03496439382433891,
0.12229146808385849,
0.5112169981002808,
-0.194464311003685,
-0.05493107810616493,
0.717278003692627,
-0.036589089781045914,
0.9959990978240967,
0.3533177971839905,
-0.3671644330024719,
-0.004079498816281557,
0.4090324938297272,
0.3360670804977417,
0.14600922167301178,
0.7788181304931641,
-0.20415346324443817,
-0.3179987668991089,
-0.5044571161270142,
0.13389471173286438,
0.43221211433410645,
-0.3355391025543213,
0.3220334053039551,
-0.5694235563278198,
-0.34084615111351013,
-0.453009694814682,
0.15355949103832245,
-0.13952620327472687,
-0.33757808804512024,
-0.2534121572971344,
-0.08198180794715881,
-0.047266166657209396,
0.7284634113311768,
0.3552108705043793,
0.5131992101669312,
-0.7634165287017822,
0.3075965344905853,
0.353338360786438,
0.37167584896087646,
0.11255065351724625,
-0.2915632128715515,
-0.3021419942378998,
0.00028506008675321937,
-0.10354063659906387,
-1.1543248891830444,
0.30929768085479736,
0.16780409216880798,
0.5759752988815308,
0.12491413205862045,
-0.5359352231025696,
0.5069924592971802,
-0.8054181933403015,
1.2070502042770386,
0.09528186172246933,
-1.1357872486114502,
0.5604617595672607,
-0.23971353471279144,
0.7129200100898743,
-0.0931246355175972,
0.10521987080574036,
-0.6109088063240051,
-0.45250028371810913,
-0.3518342971801758,
-0.6583430767059326,
0.7950318455696106,
0.2854762673377991,
-0.17721663415431976,
-0.0956033319234848,
0.38314154744148254,
-0.13713738322257996,
-0.10975737869739532,
-0.7105685472488403,
-0.3311541974544525,
0.07514860481023788,
0.018486976623535156,
-0.03632615879178047,
-0.35508111119270325,
-0.015974614769220352,
-0.09898708015680313,
-0.0004989971057511866,
0.007389753125607967,
0.7591476440429688,
0.11455831676721573,
-0.3173902928829193,
-0.34555354714393616,
0.2890914976596832,
0.5356832146644592,
0.8481914401054382,
-0.08242890983819962,
0.22992075979709625,
0.1279451698064804,
-0.5442029237747192,
0.04179023951292038,
0.27500784397125244,
0.21670494973659515,
0.13920161128044128,
0.7055110931396484,
0.8354759812355042,
0.01515666302293539,
-0.444109171628952,
0.30005690455436707,
-0.37946611642837524,
-0.0004031003045383841,
-0.306370347738266,
0.05748188868165016,
0.14611002802848816,
0.37250182032585144,
0.49617496132850647,
-0.0026632125955075026,
-0.15145154297351837,
-0.24961499869823456,
0.09471901506185532,
0.20765720307826996,
-0.1467965990304947,
-0.9489918947219849,
0.9640899300575256,
-0.26291728019714355,
-0.4994170665740967,
0.6003714799880981,
0.11262053996324539,
-0.3458075523376465,
0.6415419578552246,
0.7158637642860413,
0.9869878888130188,
-0.4292304217815399,
-0.033699698746204376,
0.2553013563156128,
0.12801457941532135,
0.1764851063489914,
0.5303712487220764,
0.006681572645902634,
-0.7150104641914368,
-0.8471626043319702,
-0.6236727237701416,
0.3129826784133911,
0.37840595841407776,
-0.6384962201118469,
0.04479425773024559,
-0.21444979310035706,
-0.5721482634544373,
0.25487181544303894,
-0.3325725495815277,
-0.8567083477973938,
0.023420734331011772,
0.4516274333000183,
0.7598087787628174,
-0.7800442576408386,
1.0067964792251587,
0.7059770822525024,
-0.22627213597297668,
-0.7141849994659424,
0.23424559831619263,
-0.28163039684295654,
-0.6247054934501648,
0.7849347591400146,
-0.0753948763012886,
-0.3419018089771271,
0.06184440106153488,
-0.3772013783454895,
-0.638035237789154,
0.9428349137306213,
0.7389870285987854,
-0.637007474899292,
-0.47814518213272095,
0.29255133867263794,
0.9396836161613464,
-0.09038116782903671,
0.3115019202232361,
0.9635800123214722,
0.2566050589084625,
-0.42675670981407166,
-0.9813618659973145,
-0.27433180809020996,
-0.20948798954486847,
0.16743996739387512,
0.5238998532295227,
-0.3816128075122833,
0.7044069766998291,
0.18352408707141876,
-0.6065292954444885,
-0.3023154139518738,
0.8920301198959351,
-0.07734674215316772,
0.006646350957453251,
0.5864105820655823,
0.6492006778717041,
0.32718729972839355,
-0.3340985178947449,
0.8867914080619812,
-0.4833621084690094,
0.10619349777698517,
0.8553677797317505,
-0.26545971632003784,
0.9213144183158875,
0.904414713382721,
-0.453107625246048,
0.6942024827003479,
0.4562825560569763,
0.4539323151111603,
0.515214204788208,
-0.010452247224748135,
-0.26087382435798645,
-0.10179485380649567,
-0.15430952608585358,
-0.097862109541893,
0.22100986540317535,
0.44739410281181335,
-0.15746892988681793,
-0.16952118277549744,
0.3450433611869812,
-0.4372212588787079,
0.07672957330942154,
-0.2961685061454773,
0.5309439301490784,
-0.02574046142399311,
-0.8165300488471985,
0.3017610013484955,
-0.2176200896501541,
0.26406025886535645,
-0.697506844997406,
-0.0322549045085907,
-0.06987962871789932,
0.02837623469531536,
0.08846139162778854,
-1.056504487991333,
0.36083686351776123,
-0.2829124629497528,
-0.22503310441970825,
-0.44996383786201477,
0.4621836245059967,
-0.7146030068397522,
-0.06481020152568817,
0.8679764866828918,
0.34171250462532043,
-0.3256075978279114,
0.2279951274394989,
-0.3742919862270355,
0.2085098773241043,
-0.16497768461704254,
-0.3500411808490753,
0.12681944668293,
0.5538414120674133,
0.13417840003967285,
0.43835878372192383,
0.1166650727391243,
0.31465569138526917,
0.5597289204597473,
0.39471545815467834,
0.407474547624588,
-0.7724980115890503,
-0.5852150321006775,
-0.8949812054634094,
0.33601707220077515,
0.28110331296920776,
-0.030745772644877434,
0.23293127119541168,
0.18794666230678558,
0.9466180801391602,
-0.04220511019229889,
0.30618318915367126,
-0.31430086493492126,
0.32734790444374084,
-0.7343218326568604,
0.6289101839065552,
-0.42622214555740356,
0.2132137417793274,
0.21425685286521912,
-0.9669947624206543,
-0.16544294357299805,
0.36237090826034546,
-0.30701321363449097,
-0.16492556035518646,
1.0969277620315552,
0.6347543597221375,
-0.00044620700646191835,
0.17065611481666565,
0.28137943148612976,
0.44925981760025024,
0.38611140847206116,
0.545495331287384,
0.7910167574882507,
-0.33918139338493347,
0.21631106734275818,
-0.2641153633594513,
0.15484094619750977,
0.18923015892505646,
-0.7509109377861023,
-0.8205660581588745,
-1.044049620628357,
-0.2711818516254425,
-0.1446629762649536,
-0.15302349627017975,
0.8141359090805054,
0.38364648818969727,
-0.8631921410560608,
-0.5429851412773132,
0.015016869641840458,
-0.24747543036937714,
-0.5053529143333435,
-0.3150905668735504,
0.4826851785182953,
-0.5055408477783203,
-0.9345131516456604,
0.4496493339538574,
0.23814351856708527,
0.18600153923034668,
-0.3436189889907837,
0.32032862305641174,
-0.5039893984794617,
0.05290517210960388,
0.6426814794540405,
0.03825424611568451,
-0.5442923307418823,
-0.2873658537864685,
0.3589480519294739,
-0.2008931040763855,
0.14904308319091797,
1.1209006309509277,
-0.9106860160827637,
0.4509808421134949,
0.79300457239151,
0.5708766579627991,
0.5344016551971436,
-0.36438482999801636,
0.8338122367858887,
-0.8548516631126404,
0.16254153847694397,
0.2810429632663727,
0.609113872051239,
0.024131517857313156,
-0.27305713295936584,
0.13167576491832733,
0.04918164387345314,
-0.6422312259674072,
-0.686036229133606,
0.08806301653385162,
-1.0651432275772095,
-0.27355387806892395,
0.7718184590339661,
0.2739943861961365,
-0.6255801916122437,
0.02887938916683197,
-0.06361053138971329,
0.49040281772613525,
-0.1872442215681076,
0.7977584004402161,
1.333507776260376,
-0.4102759063243866,
-0.2243671417236328,
-0.43003490567207336,
0.15639355778694153,
0.43159517645835876,
-0.43142640590667725,
0.05888749286532402,
0.24085870385169983,
-0.08378656953573227,
0.42979151010513306,
0.3095594048500061,
-0.19241592288017273,
0.07211553305387497,
-0.15089260041713715,
-0.14167386293411255,
0.2959725856781006,
-0.2940414845943451,
-0.5030314922332764,
0.30134958028793335,
-0.04564683884382248,
-0.2310994565486908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19874v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19874v1 | Detecting Subtle Differences between Human and Model Languages Using Spectrum of Relative Likelihood | 2024-06-28T12:28:52 | 2024-06-28T12:28:52 | Yang Xu, Yu Wang, Hao An, Zhichen Liu, Yongyuan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Human and model-generated texts can be distinguished by examining the
magnitude of likelihood in language. However, it is becoming increasingly
difficult as language model's capabilities of generating human-like texts keep
evolving. This study provides a new perspective by using the relative
likelihood values instead of absolute ones, and extracting useful features from
the spectrum-view of likelihood for the human-model text detection task. We
propose a detection procedure with two classification methods, supervised and
heuristic-based, respectively, which results in competitive performances with
previous zero-shot detection methods and a new state-of-the-art on short-text
detection. Our method can also reveal subtle differences between human and
model languages, which find theoretical roots in psycholinguistics studies. Our
code is available at https://github.com/CLCS-SUSTech/FourierGPT | [
-0.5069479942321777,
-0.9169765114784241,
0.6769905090332031,
-0.20498277246952057,
-0.09686233103275299,
0.23834574222564697,
-0.36149272322654724,
-0.8383321166038513,
0.08896342664957047,
0.4302839934825897,
-0.4543944001197815,
-0.4551801085472107,
-0.3180408775806427,
0.08431590348482132,
-0.46104782819747925,
0.6050826907157898,
0.24285119771957397,
-0.15050108730793,
0.17365799844264984,
-0.12714830040931702,
-0.07832988351583481,
-0.502661406993866,
-0.5331519842147827,
-0.29880470037460327,
0.6180051565170288,
0.3043993413448334,
0.5202113389968872,
0.46072062849998474,
0.5345044136047363,
0.20096376538276672,
-0.10432533174753189,
-0.18650366365909576,
0.03015403263270855,
0.05723947286605835,
0.01582234352827072,
-0.5653059482574463,
-0.2521071135997772,
-0.16564138233661652,
0.9468074440956116,
0.7558649778366089,
0.20137135684490204,
0.20200037956237793,
0.11773262172937393,
0.6905146241188049,
-0.7408026456832886,
0.1379566490650177,
-0.40821877121925354,
0.007550032343715429,
-1.0101755857467651,
-0.10180903971195221,
-0.40840888023376465,
-0.08662984520196915,
0.04367687553167343,
-0.22301629185676575,
0.5331536531448364,
0.043232761323451996,
0.9682650566101074,
-0.09075061231851578,
-0.4930431544780731,
-0.17934446036815643,
-0.8579437136650085,
0.9191122651100159,
-0.8657780885696411,
0.7987396121025085,
0.5953296422958374,
0.5129351615905762,
-0.12208087742328644,
-0.5721842050552368,
-0.6632928848266602,
-0.5098321437835693,
0.011172099970281124,
-0.24170207977294922,
-0.4874241352081299,
-0.19047893583774567,
0.25670912861824036,
0.22661416232585907,
-0.7092019319534302,
0.2517600655555725,
-0.3215850293636322,
-0.4687764346599579,
0.4815368950366974,
-0.13236664235591888,
0.23057544231414795,
-0.36879047751426697,
0.20702973008155823,
-0.24374021589756012,
-0.49655798077583313,
0.08915106952190399,
0.7577963471412659,
0.3704604208469391,
-0.30206337571144104,
0.27041390538215637,
-0.32695329189300537,
0.638022243976593,
-0.07977819442749023,
-0.19722062349319458,
0.3736858367919922,
0.05632036551833153,
-0.06657861173152924,
-0.13546980917453766,
0.7628210783004761,
-0.16555078327655792,
0.3592633903026581,
-0.09393243491649628,
-0.19922490417957306,
0.4149903655052185,
-0.050927046686410904,
-0.509706437587738,
-0.5702680945396423,
-0.2590436339378357,
-0.632631778717041,
-0.7161875367164612,
-0.07985551655292511,
-0.5033935904502869,
-0.3741621673107147,
-0.0807264968752861,
0.08468663692474365,
-0.47319895029067993,
-0.4229588806629181,
0.19537189602851868,
-0.017335159704089165,
0.11377640813589096,
-0.12713417410850525,
-0.8861530423164368,
0.43560534715652466,
0.4293248951435089,
0.5008311867713928,
-0.14435504376888275,
0.08611970394849777,
-0.29444536566734314,
-0.17516636848449707,
-0.3657466769218445,
1.205578327178955,
-0.5395002365112305,
-0.2304103672504425,
-0.1604813188314438,
-0.32156166434288025,
0.27055731415748596,
-0.5552172660827637,
0.7749483585357666,
-0.4710995852947235,
0.5989890098571777,
-0.325844943523407,
-0.582949161529541,
-0.32441580295562744,
0.15483546257019043,
-0.6728104948997498,
1.2397533655166626,
0.07146316766738892,
-0.972349226474762,
0.41575363278388977,
-0.5362805724143982,
-0.384874552488327,
0.12546367943286896,
-0.47760945558547974,
-0.7363262176513672,
0.19227153062820435,
0.16835904121398926,
0.43983203172683716,
-0.4030565917491913,
0.2245853692293167,
-0.5045396685600281,
-0.5197436213493347,
0.613135576248169,
-0.769734263420105,
0.7469087839126587,
0.24382835626602173,
-0.29508712887763977,
0.017533913254737854,
-1.0119900703430176,
-0.044593747705221176,
0.14965209364891052,
-0.21861296892166138,
-0.41705262660980225,
0.27566707134246826,
0.3174600601196289,
0.15383845567703247,
0.022846771404147148,
-0.4356357157230377,
-0.023938635364174843,
-0.49163031578063965,
0.23887059092521667,
0.3738831877708435,
0.12797506153583527,
0.6114659309387207,
-0.2737545669078827,
0.5060897469520569,
-0.05991668254137039,
0.08023235201835632,
-0.04967714473605156,
-0.6180464029312134,
-0.6516686081886292,
-0.42568978667259216,
0.49167340993881226,
0.4530850648880005,
-0.767747163772583,
0.5860751271247864,
0.02921011485159397,
-0.32334721088409424,
-0.22510047256946564,
-0.10327429324388504,
0.48194918036460876,
0.5915412902832031,
0.18090508878231049,
-0.3545284569263458,
-0.3952619135379791,
-1.1583168506622314,
-0.3656664490699768,
-0.5094330310821533,
-0.3693118393421173,
0.17958220839500427,
0.36908984184265137,
-0.20537099242210388,
1.1645320653915405,
-0.7350288033485413,
-0.11815761029720306,
-0.12023653090000153,
0.2379886358976364,
0.04073439911007881,
0.29672661423683167,
0.8970038890838623,
-0.8796762824058533,
-0.6711482405662537,
-0.03985380008816719,
-0.7622835636138916,
-0.3741074800491333,
0.015422011725604534,
0.0001072949162335135,
0.15484069287776947,
0.6232615113258362,
-0.06475567817687988,
0.34129825234413147,
0.16694888472557068,
-0.2538146376609802,
0.6485922336578369,
-0.03563675284385681,
0.23427429795265198,
-0.9022482633590698,
0.11703121662139893,
0.39026525616645813,
-0.3744371831417084,
-0.8716078400611877,
0.11971503496170044,
0.2396710216999054,
0.32447007298469543,
-0.46638041734695435,
0.651904821395874,
-0.3601062595844269,
-0.15443302690982819,
-0.3330531120300293,
-0.003997431602329016,
-0.3299461305141449,
0.5840014219284058,
0.1921246349811554,
0.34846898913383484,
0.5686600208282471,
-0.49435845017433167,
0.1116163358092308,
-0.09122666716575623,
-0.4183718264102936,
0.5773788094520569,
-0.319900780916214,
0.14120440185070038,
-0.09057070314884186,
0.1017022356390953,
-0.9829161763191223,
-0.40541619062423706,
0.6062934994697571,
-0.554564893245697,
0.29334598779678345,
-0.31418702006340027,
-0.6408537030220032,
-0.3590035140514374,
-0.44000598788261414,
0.5232457518577576,
0.7592568397521973,
-0.0882362350821495,
0.11859249323606491,
0.22511862218379974,
-0.07394418865442276,
-0.3426164984703064,
-0.6262766122817993,
0.07674016058444977,
-0.46110761165618896,
-0.5296781659126282,
0.3733118772506714,
0.10728096961975098,
-0.38447603583335876,
-0.1311672031879425,
-0.07010176032781601,
-0.44353368878364563,
0.22516688704490662,
0.02059420756995678,
0.2208988517522812,
-0.38312074542045593,
0.17358285188674927,
0.33803591132164,
-0.42754125595092773,
-0.1987779289484024,
-0.3944385349750519,
0.4432441294193268,
-0.2504183053970337,
-0.3732406198978424,
-0.5880098342895508,
0.22405223548412323,
0.22692984342575073,
-0.2875424325466156,
0.3237869441509247,
0.929715633392334,
-0.4116053283214569,
-0.009107970632612705,
-0.6168009042739868,
-0.5661248564720154,
-0.48428767919540405,
0.31621620059013367,
-0.33922988176345825,
-0.8116734623908997,
0.6218602657318115,
0.031955502927303314,
-0.3679525852203369,
0.3765828311443329,
0.510785698890686,
-0.3490401804447174,
0.8689586520195007,
0.8852203488349915,
-0.023075010627508163,
0.770489513874054,
0.11701862514019012,
0.13878637552261353,
-0.5902313590049744,
0.29220348596572876,
-0.7402609586715698,
-0.18076519668102264,
-0.5179978013038635,
-0.2554100453853607,
0.438002347946167,
0.221768319606781,
-0.10692933201789856,
0.29317930340766907,
-0.39412879943847656,
0.6607645153999329,
0.4735059142112732,
0.1419343650341034,
0.3369329571723938,
0.21693480014801025,
-0.12897488474845886,
-0.38433462381362915,
-0.30411073565483093,
-0.6425926685333252,
1.128092646598816,
0.47103387117385864,
0.40263837575912476,
0.3218936324119568,
0.7869894504547119,
0.5103231072425842,
0.1727209836244583,
-0.725473940372467,
0.5451618432998657,
-0.2148485779762268,
-0.5446175932884216,
-0.21707722544670105,
-0.46569228172302246,
-0.8886197805404663,
0.33015212416648865,
-0.38322821259498596,
-1.0168908834457397,
0.1265670359134674,
0.1126454770565033,
-0.27099353075027466,
0.17719519138336182,
-0.5473414659500122,
0.9046608209609985,
0.10464712977409363,
-0.14212748408317566,
0.044942520558834076,
-0.6637117266654968,
0.41565772891044617,
-0.3490258753299713,
0.37369322776794434,
-0.25758054852485657,
0.2591364085674286,
0.7392457723617554,
0.01342101488262415,
0.9356175065040588,
-0.15506045520305634,
-0.35250094532966614,
0.24789012968540192,
0.32940030097961426,
0.2540811598300934,
-0.19808438420295715,
0.051184333860874176,
0.1422056257724762,
-0.07048236578702927,
-0.5072785019874573,
-0.41366416215896606,
0.3531256914138794,
-0.30998098850250244,
-0.20280219614505768,
-0.2486967295408249,
-0.5245757102966309,
-0.21590471267700195,
0.3539949059486389,
0.6142399311065674,
0.4202747344970703,
-0.2566726505756378,
-0.10719181597232819,
0.6063348650932312,
-0.27361422777175903,
0.660574734210968,
0.6422099471092224,
-0.48585712909698486,
0.191483736038208,
0.8903030753135681,
-0.1499970406293869,
0.23293936252593994,
0.4558738172054291,
0.4869522452354431,
-0.3570842742919922,
-0.5594456791877747,
-0.312188982963562,
0.34427687525749207,
-0.4771958291530609,
0.12254605442285538,
-0.3421981632709503,
0.11575203388929367,
-0.3086763620376587,
-0.1982792764902115,
-0.24624189734458923,
-0.4206407964229584,
-0.1742393672466278,
0.34606876969337463,
0.04765644297003746,
0.47874873876571655,
-0.009348529390990734,
0.4457756578922272,
-0.769474446773529,
0.3948027789592743,
0.15728133916854858,
0.006832818500697613,
-0.1476755440235138,
-0.5324693322181702,
-0.09833347797393799,
0.16736549139022827,
-0.2655723989009857,
-1.0788614749908447,
0.467031866312027,
0.2574322521686554,
0.4802651107311249,
0.5117378234863281,
0.15669302642345428,
0.24447862803936005,
-0.2953689396381378,
0.6333867311477661,
0.17879097163677216,
-1.0792852640151978,
0.44327571988105774,
-0.5101333260536194,
0.3026188015937805,
0.3287922739982605,
0.12425419688224792,
-0.6434379816055298,
-0.6073760986328125,
-0.540346622467041,
-0.3595905303955078,
0.8019894957542419,
0.6259159445762634,
-0.030925920233130455,
0.06774286925792694,
0.3896438479423523,
-0.032953180372714996,
-0.046236567199230194,
-0.8079137206077576,
-0.21741485595703125,
0.36877545714378357,
-0.3748503029346466,
0.010806029662489891,
-0.13488195836544037,
0.15579749643802643,
-0.06239927187561989,
0.4114519953727722,
-0.35678595304489136,
0.47808974981307983,
-0.23008961975574493,
-0.37416037917137146,
-0.04843046888709068,
0.4518175423145294,
0.6814243793487549,
0.16558803617954254,
-0.32482337951660156,
0.38631367683410645,
0.12309684604406357,
-0.572117030620575,
0.09313260018825531,
-0.017490217462182045,
-0.24280700087547302,
0.1175258606672287,
0.7381657958030701,
0.4996435046195984,
0.48468413949012756,
-0.529346227645874,
0.5779107809066772,
-0.02362281270325184,
-0.1206078827381134,
-0.17776432633399963,
-0.012769699096679688,
0.05838297680020332,
0.4464596211910248,
0.33495479822158813,
0.40312138199806213,
0.508598268032074,
-0.4903135895729065,
0.36765092611312866,
0.15175975859165192,
-0.5197650194168091,
-0.4787285625934601,
0.5152818560600281,
0.01005063857883215,
-0.38088732957839966,
0.40904220938682556,
-0.6872080564498901,
-0.5798394083976746,
0.6089451313018799,
0.3035089373588562,
1.0303324460983276,
-0.17168819904327393,
0.3706003427505493,
-0.06675048917531967,
0.067217156291008,
-0.046612583100795746,
0.2272559553384781,
-0.3848429322242737,
-1.0190213918685913,
-0.2614244222640991,
-0.49349531531333923,
-0.11903908848762512,
-0.10834330320358276,
-0.7982696890830994,
0.4832921326160431,
-0.1596318930387497,
-0.1869322508573532,
0.6848474740982056,
-0.13108888268470764,
-0.2892458736896515,
-0.2195204347372055,
0.49138590693473816,
0.4932396709918976,
-0.9442513585090637,
1.3950133323669434,
0.4614485502243042,
-0.2796584665775299,
-0.5371126532554626,
0.40231290459632874,
0.4548788070678711,
-0.378028005361557,
0.8319846987724304,
0.06443691998720169,
-0.29449203610420227,
-0.13297410309314728,
-0.27994027733802795,
-0.49900445342063904,
0.7218102812767029,
0.5544977784156799,
-0.7230510711669922,
-0.05006797984242439,
0.21489287912845612,
0.6830635070800781,
0.10588658601045609,
0.04457275941967964,
0.5404638051986694,
0.3763502836227417,
0.014551317319273949,
-1.046460509300232,
-0.2791999578475952,
0.0944681242108345,
0.03501151129603386,
0.6025480628013611,
0.03924207389354706,
1.0743629932403564,
0.06495388597249985,
-0.4434102773666382,
-0.012285967357456684,
0.6161929368972778,
0.1479531079530716,
0.3470553755760193,
0.5014248490333557,
0.20465673506259918,
0.79572993516922,
0.004391173832118511,
0.9256981015205383,
-0.17805473506450653,
0.7713572978973389,
0.8467574715614319,
-0.433175653219223,
0.9075546860694885,
0.17434006929397583,
-0.3846440613269806,
0.626481831073761,
0.49513939023017883,
0.16623961925506592,
0.5326418876647949,
0.08535001426935196,
-0.6221179962158203,
-0.3707735240459442,
0.32579103112220764,
-0.26509708166122437,
0.5512784123420715,
0.4574786424636841,
-0.2548527419567108,
-0.5338484644889832,
0.27133071422576904,
0.10195517539978027,
0.25506195425987244,
-0.012950167991220951,
0.5220752358436584,
0.10243102163076401,
-0.10761505365371704,
0.5977296233177185,
0.44395801424980164,
0.994077205657959,
-0.44609642028808594,
0.09844277799129486,
0.05295904353260994,
0.37884435057640076,
-0.20722481608390808,
-0.7635223269462585,
0.4197927415370941,
0.09463720768690109,
-0.24446706473827362,
0.0839872807264328,
1.0554691553115845,
-0.3445051908493042,
-0.4821699857711792,
0.187678724527359,
0.5642684102058411,
0.11657273769378662,
-0.34828516840934753,
-0.7707199454307556,
-0.03421506658196449,
0.09681184589862823,
0.0904453918337822,
0.23862768709659576,
0.12267561256885529,
-0.5787824392318726,
0.5401309132575989,
0.610252320766449,
-0.24168196320533752,
-0.010673485696315765,
0.17001916468143463,
0.3935621976852417,
-0.623740017414093,
-0.6719524264335632,
-1.0392236709594727,
0.20052506029605865,
-0.08033006638288498,
-0.25136345624923706,
0.6511157751083374,
0.49217984080314636,
0.6757239103317261,
-0.23331069946289062,
0.552812397480011,
-0.05821487307548523,
0.5937836170196533,
-0.4772801101207733,
0.7088631987571716,
-0.33300721645355225,
0.5113510489463806,
-0.46968159079551697,
-0.998513400554657,
-0.7955068945884705,
0.8123562932014465,
-0.33852577209472656,
-0.05663164332509041,
0.733113169670105,
0.8334462642669678,
-0.2746003568172455,
-0.0018737047212198377,
0.5216158032417297,
-0.0010714007075875998,
0.5424569249153137,
0.5325096249580383,
0.8563470244407654,
-0.4253319501876831,
0.32099854946136475,
-0.30588364601135254,
-0.31030651926994324,
-0.2079858034849167,
-0.8604196906089783,
-0.894811749458313,
-0.8392455577850342,
-0.6395092010498047,
-0.062226250767707825,
-0.14118695259094238,
0.6991311311721802,
0.8752398490905762,
-0.7492288947105408,
-0.2791796028614044,
-0.16070973873138428,
0.017853042110800743,
-0.28866270184516907,
-0.23734602332115173,
0.41635024547576904,
-0.02695205621421337,
-0.6342196464538574,
0.4174136817455292,
0.34989163279533386,
0.15909680724143982,
-0.34671512246131897,
-0.0960184633731842,
-0.062443576753139496,
0.24444714188575745,
0.5662834644317627,
0.5421498417854309,
-0.8352805972099304,
-0.4994981288909912,
-0.017351288348436356,
-0.26068437099456787,
-0.09599483758211136,
0.8839493989944458,
-0.9720257520675659,
0.2428547739982605,
0.4857530891895294,
0.15343503654003143,
0.6426540613174438,
-0.5978409647941589,
0.279398113489151,
-1.2392038106918335,
0.4645344913005829,
0.22964206337928772,
0.22435502707958221,
0.240712970495224,
-0.13321837782859802,
0.34764203429222107,
0.5097830295562744,
-0.2850431203842163,
-0.9495406150817871,
0.500341534614563,
-1.2239090204238892,
-0.5103479027748108,
0.9394510984420776,
0.0589413084089756,
-0.09871204942464828,
-0.39098548889160156,
-0.36294886469841003,
0.11186220496892929,
-0.28372493386268616,
0.6933041214942932,
0.5229276418685913,
-0.20065143704414368,
-0.1834961622953415,
-0.43936002254486084,
0.5414905548095703,
0.1585301160812378,
-0.8181917667388916,
-0.1485520601272583,
0.4461088478565216,
0.4222428500652313,
0.22211100161075592,
0.7047291994094849,
-0.12847396731376648,
0.36085495352745056,
0.11550735682249069,
0.14242513477802277,
0.1302746683359146,
-0.1479603499174118,
-0.44334858655929565,
0.23735632002353668,
0.06931157410144806,
-0.18136443197727203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19853v1 | YuLan: An Open-source Large Language Model | 2024-06-28T11:52:53 | 2024-06-28T11:52:53 | Yutao Zhu, Kun Zhou, Kelong Mao, Wentong Chen, Yiding Sun, Zhipeng Chen, Qian Cao, Yihan Wu, Yushuo Chen, Feng Wang, Lei Zhang, Junyi Li, Xiaolei Wang, Lei Wang, Beichen Zhang, Zican Dong, Xiaoxue Cheng, Yuhan Chen, Xinyu Tang, Yupeng Hou, Qiangqiang Ren, Xincheng Pang, Shufang Xie, Wayne Xin Zhao, Zhicheng Dou, Jiaxin Mao, Yankai Lin, Ruihua Song, Jun Xu, Xu Chen, Rui Yan, Zhewei Wei, Di Hu, Wenbing Huang, Ze-Feng Gao, Yueguo Chen, Weizheng Lu, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have become the foundation of many applications,
leveraging their extensive capabilities in processing and understanding natural
language. While many open-source LLMs have been released with technical
reports, the lack of training details hinders further research and development.
This paper presents the development of YuLan, a series of open-source LLMs with
$12$ billion parameters. The base model of YuLan is pre-trained on
approximately $1.7$T tokens derived from a diverse corpus, including massive
English, Chinese, and multilingual texts. We design a three-stage pre-training
method to enhance YuLan's overall capabilities. Subsequent phases of training
incorporate instruction-tuning and human alignment, employing a substantial
volume of high-quality synthesized data. To facilitate the learning of complex
and long-tail knowledge, we devise a curriculum-learning framework throughout
across these stages, which helps LLMs learn knowledge in an easy-to-hard
manner. YuLan's training is finished on Jan, 2024 and has achieved performance
on par with state-of-the-art LLMs across various English and Chinese
benchmarks. This paper outlines a comprehensive technical roadmap for
developing LLMs from scratch. Our model and codes are available at
https://github.com/RUC-GSAI/YuLan-Chat. | [
-0.08241726458072662,
-0.6268384456634521,
0.42137399315834045,
0.04812435805797577,
-0.18471553921699524,
-0.060930509120225906,
-0.49995702505111694,
-0.4777040183544159,
0.28806477785110474,
0.6589056849479675,
-0.2659114599227905,
-0.4061402380466461,
-0.23448167741298676,
-0.14322859048843384,
-0.27009573578834534,
1.0605162382125854,
0.09079692512750626,
0.046609073877334595,
0.37640050053596497,
-0.058001432567834854,
-0.10897446423768997,
-0.10963092744350433,
-0.33998697996139526,
-0.29338765144348145,
0.9033945798873901,
0.48417720198631287,
0.5697031021118164,
1.0658620595932007,
0.3077971339225769,
0.2705828845500946,
-0.1920592188835144,
0.10359567403793335,
-0.5088070034980774,
-0.0011536672245711088,
-0.16354796290397644,
-0.401691198348999,
-0.6856523156166077,
0.08177384734153748,
0.8787915110588074,
0.8271639943122864,
-0.010109701193869114,
0.45448529720306396,
0.057877808809280396,
0.5030047297477722,
-0.44849497079849243,
0.133791983127594,
-0.7295928001403809,
-0.013487562537193298,
-0.6247455477714539,
-0.13566866517066956,
-0.33219224214553833,
-0.25767233967781067,
0.15244288742542267,
-0.6247237324714661,
-0.1508992463350296,
0.03407013416290283,
0.8152615427970886,
-0.04828490689396858,
-0.15410305559635162,
-0.2549436092376709,
-0.4873124361038208,
0.9082933068275452,
-0.8762550354003906,
0.5446622371673584,
0.3577044904232025,
0.4145693778991699,
-0.22049084305763245,
-0.734237790107727,
-0.378738671541214,
-0.3962594270706177,
0.17683830857276917,
-0.257429301738739,
0.5072425603866577,
-0.09140590578317642,
0.16004563868045807,
0.330150306224823,
-0.4769599735736847,
0.45802876353263855,
-0.518460214138031,
0.10510467737913132,
0.3630598187446594,
0.1268477439880371,
0.17614009976387024,
-0.16628965735435486,
-0.5788177251815796,
0.19906216859817505,
-0.8333945870399475,
-0.3031172454357147,
0.4206245541572571,
0.710784912109375,
-0.36774590611457825,
0.5307928919792175,
-0.23991012573242188,
0.5688044428825378,
-0.14805303514003754,
-0.5717710852622986,
0.317630797624588,
-0.062223296612501144,
-0.5101591944694519,
-0.07830271124839783,
0.796725869178772,
-0.18991094827651978,
0.08427635580301285,
-0.1369069367647171,
-0.39780059456825256,
-0.3187548816204071,
0.015888668596744537,
-0.7319107055664062,
-0.09871502220630646,
0.38756927847862244,
-0.4019804298877716,
-0.2140025645494461,
-0.12375790625810623,
-0.6580457091331482,
-0.6478644609451294,
-0.6142487525939941,
0.47836044430732727,
-0.40758833289146423,
-0.37785810232162476,
0.1997324377298355,
0.3893079161643982,
0.42191818356513977,
0.45635929703712463,
-0.7527475357055664,
-0.012271185405552387,
0.6378229856491089,
0.8939977288246155,
-0.016566205769777298,
-0.674502968788147,
-0.7845674157142639,
0.29620227217674255,
-0.4564581513404846,
0.421805739402771,
0.009320535697042942,
0.1379317045211792,
0.239085391163826,
-0.2587772309780121,
0.2719946503639221,
-0.43779608607292175,
0.4818088412284851,
-0.878024697303772,
0.25244688987731934,
-0.09972607344388962,
-0.4937409460544586,
0.18180273473262787,
0.3360164165496826,
-0.7936743497848511,
0.6392214894294739,
-0.011282755993306637,
-0.8888309597969055,
0.14945659041404724,
-0.7919455170631409,
-0.3370647132396698,
0.6440080404281616,
-0.08923795819282532,
-0.16213764250278473,
-0.22637179493904114,
-0.03540836647152901,
0.6269873976707458,
-0.734094500541687,
0.4395788609981537,
-0.28931501507759094,
-0.3050430715084076,
0.09197436273097992,
-0.012089202180504799,
1.0225144624710083,
0.6152682900428772,
-0.23159921169281006,
0.24038325250148773,
-0.760034441947937,
0.15086261928081512,
0.191452294588089,
-0.5016700625419617,
-0.1508786529302597,
-0.11191646009683609,
0.0784425288438797,
0.019047502428293228,
0.5727314352989197,
-0.3998696208000183,
-0.10103117674589157,
-0.374579519033432,
0.3498939573764801,
0.7781488299369812,
-0.48726820945739746,
0.3962115943431854,
-0.21785573661327362,
0.2987588047981262,
0.15495260059833527,
0.034332867711782455,
-0.7446103096008301,
-0.08790361881256104,
-1.0393030643463135,
-0.2659446895122528,
0.13238362967967987,
0.1679840087890625,
-0.7598419189453125,
0.4638906419277191,
-0.21874195337295532,
-0.5164331793785095,
-0.538605809211731,
0.6132940053939819,
0.2987619638442993,
0.2935815155506134,
0.33980655670166016,
0.07626837491989136,
-0.5816352367401123,
-0.6554076671600342,
-0.1641547679901123,
-0.3374415338039398,
-0.0426592193543911,
-0.36343201994895935,
0.4476480484008789,
-0.16518227756023407,
0.9407508373260498,
-0.40227237343788147,
-0.5989732146263123,
-0.6422154307365417,
0.02035280130803585,
0.31278228759765625,
0.21226182579994202,
0.36968931555747986,
-0.528717577457428,
-0.491699755191803,
0.5005154609680176,
-0.6722849607467651,
-0.09900592267513275,
0.028973150998353958,
0.03282702714204788,
0.3330354392528534,
0.6547993421554565,
-0.3557760417461395,
-0.008990530855953693,
0.6677275896072388,
-0.09563612937927246,
0.5385091304779053,
-0.31531983613967896,
-0.33400410413742065,
-1.3632546663284302,
0.38706180453300476,
0.0981552004814148,
-0.15526911616325378,
-0.7115188837051392,
0.39554381370544434,
0.23168505728244781,
-0.08274607360363007,
-0.5637326836585999,
0.569926917552948,
-0.52009516954422,
0.09215226024389267,
-0.33269110321998596,
0.16147807240486145,
-0.3472617268562317,
0.42299261689186096,
0.008481021039187908,
0.5431153774261475,
0.249740332365036,
-0.524697482585907,
0.48496782779693604,
-0.13373209536075592,
-0.7725280523300171,
0.379881352186203,
-0.855992317199707,
0.09470480680465698,
-0.2045578509569168,
-0.17566439509391785,
-0.43462860584259033,
-0.4734193980693817,
0.13831885159015656,
-0.16060006618499756,
0.08425336331129074,
-0.04844091832637787,
-0.5155776739120483,
-0.25900182127952576,
-0.19687041640281677,
0.07430513948202133,
0.4255630373954773,
-0.631956934928894,
0.36092790961265564,
0.5408124923706055,
-0.21599355340003967,
-0.48466548323631287,
-0.6123102307319641,
0.1843235343694687,
-0.24162466824054718,
-0.4130248725414276,
-0.06921276450157166,
-0.17138217389583588,
-0.31665924191474915,
-0.050554901361465454,
0.4639706313610077,
-0.2832711338996887,
0.08465979248285294,
-0.08461581915616989,
0.29646778106689453,
-0.35497575998306274,
0.23163481056690216,
-0.28511708974838257,
-0.036030083894729614,
-0.007661549840122461,
-0.7493119835853577,
0.580359935760498,
-0.12351728975772858,
-0.37694719433784485,
-0.31026291847229004,
-0.04715752229094505,
0.5205138325691223,
-0.5271676182746887,
0.7107742428779602,
0.4535204768180847,
-0.466316282749176,
-0.7097582817077637,
-0.5992514491081238,
0.35735663771629333,
-0.4941547214984894,
0.6104562878608704,
-0.18063628673553467,
-0.9500805139541626,
0.3028036057949066,
0.0855012908577919,
0.41844233870506287,
0.1953234076499939,
0.7597286105155945,
0.08836600184440613,
0.224106103181839,
0.7324707508087158,
-0.35913094878196716,
0.48816823959350586,
0.02929418906569481,
0.2041473090648651,
-0.32114312052726746,
-0.28428012132644653,
-0.5404732823371887,
-0.050518497824668884,
-0.3043269217014313,
-0.7401753664016724,
0.36476823687553406,
-0.14331220090389252,
-0.5997809171676636,
0.33617115020751953,
0.24810419976711273,
0.752056896686554,
0.5648463368415833,
-0.1378730833530426,
0.4234461784362793,
-0.12264454364776611,
-0.05483373999595642,
-0.016469646245241165,
-0.5640568137168884,
-0.4949546158313751,
1.0268474817276,
0.7611627578735352,
1.0236966609954834,
0.08915683627128601,
0.6462222933769226,
0.12884347140789032,
0.14994144439697266,
-0.654872477054596,
0.5266129970550537,
0.04441866651177406,
-0.6049720644950867,
-0.4736948609352112,
-0.616956889629364,
-0.7734057903289795,
0.029717445373535156,
-0.0780220478773117,
-0.382299542427063,
-0.4770949184894562,
-0.03899393230676651,
-0.1871359646320343,
0.5697810053825378,
-0.5516064763069153,
0.638354480266571,
-0.6365217566490173,
-0.5449987053871155,
-0.02371436171233654,
-0.7402368187904358,
0.618192732334137,
-0.4321948289871216,
0.28941527009010315,
-0.014503298327326775,
-0.020803913474082947,
0.6497704386711121,
-0.3003557026386261,
0.9155949950218201,
-0.09550722688436508,
-0.4281691014766693,
0.3648620545864105,
-0.15100017189979553,
0.2027760148048401,
-0.027415502816438675,
-0.08905184268951416,
0.05634832754731178,
-0.33605778217315674,
-0.37002795934677124,
-0.21501524746418,
0.7363957166671753,
-0.9454292058944702,
-0.3712681829929352,
-0.20316775143146515,
-0.7109814286231995,
-0.12138711661100388,
0.5710638165473938,
-0.20024941861629486,
0.20490092039108276,
-0.3504525423049927,
0.1549506038427353,
0.8555495142936707,
-0.6177158951759338,
0.35595619678497314,
0.4639105498790741,
-0.6108129024505615,
-0.6769440770149231,
0.8260258436203003,
0.0477709025144577,
0.48196136951446533,
0.31805381178855896,
0.3272084891796112,
-0.07177992910146713,
-0.4666723906993866,
-0.3450661301612854,
0.535505473613739,
-0.6166525483131409,
-0.21301189064979553,
-0.3967607021331787,
-0.41580846905708313,
-0.604675829410553,
0.08374698460102081,
-0.5674484968185425,
0.011301549151539803,
-0.2235197126865387,
0.11585558205842972,
0.0822770968079567,
0.9848609566688538,
0.08648064732551575,
0.4064332842826843,
-0.7016127705574036,
0.41592928767204285,
0.31042370200157166,
0.6601375937461853,
0.09903696179389954,
-0.6239446997642517,
-0.8896324634552002,
0.1797155737876892,
-0.21729867160320282,
-0.3147202730178833,
0.5489500164985657,
0.02201252058148384,
0.38823914527893066,
0.6477041840553284,
-0.060534458607435226,
0.6959515810012817,
-0.4455336928367615,
0.7010185718536377,
0.43678978085517883,
-0.9786996841430664,
0.4181719124317169,
-0.6837183237075806,
0.39862316846847534,
0.310210645198822,
0.4324377775192261,
-0.6479424834251404,
-0.06693468987941742,
-0.14047715067863464,
-0.43052804470062256,
0.9247689843177795,
-0.28035029768943787,
0.10758889466524124,
0.20376121997833252,
0.1788059026002884,
0.12244199216365814,
0.12157607078552246,
-0.9524908661842346,
-0.060227807611227036,
0.03775578737258911,
-0.014271903783082962,
-0.188259556889534,
-0.2847495377063751,
-0.0032543938141316175,
-0.20818932354450226,
0.6217589974403381,
-0.3102833032608032,
-0.10793997347354889,
-0.2420019954442978,
-0.1508943736553192,
-0.14460162818431854,
0.3198009729385376,
0.3695331811904907,
0.5996870994567871,
-0.14710432291030884,
0.08025334030389786,
0.053064290434122086,
-0.3471134603023529,
-0.0833594799041748,
0.0017264785710722208,
-0.03212245926260948,
-0.20801980793476105,
0.44698113203048706,
0.7059011459350586,
-0.009193255566060543,
-0.7990374565124512,
0.510448694229126,
0.35421010851860046,
-0.2892191708087921,
-0.4567788541316986,
-0.13838575780391693,
0.43198853731155396,
0.4047299325466156,
0.26085329055786133,
-0.5579172968864441,
-0.3633621633052826,
-0.5593403577804565,
-0.047711919993162155,
0.17827816307544708,
-0.24279911816120148,
-0.4930104613304138,
0.7183914184570312,
0.283174067735672,
-0.07195953279733658,
0.5019554495811462,
-0.22054125368595123,
-0.5043782591819763,
0.15028239786624908,
0.5945419073104858,
0.8033862113952637,
-0.23014886677265167,
0.32177579402923584,
0.36206233501434326,
0.41877177357673645,
-0.27454397082328796,
0.22472834587097168,
0.22032073140144348,
-0.5957755446434021,
-0.6082173585891724,
-0.7999310493469238,
-0.4944940507411957,
0.4701835811138153,
-0.20473487675189972,
0.8658996820449829,
-0.6604571342468262,
0.15274329483509064,
-0.3604755699634552,
0.25960418581962585,
-0.510170578956604,
0.14421814680099487,
0.34943825006484985,
0.9994348883628845,
-0.5688923597335815,
1.2036621570587158,
0.7830697894096375,
-0.509768009185791,
-0.8181145787239075,
-0.08018505573272705,
-0.17894470691680908,
-0.6541485786437988,
0.8943895101547241,
0.1265534907579422,
-0.0044050198048353195,
-0.09955313801765442,
-0.6968556642532349,
-0.855333685874939,
1.172861099243164,
0.6410015225410461,
-0.43298521637916565,
-0.3884722888469696,
0.5759829878807068,
0.47209250926971436,
-0.22293785214424133,
0.14098145067691803,
0.2830356955528259,
0.23519760370254517,
0.16641581058502197,
-1.04349946975708,
-0.33645713329315186,
-0.09194169193506241,
0.024343425408005714,
0.13358204066753387,
-0.7506456971168518,
1.237406849861145,
-0.3745240271091461,
-0.10281272977590561,
0.39439040422439575,
0.9169296622276306,
0.18297778069972992,
0.18634675443172455,
0.3343068063259125,
0.5113603472709656,
0.7799680829048157,
0.2876846492290497,
0.5230600833892822,
-0.3072110414505005,
0.15872128307819366,
1.2218605279922485,
-0.4935609996318817,
0.9401074647903442,
0.4399423599243164,
-0.013290412724018097,
0.35875001549720764,
0.09102337062358856,
0.3683113753795624,
0.17644836008548737,
0.3818647265434265,
-0.24608662724494934,
-0.1736569106578827,
-0.3136370778083801,
-0.3488609790802002,
0.44255390763282776,
0.2982126772403717,
-0.41018038988113403,
-0.26564130187034607,
-0.2955075204372406,
0.10452340543270111,
0.11173595488071442,
-0.35519787669181824,
0.4110717177391052,
0.18716751039028168,
-0.3810756802558899,
0.3950859308242798,
0.2664715051651001,
0.6963956952095032,
-0.939534068107605,
0.204152449965477,
-0.31883811950683594,
0.29956701397895813,
-0.10998504608869553,
-0.4701145589351654,
-0.05090665817260742,
0.2261328548192978,
0.29084643721580505,
-0.34474441409111023,
0.621443510055542,
-0.6289820075035095,
-0.2584374248981476,
0.2394082099199295,
0.6637777090072632,
0.07872624695301056,
0.22340476512908936,
-0.20533813536167145,
0.25904643535614014,
-0.1792002022266388,
-0.21190476417541504,
0.384679913520813,
0.7295964360237122,
0.04474432021379471,
0.6358466744422913,
0.5773995518684387,
0.38466277718544006,
0.014619623310863972,
-0.0321928933262825,
1.0009546279907227,
-0.7780850529670715,
-0.47996190190315247,
-0.6173408031463623,
0.4541603922843933,
0.012608930468559265,
-0.41484689712524414,
0.691150963306427,
0.38458070158958435,
0.9211737513542175,
0.004806114360690117,
0.868552565574646,
0.00929486658424139,
0.6748861074447632,
-0.5279493927955627,
1.020780324935913,
-0.5580508708953857,
0.3927552402019501,
-0.31141263246536255,
-0.891886293888092,
-0.46300333738327026,
0.3925676941871643,
-0.040069375187158585,
-0.024062629789114,
0.5352604985237122,
0.6008849740028381,
-0.050389084964990616,
0.026811255142092705,
0.503828763961792,
0.2841285765171051,
0.4728456139564514,
0.5520838499069214,
0.9608600735664368,
-0.12030895054340363,
0.35545799136161804,
-0.10004163533449173,
-0.22326144576072693,
-0.026456324383616447,
-1.007957100868225,
-1.1799153089523315,
-0.5390719175338745,
0.003255097661167383,
-0.04411108046770096,
-0.0514083132147789,
1.3249977827072144,
0.5391270518302917,
-0.5089612007141113,
-0.8330703377723694,
0.15235300362110138,
-0.08401645720005035,
0.32669004797935486,
-0.07658528536558151,
0.046682924032211304,
-0.7418056130409241,
-0.7932336330413818,
0.4017101228237152,
0.13135556876659393,
-0.1050078272819519,
-0.7617228031158447,
-0.3768186569213867,
-0.24861781299114227,
-0.2325560748577118,
0.6317663192749023,
0.39113113284111023,
-0.5332493782043457,
-0.05403943732380867,
0.15629549324512482,
-0.3036423325538635,
-0.1414284110069275,
0.6245964765548706,
-0.6944423317909241,
0.2657095789909363,
0.4126377999782562,
0.9868505001068115,
0.0343780592083931,
-0.4086071848869324,
0.5296255946159363,
-0.3664030432701111,
0.22949565947055817,
0.015924345701932907,
0.284505158662796,
0.313873291015625,
0.15328186750411987,
0.3092496395111084,
0.03272833302617073,
-0.5998538136482239,
-0.7773899435997009,
0.19158104062080383,
-0.6963487267494202,
-0.10816362500190735,
1.2907099723815918,
-0.19990098476409912,
-0.22059836983680725,
-0.005497352220118046,
-0.104164257645607,
0.17076441645622253,
-0.17289592325687408,
0.53280109167099,
0.3752382695674896,
0.589999258518219,
0.05620650574564934,
-0.5157442688941956,
0.10149861872196198,
0.2689477503299713,
-0.9527043700218201,
0.20957735180854797,
0.6344016194343567,
0.1936929076910019,
0.11262288689613342,
0.5704904198646545,
-0.15705013275146484,
0.09289643913507462,
-0.22863240540027618,
0.25731557607650757,
-0.16110044717788696,
-0.6519110202789307,
-0.3294456899166107,
0.28271859884262085,
0.7162830829620361,
-0.02613893710076809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19840v1 | AnomaLLMy -- Detecting anomalous tokens in black-box LLMs through low-confidence single-token predictions | 2024-06-28T11:28:44 | 2024-06-28T11:28:44 | Waligóra Witold | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces AnomaLLMy, a novel technique for the automatic
detection of anomalous tokens in black-box Large Language Models (LLMs) with
API-only access. Utilizing low-confidence single-token predictions as a
cost-effective indicator, AnomaLLMy identifies irregularities in model
behavior, addressing the issue of anomalous tokens degrading the quality and
reliability of models. Validated on the cl100k_base dataset, the token set of
GPT-4, AnomaLLMy detected 413 major and 65 minor anomalies, demonstrating the
method's efficiency with just \$24.39 spent in API credits. The insights from
this research are expected to be beneficial for enhancing the robustness of and
accuracy of LLMs, particularly in the development and assessment of tokenizers. | [
-0.0810566172003746,
-0.875460684299469,
0.5582386255264282,
0.17557473480701447,
-0.08944150060415268,
0.24650126695632935,
0.1144738644361496,
-0.3062659800052643,
0.39391791820526123,
0.7831478714942932,
-0.6975728869438171,
-0.8176488876342773,
-0.693787693977356,
0.2155943065881729,
-0.7992773056030273,
0.40820392966270447,
0.16913767158985138,
-0.16790302097797394,
-0.2610883116722107,
-0.01927531696856022,
-0.5289040207862854,
-0.705047070980072,
-0.7560116648674011,
-0.14455047249794006,
0.1503225415945053,
0.32025063037872314,
0.7707065343856812,
1.0726532936096191,
0.40733733773231506,
0.26252901554107666,
-0.29907000064849854,
0.22568881511688232,
-0.2685372233390808,
-0.19504785537719727,
0.05505869537591934,
-0.867808997631073,
-0.64947509765625,
-0.044092949479818344,
0.5162637829780579,
0.29034313559532166,
0.007466122508049011,
0.240882009267807,
-0.1469886600971222,
0.2940928041934967,
-0.4423070549964905,
0.07756883651018143,
-0.7937160730361938,
0.14749154448509216,
-0.546366810798645,
-0.18374043703079224,
-0.34670597314834595,
-0.29328981041908264,
-0.24232351779937744,
-0.3754504919052124,
0.1371854990720749,
0.43819504976272583,
0.903017520904541,
0.3842924237251282,
-0.20569071173667908,
-0.5924671292304993,
-0.3662368953227997,
1.1642696857452393,
-0.9932146668434143,
0.10128481686115265,
0.34544557332992554,
0.16074897348880768,
-0.594973623752594,
-0.7736867070198059,
-0.6297208666801453,
-0.19505508244037628,
-0.31533533334732056,
-0.27550405263900757,
-0.5031121969223022,
-0.013598121702671051,
0.1376153528690338,
0.3835400342941284,
-0.5153303146362305,
0.3684282898902893,
-0.25293615460395813,
-0.662632942199707,
0.49614351987838745,
0.21273064613342285,
0.31916481256484985,
-0.40226486325263977,
-0.6364185214042664,
0.5789861083030701,
-0.9667074680328369,
-0.26420292258262634,
0.841212272644043,
0.30999284982681274,
-0.22239653766155243,
0.56731116771698,
0.194282665848732,
0.62336665391922,
-0.00697737280279398,
-0.18266330659389496,
0.09246464818716049,
-0.5806821584701538,
-0.013117765076458454,
0.14628566801548004,
0.5536266565322876,
-0.13564124703407288,
0.27637872099876404,
-0.22731181979179382,
-0.40633612871170044,
0.1345193088054657,
0.10845533013343811,
-0.6616961359977722,
-0.2630346715450287,
0.5493096113204956,
-0.5568164587020874,
-0.370648592710495,
-0.17857655882835388,
-0.7074061632156372,
-0.6400104761123657,
-0.14897069334983826,
0.5230333209037781,
-0.23332668840885162,
-0.6678547859191895,
-0.08395105600357056,
-0.11292444169521332,
-0.32780012488365173,
0.2651204466819763,
-0.37911733984947205,
0.15863703191280365,
0.6265771985054016,
1.0156970024108887,
-0.5840253233909607,
-0.5086541771888733,
-0.5212075710296631,
-0.005458371713757515,
-0.37344372272491455,
0.891291618347168,
-0.5386954545974731,
-0.4726061522960663,
0.04880073666572571,
0.09420770406723022,
-0.08127298951148987,
-0.6241848468780518,
0.3279874920845032,
-0.005611030850559473,
0.10827536880970001,
0.10273101180791855,
-0.7212615609169006,
-0.294444739818573,
0.3791239559650421,
-0.5584574937820435,
0.821074903011322,
0.15270406007766724,
-0.548165500164032,
0.26427724957466125,
-0.6766732931137085,
0.004775106906890869,
0.2683265209197998,
-0.11492909491062164,
-0.3326193392276764,
0.3349309265613556,
-0.031622473150491714,
0.31221428513526917,
-0.09705109149217606,
0.18897108733654022,
-0.4801781475543976,
-0.74228835105896,
0.6422452330589294,
-0.6029457449913025,
0.7098895907402039,
0.08545277267694473,
-0.2738562822341919,
0.15973742306232452,
-0.7976070642471313,
-0.21547424793243408,
0.005390403792262077,
-0.13470984995365143,
-0.2577059864997864,
-0.2079336792230606,
-0.19329485297203064,
0.09872230142354965,
0.43278029561042786,
-0.4827178418636322,
0.334454208612442,
-0.45856690406799316,
0.3310439884662628,
0.9109787344932556,
0.0601237453520298,
0.3807469308376312,
-0.16547875106334686,
0.6538407802581787,
0.2702184021472931,
0.19661444425582886,
-0.3560825288295746,
-0.7869276404380798,
-0.6579440832138062,
-0.7589319944381714,
0.5313476324081421,
0.38331112265586853,
-0.3339618742465973,
0.5236785411834717,
0.1461789757013321,
-0.08599674701690674,
-0.8527123332023621,
0.459824800491333,
0.30125924944877625,
0.4411909282207489,
0.31183600425720215,
-0.3064568042755127,
-0.5814691185951233,
-0.7852708697319031,
-0.4095681309700012,
-0.134285107254982,
0.056970808655023575,
0.3195910155773163,
0.5875913500785828,
-0.6710388660430908,
0.915974497795105,
-0.24524399638175964,
-0.4905032515525818,
0.07576480507850647,
0.3127458989620209,
0.5276526808738708,
0.33640751242637634,
0.7322866320610046,
-0.5322951674461365,
-0.31049636006355286,
-0.19394150376319885,
-0.6304836869239807,
-0.19364920258522034,
0.1367066353559494,
-0.11366068571805954,
0.4101160168647766,
0.4310133159160614,
-0.5898672938346863,
0.7874401211738586,
0.8426368832588196,
-0.6358010172843933,
0.5303916335105896,
-0.2171463668346405,
0.07874348759651184,
-0.7300252318382263,
-0.049468107521533966,
-0.3262236714363098,
-0.058320917189121246,
-0.7846875190734863,
-0.1519378274679184,
0.4067228436470032,
0.19342204928398132,
-0.43945786356925964,
0.883918821811676,
-0.37301939725875854,
0.17634931206703186,
-0.594082772731781,
-0.04219081625342369,
-0.1624947041273117,
0.3264562785625458,
-0.3638775646686554,
0.8375465273857117,
0.6964432001113892,
-0.5574028491973877,
0.3539057672023773,
-0.03989866003394127,
0.07145688682794571,
0.5031754970550537,
-0.06263577193021774,
0.1921713799238205,
-0.05878335237503052,
-0.20360204577445984,
-1.3870071172714233,
-0.1091436967253685,
0.2368057519197464,
-0.6059106588363647,
0.3535284996032715,
-0.5824950933456421,
-0.4309656023979187,
-0.44005391001701355,
-0.3294426202774048,
0.19909201562404633,
0.26382189989089966,
-0.9279270172119141,
0.7823556661605835,
0.45569950342178345,
-0.09917508065700531,
-0.776787281036377,
-0.8021833896636963,
0.2561717927455902,
-0.35429608821868896,
-0.3234555423259735,
-0.09634465724229813,
-0.04460708424448967,
-0.026291437447071075,
0.3320056200027466,
-0.37425482273101807,
-0.09367963671684265,
0.44510549306869507,
0.30139702558517456,
0.36827510595321655,
-0.13882292807102203,
0.06593552231788635,
-0.10015229135751724,
-0.159766286611557,
0.0990229919552803,
-0.4638286530971527,
0.7788634896278381,
0.09537529945373535,
-0.3260646462440491,
-0.4624614119529724,
-0.05214301496744156,
0.46044766902923584,
0.1022987961769104,
0.5161371231079102,
0.6260200142860413,
-0.7347310185432434,
-0.2399391531944275,
-0.7064568400382996,
-0.12778586149215698,
-0.4787771701812744,
0.25703954696655273,
-0.07030346244573593,
-0.6884326338768005,
0.6641355752944946,
-0.036814987659454346,
-0.20309290289878845,
0.372012197971344,
0.5891940593719482,
0.3768470883369446,
1.215965747833252,
0.3849596381187439,
-0.23030787706375122,
0.3112131655216217,
-0.05307115614414215,
0.2850414514541626,
-0.4260992109775543,
-0.10493387281894684,
-0.5464837551116943,
-0.16788733005523682,
-0.5464999079704285,
-0.5165385603904724,
0.04834785684943199,
0.08263851702213287,
0.022711923345923424,
0.27115917205810547,
-0.3806232511997223,
0.3354894518852234,
0.6944241523742676,
-0.22553017735481262,
0.5043982267379761,
-0.09911634773015976,
-0.24338214099407196,
0.14249154925346375,
-0.4440821707248688,
-0.488225519657135,
1.424953579902649,
0.39092370867729187,
0.7198629379272461,
0.2635039985179901,
0.7212197184562683,
0.5020309090614319,
0.6411074995994568,
-0.8320824503898621,
0.34385719895362854,
-0.08956265449523926,
-0.8176587820053101,
-0.2790382206439972,
-0.6221367716789246,
-0.8821479678153992,
-0.10103417187929153,
-0.3400017023086548,
-1.0109527111053467,
0.33089542388916016,
0.49504324793815613,
-0.09752190113067627,
0.3085721433162689,
-0.9119172692298889,
0.7725012302398682,
-0.29645824432373047,
-0.20238305628299713,
-0.08146830648183823,
0.03640429303050041,
0.6028397083282471,
-0.32556062936782837,
0.491939902305603,
-0.41477441787719727,
-0.22861169278621674,
0.3746665418148041,
-0.18302567303180695,
0.6624553799629211,
-0.3984133303165436,
-0.01123000681400299,
0.3245581090450287,
0.3071867525577545,
0.6816253662109375,
0.29425519704818726,
-0.16988824307918549,
0.5874423980712891,
0.02589893527328968,
-0.5661463141441345,
-0.22009477019309998,
0.8608897924423218,
-0.41436266899108887,
-0.5849904417991638,
-0.42302581667900085,
-0.5743883848190308,
-0.13180066645145416,
0.37170645594596863,
0.11218336224555969,
0.1813342422246933,
0.07782310992479324,
0.12667450308799744,
0.43961337208747864,
-0.2237013429403305,
0.5207071900367737,
0.5173845887184143,
-0.3654005229473114,
-0.4031434953212738,
0.8455778360366821,
0.142659991979599,
-0.007001769263297319,
0.09086184948682785,
0.38755613565444946,
-0.5845195651054382,
-0.9926908612251282,
-0.46927717328071594,
0.31063511967658997,
-0.4158704876899719,
-0.5347278118133545,
-0.47729620337486267,
-0.06330816447734833,
-0.4868518114089966,
0.35793739557266235,
-0.3992033302783966,
-0.604454517364502,
-0.2453928291797638,
-0.11833944171667099,
0.34244295954704285,
0.6388567686080933,
0.004613450262695551,
0.37231093645095825,
-0.6110196709632874,
0.12145115435123444,
0.3127508759498596,
0.3792468309402466,
0.016141610220074654,
-0.5948683023452759,
-0.22626309096813202,
-0.06754254549741745,
-0.11745363473892212,
-0.7835569977760315,
0.6786811351776123,
0.048010535538196564,
0.7839757204055786,
0.730862557888031,
-0.16822345554828644,
0.7444900274276733,
-0.23114414513111115,
0.75554358959198,
0.2620387077331543,
-1.088356614112854,
0.49426326155662537,
0.04089335352182388,
0.24204163253307343,
0.1814650297164917,
0.3712838292121887,
-0.2658020257949829,
-0.8537350296974182,
-0.6105908751487732,
-0.8810475468635559,
0.8877964019775391,
0.2584216296672821,
0.04772545024752617,
0.0004127513384446502,
0.5657933354377747,
0.15377937257289886,
0.6878965497016907,
-0.6388083696365356,
-0.6936826705932617,
-0.17397446930408478,
-0.35569772124290466,
-0.05208268389105797,
-0.49281808733940125,
-0.22694618999958038,
0.08260533958673477,
0.5943914651870728,
-0.1693519651889801,
0.318390429019928,
-0.1585913598537445,
-0.25252464413642883,
-0.34336403012275696,
0.1654612421989441,
0.6171509027481079,
0.8396012783050537,
-0.40006694197654724,
0.35168296098709106,
0.29133203625679016,
-0.6168901324272156,
-0.010150384157896042,
0.1736443191766739,
-0.12479342520236969,
0.25406819581985474,
0.36132076382637024,
0.6432721018791199,
0.05811832845211029,
-0.7254054546356201,
0.6376563310623169,
-0.245146706700325,
-0.16323843598365784,
-0.33732324838638306,
0.17830801010131836,
-0.06626550108194351,
0.11518660187721252,
0.7455502152442932,
-0.042464155703783035,
0.18252569437026978,
-0.5443392992019653,
0.2951616942882538,
0.6165502667427063,
-0.36665329337120056,
-0.45926347374916077,
0.5002158284187317,
-0.13262245059013367,
-0.6288830637931824,
0.15227000415325165,
-0.4781217575073242,
-0.4487813711166382,
0.6229631304740906,
0.6064673662185669,
0.7163486480712891,
-0.4693961441516876,
0.018482713028788567,
0.14414696395397186,
0.4196057617664337,
-0.14561927318572998,
0.09906065464019775,
0.34028923511505127,
-0.817358136177063,
-0.2033734917640686,
-0.718328595161438,
-0.6520815491676331,
0.3564990162849426,
-0.3707367479801178,
0.47300729155540466,
-0.44640520215034485,
-0.21972303092479706,
-0.0506136529147625,
0.15271839499473572,
-0.6391024589538574,
-0.030860604718327522,
0.14064231514930725,
0.811738908290863,
-0.7433789968490601,
0.8223763704299927,
0.6461513638496399,
-0.07161712646484375,
-0.5445348024368286,
-0.08302867412567139,
0.40413326025009155,
-1.2500998973846436,
0.2638894021511078,
0.1777278482913971,
0.19057650864124298,
0.10074563324451447,
-0.4054541289806366,
-0.9910528063774109,
1.0698150396347046,
0.4186447560787201,
-0.5021132230758667,
0.0017826760886237025,
0.03082886151969433,
0.32514649629592896,
-0.45310935378074646,
0.22353345155715942,
0.8638656139373779,
0.7642353177070618,
0.04945036396384239,
-0.777446448802948,
0.18597197532653809,
0.037214022129774094,
-0.2400447130203247,
0.450008749961853,
-0.46226397156715393,
0.9870408177375793,
0.08353335410356522,
-0.39373236894607544,
0.288272887468338,
0.1853618025779724,
0.3641885221004486,
0.49647951126098633,
0.5597655773162842,
0.3309193253517151,
1.1834396123886108,
-0.29305851459503174,
0.7710650563240051,
-0.5806177258491516,
0.5493322014808655,
0.5165132880210876,
0.08979780972003937,
0.42679649591445923,
0.6254815459251404,
-0.07195929437875748,
0.29040437936782837,
0.36099186539649963,
-0.1661367118358612,
0.3745959997177124,
0.3424963653087616,
-0.3342071771621704,
-0.2325877696275711,
-0.03928728029131889,
-0.3347107172012329,
0.39367952942848206,
0.7197474241256714,
-0.10429155826568604,
0.0022119893692433834,
-0.06947707384824753,
0.20903567969799042,
-0.08820540457963943,
-0.5784586668014526,
0.6591728329658508,
0.14506182074546814,
-0.31262320280075073,
0.5621294379234314,
-0.00006505214696517214,
1.0470587015151978,
-0.5047339797019958,
0.0034303900320082903,
-0.417683482170105,
0.366192489862442,
-0.3542904257774353,
-0.33092692494392395,
0.17452412843704224,
0.05843023955821991,
0.15913183987140656,
-0.04313918948173523,
0.9721254110336304,
-0.45215505361557007,
-0.5706266760826111,
0.44689950346946716,
0.6743661761283875,
0.0572807602584362,
-0.054043322801589966,
-0.6792262196540833,
0.006769550032913685,
-0.19729392230510712,
-0.07918506115674973,
0.28780680894851685,
0.6590954065322876,
0.10716234147548676,
0.6591976284980774,
0.7083231806755066,
0.5565165281295776,
0.09153366088867188,
-0.27715176343917847,
0.5830549597740173,
-0.8192857503890991,
-0.42785805463790894,
-0.9887898564338684,
0.23355254530906677,
-0.1451362818479538,
-0.19573120772838593,
0.9092420339584351,
0.6699842214584351,
0.5681305527687073,
-0.002410539658740163,
0.7937033176422119,
0.3811470568180084,
0.7894880771636963,
-0.49197593331336975,
0.6116231083869934,
-0.5758334994316101,
0.6592465043067932,
0.03788447007536888,
-0.5884877443313599,
-0.5243827104568481,
0.37523019313812256,
-0.06458255648612976,
-0.4666553735733032,
0.75226891040802,
1.1623854637145996,
0.030723588541150093,
-0.17982609570026398,
0.49410632252693176,
0.5521215796470642,
0.10288713127374649,
0.2130870819091797,
1.026758074760437,
-0.2453795224428177,
0.8523344397544861,
-0.08842530846595764,
-0.25691184401512146,
-0.4361537992954254,
-0.9855083227157593,
-1.2470059394836426,
0.15780335664749146,
-0.28292638063430786,
-0.5651535987854004,
0.13745421171188354,
0.8022578358650208,
0.5723586082458496,
-1.25040864944458,
-0.3928471505641937,
-0.15214747190475464,
0.8415434956550598,
-0.2794840633869171,
-0.2559988498687744,
0.18830081820487976,
-0.5977537631988525,
-1.0360504388809204,
0.4600710868835449,
0.606526255607605,
0.20734935998916626,
-0.36386412382125854,
-0.04115448147058487,
-0.13724838197231293,
0.27302879095077515,
0.2163466513156891,
0.15710493922233582,
-0.6511396169662476,
-0.5011491775512695,
0.029641643166542053,
0.06398104131221771,
0.03392215818166733,
0.6483541131019592,
-0.404634952545166,
0.4413122236728668,
0.14859749376773834,
0.47434139251708984,
0.4899221956729889,
-0.03153872862458229,
0.4943471848964691,
-1.0525758266448975,
0.4737742245197296,
0.1528051197528839,
0.3665536344051361,
0.059813857078552246,
-0.506198525428772,
0.368884414434433,
0.5330296754837036,
-0.25202053785324097,
-1.4625147581100464,
0.015549356117844582,
-0.6243656873703003,
-0.2880922257900238,
1.1161378622055054,
-0.2864404022693634,
-0.34788817167282104,
-0.4039560854434967,
-0.04827243462204933,
-0.17890334129333496,
-0.4178691804409027,
0.8659956455230713,
0.8630838394165039,
-0.08806923776865005,
0.04536851868033409,
-0.3995460271835327,
0.6208494901657104,
0.08707688748836517,
-0.6642995476722717,
-0.24359698593616486,
0.21785175800323486,
0.24592894315719604,
0.40716424584388733,
0.42317190766334534,
-0.09337303787469864,
0.3573123514652252,
-0.06343771517276764,
-0.11166822910308838,
-0.38534805178642273,
-0.24305690824985504,
-0.49993449449539185,
0.3012082874774933,
0.22801175713539124,
-0.3252948522567749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19820v1 | BeamAggR: Beam Aggregation Reasoning over Multi-source Knowledge for Multi-hop Question Answering | 2024-06-28T10:53:48 | 2024-06-28T10:53:48 | Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Qianglong Chen, Haotian Wang, Kun Zhu, Xiyuan Du, Weijiang Yu, Ming Liu, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong reasoning capabilities.
Nevertheless, they still suffer from factual errors when tackling
knowledge-intensive tasks. Retrieval-augmented reasoning represents a promising
approach. However, significant challenges still persist, including inaccurate
and insufficient retrieval for complex questions, as well as difficulty in
integrating multi-source knowledge. To address this, we propose Beam
Aggregation Reasoning, BeamAggR, a reasoning framework for knowledge-intensive
multi-hop QA. BeamAggR explores and prioritizes promising answers at each hop
of question. Concretely, we parse the complex questions into trees, which
include atom and composite questions, followed by bottom-up reasoning. For
atomic questions, the LLM conducts reasoning on multi-source knowledge to get
answer candidates. For composite questions, the LLM combines beam candidates,
explores multiple reasoning paths through probabilistic aggregation, and
prioritizes the most promising trajectory. Extensive experiments on four
open-domain multi-hop reasoning datasets show that our method significantly
outperforms SOTA methods by 8.5%. Furthermore, our analysis reveals that
BeamAggR elicits better knowledge collaboration and answer aggregation. | [
-0.4209234416484833,
-1.1662743091583252,
0.9573817849159241,
0.168040469288826,
0.036650609225034714,
0.49278947710990906,
0.228759765625,
-0.3012239933013916,
-0.02251708135008812,
0.29433029890060425,
-0.24201032519340515,
-0.4772391617298126,
-0.6476097106933594,
-0.13612037897109985,
-0.1454416960477829,
0.5334107279777527,
0.0053058210760355,
0.04645634442567825,
-0.5310711860656738,
-0.29957231879234314,
-0.5781415700912476,
-0.2290392518043518,
-0.5534741282463074,
-0.32712364196777344,
0.546912431716919,
0.4292556345462799,
0.730676531791687,
0.32219186425209045,
0.6516522765159607,
0.31568798422813416,
-0.41579487919807434,
0.7854477167129517,
-0.17509689927101135,
0.30418041348457336,
-0.43946030735969543,
-0.2993420958518982,
-0.5420612096786499,
-0.4221173822879791,
0.47590041160583496,
0.7841594815254211,
-0.12007931619882584,
0.21613094210624695,
-0.39687374234199524,
0.3818355202674866,
-0.6431241631507874,
0.13322360813617706,
-0.5964030623435974,
-0.24332278966903687,
-0.09188677370548248,
-0.18229904770851135,
-0.6033015251159668,
-0.3602645993232727,
-0.22795633971691132,
-0.41919180750846863,
-0.05836863815784454,
0.39569512009620667,
0.5409424304962158,
0.28408753871917725,
-0.776543915271759,
-0.1345071941614151,
-0.4065447151660919,
0.6744387149810791,
-0.4235086143016815,
0.3925175070762634,
0.307881623506546,
0.4308021068572998,
-0.24904531240463257,
-0.7258142828941345,
-0.16911537945270538,
0.03560807183384895,
-0.3009248375892639,
0.18591724336147308,
-0.15256071090698242,
0.3560341000556946,
0.0586196705698967,
0.11276090890169144,
-1.0956064462661743,
-0.3374859690666199,
-0.19324663281440735,
-0.2961566150188446,
0.6429045796394348,
0.05505472421646118,
0.05832673981785774,
0.024845952168107033,
-0.4543662965297699,
0.1800355315208435,
-0.4879680275917053,
0.04496054723858833,
-0.14797908067703247,
0.19796918332576752,
0.32509201765060425,
0.6231077313423157,
-0.44559866189956665,
1.096505045890808,
0.1302640438079834,
-0.03025003708899021,
0.15670864284038544,
-0.5914921760559082,
-0.01815684698522091,
0.0820273756980896,
0.5483846068382263,
0.09821759164333344,
-0.04286295548081398,
-0.17862378060817719,
0.2189936637878418,
-0.21809178590774536,
0.08885759860277176,
-0.6063628196716309,
0.1602562516927719,
0.7322489023208618,
-0.4622771143913269,
0.3077840209007263,
-0.2412339448928833,
-0.6066900491714478,
-0.2406473159790039,
0.0664457306265831,
0.6083628535270691,
-0.570633053779602,
-0.1997201293706894,
0.36852747201919556,
-0.4463769197463989,
0.17665798962116241,
0.46811985969543457,
-0.39497506618499756,
-0.31973662972450256,
0.8885766267776489,
0.7521246671676636,
0.3524375259876251,
-0.5606822967529297,
-0.90340256690979,
0.3204711079597473,
-0.339650422334671,
1.2530417442321777,
-0.7315412163734436,
-0.23392198979854584,
-0.20536743104457855,
-0.3659808039665222,
-0.09904854744672775,
-0.2864616811275482,
0.36125102639198303,
-0.9064124822616577,
0.24528738856315613,
-0.19569404423236847,
-0.8842290043830872,
-0.2096405029296875,
0.5327438712120056,
-0.1601039618253708,
0.6666462421417236,
0.03883396089076996,
-0.7796685099601746,
0.31434300541877747,
-0.44078996777534485,
-0.3582393229007721,
0.5271202921867371,
-0.2607828676700592,
-0.04925159364938736,
-0.09175687283277512,
0.3104938566684723,
0.3197978436946869,
-0.3999769985675812,
0.7593017220497131,
-0.5226562023162842,
-0.18713165819644928,
-0.04330604523420334,
0.010160704143345356,
0.811054527759552,
0.640230119228363,
0.163762167096138,
0.07905472069978714,
-0.43940606713294983,
0.16750770807266235,
0.0415726862847805,
-0.48614680767059326,
-0.3071180284023285,
0.12044795602560043,
-0.5930927395820618,
0.06814131140708923,
0.26997917890548706,
-0.44597840309143066,
0.5345181822776794,
-0.0819999948143959,
0.09107627719640732,
0.4947124123573303,
0.18811751902103424,
0.37926337122917175,
-0.4191499352455139,
0.731110692024231,
-0.0424133725464344,
0.020128604024648666,
-0.5680603384971619,
-0.8284084796905518,
-0.25500908493995667,
-0.21809324622154236,
-0.10166039317846298,
0.3685508668422699,
-1.159047245979309,
0.1965879648923874,
-0.22770772874355316,
-0.5788880586624146,
-0.503212034702301,
-0.055904537439346313,
0.4404529333114624,
0.6745416522026062,
0.6055304408073425,
0.28737491369247437,
-0.25887343287467957,
-0.504639744758606,
-0.4086833894252777,
-0.45521241426467896,
0.1685638278722763,
0.2162078320980072,
0.3507842421531677,
-0.1149689108133316,
1.1506483554840088,
-0.8001235127449036,
-0.08974058926105499,
-0.22271881997585297,
0.48218074440956116,
0.3399503529071808,
0.21495947241783142,
0.350956529378891,
-0.9416078925132751,
-0.25234827399253845,
0.09145534038543701,
-0.8377901315689087,
-0.15607468783855438,
-0.22154098749160767,
-0.3857085704803467,
-0.3665933907032013,
0.5251757502555847,
-0.9992529153823853,
-0.25614798069000244,
0.6121830940246582,
-0.7592482566833496,
0.6993791460990906,
-0.12399880588054657,
0.35003000497817993,
-1.053965449333191,
-0.0501810759305954,
-0.28190621733665466,
-0.10076232254505157,
-0.5936058759689331,
0.43959903717041016,
-0.09626644849777222,
0.07879108190536499,
-0.3611606955528259,
0.8207550644874573,
-0.26738202571868896,
-0.12927331030368805,
-0.2279583364725113,
0.28109437227249146,
0.35598331689834595,
0.2657948434352875,
-0.05617666617035866,
0.86915522813797,
0.676007866859436,
-0.34518948197364807,
0.7569390535354614,
0.565456748008728,
-0.2761075794696808,
0.6742270588874817,
-0.5238408446311951,
0.04067201167345047,
-0.5146450996398926,
0.46468856930732727,
-1.119063138961792,
-0.17157894372940063,
-0.14853867888450623,
-0.7960112690925598,
-0.019087349995970726,
-0.16587111353874207,
-0.24823588132858276,
-0.28197595477104187,
0.013615045696496964,
0.6201016902923584,
0.06598307937383652,
-0.6005088686943054,
1.1570194959640503,
0.25046783685684204,
-0.15040276944637299,
-0.8183072805404663,
-0.4071676433086395,
-0.1015220656991005,
-0.09080638736486435,
-1.0528727769851685,
0.1368636041879654,
-0.1349799782037735,
-0.5125681757926941,
0.2515920102596283,
-0.018088078126311302,
-0.21042534708976746,
0.08246098458766937,
-0.18444959819316864,
0.029431458562612534,
-0.26919227838516235,
0.5954386591911316,
0.12970444560050964,
-0.11542535573244095,
-0.11026279628276825,
-0.46981608867645264,
0.4298740327358246,
-0.3308778405189514,
-0.7542787790298462,
0.5463176369667053,
0.5300089120864868,
0.5068355798721313,
-0.5457382798194885,
0.6808551549911499,
0.7198745012283325,
-0.082940973341465,
-0.13334724307060242,
-0.6177278757095337,
-0.050939176231622696,
-0.38754957914352417,
0.45187199115753174,
-0.6496981382369995,
-1.2596724033355713,
0.4767293334007263,
-0.25061169266700745,
0.27028897404670715,
0.24122987687587738,
0.6845390796661377,
-0.2306581288576126,
1.2539311647415161,
-0.08787190914154053,
0.1813810020685196,
-0.005942235235124826,
-0.15902355313301086,
0.4105350971221924,
-0.5629649758338928,
-0.4492962658405304,
-0.5683977603912354,
-0.06591734290122986,
-0.07473799586296082,
-0.8294291496276855,
0.4693099558353424,
0.31098130345344543,
-0.3167869448661804,
0.07417644560337067,
-0.23629321157932281,
0.4031333029270172,
0.6361511945724487,
-0.13426342606544495,
0.5803602337837219,
-0.4989926218986511,
0.04280669987201691,
0.6826680898666382,
-0.9388525485992432,
-0.07758556306362152,
0.6543661952018738,
0.03541899845004082,
0.766311526298523,
0.17734472453594208,
0.5368025302886963,
0.17230838537216187,
-0.02851693518459797,
-0.7002158761024475,
0.5526175498962402,
0.17651845514774323,
-1.2141764163970947,
-0.3251500129699707,
-0.8409309387207031,
-1.0747026205062866,
0.7306399941444397,
0.09001244604587555,
-0.6057973504066467,
0.16461196541786194,
0.3661724627017975,
-0.451058030128479,
0.22446848452091217,
-0.7777785062789917,
0.8465409278869629,
-0.4016408622264862,
-0.2804316580295563,
-0.24656209349632263,
-0.8392406702041626,
0.509483814239502,
-0.016796335577964783,
0.6215986013412476,
-0.3107740879058838,
0.35898005962371826,
0.40430644154548645,
-0.26799049973487854,
0.13113559782505035,
-0.21703405678272247,
0.0897778570652008,
0.8187061548233032,
0.26665452122688293,
0.5006558895111084,
-0.040422048419713974,
0.018904918804764748,
0.14230501651763916,
0.006224415265023708,
-0.6042228937149048,
-0.6129739284515381,
0.41766759753227234,
-0.4688013195991516,
-0.8434000611305237,
-0.32939496636390686,
-0.7921086549758911,
-0.5899098515510559,
0.2045910358428955,
0.006709907669574022,
0.3698441982269287,
0.27576643228530884,
0.43998512625694275,
0.4093201160430908,
-0.02653937041759491,
0.18490007519721985,
0.39049652218818665,
-0.6001225709915161,
-0.3360477089881897,
0.7960002422332764,
-0.030916638672351837,
0.45104268193244934,
0.6053397059440613,
0.3808497190475464,
-0.38253188133239746,
-0.576621413230896,
-0.4704537093639374,
0.3144557476043701,
-0.7546074986457825,
-0.3991228938102722,
-0.7642421126365662,
-0.15495891869068146,
-0.48687079548835754,
-0.34365004301071167,
-0.22972212731838226,
-0.2297571897506714,
0.09250305593013763,
-0.2835400104522705,
0.283684641122818,
-0.012019060552120209,
0.040444593876600266,
0.19783179461956024,
-1.410488247871399,
0.41018983721733093,
0.687864363193512,
0.3034398555755615,
-0.16602754592895508,
-0.4308306574821472,
-0.3217978775501251,
-0.031609177589416504,
-0.17040614783763885,
-0.7607709169387817,
0.13387811183929443,
0.098143570125103,
0.7877378463745117,
0.43622469902038574,
-0.06681012362241745,
0.6621893644332886,
-0.3613734543323517,
0.7235896587371826,
0.14311878383159637,
-0.7424348592758179,
0.5115480422973633,
-0.5329306721687317,
0.4638621509075165,
0.4798464775085449,
0.39321690797805786,
-0.4302130937576294,
-0.5408200621604919,
-0.5626046657562256,
-0.7073038220405579,
0.7244701385498047,
-0.13304047286510468,
-0.23318500816822052,
-0.10759041458368301,
-0.02564176358282566,
-0.2001495510339737,
0.21839798986911774,
-0.38761773705482483,
-0.13178884983062744,
-0.05920393019914627,
-0.04472943767905235,
0.09070149064064026,
-0.21914389729499817,
-0.15988923609256744,
0.04152850806713104,
0.566236138343811,
-0.4664912223815918,
0.03236949443817139,
-0.03230765834450722,
-0.1528930813074112,
-0.02030302956700325,
0.3753274977207184,
0.11951842904090881,
0.8075975775718689,
-0.39175304770469666,
0.5208259224891663,
0.06451838463544846,
0.004500656854361296,
0.3486127257347107,
0.08695894479751587,
-0.05388084053993225,
-0.09244765341281891,
0.6560261249542236,
0.6397354006767273,
-0.38709065318107605,
-1.0372287034988403,
0.5584145188331604,
0.028610017150640488,
-0.3972199559211731,
0.31299930810928345,
-0.06752851605415344,
0.39065462350845337,
0.5717003345489502,
0.49946433305740356,
0.0793795958161354,
0.12441323697566986,
-0.4313395321369171,
0.2318544089794159,
0.6020619869232178,
0.06788820773363113,
0.07217983156442642,
0.6655327081680298,
0.11734795570373535,
-0.12488561123609543,
0.5086420774459839,
-0.43170374631881714,
-0.3777947425842285,
0.5534472465515137,
0.37305188179016113,
0.5422122478485107,
-0.24036961793899536,
0.45510807633399963,
0.2967713177204132,
0.1518675684928894,
-0.1080198809504509,
0.27775904536247253,
-0.07479452341794968,
-1.1080816984176636,
-1.0281206369400024,
-0.587613582611084,
-0.5301029682159424,
-0.41137927770614624,
-0.30059197545051575,
0.09289658814668655,
-0.03590861335396767,
-0.02877587266266346,
-0.18637017905712128,
-0.3765692710876465,
-0.1337684541940689,
0.07381652295589447,
0.2110922485589981,
0.8283257484436035,
-0.8972219228744507,
0.46606528759002686,
0.850848376750946,
-0.49727028608322144,
-0.761100172996521,
-0.20869095623493195,
-0.04190583527088165,
-0.9348227381706238,
0.5766445994377136,
-0.09940540790557861,
-0.23248790204524994,
0.039273541420698166,
-0.38383737206459045,
-1.1525386571884155,
1.0459604263305664,
0.40789905190467834,
-0.20019815862178802,
-0.08785384893417358,
-0.25411662459373474,
0.33509960770606995,
-0.04553023725748062,
0.5806364417076111,
0.495251327753067,
0.6171180009841919,
0.7713896632194519,
-0.635593056678772,
-0.19012485444545746,
0.028009911999106407,
-0.26344314217567444,
0.27445200085639954,
-0.8792115449905396,
0.8104960322380066,
-0.27419644594192505,
0.05982602760195732,
-0.5355182886123657,
0.5969634652137756,
0.775132954120636,
0.5705941915512085,
0.3730902671813965,
0.6711577773094177,
0.7241986393928528,
-0.08449845761060715,
0.9399802088737488,
-0.2764182984828949,
0.45586612820625305,
1.0507335662841797,
-0.3664369583129883,
0.36695006489753723,
0.4399520754814148,
-0.3823238015174866,
0.3628638982772827,
0.5763080716133118,
0.28410470485687256,
0.377886027097702,
-0.2065959870815277,
-0.2289804369211197,
-0.6916329264640808,
-0.2896912097930908,
-0.34104034304618835,
0.6444053053855896,
0.23526866734027863,
0.18043947219848633,
-0.6376122236251831,
0.0057148984633386135,
0.04814590513706207,
-0.06059370934963226,
-0.3326513171195984,
0.6835182309150696,
-0.0020509688183665276,
-0.9312378764152527,
0.31548887491226196,
-0.08478395640850067,
0.12149454653263092,
-0.6199877858161926,
-0.08715539425611496,
-0.49204349517822266,
0.06644497811794281,
-0.29140883684158325,
-0.8254472017288208,
0.4666990637779236,
-0.12592390179634094,
0.003213434014469385,
-0.4033682346343994,
0.7031362652778625,
-0.5570785999298096,
-0.38880401849746704,
0.3492472171783447,
1.0368000268936157,
-0.004283098969608545,
-0.20836341381072998,
-0.49472782015800476,
-0.2887722849845886,
-0.038759827613830566,
-0.3423484265804291,
0.34265023469924927,
0.5303412675857544,
0.059658680111169815,
0.9494865536689758,
0.6212177276611328,
0.1567404866218567,
0.19983139634132385,
0.06380711495876312,
0.8270106911659241,
-0.30129945278167725,
-0.40153074264526367,
-0.7622520923614502,
0.6675174832344055,
-0.049951404333114624,
-0.012719692662358284,
0.8773412108421326,
0.49557238817214966,
0.5650280714035034,
0.20204420387744904,
0.5646860003471375,
-0.18555553257465363,
0.6445925235748291,
-0.5539282560348511,
0.1577339619398117,
-0.6338615417480469,
0.10083259642124176,
-0.09472301602363586,
-0.8290261030197144,
-0.4970770478248596,
0.5310267210006714,
-0.38535648584365845,
0.045562610030174255,
0.8342834115028381,
0.7057580947875977,
0.12087597697973251,
-0.1110580563545227,
0.389644593000412,
0.16648127138614655,
0.7053642272949219,
0.7237673401832581,
1.1447787284851074,
0.06061675027012825,
0.9332405924797058,
0.30600959062576294,
-0.18463443219661713,
-0.3182336091995239,
-0.7368833422660828,
-0.4236450493335724,
-0.34562888741493225,
-0.2952924072742462,
-0.17817865312099457,
-0.10634627938270569,
0.9312170743942261,
0.5862770676612854,
-0.6596338748931885,
-0.06287217140197754,
-0.16859117150306702,
0.6302515268325806,
-0.39694535732269287,
-0.2287057787179947,
0.3500733971595764,
-0.6420217752456665,
-0.379489928483963,
0.7132986187934875,
0.3951621353626251,
-0.5261306166648865,
0.0544925332069397,
-0.044109538197517395,
-0.6211330890655518,
0.10755343735218048,
0.692440927028656,
0.054448485374450684,
-0.464525431394577,
-0.432853102684021,
0.08366675674915314,
0.10510227084159851,
0.10908501595258713,
0.6037265658378601,
-0.7007375955581665,
0.8399853110313416,
0.8942992687225342,
0.9229276180267334,
0.42557626962661743,
0.6374323964118958,
0.11880001425743103,
-0.7752553820610046,
0.03147869184613228,
0.4496009945869446,
0.5586417317390442,
-0.14327843487262726,
-0.16205982863903046,
0.38861533999443054,
0.20336249470710754,
-0.8859220743179321,
-0.5602142214775085,
0.3810308575630188,
-0.7217815518379211,
-0.75699383020401,
1.3878787755966187,
-0.35923635959625244,
0.1584198772907257,
-0.24861668050289154,
-0.2659788429737091,
-0.0269183199852705,
-0.26915910840034485,
0.6331559419631958,
0.8168560266494751,
-0.5774024128913879,
-0.3390626013278961,
-0.0449361614882946,
0.00842712540179491,
0.3624286949634552,
-1.0449885129928589,
0.09529250115156174,
1.0251274108886719,
-0.26308473944664,
0.4481810927391052,
0.9633304476737976,
0.17036212980747223,
0.23352940380573273,
0.2307172566652298,
-0.12648087739944458,
-0.227680966258049,
-0.5941177010536194,
-0.1664123386144638,
0.7376014590263367,
0.3388456404209137,
-0.21887803077697754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00134v1 | A Simple Attention-Based Mechanism for Bimodal Emotion Classification | 2024-06-28T10:43:02 | 2024-06-28T10:43:02 | Mazen Elabd, Sardar Jaf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Big data contain rich information for machine learning algorithms to utilize
when learning important features during classification tasks. Human beings
express their emotion using certain words, speech (tone, pitch, speed) or
facial expression. Artificial Intelligence approach to emotion classification
are largely based on learning from textual information. However, public
datasets containing text and speech data provide sufficient resources to train
machine learning algorithms for the tack of emotion classification. In this
paper, we present novel bimodal deep learning-based architectures enhanced with
attention mechanism trained and tested on text and speech data for emotion
classification. We report details of different deep learning based
architectures and show the performance of each architecture including rigorous
error analyses. Our finding suggests that deep learning based architectures
trained on different types of data (text and speech) outperform architectures
trained only on text or speech. Our proposed attention-based bimodal
architecture outperforms several state-of-the-art systems in emotion
classification. | [
-0.3684339225292206,
-0.6379047632217407,
0.2774280309677124,
0.4981923997402191,
-0.1545214056968689,
0.049724020063877106,
-0.38381773233413696,
-0.49640342593193054,
-0.0813969150185585,
0.07418499141931534,
-0.42020291090011597,
-0.3795278072357178,
-0.4323538839817047,
-0.12213941663503647,
-0.054873380810022354,
0.8079386353492737,
-0.013330362737178802,
0.24191971123218536,
-0.1161891296505928,
-0.4620407521724701,
-0.3121072053909302,
-0.5542618632316589,
-0.4353337287902832,
-0.2377346307039261,
0.8969982862472534,
0.39249902963638306,
0.5038928389549255,
0.16736187040805817,
0.5842893719673157,
0.393405556678772,
0.14436328411102295,
0.25456640124320984,
-0.3351854979991913,
0.023785300552845,
-0.017372334375977516,
-0.36711445450782776,
-0.26593896746635437,
0.03739494830369949,
0.23516015708446503,
0.1955699473619461,
0.013607478700578213,
0.2017982453107834,
-0.06778857856988907,
0.906792163848877,
-0.7952582240104675,
0.6780888438224792,
-0.10499875992536545,
0.5513983368873596,
-0.1871640980243683,
-0.10793500393629074,
-0.5027863383293152,
-0.23440466821193695,
0.14188656210899353,
0.029434921219944954,
-0.08135821670293808,
0.10098359733819962,
0.6340586543083191,
0.5689299702644348,
-0.605820894241333,
-0.3727586269378662,
-0.6388886570930481,
0.4924185276031494,
-0.4557110369205475,
0.5476936101913452,
0.09359624236822128,
0.24890847504138947,
0.5262362957000732,
-0.5270351767539978,
-0.7920607328414917,
-0.07716774195432663,
0.06406966596841812,
0.30512735247612,
-0.2705532908439636,
0.3170660138130188,
0.19100141525268555,
0.4632302224636078,
-0.8247321844100952,
0.13684433698654175,
-0.03778013586997986,
0.08646742254495621,
0.5385861396789551,
0.3479832112789154,
0.2215144783258438,
-0.20864495635032654,
-0.5398703813552856,
-0.31016385555267334,
-0.21149787306785583,
0.10833892226219177,
0.09920872747898102,
0.24270661175251007,
-0.4765268564224243,
0.26870277523994446,
-0.17059066891670227,
0.2616511285305023,
0.16980428993701935,
0.24343551695346832,
0.704961895942688,
0.07297548651695251,
-0.5468549728393555,
0.3560585379600525,
0.665816605091095,
0.49629470705986023,
0.2036798745393753,
-0.2906230092048645,
0.08924078941345215,
0.4491875469684601,
0.32206666469573975,
-0.8750917911529541,
0.07409869879484177,
0.21929116547107697,
-0.5058693885803223,
-0.1840571016073227,
-0.2245166003704071,
-1.1623685359954834,
-0.3832511305809021,
-0.4816509783267975,
0.3736809492111206,
-0.32010617852211,
-0.019841475412249565,
0.05724791809916496,
0.12915733456611633,
0.2118830531835556,
0.287222683429718,
-0.8940181136131287,
-0.0010727508924901485,
0.5548238158226013,
0.7519773244857788,
-0.07908614724874496,
0.10795179754495621,
-0.5217976570129395,
-0.17613327503204346,
-0.2853008508682251,
0.5471718907356262,
-0.6470984220504761,
0.252897709608078,
0.22838740050792694,
-0.09144262969493866,
-0.05961524695158005,
-0.29716619849205017,
0.5560730695724487,
-0.754598081111908,
0.3505493998527527,
0.12467075884342194,
-0.37078380584716797,
-0.7557356357574463,
0.2795923352241516,
-0.6215388178825378,
0.5138469934463501,
0.08288291096687317,
-0.6772953867912292,
0.2278439998626709,
-0.8202401995658875,
-0.680591881275177,
0.12286429107189178,
0.14369210600852966,
-0.5148611068725586,
0.3279540538787842,
0.010423577390611172,
0.8177804350852966,
-0.3852114975452423,
0.06106298416852951,
-0.7146565318107605,
-0.17233987152576447,
0.34621697664260864,
-0.39910048246383667,
0.2950836718082428,
0.5170408487319946,
-0.7874194383621216,
0.1220463216304779,
-0.8436164259910583,
-0.023803753778338432,
-0.1548418402671814,
-0.46418073773384094,
-0.13945309817790985,
-0.15467214584350586,
0.26056918501853943,
0.32029351592063904,
-0.003924537915736437,
-0.5880801677703857,
-0.12353461980819702,
-0.5603559017181396,
0.3996227979660034,
0.6178920269012451,
-0.24464714527130127,
0.3334178030490875,
0.15004666149616241,
0.33282577991485596,
0.26507675647735596,
-0.08754586428403854,
-0.22467279434204102,
-0.17708972096443176,
-0.7248278856277466,
-0.43798694014549255,
0.22434353828430176,
0.6942285299301147,
-0.4842623174190521,
0.36936649680137634,
-0.13614021241664886,
-0.5279281735420227,
-0.8833352327346802,
0.13288350403308868,
0.6044779419898987,
0.6479572653770447,
0.19409851729869843,
-0.22340504825115204,
-0.410434752702713,
-0.851944088935852,
0.0788329467177391,
-0.04438888281583786,
0.158916175365448,
0.753621518611908,
0.012246357277035713,
-0.5722478032112122,
0.5015482306480408,
-0.09688281267881393,
-0.05816129967570305,
-0.008145286701619625,
0.6464724540710449,
-0.08999372273683548,
0.17709927260875702,
0.599409818649292,
-1.0733429193496704,
-0.5209505558013916,
0.29906994104385376,
-0.7940079569816589,
0.020463852211833,
0.04178992658853531,
0.15911099314689636,
0.6078193187713623,
-0.05427204445004463,
-0.7956596612930298,
0.4633718430995941,
0.3623451292514801,
-0.11105456203222275,
-0.09416460245847702,
0.13591262698173523,
0.2616807818412781,
-0.7350771427154541,
0.056023746728897095,
0.07200322300195694,
-0.030723057687282562,
-0.6148511171340942,
-0.3391013741493225,
0.2584470212459564,
-0.37050411105155945,
-0.5448766350746155,
0.4991847276687622,
-0.2669108808040619,
-0.19471390545368195,
-0.29421788454055786,
-0.07294204086065292,
-0.042021408677101135,
1.007171869277954,
0.2939806282520294,
0.04942537471652031,
0.7263679504394531,
-0.576495885848999,
1.0722934007644653,
0.4513738453388214,
-0.4179293215274811,
0.6994485855102539,
-0.3355382978916168,
0.5485891103744507,
-0.41682198643684387,
0.10019450634717941,
-1.3955129384994507,
-0.4499681293964386,
0.24196578562259674,
-0.5405594110488892,
0.5589473843574524,
0.1493242383003235,
-0.45853227376937866,
-0.35061904788017273,
-0.3213065266609192,
0.06797942519187927,
0.500770628452301,
-0.8406214118003845,
0.6878988146781921,
-0.07362533360719681,
-0.4880122244358063,
-0.3634801208972931,
-0.9064782857894897,
0.12335048615932465,
-0.3261815905570984,
-0.7576475143432617,
-0.14130602777004242,
0.019696274772286415,
0.04226920008659363,
-0.004459814168512821,
0.3639483153820038,
-0.033050473779439926,
-0.02730540931224823,
0.7732986807823181,
0.17139720916748047,
-0.15206880867481232,
0.709355354309082,
-0.016366522759199142,
-0.06645635515451431,
0.12162280082702637,
0.3117672801017761,
0.45239493250846863,
-0.28985515236854553,
-0.2351275235414505,
-0.7887346148490906,
0.6808042526245117,
0.9756361842155457,
-0.4774532616138458,
0.22675330936908722,
1.0943809747695923,
-0.19775250554084778,
-0.13530278205871582,
-0.5882171988487244,
0.03418127819895744,
-0.45499560236930847,
0.5887360572814941,
-0.11354459077119827,
-0.8005885481834412,
0.09655824303627014,
-0.2883143723011017,
-0.13885127007961273,
0.03610135242342949,
1.0953983068466187,
-0.21980999410152435,
1.2762633562088013,
0.3335862457752228,
-0.3645736277103424,
0.6215780377388,
0.036526236683130264,
0.2660045325756073,
-0.6195135712623596,
-0.3081825077533722,
-0.43909451365470886,
-0.9145631194114685,
-0.3904876708984375,
-0.2636414170265198,
-0.029666177928447723,
-0.4773787260055542,
-0.5568023324012756,
-0.17323999106884003,
-0.46025121212005615,
-0.11161543428897858,
0.3437621593475342,
0.17745105922222137,
-0.343239963054657,
0.34760987758636475,
0.4413818120956421,
-0.05132937431335449,
-0.4269837439060211,
-0.2980685830116272,
0.7595607042312622,
0.5467193722724915,
0.8797852396965027,
0.04508418217301369,
0.391510009765625,
0.4186856150627136,
0.544698178768158,
-0.8046906590461731,
0.35994601249694824,
-0.0836314782500267,
-0.6182829737663269,
-0.10923811048269272,
-0.4675044119358063,
-0.6145704984664917,
-0.10399985313415527,
-0.09534591436386108,
-0.585143506526947,
0.6317179203033447,
0.06169504299759865,
-0.2880222499370575,
0.05225721001625061,
-1.082419991493225,
0.979107677936554,
-0.6788260340690613,
-0.48992812633514404,
-0.4630201458930969,
-0.927821159362793,
0.10628752410411835,
0.1708797663450241,
0.034616392105817795,
0.11389031261205673,
-0.07875316590070724,
0.6283242106437683,
0.14300775527954102,
0.9681332111358643,
-0.3502064347267151,
0.24255035817623138,
0.13609400391578674,
-0.1801811307668686,
0.47917237877845764,
-0.03498772159218788,
-0.09259487688541412,
0.09550540894269943,
-0.7757536768913269,
-0.19040435552597046,
-0.7153429985046387,
0.5149266719818115,
-0.6157147884368896,
-0.23282761871814728,
-0.1782636195421219,
-0.5266463160514832,
-0.5640246272087097,
-0.18710936605930328,
-0.10300823301076889,
0.4063132703304291,
-0.06722550094127655,
0.6570614576339722,
0.8546939492225647,
-0.14128746092319489,
0.7612941861152649,
0.4721876084804535,
0.19878385961055756,
-0.5315447449684143,
1.052599310874939,
-0.2027292251586914,
-0.05998580902814865,
0.6985332369804382,
0.07504482567310333,
-0.3633093237876892,
-0.31084004044532776,
-0.4646335244178772,
-0.09516646713018417,
-0.37109097838401794,
-0.38440456986427307,
-0.8037387728691101,
0.1201246902346611,
-0.627938985824585,
-0.07355239242315292,
-0.16126787662506104,
0.10020671039819717,
-0.3742941617965698,
-0.4388601779937744,
0.40105998516082764,
0.17223410308361053,
-0.1275455355644226,
-0.005882312543690205,
-0.9347072243690491,
0.42916056513786316,
0.8859200477600098,
0.481849730014801,
0.24130940437316895,
-0.1437225043773651,
-0.24616865813732147,
0.007185149472206831,
-0.3522687554359436,
-0.8361307978630066,
0.5883716344833374,
0.38009700179100037,
0.06367660313844681,
0.9170510768890381,
-0.001963772112503648,
0.4803309440612793,
-0.2774832248687744,
0.421196311712265,
0.4098447263240814,
-0.8494374752044678,
0.45448237657546997,
-0.07129503041505814,
0.10102193802595139,
0.3746638894081116,
0.6247498989105225,
-0.4701339900493622,
0.365402489900589,
-0.2893611192703247,
-0.6547561883926392,
1.0764617919921875,
0.04987747222185135,
0.2852938175201416,
0.10018334537744522,
0.15082359313964844,
-0.03209293633699417,
0.49211031198501587,
-0.5257248282432556,
-0.021107764914631844,
-0.4291984736919403,
-0.8230115175247192,
-0.1980275809764862,
-0.30140456557273865,
0.036077894270420074,
-0.011779969558119774,
0.21685832738876343,
-0.13636377453804016,
0.47201913595199585,
0.25793957710266113,
-0.19399604201316833,
-0.23734483122825623,
0.3892447054386139,
0.5749412775039673,
-0.3242207467556,
-0.4006967544555664,
-0.04195413365960121,
0.055348217487335205,
-0.2759116291999817,
0.20091603696346283,
0.143699511885643,
0.2240729182958603,
-0.09789688885211945,
0.3793547749519348,
1.4668803215026855,
0.2084910273551941,
-0.9044753313064575,
0.5223600268363953,
-0.07977719604969025,
-0.0253619197756052,
-0.0072609009221196175,
-0.05319731682538986,
0.42082685232162476,
0.7156413197517395,
0.06415127217769623,
-0.022184334695339203,
0.5964954495429993,
-1.0102887153625488,
-0.043059442192316055,
0.1519053727388382,
-0.7746601104736328,
-0.37949138879776,
0.36747708916664124,
0.470284640789032,
-0.4717615246772766,
0.516598641872406,
-0.22944806516170502,
-0.6060878038406372,
0.47611862421035767,
0.15126658976078033,
1.1206793785095215,
-0.4671264886856079,
0.1913871020078659,
-0.21302951872348785,
-0.06191558763384819,
0.5610760450363159,
0.5098236203193665,
-0.40415406227111816,
-0.3773263394832611,
-0.2356988787651062,
-0.6010132431983948,
-0.4438519775867462,
0.013761359266936779,
-0.45279738306999207,
-0.11285235732793808,
-0.6460971832275391,
-0.01671718806028366,
0.16115573048591614,
-0.05857560783624649,
-0.7486943006515503,
0.6474875211715698,
0.981448233127594,
0.6308886408805847,
-0.5752917528152466,
0.3924190402030945,
0.9622496962547302,
0.023990919813513756,
-0.6534265279769897,
-0.34877249598503113,
-0.04357404261827469,
-0.48664963245391846,
1.1229956150054932,
0.5123778581619263,
-0.125619575381279,
-0.3415592312812805,
-0.6345105171203613,
-0.40527746081352234,
0.6916595101356506,
0.2577597498893738,
-0.8321401476860046,
0.05879044160246849,
0.24540801346302032,
0.9341886043548584,
-0.5148424506187439,
0.2427418977022171,
0.05931130796670914,
0.6708021759986877,
0.14986486732959747,
-0.41550213098526,
-0.2659148871898651,
-0.523484468460083,
-0.14322954416275024,
-0.002492995699867606,
-1.0058577060699463,
0.533149242401123,
0.027602676302194595,
-0.24805548787117004,
-0.3794483542442322,
0.869235098361969,
-0.23541998863220215,
0.9969959259033203,
0.5030592679977417,
0.9610304236412048,
0.526483416557312,
-0.15004436671733856,
0.8879665732383728,
0.06313960999250412,
0.27017492055892944,
0.8865156173706055,
-0.7182337045669556,
0.7280104756355286,
-0.039092689752578735,
-0.10746283084154129,
0.44713130593299866,
0.724751889705658,
-0.1366083323955536,
0.7161815166473389,
0.04247134551405907,
-0.2897655963897705,
-0.32066553831100464,
-0.0282495878636837,
-0.171644926071167,
0.5758206844329834,
0.5240064859390259,
-0.3136727511882782,
-0.1233685091137886,
0.742771327495575,
-0.22494745254516602,
-0.28579622507095337,
-0.4709899127483368,
1.0126488208770752,
-0.05719071254134178,
-0.26857689023017883,
0.19603249430656433,
-0.38870617747306824,
0.6201316118240356,
-0.37924593687057495,
0.010981112718582153,
-0.15053120255470276,
0.423373818397522,
-0.3250812292098999,
-0.5820022225379944,
-0.005146045703440905,
0.15714402496814728,
-0.2846476137638092,
-0.06670594215393066,
0.7276016473770142,
-0.34578314423561096,
-0.25229766964912415,
0.356720894575119,
-0.3464467525482178,
-0.08752909302711487,
-0.32191264629364014,
-0.6055359840393066,
0.07003647834062576,
-0.143487811088562,
-0.656629204750061,
0.3348914384841919,
0.8747060894966125,
0.17587321996688843,
0.7299054265022278,
0.3702160120010376,
-0.5087867975234985,
0.1333693414926529,
-0.08163883537054062,
0.8074613809585571,
-0.8150613307952881,
-0.5672141313552856,
-0.6408231258392334,
0.5979408621788025,
-0.19615459442138672,
-0.19852392375469208,
0.2938113808631897,
0.29267823696136475,
0.24254769086837769,
-0.2529737055301666,
0.6229616403579712,
-0.0608522891998291,
0.6117410063743591,
-0.24619778990745544,
0.35066038370132446,
-0.5559741258621216,
-0.6427434682846069,
-0.2765156328678131,
-0.6708289980888367,
-0.21744586527347565,
0.23624232411384583,
-0.1845046728849411,
0.25469592213630676,
0.47566983103752136,
0.539004385471344,
0.1401553750038147,
0.12875577807426453,
0.4197961091995239,
0.4199536442756653,
0.0024106455966830254,
0.9579588770866394,
0.6856383085250854,
-0.19002048671245575,
0.3885941505432129,
-0.4372924268245697,
-0.3578588366508484,
-1.03238046169281,
-0.5059365630149841,
-0.922153651714325,
-0.45910489559173584,
-0.3541427552700043,
-0.0266954954713583,
0.15589208900928497,
0.6657364964485168,
0.8259563446044922,
-0.6475275158882141,
0.41693833470344543,
0.2544853389263153,
-0.10639631003141403,
0.027825715020298958,
-0.25833001732826233,
0.5458630323410034,
-0.3811592161655426,
-0.8405636548995972,
0.2015589326620102,
0.8688974380493164,
-0.14297635853290558,
-0.1561734676361084,
-0.18680772185325623,
-0.05859797075390816,
0.2831839621067047,
0.6613069176673889,
0.31447482109069824,
-0.2931174635887146,
-0.1624297946691513,
-0.13923504948616028,
-0.51125568151474,
0.14699463546276093,
0.6380733847618103,
-0.6191975474357605,
0.39158928394317627,
0.7504634261131287,
0.9650449752807617,
0.5791863203048706,
-0.002353040501475334,
0.0059227487072348595,
-0.5304651260375977,
0.3845154345035553,
0.4503912329673767,
0.36664092540740967,
0.3588213622570038,
-0.45092296600341797,
0.31603869795799255,
0.009462380781769753,
-0.5259481072425842,
-0.7199634909629822,
0.10029968619346619,
-1.5961710214614868,
0.06953074038028717,
0.7109695076942444,
-0.28318068385124207,
-0.6293925642967224,
0.2333207130432129,
-0.45269709825515747,
0.30071014165878296,
-0.46881648898124695,
1.1160019636154175,
0.5091511607170105,
-0.1387687474489212,
-0.5481385588645935,
-0.055410854518413544,
0.195556178689003,
0.5634535551071167,
-0.9364821314811707,
0.29589125514030457,
0.5312635898590088,
-0.1911449134349823,
0.498494416475296,
-0.13846522569656372,
-0.18605884909629822,
0.5357937216758728,
-0.20665618777275085,
0.4378810226917267,
-0.19572602212429047,
-0.31580591201782227,
-0.4739209711551666,
0.6447160243988037,
-0.6388749480247498,
-0.36035028100013733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19803v1 | Scalable and Domain-General Abstractive Proposition Segmentation | 2024-06-28T10:24:31 | 2024-06-28T10:24:31 | Mohammad Javad Hosseini, Yang Gao, Tim Baumgärtner, Alex Fabrikant, Reinald Kim Amplayo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Segmenting text into fine-grained units of meaning is important to a wide
range of NLP applications. The default approach of segmenting text into
sentences is often insufficient, especially since sentences are usually complex
enough to include multiple units of meaning that merit separate treatment in
the downstream task. We focus on the task of abstractive proposition
segmentation: transforming text into simple, self-contained, well-formed
sentences. Several recent works have demonstrated the utility of proposition
segmentation with few-shot prompted LLMs for downstream tasks such as
retrieval-augmented grounding and fact verification. However, this approach
does not scale to large amounts of text and may not always extract all the
facts from the input text. In this paper, we first introduce evaluation metrics
for the task to measure several dimensions of quality. We then propose a
scalable, yet accurate, proposition segmentation model. We model proposition
segmentation as a supervised task by training LLMs on existing annotated
datasets and show that training yields significantly improved results. We
further show that by using the fine-tuned LLMs as teachers for annotating large
amounts of multi-domain synthetic distillation data, we can train smaller
student models with results similar to the teacher LLMs. We then demonstrate
that our technique leads to effective domain generalization, by annotating data
in two domains outside the original training data and evaluating on them.
Finally, as a key contribution of the paper, we share an easy-to-use API for
NLP practitioners to use. | [
-0.33889904618263245,
-0.8252555727958679,
0.700110137462616,
0.21237589418888092,
-0.45646947622299194,
-0.04837340489029884,
-0.07069363445043564,
-0.43642231822013855,
0.07850177586078644,
0.5386306643486023,
-0.29236599802970886,
-0.4731315076351166,
-0.592211127281189,
0.13782039284706116,
-0.440670371055603,
0.9700927734375,
0.08389468491077423,
0.010332409292459488,
-0.5604963302612305,
-0.317828506231308,
-0.3877669870853424,
-0.6813763380050659,
-0.5495059490203857,
-0.4166702926158905,
0.30811455845832825,
0.31190237402915955,
0.3514900505542755,
0.9554821848869324,
0.549859344959259,
0.24788282811641693,
-0.10039612650871277,
0.5046989321708679,
-0.1843537837266922,
0.18497589230537415,
-0.4679677486419678,
-0.5551623702049255,
-0.29228082299232483,
0.22149202227592468,
0.6040140390396118,
1.0044262409210205,
0.11586122214794159,
0.16383381187915802,
-0.02715805359184742,
0.7350887656211853,
-0.5360522866249084,
0.047398641705513,
-0.7355883717536926,
0.18064312636852264,
-0.014433853328227997,
-0.20902307331562042,
-0.5309712290763855,
-0.1921103596687317,
0.6409152746200562,
-0.4553203582763672,
0.27128171920776367,
0.23383010923862457,
0.753713846206665,
0.4208943545818329,
-0.5637800097465515,
-0.4156416654586792,
-0.5670254230499268,
0.9222999811172485,
-0.35799795389175415,
-0.07342477887868881,
0.11771385371685028,
0.10530347377061844,
-0.013519354164600372,
-0.8595370054244995,
-0.41786059737205505,
-0.07075469195842743,
-0.1452818065881729,
-0.22333543002605438,
-0.24407994747161865,
0.05889539793133736,
0.1349312961101532,
0.6766547560691833,
-0.28039106726646423,
0.0719594955444336,
-0.14992575347423553,
-0.2573874294757843,
0.5569571852684021,
0.18329869210720062,
0.1897733360528946,
-0.34761905670166016,
-0.6208500862121582,
0.10196052491664886,
-0.6837747693061829,
-0.05880603566765785,
0.2093311846256256,
0.449479341506958,
0.2958892285823822,
0.8302507996559143,
-0.09835224598646164,
0.7800906896591187,
0.12278486043214798,
-0.4027729034423828,
-0.058781031519174576,
-0.3189208209514618,
-0.16110600531101227,
-0.06603068858385086,
0.6252384185791016,
0.29805445671081543,
0.023335542529821396,
0.00580461835488677,
-0.13769060373306274,
0.09266995638608932,
0.26464685797691345,
-0.9583390355110168,
-0.3126138150691986,
0.42237910628318787,
-0.3009827136993408,
-0.07862908393144608,
-0.24835149943828583,
-0.48634272813796997,
-0.21246454119682312,
-0.6600731015205383,
0.32955339550971985,
-0.5694774985313416,
0.2378641813993454,
0.23710644245147705,
-0.10303869098424911,
0.19735181331634521,
0.34662744402885437,
-1.0614100694656372,
0.418750524520874,
0.7982211709022522,
0.9738681316375732,
-0.6841487288475037,
0.022957103326916695,
-0.6034866571426392,
0.044695258140563965,
-0.21738062798976898,
0.9959346055984497,
-0.42932945489883423,
-0.28088852763175964,
-0.008619243279099464,
-0.07111065089702606,
-0.0836908370256424,
-0.7751971483230591,
0.6795385479927063,
-0.4945017397403717,
0.24695974588394165,
0.009518126957118511,
-0.9280481934547424,
-0.16844193637371063,
0.7396379113197327,
-0.45399945974349976,
0.7395995259284973,
-0.03489051014184952,
-0.6108847856521606,
0.31648707389831543,
-0.6093416810035706,
-0.49030405282974243,
0.033785440027713776,
-0.15171897411346436,
-0.35207512974739075,
0.20729497075080872,
0.5320829153060913,
0.6171082854270935,
-0.17696289718151093,
0.04524688422679901,
-0.05244951322674751,
0.06406982988119125,
0.16949479281902313,
-0.45116451382637024,
0.4202323257923126,
0.012331288307905197,
-0.042652856558561325,
0.16724832355976105,
-1.040717363357544,
0.17382097244262695,
-0.1082342267036438,
-0.3843899071216583,
-0.46067357063293457,
0.1610882729291916,
-0.02358246222138405,
-0.02751241624355316,
0.21223708987236023,
-0.5624036192893982,
0.4044940173625946,
-0.6980165243148804,
0.5164827108383179,
0.47781410813331604,
0.3315371870994568,
0.7113083600997925,
-0.12488987296819687,
0.3185548484325409,
-0.05390165001153946,
-0.18789976835250854,
-0.36340758204460144,
-0.319119393825531,
-0.9147789478302002,
-0.6293958425521851,
0.31552666425704956,
0.3586597740650177,
-0.7123059630393982,
0.5304388999938965,
-0.08571745455265045,
-0.25967252254486084,
-0.11612459272146225,
-0.09664087742567062,
0.07565978169441223,
0.630386471748352,
0.5915197730064392,
0.007138980086892843,
-0.4603274464607239,
-0.9214763641357422,
-0.16614952683448792,
-0.012435775250196457,
-0.3596062660217285,
0.08236223459243774,
0.6103003025054932,
-0.2632010281085968,
1.3893119096755981,
-0.9578668475151062,
-0.5885372161865234,
-0.22506462037563324,
0.22770220041275024,
0.10128197073936462,
0.5350209474563599,
0.4086909890174866,
-0.7677561640739441,
-0.4462195634841919,
-0.050116896629333496,
-0.5238045454025269,
0.043021347373723984,
-0.32397857308387756,
-0.07229368388652802,
-0.2566591203212738,
0.18843162059783936,
-0.5473498702049255,
0.25065699219703674,
0.1357056051492691,
-0.15092696249485016,
0.5058876872062683,
-0.2055346816778183,
-0.1617717146873474,
-0.9083483219146729,
-0.32888317108154297,
0.24713686108589172,
-0.5375929474830627,
-0.5296947956085205,
0.15984520316123962,
-0.2704668939113617,
0.030345093458890915,
-0.565683126449585,
0.3633897602558136,
-0.2383423149585724,
-0.057528384029865265,
-0.6181269884109497,
0.2948370575904846,
0.2661871612071991,
0.29482269287109375,
0.34936201572418213,
0.6775438785552979,
0.402707576751709,
-0.6972779035568237,
0.3982425928115845,
0.3775497376918793,
-0.3351987302303314,
0.8133055567741394,
-0.7522750496864319,
0.06779559701681137,
0.03580266982316971,
0.26850956678390503,
-0.8643674254417419,
-0.19813299179077148,
0.20848746597766876,
-0.018210425972938538,
0.01660090498626232,
-0.2733836770057678,
-0.38516703248023987,
-0.052251506596803665,
-0.11400582641363144,
0.24372036755084991,
0.1878499686717987,
-0.7522901296615601,
0.5316562652587891,
0.5062355995178223,
-0.03625637665390968,
-0.33669087290763855,
-0.5962175130844116,
0.04179616644978523,
-0.3382335305213928,
-0.5223661661148071,
0.6351356506347656,
0.19109566509723663,
-0.18218064308166504,
-0.0842379480600357,
-0.2544184625148773,
-0.40506988763809204,
-0.1318422555923462,
0.22562864422798157,
0.1828359067440033,
-0.19413301348686218,
0.22907201945781708,
0.2828907370567322,
-0.252849817276001,
0.2553727626800537,
-0.6726856827735901,
0.25477471947669983,
-0.3005000054836273,
-0.2880341112613678,
-0.3095708191394806,
0.35205650329589844,
0.15833032131195068,
-0.11324898898601532,
0.5466139912605286,
0.41058871150016785,
-0.42274364829063416,
-0.622126042842865,
-0.25048986077308655,
0.009511436335742474,
-0.4146907329559326,
0.15470845997333527,
-0.3905842900276184,
-1.112648367881775,
0.12945911288261414,
-0.5869958400726318,
0.1221042275428772,
0.7449729442596436,
0.4501461982727051,
-0.1339539885520935,
0.7397785782814026,
0.6835306882858276,
0.32737118005752563,
-0.015919391065835953,
-0.5275290012359619,
0.2622620761394501,
-0.8124851584434509,
-0.1207195296883583,
-0.36372309923171997,
-0.2625768184661865,
-0.37738701701164246,
-0.754726767539978,
0.2726307809352875,
0.059616800397634506,
0.13997329771518707,
0.10114068537950516,
-0.8598805069923401,
0.8042295575141907,
0.36605170369148254,
-0.046057697385549545,
0.4195983409881592,
0.1585416942834854,
0.01711351051926613,
-0.2808454930782318,
-0.3877234160900116,
-0.8732085227966309,
0.9816782474517822,
0.49761971831321716,
0.520720362663269,
-0.14975214004516602,
0.653915524482727,
0.2961123287677765,
0.3078317940235138,
-1.3150097131729126,
0.6288659572601318,
-0.3711129426956177,
-0.5867148041725159,
-0.40170565247535706,
-0.29525649547576904,
-0.6855655312538147,
0.8685171604156494,
-0.08113811910152435,
-0.5948607325553894,
0.1842445284128189,
0.026681749150156975,
-0.596855878829956,
0.21797288954257965,
-0.6105151772499084,
0.7083001136779785,
-0.1566457599401474,
-0.03384014219045639,
-0.035342972725629807,
-0.5155390501022339,
0.2622513473033905,
-0.18857404589653015,
-0.07769692689180374,
-0.48264405131340027,
-0.10958636552095413,
0.7670391798019409,
-0.8060187697410583,
0.8167935609817505,
-0.15916281938552856,
-0.05052080377936363,
0.6443866491317749,
-0.21376895904541016,
0.19155758619308472,
0.23018577694892883,
0.14354872703552246,
0.05408620834350586,
0.2645065486431122,
-0.2625758945941925,
-0.7038249373435974,
0.4435149133205414,
-0.5869541764259338,
-0.5694267153739929,
-0.5156129598617554,
-0.3650796115398407,
-0.3807240128517151,
0.04060516506433487,
0.17585694789886475,
0.3247702717781067,
-0.2555198073387146,
0.32459941506385803,
0.751189649105072,
0.17873167991638184,
0.3229512870311737,
0.17907783389091492,
-0.08382949233055115,
-0.4632017910480499,
0.8644286394119263,
-0.04308895021677017,
0.07094675302505493,
0.664233922958374,
0.3936231732368469,
-0.6218322515487671,
-0.7303860187530518,
-0.32296431064605713,
-0.016782956197857857,
-0.7680780291557312,
-0.2473011463880539,
-0.5879032611846924,
-0.05139703303575516,
-0.0012024437310174108,
-0.15620949864387512,
-0.5687100887298584,
-0.7268576622009277,
-0.6049075722694397,
-0.1980580985546112,
0.09839147329330444,
0.5076775550842285,
-0.06562257558107376,
0.5772876143455505,
-0.6735143065452576,
0.4710181951522827,
0.5350366234779358,
-0.06499319523572922,
-0.24995410442352295,
-0.6044747829437256,
-0.031164484098553658,
-0.018450232222676277,
-0.45880964398384094,
-0.3231087625026703,
0.46359390020370483,
0.5539760589599609,
0.20829777419567108,
0.4528999328613281,
0.1957102119922638,
0.5857505798339844,
-0.8619410395622253,
0.8976227641105652,
0.3420964479446411,
-0.9793429374694824,
0.8518603444099426,
-0.03318895772099495,
0.053069666028022766,
0.6890992522239685,
0.5992715358734131,
-0.1989489644765854,
-0.013408742845058441,
-0.24219809472560883,
-0.8753655552864075,
0.44376569986343384,
0.05820383504033089,
0.3778044879436493,
-0.1978571116924286,
0.6376226544380188,
0.3139781653881073,
0.11799641698598862,
-0.7912329435348511,
-0.4536370635032654,
-0.10807472467422485,
-0.04350246116518974,
0.08679480850696564,
-0.5052865147590637,
-0.3836055099964142,
-0.2574246823787689,
0.43027302622795105,
-0.3390733599662781,
-0.0676775723695755,
0.2556499242782593,
-0.08594513684511185,
0.3749241232872009,
0.456755131483078,
0.36358878016471863,
0.6683993935585022,
-0.07991630584001541,
0.3960598409175873,
0.009819754399359226,
-0.44841140508651733,
0.7057111859321594,
0.012513779103755951,
-0.16458286345005035,
0.10979357361793518,
0.39925235509872437,
0.4777229428291321,
0.012482898309826851,
-0.48139688372612,
0.6169309020042419,
0.005106527823954821,
-0.33085396885871887,
-0.1667746603488922,
-0.004856191109865904,
-0.19963406026363373,
0.27245983481407166,
0.5522462129592896,
0.19310912489891052,
0.24331489205360413,
-0.3978599011898041,
0.3771251142024994,
0.19269666075706482,
-0.19746504724025726,
-0.21630632877349854,
0.5519106388092041,
0.4356782138347626,
-0.05701322481036186,
0.48112785816192627,
-0.41398367285728455,
-0.4045802652835846,
0.25497493147850037,
0.5875763893127441,
0.8412614464759827,
0.14565429091453552,
0.4759385883808136,
0.21523919701576233,
0.09776005148887634,
-0.1883244514465332,
-0.18757961690425873,
-0.03296876326203346,
-0.7864886522293091,
-0.7299844026565552,
-0.7461082935333252,
-0.6408665776252747,
0.012132137082517147,
-0.5652574896812439,
-0.1821475774049759,
-0.6590717434883118,
-0.30367544293403625,
0.2891615033149719,
-0.007534018252044916,
-0.40240001678466797,
0.4429108202457428,
0.030110204592347145,
0.6474363803863525,
-0.6996017694473267,
0.5667036175727844,
0.6739789247512817,
-0.2862705588340759,
-0.5715667009353638,
-0.07418731600046158,
-0.31149932742118835,
-0.5270071029663086,
0.7817406058311462,
0.3430231511592865,
-0.06169804558157921,
-0.27875465154647827,
-0.6489519476890564,
-0.6560876369476318,
0.7501773834228516,
0.3956696391105652,
-0.40137141942977905,
-0.0944756343960762,
0.6308003067970276,
0.7287323474884033,
-0.7288326025009155,
-0.2530601918697357,
0.6518193483352661,
0.076988585293293,
0.5181596279144287,
-0.3405850827693939,
-0.12786461412906647,
0.28838106989860535,
0.09753766655921936,
-0.04256029427051544,
-0.24681393802165985,
0.6931771039962769,
-0.08179192990064621,
-0.24387961626052856,
-0.09878887236118317,
0.9174494743347168,
0.1752333790063858,
0.39042022824287415,
0.5730572938919067,
0.5599989891052246,
0.8690310120582581,
-0.31663674116134644,
0.8173058032989502,
0.047810062766075134,
0.4063107967376709,
1.4082016944885254,
-0.11010913550853729,
0.9960547685623169,
0.5108991265296936,
-0.38287198543548584,
0.4831470847129822,
0.6444655656814575,
-0.03229345753788948,
0.4355587065219879,
0.371997594833374,
-0.3772861063480377,
-0.38995125889778137,
-0.3159535229206085,
-0.03952277451753616,
0.6365721225738525,
0.5081900358200073,
-0.19027765095233917,
-0.23280933499336243,
0.1622256189584732,
-0.2438146322965622,
0.18667981028556824,
-0.3800453543663025,
0.6784831285476685,
0.23469363152980804,
-0.4515022337436676,
0.3616979122161865,
0.19942186772823334,
0.5959448218345642,
-0.3547389805316925,
-0.0683351680636406,
0.03415854275226593,
0.055042564868927,
-0.4359634220600128,
-0.773103654384613,
0.602615475654602,
0.025672923773527145,
-0.3286135792732239,
-0.31056901812553406,
0.7922671437263489,
-0.352899432182312,
-0.3648630976676941,
-0.21051572263240814,
0.47486400604248047,
0.12846538424491882,
-0.4242648780345917,
-0.566460132598877,
-0.07474186271429062,
0.09884647279977798,
-0.054493241012096405,
0.21797779202461243,
0.5990909934043884,
0.19716429710388184,
0.563495397567749,
0.6641507744789124,
0.027707993984222412,
-0.09335947781801224,
0.05205077677965164,
0.8154568076133728,
-0.42945000529289246,
-0.3988264799118042,
-0.8678371906280518,
0.5596830248832703,
-0.1858396679162979,
-0.3301083445549011,
0.7469426393508911,
0.6256029605865479,
0.6577473282814026,
-0.09733809530735016,
0.5495001077651978,
0.22560039162635803,
0.4829747974872589,
-0.5097638368606567,
0.24031902849674225,
-0.20930390059947968,
0.27970239520072937,
0.09383242577314377,
-1.1197800636291504,
-0.5196675062179565,
0.8077168464660645,
-0.5211502313613892,
-0.4773263931274414,
0.6782465577125549,
0.04359162598848343,
0.060541801154613495,
-0.08560342341661453,
0.31899091601371765,
-0.25766435265541077,
0.531329870223999,
0.16678588092327118,
1.0154774188995361,
-0.36448124051094055,
0.4792051613330841,
-0.2761228084564209,
-0.12024291604757309,
-0.038999468088150024,
-0.8231824636459351,
-0.90653395652771,
-0.41449859738349915,
-0.7041641473770142,
0.025774981826543808,
-0.40272632241249084,
0.914936363697052,
0.8768508434295654,
-0.8130437731742859,
0.015587573871016502,
-0.1525014340877533,
0.19369569420814514,
0.00781527254730463,
-0.25401172041893005,
0.5636968612670898,
-0.5792086124420166,
-0.8300393223762512,
0.5444691777229309,
0.5833628177642822,
0.13973960280418396,
-0.340557724237442,
0.3803541660308838,
-0.12156028300523758,
0.19187776744365692,
1.0660362243652344,
0.11977993696928024,
-0.6584528684616089,
-0.4541063606739044,
-0.28103622794151306,
0.012077094055712223,
0.21718165278434753,
0.7742989659309387,
-0.6053066253662109,
0.4226873219013214,
0.10119448602199554,
0.9069128036499023,
0.5684467554092407,
0.26436105370521545,
0.3676130473613739,
-1.1449604034423828,
0.10023510456085205,
0.5321485996246338,
0.3366791903972626,
0.36913976073265076,
-0.23643267154693604,
0.6882520914077759,
0.24505667388439178,
-0.5631830096244812,
-0.6780362129211426,
0.20889067649841309,
-1.1199138164520264,
-0.2730028033256531,
1.0706090927124023,
-0.40999406576156616,
-0.19637049734592438,
0.03308940306305885,
-0.339364618062973,
-0.30181828141212463,
-0.053140223026275635,
0.42834872007369995,
0.7192277312278748,
-0.4451121985912323,
0.1190040335059166,
-0.05076688155531883,
0.47162631154060364,
0.08318644016981125,
-1.005550742149353,
-0.019465887919068336,
0.7165403962135315,
0.22492629289627075,
0.49430832266807556,
0.4227348268032074,
0.10286684334278107,
-0.2068450003862381,
0.1506424844264984,
-0.1853199601173401,
0.14069001376628876,
-0.26563745737075806,
-0.27334916591644287,
0.6833441853523254,
0.038229744881391525,
-0.4677216112613678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19783v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19783v1 | NLPerturbator: Studying the Robustness of Code LLMs to Natural Language Variations | 2024-06-28T09:39:33 | 2024-06-28T09:39:33 | Junkai Chen, Zhenhao Li, Xing Hu, Xin Xia | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) achieve promising results in code generation
based on a given natural language description. They have been integrated into
open-source projects and commercial products to facilitate daily coding
activities. The natural language description in the prompt is crucial for LLMs
to comprehend users' requirements. Prior studies uncover that LLMs are
sensitive to the changes in the prompts, including slight changes that look
inconspicuous. However, the natural language descriptions often vary in
real-world scenarios (e.g., different formats, grammar, and wording). Prior
studies on the robustness of LLMs are often based on random perturbations and
such perturbations may not actually happen. In this paper, we conduct a
comprehensive study to investigate how are code LLMs robust to variations of
natural language description in real-world scenarios. We summarize 18
categories of perturbations of natural language and 3 combinations of
co-occurred categories based on our literature review and an online survey with
practitioners. We propose an automated framework, NLPerturbator, which can
perform perturbations of each category given a set of prompts. Through a series
of experiments on code generation using six code LLMs, we find that the
perturbed prompts can decrease the performance of code generation by a
considerable margin (e.g., up to 21.2%, and 4.8% to 6.1% on average). Our study
highlights the importance of enhancing the robustness of LLMs to real-world
variations in the prompts, as well as the essentiality of attentively
constructing the prompts. | [
-0.6429969668388367,
-1.1320101022720337,
0.2208269238471985,
0.4921560287475586,
-0.19528064131736755,
0.1034066304564476,
-0.2852715849876404,
-0.3201427161693573,
0.10553547739982605,
0.6283268332481384,
-0.5452213287353516,
-0.4618070721626282,
-0.4460013508796692,
0.7029524445533752,
-0.38144081830978394,
0.9577195048332214,
0.016399119049310684,
-0.21950604021549225,
-0.20354656875133514,
0.21905522048473358,
-0.4260997772216797,
-0.7017008662223816,
-0.3858847916126251,
-0.1473049819469452,
0.46252545714378357,
0.1539112627506256,
0.8209776878356934,
0.5038100481033325,
0.7182671427726746,
0.2299615740776062,
-0.35605648159980774,
-0.011480547487735748,
-0.39735478162765503,
0.5659202337265015,
0.05317008122801781,
-0.69466233253479,
-0.1852947324514389,
-0.3878364562988281,
0.5308036804199219,
0.3992004692554474,
-0.12206824123859406,
0.028367172926664352,
0.19799558818340302,
0.4285021424293518,
-0.502564013004303,
-0.11911214143037796,
-0.6412428021430969,
0.19353389739990234,
0.014969372190535069,
-0.5517988801002502,
-0.2839941084384918,
-0.42465654015541077,
-0.1338559091091156,
-0.25415584444999695,
0.31287726759910583,
0.13159556686878204,
0.8698049187660217,
0.5702583193778992,
-0.22127699851989746,
-0.5043447613716125,
-0.9267740845680237,
0.7454924583435059,
-0.9470944404602051,
0.0016086071263998747,
0.18710725009441376,
0.27218466997146606,
-0.7395376563072205,
-0.7601239085197449,
-0.6346307396888733,
-0.7038612961769104,
-0.05323430523276329,
-0.09497089684009552,
-0.2884310483932495,
0.08502048999071121,
0.6668346524238586,
0.4596126973628998,
-0.46679696440696716,
0.3301199674606323,
0.18137066066265106,
-0.2567138969898224,
0.3932345509529114,
0.5414117574691772,
0.3636595606803894,
-0.5036846995353699,
-0.1750125288963318,
-0.11698801070451736,
-0.6977412700653076,
0.31604620814323425,
0.8174839019775391,
0.28133103251457214,
-0.1359795480966568,
0.6141281127929688,
0.03976835310459137,
0.7840794920921326,
0.11639395356178284,
-0.20431949198246002,
-0.039051603525877,
-0.47915831208229065,
-0.13127781450748444,
-0.17826570570468903,
0.9484738707542419,
0.37782591581344604,
0.10498615354299545,
0.03163718804717064,
-0.37865138053894043,
-0.012647178024053574,
0.5676714777946472,
-0.8715611696243286,
-0.1862022876739502,
0.32284221053123474,
-0.4100210964679718,
-0.6683536171913147,
0.052141498774290085,
-0.9108685255050659,
-0.6664059162139893,
-0.279581218957901,
-0.03699658066034317,
-0.3115462064743042,
-0.014706846326589584,
0.08425154536962509,
0.23919403553009033,
0.15239474177360535,
0.1677538901567459,
-0.5569332838058472,
0.12506620585918427,
0.6093846559524536,
0.6537349224090576,
-0.14868786931037903,
-0.2813005745410919,
-0.564490795135498,
-0.2711033523082733,
-0.21315692365169525,
0.7548823952674866,
-0.6316015720367432,
-0.5892235636711121,
0.04859746992588043,
-0.20759448409080505,
0.19429314136505127,
-0.5049405097961426,
0.6232631206512451,
-0.3961908221244812,
0.2525157034397125,
-0.00955275073647499,
-0.5671485662460327,
0.09627082198858261,
0.40897229313850403,
-0.7166153788566589,
0.9233794212341309,
-0.10822413116693497,
-1.1120010614395142,
0.21017245948314667,
-0.5669567584991455,
-0.417841374874115,
0.03789467737078667,
-0.3277900516986847,
-0.6122559309005737,
0.30788686871528625,
0.3312837779521942,
0.300018310546875,
-0.2973017990589142,
0.3339872360229492,
0.007618029601871967,
-0.5750293731689453,
0.8206173181533813,
-0.6308651566505432,
0.7249317765235901,
0.2701556086540222,
-0.33857518434524536,
0.336149126291275,
-0.940037190914154,
-0.2231415957212448,
0.10797260701656342,
-0.5170308351516724,
0.04664021357893944,
0.19066989421844482,
0.12047288566827774,
0.09984949231147766,
-0.0411357544362545,
-0.2534213960170746,
0.4260188937187195,
-0.6004725694656372,
0.264750599861145,
0.5319586992263794,
0.525592565536499,
0.22462114691734314,
-0.4169517755508423,
1.2362744808197021,
-0.19640086591243744,
0.18844068050384521,
-0.44923144578933716,
-0.5489582419395447,
-0.4491467773914337,
-0.3410657048225403,
0.08836116641759872,
0.5627788305282593,
-0.7806611657142639,
0.6200137138366699,
0.030850205570459366,
-0.4216344952583313,
-0.3321148157119751,
0.1295427680015564,
0.2422061264514923,
0.5568661689758301,
0.20793886482715607,
0.004480869974941015,
-0.7614797949790955,
-0.763293445110321,
-0.5775186419487,
-0.06805635988712311,
-0.29129472374916077,
0.05809945985674858,
0.23338006436824799,
-0.6011950373649597,
1.1234164237976074,
-0.27291756868362427,
0.12043928354978561,
-0.33772706985473633,
0.1500846892595291,
0.738806426525116,
0.3269023597240448,
0.4310457408428192,
-0.6634207367897034,
-0.3027358949184418,
-0.4161567687988281,
-0.2687879204750061,
-0.41136929392814636,
-0.5970489978790283,
0.16472283005714417,
0.3002743422985077,
0.6329569220542908,
-0.3704589009284973,
0.39974313974380493,
0.6081953644752502,
-0.24278561770915985,
0.8894665241241455,
-0.24690678715705872,
-0.040617961436510086,
-1.1296913623809814,
0.2067294865846634,
0.00017237054998986423,
-0.0057413093745708466,
-0.6032207608222961,
0.3884952664375305,
-0.008200014941394329,
0.08460110425949097,
-0.46837419271469116,
0.2018917202949524,
-0.30332881212234497,
0.3196350932121277,
-0.3139958679676056,
-0.1374887079000473,
-0.1287214159965515,
0.15371598303318024,
-0.3064028322696686,
0.8303428292274475,
0.6319199204444885,
-0.7628588676452637,
0.4698711633682251,
0.13992394506931305,
-0.1941463053226471,
0.2884034216403961,
-0.769259512424469,
0.2436041682958603,
-0.26511693000793457,
0.2817663252353668,
-0.9766878485679626,
-0.40989917516708374,
0.21789205074310303,
-0.46148353815078735,
0.21453987061977386,
-0.1881697177886963,
-0.8028553128242493,
-0.3738988935947418,
-0.5112797617912292,
-0.006923162378370762,
0.5179652571678162,
-0.4180258810520172,
0.6575904488563538,
-0.034165289252996445,
0.03267870470881462,
-0.49885839223861694,
-0.5633153915405273,
0.4455925226211548,
-0.24508188664913177,
-0.4150162935256958,
-0.044389158487319946,
-0.3138323128223419,
-0.4192505180835724,
-0.36064472794532776,
-0.1595417857170105,
0.34945398569107056,
0.4734344482421875,
0.6749786138534546,
0.30984264612197876,
-0.03611486405134201,
-0.08475559204816818,
-0.06597680598497391,
-0.06523814797401428,
0.3462317883968353,
-0.00419385964050889,
0.792168915271759,
-0.1276058554649353,
-0.2958505153656006,
-0.24594072997570038,
0.09555293619632721,
0.23346440494060516,
-0.1303037852048874,
0.5765106081962585,
0.6200645565986633,
-0.23604486882686615,
-0.367044597864151,
-0.3765351176261902,
-0.11723863333463669,
-0.5938194990158081,
0.3768942654132843,
-0.35930773615837097,
-0.9476932287216187,
0.6099236607551575,
0.082706019282341,
0.09372372180223465,
0.2704245150089264,
0.7771696448326111,
0.015477830544114113,
0.9033864736557007,
0.5961233973503113,
0.153071328997612,
0.37745821475982666,
0.14697962999343872,
0.25134730339050293,
-0.589813768863678,
-0.16591273248195648,
-0.7492579817771912,
-0.22912855446338654,
-0.8396288156509399,
-0.2982538938522339,
0.19192928075790405,
0.1828990876674652,
-0.06569875031709671,
0.2647116780281067,
-0.6894485354423523,
0.639790415763855,
0.3726215362548828,
-0.42283275723457336,
0.10284440964460373,
0.10693541914224625,
-0.31547001004219055,
-0.18770910799503326,
-0.4668790102005005,
-0.9036055207252502,
0.977131724357605,
0.44113901257514954,
1.0755518674850464,
0.13400402665138245,
0.7912538647651672,
0.16635173559188843,
0.12102878838777542,
-0.6949371099472046,
0.5133436322212219,
0.08913733810186386,
-0.3671102523803711,
0.010533036664128304,
-0.5506823062896729,
-1.0698845386505127,
-0.12754198908805847,
-0.40898144245147705,
-0.6123122572898865,
0.03582945093512535,
0.34271055459976196,
-0.44775936007499695,
0.23411348462104797,
-0.36187300086021423,
0.4369826316833496,
-0.20669421553611755,
-0.3970033526420593,
0.3677414357662201,
-0.5913494825363159,
0.07401139289140701,
-0.2304564267396927,
0.2838877737522125,
0.07793006300926208,
-0.25509199500083923,
0.34904345870018005,
-0.15814699232578278,
0.9893618226051331,
0.06380400061607361,
-0.5251429677009583,
0.2991666793823242,
0.5596992373466492,
0.6198536157608032,
0.49249863624572754,
-0.12208566069602966,
-0.09831424802541733,
-0.24586011469364166,
-0.23944662511348724,
-0.521399974822998,
0.7511531114578247,
-0.6004167199134827,
-0.6122370958328247,
-0.26279476284980774,
-0.5632132887840271,
-0.29241126775741577,
0.13590428233146667,
0.6937375068664551,
0.4427870512008667,
0.06371026486158371,
0.03462986648082733,
0.6218739151954651,
-0.7213819622993469,
0.6266101598739624,
0.19075433909893036,
-0.5404549241065979,
-0.3719469904899597,
0.5431213974952698,
-0.17990615963935852,
0.09641331434249878,
0.5003865361213684,
0.27613502740859985,
-0.11627499014139175,
-0.7625951170921326,
-0.11932409554719925,
-0.06693703681230545,
-0.6805092096328735,
-0.23995736241340637,
-0.6230705380439758,
0.09766200184822083,
-0.26115110516548157,
-0.38828811049461365,
-0.09861995279788971,
-0.2616901695728302,
-0.47117123007774353,
-0.12892396748065948,
0.4088152050971985,
0.8545908331871033,
0.29601752758026123,
0.19068779051303864,
-0.8905165791511536,
0.21438860893249512,
0.09897911548614502,
0.5245670676231384,
-0.21824762225151062,
-0.5508769750595093,
-0.03210127726197243,
-0.14111553132534027,
-0.10438163578510284,
-0.8719463348388672,
0.4975566565990448,
-0.06347121298313141,
0.5473527312278748,
0.27474430203437805,
0.32888248562812805,
0.4460953176021576,
-0.26864829659461975,
1.1068283319473267,
0.11446607857942581,
-0.9061061143875122,
0.5837699770927429,
-0.47258856892585754,
0.6083115339279175,
0.4860435128211975,
0.20258969068527222,
-0.4014534652233124,
-0.9087245464324951,
-0.428646445274353,
-1.0911353826522827,
0.4694058299064636,
0.25106680393218994,
0.501980185508728,
-0.10874893516302109,
0.6683939695358276,
0.206941619515419,
0.1422712206840515,
-0.64818274974823,
-0.3482125997543335,
-0.3991968631744385,
-0.15921102464199066,
0.008221330121159554,
-0.43772292137145996,
0.00815842766314745,
0.13063496351242065,
0.24017617106437683,
-0.1756608635187149,
0.3076718747615814,
0.17869235575199127,
-0.028508640825748444,
-0.20501962304115295,
0.4311803877353668,
0.9147709012031555,
0.5543248057365417,
-0.2754526138305664,
0.42464160919189453,
0.13700437545776367,
-0.6558467149734497,
0.019456638023257256,
-0.09073542803525925,
-0.20108820497989655,
0.04218568280339241,
0.6110321283340454,
0.886490523815155,
0.06212705746293068,
-0.9339913725852966,
0.27963536977767944,
-0.3871091306209564,
-0.10223513096570969,
-0.3002338707447052,
0.3204697072505951,
-0.04720202088356018,
-0.0429312139749527,
0.36705082654953003,
0.29163938760757446,
0.14415031671524048,
-0.21285563707351685,
0.10165690630674362,
0.16996751725673676,
-0.18218933045864105,
-0.391114741563797,
0.7203283309936523,
0.00145390210673213,
-0.6308593153953552,
0.3691597282886505,
-0.3007102608680725,
-0.5333012938499451,
0.7046365141868591,
0.7796653509140015,
0.8703802824020386,
-0.006044548470526934,
-0.14636212587356567,
0.33064955472946167,
0.5309808254241943,
0.07695169746875763,
0.27294138073921204,
0.2969984710216522,
-0.46566280722618103,
-0.6934409141540527,
-0.6329286694526672,
-0.5642836093902588,
0.02780192345380783,
-0.5795934200286865,
0.393745481967926,
-0.7691643238067627,
-0.43543529510498047,
-0.35593101382255554,
-0.18412689864635468,
-0.5091134905815125,
-0.045572053641080856,
0.1791025549173355,
0.8795627951622009,
-0.47097307443618774,
0.6080495715141296,
1.0698201656341553,
-0.3298642933368683,
-0.9574573636054993,
0.4337606430053711,
0.006129559129476547,
-0.3592453598976135,
0.3807796537876129,
0.08505668491125107,
-0.08049016445875168,
-0.1735820770263672,
-0.7200027704238892,
-0.613768994808197,
0.6531131863594055,
0.5468552112579346,
-0.7732220888137817,
0.005227858200669289,
0.20811136066913605,
0.8513184189796448,
-0.07344955205917358,
0.2918398678302765,
0.27591678500175476,
0.3908926546573639,
0.07347073405981064,
-0.7335196137428284,
0.2331921011209488,
-0.2359551638364792,
0.4167500436306,
0.21337170898914337,
-0.13811099529266357,
0.8366603255271912,
-0.2324991375207901,
-0.1991441398859024,
0.008583706803619862,
0.37392276525497437,
0.36315101385116577,
-0.1347491443157196,
0.22246034443378448,
0.06457705050706863,
0.6211073398590088,
0.022180957719683647,
1.485451340675354,
-0.5892863273620605,
0.48709291219711304,
1.0719612836837769,
-0.23631954193115234,
0.6340847015380859,
0.767066240310669,
-0.2762046456336975,
0.43744704127311707,
0.29638606309890747,
-0.2910672426223755,
-0.05453938990831375,
0.6378535032272339,
0.03436991199851036,
-0.13587641716003418,
0.17420561611652374,
-0.19505296647548676,
0.18631820380687714,
0.13545460999011993,
-0.2271978110074997,
-0.01937427930533886,
0.04611921310424805,
0.08186496049165726,
0.3096521496772766,
-0.07023007422685623,
0.6861939430236816,
0.009987035766243935,
-0.5761241316795349,
0.901414155960083,
0.05696022883057594,
1.075197696685791,
-0.4786112308502197,
0.08972384035587311,
-0.35535526275634766,
0.10581333935260773,
-0.5392159223556519,
-0.6459057331085205,
0.37634631991386414,
0.2796548008918762,
-0.019824229180812836,
-0.11033163219690323,
0.6997795701026917,
0.02489571087062359,
-0.5415717363357544,
0.1373325139284134,
0.1484418511390686,
-0.16804802417755127,
0.09678112715482712,
-0.4633116126060486,
0.3619311451911926,
0.196055606007576,
-0.46523311734199524,
0.18722376227378845,
0.3163999617099762,
0.18550196290016174,
0.6672159433364868,
0.6353713274002075,
0.18059128522872925,
0.37598279118537903,
0.08089730888605118,
0.7682546973228455,
-0.6263805627822876,
-0.3706529438495636,
-1.056728482246399,
0.49116113781929016,
0.10615278035402298,
-0.36560723185539246,
1.0659527778625488,
0.4282335638999939,
0.49768391251564026,
-0.2748306691646576,
0.6534951329231262,
-0.03068489581346512,
0.38053029775619507,
-0.5621969103813171,
0.5337608456611633,
-0.17718873918056488,
0.9121944308280945,
-0.38392171263694763,
-1.0962581634521484,
-0.786923348903656,
0.4673957824707031,
-0.09557153284549713,
-0.17815400660037994,
0.5049216151237488,
0.8815550804138184,
0.37657561898231506,
-0.019506683573126793,
0.16243557631969452,
0.22870464622974396,
0.7257934212684631,
0.14770542085170746,
0.9978175759315491,
0.0072998893447220325,
0.6189472675323486,
-0.24870601296424866,
0.019272509962320328,
-0.2892650067806244,
-1.1517727375030518,
-0.9673032164573669,
-0.2847293019294739,
-0.5149171948432922,
-0.5428341627120972,
-0.1444762945175171,
1.3081109523773193,
0.13021279871463776,
-0.8895231485366821,
-0.2173183709383011,
-0.3901708722114563,
-0.007261394988745451,
-0.05136248469352722,
-0.27187997102737427,
0.07667777687311172,
-0.6379790306091309,
-0.5311797261238098,
0.35707253217697144,
0.13871648907661438,
0.131258025765419,
-0.3027726411819458,
-0.05998016521334648,
0.16059067845344543,
0.34096530079841614,
0.37559056282043457,
0.06589934974908829,
-0.6457751393318176,
-0.11794032156467438,
0.19381259381771088,
-0.26489323377609253,
0.08590157330036163,
0.9255933165550232,
-0.7716782093048096,
0.421657919883728,
0.45384228229522705,
0.5968414545059204,
-0.047970253974199295,
-0.0763193815946579,
0.5274891257286072,
-0.9666373133659363,
0.053886134177446365,
0.4565230906009674,
0.3192121684551239,
0.2755339741706848,
-0.4268709719181061,
0.22682373225688934,
-0.018241701647639275,
-0.585037350654602,
-1.017783522605896,
0.3933105766773224,
-0.8336783051490784,
-0.24611778557300568,
1.5605379343032837,
0.12533186376094818,
-0.07323997467756271,
-0.1540389060974121,
-0.5239426493644714,
0.07310577481985092,
-0.4241647720336914,
0.8697701692581177,
0.4057013690471649,
-0.18966209888458252,
-0.14797811210155487,
-0.40206512808799744,
0.5652806758880615,
0.2178497165441513,
-0.6620765924453735,
0.023084502667188644,
0.4622628092765808,
0.28034985065460205,
0.2518165707588196,
0.14487379789352417,
-0.012842672877013683,
0.0679893046617508,
-0.08103509247303009,
0.17063193023204803,
-0.3633865416049957,
0.145075723528862,
-0.8803975582122803,
0.47857388854026794,
0.5694543719291687,
0.3178216814994812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19774v1 | Direct Preference Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-28T09:23:40 | 2024-06-28T09:23:40 | Yixing Li, Yuxian Gu, Li Dong, Dequan Wang, Yu Cheng, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the field of large language models (LLMs), Knowledge Distillation (KD) is
a critical technique for transferring capabilities from teacher models to
student models. However, existing KD methods face limitations and challenges in
distillation of LLMs, including efficiency and insufficient measurement
capabilities of traditional KL divergence. It is shown that LLMs can serve as
an implicit reward function, which we define as a supplement to KL divergence.
In this work, we propose Direct Preference Knowledge Distillation (DPKD) for
LLMs. DPKD utilizes distribution divergence to represent the preference loss
and implicit reward function. We re-formulate KD of LLMs into two stages: first
optimizing and objective consisting of implicit reward and reverse KL
divergence and then improving the preference probability of teacher outputs
over student outputs. We conducted experiments and analysis on various datasets
with LLM parameters ranging from 120M to 13B and demonstrate the broad
applicability and effectiveness of our DPKD approach. Meanwhile, we prove the
value and effectiveness of the introduced implicit reward and output preference
in KD through experiments and theoretical analysis. The DPKD method outperforms
the baseline method in both output response precision and exact match
percentage. Code and data are available at https://aka.ms/dpkd. | [
-0.3407057821750641,
-0.4404236674308777,
0.9480928778648376,
0.14903894066810608,
-0.45797398686408997,
0.11430706083774567,
-0.6041377186775208,
0.18531924486160278,
-0.18808890879154205,
0.39807185530662537,
-0.33439281582832336,
-0.5424882769584656,
-0.9030623435974121,
0.003799573751166463,
-0.22624579071998596,
0.929253101348877,
-0.2477947324514389,
0.19364742934703827,
-0.36177438497543335,
0.23563861846923828,
-0.46234560012817383,
-0.6208726763725281,
-0.7231177091598511,
-0.6801073551177979,
0.723781168460846,
0.6945188045501709,
0.24857164919376373,
0.4397716224193573,
0.2759781777858734,
0.22316020727157593,
-0.19169095158576965,
-0.11728416383266449,
-0.6198988556861877,
0.31889963150024414,
-0.14183549582958221,
-0.5212420225143433,
-0.17562338709831238,
0.08520181477069855,
0.5781362652778625,
0.9120135307312012,
-0.24371790885925293,
-0.07193443179130554,
0.4261429011821747,
1.1390190124511719,
-0.7100602984428406,
0.34117063879966736,
-0.5595967769622803,
0.14460530877113342,
-0.0517452098429203,
-0.016661901026964188,
-0.45943301916122437,
-0.7516463398933411,
0.5308303833007812,
-0.24547883868217468,
-0.029871491715312004,
-0.4829166531562805,
0.30164262652397156,
0.40306973457336426,
-0.7154484391212463,
-0.46688809990882874,
-1.0217230319976807,
0.7868229150772095,
-0.8282045125961304,
0.43715089559555054,
0.45672208070755005,
0.48302164673805237,
-0.026757624000310898,
-0.573456883430481,
-0.6881292462348938,
-0.3570598065853119,
0.005430619698017836,
-0.0008299129549413919,
0.15170074999332428,
0.04590233042836189,
0.11349904537200928,
0.4590704143047333,
-0.017380496487021446,
0.16461028158664703,
-0.2453092336654663,
0.22632063925266266,
0.6600106358528137,
0.03616033121943474,
-0.10540325939655304,
0.07456662505865097,
-0.334115207195282,
-0.46727320551872253,
-0.7418577671051025,
0.13641351461410522,
0.4735853672027588,
0.25064563751220703,
0.10192932188510895,
0.4954077899456024,
-0.35580503940582275,
0.40773648023605347,
0.2474527508020401,
-0.6144227385520935,
0.12449459731578827,
0.0037955548614263535,
-0.009634409099817276,
0.2962897717952728,
0.556236743927002,
0.19076435267925262,
0.46349310874938965,
0.09969446808099747,
-0.11603666841983795,
-0.18784362077713013,
-0.24138134717941284,
-0.8631471991539001,
-0.5062775611877441,
0.11008591204881668,
-0.16144350171089172,
-0.44420143961906433,
-0.2884922921657562,
-0.6178468465805054,
-0.6117076277732849,
-0.6800084114074707,
0.148661270737648,
-0.32846561074256897,
-0.7016843557357788,
0.350216269493103,
-0.1672229766845703,
-0.1998436450958252,
0.3039063513278961,
-1.091998815536499,
0.15588100254535675,
0.5037218332290649,
0.6345275640487671,
-0.5266522169113159,
-0.1668199747800827,
-0.13125552237033844,
0.2151091992855072,
-0.14498277008533478,
0.3891129791736603,
-0.40339937806129456,
-0.554603636264801,
0.09202073514461517,
-0.29832687973976135,
0.15686345100402832,
-0.652245819568634,
0.6810604929924011,
-0.5945819616317749,
-0.061915602535009384,
-0.46932968497276306,
-0.7432342171669006,
-0.09038642048835754,
0.07641533762216568,
-0.6467360258102417,
0.8125767707824707,
-0.04562076926231384,
-0.7191677093505859,
0.6236960887908936,
-0.4216029644012451,
-0.36163753271102905,
0.014911893755197525,
-0.04714908078312874,
-0.04568588733673096,
0.1683102697134018,
0.07700982689857483,
0.6177164912223816,
-0.03413313627243042,
0.6964841485023499,
-0.4484016001224518,
-0.09883030503988266,
0.08434165269136429,
-0.6431471109390259,
0.6332659125328064,
0.15392941236495972,
-0.19052407145500183,
-0.20275379717350006,
-0.6196540594100952,
-0.23582540452480316,
0.19657301902770996,
-0.6644316911697388,
-0.911413848400116,
0.10614793002605438,
-0.3567351698875427,
-0.06389304250478745,
0.3744826316833496,
-0.4407077133655548,
0.5627100467681885,
-0.2899160087108612,
0.24033525586128235,
1.189416766166687,
-0.09055183827877045,
0.7275387048721313,
0.22369025647640228,
0.2996925413608551,
0.2383045107126236,
0.03468557447195053,
0.21060605347156525,
-0.18917445838451385,
-0.6133483648300171,
-0.4686114192008972,
0.43948236107826233,
0.07172597944736481,
-0.8579455614089966,
0.39503592252731323,
-0.36161065101623535,
-0.40883854031562805,
-0.34664082527160645,
0.21352185308933258,
0.11476730555295944,
0.543258011341095,
0.13421043753623962,
0.22447608411312103,
-0.35176292061805725,
-0.9061393737792969,
0.07384799420833588,
-0.3416591286659241,
-0.1570022702217102,
0.43693840503692627,
0.2680666744709015,
0.11760929226875305,
1.092593789100647,
-1.0855013132095337,
-0.28504806756973267,
-0.2691548764705658,
-0.129108726978302,
0.4629267156124115,
0.2534327805042267,
0.4261939525604248,
-0.8362948298454285,
-0.942979633808136,
-0.04650621488690376,
-0.37409496307373047,
-0.2301805168390274,
0.37076786160469055,
-0.202474445104599,
0.34467175602912903,
0.20076967775821686,
-0.4075259864330292,
0.06525574624538422,
0.57295161485672,
-0.2922860085964203,
0.5744175910949707,
-0.11991766840219498,
0.22202187776565552,
-1.0626258850097656,
0.1534656435251236,
-0.08754356950521469,
-0.19629135727882385,
-0.4645906984806061,
-0.23378027975559235,
0.07506626099348068,
0.2417503148317337,
-0.4401131868362427,
0.5351629853248596,
-0.20802199840545654,
0.1476694792509079,
-0.40210404992103577,
0.03900527209043503,
-0.04164024442434311,
0.4308597445487976,
0.37364041805267334,
0.3520877957344055,
0.4848325550556183,
-0.826774537563324,
0.8119099736213684,
0.09064817428588867,
-0.46156296133995056,
0.40411376953125,
-0.5886010527610779,
0.07423549890518188,
-0.213962584733963,
0.30704283714294434,
-1.210010051727295,
0.029431771486997604,
0.18788446485996246,
-0.13726678490638733,
0.4052366316318512,
-0.42191997170448303,
-0.2927691638469696,
-0.37455523014068604,
-0.25518345832824707,
0.3219849467277527,
0.7567884922027588,
-0.8574275374412537,
0.34273892641067505,
0.0688394084572792,
-0.46546411514282227,
-0.7706112265586853,
-0.5637169480323792,
-0.25254958868026733,
-0.3180020749568939,
-0.46632373332977295,
0.20566774904727936,
-0.3021854758262634,
-0.29711389541625977,
0.1363111436367035,
-0.2256075143814087,
-0.02663365751504898,
0.09038332104682922,
0.08702506870031357,
0.4323289096355438,
-0.06766808032989502,
0.21619847416877747,
0.3769122362136841,
-0.07713105529546738,
0.07947471737861633,
-0.29778921604156494,
0.6689120531082153,
0.4301953911781311,
-0.46361199021339417,
-0.03536171838641167,
0.191372811794281,
0.5101252794265747,
0.17989487946033478,
0.7148832678794861,
0.23375332355499268,
0.015096282586455345,
-0.5132132172584534,
-0.6229567527770996,
-0.44249585270881653,
-0.5000246167182922,
0.38723474740982056,
-0.43616563081741333,
-0.8503251671791077,
0.18500341475009918,
-0.34247568249702454,
-0.047653041779994965,
0.2610752582550049,
0.6584081053733826,
0.18369045853614807,
0.9365379214286804,
0.6951833963394165,
-0.3583163619041443,
0.3541686236858368,
-0.2292817085981369,
0.19531889259815216,
-0.6643552184104919,
-0.34127119183540344,
-0.5174056887626648,
-0.44606468081474304,
-0.16431011259555817,
-0.09677407145500183,
0.4122598171234131,
0.33340349793434143,
-0.12767665088176727,
-0.22748416662216187,
-0.3766024708747864,
0.6379156112670898,
0.6671388745307922,
-0.11568605899810791,
0.6515714526176453,
0.2308693826198578,
-0.3571617901325226,
-0.17662811279296875,
-0.4666368365287781,
-0.4005834758281708,
1.362464189529419,
0.3541305661201477,
0.9266271591186523,
0.10993479192256927,
0.9257116317749023,
0.2531331479549408,
0.22653836011886597,
-0.851182758808136,
0.4599221348762512,
-0.28651323914527893,
-0.3731847405433655,
-0.47028231620788574,
-0.4399750828742981,
-0.5977781414985657,
0.25627601146698,
0.1447247713804245,
-0.401176780462265,
0.14984138309955597,
0.18614548444747925,
-0.07427224516868591,
0.2887505888938904,
-0.9187801480293274,
0.6111871004104614,
-0.05205239728093147,
-0.2900196313858032,
-0.1328137367963791,
-0.19336199760437012,
0.7260395288467407,
-0.16371777653694153,
-0.13690879940986633,
-0.19242554903030396,
0.1893436759710312,
0.6437549591064453,
-0.2651158273220062,
0.7050599455833435,
-0.5551905632019043,
-0.5971613526344299,
0.001122953137382865,
0.1888536959886551,
0.6291434168815613,
0.2794835567474365,
-0.12570858001708984,
0.0021230813581496477,
0.020518233999609947,
-0.04363987222313881,
-0.6860655546188354,
1.1575069427490234,
-0.917759120464325,
-0.897168755531311,
-0.32110998034477234,
-0.4290326237678528,
-0.2769249677658081,
0.13622982800006866,
-0.04102432355284691,
0.041441332548856735,
0.010798993520438671,
0.22831642627716064,
0.7178795337677002,
-0.062325768172740936,
0.5771861672401428,
0.8491776585578918,
-0.3674001395702362,
-0.18368078768253326,
0.7969027161598206,
0.12267488241195679,
0.4741547703742981,
0.24024255573749542,
0.5075603723526001,
-0.880424976348877,
-0.5850639343261719,
-0.3591752052307129,
0.08375922590494156,
-0.8166908025741577,
-0.04231720790266991,
-0.4489501714706421,
-0.11882210522890091,
-0.5116561651229858,
0.0016323053278028965,
-0.5477815866470337,
-0.3328871726989746,
-0.2023131400346756,
-0.17743434011936188,
0.453182578086853,
0.7100090980529785,
-0.050213634967803955,
-0.08663913607597351,
-0.4531087577342987,
0.23327253758907318,
0.6040358543395996,
0.5925449728965759,
0.22550618648529053,
-0.518089771270752,
-0.09280507266521454,
0.3442261815071106,
-0.22031764686107635,
-0.6810874938964844,
0.5026522874832153,
0.04094087332487106,
0.4925895631313324,
0.44075819849967957,
0.54400235414505,
0.28369492292404175,
-0.49560829997062683,
0.7206597924232483,
0.3055145740509033,
-0.7847186326980591,
0.4419955611228943,
-0.07560472935438156,
0.27321961522102356,
0.5450757741928101,
0.8082318305969238,
-0.6882559657096863,
-0.19548417627811432,
-0.20046785473823547,
-0.9779011011123657,
0.824229896068573,
-0.08909467607736588,
0.13507340848445892,
0.2091277688741684,
0.3987416923046112,
0.3929882049560547,
0.2485496997833252,
-0.601222813129425,
-0.6248255968093872,
0.07560158520936966,
-0.37285828590393066,
-0.39885351061820984,
-0.48095452785491943,
-0.13036446273326874,
-0.35405412316322327,
0.8674883842468262,
-0.05699069797992706,
-0.3536010682582855,
0.15952622890472412,
0.08470384776592255,
0.03942999616265297,
0.32440826296806335,
0.2731820344924927,
0.6480370759963989,
-0.2649862766265869,
0.42053836584091187,
0.0009576327865943313,
-0.6483463644981384,
0.5398246049880981,
-0.06763065606355667,
-0.13806454837322235,
-0.112043097615242,
-0.09208410978317261,
0.7406095266342163,
-0.1281425803899765,
-0.44108015298843384,
0.4644972085952759,
-0.02425251714885235,
-0.415336936712265,
-0.25320467352867126,
0.03433817997574806,
0.5231192111968994,
0.28404417634010315,
0.5922073125839233,
-0.3623325228691101,
0.19397294521331787,
-0.2780645191669464,
-0.06631708145141602,
0.19110384583473206,
-0.10493957996368408,
-0.09708236902952194,
0.2856293320655823,
0.24341200292110443,
0.20272527635097504,
0.5498507022857666,
-0.0385470911860466,
-0.40243157744407654,
0.39474213123321533,
0.48651888966560364,
0.8275421261787415,
-0.39697760343551636,
0.3591417670249939,
0.2556438744068146,
-0.21258001029491425,
-0.23572567105293274,
-0.1393120139837265,
-0.17343398928642273,
-0.8658419251441956,
-0.4690190851688385,
-0.8741375207901001,
-0.35870176553726196,
0.35706785321235657,
-0.5426010489463806,
0.371016263961792,
-0.1929299682378769,
0.02065814472734928,
0.11343880742788315,
0.12706376612186432,
-0.4461987614631653,
-0.14336541295051575,
0.361571729183197,
0.5543842911720276,
-0.924776554107666,
1.0627388954162598,
0.6276330351829529,
-0.1737814098596573,
-0.9392234683036804,
-0.0900312215089798,
-0.1418820470571518,
-0.645050585269928,
1.3350107669830322,
-0.46089068055152893,
0.05964067578315735,
0.11071109026670456,
-0.39714372158050537,
-0.7480083107948303,
1.199957013130188,
0.6508703827857971,
-0.9762043356895447,
0.2312147468328476,
0.426893025636673,
0.34555208683013916,
-0.26807937026023865,
0.15600469708442688,
0.6981137990951538,
0.568665623664856,
0.6538074016571045,
-0.8095633387565613,
0.017889024689793587,
0.040242861956357956,
0.15416933596134186,
0.12250572443008423,
-0.34061670303344727,
0.8502709269523621,
-0.061040427535772324,
-0.1884109079837799,
-0.4321238696575165,
0.30871114134788513,
0.3953517973423004,
0.21598996222019196,
0.600154459476471,
0.4635428786277771,
0.571979284286499,
-0.05607089772820473,
0.7920308113098145,
-0.19151154160499573,
0.4353833794593811,
1.0459468364715576,
-0.5855186581611633,
0.839062511920929,
0.8382622599601746,
-0.5707617402076721,
0.2334662675857544,
0.35060951113700867,
0.22109337151050568,
0.8330993056297302,
0.4074762761592865,
-0.5445449948310852,
-0.11630616337060928,
-0.13701231777668,
-0.5512334108352661,
0.030661897733807564,
-0.16144616901874542,
-0.3051896393299103,
-0.19189344346523285,
0.1452690213918686,
-0.004361746832728386,
0.14127714931964874,
-0.19913946092128754,
0.9437798857688904,
0.09160590916872025,
-0.8249043822288513,
0.718269944190979,
-0.09914486110210419,
0.7661192417144775,
-0.6847793459892273,
-0.12278328090906143,
-0.4918536841869354,
0.5584893226623535,
-0.08139288425445557,
-0.9153217077255249,
-0.04348239302635193,
-0.05078273266553879,
-0.45335954427719116,
-0.25987744331359863,
0.7727428078651428,
-0.9582255482673645,
-0.4053334593772888,
0.30543088912963867,
0.3771754205226898,
-0.06805551052093506,
-0.20064988732337952,
-0.21954873204231262,
0.10124211013317108,
0.19436223804950714,
-0.37791529297828674,
0.5319409966468811,
0.4831112027168274,
0.35607725381851196,
0.665630042552948,
0.6631874442100525,
0.30318862199783325,
0.024930868297815323,
0.18485713005065918,
1.1195242404937744,
-0.2016921490430832,
-0.4814521372318268,
-1.2415770292282104,
0.4331092834472656,
-0.07753841578960419,
-0.0008418912184424698,
0.8936922550201416,
0.4408486485481262,
0.9136935472488403,
-0.396807998418808,
1.018155813217163,
0.08802761137485504,
0.480167031288147,
-0.5130359530448914,
0.8362533450126648,
-0.3836893141269684,
0.3663178086280823,
-0.2640780508518219,
-1.1745054721832275,
0.2289522886276245,
0.30649393796920776,
-0.4908129572868347,
-0.11972444504499435,
0.6550527811050415,
0.3833625018596649,
-0.044633131474256516,
-0.08175567537546158,
0.3720702826976776,
0.1741287112236023,
0.4212566912174225,
0.7032586336135864,
1.0404694080352783,
0.03694196417927742,
0.36598190665245056,
-0.5257576107978821,
-0.22919167578220367,
-0.16759949922561646,
-1.0195776224136353,
-0.8135001063346863,
-0.7513506412506104,
-0.5007814764976501,
-0.10776899755001068,
-0.02161453478038311,
0.8164579272270203,
0.609795868396759,
-0.6211353540420532,
-0.20996131002902985,
-0.1090877503156662,
0.39334753155708313,
0.09616237133741379,
-0.2641462981700897,
0.43192028999328613,
-0.3165203034877777,
-1.062339186668396,
0.1127910315990448,
-0.08681720495223999,
0.11786056309938431,
-0.5081982612609863,
-0.40927621722221375,
-0.09841211140155792,
-0.10531050711870193,
0.6334575414657593,
-0.12929269671440125,
-0.6047267913818359,
-0.1743127554655075,
-0.21526826918125153,
-0.057412438094615936,
-0.35348549485206604,
0.8321003317832947,
-0.653685450553894,
0.3170353174209595,
0.5462433695793152,
0.4756787419319153,
0.6465085744857788,
-0.2143528312444687,
0.6975654363632202,
-0.8929821848869324,
0.1552516669034958,
0.1454160511493683,
0.15795250236988068,
0.13402563333511353,
-0.3642861545085907,
0.31988614797592163,
0.24378536641597748,
-0.4548366069793701,
-0.9204767346382141,
0.15359488129615784,
-0.7440034747123718,
-0.4251026213169098,
1.5865840911865234,
-0.381779283285141,
-0.058954428881406784,
0.06764401495456696,
-0.44113022089004517,
0.1664331704378128,
-0.6962544918060303,
0.7359507083892822,
0.9355568289756775,
0.3421599268913269,
0.001266682636924088,
-0.26592209935188293,
0.8218334913253784,
0.24885378777980804,
-0.32085272669792175,
0.32416272163391113,
0.5705170035362244,
0.5364177227020264,
-0.1457347869873047,
0.6717928051948547,
-0.0530221126973629,
-0.16685904562473297,
-0.21920347213745117,
0.26703065633773804,
-0.4271010160446167,
-0.24105866253376007,
-0.37930598855018616,
0.22547273337841034,
0.3624570965766907,
-0.0857064425945282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19764v1 | Belief Revision: The Adaptability of Large Language Models Reasoning | 2024-06-28T09:09:36 | 2024-06-28T09:09:36 | Bryan Wilie, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Etsuko Ishii, Junxian He, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capability to reason from text is crucial for real-world NLP
applications. Real-world scenarios often involve incomplete or evolving data.
In response, individuals update their beliefs and understandings accordingly.
However, most existing evaluations assume that language models (LMs) operate
with consistent information. We introduce Belief-R, a new dataset designed to
test LMs' belief revision ability when presented with new evidence. Inspired by
how humans suppress prior inferences, this task assesses LMs within the newly
proposed delta reasoning ($\Delta R$) framework. Belief-R features sequences of
premises designed to simulate scenarios where additional information could
necessitate prior conclusions drawn by LMs. We evaluate $\sim$30 LMs across
diverse prompting strategies and found that LMs generally struggle to
appropriately revise their beliefs in response to new information. Further,
models adept at updating often underperformed in scenarios without necessary
updates, highlighting a critical trade-off. These insights underscore the
importance of improving LMs' adaptiveness to changing information, a step
toward more reliable AI systems. | [
-0.4222870469093323,
-0.5766450762748718,
0.8462517857551575,
0.050845447927713394,
-0.05788999795913696,
-0.26456692814826965,
-0.38188573718070984,
-0.4564681649208069,
-0.013965314254164696,
0.56898432970047,
-0.697136640548706,
-0.22778865694999695,
-0.462685227394104,
0.26757097244262695,
-0.10994108766317368,
0.7097849249839783,
-0.10710622370243073,
-0.052699774503707886,
-0.05494936183094978,
-0.053548913449048996,
-0.7839637994766235,
-0.46133744716644287,
-0.7770351767539978,
-0.5986709594726562,
0.5484836101531982,
0.37738102674484253,
0.8905121088027954,
0.3345296084880829,
0.3118542730808258,
0.16738207638263702,
-0.06742797046899796,
0.03539304807782173,
-0.19854824244976044,
0.7217645645141602,
-0.4647972583770752,
-0.9474508762359619,
-0.3787630498409271,
-0.22170639038085938,
0.7038503885269165,
0.5875201225280762,
-0.19501736760139465,
-0.21337376534938812,
-0.06831137090921402,
0.7898485660552979,
-0.5695450901985168,
0.10618972778320312,
-1.14374840259552,
0.08634679764509201,
0.3787548542022705,
-0.11314717680215836,
-0.8874871730804443,
-0.46215343475341797,
0.3167257308959961,
-0.5359257459640503,
0.4213695228099823,
0.06882468611001968,
0.804219126701355,
0.5721626877784729,
-0.16475196182727814,
-0.334218829870224,
-0.8642404675483704,
0.6845445036888123,
-0.994087278842926,
0.7146044969558716,
0.5177778005599976,
0.3779667317867279,
-0.4699395000934601,
-0.6804642081260681,
-0.8518269062042236,
-0.28486886620521545,
0.19437839090824127,
-0.03250433877110481,
-0.1205076053738594,
-0.09663166850805283,
0.36267754435539246,
0.13923904299736023,
-0.3332335650920868,
-0.00921744853258133,
0.030652225017547607,
0.059151530265808105,
0.4313693344593048,
-0.025880450382828712,
0.07421895861625671,
0.019555194303393364,
0.08334898948669434,
-0.58013516664505,
-0.8428353667259216,
-0.1028595119714737,
0.16193610429763794,
0.29844966530799866,
0.19657886028289795,
0.4750671684741974,
-0.2517887353897095,
0.7885005474090576,
0.12694013118743896,
-0.03612761199474335,
0.11919647455215454,
-0.03382018581032753,
-0.4968195855617523,
-0.04876545071601868,
0.3429841995239258,
0.5452461242675781,
0.20445482432842255,
0.11957735568284988,
-0.4194411635398865,
0.1077478677034378,
0.33859163522720337,
-0.44960731267929077,
-0.2704285681247711,
0.38506826758384705,
-0.39259448647499084,
0.06161065772175789,
-0.12871278822422028,
-0.7084380388259888,
-0.7667620778083801,
-0.319805383682251,
0.2893643379211426,
-0.6630635261535645,
-0.43493834137916565,
0.6318898797035217,
-0.2220848649740219,
-0.03165501356124878,
1.0300990343093872,
-0.929324746131897,
-0.10931932926177979,
0.7453934550285339,
0.47593235969543457,
0.08371251076459885,
-0.3103224039077759,
-0.059604328125715256,
-0.10012968629598618,
-0.6966534852981567,
0.9435943961143494,
-0.5627037286758423,
-0.2714003622531891,
-0.013084137812256813,
0.15673092007637024,
-0.1964685320854187,
-0.6222164034843445,
0.9295861124992371,
-0.6623716354370117,
0.1821862757205963,
-0.6512631177902222,
-0.8027209639549255,
-0.3216223120689392,
0.399284303188324,
-0.605431079864502,
0.7449020147323608,
-0.07718700170516968,
-0.708541750907898,
0.7340627908706665,
-0.486991286277771,
-0.04294626787304878,
-0.19798187911510468,
-0.000926005479414016,
-0.3683057427406311,
0.15938033163547516,
0.17670461535453796,
0.16520191729068756,
-0.12149494886398315,
0.13012172281742096,
-0.5739230513572693,
-0.08859514445066452,
0.3586863875389099,
-0.5493872165679932,
0.3874574303627014,
0.3200690448284149,
-0.12163999676704407,
0.23345215618610382,
-0.49716636538505554,
0.07523830980062485,
-0.06102948635816574,
-0.24190367758274078,
-0.486320436000824,
0.6396576166152954,
-0.4034554958343506,
0.12349675595760345,
-0.11669635027647018,
-0.5184047222137451,
0.6327700018882751,
-0.5013653635978699,
0.160667285323143,
0.8005093932151794,
0.25812774896621704,
0.38229334354400635,
-0.6001780033111572,
0.46025851368904114,
-0.047894857823848724,
0.11917044967412949,
-0.3655961751937866,
-0.7237368822097778,
-1.07954740524292,
0.21903041005134583,
0.24285604059696198,
0.41648802161216736,
-0.6326795816421509,
0.2887735366821289,
-0.22804401814937592,
-0.38809826970100403,
-0.5043300986289978,
-0.18399325013160706,
-0.09806124120950699,
0.3884200155735016,
0.561632513999939,
0.10640870034694672,
-0.9004931449890137,
-0.7395859360694885,
-0.5288276672363281,
-0.5490961074829102,
-0.28299760818481445,
0.04168936610221863,
0.537521243095398,
-0.47998079657554626,
1.0869625806808472,
-0.3982207179069519,
0.08931785821914673,
-0.241681307554245,
0.14398029446601868,
0.2827456593513489,
0.4049760103225708,
0.455267071723938,
-0.7934232354164124,
-0.22529110312461853,
-0.0037372210063040257,
-0.6933544874191284,
0.09527269750833511,
-0.5798525810241699,
0.24010664224624634,
0.3682084083557129,
0.3654947280883789,
-0.6402970552444458,
0.5899971723556519,
0.5783851742744446,
-0.40259823203086853,
0.6146818399429321,
-0.2932550013065338,
0.21302133798599243,
-0.9627721309661865,
-0.33743029832839966,
0.19067399203777313,
-0.25149229168891907,
-0.4132285714149475,
0.17773686349391937,
0.06525720655918121,
0.3163990378379822,
0.06084184721112251,
0.5570576190948486,
-0.3864160478115082,
0.04451349750161171,
-0.36810824275016785,
0.05011394992470741,
-0.07874703407287598,
0.14242810010910034,
0.3814513087272644,
0.5249825119972229,
0.386515736579895,
-0.8499931693077087,
0.2435009628534317,
0.25958114862442017,
-0.4605615437030792,
0.24559488892555237,
-0.5707752704620361,
0.1494380533695221,
-0.3640845715999603,
0.5044735074043274,
-0.7989080548286438,
-0.29060301184654236,
0.15222392976284027,
-0.5074358582496643,
0.1112075075507164,
-0.32561245560646057,
-0.2932337820529938,
-0.21271353960037231,
0.04042452201247215,
-0.03946147859096527,
0.5110777616500854,
-0.4556983411312103,
0.7720829844474792,
0.13982757925987244,
-0.37399816513061523,
-0.6634165644645691,
-0.6454998850822449,
0.34958207607269287,
0.033872202038764954,
-0.4135391116142273,
0.19427421689033508,
-0.3008178174495697,
-0.7239566445350647,
0.12106513231992722,
-0.21702872216701508,
-0.0018009818159043789,
-0.05658436566591263,
0.08778990060091019,
0.3030688762664795,
-0.3548830449581146,
0.2237301468849182,
0.042680010199546814,
0.07567275315523148,
0.1279229074716568,
-0.3386850953102112,
0.3705124855041504,
0.010968501679599285,
-0.5458440184593201,
-0.3321506381034851,
-0.06439144909381866,
0.5264949202537537,
0.2629028856754303,
0.7486780881881714,
-0.028904831036925316,
-0.5217897891998291,
-0.42848557233810425,
-0.6003336906433105,
-0.26768621802330017,
-0.4368516504764557,
0.4285687506198883,
-0.453491747379303,
-0.815971314907074,
0.36114850640296936,
-0.07012408971786499,
0.5300132632255554,
0.408639520406723,
0.6921442151069641,
-0.19400633871555328,
0.920647919178009,
0.4785877466201782,
0.2468709647655487,
0.3528086245059967,
0.31592097878456116,
0.21319684386253357,
-0.6317736506462097,
-0.05155498906970024,
-0.5240575671195984,
0.018331510946154594,
-0.4365774989128113,
-0.7133103013038635,
0.08776874840259552,
0.23440906405448914,
-0.058086466044187546,
0.22610561549663544,
-0.25622615218162537,
0.3474051356315613,
0.25162145495414734,
0.1317015439271927,
0.19177648425102234,
-0.2960963547229767,
-0.09402255713939667,
-0.20110327005386353,
-0.547137439250946,
-0.6897058486938477,
0.9843514561653137,
0.5640638470649719,
0.9169936776161194,
0.289993017911911,
0.25278136134147644,
0.5905706882476807,
0.598868727684021,
-0.8960626721382141,
0.3736048936843872,
0.31200292706489563,
-0.6031026840209961,
-0.26547133922576904,
-0.2577417194843292,
-0.6363479495048523,
0.3304348587989807,
-0.5374978184700012,
-0.5697110295295715,
0.354139506816864,
0.4991936981678009,
-0.23787903785705566,
0.46221044659614563,
-0.8094627261161804,
0.6098719835281372,
0.24236033856868744,
-0.05424395948648453,
-0.387340247631073,
-0.4114397466182709,
0.24320389330387115,
-0.3827441930770874,
0.1595107465982437,
0.07861210405826569,
0.19091938436031342,
0.4386487901210785,
-0.31926393508911133,
0.9172448515892029,
-0.313749760389328,
-0.3175986707210541,
0.19589732587337494,
0.3430815041065216,
0.6612353920936584,
0.08779849857091904,
-0.4398025870323181,
-0.25280728936195374,
0.1687697023153305,
-0.13029152154922485,
-0.9945931434631348,
0.4324585795402527,
-0.4791027009487152,
-0.9386557936668396,
-0.5081536769866943,
-0.5389970541000366,
-0.5011069178581238,
0.025583257898688316,
0.12131984531879425,
0.08481981605291367,
-0.2150174379348755,
0.4075384736061096,
0.9163476824760437,
-0.3594176471233368,
0.21962587535381317,
0.4924991726875305,
-0.5355560183525085,
-0.2141893059015274,
0.2929341793060303,
-0.14734408259391785,
0.5283079743385315,
0.4067375063896179,
0.22632203996181488,
-0.4618493616580963,
-0.6888707876205444,
-0.362161248922348,
0.016778307035565376,
-1.0091361999511719,
0.003767547430470586,
-0.4723559021949768,
0.07972913235425949,
-0.46622616052627563,
-0.056572701781988144,
-0.3529820144176483,
-0.4599567651748657,
0.07649601250886917,
-0.15718284249305725,
0.34388238191604614,
0.9875805377960205,
-0.0798330157995224,
0.004610425792634487,
-0.6217223405838013,
0.3155056834220886,
0.26329731941223145,
0.24810664355754852,
0.026496412232518196,
-0.7595616579055786,
-0.06632939726114273,
0.5457930564880371,
-0.06783734261989594,
-0.942907989025116,
0.3152329921722412,
0.13656190037727356,
0.602455198764801,
0.0684225782752037,
0.3445330858230591,
0.4751659631729126,
-0.5874762535095215,
0.7250832319259644,
0.05678845942020416,
-0.8060019612312317,
0.6565189957618713,
-0.26199373602867126,
0.23753784596920013,
0.3330691456794739,
0.3183709383010864,
-0.9363664984703064,
-0.425567626953125,
-0.43244868516921997,
-0.4355168044567108,
0.4215868413448334,
-0.07426062226295471,
-0.045801032334566116,
0.12094980478286743,
0.7243478894233704,
0.15105484426021576,
-0.07842229306697845,
-0.6680367588996887,
-0.27689117193222046,
-0.4882832467556,
-0.20505042374134064,
-0.026337748393416405,
-0.2705788314342499,
0.0016149827279150486,
-0.3083915710449219,
0.8123611211776733,
-0.2580491602420807,
0.28687387704849243,
0.4784170985221863,
0.05093362554907799,
-0.14046601951122284,
0.5245476365089417,
0.886250376701355,
0.8971861600875854,
-0.40167638659477234,
0.08661108464002609,
0.2769857347011566,
-0.43782660365104675,
0.1609078049659729,
-0.2780998647212982,
-0.5128294825553894,
0.1737154722213745,
0.3975330591201782,
1.009444236755371,
0.028653379529714584,
-0.6146507859230042,
0.18115471303462982,
-0.40487152338027954,
-0.18810167908668518,
-0.4482152462005615,
0.24848899245262146,
0.107545405626297,
0.0777929350733757,
0.5575299263000488,
0.875028669834137,
-0.38532036542892456,
-0.7537000775337219,
0.381290078163147,
-0.010523250326514244,
-0.46753138303756714,
-0.4228774607181549,
0.5111274123191833,
-0.3679957389831543,
-0.37088489532470703,
0.26910656690597534,
-0.1584993302822113,
-0.49480804800987244,
0.3227652311325073,
0.5645977854728699,
0.780185878276825,
-0.40857595205307007,
0.1534828394651413,
0.5352914333343506,
0.5144398212432861,
-0.43729132413864136,
0.1377655267715454,
0.44616463780403137,
-1.426722764968872,
-0.6204431653022766,
-0.4925752878189087,
-0.7380314469337463,
0.17386548221111298,
-0.6515544652938843,
0.2768757939338684,
-0.6185228824615479,
-0.2337634116411209,
-0.0679304301738739,
-0.4658111035823822,
-0.38879337906837463,
0.5597651600837708,
-0.05554159730672836,
1.2070965766906738,
-0.7564953565597534,
1.1171929836273193,
0.5799365043640137,
-0.3482956290245056,
-0.6983358263969421,
0.5449413657188416,
0.011468015611171722,
-0.6622079610824585,
0.570518970489502,
-0.35455620288848877,
-0.010920032858848572,
-0.244750514626503,
-0.547842264175415,
-0.7420259118080139,
0.6394557952880859,
0.5126519799232483,
-0.6663597822189331,
-0.012498889118432999,
-0.19599780440330505,
0.6474636793136597,
-0.375110000371933,
0.077596515417099,
0.3573165237903595,
0.6026170253753662,
0.17853593826293945,
-0.7688424587249756,
-0.10008104145526886,
-0.025278965011239052,
-0.20629677176475525,
0.008531102910637856,
-0.07358045876026154,
0.871803879737854,
-0.515943169593811,
-0.0818868950009346,
0.04750203341245651,
0.8585899472236633,
0.6014878153800964,
0.062247976660728455,
0.8331224322319031,
0.5415674448013306,
1.0188672542572021,
-0.13891196250915527,
1.067569375038147,
-0.04811875522136688,
0.3882474899291992,
1.3876184225082397,
-0.5992332696914673,
1.3538951873779297,
0.3606397807598114,
-0.10899668186903,
0.817480742931366,
0.741273045539856,
0.15115207433700562,
0.4616338908672333,
-0.033874887973070145,
-0.28801149129867554,
-0.48708099126815796,
0.06514637172222137,
-0.4074280261993408,
0.19018074870109558,
0.4965011477470398,
-0.24224689602851868,
0.015726996585726738,
-0.15307565033435822,
0.1003013476729393,
0.17360660433769226,
-0.15918797254562378,
0.5392007231712341,
0.014729287475347519,
-1.0948039293289185,
0.7133222818374634,
0.04368436709046364,
0.4943651258945465,
-0.6650998592376709,
-0.3903336822986603,
-0.04245441034436226,
0.43979954719543457,
-0.11229924112558365,
-0.9476113319396973,
0.40436825156211853,
-0.05310004949569702,
-0.39824923872947693,
-0.33387666940689087,
0.6257135272026062,
-0.20296211540699005,
-0.2501508891582489,
0.1623094230890274,
0.23909848928451538,
-0.17058591544628143,
-0.05959727242588997,
-0.8239411115646362,
0.3093058168888092,
0.3938380181789398,
-0.3112534284591675,
0.22260306775569916,
0.5612586736679077,
-0.030757125467061996,
1.0546215772628784,
0.6697660684585571,
0.32587867975234985,
-0.04693674296140671,
0.2505413889884949,
0.7865689992904663,
-0.6696748733520508,
-0.363655149936676,
-0.675115168094635,
0.16594362258911133,
-0.014805976301431656,
-0.2429792732000351,
0.8246897459030151,
0.25648584961891174,
0.7831138372421265,
-0.06656476110219955,
1.182090163230896,
0.09914066642522812,
0.7861052751541138,
-0.8318583369255066,
0.5626397132873535,
-0.3940701484680176,
0.40459108352661133,
-0.31735897064208984,
-0.7350636720657349,
-0.20612381398677826,
0.9477067589759827,
-0.3403761088848114,
-0.0006294923950918019,
0.8945972323417664,
0.5682202577590942,
0.23462432622909546,
0.5223516225814819,
0.33102694153785706,
0.5655040740966797,
0.3617905080318451,
0.31308597326278687,
1.000227928161621,
-0.5508356094360352,
-0.021089600399136543,
0.15696024894714355,
-0.12368644028902054,
-0.08586082607507706,
-1.1201422214508057,
-0.5443970561027527,
-0.6682106852531433,
-0.4308653175830841,
-0.6458277106285095,
0.008327096700668335,
1.1338149309158325,
0.5015661716461182,
-1.007515788078308,
0.024159887805581093,
-0.22544272243976593,
0.1938709020614624,
-0.3511720895767212,
-0.2141740918159485,
0.05495915189385414,
-0.21337996423244476,
-0.4907616972923279,
0.770435094833374,
0.08953060209751129,
0.09564879536628723,
-0.24134059250354767,
-0.3305937945842743,
-0.24870282411575317,
0.19530226290225983,
0.3925180733203888,
0.47645124793052673,
-1.0609204769134521,
-0.7869740724563599,
0.019802791997790337,
0.1346932351589203,
0.07033830136060715,
0.8094050288200378,
-0.8065311908721924,
0.571780800819397,
0.49750494956970215,
0.6047654151916504,
0.3570261299610138,
-0.13307270407676697,
0.967161238193512,
-0.4804156720638275,
0.12488490343093872,
0.4169164299964905,
0.7323615550994873,
0.44924238324165344,
-0.03978341817855835,
0.3593197762966156,
0.3800419867038727,
-0.6168837547302246,
-0.9372955560684204,
0.46119019389152527,
-0.7095566987991333,
-0.5238989591598511,
1.1292916536331177,
-0.28479084372520447,
-0.09231170266866684,
-0.444736123085022,
-0.2308969348669052,
-0.13177481293678284,
-0.33855223655700684,
0.714077889919281,
0.9405685663223267,
-0.028881702572107315,
-0.48461756110191345,
-0.6250950694084167,
0.6851662993431091,
0.44458502531051636,
-0.5678220391273499,
0.5466364622116089,
0.5061148405075073,
0.3559466302394867,
0.15368779003620148,
0.7138996720314026,
0.22666889429092407,
0.18036967515945435,
0.14203941822052002,
0.2045634239912033,
0.43118658661842346,
-0.2007751315832138,
-0.26323646306991577,
-0.02377951703965664,
0.5391256809234619,
0.42109429836273193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19760v1 | Learning Interpretable Legal Case Retrieval via Knowledge-Guided Case Reformulation | 2024-06-28T08:59:45 | 2024-06-28T08:59:45 | Chenlong Deng, Kelong Mao, Zhicheng Dou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Legal case retrieval for sourcing similar cases is critical in upholding
judicial fairness. Different from general web search, legal case retrieval
involves processing lengthy, complex, and highly specialized legal documents.
Existing methods in this domain often overlook the incorporation of legal
expert knowledge, which is crucial for accurately understanding and modeling
legal cases, leading to unsatisfactory retrieval performance. This paper
introduces KELLER, a legal knowledge-guided case reformulation approach based
on large language models (LLMs) for effective and interpretable legal case
retrieval. By incorporating professional legal knowledge about crimes and law
articles, we enable large language models to accurately reformulate the
original legal case into concise sub-facts of crimes, which contain the
essential information of the case. Extensive experiments on two legal case
retrieval benchmarks demonstrate superior retrieval performance and robustness
on complex legal case queries of KELLER over existing methods. | [
-0.03666737303137779,
-0.7101773619651794,
1.1325314044952393,
-0.20806054770946503,
-0.4712901711463928,
-0.14638595283031464,
-0.22685934603214264,
-0.3435174524784088,
0.2029542624950409,
1.008512020111084,
-0.19015942513942719,
-0.7614532709121704,
-0.5650733113288879,
-0.09307420998811722,
-0.5460787415504456,
1.0661295652389526,
0.1007368192076683,
0.277267724275589,
-0.13010278344154358,
-0.29550424218177795,
-0.3052905797958374,
-0.4121321439743042,
-0.5248796343803406,
-0.23962555825710297,
0.508976936340332,
0.29807454347610474,
0.40123802423477173,
0.5731467604637146,
0.737811267375946,
0.3000686764717102,
-0.3320147395133972,
-0.2558082640171051,
-0.532375693321228,
0.2003604918718338,
-0.16300982236862183,
-0.7947224378585815,
-0.5426279902458191,
-0.18639922142028809,
0.1427965760231018,
0.38451942801475525,
-0.8220645189285278,
0.10226793587207794,
-0.5035021305084229,
0.6858383417129517,
-0.7498303055763245,
0.3149683475494385,
-0.8212451338768005,
0.24394173920154572,
-0.4411555230617523,
-0.2563477158546448,
-0.6243939995765686,
-0.6012824177742004,
-0.019702265039086342,
-0.9176089763641357,
0.4316062331199646,
0.2104453295469284,
0.31081855297088623,
0.2613295614719391,
-0.9711165428161621,
-0.47989901900291443,
-0.6215078830718994,
0.6639443635940552,
-0.9625123739242554,
0.5332120656967163,
0.2531413435935974,
1.1332316398620605,
-0.2884773015975952,
-1.3042144775390625,
-0.6955382227897644,
-0.2616288661956787,
-0.18965107202529907,
-0.06608782708644867,
-0.2785501778125763,
0.2912508547306061,
0.39600270986557007,
-0.09513036906719208,
-0.4110569953918457,
-0.30807167291641235,
-0.5607548356056213,
-0.3477661609649658,
0.6898971796035767,
0.08719689399003983,
0.2780531346797943,
-0.22188009321689606,
-0.027088038623332977,
-0.1011723205447197,
-0.8135940432548523,
0.13274700939655304,
0.4970884919166565,
0.4936336278915405,
0.36487260460853577,
0.5433761477470398,
-0.1549835354089737,
0.743439793586731,
-0.09972665458917618,
-0.4221762716770172,
0.18949826061725616,
0.10162018239498138,
-0.2945234775543213,
0.24026700854301453,
0.3527163863182068,
0.2882678806781769,
0.3032063841819763,
-0.2487512230873108,
-0.5457653999328613,
-0.9144116044044495,
0.5735170245170593,
-0.5631240010261536,
0.07780066132545471,
0.14783237874507904,
-0.5309405326843262,
-0.03638928383588791,
0.5372841358184814,
-0.6241205334663391,
-0.3746381103992462,
-0.403640478849411,
0.24872919917106628,
-0.30633485317230225,
-0.012461259961128235,
0.23829258978366852,
-0.2409953773021698,
0.23017916083335876,
0.615345299243927,
-0.5843919515609741,
0.1891983300447464,
0.8585696816444397,
0.13062383234500885,
0.27189770340919495,
0.32975366711616516,
-1.171736240386963,
0.39026975631713867,
-0.15080057084560394,
0.43191149830818176,
-0.7600621581077576,
-0.11886820942163467,
0.306539922952652,
0.18464547395706177,
0.47308647632598877,
-0.7815638780593872,
0.9754474759101868,
-1.3262009620666504,
-0.24891404807567596,
-0.28211480379104614,
-0.44567230343818665,
-0.6050437092781067,
0.306569367647171,
-0.7233531475067139,
0.16293171048164368,
-0.05403144285082817,
-0.42537298798561096,
0.7264053821563721,
-0.5811564326286316,
-0.738655149936676,
0.2527734041213989,
-0.030099542811512947,
-0.48889607191085815,
0.14873887598514557,
0.24394471943378448,
0.4121982753276825,
0.14597122371196747,
0.7117869853973389,
-0.24333126842975616,
-0.31345364451408386,
-0.23906639218330383,
0.026296986266970634,
0.7360312938690186,
0.3459632396697998,
0.0034391540102660656,
-0.020855853334069252,
-0.512590765953064,
-0.2604719400405884,
0.04773535206913948,
-0.5665841698646545,
-0.47027474641799927,
-0.11493111401796341,
-0.09588401764631271,
-0.1170738935470581,
0.0529068186879158,
-0.6984943747520447,
0.11315055936574936,
-0.015580764040350914,
0.2938055992126465,
0.5998174548149109,
-0.023723658174276352,
0.3587547242641449,
-0.1367965191602707,
0.6871427297592163,
0.2846336364746094,
0.3674435615539551,
0.050658486783504486,
-0.39141109585762024,
-0.45004817843437195,
-0.0634319931268692,
0.4565213620662689,
0.34367769956588745,
-0.7226697206497192,
-0.09927587956190109,
-0.41441425681114197,
-0.1072407141327858,
-0.7923643589019775,
0.20991890132427216,
0.17636166512966156,
0.5685980319976807,
0.6922279596328735,
0.03024664707481861,
-0.6636883616447449,
-1.1237359046936035,
-0.7764940857887268,
0.12253234535455704,
-0.02126189135015011,
0.46029379963874817,
0.6444799900054932,
-0.39721259474754333,
1.0898796319961548,
-0.5310938358306885,
-0.5775502324104309,
-0.19192028045654297,
0.07688330113887787,
0.373043417930603,
-0.03675203397870064,
0.31209662556648254,
-1.0759867429733276,
-0.6274685859680176,
0.17669200897216797,
-0.7237381935119629,
-0.03671194240450859,
0.2456486076116562,
0.15986193716526031,
0.05301714688539505,
1.0055536031723022,
-0.3844495117664337,
0.4192374050617218,
-0.2949718236923218,
-0.6066926717758179,
0.4626438617706299,
-0.2397286295890808,
0.16466061770915985,
-0.7807819247245789,
-0.04833849146962166,
-0.08360926806926727,
-0.7458339333534241,
-0.49425172805786133,
0.4031361937522888,
0.3612043559551239,
0.3934476375579834,
-0.7708232402801514,
0.4509862959384918,
-0.36770376563072205,
-0.2330617606639862,
-0.09930761903524399,
0.4243709444999695,
0.0807000920176506,
0.2035563439130783,
-0.5040833950042725,
0.5511976480484009,
0.057974062860012054,
-0.4752482771873474,
0.5485085844993591,
0.15362943708896637,
-0.6855018138885498,
0.7197908163070679,
-0.34338846802711487,
-0.13412132859230042,
-0.6133843064308167,
0.3130612373352051,
-0.28539153933525085,
-0.22202305495738983,
-0.10512229055166245,
0.12439661473035812,
0.5177029967308044,
-0.5363489985466003,
-0.5953730940818787,
-0.24485532939434052,
-0.060423433780670166,
0.6057894825935364,
0.5984863042831421,
-0.48072344064712524,
0.7237229347229004,
0.5469170808792114,
-0.22110487520694733,
-0.8017003536224365,
-0.5296652913093567,
0.07221300154924393,
-0.2831912636756897,
-0.2873872220516205,
0.3743915855884552,
0.3134572207927704,
-0.5088362693786621,
0.22400341928005219,
-0.034807201474905014,
-0.03026445023715496,
-0.2479356974363327,
-0.04199864715337753,
-0.31900957226753235,
-0.28101110458374023,
0.40030965209007263,
0.28126147389411926,
0.17434793710708618,
0.05940208211541176,
0.057974860072135925,
0.39002567529678345,
0.1435365080833435,
-0.6156957745552063,
-0.34649479389190674,
0.2966468334197998,
0.5175977349281311,
-0.014328262768685818,
0.32648971676826477,
0.35098281502723694,
-0.11105267703533173,
-0.19850338995456696,
-0.9839948415756226,
-0.3895682394504547,
-0.38980042934417725,
0.2782123386859894,
-0.5624510049819946,
-0.9928732514381409,
0.5919336676597595,
-0.007543615531176329,
0.0741555467247963,
0.4710782468318939,
0.10607170313596725,
-0.07675914466381073,
0.6434212923049927,
0.7022454142570496,
0.12213259935379028,
0.46053698658943176,
-0.04680996760725975,
0.38877105712890625,
-0.8266326785087585,
-0.6540810465812683,
-0.38775455951690674,
-0.11220826953649521,
-0.20111197233200073,
-0.36669519543647766,
0.5502713918685913,
0.1004197746515274,
-0.27598249912261963,
0.22919292747974396,
0.013955219648778439,
0.5144379734992981,
0.6151028275489807,
0.3633410632610321,
0.9394371509552002,
0.14962340891361237,
-0.3252931237220764,
-0.03254479169845581,
-0.48955079913139343,
-0.42779096961021423,
1.5816385746002197,
0.07696318626403809,
0.507103681564331,
0.5747407078742981,
0.6286859512329102,
0.5578615069389343,
0.5911902189254761,
-0.8442674875259399,
0.46996307373046875,
-0.19447371363639832,
-0.5278274416923523,
-0.38312825560569763,
-0.596468985080719,
-1.0073484182357788,
0.25967729091644287,
-0.06772402673959732,
-0.4426925480365753,
-0.1003524512052536,
-0.344685435295105,
-0.336003839969635,
0.24438795447349548,
-0.44193586707115173,
0.45101916790008545,
0.19327743351459503,
-0.06147117540240288,
-0.4958464503288269,
-0.46267691254615784,
0.5200639963150024,
-0.3905031383037567,
0.5838965177536011,
0.13341651856899261,
0.14702056348323822,
0.7065322399139404,
-0.7075497508049011,
0.5274911522865295,
-0.24957114458084106,
-0.05773628130555153,
0.18000106513500214,
0.13214120268821716,
0.6850900650024414,
0.08004983514547348,
-0.2903972566127777,
-0.3106600344181061,
0.15021303296089172,
-0.28269654512405396,
-1.1886019706726074,
0.4388122260570526,
-0.2670520544052124,
-1.3347691297531128,
-0.1451181322336197,
-0.6726685166358948,
0.049619778990745544,
0.2052060216665268,
-0.26577994227409363,
0.20794294774532318,
0.028165046125650406,
0.17957037687301636,
0.47407442331314087,
-0.038208987563848495,
0.27227023243904114,
1.1227492094039917,
-0.2100052535533905,
-0.29512953758239746,
0.5612764954566956,
0.17248757183551788,
-0.330910861492157,
0.42143112421035767,
0.1052599623799324,
-0.5214266180992126,
-0.5858538746833801,
-0.2321084588766098,
0.37285712361335754,
-0.9277042746543884,
-0.40544530749320984,
-0.7307257056236267,
0.02697574719786644,
-0.5969710350036621,
-0.08121518790721893,
-0.09773056954145432,
-0.3347090780735016,
0.18129019439220428,
-0.05401816591620445,
0.45768797397613525,
0.8787733316421509,
0.0961451455950737,
0.051577210426330566,
-0.7392348647117615,
0.2662639021873474,
0.6861976981163025,
0.4792974889278412,
-0.055893585085868835,
-0.9315242767333984,
0.028270971029996872,
-0.022634128108620644,
-0.1892794668674469,
-0.600920557975769,
0.1562178134918213,
-0.08696512877941132,
0.7490300536155701,
0.5996407866477966,
0.42734265327453613,
0.6531329154968262,
-0.7751215100288391,
0.29669907689094543,
0.1158522367477417,
-0.8005272746086121,
0.6611883640289307,
-0.20034398138523102,
-0.2114170491695404,
0.6697977781295776,
0.1415838748216629,
-0.37636080384254456,
-0.308784157037735,
-0.39656588435173035,
-0.8104472756385803,
0.78730708360672,
0.11580014228820801,
0.2618963420391083,
0.333465039730072,
0.7953664660453796,
0.19727252423763275,
0.39666226506233215,
-0.6714291572570801,
0.2498445212841034,
0.11978242546319962,
-0.26520609855651855,
-0.07672443240880966,
-0.35809072852134705,
-0.5109338760375977,
-0.6021526455879211,
0.6481178402900696,
0.03902805596590042,
0.00882712285965681,
0.17385539412498474,
-0.3205305337905884,
0.04163544997572899,
0.37623053789138794,
0.7246100306510925,
0.5564820766448975,
-0.2648777961730957,
0.11615070700645447,
0.14257557690143585,
-0.5261204838752747,
0.17298118770122528,
-0.06543991714715958,
-0.26557645201683044,
-0.02794266678392887,
0.43737202882766724,
0.6359536051750183,
0.010036052204668522,
-0.7138522267341614,
0.7427543997764587,
-0.2005613148212433,
-0.2784983813762665,
-0.33984971046447754,
0.12687715888023376,
-0.10475125163793564,
0.6858407258987427,
0.618302583694458,
-0.284298300743103,
0.4729362428188324,
-0.7645165920257568,
0.4484959840774536,
0.5490207672119141,
-0.6524277925491333,
0.22601978480815887,
0.607704758644104,
0.11233878880739212,
-0.442078560590744,
0.6136729717254639,
-0.1563117802143097,
-0.38057494163513184,
0.6748650670051575,
0.4406101703643799,
0.48395925760269165,
-0.030458243563771248,
0.31719034910202026,
0.010149387642741203,
0.07824550569057465,
-0.5409513711929321,
0.2215660959482193,
-0.3056468963623047,
-0.3827531337738037,
-0.33783450722694397,
-0.7725285291671753,
-0.05572504550218582,
0.06341348588466644,
-0.764664888381958,
0.15967640280723572,
-0.024924756959080696,
-0.13870088756084442,
-0.48589083552360535,
-0.06037353724241257,
-0.44876933097839355,
0.06782414019107819,
-0.6876651048660278,
1.1232860088348389,
-0.3122006952762604,
0.8865475058555603,
0.6862262487411499,
-0.2934107184410095,
-0.6916287541389465,
0.1990826278924942,
-0.12422453612089157,
-0.5588060617446899,
0.9085178375244141,
-0.17970611155033112,
0.08753293007612228,
0.12045856565237045,
-0.35191234946250916,
-0.3708861768245697,
1.3355189561843872,
0.629004716873169,
-0.6500860452651978,
0.13709913194179535,
0.32760149240493774,
0.6311637163162231,
-0.29129332304000854,
0.10395558923482895,
0.6275425553321838,
0.6737900376319885,
0.40071767568588257,
-0.6233835220336914,
0.3619491755962372,
-0.0628722608089447,
-0.026511818170547485,
0.17638380825519562,
-0.2877998650074005,
0.4603172540664673,
-0.42606881260871887,
-0.04483884572982788,
-0.4103570282459259,
0.4773862361907959,
0.1846645325422287,
0.5775002241134644,
0.41766372323036194,
0.65170818567276,
0.8633573055267334,
-0.13043929636478424,
1.0915892124176025,
-0.23160851001739502,
0.38623321056365967,
0.6882424354553223,
0.0029544320423156023,
0.8288919925689697,
0.7768836617469788,
-0.1480095237493515,
0.4465140700340271,
0.12725256383419037,
0.02749061770737171,
0.6441599726676941,
0.3557785153388977,
-0.3469838500022888,
-0.4869026243686676,
0.12747253477573395,
-0.033045075833797455,
0.4052131175994873,
-0.015314764343202114,
-0.49733462929725647,
-0.3620138466358185,
0.10616324841976166,
0.23265805840492249,
0.20766088366508484,
-0.378732830286026,
0.7314289212226868,
0.21709789335727692,
-0.7296594977378845,
0.11909176409244537,
0.28771981596946716,
0.43007731437683105,
-0.276532918214798,
-0.19593752920627594,
-0.5480598211288452,
0.1603361964225769,
-0.3341286778450012,
-0.898279070854187,
0.3859369158744812,
-0.1446227878332138,
-0.11921825259923935,
-0.1633824110031128,
0.3595919609069824,
-0.38548725843429565,
-0.36271369457244873,
0.30118605494499207,
0.2928207814693451,
0.1293582171201706,
-0.2745927572250366,
-0.37131792306900024,
-0.216928169131279,
0.008902239613234997,
-0.4137612283229828,
0.30450430512428284,
0.5178125500679016,
-0.16351436078548431,
1.0178419351577759,
0.6068370938301086,
-0.03329584747552872,
-0.003786717774346471,
0.40373581647872925,
0.7510364055633545,
-0.6521495580673218,
-0.23618540167808533,
-0.668817400932312,
0.5551630258560181,
-0.17107070982456207,
0.23947130143642426,
0.45835477113723755,
0.5873686075210571,
0.6360107660293579,
-0.0826537236571312,
0.45149585604667664,
0.30905330181121826,
0.24321159720420837,
-0.8022117018699646,
0.964536726474762,
-0.7446873784065247,
0.4876156449317932,
-0.10946011543273926,
-0.8299114108085632,
-0.553189754486084,
0.4028793275356293,
-0.47729501128196716,
0.2043689787387848,
0.36893805861473083,
0.7374256253242493,
-0.641631543636322,
-0.060278717428445816,
0.6513828635215759,
0.3468305468559265,
0.5085967183113098,
0.2855568826198578,
0.3194827139377594,
-0.5276032090187073,
0.9399051666259766,
0.19320672750473022,
0.020281968638300896,
-0.7624433636665344,
-0.6560624837875366,
-0.6460539698600769,
-0.5515663623809814,
0.06956734508275986,
-0.17601290345191956,
0.2550603747367859,
0.423705130815506,
0.7586408853530884,
-0.7182712554931641,
0.03924768790602684,
-0.2863735556602478,
0.500668466091156,
0.08914768695831299,
-0.29897937178611755,
0.23117844760417938,
-0.5861148834228516,
-0.6816850900650024,
0.3188987672328949,
0.14730504155158997,
-0.14869947731494904,
0.06412987411022186,
-0.1793154627084732,
0.0560360848903656,
0.16398759186267853,
0.7702187299728394,
0.11339899897575378,
-0.7477368712425232,
-0.12851561605930328,
-0.321517676115036,
-0.1550707370042801,
0.03169718384742737,
1.2431652545928955,
-0.808071494102478,
0.57846999168396,
0.2763720452785492,
0.3748164474964142,
0.9099317789077759,
0.07377149909734726,
0.7131250500679016,
-0.6281523704528809,
0.10705209523439407,
0.3365226089954376,
0.49060797691345215,
0.19386136531829834,
-0.31842026114463806,
0.3011246919631958,
0.22228258848190308,
-0.3450513184070587,
-0.8964149951934814,
0.495360404253006,
-0.7902554273605347,
-0.4920121729373932,
1.0654213428497314,
-0.29531586170196533,
-0.2348097413778305,
-0.511361300945282,
-0.020197834819555283,
0.28012096881866455,
-0.5902929902076721,
1.0843136310577393,
0.5725624561309814,
0.13680410385131836,
-0.31035664677619934,
-0.7839130759239197,
0.5767908096313477,
0.22139444947242737,
-0.5324018001556396,
-0.24941429495811462,
0.32322412729263306,
0.5220115780830383,
0.05382741615176201,
0.4368423521518707,
-0.3872663378715515,
0.1428970992565155,
-0.3323619067668915,
0.08611015975475311,
-0.3423571288585663,
-0.2247929871082306,
-0.19848905503749847,
0.5552458763122559,
-0.22789166867733002,
0.41793403029441833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19759v1 | Breaking the Script Barrier in Multilingual Pre-Trained Language Models with Transliteration-Based Post-Training Alignment | 2024-06-28T08:59:24 | 2024-06-28T08:59:24 | Orgest Xhelili, Yihong Liu, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pre-trained models (mPLMs) have shown impressive performance on
cross-lingual transfer tasks. However, the transfer performance is often
hindered when a low-resource target language is written in a different script
than the high-resource source language, even though the two languages may be
related or share parts of their vocabularies. Inspired by recent work that uses
transliteration to address this problem, our paper proposes a
transliteration-based post-pretraining alignment (PPA) method aiming to improve
the cross-lingual alignment between languages using diverse scripts. We select
two areal language groups, $\textbf{Mediterranean-Amharic-Farsi}$ and
$\textbf{South+East Asian Languages}$, wherein the languages are mutually
influenced but use different scripts. We apply our method to these language
groups and conduct extensive experiments on a spectrum of downstream tasks. The
results show that after PPA, models consistently outperform the original model
(up to 50% for some tasks) in English-centric transfer. In addition, when we
use languages other than English as sources in transfer, our method obtains
even larger improvements. We will make our code and models publicly available
at \url{https://github.com/cisnlp/Transliteration-PPA}. | [
-0.12019311636686325,
0.06833406537771225,
0.3516431152820587,
0.103553406894207,
-0.27280285954475403,
0.40322357416152954,
-0.244850292801857,
-0.274578720331192,
0.16295592486858368,
0.3293561339378357,
-0.6614827513694763,
-0.3867124617099762,
-0.7274463176727295,
0.1021062582731247,
0.006000715307891369,
0.8368098139762878,
-0.5306848883628845,
0.4846522808074951,
0.2128734141588211,
-0.2371407002210617,
-0.28692716360092163,
-0.44503623247146606,
-0.08117403090000153,
-0.07417567819356918,
0.767956554889679,
0.3920762240886688,
0.5879589319229126,
0.6132422089576721,
0.8447960019111633,
0.23353920876979828,
0.4408245384693146,
-0.01401186641305685,
-0.2823405861854553,
-0.2325054407119751,
-0.34352725744247437,
-0.3923911154270172,
-0.38499000668525696,
0.030256999656558037,
0.7838916182518005,
0.8661426901817322,
-0.27116549015045166,
0.19067290425300598,
0.00886970292776823,
0.3474774658679962,
-0.8472074866294861,
-0.02894977480173111,
-0.7384188175201416,
0.005239007994532585,
-0.6099525094032288,
-0.17292670905590057,
-0.43656834959983826,
-0.2533241808414459,
0.15335041284561157,
-0.7262679934501648,
-0.03531154245138168,
-0.06720307469367981,
1.0476436614990234,
0.10389793664216995,
-0.23830044269561768,
-0.04241636022925377,
-0.7849821448326111,
1.031470537185669,
-0.6859031915664673,
0.5251399278640747,
0.3373476564884186,
0.43819907307624817,
0.287464439868927,
-0.500907838344574,
-0.4726911783218384,
0.07327309995889664,
-0.19092953205108643,
-0.024455517530441284,
-0.028972169384360313,
-0.13306723535060883,
0.16484074294567108,
0.0537860281765461,
-0.6685588359832764,
0.26003023982048035,
-0.3487139344215393,
-0.4883526861667633,
0.22330033779144287,
-0.32002443075180054,
0.6471309661865234,
0.09187401831150055,
-0.4213857352733612,
-0.19228069484233856,
-1.0510870218276978,
-0.02503950148820877,
0.5912250876426697,
0.6687675714492798,
-0.10147438198328018,
0.46013349294662476,
0.0789215937256813,
0.6118479371070862,
0.09168022871017456,
-0.254507839679718,
0.4252070188522339,
-0.7042478919029236,
0.11251236498355865,
0.16490153968334198,
0.559779167175293,
0.2822294533252716,
0.36627495288848877,
-0.2578764855861664,
-0.05941803380846977,
0.03033890575170517,
0.13179415464401245,
-0.7899486422538757,
-0.09300899505615234,
-0.2014041543006897,
-0.4706895351409912,
0.0815354585647583,
0.0642031580209732,
-0.6015548706054688,
-0.26508840918540955,
-0.5010963082313538,
0.46952030062675476,
-0.5930126309394836,
-0.4623833894729614,
-0.10438995063304901,
0.35989075899124146,
0.6559038162231445,
0.2563689649105072,
-0.976806104183197,
-0.09780635684728622,
0.5609551668167114,
0.8202815651893616,
0.04061952233314514,
-0.8740558624267578,
-0.7121284008026123,
0.34293052554130554,
-0.21854370832443237,
0.9210902452468872,
-0.7037966251373291,
-0.030821258202195168,
0.28393545746803284,
0.03271748125553131,
-0.46178266406059265,
-0.45434924960136414,
0.08489347994327545,
-0.364859402179718,
0.4788509011268616,
-0.3687160015106201,
-0.2378949671983719,
0.033750008791685104,
0.025050226598978043,
-0.5066475868225098,
0.6547389626502991,
0.1996150016784668,
-0.6750507354736328,
0.4113315939903259,
-0.5498981475830078,
-0.7354707717895508,
-0.18088790774345398,
0.012156136333942413,
-0.22816449403762817,
-0.1714307814836502,
0.28799208998680115,
0.16388724744319916,
-0.2932848632335663,
0.16641893982887268,
-0.2032163441181183,
-0.2891797721385956,
0.03948499262332916,
-0.16789433360099792,
0.6386568546295166,
0.3179148733615875,
-0.16482172906398773,
0.32324105501174927,
-0.7227878570556641,
0.13413184881210327,
-0.1469467133283615,
-0.09306132048368454,
-0.23891066014766693,
-0.2392028123140335,
-0.04563744366168976,
0.7042689323425293,
0.40984785556793213,
-0.44857650995254517,
0.23917588591575623,
-0.15114501118659973,
0.13083311915397644,
0.8378314971923828,
-0.6437031030654907,
0.8481230139732361,
-0.357528418302536,
0.8439071774482727,
0.1275990903377533,
0.15090389549732208,
-0.21990886330604553,
0.09860410541296005,
-0.536870002746582,
-0.34455156326293945,
0.6955357789993286,
0.5464755892753601,
-0.9913197159767151,
0.14725357294082642,
-0.5431784391403198,
-0.5610827803611755,
-1.0478626489639282,
0.17148417234420776,
0.5063297748565674,
0.4860280752182007,
0.3717789053916931,
-0.6772177815437317,
-0.7148217558860779,
-0.6996666789054871,
-0.38966628909111023,
-0.16290076076984406,
-0.0784013420343399,
-0.047707654535770416,
0.008032911457121372,
-0.13151656091213226,
0.6280525922775269,
-0.13555437326431274,
-0.4035499691963196,
-0.47113391757011414,
0.22332844138145447,
0.08073558658361435,
0.6623405814170837,
0.5358138084411621,
-0.5681875944137573,
-0.9715393781661987,
0.27031779289245605,
-0.2370263785123825,
-0.4536570906639099,
-0.15622898936271667,
-0.4518826901912689,
0.17393548786640167,
0.44881919026374817,
-0.5958189368247986,
0.20768970251083374,
0.8950107097625732,
-0.10622154176235199,
0.8279644250869751,
-0.06330808997154236,
0.406213641166687,
-1.2325266599655151,
0.377517431974411,
-0.2944797873497009,
-0.13113033771514893,
-0.6184310913085938,
-0.15024502575397491,
0.15599288046360016,
-0.22557328641414642,
-0.805023193359375,
0.4430512487888336,
-0.6679338812828064,
-0.185218945145607,
-0.15416103601455688,
-0.11049657315015793,
-0.17710016667842865,
0.5855882167816162,
0.20888638496398926,
0.8585951328277588,
0.7826400995254517,
-0.25775453448295593,
-0.04950210079550743,
0.13614022731781006,
-0.3238770663738251,
0.5677403211593628,
-0.22074241936206818,
0.30775120854377747,
0.005306776147335768,
0.4094479978084564,
-0.8462001085281372,
-0.0670454278588295,
0.4602733254432678,
-0.25579604506492615,
0.6218730807304382,
-0.4691997170448303,
-0.3329884707927704,
0.1739613264799118,
-0.07026522606611252,
0.7105585336685181,
0.43986770510673523,
-0.40888723731040955,
0.7100281715393066,
0.1939707100391388,
-0.390960156917572,
-0.9592984914779663,
-0.4132154583930969,
0.009985174052417278,
-0.2451259344816208,
-0.5187610983848572,
0.599297046661377,
0.005182155407965183,
-0.13089092075824738,
-0.25142550468444824,
-0.1485835313796997,
-0.3407328426837921,
-0.25704455375671387,
-0.08609108626842499,
0.45076248049736023,
-0.4214298129081726,
-0.17728425562381744,
-0.12780892848968506,
-0.23770594596862793,
-0.3922257721424103,
-0.5058361291885376,
0.8324707746505737,
0.16526077687740326,
-0.5047275424003601,
-0.5754212141036987,
0.3389359712600708,
0.655135989189148,
-0.7967222332954407,
0.9611252546310425,
0.8198385834693909,
-0.21186858415603638,
0.14882133901119232,
-0.4825950562953949,
-0.03848865255713463,
-0.39543330669403076,
0.2770359516143799,
-0.5199131965637207,
-0.5353705286979675,
0.5791406631469727,
-0.2771412432193756,
-0.022927341982722282,
0.27572500705718994,
0.3520776927471161,
-0.05952894687652588,
0.8017572164535522,
0.8470264077186584,
-0.1034058928489685,
0.8492560386657715,
0.19350743293762207,
0.4430435597896576,
-0.6716100573539734,
0.17620208859443665,
-0.6694347858428955,
-0.30382925271987915,
-0.507411539554596,
-0.6343371272087097,
-0.17745034396648407,
0.16977910697460175,
0.042245786637067795,
0.7455592155456543,
0.013870001770555973,
0.5722824931144714,
0.4410882890224457,
-0.29070818424224854,
0.08059144765138626,
0.15450537204742432,
-0.17554505169391632,
-0.28651025891304016,
-0.6634672284126282,
-0.4002077281475067,
1.3127750158309937,
0.0878310352563858,
0.7049233913421631,
0.2534859776496887,
0.7058061361312866,
-0.10177155584096909,
0.6607406735420227,
-0.410507470369339,
0.3709176778793335,
-0.48059219121932983,
-0.37414994835853577,
-0.22603921592235565,
-0.49664559960365295,
-0.9245012402534485,
0.571789562702179,
0.0006887292838655412,
-0.6408253908157349,
0.008775421418249607,
-0.09432424604892731,
-0.24375420808792114,
0.41052481532096863,
-0.7430610656738281,
1.0910121202468872,
-0.3097759187221527,
-0.35197025537490845,
-0.17544806003570557,
-0.9504832625389099,
0.11721725761890411,
-0.38330405950546265,
0.19058483839035034,
-0.052948109805583954,
0.3079862892627716,
0.5767393112182617,
-0.6120958924293518,
0.4800027310848236,
-0.21568138897418976,
-0.26925018429756165,
0.03441168740391731,
-0.05578004941344261,
0.47190263867378235,
-0.6929976940155029,
0.002911090385168791,
0.3558382987976074,
0.04221378639340401,
-0.7024711966514587,
-0.5257712602615356,
0.3124474883079529,
-0.7591896653175354,
-0.4064461886882782,
-0.4675932824611664,
-0.7211816906929016,
-0.3591712713241577,
0.5594667792320251,
0.39463546872138977,
0.252917617559433,
-0.043506838381290436,
-0.07246074825525284,
0.2646927237510681,
-0.3708120882511139,
0.29065728187561035,
0.9473817944526672,
-0.28057512640953064,
-0.17557284235954285,
1.0790305137634277,
0.3169146776199341,
0.49647581577301025,
0.6460615992546082,
-0.10554049909114838,
-0.4686022698879242,
-0.8023256063461304,
-0.5438048839569092,
0.4635319411754608,
-0.5856929421424866,
-0.03646838665008545,
-0.3526614010334015,
-0.08528970927000046,
-0.9204013347625732,
-0.20814158022403717,
-0.48952314257621765,
-0.2147454023361206,
-0.07521576434373856,
0.05886416882276535,
-0.4133574664592743,
0.28646618127822876,
-0.2044200599193573,
0.45545390248298645,
-1.0238533020019531,
0.1534983217716217,
-0.027241969481110573,
0.3323880136013031,
-0.24169011414051056,
-0.7529064416885376,
-0.2719342112541199,
0.028818143531680107,
-0.09581517428159714,
-0.7841610908508301,
0.43197113275527954,
0.061746641993522644,
0.45304161310195923,
0.26634156703948975,
-0.01524501945823431,
1.0343457460403442,
-0.7723257541656494,
0.3599959909915924,
0.542174756526947,
-0.8968517780303955,
0.2644748091697693,
-0.3655916452407837,
0.3650120198726654,
0.7355738282203674,
0.4714421331882477,
-0.7101940512657166,
-0.2107255756855011,
-0.35889431834220886,
-0.7595071196556091,
0.8888327479362488,
0.07333260774612427,
-0.027439357712864876,
0.4561077058315277,
-0.0997118204832077,
0.435048907995224,
0.15358127653598785,
-0.8367754220962524,
0.017145246267318726,
-0.10356529802083969,
-0.3349454700946808,
-0.21309223771095276,
0.028088636696338654,
0.006878027692437172,
-0.1380164921283722,
0.6843454837799072,
-0.18108779191970825,
-0.25897130370140076,
-0.031959373503923416,
-0.707787811756134,
-0.3485259711742401,
0.3691256642341614,
0.4940427839756012,
1.0085262060165405,
-0.08046407997608185,
0.1666087508201599,
0.02006572298705578,
-0.44142967462539673,
0.4095497131347656,
0.49776968359947205,
0.057192474603652954,
-0.09838668256998062,
0.3972301185131073,
0.6356860399246216,
0.21245519816875458,
-0.6672943234443665,
0.5624324083328247,
-0.09684645384550095,
0.23956826329231262,
-0.02947862073779106,
-0.3774545192718506,
-0.14829762279987335,
0.001338155590929091,
0.2850361466407776,
0.329903244972229,
-0.35063397884368896,
-0.5598480701446533,
0.304739773273468,
0.2414548546075821,
-0.29571497440338135,
-0.6436679363250732,
0.37560102343559265,
0.28536099195480347,
-0.24261373281478882,
0.5741215348243713,
-0.08641054481267929,
-0.6470206379890442,
0.31498053669929504,
0.5508998036384583,
0.766682505607605,
-0.7819324135780334,
0.39040130376815796,
0.2905687391757965,
0.40919730067253113,
0.024174261838197708,
-0.026258431375026703,
0.024448126554489136,
-0.7788804173469543,
-0.8328203558921814,
-0.7806024551391602,
-0.3526805341243744,
-0.035646259784698486,
-0.5649548172950745,
0.4433436691761017,
-0.27671051025390625,
0.24823163449764252,
-0.00006409420166164637,
-0.12044792622327805,
-0.7948724031448364,
-0.030936649069190025,
0.305071085691452,
0.5682280659675598,
-0.9115616679191589,
1.2575303316116333,
0.6827234029769897,
-0.45481300354003906,
-1.0036612749099731,
0.35307377576828003,
-0.15832825005054474,
-0.840305745601654,
0.5735986232757568,
0.35333582758903503,
-0.16233983635902405,
-0.01148788072168827,
-0.00677652470767498,
-1.1130963563919067,
0.8260045051574707,
0.7514196038246155,
-0.717305064201355,
-0.14301447570323944,
0.46976107358932495,
0.5621633529663086,
-0.48212993144989014,
0.20072153210639954,
0.4332197904586792,
0.5003358125686646,
0.0846332237124443,
-1.2454310655593872,
-0.06544772535562515,
-0.21550624072551727,
-0.3192312717437744,
0.1776788979768753,
-0.5733437538146973,
0.8365687727928162,
-0.24308671057224274,
-0.41559964418411255,
0.20372508466243744,
0.6338626146316528,
0.10685134679079056,
0.03956077992916107,
0.6148444414138794,
0.436267226934433,
0.6674924492835999,
0.022710202261805534,
1.0186818838119507,
-0.4041968882083893,
0.06903316080570221,
1.2421705722808838,
-0.7576974034309387,
0.7740352153778076,
0.7211807370185852,
-0.34883537888526917,
0.6218558549880981,
0.5974038243293762,
0.26958730816841125,
0.6602269411087036,
0.14117665588855743,
-0.08014418929815292,
-0.16207252442836761,
-0.41709259152412415,
-0.4791727662086487,
0.6092466711997986,
-0.19020554423332214,
-0.3162634074687958,
-0.31738513708114624,
-0.037570707499980927,
0.07749747484922409,
-0.06378626078367233,
-0.21992452442646027,
0.533564567565918,
-0.16698184609413147,
-1.088386058807373,
0.4958859980106354,
-0.045073479413986206,
0.6993314027786255,
-1.1330459117889404,
0.11665944010019302,
-0.20430122315883636,
0.2792774736881256,
-0.070275217294693,
-0.3350723683834076,
0.3200899660587311,
0.11156533658504486,
-0.10561390966176987,
-0.6858059167861938,
0.673897922039032,
-0.982891321182251,
-0.4515376687049866,
0.3831164240837097,
0.6282278895378113,
0.15825296938419342,
-0.02713972143828869,
-0.6468549966812134,
-0.005350920837372541,
0.1891016662120819,
0.16115997731685638,
0.7983764410018921,
0.16674990952014923,
0.025944964960217476,
0.29133638739585876,
0.8190508484840393,
0.2883634567260742,
0.20284448564052582,
0.35115647315979004,
0.5257211923599243,
-0.37693551182746887,
-0.484935462474823,
-0.6139522194862366,
0.40821513533592224,
0.2558073103427887,
-0.3094594478607178,
0.8375260233879089,
0.44467756152153015,
1.0871548652648926,
-0.10556265711784363,
0.689491331577301,
-0.07976923882961273,
0.40031370520591736,
-0.5802785754203796,
0.8179691433906555,
-0.5182912349700928,
0.043386060744524,
-0.4600577652454376,
-1.2096831798553467,
-0.3788672685623169,
0.46952176094055176,
-0.3809196352958679,
-0.11774254590272903,
0.7937166690826416,
0.813837468624115,
-0.18303972482681274,
-0.3969644010066986,
0.2731504738330841,
-0.06494598090648651,
0.28490665555000305,
0.6970648765563965,
0.9852508902549744,
-0.2290748804807663,
0.8887810707092285,
-0.3550185561180115,
-0.14313766360282898,
0.04722907766699791,
-0.8027559518814087,
-0.44332951307296753,
-0.5558384656906128,
-0.3340838849544525,
-0.27738407254219055,
-0.04572436958551407,
0.6844387054443359,
0.7610056400299072,
-0.8349331617355347,
-0.3643268942832947,
0.2016698569059372,
0.13856719434261322,
-0.34963563084602356,
-0.14208771288394928,
0.45804113149642944,
-0.4749389886856079,
-0.9134702086448669,
0.3381410539150238,
0.15854915976524353,
0.1341736763715744,
-0.24437853693962097,
-0.1710529774427414,
-0.5800662040710449,
-0.09273017197847366,
0.2670843303203583,
0.3134036064147949,
-0.5129407644271851,
-0.2779877781867981,
0.02128753438591957,
-0.25894594192504883,
0.21031524240970612,
1.050032615661621,
-0.3209221661090851,
0.43164458870887756,
0.45142123103141785,
0.6601409316062927,
0.08978553116321564,
-0.036951228976249695,
0.9460291266441345,
-0.8158062696456909,
0.24100512266159058,
0.08986847847700119,
0.5471022725105286,
0.5983233451843262,
0.016667084768414497,
0.4166369140148163,
0.26210159063339233,
-0.18593448400497437,
-0.9426017999649048,
0.24711190164089203,
-0.59334397315979,
-0.28310516476631165,
1.0750118494033813,
-0.48526790738105774,
-0.12066887319087982,
0.04297756031155586,
-0.28200072050094604,
0.6313878297805786,
0.030703580006957054,
0.7107096910476685,
1.0300955772399902,
0.2309773564338684,
-0.022116752341389656,
0.018270371481776237,
0.4915112555027008,
0.8624603152275085,
-0.7909623980522156,
0.25711509585380554,
0.3541533946990967,
0.3982740342617035,
0.33109158277511597,
0.7298605442047119,
-0.31413087248802185,
0.33583876490592957,
-0.08824437111616135,
0.23327326774597168,
0.26348814368247986,
-0.5596582293510437,
-0.4085516333580017,
0.0031916943844407797,
-0.04960726201534271,
-0.29487115144729614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19736v1 | MM-Instruct: Generated Visual Instructions for Large Multimodal Model Alignment | 2024-06-28T08:25:27 | 2024-06-28T08:25:27 | Jihao Liu, Xin Huang, Jinliang Zheng, Boxiao Liu, Jia Wang, Osamu Yoshie, Yu Liu, Hongsheng Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces MM-Instruct, a large-scale dataset of diverse and
high-quality visual instruction data designed to enhance the
instruction-following capabilities of large multimodal models (LMMs). While
existing visual instruction datasets often focus on question-answering, they
struggle to generalize to broader application scenarios such as creative
writing, summarization, or image analysis. To address these limitations, we
propose a novel approach to constructing MM-Instruct that leverages the strong
instruction-following capabilities of existing LLMs to generate novel visual
instruction data from large-scale but conventional image captioning datasets.
MM-Instruct first leverages ChatGPT to automatically generate diverse
instructions from a small set of seed instructions through augmenting and
summarization. It then matches these instructions with images and uses an
open-sourced large language model (LLM) to generate coherent answers to the
instruction-image pairs. The LLM is grounded by the detailed text descriptions
of images in the whole answer generation process to guarantee the alignment of
the instruction data. Moreover, we introduce a benchmark based on the generated
instruction data to evaluate the instruction-following capabilities of existing
LMMs. We demonstrate the effectiveness of MM-Instruct by training a LLaVA-1.5
model on the generated data, denoted as LLaVA-Instruct, which exhibits
significant improvements in instruction-following capabilities compared to
LLaVA-1.5 models. The MM-Instruct dataset, benchmark, and pre-trained models
are available at https://github.com/jihaonew/MM-Instruct. | [
-0.26714280247688293,
-0.821399986743927,
0.4282618761062622,
-0.1004943922162056,
-0.13633529841899872,
0.11107964813709259,
-0.04995514079928398,
-0.004300212487578392,
-0.01519759465008974,
0.5712809562683105,
-0.9371931552886963,
-0.6743268966674805,
-0.4829583168029785,
-0.2091495841741562,
-0.16019868850708008,
0.8011723160743713,
-0.10480494797229767,
0.35089847445487976,
-0.6370320916175842,
0.006337959785014391,
-0.8019022941589355,
-0.20673011243343353,
0.018762409687042236,
0.1588539034128189,
0.4588332772254944,
0.8875603675842285,
0.6143481135368347,
0.7284733057022095,
0.6097187995910645,
0.28792014718055725,
0.47114109992980957,
0.6509817242622375,
-0.44513651728630066,
-0.02338556759059429,
0.1293403059244156,
-0.4412307143211365,
-0.4122833013534546,
0.04367590695619583,
0.7702346444129944,
0.5260484218597412,
-0.29757946729660034,
0.4944405257701874,
0.052519723773002625,
0.5250386595726013,
-0.581294059753418,
0.3320004642009735,
-0.47872838377952576,
-0.09636799246072769,
-0.10642635822296143,
-0.41405996680259705,
-0.8937456011772156,
-0.5974050760269165,
0.10871779918670654,
-0.6459414958953857,
-0.00340521102771163,
0.1122249886393547,
0.5449951887130737,
0.23314107954502106,
-0.48864540457725525,
-0.37139418721199036,
-0.4230027496814728,
0.7744025588035583,
-0.6120904684066772,
0.3026117980480194,
0.15491382777690887,
0.7429906725883484,
-0.05577180162072182,
-0.5214248299598694,
-0.5243307948112488,
-0.09829313308000565,
0.26046472787857056,
0.3551754951477051,
0.06992802023887634,
-0.0014507515588775277,
0.1709088534116745,
0.17188021540641785,
-0.6194552183151245,
0.3069150745868683,
-0.34003540873527527,
0.07809167355298996,
0.32599031925201416,
0.37690842151641846,
0.4703236520290375,
0.007059367839246988,
-0.5015864372253418,
-0.25848305225372314,
-0.9710437059402466,
0.01984185166656971,
0.36017435789108276,
0.18758155405521393,
-0.30881568789482117,
0.9049360752105713,
-0.07301509380340576,
0.7431952953338623,
0.05728856846690178,
-0.38292691111564636,
0.26837024092674255,
-0.18700121343135834,
-0.19713075459003448,
0.06252823770046234,
0.6216647028923035,
0.7866360545158386,
0.34144413471221924,
0.01631663367152214,
-0.004750503692775965,
-0.12923984229564667,
0.09704715758562088,
-1.083947777748108,
-0.0024331852328032255,
-0.09921563416719437,
-0.38779959082603455,
-0.2246987521648407,
0.30443423986434937,
-0.9127619862556458,
-0.3657836616039276,
-0.5799592733383179,
0.6598504781723022,
-0.42817234992980957,
0.1178082600235939,
0.05445166304707527,
0.1515677571296692,
0.5141961574554443,
0.5360296368598938,
-0.9891922473907471,
0.005289941560477018,
0.48617878556251526,
0.7001919150352478,
0.08678504824638367,
-0.37640181183815,
-0.7189249396324158,
0.4771949350833893,
-0.3257894515991211,
0.6048133969306946,
-0.7509424686431885,
-0.19073496758937836,
0.07366418838500977,
0.1470804065465927,
-0.14931826293468475,
-0.3967885971069336,
0.003185406792908907,
-0.3022376596927643,
0.6451444625854492,
-0.023272542282938957,
-0.8267745971679688,
-0.3105787932872772,
0.2862626314163208,
-0.29359355568885803,
0.5511752963066101,
-0.00878927018493414,
-0.7678215503692627,
0.05044359341263771,
-0.5751467943191528,
-0.20111405849456787,
-0.17334702610969543,
-0.3045092821121216,
-0.4082511067390442,
-0.0604105144739151,
0.7285518646240234,
0.725684642791748,
-0.2695828080177307,
-0.1357736885547638,
-0.37109217047691345,
-0.3967614769935608,
0.3149866461753845,
-0.7238062024116516,
0.6889682412147522,
-0.2286032885313034,
-0.1349881887435913,
0.2738751471042633,
-0.7801409959793091,
-0.059378188103437424,
0.08506201952695847,
-0.07596226036548615,
-0.07344432175159454,
-0.08046817779541016,
-0.49407023191452026,
-0.04797077924013138,
0.22269728779792786,
-0.5468522310256958,
0.5964658260345459,
-0.1006593108177185,
0.2374771684408188,
1.0000027418136597,
0.08710890263319016,
0.5734764933586121,
-0.2057756781578064,
0.7930558919906616,
-0.006655183620750904,
0.4041597545146942,
-0.8831703066825867,
-0.5108919739723206,
-0.7287603616714478,
-0.3845144510269165,
0.16100680828094482,
0.8282790780067444,
-1.1343510150909424,
-0.18374942243099213,
-0.48105761408805847,
-0.4117530286312103,
-0.8724952936172485,
0.24559557437896729,
0.6170514822006226,
0.7278609275817871,
0.37829193472862244,
-0.012651422992348671,
-0.41069817543029785,
-0.9402958750724792,
0.6101314425468445,
0.21086238324642181,
0.11591798812150955,
0.15724211931228638,
0.49666306376457214,
-0.28351011872291565,
0.3997611105442047,
-0.6960920691490173,
-0.025217808783054352,
0.12757542729377747,
0.11787936091423035,
0.12907345592975616,
0.463388592004776,
0.42401930689811707,
-0.4770403802394867,
-0.5054057240486145,
0.0808679610490799,
-0.8866126537322998,
-0.038409315049648285,
-0.16447065770626068,
-0.4582083821296692,
-0.07668419927358627,
0.6359401345252991,
-0.5344706773757935,
0.12315070629119873,
0.653644859790802,
-0.027028147131204605,
0.7498803734779358,
-0.2049158364534378,
0.43348145484924316,
-1.4327936172485352,
-0.32333675026893616,
-0.292062908411026,
0.02667864039540291,
-0.3373187780380249,
0.21725255250930786,
0.2447400689125061,
-0.14270876348018646,
-0.45758453011512756,
0.14206022024154663,
-0.6466879844665527,
-0.006950177252292633,
0.06723392009735107,
-0.18669269979000092,
0.00047800684114918113,
0.6194815635681152,
-0.39614808559417725,
0.9898569583892822,
0.6013046503067017,
-0.24146772921085358,
0.3476337194442749,
0.45502543449401855,
-0.5466006398200989,
0.7142072319984436,
-0.35855579376220703,
0.18354284763336182,
-0.3439652621746063,
-0.004602143075317144,
-1.143865704536438,
-0.517282247543335,
0.20627789199352264,
-0.34896522760391235,
0.5327709317207336,
-0.5791701674461365,
-0.6754080653190613,
-0.23160454630851746,
-0.22054344415664673,
0.10501831024885178,
0.4973536729812622,
-0.7207083106040955,
0.5786423087120056,
0.045595940202474594,
-0.20861999690532684,
-0.8027681708335876,
-0.8049981594085693,
-0.08049628138542175,
-0.21253354847431183,
-0.5965216755867004,
0.06003662943840027,
-0.3548682630062103,
0.08335752785205841,
-0.15281976759433746,
0.17251810431480408,
-0.09689309448003769,
-0.2573355734348297,
0.5317075848579407,
0.6827884912490845,
-0.42116013169288635,
0.08428585529327393,
0.3992864787578583,
0.009233507327735424,
0.004364544991403818,
-0.15367059409618378,
0.4269563555717468,
0.04040389880537987,
-0.8349181413650513,
-0.6509561538696289,
0.42245960235595703,
0.8080562353134155,
-0.5741880536079407,
0.5947466492652893,
0.5497862696647644,
0.09549784660339355,
-0.15446579456329346,
-0.3836610019207001,
-0.04850386455655098,
-0.47584807872772217,
0.3348986804485321,
-0.11911986768245697,
-0.7080194354057312,
0.14231932163238525,
0.027708640322089195,
0.44305863976478577,
-0.06779929995536804,
0.5430775284767151,
-0.6066778302192688,
1.2010859251022339,
0.47420164942741394,
0.21340227127075195,
0.6462709307670593,
-0.280195027589798,
-0.32857581973075867,
-0.5711015462875366,
-0.32138457894325256,
0.06252340227365494,
-0.15605279803276062,
-0.4105813205242157,
-0.806735634803772,
0.40446537733078003,
-0.18988457322120667,
-0.2767123281955719,
0.05391548201441765,
-0.5381450653076172,
0.6366799473762512,
0.5674310326576233,
0.4200292229652405,
-0.012737378478050232,
0.19093938171863556,
-0.1167750433087349,
-0.14538052678108215,
-0.7287730574607849,
-0.5000227689743042,
1.1667996644973755,
0.2467479407787323,
1.0343096256256104,
0.19172529876232147,
0.7301585078239441,
0.06384170055389404,
0.43950745463371277,
-0.6768726706504822,
0.6234674453735352,
-0.24077455699443817,
-0.18366645276546478,
-0.012486839666962624,
-0.3807350993156433,
-0.8134481906890869,
0.14785413444042206,
-0.45566079020500183,
-0.36852869391441345,
-0.3328290581703186,
0.26009678840637207,
-0.22277666628360748,
0.2520245611667633,
-1.3203374147415161,
0.9167708158493042,
-0.4553270936012268,
-0.2763020098209381,
-0.05668456852436066,
-0.650089681148529,
0.6228131055831909,
0.2955801784992218,
0.10841068625450134,
0.048780638724565506,
0.05014696717262268,
0.38365569710731506,
-0.18762387335300446,
1.0865470170974731,
-0.29027557373046875,
-0.19480063021183014,
0.4169447124004364,
0.07039936631917953,
0.4211500585079193,
-0.3282262682914734,
0.27806031703948975,
-0.3818088173866272,
-0.12413762509822845,
-0.18106979131698608,
-0.9345878958702087,
0.5277464985847473,
-0.46888598799705505,
-0.563749372959137,
0.17171691358089447,
-0.881593644618988,
-0.12107454240322113,
0.13454963266849518,
0.05138783156871796,
0.8790753483772278,
-0.07735564559698105,
0.43552500009536743,
0.93748939037323,
-0.510261058807373,
0.3070163428783417,
0.3036012351512909,
-0.2616916298866272,
-0.8417602777481079,
1.0051000118255615,
0.15804027020931244,
0.5543516278266907,
0.8091118335723877,
0.0645442008972168,
-0.05145052447915077,
-0.3854454755783081,
-0.9136456847190857,
-0.008706842549145222,
-0.8387845158576965,
-0.3543713390827179,
-0.2733635902404785,
-0.028322923928499222,
-0.1066627949476242,
-0.25662732124328613,
-0.2604314386844635,
-0.24636974930763245,
-0.2017146199941635,
0.048322178423404694,
0.22839802503585815,
0.5262237787246704,
0.40768325328826904,
0.644485354423523,
-0.8330889940261841,
0.26018226146698,
0.5883975028991699,
0.1785954087972641,
0.03838019445538521,
-0.48661744594573975,
-0.3523988723754883,
0.27215176820755005,
-0.40503790974617004,
-0.8907277584075928,
0.13737013936042786,
0.14529123902320862,
0.5674278736114502,
0.5860614776611328,
-0.26237455010414124,
1.0238614082336426,
-0.920872151851654,
0.5283626317977905,
0.45911523699760437,
-0.62813401222229,
0.5595062971115112,
-0.3449614346027374,
0.7472979426383972,
0.19438506662845612,
0.2785862386226654,
-0.11863159388303757,
-0.4000374972820282,
-0.30123209953308105,
-0.5911354422569275,
0.3672144412994385,
0.07016678899526596,
0.20093151926994324,
0.18762153387069702,
0.11566948145627975,
0.4807431399822235,
0.15108969807624817,
-0.4590150713920593,
0.030771367251873016,
-0.1977032572031021,
-0.6934306621551514,
-0.03478376939892769,
-0.27970975637435913,
-0.089186891913414,
-0.1878625601530075,
0.3871579170227051,
-0.35644659399986267,
0.363791286945343,
-0.22783443331718445,
-0.34735652804374695,
0.19302703440189362,
0.12437950074672699,
0.8271149396896362,
0.6855016946792603,
-0.11222187429666519,
0.137224942445755,
0.07703975588083267,
-0.3446274399757385,
0.11767499148845673,
0.05690305680036545,
-0.172710120677948,
-0.15369847416877747,
0.5253301858901978,
0.6477997303009033,
0.3627772331237793,
-0.7665765285491943,
0.5668110847473145,
0.019668184220790863,
-0.1731458306312561,
-0.2189202755689621,
0.10257105529308319,
0.2703480124473572,
0.4229559302330017,
0.08925867080688477,
-0.12520502507686615,
-0.10274865478277206,
-0.3875911235809326,
0.20133857429027557,
0.5565267205238342,
-0.16191521286964417,
-0.2961723804473877,
0.6586677432060242,
0.12165448814630508,
0.06095580756664276,
0.7137874960899353,
0.0402001217007637,
-0.13316747546195984,
0.6024599671363831,
0.407953679561615,
0.5009204149246216,
-0.17169129848480225,
0.3025137782096863,
0.40411269664764404,
0.3827003836631775,
0.19423802196979523,
0.4513280391693115,
-0.04021541401743889,
-0.389533668756485,
-0.7168840169906616,
-0.19013553857803345,
-0.5672321915626526,
-0.21627025306224823,
-0.6417976021766663,
0.25900962948799133,
-0.503524124622345,
0.11331342160701752,
0.08022738993167877,
-0.5068888068199158,
-0.5394653081893921,
0.024834413081407547,
0.3250758647918701,
0.5593364238739014,
-0.6283663511276245,
0.7950093150138855,
0.5479069352149963,
-0.6616592407226562,
-0.5580483675003052,
-0.1911648064851761,
0.2275094985961914,
-0.9544673562049866,
0.5108344554901123,
0.5735903382301331,
-0.06305331736803055,
-0.04444596543908119,
-1.1721709966659546,
-0.5909302830696106,
1.39207124710083,
0.6712231040000916,
-0.5570887327194214,
0.08195587992668152,
0.05660102143883705,
0.15954463183879852,
-0.6875510215759277,
0.16761565208435059,
-0.0988839715719223,
0.17590370774269104,
0.3187635838985443,
-0.5980273485183716,
-0.19193865358829498,
-0.1539343148469925,
-0.22029027342796326,
0.245016947388649,
-0.5018303990364075,
0.5639857649803162,
-0.6508740186691284,
-0.1318802684545517,
0.2744472324848175,
0.7628887891769409,
0.2498021125793457,
0.1954708844423294,
0.3007025122642517,
0.5365575551986694,
0.5640440583229065,
0.12124953418970108,
0.8540111184120178,
-0.024921048432588577,
-0.12312708050012589,
1.5925155878067017,
0.17785008251667023,
0.9954162836074829,
0.5759974122047424,
0.14476794004440308,
0.5828288793563843,
0.4285493493080139,
-0.3430323004722595,
0.5098058581352234,
-0.0900854542851448,
0.11338331550359726,
-0.025011807680130005,
-0.06589065492153168,
-0.23649545013904572,
0.5961111783981323,
0.2918132245540619,
-0.5051880478858948,
-0.1530585139989853,
0.08582659065723419,
-0.07686370611190796,
-0.016587059944868088,
-0.3582834005355835,
0.7096682786941528,
-0.27761146426200867,
-0.5183531045913696,
0.5091750025749207,
-0.49601584672927856,
0.41856813430786133,
-0.6849129796028137,
-0.5689089298248291,
-0.16547735035419464,
0.08552183210849762,
-0.15388721227645874,
-1.083241581916809,
-0.11178181320428848,
0.0010825792560353875,
-0.32562869787216187,
-0.32898133993148804,
0.20751886069774628,
-0.6987769603729248,
-0.6157036423683167,
-0.29822954535484314,
0.46255624294281006,
0.03680236637592316,
0.37673941254615784,
-0.4782516062259674,
-0.29048803448677063,
0.19525694847106934,
0.009358950890600681,
0.20159821212291718,
0.576424777507782,
-0.10574399679899216,
0.938170313835144,
0.6495252847671509,
-0.35952144861221313,
0.3773861229419708,
0.2705649733543396,
0.6662685871124268,
-0.2504960298538208,
-0.1890510469675064,
-0.7691597938537598,
0.8706817030906677,
0.006777256727218628,
-0.146020770072937,
0.8691461086273193,
0.4801684319972992,
0.7908543348312378,
-0.48661285638809204,
0.4736206829547882,
0.05394605174660683,
0.17232675850391388,
-0.8780783414840698,
0.47492867708206177,
-0.5225141644477844,
0.08774103969335556,
-0.30610528588294983,
-0.9156247973442078,
-0.19648747146129608,
0.1785634607076645,
-0.16454662382602692,
-0.2103087604045868,
0.34547027945518494,
1.2084647417068481,
-0.40946242213249207,
-0.160721093416214,
0.23561403155326843,
-0.032228536903858185,
0.18063251674175262,
0.5312687754631042,
1.0651624202728271,
-0.20570482313632965,
0.7797417640686035,
-0.3457854092121124,
-0.3136252462863922,
0.05094269663095474,
-0.7222930192947388,
-1.0448250770568848,
-0.5427693724632263,
-0.3415423333644867,
-0.05880192667245865,
-0.11884919553995132,
0.9251384735107422,
0.6702736616134644,
-0.6180103421211243,
-0.1860327273607254,
0.17453135550022125,
-0.06326490640640259,
-0.34064769744873047,
-0.20050379633903503,
0.4289911091327667,
-0.19121770560741425,
-0.7850618362426758,
0.3895302712917328,
0.3182958960533142,
0.4755996763706207,
-0.21838505566120148,
-0.11420349031686783,
-0.3482935428619385,
-0.05442904680967331,
0.7965204119682312,
-0.04352372884750366,
-0.5994147658348083,
-0.11651085317134857,
0.18325892090797424,
-0.10089822858572006,
0.1613338589668274,
0.45052096247673035,
-0.14782291650772095,
0.9147688150405884,
0.319164514541626,
0.8443372249603271,
0.2826227843761444,
-0.02007637731730938,
0.570539116859436,
-0.8489177227020264,
0.0829262062907219,
-0.0504944734275341,
0.41352614760398865,
0.44090375304222107,
-0.1187262237071991,
0.4246569275856018,
-0.16896948218345642,
-0.4001222848892212,
-0.6403607726097107,
0.251645028591156,
-1.036965012550354,
-0.157637819647789,
0.9713654518127441,
-0.08680915087461472,
-0.2710557281970978,
0.5144271850585938,
-0.6536770462989807,
0.16141504049301147,
-0.21906916797161102,
0.6235126256942749,
0.5604881048202515,
0.014516670256853104,
-0.6724367737770081,
-0.9032624363899231,
-0.22290265560150146,
0.13740478456020355,
-0.8851462602615356,
0.07652028650045395,
0.7716696262359619,
0.10884785652160645,
-0.0470200777053833,
-0.010915297083556652,
-0.1643441766500473,
0.38910555839538574,
0.23638372123241425,
0.3184693157672882,
-0.47449570894241333,
-0.26855096220970154,
0.040886182337999344,
0.2022860050201416,
-0.2484406977891922,
-0.7992364168167114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19731v1 | Message du troisi{è}me type : irruption d'un tiers dans un dialogue en ligne | 2024-06-28T08:20:32 | 2024-06-28T08:20:32 | Ludovic Tanguy, Céline Poudat, Lydia-Mai Ho-Dac | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our study focuses on Wikipedia talk pages, from a global perspective
analyzing contributors' behaviors in online interactions. Using a corpus
comprising all Wikipedia talk pages in French, totaling more than 300,000
discussion threads, we examine how discussions with more than two participants
(multiparty conversation) unfold and we specifically investigate the role of a
third participant's intervention when two Wikipedians have already initiated an
exchange. In this regard, we concentrate on the sequential structure of these
interactions in terms of articulation among different participants and aim to
specify this third message by exploring its lexical particularities, while also
proposing an initial typology of the third participant's message role and how
it aligns with preceding messages. | [
-0.7813004851341248,
-0.8161625862121582,
0.5327888131141663,
0.4973870813846588,
-0.04680916666984558,
-0.020824259147047997,
-0.0471753366291523,
-0.7669835686683655,
0.8038969039916992,
0.33922454714775085,
-0.4888570308685303,
-0.05380881577730179,
-0.5497006177902222,
0.2724880576133728,
-0.7577619552612305,
1.2908415794372559,
-0.09562740474939346,
0.153387188911438,
-0.12028827518224716,
-0.06736821681261063,
-0.1936579793691635,
-0.4278966784477234,
-0.9886234402656555,
-0.13158079981803894,
1.1307166814804077,
0.8095542192459106,
0.5322458744049072,
-0.07081686705350876,
0.3842809498310089,
0.48156940937042236,
0.18045532703399658,
-0.01564251072704792,
-0.9222815632820129,
0.2930346727371216,
-0.3582300543785095,
-0.4748494625091553,
-0.38151219487190247,
0.13631190359592438,
0.6208857893943787,
0.7106203436851501,
0.005412016995251179,
0.13467146456241608,
0.21810492873191833,
0.7311885356903076,
-0.6231828331947327,
0.11574853211641312,
-0.33969902992248535,
-0.20467476546764374,
-0.2593468427658081,
-0.2131848931312561,
-0.3972489833831787,
-0.2420307844877243,
0.3007362484931946,
-0.30907103419303894,
0.014828755520284176,
-0.16236893832683563,
0.5308772921562195,
-0.233473539352417,
-0.40557029843330383,
-0.31080812215805054,
-0.7447625994682312,
0.31043165922164917,
-0.25032156705856323,
0.11993930488824844,
0.2876773476600647,
-0.11045195162296295,
-0.3114704191684723,
-0.760506808757782,
-1.0480612516403198,
0.12140282243490219,
-0.27176642417907715,
0.20798487961292267,
-0.2988209128379822,
-0.025374211370944977,
0.016172584146261215,
0.38717588782310486,
-0.04651704803109169,
0.009390810504555702,
-0.8200055956840515,
-0.09145147353410721,
0.42340779304504395,
0.13063675165176392,
0.5751611590385437,
-0.3022794723510742,
-0.21860849857330322,
0.15958936512470245,
-0.37009936571121216,
-0.13298873603343964,
0.8961246609687805,
-0.1632276177406311,
-0.4747563600540161,
0.7993525266647339,
-0.03944103419780731,
0.5886633396148682,
0.14791160821914673,
0.23636272549629211,
0.15070568025112152,
-0.4241957366466522,
0.2532040774822235,
-0.099664606153965,
0.8881754875183105,
0.7831733226776123,
0.6134653687477112,
-0.06647095084190369,
0.3523193895816803,
-0.43460777401924133,
0.35708850622177124,
-0.7637566328048706,
-0.32437562942504883,
0.2623564898967743,
-0.4455549716949463,
-0.3449713885784149,
0.610671877861023,
-0.8960771560668945,
-0.37492379546165466,
0.033331248909235,
0.17975467443466187,
-0.15403011441230774,
-0.5675965547561646,
-0.2349928915500641,
-0.2505696415901184,
0.05873966962099075,
0.26664742827415466,
-1.0408811569213867,
0.23401039838790894,
0.6254033446311951,
0.771314799785614,
-0.17703811824321747,
-0.7900459170341492,
-0.2913571298122406,
0.4945392906665802,
-0.34852224588394165,
0.8932510614395142,
-0.30655720829963684,
-0.8201929330825806,
0.07436017692089081,
0.11115261167287827,
-0.11182431876659393,
0.2633417546749115,
0.596728503704071,
-0.5568952560424805,
0.5799967646598816,
-0.2833639085292816,
-0.44649550318717957,
-0.26101064682006836,
0.3108891248703003,
-0.8497166633605957,
0.4862367510795593,
-0.04756579175591469,
-1.3011714220046997,
-0.054014384746551514,
-0.704856812953949,
-0.1445552110671997,
0.10448388010263443,
-0.41785702109336853,
0.07177766412496567,
0.1980007141828537,
-0.32320791482925415,
0.31058189272880554,
-0.1282619833946228,
-0.22075730562210083,
-0.3040967881679535,
-0.15272973477840424,
0.6600940227508545,
-0.37871015071868896,
0.5572737455368042,
-0.13878099620342255,
-0.2599833011627197,
-0.0918855145573616,
-0.48248517513275146,
-0.033891502767801285,
-0.0580429844558239,
-0.29180437326431274,
-0.4829481244087219,
-0.025318771600723267,
-0.027173057198524475,
0.22913916409015656,
0.22098390758037567,
-0.5423761606216431,
0.28276145458221436,
-0.8379697203636169,
0.31635525822639465,
0.7292824983596802,
0.6096803545951843,
0.43064993619918823,
-0.2710009515285492,
-0.20541571080684662,
0.10444243997335434,
0.4463198184967041,
0.008535439148545265,
-0.8246532082557678,
-1.322001576423645,
0.23197999596595764,
0.0768551230430603,
0.6103507876396179,
-0.5448749661445618,
0.03735177218914032,
-0.6353675127029419,
-0.13553881645202637,
-0.280020534992218,
0.055993542075157166,
0.40881776809692383,
-0.03200998157262802,
0.10336925834417343,
-0.17885366082191467,
-0.33354824781417847,
-1.3740227222442627,
-0.2718297243118286,
-0.6776168346405029,
0.11374856531620026,
0.33850058913230896,
0.5927140116691589,
-0.23165708780288696,
0.7503358721733093,
-0.3100636899471283,
0.10945644229650497,
-0.33109724521636963,
0.5742711424827576,
-0.08918071538209915,
0.3987296223640442,
0.5478079319000244,
-0.9992427229881287,
-1.042980432510376,
-0.11540541797876358,
-0.46598300337791443,
0.09600286185741425,
0.0268117543309927,
-0.5431417226791382,
0.15951119363307953,
0.654394805431366,
-0.5182616710662842,
0.32873454689979553,
0.4165806472301483,
-0.2927872836589813,
-0.10313239693641663,
-0.0859338715672493,
0.4910902678966522,
-1.3648326396942139,
-0.378990113735199,
-0.3322351276874542,
0.1661975383758545,
-0.9189444184303284,
-0.37051281332969666,
-0.31818515062332153,
0.21365895867347717,
-0.5994747877120972,
0.4039970338344574,
-0.4236614406108856,
0.11489955335855484,
-0.30131348967552185,
0.45147475600242615,
-0.042725443840026855,
0.47103381156921387,
-0.1248205155134201,
0.49828407168388367,
0.41083699464797974,
-0.4679184556007385,
0.45987755060195923,
0.5738074779510498,
-0.06067245081067085,
0.9245011210441589,
-0.3701728582382202,
0.48581013083457947,
-0.3090665340423584,
0.21558940410614014,
-1.1410858631134033,
-0.5500368475914001,
0.7026961445808411,
-0.7052780985832214,
0.2001519501209259,
-0.03582274913787842,
-0.5217295289039612,
-0.5029594302177429,
-0.5643800497055054,
0.4537521004676819,
-0.41380056738853455,
-0.20787233114242554,
0.3856656551361084,
0.5910707116127014,
-0.4483239948749542,
-0.41022324562072754,
-0.7007249593734741,
0.31467097997665405,
-0.09159517288208008,
-0.9821687936782837,
0.21702662110328674,
-0.2668529748916626,
-0.6022794246673584,
0.046323537826538086,
0.07649721205234528,
-0.17602568864822388,
-0.008337539620697498,
0.2540911138057709,
0.05781398341059685,
0.21425333619117737,
0.06934387981891632,
-0.2359447330236435,
-0.08441933244466782,
0.2116381675004959,
-0.1830650120973587,
0.5793563723564148,
-0.09163472056388855,
-0.38218486309051514,
-0.5553100109100342,
0.977662205696106,
0.565233051776886,
0.20020365715026855,
1.3259871006011963,
0.6781322956085205,
-0.13062381744384766,
0.1675862818956375,
-0.8008005619049072,
0.020767489448189735,
-0.4649495780467987,
0.07099904865026474,
-0.33950868248939514,
-0.7065313458442688,
0.38587480783462524,
0.40543365478515625,
0.0049151103012263775,
0.5921517014503479,
0.6785817742347717,
-0.41341152787208557,
0.9058944582939148,
0.820257306098938,
-0.14990870654582977,
0.36237531900405884,
-0.33787694573402405,
0.55312579870224,
-0.47363150119781494,
-0.650329053401947,
-0.49387797713279724,
-0.3807649314403534,
-0.8805769681930542,
-0.3151837885379791,
0.39389118552207947,
0.20190320909023285,
-0.021911635994911194,
0.15695150196552277,
-0.11667425185441971,
0.3737751543521881,
0.43398186564445496,
-0.06518074870109558,
0.09189300984144211,
0.0694795697927475,
0.07755251973867416,
-0.098516546189785,
-0.4108435809612274,
-0.27828603982925415,
0.6295614838600159,
0.09603653848171234,
0.5060113072395325,
0.5676138401031494,
0.6808900833129883,
0.26970604062080383,
0.3798172175884247,
-0.5769965648651123,
0.553422749042511,
0.3724054992198944,
-0.6378394961357117,
-0.29450544714927673,
-0.1616540253162384,
-0.8365386128425598,
0.0937405675649643,
-0.26625707745552063,
-1.1558303833007812,
0.3764304220676422,
-0.20130832493305206,
-0.08529787510633469,
0.3150648772716522,
-0.7025452256202698,
0.8230847120285034,
-0.09316442161798477,
-0.2667752206325531,
-0.583724319934845,
-0.680173397064209,
0.414955735206604,
-0.10093928128480911,
0.5497581362724304,
-0.20204807817935944,
-0.19313256442546844,
0.7530019283294678,
-0.26683732867240906,
0.8816192150115967,
0.21348834037780762,
-0.24203486740589142,
0.43868520855903625,
-0.08129891008138657,
0.5292960405349731,
0.3136175870895386,
0.45354530215263367,
0.09058083593845367,
-0.08028098195791245,
-0.3123244643211365,
-0.2884540259838104,
1.033652901649475,
-1.061499834060669,
-0.7985687255859375,
-0.15098707377910614,
-0.10402985662221909,
-0.31168192625045776,
0.14275968074798584,
0.7380682826042175,
0.42776355147361755,
-0.3537866175174713,
0.2547686696052551,
0.4107316732406616,
-0.10046380013227463,
0.6210576295852661,
0.6753172278404236,
-0.19244985282421112,
-0.5406605005264282,
0.953124463558197,
-0.2665516436100006,
0.32739245891571045,
0.4876018166542053,
-0.07988376915454865,
0.001226431573741138,
-0.24098961055278778,
-0.14371319115161896,
0.34107255935668945,
-0.9112358093261719,
-0.023692913353443146,
-1.2079558372497559,
-0.17392756044864655,
-0.2244834452867508,
-0.02939629927277565,
-0.28698021173477173,
-0.5136768817901611,
-0.25343504548072815,
-0.20713810622692108,
0.32762888073921204,
1.025896668434143,
-0.32844653725624084,
0.4713842272758484,
-0.9440684914588928,
0.3817444443702698,
0.5379805564880371,
0.3966864049434662,
0.0434236004948616,
-0.1746014654636383,
-0.4585459232330322,
0.0022452273406088352,
-0.21545720100402832,
-1.2691558599472046,
-0.20700308680534363,
0.173336461186409,
0.7442507147789001,
0.3822033107280731,
-0.1883891224861145,
0.40973731875419617,
-0.49488547444343567,
0.9307563304901123,
0.4831278324127197,
-0.8425607085227966,
0.5467306971549988,
-0.32191088795661926,
-0.20185379683971405,
0.40685904026031494,
0.601011335849762,
-0.91367506980896,
-0.8002778887748718,
-0.7774377465248108,
-0.8997002840042114,
0.7447990775108337,
0.4734271764755249,
0.513526201248169,
-0.4170863926410675,
0.1442931741476059,
-0.1893017292022705,
0.14828428626060486,
-0.8956572413444519,
-0.7909973859786987,
0.0008302821079269052,
0.15596430003643036,
0.2339361011981964,
-0.8668928742408752,
-0.5293343663215637,
-0.017908327281475067,
0.6125864386558533,
0.19739773869514465,
0.2848648130893707,
0.14417938888072968,
-0.04408050701022148,
-0.20450499653816223,
0.3368730843067169,
0.6075845956802368,
0.6693543791770935,
0.30536994338035583,
0.05719415098428726,
-0.00513935461640358,
-0.5661900043487549,
-0.0771566852927208,
0.007708163000643253,
-0.03134765475988388,
0.0428549088537693,
0.4979753792285919,
0.8322100043296814,
0.48656314611434937,
0.08396395295858383,
0.7833720445632935,
-0.39798781275749207,
-0.18685166537761688,
-0.3676893413066864,
0.0023320892360061407,
0.18087762594223022,
0.48263198137283325,
0.22277244925498962,
-0.07134271413087845,
0.25440603494644165,
-0.6940094828605652,
0.20105797052383423,
0.28970491886138916,
-0.1422172635793686,
-0.42664679884910583,
0.5003488063812256,
0.629128634929657,
-0.23546232283115387,
0.4304550886154175,
-0.07391421496868134,
-0.5658158659934998,
0.11156636476516724,
-0.03657040745019913,
0.9491759538650513,
-0.11428643763065338,
0.6005592942237854,
0.5320641994476318,
0.12248936295509338,
0.051423437893390656,
0.32994377613067627,
-0.020778968930244446,
-0.88657546043396,
-0.3826422095298767,
-0.3849327862262726,
-0.3063911199569702,
0.07330697774887085,
-0.6239883303642273,
0.2179379165172577,
0.04739141836762428,
-0.23499158024787903,
0.373047798871994,
-0.1358811855316162,
-0.4804532527923584,
-0.3224523067474365,
0.3094901442527771,
0.6512609720230103,
-0.5755965709686279,
0.6401643753051758,
0.37615928053855896,
-0.7309635877609253,
-0.3353642523288727,
0.48151618242263794,
-0.08186672627925873,
-0.4034748375415802,
0.6355409026145935,
0.08745517581701279,
-0.2566225230693817,
0.14875197410583496,
-0.709476888179779,
-0.8721991777420044,
0.49296727776527405,
0.029665349051356316,
-0.25067877769470215,
0.0385269857943058,
0.19528111815452576,
0.5450676083564758,
-0.26693257689476013,
0.14832833409309387,
0.38431715965270996,
0.531883955001831,
-0.034677620977163315,
-0.9852188229560852,
-0.4526606798171997,
-0.45235681533813477,
-0.045977357774972916,
0.30373862385749817,
-0.9651263356208801,
0.8516844511032104,
-0.06949136406183243,
-0.500411331653595,
0.16903753578662872,
0.8186517953872681,
-0.41700148582458496,
-0.32410624623298645,
0.6488462090492249,
0.02853749692440033,
0.4639808237552643,
0.021102789789438248,
0.9772074222564697,
-0.7112777233123779,
0.15920399129390717,
0.8085034489631653,
0.09164705872535706,
0.6456748843193054,
0.6505312323570251,
-0.09110398590564728,
0.935776948928833,
0.3526880145072937,
0.1726398766040802,
0.4596180319786072,
0.2859727442264557,
-0.6858021020889282,
-0.021942880004644394,
-0.0667055994272232,
-0.3677094876766205,
0.4222174286842346,
0.6152965426445007,
0.039160411804914474,
-0.1375325620174408,
0.22366568446159363,
0.08916114270687103,
-0.005907402839511633,
-0.37102535367012024,
0.9867797493934631,
-0.055737219750881195,
-0.8295392990112305,
0.2182345688343048,
0.031169075518846512,
0.16843919456005096,
-0.04578900709748268,
-0.04590950161218643,
-0.25014644861221313,
0.11218926310539246,
-0.40814200043678284,
-1.0642547607421875,
0.22892418503761292,
-0.034136079251766205,
-0.3847428858280182,
-0.1697172075510025,
0.3917306661605835,
-0.5640090107917786,
-0.3379502594470978,
0.42247816920280457,
0.8025297522544861,
0.36651894450187683,
0.26389187574386597,
-0.6551597118377686,
0.2209043800830841,
0.07171918451786041,
-0.17361773550510406,
0.09979697316884995,
0.701758623123169,
-0.05951402336359024,
0.3874243497848511,
0.3040417730808258,
-0.04705997556447983,
0.06765960156917572,
0.304487407207489,
0.9081996083259583,
-0.4682917296886444,
-0.6099267601966858,
-0.8636748790740967,
0.5487051606178284,
-0.4797334372997284,
-0.03847891464829445,
0.9542660713195801,
0.529461681842804,
0.9195200800895691,
0.21210168302059174,
0.7506051063537598,
-0.24097920954227448,
0.709555983543396,
-0.3054549992084503,
0.3736775815486908,
-0.3351263105869293,
0.18461373448371887,
-0.2723847031593323,
-0.8151267766952515,
0.2904859185218811,
0.4351041913032532,
0.02035035751760006,
-0.1892770230770111,
0.8034417033195496,
0.3965134620666504,
0.15168406069278717,
0.5232411026954651,
-0.0700143352150917,
0.462711364030838,
0.10784225910902023,
0.18017491698265076,
1.3013129234313965,
-0.12336909025907516,
0.7642077207565308,
-0.31621143221855164,
0.014148185960948467,
-0.13442301750183105,
-0.6379200220108032,
-1.0025694370269775,
-0.8818878531455994,
-0.13963468372821808,
-0.5702307224273682,
-0.08227614313364029,
0.6612411141395569,
0.06060206890106201,
-0.8146430850028992,
-0.24940307438373566,
-0.13521437346935272,
0.2647092342376709,
0.3694664537906647,
-0.2291642427444458,
0.10464107245206833,
-0.20088569819927216,
-1.1420855522155762,
0.19375619292259216,
0.43310046195983887,
0.14186736941337585,
-0.6132077574729919,
0.12431839853525162,
-0.20910319685935974,
0.012045592069625854,
0.5119537711143494,
0.2146156132221222,
-0.573863685131073,
-0.5020322799682617,
-0.2713133990764618,
-0.22191590070724487,
-0.07425037026405334,
1.1639553308486938,
-0.1455073207616806,
0.3838690221309662,
0.5642757415771484,
0.1615665704011917,
0.6558219194412231,
-0.1795879602432251,
0.8166740536689758,
-0.7419856786727905,
0.4288507103919983,
-0.038821808993816376,
0.26028159260749817,
0.460673987865448,
-0.26774024963378906,
0.39806613326072693,
0.41879892349243164,
-0.39601725339889526,
-0.6716477870941162,
0.23909202218055725,
-0.3463965952396393,
-0.2594279944896698,
1.2018966674804688,
0.07006818801164627,
0.057055551558732986,
-0.23458409309387207,
-0.25972387194633484,
0.1838390976190567,
-0.37242141366004944,
0.4392082989215851,
1.299222707748413,
-0.2150757759809494,
-0.11444290727376938,
-0.9009946584701538,
0.5992007255554199,
-0.350266695022583,
-0.6979131102561951,
-0.18870893120765686,
0.6652892827987671,
0.03211250528693199,
0.5487277507781982,
1.0608348846435547,
0.21156272292137146,
0.026649052277207375,
-0.014500482939183712,
-0.26547133922576904,
0.6589860320091248,
-0.5736615061759949,
0.27016565203666687,
0.12075259536504745,
-0.2573530375957489,
-0.1562962532043457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19729v1 | Le sens de la famille : analyse du vocabulaire de la parent{é} par les plongements de mots | 2024-06-28T08:19:36 | 2024-06-28T08:19:36 | Ludovic Tanguy, Cécile Fabre, Nabil Hathout, Lydia-Mai Ho-Dac | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this study, we propose a corpus analysis of an area of the French lexicon
that is both dense and highly structured: the vocabulary of family
relationships. Starting with a lexicon of 25 nouns designating the main
relationships (son, cousin, mother, grandfather, sister-in-law etc.), we
examine how these terms are positioned in relation to each other through
distributional analyses based on the use of these terms in corpora. We show
that distributional information can capture certain features that organize this
vocabulary (descent, alliance, siblings, genre), in ways that vary according to
the different corpora compared. | [
-0.5783604383468628,
-0.6263799667358398,
0.21906335651874542,
0.41179144382476807,
-0.015486442483961582,
-0.037267979234457016,
0.11031337082386017,
-0.07303895056247711,
0.4232235848903656,
0.3992403745651245,
-0.39483442902565,
-0.15066736936569214,
-0.7817195653915405,
0.2016414850950241,
-0.3038851320743561,
0.6713959574699402,
-0.13276280462741852,
-0.11173580586910248,
-0.04629594832658768,
-0.5582597255706787,
0.06895790994167328,
-1.1747242212295532,
-0.8120849132537842,
0.08245033025741577,
0.7515526413917542,
0.07652294635772705,
0.8252822756767273,
0.6825428605079651,
0.4199945330619812,
0.2906697690486908,
-0.3926912248134613,
-0.028174296021461487,
-0.6285647749900818,
0.36760231852531433,
-0.17458386719226837,
-0.23762355744838715,
-0.2970592677593231,
-0.29290419816970825,
0.46337583661079407,
1.26115882396698,
0.4027397036552429,
-0.00813912134617567,
0.09960489720106125,
1.1867197751998901,
-0.6468630433082581,
0.23664258420467377,
-0.20133377611637115,
-0.06921329349279404,
0.04609493166208267,
-0.7211906313896179,
-0.037380997091531754,
-0.04663506895303726,
0.3294653594493866,
-0.1905863732099533,
0.7621787786483765,
-0.08398735523223877,
1.1174840927124023,
-0.14332319796085358,
-0.5287391543388367,
-0.48345404863357544,
-0.5459609627723694,
0.430610328912735,
0.23947261273860931,
0.6452727317810059,
0.44013577699661255,
-0.34306859970092773,
-0.3198654055595398,
-0.19166994094848633,
-0.2067583203315735,
-0.17844873666763306,
-0.2595154047012329,
-0.005201591644436121,
-0.41029343008995056,
-0.1622924655675888,
0.22013965249061584,
0.6483367085456848,
-0.4238441586494446,
-0.43853452801704407,
-0.29129812121391296,
-0.039709124714136124,
0.4527477025985718,
0.0024830717593431473,
0.6944258809089661,
-0.042510345578193665,
-0.5856807231903076,
-0.010276473127305508,
-0.5553213357925415,
-0.18722739815711975,
0.6671901941299438,
0.06817644089460373,
-0.43430137634277344,
0.7526499629020691,
0.02650066278874874,
0.5002947449684143,
-0.10681699216365814,
-0.07711931318044662,
0.3000168204307556,
-0.40871453285217285,
0.11800569295883179,
-0.17629878222942352,
0.7516918182373047,
0.5147354602813721,
0.715895414352417,
-0.10103526711463928,
-0.2824915647506714,
0.17412810027599335,
-0.13451401889324188,
-0.5516186952590942,
-0.19460982084274292,
-0.004220569506287575,
-0.3603757321834564,
-0.17441010475158691,
0.17073364555835724,
-0.7275391817092896,
-0.34371206164360046,
-0.19120115041732788,
0.0815340057015419,
-0.5104281902313232,
-0.34438616037368774,
-0.11428964883089066,
-0.4517010450363159,
0.1757941097021103,
-0.07040916383266449,
-1.0600031614303589,
0.3390774130821228,
0.5664833188056946,
1.0232104063034058,
-0.18560516834259033,
-0.2002047300338745,
-0.33899691700935364,
0.40186864137649536,
-0.04140745475888252,
0.7410323023796082,
-0.487948477268219,
-0.9417300224304199,
0.3824690580368042,
0.07013434916734695,
-0.3517686426639557,
-0.4284537434577942,
0.40894269943237305,
-0.3278389871120453,
-0.11625095456838608,
0.04170095548033714,
-0.603985071182251,
0.011245159432291985,
-0.025811441242694855,
-1.0617722272872925,
0.7052439451217651,
0.6016210913658142,
-0.9331677556037903,
0.2698438763618469,
-0.2725505828857422,
-0.2893209755420685,
0.03399583697319031,
-0.39453235268592834,
0.10468824952840805,
0.12911541759967804,
-0.04403636232018471,
0.7198681831359863,
0.02749614231288433,
-0.17637671530246735,
-0.06330769509077072,
0.12192188948392868,
0.10716910660266876,
0.08937311917543411,
0.820001482963562,
0.40992435812950134,
0.02060885727405548,
-0.12117692828178406,
-0.5685983896255493,
-0.7938330173492432,
0.14163146913051605,
0.014104883186519146,
-0.7825682759284973,
0.06304209679365158,
0.14637190103530884,
0.004641801118850708,
0.14960210025310516,
-0.42107754945755005,
0.20620349049568176,
-0.5643813610076904,
0.5995817184448242,
0.16569167375564575,
0.4434172809123993,
0.8141218423843384,
-0.2749648690223694,
0.6037128567695618,
0.1838567852973938,
0.20998723804950714,
0.13470666110515594,
-0.49188387393951416,
-0.5543596148490906,
-0.24819886684417725,
0.46948981285095215,
0.6360076665878296,
-0.5117588639259338,
0.7215713262557983,
-0.5673897862434387,
0.10946686565876007,
0.1484636515378952,
0.3928382992744446,
0.04617788642644882,
-0.0001745583867887035,
0.005567729938775301,
-0.477770060300827,
-0.19291605055332184,
-1.0524414777755737,
0.39021173119544983,
-0.060318250209093094,
0.20108406245708466,
0.17163465917110443,
0.7628251314163208,
-0.0030641225166618824,
0.6525135040283203,
-0.6474703550338745,
-0.3707151710987091,
-0.46059513092041016,
-0.08251026272773743,
-0.1683633178472519,
0.2070971131324768,
0.966603696346283,
-1.0909626483917236,
-0.29911932349205017,
0.21360093355178833,
-0.2734009623527527,
0.1738411784172058,
0.3026779592037201,
-0.5675328373908997,
-0.02217196859419346,
0.4790283739566803,
-0.14115367829799652,
0.5599304437637329,
0.6195963621139526,
-0.769900381565094,
0.16544243693351746,
-0.02143000066280365,
-0.3690933883190155,
-1.2197563648223877,
-0.2455887645483017,
0.21537156403064728,
-0.07497020810842514,
-0.5090352892875671,
0.22599053382873535,
-0.24409863352775574,
0.2227495312690735,
-0.46908071637153625,
0.8777704834938049,
-0.39197298884391785,
0.1527891755104065,
-0.008012705482542515,
0.4923126995563507,
-0.07698342204093933,
0.3814924955368042,
0.17807884514331818,
0.618979811668396,
0.3253929913043976,
-0.5870667695999146,
0.38491207361221313,
0.4339374601840973,
0.2284994274377823,
0.823820173740387,
-0.32517480850219727,
-0.4092453420162201,
-0.2760644555091858,
0.04276813194155693,
-1.0123798847198486,
-0.30069196224212646,
0.10716235637664795,
-0.6602460741996765,
0.10159995406866074,
-0.07933156937360764,
-0.6774081587791443,
-0.009372474625706673,
-0.28659260272979736,
0.49192023277282715,
-0.023713508620858192,
-0.184812530875206,
0.5303347110748291,
0.6617339253425598,
-0.04513601213693619,
-0.5128896832466125,
-0.3334370255470276,
-0.2975415289402008,
-0.28705689311027527,
-1.137219786643982,
0.14743414521217346,
0.09402469545602798,
-0.8100152015686035,
0.23737704753875732,
-0.14252665638923645,
-0.6874998807907104,
0.16192296147346497,
0.1977146863937378,
0.2924357056617737,
-0.23411095142364502,
0.4771137833595276,
-0.1001330018043518,
0.21461062133312225,
-0.22551816701889038,
0.23501744866371155,
0.6648614406585693,
-0.04806825518608093,
0.7602535486221313,
0.042997706681489944,
0.6393679976463318,
0.4723455607891083,
-0.022368542850017548,
1.0576989650726318,
0.04536963626742363,
-0.3383021354675293,
-0.4529472291469574,
-0.4681040346622467,
0.02924392558634281,
-0.3285179138183594,
-0.16669239103794098,
-0.7698702812194824,
-0.8507300019264221,
0.7124643325805664,
0.2252681702375412,
-0.22932760417461395,
0.7255728840827942,
0.49625685811042786,
-0.1787591427564621,
0.42713841795921326,
0.8438833951950073,
-0.12860602140426636,
0.250738263130188,
-0.6909976005554199,
0.11517615616321564,
-0.8277227878570557,
0.027447868138551712,
-0.4537546932697296,
-0.09035813063383102,
-0.5019006729125977,
-0.24079887568950653,
-0.030944814905524254,
0.2164236158132553,
-0.07014573365449905,
0.5789092183113098,
-0.24692972004413605,
0.2016935795545578,
0.22687125205993652,
-0.1237790435552597,
0.3777952194213867,
0.07129672914743423,
-0.23068185150623322,
0.38932904601097107,
-0.5095335841178894,
-0.817389726638794,
0.6146922707557678,
0.4331851303577423,
0.24375542998313904,
0.44113072752952576,
0.7672786116600037,
-0.1288336217403412,
0.456722229719162,
-1.1609714031219482,
0.4424256682395935,
-0.6348662376403809,
-0.7807047367095947,
-0.09858563542366028,
-0.6011543273925781,
-1.3600027561187744,
0.18685191869735718,
-0.03188196197152138,
-0.7610914707183838,
0.8665834069252014,
-0.21533557772636414,
-0.6300719380378723,
0.15574778616428375,
-0.8168624043464661,
0.8407037854194641,
0.016773143783211708,
-0.40005558729171753,
0.21262748539447784,
-0.43421489000320435,
0.36443519592285156,
-0.037117261439561844,
0.29670315980911255,
-0.4549940228462219,
-0.40524211525917053,
0.7901694774627686,
-0.510137140750885,
0.46946629881858826,
0.3483831286430359,
-0.09024389088153839,
0.28287068009376526,
0.5003510117530823,
-0.3313165307044983,
-0.018711470067501068,
-0.05751954764127731,
-0.16696813702583313,
0.6556436419487,
-0.4844185709953308,
-0.41845861077308655,
0.9637171626091003,
-0.8537812829017639,
-0.07465940713882446,
-0.6345720291137695,
-0.7352959513664246,
-0.438869833946228,
-0.20751889050006866,
0.37833595275878906,
0.7634994983673096,
-0.2668721079826355,
0.4552046060562134,
0.3560395836830139,
-0.12362090498209,
0.34844404458999634,
0.16542130708694458,
-0.23183609545230865,
-0.2272515743970871,
0.7369410395622253,
0.4403386116027832,
0.3529641628265381,
0.6878543496131897,
0.35235169529914856,
-0.25814253091812134,
-0.15087445080280304,
-0.034614160656929016,
0.6807944774627686,
-0.4326755702495575,
0.2568340003490448,
-0.7183895707130432,
-0.19260680675506592,
-0.0822078287601471,
-0.29123011231422424,
-0.109290212392807,
-0.36967945098876953,
-0.03892899677157402,
-0.27105265855789185,
0.1700587421655655,
0.5625686049461365,
0.2690059244632721,
0.4053686857223511,
-0.7753185629844666,
0.473638653755188,
0.16070763766765594,
0.24388587474822998,
-0.06207374855875969,
-0.24867822229862213,
0.3106840252876282,
-0.5233982801437378,
-0.1715981513261795,
-1.0260403156280518,
0.3373855948448181,
0.1193997859954834,
0.325000524520874,
0.332564115524292,
-0.08717262744903564,
0.182021826505661,
-0.2003549486398697,
0.6712194681167603,
0.2313469499349594,
-0.6809359192848206,
0.20848555862903595,
-0.7278391718864441,
-0.18012647330760956,
0.737740159034729,
0.5691608786582947,
-0.3651880919933319,
0.07341577857732773,
-1.0917613506317139,
-1.188158392906189,
0.11415646970272064,
0.5984055399894714,
0.41387271881103516,
-0.2636585235595703,
0.4309465289115906,
0.0031084211077541113,
0.2513104975223541,
-0.4523361921310425,
-0.6803523898124695,
0.24808435142040253,
-0.42538678646087646,
0.030362561345100403,
-0.2827761769294739,
-0.2851400673389435,
-0.41061556339263916,
0.38517633080482483,
0.25758904218673706,
0.2894291579723358,
0.5581080317497253,
0.022937584668397903,
-0.07562077045440674,
-0.012668471783399582,
0.5537709593772888,
0.8566884994506836,
-0.17685262858867645,
0.30699315667152405,
-0.369149774312973,
-0.6230857372283936,
0.2478313148021698,
-0.1413360983133316,
0.0017775207525119185,
0.11860927939414978,
0.5371402502059937,
0.5411025881767273,
0.25062984228134155,
-0.27678805589675903,
0.9003390669822693,
0.09632090479135513,
-0.5292930603027344,
-0.6986469030380249,
-0.19435356557369232,
0.4779864251613617,
-0.15525266528129578,
0.07017631083726883,
-0.29622510075569153,
-0.06813463568687439,
-1.1586241722106934,
0.5606363415718079,
0.30470937490463257,
-0.46854135394096375,
-0.23788529634475708,
0.3949805200099945,
0.41364485025405884,
-0.13675625622272491,
0.15838876366615295,
-0.43333899974823,
-0.5383087992668152,
0.47144216299057007,
-0.0352754183113575,
0.834847092628479,
-0.25634124875068665,
0.33965158462524414,
0.4254906475543976,
0.0662313923239708,
-0.016208739951252937,
0.3291897773742676,
0.07823076844215393,
-1.193413257598877,
-0.32703882455825806,
-0.9612313508987427,
-0.04070707783102989,
0.23907141387462616,
-0.36827462911605835,
0.21275360882282257,
-0.2761722207069397,
-0.012473898008465767,
0.3040935695171356,
-0.2785147726535797,
-0.7192672491073608,
0.08447720855474472,
0.16467784345149994,
0.7821584939956665,
-0.5992991328239441,
0.7730777859687805,
0.4636305272579193,
-0.6704726815223694,
-0.8634647130966187,
0.10836251080036163,
-0.28778931498527527,
-0.5544553399085999,
1.2175238132476807,
-0.10162107646465302,
-0.4538017511367798,
0.0733063668012619,
-0.16346479952335358,
-0.7772132754325867,
0.5856366157531738,
-0.0365237295627594,
-0.5309256911277771,
0.013641108758747578,
-0.22882060706615448,
0.683597981929779,
-0.618535578250885,
-0.10039304196834564,
0.7887974381446838,
0.4002223312854767,
0.01951938308775425,
-0.5298449993133545,
-0.13946056365966797,
-0.24558095633983612,
-0.0742054358124733,
0.6954480409622192,
-0.6858559250831604,
0.6793813705444336,
0.34114280343055725,
-0.4972178041934967,
0.13832223415374756,
0.6013872623443604,
-0.3521004915237427,
0.1771654337644577,
0.8203719854354858,
0.290760338306427,
0.17563211917877197,
-0.18307629227638245,
1.3756531476974487,
-0.7623423933982849,
0.31592869758605957,
0.7345377802848816,
-0.1755957454442978,
0.8906196355819702,
0.6087955236434937,
-0.330526202917099,
0.45837458968162537,
0.5200294852256775,
0.17392776906490326,
-0.1302964687347412,
0.5363244414329529,
-0.5196015238761902,
0.09369474649429321,
-0.2214309424161911,
0.023250684142112732,
0.3275805413722992,
0.7816042900085449,
-0.5818384885787964,
-0.11287681013345718,
-0.2104923129081726,
0.08784864097833633,
0.2635728418827057,
-0.4365312457084656,
0.5403186082839966,
0.4970412254333496,
-0.35593587160110474,
0.41689592599868774,
-0.5427330732345581,
0.4319906532764435,
-0.3385023772716522,
0.23476020991802216,
-0.17778714001178741,
-0.08616400510072708,
-0.57030189037323,
-0.8074396252632141,
0.19799163937568665,
-0.3987720310688019,
-0.05656208097934723,
0.2824564278125763,
0.3992331027984619,
-0.30415329337120056,
-0.4311417043209076,
0.8667155504226685,
1.0878946781158447,
-0.037911515682935715,
0.012409050948917866,
-0.38323453068733215,
-0.1298058032989502,
-0.2773423194885254,
-0.40353548526763916,
0.08533262461423874,
0.5013749599456787,
-0.1483009159564972,
0.2932879626750946,
0.15728916227817535,
0.2577623426914215,
0.333629310131073,
0.28400009870529175,
0.434946745634079,
-0.6687818169593811,
-0.3583987355232239,
-0.6603690981864929,
0.24967123568058014,
-0.10482918471097946,
-0.662432849407196,
0.5980687141418457,
0.4050701856613159,
0.631929337978363,
0.004649251699447632,
0.708853542804718,
-0.1062128096818924,
0.375434547662735,
-0.005152687430381775,
0.0723978653550148,
-0.45779821276664734,
0.02631847746670246,
-0.13377226889133453,
-1.3633521795272827,
-0.5394789576530457,
0.5732775330543518,
-0.5040322542190552,
-0.35868480801582336,
1.0630687475204468,
0.6074626445770264,
-0.18331678211688995,
0.07172482460737228,
0.4309141933917999,
0.17661745846271515,
-0.2567143440246582,
0.31944864988327026,
0.8533506393432617,
-0.04710625484585762,
0.3961806297302246,
-0.7731029391288757,
-0.2591473460197449,
-0.2522311210632324,
-0.417657732963562,
-0.7857073545455933,
-1.0338009595870972,
-0.21583931148052216,
-0.3639902174472809,
0.1241416186094284,
1.0119796991348267,
0.18663284182548523,
-0.6466909646987915,
-0.547890305519104,
-0.05400776490569115,
-0.03166157007217407,
-0.15232358872890472,
-0.2975488007068634,
0.565665066242218,
-0.11960867047309875,
-0.912110447883606,
0.15988880395889282,
0.18591465055942535,
-0.1281437873840332,
-0.316034734249115,
0.22280868887901306,
-0.31646230816841125,
0.2683073878288269,
0.8412100076675415,
-0.021014690399169922,
-0.3276074230670929,
-0.502174973487854,
-0.25541484355926514,
-0.33667781949043274,
-0.017979774624109268,
1.1667994260787964,
-0.14773185551166534,
0.21749889850616455,
1.0585107803344727,
0.1964789777994156,
-0.049751948565244675,
0.370099276304245,
0.6275559663772583,
-0.8311031460762024,
0.29790014028549194,
0.2581435739994049,
0.6630043387413025,
0.2372031956911087,
-0.43737345933914185,
1.052328109741211,
0.5340136885643005,
-0.3247803747653961,
-0.38998717069625854,
0.48864322900772095,
-1.3177049160003662,
-0.49916526675224304,
1.499213695526123,
0.21941250562667847,
-0.42874476313591003,
-0.6651851534843445,
-0.3251546323299408,
0.13665784895420074,
-0.5418452024459839,
-0.012153311632573605,
1.1171042919158936,
-0.3613000512123108,
0.02968333475291729,
-1.1583266258239746,
0.5899181962013245,
0.079245924949646,
-0.014195363968610764,
-0.06480562686920166,
0.1993110626935959,
0.13958044350147247,
0.6902841329574585,
0.47581347823143005,
-0.29674389958381653,
-0.018020393326878548,
-0.1220666766166687,
-0.014755694195628166,
0.45720812678337097,
-0.178190678358078,
-0.23521867394447327,
0.7387405633926392,
-0.06163976341485977,
-0.039271049201488495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19712v1 | Uncertainty Quantification in Large Language Models Through Convex Hull Analysis | 2024-06-28T07:47:34 | 2024-06-28T07:47:34 | Ferhat Ozgur Catak, Murat Kuzlu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Uncertainty quantification approaches have been more critical in large
language models (LLMs), particularly high-risk applications requiring reliable
outputs. However, traditional methods for uncertainty quantification, such as
probabilistic models and ensemble techniques, face challenges when applied to
the complex and high-dimensional nature of LLM-generated outputs. This study
proposes a novel geometric approach to uncertainty quantification using convex
hull analysis. The proposed method leverages the spatial properties of response
embeddings to measure the dispersion and variability of model outputs. The
prompts are categorized into three types, i.e., `easy', `moderate', and
`confusing', to generate multiple responses using different LLMs at varying
temperature settings. The responses are transformed into high-dimensional
embeddings via a BERT model and subsequently projected into a two-dimensional
space using Principal Component Analysis (PCA). The Density-Based Spatial
Clustering of Applications with Noise (DBSCAN) algorithm is utilized to cluster
the embeddings and compute the convex hull for each selected cluster. The
experimental results indicate that the uncertainty of the model for LLMs
depends on the prompt complexity, the model, and the temperature setting. | [
-0.5130012631416321,
-1.549804449081421,
0.825720489025116,
0.28091317415237427,
-0.201353520154953,
-0.09494244307279587,
-0.3717656433582306,
-0.10504249483346939,
0.12421753257513046,
-0.006525720003992319,
-0.3834001123905182,
-0.6880958676338196,
-0.674311101436615,
-0.12114842236042023,
-0.07731395959854126,
0.3433457612991333,
0.017054017633199692,
0.11660482734441757,
-0.15551503002643585,
0.16124069690704346,
-0.33175888657569885,
-0.47457271814346313,
-0.4821719229221344,
0.23295742273330688,
0.419341504573822,
0.1473575234413147,
0.8959961533546448,
0.2887420952320099,
0.7038514614105225,
0.3268689513206482,
-0.10022178292274475,
-0.13952499628067017,
-0.2266848087310791,
0.19434432685375214,
0.01462517585605383,
-0.1896241456270218,
-0.38004109263420105,
-0.3080996870994568,
0.7991180419921875,
0.9144987463951111,
-0.33262985944747925,
0.05400508642196655,
0.2522144317626953,
0.36115092039108276,
-0.6735928654670715,
0.4217587411403656,
-0.6268483996391296,
0.08161457628011703,
-0.15867434442043304,
0.20270828902721405,
-0.1549096256494522,
-0.5703928470611572,
0.17262394726276398,
-0.6795449256896973,
-0.09812580049037933,
0.029094107449054718,
0.36847934126853943,
0.4276307225227356,
-0.4467869699001312,
-0.42071497440338135,
-1.0001614093780518,
1.1665383577346802,
-1.0818805694580078,
0.4310576021671295,
0.36780571937561035,
0.31282076239585876,
-0.3542267978191376,
-0.17621129751205444,
-0.7879302501678467,
0.12889312207698822,
0.10719318687915802,
0.1002502515912056,
-0.20224514603614807,
0.053859975188970566,
-0.25962987542152405,
0.2760962247848511,
-0.6827894449234009,
0.4276559054851532,
0.004326650407165289,
-0.16798906028270721,
0.6140525937080383,
0.2204640805721283,
0.06778522580862045,
-0.16772431135177612,
-0.10367149114608765,
-0.4575551450252533,
-0.17657950520515442,
0.1920972764492035,
0.4728648066520691,
0.45625919103622437,
-0.3617978096008301,
0.6746749877929688,
0.08682036399841309,
0.6332581639289856,
-0.1363360583782196,
-0.29643675684928894,
0.011877848766744137,
-0.06507009267807007,
-0.2140474021434784,
-0.18296603858470917,
0.9388282299041748,
0.04944995790719986,
-0.14643517136573792,
0.4183332920074463,
-0.09663542360067368,
-0.21146321296691895,
0.08500052988529205,
-0.3984665274620056,
-0.07995892316102982,
0.5928617119789124,
-0.24687990546226501,
-0.34849560260772705,
0.08021534979343414,
-1.2258663177490234,
-0.4617394506931305,
-0.07853943854570389,
0.5032182931900024,
-0.40992623567581177,
-0.39188989996910095,
0.3968501389026642,
0.4386427402496338,
0.1728825867176056,
0.1647876650094986,
-0.6321532130241394,
0.037533655762672424,
0.6467906832695007,
0.5904046893119812,
-0.23917438089847565,
0.031177042052149773,
-0.10808471590280533,
0.27948465943336487,
-0.400876522064209,
0.5594000220298767,
-0.7238214612007141,
-0.5062891840934753,
0.3576820492744446,
-0.4652213156223297,
0.15351489186286926,
-0.1447744071483612,
0.29774796962738037,
-0.2096284180879593,
0.04895736277103424,
-0.22863730788230896,
-0.44864538311958313,
-0.11788375675678253,
0.29951542615890503,
-0.7817984223365784,
1.4380712509155273,
0.058304570615291595,
-0.797223687171936,
0.21898657083511353,
-0.1518528014421463,
-0.2992820739746094,
0.036523766815662384,
-0.47987836599349976,
-0.7992448806762695,
0.38890621066093445,
0.3511583209037781,
0.852688193321228,
-0.3680179715156555,
0.3904725909233093,
-0.7547889351844788,
-0.12277203798294067,
0.6745114326477051,
-0.3456866145133972,
0.3525443971157074,
0.21939556300640106,
-0.2652955651283264,
-0.11093086749315262,
-0.894509494304657,
0.13965478539466858,
0.005377914756536484,
-0.5604214668273926,
-0.4286283254623413,
0.2075616717338562,
-0.13638858497142792,
-0.09016036242246628,
0.4423789978027344,
-0.5079777836799622,
0.28844961524009705,
-0.15930277109146118,
0.27770864963531494,
0.7171992659568787,
0.26533976197242737,
0.3861334025859833,
-0.04227571561932564,
0.509840190410614,
0.2938152253627777,
0.24829286336898804,
0.4957408010959625,
-0.7045168876647949,
-0.43632885813713074,
-0.4522857666015625,
-0.0908123329281807,
0.5439215898513794,
-0.6474725008010864,
0.5741987228393555,
-0.12385768443346024,
-0.6010382771492004,
-0.07220536470413208,
-0.28964895009994507,
0.03005463257431984,
-0.11817234009504318,
0.07304548472166061,
0.10352271050214767,
-0.41011014580726624,
-0.6457986235618591,
0.1505078673362732,
-0.4417775273323059,
-0.10406658798456192,
0.2757105827331543,
0.35334357619285583,
-0.14676079154014587,
0.9136382937431335,
-0.802416980266571,
-0.040323540568351746,
-0.1469728946685791,
0.1947004795074463,
0.5859576463699341,
0.47230294346809387,
0.6244576573371887,
-0.41436833143234253,
-0.3576889634132385,
0.25309988856315613,
-0.4731842577457428,
0.034361690282821655,
-0.17974893748760223,
-0.05501467362046242,
0.010668515227735043,
0.3705911636352539,
-0.6696722507476807,
0.5812165141105652,
0.7370600700378418,
0.057667773216962814,
0.641972005367279,
-0.15382172167301178,
0.005076148081570864,
-1.2190102338790894,
-0.138666033744812,
0.1162075623869896,
0.1806749552488327,
-0.5090753436088562,
-0.08738195151090622,
-0.25656071305274963,
-0.11903740465641022,
-0.1641257405281067,
0.16081762313842773,
-0.2850998044013977,
-0.33353370428085327,
0.07848328351974487,
0.03219877555966377,
-0.16741783916950226,
0.4255716800689697,
0.08596677333116531,
0.41044682264328003,
0.7031298875808716,
-0.564628005027771,
0.4473850727081299,
0.2574969232082367,
-0.4735214412212372,
0.7674192786216736,
-0.8178192973136902,
-0.08191025257110596,
-0.15743881464004517,
-0.010015624575316906,
-1.4026027917861938,
-0.13289450109004974,
0.2765481472015381,
-0.35818541049957275,
0.3422820270061493,
0.14749303460121155,
-0.2990470826625824,
-0.3795737028121948,
-0.20429137349128723,
0.5817340016365051,
0.13206997513771057,
0.0486564114689827,
0.5031870007514954,
0.39260634779930115,
-0.7379748225212097,
-0.3894200623035431,
-0.5587400197982788,
-0.2391292303800583,
-0.36005499958992004,
-0.4296882748603821,
0.03040008246898651,
-0.25384125113487244,
-0.3450137674808502,
-0.3481309711933136,
-0.02854727953672409,
-0.5016468167304993,
0.12491469085216522,
0.28772953152656555,
-0.017967047169804573,
-0.1838131546974182,
0.015063445083796978,
0.19698049128055573,
0.1914910227060318,
0.15713296830654144,
-0.37568971514701843,
0.5024663805961609,
-0.05229058861732483,
-0.543968915939331,
-0.3616391718387604,
0.5246479511260986,
0.5105032920837402,
-0.121892549097538,
0.7028687596321106,
0.8167921304702759,
-0.5993484854698181,
-0.33384808897972107,
-0.48559579253196716,
-0.12408027797937393,
-0.4813252389431,
0.5828606486320496,
-0.4541827142238617,
-0.7540221810340881,
0.7808954119682312,
0.1957147866487503,
-0.047401588410139084,
0.2901436686515808,
0.8119252324104309,
-0.3838508725166321,
0.8456975221633911,
0.5614849925041199,
-0.12410296499729156,
0.17362000048160553,
-0.013310783542692661,
0.5278518795967102,
-0.3861672878265381,
-0.3283732831478119,
-0.8857381939888,
-0.3559110164642334,
-0.4890085756778717,
-0.622377336025238,
0.8679428696632385,
-0.06437460333108902,
-0.25630509853363037,
0.009414061903953552,
-0.22655710577964783,
0.007896034978330135,
0.5500756502151489,
0.07814966142177582,
0.09312029927968979,
0.19956034421920776,
-0.27358412742614746,
-0.3149670362472534,
-0.5142356753349304,
-0.2561960220336914,
0.751639187335968,
0.49307185411453247,
1.0410953760147095,
0.49930885434150696,
0.3942263424396515,
0.15808804333209991,
-0.36932748556137085,
-0.6712296605110168,
0.3604563772678375,
-0.019583923742175102,
-0.22172792255878448,
-0.8663708567619324,
-0.5935761332511902,
-0.9092137813568115,
0.13158436119556427,
-0.3456382751464844,
-0.7947689890861511,
0.35402148962020874,
-0.08332487940788269,
-0.6788785457611084,
0.4167734682559967,
-0.18363283574581146,
0.41656026244163513,
-0.0627773329615593,
-0.06871575862169266,
-0.00949131604284048,
-0.26887694001197815,
0.011042161844670773,
-0.3833529055118561,
0.5611310005187988,
-0.055574458092451096,
0.2014160305261612,
0.3939603865146637,
-0.25014492869377136,
1.0246464014053345,
-0.12461575120687485,
-0.6809244155883789,
0.2562820315361023,
0.6676594614982605,
0.711591899394989,
0.29523152112960815,
-0.19742144644260406,
0.3523918688297272,
0.14888817071914673,
-0.37103724479675293,
-0.45856574177742004,
0.569186270236969,
-0.8919485807418823,
-0.3735255300998688,
-0.3130102753639221,
-0.877184271812439,
-0.4813135266304016,
0.01632433570921421,
0.4837554693222046,
0.23246696591377258,
-0.136240616440773,
0.17086462676525116,
0.6369173526763916,
-0.820242702960968,
0.3474799692630768,
0.3539191782474518,
-0.005735414568334818,
-0.17200978100299835,
0.7127569913864136,
0.20225562155246735,
-0.06645994633436203,
0.4449958801269531,
0.22507871687412262,
-0.18785476684570312,
-0.9427322149276733,
0.04703902825713158,
0.08921249955892563,
-0.21716657280921936,
-0.2629755139350891,
-0.25189995765686035,
0.0781422108411789,
-0.5696517825126648,
-0.346427321434021,
-0.49505719542503357,
-0.32768887281417847,
-0.373552143573761,
-0.26637399196624756,
0.17421680688858032,
1.0612837076187134,
-0.21271257102489471,
0.5852311849594116,
-0.5768945217132568,
-0.03607143834233284,
0.2783597707748413,
0.3113810420036316,
-0.19566982984542847,
-0.32168710231781006,
-0.3098403513431549,
0.3741193413734436,
-0.10992804169654846,
-0.9950376749038696,
0.46552228927612305,
0.32524412870407104,
0.6867691278457642,
0.4142951965332031,
0.2395528107881546,
0.4041181802749634,
-0.1570511907339096,
0.8796604871749878,
0.095963254570961,
-1.0257941484451294,
0.43557897210121155,
-0.5484524369239807,
0.21675021946430206,
0.04755888134241104,
0.39851614832878113,
-0.1631302535533905,
-0.5636311769485474,
-0.08638639003038406,
-0.8701756000518799,
0.12502437829971313,
0.11335891485214233,
-0.042976994067430496,
-0.017437921836972237,
0.5151765942573547,
0.01721830479800701,
0.07433732599020004,
-0.5423775315284729,
0.0032134398352354765,
0.04737961292266846,
-0.3724311590194702,
-0.04254227876663208,
-0.6176068186759949,
0.1542600691318512,
-0.044575147330760956,
0.5098029971122742,
-0.05775894224643707,
0.4525359272956848,
-0.029830599203705788,
-0.08482766151428223,
-0.06944163143634796,
0.2094743549823761,
0.5489306449890137,
0.5131305456161499,
-0.38060423731803894,
0.20392750203609467,
0.21160414814949036,
-0.5220244526863098,
0.0971967950463295,
-0.22652292251586914,
0.18407973647117615,
0.13039839267730713,
0.42258724570274353,
0.4323234558105469,
0.2512114346027374,
-0.2966814935207367,
0.5209858417510986,
-0.03690831735730171,
-0.1855010986328125,
-0.469978392124176,
-0.47262808680534363,
-0.187804713845253,
0.32199424505233765,
0.4377804696559906,
-0.3840905725955963,
0.16547492146492004,
-0.06024714186787605,
0.17086179554462433,
0.41859936714172363,
-0.2407248616218567,
-0.4300844669342041,
0.42017483711242676,
-0.006876741535961628,
0.5272824764251709,
0.660901665687561,
0.01763656735420227,
-0.2915670573711395,
0.6306900382041931,
0.3612942695617676,
0.46615836024284363,
-0.582861602306366,
0.35660234093666077,
0.47040465474128723,
0.5866386890411377,
0.29978078603744507,
0.5902840495109558,
0.360365629196167,
-0.9125726819038391,
-0.505017101764679,
-0.8995258212089539,
-0.30183181166648865,
0.03836672753095627,
-1.1460464000701904,
-0.14811943471431732,
-0.516451358795166,
-0.49984437227249146,
-0.12413131445646286,
-0.14509013295173645,
-0.5236349105834961,
0.08349402248859406,
0.174282506108284,
0.5075581669807434,
-1.0193378925323486,
0.6521674394607544,
0.5571199059486389,
0.051166877150535583,
-0.7483623027801514,
-0.2005549520254135,
0.10346154868602753,
-0.6955010294914246,
0.2818370759487152,
-0.2398819476366043,
0.07532847672700882,
-0.18611401319503784,
-0.3251296579837799,
-1.1085976362228394,
0.8417225480079651,
0.428986519575119,
-0.7677658200263977,
0.12557891011238098,
0.8593215942382812,
0.3404247462749481,
-0.023104548454284668,
-0.03436199203133583,
0.6277311444282532,
0.6501442193984985,
0.04939548298716545,
-0.8298539519309998,
-0.04594450816512108,
0.19303449988365173,
0.4245414733886719,
0.14034445583820343,
-0.152567520737648,
1.0569244623184204,
-0.20833785831928253,
-0.1666608452796936,
0.11132673919200897,
0.7784445285797119,
0.1394391506910324,
-0.043127454817295074,
0.3724231421947479,
0.6106618046760559,
0.83930504322052,
-0.3472921848297119,
0.8084964752197266,
-0.18863996863365173,
0.7902929186820984,
0.9046897292137146,
-0.3808255195617676,
1.0424041748046875,
0.5729719996452332,
-0.6491004228591919,
0.3951050937175751,
0.7079887986183167,
0.15654224157333374,
0.24930976331233978,
0.5392407774925232,
-0.2408743053674698,
-0.20665313303470612,
0.12972500920295715,
-0.36459362506866455,
0.3276841640472412,
0.9359192848205566,
0.21474239230155945,
-0.04920247942209244,
0.1954021155834198,
-0.00020047760335728526,
0.021800311282277107,
-0.09318291395902634,
0.7133363485336304,
0.08595997095108032,
-0.11788742244243622,
0.47107768058776855,
0.03490108996629715,
0.4675666391849518,
-0.47152480483055115,
0.23435577750205994,
-0.33703428506851196,
0.14556953310966492,
-0.06709349900484085,
-0.8849853277206421,
0.4235779941082001,
-0.40643224120140076,
-0.054830387234687805,
0.20041508972644806,
-0.012525615282356739,
-0.5516315698623657,
-0.9509638547897339,
0.06001326069235802,
0.35623493790626526,
0.10912147909402847,
-0.2034505307674408,
-0.539014458656311,
0.6720085144042969,
-0.18660493195056915,
-0.3617526888847351,
0.014004144817590714,
0.630492627620697,
0.0676664412021637,
0.5702784657478333,
0.5188819766044617,
0.03645138815045357,
0.34485897421836853,
-0.2866309881210327,
0.5056382417678833,
-0.186043381690979,
-0.4483700692653656,
-0.7908194065093994,
0.3801877200603485,
0.38481616973876953,
-0.20134124159812927,
0.77731853723526,
0.35460221767425537,
0.4639345109462738,
-0.2537544369697571,
0.8202474117279053,
-0.07996062934398651,
0.27170130610466003,
-0.6472910046577454,
0.43725040555000305,
-0.2634681463241577,
0.37633538246154785,
-0.499423086643219,
-1.2392284870147705,
-0.48343712091445923,
0.9175761938095093,
-0.17526313662528992,
-0.06783593446016312,
0.5937916040420532,
0.8467012643814087,
0.022367997094988823,
-0.22393453121185303,
0.4688325822353363,
0.7612303495407104,
0.31128808856010437,
0.6844833493232727,
0.6032318472862244,
-0.13774138689041138,
0.3884284496307373,
-0.295859158039093,
-0.3515220284461975,
-0.1229807659983635,
-0.9000268578529358,
-0.5662426948547363,
-1.0478678941726685,
-0.3482702970504761,
-0.322336345911026,
-0.16282378137111664,
0.5557667016983032,
0.7343753576278687,
-1.0177297592163086,
-0.3724667727947235,
0.27318716049194336,
-0.0856868177652359,
-0.26550713181495667,
-0.25970548391342163,
0.6508029103279114,
-0.06465711444616318,
-0.7894622087478638,
0.25469061732292175,
0.21519333124160767,
0.2536059617996216,
-0.5518352389335632,
0.17879687249660492,
-0.04700044170022011,
0.3862403929233551,
0.6524258255958557,
-0.12733855843544006,
-0.5549936294555664,
-0.49900752305984497,
-0.25218454003334045,
-0.20715413987636566,
-0.3327252268791199,
0.5533356070518494,
-0.08307375758886337,
0.1783200204372406,
0.56695955991745,
0.6711798906326294,
0.41144296526908875,
-0.3237744867801666,
0.8796149492263794,
-1.1733320951461792,
0.27810657024383545,
-0.027573853731155396,
0.4786372780799866,
0.09583862870931625,
-0.604790985584259,
0.12998375296592712,
-0.052634332329034805,
-0.42660439014434814,
-0.6281885504722595,
0.4616873562335968,
-1.2055675983428955,
-0.5522170066833496,
1.238227367401123,
-0.24474306404590607,
-0.1717054694890976,
-0.11193446069955826,
-0.06858813017606735,
-0.07074641436338425,
-0.38991987705230713,
0.913072407245636,
0.8549299240112305,
0.3034709692001343,
-0.025088349357247353,
-0.4623711109161377,
0.15602995455265045,
0.26023590564727783,
-0.8001402020454407,
-0.015630386769771576,
0.6314339637756348,
0.14094874262809753,
0.06464815884828568,
-0.047568608075380325,
-0.05534449964761734,
-0.08551943302154541,
-0.2557583451271057,
0.2449817657470703,
0.21273109316825867,
-0.2640381455421448,
-0.3291460871696472,
0.28017958998680115,
0.0408475436270237,
0.01336127519607544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19674v1 | Less is More: Accurate Speech Recognition & Translation without Web-Scale Data | 2024-06-28T06:22:23 | 2024-06-28T06:22:23 | Krishna C. Puvvada, Piotr Żelasko, He Huang, Oleksii Hrinchuk, Nithin Rao Koluguri, Kunal Dhawan, Somshubra Majumdar, Elena Rastorgueva, Zhehuai Chen, Vitaly Lavrukhin, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent advances in speech recognition and translation rely on hundreds of
thousands of hours of Internet speech data. We argue that state-of-the art
accuracy can be reached without relying on web-scale data. Canary -
multilingual ASR and speech translation model, outperforms current
state-of-the-art models - Whisper, OWSM, and Seamless-M4T on English, French,
Spanish, and German languages, while being trained on an order of magnitude
less data than these models. Three key factors enables such data-efficient
model: (1) a FastConformer-based attention encoder-decoder architecture (2)
training on synthetic data generated with machine translation and (3) advanced
training techniques: data-balancing, dynamic data blending, dynamic bucketing
and noise-robust fine-tuning. The model, weights, and training code will be
open-sourced. | [
-0.2203812301158905,
-0.3852701485157013,
0.12957912683486938,
0.15896296501159668,
-0.06627701222896576,
0.0156877301633358,
-0.17855870723724365,
-0.7605010867118835,
0.11913236230611801,
0.21686656773090363,
-0.5315589904785156,
-0.25302696228027344,
-0.6628366112709045,
0.07904117554426193,
-0.8120582103729248,
0.5640937685966492,
0.40182754397392273,
0.3059966564178467,
-0.024689683690667152,
-0.16733066737651825,
0.15510593354701996,
-0.38662341237068176,
-0.8797891139984131,
-0.32612383365631104,
0.49301469326019287,
0.3761764168739319,
0.6965336799621582,
0.9613381624221802,
0.4331429600715637,
0.24101197719573975,
-0.15123102068901062,
0.07143860310316086,
-0.46686676144599915,
-0.4645453691482544,
0.24213792383670807,
-0.36214545369148254,
-0.5482264757156372,
0.0037391679361462593,
0.5052803158760071,
0.8225056529045105,
-0.10574308037757874,
0.3065200746059418,
-0.0037659688387066126,
0.8540986180305481,
-0.5879209637641907,
0.2634420394897461,
-0.7747636437416077,
0.053988534957170486,
-0.23454152047634125,
0.25914233922958374,
-0.25600549578666687,
-0.37490057945251465,
0.2394874393939972,
-0.7942690253257751,
0.2951742708683014,
-0.19034837186336517,
0.6405261754989624,
0.524958610534668,
-0.5600716471672058,
-0.2771788239479065,
-0.7270739674568176,
0.7422671914100647,
-0.667361319065094,
1.0569020509719849,
0.39763107895851135,
0.46329087018966675,
0.11152204871177673,
-0.8364980816841125,
-0.7210590839385986,
-0.03286353126168251,
0.3062881529331207,
0.22952458262443542,
-0.42745447158813477,
-0.040626682341098785,
0.06768486648797989,
0.3408615291118622,
-0.6733644604682922,
0.16118142008781433,
-0.5263194441795349,
-0.2288852035999298,
0.43703651428222656,
-0.2341143935918808,
-0.15885324776172638,
0.19516372680664062,
-0.09607842564582825,
-0.35985034704208374,
-0.697440505027771,
0.2122986614704132,
-0.013677443377673626,
0.7402934432029724,
-0.578141450881958,
0.394320011138916,
-0.36965852975845337,
0.7503724098205566,
0.210977703332901,
-0.38461053371429443,
0.39106667041778564,
-0.1062217578291893,
-0.2744464576244354,
0.4019779860973358,
0.6544281244277954,
0.2890228033065796,
0.3430064618587494,
-0.24422655999660492,
0.16034583747386932,
0.2931530773639679,
-0.0098831532523036,
-0.5666242241859436,
-0.23363789916038513,
0.39011070132255554,
-0.31408828496932983,
-0.11439680308103561,
-0.16246455907821655,
-0.3475269675254822,
-0.3288135528564453,
-0.4572204053401947,
0.06707248091697693,
-0.11680197715759277,
-0.06512267142534256,
0.03434073552489281,
-0.14252489805221558,
0.3265611231327057,
0.547045886516571,
-0.4593752324581146,
0.3303309977054596,
0.5228230357170105,
1.0959452390670776,
-0.14959417283535004,
-0.17411625385284424,
-0.8184678554534912,
0.04953911527991295,
-0.3922852575778961,
0.5117657780647278,
-0.2918953597545624,
-0.19022181630134583,
0.02261669747531414,
0.01260734535753727,
-0.029125548899173737,
-0.4297361373901367,
0.7190501689910889,
-0.4305661916732788,
0.030804844573140144,
-0.20527499914169312,
-0.5309033393859863,
-0.18143223226070404,
0.0858464166522026,
-0.8528141975402832,
0.7458667159080505,
-0.35618969798088074,
-0.664264976978302,
0.2344149798154831,
-0.7417488098144531,
-0.5384796261787415,
-0.2095545083284378,
0.24864564836025238,
-0.14185358583927155,
0.1773098111152649,
0.5004826188087463,
0.2157493233680725,
-0.3827427327632904,
-0.12377037107944489,
-0.17279931902885437,
-0.22749677300453186,
0.3147066831588745,
-0.7010658979415894,
0.7284337282180786,
0.44532859325408936,
-0.25687745213508606,
-0.13199229538440704,
-1.085005760192871,
0.0537136010825634,
-0.03944794833660126,
-0.7027598023414612,
0.12119486182928085,
0.12025987356901169,
0.5543258786201477,
0.34637439250946045,
0.4196789860725403,
-0.9708521366119385,
-0.29540109634399414,
-0.7075046300888062,
0.6832398772239685,
0.2696329653263092,
-0.6088833212852478,
0.5045909881591797,
-0.3229077160358429,
0.27125540375709534,
-0.17532645165920258,
0.2711630165576935,
0.21059861779212952,
-0.5531174540519714,
-0.8826356530189514,
-0.2870504558086395,
0.4203381836414337,
0.7184413075447083,
-0.5122040510177612,
0.21779902279376984,
-0.9316571950912476,
-0.6471593379974365,
-0.9573023915290833,
0.15980587899684906,
0.5282773375511169,
0.6294239163398743,
0.5921227335929871,
0.0009733726619742811,
-0.5578951835632324,
-0.5582038164138794,
-0.21183843910694122,
0.04107718914747238,
-0.10660596191883087,
0.1401633322238922,
0.08495458215475082,
-0.20675316452980042,
0.69733065366745,
-0.1773151457309723,
-0.48293066024780273,
-0.2946554720401764,
-0.15486691892147064,
0.28791543841362,
0.46288153529167175,
0.2171587496995926,
-0.8563037514686584,
-0.7245063781738281,
0.41959109902381897,
-0.45676183700561523,
0.17625854909420013,
0.20527520775794983,
0.42419496178627014,
0.1285586953163147,
0.4532944858074188,
-0.4423035681247711,
0.22049745917320251,
0.8020411133766174,
0.3808498680591583,
-0.12664847075939178,
-0.18352153897285461,
-0.07633941620588303,
-0.8575229644775391,
0.2517715394496918,
-0.1288425177335739,
-0.6673870086669922,
-0.8334715366363525,
0.11851813644170761,
0.23198148608207703,
-0.42229264974594116,
-0.8827416300773621,
0.5528032183647156,
-0.414332777261734,
-0.2182227075099945,
-0.3705880343914032,
0.40063413977622986,
0.04077643156051636,
0.2045276165008545,
0.23606908321380615,
0.772929310798645,
0.4669043719768524,
-0.6778734922409058,
0.35057902336120605,
0.2863647937774658,
-0.08518318086862564,
0.47864747047424316,
-0.7414420247077942,
0.2862986624240875,
0.036548737436532974,
0.10403548926115036,
-0.8344114422798157,
-0.2803356349468231,
-0.20473065972328186,
-0.7574955224990845,
0.12592969834804535,
-0.27348947525024414,
-0.41177457571029663,
-0.4507278501987457,
-0.37444519996643066,
0.02889508567750454,
0.599852442741394,
-0.6796020865440369,
0.2970483899116516,
0.4914311468601227,
-0.1334116905927658,
-0.5253225564956665,
-1.056411623954773,
0.04851515591144562,
0.005747226532548666,
-0.414029985666275,
0.20789285004138947,
0.1653381586074829,
0.05646171793341637,
-0.144331693649292,
-0.28767234086990356,
-0.6085560321807861,
-0.15643952786922455,
0.04071376845240593,
-0.20854248106479645,
-0.23170873522758484,
0.1426580846309662,
0.09285397082567215,
-0.06813251972198486,
-0.3400084674358368,
-0.4561205506324768,
0.49952465295791626,
-0.034429293125867844,
-0.31456926465034485,
-0.915567934513092,
0.34148484468460083,
0.9513828158378601,
-0.23072902858257294,
0.45278769731521606,
0.63739013671875,
-0.5297426581382751,
0.37520021200180054,
-0.5161473155021667,
0.07175217568874359,
-0.46928659081459045,
0.22586335241794586,
-0.4177344739437103,
-0.6036123037338257,
0.4169284403324127,
0.10091337561607361,
0.2807745635509491,
0.33099624514579773,
0.21281087398529053,
-0.25832313299179077,
1.1577798128128052,
0.6186103820800781,
-0.2926163673400879,
0.502690315246582,
-0.05493909865617752,
-0.06395193934440613,
-0.7633477449417114,
-0.039031822234392166,
-0.510134756565094,
-0.3115684688091278,
-0.6177309155464172,
-0.3535762429237366,
0.5333099961280823,
-0.16007956862449646,
-0.07160839438438416,
0.47198861837387085,
-0.6006348729133606,
0.3133997917175293,
0.745115339756012,
0.11819839477539062,
0.45674052834510803,
0.15210294723510742,
0.2372642159461975,
-0.0840655192732811,
-0.8917370438575745,
-0.3029179275035858,
1.4286977052688599,
0.1561506688594818,
0.7795639634132385,
0.22487685084342957,
0.3462764322757721,
0.3470333516597748,
-0.11820743978023529,
-0.7572904825210571,
-0.01684548333287239,
-0.5197986960411072,
-0.6164243221282959,
-0.4198334217071533,
-0.4778473377227783,
-1.1755694150924683,
0.23904868960380554,
-0.179649218916893,
-0.48309844732284546,
0.28375548124313354,
0.5226277112960815,
-0.32371240854263306,
-0.017102034762501717,
-0.7498325109481812,
0.6091225147247314,
-0.3436746895313263,
-0.07178304344415665,
-0.17999963462352753,
-0.7465217709541321,
0.07112631946802139,
-0.2591748535633087,
0.4390449821949005,
0.013666494749486446,
-0.15204884111881256,
0.7319170832633972,
-0.5172359347343445,
0.8147392272949219,
-0.2190137505531311,
0.08125127106904984,
0.12287034094333649,
-0.25346115231513977,
0.7873021364212036,
-0.3707013428211212,
-0.15162569284439087,
0.22943855822086334,
0.21995946764945984,
-0.48689961433410645,
-0.39604735374450684,
0.5824256539344788,
-0.8626829981803894,
0.012205575592815876,
-0.24175502359867096,
-0.365801066160202,
-0.18612417578697205,
0.1773311048746109,
0.49028751254081726,
0.40440118312835693,
-0.22053895890712738,
0.3183193802833557,
0.5494784116744995,
-0.028237011283636093,
0.3589732348918915,
0.7306063175201416,
-0.02584053948521614,
-0.6047528982162476,
1.0344085693359375,
0.5019855499267578,
0.2790830135345459,
0.6628143191337585,
0.25530001521110535,
-0.7383803129196167,
-0.527151882648468,
-0.6508734822273254,
0.19362859427928925,
-0.6619824171066284,
-0.07920761406421661,
-0.9292881488800049,
-0.07175582647323608,
-0.6857458353042603,
-0.13350549340248108,
-0.8709756135940552,
-0.5888872146606445,
-0.23116976022720337,
-0.06381373107433319,
0.5585945248603821,
0.5491344332695007,
-0.21248146891593933,
0.852210283279419,
-0.8376509547233582,
0.33346134424209595,
0.3701409101486206,
-0.2115478664636612,
-0.11185802519321442,
-0.5866953134536743,
-0.31920701265335083,
0.4020169973373413,
-0.05597768723964691,
-0.6214948296546936,
0.5647894740104675,
0.6806997656822205,
0.21454313397407532,
0.46239355206489563,
0.09414814412593842,
0.9884973168373108,
-0.6213098764419556,
0.5353407859802246,
0.3273043930530548,
-1.2960789203643799,
0.4701699912548065,
-0.10198133438825607,
0.4941418766975403,
0.5303742289543152,
0.19389471411705017,
-0.6261982321739197,
-0.16242605447769165,
-0.3471407890319824,
-0.7215335369110107,
0.6554341316223145,
0.1879601925611496,
0.07006452232599258,
0.3736540973186493,
0.12464117258787155,
0.01224290020763874,
0.45767444372177124,
-0.7205981612205505,
-0.2624340057373047,
-0.5647211670875549,
-0.4202057421207428,
-0.24280473589897156,
0.31358158588409424,
0.16516582667827606,
-0.45580315589904785,
0.5754662752151489,
-0.20836202800273895,
0.20661760866641998,
0.13052219152450562,
-0.47747376561164856,
0.05313714221119881,
0.11711414903402328,
0.6784073114395142,
0.18755680322647095,
-0.14160002768039703,
0.1899537742137909,
0.37440866231918335,
-0.4811190366744995,
0.20664414763450623,
0.1916721910238266,
-0.1395108997821808,
0.1422690600156784,
0.3870428502559662,
0.7393202781677246,
0.2203843742609024,
-0.8069748878479004,
0.6996685266494751,
-0.0013020425103604794,
0.014197704382240772,
-0.46685653924942017,
-0.11389410495758057,
0.3179171681404114,
0.1729622781276703,
0.18775831162929535,
0.1359601765871048,
0.3496171832084656,
-0.37084609270095825,
0.11190744489431381,
0.3215349018573761,
-0.5970203280448914,
-0.29593899846076965,
0.8106210827827454,
0.3775627911090851,
-0.19277432560920715,
0.33307915925979614,
-0.12776899337768555,
-0.21923378109931946,
0.41193243861198425,
0.38043802976608276,
0.4158403277397156,
-0.2752029299736023,
0.08963841944932938,
0.2832568883895874,
0.44126254320144653,
-0.1797610968351364,
0.3336106538772583,
-0.14966893196105957,
-0.5221547484397888,
-0.5160838961601257,
-0.46881937980651855,
-0.6393103003501892,
0.36860373616218567,
-0.8224087953567505,
0.0976734533905983,
-0.50928795337677,
-0.21195249259471893,
0.008873258717358112,
-0.14781822264194489,
-0.7494863271713257,
0.3620738089084625,
0.03441186249256134,
0.983463704586029,
-0.7816568613052368,
1.1092020273208618,
0.5235942006111145,
-0.1883702278137207,
-0.6092329025268555,
-0.27409785985946655,
0.2421616017818451,
-0.8028562664985657,
0.5392183661460876,
0.19974029064178467,
-0.3592798709869385,
0.43885841965675354,
-0.3012590706348419,
-1.2862186431884766,
0.7597753405570984,
0.8178377151489258,
-0.8882184624671936,
0.13047783076763153,
0.14068959653377533,
0.5021300315856934,
-0.06806113570928574,
-0.11228801310062408,
0.35153868794441223,
0.42754408717155457,
0.09132763743400574,
-1.2758225202560425,
-0.5131295323371887,
-0.23698990046977997,
-0.26622387766838074,
-0.16997545957565308,
-0.5365520715713501,
0.932733416557312,
0.04902873560786247,
-0.25987762212753296,
-0.021602587774395943,
0.37000566720962524,
-0.2851226031780243,
0.17543068528175354,
0.1994345337152481,
0.49022364616394043,
1.0205949544906616,
-0.03106408566236496,
1.082171082496643,
-0.23691165447235107,
0.13804803788661957,
1.4176121950149536,
-0.39494040608406067,
1.1977424621582031,
0.27445894479751587,
-0.31794726848602295,
-0.0764143094420433,
0.5390406847000122,
0.25332438945770264,
0.6793181300163269,
-0.15452583134174347,
-0.09419450163841248,
-0.22933270037174225,
-0.20655055344104767,
-0.4230746030807495,
0.7526440620422363,
0.23947691917419434,
-0.07006566971540451,
-0.1491243541240692,
0.25893786549568176,
-0.010765976272523403,
0.07004398852586746,
-0.28187960386276245,
0.9512150287628174,
0.026914792135357857,
-0.08863787353038788,
0.9845106601715088,
0.031691763550043106,
0.8130896687507629,
-0.5489720702171326,
0.3083609938621521,
-0.02301683835685253,
0.26210448145866394,
-0.2704910337924957,
-0.14198699593544006,
0.3574525713920593,
0.5342988967895508,
-0.27694353461265564,
0.010221816599369049,
0.28763702511787415,
-0.3691490888595581,
-0.8019428849220276,
0.30753055214881897,
0.673190176486969,
0.4696316421031952,
-0.4152979552745819,
-0.6690149307250977,
0.1694985181093216,
0.015726393088698387,
0.1393919289112091,
0.02816670946776867,
0.09130627661943436,
0.1533932387828827,
0.806853711605072,
1.0479426383972168,
0.4987953305244446,
0.6640212535858154,
0.0037061944603919983,
0.5276941061019897,
-0.40159597992897034,
-0.5441890358924866,
-0.5368386507034302,
0.3508542776107788,
-0.19519558548927307,
-0.15615779161453247,
0.664135754108429,
0.6730228066444397,
0.8311941623687744,
-0.07524263858795166,
0.9163470268249512,
0.24767673015594482,
0.8190409541130066,
-0.39680215716362,
0.6835600137710571,
-0.5882251858711243,
-0.1933056116104126,
-0.16030855476856232,
-0.5804290771484375,
-0.3915160000324249,
0.9239159226417542,
-0.13560500741004944,
-0.34575730562210083,
0.34771084785461426,
0.6407541632652283,
-0.27668511867523193,
-0.12124887108802795,
0.5866984128952026,
0.012538546696305275,
0.30697768926620483,
0.5657447576522827,
0.4871287941932678,
-0.7739878296852112,
0.7366732358932495,
-0.2091456800699234,
-0.11557070165872574,
-0.3623112142086029,
-0.5709313750267029,
-0.7516021728515625,
-0.3930552005767822,
-0.39008426666259766,
0.08282357454299927,
-0.037743356078863144,
1.0914838314056396,
1.1152784824371338,
-0.93918377161026,
-0.285279780626297,
-0.4322543740272522,
-0.08803022652864456,
-0.4455297887325287,
-0.1183600202202797,
0.3807324767112732,
-0.14269767701625824,
-0.9844000935554504,
0.8436437249183655,
0.19182254374027252,
0.3339672386646271,
0.03792164847254753,
-0.2785673141479492,
0.01404129434376955,
0.15932917594909668,
0.6370030045509338,
0.45633167028427124,
-0.8285619020462036,
-0.14911982417106628,
0.007378588896244764,
-0.15712231397628784,
0.3908284306526184,
0.26606014370918274,
-0.6524756550788879,
0.6454176902770996,
0.3853021264076233,
0.8165232539176941,
0.7915897965431213,
-0.012909595854580402,
0.411281943321228,
-0.7173224687576294,
0.44416606426239014,
0.017836296930909157,
0.15739381313323975,
0.6657218933105469,
-0.22453227639198303,
0.3812502324581146,
0.09346165508031845,
-0.08211732655763626,
-0.8174363374710083,
0.24782784283161163,
-1.0182428359985352,
0.05941591411828995,
0.749958336353302,
-0.34223413467407227,
-0.10580632090568542,
-0.24541427195072174,
-0.0700175017118454,
0.46870070695877075,
-0.6724801659584045,
0.5173755884170532,
0.3414960205554962,
-0.29969900846481323,
-0.3105490505695343,
-0.6239621043205261,
0.4644951820373535,
0.03864699602127075,
-0.7682082653045654,
0.10330012440681458,
0.3935355544090271,
0.19724072515964508,
0.33616361021995544,
0.44466498494148254,
-0.1210259273648262,
0.32742229104042053,
0.23439577221870422,
0.1328098326921463,
-0.12565454840660095,
-0.27920329570770264,
-0.5028712153434753,
0.21786794066429138,
0.16932325065135956,
-0.638892412185669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19650v1 | DECOR: Improving Coherence in L2 English Writing with a Novel Benchmark for Incoherence Detection, Reasoning, and Rewriting | 2024-06-28T04:38:54 | 2024-06-28T04:38:54 | Xuanming Zhang, Anthony Diaz, Zixun Chen, Qingyang Wu, Kun Qian, Erik Voss, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coherence in writing, an aspect that second-language (L2) English learners
often struggle with, is crucial in assessing L2 English writing. Existing
automated writing evaluation systems primarily use basic surface linguistic
features to detect coherence in writing. However, little effort has been made
to correct the detected incoherence, which could significantly benefit L2
language learners seeking to improve their writing. To bridge this gap, we
introduce DECOR, a novel benchmark that includes expert annotations for
detecting incoherence in L2 English writing, identifying the underlying
reasons, and rewriting the incoherent sentences. To our knowledge, DECOR is the
first coherence assessment dataset specifically designed for improving L2
English writing, featuring pairs of original incoherent sentences alongside
their expert-rewritten counterparts. Additionally, we fine-tuned models to
automatically detect and rewrite incoherence in student essays. We find that
incorporating specific reasons for incoherence during fine-tuning consistently
improves the quality of the rewrites, achieving a result that is favored in
both automatic and human evaluations. | [
-0.32402002811431885,
-0.7683858275413513,
0.33686745166778564,
0.17105619609355927,
-0.04906196519732475,
0.2817983329296112,
-0.23825708031654358,
-0.7651693224906921,
0.2983317971229553,
0.17104850709438324,
-0.4585844576358795,
-0.23283199965953827,
-0.48720622062683105,
0.3134240210056305,
-0.14577147364616394,
0.6874871850013733,
-0.35525646805763245,
-0.020451296120882034,
-0.7014642357826233,
-0.33978018164634705,
-0.5647810697555542,
-0.11126063019037247,
-0.9351094365119934,
-0.19946779310703278,
0.5371968150138855,
0.7617599368095398,
0.4558120667934418,
0.43992725014686584,
0.6451209783554077,
0.19873808324337006,
0.36528104543685913,
0.4002675414085388,
-0.32663553953170776,
0.5412592887878418,
-0.10974511504173279,
-0.33449429273605347,
-0.5850739479064941,
-0.04473051056265831,
0.46458306908607483,
0.5593889951705933,
0.24362577497959137,
0.1452421247959137,
0.3111017048358917,
0.5770784020423889,
-0.6617994904518127,
0.1795327067375183,
-0.6930080652236938,
-0.0002963817387353629,
-0.13382424414157867,
-0.2774776220321655,
-0.6472159028053284,
-0.0548471100628376,
0.018692489713430405,
-0.7661487460136414,
0.5537293553352356,
0.3778894543647766,
0.9882527589797974,
0.43689221143722534,
-0.20061913132667542,
-0.24716681241989136,
-0.06986277550458908,
0.7876054048538208,
-0.38480016589164734,
0.5205298662185669,
0.39999547600746155,
0.00892704352736473,
-0.30166131258010864,
-0.7076520323753357,
-0.5148388147354126,
-0.18023879826068878,
-0.28679925203323364,
0.40798625349998474,
0.12384313344955444,
-0.2571883201599121,
0.18509729206562042,
0.5306456089019775,
-0.45493078231811523,
-0.13401944935321808,
0.11091822385787964,
-0.607856035232544,
0.6725565195083618,
0.004663725849241018,
0.5241628289222717,
0.2516240179538727,
-0.23179595172405243,
0.14246760308742523,
-0.398746520280838,
0.18527892231941223,
0.3361981213092804,
-0.16974776983261108,
-0.04616013169288635,
0.3714849054813385,
0.04049362242221832,
0.2495836317539215,
0.14062835276126862,
-0.12101177871227264,
-0.08119101077318192,
-0.2571692168712616,
0.022941933944821358,
0.05206836387515068,
0.34259071946144104,
0.6716911792755127,
0.29817330837249756,
-0.1612551361322403,
-0.122906394302845,
0.4905954897403717,
-0.05400968715548515,
-0.7667836546897888,
-0.7461509108543396,
0.3277507722377777,
-0.2972423732280731,
-0.1580326110124588,
-0.3186052143573761,
-0.5215446352958679,
-0.5154685974121094,
-0.33404040336608887,
0.21191629767417908,
-0.4323993921279907,
-0.3885005712509155,
-0.03008369356393814,
-0.27567705512046814,
0.1513698697090149,
0.632034420967102,
-0.9345021843910217,
0.4228063225746155,
1.061716914176941,
0.6935765743255615,
-0.38662049174308777,
-0.6692365407943726,
-0.47300925850868225,
-0.13335420191287994,
-0.6334916353225708,
1.14812171459198,
-0.33181193470954895,
0.011714618653059006,
-0.038892798125743866,
0.006985614076256752,
0.09367683529853821,
-0.33005204796791077,
0.9128332138061523,
-0.24762968719005585,
0.6089084148406982,
-0.34642547369003296,
-0.8677036762237549,
0.24730390310287476,
0.06617438048124313,
-0.6439687609672546,
0.9119647741317749,
0.22925585508346558,
-0.9902355074882507,
0.8215062022209167,
-0.34282100200653076,
-0.5567813515663147,
-0.0772242620587349,
-0.07558489590883255,
-0.9794508218765259,
0.4105372428894043,
0.04347892105579376,
0.08159413188695908,
0.2694970667362213,
-0.13578733801841736,
-0.11213316768407822,
-0.5914824604988098,
-0.07508154213428497,
-0.39479655027389526,
0.5293366312980652,
0.054619528353214264,
-0.16034474968910217,
0.21382910013198853,
-0.8223146200180054,
0.20827099680900574,
-0.10292872041463852,
-0.35561099648475647,
-0.3877851963043213,
-0.0008988578920252621,
0.1664392054080963,
-0.27036145329475403,
0.48926424980163574,
-0.5080527067184448,
-0.0937240719795227,
-0.46022868156433105,
0.2372119426727295,
0.5806829333305359,
0.1086094006896019,
0.38547423481941223,
-0.7663166522979736,
0.24842901527881622,
-0.22423972189426422,
-0.34410548210144043,
-0.5635820627212524,
-0.5665603280067444,
-1.066845417022705,
-0.5324049592018127,
-0.0844605416059494,
0.14072634279727936,
-0.2126423567533493,
0.3703988492488861,
0.040268588811159134,
-0.1913575381040573,
-0.8548349738121033,
0.17879514396190643,
0.5935865044593811,
0.5486918091773987,
0.4272749125957489,
-0.318413108587265,
-0.828952431678772,
-0.5980603098869324,
-0.6858989000320435,
-0.12973111867904663,
0.3103535771369934,
-0.21967095136642456,
0.39183109998703003,
0.06514888256788254,
0.596956729888916,
-0.20491951704025269,
-0.35454297065734863,
0.11497066169977188,
0.26703378558158875,
-0.27467912435531616,
0.7139804363250732,
0.22832903265953064,
-0.1633218377828598,
-0.8918378949165344,
-0.03196512535214424,
-0.5399930477142334,
-0.3656786382198334,
-0.24591849744319916,
-0.3635200560092926,
0.7829740643501282,
0.7478843331336975,
-0.15500067174434662,
0.2583489418029785,
0.30848464369773865,
-0.7293073534965515,
0.6031413078308105,
-0.2047259658575058,
0.21332305669784546,
-0.9843624830245972,
-0.149898499250412,
-0.2544085383415222,
-0.40845322608947754,
-0.24318446218967438,
0.33384591341018677,
-0.010994670912623405,
0.1903870403766632,
0.08584219962358475,
0.4912879467010498,
-0.729938805103302,
0.2830243408679962,
-0.32280051708221436,
0.044451016932725906,
0.6568713188171387,
0.3874017596244812,
0.05705883353948593,
0.7195265293121338,
0.27311208844184875,
0.1642206460237503,
-0.06537596881389618,
0.23234649002552032,
-0.5364243984222412,
1.060587763786316,
-0.36690980195999146,
0.34529560804367065,
-0.05405868962407112,
0.24274083971977234,
-1.4252089262008667,
-0.44603151082992554,
0.07740188390016556,
-0.32753798365592957,
0.4010371267795563,
0.15780171751976013,
-0.05060645937919617,
0.05278641730546951,
-0.4418252408504486,
0.2332327663898468,
0.32909899950027466,
-0.47245895862579346,
0.20914480090141296,
0.1155763790011406,
-0.10788631439208984,
-0.3481237292289734,
-0.5711860060691833,
0.3358802795410156,
-0.0039052770007401705,
-0.6719014048576355,
0.29169347882270813,
-0.1734599769115448,
-0.35476309061050415,
-0.21152330935001373,
-0.2641012668609619,
-0.23099923133850098,
0.22616684436798096,
0.1402643620967865,
-0.03860131651163101,
-0.2558095157146454,
0.10746607929468155,
0.312345951795578,
-0.21040889620780945,
0.21462585031986237,
-0.16928039491176605,
0.3493158221244812,
-0.08447141200304031,
-0.4434477686882019,
-0.9703869819641113,
0.6147432327270508,
0.6897114515304565,
0.014945064671337605,
0.19548200070858002,
0.5326998233795166,
-0.362399697303772,
-0.5891006588935852,
-0.6244819760322571,
-0.25213485956192017,
-0.40260252356529236,
0.4532160758972168,
-0.8655879497528076,
-0.5979160666465759,
0.35772788524627686,
0.2300499528646469,
0.32796216011047363,
0.36232659220695496,
0.2797689735889435,
-0.4378264248371124,
0.6066756248474121,
0.706506609916687,
0.30615416169166565,
0.37368717789649963,
0.03863384947180748,
0.17624418437480927,
-0.7604299783706665,
-0.12330490350723267,
-0.3501550555229187,
-0.3738689124584198,
-0.40295299887657166,
-0.3729858994483948,
0.13799218833446503,
0.11700484156608582,
-0.21826443076133728,
0.17099174857139587,
-0.7922109961509705,
0.7467753291130066,
0.4708356559276581,
0.06827572733163834,
0.6592446565628052,
0.2626643180847168,
-0.05569390952587128,
-0.5717086791992188,
-0.33526062965393066,
-0.553642988204956,
0.735948383808136,
0.5939151048660278,
0.5163276791572571,
0.04118996858596802,
0.6613882184028625,
0.3354965150356293,
0.4114956855773926,
-0.9295703768730164,
0.41387635469436646,
-0.05543530732393265,
-0.14861230552196503,
-0.3523302972316742,
0.1416654884815216,
-0.6607627272605896,
0.18988782167434692,
-0.13055990636348724,
-0.19401904940605164,
0.32435211539268494,
0.3492371737957001,
-0.25288480520248413,
-0.08029311150312424,
-0.7635512351989746,
0.8443878293037415,
-0.11494696140289307,
-0.9161022901535034,
-0.218046173453331,
-0.20086728036403656,
0.10829516500234604,
0.006198378745466471,
-0.08135338872671127,
-0.14145074784755707,
-0.25070834159851074,
0.5966604351997375,
-0.5545011162757874,
0.5630333423614502,
0.06986647844314575,
-0.5111749172210693,
0.32913780212402344,
0.5688847899436951,
0.6666635274887085,
-0.06811975687742233,
-0.45982691645622253,
0.17735810577869415,
0.26291555166244507,
-0.429932177066803,
-0.4291720390319824,
0.7711216807365417,
-0.6441959142684937,
-0.4918513298034668,
-0.3949491083621979,
-0.6944996118545532,
-0.23739339411258698,
0.16660110652446747,
0.5623345375061035,
0.32388007640838623,
-0.3636856973171234,
-0.05689713731408119,
0.3838229179382324,
0.2646251618862152,
0.3988974988460541,
0.4770379662513733,
-0.0938083752989769,
-0.6250856518745422,
0.7600334882736206,
0.16857202351093292,
0.29030025005340576,
0.30883800983428955,
0.18466243147850037,
-0.28186750411987305,
-0.5242819786071777,
-0.475090891122818,
-0.14134815335273743,
-0.8574444651603699,
0.17474132776260376,
-0.5788055062294006,
0.12381807714700699,
-0.4922460615634918,
-0.6265321373939514,
-0.17915455996990204,
-0.5335267782211304,
-0.061250098049640656,
0.1642250418663025,
0.13424023985862732,
0.5888098478317261,
-0.007568448316305876,
-0.08271035552024841,
0.049008775502443314,
0.06681473553180695,
0.13377219438552856,
0.5461958646774292,
-0.10074958205223083,
-0.7632037997245789,
-0.31614556908607483,
-0.2690739035606384,
-0.17305488884449005,
-0.23046113550662994,
0.016036540269851685,
0.4341218173503876,
0.1854209303855896,
0.25697019696235657,
0.005118250846862793,
0.8443577289581299,
-0.6291936635971069,
0.6447461247444153,
0.2066476196050644,
-1.0242360830307007,
0.3889434039592743,
-0.17588604986667633,
0.17931820452213287,
0.9411821961402893,
-0.18909938633441925,
-0.5182311534881592,
-0.6424067616462708,
-0.39087793231010437,
-0.7463058829307556,
0.24838173389434814,
-0.08367777615785599,
-0.06101062148809433,
-0.0031947691459208727,
0.32359498739242554,
0.38432782888412476,
0.11181824654340744,
-0.524410605430603,
0.25756654143333435,
-0.27843910455703735,
-0.42159250378608704,
0.15929856896400452,
-0.5525961518287659,
-0.26786258816719055,
-0.40818458795547485,
0.6632935404777527,
-0.10267700254917145,
0.08632539957761765,
0.6654723882675171,
-0.10062051564455032,
-0.6813416481018066,
0.10703156143426895,
0.5612421631813049,
0.4557512700557709,
-0.15631699562072754,
0.43698665499687195,
0.41124215722084045,
-0.427097350358963,
0.17854422330856323,
-0.28027576208114624,
-0.254736989736557,
0.2013845443725586,
0.9067937731742859,
0.31775009632110596,
0.0630325973033905,
-0.3072485625743866,
0.6110789775848389,
-0.12743733823299408,
-0.05355336517095566,
-0.606995165348053,
0.21302370727062225,
-0.04316438362002373,
-0.21110451221466064,
-0.2627164125442505,
0.5242077708244324,
-0.027533432468771935,
-0.7007860541343689,
0.5415055155754089,
0.5914346575737,
-0.43851205706596375,
-0.27727219462394714,
0.7025576233863831,
0.48347046971321106,
-0.541451632976532,
0.05235544592142105,
-0.3232235908508301,
-0.1976771205663681,
0.4828089773654938,
0.6061524748802185,
1.1929879188537598,
-0.1318897157907486,
0.03948308154940605,
0.4374180734157562,
0.3224514126777649,
0.08718618005514145,
0.611355185508728,
-0.3365371525287628,
-0.6643169522285461,
-0.19814319908618927,
-0.6300079226493835,
-0.7879575490951538,
-0.02449474111199379,
-0.5622310042381287,
0.5130234956741333,
-0.6373076438903809,
0.3194728493690491,
-0.04639773815870285,
0.31510964035987854,
-0.4038848876953125,
0.12050703912973404,
-0.005836863070726395,
0.8743166923522949,
-0.9184154272079468,
0.6026366353034973,
0.8421386480331421,
-0.24785897135734558,
-0.6815333366394043,
0.42175447940826416,
-0.09934128075838089,
-0.5522463321685791,
0.16941849887371063,
0.3705023229122162,
-0.49786484241485596,
-0.0023332920391112566,
-0.4017066955566406,
-0.5160750150680542,
0.8305172324180603,
0.25008442997932434,
-0.9244492053985596,
0.3576813042163849,
0.10560017824172974,
0.9152984619140625,
-0.46843189001083374,
0.47903791069984436,
0.5523674488067627,
0.5711052417755127,
-0.003558200551196933,
-0.6352135539054871,
0.14310897886753082,
-0.376952588558197,
-0.2770461440086365,
-0.16704194247722626,
-0.9323543310165405,
0.6106688380241394,
-0.26161709427833557,
-0.49036508798599243,
0.4894351065158844,
0.7250818014144897,
-0.09607111662626266,
0.9251337647438049,
0.41553184390068054,
0.8319462537765503,
1.1646915674209595,
-0.3745674192905426,
0.6323210597038269,
-0.6447525024414062,
0.18379679322242737,
1.6220736503601074,
-0.4776746332645416,
1.0661060810089111,
0.5025456547737122,
-0.06816250830888748,
0.8964382410049438,
0.48169630765914917,
0.06304732710123062,
0.41870012879371643,
0.3269478976726532,
-0.5561469197273254,
-0.2516181766986847,
-0.20035317540168762,
-0.4033694863319397,
0.3369656205177307,
0.019151190295815468,
-0.19871163368225098,
-0.0757841095328331,
-0.22156694531440735,
0.3140857219696045,
0.6567482352256775,
-0.06746689230203629,
0.8235724568367004,
0.0114970738068223,
-1.3316229581832886,
0.7480833530426025,
-0.21878229081630707,
0.5186915397644043,
-0.1915348917245865,
-0.19491904973983765,
-0.4900936484336853,
0.45018652081489563,
-0.6784520745277405,
-0.7534152269363403,
0.7364885807037354,
-0.20139990746974945,
-0.3864537477493286,
-0.3955128788948059,
0.7583006024360657,
-0.6834093332290649,
-0.5603649616241455,
0.10740136355161667,
0.2769172191619873,
0.1610592156648636,
0.13448597490787506,
-0.32726261019706726,
0.1876501739025116,
-0.21873295307159424,
-0.037338726222515106,
-0.10856975615024567,
0.6424205899238586,
0.018182450905442238,
0.1950020045042038,
0.5667904019355774,
0.13072887063026428,
-0.39895832538604736,
0.2676345407962799,
0.3345569670200348,
-0.28728359937667847,
-0.3198506236076355,
-0.7590099573135376,
0.5659904479980469,
-0.17843443155288696,
-0.47427883744239807,
0.9281951785087585,
0.8171296715736389,
0.8231371641159058,
0.023592986166477203,
0.9501213431358337,
0.19736334681510925,
0.6456640362739563,
-0.1964346170425415,
0.8822806477546692,
-0.6428177952766418,
0.23599977791309357,
-0.1525145024061203,
-0.6113647222518921,
-0.4918375313282013,
0.7340990304946899,
-0.16685032844543457,
-0.44471678137779236,
0.9669756889343262,
1.0748348236083984,
0.10414088517427444,
0.11869429051876068,
0.5272058844566345,
0.33732035756111145,
0.41896381974220276,
0.4154948592185974,
0.9201597571372986,
-0.6435505151748657,
0.1640390306711197,
-0.31561893224716187,
-0.322521835565567,
-0.14257143437862396,
-0.984734058380127,
-1.101607322692871,
-0.5309469103813171,
-0.8060189485549927,
-0.8317198753356934,
0.28762006759643555,
0.9191961884498596,
0.37922385334968567,
-1.259637713432312,
-0.03374091163277626,
-0.6891922354698181,
0.2677977383136749,
-0.4157724678516388,
-0.23800644278526306,
0.5453582406044006,
-0.788969874382019,
-0.8206340670585632,
0.31475207209587097,
0.6804877519607544,
-0.21685858070850372,
-0.4325331449508667,
0.06293287128210068,
0.0817144587635994,
0.3647365868091583,
0.442220002412796,
0.006410740781575441,
-0.6465671062469482,
-0.6199543476104736,
-0.18285809457302094,
-0.314241886138916,
0.24767960608005524,
0.5710766315460205,
-0.43284422159194946,
0.803161084651947,
0.8666604161262512,
0.30255326628685,
-0.26667359471321106,
0.016069702804088593,
0.24688459932804108,
-0.5274140238761902,
-0.08544180542230606,
0.13909360766410828,
0.5189422965049744,
0.5292735695838928,
-0.4966108798980713,
0.4338681697845459,
0.58298659324646,
-0.8273669481277466,
-0.9052184224128723,
0.27883458137512207,
-0.8358771204948425,
-0.04128332808613777,
0.7498278617858887,
-0.36910247802734375,
-0.05037141218781471,
-0.5786268711090088,
-0.6742668151855469,
0.06830897927284241,
-0.14616695046424866,
1.1548761129379272,
0.9164304137229919,
-0.2347526103258133,
-0.13166144490242004,
-0.03459955379366875,
0.8795598745346069,
0.9646244645118713,
-0.7794167399406433,
0.12496142834424973,
0.5445869565010071,
0.43859586119651794,
0.1345108598470688,
0.8120115399360657,
0.22918665409088135,
0.49128633737564087,
0.3144895136356354,
-0.10343993455171585,
-0.026902243494987488,
-0.37631121277809143,
-0.07896331697702408,
0.40504878759384155,
0.2526797652244568,
-0.2255835235118866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19648v1 | Designing and Evaluating Multi-Chatbot Interface for Human-AI Communication: Preliminary Findings from a Persuasion Task | 2024-06-28T04:33:41 | 2024-06-28T04:33:41 | Sion Yoon, Tae Eun Kim, Yoo Jung Oh | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The dynamics of human-AI communication have been reshaped by language models
such as ChatGPT. However, extant research has primarily focused on dyadic
communication, leaving much to be explored regarding the dynamics of human-AI
communication in group settings. The availability of multiple language model
chatbots presents a unique opportunity for scholars to better understand the
interaction between humans and multiple chatbots. This study examines the
impact of multi-chatbot communication in a specific persuasion setting:
promoting charitable donations. We developed an online environment that enables
multi-chatbot communication and conducted a pilot experiment utilizing two
GPT-based chatbots, Save the Children and UNICEF chatbots, to promote
charitable donations. In this study, we present our development process of the
multi-chatbot interface and present preliminary findings from a pilot
experiment. Analysis of qualitative and quantitative feedback are presented,
and limitations are addressed. | [
-0.4467737674713135,
-0.783959686756134,
0.21800300478935242,
0.2169075757265091,
-0.2792922854423523,
0.3689556121826172,
-0.24058401584625244,
-0.5543774366378784,
0.13797123730182648,
0.0750320553779602,
-0.6492619514465332,
-0.01900607720017433,
-0.5203100442886353,
0.1348327398300171,
-0.1734926402568817,
1.0925841331481934,
0.4152940511703491,
0.2609539031982422,
-0.21720600128173828,
-0.06869137287139893,
-0.49458688497543335,
-0.865136444568634,
-1.144055962562561,
-0.4053340256214142,
0.5888761281967163,
0.3265724778175354,
0.6780728697776794,
0.061765462160110474,
0.5504308938980103,
0.41949304938316345,
0.24461710453033447,
-0.19756321609020233,
-0.6881066560745239,
0.06194540858268738,
-0.0803431048989296,
-0.41139230132102966,
-0.18958967924118042,
0.19057004153728485,
0.20692189037799835,
0.21335089206695557,
-0.21896295249462128,
0.1578247994184494,
0.2856924831867218,
0.5142906904220581,
-0.3595632314682007,
0.28251174092292786,
-0.41125351190567017,
-0.19507017731666565,
0.03577994927763939,
-0.22168081998825073,
-0.32804256677627563,
-0.49193501472473145,
0.37451013922691345,
-0.5743668079376221,
0.09724156558513641,
-0.11803705990314484,
0.5652334690093994,
-0.024829784408211708,
-0.4076467752456665,
-0.6802374720573425,
-0.9013032913208008,
0.623168408870697,
-0.39652249217033386,
0.1290934979915619,
0.6540830731391907,
0.1998610943555832,
-0.1726115643978119,
-0.45752882957458496,
-0.650626540184021,
-0.5530863404273987,
0.07540062069892883,
0.2514578402042389,
-0.3328744173049927,
0.09739602357149124,
-0.2578881084918976,
-0.04243912920355797,
-0.20157912373542786,
-0.11370031535625458,
-0.3275836110115051,
-0.20102939009666443,
0.5596601963043213,
-0.08581648021936417,
0.31493401527404785,
-0.06533250957727432,
-0.3600408136844635,
-0.42871299386024475,
-0.4248718321323395,
0.0880163386464119,
0.5771440863609314,
0.3128291666507721,
-0.48764684796333313,
0.3165017366409302,
0.15338851511478424,
0.38957521319389343,
0.1578371226787567,
-0.01721612550318241,
-0.10417625308036804,
-0.7770769596099854,
-0.10342154651880264,
-0.22937141358852386,
0.7771437168121338,
0.48731061816215515,
0.4346310496330261,
0.21917518973350525,
0.16999053955078125,
0.4474223554134369,
0.3261936902999878,
-0.674206018447876,
-0.29794931411743164,
0.01858399249613285,
-0.9404404163360596,
-0.5566675066947937,
-0.08244957774877548,
-0.6368974447250366,
-0.670790433883667,
-0.15718507766723633,
0.6476584672927856,
-0.256506085395813,
-0.5615443587303162,
0.07665374130010605,
-0.5359188318252563,
0.11289149522781372,
0.7453954815864563,
-0.7588405609130859,
0.13240012526512146,
0.5589793920516968,
0.6795445680618286,
0.18533290922641754,
-0.25485748052597046,
-0.5663532614707947,
0.08206351101398468,
0.18313704431056976,
0.8461320400238037,
-0.8507948517799377,
-0.706192672252655,
0.06335889548063278,
-0.23218071460723877,
-0.03483656048774719,
-0.16927224397659302,
0.48624563217163086,
-0.17725799977779388,
0.5660185813903809,
-0.018649883568286896,
-0.3913044333457947,
0.011515965685248375,
0.5170602202415466,
-0.4238477051258087,
0.2797670066356659,
0.08643261343240738,
-0.47532641887664795,
0.39070919156074524,
-1.0099619626998901,
-0.54399174451828,
0.15205435454845428,
-0.21000482141971588,
-0.22235088050365448,
0.1218925341963768,
0.1934150755405426,
0.3068849444389343,
-0.2040199190378189,
0.26309987902641296,
-0.2697720527648926,
-0.23605383932590485,
0.3909723162651062,
-1.0480707883834839,
0.7438691258430481,
-0.03214283660054207,
-0.3285399377346039,
0.33780041337013245,
-0.39683809876441956,
-0.28427356481552124,
0.10405445843935013,
-0.35579928755760193,
-0.19449691474437714,
0.21402671933174133,
0.2667318880558014,
0.294704794883728,
0.0013043030630797148,
-0.5717642903327942,
0.5658532381057739,
-0.027934933081269264,
0.7082759141921997,
0.6666109561920166,
-0.21765010058879852,
0.18172650039196014,
-0.3653368353843689,
0.7967584133148193,
-0.18087317049503326,
0.522495687007904,
-0.1028493121266365,
-1.023659348487854,
-0.44442954659461975,
-0.15443581342697144,
0.027495836839079857,
0.29638078808784485,
-0.6215319633483887,
-0.05389764904975891,
0.06518753618001938,
-0.18946154415607452,
-0.840319037437439,
-0.37107110023498535,
0.30152472853660583,
0.29492297768592834,
0.1423034816980362,
-0.2735726237297058,
-0.15672220289707184,
-1.1489174365997314,
-0.20834265649318695,
-0.7662801146507263,
-0.1117277443408966,
0.43798428773880005,
0.41793930530548096,
-0.02962426096200943,
0.6961570382118225,
-0.03322721645236015,
-0.24270768463611603,
-0.3332901895046234,
0.3086211383342743,
-0.231160506606102,
0.4384622573852539,
0.5535765886306763,
-0.9158610701560974,
-0.5112468004226685,
-0.21977598965168,
0.06855268776416779,
0.36670613288879395,
-0.31614813208580017,
0.010782353579998016,
-0.19043345749378204,
-0.2609718143939972,
-0.5679184198379517,
0.8619289994239807,
0.9158873558044434,
-0.26699569821357727,
0.39890122413635254,
-0.22431913018226624,
0.9518455862998962,
-1.036286473274231,
-0.07234303653240204,
-0.07735022902488708,
-0.09338854253292084,
-1.0382275581359863,
-0.43987491726875305,
-0.09874267876148224,
-0.11261638253927231,
-0.5599587559700012,
0.5062510371208191,
-0.1794610619544983,
0.35179099440574646,
-0.4185875356197357,
0.2996968626976013,
-0.03984465077519417,
0.3233472406864166,
0.22158002853393555,
0.7357597351074219,
0.5776054859161377,
-0.571277916431427,
0.3869353234767914,
0.4853379726409912,
0.07074087113142014,
1.0583534240722656,
-0.8888546824455261,
0.43269476294517517,
-0.04017537087202072,
0.5435510277748108,
-1.1379114389419556,
-0.1854214072227478,
0.7160133123397827,
-0.9418099522590637,
-0.05168415978550911,
-0.29430729150772095,
-0.21464234590530396,
-0.4667228162288666,
-0.5047961473464966,
0.25187423825263977,
0.08380122482776642,
-0.33718016743659973,
0.4966554045677185,
0.5721035599708557,
-0.16205653548240662,
-0.26996541023254395,
-0.5381343364715576,
0.36372387409210205,
-0.396868497133255,
-0.7736604809761047,
-0.0012211278080940247,
-0.28450217843055725,
-0.17978835105895996,
-0.17064900696277618,
0.4655715823173523,
-0.1539807915687561,
0.26088088750839233,
0.16162633895874023,
0.2738235890865326,
0.021148722618818283,
0.2724957764148712,
-0.06453703343868256,
-0.09397498518228531,
-0.03021744079887867,
0.11843269318342209,
0.7249558568000793,
-0.22090566158294678,
-0.7366333603858948,
-1.0365618467330933,
0.6198026537895203,
0.20825974643230438,
-0.12115658819675446,
1.0260742902755737,
0.5734972953796387,
-0.2899017930030823,
0.5008706450462341,
-0.4618690311908722,
-0.5621142387390137,
-0.4975464344024658,
0.25057509541511536,
-0.3594818115234375,
-0.996892511844635,
0.13768409192562103,
-0.07336252182722092,
0.2589164972305298,
0.26211702823638916,
0.789261519908905,
-0.02522267960011959,
1.3572055101394653,
0.5267470479011536,
-0.2891446352005005,
0.6183866262435913,
0.08440177887678146,
0.16135020554065704,
-0.5804123878479004,
-0.23477378487586975,
-0.8700988292694092,
-0.24165600538253784,
-0.3255586326122284,
-0.27870064973831177,
0.413186252117157,
0.1912369430065155,
-0.0756111890077591,
0.21153834462165833,
-0.6319816708564758,
0.1340014636516571,
0.794042706489563,
-0.09200407564640045,
0.37332233786582947,
-0.06815255433320999,
0.41462740302085876,
0.1682061105966568,
-0.5885909199714661,
-0.5426947474479675,
0.8865953087806702,
0.14547720551490784,
0.6151866912841797,
0.4920310080051422,
0.5378782153129578,
0.5260165929794312,
0.9092456698417664,
-0.6165533661842346,
0.22607417404651642,
0.282736212015152,
-0.7206962704658508,
-0.4492571949958801,
-0.26197370886802673,
-1.4502918720245361,
0.45125654339790344,
-0.2248656302690506,
-0.8586075305938721,
-0.11464986205101013,
0.2458873987197876,
-0.14079953730106354,
0.018092820420861244,
-0.7827630639076233,
0.6924205422401428,
-0.2700137495994568,
-0.06631134450435638,
-0.8814977407455444,
-0.7244858145713806,
0.13200150430202484,
0.07381940633058548,
0.37770187854766846,
-0.2283729761838913,
0.3383603096008301,
0.4226718842983246,
-0.15196342766284943,
0.9934622645378113,
-0.1650906205177307,
-0.15887774527072906,
0.28137972950935364,
-0.1953088492155075,
0.5405855178833008,
0.41581445932388306,
-0.1288520246744156,
-0.0466318354010582,
-0.09407898783683777,
-0.09132561087608337,
-0.2990882396697998,
0.6322026252746582,
-0.8328194618225098,
-0.8320891261100769,
-0.2535470724105835,
-0.3459317684173584,
-0.24487923085689545,
0.07976773381233215,
-0.3486538827419281,
0.5705330967903137,
-0.5471236705780029,
0.13613168895244598,
-0.07312003523111343,
-0.41265666484832764,
0.472579687833786,
0.4895361065864563,
0.1505277454853058,
-0.43820324540138245,
0.9103430509567261,
-0.7669402360916138,
0.588092029094696,
0.35828250646591187,
0.6874703764915466,
-0.527067244052887,
-0.12161369621753693,
-0.9380576610565186,
0.14115110039710999,
-0.45758044719696045,
0.04636481776833534,
-0.3419664800167084,
0.264139324426651,
-0.6941434144973755,
-0.17859101295471191,
-0.15396803617477417,
-0.5269933938980103,
-0.1699189692735672,
0.37044113874435425,
0.30811062455177307,
1.2412375211715698,
-0.20768579840660095,
0.32506251335144043,
-0.9775914549827576,
0.22020937502384186,
0.2926618456840515,
0.20295792818069458,
0.18544359505176544,
-0.1731402575969696,
-0.06007695943117142,
0.4237484037876129,
-0.42825818061828613,
-1.0351371765136719,
0.007030443288385868,
0.1666717678308487,
0.5905992388725281,
0.6012519001960754,
-0.028528060764074326,
0.7816861867904663,
-0.3075813055038452,
0.9297729134559631,
0.45056724548339844,
-0.8362921476364136,
0.5413897037506104,
-0.3891838788986206,
0.16205856204032898,
0.4287169873714447,
0.18028737604618073,
-0.9273009300231934,
-0.5257591605186462,
-0.7621831297874451,
-0.3082287907600403,
0.821834146976471,
0.6206153631210327,
0.3533461093902588,
-0.015149644576013088,
-0.12919944524765015,
0.14121034741401672,
0.6837649345397949,
-0.5252739191055298,
-0.5520064830780029,
-0.29896458983421326,
0.05543227866292,
0.002310651121661067,
0.08649837225675583,
-0.43260645866394043,
-0.0295080728828907,
0.3721984624862671,
0.10433594882488251,
0.20866672694683075,
-0.13805176317691803,
0.21041344106197357,
0.17553237080574036,
0.4061182141304016,
0.8596358299255371,
0.7192651033401489,
0.3408578038215637,
-0.24084541201591492,
-0.45736876130104065,
-0.4024782180786133,
0.1476033329963684,
0.19716331362724304,
0.01707141473889351,
-0.23809343576431274,
0.2588396966457367,
0.704041600227356,
-0.09218961745500565,
-0.3760787546634674,
0.4215855896472931,
-0.6479441523551941,
-0.16168983280658722,
0.09384306520223618,
-0.17640459537506104,
0.5584425926208496,
0.12094604969024658,
0.17911046743392944,
0.06283906102180481,
0.22501157224178314,
-0.6418634057044983,
0.0556192584335804,
0.8218942284584045,
-0.15859654545783997,
-0.41608625650405884,
0.7580517530441284,
0.9063464999198914,
-0.9233778715133667,
0.829197883605957,
-0.1342814862728119,
-0.6925517320632935,
0.5996204614639282,
0.4980989396572113,
0.8450275659561157,
-0.3168233335018158,
0.7451215982437134,
0.1379784792661667,
0.14021003246307373,
0.19110241532325745,
-0.04403199255466461,
-0.3391065001487732,
-0.7084932923316956,
-0.003491046605631709,
-0.16686221957206726,
-0.7562264800071716,
0.1439717411994934,
-0.4427412450313568,
0.06333602964878082,
0.004203755874186754,
-0.42094868421554565,
0.18158169090747833,
-0.22834590077400208,
-0.8324760794639587,
-0.3422992527484894,
0.10654103010892868,
0.07077039033174515,
-0.4334897994995117,
0.5984451174736023,
0.7515223026275635,
-0.4357621371746063,
-0.6437714099884033,
-0.027178624644875526,
0.13015134632587433,
-0.8696464896202087,
0.47133511304855347,
0.1427983194589615,
-0.5660116672515869,
0.06167042255401611,
-0.48379087448120117,
-0.7071120738983154,
0.5048617720603943,
0.06559880822896957,
-0.4412505030632019,
0.3685053288936615,
0.3184468746185303,
0.5107906460762024,
-0.25008803606033325,
0.5409613847732544,
0.10056810081005096,
0.7431981563568115,
-0.16169923543930054,
-1.314158320426941,
-0.2774052619934082,
-0.2162274271249771,
-0.2142230123281479,
0.22158263623714447,
-0.8750286102294922,
0.46892064809799194,
-0.17858287692070007,
-0.30438870191574097,
0.14782492816448212,
0.5282953977584839,
0.2439521700143814,
0.08597380667924881,
0.704742968082428,
-0.20783650875091553,
0.6109715700149536,
0.10991445928812027,
1.0069125890731812,
-0.4571468234062195,
0.3361304700374603,
0.6450175046920776,
-0.25220146775245667,
0.4966304302215576,
0.5799751281738281,
-0.37863433361053467,
0.22991150617599487,
0.26202166080474854,
0.19733069837093353,
0.13129745423793793,
0.7828965187072754,
-0.5958691239356995,
-0.10299336910247803,
-0.40921053290367126,
-0.3736538589000702,
0.37325629591941833,
0.4999757409095764,
0.18436390161514282,
-0.0416506826877594,
0.3794071078300476,
0.06265832483768463,
-0.2673342823982239,
-0.023132044821977615,
0.4948868751525879,
-0.20194600522518158,
-0.7193608283996582,
-0.022404540330171585,
0.06500938534736633,
0.7457646131515503,
-0.5737836956977844,
-0.42755597829818726,
0.04425713047385216,
0.41134628653526306,
0.20491303503513336,
-0.6326873302459717,
-0.07105507701635361,
-0.18669524788856506,
0.14470531046390533,
-0.2728792726993561,
0.8503870368003845,
-0.5003214478492737,
-0.4248547852039337,
0.17190761864185333,
0.7517424821853638,
0.33863142132759094,
-0.02905154414474964,
-1.0617238283157349,
0.28162717819213867,
-0.10524097084999084,
-0.3468080163002014,
0.4553132951259613,
0.14196525514125824,
-0.06520167738199234,
0.844811201095581,
0.7803681492805481,
-0.05191385746002197,
-0.33288103342056274,
0.8539465665817261,
0.8389360308647156,
-0.36399683356285095,
-0.3655810058116913,
-0.8819040060043335,
0.3609441816806793,
-0.10507284849882126,
-0.5281966924667358,
0.8578180074691772,
0.35083845257759094,
0.7098643779754639,
-0.17303770780563354,
0.9340364336967468,
-0.37800073623657227,
0.27113887667655945,
0.06540025025606155,
0.594283401966095,
-0.38366422057151794,
-0.09970720112323761,
-0.49855586886405945,
-0.36237090826034546,
-0.026249103248119354,
0.7455877661705017,
0.3093782365322113,
0.2106439620256424,
0.3400076925754547,
0.45127469301223755,
0.2957436144351959,
0.5178600549697876,
0.11208096891641617,
-0.2019609659910202,
0.9033691883087158,
0.45325884222984314,
1.3350025415420532,
-0.05029883235692978,
0.7482200264930725,
-0.17126582562923431,
-0.3750445246696472,
-0.0803418681025505,
-0.7728584408760071,
-1.09658682346344,
-0.5901741981506348,
-0.3363270163536072,
-0.2562990188598633,
0.34039512276649475,
0.7783073782920837,
0.5916690826416016,
-0.5522217154502869,
-0.42246776819229126,
0.3089554011821747,
0.049581632018089294,
-0.2545642852783203,
-0.25968000292778015,
0.30747362971305847,
0.2968752980232239,
-1.0155500173568726,
0.48337996006011963,
0.354446142911911,
0.016290992498397827,
-0.7225615382194519,
-0.06033322960138321,
-0.3564069867134094,
-0.02337617613375187,
0.5899316072463989,
0.1493343859910965,
-0.7355185747146606,
-0.5710680484771729,
-0.035254206508398056,
0.10209627449512482,
0.1677742451429367,
1.2242372035980225,
-0.8370063900947571,
0.16638913750648499,
0.3316883146762848,
0.5388235449790955,
0.2434009462594986,
0.4204835295677185,
0.7965710163116455,
-0.1819053739309311,
0.07737956196069717,
0.3468916416168213,
-0.0036316642072051764,
0.31412234902381897,
-0.34266525506973267,
0.28592798113822937,
0.24278396368026733,
-0.7704101204872131,
-0.4445384740829468,
0.31209617853164673,
-0.5417613983154297,
-0.09578321129083633,
0.9238330125808716,
0.06381101161241531,
0.46847212314605713,
-0.4803387522697449,
-0.5819464325904846,
0.15009523928165436,
-1.000478982925415,
0.731366753578186,
1.0122790336608887,
-0.6110360026359558,
-0.025680191814899445,
-0.3793018162250519,
0.46534463763237,
0.4006337821483612,
-0.9065932035446167,
-0.08130725473165512,
0.5607654452323914,
-0.06936015188694,
0.21447525918483734,
1.1457232236862183,
0.21482904255390167,
0.1760801076889038,
-0.03945290669798851,
-0.00004583804911817424,
0.1868208646774292,
-0.23969030380249023,
-0.25108543038368225,
0.019367728382349014,
-0.018845101818442345,
-0.31273210048675537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19643v1 | Unlocking Varied Perspectives: A Persona-Based Multi-Agent Framework with Debate-Driven Text Planning for Argument Generation | 2024-06-28T04:21:20 | 2024-06-28T04:21:20 | Zhe Hu, Hou Pong Chan, Jing Li, Yu Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Writing persuasive arguments is a challenging task for both humans and
machines. It entails incorporating high-level beliefs from various perspectives
on the topic, along with deliberate reasoning and planning to construct a
coherent narrative. Current language models often generate surface tokens
autoregressively, lacking explicit integration of these underlying controls,
resulting in limited output diversity and coherence. In this work, we propose a
persona-based multi-agent framework for argument writing. Inspired by the human
debate, we first assign each agent a persona representing its high-level
beliefs from a unique perspective, and then design an agent interaction process
so that the agents can collaboratively debate and discuss the idea to form an
overall plan for argument writing. Such debate process enables fluid and
nonlinear development of ideas. We evaluate our framework on argumentative
essay writing. The results show that our framework can generate more diverse
and persuasive arguments through both automatic and human evaluations. | [
-0.6930874586105347,
-0.5987662672996521,
0.8138469457626343,
0.24248240888118744,
0.005676829721778631,
0.2888530194759369,
0.18444041907787323,
0.04029873013496399,
0.23053710162639618,
0.6603062748908997,
-0.7825362682342529,
-0.3751942217350006,
-0.20900171995162964,
0.1781163513660431,
0.19779068231582642,
1.0581717491149902,
-0.11938881874084473,
-0.12049755454063416,
-0.2658282518386841,
-0.31766486167907715,
-0.38448330760002136,
-0.5759780406951904,
-0.6331808567047119,
-0.38745245337486267,
0.973752498626709,
0.7358143329620361,
0.40720081329345703,
0.3144221603870392,
0.023173155263066292,
0.3881075084209442,
0.5174809694290161,
0.2665591835975647,
-0.060712214559316635,
0.730366051197052,
-0.5719037055969238,
-0.2155834585428238,
-0.19959399104118347,
0.016974560916423798,
0.6021164655685425,
0.46862754225730896,
0.11551379412412643,
-0.274506539106369,
-0.30107325315475464,
0.262654185295105,
-0.6410424113273621,
-0.33636945486068726,
-0.6116290092468262,
0.32066377997398376,
-0.22592318058013916,
-0.09936884045600891,
-0.4274277091026306,
-0.28856194019317627,
0.3551193177700043,
-0.47146227955818176,
-0.11547964066267014,
-0.0694229006767273,
0.7766280174255371,
-0.08319620043039322,
-0.5653727054595947,
-0.35079482197761536,
-0.6912277936935425,
0.5252037644386292,
-0.552314817905426,
-0.21694892644882202,
-0.33523041009902954,
0.30236074328422546,
-0.11445102095603943,
-0.7674956917762756,
-0.6237130761146545,
0.14112302660942078,
0.11445030570030212,
0.2711038291454315,
-0.08998939394950867,
0.03751465305685997,
-0.13289391994476318,
-0.0652027428150177,
-0.3450920283794403,
0.0052114492282271385,
0.367461621761322,
-0.22401350736618042,
0.6465013027191162,
0.30208247900009155,
0.14528274536132812,
-0.18247808516025543,
-0.4741688072681427,
-0.12065399438142776,
-0.3396146297454834,
0.1700921207666397,
0.8643248081207275,
0.24809181690216064,
0.02333925850689411,
0.47308647632598877,
-0.04401319846510887,
0.23251190781593323,
0.5370497107505798,
-0.18464995920658112,
-0.28641340136528015,
-0.02033780887722969,
-0.14940796792507172,
-0.14086133241653442,
0.9442014098167419,
0.3399324417114258,
-0.1564021110534668,
-0.0787462666630745,
-0.04659915715456009,
0.1146211102604866,
0.436440110206604,
-0.8857837915420532,
-0.21271930634975433,
0.3390883207321167,
-0.45561444759368896,
-0.4534229636192322,
0.10700749605894089,
-1.1964105367660522,
-0.9080333709716797,
-0.09045746922492981,
0.25034311413764954,
-0.2813657224178314,
-0.333893746137619,
0.08041401207447052,
-0.4754187762737274,
0.28759920597076416,
0.5435197353363037,
-0.7171835899353027,
0.34660980105400085,
0.46634364128112793,
0.2749820649623871,
-0.14074599742889404,
-0.600300669670105,
-0.5951213836669922,
0.5115428566932678,
-0.35594579577445984,
1.4673634767532349,
-0.9376137256622314,
-0.3068650960922241,
0.08026369661092758,
-0.33487164974212646,
-0.12945374846458435,
-0.28442275524139404,
0.7225384712219238,
-0.04882923886179924,
0.6133263111114502,
-0.5515024662017822,
-0.49545833468437195,
0.17385533452033997,
0.23325203359127045,
-0.5227063298225403,
0.5605882406234741,
-0.10752768069505692,
-0.7139718532562256,
0.7262625694274902,
-1.0106420516967773,
-0.6070528626441956,
0.2981821298599243,
-0.5988190174102783,
-0.4647698998451233,
0.03744103014469147,
0.17863361537456512,
0.4078046977519989,
-0.4487704634666443,
0.48645853996276855,
-0.06666330248117447,
0.21657010912895203,
0.4304749667644501,
-0.40362074971199036,
0.49118974804878235,
0.24010609090328217,
-0.7144213318824768,
0.47297951579093933,
-0.7555961012840271,
-0.028817497193813324,
-0.07624891400337219,
-0.48489615321159363,
0.003427512478083372,
0.3965851068496704,
-0.03874896466732025,
0.2688450217247009,
0.05749151483178139,
-0.48387476801872253,
0.2096031904220581,
-0.3529873192310333,
0.40862077474594116,
0.788838803768158,
0.3245004117488861,
0.5123066902160645,
-0.6237937808036804,
0.7080231308937073,
0.23195034265518188,
-0.38617318868637085,
-0.4375027120113373,
-0.5885127186775208,
-0.5784052610397339,
-0.17010733485221863,
-0.19550399482250214,
0.372340589761734,
-0.6503838896751404,
0.16505616903305054,
0.043997667729854584,
-0.42699286341667175,
-0.3982502520084381,
-0.17922188341617584,
0.3667680323123932,
0.42426609992980957,
-0.04397214204072952,
-0.2200649082660675,
-0.5104167461395264,
-0.9948722720146179,
-0.602878212928772,
-0.4072897136211395,
0.10253658145666122,
0.3997538387775421,
0.40547776222229004,
-0.1647319793701172,
1.1274380683898926,
-0.5317896604537964,
0.18032220005989075,
-0.5519537329673767,
0.6911846399307251,
-0.45358145236968994,
0.49794647097587585,
0.6109997630119324,
-0.6537724137306213,
-0.61639404296875,
0.0568801611661911,
-0.5313628911972046,
-0.26297733187675476,
-0.8929373621940613,
-0.5905390977859497,
0.21147921681404114,
0.03282606229186058,
-0.6904872059822083,
0.35546043515205383,
-0.14669232070446014,
-0.5841700434684753,
0.5145156383514404,
-0.023800315335392952,
0.18698933720588684,
-1.3672525882720947,
-0.07539734244346619,
0.1466730237007141,
-0.1729080080986023,
-0.5778601169586182,
0.11162367463111877,
-0.5442236661911011,
-0.2947559952735901,
-0.216166153550148,
0.6147971153259277,
-0.1287008374929428,
0.5210726261138916,
-0.45430445671081543,
-0.025940265506505966,
0.6224877834320068,
0.467178076505661,
0.17510002851486206,
0.41127467155456543,
0.15800367295742035,
-0.193404883146286,
0.309532105922699,
0.12892045080661774,
0.12607437372207642,
1.1623671054840088,
-0.4121982455253601,
0.3929865062236786,
-0.28833356499671936,
0.5658523440361023,
-1.0091856718063354,
-0.49456143379211426,
0.46385058760643005,
-0.11495781689882278,
-0.00786228571087122,
0.08548139780759811,
-0.14301708340644836,
-0.16716797649860382,
-0.33282068371772766,
-0.007458335720002651,
-0.20351694524288177,
-0.3268739879131317,
1.0956958532333374,
0.7134956121444702,
-0.40575870871543884,
-0.4813686013221741,
-0.46815210580825806,
0.5812926292419434,
-0.6117942333221436,
-0.711823582649231,
0.6167293787002563,
-0.24807296693325043,
-0.5675296783447266,
-0.110746830701828,
0.20570316910743713,
-0.23936046659946442,
-0.32429125905036926,
0.25845932960510254,
-0.19438089430332184,
-0.25863662362098694,
0.10863448679447174,
0.575864315032959,
0.011845631524920464,
0.15675975382328033,
-0.553321897983551,
0.5000723004341125,
-0.21389904618263245,
-0.19528038799762726,
-0.1626921445131302,
1.2498530149459839,
0.6457636952400208,
-0.179603710770607,
0.42232683300971985,
0.22403094172477722,
-0.4234517812728882,
-0.43377092480659485,
-0.6914864778518677,
0.10052613168954849,
-0.4666441082954407,
0.20459085702896118,
-0.7620152831077576,
-0.48251405358314514,
0.6122824549674988,
-0.39023804664611816,
0.5831247568130493,
0.4164992570877075,
0.9346780180931091,
0.00510444026440382,
0.6775900721549988,
0.3417648375034332,
0.44683077931404114,
0.129736989736557,
0.1647598296403885,
0.18891318142414093,
-0.23360957205295563,
-0.27878692746162415,
-0.6092835664749146,
-0.37971797585487366,
-0.15714667737483978,
-0.3647749722003937,
-0.2406477928161621,
-0.4838184416294098,
-0.39710867404937744,
0.027939867228269577,
-0.6757836937904358,
0.45576927065849304,
0.4575352966785431,
-0.3863104581832886,
0.03207535669207573,
-0.07578038424253464,
-0.5710694193840027,
-0.37025266885757446,
-0.46824946999549866,
-1.0824542045593262,
0.8376911282539368,
0.1726987212896347,
0.2732086777687073,
0.06679242849349976,
0.7303705811500549,
0.2987835109233856,
0.501680314540863,
-0.5236709713935852,
0.6525551080703735,
0.10950524359941483,
-0.7630478739738464,
-0.16327908635139465,
-0.10150417685508728,
-0.8757447004318237,
0.7812120914459229,
-0.2613820433616638,
-0.755286455154419,
0.44115540385246277,
-0.13308703899383545,
-0.5038815140724182,
0.4885596036911011,
-0.7056620717048645,
1.082335114479065,
-0.24412809312343597,
-0.6446921229362488,
0.012574756518006325,
-0.7153946757316589,
-0.008567145094275475,
0.20317184925079346,
-0.09867220371961594,
-0.036318037658929825,
-0.037390533834695816,
0.6037780046463013,
-0.4671964943408966,
0.7996357679367065,
-0.3001067638397217,
-0.3098682463169098,
0.6638332605361938,
-0.1120881661772728,
0.10495433211326599,
0.30334198474884033,
-0.26815035939216614,
-0.5401429533958435,
-0.10769487917423248,
-0.24270989000797272,
-0.39457982778549194,
0.5815856456756592,
-0.7348564863204956,
-0.7114500999450684,
-0.3656120002269745,
-0.5472859740257263,
-0.4011247158050537,
0.17511381208896637,
0.3364107012748718,
0.34094521403312683,
-0.7415513396263123,
-0.16810579597949982,
0.3884706199169159,
-0.33933645486831665,
0.5426713228225708,
0.3473869562149048,
-0.025635583326220512,
-0.8113713264465332,
0.9908233284950256,
-0.03720162808895111,
-0.06735832989215851,
0.3838815689086914,
0.5164373517036438,
-0.32499960064888,
-0.33152440190315247,
-0.6619063019752502,
-0.14187541604042053,
-0.8402007818222046,
-0.03165801241993904,
-0.7874805927276611,
0.034695811569690704,
-0.36006978154182434,
-0.6574459671974182,
-0.41947653889656067,
-0.4359508454799652,
-0.06358625739812851,
0.06820973008871078,
-0.2604402005672455,
0.6885039806365967,
0.14401982724666595,
0.5355207920074463,
-0.2250588983297348,
0.341048002243042,
0.4431843161582947,
0.04706117883324623,
-0.11364027857780457,
0.18272218108177185,
0.020894518122076988,
0.0007754597463645041,
-1.024111270904541,
-1.2425905466079712,
0.36355412006378174,
-0.12553590536117554,
0.6418259739875793,
0.5697009563446045,
0.06733274459838867,
0.5163307785987854,
-0.4495769441127777,
0.8286482691764832,
0.32042592763900757,
-0.8928764462471008,
0.5634713768959045,
-0.5288283824920654,
0.26496970653533936,
0.7597722411155701,
-0.03282162919640541,
-0.44310569763183594,
-0.4601178467273712,
-0.6296576261520386,
-0.687127947807312,
0.5368301272392273,
0.03960668295621872,
0.1002749353647232,
0.1916477233171463,
0.3354951739311218,
0.6351790428161621,
0.5606564283370972,
-0.935501217842102,
0.1143130287528038,
-0.6138578057289124,
-0.24062174558639526,
0.3292529582977295,
0.07268678396940231,
-0.5154218077659607,
-0.3493747413158417,
0.18373925983905792,
-0.41058051586151123,
0.1753533035516739,
0.1301662176847458,
0.2814677059650421,
-0.2580328583717346,
0.5245583057403564,
0.7088652849197388,
0.6273308992385864,
0.304725706577301,
0.26648619771003723,
-0.13726617395877838,
-0.28991565108299255,
0.41461512446403503,
0.2461559921503067,
-0.24197795987129211,
-0.05770710110664368,
0.10782228410243988,
0.8659868836402893,
-0.0381765142083168,
-0.47200465202331543,
0.2889215052127838,
-0.44173872470855713,
-0.6123884916305542,
-0.24951907992362976,
0.027527399361133575,
0.5154208540916443,
0.366064190864563,
0.3179968595504761,
0.4097866415977478,
-0.08922336995601654,
-0.6030322313308716,
-0.020587708801031113,
0.3283727765083313,
0.006623644381761551,
-0.2689853012561798,
0.836614191532135,
0.617801308631897,
-0.5421395301818848,
-0.11514919251203537,
-0.22943690419197083,
-0.31515946984291077,
0.6338915228843689,
0.47508808970451355,
1.1974526643753052,
-0.12000852823257446,
0.7999268770217896,
-0.0883210152387619,
0.07416980713605881,
0.37446826696395874,
0.37844231724739075,
0.002401338191702962,
-0.7223195433616638,
-0.12982700765132904,
-0.42992568016052246,
-0.6000460386276245,
0.3586563467979431,
-0.004055425059050322,
0.10591715574264526,
-0.7862876653671265,
-0.14530104398727417,
0.3471356928348541,
0.4024929702281952,
-0.2846715450286865,
0.08186373859643936,
0.009135027416050434,
0.36571967601776123,
-0.6816204190254211,
0.4179685115814209,
1.182461142539978,
-0.3038763701915741,
-0.5036229491233826,
0.6890330910682678,
-0.0031063708011060953,
0.22993479669094086,
0.0196699071675539,
0.24865388870239258,
-0.5830532312393188,
-0.43675917387008667,
-0.6485898494720459,
-0.38592737913131714,
0.7824931144714355,
0.7724347710609436,
-0.09424392133951187,
-0.014071750454604626,
0.3195582628250122,
0.6015905737876892,
-1.1765164136886597,
-0.00400790898129344,
0.07190661132335663,
0.6763039231300354,
0.20982979238033295,
-0.08423110842704773,
0.0005929755861870944,
-0.4028453230857849,
-0.1656956523656845,
-0.3411891460418701,
-0.8201125264167786,
1.0069353580474854,
-0.13530667126178741,
-0.17647449672222137,
-0.029847964644432068,
0.8700727820396423,
0.2410854995250702,
0.6016880869865417,
0.34599316120147705,
0.3140804171562195,
0.8700368404388428,
0.37068480253219604,
0.7495426535606384,
-0.08705639839172363,
-0.39202752709388733,
1.1316782236099243,
-0.7369409203529358,
0.5249666571617126,
0.3178241550922394,
0.2570669651031494,
0.9380021095275879,
0.37810948491096497,
0.22344522178173065,
0.2673950493335724,
0.18516753613948822,
-0.6190962195396423,
-0.5162739753723145,
-0.0743606686592102,
-0.06268724054098129,
0.468180775642395,
0.22483621537685394,
0.0020219171419739723,
-0.1551886647939682,
-0.05036720260977745,
0.22284115850925446,
0.7835981845855713,
0.25842297077178955,
0.7628241777420044,
-0.1842595785856247,
-1.1793211698532104,
-0.04483354091644287,
0.4625474810600281,
0.2731289267539978,
-0.30271151661872864,
0.025406502187252045,
-0.003716045059263706,
0.11250844597816467,
-0.0765315517783165,
-0.7198503017425537,
0.06696267426013947,
0.13671875,
-0.15242229402065277,
-0.504656970500946,
0.9594199657440186,
-0.2996419370174408,
-0.44999775290489197,
-0.11457792669534683,
0.695637047290802,
-0.18743206560611725,
0.22213973104953766,
-0.6507065296173096,
-0.15394948422908783,
-0.15974360704421997,
-0.44417840242385864,
0.29115933179855347,
0.8524232506752014,
-0.018967393785715103,
0.35372093319892883,
0.33542105555534363,
-0.1570330560207367,
-0.15157102048397064,
0.15908990800380707,
1.1224496364593506,
-0.4128068685531616,
-0.6626659631729126,
-0.9174056053161621,
0.7828264832496643,
-0.5978904962539673,
-0.6989299058914185,
0.319187194108963,
0.7135700583457947,
0.18691104650497437,
0.13535426557064056,
1.188236117362976,
0.028020234778523445,
0.4868718683719635,
0.17439021170139313,
0.8545028567314148,
-0.29049816727638245,
-0.04029330238699913,
-0.5683251023292542,
-0.641307532787323,
-0.030068950727581978,
0.8378801941871643,
-0.09879361838102341,
-0.06967775523662567,
0.7029606699943542,
0.2389005571603775,
0.09826580435037613,
0.20471909642219543,
0.05123294144868851,
-0.10796692967414856,
0.836523711681366,
0.7510764598846436,
1.0301064252853394,
0.006544915493577719,
0.4315837621688843,
0.04086818918585777,
-0.2128480225801468,
0.15972566604614258,
-1.009092092514038,
-1.2005895376205444,
-0.8079357743263245,
-0.4885585904121399,
-0.11218766868114471,
-0.05693049356341362,
0.814592719078064,
0.5672373175621033,
-0.3966507613658905,
-0.4860494136810303,
-0.34662505984306335,
0.29946959018707275,
0.07221534848213196,
-0.2601029574871063,
-0.12787127494812012,
-0.18920904397964478,
-0.7040836215019226,
0.3717821538448334,
0.49686387181282043,
-0.29802364110946655,
-0.5820502638816833,
-0.262987345457077,
-0.5092306137084961,
0.9029766917228699,
0.38759535551071167,
0.4139738380908966,
-0.650616466999054,
-0.31901466846466064,
-0.3349461257457733,
-0.18520395457744598,
0.35692620277404785,
1.150842308998108,
-0.7518276572227478,
0.396610826253891,
0.3441927134990692,
0.7146620750427246,
0.2998862564563751,
0.1756749004125595,
0.9814431071281433,
-0.5670061111450195,
0.1873064935207367,
0.6350914835929871,
0.14011752605438232,
0.35644736886024475,
-0.2648663818836212,
-0.15376169979572296,
0.225770965218544,
-0.5139583349227905,
-0.7119788527488708,
0.579473078250885,
-0.7648084163665771,
-0.6942070126533508,
0.863156259059906,
-0.28600969910621643,
0.05587514862418175,
-0.16336208581924438,
-0.6464480757713318,
0.053084325045347214,
-0.565837025642395,
0.681354820728302,
1.0379266738891602,
-0.4894647002220154,
-0.14489516615867615,
0.006837751250714064,
0.5052972435951233,
0.4582899510860443,
-1.3368088006973267,
0.2669409513473511,
0.7787660956382751,
-0.011268443427979946,
0.2483624815940857,
1.010993480682373,
0.06732085347175598,
0.0973026379942894,
0.5252705216407776,
-0.10781797021627426,
0.3614519536495209,
-0.69060218334198,
0.17897309362888336,
0.9438775181770325,
-0.04485737904906273,
0.23879702389240265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19642v1 | IDT: Dual-Task Adversarial Attacks for Privacy Protection | 2024-06-28T04:14:35 | 2024-06-28T04:14:35 | Pedro Faustini, Shakila Mahjabin Tonni, Annabelle McIver, Qiongkai Xu, Mark Dras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Natural language processing (NLP) models may leak private information in
different ways, including membership inference, reconstruction or attribute
inference attacks. Sensitive information may not be explicit in the text, but
hidden in underlying writing characteristics. Methods to protect privacy can
involve using representations inside models that are demonstrated not to detect
sensitive attributes or -- for instance, in cases where users might not trust a
model, the sort of scenario of interest here -- changing the raw text before
models can have access to it. The goal is to rewrite text to prevent someone
from inferring a sensitive attribute (e.g. the gender of the author, or their
location by the writing style) whilst keeping the text useful for its original
intention (e.g. the sentiment of a product review). The few works tackling this
have focused on generative techniques. However, these often create extensively
different texts from the original ones or face problems such as mode collapse.
This paper explores a novel adaptation of adversarial attack techniques to
manipulate a text to deceive a classifier w.r.t one task (privacy) whilst
keeping the predictions of another classifier trained for another task
(utility) unchanged. We propose IDT, a method that analyses predictions made by
auxiliary and interpretable models to identify which tokens are important to
change for the privacy task, and which ones should be kept for the utility
task. We evaluate different datasets for NLP suitable for different tasks.
Automatic and human evaluations show that IDT retains the utility of text,
while also outperforming existing methods when deceiving a classifier w.r.t
privacy task. | [
-0.24135248363018036,
-0.8827303647994995,
0.1196555644273758,
0.20615018904209137,
-0.1555517017841339,
0.3086090087890625,
-0.13269877433776855,
-0.44534680247306824,
-0.2505066692829132,
0.6807976365089417,
-0.5662062168121338,
-0.40007483959198,
-0.8937206864356995,
-0.05012545734643936,
-0.5780421495437622,
1.3089019060134888,
0.2137896716594696,
-0.1466648280620575,
-0.061714719980955124,
-0.06632420420646667,
-0.2974749207496643,
-0.78801429271698,
-0.8336026668548584,
-0.23752817511558533,
0.2851819396018982,
-0.09291209280490875,
0.9377784132957458,
0.3327185809612274,
0.6894955635070801,
0.2504238486289978,
-0.07302172482013702,
-0.031514063477516174,
-0.22590802609920502,
0.4420383870601654,
-0.3075411319732666,
-0.5242342352867126,
-0.18118123710155487,
0.0724688470363617,
0.5405600070953369,
0.07826392352581024,
0.34316834807395935,
-0.0032096276991069317,
0.46908727288246155,
0.7589947581291199,
-0.5888712406158447,
0.26020923256874084,
-0.8331562280654907,
0.09889538586139679,
-0.24107611179351807,
-0.27736109495162964,
-0.6215185523033142,
-0.060666389763355255,
0.12225735187530518,
-0.2074180394411087,
0.47172877192497253,
-0.15621836483478546,
0.7491478323936462,
0.6914710998535156,
-0.5229877233505249,
-0.18344125151634216,
-0.8728713393211365,
0.5370474457740784,
-0.5577024221420288,
-0.03556254133582115,
0.5286731123924255,
0.041186895221471786,
-0.3015260696411133,
-0.6406909823417664,
-0.5450213551521301,
-0.46795719861984253,
-0.40863680839538574,
0.10260789096355438,
-0.3714763820171356,
0.25972050428390503,
0.40080299973487854,
0.38023385405540466,
-0.5563985705375671,
0.19096995890140533,
-0.08306602388620377,
-0.04526406154036522,
0.7562400102615356,
-0.11653929203748703,
0.3461986780166626,
-0.18179017305374146,
-0.8399826884269714,
-0.2420247346162796,
-0.6135836243629456,
0.07348731905221939,
0.786384105682373,
0.11005707085132599,
-0.03996913880109787,
0.4668085277080536,
0.10758011788129807,
0.45611289143562317,
0.11694357544183731,
0.032320912927389145,
-0.2753497064113617,
-0.24528129398822784,
-0.4296652376651764,
0.028212418779730797,
1.0092579126358032,
0.13283400237560272,
-0.13509124517440796,
-0.48116186261177063,
-0.07586101442575455,
0.3171828091144562,
0.4898616075515747,
-0.6011704206466675,
-0.4412521719932556,
0.24122291803359985,
-0.3679253160953522,
-0.6777167916297913,
0.18005193769931793,
-0.9075284600257874,
-0.7525469660758972,
-0.3071196973323822,
0.5007513165473938,
-0.5783379077911377,
-0.27000948786735535,
-0.0003405568131711334,
-0.18949458003044128,
-0.13028603792190552,
-0.07044199109077454,
-0.9099729657173157,
0.5407435894012451,
0.9840419888496399,
0.765188455581665,
-0.08227243274450302,
-0.20479710400104523,
-0.24146108329296112,
0.11789366602897644,
0.15294089913368225,
0.39649707078933716,
-0.31545549631118774,
-0.43906036019325256,
-0.20405925810337067,
-0.10960634797811508,
-0.3651280999183655,
-0.17453807592391968,
0.6752349138259888,
-0.7141796350479126,
0.4538596272468567,
-0.053544461727142334,
-0.29887664318084717,
-0.40781325101852417,
0.5099498629570007,
-0.8886941075325012,
0.85767662525177,
-0.06859447062015533,
-1.2585241794586182,
0.2306981086730957,
-1.0312117338180542,
-0.4701519012451172,
-0.12238448858261108,
-0.10092504322528839,
-0.6016200184822083,
-0.0038213988300412893,
0.23022852838039398,
0.3649381101131439,
-0.07993243634700775,
0.051854319870471954,
-0.01903684437274933,
-0.1008673906326294,
0.46119260787963867,
-0.8559778928756714,
1.1674436330795288,
0.2109374850988388,
-0.6905645132064819,
0.1866372674703598,
-0.5781962275505066,
-0.09157434850931168,
0.2727721929550171,
-0.16288486123085022,
-0.6362287402153015,
-0.053166463971138,
-0.04388647526502609,
-0.00164781603962183,
0.351767361164093,
-0.676842212677002,
0.2553330361843109,
-0.5891081690788269,
0.5761878490447998,
0.8779548406600952,
0.1396550089120865,
0.4982456862926483,
-0.4219653308391571,
0.601723849773407,
-0.12811602652072906,
0.31243276596069336,
0.1121935322880745,
-0.6606301665306091,
-0.4208344519138336,
-0.21519352495670319,
0.4385421574115753,
0.6937898397445679,
-0.8562555313110352,
0.22473427653312683,
-0.17816098034381866,
-0.3938404321670532,
-0.5405070781707764,
-0.0632539689540863,
0.7153638601303101,
0.2405950278043747,
0.14425621926784515,
-0.05397065356373787,
-0.30720630288124084,
-0.9907395243644714,
-0.8127936124801636,
-0.1234007254242897,
0.1268802434206009,
-0.2658044099807739,
0.46155133843421936,
-0.21862219274044037,
0.748656690120697,
-0.29085561633110046,
-0.4166264235973358,
-0.04275008291006088,
0.34269699454307556,
-0.2466045469045639,
0.7274601459503174,
0.6423461437225342,
-1.3333491086959839,
-0.6366228461265564,
-0.15016955137252808,
-0.6653326749801636,
0.3022949695587158,
-0.4362047016620636,
-0.12296462804079056,
0.11283646523952484,
0.20207414031028748,
-0.4775870442390442,
0.7302810549736023,
0.7144481539726257,
-0.5955950617790222,
0.3146096169948578,
-0.34512338042259216,
0.11333707720041275,
-1.1064404249191284,
-0.22435256838798523,
-0.06827962398529053,
-0.2526724636554718,
-0.7055301070213318,
0.5294151902198792,
0.11210934817790985,
-0.20817528665065765,
-0.23493891954421997,
0.47487038373947144,
-0.4933570921421051,
0.35268256068229675,
-0.3758774399757385,
-0.3403606414794922,
0.10806535184383392,
0.5050367712974548,
-0.3785518705844879,
0.8944635391235352,
0.4359629154205322,
-0.4616783559322357,
0.2868436276912689,
0.2910766303539276,
-0.002336605219170451,
0.5435900688171387,
-0.34588736295700073,
0.7164479494094849,
-0.294341117143631,
-0.11105664819478989,
-0.8082903027534485,
-0.11387830227613449,
0.552935004234314,
-0.5634825825691223,
0.694856584072113,
-0.24917972087860107,
-0.8615387082099915,
-0.1002735123038292,
-0.5313578248023987,
0.09090042859315872,
0.2576466202735901,
-0.6832355260848999,
0.5319541096687317,
0.4641042947769165,
0.05595727264881134,
-0.716431736946106,
-0.9810548424720764,
0.6130461692810059,
-0.5264219641685486,
-0.686840295791626,
0.6501191258430481,
-0.10219673067331314,
-0.36537522077560425,
0.34804877638816833,
-0.015702296048402786,
-0.19229832291603088,
0.5401572585105896,
0.42678624391555786,
0.04201405495405197,
0.1759258210659027,
0.04233178123831749,
0.09105850011110306,
-0.2741091847419739,
0.2952258586883545,
-0.20804762840270996,
0.29959604144096375,
-0.06553865224123001,
-0.30313947796821594,
-0.7437488436698914,
0.686881959438324,
0.4619576632976532,
-0.2835160493850708,
0.9498106837272644,
0.5516400933265686,
-0.47609859704971313,
-0.27808523178100586,
-0.27099066972732544,
-0.28217315673828125,
-0.4320732057094574,
0.20987848937511444,
-0.43909451365470886,
-0.501339316368103,
0.27058306336402893,
0.1833278089761734,
0.2911488115787506,
0.26074478030204773,
0.39807233214378357,
0.03818498179316521,
1.1417957544326782,
0.857676088809967,
-0.02980705536901951,
0.5732392072677612,
-0.33358055353164673,
0.5316992402076721,
-0.8263999223709106,
-0.0936480462551117,
-0.30190330743789673,
-0.47367045283317566,
-0.7164674401283264,
-0.12654146552085876,
0.4096031188964844,
-0.21794463694095612,
0.03228866308927536,
0.4512307345867157,
-0.9267652034759521,
0.3755861818790436,
0.9973624348640442,
0.4091028571128845,
0.3580581247806549,
0.05395597591996193,
0.4305763244628906,
-0.20908620953559875,
-0.36049237847328186,
-0.6246347427368164,
1.3891642093658447,
0.2630734145641327,
0.6855172514915466,
0.32536277174949646,
0.7113631367683411,
0.6153944134712219,
0.3734618127346039,
-0.5241457223892212,
0.48647579550743103,
-0.610839307308197,
-0.7334507703781128,
-0.1302030086517334,
-0.1733676940202713,
-0.8520371913909912,
0.4453177750110626,
-0.09888552874326706,
-0.8318191170692444,
0.05984203517436981,
0.08744586259126663,
-0.2833513617515564,
0.6545575857162476,
-0.82915198802948,
0.8127005100250244,
-0.2670058310031891,
-0.34532299637794495,
-0.03992042690515518,
-0.6959491968154907,
0.5894613862037659,
-0.10531142354011536,
-0.08305992186069489,
0.06288027763366699,
0.16006074845790863,
0.7966757416725159,
-0.16092945635318756,
1.0271990299224854,
-0.19247262179851532,
0.17131060361862183,
0.05071745440363884,
0.29780006408691406,
0.6864931583404541,
0.2583155632019043,
-0.11717043817043304,
0.11857336759567261,
0.24428483843803406,
-0.16662167012691498,
-0.692306399345398,
0.7719751000404358,
-0.5419318079948425,
-0.9613573551177979,
-0.7516060471534729,
-0.6435353755950928,
-0.15160836279392242,
0.04988503456115723,
0.4806203842163086,
0.26449131965637207,
-0.14792244136333466,
0.4268970191478729,
0.7412357330322266,
0.033283185213804245,
0.29135170578956604,
0.09457818418741226,
0.2930484414100647,
-0.17778268456459045,
0.5689145922660828,
-0.044708508998155594,
0.4322816729545593,
0.5503942370414734,
0.31834906339645386,
-0.36168530583381653,
-0.6559730172157288,
-0.34579864144325256,
0.00596534414216876,
-0.7412331700325012,
-0.26962509751319885,
-0.8118366003036499,
-0.2994718551635742,
-0.5688226222991943,
0.025905510410666466,
-0.12414811551570892,
-0.45529991388320923,
-0.36559587717056274,
-0.12256285548210144,
0.3807941675186157,
0.6684591174125671,
-0.0729384571313858,
0.4201407730579376,
-0.47103625535964966,
0.5188289880752563,
0.3401549160480499,
0.02486507222056389,
-0.3455340266227722,
-0.23715412616729736,
0.17746905982494354,
0.1399446725845337,
-0.33673930168151855,
-1.0611019134521484,
0.43201932311058044,
-0.005896033253520727,
0.3074643015861511,
0.04176456853747368,
0.46105778217315674,
0.15358273684978485,
-0.10342139005661011,
0.7296578288078308,
-0.03857553005218506,
-0.763393759727478,
0.44426828622817993,
-0.1342000663280487,
0.05965917930006981,
0.5838598608970642,
0.05711875110864639,
-0.29385027289390564,
-0.5402131080627441,
-0.7695648074150085,
-0.730890154838562,
0.7039985060691833,
0.5242587327957153,
0.25796276330947876,
0.32435867190361023,
0.27265435457229614,
0.18513375520706177,
0.3250318467617035,
-0.9942654967308044,
-0.38409629464149475,
-0.28539958596229553,
-0.39981183409690857,
0.2846544086933136,
-0.4741014540195465,
-0.46669572591781616,
0.14385803043842316,
0.6759681105613708,
0.018465030938386917,
0.19982753694057465,
0.09372353553771973,
0.15694603323936462,
0.29588642716407776,
0.4026518762111664,
0.18045973777770996,
0.23591946065425873,
0.004352455493062735,
0.19823536276817322,
-0.29010578989982605,
-0.7012382745742798,
0.12437836825847626,
0.5267970561981201,
-0.6413813233375549,
-0.04453292489051819,
0.011500468477606773,
0.5827886462211609,
0.08945739269256592,
-0.233562633395195,
0.671299397945404,
-0.3812200725078583,
-0.14194655418395996,
-0.5051621198654175,
-0.020549073815345764,
-0.30595213174819946,
0.2037297636270523,
0.054915040731430054,
0.5161678791046143,
0.26469895243644714,
-0.5297669768333435,
0.046787627041339874,
0.6411154866218567,
-0.5226245522499084,
-0.4464908242225647,
1.1414215564727783,
-0.13407659530639648,
-0.41618743538856506,
0.3027171492576599,
-0.475797563791275,
-0.6547227501869202,
0.5908809304237366,
0.5725479125976562,
1.4079415798187256,
-0.30735349655151367,
0.25229886174201965,
0.030634045600891113,
0.684001088142395,
0.09768735617399216,
0.11283289641141891,
-0.07028645277023315,
-0.4628237783908844,
0.04512786865234375,
-0.30304303765296936,
-0.26918596029281616,
0.2988564372062683,
-0.7696834206581116,
-0.0602634996175766,
-0.7301850318908691,
-0.23558087646961212,
0.04771740734577179,
-0.17200256884098053,
-0.6892542243003845,
0.13834571838378906,
0.019183803349733353,
0.4063628911972046,
-0.5155511498451233,
0.9362618327140808,
0.5881630778312683,
-0.2421778440475464,
-0.24206779897212982,
0.39628931879997253,
0.26169267296791077,
-0.5070234537124634,
0.6553526520729065,
0.06337172538042068,
-0.07897426187992096,
-0.21356059610843658,
-0.2948164939880371,
-0.792332112789154,
0.7791543006896973,
0.49106064438819885,
-0.2947247326374054,
-0.3522346019744873,
0.1360902041196823,
0.41731053590774536,
0.14610698819160461,
-0.5546091794967651,
0.5330966114997864,
0.385345458984375,
-0.47285112738609314,
-0.7242891788482666,
0.30447086691856384,
-0.10554693639278412,
-0.0679231584072113,
0.19159527122974396,
-0.5197892785072327,
1.0171287059783936,
0.057266369462013245,
-0.6231444478034973,
-0.009782826527953148,
0.4122341275215149,
-0.2111661583185196,
0.3128405511379242,
0.6213792562484741,
0.46770718693733215,
0.6566250920295715,
-0.1298733353614807,
1.2082312107086182,
-0.2889609634876251,
0.2763527035713196,
1.306868314743042,
-0.023451633751392365,
0.397373765707016,
0.25901076197624207,
-0.1281862109899521,
0.2487461417913437,
0.16336162388324738,
0.003945525269955397,
0.764167308807373,
0.00261522619985044,
-0.6388199329376221,
0.27906903624534607,
0.10898272693157196,
-0.25555577874183655,
0.5980474352836609,
0.47747546434402466,
-0.3999459445476532,
-0.11861434578895569,
0.31062886118888855,
0.5047881007194519,
0.5644164085388184,
0.043537937104701996,
0.8987194895744324,
0.020725728943943977,
-0.6085626482963562,
0.22781884670257568,
0.2846122980117798,
0.7679537534713745,
-0.6480243802070618,
0.08691403269767761,
0.30782899260520935,
0.5081937909126282,
-0.13316799700260162,
-0.6961739659309387,
0.5598328113555908,
0.06576433032751083,
-0.24423161149024963,
-0.6088629364967346,
0.7688591480255127,
-0.25577598810195923,
-0.32753363251686096,
0.2864014506340027,
-0.11874979734420776,
-0.3266849219799042,
-0.5634673833847046,
-1.08571457862854,
-0.278198778629303,
0.2595847547054291,
-0.3307546377182007,
0.4875555634498596,
0.2617454528808594,
0.04234125092625618,
0.4604552984237671,
0.7068105936050415,
-0.005792850162833929,
0.1140824481844902,
-0.14304892718791962,
0.7415759563446045,
-0.479998379945755,
-0.8431848883628845,
-1.071906328201294,
0.4069023132324219,
-0.36753371357917786,
-0.16273415088653564,
1.0149558782577515,
0.3810913562774658,
0.7967236042022705,
0.08906593173742294,
1.105040431022644,
0.03510761633515358,
0.626801073551178,
-0.7239277958869934,
0.8385739922523499,
-0.11369428038597107,
0.3253493905067444,
0.016753612086176872,
-0.4979877471923828,
-0.41934311389923096,
0.11412657797336578,
-0.44113901257514954,
-0.3238375782966614,
0.804851233959198,
0.5847339034080505,
0.03884356841444969,
0.20957708358764648,
0.23261696100234985,
0.21451687812805176,
0.7759605646133423,
0.4168865382671356,
0.6460444927215576,
-0.6763661503791809,
0.5366012454032898,
-0.8084133267402649,
-0.16217799484729767,
0.03266806900501251,
-0.7328233122825623,
-0.9592861533164978,
-0.6463428139686584,
-0.5844955444335938,
-0.42904216051101685,
0.16823770105838776,
0.3933655321598053,
0.5451091527938843,
-0.6507404446601868,
0.3437346816062927,
-0.05714891850948334,
0.07001429051160812,
-0.4025714099407196,
-0.28127527236938477,
0.6556611061096191,
-0.04269511625170708,
-0.9178653955459595,
0.5054415464401245,
0.32244259119033813,
0.1754717230796814,
-0.5238132476806641,
0.5713887214660645,
-0.14705094695091248,
-0.16691121459007263,
0.2842101752758026,
0.31281399726867676,
-0.7667104005813599,
-0.30020907521247864,
-0.33432233333587646,
-0.015215596184134483,
-0.02058514952659607,
0.8862221240997314,
-0.6855921745300293,
0.7915173172950745,
0.37240514159202576,
0.854066014289856,
0.18786831200122833,
0.14372530579566956,
0.4585123062133789,
-0.9487598538398743,
0.5281364917755127,
0.7014021277427673,
0.28325650095939636,
0.5301313996315002,
-1.0474944114685059,
0.41958096623420715,
0.13872690498828888,
-0.4785497188568115,
-0.9475641846656799,
0.4345347583293915,
-0.664506196975708,
-0.4985083341598511,
0.8983338475227356,
-0.29840508103370667,
-0.2502600848674774,
-0.3193422555923462,
-0.3622778356075287,
0.03242907673120499,
-0.18409112095832825,
1.0086318254470825,
0.44841572642326355,
0.14817771315574646,
0.1644296795129776,
-0.7276313900947571,
0.7978129386901855,
0.1659242808818817,
-0.5830622315406799,
0.23042388260364532,
-0.11077117919921875,
0.15465398132801056,
0.1287832409143448,
0.4832445979118347,
-0.30725038051605225,
0.008513680659234524,
0.12215450406074524,
-0.3943609297275543,
-0.2426033318042755,
-0.19649672508239746,
-0.44473710656166077,
0.41234561800956726,
-0.04878170043230057,
-0.6218798160552979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19598v1 | Mixture of In-Context Experts Enhance LLMs' Long Context Awareness | 2024-06-28T01:46:41 | 2024-06-28T01:46:41 | Hongzhan Lin, Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Chen Zhu, Yang Song, Hengshu Zhu, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many studies have revealed that large language models (LLMs) exhibit uneven
awareness of different contextual positions.Their limited context awareness can
lead to overlooking critical information and subsequent task failures. While
several approaches have been proposed to enhance LLMs' context awareness,
achieving both effectiveness and efficiency remains challenging.In this paper,
for LLMs utilizing RoPE as position embeddings, we introduce a novel method
called ``Mixture of In-Context Experts'' (MoICE) to address this challenge.
MoICE comprises two key components: a router integrated into each attention
head within LLMs and a lightweight router-only training optimization strategy:
(1) MoICE views each RoPE angle as an `in-context' expert, demonstrated to be
capable of directing the attention of a head to specific contextual positions.
Consequently, each attention head flexibly processes tokens using multiple RoPE
angles dynamically selected by the router to attend to the needed positions.
This approach mitigates the risk of overlooking essential contextual
information. (2) The router-only training strategy entails freezing LLM
parameters and exclusively updating routers for only a few steps. When applied
to open-source LLMs including Llama and Mistral, MoICE surpasses prior methods
across multiple tasks on long context understanding and generation, all while
maintaining commendable inference efficiency. | [
-0.5445864796638489,
-0.5253634452819824,
0.48956093192100525,
0.24633188545703888,
-0.3606787621974945,
0.22331681847572327,
-0.3377450406551361,
-0.38865408301353455,
0.29412516951560974,
0.33109042048454285,
-0.31908565759658813,
-0.5045214295387268,
-0.5010356307029724,
-0.05519719794392586,
-0.2519819736480713,
0.8237850069999695,
-0.02536921575665474,
-0.13991379737854004,
-0.2675056457519531,
-0.563411295413971,
-0.6062193512916565,
-0.45839500427246094,
-0.646110475063324,
-0.37642940878868103,
0.5668050646781921,
0.5747211575508118,
0.2955332398414612,
0.41819655895233154,
0.11658529192209244,
0.29704269766807556,
-0.1635507047176361,
0.44814684987068176,
-0.6203833222389221,
0.1314069777727127,
-0.3448008596897125,
-0.17423051595687866,
-0.5614864826202393,
-0.20973694324493408,
0.5695376396179199,
0.750747799873352,
-0.18675316870212555,
-0.15212349593639374,
0.4464331865310669,
0.7766380906105042,
-1.0592312812805176,
-0.40971508622169495,
-0.8368672132492065,
0.06736323237419128,
-0.16530859470367432,
-0.31084343791007996,
-0.330306738615036,
0.194072887301445,
0.38427940011024475,
-0.4955126643180847,
-0.016635876148939133,
0.09111598134040833,
0.1985073983669281,
0.3517180383205414,
-0.7542188763618469,
0.009907352738082409,
-0.5030021667480469,
0.9852054715156555,
-0.5818564295768738,
0.5939024686813354,
0.25872698426246643,
0.20294372737407684,
-0.34541288018226624,
-0.35704055428504944,
-0.42128807306289673,
0.0735744759440422,
0.07516355812549591,
0.2171875238418579,
0.3108111023902893,
0.024775834754109383,
0.05775555595755577,
0.04271814227104187,
-0.20522242784500122,
0.0969608724117279,
-0.006117727607488632,
0.014507727697491646,
0.5061486959457397,
-0.06982016563415527,
0.04997985437512398,
0.18126170337200165,
-0.7098928093910217,
0.29252174496650696,
-0.6477755904197693,
0.17646637558937073,
-0.04339248314499855,
-0.21936242282390594,
-0.2405988723039627,
0.429236501455307,
-0.27776551246643066,
0.8339901566505432,
0.40351012349128723,
-0.49722957611083984,
0.17927098274230957,
0.0915980190038681,
-0.2293388396501541,
0.317283570766449,
0.5425347685813904,
0.2607278823852539,
0.04289345443248749,
-0.17106914520263672,
-0.3625643253326416,
-0.5635623335838318,
0.07687463611364365,
-0.3669932186603546,
-0.17688599228858948,
0.1942453682422638,
-0.07439712435007095,
-0.1680905669927597,
0.031382966786623,
-0.4916904866695404,
-0.57151859998703,
-0.3063545525074005,
0.356685996055603,
-0.4525921642780304,
-0.15698976814746857,
0.17650897800922394,
-0.07012797892093658,
0.24414202570915222,
0.5021184086799622,
-0.7747632265090942,
0.11710244417190552,
0.8239710330963135,
0.715480625629425,
-0.24034297466278076,
-0.23357617855072021,
-0.9198082089424133,
0.7248559594154358,
-0.10111262649297714,
0.6748886108398438,
-0.42842960357666016,
-0.34922894835472107,
-0.06236349791288376,
-0.2571229040622711,
-0.22368837893009186,
-0.3359076976776123,
0.39256009459495544,
-0.6342675685882568,
0.2270047962665558,
-0.06111098825931549,
-0.6376121640205383,
-0.34798291325569153,
0.3561284840106964,
-0.3589943051338196,
1.1908286809921265,
0.24151885509490967,
-1.0688763856887817,
0.3218136727809906,
-0.4017995595932007,
-0.4975210726261139,
0.037278201431035995,
-0.4467795491218567,
0.028003854677081108,
0.22438254952430725,
0.48247721791267395,
0.44982337951660156,
0.07658305019140244,
0.11636407673358917,
-0.07240541279315948,
-0.30220827460289,
0.47018980979919434,
-0.18043290078639984,
0.4349376857280731,
-0.15939272940158844,
-0.43337029218673706,
0.1699577271938324,
-0.5899249911308289,
-0.18773223459720612,
-0.3764636218547821,
-0.4939083158969879,
-0.7069138884544373,
0.16855885088443756,
-0.04916902631521225,
0.24644941091537476,
0.29217472672462463,
-0.3309456408023834,
-0.15991981327533722,
-0.4544818103313446,
0.24161387979984283,
0.8134068846702576,
0.12780898809432983,
0.6245530843734741,
-0.2496938705444336,
0.3562636971473694,
0.18100988864898682,
-0.1962532103061676,
-0.10445377975702286,
-0.3096592128276825,
-1.1003224849700928,
-0.5432531833648682,
0.029029373079538345,
0.553516685962677,
-0.8003308773040771,
0.8374226093292236,
-0.41444239020347595,
-0.19296109676361084,
-0.18009209632873535,
0.5586689114570618,
0.40879619121551514,
0.8889390826225281,
0.24698050320148468,
-0.32644781470298767,
-0.3660370409488678,
-0.767590343952179,
-0.20945227146148682,
0.2319982349872589,
-0.2048019915819168,
0.332006573677063,
0.324076771736145,
-0.15970663726329803,
1.1592828035354614,
-0.3838653862476349,
-0.22369514405727386,
-0.3017077147960663,
-0.22008317708969116,
0.2756820023059845,
0.5952529907226562,
0.33636561036109924,
-0.7200317978858948,
-0.6973947882652283,
0.09890470653772354,
-0.729809045791626,
0.17441821098327637,
-0.16299359500408173,
-0.3426401913166046,
0.21393457055091858,
0.530627429485321,
-0.26137566566467285,
0.045039329677820206,
0.47047996520996094,
0.11016163975000381,
0.1696559488773346,
-0.19234447181224823,
-0.19914770126342773,
-1.158026099205017,
-0.005235317628830671,
0.22209669649600983,
-0.44146329164505005,
-0.6938818693161011,
-0.05760524421930313,
0.25919780135154724,
0.14519192278385162,
-0.6137320399284363,
0.6752541661262512,
-0.6109829545021057,
0.14169949293136597,
-0.16024255752563477,
0.5198541879653931,
-0.024972256273031235,
0.6911544799804688,
0.05183126777410507,
0.7212333083152771,
0.6438605189323425,
-0.6432381868362427,
0.0673108845949173,
0.17599505186080933,
-0.4313468635082245,
0.9437936544418335,
-0.4720621705055237,
0.5053333044052124,
-0.08972813934087753,
0.41181081533432007,
-0.863944947719574,
-0.4540005326271057,
0.2725831866264343,
-0.14859576523303986,
0.4235995411872864,
-0.24331548810005188,
-0.16129693388938904,
-0.11290545016527176,
-0.548072874546051,
0.655092179775238,
0.22183749079704285,
-0.5207570195198059,
0.7104809880256653,
0.514843761920929,
-0.0012270697625353932,
-0.8826413154602051,
-0.7073937654495239,
0.18323183059692383,
-0.5152868628501892,
-0.7206661701202393,
0.4550792872905731,
-0.030481956899166107,
-0.14708590507507324,
-0.31049999594688416,
-0.496181458234787,
-0.046952445060014725,
0.08181456476449966,
-0.05695552006363869,
-0.03419005125761032,
-0.1748158484697342,
0.08561193197965622,
0.11591043323278427,
-0.2693033218383789,
-0.07094267010688782,
-0.5741310119628906,
0.33102697134017944,
0.0362217053771019,
-0.5859739184379578,
-0.5365228056907654,
0.49230310320854187,
0.4406125545501709,
-0.3404574692249298,
0.6604100465774536,
0.5087761282920837,
-0.18164493143558502,
-0.30003803968429565,
-0.9665879011154175,
-0.12923894822597504,
-0.5489904880523682,
0.43690183758735657,
-0.3022557497024536,
-1.0243481397628784,
0.458535760641098,
-0.15852753818035126,
-0.08623705804347992,
-0.06813964992761612,
0.2388252466917038,
-0.2775132358074188,
0.7233982086181641,
0.8018062710762024,
-0.5069356560707092,
0.7156113386154175,
-0.21663108468055725,
0.2371923178434372,
-1.2659205198287964,
-0.32637110352516174,
-0.15306152403354645,
-0.510236918926239,
-0.3202994763851166,
-0.6363623142242432,
1.030940055847168,
0.29188859462738037,
-0.33154234290122986,
-0.018715107813477516,
-0.3259454667568207,
0.6730303764343262,
0.46081680059432983,
0.5279392004013062,
0.1503315567970276,
0.15597909688949585,
-0.1559564173221588,
0.18550099432468414,
-0.9394363164901733,
-0.2719424068927765,
0.8850350379943848,
0.2655623257160187,
0.6818346381187439,
-0.03633624687790871,
0.6942369937896729,
-0.05888771265745163,
0.016486315056681633,
-0.796893298625946,
0.6084537506103516,
0.13915233314037323,
-0.2717114984989166,
-0.1238539069890976,
-0.09657081216573715,
-0.5113294124603271,
0.3791770339012146,
-0.09393569827079773,
-0.8617832660675049,
0.2559000849723816,
0.10524909943342209,
-0.42211148142814636,
0.2984427511692047,
-0.17832976579666138,
0.5547753572463989,
-0.28707176446914673,
-0.5372689366340637,
-0.36472591757774353,
-0.9605774879455566,
0.3051816523075104,
-0.20048189163208008,
0.33856910467147827,
-0.07756166160106659,
-0.4676932990550995,
0.6183871030807495,
-0.211528480052948,
0.8831803798675537,
-0.09277593344449997,
-0.32509854435920715,
0.42216697335243225,
0.11742737889289856,
0.7527356147766113,
0.1608234941959381,
-0.128744974732399,
0.010474445298314095,
-0.7388696074485779,
-0.4106089770793915,
-0.5079729557037354,
0.8207780718803406,
-0.6238773465156555,
-0.692630410194397,
-0.16192153096199036,
-0.6677393317222595,
-0.4404255151748657,
0.058663059026002884,
0.04787309840321541,
0.6325347423553467,
0.0020617262925952673,
0.4892205595970154,
0.9528522491455078,
0.008612213656306267,
0.5528292655944824,
0.2861868441104889,
0.306021511554718,
-0.7091977596282959,
0.5331814885139465,
-0.16360673308372498,
0.23404879868030548,
0.663455069065094,
0.11045251041650772,
-0.055629584938287735,
-0.5034514665603638,
-0.2893591523170471,
0.02963242307305336,
-0.8909006118774414,
-0.16729752719402313,
-0.7945343852043152,
-0.13449148833751678,
0.009489335119724274,
-0.7516476511955261,
-0.2524377107620239,
-0.3649483621120453,
-0.2705848217010498,
0.04776570945978165,
0.29722341895103455,
0.34167057275772095,
0.07574089616537094,
0.6277738213539124,
-0.7649921178817749,
0.0369078665971756,
0.44457149505615234,
0.08379527926445007,
0.10832654684782028,
-0.4036511182785034,
-0.5431297421455383,
0.09763806313276291,
-0.3101060688495636,
-0.6822359561920166,
0.20665891468524933,
0.2544054090976715,
0.8856539726257324,
0.7029421329498291,
-0.07997041940689087,
0.6023082733154297,
-0.3866766095161438,
0.6990495920181274,
0.20849570631980896,
-1.0985406637191772,
0.389469712972641,
-0.577013373374939,
0.20454905927181244,
0.6361519694328308,
0.29345831274986267,
-0.48008254170417786,
-0.4456992447376251,
-0.21362148225307465,
-0.9814241528511047,
0.6022591590881348,
0.04686490073800087,
0.08489295840263367,
0.09291677922010422,
0.24755628407001495,
0.04143380746245384,
0.23356817662715912,
-0.4491192400455475,
0.0201431717723608,
-0.0026386771351099014,
-0.33114808797836304,
-0.034339867532253265,
-0.35970085859298706,
-0.4594029486179352,
-0.3380722105503082,
0.4474368989467621,
-0.31784141063690186,
-0.046598415821790695,
0.28656935691833496,
-0.3824301064014435,
-0.024066779762506485,
0.08645900338888168,
0.7953065037727356,
0.9234248995780945,
-0.122797392308712,
0.3599829375743866,
0.788752555847168,
-0.19306530058383942,
0.15972140431404114,
-0.4161822497844696,
-0.027652211487293243,
-0.15441562235355377,
0.47468531131744385,
0.5808103680610657,
0.8505629897117615,
-0.3905157744884491,
0.4715281128883362,
0.45625945925712585,
0.15975113213062286,
-0.31990182399749756,
0.24426382780075073,
0.15973466634750366,
0.30857908725738525,
0.5547255873680115,
0.20775774121284485,
-0.0068544731475412846,
-0.039271485060453415,
0.17284931242465973,
0.4054478406906128,
-0.3756726086139679,
-0.19766667485237122,
0.4792519509792328,
0.5777403712272644,
-0.20777441561222076,
0.1923619508743286,
0.08439487218856812,
-0.6621842384338379,
0.45209750533103943,
0.44500264525413513,
1.019167423248291,
-0.2894839942455292,
-0.14791351556777954,
0.0033302241936326027,
-0.027987368404865265,
-0.029486119747161865,
0.06914284825325012,
-0.24760150909423828,
-0.8193708062171936,
-0.32259199023246765,
-0.30106300115585327,
-0.3569960296154022,
-0.2227562516927719,
-0.42840149998664856,
0.3068927824497223,
-0.23226849734783173,
-0.02659648470580578,
-0.47047412395477295,
-0.2211182713508606,
-0.5080395340919495,
0.1433008462190628,
0.08408233523368835,
0.8736557364463806,
-0.47373583912849426,
0.9214327335357666,
0.8499752879142761,
0.07327256351709366,
-0.40087220072746277,
0.32756373286247253,
0.05705909803509712,
-0.6551328301429749,
0.48264840245246887,
0.36024945974349976,
-0.6067987084388733,
0.11105825752019882,
-0.4506612718105316,
-0.7463499903678894,
1.221711277961731,
0.1874455213546753,
-0.4497829079627991,
0.18768197298049927,
-0.03539220243692398,
0.19610366225242615,
-0.6672641634941101,
0.19404950737953186,
0.21053560078144073,
0.28287893533706665,
0.16599531471729279,
-0.6757363677024841,
-0.03008221834897995,
0.13359838724136353,
0.19949492812156677,
-0.01854138821363449,
-0.7867209315299988,
0.5569159984588623,
-0.01634606532752514,
0.03086124360561371,
-0.2881360948085785,
0.9568846821784973,
0.5029909014701843,
0.33906301856040955,
0.791264533996582,
0.3256511688232422,
0.779555082321167,
0.5483531355857849,
0.8204425573348999,
-0.643172025680542,
0.0900317057967186,
1.1289960145950317,
-0.24486754834651947,
0.7920079827308655,
0.6805056929588318,
0.2594854235649109,
0.5402388572692871,
0.5621970891952515,
0.5359718203544617,
0.8135219812393188,
-0.06280247122049332,
-0.6407220363616943,
-0.4204331934452057,
-0.12481328845024109,
-0.35290613770484924,
0.33149272203445435,
0.3763228952884674,
-0.14278607070446014,
-0.23421041667461395,
0.11961067467927933,
0.2091522514820099,
-0.012246692553162575,
-0.31837528944015503,
0.7192112803459167,
0.2954614460468292,
-0.46805429458618164,
0.6123502254486084,
0.04646611586213112,
0.889974057674408,
-0.4936179220676422,
0.32412320375442505,
-0.30861708521842957,
0.2838873565196991,
-0.19302789866924286,
-0.7335979342460632,
-0.05108551308512688,
-0.12840667366981506,
0.06289042532444,
-0.1294129341840744,
0.7428039312362671,
-0.6037259697914124,
-0.46409890055656433,
0.23825591802597046,
0.5224557518959045,
-0.08662149310112,
-0.2822822630405426,
-0.30560302734375,
-0.13701984286308289,
-0.07898202538490295,
-0.3388078510761261,
0.38200369477272034,
0.7090327739715576,
-0.06014779210090637,
0.759175181388855,
0.3318531811237335,
-0.27949056029319763,
-0.09081728756427765,
-0.16946977376937866,
1.2233729362487793,
-0.46815910935401917,
-0.47995051741600037,
-0.8890357613563538,
0.7479920387268066,
-0.1958393007516861,
-0.3434150815010071,
0.6791011095046997,
0.5106280446052551,
0.90253084897995,
-0.01771400310099125,
0.6246081590652466,
0.29907941818237305,
0.06366907805204391,
-0.5756803750991821,
0.7273085713386536,
-0.6701353192329407,
0.18262138962745667,
-0.24075959622859955,
-1.0063077211380005,
-0.14883051812648773,
0.6116806268692017,
-0.2580243945121765,
0.09198765456676483,
0.695453941822052,
0.6950666308403015,
-0.47894203662872314,
-0.18108005821704865,
0.23785032331943512,
-0.015833552926778793,
0.22847871482372284,
0.8123772740364075,
0.7859783172607422,
-0.004478743765503168,
0.16802971065044403,
-0.3945609927177429,
-0.3257569372653961,
-0.46799007058143616,
-1.1278512477874756,
-1.0693609714508057,
-0.281486839056015,
-0.3017016649246216,
0.09542307257652283,
0.03671739250421524,
1.1323368549346924,
0.8762994408607483,
-0.6423841118812561,
-0.38253477215766907,
0.06201932206749916,
0.17467305064201355,
-0.18604819476604462,
-0.11854453384876251,
0.34974390268325806,
-0.42969027161598206,
-0.49432373046875,
0.8553473949432373,
0.4828312397003174,
-0.22598159313201904,
-0.24722713232040405,
-0.1407419741153717,
-0.30021238327026367,
0.039622776210308075,
0.6512143015861511,
-0.14558105170726776,
-0.7095208764076233,
-0.4925585389137268,
-0.16194333136081696,
-0.16490258276462555,
0.28852489590644836,
0.7450539469718933,
-0.7561334371566772,
0.38980749249458313,
0.7100628018379211,
0.5862604379653931,
0.3792214095592499,
0.26641204953193665,
0.7123886346817017,
-1.0723634958267212,
0.49564993381500244,
0.15627619624137878,
0.4137561321258545,
0.4613979458808899,
-0.4270598590373993,
0.5791251063346863,
0.14469513297080994,
-0.47220665216445923,
-0.5055550932884216,
0.12235241383314133,
-1.2143523693084717,
-0.06333494186401367,
1.146538496017456,
-0.20073221623897552,
-0.15942735970020294,
-0.17556770145893097,
-0.35901519656181335,
0.15264680981636047,
-0.46770960092544556,
0.6834306120872498,
0.43042415380477905,
-0.02181498520076275,
-0.021175555884838104,
-0.6937466263771057,
0.2656954824924469,
0.5638617277145386,
-0.565658450126648,
-0.24817170202732086,
0.30211159586906433,
0.39006316661834717,
-0.0743860974907875,
0.5558108687400818,
0.3898206949234009,
-0.17752662301063538,
-0.4784477949142456,
-0.06261557340621948,
-0.1270206719636917,
-0.48753413558006287,
-0.2164277732372284,
0.1313958615064621,
-0.1132904589176178,
-0.3009899854660034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19593v1 | SK-VQA: Synthetic Knowledge Generation at Scale for Training Context-Augmented Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-28T01:14:43 | 2024-06-28T01:14:43 | Xin Su, Man Luo, Kris W Pan, Tien Pei Chou, Vasudev Lal, Phillip Howard | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Synthetic data generation has gained significant attention recently for its
utility in training large vision and language models. However, the application
of synthetic data to the training of multimodal context-augmented generation
systems has been relatively unexplored. This gap in existing work is important
because existing vision and language models (VLMs) are not trained specifically
for context-augmented generation. Resources for adapting such models are
therefore crucial for enabling their use in retrieval-augmented generation
(RAG) settings, where a retriever is used to gather relevant information that
is then subsequently provided to a generative model via context augmentation.
To address this challenging problem, we generate SK-VQA: a large synthetic
multimodal dataset containing over 2 million question-answer pairs which
require external knowledge to determine the final answer. Our dataset is both
larger and significantly more diverse than existing resources of its kind,
possessing over 11x more unique questions and containing images from a greater
variety of sources than previously-proposed datasets. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that our synthetic dataset can not only serve as a
challenging benchmark, but is also highly effective for adapting existing
generative multimodal models for context-augmented generation. | [
-0.5877444744110107,
-0.4449467957019806,
0.6220257878303528,
0.0021847039461135864,
-0.1924983114004135,
0.21104978024959564,
-0.10757001489400864,
-0.4022344648838043,
0.12609300017356873,
0.5991279482841492,
-0.7686535120010376,
-0.012719646096229553,
-0.17001496255397797,
0.2172078788280487,
-0.3044763207435608,
0.7370516061782837,
0.0914958044886589,
0.3554246723651886,
-0.6745981574058533,
-0.3797590732574463,
-0.39068347215652466,
-0.6748270392417908,
-0.22330394387245178,
0.04087261110544205,
0.5338156819343567,
0.2596176564693451,
0.20491033792495728,
0.28222164511680603,
0.2188841998577118,
0.3194600045681,
0.14357127249240875,
0.7457098960876465,
-0.5259830355644226,
0.41801518201828003,
-0.305874764919281,
-0.4615398645401001,
-0.11971942335367203,
-0.15883660316467285,
0.7381970882415771,
0.4827079474925995,
0.1401323676109314,
0.4716494381427765,
-0.3176312744617462,
0.603034257888794,
-0.7576462030410767,
-0.06489226967096329,
-1.1190903186798096,
0.00014389502757694572,
0.033546749502420425,
-0.2461995631456375,
-0.32898297905921936,
-0.1988297551870346,
0.15436720848083496,
-0.8553690910339355,
0.4209280014038086,
0.07670890539884567,
0.66424161195755,
0.3118671178817749,
-0.9628767371177673,
-0.18831676244735718,
-0.7463126182556152,
0.7128582000732422,
-0.3145093321800232,
0.5172123312950134,
0.02089717984199524,
0.6866008639335632,
-0.24163818359375,
-1.0014547109603882,
-1.0437960624694824,
-0.2074548900127411,
0.09819523245096207,
0.2908151149749756,
0.2013380080461502,
-0.028510097414255142,
0.4798707962036133,
0.3039322793483734,
-0.39964741468429565,
-0.4544796049594879,
-0.7339613437652588,
-0.2978971600532532,
0.6359390020370483,
0.35020866990089417,
0.06801334768533707,
-0.4930292069911957,
-0.6215481758117676,
-0.4106237590312958,
-0.767247200012207,
0.062251996248960495,
0.1312524825334549,
0.19580954313278198,
0.13941065967082977,
1.0679032802581787,
-0.5619648694992065,
0.8215911388397217,
0.06625533103942871,
-0.2074439525604248,
0.3662186861038208,
-0.8234384059906006,
-0.023126155138015747,
-0.23800207674503326,
0.4721231162548065,
0.5551595091819763,
-0.007644773460924625,
0.060305166989564896,
-0.08478821069002151,
0.14523854851722717,
0.6634926795959473,
-0.7087222933769226,
-0.21467919647693634,
-0.07209493964910507,
0.16363130509853363,
-0.24551090598106384,
-0.12343673408031464,
-0.6669871807098389,
-0.4258420765399933,
-0.7185941934585571,
0.7268303036689758,
-0.2819584906101227,
-0.18871858716011047,
-0.2120661735534668,
-0.36194631457328796,
0.5075982213020325,
0.4359360337257385,
-0.5753203630447388,
-0.1608312726020813,
0.17489783465862274,
0.5363480448722839,
-0.23763957619667053,
-0.038445014506578445,
-0.34447747468948364,
0.2927863597869873,
-0.570869505405426,
0.7425090670585632,
-0.28132566809654236,
-0.35161951184272766,
-0.08095361292362213,
0.1375621259212494,
0.11113063246011734,
-0.6295081973075867,
0.26575201749801636,
-0.556833028793335,
0.15336459875106812,
-0.4959772527217865,
-0.20698390901088715,
-0.04538867622613907,
0.6113353967666626,
-0.7082723379135132,
1.2257403135299683,
0.5520159006118774,
-0.6134263277053833,
0.7285540103912354,
-0.3443903625011444,
-0.12782810628414154,
0.26459836959838867,
-0.48921239376068115,
-0.1460421085357666,
0.35628795623779297,
0.3656767010688782,
0.2633182108402252,
-0.4134349822998047,
0.1684037446975708,
-0.2021135836839676,
0.03568538278341293,
0.32242223620414734,
-0.31021246314048767,
0.34456461668014526,
0.08857527375221252,
-0.07086040824651718,
0.10522383451461792,
-1.1284748315811157,
0.5137841105461121,
0.09712956100702286,
-0.5738747715950012,
-0.4720941483974457,
-0.2998969256877899,
0.07378116250038147,
0.5446099042892456,
0.22061146795749664,
-0.6160339117050171,
0.26610952615737915,
-0.3555474877357483,
0.2021106481552124,
0.7959054708480835,
0.13733021914958954,
0.5063616633415222,
-0.39178267121315,
0.5224438309669495,
0.1250554919242859,
-0.01636088453233242,
-0.17029260098934174,
-0.3084169328212738,
-0.7727974057197571,
-0.2750093638896942,
0.17187325656414032,
0.25561952590942383,
-1.5521200895309448,
-0.21254193782806396,
-0.42144376039505005,
-0.5243123173713684,
-0.4922855496406555,
0.19126038253307343,
0.30124661326408386,
0.6571404337882996,
0.3409540355205536,
-0.1691380739212036,
-0.8761350512504578,
-1.0151463747024536,
-0.04020971059799194,
-0.045080043375492096,
-0.22490184009075165,
0.711650550365448,
0.49300023913383484,
-0.3673619031906128,
1.2568341493606567,
-0.39317992329597473,
0.044589683413505554,
-0.20228080451488495,
-0.07887448370456696,
-0.1953086405992508,
0.364411860704422,
0.5911921858787537,
-1.1846485137939453,
-0.434248149394989,
-0.07945358008146286,
-0.7488746643066406,
0.03550616651773453,
-0.259614497423172,
-0.252438485622406,
0.20982331037521362,
0.3914528787136078,
-0.5469757914543152,
0.15271726250648499,
0.7127655744552612,
-0.06824032962322235,
0.8502310514450073,
-0.35848167538642883,
0.23725993931293488,
-1.510399341583252,
-0.007194777950644493,
-0.1835504025220871,
-0.1817968636751175,
-0.6484139561653137,
0.15822045505046844,
0.23245124518871307,
-0.10678509622812271,
-0.6361092329025269,
0.8227202892303467,
-0.3581492602825165,
-0.16418509185314178,
-0.17432145774364471,
0.0481533482670784,
0.1507522165775299,
0.5006098747253418,
0.16510161757469177,
1.002616047859192,
0.3769141435623169,
-0.6795782446861267,
0.6444084048271179,
0.365526020526886,
-0.4274463355541229,
0.7553682923316956,
-0.47315171360969543,
0.1827704757452011,
-0.12569499015808105,
0.37208232283592224,
-1.027406096458435,
-0.8369410634040833,
0.02809995226562023,
-0.4292719066143036,
-0.019495146349072456,
-0.11460307240486145,
-0.3682582974433899,
-0.36134016513824463,
-0.1870240420103073,
0.8482643365859985,
0.4909837245941162,
-0.9727155566215515,
0.886371374130249,
0.3768112361431122,
-0.0395519994199276,
-0.5409471392631531,
-0.45176252722740173,
-0.04326159879565239,
-0.15180034935474396,
-0.7144842147827148,
0.336359441280365,
-0.23111294209957123,
-0.1727769672870636,
-0.2037668228149414,
-0.3102472722530365,
-0.0679117813706398,
-0.2914672791957855,
0.28853172063827515,
0.24932414293289185,
-0.19349335134029388,
0.2027425765991211,
0.2539948523044586,
0.17428413033485413,
0.1265794187784195,
-0.04436660557985306,
0.5114471912384033,
0.12656065821647644,
-0.29966500401496887,
0.09315302222967148,
0.3075679838657379,
0.7996495366096497,
-0.1017465740442276,
0.8130724430084229,
0.6839425563812256,
-0.28669413924217224,
-0.5248098373413086,
-0.5413057208061218,
-0.16145658493041992,
-0.5150212049484253,
0.3833748996257782,
-0.5422639846801758,
-0.8925666809082031,
0.345969021320343,
-0.4489448368549347,
-0.06057746335864067,
0.3468168079853058,
0.7932168245315552,
-0.2131258100271225,
1.1873961687088013,
0.4699670374393463,
0.46633660793304443,
0.2764078378677368,
-0.3629574179649353,
-0.09401238709688187,
-1.0780258178710938,
-0.5296645760536194,
-0.07577573508024216,
-0.16849537193775177,
-0.675381064414978,
-0.7683486342430115,
0.7946366667747498,
0.00437470618635416,
-0.10089241713285446,
0.22780369222164154,
-0.35483238101005554,
0.33788567781448364,
0.7530583739280701,
0.31340041756629944,
0.05366922914981842,
0.12511689960956573,
-0.2660413384437561,
-0.029125791043043137,
-0.8290101289749146,
-0.17232100665569305,
1.397668480873108,
-0.2841479182243347,
0.5412923097610474,
0.001962970942258835,
0.3981252908706665,
0.1411886364221573,
0.19339117407798767,
-0.6238731145858765,
0.6507320404052734,
0.11515934765338898,
-0.8192631006240845,
-0.20509111881256104,
-0.5552408695220947,
-0.5776923894882202,
0.42204979062080383,
-0.6611633896827698,
-0.22319327294826508,
0.17471528053283691,
0.3482714593410492,
-0.22677825391292572,
0.044993918389081955,
-0.6751601099967957,
0.5190354585647583,
-0.22634394466876984,
-0.33668193221092224,
0.010814170353114605,
-0.5897941589355469,
0.6335546970367432,
-0.44938820600509644,
0.09486322849988937,
0.18266309797763824,
0.020509418100118637,
0.38578227162361145,
-0.37298744916915894,
0.5808699727058411,
-0.16101773083209991,
-0.1577896922826767,
0.4136334955692291,
-0.07883955538272858,
0.4369388520717621,
0.30361321568489075,
0.27808430790901184,
-0.1710166186094284,
0.08247106522321701,
-0.3228951394557953,
-0.6268697381019592,
0.6715225577354431,
-0.6843620538711548,
-0.4943092167377472,
-0.32637715339660645,
-0.9284743666648865,
-0.5472189784049988,
0.00995471328496933,
0.38123688101768494,
0.5664262771606445,
0.023838602006435394,
0.5447177290916443,
0.5862330794334412,
-0.4721510708332062,
-0.11398465186357498,
0.18234485387802124,
-0.2033429592847824,
-0.6764153242111206,
1.057641625404358,
0.09181611984968185,
0.6127684712409973,
-0.04051628336310387,
-0.06909190863370895,
-0.4482996463775635,
-0.3168807327747345,
-0.7121764421463013,
0.0041085402481257915,
-0.761741042137146,
-0.2577495574951172,
-0.5982221961021423,
-0.45949041843414307,
-0.3356444239616394,
-0.1736615151166916,
-0.26090770959854126,
-0.6344292163848877,
0.015012596733868122,
-0.07624734193086624,
0.44601988792419434,
0.5782608985900879,
-0.1381426453590393,
0.173851877450943,
-0.6471737623214722,
0.873490035533905,
0.7506284117698669,
0.048569172620773315,
-0.3190464973449707,
-0.42196425795555115,
-0.17203225195407867,
0.3931494653224945,
-0.21603678166866302,
-0.6051717400550842,
0.4016511142253876,
0.3502054214477539,
0.5016980767250061,
-0.15513838827610016,
0.27618756890296936,
0.8224141001701355,
-0.5905216336250305,
1.0097458362579346,
0.14426039159297943,
-0.41954609751701355,
0.44546735286712646,
-0.3659447431564331,
0.42464911937713623,
0.4486415982246399,
0.36139920353889465,
-0.24750320613384247,
-0.17970159649848938,
-0.4391383230686188,
-1.049838900566101,
0.6195731163024902,
0.17914462089538574,
0.3654015362262726,
0.021690653637051582,
0.485806405544281,
0.20691049098968506,
0.3687822222709656,
-0.6988126635551453,
-0.02000107616186142,
-0.38641852140426636,
-0.22920531034469604,
0.014645419083535671,
-0.2785172462463379,
-0.3383571207523346,
-0.356452614068985,
0.5603724122047424,
-0.39212989807128906,
0.09593667834997177,
0.17989014089107513,
-0.21768556535243988,
0.04900037497282028,
0.024180592969059944,
0.6527773141860962,
0.6513199210166931,
0.10068173706531525,
0.03747227415442467,
0.5350594520568848,
-0.5467275381088257,
0.18962225317955017,
-0.19988766312599182,
-0.2206353098154068,
-0.02546030469238758,
0.07748096436262131,
0.7623674869537354,
0.022968783974647522,
-1.081146478652954,
0.3303045332431793,
-0.07907392829656601,
-0.47082698345184326,
-0.6178210973739624,
0.3213013708591461,
-0.05924182012677193,
0.5615237951278687,
0.5738191604614258,
0.068723663687706,
-0.10241125524044037,
-0.5105862021446228,
0.29570627212524414,
0.5488114953041077,
-0.013485698960721493,
-0.20495565235614777,
0.577402651309967,
0.04033386707305908,
0.012358634732663631,
0.640028715133667,
-0.08299227803945541,
-0.48980775475502014,
0.5295442342758179,
0.4766063988208771,
0.39400285482406616,
-0.05714574083685875,
0.29248616099357605,
0.6363077759742737,
0.04506660997867584,
0.06253287196159363,
0.5283043384552002,
-0.25238534808158875,
-0.7188163995742798,
-0.4080173373222351,
-0.8238673210144043,
-0.3250553011894226,
0.358936071395874,
-0.703251302242279,
0.08740033954381943,
-0.3792373239994049,
-0.16997797787189484,
-0.18813075125217438,
-0.2923550307750702,
-0.8557295799255371,
0.5295884609222412,
0.056759659200906754,
0.6600886583328247,
-0.6676120162010193,
0.6985070705413818,
0.698505163192749,
-0.20375175774097443,
-0.6841323971748352,
-0.17068266868591309,
-0.1515209823846817,
-0.7342179417610168,
0.8406671285629272,
0.010078839026391506,
-0.02794795297086239,
0.015985609963536263,
-0.7399502992630005,
-0.9068623781204224,
1.2871272563934326,
0.42818960547447205,
-0.4513989984989166,
-0.20575660467147827,
0.4683040380477905,
0.6134838461875916,
-0.42648622393608093,
-0.17054519057273865,
0.2650633752346039,
0.28298866748809814,
0.5370082259178162,
-0.7425661087036133,
-0.14895473420619965,
-0.3207685947418213,
0.21121855080127716,
0.10507551580667496,
-0.3800048828125,
0.8487507700920105,
-0.20556382834911346,
-0.16533832252025604,
0.28976452350616455,
0.45921286940574646,
0.7297127842903137,
0.23826734721660614,
0.5043638348579407,
0.5045027732849121,
0.30418479442596436,
-0.1536889672279358,
0.9464717507362366,
-0.18535009026527405,
-0.010815586894750595,
1.1459732055664062,
-0.23806488513946533,
0.7689275145530701,
0.7552481889724731,
0.14599613845348358,
0.24669182300567627,
0.4259307384490967,
0.0012326168362051249,
0.6625156402587891,
0.2507348954677582,
-0.5907146334648132,
-0.5803906321525574,
-0.19170504808425903,
-0.42165958881378174,
0.6001636981964111,
0.41030311584472656,
-0.33219271898269653,
-0.12221091240644455,
0.40610915422439575,
-0.6583524942398071,
0.003215573262423277,
-0.35651159286499023,
0.895747184753418,
-0.1300114393234253,
-0.6018120050430298,
0.6340733170509338,
-0.2851678133010864,
0.43742457032203674,
-0.6217512488365173,
-0.28868305683135986,
-0.06735766679048538,
0.09404332935810089,
0.05944931134581566,
-0.66280198097229,
0.07805951684713364,
-0.006622538436204195,
-0.29872435331344604,
-0.0924023687839508,
0.7013200521469116,
-0.5535391569137573,
-0.6996992826461792,
-0.09119107574224472,
0.6176884770393372,
-0.19027920067310333,
0.006233150605112314,
-0.3968615233898163,
-0.16261768341064453,
-0.03616229072213173,
-0.28567811846733093,
0.538135826587677,
0.5475043654441833,
-0.1535828411579132,
0.6806135177612305,
0.9606035351753235,
0.012075124308466911,
0.5590108633041382,
-0.1639334112405777,
1.2167823314666748,
-0.46988463401794434,
-0.21267551183700562,
-0.24406585097312927,
0.8267302513122559,
-0.14488378167152405,
-0.319047749042511,
0.7981165647506714,
0.5003867745399475,
1.2227990627288818,
-0.354576051235199,
0.9555352330207825,
-0.25344452261924744,
0.4360993802547455,
-0.562312662601471,
0.5333687663078308,
-0.9125819206237793,
-0.13060078024864197,
-0.08088432252407074,
-1.0094276666641235,
0.11227204650640488,
0.4471711814403534,
0.012781060300767422,
0.010437806136906147,
0.28366634249687195,
0.8921614289283752,
-0.16744883358478546,
-0.28113070130348206,
0.34508538246154785,
0.1181592270731926,
0.2538706958293915,
0.3482291102409363,
1.044921875,
-0.4435218870639801,
0.6614992618560791,
-0.2693723738193512,
0.10662585496902466,
-0.02047857828438282,
-0.7348619699478149,
-0.8423886299133301,
-1.1426252126693726,
0.02142910473048687,
-0.29787394404411316,
-0.10022348910570145,
0.8123269081115723,
0.7395209074020386,
-0.5615682601928711,
0.206528440117836,
-0.04348815232515335,
-0.4343797564506531,
0.09391023218631744,
-0.1874351054430008,
0.025836147367954254,
-0.2511005401611328,
-0.6304090023040771,
0.65608149766922,
-0.06908104568719864,
0.16160547733306885,
-0.4635668694972992,
-0.15328346192836761,
-0.09517381340265274,
0.29930299520492554,
0.9685031175613403,
0.22985881567001343,
-0.6730415225028992,
-0.46123144030570984,
0.2572093904018402,
0.010940730571746826,
-0.05540623888373375,
0.7087691426277161,
-1.2014175653457642,
0.9366422891616821,
0.4715820550918579,
0.7773552536964417,
0.659603476524353,
0.19308339059352875,
0.7546080350875854,
-1.1409646272659302,
0.11186876147985458,
0.20362642407417297,
0.17714449763298035,
0.25704291462898254,
-0.09273094683885574,
0.38538694381713867,
0.21261616051197052,
-0.3722243905067444,
-1.1083582639694214,
0.4268331825733185,
-1.135122537612915,
-0.13000790774822235,
1.2660468816757202,
0.19373638927936554,
-0.24638105928897858,
0.01812933385372162,
-0.5619511604309082,
0.13542449474334717,
0.06263907998800278,
0.8040724396705627,
0.5326632857322693,
0.007284898776561022,
-0.16692255437374115,
-0.5993539094924927,
0.6229385733604431,
0.08218929171562195,
-0.8556064367294312,
-0.11528680473566055,
0.9235406517982483,
0.2933447062969208,
0.2905050218105316,
0.2978787422180176,
0.020080136135220528,
0.4992714822292328,
0.1569398194551468,
-0.019310656934976578,
-0.19024744629859924,
-0.5655057430267334,
-0.013710365630686283,
0.314769446849823,
-0.2671106159687042,
-0.020319264382123947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19578v1 | PathAlign: A vision-language model for whole slide images in histopathology | 2024-06-27T23:43:36 | 2024-06-27T23:43:36 | Faruk Ahmed, Andrew Sellergren, Lin Yang, Shawn Xu, Boris Babenko, Abbi Ward, Niels Olson, Arash Mohtashamian, Yossi Matias, Greg S. Corrado, Quang Duong, Dale R. Webster, Shravya Shetty, Daniel Golden, Yun Liu, David F. Steiner, Ellery Wulczyn | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Microscopic interpretation of histopathology images underlies many important
diagnostic and treatment decisions. While advances in vision-language modeling
raise new opportunities for analysis of such images, the gigapixel-scale size
of whole slide images (WSIs) introduces unique challenges. Additionally,
pathology reports simultaneously highlight key findings from small regions
while also aggregating interpretation across multiple slides, often making it
difficult to create robust image-text pairs. As such, pathology reports remain
a largely untapped source of supervision in computational pathology, with most
efforts relying on region-of-interest annotations or self-supervision at the
patch-level. In this work, we develop a vision-language model based on the
BLIP-2 framework using WSIs paired with curated text from pathology reports.
This enables applications utilizing a shared image-text embedding space, such
as text or image retrieval for finding cases of interest, as well as
integration of the WSI encoder with a frozen large language model (LLM) for
WSI-based generative text capabilities such as report generation or
AI-in-the-loop interactions. We utilize a de-identified dataset of over 350,000
WSIs and diagnostic text pairs, spanning a wide range of diagnoses, procedure
types, and tissue types. We present pathologist evaluation of text generation
and text retrieval using WSI embeddings, as well as results for WSI
classification and workflow prioritization (slide-level triaging).
Model-generated text for WSIs was rated by pathologists as accurate, without
clinically significant error or omission, for 78% of WSIs on average. This work
demonstrates exciting potential capabilities for language-aligned WSI
embeddings. | [
0.06360971182584763,
-0.2519110143184662,
0.8191941976547241,
0.1255323886871338,
-0.6018441915512085,
-0.07356292009353638,
-0.08867306262254715,
-0.4345680773258209,
0.5155948996543884,
0.6026812791824341,
-0.2302844226360321,
-0.5911415815353394,
-0.7305088639259338,
0.11286171525716782,
-0.28833165764808655,
0.9983677864074707,
0.051742859184741974,
0.32441550493240356,
-0.3136918842792511,
-0.25033333897590637,
-0.2097506821155548,
0.12025690823793411,
-0.4790908992290497,
-0.0376400426030159,
0.4389810860157013,
0.3196350932121277,
1.0092284679412842,
1.0378587245941162,
0.961094081401825,
0.23531685769557953,
-0.23158706724643707,
-0.10893458873033524,
-0.0890248715877533,
0.25864386558532715,
-0.2957373559474945,
-0.26566484570503235,
-0.3378508687019348,
-0.020772363990545273,
0.525764524936676,
0.914694607257843,
-0.43997785449028015,
-0.06638146191835403,
-0.27169862389564514,
0.3631367087364197,
-0.5994660258293152,
0.07023584097623825,
-0.23274551331996918,
0.3036680519580841,
-0.3385710120201111,
-0.13704441487789154,
-0.41977423429489136,
-0.1343131810426712,
0.22223560512065887,
-0.7326638102531433,
-0.07606877386569977,
-0.06900901347398758,
0.8641310930252075,
0.31773683428764343,
-0.42591360211372375,
-0.2901647388935089,
-0.4251006543636322,
0.48864609003067017,
-0.8092800974845886,
0.4511528015136719,
0.23817488551139832,
0.5764709115028381,
0.10652521997690201,
-0.8955883383750916,
-0.17372249066829681,
-0.151429682970047,
-0.19447776675224304,
0.3980061411857605,
-0.15393464267253876,
0.10794227570295334,
0.17208558320999146,
0.4560001492500305,
-0.7167463302612305,
0.33625784516334534,
-0.5180661082267761,
-0.5640301704406738,
0.43584316968917847,
0.4324447810649872,
0.38810282945632935,
-0.25039640069007874,
-0.5180739164352417,
0.04972934350371361,
-0.7351195216178894,
-0.5096032619476318,
-0.32453539967536926,
0.1780049353837967,
-0.14881977438926697,
0.5609967708587646,
0.0004749475629068911,
0.8616688251495361,
-0.06982986629009247,
-0.5862723588943481,
0.21711163222789764,
-0.20978637039661407,
-0.27999815344810486,
0.05195755138993263,
0.963003933429718,
0.41034385561943054,
-0.017979256808757782,
-0.2892242968082428,
0.1184948980808258,
0.017118770629167557,
0.353472501039505,
-0.8688725233078003,
-0.07407539337873459,
0.26606911420822144,
-0.6262123584747314,
-0.5813535451889038,
-0.3296014070510864,
-1.0312721729278564,
-0.6876700520515442,
-0.03342090919613838,
0.3730963170528412,
-0.472644567489624,
-0.09280901402235031,
0.06771598756313324,
-0.20248077809810638,
-0.2622351050376892,
0.4678994119167328,
-0.5158212780952454,
0.1045394167304039,
0.18298698961734772,
1.0543668270111084,
-0.01359882764518261,
-0.2884276807308197,
-0.8688721060752869,
0.6083925366401672,
-0.6802038550376892,
0.6759567856788635,
-0.8376509547233582,
-0.31577667593955994,
0.1673402041196823,
-0.004843194503337145,
0.0330452062189579,
-0.22270363569259644,
0.2645733058452606,
-0.1751135140657425,
0.2680487632751465,
0.022215016186237335,
-0.5577473044395447,
0.14112496376037598,
0.03392234072089195,
-0.5437397956848145,
0.6641131043434143,
0.17337040603160858,
-0.8676852583885193,
0.36711108684539795,
-0.47886115312576294,
-0.33152925968170166,
0.3980322778224945,
-0.43667659163475037,
-0.30192238092422485,
0.016997171565890312,
-0.05497052147984505,
0.37223130464553833,
-0.31110018491744995,
0.4984132945537567,
-0.0790029913187027,
-0.2687682807445526,
-0.058021657168865204,
-0.08938300609588623,
0.5984710454940796,
-0.04451422020792961,
-0.4339979588985443,
0.1172851100564003,
-0.36144742369651794,
-0.340070515871048,
0.0939076840877533,
0.03749126195907593,
-0.3188740611076355,
0.019366763532161713,
-0.13907021284103394,
0.3449386954307556,
0.34621545672416687,
-0.8001793622970581,
0.2953076958656311,
-0.6536977887153625,
0.16457943618297577,
0.4216948449611664,
0.04109325259923935,
0.31882819533348083,
-0.03220529854297638,
0.4838121235370636,
0.571542501449585,
0.3443875312805176,
-0.38667306303977966,
-0.8872138261795044,
-0.4159707725048065,
-0.17275439202785492,
0.20404355227947235,
0.5949850678443909,
-0.8107439279556274,
0.03413531556725502,
-0.34973686933517456,
-0.5780584216117859,
-0.355875164270401,
-0.056275784969329834,
0.6806936264038086,
0.6285271048545837,
0.34602469205856323,
-0.48140960931777954,
-0.22384783625602722,
-1.1806646585464478,
0.35304856300354004,
0.05241841450333595,
-0.12437630444765091,
0.34851911664009094,
0.29351019859313965,
-0.3457357883453369,
0.5413303971290588,
-0.9322783946990967,
-0.6178015470504761,
-0.09213453531265259,
0.06725016236305237,
0.09285453706979752,
0.2689284384250641,
0.41232970356941223,
-0.6917917728424072,
-0.5216188430786133,
0.1428922563791275,
-0.7475242018699646,
-0.0432610809803009,
0.055563002824783325,
-0.3182261884212494,
0.26347997784614563,
0.6981410384178162,
-0.65036940574646,
0.9077409505844116,
0.7051435708999634,
-0.496730238199234,
0.5400615334510803,
-0.4505859613418579,
0.1500343680381775,
-1.2725781202316284,
0.17097051441669464,
0.3783935308456421,
-0.37617290019989014,
-0.5695117115974426,
0.09089913964271545,
0.0568428710103035,
-0.2608504593372345,
-0.20115958154201508,
0.36282625794410706,
-0.3702095150947571,
-0.3631914556026459,
0.03413137421011925,
0.4339648187160492,
0.03297288715839386,
0.24069802463054657,
0.30596932768821716,
0.8140153288841248,
0.9338892102241516,
-0.38169780373573303,
0.08628480136394501,
0.5507876873016357,
-0.05487645044922829,
0.32641249895095825,
-0.4255897104740143,
-0.08474583923816681,
0.012755941599607468,
0.350847452878952,
-0.855293869972229,
-0.29374098777770996,
0.17183728516101837,
-0.23826149106025696,
0.5494301319122314,
-0.4022676944732666,
-0.45864251255989075,
-0.41139838099479675,
-0.31939730048179626,
0.17472855746746063,
0.4321349263191223,
-0.3742349445819855,
0.3789714276790619,
0.4550566077232361,
-0.29953259229660034,
-0.4400196373462677,
-0.7375232577323914,
0.4810466766357422,
0.018013594672083855,
-0.5530226826667786,
0.7307530045509338,
-0.13245324790477753,
-0.13621385395526886,
-0.13867802917957306,
0.013640148565173149,
-0.38035446405410767,
-0.4262149930000305,
0.3008630573749542,
0.2713194787502289,
-0.3432580530643463,
0.13694342970848083,
0.21744020283222198,
-0.09442844986915588,
-0.35431066155433655,
-0.21711093187332153,
0.3975387215614319,
0.06935145705938339,
-0.3530143201351166,
-0.37321266531944275,
0.3136945962905884,
0.8636911511421204,
-0.24913421273231506,
0.5046231150627136,
0.5701416730880737,
-0.532521665096283,
0.31354087591171265,
-0.29139551520347595,
-0.09023260325193405,
-0.43012312054634094,
0.17327921092510223,
-0.26200541853904724,
-0.6180058121681213,
0.2898881137371063,
-0.04295920953154564,
0.1465754508972168,
0.3056128919124603,
0.5300607681274414,
-0.23021432757377625,
1.0955532789230347,
0.7676010131835938,
-0.01988409087061882,
0.13838133215904236,
0.006410714238882065,
0.19587664306163788,
-0.964246392250061,
-0.16895906627178192,
-0.3293806314468384,
0.04307517036795616,
-0.5256953835487366,
-0.5981823801994324,
0.5260938405990601,
-0.24829186499118805,
0.03787548840045929,
0.1702830195426941,
-0.7260542511940002,
0.269340455532074,
0.2254738062620163,
0.3430293798446655,
0.08151215314865112,
0.036698874086141586,
-0.1468101590871811,
-0.4183148741722107,
-0.6533912420272827,
-0.6432759761810303,
1.0258657932281494,
0.2691933512687683,
0.37471893429756165,
0.4119543433189392,
0.672496497631073,
0.09749309718608856,
0.11844901740550995,
-0.7039435505867004,
0.46143707633018494,
-0.7476140856742859,
-0.3973367512226105,
-0.4103039801120758,
-0.26471373438835144,
-0.9071357250213623,
0.29125046730041504,
0.07052919268608093,
-1.2181278467178345,
0.04170774295926094,
0.2568228244781494,
-0.35984060168266296,
0.38630369305610657,
-0.29597288370132446,
0.9373689889907837,
0.07392224669456482,
-0.5271072387695312,
-0.2602539658546448,
-0.8526046276092529,
0.2601490318775177,
0.27034732699394226,
0.32089757919311523,
0.1937931478023529,
-0.23621860146522522,
0.7693948745727539,
-0.2623688578605652,
0.9413135647773743,
-0.1937161087989807,
-0.20447471737861633,
0.005734197795391083,
0.6284895539283752,
0.17290504276752472,
0.1820068210363388,
0.13602706789970398,
0.11392026394605637,
0.14866340160369873,
-0.2882949411869049,
-0.3480868339538574,
0.5744989514350891,
-0.16074499487876892,
-0.47929900884628296,
-0.29959383606910706,
-0.42119473218917847,
-0.3914930820465088,
0.2091607004404068,
0.4896036982536316,
0.95311039686203,
0.08692140877246857,
-0.14678353071212769,
0.8157691955566406,
-0.26852157711982727,
0.560361921787262,
0.334306538105011,
-0.24966813623905182,
-0.13564927875995636,
1.0768898725509644,
-0.19283175468444824,
0.10413294285535812,
0.3192266523838043,
0.4004184305667877,
-0.013604803010821342,
-0.7141907215118408,
-1.0197759866714478,
0.25714966654777527,
-0.5676469206809998,
-0.4583405554294586,
-0.470044881105423,
-0.1657112091779709,
-0.28350478410720825,
-0.30501627922058105,
-0.38900038599967957,
-0.39389321208000183,
-0.2565588057041168,
0.04339941591024399,
0.3124113380908966,
0.826138436794281,
-0.3055897355079651,
0.2934711277484894,
-0.8875914216041565,
-0.016549335792660713,
-0.19187988340854645,
0.48713865876197815,
-0.2931036055088043,
-0.4252009391784668,
-0.2912183403968811,
-0.06139863654971123,
-0.2068103849887848,
-1.1800063848495483,
0.49921560287475586,
0.25621122121810913,
0.29879230260849,
0.48899343609809875,
-0.45153796672821045,
0.4139748513698578,
-0.5086522102355957,
0.8365364670753479,
0.4344974756240845,
-0.6734515428543091,
0.8802639842033386,
-0.4511575996875763,
0.15910346806049347,
0.40959057211875916,
0.41040870547294617,
-0.5904513597488403,
-0.7649899125099182,
-0.6774793863296509,
-0.572330892086029,
0.6994282603263855,
0.14060086011886597,
-0.239874467253685,
0.04839634522795677,
0.327825129032135,
0.007293920498341322,
0.06999211013317108,
-0.5723873376846313,
0.07264794409275055,
-0.22605855762958527,
-0.6388300657272339,
-0.07227620482444763,
-0.26383960247039795,
-0.5189188122749329,
-0.13944867253303528,
0.30353981256484985,
-0.5084537863731384,
0.47150537371635437,
0.27256157994270325,
-0.3483547866344452,
-0.15431497991085052,
-0.0771898552775383,
0.7542448043823242,
0.6824526786804199,
-0.08996753394603729,
0.0028615023475140333,
-0.04459916800260544,
-0.714909553527832,
-0.37846842408180237,
-0.04842578247189522,
-0.006521923933178186,
0.14754226803779602,
0.6043406128883362,
0.4750015437602997,
0.27623483538627625,
-0.6767759323120117,
0.9168508648872375,
0.04889450594782829,
-0.2129034847021103,
0.08923617005348206,
-0.10684530436992645,
0.09349735826253891,
0.024178819730877876,
0.25520405173301697,
-0.016574785113334656,
0.5675015449523926,
-0.1360492706298828,
0.42173394560813904,
0.21895278990268707,
-0.9591643810272217,
-0.2795533537864685,
0.3242121934890747,
0.18795394897460938,
0.002273744670674205,
0.7242236733436584,
-0.28797367215156555,
-0.5521236062049866,
0.7798913717269897,
0.6202852129936218,
0.2580498158931732,
-0.18833652138710022,
0.5589054822921753,
0.4910934269428253,
0.2596510648727417,
0.22490298748016357,
0.03682418167591095,
0.2805810570716858,
-0.4795757532119751,
-0.3571815490722656,
-0.6273438334465027,
-0.43377360701560974,
0.0463440865278244,
-0.5516974329948425,
0.06693639606237411,
-0.4941351115703583,
0.09703279286623001,
0.3915575444698334,
-0.29677143692970276,
-0.0583045519888401,
0.5887231826782227,
0.20950452983379364,
0.9953804612159729,
-0.7522760033607483,
0.6159104704856873,
0.7956089973449707,
-0.6373785138130188,
-0.6334838271141052,
0.24954593181610107,
0.3116246461868286,
-0.6337026357650757,
0.5231267809867859,
0.21732157468795776,
0.2070460170507431,
-0.20281119644641876,
-0.4045723080635071,
-1.0039995908737183,
1.0890564918518066,
0.08507165312767029,
-0.6138153076171875,
-0.11318753659725189,
-0.17246600985527039,
0.716033935546875,
-0.47911733388900757,
0.2663707435131073,
0.4184746742248535,
0.3027185797691345,
0.39117902517318726,
-1.1259396076202393,
0.31939056515693665,
0.054277125746011734,
-0.13227607309818268,
0.46164143085479736,
-0.47812262177467346,
0.6072266101837158,
-0.37071654200553894,
-0.1741195172071457,
-0.03628407046198845,
0.15108774602413177,
0.08964578807353973,
0.2002660036087036,
0.33647534251213074,
0.6808562874794006,
0.4327629506587982,
0.004674612078815699,
1.1506365537643433,
-0.5286985635757446,
0.07473057508468628,
0.5806403160095215,
-0.2749529778957367,
0.6922374367713928,
0.30739569664001465,
0.0014106263406574726,
0.6651691794395447,
0.5835275650024414,
0.027891011908650398,
0.5101752877235413,
-0.14097952842712402,
-0.04508383572101593,
-0.2559499442577362,
-0.12613609433174133,
-0.17099334299564362,
0.5278032422065735,
0.6451914310455322,
-0.3173331320285797,
-0.2786230444908142,
0.08038485050201416,
0.003855542978271842,
-0.15483416616916656,
-0.29943951964378357,
0.8291047215461731,
-0.07664187252521515,
-0.5345032215118408,
0.0673731192946434,
-0.14181862771511078,
0.6872109770774841,
-0.44191572070121765,
-0.09500432759523392,
-0.35005655884742737,
-0.022504014894366264,
-0.33069634437561035,
-1.1168123483657837,
0.6989874243736267,
-0.050341930240392685,
0.07411905378103256,
0.25818485021591187,
0.45076385140419006,
-0.4087749123573303,
-0.5518833994865417,
0.23901642858982086,
0.27239859104156494,
0.2973039150238037,
0.394417941570282,
-0.4479917883872986,
-0.052074868232011795,
0.18962523341178894,
0.00350461108610034,
0.41835638880729675,
0.19679434597492218,
-0.2640335261821747,
0.7992181181907654,
0.34314942359924316,
0.1627631038427353,
-0.24649319052696228,
0.36583229899406433,
0.8365308046340942,
-0.48304590582847595,
-0.3425082266330719,
-0.585612952709198,
0.6012025475502014,
-0.3629753887653351,
-0.5251819491386414,
0.16834622621536255,
0.5779162645339966,
0.20476357638835907,
0.182956263422966,
0.4237457513809204,
-0.042741723358631134,
0.2900561988353729,
-0.5161315202713013,
0.6062487959861755,
-0.8455656170845032,
-0.17769332230091095,
-0.49709174036979675,
-0.36889615654945374,
-0.38858920335769653,
0.5962805151939392,
-0.08195618540048599,
-0.16922229528427124,
0.868390679359436,
0.7569081783294678,
-0.2577364146709442,
-0.2248610258102417,
0.4034733176231384,
0.24906420707702637,
0.16969026625156403,
0.5114122629165649,
0.35765907168388367,
-0.26709166169166565,
0.7423331141471863,
-0.3702329993247986,
-0.5699557065963745,
-0.2454303354024887,
-0.6733428239822388,
-0.6912344098091125,
-0.8180050253868103,
-0.6762322187423706,
-0.15916329622268677,
0.16539956629276276,
0.32548028230667114,
0.9602881073951721,
-0.4310169517993927,
-0.01657475344836712,
0.015069350600242615,
-0.14551891386508942,
0.1753644198179245,
-0.14420785009860992,
0.5065039992332458,
-0.2922348976135254,
-0.4396798014640808,
0.4663044214248657,
0.9052480459213257,
0.21948590874671936,
-0.25592437386512756,
0.21570302546024323,
-0.04826115444302559,
-0.11639723926782608,
0.7144870162010193,
0.029332714155316353,
-0.5373564958572388,
0.0045592631213366985,
-0.1028120368719101,
-0.430736780166626,
0.20354287326335907,
0.5707303881645203,
-0.48155686259269714,
0.3969824016094208,
0.015199108049273491,
0.2615419030189514,
0.6912146210670471,
-0.37305885553359985,
0.6209905743598938,
-0.6299116015434265,
0.18474633991718292,
0.4111625850200653,
0.46120908856391907,
0.35316401720046997,
-0.6343885660171509,
0.5218915343284607,
0.07181773334741592,
-0.21031294763088226,
-0.850043773651123,
0.4305832087993622,
-1.0109443664550781,
-0.47749993205070496,
1.0980604887008667,
-0.1440938115119934,
-0.2001490443944931,
0.07172040641307831,
-0.19985909759998322,
0.10329106450080872,
-0.2538827061653137,
0.6335855722427368,
0.257752001285553,
-0.24437928199768066,
-0.4520358741283417,
-0.24840524792671204,
0.6169694662094116,
0.19717440009117126,
-0.7527863383293152,
-0.08600329607725143,
0.6476162672042847,
0.34785738587379456,
0.5646553039550781,
0.67438805103302,
-0.1879233717918396,
0.5288740992546082,
0.06351697444915771,
0.04439380392432213,
0.06802432984113693,
-0.46372494101524353,
-0.17770656943321228,
-0.03589500114321709,
-0.008913164027035236,
-0.141646146774292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19564v1 | Voices Unheard: NLP Resources and Models for Yorùbá Regional Dialects | 2024-06-27T22:38:04 | 2024-06-27T22:38:04 | Orevaoghene Ahia, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Diana Abagyan, Hila Gonen, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Daud Abolade, Noah A. Smith, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Yor\`ub\'a an African language with roughly 47 million speakers encompasses a
continuum with several dialects. Recent efforts to develop NLP technologies for
African languages have focused on their standard dialects, resulting in
disparities for dialects and varieties for which there are little to no
resources or tools. We take steps towards bridging this gap by introducing a
new high-quality parallel text and speech corpus YOR\`ULECT across three
domains and four regional Yor\`ub\'a dialects. To develop this corpus, we
engaged native speakers, travelling to communities where these dialects are
spoken, to collect text and speech data. Using our newly created corpus, we
conducted extensive experiments on (text) machine translation, automatic speech
recognition, and speech-to-text translation. Our results reveal substantial
performance disparities between standard Yor\`ub\'a and the other dialects
across all tasks. However, we also show that with dialect-adaptive finetuning,
we are able to narrow this gap. We believe our dataset and experimental
analysis will contribute greatly to developing NLP tools for Yor\`ub\'a and its
dialects, and potentially for other African languages, by improving our
understanding of existing challenges and offering a high-quality dataset for
further development. We release YOR\`ULECT dataset and models publicly under an
open license. | [
-0.6673583388328552,
-0.6711573004722595,
0.129819855093956,
0.18908138573169708,
-0.14034482836723328,
0.14212629199028015,
-0.25295379757881165,
-0.5451331734657288,
0.38983041048049927,
0.8253394365310669,
-0.5721209645271301,
-0.2419085055589676,
-0.4487273395061493,
0.2724127471446991,
-0.450102299451828,
0.7690122127532959,
0.7605820894241333,
-0.07284819334745407,
0.1308857798576355,
-0.5803020596504211,
-0.7067641615867615,
-0.5091615915298462,
-0.18514730036258698,
-0.288844496011734,
0.2874011695384979,
0.45855894684791565,
0.6917218565940857,
0.358152836561203,
-0.12152183055877686,
0.408614844083786,
-0.6286065578460693,
0.3297325670719147,
-0.20948490500450134,
0.19684365391731262,
-0.20068372786045074,
-0.23425382375717163,
-0.376907080411911,
-0.29455000162124634,
0.38481709361076355,
1.1542240381240845,
-0.41383102536201477,
0.33683156967163086,
0.03684547170996666,
0.8351001143455505,
-0.5092067718505859,
0.04757005348801613,
-0.76218181848526,
-0.06996020674705505,
-0.6446271538734436,
0.151707723736763,
-0.056622445583343506,
-0.4169923961162567,
-0.0300491563975811,
-0.423341304063797,
0.3472764492034912,
-0.3089703619480133,
0.5769715309143066,
0.13865245878696442,
-0.4800882339477539,
0.004278280306607485,
-0.5859556794166565,
0.5799135565757751,
-1.20216703414917,
0.3258698582649231,
0.45612576603889465,
0.18485118448734283,
-0.4691247344017029,
-0.756111204624176,
-0.6675575375556946,
0.07529225200414658,
0.15219934284687042,
0.07893060147762299,
-0.41224923729896545,
-0.11781023442745209,
0.12456519901752472,
0.4103086292743683,
-0.24925735592842102,
0.26345518231391907,
-0.6059963703155518,
-0.10638294368982315,
0.4837484359741211,
0.021414589136838913,
0.15228213369846344,
-0.4630981683731079,
0.07915489375591278,
0.141722172498703,
-0.4195316731929779,
-0.10331535339355469,
0.7142202854156494,
0.9030835628509521,
-0.02050972916185856,
0.5140483379364014,
-0.37501898407936096,
1.0705043077468872,
-0.16761824488639832,
-0.03619757667183876,
0.3747308850288391,
0.035523299127817154,
-0.22685779631137848,
-0.048827655613422394,
0.9794623851776123,
0.20587298274040222,
0.13883712887763977,
-0.2942703068256378,
-0.18936869502067566,
-0.2020370364189148,
0.4226595461368561,
-0.5096823573112488,
0.06073008105158806,
-0.04237856715917587,
-0.35804709792137146,
0.03541850298643112,
-0.32930466532707214,
-1.0534584522247314,
-0.5544059872627258,
-0.3307075500488281,
0.3943352699279785,
-0.3283662497997284,
-0.4252779185771942,
-0.0057440027594566345,
0.001196338445879519,
-0.19193695485591888,
0.04848823696374893,
-1.097434163093567,
0.5684463381767273,
0.33044007420539856,
0.7096155285835266,
0.08848559111356735,
-0.0856170654296875,
-0.028826190158724785,
-0.3577812910079956,
-0.1790533810853958,
0.5438925623893738,
0.0001688122283667326,
-0.5456846356391907,
0.1242823526263237,
-0.10789256542921066,
-0.08296719938516617,
-0.6548715233802795,
0.6753394603729248,
-0.4181269109249115,
0.1480759084224701,
-0.2575128376483917,
-0.1519617736339569,
-0.4434736967086792,
-0.25824078917503357,
-0.740081250667572,
1.0131815671920776,
0.3972152769565582,
-0.3806154429912567,
-0.15381796658039093,
-0.6833078861236572,
-0.5969275832176208,
0.2995539605617523,
-0.17197422683238983,
-0.15756699442863464,
0.6827192306518555,
0.3729167580604553,
0.32201087474823,
-0.5027800798416138,
0.29903313517570496,
0.12483762949705124,
-0.0268967617303133,
0.284050315618515,
-0.7905227541923523,
1.4377098083496094,
0.3303626477718353,
-0.29782313108444214,
-0.24997594952583313,
-1.1721174716949463,
0.38357841968536377,
0.1631259173154831,
-0.13828900456428528,
-0.18660348653793335,
-0.09269070625305176,
0.5501154065132141,
-0.19118964672088623,
-0.010122593492269516,
-0.7712060213088989,
0.15129050612449646,
-0.2921450436115265,
0.6585076451301575,
0.3478226661682129,
-0.22610430419445038,
0.18021312355995178,
0.035370927304029465,
0.4817747175693512,
-0.1049170270562172,
-0.03916643559932709,
0.149664044380188,
-0.7359068393707275,
-0.7660130262374878,
0.10430839657783508,
0.41868647933006287,
0.34732627868652344,
-0.2281024008989334,
0.6408687829971313,
0.15650679171085358,
-0.41323062777519226,
-0.9058883786201477,
0.15801887214183807,
0.19955389201641083,
0.986332893371582,
0.6613655686378479,
-0.47311878204345703,
-0.5262469053268433,
-1.0098258256912231,
0.2331198751926422,
-0.3321337401866913,
-0.0582418218255043,
0.06318304687738419,
0.033593472093343735,
-0.29395419359207153,
1.1133049726486206,
-0.20092417299747467,
-0.6104096174240112,
-0.5210248827934265,
0.27901026606559753,
0.297569215297699,
0.2779630720615387,
0.7203430533409119,
-0.897417426109314,
-0.10332111269235611,
0.08718577772378922,
-0.47719910740852356,
-0.5895651578903198,
0.07941963523626328,
0.14933328330516815,
0.5467453002929688,
0.4731942117214203,
-0.06331102550029755,
0.42644092440605164,
0.9206359386444092,
-0.20200519263744354,
0.2970031201839447,
-0.3088728189468384,
0.009090473875403404,
-1.2052180767059326,
0.03198660537600517,
-0.29380613565444946,
-0.06840378791093826,
-0.5993002653121948,
-0.025951949879527092,
-0.000133361536427401,
-0.24287407100200653,
-0.17804470658302307,
0.3215087652206421,
-0.504027247428894,
-0.13956353068351746,
-0.25405263900756836,
0.07786557078361511,
0.05162434279918671,
0.2814018726348877,
-0.011383982375264168,
0.8025800585746765,
0.17709340155124664,
-0.5794143676757812,
0.32282719016075134,
0.7086691856384277,
-0.5544896721839905,
0.49074530601501465,
-0.818728506565094,
0.22339756786823273,
0.12868377566337585,
-0.21910011768341064,
-0.699134111404419,
-0.2732515335083008,
-0.29212307929992676,
-0.621131181716919,
0.43204134702682495,
-0.30218106508255005,
-0.0826888158917427,
-0.355014830827713,
0.5114683508872986,
0.15483644604682922,
0.3724271357059479,
-0.5236525535583496,
0.5067024827003479,
0.7588645219802856,
-0.4510720670223236,
-0.8290268182754517,
-1.1021682024002075,
0.33387669920921326,
-0.08999267220497131,
-0.350360244512558,
0.09008564800024033,
0.061255697160959244,
-0.06282015889883041,
0.13967293500900269,
-0.14964044094085693,
-0.5327805280685425,
0.2867010235786438,
0.3942447006702423,
-0.04207920655608177,
-0.44039297103881836,
-0.14555703103542328,
-0.1261632889509201,
0.10163294523954391,
-0.10314494371414185,
-0.23531845211982727,
0.586674153804779,
-0.20697402954101562,
-0.20399001240730286,
-0.20111045241355896,
0.7543154954910278,
0.27663299441337585,
-0.4810884892940521,
0.8139066696166992,
0.5750387907028198,
-0.3616185188293457,
-0.23691198229789734,
-0.6945018172264099,
0.3589017391204834,
-0.4596361517906189,
0.619228720664978,
-0.19353850185871124,
-0.806906521320343,
0.6608896255493164,
0.08661793917417526,
-0.06624795496463776,
0.3477570712566376,
0.44677749276161194,
-0.14236339926719666,
0.3750465512275696,
0.8946148157119751,
-0.3977799415588379,
0.35047647356987,
-0.24536721408367157,
0.22015731036663055,
-0.8295518159866333,
-0.4312590956687927,
-0.9660099148750305,
-0.20989589393138885,
-0.9164104461669922,
-0.136266827583313,
0.4230654239654541,
0.12530265748500824,
0.04017828777432442,
0.6954423785209656,
-0.11166374385356903,
0.42742300033569336,
0.9396209120750427,
-0.11966844648122787,
0.12123669683933258,
0.021886225789785385,
-0.06237929314374924,
-0.1767234057188034,
-0.8508195281028748,
-0.3994665741920471,
0.9585375785827637,
-0.09130636602640152,
0.505521833896637,
0.38976046442985535,
0.6962463855743408,
0.34478622674942017,
-0.22837381064891815,
-0.6179212927818298,
0.4020303189754486,
-0.27402830123901367,
-0.7137148380279541,
-0.36283430457115173,
-0.49993735551834106,
-1.0881541967391968,
0.12797071039676666,
-0.2847205400466919,
-0.9622547030448914,
0.38422712683677673,
-0.08316139876842499,
-0.22268304228782654,
0.5751693844795227,
-0.46497711539268494,
0.8775210976600647,
-0.07618892937898636,
0.05822426453232765,
0.06302925199270248,
-0.845873236656189,
-0.018685974180698395,
-0.16488531231880188,
0.2583269476890564,
-0.12523585557937622,
0.3887951970100403,
0.6738250851631165,
-0.46308434009552,
0.7365151047706604,
-0.08874183148145676,
0.07190665602684021,
0.5002934336662292,
0.09916552156209946,
-0.26722148060798645,
-0.09525305777788162,
-0.31658411026000977,
0.5950829982757568,
-0.1614539921283722,
-0.367692768573761,
-0.2096920907497406,
0.727632999420166,
-0.8651415109634399,
-0.36316248774528503,
-0.3426916301250458,
-0.8783950805664062,
-0.6157687306404114,
0.42250970005989075,
0.33467257022857666,
0.8868464231491089,
-0.43340080976486206,
0.38640180230140686,
0.3548727035522461,
-0.41398704051971436,
0.5991425514221191,
0.4705107510089874,
0.061318907886743546,
-0.4995591640472412,
0.6909157037734985,
0.1372847706079483,
0.40936043858528137,
0.030762139707803726,
0.22573935985565186,
-0.45570915937423706,
-0.8895277976989746,
-0.6041680574417114,
-0.025482267141342163,
-0.3958439528942108,
-0.4855475425720215,
-0.41492149233818054,
-0.21630410850048065,
-0.7207513451576233,
-0.010307337157428265,
-0.5900357961654663,
-0.7706862688064575,
0.0017942398553714156,
-0.06938210129737854,
0.2956606447696686,
1.0254493951797485,
-0.5407505035400391,
0.6056632399559021,
-0.8907290101051331,
0.7217373847961426,
0.12837865948677063,
0.14726145565509796,
-0.16511839628219604,
-0.9389840960502625,
-0.22067448496818542,
0.09468579292297363,
-0.3513457477092743,
-0.7726727724075317,
0.7907564640045166,
0.15490920841693878,
0.5956479907035828,
0.19744384288787842,
0.220598042011261,
0.8334326148033142,
-0.5613383054733276,
0.7478326559066772,
0.23633062839508057,
-1.0398973226547241,
0.40413129329681396,
-0.299980491399765,
0.1999586522579193,
0.80994713306427,
0.34986600279808044,
-0.8506589531898499,
-0.4202595353126526,
-0.583673894405365,
-1.092064619064331,
0.6641738414764404,
0.29565829038619995,
0.25609445571899414,
-0.02002599462866783,
0.017246507108211517,
0.1772381216287613,
0.31219926476478577,
-0.6731159090995789,
-0.5856941938400269,
-0.33078500628471375,
-0.07292354106903076,
-0.2419811487197876,
-0.2627231478691101,
0.027886051684617996,
-0.025521425530314445,
0.4972453713417053,
-0.0952782854437828,
0.20002420246601105,
0.18924781680107117,
0.05946914106607437,
-0.11067947745323181,
0.6195383667945862,
0.14216461777687073,
0.5785927176475525,
-0.4699598550796509,
-0.26565122604370117,
-0.06463649123907089,
-0.6764042973518372,
0.033320359885692596,
0.4466254711151123,
-0.6542428135871887,
0.2518923580646515,
0.39383840560913086,
0.7392237186431885,
-0.08418382704257965,
-0.3542657792568207,
0.17128431797027588,
-0.014749660156667233,
0.02557307854294777,
-0.25805994868278503,
-0.09362432360649109,
0.28392308950424194,
0.24322636425495148,
0.4710911214351654,
0.3415345251560211,
0.28752025961875916,
-0.7145130634307861,
-0.12359611690044403,
0.1700763702392578,
-0.4145490825176239,
-0.07510466873645782,
0.7308663129806519,
0.3283677101135254,
-0.418989896774292,
0.8995577096939087,
-0.08328380435705185,
-0.3621271550655365,
0.5670272707939148,
0.7352132797241211,
0.6360946297645569,
-0.27024659514427185,
0.3856499195098877,
0.32716599106788635,
0.3432858884334564,
0.0996878519654274,
0.2853507101535797,
0.18279679119586945,
-0.7501828074455261,
-0.22651788592338562,
-0.8100285530090332,
-0.38446834683418274,
0.41301050782203674,
-1.3227229118347168,
-0.1279233694076538,
-0.24380601942539215,
-0.42721059918403625,
0.1483309417963028,
-0.00033353609615005553,
-0.47409507632255554,
0.38479718565940857,
0.2751466631889343,
0.7876680493354797,
-0.9041328430175781,
0.6590399146080017,
0.5818294286727905,
-0.4182319641113281,
-0.5890842080116272,
-0.14653493463993073,
0.2790411114692688,
-0.6133413910865784,
0.37747758626937866,
-0.027376210317015648,
-0.13776694238185883,
-0.007314413320273161,
-0.16244858503341675,
-0.6160086989402771,
0.7383593916893005,
0.41453567147254944,
-0.589970052242279,
0.18040654063224792,
0.37042418122291565,
0.4809408187866211,
-0.050396498292684555,
0.2918871343135834,
0.5567092895507812,
0.2853572368621826,
-0.18632355332374573,
-1.0819185972213745,
-0.46058323979377747,
-0.059576503932476044,
0.043307483196258545,
0.2784685790538788,
-0.47647932171821594,
0.6834543347358704,
-0.378168523311615,
-0.05421268939971924,
0.54230135679245,
0.9040728807449341,
-0.2627781629562378,
0.2272321581840515,
0.3825228214263916,
0.46671101450920105,
0.8286314010620117,
-0.2159803807735443,
0.7716149687767029,
0.22946162521839142,
-0.06298602372407913,
1.4263958930969238,
-0.15632613003253937,
0.8432983160018921,
0.3941155672073364,
-0.3830854594707489,
0.3082898259162903,
0.028244338929653168,
0.3747290372848511,
0.45266374945640564,
0.0872509628534317,
-0.3327670991420746,
-0.018011249601840973,
-0.5617143511772156,
-0.38339555263519287,
0.8325871825218201,
0.3908025622367859,
0.25073477625846863,
-0.21143901348114014,
-0.2489468902349472,
-0.23608915507793427,
0.775475263595581,
-0.48158544301986694,
0.4880971908569336,
0.041550327092409134,
-0.14021307229995728,
0.35599711537361145,
0.03958037495613098,
0.5393009185791016,
-0.862033486366272,
0.1992323398590088,
-0.6604520678520203,
0.1432325392961502,
-0.16823241114616394,
-0.6323942542076111,
0.528948187828064,
0.1580587476491928,
-0.044714417308568954,
-0.0330304354429245,
0.3657146096229553,
-0.319452166557312,
-0.45427271723747253,
0.5573248863220215,
0.6572486758232117,
0.089524045586586,
0.09423033893108368,
-0.4134370982646942,
0.006174543872475624,
0.12500131130218506,
-0.09812163561582565,
0.3534542918205261,
0.7530868649482727,
-0.10570298135280609,
0.5303956866264343,
0.5208417773246765,
0.625074028968811,
0.22800730168819427,
0.5837110877037048,
0.5998976826667786,
-0.7900649905204773,
-0.2562524676322937,
-0.27521881461143494,
0.27633100748062134,
0.027324052527546883,
-0.6606867909431458,
0.6619270443916321,
0.439737468957901,
1.120527982711792,
-0.08493279665708542,
0.6317517757415771,
-0.4839199185371399,
0.7554677724838257,
-0.39116954803466797,
0.7793130278587341,
-0.4963415861129761,
-0.20333921909332275,
-0.31822454929351807,
-0.7555872797966003,
-0.12637458741664886,
0.6474369764328003,
0.4301919639110565,
-0.13616248965263367,
0.37724804878234863,
0.58119797706604,
-0.20309606194496155,
0.03720390424132347,
0.5905224084854126,
0.46899211406707764,
-0.14953665435314178,
0.24440480768680573,
0.5874011516571045,
-0.5543248653411865,
0.31501680612564087,
-0.5386902093887329,
0.039934270083904266,
0.14418357610702515,
-1.0284397602081299,
-0.6736075282096863,
-0.7410890460014343,
-0.1367676556110382,
-0.3974235951900482,
-0.028229469433426857,
0.837101936340332,
0.6194168329238892,
-1.096342921257019,
-0.5369348526000977,
0.07105672359466553,
-0.20202325284481049,
-0.21136389672756195,
-0.13895021378993988,
0.013924113474786282,
-0.08756406605243683,
-0.7576799988746643,
0.9031594395637512,
-0.11427560448646545,
0.07695513963699341,
-0.14366039633750916,
0.1293586939573288,
-0.18551456928253174,
-0.16699573397636414,
0.3933134973049164,
0.7641139626502991,
-0.6666037440299988,
0.05817972123622894,
-0.2095315158367157,
0.17748093605041504,
-0.07983069866895676,
0.6284868121147156,
-0.6763759255409241,
0.4695594310760498,
0.1432545930147171,
0.8491765856742859,
0.22541038691997528,
-0.025863785296678543,
0.6755613088607788,
-0.9145869016647339,
0.6501418948173523,
0.3314521908760071,
0.5740429162979126,
0.5469542741775513,
0.023097164928913116,
0.6496037244796753,
0.15714359283447266,
-0.515234649181366,
-0.6441009044647217,
0.1775219738483429,
-1.324007272720337,
-0.15948404371738434,
0.8048579096794128,
-0.18433961272239685,
-0.04228712245821953,
-0.31193143129348755,
-0.10496291518211365,
0.3609674870967865,
-0.42134714126586914,
0.596116304397583,
0.3831322193145752,
0.1058383658528328,
0.27290967106819153,
-0.8956945538520813,
0.21571238338947296,
0.42389705777168274,
-0.6234580278396606,
0.22092163562774658,
0.8676154613494873,
0.13888828456401825,
0.30394378304481506,
0.5062310695648193,
-0.1593550592660904,
0.08434142172336578,
0.006328745745122433,
0.258113294839859,
-0.4295479953289032,
-0.32425493001937866,
-0.5978653430938721,
-0.05296424776315689,
0.029117153957486153,
-0.1974635273218155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19552v1 | Rethinking harmless refusals when fine-tuning foundation models | 2024-06-27T22:08:22 | 2024-06-27T22:08:22 | Florin Pop, Judd Rosenblatt, Diogo Schwerz de Lucena, Michael Vaiana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we investigate the degree to which fine-tuning in Large
Language Models (LLMs) effectively mitigates versus merely conceals undesirable
behavior. Through the lens of semi-realistic role-playing exercises designed to
elicit such behaviors, we explore the response dynamics of LLMs post
fine-tuning interventions. Our methodology involves prompting models for
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning and analyzing the coherence between the
reasoning traces and the resultant outputs. Notably, we identify a pervasive
phenomenon we term \emph{reason-based deception}, where models either stop
producing reasoning traces or produce seemingly ethical reasoning traces that
belie the unethical nature of their final outputs. We further examine the
efficacy of response strategies (polite refusal versus explicit rebuttal) in
curbing the occurrence of undesired behavior in subsequent outputs of
multi-turn interactions. Our findings reveal that explicit rebuttals
significantly outperform polite refusals in preventing the continuation of
undesired outputs and nearly eliminate reason-based deception, challenging
current practices in model fine-tuning. Accordingly, the two key contributions
of this paper are (1) defining and studying reason-based deception, a new type
of hidden behavior, and (2) demonstrating that rebuttals provide a more robust
response model to harmful requests than refusals, thereby highlighting the need
to reconsider the response strategies in fine-tuning approaches. | [
-0.532357931137085,
-1.1566115617752075,
0.5235363841056824,
-0.012328573502600193,
-0.24776685237884521,
0.04175713285803795,
-0.2130337953567505,
-0.398331880569458,
0.013186593540012836,
0.9580917954444885,
-0.9164802432060242,
-0.06762750446796417,
-0.35575634241104126,
-0.03940850868821144,
-0.5329957604408264,
1.1694626808166504,
0.08501382917165756,
-0.1190936416387558,
0.021364791318774223,
0.034971632063388824,
-0.6031771302223206,
-0.2851596772670746,
-0.8607041835784912,
-0.5861763954162598,
0.6280409097671509,
0.577791690826416,
0.7523031830787659,
0.508499801158905,
0.2552093267440796,
0.26500070095062256,
-0.07490154355764389,
0.16968752443790436,
-1.0106147527694702,
0.2124398946762085,
-0.35826432704925537,
-0.6532933115959167,
-0.21144510805606842,
0.2789520025253296,
0.24032410979270935,
0.6838994026184082,
-0.2821443974971771,
0.11297300457954407,
0.1923215091228485,
0.7650976181030273,
-0.6830592155456543,
-0.25302115082740784,
-0.9660319685935974,
-0.1321333348751068,
-0.015130484476685524,
-0.341644823551178,
-0.8931711316108704,
-0.1347411721944809,
0.005551864393055439,
-0.39029401540756226,
0.3715684413909912,
0.10495027899742126,
0.791857123374939,
0.2829693555831909,
-0.2618800401687622,
-0.5733755230903625,
-0.7022539973258972,
0.8765066266059875,
-0.6260903477668762,
0.22746042907238007,
0.5456138253211975,
0.25725579261779785,
-0.4879514276981354,
-0.5558648109436035,
-0.3034496009349823,
-0.33884745836257935,
-0.03115374781191349,
-0.15371951460838318,
-0.21404904127120972,
0.17848746478557587,
0.3623740077018738,
0.4534609913825989,
0.002984171500429511,
0.2113078236579895,
-0.16183409094810486,
-0.3135228455066681,
0.6410893201828003,
0.20210544764995575,
-0.007083804812282324,
0.05923011898994446,
-0.2936444878578186,
0.043420400470495224,
-0.9813582301139832,
0.37457555532455444,
0.5420469641685486,
0.3903144299983978,
0.015376035124063492,
0.6306565403938293,
-0.46848762035369873,
0.6179946064949036,
0.46243345737457275,
0.23760981857776642,
-0.3373737335205078,
-0.2820626497268677,
-0.4608646035194397,
-0.037216197699308395,
0.460640013217926,
0.40533846616744995,
0.5533825755119324,
-0.17207565903663635,
-0.5081561207771301,
0.32080891728401184,
0.4475068151950836,
-0.7018994092941284,
-0.3333651125431061,
0.30406928062438965,
-0.5207673907279968,
-0.7874115109443665,
-0.12460699677467346,
-0.8209028840065002,
-0.5350291728973389,
-0.44279026985168457,
0.2582707405090332,
-0.2345741093158722,
-0.23191136121749878,
0.3058597445487976,
0.05759648233652115,
0.2678685784339905,
0.3505646586418152,
-0.8011165261268616,
0.4203883111476898,
0.7804256677627563,
0.49884024262428284,
0.08219438046216965,
-0.09429538995027542,
-0.8967269062995911,
0.12138735502958298,
-0.6234281659126282,
0.6252278685569763,
-0.5847253799438477,
-0.46509048342704773,
-0.08841202408075333,
0.14498038589954376,
0.10376863181591034,
-0.6798993945121765,
0.7050275802612305,
-0.4653988480567932,
-0.17673413455486298,
-0.445936918258667,
-0.22378744184970856,
-0.1743515133857727,
0.5302663445472717,
-0.641635000705719,
0.5347728729248047,
-0.29840797185897827,
-0.6061182022094727,
0.268860787153244,
-0.3735056519508362,
-0.49808982014656067,
-0.5231273174285889,
-0.05904869735240936,
-0.3715961277484894,
0.4538569748401642,
-0.09546738862991333,
0.41200172901153564,
-0.32437068223953247,
0.3072909116744995,
-0.6192228198051453,
-0.45360979437828064,
0.5945662260055542,
-0.8625186085700989,
0.8225857615470886,
0.28556206822395325,
-0.38554647564888,
0.1901736855506897,
-0.8295770287513733,
0.1069396510720253,
0.025833478197455406,
-0.3207136392593384,
-0.4107540249824524,
-0.007988184690475464,
-0.3740454614162445,
0.3102341294288635,
-0.04872925207018852,
-0.4068968594074249,
-0.16654923558235168,
-0.6515809297561646,
0.5409524440765381,
1.0573548078536987,
0.0007848910754546523,
0.3648293912410736,
-0.6180351972579956,
0.40716877579689026,
-0.26518499851226807,
0.26248133182525635,
-0.09122445434331894,
-0.2517358362674713,
-0.8709986805915833,
0.036169201135635376,
0.03556595742702484,
0.08956612646579742,
-0.680083155632019,
-0.18548360466957092,
0.027613362297415733,
-0.3260733187198639,
-0.6862384080886841,
-0.10405894368886948,
0.6677379012107849,
0.43367817997932434,
0.22131629288196564,
-0.2059897929430008,
-0.26417186856269836,
-0.9539143443107605,
-0.6724518537521362,
-0.08704187721014023,
0.2627352178096771,
0.14782942831516266,
0.3233155608177185,
0.04541991651058197,
0.635330319404602,
-0.10987067222595215,
0.029549580067396164,
-0.03939852491021156,
0.15193872153759003,
-0.03259936347603798,
0.5302267670631409,
0.511622428894043,
-0.9905072450637817,
-0.2182834893465042,
-0.14778104424476624,
-0.30575913190841675,
0.08518731594085693,
-0.28242427110671997,
0.022826362401247025,
0.463828444480896,
0.6341435313224792,
-0.5363551378250122,
0.7075428366661072,
0.26690924167633057,
-0.4765557050704956,
0.8900578022003174,
0.14001086354255676,
0.20165330171585083,
-0.5958777070045471,
0.0036748514976352453,
-0.3265232443809509,
-0.08488019555807114,
-0.5897420644760132,
0.471474826335907,
-0.20054960250854492,
0.2167799025774002,
-0.5244325399398804,
0.22226932644844055,
-0.4646705090999603,
0.23729373514652252,
-0.3700295090675354,
-0.16940712928771973,
-0.09349558502435684,
0.41938477754592896,
-0.28360047936439514,
0.574225664138794,
0.6594718098640442,
-1.0264312028884888,
0.22705425322055817,
0.18411335349082947,
0.023240862414240837,
0.6618214249610901,
-0.5661853551864624,
0.12594325840473175,
-0.0985724925994873,
0.3197172284126282,
-1.1074039936065674,
-0.2847193777561188,
0.30002936720848083,
-0.548484206199646,
0.17228564620018005,
-0.39771491289138794,
-0.19313950836658478,
-0.3596361577510834,
-0.5640091300010681,
0.12332673370838165,
0.2113688886165619,
-0.5097169876098633,
0.5255730152130127,
0.025566739961504936,
0.14982768893241882,
-0.6165748834609985,
-1.0034382343292236,
-0.024320101365447044,
-0.3646145462989807,
-0.41216394305229187,
0.27569684386253357,
-0.3334943652153015,
-0.4186452329158783,
-0.29752275347709656,
-0.45879340171813965,
0.10739200562238693,
0.3440363109111786,
0.28012940287590027,
-0.07162046432495117,
-0.005895471200346947,
-0.31513863801956177,
0.08909264206886292,
-0.20841720700263977,
0.4646691083908081,
0.06083570793271065,
0.54050213098526,
-0.2587881088256836,
-0.5091043710708618,
-0.39043983817100525,
0.41817739605903625,
0.8527848124504089,
-0.24867984652519226,
0.6844603419303894,
0.33455485105514526,
-0.3544425666332245,
-0.1346791535615921,
-0.5528807044029236,
-0.6982530355453491,
-0.5350438356399536,
0.0631832703948021,
-0.5809110999107361,
-1.0766512155532837,
0.6566957831382751,
-0.2800551652908325,
0.3179241120815277,
0.00989670492708683,
0.5254344940185547,
-0.03389231488108635,
1.0376291275024414,
0.5793763995170593,
0.1632099151611328,
0.23146778345108032,
-0.18979761004447937,
0.5277690291404724,
-0.7458234429359436,
-0.26660096645355225,
-0.6633734703063965,
-0.32204559445381165,
-0.7830711603164673,
-0.06583326309919357,
-0.1777556836605072,
0.2142307609319687,
-0.2791926860809326,
0.020496057346463203,
-0.31822314858436584,
0.5868332982063293,
0.1373308002948761,
0.21655789017677307,
0.38195642828941345,
-0.007963023148477077,
-0.25477495789527893,
0.0038988995365798473,
-0.6661669611930847,
-0.539198637008667,
0.8807010054588318,
0.43435341119766235,
0.9536823034286499,
0.40585917234420776,
0.5852939486503601,
-0.015760764479637146,
0.40676450729370117,
-0.9459534883499146,
0.7149943709373474,
0.15861111879348755,
-0.6116657853126526,
-0.319001704454422,
-0.3391472101211548,
-0.9049002528190613,
0.27542242407798767,
-0.3518674373626709,
-0.8291374444961548,
0.21091747283935547,
0.4087395668029785,
-0.48120880126953125,
0.2846909761428833,
-0.639094352722168,
0.5860853791236877,
0.0020066865254193544,
-0.9104337096214294,
-0.496675968170166,
-0.5476531982421875,
0.6073498725891113,
-0.006749700754880905,
0.32163742184638977,
0.09445852041244507,
0.33291637897491455,
0.5016279816627502,
-0.3046010732650757,
1.094932198524475,
0.01615060307085514,
-0.5479161739349365,
0.28706076741218567,
0.7397912740707397,
0.8917643427848816,
0.21878862380981445,
-0.2832545340061188,
-0.3498578369617462,
0.04564227908849716,
-0.3992000222206116,
-0.5189439058303833,
1.093574047088623,
-0.2530311346054077,
-1.1061087846755981,
-0.18446753919124603,
-0.4741203486919403,
-0.4311389923095703,
0.5553761124610901,
0.2794845402240753,
0.30924829840660095,
-0.24701790511608124,
0.3738994002342224,
1.1108478307724,
-0.1419769674539566,
0.5026986002922058,
0.8904193639755249,
-0.22803519666194916,
0.05797429755330086,
0.7572710514068604,
-0.1729058474302292,
0.7278299927711487,
0.09372491389513016,
0.3010717034339905,
-0.29761818051338196,
-0.6172106266021729,
-0.18632780015468597,
0.15837045013904572,
-0.5394138097763062,
-0.15703900158405304,
-0.2981429398059845,
-0.06635168194770813,
-0.18161718547344208,
-0.2719595730304718,
-0.4774166941642761,
-0.22678066790103912,
-0.16688428819179535,
-0.20320606231689453,
0.13310137391090393,
0.716551661491394,
0.098137266933918,
0.01532007660716772,
-0.3167436420917511,
0.2561051845550537,
0.20379190146923065,
0.573492705821991,
0.280674010515213,
-0.5963939428329468,
0.07993494719266891,
0.3948924243450165,
-0.46131688356399536,
-0.671337366104126,
-0.034495461732149124,
-0.21009337902069092,
0.4822344183921814,
0.4882560074329376,
0.4714694023132324,
0.6597254276275635,
-0.3295430839061737,
0.513202428817749,
0.05072078853845596,
-0.6106442809104919,
0.5380103588104248,
-0.6136260032653809,
-0.10543354600667953,
0.5614851117134094,
0.11721991002559662,
-0.24857014417648315,
-0.5887018442153931,
-0.784803569316864,
-0.8047658801078796,
0.6454716920852661,
0.15002265572547913,
0.2597733736038208,
0.07276495546102524,
0.5598955154418945,
0.16644710302352905,
0.4038374125957489,
-0.708835780620575,
-0.24468891322612762,
0.07431170344352722,
0.2650837302207947,
0.1343879997730255,
-0.28659191727638245,
-0.5469889044761658,
-0.04160839319229126,
0.6220141053199768,
-0.262095183134079,
0.0607135109603405,
0.11300033330917358,
-0.036423541605472565,
-0.4553193747997284,
0.4872537851333618,
0.6681534647941589,
0.6108502745628357,
0.08529304713010788,
0.3262835443019867,
0.01764656789600849,
-0.25098830461502075,
0.1154279112815857,
-0.2707153856754303,
-0.1964600384235382,
-0.39014366269111633,
0.17705562710762024,
0.5668699145317078,
0.4122498333454132,
-0.4738250970840454,
0.2781360149383545,
0.07671169191598892,
-0.2038823366165161,
-0.015642864629626274,
0.27393853664398193,
-0.0018565327627584338,
0.08191224932670593,
-0.004991626366972923,
0.44460156559944153,
0.2801631689071655,
-0.793075680732727,
0.3093772232532501,
0.8218914270401001,
-0.4352622330188751,
-0.20625479519367218,
0.5198159217834473,
0.09944690018892288,
-0.32418492436408997,
0.3803572356700897,
0.00496493699029088,
-0.332529217004776,
0.5544558167457581,
0.590273916721344,
0.5664060711860657,
-0.16947884857654572,
0.42971062660217285,
-0.039304908365011215,
0.4801308512687683,
-0.1349460929632187,
0.12918120622634888,
-0.00573462201282382,
-0.7425041198730469,
-0.4379725754261017,
-0.33191198110580444,
-0.20113766193389893,
0.45644423365592957,
-0.9722630381584167,
0.14127163589000702,
-0.8039999008178711,
0.07040395587682724,
-0.09749093651771545,
-0.059144772589206696,
-0.3901698887348175,
0.12338447570800781,
-0.1520826816558838,
1.0677456855773926,
-0.7555316090583801,
0.5567169189453125,
0.5756126642227173,
-0.3190922439098358,
-0.8718923926353455,
0.38488221168518066,
0.22048304975032806,
-0.7639302015304565,
-0.07918934524059296,
0.16403113305568695,
-0.6133598685264587,
0.08160345256328583,
-0.8560558557510376,
-0.5417049527168274,
0.7731212973594666,
0.5530228018760681,
-0.6800384521484375,
0.26199570298194885,
0.0938737541437149,
0.49167996644973755,
-0.07255097478628159,
-0.08989911526441574,
0.8796471357345581,
0.4599338173866272,
0.18180428445339203,
-0.874090850353241,
0.4707508087158203,
0.09685224294662476,
-0.12649573385715485,
0.1363590508699417,
-1.0645908117294312,
0.5885114073753357,
-0.548983633518219,
-0.14789827167987823,
0.32982295751571655,
0.4393441677093506,
0.5941553115844727,
0.4347556233406067,
0.5537142753601074,
0.4612954258918762,
0.8031870722770691,
-0.10070541501045227,
0.9259445071220398,
0.046420689672231674,
0.262136310338974,
0.9348045587539673,
-0.11045104265213013,
0.6756371259689331,
0.9750211834907532,
0.20935237407684326,
0.4161249101161957,
0.6808701157569885,
0.29652389883995056,
0.6463793516159058,
0.5691709518432617,
-0.041752081364393234,
-0.5177177786827087,
-0.19644726812839508,
-0.1942550092935562,
0.339587926864624,
0.5344296097755432,
-0.0031846612691879272,
-0.20059992372989655,
-0.07172750681638718,
0.13082802295684814,
0.39670345187187195,
-0.5025972723960876,
0.5242766737937927,
0.21678775548934937,
-0.98614102602005,
0.7703606486320496,
0.14314387738704681,
0.6432650089263916,
-0.35636529326438904,
-0.03530982509255409,
-0.1681888848543167,
0.22490046918392181,
-0.35638198256492615,
-0.7802554368972778,
0.47164782881736755,
-0.13432177901268005,
-0.38855165243148804,
-0.22592177987098694,
0.7931749224662781,
-0.2224811166524887,
-0.07030641287565231,
0.2996636629104614,
0.3230425715446472,
-0.11716757714748383,
-0.03735419362783432,
-0.921558678150177,
0.24979422986507416,
0.19724518060684204,
-0.35853710770606995,
0.42487838864326477,
0.6823291182518005,
-0.38105976581573486,
1.0308881998062134,
0.8295838832855225,
-0.2097407579421997,
-0.26258546113967896,
0.17135661840438843,
1.0414992570877075,
-0.47757357358932495,
-0.7384313941001892,
-0.8382494449615479,
0.45990851521492004,
0.20538073778152466,
0.008875438012182713,
0.6254658699035645,
0.21391266584396362,
0.967081606388092,
0.057203005999326706,
0.5595578551292419,
0.054375678300857544,
0.3629690408706665,
-0.7606842517852783,
0.6973571181297302,
-0.4954396188259125,
0.7082949280738831,
-0.31451931595802307,
-0.45294618606567383,
-0.06276263296604156,
0.5012858510017395,
-0.2838503122329712,
0.23821769654750824,
0.6370795965194702,
0.9466385245323181,
-0.049628760665655136,
0.3548332154750824,
0.3030906021595001,
0.527926504611969,
0.40896737575531006,
0.5909318327903748,
0.9147936105728149,
-0.25339433550834656,
0.5268646478652954,
-0.029054837301373482,
-0.22203607857227325,
-0.41005367040634155,
-0.7765999436378479,
-0.9694069027900696,
-0.2870405614376068,
-0.21204543113708496,
-0.6986992955207825,
0.09279649704694748,
0.5265655517578125,
0.455832839012146,
-0.9132803082466125,
0.029902569949626923,
-0.5411169528961182,
0.2737639844417572,
-0.31370723247528076,
-0.2333323210477829,
-0.05010956898331642,
-0.09284686297178268,
-0.3734574019908905,
0.36386504769325256,
-0.00450988719239831,
0.152590811252594,
-0.43115314841270447,
-0.23622138798236847,
-0.17607472836971283,
0.38130563497543335,
0.45748233795166016,
0.429268479347229,
-1.021918773651123,
-0.4207603633403778,
0.03534042090177536,
0.07666712999343872,
-0.2937103509902954,
0.9511337876319885,
-0.7682570219039917,
0.23848176002502441,
0.056835927069187164,
0.468001127243042,
0.14608249068260193,
-0.1086508184671402,
0.6674098968505859,
-0.6167925596237183,
0.10406193882226944,
0.12800753116607666,
0.0534050390124321,
0.2733406722545624,
-0.6018288731575012,
0.22776088118553162,
0.09820511937141418,
-0.3101378381252289,
-1.128369688987732,
0.6654577255249023,
-0.5989447832107544,
-0.46248573064804077,
0.9713093042373657,
0.03744492679834366,
-0.1719449907541275,
-0.20925259590148926,
-0.36927685141563416,
0.05908310413360596,
-0.31414473056793213,
1.0890758037567139,
0.9760444760322571,
-0.2690969407558441,
-0.22240933775901794,
-0.49725502729415894,
0.8091748952865601,
0.7816472053527832,
-0.3745928406715393,
0.5405030846595764,
0.5022740960121155,
0.406105101108551,
0.09754350781440735,
0.529872715473175,
-0.17930994927883148,
0.4159538745880127,
-0.34184011816978455,
-0.669360339641571,
-0.18065975606441498,
-0.6805906891822815,
-0.41273385286331177,
0.033254098147153854,
0.22697985172271729,
0.08198628574609756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19545v1 | Leveraging Machine-Generated Rationales to Facilitate Social Meaning Detection in Conversations | 2024-06-27T21:47:42 | 2024-06-27T21:47:42 | Ritam Dutt, Zhen Wu, Kelly Shi, Divyanshu Sheth, Prakhar Gupta, Carolyn Penstein Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present a generalizable classification approach that leverages Large
Language Models (LLMs) to facilitate the detection of implicitly encoded social
meaning in conversations. We design a multi-faceted prompt to extract a textual
explanation of the reasoning that connects visible cues to underlying social
meanings. These extracted explanations or rationales serve as augmentations to
the conversational text to facilitate dialogue understanding and transfer. Our
empirical results over 2,340 experimental settings demonstrate the significant
positive impact of adding these rationales. Our findings hold true for
in-domain classification, zero-shot, and few-shot domain transfer for two
different social meaning detection tasks, each spanning two different corpora. | [
-0.2933734953403473,
-1.0718715190887451,
0.9560814499855042,
0.27274036407470703,
-0.505328893661499,
0.06982672959566116,
-0.1832686960697174,
-0.5386066436767578,
0.1696796715259552,
0.4647045135498047,
-0.5217889547348022,
-0.4588220715522766,
-0.9244154095649719,
0.12557564675807953,
-0.30159834027290344,
0.8094908595085144,
0.08911239355802536,
-0.09418167173862457,
-0.2559337913990021,
-0.256736695766449,
-0.3568660020828247,
-0.7633388638496399,
-0.8006975054740906,
-0.3585703372955322,
0.8881267309188843,
0.46749457716941833,
0.6413096785545349,
0.4342496693134308,
0.1479501724243164,
0.30768507719039917,
-0.1620343029499054,
0.540244996547699,
-0.4364546239376068,
0.20839470624923706,
-0.2744675874710083,
-0.48269587755203247,
-0.24157163500785828,
0.15055984258651733,
0.5863265991210938,
0.8572993278503418,
0.3708336055278778,
0.2907698154449463,
0.157781720161438,
0.3597031533718109,
-0.4101697504520416,
0.42383304238319397,
-0.6980286240577698,
-0.14098992943763733,
0.03730475530028343,
-0.5729129910469055,
-0.5910331010818481,
-0.36942848563194275,
0.13324834406375885,
-0.35624635219573975,
-0.050338421016931534,
0.014510883949697018,
0.8397031426429749,
-0.059961553663015366,
-0.49378395080566406,
-0.4908706843852997,
-0.623749315738678,
0.8423606157302856,
-0.31946471333503723,
0.1431654989719391,
0.22625818848609924,
0.5330321192741394,
-0.19812430441379547,
-0.6496657133102417,
-0.8883240818977356,
0.11299360543489456,
-0.2892691493034363,
-0.17645931243896484,
-0.18395602703094482,
0.040978193283081055,
0.3403055965900421,
0.026032494381070137,
-0.19200223684310913,
-0.2520964741706848,
-0.2839912176132202,
-0.07795842736959457,
0.6990368366241455,
0.27544617652893066,
0.4146634340286255,
-0.336444228887558,
-0.12209470570087433,
0.08585260808467865,
-0.6215537786483765,
0.2170739322900772,
0.15783117711544037,
0.3446000814437866,
-0.3641819655895233,
0.49270927906036377,
-0.02944527566432953,
0.2761232554912567,
0.05666547268629074,
-0.11203911155462265,
0.045243438333272934,
-0.4435887634754181,
-0.24449269473552704,
0.05898416414856911,
0.7262201309204102,
0.5371729135513306,
0.6905684471130371,
-0.03571701422333717,
0.06540188938379288,
0.22929205000400543,
-0.25709956884384155,
-0.9233971238136292,
0.13174748420715332,
0.11103018373250961,
-0.4343373477458954,
-0.5351572036743164,
-0.12527582049369812,
-0.5855021476745605,
-0.5409918427467346,
-0.6016037464141846,
-0.004034893587231636,
-0.23349453508853912,
-0.30018842220306396,
0.23480603098869324,
-0.5114648938179016,
0.6955249905586243,
0.7088137865066528,
-0.9114786982536316,
0.07593825459480286,
0.77973473072052,
0.9013944864273071,
0.042672231793403625,
0.18757213652133942,
-0.5458646416664124,
0.4410252869129181,
-0.3268788456916809,
1.1606776714324951,
-0.7333856821060181,
-0.3732385039329529,
0.21353429555892944,
0.33355191349983215,
-0.1396913230419159,
-0.18997763097286224,
0.3726235330104828,
-0.42674311995506287,
0.3989902138710022,
-0.31814324855804443,
-0.5325851440429688,
-0.2425442934036255,
0.3444952070713043,
-0.20027807354927063,
0.8191117644309998,
-0.09208270907402039,
-0.520734429359436,
0.29883748292922974,
-0.6053006052970886,
-0.5209198594093323,
0.588840126991272,
-0.33095312118530273,
0.00833971705287695,
0.09448341280221939,
0.011661055497825146,
0.8065602779388428,
-0.2824966013431549,
0.39955976605415344,
-0.7645746469497681,
-0.23727409541606903,
0.7523736357688904,
-0.6875004768371582,
0.7720484733581543,
0.25128358602523804,
-0.33617541193962097,
0.14423589408397675,
-0.5023768544197083,
-0.011929580010473728,
0.201758474111557,
-0.16546869277954102,
-0.39803215861320496,
0.01507163979113102,
-0.2421361356973648,
0.1853238046169281,
0.013674815185368061,
-0.3027353286743164,
-0.10112305730581284,
-0.25126752257347107,
0.5692470669746399,
0.9701811075210571,
0.08479854464530945,
0.7659100890159607,
-0.2914341688156128,
0.4683305323123932,
-0.0734834372997284,
0.1119886115193367,
-0.2766144871711731,
-0.7796570062637329,
-0.7605028748512268,
-0.5744446516036987,
-0.053399160504341125,
0.6617498397827148,
-0.7060673236846924,
0.3629987835884094,
-0.272388219833374,
-0.03130965679883957,
-0.41000163555145264,
0.10786699503660202,
-0.060475487262010574,
0.3328482508659363,
0.11515944451093674,
0.2523360550403595,
-0.4536839723587036,
-0.7793976068496704,
-0.38757920265197754,
-0.2937776446342468,
-0.32708796858787537,
0.6363978385925293,
0.519455075263977,
-0.45549359917640686,
0.8289326429367065,
-0.5400760769844055,
-0.02314278669655323,
-0.5549400448799133,
0.2722551226615906,
-0.013826022855937481,
0.032637376338243484,
0.38476887345314026,
-0.6575624942779541,
-0.5381081104278564,
0.12428494542837143,
-1.1425737142562866,
-0.3661768436431885,
-0.3011844754219055,
-0.4068133234977722,
0.10828710347414017,
0.6411826014518738,
-0.7095356583595276,
0.5449528694152832,
0.11538135260343552,
-0.29243600368499756,
0.2913559079170227,
0.2326042801141739,
0.3034282326698303,
-1.152426838874817,
-0.19011430442333221,
0.1323830634355545,
-0.3377950191497803,
-0.6760075092315674,
-0.34329846501350403,
-0.30829963088035583,
0.02666115015745163,
-0.4694874882698059,
0.7735395431518555,
-0.2965402603149414,
0.02181892842054367,
-0.08990976214408875,
0.6952108144760132,
0.21387282013893127,
0.3256368935108185,
0.052268922328948975,
0.4896618723869324,
0.2807266116142273,
-0.5309869647026062,
0.48776933550834656,
0.11653878539800644,
-0.16016508638858795,
0.9077648520469666,
-0.7921578884124756,
0.31368565559387207,
-0.471677303314209,
0.365292489528656,
-1.3612256050109863,
-0.47956347465515137,
0.6884704232215881,
-0.7324038147926331,
-0.10228049755096436,
-0.4977542757987976,
-0.654995858669281,
-0.006837185006588697,
-0.37826257944107056,
0.23140372335910797,
0.38348081707954407,
-0.6233386397361755,
0.8315751552581787,
0.5772740244865417,
-0.31289756298065186,
0.02146098203957081,
-0.49939990043640137,
0.0824131891131401,
-0.5908727645874023,
-1.0506993532180786,
0.1425652652978897,
-0.07830779254436493,
-0.5835780501365662,
-0.12443346530199051,
0.3331610858440399,
0.04018021747469902,
0.2434578388929367,
0.37437114119529724,
0.5050394535064697,
-0.24757763743400574,
0.4394279718399048,
0.3826093375682831,
-0.03670434653759003,
0.44632837176322937,
-0.05015444755554199,
0.4912119507789612,
-0.14992444217205048,
-0.17165160179138184,
-0.3750065863132477,
0.5949586033821106,
0.7321668267250061,
0.22612977027893066,
0.9438596963882446,
0.6060914397239685,
-0.4191569983959198,
-0.35512563586235046,
-0.45425885915756226,
-0.131280779838562,
-0.5467526912689209,
-0.2290221005678177,
-0.3734166622161865,
-1.1421869993209839,
0.562713086605072,
-0.2678772509098053,
-0.14672233164310455,
0.0801202580332756,
0.4523372948169708,
-0.2312646061182022,
1.5543557405471802,
0.24508540332317352,
0.2035389542579651,
0.593532145023346,
0.07076159864664078,
0.40945062041282654,
-0.6876038312911987,
-0.32695239782333374,
-0.47228944301605225,
0.02460973896086216,
-0.506512463092804,
-0.5682255029678345,
0.11681842058897018,
0.017639461904764175,
-0.06224099174141884,
0.001484681386500597,
-0.5024755001068115,
0.5753633379936218,
0.18270200490951538,
0.03910175710916519,
0.250016987323761,
0.1492234468460083,
0.20174497365951538,
0.17654326558113098,
-0.40699926018714905,
-1.0152884721755981,
0.7260001301765442,
0.451118528842926,
0.6118438243865967,
0.18541772663593292,
0.5801041722297668,
0.36619699001312256,
0.656243085861206,
-1.1001172065734863,
0.7339006066322327,
0.23719514906406403,
-0.44747915863990784,
-0.1898120939731598,
-0.44215378165245056,
-1.0052374601364136,
0.3941444754600525,
-0.34992703795433044,
-0.9640243053436279,
-0.07565043121576309,
-0.0011890928726643324,
-0.24075694382190704,
-0.10957805067300797,
-0.8645888566970825,
0.7394344210624695,
-0.20316492021083832,
-0.21019116044044495,
-0.2584315538406372,
-0.3322056531906128,
0.47791653871536255,
0.1459963470697403,
0.46975383162498474,
-0.3842889666557312,
0.3173103332519531,
0.5759023427963257,
-0.1720125377178192,
1.0976580381393433,
-0.16977664828300476,
-0.09071176499128342,
0.40015771985054016,
-0.21005089581012726,
0.4390563368797302,
0.15616725385189056,
0.14486730098724365,
0.18351994454860687,
-0.02530725486576557,
-0.2920839488506317,
-0.8818572759628296,
0.4653162658214569,
-0.4407294988632202,
-0.7233718633651733,
-0.19516170024871826,
-0.45812806487083435,
0.010446691885590553,
-0.04647008329629898,
-0.1112937331199646,
0.4175611734390259,
-0.11740853637456894,
0.39267614483833313,
0.8065652847290039,
-0.44818007946014404,
-0.013517159037292004,
0.4541814923286438,
-0.20742684602737427,
-0.15031751990318298,
0.591879665851593,
-0.08675332367420197,
0.4063417911529541,
0.17518912255764008,
0.331350713968277,
-0.5464187860488892,
-0.17124706506729126,
-0.5668752789497375,
0.35266318917274475,
-1.1449357271194458,
0.03967411443591118,
-0.8702478408813477,
-0.05659184977412224,
-0.5612612962722778,
-0.5418673753738403,
0.3474005162715912,
-0.16679641604423523,
-0.5370510816574097,
-0.2921881377696991,
0.6122244000434875,
0.5547857284545898,
-0.04975603148341179,
0.4124276340007782,
-0.9455689787864685,
0.41895994544029236,
0.41104891896247864,
0.044117409735918045,
-0.11509975045919418,
-0.609128475189209,
0.11570043861865997,
0.3008253574371338,
-0.03618251532316208,
-1.0233500003814697,
0.37123212218284607,
0.0877484679222107,
0.7282170057296753,
0.4491579532623291,
-0.024463612586259842,
0.6653344631195068,
-0.38811907172203064,
0.6375349164009094,
0.3095458447933197,
-1.0583635568618774,
0.8423237800598145,
-0.343044251203537,
0.06978484988212585,
0.28870636224746704,
0.4152491092681885,
-0.7534904479980469,
-0.31871315836906433,
-0.519460916519165,
-0.6606999039649963,
0.5854913592338562,
0.0031736751552671194,
0.5446837544441223,
-0.4338591992855072,
0.4366186261177063,
-0.2627260982990265,
-0.09299080073833466,
-0.5820085406303406,
-0.141779825091362,
0.008414334617555141,
-0.41149911284446716,
0.272125244140625,
-0.3844769597053528,
-0.18675802648067474,
-0.2397499531507492,
0.31890666484832764,
-0.4665425419807434,
0.4263352155685425,
0.0181561391800642,
-0.28022465109825134,
-0.12674947082996368,
0.3840412497520447,
0.4188305735588074,
0.3359779715538025,
0.01865500397980213,
0.42074891924858093,
0.324278861284256,
0.010570880956947803,
-0.08559851348400116,
-0.0011746273376047611,
0.0804557129740715,
-0.000050527371058706194,
0.3484283983707428,
0.7023252844810486,
0.23515062034130096,
-0.4845288097858429,
0.6619490385055542,
-0.3692484498023987,
-0.25554850697517395,
-0.2626621127128601,
0.03745708614587784,
0.2692229151725769,
0.34724241495132446,
0.23239019513130188,
-0.35021454095840454,
0.158739373087883,
-1.018237590789795,
0.22084088623523712,
0.794808030128479,
-0.2810932397842407,
-0.5207677483558655,
0.25926342606544495,
0.3485693633556366,
-0.48235902190208435,
0.29859089851379395,
-0.28289368748664856,
-0.7165710926055908,
0.358049601316452,
0.39197367429733276,
1.0279076099395752,
0.05155668035149574,
0.6090894937515259,
0.11768773198127747,
0.03486557677388191,
0.11686857789754868,
0.07058221846818924,
-0.43173131346702576,
-1.1861861944198608,
-0.5854182243347168,
-0.5465379953384399,
-0.6043700575828552,
0.07719700038433075,
-0.49003222584724426,
0.38884010910987854,
-0.4378884434700012,
0.024594394490122795,
0.697224497795105,
-0.4600558876991272,
-0.5479151606559753,
-0.3412167727947235,
0.5210960507392883,
0.4779508411884308,
-1.0214213132858276,
0.7116641998291016,
0.37476274371147156,
-0.43040573596954346,
-0.8070662617683411,
-0.21924197673797607,
0.12103008478879929,
-1.0181411504745483,
1.0147989988327026,
0.424195796251297,
-0.5424335598945618,
-0.26404961943626404,
-1.0401654243469238,
-0.4766331911087036,
0.8720369935035706,
0.28578194975852966,
-0.03542787581682205,
0.16403204202651978,
0.4197099804878235,
0.5623505115509033,
-0.693816602230072,
0.3204302191734314,
0.5993431806564331,
0.5204606652259827,
0.592780590057373,
-0.48521190881729126,
0.23023587465286255,
-0.2680019438266754,
-0.04743267968297005,
0.04689379408955574,
-0.04293994978070259,
0.3400561213493347,
0.021371589973568916,
-0.7729523777961731,
-0.14622899889945984,
0.5020044445991516,
0.4103401303291321,
0.6471297740936279,
0.5278322100639343,
-0.07939078658819199,
0.792232871055603,
-0.05169863998889923,
1.0172760486602783,
-0.12984758615493774,
0.010461298748850822,
0.6716480255126953,
-0.3665422201156616,
0.4989321231842041,
0.40896347165107727,
0.020930029451847076,
0.7966278195381165,
0.5138923525810242,
0.4555326998233795,
0.18325099349021912,
0.1351700872182846,
-0.6003527045249939,
-0.5003923773765564,
-0.5069169998168945,
-0.0034568498376756907,
0.19643737375736237,
0.9191474318504333,
-0.5513920783996582,
-0.09926673769950867,
-0.19578146934509277,
0.18209363520145416,
-0.0051644425839185715,
-0.23586851358413696,
0.9669342041015625,
0.4327234923839569,
-0.7441473603248596,
0.5553278923034668,
-0.30682340264320374,
0.5397852659225464,
-0.37083885073661804,
-0.3592340052127838,
-0.08877535164356232,
0.26423463225364685,
-0.2106361985206604,
-1.0044469833374023,
0.4601338803768158,
0.03144847974181175,
-0.016324007883667946,
-0.5411009788513184,
1.1933153867721558,
-0.4670475721359253,
-0.2883175313472748,
0.46416929364204407,
0.4909421503543854,
0.36197030544281006,
-0.17468473315238953,
-0.8043890595436096,
0.15855370461940765,
-0.027286823838949203,
-0.026518648490309715,
0.3191440999507904,
1.1523276567459106,
-0.20083050429821014,
0.5624726414680481,
1.0572831630706787,
-0.27738410234451294,
-0.11537753790616989,
0.4106636643409729,
0.9594203233718872,
-0.5924473404884338,
-0.2802722156047821,
-1.0558674335479736,
0.5334192514419556,
-0.4115988612174988,
0.016217799857258797,
0.7650980353355408,
-0.029519611969590187,
0.5307883620262146,
0.2717655301094055,
0.8419530391693115,
0.2901623249053955,
0.36048251390457153,
-0.3459731638431549,
0.2763952314853668,
-0.22494910657405853,
0.43320348858833313,
-0.4288688898086548,
-0.5692881941795349,
-0.343299001455307,
0.9342349171638489,
-0.617804765701294,
-0.3766722083091736,
0.45475906133651733,
0.7859464883804321,
0.21271038055419922,
0.2789670526981354,
0.42979851365089417,
-0.1399611383676529,
0.5287900567054749,
0.31131646037101746,
1.3813267946243286,
-0.018171992152929306,
0.6183059215545654,
0.3372085690498352,
-0.5692216753959656,
-0.2204042673110962,
-0.810271143913269,
-1.2940404415130615,
-0.27494919300079346,
-0.2875136435031891,
-0.5087706446647644,
-0.03313146159052849,
0.9833554029464722,
0.5168406367301941,
-0.5410043001174927,
-0.14701871573925018,
-0.0144683001562953,
0.5171642899513245,
0.25433751940727234,
-0.36453112959861755,
-0.002737803151831031,
-0.5938472151756287,
-0.548204779624939,
0.22376230359077454,
0.49771633744239807,
0.0758190006017685,
-0.09939062595367432,
-0.18815982341766357,
-0.07619162648916245,
0.6283001899719238,
1.286522626876831,
-0.09008283913135529,
-0.6674139499664307,
-0.8905320167541504,
0.20589694380760193,
-0.034394580870866776,
-0.16596394777297974,
0.5949251055717468,
-0.5701612830162048,
0.08014991879463196,
0.6323902010917664,
0.5241100192070007,
0.39472636580467224,
0.06222866475582123,
0.6100627779960632,
-0.6168612837791443,
-0.018192123621702194,
-0.04455329105257988,
0.41172724962234497,
0.42303141951560974,
-0.6650027632713318,
0.45669519901275635,
0.4810657203197479,
-0.3442937135696411,
-0.8451854586601257,
0.42421168088912964,
-1.0134657621383667,
-0.3495601713657379,
1.659827470779419,
-0.2956925928592682,
-0.4095017910003662,
-0.5053138732910156,
-0.27969369292259216,
0.21419471502304077,
-0.49359655380249023,
0.6991907358169556,
0.7238591909408569,
-0.01501420047134161,
-0.36264684796333313,
-0.35672545433044434,
0.43454262614250183,
0.08311916142702103,
-1.1268646717071533,
0.22647306323051453,
0.6868165135383606,
0.13962896168231964,
0.2666390836238861,
0.8928086161613464,
-0.1890399008989334,
0.13787662982940674,
-0.34417515993118286,
-0.2830604016780853,
0.36081910133361816,
-0.014641321264207363,
-0.1836966872215271,
0.13209575414657593,
-0.17174282670021057,
-0.1218213215470314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19543v1 | Demarked: A Strategy for Enhanced Abusive Speech Moderation through Counterspeech, Detoxification, and Message Management | 2024-06-27T21:45:33 | 2024-06-27T21:45:33 | Seid Muhie Yimam, Daryna Dementieva, Tim Fischer, Daniil Moskovskiy, Naquee Rizwan, Punyajoy Saha, Sarthak Roy, Martin Semmann, Alexander Panchenko, Chris Biemann, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Despite regulations imposed by nations and social media platforms, such as
recent EU regulations targeting digital violence, abusive content persists as a
significant challenge. Existing approaches primarily rely on binary solutions,
such as outright blocking or banning, yet fail to address the complex nature of
abusive speech. In this work, we propose a more comprehensive approach called
Demarcation scoring abusive speech based on four aspect -- (i) severity scale;
(ii) presence of a target; (iii) context scale; (iv) legal scale -- and
suggesting more options of actions like detoxification, counter speech
generation, blocking, or, as a final measure, human intervention. Through a
thorough analysis of abusive speech regulations across diverse jurisdictions,
platforms, and research papers we highlight the gap in preventing measures and
advocate for tailored proactive steps to combat its multifaceted
manifestations. Our work aims to inform future strategies for effectively
addressing abusive speech online. | [
-0.565057098865509,
-1.1122605800628662,
0.278881311416626,
0.14815817773342133,
-0.5185552835464478,
0.5134854316711426,
-0.02933141030371189,
-0.38593295216560364,
0.3772850036621094,
0.6452040076255798,
-0.6347090005874634,
-0.5224186778068542,
-1.0349650382995605,
0.06993976980447769,
-0.5952900052070618,
1.0572293996810913,
0.14918726682662964,
0.20202386379241943,
-0.1787964105606079,
-0.03499821200966835,
-0.7107630968093872,
-0.7117106318473816,
-0.64579176902771,
-0.20885175466537476,
0.7408422231674194,
0.21953506767749786,
0.5661488771438599,
0.6257404685020447,
0.8901118040084839,
0.3431485593318939,
-0.09764111787080765,
-0.10919636487960815,
-0.7979345321655273,
0.6075868606567383,
-0.2661144435405731,
-0.268176406621933,
-0.702937126159668,
0.02002795599400997,
0.43206992745399475,
0.2989024519920349,
-0.4229108691215515,
0.184182807803154,
-0.09934152662754059,
0.35728684067726135,
-0.7406873106956482,
-0.40091004967689514,
-0.517071545124054,
0.07202132046222687,
-0.3089883625507355,
-0.24001488089561462,
-0.1038861870765686,
-0.3298991322517395,
-0.4734497666358948,
-0.2072647213935852,
-0.38282278180122375,
-0.36635106801986694,
0.5418151021003723,
0.3900666832923889,
-0.3375357985496521,
-0.4523017704486847,
-1.0692259073257446,
0.8829091191291809,
-0.6280632019042969,
0.329441100358963,
0.6272009611129761,
0.17737281322479248,
0.12894277274608612,
-0.9407477378845215,
-0.27563047409057617,
0.1748623549938202,
0.09443409740924835,
0.16559794545173645,
-0.8873851895332336,
0.09634717553853989,
0.31388530135154724,
0.1186620369553566,
0.055314838886260986,
0.35435202717781067,
-0.48686909675598145,
-0.3025822937488556,
0.7996391654014587,
0.551261305809021,
0.41348713636398315,
0.12114930897951126,
-0.5027937293052673,
0.19695281982421875,
-0.40782877802848816,
-0.2786374092102051,
1.1622743606567383,
0.48682379722595215,
-0.1457495093345642,
0.14613431692123413,
-0.023848069831728935,
0.30303892493247986,
0.3751394748687744,
-0.07888912409543991,
0.08089756220579147,
-0.14286595582962036,
0.1825479120016098,
0.36384251713752747,
0.7415710091590881,
0.7266274690628052,
0.03655038774013519,
0.15262049436569214,
-0.42199498414993286,
0.016910135746002197,
0.8032699227333069,
-1.0773234367370605,
-0.24127691984176636,
0.5178303122520447,
-0.36002370715141296,
-0.6220207810401917,
-0.2921984791755676,
-1.3148638010025024,
-0.930936336517334,
-0.3772216737270355,
0.45397675037384033,
-0.2910460829734802,
-0.7323508262634277,
-0.3108842968940735,
-0.46497777104377747,
0.020840197801589966,
0.2019720822572708,
-0.7948780655860901,
0.8986197710037231,
0.6491694450378418,
0.6765246391296387,
-0.058443691581487656,
0.33267438411712646,
-0.38130494952201843,
-0.10136401653289795,
-0.5350421071052551,
0.44759562611579895,
-1.2528257369995117,
-0.13839399814605713,
0.10802972316741943,
-0.420680969953537,
0.34993886947631836,
-0.5642070770263672,
0.9794707298278809,
-0.7817997336387634,
0.34707245230674744,
-0.3757164180278778,
-0.23322728276252747,
-0.47397592663764954,
0.4402475953102112,
-0.5562704801559448,
0.7329076528549194,
0.085433229804039,
-0.8434081673622131,
0.4497221112251282,
-0.607555627822876,
-0.3004489839076996,
0.15884482860565186,
-0.018512815237045288,
-0.5077894926071167,
-0.02838938869535923,
0.14103788137435913,
0.24808773398399353,
0.1254223734140396,
0.3137970268726349,
-0.2297617644071579,
-0.33715376257896423,
-0.03496595099568367,
-0.8085497617721558,
0.7668800354003906,
0.4365767240524292,
-0.4429980218410492,
0.4653586149215698,
-0.5265329480171204,
0.07582699507474899,
-0.029556481167674065,
-0.2189982831478119,
-0.5136708617210388,
0.038762833923101425,
0.2627861797809601,
0.2903360426425934,
0.038276005536317825,
-0.592860221862793,
-0.28337475657463074,
-0.29867979884147644,
0.4294055700302124,
0.7565629482269287,
0.3091922700405121,
-0.07490913569927216,
-0.4439285099506378,
0.7627102136611938,
0.09124569594860077,
0.22472059726715088,
0.11092930287122726,
0.11112149804830551,
-0.26546710729599,
-0.6548996567726135,
0.09855195134878159,
0.4267992675304413,
-0.2867771089076996,
0.3681311309337616,
-0.3249390721321106,
-0.5171919465065002,
-0.5014337301254272,
-0.08482776582241058,
0.4259845018386841,
0.11478142440319061,
0.6587587594985962,
-0.47985997796058655,
-0.6863070130348206,
-0.8889116048812866,
-0.2898813784122467,
0.015438923612236977,
0.1825857311487198,
0.0274185948073864,
0.37048888206481934,
-0.1403186172246933,
0.6377316117286682,
0.06776031106710434,
-0.36781609058380127,
-0.3821028172969818,
0.24579519033432007,
-0.23399469256401062,
0.09699130803346634,
0.663398265838623,
-0.9141157865524292,
-0.4852074682712555,
-0.3667432963848114,
-0.22201743721961975,
-0.5047143697738647,
-0.15869635343551636,
0.12006637454032898,
-0.5529435276985168,
0.600699245929718,
0.09620847553014755,
0.36128154397010803,
0.4109446704387665,
-0.18594977259635925,
0.47739049792289734,
0.32194772362709045,
0.5876284837722778,
-0.9495855569839478,
-0.12438074499368668,
-0.4095528721809387,
-0.4964306354522705,
-1.0076996088027954,
-0.004747898317873478,
-0.4831506609916687,
-0.053542498499155045,
-0.578862190246582,
0.23423323035240173,
-0.05579785630106926,
0.5896537899971008,
-0.4281720519065857,
0.39864060282707214,
-0.25477057695388794,
0.301347941160202,
-0.308956503868103,
0.4679217040538788,
0.6736088991165161,
-0.48459872603416443,
0.6557788252830505,
0.2373935580253601,
0.34630826115608215,
1.191602110862732,
-0.5377985239028931,
0.3210722506046295,
-0.24147920310497284,
0.15037983655929565,
-0.8852143287658691,
-0.14507806301116943,
0.6226130723953247,
-0.14411966502666473,
0.35125842690467834,
-0.14985163509845734,
-0.2706252634525299,
-0.23938463628292084,
-0.6439156532287598,
0.6228465437889099,
0.3017835021018982,
-0.13710740208625793,
0.6530731320381165,
0.8417532444000244,
-0.386836975812912,
-0.5703354477882385,
-0.23664389550685883,
0.6308436393737793,
-0.8044050931930542,
-0.125077024102211,
0.4153127372264862,
0.08734660595655441,
-0.7263158559799194,
-0.23742613196372986,
-0.0689428299665451,
0.03386332467198372,
0.12058316171169281,
0.3743143677711487,
-0.5849138498306274,
0.31665802001953125,
-0.018143868073821068,
0.29096493124961853,
0.07017602771520615,
0.5081063508987427,
0.4599365293979645,
0.9473288655281067,
0.08642122149467468,
-0.29804566502571106,
-0.6483582258224487,
0.5288811922073364,
0.6231624484062195,
-0.08606810867786407,
0.2463873028755188,
0.7620071768760681,
-0.5062425136566162,
-0.2150527536869049,
-0.18386149406433105,
-0.5630649924278259,
-0.48069849610328674,
0.4739939868450165,
-0.2948252856731415,
-0.33715033531188965,
0.6867766380310059,
-0.5935349464416504,
0.25710147619247437,
0.20085810124874115,
0.8283073306083679,
0.05417235568165779,
1.0610145330429077,
0.3660380244255066,
0.027663525193929672,
0.5717788338661194,
0.04415131360292435,
0.393322616815567,
-0.541713535785675,
-0.16787491738796234,
-0.33838894963264465,
-0.64982670545578,
-0.5572644472122192,
-0.19896405935287476,
0.06181476265192032,
0.19524146616458893,
-0.45014551281929016,
0.3652568757534027,
-0.4692456126213074,
0.3474106192588806,
0.07003865391016006,
0.05538775399327278,
0.14147403836250305,
0.08025450259447098,
-0.23993180692195892,
-0.32417935132980347,
-0.4001796245574951,
-0.5549764633178711,
0.5711599588394165,
0.7539315819740295,
0.6357894539833069,
0.32336777448654175,
0.6996540427207947,
0.7732606530189514,
0.36094921827316284,
-0.8012247085571289,
0.5359904766082764,
0.0020337423775345087,
-0.8767957091331482,
-0.16924630105495453,
-0.32508254051208496,
-0.8335133194923401,
0.4169189929962158,
-0.1786985695362091,
-1.0408763885498047,
0.015342258848249912,
-0.10925018787384033,
-0.31111305952072144,
0.5003676414489746,
-0.21063290536403656,
0.39887726306915283,
-0.20434978604316711,
-0.5601109266281128,
-0.7492755651473999,
-0.48507142066955566,
0.16022923588752747,
-0.3016376197338104,
0.7074595093727112,
-0.3582766056060791,
-0.1597403734922409,
1.24896240234375,
-0.39965763688087463,
1.3061599731445312,
-0.3018374443054199,
-0.25669339299201965,
0.38301917910575867,
0.3214678466320038,
0.2713799476623535,
-0.2188919484615326,
-0.12461534887552261,
0.4576621949672699,
0.3381848931312561,
0.011454825289547443,
-0.333305686712265,
0.5393755435943604,
-0.6183772087097168,
-0.5883083939552307,
-0.2964889705181122,
-0.2641347646713257,
-0.29301705956459045,
0.400310218334198,
0.07940490543842316,
0.7266982197761536,
-0.2978092133998871,
0.19888204336166382,
0.3432825803756714,
-0.12742869555950165,
0.43108227849006653,
0.25219860672950745,
-0.28295519948005676,
-0.8843938112258911,
0.784900426864624,
-0.14306475222110748,
0.22567583620548248,
0.03304193541407585,
0.4232375919818878,
-0.49287930130958557,
-0.48067712783813477,
-0.2506984770298004,
-0.11940709501504898,
-0.8846005201339722,
-0.5141574740409851,
-0.6020909547805786,
-0.17944931983947754,
-0.282848984003067,
-0.0891694650053978,
-0.5254194140434265,
-0.04803990572690964,
0.042952775955200195,
-0.1549106389284134,
0.3626003861427307,
0.8941584229469299,
-0.5024241805076599,
0.4079294502735138,
-0.45945408940315247,
0.3407895565032959,
-0.030808791518211365,
0.5298261642456055,
-0.19914516806602478,
-0.9202700853347778,
0.2814924418926239,
0.2951952815055847,
-0.5136792659759521,
-1.1159416437149048,
0.22538615763187408,
0.10688599199056625,
0.4986684322357178,
0.7097716927528381,
0.46621081233024597,
1.0077108144760132,
-0.5470443964004517,
0.7042847275733948,
0.5364553928375244,
-0.6988714933395386,
0.6179320216178894,
-0.45211082696914673,
-0.18723833560943604,
0.5772362351417542,
0.5735523104667664,
-0.8831982016563416,
-0.8164246082305908,
-0.5329105257987976,
-0.9880837202072144,
0.28224509954452515,
0.17842134833335876,
1.118772029876709,
-0.16191299259662628,
-0.0882321372628212,
0.010776660405099392,
0.45118117332458496,
-0.574665367603302,
-0.2901555597782135,
-0.026122912764549255,
-0.19407020509243011,
0.6631254553794861,
-0.4086686968803406,
-0.8492324352264404,
-0.5152161717414856,
0.3506329357624054,
0.392366886138916,
0.14414551854133606,
-0.155001699924469,
0.1652911752462387,
-0.46010664105415344,
0.3324631452560425,
0.584334671497345,
0.9028686881065369,
0.04274255409836769,
0.24538752436637878,
0.07442813366651535,
-0.9904430508613586,
0.06402789056301117,
-0.3063553273677826,
-0.04460262879729271,
-0.1697181910276413,
0.5246298909187317,
0.6764683723449707,
0.2119329422712326,
-0.561830461025238,
0.6111863851547241,
0.030554823577404022,
-0.3865930140018463,
-0.2304813116788864,
0.13293489813804626,
-0.3452688753604889,
0.20078310370445251,
0.08781135082244873,
-0.0855436697602272,
0.08327129483222961,
-0.49069127440452576,
0.5907058119773865,
0.3626270890235901,
-1.0111277103424072,
-0.19582565128803253,
0.7583472728729248,
0.45163294672966003,
-0.3716078996658325,
0.3950200080871582,
-0.19731736183166504,
-0.7812121510505676,
0.13442003726959229,
0.5449644923210144,
0.8837981820106506,
-0.17162984609603882,
0.4009281396865845,
0.4790644347667694,
0.2195877581834793,
0.4344317615032196,
0.3698326647281647,
0.11627591401338577,
-0.6318979859352112,
-0.150139719247818,
-0.8086311221122742,
-0.0454367958009243,
0.4120958149433136,
-0.7155268788337708,
0.3635369837284088,
-0.9498002529144287,
-0.5007119178771973,
-0.015224012546241283,
0.09827028959989548,
-0.296368271112442,
0.05652822554111481,
0.36904075741767883,
0.5680642127990723,
-1.0784708261489868,
-0.006178798619657755,
0.44736844301223755,
-0.35308539867401123,
-0.48739907145500183,
0.0630638524889946,
0.3596895635128021,
-0.4483462870121002,
0.2736074924468994,
0.07982335984706879,
-0.4675745964050293,
0.10847657918930054,
-0.626488447189331,
-0.6106387376785278,
0.5103299617767334,
0.14302651584148407,
-0.6515234708786011,
0.6919372081756592,
0.08353633433580399,
0.8415148854255676,
-0.033317431807518005,
0.32427841424942017,
0.5873525142669678,
0.5972962379455566,
0.27413299679756165,
-0.8093472719192505,
0.2835201323032379,
0.004866567440330982,
-0.4647969901561737,
0.3126985430717468,
-0.5870722532272339,
0.318176805973053,
-0.19548773765563965,
-0.6587601900100708,
-0.36599335074424744,
0.04607430845499039,
-0.33424827456474304,
0.04389050230383873,
0.6063845157623291,
0.646909236907959,
0.7723636031150818,
-0.05981990694999695,
0.6535603404045105,
-0.13567237555980682,
-0.03393715247511864,
0.9833940267562866,
-0.12616758048534393,
0.8434849381446838,
0.36412274837493896,
-0.2894056737422943,
0.786933958530426,
0.6384007334709167,
-0.2572402060031891,
0.7719148397445679,
0.37421488761901855,
-0.4636162221431732,
-0.41454020142555237,
-0.5136684775352478,
-0.1874239593744278,
0.8376328945159912,
0.5339398384094238,
-0.33424487709999084,
-0.572053849697113,
0.21599538624286652,
0.31932368874549866,
0.6373856067657471,
-0.3026556372642517,
1.0627104043960571,
-0.036988455802202225,
0.02919366955757141,
0.46274328231811523,
0.25355133414268494,
0.31974703073501587,
-0.31654253602027893,
-0.26659345626831055,
-0.0939568504691124,
-0.007102847099304199,
-0.2738173007965088,
-0.6642202734947205,
0.44568413496017456,
0.12817132472991943,
0.2234589159488678,
-0.5946803689002991,
0.7148910164833069,
-0.29500773549079895,
-0.3208673596382141,
0.4292992055416107,
0.4212554395198822,
0.3041035532951355,
0.024370204657316208,
-0.982538640499115,
0.4176699221134186,
-0.3055327534675598,
-0.11046857386827469,
0.26389265060424805,
0.19644789397716522,
-0.25349047780036926,
0.6032421588897705,
0.44982147216796875,
0.3103833794593811,
-0.07523486018180847,
0.546735405921936,
1.1559187173843384,
-0.41041579842567444,
-0.4531605541706085,
-1.2711012363433838,
0.4884646534919739,
-0.40212365984916687,
-0.30898478627204895,
0.5292150974273682,
0.486720472574234,
0.6292475461959839,
0.5405214428901672,
0.5104191303253174,
-0.46160027384757996,
0.4147525727748871,
0.045211054384708405,
0.7596627473831177,
-0.24094021320343018,
0.18459632992744446,
-0.419111430644989,
-0.8131705522537231,
-0.3750874400138855,
0.197431281208992,
-0.5648751258850098,
0.06994706392288208,
0.36416202783584595,
0.7221260666847229,
0.02885425090789795,
-0.21287712454795837,
0.47877612709999084,
0.18817780911922455,
0.6067306995391846,
-0.29037904739379883,
0.9067233800888062,
-0.34524136781692505,
0.6637213230133057,
-0.22494275867938995,
-0.11201991140842438,
-0.08624431490898132,
-0.703596293926239,
-0.9054611325263977,
-0.47636938095092773,
-0.3439582288265228,
-0.20458067953586578,
0.16499482095241547,
0.6204215288162231,
0.6829767823219299,
-0.8140220642089844,
0.22784677147865295,
0.2802886664867401,
0.15061120688915253,
-0.6523670554161072,
-0.24406816065311432,
0.02626323699951172,
-0.2514464557170868,
-0.874522864818573,
0.13415643572807312,
0.41397514939308167,
-0.4127228856086731,
-0.36216244101524353,
0.1609956920146942,
-0.1098645031452179,
0.3556326627731323,
0.6371634006500244,
-0.1399267017841339,
-0.7743014693260193,
-0.41985273361206055,
-0.4576888978481293,
-0.19375747442245483,
0.1039060652256012,
0.6103570461273193,
-0.3234788775444031,
0.6433456540107727,
0.4826708137989044,
0.41973692178726196,
0.05008776858448982,
0.8088642358779907,
0.4629473090171814,
-1.0644017457962036,
0.04550103470683098,
0.7449797987937927,
-0.1414434015750885,
0.23228609561920166,
-0.2252184897661209,
0.0008491315529681742,
0.10671444982290268,
-0.1089172288775444,
-0.9387070536613464,
0.4325275123119354,
-0.5918588638305664,
-0.42925119400024414,
1.2590408325195312,
0.16657306253910065,
0.2350018471479416,
-0.45088711380958557,
-0.4032163918018341,
0.033970143646001816,
-0.3467329144477844,
1.067618489265442,
0.6664980053901672,
-0.00553645147010684,
-0.18686656653881073,
-0.6815304160118103,
0.6719895601272583,
-0.1768009066581726,
-0.6706411838531494,
0.6329421401023865,
0.5933747291564941,
0.3574064075946808,
0.38894739747047424,
0.5890622735023499,
-0.4467337131500244,
-0.1553061306476593,
0.4930930733680725,
-0.07058283686637878,
-0.02584116905927658,
-0.5504320859909058,
-0.2700240910053253,
0.3540024161338806,
-0.2876925766468048,
-0.14552415907382965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19538v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19538v1 | Context Matters: An Empirical Study of the Impact of Contextual Information in Temporal Question Answering Systems | 2024-06-27T21:31:30 | 2024-06-27T21:31:30 | Dan Schumacher, Fatemeh Haji, Tara Grey, Niharika Bandlamudi, Nupoor Karnik, Gagana Uday Kumar, Jason Cho-Yu Chiang, Paul Rad, Nishant Vishwamitra, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with temporal reasoning, crucial
for tasks like historical event analysis and time-sensitive information
retrieval. Despite advancements, state-of-the-art models falter in handling
temporal information, especially when faced with irrelevant or noisy contexts.
This paper addresses this gap by empirically examining the robustness of
temporal question-answering (TQA) systems trained on various context types,
including relevant, irrelevant, slightly altered, and no context. Our findings
indicate that training with a mix of these contexts enhances model robustness
and accuracy. Additionally, we show that the position of context relative to
the question significantly impacts performance, with question-first positioning
yielding better results. We introduce two new context-rich TQA datasets,
ContextAQA and ContextTQE, and provide comprehensive evaluations and guidelines
for training robust TQA models. Our work lays the foundation for developing
reliable and context-aware temporal QA systems, with broader implications for
enhancing LLM robustness against diverse and potentially adversarial
information. | [
-0.19141267240047455,
-0.8794991970062256,
0.8888845443725586,
0.2208375334739685,
-0.13937526941299438,
-0.19412459433078766,
0.17360687255859375,
-0.4514296054840088,
-0.34402909874916077,
-0.238486647605896,
-0.47333869338035583,
-0.1599690020084381,
-0.42398279905319214,
0.016159027814865112,
-0.3350732624530792,
0.6328617334365845,
0.04535298049449921,
0.1994815170764923,
-0.2829975187778473,
-0.5882806181907654,
-0.6326309442520142,
-0.8692528605461121,
-0.7179386615753174,
-0.07555308192968369,
0.46507948637008667,
-0.18021728098392487,
0.6310192942619324,
0.4551364481449127,
-0.0386442169547081,
0.19501806795597076,
-0.3739200532436371,
-0.0342060811817646,
-0.2994648814201355,
0.4855917990207672,
-0.33849501609802246,
-0.5283393859863281,
-0.327000230550766,
-0.2062697559595108,
0.6826561093330383,
0.6095961332321167,
-0.13691407442092896,
0.291976660490036,
-0.1254110485315323,
0.049460504204034805,
-0.7969520092010498,
0.07199376076459885,
-0.8430934548377991,
-0.0074254535138607025,
-0.04320906102657318,
-0.59065181016922,
-0.22669944167137146,
-0.378741979598999,
0.29926568269729614,
-0.586625874042511,
-0.13306479156017303,
-0.16495229303836823,
0.852489173412323,
0.39788129925727844,
-0.8018534183502197,
0.1238483190536499,
-0.7924816608428955,
0.848486065864563,
-0.7567177414894104,
0.4670332372188568,
0.28477370738983154,
0.41880252957344055,
0.033154211938381195,
-0.5621953010559082,
-0.3772118389606476,
0.3383832275867462,
0.03750310093164444,
0.06457817554473877,
-0.04964732751250267,
-0.3345329463481903,
0.42391347885131836,
0.0018764191772788763,
-0.3247167468070984,
0.05381430312991142,
-0.007845423184335232,
-0.06710139662027359,
0.010466082021594048,
0.3568008840084076,
0.5028433799743652,
-0.08291399478912354,
-0.22250114381313324,
-0.06721799820661545,
-0.7379782795906067,
0.49208784103393555,
-0.06798732280731201,
0.12673251330852509,
-0.015598094090819359,
0.341746985912323,
-0.30258455872535706,
0.7334795594215393,
0.12438897043466568,
-0.27036428451538086,
-0.46512603759765625,
-0.39536410570144653,
-0.251787006855011,
-0.3341197967529297,
0.30563679337501526,
0.2186988890171051,
-0.09425561875104904,
-0.5870245695114136,
-0.09171959012746811,
-0.22600163519382477,
0.23264525830745697,
-0.7590665221214294,
0.31975650787353516,
0.537562906742096,
-0.03730874881148338,
-0.015070815570652485,
-0.055255018174648285,
-0.19001588225364685,
-0.012954549863934517,
-0.5094199180603027,
0.4049411714076996,
-0.40638282895088196,
-0.08737006038427353,
-0.2599997818470001,
-0.16418799757957458,
0.7551037073135376,
0.5045002698898315,
-0.7764809131622314,
-0.2061677724123001,
0.7052847146987915,
0.4984302818775177,
0.03321687877178192,
-0.2666735053062439,
-0.7280471324920654,
0.36451467871665955,
-0.5116153955459595,
0.5537865161895752,
-0.5410264134407043,
-0.1673515886068344,
0.051928162574768066,
0.2141493558883667,
-0.36127594113349915,
-0.4310493767261505,
0.3648850917816162,
-1.1881624460220337,
0.37802553176879883,
-0.5082156658172607,
-0.34969890117645264,
0.1764175295829773,
0.366169810295105,
-0.4032106399536133,
0.9388092160224915,
0.3376873731613159,
-0.8780692219734192,
0.6614426374435425,
-0.2287396639585495,
-0.47121161222457886,
-0.15628057718276978,
-0.11667340993881226,
-0.22150692343711853,
0.05302102863788605,
0.4538279175758362,
0.487491637468338,
0.13681095838546753,
0.5922812223434448,
-0.3447865843772888,
-0.4469720125198364,
0.6786819100379944,
-0.3953968286514282,
0.7660853266716003,
0.2341141700744629,
-0.28883296251296997,
-0.09303334355354309,
-0.4354625344276428,
0.23982921242713928,
0.09523840248584747,
-0.5285343527793884,
-0.46586695313453674,
0.13045085966587067,
-0.014187592081725597,
0.3210257887840271,
0.14506182074546814,
-0.24170558154582977,
-0.028912290930747986,
-0.06568912416696548,
0.7524747848510742,
0.7106775641441345,
0.10274317115545273,
0.43092432618141174,
-0.47127029299736023,
0.524247407913208,
0.08634946495294571,
0.19714239239692688,
-0.024030478671193123,
-0.17665722966194153,
-0.3052348494529724,
0.2672457695007324,
0.1405992954969406,
0.5993279814720154,
-1.0119282007217407,
0.020907385274767876,
-0.5567380785942078,
-0.1403639167547226,
0.1276383250951767,
-0.22244393825531006,
0.16570892930030823,
0.7533244490623474,
0.1967494785785675,
0.06313323974609375,
-0.530266284942627,
-0.6530536413192749,
-0.33214229345321655,
-0.5031273365020752,
-0.16566167771816254,
0.4166121482849121,
0.30642130970954895,
-0.04778824374079704,
1.2035645246505737,
-0.1025058925151825,
0.41556087136268616,
0.04677078500390053,
-0.1746242344379425,
-0.11814869195222855,
0.18521028757095337,
0.6646550893783569,
-0.8126110434532166,
-0.061597175896167755,
-0.3296988606452942,
-0.8157995939254761,
-0.1277502179145813,
-0.1171276792883873,
-0.0832330659031868,
0.18551914393901825,
0.4310418367385864,
-0.33531343936920166,
0.2294507473707199,
0.40480244159698486,
-0.44966214895248413,
0.2942177355289459,
0.14303317666053772,
0.2768964171409607,
-1.2053650617599487,
0.3385111093521118,
-0.31404614448547363,
-0.33945798873901367,
-0.720746636390686,
0.03907420113682747,
0.2183893620967865,
-0.15225601196289062,
-0.6923753023147583,
0.9196219444274902,
-0.09902430325746536,
-0.08623407781124115,
-0.03540680184960365,
0.13317930698394775,
0.1937706470489502,
0.4608757495880127,
0.19111564755439758,
1.115551471710205,
0.14557774364948273,
-0.7505404949188232,
-0.3561517894268036,
0.2581753432750702,
-0.23069965839385986,
0.6891195178031921,
-0.6399099826812744,
0.25940677523612976,
-0.17591343820095062,
0.18075117468833923,
-0.5907506346702576,
-0.35599711537361145,
-0.12194450944662094,
-0.4489164650440216,
0.4353640377521515,
-0.3095174729824066,
-0.3564160466194153,
0.19637608528137207,
0.03295453265309334,
0.6846882104873657,
0.24835948646068573,
-0.4801141023635864,
0.47746437788009644,
0.4382784068584442,
-0.20727555453777313,
-0.7291306853294373,
-0.5884060859680176,
-0.054275888949632645,
-0.3990017771720886,
-0.5391589403152466,
0.12622423470020294,
-0.01758834905922413,
-0.4487062990665436,
-0.21843503415584564,
-0.5058221817016602,
-0.4764231741428375,
0.6560671925544739,
0.21276947855949402,
0.050456702709198,
-0.3075794279575348,
0.3028947114944458,
0.03505157679319382,
0.2303813397884369,
0.11696243286132812,
-0.2378847599029541,
0.3749406337738037,
-0.22582250833511353,
-0.2376495599746704,
-0.41118350625038147,
0.36695921421051025,
0.6961226463317871,
0.01999182440340519,
0.9877376556396484,
0.48410969972610474,
-0.4300343990325928,
0.005953870713710785,
-0.37767294049263,
-0.2722916603088379,
-0.4005883038043976,
0.3165499269962311,
-0.1691283881664276,
-1.2189781665802002,
0.5669630765914917,
0.3361143171787262,
0.1374068409204483,
0.25199854373931885,
0.27030113339424133,
-0.2336861789226532,
0.9204732775688171,
0.43539193272590637,
-0.15693023800849915,
0.8132286667823792,
0.10875020921230316,
0.08613881468772888,
-0.9411569237709045,
-0.09670483320951462,
-0.48225274682044983,
-0.06620095670223236,
-0.17989006638526917,
-0.1821380853652954,
0.6245278716087341,
0.21067117154598236,
-0.5918524265289307,
-0.08053995668888092,
-0.06950970739126205,
0.3487321436405182,
0.3798791170120239,
0.03209459036588669,
0.2509600520133972,
-0.09279120713472366,
0.23870950937271118,
0.10500699281692505,
-1.0552688837051392,
-0.7261739373207092,
0.9445822238922119,
0.29282182455062866,
0.4476420283317566,
0.3459559977054596,
0.01118585467338562,
-0.030860895290970802,
0.2529800534248352,
-0.4656963050365448,
0.2644551396369934,
0.27075204253196716,
-0.867438793182373,
-0.5123293399810791,
-0.3682854175567627,
-0.9499906897544861,
0.18664385378360748,
-0.03313717246055603,
-0.6853633522987366,
0.30793100595474243,
-0.07464710623025894,
-0.7003397941589355,
0.41338714957237244,
-0.5312682390213013,
0.616226077079773,
-0.1539045125246048,
-0.5016498565673828,
0.4044591784477234,
-0.7412301301956177,
0.023826315999031067,
0.10886218398809433,
0.13497650623321533,
-0.060918841511011124,
-0.16667811572551727,
0.7655401825904846,
-0.1689714640378952,
0.8757736086845398,
-0.11926253139972687,
-0.2195660024881363,
0.19583676755428314,
0.23942223191261292,
0.28125837445259094,
0.5779814124107361,
-0.04226405918598175,
0.05265397951006889,
0.5890774726867676,
-0.7785463333129883,
-0.6579205393791199,
0.46400830149650574,
-0.8800954818725586,
-0.7201387286186218,
-0.3891657292842865,
-0.6456393003463745,
-0.7140330672264099,
0.0641532614827156,
0.2066556215286255,
0.8805988430976868,
-0.19752168655395508,
0.4235210418701172,
0.9479803442955017,
-0.15326762199401855,
0.5078226327896118,
0.6875966787338257,
0.26533243060112,
-0.14630945026874542,
0.272606760263443,
0.09191451966762543,
0.35464638471603394,
0.6674126982688904,
-0.03898521512746811,
-0.4488385021686554,
-0.5885403156280518,
-0.4419395625591278,
-0.11394572257995605,
-0.85887211561203,
-0.1245538592338562,
-0.740764856338501,
-0.2680440843105316,
-0.5019336938858032,
-0.1205531433224678,
-0.10787826031446457,
-0.4395151436328888,
-0.39633774757385254,
-0.07108721137046814,
0.09823299944400787,
0.380964457988739,
0.33717113733291626,
0.24990487098693848,
-0.7079857587814331,
0.11561019718647003,
0.8523851633071899,
0.21693286299705505,
-0.10691972821950912,
-0.5573188066482544,
-0.07909810543060303,
-0.0354900099337101,
-0.14004667103290558,
-0.8055689930915833,
0.09668949991464615,
0.07315146178007126,
0.6577122807502747,
0.26722654700279236,
0.1387915313243866,
0.39066416025161743,
-0.22169305384159088,
1.026798129081726,
-0.4535488486289978,
-0.833077073097229,
0.7246102690696716,
-0.764140784740448,
0.8546985983848572,
0.5434966087341309,
0.15067827701568604,
-0.6431931853294373,
-0.38690871000289917,
-0.425211101770401,
-0.684664249420166,
0.7144753336906433,
0.23028796911239624,
0.08212637156248093,
-0.09955938905477524,
0.6821715235710144,
-0.003841075347736478,
0.083131805062294,
-0.8035796284675598,
-0.05616817623376846,
-0.20810291171073914,
0.12956739962100983,
0.04381638392806053,
-0.3646492660045624,
-0.37138867378234863,
0.08972980082035065,
0.470938503742218,
-0.30834752321243286,
0.24725675582885742,
0.42045068740844727,
-0.1964629739522934,
0.06532049179077148,
0.6757280826568604,
0.6519887447357178,
1.1533716917037964,
-0.30000391602516174,
0.15701895952224731,
0.5421918034553528,
-0.2237301766872406,
0.34531527757644653,
-0.13443145155906677,
-0.4251754581928253,
-0.2445247918367386,
0.5706256031990051,
0.6997162699699402,
0.28439992666244507,
-0.5670546889305115,
0.34184783697128296,
-0.4488755762577057,
0.2740502655506134,
-0.21083205938339233,
0.034486379474401474,
-0.03989845886826515,
0.3268277049064636,
0.5396721959114075,
-0.2586648464202881,
-0.10766618698835373,
-0.7008465528488159,
-0.06950315833091736,
0.4582841396331787,
-0.41901731491088867,
-0.3422754108905792,
0.7748739123344421,
-0.10374496877193451,
0.05087483301758766,
0.3364008665084839,
0.13888835906982422,
-0.6443229913711548,
0.7950823903083801,
0.3626770079135895,
0.6766152381896973,
-0.17818337678909302,
0.08619505912065506,
0.22535139322280884,
0.3077923655509949,
0.12785039842128754,
0.30815255641937256,
-0.2779766321182251,
-0.5713141560554504,
-0.33056700229644775,
-0.4752432405948639,
-0.6320924758911133,
0.20827530324459076,
-0.6977050304412842,
-0.39154428243637085,
-0.49404376745224,
-0.4410777986049652,
-0.572031557559967,
-0.03192739188671112,
-0.721567690372467,
0.4138445556163788,
-0.05131017789244652,
0.6418458223342896,
-0.6832213401794434,
0.5983865261077881,
0.8989966511726379,
0.04326249659061432,
-0.7799782156944275,
0.2441827654838562,
-0.18883216381072998,
-0.4743460416793823,
0.567314863204956,
-0.0555725134909153,
-0.12941381335258484,
-0.2938074469566345,
-0.5835932493209839,
-1.0805480480194092,
1.432055950164795,
0.34746912121772766,
-0.09945295751094818,
-0.03408558666706085,
-0.04177744314074516,
0.6048358082771301,
-0.1593547761440277,
0.23525038361549377,
0.3879549503326416,
0.15037626028060913,
-0.016689391806721687,
-0.7937952280044556,
0.1445745825767517,
-0.26033127307891846,
0.13211306929588318,
-0.0640709400177002,
-0.8491384983062744,
0.6456929445266724,
0.06969618052244186,
-0.6575748324394226,
0.17418324947357178,
0.5853130221366882,
0.2980674207210541,
0.5627710819244385,
0.301946759223938,
0.2709748446941376,
0.7235198616981506,
-0.5068755745887756,
1.265175223350525,
-0.34480956196784973,
-0.10670898854732513,
1.2448651790618896,
-0.14402924478054047,
0.7820302844047546,
0.5418044924736023,
-0.1663128286600113,
0.3470113277435303,
0.8854913711547852,
0.6598372459411621,
0.3214273452758789,
-0.3337666988372803,
-0.13354751467704773,
-0.5092419385910034,
-0.06884771585464478,
-0.7348939180374146,
0.21782396733760834,
0.24974654614925385,
0.10177081823348999,
-0.1682983636856079,
-0.2249354124069214,
0.0021387245506048203,
-0.2788470387458801,
-0.11800245195627213,
0.6701754331588745,
-0.01991787739098072,
-0.8415307998657227,
0.44626984000205994,
-0.10161212831735611,
0.31745874881744385,
-0.6476150751113892,
0.4343695044517517,
-0.6547874212265015,
-0.1614278256893158,
0.06206901744008064,
-0.6095269322395325,
0.34050631523132324,
-0.13022753596305847,
-0.33025887608528137,
-0.07157521694898605,
0.5043156147003174,
-0.0847342312335968,
-0.022290294989943504,
0.02431340329349041,
0.8299465179443359,
-0.25366318225860596,
-0.0748615488409996,
-0.2723737359046936,
-0.06242452934384346,
-0.46218109130859375,
-0.16902634501457214,
0.5147057175636292,
0.6836103200912476,
-0.18461686372756958,
0.826479971408844,
0.47358834743499756,
-0.17608539760112762,
0.16894835233688354,
-0.10934992134571075,
0.7080168724060059,
-0.7252928018569946,
-0.5186071991920471,
-0.4776875972747803,
0.2652168869972229,
-0.005624829791486263,
-0.3900179862976074,
0.7186135649681091,
0.24980725347995758,
0.6686946153640747,
0.24896089732646942,
0.5591678619384766,
0.15068042278289795,
0.40362119674682617,
-0.7632361054420471,
0.6434290409088135,
-0.6748491525650024,
0.5874001979827881,
0.06046001985669136,
-0.8127043843269348,
-0.1644350290298462,
0.020881976932287216,
-0.48907530307769775,
0.26804298162460327,
0.48268693685531616,
0.46090179681777954,
-0.000361865182640031,
0.02755117230117321,
0.32829907536506653,
0.013918861746788025,
0.3636833131313324,
0.8036328554153442,
1.2713743448257446,
-0.43173402547836304,
0.4268522262573242,
-0.13736414909362793,
0.1125466525554657,
-0.18927451968193054,
-0.8898956775665283,
-0.7801423668861389,
-0.6076712012290955,
-0.297650545835495,
-0.30707448720932007,
0.22506000101566315,
0.4976443946361542,
0.9232019782066345,
-0.8778359293937683,
0.1345040202140808,
0.4391147792339325,
0.2546480596065521,
-0.0993381217122078,
-0.2557578384876251,
0.47166237235069275,
-0.3818134665489197,
-0.6275401711463928,
0.5232453942298889,
0.2665196657180786,
0.32494667172431946,
0.07775196433067322,
0.20171205699443817,
-0.1263197809457779,
0.2438514232635498,
0.7776668667793274,
0.4721301794052124,
-0.6559084057807922,
-0.5075805187225342,
0.32717078924179077,
-0.3319963812828064,
0.09848915785551071,
0.8358676433563232,
-0.7581925988197327,
0.3154350519180298,
0.5052024126052856,
0.7303798198699951,
0.08807400614023209,
0.2817035913467407,
0.6265817880630493,
-0.837762176990509,
0.006429051049053669,
0.2096344232559204,
0.424777626991272,
0.3636748492717743,
-0.3980945348739624,
0.5411150455474854,
0.05657968670129776,
-0.6410130858421326,
-0.7682389616966248,
0.06356239318847656,
-0.8988041281700134,
-0.6430323123931885,
1.319456696510315,
-0.0011366507969796658,
-0.317261666059494,
-0.4755846858024597,
0.11155972629785538,
0.2363867312669754,
-0.20735009014606476,
0.9196885824203491,
0.9036691188812256,
0.03178558126091957,
0.020483022555708885,
-0.5641258358955383,
0.5009089708328247,
0.7372215986251831,
-0.7898117899894714,
-0.2440202236175537,
0.5303158760070801,
0.5252873301506042,
-0.062175799161195755,
0.6187154650688171,
-0.17771592736244202,
0.4710727334022522,
-0.2815745174884796,
-0.6381127238273621,
-0.01386191975325346,
-0.2556821405887604,
-0.6210299134254456,
0.5044148564338684,
0.08172643184661865,
0.18124695122241974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19537v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19537v1 | Handling Ontology Gaps in Semantic Parsing | 2024-06-27T21:21:22 | 2024-06-27T21:21:22 | Andrea Bacciu, Marco Damonte, Marco Basaldella, Emilio Monti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The majority of Neural Semantic Parsing (NSP) models are developed with the
assumption that there are no concepts outside the ones such models can
represent with their target symbols (closed-world assumption). This assumption
leads to generate hallucinated outputs rather than admitting their lack of
knowledge. Hallucinations can lead to wrong or potentially offensive responses
to users. Hence, a mechanism to prevent this behavior is crucial to build
trusted NSP-based Question Answering agents. To that end, we propose the
Hallucination Simulation Framework (HSF), a general setting for stimulating and
analyzing NSP model hallucinations. The framework can be applied to any NSP
task with a closed-ontology. Using the proposed framework and KQA Pro as the
benchmark dataset, we assess state-of-the-art techniques for hallucination
detection. We then present a novel hallucination detection strategy that
exploits the computational graph of the NSP model to detect the NSP
hallucinations in the presence of ontology gaps, out-of-domain utterances, and
to recognize NSP errors, improving the F1-Score respectively by ~21, ~24% and
~1%. This is the first work in closed-ontology NSP that addresses the problem
of recognizing ontology gaps. We release our code and checkpoints at
https://github.com/amazon-science/handling-ontology-gaps-in-semantic-parsing. | [
-0.6792635321617126,
-0.8325945734977722,
0.819351315498352,
0.26813507080078125,
0.10156046599149704,
-0.3402315080165863,
0.19074203073978424,
-0.5010288953781128,
0.16348575055599213,
0.8970275521278381,
-0.9241143465042114,
-0.5724153518676758,
-0.44294625520706177,
0.08461301773786545,
-0.30151593685150146,
0.3124617040157318,
0.3654007911682129,
-0.12566189467906952,
-0.4532672166824341,
0.12253326177597046,
-0.4440930187702179,
-0.5617892146110535,
-0.24866770207881927,
-0.4502924084663391,
0.1074814647436142,
0.28651490807533264,
0.8914583325386047,
0.6238604784011841,
0.46141698956489563,
0.2297656387090683,
-0.13979682326316833,
0.1190149262547493,
-0.23762746155261993,
0.364928275346756,
-0.219842329621315,
-0.008261731825768948,
-0.4354347288608551,
-0.35035714507102966,
0.3956579864025116,
0.8999469876289368,
-0.3406955897808075,
-0.33851757645606995,
-0.22812415659427643,
0.2579817771911621,
-0.5779581069946289,
0.19240866601467133,
-0.6340678930282593,
0.6345245838165283,
0.04020848870277405,
-0.4087323546409607,
-0.4554321765899658,
-0.09181298315525055,
0.10734885185956955,
-0.6587530374526978,
0.24653294682502747,
0.04521223157644272,
0.9811438918113708,
0.5704039335250854,
0.22882242500782013,
-0.275850385427475,
-0.3126417100429535,
0.6728078126907349,
-0.772493839263916,
0.6535176634788513,
0.6123033165931702,
0.3544480800628662,
-0.5473166108131409,
-0.796749472618103,
-0.6377018094062805,
-0.22680839896202087,
0.06855826079845428,
-0.07184529304504395,
-0.0017910250462591648,
0.10007935762405396,
0.397915244102478,
0.16105253994464874,
-0.7195746898651123,
-0.03055328130722046,
-0.0627770647406578,
-0.35731157660484314,
0.2811071574687958,
0.2880762219429016,
0.3211548328399658,
-0.565387487411499,
-0.36717116832733154,
-0.17680294811725616,
-0.32313272356987,
-0.39346519112586975,
0.25996577739715576,
0.36312052607536316,
0.3340018689632416,
0.4683104157447815,
-0.38446786999702454,
0.724726676940918,
-0.28492817282676697,
0.11047543585300446,
0.14636068046092987,
0.023410042747855186,
-0.29197898507118225,
0.2697778046131134,
0.26568469405174255,
0.32851752638816833,
0.13299338519573212,
-0.49577683210372925,
-0.058004360646009445,
0.45216506719589233,
0.6140708923339844,
-0.5672749876976013,
-0.30732104182243347,
0.527915894985199,
-0.30204591155052185,
-0.30597004294395447,
-0.10669627785682678,
-0.9415751099586487,
-0.5066043734550476,
-0.06598559767007828,
0.35133910179138184,
-0.5650994181632996,
-0.20620018243789673,
0.677021324634552,
-0.14425034821033478,
0.22168757021427155,
0.18436580896377563,
-0.6687490344047546,
0.754749596118927,
0.7828672528266907,
0.6510815620422363,
0.20575550198554993,
-0.4185437560081482,
-0.49269095063209534,
0.08348765224218369,
-0.17762117087841034,
1.1976449489593506,
-0.48196712136268616,
-0.09248173236846924,
-0.0916290283203125,
-0.068281389772892,
-0.10520771890878677,
-0.6759366393089294,
0.6519313454627991,
-0.5204355120658875,
-0.014941374771296978,
-0.45961517095565796,
-0.749649703502655,
-0.18234950304031372,
0.4926173686981201,
-0.4951915144920349,
0.9297208786010742,
0.1653125286102295,
-0.7126498222351074,
0.12870676815509796,
-0.5960234999656677,
0.11056364327669144,
0.13485705852508545,
-0.3126140236854553,
-0.14892850816249847,
-0.1026979386806488,
0.23938040435314178,
0.29148977994918823,
-0.17161723971366882,
0.22422613203525543,
-0.32482948899269104,
-0.30022889375686646,
0.18332946300506592,
0.11923374235630035,
0.701472818851471,
0.009181447327136993,
-0.3935059905052185,
0.033373817801475525,
-0.7852845191955566,
0.40593332052230835,
0.024447914212942123,
0.3087717592716217,
-0.31548210978507996,
-0.07720618695020676,
0.02462191879749298,
0.5020190477371216,
-0.45467641949653625,
-0.5332188010215759,
0.030200792476534843,
-0.7522453665733337,
0.2141999900341034,
0.6706386208534241,
0.04576436057686806,
0.06977914273738861,
-0.21275408565998077,
0.3548445999622345,
0.09138786792755127,
0.13469278812408447,
-0.16673266887664795,
-0.7009394764900208,
-0.7132866978645325,
0.1578078418970108,
0.2490559071302414,
0.35101383924484253,
-0.6049150824546814,
0.8723321557044983,
0.09521994739770889,
-0.1049116924405098,
-0.42730170488357544,
-0.2283819019794464,
0.34574493765830994,
0.7438152432441711,
0.5723597407341003,
-0.3434128165245056,
-0.5321184396743774,
-0.4164583384990692,
0.03436121717095375,
-0.2881142199039459,
0.00997693371027708,
0.16950924694538116,
0.4911990761756897,
-0.40672749280929565,
0.9766026139259338,
-0.761421799659729,
-0.7489117980003357,
0.02242761291563511,
0.05938732251524925,
-0.25035881996154785,
0.5567718744277954,
0.225950226187706,
-0.7668881416320801,
0.12602561712265015,
-0.2581450939178467,
-1.0619570016860962,
-0.42391473054885864,
-0.1095397099852562,
-0.3687012791633606,
0.09672999382019043,
0.5513551235198975,
-0.810093104839325,
0.6396394968032837,
0.22063851356506348,
-0.7447287440299988,
0.45078033208847046,
0.10988414287567139,
-0.0532086081802845,
-0.7122786045074463,
-0.18920829892158508,
-0.4678574800491333,
-0.12087216228246689,
-0.7199638485908508,
0.22834248840808868,
-0.20589467883110046,
-0.035715799778699875,
-0.4048658609390259,
0.3646179139614105,
-0.0999453142285347,
-0.3336696922779083,
-0.4273093640804291,
0.34706175327301025,
0.24542883038520813,
0.3912072777748108,
0.342965692281723,
0.12657973170280457,
0.44727304577827454,
-0.36818990111351013,
0.06456690281629562,
0.6897011399269104,
-0.11728929728269577,
0.1399901956319809,
-0.5190742015838623,
0.06680874526500702,
-0.12298008799552917,
-0.03959208354353905,
-0.7996065616607666,
-0.4176871180534363,
0.5942981243133545,
-0.5523232221603394,
-0.1827462613582611,
0.09095204621553421,
-0.5679137110710144,
-0.10497323423624039,
-0.038431599736213684,
0.21405665576457977,
0.4640895426273346,
-0.5630748271942139,
0.4427947998046875,
0.327583372592926,
0.27120572328567505,
-0.5682870149612427,
-0.5987345576286316,
0.15175136923789978,
0.09698685258626938,
-1.109978199005127,
0.55368572473526,
0.08827672153711319,
-0.22775407135486603,
0.18207278847694397,
-0.31547829508781433,
-0.11285383254289627,
0.2012898027896881,
0.4507087767124176,
-0.04428179934620857,
-0.40950247645378113,
0.17023658752441406,
0.1865571141242981,
-0.4119015336036682,
0.37137722969055176,
-0.40552255511283875,
0.9498282074928284,
-0.25351059436798096,
-0.5010148286819458,
-0.4281742572784424,
0.31544381380081177,
0.23085340857505798,
0.21605470776557922,
0.7453500628471375,
0.2933475375175476,
-0.9016804695129395,
-0.3893064856529236,
-0.4896292984485626,
-0.643144965171814,
-0.45025017857551575,
0.12876881659030914,
-0.38020390272140503,
-0.653640866279602,
0.5345345735549927,
0.026511242613196373,
-0.28924548625946045,
0.32655656337738037,
0.41773468255996704,
0.22981232404708862,
0.8243355751037598,
0.5702383518218994,
0.5435994863510132,
-0.25832146406173706,
-0.2227364182472229,
0.4268087148666382,
-0.6231293678283691,
-0.3771207332611084,
-0.5962258577346802,
0.2519248127937317,
-0.1435289829969406,
-0.6251735091209412,
0.08224660903215408,
0.2908861041069031,
0.07876764982938766,
0.1795678436756134,
-0.44895312190055847,
0.6116212606430054,
0.22870850563049316,
-0.1843220740556717,
0.32096460461616516,
0.059289220720529556,
-0.2025924026966095,
-0.24129293859004974,
-0.6699793934822083,
-0.5170302391052246,
0.3574713170528412,
0.31037092208862305,
0.5111531019210815,
-0.19821709394454956,
0.6457970142364502,
0.4352387487888336,
-0.33125805854797363,
-0.6724981665611267,
0.7173038125038147,
0.18542248010635376,
-0.31267496943473816,
-0.5355902910232544,
-0.435262531042099,
-0.5532140731811523,
0.6290066838264465,
-0.1500578671693802,
-0.8561649322509766,
0.42875444889068604,
0.09428583830595016,
-0.41045671701431274,
0.33247798681259155,
-0.2441280335187912,
1.1337599754333496,
0.31148871779441833,
-0.12211853265762329,
0.16968032717704773,
-0.8688493967056274,
0.41703084111213684,
0.008913200348615646,
-0.11658401042222977,
-0.4775574207305908,
0.3093319833278656,
0.5651416182518005,
-0.479047030210495,
0.7905645370483398,
-0.28350430727005005,
0.026833314448595047,
0.22391781210899353,
0.08701635897159576,
0.1288253366947174,
0.18922729790210724,
-0.10508282482624054,
0.41828176379203796,
0.03090573288500309,
-0.28816160559654236,
-0.6357701420783997,
0.6083297729492188,
-0.6050727367401123,
-0.44738948345184326,
-0.7543379664421082,
-0.6516925096511841,
-0.31828388571739197,
0.15450485050678253,
0.3141149580478668,
0.019327765330672264,
-0.10484064370393753,
-0.1319326013326645,
0.7198361754417419,
-0.35969027876853943,
0.07524765282869339,
0.18071480095386505,
-0.3639651834964752,
-0.0826643779873848,
0.5887693762779236,
0.06922399997711182,
0.11651799082756042,
-0.031072493642568588,
0.29380369186401367,
-0.30251654982566833,
-0.25429925322532654,
-0.39801040291786194,
0.19869132339954376,
-0.9662015438079834,
-0.2776886522769928,
-1.2560007572174072,
-0.5478860139846802,
-0.9306732416152954,
-0.13680782914161682,
-0.31839218735694885,
-0.6436641216278076,
-0.08938758075237274,
-0.07682254165410995,
0.24677066504955292,
0.24419516324996948,
-0.13707688450813293,
0.3089524209499359,
-0.7797179222106934,
0.5884549021720886,
0.0025575130712240934,
0.22610969841480255,
0.17431937158107758,
-0.394056111574173,
0.2293396294116974,
-0.14360103011131287,
-0.3273048996925354,
-0.7042281031608582,
0.5750918388366699,
-0.07101491093635559,
0.4484281539916992,
0.5350469350814819,
0.4030325710773468,
0.8811538815498352,
-0.3503990173339844,
0.5889574289321899,
0.0392754040658474,
-1.0922778844833374,
0.4888349175453186,
-0.05957069620490074,
0.15177825093269348,
0.4729023575782776,
0.36427733302116394,
-0.750978410243988,
-0.5514352321624756,
-0.6233192086219788,
-0.740125834941864,
0.8855545520782471,
0.5622639656066895,
-0.10800229012966156,
-0.11054912209510803,
0.3808879256248474,
0.1595071703195572,
0.14781250059604645,
-0.6486555337905884,
0.08856584876775742,
-0.40829798579216003,
0.028093282133340836,
0.42549028992652893,
-0.22370655834674835,
-0.08220335841178894,
-0.036672838032245636,
0.4527030289173126,
-0.16620884835720062,
0.15293611586093903,
0.2742350101470947,
-0.0943007841706276,
-0.20445024967193604,
0.07345345616340637,
0.37644559144973755,
0.7108942866325378,
-0.4025956690311432,
0.2760932743549347,
-0.10131420195102692,
-0.5152053833007812,
-0.03590238839387894,
0.026495371013879776,
-0.22513876855373383,
0.05855323374271393,
0.2722955048084259,
0.49911364912986755,
-0.015651259571313858,
-1.037514090538025,
0.3741379380226135,
-0.1419658660888672,
-0.20193660259246826,
-0.38760071992874146,
0.1260494440793991,
-0.0753893330693245,
0.30804795026779175,
-0.08958379179239273,
0.12001537531614304,
0.43198704719543457,
-0.35365331172943115,
0.5580077171325684,
-0.01419043354690075,
-0.5505551099777222,
-0.25030940771102905,
0.5391601324081421,
-0.35473117232322693,
-0.30324503779411316,
0.9205257296562195,
-0.2391553670167923,
-0.7121434211730957,
0.7299172878265381,
0.7481392025947571,
0.8992792367935181,
-0.16731663048267365,
0.41093993186950684,
-0.07457112520933151,
0.4080658257007599,
-0.13701733946800232,
0.5298871994018555,
-0.05690005049109459,
-0.9162310361862183,
-0.07117623090744019,
-0.9632967114448547,
-0.4840835630893707,
0.03554796054959297,
-0.7209193706512451,
0.2246183604001999,
-0.3150661289691925,
-0.07506931573152542,
0.21168024837970734,
-0.38024455308914185,
0.023012489080429077,
0.22368723154067993,
0.16425587236881256,
0.7470399141311646,
-0.9977921843528748,
0.7096423506736755,
0.32455405592918396,
-0.33935508131980896,
-0.302239328622818,
0.3719492554664612,
-0.05152957886457443,
-0.5266454219818115,
0.49657562375068665,
0.4538971185684204,
-0.18205545842647552,
-0.24482104182243347,
-0.22642844915390015,
-0.6614747643470764,
0.615073561668396,
0.20341481268405914,
0.007839247584342957,
-0.24274170398712158,
0.5700276494026184,
0.5754558444023132,
-0.3486608564853668,
-0.29060599207878113,
0.7076981663703918,
0.4934134781360626,
0.24429140985012054,
-0.2127818614244461,
0.28352826833724976,
-0.10401709377765656,
0.08748343586921692,
0.2221660166978836,
-0.22001519799232483,
0.8574655055999756,
-0.11099989712238312,
-0.08931607007980347,
0.29132920503616333,
0.550106406211853,
0.5574421286582947,
0.7361273765563965,
0.5847265720367432,
0.853422224521637,
0.725554347038269,
-0.12620480358600616,
0.7404851317405701,
-0.09468982368707657,
0.2177029699087143,
1.0803859233856201,
-0.7362985014915466,
0.6942756772041321,
0.6013866662979126,
0.35653430223464966,
0.2608547806739807,
0.5423021912574768,
-0.156276673078537,
0.6444486975669861,
0.3253442347049713,
0.047364622354507446,
-0.490065336227417,
-0.4099576771259308,
-0.5549231171607971,
0.44137898087501526,
0.5474759936332703,
-0.05618029460310936,
-0.4677368998527527,
0.27696287631988525,
-0.14520807564258575,
0.18613307178020477,
0.09724118560552597,
0.6344200968742371,
0.23204894363880157,
-0.4440326988697052,
0.6464092135429382,
0.12203016877174377,
0.062363401055336,
-0.45811396837234497,
-0.41899508237838745,
-0.14379090070724487,
0.15949803590774536,
-0.3110290467739105,
-0.5132836699485779,
0.7943277955055237,
-0.2257612645626068,
-0.16897733509540558,
-0.05688402056694031,
0.8682520389556885,
-0.06672531366348267,
-0.2641622722148895,
0.8562865257263184,
0.3425195813179016,
0.45854058861732483,
-0.33495885133743286,
-0.48787257075309753,
0.28627264499664307,
-0.28200286626815796,
-0.015249921940267086,
0.24957327544689178,
0.44318386912345886,
-0.17426510155200958,
0.46495407819747925,
0.5287754535675049,
-0.19890610873699188,
0.3080313801765442,
0.28145018219947815,
1.0673669576644897,
-0.808605968952179,
-0.7499193549156189,
-0.5661388635635376,
0.14212891459465027,
-0.2024673968553543,
-0.3548668920993805,
0.649761974811554,
0.27504220604896545,
0.9002013802528381,
-0.08464663475751877,
0.43264877796173096,
-0.031570032238960266,
0.3447548449039459,
-0.7256550788879395,
0.753510594367981,
-0.6661300659179688,
0.45525339245796204,
-0.43400391936302185,
-0.9168695211410522,
-0.6919988393783569,
0.81205153465271,
-0.029116448014974594,
-0.15281790494918823,
0.8051595091819763,
1.0027618408203125,
-0.056896042078733444,
0.5350567102432251,
0.7085531949996948,
0.26184138655662537,
-0.031517092138528824,
0.36394205689430237,
1.1499383449554443,
-0.5245981812477112,
0.3292137682437897,
-0.5191502571105957,
0.012919163331389427,
-0.20612302422523499,
-0.6265819072723389,
-0.8959566950798035,
-0.3956500291824341,
-0.3097493648529053,
-0.7979366183280945,
0.25125643610954285,
0.708774983882904,
0.6454430222511292,
-0.8330506682395935,
-0.19969430565834045,
-0.29721173644065857,
0.081600621342659,
-0.3064131736755371,
-0.255591481924057,
0.3645145297050476,
-0.5787294507026672,
-0.2624140977859497,
0.3205517530441284,
0.5273844599723816,
-0.058991942554712296,
-0.20377947390079498,
-0.11379373073577881,
-0.19713595509529114,
0.23668034374713898,
0.4821328818798065,
0.12835192680358887,
-0.9327778816223145,
-0.136800616979599,
0.3588870167732239,
0.09976920485496521,
0.21617498993873596,
0.7290102243423462,
-0.7778903245925903,
0.308975487947464,
0.4955666959285736,
0.8724148869514465,
0.26969024538993835,
-0.02957022376358509,
0.1615075320005417,
-0.6025184392929077,
0.2050614207983017,
0.5220358371734619,
0.10717979818582535,
0.15918581187725067,
-0.5545222759246826,
0.5714396834373474,
0.408012330532074,
-0.41179388761520386,
-1.231116771697998,
0.18782493472099304,
-0.9932460188865662,
-0.6031391024589539,
0.7517998218536377,
-0.11259858310222626,
-0.3613024353981018,
-0.4811376631259918,
0.049210868775844574,
-0.1094178780913353,
-0.056422531604766846,
1.226861834526062,
0.5957902073860168,
-0.33437007665634155,
0.13413675129413605,
-0.4125596284866333,
0.5712827444076538,
0.5640685558319092,
-1.0516371726989746,
0.22372989356517792,
0.5422486066818237,
-0.2362177073955536,
0.4611167013645172,
0.6380055546760559,
-0.1521536111831665,
0.4658394157886505,
0.37860822677612305,
0.1162964254617691,
0.12550927698612213,
-0.7800161838531494,
-0.3393529951572418,
0.4881855547428131,
-0.3175853192806244,
-0.002582525834441185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19526v1 | TocBERT: Medical Document Structure Extraction Using Bidirectional Transformers | 2024-06-27T20:56:57 | 2024-06-27T20:56:57 | Majd Saleh, Sarra Baghdadi, Stéphane Paquelet | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Text segmentation holds paramount importance in the field of Natural Language
Processing (NLP). It plays an important role in several NLP downstream tasks
like information retrieval and document summarization. In this work, we propose
a new solution, namely TocBERT, for segmenting texts using bidirectional
transformers. TocBERT represents a supervised solution trained on the detection
of titles and sub-titles from their semantic representations. This task was
formulated as a named entity recognition (NER) problem. The solution has been
applied on a medical text segmentation use-case where the Bio-ClinicalBERT
model is fine-tuned to segment discharge summaries of the MIMIC-III dataset.
The performance of TocBERT has been evaluated on a human-labeled ground truth
corpus of 250 notes. It achieved an F1-score of 84.6% when evaluated on a
linear text segmentation problem and 72.8% on a hierarchical text segmentation
problem. It outperformed a carefully designed rule-based solution, particularly
in distinguishing titles from subtitles. | [
-0.07362577319145203,
-0.5628584027290344,
0.6487780213356018,
0.3003484606742859,
-0.6077564358711243,
0.12144608795642853,
-0.3018249571323395,
-0.21785806119441986,
0.17250581085681915,
0.6556328535079956,
-0.4067919850349426,
-0.8650436997413635,
-0.7842131853103638,
0.3149755299091339,
-0.7170380353927612,
1.269876480102539,
-0.052676666527986526,
0.03531772270798683,
-0.4640040993690491,
-0.029218677431344986,
-0.48743724822998047,
-0.2459835708141327,
-0.4245971441268921,
-0.21722723543643951,
0.4903891384601593,
0.6616103053092957,
0.45608922839164734,
0.7822712063789368,
0.9079157710075378,
0.35039934515953064,
-0.2152995616197586,
0.038682326674461365,
-0.049284934997558594,
0.3096604645252228,
-0.3435407280921936,
-0.45007532835006714,
-0.3312458395957947,
-0.24750074744224548,
0.8846450448036194,
0.6401430368423462,
-0.17745448648929596,
-0.14188049733638763,
-0.20796161890029907,
0.7078993320465088,
-0.16980189085006714,
-0.0357772521674633,
-0.2783040702342987,
0.015531172044575214,
-0.39420512318611145,
-0.39609310030937195,
-0.5945780873298645,
-0.22843167185783386,
0.11995017528533936,
-0.33166539669036865,
0.6068829894065857,
0.14553792774677277,
1.2979514598846436,
0.5560877323150635,
-0.42375773191452026,
-0.5444759726524353,
-0.4388926029205322,
0.6669175028800964,
-0.5140414237976074,
0.6144283413887024,
0.0328008234500885,
0.38665077090263367,
-0.0038810332771390676,
-0.9740802049636841,
-0.3729041516780853,
-0.11369460076093674,
-0.21063028275966644,
0.37891387939453125,
-0.07395970821380615,
0.1562381237745285,
0.12165649980306625,
0.4841287434101105,
-0.5248945355415344,
0.19331371784210205,
-0.6119661927223206,
-0.272384911775589,
0.46935081481933594,
-0.050827477127313614,
0.45556628704071045,
-0.7292905449867249,
-0.609821081161499,
-0.1476355493068695,
-0.12136078625917435,
-0.002981598721817136,
0.1302112340927124,
0.05730932950973511,
-0.03224252164363861,
0.7048776745796204,
0.043326299637556076,
0.33339351415634155,
0.4642995297908783,
-0.6728681325912476,
0.2572827637195587,
0.14345574378967285,
-0.39232170581817627,
0.6931531429290771,
0.6027172207832336,
0.20507952570915222,
0.02396264486014843,
-0.288453608751297,
-0.04171568527817726,
-0.09787534922361374,
0.5703122615814209,
-0.9099560976028442,
-0.28108280897140503,
0.27741676568984985,
-0.7690285444259644,
-0.478661447763443,
0.04002626985311508,
-0.8446817994117737,
-0.16245661675930023,
-0.21338781714439392,
0.0003093584382440895,
-0.48354053497314453,
0.1254165768623352,
0.07080259174108505,
-0.22407029569149017,
0.40425845980644226,
0.36907443404197693,
-0.7823372483253479,
0.4360465705394745,
0.6990026831626892,
0.7470227479934692,
-0.7526952028274536,
0.18249544501304626,
-0.24482426047325134,
0.2733534872531891,
-0.11183545738458633,
1.3345494270324707,
-0.26381176710128784,
-0.6887738704681396,
-0.32229724526405334,
0.3966677486896515,
-0.0931091234087944,
-0.7873437404632568,
0.8970128297805786,
-0.41722893714904785,
0.5626894235610962,
0.06426462531089783,
-0.3465762734413147,
-0.2941037714481354,
0.48864179849624634,
-0.7502277493476868,
0.8625645041465759,
0.2636535167694092,
-0.9702864289283752,
0.15457163751125336,
-0.5421724319458008,
-1.0435973405838013,
0.04403812810778618,
-0.15374501049518585,
-0.8472429513931274,
0.14867138862609863,
0.5216748714447021,
0.20823653042316437,
-0.6416856050491333,
0.309582382440567,
0.2772049009799957,
0.1222112849354744,
-0.007246195804327726,
-0.5304999947547913,
0.9444511532783508,
-0.1507188379764557,
-0.2855650782585144,
0.25929713249206543,
-0.8619111180305481,
-0.20393291115760803,
0.1784369796514511,
-0.3846967816352844,
-0.5513780117034912,
0.03624529391527176,
0.25312602519989014,
0.09970532357692719,
0.004241799935698509,
-0.5845006704330444,
0.15827494859695435,
-0.4257805645465851,
-0.07179062068462372,
0.5362565517425537,
0.359365850687027,
0.5388426780700684,
-0.1987854689359665,
0.5460096597671509,
0.16247081756591797,
0.14189757406711578,
-0.00420637521892786,
-0.27778375148773193,
-0.7361292839050293,
-0.8414952754974365,
0.5225938558578491,
0.5095170736312866,
-0.7431116104125977,
0.34328892827033997,
-0.18581099808216095,
-0.3905276954174042,
-0.26174914836883545,
-0.24457189440727234,
0.3048478960990906,
1.2350398302078247,
0.8142492175102234,
-0.3898216784000397,
-0.44079044461250305,
-1.1021405458450317,
0.04425167664885521,
-0.28954559564590454,
-0.05505124107003212,
0.2476121187210083,
0.32000732421875,
-0.5055230259895325,
0.9794108271598816,
-0.8321019411087036,
-0.598601758480072,
-0.3138444125652313,
0.12330445647239685,
0.16771307587623596,
0.34260526299476624,
0.4015777111053467,
-1.0454304218292236,
-0.41041675209999084,
0.015340573154389858,
-0.6354780793190002,
-0.4066317677497864,
-0.2203069031238556,
-0.2549790143966675,
0.015180892311036587,
0.6189244985580444,
-0.3958086371421814,
0.32908710837364197,
0.38987892866134644,
0.034482888877391815,
0.5609907507896423,
-0.259435772895813,
-0.06869661808013916,
-1.5204066038131714,
0.23594088852405548,
-0.1414903700351715,
-0.3457663953304291,
-0.5248586535453796,
-0.1870017945766449,
0.44780614972114563,
-0.03458317369222641,
-0.39474061131477356,
0.3444134294986725,
-0.6164363026618958,
0.06921541690826416,
-0.22616906464099884,
0.17793652415275574,
0.06048120930790901,
0.34661349654197693,
0.3234151303768158,
0.3879701793193817,
0.2776206433773041,
-0.528262197971344,
0.3523973822593689,
0.774891197681427,
-0.09347822517156601,
0.8846697807312012,
-0.7070177793502808,
0.027421703562140465,
-0.3211163580417633,
0.1570659726858139,
-0.9824768304824829,
-0.11929509788751602,
0.2302996963262558,
-0.4161767363548279,
0.7256842851638794,
-0.08271796256303787,
-0.3435318171977997,
-0.24962171912193298,
-0.15984567999839783,
0.4982610046863556,
0.13353948295116425,
-0.5178972482681274,
0.5646882653236389,
0.5815747380256653,
-0.374315083026886,
-0.4656469523906708,
-0.38588863611221313,
0.037718530744314194,
-0.04444967582821846,
-0.5228440165519714,
0.8581965565681458,
0.27450793981552124,
-0.012022405862808228,
-0.04352385550737381,
-0.4626781642436981,
-0.38213491439819336,
-0.1518460214138031,
0.44725167751312256,
0.5154873132705688,
-0.11517997831106186,
0.15369825065135956,
0.7425144910812378,
-0.4661225378513336,
0.17849275469779968,
-0.12882067263126373,
0.3514324128627777,
0.2755867540836334,
-0.2877270579338074,
-0.30346736311912537,
0.29818621277809143,
0.5490905046463013,
-0.4538518786430359,
0.303152471780777,
0.3872615396976471,
-0.5051155090332031,
-0.15446536242961884,
-0.48062989115715027,
-0.04469730705022812,
-0.4290503263473511,
0.528788685798645,
0.0793873518705368,
-0.5356895327568054,
0.15986166894435883,
-0.3162887990474701,
0.002911052666604519,
0.7313246726989746,
0.687487781047821,
-0.30201834440231323,
0.7038121819496155,
0.6318660378456116,
-0.04568595439195633,
0.31422433257102966,
0.02177727222442627,
0.12990671396255493,
-0.9892407655715942,
-0.5942285060882568,
-0.726000189781189,
-0.36043739318847656,
-0.4074725806713104,
-0.5139150023460388,
0.4808284342288971,
-0.17987404763698578,
0.456788569688797,
0.5013011693954468,
-0.761756420135498,
0.15644514560699463,
0.1650981456041336,
0.237178236246109,
0.4835667908191681,
0.07719090580940247,
-0.3762320280075073,
0.08311674743890762,
-0.16730843484401703,
-0.346249520778656,
0.718113899230957,
0.3166540861129761,
0.5366283059120178,
-0.1662360578775406,
0.8028411865234375,
0.20276330411434174,
0.675143837928772,
-1.1198134422302246,
0.6156378388404846,
-0.268614262342453,
-0.7863260507583618,
-0.3312400281429291,
-0.19896464049816132,
-1.0295637845993042,
0.0979921743273735,
-0.041632164269685745,
-0.33662205934524536,
0.21050725877285004,
-0.5034927129745483,
-0.16217759251594543,
-0.02388126589357853,
-0.35505542159080505,
0.7217373251914978,
-0.27069324254989624,
-0.04643874987959862,
-0.03540889918804169,
-0.8917010426521301,
0.07772384583950043,
-0.18490780889987946,
-0.011176490224897861,
-0.028022950515151024,
0.1044023334980011,
0.9497522115707397,
-0.5948679447174072,
0.25955501198768616,
-0.06131615489721298,
-0.1800372451543808,
0.18516306579113007,
-0.2535195052623749,
0.23660798370838165,
0.1974928379058838,
0.19534911215305328,
0.23641881346702576,
0.07184101641178131,
-0.09703885018825531,
-0.3096323013305664,
0.26614508032798767,
-0.36299511790275574,
-0.6306401491165161,
-0.5687819123268127,
-0.4539770483970642,
-0.020484168082475662,
0.6369666457176208,
0.4132160544395447,
0.4971027076244354,
-0.17276033759117126,
0.4063746929168701,
0.48844000697135925,
-0.40599703788757324,
0.4638010263442993,
0.4135092794895172,
0.015035683289170265,
-0.5695507526397705,
0.40395021438598633,
-0.27753278613090515,
-0.07020677626132965,
1.0037834644317627,
0.14111554622650146,
-0.42868974804878235,
-0.5958574414253235,
-0.4368673861026764,
0.5088081359863281,
-0.5427940487861633,
-0.46077242493629456,
-0.7521151304244995,
-0.4250754714012146,
-0.32163551449775696,
-0.2208482325077057,
-0.41611555218696594,
-0.3652816712856293,
-0.4118722975254059,
-0.06729352474212646,
-0.06827780604362488,
0.05588407814502716,
0.19989287853240967,
0.23845531046390533,
-0.8438571691513062,
0.8195605874061584,
0.12675228714942932,
-0.15619367361068726,
-0.3918285071849823,
-0.5742663145065308,
-0.051568057388067245,
-0.5219977498054504,
-0.4377307593822479,
-1.147523045539856,
0.5922600030899048,
-0.15287257730960846,
0.5566892027854919,
0.6034321784973145,
0.23809781670570374,
0.8524567484855652,
-0.7103117108345032,
0.24214017391204834,
0.29056844115257263,
-0.7547191977500916,
0.5009049773216248,
-0.03496771305799484,
0.11228492110967636,
0.7158731818199158,
0.29215341806411743,
-0.6466478109359741,
-0.2409631609916687,
-0.3860168159008026,
-0.8054071068763733,
0.6684540510177612,
0.22869448363780975,
-0.3285251557826996,
-0.009043781086802483,
0.2731165885925293,
0.14139015972614288,
0.1494709849357605,
-0.4277571439743042,
-0.2599963843822479,
0.0837438702583313,
-0.5980914831161499,
0.18996866047382355,
-0.3080468773841858,
0.07119050621986389,
-0.22495275735855103,
0.5143290758132935,
0.027536798268556595,
0.41815638542175293,
0.6921080350875854,
-0.4235437512397766,
-0.030627479776740074,
0.4457080066204071,
0.44007280468940735,
0.21886183321475983,
-0.1545417308807373,
0.09875773638486862,
0.00806789007037878,
-0.9436606168746948,
0.03964455425739288,
0.6058105230331421,
-0.13782687485218048,
0.27460432052612305,
0.37744641304016113,
0.17026692628860474,
0.2053585946559906,
-0.6041803359985352,
0.650697648525238,
-0.159844309091568,
-0.3521786630153656,
-0.15976357460021973,
-0.37487369775772095,
-0.05226104333996773,
0.4281744062900543,
0.2736278474330902,
0.133216992020607,
0.5134617686271667,
-0.36806192994117737,
0.3310251832008362,
0.3366599678993225,
-0.7286459803581238,
-0.24716736376285553,
0.6576177477836609,
0.01584845781326294,
-0.31309282779693604,
0.9604960083961487,
0.18594934046268463,
-0.7606276869773865,
0.66013103723526,
0.6469205021858215,
1.0549629926681519,
-0.35300567746162415,
0.32566317915916443,
0.0403515100479126,
0.19381199777126312,
-0.017846524715423584,
-0.07016728818416595,
-0.3057691156864166,
-0.44974470138549805,
-0.2444918304681778,
-0.8132746815681458,
-0.45949479937553406,
-0.3882276117801666,
-0.7729040384292603,
0.5814797282218933,
-0.3322516083717346,
-0.012128578498959541,
0.2599157989025116,
-0.09367964416742325,
-0.21222861111164093,
0.5124709606170654,
0.1006171852350235,
0.6683708429336548,
-0.4533715844154358,
0.9895704388618469,
0.7653602361679077,
-0.22055891156196594,
-0.7149168252944946,
0.18055425584316254,
-0.20002105832099915,
-0.5744894742965698,
0.6300321817398071,
0.35419532656669617,
0.14342249929904938,
-0.05314021557569504,
-0.17908774316310883,
-0.49701356887817383,
1.075107216835022,
0.09641502052545547,
-0.4618247151374817,
-0.6630198955535889,
0.26017874479293823,
0.6769269108772278,
0.07042650878429413,
0.24334362149238586,
0.4485691487789154,
0.4966360330581665,
0.08939460664987564,
-0.8634573817253113,
0.14360785484313965,
-0.2176865041255951,
-0.2959645390510559,
0.42407849431037903,
-0.48547202348709106,
0.6954596638679504,
-0.21032817661762238,
-0.33302509784698486,
-0.013658756390213966,
0.5558426976203918,
0.20116902887821198,
0.5303822159767151,
0.5641428828239441,
0.3220491409301758,
0.6694225072860718,
-0.05845283716917038,
0.7485541105270386,
-0.09543129801750183,
0.5084391236305237,
0.8000750541687012,
-0.1843836009502411,
0.4953908920288086,
0.6000406742095947,
0.02239076793193817,
0.957950234413147,
0.3548237979412079,
-0.12456891685724258,
0.6717613935470581,
-0.03254498541355133,
0.0011482569389045238,
0.047097716480493546,
-0.04283999279141426,
-0.2545351982116699,
0.635960578918457,
0.32269570231437683,
-0.6106067299842834,
-0.3655078709125519,
0.04482943192124367,
0.19991540908813477,
-0.032795000821352005,
-0.2711227238178253,
0.7985528707504272,
0.18809819221496582,
-0.593192994594574,
0.2522510886192322,
0.3793402910232544,
0.22060754895210266,
-0.5185889005661011,
0.02627759613096714,
-0.05669339373707771,
0.41821008920669556,
-0.32367879152297974,
-0.40566614270210266,
0.4545873999595642,
-0.026600871235132217,
-0.33083218336105347,
-0.32089775800704956,
0.9576777219772339,
-0.33128905296325684,
-0.6187149882316589,
0.1692432165145874,
0.08309640735387802,
0.02626453898847103,
-0.2642073631286621,
-0.41804149746894836,
-0.34549596905708313,
0.048839591443538666,
-0.024277135729789734,
0.04240969568490982,
0.5116226673126221,
-0.19639058411121368,
0.23364706337451935,
0.6768211722373962,
-0.043227680027484894,
-0.20498739182949066,
-0.17811231315135956,
0.9673598408699036,
-0.7860193252563477,
-0.6780566573143005,
-0.8722187280654907,
0.41567060351371765,
-0.28926217555999756,
-0.22480882704257965,
0.6570534706115723,
1.019810438156128,
0.48700234293937683,
-0.09440930932760239,
0.4193304777145386,
0.027245962992310524,
0.7069181203842163,
-0.2637791037559509,
0.8022369742393494,
-0.6731659173965454,
-0.09055320173501968,
-0.5882132649421692,
-0.959235668182373,
-0.6012256145477295,
0.4908822774887085,
-0.22234424948692322,
-0.4024432897567749,
1.2642147541046143,
0.5357534885406494,
-0.017505506053566933,
-0.07571932673454285,
0.09020063281059265,
0.0410146489739418,
0.45779168605804443,
0.3080206513404846,
0.3684063255786896,
-0.49487408995628357,
0.692935585975647,
-0.3674986958503723,
-0.23005719482898712,
-0.4570946991443634,
-0.5960640907287598,
-0.9667469263076782,
-0.48351964354515076,
-0.32764628529548645,
-0.28722813725471497,
-0.06622976064682007,
0.6984468698501587,
0.5173680186271667,
-0.8139179348945618,
0.019741240888834,
0.02165101282298565,
0.3678034543991089,
-0.13655416667461395,
-0.24035121500492096,
0.8532035946846008,
-0.19643419981002808,
-0.7906065583229065,
0.3930206000804901,
0.7729696035385132,
-0.24112798273563385,
0.3204253613948822,
0.16036997735500336,
-0.19011519849300385,
-0.12330587208271027,
0.567687451839447,
0.23001132905483246,
-0.3364332318305969,
-0.0916762426495552,
0.22878827154636383,
-0.2872397005558014,
0.4018827974796295,
0.806230366230011,
-0.5809013843536377,
0.4211418330669403,
0.5149179100990295,
0.604120671749115,
0.6799627542495728,
0.4012451469898224,
0.17300952970981598,
-0.647079586982727,
0.10873465985059738,
0.41080665588378906,
0.25322964787483215,
0.3355906009674072,
-0.29297181963920593,
0.21417994797229767,
0.4746702313423157,
-0.43400612473487854,
-0.7672430276870728,
-0.12858077883720398,
-1.53792405128479,
-0.2302463948726654,
1.2103501558303833,
0.318127304315567,
-0.4705350995063782,
-0.2291744500398636,
-0.717421293258667,
0.7660424113273621,
-0.32436704635620117,
0.6531035900115967,
0.26629844307899475,
0.04741836339235306,
-0.2083999216556549,
-0.20897647738456726,
0.20560289919376373,
0.22327320277690887,
-1.130710482597351,
-0.32756751775741577,
0.26470690965652466,
0.3652907907962799,
0.41781342029571533,
0.3880169987678528,
-0.6302246451377869,
0.16124816238880157,
-0.28985512256622314,
0.24381166696548462,
-0.08798155188560486,
-0.4377692937850952,
0.012751270085573196,
0.4048299491405487,
-0.3538096249103546,
-0.42620182037353516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19512v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19512v1 | Captioning Visualizations with Large Language Models (CVLLM): A Tutorial | 2024-06-27T20:18:18 | 2024-06-27T20:18:18 | Giuseppe Carenini, Jordon Johnson, Ali Salamatian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Automatically captioning visualizations is not new, but recent advances in
large language models(LLMs) open exciting new possibilities. In this tutorial,
after providing a brief review of Information Visualization (InfoVis)
principles and past work in captioning, we introduce neural models and the
transformer architecture used in generic LLMs. We then discuss their recent
applications in InfoVis, with a focus on captioning. Additionally, we explore
promising future directions in this field. | [
-0.24504628777503967,
-0.4558205008506775,
0.5111764669418335,
0.25439751148223877,
-0.16891354322433472,
0.23559416830539703,
-0.15629814565181732,
-0.12683707475662231,
0.11960713565349579,
0.8239210247993469,
-0.5840089321136475,
-0.689769446849823,
-0.557650625705719,
-0.18595615029335022,
-0.721842885017395,
0.9150964021682739,
-0.1604415327310562,
0.5798854231834412,
-0.6649962663650513,
-0.00940132886171341,
-0.5692998766899109,
-0.5788688063621521,
-0.6854757070541382,
-0.18405863642692566,
0.5441529154777527,
0.6192167401313782,
0.5233411192893982,
0.7978806495666504,
0.6373541355133057,
0.3241448998451233,
0.14027002453804016,
-0.015836969017982483,
-0.42687761783599854,
0.19362708926200867,
0.16939513385295868,
-0.8703833818435669,
0.04810936003923416,
-0.08264902234077454,
0.7011073231697083,
0.8835732340812683,
0.1650538295507431,
0.10529085993766785,
-0.2603730261325836,
0.7247351408004761,
-0.09143844991922379,
0.8177942037582397,
-0.36376315355300903,
0.1265176385641098,
0.059554312378168106,
-0.5941492915153503,
-0.6089526414871216,
-0.6423417329788208,
0.49656760692596436,
-0.5135715007781982,
0.15840445458889008,
0.7460523247718811,
0.6185895204544067,
0.3031292259693146,
-0.42161867022514343,
-0.07644712924957275,
-0.9194890260696411,
0.7945663332939148,
-0.4598716199398041,
0.27044156193733215,
-0.1284819096326828,
0.9325106739997864,
0.19792737066745758,
-1.1724302768707275,
-0.40514907240867615,
-0.45274877548217773,
0.011286507360637188,
0.07635528594255447,
-0.479730486869812,
0.023269513621926308,
0.3708592355251312,
0.325821191072464,
-0.48964622616767883,
0.337600976228714,
-0.6921738982200623,
-0.0185257401317358,
0.44364944100379944,
0.49987170100212097,
0.5733867287635803,
-0.01210635993629694,
-0.6832220554351807,
-0.11932506412267685,
-0.9783909916877747,
-0.3116389811038971,
0.1912137120962143,
0.19662420451641083,
-0.35418206453323364,
0.7584004998207092,
0.1692183017730713,
0.9805760979652405,
-0.3463156223297119,
0.15458717942237854,
-0.1087850034236908,
-0.09723308682441711,
-0.37965819239616394,
0.10475631803274155,
0.6562241911888123,
0.5762927532196045,
0.5986701846122742,
-0.3223361372947693,
0.07168986648321152,
-0.41909751296043396,
0.27170246839523315,
-0.6580259203910828,
-0.45827624201774597,
0.20207540690898895,
-0.7393593788146973,
-0.3878409266471863,
0.16997116804122925,
-0.7598562836647034,
-0.8762471675872803,
-0.8246347308158875,
0.37017834186553955,
-0.22097080945968628,
-0.14126117527484894,
0.03319736570119858,
-0.2694356441497803,
0.6083346009254456,
0.35356757044792175,
-0.7987638711929321,
0.5497543811798096,
0.36377209424972534,
0.7747941613197327,
-0.5963954329490662,
-0.32354506850242615,
-0.4564342796802521,
0.08396845310926437,
-0.3890031576156616,
0.7489256262779236,
-0.14108909666538239,
-0.038377050310373306,
0.32614195346832275,
0.225445955991745,
0.05876559019088745,
-0.4673338532447815,
0.05094614997506142,
-0.7423704862594604,
0.14457343518733978,
-0.11045826226472855,
-0.6930936574935913,
-0.6331316828727722,
0.16829244792461395,
-0.9864445328712463,
0.2724238634109497,
0.11665746569633484,
-0.7560866475105286,
-0.07179681211709976,
-1.1116303205490112,
-0.39373406767845154,
0.13914071023464203,
-0.20515675842761993,
-0.17296960949897766,
0.05665984004735947,
-0.02171633578836918,
0.5891603231430054,
-0.453509658575058,
0.2661847174167633,
0.28945857286453247,
-0.3180563151836395,
0.45128580927848816,
-0.477883905172348,
0.6661074757575989,
0.19854091107845306,
-0.1439996361732483,
0.6492097973823547,
-0.6693300604820251,
-0.3061142861843109,
0.33439260721206665,
-0.028105562552809715,
-0.05273713171482086,
0.3432579040527344,
0.3862403631210327,
-0.13093963265419006,
0.31937798857688904,
-0.11726725846529007,
0.4293384552001953,
-0.28618136048316956,
0.8523687720298767,
0.5406336188316345,
-0.20745263993740082,
0.7406502962112427,
-0.07808735221624374,
0.7330727577209473,
0.2146887630224228,
0.39809882640838623,
-0.6773878335952759,
-0.41989415884017944,
-1.076622486114502,
-0.07377292215824127,
0.2928531765937805,
0.559893786907196,
-1.0145323276519775,
0.04264966398477554,
-0.3720427453517914,
-0.40138307213783264,
-0.2913239002227783,
-0.034053776413202286,
-0.1212414875626564,
0.40533676743507385,
0.34312334656715393,
0.16092433035373688,
-0.6791926026344299,
-1.1884182691574097,
0.03871483355760574,
-0.0048307511024177074,
0.19441013038158417,
0.03648070991039276,
0.1347244530916214,
-0.18660981953144073,
0.7942642569541931,
-0.6372106075286865,
-0.21690385043621063,
-0.6617037057876587,
0.2988514304161072,
0.3900989294052124,
0.25093019008636475,
0.6243860721588135,
-1.0147172212600708,
-0.3295401334762573,
-0.0948881134390831,
-0.774772584438324,
0.15261302888393402,
-0.13199040293693542,
-0.007828548550605774,
-0.051576703786849976,
1.037163257598877,
-0.5619739890098572,
0.3847725987434387,
0.5848740935325623,
-0.004953675903379917,
0.5080804228782654,
-0.2426435351371765,
-0.032441508024930954,
-0.9020185470581055,
-0.2994004487991333,
-0.0739036574959755,
-0.3354944586753845,
-0.8225120902061462,
0.0046187699772417545,
0.1294761449098587,
-0.20973297953605652,
-0.6706605553627014,
0.512006402015686,
-0.8731335401535034,
-0.1492525339126587,
-0.5436770915985107,
-0.006558118388056755,
-0.15625762939453125,
0.346385657787323,
0.06863594800233841,
0.5288470983505249,
1.0745636224746704,
-0.41481247544288635,
0.8038142323493958,
0.0483580082654953,
-0.7189467549324036,
0.3756183981895447,
-0.5569294691085815,
-0.37575680017471313,
-0.5179827809333801,
-0.027228763327002525,
-1.4095213413238525,
-0.3909364342689514,
-0.19586215913295746,
-0.09817701578140259,
0.6134458184242249,
-0.17092812061309814,
-0.5453471541404724,
-0.6365700960159302,
-0.3302569091320038,
0.2756999731063843,
0.41402414441108704,
-1.0514206886291504,
0.8591389060020447,
0.3975737690925598,
-0.24325384199619293,
-0.5013697147369385,
-0.8994567394256592,
0.38223859667778015,
-0.38369905948638916,
-0.6072008013725281,
0.26191243529319763,
-0.39132246375083923,
-0.4415348172187805,
-0.2822456955909729,
0.41144561767578125,
-0.24283897876739502,
-0.09857095777988434,
0.5006402730941772,
0.6081609129905701,
-0.31823915243148804,
0.3902968764305115,
-0.08099867403507233,
-0.08266980201005936,
0.10504110902547836,
-0.49962425231933594,
0.6857569813728333,
-0.45869380235671997,
-0.31085240840911865,
-0.36754700541496277,
0.2329588085412979,
0.6147900223731995,
-0.12233167141675949,
0.6045167446136475,
0.4397481679916382,
-0.26012367010116577,
0.013943132013082504,
-0.6617615818977356,
-0.11017496138811111,
-0.4415290355682373,
0.639685332775116,
0.04303956404328346,
-0.90972900390625,
0.3896143138408661,
-0.12990231812000275,
-0.05859874188899994,
0.40408506989479065,
0.6164193749427795,
-0.2902255356311798,
0.9945913553237915,
1.1467519998550415,
-0.13639643788337708,
0.5744851231575012,
-0.5116531252861023,
0.33429044485092163,
-0.408170610666275,
-0.3416241407394409,
-0.23710456490516663,
-0.14165745675563812,
-0.465286523103714,
-0.5922274589538574,
0.25510597229003906,
-0.04429430142045021,
-0.23825430870056152,
0.2532629668712616,
-0.5996177792549133,
0.7227164506912231,
0.536868155002594,
-0.47141844034194946,
0.30921030044555664,
0.13453975319862366,
0.17936213314533234,
-0.19776515662670135,
-1.0129904747009277,
-0.5071678757667542,
0.8798390030860901,
0.508544921875,
1.2048475742340088,
-0.126770481467247,
0.19832843542099,
0.2974078953266144,
0.7023123502731323,
-1.0187267065048218,
0.47103384137153625,
-0.24118641018867493,
-0.2542426586151123,
-0.263047456741333,
-0.1100253090262413,
-0.9899861812591553,
-0.12376002222299576,
-0.23027966916561127,
-0.7099879384040833,
-0.024099530652165413,
0.15027417242527008,
-0.14798802137374878,
0.5506216883659363,
-0.9028931260108948,
0.7444342970848083,
-0.5712254643440247,
0.19270539283752441,
0.2291046530008316,
-0.7854660749435425,
0.367323637008667,
0.11838080734014511,
0.27115434408187866,
0.23682980239391327,
0.0701906606554985,
0.6948366165161133,
-0.043621305376291275,
0.8354143500328064,
-0.08214134722948074,
-0.0011899814708158374,
0.3312946856021881,
0.026378430426120758,
0.21407648921012878,
-0.306037038564682,
0.27371591329574585,
0.11431185156106949,
-0.07256139814853668,
-0.004121754318475723,
-0.5706775188446045,
1.0136375427246094,
-0.6323865652084351,
-0.6584071516990662,
-0.2456740289926529,
-0.8885748386383057,
0.1618303805589676,
0.23140189051628113,
0.21306774020195007,
0.366892546415329,
-0.10417293012142181,
0.3170728385448456,
1.0172227621078491,
-0.6063901782035828,
0.5541102886199951,
0.4996596574783325,
-0.6800023913383484,
-0.36600029468536377,
0.9642518758773804,
0.2033890187740326,
0.0365089550614357,
0.7600044012069702,
0.16622856259346008,
-0.5615002512931824,
-0.69976407289505,
-0.4212303161621094,
0.29110226035118103,
-1.2124929428100586,
-0.14862962067127228,
-0.5419626832008362,
-0.5054563879966736,
-0.234701007604599,
-0.06272289156913757,
-0.1996217668056488,
-0.5954074263572693,
-0.29669925570487976,
-0.30054008960723877,
0.5504409670829773,
1.1395289897918701,
0.3991890251636505,
0.6292219161987305,
-0.5258346199989319,
0.22404886782169342,
0.5425115823745728,
0.1961115151643753,
0.006468606181442738,
-0.3312322795391083,
-0.2186591625213623,
-0.34568721055984497,
-0.10697492212057114,
-0.8020409941673279,
0.4444456994533539,
-0.17979414761066437,
0.7647099494934082,
0.4616580605506897,
-0.4039480984210968,
0.1387491375207901,
-0.690258800983429,
0.9589574337005615,
0.6061074733734131,
-0.6932913064956665,
0.42027249932289124,
-0.2441501021385193,
0.518844723701477,
0.025687750428915024,
0.5650565028190613,
-0.4185103178024292,
-0.18926778435707092,
-0.1924613118171692,
-0.8650301098823547,
0.3754386007785797,
-0.12733706831932068,
0.40223428606987,
0.07426471263170242,
0.1950804442167282,
0.1169213280081749,
0.1771089732646942,
-1.0265154838562012,
-0.4825853705406189,
-0.41434624791145325,
-0.48423120379447937,
-0.23744098842144012,
-0.27108034491539,
-0.23676526546478271,
-0.303210586309433,
0.19734318554401398,
-0.23753653466701508,
0.373014360666275,
-0.1109890565276146,
-0.1896030753850937,
0.03806355968117714,
0.009058316238224506,
0.7074137330055237,
0.835440993309021,
0.09252214431762695,
0.40203186869621277,
0.05592501536011696,
-0.07362563163042068,
0.021689388900995255,
0.1753760725259781,
-0.03228429704904556,
0.06189083680510521,
0.36104312539100647,
1.272871494293213,
0.28265562653541565,
-0.6783496141433716,
0.784607470035553,
-0.16692526638507843,
-0.24613158404827118,
-0.6009994149208069,
-0.06901997327804565,
0.5936818718910217,
0.3611479699611664,
0.4356295168399811,
-0.2322159856557846,
0.008464464917778969,
-0.41441819071769714,
-0.28589949011802673,
0.4282340705394745,
-0.6516232490539551,
-0.04086427390575409,
1.052936315536499,
-0.1139673963189125,
-0.3936651051044464,
0.3587843179702759,
0.5244876146316528,
-0.2933972477912903,
0.8505334258079529,
0.4232921600341797,
0.8083269596099854,
-0.14162270724773407,
0.09631587564945221,
0.1668248325586319,
0.3934093415737152,
-0.12553207576274872,
0.3466641306877136,
0.08735036104917526,
-0.26909419894218445,
-0.5777038931846619,
-0.40089988708496094,
-0.4944041669368744,
0.09034402668476105,
-0.4597908556461334,
0.38127201795578003,
-0.38544151186943054,
-0.033232755959033966,
0.295840322971344,
-0.6362840533256531,
-0.9325801134109497,
0.2713887691497803,
0.33294108510017395,
1.1874734163284302,
-0.729421854019165,
0.8672416806221008,
0.7055487036705017,
-0.6086737513542175,
-0.3195030093193054,
-0.43824875354766846,
-0.34232985973358154,
-0.7046005725860596,
1.028659701347351,
0.22758732736110687,
0.07848535478115082,
0.13032032549381256,
-1.2588366270065308,
-0.9328919649124146,
1.1944750547409058,
0.31718823313713074,
-0.8481649160385132,
0.04316788166761398,
0.3022988438606262,
0.568853497505188,
-0.7089762687683105,
0.18448427319526672,
0.3694177269935608,
0.6164299249649048,
-0.2333471029996872,
-0.1819910854101181,
-0.22546812891960144,
-0.11610393226146698,
0.22717846930027008,
-0.15641215443611145,
-0.48316317796707153,
0.8853462338447571,
-0.23001998662948608,
-0.023485220968723297,
0.29376208782196045,
0.8801368474960327,
-0.19472943246364594,
0.07741419225931168,
0.44737011194229126,
-0.011199502274394035,
0.5112594962120056,
-0.4332161545753479,
1.3725279569625854,
-0.4624840021133423,
0.09469112008810043,
1.2323250770568848,
-0.017084557563066483,
0.453707754611969,
0.6349703073501587,
0.0045033167116343975,
0.650281548500061,
0.45828813314437866,
-0.3657244145870209,
0.37767285108566284,
0.6651200652122498,
0.061743058264255524,
-0.035652343183755875,
-0.05721474438905716,
-0.05952843278646469,
0.2519560158252716,
0.20632542669773102,
-0.7647730112075806,
-0.06022722274065018,
0.4370350241661072,
-0.33832791447639465,
0.0576983243227005,
-0.48600926995277405,
0.718944251537323,
0.13425220549106598,
-0.5716314315795898,
0.42517685890197754,
-0.09597092866897583,
0.36861932277679443,
-0.6732936501502991,
-0.2293729931116104,
-0.006286093033850193,
-0.2486925721168518,
-0.06850598752498627,
-0.9287484288215637,
0.12535874545574188,
0.020922435447573662,
-0.4130190312862396,
-0.2572713792324066,
0.7837517857551575,
-0.6610316038131714,
-0.4364064335823059,
0.47417640686035156,
0.288938045501709,
0.34373384714126587,
0.01626458950340748,
-0.34164711833000183,
0.06615187227725983,
-0.16288381814956665,
-0.026027312502264977,
-0.0305632371455431,
-0.035434845834970474,
-0.22674450278282166,
0.9667184352874756,
0.3536842167377472,
0.0334540531039238,
0.4334345757961273,
0.6672989130020142,
0.8260441422462463,
-0.8629364371299744,
-0.2947375476360321,
-0.8302345275878906,
0.5681527256965637,
-0.13851293921470642,
0.4213472008705139,
0.7952935099601746,
0.7024699449539185,
0.3517177999019623,
-0.6702672243118286,
1.0150494575500488,
0.37883874773979187,
0.2648884057998657,
-0.6155324578285217,
0.8359423875808716,
-0.3537125885486603,
0.1275608092546463,
0.05681142583489418,
-1.2669247388839722,
-0.59975266456604,
0.22320213913917542,
-0.21363292634487152,
-0.4186450242996216,
0.6214220523834229,
0.6582379341125488,
-0.01312418095767498,
0.05218542739748955,
0.47821879386901855,
0.4880916476249695,
0.2514629662036896,
0.29714250564575195,
1.265420913696289,
-0.1395883858203888,
0.6922516822814941,
-0.07081744074821472,
-0.2150983065366745,
-0.1350577175617218,
-1.1435497999191284,
-1.0476864576339722,
-0.5834469199180603,
-0.4558877646923065,
-0.07023114711046219,
-0.24889978766441345,
0.6132142543792725,
0.903981626033783,
-0.8512287735939026,
-0.5460963249206543,
-0.14585673809051514,
0.17140759527683258,
0.12550006806850433,
-0.25242379307746887,
0.45835569500923157,
-0.2120133489370346,
-0.7891737818717957,
0.4316234588623047,
0.5533447861671448,
0.4200386703014374,
-0.8429384231567383,
-0.06699906289577484,
0.06049754098057747,
0.2848789393901825,
0.6489331722259521,
0.2574959099292755,
-0.6362209916114807,
-0.03574711084365845,
-0.11238031834363937,
-0.09955313056707382,
0.3607969582080841,
0.8459103107452393,
-0.4861873686313629,
0.7703065872192383,
0.6330358982086182,
0.46339595317840576,
0.8973916172981262,
-0.1898909956216812,
0.5635778307914734,
-0.36265093088150024,
0.12198909372091293,
-0.03513098508119583,
0.5340418815612793,
0.6426824927330017,
-0.10106267780065536,
0.2812957465648651,
-0.16456462442874908,
-0.3129451274871826,
-0.6427382826805115,
0.08147210627794266,
-1.3518372774124146,
-0.19584019482135773,
0.977708637714386,
-0.007817931473255157,
-0.4669222831726074,
0.13357104361057281,
-0.5386078953742981,
0.23911772668361664,
0.42404237389564514,
0.6307386159896851,
0.6961468458175659,
0.1898323893547058,
-0.3790481686592102,
-0.6832948923110962,
0.4221443235874176,
-0.10701946169137955,
-1.0922982692718506,
-0.022961217910051346,
0.22445768117904663,
0.34807878732681274,
0.23055416345596313,
0.30528783798217773,
-0.23430417478084564,
0.17528146505355835,
-0.3614976108074188,
0.332813024520874,
-0.22630760073661804,
-0.5705221891403198,
-0.4920319616794586,
0.07373551279306412,
0.10372927039861679,
-0.04751573130488396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19504v1 | Are Generative Language Models Multicultural? A Study on Hausa Culture and Emotions using ChatGPT | 2024-06-27T19:42:13 | 2024-06-27T19:42:13 | Ibrahim Said Ahmad, Shiran Dudy, Resmi Ramachandranpillai, Kenneth Church | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, are widely used to generate
content for various purposes and audiences. However, these models may not
reflect the cultural and emotional diversity of their users, especially for
low-resource languages. In this paper, we investigate how ChatGPT represents
Hausa's culture and emotions. We compare responses generated by ChatGPT with
those provided by native Hausa speakers on 37 culturally relevant questions. We
conducted experiments using emotion analysis and applied two similarity metrics
to measure the alignment between human and ChatGPT responses. We also collected
human participants ratings and feedback on ChatGPT responses. Our results show
that ChatGPT has some level of similarity to human responses, but also exhibits
some gaps and biases in its knowledge and awareness of the Hausa culture and
emotions. We discuss the implications and limitations of our methodology and
analysis and suggest ways to improve the performance and evaluation of LLMs for
low-resource languages. | [
-0.5854912996292114,
-0.6148858666419983,
-0.19850532710552216,
0.3771599233150482,
-0.3388354480266571,
0.3467918932437897,
-0.5904892086982727,
-0.5397207736968994,
0.27193501591682434,
0.04877902939915657,
-0.5166516304016113,
-0.3294275104999542,
-0.3764697313308716,
0.2854253351688385,
-0.17482119798660278,
0.9122461676597595,
0.057153038680553436,
-0.2036629021167755,
0.08050726354122162,
-0.4060510993003845,
-0.36435800790786743,
-0.7770100235939026,
-0.7643646001815796,
-0.3858029842376709,
0.47118231654167175,
0.20717677474021912,
0.9675911664962769,
0.2443196028470993,
0.48588547110557556,
0.23240794241428375,
-0.46580663323402405,
-0.18507586419582367,
-0.6796374917030334,
0.05346555635333061,
-0.07391656190156937,
-0.4130592346191406,
-0.37640607357025146,
0.02276010438799858,
0.21426008641719818,
0.48081615567207336,
-0.31568586826324463,
0.20614303648471832,
0.2796582281589508,
0.7026997208595276,
-0.4472225606441498,
0.06186518445611,
-0.29094356298446655,
0.6503191590309143,
-0.3385815918445587,
-0.06896262615919113,
-0.1730653941631317,
-0.5254179835319519,
0.2274533063173294,
-0.4960704445838928,
0.23183606564998627,
0.24621130526065826,
0.6850464940071106,
0.3327668607234955,
-0.9252280592918396,
-0.4294084906578064,
-0.6400840282440186,
0.7268811464309692,
-0.575676679611206,
0.14240704476833344,
0.09463626891374588,
0.1042412668466568,
0.056805048137903214,
0.07546433061361313,
-0.8321064114570618,
-0.062110207974910736,
-0.09570718556642532,
0.5256330966949463,
-0.4928462505340576,
-0.1655552238225937,
0.31769561767578125,
0.7124537825584412,
-0.8879379034042358,
0.33984699845314026,
-0.3622474670410156,
0.023358387872576714,
0.6955680251121521,
0.36187681555747986,
0.5334004163742065,
-0.5054389238357544,
-0.5548291206359863,
-0.18312734365463257,
-0.7641322612762451,
-0.12857988476753235,
0.5274924039840698,
0.14398561418056488,
-0.6877605319023132,
0.49074089527130127,
0.02779010310769081,
0.5177575945854187,
-0.4760400056838989,
-0.20405539870262146,
0.33951401710510254,
0.10573014616966248,
-0.13066579401493073,
-0.2305845320224762,
1.0090445280075073,
0.48110127449035645,
0.9499897956848145,
0.143861323595047,
0.04054229333996773,
0.13561683893203735,
0.2563648223876953,
-0.6242101192474365,
-0.04685286805033684,
-0.19162236154079437,
-0.7557875514030457,
-0.28906041383743286,
-0.31649452447891235,
-1.0950801372528076,
-0.4826256036758423,
-0.0009946160716935992,
-0.048156168311834335,
-0.3290952146053314,
-0.575131893157959,
-0.16398204863071442,
0.07761125266551971,
0.30245354771614075,
0.29315754771232605,
-1.0083428621292114,
0.25095367431640625,
0.5330982804298401,
0.6060922145843506,
-0.4492819011211395,
-0.11283410340547562,
0.2693215012550354,
-0.501319944858551,
-0.19515559077262878,
0.5149915218353271,
-0.487244188785553,
-0.8506941795349121,
0.16800671815872192,
-0.3500231206417084,
-0.024974945932626724,
-0.6840937733650208,
0.5416944622993469,
-0.5577830076217651,
0.3858075737953186,
-0.6544621586799622,
-0.20648643374443054,
-0.23426173627376556,
0.3943243622779846,
-0.5021085739135742,
0.97976154088974,
0.28929704427719116,
-0.8615436553955078,
0.24536415934562683,
-0.5972634553909302,
-0.3634974956512451,
0.3766654431819916,
-0.3120918571949005,
0.053537096828222275,
0.08562421798706055,
-0.11179209500551224,
-0.028406860306859016,
-0.5011194944381714,
-0.2513140141963959,
-0.37406203150749207,
-0.38965359330177307,
0.41811519861221313,
-0.5277720093727112,
0.7664478421211243,
0.6609958410263062,
-0.3228274881839752,
-0.049058057367801666,
-0.4437514841556549,
-0.2165660262107849,
0.3677046000957489,
-0.5730498433113098,
-0.1812131702899933,
-0.06788334250450134,
-0.005126669071614742,
0.29690927267074585,
0.057936571538448334,
-0.4900118410587311,
0.2232300192117691,
-0.0842515379190445,
0.16762930154800415,
0.8347451686859131,
-0.2307991087436676,
0.32404494285583496,
-0.24923411011695862,
1.0287450551986694,
0.13073311746120453,
-0.05025342106819153,
0.14239250123500824,
-0.7381623387336731,
-0.8747031092643738,
-0.06879536062479019,
-0.2521425783634186,
0.6900609135627747,
-0.2899043560028076,
0.24057918787002563,
-0.13122883439064026,
-0.49975112080574036,
-0.5256651639938354,
0.07499478757381439,
0.07112810015678406,
0.5649204850196838,
-0.15638960897922516,
-0.49556466937065125,
-0.4134269654750824,
-0.8531920909881592,
-0.08813970535993576,
-0.49346333742141724,
-0.2071143388748169,
0.5411599278450012,
0.3304767608642578,
-0.19424289464950562,
0.9229548573493958,
-0.47128117084503174,
0.027618397027254105,
-0.031702615320682526,
0.36513257026672363,
-0.015135704539716244,
0.08099790662527084,
0.6720269322395325,
-0.7476145625114441,
-0.6731021404266357,
0.3392368257045746,
-1.1022932529449463,
0.007294573355466127,
0.3583569824695587,
-0.15528813004493713,
0.2956119179725647,
-0.04756832495331764,
-0.6803534626960754,
0.3947312533855438,
0.7422744631767273,
-0.268830269575119,
0.4700538218021393,
-0.014419835060834885,
0.3242720067501068,
-1.2865748405456543,
-0.03957753628492355,
-0.008626319468021393,
0.15491095185279846,
-0.45059970021247864,
-0.03919641301035881,
-0.1173514798283577,
-0.7314999103546143,
-0.5531644225120544,
0.6980311870574951,
-0.2607599198818207,
-0.1589750349521637,
-0.3735828399658203,
0.0726703330874443,
-0.08614262193441391,
0.38194069266319275,
0.4913792312145233,
0.7362591624259949,
0.3427650034427643,
-0.21535436809062958,
0.7657965421676636,
0.4539262652397156,
-0.5483449101448059,
0.7034899592399597,
-0.47360116243362427,
0.29024428129196167,
-0.27688324451446533,
0.21256591379642487,
-0.6370653510093689,
-0.3897869288921356,
0.16674576699733734,
-0.20850270986557007,
-0.20855292677879333,
-0.25837066769599915,
-0.5077642202377319,
-0.4677334129810333,
0.20857654511928558,
0.5939632058143616,
1.146360158920288,
-0.3510607182979584,
0.3905683755874634,
0.15644870698451996,
-0.552907407283783,
-0.4109000861644745,
-0.5018605589866638,
-0.050658851861953735,
-0.5814759135246277,
-0.8338631987571716,
-0.0572056919336319,
-0.058107972145080566,
-0.5699285268783569,
-0.0741814598441124,
0.3058288097381592,
0.11953526735305786,
0.16115087270736694,
0.355298787355423,
0.14600540697574615,
-0.451770156621933,
0.22202423214912415,
-0.4154292345046997,
0.39757224917411804,
-0.0037493871059268713,
0.11545539647340775,
0.7464324831962585,
-0.6133490204811096,
-0.5252971053123474,
-0.04629412665963173,
0.5300602316856384,
0.4531111419200897,
-0.387677401304245,
0.6865209937095642,
0.9600102305412292,
-0.3502231538295746,
0.06648163497447968,
-0.3516608476638794,
-0.05335734412074089,
-0.3685363531112671,
0.2753337025642395,
-0.2803320288658142,
-1.2412710189819336,
0.869694173336029,
0.3745388388633728,
-0.27558696269989014,
0.25634321570396423,
1.1483054161071777,
-0.43744853138923645,
0.4390745162963867,
0.5471380949020386,
-0.1845148354768753,
0.37321943044662476,
0.10230106115341187,
0.3320920765399933,
-0.6396564245223999,
-0.13078229129314423,
-0.5320959091186523,
-0.5403476357460022,
-1.0557852983474731,
-0.17358939349651337,
0.4326099455356598,
-0.19253024458885193,
-0.3272460401058197,
-0.0697002112865448,
-0.048246145248413086,
0.28031885623931885,
0.3820536434650421,
-0.3314202129840851,
0.16935260593891144,
0.1619715690612793,
0.29614904522895813,
-0.15890997648239136,
-0.7923927307128906,
-0.609818160533905,
0.5761842131614685,
0.5331820845603943,
1.1477235555648804,
0.4729354977607727,
0.7420105934143066,
0.24079829454421997,
0.6249077916145325,
-0.823900580406189,
0.3757708966732025,
-0.07698650658130646,
-0.8770184516906738,
-0.09001857042312622,
-0.5668428540229797,
-0.8941026329994202,
0.5368854999542236,
-0.2122575044631958,
-0.9201523065567017,
0.26249054074287415,
0.1108715683221817,
-0.2402956783771515,
0.2876800000667572,
-0.7165443301200867,
0.8539300560951233,
-0.0681016743183136,
-0.033326562494039536,
-0.03930426016449928,
-0.3568480908870697,
0.4783001244068146,
-0.1612870991230011,
0.36988532543182373,
-0.36436542868614197,
0.3196706771850586,
0.7308804988861084,
-0.33953720331192017,
1.0968892574310303,
0.35815221071243286,
-0.5071211457252502,
0.5416575074195862,
0.38127192854881287,
0.06444192677736282,
-0.05349614843726158,
-0.2343040406703949,
0.07328978180885315,
-0.3700648844242096,
-0.537861704826355,
-0.4627286195755005,
0.7111797332763672,
-0.9731159210205078,
-0.6532502174377441,
-0.34368836879730225,
-0.7364993691444397,
0.04198945313692093,
-0.12989693880081177,
0.36128881573677063,
0.06904260069131851,
-0.3503279983997345,
0.04768684506416321,
0.25898706912994385,
-0.5076436400413513,
0.2925129532814026,
0.3825945556163788,
-0.023633098229765892,
0.017073091119527817,
0.7135228514671326,
-0.16925151646137238,
0.41652774810791016,
0.05810554698109627,
0.20661821961402893,
-0.07209935039281845,
0.1782083511352539,
-0.4338345229625702,
0.06462676078081131,
-0.7618476748466492,
0.11464852839708328,
-0.30656206607818604,
-0.018260881304740906,
-0.3892141580581665,
-0.13017579913139343,
-0.36847054958343506,
-0.05818381905555725,
-0.1153808981180191,
-0.023120664060115814,
0.24405477941036224,
0.7463299036026001,
0.09543026983737946,
0.5489025712013245,
-0.8174524903297424,
-0.03086138144135475,
0.4457540214061737,
0.26004040241241455,
0.09810956567525864,
-0.5206561088562012,
-0.06761691719293594,
0.025156669318675995,
-0.4861849546432495,
-0.9910129308700562,
0.4646916687488556,
0.14593054354190826,
0.17828328907489777,
0.5998685359954834,
0.052536651492118835,
0.25938233733177185,
-0.1221286877989769,
0.9243309497833252,
-0.09056711196899414,
-0.638952374458313,
0.3525856137275696,
-0.4583981931209564,
0.4303167164325714,
0.07945980876684189,
0.5879391431808472,
-0.9911065697669983,
-0.1865212470293045,
-0.3289163410663605,
-0.3860726058483124,
0.45920252799987793,
0.29388803243637085,
0.6415210962295532,
-0.344651997089386,
-0.07413557171821594,
0.0696398913860321,
0.047605905681848526,
-0.9904124140739441,
-0.06178055703639984,
-0.23975609242916107,
-0.22909408807754517,
-0.06961803883314133,
-0.3318798840045929,
-0.14896948635578156,
0.4022035300731659,
0.20718950033187866,
-0.07924631983041763,
0.24582761526107788,
-0.25781914591789246,
-0.006095594260841608,
-0.3287309408187866,
0.6719748377799988,
0.31771695613861084,
0.18906809389591217,
-0.33515268564224243,
0.10045424103736877,
0.3642840087413788,
-0.3069366216659546,
0.3575396239757538,
-0.27150967717170715,
-0.03165825828909874,
-0.20389634370803833,
0.6175045967102051,
0.910393238067627,
-0.0065835039131343365,
-0.5548874139785767,
0.43033459782600403,
-0.2142695039510727,
0.21836215257644653,
-0.26345711946487427,
-0.07009001821279526,
0.2617780864238739,
0.24323856830596924,
-0.0035214375238865614,
-0.062177930027246475,
-0.03454208746552467,
-0.7879992127418518,
-0.4376353919506073,
0.3686389625072479,
-0.4689716100692749,
-0.3418893814086914,
0.38681983947753906,
0.5142112374305725,
-0.24731899797916412,
1.1684683561325073,
-0.21955499053001404,
-0.7718489170074463,
0.47452646493911743,
0.5676774382591248,
0.6576731204986572,
-0.24359171092510223,
0.2676747739315033,
0.2870792746543884,
0.27495166659355164,
0.2865251302719116,
0.35896608233451843,
-0.062225691974163055,
-1.1014845371246338,
-0.32527992129325867,
-0.9548470377922058,
-0.47911131381988525,
-0.1567935198545456,
-0.8297138810157776,
0.015610840171575546,
-0.030642863363027573,
-0.4017915725708008,
-0.5033029913902283,
-0.27928394079208374,
-0.8815529346466064,
0.37984979152679443,
0.5336417555809021,
0.8814663290977478,
-1.107025384902954,
0.587308943271637,
0.7922863960266113,
-0.3440340459346771,
-0.5707904100418091,
0.07227260619401932,
0.3725828230381012,
-0.6616360545158386,
1.0338048934936523,
-0.07283991575241089,
0.10680336505174637,
-0.24208371341228485,
0.023612050339579582,
-0.595130980014801,
0.6601762175559998,
0.24117141962051392,
-0.13115942478179932,
0.02424473688006401,
0.4610738456249237,
0.8514963984489441,
-0.3007846772670746,
0.2632163166999817,
0.3484778106212616,
0.07323557883501053,
-0.10820251703262329,
-0.9817069172859192,
-0.200413778424263,
-0.5515839457511902,
0.2609153389930725,
-0.041030243039131165,
-0.9701372981071472,
0.8519476652145386,
-0.23254458606243134,
-0.47125449776649475,
-0.07833823561668396,
0.8107762336730957,
0.44176653027534485,
-0.07851123809814453,
0.462490975856781,
0.44372227787971497,
0.7125077247619629,
-0.22849620878696442,
1.3488978147506714,
0.018805088475346565,
0.45273301005363464,
0.7261025905609131,
-0.5520138740539551,
0.7425451874732971,
0.24190013110637665,
-0.5245415568351746,
0.4457341730594635,
0.9066353440284729,
0.11465177685022354,
-0.035391077399253845,
0.532996416091919,
-0.6440685391426086,
-0.17007897794246674,
-0.34532639384269714,
-0.46030882000923157,
0.7190216779708862,
0.008278838358819485,
-0.09677290916442871,
-0.13151349127292633,
0.05770079791545868,
0.1625669151544571,
-0.1362772285938263,
0.041694920510053635,
0.7152988314628601,
0.42878684401512146,
-0.5566841959953308,
0.6735252737998962,
-0.056885976344347,
0.783141553401947,
-0.2818717360496521,
0.4545106589794159,
-0.8132248520851135,
-0.13796450197696686,
-0.16771861910820007,
-0.9418215155601501,
0.2659429907798767,
0.47879719734191895,
-0.07057145982980728,
0.04342992603778839,
0.4539630115032196,
-0.31661754846572876,
-0.3424968421459198,
0.19464920461177826,
0.5064871311187744,
0.36827483773231506,
0.005124852992594242,
-0.28196293115615845,
0.2435176819562912,
0.045443084090948105,
-0.2939114570617676,
0.26153364777565,
0.38788074254989624,
-0.3184537887573242,
0.8156678080558777,
0.29190298914909363,
-0.045257728546857834,
0.0423087514936924,
0.28416502475738525,
0.3768489956855774,
-0.5903326272964478,
-0.41599681973457336,
-0.9573123455047607,
0.3596246838569641,
0.14722175896167755,
-0.4886854588985443,
0.43557122349739075,
0.423113077878952,
0.8021782040596008,
-0.4623275697231293,
0.86640465259552,
-0.16193845868110657,
0.1637628823518753,
-0.3849562108516693,
0.7991554141044617,
-0.4971468150615692,
-0.005377646069973707,
-0.27514317631721497,
-1.239255666732788,
0.05668456479907036,
0.5285462737083435,
-0.3014387786388397,
0.26639267802238464,
0.36050793528556824,
0.7394707798957825,
-0.1469302475452423,
0.33706796169281006,
0.2596307694911957,
0.13588517904281616,
0.3095134198665619,
0.5624861121177673,
1.312024712562561,
0.04680497571825981,
0.381269246339798,
-0.23096264898777008,
-0.33297932147979736,
-0.115620456635952,
-0.896651029586792,
-0.7192169427871704,
-0.44216325879096985,
-0.38372308015823364,
-0.09823096543550491,
-0.20907188951969147,
0.9707427620887756,
0.5992900729179382,
-0.5713282823562622,
-0.5487105846405029,
0.6160735487937927,
-0.16232459247112274,
0.2778507471084595,
-0.2192211002111435,
0.19449204206466675,
-0.06299015879631042,
-0.7800964713096619,
-0.013498295098543167,
0.20722396671772003,
0.3903455436229706,
-0.13935430347919464,
-0.3419809937477112,
0.4266754686832428,
-0.10646635293960571,
0.8130199909210205,
0.3030897378921509,
-0.6512649655342102,
-0.3434223234653473,
0.024746373295783997,
-0.20374707877635956,
-0.03130139783024788,
0.5637788772583008,
-0.2856009900569916,
0.22814905643463135,
0.5874564051628113,
0.34838026762008667,
0.4244611859321594,
0.11242372542619705,
0.7031551003456116,
-0.7587321400642395,
0.4013160765171051,
0.019841661676764488,
0.5606657862663269,
0.6345009803771973,
-0.0774075910449028,
0.4406558573246002,
0.24904388189315796,
-0.5074096322059631,
-0.3786654770374298,
0.5378502607345581,
-1.0230180025100708,
0.40109631419181824,
1.258568525314331,
-0.3282293379306793,
-0.057883381843566895,
0.49196016788482666,
-0.2720327377319336,
0.25812074542045593,
-0.10733036696910858,
0.8657435178756714,
0.9730556607246399,
-0.13470669090747833,
-0.27692246437072754,
-0.3963465094566345,
0.34280911087989807,
0.5579447150230408,
-0.9483482837677002,
-0.010276139713823795,
0.3551700711250305,
0.282535582780838,
0.1846032440662384,
0.5018940567970276,
-0.2554278075695038,
0.10138104856014252,
-0.10929080098867416,
0.4124968945980072,
0.59908527135849,
0.39341095089912415,
-0.217249795794487,
0.0470639243721962,
0.3083963096141815,
0.34262117743492126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19502v1 | Investigating How Large Language Models Leverage Internal Knowledge to Perform Complex Reasoning | 2024-06-27T19:29:36 | 2024-06-27T19:29:36 | Miyoung Ko, Sue Hyun Park, Joonsuk Park, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant advancements, there is a limited understanding of how
large language models (LLMs) utilize knowledge for reasoning. To address this,
we propose a method that deconstructs complex real-world questions into a
graph, representing each question as a node with parent nodes of background
knowledge needed to solve the question. We develop the DepthQA dataset,
deconstructing questions into three depths: (i) recalling conceptual knowledge,
(ii) applying procedural knowledge, and (iii) analyzing strategic knowledge.
Based on a hierarchical graph, we quantify forward discrepancy, discrepancies
in LLMs' performance on simpler sub-problems versus complex questions. We also
measure backward discrepancy, where LLMs answer complex questions but struggle
with simpler ones. Our analysis shows that smaller models have more
discrepancies than larger models. Additionally, guiding models from simpler to
complex questions through multi-turn interactions improves performance across
model sizes, highlighting the importance of structured intermediate steps in
knowledge reasoning. This work enhances our understanding of LLM reasoning and
suggests ways to improve their problem-solving abilities. | [
-0.4541741907596588,
-0.9914886951446533,
0.9956121444702148,
-0.23486100137233734,
0.0554816760122776,
0.397510826587677,
-0.1585642397403717,
-0.4517645537853241,
-0.3808557093143463,
0.6328651309013367,
-0.6118971705436707,
-0.46982067823410034,
-0.5182431936264038,
-0.07223650068044662,
-0.2010822296142578,
0.5673571825027466,
-0.15127748250961304,
0.06117652356624603,
-0.23606625199317932,
0.007130177691578865,
-0.2929559350013733,
-0.40268775820732117,
-0.8387022614479065,
-0.6760377287864685,
0.6585744023323059,
0.7453600168228149,
0.7933555841445923,
0.2647780179977417,
0.41755393147468567,
0.2867850065231323,
-0.32826152443885803,
0.5382865071296692,
-0.67109614610672,
0.2165646255016327,
-0.3063320219516754,
-0.5951362252235413,
-0.19199281930923462,
-0.33457767963409424,
0.7418851256370544,
1.1659339666366577,
0.10561071336269379,
0.11394231021404266,
-0.08480160683393478,
0.6074676513671875,
-0.36897948384284973,
0.4862613081932068,
-0.6604813933372498,
-0.023864688351750374,
0.05646010488271713,
-0.023533333092927933,
-0.20171785354614258,
-0.42751261591911316,
0.1965842992067337,
-0.39701518416404724,
-0.12767615914344788,
-0.03739172965288162,
0.753990888595581,
0.14970363676548004,
-0.6963036060333252,
-0.416287899017334,
-0.9348659515380859,
0.41284167766571045,
-0.7750148177146912,
0.3040238618850708,
0.2620214819908142,
0.36626580357551575,
-0.2654045820236206,
-0.6102781891822815,
-0.6136444807052612,
-0.17404422163963318,
-0.19684380292892456,
-0.20003455877304077,
-0.35979384183883667,
0.15931478142738342,
0.4476321339607239,
0.22675415873527527,
-0.40599584579467773,
0.11221984028816223,
-0.5354567170143127,
-0.07162366807460785,
0.5885747671127319,
0.285397469997406,
0.4457041621208191,
0.03168213739991188,
0.09292687475681305,
-0.15738119184970856,
-0.9295989274978638,
0.34578388929367065,
0.3550839424133301,
0.2875177264213562,
0.1593930423259735,
0.6362926363945007,
-0.2817418873310089,
0.6867445707321167,
-0.008898994885385036,
-0.32206547260284424,
0.00808921828866005,
-0.20912589132785797,
-0.15109525620937347,
-0.03944483771920204,
0.38378340005874634,
0.14329877495765686,
0.622488260269165,
-0.06333710253238678,
-0.2022416591644287,
-0.4050550162792206,
0.0010690450435504317,
-0.6276667714118958,
-0.37343332171440125,
0.2516377866268158,
-0.10247425734996796,
0.1431201994419098,
-0.01869865693151951,
-0.25486841797828674,
-0.3367307782173157,
-0.5858224034309387,
0.5102530121803284,
-0.4416724741458893,
-0.4623994529247284,
0.2919641137123108,
-0.20210319757461548,
0.21032530069351196,
0.4222581088542938,
-0.3750855624675751,
0.33344322443008423,
0.8519887328147888,
0.48125356435775757,
0.19625553488731384,
-0.21074621379375458,
-0.16814254224300385,
0.3651328384876251,
-0.543948769569397,
0.7735859155654907,
-0.42838239669799805,
-0.16897383332252502,
-0.08171245455741882,
0.07303366810083389,
-0.1085864007472992,
-0.8064548969268799,
0.3334420621395111,
-0.5593741536140442,
0.009896557778120041,
-0.597042977809906,
-0.567115068435669,
-0.4484845995903015,
0.7474376559257507,
-0.7282511591911316,
0.7597992420196533,
-0.012039915658533573,
-0.8410654664039612,
0.08021921664476395,
-0.5126321911811829,
-0.34669917821884155,
-0.028363671153783798,
-0.24223223328590393,
-0.12622413039207458,
-0.09916028380393982,
0.2654552757740021,
0.5383807420730591,
-0.42408084869384766,
0.24155330657958984,
-0.30574649572372437,
-0.23024232685565948,
0.14223316311836243,
-0.07738740742206573,
0.7341957092285156,
0.022178320214152336,
-0.10537803173065186,
0.27480778098106384,
-0.73793625831604,
0.042585380375385284,
0.2904781103134155,
-0.35800668597221375,
-0.44886818528175354,
-0.1289253979921341,
-0.7879460453987122,
0.32495924830436707,
0.11587192118167877,
-0.4199731647968292,
0.468457967042923,
-0.5152763724327087,
0.5138348937034607,
0.5425408482551575,
0.218143031001091,
0.47786957025527954,
-0.1542072892189026,
0.4573083519935608,
0.2227727770805359,
0.027729440480470657,
0.01099899411201477,
-0.5064470767974854,
-0.9013046026229858,
-0.022337399423122406,
0.043667446821928024,
0.39425575733184814,
-0.7391707897186279,
-0.06737957149744034,
-0.34251824021339417,
-0.46873000264167786,
-0.37883231043815613,
0.03630359098315239,
0.3502725660800934,
0.6325317025184631,
0.38037946820259094,
0.19419053196907043,
-0.31393352150917053,
-1.1283938884735107,
-0.26265913248062134,
-0.24662978947162628,
0.11670263856649399,
0.3366425633430481,
0.7781479358673096,
-0.15640975534915924,
0.8187768459320068,
-0.7399662733078003,
0.16224949061870575,
-0.5575427412986755,
0.08127178996801376,
0.11779017746448517,
0.3294101357460022,
0.13134780526161194,
-0.6637028455734253,
-0.04878054931759834,
0.023050524294376373,
-0.7725685834884644,
0.058622993528842926,
0.022372959181666374,
-0.33838778734207153,
-0.23805417120456696,
0.6638075113296509,
-0.9444953203201294,
0.1863621324300766,
0.356751412153244,
-0.44289150834083557,
0.6393536925315857,
-0.18739916384220123,
-0.0273220706731081,
-0.6268526911735535,
-0.10639052093029022,
-0.14455603063106537,
-0.04405701905488968,
-0.5873870849609375,
0.29034656286239624,
-0.07394430041313171,
0.06289437413215637,
-0.11174426227807999,
0.596207857131958,
-0.5715491771697998,
-0.23163549602031708,
0.1654573529958725,
0.23552881181240082,
0.19734075665473938,
0.4079035222530365,
-0.055196408182382584,
0.46135666966438293,
0.26491639018058777,
-0.5957164764404297,
0.3394770622253418,
-0.00022642911062575877,
-0.5650287866592407,
0.22832393646240234,
-0.7706893682479858,
0.19679798185825348,
-0.4131292998790741,
0.2706576883792877,
-1.255757212638855,
-0.31595081090927124,
0.010879169218242168,
-0.20988141000270844,
0.3077573776245117,
-0.2637570798397064,
-0.7516905069351196,
-0.42757028341293335,
0.062209177762269974,
0.5932046175003052,
0.21922628581523895,
-0.3240264654159546,
0.7973525524139404,
0.43811851739883423,
-0.18767109513282776,
-0.39905181527137756,
-0.6468197107315063,
-0.1718401461839676,
-0.1341647505760193,
-1.0779204368591309,
0.10488734394311905,
0.016186363995075226,
-0.827051043510437,
0.09402954578399658,
-0.045954808592796326,
-0.20245139300823212,
0.052978288382291794,
0.053232233971357346,
-0.13019625842571259,
-0.37141770124435425,
0.3682705760002136,
0.2765161097049713,
0.16919618844985962,
0.4336472451686859,
-0.3030740022659302,
0.661676287651062,
-0.17665264010429382,
-0.5580040216445923,
-0.18441778421401978,
0.35114654898643494,
0.6946172118186951,
-0.3447653353214264,
0.7523652911186218,
0.17808909714221954,
-0.46124520897865295,
-0.4405937194824219,
-0.5083329677581787,
-0.26608678698539734,
-0.3716026544570923,
0.3305750787258148,
-0.7389305233955383,
-0.9877153038978577,
0.7508319020271301,
-0.28568828105926514,
0.037103328853845596,
0.39815011620521545,
0.6477826833724976,
-0.10285866260528564,
1.185632348060608,
0.3255962133407593,
0.3339570462703705,
-0.11357857286930084,
-0.6732825636863708,
0.38466566801071167,
-0.6827970743179321,
-0.6682621240615845,
-0.3533950448036194,
-0.33519402146339417,
-0.09662692993879318,
-0.6132130026817322,
0.3740338683128357,
0.41136932373046875,
-0.793074369430542,
-0.06602402776479721,
-0.10515667498111725,
0.49495232105255127,
0.4656519293785095,
0.059254296123981476,
0.5939262509346008,
-0.29369819164276123,
-0.40566587448120117,
0.22137877345085144,
-0.8949517011642456,
-0.40718573331832886,
0.6479146480560303,
0.5009742975234985,
0.7809426188468933,
0.23040039837360382,
0.4239835739135742,
-0.1953427642583847,
0.1130218431353569,
-0.8992225527763367,
0.5192644596099854,
0.23942190408706665,
-0.6585933566093445,
-0.5323101282119751,
-0.6704569458961487,
-0.9379211664199829,
0.48754724860191345,
-0.02753189019858837,
-0.3781314492225647,
0.090333953499794,
-0.019439511001110077,
-0.27254074811935425,
0.5522632002830505,
-0.7126241326332092,
0.7995760440826416,
-0.22270658612251282,
0.052037760615348816,
-0.17293618619441986,
-0.5160084962844849,
0.7274812459945679,
0.18108800053596497,
0.5171738266944885,
-0.1554255336523056,
0.35136908292770386,
0.45791569352149963,
-0.39449554681777954,
0.8294152021408081,
-0.0950128510594368,
-0.5662615895271301,
0.46104395389556885,
0.577772319316864,
0.47276946902275085,
-0.028916597366333008,
0.07067084312438965,
0.036412257701158524,
-0.009571426548063755,
-0.3543621599674225,
-0.7411353588104248,
0.5931283831596375,
-0.8740879893302917,
-0.8361877202987671,
-0.023709939792752266,
-0.7703073024749756,
-0.511900782585144,
0.12998273968696594,
0.003297609044238925,
0.4730277955532074,
0.08975342661142349,
0.2977491021156311,
0.8577307462692261,
-0.2247789055109024,
0.0490681454539299,
0.3739430606365204,
-0.3569730818271637,
-0.02622171677649021,
0.3745461106300354,
0.44128042459487915,
0.5156694650650024,
0.4873828887939453,
0.40876471996307373,
-0.2880970537662506,
-0.48675650358200073,
-0.09968606382608414,
0.4123906195163727,
-1.100540280342102,
-0.13048122823238373,
-0.6522292494773865,
-0.30010786652565,
-0.3446226418018341,
0.18125562369823456,
-0.26616883277893066,
-0.41489002108573914,
-0.03286796808242798,
-0.3941657245159149,
0.03602362424135208,
0.9456827640533447,
0.12531405687332153,
0.034570928663015366,
-0.7506816387176514,
0.32304897904396057,
0.7067903876304626,
0.07414793968200684,
0.4928707778453827,
-0.4924681782722473,
-0.06281624734401703,
0.13921226561069489,
-0.05573229119181633,
-0.8650049567222595,
0.11688266694545746,
-0.013416426256299019,
0.6134480834007263,
0.1543242633342743,
0.016001315787434578,
0.7793322205543518,
-0.44044607877731323,
0.6287204027175903,
-0.1785440444946289,
-0.9104817509651184,
0.45546817779541016,
-0.42810291051864624,
0.6596677303314209,
0.19377078115940094,
0.5326648950576782,
-0.34984806180000305,
-0.4214113652706146,
-0.45337191224098206,
-0.7884119749069214,
0.46756497025489807,
0.10053117573261261,
-0.04595065861940384,
0.08279314637184143,
0.5257519483566284,
-0.1318376511335373,
0.040733423084020615,
-0.5608793497085571,
-0.09473440051078796,
0.15852957963943481,
-0.0950983464717865,
0.19346176087856293,
-0.28701308369636536,
-0.38838663697242737,
-0.5735222101211548,
0.38257232308387756,
-0.23699043691158295,
-0.06204015016555786,
0.19964629411697388,
-0.0744270458817482,
-0.1975131630897522,
0.19974085688591003,
0.4005306363105774,
1.0904425382614136,
0.062245968729257584,
0.3507744073867798,
0.259880393743515,
0.04548582062125206,
-0.11222907900810242,
-0.333126425743103,
-0.031777169555425644,
-0.39394673705101013,
0.8446153402328491,
0.6200056076049805,
0.3207996189594269,
-0.8708513975143433,
0.2989254295825958,
-0.010197623632848263,
-0.34515154361724854,
-0.25394049286842346,
-0.040058985352516174,
0.5996161699295044,
0.6019975543022156,
0.3703822195529938,
-0.22840818762779236,
0.0025044120848178864,
-0.9984654188156128,
0.09474658966064453,
0.38281184434890747,
-0.18147502839565277,
-0.1907096803188324,
0.182460218667984,
-0.06285090744495392,
-0.1778760552406311,
0.7809535264968872,
-0.04355042800307274,
-0.8238028883934021,
0.768156886100769,
0.4772164523601532,
0.3138900101184845,
-0.03148564323782921,
0.2731667757034302,
0.3808816373348236,
0.42677631974220276,
-0.18142341077327728,
0.43788138031959534,
0.08064309507608414,
-1.0727962255477905,
-0.6660327315330505,
-0.24883130192756653,
-0.4033106863498688,
0.2553237974643707,
-0.4691663384437561,
-0.05847639963030815,
-0.6220215559005737,
0.08489692211151123,
-0.06868899613618851,
0.0293571874499321,
-0.7580260038375854,
0.38268157839775085,
0.2219092696905136,
0.8378685712814331,
-0.5032899379730225,
0.6724659204483032,
0.5254433751106262,
-0.5643277764320374,
-1.2744601964950562,
0.06176670268177986,
-0.11577995121479034,
-0.8251285552978516,
1.0843298435211182,
0.03436766564846039,
-0.4759726822376251,
-0.09580927342176437,
-0.8135442137718201,
-1.0126816034317017,
1.0525389909744263,
0.3892798125743866,
-0.6228042840957642,
-0.2239086627960205,
0.13915374875068665,
0.55013108253479,
-0.5211924314498901,
0.08682778477668762,
0.7448878884315491,
0.5485960841178894,
0.36365851759910583,
-0.8400763273239136,
0.21037688851356506,
-0.03683752939105034,
-0.34199631214141846,
0.24530315399169922,
-0.533679187297821,
1.2971999645233154,
-0.5057957172393799,
-0.1651483178138733,
-0.33390602469444275,
0.45809561014175415,
0.4151415228843689,
0.24092429876327515,
0.5901440382003784,
0.5261439085006714,
1.0594645738601685,
-0.14981922507286072,
0.9648776650428772,
-0.25017085671424866,
0.28426221013069153,
1.2063794136047363,
-0.2544425427913666,
0.7663067579269409,
0.26902931928634644,
0.042861711233854294,
0.833037793636322,
0.4609659016132355,
0.29097795486450195,
0.19123348593711853,
0.575604259967804,
0.10732237249612808,
-0.7752816677093506,
0.11878801137208939,
-0.2960469126701355,
0.5926578640937805,
0.5982425808906555,
-0.0859035775065422,
-0.3298662006855011,
-0.23705704510211945,
0.22801704704761505,
0.011233785189688206,
-0.48871979117393494,
0.8627331852912903,
0.22096186876296997,
-0.767084002494812,
0.5982841849327087,
0.04422007128596306,
0.08345679193735123,
-0.5303526520729065,
-0.1696528047323227,
-0.2860962748527527,
0.2918822169303894,
-0.24440482258796692,
-1.3428877592086792,
0.2329617589712143,
-0.15579992532730103,
-0.10431420058012009,
0.13541297614574432,
0.7156949639320374,
-0.5365582704544067,
-0.44624248147010803,
0.5414060950279236,
0.8061065077781677,
0.017412712797522545,
-0.35357430577278137,
-0.6296528577804565,
-0.012075621634721756,
-0.06500428915023804,
-0.1752292364835739,
0.15330106019973755,
1.0341404676437378,
-0.20327091217041016,
1.0496468544006348,
0.6017409563064575,
-0.06293778866529465,
0.04852740839123726,
0.3569103181362152,
1.0943267345428467,
-0.705398440361023,
-0.26642343401908875,
-0.7779847979545593,
0.6154594421386719,
-0.16553544998168945,
-0.2500823736190796,
0.8355699777603149,
0.3936169445514679,
0.9324475526809692,
0.11491722613573074,
0.64305180311203,
0.37987151741981506,
0.5085297226905823,
-0.6232301592826843,
0.4244568645954132,
-0.6186564564704895,
0.4736098349094391,
-0.13778549432754517,
-0.7165161967277527,
-0.30550214648246765,
0.5164002180099487,
-0.5746999979019165,
-0.11737716943025589,
0.5858127474784851,
0.5600064992904663,
0.000005784133918496082,
-0.08203745633363724,
0.24131076037883759,
0.6877163052558899,
0.6002886891365051,
0.7563956379890442,
1.1339696645736694,
-0.03269295394420624,
0.5943851470947266,
-0.19544148445129395,
-0.08530697226524353,
0.009584221988916397,
-0.4807322323322296,
-1.127651572227478,
-0.44548720121383667,
-0.12681153416633606,
-0.2987577021121979,
-0.14845570921897888,
0.7433595061302185,
0.6381747126579285,
-0.6363098621368408,
-0.28696244955062866,
0.06865192949771881,
0.4676158130168915,
-0.018921751528978348,
-0.24573303759098053,
0.3586438000202179,
-0.1891847550868988,
-0.39818039536476135,
0.4466783404350281,
0.19334977865219116,
-0.120795838534832,
-0.5753032565116882,
0.03561890870332718,
-0.3500412106513977,
0.2629854083061218,
0.9197181463241577,
0.05905468761920929,
-0.8038035035133362,
-0.3607077896595001,
-0.06955549120903015,
0.034918829798698425,
-0.0005300780176185071,
1.070387363433838,
-0.5670475363731384,
0.15367867052555084,
0.7302430868148804,
0.45982781052589417,
0.6350181698799133,
0.12092909216880798,
0.5428071618080139,
-0.660025417804718,
-0.0873735174536705,
0.3854086101055145,
0.40696918964385986,
0.40343740582466125,
-0.284228652715683,
0.37782466411590576,
0.05145501345396042,
-0.4706425666809082,
-0.726576030254364,
0.5489078164100647,
-0.6689749956130981,
-0.8642356395721436,
1.318674921989441,
-0.19597144424915314,
-0.08958067744970322,
-0.2593522369861603,
-0.35896626114845276,
0.07433783262968063,
-0.1918288767337799,
0.5442591309547424,
0.9744154810905457,
-0.3493916392326355,
-0.3192564845085144,
-0.38420385122299194,
0.4721696078777313,
-0.05179957300424576,
-0.8575578927993774,
0.01508669089525938,
0.5018094778060913,
0.48896268010139465,
0.14350467920303345,
0.539544403553009,
-0.11748407036066055,
-0.19853752851486206,
-0.1137004941701889,
-0.34978964924812317,
-0.06762699782848358,
-0.6256020665168762,
-0.06242237240076065,
0.6100658774375916,
0.0967065617442131,
0.43320560455322266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19501v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19501v1 | Monitoring Latent World States in Language Models with Propositional Probes | 2024-06-27T19:28:43 | 2024-06-27T19:28:43 | Jiahai Feng, Stuart Russell, Jacob Steinhardt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models are susceptible to bias, sycophancy, backdoors, and other
tendencies that lead to unfaithful responses to the input context. Interpreting
internal states of language models could help monitor and correct unfaithful
behavior. We hypothesize that language models represent their input contexts in
a latent world model, and seek to extract this latent world state from the
activations. We do so with 'propositional probes', which compositionally probe
tokens for lexical information and bind them into logical propositions
representing the world state. For example, given the input context ''Greg is a
nurse. Laura is a physicist.'', we decode the propositions ''WorksAs(Greg,
nurse)'' and ''WorksAs(Laura, physicist)'' from the model's activations. Key to
this is identifying a 'binding subspace' in which bound tokens have high
similarity (''Greg'' and ''nurse'') but unbound ones do not (''Greg'' and
''physicist''). We validate propositional probes in a closed-world setting with
finitely many predicates and properties. Despite being trained on simple
templated contexts, propositional probes generalize to contexts rewritten as
short stories and translated to Spanish. Moreover, we find that in three
settings where language models respond unfaithfully to the input context --
prompt injections, backdoor attacks, and gender bias -- the decoded
propositions remain faithful. This suggests that language models often encode a
faithful world model but decode it unfaithfully, which motivates the search for
better interpretability tools for monitoring LMs. | [
0.07723245024681091,
-0.6982331275939941,
0.8090899586677551,
0.01333952322602272,
-0.13293883204460144,
-0.2290593385696411,
0.0026025427505373955,
-0.17829976975917816,
-0.10426141321659088,
0.5512051582336426,
-0.49104565382003784,
-0.41701722145080566,
-0.3436126410961151,
0.05151265487074852,
-0.5830106735229492,
0.9482211470603943,
-0.022738119587302208,
0.0719766765832901,
-0.27011507749557495,
0.07653386145830154,
-0.059614647179841995,
-0.5766173601150513,
-0.17121803760528564,
-0.5161803364753723,
0.3083761930465698,
-0.13019967079162598,
0.7505931854248047,
0.28956249356269836,
0.3572966158390045,
0.27712076902389526,
-0.37763506174087524,
0.02483268640935421,
-0.5712189674377441,
0.30466222763061523,
-0.4885587990283966,
-0.7146490812301636,
-0.2843290865421295,
0.3023642897605896,
0.6197951436042786,
0.8325107097625732,
0.019881023094058037,
0.13348472118377686,
0.16298164427280426,
0.09274706244468689,
-0.6403129696846008,
0.335915744304657,
-0.4140401780605316,
0.22430887818336487,
-0.04314574971795082,
-0.24500992894172668,
-0.5967031121253967,
-0.07788244634866714,
0.3438064157962799,
-0.37180620431900024,
0.2796632945537567,
0.047487907111644745,
0.6382885575294495,
0.20301812887191772,
-0.8361837863922119,
-0.2519649565219879,
-0.7500808238983154,
0.7394723296165466,
-0.8707565665245056,
0.5841187834739685,
0.3324797451496124,
-0.14718656241893768,
-0.7018293738365173,
-0.519207775592804,
-0.6886574029922485,
-0.4343012571334839,
-0.31626540422439575,
0.19078980386257172,
-0.4502183794975281,
0.3346399664878845,
0.38660019636154175,
0.39237314462661743,
-0.5102352499961853,
0.05331263318657875,
-0.16137121617794037,
-0.5419905781745911,
0.20927032828330994,
0.18004968762397766,
0.5028948187828064,
-0.40007805824279785,
-0.29760444164276123,
0.03626353293657303,
-0.835277795791626,
0.24803094565868378,
0.3431406617164612,
0.26684045791625977,
-0.17261220514774323,
0.8531426787376404,
0.13263453543186188,
0.8668909072875977,
-0.17379622161388397,
-0.22495470941066742,
-0.16118323802947998,
-0.281289666891098,
-0.06324924528598785,
-0.08491034060716629,
0.7658923864364624,
0.3152235448360443,
0.015068130567669868,
-0.19469574093818665,
-0.3759280741214752,
0.4235629439353943,
0.29590675234794617,
-0.6330852508544922,
-0.0756562277674675,
0.2691692113876343,
-0.3929642140865326,
-0.41521087288856506,
0.06220570579171181,
-0.5665867328643799,
-0.434963196516037,
-0.14600709080696106,
0.2995222508907318,
-0.23212170600891113,
-0.2769092321395874,
0.022258339449763298,
-0.05911663919687271,
0.13563376665115356,
0.1286836862564087,
-0.78166663646698,
0.4125101566314697,
0.9199912548065186,
0.9318535327911377,
-0.19036661088466644,
-0.35887637734413147,
-0.7697659134864807,
-0.08841323107481003,
-0.5503823161125183,
0.6364604234695435,
-0.6307350993156433,
-0.5369731187820435,
0.15260447561740875,
0.2307300716638565,
-0.030018998309969902,
-0.431888610124588,
0.2862476408481598,
-0.60183185338974,
0.4618149697780609,
-0.29976171255111694,
-0.7394334077835083,
-0.0896032303571701,
0.42391180992126465,
-0.5353521108627319,
0.9880733489990234,
-0.025394199416041374,
-0.746223509311676,
0.10394216328859329,
-0.6198262572288513,
-0.02874869666993618,
-0.43561726808547974,
-0.19311001896858215,
-0.003907778766006231,
0.5371089577674866,
0.16448655724525452,
0.4149741530418396,
-0.23776838183403015,
0.4897400438785553,
-0.23286302387714386,
-0.4493812024593353,
0.6714664101600647,
-0.4975292980670929,
0.8205969929695129,
0.0023724117781966925,
-0.16949662566184998,
0.19869041442871094,
-0.5688506960868835,
-0.21989279985427856,
0.17461153864860535,
-0.3537198007106781,
-0.38172364234924316,
0.13549649715423584,
-0.10060122609138489,
0.27410468459129333,
0.050903428345918655,
-0.8814096450805664,
0.17527632415294647,
-0.8683527112007141,
0.4954691231250763,
0.662966251373291,
0.27873778343200684,
0.4045674502849579,
-0.14072515070438385,
0.7119448184967041,
0.2901882827281952,
-0.0756969079375267,
-0.2838082015514374,
-0.574802815914154,
-0.5990735292434692,
0.03839334845542908,
0.06480913609266281,
0.42502421140670776,
-0.7216697335243225,
0.22352206707000732,
-0.11639044433832169,
-0.34807130694389343,
-0.2753416895866394,
-0.3242139518260956,
0.6185373663902283,
0.7886384725570679,
0.05898449569940567,
-0.15176056325435638,
-0.25958922505378723,
-0.8888528347015381,
-0.5293278694152832,
-0.3532485067844391,
0.028057878836989403,
0.10755253583192825,
0.8362206816673279,
-0.1195003017783165,
1.158576250076294,
-0.5844019055366516,
-0.17078158259391785,
0.03782905265688896,
-0.05873415246605873,
0.44260773062705994,
0.4120817184448242,
0.37386733293533325,
-0.7410405874252319,
0.036130525171756744,
-0.17260658740997314,
-0.7798296809196472,
-0.029254844412207603,
0.03331270068883896,
0.03841933608055115,
-0.150166317820549,
0.6907525062561035,
-0.30720749497413635,
0.622164249420166,
0.7714366912841797,
-0.6538981795310974,
0.6443434953689575,
-0.20980802178382874,
-0.13748541474342346,
-1.0307810306549072,
0.0521598644554615,
-0.05376092717051506,
-0.41963082551956177,
-0.7167786955833435,
0.20562848448753357,
0.10971362888813019,
-0.16281354427337646,
-0.7021451592445374,
0.6998947262763977,
-0.4178794324398041,
-0.2863340675830841,
-0.31259316205978394,
0.04174211993813515,
0.06855935603380203,
0.4005550742149353,
0.09503961354494095,
0.7483745217323303,
0.5383198261260986,
-0.46986907720565796,
0.4150386452674866,
0.24387404322624207,
-0.1700245589017868,
0.527704656124115,
-0.7389410138130188,
0.12652738392353058,
-0.06621532887220383,
0.5200158953666687,
-0.9096503853797913,
0.007127462886273861,
0.3558751344680786,
-0.39623212814331055,
-0.13675732910633087,
-0.3827039301395416,
-0.5778622031211853,
-0.05789653956890106,
-0.0641598105430603,
0.37562835216522217,
0.2224256843328476,
-0.6020099520683289,
0.6154552102088928,
0.22885075211524963,
0.2568407356739044,
-0.6395533084869385,
-0.6921953558921814,
-0.12364057451486588,
-0.003077512141317129,
-0.22560372948646545,
0.2824642062187195,
0.1386823058128357,
-0.4835931956768036,
0.12473516911268234,
-0.29525822401046753,
-0.12715671956539154,
0.13474306464195251,
0.5276159048080444,
0.3331563472747803,
-0.2970772683620453,
-0.011880111880600452,
0.2441488653421402,
-0.28068414330482483,
0.4937666356563568,
-0.4525769054889679,
0.5833670496940613,
-0.32517048716545105,
-0.6076873540878296,
-0.30189934372901917,
0.4022114872932434,
0.6272233724594116,
-0.36120977997779846,
0.872651219367981,
0.24319052696228027,
-0.8836092352867126,
-0.07556317746639252,
-0.16086313128471375,
-0.5051677823066711,
-0.4878982603549957,
0.29308226704597473,
-0.5378089547157288,
-0.922710120677948,
0.9670196771621704,
-0.008764754980802536,
-0.12259643524885178,
0.3477516770362854,
0.6099401712417603,
0.0844610258936882,
1.009804606437683,
0.5219268202781677,
0.010485905222594738,
0.32242488861083984,
-0.21164506673812866,
0.43027356266975403,
-1.0186288356781006,
-0.101531982421875,
-0.3090790808200836,
0.08569532632827759,
-0.6017935276031494,
-0.3846307098865509,
0.637083113193512,
-0.025555487722158432,
0.06506477296352386,
0.008112485520541668,
-0.25611254572868347,
0.7720947265625,
0.5021076202392578,
0.11665366590023041,
0.3917197585105896,
-0.34154802560806274,
-0.4972040057182312,
-0.4133369028568268,
-0.4973023533821106,
-0.5900699496269226,
1.0871293544769287,
0.4289275109767914,
0.7570958137512207,
0.3706303536891937,
0.5561251640319824,
0.028742531314492226,
0.2511107921600342,
-0.8145247101783752,
0.43522217869758606,
0.05672813206911087,
-0.8469686508178711,
-0.058585308492183685,
-0.20497553050518036,
-0.9877980351448059,
0.6129373908042908,
-0.0702594742178917,
-1.1276811361312866,
0.5158590078353882,
0.28748613595962524,
-0.23515412211418152,
0.35959556698799133,
-0.3251573145389557,
0.9505107998847961,
-0.1181061789393425,
-0.35945141315460205,
-0.10592550784349442,
-0.44855430722236633,
0.42278745770454407,
0.11788614094257355,
-0.02922065556049347,
0.022644761949777603,
-0.0435122586786747,
0.6057984232902527,
-0.49381116032600403,
1.2040506601333618,
-0.061048947274684906,
-0.692495584487915,
0.07916423678398132,
0.5928588509559631,
0.4066298007965088,
0.30296579003334045,
-0.005697936750948429,
0.074858658015728,
0.3979269564151764,
-0.2851751446723938,
-0.5985792279243469,
0.6537121534347534,
-0.6134447455406189,
-0.4924599826335907,
-0.8189098238945007,
-0.5252554416656494,
-0.316224604845047,
0.3818102180957794,
0.5333844423294067,
0.7506327629089355,
-0.4199160933494568,
-0.1474386304616928,
0.808686375617981,
-0.28789275884628296,
0.1832420974969864,
0.8945630788803101,
-0.5584444999694824,
0.34879070520401,
0.8652461767196655,
-0.18414592742919922,
0.31027528643608093,
0.49218904972076416,
0.39721372723579407,
-0.3871423602104187,
-0.3031785488128662,
-0.29186031222343445,
0.2534676194190979,
-0.7660015821456909,
-0.07712255418300629,
-0.5215599536895752,
-0.13025598227977753,
-0.2833155691623688,
0.08487693220376968,
-0.5073778033256531,
-0.0007912326254881918,
-0.44094446301460266,
-0.10190167278051376,
0.0020749408286064863,
0.7856621742248535,
-0.03780217468738556,
0.15809638798236847,
-0.6294270157814026,
0.30434557795524597,
0.3101789951324463,
0.21652589738368988,
-0.11783622205257416,
-0.6496149301528931,
0.13787445425987244,
0.08022002130746841,
0.0048986030742526054,
-1.4114677906036377,
0.36578673124313354,
0.1927299052476883,
0.318787157535553,
0.45920729637145996,
0.0884540006518364,
0.27434059977531433,
-0.45635077357292175,
0.8242665529251099,
-0.19927208125591278,
-1.3131697177886963,
0.7366185188293457,
-0.6725786924362183,
0.21423976123332977,
0.09583877772092819,
0.23284369707107544,
-1.0601391792297363,
-0.5561264753341675,
-0.4573748707771301,
-0.4820558726787567,
0.7753333449363708,
-0.14240042865276337,
0.30207359790802,
-0.03586360439658165,
0.5703630447387695,
0.12620773911476135,
0.24791112542152405,
-0.9278961420059204,
-0.19836385548114777,
-0.023943085223436356,
-0.09356145560741425,
-0.037298157811164856,
-0.2899811267852783,
-0.3769140839576721,
-0.1543843299150467,
0.3245396018028259,
-0.4726608991622925,
0.4341067671775818,
0.266741007566452,
-0.3555152714252472,
-0.09197106212377548,
0.2556811273097992,
0.4916319251060486,
0.7371438145637512,
-0.17065028846263885,
0.41464003920555115,
-0.06907631456851959,
-0.3782115578651428,
0.3236396908760071,
0.06359973549842834,
-0.2745636999607086,
-0.12814025580883026,
0.6544610857963562,
0.6053609251976013,
0.3996000587940216,
-0.7944024205207825,
0.9174869060516357,
-0.17531174421310425,
0.1582372635602951,
-0.3110223412513733,
0.12847737967967987,
0.013290663249790668,
0.32202571630477905,
0.04894207417964935,
-0.08514575660228729,
0.15962530672550201,
-0.8006479144096375,
-0.010591808706521988,
0.38868221640586853,
-0.5764481425285339,
-0.6907662153244019,
0.5425167679786682,
-0.15990257263183594,
-0.21873556077480316,
0.6389867663383484,
-0.35523369908332825,
-0.9618262052536011,
0.4131525754928589,
0.9629972577095032,
0.49085161089897156,
-0.22988083958625793,
0.28852301836013794,
0.09713855385780334,
0.4378141760826111,
0.028634408488869667,
0.5250837802886963,
0.23543259501457214,
-1.0863910913467407,
-0.3573431968688965,
-0.40260812640190125,
-0.6233659386634827,
0.20626261830329895,
-1.0264314413070679,
-0.25625908374786377,
-0.35453668236732483,
0.09721547365188599,
-0.2169562578201294,
-0.2861821949481964,
-0.6667295694351196,
0.21328027546405792,
0.08701153844594955,
0.5600546598434448,
-1.1545122861862183,
0.744162380695343,
0.8724358677864075,
-0.16074886918067932,
-0.5514923334121704,
0.13763271272182465,
0.4456521272659302,
-0.8162640333175659,
0.5452343821525574,
0.036603450775146484,
-0.2638397216796875,
-0.1446613222360611,
-0.4097910523414612,
-1.042280912399292,
0.45647186040878296,
0.4963654577732086,
-0.4331662058830261,
0.02879112772643566,
0.1571010947227478,
0.832114040851593,
-0.24158737063407898,
0.11173465847969055,
0.629357635974884,
0.1400475800037384,
-0.6388373374938965,
-0.9025371670722961,
0.28048989176750183,
-0.3092738389968872,
-0.112859345972538,
0.1547108292579651,
-0.40433549880981445,
1.0097544193267822,
-0.20459400117397308,
-0.12636393308639526,
-0.08291111886501312,
0.7295661568641663,
0.15099668502807617,
0.2453063428401947,
0.5155025720596313,
0.30059653520584106,
0.7082915306091309,
-0.28580164909362793,
1.0322178602218628,
-0.27060312032699585,
0.45212218165397644,
0.9917086362838745,
-0.174266055226326,
0.8435418605804443,
0.5078036785125732,
-0.18206046521663666,
0.5501697659492493,
0.5720889568328857,
0.16395309567451477,
0.41764768958091736,
0.29514601826667786,
-0.08543474972248077,
-0.1454441398382187,
-0.44051384925842285,
-0.24686095118522644,
0.7660046219825745,
0.761038064956665,
-0.2033831775188446,
-0.12503473460674286,
0.23680278658866882,
0.13048601150512695,
0.07085301727056503,
0.0708509087562561,
0.5381606221199036,
0.21183572709560394,
-0.7152027487754822,
0.2542839050292969,
0.11344172060489655,
0.4744144082069397,
-0.4465048611164093,
0.02614862471818924,
-0.17975826561450958,
0.25389260053634644,
-0.09347616881132126,
-0.677617073059082,
0.06583964079618454,
0.03090176358819008,
-0.14523977041244507,
-0.15215304493904114,
0.5891506671905518,
-0.3065963685512543,
-0.360564649105072,
0.28238967061042786,
0.7619431614875793,
0.11042266339063644,
-0.25088876485824585,
-0.5413249731063843,
0.04251467436552048,
-0.06768158823251724,
-0.27170678973197937,
0.22663678228855133,
0.1728036105632782,
-0.18462926149368286,
0.622646152973175,
0.7304368615150452,
0.2924402058124542,
-0.03770843520760536,
-0.05353256314992905,
0.8019039630889893,
-0.7504285573959351,
-0.7691856026649475,
-0.7469073534011841,
0.2839483320713043,
0.3346477746963501,
-0.6569157242774963,
0.6771291494369507,
0.4734131395816803,
0.7736305594444275,
0.24598626792430878,
0.4491908550262451,
0.36683398485183716,
0.4617435038089752,
-0.6537582874298096,
0.5074095129966736,
-0.5160766243934631,
0.2518261969089508,
-0.25685814023017883,
-0.9879618287086487,
-0.09815850108861923,
0.6706478595733643,
-0.5160684585571289,
-0.2175944596529007,
0.8014100790023804,
0.6690927743911743,
-0.20879660546779633,
0.17585337162017822,
0.159466952085495,
0.4162864685058594,
0.6556429862976074,
0.39959660172462463,
1.1654176712036133,
-0.27140694856643677,
0.040049295872449875,
-0.34981104731559753,
-0.15907293558120728,
-0.16266386210918427,
-0.8574281930923462,
-0.9255625605583191,
-0.6635448932647705,
-0.09818363189697266,
-0.5656116604804993,
-0.1279774010181427,
0.7127744555473328,
0.5201786756515503,
-0.8506779670715332,
-0.06369782239198685,
0.05908053740859032,
0.0965120792388916,
-0.198981374502182,
-0.2512935400009155,
0.4980161488056183,
0.07504204660654068,
-0.7823431491851807,
0.6837302446365356,
0.2769116461277008,
0.1144421324133873,
-0.7119529843330383,
0.21393677592277527,
0.08957002311944962,
-0.002920362865552306,
0.37734633684158325,
0.19096241891384125,
-1.0073819160461426,
-0.2863597571849823,
0.09779676795005798,
-0.11045681685209274,
-0.11255031824111938,
1.0300706624984741,
-0.8340948224067688,
0.6003303527832031,
0.34988731145858765,
0.3402080237865448,
0.2754366099834442,
-0.30108731985092163,
0.8157572746276855,
-0.8537465333938599,
0.4411449730396271,
0.5886850357055664,
0.6273119449615479,
0.22189290821552277,
-0.40362152457237244,
0.2803904712200165,
0.23912952840328217,
-0.37500980496406555,
-1.2032052278518677,
0.5365182161331177,
-0.6292852759361267,
-0.3157930076122284,
0.9266193509101868,
-0.2632617652416229,
-0.38778766989707947,
-0.07153482735157013,
-0.025011252611875534,
0.1431266814470291,
-0.23379509150981903,
0.4881136119365692,
0.7724059820175171,
-0.19427195191383362,
0.14754359424114227,
-0.6450119018554688,
0.3665255904197693,
0.775881290435791,
-0.6114141345024109,
-0.09635047614574432,
0.5825793147087097,
0.2572478950023651,
0.1353352963924408,
0.47143277525901794,
-0.02079552598297596,
0.26244789361953735,
0.03350786492228508,
-0.3890974819660187,
0.15756432712078094,
-0.1635294109582901,
-0.611882209777832,
-0.04711892083287239,
-0.0843014344573021,
-0.07291844487190247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19500v1 | Knowledge acquisition for dialogue agents using reinforcement learning on graph representations | 2024-06-27T19:28:42 | 2024-06-27T19:28:42 | Selene Baez Santamaria, Shihan Wang, Piek Vossen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We develop an artificial agent motivated to augment its knowledge base beyond
its initial training. The agent actively participates in dialogues with other
agents, strategically acquiring new information. The agent models its knowledge
as an RDF knowledge graph, integrating new beliefs acquired through
conversation. Responses in dialogue are generated by identifying graph patterns
around these new integrated beliefs. We show that policies can be learned using
reinforcement learning to select effective graph patterns during an
interaction, without relying on explicit user feedback. Within this context,
our study is a proof of concept for leveraging users as effective sources of
information. | [
-0.48585203289985657,
-0.9094484448432922,
0.8129299879074097,
-0.1098884865641594,
0.06012601777911186,
0.49726665019989014,
0.019774818792939186,
-0.5356188416481018,
0.08573569357395172,
0.6985347867012024,
-0.48159343004226685,
-0.5029612183570862,
-0.5793364644050598,
0.06614788621664047,
0.041715651750564575,
0.9530734419822693,
0.04664945974946022,
-0.15249107778072357,
-0.1779044270515442,
0.06666899472475052,
-0.405707448720932,
-0.15503981709480286,
-1.087504506111145,
-0.7605125904083252,
0.6946868300437927,
0.4065989553928375,
0.8185077905654907,
0.2568472921848297,
-0.046939667314291,
0.5022004842758179,
0.15185268223285675,
0.7186138033866882,
-0.5609938502311707,
0.31516942381858826,
-0.30268242955207825,
-0.4471200704574585,
0.09685775637626648,
0.10118274390697479,
0.6761124134063721,
0.5852864980697632,
-0.09251636266708374,
-0.4420478045940399,
-0.13350443542003632,
0.3627045750617981,
-0.3392934203147888,
0.803304135799408,
-0.38648152351379395,
0.17171461880207062,
0.36884042620658875,
-0.4747392237186432,
-0.731848418712616,
-0.6577794551849365,
0.3693951666355133,
-1.1112030744552612,
-0.2904500961303711,
0.2002076506614685,
0.8822718858718872,
-0.0024674718733876944,
-0.8735365271568298,
-0.5420185327529907,
-0.8160377740859985,
0.5210715532302856,
-0.17727349698543549,
0.2921501100063324,
0.5887778401374817,
0.5655357837677002,
-0.6644982099533081,
-0.9428474307060242,
-0.685202956199646,
-0.2777707278728485,
-0.31090977787971497,
0.07972563803195953,
-0.2475876659154892,
0.42078685760498047,
0.40437474846839905,
-0.039051353931427,
-0.2556247115135193,
-0.16721047461032867,
-0.20841388404369354,
-0.33945927023887634,
0.5543853640556335,
0.18197262287139893,
0.2910178303718567,
-0.2839532494544983,
-0.4251088500022888,
-0.31676506996154785,
-0.4213382303714752,
0.29797738790512085,
0.3508894145488739,
0.2551293671131134,
0.24615055322647095,
0.3072149455547333,
-0.27449536323547363,
0.8086807727813721,
0.13008743524551392,
-0.274832159280777,
0.16786283254623413,
-0.30703526735305786,
-0.05521776154637337,
0.08265269547700882,
0.5521271824836731,
0.06632953137159348,
0.38375991582870483,
-0.29989275336265564,
-0.2617875039577484,
-0.26925069093704224,
0.32888782024383545,
-0.6250757575035095,
-0.18305282294750214,
-0.05373682454228401,
-0.27054834365844727,
-0.35182633996009827,
0.12614016234874725,
-0.4920650124549866,
-0.5391149520874023,
-0.1929163932800293,
0.24589446187019348,
-0.6232239603996277,
-0.3598741590976715,
-0.02222423255443573,
-0.723071277141571,
0.15396776795387268,
0.7025101184844971,
-0.7074649333953857,
0.5229370594024658,
0.46348676085472107,
0.5880593061447144,
0.14429374039173126,
-0.332152783870697,
-0.47203391790390015,
0.42522555589675903,
-0.4017884433269501,
0.9005497694015503,
-0.6602035164833069,
-0.6790395379066467,
0.21831050515174866,
0.1667824685573578,
-0.3059884309768677,
-0.3386538028717041,
-0.0437728613615036,
-0.9673887491226196,
0.21852849423885345,
-0.253431499004364,
-0.6759722232818604,
-0.5569775104522705,
0.32428422570228577,
-0.6179350018501282,
0.6221734285354614,
0.6606282591819763,
-0.47451090812683105,
0.5158782601356506,
-0.9116647839546204,
-0.48892754316329956,
0.27344220876693726,
-0.303219199180603,
-0.03429168090224266,
-0.4285493791103363,
-0.03297768533229828,
0.10065876692533493,
0.19045384228229523,
-0.129936084151268,
-0.30273735523223877,
0.004189923871308565,
0.5747177004814148,
-0.10823474824428558,
0.7452255487442017,
0.41838908195495605,
-0.024577707052230835,
0.13420483469963074,
-0.3921469748020172,
0.13684476912021637,
0.17196469008922577,
-0.40176811814308167,
-0.28532445430755615,
0.13742029666900635,
-0.5908937454223633,
0.08017227053642273,
-0.03692081198096275,
-0.4374397397041321,
0.4012625515460968,
-0.3805030882358551,
0.4394247829914093,
0.7835185527801514,
0.6858384609222412,
0.4094073176383972,
-0.5384349226951599,
0.5862823128700256,
0.10475628823041916,
-0.017621077597141266,
-0.033691368997097015,
-0.4919370114803314,
-0.6909412145614624,
-0.08354244381189346,
0.07481888681650162,
0.38921794295310974,
-1.240116000175476,
0.13755302131175995,
-0.0056106895208358765,
-0.07378808408975601,
0.07286538928747177,
0.3412083089351654,
0.33422979712486267,
0.48338472843170166,
0.047616951167583466,
-0.3848591148853302,
-0.47290652990341187,
-0.2385593205690384,
0.08511664718389511,
-0.4431909918785095,
0.32990762591362,
0.6729284524917603,
0.40803262591362,
-0.34594449400901794,
1.1228944063186646,
-0.629158616065979,
-0.10865166038274765,
-0.6801351308822632,
0.5227844715118408,
-0.24997040629386902,
0.2784707546234131,
0.513103187084198,
-0.7388016581535339,
-0.4421772360801697,
0.31467026472091675,
-0.8726181387901306,
0.45028987526893616,
-0.1608421951532364,
-0.2909386157989502,
0.11481790244579315,
0.38527166843414307,
-0.6804088354110718,
0.37818560004234314,
0.18689921498298645,
-0.5138059854507446,
0.2429955154657364,
-0.14485685527324677,
0.1380193531513214,
-0.886185884475708,
-0.4446931481361389,
-0.047731127589941025,
-0.8807847499847412,
-0.5051295161247253,
-0.4191752076148987,
-0.5000969767570496,
-0.07170367985963821,
-0.14609022438526154,
0.546565055847168,
-0.3621518611907959,
-0.16994626820087433,
-0.2756381332874298,
0.4545668065547943,
0.13805727660655975,
0.6905911564826965,
0.3363593816757202,
0.6647179126739502,
0.06091250479221344,
-0.828248143196106,
0.46880751848220825,
0.6486663818359375,
-0.37204092741012573,
0.43158477544784546,
-0.4614672064781189,
0.2616540789604187,
-0.25023993849754333,
0.39765048027038574,
-0.9527958035469055,
-0.22844965755939484,
0.49716976284980774,
-0.5030688643455505,
0.28132739663124084,
-0.20696522295475006,
-0.18249544501304626,
-0.24051254987716675,
0.18528661131858826,
-0.1296442300081253,
0.5086433291435242,
-0.4354594647884369,
0.5752090811729431,
0.6940577030181885,
-0.12587979435920715,
-0.5068008899688721,
0.10739044845104218,
-0.219011127948761,
0.06067744642496109,
-0.5491154193878174,
-0.09987294673919678,
0.2667679488658905,
-0.35541293025016785,
0.3390062749385834,
0.14550234377384186,
-0.2520926892757416,
0.19868116080760956,
0.2146078199148178,
0.027287129312753677,
-0.10275046527385712,
0.3564382493495941,
0.048063527792692184,
-0.14039912819862366,
0.10912451893091202,
-0.7366612553596497,
0.5445263981819153,
0.034999389201402664,
-0.1731177568435669,
-0.45570051670074463,
0.11778108030557632,
0.24975623190402985,
0.01184904109686613,
0.5784673094749451,
0.3910002112388611,
-0.12462314963340759,
-0.48175758123397827,
-0.13246481120586395,
-0.3040900230407715,
-0.5406209826469421,
0.37884923815727234,
-0.3533734381198883,
-0.7683131098747253,
0.32315945625305176,
-0.7924538254737854,
-0.040356844663619995,
0.17449404299259186,
0.10523131489753723,
-0.384555459022522,
1.3661977052688599,
0.6891665458679199,
0.20875118672847748,
0.9359772205352783,
-0.5793017745018005,
0.028476785868406296,
-0.47903066873550415,
-0.4739847779273987,
-0.3777816593647003,
-0.022887814790010452,
-0.41676613688468933,
-0.3983597457408905,
0.18428413569927216,
0.12976109981536865,
-0.5036711692810059,
0.3220134377479553,
-0.20678353309631348,
0.36014485359191895,
0.6490399241447449,
0.3364594876766205,
0.3925156593322754,
-0.057147640734910965,
-0.2050640881061554,
0.2768339514732361,
-0.7316791415214539,
-0.3537847101688385,
0.9064182043075562,
0.12284567207098007,
0.6916666030883789,
0.14567676186561584,
0.6178852915763855,
0.8536685705184937,
0.11310099810361862,
-0.7733393311500549,
0.3899938762187958,
0.5895283818244934,
-0.15795476734638214,
-0.7151806354522705,
-0.5868254899978638,
-1.1541333198547363,
0.11685238033533096,
-0.17108154296875,
-0.9279876351356506,
0.31564146280288696,
0.16625584661960602,
-0.08164844661951065,
0.05518735572695732,
-0.6494228839874268,
0.8768885135650635,
-0.23869557678699493,
-0.025290602818131447,
-0.5489562749862671,
-0.5524019002914429,
0.016475699841976166,
0.3089437484741211,
-0.05647535249590874,
-0.03442396596074104,
0.24428626894950867,
0.6674392819404602,
-0.5600014925003052,
0.8956907987594604,
-0.6456820964813232,
0.1683128923177719,
0.6447017192840576,
0.09233222901821136,
0.9453961849212646,
0.09501904994249344,
0.22374327480793,
-0.18619094789028168,
-0.0920834094285965,
-0.34990394115448,
-1.1774730682373047,
-0.0017763348296284676,
-1.200548529624939,
-0.5455973744392395,
-0.4059600234031677,
-0.5676326155662537,
-0.45867419242858887,
0.3639841675758362,
-0.24465882778167725,
0.1707095056772232,
-0.5068768858909607,
-0.04732218384742737,
0.6938241124153137,
-0.04469934478402138,
0.06307346373796463,
0.6871982216835022,
-0.40107259154319763,
-0.4261397123336792,
1.0106059312820435,
-0.015430251136422157,
0.5525041818618774,
0.39051175117492676,
0.04851583391427994,
-0.3988891839981079,
-0.4385002553462982,
-0.21485763788223267,
0.12951287627220154,
-0.8345892429351807,
-0.04790158569812775,
-0.5649594664573669,
-0.4060613214969635,
-0.3643953502178192,
0.039680082350969315,
0.14440757036209106,
-0.5378642678260803,
0.00011403166718082502,
-0.5077115297317505,
0.5765764117240906,
1.20037043094635,
-0.04881560057401657,
0.5586122870445251,
-0.49856996536254883,
0.02011840231716633,
0.6955834031105042,
-0.08326838165521622,
-0.10306072980165482,
-0.13981865346431732,
-0.34113648533821106,
0.22370530664920807,
-0.6143952012062073,
-0.9977105259895325,
0.2688796818256378,
0.17920386791229248,
0.8799647688865662,
0.743661642074585,
0.13966727256774902,
0.47084304690361023,
-0.06986071914434433,
0.4895927906036377,
0.23801074922084808,
-0.6794257760047913,
0.6844515800476074,
-0.24388770759105682,
-0.1416012942790985,
0.3782042860984802,
0.529228687286377,
-0.7918756008148193,
-0.4229077994823456,
-0.7431647181510925,
-0.2542783319950104,
0.848036527633667,
-0.1473909169435501,
0.07064906507730484,
-0.154963880777359,
0.21212349832057953,
-0.049545928835868835,
0.4925546944141388,
-0.33388277888298035,
0.018360765650868416,
-0.530319094657898,
0.05831054225564003,
-0.10000409930944443,
-0.14940926432609558,
-0.4936502277851105,
-0.24600102007389069,
0.6330373883247375,
-0.5090764164924622,
0.4856759309768677,
0.058024775236845016,
-0.40340712666511536,
-0.06929945945739746,
0.05404001474380493,
0.3736959993839264,
0.5756642818450928,
-0.09704894572496414,
-0.03301927447319031,
0.08821417391300201,
-0.20142892003059387,
0.10565792769193649,
0.0005485992878675461,
-0.1364470273256302,
-0.08052311837673187,
0.1378258317708969,
1.1177486181259155,
0.34345096349716187,
-0.5644153952598572,
0.5352635383605957,
-0.12208449840545654,
-0.31713059544563293,
-0.4395786225795746,
0.47970107197761536,
-0.08279795199632645,
0.5279009938240051,
0.014519279822707176,
-0.06691845506429672,
0.010666041634976864,
-0.739442765712738,
0.5582236051559448,
0.4952181875705719,
-0.6381061673164368,
-0.08306702971458435,
0.1255723237991333,
0.3988172709941864,
-0.49002543091773987,
0.9987208843231201,
-0.41340452432632446,
-0.5743744969367981,
0.5265921354293823,
0.7629486322402954,
0.5690137147903442,
0.10324225574731827,
0.9207614660263062,
0.23366011679172516,
-0.07594138383865356,
0.21373477578163147,
0.2512763738632202,
-0.6580371856689453,
-1.193516492843628,
-0.12746137380599976,
-0.28044775128364563,
-0.8708165884017944,
-0.3521353006362915,
-0.49029088020324707,
0.07961704581975937,
-0.6893321871757507,
-0.29452407360076904,
-0.06290831416845322,
0.29540637135505676,
-0.6234285831451416,
-0.13132445514202118,
-0.15925069153308868,
0.7452701330184937,
-0.6496602296829224,
0.8735636472702026,
0.34540408849716187,
-0.8914763927459717,
-1.0438992977142334,
-0.2976057231426239,
-0.18604281544685364,
-1.2387555837631226,
0.8294130563735962,
-0.17953304946422577,
-0.19499193131923676,
0.05141042545437813,
-0.6558258533477783,
-0.7990637421607971,
1.0954023599624634,
0.31792494654655457,
0.05554088205099106,
-0.26549965143203735,
0.10305456817150116,
0.3069086968898773,
-0.46952950954437256,
0.5610453486442566,
0.4268133044242859,
0.5471483469009399,
0.43065145611763,
-0.4047166407108307,
-0.11352581530809402,
-0.17763559520244598,
-0.040206413716077805,
0.11684617400169373,
-0.6793736219406128,
0.7061306238174438,
-0.3254750370979309,
-0.27647140622138977,
-0.1808435022830963,
0.7638320922851562,
-0.10844016820192337,
0.26195552945137024,
0.6164060831069946,
0.1360289454460144,
1.3595178127288818,
-0.04024890065193176,
1.078991174697876,
-0.3618176281452179,
0.2780097424983978,
1.0219773054122925,
-0.1420263797044754,
0.3234611749649048,
0.13459612429141998,
-0.07178889214992523,
1.2282785177230835,
0.6930579543113708,
0.3238834738731384,
0.6091150641441345,
-0.011344029568135738,
-0.5236484408378601,
-0.537290632724762,
-0.43037742376327515,
-0.14527268707752228,
0.3284379839897156,
0.7238641977310181,
-0.4060913324356079,
-0.19409017264842987,
0.11599738895893097,
0.010092140175402164,
-0.0014550958294421434,
-0.1536426544189453,
1.4047247171401978,
0.09759528934955597,
-0.9214295744895935,
0.2713439464569092,
-0.28702738881111145,
-0.2289552390575409,
-0.803534209728241,
-0.5940260887145996,
0.11940828710794449,
0.09409549832344055,
-0.26861318945884705,
-0.7513071894645691,
-0.07147037237882614,
-0.5222277641296387,
-0.057501211762428284,
-0.4087371230125427,
0.7661517262458801,
-0.36736464500427246,
0.0025756715331226587,
0.2858704626560211,
0.45795542001724243,
0.16744312644004822,
0.32247474789619446,
-0.6093246936798096,
-0.38726797699928284,
0.04611562564969063,
-0.14045877754688263,
0.2540254294872284,
0.5842535495758057,
-0.184487983584404,
0.8101201057434082,
0.6696054935455322,
0.15446098148822784,
0.008212198503315449,
0.016057446599006653,
0.9338716268539429,
-0.5146145224571228,
-0.5809228420257568,
-0.25072425603866577,
0.29099008440971375,
-0.5884378552436829,
0.05451474338769913,
0.7922709584236145,
0.1733435094356537,
0.9757036566734314,
0.34550711512565613,
1.165627360343933,
-0.05932990461587906,
0.34728991985321045,
-0.4855028986930847,
0.39816102385520935,
-0.11366491764783859,
-0.15050539374351501,
-0.14175133407115936,
-0.3516806364059448,
0.31560656428337097,
0.938677966594696,
-0.4424339532852173,
0.06530290842056274,
0.7638794779777527,
0.6605402827262878,
0.3538739085197449,
0.3356172740459442,
0.30174389481544495,
0.09814903885126114,
0.38052427768707275,
0.5415884256362915,
1.3246513605117798,
-0.0023124993313103914,
0.6803412437438965,
-0.10290944576263428,
-0.17759957909584045,
-0.18276409804821014,
-0.23864619433879852,
-0.912010908126831,
-0.5211342573165894,
-0.06712693721055984,
-0.7794099450111389,
0.4360068142414093,
1.0028941631317139,
0.7923550009727478,
-0.6149981617927551,
-0.2850510776042938,
-0.22216805815696716,
0.9306889772415161,
-0.45765677094459534,
-0.2161693125963211,
0.0010174144990742207,
-0.8566454648971558,
-0.6417697668075562,
0.385804146528244,
0.09395837038755417,
0.10993719846010208,
-0.24657467007637024,
-0.7238419055938721,
-0.1226847693324089,
0.19995495676994324,
0.4227847158908844,
0.8834758400917053,
-0.28686967492103577,
-0.5974183082580566,
-0.2841506898403168,
-0.11486420780420303,
0.29962489008903503,
1.118170142173767,
-0.8724378943443298,
0.7623812556266785,
0.4609149396419525,
0.6662558317184448,
0.8439256548881531,
0.14854857325553894,
0.8706632256507874,
-0.49733319878578186,
0.20692817866802216,
0.1908876597881317,
0.17720496654510498,
0.043492790311574936,
-0.49466267228126526,
0.2252558320760727,
0.39458853006362915,
-0.4341149628162384,
-0.4678935706615448,
0.516067624092102,
-0.7193471789360046,
-0.18479566276073456,
0.9298493266105652,
-0.3912808299064636,
-0.23760256171226501,
-0.6304914951324463,
-0.328827828168869,
0.35119467973709106,
-0.8045647740364075,
0.5415424704551697,
0.47229790687561035,
-0.47626277804374695,
-0.05616886913776398,
-0.21574218571186066,
0.7868497371673584,
-0.14359118044376373,
-0.817374587059021,
-0.2885691523551941,
0.5789615511894226,
0.22755886614322662,
0.16196797788143158,
1.0208094120025635,
0.16889163851737976,
0.3677407503128052,
0.3388154208660126,
-0.2309376299381256,
-0.2621639370918274,
-0.6085760593414307,
0.16005712747573853,
0.20652805268764496,
0.5118341445922852,
-0.1603614240884781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19497v1 | Inclusivity in Large Language Models: Personality Traits and Gender Bias in Scientific Abstracts | 2024-06-27T19:26:11 | 2024-06-27T19:26:11 | Naseela Pervez, Alexander J. Titus | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly utilized to assist in
scientific and academic writing, helping authors enhance the coherence of their
articles. Previous studies have highlighted stereotypes and biases present in
LLM outputs, emphasizing the need to evaluate these models for their alignment
with human narrative styles and potential gender biases. In this study, we
assess the alignment of three prominent LLMs - Claude 3 Opus, Mistral AI Large,
and Gemini 1.5 Flash - by analyzing their performance on benchmark
text-generation tasks for scientific abstracts. We employ the Linguistic
Inquiry and Word Count (LIWC) framework to extract lexical, psychological, and
social features from the generated texts. Our findings indicate that, while
these models generally produce text closely resembling human authored content,
variations in stylistic features suggest significant gender biases. This
research highlights the importance of developing LLMs that maintain a diversity
of writing styles to promote inclusivity in academic discourse. | [
-0.34141290187835693,
-0.3208909332752228,
0.7288341522216797,
0.4179033041000366,
0.17374566197395325,
0.15352575480937958,
-0.28587308526039124,
-0.65822833776474,
0.3268784284591675,
0.37021711468696594,
-0.43753233551979065,
-0.5320701599121094,
-0.7757982611656189,
0.7154461145401001,
-0.6737025380134583,
1.0661753416061401,
-0.07378402352333069,
0.38320547342300415,
-0.42988377809524536,
-0.1614372581243515,
-0.2731776535511017,
-0.4601496756076813,
-0.22893500328063965,
-0.4367443919181824,
0.7547573447227478,
0.2551034986972809,
0.611342191696167,
0.6387907862663269,
0.530875027179718,
0.21621623635292053,
-0.02703903429210186,
0.11910881102085114,
-0.4139460325241089,
0.39422062039375305,
-0.15612755715847015,
-0.3327775299549103,
-0.6045976877212524,
-0.10209845751523972,
0.7396577000617981,
0.7969956994056702,
0.27999746799468994,
0.2140587717294693,
0.27151697874069214,
0.579210102558136,
-0.35899728536605835,
0.026250336319208145,
-0.3981766998767853,
-0.0569973848760128,
-0.411205530166626,
-0.08355822414159775,
-0.3046160936355591,
-0.44083118438720703,
0.534590482711792,
-0.43204063177108765,
0.3105882704257965,
0.17648151516914368,
0.4889410138130188,
-0.09331042319536209,
-0.5048937201499939,
-0.48608294129371643,
-0.47866570949554443,
0.8615883588790894,
-0.8041141629219055,
0.041593726724386215,
-0.05775252729654312,
-0.3054961562156677,
-0.11279290169477463,
-0.3804992437362671,
-0.6695179343223572,
-0.1662190556526184,
-0.03413715586066246,
-0.06888959556818008,
-0.12944425642490387,
-0.25199148058891296,
0.2761540710926056,
0.11275240033864975,
-0.5671466588973999,
0.5063338875770569,
-0.4177824854850769,
0.03301648795604706,
0.805711030960083,
0.2720333933830261,
0.2765785753726959,
-0.09387558698654175,
0.10828318446874619,
-0.09347271919250488,
-0.8973937630653381,
-0.17387157678604126,
0.8091350793838501,
0.3522680997848511,
-0.26312538981437683,
0.7646118998527527,
0.004830004647374153,
0.34599554538726807,
-0.02252034656703472,
-0.1876804679632187,
0.2832624912261963,
-0.3030492663383484,
0.31900644302368164,
0.4890099763870239,
0.9578661322593689,
0.3641810715198517,
0.39129072427749634,
0.10347259789705276,
0.08426737040281296,
-0.11533316969871521,
0.3226267099380493,
-0.7877928614616394,
0.10389019548892975,
0.23159517347812653,
-0.608860969543457,
-0.46123218536376953,
0.1591685712337494,
-0.7303367257118225,
-0.6454187035560608,
-0.13393233716487885,
0.09898610413074493,
-0.2674717605113983,
-0.2565102279186249,
-0.31712743639945984,
-0.17625954747200012,
0.2517504394054413,
0.33167192339897156,
-1.081640362739563,
0.3490074872970581,
0.7080180048942566,
0.8307749629020691,
-0.5968922972679138,
-0.21883593499660492,
-0.37019312381744385,
0.16875454783439636,
-0.36090099811553955,
0.43615323305130005,
-0.5362200736999512,
-0.5096146464347839,
0.09898564219474792,
-0.21493563055992126,
0.19981059432029724,
-0.29073065519332886,
0.49813613295555115,
0.039056453853845596,
0.29203900694847107,
-0.5420346856117249,
-0.5172399878501892,
0.02071789652109146,
-0.05387704819440842,
-0.3869191110134125,
0.8841094970703125,
-0.07000511884689331,
-0.8803956508636475,
0.38109374046325684,
-0.5938954949378967,
-0.29644590616226196,
-0.010887966491281986,
-0.6466566920280457,
-0.35642197728157043,
0.22053636610507965,
0.014253053814172745,
0.5719326734542847,
-0.28254562616348267,
0.4519820213317871,
-0.3543644845485687,
-0.11598615348339081,
0.6892931461334229,
-0.04639405012130737,
0.306918203830719,
0.0436507984995842,
-0.5076019763946533,
0.3628639280796051,
-0.6405726075172424,
-0.33690300583839417,
-0.0734613761305809,
-0.1802256852388382,
-0.4042338728904724,
0.24615561962127686,
0.09270819276571274,
0.13678483664989471,
0.23407411575317383,
-0.7460573315620422,
0.1702672839164734,
-0.2815989553928375,
0.42898884415626526,
0.7209095358848572,
-0.2636635899543762,
0.4904043674468994,
-0.394962877035141,
0.37155961990356445,
-0.058868441730737686,
-0.22093552350997925,
-0.16961254179477692,
-0.5450202822685242,
-0.5734180808067322,
-0.4404509663581848,
0.14051131904125214,
0.11278202384710312,
-0.20624783635139465,
0.38193389773368835,
-0.27487826347351074,
-0.5972849726676941,
-0.47908318042755127,
0.20770086348056793,
0.4299556314945221,
0.45874378085136414,
0.1337677538394928,
-0.2048359513282776,
-0.4641472399234772,
-1.265167236328125,
-0.40680399537086487,
0.033885445445775986,
-0.16033920645713806,
0.30360648036003113,
0.8892439007759094,
-0.17966870963573456,
0.8524234890937805,
-0.2747066020965576,
0.05736830458045006,
-0.3001183867454529,
0.32654717564582825,
0.1475628912448883,
0.44171831011772156,
0.5967926979064941,
-0.43970397114753723,
-0.3655029535293579,
-0.1175638809800148,
-0.8599870204925537,
-0.5162937045097351,
0.2916412651538849,
0.10715316236019135,
0.3587382137775421,
0.45056450366973877,
-0.47113296389579773,
0.27697455883026123,
0.5676170587539673,
-0.384208083152771,
0.7594718933105469,
0.054842766374349594,
-0.00023450655862689018,
-0.6668437123298645,
0.12153096497058868,
0.3503888249397278,
-0.1349971443414688,
-0.6317708492279053,
-0.16971555352210999,
-0.01275743916630745,
0.10730288922786713,
-0.18779025971889496,
0.7568654417991638,
-0.6712219715118408,
-0.1262134164571762,
-0.316152423620224,
0.17979523539543152,
0.0056611960753798485,
-0.13925227522850037,
0.3602813482284546,
0.556354284286499,
0.34885141253471375,
-0.6200910806655884,
-0.261685848236084,
0.27026882767677307,
-0.30283400416374207,
0.4617519676685333,
-0.8198890686035156,
-0.02923363260924816,
-0.30509278178215027,
0.33022060990333557,
-1.0360544919967651,
-0.4023023247718811,
-0.13035397231578827,
-0.3013076186180115,
0.38961607217788696,
0.46166402101516724,
-0.5142608284950256,
-0.2920825183391571,
-0.5711269974708557,
0.5535768270492554,
0.2994949519634247,
-0.2038884162902832,
0.4581858813762665,
0.2770708501338959,
-0.6836138963699341,
-0.5433796048164368,
-0.5267611145973206,
-0.0035786214284598827,
-0.19613873958587646,
-0.6275967955589294,
0.41339635848999023,
-0.13577285408973694,
-0.7067488431930542,
-0.3089580237865448,
0.007301182020455599,
0.4118092358112335,
-0.09337110072374344,
0.2654181122779846,
0.505862832069397,
-0.14409908652305603,
-0.02842315100133419,
0.2150915414094925,
0.3194533884525299,
0.0653572529554367,
-0.016394471749663353,
0.6317620873451233,
-0.12021847814321518,
-0.06894995272159576,
-0.17890548706054688,
0.6061631441116333,
0.6403281688690186,
0.06372077763080597,
0.8091862797737122,
0.41084352135658264,
0.009313199669122696,
0.03658047690987587,
-0.5766850709915161,
-0.39421889185905457,
-0.34603607654571533,
0.3441779315471649,
0.011002429760992527,
-1.2379933595657349,
0.5570951700210571,
0.37334734201431274,
0.19937382638454437,
0.554818868637085,
0.7333518266677856,
-0.14353178441524506,
1.0669145584106445,
0.6810237169265747,
0.17545340955257416,
0.1938127726316452,
0.14145736396312714,
0.06326476484537125,
-1.06893789768219,
-0.16407084465026855,
-0.8418454527854919,
-0.4100325107574463,
-0.7138010859489441,
-0.121441550552845,
0.46127113699913025,
-0.4533301889896393,
-0.5070314407348633,
-0.05606641247868538,
-0.7242575883865356,
0.06021255627274513,
0.37433022260665894,
-0.3087914288043976,
0.34997716546058655,
-0.0005046837613917887,
0.00679726293310523,
-0.4617665112018585,
-0.47959449887275696,
-0.8077036738395691,
1.323485016822815,
0.698829174041748,
0.7102735042572021,
0.28565964102745056,
0.4133414626121521,
0.16258877515792847,
0.6230792999267578,
-0.44150277972221375,
0.4620034098625183,
-0.09026045352220535,
-0.6947450041770935,
-0.19674843549728394,
-0.38426443934440613,
-0.754753589630127,
0.25161880254745483,
-0.4654441773891449,
-1.0095359086990356,
0.4045468866825104,
-0.12892106175422668,
-0.09676879644393921,
-0.02117961458861828,
-0.18951624631881714,
0.5142396092414856,
-0.32207033038139343,
-0.45625439286231995,
0.039304327219724655,
-0.6772828698158264,
0.7316178679466248,
-0.3307449519634247,
0.3608604371547699,
-0.19831372797489166,
-0.3419318199157715,
0.7850780487060547,
-0.2775830924510956,
0.9242269992828369,
0.2939631938934326,
-0.42336687445640564,
-0.15874607861042023,
0.23999986052513123,
0.37215107679367065,
0.06632060557603836,
-0.09816505014896393,
0.47622618079185486,
-0.05524355173110962,
-0.11932791024446487,
0.0016662349225953221,
0.8541591763496399,
-1.0022156238555908,
-0.49255725741386414,
-0.6980348229408264,
-0.7840896844863892,
-0.06285272538661957,
0.0913061648607254,
0.4336811602115631,
0.4624968469142914,
-0.2705094814300537,
0.222789004445076,
0.7598210573196411,
-0.6187679171562195,
0.5141947865486145,
0.5673108100891113,
-0.49033278226852417,
-0.2920457422733307,
0.5164146423339844,
0.07711223512887955,
0.46618789434432983,
0.2485256791114807,
0.08492130041122437,
-0.16014143824577332,
-0.5802882313728333,
-0.17871828377246857,
0.5610026121139526,
-0.37000536918640137,
0.08803173899650574,
-1.0063703060150146,
-0.18879780173301697,
-0.6481549739837646,
-0.2742503881454468,
-0.3219548761844635,
-0.430483341217041,
-0.38925936818122864,
0.14525152742862701,
0.2839585244655609,
0.8535860180854797,
0.26746949553489685,
0.309519499540329,
-0.5151721835136414,
0.10523756593465805,
-0.09213176369667053,
-0.10031146556138992,
0.023615945130586624,
-0.5555082559585571,
0.09270399808883667,
-0.38023364543914795,
-0.5038909316062927,
-0.9147481918334961,
0.546764075756073,
0.12076651304960251,
0.31921204924583435,
0.3663046360015869,
-0.2803410589694977,
0.03826143965125084,
-0.4677787125110626,
0.9534883499145508,
0.4629892110824585,
-0.8294594287872314,
0.2590917646884918,
-0.7810675501823425,
0.46139630675315857,
0.39153558015823364,
0.4839290380477905,
-0.39574146270751953,
-0.8654006719589233,
-0.4949846863746643,
-0.9495024085044861,
0.47387707233428955,
0.37979140877723694,
0.12201590090990067,
-0.14538629353046417,
0.28125545382499695,
0.59989333152771,
0.6045357584953308,
-0.9017658233642578,
-0.42497318983078003,
-0.10959815233945847,
-0.4321300983428955,
-0.0344848595559597,
-0.4023348391056061,
-0.29564234614372253,
-0.19274860620498657,
0.6462998986244202,
-0.28847602009773254,
0.10261698067188263,
0.3357081711292267,
0.16936452686786652,
0.08163896203041077,
0.4340537190437317,
1.0145072937011719,
0.8506341576576233,
-0.11583113670349121,
0.13236406445503235,
-0.05992475524544716,
-0.6018028855323792,
0.07370717078447342,
-0.005142230540513992,
-0.42140862345695496,
0.049634501338005066,
0.4983571767807007,
0.3965575397014618,
0.22432449460029602,
-0.6293802261352539,
0.3588865399360657,
-0.1940455287694931,
-0.3560541868209839,
-0.3086540997028351,
0.19469982385635376,
0.17872372269630432,
0.14039567112922668,
0.5374109745025635,
-0.0372285358607769,
0.1463330090045929,
-0.7120947241783142,
-0.4226516783237457,
0.6233140230178833,
-0.1930677443742752,
-0.22783637046813965,
0.7698310613632202,
0.25794681906700134,
-0.012954292818903923,
0.2887008488178253,
0.06376538425683975,
-0.2793150842189789,
0.48983973264694214,
0.5366832613945007,
0.894263505935669,
0.03171869367361069,
0.12077528983354568,
0.4093306064605713,
0.3729616105556488,
-0.1462925225496292,
0.18171310424804688,
0.2736209034919739,
-0.6477677822113037,
-0.4328893721103668,
-0.7763625979423523,
-0.4127837121486664,
0.10895872116088867,
-0.4395846426486969,
0.327858567237854,
-0.31447046995162964,
-0.1324448585510254,
0.28933611512184143,
-0.25777262449264526,
-0.48060372471809387,
-0.2592970132827759,
0.3965589106082916,
0.7074925303459167,
-0.6597869992256165,
0.44573870301246643,
0.5939403176307678,
-0.13890109956264496,
-0.6845353245735168,
-0.17641128599643707,
0.3635351061820984,
-0.297335147857666,
0.8673955798149109,
0.22975753247737885,
0.07705214619636536,
-0.2525050938129425,
-0.72365802526474,
-0.9328312277793884,
0.8543825149536133,
0.3279639780521393,
-0.8602074384689331,
0.10222569853067398,
0.1308482140302658,
0.6177940964698792,
-0.841982901096344,
0.473198264837265,
0.5167718529701233,
0.6492919921875,
-0.1436949223279953,
-1.1049423217773438,
0.06396663188934326,
-0.28431642055511475,
0.05723364278674126,
-0.020798135548830032,
-0.6310710906982422,
1.0147818326950073,
-0.06770479679107666,
0.23322123289108276,
0.25726810097694397,
0.8905031681060791,
0.6273394823074341,
0.21500343084335327,
0.03540648892521858,
0.162870854139328,
0.8380778431892395,
-0.11759606003761292,
1.026560664176941,
-0.17004042863845825,
-0.1768038123846054,
0.9770137667655945,
-0.5868076682090759,
0.45862069725990295,
0.49544477462768555,
-0.04724782332777977,
0.7092263102531433,
0.30637291073799133,
-0.02472146786749363,
0.12782737612724304,
0.2927563190460205,
-0.29984644055366516,
0.12369908392429352,
-0.1531449258327484,
-0.5460630655288696,
0.4738634526729584,
0.35537537932395935,
-0.7281789183616638,
0.08464828133583069,
-0.12346498668193817,
0.3691616356372833,
0.13376611471176147,
-0.4211006760597229,
0.5869322419166565,
0.2826841473579407,
-0.8903976678848267,
0.060774412006139755,
0.06548874825239182,
0.9445284605026245,
-0.6361767053604126,
0.18586447834968567,
-0.10644958168268204,
0.03420664742588997,
-0.5288829803466797,
-0.9385470151901245,
0.03084954433143139,
0.30936989188194275,
-0.5213865637779236,
-0.18126718699932098,
0.6810944080352783,
-0.42683109641075134,
-0.5508519411087036,
-0.1146240234375,
0.37694963812828064,
0.3428938090801239,
0.13659432530403137,
-0.2219773828983307,
0.27787140011787415,
-0.12117275595664978,
-0.1138424426317215,
0.6345252990722656,
0.21541890501976013,
-0.23125463724136353,
0.5850287079811096,
0.4659208655357361,
0.2755914330482483,
0.04717850685119629,
0.11133560538291931,
0.47490671277046204,
-0.5580676198005676,
-0.18949104845523834,
-1.115884780883789,
0.3731708526611328,
-0.25155067443847656,
-0.47772467136383057,
1.1043200492858887,
0.7047015428543091,
0.21351982653141022,
-0.14217129349708557,
0.9059569835662842,
-0.021948710083961487,
0.4154967665672302,
-0.14844109117984772,
0.7421202659606934,
-0.30330708622932434,
0.25077685713768005,
-0.6889747977256775,
-1.1465119123458862,
-0.1462833136320114,
0.3879229426383972,
-0.3069715201854706,
0.16034047305583954,
0.6594061255455017,
0.4080323278903961,
0.27924874424934387,
0.2090035378932953,
-0.08189507573843002,
0.3816100060939789,
0.3894367814064026,
0.15652884542942047,
0.8292680978775024,
-0.007644092198461294,
0.11311997473239899,
0.1603446751832962,
-0.35266736149787903,
-0.15578676760196686,
-1.2278072834014893,
-0.9534632563591003,
-0.2632351517677307,
-0.4718626141548157,
-0.3760240375995636,
-0.326236367225647,
0.8136778473854065,
0.30383360385894775,
-0.5788642764091492,
-0.3490809202194214,
0.06405527144670486,
0.09052716940641403,
0.0794970914721489,
-0.2941041886806488,
0.16955848038196564,
-0.08038823306560516,
-0.6543578505516052,
0.021888654679059982,
0.5922751426696777,
-0.11888422816991806,
-0.6349983215332031,
-0.03314729034900665,
0.012465769425034523,
0.27974042296409607,
0.5955536961555481,
0.18462112545967102,
-0.6666066646575928,
-0.36417192220687866,
0.10838668048381805,
-0.35147830843925476,
-0.0391809307038784,
0.7105199098587036,
-0.4676249921321869,
0.2313494086265564,
0.45120787620544434,
0.13134339451789856,
0.4147546887397766,
-0.1784888505935669,
0.89387047290802,
-0.7181963920593262,
-0.07831161469221115,
0.2619507610797882,
0.4440479278564453,
0.5377719402313232,
-0.3030383586883545,
0.4399343729019165,
0.02819724939763546,
-0.8278888463973999,
-1.0495175123214722,
-0.00574245722964406,
-1.114135980606079,
-0.23190349340438843,
1.2853738069534302,
0.3257885277271271,
-0.182295560836792,
-0.027854453772306442,
-0.20818011462688446,
-0.023970868438482285,
-0.4885397255420685,
0.7358211278915405,
1.0035405158996582,
-0.39799946546554565,
-0.023861564695835114,
-0.7431116700172424,
0.4575878977775574,
0.30221766233444214,
-0.8143367767333984,
0.024876030161976814,
0.5169230699539185,
0.3188524544239044,
0.36276039481163025,
0.5290634036064148,
-0.43303707242012024,
0.15318378806114197,
-0.29484841227531433,
0.3743760883808136,
0.23583123087882996,
-0.10693075507879257,
-0.12143190205097198,
0.1451593041419983,
0.1035907119512558,
0.7055715918540955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19493v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19493v1 | Development and Evaluation of a Retrieval-Augmented Generation Tool for Creating SAPPhIRE Models of Artificial Systems | 2024-06-27T19:20:09 | 2024-06-27T19:20:09 | Anubhab Majumder, Kausik Bhattacharya, Amaresh Chakrabarti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representing systems using the SAPPhIRE causality model is found useful in
supporting design-by-analogy. However, creating a SAPPhIRE model of artificial
or biological systems is an effort-intensive process that requires human
experts to source technical knowledge from multiple technical documents
regarding how the system works. This research investigates how to leverage
Large Language Models (LLMs) in creating structured descriptions of systems
using the SAPPhIRE model of causality. This paper, the second part of the
two-part research, presents a new Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) tool for
generating information related to SAPPhIRE constructs of artificial systems and
reports the results from a preliminary evaluation of the tool's success -
focusing on the factual accuracy and reliability of outcomes. | [
-0.11126276850700378,
-0.6179108023643494,
0.7512143850326538,
0.31707122921943665,
-0.18790559470653534,
0.07204417139291763,
-0.06553567200899124,
-0.3202011287212372,
0.41770678758621216,
0.3035980463027954,
-0.33984246850013733,
-0.19065789878368378,
-0.21159735321998596,
0.13253700733184814,
-0.6494183540344238,
0.8715527653694153,
0.08115143328905106,
0.16962389647960663,
-0.01704443246126175,
0.3585384488105774,
-0.6487786173820496,
-0.25722646713256836,
-0.6605314612388611,
-0.4128859043121338,
0.5681752562522888,
0.11684435606002808,
0.6394039988517761,
0.41756078600883484,
0.852755069732666,
0.3244612514972687,
-0.051994577050209045,
0.27912527322769165,
-0.37967145442962646,
0.2972864806652069,
-0.523004412651062,
-0.3677746653556824,
-0.502970278263092,
0.10871639847755432,
0.8409901261329651,
0.45510631799697876,
-0.3387238681316376,
0.5475161075592041,
0.14598770439624786,
0.2576944828033447,
-0.5824620723724365,
0.10741226375102997,
-0.6767711043357849,
0.19020481407642365,
-0.2508736550807953,
-0.4774557054042816,
-0.7055732607841492,
-0.46419620513916016,
-0.25582680106163025,
-0.6582651138305664,
-0.04006364941596985,
0.19845274090766907,
0.7291454076766968,
0.2884899973869324,
-0.3125116229057312,
-0.2511582374572754,
-1.234113335609436,
0.8817219138145447,
-0.8382044434547424,
0.21923735737800598,
0.19843025505542755,
0.4689558148384094,
-0.3858346939086914,
-0.7924533486366272,
-0.617922306060791,
-0.6247168779373169,
-0.3213585913181305,
0.12435603886842728,
0.018337998539209366,
-0.22334173321723938,
0.49396276473999023,
0.12157510221004486,
-0.3291206955909729,
-0.15758483111858368,
-0.5990651249885559,
-0.1669074147939682,
0.7694321870803833,
0.42959490418434143,
0.4643048942089081,
-0.7568471431732178,
-0.3907109200954437,
0.1656343638896942,
-0.7418597340583801,
-0.37115564942359924,
0.13471952080726624,
0.36784180998802185,
0.15884728729724884,
1.0353765487670898,
0.02987677790224552,
0.6799121499061584,
0.011625750921666622,
-0.32185155153274536,
-0.09754234552383423,
-0.33667388558387756,
-0.2229657620191574,
0.03526102378964424,
0.587578296661377,
0.03687373921275139,
-0.23783473670482635,
-0.4636918604373932,
-0.39909377694129944,
0.1698487251996994,
0.48904797434806824,
-0.7943251132965088,
0.06825052946805954,
0.08928007632493973,
-0.487559974193573,
-0.4267353117465973,
0.0896104946732521,
-0.364086389541626,
-0.49222299456596375,
-0.5137729048728943,
0.5406453609466553,
-0.48916980624198914,
-0.25690174102783203,
-0.09028962254524231,
-0.2852681875228882,
0.3944718837738037,
0.06144255772233009,
-0.4609093964099884,
0.30282124876976013,
0.7147114872932434,
0.6038225293159485,
-0.15747839212417603,
-0.08311063051223755,
-0.6284056305885315,
0.5055691599845886,
-0.5817649960517883,
0.7679952383041382,
-0.46179255843162537,
-0.6734346747398376,
-0.38671013712882996,
-0.31156986951828003,
0.16209231317043304,
-0.40579289197921753,
0.7714962959289551,
-0.6464363932609558,
-0.14693711698055267,
0.09248746931552887,
-0.4160749912261963,
0.011347470805048943,
0.046167366206645966,
-0.5104824900627136,
0.9386261105537415,
0.010834803804755211,
-0.6819445490837097,
0.3268029987812042,
-0.3380036950111389,
-0.3501461446285248,
0.391639769077301,
-0.5317096710205078,
-0.14872276782989502,
0.31762537360191345,
-0.46602341532707214,
0.3943397104740143,
-0.6450687050819397,
0.6591118574142456,
-0.24466338753700256,
-0.24786730110645294,
0.39762988686561584,
-0.25822892785072327,
0.5056926012039185,
0.1234239861369133,
-0.35728320479393005,
0.005068256985396147,
-0.9847797751426697,
0.11769220978021622,
-0.08300944417715073,
-0.6075463891029358,
-0.4778723418712616,
0.4823285639286041,
-0.23716318607330322,
0.1707371324300766,
0.2948375940322876,
-0.7228977084159851,
0.21831493079662323,
-0.23955613374710083,
0.2002863734960556,
0.6033868193626404,
0.05563686043024063,
0.3031908869743347,
-0.09718569368124008,
0.23503097891807556,
-0.324553906917572,
0.2089942991733551,
0.07476706057786942,
-0.2617862820625305,
-0.6874618530273438,
-0.048230063170194626,
0.32681283354759216,
0.704094409942627,
-0.7580013275146484,
0.1711035519838333,
-0.34554439783096313,
-0.5983545780181885,
0.08159264177083969,
-0.04376085102558136,
0.6990725994110107,
0.6084402203559875,
0.08246258646249771,
-0.3602072298526764,
-0.5930557250976562,
-1.1623502969741821,
-0.07731293886899948,
-0.24766720831394196,
-0.16350629925727844,
0.7037478685379028,
0.5288903117179871,
-0.27024343609809875,
0.9318593740463257,
-0.5149970054626465,
0.12846146523952484,
0.11830940842628479,
0.3076331615447998,
0.2534622848033905,
0.4635225236415863,
0.30043163895606995,
-0.6542593240737915,
-0.15064595639705658,
0.09064415842294693,
-0.9712154865264893,
0.1367347240447998,
0.1289641410112381,
-0.5555183291435242,
0.026764588430523872,
0.41175979375839233,
-0.6275102496147156,
0.5693410634994507,
0.22877635061740875,
-0.40801000595092773,
1.0709890127182007,
-0.31345072388648987,
0.30903568863868713,
-1.2013120651245117,
0.6139891147613525,
0.0727248415350914,
0.04926769807934761,
-0.48253029584884644,
0.13508570194244385,
-0.03605389595031738,
-0.37004774808883667,
-0.25521424412727356,
0.6446321606636047,
-0.44765952229499817,
-0.37522515654563904,
-0.12886691093444824,
0.28677642345428467,
-0.19954529404640198,
0.2985166609287262,
-0.12159687280654907,
0.9712684750556946,
0.002348038600757718,
-0.823647141456604,
0.46407920122146606,
0.3650204837322235,
-0.2425103783607483,
0.6834033727645874,
-0.881207287311554,
0.04772738367319107,
0.04196237772703171,
0.014951396733522415,
-0.39004188776016235,
-0.4363762140274048,
0.0627884492278099,
-0.5800008177757263,
0.32464951276779175,
-0.1315213143825531,
-0.5358802080154419,
-0.38201257586479187,
0.0163786169141531,
0.29567256569862366,
0.616873562335968,
-0.3035133183002472,
1.0072895288467407,
0.5190721750259399,
-0.3082317113876343,
-0.42458197474479675,
-0.4955269396305084,
0.27407750487327576,
-0.1251116842031479,
-0.7446643710136414,
0.4055526554584503,
0.03825347498059273,
-0.6846230030059814,
0.1992293894290924,
0.134564608335495,
0.09314896166324615,
0.17741182446479797,
0.26681607961654663,
0.6257250308990479,
-0.2949884831905365,
0.3356758952140808,
0.012851743027567863,
-0.1677972376346588,
0.20555716753005981,
0.027967477217316628,
0.43579351902008057,
0.17339807748794556,
-0.39861419796943665,
-0.24461324512958527,
0.21681228280067444,
0.23405620455741882,
-0.23506268858909607,
0.7527714967727661,
0.26386186480522156,
-0.431283175945282,
-0.42984074354171753,
-0.4825894832611084,
-0.09933961182832718,
-0.4343734681606293,
0.2504909932613373,
-0.3736363351345062,
-0.28752899169921875,
0.3746536374092102,
-0.26263347268104553,
0.15021009743213654,
0.6580080389976501,
0.2594526410102844,
0.05506956949830055,
1.0498961210250854,
0.692068338394165,
0.08751356601715088,
0.2834167778491974,
-0.0836598202586174,
0.2096404731273651,
-1.1626882553100586,
-0.34347692131996155,
-0.764670729637146,
0.017028674483299255,
-0.3283820152282715,
-0.5799464583396912,
0.5434751510620117,
0.35812708735466003,
-0.5896031856536865,
0.26615676283836365,
-0.5435327291488647,
-0.022264137864112854,
0.5567609071731567,
0.3733369708061218,
0.29909172654151917,
0.20901449024677277,
-0.21143673360347748,
0.06637535244226456,
-0.49791306257247925,
-0.84354168176651,
1.0314234495162964,
-0.0890660509467125,
0.9672327637672424,
0.37295129895210266,
0.5021042227745056,
0.46487829089164734,
0.3483770787715912,
-0.5256957411766052,
0.7228426933288574,
-0.20185530185699463,
-0.6289727091789246,
-0.3003288805484772,
-0.4495963454246521,
-0.9079827666282654,
-0.14403004944324493,
-0.5624494552612305,
-0.5682888627052307,
0.20887655019760132,
0.14107224345207214,
-0.593311607837677,
0.16661691665649414,
-0.3659682273864746,
0.2333051860332489,
-0.3330386281013489,
-0.6733642816543579,
-0.5264284014701843,
-0.33920755982398987,
0.7553094625473022,
-0.2871266305446625,
0.3324702978134155,
0.12823650240898132,
-0.01299257855862379,
0.6330655217170715,
-0.404657781124115,
0.7132377624511719,
0.028558069840073586,
-0.039269253611564636,
0.3364877998828888,
0.430534303188324,
0.5236001014709473,
0.05741680786013603,
-0.3920138478279114,
-0.3293669819831848,
-0.24438396096229553,
-0.06965368986129761,
-0.7023946642875671,
0.6621259450912476,
-0.5538913607597351,
-0.6870911717414856,
-0.24247746169567108,
-0.31756946444511414,
-0.13870254158973694,
0.31786975264549255,
-0.23714864253997803,
0.9299178719520569,
-0.3200250566005707,
-0.06902400404214859,
0.7612732648849487,
-0.6398705244064331,
0.017128806561231613,
0.5678572058677673,
-0.4462055563926697,
-0.28840482234954834,
1.0619442462921143,
-0.116621233522892,
0.06408407539129257,
0.0936705693602562,
0.02285226434469223,
0.20997188985347748,
-0.3670262396335602,
-0.5423922538757324,
0.39326462149620056,
-0.39181068539619446,
-0.25045955181121826,
-0.23883625864982605,
-0.6284811496734619,
-0.30409789085388184,
-0.016527211293578148,
-0.19424912333488464,
-0.6576734781265259,
-0.172310471534729,
0.04565715417265892,
0.26724177598953247,
1.2949211597442627,
-0.4148734509944916,
-0.019014131277799606,
-0.8965067267417908,
0.39448392391204834,
0.3504487872123718,
0.36828848719596863,
-0.02815711870789528,
-0.48976078629493713,
-0.4960392415523529,
-0.02771291323006153,
-0.39936476945877075,
-0.9288824796676636,
0.3733718991279602,
0.039783354848623276,
0.8367105722427368,
-0.00041792981210164726,
-0.21198076009750366,
0.5276138186454773,
-0.8193254470825195,
0.8363699316978455,
0.11113325506448746,
-0.7370449900627136,
0.7949989438056946,
-0.4633447825908661,
-0.37297388911247253,
0.05383986234664917,
0.19219274818897247,
-0.3377934694290161,
-0.11587762832641602,
-0.6286169290542603,
-0.8256605863571167,
0.540898323059082,
0.20161601901054382,
0.05155108496546745,
-0.03462202101945877,
0.8065342903137207,
-0.1570982187986374,
0.041113268584012985,
-0.4170757234096527,
-0.32025471329689026,
0.40245673060417175,
-0.0654766708612442,
-0.023663334548473358,
-0.6070985794067383,
-0.2295272946357727,
0.2160012125968933,
1.1548991203308105,
0.22192487120628357,
0.2668286859989166,
0.2613373100757599,
-0.1339440941810608,
-0.02450433559715748,
0.23099659383296967,
0.4396054744720459,
0.6605451703071594,
-0.07067560404539108,
-0.024773918092250824,
0.003509625792503357,
-0.35488027334213257,
0.16102975606918335,
0.1907275766134262,
-0.4692187011241913,
0.0058927983045578,
0.20259985327720642,
0.6998893022537231,
0.35323143005371094,
-0.4889533519744873,
0.06751091033220291,
-0.09005565941333771,
0.15445004403591156,
-0.4358676075935364,
0.17054662108421326,
-0.045637134462594986,
0.3952038586139679,
0.4912172257900238,
0.03864278644323349,
0.4499746263027191,
-0.4857773780822754,
0.3007107973098755,
0.6662558317184448,
-0.039784085005521774,
-0.20094077289104462,
0.6799036860466003,
0.3005492687225342,
-0.6784322261810303,
0.6943782567977905,
-0.3329930305480957,
-0.2639402449131012,
0.617148756980896,
0.4089356064796448,
0.721429169178009,
-0.30771148204803467,
0.2816973924636841,
0.726333737373352,
0.19950829446315765,
-0.08232799917459488,
0.1148563027381897,
-0.04499635845422745,
-0.5134370923042297,
-0.6650136113166809,
-0.9255554676055908,
-0.35169678926467896,
-0.33938509225845337,
-0.7004268765449524,
0.4277568757534027,
-0.23842452466487885,
-0.5855770111083984,
0.021437207236886024,
-0.10961908102035522,
-0.33715179562568665,
0.13279098272323608,
0.10909371078014374,
0.9372345209121704,
-0.7419763207435608,
0.3383026719093323,
0.5441320538520813,
-0.6994158625602722,
-1.4691797494888306,
-0.4323321580886841,
-0.4007650911808014,
-0.6463386416435242,
1.2663493156433105,
-0.653577446937561,
-0.40418291091918945,
-0.0806935727596283,
-0.5118719339370728,
-1.2511061429977417,
1.3503055572509766,
0.29735061526298523,
-0.3604363799095154,
-0.1963392198085785,
-0.024827977642416954,
0.568975031375885,
-0.04779331758618355,
0.3405357599258423,
0.3720734715461731,
0.3232835829257965,
0.0783400610089302,
-1.1365079879760742,
0.09688472002744675,
-0.42507991194725037,
0.2703356146812439,
0.11343560367822647,
-0.4619947671890259,
0.9515212178230286,
-0.09742188453674316,
-0.5081584453582764,
0.32515949010849,
0.684808611869812,
0.6668280363082886,
-0.02864324115216732,
0.1393260657787323,
0.38193249702453613,
0.5114247798919678,
0.1233818456530571,
1.2963237762451172,
-0.5917767882347107,
0.33829423785209656,
1.1756869554519653,
-0.18218238651752472,
0.9827523827552795,
0.34145742654800415,
-0.2772781550884247,
0.7943742871284485,
0.24964214861392975,
0.11454750597476959,
0.10839861631393433,
0.3520212471485138,
-0.32655420899391174,
-0.2421351671218872,
-0.07380148768424988,
-0.21242572367191315,
0.05401752144098282,
0.50352543592453,
-0.5096051096916199,
-0.15576627850532532,
-0.1401423215866089,
-0.19331824779510498,
-0.030433770269155502,
-0.3751290738582611,
0.7144412398338318,
0.15269359946250916,
-0.8288922309875488,
0.17027439177036285,
0.16622896492481232,
0.40656793117523193,
-0.42045530676841736,
-0.3690807819366455,
-0.2057362198829651,
0.18001310527324677,
-0.3327976167201996,
-0.6642293334007263,
0.3891885280609131,
0.23454549908638,
-0.3956417739391327,
0.19995097815990448,
0.9729733467102051,
-0.05628278851509094,
-0.9096180200576782,
0.10634337365627289,
0.3749663233757019,
0.42718714475631714,
0.5710864067077637,
-0.5523505806922913,
-0.010493585839867592,
-0.15525953471660614,
-0.26621565222740173,
-0.020350219681859016,
0.2848811745643616,
-0.19748133420944214,
0.8107300996780396,
0.398406982421875,
0.4736315906047821,
0.29219186305999756,
-0.08955376595258713,
0.6781599521636963,
-0.6528113484382629,
0.030754581093788147,
-0.6060736775398254,
0.5329079031944275,
-0.20630693435668945,
0.1348259299993515,
0.9944477081298828,
0.7444714903831482,
0.3485710024833679,
0.07526838779449463,
0.9431126713752747,
-0.2428145855665207,
0.8255239129066467,
-0.37648412585258484,
0.6152536273002625,
-0.5010561943054199,
0.4225091338157654,
-0.32696160674095154,
-0.822797954082489,
-0.09183833003044128,
0.5920417308807373,
-0.2012302279472351,
0.04097446799278259,
0.5094507336616516,
0.9354739189147949,
-0.08677265793085098,
-0.17565035820007324,
0.14195691049098969,
0.565105676651001,
0.30360475182533264,
0.09904669225215912,
1.0576248168945312,
-0.3512665331363678,
0.3579547703266144,
-0.07676386833190918,
-0.3598414361476898,
0.1223684549331665,
-0.8349021673202515,
-0.4498388171195984,
-0.4450666606426239,
-0.03983213007450104,
-0.5996219515800476,
0.08639686554670334,
0.5350322127342224,
0.47667622566223145,
-0.38939857482910156,
-0.4400673508644104,
-0.0296142790466547,
-0.12164322286844254,
0.4038645625114441,
-0.16287243366241455,
0.36212390661239624,
-0.5718805193901062,
-0.457220196723938,
0.3004254102706909,
0.30275851488113403,
-0.1545732468366623,
-0.6275352835655212,
0.03582116216421127,
0.06613727658987045,
0.45186519622802734,
0.8383893370628357,
0.3432265520095825,
-0.4262484908103943,
-0.2399471551179886,
0.058995749801397324,
-0.3109796941280365,
-0.42881831526756287,
0.8852646946907043,
-0.854485273361206,
0.022365108132362366,
0.28841444849967957,
0.3199564516544342,
0.47650524973869324,
0.041917260736227036,
0.8029772043228149,
-0.31515026092529297,
-0.10310214757919312,
-0.014938052743673325,
0.46377894282341003,
0.23587021231651306,
-0.4242130517959595,
0.6046878695487976,
0.037016384303569794,
-0.8589522242546082,
-0.8987097144126892,
0.2918192148208618,
-0.8369783163070679,
-0.2349461317062378,
1.3629398345947266,
0.11287659406661987,
-0.46859386563301086,
0.12233316153287888,
-0.4263167679309845,
0.3758777976036072,
-0.04206052049994469,
0.7013810873031616,
0.3322310149669647,
-0.2605672776699066,
0.6116210222244263,
-0.46751004457473755,
0.3293144404888153,
0.1197754368185997,
-0.7870795726776123,
-0.11173639446496964,
0.8369047045707703,
0.47260767221450806,
0.44208824634552,
0.5162971019744873,
-0.16996259987354279,
0.20292331278324127,
0.1698782593011856,
0.43232953548431396,
0.11672426015138626,
-0.15996630489826202,
-0.019284561276435852,
-0.1443903148174286,
0.1934816539287567,
0.3515167832374573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19486v1 | LoPT: Low-Rank Prompt Tuning for Parameter Efficient Language Models | 2024-06-27T19:02:41 | 2024-06-27T19:02:41 | Shouchang Guo, Sonam Damani, Keng-hao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET, cs.LG, eess.SP | In prompt tuning, a prefix or suffix text is added to the prompt, and the
embeddings (soft prompts) or token indices (hard prompts) of the prefix/suffix
are optimized to gain more control over language models for specific tasks.
This approach eliminates the need for hand-crafted prompt engineering or
explicit model fine-tuning. Prompt tuning is significantly more
parameter-efficient than model fine-tuning, as it involves optimizing partial
inputs of language models to produce desired outputs.
In this work, we aim to further reduce the amount of trainable parameters
required for a language model to perform well on specific tasks. We propose
Low-rank Prompt Tuning (LoPT), a low-rank model for prompts that achieves
efficient prompt optimization. The proposed method demonstrates similar
outcomes to full parameter prompt tuning while reducing the number of trainable
parameters by a factor of 5. It also provides promising results compared to the
state-of-the-art methods that would require 10 to 20 times more parameters. | [
-0.46535345911979675,
-0.9820191264152527,
0.5060246586799622,
0.13720890879631042,
-0.4215904772281647,
-0.2097506821155548,
-0.2881796360015869,
-0.00969393365085125,
-0.019096283242106438,
0.37517520785331726,
-0.7634738683700562,
-0.3655635714530945,
-0.44947177171707153,
0.22577890753746033,
0.15645958483219147,
0.8311578035354614,
0.21957813203334808,
-0.04891831427812576,
0.007055612746626139,
0.024776378646492958,
-0.5363524556159973,
-0.38109540939331055,
-1.1093372106552124,
0.026456890627741814,
0.9247413277626038,
0.780302882194519,
0.506520688533783,
0.8978392481803894,
0.4341138005256653,
0.23557862639427185,
-0.40479961037635803,
0.32679256796836853,
-0.5484414100646973,
0.3403412401676178,
0.10074867308139801,
-0.33311089873313904,
-0.6613144278526306,
0.16493871808052063,
0.6488161683082581,
1.0268272161483765,
0.2203005999326706,
0.2116125077009201,
0.14574868977069855,
0.45146653056144714,
-0.7232498526573181,
-0.005181275308132172,
-0.47147127985954285,
-0.2289307862520218,
-0.015788763761520386,
-0.4755565822124481,
-0.48245149850845337,
-0.5703554153442383,
-0.26557397842407227,
-0.5622074007987976,
0.04688698798418045,
0.4674662947654724,
0.7409035563468933,
0.3830870985984802,
-0.2149372547864914,
0.1418481022119522,
-0.3564850986003876,
0.8938544988632202,
-0.8451493978500366,
0.3345377445220947,
0.5463793277740479,
0.183889240026474,
-0.20564702153205872,
-0.3732854425907135,
-0.20000530779361725,
-0.41502848267555237,
0.0034760641865432262,
-0.21765366196632385,
0.07234273850917816,
0.34209102392196655,
0.6470349431037903,
0.09763592481613159,
-0.4557250440120697,
0.5956467986106873,
-0.02667131833732128,
-0.2914707064628601,
0.18116672337055206,
0.2343541830778122,
0.19927820563316345,
-0.4224664568901062,
-0.245510533452034,
0.13910983502864838,
-1.0732983350753784,
0.3738148510456085,
0.5882763862609863,
1.105905294418335,
-0.06315145641565323,
0.586197018623352,
-0.5141305327415466,
0.9845319986343384,
0.23972369730472565,
-0.29925236105918884,
-0.3004935681819916,
-0.35725924372673035,
0.04122605547308922,
0.09477856010198593,
0.5065456628799438,
0.25401002168655396,
0.19441883265972137,
0.09238319098949432,
-0.3846528232097626,
-0.20030559599399567,
-0.14384277164936066,
-1.0675071477890015,
0.06640800088644028,
-0.0979500412940979,
-0.5829257369041443,
-0.4510646462440491,
-0.361752450466156,
-0.5461736917495728,
-0.5763648748397827,
-0.35732874274253845,
0.32955169677734375,
-0.6063183546066284,
0.19946898519992828,
-0.159466952085495,
-0.1651942878961563,
0.2939736843109131,
0.5329317450523376,
-1.0326811075210571,
0.1685827225446701,
0.858310878276825,
0.7644151449203491,
-0.37804165482521057,
-0.2961824834346771,
-1.4468623399734497,
-0.10128217935562134,
-0.18762819468975067,
0.7768707275390625,
-0.8704103231430054,
-0.5016082525253296,
-0.01177123375236988,
0.03663086146116257,
-0.05898217111825943,
-0.2248740941286087,
0.7803674340248108,
-0.39160969853401184,
0.3308342397212982,
-0.383840411901474,
-0.5016865730285645,
0.3231286108493805,
0.1818111687898636,
-0.5967549681663513,
1.1976604461669922,
0.20574067533016205,
-0.4452294409275055,
0.3461446464061737,
-0.6901932954788208,
-0.4413866400718689,
0.19480623304843903,
0.002045556902885437,
-0.08572782576084137,
0.4414157569408417,
0.47797492146492004,
0.3536983132362366,
-0.6005434393882751,
-0.0938614159822464,
-0.08498470485210419,
-0.6914721131324768,
-0.1892385333776474,
-0.5398798584938049,
0.5437167286872864,
0.14657792448997498,
-0.0430239699780941,
0.13099415600299835,
-0.7612223029136658,
0.07483715564012527,
0.01964733377099037,
-0.5953087210655212,
-0.6303585767745972,
-0.10875914990901947,
-0.12368863821029663,
-0.013101980090141296,
0.4457596242427826,
-0.4138652980327606,
0.7248521447181702,
-0.8593419194221497,
0.4118061363697052,
0.7829626798629761,
0.04133341833949089,
0.6165484189987183,
-0.20463760197162628,
0.6884105801582336,
-0.09935512393712997,
0.24263222515583038,
-0.400118350982666,
-0.7422571182250977,
-0.7552505135536194,
-0.6077600717544556,
0.6384819746017456,
0.3894171118736267,
-0.7681168913841248,
0.5350466370582581,
-0.05781262367963791,
-0.3403501510620117,
-0.5894609093666077,
0.058432914316654205,
0.27621152997016907,
0.8283242583274841,
0.14962635934352875,
0.2791016399860382,
-0.12243705987930298,
-0.9121313691139221,
-0.5466707348823547,
-0.1705354005098343,
0.029719965532422066,
0.3100588619709015,
0.20818458497524261,
0.3632453382015228,
1.057314157485962,
-0.6664988398551941,
0.04588746652007103,
-0.5370641350746155,
0.26468631625175476,
0.6739826798439026,
0.6633614897727966,
0.47051936388015747,
-0.47740668058395386,
-0.644648015499115,
-0.29846522212028503,
-0.05056096985936165,
-0.3834695816040039,
0.14226751029491425,
-0.04798773676156998,
0.3149475157260895,
0.6678743362426758,
-0.6560909152030945,
0.2661449611186981,
0.18037493526935577,
-0.623615562915802,
0.2676337659358978,
-0.3275678753852844,
0.34636634588241577,
-0.8572602272033691,
0.20371747016906738,
-0.2297142595052719,
-0.3517173230648041,
-0.6154381632804871,
0.08293364942073822,
0.08075698465108871,
-0.6765334010124207,
-0.6600127816200256,
1.001477599143982,
-0.4684550166130066,
0.38470029830932617,
-0.37336426973342896,
0.22162798047065735,
0.03733552619814873,
0.729556143283844,
-0.09116015583276749,
0.9077785611152649,
0.5505843758583069,
-0.7285078763961792,
0.19330057501792908,
0.1077454462647438,
-0.24251750111579895,
0.7274498343467712,
-0.8092374801635742,
0.16752366721630096,
-0.19343875348567963,
-0.25407782196998596,
-1.1688669919967651,
0.019845914095640182,
0.3307127356529236,
-0.33665400743484497,
0.23251290619373322,
-0.6054019331932068,
-0.7769189476966858,
-0.06734391301870346,
-0.4488128125667572,
0.4283216595649719,
0.9178569912910461,
-0.5367249846458435,
0.34773844480514526,
-0.10362643003463745,
-0.5133866667747498,
-0.1933065801858902,
-0.1387876272201538,
-0.24292580783367157,
-0.41140174865722656,
-0.3740040361881256,
0.3463671803474426,
-0.12115897983312607,
0.16614903509616852,
-0.3394206464290619,
0.08999194949865341,
0.22781777381896973,
0.34113138914108276,
0.08915771543979645,
0.2156078964471817,
-0.4198441803455353,
0.23185472190380096,
0.3913098871707916,
-0.4620828926563263,
-0.36712074279785156,
-0.10256247222423553,
0.7737599611282349,
0.16160473227500916,
-0.4393797516822815,
-0.5010515451431274,
0.6427773237228394,
0.4221601188182831,
-0.20834018290042877,
0.794774055480957,
0.4278927743434906,
-0.43388882279396057,
-0.39475640654563904,
-0.32562512159347534,
-0.4385319650173187,
-0.5777512788772583,
0.105837382376194,
-0.49342861771583557,
-0.848792552947998,
0.39484903216362,
-0.4013655483722687,
0.027227243408560753,
0.35501718521118164,
0.3518271744251251,
0.04564034566283226,
1.4834214448928833,
0.7782353162765503,
-0.05250981077551842,
0.6208764910697937,
0.28177696466445923,
0.1790178120136261,
-0.6790094375610352,
0.21227200329303741,
-0.9470199346542358,
-0.4399900734424591,
-0.6781811714172363,
-0.31183281540870667,
0.570506751537323,
0.2269437611103058,
-0.5263499021530151,
0.16036710143089294,
-0.5745722651481628,
0.5364053845405579,
0.8509801626205444,
-0.1599961370229721,
0.42109164595603943,
0.007060791831463575,
-0.23574507236480713,
-0.07223757356405258,
-0.7718824744224548,
-0.516511857509613,
0.6059147715568542,
0.30570560693740845,
0.8370689153671265,
0.020355340093374252,
0.6453372240066528,
0.2904007136821747,
-0.311399906873703,
-0.9625381231307983,
0.774998664855957,
-0.20978163182735443,
-0.3264221251010895,
-0.6011229157447815,
-0.40316590666770935,
-0.9540097117424011,
0.04186641797423363,
-0.12160930782556534,
-0.8675211071968079,
0.2608204782009125,
0.27244216203689575,
-0.6982215642929077,
0.007297929842025042,
-0.7359699606895447,
0.8417479395866394,
-0.039228226989507675,
-0.17499616742134094,
0.07821091264486313,
-0.3700176775455475,
-0.07577590644359589,
0.15089216828346252,
-0.2019607275724411,
-0.28625959157943726,
-0.44401949644088745,
0.8478813171386719,
-0.7313965559005737,
0.9303149580955505,
-0.618809163570404,
-0.22396111488342285,
0.01965479739010334,
0.003920353017747402,
1.1600570678710938,
0.13911959528923035,
-0.4509996771812439,
-0.330762654542923,
-0.011899939738214016,
-0.4175519347190857,
-0.6846426725387573,
0.9099915623664856,
-0.5805272459983826,
-0.5745705962181091,
-0.25219541788101196,
-0.25286734104156494,
-0.5160508751869202,
0.3832598328590393,
0.43649888038635254,
0.6544126272201538,
-0.0941857248544693,
-0.02738986350595951,
0.6655797362327576,
-0.40642228722572327,
0.6197300553321838,
0.588900089263916,
-0.06326474994421005,
-0.24781683087348938,
0.9870649576187134,
-0.027480410411953926,
0.16943706572055817,
0.3938356935977936,
0.4132625460624695,
-0.1661069691181183,
-0.48300036787986755,
-0.42957910895347595,
0.3444785177707672,
-0.6483426094055176,
-0.3195788264274597,
-0.38602712750434875,
-0.037155576050281525,
-0.4058367609977722,
-0.28458479046821594,
-0.3654443323612213,
-0.7156513333320618,
-0.501926839351654,
0.3055199682712555,
0.6275132298469543,
0.2035771906375885,
0.24744033813476562,
0.8482770323753357,
-0.5395438075065613,
0.5743727684020996,
0.23172619938850403,
0.602922797203064,
-0.29080677032470703,
-0.7800542712211609,
-0.12937165796756744,
-0.11990759521722794,
0.041736144572496414,
-0.6622311472892761,
0.31361934542655945,
0.43568429350852966,
0.49392279982566833,
0.36450961232185364,
0.3903881907463074,
0.5830257534980774,
-0.6919183731079102,
0.8773031830787659,
0.02734271064400673,
-0.9902011752128601,
0.947394847869873,
-0.604576051235199,
0.5910643339157104,
0.8642047643661499,
0.23907995223999023,
-0.4871755540370941,
-0.19330504536628723,
-0.2830072045326233,
-0.824557900428772,
1.0673530101776123,
-0.047293949872255325,
0.15387119352817535,
-0.023985084146261215,
0.5400980114936829,
0.33910855650901794,
0.22360479831695557,
-0.3115689158439636,
-0.292987585067749,
0.1038326621055603,
-0.1980423927307129,
0.06863850355148315,
-0.3436613082885742,
0.057651590555906296,
-0.4318130314350128,
0.6520681381225586,
-0.5350713133811951,
0.37570858001708984,
-0.23681901395320892,
0.022470036521553993,
-0.1688576638698578,
0.3710499703884125,
0.5670940279960632,
0.24277962744235992,
-0.22624945640563965,
0.09962377697229385,
0.2441350221633911,
-0.2628747820854187,
0.11852852255105972,
0.0948161706328392,
-0.3353230059146881,
-0.03921741247177124,
0.23239074647426605,
1.0620449781417847,
0.23219916224479675,
-0.5148068070411682,
0.5938562750816345,
-0.08448956161737442,
0.10676882416009903,
0.194203183054924,
0.32756224274635315,
-0.0858159139752388,
-0.09753387421369553,
0.19112472236156464,
-0.12953956425189972,
0.0442378930747509,
-0.3609313666820526,
-0.24003680050373077,
0.4151928126811981,
-0.5145911574363708,
-0.14722001552581787,
0.5416399240493774,
0.5527366399765015,
-0.6301141381263733,
0.7765851616859436,
-0.23485825955867767,
-0.11209016293287277,
0.4292626976966858,
0.5678895115852356,
0.6738508343696594,
-0.2287306785583496,
0.24589715898036957,
0.35279232263565063,
0.22318466007709503,
0.03339977189898491,
0.5600394010543823,
-0.03522084280848503,
-0.18532665073871613,
-0.454179972410202,
-0.7732936143875122,
-0.47228506207466125,
0.13736969232559204,
-0.45311763882637024,
0.8280355334281921,
-0.5117367506027222,
-0.2593863010406494,
-0.12485269457101822,
-0.021405339241027832,
-0.6212655305862427,
0.0352606326341629,
0.0591333769261837,
1.1494249105453491,
-0.682947039604187,
0.6671218276023865,
0.6449797749519348,
-0.25995880365371704,
-0.6240972280502319,
-0.07693527638912201,
-0.3068598806858063,
-0.861157238483429,
0.7042154669761658,
0.11818905919790268,
-0.09822314977645874,
0.3856453001499176,
-0.6429221034049988,
-0.9858154058456421,
0.6259125471115112,
0.5684319138526917,
-0.4564286172389984,
-0.3124992847442627,
0.253784716129303,
0.32357102632522583,
-0.2882978022098541,
0.3907800316810608,
0.44997844099998474,
0.7385585904121399,
-0.02663513645529747,
-0.7731462121009827,
0.3464978337287903,
-0.2681821882724762,
0.14572489261627197,
0.31451818346977234,
-0.5894696116447449,
0.9240473508834839,
-0.02935885079205036,
-0.2528367340564728,
0.41313669085502625,
0.5567922592163086,
0.3639712333679199,
-0.025423768907785416,
0.6831854581832886,
0.016041789203882217,
0.7458529472351074,
-0.32726702094078064,
0.9197270274162292,
-0.5228990316390991,
0.10572128742933273,
0.8206067681312561,
-0.2501903474330902,
0.7162036895751953,
0.6809879541397095,
0.11639241874217987,
0.14691297709941864,
0.7480823397636414,
0.1201268881559372,
0.7177444100379944,
0.18870404362678528,
0.020994743332266808,
-0.7063637971878052,
-0.40003910660743713,
-0.21381725370883942,
0.45347997546195984,
0.13429366052150726,
-0.14302751421928406,
-0.25224006175994873,
0.2384520024061203,
-0.038381610065698624,
-0.21262028813362122,
-0.38585469126701355,
0.783748984336853,
0.06100437417626381,
-0.8988338112831116,
0.9448580145835876,
0.251082181930542,
0.6627024412155151,
-0.713196873664856,
-0.09019162505865097,
-0.48038187623023987,
-0.22274725139141083,
0.182734876871109,
-0.21157096326351166,
-0.28903087973594666,
0.1049656793475151,
-0.30777308344841003,
-0.4916255474090576,
0.6745817065238953,
-0.24393142759799957,
-0.4725598394870758,
-0.14621491730213165,
0.8139187097549438,
0.002001714427024126,
-0.2320697009563446,
-0.5061383843421936,
-0.009150869213044643,
-0.33421212434768677,
-0.5353148579597473,
0.3439873158931732,
0.4949813187122345,
-0.02403436414897442,
0.6080123782157898,
0.4922415316104889,
0.38210049271583557,
-0.26963260769844055,
0.2852582037448883,
0.965408444404602,
-1.0324195623397827,
-0.8119215965270996,
-0.8364201188087463,
0.5724489092826843,
-0.024248631671071053,
-0.5302310585975647,
0.517792284488678,
0.4544470012187958,
-0.003911003470420837,
-0.10239185392856598,
0.6723190546035767,
-0.04648100957274437,
0.7515830397605896,
-0.7130641937255859,
0.7052416205406189,
-0.8399025201797485,
0.3747989237308502,
-0.18341349065303802,
-0.9930979013442993,
-0.13344033062458038,
0.2243340164422989,
-0.21491853892803192,
0.22469715774059296,
0.6855617165565491,
0.8352336883544922,
-0.1483639031648636,
-0.22574226558208466,
0.5026878714561462,
-0.08314096182584763,
0.15076473355293274,
0.41916388273239136,
0.97544926404953,
-0.2375497817993164,
0.2504030168056488,
-0.03175682574510574,
-0.3261449337005615,
-0.5662434101104736,
-1.0744892358779907,
-1.0943034887313843,
-0.535015881061554,
-0.3126644790172577,
0.04035957530140877,
0.13178743422031403,
1.2164283990859985,
0.7081023454666138,
-0.7394209504127502,
0.13657818734645844,
0.1759573370218277,
0.4013529419898987,
-0.2756860554218292,
-0.19498944282531738,
0.5995271801948547,
-0.6970871686935425,
-1.0097334384918213,
0.785772979259491,
0.15843620896339417,
-0.09504076093435287,
-0.20016005635261536,
0.04523775726556778,
0.011080412194132805,
0.3699778914451599,
0.6380141377449036,
0.155588760972023,
-0.592936635017395,
-0.31795233488082886,
0.2104027420282364,
-0.24732337892055511,
0.03605276346206665,
0.849077582359314,
-0.9107939600944519,
0.04544500634074211,
0.8060966730117798,
0.3359653651714325,
-0.036694955080747604,
0.2869858741760254,
0.6602604985237122,
-1.0810784101486206,
0.1496392786502838,
0.23403911292552948,
0.28686222434043884,
0.20182837545871735,
-0.421801894903183,
0.18912312388420105,
0.13822871446609497,
-0.3255169093608856,
-1.137384295463562,
0.3167167007923126,
-1.1132577657699585,
-0.3235369324684143,
1.352899432182312,
0.12497419863939285,
-0.26779839396476746,
0.03235330805182457,
-0.4940350353717804,
0.08832912892103195,
-0.7900106310844421,
0.38850221037864685,
0.3423650562763214,
-0.29041752219200134,
-0.2753983438014984,
-0.3075050413608551,
0.8943072557449341,
0.5363827347755432,
-0.7659074068069458,
0.19371916353702545,
0.3145776689052582,
-0.01854540966451168,
-0.10798188298940659,
0.5377699136734009,
0.2447064220905304,
0.24688483774662018,
-0.17127326130867004,
-0.27528223395347595,
-0.36337733268737793,
-0.2981414496898651,
-0.4581072926521301,
0.46465083956718445,
0.5446752905845642,
-0.07170604914426804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19482v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19482v1 | xTower: A Multilingual LLM for Explaining and Correcting Translation Errors | 2024-06-27T18:51:46 | 2024-06-27T18:51:46 | Marcos Treviso, Nuno M. Guerreiro, Sweta Agrawal, Ricardo Rei, José Pombal, Tania Vaz, Helena Wu, Beatriz Silva, Daan van Stigt, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | While machine translation (MT) systems are achieving increasingly strong
performance on benchmarks, they often produce translations with errors and
anomalies. Understanding these errors can potentially help improve the
translation quality and user experience. This paper introduces xTower, an open
large language model (LLM) built on top of TowerBase designed to provide
free-text explanations for translation errors in order to guide the generation
of a corrected translation. The quality of the generated explanations by xTower
are assessed via both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation. We ask expert
translators to evaluate the quality of the explanations across two dimensions:
relatedness towards the error span being explained and helpfulness in error
understanding and improving translation quality. Extrinsically, we test xTower
across various experimental setups in generating translation corrections,
demonstrating significant improvements in translation quality. Our findings
highlight xTower's potential towards not only producing plausible and helpful
explanations of automatic translations, but also leveraging them to suggest
corrected translations. | [
0.08454429358243942,
-0.46830424666404724,
0.39941170811653137,
0.4106851816177368,
-0.17284457385540009,
-0.08162261545658112,
-0.1898222267627716,
-0.30900269746780396,
0.08961241692304611,
0.3915025293827057,
-0.5530022978782654,
-0.5575610995292664,
-0.7307700514793396,
0.11638308316469193,
-0.5243204236030579,
0.9852644801139832,
-0.6225007772445679,
0.12632954120635986,
0.219508096575737,
-0.2747162878513336,
-0.5845240354537964,
-0.31118953227996826,
-0.7936649918556213,
-0.32323887944221497,
0.5053728818893433,
0.545473575592041,
1.359523057937622,
1.0009530782699585,
0.36226561665534973,
0.3133801817893982,
0.04930667206645012,
0.3461650311946869,
-0.5491470098495483,
0.012741581536829472,
-0.2645883560180664,
-0.6231564283370972,
-0.6804651021957397,
-0.2929631769657135,
0.6528562903404236,
0.6501493453979492,
-0.18709540367126465,
0.024657949805259705,
-0.07976333051919937,
0.7539015412330627,
0.006858861539512873,
0.1392851322889328,
-0.5944430828094482,
0.31750720739364624,
-0.31693363189697266,
-0.4563519060611725,
-0.38196077942848206,
-0.27644672989845276,
-0.013951346278190613,
-0.767342209815979,
0.4585094451904297,
0.5271322131156921,
0.8673498034477234,
0.3519631028175354,
-0.41402003169059753,
-0.20923933386802673,
-0.4334452748298645,
0.8050835132598877,
-0.3113139569759369,
0.30088675022125244,
0.10667029023170471,
0.5402240753173828,
-0.3611013889312744,
-0.4656088650226593,
-0.5601043701171875,
0.07163217663764954,
-0.1767154335975647,
0.43604791164398193,
-0.5557990074157715,
-0.056877247989177704,
-0.10993658751249313,
0.5360631346702576,
-0.6831085681915283,
0.05323474109172821,
0.011838595382869244,
-0.09871666133403778,
0.3730039596557617,
0.05856730416417122,
0.4673811197280884,
-0.40053752064704895,
-0.36742082238197327,
-0.25365257263183594,
-0.8639897704124451,
0.35634759068489075,
0.23349930346012115,
0.11899726837873459,
-0.14821110665798187,
0.34991025924682617,
0.15734700858592987,
0.7178015112876892,
-0.17742234468460083,
0.04796497896313667,
-0.021492380648851395,
-0.1529035121202469,
-0.4483383297920227,
0.3804658353328705,
0.4457455277442932,
0.5810803771018982,
0.24139998853206635,
-0.3649994432926178,
-0.1984143853187561,
-0.1795061081647873,
0.2590198814868927,
-0.5497413873672485,
-0.005439461208879948,
0.6387273073196411,
-0.6978825926780701,
-0.3466729521751404,
0.07190705835819244,
-0.44881442189216614,
-0.3973146080970764,
-0.10835310816764832,
0.23690509796142578,
-0.28631481528282166,
-0.3545970916748047,
0.30315983295440674,
-0.28119388222694397,
-0.3278748691082001,
0.4722348153591156,
-0.7024226784706116,
-0.11313315480947495,
0.11194811761379242,
0.7051390409469604,
-0.031260471791028976,
-0.43362823128700256,
-0.8415771126747131,
0.4844609200954437,
-0.686846137046814,
0.5359364748001099,
0.09628082811832428,
-0.2596901059150696,
0.1427873820066452,
-0.0739295482635498,
0.2725422978401184,
-0.48276951909065247,
0.633399486541748,
-0.61066073179245,
0.007141090463846922,
-0.27803733944892883,
0.003336973488330841,
-0.4657237231731415,
0.16318023204803467,
-0.41697654128074646,
0.9081289768218994,
0.22369281947612762,
-0.5510799288749695,
0.2626369297504425,
-0.7232665419578552,
-0.28253844380378723,
0.0448719747364521,
0.2137776017189026,
-0.2280554473400116,
0.6356597542762756,
0.3306041657924652,
0.2756138741970062,
-0.20483613014221191,
0.3087892532348633,
0.03969810903072357,
-0.13387860357761383,
0.4951021373271942,
-0.37226057052612305,
0.844590961933136,
0.053966984152793884,
-0.42251554131507874,
0.36504486203193665,
-0.7958442568778992,
0.3717461824417114,
0.09991823136806488,
-0.22639378905296326,
-0.16848674416542053,
0.18606188893318176,
-0.2747684717178345,
0.19604350626468658,
-0.2074931114912033,
-0.3800545930862427,
-0.1776564121246338,
-0.21877069771289825,
0.3047855794429779,
0.586897611618042,
-0.5070446729660034,
0.10963796079158783,
-0.27016326785087585,
0.5534325242042542,
0.17606231570243835,
0.13755638897418976,
-0.5430628061294556,
-0.3976220488548279,
-0.627897322177887,
-0.01975114829838276,
0.00441694213077426,
0.5433646440505981,
-0.6808518767356873,
-0.0980617105960846,
-0.4354825019836426,
-0.06565272063016891,
-0.551154613494873,
0.36033064126968384,
0.775153636932373,
0.49529463052749634,
0.7191154956817627,
0.12954603135585785,
-0.5909757018089294,
-0.5082319378852844,
-0.535728931427002,
-0.33280375599861145,
0.12921957671642303,
-0.06002084165811539,
0.29253268241882324,
-0.18300871551036835,
0.8585553765296936,
-0.10418125241994858,
-0.3578808605670929,
-0.21606026589870453,
0.018551122397184372,
0.12733274698257446,
0.04441960155963898,
0.46498939394950867,
-0.7397261261940002,
-0.5469704866409302,
0.5337042212486267,
-1.032000184059143,
-0.4295485019683838,
-0.06103021651506424,
-0.17263135313987732,
0.0014293265994638205,
0.27863821387290955,
-0.43727609515190125,
0.3157382607460022,
1.017258644104004,
-0.17751207947731018,
0.7631916999816895,
-0.5250603556632996,
0.30477088689804077,
-0.8917985558509827,
-0.47485074400901794,
-0.10913720726966858,
-0.48425954580307007,
-0.5285975337028503,
0.3836551308631897,
0.18365751206874847,
0.012332937680184841,
-0.21608103811740875,
0.21725037693977356,
-0.7078676223754883,
0.0005070248153060675,
-0.27996522188186646,
0.8152439594268799,
0.2428802102804184,
0.04908011481165886,
-0.2489539384841919,
0.7015019059181213,
0.40579867362976074,
-0.1797703504562378,
0.31448841094970703,
0.584550678730011,
-0.23607367277145386,
0.5414367914199829,
-0.6207279562950134,
-0.3494466245174408,
-0.23910219967365265,
0.1518121212720871,
-1.3432297706604004,
-0.4275346100330353,
0.22463439404964447,
-0.6368377208709717,
0.23608264327049255,
-0.32777541875839233,
-0.3592832386493683,
-0.3492673337459564,
-0.016773821786046028,
0.08259760588407516,
0.22010323405265808,
-1.0356218814849854,
0.21686074137687683,
-0.052674029022455215,
0.10056452453136444,
-0.8243887424468994,
-1.0063955783843994,
0.37950876355171204,
0.056732356548309326,
-1.2235244512557983,
0.7089085578918457,
0.2161301076412201,
-0.6572401523590088,
0.1520508974790573,
-0.13026019930839539,
-0.06370078027248383,
0.09847480058670044,
0.5523688197135925,
-0.03473350778222084,
-0.43816184997558594,
0.46072933077812195,
0.1846555471420288,
-0.45711463689804077,
0.0968850627541542,
-0.6244246959686279,
-0.21094433963298798,
-0.22166460752487183,
-0.29978883266448975,
-0.40714550018310547,
0.5742818713188171,
0.45729967951774597,
-0.20214906334877014,
0.7465838193893433,
0.27763912081718445,
-0.129969522356987,
-0.3997211754322052,
-0.3228103816509247,
0.3324984312057495,
-0.39668288826942444,
0.29531970620155334,
-0.6304155588150024,
-0.7036172747612,
0.5257351994514465,
0.0940701812505722,
0.14074921607971191,
0.45892593264579773,
0.31446850299835205,
-0.17142853140830994,
1.357709527015686,
0.6822094321250916,
0.5151782631874084,
0.1324739158153534,
0.05042174085974693,
0.5541068315505981,
-0.45354780554771423,
-0.017820844426751137,
-0.6577566266059875,
-0.17805156111717224,
-0.24220196902751923,
-0.4724973142147064,
0.46815866231918335,
0.455788791179657,
0.16047173738479614,
0.3551953434944153,
-0.26334452629089355,
0.46426913142204285,
0.27427586913108826,
-0.32288554310798645,
0.7703202366828918,
0.46824437379837036,
-0.3572148382663727,
-0.12622341513633728,
-0.7716872692108154,
-0.7523424029350281,
0.3660007417201996,
0.2838283181190491,
0.5080512166023254,
0.5473186373710632,
0.3893011510372162,
0.173976331949234,
0.7510794997215271,
-0.652115523815155,
-0.004269779659807682,
-0.18769793212413788,
-0.7502405643463135,
-0.28322023153305054,
-0.6652085781097412,
-0.7733104228973389,
0.5946089625358582,
-0.06522518396377563,
-0.619828462600708,
-0.3314053416252136,
0.6690153479576111,
-0.32908323407173157,
0.48235851526260376,
-0.804782509803772,
0.9654646515846252,
-0.41807788610458374,
-0.24469879269599915,
-0.4104553759098053,
-0.5206471681594849,
0.5578057169914246,
-0.0743715688586235,
0.5168296098709106,
0.05128723755478859,
0.15869753062725067,
0.21932485699653625,
-0.6293115019798279,
0.598942220211029,
-0.15684640407562256,
-0.31787553429603577,
0.22268252074718475,
0.3024881184101105,
0.6121293902397156,
0.08844967186450958,
-0.5387227535247803,
0.3452438712120056,
0.02331462688744068,
-0.42184171080589294,
-0.8871016502380371,
0.5637348294258118,
-0.9594472050666809,
-0.7575081586837769,
0.005812464747577906,
-0.6279302835464478,
0.053014498203992844,
-0.032578978687524796,
0.2874257266521454,
0.6182153820991516,
0.10378900170326233,
0.08991747349500656,
0.5982837677001953,
-0.5309560894966125,
0.2797331213951111,
0.6886414885520935,
-0.7031421065330505,
-0.3904586434364319,
0.5886871814727783,
0.31049203872680664,
0.14873456954956055,
0.5216881632804871,
0.31206977367401123,
-0.22630129754543304,
-1.010021686553955,
-1.2785906791687012,
-0.062036268413066864,
-0.9147526621818542,
-0.21541975438594818,
-0.5052290558815002,
0.28996261954307556,
0.20886176824569702,
-0.3341270685195923,
-0.15915895998477936,
-0.5610682368278503,
0.13261778652668,
-0.33949363231658936,
0.2917872369289398,
0.7299044728279114,
-0.10122348368167877,
1.0866832733154297,
-1.2095947265625,
0.36096474528312683,
-0.29834434390068054,
0.31071457266807556,
0.10435566306114197,
-0.7016704678535461,
-0.4926076829433441,
0.18268878757953644,
-0.282219797372818,
-1.1426961421966553,
0.21100173890590668,
0.04829726740717888,
0.5122138857841492,
0.4358939230442047,
-0.22304606437683105,
0.9892962574958801,
-0.5728501081466675,
0.7622716426849365,
0.5033403635025024,
-1.392240047454834,
0.42156556248664856,
-0.2919946610927582,
0.08523533493280411,
0.1265391707420349,
0.24802494049072266,
-0.9528807401657104,
-0.3502104878425598,
-0.28512996435165405,
-0.546278715133667,
0.615757167339325,
0.2544578015804291,
0.2020121067762375,
-0.13977530598640442,
0.7046959400177002,
0.33958420157432556,
-0.11905746906995773,
-0.8736433386802673,
-0.34827670454978943,
-0.45107409358024597,
-0.04635242745280266,
0.10644260048866272,
-0.34340599179267883,
-0.11986777931451797,
0.2632240653038025,
1.0723962783813477,
-0.2072926163673401,
0.01701873540878296,
0.4005638360977173,
-0.6777875423431396,
-0.7877881526947021,
0.2536768317222595,
0.5934361219406128,
1.1060782670974731,
0.20420528948307037,
0.3567211925983429,
0.2558108866214752,
0.0037096997257322073,
0.3279637396335602,
-0.133335679769516,
0.1448417454957962,
0.3546973168849945,
0.40467023849487305,
0.5392723083496094,
-0.1732662320137024,
-0.3729183077812195,
0.595620334148407,
-0.06862566620111465,
-0.15957966446876526,
-0.24203553795814514,
-0.17272816598415375,
0.07806698977947235,
0.02739126794040203,
0.493813157081604,
0.16285251080989838,
-0.31800758838653564,
-0.2785915732383728,
-0.03750167787075043,
0.41919195652008057,
-0.748000979423523,
-0.4592515528202057,
0.8864456415176392,
0.24369551241397858,
-0.32522156834602356,
0.4114958643913269,
-0.318395733833313,
-0.48850107192993164,
0.2206794172525406,
0.5973129868507385,
0.6016836166381836,
-0.2159423679113388,
0.41791239380836487,
0.06810003519058228,
0.43953046202659607,
-0.013314991258084774,
0.08509604632854462,
0.14835432171821594,
-0.7316752672195435,
-1.0466828346252441,
-0.2959383428096771,
-0.39196035265922546,
-0.36247143149375916,
-0.4245544970035553,
0.02082076296210289,
-0.09421932697296143,
0.016140611842274666,
0.023417983204126358,
-0.4243651330471039,
-0.2546539902687073,
0.3252158761024475,
-0.22758451104164124,
1.223618507385254,
-0.6505038142204285,
0.6793740391731262,
0.571968138217926,
-0.2984078824520111,
-0.9712578058242798,
-0.08934219181537628,
0.13374081254005432,
-1.1457312107086182,
0.935606062412262,
0.2226969450712204,
-0.664998471736908,
-0.05477927252650261,
-0.24402353167533875,
-0.7407875061035156,
0.6485525369644165,
0.3645060658454895,
-0.5445403456687927,
0.2151649296283722,
0.2905930280685425,
0.5943166613578796,
0.06198826804757118,
0.42256301641464233,
0.22978760302066803,
0.7874063849449158,
-0.30397331714630127,
-0.5088065266609192,
0.1970914602279663,
-0.27202653884887695,
0.029644574970006943,
0.5639711618423462,
-0.5766769647598267,
0.37276801466941833,
-0.4907990097999573,
-0.17265461385250092,
0.39703720808029175,
0.730003297328949,
-0.34928497672080994,
0.11589933186769485,
0.40591856837272644,
0.4270961880683899,
0.9117908477783203,
-0.44066867232322693,
1.4312535524368286,
-0.37834054231643677,
0.06153218075633049,
1.018639326095581,
0.003760648425668478,
0.5762243866920471,
0.6205772161483765,
-0.07388047873973846,
0.8810120224952698,
0.6260120272636414,
0.34470346570014954,
0.048119138926267624,
0.5113051533699036,
-0.1702728420495987,
-0.20631729066371918,
0.10200291872024536,
-0.35553282499313354,
0.2639400064945221,
0.24560903012752533,
-0.5906205177307129,
-0.5406516790390015,
0.10542702674865723,
0.2354598492383957,
0.08749400079250336,
-0.30485764145851135,
0.17266976833343506,
0.08475635945796967,
-0.9901296496391296,
0.7624226808547974,
0.5622531175613403,
0.04358666017651558,
-0.6785190105438232,
-0.006462045479565859,
-0.3179037868976593,
0.704753577709198,
-0.6357890367507935,
-0.8072559237480164,
0.6826823353767395,
0.10754750669002533,
-0.5953614711761475,
-0.821654200553894,
0.30944380164146423,
-0.2859060764312744,
-0.13699474930763245,
0.5827846527099609,
0.6374373435974121,
0.5449472069740295,
-0.4465934932231903,
-0.5832909345626831,
0.038602251559495926,
0.15900614857673645,
-0.011455230414867401,
-0.06321622431278229,
0.6975508332252502,
-0.48150551319122314,
0.6742414236068726,
0.533769428730011,
-0.023452889174222946,
0.20148076117038727,
0.09704934060573578,
0.18942321836948395,
-0.4778476655483246,
-0.2861678898334503,
-1.0107160806655884,
0.8245148062705994,
0.06870654225349426,
-0.4119269549846649,
0.979745626449585,
0.2249894142150879,
0.6635873913764954,
-0.06171475723385811,
0.9252979755401611,
0.17834340035915375,
0.24791930615901947,
-0.41600775718688965,
0.3697740435600281,
-0.7137612104415894,
0.3173341453075409,
0.11922311782836914,
-0.849392294883728,
-0.5894052386283875,
0.4735065996646881,
-0.09678222984075546,
-0.381603479385376,
0.9595972299575806,
1.042690634727478,
-0.1585499346256256,
0.4159480333328247,
0.4660361111164093,
0.5977442860603333,
0.4136838912963867,
0.189023956656456,
1.0529801845550537,
-0.5855726003646851,
1.2650842666625977,
0.2024100422859192,
-0.5430407524108887,
-0.2222575694322586,
-1.1853454113006592,
-0.6477028131484985,
-0.03945642709732056,
-0.3595116436481476,
-0.5295425057411194,
0.32847556471824646,
0.7948012948036194,
0.7901231050491333,
-0.7880723476409912,
-0.2336026281118393,
-0.23889848589897156,
0.4683205187320709,
-0.691286027431488,
-0.13775110244750977,
0.2828434407711029,
-0.5584997534751892,
-0.48928797245025635,
0.5574600100517273,
0.5216472744941711,
0.024636603891849518,
-0.18473035097122192,
-0.19210898876190186,
0.7351803779602051,
-0.09446431696414948,
0.7535029053688049,
-0.22204023599624634,
-0.9078265428543091,
-0.44904205203056335,
0.020545804873108864,
0.07597049325704575,
0.38664090633392334,
0.9039255976676941,
-0.3366571068763733,
0.6370939612388611,
0.42920270562171936,
0.578176736831665,
0.39213478565216064,
-0.13462413847446442,
0.83544921875,
-0.733025848865509,
-0.41195446252822876,
-0.7086150050163269,
0.4767613708972931,
0.586176872253418,
-0.3884950280189514,
0.42961180210113525,
0.04684952273964882,
-0.41036513447761536,
-0.48114126920700073,
0.26684078574180603,
-0.7733483910560608,
-0.17236635088920593,
0.9227462410926819,
-0.6703589558601379,
-0.1671399176120758,
-0.1933223456144333,
-0.40639838576316833,
0.3203795850276947,
-0.01433473452925682,
0.7892122864723206,
0.9638161063194275,
0.09633725881576538,
-0.136357843875885,
-0.9867706894874573,
0.47442591190338135,
0.7262889742851257,
-0.8040326833724976,
0.3967462182044983,
0.3164045214653015,
0.1778976321220398,
0.27063295245170593,
0.1278098076581955,
-0.340972363948822,
0.5995426177978516,
-0.06154809892177582,
-0.15223491191864014,
-0.1124674379825592,
-0.26731011271476746,
-0.30162084102630615,
0.1660696268081665,
0.0923154428601265,
-0.18958714604377747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19478v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19478v1 | Sparse Regression for Machine Translation | 2024-06-27T18:43:51 | 2024-06-27T18:43:51 | Ergun Biçici | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, G.3; I.2.7 | We use transductive regression techniques to learn mappings between source
and target features of given parallel corpora and use these mappings to
generate machine translation outputs. We show the effectiveness of $L_1$
regularized regression (\textit{lasso}) to learn the mappings between sparsely
observed feature sets versus $L_2$ regularized regression. Proper selection of
training instances plays an important role to learn correct feature mappings
within limited computational resources and at expected accuracy levels. We
introduce \textit{dice} instance selection method for proper selection of
training instances, which plays an important role to learn correct feature
mappings for improving the source and target coverage of the training set. We
show that $L_1$ regularized regression performs better than $L_2$ regularized
regression both in regression measurements and in the translation experiments
using graph decoding. We present encouraging results when translating from
German to English and Spanish to English. We also demonstrate results when the
phrase table of a phrase-based decoder is replaced with the mappings we find
with the regression model. | [
-0.03281254321336746,
-0.7212316989898682,
0.5116246342658997,
0.319890558719635,
-0.20331600308418274,
0.01480058953166008,
-0.39625370502471924,
-0.3310484290122986,
0.1914103925228119,
0.5106889009475708,
-0.4916549026966095,
-0.47173622250556946,
-0.8242684602737427,
0.4530525803565979,
-0.4965532124042511,
1.2248276472091675,
-0.1772751361131668,
0.45607078075408936,
-0.0816507488489151,
-0.18398143351078033,
-0.6280866861343384,
-0.28236860036849976,
-0.4827748239040375,
-0.012087957002222538,
0.5214069485664368,
0.24543766677379608,
0.8535282015800476,
0.7278677821159363,
0.548325777053833,
0.2639252841472626,
0.2616703510284424,
0.2599967420101166,
-0.8795642256736755,
0.05219367891550064,
0.2284035086631775,
-0.46664753556251526,
-0.21590690314769745,
0.05797683820128441,
0.7028508186340332,
0.916706919670105,
0.2163722962141037,
0.2091411054134369,
0.27522575855255127,
0.5717423558235168,
-0.2720664143562317,
0.13950225710868835,
-0.6419690847396851,
-0.02127130702137947,
0.09850328415632248,
0.11665266007184982,
-0.3670004904270172,
-0.41353335976600647,
-0.12188071012496948,
-0.623881459236145,
0.6392287611961365,
0.02316935732960701,
0.8398988842964172,
0.6927301287651062,
-0.12488306313753128,
-0.12944315373897552,
-0.8736515641212463,
1.1483590602874756,
-0.3068741261959076,
0.5877241492271423,
0.6433063745498657,
0.30034488439559937,
-0.04983733221888542,
-0.7459975481033325,
0.20186813175678253,
-0.37012508511543274,
-0.3752281069755554,
0.06686262041330338,
-0.15604856610298157,
0.020153366029262543,
0.16865608096122742,
0.09433592855930328,
-0.7798811197280884,
-0.12108302861452103,
-0.7724968791007996,
-0.33731064200401306,
0.6876283884048462,
-0.06360245496034622,
0.03850500285625458,
0.1414480358362198,
-0.1459740400314331,
-0.10511651635169983,
-0.5003746747970581,
-0.33635109663009644,
0.1786354035139084,
0.7169308662414551,
0.016407962888479233,
0.3801020383834839,
0.1079322025179863,
0.8058470487594604,
-0.3890789747238159,
-0.3995067775249481,
0.33469241857528687,
-0.4440459609031677,
-0.2351377159357071,
-0.04553314670920372,
0.6098769903182983,
-0.1945546269416809,
0.45329660177230835,
-0.6061592698097229,
-0.28946739435195923,
-0.15339690446853638,
0.1868571788072586,
-0.41855767369270325,
0.3237172067165375,
0.0005232755211181939,
-0.5264937281608582,
-0.019664984196424484,
0.0488540455698967,
-0.5866384506225586,
0.025567099452018738,
-0.29560065269470215,
0.1743801236152649,
-0.3269968628883362,
0.020126348361372948,
0.0794752910733223,
-0.14760488271713257,
-0.15183064341545105,
0.27569860219955444,
-0.7030524611473083,
0.5415734052658081,
0.3745117783546448,
0.975111722946167,
-0.22319012880325317,
-0.33860042691230774,
-0.7623544931411743,
-0.038481712341308594,
-0.5291855335235596,
0.24183589220046997,
-0.34469422698020935,
-0.33617398142814636,
0.41041141748428345,
-0.11086801439523697,
-0.2565958499908447,
-0.5333616733551025,
0.4682214558124542,
-0.17930525541305542,
0.025632191449403763,
-0.0759604349732399,
-0.25860321521759033,
-0.2081654965877533,
-0.08414290100336075,
-0.6412034630775452,
1.0399746894836426,
0.5558090209960938,
-0.4545563757419586,
0.2969508469104767,
-0.12370925396680832,
-0.5510363578796387,
-0.2118711620569229,
-0.09861525148153305,
-0.5239687561988831,
0.2606465816497803,
0.06884483247995377,
0.47519055008888245,
-0.36420702934265137,
0.23494040966033936,
-0.19279475510120392,
-0.48437198996543884,
0.18994911015033722,
-0.0647554025053978,
0.7279088497161865,
0.5279737114906311,
-0.2917269766330719,
0.09877447783946991,
-0.5005987286567688,
-0.21915344893932343,
0.03649697080254555,
-0.20831169188022614,
-0.2641717493534088,
0.06943535804748535,
0.5208373069763184,
-0.06338860094547272,
0.17226754128932953,
-0.34646040201187134,
0.13133041560649872,
-0.08229212462902069,
0.2629600763320923,
0.24066196382045746,
-0.24564775824546814,
0.5684086680412292,
-0.15369324386119843,
0.595535933971405,
-0.2745738923549652,
0.07106257975101471,
0.2234201580286026,
-0.4094683825969696,
-0.692668080329895,
-0.6449740529060364,
0.5801342129707336,
0.7979003190994263,
-0.5204211473464966,
0.19809122383594513,
-0.14976724982261658,
-0.16115261614322662,
-0.94788658618927,
0.4549221396446228,
0.4111172556877136,
0.41778242588043213,
0.7049911022186279,
0.24866122007369995,
-0.5594444274902344,
-0.9756667613983154,
-0.03985852375626564,
0.07980335503816605,
-0.12600892782211304,
0.12188805639743805,
0.27485018968582153,
-0.23582468926906586,
0.578535795211792,
-0.5880513191223145,
-0.820931613445282,
-0.5263481736183167,
0.16422922909259796,
0.07159410417079926,
0.5349475145339966,
0.8565223217010498,
-0.8284645676612854,
-0.6548797488212585,
0.11617901921272278,
-0.682483434677124,
-0.16573862731456757,
-0.49779629707336426,
-0.046250272542238235,
0.36624205112457275,
0.6419777870178223,
-0.1754917949438095,
0.36542922258377075,
0.4196566939353943,
0.04610862955451012,
-0.14523622393608093,
-0.2979261875152588,
0.1538659930229187,
-1.0642106533050537,
0.026738470420241356,
0.25924012064933777,
-0.6630407571792603,
-0.4517171382904053,
-0.08344562351703644,
-0.07692225277423859,
0.08640293776988983,
-0.25246527791023254,
0.26278308033943176,
-0.4874265789985657,
-0.30871105194091797,
-0.08825619518756866,
0.04233993962407112,
-0.37609684467315674,
0.2001536339521408,
0.06610269099473953,
1.0650720596313477,
0.3159227669239044,
-0.20474891364574432,
0.163170725107193,
0.3600735068321228,
-0.02354605682194233,
-0.28334611654281616,
-0.6869171261787415,
0.012058328837156296,
-0.14106819033622742,
-0.08011747896671295,
-0.9450401663780212,
0.015643589198589325,
0.1731162965297699,
-0.5679834485054016,
0.578026533126831,
-0.06577994674444199,
-0.5275227427482605,
-0.2684197723865509,
-0.0466039776802063,
-0.11328448355197906,
0.9174445271492004,
-0.03901853412389755,
0.1641923040151596,
0.29387059807777405,
-0.05341725051403046,
-0.5757154822349548,
-0.8027042150497437,
-0.11875267326831818,
-0.2583729326725006,
-0.35651835799217224,
0.15770262479782104,
0.14647136628627777,
-0.174308642745018,
-0.03174273669719696,
0.06586918979883194,
-0.22212766110897064,
0.21244384348392487,
-0.019137097522616386,
0.4189468026161194,
-0.21736577153205872,
-0.06967364996671677,
0.13099616765975952,
-0.15352074801921844,
-0.1212838888168335,
-0.3577212989330292,
0.3788330852985382,
-0.020975638180971146,
0.10351014882326126,
-0.0036102100275456905,
0.6268607378005981,
0.35525795817375183,
-0.08147034049034119,
0.694789469242096,
0.9498534202575684,
-0.4646065831184387,
-0.29453322291374207,
-0.5806756615638733,
-0.1925259530544281,
-0.32668328285217285,
0.7192918658256531,
-0.5827641487121582,
-0.9137889742851257,
0.4268988072872162,
0.021921250969171524,
-0.2257278710603714,
0.42531970143318176,
0.5007134675979614,
0.07221150398254395,
1.2482572793960571,
1.1751594543457031,
-0.24616649746894836,
0.4062182307243347,
-0.4550340473651886,
0.0753878504037857,
-0.5457791686058044,
-0.11658865958452225,
-0.9302352070808411,
-0.17850980162620544,
-0.7932895421981812,
-0.37283456325531006,
0.5717406868934631,
0.22133275866508484,
0.02503981627523899,
0.6250567436218262,
-0.5925905108451843,
0.0984782725572586,
0.6418365836143494,
0.12611603736877441,
0.05240665376186371,
0.3834455609321594,
0.1119958758354187,
-0.4439130127429962,
-0.8572922945022583,
-0.35562992095947266,
0.9066730737686157,
0.3009461462497711,
0.7865656018257141,
-0.165103942155838,
0.7491288185119629,
0.3385765552520752,
0.2902064025402069,
-0.7463909387588501,
0.2375720739364624,
-0.43107539415359497,
-0.30247315764427185,
-0.3914821445941925,
-0.5650691986083984,
-0.9754886031150818,
0.11676955223083496,
-0.43377819657325745,
-0.5400851368904114,
0.10679346323013306,
-0.06973547488451004,
-0.020926592871546745,
-0.03430865332484245,
-0.6726536750793457,
0.9485337734222412,
-0.1409931629896164,
-0.49336209893226624,
-0.2756430506706238,
-0.7506623268127441,
0.08203384280204773,
-0.27200502157211304,
0.020103275775909424,
0.1472082883119583,
-0.09544098377227783,
0.5085507035255432,
-0.2103385031223297,
0.710385262966156,
0.08630051463842392,
0.3850792944431305,
0.1846146434545517,
0.26764485239982605,
0.30143147706985474,
0.048001036047935486,
-0.0812632143497467,
0.2659388482570648,
-0.12127047032117844,
-0.5812088251113892,
-0.4428493082523346,
0.5044973492622375,
-1.0819270610809326,
-0.5726100206375122,
-0.43093445897102356,
-1.1129549741744995,
-0.18005689978599548,
0.08622980862855911,
0.31275713443756104,
-0.10135693848133087,
-0.2281537801027298,
0.15440040826797485,
0.6873091459274292,
0.036242254078388214,
0.20895318686962128,
0.24947170913219452,
-0.08215250074863434,
-0.5103031992912292,
0.9292622208595276,
0.3451139032840729,
0.2319120317697525,
0.41459640860557556,
0.035421840846538544,
-0.19921162724494934,
-0.707053542137146,
-0.5715578198432922,
0.5331147909164429,
-0.4720325767993927,
-0.440828412771225,
-0.5926752686500549,
-0.2852609157562256,
-0.6728530526161194,
-0.34959325194358826,
-0.10219073295593262,
-0.4056200683116913,
-0.3963450789451599,
-0.09487196803092957,
0.24555881321430206,
0.7586989402770996,
-0.32762911915779114,
0.05287150293588638,
-0.9066349864006042,
0.2379540205001831,
-0.013010562397539616,
-0.26143234968185425,
-0.6312186121940613,
-0.5263234376907349,
-0.5457749366760254,
-0.005919060204178095,
-0.017321797087788582,
-1.0524502992630005,
0.7680454254150391,
-0.02320089191198349,
0.684285044670105,
0.12827037274837494,
-0.1680457890033722,
0.6318181157112122,
-0.554716944694519,
0.40075525641441345,
0.03388431668281555,
-0.8122345805168152,
0.544387936592102,
-0.33272862434387207,
-0.105404794216156,
0.6715709567070007,
0.7625203132629395,
-0.14486899971961975,
-0.628024697303772,
-0.4767535328865051,
-0.659650981426239,
0.6428579092025757,
0.3452427387237549,
0.03887366130948067,
0.10733726620674133,
0.4930412769317627,
0.3186179995536804,
0.27864107489585876,
-0.5937236547470093,
-0.21212805807590485,
-0.09285932779312134,
-0.3655698895454407,
-0.3302810490131378,
-0.294404000043869,
-0.09819401800632477,
-0.21427218616008759,
0.7635414600372314,
-0.1843770295381546,
0.017605962231755257,
0.24176949262619019,
-0.20172269642353058,
-0.24971690773963928,
-0.06486628204584122,
0.6234288811683655,
0.618786633014679,
-0.505246102809906,
-0.13184323906898499,
0.21346402168273926,
-0.3657410442829132,
-0.06770665943622589,
0.4035937190055847,
-0.6643484234809875,
0.4594433903694153,
0.4157099723815918,
0.7745354771614075,
-0.09637359529733658,
-0.36267873644828796,
0.42931804060935974,
0.3180377185344696,
-0.1132725179195404,
-0.21010378003120422,
-0.14765767753124237,
-0.1706623136997223,
0.0916091650724411,
0.33079254627227783,
0.1287609487771988,
0.4540286660194397,
-0.33900168538093567,
0.21210584044456482,
0.4219714105129242,
-0.6531108617782593,
-0.09032348543405533,
0.9841456413269043,
-0.013770337216556072,
-0.15897752344608307,
0.7093212604522705,
-0.04482559114694595,
-0.40495145320892334,
0.7315137982368469,
0.9811767935752869,
0.9431335926055908,
-0.17641133069992065,
0.360880583524704,
0.6896234750747681,
0.8096562623977661,
-0.312754362821579,
0.024445166811347008,
-0.05190233886241913,
-0.3261777460575104,
-0.5674872994422913,
-0.4604140818119049,
-0.04961211606860161,
0.08154263347387314,
-0.7898260951042175,
0.40143221616744995,
0.08708526939153671,
0.00888698361814022,
-0.29127979278564453,
-0.11070962250232697,
-0.5867360830307007,
-0.06342282146215439,
0.288616418838501,
0.8288031816482544,
-1.3131555318832397,
0.8964560627937317,
0.77018803358078,
-0.9961756467819214,
-0.6722607016563416,
-0.18027497828006744,
-0.28735849261283875,
-0.8676818013191223,
0.8727425932884216,
-0.18417640030384064,
0.005740607623010874,
0.006024722475558519,
-0.5755155682563782,
-1.0441330671310425,
0.9504892230033875,
0.5607632398605347,
-0.4163101017475128,
0.007892434485256672,
0.4958489239215851,
0.5635579824447632,
-0.5300477743148804,
0.20879900455474854,
0.5839397311210632,
0.4010321795940399,
-0.013390298001468182,
-0.9830593466758728,
-0.049297213554382324,
0.2596488296985626,
0.3635432720184326,
0.25984010100364685,
-0.6114016771316528,
0.7081598043441772,
-0.15695799887180328,
0.020044980570673943,
0.2539910674095154,
0.8238762617111206,
-0.02926483005285263,
0.15881867706775665,
0.26452478766441345,
0.2630012333393097,
0.38988420367240906,
-0.238174170255661,
1.1435447931289673,
-0.1787777841091156,
0.49710384011268616,
0.8183237910270691,
-0.11893144249916077,
0.6172031760215759,
0.702515184879303,
-0.2746333181858063,
0.004103019367903471,
0.7314093112945557,
-0.09143384546041489,
0.673378586769104,
0.2954578101634979,
0.1071881577372551,
-0.36529481410980225,
-0.23409059643745422,
-0.2948867380619049,
0.0748223215341568,
0.3743038475513458,
-0.3938160240650177,
-0.37557485699653625,
0.24753998219966888,
0.23782891035079956,
0.55223149061203,
-0.22601765394210815,
0.6735848784446716,
0.04798750579357147,
-0.55052250623703,
0.7701178789138794,
-0.005030221771448851,
0.2911315858364105,
-0.8763972520828247,
-0.38236284255981445,
-0.4731736183166504,
0.1826302856206894,
-0.18055281043052673,
-0.2921774983406067,
0.534906804561615,
0.0014551443746313453,
-0.2735024392604828,
-0.5814396739006042,
0.5949468612670898,
-0.756888210773468,
-0.789743185043335,
0.5265980362892151,
0.8360487818717957,
0.3306742310523987,
0.2202676385641098,
-0.7235813736915588,
0.268716961145401,
0.23771506547927856,
-0.06529857963323593,
0.3988184928894043,
0.23454895615577698,
-0.25918468832969666,
0.3903942406177521,
0.4315110146999359,
0.31848421692848206,
0.15841729938983917,
0.010338447988033295,
0.74920254945755,
-0.23119044303894043,
-0.11124584078788757,
-0.38970524072647095,
0.3487285375595093,
-0.07486189901828766,
-0.23306098580360413,
0.7061166167259216,
0.9271798133850098,
1.0585153102874756,
-0.3055165112018585,
0.8550964593887329,
0.01175613235682249,
0.5310136079788208,
-0.5290642380714417,
0.383683979511261,
-0.5684834718704224,
0.011727840639650822,
0.06822921335697174,
-1.1607158184051514,
-0.6297836899757385,
0.8936284184455872,
-0.1329401731491089,
-0.06463447958230972,
0.9308561682701111,
0.8483898639678955,
-0.1373441517353058,
-0.5972342491149902,
0.5680694580078125,
0.30319687724113464,
-0.1833779364824295,
0.36023733019828796,
0.42262163758277893,
-0.7551819682121277,
0.707380473613739,
-0.21634389460086823,
-0.3291086256504059,
-0.07504262030124664,
-0.4464743733406067,
-0.8685528635978699,
-0.7222161889076233,
-0.3234596252441406,
-0.83702552318573,
0.26767152547836304,
0.8890244364738464,
0.6743622422218323,
-0.9112136363983154,
-0.6078355312347412,
-0.06494012475013733,
0.2574593424797058,
-0.5703427195549011,
-0.19516566395759583,
0.33949199318885803,
-1.0715880393981934,
-1.1253620386123657,
0.3738318681716919,
0.10379795730113983,
0.0585130974650383,
-0.26081520318984985,
-0.1489713191986084,
-0.26400718092918396,
-0.16448113322257996,
0.27476099133491516,
0.21950170397758484,
-0.6195409893989563,
-0.14323312044143677,
0.2579207420349121,
-0.4428982734680176,
0.04006163775920868,
0.9034784436225891,
-0.9084383249282837,
0.19794774055480957,
0.6449598670005798,
0.8834652304649353,
0.8716696500778198,
-0.23270945250988007,
0.6424282193183899,
-0.6260514855384827,
0.6340859532356262,
0.2530249357223511,
0.38548898696899414,
0.4097195565700531,
-0.5285180807113647,
1.1317843198776245,
0.34392523765563965,
-0.43899300694465637,
-0.8172027468681335,
0.1439642310142517,
-0.9766256213188171,
-0.3362364172935486,
1.425788402557373,
-0.0877290889620781,
-0.3543757498264313,
-0.1075681522488594,
-0.17917923629283905,
0.481429785490036,
-0.2674022316932678,
0.6752778887748718,
0.34275349974632263,
0.054609499871730804,
-0.005703275557607412,
-0.9645700454711914,
0.6161207556724548,
0.5808181166648865,
-0.4499320685863495,
-0.33690154552459717,
0.6810745000839233,
0.11480124294757843,
0.11904314905405045,
0.5283355116844177,
-0.07717009633779526,
0.09578140079975128,
0.09985538572072983,
-0.017076779156923294,
-0.046016477048397064,
-0.4177320897579193,
-0.28583312034606934,
-0.11254478245973587,
-0.04883359372615814,
-0.40695568919181824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19470v1 | Changing Answer Order Can Decrease MMLU Accuracy | 2024-06-27T18:21:32 | 2024-06-27T18:21:32 | Vipul Gupta, David Pantoja, Candace Ross, Adina Williams, Megan Ung | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) have grown in prevalence, particular
benchmarks have become essential for the evaluation of these models and for
understanding model capabilities. Most commonly, we use test accuracy averaged
across multiple subtasks in order to rank models on leaderboards, to determine
which model is best for our purposes. In this paper, we investigate the
robustness of the accuracy measurement on a widely used multiple choice
question answering dataset, MMLU. When shuffling the answer label contents, we
find that all explored models decrease in accuracy on MMLU, but not every model
is equally sensitive. These findings suggest a possible adjustment to the
standard practice of leaderboard testing, where we additionally consider the
percentage of examples each model answers correctly by random chance. | [
-0.29546698927879333,
-0.9474762082099915,
0.5038999319076538,
-0.07032383978366852,
-0.002432269509881735,
0.06568817049264908,
0.06823465973138809,
-0.5779310464859009,
0.09298001974821091,
0.15448591113090515,
-0.5695302486419678,
-0.25300851464271545,
-0.8355884552001953,
0.18860873579978943,
-0.3715248703956604,
0.8702316284179688,
-0.04613574221730232,
0.2278461903333664,
-0.45153769850730896,
-0.7031423449516296,
-0.5956087112426758,
-0.7104912996292114,
-0.6501675248146057,
-0.5722342133522034,
0.8690515756607056,
0.2804684042930603,
1.209987759590149,
0.586885929107666,
0.59499591588974,
0.26550307869911194,
-0.4188029170036316,
0.18936333060264587,
-0.6641828417778015,
0.06582284718751907,
0.12519459426403046,
-0.9441972970962524,
-1.0068767070770264,
0.32679352164268494,
0.41427937150001526,
0.6560308933258057,
-0.4099498689174652,
0.5582898855209351,
0.06890517473220825,
0.4276677072048187,
-0.403464138507843,
-0.046512849628925323,
-0.8329004049301147,
-0.2598714232444763,
-0.12650005519390106,
-0.3216100335121155,
-0.6799235343933105,
-0.2972252368927002,
-0.08679068088531494,
-0.43689289689064026,
0.04967840760946274,
0.07849524170160294,
0.7843753099441528,
0.2592496871948242,
-0.16745057702064514,
-0.2081930935382843,
-0.5073936581611633,
0.9672034978866577,
-0.8731963038444519,
0.5519579648971558,
0.6646134853363037,
0.5093967914581299,
-0.18811281025409698,
-0.3733082413673401,
-0.15977950394153595,
-0.13525334000587463,
0.22156989574432373,
0.2007807493209839,
0.14909720420837402,
-0.19383439421653748,
0.2170058786869049,
0.14398881793022156,
-0.44411715865135193,
0.47533899545669556,
-0.2053479254245758,
-0.05689799040555954,
0.7438628077507019,
0.4133717119693756,
-0.008897818624973297,
0.22692926228046417,
-0.011385108344256878,
-0.23118837177753448,
-0.8138265609741211,
0.5006034970283508,
0.6629007458686829,
0.2525922656059265,
0.30535903573036194,
0.7463051080703735,
-0.06747473031282425,
0.8305317759513855,
0.2114294022321701,
-0.6845986843109131,
0.26696863770484924,
-0.08046850562095642,
-0.43906277418136597,
-0.3140147030353546,
0.29530805349349976,
0.696212887763977,
0.023470822721719742,
0.1318621188402176,
-0.16148622334003448,
-0.249324768781662,
0.26332005858421326,
-0.6486344933509827,
-0.2506479024887085,
0.5501543283462524,
-0.4658293128013611,
-0.4586760401725769,
0.013311905786395073,
-0.26092329621315,
-0.2543211877346039,
-0.17513234913349152,
0.23082444071769714,
-0.21349427103996277,
0.08804373443126678,
-0.05390159413218498,
0.20610210299491882,
0.21198336780071259,
0.6915768980979919,
-0.8779784440994263,
0.09445558488368988,
0.681463360786438,
0.6380568146705627,
-0.3493516445159912,
-0.6472174525260925,
-0.8401197195053101,
-0.23845717310905457,
-0.6756455302238464,
0.6518332362174988,
-0.45717310905456543,
-0.4168744683265686,
-0.37285715341567993,
-0.05570054054260254,
-0.3306388258934021,
-0.8158243894577026,
0.48014599084854126,
-0.7893153429031372,
0.14912521839141846,
-0.4757886826992035,
-0.6621829271316528,
0.0451267771422863,
0.3121189475059509,
-0.6035986542701721,
0.9396070241928101,
-0.10278388112783432,
-0.6519780158996582,
0.5480015277862549,
-0.1518556922674179,
-0.14711211621761322,
-0.35618337988853455,
-0.03441442921757698,
-0.5435338616371155,
0.042923957109451294,
0.3683098554611206,
0.3960098922252655,
0.1797056347131729,
0.18513374030590057,
-0.5489426255226135,
-0.5152889490127563,
0.8018215894699097,
-0.5361570119857788,
1.0072765350341797,
0.14076200127601624,
0.1837725192308426,
0.19002248346805573,
-0.47764062881469727,
0.12590938806533813,
-0.11917519569396973,
-0.8080890774726868,
-0.25968798995018005,
0.11025084555149078,
-0.14980939030647278,
0.24965544044971466,
0.1142592802643776,
-0.3851361572742462,
0.09956397116184235,
-0.018509721383452415,
0.04740096628665924,
1.1975915431976318,
-0.23360773921012878,
0.3442654013633728,
-0.9390928149223328,
0.6330244541168213,
-0.008313283324241638,
0.3133895993232727,
0.4217817783355713,
-1.3465899229049683,
-0.5351539850234985,
0.18034616112709045,
0.3478439748287201,
0.6382263898849487,
-0.41935381293296814,
0.21455100178718567,
-0.41502267122268677,
-0.49925199151039124,
-0.9390748143196106,
0.3589431047439575,
0.06259991228580475,
0.42367762327194214,
0.35454344749450684,
-0.011720053851604462,
-0.04589945450425148,
-0.7120116949081421,
-0.23855717480182648,
-0.4605068564414978,
-0.07935968786478043,
0.3954736590385437,
0.2795790135860443,
-0.09055420011281967,
0.6049957871437073,
-0.5629190802574158,
0.2244534194469452,
-0.270539253950119,
0.04944802075624466,
0.5073119401931763,
0.14188477396965027,
0.5308462381362915,
-0.8304442167282104,
-0.34688401222229004,
-0.2033427208662033,
-0.30965667963027954,
-0.10932736098766327,
-0.004492608830332756,
-0.12402103841304779,
0.37891966104507446,
0.45625510811805725,
-0.5281461477279663,
0.3060804009437561,
0.7750533223152161,
-0.12612058222293854,
0.7803837656974792,
-0.19463317096233368,
0.36997586488723755,
-1.0062038898468018,
-0.056160300970077515,
-0.4248567223548889,
-0.08997455984354019,
-0.6495499014854431,
0.3796458840370178,
0.2502133846282959,
0.2760264277458191,
-0.41457599401474,
0.3558740019798279,
-0.10960668325424194,
-0.09380225092172623,
-0.09922146797180176,
0.03257382661104202,
0.006461155600845814,
0.08938856422901154,
-0.47561073303222656,
0.9761493802070618,
0.2100708931684494,
-0.7142635583877563,
0.28929874300956726,
0.2569693326950073,
-0.5482069849967957,
0.5423547625541687,
-0.3678128719329834,
0.19399867951869965,
-0.22804956138134003,
-0.17697098851203918,
-1.2215322256088257,
-0.12020468711853027,
-0.14316192269325256,
-0.5654512643814087,
0.22289423644542694,
-0.014168823137879372,
-0.4662872850894928,
-0.4081292152404785,
-0.2820737957954407,
0.008432568982243538,
0.4655647277832031,
-0.5200241804122925,
0.09938757121562958,
0.24580343067646027,
-0.18347592651844025,
-0.9410249590873718,
-0.7977773547172546,
-0.25610336661338806,
-0.22041518986225128,
-0.5894626379013062,
0.1308681219816208,
-0.8952990770339966,
-0.42457643151283264,
-0.48256784677505493,
-0.4032317101955414,
-0.16908948123455048,
0.5538992881774902,
0.05543070286512375,
0.2844732403755188,
-0.36147499084472656,
0.33701929450035095,
-0.0781477838754654,
0.1579848825931549,
-0.0196696724742651,
0.37136703729629517,
0.44387102127075195,
0.07998472452163696,
-0.4378286898136139,
-0.04653562605381012,
0.13865840435028076,
0.9148082733154297,
-0.15567325055599213,
0.9489309191703796,
0.19531404972076416,
-0.061194706708192825,
-0.04771736264228821,
-0.39199933409690857,
-0.11090753227472305,
-0.5043032169342041,
0.31254616379737854,
-0.6909747123718262,
-0.796671986579895,
0.9454871416091919,
0.5937695503234863,
0.6682249903678894,
0.2649148106575012,
0.6017502546310425,
-0.4611596465110779,
1.1277549266815186,
0.4690994322299957,
-0.09456859529018402,
0.2370995581150055,
0.32604628801345825,
0.2834041714668274,
-0.6803906559944153,
0.0379510298371315,
-0.5435678958892822,
-0.4957340359687805,
-0.6986221075057983,
-0.43005532026290894,
0.2273492068052292,
0.013267120346426964,
0.1478160321712494,
0.021510932594537735,
-0.21967527270317078,
0.45875534415245056,
0.44115814566612244,
0.42275357246398926,
0.4857174754142761,
-0.06501547992229462,
-0.07051018625497818,
-0.08432823419570923,
-0.6825862526893616,
-0.40314412117004395,
1.2128545045852661,
0.36223936080932617,
1.1229889392852783,
0.3880555033683777,
0.4109884202480316,
0.005789163056761026,
0.6208856105804443,
-0.7969253659248352,
0.5125739574432373,
-0.1970396339893341,
-0.7067903280258179,
-0.7275709509849548,
-0.39071768522262573,
-0.8653215169906616,
0.35939040780067444,
-0.06126978248357773,
-0.6212896108627319,
0.07361482083797455,
-0.0816403329372406,
-0.6060177087783813,
0.4078945219516754,
-0.5060015916824341,
0.5550459027290344,
-0.03311123326420784,
0.07393128424882889,
0.36910611391067505,
-0.3669237792491913,
0.35091885924339294,
-0.2504713833332062,
0.1844804584980011,
-0.35180598497390747,
0.010995686054229736,
0.7434836626052856,
-0.2822335958480835,
0.641575038433075,
0.2711639106273651,
-0.31559857726097107,
0.2292487621307373,
0.05721167474985123,
0.4419819712638855,
-0.03552529960870743,
-0.6799833178520203,
-0.14353878796100616,
-0.16128934919834137,
-0.642092227935791,
-0.658555805683136,
0.7849286794662476,
-0.8718635439872742,
-0.8604854345321655,
-0.14858146011829376,
-0.8836785554885864,
-0.21165788173675537,
-0.1536792665719986,
0.3459627032279968,
0.3700443208217621,
-0.026691433042287827,
0.1632714420557022,
0.677447497844696,
-0.02164909616112709,
0.5218583345413208,
0.3312380313873291,
-0.4532771110534668,
-0.12333011627197266,
0.28305181860923767,
0.8084076642990112,
0.5086932182312012,
0.23751147091388702,
0.31999894976615906,
-0.39472541213035583,
-0.8900650143623352,
-0.503828763961792,
-0.05057357996702194,
-1.0114308595657349,
-0.051942527294158936,
-0.49342265725135803,
-0.243809312582016,
-0.5842464566230774,
-0.2360229194164276,
-0.15568968653678894,
-0.3999980688095093,
-0.46540141105651855,
-0.5547285676002502,
0.29314351081848145,
0.6569604277610779,
0.4930027425289154,
0.15482434630393982,
-0.4986318051815033,
0.24062295258045197,
0.7068695425987244,
0.29514533281326294,
-0.12097461521625519,
-1.0164841413497925,
0.001069679856300354,
0.06296385824680328,
-0.09756259620189667,
-1.0045627355575562,
0.1902429163455963,
0.1875964105129242,
0.8949941396713257,
0.2094484120607376,
0.00006844475865364075,
0.8693841099739075,
-0.32991963624954224,
0.6018794178962708,
-0.18424372375011444,
-0.5128964185714722,
0.4208616316318512,
-0.3673953711986542,
0.84736567735672,
0.6225321888923645,
0.28734973073005676,
-0.3704266846179962,
-0.7999168038368225,
-0.6557611227035522,
-0.4149056077003479,
0.3362423777580261,
0.15600726008415222,
0.0962122231721878,
0.3016950488090515,
0.3898811638355255,
0.30277425050735474,
0.0801202803850174,
-0.9045698046684265,
-0.6630905866622925,
0.189266636967659,
0.05426830053329468,
-0.4380186200141907,
-0.3032624423503876,
-0.00015811622142791748,
-0.2718426287174225,
0.7928679585456848,
-0.23723068833351135,
-0.03405717387795448,
-0.06317050755023956,
-0.10947874933481216,
-0.28662240505218506,
0.483969122171402,
0.8647140264511108,
1.1835271120071411,
-0.5420342683792114,
0.08853024244308472,
0.411213219165802,
-0.7013274431228638,
0.3033805191516876,
-0.06739994138479233,
-0.46864932775497437,
0.1941577047109604,
0.26717790961265564,
0.33269748091697693,
-0.005863924510776997,
-0.4214354455471039,
0.21835093200206757,
-0.04208209738135338,
-0.0922083854675293,
0.15553459525108337,
0.13384270668029785,
0.33207640051841736,
-0.14872242510318756,
0.36104732751846313,
0.25630900263786316,
-0.07109896838665009,
-0.5575324892997742,
0.5251802206039429,
0.2539582848548889,
-0.21522793173789978,
0.0359826497733593,
0.6403583288192749,
-0.15330183506011963,
-0.49582070112228394,
0.5280793309211731,
0.050303865224123,
-0.18616381287574768,
0.8169849514961243,
0.42255812883377075,
0.37077704071998596,
-0.8372225761413574,
0.3759755790233612,
0.27646276354789734,
0.7203608751296997,
-0.14689378440380096,
0.30321967601776123,
0.5083616971969604,
-0.8710563778877258,
-0.43876513838768005,
-0.5979148149490356,
-0.6537350416183472,
0.36893102526664734,
-0.7990247011184692,
0.05455882474780083,
-0.5661503672599792,
-0.5269742012023926,
0.15485045313835144,
-0.1615394800901413,
-0.34463733434677124,
0.21781539916992188,
0.04281780123710632,
0.5974839329719543,
-0.8839952349662781,
0.9952250719070435,
0.9270133972167969,
0.08965514600276947,
-0.6926633715629578,
-0.17085380852222443,
0.024188201874494553,
-0.7053718566894531,
0.3218062222003937,
0.2574949264526367,
0.10110998153686523,
-0.36870521306991577,
-0.6258513331413269,
-1.0397074222564697,
1.142783522605896,
0.25791725516319275,
-0.43451255559921265,
0.33866503834724426,
0.13019737601280212,
0.6235735416412354,
-0.31244802474975586,
0.385833740234375,
0.4358452260494232,
0.23253270983695984,
0.09661790728569031,
-1.0564020872116089,
-0.15070587396621704,
-0.0699111744761467,
-0.1522848904132843,
0.18682388961315155,
-0.6516304016113281,
1.1486320495605469,
-0.5032477378845215,
0.0981692522764206,
0.14698299765586853,
0.516668438911438,
0.6958440542221069,
0.22563719749450684,
0.4049409031867981,
0.5122019648551941,
1.195317029953003,
-0.057166509330272675,
0.9872015714645386,
0.3790876269340515,
0.31052151322364807,
1.4729714393615723,
-0.34335654973983765,
1.1511776447296143,
0.5955384373664856,
-0.3034975230693817,
0.14807505905628204,
0.997531533241272,
-0.06118340045213699,
0.3383813798427582,
0.1633003056049347,
0.1622471958398819,
-0.5002554655075073,
0.3431616723537445,
-0.11637286096811295,
0.3918260931968689,
0.13148966431617737,
-0.29212093353271484,
-0.2187245786190033,
-0.06449563801288605,
0.1180938333272934,
-0.12330704927444458,
-0.28824982047080994,
0.3784547746181488,
0.03036491945385933,
-0.7014939188957214,
0.7716082334518433,
-0.07537691295146942,
0.5229902267456055,
-0.19569118320941925,
0.12442316859960556,
-0.5676518082618713,
0.04097248986363411,
-0.11890405416488647,
-0.9955247640609741,
0.09918847680091858,
-0.2123267650604248,
-0.2610321640968323,
-0.32778650522232056,
0.36456960439682007,
-0.35326817631721497,
-0.7097649574279785,
0.2955450415611267,
0.7919682860374451,
0.15487761795520782,
0.22382931411266327,
-0.9751755595207214,
-0.08969087898731232,
0.01919023133814335,
-0.41812601685523987,
0.46420803666114807,
-0.12172408401966095,
0.012032667174935341,
1.023515224456787,
0.7372198104858398,
-0.23371687531471252,
0.6742078065872192,
0.11079616844654083,
0.4630577564239502,
-0.03445988893508911,
-0.5014244318008423,
-0.7622840404510498,
0.3820703625679016,
-0.22431063652038574,
-0.5221476554870605,
0.9236175417900085,
0.37773603200912476,
0.8462150692939758,
-0.025678759440779686,
0.31807973980903625,
0.23581866919994354,
0.48342880606651306,
-0.644352912902832,
0.9904909133911133,
-0.5511795878410339,
0.5578978061676025,
-0.09160798788070679,
-1.0280202627182007,
-0.3479660153388977,
0.29271987080574036,
-0.21591055393218994,
-0.056953199207782745,
0.7161410450935364,
0.8265477418899536,
0.007942473515868187,
-0.09043470770120621,
0.9897139668464661,
0.4613085389137268,
0.32840925455093384,
0.3237897753715515,
0.6986855268478394,
-0.6861165761947632,
0.6326434016227722,
-0.33961936831474304,
-0.054923754185438156,
-0.20657142996788025,
-0.5211060047149658,
-1.0030661821365356,
-0.3626493811607361,
-0.5103343725204468,
-0.328677237033844,
0.1525145322084427,
0.4155137538909912,
0.550918698310852,
-1.037214994430542,
-0.3610282838344574,
0.5720465779304504,
0.4055147171020508,
-0.5097525715827942,
-0.1744157373905182,
0.34964653849601746,
-0.1339934766292572,
-0.5515131950378418,
0.3869357705116272,
0.004265487194061279,
0.2942824959754944,
0.16095134615898132,
0.07486941665410995,
-0.5032467842102051,
0.24568700790405273,
0.5399802923202515,
-0.14848437905311584,
-0.9065057039260864,
-0.5921792387962341,
0.4753183424472809,
-0.3871099054813385,
0.5467735528945923,
0.31765812635421753,
-0.2482215166091919,
0.37925854325294495,
0.6100168228149414,
0.5410940051078796,
0.05299363657832146,
0.30303966999053955,
0.285247802734375,
-0.6054737567901611,
-0.2808852791786194,
0.044213224202394485,
0.38543134927749634,
0.2611757218837738,
-0.38568586111068726,
0.4824187755584717,
0.02215300127863884,
-0.7271984815597534,
-0.6565546989440918,
0.18215663731098175,
-0.8910616040229797,
-0.4377526342868805,
1.1989874839782715,
-0.18754351139068604,
-0.24463419616222382,
-0.36483994126319885,
-0.079350546002388,
-0.24548248946666718,
-0.29426249861717224,
0.756685197353363,
1.338851809501648,
-0.3794768750667572,
-0.37669268250465393,
-0.8583325147628784,
0.3928264379501343,
0.6797969937324524,
-0.7683866024017334,
0.12127804756164551,
0.23916909098625183,
0.48016199469566345,
0.3198866844177246,
0.6690788865089417,
0.006515695247799158,
0.3968783915042877,
-0.20139536261558533,
-0.4823680520057678,
0.3239772319793701,
-0.41631394624710083,
-0.3786559998989105,
0.3958582282066345,
0.4399740695953369,
-0.11243230104446411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19465v1 | Can Large Language Models Generate High-quality Patent Claims? | 2024-06-27T18:07:40 | 2024-06-27T18:07:40 | Lekang Jiang, Caiqi Zhang, Pascal A Scherz, Stephan Goetz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional performance across
various text generation tasks but remain under-explored in the patent domain,
which offers highly structured and precise language. This paper constructs a
dataset to investigate the performance of current LLMs in patent claim
generation. Our results demonstrate that generating claims based on patent
descriptions outperforms previous research relying on abstracts. Interestingly,
current patent-specific LLMs perform much worse than state-of-the-art general
LLMs, highlighting the necessity for future research on in-domain LLMs. We also
find that LLMs can produce high-quality first independent claims, but their
performances markedly decrease for subsequent dependent claims. Moreover,
fine-tuning can enhance the completeness of inventions' features, conceptual
clarity, and feature linkage. Among the tested LLMs, GPT-4 demonstrates the
best performance in comprehensive human evaluations by patent experts, with
better feature coverage, conceptual clarity, and technical coherence. Despite
these capabilities, comprehensive revision and modification are still necessary
to pass rigorous patent scrutiny and ensure legal robustness. | [
-0.0679422989487648,
-0.4489767849445343,
0.6672205924987793,
0.20973849296569824,
-0.08512913435697556,
0.24017120897769928,
-0.2464643269777298,
-0.7652288675308228,
0.13605588674545288,
0.5654151439666748,
0.12070753425359726,
-0.42702218890190125,
-0.6346586346626282,
0.1847248673439026,
-0.3122495412826538,
0.6993988752365112,
-0.010897264815866947,
-0.2434076964855194,
-0.19595082104206085,
0.32885751128196716,
-0.4346645772457123,
-0.7279574275016785,
-0.27844947576522827,
-0.5328575372695923,
0.4026573896408081,
0.21918515861034393,
0.44822996854782104,
0.5274163484573364,
0.34886786341667175,
0.30392706394195557,
-0.2830422520637512,
0.10220245271921158,
-0.1068662703037262,
0.12008864432573318,
-0.09173865616321564,
-0.4006679952144623,
-0.6686317324638367,
0.031326424330472946,
0.6543642282485962,
0.6592183709144592,
-0.0032710740342736244,
0.06445670872926712,
0.2554788887500763,
0.3166796863079071,
-0.4134637117385864,
0.1620120406150818,
-1.049404501914978,
0.039974913001060486,
-0.46937063336372375,
-0.19688348472118378,
-0.5624191761016846,
-0.15812456607818604,
0.3730938732624054,
-0.4605485200881958,
0.4888746440410614,
0.3428122103214264,
1.3118577003479004,
-0.1443852335214615,
-0.24127444624900818,
-0.29125118255615234,
-0.4962216317653656,
0.6582361459732056,
-0.9790459275245667,
-0.08347155898809433,
0.1712106615304947,
0.0857122614979744,
-0.43211764097213745,
-1.0674594640731812,
-0.5523457527160645,
-0.553745687007904,
0.164098858833313,
-0.2774735689163208,
-0.310868501663208,
0.03176102414727211,
0.45625224709510803,
0.36279866099357605,
-0.5926390886306763,
0.61342853307724,
-0.44774606823921204,
-0.47055917978286743,
0.6376848816871643,
-0.030351337045431137,
0.22018659114837646,
-0.3789292573928833,
-0.29867950081825256,
0.10702932626008987,
-1.3634157180786133,
-0.08987001329660416,
0.4266716241836548,
0.320434033870697,
0.15062585473060608,
0.8242262601852417,
-0.17489399015903473,
0.49462026357650757,
-0.12857329845428467,
-0.22140304744243622,
0.15858082473278046,
-0.24520675837993622,
-0.27570104598999023,
0.20854969322681427,
0.8423183560371399,
0.18408477306365967,
0.28501880168914795,
-0.19726251065731049,
-0.4369288384914398,
-0.48245882987976074,
-0.029104553163051605,
-1.0917268991470337,
-0.051925186067819595,
0.20121580362319946,
-0.4824855625629425,
-0.17316550016403198,
0.011452903971076012,
-0.4329216778278351,
-0.6394653916358948,
-0.22570675611495972,
0.449745237827301,
-0.1858050376176834,
-0.229555144906044,
0.36736786365509033,
-0.1236485093832016,
0.06545064598321915,
-0.02258351817727089,
-0.9141461253166199,
0.06839731335639954,
0.9039751291275024,
0.8271787762641907,
-0.0695459321141243,
-0.2525826096534729,
-0.40318503975868225,
0.23398488759994507,
-0.6972572803497314,
0.9771140813827515,
-0.19368602335453033,
-0.36360710859298706,
0.04522615671157837,
-0.17908449470996857,
0.06000664457678795,
-1.0455962419509888,
0.6481996178627014,
-0.590335488319397,
-0.01741865649819374,
-0.28389260172843933,
-0.5656711459159851,
0.3035583198070526,
0.12258333712816238,
-0.5680113434791565,
0.3777886927127838,
-0.1883448362350464,
-0.7541259527206421,
0.8327693343162537,
-0.4689972698688507,
-0.6662468314170837,
0.3181082606315613,
-0.4295509159564972,
-0.5006223320960999,
0.3902847170829773,
0.07292090356349945,
0.6214309334754944,
-0.6817690134048462,
0.4737049639225006,
-0.11101710796356201,
-0.025067994371056557,
0.49229007959365845,
-0.22582672536373138,
0.4120776057243347,
0.3585335314273834,
-0.5080929398536682,
0.009181302040815353,
-0.6889689564704895,
0.039349015802145004,
0.3312038779258728,
-0.423812597990036,
-0.10594242811203003,
0.037683967500925064,
-0.3470229506492615,
0.29310697317123413,
0.5466214418411255,
-0.9019407033920288,
0.057217974215745926,
-0.6118877530097961,
0.6977460980415344,
0.7889831066131592,
-0.015045077539980412,
-0.11509893834590912,
-0.2525789439678192,
0.51790452003479,
-0.16758593916893005,
-0.12107755243778229,
-0.38683003187179565,
-0.6156290173530579,
-0.5980751514434814,
-0.3897705674171448,
0.64231276512146,
0.15059100091457367,
-0.568140983581543,
0.43373626470565796,
-0.49058476090431213,
-0.18323439359664917,
-0.14172805845737457,
0.05176495760679245,
0.4617425501346588,
0.38651803135871887,
-0.07439786195755005,
-0.35154256224632263,
-0.42451557517051697,
-1.176700234413147,
-0.32072776556015015,
-0.19543883204460144,
-0.2354571670293808,
0.41345447301864624,
0.4395769536495209,
0.08406621962785721,
0.873094379901886,
-0.5006918907165527,
-0.14852972328662872,
-0.269232839345932,
0.31839603185653687,
0.39217981696128845,
0.060641609132289886,
0.6274313926696777,
-0.5572631359100342,
-0.4545057415962219,
0.28923216462135315,
-0.5851265788078308,
-0.26448723673820496,
-0.004451480228453875,
0.14605876803398132,
0.3702237904071808,
0.2642059326171875,
-0.9093972444534302,
0.07814610749483109,
0.26610326766967773,
-0.28828760981559753,
0.7330751419067383,
-0.3927055895328522,
-0.014037585817277431,
-1.0237412452697754,
0.25113940238952637,
0.11038447171449661,
0.009483721107244492,
-0.35648152232170105,
-0.12185980379581451,
0.085961252450943,
-0.24568314850330353,
-0.4823673367500305,
0.6592925190925598,
-0.5957910418510437,
-0.10904253274202347,
-0.49142390489578247,
-0.10596861690282822,
0.20996755361557007,
-0.17862960696220398,
-0.3656752407550812,
0.8941007852554321,
0.634364128112793,
-0.5252478122711182,
0.2963157296180725,
0.061079978942871094,
-0.7169290781021118,
0.06781275570392609,
-0.9240056276321411,
-0.04092853143811226,
0.17383477091789246,
0.17074796557426453,
-0.8248940706253052,
-0.5914137959480286,
-0.46512842178344727,
-0.21393978595733643,
0.5798479914665222,
0.028866175562143326,
-0.9435776472091675,
-0.7708814144134521,
-0.19772490859031677,
-0.08661734312772751,
0.5479324460029602,
-0.7364264726638794,
0.27285581827163696,
0.37885338068008423,
-0.8263517618179321,
-0.4813999533653259,
-0.7386246919631958,
0.6384938359260559,
-0.3166245222091675,
-0.7884576320648193,
0.5651403665542603,
0.3503528833389282,
-0.13079801201820374,
-0.2079615741968155,
0.037173956632614136,
-0.09213295578956604,
-0.08192359656095505,
0.07357747852802277,
0.1730348765850067,
-0.27458763122558594,
0.05411449074745178,
-0.04954679682850838,
-0.10335816442966461,
0.20469702780246735,
-0.2046356201171875,
0.5433252453804016,
0.2157914638519287,
-0.30322977900505066,
-0.4188515543937683,
0.17366057634353638,
0.5452166199684143,
-0.10301858186721802,
0.20478497445583344,
-0.0836411565542221,
-0.3643059730529785,
-0.35534021258354187,
-0.6370987296104431,
0.06923206895589828,
-0.5102750062942505,
0.37056055665016174,
-0.6045942306518555,
-1.0085376501083374,
0.4427124857902527,
-0.13286687433719635,
0.21111451089382172,
0.8008880019187927,
0.5760713219642639,
0.22317129373550415,
0.9165596961975098,
0.5077722668647766,
-0.11492784321308136,
0.1549624651670456,
-0.05111357569694519,
0.614251434803009,
-0.4954800009727478,
-0.20483337342739105,
-0.7598505020141602,
-0.06557214260101318,
-0.4918389916419983,
-0.12794551253318787,
0.16477838158607483,
0.061392806470394135,
-0.19627080857753754,
0.3191375136375427,
-0.5791676640510559,
0.49071499705314636,
0.6307023763656616,
-0.1541610062122345,
0.392943799495697,
0.4221741855144501,
-0.3934077024459839,
-0.17333538830280304,
-0.4915340840816498,
-0.9355090260505676,
1.4578238725662231,
0.565705418586731,
0.8859809041023254,
-0.052451666444540024,
0.5894786715507507,
0.3160706162452698,
0.3013669550418854,
-0.5019643306732178,
0.5379049777984619,
-0.2952536642551422,
-0.6005135774612427,
0.030513709411025047,
-0.3707020878791809,
-0.9409080743789673,
0.11744929105043411,
-0.08301687985658646,
-0.6349298357963562,
0.11305608600378036,
0.2533358931541443,
-0.5578637719154358,
0.20810110867023468,
-0.798864483833313,
0.5673867464065552,
-0.6540784239768982,
-0.4061877727508545,
-0.24255569279193878,
-0.24392671883106232,
0.585692286491394,
-0.618338406085968,
-0.21598172187805176,
-0.15841472148895264,
0.23978331685066223,
0.7369788885116577,
-0.537592887878418,
0.7969434857368469,
-0.19273237884044647,
-0.5809832215309143,
0.42745333909988403,
-0.11498890817165375,
0.5139780044555664,
-0.15976126492023468,
-0.28100767731666565,
-0.022694000974297523,
-0.23508457839488983,
-0.1729048788547516,
-0.30001163482666016,
0.8305956721305847,
-0.24697694182395935,
-0.7150248289108276,
-0.30727681517601013,
-0.37485286593437195,
-0.2099972367286682,
0.39161938428878784,
0.5571354627609253,
0.4266141355037689,
-0.2049502581357956,
0.14700907468795776,
0.4423828721046448,
-0.6416944265365601,
0.39330267906188965,
0.334304541349411,
-0.13929729163646698,
-0.4456755518913269,
1.0766359567642212,
0.2869766652584076,
0.1931295394897461,
0.08230520039796829,
0.2563493847846985,
-0.5548804402351379,
-0.9732627272605896,
-0.2845247983932495,
0.27352115511894226,
-0.4720749855041504,
-0.32169103622436523,
-0.6241194605827332,
-0.3093721270561218,
-0.5270795822143555,
0.20134736597537994,
-0.27139246463775635,
-0.6375935077667236,
0.07542649656534195,
-0.01057217177003622,
0.07859236001968384,
0.9594379663467407,
0.09568257629871368,
0.06602392345666885,
-0.6302905082702637,
0.3393842577934265,
0.5323301553726196,
0.43924492597579956,
-0.17262952029705048,
-0.4419839382171631,
-0.2428758144378662,
-0.04108300805091858,
-0.8424654603004456,
-0.07498924434185028,
0.3914768397808075,
0.3321015536785126,
0.6558504104614258,
0.26553967595100403,
-0.14470326900482178,
0.43482470512390137,
-0.8074551820755005,
1.015325665473938,
0.3011883497238159,
-0.7292231917381287,
0.4101070165634155,
-0.29589128494262695,
-0.1419987976551056,
-0.04541889205574989,
0.05343969538807869,
0.0520516075193882,
-0.2387198805809021,
-0.561011791229248,
-1.009140133857727,
0.34189459681510925,
0.07499333471059799,
0.3784182667732239,
-0.025707537308335304,
0.37493857741355896,
0.1486446112394333,
0.14086025953292847,
-0.5058892965316772,
0.308306485414505,
0.1823180764913559,
-0.04576785862445831,
0.15741199254989624,
-0.30287981033325195,
-0.07101308554410934,
0.10439706593751907,
0.542961597442627,
-0.03671669587492943,
0.2348661571741104,
0.12197178602218628,
0.18467845022678375,
-0.021182049065828323,
0.4608575403690338,
0.7959124445915222,
0.8781682252883911,
0.08463761955499649,
0.13292501866817474,
-0.0987938940525055,
-0.3172655403614044,
0.1105339527130127,
0.40244969725608826,
-0.03173183277249336,
0.1519845873117447,
0.380505234003067,
0.6284520626068115,
-0.08051594346761703,
-0.9197970032691956,
0.5965936183929443,
-0.0514008104801178,
-0.5208979249000549,
0.1505119651556015,
0.13435840606689453,
0.022215817123651505,
0.28171926736831665,
0.6166654229164124,
-0.19817006587982178,
0.14052017033100128,
-0.3777259588241577,
0.24771150946617126,
0.4982379376888275,
0.3734864592552185,
-0.34523847699165344,
0.7470988035202026,
0.162389874458313,
-0.05438574030995369,
0.08465926349163055,
0.05896064639091492,
-0.40671852231025696,
0.6944096684455872,
0.7462199926376343,
0.9027853012084961,
0.06996718794107437,
-0.06852320581674576,
0.12322382628917694,
0.2122296243906021,
-0.34552252292633057,
0.08209436386823654,
0.16194726526737213,
-0.517835259437561,
-0.6937815546989441,
-0.470255970954895,
-0.6134769320487976,
0.3723578155040741,
-0.023426571860909462,
0.14221714437007904,
-0.44735369086265564,
-0.5191084146499634,
0.19312052428722382,
-0.05851273611187935,
-0.4967877268791199,
-0.03319529816508293,
0.10183786600828171,
0.7268866896629333,
-0.4979831576347351,
0.5981506109237671,
0.49944090843200684,
-0.1733981966972351,
-0.7293066382408142,
0.07095232605934143,
-0.25379684567451477,
-0.45258796215057373,
0.9981556534767151,
0.1544497013092041,
-0.060181766748428345,
-0.16956289112567902,
-0.7114355564117432,
-0.683956503868103,
0.9258162975311279,
0.8315814137458801,
-0.5732199549674988,
-0.09272550791501999,
0.5654376149177551,
0.4880417287349701,
-0.3205077648162842,
-0.37004703283309937,
0.34161463379859924,
0.2681904733181,
0.07515408098697662,
-1.2754789590835571,
0.02553841471672058,
-0.147225022315979,
0.22980882227420807,
-0.12906260788440704,
-0.47995707392692566,
0.8735831379890442,
-0.35620614886283875,
-0.3035185933113098,
0.4134752154350281,
0.5558885931968689,
0.5915466547012329,
0.20835953950881958,
0.03145845979452133,
0.5050709843635559,
0.8544077277183533,
-0.1393761783838272,
1.169637680053711,
-0.4686669707298279,
0.12703725695610046,
1.167281985282898,
-0.7472758889198303,
0.9456177949905396,
0.11644048988819122,
-0.05159838870167732,
0.06991815567016602,
0.4760861396789551,
-0.02859615907073021,
0.26020029187202454,
0.5820508003234863,
-0.26081427931785583,
-0.09394267201423645,
-0.2439347207546234,
-0.41405120491981506,
0.27535805106163025,
0.28198423981666565,
-0.7222279906272888,
-0.10147468745708466,
-0.10188053548336029,
-0.0035720388405025005,
-0.08041294664144516,
0.04143963009119034,
0.5746873021125793,
0.19503584504127502,
-0.7637249231338501,
0.8730627298355103,
0.151860773563385,
0.7777308821678162,
-0.3797880709171295,
-0.021908214315772057,
-0.052142348140478134,
0.22091999650001526,
-0.19016478955745697,
-0.8114336729049683,
-0.21416769921779633,
0.44542840123176575,
-0.08051543682813644,
-0.15905535221099854,
0.7588873505592346,
-0.06571363657712936,
-0.30152398347854614,
-0.021145006641745567,
0.29251807928085327,
0.21163366734981537,
0.024466795846819878,
-0.27943044900894165,
-0.14594702422618866,
-0.22623030841350555,
-0.3663416802883148,
0.2676755487918854,
0.673163890838623,
-0.14696094393730164,
0.6217418313026428,
0.5323906540870667,
0.5163852572441101,
0.4619990885257721,
0.15912504494190216,
0.8228960633277893,
-0.6668637990951538,
-0.1435183435678482,
-0.7277366518974304,
0.35036858916282654,
-0.3081718683242798,
-0.34084901213645935,
0.6041586995124817,
0.8855333924293518,
0.45886602997779846,
-0.07591940462589264,
1.086243987083435,
0.028002148494124413,
0.5472460389137268,
-0.7097136378288269,
0.8780506253242493,
-0.2273956537246704,
0.31210261583328247,
-0.2188304215669632,
-0.8551274538040161,
-0.572100043296814,
0.2949492335319519,
-0.16758407652378082,
0.07027922570705414,
0.5789512991905212,
0.7455535531044006,
0.047561418265104294,
-0.22838976979255676,
0.4230869710445404,
0.5016595721244812,
0.9263508319854736,
0.3825037479400635,
0.8732503652572632,
-0.31551656126976013,
0.364755243062973,
0.18146340548992157,
-0.10872504860162735,
-0.013352155685424805,
-1.0153571367263794,
-0.6683845520019531,
-0.200228750705719,
-0.2279176265001297,
-0.35923606157302856,
-0.12025204300880432,
0.7088379859924316,
0.7021097540855408,
-0.7144330739974976,
-0.0963183343410492,
-0.1135696992278099,
-0.32494205236434937,
0.4194665253162384,
-0.15505413711071014,
0.5332178473472595,
-0.5229468941688538,
-0.5717926025390625,
0.4507843554019928,
0.37520846724510193,
0.1697942614555359,
-0.17513719201087952,
-0.06243882328271866,
0.3162981867790222,
0.08938398957252502,
0.861604630947113,
0.42728328704833984,
-0.841262936592102,
-0.15636232495307922,
-0.05698757618665695,
-0.2892542779445648,
0.07366197556257248,
1.0055464506149292,
-0.4354933798313141,
0.4066489338874817,
0.47939786314964294,
0.8302607536315918,
0.3852004110813141,
-0.09485659748315811,
0.7395426630973816,
-0.6202207207679749,
0.04092986881732941,
0.2254450023174286,
0.6503728032112122,
0.3593156039714813,
-0.159393310546875,
0.14689327776432037,
0.0930914580821991,
-0.7634326219558716,
-0.7802194952964783,
0.1271025836467743,
-0.6702073216438293,
-0.12627233564853668,
1.24313485622406,
-0.1867554634809494,
-0.14601671695709229,
-0.051846086978912354,
-0.3492540717124939,
-0.17898297309875488,
-0.24487489461898804,
0.8155727386474609,
0.8925173282623291,
-0.239077627658844,
0.21117503941059113,
-0.6298343539237976,
0.3185533583164215,
0.25562241673469543,
-0.756306529045105,
0.3104557394981384,
0.5591835379600525,
0.3947296142578125,
0.2170507162809372,
0.4821683466434479,
-0.5566053986549377,
0.10906293988227844,
-0.21344569325447083,
0.23828352987766266,
-0.047852177172899246,
-0.3752727806568146,
-0.23158305883407593,
0.36628642678260803,
0.902614176273346,
-0.04593496024608612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19388v1 | Taming Data and Transformers for Audio Generation | 2024-06-27T17:58:54 | 2024-06-27T17:58:54 | Moayed Haji-Ali, Willi Menapace, Aliaksandr Siarohin, Guha Balakrishnan, Sergey Tulyakov, Vicente Ordonez | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM, eess.AS | Generating ambient sounds and effects is a challenging problem due to data
scarcity and often insufficient caption quality, making it difficult to employ
large-scale generative models for the task. In this work, we tackle the problem
by introducing two new models. First, we propose AutoCap, a high-quality and
efficient automatic audio captioning model. We show that by leveraging metadata
available with the audio modality, we can substantially improve the quality of
captions. AutoCap reaches CIDEr score of 83.2, marking a 3.2% improvement from
the best available captioning model at four times faster inference speed. We
then use AutoCap to caption clips from existing datasets, obtaining 761,000
audio clips with high-quality captions, forming the largest available
audio-text dataset. Second, we propose GenAu, a scalable transformer-based
audio generation architecture that we scale up to 1.25B parameters and train
with our new dataset. When compared to state-of-the-art audio generators, GenAu
obtains significant improvements of 15.7% in FAD score, 22.7% in IS, and 13.5%
in CLAP score, indicating significantly improved quality of generated audio
compared to previous works. This shows that the quality of data is often as
important as its quantity. Besides, since AutoCap is fully automatic, new audio
samples can be added to the training dataset, unlocking the training of even
larger generative models for audio synthesis. | [
-0.7766627669334412,
-0.6043566465377808,
0.27142834663391113,
0.2571495473384857,
-0.12276303023099899,
0.34631991386413574,
0.022042013704776764,
-0.45834261178970337,
0.0695783868432045,
0.6033873558044434,
-0.6379005312919617,
-0.3406115770339966,
-0.46536681056022644,
0.12036652117967606,
-0.8320067524909973,
0.6623579859733582,
0.12112167477607727,
-0.35361912846565247,
-0.04444718360900879,
0.02176312915980816,
-0.9242781400680542,
-0.3961661756038666,
-0.5805010199546814,
-0.03330496326088905,
-0.2108640819787979,
0.3551994860172272,
0.8051978945732117,
0.887865424156189,
0.45561298727989197,
0.32524463534355164,
0.20124903321266174,
0.20768971741199493,
-0.09350074827671051,
0.27865514159202576,
0.35046759247779846,
-0.21142594516277313,
-0.35884347558021545,
0.08186754584312439,
0.3932742476463318,
0.22504858672618866,
-0.3130030035972595,
0.16233880817890167,
-0.14848190546035767,
0.4960442781448364,
-0.2639915347099304,
0.2556346356868744,
-0.8613178730010986,
0.32467082142829895,
0.01920502446591854,
-0.497459352016449,
-0.2675814926624298,
0.1070784479379654,
-0.23113998770713806,
-0.7787759304046631,
0.6168418526649475,
0.44071611762046814,
1.0248078107833862,
0.8230236172676086,
0.031992148607969284,
-0.36833834648132324,
-1.1709176301956177,
0.5361414551734924,
-0.6332595348358154,
0.43529996275901794,
0.32367372512817383,
0.5698776245117188,
0.06764685362577438,
-0.8256227374076843,
-0.707231879234314,
-0.16953660547733307,
0.016536980867385864,
0.4097154140472412,
-0.6268505454063416,
-0.022801486775279045,
0.32878658175468445,
1.093542218208313,
-0.2200934886932373,
0.08312832564115524,
-0.569857120513916,
-0.21468941867351532,
0.8781349658966064,
0.40163126587867737,
0.5104966163635254,
-0.4920244812965393,
-0.3724425435066223,
-0.409806489944458,
-0.795973539352417,
0.07523320615291595,
0.8057324886322021,
0.24624408781528473,
-0.10283852368593216,
0.4492748975753784,
-0.051299236714839935,
0.4422144889831543,
0.5295217633247375,
0.1386331021785736,
0.10989965498447418,
-0.5812891125679016,
-0.17187656462192535,
0.056416939944028854,
1.0338469743728638,
0.29852399230003357,
-0.14638933539390564,
-0.1823461651802063,
-0.4409496486186981,
-0.019136954098939896,
0.6319375038146973,
-0.6629984974861145,
-0.6622592806816101,
0.3313993811607361,
-0.3094176650047302,
-0.35500413179397583,
0.20283211767673492,
-1.0251758098602295,
0.0872456282377243,
-0.8395929932594299,
0.6781014204025269,
-0.38402846455574036,
-0.09866064041852951,
-0.03978033736348152,
-0.2569827735424042,
0.09740031510591507,
-0.061816733330488205,
-1.0121357440948486,
0.3504410982131958,
0.17070214450359344,
0.8263025283813477,
-0.4215250015258789,
0.11878125369548798,
-0.5736739635467529,
0.2657296061515808,
-0.3788691461086273,
0.7386652231216431,
-0.22375571727752686,
-0.6150102019309998,
-0.2381402552127838,
-0.11961790174245834,
0.20790119469165802,
-0.8337644338607788,
0.5140256285667419,
-0.2508101463317871,
0.26537957787513733,
0.022200046107172966,
-0.30269140005111694,
0.16234903037548065,
-0.6739498376846313,
-0.9995585083961487,
1.0464694499969482,
0.2570425868034363,
-0.20278112590312958,
0.5048559904098511,
-1.0326634645462036,
-0.6790341138839722,
0.07118895649909973,
0.11371541768312454,
-0.7719670534133911,
0.1370994746685028,
0.7054076194763184,
0.2459719181060791,
-0.21379153430461884,
0.45298314094543457,
0.16421128809452057,
-0.30758795142173767,
0.16461032629013062,
-0.6969665288925171,
0.5417715907096863,
0.6755451560020447,
-0.6239942908287048,
0.08439501374959946,
-0.6554354429244995,
-0.423068642616272,
-0.0429389625787735,
-0.011127328500151634,
0.20515848696231842,
-0.13986249268054962,
0.3873215615749359,
0.16252072155475616,
-0.4858165383338928,
-0.48743680119514465,
-0.25082793831825256,
-0.3671112656593323,
0.7818797826766968,
0.6276447772979736,
0.2988876700401306,
0.4400721788406372,
-0.6463468670845032,
0.7061246633529663,
-0.17112818360328674,
0.22726649045944214,
-0.5459696650505066,
-0.34362682700157166,
-0.5146031975746155,
-0.6627820134162903,
0.25090721249580383,
0.222093403339386,
-0.4899378716945648,
0.7351384162902832,
-0.0408160462975502,
-0.5303627848625183,
-1.1021586656570435,
0.04448024556040764,
-0.1356074959039688,
0.31326666474342346,
0.6155652403831482,
-0.4527888894081116,
-0.8715493083000183,
-0.786685585975647,
0.02527569979429245,
-0.013546936213970184,
-0.6104004383087158,
0.5216206312179565,
0.18767961859703064,
-0.16062772274017334,
1.2330455780029297,
-0.5120264887809753,
-0.5439098477363586,
0.05619426816701889,
0.473493367433548,
0.24162833392620087,
0.7267768979072571,
0.6802815198898315,
-0.6547718644142151,
-0.4915238618850708,
-0.5191330313682556,
-0.5386661887168884,
-0.5507326722145081,
-0.4191322326660156,
-0.09476297348737717,
-0.11549154669046402,
0.7315506935119629,
-0.8649348616600037,
0.06404491513967514,
0.4043470621109009,
0.12640081346035004,
0.7266771197319031,
0.072295643389225,
0.36307111382484436,
-0.9168907999992371,
0.06434793025255203,
-0.43791791796684265,
-0.17527629435062408,
-0.5480128526687622,
0.023451702669262886,
-0.5752403736114502,
-0.6265662312507629,
-0.4439714848995209,
0.26445236802101135,
-0.48348167538642883,
-0.044980935752391815,
-0.5560376048088074,
-0.07158444076776505,
0.3048792779445648,
0.3463836908340454,
-0.07243206351995468,
1.049944281578064,
0.6310555338859558,
-0.5552970170974731,
0.633160412311554,
0.5027323365211487,
-0.538263201713562,
0.4829484224319458,
-0.8512081503868103,
0.1938823163509369,
-0.08884802460670471,
0.34536680579185486,
-1.16389799118042,
-0.4507303833961487,
-0.006829411257058382,
-0.6524440050125122,
0.3725840747356415,
0.15083424746990204,
-0.9420838356018066,
-0.4953058362007141,
0.09880083799362183,
0.33215126395225525,
0.8940762877464294,
-0.9535821080207825,
0.7482292056083679,
0.6005527377128601,
-0.2789185345172882,
0.20230944454669952,
-0.6634796261787415,
0.3455891013145447,
-0.6096372008323669,
-0.392284095287323,
0.6042228937149048,
-0.3214409053325653,
-0.18199390172958374,
-0.05089130997657776,
-0.1558084487915039,
0.014047635719180107,
-0.18477536737918854,
0.5081404447555542,
0.33563414216041565,
-0.08370058238506317,
0.19500640034675598,
0.24516475200653076,
-0.22996141016483307,
0.3570935130119324,
-0.08249417692422867,
0.3760756254196167,
0.003520406549796462,
-0.13869376480579376,
-0.5800301432609558,
0.34907498955726624,
0.9045491218566895,
-0.3053134083747864,
0.025361327454447746,
0.692889928817749,
-0.10955624282360077,
-0.1897002011537552,
-0.5719360709190369,
-0.4973389506340027,
-0.6288332343101501,
0.01717313565313816,
-0.2965176999568939,
-0.5883051156997681,
0.486106276512146,
-0.08050601929426193,
0.296836256980896,
0.8435395359992981,
0.3858411908149719,
-0.4973728060722351,
0.9771751761436462,
0.18137168884277344,
-0.164657324552536,
0.4086669087409973,
-0.437782883644104,
0.1668049395084381,
-0.759644627571106,
-0.06287859380245209,
-0.35102370381355286,
-0.11314977705478668,
-0.5210187435150146,
-0.3570992946624756,
0.629672110080719,
-0.2997666001319885,
-0.16607020795345306,
0.7109825611114502,
-0.8607237935066223,
0.2107369303703308,
0.749156653881073,
-0.11913446336984634,
0.3143092095851898,
0.370726615190506,
0.37660086154937744,
0.027792254462838173,
-0.7255645394325256,
-0.12496185302734375,
1.1004971265792847,
0.37495213747024536,
0.5779740214347839,
-0.08139453083276749,
0.46771302819252014,
0.7605500221252441,
0.16907545924186707,
-0.5042835474014282,
0.1555922031402588,
-0.05958211049437523,
-0.741947591304779,
-0.4761694669723511,
-0.2749783396720886,
-0.7957765460014343,
0.08019893616437912,
-0.4002127945423126,
-0.31064003705978394,
0.23235203325748444,
0.09113167971372604,
-0.5308768153190613,
0.4178018569946289,
-0.45524895191192627,
0.2997029423713684,
-0.014284380711615086,
-0.20710790157318115,
0.10215911269187927,
-0.5490891337394714,
0.2561385929584503,
-0.2666704058647156,
0.4155862331390381,
-0.1113695502281189,
0.5234614014625549,
0.563143253326416,
-0.2507473826408386,
0.562617838382721,
-0.0716717541217804,
-0.28871116042137146,
0.9283978939056396,
-0.004539838060736656,
0.34984225034713745,
0.12763097882270813,
0.10656064003705978,
0.3149837255477905,
-0.1598060131072998,
-0.05382811650633812,
-0.5595765113830566,
0.5676631927490234,
-0.7933263778686523,
-0.5894323587417603,
0.1591707468032837,
-1.045408844947815,
-0.05511355772614479,
-0.2091321349143982,
0.7129809260368347,
0.5854312181472778,
0.04051002487540245,
0.3455786108970642,
0.5252271890640259,
-0.3200173079967499,
0.7173640727996826,
0.4628503620624542,
0.2594905197620392,
-0.8145097494125366,
0.9266883730888367,
-0.09139344096183777,
0.41263726353645325,
0.12114278972148895,
0.15825989842414856,
-0.41625896096229553,
-0.13415729999542236,
-0.6649246215820312,
-0.2187892496585846,
-0.4545919597148895,
-0.49633023142814636,
-0.8150413632392883,
-0.2636924088001251,
-0.4793758690357208,
-0.17081566154956818,
-0.7696667313575745,
-0.2897275388240814,
-0.23921896517276764,
-0.30556032061576843,
0.5987318158149719,
0.3225935399532318,
-0.5901370048522949,
0.4996907114982605,
-0.7028684020042419,
1.0570125579833984,
0.4052395820617676,
0.15984103083610535,
-0.12687982618808746,
-0.7009251713752747,
-0.03352085128426552,
0.0018078989814966917,
-0.2955801784992218,
-0.7204620838165283,
0.578406810760498,
0.17002448439598083,
0.44434410333633423,
0.2959280014038086,
0.30143067240715027,
0.6125382781028748,
-0.5077362656593323,
0.826452374458313,
0.22446319460868835,
-1.0740408897399902,
0.4403950572013855,
-0.37410321831703186,
0.42126569151878357,
0.5481608510017395,
-0.07487425953149796,
-0.18551473319530487,
-0.8335989117622375,
-0.8597029447555542,
-1.0890494585037231,
0.5844699740409851,
0.758642852306366,
0.560052752494812,
0.08242490142583847,
0.09381234645843506,
0.42049548029899597,
0.3947807848453522,
-0.6242551803588867,
-0.33307144045829773,
-0.8741329908370972,
-0.0794617310166359,
-0.019407207146286964,
0.14486609399318695,
-0.11783298850059509,
-0.5777269601821899,
0.727152943611145,
0.11641884595155716,
0.5793813467025757,
0.19000713527202606,
0.27550575137138367,
-0.4812498092651367,
0.21078826487064362,
0.1758885234594345,
-0.1095919981598854,
-0.13181963562965393,
0.16374234855175018,
0.17430324852466583,
-0.35829958319664,
0.3901670277118683,
-0.06579470634460449,
-0.18310129642486572,
0.392378032207489,
0.22556206583976746,
1.0014805793762207,
0.05035419017076492,
-0.6265802383422852,
0.311078280210495,
0.31804555654525757,
-0.19262826442718506,
-0.6194989681243896,
0.2754773795604706,
-0.08193077892065048,
-0.3266802430152893,
0.5186266303062439,
0.1928890347480774,
0.47927168011665344,
-0.4690929651260376,
0.6652408242225647,
0.06101777032017708,
-0.4032769203186035,
-0.19100220501422882,
1.264278531074524,
0.08623816072940826,
-0.11256355047225952,
0.8654657006263733,
0.15029099583625793,
0.009537016041576862,
0.7630510926246643,
0.6635047197341919,
1.006839394569397,
-0.47565993666648865,
0.007983284071087837,
0.6748507618904114,
0.4573303461074829,
0.30550381541252136,
-0.13536790013313293,
-0.3821163773536682,
-0.2829058766365051,
-0.3538031578063965,
-0.6985283493995667,
-0.5178127884864807,
0.3680537939071655,
-0.7353438138961792,
0.1845950037240982,
-0.11579567193984985,
-0.09221541881561279,
-0.12279409170150757,
-0.5387013554573059,
-0.674625813961029,
0.39776942133903503,
-0.12305456399917603,
0.45015794038772583,
-1.2028447389602661,
0.277301162481308,
0.07579397410154343,
-0.5469306707382202,
-0.6930492520332336,
-0.10783994942903519,
-0.2440977841615677,
-0.2544254660606384,
0.30727875232696533,
0.0679386630654335,
-0.0905771553516388,
0.27959907054901123,
-0.6961227655410767,
-0.9334725141525269,
0.9962640404701233,
0.10936647653579712,
-0.6871849894523621,
0.2670726180076599,
0.48201170563697815,
0.6396132111549377,
-0.3639279901981354,
0.019045688211917877,
0.716009259223938,
0.7907508015632629,
0.1561131775379181,
-0.5917235016822815,
-0.07866337895393372,
-0.4782525300979614,
-0.16068217158317566,
-0.12741625308990479,
-0.453348845243454,
0.5282788276672363,
-0.2115665078163147,
-0.4880542755126953,
0.09518305957317352,
0.8220201730728149,
0.263821005821228,
0.30449196696281433,
0.826201319694519,
0.3838065564632416,
0.3272314667701721,
-0.4032975435256958,
1.0724513530731201,
-0.6010116338729858,
0.02429378218948841,
1.0306459665298462,
0.11907269060611725,
0.32848232984542847,
0.34043213725090027,
-0.24406012892723083,
0.2928922772407532,
0.35722091794013977,
-0.7272732257843018,
0.7419288158416748,
0.3317190408706665,
-0.2551845610141754,
-0.15319864451885223,
-0.12060202658176422,
-0.20353646576404572,
0.7208290696144104,
0.12634950876235962,
-0.34490492939949036,
0.2594521641731262,
0.593413770198822,
-0.3120826482772827,
0.14514625072479248,
0.1431150883436203,
0.791350245475769,
0.00974176824092865,
-0.5009192824363708,
0.434689998626709,
-0.15990227460861206,
0.5354675650596619,
-0.171579509973526,
-0.18605069816112518,
-0.20077894628047943,
-0.5619856715202332,
-0.10970009863376617,
-0.47345399856567383,
0.58418208360672,
-0.04087749123573303,
-0.32462620735168457,
-0.48394641280174255,
0.32603272795677185,
-0.45091184973716736,
-0.3758923411369324,
-0.011271451599895954,
0.07116028666496277,
0.014532101340591908,
-0.15627343952655792,
-0.198776513338089,
0.07190416008234024,
-0.33128827810287476,
0.06046253442764282,
-0.2644224166870117,
0.1232978105545044,
0.34251701831817627,
0.3761052191257477,
1.0376884937286377,
0.050697196274995804,
0.11755240708589554,
0.10850438475608826,
0.6201053857803345,
-0.41195258498191833,
-0.5620723962783813,
-0.4961641728878021,
0.4735575318336487,
0.06803333014249802,
0.01283175777643919,
0.5785942077636719,
0.68578040599823,
0.5301601886749268,
-0.5290181040763855,
0.8619799017906189,
0.034482505172491074,
0.24543417990207672,
-0.5520467162132263,
0.7556098103523254,
-0.22864899039268494,
0.3951958119869232,
-0.5659166574478149,
-1.0295802354812622,
-0.0801677256822586,
0.15177538990974426,
0.18874171376228333,
-0.04184270277619362,
0.3592154085636139,
0.7315860390663147,
-0.2662162780761719,
0.10508696734905243,
0.32546356320381165,
0.10221888870000839,
0.5619478821754456,
0.23058031499385834,
0.7794910669326782,
-0.795991063117981,
0.6294569969177246,
-0.4807319641113281,
0.10238255560398102,
0.18822622299194336,
-0.5237056016921997,
-0.4463422894477844,
-0.7607517838478088,
-0.577465832233429,
0.036554981023073196,
-0.031106648966670036,
0.4773575961589813,
0.9749847650527954,
-0.9348356127738953,
-0.08027344942092896,
-0.4831714332103729,
-0.343152791261673,
-0.5090336799621582,
-0.43553873896598816,
0.4790932536125183,
-0.29810860753059387,
-1.1204942464828491,
0.9189403653144836,
0.20264331996440887,
0.25957968831062317,
-0.3071896433830261,
0.05989721789956093,
0.39227840304374695,
0.4543769955635071,
0.601330041885376,
0.11215617507696152,
-0.7872051000595093,
-0.4636504054069519,
-0.03421211987733841,
0.10761606693267822,
0.337384968996048,
0.6338609457015991,
-0.7412853240966797,
0.7977612018585205,
0.35638555884361267,
0.23139642179012299,
0.6943025588989258,
0.19285038113594055,
0.8039196133613586,
-0.75862056016922,
-0.1648588925600052,
0.007881499826908112,
0.2137175351381302,
0.45513716340065,
-0.4044188857078552,
0.5002403259277344,
0.0912434458732605,
-0.4256663918495178,
-0.7405287623405457,
0.07218660414218903,
-0.9338274598121643,
-0.08866862952709198,
1.1055101156234741,
0.28533437848091125,
0.2971150875091553,
-0.16545410454273224,
-0.3932205140590668,
0.6176332831382751,
-0.3838720917701721,
1.296975016593933,
0.2710108757019043,
-0.009834355674684048,
-0.08752062171697617,
-0.6717072129249573,
0.6821686029434204,
0.223347008228302,
-0.8354403376579285,
0.22314441204071045,
0.7526893019676208,
0.11014549434185028,
0.3761765658855438,
0.38278868794441223,
-0.6156235933303833,
0.4341792166233063,
0.362456738948822,
0.33045390248298645,
-0.6782975792884827,
-0.6293450593948364,
-0.16299749910831451,
0.47173675894737244,
-0.4762856364250183,
-0.3483198583126068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19384v1 | The Remarkable Robustness of LLMs: Stages of Inference? | 2024-06-27T17:57:03 | 2024-06-27T17:57:03 | Vedang Lad, Wes Gurnee, Max Tegmark | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We demonstrate and investigate the remarkable robustness of Large Language
Models by deleting and swapping adjacent layers. We find that deleting and
swapping interventions retain 72-95\% of the original model's prediction
accuracy without fine-tuning, whereas models with more layers exhibit more
robustness. Based on the results of the layer-wise intervention and further
experiments, we hypothesize the existence of four universal stages of inference
across eight different models: detokenization, feature engineering, prediction
ensembling, and residual sharpening. The first stage integrates local
information, lifting raw token representations into higher-level contextual
representations. Next is the iterative refinement of task and entity-specific
features. Then, the second half of the model begins with a phase transition,
where hidden representations align more with the vocabulary space due to
specialized model components. Finally, the last layer sharpens the following
token distribution by eliminating obsolete features that add noise to the
prediction. | [
-0.2278256118297577,
-0.858778178691864,
0.7738871574401855,
0.03046220913529396,
-0.0015169058460742235,
0.07955168187618256,
-0.0806322991847992,
-0.43649527430534363,
-0.20812740921974182,
0.5533715486526489,
-0.5462568998336792,
-0.4619857966899872,
-0.4880235493183136,
-0.1407036930322647,
-0.7381148338317871,
0.7993941307067871,
0.20901507139205933,
0.16730155050754547,
0.07466685026884079,
0.11862731724977493,
-0.19606684148311615,
-0.38351404666900635,
-0.8154637813568115,
-0.5369654297828674,
0.4188471734523773,
0.21223488450050354,
0.8112620711326599,
0.9417303204536438,
0.1097080186009407,
0.34535881876945496,
-0.5012506246566772,
-0.032830458134412766,
-0.3907110393047333,
0.4245120882987976,
-0.25458577275276184,
-0.9647767543792725,
-0.25786522030830383,
0.1501285284757614,
0.783781111240387,
1.0649060010910034,
-0.17254412174224854,
-0.1782960444688797,
0.40308836102485657,
0.524547815322876,
-0.4663236439228058,
-0.005604241508990526,
-1.0284309387207031,
-0.06577794998884201,
-0.009463271126151085,
0.15356992185115814,
-0.5448929667472839,
0.06501273810863495,
0.05849861726164818,
-0.3884468078613281,
0.22064879536628723,
-0.05066081881523132,
0.805360734462738,
0.20383146405220032,
-0.5178730487823486,
-0.10618649423122406,
-0.843754231929779,
1.0428283214569092,
-0.8364202976226807,
0.43986281752586365,
0.5876057744026184,
0.07306276261806488,
-0.2733364701271057,
-0.8608025312423706,
-0.3783693313598633,
-0.4334440529346466,
0.276327908039093,
-0.0665288046002388,
-0.10427705198526382,
0.26812273263931274,
0.3952057659626007,
0.250662237405777,
0.0684601292014122,
0.5850411653518677,
-0.1239597499370575,
-0.41286927461624146,
0.31955277919769287,
0.15664616227149963,
0.2419346272945404,
-0.1969410479068756,
-0.37434351444244385,
0.2127210646867752,
-0.8400526642799377,
-0.13870558142662048,
0.38793084025382996,
0.3899376094341278,
-0.09363463521003723,
0.5264589786529541,
-0.04475008323788643,
0.4339030683040619,
0.1032634824514389,
-0.43898114562034607,
0.01962973177433014,
-0.3029108941555023,
-0.4126538038253784,
-0.3527184724807739,
0.49631422758102417,
-0.07567568123340607,
0.25841665267944336,
-0.338506281375885,
-0.4378400444984436,
0.10826385021209717,
0.18235617876052856,
-0.43724769353866577,
-0.15844585001468658,
0.5231358408927917,
-0.47354361414909363,
-0.4718555808067322,
-0.18769320845603943,
-0.31372174620628357,
-0.4586730897426605,
-0.3249637484550476,
0.30372369289398193,
-0.5731163024902344,
-0.2112225443124771,
0.08879496902227402,
0.21037983894348145,
0.21729007363319397,
0.48127052187919617,
-0.864601194858551,
0.3354918360710144,
0.9009266495704651,
0.6846382021903992,
-0.38432836532592773,
-0.4996523857116699,
-0.26451221108436584,
0.29120683670043945,
-0.5578614473342896,
0.7640596628189087,
-0.8683788180351257,
-0.2528209984302521,
0.004278974607586861,
0.11401190608739853,
-0.24069619178771973,
-0.7505995035171509,
0.7494534850120544,
-0.610908031463623,
0.11751825362443924,
-0.27981001138687134,
-0.7503623366355896,
-0.25401002168655396,
0.24380050599575043,
-0.7113840579986572,
1.0266042947769165,
-0.17743037641048431,
-0.769346296787262,
0.4864782989025116,
-0.29987218976020813,
-0.21995259821414948,
-0.4280422627925873,
0.12587234377861023,
-0.2643992602825165,
0.30189916491508484,
0.25380560755729675,
0.6369714736938477,
-0.033746734261512756,
0.20323783159255981,
-0.5869537591934204,
-0.3003281354904175,
0.4079183042049408,
-0.660936713218689,
0.728969156742096,
0.1888515055179596,
-0.42132434248924255,
0.08711383491754532,
-0.9687345027923584,
-0.22856861352920532,
-0.10014492273330688,
-0.39799705147743225,
-0.20649661123752594,
0.15348567068576813,
-0.2539530396461487,
0.18164809048175812,
0.07540833204984665,
-0.35518911480903625,
0.10372521728277206,
-0.3414410352706909,
0.8102691769599915,
0.8348227739334106,
0.10332883149385452,
0.7848597168922424,
-0.2354675680398941,
0.532139778137207,
0.5774643421173096,
0.18254321813583374,
-0.39303281903266907,
-0.5627819895744324,
-0.897861897945404,
-0.48803776502609253,
0.48904967308044434,
0.6534556746482849,
-0.6200916171073914,
0.3185421824455261,
-0.05386114865541458,
-0.0600941963493824,
-0.23406410217285156,
0.16854941844940186,
0.36682459712028503,
0.44467592239379883,
0.10168477892875671,
-0.08785513043403625,
-0.2746709883213043,
-0.9524032473564148,
-0.17180518805980682,
-0.21958498656749725,
-0.20259441435337067,
-0.31040579080581665,
0.5573802590370178,
-0.29420581459999084,
0.5541810393333435,
0.06471423804759979,
0.24058440327644348,
-0.25119614601135254,
0.02606065943837166,
0.13320820033550262,
0.5579177737236023,
0.1867041438817978,
-0.49121981859207153,
-0.06307430565357208,
-0.1355436146259308,
-0.5871309638023376,
-0.11302495002746582,
-0.2806548476219177,
-0.14206074178218842,
0.291301965713501,
0.6426024436950684,
-0.6433992981910706,
0.40422767400741577,
0.3889455795288086,
-0.006996833253651857,
0.4790252149105072,
-0.17147038877010345,
-0.04640858247876167,
-1.1091525554656982,
-0.12150406837463379,
-0.09897293895483017,
-0.5167431235313416,
-0.8976327180862427,
0.14928631484508514,
0.07509178668260574,
0.19199597835540771,
-0.1889539211988449,
0.44967636466026306,
-0.8441067337989807,
-0.15936917066574097,
-0.12795919179916382,
0.37918612360954285,
0.020523378625512123,
0.3187955617904663,
-0.40835335850715637,
0.5866683125495911,
0.7189033031463623,
-0.6143941283226013,
-0.23289646208286285,
-0.1384100466966629,
-0.545238733291626,
0.37009575963020325,
-0.5417124032974243,
0.08834342658519745,
-0.17025946080684662,
-0.02208574302494526,
-1.2920947074890137,
-0.16211657226085663,
0.09289304912090302,
-0.1686180979013443,
0.48195797204971313,
-0.17752856016159058,
-0.4785119891166687,
-0.26974472403526306,
-0.42713645100593567,
-0.011604074388742447,
0.42426997423171997,
-0.2240959256887436,
0.6812470555305481,
0.4296112656593323,
-0.1798357218503952,
-0.6977089643478394,
-1.0860514640808105,
0.23013876378536224,
-0.23378099501132965,
-0.3772794306278229,
0.07184820622205734,
-0.0030649653635919094,
-0.4360620975494385,
0.06338963657617569,
-0.14960645139217377,
-0.015081353485584259,
0.3686961233615875,
0.36521196365356445,
0.20680896937847137,
-0.08000228554010391,
-0.07761549204587936,
0.2250407338142395,
-0.09303256869316101,
-0.0907159224152565,
-0.3577590584754944,
0.5334151983261108,
0.13171343505382538,
-0.713842511177063,
-0.531813383102417,
0.14486433565616608,
0.6895917654037476,
0.027940386906266212,
0.7109237909317017,
0.37008532881736755,
-0.5545657873153687,
-0.3247601091861725,
-0.7541072964668274,
-0.03353084623813629,
-0.44303926825523376,
0.42347219586372375,
-0.575925350189209,
-1.0913549661636353,
1.1752172708511353,
0.0001868410618044436,
0.23372338712215424,
0.4462200105190277,
0.5091665983200073,
0.043529901653528214,
1.312003254890442,
0.5682462453842163,
-0.15026631951332092,
0.5488486289978027,
-0.19519738852977753,
0.1650094836950302,
-0.936732292175293,
-0.3263013958930969,
-0.5482239127159119,
-0.28001511096954346,
-0.582863450050354,
-0.7201355695724487,
0.1422661393880844,
0.5509205460548401,
-0.3890262246131897,
-0.03195850923657417,
-0.1181878075003624,
0.584291398525238,
0.5035519003868103,
0.2390362173318863,
0.31687411665916443,
0.29868191480636597,
-0.43098941445350647,
-0.15213868021965027,
-0.5864721536636353,
-0.6327561736106873,
1.014022707939148,
0.6018143892288208,
0.8669096231460571,
-0.14400289952754974,
0.7007132768630981,
0.08961263298988342,
0.2604590356349945,
-0.7430623769760132,
0.6735774874687195,
-0.014195083640515804,
-0.6599844694137573,
-0.38745009899139404,
-0.34539473056793213,
-0.9307212233543396,
0.34978437423706055,
-0.3448326289653778,
-1.0647941827774048,
0.2436082661151886,
0.09417799115180969,
-0.25739195942878723,
0.6000369787216187,
-0.5652849674224854,
0.35885125398635864,
0.2381170392036438,
-0.3393816649913788,
-0.36383289098739624,
-0.6341128945350647,
0.5459560751914978,
-0.13453425467014313,
0.2855739891529083,
-0.19971317052841187,
-0.44259101152420044,
0.46738529205322266,
-0.2136879563331604,
1.0189738273620605,
-0.049927614629268646,
-0.340624064207077,
0.24046587944030762,
0.4656270146369934,
0.5990615487098694,
-0.1949242204427719,
-0.358055055141449,
0.021432731300592422,
0.013238770887255669,
-0.4390213191509247,
-0.692963719367981,
0.6552219986915588,
-0.5599082708358765,
-0.6991676092147827,
-0.07636453211307526,
-0.693081796169281,
-0.5035161972045898,
0.24366234242916107,
-0.008201665244996548,
0.630862295627594,
-0.1398836225271225,
0.035081371665000916,
0.6998449563980103,
-0.22856569290161133,
0.5725208520889282,
0.11254935711622238,
-0.448609322309494,
-0.41114139556884766,
0.618816077709198,
0.0858350396156311,
0.674726128578186,
0.41537097096443176,
0.1607363224029541,
-0.3323158323764801,
-1.0607367753982544,
-0.07418142259120941,
0.37827229499816895,
-0.9414400458335876,
0.10208816826343536,
-0.7586673498153687,
-0.2686367332935333,
-0.35913410782814026,
0.02353399433195591,
-0.37028104066848755,
-0.7109244465827942,
-0.36833807826042175,
-0.34775251150131226,
-0.12387779355049133,
1.1575424671173096,
-0.20240727066993713,
0.28654128313064575,
-0.7722803950309753,
0.15624278783798218,
0.2609206438064575,
0.13492600619792938,
0.17934763431549072,
-0.8607120513916016,
-0.24741393327713013,
0.07743041217327118,
-0.2187178134918213,
-0.7104517817497253,
0.2641260623931885,
0.3155657947063446,
0.8211095929145813,
0.8124243021011353,
-0.39939582347869873,
0.6952031254768372,
-0.5367753505706787,
1.0903421640396118,
0.026283370330929756,
-1.0296392440795898,
0.2700570523738861,
-0.40170055627822876,
0.3674275279045105,
0.510200023651123,
0.35816630721092224,
-0.22204187512397766,
-0.7250654101371765,
-0.6072235107421875,
-0.7652325630187988,
0.5111863613128662,
-0.07228758931159973,
0.2921501696109772,
-0.01719890534877777,
0.6965405344963074,
0.2396448403596878,
0.22624576091766357,
-0.6302983164787292,
-0.28189146518707275,
0.16548265516757965,
0.06697310507297516,
0.12270371615886688,
-0.6786128878593445,
-0.16441574692726135,
-0.2538508474826813,
0.5126026272773743,
-0.0035100807435810566,
0.15092524886131287,
-0.08020550012588501,
-0.09137856215238571,
0.05322658270597458,
0.2937769889831543,
0.6071714758872986,
0.9951328635215759,
0.034248799085617065,
0.40290334820747375,
0.352789044380188,
-0.3787403404712677,
0.03722602128982544,
-0.20527637004852295,
-0.28257882595062256,
-0.20485162734985352,
0.8021408319473267,
0.9133360385894775,
0.577583909034729,
-0.26374298334121704,
0.21446362137794495,
0.10729154944419861,
-0.137677863240242,
0.09182193130254745,
0.06982976943254471,
0.2038271576166153,
0.544093132019043,
0.3862501084804535,
0.08491414785385132,
0.1949145793914795,
-0.7846340537071228,
0.24504753947257996,
0.5067456960678101,
-0.2814456820487976,
-0.5297392010688782,
0.9338858127593994,
-0.18364842236042023,
-0.031610727310180664,
0.4348202347755432,
-0.06323309242725372,
-0.5576894283294678,
0.362517774105072,
0.5463849306106567,
0.9837287068367004,
-0.318854957818985,
0.3565792143344879,
0.17982493340969086,
0.43575698137283325,
-0.4126712381839752,
0.2222711741924286,
0.1063368022441864,
-0.8688616156578064,
-0.65798020362854,
-0.687289297580719,
-0.3664783239364624,
0.09395597875118256,
-0.7025144100189209,
-0.10141731053590775,
-0.4917040765285492,
-0.22630952298641205,
-0.0740547925233841,
-0.08936798572540283,
-0.4765356481075287,
0.2876453697681427,
0.31289413571357727,
0.9826770424842834,
-0.8598833084106445,
0.9808241724967957,
0.3423456847667694,
-0.06714967638254166,
-0.7899268865585327,
0.16727964580059052,
0.21395902335643768,
-1.1103726625442505,
0.6186079382896423,
0.089814193546772,
-0.04794588312506676,
-0.13528867065906525,
-0.781370997428894,
-0.9384241700172424,
0.9492504000663757,
0.7691447734832764,
-0.5442282557487488,
-0.2924504280090332,
0.12424805015325546,
0.4529748857021332,
-0.2783777117729187,
0.2647647261619568,
0.7237071394920349,
0.28485193848609924,
0.27555641531944275,
-0.8830926418304443,
0.049708954989910126,
0.06471668928861618,
0.4405546188354492,
-0.06837653368711472,
-0.2568638026714325,
1.1315346956253052,
-0.28516072034835815,
-0.49891266226768494,
0.294893741607666,
0.7581937313079834,
0.17531678080558777,
-0.11346223950386047,
0.7841159701347351,
0.6421425342559814,
1.0687260627746582,
-0.1266237199306488,
1.0794414281845093,
-0.5272168517112732,
0.23664219677448273,
1.0556265115737915,
-0.15444988012313843,
0.9134789705276489,
0.38290169835090637,
-0.23734840750694275,
0.5810644626617432,
0.7424584627151489,
0.353796124458313,
0.3883230686187744,
0.01677611470222473,
-0.28939610719680786,
-0.5136727094650269,
0.07263430953025818,
-0.127506285905838,
0.3541124165058136,
0.41562420129776,
-0.3170611560344696,
-0.07983281463384628,
0.020409133285284042,
0.26997849345207214,
-0.13157355785369873,
-0.34837159514427185,
0.516659677028656,
0.3269537687301636,
-0.6372816562652588,
0.5298177003860474,
-0.15685707330703735,
0.6395696401596069,
-0.571983814239502,
0.06677887588739395,
-0.3910028040409088,
0.15619002282619476,
-0.14550073444843292,
-0.8974126577377319,
0.10270807147026062,
-0.35774558782577515,
-0.09034566581249237,
-0.13768187165260315,
0.7895525097846985,
-0.5311325192451477,
-0.5955749750137329,
0.3809230625629425,
0.5922250151634216,
0.25619345903396606,
0.016270453110337257,
-0.8064163327217102,
0.2453751564025879,
0.011395737528800964,
-0.6688305139541626,
0.39600831270217896,
0.7123608589172363,
-0.10199915617704391,
1.072319507598877,
0.49617063999176025,
0.37429115176200867,
0.41791319847106934,
0.3819676339626312,
0.8433498740196228,
-0.6690144538879395,
-0.23168551921844482,
-0.9127579927444458,
0.5892323851585388,
-0.003861012402921915,
-0.015470974147319794,
0.8441734910011292,
0.201629176735878,
0.6107599139213562,
0.22834089398384094,
0.6937891840934753,
0.3380235731601715,
0.4628225266933441,
-0.7515022158622742,
0.396048367023468,
-0.5503227114677429,
0.414707750082016,
-0.21285904943943024,
-0.9612680077552795,
-0.4693242311477661,
0.3170938789844513,
-0.1347258985042572,
0.311718225479126,
0.7232792973518372,
0.9918435215950012,
-0.09430244565010071,
-0.07298830151557922,
0.7214227318763733,
0.6126092076301575,
0.2099536508321762,
0.1666804552078247,
0.9001002311706543,
-0.19762210547924042,
0.1644168347120285,
-0.257649689912796,
-0.15180884301662445,
0.07912680506706238,
-0.9613654017448425,
-1.0095797777175903,
-0.5559706687927246,
-0.21741034090518951,
-0.5825430750846863,
-0.08241067081689835,
0.646245002746582,
0.6967562437057495,
-1.0146572589874268,
-0.13664431869983673,
0.06121837720274925,
0.2618587017059326,
-0.13911227881908417,
-0.17238247394561768,
0.2056231051683426,
-0.4578413665294647,
-0.9427509903907776,
0.47344306111335754,
0.4233984649181366,
0.00046865182230249047,
-0.5495575666427612,
0.29028749465942383,
-0.13515855371952057,
0.20209051668643951,
0.6843544840812683,
0.10054183006286621,
-0.963645875453949,
-0.524299144744873,
-0.19448935985565186,
-0.19553104043006897,
-0.0023278258740901947,
0.7470067143440247,
-0.47698792815208435,
0.3159898519515991,
0.48553600907325745,
0.5927835702896118,
0.5106208920478821,
-0.14120517671108246,
0.574672520160675,
-0.3204849064350128,
0.3016713857650757,
-0.17179682850837708,
0.5998928546905518,
0.43442302942276,
-0.04876011982560158,
0.4332623779773712,
0.13509583473205566,
-0.7077343463897705,
-1.1082127094268799,
0.3428741991519928,
-0.9443732500076294,
-0.28328078985214233,
1.193996787071228,
-0.23717209696769714,
-0.3909388482570648,
-0.24443796277046204,
0.0565834641456604,
0.23512491583824158,
-0.06678414344787598,
0.6597856283187866,
0.6932148337364197,
-0.09200583398342133,
-0.2975756525993347,
-0.7283923625946045,
0.2865695655345917,
0.4885806441307068,
-0.6618675589561462,
0.09231288731098175,
0.47226008772850037,
0.5085288882255554,
0.09848617017269135,
0.41973838210105896,
-0.19968754053115845,
-0.4477465748786926,
0.16624143719673157,
-0.2490944266319275,
0.10512132942676544,
-0.37742701172828674,
-0.6240987181663513,
0.2749235928058624,
0.37543562054634094,
0.012349623255431652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19371v1 | Suri: Multi-constraint Instruction Following for Long-form Text Generation | 2024-06-27T17:50:35 | 2024-06-27T17:50:35 | Chau Minh Pham, Simeng Sun, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing research on instruction following largely focuses on tasks with
simple instructions and short responses. In this work, we explore
multi-constraint instruction following for generating long-form text. We create
Suri, a dataset with 20K human-written long-form texts paired with
LLM-generated backtranslated instructions that contain multiple complex
constraints. Because of prohibitive challenges associated with collecting human
preference judgments on long-form texts, preference-tuning algorithms such as
DPO are infeasible in our setting; thus, we propose Instructional ORPO
(I-ORPO), an alignment method based on the ORPO algorithm. Instead of receiving
negative feedback from dispreferred responses, I-ORPO obtains negative feedback
from synthetically corrupted instructions generated by an LLM. Using Suri, we
perform supervised and I-ORPO fine-tuning on Mistral-7b-Instruct-v0.2. The
resulting models, Suri-SFT and Suri-I-ORPO, generate significantly longer texts
(~5K tokens) than base models without significant quality deterioration. Our
human evaluation shows that while both SFT and I-ORPO models satisfy most
constraints, Suri-I-ORPO generations are generally preferred for their coherent
and informative incorporation of the constraints. We release our code at
https://github.com/chtmp223/suri. | [
-0.06113022193312645,
-0.48768794536590576,
0.4604957401752472,
0.17938752472400665,
-0.00022558963974006474,
-0.1345139741897583,
-0.26039278507232666,
-0.4971959888935089,
-0.11297747492790222,
1.0259345769882202,
-1.0569703578948975,
-0.6260744333267212,
-0.23869390785694122,
0.2730541527271271,
-0.060202158987522125,
1.0448330640792847,
-0.25023308396339417,
-0.08536174893379211,
-0.29009708762168884,
0.05413171276450157,
-0.8136101961135864,
-0.4802462160587311,
-0.2817520499229431,
-0.3270244002342224,
0.36092042922973633,
0.9300718307495117,
0.4037702977657318,
0.8732277154922485,
0.2706153988838196,
0.29187414050102234,
0.11652467399835587,
0.7222698926925659,
-0.5810381174087524,
0.15502594411373138,
-0.09436752647161484,
-0.29601234197616577,
-0.3441697955131531,
-0.10006137937307358,
0.7225647568702698,
0.4958728551864624,
-0.10462237149477005,
0.11801747977733612,
0.13028769195079803,
0.7790588736534119,
-0.7691999077796936,
-0.03264551982283592,
-0.2698567509651184,
-0.1739339828491211,
-0.24163036048412323,
-0.1917748898267746,
-0.688729465007782,
-0.5861237049102783,
-0.03906174376606941,
-0.6041163802146912,
0.27193689346313477,
0.18357226252555847,
0.5385667681694031,
0.4582950472831726,
-0.47886911034584045,
-0.6709437966346741,
-0.7293925881385803,
0.9203663468360901,
-0.538103461265564,
0.4163537919521332,
0.1838350147008896,
0.057757340371608734,
-0.567793071269989,
-0.22997896373271942,
-0.5521288514137268,
-0.13904522359371185,
-0.015969859436154366,
0.40187758207321167,
0.34511515498161316,
0.2738316059112549,
0.35478606820106506,
0.09095152467489243,
-0.44487738609313965,
0.3665717840194702,
-0.5296039581298828,
0.040921036154031754,
0.6822785139083862,
0.2562774419784546,
0.08905613422393799,
-0.3292294144630432,
-0.5878939628601074,
-0.1009426862001419,
-0.8876311779022217,
0.056336645036935806,
0.5868372321128845,
0.246677964925766,
-0.16234225034713745,
0.9325457215309143,
-0.13335275650024414,
0.857856273651123,
0.14533518254756927,
-0.45138970017433167,
0.16864465177059174,
-0.425506055355072,
-0.019905349239706993,
0.22371089458465576,
0.718257486820221,
0.3550850450992584,
0.16698254644870758,
0.13298629224300385,
-0.0723944827914238,
-0.06062440574169159,
0.19829556345939636,
-0.7793580293655396,
0.21599437296390533,
-0.15775470435619354,
-0.4286055266857147,
-0.176791712641716,
0.24862726032733917,
-0.8240875601768494,
-0.5122362375259399,
-0.5908668041229248,
0.20871877670288086,
-0.7821828722953796,
0.44160327315330505,
0.31938436627388,
-0.10903143137693405,
0.28501182794570923,
0.2472093254327774,
-1.0967655181884766,
0.2307436317205429,
0.669743001461029,
0.43780702352523804,
-0.16565963625907898,
-0.6157795190811157,
-0.5872687101364136,
0.5055837035179138,
-0.15792657434940338,
0.5267519354820251,
-0.6732936501502991,
-0.5496012568473816,
0.05440705642104149,
-0.11211239546537399,
-0.18398863077163696,
-0.3385509252548218,
0.6333521008491516,
-0.24926836788654327,
0.45589640736579895,
-0.10472758114337921,
-0.7316100001335144,
0.03884920850396156,
-0.06996561586856842,
-0.4552527070045471,
0.9730219841003418,
-0.04277057945728302,
-0.6334617137908936,
0.2650129199028015,
-0.5150386691093445,
-0.6158844232559204,
-0.2841789424419403,
-0.3959943950176239,
-0.6707718372344971,
0.20989331603050232,
0.28133663535118103,
0.3408297896385193,
-0.37723803520202637,
0.08044889569282532,
-0.2811454236507416,
-0.3789966404438019,
0.1195375919342041,
-0.6167323589324951,
0.6531060338020325,
-0.15292596817016602,
-0.31533294916152954,
0.03834585100412369,
-1.07078218460083,
-0.12172535806894302,
-0.25837957859039307,
-0.49676671624183655,
-0.27607545256614685,
0.08600134402513504,
-0.35296303033828735,
-0.053166791796684265,
0.3144657015800476,
-0.7211668491363525,
0.6502165198326111,
-0.16574585437774658,
0.5805360674858093,
0.6946402192115784,
0.13928991556167603,
0.2660744786262512,
-0.2889310121536255,
0.4860542118549347,
-0.5391232967376709,
0.292120099067688,
-0.20086221396923065,
-0.19405154883861542,
-0.7274051308631897,
-0.0897500142455101,
0.09345398843288422,
0.5400825142860413,
-0.8258470892906189,
0.3957376480102539,
-0.4027933180332184,
-0.2216690629720688,
-0.39144712686538696,
0.18238091468811035,
0.8159220218658447,
0.6683591604232788,
0.5094985961914062,
0.12040843069553375,
-0.612411379814148,
-0.8729616403579712,
0.21950317919254303,
-0.006966562941670418,
0.16738110780715942,
0.38225388526916504,
0.4405883252620697,
-0.21755170822143555,
0.6003135442733765,
-0.8127821683883667,
-0.32476189732551575,
-0.08171244710683823,
0.36836206912994385,
0.028751663863658905,
0.5540730953216553,
0.4155954122543335,
-0.5584303736686707,
-0.4628879427909851,
-0.07977036386728287,
-0.39224931597709656,
-0.2313399314880371,
-0.41981616616249084,
-0.3607332706451416,
0.4048720896244049,
0.619655966758728,
-0.6942445635795593,
0.4994575083255768,
0.4513781666755676,
-0.02491924911737442,
0.7638975977897644,
-0.3272187411785126,
0.32595106959342957,
-1.2509492635726929,
-0.13347673416137695,
-0.1261390596628189,
-0.06959773600101471,
-0.4682488441467285,
-0.004189823288470507,
0.18303655087947845,
-0.20208066701889038,
-0.20902974903583527,
0.14855070412158966,
-0.6373595595359802,
0.252201110124588,
-0.2561340928077698,
-0.29062649607658386,
0.21722714602947235,
0.5918334126472473,
0.3166693150997162,
0.8402529358863831,
0.27135151624679565,
-0.5812737345695496,
0.22940026223659515,
0.2916375398635864,
-0.14943265914916992,
0.5602899789810181,
-0.5772713422775269,
0.2879709303379059,
-0.18446630239486694,
0.43681800365448,
-0.8453295826911926,
-0.5695687532424927,
0.2577151656150818,
-0.3336421251296997,
0.6219636797904968,
-0.17717963457107544,
-0.5152813792228699,
-0.36475956439971924,
-0.44385161995887756,
0.4439929127693176,
0.3124209940433502,
-0.6390686631202698,
0.6792026162147522,
-0.059595219790935516,
0.04175415635108948,
-0.7133793830871582,
-0.5886505842208862,
-0.22814695537090302,
-0.12204696238040924,
-0.4661937654018402,
0.7024365663528442,
0.0021011210046708584,
0.3778286576271057,
-0.24177083373069763,
-0.14326922595500946,
0.09032326936721802,
-0.4439925253391266,
0.6122351884841919,
0.39890164136886597,
-0.13847343623638153,
0.12193314731121063,
0.5766746401786804,
-0.1363484263420105,
-0.02577095478773117,
-0.2730511426925659,
0.407950222492218,
0.2360345423221588,
-0.4688636064529419,
-0.6615355610847473,
0.6650816202163696,
0.6674898266792297,
-0.16767023503780365,
0.6090095043182373,
0.22985169291496277,
-0.15371207892894745,
-0.2883971631526947,
-0.6402485370635986,
0.11357171088457108,
-0.45271220803260803,
0.2754153907299042,
-0.4207388758659363,
-0.7470102906227112,
0.07794304937124252,
-0.10925661027431488,
0.36529555916786194,
0.2858296036720276,
0.21865656971931458,
-0.17151325941085815,
1.0716804265975952,
0.7979313135147095,
-0.026279864832758904,
0.5000799298286438,
-0.131039559841156,
-0.4028280973434448,
-0.7429503202438354,
-0.39411818981170654,
-0.5604875087738037,
-0.2167588323354721,
-0.3607807755470276,
-0.2830215096473694,
0.3044346868991852,
0.3113669455051422,
-0.3014506995677948,
0.4008225202560425,
-0.7391502857208252,
0.5800217390060425,
0.8825388550758362,
0.29472002387046814,
0.04302367568016052,
-0.05549041926860809,
0.20359592139720917,
0.03273642063140869,
-0.6547515392303467,
-0.39993739128112793,
0.98526930809021,
0.07422531396150589,
1.0404120683670044,
0.1612001359462738,
1.1632864475250244,
0.04492144659161568,
0.24824954569339752,
-0.5999835133552551,
0.41122445464134216,
-0.47255435585975647,
-0.2975364625453949,
-0.413557767868042,
-0.6094041466712952,
-0.9801100492477417,
-0.30393126606941223,
-0.2196732759475708,
-0.6661402583122253,
0.2284601628780365,
0.3484424650669098,
-0.6662160754203796,
-0.14067581295967102,
-0.9950953722000122,
0.7478029727935791,
-0.46702441573143005,
-0.19344210624694824,
-0.06516730040311813,
-0.9292318224906921,
0.3758080303668976,
0.20268577337265015,
-0.05479275807738304,
0.3467748463153839,
-0.13730910420417786,
0.4559270739555359,
-0.5807690024375916,
1.1380761861801147,
0.16120170056819916,
-0.17898643016815186,
0.5482459664344788,
-0.36669057607650757,
0.47909411787986755,
0.038041852414608,
-0.09387117624282837,
-0.32444390654563904,
-0.06411029398441315,
-0.13998106122016907,
-0.7131652235984802,
0.7423631548881531,
-0.9110782146453857,
-0.6164461970329285,
-0.15803074836730957,
-0.35907796025276184,
0.030018188059329987,
0.46892234683036804,
0.6618180274963379,
0.6791465878486633,
0.02616208791732788,
0.12247227877378464,
0.7817938923835754,
-0.20304828882217407,
0.18148888647556305,
0.3237901031970978,
-0.07994527369737625,
-0.7551414966583252,
1.1818922758102417,
0.17873568832874298,
0.37800756096839905,
0.7015438079833984,
0.26919591426849365,
-0.3702625036239624,
-0.42419493198394775,
-0.800771951675415,
0.37233275175094604,
-0.4502955377101898,
-0.43693506717681885,
-0.0589355006814003,
-0.23713138699531555,
-0.5039112567901611,
-0.17268069088459015,
-0.4490974247455597,
-0.2469005137681961,
-0.6302818655967712,
0.17261062562465668,
0.22645169496536255,
0.8305414319038391,
0.19152194261550903,
0.151962548494339,
-0.9436839818954468,
0.4439711272716522,
0.3034555912017822,
0.2877522110939026,
-0.2037269026041031,
-0.42767056822776794,
-0.1286117434501648,
0.1286913901567459,
-0.5522087812423706,
-1.087921142578125,
-0.09856542199850082,
0.2266184389591217,
0.1788294017314911,
0.30361711978912354,
0.24948827922344208,
0.9638083577156067,
-0.6920815110206604,
0.4476951062679291,
0.3426196873188019,
-0.9353123307228088,
0.5801729559898376,
-0.1727023720741272,
0.3748457133769989,
0.7049776315689087,
0.2988530993461609,
-0.25406521558761597,
-0.24251002073287964,
-0.29942429065704346,
-0.6267299652099609,
0.9072796702384949,
0.17243452370166779,
0.22013701498508453,
-0.03767015039920807,
0.8166310787200928,
0.49379339814186096,
0.22210581600666046,
-0.6113347411155701,
-0.1495264172554016,
-0.21869809925556183,
-0.2516927719116211,
0.14978434145450592,
-0.4884202182292938,
0.010741951875388622,
0.09553826600313187,
0.8198243975639343,
-0.0785740464925766,
-0.1355651170015335,
0.23296408355236053,
0.06779389828443527,
-0.066423699259758,
0.33085888624191284,
1.0556306838989258,
0.48676395416259766,
-0.07103435695171356,
0.00658065639436245,
0.08533971011638641,
-0.42431753873825073,
0.03642573580145836,
0.3696088194847107,
-0.436082661151886,
-0.24491092562675476,
0.47616612911224365,
0.8647139072418213,
-0.06686948239803314,
-0.569532573223114,
0.2794187366962433,
0.05313311517238617,
-0.3233148157596588,
-0.2645392417907715,
0.19412744045257568,
-0.16920924186706543,
0.19585415720939636,
0.0421895906329155,
0.023501494899392128,
0.05775900185108185,
-0.370274156332016,
-0.11698929965496063,
0.2980220913887024,
-0.37794584035873413,
-0.23259088397026062,
0.6251018643379211,
0.3443271219730377,
-0.3043128550052643,
0.7720746994018555,
-0.032006438821554184,
-0.37949132919311523,
0.41602712869644165,
0.5660189986228943,
0.5547637939453125,
-0.024837249889969826,
0.19711293280124664,
0.21051795780658722,
0.16430062055587769,
-0.14254140853881836,
0.4459534287452698,
-0.1066867783665657,
-0.4627116918563843,
-0.6434735655784607,
-0.3411136567592621,
-0.29981517791748047,
0.30443477630615234,
-0.7008671164512634,
0.5646868944168091,
-0.42629778385162354,
-0.044688694179058075,
-0.020611803978681564,
-0.1799578219652176,
-0.24889524281024933,
0.11928912252187729,
0.1842755824327469,
0.5103024840354919,
-0.7032077312469482,
0.7349768280982971,
0.7644458413124084,
-0.37439778447151184,
-0.8342090249061584,
0.016916410997509956,
0.030421433970332146,
-0.5512580275535583,
0.3195187449455261,
0.4930232763290405,
-0.5265129208564758,
-0.027706297114491463,
-0.663851261138916,
-0.746349573135376,
0.9786279797554016,
0.499550461769104,
-0.5743215680122375,
-0.09405882656574249,
0.2527603209018707,
0.5975892543792725,
-0.28520604968070984,
-0.10236421972513199,
0.39695772528648376,
0.2366950511932373,
0.18766963481903076,
-0.5856409668922424,
0.062452878803014755,
0.05866100266575813,
0.06707462668418884,
0.6215032935142517,
-0.9828893542289734,
0.46178293228149414,
-0.3213914632797241,
-0.32024258375167847,
0.5866026282310486,
0.9485725164413452,
0.41848352551460266,
0.2735021412372589,
0.336656391620636,
0.5781196355819702,
0.4397275745868683,
0.3377077579498291,
0.9048457741737366,
-0.2387286275625229,
0.09740721434354782,
1.5169146060943604,
-0.13926874101161957,
0.7452042102813721,
0.6302370429039001,
0.1681203991174698,
0.42738357186317444,
0.4623505771160126,
0.06146115064620972,
0.3207499384880066,
0.3203955590724945,
0.03282812982797623,
-0.2762601375579834,
-0.2642035186290741,
-0.4274922013282776,
0.36650264263153076,
0.18015886843204498,
-0.4218895733356476,
-0.016828371211886406,
-0.10025808215141296,
-0.1393858939409256,
0.3279949128627777,
-0.09931688755750656,
0.7135772705078125,
-0.10438167303800583,
-1.2260856628417969,
0.7253168821334839,
0.06263188272714615,
0.3954688608646393,
-0.4639909565448761,
-0.6021259427070618,
-0.1462390273809433,
0.1300225853919983,
-0.2056909054517746,
-0.7363461852073669,
0.01092339213937521,
-0.015282130800187588,
-0.5541386604309082,
-0.3107476234436035,
0.5245232582092285,
-0.6149260401725769,
-0.5698778033256531,
-0.20268386602401733,
-0.051439426839351654,
-0.01566893421113491,
0.4082731008529663,
-0.4818918704986572,
0.035161953419446945,
0.3439856171607971,
-0.2995377480983734,
0.14214275777339935,
0.5658814311027527,
-0.239820659160614,
0.5502863526344299,
0.394693523645401,
-0.26328736543655396,
0.17982704937458038,
0.3133997619152069,
0.748203694820404,
-0.4151355028152466,
-0.0482376329600811,
-0.9051283597946167,
0.40756770968437195,
-0.04452917352318764,
-0.7305076122283936,
0.6171533465385437,
0.7933003306388855,
0.7978459000587463,
-0.1374598741531372,
0.6431177854537964,
-0.01139627955853939,
0.53584223985672,
-0.9615426063537598,
0.2734713554382324,
-0.5126059651374817,
0.3011946976184845,
-0.2212783545255661,
-1.0182052850723267,
-0.26954516768455505,
0.15780480206012726,
-0.24778227508068085,
-0.13791967928409576,
0.4418029189109802,
0.6580324769020081,
-0.08477313071489334,
0.03383341804146767,
-0.09085259586572647,
-0.2653943598270416,
0.16193123161792755,
0.786794900894165,
0.9342010021209717,
-0.197445809841156,
0.8540562391281128,
-0.43914803862571716,
-0.39700543880462646,
0.0007984326803125441,
-0.8572962284088135,
-1.1108144521713257,
-0.2554680407047272,
-0.2440398633480072,
-0.22673046588897705,
0.05352312698960304,
0.9869577884674072,
0.5640218257904053,
-0.6060081124305725,
-0.27376577258110046,
-0.4546833634376526,
0.2786839008331299,
-0.29365551471710205,
-0.18121053278446198,
0.576103687286377,
-0.26599571108818054,
-0.8978428840637207,
0.42408713698387146,
0.25552624464035034,
0.3194087743759155,
-0.045424509793519974,
-0.2516230046749115,
-0.011494070291519165,
0.03280530497431755,
0.3731008470058441,
0.5027596354484558,
-0.6723939180374146,
-0.5484035611152649,
0.14313358068466187,
-0.19915735721588135,
-0.08982142060995102,
0.8385037779808044,
-0.33629748225212097,
0.5456054210662842,
0.4984326958656311,
0.5914841294288635,
0.4511345624923706,
0.4377903640270233,
0.7137492299079895,
-1.03548002243042,
-0.22129473090171814,
0.02054702863097191,
0.033435624092817307,
0.13311176002025604,
-0.5660674571990967,
0.33138811588287354,
0.03343890979886055,
-0.5206465721130371,
-0.775570273399353,
0.5339826345443726,
-0.7605441212654114,
-0.2385179102420807,
1.1254653930664062,
0.03061790019273758,
-0.1710370033979416,
0.3342731297016144,
-0.6136724948883057,
0.35110801458358765,
-0.5517275333404541,
0.8490470051765442,
0.5193521976470947,
-0.5023030042648315,
-0.1308775097131729,
-0.2026796191930771,
0.35980647802352905,
0.3639694154262543,
-0.7698307633399963,
0.10784956812858582,
0.7769688963890076,
-0.10378120839595795,
0.318123459815979,
0.26207268238067627,
0.13886502385139465,
0.41086116433143616,
-0.055827945470809937,
0.24672743678092957,
-0.3678683638572693,
-0.6387109160423279,
0.07026107609272003,
0.06982174515724182,
-0.29597407579421997,
-0.45279425382614136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00121v1 | Granite-Function Calling Model: Introducing Function Calling Abilities via Multi-task Learning of Granular Tasks | 2024-06-27T17:47:26 | 2024-06-27T17:47:26 | Ibrahim Abdelaziz, Kinjal Basu, Mayank Agarwal, Sadhana Kumaravel, Matthew Stallone, Rameswar Panda, Yara Rizk, GP Bhargav, Maxwell Crouse, Chulaka Gunasekara, Shajith Ikbal, Sachin Joshi, Hima Karanam, Vineet Kumar, Asim Munawar, Sumit Neelam, Dinesh Raghu, Udit Sharma, Adriana Meza Soria, Dheeraj Sreedhar, Praveen Venkateswaran, Merve Unuvar, David Cox, Salim Roukos, Luis Lastras, Pavan Kapanipathi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently shown tremendous promise in
serving as the backbone to agentic systems, as demonstrated by their
performance in multi-faceted, challenging benchmarks like SWE-Bench and
Agent-Bench. However, to realize the true potential of LLMs as autonomous
agents, they must learn to identify, call, and interact with external tools and
application program interfaces (APIs) to complete complex tasks. These tasks
together are termed function calling. Endowing LLMs with function calling
abilities leads to a myriad of advantages, such as access to current and
domain-specific information in databases and knowledge sources, and the ability
to outsource tasks that can be reliably performed by tools, e.g., a Python
interpreter or calculator. While there has been significant progress in
function calling with LLMs, there is still a dearth of open models that perform
on par with proprietary LLMs like GPT, Claude, and Gemini. Therefore, in this
work, we introduce the GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING model under an Apache 2.0
license. The model is trained using a multi-task training approach on seven
fundamental tasks encompassed in function calling, those being Nested Function
Calling, Function Chaining, Parallel Functions, Function Name Detection,
Parameter-Value Pair Detection, Next-Best Function, and Response Generation. We
present a comprehensive evaluation on multiple out-of-domain datasets comparing
GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING to more than 15 other best proprietary and open
models. GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING provides the best performance among all
open models on the Berkeley Function Calling Leaderboard and fourth overall. As
a result of the diverse tasks and datasets used for training our model, we show
that GRANITE-20B-FUNCTIONCALLING has better generalizability on multiple tasks
in seven different evaluation datasets. | [
-0.2937498688697815,
-0.8631148338317871,
0.4893566966056824,
0.26174360513687134,
-0.05178036540746689,
0.018971841782331467,
-0.4139299988746643,
-0.5085488557815552,
-0.3284885585308075,
0.8083675503730774,
-0.5936689376831055,
-0.3517950773239136,
-0.44427335262298584,
-0.03575257956981659,
-0.16699440777301788,
0.7993221282958984,
0.07231668382883072,
0.4168303906917572,
-0.583839476108551,
0.22259901463985443,
-0.4743287265300751,
-0.21278992295265198,
-0.7400909066200256,
-0.6062152981758118,
0.30157163739204407,
-0.009722856804728508,
0.659263551235199,
0.6558643579483032,
0.5332574844360352,
0.3873511850833893,
0.27864977717399597,
0.3927474915981293,
-0.19061627984046936,
-0.08076535165309906,
-0.1113256961107254,
-0.5418400764465332,
-0.6136048436164856,
-0.15636347234249115,
0.4624135494232178,
0.723395824432373,
0.07164672017097473,
0.3253699243068695,
0.08537163585424423,
0.2927935719490051,
-0.5014997124671936,
0.8814974427223206,
-0.7280213236808777,
-0.2538716197013855,
-0.26254400610923767,
-0.2840307354927063,
-0.6263965368270874,
-0.23415139317512512,
-0.005064233671873808,
-0.29789069294929504,
-0.1443394422531128,
-0.27866053581237793,
0.3671119213104248,
0.3707689046859741,
-0.4515058994293213,
-0.5730791091918945,
-0.6698101758956909,
1.1011446714401245,
-0.6135478615760803,
0.22552190721035004,
0.5981453657150269,
0.2640473544597626,
-0.2052156776189804,
-0.699152410030365,
-0.0461224764585495,
-0.40659356117248535,
0.19775058329105377,
-0.12738370895385742,
0.20715124905109406,
0.05905323475599289,
0.038998350501060486,
0.2696208953857422,
-0.16262929141521454,
-0.039045076817274094,
-0.0699976310133934,
0.20954515039920807,
0.5644698143005371,
0.28928762674331665,
0.06125255674123764,
0.0481710322201252,
-0.2569739818572998,
-0.0068961563520133495,
-0.5657017230987549,
0.2979135513305664,
0.21269795298576355,
0.9515015482902527,
-0.05635387822985649,
0.1722135841846466,
-0.06130608543753624,
0.8635740280151367,
-0.07706901431083679,
-0.5468803644180298,
0.2565251290798187,
0.16289152204990387,
-0.4390106499195099,
-0.6012179255485535,
0.6019347310066223,
-0.06566713750362396,
0.3761008381843567,
-0.44583576917648315,
-0.2527981698513031,
-0.42879125475883484,
0.6054250001907349,
-0.8638389110565186,
0.008533370681107044,
0.43341493606567383,
-0.3821864426136017,
-0.26108190417289734,
-0.15958814322948456,
-0.33636823296546936,
-0.4190863370895386,
-0.6776317358016968,
0.6476625800132751,
-0.523722767829895,
-0.17359024286270142,
-0.22173267602920532,
0.3158738315105438,
0.07567848265171051,
0.46561458706855774,
-0.9561814665794373,
0.9395643472671509,
0.7066699266433716,
0.7006030678749084,
-0.10935162007808685,
-0.40597671270370483,
-0.7904702425003052,
-0.15687775611877441,
-0.36759698390960693,
0.7460598945617676,
-0.570841908454895,
-0.5137467384338379,
-0.17786486446857452,
0.010164504870772362,
-0.40275976061820984,
-0.8341543674468994,
0.14444704353809357,
-0.42917272448539734,
-0.22961299121379852,
-0.1768348067998886,
-0.023776549845933914,
-0.3308837413787842,
0.11543197929859161,
-0.5096864700317383,
1.2424962520599365,
0.27233463525772095,
-0.2485838234424591,
0.23177550733089447,
-0.771361768245697,
-0.44773897528648376,
0.47523289918899536,
-0.27987608313560486,
-0.4930945336818695,
0.23792745172977448,
0.057867780327796936,
0.5908797383308411,
-0.6892266869544983,
0.2683814764022827,
-0.3047723174095154,
-0.22330674529075623,
0.08769791573286057,
-0.1321091204881668,
0.8462343811988831,
0.18662098050117493,
-0.378569632768631,
0.35727784037590027,
-0.30472540855407715,
0.38990461826324463,
-0.0204763226211071,
-0.20466230809688568,
-0.23652887344360352,
-0.010890313424170017,
-0.057141028344631195,
0.16398927569389343,
0.13327285647392273,
-0.3620125353336334,
-0.08672039210796356,
-0.16948914527893066,
0.392598956823349,
0.5726054906845093,
-0.4762119948863983,
0.1752883642911911,
-0.5158705711364746,
0.41063305735588074,
-0.3108816146850586,
0.3276899456977844,
-0.15486222505569458,
-0.48060256242752075,
-0.15951961278915405,
-0.8141608834266663,
0.35872840881347656,
0.7356404662132263,
-0.5482383370399475,
0.08818832039833069,
-0.26310065388679504,
-0.4188518226146698,
-0.35105979442596436,
0.12106983363628387,
0.4429314434528351,
0.21701617538928986,
0.4195277988910675,
-0.295724093914032,
-0.10888119786977768,
-0.5212653875350952,
-0.13175459206104279,
0.07630743086338043,
0.09947945922613144,
0.8647565841674805,
0.6520928740501404,
-0.02950182929635048,
0.8378351926803589,
-0.3663065433502197,
-0.4194439649581909,
-0.0968877300620079,
0.17907878756523132,
0.3509463667869568,
0.10178910195827484,
0.36984479427337646,
-1.0023813247680664,
-0.6073992252349854,
0.21585841476917267,
-0.7221993207931519,
0.01132071390748024,
0.12210516631603241,
0.16908343136310577,
-0.008075661025941372,
0.1509999781847,
-0.3297431468963623,
0.22567352652549744,
0.6363645195960999,
0.2064223438501358,
0.8070851564407349,
-0.24150624871253967,
0.2550520896911621,
-1.1687195301055908,
0.037248726934194565,
-0.1386307030916214,
-0.3636634647846222,
-0.5577610731124878,
0.3213205337524414,
0.1351005733013153,
-0.167501762509346,
-0.6795610189437866,
0.7570316195487976,
-0.7547357678413391,
-0.3440885543823242,
-0.5808128714561462,
-0.2582422196865082,
-0.5446559190750122,
0.4476988613605499,
-0.05132867023348808,
0.9074333310127258,
0.8775098919868469,
-0.7008516788482666,
0.6139556765556335,
0.24661900103092194,
-0.07024360448122025,
0.5909823179244995,
-0.2692753076553345,
0.1112440899014473,
0.25638025999069214,
0.09387679398059845,
-0.9573411345481873,
-0.14828044176101685,
-0.13875269889831543,
-0.3091900050640106,
0.1190633475780487,
-0.6050180196762085,
-0.4024278521537781,
-0.5067905187606812,
-0.26324063539505005,
0.47087058424949646,
0.33250609040260315,
-0.48714882135391235,
1.1435401439666748,
0.5848662257194519,
-0.38891300559043884,
-0.6738117337226868,
-0.650352954864502,
-0.09451988339424133,
0.011188200674951077,
-0.7090957164764404,
0.4095669686794281,
-0.1375950127840042,
-0.22673353552818298,
-0.0221419520676136,
-0.09099515527486801,
-0.4037024974822998,
0.02256988361477852,
0.7043943405151367,
0.1646798700094223,
0.07897080481052399,
0.15428784489631653,
-0.28102588653564453,
-0.0797620341181755,
0.04744750261306763,
-0.6181834936141968,
0.8223491907119751,
-0.2631044387817383,
-0.45833438634872437,
-0.1528828740119934,
0.10813159495592117,
0.5699430704116821,
-0.43720385432243347,
0.675605058670044,
0.4628491699695587,
-0.6036438941955566,
-0.4670218229293823,
-0.43565425276756287,
-0.2383853644132614,
-0.4939083158969879,
0.2275896668434143,
-0.8044915795326233,
-0.725898027420044,
0.6306979060173035,
-0.41209906339645386,
0.11711735278367996,
0.17404888570308685,
0.7806215882301331,
0.22317412495613098,
0.7031758427619934,
0.6450756788253784,
0.20021766424179077,
0.5299791693687439,
-0.3507169187068939,
0.0072197760455310345,
-0.918418824672699,
-0.1995251625776291,
-0.510343611240387,
0.16750091314315796,
-0.5379573106765747,
-0.6438285112380981,
0.42636585235595703,
-0.2501780390739441,
-0.17487993836402893,
0.37716326117515564,
-0.20601536333560944,
0.6058935523033142,
0.5854893922805786,
0.27909645438194275,
0.13757012784481049,
0.0226817037910223,
-0.13242968916893005,
0.1744338870048523,
-0.3185688853263855,
-0.4194556176662445,
1.329353928565979,
0.2966166138648987,
0.9010123610496521,
-0.10767108201980591,
0.7280741930007935,
0.28363165259361267,
0.41694769263267517,
-1.0349175930023193,
0.6264179944992065,
-0.5282847285270691,
-0.4951010048389435,
-0.3975953757762909,
-0.5943146347999573,
-0.797124445438385,
0.46348631381988525,
-0.020108439028263092,
-0.9658810496330261,
-0.21333974599838257,
-0.1202346533536911,
-0.585894763469696,
0.5193655490875244,
-0.4394538402557373,
0.6041473746299744,
-0.27383488416671753,
-0.49295538663864136,
-0.12278421968221664,
-0.43766751885414124,
0.27935338020324707,
-0.1729060858488083,
0.6414048075675964,
-0.0674000084400177,
0.3490503430366516,
0.3564474284648895,
-0.21592296659946442,
1.0673935413360596,
-0.1526428759098053,
-0.24490639567375183,
0.32267820835113525,
0.16498731076717377,
0.5577732920646667,
-0.07967425882816315,
-0.12838508188724518,
0.03495077043771744,
0.12250285595655441,
-0.18431110680103302,
-0.19545608758926392,
0.8574845194816589,
-0.8595425486564636,
-0.3228338062763214,
-0.28540486097335815,
-0.895576000213623,
-0.27793577313423157,
0.3032718598842621,
-0.21080175042152405,
1.0073035955429077,
-0.034119460731744766,
0.08014814555644989,
0.6838688850402832,
0.20177964866161346,
0.597791850566864,
0.24294975399971008,
-0.30683284997940063,
-0.4669835865497589,
1.116945743560791,
0.1304294914007187,
0.378506064414978,
0.35072585940361023,
-0.03602036088705063,
-0.5182403326034546,
-0.610701858997345,
-0.43696367740631104,
0.3271139860153198,
-0.5525352954864502,
-0.1782546043395996,
-0.8114264011383057,
-0.19660095870494843,
-0.4442216157913208,
-0.014816110953688622,
-0.47551989555358887,
-0.13974860310554504,
0.06342839449644089,
0.3383185863494873,
0.023399224504828453,
0.8335988521575928,
0.056369371712207794,
0.36953529715538025,
-0.7936099767684937,
0.30716705322265625,
0.4291844666004181,
0.34060585498809814,
0.03689287602901459,
-0.30934083461761475,
-0.4437161386013031,
0.05198296159505844,
-0.5430123805999756,
-0.6513572335243225,
0.45307210087776184,
0.07615531980991364,
0.636455237865448,
-0.05090054124593735,
-0.0582684725522995,
0.5657671093940735,
-0.4917376935482025,
0.6107431054115295,
-0.15729877352714539,
-1.1056616306304932,
0.21889139711856842,
-0.5805410742759705,
0.24517185986042023,
0.35859060287475586,
0.288289338350296,
-0.28181931376457214,
-0.206714928150177,
-0.39340871572494507,
-0.8525650501251221,
0.9231816530227661,
-0.042122285813093185,
0.1657206416130066,
-0.032048314809799194,
0.21368719637393951,
0.2582969069480896,
0.46160855889320374,
-0.7623010873794556,
0.016383443027734756,
0.19870702922344208,
-0.11956663429737091,
0.1718466579914093,
0.264169842004776,
-0.5592220425605774,
0.19263701140880585,
0.5211045145988464,
-0.6492926478385925,
0.6438553929328918,
-0.21024762094020844,
-0.23809127509593964,
-0.31664130091667175,
0.20962011814117432,
0.49863362312316895,
0.9855808019638062,
-0.13392433524131775,
0.12755367159843445,
0.5584944486618042,
-0.466571182012558,
-0.17285995185375214,
0.31011125445365906,
0.22468136250972748,
-0.5188812017440796,
0.2707405388355255,
0.6433786153793335,
0.11326020210981369,
-0.4578814208507538,
0.29611268639564514,
0.18177399039268494,
-0.10038358718156815,
-0.34717950224876404,
0.0016407776856794953,
0.031994566321372986,
0.3819168508052826,
0.5700817704200745,
0.05547362193465233,
0.14632798731327057,
-0.8189593553543091,
0.3205609619617462,
0.7886946201324463,
-0.4454675614833832,
-0.2367924004793167,
0.5499170422554016,
0.2647918164730072,
-0.41904503107070923,
0.3875351846218109,
-0.1690029352903366,
-0.34394267201423645,
0.6899785995483398,
0.5749995112419128,
0.8463630676269531,
-0.39329656958580017,
0.4238704442977905,
0.10709229111671448,
0.1274559199810028,
-0.15230174362659454,
0.3902616500854492,
-0.05728018283843994,
-0.39228472113609314,
-0.749421238899231,
-0.6705991625785828,
-0.6109938025474548,
0.12216750532388687,
-0.6292527318000793,
0.11712493002414703,
-0.42957428097724915,
-0.5210772752761841,
-0.1525696963071823,
0.2840093970298767,
-0.5036632418632507,
0.5431953072547913,
0.21717481315135956,
0.7499076724052429,
-0.6398130059242249,
0.7065938115119934,
0.8584467768669128,
-0.15724937617778778,
-0.5715079307556152,
-0.031140610575675964,
0.24425359070301056,
-0.7866628170013428,
0.6557772159576416,
0.1940043419599533,
-0.48637890815734863,
0.23147611320018768,
-0.2548690438270569,
-0.634395182132721,
1.4136191606521606,
0.3254472315311432,
-0.007677049841731787,
-0.04972792789340019,
0.30491119623184204,
0.2617768347263336,
-0.7928401231765747,
0.7860642671585083,
0.11545931547880173,
0.2840724587440491,
0.20322825014591217,
-1.4567621946334839,
0.17722944915294647,
0.04879533872008324,
0.07445918023586273,
0.4081939160823822,
-0.8367443084716797,
1.210983395576477,
-0.3790557384490967,
0.09514708071947098,
0.15743769705295563,
0.24542109668254852,
0.013178517110645771,
0.07552383840084076,
0.4081912040710449,
0.40062573552131653,
0.7906042337417603,
-0.24663877487182617,
1.1520342826843262,
-0.22710946202278137,
0.4773387908935547,
1.1199198961257935,
-0.27602314949035645,
0.8832060694694519,
0.12383238971233368,
-0.21808195114135742,
0.3813765048980713,
0.6439111232757568,
0.10104148089885712,
0.6720331311225891,
0.25072193145751953,
-0.38780173659324646,
-0.4062657952308655,
0.03803110495209694,
-0.1434958130121231,
0.24865113198757172,
0.32417768239974976,
-0.13136962056159973,
-0.40577104687690735,
-0.018080785870552063,
-0.08809888362884521,
-0.1822529286146164,
-0.41987305879592896,
0.7870714068412781,
0.1850425899028778,
-0.5120307803153992,
0.4990180730819702,
0.08223485201597214,
0.4502854645252228,
-0.8183799386024475,
0.07172484695911407,
0.1017623245716095,
0.5137825012207031,
-0.26311516761779785,
-0.5945605635643005,
0.3671953082084656,
-0.38607075810432434,
-0.16130396723747253,
-0.07737766206264496,
0.5177283883094788,
-0.31368288397789,
-0.09324726462364197,
0.6193450093269348,
0.5077328085899353,
0.1686323881149292,
-0.36044958233833313,
-0.7837579846382141,
0.05063290521502495,
-0.2914189100265503,
0.07916471362113953,
0.4386737048625946,
0.1500423550605774,
-0.41318777203559875,
1.052931785583496,
0.7520453333854675,
0.003279643366113305,
0.1462254524230957,
0.05996234714984894,
0.8024073839187622,
-0.4500996172428131,
-0.2739742398262024,
-0.7063636779785156,
0.6297635436058044,
0.19364206492900848,
-0.20031946897506714,
0.4941297769546509,
0.5890714526176453,
0.66030353307724,
-0.25512734055519104,
0.8857089877128601,
-0.09306798875331879,
0.17150446772575378,
-0.44797366857528687,
0.28763166069984436,
-0.38186994194984436,
0.08737272769212723,
-0.09936108440160751,
-0.8900642991065979,
-0.3337867259979248,
0.3117844760417938,
-0.8475254774093628,
0.5494281053543091,
0.8098210692405701,
0.7349623441696167,
-0.24660179018974304,
0.07949905842542648,
0.40037471055984497,
-0.04084917902946472,
0.33167803287506104,
0.4348737299442291,
0.5989458560943604,
-0.3520947992801666,
0.4570524990558624,
0.10287167876958847,
-0.6894211769104004,
-0.23598423600196838,
-0.6707492470741272,
-1.139315128326416,
-0.659730851650238,
-0.17211021482944489,
-0.314645916223526,
0.31407883763313293,
1.0717236995697021,
1.1788955926895142,
-0.8464102149009705,
-0.8691251277923584,
0.06906824558973312,
-0.18192563951015472,
-0.5675628185272217,
-0.19673405587673187,
0.14589016139507294,
-0.7107109427452087,
-0.8868151903152466,
0.5428770184516907,
0.3500939607620239,
-0.2436220794916153,
-0.06224740296602249,
-0.03976404294371605,
-0.021833643317222595,
0.34314146637916565,
0.6062300801277161,
0.21379387378692627,
-0.6331672668457031,
0.04525329917669296,
-0.06705784052610397,
-0.10827654600143433,
-0.0012419401900842786,
0.7890486717224121,
-0.5257446765899658,
0.2960158586502075,
0.13486550748348236,
0.7813701033592224,
0.7498920559883118,
0.026557862758636475,
0.38041186332702637,
-0.678058385848999,
-0.20332711935043335,
-0.0256760623306036,
0.021357420831918716,
0.3618882894515991,
-0.4042404592037201,
0.6009401679039001,
0.11446714401245117,
-0.7543967366218567,
-0.7098046541213989,
0.4152798652648926,
-0.8588262796401978,
-0.21154621243476868,
0.9972142577171326,
-0.26075395941734314,
-0.3613283634185791,
-0.19086894392967224,
-0.2626143991947174,
-0.10070880502462387,
-0.3106100857257843,
0.6073285341262817,
0.6255653500556946,
-0.5908327698707581,
-0.1319076418876648,
-0.7236788868904114,
0.4541323482990265,
-0.035770341753959656,
-1.1017351150512695,
0.2692038118839264,
0.22280199825763702,
0.6270508766174316,
0.34447798132896423,
0.772486686706543,
-0.31801602244377136,
0.14855727553367615,
-0.08408061414957047,
0.09246668964624405,
-0.45472732186317444,
-0.6890313625335693,
-0.052222952246665955,
0.31338945031166077,
0.21615935862064362,
-0.26425740122795105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19358v1 | The Model Arena for Cross-lingual Sentiment Analysis: A Comparative Study in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-06-27T17:38:45 | 2024-06-27T17:38:45 | Xiliang Zhu, Shayna Gardiner, Tere Roldán, David Rossouw | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis serves as a pivotal component in Natural Language
Processing (NLP). Advancements in multilingual pre-trained models such as XLM-R
and mT5 have contributed to the increasing interest in cross-lingual sentiment
analysis. The recent emergence in Large Language Models (LLM) has significantly
advanced general NLP tasks, however, the capability of such LLMs in
cross-lingual sentiment analysis has not been fully studied. This work
undertakes an empirical analysis to compare the cross-lingual transfer
capability of public Small Multilingual Language Models (SMLM) like XLM-R,
against English-centric LLMs such as Llama-3, in the context of sentiment
analysis across English, Spanish, French and Chinese. Our findings reveal that
among public models, SMLMs exhibit superior zero-shot cross-lingual performance
relative to LLMs. However, in few-shot cross-lingual settings, public LLMs
demonstrate an enhanced adaptive potential. In addition, we observe that
proprietary GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 lead in zero-shot cross-lingual capability, but
are outpaced by public models in few-shot scenarios. | [
-0.5095821619033813,
-0.25431278347969055,
0.5675982236862183,
0.5721489787101746,
-0.21612606942653656,
0.19771361351013184,
-0.28884944319725037,
-0.6994324922561646,
0.0784231573343277,
0.24032483994960785,
-0.227972149848938,
-0.4829382598400116,
-0.6537782549858093,
0.46182137727737427,
-0.16488862037658691,
1.0086796283721924,
-0.038547348231077194,
0.2973096966743469,
-0.023303203284740448,
-0.4284079968929291,
-0.12807239592075348,
-0.8534864187240601,
-0.46316275000572205,
-0.22633127868175507,
0.7824050188064575,
0.10549573600292206,
0.6638405919075012,
-0.10319383442401886,
0.5225004553794861,
0.19418250024318695,
-0.05592557042837143,
-0.2940863370895386,
-0.37658390402793884,
-0.49685055017471313,
-0.38709595799446106,
-0.524742603302002,
-0.8807333707809448,
0.022033236920833588,
0.7803820371627808,
0.6550336480140686,
0.08877752721309662,
0.10503880679607391,
0.15446116030216217,
0.6714849472045898,
-0.4125000834465027,
0.1785683035850525,
-0.6659700870513916,
0.2441718578338623,
-0.24442259967327118,
-0.031764816492795944,
-0.40057215094566345,
-0.16303956508636475,
0.18346302211284637,
-0.4137422442436218,
-0.22079864144325256,
0.02286108210682869,
0.7448739409446716,
-0.08538895100355148,
-0.3731371760368347,
-0.12425732612609863,
-0.46843665838241577,
1.1076983213424683,
-0.9202056527137756,
0.5314151644706726,
-0.1233280599117279,
0.21044546365737915,
0.42165201902389526,
-0.5533344745635986,
-0.5560961961746216,
-0.16334673762321472,
-0.11271614581346512,
0.16148722171783447,
-0.5128705501556396,
-0.24792420864105225,
-0.046629417687654495,
0.17167407274246216,
-0.630355179309845,
0.34834524989128113,
-0.3076171875,
0.07482137531042099,
0.5052057504653931,
0.1360052078962326,
0.30084308981895447,
-0.5027768015861511,
-0.6785939931869507,
0.06418842077255249,
-0.8766016960144043,
0.06105237826704979,
0.022443391382694244,
0.5918495655059814,
-0.27517324686050415,
0.3682499825954437,
-0.029384220018982887,
0.48827412724494934,
-0.12576915323734283,
-0.20310206711292267,
0.32656314969062805,
-0.3474678695201874,
-0.5588283538818359,
-0.08725650608539581,
0.9839892983436584,
0.5029942393302917,
0.4004818797111511,
-0.10324572771787643,
-0.27249032258987427,
-0.10425054281949997,
-0.09393241256475449,
-0.6530831456184387,
0.15964485704898834,
-0.11772356182336807,
-0.5698189735412598,
-0.2200370728969574,
-0.09030581265687943,
-0.7538230419158936,
-0.32906219363212585,
-0.20619690418243408,
0.46715033054351807,
-0.03480447456240654,
-0.45379185676574707,
0.19631792604923248,
0.110198013484478,
0.503108024597168,
0.26107215881347656,
-0.6761112809181213,
0.37539803981781006,
0.7970674633979797,
1.03323233127594,
-0.5806612372398376,
-0.485588014125824,
-0.24914103746414185,
-0.0984966903924942,
-0.3883379101753235,
0.7507581114768982,
-0.5704423785209656,
-0.4878541827201843,
-0.026013318449258804,
0.16957662999629974,
-0.35806432366371155,
-0.5232561230659485,
0.43085014820098877,
-0.48532214760780334,
0.4214459955692291,
-0.5102950930595398,
-0.09009075164794922,
-0.41456204652786255,
0.5364990234375,
-0.4859459102153778,
0.7169738411903381,
0.07060584425926208,
-0.8342606425285339,
0.33245041966438293,
-0.7877752780914307,
-0.36834099888801575,
-0.17873045802116394,
0.016530165448784828,
-0.20968830585479736,
0.18815402686595917,
0.38815632462501526,
0.7002295255661011,
-0.4281071424484253,
-0.1025858074426651,
-0.7328026294708252,
-0.3338051438331604,
0.31835922598838806,
-0.44111767411231995,
0.7777386903762817,
0.09132484346628189,
-0.16567182540893555,
-0.04020543023943901,
-0.582802951335907,
-0.14259469509124756,
0.03284301981329918,
-0.2735539674758911,
-0.4927959144115448,
-0.361782044172287,
0.05939876288175583,
0.599514901638031,
0.15487535297870636,
-0.5764808654785156,
0.02226497232913971,
-0.37131598591804504,
0.2324688732624054,
0.7224817276000977,
-0.21841123700141907,
0.6160659193992615,
-0.20234499871730804,
0.814372718334198,
0.11599849909543991,
-0.014723909087479115,
0.21868197619915009,
-0.4038483500480652,
-0.5854300260543823,
-0.33748728036880493,
0.4482273757457733,
0.6405143141746521,
-0.6989977955818176,
-0.15720196068286896,
-0.6026772260665894,
-0.24637898802757263,
-0.6127581000328064,
0.11825653910636902,
0.1464560627937317,
0.32378435134887695,
0.32408615946769714,
-0.24745717644691467,
-0.4177209734916687,
-0.8804233074188232,
-0.35557106137275696,
-0.28113898634910583,
0.035568900406360626,
0.37376919388771057,
0.2756185531616211,
-0.21490056812763214,
0.5852987170219421,
-0.04854116588830948,
-0.44976186752319336,
-0.5906276702880859,
0.15575061738491058,
0.14177949726581573,
-0.1674042046070099,
1.1100572347640991,
-0.5128423571586609,
-0.999445378780365,
0.4650522470474243,
-0.6887198090553284,
-0.4411556124687195,
0.020129619166254997,
0.038153331726789474,
0.6570637822151184,
0.09309523552656174,
-0.6717063784599304,
0.08252152055501938,
1.107428789138794,
-0.09929144382476807,
0.3950177729129791,
0.1468709111213684,
0.28320443630218506,
-0.8858261108398438,
0.22558054327964783,
0.02673908695578575,
-0.38541221618652344,
-0.6518638730049133,
-0.06956633925437927,
0.004078000318259001,
0.08428533375263214,
-0.830145001411438,
0.7294512987136841,
-0.511867105960846,
-0.559357225894928,
-0.295633465051651,
0.38026994466781616,
0.006007801275700331,
0.4622323215007782,
0.36597204208374023,
0.5301967859268188,
0.58290696144104,
-0.28624191880226135,
0.27502205967903137,
-0.07322785258293152,
-0.17718711495399475,
0.7290413975715637,
-0.5316566228866577,
0.04045535624027252,
0.1662507951259613,
0.21305209398269653,
-0.7479965686798096,
0.06123179942369461,
0.31888797879219055,
-0.3012351989746094,
0.25853750109672546,
-0.1320464164018631,
-0.2671568989753723,
-0.135893777012825,
-0.4451562464237213,
0.2322477400302887,
0.44370266795158386,
-0.5800997614860535,
0.7111209034919739,
0.1954888254404068,
-0.6562640070915222,
-0.6161626577377319,
-0.9276626706123352,
0.28130966424942017,
-0.41711288690567017,
-0.5175874829292297,
0.012566227465867996,
0.11150277405977249,
-0.4405786693096161,
0.09964317828416824,
0.20127828419208527,
0.12880128622055054,
-0.0926034078001976,
-0.006890518125146627,
0.5102330446243286,
-0.5043268799781799,
-0.18789178133010864,
-0.2552129030227661,
-0.009251890704035759,
0.1295485496520996,
0.0026900856755673885,
0.27435415983200073,
-0.3578372001647949,
-0.3145626187324524,
-0.12289134413003922,
0.24513058364391327,
0.7380112409591675,
-0.11693227291107178,
0.6615042686462402,
0.6298053860664368,
-0.08783198893070221,
-0.2264399230480194,
-0.2439448982477188,
0.2929023504257202,
-0.36185741424560547,
0.37047797441482544,
-0.41345152258872986,
-0.9011092782020569,
0.3819628357887268,
0.3454091250896454,
0.07583684474229813,
0.4256005585193634,
0.7833722829818726,
0.21649490296840668,
1.1243412494659424,
0.5419874787330627,
-0.6338249444961548,
0.29804137349128723,
0.10572139173746109,
0.2397250533103943,
-0.7812157273292542,
0.2750992774963379,
-0.4339107573032379,
-0.18458835780620575,
-0.5695245862007141,
-0.535426139831543,
0.2096584290266037,
-0.20827478170394897,
0.00680693332105875,
0.10142617672681808,
0.14547032117843628,
0.13598673045635223,
0.047612160444259644,
-0.5003871917724609,
0.4439699947834015,
0.12191726267337799,
-0.11776454746723175,
-0.15827623009681702,
-0.9042060971260071,
-0.5212260484695435,
0.9728204011917114,
0.5990643501281738,
0.7027459740638733,
0.19714100658893585,
0.4484415650367737,
0.09797240048646927,
0.754936695098877,
-0.778391420841217,
0.6780348420143127,
-0.5688339471817017,
-0.413993775844574,
-0.12930548191070557,
-0.48385384678840637,
-0.6406762599945068,
0.6725639700889587,
-0.17991754412651062,
-0.5209751725196838,
0.17373567819595337,
-0.22647814452648163,
-0.36340999603271484,
0.5015033483505249,
-0.5336689949035645,
0.8130108714103699,
-0.2813885509967804,
-0.27977320551872253,
-0.0674327090382576,
-0.38318848609924316,
0.5299246311187744,
-0.4413706064224243,
0.5852724313735962,
-0.19309987127780914,
-0.07360339164733887,
0.44429323077201843,
0.040112510323524475,
0.8831959962844849,
-0.26991650462150574,
-0.4089188873767853,
0.045306358486413956,
0.1667308658361435,
0.3042581081390381,
-0.144633486866951,
-0.2590692341327667,
0.5005130171775818,
-0.04598249867558479,
-0.21866528689861298,
-0.5171684622764587,
1.0000232458114624,
-0.8956426978111267,
-0.5668641328811646,
-0.43785393238067627,
-0.4242000877857208,
-0.4095802903175354,
0.02327950857579708,
0.0133913429453969,
0.06298699975013733,
-0.28726163506507874,
0.331509530544281,
0.16887569427490234,
-0.3513626158237457,
0.5734944939613342,
0.6380169987678528,
-0.5894246101379395,
-0.19455866515636444,
0.7886595129966736,
0.37600424885749817,
0.4614318609237671,
0.5672725439071655,
0.3485352396965027,
-0.412924587726593,
-0.32502520084381104,
-0.4675748944282532,
0.23498773574829102,
-0.7738829851150513,
-0.13253861665725708,
-0.5933113098144531,
0.0547187440097332,
-0.475707083940506,
-0.2560734748840332,
-0.4136725664138794,
-0.4723823368549347,
-0.19084051251411438,
-0.2882142663002014,
0.116445392370224,
0.6577886939048767,
-0.2994020879268646,
0.060582857578992844,
-0.9904536008834839,
0.42664363980293274,
0.45329537987709045,
0.2731967568397522,
0.021170644089579582,
-0.7111405730247498,
-0.03844226524233818,
0.007741712965071201,
0.05995398014783859,
-0.7228612303733826,
0.6865746974945068,
0.1333262324333191,
0.45072314143180847,
0.22165831923484802,
-0.12500803172588348,
0.7123059630393982,
-0.2837863862514496,
1.0076227188110352,
0.18994201719760895,
-0.9776604175567627,
-0.08684553951025009,
-0.27354925870895386,
0.3186713457107544,
0.11229473352432251,
0.6001060605049133,
-0.6622458696365356,
-0.3283174932003021,
-0.22894297540187836,
-0.524569034576416,
0.8034380674362183,
-0.23504486680030823,
0.04803530499339104,
0.13609297573566437,
-0.18473391234874725,
0.2141706943511963,
0.05325525999069214,
-1.289718508720398,
0.20222187042236328,
-0.2475409209728241,
-0.09505759179592133,
-0.37569674849510193,
-0.15024429559707642,
0.015326503664255142,
-0.04596530273556709,
0.6309648752212524,
-0.1949165165424347,
0.09286864846944809,
0.0746946781873703,
-0.2732612192630768,
-0.17713722586631775,
0.6054778695106506,
0.414543479681015,
0.4854077100753784,
-0.0393366776406765,
0.18255068361759186,
0.6734718084335327,
-0.18094292283058167,
0.08421675115823746,
-0.038960397243499756,
-0.1170027032494545,
-0.06118527054786682,
0.5008019804954529,
0.9461989402770996,
0.5058770775794983,
-0.29838642477989197,
0.66224205493927,
0.04124654456973076,
-0.3204593360424042,
0.061132416129112244,
-0.2893637418746948,
0.06999959796667099,
0.2758675515651703,
0.08590562641620636,
-0.17915424704551697,
0.046928178519010544,
-0.7384033203125,
-0.3073549270629883,
0.49977684020996094,
-0.4197748005390167,
-0.6601166129112244,
0.3885277509689331,
0.14774587750434875,
0.04693150520324707,
0.22008715569972992,
-0.11840245872735977,
-0.6438631415367126,
0.12439028173685074,
0.49938201904296875,
0.9477866291999817,
0.01595664955675602,
0.22033736109733582,
0.06511110067367554,
0.27792051434516907,
-0.10105971992015839,
0.12052924931049347,
0.16311340034008026,
-0.7749679684638977,
-0.6789085268974304,
-0.8058134317398071,
-0.46622416377067566,
-0.021001890301704407,
-0.5972424745559692,
0.1794850379228592,
-0.29327067732810974,
-0.14852042496204376,
-0.24007020890712738,
0.06543855369091034,
-0.7053968906402588,
0.20891010761260986,
0.5866981744766235,
0.856691837310791,
-0.9082468152046204,
0.9056072235107422,
0.8000534176826477,
-0.04775423929095268,
-0.8214691281318665,
-0.09195618331432343,
-0.016247021034359932,
-0.7394216060638428,
0.7882277965545654,
0.11334507167339325,
-0.4681367576122284,
-0.19625873863697052,
-0.27922266721725464,
-0.5586900115013123,
0.9596102237701416,
0.15231645107269287,
-0.6584842205047607,
-0.05008082464337349,
0.5461990237236023,
0.8252556920051575,
-0.5721378326416016,
0.03789915889501572,
0.5963121652603149,
0.5612372159957886,
-0.09235713630914688,
-1.1300793886184692,
-0.04336676001548767,
0.03604309260845184,
0.022250616922974586,
-0.04215557873249054,
-0.7083507776260376,
0.9013296961784363,
-0.04881499707698822,
-0.21893271803855896,
-0.06147055700421333,
0.5564910769462585,
0.373787522315979,
0.25669077038764954,
0.6016368269920349,
0.38437336683273315,
0.33060944080352783,
0.045679979026317596,
1.1459051370620728,
-0.2114141583442688,
0.19673116505146027,
0.8186380863189697,
-0.9057489037513733,
1.330167531967163,
0.5355350971221924,
-0.2927885949611664,
0.5425706505775452,
0.18184910714626312,
0.182188019156456,
0.3380739688873291,
-0.23399637639522552,
-0.08195534348487854,
-0.21673376858234406,
0.173344224691391,
-0.3005874454975128,
0.5576553344726562,
0.17201445996761322,
-0.20726467669010162,
-0.14654074609279633,
0.21225103735923767,
0.018023455515503883,
-0.15250186622142792,
-0.7342145442962646,
0.7098655104637146,
0.4807700216770172,
-0.5437065362930298,
0.3698262870311737,
0.039510272443294525,
1.0010205507278442,
-0.5931181311607361,
0.348183810710907,
-0.29566097259521484,
0.23765744268894196,
-0.23706752061843872,
-0.9625855684280396,
0.37191981077194214,
0.3292071521282196,
0.04973577335476875,
-0.33618226647377014,
0.769916296005249,
-0.19517405331134796,
-0.5759040117263794,
0.8546117544174194,
0.6247556805610657,
0.17762313783168793,
0.014576043002307415,
-0.8259419202804565,
0.08951283246278763,
-0.049801625311374664,
-0.525993287563324,
0.6368971467018127,
0.6038292050361633,
-0.11476565152406693,
0.47070154547691345,
0.6074694991111755,
0.5108961462974548,
0.21460391581058502,
0.3605707585811615,
0.6081196069717407,
-0.7202865481376648,
-0.3873869478702545,
-0.7517749071121216,
0.3161863684654236,
0.24404984712600708,
-0.09567588567733765,
1.0808473825454712,
0.19295914471149445,
1.004455804824829,
-0.20933355391025543,
0.8894593119621277,
0.077081099152565,
0.7302845120429993,
-0.5026189088821411,
0.5688219666481018,
-0.6878922581672668,
0.26928889751434326,
-0.396624356508255,
-0.9609443545341492,
-0.46470582485198975,
0.5215758681297302,
-0.611075222492218,
-0.02636822685599327,
0.4326883852481842,
0.7526283264160156,
-0.14065732061862946,
-0.12737171351909637,
0.6172650456428528,
0.3734700679779053,
0.1329621821641922,
0.5491468906402588,
1.103515386581421,
-0.10382604598999023,
0.5940441489219666,
-0.1745927929878235,
0.057799991220235825,
-0.14680080115795135,
-1.0777966976165771,
-0.8981139659881592,
0.03428021818399429,
-0.11077025532722473,
0.055193036794662476,
-0.16649678349494934,
0.7463165521621704,
0.5165628790855408,
-0.698927104473114,
-0.4015941917896271,
0.38242819905281067,
0.0006281204405240715,
-0.019760729745030403,
-0.26245033740997314,
0.13177508115768433,
-0.23166926205158234,
-0.659408450126648,
0.350503534078598,
0.5431239008903503,
0.015121051110327244,
-0.556171178817749,
-0.1938849538564682,
0.010548410937190056,
0.3876592516899109,
0.9973304867744446,
0.24814686179161072,
-0.6841012239456177,
-0.38652145862579346,
0.202581986784935,
-0.31209230422973633,
0.24604927003383636,
0.628856897354126,
-0.5765045881271362,
0.04786325991153717,
0.547592282295227,
0.38712790608406067,
0.17979171872138977,
-0.06766945123672485,
0.6049191355705261,
-0.6224726438522339,
0.09360113739967346,
0.08158665150403976,
0.5560378432273865,
0.6677204370498657,
0.0819588452577591,
0.30503401160240173,
0.14795683324337006,
-0.5219559073448181,
-0.8262744545936584,
-0.11348254978656769,
-0.9312141537666321,
-0.3835802972316742,
1.402564525604248,
-0.29978224635124207,
-0.21019026637077332,
0.18332113325595856,
-0.16400465369224548,
-0.16597148776054382,
-0.11034364998340607,
0.539756715297699,
0.7823024392127991,
-0.046902671456336975,
-0.29631897807121277,
-0.4504762291908264,
0.2751794755458832,
0.4099658727645874,
-0.8127696514129639,
0.010837864130735397,
0.3036198019981384,
0.308352530002594,
0.1353885531425476,
0.6417539119720459,
-0.30592331290245056,
0.16754040122032166,
-0.13986410200595856,
-0.09880680590867996,
0.22237908840179443,
-0.3715701699256897,
-0.760517418384552,
0.43517327308654785,
0.2992534041404724,
0.17154596745967865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19356v1 | DiVERT: Distractor Generation with Variational Errors Represented as Text for Math Multiple-choice Questions | 2024-06-27T17:37:31 | 2024-06-27T17:37:31 | Nigel Fernandez, Alexander Scarlatos, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | High-quality distractors are crucial to both the assessment and pedagogical
value of multiple-choice questions (MCQs), where manually crafting ones that
anticipate knowledge deficiencies or misconceptions among real students is
difficult. Meanwhile, automated distractor generation, even with the help of
large language models (LLMs), remains challenging for subjects like math. It is
crucial to not only identify plausible distractors but also understand the
error behind them. In this paper, we introduce DiVERT (Distractor Generation
with Variational Errors Represented as Text), a novel variational approach that
learns an interpretable representation of errors behind distractors in math
MCQs. Through experiments on a real-world math MCQ dataset with 1,434 questions
used by hundreds of thousands of students, we show that DiVERT, despite using a
base open-source LLM with 7B parameters, outperforms state-of-the-art
approaches using GPT-4o on downstream distractor generation. We also conduct a
human evaluation with math educators and find that DiVERT leads to error labels
that are of comparable quality to human-authored ones. | [
-0.48466724157333374,
-0.6488328576087952,
0.6466666460037231,
0.239061638712883,
-0.2291414439678192,
0.2112293839454651,
0.010203211568295956,
0.04268641769886017,
-0.057086117565631866,
0.6058219075202942,
-0.9636712670326233,
0.07931376248598099,
-0.531717836856842,
0.19612573087215424,
-0.00889506284147501,
0.8504313230514526,
-0.39613988995552063,
0.22384166717529297,
-0.22090460360050201,
0.02733374945819378,
-0.5867592692375183,
-0.3609592318534851,
-0.36356252431869507,
0.11360321938991547,
0.768144428730011,
0.5462833046913147,
0.4092329442501068,
0.4250779151916504,
0.5338104963302612,
0.21403692662715912,
0.01786419004201889,
0.3192274570465088,
-0.43333670496940613,
0.10242368280887604,
-0.3295557200908661,
-0.5192543268203735,
0.4382116496562958,
-0.3678525984287262,
0.6838383078575134,
0.7699994444847107,
-0.16803254187107086,
-0.250217080116272,
0.07158846408128738,
0.5911468863487244,
-0.8682680726051331,
-0.18211106956005096,
-0.48161831498146057,
-0.10428282618522644,
-0.2861761748790741,
-0.153463214635849,
-0.43695658445358276,
-0.4549655616283417,
-0.02678285911679268,
-0.41883784532546997,
0.44797879457473755,
-0.35819748044013977,
0.8054154515266418,
0.5072394013404846,
-0.4370678663253784,
-0.6688282489776611,
-0.7631736993789673,
1.1471028327941895,
-0.33847758173942566,
0.17826302349567413,
0.1785954236984253,
0.5688937306404114,
-0.03053656779229641,
-0.2856447994709015,
-0.3784903883934021,
0.1002216711640358,
-0.014777187258005142,
0.44286611676216125,
0.14694850146770477,
-0.41299721598625183,
0.21726541221141815,
0.13157778978347778,
-0.08528463542461395,
-0.21579678356647491,
-0.5716428160667419,
-0.26929277181625366,
0.5837010145187378,
0.3628632426261902,
0.3036482334136963,
-0.17106372117996216,
-0.41512373089790344,
-0.1940123736858368,
-0.7730944752693176,
-0.03945065662264824,
0.3826196789741516,
0.17093010246753693,
-0.017890967428684235,
0.3827558159828186,
0.2650550305843353,
0.7604700326919556,
0.11759907007217407,
-0.014974734745919704,
-0.1940840780735016,
-0.2807241976261139,
0.20920152962207794,
-0.5478782057762146,
0.6203365921974182,
-0.046053603291511536,
-0.17335659265518188,
0.16936329007148743,
-0.08105286210775375,
-0.2219107449054718,
0.2919202744960785,
-0.678806722164154,
-0.298241525888443,
-0.02107682265341282,
0.13980844616889954,
-0.143249973654747,
0.04432528838515282,
-1.2612651586532593,
-0.3516436815261841,
-0.22981791198253632,
0.1257476508617401,
-0.5778945088386536,
0.06646809726953506,
0.012834998778998852,
0.07586853206157684,
0.27841898798942566,
0.7687857151031494,
-0.8469465970993042,
-0.00817147083580494,
0.1992645114660263,
0.44538596272468567,
-0.4569173753261566,
-0.5121643543243408,
-0.6471794247627258,
-0.03437059372663498,
-0.24579580128192902,
0.9425866603851318,
-0.423441618680954,
-0.6596981883049011,
0.03646443784236908,
-0.5383899211883545,
-0.4852119982242584,
-0.6300726532936096,
0.8620523810386658,
-0.573479413986206,
0.6144979596138,
-0.38735467195510864,
-0.45068031549453735,
-0.25775566697120667,
0.31709107756614685,
-0.7840798497200012,
0.7217928171157837,
0.5311152338981628,
-0.6788728833198547,
0.27505651116371155,
-0.5082657933235168,
-0.15872976183891296,
0.12130138278007507,
-0.44588345289230347,
-0.4779984951019287,
0.23024336993694305,
0.3607047498226166,
0.010190753266215324,
-0.43574580550193787,
0.41173139214515686,
-0.004447749815881252,
-0.004139984492212534,
0.7720574140548706,
-0.7612693905830383,
0.7650516033172607,
0.15128874778747559,
-0.20849986374378204,
0.060175660997629166,
-0.6421274542808533,
-0.16375795006752014,
-0.06271965056657791,
-0.5773832201957703,
-0.2292148917913437,
0.1767694354057312,
0.03980587050318718,
0.599655270576477,
-0.0700334832072258,
-0.4392741918563843,
-0.23088975250720978,
0.11222492158412933,
-0.024614820256829262,
0.8287176489830017,
0.08971217274665833,
0.14580422639846802,
-0.6169686317443848,
0.8772492408752441,
0.22884805500507355,
-0.02870531566441059,
-0.2305707037448883,
-0.33598053455352783,
-0.8754810690879822,
-0.5693216919898987,
0.2914257049560547,
0.40795496106147766,
-0.8226479887962341,
0.15956877171993256,
0.030906742438673973,
-0.13280126452445984,
-0.07476736605167389,
0.17209884524345398,
0.29377496242523193,
0.6383049488067627,
0.38507819175720215,
0.11685186624526978,
-0.49699193239212036,
-0.6240479946136475,
-0.4089452028274536,
0.36835816502571106,
-0.21251937747001648,
0.7874128222465515,
0.46162641048431396,
-0.15544120967388153,
1.1343425512313843,
-0.8738534450531006,
-0.17176930606365204,
-0.16569283604621887,
0.16926239430904388,
-0.1598573625087738,
0.535486102104187,
0.31836313009262085,
-1.1471089124679565,
-0.6105309128761292,
-0.33028966188430786,
-0.4198624789714813,
-0.25462228059768677,
-0.5444632768630981,
-0.6379315853118896,
-0.07247242331504822,
0.29277002811431885,
-0.40730881690979004,
0.1026313379406929,
0.09000338613986969,
-0.32129406929016113,
1.0116342306137085,
0.1915879100561142,
-0.19883036613464355,
-1.152829647064209,
0.030181603506207466,
-0.14575116336345673,
0.06529837846755981,
-0.48847177624702454,
0.05060984939336777,
0.3563668131828308,
0.08525211364030838,
-0.6323836445808411,
0.7360050678253174,
-0.3966434597969055,
0.5718989968299866,
-0.013529875315725803,
0.025429317727684975,
-0.07148243486881256,
0.25665515661239624,
-0.04232165217399597,
0.6844140887260437,
0.28016459941864014,
-0.4845581650733948,
0.10231046378612518,
0.1532433182001114,
0.019729478284716606,
0.8137553930282593,
-0.19837486743927002,
-0.06918084621429443,
-0.2239800989627838,
0.03521285578608513,
-1.1320796012878418,
-0.7491987943649292,
0.2979872524738312,
-0.35381829738616943,
0.35264796018600464,
0.039245955646038055,
0.02238929457962513,
-0.5381780862808228,
-0.3528558313846588,
0.5651213526725769,
0.41036462783813477,
-0.6515536308288574,
0.812102198600769,
0.048254434019327164,
-0.2273309975862503,
-0.9077718257904053,
-0.5901073813438416,
-0.42264628410339355,
-0.2799207270145416,
-0.23744697868824005,
0.10001558810472488,
-0.4850408136844635,
-0.05808032676577568,
-0.038271546363830566,
-0.23946382105350494,
-0.3822789490222931,
0.12862339615821838,
-0.06331834197044373,
0.5150994658470154,
-0.07006590068340302,
0.023581048473715782,
0.37388426065444946,
0.1319373995065689,
0.29533252120018005,
0.027590662240982056,
0.5218818187713623,
0.3115587830543518,
-0.6168330311775208,
0.06777451187372208,
0.40506550669670105,
0.42207011580467224,
0.10315611213445663,
0.4265102744102478,
0.1951242983341217,
-0.45934638381004333,
-0.4068796932697296,
-0.594049870967865,
-0.17386949062347412,
-0.4701339602470398,
0.32672423124313354,
-0.44123396277427673,
-0.9029513597488403,
0.6754871010780334,
-0.16279737651348114,
0.05466274172067642,
0.6069058179855347,
0.5549634695053101,
0.028584042564034462,
0.8389648795127869,
0.38262805342674255,
0.28045913577079773,
0.640238344669342,
-0.10790382325649261,
-0.13536234200000763,
-0.8481736183166504,
-0.2007208913564682,
-0.4905106723308563,
-0.07932984083890915,
-0.10431350767612457,
-0.7696316242218018,
0.014050190337002277,
0.3675755560398102,
-0.11386525630950928,
-0.13788087666034698,
-0.3570353388786316,
0.7421218752861023,
0.49854394793510437,
-0.03608138859272003,
-0.012625985778868198,
0.08076941221952438,
-0.43403223156929016,
-0.38440272212028503,
-0.4872196912765503,
-0.3486022651195526,
0.985313355922699,
-0.05006713047623634,
0.9465559124946594,
0.30438554286956787,
1.0349221229553223,
-0.10678516328334808,
1.0285489559173584,
-0.7501221895217896,
0.28217312693595886,
0.04303232952952385,
-0.928063690662384,
-0.39051923155784607,
-0.8706156611442566,
-0.8541094064712524,
0.6794244647026062,
0.19334787130355835,
-0.5999773740768433,
0.30693700909614563,
0.1913098394870758,
-0.4358050227165222,
0.31939342617988586,
-0.5916589498519897,
0.6674849390983582,
-0.29424846172332764,
-0.6339133977890015,
0.3483673632144928,
-0.3897303640842438,
0.781606137752533,
-0.4274820387363434,
0.31996792554855347,
-0.030139325186610222,
-0.09490548074245453,
0.5374892950057983,
-0.32687681913375854,
0.8152127265930176,
-0.08253295719623566,
-0.1786586493253708,
0.5895377993583679,
0.4946560263633728,
0.26335760951042175,
0.162905752658844,
0.04937049746513367,
-0.3999406397342682,
-0.41124430298805237,
-0.4209184944629669,
-0.5952841639518738,
0.6692048907279968,
-0.802680253982544,
-0.47280988097190857,
-0.31888872385025024,
-0.8451613783836365,
-0.11412695795297623,
0.375038206577301,
0.39459818601608276,
0.364266574382782,
0.00017050528549589217,
-0.09409073740243912,
0.5403697490692139,
-0.09883759170770645,
0.5253182649612427,
0.3839455246925354,
0.09666503965854645,
-0.8445837497711182,
1.1125500202178955,
0.12622785568237305,
0.2714262008666992,
0.5939888954162598,
0.4058865010738373,
-0.593859851360321,
-0.261059045791626,
-0.6199372410774231,
0.351960688829422,
-0.7533234357833862,
-0.3382610082626343,
-0.4998461604118347,
-0.17266245186328888,
0.09719866514205933,
-0.5394819974899292,
-0.20905083417892456,
-0.1756463199853897,
-0.7305960059165955,
0.052703626453876495,
-0.24903057515621185,
0.5291692018508911,
-0.07773532718420029,
0.2252967357635498,
-0.8100656270980835,
0.015598820522427559,
0.618398129940033,
0.2074672430753708,
-0.13195599615573883,
-0.5063249468803406,
-0.03467830643057823,
0.1169561967253685,
-0.884716808795929,
-1.0754408836364746,
0.5057066679000854,
-0.11861100792884827,
0.5339146256446838,
0.5131896734237671,
0.28857460618019104,
0.4785201847553253,
-0.385808527469635,
0.6542658805847168,
0.5585952401161194,
-1.0810232162475586,
0.34545448422431946,
-0.4351753294467926,
0.346256822347641,
0.5046510696411133,
0.39701876044273376,
-0.4298938512802124,
-0.3088335394859314,
-0.6250461935997009,
-0.6882311105728149,
0.8770397305488586,
0.28620800375938416,
0.13358454406261444,
-0.05040610954165459,
0.16191208362579346,
0.3222947120666504,
0.0867011770606041,
-0.793586015701294,
0.031985994428396225,
-0.2750215530395508,
-0.6126194000244141,
-0.01309926062822342,
-0.5287879109382629,
-0.34627464413642883,
0.21772007644176483,
0.3340052366256714,
-0.2607124447822571,
0.21934618055820465,
0.19958627223968506,
-0.2927357852458954,
-0.17106646299362183,
0.5559424757957458,
1.247910499572754,
0.7883321046829224,
-0.07124269753694534,
0.2582884132862091,
0.27919402718544006,
-0.5449331402778625,
0.2844996750354767,
0.29922977089881897,
-0.5233798623085022,
0.0317489355802536,
0.03679351881146431,
0.41317853331565857,
0.11698783934116364,
-0.8874683976173401,
0.3563452661037445,
-0.03076663427054882,
-0.3991785943508148,
-0.127639040350914,
-0.07363779097795486,
-0.01245580893009901,
-0.28437623381614685,
0.5597821474075317,
0.2625039219856262,
0.11007067561149597,
0.0508078970015049,
0.23924410343170166,
0.17492179572582245,
-0.45098528265953064,
-0.3667011260986328,
0.6369603872299194,
0.30881062150001526,
-0.4258010983467102,
0.21970729529857635,
-0.16367343068122864,
-0.6305946111679077,
0.6084266901016235,
0.6778789758682251,
0.8500608205795288,
-0.46348828077316284,
0.31778812408447266,
0.471205472946167,
0.08042597770690918,
0.01528868917375803,
0.3587024211883545,
-0.1426120400428772,
-0.8449381589889526,
-0.544576108455658,
-0.21994945406913757,
-0.8351619839668274,
0.09846657514572144,
-0.5615352392196655,
0.10755281150341034,
-0.4614809453487396,
0.10521037876605988,
-0.08933775126934052,
-0.43762916326522827,
-0.5308898091316223,
0.12428050488233566,
0.199393630027771,
0.5025854110717773,
-0.547142744064331,
0.13964687287807465,
0.8745146989822388,
-0.469737708568573,
-0.8975308537483215,
0.2736104726791382,
-0.16532936692237854,
-0.3186855912208557,
0.7110595107078552,
0.2387370467185974,
0.008362415246665478,
-0.1560257524251938,
-0.6209105253219604,
-1.0080757141113281,
0.6062785387039185,
0.4071565270423889,
-0.4938229024410248,
0.09049471467733383,
0.366058349609375,
0.15998463332653046,
-0.07002678513526917,
0.6200456023216248,
0.16062615811824799,
0.030806230381131172,
0.33956998586654663,
-0.27763476967811584,
0.19697359204292297,
0.012994248420000076,
0.02361336722970009,
0.506093442440033,
-0.7506111264228821,
1.2494380474090576,
-0.2376789152622223,
-0.22668780386447906,
-0.07679776847362518,
0.36780041456222534,
0.6212371587753296,
0.15309692919254303,
0.3343711495399475,
0.2778283655643463,
0.7354532480239868,
-0.3059675097465515,
0.9327335357666016,
0.015516412444412708,
0.623831570148468,
1.2118237018585205,
-0.25588297843933105,
0.7078376412391663,
0.7979601621627808,
-0.28745779395103455,
0.5105901956558228,
0.5444818735122681,
0.21059861779212952,
0.4187750220298767,
0.71097332239151,
-0.41205212473869324,
-0.33593064546585083,
0.3023965358734131,
-0.07844341546297073,
0.08905956149101257,
0.6459784507751465,
-0.11156682670116425,
-0.4901229441165924,
0.19433507323265076,
-0.06983249634504318,
0.11648909002542496,
-0.0886230543255806,
0.3829004764556885,
-0.046419285237789154,
-1.0171723365783691,
0.552676796913147,
-0.19511282444000244,
0.7155730724334717,
-0.4508138597011566,
0.01847427524626255,
-0.6341257095336914,
0.49650248885154724,
0.11362256854772568,
-0.683096706867218,
0.28783851861953735,
-0.05975658819079399,
-0.2077159583568573,
-0.03879326581954956,
0.5612928867340088,
-0.38888320326805115,
-0.71349036693573,
-0.11122196167707443,
0.5978977084159851,
-0.10719114542007446,
0.024290630593895912,
-0.5428746342658997,
-0.17349602282047272,
0.2013576179742813,
-0.039430394768714905,
0.05824632942676544,
0.47514981031417847,
-0.01840236596763134,
0.6687580943107605,
0.5964657664299011,
-0.3854144513607025,
0.4292263984680176,
0.033414121717214584,
0.9594839215278625,
-0.7377293109893799,
-0.5481114983558655,
-0.7873861789703369,
0.7701685428619385,
-0.09578866511583328,
-0.7045893669128418,
0.6810089945793152,
0.5590033531188965,
0.9213356971740723,
-0.5376035571098328,
0.9103567600250244,
0.05315392464399338,
0.839232325553894,
-0.298350065946579,
0.2405354380607605,
-0.37596219778060913,
0.32039180397987366,
-0.25628912448883057,
-0.7063042521476746,
-0.5534437298774719,
0.48258423805236816,
-0.5052175521850586,
0.016749346628785133,
0.7632246017456055,
0.4001646935939789,
-0.20435187220573425,
-0.0975794643163681,
0.4685207009315491,
-0.367190420627594,
0.6265383958816528,
0.7232856154441833,
1.510227084159851,
-0.30129000544548035,
0.961014986038208,
-0.3411870300769806,
-0.20391738414764404,
-0.47223809361457825,
-0.3930615484714508,
-0.9599394202232361,
-0.2681713402271271,
-0.4493843913078308,
-0.3112773597240448,
-0.3422788679599762,
0.5779953598976135,
0.4303330183029175,
-0.8737848997116089,
-0.08671874552965164,
-0.48057907819747925,
0.6576035022735596,
-0.16581936180591583,
-0.310737669467926,
0.41123250126838684,
-0.5021044611930847,
-0.8670554757118225,
-0.09233037382364273,
-0.172294020652771,
0.32143792510032654,
-0.1255294382572174,
-0.03878428041934967,
-0.032605282962322235,
0.3791664242744446,
0.2725476324558258,
0.34461772441864014,
-0.7363587021827698,
-0.03832332044839859,
0.22501541674137115,
-0.2724592685699463,
0.02435939386487007,
1.0265164375305176,
-0.44937634468078613,
0.47671598196029663,
0.4667031466960907,
0.747488260269165,
0.3156124949455261,
0.08094511926174164,
0.32709741592407227,
-0.6769813895225525,
-0.20502613484859467,
0.6494602560997009,
0.2234203964471817,
0.3508841097354889,
-0.37678346037864685,
0.20144851505756378,
0.4523220956325531,
-0.29635801911354065,
-0.8501810431480408,
0.4268621802330017,
-0.6773943901062012,
-0.20316477119922638,
1.1174228191375732,
-0.2268926054239273,
-0.08837482333183289,
-0.095888152718544,
-0.6472400426864624,
-0.09071523696184158,
-0.2621557116508484,
0.9034796953201294,
0.9251713752746582,
-0.19880971312522888,
-0.4463983178138733,
-0.32222089171409607,
0.44072914123535156,
0.7662593126296997,
-1.0241107940673828,
-0.03208546340465546,
0.704116940498352,
0.35270926356315613,
0.5509220957756042,
0.3101516664028168,
-0.0700155571103096,
0.5369755625724792,
0.20741377770900726,
0.05559062585234642,
0.2094518095254898,
-0.10514631122350693,
-0.34811270236968994,
0.2197686731815338,
-0.14113880693912506,
-0.38852185010910034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19354v1 | Fundamental Problems With Model Editing: How Should Rational Belief Revision Work in LLMs? | 2024-06-27T17:33:03 | 2024-06-27T17:33:03 | Peter Hase, Thomas Hofweber, Xiang Zhou, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The model editing problem concerns how language models should learn new facts
about the world over time. While empirical research on model editing has drawn
widespread attention, the conceptual foundations of model editing remain shaky
-- perhaps unsurprisingly, since model editing is essentially belief revision,
a storied problem in philosophy that has eluded succinct solutions for decades.
Model editing nonetheless demands a solution, since we need to be able to
control the knowledge within language models. With this goal in mind, this
paper critiques the standard formulation of the model editing problem and
proposes a formal testbed for model editing research. We first describe 12 open
problems with model editing, based on challenges with (1) defining the problem,
(2) developing benchmarks, and (3) assuming LLMs have editable beliefs in the
first place. Many of these challenges are extremely difficult to address, e.g.
determining far-reaching consequences of edits, labeling probabilistic
entailments between facts, and updating beliefs of agent simulators. Next, we
introduce a semi-synthetic dataset for model editing based on Wikidata, where
we can evaluate edits against labels given by an idealized Bayesian agent. This
enables us to say exactly how belief revision in language models falls short of
a desirable epistemic standard. We encourage further research exploring
settings where such a gold standard can be compared against. Our code is
publicly available at: https://github.com/peterbhase/LLM-belief-revision | [
-0.09273593872785568,
-0.9173011183738708,
0.8812291026115417,
-0.002551514655351639,
0.046598196029663086,
0.030461478978395462,
-0.2592014968395233,
-0.4093421995639801,
-0.13967883586883545,
0.588115394115448,
-0.5603973269462585,
-0.45660457015037537,
-0.5255982279777527,
0.25411224365234375,
-0.14640800654888153,
0.7004338502883911,
-0.47676777839660645,
0.09497689455747604,
-0.3064746558666229,
-0.10022002458572388,
-0.4120999574661255,
-0.5181479454040527,
-0.5092780590057373,
-0.2850259244441986,
0.314834862947464,
0.252107709646225,
1.0092763900756836,
0.5939040780067444,
0.3440950810909271,
0.2646434009075165,
-0.5291542410850525,
0.3238552212715149,
-0.5206470489501953,
0.24281686544418335,
-0.4263187050819397,
-0.7755753993988037,
-0.6640227437019348,
0.2086481750011444,
0.7099268436431885,
0.579154372215271,
-0.047712620347738266,
0.0008518616668879986,
-0.23493540287017822,
0.41683945059776306,
-0.41582274436950684,
0.23056325316429138,
-0.9274998903274536,
0.09357558190822601,
0.013659331947565079,
0.018997805193066597,
-0.4494996666908264,
-0.47842711210250854,
-0.012682382948696613,
-0.6356151700019836,
0.3312787413597107,
0.05093349888920784,
0.8774575591087341,
0.3262992799282074,
-0.5191431641578674,
-0.24087974429130554,
-0.806506872177124,
0.49060115218162537,
-1.0255824327468872,
0.36542344093322754,
0.4126974642276764,
0.00791389774531126,
-0.4985734522342682,
-0.34027621150016785,
-0.76152503490448,
-0.31065142154693604,
0.26772814989089966,
-0.1577683389186859,
-0.2000788152217865,
0.13655316829681396,
0.6071611642837524,
0.2706320285797119,
-0.27941402792930603,
0.017528001219034195,
-0.2483798712491989,
-0.19329555332660675,
0.5852593779563904,
0.17722231149673462,
0.2608981132507324,
-0.16586053371429443,
0.08945152163505554,
-0.13029904663562775,
-0.9604302048683167,
-0.08827131241559982,
0.41511592268943787,
0.05057789385318756,
0.4680126905441284,
0.9464269876480103,
-0.28589117527008057,
0.6714730858802795,
0.15193259716033936,
-0.21581311523914337,
-0.038671936839818954,
0.025232652202248573,
-0.3555622398853302,
-0.17256197333335876,
0.25870874524116516,
0.7089771628379822,
0.13788938522338867,
0.03110405057668686,
-0.5707878470420837,
0.29952529072761536,
0.15886817872524261,
-0.5037378668785095,
-0.0997045561671257,
0.1722550243139267,
-0.16180890798568726,
-0.510959267616272,
-0.38134825229644775,
-0.21466712653636932,
-0.4901457726955414,
-0.5002107620239258,
0.6147774457931519,
-0.5000619888305664,
-0.03415955975651741,
0.4430438280105591,
-0.1348281055688858,
-0.14815162122249603,
0.9223029613494873,
-0.6767772436141968,
0.08092839270830154,
0.630939245223999,
0.5629852414131165,
0.2618074417114258,
-0.34742972254753113,
0.1791110336780548,
0.27427512407302856,
-0.5942126512527466,
0.7428154349327087,
-0.7242542505264282,
-0.6048688888549805,
-0.17611588537693024,
0.029187064617872238,
-0.026320690289139748,
-0.47227299213409424,
0.47155410051345825,
-0.5986026525497437,
0.2623334228992462,
-0.5109646320343018,
-1.2066224813461304,
-0.09778615832328796,
0.33534762263298035,
-0.44016319513320923,
0.8885730504989624,
-0.03520002216100693,
-0.8091319799423218,
0.040141720324754715,
-0.5625342130661011,
0.069608673453331,
-0.4746035635471344,
0.02157781273126602,
-0.17664721608161926,
0.3884713053703308,
-0.20917780697345734,
0.1316550225019455,
-0.01628444343805313,
0.44478440284729004,
-0.47725725173950195,
-0.012912608683109283,
0.7138654589653015,
-0.43651247024536133,
0.5984957218170166,
0.11251244693994522,
-0.0781039297580719,
0.19159679114818573,
-0.8003878593444824,
-0.13743536174297333,
0.2310531735420227,
-0.19853496551513672,
-0.4548114836215973,
0.187273308634758,
-0.3293139338493347,
0.04518686234951019,
0.25278064608573914,
-0.7542279362678528,
0.7939919829368591,
-0.2714735269546509,
0.3943297564983368,
1.192833423614502,
0.27122706174850464,
0.3262616991996765,
-0.5674319267272949,
0.3562118709087372,
-0.17407478392124176,
0.4173629581928253,
0.01262560486793518,
-0.6373424530029297,
-0.8914971947669983,
0.19354631006717682,
0.5746873021125793,
0.5004492998123169,
-0.40070927143096924,
0.021196065470576286,
0.12016656249761581,
-0.5908253192901611,
-0.6934311985969543,
0.056943126022815704,
0.19583657383918762,
0.5450116395950317,
0.3211323618888855,
-0.04188317060470581,
-0.47204533219337463,
-1.0737663507461548,
-0.4858272075653076,
-0.41304031014442444,
0.052286066114902496,
0.10278689116239548,
0.7234153747558594,
-0.41474485397338867,
1.1225508451461792,
-0.6926636099815369,
0.03850610554218292,
0.1161450743675232,
0.11006428301334381,
-0.04523513466119766,
0.572441577911377,
0.27703121304512024,
-0.7119807600975037,
-0.246067076921463,
-0.1226748526096344,
-0.7708083987236023,
-0.27864882349967957,
-0.12574376165866852,
-0.15673042833805084,
0.259049654006958,
0.2462967485189438,
-0.9921033978462219,
0.6517367362976074,
0.335649698972702,
-0.3978990614414215,
0.8604114055633545,
-0.30951857566833496,
0.23825377225875854,
-0.9546043276786804,
-0.21066755056381226,
-0.09123353660106659,
-0.14982515573501587,
-0.6790329217910767,
0.2689758539199829,
0.20476071536540985,
0.05763540789484978,
-0.3655329942703247,
0.3936654031276703,
-0.23939567804336548,
0.1757083386182785,
-0.22899122536182404,
0.053514450788497925,
0.09052973985671997,
0.3357633352279663,
-0.08487627655267715,
0.5615149736404419,
0.1506624072790146,
-0.4658830165863037,
0.323130339384079,
0.4138866364955902,
-0.2938425540924072,
0.22509853541851044,
-0.6117203235626221,
0.4634813368320465,
-0.18954545259475708,
0.3010152578353882,
-0.6359317302703857,
-0.15042239427566528,
0.39734917879104614,
-0.38627833127975464,
0.2522522807121277,
-0.26271337270736694,
-0.6791437864303589,
0.22010178864002228,
-0.11338891088962555,
-0.03509799763560295,
0.4564499855041504,
-0.19638536870479584,
0.4045986533164978,
0.35881322622299194,
-0.28055238723754883,
-0.517540454864502,
-0.5192283987998962,
0.23224729299545288,
0.11815298348665237,
-0.7248892188072205,
0.4922993779182434,
-0.3859100341796875,
-0.7237598896026611,
0.3335741460323334,
-0.3300550878047943,
0.055325280874967575,
0.10287171602249146,
0.0053184302523732185,
0.45647889375686646,
-0.00012712247553281486,
0.1428431123495102,
0.3736140727996826,
-0.12250141054391861,
0.13122877478599548,
-0.0757666826248169,
-0.07870431244373322,
0.009800823405385017,
-0.5891396403312683,
-0.26163214445114136,
0.0727921649813652,
0.48297083377838135,
-0.1140955463051796,
0.46812137961387634,
-0.20848539471626282,
-0.753440260887146,
-0.3276418447494507,
-0.6778275966644287,
0.0075544980354607105,
-0.43112266063690186,
0.3115226626396179,
-0.437184602022171,
-0.986112654209137,
0.36716821789741516,
-0.2946663498878479,
0.3187553584575653,
0.3974185287952423,
0.6153791546821594,
-0.3487274646759033,
1.1282497644424438,
0.6129984855651855,
0.4359150826931,
0.1431378871202469,
-0.10405050963163376,
0.043959714472293854,
-0.8158180117607117,
0.05616937577724457,
-0.48038917779922485,
-0.1777014285326004,
-0.3948363661766052,
-0.8590006828308105,
0.18438632786273956,
0.39409127831459045,
-0.027312111109495163,
0.1179274246096611,
-0.05657217279076576,
0.5666643381118774,
0.1280522644519806,
0.16938406229019165,
0.5881786942481995,
-0.41320911049842834,
-0.31537801027297974,
-0.4788326621055603,
-0.519822895526886,
-0.9942222833633423,
1.1249643564224243,
0.4141118824481964,
0.8236265778541565,
0.29768091440200806,
0.3652532398700714,
0.43382033705711365,
0.4456265866756439,
-0.6024276614189148,
0.586367130279541,
0.23217663168907166,
-0.915580153465271,
-0.14421126246452332,
-0.1628909856081009,
-0.22720009088516235,
0.4739576578140259,
-0.27524369955062866,
-0.5678035020828247,
0.34449997544288635,
0.5125985145568848,
-0.05612397566437721,
0.7222326993942261,
-0.5473281741142273,
0.9307429790496826,
-0.08170002698898315,
-0.2777891159057617,
-0.3835428059101105,
-0.39112111926078796,
0.4106062352657318,
-0.2603277266025543,
0.3672904670238495,
-0.18499791622161865,
0.05551186203956604,
0.4977658987045288,
-0.5753087401390076,
1.0772377252578735,
-0.14418640732765198,
-0.2507442533969879,
0.04536770284175873,
0.555084764957428,
0.7944644689559937,
0.22351491451263428,
-0.0486035980284214,
-0.24396131932735443,
0.3903700113296509,
-0.30958643555641174,
-0.9543521404266357,
0.404162734746933,
-0.7489010691642761,
-0.9979605674743652,
-0.4645107686519623,
-0.5359938144683838,
-0.5138782858848572,
0.06269413232803345,
-0.018075095489621162,
0.3343767821788788,
-0.47790196537971497,
-0.12036347389221191,
1.0905768871307373,
-0.3134886920452118,
-0.12098175287246704,
0.7024075388908386,
-0.7814897298812866,
-0.15115688741207123,
0.6857524514198303,
0.3868444561958313,
0.6257101893424988,
0.1784963607788086,
0.15496878325939178,
-0.06382603943347931,
-0.7513552308082581,
-0.3685426115989685,
0.18160106241703033,
-1.1028770208358765,
0.08313898742198944,
-0.5749832391738892,
-0.134422168135643,
-0.34051403403282166,
-0.14855852723121643,
-0.4483298659324646,
-0.6331098675727844,
-0.22500593960285187,
-0.16408002376556396,
0.31334954500198364,
1.0661345720291138,
-0.2031601518392563,
0.06046009436249733,
-0.6490226984024048,
0.31788673996925354,
0.18070253729820251,
0.17172329127788544,
-0.19012707471847534,
-0.787164032459259,
-0.12565091252326965,
0.30320578813552856,
-0.26204395294189453,
-1.16068696975708,
0.20592035353183746,
-0.131276935338974,
0.40507248044013977,
0.17239126563072205,
0.22002175450325012,
0.7425647974014282,
-0.6300159692764282,
0.5013660788536072,
-0.3843788802623749,
-1.2122149467468262,
0.7242697477340698,
-0.18434470891952515,
-0.04174092784523964,
0.3566519021987915,
0.3309210538864136,
-1.0602647066116333,
-0.6708214282989502,
-0.7316120266914368,
-0.1366065889596939,
0.44270578026771545,
0.21309855580329895,
0.09570606797933578,
0.17198841273784637,
0.7756450176239014,
0.11882182955741882,
0.19692541658878326,
-0.5068532228469849,
-0.20683015882968903,
-0.13337324559688568,
0.07797078788280487,
-0.09568153321743011,
-0.3947753310203552,
-0.19970090687274933,
-0.49693456292152405,
0.9750317335128784,
-0.01381455734372139,
0.05698012188076973,
0.49308067560195923,
-0.4002567529678345,
-0.45392775535583496,
0.5389544367790222,
0.760691225528717,
0.9249911308288574,
-0.4710824191570282,
-0.02303967997431755,
0.30352380871772766,
-0.12084402143955231,
0.19287534058094025,
-0.23011037707328796,
-0.8188516497612,
0.19341550767421722,
0.22648367285728455,
1.0256425142288208,
0.41369226574897766,
-0.49586644768714905,
0.16792179644107819,
-0.16546852886676788,
-0.3066790997982025,
-0.23862037062644958,
0.07435160875320435,
0.22513428330421448,
0.26296740770339966,
0.08138454705476761,
0.6219851970672607,
-0.17195136845111847,
-0.505885899066925,
-0.05729440599679947,
0.1632401943206787,
-0.11186468601226807,
-0.5982359647750854,
0.5506002902984619,
-0.1400904357433319,
-0.5617543458938599,
0.3370291590690613,
-0.18691100180149078,
-0.7608394026756287,
0.38778936862945557,
0.6298690438270569,
0.5455421209335327,
-0.26256272196769714,
0.25131580233573914,
0.1507081687450409,
0.6625630855560303,
-0.10810305923223495,
0.23065905272960663,
0.4485229253768921,
-1.0989556312561035,
-0.4953556954860687,
-0.3794754445552826,
-1.0532119274139404,
0.06453317403793335,
-0.39987504482269287,
0.32768356800079346,
-0.750301718711853,
-0.20384098589420319,
-0.03366170451045036,
-0.075835220515728,
-0.36492034792900085,
0.17473919689655304,
0.025018205866217613,
1.1797302961349487,
-0.7343217730522156,
1.0496290922164917,
0.7648893594741821,
-0.34312891960144043,
-0.5983651876449585,
-0.10307160764932632,
0.3703164756298065,
-0.529357373714447,
0.42027339339256287,
-0.2830839157104492,
0.06896524876356125,
0.04495325684547424,
-0.9334302544593811,
-0.7844852209091187,
0.7952668070793152,
0.627686083316803,
-0.632757842540741,
-0.2716755270957947,
-0.03106115013360977,
0.5352224707603455,
-0.25713658332824707,
-0.11364497989416122,
0.39666494727134705,
0.7441419363021851,
-0.03117401711642742,
-0.6858757138252258,
-0.11084076762199402,
-0.2444884032011032,
0.029111452400684357,
-0.08363480865955353,
-0.5698908567428589,
0.9921677708625793,
-0.21991030871868134,
-0.011596839874982834,
-0.010244902223348618,
0.6006274223327637,
0.25926437973976135,
0.0330837182700634,
0.5476015210151672,
0.795185387134552,
0.9184380173683167,
0.035245779901742935,
0.8570185303688049,
-0.13456584513187408,
0.662146806716919,
1.1795986890792847,
-0.5712310075759888,
0.9193523526191711,
0.48961061239242554,
-0.3862603008747101,
0.27332139015197754,
0.8705321550369263,
0.032027240842580795,
0.23164796829223633,
0.16184476017951965,
-0.3117762506008148,
-0.4124223291873932,
0.04157256335020065,
-0.37781891226768494,
0.23648707568645477,
0.4757118821144104,
-0.07464040815830231,
-0.037179529666900635,
-0.14643745124340057,
0.3435764014720917,
0.049093183130025864,
-0.05323789641261101,
0.4486731290817261,
-0.00325185083784163,
-0.4196723401546478,
0.3348310887813568,
0.6138457655906677,
0.30510178208351135,
-0.5991533398628235,
-0.13160118460655212,
-0.23068375885486603,
0.14704814553260803,
-0.14604486525058746,
-0.6402918100357056,
0.36883509159088135,
0.28418514132499695,
-0.27575254440307617,
-0.36210906505584717,
0.7986782193183899,
-0.2953117787837982,
-0.5223521590232849,
0.07921857386827469,
0.456555038690567,
-0.08545748889446259,
-0.07602149993181229,
-0.8708505034446716,
0.4478851854801178,
0.1784559041261673,
-0.44427651166915894,
0.38480237126350403,
0.519067108631134,
-0.04800434038043022,
0.7171427011489868,
0.8496115803718567,
0.410776823759079,
0.05114154890179634,
-0.19762049615383148,
0.9017466902732849,
-0.8117097616195679,
-0.2925074100494385,
-0.7826858758926392,
0.40930843353271484,
0.04403913393616676,
-0.34254220128059387,
0.6531587839126587,
0.27194538712501526,
1.0834071636199951,
-0.04700639098882675,
0.9217028021812439,
-0.025024907663464546,
0.4498409926891327,
-0.758933961391449,
0.7423800230026245,
-0.39448225498199463,
0.27737125754356384,
-0.36781591176986694,
-0.9534556865692139,
-0.26392900943756104,
0.6838235259056091,
-0.34417811036109924,
-0.3066524863243103,
0.8132005333900452,
0.9398881196975708,
0.07711440324783325,
0.3101789057254791,
0.3675439953804016,
0.8270995616912842,
0.3371956944465637,
0.21615377068519592,
1.2884328365325928,
-0.4847725033760071,
-0.08579246699810028,
-0.6088945865631104,
-0.13122932612895966,
-0.04818876460194588,
-0.876828670501709,
-0.6411304473876953,
-0.47772377729415894,
-0.5337285995483398,
-0.4559943974018097,
0.2991195023059845,
1.2484885454177856,
0.22774682939052582,
-0.743806779384613,
-0.19862240552902222,
0.26307541131973267,
0.3558862507343292,
-0.04436001926660538,
-0.1312985122203827,
0.1319529116153717,
-0.05210809037089348,
-0.6639074683189392,
0.5882506370544434,
0.23670876026153564,
0.23505571484565735,
-0.28801229596138,
-0.1180444210767746,
-0.34626826643943787,
0.3767220675945282,
0.43761423230171204,
0.221109539270401,
-0.9584614038467407,
-0.6790840029716492,
-0.06202869489789009,
-0.156680166721344,
-0.04219109192490578,
0.7979242205619812,
-0.37521421909332275,
0.6339950561523438,
0.2315230816602707,
0.6867541074752808,
0.22617849707603455,
-0.16845791041851044,
0.5926793217658997,
-0.2825700640678406,
-0.14821180701255798,
0.18736065924167633,
0.6066941618919373,
0.2785411477088928,
-0.14683149755001068,
0.24587862193584442,
0.8535105586051941,
-0.556323230266571,
-1.1629647016525269,
0.18362747132778168,
-0.7455609440803528,
-0.3645976185798645,
0.91920006275177,
-0.19348356127738953,
-0.30376800894737244,
-0.07681972533464432,
-0.4938242435455322,
0.290455162525177,
-0.005059337243437767,
0.7390743494033813,
1.110012412071228,
-0.06405365467071533,
-0.0829625278711319,
-0.7408926486968994,
0.4690491855144501,
0.44924429059028625,
-0.48225167393684387,
0.3268482983112335,
0.7852218747138977,
0.5418148636817932,
-0.15009529888629913,
0.6300548315048218,
-0.08917858451604843,
0.1981523185968399,
-0.015204737894237041,
0.3178592324256897,
-0.16449271142482758,
-0.1650998741388321,
-0.4913483262062073,
-0.07912161946296692,
0.4629410207271576,
0.5478132367134094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19349v1 | IndoToxic2024: A Demographically-Enriched Dataset of Hate Speech and Toxicity Types for Indonesian Language | 2024-06-27T17:26:38 | 2024-06-27T17:26:38 | Lucky Susanto, Musa Izzanardi Wijanarko, Prasetia Anugrah Pratama, Traci Hong, Ika Idris, Alham Fikri Aji, Derry Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Hate speech poses a significant threat to social harmony. Over the past two
years, Indonesia has seen a ten-fold increase in the online hate speech ratio,
underscoring the urgent need for effective detection mechanisms. However,
progress is hindered by the limited availability of labeled data for Indonesian
texts. The condition is even worse for marginalized minorities, such as Shia,
LGBTQ, and other ethnic minorities because hate speech is underreported and
less understood by detection tools. Furthermore, the lack of accommodation for
subjectivity in current datasets compounds this issue. To address this, we
introduce IndoToxic2024, a comprehensive Indonesian hate speech and toxicity
classification dataset. Comprising 43,692 entries annotated by 19 diverse
individuals, the dataset focuses on texts targeting vulnerable groups in
Indonesia, specifically during the hottest political event in the country: the
presidential election. We establish baselines for seven binary classification
tasks, achieving a macro-F1 score of 0.78 with a BERT model (IndoBERTweet)
fine-tuned for hate speech classification. Furthermore, we demonstrate how
incorporating demographic information can enhance the zero-shot performance of
the large language model, gpt-3.5-turbo. However, we also caution that an
overemphasis on demographic information can negatively impact the fine-tuned
model performance due to data fragmentation. | [
-0.4712672531604767,
-0.6304607391357422,
-0.021048761904239655,
0.36687299609184265,
-0.18930888175964355,
-0.1317179948091507,
-0.4090878665447235,
-0.6541132926940918,
0.09774238616228104,
0.7577537298202515,
-0.3301606774330139,
-0.5680959224700928,
-0.6862162947654724,
0.24932782351970673,
-0.33363908529281616,
1.2041807174682617,
0.576702356338501,
-0.19255104660987854,
-0.11290352791547775,
-0.4906269311904907,
-0.2939014434814453,
-0.5283492207527161,
-0.48141559958457947,
-0.009274412877857685,
0.779747724533081,
0.5196243524551392,
0.46134719252586365,
0.6303436160087585,
0.27295929193496704,
0.22192701697349548,
-0.22739793360233307,
-0.21326948702335358,
-0.3707585334777832,
0.5648747682571411,
-0.34591755270957947,
-0.4654513895511627,
-0.1123659536242485,
-0.1260022222995758,
0.2786598801612854,
0.4159186780452728,
-0.07636787742376328,
0.05540170893073082,
0.0441652275621891,
0.3919414281845093,
-0.727107584476471,
0.3393368422985077,
-0.7930602431297302,
-0.11295109242200851,
-0.8215451836585999,
0.025684285908937454,
-0.35311704874038696,
-0.4957866966724396,
0.030158795416355133,
-0.3659836947917938,
-0.24097739160060883,
-0.16074639558792114,
0.37454697489738464,
0.4096532464027405,
-0.6121983528137207,
-0.3144727647304535,
-0.7690778374671936,
0.6979164481163025,
-0.4905971586704254,
0.04319978505373001,
0.5397100448608398,
0.17678575217723846,
0.08081236481666565,
-0.24362187087535858,
-0.5901095271110535,
0.11379639804363251,
0.26625287532806396,
0.08243279904127121,
-0.14582161605358124,
0.10810339450836182,
0.0388275682926178,
0.13880555331707,
-0.7010115385055542,
0.36063718795776367,
-0.7442139983177185,
-0.16451339423656464,
0.852441668510437,
0.14771761000156403,
0.4303889870643616,
-0.6491332054138184,
-0.09731870889663696,
0.09605062752962112,
-0.5089306831359863,
-0.38154834508895874,
0.9216143488883972,
0.4699063003063202,
-0.004377380479127169,
0.6390392184257507,
-0.09827195852994919,
0.49845999479293823,
-0.19253911077976227,
0.10694050788879395,
0.34322863817214966,
0.03328978642821312,
0.27111127972602844,
0.41721150279045105,
0.722064197063446,
0.5064300894737244,
0.6371583342552185,
0.13736696541309357,
0.3229084014892578,
0.3736572861671448,
0.3213312029838562,
-0.9170334339141846,
-0.2786843180656433,
0.2825917899608612,
-0.2474934309720993,
-0.6148197650909424,
-0.4963655471801758,
-1.2650883197784424,
-0.6886481046676636,
-0.19373786449432373,
0.11851570010185242,
-0.48381584882736206,
-0.5454915761947632,
-0.46835169196128845,
-0.21786868572235107,
0.11537651717662811,
0.28356340527534485,
-0.7627273797988892,
0.06980139762163162,
0.6707056164741516,
0.6015321612358093,
-0.38562339544296265,
0.17230801284313202,
-0.1929323375225067,
0.08822127431631088,
-0.263471782207489,
0.8194236159324646,
-1.1449036598205566,
-0.44230130314826965,
0.08760423213243484,
-0.15927347540855408,
0.02885451726615429,
-0.7836836576461792,
0.8139477968215942,
-0.3125929832458496,
0.37371981143951416,
0.24315038323402405,
-0.5312380790710449,
-0.20981135964393616,
-0.0005250800168141723,
-0.4708186686038971,
0.8857088088989258,
-0.03469003364443779,
-1.0981216430664062,
0.46604567766189575,
-0.6232268214225769,
-0.37460097670555115,
0.6414484977722168,
-0.12233621627092361,
-0.5903077125549316,
-0.13730481266975403,
-0.15541675686836243,
0.3260576128959656,
0.017852196469902992,
0.24694839119911194,
-0.7152431607246399,
-0.2652744650840759,
-0.030883237719535828,
-0.3938118815422058,
1.0863906145095825,
0.6357472538948059,
-0.3573034703731537,
0.2586037814617157,
-0.8688246011734009,
-0.40102773904800415,
0.10891582071781158,
-0.08299492299556732,
-1.0112720727920532,
0.0721881240606308,
0.3218734860420227,
0.3009811341762543,
-0.11443106830120087,
-0.8571975231170654,
-0.15551096200942993,
-0.40271466970443726,
0.19811810553073883,
0.9486863017082214,
0.05141795426607132,
0.04349344223737717,
-0.264279305934906,
0.42740103602409363,
0.016816670075058937,
0.21226106584072113,
0.1838865876197815,
-0.7063802480697632,
-0.39013671875,
-0.24763606488704681,
-0.1469409465789795,
0.851464033126831,
-0.64738529920578,
0.5343753695487976,
-0.278812050819397,
-0.8698312044143677,
-0.03497800603508949,
-0.12082874029874802,
0.03065962716937065,
0.29139506816864014,
0.2747024595737457,
0.006995226722210646,
-0.9706039428710938,
-0.7486240863800049,
-0.5641008615493774,
-0.40985092520713806,
0.007974077947437763,
0.6236070990562439,
0.3264800012111664,
-0.25358662009239197,
0.5843979120254517,
-0.19395309686660767,
-0.4280473291873932,
-0.18091118335723877,
0.22771163284778595,
-0.10664241015911102,
0.39193254709243774,
0.5070683360099792,
-0.9016690850257874,
-0.7701156735420227,
-0.18419979512691498,
-0.5492232441902161,
-0.3455216884613037,
0.33028465509414673,
-0.06879354268312454,
0.17249685525894165,
0.4390103220939636,
0.042577143758535385,
0.469473272562027,
0.5706562995910645,
-0.17125289142131805,
0.43766698241233826,
0.3559010624885559,
0.13971169292926788,
-1.097075343132019,
-0.10566075891256332,
0.16728247702121735,
0.020256370306015015,
-0.6718066930770874,
-0.23291179537773132,
-0.2993831932544708,
-0.3314686119556427,
-0.6551402807235718,
0.3441232144832611,
0.32646262645721436,
0.5552308559417725,
-0.1541460156440735,
-0.19220125675201416,
-0.7362315058708191,
0.313150018453598,
0.15151497721672058,
0.6932307481765747,
0.2376127690076828,
-0.40194961428642273,
0.45451876521110535,
0.3196788728237152,
-0.28796839714050293,
0.9802223443984985,
-0.18424707651138306,
-0.08110839128494263,
-0.41824498772621155,
0.40058496594429016,
-0.8022375106811523,
-0.6609383225440979,
0.3948659598827362,
-0.4396083652973175,
-0.009240013547241688,
-0.369382381439209,
-0.38630953431129456,
-0.284382700920105,
-0.26772192120552063,
0.6713503003120422,
0.41944292187690735,
-0.2624187767505646,
0.3836028575897217,
0.6864526271820068,
-0.6277641654014587,
-0.3345435857772827,
-0.6746966242790222,
0.13844634592533112,
-0.8571838736534119,
-0.43577906489372253,
0.15015637874603271,
0.01742725260555744,
-0.32024145126342773,
-0.017683839425444603,
0.17956268787384033,
-0.13588401675224304,
-0.1231251060962677,
0.6406680941581726,
-0.004088465590029955,
0.17157061398029327,
0.2691114842891693,
0.21540357172489166,
0.02296285331249237,
0.37386441230773926,
-0.1862252950668335,
0.5582863092422485,
0.23561213910579681,
0.3120114803314209,
-0.2552509009838104,
0.35172268748283386,
0.7178358435630798,
-0.18201898038387299,
0.8970010280609131,
0.4251023232936859,
-0.5673120617866516,
-0.004467209801077843,
-0.3722434639930725,
0.09977228194475174,
-0.38257718086242676,
0.23404783010482788,
0.012324521318078041,
-0.8347457647323608,
0.4153808653354645,
-0.05489205941557884,
-0.08726851642131805,
0.6876596212387085,
0.7120758891105652,
0.2453257143497467,
0.9454229474067688,
0.33953526616096497,
0.008721034973859787,
0.6126947999000549,
0.3893648087978363,
0.08270802348852158,
-0.4493196904659271,
-0.39079487323760986,
-0.8007696270942688,
0.3098737895488739,
-1.0102826356887817,
-0.354579895734787,
0.53116774559021,
-0.6414229273796082,
-0.5255548357963562,
0.3071545660495758,
-0.7360902428627014,
0.48743268847465515,
0.09854652732610703,
-0.0000675649571348913,
0.16237150132656097,
0.21263250708580017,
0.271992564201355,
-0.5961862802505493,
-0.28114446997642517,
-0.23906481266021729,
1.2997477054595947,
0.20701390504837036,
0.6333510875701904,
0.07693387567996979,
0.5717835426330566,
0.5380895733833313,
0.6700869202613831,
-0.21852999925613403,
0.29521793127059937,
-0.6669577956199646,
-1.3431134223937988,
-0.1245410367846489,
-0.6044398546218872,
-0.7422075271606445,
0.03910353407263756,
0.22094129025936127,
-0.9261884093284607,
0.38569003343582153,
-0.07389601320028305,
-0.24555177986621857,
0.4244548976421356,
-0.5136016011238098,
0.8371546268463135,
-0.00032720118178986013,
-0.32018283009529114,
-0.40561434626579285,
-0.6890275478363037,
0.595468282699585,
-0.27678483724594116,
0.5217150449752808,
-0.5716875791549683,
0.028720516711473465,
0.8856831192970276,
-0.4168239235877991,
0.8859266042709351,
-0.2664824426174164,
-0.07432589679956436,
0.21434944868087769,
-0.144609272480011,
0.24759921431541443,
-0.19284994900226593,
-0.4310705363750458,
0.3083273768424988,
0.01988818496465683,
-0.4258248209953308,
-0.15602272748947144,
0.8112708330154419,
-0.6610368490219116,
-0.15380729734897614,
-0.4828181564807892,
-0.25875797867774963,
-0.03805563971400261,
0.03810698539018631,
0.4694480299949646,
0.20201589167118073,
-0.06129123270511627,
0.3752616047859192,
0.6654384732246399,
-0.6607764363288879,
-0.07358986139297485,
0.23748020827770233,
-0.26216745376586914,
-0.4987887442111969,
1.420755386352539,
0.4364639222621918,
0.18068785965442657,
-0.03365127742290497,
0.09293340891599655,
-0.3883136808872223,
-0.11345497518777847,
-0.28711289167404175,
0.09022717922925949,
-0.613764762878418,
-0.20089897513389587,
-1.1176682710647583,
-0.2972385287284851,
-0.4130764305591583,
0.10471481829881668,
-0.3166927099227905,
-0.24906620383262634,
-0.15591511130332947,
0.041821833699941635,
0.5674593448638916,
0.7238509654998779,
-0.5263206362724304,
0.20141242444515228,
-0.17286553978919983,
0.10717888176441193,
0.3511286973953247,
0.5710291862487793,
-0.27463239431381226,
-0.5771356821060181,
0.24463090300559998,
-0.02530515380203724,
-0.008822001516819,
-1.087972640991211,
0.43704432249069214,
0.2320265769958496,
0.007337047252804041,
0.2470276951789856,
0.6355692148208618,
0.5442159175872803,
-0.2899707853794098,
0.6378811001777649,
-0.24333152174949646,
-0.5600911378860474,
0.843288242816925,
-0.579766035079956,
-0.11574345082044601,
0.5553121566772461,
0.8059482574462891,
-0.755599856376648,
-0.748205304145813,
-0.6996352672576904,
-1.0805038213729858,
0.6931470632553101,
0.31738972663879395,
0.2964417636394501,
-0.1306704580783844,
0.09643828868865967,
0.25156792998313904,
0.06142762303352356,
-0.6009665131568909,
-0.39201807975769043,
-0.3857569396495819,
-0.44815900921821594,
0.23462939262390137,
-0.41705092787742615,
0.01863170973956585,
-0.3894727826118469,
0.6260988116264343,
0.1683138906955719,
-0.013827260583639145,
-0.22197496891021729,
0.0689786821603775,
-0.1270408183336258,
0.356460839509964,
0.3571769595146179,
0.21090830862522125,
-0.4492371678352356,
0.05092976614832878,
0.10844822973012924,
-0.6584281921386719,
0.23828662931919098,
0.4362941086292267,
-0.05797388777136803,
-0.1604652851819992,
0.13169363141059875,
0.5111414790153503,
-0.14041021466255188,
-0.7301357984542847,
0.5207730531692505,
-0.24187171459197998,
0.058189667761325836,
-0.8247309327125549,
0.11257696151733398,
-0.30673179030418396,
-0.16198459267616272,
0.4938966929912567,
0.08306701481342316,
0.2561534643173218,
-0.22331227362155914,
0.45724329352378845,
0.008196985349059105,
-0.6840101480484009,
-0.15689778327941895,
0.9373881220817566,
0.4893348813056946,
0.028396807610988617,
0.5745514631271362,
-0.18581484258174896,
-0.5361624956130981,
0.4448588192462921,
0.0883011743426323,
0.6637852787971497,
-0.6021199226379395,
0.3502758741378784,
0.6132725477218628,
0.27582451701164246,
0.8096932768821716,
0.06285213679075241,
-0.02275725267827511,
-0.4121275544166565,
-0.4630240797996521,
-0.7457905411720276,
-0.25481298565864563,
0.27908679842948914,
-0.6150233745574951,
0.1491008698940277,
-0.649055540561676,
0.127237930893898,
0.22454801201820374,
-0.026323789730668068,
-0.3361451029777527,
0.06365479528903961,
0.2980205714702606,
0.5925962328910828,
-1.143937587738037,
0.5078558325767517,
0.49643683433532715,
-0.3067435920238495,
-0.31554001569747925,
-0.03618704900145531,
0.512728750705719,
-0.5871936082839966,
0.5093501210212708,
0.5215480923652649,
0.4224412739276886,
-0.008410497568547726,
-0.8192939162254333,
-0.5082094073295593,
0.23510879278182983,
0.14409750699996948,
-0.4009450078010559,
0.43787747621536255,
0.38209155201911926,
0.7549504041671753,
-0.15114885568618774,
0.1243663802742958,
0.5434185862541199,
0.6161126494407654,
-0.011618036776781082,
-0.5895951986312866,
-0.059263695031404495,
-0.41935354471206665,
-0.13800205290317535,
0.08679195493459702,
-0.6627963185310364,
0.453470379114151,
0.29874658584594727,
-0.2853016257286072,
-0.02592059038579464,
0.534724235534668,
-0.04710008576512337,
0.18578654527664185,
0.738281786441803,
0.5694060921669006,
0.33932965993881226,
-0.07863204181194305,
0.8424606919288635,
-0.0034861324820667505,
0.05426754057407379,
0.8864069581031799,
-0.2855609953403473,
0.530712902545929,
-0.0023190162610262632,
-0.16122187674045563,
0.42649051547050476,
0.6792842745780945,
0.2683345377445221,
0.3431212902069092,
0.24999696016311646,
-0.5776380300521851,
-0.5008496642112732,
-0.8347358107566833,
-0.4809770882129669,
0.6051189303398132,
0.8702360987663269,
0.009996691718697548,
-0.24353626370429993,
0.505025327205658,
0.26918402314186096,
0.24850162863731384,
0.01409187726676464,
0.9896042346954346,
-0.25821971893310547,
-0.423629492521286,
0.28122979402542114,
-0.21455644071102142,
0.8512203693389893,
-0.33892661333084106,
-0.0273292176425457,
-0.23732265830039978,
0.30579930543899536,
-0.30408674478530884,
-0.9679925441741943,
0.8884972333908081,
0.26621466875076294,
-0.03724121302366257,
0.05269668251276016,
0.5455155372619629,
-0.7175521850585938,
-0.2909056842327118,
0.3721986413002014,
-0.27265653014183044,
0.33720463514328003,
-0.4958259165287018,
-0.6522718667984009,
0.5126329064369202,
0.10699115693569183,
0.21832777559757233,
0.245677649974823,
0.4878205358982086,
-0.29052501916885376,
0.5627323389053345,
0.5527631044387817,
0.08674260228872299,
0.18186001479625702,
-0.1557447463274002,
0.7649356722831726,
-0.44224441051483154,
-0.3167806565761566,
-0.4979717433452606,
0.3713175356388092,
-0.42872098088264465,
-0.5686799883842468,
0.656129002571106,
0.7221916317939758,
1.0025924444198608,
0.278488427400589,
0.9929534792900085,
-0.31982654333114624,
0.9977185130119324,
0.2905983030796051,
0.7585952877998352,
-0.5176219940185547,
0.020611239597201347,
-0.46931785345077515,
-0.7873002290725708,
-0.5854270458221436,
0.3913961946964264,
-0.5479381084442139,
-0.053858064115047455,
0.007273838389664888,
0.7557737827301025,
0.2006528377532959,
0.31355908513069153,
0.16466514766216278,
0.5386108756065369,
0.6734755635261536,
0.3210863471031189,
0.7361130118370056,
-0.3223416805267334,
0.9363085031509399,
-0.5933967232704163,
-0.29048606753349304,
-0.3534514307975769,
-0.42766982316970825,
-0.673547625541687,
-0.6866549849510193,
-0.44175392389297485,
-0.3864414393901825,
0.44760897755622864,
0.8826873898506165,
0.5240395069122314,
-0.9678577184677124,
-0.04772449657320976,
0.10173724591732025,
0.1919461488723755,
0.27510708570480347,
-0.32598868012428284,
0.013911809772253036,
-0.014498668722808361,
-0.8250199556350708,
-0.05845124274492264,
0.49002110958099365,
-0.13688209652900696,
-0.15439656376838684,
-0.02275701053440571,
-0.2985314428806305,
0.17454107105731964,
0.6035186648368835,
0.5446301698684692,
-0.5391778945922852,
-0.24005772173404694,
-0.5840230584144592,
-0.0856771469116211,
-0.2254415899515152,
0.49851810932159424,
-0.5263247489929199,
0.6766195893287659,
0.43031346797943115,
0.5817814469337463,
0.29658156633377075,
0.04898781701922417,
0.2522526681423187,
-0.6216958165168762,
0.4844411015510559,
0.4868949353694916,
-0.12838123738765717,
0.41710078716278076,
-0.28766903281211853,
0.49616310000419617,
0.5384173393249512,
-0.5911858081817627,
-0.8610631823539734,
0.1478467583656311,
-0.6377867460250854,
-0.28140226006507874,
1.0785359144210815,
0.18397940695285797,
-0.32600322365760803,
-0.5615842938423157,
-0.2960158884525299,
0.14554955065250397,
-0.5076568126678467,
0.7049281001091003,
0.6052020788192749,
-0.002227895660325885,
-0.1778932362794876,
-0.4204709231853485,
0.6990270614624023,
0.41013047099113464,
-0.9423038959503174,
0.3116838335990906,
0.6433089971542358,
0.21578703820705414,
0.09946552664041519,
0.23560534417629242,
-0.3957987129688263,
0.18627972900867462,
0.009396112523972988,
-0.06608472019433975,
0.38916125893592834,
-0.32464006543159485,
-0.18751725554466248,
0.16043798625469208,
-0.3640598654747009,
-0.002666543470695615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19317v1 | Jump Starting Bandits with LLM-Generated Prior Knowledge | 2024-06-27T16:52:19 | 2024-06-27T16:52:19 | Parand A. Alamdari, Yanshuai Cao, Kevin H. Wilson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present substantial evidence demonstrating the benefits of integrating
Large Language Models (LLMs) with a Contextual Multi-Armed Bandit framework.
Contextual bandits have been widely used in recommendation systems to generate
personalized suggestions based on user-specific contexts. We show that LLMs,
pre-trained on extensive corpora rich in human knowledge and preferences, can
simulate human behaviours well enough to jump-start contextual multi-armed
bandits to reduce online learning regret. We propose an initialization
algorithm for contextual bandits by prompting LLMs to produce a pre-training
dataset of approximate human preferences for the bandit. This significantly
reduces online learning regret and data-gathering costs for training such
models. Our approach is validated empirically through two sets of experiments
with different bandit setups: one which utilizes LLMs to serve as an oracle and
a real-world experiment utilizing data from a conjoint survey experiment. | [
-0.47377729415893555,
-0.6747411489486694,
0.7550473809242249,
-0.040589265525341034,
-0.04731392487883568,
0.14714430272579193,
-0.45989519357681274,
-0.31093358993530273,
0.2930300533771515,
0.8719488978385925,
-0.513580322265625,
-0.6555713415145874,
-0.5977693796157837,
-0.2575988173484802,
-0.14011234045028687,
1.278803825378418,
0.20125024020671844,
-0.21612006425857544,
-0.12491209805011749,
0.16757577657699585,
-0.5009356737136841,
-0.700047492980957,
-0.9670432209968567,
-0.3081728219985962,
0.9094231128692627,
0.20458576083183289,
0.4900193214416504,
0.14847911894321442,
0.06834407150745392,
0.23315532505512238,
0.005277839954942465,
0.3284206688404083,
-0.764649510383606,
0.17388813197612762,
-0.05598607659339905,
-0.6499645113945007,
-0.038738761097192764,
0.1114560142159462,
0.1629040539264679,
0.5875368714332581,
-0.46670442819595337,
-0.157250314950943,
0.012271270155906677,
0.49797993898391724,
-0.7699959874153137,
-0.05353744700551033,
-0.5798564553260803,
-0.08467335253953934,
-0.11618207395076752,
-0.3395591378211975,
-0.4712171256542206,
-0.5651862621307373,
0.7237437963485718,
-0.8712507486343384,
-0.08295938372612,
0.005357732996344566,
0.4319702684879303,
0.20547139644622803,
-0.5102649331092834,
-0.4239102303981781,
-0.8380786180496216,
0.7598706483840942,
-0.5747770071029663,
0.0946928858757019,
0.6509939432144165,
0.3913689851760864,
-0.1661161184310913,
-0.5973366498947144,
-0.2552548050880432,
-0.2930937111377716,
-0.1648804247379303,
-0.17285963892936707,
0.07271231710910797,
0.06818432360887527,
0.31549206376075745,
-0.1794988363981247,
-0.4159890115261078,
0.11042831838130951,
-0.4279589056968689,
-0.13206283748149872,
0.7158388495445251,
0.01977822184562683,
-0.0537765733897686,
0.07774375379085541,
-0.49952295422554016,
-0.23171314597129822,
-0.9914119243621826,
0.44001132249832153,
0.6962894797325134,
0.5287895798683167,
-0.06366924196481705,
0.4917903244495392,
-0.20389847457408905,
0.9395291209220886,
0.24740482866764069,
-0.47677674889564514,
0.1628466695547104,
-0.14608685672283173,
-0.20479370653629303,
0.08710610866546631,
0.45232152938842773,
0.44600173830986023,
0.7512376308441162,
-0.0006571962148882449,
-0.19212785363197327,
-0.1784055233001709,
0.28219935297966003,
-0.5103520750999451,
-0.13680745661258698,
0.14872173964977264,
-0.12749820947647095,
-0.24414794147014618,
-0.09229322522878647,
-0.4903920888900757,
-0.47139444947242737,
-0.30207180976867676,
0.5104900002479553,
-0.4487687349319458,
0.14088597893714905,
0.12872318923473358,
-0.2823323607444763,
0.2894628942012787,
0.410665363073349,
-0.9209284782409668,
0.033075347542762756,
0.42464879155158997,
0.7173274755477905,
-0.06616184115409851,
-0.34800583124160767,
-0.8688016533851624,
0.3285170793533325,
-0.2993195652961731,
0.7870110869407654,
-0.5323372483253479,
-0.6514600515365601,
0.37119996547698975,
-0.20073790848255157,
0.09846290946006775,
-0.40139245986938477,
0.4009324014186859,
-0.8490219712257385,
0.35134005546569824,
-0.16767403483390808,
-0.5517328381538391,
-0.2210749387741089,
0.5039877891540527,
-0.3936241865158081,
0.9318864941596985,
0.011420462280511856,
-0.6096469163894653,
0.8309240937232971,
-0.6251208782196045,
-0.5622180104255676,
-0.018902679905295372,
0.09123408794403076,
0.02850484848022461,
-0.15293417870998383,
0.5220862030982971,
0.6659045815467834,
-0.05909920856356621,
0.478009968996048,
-0.48195144534111023,
-0.5636447072029114,
0.06371129304170609,
0.039340000599622726,
0.825158953666687,
0.09280666708946228,
0.022248612716794014,
0.14670279622077942,
-0.36486953496932983,
-0.27540603280067444,
-0.05073467642068863,
-0.5704942941665649,
-0.7821930050849915,
0.24423640966415405,
-0.02116827853024006,
0.10751773416996002,
0.25724342465400696,
-0.26674309372901917,
0.5040938258171082,
-0.5499758124351501,
0.19089071452617645,
0.8889224529266357,
0.11495316028594971,
0.47528398036956787,
-0.3974704146385193,
0.37855064868927,
-0.23608489334583282,
-0.1999213844537735,
-0.5190655589103699,
-0.3059976398944855,
-0.5784041881561279,
-0.33362212777137756,
0.3602805435657501,
0.6136370301246643,
-0.9292789101600647,
0.6225658655166626,
0.019810864701867104,
-0.2413087636232376,
0.21438653767108917,
0.2963239252567291,
0.06195671483874321,
0.10850004106760025,
0.27025100588798523,
-0.41600948572158813,
-0.5735005140304565,
-0.7029377222061157,
-0.5010941028594971,
-0.12123707681894302,
-0.5011759400367737,
0.6138021945953369,
0.07204458117485046,
-0.4080679714679718,
1.2408545017242432,
-0.7679824829101562,
-0.44974443316459656,
-0.27324193716049194,
0.14143019914627075,
0.2956075072288513,
0.19723492860794067,
0.5839331746101379,
-0.49631085991859436,
-0.39135459065437317,
-0.4432063400745392,
-0.5416350960731506,
0.14028321206569672,
-0.21244485676288605,
-0.07829345762729645,
-0.07920124381780624,
0.3734588921070099,
-0.5879278182983398,
0.15223167836666107,
0.30787378549575806,
-0.2319737672805786,
0.15100421011447906,
-0.36632493138313293,
0.08465792238712311,
-1.1190232038497925,
-0.25325241684913635,
0.2823416590690613,
-0.15562325716018677,
-0.5111517906188965,
-0.22832044959068298,
-0.15805503726005554,
0.0883578434586525,
-0.3756575882434845,
0.6871141791343689,
-0.19203750789165497,
-0.04577482491731644,
-0.06521803885698318,
0.2907160818576813,
-0.27480030059814453,
0.5505250096321106,
0.31590551137924194,
0.6022987961769104,
0.6258543133735657,
-0.8416426181793213,
0.17687644064426422,
0.2775288224220276,
-0.5243212580680847,
0.6374809741973877,
-0.5359557867050171,
0.12012345343828201,
-0.11544885486364365,
0.5568556785583496,
-0.9696443676948547,
-0.3888593018054962,
0.07371813803911209,
-0.34725311398506165,
0.30524542927742004,
-0.41608166694641113,
-0.07169943302869797,
-0.15830020606517792,
-0.46875452995300293,
0.16062438488006592,
0.5094916224479675,
-0.7149381637573242,
0.4984256625175476,
0.5029589533805847,
-0.33782458305358887,
-0.7753791213035583,
-0.3941231071949005,
0.10337168723344803,
-0.5322703123092651,
-0.4028399884700775,
0.34154826402664185,
-0.03471432253718376,
-0.28999465703964233,
-0.2627716362476349,
0.34430497884750366,
0.04871530458331108,
0.0542415976524353,
0.03382843732833862,
0.4198940694332123,
0.1506892293691635,
0.14471977949142456,
0.10074184834957123,
-0.06469327211380005,
0.05424373596906662,
-0.840429425239563,
0.41645723581314087,
0.2894836366176605,
-0.10188528150320053,
0.1233890950679779,
-0.025068208575248718,
0.21950171887874603,
-0.04234844073653221,
0.5641245245933533,
0.609551191329956,
-0.29987746477127075,
-0.2917150557041168,
-0.671656608581543,
-0.18208050727844238,
-0.4652986526489258,
0.04796909913420677,
-0.07377520203590393,
-1.3487739562988281,
0.1241878941655159,
-0.23757970333099365,
0.2639927268028259,
0.2082902044057846,
0.6572408080101013,
-0.24033908545970917,
0.5916033983230591,
0.769482433795929,
-0.1830594539642334,
0.6111704707145691,
-0.29696837067604065,
0.09209027141332626,
-0.5950676202774048,
-0.17301645874977112,
-0.2049562782049179,
-0.25361207127571106,
-0.4805797338485718,
-0.5179012417793274,
0.43040281534194946,
0.11094069480895996,
-0.25461211800575256,
0.2682764232158661,
-0.013949735090136528,
0.6366472244262695,
0.7824323773384094,
0.14865466952323914,
0.05830493941903114,
-0.005623118951916695,
-0.36651623249053955,
0.13301481306552887,
-0.6145488023757935,
-0.406258761882782,
1.6834429502487183,
-0.12329065054655075,
0.8987634181976318,
-0.0871259868144989,
0.8434927463531494,
0.6853601336479187,
0.36261284351348877,
-0.8672702312469482,
0.19172267615795135,
0.1708962321281433,
-0.7502248883247375,
-0.47723427414894104,
-0.24570149183273315,
-1.1305965185165405,
0.051129575818777084,
-0.48492223024368286,
-0.893025815486908,
0.13964557647705078,
0.32926660776138306,
-0.9566841721534729,
0.23422124981880188,
-0.5669968724250793,
0.5609796047210693,
-0.5105763673782349,
-0.4707956314086914,
-0.23952114582061768,
-0.742561399936676,
0.822554886341095,
-0.12234921008348465,
0.35485222935676575,
-0.13829585909843445,
-0.11636752635240555,
0.9009780883789062,
-0.2231341451406479,
1.0169483423233032,
-0.40248411893844604,
-0.06623829156160355,
0.5114964246749878,
0.09866628795862198,
0.7347301840782166,
0.24570131301879883,
0.32861796021461487,
0.14705409109592438,
-0.30346041917800903,
-0.2579931318759918,
-0.3769158720970154,
0.8287035226821899,
-0.7275574803352356,
-0.5868139266967773,
-0.36681005358695984,
-0.3964008092880249,
-0.5398412942886353,
0.028073512017726898,
-0.0974295437335968,
0.22587285935878754,
-0.34140434861183167,
0.30528751015663147,
0.7618946433067322,
-0.2694436013698578,
0.43665552139282227,
0.3943726122379303,
-0.2765794098377228,
-0.6293631196022034,
0.6080570220947266,
-0.06782912462949753,
-0.04570430517196655,
0.4082217514514923,
0.09761819243431091,
-0.5133448243141174,
-0.40712589025497437,
-0.4575154483318329,
-0.051679160445928574,
-0.6288706064224243,
-0.07358357310295105,
-0.6650405526161194,
0.2609527111053467,
-0.227668896317482,
-0.5732780694961548,
0.0029909005388617516,
-0.16626396775245667,
-0.09060065448284149,
-0.11900144070386887,
0.5229488015174866,
0.8315573334693909,
-0.12331953644752502,
0.5876436829566956,
-0.8286744952201843,
0.16549143195152283,
0.7089000344276428,
0.3410991132259369,
-0.26822492480278015,
-0.5085415244102478,
-0.5039762854576111,
-0.1324731558561325,
-0.11607447266578674,
-0.6672481894493103,
0.5297558903694153,
-0.020876239985227585,
0.6881459951400757,
0.7833483219146729,
-0.0072538587264716625,
0.4019339978694916,
-0.48078685998916626,
0.8424772024154663,
0.12960167229175568,
-0.6677560806274414,
0.42886972427368164,
-0.7327690720558167,
0.07918918877840042,
0.5625855326652527,
0.9439805150032043,
-0.41398924589157104,
0.14332357048988342,
-0.3374302387237549,
-0.8372309803962708,
0.7766599655151367,
-0.09807968884706497,
0.10902078449726105,
0.21438920497894287,
0.4142400920391083,
0.15735402703285217,
0.2337343990802765,
-0.464017778635025,
-0.09610172361135483,
0.1807500571012497,
0.14515681564807892,
-0.8636990785598755,
-0.2907733917236328,
-0.36163920164108276,
0.003047034377232194,
0.4449812173843384,
-0.3139455020427704,
-0.12575623393058777,
-0.12961313128471375,
-0.3115983009338379,
0.1053883358836174,
0.09161090850830078,
0.47849950194358826,
0.7379403710365295,
-0.36355826258659363,
-0.03714483976364136,
0.4140278398990631,
-0.04285423085093498,
0.3001130521297455,
0.03655773028731346,
-0.34387844800949097,
-0.40375348925590515,
0.2670474946498871,
0.703799843788147,
0.6784103512763977,
-0.937472403049469,
0.40480858087539673,
-0.09695429354906082,
-0.27625206112861633,
-0.42156219482421875,
0.17883232235908508,
0.4040379226207733,
0.35042551159858704,
0.5489020943641663,
0.19186094403266907,
0.13137120008468628,
-0.4557810425758362,
0.2525659203529358,
0.6779288053512573,
-0.08579602837562561,
0.04484875127673149,
0.2416428029537201,
0.40175682306289673,
-0.4100460708141327,
0.3209124803543091,
0.10803217440843582,
-0.35468417406082153,
0.15732966363430023,
0.33722954988479614,
0.884575605392456,
0.0004772024694830179,
0.07751985639333725,
0.4688321650028229,
0.2849045693874359,
-0.13202396035194397,
-0.3034736216068268,
-0.43630263209342957,
-0.8315631151199341,
-0.5038109421730042,
-0.6891924142837524,
-0.6470033526420593,
-0.11746973544359207,
-0.5159581899642944,
0.6877234578132629,
-0.4629457890987396,
-0.05244719982147217,
-0.26100051403045654,
-0.004510810598731041,
-0.7462628483772278,
0.2105618566274643,
0.3837631046772003,
0.6847533583641052,
-0.6353186964988708,
0.8492743372917175,
0.45655953884124756,
-0.1490330696105957,
-0.4064669609069824,
0.16286911070346832,
0.013683700002729893,
-0.7968764901161194,
0.5496883392333984,
0.05391877517104149,
-0.17532773315906525,
0.006773629225790501,
-0.6505439877510071,
-1.0826412439346313,
1.0881915092468262,
0.17887133359909058,
-0.4558522701263428,
-0.12154443562030792,
-0.5088242292404175,
0.24994027614593506,
-0.6809325218200684,
0.43782323598861694,
0.7102434039115906,
0.5562819838523865,
0.38544583320617676,
-0.7234324216842651,
-0.30524343252182007,
0.2620146870613098,
0.06693082302808762,
0.21109139919281006,
-0.2556441128253937,
0.9157203435897827,
-0.5349447727203369,
-0.03678639978170395,
-0.3284741938114166,
0.43170103430747986,
0.46969908475875854,
0.22410035133361816,
0.7710096836090088,
0.4932851493358612,
0.7607208490371704,
0.017099691554903984,
1.1349321603775024,
-0.29532667994499207,
0.07570583373308182,
1.0579941272735596,
-0.5486383438110352,
0.9500298500061035,
0.2671431005001068,
-0.3624555766582489,
0.7439146637916565,
1.032371163368225,
0.3272402286529541,
0.5362170934677124,
0.16590094566345215,
-0.25418251752853394,
-0.4682355225086212,
0.31512507796287537,
-0.2949409782886505,
0.39516711235046387,
0.433823823928833,
-0.12395690381526947,
-0.2150035947561264,
-0.003423023968935013,
-0.020667750388383865,
-0.09648562967777252,
-0.2371864765882492,
1.0007885694503784,
-0.22167980670928955,
-0.9569204449653625,
0.5624480843544006,
0.2518329918384552,
1.2449111938476562,
-1.070346474647522,
0.14913257956504822,
-0.24005533754825592,
-0.008470432832837105,
0.06135454401373863,
-0.5268351435661316,
0.01589803956449032,
0.11025428771972656,
-0.08167695254087448,
-0.23757219314575195,
0.8608915209770203,
-0.569050669670105,
-0.27279433608055115,
0.31148117780685425,
0.7170297503471375,
0.14378732442855835,
-0.06835799664258957,
-0.35406607389450073,
-0.395950049161911,
-0.1469336748123169,
-0.47126954793930054,
0.6175673007965088,
0.06924980133771896,
-0.02629963308572769,
0.6236862540245056,
1.205583930015564,
-0.11643633991479874,
-0.07693164050579071,
-0.23246769607067108,
0.9318116903305054,
-0.8056313395500183,
-0.7366828322410583,
-0.8179186582565308,
0.35293999314308167,
-0.039733562618494034,
-0.1775939017534256,
0.8569919466972351,
0.4706614911556244,
1.1561012268066406,
-0.17792320251464844,
1.024571180343628,
0.03952013701200485,
0.36408570408821106,
-0.6685812473297119,
0.5376343727111816,
-0.38773974776268005,
0.2630896270275116,
-0.06182185932993889,
-0.9074785709381104,
-0.18974632024765015,
0.5265741944313049,
-0.6112710237503052,
0.1866212636232376,
0.3336281478404999,
0.652023196220398,
0.08237427473068237,
-0.3621668517589569,
0.5149210691452026,
-0.2208450585603714,
-0.0021969452500343323,
0.6684953570365906,
0.918490469455719,
0.11129478365182877,
0.4595000743865967,
0.03462645784020424,
-0.25372418761253357,
-0.390536367893219,
-1.0025569200515747,
-1.2255828380584717,
-0.1613755226135254,
0.2143450677394867,
-0.264529824256897,
0.12729528546333313,
1.372895359992981,
0.9127538800239563,
-0.6216037273406982,
-0.5817381143569946,
0.3172367513179779,
0.31813356280326843,
-0.07927896827459335,
-0.1694970726966858,
0.0012354267528280616,
-0.49553829431533813,
-0.7150577902793884,
0.7288792133331299,
0.2644835412502289,
-0.05550142750144005,
-0.5637773871421814,
-0.4595605134963989,
-0.5111042261123657,
0.372286319732666,
0.81843501329422,
0.22520595788955688,
-0.825486421585083,
-0.14489342272281647,
-0.06332730501890182,
0.12648294866085052,
-0.0892726257443428,
1.28581702709198,
-1.3348993062973022,
0.4029931426048279,
0.30350223183631897,
0.6248958110809326,
0.945372998714447,
-0.02164180763065815,
0.7096692323684692,
-0.7536172270774841,
0.2905045747756958,
0.07817016541957855,
0.36622706055641174,
0.2518385648727417,
-0.3826791048049927,
0.36560970544815063,
0.17047058045864105,
-0.2748227119445801,
-0.5993105173110962,
-0.0015615003649145365,
-0.6309095621109009,
-0.27747297286987305,
1.079196572303772,
-0.49211782217025757,
0.14752258360385895,
-0.11774683743715286,
-0.3203241527080536,
-0.1412392258644104,
-0.5323295593261719,
0.6239382028579712,
0.7098851799964905,
-0.08428669720888138,
0.1543944627046585,
-0.3178035318851471,
0.6499559879302979,
0.11046702414751053,
-0.8707351684570312,
-0.0004609860188793391,
0.6723021864891052,
0.2792932689189911,
0.058024391531944275,
0.6261303424835205,
0.5140392184257507,
0.10483431816101074,
-0.027613988146185875,
0.1632387489080429,
-0.08827553689479828,
-0.5937276482582092,
-0.34743532538414,
0.42456474900245667,
0.09930913150310516,
0.23633968830108643
] |
Subsets and Splits